id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08253v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08253v2 | Benchmarking Neural Network Generalization for Grammar Induction | 2023-08-16T09:45:06 | 2023-08-25T13:40:31 | Nur Lan, Emmanuel Chemla, Roni Katzir | cs.CL | cs.CL | How well do neural networks generalize? Even for grammar induction tasks,
where the target generalization is fully known, previous works have left the
question open, testing very limited ranges beyond the training set and using
different success criteria. We provide a measure of neural network
generalization based on fully specified formal languages. Given a model and a
formal grammar, the method assigns a generalization score representing how well
a model generalizes to unseen samples in inverse relation to the amount of data
it was trained on. The benchmark includes languages such as $a^nb^n$,
$a^nb^nc^n$, $a^nb^mc^{n+m}$, and Dyck-1 and 2. We evaluate selected
architectures using the benchmark and find that networks trained with a Minimum
Description Length objective (MDL) generalize better and using less data than
networks trained using standard loss functions. The benchmark is available at
https://github.com/taucompling/bliss. | [
-0.0166160967,
0.0571574643,
0.014691663,
-0.0123077333,
-0.0303301346,
0.0289396551,
-0.0292146672,
0.0011658964,
-0.0753530338,
0.0157411508,
0.0192317646,
-0.0649077073,
-0.0003969336,
-0.002246575,
0.0607587583,
-0.0230697803,
0.0445398465,
-0.0079209944,
-0.0230330508,
-0.0026828162,
0.0076147323,
-0.0113525102,
-0.0019034705,
0.0246958733,
-0.0882920548,
0.027471533,
-0.0108196968,
-0.028709067,
-0.0320167616,
-0.0062902975,
0.0012230154,
0.0403866358,
-0.013033038,
0.0601683334,
0.0000016294,
-0.0868158713,
0.026538549,
-0.010044557,
-0.0395881012,
0.0144848423,
0.0137059083,
-0.0302175954,
-0.0016578417,
-0.0016138174,
-0.0493855774,
-0.074509047,
0.0606420748,
-0.001790385,
0.0528741889,
0.0921893939,
0.0021381411,
-0.0537553951,
0.079761602,
-0.0224337783,
-0.0346082561,
0.0069850432,
0.0049824193,
0.0009775922,
-0.0128979888,
-0.0828042999,
0.0143496543,
-0.0001645824,
0.0366284326,
0.00842652,
0.0121311061,
0.0372456424,
-0.0628862306,
-0.030399451,
0.0075767045,
0.0458935052,
-0.00293401,
-0.014843517,
-0.0040198835,
0.0134544764,
0.0402351543,
-0.02837139,
-0.0486857295,
0.0325771458,
-0.0013319216,
0.037620578,
0.0325773843,
-0.0331591778,
0.0730174109,
-0.0180337857,
0.0056180079,
0.1154710278,
0.0227021258,
-0.0356812067,
0.055908978,
0.0090830727,
-0.0181668121,
-0.0328524075,
-0.015572384,
0.0397043638,
-0.0140740993,
0.0159673188,
-0.0061782291,
-0.0107722869,
0.0057743485,
-0.0808850229,
0.065175347,
0.0299052745,
0.0044806092,
0.0243096277,
-0.068809703,
0.0363531671,
0.004025856,
0.0245885458,
-0.0134512223,
0.0220833682,
-0.0573725291,
-0.0008372149,
-0.041466482,
0.0322771594,
0.0301301721,
0.0017800543,
-0.0559641942,
0.0059406147,
-0.0311949831,
0.0628575012,
0.0276104528,
-0.0048330263,
-0.0400070176,
0.0119218929,
-0.0141664064,
-0.0281886682,
-0.0693620071,
-0.0153136887,
0.0475133099,
-0.0649921224,
-0.0134956455,
-0.0147333806,
0.0243100077,
0.0087668616,
-0.0160662457,
0.0687184706,
0.0162157528,
-0.0161587857,
-0.0438691303,
-0.00343251,
-0.0108733149,
-0.0414107032,
0.0384152755,
-0.0550935641,
-0.0065799654,
-0.0126559902,
0.0226302389,
-0.032580629,
0.0008311751,
-0.0068993936,
0.0044840127,
0.0128016565,
-0.0317357853,
-0.0139239328,
0.0334438495,
-0.0077359267,
0.0391040109,
0.0726013556,
-0.0054739979,
0.011700416,
0.0219471734,
-0.0376244225,
0.0084373951,
0.0350814424,
0.0045702113,
-0.0222821739,
-0.0193031263,
-0.0327769928,
0.0132058272,
0.0759373754,
-0.0104874941,
0.0749274567,
-0.0511428714,
-0.0247289296,
0.0082268529,
0.0412570275,
0.0177216921,
0.0356864817,
0.1097106636,
-0.0270861853,
0.0316397995,
0.0316779055,
-0.0289722476,
-0.0249466356,
-0.0370144807,
0.0131241018,
-0.0162103307,
-0.0160309914,
-0.0204341989,
-0.0516595431,
-0.0073273885,
-0.0632930174,
0.0206774659,
-0.1000733897,
0.0727384239,
0.0899826139,
-0.0251348317,
0.0297986399,
0.0753629804,
-0.057156451,
0.0162261464,
-0.0065686293,
0.0255951006,
-0.0390151851,
-0.0051065348,
-0.0248429198,
-0.0467667505,
-0.0168900136,
-0.0125583354,
0.0289689638,
0.0604352541,
-0.0122215487,
0.0329848565,
-0.0193649009,
0.0374669284,
-0.0031455273,
0.0545938611,
0.0112279011,
-0.0057457704,
-0.0251374673,
0.0043823817,
-0.0306983385,
-0.0749694258,
0.066660434,
0.0036995932,
-0.0424708761,
0.0018310648,
0.0194309186,
0.0435686894,
-0.0029630116,
-0.0129755372,
-0.0041334643,
0.0244866833,
-0.0439320318,
0.006959293,
-0.0034162141,
-0.0978010595,
-0.0430345908,
0.0467228405,
-0.0424139798,
-0.0062676477,
0.0436194241,
-0.0186374467,
-0.0376736298,
0.0540644191,
-0.05353361,
0.0598889701,
-0.0138748325,
0.0072442563,
-0.0065621622,
0.0056593935,
-0.0127462707,
0.0573822595,
0.0048092538,
0.0222416427,
-0.0411281697,
-0.0633954704,
0.0208202153,
-0.0148257175,
-0.0251815114,
0.0139529342,
-0.0330725014,
-0.0001857495,
0.0133308703,
-0.0108753815,
-0.0591111518,
0.0157995503,
-0.0536663719,
-0.0328403488,
-0.0343343839,
0.0491545834,
0.0212988704,
-0.0115925884,
0.0090996213,
-0.0139956521,
-0.0600854419,
0.0624367557,
0.010920357,
-0.0137313604,
0.0606607385,
0.0217378046,
-0.0709208548,
-0.0318238772,
-0.039659556,
-0.0302461702,
0.0725440606,
0.0036425286,
0.0252633151,
-0.0219522547,
-0.0107596358,
-0.0070071905,
0.0095324982,
-0.0016668908,
-0.0335234441,
0.0313690305,
-0.0487305671,
-0.0434984006,
0.0353351943,
-0.0041694362,
-0.0415038355,
0.0225069877,
0.0222037882,
-0.0540952682,
-0.0031765776,
-0.0348203368,
0.0151026463,
-0.0604571067,
-0.0094747357,
0.018372776,
0.1322481185,
-0.0333966091,
-0.0188541636,
-0.0206054281,
0.0163456351,
-0.0331737846,
-0.0032432005,
-0.0284167975,
-0.0345442668,
-0.0433860868,
0.0380219705,
-0.0179422107,
-0.1025357023,
0.0337066762,
-0.0332610458,
-0.0251446608,
0.0259875078,
-0.0242647473,
-0.0113018723,
0.0298356842,
0.0628981367,
0.0400481559,
0.0324765109,
-0.0272884872,
-0.0192811936,
0.0099406298,
0.046203509,
0.0478301756,
0.0301279854,
-0.0420044363,
0.0071388907,
0.0069896556,
-0.0138134807,
-0.0440461002,
0.0313676447,
-0.0143055869,
0.0124573857,
-0.0226046462,
-0.0268342998,
0.0402396135,
-0.0293449555,
-0.0622098409,
0.0380245037,
0.0079905251,
-0.0175008737,
-0.0086689377,
0.0075557604,
-0.0086353598,
-0.0013578882,
0.0130391205,
-0.0287866127,
-0.0412768647,
-0.0066685132,
-0.0081279082,
0.0476526618,
-0.0900090188,
0.0173186213,
0.0140175419,
-0.0507886149,
-0.0343780406,
0.0265776403,
0.0155527536,
-0.014135858,
-0.0390804969,
0.0792030245,
0.0293347072,
-0.017601518,
0.0528858416,
0.0313118175,
0.0652061254,
-0.0001052972,
0.0090538161,
-0.0475412309,
0.0031191092,
0.0262288097,
-0.0064555756,
0.0019905076,
-0.0369670652,
0.0038130062,
-0.0874147341,
-0.030600816,
0.0322906263,
-0.0323101208,
0.0262622833,
-0.0022100534,
-0.0116070677,
-0.027750738,
0.0057704002,
0.0138449911,
0.0137153296,
-0.0149344597,
0.045986183,
-0.0510416329,
-0.0510308146,
-0.0373607688,
-0.0709429085,
0.0512465611,
0.0443566144,
-0.0097412681,
-0.0421152338,
-0.0271519832,
0.0920843929,
0.0618321858,
-0.014864468,
0.0447447561,
0.0516021699,
0.0392606296,
-0.0110065993,
0.0164146926,
0.0235389899,
-0.0370839424,
0.0361003429,
-0.0057180068,
0.0647395998,
0.0474991389,
-0.0508029871,
0.02390242,
-0.0059058848,
-0.049652867,
-0.0050716428,
0.0630808175,
-0.0237327348,
-0.0010231584,
-0.079723984,
0.0073681795,
-0.0524170883,
-0.0316592753,
0.0287772771,
0.0219473429,
-0.0766969174,
-0.1160980687,
-0.0253083501,
-0.0138134267,
0.0625244528,
0.0089737475,
-0.0420686528,
0.0300547946,
-0.003436425,
-0.0099543622,
0.0537139438,
0.0187148135,
-0.0284387209,
-0.0540890209,
-0.0276040994,
-0.0036689632,
0.0210399535,
-0.0284197368,
-0.0228596739,
-0.0485692769,
-0.0657951236,
0.0593825839,
0.0711358562,
0.0200589728,
-0.0059815873,
-0.0162391942,
-0.0266583003,
-0.0012361156,
0.0284457467,
0.0092551392,
-0.0154542206,
0.0906089768,
-0.0495358855,
0.0128636034,
0.0415787548,
-0.005035188,
0.0094341356,
0.0185765028,
0.007026657,
0.0191349667,
0.0631893575,
0.0704676285,
0.0505724885,
0.0066478634,
-0.007967528,
-0.003698203,
-0.0218309909,
-0.0209991392,
0.0221248716,
-0.0119172158,
-0.0459919237,
0.0222311858,
0.0342318937,
0.0497266427,
0.0007894232,
-0.0375064947,
0.0261632651,
0.0216477048,
-0.0195393842,
-0.0117527517,
0.0658980981,
0.0238104928,
0.0390501134,
-0.0090892408,
-0.0194109622,
0.0063312696,
-0.0104758693,
0.0172572602,
-0.0377006009,
-0.0241885912,
0.0263433196,
0.0475656092,
-0.0293803494,
-0.0054456955,
-0.0092111127,
0.0100994688,
-0.0338395201,
0.0154598821,
0.0718851089,
-0.025564488,
0.0092234407,
-0.0328637734,
0.0143881235,
-0.0007931942,
0.0129906451,
-0.0319148153,
-0.0337388068,
0.0155299809,
-0.0006520385,
-0.0185583141,
-0.0236664005,
0.0597991981,
-0.0222331509,
0.0697459653,
-0.0099330014,
0.0462233759,
-0.0405021943,
-0.0010007098,
-0.0210476965,
0.0222872291,
-0.0027663442,
0.0118096462,
-0.0110553289,
-0.073252514,
-0.0536545441,
0.0427024588,
0.0259957407,
0.0255233981,
0.0417947471,
0.0448776521,
-0.0079896823,
0.0061295442,
-0.0019355743,
-0.0478776731,
0.0241650306,
0.0105187139,
-0.0040210648,
-5.664920335e-33,
-0.0131534543,
0.0353998244,
-0.0217825323,
0.0162085015,
0.0014484827,
-0.0202468876,
-0.0355729572,
0.0307145547,
-0.0078982133,
0.0472421087,
-0.0183208399,
-0.0070301676,
-0.0073848148,
0.0212316308,
0.002108139,
0.0014902157,
0.0006355182,
-0.0097868033,
-0.0362720005,
0.0027668022,
-0.0160701293,
0.0529365838,
0.087028943,
-0.0030977805,
0.0289424323,
0.0160806198,
-0.008143967,
0.0138798635,
-0.040043775,
0.0009950441,
0.0173612237,
0.0278410632,
0.0144590987,
0.0224603862,
-0.02103246,
-0.0147101777,
-0.0714884847,
-0.0551716462,
0.0001103734,
0.0131303677,
-0.091760315,
-0.0151221063,
0.0612618029,
-0.0150539028,
-0.056720674,
0.0326187238,
0.0024879219,
0.0112659615,
-0.0186543651,
-0.0164721422,
-0.0448970124,
0.019713752,
0.0074646124,
0.0287055243,
0.007205171,
0.0048977011,
-0.026671946,
-0.0595245436,
0.0117048146,
0.013670506,
0.0505402647,
0.0287336838,
0.0350225717,
0.0004897097,
-0.020950783,
0.0311216302,
0.0862607732,
0.0022129803,
0.0099599315,
0.0367177576,
0.0340981036,
0.0144019648,
0.0054481463,
0.0287989192,
0.0836053118,
-0.0062333113,
-0.0756419674,
0.0041359682,
0.0518988855,
0.047612235,
0.0060473788,
0.0154855382,
-0.0183959305,
-0.0286081936,
-0.0517521352,
0.0169899054,
0.0069117267,
-0.0179921389,
0.0104001462,
0.0163962394,
0.0116406381,
-0.0172446072,
-0.0480721481,
-0.0236713309,
0.0136919748,
0.0149617782,
0.0211023279,
0.0016295546,
0.0137996413,
0.0192716997,
-0.0189179759,
-0.0305323619,
-0.0280249808,
-0.0009337644,
0.0706624612,
-0.0027926783,
0.0617646575,
0.0056876265,
-0.0467275009,
0.0031638958,
-0.0751619041,
-0.0374658704,
0.0193204936,
0.0245345403,
0.0719498917,
-0.0034309961,
-0.0260998663,
0.0273018647,
-0.0080144135,
0.0268114954,
-0.022717854,
-0.0104183881,
0.0127712954,
0.0422181897,
-0.0129874945,
-0.0362485796,
0.0037099258,
-0.0105834501,
0.0813562125,
-0.0364881344,
0.0047900705,
-0.0025941739,
2.494e-7,
0.0251937918,
0.0574877672,
0.0144840917,
0.0169432294,
0.0223877337,
-0.0119936951,
-0.0670799538,
0.0058543258,
-0.0342122354,
-0.0186791215,
-0.0036543692,
-0.0088464664,
0.0297771394,
0.027297385,
-0.1001206636,
-0.0444712974,
-0.0589117855,
0.0189454705,
0.0057698339,
-0.0072941743,
-0.0196893569,
0.0797452629,
-0.0076843505,
-0.0108591858,
0.0405249596,
-0.0649210438,
0.0084848208,
-0.0381732658,
0.0190561917,
0.0245678239,
0.0279218759,
-0.0095072174,
-0.0047644107,
0.0063920026,
0.0038783953,
0.0324928835,
-0.0155752599,
-0.0017414151,
-0.0118621308,
0.0587886125,
0.0318441205,
-0.0153169138,
0.0013453166,
0.0018351808,
0.0102503663,
-0.0498450138,
-0.0216530338,
0.0305822175,
-0.0298683122,
0.001043541,
0.017473001,
0.0184647646,
0.0090675578,
-0.0020459357,
0.0348149389,
-0.026656935,
-0.014882951,
-0.0355666913,
0.0074790674,
0.0517593734,
0.0057796147,
-0.0520637892,
-0.0213235877,
0.0029261461,
-0.0042107892,
-0.0313756987,
0.0184377693,
2.050690073e-34,
0.0162089467,
-0.0158697851,
0.0544717126,
0.0309450086,
0.0333060995,
-0.0457415991,
-0.0163833369,
-0.0127670309,
0.0123464158,
-0.0498952568,
0.0051720673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08241v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08241v2 | TEST: Text Prototype Aligned Embedding to Activate LLM's Ability for Time Series | 2023-08-16T09:16:02 | 2024-02-22T02:03:42 | Chenxi Sun, Hongyan Li, Yaliang Li, Shenda Hong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This work summarizes two ways to accomplish Time-Series (TS) tasks in today's
Large Language Model (LLM) context: LLM-for-TS (model-centric) designs and
trains a fundamental large model, or fine-tunes a pre-trained LLM for TS data;
TS-for-LLM (data-centric) converts TS into a model-friendly representation to
enable the pre-trained LLM to handle TS data. Given the lack of data, limited
resources, semantic context requirements, and so on, this work focuses on
TS-for-LLM, where we aim to activate LLM's ability for TS data by designing a
TS embedding method suitable for LLM. The proposed method is named TEST. It
first tokenizes TS, builds an encoder to embed TS via instance-wise,
feature-wise, and text-prototype-aligned contrast, where the TS embedding space
is aligned to LLM embedding layer space, then creates soft prompts to make LLM
more open to that embeddings, and finally implements TS tasks using the frozen
LLM. We also demonstrate the feasibility of TS-for-LLM through theory and
experiments. Experiments are carried out on TS classification, forecasting, and
representation tasks using eight frozen LLMs with various structures and sizes.
The results show that the pre-trained LLM with TEST strategy can achieve better
or comparable performance than today's SOTA TS models and offer benefits for
few-shot and generalization. By treating LLM as the pattern machine, TEST can
endow LLM's ability to process TS data without compromising language ability.
We hope that this study will serve as a foundation for future work to support
TS+LLM progress. | [
-0.0169492178,
0.0789764524,
-0.0039669536,
0.0394712649,
-0.0168529674,
0.0370790511,
0.0447185673,
0.0003293268,
-0.0032088514,
-0.0350683816,
-0.0064854003,
-0.0510875806,
-0.0041878195,
0.0747613236,
0.009978842,
-0.0430627801,
0.0226950385,
0.0063184509,
-0.0100511517,
0.0159304049,
0.0052868831,
-0.0126473028,
0.0517447442,
0.0233281422,
-0.0111921094,
0.0099760182,
-0.0533082671,
-0.0294376127,
0.0177146364,
-0.0632070601,
-0.0298547279,
0.0218099058,
0.0889572278,
0.0550668836,
0.0000020805,
-0.0134355817,
-0.0095069138,
-0.0076208115,
-0.0166819002,
0.0197354816,
0.0667610765,
-0.0367692001,
0.0282896794,
0.0242791399,
-0.0496870838,
-0.0152971251,
0.0452782474,
0.0565282367,
0.0347285233,
0.088890329,
-0.0267520882,
-0.0339614674,
0.0398186333,
-0.0372034125,
-0.0139169004,
-0.0104994997,
0.0197129548,
-0.0561215691,
0.0061049582,
0.0159775242,
-0.0057327747,
0.0329345316,
0.0275738649,
0.0287899841,
0.0197253022,
0.0540618859,
-0.0008405786,
-0.0001324653,
-0.0191456564,
0.0510809422,
0.0214834046,
-0.0194319021,
0.0031752207,
0.0065477248,
-0.0296292137,
-0.0042649619,
-0.0479517281,
-0.0150713045,
0.0467381813,
0.0672599822,
0.0505660363,
0.0213836171,
0.0287587456,
0.0098166931,
-0.0450086743,
0.0274276659,
-0.0146840895,
-0.0614889003,
-0.0484770499,
0.00127403,
0.0148898289,
-0.0321542025,
-0.0064521134,
0.0269148741,
-0.0124790519,
0.0069165905,
-0.0317235962,
-0.0308521278,
-0.0197243169,
-0.0492561981,
0.0435839072,
0.0400566943,
-0.0322684646,
0.0272836592,
-0.0482588634,
0.0377005078,
0.0091714356,
-0.0183428787,
-0.0462171808,
0.0161323454,
-0.0491073504,
-0.020678699,
-0.0372011177,
-0.0015098961,
0.00722672,
-0.0072662048,
-0.0340235643,
0.0458903797,
0.0099982657,
0.0316091776,
-0.0135830389,
-0.0172022767,
-0.0106576318,
0.0036378971,
-0.0362653472,
-0.0073339958,
-0.0068882713,
0.0163748171,
-0.0135138333,
-0.0305648465,
-0.008716248,
0.0115160625,
0.028142089,
0.0069733737,
0.0144382007,
0.0563820265,
0.0360234901,
-0.0378752314,
-0.0667641088,
-0.008483463,
-0.0107830968,
-0.026830513,
-0.007821762,
-0.0186064877,
0.0069418452,
0.0028375038,
0.023424821,
-0.0076088295,
-0.0111111477,
0.003844013,
-0.0196934696,
0.0782914758,
0.0096566658,
-0.0228048209,
-0.0065291263,
-0.0251848232,
0.0120433178,
0.0810676515,
0.0585012585,
0.0279786456,
0.0128509207,
-0.0333426781,
-0.0337432772,
0.040861357,
0.0010130733,
-0.0084930528,
-0.1024937257,
0.0188261587,
-0.0075834831,
0.0312998481,
0.0288209226,
0.0067315116,
0.0019484876,
0.0028714356,
0.0491937548,
0.0653858632,
0.0131808445,
0.039321281,
0.048078727,
-0.0169400387,
0.0012678494,
-0.0065152678,
-0.0036735877,
0.0202539731,
-0.0493993573,
0.0317794234,
-0.0320662335,
0.0309644304,
-0.0474493578,
-0.0378545262,
-0.0282313228,
-0.0225480758,
0.0089052236,
-0.0163572542,
0.051910609,
-0.048707284,
-0.0588895008,
0.0510024279,
0.0173374712,
0.0009391312,
-0.0096241077,
-0.0184275303,
0.0480339713,
0.0904881582,
-0.0001949302,
-0.0072249323,
0.0039496883,
-0.020021528,
0.0224327259,
0.052892331,
0.0457187109,
0.00282351,
-0.0142781716,
-0.0609864257,
-0.0487207063,
-0.0084118014,
0.0094054574,
0.0118726203,
-0.0472696237,
0.03698254,
0.0280359834,
-0.0258851331,
-0.0050806478,
0.0213669091,
-0.0287233368,
-0.0505363122,
-0.0083972691,
0.0131293964,
0.0558948964,
0.0141600277,
-0.0031786803,
0.0043691229,
0.0380093567,
-0.0449621715,
-0.0239929371,
0.0352529846,
-0.1025783122,
-0.0451494902,
-0.0108357342,
0.0210800767,
-0.0119289272,
0.009580289,
-0.078355141,
-0.0572616011,
0.0201483257,
-0.0029770343,
0.0750909373,
-0.0723289996,
0.0061393999,
-0.0011023296,
0.0043284418,
-0.0326328166,
0.0476379693,
-0.0169532634,
0.0094515197,
0.0005148997,
0.0297360662,
0.0086655263,
-0.012289525,
-0.0356393792,
0.0262323543,
0.0386940688,
0.0089919772,
-0.013145973,
0.0043485663,
-0.0182165466,
-0.0404916033,
-0.0879031345,
-0.0313344337,
-0.0268584155,
0.0261729751,
-0.0024539372,
-0.0254475698,
-0.005817655,
0.0011177292,
-0.0335435458,
0.0222642273,
-0.0210147705,
-0.001475621,
0.056173183,
0.0076185861,
-0.0457987934,
0.0023478142,
0.0166238453,
-0.0145444283,
0.0722209811,
-0.0193555001,
-0.0050502671,
-0.0445708483,
0.0159354303,
-0.0047130696,
-0.0033506935,
0.0032042204,
0.0019911374,
-0.0036712005,
-0.0305891633,
0.0299094524,
0.0084183188,
0.0008012464,
0.0397571065,
0.0271147583,
-0.0244151056,
-0.0415306725,
0.0160514303,
0.0046707173,
0.0394009724,
-0.0394418985,
0.0127520943,
-0.0089678112,
0.0849210322,
-0.0162630435,
0.0166403502,
-0.0504344292,
0.005812231,
-0.0238435362,
0.020020213,
-0.0328204222,
0.0109056644,
-0.0402152278,
-0.0006760283,
-0.0129108317,
-0.0812500864,
0.0520475693,
-0.042914018,
-0.0140818395,
0.0033732569,
-0.0733571574,
-0.0883598328,
0.0361042731,
0.0070529701,
-0.0064917752,
-0.009909248,
-0.0298511367,
-0.0362081043,
-0.0049303113,
-0.0339520648,
-0.0126465866,
0.0344655141,
0.0065541361,
0.0093403636,
-0.0094090197,
-0.001906955,
-0.0244037975,
-0.0459413938,
-0.074498117,
0.0273804367,
-0.0149288112,
-0.0118508833,
-0.0461342223,
0.0645450652,
-0.0546844006,
0.0292453356,
0.0194647349,
-0.0049184533,
0.0015684264,
0.0187948681,
0.0359118804,
0.0109540774,
-0.0293584242,
-0.0027752586,
0.0619587898,
-0.0232567955,
0.0123644108,
-0.0024374493,
-0.0711850747,
0.0178352948,
0.025166221,
-0.0245135166,
-0.0336909182,
0.0180793442,
-0.0242332648,
-0.0613545589,
0.0103609283,
0.1414320618,
0.019215174,
-0.0316534005,
0.0033388773,
0.0000658474,
0.035979826,
-0.0032919769,
-0.0051099318,
-0.0525825061,
-0.0021498408,
0.0113922125,
-0.0182681847,
0.0119302357,
-0.0263233073,
-0.0267266687,
-0.0680850297,
0.0342013463,
0.0289050154,
-0.0500792414,
-0.012901145,
-0.0610754378,
-0.0157902371,
-0.0201221164,
0.0280996989,
-0.005566421,
-0.03396561,
0.0192081667,
0.0373002663,
-0.071768105,
-0.06688454,
-0.0003946037,
0.0113794059,
0.0034998565,
0.0428531058,
0.0280572902,
-0.0240352675,
-0.0451095365,
-0.0219216812,
-0.0104409717,
0.04420105,
-0.0363400467,
0.002292773,
-0.0127185639,
-0.0254772287,
0.0143357906,
0.0328034721,
-0.0376479179,
0.0021096638,
0.0055754986,
0.0964520946,
-0.032578446,
-0.0170822293,
-0.0093301665,
-0.0388994627,
0.0043475931,
0.0784028769,
0.0267221145,
-0.0214211922,
-0.0244878288,
0.0046961382,
-0.0103567876,
-0.0416493565,
-0.0026625746,
-0.01038408,
-0.0133604892,
0.021971155,
-0.0306333229,
-0.02619908,
0.0213635601,
0.0675352588,
-0.0190188102,
0.0234924462,
-0.0226202533,
-0.0235042479,
-0.0502547212,
0.0268502142,
-0.0386430584,
0.0176166464,
-0.054440815,
0.0058437274,
0.0616314821,
-0.022494562,
-0.0210269298,
0.0000953286,
-0.0830145851,
-0.0463644229,
0.0203046575,
-0.0318854302,
0.0126370471,
0.0206535365,
0.0485082902,
0.0072960136,
0.1679751724,
0.0260113645,
-0.0128311589,
-0.0070148553,
0.0328282528,
0.0106591126,
0.0084964829,
0.0207051672,
-0.0307139792,
0.0330850333,
-0.0219819397,
-0.0025069192,
-0.0332223661,
-0.0263950266,
-0.0143700419,
-0.0104493564,
0.0670123324,
0.003031567,
-0.0195710547,
-0.0276611522,
0.0193507858,
-0.0031391673,
0.0176770445,
-0.0523241051,
0.0014907215,
0.0155881057,
-0.007640454,
-0.0268080886,
0.0132863503,
0.0229776725,
0.0266644415,
-0.002844014,
0.0694026873,
-0.0194032639,
0.0128282616,
0.0256254617,
0.0592987686,
0.0006807987,
0.0007952718,
-0.0165615454,
0.0036822758,
-0.002782552,
0.0357014053,
-0.011745641,
0.0650435016,
-0.0406545103,
0.0152901616,
-0.0625052005,
-0.0089654373,
-0.0294162333,
-0.0055676238,
0.037596833,
-0.042558495,
0.0105461944,
-0.0443357527,
0.0002774725,
0.0192412101,
0.0375975035,
-0.0285509732,
-0.0298748352,
0.0778169259,
-0.0032321825,
-0.0823908821,
-0.0142948162,
0.0439652465,
0.0479629524,
0.0300463699,
0.0196284316,
-0.0134208603,
-0.0378795601,
0.0155611495,
0.0914564729,
-0.0035807602,
-0.0035081864,
-0.0283187162,
-0.05407032,
-0.0530584343,
0.0478368327,
-0.0599765517,
-0.0515311286,
-0.0292161927,
0.0013416091,
0.0266204774,
0.0116725611,
0.0630697832,
0.0173768271,
-0.0080148512,
0.0136133162,
-0.0646052957,
-0.0159960054,
-6.474862391e-33,
-0.0107221482,
-0.0009276312,
0.0297170579,
-0.0406123735,
-0.0225822516,
0.0858939663,
0.0029372536,
-0.0382474959,
0.0200538374,
-0.0190798901,
-0.0184654873,
-0.0225136671,
0.0204854347,
0.011744475,
0.0395691656,
-0.0161593556,
0.0737047791,
-0.0268916171,
0.0367248841,
-0.0069482126,
0.0327670127,
0.0545863621,
0.0745265856,
-0.0179944914,
0.0008308128,
-0.0066540241,
-0.0157119967,
-0.0046253866,
0.0538695492,
0.0430337675,
-0.0265279934,
0.047245685,
0.0269843787,
-0.0225317273,
-0.0566092208,
0.03807576,
-0.0289690346,
-0.069137089,
-0.0011566291,
0.0091191567,
-0.0089799035,
-0.0201462787,
0.0084141996,
-0.0076052761,
0.0019580913,
0.0194911305,
0.0115768798,
-0.0313276164,
-0.0195329487,
-0.0183370616,
-0.0082092714,
0.047554329,
0.0025253659,
0.0213894248,
0.0720088556,
0.0209968984,
0.0332276784,
0.0380824469,
-0.079265736,
0.015248172,
0.001243663,
-0.0016859539,
0.0371240862,
0.0298231989,
0.015077712,
0.0494814478,
-0.0113381473,
0.0025103367,
-0.013555482,
0.0105519444,
0.0414090492,
0.022165712,
0.0070895925,
0.0130006894,
0.0636024773,
-0.0416044816,
-0.0173569489,
0.0402355082,
0.0484800339,
0.0281193182,
0.0323466249,
0.0525134839,
-0.0419767722,
-0.0333760828,
-0.0206032339,
-0.0181852654,
-0.0223736037,
-0.0580977499,
0.0381544195,
0.03752077,
0.0464482531,
0.0081066415,
0.0392692052,
-0.0382036269,
-0.0233158637,
0.018936174,
-0.0207914636,
0.0132940421,
0.0223238636,
-0.0008367435,
-0.0936377347,
-0.0837602466,
0.0242414698,
0.0280698016,
0.0000682244,
-0.0394723229,
0.0316856727,
0.0645565614,
-0.0722004846,
-0.0111615648,
0.0060657202,
-0.0441869125,
0.018185392,
-0.0210499316,
0.0343932472,
-0.0302302539,
-0.0007581403,
0.0460126027,
0.0032585887,
-0.0172763448,
0.0061725443,
-0.0152111771,
0.0063020256,
0.0439775661,
0.0168944132,
-0.0166552868,
-0.009149895,
0.0076078898,
0.0770205408,
-0.0307258684,
0.0020388616,
0.0040588318,
2.802e-7,
0.0217788965,
0.0399335101,
0.011714655,
0.0066151326,
0.0222821813,
0.0248714089,
-0.0417316183,
0.0289597362,
-0.0198056828,
0.0408255681,
0.0724337026,
-0.0002857595,
0.05840002,
0.0399898924,
-0.0889372379,
-0.0128924241,
-0.095598951,
0.0203467961,
-0.0650056154,
0.0066094277,
0.0765730813,
0.1264820248,
0.0357344337,
0.0026380434,
0.0109478785,
-0.0639831647,
0.0524132363,
-0.0572004132,
-0.0143595627,
-0.0047506317,
-0.0055727838,
0.0380231552,
-0.0352397449,
-0.0138465455,
-0.0060315207,
0.0473976023,
-0.0268120468,
0.0241220389,
0.0126701389,
-0.0055655362,
0.0109634688,
0.0030972334,
-0.0365063101,
-0.0521837883,
0.0535645448,
-0.0422431305,
-0.0630566776,
-0.0597985536,
-0.033779636,
-0.0024639757,
0.0245421939,
0.0207757633,
0.0040136087,
0.0299973488,
-0.0112822438,
-0.0434583202,
-0.0337887332,
-0.0738950893,
-0.0232724342,
0.0206649844,
-0.0445587188,
-0.0160366744,
-0.0692482442,
0.026514478,
0.0693371519,
-0.022275595,
0.0202589836,
2.983900574e-34,
0.050134819,
-0.0196131002,
-0.0248909313,
0.0650799051,
0.0103324987,
-0.0178487357,
0.0307192281,
0.0430250056,
0.0362135731,
-0.1015480682,
-0.0047616218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08239v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08239v2 | MemoChat: Tuning LLMs to Use Memos for Consistent Long-Range Open-Domain Conversation | 2023-08-16T09:15:18 | 2023-08-23T03:37:04 | Junru Lu, Siyu An, Mingbao Lin, Gabriele Pergola, Yulan He, Di Yin, Xing Sun, Yunsheng Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose MemoChat, a pipeline for refining instructions that enables large
language models (LLMs) to effectively employ self-composed memos for
maintaining consistent long-range open-domain conversations. We demonstrate a
long-range open-domain conversation through iterative
"memorization-retrieval-response" cycles. This requires us to carefully design
tailored tuning instructions for each distinct stage. The instructions are
reconstructed from a collection of public datasets to teach the LLMs to
memorize and retrieve past dialogues with structured memos, leading to enhanced
consistency when participating in future conversations. We invite experts to
manually annotate a test set designed to evaluate the consistency of long-range
conversations questions. Experiments on three testing scenarios involving both
open-source and API-accessible chatbots at scale verify the efficacy of
MemoChat, which outperforms strong baselines. Our codes, data and models are
available here: https://github.com/LuJunru/MemoChat. | [
0.054145921,
0.0752913505,
-0.0218549129,
0.0189618915,
-0.0454347469,
-0.0096998895,
0.0045366511,
-0.00003021,
0.0537870005,
-0.0349339843,
-0.0211789254,
-0.0483441763,
-0.0047014235,
0.0281171668,
-0.0107736383,
-0.0462935455,
0.0307876002,
-0.0426803939,
-0.0018196005,
-0.0172704309,
0.0060562966,
-0.0032509372,
-0.0318643339,
0.045836024,
-0.0013701594,
-0.0350659564,
-0.0312577151,
-0.0038040702,
-0.0298023112,
-0.030214794,
0.0280835424,
0.0486057028,
0.0203182045,
0.0136604402,
0.000001847,
-0.0414172076,
-0.0176374931,
-0.0256856475,
-0.0463677011,
-0.0216300935,
0.0172221698,
0.0164265186,
-0.0064452793,
0.0438860878,
-0.0360083543,
0.005488453,
0.0316730849,
0.0024126759,
0.0821696669,
0.0849221349,
0.0134018585,
0.0032672891,
0.0173208788,
-0.020099666,
0.0034214747,
-0.0746515915,
0.005326007,
0.022379769,
0.0077278633,
0.030135978,
-0.0024485574,
0.0243832003,
0.0364755467,
-0.0128469616,
0.01615371,
0.0359264649,
-0.025888104,
-0.027201293,
-0.0245075822,
0.0944046378,
0.0731188953,
0.0014943662,
0.0008447761,
0.0168060362,
0.0160923153,
-0.0334830433,
-0.0996941701,
0.0361219533,
-0.0054612681,
-0.0142299077,
-0.0472171158,
-0.0291969962,
-0.0066566998,
0.0185202714,
-0.0314203128,
0.0213351939,
0.0070325565,
-0.0241227541,
-0.0185854286,
-0.0279362705,
0.025394354,
-0.0915657729,
0.0158544779,
0.0730900019,
-0.0532491393,
0.0456053279,
-0.02155862,
0.0045848717,
0.041897323,
-0.0203303844,
0.0295728762,
0.0480757207,
-0.0128659382,
0.0587226041,
0.0243656691,
0.0575689338,
0.0071341787,
0.0052818628,
-0.0110740382,
-0.0230978578,
-0.0523578227,
-0.0207767375,
-0.0297521967,
0.0335988551,
-0.0101553537,
-0.0228520539,
-0.0066101649,
0.0492101237,
0.0138399815,
0.0447755121,
-0.0018989776,
-0.0011676331,
-0.0407103114,
-0.0204429924,
-0.0425536893,
0.0544573404,
-0.0427801497,
-0.0150320102,
0.047780443,
-0.0791674629,
-0.0383234471,
0.0209298711,
-0.0234392826,
-0.0091432994,
-0.0252301097,
0.0870927349,
-0.001211663,
-0.0199796613,
-0.0039919722,
-0.0363347791,
-0.0187347662,
-0.0795968324,
0.0376956686,
-0.0457249284,
0.0368294083,
0.0171380043,
-0.0068293116,
-0.0265572593,
0.014199282,
0.0327667557,
-0.0158777367,
0.0444179736,
0.0213933438,
0.00771255,
0.0324459746,
0.04550419,
-0.0163492411,
0.0788807645,
0.017997168,
0.016166959,
0.0557570495,
-0.0096659698,
0.017220987,
0.0162635148,
0.0290003996,
0.0004591487,
0.008967774,
0.0583276339,
0.0257486068,
0.0593833961,
0.0048063039,
0.0444901958,
-0.042806562,
-0.0389416553,
0.0624282174,
0.0377097949,
-0.0043126754,
0.0177154504,
0.0178752001,
0.0312796645,
0.0260111708,
0.0200237148,
-0.0569972359,
0.0340566412,
-0.0029836176,
-0.0016405359,
0.0443023629,
0.0019528511,
-0.0513773225,
-0.0339485593,
0.0014822948,
-0.0172434412,
-0.013707649,
0.0080816196,
0.036125496,
0.0161556005,
-0.0573992878,
0.0977961496,
0.0183860958,
-0.043591056,
-0.0474621952,
-0.0184406042,
0.0443845131,
0.0650463253,
0.0645590723,
-0.0221385639,
-0.0541507415,
-0.007856789,
0.0238675941,
0.0250189081,
0.0591616221,
-0.0061256541,
0.0186120942,
-0.0564809255,
-0.020247506,
-0.0070959246,
-0.000039763,
0.0148038445,
0.0542472377,
0.004977874,
0.0034780088,
-0.0129194958,
0.0257449169,
0.0101354998,
-0.0454518721,
-0.0131413406,
-0.0057403157,
-0.0303857215,
0.0301044658,
0.0264307316,
0.0082856631,
0.0051826835,
0.0307166874,
-0.0081526032,
-0.0231637247,
0.0078308973,
-0.1071307585,
-0.0017254268,
0.0537543595,
0.0279145315,
-0.0278007705,
0.0206236579,
-0.0311701428,
-0.0254410692,
0.0360493585,
-0.0174447764,
0.0433460735,
-0.0374359302,
0.0206580833,
0.0246281773,
-0.0048622042,
-0.0255210977,
0.0117182834,
0.0080698337,
-0.0107723642,
0.0168034993,
0.01423233,
-0.0042165606,
-0.0570258871,
0.0267205816,
0.0505933762,
-0.0028404142,
0.0120129371,
0.0135621922,
0.0169932898,
-0.0829844996,
-0.0504463725,
-0.1434643418,
0.0287619885,
-0.0198038258,
-0.0073869568,
0.0190789159,
0.0194316208,
-0.0110787926,
-0.0262231864,
-0.0335249938,
0.0327334963,
0.0289986469,
0.0296062808,
0.0268924031,
0.0000104211,
-0.0178762004,
-0.0370814875,
0.0014464083,
0.0094187139,
0.0306618251,
-0.0102353431,
0.0177523009,
-0.0640054271,
-0.0178572405,
-0.0509546623,
0.0337670445,
-0.0274952594,
-0.0338679701,
0.0150007624,
-0.014764647,
0.0594180897,
0.0731233731,
0.0335539505,
0.0244153626,
0.0007906905,
-0.0354980044,
-0.0802480131,
0.0336099453,
-0.0110059334,
-0.0548769683,
-0.0425441191,
0.009481688,
-0.0102989851,
0.0364618935,
-0.0187436435,
0.0186449196,
-0.0300886631,
0.0147915492,
0.0116217053,
-0.0152999926,
-0.0016296878,
0.0230601653,
-0.0376287289,
0.0051625748,
-0.0084014749,
-0.0602266155,
0.054724168,
-0.032831043,
-0.014914738,
-0.0356944837,
-0.0062722452,
-0.0403316803,
0.0934914649,
-0.0368554592,
-0.0133846849,
-0.0072298902,
-0.0459748432,
-0.0402671099,
-0.0272491965,
0.0027875679,
-0.0483893193,
0.0270596631,
-0.0577999428,
0.0109196249,
0.0075544538,
-0.0324420072,
-0.0754149854,
-0.0026007947,
-0.0444452539,
0.0197616499,
-0.0215660445,
-0.0228964612,
-0.063928552,
-0.0092550879,
0.0235511623,
0.0212308783,
-0.0109256217,
0.0103817116,
-0.022614941,
-0.0074510425,
0.0421445332,
0.0258945879,
-0.0023482956,
-0.0330761522,
0.0480637588,
0.0684591085,
0.0253916923,
-0.0058619641,
-0.0038090141,
-0.0236814246,
0.0204874687,
-0.0417417772,
0.0200284831,
0.0054043154,
0.0810175762,
-0.0550192893,
-0.0417270623,
0.1087200567,
0.0234518051,
-0.0521331392,
-0.02349668,
-0.0274052527,
0.0716011003,
0.0107985875,
0.0228867289,
-0.0995410681,
-0.025370419,
0.0340576544,
0.0317994244,
0.0130288796,
-0.0377990268,
-0.021082785,
-0.1234894171,
0.0032063723,
0.0162758771,
-0.0542544462,
-0.0000837246,
-0.0412329808,
-0.0002229687,
0.0083667384,
0.056823045,
0.0375888832,
-0.0002808908,
-0.014185044,
-0.0256464574,
-0.0326681398,
0.0062358733,
0.0474230871,
-0.0262690205,
0.0790849105,
0.0464552417,
0.0270884056,
0.057201229,
-0.0004495603,
0.0653136894,
0.0001412553,
-0.0096119568,
-0.0135688316,
0.0602771714,
-0.0121291177,
0.0044091893,
-0.0049769226,
0.0287702475,
-0.028469177,
-0.0010730026,
0.034847077,
0.0356917866,
-0.039694,
0.012183493,
0.0028382093,
0.038763877,
0.0283391736,
0.0681165829,
0.0298982691,
-0.0167962126,
-0.0535768308,
-0.0284227822,
-0.0016054279,
-0.0310493372,
0.0055083712,
0.0080280015,
-0.0149026774,
0.0200465899,
-0.0681334138,
-0.0593013018,
0.0291095693,
0.0029367222,
-0.0035553616,
-0.0176225379,
0.0114862919,
0.0181653723,
-0.0114540262,
0.0308724437,
-0.0867603198,
0.0102512538,
-0.062020503,
-0.0347894542,
0.0293972604,
-0.0297538769,
0.0084924046,
0.0569562875,
-0.0964051187,
-0.0536598712,
-0.0084691066,
0.0448575653,
0.0262671039,
0.068061009,
-0.0016945653,
-0.0226956066,
0.0013590745,
0.0147584565,
-0.0667896643,
-0.0025642889,
0.030034624,
0.0584835634,
-0.0028983683,
0.0485809371,
-0.0424900316,
-0.0080348141,
-0.0161723103,
0.0670997947,
0.0102678137,
-0.0543177873,
0.0161737185,
-0.0083746528,
-0.0137372967,
0.0393024907,
-0.0027316639,
0.0041319993,
0.0519261695,
-0.0330203772,
-0.0078838998,
-0.0418472849,
0.0110829799,
-0.0114965588,
-0.0479684398,
0.0315333642,
-0.0210810695,
-0.041914884,
0.0570226647,
0.0055962112,
-0.0071450123,
0.0026718527,
-0.0138326492,
0.0288758073,
-0.0241158139,
-0.0354401916,
0.0126103405,
-0.0218039323,
0.0289843343,
-0.0013640665,
0.0794410706,
0.0073087867,
-0.0245170686,
0.0030713424,
0.0117151672,
-0.0693997443,
-0.1001472399,
0.0198564883,
0.0648972467,
0.046946004,
0.0210450832,
0.0196898207,
-0.0376146771,
0.0175812487,
-0.0305783749,
0.0244487878,
-0.0055490294,
-0.0207960065,
0.0209216941,
0.0351401679,
-0.0187811609,
0.0241968911,
0.06270504,
-0.0149194356,
0.0335912816,
0.0001099664,
0.0236045569,
-0.040875949,
-0.0423178561,
0.0298370104,
0.0252651051,
-0.0102114631,
-0.0286342427,
-0.0117536774,
-0.0442746244,
0.0108925244,
0.0095988968,
-0.0353127457,
-0.0031579807,
0.0263771452,
0.0629162416,
-0.0277282968,
-0.0126117328,
-0.0452001877,
0.0358401313,
-0.0350610651,
-0.034038607,
-0.0231183935,
-6.279016951e-33,
-0.0188925676,
-0.0329201929,
0.0551523007,
0.0122930594,
-0.0651530996,
-0.0270441938,
-0.0554872938,
0.0064306762,
-0.0064755706,
-0.0244299117,
-0.0389316007,
0.0337841623,
0.0249910001,
0.0370194651,
-0.0043063913,
-0.0375766605,
0.0402495712,
-0.0031644288,
-0.0124823507,
0.0604089424,
0.0245458763,
0.0455703139,
0.0243791696,
-0.0676934123,
0.0323133692,
-0.0138701061,
0.0254097655,
0.0364973024,
-0.0119200107,
0.0548762344,
-0.01962981,
0.0174637977,
0.0056331865,
-0.0279179383,
-0.030236356,
0.0110317217,
-0.0684661716,
-0.0103355991,
0.0157900676,
0.0004811137,
-0.03948332,
-0.0328919739,
0.0197214372,
-0.0398509763,
0.0315464027,
-0.0375845172,
0.0022906417,
-0.013359135,
-0.0307242591,
0.0198808685,
-0.0112964772,
0.017818734,
-0.0058196997,
-0.0408717357,
-0.0315327197,
0.0187229365,
0.0467871726,
0.034119729,
-0.0248230882,
0.0305928662,
-0.0082928846,
0.0121520925,
0.0470648184,
0.0108479643,
0.0255525056,
0.0641257614,
0.015760392,
0.0200792775,
-0.0088961739,
-0.0413962789,
0.0045820572,
0.0357383154,
-0.0001643087,
0.0250902083,
0.0006903197,
-0.0051477687,
-0.0264434554,
-0.0131609691,
0.0045311372,
0.0505256169,
-0.0085729435,
0.0258374047,
-0.0173077714,
0.0075578191,
-0.0422817692,
0.0339841433,
-0.0301319975,
-0.0316060036,
0.0394431762,
0.0327638984,
-0.0133565785,
-0.0476048142,
0.0424520411,
-0.0374992006,
-0.0077877194,
0.0149521325,
-0.0089627886,
-0.0029636,
-0.015399524,
0.0367549807,
-0.0551813729,
-0.0213814881,
0.0230434351,
-0.0127907675,
-0.0037766045,
0.0320344716,
-0.0040007392,
-0.0012348761,
-0.0544283316,
-0.0079312315,
-0.0433533043,
0.0427593812,
-0.0292568989,
-0.0027048481,
0.018498905,
0.0328972042,
-0.0208458658,
0.0974359885,
-0.0016925264,
-0.003995785,
-0.0451500863,
-0.0216142647,
0.0074920803,
-0.0124501791,
-0.0282995626,
-0.0048332349,
-0.0324737579,
-0.0008893027,
0.0031703077,
-0.0355461501,
0.0122123472,
-0.0141634448,
2.546e-7,
-0.0164813548,
0.0326028541,
0.0516940057,
0.0446135849,
0.0284071174,
0.0073951506,
-0.0238857828,
0.01605892,
0.0115184626,
-0.0389503278,
-0.0063079656,
0.067270197,
0.062344268,
0.0314773507,
-0.1031887531,
-0.0241568312,
-0.0648925006,
-0.0534196012,
-0.0621031336,
-0.0200474616,
0.0600748211,
0.0738618746,
0.0129892146,
0.0173519421,
0.0023833213,
-0.025626136,
0.0658413991,
-0.0427335389,
-0.0229956601,
0.0303963069,
0.0339934491,
0.0057067033,
0.0219598934,
-0.0036697234,
0.0127384225,
-0.0129717514,
-0.0238775238,
0.0792487189,
0.0347788483,
-0.0713858455,
-0.003601166,
-0.0038687158,
-0.0089541879,
-0.038656719,
0.0369479246,
-0.072777845,
-0.0333787464,
-0.0161163285,
-0.0018851048,
-0.0330860317,
0.031918522,
0.0085203266,
-0.0061226068,
0.0399161689,
-0.0083851712,
0.025168851,
0.0312835947,
-0.0766050965,
-0.002203325,
-0.0366918556,
-0.0670315325,
-0.061984539,
-0.0344324633,
-0.0370461382,
-0.0198157746,
-0.0516874567,
0.0194634721,
1.926206828e-34,
0.047918126,
-0.0099104242,
0.0048987246,
0.0555915311,
0.0424967818,
-0.0220496133,
0.0406908765,
0.0242692754,
0.0350601673,
-0.0763309151,
-0.0238872115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08234v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08234v1 | Challenges and Opportunities of Using Transformer-Based Multi-Task Learning in NLP Through ML Lifecycle: A Survey | 2023-08-16T09:11:00 | 2023-08-16T09:11:00 | Lovre Torbarina, Tin Ferkovic, Lukasz Roguski, Velimir Mihelcic, Bruno Sarlija, Zeljko Kraljevic | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The increasing adoption of natural language processing (NLP) models across
industries has led to practitioners' need for machine learning systems to
handle these models efficiently, from training to serving them in production.
However, training, deploying, and updating multiple models can be complex,
costly, and time-consuming, mainly when using transformer-based pre-trained
language models. Multi-Task Learning (MTL) has emerged as a promising approach
to improve efficiency and performance through joint training, rather than
training separate models. Motivated by this, we first provide an overview of
transformer-based MTL approaches in NLP. Then, we discuss the challenges and
opportunities of using MTL approaches throughout typical ML lifecycle phases,
specifically focusing on the challenges related to data engineering, model
development, deployment, and monitoring phases. This survey focuses on
transformer-based MTL architectures and, to the best of our knowledge, is novel
in that it systematically analyses how transformer-based MTL in NLP fits into
ML lifecycle phases. Furthermore, we motivate research on the connection
between MTL and continual learning (CL), as this area remains unexplored. We
believe it would be practical to have a model that can handle both MTL and CL,
as this would make it easier to periodically re-train the model, update it due
to distribution shifts, and add new capabilities to meet real-world
requirements. | [
0.0488769114,
0.0622179918,
-0.0139913736,
-0.0083480906,
-0.0370236374,
0.0194635317,
-0.0097430712,
-0.0497643277,
-0.0021963881,
-0.0611988939,
-0.0151220709,
-0.0340191387,
-0.0314376466,
0.0241813194,
-0.0040764092,
-0.0154644232,
0.0217190757,
0.0052122925,
-0.0265253,
0.019910926,
-0.0130643211,
0.015402846,
-0.0061977524,
0.0412046127,
-0.0282616355,
-0.0372378044,
-0.0298442263,
-0.0291245077,
-0.0019258201,
0.0156650543,
0.0133847753,
0.022529671,
0.0332310796,
0.0329166874,
0.0000019165,
-0.0348446593,
-0.0602136925,
0.002500602,
-0.0360895693,
-0.0599997379,
0.0618812181,
-0.0324369967,
-0.0099938223,
0.0379032232,
-0.0601035133,
-0.0141322762,
0.0762995631,
0.0590045899,
0.0658037663,
0.0410271659,
-0.014767644,
-0.0205732081,
0.0449046083,
-0.0026264442,
-0.0279786363,
-0.0316832103,
0.0184759628,
-0.0025777027,
-0.0360070728,
-0.015205319,
-0.0149930427,
0.0562991053,
0.0240637381,
0.0026848156,
-0.0094160987,
0.0213079285,
0.0085155526,
-0.02680609,
-0.061335694,
0.0203609783,
-0.0600866377,
-0.0244576558,
-0.0192189012,
0.0103159724,
-0.00299182,
0.0050349175,
-0.0258743707,
0.03658792,
0.0140264919,
0.0161612798,
-0.0063704834,
-0.0202082172,
0.0029644198,
-0.0050169784,
-0.0669738129,
0.0405238271,
-0.0216122326,
-0.0217122082,
0.01268519,
0.0358288102,
-0.0141380932,
-0.0045067044,
0.0014418268,
0.0338487141,
-0.0456496812,
0.0412615798,
-0.0252741259,
-0.0649964586,
-0.005993309,
-0.0360232219,
0.0581295677,
-0.0015827453,
-0.0328684151,
0.0400416031,
-0.0256831292,
0.0049482193,
0.0156592634,
-0.0164881833,
-0.0302916747,
-0.0309391562,
-0.0948700458,
-0.020191066,
-0.0530831181,
0.0485818796,
-0.0143215274,
-0.0201912373,
-0.0087774517,
0.0584791191,
-0.021620851,
-0.0144466488,
0.0365749113,
0.0133782262,
-0.0505393147,
0.0108446553,
-0.0060783043,
0.0655377954,
0.0328542888,
0.0199458245,
-0.0270842668,
-0.0400558747,
-0.0041738707,
0.0060542026,
0.0034975351,
-0.0244019814,
0.0106813293,
0.062696673,
-0.0223223791,
-0.0461904146,
-0.04767441,
0.0060178512,
-0.0142162545,
-0.0388711691,
-0.002316996,
-0.0448352471,
0.0330303907,
0.0105017852,
0.0317690782,
-0.0122387568,
-0.0018869975,
0.0205574669,
-0.0230493061,
0.1184743419,
0.0271063074,
0.0197826605,
-0.0328156762,
-0.0217326302,
-0.0061322316,
0.0896801427,
0.0363910273,
-0.0037982727,
0.0396845378,
-0.0040315576,
-0.0082878768,
0.0383019932,
-0.0173917264,
-0.0090352362,
0.0231500603,
-0.02292661,
0.0038079009,
-0.022619294,
0.0034413724,
0.0210277084,
0.0066185151,
0.0392514579,
0.0636469573,
0.0099111777,
0.0393722057,
0.0201694611,
0.0625709593,
0.02966916,
-0.0273924582,
-0.0090620182,
-0.0296354592,
-0.0033167454,
-0.027538795,
-0.0097781112,
-0.0711232051,
0.0541744456,
-0.0234486051,
-0.0488186218,
0.0096050818,
-0.0550988205,
0.0273224078,
0.0044256928,
0.0631751567,
0.0290371291,
-0.0523279719,
0.0960896686,
0.0211725496,
-0.0119077433,
-0.0168945864,
-0.0550058,
-0.0666429698,
0.0357427523,
0.0172874127,
-0.0617703423,
-0.0562655032,
-0.0410325751,
0.0177539364,
0.0039243368,
0.0084505193,
-0.0216006227,
0.0290712621,
-0.009544136,
-0.0321540087,
0.0152531806,
0.0061534108,
-0.0053313277,
0.0145746171,
-0.0007393147,
-0.024266528,
-0.0216775816,
-0.0423845127,
0.0420492701,
-0.0587664843,
-0.0081024067,
0.0349727832,
0.0076184436,
0.0025803181,
-0.0079644518,
-0.0154632069,
-0.0034169573,
0.0712343901,
-0.0315021686,
-0.0399411991,
0.0438887365,
-0.0311459173,
0.0015825267,
0.0454463027,
0.0157583226,
0.0170904025,
0.0531498827,
-0.0344770215,
-0.0160559211,
-0.0484265424,
-0.0245988034,
0.0530994199,
0.0023992772,
0.030920675,
-0.0298188906,
0.0098896343,
-0.0527775213,
0.0297887269,
-0.0102075869,
-0.0275738742,
-0.0094406186,
-0.0434241593,
-0.0195268802,
0.0007577472,
-0.0370816588,
0.0186361056,
0.0005501552,
0.0330252908,
0.0130309314,
0.018244883,
-0.0462465696,
-0.0375859141,
-0.0866605118,
-0.00397838,
-0.0396674164,
0.0072731855,
0.0203541778,
0.002666841,
0.0026799862,
-0.0150661552,
0.0125378855,
0.0024020397,
0.0007992293,
0.0166300088,
0.0177698079,
-0.0052910568,
0.0152564999,
0.0198454615,
-0.0228233747,
-0.0112616923,
0.0558982901,
-0.0152248712,
-0.0470444933,
-0.0910593495,
-0.0139546208,
0.0239157565,
0.0335942805,
-0.002426317,
0.0339322202,
-0.0234722458,
0.0114017511,
0.066255331,
0.0329097249,
0.0184891224,
0.0651834235,
0.0233210456,
-0.0163374469,
-0.0378931984,
0.0162620116,
-0.0503665581,
-0.0401788242,
-0.062517561,
0.0283335652,
0.028747905,
0.0405396447,
-0.0486045629,
-0.029270567,
-0.0158240516,
0.0052497159,
-0.0324065536,
-0.0378768593,
0.0066646975,
0.0126411952,
-0.0214964878,
-0.0048407838,
0.0036721381,
-0.0412720181,
0.0440695211,
0.0156159373,
-0.0065056169,
-0.1066778526,
-0.0245016571,
-0.0152769545,
0.0770103112,
0.0094410665,
0.0192724764,
0.0450976826,
-0.0370109975,
-0.0362928063,
0.0525073335,
0.0013792223,
-0.0086502908,
0.0880796164,
-0.0183858853,
0.0046922658,
-0.0069598146,
-0.0508600809,
-0.0451851897,
-0.0265538786,
-0.0229950603,
0.0338499174,
-0.0107939197,
-0.0032202441,
-0.0792188942,
0.0086688884,
-0.0025721341,
0.013532036,
0.0147984857,
-0.0598341711,
-0.0196856763,
0.0312158912,
0.0348759852,
0.033285968,
0.0304413568,
0.0014504155,
0.009628512,
0.0549215116,
0.0770899877,
-0.0298626386,
-0.0221485812,
-0.015130043,
0.0725646615,
-0.0676531345,
0.0111107687,
0.0056340089,
0.0191115402,
-0.0511074029,
-0.0158249475,
0.0982013717,
0.0169793442,
-0.0415689088,
0.0173837114,
0.0238968935,
0.006144424,
0.0217256602,
0.0387166962,
-0.073909536,
-0.0233768504,
0.0093226349,
0.0352542549,
0.0080539845,
-0.0159560386,
-0.0190069731,
-0.081530951,
0.0308786239,
-0.031989757,
0.0116595207,
0.0025536309,
-0.0551219061,
-0.0166630093,
-0.0643479973,
0.026484333,
-0.0251918882,
-0.0488002039,
-0.0322568156,
0.034192767,
-0.0308742691,
-0.0629637688,
0.0201339833,
-0.0518576875,
0.0101106521,
0.0437396429,
-0.0016874742,
-0.0179003682,
-0.0196966585,
0.0198448095,
0.0242198575,
0.0122120827,
-0.0110769561,
0.0334785655,
-0.0391844288,
-0.0167593155,
0.0067465333,
0.0075122556,
-0.0409258008,
-0.0125074321,
-0.0193258263,
0.1143719032,
0.0051739207,
0.0099073974,
0.0158601739,
-0.0390682444,
0.0188187473,
0.0656101257,
-0.0319226794,
-0.0856049433,
-0.0401343815,
0.0059643965,
-0.0068766833,
-0.0162074808,
-0.0486439504,
0.0096139712,
-0.0442640297,
-0.0117531717,
-0.0185765754,
-0.0259146057,
0.0439595543,
0.0468505658,
0.0194590092,
0.0127426339,
0.0674970523,
-0.0157813672,
-0.0980314985,
-0.0035161958,
-0.0314698257,
0.0369230695,
-0.0355010405,
-0.0305096153,
0.0489116982,
0.006432923,
-0.0207463335,
-0.0298754182,
-0.1077545136,
-0.0213979967,
0.0144569548,
0.0657836869,
0.0122430529,
0.0532153994,
-0.0019730038,
-0.012775681,
0.0050317808,
0.0530694984,
-0.0572246574,
-0.0235668179,
0.0622070841,
-0.0493626781,
-0.0054845931,
0.026206769,
-0.0158968717,
0.0066477596,
-0.0029459412,
0.0343626328,
-0.0035982467,
-0.0121279033,
0.0404438786,
-0.0061966353,
0.0633401051,
0.0260515623,
-0.0003967933,
-0.0232631899,
0.011022131,
0.0287910663,
-0.0338166803,
-0.0484867878,
0.0282545146,
0.0117187435,
0.0345846899,
-0.0121762892,
0.0409233831,
0.0310516823,
0.0184882246,
-0.052607432,
0.0248721167,
0.00966221,
-0.0382178053,
0.0199170336,
0.0196246468,
-0.0007526829,
-0.0338219553,
0.0524565913,
0.0379229225,
0.0019784418,
0.0276414305,
0.0352367908,
0.0282013547,
-0.0402102359,
0.0695186853,
-0.0539397635,
-0.0461954325,
-0.0180984344,
-0.0157650784,
0.0719188824,
-0.0388116427,
0.0765609667,
-0.0312119052,
-0.0192538686,
-0.0120332576,
0.0071457978,
0.0100457957,
0.0142207481,
-0.0146115739,
0.0083934981,
-0.0137388147,
-0.0040460927,
0.0820057094,
-0.021967724,
0.0388006642,
-0.0109195085,
-0.0458914079,
-0.0443076305,
-0.024299087,
0.006010009,
-0.0127905402,
-0.0035468058,
-0.0112692863,
-0.0381296426,
-0.0341962762,
0.0566590354,
-0.037219014,
0.0320653319,
-0.0458305962,
0.0178812146,
0.0945500135,
0.0494809188,
0.0193101577,
-0.040628463,
-0.0054545533,
0.0711548403,
0.0113738766,
-0.0025667145,
-5.661152508e-33,
0.0044986997,
-0.0122770788,
0.0450108461,
0.0103760324,
-0.0228610747,
0.0337721221,
0.033754006,
-0.0075111226,
-0.0049716998,
-0.0121052684,
-0.0077531878,
0.0033593948,
0.0146156931,
0.0141935768,
0.0400851145,
-0.0043953168,
0.0513979867,
-0.0031325759,
-0.010043107,
-0.003184577,
0.0297841541,
0.0556358062,
0.0675404593,
-0.0445483439,
0.0024864054,
0.050701037,
0.0263379496,
0.0313521251,
0.0089963647,
0.0657912567,
0.0037976375,
0.0522269793,
0.0502689891,
-0.1017989069,
-0.0450498201,
0.0045073405,
-0.1262442172,
0.0084295683,
-0.0336676463,
0.0388221629,
-0.033608973,
0.0402802527,
0.0403058082,
0.0020684456,
0.0065838965,
-0.0253267121,
0.0360320061,
-0.0262055248,
-0.0005925497,
-0.0563474782,
-0.0749709979,
0.0019389249,
0.0210059695,
-0.0236613061,
0.0405038074,
0.0443846136,
0.0222292896,
-0.0007354786,
-0.0964674056,
-0.003672505,
-0.0132519351,
0.0039503798,
0.0445462503,
0.0214756075,
-0.0158846453,
0.0320791788,
-0.021035308,
0.0173439421,
-0.0073991111,
0.0187863875,
0.0401655063,
0.0551626123,
0.0057323654,
-0.0303951744,
0.0156606622,
0.0002665152,
-0.0283275768,
0.0076503153,
0.0441832989,
0.0519065,
0.0191586446,
0.0187320542,
-0.0001985561,
-0.0283655487,
-0.0316983797,
0.0397813618,
-0.0072414181,
0.0044124648,
0.0197936185,
0.0429116637,
-0.0358550176,
0.0802243054,
0.0352024958,
-0.0595227219,
-0.0348157994,
0.0097073289,
-0.0142451525,
0.0132546648,
0.0016333641,
0.0320195518,
-0.0459744856,
-0.0311647486,
-0.0256695431,
-0.0016455504,
-0.0016533541,
-0.0024001019,
0.0656978786,
0.0624212809,
-0.0686302111,
0.0131240319,
-0.0203937292,
0.0267177355,
0.0200862065,
0.0654277578,
0.0455044284,
0.0356147848,
-0.0141525753,
0.0425906628,
0.0532859862,
-0.0318608545,
-0.039608229,
0.0529680364,
0.0043654884,
-0.0006423339,
0.0119261723,
-0.0224012304,
-0.0492968373,
0.0127033526,
-0.0052582938,
-0.0916018784,
-0.025437519,
-0.0189960692,
2.567e-7,
0.0539840162,
0.0551724844,
0.0120568071,
0.0023679938,
0.0292985365,
0.0265566111,
-0.0129004242,
0.0217815563,
-0.0015764823,
0.0417463183,
-0.0096753137,
0.0101086954,
0.0034914676,
0.0190940164,
-0.0563952066,
-0.0512562469,
-0.0417139791,
0.0341568738,
-0.0546792708,
0.0059204185,
0.0446885116,
0.0735930577,
0.0012714084,
-0.0202762149,
0.0109452736,
-0.0242806468,
0.0634113923,
-0.0037902456,
0.022368269,
0.0258446075,
0.0366763435,
0.0162318312,
0.0117884139,
0.0227003805,
-0.0298622064,
0.0135002881,
-0.015734354,
0.0542653389,
-0.0012253362,
-0.0191191323,
0.0278510265,
0.0024145278,
-0.0203241296,
-0.0200015921,
0.0854120031,
-0.1073591188,
-0.0286504086,
-0.0168186985,
-0.0156361852,
0.0222392008,
-0.0255399514,
0.0134311989,
-0.0258484054,
0.0330733955,
0.0371742137,
0.0137154898,
-0.0391843542,
-0.0857558176,
-0.0034789075,
0.0104265166,
-0.002481302,
-0.0027715527,
-0.0186011977,
-0.0650573224,
0.022001151,
-0.0673355907,
-0.0081656836,
2.673401088e-34,
0.0250832997,
0.0240723398,
0.027501205,
0.0482791141,
-0.0241909306,
-0.0319378264,
0.0005447072,
-0.015394832,
-0.0119424779,
-0.0609562546,
-0.0180115774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.11521v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.11521v2 | Self-Deception: Reverse Penetrating the Semantic Firewall of Large Language Models | 2023-08-16T09:04:36 | 2023-08-25T00:25:06 | Zhenhua Wang, Wei Xie, Kai Chen, Baosheng Wang, Zhiwen Gui, Enze Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, have emerged with astonishing
capabilities approaching artificial general intelligence. While providing
convenience for various societal needs, LLMs have also lowered the cost of
generating harmful content. Consequently, LLM developers have deployed
semantic-level defenses to recognize and reject prompts that may lead to
inappropriate content. Unfortunately, these defenses are not foolproof, and
some attackers have crafted "jailbreak" prompts that temporarily hypnotize the
LLM into forgetting content defense rules and answering any improper questions.
To date, there is no clear explanation of the principles behind these
semantic-level attacks and defenses in both industry and academia.
This paper investigates the LLM jailbreak problem and proposes an automatic
jailbreak method for the first time. We propose the concept of a semantic
firewall and provide three technical implementation approaches. Inspired by the
attack that penetrates traditional firewalls through reverse tunnels, we
introduce a "self-deception" attack that can bypass the semantic firewall by
inducing LLM to generate prompts that facilitate jailbreak. We generated a
total of 2,520 attack payloads in six languages (English, Russian, French,
Spanish, Chinese, and Arabic) across seven virtual scenarios, targeting the
three most common types of violations: violence, hate, and pornography. The
experiment was conducted on two models, namely the GPT-3.5-Turbo and GPT-4. The
success rates on the two models were 86.2% and 67%, while the failure rates
were 4.7% and 2.2%, respectively. This highlighted the effectiveness of the
proposed attack method. All experimental code and raw data will be released as
open-source to inspire future research. We believe that manipulating AI
behavior through carefully crafted prompts will become an important research
direction in the future. | [
0.0814181641,
0.0386460349,
-0.0465633571,
0.0319038108,
-0.0623238347,
-0.0090210931,
0.0552679747,
0.0256910417,
0.0771417022,
-0.0333977714,
-0.0018102733,
-0.0068654711,
0.001631108,
0.025112791,
0.0450472459,
0.009520987,
0.0355377756,
-0.0023277791,
0.0110036004,
-0.0177723356,
0.0315366387,
0.0057571405,
0.0212919507,
0.0299613606,
-0.003848494,
-0.0315146632,
-0.0074472767,
0.0116611449,
-0.0085256072,
-0.0436676815,
-0.00015475,
0.0424361825,
0.0065441709,
0.0586055852,
0.0000022937,
-0.0737674236,
-0.0253198072,
0.0102354931,
-0.0476350449,
0.0346683264,
0.029814519,
-0.0234267376,
-0.0467040017,
0.0294922404,
-0.0440438613,
0.0201835148,
0.028557172,
0.0606934354,
0.094574362,
0.0734466463,
-0.0138230771,
-0.0127287814,
0.046280425,
0.0016657201,
0.0181012247,
-0.0336264558,
0.0309782363,
-0.0175201166,
-0.0207670908,
0.002656799,
-0.0061701606,
0.0053203884,
0.0197157823,
-0.0123299928,
-0.0599828996,
-0.0036547089,
-0.0565005988,
-0.0361873135,
0.0029165379,
0.0220428333,
-0.0423766077,
-0.0279272832,
0.0316478349,
0.0180558283,
0.0140175438,
0.020244386,
-0.0152089642,
0.0248883869,
-0.022054648,
-0.0320711471,
0.0262148492,
-0.0072062099,
0.0443929099,
0.0226513725,
0.0071427478,
0.0153779844,
0.0091486825,
-0.0457673781,
0.000970968,
-0.0675543621,
0.0262547843,
-0.0713767484,
0.0109764896,
-0.0005741525,
-0.017232528,
0.0181172788,
-0.0716846436,
-0.0411120318,
0.0398826599,
-0.058775343,
-0.0292417184,
0.0650505945,
-0.0017708244,
0.0221377667,
-0.0041205026,
0.0418921523,
-0.041056674,
0.0362441801,
0.0161322039,
0.0170482788,
-0.0000468282,
-0.0142328637,
-0.0218414385,
0.0059929336,
0.0211178716,
0.0176021867,
-0.0473703854,
0.0410322659,
-0.0756739751,
0.0343785919,
-0.0471439362,
0.0005265092,
-0.0018891098,
-0.0034148458,
0.0064074099,
-0.035068728,
-0.0224037785,
-0.030376453,
-0.018018404,
-0.0882770494,
-0.0083212871,
0.0016381409,
-0.0678694099,
0.0203234069,
0.0312269386,
0.1240426376,
0.0120258713,
-0.0117979851,
-0.0464862771,
-0.0743030533,
-0.0204323102,
-0.0447635502,
0.01897409,
-0.0732337162,
-0.0011986624,
-0.0183452033,
-0.0194734801,
-0.06109225,
0.005591434,
0.0021105227,
-0.0331598148,
0.0699233711,
0.0131806685,
-0.0187088214,
0.0482927971,
0.0617049336,
-0.0051729577,
0.0510757267,
-0.0136175482,
0.0642521903,
0.0587667264,
-0.0103403199,
0.0460884757,
0.0247311331,
0.0223617125,
0.0356676504,
-0.0239539649,
-0.0056024319,
0.0247988813,
0.0055627003,
-0.0456099026,
0.0319778398,
-0.0221664552,
-0.0523272492,
0.0588197336,
0.0594084524,
-0.0651518852,
0.0661221147,
0.0224699434,
0.0166198593,
-0.0074720187,
0.0319918729,
-0.0439698994,
0.0202083401,
-0.0591721274,
-0.031892091,
0.0119691165,
0.0513543375,
-0.0095075499,
-0.014900269,
0.0041398951,
0.0022564407,
0.0425037891,
0.0228009801,
0.0032735777,
0.0300034676,
-0.0048390832,
-0.0004714356,
0.0496263131,
-0.0061946688,
-0.0286657214,
-0.1035035402,
0.0110639213,
0.0651986897,
0.0699294508,
-0.0002707587,
0.0171004683,
-0.0306689944,
0.0003418906,
0.0430816598,
0.008920054,
0.0217580907,
-0.0668992251,
-0.0021058726,
-0.012815495,
-0.014894356,
0.0054150391,
0.0155311022,
-0.019746596,
-0.0132139726,
-0.0062533449,
0.0442459174,
-0.0028176759,
0.0131863914,
0.0045130663,
-0.0280263312,
-0.0255936999,
0.0315070525,
0.04705045,
0.0034541639,
-0.0199148674,
-0.0102867037,
0.0561042801,
0.0061314064,
0.0025213587,
-0.0261873659,
-0.0262450818,
0.0274487827,
0.0260816664,
-0.0471655875,
-0.0024640914,
0.0712609366,
0.0043222229,
0.0223832168,
0.0658630654,
-0.0289863721,
0.0349449106,
-0.0378853157,
0.0127321072,
-0.0291250832,
0.013796635,
-0.0139673902,
0.0064093377,
-0.0071454006,
0.0080407336,
0.0074626808,
-0.0048223552,
0.0444913246,
0.001071364,
-0.0316332541,
-0.0004987678,
-0.0485097282,
0.0262128394,
0.0416258238,
0.0080989795,
-0.0218392406,
-0.0219768789,
-0.0689379424,
-0.0377533287,
-0.0142526403,
-0.0076489924,
0.0404775888,
-0.0082344329,
-0.0398122109,
0.0010648775,
-0.0538455136,
-0.0071320143,
0.0070877974,
0.0248149987,
-0.0087596299,
-0.0497261547,
-0.0396438166,
0.0033248649,
0.0179760028,
-0.0311573576,
0.033729583,
-0.0059864502,
-0.0275365803,
0.0116967997,
0.0128199132,
-0.0437504873,
0.0248441752,
-0.0232640114,
-0.0751339197,
0.0365901142,
-0.0046581505,
-0.0238108728,
0.0686740577,
0.0593451373,
0.0629528165,
0.0780570805,
0.0237994194,
-0.0625445917,
-0.0065118656,
0.0366167277,
-0.0158359222,
-0.029519584,
-0.0631674007,
0.0076824958,
0.0403601006,
0.0664769188,
0.026734408,
-0.0401900448,
0.0756256953,
-0.0472039469,
-0.036599081,
-0.0138435867,
-0.0497377291,
-0.040350154,
0.037698403,
0.0028672633,
-0.0576822162,
0.0802805945,
-0.0286601856,
0.0166442357,
-0.0078533906,
-0.0104207154,
0.0261141993,
0.0550572164,
-0.0252440684,
0.039098423,
0.0615984164,
-0.0151816159,
-0.0367296897,
-0.0296793338,
0.0597205237,
-0.0169256423,
-0.0132005978,
-0.0246626753,
-0.006470731,
0.0224181674,
-0.0330568366,
-0.072475858,
-0.0784274116,
-0.0208560377,
-0.0549831726,
0.0077894679,
-0.0250255596,
0.0101163676,
-0.0459538996,
0.0387098975,
-0.0067931721,
-0.0154167246,
-0.0225772765,
-0.0168429501,
-0.0080921333,
0.0475983433,
-0.0316143259,
-0.0011217908,
0.0097788442,
0.038882941,
0.0815255567,
-0.0078792805,
-0.0053406185,
0.0357858576,
0.0233888663,
0.0212339107,
0.0226094425,
0.0127484128,
0.0306095537,
0.0045702597,
-0.0300289486,
-0.0086021535,
0.0539845116,
0.0366879329,
-0.0182521679,
-0.0076029859,
-0.0202678423,
-0.0051057297,
0.0167637952,
0.0055074762,
-0.0838980079,
-0.0150338979,
0.0030787557,
0.0419069529,
-0.0768201873,
-0.0055992613,
-0.0242565684,
-0.0706539154,
0.0260762535,
0.0172968693,
-0.0323847197,
0.019379504,
-0.0179235153,
-0.0352355987,
0.0373437516,
0.0141938962,
-0.0439951867,
0.0247281324,
-0.0184916165,
-0.0134119829,
-0.0269726831,
0.0235593412,
0.0412692167,
-0.0210980009,
0.0822140425,
0.0524490848,
0.0159114283,
-0.0576089174,
-0.0149874063,
0.0438731238,
0.0005639257,
-0.0214795768,
-0.0008618722,
0.0203724112,
0.0141415745,
-0.0101996381,
0.0078877332,
0.0335128494,
0.0132765248,
-0.0221071411,
0.0585441701,
0.0805145055,
0.0061147064,
-0.0281651802,
-0.0129605206,
-0.0008842237,
0.0084523028,
0.0606985018,
0.0026908165,
-0.0501508005,
-0.0095441509,
-0.0820962265,
-0.0212154277,
0.0108321719,
-0.0683810413,
-0.0169593859,
0.0190100186,
-0.061300993,
-0.0316945538,
-0.0167822279,
-0.0258002728,
0.0109295817,
0.057397753,
-0.0210872944,
-0.0019607379,
0.0274965111,
-0.0091216061,
-0.0551235564,
-0.0208352059,
0.0312933996,
-0.0346044637,
0.0315487124,
-0.0369072556,
-0.0671262443,
0.0146332737,
0.0368799232,
-0.0099982684,
-0.0614104085,
0.0439290069,
0.0601640642,
0.0261266232,
0.0244877432,
-0.0229327958,
-0.0256460961,
0.0656057075,
0.049726788,
-0.0991918594,
0.0270489939,
0.0784973502,
0.0024574168,
0.0014155906,
0.0070805992,
-0.0189845711,
0.0075993189,
0.0624567904,
-0.0240950584,
-0.060959015,
-0.0190039258,
0.0515210293,
0.0556711704,
-0.0039393813,
-0.0131426714,
0.0243939832,
0.0208990891,
0.003657416,
-0.0175478049,
-0.0268133171,
0.0225583836,
-0.0010780877,
0.0055465526,
-0.0253942106,
0.0378986597,
0.0042939782,
-0.0444173105,
-0.0398674011,
-0.0059159873,
-0.0095478659,
0.0055991849,
0.0675521567,
0.0311050545,
0.0124671385,
-0.0162031651,
0.0366578698,
0.0136141153,
0.0105050039,
-0.0057085301,
0.0642208159,
0.0065330225,
-0.0266191103,
-0.0110382047,
0.0321959108,
-0.0511756018,
-0.0448923372,
0.0447958596,
0.0610774532,
0.0139796697,
0.0355524272,
-0.0036788615,
0.0015073936,
-0.0061059198,
-0.0101872096,
-0.0107793296,
-0.0038394534,
-0.0791125521,
0.0158942286,
-0.0047826157,
-0.0195080359,
0.0076454217,
0.0229510032,
-0.032245189,
0.0431898013,
0.048209697,
-0.0252663009,
-0.0344728678,
-0.0079711312,
0.0337907672,
0.0352923721,
-0.0264766607,
-0.0269417893,
-0.0829389915,
-0.0689017922,
-0.0512144454,
0.0077144117,
0.027962368,
-0.03862492,
-0.0310670417,
0.0687683672,
0.0187697019,
0.0251025502,
-0.0569230542,
0.0382958427,
-0.0193624943,
-0.0455780253,
0.0071700574,
-6.117102155e-33,
0.0439155102,
-0.0473733582,
-0.0263007991,
0.0237372145,
0.012703049,
-0.0225286465,
-0.0107988957,
0.0069597643,
-0.0282373466,
-0.0015998597,
-0.0303450413,
-0.004492763,
-0.0107977726,
-0.0251782369,
-0.037028078,
-0.0249141622,
0.0044662822,
-0.0206305329,
-0.0355925336,
0.0503932126,
0.0563399196,
-0.006933135,
-0.0107055036,
-0.0713216513,
0.0510428138,
-0.0384203456,
-0.0454826318,
0.0105552608,
-0.0382214226,
0.0344585553,
-0.0150378961,
0.0494458005,
0.0100699682,
-0.0405358747,
0.0121161658,
0.0742190257,
0.0219282378,
-0.0412412621,
0.0422390699,
-0.016599847,
0.0019536838,
-0.0353452377,
0.0050633769,
-0.0251051709,
-0.0321512297,
0.0011909393,
-0.0016043145,
-0.0002699643,
-0.0022753635,
-0.0349302776,
-0.0609358959,
-0.0187466294,
-0.0335744694,
-0.0290946141,
-0.0109273931,
0.0290721469,
0.0073468443,
-0.0305166375,
-0.0471460558,
0.0449361168,
0.0218560696,
-0.0301928148,
0.0405191258,
-0.0356724411,
-0.0059011686,
0.0618089139,
-0.0070691654,
0.0134793557,
-0.0073886113,
0.004321761,
0.0158830993,
0.0022833946,
0.0798700005,
0.0665246099,
0.032587491,
-0.077228792,
-0.0557144806,
-0.0030384802,
0.0431559011,
0.0098158251,
0.0390724875,
-0.0222204328,
-0.0524130128,
-0.0125981886,
-0.0052360706,
-0.0299131349,
-0.0321003348,
-0.071727328,
0.0188803971,
-0.006727078,
-0.0165963192,
-0.0726693422,
-0.0114629213,
-0.0750548393,
0.0281272735,
0.0150964325,
0.0013422194,
-0.0275973771,
0.0212989151,
0.0148379495,
0.0049017677,
0.0146734687,
-0.0019360713,
-0.0513901561,
0.0270155407,
-0.0028008753,
0.0087491581,
0.0355030522,
-0.0438073911,
-0.0095943939,
-0.0206813887,
0.0418317318,
0.0252796337,
-0.0258079302,
0.0096793994,
0.0260424111,
0.0034012753,
-0.0385425501,
0.0620838217,
-0.0310978554,
-0.0810089931,
0.037623059,
-0.0284314435,
0.033955548,
-0.0242530964,
0.0101022068,
-0.0447934195,
0.0445565134,
0.0455220751,
-0.0852065831,
-0.0164551288,
-0.0309443306,
3.1e-7,
-0.0561638996,
-0.0044647981,
-0.0068673603,
0.0337438025,
0.0207743347,
0.082593292,
0.0171331931,
0.0828214437,
0.0142980115,
-0.0540764928,
-0.0271519367,
0.0007460676,
0.0464354716,
0.026956128,
-0.0671037287,
0.0413945839,
-0.0311381239,
-0.0152181759,
-0.0567619242,
0.0247503053,
0.0655200928,
0.0722676292,
0.0357830338,
-0.0332193635,
-0.0116970707,
-0.013178329,
0.0011419331,
-0.002717749,
-0.0184799079,
-0.0114411097,
0.0291993842,
0.0293141697,
-0.0015046672,
0.040346045,
-0.0204767007,
-0.032308504,
-0.0605912507,
0.0186027717,
0.0228131227,
0.0171804763,
-0.0211091619,
-0.0378623195,
0.0142631736,
-0.0808736235,
0.0652707443,
0.0004702268,
-0.017220581,
-0.0033936487,
0.0157259908,
-0.0624309741,
0.0323652141,
-0.0457942709,
-0.0221339762,
0.0035792263,
0.0199214015,
0.0266999081,
0.0592068546,
-0.0451869145,
0.0151433228,
-0.0078949044,
0.0025333385,
-0.0296575651,
0.0124320341,
0.0404588766,
0.0395029858,
-0.0158970058,
0.03130164,
2.952861095e-34,
0.0098853176,
-0.0230831411,
0.0162268262,
-0.0230873358,
0.0252584778,
0.022861477,
0.0332927667,
0.0297421683,
0.0221695844,
-0.0029270411,
-0.021540869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08204v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08204v1 | MoCoSA: Momentum Contrast for Knowledge Graph Completion with Structure-Augmented Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-08-16T08:09:10 | 2023-08-16T08:09:10 | Jiabang He, Liu Jia, Lei Wang, Xiyao Li, Xing Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge Graph Completion (KGC) aims to conduct reasoning on the facts
within knowledge graphs and automatically infer missing links. Existing methods
can mainly be categorized into structure-based or description-based. On the one
hand, structure-based methods effectively represent relational facts in
knowledge graphs using entity embeddings. However, they struggle with
semantically rich real-world entities due to limited structural information and
fail to generalize to unseen entities. On the other hand, description-based
methods leverage pre-trained language models (PLMs) to understand textual
information. They exhibit strong robustness towards unseen entities. However,
they have difficulty with larger negative sampling and often lag behind
structure-based methods. To address these issues, in this paper, we propose
Momentum Contrast for knowledge graph completion with Structure-Augmented
pre-trained language models (MoCoSA), which allows the PLM to perceive the
structural information by the adaptable structure encoder. To improve learning
efficiency, we proposed momentum hard negative and intra-relation negative
sampling. Experimental results demonstrate that our approach achieves
state-of-the-art performance in terms of mean reciprocal rank (MRR), with
improvements of 2.5% on WN18RR and 21% on OpenBG500. | [
0.0176443998,
0.0569199175,
-0.0105280681,
0.057385359,
0.0262312815,
0.0076955315,
-0.0930665135,
-0.0101006953,
0.042359978,
-0.0310298018,
-0.0045615137,
-0.0248288214,
0.0008636245,
0.0190331284,
0.0339434184,
-0.0315476917,
0.0100114793,
0.0053424137,
-0.0071743918,
-0.0326017514,
-0.0181107596,
0.0319641232,
0.0066544903,
-0.0205022227,
0.0326336473,
0.0062692813,
-0.0237870328,
0.0038377049,
0.0044084853,
-0.0420689024,
0.0098694302,
0.0372364148,
0.0269928705,
-0.044496052,
0.000002125,
-0.0230160635,
0.0223207437,
-0.0158350747,
-0.0266749188,
-0.0024093948,
-0.0013452122,
-0.0478152558,
0.0348317884,
-0.0044846213,
-0.0280987956,
-0.0653107241,
0.0137896668,
0.0506680496,
0.0012521956,
0.0454449505,
-0.0152045581,
-0.0540509671,
0.0247963127,
-0.0592327863,
0.0061129672,
-0.0316627622,
0.0443596654,
0.0214255936,
0.0163133889,
0.0221768096,
-0.0407616384,
0.0285102166,
0.0191954393,
0.0073702964,
0.0546960346,
0.0437812842,
0.0033783885,
0.0343794972,
0.0361533724,
0.1256618351,
-0.0200840551,
0.0079492247,
0.0062882262,
-0.0300282817,
-0.0226829741,
0.0188302621,
-0.0289177503,
-0.0263826959,
0.004200655,
0.020896513,
-0.0354577675,
0.0122175962,
0.0570418909,
-0.0109376619,
-0.0107723391,
0.0542516373,
0.0221280195,
-0.0151508711,
0.016345825,
0.0363898203,
-0.0284543876,
-0.0275541507,
0.0072441464,
0.0039956891,
0.0189459026,
0.0355976112,
-0.016876122,
0.0081308046,
-0.0019718052,
-0.0654534176,
-0.0389140956,
0.0094159795,
0.0096467128,
0.0606736802,
-0.0828427821,
-0.0020939361,
-0.019267885,
0.0169638861,
-0.0566334128,
-0.0435157605,
-0.0149617651,
0.0155713279,
-0.0011050883,
0.0669330731,
-0.0176579189,
-0.0241321214,
-0.0292095579,
0.0197404008,
-0.020464642,
0.037833415,
-0.0013245179,
0.0091885431,
0.0040301969,
-0.0444628373,
-0.0207510758,
0.0419317447,
-0.0135481209,
0.0111352587,
-0.0552959181,
0.0417148545,
-0.0333589576,
-0.0048889918,
0.0308935698,
-0.0347741432,
0.0123241227,
0.060090784,
0.0052809957,
-0.0153874364,
-0.0472311191,
-0.0270873904,
-0.0024342702,
-0.0498419628,
0.0095428964,
-0.0384217575,
0.0705319494,
0.0474437587,
-0.020739112,
-0.0390041433,
0.0384338535,
-0.0119423885,
-0.0659749284,
0.0537907816,
-0.0149259018,
-0.0156830419,
-0.0362750962,
0.0027555474,
0.004553597,
0.0664429888,
-0.0145497918,
0.0139200753,
0.023189798,
0.0121189468,
-0.0382661484,
0.0181636531,
0.0641860738,
0.0151086263,
0.0111306943,
0.0009771653,
0.002599421,
0.019974649,
0.065525271,
0.0243742988,
-0.0543148816,
-0.0205122903,
0.0231517591,
-0.0245224983,
0.0282425787,
0.0176108666,
0.0211223792,
-0.0184067804,
-0.004885619,
-0.0026337241,
-0.0325175412,
0.0130418129,
-0.0667328164,
0.0333329886,
0.0049116593,
0.0108491462,
-0.0358289182,
-0.0058269622,
0.0106143104,
-0.0276145134,
0.0477604903,
0.0271013323,
0.1004388556,
0.0339703411,
-0.0493616611,
0.0251011588,
0.0532466695,
-0.0080992458,
0.0483890139,
0.0493260548,
0.0235389285,
0.0438018702,
0.0591669641,
-0.019885404,
-0.0393177904,
-0.0054805628,
-0.0260454603,
0.0048155598,
0.0150625221,
-0.0299788713,
0.0044835103,
-0.0509342477,
-0.0601487383,
-0.0005873065,
-0.0023149881,
0.0216676686,
0.0419247821,
0.0335873775,
0.0689448938,
-0.0914928615,
0.0018000185,
0.0128636435,
-0.0376758724,
0.0290971976,
0.0110831624,
0.0037311751,
0.0098223407,
0.0357061662,
0.0239387657,
-0.0059664296,
0.0376158543,
-0.0434736721,
-0.0485701524,
-0.0097966827,
-0.0344614089,
-0.0820746571,
0.0491799451,
-0.0325690731,
-0.0017617164,
-0.0002551416,
-0.0374263972,
-0.0447210111,
0.0540389791,
0.0057109036,
0.0751433447,
-0.0159003995,
0.0022998368,
0.0189568847,
0.0226951744,
0.0218818616,
0.0764572248,
-0.0283309296,
0.0209254846,
0.0305622779,
-0.0291521512,
0.0007210075,
-0.006906088,
-0.0606523827,
-0.0056708208,
0.0283753201,
-0.0145751284,
0.0277309343,
-0.0348810405,
-0.05731396,
0.0104974303,
-0.0995116085,
0.0115303397,
-0.0061157444,
0.011455385,
0.0149633251,
0.0180470459,
0.0253141876,
-0.024344366,
0.0031277987,
0.0179709233,
-0.0493091382,
0.0144884,
0.0178440381,
-0.0051024333,
-0.0045966138,
-0.0215338264,
-0.0319193415,
-0.0012519332,
0.0753948465,
-0.0092196297,
-0.0384197459,
-0.0130959507,
0.028204184,
-0.0487772264,
0.0115178553,
-0.0387023315,
0.0000216807,
-0.0280702896,
-0.0276660025,
0.0429590419,
0.0202007052,
-0.0388103873,
-0.0017321069,
0.0421063676,
0.0110211112,
-0.0370806009,
-0.0140915718,
-0.0531952679,
0.0382298641,
-0.0239267386,
0.0141254328,
-0.0403741635,
0.0274631046,
0.0077917026,
-0.0295630842,
-0.0699493811,
-0.0441182815,
0.0070700552,
0.0124205062,
-0.0187790059,
0.0033482146,
0.0320217721,
-0.0371874534,
-0.0429299995,
0.0195271708,
0.0642789751,
-0.0152762588,
-0.0071716905,
0.0338413194,
0.0177231058,
-0.0219540428,
0.0722618774,
0.0410981737,
-0.0028144373,
-0.0223317705,
-0.0229130257,
-0.0263340045,
0.0124721564,
0.0414419882,
-0.0134671601,
-0.0158180166,
-0.0146204559,
0.0286719743,
0.0158086028,
0.003249798,
-0.0429191738,
-0.0145530375,
-0.0181740634,
0.0276139975,
0.0144510278,
-0.0076681827,
0.0342594534,
0.0114768539,
0.0070386478,
0.0201004595,
0.0177940857,
0.0029281834,
-0.0306790676,
0.0213218834,
0.0521075502,
-0.0179823432,
0.0328929126,
-0.0039620153,
0.0171914492,
0.0470329002,
0.0349813886,
-0.0524861179,
-0.0024014097,
0.0186499078,
0.0040268148,
-0.0268450864,
-0.025451608,
-0.0005371489,
0.0147862444,
-0.0230043959,
0.0237655994,
0.1124325767,
0.0032687769,
-0.0197906252,
-0.0020058937,
0.0186276603,
0.0116941221,
0.0343830176,
-0.0031823462,
-0.0793545693,
-0.0009460765,
-0.0119806668,
-0.0089465193,
0.0601228736,
-0.0766457766,
-0.0016762319,
-0.1129181758,
-0.0251270309,
0.0273674224,
0.0219278522,
-0.0632668734,
-0.0526747964,
0.0300095621,
-0.0176884159,
-0.0188629031,
0.0035477418,
0.0020545004,
0.0088538574,
-0.0161460247,
0.0009860405,
-0.0463692695,
0.0062540681,
-0.0691336095,
0.0407015197,
0.0031777811,
0.0238577556,
-0.0116833309,
-0.0077370945,
0.0124782436,
-0.0211580079,
-0.0234045424,
-0.0014686325,
0.0359661318,
-0.0276230201,
0.0044708983,
-0.0164691843,
0.0256736726,
-0.06661015,
-0.0281201061,
-0.0104526328,
0.1033693328,
0.0021626365,
-0.0434504636,
-0.0052987589,
-0.0248560719,
-0.0081342673,
0.0616652854,
0.0069893217,
0.0071060145,
0.0081009986,
-0.009957741,
0.0479217246,
0.0137639707,
0.0084486986,
0.0330084935,
-0.0143955722,
0.0383642651,
-0.0513210744,
-0.0691071525,
0.0614360534,
0.0220475141,
-0.0093911914,
0.0311168954,
0.0542795435,
-0.0618203506,
-0.0695620924,
-0.0085289041,
-0.0437965244,
-0.0023596522,
0.0013994811,
0.0002826496,
0.0135879554,
-0.0197607484,
-0.0191418845,
-0.0377750285,
-0.0568808988,
-0.0564593785,
-0.0533535406,
0.0381195433,
0.001167511,
0.0830347091,
-0.0610958077,
-0.0414674766,
0.0360274389,
0.0307378564,
-0.0468242504,
0.032478001,
0.0406191647,
-0.0410092101,
-0.0012064478,
0.0394221619,
-0.069931902,
-0.0089557478,
0.0317281857,
0.0842051879,
-0.0287498776,
-0.0503278635,
0.0103438823,
0.0231823958,
0.0446796194,
-0.0005176874,
-0.0043085166,
-0.063374415,
0.0232939869,
-0.0538610257,
-0.0068652709,
-0.0453289449,
-0.0256857648,
0.0390124097,
-0.0085803606,
-0.004667311,
-0.0061190012,
-0.0132910823,
0.0332098119,
-0.0191310178,
-0.0364264883,
0.0169276614,
-0.0249416232,
0.0615681,
-0.0065596038,
-0.0156569947,
0.0221214853,
0.0368664525,
0.00468578,
-0.0364618339,
0.0198185816,
0.0018148653,
-0.0217951071,
-0.046808362,
-0.0091255754,
-0.0278500803,
-0.0134340907,
-0.0598564669,
0.0185990781,
0.0591271445,
-0.0133274067,
0.0371203236,
-0.0076338327,
-0.0142526198,
-0.0166704319,
0.0436976254,
-0.023766892,
-0.0278685689,
0.0335840285,
0.0073529449,
-0.0220809672,
0.0590509027,
0.081280373,
0.0095029641,
0.0670546815,
-0.0006930197,
-0.0142394258,
-0.0107584829,
-0.0427651517,
0.0192393903,
0.059469223,
-0.0195258111,
0.0444576256,
-0.0291784201,
-0.0940922722,
0.0291523337,
-0.0469495282,
-0.0747072995,
0.0221525878,
0.0093910648,
0.0149964765,
0.0001095297,
-0.0326389559,
-0.0298394673,
0.0201332606,
-0.0061152368,
-0.0081963744,
0.00812071,
-6.756222107e-33,
-0.0360761955,
-0.0366723202,
-0.0167716015,
-0.0380314142,
-0.0324295014,
0.0155215692,
-0.0141370893,
-0.0101853739,
-0.029335307,
0.0433655344,
0.0099582169,
0.0118316971,
-0.02512661,
0.0491962694,
-0.0145791741,
-0.0118719898,
0.0440273322,
0.0350934565,
0.041954875,
0.014732983,
0.0165195018,
0.0488091186,
0.0780132338,
-0.0611599982,
0.0212900732,
-0.0416997746,
0.0206829607,
-0.0003965751,
0.0550009981,
0.0248722453,
-0.0218904875,
0.0536570475,
0.0164650809,
-0.0219336115,
-0.0155221988,
-0.0386963598,
-0.1276407093,
-0.0629318058,
0.0212257076,
0.0003380654,
-0.0125860255,
0.0092797447,
0.0542786196,
0.000857192,
0.0822733417,
-0.0505099408,
0.0276763514,
-0.029218873,
-0.0572163798,
-0.0496453457,
-0.0279755443,
0.0341165289,
0.0121788764,
0.0272307415,
0.0265152268,
-0.0220807809,
0.0196047239,
-0.0158450045,
-0.0793378949,
-0.0197137855,
-0.0259802174,
0.0020457255,
0.005372663,
0.0145711508,
0.0316512808,
0.0394065008,
-0.0259606317,
-0.0010566801,
-0.0282617509,
0.0427560061,
-0.0027081894,
0.0328061804,
-0.0116289929,
0.0505795255,
-0.017633386,
-0.0018678522,
-0.0952114686,
0.0084849447,
-0.0061802808,
0.0324151926,
-0.0175880436,
0.0299202073,
-0.044150684,
-0.0544197001,
-0.067618832,
-0.0469293818,
-0.016084142,
-0.0627301186,
-0.0089405132,
0.0160588883,
-0.0210072845,
0.0081182243,
-0.0063562649,
-0.071162425,
-0.04432391,
0.0691585988,
-0.0098835155,
0.006588723,
0.0068734265,
0.0415572226,
-0.0577380583,
-0.0205950383,
0.043968536,
-0.0518260822,
-0.0091905538,
-0.0013621623,
0.0306274239,
0.0100327441,
-0.0204577558,
-0.022195816,
-0.0347758308,
-0.0230866242,
0.0115454998,
-0.0054098535,
0.0484141596,
0.0621099807,
-0.0193314049,
0.0796374083,
0.056870278,
0.0500205234,
-0.0140932575,
0.0283192471,
0.0503233485,
0.024959527,
-0.0193342809,
-0.0084234755,
-0.0239875559,
-0.0026955812,
0.0529177636,
-0.0726501271,
-0.0214975495,
-0.0054064789,
2.866e-7,
0.0550704077,
-0.004490932,
0.0284736231,
0.0114826877,
-0.0064299805,
0.0232426375,
0.0236529652,
0.0310921725,
0.0160394311,
-0.0111285271,
0.0520818308,
0.0202966426,
-0.02181058,
0.0198225789,
-0.073932603,
0.0317196809,
-0.0500068218,
-0.0467216782,
-0.0121233929,
-0.0338032246,
0.0359139182,
0.0717308372,
0.066639699,
0.0313974246,
-0.0146944476,
-0.0376147032,
0.1021076366,
-0.0130360713,
-0.0291975886,
0.0157965682,
0.0145950327,
0.0339785628,
-0.0223183911,
0.0410818495,
-0.0216815118,
0.0391998962,
0.0466526635,
0.0334355868,
0.0030275628,
0.0071326336,
-0.0107099377,
-0.0216264836,
0.0199775808,
-0.0102195237,
0.1213362366,
-0.0813425183,
0.0058330484,
0.0315298364,
-0.0797696263,
0.0099252407,
-0.0044459454,
0.0131574022,
0.0055868416,
0.006538331,
0.0358188003,
0.0217178874,
-0.0176761877,
-0.086318396,
0.018569747,
0.0382339135,
-0.00842073,
-0.0271479804,
0.01558745,
-0.0544723719,
0.0343647413,
-0.0424033441,
0.0394427627,
2.645538887e-34,
0.0198269226,
0.0105708521,
-0.0228853226,
0.0070794257,
0.0405666493,
-0.0526388362,
-0.0268805493,
0.0022133458,
0.0442984588,
-0.0955228731,
-0.0078506386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.11001v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.11001v1 | Leveraging Explainable AI to Analyze Researchers' Aspect-Based Sentiment about ChatGPT | 2023-08-16T07:44:06 | 2023-08-16T07:44:06 | Shilpa Lakhanpal, Ajay Gupta, Rajeev Agrawal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The groundbreaking invention of ChatGPT has triggered enormous discussion
among users across all fields and domains. Among celebration around its various
advantages, questions have been raised with regards to its correctness and
ethics of its use. Efforts are already underway towards capturing user
sentiments around it. But it begs the question as to how the research community
is analyzing ChatGPT with regards to various aspects of its usage. It is this
sentiment of the researchers that we analyze in our work. Since Aspect-Based
Sentiment Analysis has usually only been applied on a few datasets, it gives
limited success and that too only on short text data. We propose a methodology
that uses Explainable AI to facilitate such analysis on research data. Our
technique presents valuable insights into extending the state of the art of
Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis on newer datasets, where such analysis is not
hampered by the length of the text data. | [
0.0481598228,
0.0726319477,
-0.0342310518,
0.0319807343,
-0.0282505564,
0.0237908214,
0.0340874828,
-0.0030300983,
0.012306856,
-0.002700534,
-0.0179857817,
0.0259244945,
-0.0132388473,
0.0776002631,
-0.0187933706,
-0.0202852655,
-0.0177029558,
0.0540102944,
0.0404773578,
0.0420346484,
0.0598394312,
0.0308150761,
-0.0107038701,
0.0442203246,
0.0149054769,
-0.0293733645,
-0.0035488617,
-0.0306129623,
0.0138519453,
-0.0158051532,
0.0004114551,
0.0025706852,
-0.0046763248,
0.0240927637,
0.0000019436,
-0.0205892753,
-0.0313539989,
0.01797962,
0.006927785,
0.0021501358,
0.0914027244,
0.0356284827,
0.0172469448,
0.0100369351,
-0.0477014333,
0.0261761788,
0.0586621165,
0.0560449027,
0.0469527468,
0.0455741212,
-0.0417991132,
-0.0181786083,
-0.0263946354,
0.0189683195,
0.0086228279,
-0.0091141295,
-0.017874524,
-0.0124774259,
-0.0007451242,
0.0529362448,
0.0074087149,
0.0086583821,
0.0019703491,
-0.0519135147,
0.0169396754,
-0.0090126228,
0.000026392,
-0.0146230999,
0.0321666226,
0.0566425249,
0.0508108325,
-0.0242560729,
0.0313084424,
-0.0059309802,
-0.0120141013,
0.0209920369,
-0.027838042,
-0.0253936891,
0.0078003043,
0.0155206537,
0.0179495718,
0.0629342571,
0.0263206679,
0.0280692447,
-0.0049711587,
0.0223699491,
-0.0326285623,
-0.0169453789,
-0.0113440324,
0.0258646179,
0.0220837891,
0.0000935193,
0.0206259973,
0.0000071728,
-0.0117672049,
0.0479561873,
0.0383892506,
0.0227662362,
0.0039350335,
-0.0261322632,
-0.0315165259,
0.0273053441,
-0.0070293047,
0.0312045515,
0.0389941894,
0.0028162589,
0.0283653047,
-0.0271079913,
0.0094083305,
-0.0001294512,
-0.0918128788,
0.0009760205,
0.014277772,
0.0016363289,
-0.0099089397,
0.0122330338,
-0.0285390057,
0.0132031562,
-0.0144061707,
-0.0308945719,
0.0363286473,
0.0101334043,
-0.0152126281,
0.0091142189,
-0.034341298,
0.0240275357,
-0.0774975196,
0.0298077296,
-0.0019138349,
-0.032772664,
0.0207406543,
0.0332530029,
0.0234234631,
-0.0113152778,
-0.0186863877,
0.0201551318,
0.0687718019,
-0.0144641036,
-0.0016484699,
-0.053792879,
-0.0232871752,
-0.0471182615,
-0.0028556867,
-0.0236209966,
0.0387101136,
0.019057706,
-0.0195845366,
-0.0132853417,
-0.0121524278,
0.0086162472,
-0.0199178196,
0.0743743032,
-0.0615838654,
-0.0109280758,
-0.0254132226,
0.0482537895,
0.0111095998,
0.0336572193,
0.0059167179,
0.0278394576,
0.0572730266,
-0.0217112638,
0.0137413098,
-0.0250036437,
0.0244535599,
-0.002883232,
0.0281272102,
-0.0049789199,
-0.0980260819,
-0.022581026,
-0.0273159835,
0.0353808701,
-0.0003851603,
-0.006439602,
0.0154888881,
0.0681631863,
0.024306329,
0.0952744856,
0.0204558335,
0.0157944672,
-0.0085276477,
0.0070722047,
0.0262334794,
0.0388150923,
-0.0099681159,
-0.0225170702,
0.0112175141,
0.0053536003,
-0.0208561867,
-0.0997198746,
0.0251801107,
-0.0069547356,
0.0381113999,
0.0089456961,
0.0459952392,
-0.0037803331,
-0.0111577008,
-0.0373184048,
0.0603811629,
-0.0790108889,
-0.0171482544,
-0.0703837425,
0.046356,
0.0690784901,
0.0285774674,
-0.023242455,
-0.0209219977,
-0.0084788678,
-0.0086571025,
0.020037353,
0.0211693738,
0.0112052271,
-0.0085839499,
-0.0354433581,
0.0087377299,
-0.00348874,
0.0002320748,
-0.0110318512,
-0.0079566222,
0.0184072219,
-0.0279514343,
-0.0328572541,
-0.0022093949,
-0.0211315211,
-0.0263632275,
0.0105909426,
0.0005634206,
0.0047075986,
0.0525814295,
0.0550768264,
0.0197292846,
0.0088296626,
0.0211090408,
-0.0071972837,
-0.0373389535,
0.0624089018,
0.0016025841,
-0.0245488435,
-0.0083820876,
-0.0608172491,
-0.0003716795,
-0.0010286133,
-0.0220624171,
-0.0161784403,
0.0225531925,
-0.0299314689,
0.034327969,
-0.0122242849,
-0.0268923342,
-0.0252409317,
0.0023715782,
-0.0121599967,
0.0307955723,
-0.0147823077,
0.0153887104,
-0.0281113237,
-0.031112114,
0.030349141,
0.0120760296,
-0.0259583425,
-0.0001257231,
-0.0001012206,
-0.0023905463,
0.035913188,
-0.022162484,
-0.0386076048,
-0.0070960396,
-0.1241755113,
-0.0263857096,
0.009930552,
0.0190383736,
0.0370130278,
0.02070654,
0.0344833359,
0.0180817544,
-0.066888079,
-0.0069818026,
-0.0180504248,
0.0044199447,
0.0647446215,
0.0094974954,
0.0207144208,
-0.070674628,
-0.0072970814,
-0.0478542373,
0.041498933,
0.0490584671,
-0.0209363643,
-0.0421762317,
0.0325718299,
-0.0591389313,
-0.0400488079,
-0.0434858911,
-0.0606363602,
0.0161051601,
0.0094389543,
-0.0299937688,
0.0090779215,
0.0154989325,
0.0803857222,
-0.0105589358,
0.0411281213,
-0.0303249378,
-0.0194717497,
-0.0436616577,
0.0089337425,
0.0180921406,
-0.0629830733,
0.0296110157,
0.0479886532,
-0.0138777858,
0.0248641651,
-0.0745305717,
0.0526476763,
-0.0333300829,
-0.0171754938,
-0.0085243154,
-0.0039777532,
0.0123331482,
0.0406169593,
0.021279119,
-0.019812014,
0.0723626688,
0.0051467596,
-0.0093911812,
-0.0584402829,
-0.02748169,
-0.048722472,
0.0706131011,
-0.0434138514,
0.013619585,
0.0270857438,
0.0146586075,
0.0064481208,
-0.0396007113,
-0.0078377603,
-0.0173409209,
0.0285405423,
-0.0147965821,
0.0058390298,
0.0579321161,
-0.0238828957,
0.0231967065,
-0.0673014373,
-0.0347120911,
-0.0109846359,
0.0595941804,
-0.0461033434,
0.0136682075,
0.0210292544,
-0.003207979,
-0.0526992381,
-0.0042775758,
-0.0518599674,
0.0158094838,
0.0025693025,
0.0646343306,
-0.0182651151,
0.020243872,
0.022990305,
0.017344702,
0.052698981,
-0.035248179,
-0.0284036826,
-0.040403042,
-0.0335651822,
-0.0379528366,
-0.0122031625,
-0.0189131871,
-0.049203027,
0.0941541195,
-0.0328102931,
-0.0156339016,
0.0942078009,
0.0258981902,
-0.0559031591,
0.0034610231,
-0.0076097017,
0.0184169468,
-0.0243437961,
0.0167257804,
-0.0393182896,
-0.0174710248,
-0.0492953248,
0.0445593819,
-0.0316160284,
-0.0316508859,
-0.0101887686,
-0.0718061775,
0.0279305335,
-0.023946112,
-0.0462686308,
-0.0347804204,
-0.0727792755,
-0.013394421,
-0.0442272499,
0.0085346913,
-0.0388819128,
0.0142257689,
0.0252821501,
0.0130872056,
-0.0581995323,
-0.0042342525,
0.0655077919,
0.0035513225,
0.0691079199,
0.0410847403,
0.099718608,
0.0159595329,
-0.0315303765,
-0.0357157812,
-0.0097167613,
0.0185828377,
0.0046198368,
0.0953342915,
0.0046030036,
-0.0122330217,
-0.0644481704,
0.0354528725,
-0.0594904423,
-0.0051584272,
0.0031405909,
0.0589944161,
-0.025918765,
-0.0112480354,
-0.0378919058,
0.0416895002,
0.0458017923,
0.0853299424,
0.0409794226,
-0.049239397,
-0.0138361808,
-0.0243916437,
0.0075412393,
-0.0125274435,
-0.0670852065,
-0.0742387474,
0.0144013017,
-0.0312304161,
-0.0690186322,
-0.0581712611,
-0.0339550003,
0.0382155478,
-0.0287418235,
-0.0002670259,
0.012485967,
0.0149066243,
-0.0227912739,
0.019705141,
0.0261036884,
0.0113943266,
0.0155373309,
-0.0240196567,
0.0500555672,
-0.0241035391,
-0.0036500921,
-0.0351406224,
-0.0009169506,
-0.0127544627,
-0.0240717586,
0.0277235359,
0.0307179857,
0.0138719277,
-0.0196109079,
-0.0284604114,
-0.0173518155,
0.0634546503,
-0.03942056,
-0.0321431309,
0.0426501743,
0.0739933252,
0.0282076262,
0.0050794897,
-0.0071857641,
-0.0034633246,
-0.023062123,
-0.0441212393,
-0.0746565759,
-0.0167981368,
0.0063161459,
-0.0064295582,
0.0394015349,
0.0347468033,
-0.0144444071,
-0.0283488482,
-0.0556367226,
-0.0319506153,
0.0036721665,
-0.0390481204,
-0.0060416702,
-0.0206099413,
-0.0157258492,
-0.0553107969,
-0.0099376077,
-0.0788459927,
-0.0307959821,
-0.0341730975,
0.0754957348,
-0.0104266591,
0.0211436041,
-0.0282016452,
0.0281607658,
-0.0170343369,
-0.0072998353,
0.0076933461,
0.0350593217,
-0.0045297379,
0.0937689096,
0.0042104651,
0.0162357315,
0.0168557558,
0.0498398244,
-0.0586709045,
-0.0465547964,
0.035835851,
-0.014592072,
-0.0380124263,
-0.030815715,
0.0683752596,
-0.0037998657,
0.0005390063,
0.0028018069,
0.0654426888,
-0.0012074363,
-0.0188503973,
-0.0007102013,
-0.0021176699,
-0.0397213586,
-0.0439989455,
0.0674716458,
-0.0683098435,
0.0265410878,
0.0367466509,
-0.0516406447,
-0.022054024,
-0.0173607506,
0.0115242228,
0.0131095098,
0.0157279354,
-0.0066302931,
-0.0631311759,
-0.0535336696,
-0.0315080136,
-0.052763585,
0.009729824,
-0.0285126399,
0.0084615769,
0.0428410098,
-0.0063983873,
0.0390230455,
-0.0783015564,
0.003935989,
-0.055967804,
-0.0209925864,
-0.0108988285,
-5.697493651e-33,
0.0276241563,
-0.0631074384,
-0.0332515016,
0.0071423468,
-0.0113021396,
0.0157197043,
-0.0598951653,
0.0106018335,
-0.0063120392,
0.0422795564,
-0.0096390359,
0.036355529,
-0.0047018542,
0.0216374211,
-0.0013271903,
-0.0279969778,
0.035363216,
0.0309611764,
0.0170524642,
0.100439325,
0.061034631,
0.0035917221,
0.0112113515,
-0.1227378994,
0.0844093114,
0.0099176047,
-0.0251886919,
0.0034786453,
0.0113988835,
0.083101742,
-0.0176208578,
0.0271626189,
0.0377668105,
-0.0202548392,
0.0074632955,
0.0139053958,
-0.0188802462,
-0.035613291,
0.0102641974,
-0.0071628033,
-0.0323815234,
-0.0259933975,
0.0111327106,
-0.0239160284,
-0.0029875822,
-0.0059749605,
0.05853137,
-0.0032041729,
0.0126977451,
-0.0491038747,
-0.0310993865,
0.0273641497,
-0.0491682999,
-0.0141213918,
0.0063944729,
0.0274587795,
0.0109683387,
0.03152778,
-0.0284202043,
0.0178692322,
-0.0092589119,
-0.0193175562,
0.0254264288,
-0.0447376184,
0.0140124597,
0.0589581393,
0.0215645973,
0.0371709056,
-0.0349841602,
-0.0038121995,
-0.0127001274,
0.0309459362,
0.0643832758,
0.0339186564,
-0.0068837265,
-0.0460722558,
-0.0486567095,
0.0183592141,
0.0238924474,
-0.0224058498,
0.0586879849,
0.023062529,
-0.0958804786,
-0.0254665818,
0.0302816387,
-0.0300848633,
-0.0341111608,
-0.0586090013,
-0.0184545554,
-0.0544691049,
-0.0532801151,
-0.0059152269,
-0.0122102173,
-0.0605592914,
0.0067426772,
0.0349266529,
-0.040197283,
-0.0000115621,
0.0246681571,
-0.003499436,
-0.0369479358,
0.0316080302,
-0.0269565582,
0.0358334035,
0.0312465504,
-0.0105445459,
0.0592596568,
0.0102903796,
-0.0320538618,
-0.0478653423,
-0.0499275625,
-0.0039917124,
-0.0266448092,
-0.0088728564,
-0.0094969608,
0.0339006856,
-0.0251399595,
0.06853728,
0.0442958139,
0.0522043891,
-0.011710288,
-0.0055211256,
-0.0282160584,
-0.0305267908,
-0.0321785249,
-0.0627943426,
0.0040567107,
0.0032713469,
0.0222851653,
-0.0446951129,
-0.0234603081,
-0.0439886972,
2.572e-7,
0.061661493,
0.0506040826,
-0.0178283229,
-0.0088714659,
0.0500414409,
0.0531572662,
0.0451647043,
0.001700511,
0.011497952,
0.0045810663,
0.0674467981,
0.0166076012,
0.0312588252,
0.0296760891,
-0.0392193198,
-0.0172338597,
-0.0192448366,
-0.0503727868,
-0.0428905375,
0.054377459,
0.1027659327,
0.0543417633,
0.0346840769,
0.0129558537,
0.0111310389,
0.0346962102,
0.0137795173,
-0.0693523586,
-0.0037605674,
0.0331559181,
0.0073820697,
0.0064257449,
0.00299284,
-0.0386878364,
-0.0287133958,
-0.0230182,
-0.0059678759,
0.0437301584,
0.0115338396,
-0.0389946438,
0.0223109275,
-0.0032528276,
0.0393774472,
-0.0574927777,
0.0481853746,
-0.0564746186,
-0.0969394371,
-0.0630658641,
0.0172930304,
0.0019898752,
-0.0049523842,
0.0043729581,
-0.0194165446,
0.0451137498,
-0.0397218242,
-0.0310248248,
-0.0270197596,
-0.060748037,
0.0157555342,
0.0073231133,
-0.0228926986,
-0.040666379,
-0.0253515616,
0.0371829569,
0.0489118248,
-0.0349308662,
0.0387265496,
1.893128027e-34,
0.0336827002,
0.0184594076,
-0.0070063914,
0.012151313,
0.0843262151,
0.0306266602,
0.0321184583,
-0.0021399274,
0.0732451901,
0.0052373824,
-0.0015976686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08181v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08181v1 | ChinaTelecom System Description to VoxCeleb Speaker Recognition Challenge 2023 | 2023-08-16T07:21:01 | 2023-08-16T07:21:01 | Mengjie Du, Xiang Fang, Jie Li | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | This technical report describes ChinaTelecom system for Track 1 (closed) of
the VoxCeleb2023 Speaker Recognition Challenge (VoxSRC 2023). Our system
consists of several ResNet variants trained only on VoxCeleb2, which were fused
for better performance later. Score calibration was also applied for each
variant and the fused system. The final submission achieved minDCF of 0.1066
and EER of 1.980%. | [
-0.0040035532,
0.0482075252,
0.0089734122,
0.0480506904,
0.0052601919,
0.0000601956,
0.0039988714,
-0.0215987228,
-0.0683775097,
0.0452159606,
-0.0283638425,
-0.0364487767,
0.065244697,
-0.0111844996,
-0.0117295124,
-0.0488435812,
0.031979885,
0.0556405559,
-0.0271718428,
-0.0078685237,
0.0035322504,
0.0001660977,
-0.029777633,
0.0353055634,
-0.026593022,
0.0118927434,
-0.0156336911,
0.0503721945,
0.0411503315,
-0.0085250577,
0.0027390928,
0.022484675,
0.0226898361,
0.0738528296,
0.0000019161,
-0.004039424,
-0.0235951133,
0.0170168299,
-0.0648428723,
-0.0098950742,
0.0176654756,
0.0870529711,
-0.069758594,
0.0215271451,
-0.0128664039,
-0.0202886723,
0.0435782708,
0.0259764418,
0.0399327241,
0.0538392253,
0.0163720809,
0.0007595623,
0.0490163565,
0.0004806525,
0.065994367,
-0.0527515188,
-0.0001800379,
-0.001957516,
0.0136929983,
-0.04551851,
0.0373127013,
0.0103428764,
0.016576454,
0.0263411924,
-0.0262918118,
0.0013000016,
-0.0205412321,
-0.0262980517,
0.0273333453,
0.053128086,
0.055319,
0.0181527715,
-0.0065687075,
0.0448530354,
-0.0486549735,
-0.006108108,
-0.0077710361,
-0.026021786,
0.0060367608,
-0.0355682783,
-0.0514604487,
0.0063198595,
-0.0045183375,
0.0024818052,
-0.0146971056,
-0.0009582529,
-0.0124623012,
-0.0019150472,
0.0221528858,
-0.0512694567,
0.0336435139,
0.0052472581,
-0.0227055177,
-0.0084418841,
-0.0092189424,
-0.0351314396,
0.0232519638,
-0.0484967269,
-0.0466230102,
-0.0083377389,
-0.0327788964,
0.0533058494,
0.0012756375,
-0.0049516968,
-0.0698153451,
0.0527867451,
-0.0213308558,
0.0482596792,
-0.0194101278,
-0.0332878605,
-0.0438820198,
0.0286295246,
-0.0586767457,
-0.0181105901,
0.0261140373,
-0.0076303417,
-0.0818499103,
-0.0368342549,
-0.0135653699,
0.0226521939,
0.0103931203,
0.0398094915,
-0.0248287823,
0.0148075791,
-0.0316750444,
0.024145741,
-0.0167848654,
-0.0201377515,
-0.0254856478,
-0.0646195486,
-0.0289131887,
0.0084393378,
-0.0005900152,
0.0022424827,
0.0053714127,
-0.0006306104,
-0.0129690003,
-0.0225506388,
-0.0137710078,
0.0065609273,
-0.0253395308,
-0.0736490414,
0.037208844,
-0.0412245579,
0.0028565635,
-0.00168089,
0.0129967164,
0.0066089276,
0.0031682672,
-0.0449869111,
0.0362771638,
0.0465490445,
-0.0086481189,
0.0034045056,
0.0372295678,
0.0026819583,
0.0063238577,
0.025244575,
0.0147339934,
-0.008770898,
-0.0233479999,
0.0083439378,
-0.013607474,
0.0278113447,
-0.0178340487,
-0.0547061265,
-0.0858279914,
-0.0037562596,
0.0300137233,
0.0192099046,
-0.0110903345,
-0.031504143,
-0.0093750581,
-0.0149667552,
-0.0147723984,
0.0452036113,
-0.0207575504,
-0.0395566784,
-0.0222123098,
-0.0427040607,
0.0529344454,
-0.0311294645,
-0.0174561273,
0.0181379039,
0.0205782037,
-0.0284770746,
0.0094725275,
0.04754081,
-0.0395077132,
0.005335398,
-0.0005143512,
-0.0249055102,
-0.008127477,
0.0180478115,
-0.00180466,
-0.046021536,
0.024484599,
-0.0061630551,
0.0237844791,
-0.0332705565,
-0.0281911176,
-0.0674081147,
0.0068860762,
0.0056656688,
0.0017768078,
-0.0427535065,
0.0102437567,
-0.0128150312,
-0.0255457666,
0.0069409925,
0.0416686572,
0.0080940025,
0.0372481868,
-0.027130086,
-0.0656948015,
0.0824263021,
-0.0166878682,
0.0403367542,
0.0040156511,
0.0040604714,
0.0568525791,
-0.0614199229,
0.0262923352,
-0.0189085864,
0.0157288425,
0.0229713414,
-0.0014705005,
0.0208123736,
0.0598745793,
0.040584065,
-0.0270476658,
-0.0256482549,
0.0011414136,
0.0058308179,
0.0277587958,
0.0125879599,
-0.026293451,
-0.052182097,
0.048700463,
-0.0042642616,
0.0030006729,
0.1084400788,
0.002738754,
-0.0752614588,
0.0373807363,
-0.0231615771,
0.0181193519,
-0.0432887338,
0.0149093028,
-0.0242248327,
0.03606157,
0.0190996565,
0.0093741314,
0.0236091092,
0.0198864974,
0.0351732671,
-0.0336174481,
0.0263155941,
-0.0908177197,
-0.0266776215,
-0.0148695251,
-0.0060269684,
0.0025730582,
-0.0192531087,
0.0105068684,
0.0003970981,
-0.007933435,
0.0208154172,
0.006069758,
-0.0303734411,
0.0043576136,
0.0131539432,
-0.0068964669,
-0.0333257876,
-0.0463146977,
-0.0031474018,
0.0367929414,
0.0032846886,
-0.0334590524,
-0.0270574708,
-0.0303650293,
-0.0571325868,
0.0064708339,
-0.0369447581,
-0.0139846252,
0.0352436453,
-0.0394070335,
-0.0478269458,
0.0088912109,
-0.0343879536,
-0.0175652597,
0.0055251452,
-0.0160342306,
-0.0309545211,
-0.0281397011,
0.019512767,
-0.0006989582,
0.0414009914,
0.0156061035,
-0.0126393158,
-0.0751614645,
0.0342731625,
-0.0020857463,
0.0268655587,
0.0099445786,
0.0111225666,
0.004549284,
-0.0231850166,
-0.0600687787,
-0.0041843117,
-0.0345173515,
0.0346392244,
0.039775297,
0.0276465137,
-0.0070809247,
-0.0427078716,
-0.0044439253,
0.0218979847,
-0.0475377403,
-0.0065147597,
-0.0235075541,
-0.0262163468,
0.0073870807,
-0.0739272311,
-0.0262485705,
-0.070447281,
-0.0521963201,
0.0054415297,
-0.0270311255,
0.0378961377,
0.0615777783,
0.0451765545,
-0.0270408168,
-0.0427335054,
-0.0571821108,
-0.0094797947,
-0.0464597829,
-0.0153099373,
0.0720839277,
0.0157285519,
-0.0753187686,
-0.0155992173,
-0.0394684076,
0.0199163668,
-0.0231346637,
0.0811298788,
0.0277577434,
-0.0329240263,
-0.0099933408,
0.0632987097,
0.0839118212,
0.0016035769,
-0.0364173278,
0.0343259163,
0.0061674598,
0.0814862475,
-0.0129045751,
0.0886675566,
0.0171534475,
0.0164032411,
0.0159343909,
-0.0247437228,
0.0593535937,
0.0610793568,
-0.03352933,
-0.015146534,
0.0062773093,
0.0069381734,
-0.0012649432,
0.0169057623,
0.1129067838,
-0.0317443796,
0.0255891252,
0.0455424301,
0.015905289,
-0.0251697395,
-0.0604142621,
0.0165383127,
0.0114809405,
0.0201937575,
0.03397597,
-0.0231010746,
-0.0140835922,
0.0798394233,
0.0139971022,
-0.0060166195,
0.0029126208,
-0.0354659408,
-0.0714660361,
0.0498570539,
0.0191676766,
-0.0789954439,
-0.0257988032,
-0.0260199383,
-0.0528180972,
-0.0104459403,
0.0640718341,
0.0369602591,
-0.0000580875,
-0.0393071696,
0.0495764054,
-0.0395058244,
-0.0003434174,
0.014083636,
-0.0412700772,
0.0752510428,
0.0245795157,
0.0125519428,
-0.0055466946,
-0.0137217883,
-0.0331466869,
-0.03074665,
0.0184017308,
-0.0164901577,
0.0022628489,
0.0461274348,
-0.0216804016,
-0.0041411067,
-0.0005325311,
0.0229785573,
-0.0109426919,
0.0038958697,
0.0239508338,
0.0069071432,
0.0260252729,
-0.0462228768,
0.0770583823,
-0.0219761413,
0.0421981514,
0.0563415438,
0.0207665861,
-0.0347951315,
0.0298839305,
0.0622862168,
-0.0804012567,
0.0061292206,
0.023865724,
0.0138741098,
-0.0291492268,
-0.0058344943,
0.0015864219,
-0.0476577729,
0.0300273448,
0.0058694775,
-0.0260197558,
-0.0624620132,
0.0687874034,
-0.0540955588,
0.0379354879,
-0.0043763313,
0.0587392375,
-0.0811894834,
0.0007878848,
0.0316840187,
-0.0501311682,
-0.0169931166,
0.0011789649,
0.0040727095,
0.006259474,
-0.0002968766,
-0.0288090687,
0.0179142989,
0.0266981181,
-0.0313181318,
-0.0189258307,
0.0962009877,
-0.0214997791,
-0.0269204974,
0.0114707965,
0.0454378761,
-0.014205846,
-0.0713384748,
0.009810199,
-0.0008443376,
0.0801305026,
0.0541396402,
-0.0246134736,
-0.0049242522,
-0.0263850875,
0.0012588812,
0.027207816,
0.0370830856,
-0.0089964056,
0.0169397779,
-0.0497532524,
0.0440366603,
0.0146319214,
0.0419600233,
0.0035541165,
-0.0318483785,
-0.0030402855,
0.0417282879,
0.0300959256,
0.0579861589,
0.0257262122,
-0.0048760823,
0.0590737835,
0.0360451192,
0.0075330343,
0.0332796574,
-0.0374806374,
0.0070611141,
-0.0202237479,
0.0378661156,
0.0279769432,
0.0181312505,
-0.0336540565,
0.0629067048,
-0.0330697559,
-0.0299733877,
0.0266415682,
0.0489106365,
-0.0158583838,
-0.0301163252,
-0.0108348252,
-0.0004943077,
0.0245147347,
0.0402552187,
-0.0012707517,
0.0104038138,
0.0037297083,
-0.0267724358,
-0.0197934862,
-0.045964364,
0.0334659144,
0.006617825,
0.0076534362,
-0.0280182417,
0.0093135517,
0.0305572078,
0.0542192981,
-0.0167857315,
-0.0252904911,
0.0162430909,
-0.0100440225,
-0.019573193,
0.0266859382,
-0.0162902791,
-0.0487662554,
-0.0566525199,
0.0017979773,
-0.048405502,
0.0565751418,
0.0190938283,
-0.0084312055,
0.0555410795,
-0.0092399241,
-0.0329766683,
-0.0304621682,
-0.0120557044,
0.030780239,
-0.0420335308,
-0.0223278273,
0.0006895983,
0.0713759512,
-6.246884078e-33,
-0.0235833507,
0.0563861243,
-0.0157956593,
-0.0272956062,
-0.0260877367,
0.0168710612,
-0.0120283263,
0.0336634703,
-0.0460233353,
-0.060923662,
-0.0229663551,
-0.0062879734,
0.0403657742,
0.0299968459,
-0.0697765127,
-0.0172575396,
0.0993933752,
-0.0026079244,
0.0150145954,
0.0097078541,
0.0545119122,
0.0320385434,
0.0580528527,
-0.0825572386,
-0.0686941966,
0.0371514522,
-0.0193095449,
0.0214436986,
-0.0033548782,
0.0211228449,
0.0069508883,
-0.0016708665,
-0.0043892283,
-0.074228406,
0.0122887064,
0.0514340326,
-0.0879027769,
0.0099533144,
-0.0825613439,
0.0717755407,
0.0097813746,
0.010787365,
0.0262918249,
-0.0051768678,
-0.0402674526,
0.0252831932,
0.0453472137,
-0.0125415772,
-0.0034965724,
0.0139392046,
0.033249516,
0.0286531486,
0.0053150407,
-0.0207443517,
0.017873466,
0.009712996,
0.0138303228,
0.0075795734,
-0.0906013623,
0.0155554423,
-0.0357492752,
0.0515938625,
0.0129571278,
0.0885884985,
0.0107635176,
0.0457018279,
0.1128564328,
-0.088763766,
0.0140285501,
-0.0506561063,
0.0181019213,
0.0409966558,
0.0450787656,
0.0571587123,
0.0302099045,
-0.0729033798,
-0.0822769925,
0.0658055022,
0.0595336296,
-0.017838357,
-0.0402098112,
-0.0286712591,
-0.0112384222,
0.0212720279,
0.00481071,
-0.0455690809,
-0.0337336771,
-0.0070717195,
0.0216203257,
-0.0044485289,
-0.0155543527,
-0.0171667244,
0.0621088892,
-0.0475552306,
0.0261080191,
-0.0074827089,
0.0265010595,
-0.0018437845,
0.000747859,
-0.0344425663,
-0.0157193206,
-0.0565692969,
0.0343981348,
0.0240144357,
0.0007164173,
-0.0263931956,
0.0453230999,
0.0773874074,
-0.0434321016,
-0.0216398649,
0.0145493262,
0.0059451605,
-0.0105237849,
0.0558941327,
0.0202340912,
-0.0166172776,
0.0421569012,
-0.0018534397,
0.0261394307,
0.0393456221,
-0.0028320383,
-0.0729116425,
0.0486019403,
0.0216961913,
-0.0147231324,
0.0368369743,
-0.0184964128,
0.0123541225,
0.0219383519,
-0.041618146,
0.008521107,
0.0228264816,
2.863e-7,
-0.0209751073,
-0.0503897704,
0.0385996364,
-0.0776764974,
0.0091850553,
0.0084393267,
-0.0394099429,
0.0178648699,
-0.0078851432,
-0.0315331444,
0.0085109966,
-0.021898374,
0.0374542065,
0.0355888642,
-0.1012759358,
-0.0317332745,
-0.0230879597,
0.0159065817,
-0.0223876834,
0.0839407817,
0.0173642412,
0.0760454461,
0.022134494,
-0.0484918058,
0.0099263638,
-0.0100719854,
0.0084878365,
-0.0132282479,
0.0060486929,
-0.0023729452,
0.0295762401,
0.0265618414,
0.0076937075,
0.0018666227,
-0.0074363761,
0.0753966123,
0.0312053245,
0.0097789839,
-0.0201321281,
-0.0705507994,
-0.0361440144,
0.0485786609,
-0.0091307051,
0.0320346095,
0.0516227633,
0.0099838302,
-0.0529192612,
-0.0332956202,
-0.0089296838,
-0.0028064679,
0.0602248982,
-0.0073714997,
-0.0106593361,
0.020773042,
-0.0057318802,
-0.0154506024,
-0.0458655171,
-0.0598959737,
0.0015695293,
0.004560627,
-0.0597510785,
-0.0731663108,
0.0161673352,
-0.0335940868,
0.0531769283,
0.0139847863,
-0.0151219228,
1.929346454e-34,
-0.0510816127,
-0.0094936229,
-0.0056096776,
-0.0345823728,
-0.0278270766,
-0.0342576131,
0.0085945567,
-0.0216715764,
-0.040403381,
-0.002175028,
-0.0394115001
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08176v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08176v1 | RSpell: Retrieval-augmented Framework for Domain Adaptive Chinese Spelling Check | 2023-08-16T07:12:23 | 2023-08-16T07:12:23 | Siqi Song, Qi Lv, Lei Geng, Ziqiang Cao, Guohong Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chinese Spelling Check (CSC) refers to the detection and correction of
spelling errors in Chinese texts. In practical application scenarios, it is
important to make CSC models have the ability to correct errors across
different domains. In this paper, we propose a retrieval-augmented spelling
check framework called RSpell, which searches corresponding domain terms and
incorporates them into CSC models. Specifically, we employ pinyin fuzzy
matching to search for terms, which are combined with the input and fed into
the CSC model. Then, we introduce an adaptive process control mechanism to
dynamically adjust the impact of external knowledge on the model. Additionally,
we develop an iterative strategy for the RSpell framework to enhance reasoning
capabilities. We conducted experiments on CSC datasets in three domains: law,
medicine, and official document writing. The results demonstrate that RSpell
achieves state-of-the-art performance in both zero-shot and fine-tuning
scenarios, demonstrating the effectiveness of the retrieval-augmented CSC
framework. Our code is available at https://github.com/47777777/Rspell. | [
0.0644010678,
-0.0133577399,
-0.0116542997,
-0.0087208031,
-0.0315191969,
0.0000247505,
-0.0317928568,
0.0542239398,
0.0449782349,
-0.057231497,
-0.0032228483,
-0.030232586,
0.019030394,
0.0031345687,
0.0033904603,
-0.0103599057,
0.0503041968,
0.03030085,
0.028852297,
0.0211959518,
0.0430736914,
0.0014339335,
-0.0042570061,
0.0558652692,
0.0066043753,
-0.0086333361,
0.020594338,
0.0136109591,
0.0186615493,
0.0021810017,
0.0502186902,
0.0347465351,
-0.0205252133,
0.0620720983,
0.0000021833,
-0.0643926114,
-0.0621329471,
0.0267135724,
0.0218122508,
0.0133714331,
0.0525299348,
0.026593646,
-0.05388451,
0.0397989824,
-0.0034271376,
0.0251743942,
0.0478019975,
0.0509267189,
0.0553428717,
0.0584629029,
-0.0163269006,
-0.0141708171,
-0.0038502405,
0.0182726774,
0.0022992513,
-0.0590785034,
0.0421435758,
-0.0264230873,
0.0450588986,
-0.0557898805,
-0.0091608157,
0.0132347364,
-0.0576972589,
-0.0368278511,
-0.0281430557,
-0.0353462063,
0.0303945355,
-0.0067221536,
0.0127237393,
0.0117908586,
0.0074294345,
-0.0391628072,
0.02001849,
0.0105771646,
0.011733884,
0.0293013509,
-0.0068548569,
-0.0126015833,
-0.0595985688,
-0.0034238582,
0.0293086488,
-0.0418599434,
0.0127864238,
0.0558755845,
-0.0027140249,
0.0639500767,
0.0080533102,
-0.0895775259,
-0.0256596059,
0.016423706,
0.0477662422,
-0.0129537154,
0.0639830008,
0.0461955331,
-0.0512610488,
-0.0145123992,
-0.0214656405,
-0.0579311773,
0.0135831935,
-0.0350198224,
-0.0098522156,
0.0331727192,
0.0302071907,
0.0110947797,
-0.0269547887,
0.05319608,
0.026889123,
0.0054408759,
-0.0202228986,
-0.0175430235,
-0.0650989413,
0.0088069811,
-0.0480532274,
0.0035318139,
0.0123397028,
-0.0063063046,
-0.0589836948,
-0.0035607049,
-0.0432581306,
0.0391159505,
0.0218334701,
-0.0347283706,
-0.0424053296,
-0.0191534646,
-0.0228078011,
0.0279012509,
0.0066305203,
0.0060860422,
0.0043746922,
0.0304636694,
0.0002944397,
-0.0360308662,
0.0323321447,
-0.0156894606,
0.0015279992,
0.0212455317,
-0.0205323119,
-0.0171764046,
-0.0289623812,
-0.0260319915,
0.011382699,
0.0018331783,
-0.0545248874,
-0.0232423861,
-0.0691234916,
-0.0329150595,
0.0275952742,
-0.0589402616,
0.0045733303,
0.0308489148,
-0.0267448612,
0.0807532445,
-0.0605494156,
0.0076878015,
0.0018213486,
0.011233327,
0.0276860092,
0.0246394128,
0.0064905691,
-0.0402412675,
0.0634978786,
0.0168917328,
0.067873992,
0.0276080295,
-0.0187125988,
-0.0220068712,
-0.0151253715,
0.0034686883,
-0.0371164344,
0.0077600256,
0.0014639051,
0.0193677936,
0.001356939,
0.0619094931,
0.0311915688,
0.0481753275,
0.0685314089,
0.008029527,
-0.0369653888,
-0.0191761162,
0.017092403,
-0.002109915,
-0.0116107492,
0.0015139953,
-0.0720226988,
0.0430983193,
-0.002385834,
0.0059282756,
-0.0272293482,
-0.0327667147,
-0.0356479287,
0.0262296684,
0.0191660319,
0.003680791,
0.0533771068,
0.0196523536,
-0.0162887182,
0.0046180538,
-0.016056085,
-0.0706915185,
-0.0192830805,
-0.0781471282,
0.0066600116,
0.1425620168,
0.1139040589,
-0.0520976186,
-0.0313290097,
-0.0007432043,
-0.0703807101,
0.0281622037,
0.0224977601,
-0.0295531843,
-0.0647360533,
-0.0492970981,
-0.0621134788,
0.0789643675,
0.0129582938,
-0.04414903,
0.0411616303,
0.0358990319,
0.0081760883,
-0.0157424137,
-0.0511884876,
0.0351179019,
-0.0309576914,
-0.0084730741,
-0.0181415565,
0.0118707744,
-0.0080328947,
0.0046330532,
-0.0560781881,
0.0253527183,
-0.0295872129,
0.0046460857,
-0.0504362285,
-0.0249963477,
0.0532123744,
-0.0134187629,
0.0683308691,
-0.0083152978,
-0.0115658259,
0.006322585,
-0.0276829507,
-0.0330521613,
0.0002169021,
-0.0286314674,
-0.0014901554,
-0.0810286775,
0.0431414172,
-0.0300845206,
-0.0199707933,
-0.0375207812,
0.0145931346,
-0.0004015653,
0.0053438195,
-0.0307179429,
0.0231020674,
-0.0122509673,
-0.011432468,
-0.0388419293,
-0.04580779,
-0.0132609345,
0.0701436102,
0.0562853552,
0.041458331,
0.0044994405,
-0.0222387053,
0.0106078498,
0.0099104261,
-0.0289147943,
-0.0242477059,
0.0022166064,
0.0326323584,
-0.0198910087,
-0.0240844339,
0.0173541941,
0.0244903732,
0.0194441266,
-0.0155656319,
0.0211529937,
-0.0258459561,
-0.0138450507,
-0.0401366167,
0.0099514658,
-0.0152685829,
-0.0297779609,
0.0122491503,
-0.0674457774,
-0.0750922635,
0.0667012334,
-0.0343788601,
0.0335148573,
0.0284728892,
-0.0461578257,
-0.0234371629,
-0.0211573336,
-0.0086032832,
0.0490695052,
0.010950637,
-0.0285807457,
0.0358685292,
-0.0165119004,
-0.0080137597,
0.0171208382,
0.0184380841,
-0.0177947134,
0.0267342068,
-0.0021309499,
0.0246721618,
0.0289173927,
-0.0273701977,
-0.0337208658,
-0.0212286059,
-0.0171699133,
-0.0167904943,
0.0127470233,
-0.0543665588,
-0.0081531648,
-0.0141023435,
0.0373975225,
-0.0234634764,
-0.0145395212,
0.0934311524,
-0.0092460988,
0.0392936133,
-0.0847023353,
-0.0060822628,
-0.0007910938,
-0.0233788528,
-0.0548791885,
0.0091116754,
-0.009880295,
0.0000516551,
-0.0163905527,
-0.0028296674,
0.0858373418,
-0.0597259738,
0.0498231165,
-0.0186818354,
0.0569377579,
-0.0094902413,
-0.0369743742,
-0.0172521751,
0.0208724849,
-0.0244200714,
0.001169265,
0.0039795875,
-0.0174648035,
-0.0016008025,
0.0672682151,
0.0137988823,
0.0910219699,
0.0044743265,
-0.0374475606,
0.0077076303,
-0.0403578356,
0.0382872038,
-0.0081453128,
0.0293340385,
-0.0076294728,
0.0342494547,
0.0334194601,
0.0587452799,
-0.052168604,
0.0399154648,
-0.0287440531,
0.0431330465,
-0.0780572742,
0.0109402258,
0.0225087181,
0.0063873446,
-0.0837110803,
-0.0501997806,
0.1107362211,
0.0452377535,
-0.0560994484,
-0.0444063582,
-0.0346263796,
-0.0198593866,
0.0239905752,
0.0470450819,
-0.0571897402,
-0.0382677279,
0.0704393685,
0.0303016603,
-0.026262844,
-0.0174004808,
0.026156133,
-0.1260014027,
0.0647777915,
0.006920733,
0.0176965408,
-0.0809564665,
0.0083456738,
0.0246502068,
0.0079058828,
-0.0125016859,
0.0454587974,
-0.0002308497,
-0.0345561132,
-0.0238771774,
-0.0129205342,
-0.0514688231,
-0.004823979,
-0.0653625354,
-0.0137392459,
0.0825570822,
0.0292751957,
0.0371981971,
-0.0277908947,
0.0051191268,
-0.024178436,
-0.026931772,
-0.0196681917,
0.0006048715,
0.0365591608,
-0.0023251348,
-0.0378837734,
0.0100661581,
-0.0094728284,
-0.0087137548,
0.0358513482,
0.058566127,
-0.0388222337,
0.0174687188,
-0.0306921061,
0.0080550741,
0.0146890609,
0.0624782741,
0.0003434595,
-0.0378744677,
-0.0479612686,
-0.0544993766,
-0.0135400882,
-0.0193377305,
-0.0482742414,
0.0287080687,
-0.0822901875,
-0.0175024867,
-0.0727640912,
-0.0053162789,
-0.0070210397,
0.0255606845,
0.0160516836,
0.0302990563,
0.036142569,
0.0244176071,
-0.0618705451,
-0.0447013527,
-0.0074203573,
0.0431090295,
-0.0511222556,
0.0350883417,
-0.0198573153,
-0.019157799,
-0.0089181103,
0.0285485368,
0.0261712931,
-0.0288270004,
0.0307690389,
-0.0097847218,
0.013803686,
0.0092215203,
-0.062411394,
-0.0622122735,
0.0533691235,
0.0280228816,
0.009190469,
-0.0324478112,
0.0056414977,
-0.0560168773,
-0.0194660258,
0.02334629,
-0.0465812385,
0.0183181614,
-0.0225802753,
0.0486254729,
0.0018700034,
-0.0143783577,
0.0488755628,
0.0351981111,
0.0689856857,
-0.0187403858,
0.0007314749,
-0.0633955225,
0.0051004747,
0.0064143338,
-0.0667191744,
0.0083715478,
0.0066842097,
0.0010407158,
-0.0394593924,
0.0139939124,
0.0184431076,
-0.0091123953,
-0.0106495786,
-0.0116906147,
-0.0008156492,
-0.0081414171,
0.0632714033,
0.0272579081,
-0.0268811099,
0.0187274516,
0.0325397477,
0.0346705951,
0.0309433155,
-0.0137246959,
0.0502954014,
0.0252814963,
0.0448081605,
0.0044099325,
-0.0028683136,
-0.0591756739,
0.0518038273,
-0.0271050651,
0.0084381364,
0.0741807148,
-0.0221514367,
0.0337533206,
-0.0553839803,
-0.0141843688,
-0.0357817747,
0.005172479,
0.0108557707,
0.0162297282,
-0.0095571578,
0.0066179638,
-0.0023089999,
-0.0543519445,
0.061351072,
-0.0246903151,
0.0184313059,
-0.0260859169,
-0.1010962576,
-0.0158505104,
-0.0316879563,
-0.0150686661,
-0.0146773541,
-0.015451517,
-0.0168853924,
-0.0609816499,
-0.0512529276,
-0.0267514829,
0.0234510396,
-0.0263505746,
0.0117867496,
0.0041532107,
0.0494769365,
0.0190543737,
0.0290023014,
-0.0460257605,
-0.023519367,
-0.01767442,
-0.0242054611,
0.0137263779,
-6.103408748e-33,
-0.043543078,
-0.0134803541,
0.0128804324,
0.0199401714,
0.026985947,
-0.0249145105,
-0.0213150103,
-0.0213730913,
-0.0009386222,
0.0445995927,
-0.051440917,
0.036256671,
0.0096964072,
-0.0062653394,
0.015820086,
0.0380276516,
0.0411398783,
0.0262723099,
-0.0159650277,
-0.0270611141,
0.0671361089,
0.0638644099,
0.049491778,
-0.0290596951,
0.0003087007,
0.0279359259,
-0.0122418012,
0.0338761844,
-0.0027162158,
0.0457574204,
0.0313259065,
0.0329422764,
0.02067977,
0.0194993503,
-0.0147572095,
-0.00494562,
-0.0886512175,
-0.0058017527,
-0.0431983843,
0.0291226991,
0.0532467477,
-0.0006170018,
0.0564744696,
-0.0238922797,
-0.0522069819,
0.0190542322,
0.0371480957,
-0.0482460745,
0.0204658397,
-0.0344591998,
-0.0418566205,
0.0338854976,
0.0326970257,
0.0001998481,
-0.0037241434,
0.0254005212,
-0.0008772645,
-0.0007159274,
-0.0821214318,
0.0139474869,
0.0145433974,
0.0984864905,
0.0228689499,
-0.0199361388,
-0.0292060375,
-0.0042384155,
-0.0438300185,
-0.0071231592,
-0.0089667831,
-0.0128363185,
0.0276047103,
0.0132653425,
0.0707196295,
0.1025098562,
0.0404743664,
-0.0758282766,
-0.0086753769,
0.0681246892,
0.0090607377,
0.0419985466,
0.0071750917,
-0.0040035211,
-0.0510727689,
-0.0338265672,
0.0159303453,
0.0572991036,
-0.0476648584,
0.0268867556,
0.0444358885,
0.037859261,
-0.0037509524,
-0.0169029292,
-0.0222849585,
-0.0289427545,
0.0082227737,
-0.0171338823,
-0.0093008103,
-0.0111027723,
-0.018461952,
0.0200390257,
-0.0131221563,
-0.059410084,
-0.0100593315,
0.0313022397,
-0.0380870923,
0.0197347738,
0.0133393873,
0.0180142075,
-0.0695043579,
0.0264676157,
0.0181597099,
0.0296738986,
0.0260586962,
-0.0291022323,
-0.004391605,
0.000512991,
0.0384958386,
-0.0009282888,
0.0477009006,
-0.0055221491,
-0.0027061277,
-0.0318343155,
0.0040127332,
-0.0072444114,
0.0023491275,
0.0105781415,
-0.04269813,
-0.004103858,
0.0244154632,
-0.0524761453,
0.0006513963,
0.019813085,
2.983e-7,
0.0330286138,
0.0584670566,
-0.0091608502,
0.0396714099,
0.0219192319,
0.0414461493,
-0.040681269,
0.0211370122,
-0.0033257427,
0.0724610537,
0.0418455191,
-0.0339317136,
0.0657755435,
0.0097103203,
-0.0648098886,
-0.0731466338,
-0.0344113819,
0.0165962856,
0.0051778825,
0.0118552893,
-0.0326834209,
0.0235999953,
0.0029569655,
-0.0222626626,
-0.0029414692,
-0.1009365246,
0.0262323301,
0.0411441736,
0.017530039,
0.0462725945,
0.056551829,
0.0202826373,
0.0344312377,
0.0000278057,
-0.0355779454,
0.0398795232,
0.0252710134,
0.0189506542,
-0.0125100473,
0.0200669467,
0.0097243935,
-0.0170632433,
0.0245585907,
-0.0533334985,
0.0273525417,
0.0220562164,
0.0486102775,
-0.0318956822,
-0.0121779675,
-0.022519378,
0.0060340506,
-0.0211118627,
-0.0209658165,
0.0334732048,
0.0103788031,
0.0625977218,
-0.0186177008,
-0.0437792391,
-0.018916687,
-0.0210504401,
0.0263511315,
-0.0069985758,
-0.0084811989,
-0.0201888904,
-0.0057536135,
-0.0498373099,
0.0000445444,
2.789202894e-34,
0.0303048287,
-0.0250287764,
-0.0216436274,
-0.0005726306,
0.0346806347,
-0.0118018668,
-0.0124823535,
0.0266771782,
-0.0029048296,
-0.0387752987,
-0.023553839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08169v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08169v1 | Enhancing Performance on Seen and Unseen Dialogue Scenarios using Retrieval-Augmented End-to-End Task-Oriented System | 2023-08-16T06:52:10 | 2023-08-16T06:52:10 | Jianguo Zhang, Stephen Roller, Kun Qian, Zhiwei Liu, Rui Meng, Shelby Heinecke, Huan Wang, Silvio Savarese, Caiming Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | End-to-end task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems have achieved promising
performance by leveraging sophisticated natural language understanding and
natural language generation capabilities of pre-trained models. This work
enables the TOD systems with more flexibility through a simple cache. The cache
provides the flexibility to dynamically update the TOD systems and handle both
existing and unseen dialogue scenarios. Towards this end, we first fine-tune a
retrieval module to effectively retrieve the most relevant information entries
from the cache. We then train end-to-end TOD models that can refer to and
ground on both dialogue history and retrieved information during TOD
generation. The cache is straightforward to construct, and the backbone models
of TOD systems are compatible with existing pre-trained generative models.
Extensive experiments demonstrate the superior performance of our framework,
with a notable improvement in non-empty joint goal accuracy by 6.7% compared to
strong baselines. | [
0.0804515257,
0.0301474277,
0.0161714926,
0.0224361196,
0.0121206762,
0.006336119,
-0.0156898666,
-0.0079286741,
0.0181723777,
-0.0635801107,
-0.0499371812,
-0.0551792011,
-0.0389571041,
0.0642187968,
0.0147261191,
-0.0620227531,
0.0415039547,
0.0021318032,
-0.0057064383,
0.0407903232,
0.0068346751,
0.0099905962,
-0.0262903832,
0.0487725325,
-0.0203167628,
-0.0227418207,
-0.0543993451,
0.0058991439,
0.0091548739,
-0.0313768275,
0.0278779622,
0.0360949747,
0.0485894345,
0.022883663,
0.0000017102,
-0.0544028543,
-0.0066882474,
-0.0210905951,
-0.0430401154,
-0.0543387942,
0.0300920494,
0.0394821428,
0.002274815,
0.0366456695,
-0.039199315,
-0.0099505857,
0.0188463256,
0.0792617202,
0.0628119409,
0.1101112366,
-0.0101847798,
0.0030177045,
0.0045507248,
-0.0233476628,
0.0444752574,
-0.0583205894,
-0.0039075282,
0.012978008,
0.0048822742,
0.0191348102,
0.0357491113,
-0.0050078258,
0.0142913852,
-0.019034965,
-0.0080556003,
0.0251814909,
-0.0134502025,
-0.0017526115,
-0.0481970236,
0.0845338926,
0.0332225934,
0.0183098968,
-0.0022042082,
0.001591352,
0.000167822,
-0.0572358631,
-0.0426354446,
-0.0084592132,
-0.0239966568,
-0.0128364237,
-0.0350077599,
0.0403697193,
-0.0210372861,
0.0115960613,
-0.020158086,
-0.0010397504,
-0.0020417285,
-0.0259378292,
-0.0118610431,
-0.0134668034,
0.0030897784,
-0.0696208999,
0.0007695957,
0.0354422145,
-0.0602132678,
0.0285518803,
-0.023810599,
0.0143611263,
0.0029283899,
-0.0493935794,
0.0386714675,
0.0237584021,
-0.0524881706,
0.0365623385,
0.00362608,
0.0575422272,
-0.0112763699,
-0.0402038395,
-0.0423452593,
-0.0245568063,
-0.0490754247,
-0.0032515891,
-0.0714374483,
0.0420493931,
-0.061620418,
-0.030173894,
-0.0201145541,
0.0513890162,
0.0070888968,
-0.0181533583,
0.0269327294,
0.0566558838,
-0.0755504221,
-0.0120679894,
-0.0463974364,
-0.0054528299,
-0.0192625467,
0.0161875095,
0.0489466041,
-0.0483607687,
-0.0277481973,
0.0321202166,
0.0286245216,
-0.0032572316,
-0.0169434063,
0.0655066371,
-0.0260290131,
-0.0472747236,
-0.031608507,
-0.045480758,
-0.0343220979,
-0.0867981091,
-0.0037091768,
-0.0015785248,
0.0249513127,
-0.0166499447,
-0.0383770689,
-0.0157552361,
0.0260784831,
0.031806808,
-0.0082888138,
0.0326536931,
0.018363256,
-0.0279813539,
-0.0026735764,
0.0152724572,
-0.008997445,
0.0404440872,
0.0239761751,
0.0494862422,
0.0331435613,
0.0501236953,
0.0035026479,
-0.0106876474,
0.0264195651,
-0.0026552365,
0.04226809,
0.0579820126,
-0.012654027,
0.0290779714,
0.0115662785,
0.0428850986,
-0.0389094055,
0.0051724343,
0.0213452149,
0.0118243983,
0.0149810249,
0.0084534334,
0.0495011508,
0.0612666942,
-0.0244092885,
0.0030229241,
-0.0254415013,
0.0331771895,
-0.0098908199,
-0.0053451741,
0.0520153604,
-0.0024809423,
-0.0567457229,
-0.0453589223,
0.0031746125,
-0.004792748,
-0.0011962249,
0.0119345644,
0.0439105481,
0.0325208791,
-0.1209988669,
0.0182438605,
-0.0185678545,
-0.0793533847,
-0.0123990178,
-0.0245266929,
0.0124109564,
0.0516652092,
0.0598699637,
-0.0146797579,
-0.0759112164,
-0.0158675406,
-0.0151158664,
0.0504506938,
0.0322337113,
-0.0190170016,
0.0424872562,
-0.0459607691,
-0.0383827724,
-0.0191384219,
-0.0029988701,
0.0364102088,
0.0221422408,
-0.0147721358,
0.0535232723,
-0.0071531939,
-0.0045544622,
0.0143759465,
-0.0046970607,
-0.019430453,
0.0232482012,
0.0119372914,
0.0100061223,
0.022031229,
0.0045031882,
0.0026641989,
0.0241099056,
-0.0134406192,
-0.0158130489,
0.0276865587,
-0.0766573772,
-0.0521113425,
0.003075321,
0.0204915125,
-0.0002635935,
0.0232363082,
-0.0253268499,
-0.0719037428,
0.0197287686,
-0.0384884886,
0.000325104,
-0.0776410326,
0.0017598564,
0.0531956479,
-0.0043412941,
-0.0181006547,
0.0518850982,
0.0082115373,
-0.0082678888,
0.039432466,
0.0001546647,
0.0516732,
-0.0646413118,
0.0329281539,
-0.0065048495,
-0.0244616102,
0.0094264736,
0.0556509644,
0.0198934693,
-0.0511586964,
-0.0499893688,
-0.116780974,
0.0306945182,
-0.0279634707,
-0.0055804867,
0.0168371405,
0.0055519254,
-0.0149619551,
-0.0340892896,
-0.0369288251,
0.0209484659,
0.0792638361,
-0.0336698666,
0.0190023147,
0.0516845249,
0.0134568634,
-0.0454316549,
0.0487403534,
0.01875313,
0.0343967453,
0.0034163159,
-0.0366023667,
-0.0387513265,
0.0581343621,
-0.0533427559,
0.0760282502,
-0.0279777404,
0.0039941473,
0.0418472625,
0.0104487576,
0.0709535405,
0.0332001559,
0.0340917744,
0.03586125,
-0.0115366383,
-0.0634562522,
-0.075062871,
0.0512531996,
-0.0165412929,
-0.0273064673,
-0.0219952669,
0.001736203,
0.0391429551,
0.0366854742,
0.009834026,
0.0000451384,
-0.0461109877,
0.0050275163,
0.0210489184,
-0.0257732701,
-0.0098278569,
0.000385031,
-0.0299783982,
0.0146127166,
-0.0278642438,
-0.0285353865,
0.0530751944,
-0.0275922976,
-0.0278466512,
-0.0476382785,
0.0057619279,
-0.0306124836,
0.0803602412,
-0.018201245,
0.0189836733,
0.0357011631,
-0.0477349907,
-0.0407750495,
0.0016000166,
-0.00553774,
-0.0435009785,
0.0075593437,
-0.0204674061,
0.0198208019,
-0.0085060615,
-0.0431801379,
-0.1024826989,
-0.0120199407,
0.0136645511,
0.0033100795,
-0.007250885,
-0.0168358218,
-0.037185099,
0.0002585431,
0.0076672076,
0.0389507562,
0.0021464489,
-0.0225938726,
-0.0276395287,
0.0335619487,
0.0594610907,
-0.0108866189,
-0.0133671472,
-0.0251302235,
0.0263183452,
0.0462774262,
0.0528818816,
-0.0418255515,
-0.0237500947,
-0.0348569825,
0.0189466029,
-0.0111000799,
-0.0030070054,
0.0307041239,
0.0447775051,
-0.0374668837,
-0.0270839743,
0.097394906,
0.0231041703,
-0.0175710376,
-0.0320343822,
-0.0101226689,
0.0069429553,
0.019368317,
0.0440929346,
-0.0850767791,
-0.0333511531,
0.0022213745,
0.0214639157,
-0.002296062,
-0.0425046422,
-0.0586048365,
-0.0924841613,
0.046572309,
-0.0272705089,
0.007932256,
0.0124076689,
0.00801674,
0.0062138592,
0.0260071307,
0.0159250945,
0.0190676264,
0.0075106709,
-0.0107226223,
0.0076968083,
0.024884209,
-0.0011678727,
0.0198942292,
-0.0187888462,
0.0200543087,
0.0707217902,
0.0551629663,
0.0629913658,
0.0199364815,
0.0280135572,
0.0295366943,
0.0257142559,
0.0063767028,
0.0569813326,
-0.0311410576,
0.007382778,
-0.0485288613,
0.0210197214,
-0.0001534397,
-0.006287796,
0.0004310423,
0.0206841137,
-0.0568811335,
0.0240707491,
-0.0159139987,
0.0209531877,
0.0610905252,
0.0737279281,
0.0137760621,
-0.0076464885,
-0.0424432382,
0.0003181916,
0.0124009764,
-0.0764192641,
0.0163533892,
-0.0316695347,
-0.0062173218,
0.0275653955,
-0.0803610384,
-0.0659457669,
-0.0036601811,
0.0474582762,
-0.0157555006,
-0.0138356136,
-0.0103114145,
-0.0061990763,
-0.0316177905,
0.0437842198,
-0.041761037,
-0.0105598494,
-0.0488685258,
-0.0088277105,
0.0316887274,
-0.0446876362,
-0.0085311513,
0.0555024706,
-0.0616236441,
-0.0418226831,
-0.0606244802,
0.0662437677,
0.0166054256,
0.0461302698,
0.0284752697,
-0.0053701266,
0.0085879462,
-0.0022728606,
-0.0470759943,
-0.0207030214,
0.0356861278,
0.0467779189,
-0.0152205769,
0.0369996466,
-0.0609996915,
0.0280031003,
-0.012960894,
0.0453923494,
0.0101438938,
-0.0587950833,
0.0281000379,
-0.0489616133,
0.0614894331,
0.0171262268,
-0.0067276135,
-0.046920903,
0.0335010774,
-0.034361586,
-0.018286569,
-0.0697735623,
0.0438671485,
-0.0227559153,
-0.0247818176,
0.0117669301,
0.0392997004,
-0.0690519288,
0.0692672208,
-0.040630538,
-0.0467880666,
0.0067790416,
-0.0115533452,
0.0071829553,
-0.0032011701,
-0.0191680621,
0.0166373961,
0.01429764,
0.0376134664,
-0.0036909529,
0.0936704352,
0.0109834205,
-0.0089856107,
0.009284243,
0.0272618979,
-0.0513067059,
-0.0411969312,
-0.0229164418,
-0.0005398776,
0.0254264697,
0.0426105857,
0.0365955234,
-0.0238642972,
0.0450622067,
-0.0252469815,
0.0551647097,
-0.0263164099,
-0.0531497933,
0.0047442941,
0.0089802025,
-0.000203139,
0.0131695494,
0.0629112571,
-0.0267837141,
0.0263283085,
-0.0256174598,
-0.014105211,
-0.0639975742,
-0.0488877147,
0.0183538105,
0.039181605,
0.0045685708,
0.0144093782,
-0.002627736,
-0.0255910158,
-0.0113551691,
-0.0042110109,
-0.0241705906,
-0.0013228523,
0.0594341084,
0.0378058702,
-0.013973996,
-0.0227469727,
-0.0223912448,
0.0019961051,
-0.0341354497,
-0.0195579473,
-0.0316258296,
-5.559334861e-33,
-0.0478568152,
-0.0154984137,
0.0600855611,
-0.0134683717,
-0.0381791033,
-0.0138786361,
-0.0611872263,
-0.0049268855,
-0.001642077,
-0.0124529805,
0.0044205002,
0.0110427374,
0.0103425244,
0.0417222902,
-0.0473806113,
0.0216303039,
0.0591178909,
0.0029513058,
-0.015702229,
0.0512091666,
0.0759321526,
0.0484866425,
0.0383299775,
-0.0587907284,
0.0431293361,
-0.0144787179,
0.0070390347,
0.0422697514,
0.0435169712,
0.0293875318,
-0.0240128897,
0.0287198368,
0.0089913104,
-0.0398365483,
-0.0423464142,
0.0234590489,
-0.0543670505,
-0.0107969064,
0.0079388199,
-0.0111788176,
-0.0448300615,
-0.0051558437,
-0.0142641393,
-0.0171112902,
0.0078228526,
0.0166563466,
-0.0014053993,
-0.0029994955,
0.005205337,
-0.0131109776,
-0.0678556189,
0.0050968118,
0.0068287738,
-0.0800445452,
-0.0210177433,
0.1100606546,
0.032950718,
-0.0465838686,
-0.0212181453,
0.0162782241,
-0.0096019218,
-0.0037469321,
0.0256436355,
0.0347448587,
-0.0056671621,
0.0616246238,
0.0331017971,
0.008515507,
-0.0403856188,
-0.0534007549,
-0.0210868996,
0.0537851155,
-0.0166704822,
0.0385980159,
-0.0070346645,
0.0400004201,
-0.0584301949,
0.0564198084,
-0.0045588454,
0.0565557852,
0.0031856189,
0.0047594253,
-0.03273407,
0.0029275999,
-0.0181168802,
0.0321315937,
-0.0160537902,
-0.0423049256,
0.0677100718,
0.0682037622,
0.0068461946,
-0.0210754909,
0.0527242757,
-0.0236440562,
0.0305009,
0.0519643985,
-0.0404230133,
-0.0236780178,
-0.0199603718,
0.0373751931,
-0.0455801412,
-0.0236833189,
0.0723977536,
0.0134256175,
-0.0322368182,
0.0050636907,
0.0014856562,
0.010262982,
-0.0545185246,
0.0273623001,
-0.0377475806,
0.0698571503,
-0.048666466,
0.0488099381,
0.0112635279,
0.0090228105,
-0.0359827206,
0.093186453,
-0.0120264301,
-0.0232862197,
-0.0378063582,
-0.0314794071,
0.0450858586,
0.0079286024,
-0.0121699823,
0.0340992585,
-0.0053953025,
0.0074694189,
-0.0031751043,
0.0090990867,
-0.0045590666,
0.0154334363,
2.416e-7,
-0.0138362208,
0.0018381753,
0.0599016584,
0.0687139556,
-0.0160858054,
0.0467779823,
0.0116976202,
0.040765062,
0.0416002497,
0.0007786311,
0.0009949268,
0.0253562331,
0.0371165648,
0.0039384132,
-0.0602334552,
-0.0300344564,
-0.0203785356,
-0.0416798852,
-0.0490448251,
-0.0271216854,
0.0586491935,
0.0448782071,
-0.0160940234,
0.0086304722,
-0.0017831939,
-0.0377142839,
0.0825346261,
-0.011122494,
-0.0220187623,
0.0193581693,
0.0568206608,
0.0221100729,
-0.0140687842,
-0.009508864,
-0.0021584155,
0.0387684293,
-0.0170079358,
0.0280898437,
-0.0007042822,
-0.0839031115,
0.0102424612,
0.0189665891,
0.0021267375,
-0.038363263,
0.0372234248,
-0.0705102608,
0.0100657884,
-0.0280750394,
-0.0022156721,
0.0082354788,
-0.0311085135,
-0.000427587,
-0.0000634024,
0.0079919631,
0.0209708791,
-0.0083435383,
0.0243769269,
-0.0864950567,
-0.0105241844,
-0.0108418502,
-0.0560795441,
-0.0158066172,
-0.0362146199,
-0.0061055133,
-0.009436233,
-0.0374585278,
-0.012248083,
1.828024122e-34,
0.0223477259,
0.0183285046,
-0.0073399637,
0.0074446839,
0.0393362157,
-0.0017062569,
-0.014975152,
-0.0136912651,
0.0557660758,
-0.059710715,
-0.0431990437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08577v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08577v1 | AffectEcho: Speaker Independent and Language-Agnostic Emotion and Affect Transfer for Speech Synthesis | 2023-08-16T06:28:29 | 2023-08-16T06:28:29 | Hrishikesh Viswanath, Aneesh Bhattacharya, Pascal Jutras-Dubé, Prerit Gupta, Mridu Prashanth, Yashvardhan Khaitan, Aniket Bera | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.HC, eess.AS | Affect is an emotional characteristic encompassing valence, arousal, and
intensity, and is a crucial attribute for enabling authentic conversations.
While existing text-to-speech (TTS) and speech-to-speech systems rely on
strength embedding vectors and global style tokens to capture emotions, these
models represent emotions as a component of style or represent them in discrete
categories. We propose AffectEcho, an emotion translation model, that uses a
Vector Quantized codebook to model emotions within a quantized space featuring
five levels of affect intensity to capture complex nuances and subtle
differences in the same emotion. The quantized emotional embeddings are
implicitly derived from spoken speech samples, eliminating the need for one-hot
vectors or explicit strength embeddings. Experimental results demonstrate the
effectiveness of our approach in controlling the emotions of generated speech
while preserving identity, style, and emotional cadence unique to each speaker.
We showcase the language-independent emotion modeling capability of the
quantized emotional embeddings learned from a bilingual (English and Chinese)
speech corpus with an emotion transfer task from a reference speech to a target
speech. We achieve state-of-art results on both qualitative and quantitative
metrics. | [
-0.0369780362,
0.0610114001,
-0.0022190805,
0.0032032966,
0.0202477388,
-0.0151801305,
0.0201454498,
-0.0159122497,
-0.014065953,
0.0039117662,
-0.0650956556,
-0.0405556634,
-0.0373526923,
0.0218296312,
0.0266498867,
-0.0939178169,
0.0139679583,
0.0171071701,
0.0467642434,
-0.0280013829,
0.0436570756,
0.0260860138,
-0.0045300233,
0.0237533655,
-0.0328402631,
0.0129173063,
-0.0252028294,
0.0376371928,
0.0505791157,
0.0118082026,
0.0386513956,
0.0371710956,
0.0749836341,
-0.0329380445,
0.0000018643,
-0.0110826008,
-0.011067871,
-0.0133297043,
0.0141147412,
-0.0066259191,
0.0593400858,
-0.0032907734,
-0.0495575443,
0.0021300374,
-0.0074073635,
-0.0345181376,
0.0743053034,
0.0487562567,
0.0920375139,
0.0802607387,
-0.0417370461,
-0.0231301375,
0.0059738806,
-0.0178691,
0.0046847141,
0.0070019276,
-0.0064817565,
-0.0099028153,
0.0194735229,
-0.0328617021,
-0.0533919372,
0.0160663258,
-0.0075115561,
-0.0080169262,
0.0386238024,
-0.0367742255,
-0.0478620455,
-0.0100539066,
-0.0134772342,
0.058309786,
-0.0522846691,
0.0322454497,
0.0278090555,
0.0148668885,
0.0022142767,
-0.0788580328,
-0.0023792328,
-0.0216381289,
0.0328993984,
0.0217843857,
-0.0230561849,
0.061105188,
0.0024607955,
-0.0163872577,
-0.0049863858,
-0.0146399103,
0.0092564914,
-0.0347020365,
0.0106632784,
-0.0250185616,
-0.0350718573,
0.0070127682,
0.0507491566,
-0.0254894067,
0.030315917,
0.0011883293,
-0.0379346721,
-0.0199988373,
-0.0694704428,
-0.0310546774,
-0.0081887264,
0.0481000207,
-0.0194703266,
0.0158636309,
0.0040731276,
0.0601398908,
-0.0001824326,
-0.0251508988,
-0.0346794017,
-0.0104506724,
-0.0217855778,
0.0212501995,
-0.0366816856,
0.0155039383,
-0.0351613909,
-0.0344295241,
-0.0747672319,
-0.0165640023,
-0.0615520142,
0.0065322123,
-0.0087591335,
0.0212251265,
-0.0251936056,
-0.0084928581,
0.051074788,
0.0191298109,
-0.0271803364,
0.021461498,
0.0244906526,
-0.0428099073,
0.0214638207,
0.0277340971,
0.0450630002,
-0.0112180645,
0.0266332645,
0.0181527454,
-0.0185733121,
-0.0060043116,
-0.0076878928,
-0.0057055852,
-0.0241014659,
-0.0457912274,
0.0192337912,
-0.0267811771,
0.0300511587,
-0.0464032739,
0.0104628867,
-0.0363099314,
0.0035819409,
-0.0560324714,
0.0075190789,
0.0197595842,
0.0143170031,
-0.0013223763,
0.0070365239,
0.0133000109,
0.0165500045,
0.0318409055,
0.0233065858,
0.0364060216,
0.0359150805,
-0.0450611636,
0.0296275672,
0.0397657976,
0.0132754333,
0.0187932532,
-0.0342725292,
-0.0651442856,
-0.0126950042,
0.0576849729,
0.0851055309,
0.0330164246,
-0.0367171988,
0.0112057459,
0.0596815683,
0.0121309226,
0.048349455,
0.0557688177,
0.0097551038,
0.038505286,
0.0088605955,
-0.0374724008,
-0.0123988474,
0.0454262942,
0.0145595521,
-0.0015591125,
0.0537519529,
0.0125650028,
-0.0352081023,
-0.0407206267,
0.01128601,
-0.010019972,
-0.0028082149,
-0.001571979,
0.0111155491,
0.0094530974,
-0.023324661,
0.0044401591,
-0.0134964893,
-0.1181605831,
0.0373400673,
0.0048409016,
-0.0158091355,
0.0790630057,
-0.0171462055,
0.0051131905,
0.0259648971,
-0.021492919,
-0.0241797008,
0.0213434808,
0.0160516668,
-0.0160106122,
0.0731624886,
-0.078591533,
0.0352439992,
-0.0054021627,
-0.0139629319,
0.0091483751,
-0.0597557202,
0.0564636253,
-0.0166403055,
-0.0144713605,
0.0604733042,
-0.0299608931,
-0.0141342962,
-0.0360520817,
0.035174191,
0.0149803469,
0.0055533797,
0.0400710031,
-0.0139071587,
-0.0140175615,
-0.0087383399,
-0.040715944,
-0.0066903196,
0.0412827469,
-0.0203256365,
-0.0273318756,
0.0310116448,
-0.008839733,
0.0325575359,
-0.0120993135,
-0.0368069708,
-0.0504661947,
0.0585195683,
0.0095087783,
0.0419249721,
0.0022575019,
-0.002261905,
0.0046666856,
0.0818882287,
0.0473752357,
-0.0267165359,
0.012094575,
-0.0237175338,
0.0229909737,
0.0174272154,
-0.0238409322,
-0.0312265977,
-0.0278148428,
0.0199738815,
0.0208803285,
0.0424757116,
-0.0245768707,
-0.0346932299,
-0.0412189141,
-0.0561921932,
-0.0733673424,
0.0162342116,
0.0302398335,
-0.0186785739,
-0.0104137352,
0.0193207487,
-0.0232187938,
0.0265781265,
-0.094408229,
-0.0469138101,
-0.0308008976,
-0.0185392033,
-0.0389252529,
-0.0310032498,
0.0021118973,
-0.0555893369,
0.0087817982,
-0.0044305096,
-0.0037815706,
-0.0505062602,
0.0085743349,
-0.021562526,
0.0027510843,
-0.0239384584,
0.0227367375,
-0.0010838242,
-0.0802085549,
-0.006681575,
-0.006761868,
0.0658309013,
0.0488782749,
0.0069942474,
0.0349620096,
0.0218914915,
-0.0611523092,
-0.0412647985,
0.0378433652,
0.0010457594,
0.0608142093,
-0.0018553899,
-0.0234461073,
-0.0035102018,
0.0134119112,
0.0349316821,
0.0057184766,
-0.0713170394,
0.0134618394,
0.0513851047,
-0.0433949679,
0.0385818742,
-0.0146247111,
-0.0150739793,
-0.0124644777,
0.0123585593,
-0.0187220518,
0.0128805311,
-0.0143460706,
-0.0591017306,
-0.0258899424,
0.0140501158,
0.0167209655,
-0.0035673515,
-0.0843719244,
0.0097426539,
-0.0306701455,
0.0157233272,
-0.0125026209,
-0.0367530361,
-0.0293285474,
-0.0819452107,
-0.0100818546,
-0.012150663,
-0.0610687472,
0.013025553,
-0.0164634436,
0.0134123517,
0.0117757609,
-0.0241621565,
0.0329386592,
0.0418430604,
-0.0391310081,
0.0460279323,
0.0079119736,
0.0287251472,
-0.0386487506,
-0.0192202274,
0.0003686811,
0.0251996778,
0.0154501125,
0.0251998454,
0.0102319634,
-0.0029773084,
-0.0157345254,
0.0246127509,
0.0042577055,
0.0493963622,
0.0349785835,
-0.0143207498,
0.0461411998,
0.0310750045,
0.0383938104,
-0.0164565872,
-0.0467715859,
0.0607373826,
-0.0081598181,
0.0372156985,
0.0954707935,
-0.0073457952,
-0.027296517,
0.0083678197,
-0.042967733,
0.0127095561,
-0.0112098753,
0.0379517116,
-0.0429725759,
-0.0226086024,
0.0478371046,
0.041422382,
0.0140088666,
-0.0008265076,
-0.0099384049,
-0.0576089025,
0.0247218236,
0.0616524555,
0.0056978934,
-0.0439204164,
0.0136014074,
0.0007162418,
-0.0083257426,
-0.0001765888,
-0.0434624739,
0.0228815507,
-0.019585032,
0.0378469229,
-0.014884457,
-0.0351745635,
0.0238140915,
-0.0203717072,
0.0991770327,
0.0263365582,
0.1232124791,
0.0041327025,
-0.0276886281,
-0.0251901913,
-0.0087351501,
-0.0177593995,
0.0113472063,
0.0037599101,
0.0061510955,
-0.027748568,
-0.0030586149,
0.0543992147,
0.010671027,
0.0182723776,
-0.0051910407,
0.021378424,
-0.003902894,
-0.0388309024,
-0.0288166031,
0.0088639902,
-0.0000704977,
0.0373387635,
0.0099892113,
-0.0813064501,
-0.0186822508,
-0.0229014196,
0.0756194368,
-0.0433881842,
-0.0679412708,
-0.0112551171,
-0.0223158188,
-0.0464238003,
-0.1004104391,
-0.0196658876,
-0.0165192485,
0.0372821987,
-0.0286156405,
-0.0641958788,
-0.0091742175,
-0.0129115041,
-0.0137036126,
-0.0213410929,
0.0269974191,
0.0443992056,
-0.0024391096,
-0.0045442148,
-0.0046789194,
-0.028889766,
0.0139932912,
-0.0096073104,
0.0066654272,
-0.056094151,
0.0312592052,
0.0284067672,
0.0037677726,
0.0217888933,
0.0131135406,
-0.0430282652,
0.0538591854,
0.0278738905,
-0.0009818263,
0.0136337122,
0.1125942096,
0.0518852286,
-0.0116767455,
0.0108734919,
-0.0265152548,
0.0542633608,
0.0024988572,
0.0343092605,
0.0263771657,
-0.0485614054,
-0.042981334,
-0.0151778823,
0.0135742696,
-0.0042292597,
0.0012126883,
-0.0183103811,
-0.0109104505,
-0.0358951613,
0.0387343802,
-0.0884798691,
-0.0337345414,
0.008408241,
0.0297813546,
-0.0297096446,
-0.0515447855,
0.0148546612,
-0.0563533381,
0.0260605197,
0.0400706381,
0.0052778097,
0.0237059128,
-0.0056114891,
0.0425178483,
-0.0109397545,
0.020637475,
0.0048439349,
-0.0063893772,
-0.0416404717,
0.0221010726,
-0.0021275193,
-0.017342912,
0.0292577241,
0.0354851671,
0.0141890831,
0.0449455902,
-0.0298615303,
-0.0406366773,
0.023245519,
-0.0051901406,
0.089125067,
-0.0271394104,
0.0367381014,
-0.0255009644,
0.0070745628,
-0.0427230261,
-0.0461233296,
-0.0016994638,
-0.0159836691,
-0.0111675905,
0.0146558434,
0.0112850033,
-0.0618573129,
0.0397520959,
-0.0484908074,
0.0418916941,
-0.0335510671,
0.0193629209,
0.0550182834,
-0.0628735945,
0.0328829698,
-0.0164148435,
-0.0425730571,
-0.0697125569,
0.0661294907,
-0.0268349126,
-0.0220293459,
-0.0445117652,
0.0250025224,
0.0017211403,
-0.0687503889,
0.0083943922,
-0.0311497543,
-0.0081540328,
-0.0389022939,
-0.0162376724,
0.0206183102,
-5.536915245e-33,
0.0101685496,
0.0349796116,
-0.0630462617,
0.0208799224,
-0.0719225258,
0.0032637594,
-0.047436595,
-0.0066804062,
0.0046739103,
0.0326904655,
-0.0339841135,
0.0068796021,
0.0069172303,
0.0177443512,
-0.0063484088,
0.0346018635,
0.0554719418,
0.0181462392,
-0.0029243124,
0.0642956048,
0.0276220944,
0.0253938492,
0.0555995442,
-0.0934756473,
-0.0024904916,
0.0044079414,
-0.0252962802,
-0.0163988657,
0.0975624323,
0.0149502782,
0.0081482911,
0.040473599,
-0.046914313,
-0.0110559482,
-0.0253757108,
-0.0169989299,
-0.0109127816,
-0.0177797526,
-0.0062889443,
0.0127870496,
0.0012422161,
-0.0685033277,
0.0058237659,
0.0182035044,
-0.0001500739,
-0.055741258,
0.0023064604,
-0.0214948636,
0.0070179338,
-0.145536229,
-0.0250243843,
0.0313514061,
-0.0223173033,
-0.0194151886,
0.0650894493,
0.0335656516,
-0.0004598837,
-0.0422599539,
-0.0195577107,
0.0318783335,
-0.0221461207,
0.0312300604,
0.0209664181,
-0.0045382846,
0.0303327944,
0.0520461164,
0.0566802323,
-0.0432310551,
0.0250176489,
0.0755662322,
0.0708714351,
0.041462075,
0.0519458912,
0.0640702769,
-0.0045134374,
-0.0110805435,
0.0331900604,
0.0201334357,
0.0387383699,
-0.0212018397,
0.0397578143,
0.0791417733,
-0.0089759547,
0.0063040224,
-0.0280550271,
-0.051980935,
-0.0054471195,
-0.0639160424,
0.0327914767,
-0.0241049025,
0.006693298,
-0.0329374894,
0.0404809564,
-0.0125551773,
-0.0113006737,
0.0138101084,
-0.0586875454,
0.0693743452,
-0.0108344359,
0.0046129352,
0.0052534565,
-0.0366886035,
0.0880119726,
0.0429495946,
0.0479752161,
-0.0126315504,
-0.0496292673,
0.0877036229,
-0.0455317497,
-0.0248110108,
-0.0053375452,
0.0421859361,
-0.0310453158,
-0.0164985787,
-0.0334543735,
0.0196066927,
0.0019651973,
-0.0098591503,
0.0064463625,
0.0717333853,
0.0229959525,
-0.0006432642,
0.0053999638,
0.0618557446,
-0.079587765,
0.0152200041,
-0.0132362498,
-0.0408189856,
0.0181617793,
-0.032140106,
-0.0190402865,
0.0025897566,
2.738e-7,
-0.0589343347,
0.016506549,
0.0006772472,
-0.0584972575,
0.0176056046,
0.0581265278,
-0.0165030826,
0.0339461565,
0.0312185436,
0.012181907,
0.0284200124,
0.0113165025,
0.078949362,
0.0017402597,
-0.0977460817,
0.0231920201,
-0.0139545351,
0.0255456492,
0.0051303143,
-0.0049558738,
0.0659308285,
0.0658107623,
0.0213599186,
0.0153073072,
0.027188722,
0.0447975062,
0.0309640709,
-0.0239644293,
0.0153310625,
0.0050079483,
-0.0117911082,
-0.0457794294,
-0.0338222012,
-0.0345271863,
-0.0214430522,
0.0187439863,
0.0406678952,
0.0817845389,
0.014773055,
-0.0665988922,
0.009969634,
0.0283340104,
-0.0486247092,
0.0154135767,
0.0141653419,
-0.0333354622,
-0.0296500418,
-0.0380639359,
-0.0487190932,
0.0331925116,
0.0057276725,
-0.0337804705,
-0.0658234134,
0.0407256708,
0.022165427,
0.0157674551,
-0.0103419293,
-0.0672318935,
-0.0169737693,
0.002523066,
-0.0332628302,
-0.036429055,
-0.024611637,
0.0523033999,
-0.0017496247,
-0.0024743616,
-0.0054343934,
1.787241585e-34,
-0.0057716491,
-0.017482169,
0.0140583897,
0.0082445405,
0.0230743177,
-0.0046542506,
-0.0097618587,
0.0028461502,
0.0558008477,
-0.0370502584,
-0.020299254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08156v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08156v1 | Sarcasm Detection in a Disaster Context | 2023-08-16T05:58:12 | 2023-08-16T05:58:12 | Tiberiu Sosea, Junyi Jessy Li, Cornelia Caragea | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | During natural disasters, people often use social media platforms such as
Twitter to ask for help, to provide information about the disaster situation,
or to express contempt about the unfolding event or public policies and
guidelines. This contempt is in some cases expressed as sarcasm or irony.
Understanding this form of speech in a disaster-centric context is essential to
improving natural language understanding of disaster-related tweets. In this
paper, we introduce HurricaneSARC, a dataset of 15,000 tweets annotated for
intended sarcasm, and provide a comprehensive investigation of sarcasm
detection using pre-trained language models. Our best model is able to obtain
as much as 0.70 F1 on our dataset. We also demonstrate that the performance on
HurricaneSARC can be improved by leveraging intermediate task transfer
learning. We release our data and code at
https://github.com/tsosea2/HurricaneSarc. | [
0.0335612297,
0.0205877833,
-0.0226164255,
0.0442999117,
-0.0129891774,
0.0389691181,
-0.0134566054,
-0.0359060466,
0.0198626388,
-0.0363675691,
-0.0311805904,
-0.0102047892,
-0.052220691,
0.0331569053,
-0.0167319626,
-0.0593458526,
0.0273657665,
0.0220795423,
0.0127619505,
-0.0019772334,
0.0103242816,
0.016673144,
-0.0240012314,
0.0220711902,
0.0067689996,
0.0010296758,
0.0008628343,
0.0897333995,
0.038386859,
-0.0484227948,
0.0730000138,
0.0219847597,
0.015902238,
-0.0121091846,
0.0000018669,
-0.0365647972,
-0.0253782142,
-0.039211031,
-0.0352659486,
-0.026146872,
0.1132871285,
-0.0647978187,
-0.0105347503,
0.0343434364,
-0.0664703846,
-0.0115448991,
0.0516311042,
0.0176867452,
0.0752708167,
0.120920971,
-0.0175246708,
-0.0075413515,
-0.0256694369,
0.0196919367,
-0.0068654977,
-0.032941848,
0.0593026318,
0.0119761443,
-0.0563789718,
-0.0075989971,
-0.0198076423,
0.0203274637,
-0.0134963291,
0.0341088548,
-0.0237806179,
-0.0055368254,
-0.0006755356,
0.0294045098,
-0.0278888363,
0.0597224981,
-0.0020374306,
-0.0209955852,
-0.0113892574,
0.0154588493,
-0.0011386951,
-0.025774423,
-0.0404009223,
-0.0215479061,
0.0025345876,
0.0081150141,
0.0099372668,
0.0383248329,
0.0163368005,
0.0414969251,
0.0057069929,
0.005196996,
-0.019973563,
-0.032148581,
-0.0333021916,
0.0270091798,
-0.0488064177,
-0.0008588708,
0.0435641557,
0.0271544512,
0.0132398149,
0.0172878858,
-0.0337255932,
-0.0682026222,
-0.0230235606,
-0.0498877726,
-0.0131279966,
0.0187157076,
-0.0204153489,
0.063284412,
-0.0030536288,
-0.0256894343,
0.0020245239,
0.0687060654,
-0.0128214713,
-0.0520048589,
-0.0742148235,
0.0420349427,
-0.0322317369,
0.0093278755,
-0.007919386,
0.0304833222,
-0.0378778353,
0.0037141074,
0.0028093108,
-0.0507007055,
0.0468709692,
-0.0076507418,
-0.0599674769,
-0.0447701439,
0.0119733913,
0.0378231294,
-0.0053682216,
0.0638744459,
-0.0380974896,
-0.05117267,
-0.0390247591,
0.0258904155,
0.0438093692,
-0.0124196671,
0.0187134668,
0.0153091429,
0.0200202223,
-0.0636237636,
-0.0721433088,
0.0289398674,
-0.0458740443,
-0.0187457185,
0.0184742678,
-0.0173055828,
0.0243111048,
-0.0081810728,
-0.0126545671,
0.0019002949,
0.0077045592,
-0.0206336975,
-0.0395003185,
0.0431880578,
-0.0699556246,
0.0157920755,
-0.0058507309,
0.0027085082,
-0.0791603476,
0.0525300466,
0.0328401849,
0.0529985428,
0.0416520648,
0.0026886042,
-0.0350433402,
-0.0119449617,
0.008900404,
0.0205898527,
-0.0128381485,
0.0136301368,
-0.0649087802,
0.0014365904,
0.0154901342,
-0.0045174817,
-0.0118844956,
0.0293518882,
0.0545419641,
0.0146512212,
-0.0463061035,
0.0312942192,
0.0507894605,
0.0507060997,
-0.0101362113,
-0.0252273995,
-0.0154828923,
0.0198153779,
-0.0689326525,
-0.048770193,
-0.0340920724,
0.0444542989,
-0.0214257408,
-0.0329066738,
-0.0199176129,
-0.0218348838,
0.0091151968,
-0.0132593494,
0.0471516736,
0.0508633666,
-0.0381408781,
-0.0353269428,
0.0324703045,
-0.0411675945,
-0.0348092765,
-0.0087563572,
-0.025242148,
0.0695189461,
0.000288589,
-0.0278255269,
-0.057568647,
-0.0405866541,
0.0323286355,
0.0258045401,
-0.0092631485,
0.0271400232,
0.035421025,
-0.0448277965,
0.0046218946,
0.0005274494,
0.0092523834,
0.0058380766,
-0.0034824503,
0.0594701655,
-0.015215179,
-0.0085734343,
0.0269050542,
0.0315322578,
-0.0152716879,
-0.0407234952,
0.0043462962,
0.0155562544,
0.0381187499,
-0.0100891422,
0.0170698464,
-0.037436679,
0.0097354148,
-0.0359836929,
-0.0567632429,
0.0540838987,
-0.0462054648,
-0.0916933194,
0.0208320096,
-0.0579774566,
-0.0215038043,
0.0858747289,
-0.055596441,
-0.0004368898,
0.062045902,
0.0311462786,
0.0106503051,
-0.0374014154,
0.0058915047,
-0.0428803377,
0.032155972,
0.0359415077,
0.0780949146,
0.0092275515,
-0.0504964888,
-0.045952566,
0.0047187051,
-0.0199852344,
0.0524665155,
-0.0156269353,
-0.0166394152,
-0.0236369744,
0.0114573641,
-0.0236327518,
0.0186066348,
-0.037877284,
0.003815288,
-0.0919245631,
0.0467474088,
-0.0419620685,
0.0441890284,
0.0562245101,
0.0064485907,
-0.0177972782,
0.0216335226,
0.0215088967,
0.0140335709,
-0.0157407653,
-0.0133485151,
0.0196022782,
-0.0622808225,
0.0282580908,
-0.0607688501,
-0.0080119893,
-0.0217236131,
0.0142945284,
-0.0075809625,
-0.0363121778,
-0.0032438277,
0.0441402495,
-0.0052063628,
-0.0115721142,
0.0121638374,
-0.0908658653,
-0.0144034047,
-0.0152780572,
-0.0069935811,
0.0296682585,
0.0382386558,
0.0611235499,
-0.0308099892,
0.021817239,
-0.0048532272,
0.0412964001,
-0.0255204774,
-0.0062728184,
-0.0385520309,
-0.0174958911,
-0.0293568708,
0.0525526963,
0.0076127294,
-0.0052015022,
-0.0227648821,
-0.0109292697,
-0.0195597801,
0.0011526309,
0.00633155,
-0.0033517987,
-0.0284923613,
-0.0528748408,
-0.0214008577,
0.0175407976,
0.0169726796,
0.0340059586,
-0.0075483252,
-0.0663821474,
-0.0450117551,
-0.0371903777,
0.0593074635,
-0.0291210935,
0.00183032,
0.0100642508,
0.0231606867,
0.0011798098,
-0.0400204845,
0.006265129,
-0.0221544784,
0.0035197416,
-0.0122097842,
0.0057208627,
0.0093409177,
-0.0284119677,
-0.0351712741,
-0.0475952849,
-0.060610164,
-0.0148662869,
0.0251380429,
0.0038023898,
-0.0075697857,
-0.0271745212,
0.0250740424,
0.0109233437,
0.0087850858,
-0.0152624603,
-0.0119310366,
0.0142502235,
0.0182434171,
-0.0047689518,
0.0465882905,
0.0205959529,
-0.0266551338,
0.0601996072,
-0.0039343736,
0.0007684465,
-0.031039061,
-0.0014900021,
0.0218350645,
-0.0037129023,
0.0445312858,
-0.0114650307,
0.0553047806,
0.0056873662,
-0.0104288058,
0.089333646,
0.0149452444,
-0.0161159076,
0.0152103826,
-0.009420556,
-0.0457182862,
0.0329823084,
-0.0084453253,
-0.0577016845,
-0.0711129829,
-0.0191316474,
0.0001509849,
0.0084524183,
-0.0524540059,
-0.0357290395,
-0.0653507188,
0.0155862439,
-0.0215452556,
0.0165407285,
0.0249711107,
0.0037641109,
0.0457163304,
-0.0247514565,
-0.0046186345,
-0.0478133149,
-0.0027099254,
-0.0161023885,
0.0182727743,
-0.029709883,
-0.0644682869,
0.0327302106,
-0.0180356856,
0.0510416329,
-0.0013618839,
0.0694710091,
0.0047636083,
0.0020774573,
0.0114937555,
-0.0401924103,
-0.0104509369,
-0.0226637833,
0.0677014738,
-0.0213066619,
-0.013159181,
-0.0128463795,
0.0001469229,
-0.0886303559,
0.0207487922,
0.0311443731,
0.0383960381,
0.0090932809,
-0.0220502373,
-0.0332468189,
0.0063421978,
0.0757498145,
0.045793958,
0.017825596,
-0.0447249562,
-0.0021850113,
-0.0136357695,
-0.0419901125,
-0.0786010921,
-0.027133273,
0.0419507362,
-0.0232475307,
-0.0410326347,
-0.0884266496,
0.0004928883,
0.0210375674,
0.0364874974,
-0.042278979,
-0.0512518585,
0.0158332512,
-0.0334333926,
-0.0327195376,
0.002934726,
-0.034160044,
0.0212302152,
-0.0008636104,
-0.0065946039,
-0.0064509222,
-0.0375877246,
-0.0214042906,
0.011157223,
-0.0754967257,
-0.018062368,
0.0478975177,
0.0368133038,
0.0059547476,
-0.0294144992,
-0.0300839972,
-0.0061399541,
-0.0029919967,
0.0483609922,
-0.0288225785,
-0.0066154515,
0.057253968,
0.0308108162,
0.0310054328,
0.0557226054,
0.002576171,
0.0903660506,
0.0277000796,
0.0284641795,
-0.0236076843,
0.0100819198,
-0.0124960132,
-0.0158693735,
0.0888335332,
0.0573090911,
-0.1217137873,
0.0027365577,
-0.00541953,
-0.0291616526,
-0.0093456935,
-0.0338270813,
0.0316735841,
0.0163792707,
0.0197399482,
-0.0700974911,
-0.0183084533,
-0.0236320756,
0.0114074238,
0.0035151253,
0.0268966537,
0.0498968214,
0.027458543,
-0.0178375728,
0.0243028142,
-0.0391335748,
-0.0109165851,
0.0444491841,
-0.0448608063,
0.0098664751,
0.0048903758,
0.0186445732,
0.0258122757,
0.0114435731,
0.0149395382,
-0.0050049797,
0.0034330348,
-0.0110428222,
-0.0169395749,
0.0525291376,
0.0078956271,
0.0883013383,
-0.0218470581,
0.0108512007,
-0.0211498532,
0.0456492156,
-0.048334606,
-0.0252922997,
0.0054040002,
-0.0017726752,
-0.0140819112,
-0.0040469966,
0.0226179156,
-0.05151999,
0.0418926254,
0.0574704856,
-0.0150654502,
-0.0281614698,
0.0011818738,
0.0006984395,
-0.0280648246,
0.0313306972,
0.0566025749,
-0.0199420936,
-0.047818806,
0.0843352377,
-0.074596867,
-0.0379823782,
-0.0136346947,
0.0068823337,
0.0331010632,
-0.0081066201,
0.0034643237,
-0.0145449014,
0.0191473439,
-0.0310819577,
-0.0090432158,
0.0050825994,
-6.286097835e-33,
0.0142898271,
-0.0238812398,
-0.0177311487,
-0.0107934037,
0.0185317211,
0.0347257629,
-0.0282342881,
-0.0114263752,
-0.0274758562,
0.0265582018,
-0.0033829533,
0.0392131656,
0.0020280899,
0.0027914159,
-0.0015076951,
-0.0165158045,
0.0224867836,
0.0066348701,
0.0165893249,
-0.0035200976,
0.0429815613,
0.0406976715,
0.1023277491,
-0.1193311661,
-0.0162996035,
-0.0098094484,
-0.0466797352,
0.0000589542,
0.0725683495,
0.0345613211,
0.0019864817,
0.0597853847,
0.0374733657,
-0.0041087666,
-0.0182415154,
0.0365085714,
-0.0244819131,
-0.0252581965,
0.018512005,
-0.0194367692,
-0.0489647239,
-0.0256862789,
0.0216890629,
0.0373244435,
0.0030995521,
-0.0280523058,
0.0243901033,
-0.0025982221,
0.024260506,
-0.0482258908,
-0.0911768898,
0.0313741863,
-0.0175397005,
-0.0202309359,
0.0035994183,
0.0221109409,
0.0044509433,
0.007782483,
-0.0391418561,
0.0007697281,
-0.0932109877,
-0.0132096084,
-0.0119075887,
-0.0568998307,
0.0027309137,
0.0523256101,
-0.0060051843,
0.0260994025,
-0.0118722059,
-0.014356113,
0.0203966275,
0.0352489129,
0.0447635241,
0.1350072622,
0.0351286344,
-0.061323572,
-0.0583543628,
-0.0196677316,
0.0277063642,
0.0386349522,
0.0310226809,
-0.0069525396,
-0.0431970842,
0.0245981887,
0.0218384713,
0.0146154165,
0.0008449283,
-0.0139058987,
0.0269791801,
0.0166196525,
0.0007292825,
0.0555981956,
0.0204744935,
-0.0348713696,
0.00852744,
0.0455036238,
-0.0184551887,
0.0293988064,
0.0026063181,
0.0732248053,
-0.0475515723,
-0.0106109828,
0.0260667,
0.0236813203,
0.0237691496,
-0.0029881392,
0.0880014449,
0.058358673,
-0.0318045616,
-0.0025937275,
-0.0144110415,
0.0327160843,
-0.0497273952,
0.0591714941,
0.0018279491,
0.0313707143,
0.005316732,
0.01058897,
0.033857733,
-0.0106457053,
0.0022374832,
-0.01274083,
-0.0133974878,
0.0331116132,
-0.0498867966,
0.0009467051,
-0.0169834178,
-0.087026678,
-0.0484716557,
-0.0824795514,
-0.0053278841,
-0.0186071917,
2.629e-7,
0.0507259257,
0.0757692605,
-0.0075819297,
0.0376063697,
0.0004707003,
0.0528472103,
0.0134925246,
0.0474110544,
-0.0068738274,
-0.0069337375,
0.0333930217,
0.0529102348,
0.037001051,
0.0150862299,
-0.0768274739,
0.0233461522,
-0.0330638103,
0.0390167795,
0.0041846936,
-0.030929001,
0.0826084763,
0.0446509607,
0.0519435406,
-0.0137512656,
-0.0161169786,
-0.045576971,
0.0230483897,
-0.0351581983,
0.013351935,
0.017578546,
0.0284955073,
0.012218832,
-0.0335524566,
-0.0014039548,
-0.0079496503,
-0.0109115802,
0.0293933265,
0.0738665611,
-0.0199612621,
-0.0339136533,
0.0081998529,
-0.0017643365,
0.0112980651,
-0.0211694576,
0.0585547946,
-0.0493744723,
-0.018887978,
-0.011114792,
-0.039245978,
0.0382229611,
0.0311196912,
0.0202967878,
-0.0249813534,
0.0099133616,
0.056854751,
0.0046967324,
-0.0548039638,
-0.082456395,
0.025199322,
0.0346908867,
-0.0305888895,
-0.0076815849,
-0.0163997654,
0.0111663165,
0.0695488229,
-0.0751077011,
0.0625947565,
1.797011619e-34,
0.0111880675,
-0.0001569535,
0.0150083154,
-0.0150083154,
0.0081631308,
0.0202749074,
-0.0139931692,
-0.0327784158,
0.0391969569,
-0.0409372412,
0.0020673338
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08155v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08155v2 | AutoGen: Enabling Next-Gen LLM Applications via Multi-Agent Conversation | 2023-08-16T05:57:52 | 2023-10-03T20:47:10 | Qingyun Wu, Gagan Bansal, Jieyu Zhang, Yiran Wu, Beibin Li, Erkang Zhu, Li Jiang, Xiaoyun Zhang, Shaokun Zhang, Jiale Liu, Ahmed Hassan Awadallah, Ryen W White, Doug Burger, Chi Wang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | AutoGen is an open-source framework that allows developers to build LLM
applications via multiple agents that can converse with each other to
accomplish tasks. AutoGen agents are customizable, conversable, and can operate
in various modes that employ combinations of LLMs, human inputs, and tools.
Using AutoGen, developers can also flexibly define agent interaction behaviors.
Both natural language and computer code can be used to program flexible
conversation patterns for different applications. AutoGen serves as a generic
infrastructure to build diverse applications of various complexities and LLM
capacities. Empirical studies demonstrate the effectiveness of the framework in
many example applications, with domains ranging from mathematics, coding,
question answering, operations research, online decision-making, entertainment,
etc. | [
0.0126035046,
0.017772859,
-0.0268089082,
0.0370084681,
-0.044350937,
0.0013881015,
0.0113111241,
0.0157013331,
0.0037717118,
-0.0303055923,
-0.0306982137,
0.052771613,
0.0073676202,
0.0218113828,
0.0069676372,
-0.0313906781,
0.0207785182,
-0.0035997916,
0.0019492233,
0.0200228859,
0.0148724541,
-0.003307685,
-0.0550429858,
0.0335060284,
-0.0032399462,
-0.0222055297,
-0.0553854033,
0.0186836049,
0.020834133,
-0.0038895109,
-0.011831373,
0.0404449962,
0.01226555,
-0.0267211981,
0.0000021495,
-0.0631411746,
-0.0032580253,
0.0114211086,
-0.0372278132,
-0.0101782857,
0.0246981028,
0.0596979037,
-0.0104325591,
0.0124230757,
-0.0517056063,
0.0505802594,
0.0496416986,
-0.0189059619,
0.0830608979,
0.0312611908,
0.0070530996,
0.0138939265,
0.0166962799,
0.0125796385,
0.0424010307,
-0.066097565,
-0.0027722099,
0.0149509273,
0.0831392333,
-0.0066356719,
0.0261020828,
-0.000361224,
0.0016877598,
-0.0125362054,
0.0326146372,
0.0112104351,
-0.003534677,
-0.0295927431,
-0.0644069538,
0.0534966663,
0.0497989431,
0.0278077293,
0.0510691106,
-0.0152127473,
0.041327253,
0.0075847511,
-0.0445649363,
-0.0011170212,
-0.0101985577,
-0.0193335079,
-0.0290888883,
-0.0285157673,
-0.0237620007,
-0.0073694615,
-0.0201568026,
0.0752389953,
-0.0083190305,
0.0167404134,
-0.023394553,
-0.0074586691,
0.0533370748,
-0.0537302531,
-0.017987635,
0.0780474171,
-0.0638039261,
0.0092382953,
-0.0121893547,
0.0131131802,
0.0513136089,
-0.0354641974,
0.0144621711,
0.0113591449,
-0.0090456717,
0.0235584825,
0.0146699529,
0.0222626422,
0.0224862639,
-0.0095587345,
0.0211570431,
-0.0060750321,
-0.036141403,
0.0051972936,
-0.02959029,
0.0474849343,
-0.0571925938,
0.0280590877,
-0.0331523567,
0.0967418477,
-0.0157230906,
0.0681523085,
-0.0241175462,
0.0103743086,
-0.0039710142,
0.0002395673,
-0.0671673939,
-0.0362651907,
-0.0321386755,
-0.0051982948,
0.0273548514,
-0.0926376879,
0.0148947006,
0.0120853167,
-0.0295112599,
0.0093878163,
0.0077609885,
0.1273387074,
0.0053324727,
0.0180636626,
-0.0306345839,
-0.0560270846,
0.04175625,
-0.0375617109,
-0.0506590642,
-0.0800198242,
0.0160892773,
0.0084367339,
-0.0460512936,
-0.0433746167,
0.0286756605,
0.0136039471,
0.0347597785,
0.0616126209,
-0.0579039678,
0.0173493866,
0.0625523925,
0.0471432805,
-0.0063692629,
0.043618653,
0.0376819931,
0.0105468947,
0.0371487997,
0.0000260122,
0.0605385527,
0.0428200178,
-0.0319110379,
-0.0064203274,
0.0431087576,
0.0322212689,
-0.0273795277,
0.0345263854,
-0.0391414985,
-0.0263914783,
-0.0163593665,
-0.007600104,
0.0430413559,
0.0690717474,
0.0310856923,
0.0387337767,
-0.0013016644,
0.0560475215,
0.0008333361,
-0.040175315,
-0.0469703563,
0.0890618786,
-0.0180735402,
0.001657009,
-0.0347319916,
0.0266059469,
-0.0217706244,
-0.0663529187,
0.0168932602,
-0.0136466846,
-0.0010560737,
0.0166668892,
0.0261656288,
-0.0066211452,
-0.0154889598,
0.0609596781,
0.0063271266,
-0.0565562993,
-0.0647630543,
-0.0616409779,
0.0341562703,
0.0798442513,
0.0490669236,
-0.0616742559,
-0.0587061383,
-0.0035939619,
0.0043541677,
0.0262142848,
0.0540489629,
-0.0008345823,
-0.001912378,
-0.0262854286,
-0.0176574495,
-0.0163029432,
-0.0170707293,
0.0314152017,
-0.0054872953,
-0.0051393653,
-0.0144470204,
-0.0135233058,
0.0132314498,
0.0253240615,
-0.0360633545,
-0.0416228287,
-0.0053790063,
0.014827596,
-0.0055290754,
0.0398074463,
0.0003151801,
-0.0059785023,
0.0647553056,
0.008415441,
-0.030279506,
0.0043836315,
0.0287741944,
0.0246143639,
0.0304160547,
-0.0266923904,
-0.0237931684,
-0.0394351408,
-0.0415411778,
0.0142342476,
0.0049810698,
-0.0096900137,
0.0546992086,
-0.019412104,
0.003921337,
0.0115316883,
-0.0154838553,
-0.0288956556,
-0.0018035406,
0.0276999939,
-0.0188956745,
0.0423004515,
0.0219983328,
0.0109323785,
-0.0496405587,
0.0511228479,
0.0124357054,
0.0157667622,
0.0140873753,
-0.0231569577,
0.0483882427,
-0.0173443593,
-0.0262694955,
-0.0663210973,
0.0041972026,
-0.0132399723,
0.0090645235,
-0.0225981977,
0.0246535018,
-0.0115505084,
-0.0256953463,
-0.0487982035,
0.0354619995,
0.0125044864,
-0.0076523521,
0.0593672432,
0.0101297339,
-0.063000381,
-0.0228821132,
0.0192625038,
-0.0025707122,
0.0058713732,
0.0245158579,
-0.0505462363,
-0.0736533329,
0.0384868197,
-0.0374420322,
-0.0160251725,
-0.0149803963,
-0.0049852841,
0.0161551777,
-0.0031854974,
0.0048472038,
0.0467667542,
-0.0318782218,
0.0416422486,
0.0236302242,
-0.0471470021,
-0.091279909,
0.0109167974,
0.0155052934,
-0.0044297092,
-0.0316820778,
-0.0153939612,
0.0189565867,
0.0219992623,
-0.0224108677,
0.0201495811,
0.0365151502,
0.0148497587,
0.0644677579,
-0.0126536181,
0.0366163515,
0.0037193687,
-0.0208580568,
0.0604992062,
0.0024989427,
-0.0554292612,
0.0561195575,
-0.0104482928,
-0.0463313311,
-0.0011894666,
-0.0773472264,
-0.0602993965,
0.0637621582,
-0.0522520766,
-0.0276574194,
-0.0147773186,
-0.0334179327,
-0.0063257562,
-0.0135754505,
0.0217816215,
-0.0277987532,
0.0623931922,
-0.0677988157,
-0.0151936188,
-0.0030407601,
-0.019043019,
-0.0176705178,
0.0346911028,
-0.0425171107,
-0.0086655756,
0.0032554136,
-0.0254882108,
-0.0381013304,
-0.0107318219,
0.0025250635,
-0.0248603262,
0.0261472594,
-0.0320292935,
-0.0277393255,
-0.0399023555,
-0.0106440149,
0.055978708,
-0.0047202394,
-0.0228373278,
0.0209448095,
0.0592702515,
-0.0331297591,
-0.0637273937,
-0.0280732643,
-0.0228917412,
0.0359797291,
-0.0655142665,
0.0038228172,
0.0453696363,
0.0326952823,
-0.0344898291,
0.0275865961,
0.067814,
0.0373319723,
-0.0554046147,
0.0078147789,
-0.0758465305,
0.0082956906,
0.023861751,
0.0385025851,
-0.1150262356,
-0.0311274063,
-0.0172325876,
0.0249861963,
0.0018894803,
-0.0340337753,
-0.0133492034,
-0.0557073094,
0.075756669,
-0.0030860058,
0.0341761112,
0.0174762905,
-0.0067593432,
0.0247528721,
-0.0106168408,
-0.0117482236,
0.011123904,
0.0144350231,
-0.0251498129,
-0.0224079788,
-0.0787375569,
0.033717379,
0.0014057634,
-0.0204258133,
0.06480176,
0.0631956011,
0.0361849442,
0.0090691196,
-0.0616000406,
0.0342515893,
0.0584038645,
0.0468861572,
-0.0418148823,
0.0185616352,
0.0044632154,
0.0147830816,
-0.0256440379,
0.0078698918,
-0.0307423268,
-0.0114616696,
0.0534956977,
0.0550409295,
-0.0691988096,
-0.0086228857,
-0.0565898046,
0.0145204086,
0.0185623076,
0.0278328005,
-0.0034723701,
-0.0265224259,
-0.0556337722,
-0.0470324941,
-0.0392610505,
-0.0247316938,
-0.0278308913,
-0.0395227484,
-0.0127384327,
0.007200039,
-0.0201159697,
-0.0379303433,
0.0442327112,
-0.0223776698,
0.002101393,
-0.0095596937,
0.0317639969,
0.043990504,
-0.0253127255,
-0.0219690595,
0.0099860365,
0.0304086283,
-0.0086229742,
-0.0169157591,
0.0270975549,
-0.0426351577,
0.0197058562,
0.0157884955,
-0.0546465777,
-0.0445949174,
-0.0448467284,
0.0698933899,
0.0294270515,
0.0227676891,
-0.0058658454,
-0.0313691832,
0.0009887244,
0.0400366262,
-0.0554337464,
0.0245461371,
-0.0019959812,
0.0684945062,
0.005182738,
0.0026174688,
-0.0734142214,
-0.0115369493,
-0.0185793657,
0.0086724367,
-0.0612652525,
-0.106675908,
-0.0168119092,
0.015966842,
-0.0506473668,
0.0265417695,
0.0011470841,
0.0074791214,
0.043549452,
-0.0084075108,
0.0063710725,
-0.048858583,
0.0059469966,
-0.0787874758,
-0.049706459,
0.0776792169,
0.0261110477,
-0.0482589155,
0.0048373858,
0.0043686945,
0.0925912336,
-0.0287521202,
-0.002236844,
0.0209115818,
0.0084562125,
0.0172964223,
0.0321011879,
0.0067756269,
0.0590658635,
0.0146765132,
0.0411636531,
-0.0075748954,
0.0126405945,
0.0210161339,
0.0334034562,
-0.0291346032,
-0.0910459533,
0.0292526819,
0.0573010035,
0.0355403312,
0.1074771434,
0.0014237325,
-0.0583127663,
0.025461657,
0.0138914352,
0.0378417112,
-0.002468941,
-0.0020824955,
-0.0148340445,
0.0071861669,
-0.0206625741,
-0.0722457916,
0.0316467918,
-0.0225044116,
-0.0043963962,
-0.0405830443,
-0.0316067263,
-0.0700035691,
-0.0402464271,
0.045746915,
-0.01981581,
-0.0116640711,
-0.036351081,
-0.0601553433,
-0.0141270692,
0.0276391283,
0.0123625342,
-0.0230761599,
-0.0614773035,
0.0365187787,
0.0383733138,
0.0423959643,
-0.0170843638,
-0.0087966369,
0.0285477899,
-0.0331474021,
-0.0160184037,
-0.0335916653,
-5.282700265e-33,
-0.0263344701,
-0.0801216662,
0.0611421056,
0.079347074,
0.0081458474,
-0.0580532886,
-0.0202928148,
0.0370325148,
0.0165816303,
-0.0075248391,
-0.0082424683,
0.0123947533,
0.0130657796,
-0.0518100634,
0.0368133374,
-0.0172157492,
0.0195026509,
0.0004888899,
-0.0101275546,
-0.0018860863,
-0.056936007,
0.0381479599,
0.0130558591,
-0.0919778049,
0.0542201363,
0.014030342,
0.0208695717,
-0.0128566837,
-0.0348273478,
0.0278750267,
0.0354551487,
0.0391131267,
-0.0168100297,
0.001597181,
-0.0235732589,
0.0221334249,
-0.0279127806,
-0.0457944982,
0.0188352428,
0.0088621834,
-0.0357105732,
-0.0273852777,
0.0297264475,
0.0178299341,
-0.0446281172,
0.0077219815,
0.0579977781,
-0.0174876899,
-0.0154442554,
-0.0189283062,
-0.0432090089,
0.0294923931,
-0.027511768,
-0.0064712563,
0.0066015944,
0.0181143656,
-0.0192540511,
-0.0349515863,
-0.0344686508,
0.0411689878,
0.0061186594,
-0.0302872546,
0.0507820733,
-0.0244041011,
-0.0083980188,
0.0221270099,
0.0260176677,
0.0159965176,
-0.0450884067,
-0.012941855,
-0.0152735403,
0.1239158809,
0.0300436653,
0.0444854759,
-0.0495693125,
0.0179650132,
-0.0113753006,
0.0603493489,
0.0531113483,
0.00532379,
-0.0080109844,
0.0122750504,
-0.0111299735,
0.0139279719,
0.0140282754,
0.0452873372,
-0.0156082539,
-0.0550665781,
0.0004338117,
-0.0192250721,
0.0499086156,
-0.0191283356,
-0.0200458374,
-0.0122117866,
-0.0214447509,
-0.0322268382,
0.026725946,
-0.0035768538,
0.0011194206,
-0.0228729285,
-0.0179083273,
0.006087312,
-0.0490332805,
0.0174984094,
0.0696987212,
0.0230185986,
-0.0360097662,
-0.0009604769,
-0.0342561118,
0.0126239127,
-0.020078063,
0.0399618782,
0.0108128106,
-0.0051114941,
-0.0281320605,
-0.0230203345,
-0.0052517611,
0.0463000052,
-0.0531804338,
-0.0408646353,
-0.0503648967,
0.014599937,
0.0096064974,
-0.0027066448,
-0.036948543,
-0.022739023,
-0.0470281504,
0.0406454541,
0.0249059908,
-0.013237223,
-0.0144500257,
-0.0140577042,
2.77e-7,
0.0034331603,
0.0498459153,
0.0021138059,
0.0728663132,
0.0165188517,
0.0347442143,
-0.0051177768,
0.0237499066,
0.0193869993,
-0.0140233627,
0.0238135792,
0.0389093086,
0.0428854302,
0.01655888,
-0.0606273971,
-0.0248840842,
0.0357635655,
0.0122964364,
-0.0523753054,
0.0190516897,
0.0626649782,
-0.0207066257,
0.008209521,
0.0101841614,
0.0036541086,
-0.013644103,
-0.0050958334,
-0.0740972385,
0.0074605411,
0.0511491746,
0.0034806193,
-0.0168631319,
-0.0019138099,
0.0166674051,
-0.0211239364,
-0.0200055167,
-0.0393096246,
0.0750429034,
-0.0145990439,
-0.0690217391,
0.0248402301,
-0.062528424,
0.0178057794,
0.0224075485,
-0.0054491558,
-0.0068299989,
-0.0138649633,
0.0159126092,
0.0045887306,
-0.058596883,
-0.0100785531,
-0.0239250828,
0.0056931083,
-0.0303894151,
0.0033997267,
-0.0284494665,
-0.0040721032,
-0.0308229551,
0.0065473397,
0.0173222851,
-0.0459677875,
-0.0763170868,
-0.0274288859,
0.0217017848,
-0.0114317909,
-0.0143969366,
-0.0000655211,
2.494369166e-34,
0.0113874776,
0.0127975624,
-0.0190996286,
0.1342543066,
0.0383996405,
0.0373025388,
-0.0195348077,
0.034320958,
0.0514589213,
-0.0288104005,
-0.0111652007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08153v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08153v1 | Fast Training of NMT Model with Data Sorting | 2023-08-16T05:48:50 | 2023-08-16T05:48:50 | Daniela N. Rim, Kimera Richard, Heeyoul Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Transformer model has revolutionized Natural Language Processing tasks
such as Neural Machine Translation, and many efforts have been made to study
the Transformer architecture, which increased its efficiency and accuracy. One
potential area for improvement is to address the computation of empty tokens
that the Transformer computes only to discard them later, leading to an
unnecessary computational burden. To tackle this, we propose an algorithm that
sorts translation sentence pairs based on their length before batching,
minimizing the waste of computing power. Since the amount of sorting could
violate the independent and identically distributed (i.i.d) data assumption, we
sort the data partially. In experiments, we apply the proposed method to
English-Korean and English-Luganda language pairs for machine translation and
show that there are gains in computational time while maintaining the
performance. Our method is independent of architectures, so that it can be
easily integrated into any training process with flexible data lengths. | [
0.0333878547,
0.0454629883,
0.0142436875,
0.0621396676,
-0.0256890133,
0.0163091365,
0.0042958092,
0.0240041465,
-0.0414661616,
-0.011719957,
-0.0207681023,
-0.063468948,
0.032477811,
-0.0348809548,
0.018203482,
-0.0539584868,
0.022886673,
0.00416497,
-0.0283199009,
0.0096454369,
-0.041128248,
-0.0302319694,
0.0029516481,
0.026528189,
-0.0010498731,
0.004103824,
-0.0264350362,
0.0411769934,
0.0415579081,
-0.0259147175,
-0.025018163,
0.0591036677,
-0.0153528266,
0.0730784908,
0.0000021232,
0.0097633628,
-0.022830585,
0.0176786631,
0.0259556212,
-0.0176774822,
0.0533195361,
-0.0170518011,
-0.0434227884,
0.0562481768,
-0.0154107008,
-0.0521975942,
0.0612399988,
0.0477599129,
0.0799081922,
0.0944895372,
-0.02056868,
-0.0178854633,
0.0263607427,
-0.0563247465,
-0.0002629962,
-0.0203807671,
-0.0179599077,
-0.0459836386,
-0.0461863689,
0.0315835662,
-0.0145775033,
0.03894151,
0.029339293,
0.0465145074,
-0.0176354405,
0.0307574011,
-0.050139457,
-0.0265211482,
-0.0386031643,
0.0581429489,
-0.055951003,
0.0047462019,
-0.0075083966,
0.0056277611,
-0.003355951,
-0.0279151797,
-0.0240224078,
0.0205669068,
-0.0035763506,
0.0139941406,
-0.0030469857,
0.0417765975,
0.0371706598,
-0.008268293,
-0.0631474182,
0.047832381,
0.0326548219,
-0.058028657,
-0.0240563899,
-0.0218707453,
0.0068107671,
-0.0145294657,
0.0098437229,
-0.0034409813,
0.0317632966,
0.0015300718,
-0.008513934,
-0.0485235564,
-0.0405336916,
-0.0500910021,
-0.0253602192,
0.0562995225,
0.002236834,
0.0172884595,
-0.0267451983,
0.0730047077,
-0.0042375396,
0.0203452315,
-0.0885411203,
-0.0001636702,
-0.0126064522,
-0.0026341924,
-0.0641728416,
0.0082292883,
-0.0475536361,
-0.0168812256,
-0.0448742658,
0.0004774929,
0.0221908931,
-0.0474963449,
0.0711763948,
-0.0299346037,
-0.0534954332,
-0.0029448774,
-0.0185670182,
0.0234216824,
0.0096440539,
-0.0369631685,
0.0036718624,
-0.0624665506,
-0.0235784352,
0.0017839565,
-0.0075468444,
-0.026164677,
0.0002882683,
0.0629588217,
-0.0298278499,
-0.0720189512,
-0.0223812982,
0.0389255956,
0.0035454542,
-0.006528337,
0.0468996577,
-0.0706937239,
0.052920036,
0.0028473097,
0.0532337762,
0.0276253317,
-0.0060376711,
0.0233954657,
-0.0320958234,
0.0584051013,
0.0298394542,
-0.0051437928,
0.0236150306,
0.0017268189,
0.0054016109,
0.0334601626,
0.0675466508,
0.0327554159,
-0.0188477766,
-0.0086480342,
-0.0235595964,
0.0315733366,
-0.02236614,
0.0038304531,
-0.0267957281,
-0.0284016319,
-0.0347426981,
0.0239247344,
-0.0039434191,
0.0588983223,
-0.0537117459,
0.0172807463,
0.0340734236,
0.0486547425,
0.0324418843,
0.0577881411,
0.0385840647,
0.0178131536,
-0.018825246,
0.0164386388,
-0.0502153784,
0.0354659632,
0.017280994,
-0.0198697764,
0.0322566964,
0.0791934952,
-0.0345882177,
-0.0427527502,
-0.0059849331,
-0.0465147831,
0.0376861021,
-0.0437652171,
0.0002718889,
0.0244592875,
-0.0463785268,
0.0936021432,
-0.0026284135,
-0.0542559698,
-0.0404627062,
-0.0340930782,
-0.0790635422,
0.0642831996,
-0.0000499216,
0.0027960006,
-0.0460309312,
0.0113822343,
-0.0169915147,
0.0350440703,
0.0390007459,
0.0387943462,
0.001982217,
-0.0698791817,
0.0005950005,
0.0578501932,
-0.0154027026,
0.0319351926,
0.0266265329,
0.0338534117,
0.056304507,
-0.006108846,
-0.0491168164,
0.0187367611,
-0.005938516,
-0.0357275009,
0.02744787,
0.0412477739,
0.0407035686,
-0.0000714633,
-0.0049556163,
0.025695309,
0.0468498245,
-0.044504486,
-0.0581162535,
0.043104168,
-0.0711511448,
-0.0436859056,
0.0018300073,
-0.0278142691,
0.0170151945,
0.0354453214,
-0.054578539,
-0.0620195307,
-0.0347872749,
-0.0144336438,
0.0054312325,
-0.0423566215,
0.0452727117,
0.0289134048,
-0.0062459777,
-0.023770852,
0.0578457378,
-0.0429759547,
0.0324019529,
-0.0025387164,
-0.0218538735,
0.0005790266,
-0.015173208,
-0.052884087,
0.0708757564,
0.0007098833,
0.0307234451,
0.0275623612,
0.0184337683,
-0.0130451731,
-0.0778871104,
-0.0832087621,
0.0143772466,
0.0008400294,
0.0277619865,
0.0180893876,
0.0668573678,
0.0095235147,
0.0125018358,
-0.0303170402,
0.0130138053,
0.0126723116,
0.0097875632,
0.0146505916,
-0.0290968325,
-0.0130882524,
0.0090668444,
-0.0352770351,
-0.0195974763,
0.0500801131,
-0.0205218755,
-0.0207410995,
-0.0684205666,
0.0078459671,
-0.0158074778,
0.0162441377,
-0.0167874899,
-0.0843264088,
0.0209079254,
-0.0200952552,
0.0427884832,
0.0622989647,
0.0439212285,
0.0029185801,
0.0313908048,
0.0156949703,
-0.0231527034,
0.0246180929,
-0.0147370296,
0.0218265858,
-0.0194052011,
-0.0657439977,
-0.0322501361,
0.0860117972,
0.003490028,
0.0057450309,
-0.0871083513,
-0.0162901152,
-0.0387777574,
0.0043402263,
0.0152875837,
0.0378662758,
-0.0274347346,
-0.0291735735,
-0.0387272909,
-0.0073222937,
0.0367559381,
-0.0493617617,
-0.0103461826,
-0.0773060098,
-0.0001723629,
-0.034733478,
0.021186728,
0.017953869,
0.0438223146,
-0.0370368659,
-0.0293307696,
-0.0354866013,
0.0207400694,
-0.0150472503,
-0.0256112497,
0.0527958646,
0.0163485147,
0.0008326956,
-0.0372386985,
-0.013541162,
-0.0261359867,
-0.0186841786,
0.0066039716,
-0.0091109788,
0.0465375744,
-0.0352817364,
-0.022309171,
0.0506519899,
0.0359903872,
0.080661945,
-0.0365639664,
-0.0090757925,
-0.0182221644,
0.0444380566,
-0.0348021835,
-0.0038368208,
0.0117851282,
-0.0229563285,
0.0432585143,
0.0270655118,
0.0366488397,
-0.0098675881,
-0.0520443916,
-0.0475169905,
0.0076406384,
-0.0273528397,
-0.0291476306,
0.0013008922,
0.0349600799,
-0.0124127306,
-0.000710276,
0.1217688471,
0.0303609278,
-0.0254544858,
-0.0102509083,
0.0306061842,
0.0356731191,
0.0334119126,
0.0082204612,
-0.0590176173,
-0.016358491,
-0.0051571438,
0.0249622203,
0.0050819363,
-0.0080384947,
-0.0252962038,
-0.0782363117,
-0.0019881462,
0.044309672,
-0.0647402555,
-0.0282731205,
-0.0284343492,
-0.0506362505,
-0.033180885,
0.0074956543,
0.0048755268,
0.0217430945,
-0.0164490119,
0.043924313,
0.0534793288,
-0.0313680544,
-0.0246317368,
-0.0480921306,
-0.0175618473,
0.0062284204,
0.0408575423,
-0.0237981528,
-0.0376890339,
0.0064632548,
0.0132398596,
0.0214626119,
0.0073000514,
0.025853619,
0.0063425489,
-0.0073947627,
0.0137548093,
-0.0371447466,
-0.0273135845,
0.0319027789,
-0.0084831789,
0.0717396885,
-0.0087950984,
-0.0042779851,
0.0348774008,
-0.042253904,
-0.0247058682,
0.0442644171,
0.0271145403,
-0.0271985456,
0.0037025181,
-0.0294614062,
0.0161648709,
0.0028587284,
-0.0192143917,
-0.0092313737,
0.0002497183,
-0.0579209328,
-0.1007184014,
-0.06221525,
-0.0330294371,
0.0670681521,
-0.0092268996,
-0.0149379913,
0.0475641266,
0.0089573674,
-0.0416803174,
0.012639815,
-0.0020921272,
-0.0186413545,
-0.0973117575,
0.0082124984,
0.0510090478,
-0.0052084676,
-0.0152807347,
0.0059530153,
-0.1180127636,
-0.0670849159,
-0.0094689112,
0.0535783358,
0.0163616464,
0.0351895429,
0.0030138751,
0.0300537515,
0.0159971435,
0.0554509163,
-0.0302418359,
-0.0246975143,
0.0369737446,
-0.0440052822,
-0.0107969334,
-0.0001336366,
-0.0019055114,
0.0435856767,
-0.0446030498,
0.0356871448,
-0.017330857,
-0.0132864928,
0.0317840725,
0.0440190695,
0.0644551143,
-0.0047728978,
-0.0007789118,
-0.0313382931,
0.0557128191,
-0.007616275,
-0.0198166072,
-0.0358865783,
0.0091150608,
0.0461126938,
0.0490499847,
-0.0255901031,
-0.0145835821,
0.0212660115,
-0.0433223657,
0.0415131636,
-0.0167404022,
-0.0308797769,
0.024317164,
0.0162649397,
-0.0041759736,
-0.0054246737,
-0.0111652007,
0.0116659524,
-0.0008272037,
-0.0554967821,
0.0437335707,
0.0163913202,
0.0162058566,
-0.0429824926,
0.0871623605,
-0.0447459556,
-0.0476211868,
-0.0269405674,
-0.0007061054,
0.0651347116,
-0.0172174945,
0.0799300894,
-0.0245985258,
0.0089357179,
0.0160416085,
0.0117459102,
0.0238759257,
0.0048422334,
-0.0038947479,
0.0261533875,
0.0324118324,
-0.0159464106,
0.0704731345,
-0.0306818057,
-0.0104556065,
0.0233177748,
-0.0136715947,
-0.0178044233,
0.0009615648,
-0.0080688084,
-0.0404035412,
-0.0113463299,
-0.0021257948,
-0.0011816983,
-0.0322528817,
0.016198609,
0.0046225432,
0.0525198802,
-0.027071273,
0.0341520756,
0.0773386806,
-0.015419187,
-0.0012753676,
-0.0298846606,
-0.0332720801,
0.0571591221,
-0.0344150215,
-0.0288978647,
-6.592891575e-33,
-0.0265859198,
-0.0080630071,
0.033542987,
0.0016686249,
-0.0138538415,
0.0024023475,
-0.0049414039,
-0.0367093757,
-0.0042319684,
-0.0308652017,
-0.035608653,
0.0346082151,
0.0269270893,
-0.0067985468,
-0.001102136,
0.0327714272,
0.0546962246,
-0.0181947276,
-0.0256678201,
0.0155924652,
0.0234345272,
0.037616916,
0.0755150244,
-0.0079706516,
-0.024048375,
0.0015782798,
0.0311591253,
0.0181504544,
-0.0212129653,
0.0111313239,
0.0119574629,
0.0055108401,
0.0508533902,
-0.0750821754,
0.0124339843,
-0.0053401096,
-0.0720808804,
-0.0241165292,
-0.0290163141,
0.0338001214,
-0.0070359283,
-0.0272209067,
0.0467809699,
-0.0300256927,
-0.0184863973,
-0.0178308226,
-0.0126736946,
0.0008996846,
-0.043310836,
0.003795065,
-0.0295511894,
0.0298990812,
0.0104882838,
-0.0182798672,
0.0530588441,
0.0280538984,
-0.0351278186,
-0.0174188819,
-0.089687556,
0.0360843129,
0.0148963798,
0.0763248578,
0.0211122874,
0.0380607881,
-0.0181932244,
0.0011264612,
0.0764404088,
0.0053555439,
0.0469224602,
0.0233571697,
0.0263561271,
-0.0002333257,
0.0493109524,
-0.0300744921,
0.0731394812,
-0.0234434679,
-0.0497133583,
0.0373993106,
-0.0018183551,
0.0256769378,
0.0112127839,
0.0017565164,
-0.051805526,
-0.0095729735,
-0.0021728473,
-0.0445961319,
-0.0274634194,
-0.0212712921,
0.0131063862,
0.0332335941,
-0.0528510064,
-0.0416355692,
0.0496820286,
-0.0030929972,
0.0189761836,
0.0281348098,
-0.0152582303,
0.0249057729,
-0.027322799,
0.0440397784,
-0.0423557907,
-0.0486146174,
0.0107125426,
0.0272003449,
-0.0001545308,
-0.0053742183,
0.0429232083,
0.0212780032,
-0.0527341105,
-0.0200456902,
-0.0348130688,
0.0102407811,
-0.0308570303,
0.0209296457,
0.018438302,
0.0234457552,
0.0165336225,
0.0326915979,
0.0194442421,
-0.0213211775,
-0.0525312982,
0.0319329835,
0.0333418921,
0.0223719832,
-0.0145854633,
0.0351391844,
-0.0214952864,
0.038634114,
0.0535596646,
-0.0889539644,
-0.0623122379,
0.0345005393,
2.992e-7,
-0.0013963266,
0.0522086918,
0.0155680431,
0.0190477315,
0.0333224982,
0.006659938,
-0.0434966087,
0.0339321904,
0.0123447562,
0.0602949485,
0.0678454563,
0.0183943715,
0.0412509181,
0.0223157946,
-0.1076061353,
-0.0186198317,
-0.0509140976,
0.0123010455,
-0.0321074873,
-0.0197618529,
0.0235214513,
0.1098541394,
-0.0536221974,
0.0074356124,
-0.0305570662,
-0.0304701887,
0.0481833853,
0.0125383735,
0.016666105,
-0.0078623323,
0.0757389516,
-0.0047047217,
-0.0196082536,
-0.0207584538,
-0.0085175354,
0.0202305671,
0.0511328317,
0.0542125367,
-0.0192496218,
0.0049434644,
0.066411823,
0.0097524701,
-0.0447253697,
-0.0175795183,
0.0195403546,
-0.0582927316,
-0.0034656178,
0.0368393399,
-0.0058712508,
0.018274026,
-0.0059117726,
0.0065924474,
-0.027352348,
0.0259389319,
0.0444976576,
-0.0415033251,
0.0266053267,
-0.0124635985,
-0.0143698351,
0.0000466942,
-0.0325859822,
-0.0392557457,
-0.0343839042,
-0.0254127923,
-0.0008419979,
0.0222622044,
-0.0427038372,
2.737635885e-34,
0.0204707887,
0.0054305303,
0.0328988247,
0.0000472451,
0.0208834782,
-0.0223216303,
-0.0220684595,
-0.0038243358,
-0.0558859147,
-0.0607577339,
-0.0686404407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08147v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08147v1 | MDDial: A Multi-turn Differential Diagnosis Dialogue Dataset with Reliability Evaluation | 2023-08-16T04:56:55 | 2023-08-16T04:56:55 | Srija Macherla, Man Luo, Mihir Parmar, Chitta Baral | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue systems for Automatic Differential Diagnosis (ADD) have a wide range
of real-life applications. These dialogue systems are promising for providing
easy access and reducing medical costs. Building end-to-end ADD dialogue
systems requires dialogue training datasets. However, to the best of our
knowledge, there is no publicly available ADD dialogue dataset in English
(although non-English datasets exist). Driven by this, we introduce MDDial, the
first differential diagnosis dialogue dataset in English which can aid to build
and evaluate end-to-end ADD dialogue systems. Additionally, earlier studies
present the accuracy of diagnosis and symptoms either individually or as a
combined weighted score. This method overlooks the connection between the
symptoms and the diagnosis. We introduce a unified score for the ADD system
that takes into account the interplay between symptoms and diagnosis. This
score also indicates the system's reliability. To the end, we train two
moderate-size of language models on MDDial. Our experiments suggest that while
these language models can perform well on many natural language understanding
tasks, including dialogue tasks in the general domain, they struggle to relate
relevant symptoms and disease and thus have poor performance on MDDial. MDDial
will be released publicly to aid the study of ADD dialogue research. | [
0.035751123,
0.0672080815,
-0.0118279364,
0.0264308155,
0.0075680725,
0.0296321232,
0.0168801956,
0.0214008074,
0.0275143515,
-0.003733275,
-0.0189771466,
-0.0378018208,
-0.0006796485,
0.0622646511,
0.0095607257,
-0.059950076,
0.0348889455,
-0.0010744011,
0.0265530441,
0.0013238959,
0.0102846753,
0.0073027574,
-0.0708006322,
0.0529406928,
0.0050655757,
-0.0253743567,
0.0045776377,
-0.001609229,
0.0628953651,
-0.068132408,
0.0019632427,
0.0366273113,
-0.0047839391,
0.0109211942,
0.0000019778,
-0.0403206646,
0.0156380739,
-0.0147022624,
-0.0603121296,
-0.0539118759,
-0.0035300567,
0.0047169784,
0.0451784134,
0.0271880161,
-0.0358594954,
-0.0661272481,
0.0398844816,
0.0577450208,
0.0902599841,
0.0646045506,
-0.0088027902,
0.00121,
0.029081434,
-0.0170556046,
-0.0077808285,
-0.0379402153,
0.0354634076,
0.0589042529,
0.0430083387,
-0.033779297,
0.00368547,
0.0132245161,
0.0000414347,
-0.001715667,
-0.0344173349,
0.041260127,
-0.00479064,
-0.02665608,
-0.0001282782,
0.121792376,
0.0120497113,
0.0008376163,
0.0220163465,
-0.0104550226,
0.01215983,
-0.0249959473,
-0.0344300866,
-0.0288402941,
-0.0299326461,
-0.0058311266,
0.020503344,
-0.0013448874,
0.0019078734,
-0.0330664106,
-0.0125002097,
0.0168993454,
-0.0073713469,
-0.0233760457,
-0.0005219257,
-0.03094179,
-0.0189238712,
-0.0495092906,
0.046199441,
0.0047535156,
-0.0690818056,
0.0077303047,
-0.0177310314,
-0.0309476443,
0.0717776939,
-0.0533317365,
0.0163905565,
0.0111846179,
-0.0282697156,
0.0061993138,
0.0101171853,
0.0388908088,
-0.0092528211,
0.0178873558,
-0.0308096483,
0.0188745931,
-0.0435214601,
-0.0024743495,
-0.0654823631,
-0.0180945676,
0.0050466848,
-0.0109599093,
-0.0570143275,
0.0144927353,
0.0050215339,
0.0242837276,
0.0423897244,
0.0437174886,
0.0018260466,
0.0252768509,
-0.0122409947,
0.0278740823,
-0.0158844478,
0.0206383932,
0.0418011509,
-0.0381495096,
-0.0147568053,
0.0039832364,
-0.0068726814,
-0.0086506158,
0.0121896891,
0.0729611591,
-0.0058254432,
0.0036604684,
0.021253949,
-0.0147305802,
-0.068675667,
-0.0363424271,
-0.0411086865,
-0.0597721897,
0.0274555739,
0.0333699286,
0.0187927708,
-0.0448427312,
0.0287084617,
0.0038210424,
-0.0119806593,
0.0546835773,
-0.053198047,
0.0112018986,
0.0284932218,
0.0282229669,
-0.0090463497,
0.0164499339,
0.0046496657,
-0.045930624,
0.0163876619,
-0.0237878133,
0.0387280583,
0.0252332333,
0.0456312895,
0.0197395366,
0.0121646924,
0.0336546935,
-0.0222560745,
0.0688138083,
-0.0048982883,
0.0564545691,
0.0036125453,
-0.025263872,
0.0425082855,
0.0396347903,
0.0263777021,
-0.0313997343,
-0.0014753408,
0.0071557341,
-0.0081199873,
-0.0215719528,
0.0025134766,
-0.0271385256,
0.0244572703,
-0.0161605924,
0.0155464625,
-0.0270329192,
-0.02640488,
-0.0560894571,
-0.0683049262,
0.0132796131,
-0.0013894887,
0.0297484342,
0.0117052579,
-0.0092162993,
-0.0001397858,
0.0692362636,
0.0281576887,
-0.0272652395,
-0.0567679964,
-0.0789000988,
-0.0121200131,
0.0663674846,
0.0117615256,
-0.0185479447,
-0.0810582191,
-0.0298777986,
-0.0036037883,
-0.0095648542,
0.0126648769,
-0.0143910972,
0.0410295054,
-0.037901137,
0.0071917046,
0.0329505801,
0.0090610432,
-0.0217737481,
-0.0335513204,
0.0031741159,
-0.0350414105,
-0.0175831802,
-0.0423622429,
0.0290760305,
-0.0139044942,
-0.0212690104,
0.0221985988,
-0.000076874,
0.0557320155,
-0.0044730362,
-0.0260748174,
-0.0139471581,
-0.0012866576,
-0.0030741165,
-0.0520878807,
0.0607296638,
-0.0405838676,
-0.0870123729,
0.026413884,
0.011640572,
-0.0451438837,
-0.014231002,
-0.053552445,
-0.052061785,
-0.0298411977,
-0.0832399353,
-0.0339123309,
0.0068387762,
-0.0047469288,
0.0756799355,
0.0201861579,
-0.0203530565,
0.0277731754,
-0.0267696586,
0.0051221461,
-0.0028992321,
0.0135947028,
0.0370525047,
-0.0798608065,
-0.0391197391,
0.0018848649,
-0.0193246044,
0.0182185527,
-0.0198770706,
-0.0052700364,
-0.0360917561,
-0.015793344,
-0.1238539219,
-0.0190162472,
0.006512281,
-0.0294083394,
0.0334651321,
0.0383063741,
-0.0252958052,
-0.0411501825,
-0.0525759272,
-0.0045891101,
0.0834489018,
0.0185790695,
0.0492619462,
0.058025118,
-0.0186208673,
-0.0393004119,
-0.0040064389,
-0.0390117578,
0.0072145602,
-0.0061861561,
-0.0082011493,
-0.0218823999,
-0.0324164815,
-0.0354945101,
0.011210327,
-0.0108573223,
-0.0505379066,
-0.0189100262,
-0.0123352408,
-0.0261925552,
0.0551767386,
0.0085340142,
0.0264571551,
0.0176980533,
-0.0159435496,
-0.0589516088,
0.0407483615,
-0.0159730203,
-0.0043249493,
0.0078731198,
-0.055881355,
-0.0201094374,
0.1072387323,
0.0433665551,
0.0150188357,
-0.0221334845,
-0.0099709183,
0.0037902347,
-0.0149068115,
-0.0398274176,
-0.0137316342,
-0.0241643563,
0.0458826013,
-0.0120039312,
-0.0606622845,
0.1099607646,
-0.0282071084,
0.0075677233,
-0.0884878412,
-0.0496887267,
-0.0126185091,
0.0189434402,
-0.0254766885,
0.0211657863,
0.0295317173,
-0.0365314931,
0.0404857136,
0.0128432,
0.0151733691,
-0.0547852777,
0.0789798424,
-0.0470349193,
0.0277032293,
0.0169404466,
-0.0551724657,
-0.0660598502,
-0.0270459726,
-0.026538467,
-0.0205892995,
-0.0230056178,
-0.0138325887,
-0.0386772305,
0.025312189,
-0.0160299428,
0.0880118832,
0.0205629151,
0.0044956794,
0.0180413872,
-0.0218168162,
0.019107759,
0.0223979987,
-0.0045140423,
-0.045039054,
0.0444732197,
0.0160182174,
0.0022410934,
0.0081142103,
-0.0053469525,
-0.002906441,
-0.0224391222,
0.0122350268,
-0.0124986134,
0.0142173059,
0.0156520288,
-0.0389790945,
-0.0402487256,
0.0966218933,
0.001748734,
-0.0533563942,
0.0001258366,
-0.0189951435,
-0.0065499418,
-0.0289553516,
-0.0051974929,
-0.1121940017,
-0.0441825539,
-0.0049046632,
0.0370468237,
-0.0141972154,
-0.0250948183,
0.0154546341,
-0.0094570275,
0.0187755283,
-0.0214480963,
-0.0292521454,
-0.0091911843,
-0.0099182911,
-0.0191438571,
-0.0192589797,
0.0402714796,
-0.03781363,
0.0203391835,
-0.0044301758,
0.0023930485,
-0.0621978082,
-0.0602563508,
0.0459394157,
0.0167359747,
0.043382369,
0.0681496263,
0.0243195575,
0.0278591476,
-0.0150242299,
0.0200939514,
0.0016944752,
0.0209010579,
0.0030748167,
0.0895818248,
0.0109286578,
-0.0172307175,
-0.0533753149,
0.0591697879,
-0.0434715226,
0.0115833478,
0.0165891014,
0.0679410398,
-0.0499065779,
0.0038894638,
-0.0437628031,
0.0226059798,
0.0651884377,
0.0338429362,
0.006624016,
-0.0138545381,
-0.0225888751,
0.0254875384,
0.0296866093,
0.0120047824,
-0.0055038049,
0.0157328602,
-0.003504162,
-0.0427998751,
-0.068253234,
-0.0188449193,
0.0075459848,
0.0036287261,
0.0127881011,
-0.0073332735,
-0.0116410879,
0.0471181981,
-0.0385952294,
0.0802956447,
0.0670198873,
0.029163206,
-0.086697571,
-0.0248310268,
0.0521775894,
0.033300139,
-0.0296334531,
0.0438552871,
-0.0447885096,
-0.0194910765,
0.0296384674,
0.026107287,
0.0239312109,
0.019539455,
-0.0186687764,
-0.0261019208,
-0.0116062537,
-0.0133519508,
-0.0092997635,
-0.0137738483,
0.053656254,
0.0313628651,
-0.0104384217,
0.0193177294,
-0.0259127337,
0.0285065528,
-0.0026829974,
0.0129443621,
-0.0448733419,
-0.0403848141,
0.0409730263,
0.0073884609,
0.0655952916,
-0.0026198924,
-0.0315428935,
-0.0407123305,
0.0500302017,
-0.0057346155,
-0.0173633471,
-0.0248133335,
0.0392469987,
0.0265321154,
-0.0567961596,
-0.0130936615,
-0.0184145793,
-0.0833769143,
-0.0304705221,
-0.040475063,
0.0538767129,
0.0688548684,
-0.001843743,
0.0644773468,
-0.0178851467,
-0.0048069111,
0.0098217111,
0.0255817939,
0.009537369,
0.0275200736,
0.090725936,
0.0111196395,
0.0075894645,
0.0513816923,
0.0396846235,
-0.0359392464,
-0.0445873402,
-0.0100668492,
-0.0024550944,
0.0223958343,
0.0232618116,
0.0365114585,
-0.0027352266,
0.0166306216,
-0.0095999911,
0.0002530561,
-0.0096462164,
0.0036959976,
0.0490887165,
0.0028019217,
0.0009022651,
-0.0027076963,
0.064343825,
-0.0338665545,
0.0256333202,
-0.0161575992,
0.0035630385,
-0.0597133264,
-0.0217337254,
-0.0019483756,
0.0278826114,
-0.0450271107,
0.0120268948,
-0.0358601585,
-0.0613251626,
-0.0054334761,
-0.0074987677,
-0.0136441449,
0.0000071955,
0.0413939804,
0.0224347096,
0.0252661835,
-0.0346572548,
-0.0087009165,
0.063218005,
-0.0271430332,
-0.0040362673,
-0.0240830071,
-5.506854548e-33,
-0.0138320727,
-0.0069523528,
0.010661046,
-0.0083112922,
0.0277524274,
0.0236790907,
-0.040887475,
0.0295373257,
-0.0276911668,
0.0692313761,
-0.0204192568,
0.0412835814,
0.0114933047,
0.0450651608,
0.0016968213,
-0.0336131118,
0.0560829304,
0.022598682,
-0.0477419645,
0.0416021422,
0.0364872813,
0.022838708,
0.0213475823,
-0.0898357853,
0.0274653472,
-0.0235686712,
0.0081042238,
0.0320148356,
-0.0262291897,
0.0507591106,
-0.007578393,
0.0542876571,
0.0483773015,
0.0223988779,
-0.0491048433,
0.0153602641,
-0.0701307654,
-0.0144281127,
0.0092518749,
-0.0071238107,
-0.00679295,
0.0045954413,
0.031962797,
-0.0169236176,
-0.0003193352,
0.0010757152,
0.025209032,
-0.0346558802,
0.0266925525,
-0.0063687861,
0.009420041,
0.0429486372,
-0.0161664896,
-0.0464181714,
-0.0269030649,
0.0534097925,
-0.0303903446,
-0.0260177236,
-0.0028594031,
0.0175510142,
0.0212092344,
0.009525965,
0.0220026281,
-0.0257168449,
-0.0336911939,
0.0540253408,
0.0523847826,
-0.0241099335,
-0.0356933139,
-0.0083835963,
-0.063839443,
0.041159302,
0.0630786046,
0.0256046914,
0.0038485916,
0.0050099748,
-0.0532721914,
0.0152075468,
-0.0522857085,
0.0561901927,
0.0045680464,
-0.0154690631,
-0.077881515,
-0.0295673888,
-0.0480310768,
0.048290845,
-0.02420968,
-0.0231260564,
0.0608362295,
0.0020639119,
0.0298966467,
-0.0397501141,
0.0199504048,
-0.0032773197,
-0.0062178136,
-0.0028596283,
0.0506937504,
-0.0040549086,
-0.0243020616,
0.0136658149,
-0.0461063534,
-0.00306792,
0.0262087472,
0.0187068637,
0.0601937175,
0.0014878643,
0.0057551675,
-0.0415052362,
-0.0377560109,
0.0139696421,
0.0055828504,
0.0423902385,
-0.0451467223,
0.0847215429,
0.0135980137,
0.0251663309,
-0.0457423106,
0.0922214836,
-0.0338947438,
-0.0105829099,
-0.0474365465,
-0.0253347382,
-0.0062734764,
0.0181454867,
-0.0631340221,
-0.0154284406,
-0.0216498841,
0.009101036,
0.0260605048,
-0.0566908233,
0.0083405208,
-0.0023365177,
2.619e-7,
0.0622540675,
0.0426248759,
0.0492996313,
-0.0081465701,
0.0209360234,
0.0256932415,
-0.0123557402,
0.0288446341,
0.022625396,
-0.0092632007,
-0.0066028368,
0.0034236091,
0.0298958775,
0.0434262194,
-0.0260329433,
-0.0392255224,
-0.1009045467,
0.0020222687,
-0.0183209423,
-0.0096325641,
0.0669581592,
0.0917251781,
-0.0480691008,
-0.0131606739,
0.0423275679,
-0.0211460106,
0.0303716771,
-0.0227295943,
0.0085356198,
0.0303696506,
0.0402552225,
-0.0076281112,
0.0242064819,
0.0714052618,
-0.0281280633,
0.0007986961,
-0.0180691835,
0.0638184249,
-0.0405038744,
-0.0363999009,
-0.0088704564,
-0.0251565427,
0.0250759739,
-0.0560831204,
0.0311737861,
-0.0669709146,
-0.0144718755,
0.0059488928,
0.0004044441,
-0.0456360169,
0.0821894631,
-0.0372235291,
-0.0103616919,
0.0383733213,
0.0227339678,
0.0307665989,
-0.0017567301,
-0.1066102013,
-0.0453472994,
0.0319182575,
-0.0339887664,
-0.0276070368,
0.0350532532,
-0.0476218872,
-0.0072798938,
-0.0624704733,
0.0036015422,
2.105131303e-34,
0.0235107075,
0.0190423746,
-0.0090454854,
0.0386384353,
0.0248582996,
-0.0491441563,
0.031430155,
0.0277840532,
0.0438653864,
-0.0704562515,
-0.0394513234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08125v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08125v1 | Radio2Text: Streaming Speech Recognition Using mmWave Radio Signals | 2023-08-16T03:31:30 | 2023-08-16T03:31:30 | Running Zhao, Jiangtao Yu, Hang Zhao, Edith C. H. Ngai | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.HC, eess.AS | Millimeter wave (mmWave) based speech recognition provides more possibility
for audio-related applications, such as conference speech transcription and
eavesdropping. However, considering the practicality in real scenarios, latency
and recognizable vocabulary size are two critical factors that cannot be
overlooked. In this paper, we propose Radio2Text, the first mmWave-based system
for streaming automatic speech recognition (ASR) with a vocabulary size
exceeding 13,000 words. Radio2Text is based on a tailored streaming Transformer
that is capable of effectively learning representations of speech-related
features, paving the way for streaming ASR with a large vocabulary. To
alleviate the deficiency of streaming networks unable to access entire future
inputs, we propose the Guidance Initialization that facilitates the transfer of
feature knowledge related to the global context from the non-streaming
Transformer to the tailored streaming Transformer through weight inheritance.
Further, we propose a cross-modal structure based on knowledge distillation
(KD), named cross-modal KD, to mitigate the negative effect of low quality
mmWave signals on recognition performance. In the cross-modal KD, the audio
streaming Transformer provides feature and response guidance that inherit
fruitful and accurate speech information to supervise the training of the
tailored radio streaming Transformer. The experimental results show that our
Radio2Text can achieve a character error rate of 5.7% and a word error rate of
9.4% for the recognition of a vocabulary consisting of over 13,000 words. | [
-0.039288383,
0.007637037,
0.0215592403,
-0.0050333086,
-0.0007098887,
-0.0118558072,
0.0275582783,
-0.0113951126,
-0.033950109,
-0.0015596643,
-0.0263812486,
-0.0302393418,
-0.0017115937,
0.0271902494,
0.0010510109,
-0.0099399677,
0.0026384101,
-0.0703519806,
-0.0416356251,
-0.0428841971,
0.0274749137,
-0.0207456946,
-0.0425624922,
-0.0132834408,
0.0023151259,
0.0522378497,
-0.0183259565,
-0.0141564785,
0.0129050724,
-0.0248025991,
-0.0362024829,
-0.0311875418,
0.068794772,
0.0376610346,
0.0000019941,
0.0216511581,
-0.0241570808,
-0.0362438187,
-0.0593724065,
-0.0160696115,
0.0435967259,
-0.0487863831,
-0.0443990789,
0.0387861282,
0.0046013608,
-0.0454555564,
0.020179959,
0.0839887857,
0.0405410267,
0.0529790409,
0.0015967822,
-0.0507620201,
0.0318633467,
-0.026825875,
-0.0042725103,
-0.0262455586,
-0.0477872454,
0.0120552164,
-0.0226749405,
0.0284533426,
0.0144485561,
0.083702445,
-0.0035724726,
0.0311024748,
0.0332908481,
-0.0136432676,
-0.0482882783,
-0.0081700534,
-0.0249634441,
0.0243390296,
0.0288051106,
-0.0730867535,
0.0395492315,
0.0075480724,
-0.030645771,
0.0231938343,
-0.0102400612,
-0.0010577085,
-0.0141505226,
-0.0068926457,
-0.0440074429,
-0.0007499183,
0.035853114,
-0.0131098386,
-0.0414868779,
0.0164996143,
-0.0067456258,
-0.0304871947,
0.0258753635,
-0.0381355397,
-0.0090012401,
-0.0151605159,
0.0479567572,
0.0005497931,
-0.0120094363,
-0.009691257,
-0.0557906218,
-0.0130486097,
-0.0292855967,
-0.0353158563,
0.0313557722,
0.0523636267,
0.0194314998,
-0.0103537133,
-0.0224907473,
0.0234371051,
-0.0458110049,
-0.0459263846,
-0.0679610074,
-0.0170517452,
-0.0549128242,
-0.019808203,
-0.0238178,
0.0419710279,
0.0224094577,
-0.0738425702,
-0.0390425511,
-0.0018686422,
0.0368443653,
-0.0201056246,
0.0267993677,
-0.0022565387,
-0.0644475445,
-0.0075944643,
0.0235400703,
0.0810746178,
0.0166586954,
0.0434010215,
-0.0064569507,
-0.0645015463,
-0.0312132351,
0.0023532314,
0.0418804809,
0.0449501052,
-0.0279564392,
0.0250493847,
-0.0320638567,
-0.0240058359,
0.0194667783,
0.0148022575,
0.0181624908,
0.0052822973,
0.0686465204,
-0.070446521,
0.0142624164,
0.0238817185,
0.0067085829,
0.0170071255,
0.0380957983,
-0.0202370137,
0.0049845809,
0.0692735389,
-0.0091330605,
0.0040973653,
0.0801683888,
0.0287133418,
-0.018773919,
0.0445960611,
0.0454313755,
0.0038713813,
-0.0194217451,
-0.0408554189,
-0.021393558,
0.0192515254,
0.0260648392,
0.0028280565,
-0.0259056352,
-0.0484219678,
-0.0064746249,
0.0281863157,
0.0146196894,
0.0068819346,
-0.0328919478,
0.0447106734,
0.0753788054,
0.0282576662,
0.0657741576,
0.0286140181,
0.0042571416,
0.0508260392,
-0.019473346,
-0.0076916344,
0.0311199781,
0.0205265004,
-0.0347662196,
-0.0129713407,
-0.0002943889,
0.0688522682,
-0.0188621525,
-0.0192171484,
0.0184717663,
-0.0295973141,
-0.0056589935,
0.0309376754,
0.0301825181,
0.0054409793,
0.0067957323,
0.0658562332,
0.0124418167,
-0.0319658779,
-0.0047214674,
-0.0064061354,
-0.0045803813,
0.0358656719,
-0.0000071862,
-0.0461059846,
-0.0034479345,
-0.0015559726,
0.0273306947,
-0.0241986476,
0.0244289562,
0.0100459903,
0.0558806174,
-0.0198840462,
-0.0276247952,
0.0523071364,
0.0101764295,
0.0513500869,
-0.0144942924,
0.0673362687,
0.0178283844,
0.0170938764,
0.0099412408,
-0.019510068,
0.0205146596,
-0.0445534065,
0.0102659967,
0.0164253041,
0.0398789048,
-0.0118069826,
-0.0212781802,
-0.0061518042,
0.0307257865,
-0.0546259806,
-0.0037711055,
0.0065129814,
-0.100084573,
0.0108051235,
0.0009964824,
-0.033332672,
0.0711010396,
0.0547505133,
0.0358346812,
-0.0765159577,
0.0184833594,
-0.0157602765,
0.0804610923,
-0.00609119,
0.0420780554,
0.0312036872,
0.0121417092,
0.0400385596,
-0.0025032198,
0.0111768693,
-0.007109894,
-0.0761541128,
-0.0330717787,
-0.0175040998,
-0.0051361783,
-0.0426626876,
0.0393715724,
-0.0008461531,
0.0156889334,
-0.0151719972,
-0.0273769889,
-0.0074928249,
-0.0243277755,
-0.037492305,
0.0068813027,
-0.0521773025,
0.0239724386,
0.0216050558,
0.0652225018,
0.0227767732,
-0.0407333523,
-0.0351775177,
-0.0057931491,
0.0217594765,
-0.0172081068,
-0.0529303588,
0.0100581674,
-0.0074332822,
0.0353716835,
-0.0301582739,
0.0397796109,
-0.0129901059,
-0.0398379453,
-0.0206545517,
-0.0581635982,
-0.0041782707,
0.031503167,
0.0328424312,
-0.0344795659,
0.0043973918,
0.0341277495,
0.0150811765,
0.0010213385,
0.0512072407,
0.050070975,
-0.01677927,
0.0282915216,
-0.02107911,
-0.0430572815,
-0.0002919113,
0.0042902785,
0.0267462488,
-0.030411534,
0.0792965963,
-0.0271618608,
0.0030789012,
-0.015179188,
0.0541629903,
0.0130160106,
-0.0380315706,
0.01784187,
-0.0419281125,
-0.0080478732,
-0.045990929,
-0.0093919039,
-0.0236467998,
0.0239293855,
-0.0279562511,
-0.0143886786,
-0.0609130189,
-0.027386209,
-0.0383596569,
-0.0521455258,
0.0191323571,
-0.0206756089,
-0.0157606676,
0.0171228573,
-0.0054742461,
-0.0085210353,
0.0012515606,
-0.0166613813,
0.0021368023,
-0.0658458993,
0.016607549,
-0.0466115661,
-0.0211094059,
-0.0222593863,
-0.0004538886,
-0.0203131866,
0.0294576101,
0.0035682751,
0.0095591806,
0.0019710064,
0.0128300413,
-0.0567848571,
0.0308673736,
0.0419151112,
0.047929965,
-0.0001901353,
0.0187647399,
-0.0712520331,
0.0962675437,
-0.008862461,
0.0298529789,
0.018613752,
0.0368887037,
0.04147866,
-0.0042159217,
0.08241418,
-0.0053099217,
-0.0230255034,
0.0342678614,
0.0182135664,
-0.0075149699,
-0.0361870117,
0.0362454429,
0.0835284293,
-0.0605796799,
0.0275485665,
0.0497995503,
0.0090149418,
-0.034754429,
-0.0420410186,
0.0510832295,
0.0096135018,
0.0049618795,
0.0001364597,
0.007694154,
0.0008418979,
0.0466722734,
0.0350613557,
0.0079032732,
0.0167883504,
-0.0265281498,
-0.035876926,
-0.0094403606,
0.0489839502,
0.0051775128,
-0.0447703041,
-0.0332841054,
-0.0607030503,
0.0059537804,
0.0343918093,
-0.0212230571,
-0.0363213532,
-0.0270723347,
0.0282157306,
-0.0419003405,
-0.0898708329,
-0.0050884327,
-0.03830887,
0.0745474696,
0.011886145,
0.0007824053,
-0.0178211648,
-0.0690142959,
-0.0166833512,
-0.0094492333,
0.0073798024,
0.0094912695,
-0.0089695165,
-0.016008867,
-0.0079923272,
0.0120644933,
0.0128829237,
0.0142068341,
-0.0116484584,
-0.0094081024,
0.0387406386,
-0.0291591026,
-0.0087947203,
0.0507032163,
0.0150717925,
0.0350704975,
0.028596418,
-0.0128634674,
0.0155981537,
-0.0037448327,
0.0190205388,
0.0236879364,
0.0106485505,
-0.0350900367,
0.0176790785,
0.0112829786,
-0.0678224564,
-0.0125436913,
0.0151433507,
0.0151461344,
0.0247163828,
0.0243200772,
0.0295470711,
0.0772794783,
0.0495092869,
-0.0567451268,
-0.0234279688,
-0.0047091525,
0.0147508951,
-0.0214140043,
-0.0507042408,
0.0263317674,
-0.0596028343,
0.0106131723,
0.0266538486,
-0.1293242276,
0.0020013065,
0.020916516,
-0.0125726881,
0.0237006135,
0.064366743,
-0.0394981615,
0.0055545322,
0.1157960072,
0.0092767924,
-0.1239949018,
0.0135610681,
0.0441575386,
-0.0282419845,
0.0029183901,
0.0374625959,
-0.0304082427,
0.0554802455,
-0.0239240322,
-0.0139590073,
-0.033083234,
0.0506660417,
0.0094972542,
-0.0040710885,
-0.0292037372,
-0.0037837746,
0.039101515,
-0.01564903,
0.0607701652,
-0.0151683167,
0.0553233474,
-0.02704647,
0.0586181581,
0.0242052935,
0.0420324616,
0.0159251131,
-0.0061337589,
0.0516610704,
-0.0553752705,
0.0050865379,
0.0808475912,
0.0296550803,
-0.0189298838,
0.0283830408,
-0.0010872163,
-0.0063894494,
0.0040587448,
0.0435930267,
0.0025990242,
-0.0689865425,
0.0076490007,
0.0088434275,
0.0152891846,
-0.0416499451,
0.0516181439,
-0.0620246902,
-0.0748600587,
-0.0006741002,
0.1012636945,
0.0104276389,
-0.0009440985,
0.0050589098,
0.0016834856,
0.0097164521,
-0.0214446839,
0.0016987191,
-0.0285373367,
0.031661246,
0.0339835174,
0.0375899188,
-0.0033796616,
0.0564618222,
0.0021488243,
-0.0114222392,
0.0342687964,
-0.0225392245,
0.0129914787,
-0.0627758801,
-0.0357078575,
0.0165819637,
0.0272747595,
-0.0514906161,
-0.0098249782,
0.0132329622,
-0.046555385,
0.0446048714,
-0.0505037978,
0.0108363125,
-0.107253924,
-0.000771219,
0.0088239126,
-0.0261794031,
0.0245036632,
0.0391367786,
-0.0427530333,
0.013725006,
0.0070526525,
0.0405160263,
-6.154348796e-33,
-0.0353623442,
0.0632040948,
-0.0169535819,
0.0028321261,
-0.042886503,
0.0171096362,
0.0013014916,
-0.0037575024,
0.0144167477,
-0.0820992067,
-0.0443942361,
0.0412143208,
0.0425585918,
0.0027106798,
0.0045667007,
-0.0173961613,
0.084151566,
-0.0471508317,
-0.0046643703,
0.0103931297,
0.0314378887,
0.0574176908,
0.0110299988,
-0.019257335,
-0.0675207451,
0.0033150588,
-0.0211695451,
-0.0684555992,
-0.0111898696,
0.0284665972,
-0.0441246964,
0.0126292203,
0.0083392821,
-0.0515887886,
-0.0097992243,
0.0549987927,
-0.0671603456,
0.0449950807,
-0.0474289432,
0.0345364735,
0.0148297139,
-0.0040626023,
0.0400942042,
0.0318103172,
-0.0494428873,
0.0230454337,
-0.0101804119,
0.0019012603,
-0.0512254164,
-0.0425938256,
0.0089172572,
0.0099013979,
-0.0044380808,
-0.0307340529,
0.0404269509,
-0.0447468944,
-0.0485969745,
-0.0168265924,
-0.0676236376,
0.0273536891,
0.0304990783,
0.0661314055,
-0.0220887512,
0.0230902806,
0.004920016,
0.0388974361,
0.0084197922,
-0.063149415,
0.0195652414,
-0.0124965375,
0.0370994546,
0.0275440104,
-0.0289587509,
0.0163201783,
0.1083613783,
-0.086875014,
-0.0091624893,
-0.0345213823,
0.0160813909,
0.0552021749,
-0.0077931024,
0.0076332605,
-0.0013307967,
0.036709372,
-0.0407884717,
-0.039327547,
-0.0301003363,
0.0045349482,
0.0231247228,
0.0639088973,
-0.0364879109,
-0.0110564362,
0.0535216369,
-0.0348555297,
0.0349171758,
0.0069996607,
0.0074817417,
-0.0061534313,
-0.0146855973,
-0.0065590404,
-0.049093321,
-0.0333560035,
0.0578558519,
-0.0379994996,
-0.0037455421,
-0.0095455591,
0.0251554009,
0.0933526754,
-0.0761665255,
-0.0036859997,
-0.0261792205,
0.0063533424,
0.0257213656,
0.0385277383,
0.0501444526,
-0.0350642465,
0.0064869463,
-0.031749215,
-0.0376750641,
-0.0121842008,
-0.01048283,
-0.0415867865,
0.0159832183,
0.0475152396,
-0.0452139117,
0.0416491702,
-0.0316623971,
-0.0092029935,
0.0233976934,
-0.016044924,
-0.0156406127,
0.0194575284,
3.052e-7,
-0.0632334948,
0.0104623158,
0.0409155078,
-0.0750217363,
0.035028372,
-0.0105863968,
-0.0236566197,
0.0344411954,
-0.0063243378,
0.0274682809,
0.0088795749,
0.022638835,
0.0751090869,
0.0506790392,
-0.1248483658,
0.0130910445,
-0.0206680484,
0.0099694757,
-0.0059925565,
-0.015209442,
0.014191974,
0.0752107427,
-0.0155320847,
-0.0207012165,
0.0337848663,
0.0175182465,
0.0273067467,
0.03186699,
0.0307167694,
-0.0532500036,
-0.0032792431,
-0.0261765476,
-0.0816419423,
0.0402384438,
0.0003630092,
0.0165017284,
-0.0128295328,
0.0545020998,
0.0235670414,
-0.0511321612,
-0.0497748256,
0.0226937011,
-0.024091769,
0.0224259607,
0.0409603007,
0.0311479662,
-0.0065786564,
-0.0267297439,
-0.0209573694,
-0.0360983498,
-0.0288568512,
0.0265780818,
0.0419170707,
-0.0047254674,
-0.0237182826,
0.0163016859,
0.0029150457,
-0.0553836003,
0.0309237279,
0.0005531358,
-0.0295937061,
-0.0395237021,
-0.0708183497,
0.0021130836,
0.068255499,
0.0077637462,
-0.0128295198,
2.164254996e-34,
-0.0067764018,
-0.0007262515,
-0.0134447152,
-0.0396205708,
-0.0284477491,
-0.0223608073,
-0.0106853014,
-0.0039936472,
-0.0149631537,
-0.0587347746,
-0.0168673154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08090v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08090v2 | Separate the Wheat from the Chaff: Model Deficiency Unlearning via Parameter-Efficient Module Operation | 2023-08-16T01:46:01 | 2024-01-18T07:23:49 | Xinshuo Hu, Dongfang Li, Baotian Hu, Zihao Zheng, Zhenyu Liu, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have been widely used in various applications
but are known to suffer from issues related to untruthfulness and toxicity.
While parameter-efficient modules (PEMs) have demonstrated their effectiveness
in equipping models with new skills, leveraging PEMs for deficiency unlearning
remains underexplored. In this work, we propose a PEMs operation approach,
namely Extraction-before-Subtraction (Ext-Sub), to enhance the truthfulness and
detoxification of LLMs through the integration of ``expert'' PEM and
``anti-expert'' PEM. Remarkably, even anti-expert PEM possess valuable
capabilities due to their proficiency in generating fabricated content, which
necessitates language modeling and logical narrative competence. Rather than
merely negating the parameters, our approach involves extracting and
eliminating solely the deficiency capability within anti-expert PEM while
preserving the general capabilities. To evaluate the effectiveness of our
approach in terms of truthfulness and detoxification, we conduct extensive
experiments on LLMs, encompassing additional abilities such as language
modeling and mathematical reasoning. Our empirical results demonstrate that our
approach effectively improves truthfulness and detoxification, while largely
preserving the fundamental abilities of LLMs. | [
0.0503574386,
0.085170418,
-0.0463424474,
0.0532204397,
-0.0537786745,
0.0055738231,
-0.0028233335,
-0.0243835356,
0.0067724502,
0.0058632628,
-0.0188085325,
0.0475257151,
0.0083786249,
0.0534228608,
0.02717885,
-0.0160984173,
0.0655836165,
-0.0130994935,
0.0421982557,
-0.0162761156,
0.0124041252,
0.0348746292,
0.0061472286,
-0.0059488653,
-0.0134262769,
-0.0192377027,
-0.0127633456,
-0.0116998954,
0.0038946045,
0.0147902463,
0.0001111703,
0.0445410609,
0.0013118589,
0.0489580631,
0.0000025175,
-0.0172052495,
-0.0454717316,
0.0001577749,
-0.0732435584,
0.0770779029,
0.0647263378,
0.0086335801,
0.0121837845,
0.0113532841,
-0.0449699275,
0.0326747932,
0.0375210345,
0.0351592749,
0.0729086027,
0.0972619429,
-0.0069046663,
0.0220215749,
0.0447197668,
-0.0119789327,
-0.0087475041,
0.0150930583,
0.0432633609,
0.0180609804,
0.0149648599,
-0.0188801028,
0.0094049089,
0.0320410915,
0.0552692786,
0.0084057534,
-0.0123161003,
0.0191074722,
0.0262343381,
-0.0174792893,
-0.0045479443,
0.0221800003,
-0.0298919398,
-0.0420067571,
0.0205094069,
-0.0182463452,
-0.0028124158,
0.0193946827,
-0.0404341631,
0.0276716985,
-0.0277326424,
0.0165863764,
0.0267934743,
-0.0292854365,
0.0390946008,
-0.0007080107,
0.0193237979,
0.0744394735,
0.0292766467,
-0.0307292007,
-0.0320904702,
-0.0261308402,
-0.031728249,
-0.0600552335,
0.0025088668,
0.0219372045,
0.000049954,
0.0567480661,
-0.0441679917,
-0.0150000677,
0.0351981446,
-0.0904837325,
0.018759761,
0.0169728436,
0.0226532016,
0.0355069824,
-0.032189481,
0.0300870501,
0.0091892602,
0.0534590222,
-0.0326181874,
0.017538717,
-0.0204370096,
-0.0459822603,
-0.0191635508,
0.0338742658,
-0.014791321,
0.0158360377,
-0.012577001,
0.0066455835,
-0.0633231103,
-0.0091655031,
-0.0345457867,
0.0233830512,
-0.0132123809,
-0.039788086,
-0.0746782944,
0.0413230397,
-0.0154106067,
0.036547035,
-0.013277078,
-0.0795389935,
-0.0172448084,
0.0135937901,
-0.0226350762,
-0.0082319863,
0.0194086153,
0.0583980493,
-0.0278221034,
0.0080769546,
-0.0637068152,
-0.0298815165,
-0.0008109732,
-0.095472917,
-0.0021759733,
-0.0862162784,
0.0160302278,
-0.0168413632,
-0.0187524632,
-0.088175945,
0.0122839594,
0.0078313267,
-0.0596449561,
0.0051895152,
-0.0162572917,
0.0163794626,
0.0341295153,
0.0260988418,
-0.0146547984,
0.0506678559,
0.0289635211,
0.0394822992,
0.0089002009,
-0.0046266671,
0.0434080511,
0.0280630514,
0.0014868091,
0.0219598264,
-0.0399117582,
-0.0098991618,
0.0195563156,
-0.003656934,
0.0291570891,
0.0360527635,
-0.046859581,
0.0151161728,
0.095345825,
-0.0479368865,
-0.0314336866,
0.0261151474,
0.0650413558,
-0.0018128022,
0.0568328574,
0.0634069368,
-0.0755022094,
0.0153638739,
-0.03642077,
-0.00160985,
0.0031664141,
0.0523276404,
-0.0040182723,
-0.062350031,
0.0256762393,
-0.0168328322,
0.0320299417,
0.0247781891,
0.0126474407,
0.0194401927,
-0.0156074809,
0.0718106031,
0.0603841394,
-0.0577786118,
0.0264445599,
-0.0518719405,
0.0012467438,
0.0392622836,
0.0540997572,
-0.035190966,
-0.0029813957,
0.0042086244,
-0.0230913069,
0.0238062162,
0.0121547719,
0.0053210035,
0.0110661713,
-0.0071606077,
0.0036369325,
-0.0577853918,
0.0420357101,
0.0003393987,
0.0229991637,
-0.0216432698,
0.0211477112,
-0.0578488819,
-0.0262785219,
0.0301552918,
-0.0905391127,
-0.0264020376,
-0.0149340909,
-0.003181376,
-0.0033351886,
-0.02285509,
-0.0037870856,
0.0265107751,
0.0315259062,
0.0017289976,
-0.0372683294,
-0.0079575703,
-0.0509965345,
-0.0135167623,
0.0284660198,
-0.0430556275,
-0.0057066423,
0.0409426317,
0.0061723613,
-0.0103197815,
0.020505283,
-0.0464306474,
0.0467568561,
-0.0483680293,
0.0510714129,
-0.0382045433,
-0.0156248854,
-0.0077095851,
0.0850494429,
-0.0082302094,
0.0110574299,
0.0068903677,
-0.034810178,
0.002149058,
-0.0208141413,
0.0029647483,
-0.0080958996,
0.0251010656,
0.0403528251,
0.027753273,
-0.0155637795,
-0.0458352752,
-0.0526786372,
-0.0669028684,
0.0189820938,
-0.0046885796,
0.0152161093,
0.034128435,
-0.0428800769,
-0.0276129544,
0.0367720462,
-0.0268831737,
-0.0445557125,
0.0130284829,
-0.0081426073,
-0.0108298957,
0.0101301195,
-0.0091445772,
-0.0031031126,
0.0246907938,
-0.0193217099,
0.0244156979,
-0.0159979369,
0.0219533406,
-0.0120622572,
0.0284779258,
-0.060763523,
0.0210447367,
-0.002560376,
-0.0311591458,
-0.0005467854,
0.0010509528,
0.0120556615,
0.0149968108,
-0.0060465992,
0.031177422,
0.0689688399,
0.0000810123,
-0.0217853896,
-0.0021571673,
-0.015407688,
0.0132958395,
-0.0281164013,
-0.0754989311,
-0.0127221495,
0.032880649,
0.0525488332,
0.0128704291,
-0.0270527676,
0.0717519969,
-0.0097978488,
-0.0611502267,
0.0739965066,
-0.0425060764,
-0.0162544474,
0.0039198296,
-0.0382708125,
-0.0436758026,
0.0658722222,
-0.0226710867,
0.0126230661,
-0.033274699,
-0.0100776637,
-0.0032250015,
0.0100743482,
0.0056661894,
0.0303854384,
0.0701250434,
0.0164874308,
-0.0363967828,
-0.0217623096,
0.0349842124,
-0.043789234,
-0.0031499544,
-0.0689509436,
-0.0187081303,
0.0484801866,
-0.021997517,
-0.0691911802,
-0.0414563008,
0.0073800962,
0.0254496802,
-0.0003227643,
-0.0004225213,
-0.0485788025,
-0.0638547763,
0.061296124,
0.0025061024,
-0.0005995533,
0.0068629188,
-0.0249002893,
-0.0130756367,
0.0582942292,
-0.0174080282,
0.0454445817,
-0.0706787854,
0.0435603745,
0.0884818509,
-0.0386212431,
0.0043265461,
-0.0128384167,
0.0003365798,
-0.0215474535,
-0.0041532293,
-0.0061157905,
0.0308764763,
-0.0212085489,
-0.0625676587,
0.0056044688,
0.0875195861,
0.0144899543,
0.0224063192,
0.0237123184,
-0.0147638796,
0.0262853298,
0.0121467449,
0.0160388201,
-0.0787571669,
0.0194616821,
0.0049302704,
-0.003597396,
-0.0648282841,
-0.0420426577,
-0.0259060077,
-0.1145773008,
0.0460337102,
0.0347666666,
0.0036471786,
-0.026705049,
-0.0336654484,
0.0038603912,
0.0103983935,
-0.0085708387,
0.0068075131,
-0.0116842249,
0.0000107121,
0.0039350577,
-0.0428017452,
-0.0230703261,
0.0259242114,
0.0040207915,
0.0358338878,
-0.0121283615,
0.017449256,
-0.0397197306,
-0.0076717641,
-0.022602886,
0.0163501948,
-0.0155111142,
-0.0046193479,
0.0242088549,
-0.0096183354,
-0.0023996516,
-0.0197279844,
0.0326648764,
0.0148852263,
-0.059468437,
-0.0147775905,
0.1075273231,
0.0005709613,
-0.0419190079,
-0.0147208236,
-0.001601718,
0.00858285,
0.0849167332,
0.0214324277,
-0.005636455,
-0.0241092704,
-0.016908763,
-0.0549295694,
0.0218015034,
-0.0481594764,
0.0137517527,
-0.006619893,
-0.0037001106,
-0.0407721289,
-0.0350001305,
0.0182767007,
0.0148773836,
0.009570417,
0.027522048,
0.01438333,
-0.0300795622,
-0.0239744298,
-0.005066365,
-0.0636206642,
0.0264782719,
-0.0014471936,
-0.004532503,
-0.0312008373,
-0.0372335166,
0.0166041534,
0.0027425403,
-0.0708698556,
-0.0850842148,
0.0202460941,
0.0429244339,
0.0319801196,
0.0430168882,
0.0010510618,
-0.0297762267,
0.0259891525,
0.0235247593,
-0.0746523365,
0.0663815215,
0.0350735635,
0.003173538,
0.0102318358,
0.0282041933,
0.0102087511,
0.0146721173,
0.0500707626,
0.0257195756,
-0.0631086975,
-0.0142241409,
0.0555274636,
0.0513502918,
-0.0037102653,
0.0045576859,
0.0180067699,
-0.0490577184,
0.0173618793,
-0.0774737075,
-0.0377092324,
-0.0172312073,
0.0095656263,
0.0250181127,
0.0605243593,
0.0123998029,
-0.0185281709,
-0.008357184,
0.022339398,
0.0106634181,
-0.0192684736,
-0.0086459247,
-0.0310570877,
0.0241407361,
-0.0057302485,
-0.0120989094,
-0.0013533088,
-0.0366188884,
0.0320458487,
-0.0264279377,
0.0364964604,
0.0118034268,
-0.0073034177,
-0.0379897282,
-0.0111728068,
-0.020358542,
-0.0568084233,
-0.0182014797,
0.0499521382,
0.007060898,
0.0029278272,
0.0348051861,
-0.0433657393,
-0.0074396911,
-0.0354009978,
0.0172344297,
0.0229321197,
-0.0176766533,
-0.0018942324,
0.0304300357,
-0.0446148328,
-0.01201599,
0.0408885777,
0.0301681068,
0.0857817978,
-0.0236845054,
-0.0106737241,
-0.0309716258,
-0.0566375703,
0.0182323605,
-0.0338206738,
-0.0171244275,
-0.0082733724,
-0.0822197646,
-0.0655291826,
0.0028001305,
0.0208497047,
0.0006296876,
-0.0491273291,
0.0119096097,
0.0745485723,
-0.0198915508,
-0.013635831,
-0.0494830497,
0.0239558071,
0.0468501113,
-0.0084331995,
-0.0037504693,
-7.212443219e-33,
-0.0139114624,
-0.0281089656,
0.0201889277,
-0.0056429799,
-0.0009381784,
0.0034716595,
-0.0252634063,
0.0138943223,
-0.0182369612,
0.0383356065,
0.0160542633,
-0.0014007249,
0.0066280048,
-0.0310218558,
-0.0391483381,
0.0370794013,
0.0594574586,
0.0125334952,
-0.0494897813,
0.0067678932,
0.0415052772,
-0.0028683573,
0.0632686839,
-0.0893363953,
0.0266888272,
-0.0236436334,
-0.0446621776,
0.0290264599,
-0.0531752072,
0.053127788,
-0.010422742,
0.0364325419,
0.013335377,
-0.0375713259,
-0.0150260478,
-0.0179824661,
-0.0257393159,
0.0081920149,
0.0927424878,
-0.0397456624,
-0.0232312456,
-0.068612501,
0.0555876605,
-0.0122477468,
-0.0001243628,
-0.0203743707,
0.0231234804,
-0.0429445282,
-0.0027922939,
0.0624710061,
-0.0975021422,
0.015291403,
-0.0124636684,
-0.0045871073,
-0.0460662767,
0.0187255628,
-0.021510195,
-0.0282445271,
-0.0370873846,
0.0042276322,
0.0672518834,
0.0119481971,
0.0331983976,
-0.0132450983,
0.0079012718,
0.0713726729,
0.0205233376,
0.0481230281,
-0.0203038231,
0.0199086647,
0.0539233834,
0.0813144296,
0.0651058927,
0.0410267673,
0.0144348741,
-0.0288991556,
-0.0530553237,
-0.0030070855,
0.0007085718,
0.0354323722,
0.023074422,
-0.0032568092,
-0.0103041213,
-0.0251755659,
-0.059707433,
0.021909155,
-0.0328778327,
-0.032217402,
0.0059228903,
0.0116333701,
-0.054512009,
0.0030223767,
-0.0074583469,
-0.0269243941,
0.0284692738,
0.0199217685,
-0.0490252972,
0.0235025492,
0.0005704731,
0.0246532504,
-0.0572405532,
0.01141835,
0.0053410162,
-0.0265754033,
0.0374120809,
-0.0065507414,
0.0199087448,
0.0589715466,
-0.0383546054,
0.0278697889,
-0.056261532,
0.0225750692,
0.0393293984,
0.0033392664,
0.0143435048,
0.011308156,
-0.0197739303,
-0.0549609289,
-0.0022106464,
-0.0234339312,
-0.0892834738,
0.0299486723,
0.0196395107,
0.038509313,
0.0000435218,
-0.0169191323,
-0.0250197928,
-0.0092134699,
0.0593335032,
-0.0585185774,
-0.0048303585,
-0.0093360748,
3.253e-7,
0.0122629348,
0.012708744,
0.0005114758,
0.002047227,
0.0235018656,
0.0498891138,
-0.0317691714,
0.0109049007,
0.031206578,
-0.0600861609,
-0.0069053569,
0.0543904752,
0.0734777451,
0.0320252404,
-0.0324018188,
0.0430550389,
-0.0526991636,
-0.0569146872,
-0.059058439,
-0.0118257189,
0.0424846672,
0.054084871,
0.0589906015,
-0.0283716433,
-0.0201779511,
-0.0306391697,
0.0492363125,
0.0025372966,
-0.0528867617,
0.0419195704,
0.0261969082,
0.0113966204,
0.0037543022,
0.0001513075,
-0.014682305,
0.0060609076,
-0.0065417676,
0.119140327,
-0.0143995592,
-0.0197412297,
0.0008632586,
-0.041791968,
-0.0194328986,
-0.04548271,
0.0774751231,
-0.0117685003,
-0.0197713636,
-0.0661445782,
-0.0514106713,
0.0198470447,
0.0156197082,
-0.0082909986,
-0.0570687875,
0.0324216038,
-0.0009889525,
0.0012252777,
-0.0015171104,
-0.0122146178,
-0.0391506329,
0.0057232087,
-0.0730137229,
-0.0830422193,
-0.0054371376,
0.0106354142,
0.0035496855,
-0.0740327239,
0.0527958125,
3.344064467e-34,
0.0208656862,
-0.0122991614,
0.0334967002,
0.0028944358,
0.0693823323,
0.0210358705,
-0.0378771648,
0.0381147265,
-0.0019096556,
-0.0545100085,
-0.0151714701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.11767v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.11767v4 | Detection of ChatGPT Fake Science with the xFakeSci Learning Algorithm | 2023-08-15T23:22:37 | 2024-04-14T21:20:58 | Ahmed Abdeen Hamed, Xindong Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2.7; F.2; I.7 | Generative AI tools exemplified by ChatGPT are becoming a new reality. This
study is motivated by the premise that ``AI generated content may exhibit a
distinctive behavior that can be separated from scientific articles''. In this
study, we show how articles can be generated using means of prompt engineering
for various diseases and conditions. We then show how we tested this premise in
two phases and prove its validity. Subsequently, we introduce xFakeSci, a novel
learning algorithm, that is capable of distinguishing ChatGPT-generated
articles from publications produced by scientists. The algorithm is trained
using network models driven from both sources. As for the classification step,
it was performed using 300 articles per condition. The actual label steps took
place against an equal mix of 50 generated articles and 50 authentic PubMed
abstracts. The testing also spanned publication periods from 2010 to 2024 and
encompassed research on three distinct diseases: cancer, depression, and
Alzheimer's. Further, we evaluated the accuracy of the xFakeSci algorithm
against some of the classical data mining algorithms (e.g., Support Vector
Machines, Regression, and Naive Bayes). The xFakeSci algorithm achieved F1
scores ranging from 80% to 94%, outperforming common data mining algorithms,
which scored F1 values between 38% and 52%. We attribute the noticeable
difference to the introduction of calibration and a proximity distance
heuristic, which underscores this promising performance. Indeed, the prediction
of fake science generated by ChatGPT presents a considerable challenge.
Nonetheless, the introduction of the xFakeSci algorithm is a significant step
on the way to combating fake science. | [
0.0583645999,
0.019814454,
-0.0271007679,
0.0128495991,
-0.0405456908,
-0.0072093918,
0.0455926917,
0.0480872467,
0.0890524685,
-0.0202196743,
0.0073483344,
0.0233727787,
0.0255727675,
0.0824508592,
-0.0057918811,
0.0175199173,
0.0412329771,
0.060713999,
0.0656323358,
-0.0182173364,
-0.0289488975,
-0.0081318133,
-0.0002328398,
0.0265453551,
0.011228268,
-0.0339416601,
0.0562503971,
-0.0517736822,
0.0440135039,
-0.0511925556,
0.0241465662,
0.0215852857,
-0.0491882004,
0.0766763911,
0.0000021351,
-0.035273131,
-0.0381302908,
0.0204659719,
0.0030005414,
-0.0107800281,
0.0680826306,
0.0060648755,
-0.0034701205,
0.0503828675,
-0.0621620789,
-0.0364000648,
0.0238755513,
0.0694914833,
0.0322239697,
0.0838729292,
-0.0202780832,
0.0128192585,
0.0837182775,
0.0164982714,
0.0344968215,
0.0032790736,
0.0540856384,
0.0190329757,
0.0190629233,
0.0415968411,
0.0355904959,
0.0495663099,
-0.0237454101,
-0.0009834659,
0.0098653957,
0.0663455948,
-0.0342391655,
-0.0294460841,
0.0247098617,
0.0230531916,
-0.0372382104,
-0.073141858,
0.0672051683,
-0.0123065794,
0.0063296142,
0.0484196767,
-0.0082813054,
0.011316143,
-0.0347441621,
-0.0153090954,
0.0485270582,
0.0000774234,
0.0203475673,
0.0132326763,
0.0413438417,
0.023596175,
-0.0103975413,
-0.0405216105,
0.0001448726,
-0.0260121003,
0.0398921706,
-0.0778663978,
0.0252660364,
0.0281290468,
-0.0302659385,
-0.0104216598,
-0.0170700941,
-0.047310818,
0.0416687392,
-0.0680901632,
-0.0293389726,
0.0016917133,
0.0120524708,
0.0020458384,
-0.0306036081,
-0.0055688918,
-0.0259752497,
0.0608257726,
-0.0119895758,
0.0706456751,
-0.0709792227,
-0.0320060588,
-0.0030579304,
-0.0006404506,
0.0071633467,
-0.0227009114,
-0.0751691237,
-0.0098735131,
-0.004299128,
0.0168439038,
0.0144671556,
0.0526207648,
-0.0171716455,
0.0366514102,
0.0101793343,
0.0116170654,
0.0191613957,
0.0416816063,
-0.0273319222,
-0.0171117354,
-0.0015683217,
0.0190185886,
0.004939416,
0.0202514026,
0.0125871468,
0.0405815355,
-0.0028372183,
-0.0236138385,
-0.0187132936,
-0.0644360334,
-0.0198040754,
-0.0589491501,
0.0541905425,
-0.0341088772,
0.0163696501,
-0.011925715,
-0.0109987836,
-0.0421477966,
-0.023832839,
-0.0045388653,
-0.0426152386,
0.035108868,
-0.076226294,
-0.0112995561,
0.0833706111,
0.0304929912,
-0.0294378512,
0.0166575257,
0.0231369361,
0.0204058979,
0.0331121907,
-0.0119976094,
0.0261099841,
-0.0215621553,
0.0554999858,
-0.015880134,
0.0582472757,
-0.0261556879,
-0.014775971,
0.0489511192,
-0.0457155593,
0.0074407496,
-0.0157271884,
-0.0064112619,
0.0226087719,
0.0313593037,
0.0177508481,
0.0550187379,
0.0061022956,
0.0112839388,
0.0180218574,
0.015556125,
-0.0007270587,
0.0179701485,
-0.0575547554,
-0.002700778,
-0.0036885208,
0.0130232777,
0.0030774861,
-0.027219547,
-0.0088660354,
-0.013091322,
-0.0063555683,
-0.053525053,
-0.0023753478,
0.0072246362,
-0.0132875843,
-0.0499421768,
0.0330474637,
0.011544589,
-0.0132583529,
-0.0733862966,
0.0363718532,
0.0175072215,
0.0480330735,
-0.015746804,
-0.0009977379,
-0.0220201258,
-0.0488433801,
0.0207113791,
-0.0070380201,
-0.0250643808,
-0.0676977187,
0.0091373315,
-0.019740317,
-0.0127400933,
0.0234108083,
-0.0129927751,
-0.0045006308,
0.0570846833,
-0.0067426232,
-0.0254852492,
-0.0204190537,
0.0234668944,
-0.0796349421,
-0.0149205467,
0.0269095395,
-0.0262734797,
0.0661296397,
0.0012534559,
-0.016988894,
0.0316077694,
0.0323259532,
-0.0081296265,
-0.0659548789,
0.0216205381,
0.0370539464,
-0.0371571518,
-0.0072687436,
-0.0673345625,
0.0079687852,
-0.004667507,
-0.0298737399,
-0.0015903693,
0.0194454901,
-0.0157364886,
0.0037149182,
-0.0335417576,
-0.0184823666,
-0.0228297226,
0.0091140391,
0.0009909428,
0.0727393106,
0.0022490644,
0.0194514394,
0.0111030117,
-0.0331654362,
0.0340207405,
-0.0269891713,
0.0367012732,
-0.0149884131,
-0.0137517964,
-0.0184860453,
0.0152707435,
-0.018979108,
-0.001913933,
-0.0052162074,
-0.0496062413,
-0.0022195068,
0.0179288927,
0.002083591,
0.0142817618,
-0.0476535521,
-0.0076845717,
0.0241956711,
-0.034012083,
0.0062305545,
0.0359738581,
-0.0127983922,
0.0286575314,
0.0075398409,
-0.0079817418,
-0.0235990491,
0.0234072506,
-0.0695240498,
0.0619857796,
0.0607123077,
-0.006884234,
-0.0609094352,
0.0211831499,
-0.0309850387,
-0.0163913481,
-0.0156549662,
-0.0084950132,
-0.0046402602,
0.015667934,
-0.0454177596,
0.0646863952,
0.0359919444,
0.0191405881,
0.0268595573,
0.0548362583,
-0.0239121225,
-0.0264969673,
-0.0505546294,
0.0622741729,
0.0114015453,
-0.0525782965,
0.0514183491,
0.0276944339,
0.0474113338,
0.0084976675,
-0.026629623,
0.0515130423,
0.0039960938,
-0.0254849717,
0.0484056883,
-0.0099076219,
-0.022555029,
0.0133872321,
0.0330841467,
-0.0233137105,
0.0913520083,
-0.0130976066,
0.0432239138,
-0.0996765196,
-0.0034128053,
0.0242335498,
-0.0553375557,
0.0031562238,
0.0381251127,
0.0845159367,
0.054124631,
0.0229464341,
0.0183120091,
0.0074435566,
-0.0156452265,
-0.0842979103,
-0.0076995953,
0.0247920863,
0.0421596803,
-0.0012915354,
-0.0310740452,
-0.0322055556,
0.0174578596,
-0.0208380707,
0.0298057217,
-0.0410164259,
-0.0708529577,
-0.010947234,
-0.0042595654,
0.0395190716,
-0.0478154235,
-0.0149457837,
0.0096170623,
0.0408221073,
0.0557927601,
-0.077117309,
0.034077134,
-0.0005899216,
-0.0246612933,
0.0527543984,
-0.0482290201,
0.048474703,
-0.0390665494,
-0.0318819098,
-0.0277673546,
-0.0237239636,
0.0146732638,
0.0134644611,
-0.0216936003,
0.0017520009,
-0.0186898112,
0.0804768279,
0.0359911472,
-0.0429808572,
0.0160575602,
0.0150641194,
-0.0278371535,
-0.0312531777,
-0.0056237057,
-0.0910496116,
0.0074804686,
-0.0447362885,
-0.0017407848,
-0.085512124,
-0.0341708995,
-0.0257385224,
-0.0455875546,
0.0579096563,
0.0022458888,
-0.0768679529,
0.0008329178,
-0.0952730626,
-0.0353547372,
-0.0207298212,
-0.0255367942,
-0.0473486707,
0.0329597145,
0.0045301761,
-0.0010395881,
-0.058283966,
-0.0961893871,
-0.0114814313,
0.0207421873,
0.0775838941,
0.0164567996,
0.0531955138,
-0.0084252646,
-0.0432904027,
-0.0082129119,
0.02824126,
-0.0119507015,
-0.032373704,
0.0755911097,
0.0041379398,
0.0125031834,
-0.0230733957,
0.0798551589,
-0.019697316,
0.0025852318,
0.0172401685,
0.0940544456,
-0.0471701398,
-0.0793198571,
-0.0387688763,
0.0001236705,
0.0469923392,
0.0565032363,
-0.0058612991,
-0.0142223956,
-0.024782924,
-0.0077198949,
0.0575695559,
0.0134729324,
-0.0350647569,
0.0029092568,
-0.0293480065,
-0.0311190318,
-0.0826667175,
-0.0252677184,
-0.0145997433,
-0.0057958588,
0.0144957481,
-0.0042410386,
0.0337949321,
0.0037334296,
-0.0601112098,
-0.0085962676,
0.0229184683,
0.0040110792,
0.0081372103,
-0.0180737693,
0.0658937842,
-0.0131982313,
-0.0308941025,
-0.0044170702,
-0.0063918089,
-0.0432797223,
-0.0229494665,
0.040155407,
0.0209194534,
0.0095294649,
-0.0027740207,
-0.0076816794,
0.0643283352,
0.0786002055,
-0.0029263226,
-0.0248808451,
0.0013823571,
-0.0362565145,
-0.0060888203,
-0.0313259996,
0.0050450196,
0.0663551465,
0.0035528901,
-0.0325181112,
-0.0616360158,
0.0055243131,
0.0609785952,
0.0338763781,
0.0424711071,
-0.0618849732,
-0.0062813107,
-0.001805576,
-0.0352462232,
-0.0102554262,
0.0233759284,
-0.0218149275,
-0.0126995705,
0.0280496497,
0.0370260216,
0.0048562307,
-0.00490449,
-0.0819559023,
0.0013118928,
-0.0507192649,
0.0147107048,
-0.002201386,
0.0652401447,
0.0185696818,
-0.0220020972,
-0.0119478013,
-0.024025945,
0.0023459624,
0.0271528028,
-0.0065141353,
0.0339221805,
0.0386527851,
-0.0128852604,
-0.0097367764,
0.0223056506,
-0.0840197653,
-0.0013309781,
-0.0448579267,
0.0618953966,
0.0139974616,
0.0222069416,
0.0153015889,
-0.0444320552,
-0.0176560432,
-0.0252684653,
0.0407977588,
-0.0065559959,
0.0051624947,
0.0104619786,
-0.018492341,
-0.0469591096,
-0.036525771,
0.0792183354,
0.0122510055,
0.0340909474,
-0.0194590911,
-0.0518458039,
-0.0449338742,
-0.0343115367,
-0.0127487956,
-0.0113682076,
-0.0168186054,
-0.0052102981,
-0.0346836708,
-0.0086682634,
0.0267022084,
0.0117231542,
0.0252996515,
0.0125435675,
-0.0004630108,
0.0415460318,
-0.0062820683,
-0.0161602311,
-0.0010453936,
0.0141800875,
-0.0314596072,
-0.0557003506,
-0.0098036844,
-6.582830813e-33,
0.0694215149,
-0.0738440081,
-0.0216918755,
0.0421124138,
0.0267851558,
0.0450720452,
-0.0787780806,
-0.028857477,
0.0122866901,
0.0469453223,
0.0071674515,
0.0075196195,
-0.0081453677,
-0.0096420916,
-0.0144937336,
0.0219165292,
0.0239555798,
-0.0165385082,
-0.0329257101,
0.0350165963,
0.0332928039,
0.0230219122,
0.0147360815,
-0.1200518459,
0.0320566818,
-0.0129832653,
-0.0186730903,
-0.0096023474,
-0.0527803488,
0.0500865802,
-0.0324142873,
0.0264697708,
0.0217697676,
-0.0235862732,
0.0204630177,
0.0091867838,
-0.0225206316,
-0.0170662012,
0.002432351,
-0.0262807272,
-0.0282750074,
0.0007971571,
0.0469949096,
-0.0273430496,
-0.0812620744,
0.0014439831,
0.0763032064,
-0.0384862311,
-0.0267458167,
-0.0537335873,
-0.031639196,
-0.0015352205,
-0.0088999365,
0.0314670727,
-0.0230997093,
0.0421385318,
-0.0120206326,
0.0261378884,
-0.0292680413,
0.0534840152,
0.0085797869,
0.0020411618,
-0.0106503041,
-0.0588807687,
0.025385784,
0.0543209389,
0.0436918586,
-0.0022750422,
0.0096269585,
-0.0067352909,
-0.010890835,
0.0058978293,
0.0720686838,
0.0588056743,
0.0298775248,
-0.0610872135,
-0.0743877739,
0.0359737836,
0.0109136403,
-0.0318454951,
0.0129785351,
-0.0264653489,
-0.0231663659,
-0.0109917503,
0.0385921225,
-0.0159906056,
-0.0035075394,
-0.0243333541,
0.0011250213,
-0.0134084085,
-0.0417589694,
0.0112153497,
0.0001393047,
-0.0640419349,
0.0108497813,
0.0306462608,
0.0069520427,
0.0027303242,
0.0119160544,
-0.0123993745,
-0.0513952486,
-0.040770784,
0.0222826339,
-0.0047441022,
0.0575033911,
-0.0056046871,
0.0372720882,
-0.0093443329,
-0.0202000812,
0.0072193295,
0.0098517742,
-0.0059730215,
0.0276148822,
-0.0003441887,
-0.0181915015,
-0.0114338612,
0.0090364981,
-0.0023683188,
0.0245095734,
0.0865931734,
-0.0342648588,
0.0284644607,
-0.0322516076,
0.0180652998,
-0.0469038934,
-0.0215417873,
-0.0307938419,
0.0223217327,
-0.02363264,
-0.1232751831,
0.0039558015,
-0.0305641852,
3.047e-7,
0.0108136712,
0.0775707662,
-0.0251842625,
-0.0293611921,
0.0415124893,
0.0381325334,
-0.0149457967,
0.0025077444,
0.003028543,
-0.0086457562,
0.0134808673,
-0.0161260571,
-0.0011834224,
0.0188793354,
-0.05043073,
0.0002000906,
-0.0701673254,
-0.0311244987,
-0.0492997617,
0.0316939987,
0.0143884113,
0.0048520314,
0.0021304167,
-0.0341456719,
0.0244460627,
-0.0066944575,
0.0309701338,
0.0472105332,
0.0240699444,
0.0518629216,
0.0250100121,
-0.020132415,
0.0336096026,
0.0358401239,
-0.0510799065,
-0.0252386928,
-0.0323058181,
0.0137199685,
-0.0131845474,
0.0207587369,
0.0615349375,
-0.0162084009,
0.0580308996,
-0.0421284437,
0.045302242,
-0.0380120762,
-0.0449468866,
-0.069983609,
-0.0229747612,
-0.0229980424,
0.0640811622,
-0.0312912278,
0.001142962,
0.0261003952,
-0.0374075621,
0.0565671511,
0.0381152406,
-0.030339364,
0.007335715,
0.0317515358,
-0.0508606546,
-0.0221498571,
0.0175900087,
-0.0098737506,
0.0517286547,
-0.0525279939,
0.0342865475,
2.803819202e-34,
0.0539298207,
-0.0052236118,
-0.0020945526,
-0.0012304491,
-0.0161411259,
0.0082369633,
0.0619581938,
0.0080716563,
0.0037863329,
0.0021841724,
0.0023514652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08061v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08061v1 | The Costly Dilemma: Generalization, Evaluation and Cost-Optimal Deployment of Large Language Models | 2023-08-15T22:26:58 | 2023-08-15T22:26:58 | Abi Aryan, Aakash Kumar Nain, Andrew McMahon, Lucas Augusto Meyer, Harpreet Singh Sahota | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SE | When deploying machine learning models in production for any
product/application, there are three properties that are commonly desired.
First, the models should be generalizable, in that we can extend it to further
use cases as our knowledge of the domain area develops. Second they should be
evaluable, so that there are clear metrics for performance and the calculation
of those metrics in production settings are feasible. Finally, the deployment
should be cost-optimal as far as possible. In this paper we propose that these
three objectives (i.e. generalization, evaluation and cost-optimality) can
often be relatively orthogonal and that for large language models, despite
their performance over conventional NLP models, enterprises need to carefully
assess all the three factors before making substantial investments in this
technology. We propose a framework for generalization, evaluation and
cost-modeling specifically tailored to large language models, offering insights
into the intricacies of development, deployment and management for these large
language models. | [
0.0508596078,
0.0714391917,
-0.0059263967,
0.0052983556,
-0.0646916926,
-0.0007456723,
0.0436723158,
-0.0073434915,
-0.0219420493,
-0.0706213564,
0.0238256268,
-0.0039467597,
-0.0098519679,
0.0578811131,
0.0191100556,
-0.026990477,
0.0229626019,
-0.0253838468,
-0.0317070074,
0.0091177486,
0.0118496763,
0.0129341139,
0.0247231033,
0.0595962033,
-0.0186572317,
0.0109155066,
0.0112624187,
-0.0215929598,
-0.0310517456,
0.0179707743,
-0.0165944267,
0.0112491045,
0.0159387272,
0.0397341438,
0.0000018298,
-0.0735373944,
-0.0411024019,
0.0368825346,
-0.0377624035,
0.036320094,
0.0794011727,
-0.02806185,
-0.0239326227,
0.0639576092,
-0.0086615346,
0.0148441698,
0.0833954513,
0.0183477663,
0.041469682,
0.0462623686,
-0.0171397887,
-0.061093729,
0.0121403709,
-0.011505181,
-0.0608754344,
-0.0708166659,
0.0097394316,
0.0243207179,
0.0069520711,
-0.0283314977,
-0.0059134485,
0.0454046391,
0.0267935693,
0.012539858,
0.0099650007,
0.0131601384,
-0.0350686722,
-0.0020402563,
-0.0352306366,
0.0223249011,
-0.0163035057,
-0.0231247991,
-0.0097655151,
-0.0117037809,
-0.0210499149,
-0.0304473937,
-0.0272012353,
0.0289106052,
0.0335490629,
0.0151587697,
-0.0056905844,
-0.0239380654,
0.0253195297,
0.0170191135,
-0.0465009958,
0.0585130975,
0.002297272,
-0.0197091121,
0.0156076029,
0.0127702532,
-0.0460714139,
-0.0263075735,
0.0198844187,
0.025090795,
0.0030114294,
0.0341830477,
-0.0444160476,
-0.0234805085,
0.0039076582,
-0.0804978237,
0.0605106726,
0.0004671323,
0.0219000969,
0.0663193837,
-0.0453290865,
0.0495259389,
-0.0352304131,
-0.0405561998,
-0.0594132692,
-0.0185406208,
-0.0589301847,
-0.0229482688,
-0.0471178181,
0.0340902992,
-0.0204746258,
-0.0646346062,
-0.0342136361,
0.0371967293,
0.0045711785,
0.023629332,
0.042482648,
0.0024376269,
-0.0135193095,
-0.0271107759,
0.0064660362,
0.010052844,
-0.009103178,
0.0322209522,
-0.0207329299,
-0.0501508713,
0.0594733246,
0.0270906202,
-0.0158893354,
0.0252338555,
0.0253813043,
0.1045647487,
0.0114426827,
-0.0063085342,
-0.0447777659,
-0.0027346273,
-0.0386838317,
-0.0502180643,
-0.0764014497,
-0.0556914657,
-0.0123732602,
0.0400791876,
0.00790805,
-0.0313589275,
-0.0164188109,
-0.0063924082,
-0.039205417,
0.0521943793,
-0.0049452642,
0.040955428,
0.0102420077,
-0.0320028402,
0.0164446905,
0.1006785631,
0.0356855653,
0.0012574489,
0.0474397093,
-0.0270636734,
-0.0069231372,
0.0560849234,
-0.0236075185,
-0.0030370168,
-0.0621238127,
-0.013687483,
0.0254852995,
0.0061271084,
0.0027177341,
0.0460070595,
0.016938135,
0.003872948,
0.0502764396,
0.059762571,
0.0288414899,
-0.0166150387,
0.0551576391,
0.0200773329,
-0.0369573981,
-0.0680147633,
0.0037227247,
-0.0586384125,
-0.044552587,
-0.0020301694,
-0.0125119388,
0.0073870691,
-0.0225393362,
-0.0381572805,
-0.0326527283,
-0.0278671496,
0.0181810893,
0.0186070465,
0.0764460936,
-0.0447220951,
-0.0105356984,
0.0585648455,
-0.0030748441,
-0.0143741453,
-0.0066922684,
-0.0544154458,
-0.0146601275,
0.0702958405,
0.0482806228,
-0.0236078445,
0.0141642364,
0.0190383364,
-0.0271161869,
0.0098729217,
0.0467701145,
-0.0287096109,
-0.0026085032,
-0.0201178286,
-0.0236834493,
0.022599047,
0.0177465286,
-0.004347919,
0.0242049377,
0.0180864222,
-0.0071108355,
-0.0419958644,
-0.0602723211,
0.0521896221,
-0.0191050097,
-0.0270835608,
-0.0082875947,
0.0061981645,
0.0520049408,
0.0313622355,
-0.0094350632,
0.0086149946,
0.0217426307,
-0.0283885039,
-0.0218083486,
-0.0291182939,
0.0363703705,
0.0528657399,
0.0221579038,
0.0134238238,
0.0127303693,
0.0206527896,
-0.0229739659,
-0.0294262171,
0.0020791886,
-0.0456497334,
0.055844333,
0.0029265741,
0.0509798862,
-0.0619254112,
-0.0065698014,
-0.0707009435,
0.006723051,
-0.0049963677,
0.0192198679,
-0.0269788541,
-0.0315659158,
0.0196301769,
-0.0196819715,
-0.0415525287,
0.0507559814,
-0.0138044916,
0.0489276312,
0.0363081098,
-0.0119188363,
0.0015556386,
0.0066242991,
-0.0812256932,
-0.0244923942,
-0.0171376485,
0.0151417693,
0.0218825489,
0.0000918441,
0.0084549896,
-0.0001659482,
-0.0277207978,
0.0277209859,
0.0158951562,
0.0452851877,
0.0123882378,
0.0013390606,
-0.0320540257,
-0.0047747288,
-0.039717976,
0.016515268,
0.0829308107,
-0.0065732538,
0.0024684542,
-0.1091258749,
0.0301025361,
-0.0159984976,
0.0311623868,
0.0061830184,
-0.0170867704,
-0.018446343,
-0.0046800771,
0.0123091619,
0.0340358652,
-0.0273848698,
0.0221485347,
0.0420642421,
0.04781707,
-0.0677266195,
-0.0251363236,
-0.0323739685,
-0.0500998981,
-0.0680731684,
-0.0122633837,
0.0503829829,
0.0313243531,
-0.030740248,
-0.0203381982,
-0.0382042751,
0.0161242094,
-0.0672191307,
-0.0336092114,
-0.0416168571,
-0.0120513346,
0.0014579534,
0.0742537305,
0.0103627937,
-0.0809334368,
0.0236357227,
-0.0179819074,
0.0216344986,
-0.069551602,
-0.0630217716,
-0.033171352,
0.0710021257,
0.0030658182,
0.0489228591,
-0.0222784299,
-0.0321206786,
-0.03581376,
0.0322935246,
0.0035980153,
0.0005043616,
0.0708029568,
-0.0396820605,
0.0516599976,
-0.0080785351,
-0.0199682862,
-0.0127150416,
-0.0454599708,
-0.0596711636,
0.0328334123,
0.0475352183,
-0.0101919277,
-0.0268902127,
0.0852163509,
0.0145851513,
0.0345702618,
0.0438595712,
-0.0084590968,
0.001508399,
-0.0059786155,
0.0080764927,
-0.0113284281,
0.0238609854,
0.0120868534,
-0.0083578425,
0.0317336544,
0.0512252897,
0.0159821659,
-0.0452641733,
0.0069156168,
0.0462530032,
-0.0533184372,
-0.0134715466,
0.0241477471,
0.0113408165,
-0.050473772,
0.0217885971,
0.0741582662,
0.0246280916,
-0.0301931426,
0.0389754176,
0.0517825261,
0.0313130878,
0.029114062,
0.0329858884,
-0.0419683643,
-0.0079553537,
0.0281362813,
0.0189987738,
-0.0013336764,
-0.0000158651,
-0.0025938351,
-0.160561353,
0.0215371419,
-0.0320480391,
-0.0428136736,
-0.054971084,
-0.0452921316,
-0.0263324883,
-0.0683873072,
0.0483911745,
-0.0062741786,
-0.0038345302,
-0.0271273106,
0.0401368514,
-0.0647489056,
-0.0974961519,
0.0090231635,
-0.0265662931,
0.040946953,
0.0730325952,
-0.020201169,
-0.0131483786,
-0.0089465016,
0.033734642,
0.0225027576,
0.0042940341,
-0.0001983939,
0.0322329365,
0.0329090282,
-0.0173392165,
0.021506669,
-0.0124311689,
-0.0406157263,
0.0140785333,
-0.0012925229,
0.0727257058,
0.004956462,
-0.0137477992,
-0.0001209349,
-0.0282350183,
-0.02851592,
0.0632390603,
-0.0045011002,
-0.0902865455,
-0.0596332066,
-0.0113352537,
-0.0315365307,
-0.0172719192,
-0.0456506908,
0.0256640948,
-0.0295085609,
-0.0348349176,
-0.0612257905,
-0.0224014912,
0.0345537737,
0.0596672334,
0.0147800772,
0.0084161181,
-0.0000376089,
0.0119848419,
-0.0387594104,
0.0157152936,
0.0009542648,
0.0358227566,
-0.081066221,
0.0129258921,
0.032845974,
0.0038171357,
-0.0351268128,
-0.0298987534,
-0.031792365,
-0.0671572909,
0.012988464,
0.0269176196,
0.0319987535,
0.0042953757,
-0.0170511845,
-0.0941250697,
0.0448102467,
0.0122611104,
-0.0233028829,
-0.0187220331,
0.0275583789,
-0.0036408929,
-0.0210993774,
0.028110126,
-0.0344637893,
0.0203257576,
-0.0031067759,
0.0365465023,
-0.0078602582,
-0.0445168577,
0.0153114172,
0.0293432791,
0.0208652485,
-0.0286249891,
-0.0020499432,
-0.0032194236,
-0.0069926716,
0.0148640918,
-0.0276600551,
-0.0506847799,
-0.003937182,
0.0410148986,
0.0338414945,
-0.0150526157,
-0.0047730315,
0.0240217242,
-0.0247127116,
-0.0157024991,
0.0198233519,
0.0294321124,
0.0088662924,
0.061061129,
0.0263057165,
-0.0276697855,
-0.0070439181,
-0.0152952336,
-0.0099529298,
-0.0195054505,
0.035513673,
0.0119727999,
0.0257337894,
-0.0310275275,
0.037916854,
-0.0092249187,
-0.0701454803,
-0.0192661937,
0.0387022011,
0.047550831,
-0.0013362241,
0.0477371737,
-0.0475886166,
-0.0379873998,
-0.0315859094,
0.0072701736,
0.0191483982,
0.0017560853,
0.0057637645,
0.0228250567,
-0.0517294854,
0.0214288458,
0.0730369389,
0.0395494476,
0.0349122584,
-0.0513220616,
-0.0257840455,
-0.0264906399,
-0.0152519448,
0.034894079,
-0.0187374782,
-0.0477783233,
0.0159414504,
-0.0565297753,
-0.0782637447,
-0.0300097018,
0.0118400007,
0.0402798317,
-0.0290553831,
0.0228732247,
0.1144273505,
0.0400534384,
0.0239705164,
-0.0521517657,
-0.0113421306,
-0.0393504575,
-0.0098272189,
0.0047869226,
-5.960228026e-33,
0.0304338709,
0.0061814995,
0.0249229595,
-0.0248026531,
0.0112238191,
0.0364427567,
0.0380413346,
0.0034999519,
-0.0148446187,
-0.0240142196,
-0.0057771555,
-0.0119262952,
0.0086089196,
0.0206151213,
0.0355306268,
0.0345328525,
0.0438032411,
-0.0132797221,
-0.0041850223,
-0.0079271561,
0.0309430957,
0.0129265096,
0.0509142689,
-0.0365393385,
0.0113079287,
0.0247454029,
-0.0013806163,
0.0275625307,
0.0164340753,
0.0600406863,
-0.0349551737,
0.0409500934,
0.0292082876,
-0.0695127845,
-0.0085752197,
-0.0048642885,
-0.0189798735,
0.0233587753,
-0.0040452424,
0.0341112018,
-0.0052062869,
0.0116650602,
0.0522357896,
-0.0089484043,
-0.0497873165,
0.0310570784,
0.0261695348,
-0.0336682685,
-0.0343103036,
-0.0192255583,
-0.0695320144,
0.021899797,
0.0054839076,
0.0237454828,
0.0607216246,
0.0234865211,
-0.0363124907,
0.0208157115,
-0.0336053558,
-0.0039652628,
0.0156002399,
0.0367420726,
0.0946473777,
0.0198850334,
-0.0185282771,
0.0043894006,
0.0106778592,
-0.0099021178,
-0.0015564522,
0.0059741549,
0.0266074557,
0.0577303916,
0.0611054711,
0.0284093767,
0.0399621502,
0.0044490881,
-0.0471479036,
-0.0014373362,
-0.0064232033,
0.0118275853,
0.0392990038,
0.0481996723,
-0.0406762995,
-0.0511492416,
-0.0555343367,
0.0123481443,
-0.0215148591,
-0.0092441356,
0.0491645858,
0.02238282,
-0.0478896312,
0.0261195619,
0.0410494246,
-0.0628432706,
-0.0517918691,
-0.0050808289,
-0.0064624511,
0.043191053,
0.0046647419,
0.036184974,
-0.0765244365,
-0.0350523293,
-0.0457858369,
0.0128272884,
-0.003609054,
-0.0296454821,
0.0200944953,
0.0283343419,
-0.061798986,
0.023160005,
-0.0065391338,
0.0098992214,
0.0084512401,
0.042801626,
0.0536269136,
-0.0288466476,
0.00373376,
0.0359117351,
0.0259794891,
0.0009492411,
0.0049436949,
-0.0114883352,
-0.0024648677,
-0.0130628133,
-0.0268398393,
0.0145588825,
-0.0379032604,
0.0489422753,
0.045767948,
-0.02067752,
-0.0354078114,
-0.0095233424,
2.478e-7,
0.0687488094,
0.0325518027,
-0.0225932915,
0.0121901399,
0.0050857267,
0.0273245964,
0.0110199042,
-0.0002595898,
-0.0358300395,
0.0318182483,
0.0071300329,
-0.0047156857,
0.0613531359,
-0.0012659155,
-0.0419901833,
-0.0174128171,
-0.0615953542,
0.0432643816,
-0.0634688884,
0.014895753,
0.0266922452,
0.1186822057,
0.0161565691,
-0.01683609,
-0.0200880338,
-0.0523868576,
0.0226302668,
-0.0573002547,
0.0299400296,
0.0229194835,
0.0578047521,
0.0451947153,
0.0135173798,
0.0100778406,
0.0075735683,
0.0169649553,
0.0404374711,
0.0613667406,
-0.0289778356,
0.0203028452,
0.0085327066,
-0.0602131076,
-0.0160824396,
-0.05892184,
0.0642601028,
-0.0536711365,
-0.0596471764,
-0.0576230325,
0.000415875,
-0.0225975774,
-0.0065840236,
-0.0105533767,
0.0170548763,
0.0078871818,
0.0164308101,
-0.043132361,
-0.0263668038,
-0.0869728699,
0.00488587,
0.046500273,
-0.0162711777,
-0.0225240253,
-0.0122668818,
0.003606837,
0.0224274583,
-0.0227963738,
0.0287583582,
2.316463606e-34,
0.0164048411,
0.0155257173,
0.0338821523,
0.0218517669,
-0.0062290812,
0.0024326565,
0.0024546019,
-0.0213107038,
-0.0270363111,
-0.090869762,
0.0085206227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08043v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08043v4 | DiagGPT: An LLM-based and Multi-agent Dialogue System with Automatic Topic Management for Flexible Task-Oriented Dialogue | 2023-08-15T21:14:09 | 2024-04-15T07:25:40 | Lang Cao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | A significant application of Large Language Models (LLMs), like ChatGPT, is
their deployment as chat agents, which respond to human inquiries across a
variety of domains. While current LLMs proficiently answer general questions,
they often fall short in complex diagnostic scenarios such as legal, medical,
or other specialized consultations. These scenarios typically require
Task-Oriented Dialogue (TOD), where an AI chat agent must proactively pose
questions and guide users toward specific goals or task completion. Previous
fine-tuning models have underperformed in TOD and the full potential of
conversational capability in current LLMs has not yet been fully explored. In
this paper, we introduce DiagGPT (Dialogue in Diagnosis GPT), an innovative
approach that extends LLMs to more TOD scenarios. In addition to guiding users
to complete tasks, DiagGPT can effectively manage the status of all topics
throughout the dialogue development. This feature enhances user experience and
offers a more flexible interaction in TOD. Our experiments demonstrate that
DiagGPT exhibits outstanding performance in conducting TOD with users, showing
its potential for practical applications in various fields. | [
0.062161874,
-0.03592344,
-0.0357813723,
0.0051165889,
-0.0373739488,
0.0187607855,
0.0079405187,
0.0150083927,
0.0392518602,
-0.0199886616,
-0.0280820914,
-0.0260066073,
-0.0411734097,
0.0691308603,
0.001816498,
-0.0728534386,
0.0318519361,
-0.0133960946,
0.0443715826,
0.0084058838,
0.0411842987,
0.0072564669,
-0.0554743558,
0.0688549057,
-0.0249255057,
-0.0282654334,
-0.0362195075,
-0.0065494757,
-0.004531411,
-0.0344802812,
0.0198890921,
0.0578509271,
0.019080909,
-0.0223228224,
0.0000021568,
-0.0484364741,
0.0052479301,
-0.0161480363,
-0.018062003,
-0.0432914458,
0.0263905078,
0.0467024744,
-0.0005211839,
0.0418447927,
-0.0454012416,
-0.0084101846,
0.0294868704,
0.1017322093,
0.0656605363,
0.0617914423,
-0.0271883588,
0.022239022,
0.0246463325,
-0.0096760383,
0.0143534681,
-0.0890277177,
-0.0086001661,
0.0329309143,
0.0758374855,
-0.0024730002,
0.0199618042,
0.0076910532,
-0.0081127482,
-0.0272224452,
-0.0462562963,
0.0146135157,
0.0019884487,
-0.057553988,
-0.0201830231,
0.0798064545,
0.0396349691,
0.0203527864,
0.0143245161,
0.0153316101,
0.0343213975,
-0.0174601227,
-0.0519183166,
0.003884973,
-0.0486218184,
-0.0227459799,
0.0157850925,
-0.0200131536,
-0.0237695556,
-0.0002198459,
-0.0106834918,
0.0308159739,
-0.0076495144,
-0.0298478454,
-0.016808359,
-0.0186865758,
0.0096429419,
-0.0711436719,
0.0365115404,
0.0640154853,
-0.1163463742,
0.020431025,
-0.0234924909,
0.0008439231,
0.0461069793,
-0.037546441,
-0.0139590362,
0.0440480076,
-0.033206284,
0.0540081039,
0.0383668318,
0.039107047,
-0.0051246616,
-0.0121484092,
-0.0283553042,
-0.0229488257,
-0.0530534871,
-0.0012380694,
-0.0683314353,
0.0216800198,
-0.0086286515,
-0.0176642854,
-0.0103472844,
0.0815188661,
0.00390046,
0.0250473693,
0.0135530205,
0.0116388816,
-0.0451136641,
-0.0000715433,
-0.0522832125,
0.0101134479,
-0.0389464684,
0.0125405453,
0.0366168022,
-0.0270979479,
-0.0042813462,
0.0321558267,
-0.0110731851,
0.0182729326,
0.0005290113,
0.0600607656,
-0.0176839679,
-0.0151654184,
0.0058168592,
-0.0284747984,
-0.0244990159,
-0.0547404736,
-0.0310616773,
-0.0386353731,
0.0366475731,
0.0200913083,
-0.0362663418,
-0.0075474596,
0.026350705,
0.0363513641,
-0.0212564189,
0.0337179378,
-0.0442043468,
0.0467634983,
0.0408570766,
0.0373767875,
-0.0569646917,
0.0374916978,
0.0151735237,
0.026269339,
0.0252566617,
-0.0027908217,
0.0285263415,
0.0162109882,
-0.0283183623,
0.0134692444,
0.0561755486,
0.0158805251,
-0.0091279829,
0.0425654165,
-0.0226679388,
0.0569100305,
-0.018291479,
0.0239819195,
0.0416789427,
0.0764938891,
-0.001693237,
0.0198444929,
0.0148614394,
0.0352331288,
0.0046152743,
0.0153854173,
-0.0189520288,
0.0319840163,
-0.001857929,
-0.0312101692,
0.0137599269,
0.0029464597,
-0.0420448035,
-0.0404825993,
-0.0154492622,
0.0082315849,
0.0081517966,
0.021596903,
0.0309185851,
0.0008997897,
-0.0267399978,
0.049528785,
0.0242791586,
-0.0078582549,
-0.0708787665,
-0.0778676718,
0.0403099023,
0.0959115624,
0.0475108661,
-0.0482592359,
-0.1079834998,
-0.0188909136,
0.0269151311,
0.036408402,
0.0326199569,
-0.0127112223,
-0.0163828563,
-0.0202128701,
-0.0121442284,
0.0073146904,
0.0062146327,
-0.0024476021,
0.0022880647,
-0.0072467998,
-0.0185647532,
-0.0185015872,
0.0092496742,
-0.000991669,
-0.0103566209,
0.0246966984,
-0.0021376507,
-0.0073083276,
0.0398450792,
0.0241296571,
-0.0013132829,
-0.0047222162,
0.0218359847,
-0.0129645029,
-0.031780757,
0.0309933461,
-0.0189295206,
-0.012127474,
0.0194599107,
0.012216026,
-0.0221614372,
-0.0353005752,
-0.0127152083,
-0.0407270156,
-0.0146516347,
-0.0507515967,
-0.0190998204,
-0.0474814735,
0.0080048935,
0.0333612822,
-0.0130746858,
-0.0163017549,
0.0207889657,
0.0125838416,
-0.0273010582,
0.032656841,
-0.0018599079,
0.0121306293,
-0.055171445,
0.0205510687,
0.0374637619,
0.0109022493,
0.0067135128,
0.0065543824,
0.0336833,
-0.0384551175,
-0.0460443534,
-0.1586927921,
0.0154727688,
-0.0216582809,
-0.0185344294,
0.0023520046,
0.0394950174,
-0.0237756204,
-0.029323509,
-0.0653967038,
0.0410587564,
0.0774073452,
0.0115020657,
0.0453223512,
0.017562937,
-0.0197638813,
-0.0389022827,
0.0226195809,
-0.0179602467,
-0.0357345231,
0.0096283853,
-0.0443005487,
-0.0494837016,
0.0314965099,
-0.0327846743,
0.0300821234,
-0.0253700651,
-0.0272908825,
0.0309116393,
-0.0326246358,
0.0423376225,
0.0482131541,
0.0065556858,
0.0353382081,
0.0086980797,
-0.0354566388,
-0.0622288883,
0.0417849422,
-0.005621138,
-0.0080819633,
-0.0100137889,
-0.0228289925,
0.0186989978,
0.0358503237,
-0.0006216275,
0.0302252434,
-0.0341198966,
-0.0002399337,
0.0036133237,
0.0123692462,
0.0072636125,
0.0083138328,
-0.0296637043,
0.043562565,
0.0002251613,
-0.0342437997,
0.0902363807,
0.0159577038,
-0.0115472432,
-0.0766917467,
-0.0490598604,
-0.0383430123,
0.0696109608,
-0.0465604365,
0.016571179,
0.0198710728,
-0.0359716192,
-0.0166591648,
0.0076974714,
0.0070506339,
-0.0420181639,
0.0492627211,
-0.0563398115,
0.022668412,
-0.0009780965,
-0.0529894829,
-0.0450924933,
-0.0310126152,
-0.0190937296,
0.0073400382,
0.0008183517,
-0.0104619944,
-0.0503036045,
0.0170413684,
0.0095934579,
0.037571229,
0.0121767418,
-0.0138353687,
-0.0190025698,
-0.0191783682,
0.0203105714,
0.0277300421,
-0.0228586942,
-0.0161494799,
0.0615849756,
0.0531329103,
-0.0167154633,
-0.0370745808,
0.0156384576,
-0.0250428505,
0.0254464205,
-0.0080244951,
-0.0350172631,
0.0093280589,
0.0489439331,
-0.0410822779,
0.0004226488,
0.1326539516,
0.030499801,
-0.0531788953,
-0.0019341211,
-0.0603615269,
0.001905584,
0.0020053263,
0.0406734496,
-0.0792687461,
-0.0382852405,
0.0001250378,
-0.0053368197,
-0.0092847357,
-0.030756589,
-0.003384223,
-0.0149421096,
0.0496411659,
-0.0257470645,
0.044099018,
0.004403681,
0.0063456572,
0.0338307992,
0.0257443599,
0.0485317595,
0.0036543785,
0.0144522684,
-0.0318380855,
-0.012325109,
-0.0446765162,
-0.0159016978,
0.0461441278,
-0.0273116659,
0.062352065,
0.0698950738,
0.0330964029,
0.0260878447,
0.0137472255,
0.0171582457,
0.0680950135,
0.0395297073,
0.0009996939,
0.0350315198,
0.0004304406,
0.0089011025,
-0.0649696589,
0.0238588434,
-0.0372808613,
-0.0060737142,
0.0724338964,
0.0463362373,
-0.0829124004,
-0.0141777853,
-0.0255253483,
0.0295718573,
0.0199293643,
0.0615968555,
0.0041019204,
-0.05380667,
-0.0438206606,
-0.0187544338,
-0.0234866999,
0.0165347401,
0.0088679362,
-0.0257374551,
-0.0354304686,
-0.012680253,
-0.0557824224,
-0.0542720929,
0.0739931688,
-0.0024183854,
0.0003353522,
-0.0120783262,
-0.0015395078,
0.0330670178,
0.0150025738,
0.0259538516,
0.0058097388,
0.0122960433,
-0.0577987954,
-0.0296135992,
0.0523009747,
-0.0234295037,
0.0120496722,
0.030421,
-0.0460000932,
-0.0276652239,
-0.0081261927,
0.0233814735,
0.0150698023,
-0.0180090107,
-0.0253435913,
-0.0513944216,
-0.0342749208,
-0.0021708997,
-0.0502287708,
0.0072293337,
0.0168118682,
0.0555336475,
0.0017921053,
0.0396813266,
-0.0637964159,
0.0254079178,
-0.0484383292,
0.044640284,
-0.0539660938,
-0.0741096735,
0.0265630856,
0.0178230628,
0.0252078045,
0.0254792571,
-0.0323603339,
-0.0287428182,
0.0219976213,
-0.0175411515,
-0.0229107738,
-0.0538630597,
0.0347430073,
-0.0346433856,
-0.0524302609,
0.0312985294,
0.0050871996,
-0.0847009867,
-0.0224432554,
-0.02177242,
0.0146985594,
-0.0081699518,
-0.0423781238,
0.0307799447,
-0.0150427865,
-0.0039556371,
0.0216209609,
0.0231082402,
0.0127988467,
-0.0042078164,
0.1279531419,
0.0052779638,
-0.023923073,
0.0263545029,
0.0625833571,
-0.0479288884,
-0.0998851657,
0.0538492054,
0.0768992156,
0.0547721013,
0.0774386972,
0.0191602036,
-0.0612772144,
0.015331123,
-0.0105070053,
0.0276304986,
0.0177657939,
0.0075114788,
0.0291705392,
0.0207331516,
-0.003982164,
-0.0095169833,
0.050289996,
-0.0393774472,
0.0092268828,
-0.0008715205,
-0.0206812806,
-0.0555745997,
-0.0272811763,
0.0033565811,
0.0329866409,
-0.0090996325,
0.0122977588,
-0.053623803,
-0.0077815312,
-0.0142092202,
-0.0292635728,
-0.0414732844,
-0.0451339036,
0.0230856389,
0.0667977408,
0.0157691222,
-0.0325951725,
-0.0271609686,
-0.0014664551,
-0.0482022502,
-0.0029919019,
-0.0293993372,
-6.181020395e-33,
-0.0296703614,
-0.0453166924,
0.0417919941,
0.0266768727,
-0.0031884795,
-0.0281682163,
-0.0334461816,
0.0378542989,
-0.0190257952,
0.0151048554,
-0.0403141156,
0.048607178,
0.00523856,
-0.0070715058,
-0.0104116732,
-0.0203835666,
0.0502585955,
0.0114085246,
-0.0156500731,
0.0593813919,
0.0138146468,
0.0059809629,
-0.0107066343,
-0.0903617665,
0.0293353871,
-0.0039174594,
-0.0107727796,
0.0465217531,
-0.0070657246,
0.044302348,
-0.0039599854,
0.0554272458,
0.0525721163,
-0.0028063385,
-0.0116692549,
0.0408841856,
-0.0290715955,
-0.0379584394,
0.0188289843,
-0.0197658725,
-0.0237575509,
-0.0225469172,
-0.0250796378,
-0.0128554264,
-0.0090073189,
0.0096584344,
0.0187867396,
-0.0046881968,
0.0058891093,
-0.0067563471,
-0.0434990786,
0.0243360437,
-0.0086302189,
-0.0764460191,
-0.022756815,
0.0359981619,
-0.0210146289,
-0.0384036899,
0.024302572,
0.0228591487,
-0.0028626609,
-0.0154233407,
0.0213395357,
-0.0164423753,
-0.0347660147,
0.0314152166,
0.0277269408,
0.0495485924,
-0.0385502018,
-0.0496908538,
-0.0518133864,
0.0641382784,
0.0202365611,
0.0157980099,
-0.0432847291,
-0.0016215965,
-0.0177230984,
0.043912895,
0.0672030821,
0.0570349991,
0.0216214508,
0.0165394526,
-0.0674114749,
-0.0233202912,
-0.0221438315,
0.0585653484,
-0.0325760841,
-0.0465574935,
0.0485925302,
-0.0024227605,
0.0327248946,
-0.0531245954,
0.0121359341,
-0.0048047067,
0.0384301953,
-0.0070768707,
-0.0246787164,
0.0175797511,
-0.0289085824,
0.0150066996,
-0.0233171545,
-0.0168575104,
0.0281866044,
0.0058654547,
0.0152856316,
0.0364217833,
-0.0232217796,
-0.0238387566,
-0.0295891706,
0.0050738156,
-0.0033003897,
0.0558316745,
-0.0307762828,
0.0321217477,
0.0043553668,
0.0025339373,
-0.0343658589,
0.080241546,
-0.0006074978,
-0.0240500215,
-0.0762191117,
-0.0391063392,
-0.0096132457,
-0.0242986139,
-0.0438678898,
0.0074947854,
-0.023557432,
0.0140508888,
0.0166659523,
-0.0278336722,
-0.0227197651,
0.0029618179,
2.88e-7,
0.013247449,
0.067908451,
-0.006847498,
0.0400131829,
0.0243951678,
0.0477638617,
0.0045917304,
0.0241869036,
0.033856649,
-0.0171098113,
0.0173185505,
0.0379733257,
0.0288040247,
0.0263141785,
-0.0932603851,
-0.0384783819,
0.0020617158,
-0.0119121866,
-0.0572633296,
0.0207409766,
0.0809250548,
0.0492381528,
-0.0162401553,
0.0018983131,
0.0143019184,
-0.045617763,
0.0369846337,
-0.0387084559,
-0.0308517534,
0.0466909297,
0.0441290699,
0.0079178596,
0.0009345621,
0.0366138667,
0.0079124309,
0.0213261452,
-0.0149649959,
0.0997662693,
-0.0267861672,
-0.0480527803,
0.0009214452,
-0.0158779714,
0.0319947861,
-0.0436444767,
0.0440687351,
-0.0649849102,
-0.0440606847,
-0.0130773075,
0.0280991811,
-0.0360986292,
-0.0151048396,
-0.0294602606,
-0.0409999862,
0.0064492594,
-0.0043357159,
-0.0120270709,
0.0014193875,
-0.0579509288,
0.0203057416,
0.0252570361,
-0.059620928,
-0.0715423897,
-0.0059510525,
-0.0152591914,
0.0169168543,
-0.0519514568,
0.0134468833,
2.556988576e-34,
0.0387346484,
0.0146006672,
-0.0005218168,
0.0660071,
0.0435672142,
0.0249286741,
0.0150050577,
0.0228283238,
0.0607383586,
-0.0703959465,
-0.0196952522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08032v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08032v1 | Using Artificial Populations to Study Psychological Phenomena in Neural Models | 2023-08-15T20:47:51 | 2023-08-15T20:47:51 | Jesse Roberts, Kyle Moore, Drew Wilenzick, Doug Fisher | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent proliferation of research into transformer based natural language
processing has led to a number of studies which attempt to detect the presence
of human-like cognitive behavior in the models. We contend that, as is true of
human psychology, the investigation of cognitive behavior in language models
must be conducted in an appropriate population of an appropriate size for the
results to be meaningful. We leverage work in uncertainty estimation in a novel
approach to efficiently construct experimental populations. The resultant tool,
PopulationLM, has been made open source. We provide theoretical grounding in
the uncertainty estimation literature and motivation from current cognitive
work regarding language models. We discuss the methodological lessons from
other scientific communities and attempt to demonstrate their application to
two artificial population studies. Through population based experimentation we
find that language models exhibit behavior consistent with typicality effects
among categories highly represented in training. However, we find that language
models don't tend to exhibit structural priming effects. Generally, our results
show that single models tend to over estimate the presence of cognitive
behaviors in neural models. | [
0.0384639576,
0.1342436522,
-0.0536214598,
0.0164629649,
-0.0482791252,
0.0023410679,
0.0014439543,
-0.0276801437,
-0.0391839333,
-0.0308857448,
-0.0456289016,
-0.0819567814,
0.0096398648,
-0.0000516538,
0.047313787,
-0.0278568342,
0.0250912271,
-0.0222345833,
0.0220851339,
-0.0122377081,
-0.0629600957,
-0.0187100098,
0.019084543,
0.0399378091,
0.0066171661,
0.0197155811,
-0.0052769561,
0.0072299605,
0.0012196293,
-0.0335692205,
0.0187674444,
0.0791103691,
0.0365736559,
0.0102305086,
0.0000020294,
-0.0273119323,
-0.0043726778,
0.0113898572,
-0.0325998962,
-0.0316520408,
0.0820435211,
0.0074121216,
-0.0274921209,
0.0010735481,
-0.0203802977,
-0.0007349073,
0.0481398627,
0.015923582,
-0.0006493442,
0.0271008536,
-0.008642436,
-0.0415136851,
0.0050349752,
0.0057353787,
0.0077358638,
-0.0089839334,
0.0489844121,
-0.0380403437,
0.0172208287,
0.0017073738,
-0.041784931,
0.0128679937,
0.0143104643,
0.0249115359,
-0.0146650346,
0.0181526951,
-0.0119141731,
-0.069736585,
-0.0244289171,
0.0234448016,
-0.0213037003,
-0.0266030673,
-0.0043574572,
0.008115476,
0.0304684807,
0.0616809875,
-0.0094398297,
0.0521810949,
0.0268266927,
0.0033250675,
0.0257130936,
0.0289192814,
-0.0009499602,
-0.013496439,
-0.0200162828,
0.0721736923,
0.0118151354,
-0.0258685518,
0.0139641846,
0.0212281402,
-0.0500799902,
-0.0376770683,
0.0211750027,
-0.0105915656,
-0.0282280203,
0.026909899,
-0.0319883488,
-0.0592914745,
0.0171991158,
-0.031250231,
0.0522825196,
0.0531285927,
-0.0030349635,
0.0063873064,
-0.0010536035,
0.0617740601,
-0.0060770321,
0.0290539116,
-0.0126447706,
-0.0030923178,
-0.0455860794,
-0.0040709777,
-0.0523540713,
0.0020410076,
0.0032183228,
-0.0213217475,
-0.0553634167,
0.0013514836,
-0.0204710271,
-0.0301177129,
-0.0355422534,
0.021955885,
-0.0460866727,
0.0117532974,
-0.0415879376,
-0.0149930306,
-0.0146106901,
0.0288982168,
-0.001079394,
-0.0812053829,
0.000306168,
-0.002250589,
0.0173361953,
-0.0243138131,
-0.0076952064,
0.0371440053,
-0.0094383033,
-0.0472882167,
-0.0428649113,
0.0175152421,
-0.0255500935,
0.0024798347,
0.0188917834,
-0.0797134042,
0.0158255603,
0.0179378875,
0.0213834681,
-0.0469370559,
0.0124644432,
0.0083559146,
-0.0361088924,
0.0947992653,
0.0223089997,
0.0350006297,
0.0055306847,
-0.0028114698,
0.0059406082,
0.0871336386,
0.0504536033,
-0.0096749077,
0.0369085819,
-0.0058767167,
0.0401280783,
0.0246480033,
-0.0077119172,
-0.0283365659,
-0.0261954274,
-0.0465926304,
0.0001066975,
-0.0021967411,
0.051403597,
0.0745666921,
-0.0287607498,
-0.0248871185,
0.0712690577,
0.1073243096,
-0.0265965629,
0.0386488289,
0.0545339622,
-0.0002025035,
0.0112378597,
0.0284732115,
-0.0710863546,
0.0264742542,
-0.0392820686,
-0.0074608829,
-0.0306062046,
0.0416771285,
0.0021640528,
-0.0434243381,
-0.0223838445,
0.0042920504,
0.0181378629,
-0.0234500114,
0.0657800138,
0.0414125398,
-0.0061286301,
0.0402754731,
0.0254528467,
-0.0308929086,
-0.0159822665,
-0.0579730906,
-0.0070024906,
0.0012756998,
0.0167755689,
-0.0109711085,
0.0103756143,
-0.0006622435,
-0.0438384824,
0.0628490821,
0.0521232076,
-0.0038655628,
-0.0076561263,
-0.0171599723,
0.0140887862,
0.0177211519,
0.0252432991,
-0.0035010679,
0.0271433666,
-0.0130537394,
-0.0113917533,
-0.0351743586,
-0.0378866643,
0.0492348298,
-0.0472397581,
-0.0139289526,
-0.0075784707,
-0.0385794342,
0.0487854108,
-0.0426497981,
-0.022351481,
0.0248279106,
0.0195275582,
0.0135239437,
-0.0290881582,
0.0252325237,
-0.0192196835,
-0.0132423043,
0.0112420134,
-0.0368073396,
-0.0137720983,
0.0125789773,
-0.0014223418,
-0.0086775962,
0.0260897223,
-0.0583210066,
0.0383709036,
-0.0085635381,
0.0481320545,
-0.0398517959,
0.0152446646,
-0.0363238752,
0.0667666867,
0.0047757304,
0.0146442419,
0.0195480026,
-0.0328476131,
-0.0075497194,
-0.0595969148,
-0.0633513555,
-0.0407368653,
-0.0362885334,
-0.0167771503,
0.0204668585,
-0.0277384166,
-0.0417328216,
-0.0300297122,
-0.0566239432,
-0.0172853004,
-0.0021095311,
0.0070269974,
0.006091624,
-0.0237902999,
-0.0217492674,
0.0179971177,
-0.0063623297,
-0.0020519109,
0.000599885,
0.0564554855,
0.0263400711,
-0.0223173164,
-0.0119366506,
-0.0691464245,
-0.0156299025,
-0.0373076461,
0.0604367182,
0.0113710454,
-0.0086717615,
-0.0708110407,
0.0422126092,
0.0022803987,
0.0340277553,
-0.0103677679,
-0.0715873465,
0.0501239225,
0.0256168731,
0.0631207526,
0.0801422074,
0.0286264271,
0.0253899265,
0.0622202232,
0.0293919574,
-0.0359936208,
-0.0157805718,
-0.0568447337,
-0.0340623446,
-0.0191870835,
-0.0909036249,
0.0262857769,
0.1062139049,
0.014262449,
-0.0331050158,
-0.0546739995,
0.055419974,
-0.0415606275,
-0.0377368592,
-0.0162960608,
-0.00502114,
-0.02237688,
0.0651151463,
-0.0262772422,
-0.0238061342,
0.0791891962,
0.0122868726,
-0.01554335,
-0.0293315947,
0.0092016673,
0.0187093001,
0.014275087,
0.0643858686,
0.0100336196,
0.0584595986,
0.0171562228,
-0.0899174288,
-0.0001680914,
0.0079364637,
-0.0326806977,
0.0225002505,
-0.0497578196,
-0.0161122531,
0.0304570701,
-0.0200054981,
-0.0660510808,
-0.0359340273,
-0.0113351392,
0.0121084219,
0.0856388062,
-0.029409552,
-0.0189270247,
-0.001887668,
0.0315520391,
0.0269468855,
-0.0058891899,
-0.044225961,
-0.0237797759,
0.0111409156,
0.0321805328,
0.0179338548,
0.0966637358,
-0.030365115,
-0.0075487439,
0.0356847905,
0.0132106617,
0.0425329395,
-0.0423756242,
0.0216541681,
0.0305416267,
-0.0210332032,
0.0100709945,
0.0516085103,
0.0496901385,
-0.0181654766,
-0.0289335102,
0.1104351804,
0.0380640514,
-0.0297096353,
0.0312527008,
-0.020164689,
0.0151712382,
0.0322743654,
0.0480113514,
-0.017765278,
0.00793726,
0.0179800931,
0.0059940056,
-0.0608564727,
-0.0266568381,
0.0121245142,
-0.1219054088,
0.0354470052,
-0.008835814,
-0.0160029531,
0.0077898572,
-0.0239851903,
0.0479424782,
-0.0251875222,
0.0056343158,
-0.009976388,
-0.0063578114,
0.001528335,
-0.0035611871,
-0.0115125664,
-0.090088293,
0.003161601,
-0.0508379117,
0.0981041491,
0.0336474888,
0.0219078884,
-0.0371012874,
-0.0677116513,
0.0155478595,
-0.005827297,
0.006869162,
0.0225650705,
0.0232376046,
0.0371316113,
0.0023496794,
-0.0443152227,
0.0004371271,
-0.0348124467,
-0.0404760614,
-0.051091224,
0.0472598001,
0.0187932085,
-0.0661149397,
-0.0147787416,
0.0112128826,
0.013882122,
0.0774531141,
0.0257594604,
-0.0670717806,
0.02713852,
-0.0336421058,
0.0092825331,
0.0001375312,
-0.0706471503,
0.0431808941,
0.0245371368,
-0.0349268764,
-0.0761765316,
0.0189474486,
0.0186125506,
-0.0005207227,
0.0193482414,
-0.0679636449,
0.0832072422,
-0.0464925505,
-0.0104588801,
0.0641001537,
-0.0090266764,
-0.0129229743,
-0.0604576729,
-0.0358622596,
0.044939667,
-0.0188839044,
-0.0275307689,
0.0098162321,
-0.0498811491,
-0.0875176713,
0.077715084,
0.0613033772,
0.0291923191,
-0.0151229985,
-0.000584673,
-0.0470148996,
0.0510022007,
0.048046384,
-0.0143521745,
0.0190512836,
-0.0004275328,
0.0125791114,
-0.0158363953,
0.0110442964,
0.002037002,
0.0317717046,
0.051615037,
0.0083336197,
-0.0509354882,
-0.0542155504,
0.0473795496,
-0.0077517186,
0.0563266166,
-0.0174751841,
0.0052213101,
-0.0175156258,
-0.047632169,
-0.0094841449,
-0.006416223,
-0.0316825584,
-0.0793261975,
0.038550593,
0.0315122008,
-0.0204100627,
-0.0412621275,
-0.0150129991,
0.0129409758,
0.0191272441,
-0.0055512297,
0.0389792584,
-0.0027147911,
0.0121837743,
0.0357122198,
0.0222792588,
0.0192790907,
-0.0188789964,
0.0631394386,
0.0348223075,
0.0419927388,
0.0014121991,
-0.0093983812,
-0.0276123956,
0.0026788488,
-0.0714913756,
-0.046943523,
-0.0145415524,
-0.0197614562,
-0.0041033681,
-0.0267342441,
0.016933715,
-0.0496873409,
0.0046268916,
-0.0083274562,
-0.0118859718,
0.0136688035,
0.0140957646,
0.0398757868,
0.0136814946,
0.0038930867,
-0.0316874273,
0.060531795,
0.0159221981,
0.0150359375,
-0.0363716781,
-0.0419443026,
-0.0109546268,
0.0124773765,
0.0311195757,
-0.0034536596,
-0.0225330722,
-0.0008652428,
-0.0608863607,
-0.0799078643,
0.0212545116,
0.027214041,
0.046919208,
-0.0288354475,
0.0199902505,
0.044528231,
-0.0194337014,
-0.0174002163,
-0.0179453772,
-0.0178492907,
0.0087323971,
0.0190881044,
-0.0581442937,
-6.626814873e-33,
-0.0580813028,
-0.0664951056,
-0.0202227943,
-0.0230571534,
0.0341440588,
-0.0406371877,
-0.0220890976,
0.0259841532,
-0.0085343486,
0.0333461985,
-0.0252392851,
0.0218573101,
0.020614583,
-0.0061384295,
0.0206341334,
-0.0029351541,
0.0450068042,
-0.0324260592,
-0.0234226454,
-0.0638512447,
-0.0145023325,
0.0066961758,
0.0569961816,
-0.0367128551,
0.0324852206,
0.0315837413,
0.0123618264,
0.0078851124,
-0.0157961156,
0.0455682427,
-0.0041033346,
0.0509417392,
0.0142552583,
-0.0291643664,
-0.0035586613,
0.0265734885,
-0.0448505916,
-0.0432861932,
0.0080074947,
0.0248431414,
0.0125288423,
-0.0072470582,
0.0689547807,
-0.0411902703,
-0.0429453477,
0.0055480548,
0.0399755687,
-0.0174907856,
0.0345250852,
-0.0286342986,
-0.0689869151,
-0.012308592,
0.0328177437,
0.0110750031,
-0.0124597112,
0.0247725379,
-0.0490505621,
0.0110832835,
-0.0592632703,
0.0170816518,
0.0197939109,
-0.0016634937,
0.0387811027,
0.0411570556,
0.0356891751,
0.0354022309,
0.0073580933,
0.0353145301,
-0.0154100358,
-0.0383438803,
0.0511502624,
0.004409377,
0.0569010973,
0.0605536699,
0.0726462677,
0.0027081887,
-0.0080647944,
0.0248376913,
0.0302677825,
0.0086126672,
0.0790161043,
0.0122572519,
-0.0116442051,
-0.0314233005,
-0.0359346345,
-0.0519544855,
-0.0162462238,
-0.008261445,
-0.0171081852,
-0.0115319015,
-0.0353205688,
-0.0304482337,
0.030092217,
-0.052332893,
-0.0055421819,
-0.0427612327,
0.0014009445,
0.039672818,
0.0136259422,
0.008387818,
-0.0457925014,
-0.0147195822,
0.0085998103,
0.0443831608,
0.031989675,
0.0378091857,
-0.0073350496,
0.0205248762,
-0.0578798763,
0.0151989292,
-0.0136815663,
0.0006153721,
0.0310553182,
0.012395056,
0.0315936953,
0.0213445928,
-0.0179997943,
-0.0399279855,
0.0235273819,
0.0038444935,
-0.0249951202,
0.0683735535,
-0.0226607416,
0.0241185892,
-0.0147882812,
-0.0286853909,
-0.0395189896,
0.0448176116,
0.0301998258,
-0.0245335381,
-0.0275303628,
-0.0183781199,
2.839e-7,
0.0611820407,
0.0487066023,
-0.0180577878,
0.0499988087,
0.0388653092,
0.0172510296,
-0.0001760867,
-0.0127836643,
0.053396944,
-0.0634873435,
0.001544329,
0.0375277847,
0.0101747895,
0.0415949486,
-0.0645924285,
-0.0494016372,
-0.0167239066,
0.0281428583,
0.0094000539,
0.0067746122,
0.0336820409,
0.079569988,
-0.011556224,
0.010350679,
-0.0190727618,
-0.0136027783,
0.0500186086,
-0.03924191,
-0.0067018182,
0.0394018069,
0.0037973004,
0.017097272,
0.0050920271,
0.058481805,
0.0012369119,
0.0007186767,
-0.0211158842,
-0.0115172379,
-0.0103796525,
0.0103243925,
0.0055289832,
-0.0061388761,
-0.0095798522,
-0.0555471107,
0.0199066885,
-0.135987103,
-0.0271596313,
-0.0315650143,
-0.0030449699,
-0.0248987954,
0.0298165064,
-0.0233462583,
-0.0139107043,
-0.01061734,
0.0285476018,
0.0416935049,
-0.0293202512,
-0.0477760173,
0.0011373296,
0.003952886,
-0.0397694334,
-0.0649597347,
-0.0131027289,
-0.0288490448,
0.0065728934,
-0.0418260768,
0.0079051536,
2.665575556e-34,
0.0207551196,
0.0603734553,
0.019136427,
0.0040621776,
0.0310980305,
-0.0197442099,
-0.0225174241,
0.0036790804,
0.0405728593,
-0.0783195347,
-0.0142686823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08027v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08027v1 | End-to-End Open Vocabulary Keyword Search With Multilingual Neural Representations | 2023-08-15T20:33:25 | 2023-08-15T20:33:25 | Bolaji Yusuf, Jan Cernocky, Murat Saraclar | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Conventional keyword search systems operate on automatic speech recognition
(ASR) outputs, which causes them to have a complex indexing and search
pipeline. This has led to interest in ASR-free approaches to simplify the
search procedure. We recently proposed a neural ASR-free keyword search model
which achieves competitive performance while maintaining an efficient and
simplified pipeline, where queries and documents are encoded with a pair of
recurrent neural network encoders and the encodings are combined with a
dot-product. In this article, we extend this work with multilingual pretraining
and detailed analysis of the model. Our experiments show that the proposed
multilingual training significantly improves the model performance and that
despite not matching a strong ASR-based conventional keyword search system for
short queries and queries comprising in-vocabulary words, the proposed model
outperforms the ASR-based system for long queries and queries that do not
appear in the training data. | [
-0.003743401,
0.0462802239,
0.0064328653,
0.0299568065,
-0.0060217418,
-0.0306287892,
-0.0093764896,
0.008410668,
-0.0197421368,
-0.0200685412,
-0.066847086,
-0.05448246,
-0.0220046528,
0.056975089,
-0.0160448588,
0.0064972192,
0.0397177152,
-0.0136717372,
-0.015405504,
-0.0087792026,
-0.0021623904,
0.0245915558,
0.0081756441,
0.0360335447,
0.0455816798,
0.0389259271,
-0.0252168309,
0.0041574822,
-0.0441292599,
-0.0257083979,
-0.0074442676,
-0.0128820874,
0.0546605512,
0.0748620778,
0.0000018539,
-0.034354616,
-0.0241295081,
-0.0016419084,
-0.0148206726,
0.0110556977,
0.0141126066,
0.0178037658,
0.0370950773,
0.0457433723,
-0.003345835,
-0.0487698801,
0.0360770784,
0.0432673767,
0.0056593507,
0.0544370823,
-0.0001354924,
-0.0463204309,
0.0220829733,
-0.0278206691,
-0.0282363668,
-0.0577207506,
-0.016490113,
-0.0824825242,
0.0370776579,
0.0048514148,
0.0000899196,
0.0607396513,
-0.0297142379,
-0.0044888062,
0.0093387859,
0.0039990167,
0.0151037779,
-0.0341157988,
-0.0119514018,
0.0554431789,
-0.0570841469,
-0.0205183327,
-0.0143914893,
-0.0014976688,
-0.0394638814,
-0.0107561732,
-0.017264992,
0.0387685634,
-0.0032474028,
0.0024547849,
0.0155209815,
-0.0068792468,
0.0613141321,
0.0146542797,
-0.0219670795,
0.0399377681,
0.0359535851,
-0.0673178509,
0.0306101348,
-0.0612674095,
-0.0055729835,
-0.0063754926,
0.0669962466,
0.0203268565,
0.0082871541,
0.0447063558,
0.0188165493,
-0.0624103434,
0.0161898844,
-0.133690536,
0.0055554099,
0.0395525582,
-0.0080792382,
0.040314313,
-0.0207588375,
0.0534922108,
-0.0218551178,
0.0028579968,
-0.0204787645,
-0.0533189438,
-0.0314094834,
-0.0316944569,
-0.04784609,
0.0412250757,
-0.0329459235,
-0.0482053384,
-0.00473327,
0.0181043055,
0.0578295961,
-0.0432542041,
0.0107040703,
0.0275542829,
0.0116684996,
0.0293899924,
-0.0320741013,
0.0463276431,
0.0141797895,
-0.024745062,
-0.034624882,
-0.0197381619,
0.0044085225,
0.0286793094,
0.0276853591,
-0.0166993085,
0.0209464785,
0.031262394,
0.0030598193,
-0.0263336003,
-0.0414227322,
-0.0054235398,
0.039081078,
0.0191200674,
0.0005091864,
-0.024709817,
0.0632641241,
-0.0201177914,
-0.0095978947,
-0.0398385338,
0.0226374511,
0.0428143069,
-0.0184667222,
0.0684260502,
0.0243341085,
-0.0112744672,
0.0698361993,
-0.0114688007,
0.0741331577,
0.0623846613,
0.032973893,
0.0046220217,
0.0530688576,
-0.0273497943,
-0.020892797,
0.0366902985,
0.0084148049,
-0.0283606984,
0.0011516666,
0.0096649723,
0.0465813391,
0.0943507105,
0.0303488541,
0.0363231339,
-0.0298513062,
-0.0087566376,
-0.0181344692,
0.0636654198,
0.066476047,
0.0057354751,
0.0134857139,
-0.0161884241,
-0.0255730152,
-0.0621138364,
0.0108524943,
-0.0050187898,
-0.0196577944,
-0.0071033239,
0.0062464257,
-0.0091606732,
-0.0320191085,
-0.0033361423,
0.0030915088,
0.0035565926,
-0.0046543428,
-0.0016957436,
0.0731221065,
-0.0223860834,
-0.0717435777,
0.0259036757,
-0.008074332,
-0.0515633151,
0.0557587221,
-0.0397085398,
-0.0245053656,
0.0487560295,
0.0765523687,
0.0034321237,
0.0072672367,
-0.017879298,
-0.030835215,
0.0507133938,
0.0050665508,
0.0016100185,
0.0228707846,
-0.0898606852,
-0.0290843025,
-0.0069317878,
-0.0083612278,
0.0675145611,
-0.0310986973,
0.0792975947,
0.0441935062,
-0.0240688194,
-0.0139224073,
0.00593162,
-0.031152755,
-0.042404633,
0.0405978151,
0.0277967378,
-0.0137523804,
0.0338499174,
-0.0020557202,
0.0137631642,
0.0429574102,
-0.0277072061,
-0.0295548029,
-0.0086106202,
-0.0312124882,
0.0449556857,
0.0290684197,
-0.002033056,
0.06616842,
0.0439056084,
0.0287233759,
-0.0525557846,
0.0369179919,
0.0113188513,
0.072115913,
-0.0543352962,
0.030714523,
-0.0358713269,
0.0265283361,
-0.0120893335,
-0.0058150357,
0.0224626604,
0.0296851769,
-0.0329556577,
-0.0096457172,
0.0442422032,
-0.061597798,
-0.0768080354,
0.0797022507,
0.0136470646,
0.0164857265,
0.009410345,
-0.010375767,
0.0067961258,
0.0074114455,
-0.0736068189,
0.0189820956,
-0.0117535302,
0.008877567,
-0.0054641096,
0.0517123193,
0.0130056627,
-0.0267508253,
-0.0539238155,
-0.0289397258,
0.0312052816,
0.0095747048,
-0.0154725593,
0.0293380581,
-0.0211561397,
-0.0193383992,
-0.030955391,
0.0113392938,
0.014215,
0.0089953812,
-0.0527252965,
-0.0188098513,
0.0268072132,
-0.0121430727,
0.0452641472,
-0.0101137934,
-0.0295844208,
-0.005373769,
-0.0395004563,
-0.0313773155,
0.0374421142,
0.005901841,
-0.0582615919,
0.0471903197,
-0.0341027156,
-0.0720962211,
0.0253472496,
-0.0041324669,
-0.0125403786,
0.0150899561,
-0.0003216269,
0.0346002877,
0.0087827342,
-0.023808429,
0.0270528011,
-0.0318865106,
-0.0815796331,
-0.0142519092,
-0.0477642007,
-0.0958074927,
-0.0258619711,
-0.0081016123,
0.0450853743,
0.0034609295,
-0.0131506585,
0.0134687731,
-0.0276265349,
-0.0015380991,
-0.0541111641,
-0.0302100852,
-0.0648539364,
0.0136814127,
-0.055573035,
0.0130642066,
-0.047152441,
-0.04880438,
0.0140844611,
0.0231283102,
0.0003106307,
-0.0466906838,
0.0521186478,
0.0205664299,
-0.0130673433,
-0.00740238,
-0.0475472026,
-0.0178686474,
0.0099233408,
0.0030963668,
-0.002593487,
0.0362467393,
-0.0544271097,
-0.0166737642,
0.06330695,
0.0008189245,
0.0602731444,
-0.0009633902,
0.0117839742,
0.0140878679,
0.0085989488,
0.041086413,
-0.0029923641,
-0.030009428,
0.0026311267,
0.0040742471,
-0.0208463594,
0.0704403818,
-0.0561980903,
0.009398181,
-0.0403407998,
0.0508204475,
-0.022862263,
-0.0522483476,
-0.0397319682,
-0.0680924356,
-0.0117165865,
-0.0138232959,
0.0812770501,
0.0149499876,
-0.0724188834,
-0.0448308624,
-0.0615249239,
-0.0241741911,
0.0172167737,
0.0564895049,
-0.0388776846,
0.0076776897,
0.0149090094,
0.0511717871,
0.0333228186,
0.0003242636,
-0.0288488362,
-0.1023890302,
-0.0002989493,
-0.0036122415,
-0.0434503183,
-0.0343787596,
-0.074995853,
-0.0333989337,
-0.0347090326,
0.0197591558,
0.0118913604,
0.00117649,
-0.0303391591,
0.0182001665,
0.013267206,
-0.0299456026,
0.0184218641,
-0.0660249889,
-0.0023455783,
0.0735341609,
0.0263753217,
-0.0081412373,
-0.0210811999,
-0.0166566987,
-0.0092641553,
0.0039434419,
-0.0346222706,
-0.0173536986,
-0.0324958339,
-0.0076086381,
0.0200009644,
-0.0335776471,
-0.0531590581,
0.0621218793,
0.0181456525,
0.0788258091,
-0.027374804,
0.0306603629,
-0.0130547602,
-0.0336952098,
-0.0108796917,
0.0472004563,
-0.0190463234,
-0.0051218318,
-0.0316137895,
-0.0043312907,
0.0102780722,
-0.0413229764,
-0.0392734334,
-0.0017890567,
-0.0037723633,
-0.0175066832,
-0.0341089368,
-0.0647646263,
0.0049000722,
0.0111151021,
0.0395929813,
0.0500230044,
-0.0199964698,
0.0068413061,
-0.0374976657,
-0.011796494,
-0.0082735177,
0.0145750837,
-0.0902363434,
0.0418313667,
0.0359772854,
-0.0291449074,
-0.0175001156,
-0.0056575192,
-0.0142458742,
-0.0352882668,
0.0039498308,
-0.0155721931,
0.0054443381,
0.027050687,
-0.0500737056,
-0.0656413659,
0.0735838041,
0.0152659314,
-0.0339358449,
-0.0026153189,
0.0569262914,
-0.0108848009,
-0.0307312552,
0.0144712329,
-0.0626573041,
-0.0216398612,
-0.0412673503,
0.0327134281,
0.0242756512,
-0.0662115589,
0.0108416453,
0.0350640491,
0.0614610054,
0.007052328,
0.0210282393,
-0.0829460248,
0.0449721627,
-0.0109224152,
0.0235381145,
-0.0084466394,
0.0180096645,
0.0407070853,
-0.0184537601,
-0.0076563377,
0.0532563999,
0.0223780964,
-0.0289667305,
0.0003390069,
0.0575089529,
0.0268609133,
0.0061232406,
0.0128537687,
0.0526386313,
0.00357841,
0.0459455028,
0.0199577212,
0.0252615102,
-0.0601252019,
0.010828862,
-0.0001882772,
0.0141290752,
0.0075897872,
0.0255826935,
-0.0495967604,
-0.0320318863,
-0.0088198241,
-0.0123424279,
0.060336709,
-0.0219988711,
-0.0036546614,
-0.0145552726,
0.0195332449,
-0.0368038192,
-0.0062849661,
-0.0080744438,
0.0009496993,
0.0306428168,
0.0168510024,
-0.0044291713,
0.0139229009,
0.0842894837,
0.0067248358,
0.0756470859,
-0.0216824282,
0.0072820764,
0.005018991,
-0.019153513,
0.0513816476,
0.0632025227,
-0.048699718,
-0.0342280082,
0.014855382,
-0.0282264221,
0.0166616738,
-0.0210001413,
-0.0199273098,
-0.0093322285,
0.039225556,
0.0987779722,
0.0087639522,
0.0276320726,
-0.0165968966,
-0.0127154859,
-0.0555645004,
-0.0397859626,
-0.0012343024,
-5.976214382e-33,
0.0099017499,
0.0253147725,
0.0133339539,
0.0201182831,
0.0062782201,
0.0085802488,
0.0139032584,
-0.0339357592,
-0.0567793846,
-0.0474555232,
-0.039834667,
0.0332815908,
0.0187613126,
-0.0075078667,
0.0224682931,
-0.0003669657,
0.0435334966,
-0.0092895338,
0.0199612733,
0.0047772704,
0.0880643651,
0.0736951604,
0.0531450659,
-0.0141436979,
0.0018932944,
-0.0253240373,
0.0168877877,
0.0374514833,
0.0157013126,
0.0628785267,
-0.0301009044,
0.0512006879,
-0.0122315884,
-0.0356616788,
-0.0053811036,
0.0004811186,
-0.0749008432,
-0.0179697089,
0.0026771456,
0.031986177,
-0.0021006449,
0.0026084527,
0.0353558138,
-0.0024176794,
-0.0051096044,
0.0695304945,
0.0202005561,
0.0191888902,
-0.0555818602,
-0.032436192,
-0.0043694712,
0.0110202767,
0.0260000899,
0.0108686527,
0.0667738691,
0.0497035533,
-0.0030092492,
-0.0090614036,
-0.0732744858,
0.0389926918,
-0.0024614683,
0.033798296,
0.0439082757,
0.0436451137,
0.013773689,
0.0130367475,
0.025542343,
-0.0291347876,
0.0162493922,
-0.0068027903,
0.0600448996,
-0.0183084197,
0.0290618762,
0.0334277973,
0.0585407689,
-0.0315007605,
-0.0319505334,
-0.0105329165,
0.0001410776,
0.0429154746,
0.0115960911,
0.0378709584,
-0.0474879593,
-0.0115220612,
-0.0554046407,
0.001749497,
-0.0669387132,
-0.0530356355,
0.0494655371,
0.0437530614,
0.0326891653,
-0.0333374962,
0.0240683705,
-0.0034324874,
0.0307278149,
0.0359941125,
0.0232222844,
-0.0201968476,
-0.0132504283,
0.0232007578,
-0.0467497408,
-0.0077709621,
-0.0169966053,
-0.0158082284,
-0.0319190361,
-0.0107506476,
-0.0406449176,
0.0478453003,
-0.0379347615,
-0.0159979519,
-0.0134177152,
-0.0148381209,
0.0205079801,
-0.0089515541,
0.0052189897,
-0.0222379342,
0.0123158544,
0.0617963299,
0.0463464074,
0.0371189937,
-0.0099862721,
-0.0765184611,
0.0360274836,
0.0122919902,
-0.0115399901,
0.0127788559,
-0.0221220851,
0.021209592,
0.0235567167,
-0.0573827699,
-0.0007272934,
0.0407663994,
2.709e-7,
0.0111369155,
0.0219609104,
0.0068464424,
0.0475282483,
-0.0178594552,
0.0011774179,
0.0094778938,
0.028626537,
-0.0237467568,
0.0029961509,
0.0097894436,
-0.0105550019,
0.0082287379,
0.0010695888,
-0.1341324598,
-0.0522102006,
-0.0628533661,
-0.0039470014,
-0.0315724947,
-0.0387682021,
0.0200066492,
0.1060668975,
0.007432071,
-0.0207399409,
-0.0465842858,
-0.0744383186,
0.049691204,
0.0141574629,
-0.0234352313,
-0.0334195644,
0.0117852185,
0.0310331695,
-0.0275313389,
-0.0142063992,
-0.0338101722,
0.0700529963,
0.044095505,
-0.0001746492,
-0.0087393494,
-0.0696127191,
0.0326334052,
-0.0134416539,
-0.0541589372,
-0.0156745911,
0.0630929321,
0.0338737108,
-0.0075431406,
-0.0238787718,
0.0312141571,
0.0189488735,
0.0686579868,
-0.0545283742,
-0.0213517901,
-0.0122587793,
-0.0004127584,
-0.0240689702,
0.0113024404,
-0.079897292,
0.0311136842,
-0.0318901241,
-0.0095684603,
0.0331146009,
-0.0661254525,
-0.0174695011,
0.0032132524,
0.0412194245,
0.0139514087,
1.932000041e-34,
0.0565398596,
-0.0128748156,
-0.0092382776,
0.0280254558,
0.0311941057,
-0.0120882848,
-0.0092996256,
0.0279770121,
0.0003767749,
-0.0917118192,
-0.0481996611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07984v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07984v1 | Anaphoric Structure Emerges Between Neural Networks | 2023-08-15T18:34:26 | 2023-08-15T18:34:26 | Nicholas Edwards, Hannah Rohde, Henry Conklin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pragmatics is core to natural language, enabling speakers to communicate
efficiently with structures like ellipsis and anaphora that can shorten
utterances without loss of meaning. These structures require a listener to
interpret an ambiguous form - like a pronoun - and infer the speaker's intended
meaning - who that pronoun refers to. Despite potential to introduce ambiguity,
anaphora is ubiquitous across human language. In an effort to better understand
the origins of anaphoric structure in natural language, we look to see if
analogous structures can emerge between artificial neural networks trained to
solve a communicative task. We show that: first, despite the potential for
increased ambiguity, languages with anaphoric structures are learnable by
neural models. Second, anaphoric structures emerge between models 'naturally'
without need for additional constraints. Finally, introducing an explicit
efficiency pressure on the speaker increases the prevalence of these
structures. We conclude that certain pragmatic structures straightforwardly
emerge between neural networks, without explicit efficiency pressures, but that
the competing needs of speakers and listeners conditions the degree and nature
of their emergence. | [
0.0630426481,
0.0677982941,
-0.0464777164,
0.0187317617,
-0.0391221903,
-0.0213498771,
-0.033702597,
0.0158297904,
-0.028647013,
-0.0072633107,
-0.0168774016,
-0.0171694737,
0.0058917496,
-0.0040169903,
0.0536281653,
-0.090359062,
0.0271097794,
-0.0237269569,
0.0279911198,
-0.0100284852,
0.0090991678,
-0.0282305758,
-0.0018356817,
0.0411001295,
0.0107029714,
0.0085653551,
-0.0297990832,
0.0217867438,
-0.0349608138,
0.0412736088,
0.0084922072,
0.0067675887,
-0.0330973677,
-0.004309806,
0.0000016058,
-0.0224119127,
0.0673695579,
-0.0215965845,
-0.0403455719,
0.0150748789,
0.0262305979,
0.0092470497,
0.0149169676,
-0.0290713795,
-0.0653740242,
-0.0242043529,
0.0235813204,
0.039644748,
0.0445125327,
0.0608565994,
0.0085246759,
-0.044734139,
0.0069877971,
-0.0506251045,
-0.0497110523,
-0.0453472584,
-0.0021357802,
-0.0984207019,
-0.0075524654,
0.0169116911,
-0.0302539337,
0.047836259,
0.0404238775,
0.0198650658,
-0.0010216285,
0.0081216712,
0.0228794012,
-0.0348807685,
-0.0230786465,
0.0603564605,
-0.0006166548,
-0.0002237942,
0.0321287587,
-0.0074389591,
0.0456803106,
-0.0033441926,
-0.0180768557,
0.0120862406,
0.0153027494,
0.0325097367,
0.0142939407,
-0.0139051257,
0.0049656294,
0.0111058438,
-0.002556151,
0.058803387,
-0.0232864972,
-0.0367055088,
0.0441704951,
-0.0231281556,
-0.0056465026,
-0.0531856455,
0.0412807055,
0.0043934402,
0.0204206686,
0.020732522,
-0.015344183,
-0.0091384035,
0.012060944,
-0.0590126701,
0.0375680812,
-0.0084424298,
-0.0149538722,
0.0208998565,
-0.0384908915,
0.0680140927,
-0.0088728443,
0.0373319797,
-0.0264087711,
0.0104999803,
-0.0628406629,
-0.0436102934,
-0.0547897965,
0.0616040453,
-0.0233715288,
-0.0120091364,
-0.0346222036,
0.0026052026,
-0.0314222611,
-0.0037046929,
-0.0211793948,
0.0501924716,
-0.0169372316,
0.0181429833,
-0.0236624051,
0.0066067772,
-0.0672237873,
0.0336666815,
-0.0075585255,
-0.0194429364,
0.0050894408,
0.026475694,
-0.0078970613,
0.0090636229,
-0.019651521,
0.0640522167,
0.0013894346,
0.0057497039,
-0.0019276581,
-0.0298888292,
-0.0496083945,
-0.0437952355,
0.0043422906,
-0.0153176375,
0.0255841054,
-0.021609731,
-0.0034653142,
-0.0949751288,
0.0095751323,
-0.0121322041,
-0.067932494,
0.0618436597,
0.0106510585,
0.0418259837,
0.0037789533,
0.0180415902,
0.0099527985,
0.0142262271,
0.0585605688,
-0.0295992121,
0.0339078419,
-0.0259662792,
0.0068253535,
0.0370965265,
0.0242449529,
-0.0591416582,
0.0124013498,
-0.03058571,
-0.0789559335,
0.0392843448,
0.0242531244,
0.089066647,
0.0017749731,
-0.0673167408,
0.0424074642,
0.0401321314,
0.0118699493,
0.011525997,
0.0737165809,
0.0404314473,
0.0179778915,
0.0495833755,
-0.0461337529,
-0.0274245273,
-0.0149295321,
-0.0031477071,
0.0006851848,
-0.0087557519,
-0.0256269164,
-0.0554938912,
-0.0057677245,
-0.0097418949,
0.0286572967,
-0.0151153672,
0.0094147492,
0.0339357667,
-0.0140915522,
0.0432442315,
0.0091402587,
-0.0574368797,
0.0027005549,
-0.0063021439,
-0.0117304269,
0.0457088985,
-0.0244005062,
0.0327977687,
-0.0043675657,
-0.0075452127,
0.0162148848,
0.0633883923,
0.0276620723,
-0.0231722258,
0.0735525861,
-0.0137231713,
0.0432196632,
0.0168583132,
0.0344997086,
-0.0162406024,
-0.0163725354,
-0.0067868074,
0.0036164385,
0.0027265029,
-0.0390029736,
0.027399322,
-0.0294202622,
-0.0209542904,
0.0229172632,
0.0411178619,
0.0009975848,
0.0159765482,
-0.0024020115,
0.0264157373,
0.0351175517,
-0.0387132242,
-0.0055270991,
0.0617721379,
-0.0653839856,
-0.0332573839,
0.0231989101,
-0.0436899737,
0.0278884545,
0.0200915541,
0.0122684343,
-0.0719857141,
0.0380194448,
-0.0951594338,
0.0427598618,
-0.0278628469,
0.0240250807,
-0.0042208931,
0.0206054188,
-0.0280729234,
0.0201081745,
-0.0068310089,
0.013257144,
0.0013629477,
-0.0018775332,
-0.0030843751,
-0.0250823237,
0.0082270494,
-0.0231514014,
0.0007886746,
-0.0142971268,
0.0091480436,
-0.0008100434,
-0.0389964767,
-0.0460926518,
-0.0313963071,
-0.0151627064,
0.0076946514,
0.0129431151,
0.0252030306,
-0.0415775515,
0.0087086158,
-0.0174537357,
-0.026793072,
0.0170044005,
-0.0224822201,
-0.004561767,
0.076507017,
0.0559673086,
-0.0643340722,
-0.0376059599,
0.0167113878,
-0.0358513966,
0.0107456716,
0.003379642,
-0.0525932349,
-0.0339092948,
0.0319554061,
0.0210099239,
-0.0107453698,
0.012366835,
-0.0697980076,
0.0016721661,
0.0380190909,
0.007555814,
0.0365156755,
-0.01845075,
0.0479482226,
0.0066391621,
-0.0222760178,
-0.0456454307,
0.0109350225,
-0.0453021675,
0.0063360096,
-0.0558114313,
-0.0780179501,
0.0098190205,
0.0871583074,
0.0125406077,
0.0005371167,
-0.0491875373,
0.0572767816,
-0.0097826561,
-0.0491657779,
0.0454390943,
-0.0661678165,
-0.0395565554,
0.012652982,
-0.0245143659,
-0.0036723355,
0.0773223341,
0.0253992919,
-0.0530576706,
0.0061863111,
-0.0399674997,
-0.0028440487,
0.0278484207,
0.0318561159,
0.0119656324,
0.0933332518,
-0.064678967,
-0.0726750866,
-0.0229167379,
-0.0047592116,
0.0096133146,
0.0467465073,
-0.0497835763,
-0.017682137,
0.0435875356,
-0.0875161141,
-0.0213558506,
-0.0683279559,
0.0112770246,
0.037776053,
0.0094218319,
-0.0398489758,
0.0434982628,
-0.0267011188,
-0.0255353022,
0.0004030202,
-0.0145290997,
-0.0116540138,
-0.0360853821,
0.0306049827,
0.0138578741,
0.0174525492,
0.0217224695,
-0.0108002452,
0.002146069,
0.0239394512,
0.0466049314,
0.0772850066,
-0.0350393951,
-0.0026354159,
0.0082126902,
-0.0292241052,
-0.0744601414,
0.0250503588,
0.0240887832,
-0.0328796431,
-0.0122839585,
0.0961287469,
0.0015435523,
-0.0170122646,
0.0441124327,
0.0000759207,
0.0523578189,
0.0103843668,
0.0332167223,
-0.0539013073,
-0.0311767366,
0.0044171349,
0.0168953035,
-0.0449902825,
-0.0172824543,
-0.011596553,
-0.0986566916,
0.0017984299,
-0.0121292416,
-0.0794407874,
-0.0026216824,
0.0238247141,
0.0066392012,
-0.001834171,
0.0022761628,
0.0108029973,
-0.0354305357,
0.012425798,
0.0234337915,
-0.0636731684,
-0.032757286,
-0.0281275474,
-0.0469175428,
0.0535336286,
0.0334583484,
0.0604265332,
-0.0490630902,
0.0235167351,
0.0182204526,
0.0287395418,
0.0079894578,
0.0007617735,
0.0497103669,
0.0390305072,
-0.0292220414,
-0.0314966962,
0.0356614552,
-0.0385719426,
0.0211662278,
0.0227307715,
0.0474581756,
0.0073131234,
-0.039225556,
0.0141568407,
0.0560777821,
0.0275036916,
0.0831297114,
0.0586633347,
-0.0646653622,
-0.0531530455,
-0.0025251654,
0.0252334736,
-0.0467109643,
-0.0416211225,
0.0203448832,
0.0168905687,
-0.027827844,
-0.0985265821,
-0.0667121634,
-0.0223846901,
0.0240929201,
0.0670150742,
-0.0152744073,
-0.0044565806,
-0.0198485106,
-0.0041504097,
-0.0185125656,
0.0060076215,
-0.026621243,
-0.0144870905,
-0.0217765532,
0.0547762178,
0.0218074732,
-0.0211663935,
0.0250492785,
-0.0667653829,
-0.0851479247,
0.0257982742,
0.0555361845,
0.025713956,
0.0300826393,
-0.0107310526,
-0.071623981,
-0.0007742484,
0.0636931062,
-0.0325856172,
0.0607427247,
0.0650014058,
-0.0281120129,
-0.0050195171,
0.0747932419,
0.0121453013,
-0.0243914276,
-0.0118591208,
0.0184188075,
-0.0661203191,
-0.0381427892,
0.0403926149,
-0.0049843378,
-0.0031201225,
0.0109379385,
-0.0226411931,
-0.0155923907,
-0.0023520235,
0.0052970476,
-0.0145334303,
-0.0462639369,
0.0056910939,
-0.0017004495,
0.0577415451,
-0.007063257,
-0.0443405621,
0.0181665439,
0.0655854493,
0.0123165287,
-0.0339254923,
0.0467271097,
-0.02342421,
-0.0262436401,
0.0251396038,
0.0246919002,
0.0662180111,
-0.016990874,
0.0405811965,
-0.004054558,
0.0002930591,
0.0263735279,
-0.0165836047,
-0.0390558541,
-0.0008877915,
-0.0463739336,
-0.0528997816,
0.0357672721,
0.0108058304,
0.0659072921,
-0.0097297858,
0.0338927172,
-0.0622911043,
0.0369466171,
-0.0021952086,
0.0030675973,
-0.029630892,
-0.0180108417,
0.0472642966,
0.0259670913,
-0.0161545575,
-0.0272488035,
0.0420184992,
0.0171267167,
0.0204242449,
0.0053438134,
0.0113568762,
-0.0216186475,
-0.0469093658,
0.0063375789,
0.0091470415,
-0.0138012841,
0.0388725661,
-0.0281892046,
-0.0372455381,
-0.0111505669,
0.0107910484,
0.0307009816,
-0.0517946519,
0.0574053526,
0.0588354655,
-0.0011206312,
-0.0448882468,
-0.0487485677,
0.0190586224,
0.0049121245,
0.0043807114,
-0.0187239964,
-6.063763364e-33,
-0.0482970923,
-0.0310587566,
-0.0239290148,
0.000719741,
-0.0296559539,
-0.0132887401,
-0.032569699,
0.0139285289,
-0.0116012404,
0.036954511,
-0.0242523849,
0.023716379,
0.0233626422,
0.0103911422,
0.0438058227,
-0.0647976473,
0.029825177,
0.0049713659,
0.0130535606,
-0.0097929286,
0.0294458698,
0.0236885864,
0.0414787494,
-0.0618795864,
0.0045366022,
0.0308714397,
-0.0176746082,
0.0277213529,
0.0036062563,
0.0395762771,
0.0271375719,
0.030942956,
0.0042484119,
-0.0022167014,
-0.0023390898,
0.0090399543,
-0.081314899,
-0.0487539358,
0.0718218386,
0.0545629114,
-0.1061320081,
-0.0676493794,
0.0994043276,
-0.0701410323,
-0.0060333456,
0.0315141529,
0.0315607823,
-0.0110523254,
0.0227040537,
0.0057644951,
-0.0286365524,
-0.0293702688,
-0.0105139175,
-0.0200986769,
-0.0044898433,
0.0193413887,
-0.0450164601,
-0.0418479592,
-0.0357782319,
0.0183387343,
0.0167826209,
0.039150808,
-0.0085127903,
0.0283068009,
0.0058681765,
0.0479469374,
0.1009166613,
0.0196830537,
0.0055938922,
0.0087110093,
0.0430762433,
0.0346773043,
0.0284842104,
0.0179463159,
0.0597429313,
0.0253641531,
-0.0358504876,
-0.0743277073,
0.0392196774,
0.0125458799,
-0.0120997764,
-0.0290587954,
-0.0543863215,
-0.0405561738,
-0.0415561311,
-0.0549010634,
-0.0036012374,
-0.0529797338,
0.0066281799,
-0.0181433,
0.037442591,
0.0563057512,
0.0125303473,
-0.0626917258,
-0.0296340752,
-0.012537335,
-0.0112975528,
0.0217141937,
0.0155586684,
0.0307273343,
-0.0347905271,
0.0027926853,
-0.049815435,
0.0132150119,
0.0519692786,
0.039798148,
0.0598014705,
0.0151537359,
-0.0380466655,
-0.0276027173,
-0.0094175879,
-0.0076014814,
-0.0616417006,
-0.0487241037,
0.0521255322,
0.0603246801,
-0.0289075952,
0.0414811596,
0.0298546273,
0.0125583634,
-0.0464247949,
0.0171601214,
-0.0011182092,
0.0487508178,
-0.0274059679,
-0.0480018519,
0.0023515513,
0.0305498391,
0.0137515161,
-0.0557164624,
-0.0010487182,
-0.0096570877,
2.54e-7,
0.01567889,
0.031112846,
0.0252686013,
0.0387988314,
0.0149642583,
0.0024100051,
-0.027120227,
-0.0044452017,
-0.0503099449,
-0.0141976606,
-0.0012284233,
0.0055756113,
0.0440529808,
0.0290469341,
-0.1203129515,
0.0373036489,
-0.0281696264,
0.017186733,
-0.0166963283,
0.0085752932,
0.057526283,
0.0686562434,
0.0458779559,
-0.0236617103,
-0.0334113501,
-0.0398467667,
0.0375712328,
-0.019935606,
0.0245426744,
0.0545263067,
0.0035063936,
0.0016429031,
0.0060648969,
0.058045838,
0.016244024,
0.0179106575,
-0.0059450045,
0.0538537763,
0.0376206003,
-0.0253467616,
0.0015821882,
-0.0299133118,
-0.0223417468,
0.0016815511,
0.0237805787,
-0.0712667629,
-0.0319938734,
0.0337384678,
0.0280136112,
-0.0078065326,
-0.0197158493,
-0.014493404,
-0.0059295534,
-0.0025813931,
0.0195344612,
-0.0451887958,
0.0276760682,
-0.0542329401,
-0.0279089995,
0.0346555859,
-0.005820978,
0.0149415573,
-0.0107408427,
0.0066420119,
0.007195421,
-0.0608162805,
-0.0101168659,
1.957279369e-34,
0.0027171329,
-0.0011882489,
0.0549640171,
0.0674420148,
-0.0084006274,
-0.0056902762,
-0.0116695734,
0.0201500133,
0.0584055968,
-0.0058775106,
-0.0062416261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07973v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07973v1 | "Beware of deception": Detecting Half-Truth and Debunking it through Controlled Claim Editing | 2023-08-15T18:21:26 | 2023-08-15T18:21:26 | Sandeep Singamsetty, Nishtha Madaan, Sameep Mehta, Varad Bhatnagar, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL | The prevalence of half-truths, which are statements containing some truth but
that are ultimately deceptive, has risen with the increasing use of the
internet. To help combat this problem, we have created a comprehensive pipeline
consisting of a half-truth detection model and a claim editing model. Our
approach utilizes the T5 model for controlled claim editing; "controlled" here
means precise adjustments to select parts of a claim. Our methodology achieves
an average BLEU score of 0.88 (on a scale of 0-1) and a disinfo-debunk score of
85% on edited claims. Significantly, our T5-based approach outperforms other
Language Models such as GPT2, RoBERTa, PEGASUS, and Tailor, with average
improvements of 82%, 57%, 42%, and 23% in disinfo-debunk scores, respectively.
By extending the LIAR PLUS dataset, we achieve an F1 score of 82% for the
half-truth detection model, setting a new benchmark in the field. While
previous attempts have been made at half-truth detection, our approach is, to
the best of our knowledge, the first to attempt to debunk half-truths. | [
0.0802453458,
0.0354312807,
-0.0077153156,
0.0496122725,
-0.0643943176,
0.0038462831,
0.0069849244,
-0.019554222,
-0.0165177658,
-0.072035715,
-0.0060800151,
-0.0116165392,
0.0232355241,
0.0545527935,
0.020292541,
-0.017485369,
0.0672411323,
0.0360651501,
0.0766948536,
-0.0062798816,
0.0176883098,
0.0308952332,
-0.027561998,
0.0126203159,
-0.0703984648,
-0.0357965082,
0.0393405668,
0.0218905527,
0.0243057571,
0.0064789671,
0.019550873,
0.0626063719,
-0.0016024308,
0.107826978,
0.0000021307,
-0.0273721553,
-0.0314718634,
0.0207681917,
-0.0921877921,
0.0355250128,
0.035875164,
-0.0201546419,
-0.0234912112,
0.0122593073,
0.0087993909,
-0.0111508816,
0.0239873249,
0.0782627314,
0.1034345552,
0.1206599846,
0.0031393394,
-0.0032635529,
0.0195717756,
0.0069665234,
-0.0201426428,
-0.0140557569,
0.0465760753,
0.0127205234,
-0.0273890495,
-0.0167228952,
0.0142737459,
0.0177831762,
0.0000828651,
-0.0089897951,
-0.0581077598,
0.0085797571,
-0.0662610456,
-0.0281857923,
0.0167422984,
0.0138438148,
-0.0287352148,
-0.0585160926,
0.0059793447,
-0.001395213,
0.0038420565,
0.0110015674,
0.0006364163,
0.0399907045,
-0.0142985769,
-0.0236951783,
0.0032472238,
-0.0464265645,
0.0231326669,
0.0143053094,
0.0136970803,
0.0566063821,
0.0064108181,
-0.0477864593,
-0.0305428654,
-0.0327796973,
0.0561188199,
-0.0638608187,
-0.0006315486,
-0.0152833508,
-0.0088732103,
0.0087670451,
-0.0836368129,
-0.0030624578,
0.0706581399,
-0.0576833673,
0.010512962,
-0.0000890311,
-0.02505612,
0.0312354248,
-0.0340698473,
0.0230300557,
0.0098294839,
-0.001376393,
0.002100124,
-0.0366530009,
0.0339456238,
-0.0045714579,
-0.0282217395,
0.0321111456,
-0.0365206189,
0.018644115,
-0.0525559224,
-0.0258847885,
-0.0223415308,
0.0199744105,
-0.0075406637,
-0.005465358,
-0.0092732096,
-0.029865142,
0.0049068215,
0.045985233,
0.0084140031,
0.0399929732,
-0.0205431953,
-0.0751415268,
-0.0102540692,
0.0198910423,
0.0129231373,
-0.0091256509,
-0.0061863945,
-0.0357580036,
0.0219791662,
-0.0125373695,
-0.0272428561,
-0.042729985,
-0.0492318273,
-0.0685302615,
-0.0288425386,
-0.0527155809,
0.0171454325,
-0.0373206511,
-0.016046565,
-0.0332180522,
-0.0056129796,
0.0246691648,
-0.0322593451,
0.0189600401,
-0.0342584774,
-0.0294392649,
0.0756744444,
0.0009963484,
-0.0327314772,
0.0429507121,
0.028854819,
0.0780642182,
0.0696397573,
0.02912613,
0.0200782064,
-0.0072780033,
0.0542327091,
0.0234909039,
0.0766409039,
0.0006026156,
0.0300009549,
0.0010270749,
0.0001459407,
0.0225788206,
-0.0235094,
-0.0520467758,
0.1161475852,
-0.0419010557,
0.0046043471,
-0.0222572424,
0.0434906445,
0.0172862001,
0.0242580939,
-0.0061890646,
-0.0337952562,
0.0166777372,
-0.0894263834,
-0.0178060662,
0.0166162346,
0.0291692484,
0.0334644988,
-0.028908655,
-0.0302057099,
0.0038290366,
-0.0093402294,
-0.0027108924,
-0.0380212776,
0.0081756981,
-0.0461569205,
0.0171896257,
0.0223125555,
-0.0125191733,
0.0016475047,
-0.068750836,
0.0060866033,
-0.0023818747,
0.0576785542,
0.0163528547,
-0.0096771838,
-0.0635279119,
0.0301777516,
0.024555197,
0.0808981284,
-0.006331428,
-0.019079797,
0.0257683583,
-0.0125374207,
-0.0721968561,
0.0352447033,
-0.0243281517,
0.0268719792,
0.0148166269,
0.0283656418,
-0.0200518426,
0.0128836427,
0.0207141414,
0.0347045921,
0.0153502403,
0.0045420956,
0.014101658,
0.0247835182,
-0.0336178802,
-0.0254349615,
-0.0093517043,
0.0104265455,
0.0147737479,
-0.0559578873,
-0.0084425109,
0.0557675399,
-0.0266491249,
0.0339571945,
-0.0402990356,
-0.0295953434,
0.0741165727,
-0.0072552548,
0.0096313935,
0.0086374218,
-0.0444471091,
-0.0063260361,
-0.046263393,
0.0045035249,
-0.0070220246,
0.0013618227,
0.0205433443,
0.0603197999,
-0.017445052,
0.01885405,
-0.0534979776,
-0.0349502489,
0.0021217822,
-0.0334393308,
-0.0016387154,
0.0069109681,
0.0122249229,
-0.026397014,
0.0152471038,
-0.0245078821,
-0.0147514381,
-0.0097703757,
-0.0705810636,
-0.0051750354,
-0.020999372,
-0.0047394955,
0.0339697003,
-0.0166531783,
-0.0089993263,
0.0266842581,
0.0021318432,
-0.0454085767,
0.0068428004,
0.0082429191,
0.019919496,
-0.0079516917,
0.0060393191,
-0.0268658642,
0.0561735518,
-0.0251984708,
0.0049867705,
0.0076916874,
-0.0958064646,
0.0049870987,
-0.0157217216,
-0.0607626438,
0.0127515309,
-0.0180674624,
-0.0297592338,
-0.0310025681,
0.0381201506,
-0.0375228152,
0.0185778849,
0.0433526821,
-0.0006953831,
0.0123336604,
0.0302373171,
0.009212669,
0.0012630841,
-0.0024608811,
0.0362526961,
0.0087748384,
-0.0787909552,
0.0438283384,
0.0520665087,
0.0572322868,
0.001083494,
-0.0257352311,
0.0290951487,
-0.0341418609,
-0.0342362225,
0.060229104,
-0.013949302,
-0.0275595933,
0.037442103,
-0.0416162498,
-0.051020354,
0.089872919,
-0.0386611708,
0.0402576253,
-0.0344844423,
-0.0073504923,
-0.0008663035,
0.0042336471,
-0.0082166493,
0.0527144112,
0.0237950236,
0.0089730369,
0.0130273271,
-0.0332207754,
0.0551257432,
-0.0173236206,
-0.0225752778,
-0.0679223165,
0.0387602448,
0.0181279704,
-0.0327667706,
-0.0349596627,
-0.106319882,
-0.0220110621,
-0.0100763068,
-0.0400982127,
-0.0256089848,
-0.112978369,
-0.0649426281,
0.0224496648,
0.0918303877,
0.007259374,
0.0170100071,
0.0092285015,
-0.0045335828,
0.0463840924,
-0.0023435811,
0.0545902252,
-0.0206944514,
-0.0274130683,
0.0780515075,
-0.0347459912,
0.0544113927,
0.039843753,
-0.0618186332,
-0.0425333604,
-0.0527816229,
-0.0104163243,
-0.0159291178,
-0.004526977,
-0.0353801213,
-0.0031092819,
0.0811171904,
0.0153332641,
0.0535171703,
0.0153702218,
0.0104017388,
-0.0100408643,
0.0338822156,
-0.020433329,
-0.1110889539,
-0.0289658047,
0.0087056942,
-0.0264665838,
-0.0536521561,
-0.001012007,
-0.0273146406,
-0.0716129914,
0.048322048,
0.0203563031,
-0.0081348447,
-0.025681559,
-0.0423780829,
0.0098721571,
0.0401318744,
-0.0081861243,
0.0022351069,
0.0251561347,
-0.0234952439,
-0.0307879802,
-0.0210309103,
-0.0012432092,
0.0242582094,
-0.016270427,
0.0404833145,
0.0068468535,
0.0583625175,
-0.0089132385,
-0.0328354351,
0.0039048863,
0.0173194744,
-0.0445450135,
-0.011007146,
0.0663191602,
-0.055359181,
0.015691597,
0.0108503327,
0.0228701923,
0.0375518128,
-0.0139540909,
-0.0054669254,
0.0719303563,
-0.0116748093,
-0.0634537041,
-0.0022117852,
0.0270335451,
0.0207564924,
0.0691207126,
0.0128268721,
0.0239209048,
-0.0094850445,
-0.0190587789,
-0.0113853281,
-0.0197821409,
-0.0218293387,
0.0292525571,
0.0129735786,
-0.0067370902,
-0.0826105103,
-0.0052398774,
-0.0013405092,
-0.0170947872,
-0.0168038625,
-0.0032260909,
0.0210534353,
0.0134667829,
-0.0448845588,
-0.0053510158,
-0.0410846435,
0.0658723116,
-0.0277436823,
-0.0103239017,
0.0271073356,
-0.0436629057,
0.0009891361,
0.031340193,
-0.0330486372,
-0.0281432942,
0.0112002622,
0.0168298651,
0.0166287012,
0.0486948565,
-0.0054576737,
-0.0309182294,
0.0010220144,
0.008967489,
-0.0542630404,
0.0458656065,
0.0181003418,
-0.0315898024,
0.0146755064,
0.0061054337,
-0.0165268257,
-0.0028709273,
0.0384160914,
0.0006711195,
-0.0266910642,
-0.018645538,
0.0549854971,
0.0352075212,
0.0146303931,
0.0226228144,
0.0523706675,
-0.0478857644,
0.0291454736,
-0.0284808669,
-0.033140704,
0.0083122207,
0.0168104786,
0.0055644047,
0.0105263619,
-0.0225471444,
-0.0096233832,
-0.0628788918,
0.0070298137,
-0.0402437933,
-0.0196999311,
-0.0338740014,
0.0266637951,
-0.0115697281,
-0.0324186385,
-0.0272172056,
0.0225120801,
0.0162340403,
0.0400878005,
0.0178874359,
0.0129954945,
0.0190144237,
-0.0273401812,
-0.0283811372,
-0.0276503786,
-0.0355571993,
0.0032912721,
-0.031741064,
0.0252803843,
0.0023495182,
0.0310527775,
0.0303039253,
-0.0078900112,
-0.0564927533,
0.0156303346,
-0.0077374941,
-0.0043399241,
-0.0346457064,
0.0253930856,
0.0011754001,
-0.0422944613,
0.034938395,
0.0115064932,
0.000223489,
0.1039242148,
-0.0153345065,
-0.0336128548,
-0.0505824834,
-0.0673672929,
-0.0503877327,
0.0418016873,
0.0010994967,
0.0039827861,
-0.1073075682,
-0.0347302444,
0.0288626999,
0.0327703729,
0.0356842875,
0.0185516775,
-0.0182092711,
0.060188584,
0.0195355676,
-0.0447181575,
-0.0536445603,
0.0170537774,
0.0498836376,
-0.0069431299,
0.0008495979,
-6.518972082e-33,
-0.0149272243,
-0.0330800638,
-0.0280364212,
0.019402517,
-0.0016037642,
0.0365696512,
0.0151880905,
-0.0178196132,
-0.0394526348,
0.0493358076,
0.0210324246,
0.0456443951,
-0.0005111421,
-0.0033106366,
-0.0823888034,
0.0300746448,
0.0753177851,
0.0136477165,
-0.0545356385,
-0.0026913995,
0.0402243286,
-0.0094067678,
0.0447920002,
-0.0491337664,
0.0591617897,
-0.0027407119,
-0.0511063039,
0.0046597719,
-0.1002238691,
0.0440429896,
0.0177239459,
0.0110248122,
0.0133339847,
0.0085530244,
0.0056709489,
-0.0249069817,
-0.0330566354,
0.0245815888,
0.0603637248,
0.0192007776,
0.0066347062,
-0.0192265101,
0.0180488043,
-0.0107339788,
-0.0245602001,
-0.0176949725,
0.0129186064,
-0.0173268337,
0.0212196633,
-0.0345088355,
-0.0779800788,
0.0188652501,
0.0077297441,
-0.0242919941,
-0.0398789421,
0.0514074191,
-0.0009646968,
0.0227653645,
-0.1129027456,
0.0145042799,
-0.0310667045,
0.0001837951,
0.0020290294,
-0.0926985145,
-0.0256698783,
0.0501762107,
0.0229736399,
0.0541029461,
-0.0101535758,
0.0508925766,
-0.0110030668,
0.0153714856,
0.0740242675,
0.0892871395,
0.012132775,
-0.0636135563,
-0.0709549859,
-0.0212057438,
0.0172741301,
-0.0043142703,
0.0038432339,
-0.0126121929,
-0.0227334723,
0.0187669583,
-0.0670376495,
0.0116264373,
-0.0295843761,
0.0361603945,
0.0071558435,
0.0582880378,
-0.0392231382,
0.0105770845,
-0.0086597502,
-0.0387687236,
0.0568313487,
-0.0095023531,
-0.0099482946,
0.0113413557,
0.014568965,
0.0029026784,
-0.0268894397,
0.0440436788,
0.0185389835,
0.0320428833,
0.0101035163,
-0.0471719466,
0.0765878484,
0.0025255943,
-0.056756001,
0.0369267911,
-0.0251190048,
0.0599799566,
0.0167212281,
-0.0295020863,
0.0088860765,
-0.0106436005,
-0.0081696585,
-0.0369495265,
-0.0016219238,
-0.0250379872,
-0.0457548946,
0.0383512266,
-0.0098954216,
0.0214935448,
-0.0215241592,
0.0102355396,
-0.0008756644,
0.0267480426,
0.0140058016,
-0.0763065815,
0.0131500838,
0.0079110395,
2.902e-7,
0.0240509547,
0.0438378491,
-0.0021334018,
-0.0074058385,
0.025653787,
0.0462233052,
0.0360420272,
0.0116982525,
0.0258759242,
-0.0507749096,
-0.0498197228,
-0.0008934373,
0.0255433656,
0.0126837697,
-0.0379844233,
0.0330602713,
-0.0221885443,
-0.023964202,
-0.0488692708,
-0.033096578,
0.0065910923,
0.0534647182,
0.0589126535,
-0.0251295902,
0.0012208697,
0.0157404989,
0.0535857901,
0.0411653705,
-0.0487503298,
0.0180135574,
0.0224778075,
-0.0302063022,
0.0154995434,
0.0282572117,
-0.0368737243,
0.0333606303,
-0.0139919473,
0.0656064078,
-0.0113700908,
0.0156601798,
-0.0162388477,
-0.0315289646,
-0.0054771407,
-0.0527337268,
0.0495097823,
0.0156394988,
-0.0076107765,
-0.0474327244,
-0.0539390668,
0.035687454,
0.0387297794,
-0.0383642353,
-0.0211689249,
0.030667359,
0.004140411,
0.0271895435,
-0.0061578518,
-0.0098249745,
-0.0140927378,
0.0161650181,
-0.0377087891,
-0.0169841368,
0.0265381485,
-0.0138761317,
0.0542514138,
-0.0635987818,
0.0152461613,
2.294185003e-34,
0.0130471317,
-0.0067456467,
0.0120012909,
-0.0378340557,
0.07966052,
0.0307777729,
0.0054050512,
-0.0240470208,
-0.0178655665,
0.005499634,
-0.0253677852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07971v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07971v1 | MultiSChuBERT: Effective Multimodal Fusion for Scholarly Document Quality Prediction | 2023-08-15T18:18:34 | 2023-08-15T18:18:34 | Gideon Maillette de Buy Wenniger, Thomas van Dongen, Lambert Schomaker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | Automatic assessment of the quality of scholarly documents is a difficult
task with high potential impact. Multimodality, in particular the addition of
visual information next to text, has been shown to improve the performance on
scholarly document quality prediction (SDQP) tasks. We propose the multimodal
predictive model MultiSChuBERT. It combines a textual model based on chunking
full paper text and aggregating computed BERT chunk-encodings (SChuBERT), with
a visual model based on Inception V3.Our work contributes to the current
state-of-the-art in SDQP in three ways. First, we show that the method of
combining visual and textual embeddings can substantially influence the
results. Second, we demonstrate that gradual-unfreezing of the weights of the
visual sub-model, reduces its tendency to ovefit the data, improving results.
Third, we show the retained benefit of multimodality when replacing standard
BERT$_{\textrm{BASE}}$ embeddings with more recent state-of-the-art text
embedding models.
Using BERT$_{\textrm{BASE}}$ embeddings, on the (log) number of citations
prediction task with the ACL-BiblioMetry dataset, our MultiSChuBERT
(text+visual) model obtains an $R^{2}$ score of 0.454 compared to 0.432 for the
SChuBERT (text only) model. Similar improvements are obtained on the PeerRead
accept/reject prediction task. In our experiments using SciBERT, scincl,
SPECTER and SPECTER2.0 embeddings, we show that each of these tailored
embeddings adds further improvements over the standard BERT$_{\textrm{BASE}}$
embeddings, with the SPECTER2.0 embeddings performing best. | [
0.0553221963,
0.0659031719,
0.0174777173,
0.0142992586,
-0.0200200398,
-0.0213358421,
0.0385620482,
0.0423070453,
0.0077593983,
-0.0534335114,
-0.0228649713,
0.0138796689,
0.0097100828,
0.0295820776,
0.0324968137,
-0.036235556,
0.0308616646,
0.0261765905,
0.0516512692,
-0.0092119575,
0.0419307388,
-0.0332778729,
0.0390096083,
0.0316378251,
-0.0066615432,
-0.0375867598,
-0.0106009087,
0.0126236621,
0.0078934589,
-0.0030873558,
-0.0109452615,
0.0621685199,
0.0350468345,
0.0449774824,
0.0000019671,
-0.0215011742,
-0.0133390902,
0.0526455082,
0.0606687106,
0.0357869193,
0.0648905337,
-0.0251084361,
0.0179444794,
-0.0115543557,
-0.0045941737,
0.0347583517,
0.0069459318,
0.0754863769,
0.0602304637,
0.0137503175,
-0.0170263946,
-0.0045172838,
0.064821884,
0.0019002876,
-0.0050775628,
0.0031886916,
-0.0166197643,
0.001957417,
0.0034724341,
0.0479493588,
-0.0360072814,
0.0433281101,
-0.0071887025,
-0.0586839356,
0.0779646114,
0.0305371992,
-0.0265446138,
-0.0254225843,
0.0030074294,
0.0231438875,
-0.0069949129,
0.0191516615,
-0.0088811768,
0.0315211788,
-0.0029496048,
0.0827668756,
-0.0371268652,
-0.0191869661,
-0.0136529915,
-0.0257240683,
-0.0491657667,
-0.0055904817,
-0.0037415735,
0.0063937162,
0.0376593433,
-0.0306951627,
0.0171032343,
-0.0502082035,
0.020328775,
0.0437411517,
-0.0268875994,
0.0061048148,
-0.0105107073,
-0.0185113121,
0.0290800743,
-0.0300825518,
-0.0098237991,
-0.0542505831,
0.0282835569,
-0.0054098945,
0.044953648,
-0.0039056749,
-0.0511689186,
0.0534317307,
-0.0287157781,
0.0316351578,
0.0021877566,
0.0198161248,
0.0060228002,
0.0023127021,
-0.0386708416,
0.003722471,
0.0107864374,
0.003189221,
-0.0017512848,
-0.0615061447,
-0.0524253435,
-0.0220916048,
-0.0102790436,
0.0255767219,
0.0223781858,
0.0182188675,
-0.0212893579,
0.028449541,
-0.0353049487,
0.0410097837,
0.007736498,
0.010007184,
-0.0407894403,
0.026573943,
0.0163036603,
0.0247504786,
0.0108233662,
-0.0122178104,
0.0214116238,
0.0286866743,
-0.0064315856,
-0.0255992245,
0.010896815,
-0.0399384163,
-0.0428895168,
-0.0404232442,
0.0647570044,
-0.0184110329,
0.0494643897,
-0.0173970889,
0.0047607287,
-0.0112814503,
-0.0381553657,
0.0128663816,
-0.0366151966,
0.0556010157,
-0.0465023927,
-0.0173452906,
0.0253703035,
0.0117312223,
-0.0351109356,
0.0318767093,
0.0107232649,
0.0026844768,
0.0494249687,
0.0062389825,
0.0039398507,
0.0365262292,
0.023051342,
0.0329811461,
0.0092845727,
-0.0255978536,
-0.0288695674,
0.0415317863,
0.0260817576,
0.0559508279,
-0.0652888417,
-0.0347374417,
0.0886601135,
0.0275329929,
0.0585701726,
0.0194128659,
-0.0090576671,
0.0036466511,
0.042071078,
0.0206553172,
-0.0075425678,
0.0563701168,
0.0247348584,
0.0151484581,
0.0898227394,
0.0410808548,
0.0123658683,
-0.032298997,
-0.0109495353,
0.0115104932,
-0.017807357,
-0.0613671094,
0.0201086421,
-0.013278109,
-0.0416335054,
-0.0111771608,
-0.0148358783,
-0.0551885106,
0.0250149108,
0.013250174,
0.0594624169,
0.0637483299,
0.097174041,
-0.0196461082,
0.0260077156,
-0.0298695266,
-0.0268426612,
0.0409554578,
-0.012526527,
-0.011693418,
-0.0039737532,
-0.0739635229,
-0.0568471178,
-0.0012528776,
-0.0178920217,
0.0027754328,
-0.0298697874,
0.0239653736,
-0.0187648218,
-0.0670156404,
-0.0272665657,
0.0310105942,
0.000584972,
0.033806093,
-0.0236269161,
0.0026171112,
0.0287131239,
0.0095914993,
-0.0521911047,
0.0099439742,
0.0209222864,
-0.0318912156,
-0.0211323984,
-0.0045602182,
0.0178881064,
-0.0308599044,
0.0587561503,
-0.0791562125,
0.0383462012,
0.0195233189,
-0.0217915103,
-0.0246427637,
0.0277310833,
-0.0432572402,
-0.0118634375,
-0.0336532295,
-0.0284087807,
-0.0130847199,
0.0139512001,
-0.0079540769,
0.0336987004,
-0.0321195945,
0.0189067945,
0.0274064988,
-0.0404162891,
0.0298662018,
0.0198603421,
-0.0737323537,
0.0057997368,
0.0125338854,
0.0399186574,
0.0515148677,
-0.0193139426,
-0.0226778127,
-0.0166620538,
-0.0984629914,
-0.0154300975,
0.0200853255,
-0.0255456157,
-0.0504850596,
-0.0576605834,
0.0243757498,
-0.0065380749,
0.0006167573,
-0.0024899968,
-0.0405061655,
0.0333092175,
0.0280685015,
-0.0086687962,
0.0313606262,
-0.0193839669,
-0.0573848635,
-0.0159810856,
0.0797555745,
0.021899851,
0.020986395,
-0.0408986583,
-0.0256872643,
-0.0351304486,
-0.0024585878,
-0.0015123454,
-0.0032143388,
0.0096754897,
-0.0283733867,
0.0167964045,
0.0400028713,
0.0078950021,
-0.0080276318,
0.0329536162,
0.002108684,
-0.057248421,
-0.0161844548,
0.0062474604,
0.0260354765,
0.0450065769,
-0.0126409931,
-0.0115624303,
-0.031312149,
-0.0264097322,
0.0015156993,
-0.0553220548,
0.007105446,
0.0161219742,
0.0046110572,
-0.0412367471,
-0.0227296725,
0.012366537,
0.0325129442,
0.0014152323,
-0.0518563278,
0.0519322343,
-0.0305167735,
0.0073628239,
-0.0373140648,
0.0327308066,
-0.0212491676,
0.0158290826,
0.025998842,
0.0035538692,
0.0148259336,
0.031674128,
-0.0648546219,
0.0276451372,
0.0510259718,
-0.0420225561,
-0.0114984689,
0.0308088362,
-0.0133063504,
-0.0326929092,
0.0034418497,
0.0083197895,
-0.0114077125,
-0.0019711494,
0.0040714899,
-0.0107339676,
-0.0339661948,
-0.0647082776,
-0.004885036,
0.0045476616,
0.0376033895,
-0.036243964,
-0.0393303595,
0.0070317341,
0.0652782023,
0.0399159975,
-0.00490053,
-0.0000703696,
-0.0452324711,
-0.0027608899,
0.0355569683,
-0.0102826338,
-0.0001687687,
-0.0523279235,
-0.026862707,
0.0200672876,
0.0004825008,
-0.0401622914,
-0.0152576957,
0.0183506198,
-0.0499047413,
0.0288643911,
0.0772423521,
0.0180281717,
-0.0453325659,
-0.0541467816,
-0.0418143198,
0.0281875227,
0.0088003473,
0.0014940678,
-0.0726435259,
-0.0301726256,
-0.0065913037,
0.0197836272,
0.0173246283,
-0.0170554221,
0.0225004163,
-0.0943199769,
0.0641737357,
-0.003693481,
0.0334218889,
-0.0074479976,
-0.0237619299,
-0.0017640928,
-0.0329530798,
-0.0085606184,
-0.0149459885,
0.0222214051,
0.030396495,
-0.0044899448,
-0.0265567955,
-0.0476643145,
-0.0164264143,
-0.0610923991,
-0.0144542111,
0.034229368,
0.0648356527,
-0.0277153086,
-0.0902446434,
-0.0034064455,
0.0103165852,
-0.0181237012,
-0.0120362518,
0.1119557768,
-0.0287523083,
0.035241358,
-0.0171642154,
-0.0116637507,
0.0572995692,
-0.0217171982,
-0.0047895745,
0.0520417988,
0.0183619298,
-0.0204898957,
-0.1179782301,
0.0296820458,
-0.0429538414,
0.038480632,
0.0138837527,
-0.0505737886,
-0.0214051045,
0.0002981701,
0.0410857908,
-0.0234562606,
0.0015112533,
0.0010633651,
-0.0325293206,
-0.0315253474,
-0.082773976,
-0.0147080179,
-0.0314418413,
0.0075439326,
0.0293959603,
-0.0060961791,
-0.0141986916,
-0.0016249208,
-0.0515021086,
0.0085507296,
0.0373783559,
0.016088916,
-0.0293500517,
0.0473746881,
0.03626775,
-0.0009295411,
-0.0209498852,
-0.0068749641,
0.0535985157,
-0.0295493808,
-0.0495015308,
0.0543294735,
0.0130498111,
0.0083518028,
-0.0187852643,
-0.063201949,
0.0578692146,
0.0639074072,
-0.0056791534,
-0.0212030448,
0.025122365,
-0.0358059667,
-0.0408988893,
-0.0137379803,
-0.0396229737,
0.0124681778,
-0.0575614572,
-0.0331882313,
0.0020425601,
-0.0076202243,
-0.0282578599,
0.008494338,
0.0545819923,
-0.060066063,
0.0263341647,
-0.0128451446,
-0.0361654907,
0.0014611833,
-0.0176145844,
-0.0441414639,
0.0397942364,
0.0001036746,
-0.0009074965,
-0.0168936942,
0.1081802547,
-0.0049280147,
0.0330264792,
-0.065744549,
0.0342585817,
-0.001901135,
0.0120373061,
-0.0409821086,
0.0138158472,
0.0062723188,
-0.0520591736,
-0.0237058792,
0.0081084855,
0.004316329,
0.038001433,
0.0392297357,
0.0146382218,
0.047336787,
0.0282807276,
-0.0948512182,
0.0460830852,
-0.0346760191,
0.0128304167,
0.0496035032,
0.0141226761,
0.0590976365,
-0.0098029356,
-0.0295254923,
-0.0471068658,
0.0092925942,
0.0295025799,
0.0093624564,
0.0555879883,
0.0145579772,
-0.0094503202,
-0.0225609671,
0.0307389088,
0.0115737831,
-0.0157378353,
-0.0475284979,
-0.0494287089,
-0.0259919111,
0.0021176559,
0.0186912343,
0.0339106098,
0.0124621745,
-0.0038998853,
-0.0405145958,
-0.0307822265,
0.0876397789,
0.0130412262,
-0.0005969004,
-0.0174388364,
-0.0054022111,
0.0123626925,
0.0035697066,
0.0204933956,
-0.0275794938,
-0.0118166767,
-0.0176765658,
-0.0373212025,
0.0081226202,
-5.766831287e-33,
-0.0027417857,
-0.0317829251,
-0.028124107,
-0.022724146,
-0.0208937023,
0.0154318847,
-0.0205111615,
-0.0584925413,
-0.0074793589,
0.0401279591,
-0.0220564939,
-0.0079259239,
-0.0092371013,
0.0111074448,
0.0295327771,
0.0289118458,
0.0554175153,
0.0046904464,
-0.0304360464,
0.0011608328,
0.0287574083,
0.0122429589,
0.0283908937,
-0.0808050558,
0.0237443764,
0.0063996157,
-0.0430923328,
-0.0426732525,
0.0571717732,
0.0698205382,
-0.0323288068,
0.0315641314,
0.0193979982,
-0.0291429013,
-0.0126538929,
0.0362964794,
-0.0524725169,
0.0268490277,
-0.0010218343,
0.0022447414,
-0.0467973277,
-0.0126988338,
0.0385360084,
-0.0107440827,
-0.0361770317,
-0.0623541996,
0.1061058491,
-0.0264469329,
-0.0524313748,
-0.0836145431,
-0.0285636876,
0.0298698768,
-0.0130732823,
-0.0004277501,
0.0248649213,
0.0461160913,
0.0680296198,
0.0719798133,
-0.0606199428,
0.0198989958,
-0.0209004972,
0.0098893074,
-0.0066502825,
-0.0274118856,
-0.0108642224,
0.0734867901,
-0.0203464776,
-0.0369272344,
0.0227136705,
-0.0570985861,
0.0440967306,
0.037794482,
0.1176142916,
0.0841717124,
0.0451060459,
-0.0150123928,
-0.0264917985,
0.068812713,
0.0001459095,
0.0205782894,
0.0184286032,
0.0071106139,
0.0311649386,
0.002868237,
-0.0090292348,
-0.0506712981,
-0.0263087898,
-0.0032560485,
0.0149300946,
0.0143975969,
-0.0040626419,
0.0277266707,
0.0418809056,
-0.0517754517,
-0.0283596404,
0.0463807955,
-0.0520129092,
0.057466656,
0.0113226343,
-0.0112752337,
-0.023141006,
0.0088451225,
0.0342087969,
0.0051208213,
-0.0197163597,
-0.0328041278,
0.1007479504,
0.006703421,
-0.048677206,
-0.0074488078,
0.0016850291,
-0.0403086655,
0.0081288526,
0.0075872326,
0.0090341214,
-0.0227729604,
-0.028465949,
0.0142685901,
0.0259847119,
0.0950990766,
-0.0148110241,
-0.0200338196,
0.0640968382,
0.0154482238,
0.0189433731,
-0.0242028516,
-0.0160562862,
-0.0348515995,
-0.0063042431,
-0.0626466796,
-0.0238668621,
-0.0040227752,
2.76e-7,
0.0432222933,
0.0376790203,
-0.0017990242,
-0.0653538108,
0.0229685046,
0.0443910323,
-0.022816157,
0.0509723015,
-0.0113387657,
-0.0114176618,
-0.007789189,
-0.0288195368,
0.0392870456,
0.0251630656,
-0.0499591231,
-0.0744040832,
-0.0761547461,
-0.0292016938,
-0.0208708644,
0.0260505099,
0.0269912891,
0.0563315079,
-0.0203256365,
-0.0338149332,
0.0220976025,
-0.0331903808,
0.0878083557,
0.0043567871,
-0.0402440913,
-0.0249450002,
0.0581884421,
0.0162280742,
-0.0156007307,
-0.0024110428,
-0.046953883,
0.0133914147,
0.0665818229,
0.008369389,
-0.0097902324,
-0.0158362985,
0.0286094751,
0.0145829264,
-0.0016886304,
0.0112047447,
0.0447695442,
0.0447409339,
-0.0415398739,
-0.0333594307,
-0.1107372344,
-0.0184176359,
0.0885042697,
-0.0233089346,
-0.0429380462,
0.0334606878,
0.0007529957,
-0.0086780405,
-0.0046862522,
-0.0544566028,
0.0094534792,
0.0110709975,
-0.0026417035,
-0.0331289992,
-0.0059741186,
-0.0546800978,
0.0345395878,
-0.1029223278,
-0.01108135,
2.525609306e-34,
0.117723316,
-0.0426052697,
0.0351907872,
-0.005356336,
0.0220877714,
-0.0382587053,
-0.0341587104,
-0.0186437257,
0.0252170824,
-0.0242166352,
-0.0011919892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07968v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07968v1 | Teach LLMs to Personalize -- An Approach inspired by Writing Education | 2023-08-15T18:06:23 | 2023-08-15T18:06:23 | Cheng Li, Mingyang Zhang, Qiaozhu Mei, Yaqing Wang, Spurthi Amba Hombaiah, Yi Liang, Michael Bendersky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Personalized text generation is an emerging research area that has attracted
much attention in recent years. Most studies in this direction focus on a
particular domain by designing bespoke features or models. In this work, we
propose a general approach for personalized text generation using large
language models (LLMs). Inspired by the practice of writing education, we
develop a multistage and multitask framework to teach LLMs for personalized
generation. In writing instruction, the task of writing from sources is often
decomposed into multiple steps that involve finding, evaluating, summarizing,
synthesizing, and integrating information. Analogously, our approach to
personalized text generation consists of multiple stages: retrieval, ranking,
summarization, synthesis, and generation. In addition, we introduce a multitask
setting that helps the model improve its generation ability further, which is
inspired by the observation in education that a student's reading proficiency
and writing ability are often correlated. We evaluate our approach on three
public datasets, each of which covers a different and representative domain.
Our results show significant improvements over a variety of baselines. | [
0.0433439389,
0.0100911222,
-0.0071184873,
-0.0141023714,
-0.0280617122,
-0.0138089601,
0.034056779,
-0.0354173593,
0.0256072208,
-0.0683885738,
-0.0142472275,
-0.0551968478,
-0.0073493533,
0.0125670219,
0.0366409011,
-0.0627351329,
0.0012452203,
-0.0217846613,
0.0053714206,
-0.0039392682,
0.0139777018,
0.0491190106,
0.0059690671,
0.0449058376,
0.0123388013,
-0.051015798,
0.0020412244,
0.0112571893,
0.0345810056,
0.0094271684,
0.0180307254,
0.0431749485,
0.0257879924,
0.0235206895,
0.0000018867,
-0.0284286886,
-0.0309263002,
-0.0258761309,
0.0441996865,
0.0093816854,
0.084845379,
0.0151693309,
-0.0035546331,
0.0364762805,
-0.0302583016,
0.0135208797,
0.0110056456,
0.0210035816,
0.0805676281,
0.0816236883,
0.0106886886,
-0.0156973805,
0.0098603582,
-0.0330103971,
0.0225851275,
0.0314407535,
0.0056892843,
0.0295330193,
0.0092693036,
0.0221548434,
-0.0133023905,
0.0234544035,
0.0062079905,
-0.0513947532,
0.0483069569,
0.0368968844,
0.0269420557,
0.0193147194,
0.0118944393,
0.0565979779,
0.0035947585,
-0.0110330805,
0.029936241,
-0.0038440786,
0.008666818,
0.0128831714,
-0.0830199942,
0.0528492182,
-0.0092468113,
0.0052294163,
0.0286821891,
-0.010968199,
-0.0036506131,
0.0400609374,
-0.0013221564,
-0.0004408269,
0.0127501618,
-0.0184401646,
-0.0493611544,
0.0341061242,
-0.0076990481,
-0.0569398962,
0.0159352422,
0.0439251401,
-0.0222881027,
0.0027382572,
-0.0726295039,
-0.0769774616,
0.0089003853,
-0.0232179277,
0.0569705516,
0.0044480786,
0.0303846709,
-0.0140936375,
-0.0140047856,
0.0242867917,
0.0119539397,
-0.0010044144,
-0.0706011653,
0.0212726034,
-0.0688816309,
-0.0323375985,
-0.0236252993,
0.0427124612,
-0.0178450029,
-0.0217130408,
-0.0564856604,
0.0354792699,
-0.0071437759,
0.0023686518,
0.0281968974,
0.0282667577,
-0.0413504317,
0.0014169767,
0.0064747855,
0.0033032058,
-0.0176256392,
0.0006206367,
0.0354026556,
0.0315069407,
0.0130486982,
0.016555069,
0.0165249184,
-0.0066661858,
-0.0071756016,
0.0395671502,
-0.0496794172,
-0.0307541676,
-0.0385978594,
-0.0523686297,
0.0104352208,
-0.0541625656,
-0.0061010919,
-0.0813242644,
0.0208232626,
0.0280388501,
0.0093262391,
-0.0380175374,
-0.0017619857,
0.0293558259,
-0.0211338811,
-0.0282955337,
0.0283288714,
0.0203175973,
0.0634994209,
0.0118787009,
0.0345964357,
0.0421217196,
0.0690467954,
0.0499397144,
0.0071055568,
0.0069531589,
-0.005569296,
0.0091566993,
-0.0150915217,
0.0119099338,
-0.0012968739,
-0.0223381147,
-0.0254544672,
0.0279781409,
0.0067074359,
0.0460058525,
-0.0188122913,
0.0715078935,
0.083593823,
0.0133418115,
0.0387053154,
0.0425774194,
0.084072426,
0.0382258929,
0.0007983552,
0.0329861753,
0.0045815604,
0.0279627275,
-0.0061953776,
0.0471443906,
0.0448483191,
0.0540167242,
-0.0193313677,
-0.0666860342,
0.0049004601,
-0.0152207026,
-0.0096911434,
-0.0004814843,
0.0313598365,
0.0118854605,
-0.0561763719,
0.02762172,
0.0018418191,
-0.0951261148,
0.0686386451,
-0.0309994612,
0.0617656335,
0.1243364438,
0.052501332,
-0.005822463,
0.0039032337,
-0.0177854598,
0.0315748304,
0.0285860151,
0.0049942615,
-0.0210185517,
-0.018414652,
-0.0674541146,
-0.0200312957,
-0.0364988856,
0.0112063782,
0.0072235498,
0.0055929944,
0.0006787767,
0.0572367348,
-0.0002572045,
-0.0684195012,
0.0287951957,
-0.0612371638,
-0.0275782328,
0.0166352242,
-0.0061783795,
-0.0316962972,
0.0407156497,
0.0033124997,
0.0213089585,
0.0051208599,
-0.0478062369,
-0.0191664957,
0.0015982335,
-0.0237652268,
-0.0149123594,
-0.0003422372,
-0.0491292067,
0.0356110595,
0.0152068501,
-0.0221223384,
-0.0569007695,
0.013829953,
-0.032781072,
0.0067787208,
-0.0424326845,
0.0174853541,
0.0169049781,
-0.0372106023,
-0.0488350317,
0.0568242148,
0.0024765867,
0.0032044835,
0.0204960518,
0.0037265148,
-0.0252721757,
-0.0268356502,
-0.008522884,
-0.0225952454,
0.0348985158,
0.0313359424,
0.0307126381,
0.0370128714,
-0.0440564975,
-0.0829597339,
-0.0796996653,
0.0206570569,
-0.0111039123,
-0.0003210678,
0.0417383537,
0.0212477576,
-0.0068415329,
0.0103144627,
-0.0546946339,
-0.021363385,
0.0367701128,
-0.0015495388,
0.0405367836,
0.0133129088,
0.0114176786,
-0.0435642377,
-0.0143030472,
-0.0024102987,
0.0428527854,
0.0319570005,
0.0309031475,
-0.0580357909,
0.0524034053,
-0.0364633575,
-0.037010543,
0.0344541483,
-0.0026433056,
0.0015726262,
-0.0277595874,
0.0850327834,
0.0520403013,
0.0328918621,
0.0391107127,
0.0551666878,
-0.0128946016,
-0.0399140269,
0.0018765976,
-0.0382272042,
0.0244169682,
0.0130875111,
-0.0498783365,
-0.0056746202,
0.0471164323,
0.0424707979,
-0.0512027666,
-0.057334546,
0.0374508426,
-0.0173855815,
-0.0085894298,
-0.0302006677,
0.0047879932,
0.0118264025,
-0.0145658059,
-0.0101178987,
-0.0600882992,
0.055004511,
-0.0075514093,
0.0193705056,
-0.0148758665,
-0.0043168385,
-0.059915673,
0.0272278674,
0.0070253871,
0.0330929458,
-0.0270663444,
-0.0029693844,
-0.0630562231,
0.0142306024,
0.0347903259,
-0.0404007733,
0.0664650202,
-0.0531156175,
-0.0299192779,
-0.0223833974,
-0.0121667609,
-0.0350527279,
-0.0062010749,
0.0107669905,
-0.0174959376,
0.028611945,
-0.0072056279,
-0.0390955396,
-0.0317342654,
0.032308504,
0.0180134494,
-0.0472279601,
-0.0235679373,
-0.0179765113,
0.0400069468,
0.0589323156,
-0.0311980303,
-0.0446053669,
-0.0815918818,
0.0135746635,
0.0269244798,
0.0163318478,
-0.0026521904,
0.0157578848,
-0.017519353,
0.0355371051,
-0.0504002906,
0.006214486,
0.0129738683,
0.0453494452,
-0.0401781984,
-0.0280411541,
0.1140838265,
0.0242897756,
-0.0199134536,
-0.0045771045,
0.0052940547,
0.0524121113,
-0.0049128495,
0.0590013936,
-0.0343049914,
0.0017880657,
-0.0299004745,
0.0424817577,
-0.0327964798,
-0.0082353074,
-0.0531778224,
-0.0932130143,
0.0172344558,
0.0519102886,
-0.0198163688,
0.0021141837,
0.0174906924,
-0.0543151945,
0.0006286035,
-0.0099317031,
0.010646645,
-0.0564830527,
0.0356794298,
0.0308739953,
-0.0135622118,
-0.0559242293,
-0.0588113144,
-0.0149378646,
0.0087145539,
0.0371334478,
0.0277723148,
-0.0048512928,
-0.0170745514,
-0.0219737813,
0.0283353943,
0.0134249898,
-0.0167383198,
0.035696093,
-0.030700814,
0.0296236854,
-0.0624510832,
0.0598950572,
0.0015957099,
-0.0183062181,
0.0381689183,
0.0253440216,
-0.007872887,
-0.0153716328,
-0.0484680198,
0.0113921529,
0.0232560374,
0.0660288334,
0.0235520266,
-0.0940245911,
-0.0021294435,
-0.0550254956,
-0.0063400823,
-0.1035973579,
-0.0251699593,
0.0007882861,
-0.0310345944,
0.0224217977,
-0.0929410756,
-0.0357342884,
0.0426372066,
0.0090077538,
0.0203311071,
0.0295992997,
-0.0204315428,
-0.0293636732,
-0.0558410436,
0.0009292701,
-0.0171376634,
0.0052374611,
-0.0615775883,
-0.0637129769,
0.021854056,
-0.0910597891,
0.0057345778,
0.0119441394,
-0.1116336882,
-0.0747392103,
-0.0438441709,
0.0431036763,
0.0178094991,
0.0361649208,
0.0325788297,
-0.0581740402,
0.0403224304,
0.0186502319,
0.009670414,
0.0240510646,
-0.0083740326,
-0.00079275,
-0.0002332695,
0.0112927258,
-0.0258363225,
0.0154983336,
0.0016968102,
0.0435187928,
0.0080216387,
-0.0307517834,
0.0003155131,
0.0126551986,
0.0006650631,
-0.0556215607,
0.0022817284,
-0.0798313096,
-0.0000189609,
-0.0373987928,
-0.0170426331,
-0.0396866128,
0.0100087626,
0.0321208276,
-0.0005256601,
-0.0028550553,
0.0237546917,
-0.0007385691,
0.0421708412,
-0.0598582327,
0.0231163781,
-0.0809209198,
0.0062678349,
0.0310234781,
-0.0096875569,
-0.0413123928,
0.0198738575,
-0.0309219491,
0.00761363,
0.0143716009,
0.0400973819,
0.0047135479,
-0.0002711246,
0.0154304747,
0.051162295,
-0.0592220426,
-0.0086156847,
-0.0458531342,
0.0036507989,
0.0419983491,
0.0083518811,
0.0746267512,
-0.0150353722,
0.0086412737,
-0.0277878158,
0.074886255,
0.0374784023,
-0.0301601533,
-0.0451664925,
0.0008192151,
0.0070307874,
-0.0257928949,
0.1104405448,
0.0215984322,
-0.0209455602,
-0.0092683677,
-0.0082221488,
-0.0471008494,
-0.0303806122,
0.0245240293,
0.0329287276,
-0.0011807651,
-0.0149063049,
-0.0582829975,
-0.0241289344,
0.0527523048,
0.0163447987,
0.0023631728,
-0.0370234512,
0.0320146047,
0.0368164144,
-0.0612761863,
0.0162698701,
-0.0896890908,
0.0080827093,
-0.0187972654,
-0.035583403,
-0.0000084111,
-5.603984912e-33,
-0.0382711552,
-0.0572580881,
0.0215978827,
0.0300385002,
-0.0147724152,
-0.0147695234,
-0.0166842006,
0.018536618,
0.0673684031,
-0.0095736291,
0.0007277377,
-0.0345747769,
-0.0053090979,
0.0750800669,
0.0184337422,
0.0427268669,
0.068174839,
0.0215611942,
-0.0340484306,
0.0473542735,
0.0594718494,
0.0312485266,
0.0281190965,
-0.0314225741,
0.0332849398,
-0.0629900694,
-0.015563027,
-0.0210159216,
-0.0057431948,
0.0591346286,
0.0002865576,
0.0482617393,
0.0188416578,
-0.0138512682,
-0.0369602516,
0.0449431613,
-0.0212491713,
-0.0219546184,
0.0196464583,
-0.0525952317,
-0.0379201137,
-0.1080531031,
0.0074594207,
-0.014990584,
-0.0147981625,
-0.0189649723,
0.0754744112,
-0.0390929952,
-0.0202115551,
-0.0518821776,
-0.0625844747,
0.0050194464,
-0.019215351,
-0.0122684948,
-0.0187622085,
0.0393604599,
0.0036415062,
0.0180462729,
-0.0206736457,
0.0663325936,
0.0397325084,
0.0337557234,
0.0523186475,
0.0430738591,
-0.0226576515,
0.0449960008,
-0.0100170383,
0.015669493,
-0.0157868098,
0.009762194,
0.0188198257,
0.0339926481,
0.0315771177,
0.0874519199,
-0.0259835105,
-0.0104989931,
-0.0463158824,
0.0713154525,
-0.0174348373,
-0.0500510186,
0.0637593269,
-0.0258254651,
0.0005971856,
-0.0191831198,
-0.0383108333,
-0.0000026753,
-0.006369126,
-0.0123583516,
0.0174880195,
0.0320727713,
-0.0563718006,
-0.0360678732,
0.0098184999,
-0.0081717605,
-0.0201033801,
0.0217018779,
-0.05249051,
0.0329480506,
-0.0352315642,
-0.0077636093,
-0.0311847702,
-0.0365115218,
0.0207920484,
-0.0195196159,
-0.0198472887,
0.0396591462,
0.0510779172,
0.0161167383,
-0.0344302915,
0.0171627291,
-0.0131435143,
0.0393349044,
-0.0117315548,
-0.0052916799,
0.0155767975,
-0.0056159426,
-0.0156269055,
0.0545051768,
0.0153048597,
-0.0192451589,
-0.0306702368,
-0.0396842584,
0.0381307304,
0.005254338,
0.0014951337,
0.0166820046,
-0.0260146353,
-0.0058008479,
0.0652726516,
-0.03293854,
-0.0015286951,
-0.0051409691,
2.459e-7,
0.0038840543,
0.044405479,
-0.0015750718,
0.0300965048,
-0.0024192238,
0.0270651449,
-0.0176305771,
0.0515764095,
0.0223871861,
0.0254622921,
0.0096771624,
0.0408621691,
0.0622391067,
0.0038345577,
-0.0892420635,
-0.0035416991,
-0.0344232395,
0.0240758881,
-0.0586421899,
-0.0128602823,
0.0578148924,
0.0027141923,
-0.0002145563,
0.0057153013,
0.0032092598,
-0.0245204289,
0.1039217561,
-0.0353600271,
-0.0353371017,
0.0280493554,
0.0374172851,
-0.0068134139,
-0.0120301004,
-0.0104653882,
-0.0327599682,
-0.0210048556,
0.0295657218,
0.0915944725,
0.0321076326,
0.0163368545,
0.0445112884,
0.0102976598,
-0.0090283938,
-0.0185943376,
0.0272213463,
-0.0224953704,
0.0037905329,
-0.0025188124,
0.0058000134,
0.0050927228,
-0.0126484418,
-0.0454814658,
-0.0182447955,
0.032216236,
0.000454262,
-0.0270063709,
0.0354626589,
-0.0143924654,
-0.0407144167,
-0.0036260716,
-0.0288174283,
-0.0457346998,
-0.0437949188,
-0.0027747895,
0.0018700884,
-0.0742848441,
-0.0075263078,
2.264339615e-34,
0.0472891815,
-0.0077483356,
0.0116161406,
-0.0110114813,
0.0105662877,
0.0001942184,
-0.0257343389,
0.0018250817,
0.0161707476,
-0.0741863474,
-0.0323371999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07922v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07922v2 | RAVEN: In-Context Learning with Retrieval-Augmented Encoder-Decoder Language Models | 2023-08-15T17:59:18 | 2024-04-01T06:32:12 | Jie Huang, Wei Ping, Peng Xu, Mohammad Shoeybi, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang, Bryan Catanzaro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we investigate the in-context learning ability of
retrieval-augmented encoder-decoder language models. We first conduct a
comprehensive analysis of existing models and identify their limitations in
in-context learning, primarily due to a mismatch between pretraining and
inference, as well as a restricted context length. To address these issues, we
propose RAVEN, a model that combines retrieval-augmented masked language
modeling and prefix language modeling. We further introduce Fusion-in-Context
Learning to enhance the few-shot performance by enabling the model to leverage
more in-context examples without requiring additional training. Through
extensive experiments, we demonstrate that our simple yet effective design
significantly improves performance, achieving results comparable to the most
advanced language models in certain scenarios, despite having substantially
fewer parameters. Our work underscores the potential of retrieval-augmented
encoder-decoder language models for in-context learning and encourages further
research in this direction. | [
0.0087877652,
0.0263017807,
0.0044802246,
0.038022276,
0.0095726671,
0.0028379832,
0.0168982409,
0.0032945564,
-0.0478172451,
-0.0539098568,
-0.0310310815,
-0.0196766518,
0.0100868447,
0.0278634615,
0.017042499,
-0.0457022302,
0.0292183217,
-0.0208501536,
-0.0228564665,
0.0086401198,
0.0032395308,
0.0218252614,
0.0093618119,
0.0590539798,
-0.0111383228,
0.0022249829,
0.0083446242,
0.0491320454,
-0.0016199402,
-0.0396316089,
0.0480449721,
0.0226397309,
0.0698783696,
0.0336287208,
0.000001883,
-0.0258823056,
-0.008811675,
-0.0172312334,
-0.0419623181,
-0.0240019951,
0.0434753075,
-0.0456757285,
0.0199097991,
0.0479467213,
-0.0333509631,
-0.0410672799,
0.0414945371,
-0.0200137682,
0.0400833748,
0.0558831841,
-0.0156776346,
-0.0318035968,
0.0151576446,
-0.0463017747,
0.0039790547,
-0.0360355265,
0.0018094794,
-0.034742374,
-0.0111519638,
0.0145152602,
-0.0223665405,
0.051960621,
0.0272950325,
0.0497078598,
0.0183111951,
0.0356255732,
-0.0070513301,
0.0101257088,
-0.0394468121,
0.046747148,
-0.0426933058,
-0.0356343165,
-0.0234476291,
0.0061593005,
-0.0283006951,
-0.0219443664,
-0.0334632508,
0.0002347584,
0.0083189989,
0.0149720265,
-0.0054226737,
0.0584173873,
0.0294962805,
-0.0020260038,
-0.0341162086,
0.0343212709,
0.0356717855,
-0.0401188359,
-0.0490437597,
0.0049590832,
0.0087158792,
-0.0114112571,
0.0002942434,
0.0222830828,
-0.0167162325,
0.033787813,
-0.042342823,
-0.0916941538,
-0.0037724227,
0.0004166664,
0.0211677272,
0.0578329824,
-0.0348768122,
0.0479883924,
-0.0432878584,
0.0366525352,
0.0312627628,
0.0081174783,
-0.0542299412,
-0.0392994806,
-0.0116552971,
-0.0181700643,
-0.0789901093,
0.010864771,
-0.0783495307,
-0.0314619169,
-0.0154960826,
0.0143924141,
-0.0004602115,
-0.0072316872,
0.0091743385,
-0.0045623137,
-0.073616527,
-0.0322627835,
0.0405575745,
0.001076667,
-0.0002198677,
0.0192089994,
0.0176821835,
-0.0525804572,
-0.0319257081,
-0.0055285739,
0.0253766794,
-0.0348742157,
0.0121969236,
0.0504414514,
-0.0245020352,
-0.0783379748,
-0.0040934389,
0.0074225152,
-0.0068040732,
-0.0097827772,
-0.0196755305,
-0.0480055176,
0.012264071,
0.0059680492,
0.0118123163,
-0.0513863489,
-0.0015773921,
0.0302500278,
0.0179158282,
0.0819073245,
-0.024813341,
-0.0108349537,
0.0521816574,
0.0237742383,
0.0076230168,
0.0752492845,
0.0029318463,
0.0326844454,
0.0251973718,
0.039037291,
0.0181535911,
0.0436096713,
0.0473471843,
0.0154181113,
-0.0533988625,
-0.0021641799,
0.0374684595,
-0.0123223718,
0.0281510502,
0.0459098183,
-0.0528090112,
-0.0012346315,
0.0360500701,
0.0476749949,
0.0138664925,
-0.0194767695,
0.0402061008,
0.0221094787,
-0.0294086207,
-0.0371645354,
-0.020268457,
-0.0149245784,
-0.0607591942,
0.0132680638,
0.0119562773,
0.025747424,
-0.0423942767,
-0.02866951,
-0.0118679712,
-0.0140410271,
0.0111711212,
0.0405936651,
0.0452404842,
0.0470255502,
-0.0893648565,
0.013724071,
0.0167117771,
-0.0512460619,
0.0161965508,
-0.024031939,
-0.0053953747,
0.054514695,
0.0606148578,
-0.0185555965,
-0.0027330546,
0.0056101237,
0.0028436575,
0.0380206406,
0.0006791092,
-0.0231750011,
0.0489499159,
-0.0654059872,
-0.014532242,
-0.0111278491,
0.0255861878,
0.0183051731,
0.0185103733,
0.0151999295,
0.0431168042,
-0.0156258997,
0.0330840498,
0.0406680927,
-0.0357052386,
-0.0551575311,
-0.0090360297,
0.0164091699,
-0.000534415,
-0.0152301937,
-0.0129596544,
0.0041988264,
0.0322455056,
-0.0532746129,
0.0281667206,
-0.0028130554,
-0.1023170948,
-0.1147656888,
-0.0110011529,
0.0064780987,
0.0184779502,
0.0461676195,
-0.0167210735,
-0.0292066857,
-0.0071859984,
-0.0130893774,
0.0964904726,
-0.0547545776,
0.0218109787,
-0.0021255151,
0.0202691182,
-0.0391715281,
0.0503707714,
-0.0278894752,
-0.0020849088,
0.0206482131,
0.0390714444,
-0.0106198275,
-0.0483662859,
-0.0348854773,
-0.0073645455,
-0.0017038105,
-0.0001794563,
0.0105633233,
-0.0137037029,
0.0001862385,
0.0105765741,
-0.09501376,
-0.0112566417,
-0.0682905391,
-0.0305063296,
-0.0005438842,
0.0370147005,
-0.0124393469,
-0.0577566884,
0.0030538409,
-0.0379462242,
-0.005784628,
0.0398499556,
-0.0143498024,
0.029798612,
-0.0134341018,
-0.0426462665,
-0.0423771963,
0.0315005891,
0.0641626045,
-0.0366604775,
-0.0455132574,
-0.0274175033,
0.0221675914,
0.0108275572,
0.0199554358,
-0.0346041285,
0.0198403466,
0.0100616198,
-0.040299248,
0.0390019044,
0.0404323339,
-0.0052728872,
0.0601286367,
0.0264887232,
-0.0071326294,
-0.0616902299,
0.0059481743,
-0.0251210369,
-0.0563133284,
0.0001043084,
0.0164857805,
0.0050595468,
0.0400603414,
-0.0070067104,
0.0182330608,
-0.0721779764,
-0.0239117388,
-0.0148751587,
-0.0542295687,
-0.0971839055,
-0.0493027307,
-0.0189250261,
0.0391656645,
-0.0365996324,
-0.0457991846,
0.0675072894,
-0.0419202894,
-0.0221670661,
-0.0417566225,
-0.016178105,
-0.0220268518,
0.0506811403,
-0.009745284,
0.0248255096,
-0.0174068063,
-0.0627794042,
-0.0341717564,
-0.0129592381,
-0.0032926127,
-0.0422766209,
0.0241215862,
-0.032011155,
0.0167814363,
0.0145532005,
-0.030017063,
-0.0622418486,
-0.0045686788,
-0.0227533951,
0.0169646721,
-0.0064931321,
0.0183258019,
0.0036921327,
0.0274901073,
0.0004645629,
0.0720741078,
0.0361785032,
-0.0142933242,
-0.0247006621,
0.0114027457,
0.0560423918,
-0.0225383602,
-0.0300867092,
-0.0369137414,
0.0086296219,
0.032464359,
0.0815233886,
-0.0361593589,
-0.0311516393,
0.0265326574,
0.0559979342,
0.00690149,
0.0083368337,
0.0583308078,
0.0212268382,
-0.0632566959,
-0.0461752787,
0.089455083,
0.0371027142,
-0.0665532798,
-0.02139033,
-0.0198775884,
0.0244103465,
0.0178271048,
0.0078818165,
-0.0724025443,
-0.0627793223,
0.0276018269,
0.0203460753,
0.0280928258,
0.0145905158,
0.002533739,
-0.1374419034,
-0.020180963,
0.0170486867,
-0.0300197657,
-0.0593196824,
-0.0313671343,
-0.0114427228,
-0.0052541285,
0.0372775495,
0.0286173467,
-0.0154721029,
-0.0160696022,
0.0057871887,
0.025564637,
-0.0754480809,
0.0291882921,
-0.0323960595,
-0.0019225824,
0.0598876476,
-0.0184128564,
0.0211121012,
-0.0417321548,
0.009799378,
-0.0333921537,
0.0107363714,
-0.0101604331,
0.0386187769,
-0.0686282516,
0.0101723326,
0.0261408184,
0.0100644613,
-0.0323289931,
-0.0276091471,
-0.0219634473,
0.0318906456,
-0.0097801443,
0.0357150212,
-0.021859888,
-0.0466579571,
0.0503883474,
0.0644262284,
0.0199555662,
-0.021740349,
-0.0142303063,
-0.0120487576,
0.0299925227,
-0.0198020991,
0.0167748015,
-0.0159180146,
0.0079148076,
0.0049129971,
-0.0554980934,
-0.0268627722,
0.0303341523,
0.0469518341,
-0.0095489593,
0.0147647383,
-0.0279830471,
0.0138208764,
-0.054404512,
0.0276331268,
-0.0271184761,
0.0380225852,
-0.0425485484,
0.0100921299,
0.058344312,
-0.0031223977,
-0.0104026599,
0.0489796586,
-0.0641640946,
-0.0294109117,
0.0002819028,
0.04342876,
0.0215938594,
0.0753812417,
-0.0252038725,
-0.0319297612,
0.0609293729,
0.0026599567,
0.0000354791,
0.0191679411,
0.0427291766,
-0.0330736414,
-0.0229950491,
0.0254447758,
-0.081711337,
0.0121846767,
0.0077603892,
0.0385479778,
-0.052494064,
-0.0039914479,
0.0378426127,
-0.0561520793,
0.0627094433,
-0.0359710902,
-0.0109503726,
-0.0327075869,
0.0392394513,
-0.0230868906,
0.0084166666,
-0.0271234494,
-0.0073422571,
0.028038742,
0.00560014,
0.0094499849,
0.0311121643,
0.0104798432,
0.0411074497,
-0.0257837754,
-0.0010492426,
-0.0271201842,
0.0227416065,
0.0253956858,
0.0301726982,
-0.0357364118,
0.0153537625,
-0.0037026582,
0.0263686385,
-0.0409508273,
0.0213774443,
0.0234382339,
-0.0104461778,
-0.043579597,
0.0477065891,
-0.0385387056,
0.0196987782,
-0.064726226,
-0.0096334014,
0.0580781326,
-0.0201442894,
0.0079179779,
0.0004043223,
-0.0113590294,
-0.0090739913,
0.0210795552,
-0.0112951547,
-0.0625839159,
0.0321088172,
0.0303429589,
-0.0076229265,
0.0469817556,
0.0679102615,
0.0286404658,
0.033323478,
-0.0107831536,
0.0330788232,
-0.020103503,
0.0172846578,
0.0412857383,
0.0838073418,
-0.0035993052,
0.0367913172,
-0.0321156345,
-0.0833276436,
0.0254580155,
-0.0124124698,
-0.0184996147,
0.012772874,
0.0559543595,
0.0446515679,
-0.0051046563,
-0.0255443137,
0.0000686354,
0.0038559944,
0.0008711331,
-0.0114360349,
-0.0415640064,
-5.869095255e-33,
-0.0494058058,
0.0173102692,
0.0175438467,
-0.0274884924,
0.009757827,
-0.0132257519,
-0.0396868214,
-0.0119414926,
-0.0377626531,
-0.0196565986,
-0.025893962,
0.0109730875,
0.0128645124,
0.068007037,
-0.0434420407,
0.0111052375,
0.0595680885,
0.0227678008,
0.0036426976,
-0.0129421279,
0.0185964108,
0.0649639592,
0.0189522188,
-0.0355966911,
-0.0263210759,
-0.0367407985,
-0.0034951193,
0.0326019488,
0.0278256889,
0.0489882603,
-0.023889631,
0.0494243689,
0.0039952602,
-0.0336921886,
-0.0296605136,
0.0421735719,
-0.098066546,
-0.0087641831,
-0.0237008464,
0.0062490921,
-0.0193324685,
-0.0276007149,
0.0239492133,
-0.0076145665,
-0.0260304306,
0.0175125021,
0.0285914987,
-0.0339640193,
-0.0540582612,
-0.0459905341,
-0.0533112623,
0.0115083903,
0.013330969,
-0.0311465096,
0.0408559889,
0.0194363743,
0.0209068842,
0.0292583145,
-0.0780807957,
0.0000755022,
-0.0057650255,
0.046149347,
0.0709064081,
0.0810113847,
0.015918253,
0.0529284365,
-0.0204092581,
-0.0125722568,
0.0103387628,
-0.0159199703,
0.05285969,
0.0205659214,
0.0473281331,
0.0289651603,
0.0547849759,
-0.0289116502,
-0.0369409956,
0.0236190837,
-0.020665979,
0.0324495248,
0.0223723259,
0.0513229482,
-0.0486305431,
-0.0167871919,
-0.0447603688,
-0.0138948224,
-0.0316260234,
-0.0218360741,
0.0716569424,
0.0661951974,
-0.0114655271,
0.0520748533,
0.0713240877,
-0.0246385578,
0.0245276745,
0.0555532165,
0.0082129231,
0.0036786846,
-0.0017790688,
0.0626026019,
-0.0420186818,
-0.012224203,
0.02814845,
0.0222468898,
-0.0210965369,
-0.0301594865,
0.041565299,
0.0314559788,
-0.0727546364,
0.0028167341,
-0.0231509767,
0.0211585034,
0.0091361618,
0.013505741,
0.0462258123,
0.042773027,
-0.020710228,
0.0466957502,
-0.0127212051,
-0.0313474946,
-0.0225032046,
-0.0395372994,
-0.0172058027,
0.0076743551,
-0.0095802639,
0.0151457479,
-0.0268587079,
0.0170009416,
0.0874350145,
-0.0165334363,
-0.0066302889,
0.0369799733,
2.486e-7,
0.0301671159,
0.0027189483,
0.0264759511,
-0.0266046096,
0.003596596,
0.0146516133,
0.0021812033,
0.0406346768,
0.0330514982,
-0.0083892681,
-0.0079527218,
0.0243871678,
0.053096775,
-0.0110360738,
-0.0592120066,
0.0165741406,
-0.0587591603,
0.0384724401,
-0.0306414142,
-0.0012077983,
0.0412336737,
0.1253245622,
-0.0023720304,
0.0065816878,
-0.0134600587,
-0.0444981381,
0.0794245228,
-0.0216845199,
-0.0012698516,
0.0026823918,
-0.0299489126,
0.0733367503,
-0.0048139957,
-0.0169588588,
-0.0267199073,
0.0452369191,
0.0511876121,
0.0461320207,
-0.0278205387,
-0.0645891577,
-0.0036765994,
0.0271359198,
-0.0385261662,
-0.0281492695,
0.0592750534,
-0.067380853,
0.0317767784,
-0.0086329458,
-0.048149012,
0.0373946317,
-0.0133280708,
-0.0125438459,
-0.0493177548,
0.0067276023,
0.0391114689,
0.0264760517,
-0.0146963717,
-0.1395275146,
-0.0271954164,
0.0223982725,
-0.0218886975,
-0.0040548756,
-0.0251323488,
-0.0171889029,
0.0085355937,
-0.0384252556,
0.0138630699,
2.157863934e-34,
0.0150302285,
-0.0069511109,
0.0000403768,
0.0625833124,
0.0015235646,
-0.029477017,
-0.0176571682,
0.0268475078,
0.0463238917,
-0.0873437971,
0.0023761077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07921v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07921v1 | Solving Challenging Math Word Problems Using GPT-4 Code Interpreter with Code-based Self-Verification | 2023-08-15T17:58:45 | 2023-08-15T17:58:45 | Aojun Zhou, Ke Wang, Zimu Lu, Weikang Shi, Sichun Luo, Zipeng Qin, Shaoqing Lu, Anya Jia, Linqi Song, Mingjie Zhan, Hongsheng Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Recent progress in large language models (LLMs) like GPT-4 and PaLM-2 has
brought significant advancements in addressing math reasoning problems. In
particular, OpenAI's latest version of GPT-4, known as GPT-4 Code Interpreter,
shows remarkable performance on challenging math datasets. In this paper, we
explore the effect of code on enhancing LLMs' reasoning capability by
introducing different constraints on the \textit{Code Usage Frequency} of GPT-4
Code Interpreter. We found that its success can be largely attributed to its
powerful skills in generating and executing code, evaluating the output of code
execution, and rectifying its solution when receiving unreasonable outputs.
Based on this insight, we propose a novel and effective prompting method,
explicit \uline{c}ode-based \uline{s}elf-\uline{v}erification~(CSV), to further
boost the mathematical reasoning potential of GPT-4 Code Interpreter. This
method employs a zero-shot prompt on GPT-4 Code Interpreter to encourage it to
use code to self-verify its answers. In instances where the verification state
registers as ``False'', the model shall automatically amend its solution,
analogous to our approach of rectifying errors during a mathematics
examination. Furthermore, we recognize that the states of the verification
result indicate the confidence of a solution, which can improve the
effectiveness of majority voting. With GPT-4 Code Interpreter and CSV, we
achieve an impressive zero-shot accuracy on MATH dataset \textbf{(53.9\% $\to$
84.3\%)}. | [
-0.0353404023,
0.0890768841,
-0.0185841154,
0.058603134,
-0.0552508719,
0.0177367441,
0.0204566102,
0.013335228,
0.028576076,
-0.005085221,
0.0132960966,
0.0249170754,
-0.0027476079,
0.0158599503,
0.0001519126,
0.0077722995,
0.0506389886,
-0.0457324348,
0.0148698753,
-0.0279355943,
-0.0286448691,
-0.0045242095,
-0.0266342703,
-0.0089765638,
-0.020203596,
-0.0625225306,
-0.0243989062,
-0.050926704,
0.0072070304,
-0.0322790667,
-0.0185990259,
0.056131199,
0.0028159693,
0.0698396415,
0.000002445,
-0.043294318,
-0.0187861193,
0.0283511411,
-0.0632158518,
0.0390114188,
0.0229955874,
-0.0117117027,
0.0071649989,
0.023447603,
-0.0748398826,
-0.0082706911,
0.045249559,
-0.0480529778,
0.0918703675,
0.0690247118,
-0.0013338518,
-0.0194455944,
0.0424809158,
-0.0045559178,
0.0380216166,
-0.0646069273,
0.0216865074,
0.0494208001,
0.0175427981,
0.0050959196,
-0.0353521146,
0.0351436324,
0.0805167556,
0.0092205442,
-0.0240010265,
0.0182176773,
-0.0542810112,
0.0184969902,
-0.0274526123,
0.028729504,
-0.0153415697,
-0.0404999852,
-0.0309946816,
-0.0213880204,
-0.0298080407,
-0.0138271591,
-0.0356471017,
0.0158691183,
0.0057789013,
0.0163068008,
0.0042553018,
0.0158327259,
0.010235711,
0.0111083779,
-0.0689783618,
0.0992734656,
0.0178202447,
-0.0472440198,
-0.0169262085,
0.0093091074,
-0.0359282307,
-0.0605077893,
0.034873955,
0.0854331702,
0.0291914493,
0.0345105492,
-0.0393346362,
-0.0434653983,
-0.0019437553,
-0.0311312266,
0.0478710607,
0.0666869655,
0.0072827758,
0.0261116587,
-0.0385181271,
0.0825899765,
-0.0290261805,
0.0237586312,
0.0093152216,
0.0369476937,
-0.0221191831,
-0.0248619467,
-0.070153378,
0.0238856915,
0.0252981558,
0.0270313248,
-0.0385562293,
0.017575169,
-0.0295215137,
0.0384776741,
-0.0015854022,
-0.0449041016,
-0.0077796467,
-0.0461161099,
-0.0401665978,
0.0008192215,
-0.0289023723,
-0.0278157014,
-0.0114539685,
-0.0610678978,
-0.016934609,
0.0026563951,
-0.0112238135,
-0.039901305,
0.0441512689,
0.0424619913,
0.0226977896,
-0.0113938209,
-0.0059008184,
-0.0102701234,
-0.0140922917,
-0.089909479,
0.008743857,
-0.0935984477,
0.0148581583,
0.0107464707,
-0.0253599267,
-0.0408652425,
0.014627126,
0.0204623248,
0.0593440123,
0.0845671594,
-0.013506474,
-0.0203905106,
0.0312477797,
0.0063701305,
-0.014303783,
0.0304116867,
0.0628559217,
-0.0175557826,
0.0061286045,
-0.0152000617,
0.0750158727,
0.025515208,
0.0303469002,
0.0037704497,
-0.0336978175,
0.0340701714,
-0.0071236906,
0.016654795,
-0.0303859394,
0.0654194504,
-0.0202707443,
0.0069908085,
-0.0111617744,
0.0450717807,
-0.0296571739,
0.0222548451,
0.0194640383,
-0.016023634,
0.0456020907,
0.0129023604,
-0.0415879488,
0.0637344569,
-0.0140869878,
0.0078356266,
0.0144104632,
0.0069822422,
-0.0016364257,
-0.0829844102,
-0.0122033125,
-0.0091757067,
0.0083676381,
0.0107508022,
0.0670073628,
-0.0446297228,
-0.0090341289,
0.0066108713,
-0.0182254389,
-0.0663262978,
-0.0478676185,
-0.0835732594,
0.0551612675,
-0.0132077271,
0.0724737942,
-0.0314344428,
-0.017344242,
0.0111711388,
-0.0115852719,
0.0002106566,
0.0503180549,
0.0248384532,
-0.0410828628,
-0.0536721796,
0.0206056405,
-0.0281173326,
0.0160036795,
-0.0011419678,
0.0525225177,
0.0286934897,
0.0300122555,
0.0019536726,
-0.0181830842,
0.0181909464,
0.0060945996,
-0.0623856075,
0.0265098047,
0.0023546601,
0.0193963666,
-0.0079383915,
0.0043637529,
0.0551123284,
0.008519752,
0.0084892651,
-0.0236214753,
-0.065452069,
-0.0674922168,
-0.0173943751,
0.0736465305,
-0.0194228217,
-0.0455782637,
0.0327376351,
-0.0232271887,
-0.0330336541,
0.0520579815,
-0.0226981528,
-0.0180960651,
-0.0396080315,
0.023337584,
0.0055609429,
-0.0213301629,
0.0001977186,
0.0735213235,
0.0480575673,
0.0119107803,
-0.0140130483,
0.0670968145,
0.0455681235,
-0.0187415313,
-0.0268585477,
-0.0086398441,
0.0065085897,
0.0105401929,
-0.0253881775,
0.0084002363,
-0.0032827067,
-0.0142990891,
-0.0525354818,
0.0083868559,
-0.0066174911,
0.0341619179,
0.0004843826,
-0.0124805123,
-0.0009349739,
0.0022159563,
-0.051980041,
0.0025961392,
0.0076300325,
-0.0304415617,
0.0259120129,
-0.026173247,
-0.0124921957,
-0.0266149715,
-0.022014007,
-0.0599533357,
0.0111995433,
0.0018571012,
0.0470417552,
-0.0357314609,
0.0298770554,
-0.0394379683,
0.0148111479,
0.0110995574,
0.0051020612,
0.0460172296,
-0.0486778095,
0.0239839405,
0.0460844487,
-0.0247197635,
0.0299066938,
0.0388904735,
-0.0360154584,
-0.0390126221,
0.0351397283,
0.0171522461,
-0.0410795547,
0.060473226,
-0.0070180041,
-0.0117654884,
0.0458458811,
0.0207867064,
-0.0370489247,
-0.0466573872,
0.0250122752,
-0.0097782407,
0.0366232991,
0.0081296656,
-0.010635796,
-0.0333017856,
0.052951321,
0.0055894363,
-0.0795489401,
0.0716053247,
-0.0401344635,
-0.0235931315,
-0.065950796,
0.0148857953,
-0.0567651093,
0.0519416705,
-0.0111304577,
-0.025673857,
-0.0088231573,
-0.0009323444,
0.0009070942,
-0.0085195322,
0.0176573787,
-0.0452136993,
0.0806527883,
-0.0364448577,
0.0343215913,
-0.01589044,
-0.0256891754,
-0.031953916,
0.0076351101,
-0.0282719992,
-0.0024018174,
-0.0072699753,
-0.0375475474,
0.0621665306,
0.0032164601,
0.0102060735,
0.0487520024,
-0.0429428481,
-0.0273885746,
-0.0210603513,
0.0004187625,
0.01242954,
-0.0036874115,
0.0162391216,
-0.0117083546,
0.0294661019,
0.0109532904,
0.0546470806,
0.0296316557,
-0.0732188895,
0.0082765836,
-0.0045337859,
-0.0348766781,
-0.0081469547,
0.0424466133,
0.0251582954,
-0.0637400299,
-0.0379859433,
0.0739575252,
0.0530888811,
-0.0373301208,
-0.014653272,
-0.0474399962,
-0.0241949651,
0.0132921152,
0.0629075915,
-0.1093371287,
-0.0152345346,
-0.0086422917,
0.0093460223,
0.0104380231,
-0.0053201206,
-0.0323287733,
-0.1225293353,
0.0664048865,
0.0405455865,
0.0085220728,
-0.0320430845,
-0.0034126989,
-0.0115518942,
-0.0057978709,
-0.035894122,
0.0464281999,
0.022253722,
0.0376129113,
-0.0038465916,
0.02610608,
0.0167563632,
0.0480702743,
0.0167398825,
-0.0034356529,
0.0799868032,
0.0048521645,
-0.0370209031,
-0.0788359642,
0.013671807,
-0.0114412839,
-0.0155766523,
-0.0109717017,
-0.003004737,
0.0084530227,
-0.0140573001,
-0.0068223211,
0.0370384678,
-0.0363440588,
-0.0154135264,
0.0442785732,
0.1235729009,
-0.0225701313,
-0.0144813154,
-0.016568061,
-0.032858178,
-0.0216411036,
0.0363173112,
0.0184623823,
0.0237237141,
-0.0629224256,
-0.0472878516,
-0.0139121749,
-0.0317398384,
-0.0043531652,
-0.035126403,
0.0580510981,
-0.0041242014,
-0.0041885497,
-0.0282710902,
0.0729016811,
0.0540122725,
-0.0191007461,
-0.0315307938,
0.007400394,
0.0083716046,
-0.0400273651,
-0.0189564899,
-0.0665129051,
0.0525727794,
-0.0562628135,
0.0163624212,
-0.0041065752,
-0.0006102703,
0.0007500863,
0.0279858373,
-0.0948510095,
-0.0427091792,
-0.0133885406,
0.0486522093,
0.0288658813,
-0.0180840902,
-0.0229307637,
0.0226997398,
-0.0110824024,
0.0325476415,
-0.0633793846,
0.015696682,
0.0063680112,
0.0111110359,
0.0186812803,
0.0029766359,
0.0329933874,
0.0044648573,
0.0012718742,
0.0232449099,
-0.0385495014,
-0.024404861,
0.0399438925,
0.0844386071,
0.0097159045,
0.0258126967,
0.0210161153,
0.0037252752,
0.0183378495,
-0.02501099,
0.0068929535,
-0.0451481603,
0.0113450093,
-0.0190394875,
-0.0520795882,
0.0003250747,
-0.0463255793,
-0.0139664579,
-0.0104950685,
0.0205971077,
0.0482024439,
0.0104372567,
0.0614016019,
0.0440352596,
-0.0396351442,
-0.007532591,
-0.0037155191,
0.014947555,
0.0365178883,
-0.0092931166,
0.0884097293,
-0.0007319223,
0.0247247145,
-0.0113449367,
-0.013535087,
-0.0475382768,
-0.0816526115,
-0.0071538663,
0.0389727242,
0.009248429,
0.0328078233,
-0.0296757575,
-0.073734045,
-0.0021212215,
-0.0056903847,
0.001787719,
0.0237068143,
-0.0109768072,
0.0273362398,
0.0356670097,
0.0163790993,
-0.0636973307,
0.0545868315,
-0.0448514968,
0.0239647981,
0.02434076,
0.0116932765,
-0.0407180637,
-0.0288057793,
0.0145815462,
-0.0241308343,
-0.0074452832,
-0.0190365911,
-0.0438989624,
-0.0859116018,
-0.0247657802,
0.0375408716,
0.0129519841,
-0.0062699625,
0.0278356038,
0.0691529587,
-0.0180823151,
0.0057244385,
0.006874091,
0.0642598346,
-0.003631457,
-0.0362416543,
-0.0198165253,
-6.131503063e-33,
-0.03255428,
-0.0394099168,
0.0427752361,
0.015799636,
0.0432697795,
-0.0264547225,
-0.040022824,
0.0226098653,
-0.0063301176,
-0.0124863777,
-0.026271563,
0.0393814966,
0.0107567078,
-0.0187307186,
0.0306983311,
0.0036757386,
-0.0099219605,
-0.0269150324,
-0.0524734445,
-0.0044882451,
-0.0151855322,
-0.0166888982,
0.0466326997,
-0.0274627116,
0.030001089,
0.0111854272,
-0.0201362949,
-0.0023238976,
-0.0928099826,
0.0564722046,
-0.0290784631,
0.0269607212,
0.002452825,
-0.0303445663,
-0.0122317234,
-0.0120404437,
-0.0196373668,
-0.0551858582,
0.0113434652,
0.0050344542,
-0.0417476483,
-0.0391974337,
0.035026893,
-0.0007062214,
-0.0721900091,
-0.0113453679,
-0.0162805524,
-0.0255980697,
0.0231340826,
0.0016151092,
-0.0300379619,
0.0407750197,
0.0070620114,
-0.0330130942,
0.0204314291,
0.001223395,
-0.0409426577,
-0.006686924,
-0.0118251741,
0.0119125471,
0.0650234669,
0.0183132533,
0.037760701,
-0.0671544373,
-0.0202784389,
-0.0040154131,
0.0464829504,
-0.0676447079,
-0.0502329618,
-0.000023492,
0.0259714313,
0.0089723822,
0.0820064694,
0.0177103002,
0.0876190439,
0.0037407756,
-0.0317291021,
0.0188602936,
0.0048054196,
0.0227722097,
-0.004506025,
-0.0121369949,
-0.0700168163,
-0.0069326041,
0.0056968546,
0.002602478,
-0.0786916986,
-0.0555233806,
0.0293649174,
-0.0336627848,
-0.0266499892,
0.0263192505,
0.024692161,
-0.0244028401,
-0.0099912779,
0.0021186688,
0.0107450373,
0.0278986171,
0.0128330747,
0.0411935002,
-0.0136626745,
0.036754299,
-0.0208841655,
0.0025418736,
0.0463468991,
0.0268041417,
-0.0100230752,
0.0515447035,
-0.0584071651,
-0.0161571801,
-0.0417653993,
-0.021567205,
0.0552591048,
0.0111542698,
0.0191195756,
0.012776182,
0.0211398955,
0.0325852633,
-0.0344712883,
-0.0559770167,
-0.0548783094,
0.0378156491,
-0.0035314667,
0.0373080373,
-0.0200635828,
-0.0321294889,
-0.0258731153,
0.0182156451,
-0.0050129993,
-0.0427752957,
-0.0034949498,
0.040808212,
3.201e-7,
0.0362960547,
0.0338122398,
0.0370790549,
0.0339155607,
0.0085437652,
0.0279738642,
-0.046818316,
-0.0204333887,
-0.0021373692,
-0.0066879322,
0.0159293953,
0.0362833031,
0.0301529486,
0.0580867045,
-0.0009854797,
0.0367152728,
0.0281768069,
0.0112394104,
-0.07026539,
0.0485277213,
0.086060293,
0.0590789765,
0.032142628,
0.0056855055,
0.007014893,
-0.0199213009,
0.0323333293,
0.044459369,
0.0287149921,
0.0177039634,
-0.0390105173,
0.0019064469,
-0.0148935942,
0.0069769146,
0.0051053856,
0.0073635466,
0.0076554241,
0.090167284,
0.0168345924,
0.0275033545,
0.0047029154,
-0.0209704749,
-0.0165733602,
-0.0917263553,
0.0756079555,
-0.017996205,
-0.011247891,
-0.0281417388,
0.0077756848,
-0.0512243658,
0.0180573445,
0.0004146661,
0.0344657265,
0.0012194398,
0.0044714697,
0.0068939491,
-0.0009611769,
-0.0477304906,
-0.0297419913,
-0.0168005154,
-0.052104231,
-0.0141904429,
-0.0578962788,
0.0324517563,
0.0568375699,
-0.0302586462,
-0.004389172,
3.334331282e-34,
0.0250850245,
-0.0332773589,
0.0308980774,
0.0231140982,
0.0346684195,
0.0225973222,
-0.0166729018,
0.0339043848,
0.0238381084,
-0.0361497849,
-0.0660266355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07902v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07902v1 | Through the Lens of Core Competency: Survey on Evaluation of Large Language Models | 2023-08-15T17:40:34 | 2023-08-15T17:40:34 | Ziyu Zhuang, Qiguang Chen, Longxuan Ma, Mingda Li, Yi Han, Yushan Qian, Haopeng Bai, Zixian Feng, Weinan Zhang, Ting Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | From pre-trained language model (PLM) to large language model (LLM), the
field of natural language processing (NLP) has witnessed steep performance
gains and wide practical uses. The evaluation of a research field guides its
direction of improvement. However, LLMs are extremely hard to thoroughly
evaluate for two reasons. First of all, traditional NLP tasks become inadequate
due to the excellent performance of LLM. Secondly, existing evaluation tasks
are difficult to keep up with the wide range of applications in real-world
scenarios. To tackle these problems, existing works proposed various benchmarks
to better evaluate LLMs. To clarify the numerous evaluation tasks in both
academia and industry, we investigate multiple papers concerning LLM
evaluations. We summarize 4 core competencies of LLM, including reasoning,
knowledge, reliability, and safety. For every competency, we introduce its
definition, corresponding benchmarks, and metrics. Under this competency
architecture, similar tasks are combined to reflect corresponding ability,
while new tasks can also be easily added into the system. Finally, we give our
suggestions on the future direction of LLM's evaluation. | [
0.0568927079,
0.0523818098,
0.0081351278,
0.0280862432,
-0.0595376641,
0.0236946698,
0.0090570534,
-0.0066325124,
0.0089560719,
-0.0560931265,
-0.0482653379,
-0.0501926392,
-0.0022730851,
0.0435525849,
-0.0029240386,
-0.0137429824,
0.0156093948,
-0.0375804156,
0.0000625819,
0.040411707,
-0.0030739852,
-0.0068177572,
0.0101882014,
0.0480364561,
-0.0056542619,
0.0032546711,
0.0376330726,
-0.0100323455,
0.0227112621,
-0.0495638661,
-0.0020009829,
0.0200196989,
0.0109589286,
0.033488512,
0.0000020397,
-0.0755299777,
-0.0093090273,
0.0129321376,
-0.029004693,
0.0390105993,
0.0688388273,
0.0092462981,
-0.001972999,
0.0396851487,
-0.03704115,
-0.0187907703,
0.020907646,
0.055416856,
0.0442126989,
0.0842407569,
-0.0055470755,
-0.0379451253,
0.0273568202,
-0.0336599387,
-0.063436389,
-0.060776487,
0.0558941439,
0.0252283849,
0.0046427986,
-0.0103422655,
0.0026324878,
0.037539307,
-0.00710792,
-0.0156400949,
0.0103002703,
0.0116002616,
-0.0355790742,
-0.0176076647,
-0.0298280381,
0.0739663616,
-0.0440660007,
0.0073509412,
0.0023350872,
-0.02833887,
-0.0454305373,
-0.018229166,
-0.0279924367,
0.0363120884,
0.028307125,
0.0378964208,
0.0073132557,
0.0511752032,
0.048725266,
0.0300025344,
-0.0323459543,
0.0896024555,
0.023835998,
-0.0402558781,
0.0389780775,
0.0074450686,
-0.0010927367,
-0.0400598235,
0.0052308673,
0.0337818898,
-0.0226684306,
0.0315289088,
-0.0050814757,
-0.0144606307,
0.02814411,
-0.081593506,
0.0647613108,
0.0001274113,
-0.0086588357,
0.0891459137,
-0.0384815373,
0.0682323277,
-0.0090642134,
0.0270579066,
-0.0376953147,
-0.0002791598,
-0.0459528491,
0.0088871624,
-0.014204409,
0.0219812132,
-0.0142411981,
-0.0459330678,
-0.034264531,
0.0038148148,
0.005655094,
0.0076946658,
0.0226826966,
-0.0112575181,
0.0112537472,
-0.0228743292,
-0.0355376042,
0.0225986764,
0.012008531,
0.0312456544,
-0.0370235555,
-0.0445460714,
0.0257921331,
0.0332811326,
0.0054328633,
-0.0175302215,
0.0297878627,
0.0838904232,
0.0278021973,
-0.0659240261,
-0.0255477559,
0.0123714171,
-0.0256402083,
-0.094638668,
-0.0460094213,
-0.0478104278,
0.02182547,
-0.0031243085,
0.0234602373,
-0.0310108755,
0.0199253839,
-0.008020143,
-0.0357723497,
0.0568535738,
-0.0103263613,
0.0255880412,
0.0214767959,
0.0097092623,
0.0200693347,
0.0531612486,
0.046340283,
0.0334256627,
0.0531406291,
-0.0115666026,
0.0229817871,
0.0557292476,
-0.0457545184,
-0.0253121965,
-0.0072140722,
0.030850675,
-0.0054626768,
0.0207354948,
-0.0123800207,
0.0653311387,
-0.0129244719,
0.0235756692,
0.0518395156,
0.0790508538,
0.0292342585,
-0.0127562173,
0.0444491245,
0.0068052597,
0.0414004922,
-0.0532912016,
-0.0139202094,
-0.033876881,
-0.0459165722,
-0.0044901669,
0.0378901139,
0.0337082818,
-0.0152788805,
-0.0404589139,
-0.0426312611,
-0.0151159316,
0.0192261394,
-0.0065239067,
0.0745758116,
-0.0306904577,
-0.0510295443,
0.0324949734,
0.0060144113,
-0.0288398173,
0.0202595089,
-0.0583279878,
-0.0051552863,
0.0463137887,
0.0591710024,
-0.0269464813,
-0.0225955714,
-0.0014896139,
-0.0037217406,
0.0454962663,
0.0277408268,
0.0060096271,
0.0390415266,
-0.0299076494,
-0.0303822383,
0.0151288593,
0.0060930592,
-0.0010853605,
0.0431959815,
0.0095649436,
0.0333076566,
-0.0395086743,
-0.0860862732,
0.0551529862,
-0.0382594764,
-0.0395842977,
0.0127936928,
-0.014772851,
0.0530901104,
0.0091205351,
-0.0253780149,
0.0380036905,
0.0403686799,
-0.026564151,
0.000514536,
-0.0010105161,
-0.0209917855,
-0.0045512677,
0.0516944379,
-0.0264615938,
-0.0076602492,
0.0443512835,
-0.0405991599,
-0.0292011648,
-0.0117589701,
-0.0158541705,
0.0244306475,
-0.0402112268,
0.0463104434,
-0.0407504104,
-0.0011584522,
-0.0412975177,
0.058605101,
0.0138989734,
0.0217250213,
-0.0172143783,
0.0202525798,
0.0304393545,
-0.0157761872,
-0.081639491,
0.0042702076,
-0.0177817307,
0.0242268872,
0.026705889,
0.0072465129,
-0.0546108373,
-0.0263294932,
-0.1060896516,
0.0262483656,
-0.0233534481,
0.0155442264,
0.0168493092,
-0.0280374829,
-0.0204983819,
-0.0024152005,
-0.014903117,
-0.0130614247,
0.0505308881,
-0.0097344397,
0.0404773541,
0.0233448483,
-0.0269939583,
-0.0444704853,
0.0046106772,
0.0129249524,
0.0627567396,
0.0277345367,
0.0003262443,
-0.0435589924,
0.0679176003,
-0.0116215358,
0.0096119214,
0.0029756271,
-0.0342143774,
-0.0058869361,
0.0053240126,
0.0227386188,
0.0293231551,
0.0153004583,
0.0092634121,
0.0426928103,
-0.0244654305,
-0.0006450691,
-0.0138208671,
-0.049934525,
-0.0280073639,
-0.0446428172,
-0.0094279107,
0.0264938939,
0.0459966809,
-0.0202502515,
-0.0017551641,
-0.0093858372,
-0.010562106,
-0.0568810813,
-0.0204779021,
-0.0238818675,
-0.0373372175,
-0.0199057534,
0.0479569472,
-0.0293491352,
-0.0653071776,
0.0321658328,
-0.0679536238,
0.0245927647,
-0.0481512472,
-0.0433222763,
-0.0665706098,
0.0923445448,
-0.001667916,
0.0148423025,
-0.0261827093,
-0.0175508764,
0.0149662057,
-0.0138024641,
-0.0188479666,
-0.0537329577,
0.0319300443,
-0.056369517,
0.0514803156,
-0.0047676591,
0.0052015698,
-0.0404700227,
-0.0463118516,
-0.0605450347,
0.0139786815,
0.033115983,
0.0103137791,
-0.0233702008,
0.049085442,
0.017412547,
0.0103852944,
0.0147732906,
0.0053597139,
0.0019526603,
0.0178559087,
0.0251372475,
-0.0052123186,
0.0450365804,
-0.0151900789,
0.0206473544,
0.0332225561,
0.0309498683,
0.0249918867,
-0.0638886616,
0.005117029,
0.0153454971,
-0.0512726642,
0.0073169242,
0.0252787434,
0.0396147221,
-0.0523481071,
-0.0052935779,
0.1290178001,
0.0291498639,
-0.0063920082,
-0.0073746173,
0.0527412593,
-0.0504800826,
0.0075410116,
0.0061870674,
-0.0350623578,
-0.0194176231,
-0.014461074,
-0.0021119763,
-0.0150809204,
-0.0467806384,
-0.017622916,
-0.1241155416,
0.024807876,
-0.0014297272,
-0.015258152,
-0.0273174196,
-0.0632163286,
-0.0174860638,
-0.0468554869,
0.0243062861,
-0.0120680397,
-0.021151118,
-0.0325531624,
0.0345698632,
-0.0654696226,
-0.0925500616,
0.0539389104,
-0.0669134483,
0.0599154122,
0.0792739838,
0.0273101609,
-0.0204323884,
-0.0176783428,
0.0375843011,
-0.00959861,
0.0092767989,
0.0192548186,
0.023582153,
-0.0322395898,
-0.020394979,
-0.0149678383,
-0.0303049199,
-0.0427485146,
-0.0005333125,
0.005528166,
0.057030987,
-0.009962338,
-0.0039009955,
-0.0042450763,
-0.0029261431,
-0.0175400395,
0.0939323306,
-0.00043135,
-0.0234535504,
-0.0385986902,
0.0148517676,
-0.0196278021,
-0.0202650987,
-0.0415075943,
0.0216486454,
-0.0036645313,
0.013028997,
-0.0460604914,
-0.0019944056,
0.047001902,
0.0178027023,
0.0080908304,
0.0228660703,
0.0251897164,
-0.0025079432,
-0.0344989635,
0.037366692,
-0.0372901931,
0.0345230401,
-0.1023153886,
0.034368813,
0.0441031568,
0.0152833397,
-0.0309778284,
0.0102953305,
-0.0943642035,
-0.0655332282,
-0.0175828561,
0.0506082326,
0.0225640852,
-0.0027821313,
-0.0457615554,
-0.0693940967,
0.0490948968,
0.0140035907,
-0.0568513162,
0.0011207646,
0.002123364,
-0.0097159827,
-0.0072307149,
0.0131796002,
-0.0287457518,
0.0264909286,
0.0283947531,
0.0272036605,
0.0145831071,
-0.0739639178,
-0.0125035373,
0.0449901558,
0.0626732931,
-0.0189324599,
-0.0077996901,
-0.0158586055,
-0.0273626335,
-0.0244623888,
-0.0173301008,
-0.039571505,
0.000903903,
0.065223828,
0.0221244134,
-0.036993701,
0.0260435995,
-0.0111817699,
0.0073424899,
-0.0141951824,
0.0435310379,
0.0012139047,
-0.0186940338,
0.0239178762,
-0.0077601359,
-0.0283581261,
-0.0045993631,
-0.0134821031,
0.0161685329,
0.0052641821,
0.033071164,
-0.0001698125,
0.0026639705,
-0.0059573902,
0.0417992435,
-0.0683012828,
-0.0669070259,
-0.036042653,
0.0504428595,
0.0692760199,
-0.0295602996,
0.0412345491,
-0.0348715708,
0.0027304713,
-0.0534983575,
0.0031832438,
0.0111851674,
-0.034107063,
0.0150928088,
0.0112995161,
-0.0377287194,
0.0399790518,
0.0721445084,
0.0412825644,
0.0236831866,
0.0149283744,
-0.0324392579,
-0.0340568163,
-0.0116942348,
0.0119111743,
0.0015515197,
-0.0424800217,
0.02584696,
-0.0630458668,
-0.0523230024,
0.0322962888,
0.0137852887,
0.0224347524,
-0.0084360577,
0.0093921572,
0.0734218135,
0.0169076249,
0.0340552889,
-0.0452960692,
-0.028833393,
0.0069469535,
0.0076453304,
-0.0009865216,
-6.595498234e-33,
-0.0039410549,
-0.0329716802,
0.0271103084,
-0.0464530438,
-0.033824455,
0.0412400812,
-0.0136725325,
-0.0031434924,
-0.0083461003,
-0.0255086236,
-0.0136940926,
-0.0123454742,
0.0053927731,
0.0129418969,
-0.0091834925,
-0.0093681011,
0.0350743644,
-0.0007243863,
-0.0217387602,
-0.01446517,
-0.0004741891,
0.0308829267,
0.061895255,
-0.0510698818,
0.0018764301,
0.0000976359,
-0.0164952148,
0.0110524241,
0.011574572,
0.0656514689,
-0.0654805154,
0.010541114,
0.0307406522,
-0.0616423264,
-0.0031770868,
0.0186786819,
-0.0331114009,
0.0026859655,
0.0221999139,
0.0117040686,
-0.02156757,
0.0245417561,
0.0358026884,
-0.0050897729,
-0.048927784,
0.012517171,
0.0166562777,
-0.0346738473,
-0.009824086,
-0.0075735645,
-0.0563015901,
0.0558067672,
-0.0096487924,
-0.0066660796,
0.0439880416,
-0.0120219216,
-0.0309184603,
0.0334297083,
-0.0563906282,
-0.0056413854,
0.0311073028,
0.0144605385,
0.0691594556,
0.0111466236,
-0.004456982,
0.0714454055,
-0.0194861908,
0.0091496501,
-0.0149940029,
-0.0269932561,
0.020689467,
0.072648339,
0.0374451838,
0.0287936162,
0.0190773439,
0.0125634111,
-0.1018415689,
0.0255478974,
0.0044404026,
0.0454062484,
0.04039995,
0.0234841388,
-0.0262822676,
-0.0305277463,
-0.0643497854,
0.0057073394,
-0.023771707,
-0.0114408042,
0.060302373,
0.0258741789,
-0.0197498947,
0.0333858207,
0.0221474562,
-0.0632390007,
-0.0203429181,
0.0119029535,
0.0136580113,
0.0105898101,
-0.0008275617,
0.0421606973,
-0.0904621705,
-0.024384439,
0.0011797633,
-0.0037218849,
-0.0026602927,
-0.0561584383,
-0.0036133809,
0.0167477876,
-0.0501012206,
-0.0031617992,
-0.0089231525,
-0.0148277804,
0.033580035,
0.0542839803,
0.036762584,
-0.0103061264,
-0.0120631969,
0.0476842001,
-0.0000431543,
-0.014030938,
0.0104491226,
-0.0146310907,
0.0319087878,
0.0118813366,
-0.0171004776,
0.0126697132,
-0.0278578158,
0.0082279043,
0.0216913279,
-0.0145403892,
-0.0007794132,
-0.0081795864,
2.796e-7,
0.0676659644,
0.0368129387,
0.0150864646,
0.0074968501,
-0.0004043017,
0.0176334698,
-0.047962293,
0.0038250582,
-0.0092027644,
0.0104111619,
-0.0136575401,
0.0128111942,
0.0562372915,
-0.0015255649,
-0.0575411282,
-0.0364615694,
-0.0511107892,
-0.0051751961,
-0.0636471957,
-0.0110501945,
0.0713516176,
0.0925037339,
0.0106089637,
-0.0008565301,
-0.0356868431,
-0.0701251626,
0.0592387356,
-0.0563634448,
-0.0032732293,
0.03925981,
0.0378450379,
0.0730216429,
-0.005909353,
0.0120778326,
-0.0113443416,
0.0399173312,
0.0538010597,
0.0906181484,
0.0113089159,
0.0044631888,
0.0066185049,
-0.0100651272,
0.0099429162,
-0.0555078164,
0.0822844282,
-0.0531082377,
-0.0350973047,
-0.0577088855,
-0.0290765539,
-0.0324256867,
0.0566620566,
-0.013459323,
-0.0222123917,
0.0110404277,
0.0339052193,
-0.019679673,
-0.0397148877,
-0.0857056007,
0.0046088374,
-0.0091479449,
-0.0176127423,
-0.0575746447,
-0.0384985246,
0.0031733534,
0.0500290059,
-0.0533732176,
0.0205255449,
2.59128018e-34,
0.0299860798,
-0.0199369676,
0.0086482121,
-0.0011791136,
0.0470729135,
0.0316284224,
-0.0277484898,
-0.0047531347,
-0.0470270254,
-0.110524416,
0.0322002284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07899v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07899v2 | Correct and Optimal: the Regular Expression Inference Challenge | 2023-08-15T17:40:10 | 2024-05-10T11:16:19 | Mojtaba Valizadeh, Philip John Gorinski, Ignacio Iacobacci, Martin Berger | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.FL | We propose regular expression inference (REI) as a challenge for
code/language modelling, and the wider machine learning community. REI is a
supervised machine learning (ML) and program optimisation task, and poses the
problem of finding minimal regular expressions from examples: Given two finite
sets of strings $P$ and $N$ and a cost function $cost(\cdot)$, the task is to
generate an expression $r$ that accepts all strings in $P$ and rejects all
strings in $N$, while no other such expression $r'$ exists with
$cost(r')<cost(r)$. REI has advantages as a challenge problem: (i) regular
expressions are well-known, widely used, and a natural idealisation of code;
(ii) REI's asymptotic worst-case complexity is well understood; (iii) REI has a
small number of easy to understand parameters (e.g. $P$ or $N$ cardinality,
string lengths of examples, or the cost function); this lets us easily finetune
REI-hardness; (iv) REI, with its emphasis on optimisation, is an unsolved
problem for deep learning based ML. Recently, an REI solver was implemented on
GPUs, using program synthesis techniques. This enabled, for the first time,
fast generation of minimal regular expressions for complex REI instances.
Building on this advance, we generate and publish the first large-scale
datasets for REI, and devise and evaluate several initial heuristic and machine
learning baselines. We invite the community to participate and explore ML
methods that learn to solve REI problems. We believe that progress in REI
directly translates to progress in code/language modelling. | [
0.0152053162,
0.1243258566,
-0.0331180319,
0.0632988214,
-0.0529096872,
-0.0054386039,
-0.011709895,
0.0076386658,
-0.0057016932,
-0.0115495557,
0.0630828664,
-0.024598293,
-0.0210878439,
0.0428929739,
0.0259931237,
-0.0072990987,
0.0405728556,
-0.0440508984,
0.0194771439,
0.0171200335,
0.01511967,
0.0346208476,
-0.0103858467,
0.0434761904,
-0.032394316,
0.0168208256,
-0.0114550525,
0.0155647872,
-0.0306753106,
-0.0167371314,
-0.0042281291,
-0.0109009761,
0.0202346239,
0.0284743886,
0.0000020384,
-0.0482029989,
-0.0178604946,
0.0118386084,
-0.0441244245,
0.0346838795,
0.0110515691,
0.0387343876,
-0.0099248094,
0.0376735628,
-0.0006023413,
-0.0403686203,
0.0979730412,
-0.0073022451,
0.0248044115,
0.0580548421,
-0.0296765324,
-0.0032600996,
-0.0006272132,
-0.0288370289,
0.0467746742,
-0.0444091372,
0.0469808541,
-0.0156541485,
-0.0066415952,
-0.0679667369,
-0.0125222802,
-0.0211944133,
0.009016891,
0.0098884674,
-0.0715908781,
-0.0242345817,
-0.0343318395,
-0.0107397307,
-0.0111565311,
0.0723121315,
-0.0862167552,
-0.0189826619,
0.0278986786,
-0.0020590927,
-0.026306292,
-0.0530924872,
0.0142171355,
0.0262727309,
-0.0140451714,
0.016985992,
0.0139336679,
0.0031069419,
0.0190936849,
0.0062092757,
-0.0596698821,
0.0402708724,
0.0450121798,
0.0149426078,
-0.0137092173,
-0.045218803,
-0.0276287422,
-0.0853551477,
0.0135151232,
0.0185222737,
0.0253479276,
0.0055348002,
-0.0460850745,
-0.0245689191,
0.0113341743,
0.0570023134,
-0.0005163401,
0.0598872639,
0.0237757079,
0.0376261659,
-0.0544361174,
0.0275891405,
-0.017466208,
-0.0140293417,
0.0108282352,
0.0019135316,
-0.0071400255,
0.0165672582,
-0.0480522402,
0.0364649072,
-0.0319043137,
0.0298763644,
-0.0247929133,
0.0282051228,
-0.0308945384,
0.0402027816,
-0.0470934808,
0.0270175226,
-0.018463118,
0.0229687672,
-0.0088193575,
0.0024546604,
-0.0285301898,
-0.0315293334,
-0.0321440659,
-0.0842871293,
-0.0076349666,
0.032469891,
0.0248242635,
-0.0174727123,
0.0405143388,
0.0611876063,
0.0201716181,
-0.0089400439,
-0.0002282405,
-0.0346742384,
0.0573574826,
-0.0195298046,
0.0076735672,
-0.0944038108,
-0.0127461534,
-0.0185157172,
0.0005788309,
-0.0868484229,
0.0177694,
-0.0125281941,
0.0152630927,
0.0321036167,
-0.0126861138,
-0.0106994621,
0.0139774978,
-0.014458674,
-0.0263402276,
0.0044086967,
0.0388760604,
0.0264758151,
-0.0023605665,
-0.0582040586,
0.0729814544,
0.0435936116,
0.000931201,
-0.0099532064,
-0.0169687755,
-0.0021946668,
-0.0160233453,
-0.0224222373,
-0.000776388,
0.1080657616,
-0.0203975905,
-0.0434970148,
-0.0398869365,
0.0721896365,
-0.0377088562,
0.0572816283,
0.0677733496,
0.0425467268,
-0.0092211626,
-0.0216296241,
-0.0368110426,
-0.0056045088,
-0.0191438328,
-0.0132615594,
-0.0032106051,
0.0423381738,
-0.0218647365,
-0.0657900423,
-0.0134351188,
-0.0419532806,
-0.0110075129,
0.0048009036,
0.021892868,
-0.0364839435,
-0.0553861372,
-0.0167704895,
-0.0020634762,
-0.0406762846,
-0.0290721115,
-0.0280806981,
0.0264198463,
-0.0106989024,
0.06572745,
-0.0854543373,
-0.0352705345,
-0.0145256687,
-0.0348552354,
-0.0266830996,
0.0514771678,
-0.0086999163,
0.0895717368,
-0.0475296564,
0.0057453001,
0.0111443177,
0.0000160595,
0.0355225727,
0.0152647989,
-0.0668766499,
0.0204112381,
-0.0096199056,
-0.0593105108,
0.0556290969,
0.0344093591,
-0.0541677997,
0.055216115,
0.0454472937,
0.0442378893,
-0.0410231091,
-0.0056420933,
0.014964615,
0.0353227407,
-0.0209497679,
0.0029355634,
-0.0290040132,
-0.0113153849,
-0.0404619388,
0.0524306558,
-0.0690073073,
-0.0334311724,
0.0767370388,
-0.0687271133,
-0.0274144188,
0.0777864754,
-0.0465231128,
0.029901104,
0.019575879,
-0.0397336371,
0.0140239941,
0.0317129157,
-0.006541241,
0.0222968943,
0.0347533375,
0.0023564186,
0.0033834944,
-0.022418648,
0.0494007766,
-0.0145602357,
-0.0455528982,
-0.0527966321,
-0.0857862011,
0.0014618704,
0.0391853042,
0.0097746393,
0.0016565155,
-0.0010485803,
-0.0114265746,
0.0096132876,
0.0092572719,
0.0433426872,
0.0154815204,
0.0612217896,
-0.0159257203,
-0.0366526507,
-0.0147391651,
-0.0280678049,
0.0294749755,
0.0022069428,
0.065812923,
0.0144521678,
-0.0908335075,
-0.0406959243,
-0.0149789145,
-0.0413728617,
0.0685961768,
-0.0238558743,
-0.005100166,
0.0246892367,
-0.0104057901,
-0.0234802514,
0.0759649947,
-0.0002133084,
-0.0106620202,
-0.0040330272,
-0.0331615545,
0.0007164499,
0.0545323603,
-0.0048862756,
-0.0104965959,
0.0452204533,
-0.0004142246,
-0.0449337959,
0.0383667201,
0.0177552737,
-0.02730399,
0.015359615,
-0.0254020318,
0.0566526614,
0.0678175464,
-0.0012580481,
-0.0123269269,
-0.0174297784,
0.016958762,
0.0427944139,
0.003014873,
0.0095538422,
-0.0285367351,
0.0237452649,
0.0428179018,
-0.01681168,
-0.037526045,
0.0697411522,
-0.0371399857,
-0.0087551819,
-0.0458425917,
0.0024331259,
-0.0356864706,
0.0498862043,
-0.011350479,
0.0365335569,
0.0065546115,
-0.0409289636,
-0.0084773395,
0.0070505082,
0.0004315423,
-0.0197891816,
0.0288041346,
-0.042674005,
0.0417505912,
-0.0189843308,
-0.0256051216,
-0.0625460669,
-0.0059841443,
-0.0162497722,
0.0035446854,
0.041025795,
0.0166329704,
-0.0135560511,
0.0405876972,
-0.0240173601,
0.0498425625,
0.0381063111,
-0.0080942195,
0.0209321454,
-0.0153137716,
-0.0095989946,
-0.0138635943,
-0.0063348273,
0.0236402098,
-0.0073087681,
0.0168477241,
0.0632610619,
0.0468006954,
-0.0576852299,
-0.0080661569,
0.0189943109,
-0.0639897659,
0.0254776422,
0.0529661328,
-0.005195973,
-0.0742613152,
-0.0236340873,
0.0687705055,
0.0258681942,
-0.0579819232,
0.0175646674,
0.0373172909,
0.022680169,
0.0409835912,
0.0649992973,
-0.1246134341,
-0.0237264987,
0.0135309892,
-0.0099910041,
-0.0302489474,
-0.0320764109,
-0.0092860339,
-0.0957290679,
0.0045484407,
-0.0016256798,
-0.0286406167,
-0.0205369387,
-0.0336002521,
0.0265286732,
-0.007327952,
-0.0700638965,
0.0155944014,
-0.0000633828,
-0.0273122527,
-0.0064664353,
-0.0777229369,
-0.0121372789,
0.0517825186,
-0.0313590653,
-0.0056887898,
0.0443470404,
0.0180811882,
0.0168985035,
-0.064714931,
0.0298770666,
0.0303649437,
0.0062002628,
-0.0335740857,
0.0254157502,
0.027121393,
-0.0232381821,
0.0471308976,
0.0288882554,
-0.095983386,
-0.0047942963,
0.0421977341,
0.0629459694,
0.0213374756,
0.0169709865,
-0.018247107,
-0.053286735,
0.0065151472,
0.0471826456,
0.0332307331,
-0.0008195656,
-0.0734490976,
-0.0843015164,
0.0164439455,
-0.0897116438,
0.0244892072,
-0.0732037351,
0.0357882455,
-0.0054591666,
-0.0139331147,
0.0599917471,
0.0616671219,
0.0305246674,
-0.0174935404,
-0.0475197509,
0.0242866985,
0.0190631952,
-0.0661810488,
0.0135196866,
-0.0667243674,
0.005931701,
-0.0365592763,
0.0240184013,
-0.0453398675,
-0.001497518,
-0.0353856422,
0.0286008343,
-0.0790500715,
-0.0329954177,
-0.0241287909,
0.0416410491,
0.0157919675,
-0.0086317779,
-0.0343583524,
-0.0170390867,
-0.0504872352,
-0.0080238683,
0.0051090494,
-0.0106736803,
0.0216885041,
-0.0584942065,
0.0035663464,
-0.0110278968,
-0.0284889955,
0.046493765,
0.0150729688,
-0.0355603881,
0.0080124382,
-0.008419334,
0.0650775805,
0.0816882327,
-0.0007680685,
0.0269847009,
0.0232215263,
0.0027868103,
0.0246170517,
0.0381038114,
-0.0044207484,
-0.0331834443,
0.0301153474,
-0.0052780001,
0.0308742058,
0.0397712402,
-0.0394727513,
0.0324979946,
0.0515380204,
0.0069694258,
0.0378793776,
0.0588703416,
0.0541447997,
0.0431601219,
-0.0253995247,
0.0130691845,
0.0049677473,
-0.0141580915,
0.0237792917,
-0.040246319,
-0.0319048651,
0.0209817812,
0.0563263483,
-0.036776606,
-0.0239627138,
-0.0019737899,
-0.0398693532,
-0.0138081433,
0.0225601085,
0.0859335214,
0.0023221734,
-0.0133752413,
-0.0058774045,
0.0319666229,
-0.0307817999,
0.0044685146,
-0.0045158798,
-0.0120251821,
0.0025425993,
0.0451162308,
-0.006382769,
0.0273400303,
0.0453470349,
0.0071743899,
0.0860094726,
0.0195906702,
-0.0202843864,
-0.0639680773,
0.0204654653,
0.0024984553,
0.0442897901,
-0.0320105664,
-0.0136962663,
-0.0166183449,
-0.0478287973,
0.0104336152,
0.0296151116,
0.0299032442,
0.0368816964,
0.0183564294,
0.0645446703,
0.0249337889,
0.0035689552,
0.0010824765,
0.0216120649,
-0.0256370436,
-0.0441449396,
-0.0154887456,
-5.88665714e-33,
0.0378250517,
0.0006458681,
-0.0225487296,
-0.0204853397,
0.0129797822,
0.0496440865,
-0.0835205764,
-0.0327039398,
-0.0056109536,
-0.0478661321,
0.0025269501,
-0.0141389631,
-0.0047837636,
0.0225780662,
-0.0140294321,
0.0243430901,
0.0302720573,
0.0194171034,
-0.0526048318,
-0.0146909105,
-0.0094716838,
-0.0034718004,
0.0248410404,
-0.0463071987,
-0.062082462,
-0.027251916,
-0.0025204779,
0.0081403926,
-0.0068651596,
0.0659599751,
-0.0258980151,
0.0184480418,
-0.0082453853,
-0.0003612828,
-0.0084283557,
-0.0010254687,
-0.0471162684,
-0.04940309,
0.022884177,
-0.0609099455,
-0.050987117,
-0.0310609601,
0.0775815621,
0.0350208208,
0.0061268597,
0.0330814831,
0.0023013551,
0.0211389195,
0.0331231318,
-0.0410338342,
-0.052167099,
0.0362270363,
-0.0523372702,
-0.0103319502,
0.0403335169,
-0.0004737983,
0.020205386,
0.0354968905,
0.020567121,
0.0100448998,
-0.0136191333,
0.0504794195,
0.0361535549,
-0.0219005626,
0.0049489932,
-0.0131778279,
-0.0047171782,
0.0019966434,
-0.0008984493,
0.0145663172,
0.0307925139,
0.0479448251,
-0.0145118264,
0.0246027224,
0.0828785747,
-0.0173518956,
-0.0842424855,
0.0106209377,
0.039349217,
0.0487063117,
-0.0189636815,
0.0301728398,
-0.0481256656,
0.0040653995,
-0.0343996957,
0.0077021979,
-0.0367663391,
0.0006933632,
0.0150509132,
0.0192261171,
-0.0570022278,
0.0564795211,
0.0259229783,
-0.0556772649,
-0.0020361384,
0.0034388106,
0.022750143,
-0.0083142007,
-0.005433999,
-0.0052059111,
-0.0099663399,
-0.0372087099,
0.0153671168,
-0.0481004566,
0.0531794317,
-0.0180878527,
-0.0099556204,
0.0297159441,
-0.0672431216,
-0.0174824968,
-0.0571269058,
0.0304814279,
-0.0150582381,
0.0633215234,
0.0037993456,
0.0416589603,
0.0274388231,
-0.0175593775,
-0.0077440534,
-0.0287430417,
-0.0267620292,
0.0283815749,
0.0189452618,
0.0318082683,
-0.0540259108,
-0.0672261119,
-0.0294819418,
0.0118106296,
0.0348086804,
-0.0417957343,
-0.0234105717,
0.0089317458,
2.825e-7,
0.0220953263,
0.0415409021,
0.0918097198,
-0.0000547256,
0.0037104443,
0.0140172355,
0.0327579491,
-0.0266011711,
-0.048132617,
0.0123148505,
-0.0005830281,
0.0086391028,
-0.0183037445,
0.0216745697,
-0.0450449474,
0.0485374816,
-0.0103093423,
-0.0193329956,
-0.0251372755,
0.0129253613,
0.0201918278,
0.0857064873,
0.0011414522,
-0.0255140457,
-0.0231290907,
-0.0155511573,
-0.0371587835,
0.0213179514,
0.0336521119,
0.0476276278,
0.0168457218,
-0.0036846234,
-0.0017840773,
0.0045785913,
0.0137146059,
0.0359194651,
-0.0266523566,
0.0551775098,
-0.0372749306,
0.0418038629,
0.0069156191,
-0.0101475604,
0.0037388343,
-0.0206435286,
0.056829378,
0.027799407,
0.0079800012,
-0.0353624038,
-0.0234563369,
0.0312133636,
-0.0183927435,
0.0094992751,
0.0208137017,
0.0190986525,
-0.0074423202,
-0.0644961819,
-0.0250007343,
-0.0448317714,
0.0091655022,
-0.0326718949,
-0.0096791191,
0.012375785,
-0.0438041836,
0.0390565842,
0.0387634896,
0.0140769109,
0.0246343426,
2.940874726e-34,
-0.0049759485,
-0.0409684591,
-0.0182166081,
0.0078279534,
0.0376851074,
-0.0164496545,
-0.0456855744,
0.0147324717,
-0.0265251696,
-0.036812067,
-0.0218822472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.16701v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.16701v2 | Is it Really Negative? Evaluating Natural Language Video Localization Performance on Multiple Reliable Videos Pool | 2023-08-15T17:38:55 | 2024-03-18T08:55:36 | Nakyeong Yang, Minsung Kim, Seunghyun Yoon, Joongbo Shin, Kyomin Jung | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | With the explosion of multimedia content in recent years, Video Corpus Moment
Retrieval (VCMR), which aims to detect a video moment that matches a given
natural language query from multiple videos, has become a critical problem.
However, existing VCMR studies have a significant limitation since they have
regarded all videos not paired with a specific query as negative, neglecting
the possibility of including false negatives when constructing the negative
video set. In this paper, we propose an MVMR (Massive Videos Moment Retrieval)
task that aims to localize video frames within a massive video set, mitigating
the possibility of falsely distinguishing positive and negative videos. For
this task, we suggest an automatic dataset construction framework by employing
textual and visual semantic matching evaluation methods on the existing video
moment search datasets and introduce three MVMR datasets. To solve MVMR task,
we further propose a strong method, CroCs, which employs cross-directional
contrastive learning that selectively identifies the reliable and informative
negatives, enhancing the robustness of a model on MVMR task. Experimental
results on the introduced datasets reveal that existing video moment search
models are easily distracted by negative video frames, whereas our model shows
significant performance. | [
0.0037760946,
0.0095610404,
0.0083736386,
0.0317344293,
-0.0498809814,
-0.0281157251,
-0.0122871893,
0.0081445929,
-0.0464705974,
-0.0323162526,
-0.0039964062,
-0.0384966508,
-0.014561343,
-0.0160513651,
-0.0289103314,
-0.0594297908,
0.0289309062,
0.0476934202,
0.0085767042,
0.0206584334,
0.0575649925,
-0.0199372172,
-0.0001710643,
0.007649288,
-0.035025768,
-0.002434595,
0.0112496093,
0.0251192227,
0.1003717259,
-0.0516275987,
-0.0208650753,
0.0093094492,
0.047048483,
0.0090267044,
0.0000016668,
-0.0380148217,
-0.0111180274,
-0.0130324615,
-0.011043787,
-0.0036567459,
0.0188762844,
-0.0532980971,
0.0139509682,
0.0340557694,
0.005707738,
-0.0191569105,
0.0171430688,
0.0020803879,
0.0179208592,
0.0529976189,
-0.0507691167,
0.0130120395,
-0.0217122827,
-0.0038133922,
0.0481120124,
-0.0079788249,
-0.0155704925,
0.0127800601,
0.0476245955,
-0.0032955846,
-0.04233348,
0.0502238609,
-0.0103454972,
0.0042976402,
-0.0372518785,
0.0222911146,
-0.098407276,
0.0134094479,
-0.0061848299,
0.037066482,
0.0020561253,
0.0123102395,
-0.0103645744,
-0.0212397538,
-0.0291903317,
0.0147180669,
-0.0473724492,
0.0362234116,
0.0122171668,
0.005904844,
-0.0299345572,
0.0344978273,
-0.0083501972,
0.0017274431,
0.0097491601,
0.0048343088,
0.0300386157,
-0.0280984063,
-0.0608955175,
-0.0125240786,
-0.041807618,
0.0117920265,
0.0650780275,
-0.0304237437,
0.0623206608,
-0.0049643377,
-0.0140941534,
-0.007320019,
0.0010976044,
-0.0713539422,
-0.0095755104,
0.023675764,
-0.0729864985,
0.0802326351,
-0.062508747,
0.0481872633,
-0.0234250873,
-0.0018577807,
-0.035173066,
-0.0368463397,
-0.025852384,
0.0468868054,
0.0050390409,
0.006951889,
-0.0305223949,
0.0035249409,
0.0028913319,
0.0054035522,
-0.0608571284,
0.0079727992,
-0.067707561,
0.0278570037,
0.00311996,
-0.0410135984,
-0.0277728867,
0.0593629405,
-0.0387021117,
0.0270623397,
-0.0436373577,
-0.0581907891,
-0.0115496349,
0.0619806461,
0.065030694,
-0.0342233963,
0.0326794274,
0.0069478988,
-0.019903237,
-0.0618485846,
-0.0452879258,
0.0047984268,
-0.0156384911,
0.0110230902,
-0.0300152004,
-0.064799346,
0.0144173289,
0.0026258668,
-0.0115760537,
-0.0026935756,
0.0266726669,
-0.000374783,
0.0249029454,
0.101850912,
0.0376555435,
0.0160056446,
0.014597455,
-0.0207613073,
-0.0052458835,
0.0305903312,
-0.0092340736,
0.0404032394,
0.077208966,
0.0560348257,
0.0699670538,
0.0299248304,
0.0020479618,
0.0465361029,
-0.075607121,
0.0056442157,
0.0159131028,
0.0578135587,
-0.0084224958,
0.0144559052,
0.0113140102,
-0.0425732173,
0.0512831658,
0.0407121256,
-0.0594578385,
-0.0685508996,
0.0333638154,
0.0412415192,
-0.0680193007,
-0.0362233743,
0.0014352924,
0.0707859918,
-0.0296923518,
-0.0187167693,
0.0195995383,
-0.0081761209,
-0.0761995688,
0.0041111098,
-0.0237996951,
-0.0200863816,
-0.0237310827,
0.0352895781,
0.0489697717,
-0.0634234697,
-0.0733439922,
0.0310794506,
-0.0226915777,
-0.034427695,
0.0329683758,
-0.0136994924,
0.0383275934,
0.0394295715,
-0.0039898935,
-0.0463404544,
-0.057218682,
-0.013202915,
0.026323799,
0.0193697512,
-0.0034285346,
0.0089832228,
0.0107056517,
-0.053363163,
-0.0277370363,
0.0257694572,
-0.0042852242,
0.0267184824,
0.0061138556,
0.0603849515,
0.0333440192,
-0.0103117954,
-0.0074673593,
0.0355900377,
0.0568319261,
0.0106996512,
-0.0017438738,
0.0370477065,
0.0246276502,
-0.0219709165,
-0.0212761238,
-0.0091084195,
0.0340862125,
-0.0122481631,
-0.0259152986,
0.0588522479,
-0.0161752235,
-0.0408026651,
0.077244468,
-0.0972606167,
0.0395504981,
0.0597078949,
-0.0288765579,
-0.0504922047,
0.040680442,
0.0060056257,
-0.021586841,
-0.0287842769,
0.0430042669,
0.0189219043,
0.0277634058,
0.0017533964,
0.0132843526,
-0.0163247921,
-0.0028183258,
-0.0073075891,
0.0378083177,
0.0510645211,
-0.0506150648,
-0.0550463274,
-0.0619653128,
-0.0354718231,
0.029712934,
0.0692676306,
-0.0300127286,
-0.0495611578,
-0.0002893007,
-0.0665623173,
0.0499086455,
-0.0252387486,
0.0075988309,
0.0469351634,
-0.0355350301,
-0.0105786286,
-0.0343687087,
0.0119620524,
-0.0390083231,
0.0182811823,
0.0160463396,
0.0211606622,
0.0182826314,
-0.0052541038,
-0.0102673592,
-0.0232513789,
0.0025037578,
0.013088095,
-0.0055389847,
-0.0361209884,
0.0049163401,
0.0268449839,
-0.0087421704,
0.0323345847,
-0.0315583944,
-0.0043129609,
-0.0079862503,
-0.0097968429,
-0.015203069,
0.0433071181,
0.0117640924,
-0.0136937425,
0.0030017933,
0.0286076888,
-0.0048224209,
0.0093275914,
-0.0122465584,
0.0080831051,
0.0351135917,
-0.0520383008,
-0.0365026817,
-0.0443345606,
0.0001212206,
0.0211638771,
-0.0582285486,
-0.038969025,
0.0033739691,
0.0019389146,
-0.013390312,
0.0444223732,
-0.0230699629,
0.0395707861,
-0.0528277457,
-0.0446596481,
0.0006354746,
-0.0279435962,
-0.0190234352,
0.0456005856,
-0.0368825756,
-0.0185936745,
0.0763211548,
-0.0020911989,
0.0051183482,
-0.0212444719,
-0.020045137,
-0.0696626604,
-0.0631136596,
0.0549677908,
-0.0142238522,
0.0387600027,
-0.0140281245,
0.0238506906,
-0.0228496213,
-0.0045665521,
-0.0507092401,
-0.0513596795,
0.0141476337,
-0.0247072503,
-0.0476332083,
0.0113259917,
-0.0777709708,
0.0366247632,
0.0107674794,
0.0426709019,
-0.0164601952,
0.0089481408,
-0.0000280167,
0.0649646372,
0.0605228655,
0.0298932418,
-0.0077953013,
0.0090238918,
0.0104899034,
0.0369996056,
0.0299981441,
-0.0073157907,
-0.0446529426,
-0.0027668546,
0.021840224,
-0.0212134179,
0.0115802484,
0.0020761613,
0.0367063507,
-0.0148779992,
-0.0116881179,
0.0817807689,
0.029613696,
-0.0539877713,
-0.0421591885,
-0.0376603268,
-0.0536439717,
0.0893878117,
-0.0180516187,
-0.0757973194,
-0.015092182,
-0.0205157306,
0.0192931276,
-0.0007725318,
0.0049777641,
-0.020052122,
-0.1076962426,
0.019626284,
0.0072373487,
0.0047841938,
-0.0372461788,
0.0110034654,
0.0106655387,
-0.0562945828,
-0.0084743379,
0.0001024609,
0.0226062089,
0.0065814923,
-0.0144224428,
0.0136397639,
-0.0495092645,
0.0238094702,
-0.0914209187,
0.012007108,
-0.0006862048,
0.0355346315,
-0.0364777148,
-0.063126877,
-0.0163733494,
-0.0517552048,
-0.0044259722,
0.0000781647,
0.0664256141,
-0.0304849427,
-0.0223513413,
-0.0179460384,
0.0022784241,
0.0185961481,
-0.0294946916,
0.0130495857,
0.0896069556,
-0.0419572517,
0.0417640358,
-0.0523691811,
-0.0051887208,
0.0177050475,
0.0561147854,
-0.049826894,
0.0000593198,
0.0202255584,
0.0468490794,
0.0224848483,
-0.0329722539,
-0.0091102216,
-0.048029948,
0.0104508363,
0.0443597138,
-0.0298498534,
0.0073119998,
0.0644199327,
0.0546899103,
-0.0057176487,
-0.006122164,
-0.0237730797,
0.0339081287,
-0.0665706396,
0.0701770931,
-0.0237895455,
0.0037595024,
-0.0541467555,
0.0242864452,
0.0758663118,
-0.0094989082,
-0.0144785,
0.0003051973,
-0.020330783,
-0.0478619784,
-0.0754634067,
0.0291759912,
0.0053826696,
0.0750406682,
0.0051472681,
0.0065402309,
0.0294349249,
0.047343906,
-0.0170900859,
-0.035538651,
0.0374104157,
-0.0457623154,
-0.0353870876,
0.0134028196,
-0.0272923391,
0.0284721758,
-0.0087053068,
0.0328470059,
-0.0513560399,
0.0141754663,
0.0315628909,
-0.0100664701,
0.104863435,
-0.0256605688,
-0.0045651142,
-0.0525115281,
-0.0489711575,
0.0049014194,
0.0014174245,
-0.0289213769,
0.0182644688,
0.0488937683,
0.0210625958,
-0.0401178114,
0.0480291173,
-0.0362224132,
-0.0247710068,
-0.0166967064,
-0.0091427155,
0.029603269,
0.0032855698,
-0.0339757539,
0.049665194,
0.0251017418,
0.0167651717,
0.0257549696,
0.0256879758,
0.0115541788,
0.0352901444,
0.0110072782,
0.0550455004,
-0.0170350913,
0.0019788344,
0.0128194736,
0.0303875469,
-0.0182414558,
0.0157565605,
0.0981468856,
-0.0685706958,
0.0046958183,
0.0197772421,
-0.0175848547,
-0.0351857767,
0.0233214647,
-0.0208309963,
-0.0623775385,
0.0248087123,
0.0119834077,
0.0034756735,
0.0249600317,
0.0362124033,
-0.0832417384,
0.0381390601,
-0.0046324385,
-0.0447023474,
0.0020677941,
-0.0039638616,
0.0249267742,
-0.018550029,
-0.0167408716,
0.0155203156,
-0.0226179082,
-0.0635628551,
0.0265045762,
-0.0206387062,
-0.0261637252,
0.0388545915,
0.0305825062,
0.0124164838,
0.0149579113,
-0.0092336619,
-0.0006790119,
-0.016762238,
-0.0190618671,
-0.0142659331,
-0.0337484106,
-5.405386243e-33,
-0.0017075409,
-0.0162837841,
-0.0084768459,
-0.0260250531,
0.0224336106,
0.0187991634,
0.0185757559,
0.0296341367,
-0.0200753622,
0.0211184602,
0.0127019472,
0.0343612432,
0.014711773,
0.0192879885,
0.0154492306,
-0.0410240181,
0.0506174415,
-0.0344281867,
-0.0124553237,
-0.0334239416,
0.0637020916,
0.0216917023,
0.0656708404,
-0.1041012257,
-0.0539212264,
-0.0000989395,
-0.0131910956,
0.027396895,
0.0536451526,
0.0268953852,
0.0405611955,
0.0269906092,
0.0028958344,
-0.0522114001,
-0.0210327469,
-0.0535468869,
-0.0316377319,
-0.034150932,
0.0171294659,
0.013298057,
-0.00968582,
-0.0125795798,
0.0450497009,
-0.0349587761,
-0.0359210186,
0.0126900626,
0.0476459488,
-0.0314543955,
0.0280531086,
-0.0260198303,
-0.02446598,
0.0321224183,
-0.008283115,
-0.0447214432,
0.046145048,
0.0076955021,
0.0629423037,
-0.0074347802,
-0.056218002,
0.0015143065,
-0.0633172989,
0.042703893,
0.0657087639,
0.0116448523,
0.0224501919,
0.0442038067,
0.0236984696,
-0.0299946498,
0.061429929,
-0.0251122378,
0.0194178,
-0.0065159472,
0.059911415,
0.0739908591,
0.0395171791,
-0.0198866166,
-0.0228225179,
0.0403764695,
-0.0497091413,
0.0356425941,
0.0011848689,
0.0172076318,
0.0090954797,
0.0175120439,
0.0095475698,
-0.0359398462,
-0.0089070406,
0.0000990082,
0.0219935812,
0.0251401104,
-0.0091690188,
0.0293122437,
0.0652840212,
-0.017894147,
0.0381239243,
0.0433152206,
-0.0227467585,
0.0288453437,
0.0409828126,
0.0016051646,
-0.0424244814,
-0.0043652267,
0.0198345743,
-0.0345341563,
-0.0031871202,
-0.0159940142,
0.027208684,
0.0456522852,
-0.062239822,
0.0140888905,
0.0014055966,
0.0051865983,
-0.0411689691,
0.0088705318,
0.0098379562,
0.0180000309,
-0.0332398489,
0.0199595094,
0.040824037,
0.011829148,
-0.0211613793,
-0.047048308,
-0.0392682217,
0.0052752369,
-0.034672901,
0.0216475762,
-0.0514875986,
0.0045774803,
0.0416185185,
-0.0487668887,
-0.0305008702,
-0.0208427273,
2.497e-7,
-0.0003428413,
-0.003281795,
0.0315241516,
0.0142694255,
-0.0237834379,
0.0411929153,
-0.0362590998,
-0.0048597264,
0.0309582334,
0.0041206121,
0.0682288855,
0.0060815546,
-0.0094224736,
-0.002471722,
-0.0310955402,
0.0600168146,
-0.0260729231,
-0.0240724627,
-0.0084053418,
-0.0043356004,
0.035447713,
0.131761685,
0.0526869483,
0.0119093433,
-0.001891805,
-0.0903527662,
0.0588276498,
-0.0340719521,
-0.0123913651,
-0.0102191707,
-0.0000711463,
0.0125440098,
-0.0645178631,
-0.0201514028,
0.0440043174,
0.008484791,
0.0466286018,
0.0215825196,
-0.0009874527,
-0.0443402752,
-0.0363328382,
0.0421839878,
-0.0188617464,
0.0178107098,
0.0696681365,
-0.0297093317,
0.010021368,
-0.0843921676,
-0.0535693131,
0.0357337035,
0.0480976664,
0.0354082026,
-0.0031648641,
0.0110958107,
0.0188887045,
0.0295284577,
-0.0486481264,
-0.0868045315,
0.0222049095,
0.0219125282,
-0.0003633364,
0.0217632558,
0.0113104638,
0.0356591903,
0.0146312537,
-0.0066748802,
-0.0119606946,
1.530481247e-34,
0.02581653,
0.0134150991,
-0.0211886112,
-0.0478623547,
-0.010868879,
0.0129793575,
-0.1152461469,
-0.0246558785,
0.0002373324,
0.0315610804,
-0.0171333086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07891v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07891v1 | Link-Context Learning for Multimodal LLMs | 2023-08-15T17:33:24 | 2023-08-15T17:33:24 | Yan Tai, Weichen Fan, Zhao Zhang, Feng Zhu, Rui Zhao, Ziwei Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | The ability to learn from context with novel concepts, and deliver
appropriate responses are essential in human conversations. Despite current
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) and Large Language Models (LLMs) being
trained on mega-scale datasets, recognizing unseen images or understanding
novel concepts in a training-free manner remains a challenge. In-Context
Learning (ICL) explores training-free few-shot learning, where models are
encouraged to ``learn to learn" from limited tasks and generalize to unseen
tasks. In this work, we propose link-context learning (LCL), which emphasizes
"reasoning from cause and effect" to augment the learning capabilities of
MLLMs. LCL goes beyond traditional ICL by explicitly strengthening the causal
relationship between the support set and the query set. By providing
demonstrations with causal links, LCL guides the model to discern not only the
analogy but also the underlying causal associations between data points, which
empowers MLLMs to recognize unseen images and understand novel concepts more
effectively. To facilitate the evaluation of this novel approach, we introduce
the ISEKAI dataset, comprising exclusively of unseen generated image-label
pairs designed for link-context learning. Extensive experiments show that our
LCL-MLLM exhibits strong link-context learning capabilities to novel concepts
over vanilla MLLMs. Code and data will be released at
https://github.com/isekai-portal/Link-Context-Learning. | [
0.0053239935,
0.0533301458,
-0.0136578633,
0.0790149197,
-0.0228823218,
0.028959509,
0.0283103175,
0.0042633004,
0.0262728985,
-0.0877317637,
-0.0448819883,
-0.0104962951,
-0.0277384501,
-0.0046832408,
0.0604458526,
-0.0449739471,
0.0159720816,
-0.0147785759,
-0.005338388,
0.0028418887,
0.0098645408,
0.0280982982,
-0.0392473787,
0.0273631718,
-0.0511846766,
0.0024450216,
-0.0095366985,
0.0340852514,
0.0266618468,
-0.0491710231,
-0.0141088413,
0.0155284917,
0.0586219765,
0.0008918837,
0.0000019457,
-0.0570075475,
0.0220867675,
-0.0419650152,
0.0027618643,
-0.0569219626,
0.0385996327,
-0.005912879,
0.0081700552,
-0.0146078765,
-0.0364599712,
-0.006632932,
0.0524793044,
0.079229176,
0.0384434871,
0.0703555346,
-0.0322738364,
-0.0739536956,
0.0005379664,
-0.0079107368,
0.0802086219,
-0.0354659408,
0.0082318941,
0.0206998847,
-0.0029212076,
-0.0146388886,
-0.0401688479,
0.03517057,
0.0357413739,
-0.0153983878,
0.0085158953,
0.0498446152,
0.0014157627,
-0.0536247455,
0.004585864,
0.1346344352,
-0.013107758,
-0.0061828531,
-0.001063415,
-0.0180648137,
0.0137666231,
0.0349525809,
-0.064789921,
0.0370721631,
0.0008113968,
0.0329384841,
-0.0260498375,
-0.0130941113,
0.0489490926,
0.0227780752,
-0.0125577794,
0.0125123989,
-0.0037470961,
0.0029972272,
0.003104819,
-0.0058713225,
-0.0254680738,
-0.0199989807,
-0.0579239279,
0.046477247,
-0.0257529002,
0.032425724,
-0.0201582238,
-0.0072548753,
0.0192378629,
-0.0323172435,
0.0352623835,
-0.0018109512,
-0.0518104546,
0.0704405978,
-0.0521941632,
-0.0071788388,
-0.0332019739,
0.0394079871,
-0.0088823754,
-0.0160334911,
-0.0318759754,
-0.0021936288,
-0.0109074665,
-0.0138954697,
-0.0478297621,
-0.0300288014,
0.0012820736,
0.0456790328,
-0.0024575726,
0.0273121148,
-0.0211697351,
-0.0140336752,
-0.0006266465,
-0.0204639044,
-0.0123550585,
0.0284259543,
-0.0098300036,
0.0465697721,
-0.021778727,
-0.0550282672,
-0.0098080738,
0.0492502712,
0.0267496035,
-0.04751781,
0.0125304498,
0.101720117,
-0.0272154491,
-0.0553113148,
-0.0379532278,
-0.0309270453,
0.0032581056,
-0.0626187548,
0.0340903737,
-0.0335540511,
0.0108574778,
-0.0040779286,
0.0181045793,
-0.021365881,
0.0181756783,
0.0036890076,
-0.040045999,
0.1039201468,
0.0090148356,
-0.0085485997,
0.0107411807,
0.0178630874,
0.0057553658,
0.074745886,
0.0087123988,
0.0013064576,
0.0250511337,
0.010157913,
0.0115148881,
0.0404046699,
0.0315105021,
0.038731575,
-0.0445772447,
-0.0202761516,
0.044887986,
0.0411174148,
0.0314759053,
0.0055608512,
-0.0537522063,
-0.007823986,
0.0644215718,
0.0187001638,
0.0323873423,
-0.0097939614,
0.0249651913,
-0.0161230098,
0.0003180892,
-0.0305988789,
-0.0741049796,
0.071472846,
-0.0317810327,
-0.0027717617,
0.0068361131,
-0.0074146683,
-0.0413506888,
0.0142011698,
-0.0143585652,
-0.0313705429,
-0.015082988,
0.0212350134,
0.0583573952,
0.0528312363,
-0.041808892,
0.0231888425,
0.0406482108,
-0.025374366,
-0.0248286016,
-0.0287658423,
0.0345683172,
0.0371330492,
0.0258434415,
-0.024678424,
-0.0048786602,
-0.0320198759,
0.0731422454,
0.0446479768,
-0.0296874288,
-0.0151353125,
0.0488767289,
-0.0602329746,
-0.0386845097,
-0.0167107452,
-0.0225514155,
-0.0012004399,
-0.0024997988,
-0.0030412842,
0.0104704639,
-0.0373219065,
0.0512898788,
0.0432372242,
0.01093568,
0.0196763836,
-0.020922713,
0.0326764397,
0.0051751444,
0.022758022,
-0.0029862875,
-0.0255117286,
0.0346587375,
-0.0574269779,
0.0008976901,
0.0513997823,
-0.0534468852,
-0.0577180386,
0.0222593583,
-0.035168089,
-0.0155986678,
-0.0091175064,
-0.0490403436,
-0.0135193765,
0.034256272,
0.0112212328,
0.0300987866,
-0.0538534075,
-0.0398151092,
0.0312338397,
0.0140871964,
-0.0413089693,
0.0544263124,
-0.0056920089,
-0.0029679935,
0.007349351,
0.0527214184,
-0.0016654063,
-0.0351772569,
-0.0197292101,
0.0213692132,
0.0217819065,
-0.0105099082,
-0.0131959356,
0.0193104558,
-0.0599282682,
-0.0023390271,
-0.0748060122,
-0.0526245683,
-0.0172899403,
-0.0350412466,
-0.0099334242,
-0.0138253337,
-0.0011428384,
-0.0639997646,
-0.0080177449,
0.0446757339,
0.0196311753,
0.0056100874,
0.0490884073,
0.0123056676,
-0.0073312153,
-0.0212595649,
0.0161916129,
0.0273107644,
0.0881482214,
0.0209821351,
-0.017150322,
-0.0451311246,
-0.0071328855,
-0.0191345271,
0.0143938251,
-0.0258640051,
-0.011493817,
0.0195006784,
-0.0610903017,
0.0055597611,
0.0618420169,
-0.003440493,
0.012134159,
0.031517148,
-0.0079563661,
-0.0701960623,
-0.0106296875,
0.0036491347,
-0.0163959581,
-0.0544911511,
0.0268070251,
-0.0443169549,
0.0494991541,
-0.0126464898,
0.0119675873,
-0.0362739079,
0.0066775572,
0.0441792123,
-0.0524616763,
-0.0753490925,
0.0143109094,
-0.0061081988,
0.0082904492,
-0.0377464406,
-0.0676174164,
0.0241136961,
0.0026253944,
-0.0172368828,
0.0215001311,
-0.0121207871,
-0.0277395751,
0.0846718848,
0.0129354978,
0.0255490206,
0.0070255483,
-0.0096225422,
-0.0465126634,
0.0024715639,
0.0074491971,
0.0267991126,
0.0560326241,
-0.0591190048,
0.0258815307,
-0.0242139231,
-0.019416837,
-0.0463698022,
-0.0212938376,
-0.0313616917,
-0.034601029,
-0.0816797987,
0.0049562547,
0.0039191558,
-0.0193390753,
0.0533312671,
0.0111881308,
0.0218761675,
-0.0070272414,
-0.0175626092,
0.0373189896,
0.0426301546,
-0.0030563993,
-0.0215656739,
-0.0433129705,
0.0290832091,
0.0299459752,
0.0334199965,
-0.032320369,
-0.0491586886,
0.0531939864,
-0.0014944583,
0.053221982,
-0.0116478745,
0.0226403289,
0.0466907583,
-0.0158296656,
0.0123999137,
0.071352832,
-0.0045852084,
-0.0618846938,
-0.0205225702,
0.0164028797,
0.01619233,
0.0434976853,
0.0006356333,
-0.1125343814,
-0.0599599555,
-0.0113210976,
-0.033661969,
0.0261604246,
-0.0191934817,
-0.0165519491,
-0.0974259228,
0.0265052933,
0.0013628519,
-0.0757237375,
-0.0201903731,
-0.0271948446,
-0.0155020459,
-0.0109441495,
-0.0106720431,
0.0173023492,
-0.0112953745,
-0.0185009502,
-0.0048141899,
0.0526783541,
-0.0589082353,
-0.0026790211,
-0.0296265427,
0.0420467928,
0.0207340494,
0.0312012136,
0.0162734631,
-0.0330596454,
0.0688742697,
-0.0082206475,
0.0038875428,
-0.0293385703,
0.0395610705,
-0.0153870992,
-0.0277777668,
0.0170184728,
0.0598389693,
-0.028710613,
-0.0414096825,
-0.0291623734,
0.0683071315,
-0.03975017,
0.0221546311,
-0.0119123831,
-0.0082778176,
0.0233659111,
0.0418674685,
0.0321483351,
-0.0329688229,
-0.0123656793,
0.0140382508,
-0.0188307967,
-0.0219298527,
-0.0046154633,
0.0016858719,
-0.0189606585,
0.0369970091,
-0.0627081692,
-0.0158325098,
0.0053177672,
0.0626880303,
-0.0078090793,
0.0082588056,
-0.0602269098,
0.017819006,
-0.0535360239,
0.0577954166,
-0.0379108861,
0.0404602215,
-0.0320371874,
-0.0119844237,
0.063946858,
-0.0631224141,
0.0177947767,
0.0029367008,
-0.0816242173,
-0.0418085381,
-0.0577049404,
0.0562329888,
0.0167238247,
0.0647565573,
0.0352834351,
-0.0613572709,
0.0152516281,
0.0773385018,
0.00202556,
0.0187703539,
0.0093659349,
0.0138630811,
0.0131496107,
0.0347482823,
-0.0519119874,
0.0189145878,
0.0283247642,
0.0153821167,
-0.0534287095,
-0.0047774194,
0.0032329911,
-0.024805842,
0.0446274132,
-0.0508891791,
-0.008838458,
-0.034595184,
0.0212290697,
-0.0049689007,
-0.0050792671,
-0.0727400333,
0.0250152554,
0.0014023482,
0.0089154756,
0.0105889412,
-0.0461208597,
0.0209618416,
0.0752651244,
-0.0225008875,
0.0408153012,
0.0293446537,
-0.0186978225,
0.0079639303,
0.0464767143,
0.020912867,
0.0248353891,
0.0029689607,
0.0174096525,
0.0052527618,
0.0959336832,
0.0453985743,
-0.038270954,
-0.036544431,
0.0152385226,
-0.0162052941,
-0.0037357192,
-0.0102497553,
0.0265848711,
0.095077835,
0.0102210958,
0.0180202741,
-0.0061793821,
-0.0105567165,
0.0049376134,
0.0653170645,
-0.0247071758,
-0.050594449,
0.0669657663,
0.0226467941,
0.0059652617,
0.0504664257,
0.058260832,
-0.0140804583,
0.0491097346,
-0.0316533931,
0.0641118512,
-0.0307338666,
-0.0183068831,
0.0648570135,
0.027752893,
0.0066304021,
0.0429309048,
-0.0081481393,
-0.0701189861,
-0.0069041066,
0.0042756074,
-0.0196479261,
0.0244303606,
0.0474840812,
0.0369505286,
0.0101353284,
-0.0120526385,
-0.0195134524,
-0.0186746977,
0.0139006553,
-0.0094142631,
0.005064969,
-6.266539078e-33,
-0.0151233077,
-0.0423758999,
0.0399452373,
0.0026361677,
-0.0133473882,
0.0017045815,
-0.038760554,
-0.0006625281,
-0.0306945108,
0.0095029166,
0.0208401121,
-0.0136499004,
-0.0070509971,
0.0412970707,
0.0026950336,
-0.0118976729,
0.0042506601,
-0.0005589064,
0.0287826173,
0.0204570219,
0.0352461785,
0.0253637917,
0.0511533953,
-0.0367635041,
0.0037905101,
-0.0075403182,
-0.0430964306,
0.0473929755,
-0.0072848252,
0.0602351986,
-0.0222284254,
0.0375278033,
0.0182186663,
-0.0331782103,
-0.0344869196,
0.0256708935,
-0.0954121277,
-0.0039498052,
0.0247982182,
0.0251505952,
-0.0418445617,
-0.0238766614,
0.0525299795,
-0.0251831524,
-0.0063061556,
-0.0091855554,
0.04294388,
-0.0225811899,
-0.0313241296,
-0.0141667202,
-0.0253731161,
0.0145852696,
-0.0099435626,
-0.0195940342,
0.0183869097,
0.0358608402,
0.0049844892,
0.0371868499,
-0.0513132066,
0.0313563608,
-0.0384385213,
-0.0288611744,
0.0712403283,
0.0554639697,
0.0227326192,
0.0818123221,
0.0229796208,
-0.032845024,
-0.0110385083,
0.0160091408,
0.0221900251,
0.0613715425,
0.004117135,
0.1039774343,
-0.0098157218,
0.0002979893,
-0.0788513795,
-0.0065275421,
-0.0064516575,
0.0352164134,
0.0136825759,
0.0524193943,
0.0146401292,
-0.0022831094,
-0.0424759127,
-0.0025290744,
-0.0490751863,
-0.0086270794,
0.0339523852,
0.0340044983,
0.0025473689,
0.0083985049,
0.0847211257,
-0.0563011914,
-0.0255633201,
0.0155016659,
-0.0093695652,
0.0385896415,
0.0080180801,
-0.0235796217,
-0.0562841743,
-0.0462175459,
0.0519223958,
-0.0216329005,
0.0307127982,
0.0126031172,
0.0687021762,
0.0177391935,
-0.0439057536,
-0.0143739488,
-0.0416179001,
0.0004173743,
0.0100606214,
-0.0052057914,
0.0030246947,
0.0127211008,
-0.0522709712,
0.0636146665,
0.0008074902,
-0.0169861596,
0.0078377957,
-0.0361456536,
-0.0359136909,
0.0094779953,
-0.0490746759,
-0.0097334655,
-0.0178639069,
-0.0316700079,
0.0485198386,
-0.0830239952,
-0.0051401439,
0.0392049886,
2.67e-7,
0.0129976738,
0.0084981304,
-0.0161232091,
-0.0024318369,
0.0578812286,
0.0494964793,
-0.0250404812,
0.0282713454,
-0.0022011099,
-0.0294706486,
0.0026319937,
0.038385421,
0.037503887,
-0.0159167983,
-0.0676240474,
0.0298972372,
-0.0258706845,
-0.0418421254,
-0.0519734994,
0.0015075027,
0.0336654484,
0.0589644276,
0.0040749852,
-0.0291261617,
0.0306641068,
-0.0309527814,
0.0836489275,
-0.0603402704,
-0.0114398906,
-0.0558615066,
-0.004256689,
0.0032229966,
-0.0026937001,
0.0300842412,
-0.0001821801,
-0.0131771062,
0.0054490538,
0.0236969385,
-0.0097653298,
-0.0705138892,
-0.0136764478,
0.0038794854,
-0.0131217809,
-0.0442268588,
0.0756328106,
-0.0696026832,
-0.0367393978,
0.012611446,
-0.0061787572,
-0.0473603196,
0.0113502201,
-0.0095603559,
-0.0453454033,
0.0176346656,
0.0254213586,
-0.0311873443,
-0.0200086311,
-0.107693173,
-0.042057585,
0.015689645,
-0.0412459895,
-0.0273936708,
-0.0262194704,
-0.0253828187,
0.0324516371,
-0.0283097159,
-0.0570401028,
1.719389847e-34,
0.0060125496,
-0.014394925,
0.0067499173,
0.0279618092,
0.0177275091,
-0.0231766179,
-0.0635129362,
0.0045910217,
0.0381124467,
-0.0711679906,
0.0206586644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07889v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07889v1 | A Comprehensive Study on Knowledge Graph Embedding over Relational Patterns Based on Rule Learning | 2023-08-15T17:30:57 | 2023-08-15T17:30:57 | Long Jin, Zhen Yao, Mingyang Chen, Huajun Chen, Wen Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Knowledge Graph Embedding (KGE) has proven to be an effective approach to
solving the Knowledge Graph Completion (KGC) task. Relational patterns which
refer to relations with specific semantics exhibiting graph patterns are an
important factor in the performance of KGE models. Though KGE models'
capabilities are analyzed over different relational patterns in theory and a
rough connection between better relational patterns modeling and better
performance of KGC has been built, a comprehensive quantitative analysis on KGE
models over relational patterns remains absent so it is uncertain how the
theoretical support of KGE to a relational pattern contributes to the
performance of triples associated to such a relational pattern. To address this
challenge, we evaluate the performance of 7 KGE models over 4 common relational
patterns on 2 benchmarks, then conduct an analysis in theory, entity frequency,
and part-to-whole three aspects and get some counterintuitive conclusions.
Finally, we introduce a training-free method Score-based Patterns Adaptation
(SPA) to enhance KGE models' performance over various relational patterns. This
approach is simple yet effective and can be applied to KGE models without
additional training. Our experimental results demonstrate that our method
generally enhances performance over specific relational patterns. Our source
code is available from GitHub at
https://github.com/zjukg/Comprehensive-Study-over-Relational-Patterns. | [
0.0580263734,
0.0138861202,
-0.0152153829,
0.0680638105,
0.0050656861,
0.0006331211,
-0.0735482648,
0.0274612345,
0.0543562248,
-0.0213302076,
0.0381375886,
0.0460672379,
-0.0322007202,
0.0350652412,
0.0154129695,
0.0119867511,
0.0086035198,
0.0596927851,
-0.0014187306,
-0.008181978,
-0.0019926133,
0.0294008423,
0.011012272,
-0.0094251717,
-0.0612329505,
0.0093575418,
0.0265403911,
-0.0013400028,
-0.007311455,
-0.0211111754,
0.0070446595,
0.0014538487,
0.0234698132,
-0.0445055701,
0.000002077,
-0.0379238352,
-0.0044499761,
0.0043041473,
0.0169188529,
-0.0212320201,
-0.0202131681,
-0.0160260182,
0.0748433471,
-0.0053229881,
-0.0517753586,
-0.0540988818,
0.0360366441,
0.0884969532,
-0.0179214273,
0.0555300526,
-0.0191797502,
-0.0259683337,
0.0510466322,
-0.0219221581,
-0.0014613648,
-0.031987533,
0.0626399741,
0.0490358472,
-0.0053938199,
-0.0467730276,
-0.0345678963,
0.0083442144,
0.0097628981,
0.0079782661,
0.0660726875,
0.0165605228,
-0.0116106747,
0.0214317236,
0.0302438382,
0.0949725956,
-0.0064743944,
0.0423314236,
0.0006660838,
0.0270704962,
0.0108256973,
0.059039969,
-0.0137734134,
-0.0667767525,
-0.0084140021,
-0.0084089274,
-0.0186403152,
-0.0271650273,
0.0375059433,
-0.0265544914,
-0.0399254151,
0.0739018843,
-0.0178326983,
-0.0392678119,
0.00028652,
0.0001872741,
-0.0212586615,
0.0006373232,
-0.010182688,
0.0003746779,
-0.0304769557,
0.043596074,
-0.0156004447,
0.0621359535,
-0.005503207,
-0.0157215223,
0.0024986686,
0.0387302116,
0.035185039,
0.0484023318,
-0.096795775,
-0.0119378492,
0.0171562433,
0.0184976235,
-0.0614900403,
-0.0053345626,
-0.1015556455,
0.0353961959,
0.0031015195,
0.0849780664,
0.0114573231,
-0.0504087657,
-0.0345375463,
0.0346471518,
-0.0382128917,
0.0624357425,
0.0029579627,
0.0271832831,
0.032381352,
-0.002127792,
-0.0282948352,
-0.0061875642,
-0.0224714931,
0.0292691216,
-0.0483885333,
0.02999001,
0.0003234227,
-0.0615494251,
0.0362228602,
0.0023369105,
-0.0068275109,
0.0448904634,
0.0417399667,
-0.0334951654,
-0.0299557988,
-0.0412264131,
0.0219906997,
-0.0138019063,
-0.0027148114,
-0.0532494932,
0.0302718431,
0.0114197498,
0.0032948337,
-0.0080104321,
0.0326580815,
-0.0293070562,
-0.0789879486,
0.0411736034,
-0.0218601115,
-0.0116990861,
-0.044197198,
0.0071137636,
-0.0809406117,
0.0312602371,
0.0264358018,
-0.0038706397,
0.0195805226,
-0.0114515685,
-0.0449992977,
-0.0022511065,
0.0359844156,
-0.0100866091,
0.038394589,
0.0335302502,
0.0094835833,
0.0254504494,
0.0461889803,
0.0180293974,
-0.0222716834,
-0.0129119419,
0.0046185763,
0.0149440961,
0.0166174062,
0.0223663375,
0.0284265466,
-0.0047020689,
-0.0024913684,
0.032517571,
-0.026438823,
-0.039377328,
-0.0511814021,
0.0186790284,
-0.0204149783,
0.0128583768,
-0.0161309987,
-0.0288664568,
0.0152597679,
-0.0267400686,
0.0222848672,
0.037047904,
0.0709653273,
0.0141558489,
-0.0010922898,
-0.0056267437,
0.0627609119,
0.0180765335,
0.0240881927,
0.0344663896,
0.0335886031,
0.0577781238,
0.0614624992,
-0.0472104847,
-0.0029263829,
0.0020480601,
-0.0263674967,
-0.049725499,
0.0282763578,
-0.0426609814,
-0.0007583444,
-0.0377516598,
-0.0804765671,
0.0146783702,
-0.0097748581,
-0.008342132,
0.043058943,
0.0070706513,
0.0147691285,
-0.070923306,
-0.0034153161,
0.0211129654,
0.0008878442,
0.0185127147,
0.0472238101,
0.009721294,
0.0430509374,
0.0231156629,
0.0149859693,
-0.0106843244,
0.0327434987,
-0.0328399539,
-0.0565111488,
-0.0088222595,
-0.0236434937,
-0.0286383051,
0.058660578,
-0.0257892814,
-0.007873158,
-0.0159563366,
-0.0282355156,
-0.0347691327,
-0.001596001,
-0.0241171662,
0.0691926181,
-0.0009250044,
-0.0040253983,
0.0168493893,
-0.0238253437,
-0.0182636771,
0.060573332,
-0.0078452229,
0.0160641503,
-0.0327292457,
-0.0637210831,
0.0303942692,
0.0297546759,
-0.0455220863,
-0.029320281,
-0.0084169311,
-0.0022058564,
0.017399257,
-0.0439729393,
-0.064941898,
0.0084001133,
-0.0236089583,
0.0230449997,
0.044912938,
-0.0190066416,
-0.0413502529,
0.0304689333,
0.0281608887,
-0.0264973342,
-0.0291408058,
0.0301406123,
-0.0388433114,
0.0083245356,
0.0111751379,
0.0251666401,
-0.0451549068,
-0.0112951314,
-0.0295649953,
-0.0328746885,
0.0517894626,
-0.0260579959,
0.0148395384,
-0.0075475778,
0.0605024919,
-0.0435080864,
0.0106640831,
-0.0150641529,
0.0273364391,
-0.0386296436,
0.0080059301,
0.0318506546,
0.0233980156,
-0.056869179,
-0.010612742,
0.035037376,
0.0113364188,
-0.0346600041,
0.0033033201,
-0.0432639308,
0.0302682538,
-0.0322644822,
-0.0375614613,
-0.0117717562,
-0.0419526696,
0.0190184005,
-0.0391362421,
-0.071996592,
0.0127167944,
0.0054271123,
-0.0063925767,
-0.022706287,
0.0163087752,
0.0457478426,
-0.0187814198,
-0.0220864192,
0.0154125486,
0.0745305344,
0.0337330475,
0.0446455143,
-0.0059049595,
0.0167685822,
-0.0306379739,
0.045379132,
0.0244210586,
0.0228428133,
0.0173657425,
-0.0257886201,
-0.0261990745,
-0.0356380865,
0.0497755036,
-0.0126192505,
0.0266008563,
0.0222008526,
0.0077699115,
0.0228676647,
-0.0074625639,
-0.0315212011,
0.0296793673,
-0.0190026462,
0.0232028849,
-0.0015527724,
0.0011791895,
0.0107682142,
-0.006649781,
-0.0016939023,
-0.0469163135,
0.0343704931,
-0.0544988811,
-0.0287259985,
0.029166447,
0.0621132627,
-0.030604884,
-0.0081342282,
0.0478486232,
-0.0031039817,
0.0298825037,
0.0112567721,
0.0038459867,
-0.0257811043,
0.0180706047,
0.0017197861,
-0.0672760829,
-0.0342864692,
0.0285302922,
-0.0232235976,
-0.0168911032,
0.0765223429,
0.0581027828,
0.023768995,
-0.0013097287,
0.0133278845,
0.0232362021,
0.0075776321,
0.0382390358,
0.0067661153,
-0.1141808331,
0.0224374309,
-0.0116857449,
-0.02316189,
0.0418607965,
-0.0679260269,
0.0231370553,
-0.0584215708,
-0.000548918,
0.029755827,
-0.0000262718,
-0.0641117394,
-0.0608682334,
0.0200425275,
-0.017854793,
-0.0675248355,
-0.037532758,
-0.0252291039,
-0.0065334928,
-0.0037304685,
-0.0399813615,
-0.0426234491,
0.0349629186,
-0.0560602471,
0.047184743,
-0.0028538879,
0.0098352907,
-0.0084805358,
-0.0153355692,
-0.0770431682,
0.0703479499,
-0.0480877683,
-0.0057902401,
0.0208631065,
-0.0105413506,
0.0173047613,
-0.017078517,
-0.0094979228,
-0.0592798032,
0.0240387283,
0.0322845168,
0.1200074926,
0.0324787386,
-0.0372127518,
-0.0394782797,
-0.0417331122,
-0.0424962007,
0.053081952,
-0.0020778396,
0.0424562432,
0.0150084533,
-0.0256560724,
0.0268904585,
-0.0162253398,
0.0366300717,
0.0291002654,
-0.0492467731,
0.041834496,
-0.04748125,
-0.0261927173,
0.0624746792,
0.0037609846,
0.0236635357,
0.0395383909,
0.0714931414,
-0.0080457479,
-0.0601173788,
-0.0091919545,
-0.0420710742,
0.0143892355,
0.0181194488,
0.0151477363,
-0.0277140494,
0.0070258598,
-0.0112945801,
-0.074842006,
0.039515011,
-0.0219473224,
-0.059416838,
0.0333040319,
-0.0080087204,
0.0506006293,
-0.02171712,
-0.0145554077,
0.0530226231,
0.0060772225,
-0.0251426902,
-0.0416559242,
0.0367139839,
-0.0653871968,
0.0142652681,
0.043481119,
-0.058345791,
-0.0203741081,
0.0034729941,
0.075196676,
-0.0291928984,
-0.0121508846,
0.0221815575,
0.0261211582,
-0.0215590503,
0.0261601452,
-0.0157128032,
-0.0464456603,
0.0062263408,
-0.0330048203,
-0.0025167565,
-0.055244118,
-0.0049711955,
0.0346695445,
0.0165506564,
-0.0020912306,
-0.064150326,
-0.0019417666,
0.0307648201,
-0.0036072233,
-0.0264075026,
0.0366543345,
-0.0342285335,
0.0615868121,
-0.0153847495,
-0.0431434773,
-0.0124044344,
0.0118305488,
-0.0193400905,
-0.0318474025,
-0.0038643079,
0.0030782248,
-0.0183569212,
-0.0424720682,
-0.0180189069,
-0.0121116051,
0.0251611639,
-0.0053406782,
-0.0130988928,
0.0877964646,
-0.025041312,
-0.0021792178,
-0.010639024,
-0.0249976069,
-0.0003704376,
0.0228220858,
-0.0387162417,
-0.0043592388,
0.0493098535,
0.0306738727,
-0.0162976328,
0.0171552524,
0.0590094887,
0.0213542785,
0.0876549259,
-0.0231011808,
-0.0781025961,
-0.0548056476,
-0.0262126531,
0.0690812394,
0.0631830618,
-0.0461115092,
0.0361217968,
-0.0318506472,
-0.0801733509,
-0.0010740288,
-0.0318150297,
-0.0531866141,
-0.0033582349,
0.0067692511,
0.0193882063,
0.0660042316,
-0.042480886,
-0.0270861536,
-0.0357124433,
-0.0340873338,
-0.0391526148,
0.029387977,
-5.615087089e-33,
-0.0096895248,
-0.0194520429,
0.0225192588,
0.0397202224,
-0.0299776439,
0.0087069562,
0.0246104989,
-0.0286703445,
-0.0391808487,
0.0398611166,
-0.016168369,
-0.0305291209,
-0.0165231116,
-0.0185598675,
-0.0005357803,
0.0134444023,
0.0131199602,
0.0198377445,
0.0245025512,
0.0030515334,
0.0018229067,
0.0423057117,
0.0457814261,
-0.0895059109,
0.0033602517,
0.0234560445,
0.0158121847,
0.0067902976,
0.0188858025,
0.0437883884,
-0.0117920619,
0.0638463274,
0.0158601869,
0.0394755155,
0.0054971427,
-0.0446260758,
-0.1276060343,
-0.0379584357,
0.0288461838,
0.0103185028,
-0.006140775,
0.0129581485,
0.0357915126,
-0.0023975826,
0.0795718431,
-0.0615537576,
0.0427442044,
-0.0403153636,
-0.0906510279,
-0.0400492959,
-0.0434876457,
0.0175375566,
0.02454919,
-0.0153749036,
0.0053262687,
-0.0337755345,
0.0509111881,
-0.0739380196,
-0.0745457783,
-0.0077281515,
-0.0312900171,
-0.0002759747,
-0.0260526687,
-0.0186871886,
0.0036612186,
0.00633538,
-0.0016212203,
-0.0044271252,
0.0258259773,
0.0028293701,
-0.0075578755,
0.0642023385,
-0.0297385324,
-0.0055072419,
0.0145946862,
-0.04035284,
-0.0839337781,
-0.0000105918,
0.0312364344,
0.0251743365,
-0.0020871209,
0.0030902643,
-0.0795788169,
-0.0224087369,
-0.0314251147,
0.0587905161,
-0.0170019902,
-0.0543159097,
0.0013114408,
0.0177668501,
0.0277847163,
-0.0104730651,
-0.0269428585,
-0.0937912241,
-0.021349974,
0.0212801471,
0.0021598749,
-0.0057279901,
-0.0064211544,
0.0129090082,
-0.050180085,
-0.0491198041,
0.0074133184,
-0.0679599717,
-0.0006409045,
0.0183027983,
0.0696892887,
0.0045967149,
-0.0279041156,
-0.0167256631,
-0.0071189618,
-0.0693706945,
0.00224354,
-0.0448653102,
0.0214731917,
0.0770765841,
0.0111539802,
-0.005274836,
0.050197605,
0.0174509585,
-0.0234261435,
0.0337334983,
0.0324934684,
-0.0002347023,
0.0100563429,
-0.0175694041,
-0.0367633216,
0.0384116396,
0.015969187,
-0.0119028436,
-0.0294296984,
-0.0218174942,
2.82e-7,
0.0287829787,
-0.0061034933,
-0.0227830801,
0.0699648038,
-0.0241382103,
0.0126417419,
0.0091904942,
0.0408536233,
0.0123897037,
0.0330122001,
0.0503771715,
-0.0219099466,
-0.0371438824,
0.0366192348,
-0.0718124583,
-0.0606966056,
0.0099935867,
-0.044224564,
-0.0276773404,
-0.0102171469,
0.0580873713,
0.0244974345,
0.0709173456,
0.0269845407,
-0.0140773477,
-0.0302891545,
0.0564755052,
0.0036440443,
-0.0173164476,
0.0181437451,
0.0485734418,
0.0302376263,
-0.0003126336,
0.0801118016,
-0.0039675911,
0.0637054592,
0.0261378847,
0.017001776,
0.0066648973,
0.0348912254,
-0.011780493,
-0.0337108485,
0.0489478298,
-0.0196090285,
0.0690639764,
-0.0554986894,
-0.0158515498,
0.0602255911,
-0.0456565395,
-0.0050211493,
-0.0013213626,
0.0367188193,
-0.0005655969,
-0.0135467919,
0.0439300574,
0.0076918886,
0.0083864052,
-0.0417913273,
0.0587201118,
0.0307584014,
0.0031774023,
-0.0243850555,
0.0302864537,
-0.0457424782,
-0.0042506582,
-0.0008696655,
0.0381343104,
2.665004569e-34,
0.0122346608,
0.0080987038,
0.0428418331,
-0.0017288579,
0.0543096736,
-0.0542079024,
-0.0204110518,
-0.0149590895,
0.0326084122,
-0.0845992118,
0.0052765375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.09722v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.09722v1 | A Trustable LSTM-Autoencoder Network for Cyberbullying Detection on Social Media Using Synthetic Data | 2023-08-15T17:20:05 | 2023-08-15T17:20:05 | Mst Shapna Akter, Hossain Shahriar, Alfredo Cuzzocrea | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SI | Social media cyberbullying has a detrimental effect on human life. As online
social networking grows daily, the amount of hate speech also increases. Such
terrible content can cause depression and actions related to suicide. This
paper proposes a trustable LSTM-Autoencoder Network for cyberbullying detection
on social media using synthetic data. We have demonstrated a cutting-edge
method to address data availability difficulties by producing
machine-translated data. However, several languages such as Hindi and Bangla
still lack adequate investigations due to a lack of datasets. We carried out
experimental identification of aggressive comments on Hindi, Bangla, and
English datasets using the proposed model and traditional models, including
Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM), Bidirectional Long Short-Term Memory (BiLSTM),
LSTM-Autoencoder, Word2vec, Bidirectional Encoder Representations from
Transformers (BERT), and Generative Pre-trained Transformer 2 (GPT-2) models.
We employed evaluation metrics such as f1-score, accuracy, precision, and
recall to assess the models performance. Our proposed model outperformed all
the models on all datasets, achieving the highest accuracy of 95%. Our model
achieves state-of-the-art results among all the previous works on the dataset
we used in this paper. | [
0.0782200769,
0.0591640063,
-0.0231524315,
0.0538140573,
0.0058281501,
0.0213680677,
0.0333761387,
0.0265774243,
0.0371036828,
-0.0326560959,
-0.0138879782,
-0.0757529363,
-0.0293064117,
0.0503119715,
0.0123127643,
-0.0331599079,
0.0125234518,
0.0374518931,
0.0280504934,
-0.0300575923,
0.0241371319,
0.0144445673,
-0.0083709825,
0.0088831503,
-0.0591861531,
0.0159736928,
0.0352313742,
0.0091934605,
0.0289603546,
-0.0245163366,
0.0629186183,
0.0511575751,
0.0222387798,
0.0658364519,
0.0000020847,
-0.0512797758,
-0.0005033111,
-0.0349548906,
-0.019156592,
-0.0233607963,
0.0393813662,
-0.0571567789,
-0.0140010361,
0.0470996574,
-0.0464614257,
-0.0154607575,
0.0434260406,
0.039707873,
0.0932463706,
0.0766568333,
-0.0109187402,
-0.0424927548,
0.0353063643,
-0.0086671254,
-0.0104753356,
0.0485668592,
0.0330139063,
-0.0594619475,
-0.0397182889,
0.0088869948,
-0.0274098273,
0.0272482466,
0.0273276679,
-0.0182810985,
0.0214166362,
-0.0379408114,
-0.0216168296,
-0.0204645619,
0.0342846401,
0.0464688651,
-0.0614958927,
-0.0158266611,
-0.0126813464,
-0.0035290322,
-0.0479827672,
-0.0179310292,
-0.0214364231,
0.0279955957,
0.0013586037,
0.041690249,
-0.0227217413,
0.0242095254,
0.0449928194,
0.0331748389,
0.0235335939,
-0.0162921529,
-0.0014922268,
-0.0276629869,
-0.0251007602,
-0.0157402661,
-0.0220364351,
0.0119874682,
0.0353734493,
0.0222901218,
-0.0245033782,
0.0031616045,
-0.0441741049,
-0.0723566115,
-0.0127417995,
-0.0632378459,
0.0159532279,
0.0340218358,
-0.0263142455,
-0.0194961093,
-0.031986706,
0.0395466238,
-0.0230070576,
0.0383032784,
0.0246541258,
-0.0248019453,
-0.0041981381,
0.0072218296,
0.0026336466,
-0.0123962639,
0.0257666036,
0.0255900342,
-0.0757255703,
0.0085760504,
-0.0669150651,
-0.0014476931,
0.0275380816,
0.0027214377,
-0.0317937136,
-0.0079008751,
0.0022475328,
-0.0107567674,
-0.026892893,
0.0022519862,
-0.0462129042,
-0.0996509641,
0.0060942019,
0.0363541543,
0.024041675,
-0.0288004745,
0.0208171513,
0.0873878598,
0.0435424149,
-0.0553407036,
-0.0777458474,
-0.0401807278,
-0.0111480709,
-0.0141807208,
0.0126907788,
-0.059761811,
0.0337140188,
-0.0307909902,
-0.0286529437,
-0.0403490216,
0.0064642504,
-0.0003038805,
-0.054675512,
0.0756968185,
-0.0055778692,
-0.0298462268,
0.0495208614,
0.027891513,
0.0434987284,
0.0297559407,
0.042819649,
0.0334959626,
0.0534503311,
0.0005369207,
0.0385247618,
0.0507495999,
0.0711794198,
-0.0092556272,
-0.016913563,
-0.0096710529,
-0.0489672422,
-0.0170390569,
-0.0034912711,
0.0515137166,
0.0030771734,
-0.0565902069,
0.0578429513,
0.019959202,
-0.0125238253,
0.0738677233,
0.0457474813,
0.0210739654,
-0.0331314206,
-0.0526760146,
-0.0321207792,
0.0150663843,
-0.0286289304,
-0.0345471874,
0.0241210293,
0.0265640002,
-0.0301876459,
-0.0109260567,
-0.0028744696,
-0.0511533208,
0.0576157346,
-0.0565164685,
0.0371633768,
0.0333164558,
-0.045222953,
0.0697202161,
0.0154712368,
-0.026750192,
0.0069092107,
-0.041078452,
0.0516545065,
0.0329664089,
0.0228443779,
0.0228335336,
0.0185345411,
-0.0967863798,
-0.0074082706,
0.0561111197,
-0.0307354089,
0.0127187055,
0.0056942767,
-0.0295041837,
-0.0160022788,
0.0324066393,
-0.0318736248,
0.0024006679,
0.0742442533,
0.0478639007,
0.022061307,
0.0478664711,
-0.0429523885,
0.0186869483,
0.0047157928,
-0.033489123,
0.0006722353,
0.0377518162,
0.0629744977,
0.0240773913,
-0.0183483604,
-0.0487844944,
0.0308704674,
-0.020463001,
-0.0634811521,
-0.0160683468,
-0.0381733067,
-0.0316496864,
0.0244005155,
-0.0583156683,
-0.010454434,
0.0822047219,
-0.0180945173,
-0.0005074933,
0.0655971318,
-0.0325599387,
-0.0061917952,
-0.0208637025,
-0.0180060435,
-0.0522479042,
0.0447603203,
0.0496429242,
0.0369090773,
-0.0461418703,
-0.0105470456,
0.0004986887,
0.0110802921,
0.0512829609,
0.0170263592,
-0.0743115842,
-0.017380327,
-0.0227335282,
0.0091268709,
0.0291863568,
0.0374490656,
-0.0079051936,
0.0125692347,
-0.0637484565,
-0.014296555,
-0.0440173335,
-0.0152683249,
-0.0053437101,
0.0137890419,
-0.0231672805,
0.0102583021,
-0.0240779277,
-0.02193496,
0.05078049,
0.0008896501,
0.018934045,
-0.0642933249,
0.0114002442,
-0.0206878465,
-0.0114088804,
-0.0128042325,
0.0348473489,
0.0043942588,
-0.0563753694,
0.0162782967,
0.0122522116,
-0.021675827,
0.0491402671,
0.0054624262,
-0.0839740336,
0.0162274167,
0.0216990784,
0.008602662,
0.0346242525,
0.0685641393,
0.0477809235,
-0.005683851,
0.0272850972,
-0.0139468322,
-0.0002384707,
-0.031055782,
-0.015060652,
-0.0017337367,
-0.0315198824,
-0.0248333681,
0.0407852307,
0.0438358225,
-0.007461457,
-0.0403752066,
-0.0125923473,
-0.0140130818,
0.0119371964,
0.0012604886,
-0.0656285658,
-0.031633947,
0.0070417989,
-0.0298480913,
-0.0441076569,
0.0725015402,
0.0036945185,
0.0172903091,
-0.0004647837,
-0.0039397939,
0.0155070648,
0.0193451978,
0.0339255705,
0.0265277047,
-0.0424046293,
-0.0136227012,
0.0247445162,
-0.0028771246,
0.0369275808,
-0.0205341056,
-0.0227208268,
0.0070185461,
0.0158100016,
0.0058128433,
-0.0258121323,
-0.0689011216,
-0.0413023382,
-0.0263593737,
-0.0376691408,
0.0132303303,
-0.0285928808,
0.0019038307,
0.0213368945,
0.0170119926,
-0.0013023666,
-0.0054467446,
0.0089854384,
0.0226534046,
-0.0080918092,
0.0274748709,
-0.0415527448,
0.0092740795,
0.004807991,
-0.0023779962,
0.0339544117,
-0.0397257581,
-0.0105227306,
-0.0350498557,
0.0097149117,
-0.0072970791,
0.0231206883,
0.0396470837,
-0.0164100174,
0.0381888896,
-0.0056991298,
-0.0222592037,
0.1115239933,
-0.0002686344,
-0.0248130541,
-0.0141607719,
-0.0116798487,
-0.0251127519,
0.0011731377,
-0.0322019011,
-0.0802944824,
-0.0072951159,
-0.0524904691,
0.0141503764,
-0.0465409607,
-0.0361227319,
0.0043792068,
-0.0932541266,
0.000651984,
-0.0119953761,
-0.0024454361,
-0.0621108338,
0.0002030654,
-0.0318595022,
-0.0103142336,
0.0339930393,
-0.0190597493,
0.0224574097,
-0.0259732325,
-0.0037859117,
-0.0735847354,
-0.0163680967,
0.0327493846,
-0.0665584356,
0.0605308861,
0.0180853028,
0.0583661608,
-0.043318104,
-0.0308785941,
0.0001608599,
0.0016046545,
-0.0281190444,
-0.0351145752,
0.0660184696,
-0.0216401294,
-0.0307541266,
0.0017319128,
0.0536761321,
-0.0323510878,
0.0119018424,
-0.0286374353,
0.0437700339,
0.0126985079,
-0.0274624135,
-0.0224012677,
0.0013985076,
0.0054362211,
0.051234141,
0.0484441929,
-0.0335966088,
0.0269013103,
-0.0402957536,
-0.0461724885,
-0.0600244701,
-0.0755062699,
-0.0049226414,
-0.0263973698,
-0.0480242856,
-0.0330992639,
-0.0493810847,
0.0128406836,
-0.0103477677,
-0.0044074538,
-0.0330716074,
0.0449918509,
-0.0263599027,
-0.0810050666,
-0.0027192014,
-0.0046630814,
0.0559433177,
-0.0183845777,
0.0178662576,
0.0109544722,
-0.0151673593,
-0.0008886865,
0.0290526692,
-0.0722011328,
-0.035418082,
0.0335149467,
0.0772344321,
0.0164163392,
0.0513956957,
-0.0374729,
-0.0473190658,
0.0820380375,
0.0238211006,
-0.0093824808,
-0.0478137061,
0.0339691602,
0.040577095,
0.002966082,
0.0106425229,
-0.0109890932,
0.0496141464,
0.0202068929,
-0.0401750989,
-0.0464571156,
-0.0250900853,
-0.0318325311,
-0.0060225748,
0.0582037307,
0.0164711587,
-0.0300432201,
-0.0339300483,
-0.03816282,
0.0014871978,
-0.0055582337,
0.0087586297,
0.0349947363,
0.0291056763,
0.0017830933,
-0.0468237326,
-0.042444516,
-0.0317177847,
-0.0072291642,
-0.0385440178,
0.0163696818,
0.0018398401,
0.0615151562,
0.0148076992,
0.025213711,
-0.0222850889,
0.0257272199,
0.0346768275,
-0.0013944423,
0.0149528822,
0.0261403322,
-0.0047876206,
0.0404925011,
0.0409235507,
0.0031942141,
0.0241521951,
-0.0163747724,
-0.0800416023,
-0.0262871161,
0.0036367504,
-0.0230163615,
0.0595697314,
0.0031369708,
0.0099677695,
-0.0045341714,
0.0348688327,
-0.0525298566,
-0.0425267927,
0.007290334,
0.0078914454,
-0.0202657171,
0.0294503644,
0.0460246801,
-0.0105520273,
-0.0010930024,
0.0351265632,
-0.048748292,
-0.0290051959,
0.0306434985,
0.038021367,
0.0075073051,
0.0096877543,
0.0240659304,
0.0086419294,
-0.076735355,
0.0387226455,
-0.0379169807,
0.0288253687,
0.0027195362,
0.0355605334,
0.0443581156,
0.0247949343,
0.0502858795,
-0.0241648648,
0.0068777464,
0.0247870181,
-0.0788540617,
-0.0153951952,
-6.361701958e-33,
0.0180974733,
-0.0350513197,
-0.0300715286,
-0.0188675653,
0.0002722639,
-0.0231405105,
-0.0239671823,
-0.0015068501,
-0.0232564788,
0.0141699752,
0.0094328187,
0.0366787389,
-0.0105921933,
0.0203414913,
0.0088373618,
-0.040925011,
0.039032802,
0.0020472363,
0.0052919928,
0.0195254404,
0.0719044283,
0.0319542438,
0.0653039888,
-0.0734363943,
0.0568028949,
-0.0509500839,
0.0035271735,
0.01218645,
0.0358337462,
0.0632213727,
-0.0152523508,
0.0854903311,
0.0273257084,
-0.0153455418,
0.0093617439,
0.031559594,
-0.046646405,
-0.0274705347,
-0.0160879213,
0.0168640595,
-0.0178364702,
-0.0058404626,
0.0609055609,
-0.0029312687,
-0.0312912799,
-0.0035178633,
0.0292641465,
0.0116918068,
0.0201714803,
-0.0719110519,
-0.0438133255,
0.0047946451,
-0.016161453,
-0.0107395528,
-0.0083065638,
0.0449176766,
0.0312164798,
0.0265257675,
-0.1391072422,
0.0142025212,
-0.0238173213,
-0.0299534984,
0.019454414,
-0.0350255333,
-0.0198444426,
0.0424139351,
-0.0156914946,
0.0046891766,
-0.0287238918,
0.0370860584,
0.0186546501,
0.0272123627,
0.0522893816,
0.0605120845,
0.0353096016,
-0.1144443303,
-0.0828047618,
0.0253631324,
0.0506740436,
0.0297985896,
0.0238348953,
-0.0058774389,
-0.0515050665,
-0.0383645333,
0.027922092,
-0.0549864545,
-0.0326307043,
-0.0428327136,
-0.0120059317,
-0.0242414307,
-0.024742581,
-0.0146457497,
0.02367194,
-0.0361590795,
0.0228467081,
0.0432131439,
-0.0190636292,
0.0025163007,
0.0277278665,
0.0606282502,
0.0127176996,
-0.0026690317,
0.0197571535,
-0.0215014797,
0.0032200858,
0.0111409165,
0.0725567117,
0.0361606181,
-0.0437041372,
-0.0072930059,
-0.0193878207,
0.0403094962,
-0.0199571047,
0.0687143579,
-0.0344782025,
0.0399591662,
-0.0221607909,
0.0121544125,
0.0129176471,
0.0080609368,
-0.0141827874,
0.0146354334,
-0.0059427614,
-0.0188139211,
0.0053957561,
-0.0258166622,
-0.0514449328,
0.0441718474,
0.010336291,
-0.1261970699,
0.0237519424,
-0.0330006965,
2.849e-7,
-0.0136318756,
0.0540927686,
0.0134231886,
-0.0162871219,
0.0356984027,
0.0271632336,
0.0343138948,
0.0520389825,
0.0023857036,
-0.0191767421,
-0.016600186,
0.0394961722,
0.0094396416,
0.0407111607,
-0.0439954624,
-0.0120159369,
-0.0953353941,
-0.0089823706,
-0.0454536341,
-0.0082162507,
0.0081179319,
0.076251924,
0.061471343,
-0.0299871862,
0.0169278309,
-0.0157702025,
0.0250469949,
-0.0192886945,
-0.0113772899,
-0.0190250259,
0.0548522621,
0.0426843055,
0.02500787,
-0.0023250158,
-0.0103837801,
0.0212909672,
-0.0011123867,
0.0042138533,
-0.0031004064,
-0.0033581706,
0.0142428549,
-0.0128462519,
0.0112670055,
-0.0207260381,
0.0389323384,
-0.0139288986,
-0.0399975702,
-0.0038985538,
0.0075935367,
0.0006533728,
0.0701267272,
-0.0405169055,
0.0015627403,
-0.0145486649,
0.0406838618,
-0.0147092184,
0.0028156356,
-0.084591195,
0.0311991666,
-0.0177042019,
-0.0365705229,
-0.0165124908,
-0.000858881,
-0.0136035318,
0.0657695532,
0.0272172689,
0.0707361028,
2.050505254e-34,
0.032892257,
-0.006757197,
0.004974056,
-0.0290144123,
0.0472778827,
0.0353761651,
-0.005785876,
-0.0129785193,
0.04794579,
-0.0265670251,
-0.043540366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07876v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07876v3 | Leveraging Codebook Knowledge with NLI and ChatGPT for Zero-Shot Political Relation Classification | 2023-08-15T16:41:53 | 2024-06-06T14:46:44 | Yibo Hu, Erick Skorupa Parolin, Latifur Khan, Patrick T. Brandt, Javier Osorio, Vito J. D'Orazio | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Is it possible accurately classify political relations within evolving event
ontologies without extensive annotations? This study investigates zero-shot
learning methods that use expert knowledge from existing annotation codebook,
and evaluates the performance of advanced ChatGPT (GPT-3.5/4) and a natural
language inference (NLI)-based model called ZSP. ChatGPT uses codebook's
labeled summaries as prompts, whereas ZSP breaks down the classification task
into context, event mode, and class disambiguation to refine task-specific
hypotheses. This decomposition enhances interpretability, efficiency, and
adaptability to schema changes. The experiments reveal ChatGPT's strengths and
limitations, and crucially show ZSP's outperformance of dictionary-based
methods and its competitive edge over some supervised models. These findings
affirm the value of ZSP for validating event records and advancing ontology
development. Our study underscores the efficacy of leveraging transfer learning
and existing domain expertise to enhance research efficiency and scalability. | [
0.002063202,
0.0267737471,
0.0093197664,
0.0493321568,
-0.0164451655,
0.0169696622,
0.0121005857,
-0.0034433703,
0.0438348018,
-0.0741596669,
0.0485175624,
-0.0027294131,
-0.0349629782,
0.0393208526,
-0.0292066485,
-0.0708523318,
0.0673913658,
0.0346366018,
0.0130651416,
0.0391092934,
-0.0063738213,
0.0109531721,
-0.0272973105,
0.0419850424,
-0.0184882525,
0.0167842563,
-0.0339151211,
-0.0151972426,
0.0357498452,
-0.0227982197,
-0.0055887438,
0.0468015522,
0.0560683459,
0.041903086,
0.0000021335,
-0.0868066326,
-0.0486006737,
-0.0077254148,
-0.0277316999,
-0.0336593874,
0.027036,
0.0061184815,
0.02787745,
-0.0007674525,
-0.0377430506,
-0.0390571281,
0.0387001,
0.0284879059,
0.03646354,
0.0657681748,
-0.0122762546,
-0.0090255123,
-0.0026984566,
-0.0104611069,
0.0080181211,
-0.0556293428,
0.0380339101,
0.0187323485,
-0.0098305577,
-0.0036572227,
0.0083982954,
0.0051515345,
-0.00935644,
0.0036266551,
0.009024947,
0.0251276512,
-0.0410674959,
0.0226330161,
0.0147563582,
0.0234886669,
0.0594410934,
-0.0141898943,
0.0216167811,
0.0019143869,
-0.0180372074,
0.0345208347,
0.0037377223,
0.0118915429,
-0.039251823,
0.0280057173,
0.0477572978,
0.0133420061,
0.0148648825,
0.0301071946,
-0.0328125991,
0.0589412712,
-0.0250429474,
-0.0051296325,
-0.0016955753,
-0.002850875,
0.0249756128,
-0.052445814,
-0.0263054557,
0.0138910133,
0.0047355141,
0.0293325428,
-0.0109567279,
0.045861952,
-0.0054869596,
-0.0390205681,
-0.0337967016,
0.0476685427,
0.0017456225,
0.0626943111,
0.0476558693,
-0.0254401192,
0.0250464529,
-0.0018223366,
-0.0027447741,
-0.0281334091,
-0.1535831392,
0.0265308116,
-0.0338812359,
0.0694640875,
-0.0078335265,
0.0128744561,
-0.0385131091,
-0.0128722182,
0.004436227,
0.0057238918,
-0.0504518412,
-0.0137168039,
-0.0119198402,
0.0017166546,
-0.0779267997,
0.0335335247,
-0.0113555705,
-0.0009172734,
-0.0493882932,
-0.0329055041,
0.0116367191,
0.0132210879,
-0.0024322502,
0.0020718446,
-0.0313801281,
0.0535205044,
-0.0203244966,
-0.0119817061,
-0.0368633233,
-0.0100743817,
-0.0258629583,
-0.0212445147,
0.0249351207,
-0.0444985218,
0.0025388433,
-0.0084463106,
0.005719129,
-0.056840349,
-0.0058126841,
-0.0296649877,
-0.0587631762,
0.0932848901,
-0.0590383671,
-0.0074214623,
0.0431282632,
0.0397358388,
-0.0331619531,
0.0733201355,
0.0243363343,
0.0006259891,
0.0351004638,
0.0150061483,
0.0079263002,
-0.0161538348,
-0.0169155914,
0.0298620351,
-0.0212075002,
0.0059356019,
-0.0125580179,
-0.0316360258,
0.0051546581,
-0.0351937301,
-0.0088861985,
0.0053523448,
0.0130099487,
0.0424382985,
-0.0042256759,
0.0210588984,
0.0000799375,
0.0235722698,
-0.0063250884,
-0.0071375798,
-0.0277978648,
0.0204932466,
-0.0272094626,
-0.019486947,
0.0239539146,
-0.024130607,
-0.0157446153,
-0.0289641842,
-0.0308497753,
-0.0052632941,
-0.0001640007,
0.0055331294,
0.0695712864,
-0.025408553,
-0.0009613119,
0.0467860773,
0.0630324632,
-0.0216793101,
0.0121522062,
-0.0717151761,
0.0216148924,
0.0552244633,
0.0120494487,
-0.0780364051,
-0.0667696893,
-0.0343929678,
0.0246872362,
0.0443913154,
0.0587505065,
-0.0177486762,
0.0181694347,
0.0067930762,
-0.0475944467,
0.0051659974,
0.0344117656,
0.0472178608,
0.0308648217,
0.0253644064,
0.0005574104,
0.0053182198,
0.0067644836,
0.0164611973,
-0.0102286004,
-0.023781009,
-0.0074110413,
0.0143883899,
0.0213130582,
0.0147392377,
-0.0026042406,
-0.032326296,
0.0028329713,
-0.0301837288,
-0.0245574042,
-0.020675851,
-0.0171089638,
-0.0058638528,
0.0264257193,
-0.0115282936,
-0.0080361255,
-0.0129551394,
-0.0350688584,
-0.0283482838,
0.0538023785,
0.0389802568,
0.0447451994,
-0.0239621736,
-0.0315039903,
-0.0110381404,
-0.0238283779,
-0.0414388888,
0.0604107976,
0.0368108451,
-0.0181267262,
0.0062417751,
-0.0397711098,
0.0611191578,
0.0282291491,
-0.0090192324,
0.0319823585,
-0.0134319235,
-0.0071732984,
0.0469888337,
-0.0205590855,
-0.0335499272,
0.0141135044,
-0.0580244325,
0.0273867436,
-0.0141572766,
0.0361352339,
0.0127435196,
-0.0065651624,
-0.0066466797,
0.0253323801,
-0.0116182547,
-0.0239948854,
-0.0638299733,
-0.0368682183,
0.0342949145,
0.0135098249,
-0.0168789718,
-0.0261697825,
0.0416447334,
-0.0512672365,
0.0542023145,
0.0047462117,
-0.0677353665,
0.0177966543,
0.019424377,
-0.0639253706,
0.0297952984,
-0.032980606,
-0.0027898825,
0.0298655555,
0.0031862974,
0.0081675332,
-0.0290495437,
-0.0024951138,
0.0682535544,
0.0400845334,
-0.0455033928,
-0.0310226679,
0.0144356089,
-0.0223814547,
-0.0227758642,
-0.0035926758,
-0.0120089073,
-0.0025512634,
0.052099172,
0.0078203371,
-0.0091942921,
-0.0746023804,
0.0082122665,
-0.0512348823,
0.0157625042,
-0.0315544046,
0.0173226856,
0.0070038498,
0.0552436225,
-0.0043356265,
0.0011210915,
0.0311103668,
0.0281746425,
0.0482725799,
-0.0356827416,
-0.026759835,
-0.0509367846,
0.1056947336,
-0.0406422243,
0.0148007479,
0.0357656963,
-0.0013806684,
-0.0237791929,
-0.0684969202,
0.0491690896,
-0.0215447694,
0.0373193249,
-0.095786944,
0.0534128211,
-0.0407029614,
0.0022280049,
-0.0395708419,
-0.0042939619,
-0.0162456185,
0.0688738674,
0.0097599234,
0.0047700619,
0.0077008191,
0.059336748,
0.0088270037,
0.0221101362,
0.0354327299,
-0.0416275114,
0.0041758884,
0.027635932,
-0.007551685,
-0.0148321195,
-0.01529874,
0.063762702,
-0.0046914006,
0.0024811092,
-0.0011829711,
0.0340382308,
-0.0565158688,
-0.000010545,
0.0064708483,
-0.0857798904,
-0.011190312,
-0.0166713931,
-0.0040590791,
-0.0642538145,
0.020237051,
0.0973887444,
0.0575549901,
-0.0328413993,
0.0054399171,
0.010698773,
-0.0479698516,
0.0194164291,
-0.0048180372,
-0.1213734224,
-0.0108876927,
-0.0182370022,
-0.0212420486,
-0.0313480049,
-0.0691518635,
-0.0286079049,
-0.0973663628,
0.0124746663,
-0.0141227897,
-0.0648419335,
0.0065359864,
-0.0673467442,
0.0370131396,
-0.0547401533,
-0.0811474398,
-0.0290835258,
-0.0234528948,
-0.011882049,
0.003190022,
-0.0961292461,
-0.056039378,
0.0414333791,
-0.0255929139,
0.0805544779,
-0.0098115196,
0.0572771579,
0.0167781767,
0.0569430329,
0.0375605896,
-0.0369863808,
-0.0014521186,
-0.0131520219,
0.0806790143,
-0.016548669,
0.0138223749,
0.0203274582,
0.0053696739,
0.0179648474,
-0.0340207554,
0.0029202153,
0.0519745648,
-0.0326565355,
0.0031510454,
0.0139192306,
-0.0101004271,
0.031152552,
0.0698795468,
-0.0070898044,
0.0099144336,
-0.0185685977,
-0.0200498849,
0.0284953937,
-0.0476479791,
0.0014674271,
0.0062059416,
-0.0876611844,
-0.0747276992,
-0.0051828544,
-0.037078876,
0.034517318,
0.001043177,
-0.0255735964,
0.0385010391,
0.0412140377,
0.0163018163,
-0.0262874682,
0.0087361066,
-0.0610757656,
-0.021484321,
0.0512907207,
-0.0686461627,
0.0214833338,
0.0286334548,
-0.022689471,
0.0003456828,
-0.0202697273,
-0.0145141846,
0.0089449426,
-0.0226784088,
0.0258546546,
0.033440236,
0.0024707236,
0.0144466106,
0.0042894054,
0.0564681776,
-0.0224993061,
-0.0578416176,
0.023273468,
0.0718445703,
-0.0021095162,
0.0413480178,
-0.0135436719,
0.0383700654,
0.009091272,
-0.0404669568,
-0.107751824,
-0.0326824524,
0.0005823503,
-0.0298240464,
0.0645680949,
-0.0171373896,
-0.1004303098,
-0.0370066725,
-0.0201649535,
-0.0165269356,
-0.0039878734,
-0.0028380749,
-0.0288005937,
-0.0263847485,
-0.0217750762,
-0.0334332325,
0.0542263761,
-0.0512854531,
0.038159918,
-0.0173130464,
0.0157231316,
0.0443261452,
0.0343584269,
-0.012218277,
-0.0037915618,
-0.0266313925,
0.0145756425,
0.0121846413,
-0.0091503188,
-0.0303431228,
0.0114778299,
0.013818955,
0.0212798212,
0.0015255169,
-0.0153239826,
-0.0279223416,
-0.0069533596,
0.0055116937,
0.0677882284,
0.078159228,
-0.0131253675,
0.0120130451,
-0.010183814,
-0.0103778979,
0.0159032084,
0.0348826982,
-0.0046619722,
-0.011820361,
0.0002825643,
0.0163917802,
-0.0327020995,
0.0543717258,
0.0763210356,
0.02756547,
0.0191043764,
0.0302913506,
-0.0202985313,
-0.0227962136,
-0.0077481088,
0.0690596774,
0.0029960945,
-0.0047206287,
0.0042649158,
-0.0955834836,
-0.0156501364,
0.0368682668,
-0.0307960771,
-0.0166543592,
0.0337612107,
0.0267461371,
0.0404867902,
0.0307878926,
-0.0011979414,
-0.0392268747,
-0.0161594264,
-0.0167157631,
-0.0035617771,
0.0106737306,
-6.951584125e-33,
-0.0331047922,
-0.0353536904,
0.0511792786,
0.0133459307,
-0.0355043337,
0.0015144313,
-0.0304930005,
-0.0149981417,
-0.0236033499,
0.0011985217,
0.0044087139,
0.0056944839,
0.0116845081,
-0.0148124201,
0.0161757916,
-0.0406503156,
0.0267369822,
0.0285506286,
-0.0110868635,
0.0244588852,
0.054881759,
-0.0147107095,
0.056054581,
-0.0919016823,
0.0243242495,
0.0290998444,
0.0157946907,
-0.026483871,
0.0643738508,
0.0184619073,
-0.0247614309,
0.0374948308,
0.0483249761,
-0.0732087418,
0.0357965864,
-0.0172745399,
-0.0643689856,
-0.0382870622,
0.008982257,
-0.0438826121,
0.0562431887,
-0.0179191921,
-0.0208366252,
0.0392559841,
0.0088472506,
-0.0354647264,
0.0764192119,
-0.0196458437,
-0.004143503,
-0.0597123355,
-0.074213542,
0.0649289936,
-0.025829969,
-0.0189269036,
-0.0175975487,
0.0028845286,
0.0370177366,
-0.0001866718,
-0.0685099065,
-0.0007419024,
-0.0095035424,
-0.0065703099,
0.0294244252,
-0.0015755967,
-0.0250594951,
0.033646144,
-0.0112811234,
0.0331152864,
-0.0563207418,
-0.045293007,
0.0445616655,
0.0308396071,
-0.0291589107,
0.0559623614,
0.0411833413,
-0.0326242037,
-0.1041352078,
0.0227145031,
0.046025034,
0.0027297032,
-0.02705005,
0.0053040623,
0.0004185688,
-0.0476213209,
-0.0115219848,
-0.0033796579,
-0.0256176013,
-0.0137297409,
0.008445383,
-0.0153370826,
0.0016925592,
0.0783587769,
0.0232788194,
-0.032984186,
-0.001483113,
-0.0163410828,
0.002172739,
0.0188655853,
0.0032321285,
0.0119090881,
-0.0757350549,
-0.0323158316,
0.0094354209,
0.0100823659,
0.0363655984,
0.010060465,
0.0081180567,
0.0226590876,
-0.0340347141,
-0.0045577209,
-0.0074049728,
-0.0211902987,
-0.0172817558,
0.000138171,
-0.0068446179,
0.0499948412,
0.0460542552,
-0.0028661441,
0.0583061017,
0.0277783424,
0.0383524857,
0.0019402077,
-0.0467101522,
-0.0155858435,
0.0128534473,
0.0013268755,
0.0167112947,
0.0148569159,
-0.0100263385,
-0.0003678933,
-0.0235303808,
-0.0201358665,
2.999e-7,
0.0742746666,
0.0588538945,
-0.0109442845,
0.0068243193,
-0.0342482924,
0.0144025302,
0.011825108,
0.035370741,
-0.0399217457,
-0.0304789003,
0.0126538621,
0.0331019461,
0.0165837631,
0.0883023441,
-0.0725095719,
-0.0641157031,
0.0219620951,
0.0044421698,
-0.0980029553,
0.0447710976,
0.1000187695,
0.0155679788,
0.0708701536,
0.0131824249,
-0.0173316058,
-0.0034184391,
0.0225978605,
-0.0288493801,
-0.0391525663,
0.05434433,
0.0175644234,
0.025447391,
-0.012081298,
0.0790115595,
-0.0107303159,
-0.0091185151,
-0.0146696726,
0.0308331214,
-0.0260835309,
0.0060012452,
-0.0248293132,
-0.0232954156,
0.0279058665,
-0.0248754434,
0.0819986463,
-0.0770251378,
0.0105455499,
0.0043813586,
-0.0331950821,
0.0352674127,
0.0313139148,
0.0389911346,
-0.0133410664,
0.011939317,
-0.029999353,
0.0021511815,
-0.0236807056,
-0.068217054,
0.0189437773,
0.0425737239,
-0.006644072,
-0.0373699777,
0.031064136,
-0.0359873064,
0.0596031882,
-0.023948323,
0.0377901681,
2.507688527e-34,
0.0008558658,
0.0114648584,
-0.0320186354,
-0.0254243277,
0.0662279949,
-0.0048418199,
-0.0163971689,
-0.0253901333,
0.02068289,
-0.0143497605,
0.0381254032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07871v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07871v1 | Emotion Embeddings $\unicode{x2014}$ Learning Stable and Homogeneous Abstractions from Heterogeneous Affective Datasets | 2023-08-15T16:39:10 | 2023-08-15T16:39:10 | Sven Buechel, Udo Hahn | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Human emotion is expressed in many communication modalities and media formats
and so their computational study is equally diversified into natural language
processing, audio signal analysis, computer vision, etc. Similarly, the large
variety of representation formats used in previous research to describe
emotions (polarity scales, basic emotion categories, dimensional approaches,
appraisal theory, etc.) have led to an ever proliferating diversity of
datasets, predictive models, and software tools for emotion analysis. Because
of these two distinct types of heterogeneity, at the expressional and
representational level, there is a dire need to unify previous work on
increasingly diverging data and label types. This article presents such a
unifying computational model. We propose a training procedure that learns a
shared latent representation for emotions, so-called emotion embeddings,
independent of different natural languages, communication modalities, media or
representation label formats, and even disparate model architectures.
Experiments on a wide range of heterogeneous affective datasets indicate that
this approach yields the desired interoperability for the sake of reusability,
interpretability and flexibility, without penalizing prediction quality. Code
and data are archived under https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7405327 . | [
-0.0050968607,
0.0570597127,
-0.0049599367,
0.0365677401,
0.0386818238,
0.0340129882,
-0.0121528767,
-0.0393236987,
0.0209468193,
-0.0417359732,
-0.0579552576,
-0.0279265512,
-0.0538006239,
0.0256284717,
-0.0010788825,
-0.1019245759,
0.0076003936,
0.0906519368,
0.0695432052,
-0.0262617953,
0.0443767197,
0.0162456185,
0.0095401835,
0.0500114299,
-0.0679227784,
-0.0236539543,
-0.0319247432,
0.0079827989,
0.0443256684,
-0.00696103,
0.0263306741,
0.0302361306,
0.0663141832,
0.0268672686,
0.000002151,
0.0239190068,
0.021694202,
-0.0106015205,
0.0562622957,
-0.0335419662,
0.0822750181,
-0.0276890844,
-0.004471614,
0.0104640098,
-0.0222013015,
-0.0573629737,
0.0748503879,
0.0540568121,
0.0741979927,
0.0528007634,
-0.0224341527,
-0.0145393414,
-0.0305907056,
-0.0176545996,
0.0048708213,
0.0200290885,
0.0010671781,
0.0051198844,
-0.0413819291,
-0.0318730846,
-0.0576552749,
-0.0344281383,
-0.01199394,
0.0350792781,
0.0120734265,
-0.0080256416,
0.0009271042,
-0.0279356372,
-0.0234674402,
0.0887026787,
-0.0390642397,
0.0024944888,
-0.0222381894,
-0.0062419437,
-0.0159793273,
-0.0463874154,
-0.0133036021,
0.0093537606,
0.0318434946,
0.0605574511,
-0.0162129495,
0.0559328757,
0.0197226405,
-0.0078832004,
-0.0116780205,
0.0058025173,
-0.0209828261,
-0.0127228592,
0.0442019589,
-0.0082337772,
-0.0325484723,
0.0321030468,
0.0027012534,
-0.0401140861,
0.0387859754,
-0.0051045362,
-0.0266723204,
-0.0380107313,
-0.0271613747,
-0.026645761,
0.0053786314,
0.0521276407,
-0.0332581438,
0.0256214403,
0.0327100754,
0.0178678781,
0.022237394,
-0.0166441724,
-0.0324246846,
0.0005394812,
-0.0566740148,
0.0217800885,
0.0298803542,
0.0409250483,
-0.0089486428,
-0.0400465652,
-0.0889810696,
0.003628853,
-0.080237776,
0.0294626988,
0.0160594024,
0.0396627001,
0.0178311095,
0.0179821737,
0.0058080126,
0.0441526957,
-0.0647294521,
0.0323743224,
-0.006365269,
-0.0427572131,
0.0207701251,
0.0166598614,
-0.0097763855,
-0.0018266744,
0.027233718,
0.0440965369,
0.01949469,
-0.0060529327,
-0.0307086892,
-0.0167259313,
0.004658008,
-0.0267396793,
0.050976932,
-0.0263223294,
0.0632856414,
-0.0242708568,
0.0205419883,
-0.0464629047,
-0.009381352,
-0.0392472297,
-0.0248308126,
0.0891575739,
-0.0026831899,
-0.0447216146,
-0.0414828807,
0.0202871244,
-0.0011291505,
0.061211098,
0.015830569,
0.0591082573,
0.054293327,
-0.0353751108,
0.0042038886,
-0.0233796313,
0.0209500734,
-0.0392823517,
-0.0065906839,
-0.0532857589,
-0.0270071737,
0.0253545363,
0.0444718786,
0.0314156115,
-0.0269313455,
-0.0424210541,
0.0189867094,
0.0450505167,
-0.0244956985,
0.0316401683,
0.0184544511,
0.0074142409,
-0.0009887924,
-0.0219779238,
-0.0124138622,
0.0504967906,
0.0046298066,
-0.0075664166,
0.0182348806,
0.0376596451,
-0.0505188704,
-0.0580593348,
-0.0325431935,
-0.0575347692,
-0.0031908453,
-0.0155724734,
0.0259300619,
-0.0366362147,
-0.0371363871,
-0.0065383222,
0.0293600671,
-0.0811557323,
-0.0314901955,
0.0097057149,
0.0267309714,
0.0309023093,
-0.032097511,
-0.0562157184,
0.0028099327,
-0.0475494117,
-0.0096696867,
-0.0166358873,
0.0142134493,
-0.0292425267,
0.0367211886,
-0.081162639,
-0.0007895204,
-0.0091759954,
0.0298772845,
0.0481633507,
-0.0380858257,
0.027934093,
-0.0145068858,
-0.0112674739,
0.0544690602,
-0.003805144,
0.0059403935,
-0.0284473412,
0.0054929573,
0.0528645068,
0.056064032,
0.033934962,
0.0000926985,
-0.0256064404,
0.0471916012,
-0.0083658351,
-0.0498957746,
0.0448514894,
-0.0016775816,
-0.0142354164,
0.0278587639,
-0.0419972241,
0.0418285877,
0.0125810858,
-0.0672504604,
-0.0020346502,
0.0641203746,
0.0090968581,
0.0286819544,
-0.0176888984,
-0.013590334,
-0.0092359111,
0.0429913625,
0.0205977075,
0.0387189277,
-0.0323758721,
-0.0045307395,
-0.0256554205,
-0.0311048701,
0.0179466456,
0.0175755508,
-0.0755338073,
0.0084772641,
0.0167385824,
0.0248072427,
-0.0055225166,
-0.0387659073,
-0.0262114611,
-0.0482501127,
-0.0500728376,
-0.0095698619,
-0.0008276177,
-0.0149387429,
-0.0307240579,
-0.013667387,
-0.0025395774,
0.0062033907,
-0.0251390301,
0.0369736627,
0.0183929354,
0.0223090686,
-0.0163630284,
-0.0220260695,
0.0110241892,
-0.0421487354,
-0.0004752734,
-0.0245480798,
0.0389918312,
-0.0376592688,
0.0160171241,
0.0030486307,
-0.0066087688,
-0.0641533062,
0.0292560663,
-0.0267982408,
-0.0625857338,
0.0026328377,
0.0089740055,
-0.000307612,
0.0484165959,
-0.0301978607,
0.0804329291,
0.042847082,
0.0226860736,
-0.0376969427,
0.0476175919,
-0.0176784229,
0.0393673331,
-0.0089839725,
-0.0295007471,
-0.0563351251,
0.042997051,
0.0179945026,
-0.0083688162,
-0.072059609,
0.0340127051,
-0.0011429165,
-0.0507099777,
0.0111251669,
-0.0093419002,
0.0052651856,
-0.0190024413,
0.0148899741,
-0.0520277023,
0.0289878994,
0.0533108264,
-0.017670827,
-0.038061481,
0.0052561979,
-0.0202599578,
0.0598757565,
-0.0547340997,
0.0004379034,
-0.0017744609,
0.0322155915,
-0.0208296794,
-0.0368151851,
-0.0134897865,
-0.052070424,
0.0056067416,
0.0409992002,
-0.0655603111,
0.0081714932,
-0.059916459,
-0.0042613824,
-0.0223648623,
-0.0433886796,
0.0066578463,
0.0181361195,
-0.0079916334,
-0.0268388763,
-0.0324320942,
0.0154377799,
-0.099561736,
0.021362761,
-0.0086601935,
0.0187412612,
0.02682098,
0.0104031963,
-0.0230496246,
0.0359442458,
0.0047943071,
0.0083432999,
0.0297326203,
0.022538932,
-0.0202774685,
-0.0357353538,
0.0485844538,
0.020800028,
0.0512391925,
-0.026688911,
-0.0241695549,
0.0143037615,
0.0120667275,
0.0668954551,
0.1053950414,
0.0451239236,
-0.0507639609,
0.0242310278,
-0.0139545817,
0.0113825649,
0.0457506478,
0.0129690114,
-0.052225247,
-0.0098643387,
-0.0035406619,
0.0339798853,
0.0235548671,
-0.0213762783,
0.0199248679,
-0.0643820912,
0.024865374,
0.0275958981,
0.0118141389,
-0.0440277755,
-0.0139377555,
0.0059060468,
-0.0430189744,
-0.0306244809,
-0.0877417251,
0.02073263,
0.0240234844,
0.0191410724,
-0.0337908715,
-0.0610346608,
0.0199233834,
-0.0281749591,
0.0597002842,
-0.0114118606,
0.0841264576,
-0.0163120367,
-0.0591952577,
-0.0237755086,
0.012695007,
-0.0426924825,
-0.0257591922,
0.0477978326,
-0.0183986276,
-0.0167751275,
-0.022031974,
0.0378103592,
-0.0295328349,
-0.0052653789,
-0.0435893983,
0.0963877141,
-0.00883481,
-0.0268596373,
-0.0422150865,
0.0381985605,
0.0480948873,
0.0526471026,
-0.001871969,
-0.049386654,
-0.0104851788,
-0.0325971469,
0.0521003492,
0.0167015716,
-0.0329457149,
-0.0050438116,
-0.0029534441,
-0.0462614559,
-0.032044515,
-0.0663090125,
0.0119131189,
0.0204547718,
-0.0026509438,
-0.0599703677,
-0.015578473,
-0.0127073685,
-0.0521328971,
0.0365368985,
0.0436191112,
0.0038504256,
0.0127224457,
-0.0122194923,
0.0263859052,
0.0076229656,
-0.0155739486,
-0.0269139037,
0.0112010809,
-0.0593855232,
0.0119779669,
0.0308974758,
0.0065991716,
-0.0246541891,
0.0224526413,
-0.0307258572,
0.0530564077,
0.0316660516,
-0.00607868,
0.0212592948,
0.0663480163,
0.0427924171,
0.0052376441,
0.0229373686,
-0.0432924516,
0.0671319216,
0.0058209607,
-0.0082534458,
0.0045758011,
-0.011348526,
-0.0115682082,
-0.0256871227,
0.0341591053,
0.0243136305,
-0.0472829044,
-0.0479288287,
-0.0465597622,
-0.0203654766,
-0.0137420753,
-0.0557457581,
-0.0383396372,
0.0081179831,
0.0246337783,
-0.0677654743,
-0.0278049316,
0.0371569842,
0.0218375903,
-0.0131706735,
0.0407987051,
0.0556283705,
-0.0059366506,
-0.0555594675,
0.0529485084,
0.0201802906,
-0.0030481024,
-0.0373851582,
-0.0239113867,
-0.0189183932,
0.0257128663,
-0.0059097754,
0.0012266776,
-0.0210389476,
0.0448159613,
0.0016556066,
0.025682915,
-0.0215797648,
-0.0058855587,
0.0347032361,
-0.0427265018,
0.0308322832,
-0.0526979975,
0.0091574388,
-0.0256020557,
0.0187897887,
-0.0241298471,
-0.0624784082,
0.0691937357,
-0.0113142701,
-0.0365712158,
-0.0320277624,
0.0434230492,
-0.0694090351,
0.0552748218,
-0.0190497432,
-0.0283727925,
-0.0560575053,
0.0214091633,
0.1012535021,
0.0212678891,
-0.002901582,
0.0310176741,
-0.0713627562,
-0.0658537894,
0.0434311107,
-0.0171252284,
-0.0292203184,
0.0207908787,
0.0164263509,
0.0460272394,
-0.0095402384,
0.0356069729,
-0.0259990525,
-0.0018705872,
-0.0751866549,
-0.0504009537,
0.0061314958,
-5.965589015e-33,
0.0199516416,
0.0403699987,
-0.0589103177,
-0.0236175396,
-0.0244224407,
0.068229109,
0.012331292,
0.0216785818,
-0.0191358086,
0.0456421599,
-0.0199359711,
0.0251021907,
-0.0012015459,
-0.0048166555,
0.0222141165,
-0.005369293,
0.0170286037,
-0.0379107036,
0.0155613162,
0.0038124644,
0.0380059518,
0.0155242821,
0.0546062626,
-0.1258697212,
0.0022099407,
0.0359780788,
-0.022313524,
-0.0105623929,
0.0698442236,
0.0517270267,
-0.0118166842,
0.0808158293,
0.006642248,
0.0300711263,
-0.0050981278,
0.0259247366,
-0.0064618313,
-0.021045858,
-0.0311521534,
0.017836187,
-0.0439598374,
-0.0160981007,
-0.013203321,
0.0146951703,
-0.0160764959,
-0.0466541797,
0.0153160989,
-0.0058746962,
0.0159605946,
-0.033181347,
-0.0227670465,
0.0028845717,
-0.0186509602,
-0.005819934,
0.0533762872,
0.0560372956,
0.0495966077,
0.03315375,
-0.0737760589,
0.0260366704,
-0.0755769163,
-0.0110148769,
0.0110712927,
-0.0171059016,
0.0199024063,
0.0857346952,
0.0524165817,
-0.0069592241,
-0.0287332218,
0.0076570045,
0.0132458527,
0.035083212,
0.0385802574,
0.0507301912,
-0.0128801279,
-0.0470339321,
-0.010532951,
0.0364004299,
0.0872971937,
-0.0045578354,
0.0299872961,
0.0449701436,
-0.023567304,
-0.0055530188,
-0.0091313617,
-0.0242130272,
-0.0049121063,
-0.0410041027,
0.0105599472,
-0.0175293498,
0.0231870115,
-0.0037593327,
-0.0140429782,
-0.0485463403,
-0.0013089232,
0.0568095669,
-0.0049938969,
0.0555266514,
0.0244000331,
0.0040333583,
-0.0105185295,
-0.000806937,
0.0362249948,
-0.0064252517,
0.0499948487,
-0.0209156852,
0.0025400044,
0.0666813403,
-0.0519153588,
-0.0111971628,
-0.0155111467,
-0.0035801381,
0.0124852248,
0.0060657528,
-0.0142286327,
0.0454356447,
-0.0040278127,
-0.0149330189,
0.0177161116,
0.0477470756,
0.0265530162,
-0.0292491559,
-0.0030208405,
0.0404534303,
-0.0368471891,
-0.0160441604,
-0.0352718458,
-0.0507156216,
0.0134045882,
-0.0300441813,
-0.0051770704,
-0.0029881606,
2.811e-7,
-0.0130782947,
-0.0011120646,
0.0132134445,
-0.0343462974,
0.0386643074,
0.0586345159,
-0.0307479538,
0.0503544137,
-0.0025633832,
-0.0599808544,
0.0413079299,
0.0100137899,
0.0294631906,
0.0076446226,
-0.0629444942,
0.0037528882,
0.01561761,
0.0102813253,
-0.003498419,
0.0229575951,
0.0842366144,
0.1265403926,
0.0510246754,
0.0252103992,
0.0040422124,
0.0708211735,
0.0456154756,
-0.0463781208,
0.0036695309,
-0.0355588235,
-0.0133551983,
-0.0246994086,
-0.0085166013,
-0.0293556228,
0.0017485432,
-0.0120428586,
0.0406726003,
0.0341310352,
0.011889901,
-0.0504348166,
0.0061384593,
0.0304581448,
-0.0393721759,
-0.0026608941,
0.0479291193,
-0.0467456616,
-0.0607079752,
-0.0382359289,
-0.0500637405,
0.0248297453,
0.0657112449,
-0.0230013859,
-0.0447837673,
-0.0052580116,
0.0065740664,
0.0127792312,
-0.0082807997,
-0.0808403641,
0.0190195963,
0.0140438247,
-0.0722408742,
-0.0157853644,
0.0120394183,
0.0520718321,
0.0657527372,
-0.0255171806,
0.0025931837,
2.528629087e-34,
0.0158694815,
-0.023532493,
-0.0051075318,
-0.0044179619,
0.0258388203,
-0.0309915747,
-0.018988343,
-0.0378284305,
0.0569297597,
-0.0325976089,
-0.0032371192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07791v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07791v1 | Informed Named Entity Recognition Decoding for Generative Language Models | 2023-08-15T14:16:29 | 2023-08-15T14:16:29 | Tobias Deußer, Lars Hillebrand, Christian Bauckhage, Rafet Sifa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Ever-larger language models with ever-increasing capabilities are by now
well-established text processing tools. Alas, information extraction tasks such
as named entity recognition are still largely unaffected by this progress as
they are primarily based on the previous generation of encoder-only transformer
models. Here, we propose a simple yet effective approach, Informed Named Entity
Recognition Decoding (iNERD), which treats named entity recognition as a
generative process. It leverages the language understanding capabilities of
recent generative models in a future-proof manner and employs an informed
decoding scheme incorporating the restricted nature of information extraction
into open-ended text generation, improving performance and eliminating any risk
of hallucinations. We coarse-tune our model on a merged named entity corpus to
strengthen its performance, evaluate five generative language models on eight
named entity recognition datasets, and achieve remarkable results, especially
in an environment with an unknown entity class set, demonstrating the
adaptability of the approach. | [
0.0331051722,
0.0776429772,
0.0361230001,
0.0334383473,
0.0344371572,
0.0704128891,
0.0019850133,
0.0162846632,
-0.0202319007,
-0.037357416,
-0.0078267613,
-0.0316258669,
0.0005730592,
-0.0048115156,
0.038888447,
-0.016669184,
0.0074947551,
-0.0337424539,
0.0092953304,
0.034500733,
-0.0165386368,
0.0226811878,
0.0048303925,
0.0293533038,
0.0260908008,
-0.013686182,
-0.0206342842,
0.015730679,
0.0285048019,
-0.0374516807,
0.0170835406,
0.0563585497,
0.0111602088,
0.0621846803,
0.0000019509,
-0.0259596817,
-0.0492001474,
0.0076228189,
-0.0246114898,
-0.0279842615,
0.0007782987,
-0.0570999607,
-0.0199197922,
0.0121774413,
-0.0154920518,
-0.0971003994,
0.0310316086,
0.0630039796,
0.0100388303,
0.0867739916,
-0.0005284243,
-0.0481016599,
0.0635033399,
-0.0163331088,
-0.0069911862,
-0.0230400376,
0.0342753008,
-0.0159406625,
-0.0344820134,
-0.0033812614,
0.0075620832,
0.0233746432,
-0.0220046062,
0.0151209272,
0.0426741876,
0.0438501947,
-0.011618712,
-0.0136365723,
-0.0125345718,
0.038938161,
-0.0310560819,
-0.0150392121,
0.0356419347,
-0.0116040707,
-0.0309349783,
-0.0255571939,
-0.0240865462,
0.0298170373,
-0.0403276831,
0.0271044653,
0.0462024286,
0.0421250537,
0.0169923529,
-0.0079272166,
-0.0032507158,
0.0259088166,
0.0361862108,
-0.0151425879,
-0.0095127719,
0.044910036,
-0.014036919,
-0.0503927693,
0.0042957449,
0.018556267,
0.0246308967,
0.0223442912,
-0.032572981,
-0.029075725,
-0.024479406,
-0.0247676969,
-0.0217728801,
0.0211712234,
0.033699967,
0.0057018185,
-0.0427062288,
0.030294396,
-0.0022399125,
0.0094435886,
0.0190960132,
-0.0117135644,
-0.039376948,
-0.0112526482,
-0.0478873029,
0.0182731748,
-0.0495070964,
-0.0015392384,
-0.0039268048,
0.0224445425,
0.0243008714,
0.0160836671,
0.030956354,
0.004673928,
-0.0345638134,
-0.0226792283,
-0.011295951,
0.0071001477,
0.0218135491,
-0.0409794673,
0.0235885885,
-0.0715035871,
-0.020545274,
-0.0131650595,
0.045471821,
-0.0295793302,
-0.0015081409,
0.0668041706,
0.0074271527,
-0.0635599047,
-0.052443672,
-0.0018005092,
0.0237448737,
-0.0332496278,
0.0055424985,
-0.0165513176,
0.0542540103,
0.0115445899,
0.0039705229,
-0.0729793161,
0.0295398422,
0.0038684269,
-0.0429603159,
0.0446533263,
-0.0577894673,
-0.0141257811,
0.0410366245,
-0.0079785222,
0.0843104944,
0.07898096,
0.0295553692,
0.0176525749,
0.0118884379,
-0.0027668651,
0.0223457851,
0.0232091248,
0.0173825547,
-0.0160779804,
0.0182379931,
0.0045898794,
-0.0075515574,
-0.0148354396,
0.0401268639,
0.0379968137,
-0.0247287396,
0.0312319435,
0.0409243293,
-0.0156309344,
-0.0005598635,
0.0429399721,
0.0419002064,
0.0016298818,
-0.0154414792,
-0.0111959008,
-0.0010181696,
0.021953892,
-0.0277194679,
0.0205376539,
0.0010611891,
0.076523371,
-0.0232522935,
-0.0285276398,
0.0099815261,
-0.0138917575,
-0.0309448875,
0.0047988943,
0.0404685624,
0.0535509847,
-0.0971331894,
0.0653049052,
0.0422971547,
-0.0519120172,
0.0274031498,
-0.000359321,
0.013788023,
0.0800892487,
0.0891229585,
0.0116248159,
-0.042575486,
-0.0527084768,
-0.0512730703,
0.0653549135,
-0.0119349044,
-0.0179770105,
0.0293538105,
-0.061805442,
-0.0194713417,
0.0393036976,
0.0414660648,
0.0483855791,
0.0082236789,
0.006749846,
0.0361957662,
-0.0083162086,
-0.0412547439,
0.0513809323,
-0.0475361124,
-0.0624679215,
0.0042166337,
0.0176891144,
-0.0250840541,
0.0463610739,
-0.0131374197,
-0.0196342412,
-0.005664411,
-0.03988152,
-0.0258317012,
0.0059937052,
-0.0203360114,
-0.0591803938,
-0.0443341061,
-0.0043448433,
-0.0081425123,
-0.0133469766,
-0.0267364606,
-0.0495515168,
-0.0354233272,
0.0095768077,
0.0528987721,
-0.0480732881,
0.0351231433,
0.0389640145,
0.0271637235,
-0.0342467353,
0.081295833,
-0.0239124,
0.0297953282,
0.0247928817,
0.0085368007,
-0.010016826,
-0.0217788648,
-0.0389729366,
0.0300865136,
-0.025249416,
-0.0403260626,
0.0088180639,
0.0018974212,
-0.0103876665,
-0.0321029052,
-0.0518877953,
0.0028031273,
-0.0258601326,
0.0419325754,
0.0436162129,
0.0457944497,
-0.0303672422,
0.0133104324,
-0.0119165014,
-0.0041675596,
0.0030984553,
-0.0165064037,
0.0194735602,
-0.0046691676,
-0.0279546864,
0.0061460957,
0.0233216025,
-0.0107252523,
0.0553639159,
0.0397862718,
-0.0601554625,
-0.0996553898,
0.0693261996,
-0.0348998047,
0.0154119842,
0.013142922,
0.0084700203,
-0.0209481046,
-0.0056367819,
0.0625341311,
0.0300182141,
0.0135507407,
0.0473932587,
-0.0251389574,
-0.0223338977,
-0.0326862261,
0.0205969308,
-0.0340583362,
0.0186364558,
-0.0149062574,
-0.0420792811,
0.032917995,
0.1087024286,
0.001040154,
0.0072869067,
-0.083221063,
-0.0139457285,
0.0038751087,
-0.037105564,
-0.0123148868,
0.0212831739,
0.0135767907,
0.0192960985,
-0.0316857435,
-0.0160105452,
0.0493809544,
-0.0699344203,
-0.0374942869,
0.0115843145,
0.0309411474,
-0.0280390587,
0.0325228795,
0.0401804186,
0.0127994567,
0.054575406,
-0.0870578364,
0.0163191389,
0.073606655,
-0.0081007313,
-0.0349107422,
0.0116244685,
-0.0280680303,
0.0123286899,
-0.0180877615,
-0.0067850454,
-0.0670269355,
0.0036426927,
-0.0344849601,
-0.0011306194,
0.0309798717,
-0.0143226804,
-0.0024141313,
0.0500189699,
-0.0195968617,
0.0275690183,
-0.0010303665,
-0.0136122461,
-0.0578030609,
0.0405974612,
0.0479604527,
0.0090674711,
0.0136086373,
-0.0153485471,
0.0110397218,
0.0400639847,
-0.0189062562,
-0.0027825211,
0.001032509,
-0.0012828714,
0.0375976637,
-0.0475728177,
0.0178644136,
-0.0073761512,
0.0319749936,
-0.0327331647,
-0.0468388647,
0.1130994037,
0.0160559267,
-0.0350519232,
-0.0217579175,
0.0312947594,
0.0476254001,
0.00305182,
0.0216298327,
-0.089018397,
-0.0313333273,
0.0313602574,
0.0291589368,
0.0050864676,
-0.0642411187,
-0.0066841044,
-0.1127480716,
0.0292914435,
-0.0053695608,
-0.0360011756,
-0.0154613871,
-0.0239934903,
-0.0245109405,
-0.026187269,
-0.0307450816,
0.0078616878,
0.019014677,
0.0269742403,
0.0236125924,
0.0127549348,
-0.0682889149,
-0.0207224898,
-0.0356854573,
0.0601442568,
0.0923286006,
0.0243170112,
0.0234714951,
-0.0505484007,
-0.0185648333,
-0.0727413446,
-0.0224303007,
-0.0198323429,
0.0571221784,
-0.0573608465,
-0.0103673907,
-0.0139153032,
0.0147992885,
-0.0449088924,
0.0006293145,
0.0125408424,
0.0078535601,
-0.0095929969,
-0.0117053911,
0.0294578094,
-0.0288422629,
0.0408466645,
0.0839897022,
0.0273229163,
-0.0077502602,
-0.0285174511,
-0.0519260988,
0.0555562526,
-0.0763491169,
-0.0085717607,
0.0088023096,
0.0124428486,
-0.07986404,
-0.0621592551,
-0.0428636447,
0.0342709906,
0.0191922523,
0.0025085036,
0.0056691146,
0.0365832672,
0.0006849938,
-0.0452923737,
0.0073407367,
-0.0202461928,
-0.0302801859,
-0.065404214,
-0.0464184582,
0.0217586048,
-0.0138234496,
-0.0282004382,
0.0410991758,
-0.0802743062,
-0.0521064214,
-0.0016855289,
0.009611859,
0.0142218973,
0.0588140748,
-0.0297040455,
-0.0279221535,
0.0237121489,
0.0281979386,
-0.0248904172,
-0.0177852847,
0.005897426,
0.0499669611,
-0.0027220375,
0.0314459689,
-0.0240216963,
0.0308131482,
0.0110458974,
0.0447524413,
-0.012671195,
-0.0199790224,
0.0075160535,
0.0023272671,
0.0389013849,
-0.0288625043,
-0.0149949407,
-0.0517226942,
0.0199764986,
-0.0231359117,
0.0077559128,
-0.0454145148,
-0.0108299451,
0.0502506644,
-0.007626412,
-0.0174011588,
0.0740777478,
-0.0060789054,
0.0280292295,
-0.0517556742,
-0.0038553821,
-0.0305355098,
0.064761579,
0.0207406078,
-0.0413791463,
-0.0169177428,
0.0358520262,
0.0332772173,
0.0316061601,
-0.0187239051,
0.0213227458,
-0.0097410493,
0.007181902,
-0.0017861333,
0.012297445,
-0.0448574908,
0.0150080537,
-0.0667690486,
0.0609790944,
0.0273017101,
0.017880151,
0.097597532,
0.0031812356,
0.0074382704,
0.016618764,
0.0429383628,
0.0094052423,
-0.0475090221,
0.0172611177,
0.0047953348,
-0.02856596,
-0.0524329022,
0.0819461495,
0.0221338049,
0.0380618796,
-0.013707675,
0.008971422,
-0.0598089658,
-0.0444189012,
0.002638072,
-0.0115422541,
-0.0123928087,
0.0217514187,
-0.0193580836,
-0.0343863703,
0.0018909908,
-0.0233062655,
0.0213702302,
-0.0115187494,
0.0048920638,
-0.0030068776,
-0.031377472,
-0.0452203825,
-0.0489609987,
0.013313313,
-0.0181012731,
-0.0375517197,
-0.0261471588,
-6.203932984e-33,
-0.0637645125,
0.0203717854,
0.0187481437,
-0.0251852665,
-0.0175757278,
-0.0044179782,
-0.0583113022,
-0.0101217879,
0.0456609987,
-0.0301255565,
-0.0101729957,
-0.0013523553,
0.0186831132,
0.0704414845,
-0.0354659706,
-0.0176673401,
0.059762761,
0.0139032239,
-0.025271032,
0.0532374047,
0.0517050698,
0.0768608451,
0.0470379181,
-0.047894273,
0.0301401671,
-0.0421931259,
-0.0141423913,
-0.0304029826,
0.0760538653,
0.0096482662,
-0.0507356338,
-0.020892052,
0.0105669992,
-0.0733839199,
-0.0160845183,
0.0188225862,
-0.1543014646,
0.043966841,
-0.032739684,
0.0440890528,
-0.0092360117,
-0.0505667999,
0.0148700969,
0.009812044,
0.0214173868,
0.0092408024,
0.0166876037,
-0.0287408754,
0.0092265215,
-0.0871377513,
-0.0515822619,
0.0454604551,
-0.0046532801,
0.0327374414,
0.0411705226,
0.0037757857,
0.0251286756,
0.0221094918,
-0.0629482716,
0.0090996809,
0.0359896049,
0.0070507675,
0.0525968187,
0.0381502919,
-0.0173848569,
0.0288501866,
0.0014721082,
-0.0256111585,
-0.0581007451,
0.0509487465,
-0.0079524219,
0.0388568528,
-0.0318986364,
0.0495658405,
0.0209628101,
-0.0509160757,
-0.0464281999,
0.0617610663,
-0.0248976424,
-0.0294048544,
0.0167626217,
0.0017660275,
-0.0643969551,
-0.0054430594,
0.0074649639,
-0.0461875126,
-0.0211184006,
-0.006227422,
0.0475925356,
0.0278550908,
-0.0803538412,
0.003509555,
0.0396125764,
-0.0318453349,
-0.0332560502,
0.0371431336,
0.0155382548,
0.0108018294,
-0.0229680631,
0.0075566508,
-0.0214409009,
-0.0526771434,
0.0541607477,
0.0043026982,
-0.0171722565,
-0.0036423816,
0.0351184383,
-0.0097107999,
-0.071117118,
0.0078529632,
-0.0446990691,
0.0693820715,
-0.008424826,
0.0451809913,
0.0100968909,
-0.0328814462,
-0.0139687276,
-0.0101067284,
0.0421355553,
-0.0008114284,
0.0021796247,
0.0281581823,
0.0312708877,
0.0378173292,
-0.0155205531,
-0.0031033028,
0.0039339331,
-0.0415337607,
0.0387986787,
-0.0376349352,
0.0020046204,
0.0089575024,
2.549e-7,
0.0180044882,
0.0001176828,
0.0507499315,
-0.0296105836,
-0.0035826766,
-0.0055225184,
0.0558236912,
0.0615964495,
0.0052319677,
-0.0072325761,
-0.0105272578,
0.0012602834,
0.0433295593,
-0.0098984437,
-0.0935879648,
-0.0296782088,
0.0091948211,
0.0142623987,
-0.047770571,
0.0117788743,
0.0172791965,
0.0634396672,
-0.0293014925,
0.0062570432,
0.0153184794,
0.0066496939,
0.0527840108,
0.0112882815,
0.0274388455,
0.0515474491,
0.0302605219,
0.0712177902,
-0.022657983,
-0.004824508,
-0.0209737755,
0.0124115571,
-0.0078015267,
0.0566032045,
0.0134238685,
-0.0039246129,
-0.0066301147,
-0.027242709,
0.0229152162,
-0.0369367786,
0.0760874972,
-0.0405726247,
-0.0162037555,
0.0193145033,
-0.0454847552,
0.0019629872,
-0.0523342043,
0.0062684547,
-0.0243718568,
0.0342940651,
0.0348626897,
-0.0245884508,
-0.0146581912,
-0.0510464162,
0.0044076596,
-0.013993971,
-0.0389476232,
-0.0167629439,
-0.0081413072,
-0.034684971,
-0.0012266098,
-0.0472675748,
0.0094519192,
2.297867148e-34,
-0.0218620431,
0.0547839291,
-0.0463743694,
0.0285505783,
0.0415099487,
-0.0333097875,
-0.0162558332,
0.0174370576,
-0.044466801,
-0.068643108,
-0.0069604418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12877v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12877v3 | DS4DH at #SMM4H 2023: Zero-Shot Adverse Drug Events Normalization using Sentence Transformers and Reciprocal-Rank Fusion | 2023-08-15T14:07:59 | 2023-11-06T09:19:59 | Anthony Yazdani, Hossein Rouhizadeh, David Vicente Alvarez, Douglas Teodoro | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper outlines the performance evaluation of a system for adverse drug
event normalization, developed by the Data Science for Digital Health (DS4DH)
group for the Social Media Mining for Health Applications (SMM4H) 2023 shared
task 5. Shared task 5 targeted the normalization of adverse drug event mentions
in Twitter to standard concepts of the Medical Dictionary for Regulatory
Activities terminology. Our system hinges on a two-stage approach: BERT
fine-tuning for entity recognition, followed by zero-shot normalization using
sentence transformers and reciprocal-rank fusion. The approach yielded a
precision of 44.9%, recall of 40.5%, and an F1-score of 42.6%. It outperformed
the median performance in shared task 5 by 10% and demonstrated the highest
performance among all participants. These results substantiate the
effectiveness of our approach and its potential application for adverse drug
event normalization in the realm of social media text mining. | [
0.0324387737,
-0.0048966203,
0.0243514795,
-0.051341895,
0.000984924,
0.0235616621,
-0.0360428616,
-0.0076040011,
0.0350143872,
-0.0563905351,
0.0321309641,
-0.0209964365,
-0.0280050579,
0.0546374395,
-0.0043289224,
-0.0212982167,
0.0186575074,
0.0697808638,
-0.0235898104,
0.0242058747,
0.0191718079,
0.0256814994,
-0.002092581,
0.0518234037,
0.0092852628,
0.0162794087,
0.0551178232,
0.0081776958,
0.0751681253,
-0.0753402486,
0.0135037731,
0.0417370275,
-0.0264360197,
0.0215767696,
0.0000017379,
-0.060969498,
-0.0270903632,
0.0172228683,
0.0142583838,
-0.0546131991,
0.009715491,
-0.08327277,
0.0050687022,
0.0288152844,
-0.0333304554,
-0.0035169187,
0.0331087187,
0.0642455593,
0.0210821275,
0.0718611255,
-0.0382891297,
-0.0446045287,
0.0243970994,
-0.0049034585,
-0.00223375,
-0.0328808166,
0.0456021689,
-0.0205114745,
0.0127019547,
-0.0175131951,
0.0384135991,
0.013953004,
-0.0302330982,
0.0221736096,
0.0623204112,
0.0317750648,
-0.0355253108,
-0.0127666518,
0.0254648812,
0.0615266152,
0.0169159081,
-0.0032695229,
0.0555913039,
0.0222320668,
-0.0200469829,
0.0127715822,
-0.0214409605,
-0.0078201611,
-0.0381396674,
0.056548167,
-0.0045509478,
-0.0017314595,
0.0126955761,
0.0184476227,
-0.0200432297,
0.0441847593,
0.0126640033,
-0.0401158482,
0.0076296367,
0.0090049133,
-0.0065905778,
-0.029477464,
0.0641936213,
0.0143175665,
-0.0407824256,
0.0196515024,
-0.0164721701,
-0.0536628366,
0.0774556175,
-0.1031554192,
-0.0033983374,
0.0070920032,
0.0115561849,
0.0175959803,
-0.0088134287,
-0.0143692959,
0.0439954475,
0.0472139306,
-0.030577058,
0.0121421358,
-0.0703012347,
0.0213554706,
-0.0275721606,
0.0437163115,
-0.005476479,
-0.0022575599,
-0.0942707285,
-0.0113879237,
-0.0017512821,
-0.0252716001,
0.0353209935,
0.0368167013,
-0.0259258561,
0.0147501417,
0.0188339166,
0.0546470694,
0.0076828673,
0.0041680387,
-0.0195037294,
0.0049582478,
0.0258092377,
-0.03802149,
0.0415866934,
-0.015184463,
0.0145136407,
0.0214140974,
-0.0061541982,
-0.0486749597,
-0.0410718508,
-0.0247357246,
-0.0241564661,
-0.0029865368,
-0.0325201377,
-0.0345410965,
0.0426224396,
0.0132942665,
0.0158228278,
-0.0103554716,
0.0204049796,
0.0160774626,
-0.0750557333,
0.0496103503,
-0.0524380021,
0.0005185643,
0.0202417038,
0.0282500945,
0.0425020754,
0.0287900772,
0.0372019261,
0.0170953609,
0.0004413684,
-0.0023949626,
-0.0121367453,
0.0127749955,
0.0132296067,
-0.051501669,
0.009239614,
-0.0164511409,
-0.0475213863,
0.0163609367,
-0.0426437296,
0.065448828,
-0.0004434922,
0.0332676135,
0.035847839,
0.0571124889,
-0.0019714932,
-0.0241295882,
-0.0075621232,
-0.0268531796,
-0.0309955794,
-0.0273451488,
-0.0242244042,
-0.0271772183,
-0.0106521184,
-0.012777633,
0.012447183,
0.0216297414,
-0.0233750138,
0.00213539,
-0.0080914032,
-0.015793886,
0.0092555927,
-0.038987197,
0.0380104668,
-0.0273952205,
-0.0489170328,
0.0684354156,
0.0183154158,
-0.0437974744,
-0.003086895,
-0.0102851465,
-0.0487307087,
0.0757760704,
0.0598579794,
-0.0177613143,
-0.0443386436,
-0.020248482,
-0.0203318279,
0.0145036373,
-0.0170538779,
-0.027450623,
0.0076830094,
-0.0168168936,
0.0019818486,
0.0489674993,
0.0037456774,
-0.0521541312,
-0.0203125328,
0.0264900886,
-0.001444701,
-0.026882261,
-0.0168319214,
0.0474053733,
0.0048492616,
-0.041624222,
0.0036114303,
0.0123148886,
-0.0096612545,
0.0686410666,
0.017534459,
0.0101204002,
0.0416109525,
-0.0565479398,
-0.0400324687,
-0.0056649609,
0.0327394269,
-0.0234934818,
0.0381959975,
-0.0523297451,
0.0089106131,
0.0331961922,
-0.0472255163,
-0.0470716022,
0.0200895425,
-0.0307510793,
0.0233795326,
-0.0118768904,
0.0172098596,
0.026642682,
0.0004884449,
-0.0350483507,
0.0326422676,
-0.0078565646,
0.0005015739,
-0.0333834626,
-0.1158699617,
0.0106494585,
0.0104604047,
-0.0055549182,
0.0159468688,
-0.0248422697,
0.0186108407,
0.0297249611,
-0.0158068892,
-0.0353706814,
0.0260658674,
-0.0823888257,
0.0173958559,
0.0051083835,
0.0558709018,
0.0268585384,
0.041359216,
0.0147647178,
-0.0359297134,
-0.0069167721,
-0.0740739256,
0.0210734885,
0.0094941678,
0.0419877432,
0.0491087735,
-0.0076478543,
-0.0008980477,
-0.000720795,
-0.0667000413,
0.0175979808,
-0.0094161965,
-0.0545122325,
-0.0188697819,
0.0119064804,
-0.0097652497,
-0.0037494919,
0.0209143572,
-0.00183471,
-0.0051407292,
0.0450076535,
0.053185977,
0.0060994853,
-0.0027859318,
0.027938677,
0.0276713185,
0.0058847335,
0.0083119487,
0.0069855982,
-0.0155323511,
-0.0266065225,
0.0108139822,
-0.074230127,
0.0186482966,
0.0643919781,
0.0075582783,
0.0137140779,
-0.0350989327,
-0.0424438454,
-0.0250209011,
0.0316219926,
-0.0488711968,
-0.0119306352,
-0.0430654176,
-0.0132598681,
-0.0151774706,
-0.008709521,
0.0662415624,
0.0039230078,
0.0184591841,
-0.082255967,
-0.0265655331,
-0.0045859893,
-0.0451327674,
0.0066618188,
0.0271388758,
0.0073106345,
-0.0139224324,
0.0791321844,
-0.012979947,
0.0173623655,
-0.0465990491,
0.0694148913,
-0.0067409608,
0.0448332354,
-0.0493345037,
-0.0380892307,
-0.0171564706,
-0.0532367826,
-0.0268037003,
0.0121619795,
0.0098906653,
-0.0103038475,
-0.0490037091,
0.0604598448,
-0.0281039868,
0.0297782365,
0.0180268064,
-0.0213625934,
0.0289477371,
0.0370965526,
0.0585674234,
-0.0560867488,
-0.0356001705,
0.0185320899,
0.0445187762,
0.0655390099,
0.0635504201,
0.0082918294,
-0.0034766779,
-0.0217415839,
-0.0013856399,
-0.0760005638,
0.0052126474,
0.0306666549,
0.0282338839,
0.0005726941,
0.0225536339,
0.0945920795,
0.0523524843,
-0.0379787348,
0.0174586046,
0.0262472741,
-0.0608480312,
-0.0255750269,
-0.009678307,
-0.0918139294,
-0.0215198752,
-0.0145836165,
0.0340704955,
-0.0309689268,
-0.0546805747,
0.0218039956,
-0.0409800224,
-0.0078610396,
0.0075436323,
-0.0141603667,
-0.0612117425,
-0.0544120483,
0.0140387462,
-0.0272376053,
0.0177795719,
-0.0294235423,
-0.0137885334,
0.0000518202,
0.0158276167,
-0.0394560285,
-0.0895015895,
0.0012674701,
-0.0414449424,
0.0186662823,
0.0285052974,
0.0287661105,
0.0088338824,
-0.0150795402,
-0.0288774241,
-0.0342997573,
-0.0123392586,
0.0109663839,
0.0620095283,
-0.0195130259,
0.0004479166,
-0.073260963,
0.0208466295,
-0.0575273372,
-0.0548745766,
-0.0686286464,
0.0812821463,
-0.0372654088,
-0.0126004657,
-0.0455609597,
0.0112424977,
0.0102634318,
0.0511125438,
-0.0052169045,
0.0149421906,
-0.0288589392,
0.0183095522,
0.0403028652,
-0.0832896829,
-0.0066492227,
0.0152529133,
-0.0449500047,
-0.03476936,
-0.0561286286,
-0.0370001383,
0.0588761643,
-0.0507964194,
-0.0242146943,
0.0009095828,
0.0147501295,
0.0066506006,
-0.0304670278,
0.0484551378,
0.0408523455,
0.0317702107,
-0.0228843652,
-0.0183757823,
0.0290020481,
0.0728464872,
-0.0046429383,
0.039604947,
-0.0186951514,
-0.039346531,
0.0056896606,
-0.0334430598,
0.0151665509,
-0.0433943532,
0.00238482,
-0.0129777156,
0.0073848572,
0.0772920996,
-0.0142332632,
-0.0577565022,
-0.0181462709,
0.0295042284,
-0.0246692803,
0.0228981506,
-0.0161903687,
0.0194441564,
-0.0185321961,
0.0543419868,
-0.0160510875,
-0.0148651777,
0.0251664743,
0.0220992807,
0.0633758381,
-0.0345963612,
-0.0163222961,
-0.0244256631,
0.0046276045,
-0.0171311218,
0.0172115751,
0.002365943,
-0.0091904365,
0.0112101389,
-0.0145612536,
-0.0525885522,
0.0731060505,
-0.0785721987,
-0.0132958675,
-0.0793847814,
0.0426881835,
-0.0186682921,
0.0072189197,
0.0325234234,
-0.0417771451,
0.0103001529,
-0.0098103015,
0.0429370366,
0.0131937582,
-0.0427820794,
0.0113207651,
-0.0031142286,
0.0524697863,
-0.029161619,
0.0651667342,
-0.029146811,
0.0425537266,
-0.0443242565,
-0.0011955501,
0.087399222,
0.0003722025,
0.0877460912,
-0.0239211544,
-0.0088951625,
-0.0094481781,
0.0069637499,
-0.0181147363,
0.0350895151,
0.0253985804,
-0.0056308191,
-0.0304075535,
-0.0230352674,
0.099291116,
-0.0224815886,
0.0345639139,
0.0147635704,
-0.0484835505,
-0.0183018167,
-0.0060239127,
0.0161858518,
0.0155504672,
-0.0573560074,
-0.0101308795,
-0.0640935078,
-0.0373979695,
0.0516984724,
-0.0491952822,
-0.0173668936,
0.0049762013,
0.0078450227,
0.0297219045,
0.0352461711,
-0.0262832176,
-0.0070176926,
0.0216576681,
0.0287112501,
-0.016079437,
-0.0158161502,
-5.843787229e-33,
0.0096823052,
-0.0274976827,
-0.0257461723,
-0.0258345939,
0.0190250203,
-0.0023938029,
-0.0114101525,
-0.0117789218,
0.0204297975,
0.0462937057,
-0.013343961,
-0.0030992017,
0.0188831966,
0.0080575934,
0.0273844674,
-0.0201565027,
0.0260808822,
0.0152359549,
-0.008891806,
0.0285878833,
0.0110655064,
0.0906467959,
0.0911273062,
-0.0700411946,
0.0259398539,
0.0163520221,
0.0011588659,
-0.0085198432,
0.0622093007,
0.040017087,
-0.0299575254,
0.0727266669,
0.0563287251,
-0.0486212671,
0.0054235235,
0.0136017613,
-0.0744307861,
-0.0224649478,
0.0041921232,
-0.0503185615,
-0.0095827533,
-0.0154215004,
0.0560143255,
-0.0015357089,
-0.0450649969,
0.0001455534,
0.0223800875,
-0.0122459363,
0.0073704412,
-0.0664528236,
-0.0487778932,
0.0558784939,
-0.0102109304,
-0.0144565888,
0.0028004323,
0.0170365088,
-0.0151892267,
0.0265624933,
-0.0239074323,
-0.006257493,
-0.0176550914,
0.0096202185,
0.0101163834,
-0.0260398779,
-0.0611247681,
0.0275042765,
0.0044564852,
0.0133175217,
-0.0230341479,
-0.0114146685,
-0.0478322469,
0.0278266054,
-0.003566792,
0.0298167001,
0.0382342488,
0.0002957162,
-0.0764328837,
0.0928955525,
-0.0290235355,
0.0289442036,
-0.0010447376,
-0.0030265658,
-0.0294780992,
-0.0239775479,
0.0212060083,
0.0296129566,
-0.0295766201,
-0.0082133431,
-0.0175492242,
0.0083174547,
0.0171565451,
0.0991146341,
-0.0123495543,
-0.0373081528,
-0.0099659665,
0.0125381835,
0.0541814007,
0.0237083416,
-0.0290369187,
-0.032140255,
-0.0520938933,
0.0005242886,
0.040141806,
0.009915919,
0.0035699673,
-0.0008790233,
0.0274992846,
-0.0197201055,
-0.0307398979,
0.0065261498,
0.0310155451,
0.0039417157,
-0.0195715353,
0.0488609709,
-0.0015657836,
0.0319963694,
0.0224360209,
0.0515569262,
0.0129776057,
0.0322749056,
-0.0100259427,
-0.0271285344,
0.0405146442,
-0.0003954964,
-0.000068052,
0.0274060536,
-0.0262212008,
0.0530403331,
0.0326055475,
-0.0466402322,
-0.0020744905,
-0.0606257729,
2.712e-7,
0.1204861626,
0.0493394844,
0.0098016541,
-0.037117932,
-0.0024372693,
0.0011097965,
0.0156441126,
0.0601113886,
-0.0094402712,
0.0197023619,
0.0284427535,
-0.0268425811,
0.0032181742,
0.0468824692,
-0.0396052562,
-0.0487273,
-0.0975347683,
-0.0408681594,
-0.0535772629,
0.0279542916,
0.0369247533,
0.0385107026,
-0.0244616643,
-0.0300105251,
0.0246520899,
-0.0346977785,
-0.004258262,
-0.0236754101,
-0.0330589972,
0.0452076308,
0.021801969,
-0.0048556384,
0.0061935992,
0.0398666896,
-0.0328253247,
0.0171182305,
-0.0022645614,
0.0520261377,
-0.0880255029,
-0.0118581532,
0.0002943277,
-0.058777675,
0.0164321903,
-0.0169389155,
0.0532208979,
-0.0245279595,
-0.0544920564,
0.0133772483,
-0.0254498981,
0.0227664877,
0.0417786092,
0.001618246,
-0.0569812879,
0.0485179909,
0.0318818912,
0.0482700765,
-0.0445830859,
-0.1218320876,
0.0044230004,
0.0616452657,
-0.0191544238,
-0.0246740896,
0.0431595333,
-0.045005057,
-0.0095638372,
-0.0827576891,
0.0360661931,
2.480393411e-34,
0.0277327113,
0.0157394595,
0.0064940727,
0.0014151034,
0.02632281,
-0.0203885771,
0.0081951441,
-0.0094358185,
-0.0023302501,
-0.0918876231,
0.0076955613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07777v1 | Enhancing Visually-Rich Document Understanding via Layout Structure Modeling | 2023-08-15T13:53:52 | 2023-08-15T13:53:52 | Qiwei Li, Zuchao Li, Xiantao Cai, Bo Du, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, the use of multi-modal pre-trained Transformers has led to
significant advancements in visually-rich document understanding. However,
existing models have mainly focused on features such as text and vision while
neglecting the importance of layout relationship between text nodes. In this
paper, we propose GraphLayoutLM, a novel document understanding model that
leverages the modeling of layout structure graph to inject document layout
knowledge into the model. GraphLayoutLM utilizes a graph reordering algorithm
to adjust the text sequence based on the graph structure. Additionally, our
model uses a layout-aware multi-head self-attention layer to learn document
layout knowledge. The proposed model enables the understanding of the spatial
arrangement of text elements, improving document comprehension. We evaluate our
model on various benchmarks, including FUNSD, XFUND and CORD, and achieve
state-of-the-art results among these datasets. Our experimental results
demonstrate that our proposed method provides a significant improvement over
existing approaches and showcases the importance of incorporating layout
information into document understanding models. We also conduct an ablation
study to investigate the contribution of each component of our model. The
results show that both the graph reordering algorithm and the layout-aware
multi-head self-attention layer play a crucial role in achieving the best
performance. | [
0.0241380036,
-0.0140563985,
0.0233797617,
0.0398505554,
-0.0052577332,
0.0089029241,
0.0126665793,
-0.0265374072,
0.0298406594,
-0.012826548,
-0.055231858,
0.0043091951,
0.0080545479,
0.0441034026,
-0.0353209525,
-0.0385879166,
0.0120158233,
-0.0110915871,
-0.0043827794,
0.0430395715,
0.0145486947,
-0.0044807661,
0.0036585398,
-0.0385724194,
-0.0300501268,
-0.0639673322,
-0.0742203295,
0.044648882,
0.0203977749,
-0.0328269973,
-0.0228365157,
0.0330582485,
0.0495680384,
0.0605656356,
0.0000018891,
0.0094426284,
-0.0323495269,
0.0100960787,
0.0012136351,
0.0032586849,
0.026647782,
-0.0649519563,
0.0134471543,
-0.0641827807,
-0.0262878723,
-0.0035837663,
0.0499950796,
0.0807213113,
0.0571945719,
0.0520957224,
-0.0288057644,
-0.0426132791,
-0.0084287627,
-0.0294881705,
0.0458730161,
-0.0224877298,
-0.0076672239,
0.0102383317,
-0.0111678243,
0.0107787699,
-0.0694896951,
0.0029049276,
0.0409540348,
-0.0312667973,
0.0319141112,
0.018416835,
0.0232333131,
-0.0105011724,
-0.0271677468,
0.1245878488,
-0.0188760217,
-0.0064693103,
0.0063002016,
-0.0396444611,
0.0007891328,
0.0014742616,
-0.0598111637,
-0.0475545116,
-0.0316779017,
-0.0235750787,
-0.0364152975,
0.0316217057,
0.0200096127,
-0.0332193784,
-0.0241417643,
0.026352806,
-0.0232427195,
0.0086202351,
-0.0122261494,
-0.0028183728,
0.0173687413,
0.0179696474,
0.0422072262,
0.0488491207,
0.0145146875,
0.0151267145,
-0.0346535593,
-0.0656254366,
0.0083261598,
-0.0361379981,
0.0249760021,
-0.0247119814,
-0.0320812762,
0.0739890635,
-0.0226274077,
0.0568024144,
-0.0423605777,
0.069093287,
-0.0590732358,
0.0424759239,
0.0083191888,
0.0090847081,
-0.0429840758,
0.0027506354,
-0.0207077004,
-0.068543829,
0.0194944348,
0.0321704112,
0.0357938819,
-0.0006368514,
0.0217465423,
0.0117403073,
-0.082335189,
-0.0762788579,
0.0461374298,
0.0277245473,
-0.0067217345,
-0.0101149417,
-0.0294987541,
0.0122254705,
-0.0100316135,
0.0411390066,
0.0306933634,
0.0141569404,
-0.0300856605,
0.0626651719,
-0.0158483759,
-0.0527096391,
-0.0053330469,
0.0059650228,
-0.005677647,
-0.042277541,
0.0614545457,
-0.0190671571,
-0.0013904832,
-0.0055108722,
-0.0107240565,
0.001364699,
-0.022230044,
-0.0119517557,
-0.0268308781,
0.0473754741,
-0.0040741311,
0.0194915272,
0.0356072485,
0.0180293005,
-0.0092864716,
0.0403730422,
0.0162324626,
0.0667306706,
0.0048464052,
-0.0329398401,
-0.0020277346,
0.0255030114,
0.0155260917,
-0.0420470312,
0.0450442769,
0.0246046092,
-0.0619095601,
-0.0057280087,
0.0152270226,
-0.0208880361,
-0.0276332311,
-0.0374099426,
0.0365977883,
0.0161265265,
0.0442770347,
0.0256292839,
0.0000127088,
0.0316446908,
0.0057427315,
0.0365898274,
-0.0563907064,
0.0227486342,
0.0268537439,
0.029166745,
-0.0155185619,
-0.0076963105,
-0.0071540647,
-0.0316972435,
0.0165803842,
0.0007963527,
0.0536015593,
-0.0236226264,
0.0663678199,
0.0397146568,
-0.0730452836,
0.0248490367,
-0.0003916002,
-0.0431952961,
-0.0446842089,
0.0262868013,
0.0092211394,
0.0347535647,
0.024039207,
-0.0459424183,
-0.0600074939,
0.0178176891,
0.0319696814,
0.036049325,
0.0285074841,
0.012088038,
0.0465788879,
-0.0566477589,
-0.0368839651,
-0.0254049078,
-0.0164667517,
0.0303703174,
0.0113608483,
-0.0401680246,
0.0303354915,
-0.0944102705,
-0.0094192345,
0.0410460532,
0.0154071189,
-0.0273437966,
-0.0397325866,
0.0055442173,
-0.0138444332,
0.0205657668,
-0.0011911105,
0.0014733638,
0.0388877839,
-0.006337293,
0.0610483103,
-0.0163420737,
-0.0733802468,
-0.042465698,
-0.0136981485,
-0.0349931791,
-0.0277275052,
0.0245266203,
-0.0626135543,
-0.0430038199,
0.0202317704,
-0.0180332754,
0.026148973,
0.0053214571,
-0.0412807986,
0.0155240176,
0.0265222602,
-0.0302121621,
0.0376653895,
0.0134412963,
0.0155407889,
0.0170555227,
0.0282149818,
0.0118818115,
-0.0031676812,
0.0165683888,
-0.0069254707,
-0.0260629598,
-0.0158702023,
0.006000381,
0.0320033617,
-0.0583522283,
0.0053098626,
-0.0816038772,
-0.0046292604,
-0.0256633051,
0.0345321707,
0.0420917943,
0.00114766,
-0.0116321743,
-0.0961608961,
-0.0510557108,
0.0237427335,
-0.0004225295,
-0.0271534342,
0.0021212662,
-0.0071918396,
0.0274485499,
0.0047801165,
-0.0295733549,
-0.0003529506,
0.0429630727,
0.0820115358,
-0.0162312314,
-0.0019470709,
0.0219054352,
0.0395601988,
-0.0103304144,
-0.0171311665,
-0.0024904765,
-0.0038518989,
-0.0353588611,
0.0475928895,
0.1298930049,
-0.0084991138,
0.0713435709,
-0.00961746,
-0.034115985,
-0.0038251996,
0.0092336982,
-0.0159889814,
0.0684268549,
-0.0281635318,
0.0080678547,
-0.0012911585,
0.0661501735,
-0.0204027072,
0.0151006868,
-0.0168645345,
-0.04032759,
-0.0058532185,
-0.005381335,
-0.0346373022,
-0.0192032289,
0.0300200321,
0.0209910199,
-0.042337656,
-0.0325052254,
0.0451305881,
-0.0485028177,
-0.049077522,
-0.0174576491,
0.0317016654,
-0.0442516059,
0.0501438603,
0.0685740933,
0.0139934067,
-0.0105555123,
-0.0496813729,
-0.0563709065,
0.0165226068,
0.0270612705,
-0.0123297814,
0.0102060931,
-0.0137876002,
0.0443297848,
-0.049600523,
-0.0111767836,
-0.0042306352,
-0.0320827253,
0.0171347558,
-0.0350173265,
0.0017422369,
-0.0042476226,
-0.0872509554,
0.0377052203,
0.0111768125,
0.0932726488,
-0.0313540697,
-0.0163581427,
-0.0117722247,
0.103990525,
0.0045326706,
0.0280845594,
0.0162675567,
-0.0604684241,
0.0148107624,
0.0561540686,
-0.0310286172,
-0.0225285441,
-0.033493381,
0.0274017546,
-0.0162656084,
-0.0063899467,
0.016366085,
-0.0056407782,
0.0406458452,
-0.0931948274,
-0.0170678627,
0.0739068314,
0.0234443713,
-0.0652939081,
-0.0741500407,
-0.0286311209,
0.0278107002,
0.0022835664,
0.0133540342,
-0.0588934086,
-0.026444234,
-0.0201193132,
-0.0250899624,
0.0805088952,
0.0188008882,
-0.004332161,
-0.0344923809,
0.0374681726,
0.0144408457,
-0.0552786291,
-0.0182896703,
-0.0270216223,
0.0081907352,
0.0043401592,
-0.0253736656,
0.0052056955,
-0.0253778994,
-0.0427180976,
-0.0000813202,
-0.0218870956,
0.0203561485,
-0.0158286318,
0.0264610853,
-0.0562015958,
0.0271387547,
0.0272168387,
0.0205701403,
-0.0003239076,
0.031408865,
0.0318497606,
0.0283057932,
0.0107890032,
0.0649541691,
-0.0076160119,
0.0138417324,
-0.0607168414,
0.0288813841,
-0.0536613166,
-0.0240822975,
-0.0383162536,
0.0116982749,
-0.0005328904,
-0.0301952418,
-0.0436147526,
0.0011205769,
-0.0395607539,
0.0082357563,
0.0582468472,
0.0018906872,
-0.0831808969,
-0.050468836,
0.0709539279,
-0.0409017429,
-0.0116235288,
0.0398710445,
-0.0113338958,
-0.0343843959,
-0.0316897482,
-0.0367496125,
-0.0091993045,
0.0120576946,
0.0110619077,
-0.0416483767,
-0.0061516953,
-0.0335146748,
-0.0683924481,
0.0468409769,
0.0202851761,
-0.0101490784,
-0.0540668294,
0.0182328578,
0.0383465886,
-0.0385600775,
-0.0098961322,
0.0279163495,
-0.0825466365,
-0.0105053941,
0.0160800107,
0.0284378733,
0.0138826752,
0.0853540078,
-0.0162385833,
-0.0161663685,
0.0512065962,
0.0128398482,
-0.0289780963,
-0.0333239473,
0.0462398008,
-0.0422135554,
-0.0288798939,
-0.0045060366,
-0.0229617599,
0.0576174259,
0.0218740441,
-0.0220999401,
-0.0247316789,
-0.0208360087,
-0.0006740658,
-0.0062141051,
0.0215746481,
0.0315497816,
0.0412238725,
-0.0216312874,
0.0317623094,
-0.0068419618,
-0.0137135275,
-0.0172499269,
-0.0150072491,
0.0026197862,
-0.0032017976,
-0.0010282858,
0.0367618464,
0.0451399162,
0.0304120667,
-0.0112130996,
0.0306400713,
0.0312486924,
-0.047133293,
0.0174028296,
0.0206756461,
0.0029626328,
0.0183746964,
0.0068761208,
0.0426394455,
0.0184209347,
0.0683156922,
0.0267760903,
-0.0355737694,
-0.0305768419,
0.0409838967,
-0.0822578222,
-0.001987261,
-0.0490155071,
0.0053732879,
0.0035134426,
-0.0388092436,
0.0367458239,
0.0108358487,
0.0050862781,
0.009341849,
0.0484732017,
0.0373408906,
-0.009724956,
0.0043056328,
0.0255879853,
0.0384797007,
0.0004109403,
0.0635376051,
0.0578783229,
-0.0263554472,
0.0272155646,
-0.0279674642,
-0.063750729,
0.0006104181,
0.0342547782,
0.0412642434,
-0.003340154,
0.0100608179,
-0.0157523677,
-0.0186393466,
0.0534920432,
0.0044487566,
0.0039350153,
0.0248544142,
0.026101483,
0.0642649978,
0.0214649849,
-0.0178877134,
-0.0158726797,
0.0445060097,
-0.0312244557,
-0.0159454737,
0.01784008,
-5.608122652e-33,
-0.0379198343,
-0.0654316097,
-0.0151063465,
0.0152475545,
-0.0154283959,
0.0197717361,
-0.0544845723,
-0.0145980101,
0.0022171699,
0.0395240933,
-0.0238671061,
0.0117163891,
0.0240004342,
0.0527352542,
-0.0402721427,
0.003294874,
0.0514796451,
-0.0011850996,
-0.0339223817,
0.0307914801,
-0.0000689438,
0.0572598912,
0.0623082593,
-0.0244220775,
-0.0206154268,
-0.0220264401,
0.0211208034,
-0.0110186208,
-0.0064392565,
0.0341008976,
-0.0091658588,
-0.0244210642,
0.0413474962,
-0.0148045179,
-0.0455161855,
0.0751729682,
-0.1155371144,
-0.0169476066,
-0.0121381469,
0.0659463704,
-0.0489765778,
0.0056609702,
0.0548548065,
-0.017236134,
0.060729485,
-0.0644720048,
0.0721645132,
-0.0083185676,
-0.0368367508,
0.0115442853,
-0.0461669154,
0.0328563042,
-0.0456976481,
-0.032622762,
0.0603246577,
0.0079663303,
0.0057622395,
0.0595281012,
-0.0759184882,
-0.0082046352,
-0.0064642886,
0.0248009991,
0.0607186817,
0.0464874655,
-0.0116981147,
0.012054123,
-0.0080345795,
0.0019814542,
-0.0409653075,
-0.0117992489,
0.0323424377,
0.06958092,
-0.0113828126,
0.027398495,
0.0169197191,
0.0499981046,
-0.0598557852,
0.0496782735,
-0.0503661744,
0.0471065082,
0.0155430222,
0.0306415632,
-0.0120944232,
0.0062254067,
-0.0000496655,
-0.0090881949,
-0.0337880664,
-0.0038330224,
0.0083770817,
0.0109566534,
-0.0186874773,
0.0099039255,
0.0606221296,
-0.0293283816,
0.011850493,
0.0731431991,
-0.0094193686,
0.0599387586,
-0.0329248644,
-0.0154864136,
-0.0134667065,
-0.004900448,
0.0430216789,
0.0016552103,
-0.0197793879,
-0.0242170971,
0.0609651953,
0.0154699124,
-0.0372606292,
-0.0157726482,
-0.0102555975,
-0.0323464051,
0.0009339146,
0.0474719591,
0.0296851527,
-0.0197957736,
-0.0703581721,
0.0687379986,
-0.0168954339,
0.0340014659,
-0.0294206161,
-0.0015446498,
-0.0122400802,
0.0387269631,
-0.0123598445,
-0.0494998358,
-0.0270575304,
-0.0259980112,
0.041726958,
-0.0631814376,
-0.0006871212,
0.0404644758,
2.401e-7,
0.0612239465,
0.0314671881,
0.0760273263,
-0.0340718515,
0.0577995591,
0.036642313,
-0.024357453,
0.0159535836,
-0.0325015821,
-0.03985212,
0.0294444375,
0.0502847806,
0.0173755083,
-0.0080087651,
-0.0693066493,
0.0196423996,
-0.058550518,
-0.0202135742,
-0.0423660912,
-0.0310007017,
0.0030988245,
0.0573844537,
-0.0626449808,
-0.028098546,
0.0179012418,
-0.0223906115,
0.0577662662,
-0.0092983162,
0.037261758,
0.0031027745,
0.0095955264,
-0.0323169194,
-0.0629582256,
0.0136719737,
-0.0105602182,
0.0232007746,
0.041308403,
0.0514631271,
-0.0052486155,
0.0120271584,
0.0179846995,
0.0142964572,
0.0126679232,
-0.0530821569,
0.0188544057,
-0.0683493763,
-0.0406623557,
-0.0339380987,
-0.0622215569,
-0.0206622295,
-0.019660119,
0.0198126137,
0.0191753786,
0.0440126657,
0.0155733572,
-0.0654304698,
0.0042094835,
-0.0675699413,
-0.0472460948,
-0.000681182,
-0.0076036644,
0.0433289148,
-0.0382966697,
-0.018974511,
0.0411527045,
-0.0069153635,
-0.0333072618,
1.984393569e-34,
0.0285976287,
-0.0052255592,
-0.0028630795,
0.0109692253,
0.0218834393,
-0.0324866511,
-0.0194666088,
0.0038864759,
0.0056566051,
-0.0937381536,
0.015967695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07758v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07758v6 | Forward-Backward Reasoning in Large Language Models for Mathematical Verification | 2023-08-15T13:19:59 | 2024-06-05T03:37:35 | Weisen Jiang, Han Shi, Longhui Yu, Zhengying Liu, Yu Zhang, Zhenguo Li, James T. Kwok | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Self-Consistency samples diverse reasoning chains with answers and chooses
the final answer by majority voting. It is based on forward reasoning and
cannot further improve performance by sampling more reasoning chains when
saturated. To further boost performance, we introduce backward reasoning to
verify candidate answers. Specifically, for mathematical tasks, we mask a
number in the question and ask the LLM to answer a backward question created by
a simple template, i.e., to predict the masked number when a candidate answer
is provided. Instead of using forward or backward reasoning alone, we propose
FOBAR to combine FOrward and BAckward Reasoning for verification. Extensive
experiments on six standard mathematical data sets and three LLMs show that
FOBAR achieves state-of-the-art performance. In particular, FOBAR outperforms
Self-Consistency, which uses forward reasoning alone, demonstrating that
combining forward and forward reasoning is better. In addition, FOBAR performs
better than existing verification methods, showing the effectiveness of the
simple template used in backward reasoning and the proposed combination.
Extensions to non-mathematical problems are also discussed and validated
empirically. | [
-0.0204242077,
0.0586423054,
0.0175246764,
0.0133331064,
-0.0495623052,
0.016010033,
0.0018707181,
0.0047346442,
0.0046972497,
-0.0039146068,
0.0346250273,
-0.0162628386,
-0.0085137924,
-0.0068502431,
0.0261579938,
0.0101567972,
-0.0007007799,
-0.0623934269,
-0.0007108342,
-0.0562395044,
-0.017642267,
-0.0094598075,
-0.006970556,
-0.0141981952,
-0.0234378166,
-0.0513320565,
0.0201941244,
-0.0587259009,
0.0009511414,
-0.0245301146,
-0.02587975,
0.0218035392,
-0.0185593441,
-0.0238695946,
0.0000023947,
-0.0556086041,
-0.0198174436,
0.0266026091,
-0.0920178294,
-0.0041687153,
-0.0707594529,
0.0511971191,
0.0013783012,
0.0428238958,
-0.0680853948,
0.0081789028,
0.0216458179,
0.0342940241,
0.1129180714,
0.0152468728,
0.019047616,
-0.0493745208,
0.044789806,
0.0097605577,
0.0233331416,
-0.0309415646,
0.0281986874,
0.0278951973,
0.0137930922,
0.0239948574,
-0.000148075,
0.0699863136,
0.0629213005,
-0.0077535901,
-0.0453571826,
0.0234714448,
0.0246689655,
0.0173163656,
-0.010757626,
0.0388543159,
0.0201745424,
-0.0502023213,
0.0058985744,
-0.0135339899,
-0.0608150549,
0.0434981436,
-0.0442951582,
0.0264231004,
-0.0087487074,
0.0012847192,
0.0094254492,
-0.0035440812,
0.0484034643,
0.0160968192,
-0.0756743848,
0.1395033002,
-0.0057173958,
-0.0610792302,
-0.0008085191,
-0.0001303244,
0.0177423134,
-0.0831404179,
0.0355677083,
0.0641972795,
0.016514197,
-0.0052890503,
0.0076568904,
-0.0186125953,
-0.0013129058,
-0.0068521546,
0.0156534221,
0.0533298291,
-0.0244371016,
0.0346152782,
-0.0549218431,
0.0531580597,
-0.045732338,
0.0088122617,
0.0084110973,
0.0048794551,
0.0007219714,
-0.0069135176,
-0.0163623765,
0.0633921102,
0.0242439192,
0.0367321558,
-0.0468723923,
0.0027623181,
-0.0557753369,
0.055032324,
0.0060658474,
-0.0262998641,
0.0386545435,
-0.0411893837,
-0.0331890061,
-0.0081323218,
-0.0291597247,
-0.0032165679,
-0.0025123316,
-0.0183884706,
-0.0025536432,
0.0055002044,
-0.0210428722,
-0.0179531313,
0.03030953,
0.0607151613,
0.0357128903,
0.0654359162,
-0.0119049847,
-0.0278769769,
0.0365553908,
-0.0903963223,
0.0226329248,
-0.1038246229,
0.027487129,
0.0222334564,
-0.0216979217,
0.0064878613,
-0.0032124252,
0.0144459801,
0.0456056073,
0.0937522277,
0.0223917607,
0.0039344477,
0.038420096,
-0.0001741702,
0.0245599933,
-0.0086437911,
0.002416943,
-0.0318246782,
0.0253317822,
-0.0062700179,
0.0237661656,
0.0406886674,
0.0542708375,
0.0028233295,
-0.0449609905,
0.0642515495,
0.0078136027,
0.020208437,
-0.0742734745,
0.0266959593,
-0.0326133482,
-0.0412224494,
-0.0042049643,
0.0363854319,
0.0202302653,
-0.0295404866,
0.0163730364,
-0.0256692376,
0.0273648631,
0.0121829873,
-0.0384218656,
0.0456123576,
-0.0610856712,
-0.0025690005,
0.0368666127,
-0.0042068684,
-0.0308711771,
-0.081146583,
-0.012346467,
0.0138285477,
-0.0228849072,
0.0518725105,
0.0679840669,
-0.0209292471,
0.0054475381,
0.059868969,
-0.0136162704,
-0.0634338036,
-0.0495432764,
-0.0538267754,
0.0396534912,
-0.0171012674,
0.0676103383,
-0.0387587249,
-0.0332587175,
-0.0274362639,
0.0414276123,
0.0059242742,
0.0440848172,
0.0231973566,
-0.0252326205,
-0.0291635022,
-0.0107773645,
0.0632422194,
-0.0190544073,
0.0032988414,
0.0325543508,
0.0193364434,
0.0026696895,
0.0026491047,
0.0344299376,
0.0211557131,
-0.0552515388,
-0.0452986695,
0.0188606549,
0.0165001452,
0.0250731017,
-0.0110884076,
0.0052799508,
0.0339337327,
0.0224985536,
-0.0064249486,
-0.0280724801,
-0.0360559151,
-0.0747049302,
-0.0208986197,
0.0800943077,
-0.0043920241,
-0.0516883805,
0.0253047552,
-0.0537058339,
-0.0342050083,
0.0516984612,
-0.0115401922,
-0.0241567474,
-0.0420408659,
0.0147262923,
0.0092758154,
-0.0242780373,
-0.0016476982,
0.0391945057,
0.0108745061,
0.0323939249,
-0.0168337654,
-0.0017237979,
0.0426569656,
-0.0409504808,
-0.0157090053,
0.0318336971,
-0.0021482478,
0.0052037942,
0.0113383671,
0.007429726,
-0.0161517784,
0.009899918,
-0.0178011954,
0.0027097329,
-0.0016408929,
0.0347325467,
-0.0131411608,
-0.0434306264,
0.0205904059,
-0.0272860695,
-0.0259025637,
-0.0105288709,
0.01957196,
-0.0039385222,
0.0293361042,
0.0133662354,
-0.0032467647,
-0.0003269977,
-0.0344850756,
-0.0496410169,
0.0316138789,
-0.0019866945,
0.0160961393,
-0.0458436534,
-0.0285645742,
-0.0689699352,
0.0022032293,
-0.0185757224,
0.036465358,
0.0384953208,
-0.0497302748,
0.0067633386,
0.0312981084,
-0.0130469473,
-0.0340961404,
0.0339712948,
-0.0224715266,
-0.0652074218,
0.0090614902,
-0.0269020144,
0.0043159663,
0.0364369452,
-0.0186042264,
-0.0303301718,
0.0337259807,
-0.0123337125,
-0.0132862637,
-0.0101346374,
0.0284405798,
0.000392744,
0.0234077238,
-0.0562400855,
0.0025245969,
-0.0061781257,
0.0514548644,
0.0107860006,
-0.0355302393,
0.0818666443,
-0.025626177,
0.0014011794,
0.0033762783,
0.021895932,
-0.0308539085,
0.0270666424,
-0.0146771064,
-0.0125824865,
0.0125660878,
0.0094284033,
0.0022610968,
-0.0355762728,
0.0436440967,
-0.0447229818,
0.0404316001,
-0.0442218781,
0.0301759671,
0.0123219835,
-0.0600620396,
-0.0338756479,
-0.0539793298,
-0.0208409578,
0.0177042242,
-0.0912946612,
0.0105130784,
-0.0213700365,
0.0115923285,
0.0009627923,
-0.0009710902,
-0.0283946842,
-0.0191903319,
-0.0067553287,
-0.0276531316,
-0.0316461734,
0.0105327005,
0.0666038543,
-0.0131282397,
0.008128617,
0.036592681,
0.099983722,
-0.0059255552,
-0.0315235071,
0.0086835977,
0.0132611645,
-0.0558933355,
-0.042301327,
0.0167618152,
-0.0030793278,
-0.0812336206,
-0.0003916039,
0.0927428082,
0.0278618671,
0.0342492424,
-0.0365163386,
-0.0471981801,
-0.0235403571,
0.0210987721,
0.0422884375,
-0.0629502609,
-0.0228367541,
0.02726583,
0.0148668271,
0.0071792654,
-0.0360504054,
-0.0010727333,
-0.1116986275,
0.0466221236,
0.0298325606,
0.0026801261,
0.0217611231,
-0.0490814224,
-0.0026376122,
0.0225148238,
-0.0600471459,
0.0436212569,
0.0076928847,
-0.0167541932,
0.009955205,
-0.0231100898,
0.0169285294,
0.0661229789,
-0.0204489883,
0.0019420072,
0.015984904,
0.025415007,
-0.0205605384,
-0.0830188692,
0.0466734208,
-0.0169174038,
-0.0262738653,
-0.0394337475,
0.0015590992,
-0.0122202206,
-0.0047901506,
0.006690383,
0.002241136,
-0.0121848667,
-0.0209954288,
0.0206069369,
0.1282549202,
-0.0449620821,
-0.0029395267,
-0.0012429371,
0.019061543,
-0.0226569045,
0.0368821658,
-0.0160461105,
0.0247293208,
-0.0965710655,
-0.0584118851,
-0.0411177613,
0.0301804766,
-0.022502074,
-0.0262453482,
0.0349590182,
0.0065511144,
-0.0072000157,
0.0070830118,
0.0386335328,
0.0348044373,
-0.0209091064,
-0.0196415018,
0.0174690299,
-0.0104673179,
-0.036304988,
0.0074727065,
-0.05957634,
0.0529357679,
-0.0482743345,
0.0506545193,
0.0183064286,
-0.0048348405,
-0.0171519201,
0.0330214761,
-0.0437624343,
-0.0397891626,
-0.006041938,
0.0476690829,
0.0236851294,
0.0142506743,
-0.0168710724,
-0.035782095,
0.0361048207,
0.0290230997,
-0.0240655337,
0.019339703,
0.0313229673,
-0.0280495845,
0.0168435369,
0.0003651369,
-0.0096527487,
0.0075129103,
0.0313615352,
0.0103935795,
-0.0134140728,
-0.0264595784,
0.0109917223,
0.106515862,
0.0227834247,
0.0245332718,
0.0044028996,
-0.0043475013,
0.0425068326,
-0.0367592797,
-0.0168443583,
0.0043958365,
0.0500136949,
-0.0171688478,
-0.037527062,
-0.0009193976,
-0.0112109967,
-0.0074495678,
0.0062402189,
-0.0019844992,
0.0762796402,
-0.002922561,
0.0552577898,
0.0337679535,
-0.0466933772,
0.0016035958,
-0.0370893069,
0.0555181168,
0.0458414592,
-0.0090497248,
0.0336577222,
0.0259630233,
0.034203466,
-0.0520936772,
-0.0107781934,
-0.0755752921,
-0.1203379184,
-0.0088712033,
0.0306788571,
0.0308590177,
0.0362721793,
-0.0097157601,
-0.0214935374,
-0.004507455,
-0.0157501735,
0.0177323185,
0.0386959426,
-0.0228262935,
0.0545354858,
0.0240296293,
0.0053442279,
-0.0118161477,
0.0260026362,
-0.0094345631,
0.0233619679,
0.0139293531,
0.0128043983,
-0.0371172465,
-0.0351490565,
-0.0311808176,
-0.0111604193,
0.0108165815,
-0.0159062874,
-0.0146443043,
-0.0976814926,
0.0509793386,
0.0466484241,
-0.0377807654,
0.025200054,
0.0153888352,
0.0636122599,
0.0274064988,
-0.0116168913,
-0.0084733116,
0.0494972467,
-0.0135607468,
-0.0250925496,
-0.0001537786,
-6.021359977e-33,
-0.0232128836,
-0.0435298607,
0.0654629841,
-0.003894313,
0.0204816666,
-0.043171823,
-0.0282219537,
-0.0125399698,
0.0184737109,
0.0205656812,
-0.0437120497,
0.0386820436,
0.0250693168,
-0.0111459214,
0.0172057413,
-0.0330086537,
0.0383971035,
-0.0230250377,
-0.026794564,
-0.0147554073,
0.0080714114,
-0.0041034408,
0.0646073446,
-0.0977781937,
0.0225613248,
0.0022210444,
-0.0127628017,
0.0425572731,
-0.0896494314,
0.0689862743,
-0.0050318525,
-0.0007589487,
-0.005173021,
-0.0664469153,
-0.0267875418,
0.0125143789,
-0.0551560037,
-0.0552053936,
-0.0199579,
0.0120307095,
-0.0397452153,
0.0072014607,
0.0226530023,
0.0147231929,
-0.0702330247,
-0.0062997513,
-0.014316557,
-0.0299185812,
0.0293173678,
-0.0027620494,
0.0204236321,
0.0538797192,
-0.0036558695,
-0.0132470811,
0.0530965067,
0.0353679731,
-0.0550694875,
-0.028724784,
-0.0343506299,
0.0207438134,
0.0099017164,
-0.0295779444,
0.074271068,
-0.0167774968,
0.0067567569,
0.0148190791,
0.0151648885,
-0.0720807537,
-0.025474228,
-0.0260060336,
-0.0112685431,
0.0524719395,
0.0904179141,
0.0092280023,
0.0564134717,
0.0054100659,
-0.055205103,
0.0297378041,
-0.0091243992,
0.0551592447,
0.0203748923,
-0.0352209322,
-0.056136962,
-0.0414479636,
-0.0697457567,
0.0250984337,
-0.050872948,
0.0018006661,
0.0188393313,
-0.007409635,
-0.0136510795,
0.0160639994,
0.019901542,
-0.0651786625,
-0.0541662686,
0.0336717218,
0.0098628802,
-0.0135107804,
0.0267563872,
0.0452141725,
-0.0464425161,
0.043055445,
-0.0444188751,
-0.0438533574,
0.0161623582,
0.0144346301,
-0.0063375295,
0.034266375,
-0.0927790329,
-0.0209579431,
-0.0295056477,
0.00163587,
0.0539257377,
-0.0050749872,
0.054638233,
0.0150698731,
0.0311645344,
0.0651451349,
-0.0352421328,
-0.0367266238,
-0.0339830033,
0.0582500286,
0.0162839945,
0.0414320491,
0.0026149582,
-0.0036752208,
-0.0421965569,
0.0111719482,
0.0044550933,
-0.055329632,
0.0053178919,
0.055945728,
2.969e-7,
0.0161806475,
0.0379751921,
0.0160700921,
0.024562316,
0.0061858692,
0.0365587845,
-0.055691909,
-0.0392956547,
0.0086747026,
-0.0172104966,
0.0043119392,
0.0536168963,
0.0352385193,
0.0756136328,
-0.0080272919,
-0.006293979,
-0.0294113196,
-0.0163510945,
-0.0313836709,
-0.0009792128,
0.0533987954,
0.0255163275,
0.0461344086,
0.0122454567,
-0.0119213453,
-0.0569824576,
0.0710180029,
0.0079307491,
0.0093152747,
0.0079779318,
0.0122166723,
-0.0077899741,
0.0335561484,
0.0134579642,
0.0114008719,
0.0118776234,
-0.0278809313,
0.0566653535,
0.003040503,
-0.0299714804,
-0.030403316,
-0.0112959808,
0.0109090852,
-0.0240973011,
0.0683594197,
-0.0312248766,
-0.029242374,
-0.035366226,
0.000490126,
-0.0608237945,
0.0441017561,
0.0263789129,
0.0053324481,
0.0110306302,
0.0315260291,
-0.0081562428,
-0.0067995982,
-0.0776846856,
-0.0319087133,
0.0147772906,
-0.0438093171,
-0.0190373361,
-0.0118614463,
0.0304554403,
0.0355732776,
-0.0435222872,
-0.0211088229,
3.037606202e-34,
0.0272372663,
0.0027669948,
-0.0065826373,
0.0219653975,
0.0160221979,
0.0081392694,
0.0009959178,
0.0366416126,
0.0126124183,
-0.0518110991,
-0.0244787596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07711v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07711v3 | SPM: Structured Pretraining and Matching Architectures for Relevance Modeling in Meituan Search | 2023-08-15T11:45:34 | 2023-08-27T11:21:38 | Wen Zan, Yaopeng Han, Xiaotian Jiang, Yao Xiao, Yang Yang, Dayao Chen, Sheng Chen | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | In e-commerce search, relevance between query and documents is an essential
requirement for satisfying user experience. Different from traditional
e-commerce platforms that offer products, users search on life service
platforms such as Meituan mainly for product providers, which usually have
abundant structured information, e.g. name, address, category, thousands of
products. Modeling search relevance with these rich structured contents is
challenging due to the following issues: (1) there is language distribution
discrepancy among different fields of structured document, making it difficult
to directly adopt off-the-shelf pretrained language model based methods like
BERT. (2) different fields usually have different importance and their length
vary greatly, making it difficult to extract document information helpful for
relevance matching.
To tackle these issues, in this paper we propose a novel two-stage
pretraining and matching architecture for relevance matching with rich
structured documents. At pretraining stage, we propose an effective pretraining
method that employs both query and multiple fields of document as inputs,
including an effective information compression method for lengthy fields. At
relevance matching stage, a novel matching method is proposed by leveraging
domain knowledge in search query to generate more effective document
representations for relevance scoring. Extensive offline experiments and online
A/B tests on millions of users verify that the proposed architectures
effectively improve the performance of relevance modeling. The model has
already been deployed online, serving the search traffic of Meituan for over a
year. | [
0.0456010029,
-0.0150263952,
-0.0014094793,
-0.0203659069,
-0.0225109719,
-0.0171027724,
-0.0177766625,
0.0329802707,
-0.0187030137,
-0.0912988782,
-0.0660595372,
-0.002554798,
-0.0204445031,
0.0526132174,
-0.0354666524,
-0.0407645777,
0.0313740633,
0.045419395,
-0.0094659263,
0.0145008452,
0.0593734346,
0.0218699463,
0.0379729159,
0.0058901398,
0.0254564285,
0.0156099936,
-0.0129845906,
0.0356221311,
-0.0400047153,
-0.0305481683,
0.0442190245,
0.0402028114,
0.0256281458,
0.010332101,
0.0000016528,
-0.0690012649,
-0.0650138557,
0.006421444,
-0.0111833811,
0.0193185974,
0.0415691733,
0.0222186223,
0.0359527655,
0.0284073614,
-0.0267562438,
-0.0007759766,
0.0336617343,
0.0867518112,
0.0511122979,
0.0741650984,
-0.0112964557,
-0.0308859125,
0.0255304594,
0.0007211547,
0.0154043781,
-0.0312602147,
0.0247575864,
-0.0343824401,
0.0560249351,
0.0480378568,
0.0113868974,
0.0003425294,
-0.0548130125,
0.0006165921,
0.0364914201,
0.0085710948,
-0.0744760558,
0.0421803668,
0.0308257062,
0.0604313388,
-0.0139040723,
-0.0206141546,
-0.0000949794,
0.0079456773,
-0.0188466292,
0.0127873765,
-0.0485351868,
-0.0199630279,
-0.0169165432,
0.0064275716,
-0.005763669,
-0.0024985508,
0.0044784965,
0.0127332211,
-0.0208340026,
0.0884975642,
0.0379829258,
-0.0490320623,
-0.005543571,
-0.0095860157,
-0.0257725194,
-0.0388267152,
0.0295346789,
0.0268671885,
-0.006494483,
-0.0058558173,
-0.0551401749,
-0.0197377279,
0.0273955408,
-0.1172469184,
-0.0218814779,
0.0190958884,
-0.0008447619,
0.0586377159,
-0.0459738635,
0.0412455946,
0.0060460027,
-0.0233170018,
-0.0753157139,
-0.0219170451,
-0.0731344447,
-0.0165135339,
-0.0468665138,
0.045330774,
-0.0151033821,
-0.0212625582,
-0.0306660868,
0.0480372682,
0.0261777677,
-0.034324836,
0.0094787721,
-0.0176801216,
-0.0187892132,
0.0008248127,
-0.0437796265,
-0.0071001886,
-0.0350428522,
0.0038025535,
-0.0401747823,
-0.0315877125,
0.0418080613,
0.0523496456,
0.0229518525,
-0.0460345186,
0.0332261845,
-0.0247692857,
0.015561467,
-0.033004757,
-0.0582107082,
-0.0154588427,
0.0475984775,
-0.008225658,
0.0039787483,
-0.040985778,
0.0222753771,
-0.0154837668,
-0.0139456075,
0.0054354556,
-0.0171845965,
0.0179333556,
-0.024313258,
0.0659862682,
0.0005735088,
0.0117495032,
0.0522983856,
-0.0176677722,
0.0414327979,
0.0340888128,
-0.0343138687,
0.0075745457,
0.0578537621,
-0.0241223555,
-0.0055497685,
0.0166616477,
-0.0065672421,
-0.0243275929,
0.0146210296,
0.0668309256,
-0.026280405,
0.0083421869,
0.0390927047,
0.0140941422,
-0.0150562124,
0.0156474132,
0.0095141828,
0.048590526,
0.0813877285,
0.0238755215,
0.0052086986,
0.038274847,
0.0211178828,
-0.0071933544,
0.0005809975,
-0.0234160405,
-0.0468453094,
0.0059928419,
0.0273861308,
0.0051918556,
-0.0744669735,
0.0195730533,
0.0019155934,
0.003937027,
-0.0253959093,
0.0166200288,
0.0324260816,
-0.013565857,
-0.0086286059,
0.0568216667,
-0.0097092772,
-0.0247408561,
0.0393791646,
-0.0407076888,
-0.0329215676,
0.0822927505,
0.0829505026,
-0.0680909827,
-0.0191932973,
0.0115992669,
-0.0202727038,
0.0137765715,
0.0411673971,
-0.0196408201,
-0.0133751174,
-0.0505610593,
-0.0666914806,
0.0161879789,
-0.0116478838,
-0.0108283311,
0.0045577828,
0.0233884007,
0.0402236767,
-0.0680374727,
0.034215726,
0.0400179811,
0.0064750868,
-0.0386185348,
0.0136148874,
0.0050618378,
0.0041030394,
0.0046204301,
-0.008282165,
0.0101164244,
0.0306347851,
0.0113939252,
-0.0049373927,
-0.0374480635,
-0.000619625,
0.0112378383,
0.0466825292,
-0.0310612451,
0.0522134863,
0.0276426524,
-0.0018108351,
-0.0293569397,
-0.049860917,
-0.0436718464,
0.062124636,
-0.0431337506,
0.0470837541,
-0.0482106097,
0.0204265676,
-0.0621343628,
0.0416483469,
0.0305097494,
0.0298435353,
-0.0103486339,
-0.0377939083,
0.0096764844,
-0.044965785,
-0.0230682418,
0.0094892839,
-0.001560221,
0.048709888,
0.0548924245,
0.0103294682,
-0.0319974907,
0.0206835009,
-0.0835667849,
0.0124108512,
0.0062381835,
0.0559781715,
0.020067431,
0.0470962338,
-0.0143793207,
-0.0208165683,
-0.078585051,
-0.0185169745,
0.00581278,
0.0128962323,
0.0166505314,
0.0139148338,
-0.0017227265,
-0.0358202755,
-0.0432304218,
-0.0033810481,
0.0313201696,
0.0024561931,
-0.0248807948,
-0.0567523241,
0.0396954417,
-0.0371826552,
0.0308589693,
0.0114088394,
0.0204142127,
-0.0562236384,
-0.0446802974,
0.0411483683,
0.0128939925,
0.0161128361,
-0.0439267717,
0.0291930456,
-0.017903734,
-0.0759364069,
-0.0050775362,
-0.0526270904,
0.0392000899,
-0.0264697336,
-0.0251880512,
0.0560706221,
-0.0030754195,
-0.0536940098,
0.0073735556,
-0.0354536921,
-0.0544645265,
0.0208593402,
0.0100346273,
-0.0516811945,
-0.0052971891,
0.0413284823,
0.0388908982,
0.0046319123,
-0.0175313614,
0.0654995218,
-0.0303947981,
0.0182843879,
-0.0631484762,
0.0041020359,
-0.0639155433,
0.0238859896,
-0.0366729349,
0.0213645287,
-0.0402861349,
-0.0233755969,
-0.0065136859,
0.0224114563,
0.0402062722,
-0.0504755899,
-0.0039914595,
0.0362157561,
0.0378309302,
-0.0032016847,
-0.029922815,
-0.0166625418,
-0.0701205209,
0.0276884567,
0.0341980383,
0.0350617021,
0.001836677,
-0.1202358678,
0.0744838864,
-0.0041451068,
0.0215467717,
-0.0015867017,
-0.031469021,
0.0228914898,
0.044351954,
0.0440032706,
-0.0202977508,
-0.0003384332,
0.0109944427,
-0.0060366853,
-0.0024881803,
0.0281805992,
-0.0311381891,
0.011582545,
-0.0059008389,
0.0629761443,
-0.1155891865,
-0.0264293309,
0.0110376198,
-0.0254199225,
-0.0095879817,
0.0017527838,
0.1077018678,
0.0350292847,
-0.0357907079,
-0.0400457941,
-0.0423343852,
0.0062654633,
0.0181303397,
0.0890656635,
-0.0199820027,
0.0212443005,
0.0286473855,
0.0417467579,
0.0132482816,
0.0147777852,
-0.0025570004,
-0.0980583653,
-0.0090899849,
-0.0160182323,
0.0232005976,
-0.0451512709,
-0.0648402125,
0.0099420073,
0.0041641993,
0.0004266087,
0.0053047133,
-0.0328575596,
0.005773175,
0.0271808151,
-0.0111555196,
-0.0508092269,
0.0257039592,
-0.0407086313,
-0.0030757254,
0.0684291646,
0.0181354713,
0.0103201624,
-0.0272090174,
0.0102890218,
0.01650583,
-0.0183238294,
-0.0290710926,
0.019018868,
-0.0555887334,
0.0427624919,
-0.0171308778,
-0.0408919491,
0.0030172875,
0.0155304763,
0.0014903337,
0.0481775813,
-0.0246948078,
0.0275196079,
-0.0628365204,
-0.0314195976,
-0.041340474,
0.0764232352,
-0.0095200995,
-0.0333599262,
-0.0031851965,
-0.0134357167,
0.0091940733,
0.0368717127,
-0.0045481361,
0.0314124376,
-0.0640376583,
0.001924883,
-0.0650443211,
-0.0257185679,
0.005536628,
-0.0003343875,
0.0079867085,
-0.004761952,
-0.0400158614,
0.0069843824,
-0.0648595542,
0.0410747528,
-0.0268967003,
0.0277754869,
-0.0809040964,
0.0458567068,
0.0385503583,
-0.0581718199,
-0.0213783514,
-0.0825527608,
0.0116143646,
-0.0066060056,
-0.0257836301,
0.0041221716,
0.0172451455,
0.0354272574,
-0.0482236184,
-0.0711542368,
0.0082476018,
0.037276417,
-0.0497175679,
-0.017397454,
0.0231659133,
-0.0226769764,
-0.0076671871,
0.0137027828,
-0.0719973668,
0.03085953,
-0.0155621208,
0.0610412396,
0.0348349996,
-0.073635146,
0.0481730029,
0.0498542339,
0.0508910567,
0.0199782439,
0.0338467024,
-0.0305754822,
0.0359913073,
0.0069255661,
-0.0429241545,
-0.0224996079,
0.005515744,
0.0269677844,
0.0061559007,
0.0111574428,
0.0777811706,
-0.0357873179,
0.0149253057,
-0.0543269105,
0.0174136274,
-0.0159384962,
0.0284133758,
-0.0127642285,
-0.0073525067,
-0.0077181971,
-0.012053147,
0.0213634782,
0.029918462,
-0.0765869245,
0.0048727388,
0.0024229109,
0.0222881828,
-0.0282691158,
0.031670358,
-0.0438008457,
-0.0220137183,
-0.0789274722,
-0.0076592565,
0.0306892768,
-0.0362244174,
-0.0296280254,
-0.0036279175,
-0.0203992892,
-0.0348354653,
-0.0065442887,
0.0256110895,
0.0299930852,
-0.0017203296,
0.0305103566,
-0.0061406936,
-0.0147533109,
0.0600223057,
0.0412975289,
0.0337418839,
-0.0293853711,
-0.0758432671,
-0.0183570385,
-0.015464318,
0.0576734841,
0.0686883181,
-0.0621903315,
-0.0087861111,
-0.0055318768,
0.004367575,
0.025319377,
-0.0171273425,
-0.0027446654,
0.0148020852,
0.0998195261,
0.0952721983,
0.0089399051,
-0.0033144543,
-0.0308922101,
-0.0051535419,
-0.0029992743,
0.0016707934,
-0.0112446649,
-5.394589695e-33,
-0.0057513844,
0.0213946346,
0.0082159378,
-0.0017605776,
-0.0025264681,
0.0181232505,
0.0162725803,
-0.0384424888,
-0.0338841528,
-0.0325697809,
-0.0338963829,
0.0191294625,
0.0085985204,
0.0049489248,
-0.0382694937,
-0.0009065609,
0.0329918116,
0.0165658295,
-0.0321830176,
0.0260513015,
0.0139772203,
0.0545512885,
0.0412036926,
-0.0504571274,
0.0011798892,
-0.0362360403,
-0.0139329024,
0.021098461,
0.0466975383,
0.0848798528,
-0.0038369994,
0.0049568224,
0.0415780582,
-0.0091064805,
0.0008462039,
0.0278642885,
-0.0714500919,
-0.0148462225,
0.0296238661,
0.0226390306,
0.0011688902,
0.023383474,
0.0188627075,
-0.0382560417,
0.0013265818,
0.0394004174,
0.065494515,
-0.0176161546,
-0.0286192317,
-0.0759316534,
-0.0405198224,
0.0166989919,
0.0118279895,
-0.0083734477,
0.0523629412,
0.0553665757,
-0.0095659522,
0.0589812137,
0.0128547894,
0.0393609479,
-0.0286383498,
0.0627164319,
0.0491475463,
0.026231423,
-0.0041580596,
0.0283962898,
-0.0072036283,
-0.0000182745,
0.0307222027,
-0.028012475,
0.0333368219,
0.0119756944,
0.0161892101,
0.024871625,
0.028328469,
0.0225435644,
-0.0357002802,
0.0862771273,
0.0178323239,
-0.0072469949,
-0.0098175127,
0.030845033,
-0.0444657952,
-0.0310999174,
-0.013688609,
0.0312656835,
-0.0624393187,
-0.0049328865,
0.0337941647,
0.0051699756,
-0.0026846167,
0.0000062489,
0.0273180716,
-0.033614777,
-0.0285330191,
-0.0030498123,
0.0043196226,
-0.0102972602,
0.0013493259,
0.019853849,
-0.029824039,
-0.0557728931,
0.0106436694,
-0.079497233,
-0.0589182004,
-0.0329796746,
0.0141327698,
0.0073100184,
-0.0299798828,
0.001590909,
0.0382144637,
-0.0621645898,
-0.0189841297,
0.010059013,
0.0181641541,
0.0381679647,
0.0102049448,
0.0496017896,
0.0718234926,
-0.0000528527,
-0.0340590104,
-0.0661219507,
0.0386856236,
0.0297741368,
0.0024732274,
0.0275186058,
-0.0613388009,
0.0112150833,
0.0016524001,
-0.0574980453,
-0.0215106606,
0.032102216,
2.461e-7,
0.0713222921,
0.0521270931,
-0.0320864618,
-0.0038847013,
0.0027015859,
0.0019221624,
0.0152583811,
0.0515117534,
0.0029404301,
0.045528695,
0.0511507429,
-0.0145248706,
0.0171728823,
-0.0139976162,
-0.0438413471,
-0.0262482967,
-0.0574326999,
-0.0278711021,
-0.0474513136,
-0.0012298863,
0.0294249356,
0.0884283483,
0.004064566,
-0.0099369315,
-0.0053125792,
-0.0548671409,
0.0486195534,
-0.0076568853,
0.0116233295,
0.043624565,
0.0076694773,
0.0296098534,
-0.0210706051,
-0.0067885662,
-0.0090732528,
0.0510035791,
0.0552054271,
0.0427585877,
-0.0239334926,
-0.0030188777,
-0.0098991646,
-0.052580528,
-0.0003352547,
-0.0253211781,
0.0621831007,
0.0184266008,
-0.000076183,
0.0003621257,
-0.0453708842,
-0.0070997416,
0.0009439521,
-0.0504239537,
-0.0388917327,
0.0201844145,
0.0464770719,
0.0085028652,
-0.0295741353,
-0.0822394937,
-0.0050885342,
0.0003848193,
-0.0271232333,
-0.0222008955,
-0.0517827123,
0.0244709775,
0.0416425094,
-0.03969891,
0.0181731693,
2.28527719e-34,
0.0216200985,
0.0269386955,
-0.0321395062,
0.0223944504,
0.0049958453,
-0.0086048115,
0.0179953035,
0.0156320799,
0.0379812941,
-0.0938745588,
-0.0040512872
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07706v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07706v3 | Exploring Transfer Learning in Medical Image Segmentation using Vision-Language Models | 2023-08-15T11:28:21 | 2024-06-20T09:14:54 | Kanchan Poudel, Manish Dhakal, Prasiddha Bhandari, Rabin Adhikari, Safal Thapaliya, Bishesh Khanal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Medical image segmentation allows quantifying target structure size and
shape, aiding in disease diagnosis, prognosis, surgery planning, and
comprehension.Building upon recent advancements in foundation Vision-Language
Models (VLMs) from natural image-text pairs, several studies have proposed
adapting them to Vision-Language Segmentation Models (VLSMs) that allow using
language text as an additional input to segmentation models. Introducing
auxiliary information via text with human-in-the-loop prompting during
inference opens up unique opportunities, such as open vocabulary segmentation
and potentially more robust segmentation models against out-of-distribution
data. Although transfer learning from natural to medical images has been
explored for image-only segmentation models, the joint representation of
vision-language in segmentation problems remains underexplored. This study
introduces the first systematic study on transferring VLSMs to 2D medical
images, using carefully curated $11$ datasets encompassing diverse modalities
and insightful language prompts and experiments. Our findings demonstrate that
although VLSMs show competitive performance compared to image-only models for
segmentation after finetuning in limited medical image datasets, not all VLSMs
utilize the additional information from language prompts, with image features
playing a dominant role. While VLSMs exhibit enhanced performance in handling
pooled datasets with diverse modalities and show potential robustness to domain
shifts compared to conventional segmentation models, our results suggest that
novel approaches are required to enable VLSMs to leverage the various auxiliary
information available through language prompts. The code and datasets are
available at https://github.com/naamiinepal/medvlsm. | [
0.0282125995,
0.0747983903,
0.0094699878,
0.0092883538,
-0.0457245931,
0.037667606,
-0.0010108715,
0.0236148965,
-0.032517314,
-0.0212542638,
-0.0229103751,
-0.0461076498,
0.0290014334,
0.0493029132,
-0.0094130617,
-0.1289323717,
0.0023223532,
-0.0529269055,
-0.0047314544,
0.0014877578,
-0.0233771969,
-0.0080847237,
-0.0026341551,
0.0131045636,
0.0054088566,
0.0362107493,
0.0285188928,
0.0178833585,
0.0318133011,
-0.0289163664,
-0.036136236,
0.0460743681,
0.0258415118,
-0.0273244642,
0.0000020255,
-0.057021711,
-0.0060835239,
0.0304509196,
0.0007705416,
-0.0392917469,
0.0785464719,
-0.0811361521,
-0.0153935831,
-0.0566502437,
-0.012523504,
-0.0260958355,
0.0576051511,
0.0514500141,
0.0568779148,
0.0411242843,
-0.0217952393,
-0.017516762,
0.0424678698,
-0.0176554974,
0.0154586388,
-0.0363354757,
0.0609062426,
0.0088325813,
-0.0349196345,
-0.0020694016,
-0.0040253541,
0.0507294424,
-0.0094189681,
-0.0068543046,
0.0131785143,
0.0652132109,
-0.0071770744,
-0.0560257621,
-0.0232853852,
0.0728575364,
-0.0348293036,
0.0048377351,
0.0114086857,
-0.0212006122,
-0.0034289055,
0.0397639051,
-0.0612396859,
0.0378829576,
-0.00317545,
0.0189616736,
-0.0405481197,
-0.0038378087,
0.0434937403,
0.0044514085,
-0.0152200041,
0.011869167,
0.0224303398,
0.0348119438,
0.0421970636,
0.0237496253,
-0.0399143435,
-0.0418388769,
0.0270708334,
0.021795148,
-0.0105691561,
0.0094220517,
-0.0650542676,
-0.0227471236,
0.0227218978,
-0.0090724416,
0.0299750511,
-0.0393757336,
-0.0685174093,
0.0815234706,
-0.0248393621,
0.0008411665,
-0.0311412439,
0.0983833522,
-0.0544920079,
-0.0203491058,
0.0102033857,
0.0033584998,
-0.0114405975,
-0.0182241015,
0.0195763409,
-0.0128635485,
-0.017714195,
-0.0132574188,
-0.0182431545,
-0.0095662884,
0.0134486696,
0.0311525166,
-0.0309794359,
-0.0255763419,
-0.0274518002,
-0.0122829396,
0.0263375789,
0.0179856941,
-0.0219904073,
-0.0340652838,
0.0068082442,
0.0344203897,
-0.0068214484,
-0.0303494353,
0.0090301596,
0.0753458738,
-0.0359785855,
-0.0094195446,
0.0064245588,
-0.0027838286,
-0.0239503197,
-0.0219593272,
0.0820194855,
-0.0673302859,
-0.006016654,
0.0077414745,
0.0310099926,
-0.0240340568,
-0.0090220515,
0.007157885,
-0.0493955202,
0.095729351,
-0.0487671271,
-0.0032433644,
0.0269579533,
0.0225840285,
0.0336332917,
0.0476175584,
0.0395761244,
-0.0213924684,
0.0170847215,
-0.0193794481,
0.009723003,
0.0346159302,
-0.0105318902,
-0.0058279177,
-0.0861378983,
-0.0243760943,
0.0248031989,
0.0419069566,
0.0192423742,
0.0682687908,
0.0058918144,
-0.0482347421,
0.0245370083,
0.0809015483,
0.0126720192,
0.0106107853,
0.034214586,
-0.0135363629,
-0.0023840033,
-0.0143892309,
-0.0150676025,
0.0075591872,
0.027153952,
0.0019757943,
-0.0483600497,
0.0109362528,
-0.0059358454,
-0.0411215425,
-0.0327423252,
-0.024043845,
0.0366095118,
-0.0061253491,
0.0826158822,
0.0298439171,
-0.0211092755,
0.0297895316,
0.0379627421,
-0.0213715304,
-0.0192025565,
-0.0656882674,
-0.0038666166,
0.0311624669,
0.0170506015,
-0.0459516197,
-0.0109136635,
0.0277119465,
0.0658797249,
0.0237947218,
0.0154977823,
0.0173854884,
0.0344788656,
-0.0375311673,
-0.0233629476,
0.0492910407,
0.030342428,
-0.0489368364,
-0.0015992052,
0.0129075944,
0.0098173441,
-0.0577142388,
0.0099187596,
0.0573620275,
0.0082444558,
0.0269211493,
-0.0151152527,
-0.0067414609,
-0.0147066452,
-0.0465273745,
-0.016573526,
-0.0071500586,
0.003874382,
-0.0009950916,
0.0062843096,
-0.0056951782,
-0.081784904,
-0.0098753134,
0.0109269656,
-0.04771889,
-0.0171303786,
-0.0281989016,
-0.0559384972,
0.0121206632,
-0.0065352772,
-0.0170174744,
-0.0239218865,
-0.0003222258,
0.0051975329,
0.0265435912,
0.0005503271,
-0.0527109616,
0.0328962989,
-0.0177882425,
-0.0342076607,
0.0106383627,
-0.0287733264,
-0.0373228006,
-0.017819766,
0.0090200203,
0.0225289166,
-0.0163653325,
-0.0020767516,
-0.0258851722,
0.0352596529,
-0.0350899659,
-0.0027404388,
-0.0556877553,
-0.0454871058,
0.0078066676,
-0.0333054289,
0.018667018,
0.0067415303,
-0.0198405981,
-0.017444415,
0.000769959,
0.058255244,
0.0127965361,
0.0016859507,
0.0625805929,
-0.0030013169,
0.0202248488,
-0.028672047,
-0.0061466829,
0.0222134646,
0.0277847797,
0.0429110676,
-0.0706214234,
-0.0105530135,
0.0381710939,
-0.0253473539,
0.0073991157,
-0.0160791706,
0.0074290046,
0.0060606287,
-0.0538460463,
-0.0206432976,
0.0892559066,
-0.0061546289,
0.0284872223,
0.0248400401,
-0.0155042717,
0.034403041,
-0.0282801203,
-0.0192142949,
-0.044606436,
-0.0086695775,
-0.0559136309,
0.0080874953,
0.0703045353,
-0.0067923642,
-0.0066538742,
-0.0192970466,
-0.0141242687,
-0.0374241881,
0.005025133,
-0.0598618127,
0.0320338458,
-0.0426747315,
0.0565024875,
-0.0299471486,
-0.0897960067,
0.0736171827,
-0.0064468458,
0.0210661292,
-0.0208482295,
-0.0242195725,
-0.0263529141,
-0.0026361491,
0.0331511907,
0.0039677969,
0.0445661731,
0.0203078371,
-0.0490971468,
0.0253310744,
-0.017266782,
-0.0324252248,
0.0691093728,
-0.0639412329,
0.0108567839,
-0.0014307863,
-0.012807562,
-0.0159696452,
0.0336051732,
-0.031096993,
0.0257708952,
-0.0277037583,
0.0117401248,
-0.0346588977,
0.0236468818,
0.0096064266,
0.0742855221,
0.0162786786,
-0.0132014826,
-0.0041524046,
0.038122423,
0.0363519937,
0.0262745041,
-0.058100976,
-0.0487083271,
0.0196586102,
0.0514702052,
0.0150063774,
0.0025941031,
-0.019887859,
0.0366932414,
0.0139851337,
0.0425524339,
0.0018231088,
0.0523421988,
0.0631952435,
-0.0340818129,
-0.0361591503,
0.0638471469,
0.0271152649,
-0.0372471102,
-0.0276487153,
-0.0105903009,
-0.0020928716,
-0.0030593791,
-0.0197702423,
-0.0360417441,
-0.0432662405,
0.0125014586,
0.014548636,
0.0135245435,
-0.025733199,
-0.0156143,
-0.034588486,
0.0676842704,
0.0212980341,
-0.0763971731,
-0.0140715158,
-0.0360666215,
0.0445092916,
-0.0480436981,
-0.0568381362,
-0.0628427267,
-0.0486054569,
-0.0253494512,
-0.0013488905,
-0.0394462794,
-0.0391261987,
0.0049239802,
-0.0150743434,
-0.0323249735,
0.0751832724,
0.0019536819,
-0.0204233546,
-0.0363724642,
0.0708539933,
-0.01119975,
0.0029057984,
-0.0283061825,
0.0858789608,
0.0121435346,
0.0074546165,
-0.0005379368,
0.0461800545,
0.0068659121,
-0.0393778533,
-0.0158407912,
0.0810383931,
0.0069595068,
-0.0436074138,
-0.0739075765,
0.0204980504,
0.0144857513,
0.0312551185,
-0.0158076659,
-0.0288423635,
-0.0113904672,
-0.0070073176,
0.0372523256,
-0.0000929485,
-0.0268194526,
0.0107513191,
-0.0319772102,
-0.0394008458,
-0.0649858564,
0.0095374184,
0.0599320494,
0.0062930384,
0.0258719418,
-0.0075626168,
0.0193164088,
-0.0160151739,
-0.0597496964,
0.0666498244,
-0.028850507,
0.0201074928,
-0.051030688,
-0.048101183,
0.0318954214,
-0.0257764645,
-0.0200245697,
0.0138514247,
-0.0776744038,
-0.0050571682,
-0.0159106348,
0.0906277746,
0.0116020227,
0.0066003753,
-0.0137010468,
-0.0192458183,
0.0639128238,
0.0426032282,
-0.0193415787,
-0.0191464406,
0.0170222986,
-0.0047115707,
-0.0061505539,
0.008368209,
-0.0061849393,
0.0066717369,
0.0348839536,
-0.0131264674,
-0.0318612792,
-0.0400798433,
-0.0120752295,
0.0020150687,
0.0861485079,
-0.0106575219,
-0.0079465574,
-0.0198879093,
0.0129334517,
0.0010029183,
0.0081667481,
-0.0565911047,
0.0133034205,
0.0326943286,
0.0404166542,
-0.0017194869,
-0.0083849393,
-0.0256214403,
-0.0209925883,
-0.0342371576,
0.0329910517,
0.0650142282,
0.0241212398,
0.0515738726,
-0.0015959468,
0.0306525175,
-0.0195126254,
-0.0077501829,
0.0239941459,
0.0182351898,
0.060821753,
0.0165612735,
0.0352340527,
-0.0218101051,
0.0549690835,
-0.0303685628,
-0.0494180769,
-0.0440173633,
0.0464405306,
-0.0150692286,
-0.0267143231,
0.0063863508,
-0.0096561769,
-0.0023005537,
-0.0406275243,
0.0533291623,
-0.0166831017,
-0.0208787713,
0.0922770798,
0.0033663723,
0.0068270755,
-0.0092240237,
0.059461724,
0.011193214,
0.0126302764,
-0.0127412006,
-0.0172517709,
-0.0396756381,
-0.0061534089,
0.0168058667,
-0.0253518634,
-0.0347800218,
0.0564359501,
-0.0213532597,
-0.072432965,
0.0104083437,
-0.0349568352,
0.0053827637,
0.0184439067,
0.0696497336,
0.0778957605,
-0.0299019013,
-0.026797764,
0.0036427523,
0.009111586,
0.0115254167,
-0.0258203335,
0.0445473567,
-6.003288588e-33,
-0.0143209687,
-0.0143673066,
0.0361202918,
-0.0142642763,
-0.0044439756,
0.0109680202,
-0.046971973,
0.0176819414,
0.0030831364,
0.0514615737,
-0.0002077259,
-0.0347481258,
0.022840606,
0.0525475964,
-0.0224350691,
-0.0381397046,
0.0072323778,
0.0087623186,
-0.0287147742,
0.0036053893,
-0.0343317129,
0.0256708283,
0.0702067986,
-0.0572860055,
-0.0155094387,
0.0520049371,
0.0188059397,
0.0277508497,
0.015913073,
0.018602265,
-0.0282275379,
0.0137714669,
0.0229806472,
-0.0167746153,
-0.0347997434,
0.0219755452,
-0.0664213225,
-0.0137725333,
0.0253946334,
0.0236711875,
-0.0795545354,
0.0074599022,
0.0420043394,
-0.0303369276,
0.0308011565,
-0.0370321795,
0.0584688149,
-0.0506721102,
-0.0198328197,
0.0251334701,
-0.0419208519,
0.0494034626,
0.0009164839,
-0.0119137298,
0.049401246,
-0.0243103784,
-0.0004339716,
0.0307233017,
0.0000820912,
0.0268175434,
0.0590777174,
0.0031201583,
0.0631550029,
0.0317261033,
-0.0507727712,
0.0530383475,
0.0266481582,
-0.0958367661,
-0.0153750796,
0.0136227515,
-0.0192251876,
0.0836095586,
0.0511251539,
0.0062658731,
-0.0082154861,
0.0193231665,
-0.0687767714,
0.0290214457,
-0.1293789595,
0.0512548797,
-0.0033495126,
-0.0138192689,
0.0103950119,
-0.0293498952,
-0.0002777032,
-0.0381787382,
-0.0134610301,
0.0219508633,
0.0215761457,
-0.011427871,
-0.0262938812,
0.0357627235,
0.0312297605,
0.0132826129,
-0.0222394466,
-0.0154634053,
0.0056734495,
0.0400997885,
-0.0381568745,
-0.0212397631,
-0.0786338374,
-0.0240521803,
0.0560498945,
0.0152601209,
0.0384886116,
0.0117339017,
0.0188153721,
-0.0256439205,
-0.034204293,
-0.0215794183,
-0.030789841,
-0.0352821909,
-0.0058178194,
0.0727912188,
0.0514043607,
0.0177096184,
-0.0531247966,
0.0621877052,
-0.03056393,
-0.0795432031,
-0.0275167618,
-0.0167296305,
-0.0237501673,
0.0052511692,
-0.0644178391,
-0.0124647031,
-0.0155101772,
-0.0292809308,
0.064219147,
-0.0543401204,
-0.0336310975,
0.0310503431,
2.722e-7,
0.0853226036,
0.0450455286,
0.0007378408,
-0.0311365575,
-0.0070844726,
0.0359641053,
-0.0428215638,
0.0041612042,
0.0082921088,
-0.0332818143,
0.0190163571,
0.0728316084,
0.0404998399,
0.0171991792,
-0.0123403249,
0.0263804067,
-0.0226245932,
-0.0158144124,
-0.016389342,
-0.021651987,
0.0368915386,
0.0346863419,
-0.0317235701,
-0.0576050133,
0.0327574164,
-0.0514629073,
0.0309374109,
-0.0992565677,
0.0524789207,
-0.0040668384,
-0.019490825,
0.0170836188,
-0.0069520487,
0.0624149404,
0.0035572706,
-0.0552661344,
0.0672050118,
0.0457271077,
-0.0187880918,
0.0326830037,
-0.0106938975,
0.0352968872,
0.0256297924,
-0.0663699657,
0.070810996,
-0.0658532232,
-0.0088198464,
-0.0208272673,
0.0423620418,
0.0095260032,
0.0434959307,
-0.0230756477,
-0.0508733131,
0.0364089869,
0.0580138154,
0.0470845848,
-0.0690312609,
-0.0453834683,
-0.0256773513,
-0.0009204015,
-0.0295994896,
-0.0452189744,
-0.0065021473,
0.0139355492,
-0.0121676307,
-0.0416129977,
-0.0062137032,
2.17338574e-34,
0.0259975623,
0.0072141248,
-0.0077074999,
0.0267142635,
0.0120130992,
0.0186879002,
-0.0000845435,
0.022623416,
-0.0421367288,
-0.031125078,
0.0148605565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07702v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07702v2 | Better Zero-Shot Reasoning with Role-Play Prompting | 2023-08-15T11:08:30 | 2024-03-14T02:07:11 | Aobo Kong, Shiwan Zhao, Hao Chen, Qicheng Li, Yong Qin, Ruiqi Sun, Xin Zhou, Enzhi Wang, Xiaohang Dong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Modern large language models (LLMs) exhibit a remarkable capacity for
role-playing, enabling them to embody not only human characters but also
non-human entities. This versatility allows them to simulate complex human-like
interactions and behaviors within various contexts, as well as to emulate
specific objects or systems. While these capabilities have enhanced user
engagement and introduced novel modes of interaction, the influence of
role-playing on LLMs' reasoning abilities remains underexplored. In this study,
we introduce a strategically designed role-play prompting methodology and
assess its performance under the zero-shot setting across twelve diverse
reasoning benchmarks. Our empirical results illustrate that role-play prompting
consistently surpasses the standard zero-shot approach across most datasets.
Notably, in experiments conducted using ChatGPT, accuracy on AQuA rises from
53.5% to 63.8%, and on Last Letter from 23.8% to 84.2%.Upon further comparison
with the Zero-Shot-CoT technique, which prompts the model to "think step by
step", our study demonstrates that role-play prompting acts as a more effective
trigger for the CoT process. This highlights its potential to augment the
reasoning capabilities of LLMs. We release our code at
https://github.com/NKU-HLT/Role-Play-Prompting. | [
0.0191987976,
-0.0056068604,
-0.0219677184,
0.0571047738,
-0.0491256602,
0.0039148736,
0.0345675424,
-0.0037272796,
0.0034341053,
-0.0339632966,
-0.0374941379,
-0.0728552043,
-0.0036219035,
0.0432008132,
0.0280876681,
-0.043365702,
0.0573239401,
-0.0530651696,
0.0333228298,
-0.0033316901,
-0.0274205841,
0.0080708293,
-0.039909035,
0.0489509441,
0.0261441115,
-0.0140593508,
-0.0426931977,
0.0035547768,
0.0193804968,
-0.0318982005,
-0.0010083114,
0.0527367257,
0.0342295915,
0.0550533421,
0.0000022119,
-0.0568974763,
0.0354577713,
-0.0191389918,
-0.0523041263,
-0.0147322929,
-0.00474222,
0.0279607568,
-0.0029830358,
0.0088569,
-0.0352335162,
-0.0011203323,
0.0416644476,
0.0240666941,
0.0598746948,
0.0617666915,
-0.01001608,
-0.0135614229,
-0.0281476825,
-0.0004121127,
0.0815849602,
-0.0564257391,
-0.007605515,
0.0298068989,
0.0978603661,
0.0015633457,
-0.0025438354,
0.0336899087,
0.0507989191,
-0.0283055715,
-0.030527683,
0.0704342946,
-0.0327697322,
-0.0159374923,
0.0130849732,
0.0735173225,
0.0224911161,
-0.0228817556,
0.0034893155,
0.0170187466,
0.016478315,
0.0261144768,
-0.0370269269,
0.0124249971,
0.0283166021,
-0.0059375693,
-0.0145872533,
0.0288233794,
0.0353669785,
0.0237118769,
-0.0194706805,
0.0559274629,
-0.0054118759,
-0.0366760381,
-0.0307092648,
0.004957953,
-0.0097711086,
-0.0583466552,
-0.0318355374,
0.0634974316,
-0.0706028864,
0.0270819217,
-0.0345520452,
0.0366774388,
0.0156332199,
-0.0007686687,
0.042106729,
0.0648619607,
-0.0152076073,
0.0820087865,
-0.0168137103,
0.0342345573,
0.0111117,
0.0231957715,
0.0039138324,
0.0244288221,
-0.0637118146,
-0.051506158,
-0.0399483889,
0.0242121946,
-0.0139422836,
-0.0282564927,
-0.007109819,
0.0130365593,
-0.0164058339,
0.0254048984,
0.0071047307,
0.0260982495,
0.0067305858,
-0.0150469588,
-0.0317609906,
0.0298030563,
-0.0595624484,
0.0015825988,
0.0233543161,
-0.0635171756,
-0.0249669235,
-0.0285975132,
-0.0004251504,
-0.0319003239,
-0.0020923854,
0.0512617081,
-0.0107104927,
-0.0461116284,
-0.0051542022,
-0.0353833623,
-0.0016138008,
-0.0968287066,
-0.0110639185,
-0.0531440824,
0.0262848679,
-0.0124613456,
-0.0265703481,
0.0098903636,
0.0049787126,
0.0261047017,
-0.0064760819,
0.0996138752,
-0.0046149115,
0.0085434569,
-0.0127155948,
0.0446159504,
-0.0219503958,
0.0872953981,
0.041107256,
-0.0242867693,
-0.0085549122,
-0.006724698,
0.0133201424,
0.0345536768,
-0.0122419726,
-0.0317258388,
0.0245222226,
-0.005935288,
-0.0220128968,
0.0498387478,
0.0172500815,
0.0127032623,
-0.0651412681,
-0.0204604361,
0.0574524179,
0.0550934821,
-0.0149165625,
-0.0292199757,
0.0523050912,
0.0100350194,
0.0228415132,
-0.0199535657,
-0.067383334,
0.0609304234,
-0.0139700714,
0.0080660749,
-0.0364699997,
0.0036440545,
-0.0424460024,
-0.0071442155,
0.0041478151,
0.0099106412,
0.0040311664,
0.0094018215,
0.0148489131,
0.0163998269,
-0.0365187824,
0.0291973576,
0.0082324967,
-0.0448830649,
-0.0141988778,
-0.0877128541,
0.0497327149,
0.0955071449,
0.0706390068,
-0.0307576433,
-0.0654695705,
0.0059215282,
0.0126058748,
0.0465675704,
0.0059740921,
-0.0016928796,
-0.0143475384,
-0.0343861841,
0.0132644819,
-0.0177484117,
0.0122206137,
0.0264859814,
0.0135921119,
0.0048099542,
0.0002483206,
0.006411884,
0.0512554571,
0.0068558916,
-0.0226533879,
-0.0268194079,
-0.0417691953,
0.0112291034,
-0.0008454487,
0.0007279884,
0.0119618243,
-0.0051247119,
0.0062470008,
-0.0023871798,
-0.0080766547,
0.0302899033,
-0.0873044059,
-0.0448890924,
0.0344895124,
-0.0037179303,
-0.0508485921,
0.0074965456,
-0.0139136687,
-0.0244958606,
0.0139768338,
-0.006541369,
0.0256496556,
-0.0365864001,
0.0158082396,
-0.0120364707,
0.0019982471,
-0.0136979986,
0.0752096623,
0.0062099257,
0.0096656876,
0.0385834835,
0.0373183265,
-0.0109399268,
-0.0494775102,
-0.0260361731,
0.0115035642,
-0.018434817,
-0.0223574806,
-0.0089726513,
-0.0054238043,
-0.0749359652,
-0.004404468,
-0.0959751979,
-0.0173806231,
-0.0081563089,
-0.0043220171,
0.0154426657,
0.0153149404,
-0.0286323018,
0.0106675066,
-0.0191812776,
-0.0252660606,
0.0099472981,
0.0182965659,
0.0246532187,
-0.0100838281,
-0.0213771332,
-0.0197962858,
0.0164320506,
-0.0296547636,
0.044414755,
0.0013318063,
0.0344101787,
-0.0229638573,
0.0172002222,
-0.016254615,
-0.006793722,
-0.0220917407,
-0.0119727673,
0.0584864542,
-0.0104725752,
-0.0017270568,
0.0659081414,
-0.0206845235,
0.0103220949,
0.0305954572,
-0.0226448346,
-0.0649105385,
0.0315588564,
0.020178536,
-0.0124105085,
-0.0335728563,
-0.0237964597,
-0.0247260723,
0.0958579928,
-0.0431614816,
0.0209504552,
-0.0737386867,
0.0339203812,
0.0171917267,
-0.0499428697,
-0.0077144527,
-0.0156481639,
-0.03777593,
0.0211303812,
-0.0489140451,
-0.0063001076,
0.0646067485,
-0.0327141508,
-0.0469446667,
-0.0120111154,
0.0550070666,
0.0003015427,
0.0990451425,
-0.0041189054,
-0.0173335485,
0.0134744747,
-0.0211672597,
-0.0269057751,
-0.0285483859,
0.0276061166,
-0.0240255035,
0.0316085108,
-0.0403807648,
0.010653751,
-0.0052649584,
-0.0186536014,
-0.0450204425,
-0.0198680088,
-0.0582453422,
0.0263354313,
-0.0403349958,
-0.0348174125,
-0.0182331763,
-0.0098100379,
0.0214859527,
0.0247096568,
-0.0112615079,
-0.0219271481,
-0.0331869498,
0.0089771328,
0.047346618,
0.0314246714,
-0.0088534085,
-0.0036508462,
0.0858799815,
0.0627065375,
0.0006935517,
-0.0132197738,
-0.0359084196,
0.0111250188,
0.0136540178,
-0.0083149699,
-0.011180697,
0.0260400698,
0.0651782602,
-0.0762656033,
-0.0192536749,
0.1402240098,
0.0437575839,
-0.0293798111,
0.0081354054,
-0.0489602424,
0.069569096,
0.0279038884,
0.0217456091,
-0.1001532599,
-0.0535686985,
0.0407673605,
-0.0253385641,
-0.0213437937,
-0.0618833192,
-0.0080742296,
-0.1374736577,
0.054759264,
-0.017153386,
-0.0118855676,
0.0203495752,
-0.0274677761,
0.0246188007,
0.0086148763,
0.0288940165,
0.0358127467,
0.0119591383,
-0.0118033672,
-0.0034842279,
-0.0028124196,
-0.0455350615,
0.0836385787,
-0.0301722921,
0.0923734382,
0.0489604138,
0.043214906,
0.0126936594,
-0.0261390898,
-0.0140605606,
0.0272046868,
0.0250174161,
0.0014459254,
0.0354803503,
-0.0079108346,
-0.0075263972,
-0.0187455565,
0.036032021,
-0.0136455232,
-0.0562258326,
-0.0053384993,
0.0975479931,
-0.0279623903,
-0.0389920734,
-0.0156819504,
0.0167955421,
0.0022851725,
0.0705907494,
0.020380443,
-0.0341530219,
-0.0268709175,
0.0093004722,
-0.0485417172,
-0.0488979183,
-0.0748799518,
-0.0426510721,
0.0356546901,
-0.0029838912,
-0.0508856475,
-0.0509626344,
0.0713911876,
0.0508738272,
-0.0287292767,
-0.0170601252,
-0.0301918387,
0.0197953079,
-0.0038342106,
0.0152414385,
-0.0709519833,
0.0643021166,
-0.0159257613,
-0.0070213433,
0.0105882473,
-0.0513640493,
-0.0032377345,
-0.0137858819,
-0.05498337,
-0.0679945573,
-0.0036925052,
0.0530073568,
0.037699461,
0.0210941769,
-0.0196902752,
-0.0485605188,
0.0219115615,
0.0491850898,
-0.03571181,
-0.0012022785,
0.0164213274,
-0.0088162012,
0.0132776573,
0.0245102625,
-0.0109426668,
0.0064147059,
-0.0200770199,
0.0502084456,
-0.0533985905,
0.0026584517,
0.0121869864,
0.0078515289,
0.0418460779,
-0.0163646881,
0.032664597,
-0.0090876454,
0.0201453771,
-0.0565228201,
0.000066709,
-0.0182291549,
-0.0049778684,
0.0165554099,
0.000807681,
0.0111284163,
-0.0352598578,
-0.0390748754,
-0.0016017883,
0.0100339456,
0.0128422678,
0.0352200605,
0.0210208595,
0.0264766347,
0.0005746499,
-0.0076079736,
0.021254098,
-0.0163816437,
0.0510586463,
-0.012386186,
0.0595922545,
0.0308468323,
-0.0171215478,
-0.0306823961,
0.0199319571,
-0.0715821311,
-0.0451567508,
0.0565041043,
0.0536042079,
0.0508085042,
-0.0230098497,
-0.0023814526,
-0.0567209013,
0.0159501284,
0.0228493921,
-0.0011669681,
0.0309723187,
-0.0577545762,
0.0194234028,
0.0550518781,
-0.000766271,
-0.0181706809,
0.0400826074,
-0.0102520445,
0.0480075628,
0.0011045695,
0.013948503,
-0.0078832572,
-0.0370412953,
-0.0029725146,
0.0218666103,
-0.037646167,
-0.0024504669,
-0.0931787491,
-0.0754368678,
-0.0143479733,
0.0362824574,
-0.0086691128,
-0.0154514462,
0.0163611509,
0.0268139075,
0.0170166604,
-0.0097800978,
-0.0068231011,
-0.0026768937,
-0.0102881202,
-0.0065270802,
-0.0324450769,
-6.190929078e-33,
-0.0187207814,
-0.0171416868,
0.0552751608,
0.0007674896,
-0.0388246924,
0.0000646188,
-0.0690307394,
0.031653326,
-0.0034876475,
0.027249841,
-0.0360448211,
0.0020805667,
0.0158630498,
-0.0044575958,
0.0053721117,
-0.0459551141,
0.017637454,
0.004231886,
-0.0294686817,
-0.0010127587,
0.0095993849,
-0.0112813395,
0.0073831677,
-0.0351491496,
0.0256804843,
-0.0101673594,
-0.0187454503,
0.0343179516,
-0.0460476577,
0.039904803,
0.0029322917,
0.0091415755,
0.027924329,
-0.0007316932,
-0.0001732357,
0.0302219521,
-0.0524118468,
-0.0334540904,
0.0534232147,
0.0006543545,
-0.0638492703,
-0.0234237425,
-0.0177443381,
-0.0060052965,
-0.0096280687,
-0.0248031188,
-0.0006122685,
-0.0051973797,
-0.0048040161,
0.0200229622,
-0.0787661374,
-0.0107390136,
-0.024842415,
-0.0629455224,
0.0377497114,
0.0628655031,
-0.011660791,
-0.0076693264,
-0.0569522679,
0.0238943361,
-0.0213964526,
0.0078149373,
0.064710781,
0.0564627796,
0.0082800407,
0.0730034634,
0.0220279749,
0.0257677957,
-0.1092786863,
-0.0054893591,
0.0476151817,
0.0609752014,
0.0335194245,
0.0231004432,
0.052016668,
0.0117827337,
-0.019392034,
0.004782815,
0.0313020721,
0.0548831522,
0.0490337275,
0.0049726227,
-0.0499443226,
-0.0083469413,
-0.0372788832,
0.0243996195,
-0.0289122779,
-0.0555729233,
0.0255895052,
-0.0054834126,
-0.0199643299,
-0.0042641419,
0.0346553065,
-0.0344237238,
0.0022749789,
0.00475128,
0.0053354576,
0.0443829447,
-0.0216371901,
0.0193082839,
-0.0340589918,
-0.0262274444,
0.0362859517,
0.0238891654,
0.0234502424,
0.0403240807,
0.0353820473,
0.0314436443,
-0.0270953737,
-0.0296379756,
-0.0586393327,
0.033902023,
-0.0094564119,
0.0036279582,
0.008440082,
-0.0024335796,
-0.0244750902,
-0.0025397544,
0.0011367621,
-0.0389509946,
-0.035167519,
0.0600512139,
-0.0419143476,
-0.0131339645,
-0.019828761,
0.0026604384,
-0.0744644329,
0.0232738946,
0.0058244462,
-0.0513284355,
-0.0105728591,
0.0044850241,
2.956e-7,
-0.0091939252,
0.0315685868,
0.0077134436,
0.0415486433,
0.012590142,
0.0443533026,
-0.0222097989,
-0.0045888084,
0.0535979569,
-0.0530121624,
0.027021857,
0.0591180846,
0.0291067753,
0.0236839578,
-0.1264798641,
-0.000842862,
-0.0389186628,
-0.0327929705,
-0.0352187604,
-0.008727272,
0.0577589162,
0.046550896,
0.0358516127,
-0.0285043772,
0.0535575747,
-0.0284107607,
0.0415333845,
-0.018632099,
0.0230406094,
0.0223221537,
0.0203379281,
-0.0077222278,
0.0229550358,
0.0292065553,
0.0014670028,
-0.0043715737,
-0.0316058546,
0.0235240255,
-0.0120158261,
0.0000181907,
-0.0452325977,
-0.0433583781,
0.0003750323,
-0.0597347952,
0.0951460451,
-0.0615920201,
-0.0273637436,
-0.0100542465,
-0.0263866242,
-0.0106483549,
-0.0086172782,
0.0008508329,
-0.0423816256,
0.0330304019,
0.0069904127,
-0.0311341565,
-0.0040558469,
-0.0888278484,
-0.0503524765,
-0.0166176949,
-0.0326776393,
-0.0167331528,
-0.0333870277,
-0.0179135818,
0.0331077799,
-0.0525104441,
0.0011077981,
2.565997868e-34,
0.014011181,
0.013929165,
0.0548158512,
0.0493921489,
0.0470255502,
0.0229848418,
0.0221239049,
0.0168661643,
0.0434456356,
-0.0490510799,
-0.0139120258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07661v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07661v2 | Attention Is Not All You Need Anymore | 2023-08-15T09:24:38 | 2023-09-19T13:32:07 | Zhe Chen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.NE | In recent years, the popular Transformer architecture has achieved great
success in many application areas, including natural language processing and
computer vision. Many existing works aim to reduce the computational and memory
complexity of the self-attention mechanism in the Transformer by trading off
performance. However, performance is key for the continuing success of the
Transformer. In this paper, a family of drop-in replacements for the
self-attention mechanism in the Transformer, called the Extractors, is
proposed. Four types of the Extractors, namely the super high-performance
Extractor (SHE), the higher-performance Extractor (HE), the worthwhile
Extractor (WE), and the minimalist Extractor (ME), are proposed as examples.
Experimental results show that replacing the self-attention mechanism with the
SHE evidently improves the performance of the Transformer, whereas the
simplified versions of the SHE, i.e., the HE, the WE, and the ME, perform close
to or better than the self-attention mechanism with less computational and
memory complexity. Furthermore, the proposed Extractors have the potential or
are able to run faster than the self-attention mechanism since their critical
paths of computation are much shorter. Additionally, the sequence prediction
problem in the context of text generation is formulated using variable-length
discrete-time Markov chains, and the Transformer is reviewed based on our
understanding. | [
0.0650144517,
0.0149818771,
-0.0073796059,
0.025387723,
-0.0572796986,
0.0017682868,
0.007325382,
0.000820051,
0.0061386605,
-0.0472719595,
-0.023883285,
-0.0219994001,
-0.0076092207,
0.0367231295,
0.0165076405,
-0.0557446592,
0.0423323363,
-0.0188061949,
0.0039479635,
0.0253565907,
-0.0190545861,
-0.0536780134,
0.0178830903,
-0.0032323024,
0.0088673094,
-0.0069152969,
-0.0426700935,
-0.0283393636,
0.016147742,
-0.0359764136,
-0.0201796517,
0.0379017964,
-0.0200620834,
0.0048259934,
0.0000020866,
-0.0086240964,
-0.0027749918,
0.0048898379,
0.0166849215,
-0.033607211,
-0.0075461022,
-0.0359841883,
-0.0316143408,
0.012145902,
-0.0264592059,
0.0055758934,
0.0784634501,
0.035618104,
0.0481906794,
0.0779309198,
-0.0208064076,
-0.0314112827,
0.0443318971,
-0.0179980975,
0.0219324883,
-0.0170009173,
0.0307172984,
-0.0529535078,
0.0091948751,
-0.0122742811,
-0.0202158932,
0.0288883168,
-0.0001946568,
-0.0024615179,
0.0022293187,
0.0481885001,
-0.0270205084,
-0.0505783819,
-0.0663863122,
0.0145477001,
-0.0417637117,
-0.0005346322,
0.050185997,
0.0109439027,
-0.026199704,
-0.0065017613,
-0.0272632651,
0.0562311187,
-0.0416664034,
0.0161821935,
0.0452562757,
0.0500129908,
-0.0214729365,
-0.0379809625,
-0.0428946242,
0.0187301431,
0.0010848106,
-0.0386765711,
0.0080781179,
0.0237577651,
0.0330978595,
-0.0624364242,
0.0403482653,
0.068055898,
0.0430861115,
0.0219435785,
-0.0702614188,
-0.0540357307,
-0.0217097197,
-0.0556059033,
0.0440807566,
0.0417043008,
0.0133227399,
0.0075455154,
-0.0361163914,
0.0484133065,
-0.0379138961,
-0.0185420625,
-0.0313564874,
0.0502699874,
-0.0109065659,
0.0074324152,
-0.0523654073,
0.0919882506,
-0.0073367525,
-0.0318505913,
-0.0392770097,
0.0299408641,
0.0179466009,
-0.0400680043,
0.0231589284,
0.0011313106,
-0.0936940908,
-0.0029942081,
-0.021066824,
0.044302199,
-0.0032921436,
-0.0576468632,
0.029660346,
-0.0649300292,
-0.0336209908,
0.029211292,
0.0360895135,
-0.0261786748,
-0.025593942,
0.0811293945,
-0.0337010957,
-0.0619787909,
-0.013425611,
0.002223582,
-0.016382426,
-0.0591156781,
0.0431724079,
-0.0303682983,
-0.0176341813,
0.0191882998,
-0.045210354,
0.0216098353,
0.0178492386,
0.0370166153,
-0.0086180903,
0.0034575018,
0.0278137438,
-0.035927359,
0.0162114259,
-0.0113015044,
0.0057061226,
0.013448487,
0.0176701043,
0.0855069235,
0.0015005828,
-0.0263610035,
0.0374592394,
0.0313252956,
0.0033215352,
-0.0225273669,
0.0166300815,
-0.0043969932,
-0.0614505522,
-0.0352314524,
0.0666509941,
0.0621597059,
0.0097009121,
0.0327292532,
0.0382360071,
0.0423971638,
0.0492770709,
0.0929369628,
0.0537366867,
0.0064026313,
-0.0208209455,
0.0714233145,
-0.0226329695,
0.0774114802,
-0.0064185672,
0.0273453183,
0.017258741,
0.0331892855,
-0.0096175838,
-0.0474601015,
-0.0023792959,
0.0059257294,
-0.0127228983,
-0.0252294019,
0.0560334325,
0.0344963968,
-0.0802083239,
0.0671990141,
-0.0019885595,
-0.0439134128,
-0.0222502425,
-0.0672046989,
-0.0241543073,
0.0142593514,
0.0202298649,
-0.0272980835,
0.0108924806,
0.0113658002,
-0.013913108,
0.0394973122,
0.0246633608,
0.0296905208,
-0.025509337,
-0.0241249502,
-0.0156224677,
0.0231976248,
-0.0215945579,
0.0349182151,
0.0063286303,
0.0236677509,
0.0001725538,
0.0511189736,
0.0009912123,
0.0233705044,
-0.0002867391,
-0.0274691619,
0.0069667459,
0.0144310743,
0.0416562222,
-0.0258594416,
-0.0046870355,
0.0347513966,
0.0473767817,
-0.0456832871,
-0.0134282839,
0.0277341399,
-0.0872147381,
-0.0305490401,
0.0095103756,
-0.0278425161,
0.0243475158,
0.0216426551,
0.0066673527,
-0.0545616485,
0.045748353,
-0.0798561275,
0.0230166428,
-0.0090454575,
0.0347890854,
0.0476375148,
0.0250192229,
-0.0170113053,
0.077798903,
-0.019427713,
0.0004881487,
-0.0019069989,
0.0089676809,
-0.0188163761,
-0.0305331536,
-0.0081752362,
0.0113579249,
-0.0457601883,
-0.0058002067,
0.0345170572,
-0.0332138762,
-0.0368007272,
-0.0649419948,
0.0017323669,
0.0289175883,
-0.027085226,
0.065592058,
0.0149187008,
0.0175053142,
0.0177828725,
-0.0131941326,
-0.0334125981,
0.0306971446,
0.0004229228,
-0.0048728297,
0.0351046547,
0.0104374951,
-0.0154060712,
-0.0245745648,
-0.0364673547,
-0.0015372596,
0.0269075762,
0.0151098268,
-0.06040214,
-0.0479941182,
0.0061109043,
0.0189289767,
0.0441136397,
-0.0104612196,
-0.0265732724,
-0.0124355024,
-0.0313786305,
0.0788130835,
0.0470167063,
0.0639169961,
0.0247945134,
0.000019152,
-0.0379230268,
0.0214828923,
0.0270368494,
-0.0614177175,
0.0408051535,
-0.0005489856,
-0.0016856,
0.0374550633,
0.1101709604,
0.0097749569,
0.0101413457,
-0.0442492701,
-0.0294093378,
0.026314456,
-0.0231640413,
0.0638993531,
0.0072579961,
-0.0603753887,
-0.0074900808,
-0.0317012258,
-0.0493141711,
0.041678492,
-0.0242419187,
-0.0061941789,
-0.027516922,
0.0039549507,
0.0039046323,
0.0300397351,
0.0378248394,
0.0118640382,
-0.0020510419,
-0.030223038,
-0.0029101593,
0.0440401174,
0.0061722626,
-0.0414499976,
0.0381083786,
0.0069404719,
0.0170869697,
-0.0370800681,
-0.0453529954,
-0.0499659665,
0.0047037527,
-0.0012287576,
-0.0090536624,
0.0506656729,
-0.012952501,
-0.0566376522,
0.0548270382,
0.0153266564,
0.043485146,
-0.0261968803,
-0.0249354281,
-0.0149290618,
0.0709084719,
0.0240921061,
0.009561657,
0.0087010404,
0.0040053069,
0.0331436247,
0.0577186272,
0.0313595198,
-0.0033083947,
-0.0289254636,
-0.0238429196,
0.0311485343,
-0.0616587065,
-0.0202070493,
0.0505702943,
-0.0036801323,
-0.0529159792,
-0.0591761917,
0.0769975334,
0.0054313256,
-0.0229898393,
-0.0082475748,
0.0223773159,
-0.0021768806,
0.0067513245,
0.0286277514,
-0.0383234173,
-0.0133411055,
0.0005679616,
0.0367063656,
-0.0242246427,
-0.0396846905,
-0.0197258145,
-0.0924338549,
0.0513187423,
-0.0120700728,
-0.0452185757,
-0.0532663018,
-0.0328674503,
-0.0159549322,
0.0125261275,
-0.0342585482,
0.0373198949,
-0.0303522013,
0.0054685106,
0.0212405901,
-0.0282820594,
0.0025952465,
-0.0260449536,
0.0176416915,
-0.0303358529,
0.0690982565,
0.0174695998,
-0.0021875317,
-0.0198727101,
-0.0167975798,
-0.0335155725,
0.017211277,
-0.0305899251,
0.0456389971,
-0.0316080265,
-0.0157640465,
-0.0490995161,
0.0111004608,
0.0068172212,
0.0111230845,
-0.013833791,
0.0520923138,
-0.0135519076,
-0.0731943995,
-0.0081003206,
0.0175244417,
-0.0058058179,
0.0470219739,
0.0084793596,
-0.0394372232,
-0.0673089176,
-0.0027973235,
0.0229872819,
-0.1016348824,
-0.0394881554,
-0.0078067696,
0.0073476699,
-0.0696359426,
-0.0667232051,
-0.030942278,
-0.0413267091,
0.0655348748,
-0.0172974635,
-0.0071939337,
0.0745445266,
0.01073993,
-0.0649699122,
-0.0549252816,
-0.0113773244,
-0.0420720093,
-0.0560909957,
0.0031208426,
0.023627121,
0.0007695101,
-0.0074081966,
0.0176486764,
-0.1157947257,
-0.0517786629,
0.0131821251,
0.0979150236,
0.0171659198,
0.0109232245,
0.0276993103,
-0.0043697045,
0.0343389101,
0.031887874,
-0.0057793753,
0.002380518,
0.0199706461,
-0.0416625887,
-0.0105584059,
0.0058460757,
0.0056560333,
0.0471627489,
-0.0006079086,
0.0347792692,
-0.031669315,
-0.0282018408,
0.0138125112,
0.0219377894,
0.0511836112,
-0.0172949992,
0.0494407602,
0.0103406264,
0.0294427332,
-0.0176007114,
-0.0040591233,
-0.0645376965,
0.0297154691,
0.0161501896,
-0.0015152345,
0.0023815192,
0.0176665336,
-0.0102374852,
-0.0583845153,
-0.0140163405,
0.0224106144,
-0.0119881919,
0.0045245779,
0.0023289628,
-0.016498439,
-0.0085337963,
-0.0334434398,
0.063561596,
0.0434641987,
-0.037649259,
0.0532576032,
0.0396800786,
0.0367598236,
0.0178191401,
0.0191049855,
-0.0561682545,
0.0396295935,
-0.0356206559,
-0.0211548191,
0.0441016443,
-0.0196483079,
0.052017346,
-0.0062624793,
0.016836727,
-0.0146924919,
0.039251592,
0.0039907047,
-0.008115029,
0.0039170231,
0.0189817511,
0.0041919802,
-0.038255021,
0.0529812612,
-0.0524233691,
-0.0131649105,
0.0347251371,
-0.0445809886,
-0.0606097169,
-0.0273764022,
-0.0631651282,
-0.0207922906,
0.0216289926,
-0.0370742306,
-0.0289275087,
-0.012846265,
0.0537978597,
-0.0209616125,
0.0308868885,
-0.04904617,
0.0465491116,
0.0164170209,
-0.0003159651,
-0.0175036173,
-0.0474795923,
0.0455449335,
-0.0050355536,
0.0134093622,
-0.0058789686,
-6.20873047e-33,
-0.0363560542,
-0.0196498409,
0.0184344053,
0.02671629,
-0.0303060431,
0.0114712128,
-0.0644502193,
-0.0063397395,
0.0253049545,
-0.0103274714,
-0.0273618903,
-0.0160960369,
0.0283975005,
0.0175171942,
0.0036965022,
0.0324253254,
0.0486128926,
-0.0181130562,
-0.0364174359,
0.0120900394,
0.045050323,
0.061030034,
0.0526821129,
-0.0050798436,
-0.0514446832,
-0.0304120183,
0.0376271941,
-0.049483873,
0.04066021,
0.0271820296,
-0.0124936001,
0.0238520559,
0.0366646424,
-0.0701266304,
-0.0371114314,
0.0665369332,
-0.081573911,
-0.0278701112,
-0.0254606251,
0.0174386185,
-0.0138441483,
-0.0242996104,
0.0523324832,
0.0127369203,
-0.0109454747,
-0.0312255733,
0.0113673834,
0.0008259296,
-0.0564938001,
-0.0427548513,
-0.067508705,
0.038110368,
0.0237235986,
-0.0007217239,
0.050686989,
0.038057629,
0.0026599667,
0.000482851,
-0.0357917137,
0.0045033996,
0.0066437689,
0.0963586122,
0.0499487743,
0.0501132831,
0.0072700884,
0.0417897925,
0.0385969505,
0.0088142669,
0.0059917504,
0.0480756946,
-0.0029780627,
0.040768899,
0.0170227308,
-0.0131419832,
0.0763387829,
-0.0125977797,
-0.022793401,
0.0279278941,
-0.0006902091,
0.0395200439,
0.0429900661,
-0.0121953227,
-0.0409367606,
0.0105566597,
0.0264050979,
0.0059894463,
0.0002493872,
-0.0198370181,
0.031314563,
0.0475193672,
-0.0353375524,
0.0516959392,
0.0445911326,
-0.0117456801,
0.0122762453,
0.0062729996,
-0.0413705707,
0.011664045,
-0.0332432725,
-0.0083414102,
-0.07811369,
-0.0494561121,
0.010783975,
0.0364908278,
-0.0051393253,
0.0120343035,
-0.0064050909,
0.0262509976,
-0.0942328125,
-0.0308824293,
-0.0400851853,
0.0650912821,
0.0195304807,
0.0456837118,
0.0266304947,
-0.0195996128,
-0.0182992537,
0.0388933755,
-0.0002325901,
-0.0341800936,
-0.0248900186,
0.056180995,
0.0378989056,
0.0126005812,
-0.0048150956,
0.024254417,
-0.0531681292,
0.0878287926,
-0.0010569639,
-0.0592247918,
-0.0380563661,
0.0418604836,
2.831e-7,
0.0125754299,
0.0330599397,
0.0660974234,
-0.0198774375,
0.0266589466,
0.0055176038,
0.0192500912,
0.0383538939,
0.0130397845,
0.0333272144,
0.0213355981,
0.0108614145,
0.0004532627,
-0.0056407512,
-0.0660191849,
-0.0285923816,
-0.0775950328,
0.0183905028,
-0.0050483369,
-0.0060461145,
0.0287084188,
0.0419770852,
-0.048089955,
0.0001167969,
-0.0080499668,
-0.023667261,
0.0494048633,
0.0496940725,
0.0212675538,
0.0067585153,
0.0242779404,
0.0321143903,
-0.0689885765,
-0.0161387436,
-0.0391091034,
0.0084642069,
-0.0201892145,
0.0493983999,
-0.0032586793,
-0.0220149104,
0.0670468286,
0.0178410262,
0.0078928573,
0.0159669202,
0.037111111,
-0.082663402,
-0.0431166328,
-0.0123869404,
-0.0378962904,
0.023509156,
-0.0802198276,
0.0059710541,
0.0021491242,
0.027139809,
0.0223626345,
-0.019189382,
-0.0290899556,
-0.0657979921,
-0.0039087576,
-0.0112259332,
-0.0478424318,
-0.0144034987,
-0.0850009024,
0.0017328092,
0.0177380498,
-0.009065384,
-0.064873904,
2.554915849e-34,
-0.007219064,
-0.0182852969,
-0.0090231253,
0.0125119342,
-0.0024723557,
-0.0183927938,
0.0102338186,
0.045113124,
0.0075355554,
-0.0608926564,
-0.0715062916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07654v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07654v1 | SEER: Super-Optimization Explorer for HLS using E-graph Rewriting with MLIR | 2023-08-15T09:05:27 | 2023-08-15T09:05:27 | Jianyi Cheng, Samuel Coward, Lorenzo Chelini, Rafael Barbalho, Theo Drane | cs.PL | cs.PL, cs.AR, cs.CL | High-level synthesis (HLS) is a process that automatically translates a
software program in a high-level language into a low-level hardware
description. However, the hardware designs produced by HLS tools still suffer
from a significant performance gap compared to manual implementations. This is
because the input HLS programs must still be written using hardware design
principles.
Existing techniques either leave the program source unchanged or perform a
fixed sequence of source transformation passes, potentially missing
opportunities to find the optimal design. We propose a super-optimization
approach for HLS that automatically rewrites an arbitrary software program into
efficient HLS code that can be used to generate an optimized hardware design.
We developed a toolflow named SEER, based on the e-graph data structure, to
efficiently explore equivalent implementations of a program at scale. SEER
provides an extensible framework, orchestrating existing software compiler
passes and hardware synthesis optimizers.
Our work is the first attempt to exploit e-graph rewriting for large software
compiler frameworks, such as MLIR. Across a set of open-source benchmarks, we
show that SEER achieves up to 38x the performance within 1.4x the area of the
original program. Via an Intel-provided case study, SEER demonstrates the
potential to outperform manually optimized designs produced by hardware
experts. | [
-0.0265346225,
0.0269658379,
-0.0084082093,
0.0105964532,
-0.0415264554,
-0.0223687794,
-0.0094292071,
-0.0110865096,
0.0299646109,
0.0031817169,
0.0083431751,
0.0793226808,
0.0020447909,
0.01609792,
0.009815108,
0.0103912549,
-0.0013899476,
0.0086431438,
-0.0372130312,
0.0095283464,
-0.0480986647,
0.0320191793,
0.0410391688,
0.0181940719,
0.0070384056,
0.0227163099,
-0.0095596947,
0.1176528931,
0.0198428407,
0.0283023752,
-0.0300075654,
0.0126167731,
-0.0146167018,
-0.0204440933,
0.000002139,
0.0394582488,
-0.0264822301,
0.0417715125,
0.0021618537,
0.0289792288,
0.0423035547,
-0.0231425799,
0.0028608653,
-0.0007893476,
0.0290574133,
-0.0402227491,
0.0236666203,
-0.0259256307,
0.0271656457,
0.0347088985,
0.0080448985,
-0.0078814169,
-0.0229042824,
0.0265244041,
-0.0181387309,
0.0191833396,
-0.0043623364,
-0.0033135281,
-0.0099914884,
-0.0509280413,
-0.0273745023,
0.0190103091,
-0.0040063392,
-0.0262245126,
0.0594364293,
-0.0498425327,
-0.0177877005,
0.0152760688,
-0.0016660866,
0.046417702,
-0.0807952508,
-0.0507007986,
0.0376833603,
-0.0109017417,
-0.1000164747,
-0.0131979799,
0.0286208559,
-0.0175650176,
-0.0219506156,
-0.0629915819,
0.0152033577,
-0.0598493665,
0.0280483589,
-0.0340400338,
-0.0027216114,
0.0386968218,
0.0518217832,
0.0196639728,
-0.0088810576,
-0.0222092941,
0.0197926089,
-0.0609791763,
0.0229255389,
0.0080074184,
-0.0481005944,
-0.0155341458,
-0.0554566868,
0.0407576114,
0.0047711725,
-0.0019358742,
0.0580118112,
0.0291550905,
0.0779846609,
-0.0427240096,
-0.010962774,
-0.0026078781,
-0.0707927868,
-0.0504936501,
-0.0580409244,
0.0189196821,
0.0283922907,
0.0147535084,
-0.0349832475,
0.0278034117,
-0.0523581058,
0.0191544965,
-0.0524400696,
0.0210271217,
-0.0018637889,
0.006694424,
-0.0169842243,
-0.0065440275,
0.037152186,
-0.0433779955,
0.0467202887,
-0.0008571289,
0.0159192961,
-0.032723926,
-0.0494739227,
-0.0194428656,
0.0145640019,
0.0335451365,
-0.018354794,
0.0066217552,
-0.0019269669,
0.0589322448,
-0.0024591056,
-0.0440818854,
-0.0191275999,
-0.0414416045,
0.0340519659,
-0.009156472,
0.0221141484,
-0.0422837548,
0.0067649675,
-0.0619326942,
0.005880883,
-0.0269009639,
-0.022543693,
0.0146111483,
-0.0030429231,
0.0182772037,
-0.0145054534,
0.0170623735,
-0.0313882828,
-0.0019600489,
0.0091250911,
0.0179222114,
0.0164313652,
0.0171385184,
-0.0099142091,
-0.0329263918,
0.0173309967,
0.0514381975,
0.012115092,
-0.0062585133,
-0.0340415835,
0.0217817333,
-0.0580427907,
0.0106598912,
-0.0180236679,
0.0036668456,
0.001887797,
-0.0112858554,
-0.0122054452,
-0.0116691804,
0.0232311171,
0.034498442,
0.052307751,
0.0576005355,
-0.0262453444,
-0.0352716111,
-0.0400944389,
0.0277450718,
0.0373886898,
0.00287436,
0.01684325,
0.0333870724,
0.0210212879,
0.0216086023,
-0.0093132751,
-0.0227109268,
-0.0411601067,
0.0187124871,
-0.0196866635,
0.0014331687,
-0.0948655084,
0.0279681105,
0.047399804,
-0.0654614866,
-0.06440451,
-0.0453285575,
-0.0181067921,
0.0568231009,
0.0452761687,
0.0137940869,
0.0177042168,
0.0425938778,
-0.0057321647,
-0.0245877411,
0.0380281992,
-0.0293708444,
0.0475114025,
-0.0245933011,
-0.0344388001,
-0.0111178234,
-0.0042705229,
0.0872960016,
0.0211894903,
-0.0580111071,
0.0043604174,
-0.034712337,
-0.0228814054,
-0.0214033779,
0.0391279235,
0.0075381864,
0.0439524017,
0.0254015308,
-0.0036659068,
-0.0158968884,
-0.0446888097,
0.0089128045,
0.0438188501,
-0.0076901126,
-0.0019835567,
-0.0749901682,
-0.0198622402,
0.0059977388,
-0.0031058546,
-0.1328205913,
0.004783689,
0.0170207042,
-0.0610486269,
-0.023939671,
0.0650217086,
-0.0352928564,
0.0397920571,
0.028994374,
0.0324160978,
-0.0289736241,
-0.0383539423,
-0.0407938547,
0.0190226808,
0.0375826769,
-0.0401717797,
0.015487832,
0.0130869234,
0.0053498982,
0.0131908534,
0.0351342261,
0.0163974352,
0.0062162681,
0.0127011091,
0.0089994194,
0.0038045817,
0.023710357,
0.0142701641,
-0.0779807717,
0.0127975186,
-0.0240807086,
0.0151933571,
0.0709798187,
0.0449130647,
0.0565201864,
0.028218586,
0.0381262377,
0.0297429152,
-0.0177775528,
-0.0066576949,
-0.010338665,
-0.0423311293,
-0.0808458254,
0.031581331,
-0.0712492764,
-0.0204010364,
0.0459089205,
-0.0432884768,
0.0120636169,
-0.0175267365,
0.0373968855,
0.0220376216,
0.0087793851,
-0.0228744913,
0.004830068,
-0.0445091762,
-0.0048457198,
0.0181599483,
0.0639477819,
-0.0329777114,
0.0105422074,
0.0266694967,
-0.0052224388,
-0.042468112,
0.0285621695,
0.0165214147,
0.0138005856,
0.0287568271,
0.0000054355,
-0.0004404204,
-0.0010291447,
0.0187522024,
-0.0329716317,
0.0172620211,
-0.0253492892,
0.0356558561,
-0.0127482591,
-0.0087955222,
-0.0172896609,
0.0020234636,
-0.0046364218,
-0.0403414108,
-0.0374756344,
0.00727122,
-0.005618888,
0.012460757,
0.0067904633,
-0.0195793118,
-0.0436881371,
-0.0453087911,
0.0386521481,
0.0073501039,
-0.0607088953,
0.0283029694,
0.0261089318,
0.0227468684,
0.0138888694,
-0.0294768326,
0.0545737259,
0.008784241,
0.0076651098,
0.0029600877,
-0.0059375879,
-0.000056691,
0.0689926893,
0.0050492962,
-0.0141893653,
0.0252903216,
-0.0462585688,
0.0213711504,
0.005266421,
-0.0044154064,
-0.0092658354,
0.0282389745,
-0.0555330515,
-0.0000606804,
-0.0093003511,
-0.0056065251,
-0.0650290102,
0.0224508643,
0.0331076086,
-0.0152263753,
0.0368767828,
0.0390735306,
0.0036726503,
-0.0659688786,
-0.007486132,
0.0443001278,
-0.0006984906,
-0.0329206884,
0.0446201041,
0.0260576196,
-0.052376166,
0.0024852818,
-0.0138643458,
0.00830027,
-0.015625257,
0.0413423143,
0.0728814155,
0.1168319732,
0.0422566421,
0.0547796525,
-0.0786838531,
-0.0363192335,
0.0061067403,
0.0420608297,
-0.0191948749,
0.0051953886,
-0.0015876302,
-0.0070882547,
0.0285497308,
0.0203788616,
-0.004205619,
0.0085694995,
-0.0345389992,
-0.0371702537,
0.0430604927,
-0.0336415507,
0.0197395869,
-0.0181718022,
-0.0069211083,
-0.0659007579,
-0.039017342,
0.0373410471,
0.0071745501,
0.0616483837,
-0.0425982177,
-0.0029036277,
0.0369143002,
0.0416585431,
0.0304086469,
0.0481016189,
0.0220147837,
-0.0008916713,
-0.0605494305,
0.0090221353,
0.0317496844,
-0.003718185,
-0.0302287899,
-0.0257716421,
-0.0284201056,
0.0157886408,
-0.0155715123,
0.0396666415,
0.021200113,
-0.0214915331,
-0.0058856737,
-0.0126191434,
0.028211426,
-0.0227427986,
0.002706673,
0.0457804129,
-0.0433919914,
-0.057459414,
-0.0387366228,
-0.0731599256,
-0.0113844089,
-0.0016074256,
-0.0163784474,
0.0371109545,
0.0682473332,
0.1103071049,
-0.0327080488,
0.0012849072,
0.006782013,
-0.0898577645,
0.0427691191,
-0.0800089017,
-0.1251619905,
0.0008715464,
-0.0536020845,
0.0453916229,
0.0072019724,
-0.0461349972,
0.0118867746,
0.0227144677,
0.02571816,
0.06179858,
0.0098903794,
-0.0772075877,
-0.0330079421,
0.0829559416,
0.00624657,
0.0408414267,
-0.0053984299,
0.0054200031,
0.0061920569,
0.0491764434,
-0.0011417351,
0.0155518297,
-0.0014829531,
-0.0699606463,
-0.0235279612,
-0.0404141657,
-0.0234077349,
0.0232258104,
0.0938565135,
-0.0254444201,
0.086651668,
-0.0266233217,
-0.0160358679,
0.0836715326,
-0.0384270959,
-0.0071609872,
0.0196876619,
0.0588725545,
0.0234812535,
-0.0218878351,
0.0102976486,
-0.0283384677,
0.0103643136,
-0.0084676817,
0.004265354,
-0.0035043419,
0.018311413,
-0.0115587134,
0.0104406998,
-0.0383334979,
0.0505107641,
-0.0697522983,
-0.0048333406,
0.0843536779,
-0.0024400677,
0.0012622132,
0.0500499681,
0.0528835617,
0.0607348196,
-0.0043036183,
-0.0304504018,
0.015695652,
0.0353079624,
-0.0437051617,
0.0244648382,
-0.0136357555,
-0.0563660003,
-0.051385954,
-0.0109478477,
0.0603731349,
0.0774173364,
0.0315575823,
0.0276657417,
-0.0179145467,
-0.021651715,
0.0310811773,
-0.0250918157,
-0.046089001,
0.0031667876,
-0.0044074124,
-0.0004539565,
-0.0202764813,
-0.0134182405,
0.0075728535,
0.0243441015,
0.0025526544,
0.0230833013,
-0.0267220177,
-0.0252454747,
-0.003756765,
-0.0077387653,
-0.0008380876,
-0.0816044882,
-0.018295275,
-0.0334199592,
-0.0077967951,
0.0290160775,
0.0560253896,
-0.0043500764,
0.0442826971,
0.0077304859,
0.0254976079,
-0.0727759674,
0.0116558559,
-0.0080906879,
-0.0210183859,
0.0058757677,
0.0441159569,
-5.840283888e-33,
0.00934345,
-0.0204854216,
0.0079291677,
0.0248124711,
-0.0124505889,
-0.0001457265,
-0.0615972057,
-0.0183746759,
0.0176496375,
-0.0063042799,
0.0068743452,
-0.0385889336,
0.0047733192,
-0.0041274247,
-0.0410931483,
0.0522457026,
0.0413479358,
0.036584869,
-0.0811021104,
0.0444680303,
-0.028050147,
-0.0159248486,
-0.0157895852,
-0.0211452506,
-0.1064615771,
-0.029262593,
0.0557574481,
0.0006004357,
-0.0110802231,
0.0066931657,
0.0061017578,
0.0298525617,
-0.0402050205,
-0.0114918733,
-0.0047347303,
-0.0093214707,
-0.0683616847,
-0.0283666048,
0.038440749,
0.0104382196,
-0.0148478942,
-0.0768569559,
0.0308935326,
0.0864346176,
-0.057148695,
-0.056359414,
-0.0433733128,
0.0838591307,
-0.032439135,
-0.0363573991,
-0.0704428703,
0.0098302811,
0.0139020178,
0.0664386228,
0.0313082449,
-0.0128656561,
-0.0498364419,
-0.0250031371,
0.0082118697,
0.0159730501,
0.0000708098,
-0.0166897792,
0.0474886559,
-0.0094760554,
-0.0036964298,
-0.0050873663,
0.0571191646,
0.0304352622,
-0.0359551869,
0.0673368424,
0.0252362676,
0.0478411652,
-0.0487232171,
0.0169696677,
0.0069073276,
-0.0142516596,
-0.0340027995,
-0.0337151177,
-0.0481170975,
-0.0018242034,
-0.0305680893,
0.0531216003,
0.0037034806,
-0.0246448424,
-0.0211387202,
0.0394398645,
-0.0457626395,
-0.0094513753,
0.0063817329,
0.0218042415,
-0.0508216955,
0.0346352644,
-0.0080652153,
-0.0048557031,
0.0734999925,
0.0313619785,
-0.0030410292,
-0.0154865952,
0.014152565,
0.0262731146,
0.0348597839,
-0.0602757484,
-0.0220221169,
-0.0263548791,
0.0866287649,
-0.041626852,
-0.04117487,
0.0503810123,
-0.0458397754,
0.0300685875,
-0.0364043489,
-0.0278129969,
-0.0434188694,
-0.0206568465,
-0.0287269484,
0.0326123834,
-0.0049856212,
0.0164922532,
-0.0128051359,
-0.0033321495,
-0.0176450685,
0.0470771939,
0.0408508778,
0.0551083237,
-0.0306962486,
0.0055496995,
-0.0232923273,
-0.0187692717,
0.0629918128,
-0.0378802791,
-0.063762702,
0.0319888368,
3.109e-7,
0.0078487936,
0.0524185523,
0.043152377,
0.0650218502,
-0.0075470735,
0.0157630201,
0.0674716756,
0.0274894666,
0.0342020094,
0.0222088434,
-0.0090973768,
0.0247692633,
0.0243144538,
-0.0714195371,
0.0298860595,
0.0362701491,
0.0324860439,
0.0132676587,
-0.0078908494,
-0.0251362789,
-0.0097096991,
0.0077957748,
-0.0093657812,
-0.0301867072,
0.0080389697,
0.0217955261,
-0.0389983319,
-0.0055675516,
-0.0108282268,
0.0026499901,
-0.0708294064,
-0.036127504,
-0.0573669598,
0.0363897718,
-0.015403715,
-0.0213030763,
-0.0386358909,
0.1008917093,
0.0118333986,
0.0104715396,
0.0495393462,
-0.0342061073,
-0.0386604704,
0.0029593427,
0.0151210809,
0.0211402904,
-0.0238096323,
-0.0459351987,
-0.0276530404,
0.0029262798,
-0.0440480262,
-0.0139874285,
0.0921885893,
0.0527349152,
0.0121067828,
-0.0010997062,
0.0149651421,
0.0124204848,
-0.0485146306,
0.0077253082,
-0.0091370037,
-0.0365513824,
-0.0061830175,
0.0523225367,
-0.008359205,
0.0105244881,
0.0181741286,
2.841463031e-34,
0.0436747931,
-0.0116481166,
-0.0023868755,
-0.0110517442,
0.0395477451,
-0.0352059267,
-0.0495287441,
0.0005092855,
-0.0336214937,
-0.016417237,
-0.0303215925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07645v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07645v2 | Steering Language Generation: Harnessing Contrastive Expert Guidance and Negative Prompting for Coherent and Diverse Synthetic Data Generation | 2023-08-15T08:49:14 | 2023-08-17T06:08:39 | Charles O'Neill, Yuan-Sen Ting, Ioana Ciuca, Jack Miller, Thang Bui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) hold immense potential to generate synthetic
data of high quality and utility, which has numerous applications from
downstream model training to practical data utilisation. However, contemporary
models, despite their impressive capacities, consistently struggle to produce
both coherent and diverse data. To address the coherency issue, we introduce
contrastive expert guidance, where the difference between the logit
distributions of fine-tuned and base language models is emphasised to ensure
domain adherence. In order to ensure diversity, we utilise existing real and
synthetic examples as negative prompts to the model. We deem this dual-pronged
approach to logit reshaping as STEER: Semantic Text Enhancement via Embedding
Repositioning. STEER operates at inference-time and systematically guides the
LLMs to strike a balance between adherence to the data distribution (ensuring
semantic fidelity) and deviation from prior synthetic examples or existing real
datasets (ensuring diversity and authenticity). This delicate balancing act is
achieved by dynamically moving towards or away from chosen representations in
the latent space. STEER demonstrates improved performance over previous
synthetic data generation techniques, exhibiting better balance between data
diversity and coherency across three distinct tasks: hypothesis generation,
toxic and non-toxic comment generation, and commonsense reasoning task
generation. We demonstrate how STEER allows for fine-tuned control over the
diversity-coherency trade-off via its hyperparameters, highlighting its
versatility. | [
0.0432442203,
0.0434968174,
-0.007314953,
0.0247644912,
-0.0318212695,
-0.0083857616,
0.0008734133,
-0.0287896954,
0.0010849837,
-0.0451969579,
-0.0075568659,
-0.0516614988,
-0.023116013,
0.057309676,
0.0534210838,
-0.0439275429,
0.0345602073,
-0.0172150247,
-0.013983598,
-0.0150129376,
0.0119328508,
0.0288820677,
0.0236321185,
0.0364087187,
-0.0521682017,
-0.0068714842,
0.0005904413,
0.0263477936,
0.027882684,
-0.0030400655,
0.0191449225,
0.0596059784,
0.0343292989,
0.0368106887,
0.0000019993,
-0.0185039323,
0.0101245958,
0.0070205061,
0.0094589712,
-0.0031789087,
0.0520105213,
-0.0281911306,
0.0038251488,
0.0140887061,
-0.0433042794,
0.0012510966,
0.0487117022,
0.0322662964,
0.0667688102,
0.0984576717,
-0.0070061744,
-0.0421462134,
0.0052802712,
-0.0223160759,
-0.0014686601,
0.0447470769,
0.0077597788,
0.0269014612,
-0.0188064836,
0.0274128523,
-0.0095166406,
0.0099147623,
0.0519019552,
-0.0270809773,
0.021197591,
0.0362096466,
-0.004665209,
-0.0288392249,
0.004806763,
0.073907949,
-0.03009318,
-0.0417604931,
0.0020933764,
-0.0225902069,
0.0107676676,
-0.0026505012,
-0.0308888499,
0.0619327687,
-0.0039434796,
0.0433900654,
0.0751252845,
-0.00646292,
0.0345261246,
0.014234853,
-0.007755463,
0.0092537701,
0.0243507996,
-0.0338186063,
-0.0127113024,
0.0149372313,
-0.054688517,
-0.0391380265,
-0.0272416603,
0.0063666152,
-0.0486298688,
0.0180165693,
-0.0625698864,
-0.0490885302,
0.0225152075,
-0.0387976579,
0.0333682336,
0.0309261288,
-0.0090949275,
0.0205561705,
-0.0094262576,
-0.0077560884,
-0.0193191227,
0.0264083687,
-0.0473669283,
-0.018591987,
-0.0169162564,
-0.031372197,
-0.0276952405,
0.0092554009,
-0.0829801336,
0.007683381,
-0.0055588773,
0.0170525312,
-0.0272039231,
-0.0223124381,
0.0377703421,
0.0393635668,
-0.0653338432,
-0.0038951566,
-0.0140265087,
-0.0319755524,
-0.0457913838,
0.0196371749,
0.0366782509,
-0.0255029704,
-0.0204390045,
0.0585402288,
-0.036067903,
-0.0167599302,
-0.01194188,
0.0775642022,
-0.0179258902,
0.0210560746,
-0.042520225,
-0.0436975695,
-0.0422284901,
-0.041811455,
0.0260795262,
-0.0741813853,
0.0336898863,
-0.0040880931,
-0.0337539315,
-0.0364574268,
0.0076106656,
-0.000883078,
-0.03548491,
0.0245710723,
-0.0590911545,
-0.001480708,
0.0074501554,
0.0080804154,
-0.0172246657,
0.0833238959,
0.0210665017,
0.0110168718,
0.0232383125,
0.0102433907,
0.0074222912,
0.0065475102,
0.0207423605,
0.0091249291,
-0.0286747981,
-0.0023375584,
-0.0291108731,
0.0319837369,
0.0674048364,
0.0491458438,
-0.0507973395,
-0.0072590872,
0.0596452802,
-0.0054228022,
0.0081974436,
0.033587411,
0.1062162593,
0.0106513565,
-0.0441958681,
0.038893722,
-0.0476047359,
0.0231575835,
-0.0039671166,
0.0124605484,
0.0328847021,
0.0539302267,
-0.0163920578,
-0.0262956675,
0.0134155173,
0.0051108948,
-0.004129021,
-0.024871096,
0.0128459102,
0.0409033597,
-0.0247410033,
0.0241823215,
0.0774515495,
-0.04646267,
0.0197439659,
-0.0192446448,
0.0449655876,
0.0727929622,
0.0234286245,
-0.0062433728,
-0.0318797491,
-0.0015857186,
0.0187197346,
0.0837180093,
0.0408937521,
-0.0128279431,
0.0057932339,
-0.0695867315,
-0.0139931869,
-0.0381135456,
0.0199357551,
0.0352608748,
0.0214364808,
-0.0233963914,
0.0278909113,
-0.025988806,
-0.0375080109,
0.0420477726,
-0.0551235415,
0.0130583365,
0.0161472391,
-0.0312742665,
0.0248900503,
0.0095469644,
-0.0284333359,
0.0250542685,
0.0148097128,
-0.0418565124,
-0.0210794955,
0.0141882217,
-0.0486969277,
-0.0623833947,
0.0240419954,
-0.070640862,
-0.003791685,
0.0007139806,
-0.0474918149,
-0.0284882244,
0.0372091457,
-0.0223175716,
0.0080057569,
-0.0547057688,
-0.0155419838,
0.036143478,
0.0143850539,
-0.0396150835,
0.0930250213,
-0.0026704853,
-0.0010615867,
0.0277200844,
0.0189867057,
-0.0119144954,
-0.029036874,
0.0128513528,
0.0017097006,
0.0063679307,
0.0197455455,
0.0119930534,
0.0377997085,
-0.0286691003,
-0.050240986,
-0.0721856281,
0.0128495768,
-0.0478220023,
-0.0127195157,
0.053608615,
-0.0244273245,
0.0063515659,
0.031669464,
-0.0564184114,
-0.0163550377,
0.0113852555,
0.0139245959,
0.0200421922,
-0.0079641258,
-0.0020415804,
-0.0172961261,
0.0009457071,
-0.0011686359,
0.0382563509,
-0.0014799414,
0.0206079241,
-0.0885923803,
0.0101232603,
-0.0357232168,
0.0047226255,
-0.0143351108,
-0.0155450823,
0.022412952,
0.0174240004,
0.101493068,
0.0211857054,
0.0186061952,
0.0299314745,
0.0475943275,
-0.0000737824,
-0.0386283845,
-0.0001800673,
-0.0474381112,
0.0562831163,
-0.0246466752,
-0.047177095,
-0.0041770558,
0.0431439839,
0.0252659041,
-0.0200020205,
-0.0932405218,
0.0301530901,
-0.0068794745,
-0.0708657205,
0.0216934085,
-0.0145889129,
-0.0189103577,
0.0262215342,
-0.0448701009,
-0.0397880226,
0.079604663,
-0.0210341252,
0.0055305092,
-0.0325443372,
-0.0195869356,
-0.0121246213,
0.0174832549,
-0.0082672872,
0.0138108842,
-0.0051967283,
0.0526414439,
-0.0597007535,
0.0002293464,
0.0345042944,
-0.0100232847,
0.0283251479,
-0.0673476681,
-0.0030524931,
-0.0021271689,
-0.0333796293,
-0.052024778,
-0.0819581077,
0.0289421063,
0.0120471725,
0.0664933473,
-0.0147968726,
-0.0127073647,
-0.0009867502,
0.0102106929,
0.0493116677,
-0.0205038171,
0.0031028069,
-0.0159622189,
0.0039107064,
0.0632569566,
0.0271527041,
0.056880191,
-0.0242501125,
0.0128916288,
0.053834971,
-0.0239396282,
-0.034431465,
-0.0284244027,
-0.0010724091,
-0.005761297,
0.0084243119,
-0.0266110692,
0.0086260801,
0.0599565469,
-0.026797073,
-0.0397475176,
0.0777418911,
0.0133606875,
-0.0033274812,
0.0274209809,
-0.0043976759,
0.0800961629,
0.00590081,
0.0046382076,
-0.0821526647,
-0.0090304073,
-0.0067991014,
0.006413653,
-0.0250278097,
-0.0295595471,
-0.0158490483,
-0.13458094,
0.05332819,
0.0220167525,
-0.0436245389,
-0.0233544167,
-0.0348361321,
-0.0195979849,
-0.0015449662,
0.0225416683,
0.0153856259,
0.0052024028,
0.0186700877,
0.0240773447,
0.0248246156,
-0.0646260828,
-0.0278481413,
-0.019709127,
0.0842546821,
0.0159357768,
0.0074947267,
0.0234499741,
-0.0064999191,
0.0197962504,
-0.0250306278,
0.0058359373,
-0.0271398369,
0.0434767678,
0.0111927418,
-0.0117874658,
-0.030249767,
0.0536411144,
-0.0188035127,
-0.0323258825,
-0.0102386512,
0.0752498209,
-0.0230033863,
-0.0337830409,
-0.0462712832,
0.0418616459,
0.0396556817,
0.0905091539,
0.0406692326,
-0.0432303622,
-0.0166219901,
-0.0314044654,
-0.0039258786,
-0.0355183333,
-0.0352420546,
0.0212128386,
0.0040954608,
-0.0326108523,
-0.0922619998,
-0.0670359358,
0.0298384428,
0.0308019463,
0.0004838151,
-0.0163621958,
-0.0466835089,
-0.0573940873,
-0.0097144749,
0.0604487583,
-0.0372402593,
-0.0142079834,
-0.0276531409,
-0.0200297069,
0.0154221198,
-0.0607967786,
-0.0051805298,
0.0389170907,
-0.0126257688,
-0.1154542714,
-0.0022568817,
0.0549874343,
0.021307379,
0.0560217127,
-0.0139523577,
-0.0409612022,
0.0405295938,
0.0528650694,
-0.029277388,
0.0147581855,
0.0339580998,
0.0122022703,
0.0101160631,
0.0575597622,
-0.0348238163,
0.0346546061,
0.0328455716,
0.0536464192,
-0.0066075171,
-0.0007154824,
0.0221916549,
-0.0069928807,
0.0349939987,
-0.0561676286,
0.0168177038,
-0.0580152161,
-0.0196710154,
-0.0657021105,
-0.0436608605,
-0.0632976666,
0.0432216153,
0.01127801,
0.0074465149,
-0.0034050294,
0.0368664749,
-0.0358322933,
0.0563347712,
-0.0254339091,
-0.0312093254,
0.0097612692,
0.0231455974,
0.027288314,
-0.0034974364,
-0.031941589,
0.0137692885,
-0.0483567752,
0.0215982739,
-0.0045248428,
0.0239148214,
0.0331096537,
-0.016938664,
-0.0105006881,
0.0129209533,
-0.0638905317,
-0.0056498493,
-0.0493939593,
0.0270825215,
0.0512397029,
0.0040231505,
0.0814850628,
-0.0350478478,
-0.0223102085,
0.0054643033,
0.0506373495,
0.0433944575,
-0.0276161823,
0.0386869274,
0.0091761369,
-0.051434055,
-0.031009445,
0.0830648318,
0.0146830631,
0.0329157822,
-0.0043081776,
0.0321197435,
-0.0374762677,
-0.0637503266,
0.0224870518,
0.0045335055,
0.0026072848,
0.0051666852,
-0.069338508,
-0.0621994622,
0.0019978338,
0.0292327814,
-0.021272162,
0.02126549,
0.0318490416,
0.0610375963,
-0.0206294805,
0.0082842521,
-0.0149431787,
0.0104188826,
0.0210083891,
-0.026530154,
-0.0402250774,
-6.85170384e-33,
0.0028965594,
-0.0220051557,
0.027531663,
-0.0506907851,
-0.0209257696,
-0.0193764418,
-0.0189853813,
0.0116483085,
-0.0031083191,
0.0483199246,
0.0060485522,
0.0038453084,
0.0084705018,
0.0592212938,
-0.0211394895,
-0.0160825886,
0.0425490439,
0.003058322,
-0.0253115762,
0.0474933498,
0.0459734425,
-0.0119623933,
0.0613328665,
-0.0627001449,
0.0336140469,
-0.0121111693,
0.0000518577,
0.026251385,
-0.0469644442,
0.0271634888,
-0.0178099815,
0.0745929331,
0.025636496,
-0.0398575142,
-0.0319056995,
0.0035724284,
-0.0064319028,
-0.0522196367,
0.0656411573,
-0.0660023987,
-0.0593753383,
-0.0464060567,
0.0417895466,
-0.0133798216,
0.0121388799,
-0.0102020716,
0.0267180372,
-0.0387912057,
-0.0038791243,
-0.0404854938,
-0.090500243,
0.0293861944,
0.0095864385,
-0.0096889008,
-0.0194703173,
0.0400991216,
0.0208259523,
-0.0109199369,
-0.0209601093,
0.0382929593,
-0.0061315042,
-0.0029742918,
0.0504846126,
0.0175506677,
-0.0001624891,
0.0640096739,
0.0006582703,
0.0151310535,
-0.0338156223,
-0.00954259,
-0.0093948785,
0.0262373388,
0.0440113656,
0.1039633378,
0.0190274641,
-0.0001558445,
-0.0769269392,
0.0094194962,
-0.0106590521,
-0.0249774959,
0.0339510515,
-0.0109645138,
-0.0324347317,
-0.0218106508,
-0.0259753708,
-0.0340874828,
-0.0069825207,
-0.0177016165,
0.0248441026,
0.0208580773,
-0.0475279316,
-0.0101769418,
0.0032203812,
-0.0109744174,
0.0213693622,
0.0154117057,
-0.0311011001,
-0.0186846592,
0.0076368609,
0.0158618409,
-0.0339826122,
-0.0465906635,
0.0808094293,
0.0072303214,
-0.015867807,
0.0310274661,
0.0411558151,
0.0001796968,
-0.0346615575,
0.0343806669,
-0.0339485258,
0.0567444861,
-0.0035239258,
-0.0111704087,
0.0268998221,
0.0167873763,
-0.0109574208,
0.0289475638,
0.0590634421,
0.0246102512,
-0.0162441581,
0.0279592536,
-0.0094184503,
0.0281713698,
-0.0315497629,
0.0249368288,
-0.0232180841,
-0.0508873202,
0.0623162612,
-0.0703693703,
-0.0309145823,
0.0142869065,
2.72e-7,
0.0300585385,
0.0148858158,
0.0163712073,
-0.0027547474,
0.0082890531,
0.0178078916,
0.0085396506,
0.0186669622,
0.0105922911,
-0.0572392158,
-0.0127775604,
0.0460190102,
0.0442210063,
0.0340462737,
-0.0599159673,
0.0072081527,
-0.0902596936,
-0.0158790909,
-0.0511187203,
-0.0187867302,
0.0542032756,
0.1286368817,
0.0006205194,
-0.0209233351,
0.0100682322,
-0.0141900256,
0.0606793985,
-0.0298372936,
-0.0331445783,
0.0185824987,
0.0251097325,
-0.0060064928,
0.0018597341,
0.0131118204,
0.0005369135,
0.0080546429,
-0.0238845013,
0.0558695644,
0.0097912839,
-0.0179497376,
0.007469635,
-0.0497028306,
-0.0008272059,
-0.0294932127,
0.0502732657,
-0.0849142298,
-0.0327064246,
-0.0394945443,
-0.0314216092,
0.0227713492,
0.0202481337,
-0.0643731356,
-0.0226311013,
-0.0004814539,
0.023889387,
0.0235970393,
-0.0037137493,
-0.0505998582,
-0.0364022516,
0.01256424,
-0.0667491928,
-0.0358985029,
-0.0090142787,
0.0206414238,
0.0511379391,
-0.0509641133,
0.0410591327,
3.069292662e-34,
0.0508526303,
-0.0071712886,
0.0184334721,
-0.0315626189,
0.0357782878,
-0.0043526567,
-0.0019743752,
0.0064665959,
0.0357509479,
-0.0602899939,
-0.0303999875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07635v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07635v1 | LLM-Mini-CEX: Automatic Evaluation of Large Language Model for Diagnostic Conversation | 2023-08-15T08:32:20 | 2023-08-15T08:32:20 | Xiaoming Shi, Jie Xu, Jinru Ding, Jiali Pang, Sichen Liu, Shuqing Luo, Xingwei Peng, Lu Lu, Haihong Yang, Mingtao Hu, Tong Ruan, Shaoting Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | There is an increasing interest in developing LLMs for medical diagnosis to
improve diagnosis efficiency. Despite their alluring technological potential,
there is no unified and comprehensive evaluation criterion, leading to the
inability to evaluate the quality and potential risks of medical LLMs, further
hindering the application of LLMs in medical treatment scenarios. Besides,
current evaluations heavily rely on labor-intensive interactions with LLMs to
obtain diagnostic dialogues and human evaluation on the quality of diagnosis
dialogue. To tackle the lack of unified and comprehensive evaluation criterion,
we first initially establish an evaluation criterion, termed LLM-specific
Mini-CEX to assess the diagnostic capabilities of LLMs effectively, based on
original Mini-CEX. To address the labor-intensive interaction problem, we
develop a patient simulator to engage in automatic conversations with LLMs, and
utilize ChatGPT for evaluating diagnosis dialogues automatically. Experimental
results show that the LLM-specific Mini-CEX is adequate and necessary to
evaluate medical diagnosis dialogue. Besides, ChatGPT can replace manual
evaluation on the metrics of humanistic qualities and provides reproducible and
automated comparisons between different LLMs. | [
0.0610890053,
-0.0073136436,
-0.0116195101,
0.0186224338,
-0.0309214648,
0.0254632421,
-0.0073853838,
0.0602672249,
0.0316059813,
-0.0085824672,
-0.0591816567,
-0.0532330684,
0.0132436464,
0.0307352394,
0.0283010099,
-0.0468964577,
0.0229595471,
0.0031534943,
0.0299809799,
0.0069018067,
0.0267786738,
-0.0118572609,
-0.0690913573,
0.0430526845,
-0.0020912115,
0.0009221847,
0.0085140178,
-0.0121490015,
0.0430107526,
-0.0815301165,
-0.0382645018,
0.0248055067,
-0.0148923621,
-0.0164223295,
0.0000021222,
-0.0714321285,
0.0139618376,
0.0040851831,
-0.0232801996,
-0.039571058,
0.05689165,
0.0246331189,
-0.0097614583,
0.0279963445,
-0.0308045913,
-0.0066770585,
0.0210239142,
0.0587162152,
0.0649372563,
0.0797539279,
-0.0111284163,
0.0178914033,
0.0322420299,
-0.0080606248,
0.0038198645,
-0.0630241409,
0.0234074332,
0.0271156412,
0.0757647753,
-0.0054610572,
0.0069130207,
0.0393191203,
-0.0042531625,
-0.021257868,
-0.0070902244,
0.0205366556,
0.0090316357,
-0.0387389883,
-0.0141718192,
0.0782296285,
0.0366733111,
0.0360967703,
0.0239825305,
0.0015291179,
0.0197734553,
-0.0347794965,
-0.0506229736,
-0.0240007751,
-0.0168423038,
-0.0300207604,
0.0208128467,
0.0062418398,
-0.0007886401,
-0.0227550138,
0.0104477908,
0.0095165856,
-0.0002502361,
-0.0193740036,
-0.0190984346,
-0.0257547665,
0.0053377096,
-0.0383570828,
0.0348923095,
0.0602980256,
-0.1103469208,
0.0133821964,
0.0036635192,
-0.0042016995,
0.0812846944,
-0.0598345809,
0.0079030953,
-0.0002531449,
0.0068964739,
0.0220620967,
0.0057213102,
0.0302780345,
-0.0019569031,
0.0145069603,
-0.0528931133,
0.0196377132,
-0.0287534408,
-0.01515608,
-0.0359970629,
0.0102589773,
0.02903088,
-0.023599403,
-0.0912784636,
0.0058272537,
-0.0000507018,
0.0239982959,
0.0152141862,
0.0339430198,
0.0074236956,
0.0378735065,
-0.051355578,
-0.0008849201,
-0.0105484612,
0.0006737459,
-0.0022564468,
-0.0493853465,
0.0277600028,
0.0475508422,
-0.0016322098,
0.0078006042,
0.0177096426,
0.0637533367,
0.0057111369,
0.0035670279,
0.0345808826,
-0.0383605286,
-0.0380173922,
-0.0434046835,
-0.0170183554,
-0.0532050245,
0.0269384068,
0.0177724119,
0.0067466958,
-0.0202862974,
0.0278143901,
0.0001926795,
-0.0151241077,
0.025932081,
-0.049165953,
0.040010836,
0.028891407,
0.0383710191,
0.0043351687,
0.0143806767,
0.0283814501,
-0.0248606373,
0.0107474634,
-0.0453437045,
0.0464863256,
0.0424323268,
-0.0081443489,
-0.0047959653,
-0.0123888068,
0.0002693398,
-0.0154990098,
0.101112701,
-0.0284212753,
0.0935980678,
0.0145308264,
0.0121283242,
0.0239469875,
0.067031689,
0.0323078521,
0.0067788647,
0.0167568196,
-0.0054231887,
0.0202830285,
0.0199364461,
0.0270675551,
0.0280404203,
-0.0233168453,
-0.0321976617,
0.0261466429,
-0.0169069413,
-0.0207480397,
-0.0473158769,
-0.0662069991,
-0.0187557694,
-0.0156242754,
-0.0028775367,
0.0012928306,
-0.025610812,
-0.0186842363,
0.0877413824,
0.0438034721,
-0.0338018835,
-0.0502096266,
-0.1033688858,
-0.002192203,
0.104550153,
0.0409302413,
-0.012264044,
-0.0348822623,
-0.0141108315,
-0.0148898736,
0.0246082246,
0.0237794593,
-0.0038151431,
-0.005848181,
-0.0308976322,
-0.0098319463,
0.050242953,
0.0112192882,
-0.0356423482,
-0.0298247468,
0.0191241261,
-0.0108277285,
-0.0274518859,
-0.0035928525,
0.0114411358,
-0.0404926352,
-0.0033890666,
-0.0092236176,
0.0023688416,
0.0238264687,
0.0294783805,
-0.0122953625,
0.0194456857,
0.0122422613,
-0.0258886162,
-0.0234408751,
0.0417186208,
-0.0495357439,
-0.0377984978,
0.0090942075,
-0.0088017806,
-0.0325581022,
-0.0177459568,
-0.0371421203,
-0.0332904048,
-0.0434665047,
-0.096800521,
0.0236493908,
-0.0070279879,
0.0289237667,
0.028599225,
-0.0067468053,
-0.0245042089,
-0.0072246725,
-0.018171059,
0.0228070598,
0.026175512,
-0.0028774976,
0.011398498,
-0.0839965641,
-0.0528136082,
0.0106994892,
0.0002835557,
0.0100705791,
-0.0206598733,
0.0212750155,
-0.0545604415,
-0.0424989723,
-0.1574714035,
-0.0211969167,
0.0264264792,
-0.0106023531,
0.0339292325,
0.028197838,
-0.0157996677,
-0.0116285617,
-0.0823536813,
0.0277204588,
0.0698143244,
0.0026522165,
0.0602727383,
0.0195327625,
-0.0404181108,
-0.0420245677,
0.0177505128,
-0.0435394347,
0.0104909698,
0.0184063297,
-0.0063152332,
-0.0280901194,
0.0340978242,
-0.0416802727,
-0.0226594098,
0.0092503689,
-0.0820049644,
0.0100429468,
-0.0229025222,
-0.0175709669,
0.0431560837,
0.0275227595,
0.0317094959,
0.0093784677,
-0.0001066465,
-0.0313404687,
-0.0057338001,
-0.0105701555,
-0.0272861477,
-0.0008267922,
-0.0615698062,
0.0118534695,
0.077309683,
0.001700276,
0.0427646823,
-0.0187077057,
0.004681604,
-0.0033967684,
-0.0073216795,
-0.0191481207,
0.0099469172,
-0.0540600531,
0.0157879163,
0.015288149,
-0.0478371382,
0.096780166,
-0.0218348335,
0.008298751,
-0.0653906092,
-0.055884216,
-0.0470537655,
0.0113159204,
-0.0452866703,
0.0265964717,
0.0043636118,
-0.034779083,
0.0287967287,
-0.0135601675,
-0.0108640399,
-0.06851428,
0.0237737931,
-0.0248937104,
0.007171459,
0.0136423511,
-0.0133053167,
-0.036552038,
-0.0081900591,
-0.0252194274,
-0.0109934909,
0.0272485372,
0.0173540507,
-0.0336376503,
0.0486493297,
0.0044570463,
0.0127483616,
0.0173652675,
0.0051916563,
0.010264907,
0.0140399979,
0.0006509535,
0.0417367108,
0.0020824394,
-0.0111830365,
0.0639695749,
0.0685554668,
-0.0451823659,
0.0218030382,
-0.0018905732,
-0.0021462797,
-0.0108133592,
-0.0000140613,
-0.0141167697,
0.0171312001,
0.0256629772,
-0.0295211952,
0.0024653459,
0.1354670674,
0.0106490962,
-0.0556439832,
0.0073619289,
-0.0225142036,
-0.0362283885,
-0.0378102958,
-0.00752143,
-0.0771048442,
-0.0157132186,
-0.0094487825,
0.0311842393,
-0.0310142543,
-0.0092915501,
0.0195533223,
-0.0307286009,
0.027029587,
-0.0024722551,
-0.0116686318,
-0.00425913,
-0.0302871894,
0.016733937,
0.006854367,
0.0454657525,
-0.0031354097,
0.0061701713,
-0.0213707928,
-0.0046424684,
-0.1048301831,
-0.0650028214,
0.0531630926,
-0.0066128126,
0.0631697029,
0.0446241237,
0.0500436835,
-0.011300372,
-0.0343460999,
0.0157543253,
0.0391649529,
0.0431427732,
-0.0109526962,
0.0518409573,
0.0184301529,
-0.000506092,
-0.0723478124,
0.0140906824,
-0.0087800575,
0.0206097029,
0.0138020935,
0.0625343472,
-0.0743281022,
-0.0164302383,
-0.0390236937,
0.0396730229,
0.0533499494,
0.04946623,
0.0159757175,
-0.0286753941,
0.0059696585,
0.0362852439,
0.0069537233,
0.0374768712,
-0.0275457539,
-0.0011890894,
-0.0087895328,
-0.0399551839,
-0.0689722821,
-0.0259967968,
0.0232816692,
-0.0155685199,
0.0002946651,
0.0274060983,
-0.026404459,
0.0481144786,
-0.0212421585,
0.0493329689,
0.0599438511,
0.0527755581,
-0.0859161317,
-0.0043718563,
0.0743363723,
-0.0037291541,
0.0161315352,
0.0149607481,
-0.0137002328,
-0.0052064783,
-0.015390235,
0.0331095196,
0.0206040312,
-0.0125439446,
-0.0255539138,
-0.0463995039,
0.009935637,
0.020063797,
-0.0362919047,
0.0343058966,
0.0034761818,
0.0381252989,
-0.0179294609,
0.0041299164,
-0.0108325845,
0.0288095009,
-0.0292245876,
0.0449680351,
-0.0335733704,
-0.0808674544,
0.0159633551,
0.0624847375,
0.0154857514,
-0.0076244911,
-0.0170892943,
0.0071196984,
0.0218894705,
-0.0260124877,
0.007665961,
-0.0229106303,
0.0192343444,
-0.0045094094,
-0.0153120495,
0.0086131878,
-0.0387721248,
-0.090463385,
-0.0434215106,
-0.0130641218,
0.0865683779,
-0.0187864993,
-0.0481960066,
0.0606482625,
0.0098821577,
-0.0114874942,
0.0010133063,
-0.0045048129,
0.0033586242,
0.0135723222,
0.0759001151,
-0.0184542444,
0.003425834,
0.0342094377,
0.0804387107,
0.0036265717,
-0.0463612787,
-0.0082213664,
0.0632010326,
0.0452913195,
0.0434308536,
0.0241686553,
-0.0193800423,
0.0283032358,
-0.0187415089,
0.0115860002,
-0.0340392143,
-0.0009174583,
0.0549558923,
0.0028591349,
0.0166187789,
-0.0290396623,
0.0395195074,
-0.0415285341,
-0.0046482682,
-0.0251222588,
-0.0198236536,
-0.0559655465,
-0.0104767783,
0.0328769125,
-0.0122836279,
-0.0457107536,
0.0051121549,
-0.0632443577,
-0.0450261869,
0.0145149352,
-0.005022415,
-0.0366672687,
-0.0620778017,
0.058872439,
0.0361418463,
0.024241101,
0.0052326494,
-0.0135379303,
0.0315989219,
-0.0250865761,
-0.0007470822,
0.0063444488,
-5.942859362e-33,
-0.0085475547,
-0.0706427172,
0.0266228616,
-0.0049510919,
-0.01599456,
0.0042086472,
-0.0515089259,
0.0467100628,
0.0167095568,
0.0346274264,
-0.0224147458,
-0.0157894846,
0.0110106533,
0.0204285271,
-0.0183043499,
-0.0202511232,
0.0299934279,
0.0086386148,
-0.0279640537,
0.0217812173,
-0.0099088373,
0.0183786545,
0.0121828131,
-0.1154131293,
0.0080769565,
-0.0171753168,
0.0071757799,
0.026619859,
-0.0109207006,
0.0674270615,
-0.009087299,
0.0477211438,
0.0574587099,
0.0081143901,
-0.0071208291,
0.0260528307,
-0.0263135023,
-0.0253146533,
0.0285537224,
-0.0105208401,
-0.0261870138,
-0.0112277428,
0.0276195072,
-0.0214841012,
-0.0138082523,
0.0142234731,
0.0143110603,
-0.0332535319,
0.0138804931,
-0.0216584001,
-0.0163161345,
0.0554984696,
-0.0006108237,
-0.0485665277,
-0.0002141562,
-0.0077247382,
-0.0516323298,
-0.0257040281,
0.0016098686,
0.0131341955,
0.0267022494,
-0.0108426223,
0.0326893404,
-0.0220559705,
-0.0266329069,
0.0451222695,
0.0121344831,
0.007833017,
-0.0443535782,
-0.0053364099,
-0.0443507582,
0.0645829439,
0.0610861368,
0.024959432,
-0.0450278521,
-0.0102665639,
-0.026737133,
0.0358478129,
-0.005092422,
0.0590412579,
0.0156825334,
-0.0027864997,
-0.0874577388,
-0.0178125519,
-0.0209691431,
0.0464613289,
-0.0264195874,
-0.0592009611,
0.0411900431,
-0.0155229745,
0.0077208141,
-0.0701296702,
0.0210144054,
-0.0042814068,
0.0157885626,
-0.0470973589,
0.0429890715,
0.0276676025,
-0.0306420289,
-0.0247920733,
-0.0480033867,
-0.0067801489,
0.0266250242,
0.0131508131,
0.0501792915,
0.0054238467,
-0.0276563447,
-0.027159797,
-0.019378582,
0.0216678884,
0.019148577,
-0.0095370216,
-0.0267533455,
0.0092153791,
0.0029426038,
-0.0129543254,
-0.036317002,
0.0596280843,
-0.0205685757,
-0.0045088311,
-0.0643420517,
-0.0436704233,
-0.0084393863,
0.0074562924,
-0.0630651116,
0.0146197407,
-0.0298169907,
0.020363329,
0.044390738,
-0.0397145301,
-0.0017236997,
-0.0186355449,
2.863e-7,
0.0415525064,
0.0445179567,
0.0174028911,
-0.0038155762,
0.0484134443,
0.0209482424,
-0.0231296252,
0.0175247919,
0.0365392752,
-0.0479452461,
0.0330004171,
0.0165843517,
0.0575633571,
0.0265912209,
-0.0676306412,
-0.0242720004,
-0.0636522621,
-0.0337891504,
0.0025454666,
0.0011195617,
0.0984151363,
0.0273932163,
-0.0457871743,
-0.0369145758,
0.0184550472,
-0.0195616428,
0.030433191,
-0.0532990918,
-0.020421939,
0.0482016541,
0.0444809198,
0.0034453894,
0.0380271226,
0.0511765331,
0.0077427318,
-0.0156547297,
0.0015618524,
0.0817293972,
-0.0631002784,
-0.0299962889,
0.0267971102,
-0.0288854484,
0.0433805697,
-0.0363165252,
0.0339024737,
-0.0542598292,
-0.0316496827,
-0.0169652998,
0.0332732089,
-0.0426815301,
0.0632996336,
-0.052575428,
-0.0496415235,
0.0297904909,
0.0170492139,
0.0127750207,
-0.0141783291,
-0.0601391308,
-0.0199623685,
0.0140670696,
-0.0455063134,
-0.1102169231,
0.043972861,
-0.0394036099,
-0.0283801742,
-0.064924702,
0.0066594612,
2.249278594e-34,
0.0391727239,
0.0147691611,
0.014477564,
0.0504887253,
0.0463615321,
0.0203561243,
0.0452243499,
0.0396371782,
0.0404722206,
-0.0861889943,
-0.0031624727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07633v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07633v3 | A Survey on Model Compression for Large Language Models | 2023-08-15T08:31:05 | 2023-09-17T16:38:18 | Xunyu Zhu, Jian Li, Yong Liu, Can Ma, Weiping Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing
tasks with remarkable success. However, their formidable size and computational
demands present significant challenges for practical deployment, especially in
resource-constrained environments. As these challenges become increasingly
pertinent, the field of model compression has emerged as a pivotal research
area to alleviate these limitations. This paper presents a comprehensive survey
that navigates the landscape of model compression techniques tailored
specifically for LLMs. Addressing the imperative need for efficient deployment,
we delve into various methodologies, encompassing quantization, pruning,
knowledge distillation, and more. Within each of these techniques, we highlight
recent advancements and innovative approaches that contribute to the evolving
landscape of LLM research. Furthermore, we explore benchmarking strategies and
evaluation metrics that are essential for assessing the effectiveness of
compressed LLMs. By providing insights into the latest developments and
practical implications, this survey serves as an invaluable resource for both
researchers and practitioners. As LLMs continue to evolve, this survey aims to
facilitate enhanced efficiency and real-world applicability, establishing a
foundation for future advancements in the field. | [
-0.0258122254,
0.0977098197,
-0.0322092623,
0.0376080424,
-0.0612913556,
0.0002831665,
-0.0139493579,
0.0657772347,
-0.0256670229,
-0.0046684872,
0.0145854037,
-0.0422911011,
0.0241589509,
0.0200243592,
0.0089684501,
-0.0138655929,
0.0319389328,
-0.0516019911,
0.0025987555,
-0.0082103647,
-0.0169037413,
0.0021162033,
0.049309209,
0.0404100567,
-0.0035522485,
-0.0054695429,
0.0094761644,
0.0034011162,
-0.0361769274,
0.0093839588,
-0.0305591282,
0.0543775111,
0.0257753581,
0.0309859216,
0.0000020308,
-0.026792923,
-0.0192071497,
0.0343458429,
-0.0853206217,
0.0498333685,
0.049662523,
-0.0296674855,
-0.0030907446,
0.0217377208,
-0.01213123,
-0.0281308778,
0.0497945175,
0.0085182134,
0.0537670366,
0.0389312804,
0.001075306,
-0.0209784936,
0.0162281115,
-0.013011069,
-0.0611006171,
-0.0238151681,
0.0318821184,
0.0481377728,
-0.0110181766,
-0.0061705043,
-0.0205165911,
0.0349476263,
-0.0022802346,
0.0332566015,
-0.0276460256,
0.0115094446,
-0.0459147431,
-0.0165044684,
0.011036206,
0.045465447,
-0.0410726555,
-0.0378431119,
0.0143241435,
0.0170898419,
-0.021904435,
-0.0185655095,
-0.0514149666,
0.0246728919,
0.02236774,
0.0507775135,
-0.0239287522,
-0.0190979764,
0.0449031331,
0.0080383308,
-0.0575730577,
0.0401363671,
0.0266263783,
-0.0214629509,
-0.0202024579,
-0.0529200174,
-0.0713189766,
-0.0757260844,
-0.0050861971,
-0.003774279,
0.0083215479,
-0.0079623815,
-0.059709128,
-0.0243884735,
0.0145636732,
-0.0103128003,
0.0632057488,
0.0229454469,
0.044505693,
0.0408452563,
0.0026682077,
0.0778830871,
-0.001971131,
-0.0310852621,
-0.0390701555,
-0.0064831981,
-0.0550302677,
-0.0163927618,
-0.046744749,
0.0261725951,
-0.0414678864,
-0.0164560992,
-0.0131224943,
-0.0056016603,
0.0104429331,
0.0058210944,
0.0388881043,
-0.010029885,
0.0067658653,
-0.0135231363,
0.0132261645,
0.0321807265,
-0.0258358605,
-0.0027210463,
-0.0307781324,
-0.0578160696,
-0.014523359,
0.0345044248,
0.0044579613,
-0.0232428201,
0.0030114909,
0.0294020902,
0.0425505191,
-0.0433877781,
0.0053211753,
-0.0234077591,
-0.0213419758,
-0.0712122023,
-0.036378976,
-0.0743819848,
0.0207488015,
-0.0435289107,
0.0124091795,
-0.0786596611,
0.00038233,
-0.0179455504,
-0.0421520993,
0.0560822375,
-0.0057247826,
0.035538435,
-0.0082715629,
-0.0022564151,
0.0476964451,
0.0921010077,
0.042974513,
0.0189357344,
0.01735943,
-0.0306159463,
-0.0141319539,
0.0479393601,
0.0493446514,
0.0277022868,
-0.057709761,
-0.007562066,
0.0047733109,
0.0039863633,
0.017097814,
0.0980090797,
-0.0537075736,
-0.0304403212,
0.0484560244,
0.0470768921,
0.0341611728,
0.0468347035,
0.027935423,
0.0387831591,
0.017391013,
-0.0135974828,
-0.0130711766,
-0.0385945141,
-0.024305271,
0.0029665811,
0.0281542558,
0.069659315,
-0.0240002163,
-0.0190797597,
-0.0510943905,
-0.014281394,
0.0089884875,
0.0174778197,
0.0259147566,
-0.0160461012,
-0.0123766316,
0.1077130213,
0.0106192874,
-0.0486731678,
-0.0141377971,
-0.0677435324,
-0.0467452034,
0.0266956165,
0.0431456007,
-0.0115131484,
-0.0097163664,
0.0207737703,
-0.0238877852,
-0.0286545418,
-0.0086289523,
-0.0024264939,
0.0339558423,
-0.03357758,
-0.0177127682,
0.0113798091,
0.0289877467,
-0.0264450032,
0.0584923774,
0.0038800971,
0.0158061571,
-0.0678483695,
-0.0003034064,
0.0347423255,
-0.0445419997,
-0.0445669033,
0.0253359955,
-0.0187196266,
0.0643495247,
-0.0184826534,
-0.0303032584,
-0.0017721378,
0.0558338352,
-0.0388715267,
0.0089430176,
-0.0340579301,
0.0148814619,
-0.047716219,
0.0756874532,
0.002706595,
0.0485932529,
0.0593761019,
-0.0328310318,
-0.0297149234,
-0.0084061325,
-0.0396046229,
0.0417564958,
-0.0471170396,
0.0344150774,
-0.0297539309,
0.0538710579,
-0.0140563203,
0.0274875723,
-0.0522923954,
-0.0105523951,
0.0103266006,
-0.053835433,
-0.0067392155,
-0.0109449988,
-0.0214957315,
0.0278646629,
-0.0149167571,
0.0198911838,
0.0152267022,
-0.0169253666,
0.0059310743,
-0.0269641913,
-0.092860125,
0.0227326918,
-0.0012544018,
0.0254910216,
0.012564919,
0.0424412377,
-0.0102988463,
0.0226876568,
0.0032389483,
-0.0247949287,
0.0345539488,
0.0238065422,
-0.0110522332,
-0.003530628,
-0.0477429852,
-0.0234549791,
-0.0480778404,
0.0147218313,
0.0933149308,
-0.0839638561,
-0.0285394173,
-0.0524994098,
0.0407792516,
-0.0369654819,
0.0174115412,
0.0024164324,
-0.0208548438,
-0.0294897147,
0.0033428541,
0.0141398814,
0.0160740931,
-0.0124650318,
0.0442855582,
0.0909185112,
-0.0180119965,
-0.0383435376,
0.0066550979,
-0.0328799076,
-0.0218227059,
-0.0325797908,
-0.0686126873,
-0.0039480436,
0.0788144246,
-0.0119177438,
-0.0254065543,
-0.0493229851,
-0.0034703808,
-0.0254060756,
-0.0526696183,
-0.0385941714,
-0.0088934619,
-0.0076561137,
0.0488179959,
-0.0015256803,
-0.0444048829,
0.0268300511,
-0.0624045655,
0.0252099875,
-0.0051452327,
-0.0211153924,
-0.0275101457,
0.0621989593,
0.0179866292,
0.0358874351,
0.0235783122,
0.0314889066,
-0.02680571,
-0.0194682125,
0.0056967149,
-0.0374366939,
-0.00332925,
-0.0350644439,
0.039913822,
0.0073904507,
-0.0150156729,
0.0126399938,
-0.051543586,
-0.0240896903,
0.0518908836,
0.0413346589,
-0.005660268,
-0.0113754431,
0.0605970025,
-0.0226595644,
0.0112692723,
0.0290827304,
0.0188186597,
-0.0007996599,
0.0491987579,
0.0465288348,
0.0034842896,
0.0650966167,
-0.0096356003,
0.0293083023,
0.0529656261,
0.0326457582,
0.0533023775,
-0.0369044393,
-0.0202545244,
0.0389824435,
-0.0252593849,
-0.0214377958,
0.0213932395,
0.0363573171,
-0.0587055497,
0.0183753446,
0.1045657322,
0.0252192039,
-0.0004475757,
0.0215347447,
0.0134449843,
0.0810030922,
-0.0089113377,
0.0251187664,
-0.0681841746,
-0.0234015044,
0.044005204,
-0.0030173792,
0.0077146553,
-0.0339329205,
-0.0240202285,
-0.0819947124,
0.0256282575,
0.0351129696,
0.0065617501,
-0.0009930811,
-0.0574064627,
0.0108687896,
-0.0255939588,
-0.0005705133,
0.0057405974,
-0.010693145,
-0.0121702841,
-0.0016249691,
-0.0491087362,
-0.069276385,
0.0181493182,
0.0079337824,
0.0568279065,
0.0363895223,
0.0533474162,
0.0239619836,
0.0208155923,
0.0000523577,
0.0297778044,
-0.0002848631,
-0.027037628,
0.0214725845,
0.0086255847,
0.0142070279,
0.0358983539,
0.0144690722,
-0.020291537,
-0.0098260483,
-0.0094180973,
0.0958627164,
0.0072140191,
-0.0274852589,
-0.0215921868,
-0.0357445963,
-0.0096779205,
0.0914526954,
0.0471392982,
0.0160736647,
-0.0427328683,
0.0068115047,
-0.000257145,
0.0170930605,
-0.0451128334,
-0.0084021268,
-0.0130133014,
-0.0294605624,
-0.0412807241,
0.0228821114,
0.0195492692,
-0.0046630478,
-0.0176629871,
0.0176946651,
0.02669934,
0.0206447411,
-0.0744149834,
-0.0027814631,
-0.0724589005,
0.0006362888,
-0.0354965404,
0.0320948623,
-0.017313648,
-0.0028866732,
-0.0291589033,
-0.0029646333,
-0.150320828,
-0.0624348745,
-0.011825813,
0.0387945026,
0.0222416185,
0.0584879108,
0.0022894531,
-0.0647732317,
0.046094805,
0.0318735763,
-0.0371014215,
0.0556723103,
0.0114943916,
-0.046117045,
0.0090429913,
0.0631297082,
-0.0139230518,
0.0289477203,
-0.0263537783,
0.0402182229,
-0.0404377766,
-0.0671419054,
0.0141104283,
0.0638176054,
0.0243566539,
-0.0196858924,
-0.0307180285,
0.0283805653,
0.0088895774,
-0.0179539546,
-0.007490586,
-0.0516435057,
0.0255462211,
0.0217333026,
0.0175024476,
0.0046202401,
0.0079795895,
0.035903126,
0.0071580876,
0.0058289464,
0.0018338546,
-0.0172377098,
-0.0237740818,
0.0717245638,
0.0021222678,
-0.0004659723,
0.0064334264,
-0.0222430825,
0.0150691839,
-0.0459897406,
-0.0086308653,
-0.0160985868,
0.0319260433,
-0.0614360794,
0.0308655147,
-0.0122200428,
-0.0635562465,
-0.0264033545,
0.0285435934,
0.0372971445,
0.0085232854,
0.0332355723,
-0.0229796115,
-0.0297229607,
-0.0409716554,
0.0120357797,
0.0143489791,
0.0090891458,
-0.0075235926,
0.0201984625,
-0.036158286,
0.0360783562,
0.0940884128,
0.0415809527,
0.0560656302,
0.0059469459,
-0.0277748983,
-0.0433864146,
-0.0373516008,
-0.0496702194,
-0.0027725725,
0.0006273052,
0.0012845777,
-0.0635925382,
-0.0631178394,
0.0088177305,
-0.0029970428,
-0.0156251378,
-0.0235735569,
0.019505471,
0.0388132706,
0.0216762368,
0.0011410209,
-0.0384952873,
-0.0396804176,
-0.0292638838,
-0.0231255535,
0.0265032556,
-6.107162983e-33,
-0.0159323737,
0.0099945748,
0.0080466885,
-0.0555688031,
-0.0573701039,
0.0127912946,
-0.0007524302,
-0.0200911053,
-0.0174722355,
-0.0086702695,
-0.030877864,
0.0168509707,
0.0114483899,
0.016200209,
-0.0478770658,
0.0302986186,
0.0868013054,
-0.0208373833,
-0.019794913,
0.0253182389,
0.012448553,
0.024412401,
0.0170991011,
-0.0236907657,
-0.0369759016,
0.013500859,
0.0043584616,
0.0240839534,
0.010837514,
0.0514554903,
-0.0685756654,
0.0136216907,
0.0049413652,
-0.0265604462,
-0.0325635336,
0.0136735141,
-0.0465621576,
0.0033510281,
0.0335208364,
-0.0322892629,
0.0085285846,
-0.0411113724,
0.0384883918,
0.0025582851,
0.0022575057,
-0.0307224635,
-0.0268920995,
-0.0455689542,
-0.0513371937,
-0.0308350399,
-0.0235264357,
0.0385452248,
-0.0150278872,
-0.0127010122,
0.0851262212,
0.0173674207,
-0.0332624726,
0.0168694202,
-0.0146080274,
0.0055711395,
0.0524204522,
0.099269636,
0.0703089163,
0.0018058445,
0.0294286422,
0.0417077579,
-0.0068968935,
-0.0222058222,
-0.041978471,
0.0309259407,
0.0475227423,
0.0568823442,
0.0235014837,
0.0536516123,
0.050609272,
-0.0138908187,
-0.0701654851,
-0.0135448799,
-0.0061677289,
0.0433166996,
0.0154030891,
0.0333501957,
-0.014068909,
-0.026452722,
-0.0744743571,
-0.0044279727,
-0.0109934136,
-0.0091649164,
0.0073982822,
0.0189577118,
-0.0755290166,
-0.006752586,
0.0500121415,
-0.0864210799,
-0.0266748499,
0.033822313,
0.0033116138,
0.0188717172,
0.0303133521,
0.0405564457,
-0.0441875532,
-0.0100682415,
0.0031783001,
-0.0130301863,
0.0191217009,
-0.0250553004,
-0.0077867717,
0.0410246141,
-0.0450761914,
-0.0004064532,
-0.0140747521,
-0.0169714466,
-0.0033746348,
0.031026436,
0.042714268,
0.0263832919,
0.0232199579,
0.0050012488,
0.0345677026,
-0.0091056097,
-0.0116079403,
0.0222227015,
0.032440342,
0.0356301591,
-0.0019895085,
-0.0090046907,
-0.0695424005,
0.0063914605,
0.0638567805,
-0.012387855,
-0.0378304608,
0.0247915238,
2.602e-7,
0.0309827402,
0.0443192609,
0.0079265935,
-0.0266055502,
0.0113765672,
0.0085486881,
0.0104621714,
-0.0362671837,
-0.0045906575,
-0.0233953986,
0.030891085,
0.0465321802,
0.0509287678,
0.0208638497,
-0.0585835166,
0.0066087344,
-0.0327545032,
-0.0347594321,
-0.0475065969,
-0.0271711443,
0.0195740834,
0.1178803891,
0.0123508079,
-0.0122460723,
-0.0119826412,
-0.0146986367,
0.0396645889,
-0.0490732081,
0.0055268421,
0.0399950743,
0.0190899577,
-0.0087154582,
-0.0076291249,
-0.0203159805,
0.0199371427,
0.0195798408,
-0.0205801055,
0.1045599878,
-0.0019798274,
0.0269777328,
-0.0021979332,
-0.015413628,
-0.0529207364,
-0.0455462448,
0.0900928229,
-0.0202853289,
-0.0173267927,
-0.0861913785,
-0.0085482839,
-0.0310418606,
0.0053495117,
-0.0047245058,
0.0291856434,
0.023356488,
0.0043771425,
-0.0055096382,
-0.0129413512,
-0.0596645735,
-0.0184131842,
0.0108338352,
-0.0605418161,
-0.0372629538,
-0.0251111593,
-0.0210890118,
0.0249901749,
-0.0531212129,
0.0149180405,
2.765867035e-34,
0.0304350089,
0.0010210825,
0.0205655992,
0.0282299761,
0.0037341265,
-0.0418907255,
-0.0344785228,
0.0160605591,
-0.0376275927,
-0.0997288451,
-0.0017977855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07610v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07610v2 | Interpretable Online Log Analysis Using Large Language Models with Prompt Strategies | 2023-08-15T07:40:21 | 2024-01-26T02:46:11 | Yilun Liu, Shimin Tao, Weibin Meng, Jingyu Wang, Wenbing Ma, Yanqing Zhao, Yuhang Chen, Hao Yang, Yanfei Jiang, Xun Chen | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Automated log analysis is crucial in modern software-intensive systems for
facilitating program comprehension throughout software maintenance and
engineering life cycles. Existing methods perform tasks such as log parsing and
log anomaly detection by providing a single prediction value without
interpretation. However, given the increasing volume of system events, the
limited interpretability of analysis results hinders analysts' comprehension of
program status and their ability to take appropriate actions. Moreover, these
methods require substantial in-domain training data, and their performance
declines sharply (by up to 62.5%) in online scenarios involving unseen logs
from new domains, a common occurrence due to rapid software updates. In this
paper, we propose LogPrompt, a novel interpretable log analysis approach for
online scenarios. LogPrompt employs large language models (LLMs) to perform
online log analysis tasks via a suite of advanced prompt strategies tailored
for log tasks, which enhances LLMs' performance by up to 380.7% compared with
simple prompts. Experiments on nine publicly available evaluation datasets
across two tasks demonstrate that LogPrompt, despite requiring no in-domain
training, outperforms existing approaches trained on thousands of logs by up to
55.9%. We also conduct a human evaluation of LogPrompt's interpretability, with
six practitioners possessing over 10 years of experience, who highly rated the
generated content in terms of usefulness and readability (averagely 4.42/5).
LogPrompt also exhibits remarkable compatibility with open-source and
smaller-scale LLMs, making it flexible for practical deployment. Code of
LogPrompt is available at https://github.com/lunyiliu/LogPrompt. | [
0.0391134359,
0.0333895981,
0.0020960954,
0.0054618302,
-0.0045040948,
-0.0049532461,
0.0009578411,
0.0049567102,
-0.0008261047,
-0.0595715754,
0.0518194921,
-0.0332691297,
-0.0410624295,
0.0867627189,
-0.0030466083,
-0.0315437093,
0.0262093116,
-0.0439879261,
-0.0141372774,
0.0506820306,
0.0135357119,
0.0234298371,
-0.0080802739,
0.0714381933,
0.0216949917,
-0.0686026663,
-0.0117521938,
0.0447377004,
-0.0095711555,
-0.0264951941,
-0.0182425436,
-0.0010108319,
0.0288738981,
0.0148764411,
0.0000022668,
-0.074434936,
-0.0156667624,
0.0149075156,
-0.0791848972,
0.0475383699,
-0.012791669,
-0.0421789438,
-0.0092827762,
0.0200078338,
-0.0162368659,
-0.020405218,
0.0561026782,
0.040290352,
0.0617480129,
0.0285821501,
0.0010606828,
0.0050490675,
-0.0326675624,
0.0055779698,
0.0130735692,
-0.023305865,
0.014598188,
0.0252899602,
0.0266047455,
-0.0262045506,
-0.0056262598,
-0.0105101774,
0.0236052386,
-0.026185818,
0.0082923127,
0.0375177041,
0.03046076,
-0.0200196281,
0.0075234948,
0.0133833559,
-0.0377925336,
0.0041112928,
0.0319837779,
-0.0334309675,
-0.0210603885,
-0.0433742031,
-0.0324938223,
0.0226847455,
-0.0180743858,
-0.0120197255,
0.0176483802,
0.0158837941,
-0.0110909455,
-0.0154087842,
-0.0295088477,
0.0414675437,
-0.0420513973,
0.0006467716,
-0.0075321947,
0.0166850407,
-0.0052103596,
-0.0222745836,
0.0010598192,
0.0317475758,
-0.060801059,
0.0220185835,
0.0132218665,
0.0255443696,
0.0145833036,
0.0010689768,
-0.0116024362,
0.020074835,
-0.0181861091,
0.016541075,
-0.0013030093,
0.06453906,
0.0543141365,
-0.0251256842,
0.0065013687,
0.0059432159,
-0.0447372831,
-0.0140631525,
-0.0387562104,
-0.0079063503,
0.0089050084,
0.020394953,
0.0018771559,
0.0584028885,
0.0123840868,
0.0420725159,
0.0147243887,
-0.0421719253,
-0.0412502214,
0.0119227329,
-0.002788482,
-0.0224447809,
-0.012857643,
0.0040863031,
-0.0313386396,
-0.0563859008,
-0.016370032,
0.0012082855,
-0.0081419041,
-0.0121822283,
-0.0173915718,
0.0373497047,
0.0420290269,
0.0106943883,
-0.0316778272,
-0.0843042359,
0.013453708,
0.0101810126,
-0.0826011002,
-0.0281805322,
-0.0255588647,
0.0104764849,
0.0396826975,
0.0017167107,
-0.0223180335,
-0.0526286475,
0.0147941373,
0.0167687647,
-0.0543031096,
0.0213569589,
-0.0048446576,
0.0185028967,
0.00947267,
0.0590506308,
-0.0084900381,
0.0502490364,
0.0211288966,
-0.0385839045,
0.0495345555,
0.0085738683,
-0.0391373411,
-0.0371571667,
0.0020370819,
0.0192236286,
-0.0300400611,
-0.017189566,
0.0471206345,
-0.0152911926,
0.0266879275,
-0.0191526283,
0.0041397414,
0.0090120565,
0.0334703624,
0.0096946182,
0.0822176188,
0.0481448434,
-0.0326451398,
-0.0428999849,
-0.0042288601,
0.0212485977,
0.0046988586,
-0.000309041,
-0.0043853181,
0.0029582223,
-0.0100544393,
-0.0639993921,
0.0067426832,
0.0195494294,
-0.0631136224,
0.0234154817,
0.0433661267,
-0.0161692388,
0.0024811572,
0.0359944552,
0.0366696008,
0.0272557661,
0.0043090377,
-0.0365413763,
0.0141766584,
0.0963922366,
0.0244474933,
-0.0569674745,
-0.0425010473,
-0.0242523439,
0.0225535929,
-0.0245822463,
0.0095009459,
-0.0078353574,
0.0324701257,
-0.0270287376,
-0.008324218,
-0.0059379837,
0.0087056905,
0.0263884943,
-0.0293517523,
-0.0108530074,
-0.0018811134,
-0.0465606637,
-0.0735864416,
0.0203980431,
-0.0136549016,
-0.0600815825,
0.0245053563,
0.0128524648,
-0.0206319373,
-0.01007134,
-0.0249781944,
0.0016261531,
0.0556252375,
-0.0214364622,
-0.0379037596,
0.0558397658,
-0.0268852897,
0.0230657458,
0.0004681529,
0.0046178857,
-0.0056175585,
-0.0190181006,
-0.0805654526,
-0.0301863365,
0.0215138588,
-0.0790689215,
0.029663628,
0.0291367285,
-0.0152045833,
-0.0132596828,
-0.0253501274,
-0.0511165224,
0.0022438504,
0.0605304353,
0.0097470898,
-0.0352725983,
0.008302561,
0.0079956949,
-0.0112529928,
-0.021394223,
0.0313722156,
-0.0517204963,
-0.0041477354,
-0.0022797608,
-0.0042246664,
-0.0153042022,
0.0187285617,
-0.1114646271,
0.0024363364,
0.001934543,
0.0365018994,
0.051621221,
0.0443176813,
-0.0254604593,
-0.0101827998,
0.012765998,
-0.0059194211,
0.0007603233,
0.0238073114,
0.0194807369,
0.0575222485,
-0.0247903597,
0.0042492519,
-0.0206648353,
-0.0457301177,
0.0477994829,
0.0507670157,
-0.0145718008,
-0.1209583282,
0.0807601362,
0.0093289753,
-0.0121080456,
-0.0300624501,
-0.0194564108,
-0.0080019105,
-0.0442848355,
0.0633952394,
0.0629495978,
0.0089812092,
0.0527531244,
0.0197623242,
0.0147273522,
-0.0704467446,
-0.0206528064,
0.0237726811,
-0.0571693443,
-0.003602813,
-0.0336037055,
0.0297909528,
0.0731494054,
-0.0048696129,
-0.0234183427,
-0.0310028512,
-0.0338450596,
-0.0410470478,
0.0119589763,
-0.020669423,
-0.0526492633,
-0.007839798,
0.0357509404,
0.0248056985,
-0.0462636314,
0.0875216946,
0.0157715417,
-0.0330595411,
-0.0466434397,
-0.0762734413,
-0.0375544131,
0.107262753,
-0.016610764,
0.0134108299,
0.0349374823,
-0.0604562759,
0.0317950062,
-0.0190060828,
-0.0056504658,
-0.0216253418,
0.0280117597,
-0.0615211688,
0.0034787834,
0.0065982281,
0.0114366077,
-0.0032369648,
-0.1163339391,
-0.0393165424,
-0.0380956456,
-0.0256375987,
0.0044386717,
-0.051370278,
0.0072778771,
0.0121763954,
0.0370958298,
0.0534076653,
-0.0407775044,
-0.0005728523,
-0.0488458648,
0.0316231921,
0.0124654369,
0.0124071827,
-0.0434232019,
0.0491341054,
0.0382042043,
0.0399788171,
-0.0141319036,
-0.0281846449,
-0.0439989641,
-0.0039110058,
-0.0389735065,
0.0005667614,
0.0525362603,
0.0443611592,
-0.0979827195,
-0.0270691812,
0.105245553,
0.0219186153,
-0.0356728844,
0.0325144753,
-0.0129686547,
0.0242486354,
0.0368206762,
0.0343901888,
-0.093965739,
-0.0439695753,
0.0031507809,
0.0569824092,
-0.0195941497,
-0.0307054967,
-0.0037531364,
-0.0455273502,
-0.0083695175,
-0.0157960821,
-0.0073681828,
-0.0291171316,
-0.0933021456,
-0.029806599,
-0.0459300503,
-0.0108186416,
-0.0034429177,
-0.0003582361,
0.0399656594,
0.0464967974,
-0.0964980498,
-0.0366428122,
0.0877110288,
-0.0143569503,
0.0400069468,
0.0538102053,
-0.0411045849,
-0.0185677819,
0.0109849907,
0.0905561745,
0.0057428265,
0.0198338982,
-0.0119803334,
0.0195914805,
0.0371034704,
-0.0187614057,
-0.0013753342,
0.0140786441,
-0.0470898151,
0.0012059093,
0.0512981005,
0.0667645261,
-0.0355737954,
-0.0100768441,
0.0064952415,
0.011037658,
0.0496547483,
0.054763332,
0.0200918131,
-0.0678047016,
-0.0184667129,
-0.0319711678,
-0.0147052947,
0.0348003246,
-0.0198898464,
0.0088174473,
-0.0065124091,
-0.0273703206,
-0.0002333131,
-0.0334991142,
0.0135424724,
0.0420154482,
0.0082749147,
-0.0202719867,
0.0228492711,
0.0292025805,
-0.0310318004,
0.0583998039,
-0.0039497255,
0.0434508435,
-0.0565125532,
0.0581931919,
0.0352062099,
0.0267356634,
-0.0499652326,
0.0417701751,
-0.0201622583,
-0.0234678425,
0.0083941221,
0.0083481865,
0.0285481922,
-0.0047577661,
-0.0320667438,
-0.0386721231,
-0.051802624,
0.0223900825,
-0.0270699356,
0.0115768919,
-0.0004414585,
0.0323043019,
0.0205318145,
-0.0125114201,
-0.0463555306,
0.0076941876,
-0.0347123817,
-0.0406597629,
-0.052376885,
-0.0428012274,
0.0054895584,
0.0235203709,
0.0248167738,
0.0531812795,
-0.0597970597,
0.0310194679,
0.0153324967,
0.0078379111,
-0.023046175,
-0.0231398195,
0.0571298748,
0.0102187265,
-0.0414767936,
-0.0025625664,
0.0299933646,
-0.039600011,
0.0028793344,
-0.0481302664,
0.0172095653,
0.001238851,
0.0345790908,
0.0505936369,
-0.0081709819,
-0.0284950063,
-0.0198336504,
0.0209899358,
0.0729043633,
0.0221208148,
0.0625011176,
0.0025449682,
0.0148226162,
0.0077781114,
0.0113037592,
-0.0617939383,
-0.035423968,
0.0338840187,
-0.0548014641,
0.0178143401,
0.018437542,
0.0308041312,
-0.0005854538,
0.0524957515,
-0.0369758084,
0.0461242385,
0.0059974734,
-0.0185704641,
0.0272323191,
0.0145159094,
-0.0342169441,
-0.026483424,
0.0668496937,
0.021205131,
0.0474528559,
-0.0015987252,
-0.0237467997,
-0.0383395217,
0.0046092891,
0.041728545,
0.0189206321,
-0.0314858407,
-0.0272481032,
-0.0537692606,
0.0186720863,
0.0084523493,
0.0027808778,
-0.0093515487,
-0.0313835666,
0.0038631347,
0.0680422559,
0.007113094,
0.0210241433,
-0.0172570385,
0.0170736965,
0.0258179363,
-0.017813364,
-0.0072181663,
-5.62939763e-33,
0.0001136595,
-0.0519735217,
-0.0216533579,
-0.013108179,
-0.0161937606,
0.0205976814,
-0.0582525432,
0.0079062507,
0.011507811,
-0.0061643398,
0.0458513349,
0.0160445906,
0.0122617558,
-0.0464041568,
0.0261442866,
0.0001790944,
0.0327482596,
0.0575525165,
0.0209888313,
0.060133554,
0.0599310957,
0.0302658342,
-0.0060111587,
-0.103376478,
0.0631535724,
0.0024005943,
-0.0050826562,
0.0031606569,
0.026807325,
0.0469250828,
-0.0050251568,
0.0186314061,
0.0159510728,
-0.0541395172,
-0.0483696423,
-0.0202098843,
0.0021030214,
0.00547264,
0.017320035,
0.0079407766,
0.0330687612,
-0.0113264006,
0.0356080495,
0.0132853761,
0.0247630496,
-0.0012670112,
0.0532481633,
-0.0008597103,
-0.0028092186,
-0.0414591618,
-0.0205430016,
-0.002166589,
-0.0645384565,
0.0027289039,
-0.0017646474,
0.0802091062,
0.0275967829,
-0.0057705259,
-0.0264587142,
0.0036097274,
-0.0087938011,
-0.0023784409,
0.0294443332,
-0.0139402468,
-0.0262103584,
0.0072096689,
-0.0273867361,
-0.0123488093,
-0.0202272665,
0.008603625,
0.0121512776,
0.0237274636,
0.0024357331,
0.0285199359,
0.0359889343,
-0.002078824,
-0.0884592757,
0.0424366444,
0.0334317051,
0.0114602093,
0.0612828434,
0.0228025094,
-0.0676561296,
-0.0026427354,
-0.0068912837,
0.0414968655,
-0.0435824916,
0.0131128766,
0.0313258804,
0.0098047471,
-0.0443013981,
0.0090292674,
0.0328891911,
-0.0452350751,
-0.0217495896,
0.0098508047,
-0.0081766425,
-0.0219107904,
-0.0298870001,
0.0105858007,
0.0202824101,
-0.0199669898,
0.0214826055,
0.0277761072,
0.0784599707,
-0.0215297118,
0.0066525233,
0.0199588574,
-0.0554393865,
0.0050284476,
-0.0375955887,
0.0245915111,
-0.0562045947,
0.0269524027,
0.0545606688,
-0.0190141704,
0.0083942311,
0.0747567862,
-0.0044295331,
-0.0751077905,
-0.0089305667,
0.021142697,
0.0122032128,
-0.0099771125,
-0.0438261814,
-0.040872205,
-0.0108434362,
-0.0182641018,
0.0432041399,
0.004951173,
-0.0149789425,
-0.0032052884,
2.951e-7,
0.0053946879,
0.0446720459,
0.0070356624,
-0.0418336764,
0.0505016372,
0.0507849082,
0.0101662446,
-0.0050057727,
0.0098645268,
-0.0159891527,
-0.007524461,
-0.0046589733,
0.0528374165,
0.0167843178,
-0.0265142117,
-0.0352662802,
-0.0248112287,
-0.012569177,
-0.1217664182,
0.0471954942,
0.1329804063,
0.0842592046,
-0.0031445776,
0.0201592576,
0.084995769,
-0.0479517542,
-0.044560656,
-0.0309813041,
0.0216235779,
-0.0033024568,
0.0229053143,
0.0414038748,
0.0367758609,
-0.008450387,
-0.0126222931,
-0.0501186401,
-0.0586973615,
0.1140644699,
0.0082857031,
0.0281631686,
0.0035059762,
-0.0429655761,
0.015742287,
-0.0805919021,
0.0463914163,
-0.0327392332,
-0.06163821,
-0.0292947479,
0.0087961834,
-0.0369918235,
-0.0344187133,
-0.0030394292,
-0.0061149462,
0.0067071649,
0.0032487437,
-0.0679791346,
-0.0170970205,
-0.0416604131,
-0.0555130392,
0.0105613107,
-0.036643099,
-0.0025418212,
-0.0540791415,
0.0444226079,
0.06344717,
-0.0302894525,
0.0305986945,
2.920777675e-34,
0.0161113646,
0.0149806859,
0.0222520381,
-0.0085149202,
0.0423085615,
0.0258392654,
-0.0345441364,
0.0232949127,
0.0198637154,
-0.0478821956,
-0.0090052094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07601v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07601v1 | VBD-MT Chinese-Vietnamese Translation Systems for VLSP 2022 | 2023-08-15T07:10:41 | 2023-08-15T07:10:41 | Hai Long Trieu, Song Kiet Bui, Tan Minh Tran, Van Khanh Tran, Hai An Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present our systems participated in the VLSP 2022 machine translation
shared task. In the shared task this year, we participated in both translation
tasks, i.e., Chinese-Vietnamese and Vietnamese-Chinese translations. We build
our systems based on the neural-based Transformer model with the powerful
multilingual denoising pre-trained model mBART. The systems are enhanced by a
sampling method for backtranslation, which leverage large scale available
monolingual data. Additionally, several other methods are applied to improve
the translation quality including ensembling and postprocessing. We achieve
38.9 BLEU on ChineseVietnamese and 38.0 BLEU on VietnameseChinese on the public
test sets, which outperform several strong baselines. | [
0.0204151664,
0.0363732129,
0.013230822,
0.0226924885,
0.0058620716,
-0.0283511151,
-0.0017789829,
0.0311566219,
-0.0673380345,
0.0099990377,
-0.0337465107,
-0.0766788647,
0.0380799249,
0.007610077,
0.0285112169,
-0.0637182891,
0.0240494628,
0.0246813037,
-0.0328526944,
0.0027917528,
-0.0166676324,
0.0054443395,
0.0456083193,
0.0366888233,
-0.0027509644,
-0.0093202516,
0.0060267486,
0.0557245277,
0.0291167703,
-0.019140996,
-0.0248211976,
0.0260998961,
-0.0100293607,
0.0536018275,
0.0000024048,
-0.0321475677,
-0.053873729,
-0.0035673261,
-0.0023175739,
0.008396876,
0.0466286279,
-0.0643826872,
-0.0017260908,
0.0260472856,
0.0034969128,
-0.0607939996,
0.0531687103,
0.035130877,
0.0738430768,
0.0585450642,
-0.026853539,
-0.0215930715,
0.0088686347,
-0.0345909782,
-0.0288640615,
-0.0365489796,
-0.0333950967,
0.0095466673,
-0.0172313787,
-0.0172471628,
-0.0023357463,
0.0603250265,
0.0124162957,
-0.0000202119,
-0.0182626005,
0.0024021356,
0.0431354977,
-0.0543915331,
-0.0220861342,
0.0870167241,
-0.0601070374,
-0.009310226,
-0.0434403159,
-0.0017736956,
-0.023371689,
-0.0448263623,
-0.0394928381,
0.0145513555,
0.0104845669,
0.0121728256,
-0.0111824786,
0.0456323996,
0.0556165539,
0.0070799892,
-0.0172355957,
-0.0711560398,
0.0147941662,
-0.0432060882,
-0.0282543153,
-0.0020858836,
0.0104774451,
0.0127733843,
0.0747981369,
0.0031326066,
0.0129714832,
-0.0001251687,
0.0022792129,
-0.0378362574,
-0.0125382971,
-0.0527665541,
0.0118210642,
0.0567670017,
-0.0296608321,
0.0086718407,
-0.0054697166,
0.0674430877,
-0.0246710163,
-0.0031930907,
-0.0692297667,
-0.0339568071,
-0.0051023387,
0.0508664884,
-0.0430322811,
0.0179322436,
-0.0513339825,
-0.0101028141,
-0.0292957686,
-0.0391927958,
0.0100305416,
-0.0290162005,
0.036518909,
0.0098371487,
-0.0998381451,
-0.0325561054,
0.0127203669,
0.0826138258,
0.0597729683,
-0.0340757817,
-0.002475047,
-0.0409123562,
-0.0284134392,
0.0134418299,
0.0042865635,
-0.0307617728,
0.0141183063,
0.0705691501,
-0.0267553683,
-0.0032330295,
-0.0201806836,
0.0339782871,
0.0018264983,
-0.0335671715,
0.0174654741,
-0.0479002893,
0.0472803526,
-0.0213065483,
0.0446997024,
-0.0356108733,
0.0188746918,
0.0025245124,
-0.0007840965,
0.082685031,
-0.0007697901,
-0.0037805056,
0.0280081071,
-0.0048654862,
0.045111388,
0.0451134108,
0.0591590628,
0.0302599724,
0.0355921462,
0.0178679787,
0.0048966398,
0.0564336628,
-0.0130318822,
-0.0026772383,
-0.0526776463,
-0.0234702881,
0.0081295082,
0.0312744603,
0.0442051739,
0.0751756653,
-0.0453777201,
0.0263734795,
0.0533174723,
-0.0131025678,
0.0303322393,
0.0205622148,
0.0388866067,
-0.0152249159,
-0.0093229171,
-0.0267374609,
-0.0043121944,
0.0283676181,
-0.0026506891,
0.0063764928,
0.0193934366,
0.0479861945,
-0.0187009443,
-0.0715637952,
-0.0026099733,
-0.0289212521,
0.0120235672,
-0.023213448,
0.0154109821,
0.0304139722,
-0.0733520314,
0.0676124617,
-0.0110085392,
-0.0436137766,
0.0178354718,
-0.0300588291,
-0.0475765243,
0.0605986454,
0.0714624152,
0.0472032055,
-0.0416301899,
-0.0429501757,
-0.0430868417,
0.0657966658,
0.0265409108,
0.0112535637,
0.0533936024,
-0.0782816187,
-0.0194123741,
0.0482034162,
-0.0079546236,
0.0345275775,
-0.0086621596,
0.0140032405,
0.0357885174,
-0.0366705172,
-0.0541179664,
0.0172552373,
-0.0233554766,
-0.0228506848,
0.0303934235,
0.0244440418,
0.0128649231,
0.034952607,
-0.0231648181,
-0.002640435,
0.0105794137,
-0.0328905657,
0.0046929438,
0.0118639357,
-0.0600828119,
-0.0448887534,
0.0502618961,
-0.0399510376,
-0.0246806573,
0.0473347716,
-0.0237871781,
-0.057872247,
-0.0296087135,
-0.002505996,
-0.046868857,
-0.0578186885,
0.0625590831,
-0.0149756568,
0.0261071026,
-0.0554556325,
0.0039913808,
-0.0065507768,
0.0118962219,
0.0131655652,
-0.0170375109,
0.0367057584,
-0.0238506198,
-0.0435470454,
0.0501352288,
-0.0008427754,
0.0471926108,
0.0223806538,
0.068635948,
0.0084339781,
-0.0151239056,
-0.0520778783,
0.0331397727,
-0.0311758406,
0.0005290934,
0.0232602973,
0.0477253944,
-0.0046251621,
-0.034202341,
0.0101618357,
0.0237073284,
0.0056655398,
-0.0325036831,
0.0143123008,
-0.0166094322,
0.0396307446,
-0.0291233398,
-0.0014059463,
0.0327996127,
-0.0040090303,
-0.0028357951,
-0.0568652079,
-0.0553071946,
0.0378735848,
-0.0102733783,
-0.0042702188,
0.0196435954,
-0.0827707052,
-0.0123144053,
-0.0201453492,
0.0341809541,
0.0223482978,
-0.0162602179,
0.0272274241,
0.0138894627,
0.0188971441,
-0.0427732728,
0.0131224329,
-0.0288745314,
-0.0117798541,
-0.037387345,
-0.0403040051,
0.0010444721,
0.0403384455,
-0.0029125831,
0.0153869567,
-0.0496075153,
-0.0548196882,
-0.0084999464,
-0.0202612337,
0.0279346239,
0.0326284803,
-0.0194242243,
0.0116672348,
-0.0378335118,
-0.0263712294,
0.0328549221,
-0.0281378627,
-0.0380764864,
-0.0888240337,
0.0226238202,
0.0087868785,
0.0366233811,
-0.0043338174,
0.0220647007,
0.0149017898,
-0.0497511402,
-0.0402814187,
0.0436008833,
0.0008090144,
-0.0385578908,
0.0257744603,
-0.0354527496,
-0.0271541588,
-0.0334167778,
-0.0014794745,
-0.0393258557,
0.0159540735,
0.004785412,
0.0190306846,
0.0266979001,
0.0058897468,
-0.0214632191,
0.0496956967,
-0.0076738289,
0.0282597225,
0.0102279149,
0.0035438582,
-0.0177667849,
0.0477718376,
0.0118205622,
0.0065598879,
0.0245776623,
-0.0347127318,
0.0492752679,
0.0316555388,
0.0258775651,
-0.0109290779,
-0.0211364273,
-0.0311866365,
0.0650329739,
0.0091277482,
-0.0234907717,
0.0062665604,
0.0509098731,
-0.03524841,
-0.0103357639,
0.1189679652,
0.0002942796,
-0.0515052378,
-0.0080221435,
0.0204340369,
0.0100164358,
0.0177421719,
-0.0043620518,
-0.0704921931,
-0.0145011097,
0.0215391424,
-0.0185575616,
0.0379213952,
0.0467225425,
-0.0216299035,
-0.1210335642,
0.0365557447,
0.0500920303,
-0.0257093329,
-0.0326478295,
-0.0332994834,
-0.0523614436,
-0.0510604084,
0.0825026333,
-0.0384070911,
0.0154565992,
-0.0215790272,
0.0214982778,
0.0405995473,
-0.0747459978,
-0.0061798259,
-0.0492035933,
0.0305416398,
0.0656118765,
0.0672286302,
-0.0079505201,
-0.0085035898,
0.0358191989,
0.0046431809,
0.0162707362,
-0.0034689205,
0.0248359628,
0.000235259,
-0.0153473075,
0.0243297089,
-0.0097852917,
-0.021615997,
0.0174503941,
0.006871698,
0.0392252542,
-0.00302818,
-0.0027014292,
0.0172245763,
0.0018557449,
-0.030704299,
0.0316634104,
0.0138799306,
-0.0436956249,
0.0049342085,
-0.0129934484,
0.0027814985,
-0.0613929927,
-0.0237033758,
0.0250688978,
-0.1057825685,
-0.0717190504,
-0.0688634291,
-0.0784884915,
0.000147267,
0.0440090857,
0.0082933493,
-0.0157120079,
0.0289874878,
0.0318953842,
-0.012383284,
0.0214168224,
-0.0098536275,
0.0131091261,
-0.0415812097,
0.0246461537,
-0.0181705039,
-0.0100029903,
0.0245394353,
0.0262392331,
-0.0504032969,
-0.0544173047,
-0.0127764437,
0.0522676595,
0.0204605926,
0.0471604802,
-0.0237140544,
-0.0151317921,
0.0227693599,
-0.0028796373,
0.0026874912,
-0.058851473,
0.0530186035,
-0.0486479849,
-0.0132296067,
0.0400513485,
0.0152481124,
0.0174715966,
0.0129345674,
0.0601462051,
0.003265202,
-0.0264442749,
0.0428127386,
0.0355440341,
0.0458954498,
-0.0563400052,
-0.0135755325,
-0.0417056754,
0.0181062631,
-0.0227488782,
-0.0247921105,
-0.041545853,
0.0074763643,
0.0769445226,
0.0271105673,
-0.0020604299,
-0.0042147879,
0.0056425021,
-0.0673457533,
0.0184256863,
-0.0243364498,
-0.0436273105,
0.0641748086,
0.0192473568,
0.0162146799,
-0.0075154626,
-0.0080081802,
0.0304825958,
-0.0021385411,
-0.0187556092,
0.043970041,
-0.0222692862,
0.0542863086,
-0.0252672434,
0.0431091599,
-0.0313540138,
0.0006809391,
-0.051389426,
-0.0222308934,
0.0953768492,
0.0123793874,
0.1233043447,
0.0099565769,
-0.0070321588,
-0.0131987259,
0.0471712835,
-0.0084415153,
0.0138669861,
-0.032203801,
-0.0386484712,
-0.0113991695,
-0.0093243597,
0.0809364617,
-0.037215583,
0.0227388572,
0.0243858602,
0.0110333469,
-0.0135358525,
0.0036013632,
0.0106415339,
0.0250269063,
-0.0273779519,
0.0049473261,
-0.0013068295,
-0.0447042771,
0.0313074067,
-0.0024971634,
0.0080277566,
0.0045382362,
-0.0072527737,
0.0585151687,
-0.0138528934,
0.025629174,
-0.0284692142,
-0.0209787618,
0.0103379898,
0.0127916811,
-0.0192779563,
-6.75212404e-33,
-0.0330338478,
0.0344030038,
-0.0028456543,
-0.0445280895,
-0.0335993655,
-0.0101256324,
-0.0268306453,
-0.0107824393,
-0.0143087609,
0.0135111343,
-0.0128463022,
0.0108908173,
0.0419743918,
0.0279619377,
0.0111441445,
0.0356214903,
0.0809724405,
0.0146704447,
-0.0008385565,
0.0045175585,
0.0006524357,
0.0583331548,
0.0904803127,
-0.0546596125,
-0.003228992,
0.0021858837,
-0.0105377659,
0.0213471781,
0.0251376834,
0.0276826527,
-0.0063207163,
0.0422450155,
0.0095775528,
-0.0391525663,
-0.0493298769,
-0.0841666162,
-0.1068813056,
-0.0022562323,
-0.0053702169,
0.0703540668,
-0.0081846304,
-0.0213683918,
0.0431855582,
-0.0220515747,
-0.0200433768,
-0.0230883658,
0.0052498598,
-0.062121667,
-0.0128882229,
-0.0171145312,
-0.041726999,
0.0142954625,
0.0015468192,
-0.0215857942,
0.0463146232,
0.0433619469,
-0.0507059842,
0.0021079162,
-0.107993044,
-0.0086922087,
0.0112000788,
0.0461501144,
0.0738101155,
-0.0024765457,
-0.0190380011,
-0.0349344835,
0.0352940783,
-0.0355288871,
0.0296598095,
0.0018344059,
0.0281383954,
0.0617630966,
0.0607777722,
0.0316237733,
0.060448885,
-0.0404088087,
-0.0299000405,
0.0625704378,
-0.0270608906,
0.0190894697,
0.0004282771,
0.0205969177,
-0.0003625182,
-0.0170144737,
-0.039308425,
-0.0488750525,
-0.0036006349,
-0.0667074546,
-0.0100707356,
0.0312835053,
-0.0396117158,
-0.0102705518,
0.074901484,
-0.0659514889,
0.0086707193,
-0.0266994014,
-0.0085306764,
-0.0183050502,
-0.0336882845,
0.0408310741,
-0.0321725048,
-0.0545043163,
0.0036426787,
0.0110341413,
-0.0326934494,
-0.0250110384,
0.0186746679,
0.0230976976,
-0.0529989712,
0.0119717354,
-0.0465316251,
-0.0346504301,
0.0221002828,
0.0736335441,
-0.0028563428,
-0.0220312346,
-0.0029850425,
0.0095929485,
0.0322276987,
0.0224967301,
-0.0129719814,
-0.0126751848,
0.0459309407,
0.0237339474,
-0.0495127216,
0.0166811086,
-0.0558166504,
-0.016266074,
0.0442683324,
-0.0301249456,
-0.0420759022,
-0.0259366054,
3.02e-7,
0.0377323292,
0.0309924185,
0.051939901,
0.0036187898,
-0.0308130458,
0.0100891478,
-0.0165144913,
0.0109178061,
-0.0194153488,
0.0404110886,
0.0353798121,
0.0072640157,
0.0826686025,
0.0077363569,
-0.0399476439,
-0.0252404269,
-0.0084257321,
-0.003136321,
-0.0153091354,
-0.0098312395,
0.0067902487,
0.1064588577,
-0.0398695692,
-0.0136358058,
0.0185032319,
0.0053112945,
0.0437411107,
0.0024625668,
-0.041310437,
0.047643397,
0.0657132939,
-0.0104136318,
-0.0351345427,
-0.0396832898,
-0.0357806757,
0.011714492,
0.0631852075,
0.0601542369,
-0.015428151,
-0.0092033315,
0.0203334112,
0.0162243396,
-0.0270927325,
-0.0109118968,
0.0440018289,
-0.0089252433,
-0.0202366728,
0.0197569039,
-0.0098903785,
0.0410648584,
0.0427487195,
-0.0423226058,
-0.0430909619,
0.015298076,
0.054134246,
0.0172034465,
-0.0428219661,
-0.0340533666,
-0.0483006872,
-0.0180824213,
0.0043426109,
-0.0307892505,
0.0230500549,
-0.0596213862,
0.0109620914,
0.0088073043,
-0.0161991697,
2.709876999e-34,
0.0462275706,
-0.0118102049,
0.0094682276,
0.0083146775,
0.0187229719,
-0.0732045025,
-0.0270578545,
0.0059201876,
-0.0549213141,
-0.0110658426,
-0.0436770841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07556v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07556v1 | A User-Centered Evaluation of Spanish Text Simplification | 2023-08-15T03:49:59 | 2023-08-15T03:49:59 | Adrian de Wynter, Anthony Hevia, Si-Qing Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We present an evaluation of text simplification (TS) in Spanish for a
production system, by means of two corpora focused in both complex-sentence and
complex-word identification. We compare the most prevalent Spanish-specific
readability scores with neural networks, and show that the latter are
consistently better at predicting user preferences regarding TS. As part of our
analysis, we find that multilingual models underperform against equivalent
Spanish-only models on the same task, yet all models focus too often on
spurious statistical features, such as sentence length. We release the corpora
in our evaluation to the broader community with the hopes of pushing forward
the state-of-the-art in Spanish natural language processing. | [
-0.0243170336,
0.0226931069,
-0.0312431362,
0.027788179,
-0.0305974316,
0.0034842887,
0.0073344209,
0.007189367,
0.0098854518,
0.0207604449,
-0.0205850322,
0.0369883701,
0.0326191187,
-0.0203501955,
0.0268307272,
-0.0508766957,
0.0131110335,
0.0007381014,
0.0098620169,
0.0140094943,
0.0409033932,
0.0114631234,
0.0125443861,
0.0254160054,
0.0312214699,
-0.0127392355,
0.0400387235,
-0.0053243665,
-0.0081557836,
0.0447543673,
0.0252787657,
0.0507768467,
-0.0461152382,
0.0427903645,
0.0000018178,
-0.0138840796,
-0.0351560377,
-0.0046466594,
0.0207165387,
0.0452994294,
0.0965249985,
-0.0335970782,
-0.0259282701,
0.010038971,
-0.0226664674,
-0.0240976531,
0.0341044925,
0.0185054485,
0.025465494,
0.0269929189,
-0.0452220626,
-0.0615956374,
-0.0512084588,
-0.0284393486,
-0.0336201601,
0.0047052912,
-0.0091109751,
-0.0125096738,
0.0034307807,
-0.0392678306,
0.0000039588,
0.0694377795,
0.0312367771,
-0.0559317321,
-0.0188812055,
-0.0058954991,
-0.0032069655,
-0.0147501165,
0.0006653615,
0.0801073313,
-0.0846401602,
-0.0496515743,
-0.0008491109,
0.0000553486,
0.0009649293,
-0.0185120571,
-0.0457590893,
-0.0464633927,
-0.0049684318,
0.0153655121,
-0.013406503,
-0.0014801353,
0.0372032337,
0.0111052087,
-0.0120498529,
0.0240575615,
0.0269930605,
-0.0266216323,
0.0253263004,
0.0141194016,
0.0412064232,
-0.0482844636,
0.0922449678,
0.0189971179,
-0.0023256694,
-0.009371018,
-0.0130837867,
-0.0957882851,
-0.0018348906,
-0.0808412284,
0.0085401358,
0.0296565164,
-0.0004440939,
0.0162553508,
-0.0390088111,
0.0616790764,
0.0256738011,
0.0032831391,
-0.0335052833,
-0.005892938,
0.0102226064,
0.0113500087,
-0.0391517468,
0.0274238624,
-0.0439540483,
-0.0056011761,
-0.0219417475,
-0.019562738,
0.0245580673,
-0.027486477,
0.0177614316,
-0.0079398267,
0.0050168438,
-0.0090513853,
0.0125560453,
0.0826472417,
-0.0524105392,
0.01383908,
-0.0108771902,
-0.0748845488,
0.0140743228,
0.0248760339,
0.0193775091,
0.0086263232,
0.0134118851,
-0.0050223791,
-0.0585113093,
0.0041386336,
-0.0304202456,
-0.0237131026,
0.0074909613,
-0.0541242845,
-0.0190437138,
-0.0812377557,
0.0346320048,
-0.006848298,
0.0117325196,
-0.0529206321,
-0.0296156127,
0.02394717,
-0.0169356056,
0.0506912097,
-0.0287461281,
0.0088026877,
0.0218125433,
-0.0030577087,
0.019472573,
0.0475015305,
0.0324884579,
0.0322778039,
0.060591884,
-0.0085450439,
0.0368095748,
0.0735474527,
-0.0406509228,
-0.0424843952,
0.0215979666,
-0.03905911,
-0.0912770405,
0.0134839155,
0.0571579076,
0.0567933433,
-0.0178515483,
0.0079034371,
0.07102146,
0.059300784,
0.0351760872,
0.0340202935,
0.0722702071,
0.0325073116,
0.0508265384,
0.0504127294,
0.0054299175,
-0.0182785653,
-0.0332424492,
0.0408262052,
0.0167607069,
0.0055669877,
-0.0305384379,
-0.0780492574,
0.0291625075,
-0.0316323489,
0.0579902269,
-0.0260225441,
0.0334482417,
0.0233363137,
-0.0522585995,
-0.023448037,
-0.0155370729,
-0.079038091,
0.0136888856,
-0.0002440402,
0.0022801491,
0.089000687,
0.0401072837,
0.0064542335,
-0.0046122731,
0.0052155186,
-0.0010885688,
0.0388407819,
0.0501946025,
-0.0207393747,
0.051421795,
-0.0721129403,
0.010131699,
0.0419689342,
0.0173436496,
0.0213466212,
0.0008908404,
-0.0087439008,
0.0050385073,
-0.0382030606,
-0.0577558428,
0.0208047926,
-0.0224370807,
-0.0293471552,
0.015290089,
0.0229706503,
-0.0118730972,
0.050081864,
-0.0092811119,
-0.0045489669,
0.0092360368,
-0.0196439754,
-0.0083719781,
0.0193991736,
-0.0217777472,
-0.05890074,
0.0067401961,
-0.0563027002,
-0.012735405,
0.0493569337,
-0.0103939241,
-0.018245345,
0.0010746593,
-0.0664525107,
-0.0004712736,
-0.0321521498,
0.0532709807,
-0.0358089283,
0.0254919268,
-0.0464408286,
0.0169843268,
-0.0016799037,
0.0415828787,
0.034312658,
-0.0705818087,
0.0241548195,
-0.0384732261,
-0.0096061267,
-0.0023059179,
-0.0116203828,
-0.0012735236,
0.0435555167,
0.0418063477,
0.0084545799,
0.0205284338,
-0.0794386491,
-0.0021202038,
-0.0273340307,
0.0233654473,
0.040800564,
0.0057437671,
-0.0209285412,
-0.0336140059,
-0.0262899976,
-0.0149771236,
0.002802901,
0.0012320465,
0.0450024642,
0.0063006235,
-0.0191493183,
-0.0595299192,
-0.0088174408,
0.0011892767,
0.0356964543,
0.0470727719,
-0.0680539012,
-0.0421231389,
-0.0007185447,
0.0129523948,
-0.0074907616,
0.0377040207,
-0.0470830686,
-0.0509734154,
0.0132190241,
0.0578483529,
0.0783692449,
-0.0250616353,
0.0242247321,
0.0198181849,
0.0258793402,
-0.0236316584,
0.0123779299,
-0.0000646036,
-0.0027818375,
-0.0411812067,
-0.0937020034,
0.0563829355,
0.0691121295,
0.0039982344,
0.0215393268,
-0.0275319908,
-0.0199878719,
-0.0236770287,
-0.0313423201,
-0.013829763,
0.0086307544,
0.0111708771,
0.0331253558,
-0.0220407583,
-0.046757672,
0.0591456592,
-0.0296078492,
-0.0233197398,
-0.0813858211,
-0.024235541,
-0.0427989364,
-0.0167873353,
0.0221115332,
0.0314308219,
0.0260281134,
-0.0201127231,
-0.0238526855,
-0.0055914042,
-0.0039144163,
-0.0151165314,
0.0403879248,
-0.0704481527,
-0.015358353,
-0.0130249141,
-0.0710636154,
0.0063003199,
-0.0125793964,
-0.0117886644,
-0.0150717283,
0.0792660192,
-0.0253553223,
-0.0233649556,
-0.0227115918,
0.0261099748,
0.0933147669,
-0.011710559,
-0.0100939255,
0.0034560252,
0.0469172187,
0.0016496114,
-0.008587935,
0.013575593,
-0.0478222407,
0.0060825641,
-0.0088437237,
-0.0206002221,
-0.0283987522,
-0.0100438129,
-0.0189682618,
0.0188712329,
-0.0357655957,
-0.0189030282,
-0.0033388021,
-0.0033013003,
-0.0523015969,
0.0361819193,
0.0827504992,
0.0124894623,
-0.0348587036,
-0.011032274,
-0.0085882647,
0.0333692767,
-0.001788551,
0.0395696871,
-0.0266757794,
-0.025511058,
0.0236255415,
0.02513998,
0.0175531674,
0.0078970594,
-0.0512868203,
-0.0557951704,
0.0230174251,
-0.0005217285,
-0.0629253015,
-0.0500220172,
-0.0084309783,
-0.0114236176,
-0.042847544,
0.0096859466,
0.0009997833,
-0.0163021814,
-0.0060703238,
-0.0190734174,
-0.0707679018,
-0.0604981519,
-0.0557211153,
-0.0136988917,
-0.00330939,
0.04436104,
0.0371510871,
0.0049900287,
-0.0178194847,
0.039054323,
0.0129986936,
0.0128020728,
-0.0393567756,
0.0480194725,
0.0641768277,
0.0025573024,
-0.0430507511,
0.0043308279,
0.0097366795,
0.0284124073,
0.0208635069,
0.0347584076,
0.0363241881,
-0.0421490371,
0.0214075651,
-0.0077766832,
-0.0128724445,
0.0424544103,
0.0700570643,
-0.0321103521,
-0.0670495257,
-0.0389847122,
-0.0311379936,
-0.085462831,
-0.0424347334,
-0.0104822563,
-0.0419664904,
-0.0766821727,
-0.081476219,
-0.0875490755,
0.0190166328,
-0.0092529338,
0.0326800458,
0.0183207393,
0.0198536757,
-0.006852909,
-0.0440634042,
-0.006103355,
0.006397747,
0.0229021534,
-0.0579946153,
0.0135386866,
-0.0337757282,
0.0034685759,
-0.00043556,
0.0243212413,
-0.0972952023,
-0.0520787649,
-0.0307401139,
0.0428467244,
0.0273621883,
0.039644748,
-0.0282616355,
-0.0886188,
0.0205996279,
0.044265531,
-0.0627875999,
0.0244109668,
0.0294130798,
-0.009730882,
0.0080248239,
0.039180588,
0.0145694092,
0.0214921106,
-0.0174089707,
0.0183726903,
0.0069987685,
-0.0146069638,
-0.0173835009,
0.0259277727,
0.0062108501,
-0.0013609007,
0.0003074545,
-0.0317749791,
-0.0074195564,
-0.0483315326,
0.0289545339,
-0.0082059391,
-0.0052352319,
0.0143383853,
0.0535492077,
-0.0449736156,
0.0812577307,
0.0156903695,
-0.0251262598,
0.0021715516,
0.0059593967,
-0.0074977605,
-0.0157120787,
0.0016605397,
0.0072130524,
-0.0169026144,
0.0203135591,
-0.0175538566,
0.0114439409,
-0.013867734,
-0.0056901886,
-0.0124170873,
0.0014832587,
-0.0194176603,
0.0569822118,
0.0236370731,
-0.0349782743,
-0.0084726447,
0.0204746872,
0.0473606139,
-0.0227177963,
0.0787315369,
0.0112766186,
-0.0102575179,
-0.0512444153,
0.0118007697,
0.0362449773,
-0.0119458251,
-0.0127063422,
-0.0156699214,
-0.0069692112,
-0.0127542606,
0.1062314287,
-0.0184594132,
-0.0206126273,
-0.014798644,
-0.0208866559,
-0.0430011004,
-0.0217979662,
-0.0126102613,
-0.0090414938,
-0.0434692726,
-0.0772910491,
-0.0445798449,
-0.0509365536,
0.0236559864,
-0.0057287975,
0.0186102986,
-0.0100105479,
0.0313275568,
0.0607280545,
-0.0328725912,
-0.0157401413,
-0.0350845233,
-0.0168247726,
-0.032019008,
-0.0434731096,
-0.0376885161,
-5.451273869e-33,
0.0104420902,
-0.0191095136,
-0.0030072578,
-0.0182244536,
0.0082060006,
0.0150010586,
-0.1023445874,
-0.021737894,
0.006955984,
0.0587050021,
-0.010827614,
0.0074131265,
0.0370869711,
-0.0049520778,
-0.0192235801,
0.0311739929,
0.0872144476,
0.0082281921,
-0.011047639,
-0.0131590161,
-0.0304472093,
0.0346600115,
0.0516472794,
-0.0782770142,
0.0192489587,
0.0205698237,
-0.0235718861,
-0.0040238672,
0.0698065162,
0.0449262634,
-0.0031801467,
0.0410602912,
0.0275965668,
-0.0287828073,
-0.040474657,
0.0551704206,
-0.0656212643,
-0.0246754885,
0.0408316813,
0.0330502652,
-0.03990018,
-0.0747031122,
0.0805107206,
-0.0495282933,
-0.0176577922,
0.0173082016,
0.0611926541,
-0.0369038321,
0.0300786644,
-0.034275379,
-0.0506392159,
0.0324276686,
-0.0199769251,
0.0015938014,
0.0315388851,
0.0817595199,
-0.0460659377,
0.0121451663,
-0.0254929978,
0.0171361435,
0.0294227097,
0.0373096764,
0.0853862315,
-0.0203814842,
-0.0041202055,
0.0166816786,
0.0357113071,
-0.0054966123,
-0.024868302,
0.0126460595,
0.0532979704,
-0.0122327534,
0.1015982255,
0.0522722304,
0.0395036414,
0.0068812468,
-0.0561168455,
0.0637741238,
0.0171784349,
-0.0029632479,
0.0100726187,
0.0119573977,
-0.0315268226,
-0.0059190565,
-0.016907081,
-0.0184063595,
-0.0102306074,
-0.0316720679,
0.0145491688,
0.0059982436,
-0.0051187431,
-0.0139429243,
0.0390881859,
-0.0127120698,
-0.0032854527,
0.0384167656,
-0.0195712093,
0.0374750085,
0.0254308172,
-0.0054030274,
-0.0251423549,
0.0659165755,
0.0091019534,
0.0609248541,
0.0188247077,
-0.0056597069,
0.0479529798,
0.0280905645,
-0.0588751435,
0.0140108308,
0.0083968109,
0.0064131864,
0.0440362766,
0.0502983592,
0.0191356596,
0.0139321862,
-0.012228772,
0.0361508839,
0.0192087963,
0.0027933666,
-0.0108566508,
0.0040817871,
0.0407744423,
0.0331412181,
-0.0271120127,
-0.0070900978,
-0.0198662337,
0.0278038792,
0.0191593934,
-0.0502704792,
-0.0197143201,
-0.0233626012,
2.374e-7,
0.0567714423,
0.0379245728,
0.0382753983,
0.0125950975,
0.0114622572,
-0.0059600906,
0.0251984783,
-0.0037653537,
-0.0434735268,
0.0572154671,
0.0353237651,
-0.0218370054,
0.0826865286,
-0.005235807,
-0.1077767015,
-0.019815594,
0.0006483622,
-0.0127606792,
-0.0598502718,
-0.0188902132,
0.0249136295,
0.0633554906,
-0.0075077247,
0.0174091775,
0.0067679491,
-0.0526526682,
0.0124326013,
-0.0403190926,
0.031577222,
0.0276520718,
0.0723213702,
0.0086441543,
-0.0303473957,
-0.0172733683,
-0.0256312676,
-0.0060712714,
0.0439772718,
0.0957095474,
0.0027130386,
0.0530843362,
0.0468340702,
-0.0812320635,
-0.0386803523,
-0.0301874336,
0.0441695377,
-0.0189921279,
0.0111514535,
0.035593044,
0.0024930465,
0.0026520214,
0.018115202,
-0.0196421053,
-0.0574559793,
0.0402071141,
0.0385760479,
-0.0360595807,
-0.002096412,
-0.0413528681,
-0.0541717857,
0.0083573349,
-0.0057817465,
0.0289502107,
-0.0583725162,
0.0113369869,
0.0219874624,
-0.0382468551,
0.046073135,
2.036753348e-34,
0.038687706,
-0.0128656179,
0.0067547541,
-0.0095302034,
0.0419922285,
-0.0240302477,
-0.0318474807,
-0.0016564819,
-0.0050646472,
-0.0502112918,
0.0090146316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08449v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08449v1 | Improving CTC-AED model with integrated-CTC and auxiliary loss regularization | 2023-08-15T03:31:47 | 2023-08-15T03:31:47 | Daobin Zhu, Xiangdong Su, Hongbin Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Connectionist temporal classification (CTC) and attention-based encoder
decoder (AED) joint training has been widely applied in automatic speech
recognition (ASR). Unlike most hybrid models that separately calculate the CTC
and AED losses, our proposed integrated-CTC utilizes the attention mechanism of
AED to guide the output of CTC. In this paper, we employ two fusion methods,
namely direct addition of logits (DAL) and preserving the maximum probability
(PMP). We achieve dimensional consistency by adaptively affine transforming the
attention results to match the dimensions of CTC. To accelerate model
convergence and improve accuracy, we introduce auxiliary loss regularization
for accelerated convergence. Experimental results demonstrate that the DAL
method performs better in attention rescoring, while the PMP method excels in
CTC prefix beam search and greedy search. | [
-0.0244075079,
0.0654613897,
0.0301941782,
0.0290728062,
0.0284075215,
-0.0045555523,
0.0011300765,
-0.0454699434,
-0.0378207117,
0.0240371358,
-0.0338099599,
-0.0569604486,
0.0513002202,
0.0160585251,
-0.0012840399,
-0.013793584,
0.0039165327,
-0.0282435752,
-0.0020025752,
0.0058982363,
0.0240386426,
-0.0344382934,
-0.0336420126,
0.0579852983,
0.0059874989,
0.0176004134,
-0.0039439821,
0.0249454416,
0.0736525208,
-0.0186573491,
-0.0004585577,
-0.0261187144,
0.0227140747,
-0.0019762032,
0.0000022686,
-0.0128083825,
-0.0057816906,
-0.0143250199,
-0.0159157757,
-0.0052344422,
0.0059714229,
0.0021387946,
0.0151666962,
0.0570973121,
0.0112057878,
-0.0466603041,
0.0530421622,
0.0763136744,
0.0334872119,
0.0873474404,
0.0183522552,
-0.0411479324,
0.0709352568,
-0.0114131877,
-0.0118072135,
-0.0362730995,
-0.011858304,
-0.0031177022,
-0.0151983881,
-0.0657500476,
-0.0116722193,
0.0502114482,
0.0571436174,
-0.0067939754,
0.07925497,
0.0276819058,
-0.0135791861,
0.0336343087,
-0.0142268017,
0.0262553133,
-0.013931497,
-0.0302695818,
-0.0228497423,
0.0132480785,
-0.0633849278,
-0.0507977605,
-0.0376788005,
-0.0335683487,
0.0178785585,
-0.0032262737,
0.0205019917,
0.0446643978,
0.0129154706,
0.0018077644,
-0.0480711497,
-0.0013411446,
0.003396512,
-0.0561736375,
0.0190137234,
-0.0126907378,
0.010071245,
0.0069283522,
0.0559177622,
0.0412201919,
0.0069782301,
-0.0108180083,
-0.0149237551,
-0.0381126441,
-0.0410765111,
-0.0543647632,
0.0223573819,
0.0784639791,
-0.0249961447,
0.0053703468,
-0.0395020731,
0.0810212642,
0.0005154789,
0.0403736867,
-0.0181490239,
-0.0044248421,
-0.0432004854,
0.0057393801,
-0.0558749735,
0.0298985727,
0.0471480154,
0.003157533,
-0.0630934313,
0.0207364745,
-0.0179494862,
-0.0220052507,
0.0235045757,
0.0217737071,
-0.078799583,
-0.0292485915,
0.0152516328,
0.0576645173,
0.0248084012,
0.0266038533,
-0.000373217,
-0.0204586368,
-0.0496341921,
0.0218178481,
0.0186971147,
-0.0250601638,
-0.0283013899,
0.0294186566,
-0.0394774601,
-0.0623200946,
-0.0042845602,
0.0013365195,
-0.0285153426,
-0.0247263219,
-0.0148728676,
-0.0206901953,
0.0573743843,
-0.0219610296,
0.0187965017,
-0.0386354774,
-0.0182736367,
-0.0401649624,
0.0517259277,
0.0447270423,
0.0329900645,
-0.0283876304,
0.0608486459,
-0.0074111484,
0.0368828587,
0.0413156673,
0.037175145,
-0.0124561805,
-0.0821744353,
-0.0024452265,
-0.0091832196,
0.0277483426,
0.0126869641,
-0.0228630416,
-0.076514028,
0.0138737783,
0.0279438458,
0.0380849093,
0.0673308894,
0.0268036108,
-0.048089724,
-0.0126885613,
0.0527124032,
0.0010316869,
0.0476309024,
-0.0097102728,
0.0351289324,
-0.000159759,
0.0040096636,
-0.013971176,
-0.0076598991,
0.0251228008,
-0.0308810752,
0.0162096564,
0.0799221396,
0.0141420625,
-0.0312341228,
0.0003751779,
0.0380688421,
-0.0382326655,
0.0111780409,
0.0249685291,
0.0485071205,
-0.0206254721,
-0.0358013622,
0.0215101689,
0.0111205336,
-0.0333354659,
0.0317268856,
-0.0160484407,
-0.0395309106,
0.0092721395,
0.0011928597,
-0.0091353878,
-0.0407007858,
-0.0310565457,
-0.061685659,
0.0059178793,
0.0154729392,
0.0032617231,
0.0250883102,
-0.0612908341,
-0.0174962934,
0.0534322485,
-0.0353314504,
0.0434699096,
-0.0451304838,
0.0269817933,
0.0301845875,
0.0110648358,
0.015671093,
-0.0309414528,
0.0099055171,
-0.0259450413,
0.0054202303,
0.0138211092,
0.0435931496,
0.0363671221,
0.0010814582,
0.0163611136,
0.0218489673,
-0.0448340774,
-0.0206503272,
0.0488675423,
-0.0755914599,
-0.0881834403,
0.0560580567,
0.0065130708,
0.0377768576,
0.0385000966,
0.0385621861,
-0.0840788111,
0.0723421723,
-0.0486786552,
0.1241108105,
-0.022910485,
0.0760457292,
0.0438265242,
-0.0075688614,
0.0041554938,
0.0057915528,
-0.0616136938,
-0.0150216883,
0.0398930237,
-0.00793688,
-0.0403869599,
-0.1003404111,
-0.0054499721,
0.0027300213,
-0.0054704868,
0.0020187143,
0.0022178891,
-0.0234254785,
0.0069446787,
-0.001787467,
-0.0596241504,
-0.010931897,
-0.0080117192,
0.0221428033,
-0.0341341347,
0.0358875468,
0.0267786086,
0.0072295773,
0.0151449069,
-0.0005782314,
-0.0623193495,
-0.0027591905,
-0.0517740287,
0.0189945437,
-0.0271588359,
-0.018392466,
-0.0108219516,
0.0184189584,
0.0272967406,
-0.0407950319,
-0.016143227,
-0.0538311265,
0.0071245497,
0.0307363495,
0.025859151,
-0.0139737083,
-0.0205998532,
-0.0500810109,
-0.0117472205,
-0.0177452266,
0.0534774512,
0.0175289623,
0.0116869165,
-0.005066283,
0.0095634554,
-0.0637928098,
0.0503468178,
0.0028407373,
0.000650194,
0.0092477612,
0.0026719142,
-0.0199166816,
0.0826913044,
-0.0034777857,
0.0662570745,
-0.0719281957,
-0.0486175641,
-0.0048792199,
-0.032824643,
-0.0053561726,
0.0024220704,
-0.0579749644,
-0.0173375197,
-0.0263369195,
-0.0189360455,
0.0585664473,
-0.0479411259,
-0.0015122566,
-0.0225795619,
-0.0605879202,
-0.0295807179,
-0.0029480385,
0.0209562406,
-0.0024323743,
-0.0216171034,
-0.0563549064,
-0.0283730533,
0.0071188407,
-0.0254459176,
-0.0189656857,
0.0641674399,
0.0563474931,
0.0072067729,
-0.0311113913,
-0.0148751838,
-0.0119594112,
-0.0136249969,
-0.0141261509,
0.0255339537,
0.0146260876,
-0.0239299033,
-0.0503769293,
0.0105759846,
0.012417661,
0.0512829013,
-0.0220630467,
0.0046481807,
-0.0110543389,
0.099929601,
0.0376840271,
0.01461937,
-0.0311100166,
0.0017029487,
-0.004357114,
0.0177869592,
0.064445734,
-0.0045174216,
-0.0762838498,
-0.0685162097,
0.0420614071,
0.0242925771,
0.0053312229,
0.0257671513,
0.0264739152,
-0.0741161332,
-0.0056007644,
0.0789761916,
0.0012715352,
-0.0948558971,
-0.0336519815,
0.0316499658,
-0.007224672,
-0.0106957471,
-0.0270299651,
-0.0296298247,
-0.0517778471,
0.0033066997,
0.028927587,
0.0147447484,
0.0238635223,
0.0022568069,
-0.0739319101,
-0.0295800194,
0.0443625636,
-0.0235533062,
-0.0393707864,
-0.0385061353,
-0.0177034661,
-0.0413295105,
0.0176471528,
0.0369185805,
-0.013092719,
-0.0188093726,
0.0525975749,
-0.0448731594,
-0.048733633,
0.003655728,
-0.0255381372,
0.0718882158,
0.0521818586,
0.0155384606,
0.0112582771,
-0.0612514839,
0.062965706,
-0.0086642774,
-0.0059138206,
0.0089650331,
-0.0127127767,
-0.0318195075,
0.0088606821,
0.0494757108,
0.0071234792,
-0.0001966765,
0.0129917888,
-0.0000175477,
0.1007107645,
-0.0472766459,
0.0396057926,
-0.0029138695,
-0.0029478555,
0.01638606,
0.0636883453,
-0.0036608316,
-0.029038744,
-0.0260061808,
-0.0085357977,
0.0309955198,
-0.0517388992,
-0.0129719758,
0.0170523673,
0.0328371152,
-0.0844013542,
-0.0001802449,
-0.0282960869,
-0.0049791844,
-0.0076430221,
-0.0037640682,
-0.0271857698,
-0.0297996327,
0.0082236668,
-0.0353468992,
0.0424521416,
-0.0258910339,
0.0066671995,
-0.0666937009,
0.0498343743,
-0.0045257038,
-0.0662171245,
0.0166248456,
0.0547450483,
-0.0962654799,
-0.0586821847,
-0.0423760712,
-0.026977906,
-0.0000902566,
0.0639119223,
-0.0128931617,
-0.0791526586,
0.0151574193,
-0.0400591753,
0.000838514,
0.0123157511,
0.0425430238,
-0.0058324784,
-0.0065831654,
-0.0057544559,
-0.0626560301,
-0.0108831124,
-0.0099417204,
0.0366487578,
-0.0292535461,
-0.0164811388,
0.0091472706,
0.0108311465,
0.063931495,
-0.012962359,
0.0295912139,
-0.0152228428,
0.0533413477,
0.0283790044,
0.0650002435,
-0.014623099,
-0.0187383927,
0.0231618043,
0.0307478048,
0.0079766233,
-0.0102300681,
-0.0002534413,
-0.0475226492,
-0.0408782214,
0.0313750692,
0.0150215356,
-0.0074870721,
0.025104329,
-0.0123060467,
-0.0253909826,
-0.0188460257,
0.0304388478,
0.0006513978,
-0.0157670677,
0.0196726136,
-0.0069787484,
0.0243551675,
0.0116123082,
-0.0215252377,
-0.0182810444,
-0.0121395001,
-0.0462825932,
-0.0328776017,
0.0596750267,
-0.0004954102,
0.029393848,
0.0188857615,
0.0077547305,
-0.0315426402,
0.0049328883,
-0.0109973289,
-0.0300296284,
0.0502442382,
-0.0024563307,
0.0156565942,
0.0242694877,
0.0432632156,
-0.0306523535,
0.0028241414,
-0.0383743495,
0.0251193643,
-0.0260922499,
-0.014109428,
0.0014879868,
0.0492357649,
-0.0407314226,
0.0114043653,
0.0096906126,
-0.0207747128,
0.0553698391,
-0.0301505271,
-0.0015157983,
-3.411e-7,
0.0401029103,
-0.039202556,
-0.032192003,
-0.02031333,
0.0363446809,
-0.0277339332,
0.0420005284,
-0.0152012771,
-0.0227537528,
-6.895658512e-33,
-0.0000045526,
0.0436737277,
-0.006592094,
-0.0053705657,
-0.0495417826,
0.0298036486,
-0.0049645533,
-0.0072499872,
0.0268089864,
-0.0412971117,
0.0025929718,
0.0155211827,
0.0158359222,
0.0434765071,
0.0183640663,
0.0071423617,
0.0758398399,
0.0011875681,
-0.002964745,
0.0348434485,
0.0355624333,
0.0102583589,
0.0420925878,
-0.0760381967,
-0.0299384799,
0.0485244989,
0.0297945011,
0.0198149346,
0.0565766729,
0.0428108871,
-0.0111657409,
0.0513733737,
0.0067291544,
-0.0714645013,
-0.0155819282,
-0.0069255661,
-0.0584143475,
0.0253518503,
-0.0146806622,
0.0048626377,
-0.035823293,
-0.0703002065,
0.0157145802,
0.0492745712,
-0.0073510227,
-0.0810835063,
0.026151007,
-0.0312263984,
-0.0496199727,
-0.0787685961,
0.0119525641,
0.0384892561,
-0.0518606789,
-0.0106749358,
0.0152092902,
0.03115445,
-0.014795104,
-0.0023524985,
-0.0729836673,
0.0150938593,
0.0225302558,
0.0253674202,
0.0629282966,
0.0556505807,
-0.017904859,
0.0047873794,
0.0130461222,
-0.0379857719,
0.0070527922,
-0.0563236438,
-0.0002770229,
-0.0014345979,
0.0040859361,
-0.0250140838,
0.0384879187,
-0.0182883218,
-0.0119900117,
0.0156865828,
0.0669075847,
0.0919305757,
0.0502257086,
0.0521114357,
-0.0442015417,
0.0164695103,
-0.0039973077,
-0.0061802692,
-0.0316887498,
-0.0059637437,
0.0295215938,
0.0424477234,
0.0412240885,
-0.0121418824,
0.0728351995,
-0.009355586,
0.0843395069,
0.0531791337,
0.0015970515,
-0.0020528415,
-0.001059699,
0.0244744327,
-0.0637946725,
0.0129610812,
0.0106631769,
-0.0231851134,
0.0104983291,
-0.0315412581,
0.0041128178,
0.0370854698,
-0.037026085,
-0.0314020514,
-0.0207722392,
0.0064940187,
0.0036414363,
-0.0068251938,
0.0706487745,
-0.0112034185,
0.0050610085,
0.0848999768,
-0.0357021801,
0.0244645849,
-0.0144071681,
-0.0093510291,
0.0698929206,
0.00947168,
0.0042246236,
0.0371517316,
0.0048933448,
-0.0194983687,
0.0044302675,
-0.050350979,
-0.0074375118,
0.0194614027,
3.123e-7,
-0.0392514318,
-0.0296500009,
0.0044503221,
-0.0187546983,
0.002653599,
0.0102951061,
0.0089233276,
0.026162155,
0.0026316973,
0.0357101001,
0.0318242051,
-0.0084604165,
0.079298161,
-0.0086934157,
-0.0693355724,
-0.0588542968,
-0.0502842776,
0.0381876342,
-0.0007106651,
-0.0205032267,
0.0134483362,
0.074407056,
-0.0189735629,
-0.0170842949,
-0.0047184704,
-0.0199155454,
0.0519888774,
0.0358828567,
-0.0188347697,
-0.0037866666,
0.0289109461,
0.0061153625,
-0.0349993743,
-0.008365511,
-0.0237813406,
0.0342420414,
0.0146918464,
0.0304640569,
-0.0084026204,
-0.1127542853,
0.0061272457,
0.0159199908,
-0.0275194179,
0.012839701,
0.0454005897,
-0.0566823632,
-0.0044390969,
0.0183059331,
-0.0464521945,
0.0378358327,
0.0129364263,
-0.010348808,
0.0264182165,
-0.0195557997,
-0.0211723335,
-0.0097801611,
-0.0471871682,
-0.0861995444,
0.004083469,
0.0779036954,
-0.0537930541,
0.0112260366,
-0.0234861281,
-0.0266481843,
0.0545422137,
-0.0273111444,
-0.0162384585,
2.451371327e-34,
0.0274646841,
-0.0243541878,
0.0376467295,
0.0106070787,
0.0022584733,
-0.060402181,
-0.0225290451,
0.016118817,
0.0417021625,
-0.0934331119,
-0.0274135489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07540v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07540v1 | CALYPSO: LLMs as Dungeon Masters' Assistants | 2023-08-15T02:57:00 | 2023-08-15T02:57:00 | Andrew Zhu, Lara J. Martin, Andrew Head, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | The role of a Dungeon Master, or DM, in the game Dungeons & Dragons is to
perform multiple tasks simultaneously. The DM must digest information about the
game setting and monsters, synthesize scenes to present to other players, and
respond to the players' interactions with the scene. Doing all of these tasks
while maintaining consistency within the narrative and story world is no small
feat of human cognition, making the task tiring and unapproachable to new
players. Large language models (LLMs) like GPT-3 and ChatGPT have shown
remarkable abilities to generate coherent natural language text. In this paper,
we conduct a formative evaluation with DMs to establish the use cases of LLMs
in D&D and tabletop gaming generally. We introduce CALYPSO, a system of
LLM-powered interfaces that support DMs with information and inspiration
specific to their own scenario. CALYPSO distills game context into bite-sized
prose and helps brainstorm ideas without distracting the DM from the game. When
given access to CALYPSO, DMs reported that it generated high-fidelity text
suitable for direct presentation to players, and low-fidelity ideas that the DM
could develop further while maintaining their creative agency. We see CALYPSO
as exemplifying a paradigm of AI-augmented tools that provide synchronous
creative assistance within established game worlds, and tabletop gaming more
broadly. | [
0.0242771823,
0.0013741134,
-0.0347900204,
0.0649129972,
-0.0426940098,
-0.0097822901,
-0.0128106745,
-0.0057057426,
0.03221054,
-0.0254781637,
-0.0329106487,
0.0020897442,
0.0257150754,
0.0306217019,
-0.0034770472,
-0.048135981,
0.0058181714,
-0.0315453894,
0.0100482656,
0.0175820738,
-0.0157555249,
0.0247718208,
-0.0419496894,
0.0505117215,
0.015435962,
-0.0603267066,
-0.0611830465,
0.0244732741,
0.0061645471,
-0.0743648037,
-0.0089260582,
-0.0158432759,
0.0227119066,
0.0134653719,
0.0000020289,
-0.0352956764,
0.0330750532,
-0.0432451181,
0.0353582837,
-0.0052593579,
-0.0113380793,
0.0197985526,
0.0124998875,
-0.0254033506,
-0.056767609,
0.0044104359,
0.067175597,
0.0357970297,
0.0721836388,
0.038841255,
-0.0029960724,
-0.0400505438,
-0.0109843398,
-0.0042028679,
0.0272969045,
0.0038944467,
-0.0409654006,
0.0317410082,
0.0682002231,
0.0046201544,
0.0344143249,
0.0139878914,
-0.0163390525,
-0.0096747046,
-0.0034895777,
0.0419084989,
0.0189334173,
0.0155328205,
-0.0036446389,
0.050320778,
0.0163427703,
-0.0241871625,
0.0291699674,
0.0053577293,
0.005362059,
-0.0004597174,
-0.0489381552,
0.0157244261,
-0.0268915817,
-0.0000172091,
0.0044301613,
-0.00011264,
0.0456053801,
-0.0063403556,
0.0075203907,
0.0318690091,
-0.0027158856,
-0.0520481169,
-0.0503907055,
0.0184397176,
-0.0097161848,
-0.0792089179,
-0.0204984657,
0.0487379394,
-0.0645608306,
0.0150852213,
-0.0440808497,
-0.0240895096,
0.0043576891,
-0.0179633647,
0.0306623671,
0.0299191084,
-0.001834543,
0.0333776586,
0.025894478,
0.0255378503,
0.0096269529,
0.0014362289,
-0.0070790281,
0.024243325,
-0.0499250852,
-0.0295760855,
-0.0584961995,
0.0230188947,
-0.0464854874,
-0.0320964679,
-0.0269507859,
0.0306126978,
0.0118686296,
0.0352749154,
0.0376643389,
0.0307683107,
-0.0053957929,
0.0123024462,
-0.0320782289,
-0.0116610713,
-0.0375802219,
0.0187514946,
0.0308881775,
-0.0122510502,
0.0065206019,
-0.0184407867,
0.0129578356,
-0.0171573199,
0.0099339262,
0.1106663644,
-0.0047939192,
-0.0051622703,
-0.0335539244,
-0.0196221545,
-0.0148017518,
-0.0367276929,
-0.0476538055,
-0.0571669787,
0.0264381766,
-0.0086142002,
0.0301749445,
-0.0103220409,
0.0301232748,
0.0498359203,
0.0317063406,
0.0514613502,
-0.0693900511,
0.04037074,
0.0329452343,
-0.0030028545,
-0.0115655232,
0.0212726519,
0.1018867716,
0.0313434005,
0.012926531,
0.0109481541,
0.0140359132,
0.0344496332,
-0.0427761376,
-0.0377188176,
-0.0278706271,
-0.0062707583,
-0.0251977798,
0.0828429237,
-0.0213017613,
0.0451442748,
-0.01703736,
0.031250257,
0.1147914752,
0.0765639544,
0.0613502674,
0.0358313806,
0.0917065665,
0.0019173697,
-0.016267119,
-0.0005645038,
0.0145535534,
0.0186404884,
0.0942984074,
0.0146483714,
-0.0028431267,
0.0313499831,
0.043737486,
-0.037930198,
0.01928165,
0.0146700479,
0.0118387882,
-0.0106199374,
-0.0010440632,
0.0087215528,
-0.0487631969,
0.0131822256,
-0.0021103502,
-0.079291366,
0.0315725803,
-0.0357575119,
0.0418756194,
0.1392839253,
0.0524530672,
-0.0457271896,
-0.0130091533,
-0.0124363909,
0.0115789929,
0.0767349228,
-0.0030131978,
-0.0078407014,
0.028703697,
-0.0246939808,
-0.0112883272,
-0.0683635324,
-0.0062018819,
0.0550681651,
-0.0292447489,
0.015638208,
-0.0013287206,
-0.0197591018,
-0.0202653762,
0.0167481694,
-0.0137997493,
-0.0635100454,
-0.0163199976,
0.0086927619,
-0.040255893,
0.054901123,
-0.0616576336,
-0.002006277,
0.0287446398,
-0.0447485037,
-0.0414897054,
0.0372306146,
-0.046731811,
-0.0212404244,
0.0494298376,
-0.0341740511,
0.017553119,
-0.0355740003,
0.0333791673,
-0.0202183276,
0.0517785624,
-0.0440088697,
0.0395373031,
0.0026908708,
0.0009835701,
0.0019840221,
-0.0152308177,
-0.0199929457,
0.0694882795,
0.0087320227,
-0.0293849595,
0.0169171169,
-0.0288116857,
0.0372190438,
-0.0369466096,
0.0465236679,
0.0312963314,
0.0065241395,
0.0194512997,
0.0151125537,
0.0367618203,
-0.034331169,
-0.0407690033,
-0.058527559,
0.0013155685,
0.0015709039,
0.0112844994,
0.0242795385,
0.0029129805,
-0.0268592536,
0.0293778796,
-0.0624492764,
-0.0158243887,
0.0378759615,
-0.0191255808,
0.0495844297,
0.0379994884,
0.0262988489,
-0.0204203743,
0.035257142,
-0.0031938136,
0.010346083,
0.0254353415,
-0.0378861278,
-0.0199196897,
-0.0086626941,
-0.0522472449,
0.0039802245,
-0.0211278182,
-0.0548792407,
0.0621474795,
-0.0377859659,
0.039777983,
-0.0064715743,
-0.0054943557,
-0.005012061,
0.0838365257,
-0.0762581155,
-0.0029616929,
0.0153583419,
0.0321497582,
0.0211209171,
0.0043830215,
-0.0192823485,
0.0789591819,
0.0669975653,
0.0416821651,
0.0342226774,
-0.0732997805,
0.0428625979,
0.0293155592,
-0.0219996832,
-0.0007234209,
-0.0313492045,
-0.0162959043,
0.0237330105,
-0.0192210637,
0.015566879,
0.0511767156,
-0.06127638,
-0.0208305176,
0.0011518941,
-0.0157914106,
-0.0632399023,
0.0655727163,
-0.0341978222,
0.032184124,
0.0167384706,
-0.0287890285,
-0.0196562484,
0.0151614286,
0.0483535379,
-0.0243274309,
0.0278678816,
-0.0767154172,
-0.0196371153,
0.0250991341,
-0.0216379352,
0.00803883,
0.0130506828,
-0.0358405709,
-0.0361766964,
0.0327485427,
-0.0278859548,
-0.0721408725,
-0.0198485814,
0.0446728803,
0.037748415,
0.015173614,
-0.0345748328,
-0.0383684598,
-0.0049059317,
0.0491683036,
0.0392373241,
-0.0240557063,
-0.0326073356,
0.0717544034,
0.0246140324,
-0.0350042246,
-0.0449007265,
-0.0307712331,
0.0099027306,
0.0130552184,
-0.0044374866,
-0.0462813042,
0.0229021404,
0.0024138715,
-0.0584262088,
0.0082483841,
0.0813931301,
0.0148851387,
-0.0124141388,
0.0184026565,
-0.0351362824,
0.0031389152,
0.0226967037,
-0.0039044565,
-0.1165449545,
-0.0132238474,
0.0007990028,
0.0289141331,
0.0063377409,
-0.0400429517,
-0.0357769392,
-0.0793296769,
0.0271232184,
0.0135312378,
0.0000381529,
-0.0069719451,
0.0393932015,
0.0018426755,
0.0406591669,
-0.0401797555,
-0.0117334519,
0.0115410425,
0.0184406955,
0.0024311361,
-0.0234654862,
0.0166488588,
-0.0269418899,
-0.0245447084,
0.0496900119,
0.0687786564,
0.0907497257,
0.0356703661,
-0.0133290486,
-0.0452149734,
0.037155591,
0.0286862627,
-0.0144717414,
0.0380369276,
-0.0130394241,
-0.017114237,
-0.0089623351,
-0.0052927504,
-0.0141500318,
-0.0299180169,
0.0504796095,
0.0577629395,
-0.0181046426,
0.00053389,
-0.0231665093,
0.0206725337,
0.0537310354,
0.0290061161,
0.0232249927,
-0.0391173102,
-0.0222097989,
-0.0162051972,
0.0111863501,
-0.0223089419,
-0.0492342412,
-0.046668984,
0.0097546736,
0.0597451404,
-0.1163617596,
-0.0396840982,
0.0187696144,
0.0588459559,
0.0504842512,
0.0370834768,
-0.0482076071,
-0.0094517199,
0.0011166659,
-0.0264408048,
-0.0135904914,
-0.0070299366,
-0.045992285,
-0.0440591946,
-0.0161173083,
-0.0736179277,
0.0446694084,
0.0631901473,
-0.0382783413,
-0.0526666567,
-0.0090154894,
0.0282892939,
0.0173458643,
-0.0036234229,
0.0220188871,
-0.0586619489,
0.0080417637,
0.0333999693,
-0.0522049367,
-0.0027803113,
-0.0265401695,
0.0807653964,
0.0277720299,
0.000555355,
-0.0600314178,
-0.0203939918,
-0.0234884974,
0.0638048127,
-0.0209143721,
-0.0413336642,
0.0137879904,
-0.0039478443,
-0.0131136673,
-0.0539247841,
0.0118234241,
-0.0121184988,
-0.0010921576,
-0.0740645826,
-0.0349685065,
-0.0414981022,
0.0168654975,
0.0229217615,
-0.0192689896,
0.008302791,
0.0299148876,
-0.0350047126,
-0.0101638222,
-0.0614712536,
-0.0039337971,
0.0225734431,
-0.0248616319,
0.0283291135,
0.0028705017,
-0.0030024678,
0.0405732021,
-0.0481474139,
0.0673280731,
0.0064724297,
0.0513116382,
0.0103341695,
-0.0678764731,
0.0038859276,
0.0206707362,
-0.0130727328,
-0.0764866471,
0.0438372418,
0.0450985394,
0.0668203756,
0.0307262521,
0.0469811521,
-0.0133708883,
0.0115578026,
0.0256297402,
0.0085914982,
0.0514453389,
-0.0430183969,
-0.0575128794,
0.0364462435,
-0.0307781175,
-0.0183588155,
0.0213277601,
-0.0120728221,
0.0156407934,
0.0117324358,
-0.0431474894,
-0.0546807759,
-0.0202094261,
-0.0305696391,
0.0446704291,
-0.0329691544,
0.0205539633,
-0.0804676414,
-0.0014375125,
-0.0124401664,
0.0671402216,
0.0022689982,
-0.0623045117,
0.0010838209,
0.0221785624,
0.0213826317,
-0.0277494304,
-0.0257515013,
0.0355122015,
-0.0616552979,
-0.0201704372,
-0.0541907698,
-4.876778923e-33,
-0.0418645665,
-0.0480509214,
0.0582719445,
0.011843808,
-0.0354622379,
-0.0330377631,
-0.0695579126,
0.0287377909,
0.0514892973,
0.0204188637,
-0.0031105892,
-0.0257916749,
-0.0188920591,
-0.0089303767,
-0.0027096306,
-0.0353465267,
0.0303510353,
0.0211767796,
-0.0463428646,
0.0320091508,
0.0478902124,
0.0161058102,
0.033279527,
-0.0988574997,
-0.004319232,
-0.0013545417,
0.0107053882,
-0.0065393052,
0.0266505256,
-0.0056660576,
-0.0110410536,
0.002626508,
0.0208154991,
0.0190677885,
-0.0129883587,
0.030116817,
0.0007785835,
-0.0226409175,
0.0145339957,
-0.0056096483,
0.0020414093,
-0.0282142535,
0.0071056089,
0.0130839469,
0.021608565,
0.0027936846,
0.0434777997,
-0.0150697837,
0.0185125265,
-0.0282632671,
-0.064026095,
0.0049719983,
-0.0554139465,
-0.0700781718,
-0.0231192317,
0.0466215573,
-0.0004335853,
-0.0098954821,
-0.0278975349,
0.0372530222,
0.0345838591,
-0.0151776448,
0.0327849239,
0.0248021185,
0.0197749734,
0.0852775052,
0.0174220391,
0.030846471,
-0.0801081285,
0.0207623243,
-0.0207501128,
0.0445407182,
0.039686285,
0.0669450909,
-0.0153841591,
0.0283097401,
-0.0359031707,
0.0332030095,
0.0083521903,
0.0162229463,
0.029795127,
0.0242589358,
-0.0170647763,
-0.0043641767,
-0.0098575065,
0.0098707173,
-0.0030404262,
-0.0445733964,
0.0140487524,
-0.0403723717,
0.0246349722,
-0.0615341179,
-0.0029750105,
0.0021044691,
0.0041539627,
0.0144899189,
-0.052336596,
0.0223161075,
-0.0274571758,
-0.0201963969,
0.0147670144,
0.0002804059,
0.0451064706,
0.0289286114,
0.0497261658,
0.0329625309,
-0.0464979857,
0.0440415628,
-0.0154600162,
-0.0062754177,
-0.0222041477,
0.0452394374,
-0.0161381382,
-0.0114341425,
0.0370313637,
-0.070684731,
-0.0321042798,
-0.0074166227,
-0.0003549928,
-0.0549014024,
-0.0028783767,
-0.0129586114,
-0.0176188145,
-0.0166009665,
-0.0325362943,
0.0089578275,
-0.060407687,
0.0078807231,
0.0451310612,
-0.0259303711,
-0.0271497481,
-0.0235152803,
2.861e-7,
-0.036709249,
0.0258683376,
0.0012315116,
0.0274509471,
0.0174071509,
0.0376474373,
-0.035400968,
0.0081931744,
-0.0152733242,
-0.050661087,
0.0252970718,
0.0189750232,
0.0491779,
0.0200019609,
-0.0877275392,
0.0162639413,
-0.0812031999,
0.0019316395,
-0.0645995885,
0.0194278397,
0.0537910573,
-0.030308811,
0.0338904969,
-0.0288329069,
0.0073470091,
-0.0301220901,
0.0267436579,
-0.0421814285,
0.0349432565,
0.0229562744,
0.0462436005,
-0.0090400632,
-0.0501007326,
-0.0510054752,
-0.0016056501,
0.0176793225,
0.0011991252,
0.0432083569,
-0.0038656713,
0.0567944497,
0.010074487,
-0.0279126745,
-0.0030994283,
-0.0715659261,
0.007524665,
0.0109712938,
-0.0173761025,
-0.0091062924,
0.0005715225,
-0.0416183434,
-0.0416310914,
-0.0478345305,
-0.0282500815,
-0.0237221774,
-0.0193061475,
0.0091544604,
-0.002646042,
-0.0539250635,
-0.0195073169,
0.0293765459,
-0.0342681147,
-0.0142226787,
-0.0673535094,
-0.004923122,
-0.0145927798,
-0.023768248,
0.0169302095,
2.282083151e-34,
-0.0379777513,
-0.0083678244,
-0.0105072735,
0.0057842364,
0.0710734576,
0.0244609304,
0.0368463621,
0.0256075021,
0.0393911488,
-0.0492697284,
0.0114330938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07522v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07522v1 | Finding Stakeholder-Material Information from 10-K Reports using Fine-Tuned BERT and LSTM Models | 2023-08-15T01:25:34 | 2023-08-15T01:25:34 | Victor Zitian Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CE | All public companies are required by federal securities law to disclose their
business and financial activities in their annual 10-K reports. Each report
typically spans hundreds of pages, making it difficult for human readers to
identify and extract the material information efficiently. To solve the
problem, I have fine-tuned BERT models and RNN models with LSTM layers to
identify stakeholder-material information, defined as statements that carry
information about a company's influence on its stakeholders, including
customers, employees, investors, and the community and natural environment. The
existing practice uses keyword search to identify such information, which is my
baseline model. Using business expert-labeled training data of nearly 6,000
sentences from 62 10-K reports published in 2022, the best model has achieved
an accuracy of 0.904 and an F1 score of 0.899 in test data, significantly above
the baseline model's 0.781 and 0.749 respectively. Furthermore, the same work
was replicated on more granular taxonomies, based on which four distinct groups
of stakeholders (i.e., customers, investors, employees, and the community and
natural environment) are tested separately. Similarly, fined-tuned BERT models
outperformed LSTM and the baseline. The implications for industry application
and ideas for future extensions are discussed. | [
0.0565737039,
0.0428218134,
-0.004377543,
0.0259160455,
-0.0220504925,
-0.0314630792,
-0.0091217691,
0.0466784425,
-0.0398422815,
-0.0712982193,
-0.0281249043,
0.0237976257,
-0.0056133703,
0.0081312647,
0.0084827431,
-0.0339106694,
0.0430333801,
0.0418981314,
0.0603354014,
0.013202671,
0.0474237651,
0.0243149661,
0.0208796021,
0.0227481555,
-0.0117847184,
0.0152841303,
0.0002919058,
0.0012111049,
0.0338420086,
0.0043484499,
0.0264070649,
0.0339330286,
0.040465191,
0.0786184371,
0.0000018157,
-0.0375798009,
-0.0578059629,
0.0088650435,
0.003663288,
0.0555604175,
0.0467202701,
-0.0290363412,
0.0278941747,
0.003950702,
-0.0403203256,
0.0200808998,
0.0196663793,
0.0587334149,
0.0580781214,
0.062489748,
-0.0113633731,
-0.0431401879,
-0.0092048123,
-0.055411119,
0.0035570615,
-0.07206963,
0.0243657548,
-0.0375869498,
-0.0118281767,
-0.0232668705,
0.012283097,
0.0459216088,
0.0084775016,
0.0076774545,
0.0453772172,
0.0037891131,
-0.0286989938,
0.0076529356,
-0.0305587072,
0.0417032726,
0.0309392717,
0.0358341821,
0.0247687679,
-0.0286436453,
0.0295614414,
0.001459637,
0.0159622915,
0.0470080338,
-0.0388378091,
-0.0168029442,
0.0022259208,
-0.0007647892,
-0.0039481809,
0.0252939127,
-0.0347939245,
0.0221606381,
0.0069010351,
-0.0487001762,
0.0494764708,
0.0007891273,
-0.0179505162,
-0.0420434028,
0.0569537841,
-0.0027091277,
0.020087434,
0.0401795954,
-0.027039716,
-0.0211117212,
0.0122078042,
-0.0848904699,
0.0047236448,
-0.0095811086,
-0.0427189991,
0.041732762,
-0.0272598676,
0.0205694735,
-0.027927259,
0.0338717103,
0.0026757882,
0.0070561441,
-0.0241532326,
-0.0117555745,
-0.0253233071,
0.0697450265,
-0.0753101259,
-0.0324190222,
-0.040179722,
0.0207086205,
0.0040243976,
0.0362321474,
0.0073081744,
-0.0006307506,
0.0217804629,
-0.0237975121,
-0.049693428,
0.0070028519,
-0.0609571524,
-0.0047231116,
-0.020791309,
-0.0212053452,
0.0483746044,
0.0133090215,
0.0263192337,
-0.0288667157,
0.0070706634,
-0.0027511851,
0.0467687026,
-0.0344969369,
-0.0865599811,
-0.0396445319,
-0.0133646065,
-0.0146156894,
-0.0039307233,
-0.0014445344,
0.0044148988,
-0.0549863242,
-0.026146451,
-0.0345397964,
0.0061824108,
-0.0041337842,
-0.0111132786,
0.0839990824,
-0.0012907208,
-0.019836586,
0.0305658076,
0.0044429274,
0.0760683045,
0.0585384145,
0.0383701287,
0.050967522,
0.0502606481,
-0.0113011822,
-0.0052918415,
0.044784043,
0.0113951256,
-0.0513231829,
0.033747334,
0.0444358625,
-0.0737678707,
0.0330034569,
0.0066203251,
0.0259700175,
0.0036422035,
0.0167316031,
0.0520689934,
0.0388928838,
0.0438846275,
0.0327734314,
-0.0416686311,
0.0436028093,
-0.0135861272,
-0.0125325453,
0.0334732458,
-0.0057635894,
-0.0032314386,
0.0272142999,
0.0108859586,
-0.0367319025,
-0.0239642765,
-0.030492086,
-0.023134103,
0.0452644713,
-0.0496094488,
0.0143011659,
0.0454299971,
-0.003718694,
-0.1098727807,
0.0887015834,
0.00506149,
-0.0506105982,
0.0277985837,
-0.0119037703,
0.0081802178,
0.0887530744,
0.0413167663,
-0.0529478118,
0.0035622038,
-0.0208945945,
-0.0359546207,
0.0788952485,
0.035588719,
0.0247776955,
-0.0362246372,
-0.0447875448,
-0.0327757932,
0.0027839153,
0.0174073167,
0.0393121503,
-0.0221009888,
0.0313350484,
0.0247493703,
-0.044958353,
-0.0056135859,
0.0708468556,
-0.0014252512,
-0.0308092516,
-0.0019853457,
0.0337242298,
-0.0053672642,
0.0593915731,
-0.0207307842,
0.00420766,
0.010661318,
-0.0027133652,
-0.0181378871,
-0.0384133905,
-0.0091767218,
0.0125520816,
-0.0061229458,
-0.0433835536,
0.0089218458,
0.0259213261,
-0.0379879475,
-0.0087517146,
-0.0059010764,
-0.015268404,
0.0267602075,
-0.0710385367,
-0.0411686711,
-0.0164048467,
-0.0178363938,
-0.0281580966,
0.045778349,
-0.0014876249,
0.0098587535,
-0.0645111054,
-0.0275976192,
0.0094950739,
-0.0813497603,
-0.0077922442,
-0.0116335573,
-0.0379288942,
0.0185217895,
0.0650651976,
0.0129069211,
-0.0247265641,
-0.007438825,
-0.0862477794,
-0.0158911813,
-0.0212605651,
0.0176221635,
-0.0243445933,
0.0112868343,
-0.0254066139,
0.0012150703,
-0.0215373803,
-0.1139988378,
-0.0338702686,
-0.0073926384,
0.0532816462,
0.0402682088,
-0.0407162271,
-0.0555683561,
-0.0164523851,
-0.0002875926,
0.0056680134,
0.0676160678,
-0.1056828275,
-0.0238972977,
0.0209259801,
-0.0136617813,
0.0097035281,
0.0234098081,
0.0070101568,
0.0246165786,
0.0297750905,
0.0013467725,
0.033061929,
0.0361851826,
0.0640670508,
-0.0616956055,
0.0034140148,
-0.041161038,
0.0348952264,
-0.0231559835,
-0.0113756601,
0.0003642321,
-0.0536429584,
0.107536912,
-0.014096546,
-0.0227891915,
-0.0036863131,
-0.0909554362,
-0.0103538968,
-0.0134121906,
0.0108483229,
-0.0328132361,
-0.055000253,
0.0048078569,
0.0749138296,
0.0091167213,
-0.0032254914,
0.0379724167,
-0.0013535176,
0.0022914689,
-0.0381463654,
0.0335996822,
-0.0472471416,
0.058960624,
-0.0590072125,
-0.0051287776,
0.0058803265,
-0.0442305617,
0.0041792267,
-0.010494072,
0.0484594442,
-0.0343541577,
0.0209881589,
0.0060498244,
0.0345373191,
-0.0015425589,
-0.0265184548,
-0.0294115655,
-0.0460761599,
0.0121183675,
0.0055203908,
0.0574205667,
-0.0015011956,
-0.0698119178,
0.0518398248,
-0.0174723752,
0.0049676122,
0.0018145165,
-0.0089782747,
0.0018337076,
0.0205374267,
0.0520525016,
-0.0370635167,
0.0570324697,
-0.0388920121,
-0.009442389,
-0.017849341,
0.0687904954,
0.0096445354,
-0.0099854628,
-0.0622246936,
-0.0288899802,
-0.0786425248,
0.0394889861,
-0.0217186417,
-0.0235136468,
-0.0503712483,
0.0286944602,
0.0845019743,
0.0090034343,
0.0213797782,
-0.0012976446,
0.0417427681,
-0.0209811013,
-0.0158720091,
0.0638855398,
-0.0836899057,
0.0062444741,
-0.0086824987,
0.0454059467,
0.0012579542,
-0.067289412,
0.0024563237,
-0.0858395994,
0.0485056601,
-0.016983306,
0.0084216688,
-0.0831923708,
-0.033393342,
-0.0329056345,
-0.0459747501,
0.0193931498,
-0.0082821427,
-0.0174752306,
-0.0190222226,
0.0182320159,
-0.0814323276,
-0.0089677535,
-0.0161547046,
-0.0556215011,
-0.0700839162,
0.1234908774,
0.0243059173,
-0.0398154333,
-0.0252380408,
-0.0167024694,
-0.0278596822,
-0.0160000753,
0.0190244298,
0.0287168585,
-0.0621013492,
-0.0180902202,
0.0231993403,
0.0101013845,
-0.033551529,
0.0670059919,
0.0184819326,
0.0037214803,
-0.0025336507,
-0.0311349425,
0.0332524963,
0.0458581895,
-0.0115816463,
0.0792086273,
0.0037915786,
-0.0039636907,
-0.0130322939,
-0.0138855455,
0.0238477085,
-0.074087657,
0.0221151486,
-0.0205587018,
-0.0369155705,
-0.0249038246,
-0.0850855857,
-0.058887627,
0.0426588729,
0.0370953381,
0.0202212594,
0.0150126498,
0.0399645977,
0.0157974716,
-0.0229662154,
0.0282681677,
-0.0152577981,
0.028429281,
-0.0598398224,
-0.0181283094,
-0.0137040708,
0.0453732982,
-0.0534333177,
0.0077586574,
-0.0534170084,
-0.0358693935,
-0.0019172261,
-0.0198761541,
0.0181321092,
0.0040776278,
-0.0234271958,
-0.0105911186,
0.0951071307,
0.047637552,
-0.0824699625,
-0.0242418814,
0.0370979011,
0.0031803814,
-0.0268356241,
0.0207252167,
-0.0697728172,
-0.0076390151,
0.0214774217,
0.0502076633,
0.0237348862,
-0.0247572921,
-0.002873919,
0.0140571082,
0.0244316254,
0.0312062614,
-0.0294388477,
-0.0759928077,
-0.0096653504,
0.0289693382,
0.0143867005,
-0.0308642332,
-0.0124308085,
0.0128851924,
-0.0003808305,
-0.0222854801,
0.0675556362,
-0.0358069316,
0.015943829,
-0.0873827636,
0.0596410781,
0.0142351789,
0.0311796907,
-0.0159985349,
-0.036347013,
-0.025055768,
0.0067420946,
0.0222607609,
0.024390934,
0.0020289493,
0.0045797923,
0.0312312078,
0.0429519527,
-0.0012791863,
0.012542218,
-0.0186810866,
-0.020609634,
-0.0230887178,
0.0383843184,
-0.0011342964,
0.0344617963,
-0.0299980417,
-0.0900939703,
0.0182463191,
0.0105616413,
0.0206999518,
0.0531242676,
-0.0349343754,
0.0476519689,
0.0199787375,
-0.0401140861,
-0.022886306,
0.0539492294,
0.0681375638,
0.0264558718,
-0.0546321869,
-0.041153539,
-0.0521967784,
-0.0246570837,
0.0494105928,
0.0221234635,
-0.0069626197,
-0.0106641119,
-0.0600853972,
-0.0023775364,
0.0344754942,
-0.0153567968,
-0.0105870068,
0.0014841047,
0.0359779038,
0.0572494678,
0.02271864,
-0.0128698871,
0.0038820147,
0.0045368937,
-0.0196228735,
-0.0203030985,
-0.0254179891,
-5.779208508e-33,
-0.0361083299,
-0.0024262767,
0.0050368123,
-0.0214755964,
-0.0253167469,
0.0065659438,
-0.0069349632,
-0.0400283895,
-0.0093574906,
0.0073385369,
-0.0160241704,
0.0376926251,
0.0373117514,
0.0039623789,
-0.0039735264,
-0.0221749209,
0.0401446745,
-0.0062697893,
-0.0118576149,
-0.0188925844,
-0.0285378806,
0.0653069317,
0.0674159825,
-0.0279627219,
0.0525091365,
0.0171264429,
-0.0337179527,
0.0044844537,
0.0259932186,
0.0385644473,
0.0017079564,
0.0251629408,
-0.005599923,
-0.08685866,
0.0216274895,
0.0422203206,
-0.0422569402,
-0.0054005953,
0.024184892,
0.0172394142,
-0.0087729068,
0.0152692888,
0.0529356524,
-0.0017676338,
0.0064421627,
0.033027526,
0.0311194342,
-0.0045255115,
-0.0198626909,
-0.0680705905,
-0.0584218875,
0.0267617051,
0.007237759,
0.0503406264,
0.030090712,
0.035920959,
-0.0163360927,
0.0275845081,
-0.0163968094,
-0.03043787,
0.054403089,
0.0016851934,
0.037299186,
0.0511838347,
0.0135396579,
0.0326026492,
0.0124114593,
0.0565723367,
-0.0025599643,
-0.0191194434,
0.0391901471,
0.0366715714,
0.0100289546,
0.0082618101,
-0.0123211211,
-0.0161304511,
-0.0439769924,
0.0474220924,
0.0142182969,
0.0018853561,
0.0504273921,
-0.0172253959,
-0.0331349373,
-0.0299963038,
0.0192530043,
-0.0012777216,
-0.0227631163,
0.0382095203,
0.002913591,
0.0326014385,
-0.0196148288,
0.0437593572,
-0.0018960187,
-0.004327104,
-0.0017432169,
-0.0226081368,
0.0296417959,
0.0054442282,
0.0099155121,
0.0095248008,
-0.0589152798,
0.0163940508,
0.004191794,
0.0103930207,
-0.0360054187,
-0.0308637116,
0.0017542067,
-0.0347429663,
-0.0296670143,
0.0025060442,
0.0072831349,
0.0252495632,
-0.0167738777,
-0.0051287417,
0.0064596045,
0.021684913,
0.0100318436,
-0.0022450541,
0.0134720607,
-0.0193148628,
0.0044607935,
0.0190003384,
0.0187589321,
0.0055552917,
-0.006734991,
-0.0075117154,
0.0356202945,
0.0283792764,
0.0173394158,
-0.0105288168,
-0.025685085,
0.0139412237,
2.571e-7,
0.0576851927,
0.0284918584,
0.0381745026,
-0.0211259536,
0.0057789986,
0.0111850649,
0.0481547639,
0.0242537763,
-0.0399402007,
-0.0332221836,
0.0570047945,
-0.0402365103,
0.0445093177,
-0.0092391809,
-0.0714797378,
-0.0977049768,
-0.0449973121,
0.0170588493,
-0.1050263271,
0.0067746318,
-0.0020317819,
0.0379159898,
0.0290688463,
-0.0234682895,
-0.0099929441,
-0.0662695915,
0.0531046987,
-0.0598657951,
0.0096691512,
0.0217552911,
0.0277325716,
-0.0107125109,
-0.0357408188,
0.0047172243,
0.0053304625,
0.0259706862,
0.0220538657,
0.0253602322,
0.0101519795,
-0.0453783683,
-0.0087763602,
0.0017609933,
-0.0146793574,
-0.039873533,
0.0109682018,
-0.0180313233,
-0.0207760166,
0.0361698046,
-0.0131041519,
-0.0092442855,
-0.0118983956,
-0.0092312694,
-0.0304002669,
0.0105271637,
0.0028274318,
-0.0251141191,
0.0152392983,
-0.0770233199,
0.0712953508,
-0.0100815371,
-0.0459273979,
0.0221923701,
-0.0358865708,
0.0209642127,
0.0149645992,
-0.0145745492,
0.0258543752,
2.216774568e-34,
0.0432367399,
-0.0377823561,
-0.0446806885,
0.0139149986,
0.0967489555,
0.0415811166,
-0.0210319422,
0.0291322507,
0.0055002631,
-0.0748247877,
-0.01984182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07505v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07505v2 | Data Race Detection Using Large Language Models | 2023-08-15T00:08:43 | 2023-10-03T06:09:18 | Le Chen, Xianzhong Ding, Murali Emani, Tristan Vanderbruggen, Pei-hung Lin, Chuanhua Liao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are demonstrating significant promise as an
alternate strategy to facilitate analyses and optimizations of high-performance
computing programs, circumventing the need for resource-intensive manual tool
creation. In this paper, we explore a novel LLM-based data race detection
approach combining prompting engineering and fine-tuning techniques. We create
a dedicated dataset named DRB-ML, which is derived from DataRaceBench, with
fine-grain labels showing the presence of data race pairs and their associated
variables, line numbers, and read/write information. DRB-ML is then used to
evaluate representative LLMs and fine-tune open-source ones. Our experiment
shows that LLMs can be a viable approach to data race detection. However, they
still cannot compete with traditional data race detection tools when we need
detailed information about variable pairs causing data races. | [
-0.0063672028,
0.0904754773,
-0.0330360346,
0.0973568633,
-0.0325895697,
0.0020139751,
0.0091401273,
-0.0124703795,
0.0568451583,
-0.026544068,
0.0282260086,
-0.0487874001,
-0.0213188194,
0.0433491766,
0.0020249553,
0.0006327101,
0.0620587841,
-0.0443206578,
-0.0131308306,
0.0138078518,
-0.0457902625,
-0.0084573878,
0.0471584573,
-0.0256073643,
-0.0154223032,
-0.0271372572,
-0.003451745,
0.0435525253,
0.021300558,
0.0206656605,
-0.0152506242,
0.0683730245,
-0.0146262944,
0.0722588748,
0.0000022789,
-0.0619126447,
-0.0167622138,
0.0466526076,
-0.0339944065,
0.0380566791,
0.0317980498,
0.0119376583,
-0.0251475759,
0.0124353748,
0.0277338196,
-0.011264096,
0.042386502,
-0.0391697809,
0.0814798772,
0.0288795661,
0.0022434592,
0.0186431687,
-0.0077933893,
-0.0090242364,
-0.0059464397,
-0.0023742511,
0.022586789,
0.0063697165,
-0.0044023297,
-0.0119874394,
-0.02327732,
-0.0073065315,
-0.0047934656,
-0.0265388321,
-0.0490094684,
-0.0269589759,
-0.0419309139,
0.0222136471,
-0.0022640817,
0.0295635778,
-0.0668488443,
-0.0337678418,
0.0487273969,
-0.0027671563,
-0.0289876554,
-0.0345275328,
0.0267787334,
0.0332653262,
-0.0152812675,
-0.0486897156,
0.0232608486,
-0.0009145599,
0.0286391675,
-0.031468451,
-0.0338204727,
0.0649542361,
0.0331669077,
-0.0133512327,
-0.0309757069,
-0.02432172,
0.0390050858,
-0.0586522445,
-0.0118370997,
-0.0131543037,
-0.0525642596,
0.0145656643,
-0.0707649365,
-0.0508767851,
0.0414863303,
-0.0824985132,
-0.0002290184,
0.0485987179,
-0.0412507132,
0.0295387059,
-0.0026952452,
0.0230247602,
-0.0170605946,
-0.0435176641,
-0.0037921132,
-0.0077493722,
0.0606200695,
0.018078234,
-0.0234718621,
-0.018284427,
-0.011357544,
0.0498546734,
-0.0132027902,
0.0692911372,
-0.0265034419,
0.0713929757,
-0.0386416949,
-0.065385811,
0.0191484187,
0.0213238522,
0.0297578406,
-0.0552234836,
-0.0010655243,
-0.0482679792,
-0.0635381415,
-0.0721664205,
-0.0250790529,
-0.0295449942,
-0.0365200229,
-0.0306318421,
0.0313837975,
0.0760297775,
0.05269932,
0.0320513025,
-0.0461607613,
-0.0776738673,
0.0069291499,
-0.0447328463,
-0.0229954794,
-0.0581992678,
-0.0158284828,
0.0172185805,
0.0287146233,
-0.0039150701,
-0.0288147721,
0.0036017224,
-0.0398273803,
0.052465573,
-0.051728446,
0.005151296,
-0.0119332578,
0.0331296027,
0.0146770962,
0.0437453166,
-0.029351227,
-0.0127361063,
0.0252755843,
-0.0577513762,
0.0177777596,
0.0425336547,
-0.012246835,
0.0610881448,
-0.0331010744,
0.0475460142,
0.0821009949,
-0.011990034,
-0.0025656139,
0.0455639586,
0.0029766858,
-0.0574765466,
0.0078053344,
0.0201353393,
-0.0433109775,
0.0259470642,
0.0012034203,
0.0266681071,
-0.0361391269,
0.0073178741,
-0.0134547902,
-0.006018715,
-0.017367186,
-0.0102091804,
0.0469044857,
0.0420464389,
-0.0216207877,
0.0000125354,
-0.0337752439,
0.0134244775,
-0.0465688221,
0.0200246368,
0.0460674167,
-0.0323507786,
-0.0087551279,
0.0186443161,
0.0365015119,
-0.035687156,
-0.0586643368,
-0.0348986462,
0.0116629722,
0.0718297213,
0.0384078808,
-0.0687386468,
-0.0458457917,
-0.0029795172,
0.0266651139,
-0.0164234601,
0.0427154377,
0.0015256112,
0.0213066116,
-0.0126660559,
0.0104849543,
0.0417795144,
0.0060209036,
0.0290201791,
-0.0219453927,
0.0027219853,
0.0116278268,
0.0281627066,
-0.078704074,
0.0060000308,
0.0230321195,
-0.004447239,
0.0211905818,
0.005451222,
0.0099436678,
-0.020079121,
-0.050285805,
-0.0047216369,
0.0498187616,
0.0051377746,
0.0233345702,
-0.0069433716,
-0.0357822888,
0.0261056293,
0.03214233,
0.0036016672,
-0.0403280221,
0.0016301217,
-0.0759531856,
-0.0288733616,
0.0467978977,
-0.0029388145,
-0.0367530733,
0.0441853628,
0.0343731642,
-0.020732766,
0.0117059648,
-0.0249484852,
-0.0009140217,
0.0084896144,
0.0345688164,
0.0199253578,
0.0479234681,
0.0195452906,
0.0040122243,
-0.0655724853,
0.0171768125,
-0.0155187994,
0.0526438765,
-0.0473411791,
-0.0069290716,
0.0107138036,
-0.0185419265,
-0.0506017841,
0.0143840918,
0.0289817117,
0.0248116292,
0.0349480994,
-0.0038578904,
-0.0201193411,
-0.0115612708,
0.0189120844,
-0.0099184886,
0.0400738753,
0.0224818103,
0.004105302,
-0.0265045278,
-0.0889169723,
0.0079000806,
-0.0384778567,
-0.0281810518,
0.0642985925,
-0.029731473,
-0.006891916,
-0.0864565372,
0.0190447494,
0.0182851944,
0.0450246707,
-0.0464087017,
0.0194093082,
-0.0372682884,
-0.0142167108,
0.0300975163,
0.0510109775,
-0.0440106839,
-0.0076542813,
0.0309245586,
-0.0427181274,
-0.0312856399,
-0.0091558974,
0.0539210103,
-0.0070399269,
0.0210705511,
-0.0148260342,
0.009159198,
0.0451834984,
-0.012883543,
-0.0448830649,
0.0130964462,
0.0225381851,
0.0129974075,
0.0145060131,
-0.0229937322,
-0.0762109756,
-0.0164998453,
0.0297011621,
-0.0133440951,
-0.0823320299,
0.044302173,
-0.0538066663,
-0.0083854934,
-0.021937415,
-0.0279433299,
-0.0156939533,
0.0276360512,
-0.020694349,
-0.002876339,
-0.0426475331,
-0.0113422042,
0.0130413696,
0.0330412798,
-0.0173699539,
-0.0338013694,
0.06909585,
-0.0483675338,
0.0143417567,
-0.037358705,
-0.0113577759,
-0.0249875616,
-0.0192816649,
-0.0125220502,
-0.0125396475,
0.0785805658,
-0.0026073188,
0.047740303,
0.0471424013,
-0.0217296444,
0.0698309466,
0.0284735486,
0.0113174068,
0.0023736248,
-0.0328144804,
-0.0037962252,
-0.0387810171,
0.0212976504,
-0.0221476145,
0.0353987142,
0.0273340419,
0.0302575156,
-0.0426337831,
-0.0343825109,
-0.0060563292,
0.0420523174,
-0.0178379975,
-0.0024310909,
0.0353477523,
-0.0257278215,
-0.0830544382,
-0.0492611378,
0.0469220653,
0.0163959973,
-0.0331801809,
-0.00421084,
-0.0410667993,
0.064398542,
0.0343936458,
0.0560162626,
-0.1038871706,
-0.0030008731,
0.0252346359,
-0.0092180008,
-0.0055501554,
0.0024988449,
-0.010691544,
-0.0891621336,
0.0160770882,
0.018053297,
-0.0489750281,
0.002682114,
-0.0315121002,
-0.025784893,
0.0155993421,
-0.0016663193,
0.0288902465,
0.0131783085,
-0.0003916071,
-0.002942875,
-0.0165604297,
-0.0261057075,
0.0394278653,
-0.0233497154,
0.0340730436,
0.0315949656,
-0.0145750716,
-0.0273759086,
0.0176689122,
0.0839937702,
0.0212710239,
-0.0261273049,
-0.0526429154,
0.0411235355,
0.0066704392,
-0.0542102084,
-0.0064375326,
-0.038202174,
0.0100207319,
0.0200851224,
0.0204246622,
0.0711815655,
-0.0463892557,
-0.0105136856,
0.0147135267,
-0.0221821405,
0.0133528234,
0.0642044768,
0.0290508177,
-0.055145625,
-0.0203534439,
-0.0292693824,
-0.0328959152,
-0.0301176272,
0.0022049749,
-0.031236941,
-0.0120061561,
-0.0163879059,
0.0201134793,
0.0426119156,
0.0280404408,
-0.0017895756,
0.0457542352,
-0.0076073734,
0.0222622398,
-0.0299336761,
-0.075355731,
0.0484704562,
-0.0386601016,
0.0315533094,
-0.0553363338,
0.023532968,
0.0027064628,
0.0501412712,
-0.0239061862,
0.0505643748,
-0.0848317221,
-0.0854461938,
0.0202160496,
0.0872773007,
0.0192319974,
-0.0086603714,
-0.0096496772,
-0.0609526224,
-0.0695936307,
0.0413051099,
-0.0143774124,
0.0311196838,
-0.0263753813,
-0.0526712872,
-0.0109232347,
-0.050692793,
-0.0032832234,
-0.0000331951,
0.0566612259,
-0.0830237195,
-0.0020293167,
-0.046049539,
-0.0394746326,
0.0849727988,
0.0206303969,
0.0372750238,
-0.0363365822,
0.003924638,
0.0475331359,
-0.030983232,
-0.0373647846,
-0.0172911771,
0.0364763662,
-0.0231607258,
-0.0258490536,
-0.0288351085,
-0.0354912803,
0.0078309327,
-0.0168460049,
-0.054035414,
0.0142618641,
-0.0075274142,
0.0102746338,
0.0811166167,
-0.0079797134,
0.0061268308,
0.0221932605,
0.0487179458,
0.0610394217,
-0.0238654912,
0.0185017549,
0.0278879851,
0.0177967027,
0.026598366,
0.0535116754,
-0.0142443627,
-0.0557832383,
0.0027581502,
-0.0081528295,
0.0459453799,
-0.0175953042,
0.0204004794,
0.0279846247,
0.0105079599,
-0.0531536825,
-0.0015772366,
0.0122839417,
-0.0095765088,
0.010773411,
0.0049555986,
-0.0759950206,
-0.0106412573,
0.0422143117,
0.0129029052,
0.0172861088,
0.0017215849,
-0.007867978,
-0.0192613266,
0.0131243104,
0.036906112,
-0.0138217704,
-0.0369496532,
-0.0541121215,
-0.0598063245,
-0.0296077356,
-0.0108264918,
0.0216254704,
0.0349068269,
-0.0049434877,
-0.0038054041,
0.0404788889,
0.02384587,
0.015062049,
-0.0092647169,
0.0214374773,
0.0290350374,
-0.0572686344,
0.0314441994,
-6.092125471e-33,
-0.005840844,
-0.0404525101,
-0.0276648086,
-0.0232548267,
0.0062843924,
0.0147188455,
-0.0252297446,
-0.0050885663,
0.0073965047,
-0.0430865698,
0.0071316734,
0.0066861385,
0.0242711585,
-0.0419455357,
0.0085688233,
-0.0027741813,
0.0144506888,
0.0574309528,
-0.0102262236,
0.0169410668,
0.0473621711,
0.0097014587,
-0.0062423931,
-0.0554214381,
-0.0003979966,
-0.077271834,
0.0562095195,
0.003613529,
-0.0319092087,
0.0031850911,
0.0097079668,
-0.0019060258,
0.005080713,
-0.0654558316,
-0.0099525545,
0.0184033103,
-0.0153707815,
-0.0105663519,
0.0111465119,
0.027657466,
0.0622857027,
-0.034673728,
0.0173525959,
0.0732486993,
0.0014332718,
0.0157006662,
-0.0042492137,
-0.0000553481,
-0.0108329775,
-0.0186158549,
-0.0026732609,
0.0282214489,
-0.0112162605,
0.0419870615,
0.0538420081,
-0.0113179339,
0.0129393237,
0.0442218371,
-0.0322435014,
0.0266099311,
0.0462147482,
0.0594231933,
0.0851463154,
0.0494446345,
0.0074947593,
0.0424086414,
0.0092220875,
0.0613954179,
0.0363897532,
0.0249175318,
0.0315007456,
0.0231931899,
0.0016214397,
0.0100861508,
0.0037373991,
0.0020456719,
-0.0456708968,
0.0126946568,
0.0082928119,
-0.0687409788,
0.026115803,
-0.022448061,
-0.0368981883,
-0.0495344549,
-0.0517799892,
0.0649708584,
-0.0618727766,
0.0483568199,
0.0421627127,
-0.0453526415,
-0.0098493733,
0.0289111882,
0.0609040931,
-0.0353154987,
0.0086046197,
-0.0255186558,
-0.0108760698,
-0.0425083041,
-0.0336222723,
0.0382290073,
0.0223611854,
-0.0745197386,
-0.0153947519,
-0.0197405256,
0.0794512406,
-0.0042700567,
-0.0127397394,
-0.0139999259,
-0.0885100365,
0.0361669511,
-0.0284457244,
0.0285911597,
-0.0127542494,
0.0526689887,
0.015805142,
0.0198298544,
0.0281053819,
0.0684937537,
0.0462118983,
-0.0309667997,
-0.0143334623,
0.014306644,
-0.0036726641,
-0.0002344268,
0.0124750379,
0.0255893935,
0.0258248057,
-0.0145067889,
0.0520895347,
-0.0289613195,
-0.0262135398,
0.0121455435,
3.037e-7,
-0.0057579074,
0.0831905305,
0.002908248,
0.0081045413,
0.0168756098,
0.0536896065,
-0.0229711793,
0.0076426365,
0.016632406,
0.0166947041,
-0.005166945,
-0.0131319948,
0.0658319443,
0.0302591156,
-0.0120423734,
0.0092831273,
-0.063820526,
0.0186867826,
-0.0887186155,
-0.0364017636,
0.0295580812,
0.0470554456,
-0.0040351632,
-0.0124811195,
0.0312229879,
-0.0425694585,
-0.0469776988,
-0.0227611754,
-0.0093507562,
0.0563741103,
-0.0009283466,
-0.0149282347,
-0.0228283219,
0.0685982481,
-0.0111528104,
-0.0220539011,
-0.0397526287,
0.0752887875,
0.0261616521,
0.0485146195,
0.061290551,
-0.0350278877,
-0.0391743593,
-0.0550574511,
0.0619485974,
0.0411914177,
-0.0308834221,
-0.0436377265,
0.0345740207,
-0.0379884504,
0.0176141299,
-0.0084875301,
0.0396797732,
0.044410836,
0.0178313255,
-0.0151043497,
0.010474327,
-0.0155010298,
-0.0869749784,
0.0182988867,
-0.0505692028,
-0.0604347773,
-0.0136768697,
0.026998071,
0.0003793913,
-0.010283336,
0.0166451596,
3.449548784e-34,
0.0542334355,
-0.0077724801,
0.0073640007,
0.0088077486,
0.0479155183,
-0.0020685676,
-0.0535623804,
0.0228740294,
-0.0293725431,
-0.0440578014,
-0.0080718789
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07489v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07489v1 | SOTASTREAM: A Streaming Approach to Machine Translation Training | 2023-08-14T22:47:19 | 2023-08-14T22:47:19 | Matt Post, Thamme Gowda, Roman Grundkiewicz, Huda Khayrallah, Rohit Jain, Marcin Junczys-Dowmunt | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many machine translation toolkits make use of a data preparation step wherein
raw data is transformed into a tensor format that can be used directly by the
trainer. This preparation step is increasingly at odds with modern research and
development practices because this process produces a static, unchangeable
version of the training data, making common training-time needs difficult
(e.g., subword sampling), time-consuming (preprocessing with large data can
take days), expensive (e.g., disk space), and cumbersome (managing experiment
combinatorics). We propose an alternative approach that separates the
generation of data from the consumption of that data. In this approach, there
is no separate pre-processing step; data generation produces an infinite stream
of permutations of the raw training data, which the trainer tensorizes and
batches as it is consumed. Additionally, this data stream can be manipulated by
a set of user-definable operators that provide on-the-fly modifications, such
as data normalization, augmentation or filtering. We release an open-source
toolkit, SOTASTREAM, that implements this approach:
https://github.com/marian-nmt/sotastream. We show that it cuts training time,
adds flexibility, reduces experiment management complexity, and reduces disk
space, all without affecting the accuracy of the trained models. | [
0.0107867233,
0.0659705102,
-0.0028308728,
0.0316370986,
-0.0144184269,
0.0218639895,
0.0329777598,
0.0248703901,
-0.0242389906,
-0.0021016626,
-0.0535496287,
-0.0485489666,
0.0041408185,
0.0489768535,
0.0249260236,
-0.0909529328,
0.0297691822,
-0.0103034098,
-0.0421933159,
0.0008487299,
-0.0084299836,
0.0207999777,
-0.0165720955,
0.0015176573,
0.0100810686,
0.0087161511,
-0.0066959653,
0.0294694938,
0.0238911286,
-0.0250243098,
0.0006099401,
0.068616055,
0.0483442135,
0.0977886468,
0.0000020945,
0.0047303531,
-0.0222446863,
0.0039171306,
-0.004630608,
0.000959627,
0.0800585002,
-0.0693215355,
-0.0173992533,
0.018715715,
-0.0361495353,
-0.0309734587,
0.0662598237,
-0.0420095474,
0.0674620196,
0.0858139843,
-0.0137495371,
-0.0324834697,
-0.0151589876,
-0.0341125205,
-0.0162472613,
-0.0092099058,
-0.0144387269,
-0.0225483179,
-0.0326715745,
0.0363113172,
-0.0319209248,
0.0328876935,
0.0359144583,
0.0168663114,
0.0535447076,
0.0422944017,
-0.0268475823,
-0.0743854567,
-0.0329600088,
0.0831773058,
-0.0154727027,
-0.0238835998,
-0.0079077296,
-0.0042254752,
-0.0474419668,
-0.0388778001,
-0.0230589323,
0.0033431903,
0.0162981264,
0.0204405878,
-0.0211446546,
-0.01472783,
-0.0014091468,
0.0059005055,
-0.0507418476,
-0.0082674855,
0.0282002613,
-0.0145764835,
-0.0148284612,
0.0202119891,
0.0203144699,
-0.0267350003,
0.0405772738,
-0.0132294474,
-0.0205652639,
-0.0026930261,
-0.0514308885,
-0.1000300646,
-0.02034452,
-0.0457927957,
0.0570644848,
0.0590968356,
0.0131003633,
0.0346463695,
-0.0070280358,
0.0388167836,
-0.0080041606,
0.0031357806,
-0.0705354512,
-0.0104406457,
-0.0286430847,
0.0131732365,
-0.053817194,
-0.018972367,
-0.0641096383,
-0.0072613931,
-0.0262648202,
0.0090376558,
0.011275542,
-0.0167909712,
0.0192127246,
-0.0046507688,
-0.0972492918,
0.0046357103,
0.0019841427,
0.07237342,
-0.0262098443,
-0.0120350718,
-0.0067183948,
-0.0478000045,
-0.0447054021,
0.0033860425,
0.013077464,
-0.0295784995,
0.0287829135,
0.0263327993,
-0.0411044993,
-0.066492103,
-0.0003731582,
-0.0098771844,
0.0150320344,
-0.0615189336,
0.0014221104,
-0.0538748987,
0.066784583,
-0.0065991553,
0.008934062,
-0.0166332517,
-0.0014791685,
0.0005989531,
-0.023111375,
0.0702854022,
-0.0139133343,
0.0139629329,
0.0158990808,
0.0023904971,
-0.0030491697,
0.0729923621,
0.0464426503,
0.0384223238,
0.0057010218,
-0.0177070349,
-0.0205662921,
0.0440236703,
0.0280741137,
0.0348919593,
-0.0451875702,
-0.0098536611,
-0.0120605482,
0.0659845099,
0.0693988055,
0.0387773961,
-0.0456248187,
0.0279634036,
0.0788866058,
0.0577461757,
0.0156284217,
0.0579769798,
0.0595545657,
0.0163067579,
0.0083543332,
0.0108673023,
-0.0245488975,
0.0350529999,
0.0521129668,
-0.0220183022,
0.0096990857,
0.0588967577,
-0.0313010179,
-0.0065280586,
0.0142449373,
-0.0183961559,
0.0288220737,
-0.0215996169,
0.0540263988,
0.0313609876,
-0.0255655944,
0.0452513508,
0.005237285,
-0.083092615,
0.0349136963,
-0.0034662241,
0.0012553351,
0.0802852437,
0.0378344208,
0.0132283671,
-0.0214933399,
0.0054569067,
0.0242789015,
0.0348708257,
0.0780052915,
0.0164829865,
0.0604397282,
-0.056697838,
-0.0133641036,
0.0214586034,
-0.0097523769,
0.0191252492,
0.0366982259,
0.0389986858,
0.0277357176,
-0.0216929559,
-0.0503046848,
0.0411446206,
-0.0210180581,
-0.0412270576,
0.043900732,
-0.0095423525,
0.0373534225,
0.0092175957,
-0.0201727338,
-0.0162931681,
0.052457273,
-0.0243485551,
-0.0043224408,
0.0234850682,
-0.0184009261,
-0.0256520044,
0.0155796399,
-0.0309445355,
-0.0127924057,
0.0399295874,
-0.073194392,
-0.0375087336,
0.0221817177,
-0.0304803345,
0.0029514793,
-0.0190495253,
-0.0017665991,
0.0139015401,
0.0302952062,
-0.0099641383,
-0.0028409222,
0.0065663629,
-0.0068255262,
-0.018863501,
-0.0277309902,
-0.0118510779,
-0.0356272198,
0.0005337254,
0.0383298509,
0.0389237143,
-0.0019349249,
0.0284330677,
0.0366874449,
-0.0569176786,
-0.0131881014,
-0.0990794599,
0.0493816063,
-0.0087020462,
0.0566185899,
0.0323839448,
0.0524815172,
-0.0180577431,
-0.0188513827,
-0.0159089696,
0.0015594924,
0.0058674212,
0.0088265445,
0.0084334183,
-0.0183148161,
0.028836105,
0.0064309416,
-0.0227706768,
0.0222398732,
0.0499829501,
-0.006421526,
-0.0186523106,
-0.0535949357,
-0.0272010304,
-0.035403762,
0.0094821565,
0.0238115042,
-0.0398015194,
0.0035244203,
-0.0069955634,
0.041085735,
0.0449284501,
0.0195065588,
-0.000748456,
0.0137716373,
0.0082417941,
-0.0389408469,
0.0034398083,
-0.0068237553,
-0.0503481962,
-0.007650828,
-0.025895182,
-0.0143843582,
0.0249289256,
-0.004014181,
-0.0095715476,
-0.0501800813,
0.0005191172,
-0.0155672068,
-0.0274524447,
-0.0243109073,
0.0112585034,
-0.0029803761,
-0.0039677415,
-0.0046591978,
-0.0702110678,
0.0877787471,
-0.0202550534,
-0.0539167672,
-0.0764437467,
-0.0245098509,
-0.0261473488,
0.0506022274,
-0.0075958357,
0.0302248709,
-0.0323912948,
0.020897774,
-0.0138618173,
0.0129687237,
0.0083224978,
-0.0384179838,
-0.0246326011,
-0.0576973222,
-0.0103069013,
-0.0353416912,
-0.0182694718,
-0.0222886913,
0.0154747749,
0.0117533607,
-0.0196724646,
0.0114276232,
-0.0546788387,
-0.0005083671,
-0.0137764951,
0.0225738287,
0.0848861337,
-0.0277372673,
-0.0137660559,
-0.0123242186,
0.0409947038,
-0.0142095033,
-0.0069598849,
-0.0002614326,
-0.0383488424,
-0.0012474286,
0.0808524191,
0.0500322431,
-0.0330919288,
-0.0654583573,
-0.0115650576,
0.0378959887,
0.0072207293,
-0.0050666919,
-0.0093497494,
0.0510846041,
-0.0632210746,
-0.0101360073,
0.0819047913,
0.0315594599,
-0.0441043079,
-0.0031696933,
0.0544982366,
0.0397731289,
0.0057461499,
0.0421722978,
-0.0902150199,
-0.0160752367,
-0.0024396889,
0.0701475665,
0.0318139791,
0.000125529,
-0.0495174788,
-0.0317050442,
0.0507786348,
0.0692988411,
-0.0378687158,
-0.0417361744,
-0.0628530681,
-0.0423236042,
-0.0466705859,
0.0161250383,
0.0163907167,
0.0206857119,
0.035428673,
0.0221953038,
0.0274182446,
-0.0599815138,
-0.0257854406,
-0.0626462251,
0.0223494787,
0.050928276,
0.0394114554,
0.0147327157,
-0.0258941241,
0.0177156385,
0.005918643,
-0.0059688035,
-0.0342516042,
0.029872857,
0.0072351587,
-0.0179459285,
0.0078325374,
0.0496993102,
-0.025558617,
0.0074767494,
-0.0207305886,
0.060181953,
-0.0186977759,
-0.0328159519,
-0.0098519782,
-0.0464026928,
0.0541756451,
0.056960661,
-0.0060004774,
-0.0344658494,
0.0171489771,
-0.013173651,
0.0011674961,
-0.0403308645,
-0.0156306252,
-0.0456624553,
-0.0495590419,
-0.0510846414,
-0.0840244293,
-0.0347647518,
0.0099678989,
0.0391126946,
-0.0079555167,
-0.0179017372,
-0.001474309,
-0.009115913,
-0.0565134175,
0.0744659752,
-0.047007598,
0.028881751,
-0.0165764447,
-0.0582379252,
0.0355738103,
0.0054701231,
0.0057077776,
0.0664277002,
-0.1212785393,
-0.0629961789,
-0.0268157385,
0.0593261532,
0.0174978711,
0.038536638,
0.0049602939,
-0.0026694494,
0.0491994508,
0.0267134272,
-0.0679944977,
0.0285495427,
0.0388891175,
-0.0322012641,
-0.0005829229,
0.016475359,
0.0174476523,
0.0000119244,
-0.0123173036,
0.0384216569,
0.0008782818,
0.0081382794,
0.0050207265,
-0.0030790793,
0.0539040454,
-0.0348109715,
-0.0249188654,
-0.030810358,
0.0150902495,
0.0061615487,
-0.0085994452,
-0.0652422681,
0.0115883024,
0.0317231491,
0.0247143842,
-0.0204452984,
0.0199979842,
0.0125810616,
-0.0345212445,
-0.0013524184,
-0.0150899868,
-0.0239232667,
-0.0167461578,
0.0453351699,
0.0261271335,
-0.0084707187,
0.0201266985,
-0.0230278298,
0.0266873892,
-0.0374316573,
0.033191774,
0.0072386628,
0.030500751,
0.0012866821,
0.0436448306,
-0.0526345484,
-0.0201758444,
-0.0490325391,
0.0340920128,
0.0499042235,
0.0042231204,
0.07938236,
-0.0510707833,
-0.0061152461,
-0.0239277203,
0.0254558306,
-0.0486164689,
-0.0191551764,
-0.0233885534,
-0.0342229083,
-0.0011598353,
-0.0015908135,
0.0686460584,
-0.0230957121,
0.0375010967,
-0.0181074813,
-0.0164271481,
-0.0185188055,
-0.032049533,
-0.0112633668,
-0.0111606577,
-0.0286826342,
-0.0337485634,
0.0028648747,
-0.0543230101,
-0.0022783903,
0.0009616739,
-0.0205451604,
-0.0238455888,
0.0563846342,
0.0559824109,
-0.0595870875,
0.0056792754,
-0.0292037986,
0.0196927506,
0.031264443,
-0.06885162,
-0.0333187208,
-6.360724094e-33,
-0.018134864,
0.0258816686,
0.0355561301,
-0.0292131305,
-0.0375768133,
0.0144743081,
-0.0324911326,
-0.0285714772,
0.0274051894,
-0.0054258588,
-0.0023896694,
0.0196702573,
0.0268397108,
0.0073031858,
-0.0013364448,
0.0122837452,
0.0611637756,
-0.0258561634,
-0.0497288853,
0.0392156355,
0.0512526743,
0.0402264781,
0.0849987715,
-0.0638485551,
-0.0018320309,
0.024514582,
-0.0091766864,
0.0110277561,
-0.0047204043,
-0.0035818752,
-0.0008461708,
0.0004982951,
-0.019928826,
-0.0410703495,
-0.0485664718,
-0.0174798593,
-0.0940093026,
0.0002035509,
-0.0084221186,
0.0565111637,
-0.0578509644,
-0.0097163357,
0.0486527458,
-0.0299532115,
-0.0217311941,
0.0014120012,
-0.023161253,
-0.0304532796,
-0.0353611223,
-0.0183761865,
-0.044480592,
0.0132374987,
-0.0207705535,
-0.0086917104,
0.0441506132,
0.0228530094,
-0.0014369963,
-0.058344733,
-0.0637163371,
0.0353137478,
0.0187273808,
0.0375520475,
0.0647689998,
-0.0126735391,
0.0290945843,
0.0022210381,
0.046782095,
-0.0485071763,
0.0138388649,
0.0069396831,
0.0595284291,
-0.0313977711,
0.0562719069,
0.023919547,
0.0763108209,
-0.0238837022,
-0.0204156321,
0.0459546149,
0.0079844408,
0.0031152312,
-0.0077444687,
0.0419912189,
-0.0085288882,
-0.0055418257,
-0.036265485,
-0.0350753553,
-0.0136640938,
-0.0337107368,
-0.0145151932,
0.0527784526,
-0.0437733158,
-0.0022001269,
0.0698345974,
-0.0150344195,
0.0293872133,
0.0074949581,
-0.0147566646,
0.0072192056,
-0.0029767656,
0.0058214595,
-0.0208002739,
-0.0433397591,
0.0433953106,
-0.0042258622,
0.0042524436,
-0.0177823938,
0.0468803868,
0.0731275231,
-0.0321303196,
0.0186056551,
-0.0466051623,
0.0193970148,
0.019677693,
0.0155525357,
0.0172207057,
0.0122764315,
0.0087827183,
0.0337294079,
0.0353321843,
0.0058193668,
-0.0565797649,
-0.0025146804,
0.049050387,
0.0369416438,
-0.0380401947,
0.0192022044,
-0.0538546033,
-0.003035588,
0.0576580092,
-0.0603974387,
-0.0453394949,
0.010945349,
2.79e-7,
0.0335780345,
0.0665003583,
0.000111804,
0.010266481,
0.018662829,
0.0014369189,
-0.0093823383,
0.0639019683,
0.0201313198,
0.0394488201,
0.0419643223,
0.0573486239,
0.0720138699,
0.0487500355,
-0.0706741363,
-0.0526632592,
-0.064330928,
0.0202452205,
-0.061991401,
-0.0323226415,
0.0163147058,
0.1080364808,
0.0414042994,
-0.0182244424,
0.0498654805,
-0.0076351785,
0.0640884489,
0.0072570629,
0.036773406,
0.0019978294,
-0.0019256258,
0.0170621593,
-0.0288525596,
0.0082484102,
-0.0522202626,
-0.024463214,
0.0059391535,
0.0635290518,
-0.0153380902,
-0.001213324,
0.0332553312,
-0.0009935076,
-0.013633891,
-0.0422985591,
0.031113958,
-0.0133743268,
0.0191155933,
-0.0413350239,
0.0077711525,
0.010693443,
0.0324342474,
-0.0496463515,
-0.0187809821,
0.0500855185,
0.0497363657,
0.017580932,
-0.0382239893,
-0.0389710404,
-0.0241996218,
-0.0419682004,
-0.0200917386,
-0.0540525019,
-0.0713719726,
0.030934263,
-0.0060550948,
-0.0357680656,
-0.0228690989,
2.641229277e-34,
0.0128856339,
-0.0010769406,
0.0076625906,
-0.0134761361,
0.0391867012,
-0.034345001,
0.0372734815,
-0.0192985162,
-0.0090649743,
-0.0480447821,
-0.0445014611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07486v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07486v1 | O-1: Self-training with Oracle and 1-best Hypothesis | 2023-08-14T22:36:27 | 2023-08-14T22:36:27 | Murali Karthick Baskar, Andrew Rosenberg, Bhuvana Ramabhadran, Kartik Audhkhasi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | We introduce O-1, a new self-training objective to reduce training bias and
unify training and evaluation metrics for speech recognition. O-1 is a faster
variant of Expected Minimum Bayes Risk (EMBR), that boosts the oracle
hypothesis and can accommodate both supervised and unsupervised data. We
demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in terms of recognition on
publicly available SpeechStew datasets and a large-scale, in-house data set. On
Speechstew, the O-1 objective closes the gap between the actual and oracle
performance by 80\% relative compared to EMBR which bridges the gap by 43\%
relative. O-1 achieves 13\% to 25\% relative improvement over EMBR on the
various datasets that SpeechStew comprises of, and a 12\% relative gap
reduction with respect to the oracle WER over EMBR training on the in-house
dataset. Overall, O-1 results in a 9\% relative improvement in WER over EMBR,
thereby speaking to the scalability of the proposed objective for large-scale
datasets. | [
-0.0522088297,
0.0201318916,
0.0419955403,
0.0124556255,
-0.0356289558,
0.0132119916,
0.0475605242,
0.0031530035,
0.0752389729,
-0.0116909696,
-0.0776155815,
0.0487423018,
0.0145069035,
-0.0071405196,
-0.0058121728,
-0.0145473927,
0.0542781204,
-0.0388502665,
-0.0089588342,
-0.032164447,
-0.0126094921,
-0.0181796942,
-0.0804181397,
0.0003167696,
-0.0251601432,
0.0032538886,
0.0167435948,
0.0132667534,
0.0169651676,
-0.0317624994,
-0.0382600911,
0.027127739,
0.0098298267,
0.0014528799,
0.0000020181,
-0.0645156726,
-0.031166885,
-0.0153111173,
-0.0649114698,
-0.0139318937,
0.0227726586,
0.0116724074,
-0.0215292051,
0.0661697611,
-0.0054773013,
-0.0605628006,
0.0568503924,
0.0428629145,
0.0162800737,
0.055294916,
-0.0049915784,
-0.0428484716,
0.0108221378,
-0.0125508346,
-0.0435996875,
-0.0440359563,
0.0052233483,
-0.0302271266,
-0.0573696345,
-0.0551302023,
0.005574319,
0.0472360924,
0.0049924552,
0.0452680886,
0.0581687838,
0.0456192493,
0.0051998533,
0.0174003392,
-0.0235578194,
0.0246132426,
0.0101290122,
-0.0291927233,
-0.0087501695,
-0.0020670998,
-0.0382248722,
-0.0022422073,
0.0352744199,
0.0104182297,
0.0066101388,
0.007636175,
0.0142365769,
0.0683673769,
0.0102184284,
0.0255070254,
-0.0376180485,
0.040817827,
-0.0168153159,
-0.0203810204,
0.0347768031,
-0.03570522,
0.0489199273,
0.0149644446,
0.0229185894,
-0.0087587964,
0.0087816073,
-0.0061424472,
-0.0034064737,
-0.0283306278,
-0.0186892487,
-0.0621101074,
0.0084734987,
0.0240732264,
-0.0378643945,
0.0334901661,
-0.0107310237,
0.0278087631,
0.0359617993,
0.030049026,
-0.0075732544,
0.042256467,
-0.0459682979,
0.0436599404,
-0.0474196747,
0.0418639742,
-0.0040739649,
-0.0232173204,
-0.0345312767,
-0.0350664966,
-0.0005643491,
-0.0099444827,
0.0173893906,
-0.0134331025,
-0.0413094163,
0.0054432373,
-0.0055218632,
0.0076791137,
-0.0041096401,
0.0194780566,
-0.0166440085,
-0.0802966803,
-0.0365997702,
0.0197744053,
0.0330821164,
0.0019592529,
0.0292414427,
0.0933234841,
-0.0280553289,
-0.0494219922,
-0.0531461649,
0.033912275,
-0.0365503095,
-0.0212465674,
-0.0416781157,
-0.0449081175,
0.0439459048,
-0.0055267382,
0.0240220223,
-0.0094276397,
0.0027977128,
-0.0450446755,
0.0424162708,
0.096177958,
-0.0446459465,
0.0143471248,
0.0612198859,
-0.0068979692,
0.024109222,
0.0493748225,
0.0378462113,
0.0019236482,
0.0188727584,
-0.0225531012,
-0.0011865509,
0.0513911247,
0.0041076285,
-0.0039917994,
-0.0282829702,
0.025800772,
0.0139846466,
0.0478272513,
0.0472416878,
0.0015157498,
-0.045977518,
-0.0451331548,
0.0323615968,
0.0275813397,
0.0246578753,
0.0050927564,
-0.0493170507,
0.0004397781,
0.0261964686,
-0.0163470395,
-0.0142535763,
-0.0151236765,
-0.0103331683,
0.0078850929,
0.0405900553,
-0.0047449977,
-0.0273653325,
-0.0291733313,
0.0034009621,
-0.0346463919,
-0.0546030216,
0.0508743189,
0.071034275,
-0.0099373609,
-0.0173065756,
0.0265185069,
0.017708173,
-0.0359787419,
0.0074358471,
-0.0500271171,
-0.0067358091,
0.0154525191,
0.0271412935,
-0.0668136328,
-0.0026007476,
-0.0121886423,
-0.0356894583,
-0.0011570054,
0.0105167516,
0.015615901,
0.0862481892,
-0.0524990447,
-0.0212120209,
0.030946549,
-0.0094211241,
0.0733053312,
-0.0393240452,
0.0087173218,
0.0103915902,
-0.0497451201,
-0.0348445438,
0.0136931892,
0.0137899276,
-0.0611706898,
0.0681674927,
0.0564309098,
0.0910233483,
0.0400428548,
-0.0620161593,
-0.0118770283,
0.0185077433,
-0.0224564392,
0.0178622026,
0.0033260959,
-0.0921698809,
-0.0460592248,
0.0678159073,
-0.0249191094,
0.0202151705,
0.0177734699,
-0.0066702757,
-0.0852987915,
0.0118373604,
-0.006187818,
0.0345746577,
-0.0636275932,
0.0267829187,
0.0108404467,
0.0049098064,
0.0030148241,
0.0048726425,
0.0317791849,
-0.0315490775,
-0.0017453816,
-0.0049568913,
0.0575837567,
-0.0422961265,
0.0140835242,
-0.0173370484,
-0.0280564204,
0.0581563786,
-0.0014273727,
0.0041854386,
-0.0504258275,
0.0075202798,
-0.0576614104,
-0.0205718204,
-0.04963395,
0.0326450653,
0.0178603064,
0.0184754394,
-0.0230770577,
-0.0616234243,
-0.002518466,
-0.0435460955,
-0.0427401103,
-0.0147181358,
-0.0297506247,
0.005865918,
0.0178813692,
-0.0160353519,
0.0047861468,
0.0020092388,
-0.0177648496,
0.008363897,
-0.0249360241,
-0.0264955629,
0.0338398479,
0.0327629149,
0.0097214673,
-0.0055652149,
-0.0086384295,
-0.0170741584,
-0.0008857037,
0.0025995495,
0.020634843,
0.014553627,
-0.0453106426,
0.0466702171,
0.0029142855,
-0.0747204646,
-0.0042962264,
0.0171927493,
0.0104473978,
-0.0074683302,
0.0186468493,
-0.0067665405,
-0.0006542569,
0.0358562022,
0.0339914151,
-0.0167807359,
-0.0556772426,
-0.0066814772,
-0.0423566364,
-0.057697095,
-0.0184173603,
-0.0182993636,
-0.0135556161,
0.0079914266,
-0.0535931364,
0.0106925126,
-0.0954001024,
-0.0185007788,
-0.0752916336,
-0.0482183024,
-0.0118631162,
0.0177437849,
0.0066301874,
0.0355500877,
0.0236589443,
-0.0368057527,
-0.0085264724,
-0.0223045871,
0.0396084189,
-0.0312789977,
0.006680558,
0.0010043994,
0.0299833082,
-0.02213558,
-0.0478340909,
-0.0313256048,
0.029267516,
-0.0190366097,
-0.0228112377,
-0.0156839024,
0.0250606965,
-0.0042433841,
0.0439948514,
0.0036009552,
0.0707263649,
0.0129164038,
-0.0098940106,
-0.0017371798,
0.0414836854,
-0.0117417872,
0.0276592039,
0.0067866482,
0.0145429596,
0.0383819118,
-0.0047558621,
0.103710942,
-0.0220935028,
-0.0835260898,
-0.0183075797,
0.0139377881,
-0.0370975584,
0.0194508526,
0.00716076,
0.0000093777,
-0.0089639099,
0.0252798051,
0.117627196,
-0.0072878278,
-0.0267939828,
-0.0388510749,
0.0031583274,
0.0188992638,
0.0093246493,
-0.0099236798,
-0.0311615802,
-0.0305381715,
0.0183230843,
0.0809518769,
0.0054787165,
-0.0227865614,
-0.0038013572,
-0.0833752155,
0.0402119458,
0.0240141992,
-0.0114138946,
-0.0206685681,
-0.0692399368,
-0.0151327159,
-0.108033061,
0.0104463836,
0.0127341775,
-0.0234293342,
-0.0207634214,
0.0400746688,
-0.08737652,
-0.0178760309,
0.0082853474,
-0.0526461713,
0.0474423394,
0.04460866,
-0.0208394583,
0.0074984278,
-0.0026698941,
-0.0075085866,
-0.0543347076,
0.0241136253,
-0.037222594,
0.0828298479,
-0.0295499135,
0.0022298277,
0.0286638383,
0.0358916707,
-0.0006551014,
0.0357907526,
0.0670002103,
0.0262105595,
-0.0404012986,
0.0336155072,
0.0190353692,
-0.0110529698,
0.005146136,
0.0480555482,
-0.002652155,
0.0285705812,
-0.0003580912,
0.0286924466,
0.0796844587,
0.025311375,
0.0121523691,
-0.0109837893,
-0.0159273595,
-0.0814233869,
-0.0313809365,
-0.0416474491,
-0.0165834781,
0.1193398163,
-0.0001707457,
0.0198734477,
-0.0237964503,
0.0341406614,
-0.0255717356,
-0.0175567009,
-0.0449164771,
-0.0010303875,
-0.0463125855,
-0.0072101527,
0.0304634646,
-0.0275028925,
-0.0301986355,
-0.000771442,
0.0102542723,
-0.0356761143,
0.0116433259,
0.027777154,
0.0192718767,
0.0599363893,
-0.029168861,
-0.0163012911,
0.0995026976,
0.0445554703,
-0.0657911971,
-0.0032525221,
0.0833107606,
-0.0264886133,
-0.0360491835,
0.0159289874,
-0.0082081454,
0.0333333723,
-0.0048008207,
-0.0027680309,
-0.0057484615,
-0.001274702,
-0.0000861894,
0.0388229415,
0.0995090455,
-0.0404155068,
0.0277668219,
-0.0633863807,
0.0323111117,
0.0105687007,
0.0386959203,
-0.0091148335,
0.0418125689,
0.021984987,
0.0131657468,
-0.0162744857,
0.0299615525,
0.0038907495,
-0.0700524747,
0.022712294,
0.0541202836,
0.0515795909,
0.0043696468,
-0.015409261,
-0.0338394009,
-0.0057265153,
0.0344356075,
0.0959515199,
-0.0134381801,
-0.0024694158,
0.0182925556,
0.0196695141,
0.0380937196,
-0.0034039589,
0.0003079264,
-0.0264942925,
-0.0475706533,
-0.0414428413,
0.0293951817,
0.0213930681,
-0.0241206978,
0.0185240395,
-0.024087267,
0.0113912905,
-0.0300405715,
-0.0063443175,
-0.0017834225,
0.0243702438,
-0.0092887934,
-0.0083494121,
-0.0193331894,
0.0651658699,
0.0419276431,
-0.0290447529,
0.0574299768,
0.0064683245,
0.0258072987,
-0.0653425306,
-0.0502681956,
-0.0177336503,
0.0048859431,
-0.0369487628,
-0.0262360387,
0.0177601893,
-0.0610173382,
0.032126613,
0.0143034477,
0.0338937156,
0.0102425851,
0.0448925458,
0.0124669401,
-0.0306202788,
0.0278751571,
-0.0022539895,
-0.0491831787,
-0.0060503078,
-0.0092848968,
0.0310211107,
-5.879226547e-33,
-0.0019145183,
0.0194778536,
0.0192657299,
-0.0397085845,
0.023428997,
0.0184853319,
-0.0011565789,
0.0500289164,
0.0118402438,
-0.0156014049,
-0.0317698382,
-0.0148102222,
0.0542755537,
0.0032265305,
-0.0083142035,
0.0006698471,
0.0928975269,
-0.0345762707,
-0.0357108042,
-0.0162650645,
0.0120106256,
0.0315405615,
0.0227196328,
-0.0612844452,
-0.0549015813,
0.0381160378,
-0.0451407358,
-0.0146062346,
0.0464729965,
0.0063591055,
-0.0062020873,
0.0288795754,
-0.0092919357,
-0.0353805721,
-0.0046160123,
-0.0273396242,
-0.1050449833,
-0.0311686471,
-0.0445110723,
0.0258212071,
-0.0334958732,
0.0224433057,
0.0196105279,
0.0145255486,
-0.0787614882,
-0.0267544296,
0.0128484378,
-0.0274264943,
-0.0031251775,
-0.0119646369,
0.0117024286,
0.0726149231,
-0.0245790407,
0.0026206174,
0.1037399694,
-0.0068290154,
-0.0259109829,
-0.0779119134,
-0.0616935603,
0.0478202626,
0.0354239978,
0.0041941223,
0.0384730175,
0.031144619,
-0.0082300995,
0.0217274558,
0.1426164061,
-0.0842543393,
0.0677193627,
-0.0384710655,
0.0239459779,
0.0324910767,
0.0106765553,
0.0334464945,
0.0190473609,
-0.0274944231,
-0.0605469085,
0.0442955382,
0.0491217375,
-0.0142414989,
-0.0152765187,
0.0198958591,
-0.0753814504,
0.0186837707,
-0.0387404896,
-0.0489431806,
-0.0159752425,
-0.0146725643,
0.0300042797,
0.0525730327,
-0.0020677631,
-0.012905498,
0.0259775613,
-0.0161382034,
-0.0022504921,
0.0209768657,
0.0124389278,
-0.027754711,
0.000207133,
0.0181308072,
-0.064328298,
-0.0110722184,
0.0334980115,
0.0575846136,
0.0175687317,
-0.0317916423,
0.0415013991,
0.0331430621,
-0.0662868172,
-0.0100544253,
0.0335384719,
0.0115211597,
0.0028604467,
0.0041816486,
0.0440398864,
-0.0579032823,
0.044111304,
0.0517511442,
-0.010609813,
-0.0050749569,
0.0023757955,
0.0407680012,
0.0118932454,
0.0055708974,
0.0131943393,
0.0427382179,
0.0201478042,
-0.0558668561,
0.007343635,
-0.0065864902,
-0.0114614703,
0.0025068712,
2.776e-7,
-0.0310026873,
0.019438412,
0.0164226945,
-0.0173092987,
0.01352973,
0.0470448397,
-0.0115136784,
-0.0071707843,
-0.0485742204,
0.021629883,
0.0514764749,
-0.0035093075,
0.039939411,
0.0029856018,
-0.0656771436,
-0.0042676372,
-0.0423294008,
0.0459257066,
-0.0156849418,
0.0022647926,
-0.0015655205,
0.0656394586,
-0.0137089379,
-0.0443619601,
0.0120981298,
-0.0220021773,
-0.0117260041,
-0.0306136478,
0.0596657805,
0.0013713223,
-0.0065709716,
0.0416001044,
-0.0217432305,
0.0313108824,
-0.0344301797,
0.0303397179,
-0.0163240563,
0.0265270621,
-0.0191976558,
-0.0423513353,
0.0263228118,
0.0585647225,
0.0247628354,
-0.0239606015,
0.0606833175,
0.0043361685,
-0.0267171152,
-0.0262573231,
-0.0436984003,
-0.0137304356,
0.0004833219,
0.030738458,
-0.0140027944,
0.0021816376,
0.0102220243,
-0.0371056199,
-0.0355115011,
-0.0836129934,
0.0320961177,
0.0290953498,
-0.0258011371,
-0.0240698196,
-0.0348163694,
0.0523451604,
0.0296545848,
-0.052233465,
-0.0177375749,
2.095814822e-34,
0.0309512224,
-0.0474187247,
0.0169807021,
-0.0206370577,
0.00893752,
-0.040162351,
0.0171858501,
-0.0402709357,
0.0006227604,
-0.0264214817,
-0.0218267608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07462v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07462v2 | Playing with Words: Comparing the Vocabulary and Lexical Richness of ChatGPT and Humans | 2023-08-14T21:19:44 | 2023-08-31T11:09:16 | Pedro Reviriego, Javier Conde, Elena Merino-Gómez, Gonzalo Martínez, José Alberto Hernández | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The introduction of Artificial Intelligence (AI) generative language models
such as GPT (Generative Pre-trained Transformer) and tools such as ChatGPT has
triggered a revolution that can transform how text is generated. This has many
implications, for example, as AI-generated text becomes a significant fraction
of the text, would this have an effect on the language capabilities of readers
and also on the training of newer AI tools? Would it affect the evolution of
languages? Focusing on one specific aspect of the language: words; will the use
of tools such as ChatGPT increase or reduce the vocabulary used or the lexical
richness? This has implications for words, as those not included in
AI-generated content will tend to be less and less popular and may eventually
be lost. In this work, we perform an initial comparison of the vocabulary and
lexical richness of ChatGPT and humans when performing the same tasks. In more
detail, two datasets containing the answers to different types of questions
answered by ChatGPT and humans, and a third dataset in which ChatGPT
paraphrases sentences and questions are used. The analysis shows that ChatGPT
tends to use fewer distinct words and lower lexical richness than humans. These
results are very preliminary and additional datasets and ChatGPT configurations
have to be evaluated to extract more general conclusions. Therefore, further
research is needed to understand how the use of ChatGPT and more broadly
generative AI tools will affect the vocabulary and lexical richness in
different types of text and languages. | [
0.0518392585,
0.032778468,
-0.0437573232,
0.0008678563,
-0.050112538,
0.0052738371,
0.0057263761,
0.0302949417,
0.0115108527,
-0.03882863,
-0.0137276053,
-0.0102087436,
-0.0081602344,
0.0318301097,
0.0507763214,
-0.0761567354,
0.0326390453,
-0.0047081863,
0.003646913,
0.0013720869,
0.0149634918,
0.018764738,
0.0119059803,
0.0597214065,
-0.0309502892,
0.0104331616,
0.004664341,
-0.0328814797,
0.0008596663,
0.0195609275,
-0.0020654809,
0.0624511093,
0.00034826,
0.0515703745,
0.0000018972,
-0.0455437675,
0.0209386274,
0.0091874432,
-0.0129343327,
0.0186815783,
0.0771945864,
0.0312085282,
-0.0100570265,
0.0217222329,
-0.0832519159,
-0.0235882699,
0.0489085466,
0.0203790199,
0.0299794525,
0.0606061332,
-0.0249819122,
-0.0130082332,
0.0876742154,
-0.0094946586,
0.0455231182,
-0.033875756,
0.006987486,
0.0272817705,
0.0105299018,
0.0235251151,
-0.0265244562,
0.0586189888,
0.0091320397,
-0.0161504596,
0.0001177097,
0.0539579131,
-0.0442094989,
-0.0396225229,
0.0035412745,
0.0220508259,
-0.0046194387,
-0.0424741246,
0.0088348994,
0.0040569915,
0.0190183651,
0.0584489405,
-0.0479343459,
0.049646318,
-0.0002602418,
0.0043559484,
0.019726729,
-0.0204017516,
-0.0174561273,
0.0102186352,
-0.0041852207,
0.0024951317,
0.0339683518,
-0.0332673229,
-0.0206723977,
0.020465238,
-0.0392081738,
-0.0709754527,
-0.0048617544,
0.0065655247,
0.0013919094,
0.0327900574,
-0.0443901159,
-0.0483284853,
0.0131952269,
-0.0498023443,
0.0046534012,
0.0229067095,
-0.016170742,
0.0105215115,
-0.0177872553,
0.0497159027,
-0.001560566,
0.0587947704,
-0.050047081,
-0.0091725485,
-0.0662069246,
-0.0671200454,
-0.0569916442,
0.0172073152,
-0.0275033657,
-0.0269498061,
-0.0501169264,
0.0352328867,
0.0538924858,
-0.0694802329,
0.0216114558,
0.0171342883,
-0.0534101762,
0.0118330736,
-0.0332360752,
-0.0251169819,
-0.0389741436,
0.0242584348,
0.0194547009,
-0.0998261869,
0.0243555717,
0.0125287166,
0.0194513109,
-0.03528082,
-0.0052206358,
0.0846930072,
-0.022057673,
-0.0593312308,
-0.0143480496,
0.0144970296,
-0.0214966629,
-0.0358046144,
0.0000306547,
-0.0572981797,
0.0307268426,
0.0175609533,
-0.0103716217,
-0.0258368868,
-0.0142631941,
0.0501421206,
-0.0546882674,
0.0398613662,
-0.0300258994,
0.0459121615,
0.0660875887,
-0.0204252992,
0.0090112276,
0.0237875171,
0.0542456396,
-0.0156153003,
0.0433381572,
-0.0426340029,
0.0265283734,
0.0187506508,
-0.018553054,
-0.021471411,
0.0302863643,
-0.0188636538,
-0.0039907685,
0.0115753189,
0.0101715978,
0.0903117806,
-0.044798743,
-0.0061254748,
0.0913946405,
0.0912550092,
0.0372098051,
0.072860226,
0.0553820282,
0.0315023698,
0.0388944075,
0.0466674417,
-0.0216052961,
-0.0088454196,
-0.034901835,
0.0148629323,
-0.0059610568,
0.0317675173,
-0.0045085568,
-0.0497371256,
0.010418186,
0.0058911275,
0.0685494095,
-0.035843756,
0.0411877222,
0.0330710746,
-0.0272227265,
-0.0066894414,
0.0445420556,
-0.0825611278,
-0.0335582383,
-0.0863262713,
-0.0010962595,
0.0404505953,
0.0652501285,
0.0081084985,
-0.0119497618,
0.011104052,
-0.018074248,
0.0716944635,
0.0345128849,
0.0222046822,
-0.025371857,
-0.0171337426,
0.0181241427,
-0.0080443509,
-0.012523951,
0.0067139934,
0.0466345958,
0.0252809916,
0.0085125929,
-0.0099989958,
-0.0274246316,
0.0489842333,
-0.0629116148,
-0.0118929464,
-0.0218651332,
-0.0287331939,
0.011800535,
0.0114439391,
-0.040670827,
0.0288218129,
0.0042328271,
-0.0042670113,
-0.0496955812,
0.0481332652,
-0.0480948165,
-0.0111272726,
0.0093757873,
-0.0718564019,
0.0197002031,
0.0123314559,
0.0161203723,
-0.0248534791,
0.0105931042,
-0.0780134276,
0.070334971,
-0.0646016523,
0.0246316213,
-0.0202610679,
0.0370428041,
-0.0425149538,
0.0605881363,
0.0191852823,
0.0087375557,
-0.0340302475,
0.0082495995,
0.0132862953,
-0.012223335,
-0.0006942931,
0.0186441951,
0.001593919,
0.0232036058,
0.0526234061,
0.0218280926,
-0.0290843081,
-0.0056102164,
-0.1142886207,
-0.0044705318,
0.0091890553,
0.0071543055,
0.0432836227,
0.0057603177,
-0.032757625,
0.0362243205,
-0.0390150435,
0.0284636728,
0.0226197615,
0.0175099038,
0.0390195958,
-0.0123175336,
0.0284064841,
-0.0382129252,
-0.0177496374,
-0.0073995469,
0.0156681128,
0.0692776814,
-0.0277298596,
-0.0018200637,
0.0451946035,
-0.0235908851,
0.0046944716,
-0.0066554295,
-0.0740076378,
0.0113991052,
-0.0158256795,
0.0809586942,
0.02707012,
0.0693877265,
0.0249115787,
-0.0099885864,
-0.006995989,
-0.0220491476,
-0.0035138365,
-0.0401060767,
-0.0587320216,
-0.0228951704,
-0.0393406302,
0.0400255173,
0.0777782425,
0.037611004,
-0.0116086081,
-0.0447509997,
0.0348293111,
-0.0287774876,
-0.0421365537,
-0.0002229323,
-0.0104763946,
-0.0537567213,
0.0359054394,
-0.013168456,
-0.0603394695,
0.0379089676,
-0.0123564675,
-0.0145637142,
-0.0583739132,
-0.0002365944,
-0.0061570872,
0.0403536484,
0.0413580164,
0.0278417896,
0.006693725,
-0.0064446926,
-0.079791449,
-0.0096587408,
0.046846278,
-0.0312526859,
0.0083604902,
-0.0530729853,
0.0036478664,
0.0099373925,
-0.024111541,
-0.0242069494,
-0.0425640084,
0.0098945126,
-0.0148022771,
0.1048541665,
-0.0152038373,
0.0020885633,
-0.0118689584,
0.0263939165,
0.0363266394,
-0.0157771781,
-0.0181348175,
-0.0133176493,
0.0657366738,
0.0558376238,
0.00014577,
-0.0010091778,
-0.0201782882,
-0.0052697738,
0.0391426235,
-0.0294688642,
-0.0106701823,
0.0066133924,
-0.0144888861,
0.0061498391,
-0.0477446131,
-0.038063895,
0.0018136988,
0.0363008343,
-0.0186790116,
-0.0006674442,
0.1011747569,
0.0224213582,
-0.0181582831,
0.010451586,
-0.0008262524,
0.0125425998,
-0.0101283016,
0.0444970839,
-0.0845105276,
0.002223969,
-0.0105549516,
-0.0081289699,
-0.0233905278,
-0.0092186201,
-0.0126611339,
-0.1209811494,
0.0351866968,
-0.0218131375,
-0.042478852,
0.0260131676,
0.0043102917,
-0.0282469671,
0.0178808682,
-0.0036366768,
-0.0070883869,
-0.0340033509,
0.040259894,
0.0077368473,
-0.0373665057,
-0.0140638864,
-0.0079679368,
-0.0186351277,
0.0501880087,
0.0873004645,
0.0542657785,
-0.0493973643,
-0.0032175537,
0.0591061376,
0.0171089657,
0.0143959606,
0.014919159,
0.0798998773,
0.0103391288,
0.0034739256,
-0.0514287874,
0.0245427359,
0.0120068714,
-0.0088027176,
0.0309300572,
0.0277378932,
0.0124311345,
-0.0483940728,
-0.004229547,
0.007780822,
-0.0107483603,
0.0544380955,
0.0311385989,
-0.0507358648,
-0.0470667854,
-0.0181041267,
0.0240354557,
-0.044343885,
-0.0917557999,
-0.0037169768,
0.0032296807,
-0.0488677174,
-0.1109509692,
-0.0589381605,
0.0121020991,
-0.0066152401,
0.0071051768,
0.0095223477,
0.0116524231,
0.0055531645,
-0.0069575403,
-0.0062597389,
-0.0068994118,
-0.0227351449,
-0.0596478917,
-0.0716229081,
0.0160331614,
-0.0480841994,
-0.0132216513,
0.0062052608,
-0.0584528483,
-0.0473849624,
0.0450871587,
0.0355910212,
0.0268432219,
0.0059387586,
0.0021991937,
-0.0376921631,
0.0526577011,
0.0582197532,
-0.0416140109,
0.0397224501,
-0.012047668,
0.0161045995,
0.009327108,
0.0065854648,
0.0030099568,
0.0196909923,
-0.0070111393,
0.0097933766,
0.0117218355,
-0.0385249779,
0.0263714567,
0.0211027563,
0.0314491987,
-0.0271833111,
0.0296542812,
-0.0411562845,
-0.0343313329,
-0.0470975973,
0.0197381806,
-0.038472943,
-0.0293022655,
0.0287785046,
0.0222430881,
-0.0200069156,
0.0097574638,
-0.0511034913,
0.0152769731,
-0.0473414101,
0.0223847255,
0.0115445424,
0.0102426102,
0.0054253684,
0.0133829052,
0.0142994206,
0.0086694928,
-0.0438653789,
0.0303453542,
-0.008187159,
0.0602518767,
-0.0089545297,
-0.0355118141,
0.0205248185,
0.0504627675,
-0.080762215,
-0.0536013991,
-0.0210604127,
0.0493377969,
0.0180980451,
-0.0097622918,
0.0473466478,
-0.0378623717,
-0.0136345187,
-0.0276414622,
0.022388421,
0.004617312,
-0.0125731686,
-0.0316246189,
-0.0099456385,
-0.036352817,
-0.0418890975,
0.1060771942,
0.0161056072,
0.0197213478,
0.0185317826,
-0.0100485878,
-0.030240709,
-0.0255184583,
0.0016852189,
-0.0244724583,
0.0216658302,
0.0299727246,
-0.044158794,
-0.0656542629,
-0.0463333614,
0.0071203667,
0.0329306126,
-0.0191436224,
0.0484089218,
0.0516116694,
-0.0364830047,
-0.0200274549,
-0.0568756126,
0.0534785613,
-0.046422638,
-0.0155124972,
-0.0226471834,
-5.88495047e-33,
-0.0306818299,
-0.0188229606,
0.0221850071,
0.0428638756,
-0.0265975483,
-0.0189699288,
-0.0247644372,
0.0137752527,
-0.0065050875,
0.0356674194,
-0.0446047932,
0.0025788376,
0.008734704,
0.0273463111,
0.0113109117,
-0.0154735744,
0.0185958166,
-0.041019965,
-0.0102616996,
0.0289502107,
0.0059745293,
0.0271804612,
0.06593135,
-0.062000066,
-0.0073680081,
-0.0267877933,
0.0130709773,
-0.0386433378,
0.0242508259,
0.0226212163,
-0.0269878265,
0.0454846546,
0.0332009383,
-0.0328819379,
-0.0316360481,
0.046957653,
-0.0589568578,
-0.0318383165,
0.0357168168,
-0.0128228879,
-0.0273888297,
-0.0347416066,
0.0239792019,
-0.0454671793,
-0.0262394957,
0.0050629014,
0.0514177606,
-0.0031101576,
0.0006674688,
-0.0290978272,
-0.0758150667,
0.0279541966,
-0.0047562998,
-0.0212774184,
-0.0422706194,
0.0305392779,
-0.017580362,
-0.0058104414,
-0.0026052666,
0.0543056875,
0.0421912894,
0.0209323149,
0.0345649421,
0.0001517878,
0.0269543473,
0.0251413304,
0.0256430078,
-0.0026971884,
-0.0278991703,
-0.0040595978,
0.0302468427,
0.0288169961,
0.0258276854,
0.0654374138,
0.025829982,
-0.0452587605,
-0.0011436666,
0.0220776945,
0.0044596926,
0.0053817336,
0.0177648235,
-0.005781366,
-0.0429745428,
-0.0405726358,
0.0032745863,
0.015065033,
-0.0050317356,
-0.0628493577,
0.034480121,
-0.0321540684,
0.0032101739,
-0.0249720439,
0.0111212432,
-0.0539971963,
0.0087973308,
-0.0083711063,
-0.0534738451,
0.025828097,
-0.0169682465,
0.0159341842,
-0.0286450926,
-0.033566501,
0.0241426583,
0.0671124607,
0.0116157951,
0.0135589279,
0.0077254907,
0.0155070908,
-0.0540806279,
0.0038683005,
-0.0221017413,
-0.0018228003,
0.0185644906,
-0.0327711441,
0.0215308517,
0.0126922252,
-0.0174815971,
-0.0053640874,
0.0426515751,
0.0019745401,
-0.0736623704,
-0.0284175016,
-0.0104722083,
-0.0198212788,
-0.0407446027,
0.0248333458,
-0.0437930375,
0.0163489189,
0.0371603221,
-0.0377194509,
-0.0074557788,
-0.0133500723,
2.647e-7,
0.0763586685,
0.0820224881,
0.0476355478,
-0.0015140719,
0.0202838406,
0.0062513053,
0.0290232338,
0.0203146916,
0.0116727967,
0.0438770354,
0.0230443664,
0.0315223821,
0.0277734473,
0.0144835124,
-0.0651578903,
-0.013694128,
-0.0868783891,
0.0039701131,
-0.0497495085,
0.0054946514,
0.0985627621,
0.0646483675,
-0.0006767113,
-0.0199841373,
-0.0250152368,
-0.0612952746,
0.0614780113,
-0.0342024304,
-0.0206881948,
0.0215902384,
0.0131078996,
0.0445106141,
0.0179468635,
0.0170214418,
-0.0316973478,
0.0003894706,
0.0335220769,
0.0276405327,
-0.0023807224,
0.0107177328,
0.0248505957,
-0.0262691304,
-0.0134801511,
-0.0746423081,
0.0884806812,
-0.0691355839,
-0.0349053927,
-0.0239746217,
-0.0269348063,
-0.0034236207,
-0.0009540463,
-0.0427859984,
-0.0300627612,
0.0371134952,
0.028160451,
0.0214864183,
0.0028603906,
-0.0580383427,
-0.0147029776,
0.0007446489,
-0.0467176586,
-0.0494880453,
-0.0476284437,
0.0098139299,
0.0309500992,
-0.0117208399,
0.0212540627,
2.029131002e-34,
0.0196643658,
0.024417676,
0.0414187685,
-0.0069905203,
0.0485439375,
0.0159678701,
0.0834285244,
0.0397274606,
-0.0084683299,
-0.0698685423,
-0.0253102276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07407v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07407v1 | Development and Evaluation of Three Chatbots for Postpartum Mood and Anxiety Disorders | 2023-08-14T18:52:03 | 2023-08-14T18:52:03 | Xuewen Yao, Miriam Mikhelson, S. Craig Watkins, Eunsol Choi, Edison Thomaz, Kaya de Barbaro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | In collaboration with Postpartum Support International (PSI), a non-profit
organization dedicated to supporting caregivers with postpartum mood and
anxiety disorders, we developed three chatbots to provide context-specific
empathetic support to postpartum caregivers, leveraging both rule-based and
generative models. We present and evaluate the performance of our chatbots
using both machine-based metrics and human-based questionnaires. Overall, our
rule-based model achieves the best performance, with outputs that are close to
ground truth reference and contain the highest levels of empathy. Human users
prefer the rule-based chatbot over the generative chatbot for its
context-specific and human-like replies. Our generative chatbot also produced
empathetic responses and was described by human users as engaging. However,
limitations in the training dataset often result in confusing or nonsensical
responses. We conclude by discussing practical benefits of rule-based vs.
generative models for supporting individuals with mental health challenges. In
light of the recent surge of ChatGPT and BARD, we also discuss the
possibilities and pitfalls of large language models for digital mental
healthcare. | [
0.0850389227,
0.0288223289,
-0.0593804717,
-0.0612296127,
-0.0390152857,
0.0408180691,
0.0379669182,
0.0031481325,
0.0513304994,
-0.026612483,
0.0322975293,
-0.0310800076,
-0.0384666696,
0.0423184857,
-0.023071155,
-0.1004804894,
-0.0191590991,
0.063312836,
0.0565106422,
0.0065741464,
0.0312920846,
0.0483271666,
-0.0535441898,
0.0695564747,
-0.0861691758,
-0.0134640038,
0.0081277676,
0.0409813821,
0.016789509,
-0.0361015685,
0.0510867946,
0.0348635539,
-0.0036039227,
0.0095575815,
0.0000021182,
-0.0081516597,
-0.0260171909,
0.0085804444,
-0.0044570463,
-0.1017229483,
0.0962930769,
-0.048633121,
-0.0102589028,
0.0519174561,
-0.0213749297,
-0.0245340094,
0.0511972718,
0.0685775802,
0.0487801321,
0.0758773535,
-0.0415537171,
0.0121821342,
0.0134862754,
0.0082909614,
0.0184943583,
-0.0121464683,
0.0083733248,
0.0415244438,
0.0714042038,
-0.0611229874,
-0.0102575039,
0.0140978806,
-0.0179200061,
0.0052942759,
0.0081640314,
0.0037907069,
0.0159538612,
-0.0708876923,
-0.0178388208,
0.0896310806,
0.0255390443,
0.0265040509,
0.0141972098,
-0.0080503356,
0.0216550585,
0.0317348354,
-0.0441221148,
0.021024663,
-0.0243495125,
0.0026445263,
-0.0087934164,
0.0012931371,
0.0037277064,
-0.017173782,
0.042933397,
0.010253489,
0.0047431746,
-0.03027438,
-0.0241536591,
0.0001494173,
-0.0326536223,
-0.050259307,
0.0326972678,
0.0200153366,
-0.0258094706,
0.0193506218,
-0.030683063,
-0.029858686,
0.0116776498,
-0.0076893484,
-0.0201375,
0.0699041486,
-0.0274034142,
-0.0086194081,
0.053678412,
0.0062721851,
0.0484503619,
0.0110028572,
-0.0568636097,
0.0027596552,
-0.0789670199,
-0.0050518638,
-0.0311983991,
0.0236596279,
-0.0257119425,
-0.0510214604,
-0.0840104893,
0.0408183038,
-0.015762262,
-0.0320053212,
0.007511579,
-0.0110115847,
0.0063748476,
0.0220445599,
-0.0015262018,
-0.0128684342,
-0.0523893982,
0.0186928958,
0.0232050307,
-0.0859393477,
0.0299772471,
-0.0031164023,
-0.0281010922,
-0.0078741759,
0.0166442525,
0.0498468652,
0.0398626924,
-0.0334996507,
0.0328267366,
-0.0032552115,
-0.0320810117,
-0.0491473563,
0.0198453851,
-0.0075223125,
0.0599540286,
0.0188602302,
0.0134304212,
-0.0524440669,
0.0338502862,
0.0014453528,
-0.0339711346,
0.0248427354,
-0.0356583148,
0.0216931123,
0.0182634182,
0.0218525268,
-0.0259012729,
0.0525405966,
0.0149551984,
0.0033094627,
0.0333205722,
-0.0368976034,
0.0307678618,
0.0002066166,
-0.0275575854,
-0.0499210358,
0.0181666166,
-0.0320204869,
-0.0056469091,
0.0475198589,
-0.0087568145,
0.031398233,
-0.0270680245,
0.0136779677,
0.0399831012,
0.0622544214,
0.025275683,
0.0580731668,
0.0270852037,
0.0163678825,
0.0093552517,
-0.0006763386,
-0.0064855851,
0.0048412392,
-0.0266858432,
-0.0595902279,
0.0020089515,
-0.0093689226,
-0.0336845554,
-0.0694870055,
-0.0460646898,
-0.047482539,
0.0449932329,
0.0014731444,
0.0158278402,
0.0009901373,
0.0092670256,
-0.0042324211,
0.0437469818,
-0.0447529182,
-0.0693165287,
-0.0792666525,
0.0312481504,
0.111780867,
0.0465665013,
-0.049211625,
-0.0449746773,
-0.0066188723,
0.0109389843,
0.0335948765,
0.0197358672,
0.0274307709,
-0.0003291101,
-0.0137340296,
0.0003760759,
0.0342470706,
0.0135828741,
-0.0211699121,
-0.0107748937,
0.0006678246,
-0.0450548939,
0.0215424448,
-0.009788326,
0.0584961995,
0.0012470684,
0.0119100753,
-0.0032469097,
-0.0179754663,
0.0539257713,
0.038493067,
0.0128375031,
0.0142109059,
0.0274127182,
-0.0293007381,
-0.0501975752,
0.0700904131,
-0.0171277355,
-0.0318162218,
0.0148599129,
-0.0117020402,
0.0010467754,
0.0182706267,
-0.0114429174,
-0.0085065225,
0.0315019041,
-0.0717370436,
0.0621700212,
-0.0402041674,
0.0059752702,
0.0093964068,
0.0434745774,
-0.0008107274,
0.0030418269,
-0.021950243,
-0.0037750385,
-0.0193117261,
-0.0215136874,
-0.0634093285,
-0.0176883489,
0.0151134403,
-0.0275785215,
-0.021904273,
-0.0071701943,
-0.0107015204,
0.020153854,
-0.0567474328,
-0.0491646677,
-0.1061667278,
0.0015021319,
0.0066740704,
-0.0356616676,
0.0074635586,
-0.0055317786,
-0.0210425835,
-0.0247083418,
-0.0419620797,
0.0722570345,
0.033381775,
0.0204514079,
0.0153472451,
-0.0131700588,
-0.0129232658,
-0.0603083521,
0.007273166,
-0.0163388792,
0.0080345972,
0.0191962067,
0.0017708781,
-0.0318169557,
-0.0037608945,
-0.065793246,
0.0044817105,
-0.0102530438,
-0.0615870804,
0.0208221991,
-0.0374055058,
0.0284712557,
0.0218866896,
0.0199516341,
0.06095846,
-0.0191514716,
0.0276551917,
-0.0548620336,
0.0136923743,
-0.0095792431,
0.0009394503,
0.005482621,
-0.0458860733,
-0.0113684181,
0.0557717718,
0.0118382815,
0.0064551844,
-0.0806441531,
0.0270556808,
0.0238682535,
-0.0254391897,
0.0061336937,
0.0055424049,
0.0052981819,
0.0196851715,
0.0166463666,
-0.0450855866,
0.0497317426,
0.0238937344,
-0.0187002085,
-0.056588687,
-0.0459805913,
-0.0047883377,
0.0145589057,
0.0066004754,
0.0337822586,
0.0435040779,
0.004331111,
-0.0055460981,
-0.0279410407,
-0.004589899,
-0.0585418679,
-0.0564375781,
-0.0437932052,
-0.0106660435,
0.050672289,
-0.0249102395,
-0.0540113933,
-0.0174026508,
-0.0304074921,
-0.0068397596,
0.0358911939,
0.0013266997,
-0.0548234433,
0.0021152843,
0.010623428,
0.0084911548,
0.0238967575,
-0.0343411453,
0.0168075506,
-0.023909213,
0.0289490353,
0.0073985844,
0.0047561526,
-0.0081595099,
0.0380169377,
0.0461128503,
-0.0214859545,
0.0363339148,
0.0224966481,
0.0144269047,
-0.0043546064,
0.0197814573,
0.0015277351,
0.0085544987,
0.0356807373,
-0.0086907139,
0.0047213086,
0.0941839442,
0.0177431256,
-0.0253286958,
0.0309517905,
-0.0584949367,
-0.0354811847,
-0.0191274509,
-0.0010251513,
-0.0517926179,
-0.0053501874,
0.0066080568,
0.0275955033,
-0.0554134399,
-0.0193959326,
0.0224187654,
-0.0295362398,
0.0160485096,
-0.0166520365,
-0.0269832071,
-0.0160950013,
-0.0105197961,
0.0154562108,
-0.0015214748,
-0.0075305891,
-0.0253548771,
0.0220987685,
-0.008480167,
0.0044281334,
-0.0578361079,
-0.0436799079,
0.0569653511,
-0.014852941,
0.0982856899,
0.0524837188,
0.0888823569,
0.03403401,
-0.0019717833,
-0.0158996079,
0.07310123,
0.0062403656,
-0.0061798077,
0.0497903936,
0.002388617,
0.0205237828,
-0.0510724001,
0.0562833734,
-0.0146608362,
0.0095507381,
0.0249875188,
0.0336441621,
-0.0291717928,
-0.0196163096,
-0.0588016547,
0.0724278167,
0.0483543836,
0.044160679,
0.0319290385,
-0.0697699934,
-0.0273643509,
0.0059463494,
0.0611308627,
0.023746632,
-0.0355113558,
-0.0058344272,
-0.0284757875,
-0.0342912674,
-0.1005320475,
-0.0542070866,
0.0191635285,
-0.002009338,
-0.0184826087,
-0.0508352891,
0.0219899155,
0.0445698909,
-0.0195769146,
0.0052114124,
0.0160492603,
-0.0066450168,
-0.014674359,
-0.0354584828,
0.0123855341,
-0.0410445184,
0.0072057508,
0.0111545129,
0.0086012539,
0.0120192086,
0.0471264869,
0.0466668494,
0.0130424183,
-0.0379935801,
0.0009691467,
-0.0061297799,
-0.0161462687,
0.0501237288,
-0.0354810655,
-0.0300779287,
0.0387302116,
0.0813692287,
-0.0048943958,
0.0146607934,
-0.0330879465,
0.0538148209,
0.0088195503,
0.033646483,
0.0082679307,
-0.0206964631,
0.034004759,
0.0219131578,
-0.003765349,
-0.0052930121,
-0.0608753525,
0.0190641563,
-0.0276354663,
-0.0721267089,
0.0176854432,
-0.0616426058,
-0.0182204116,
-0.0021324793,
-0.0023884436,
-0.0205332208,
-0.0505560003,
-0.0940034017,
-0.0050003757,
-0.0484257154,
-0.0110974517,
-0.0019978853,
0.0120109869,
-0.0341469832,
-0.019927457,
0.0084914202,
0.005968045,
-0.0163476896,
0.0043305401,
-0.0210819338,
0.0937618166,
-0.0199257266,
-0.0108625283,
0.0031823386,
0.0604698732,
-0.0214810483,
-0.0591731556,
-0.0178755373,
0.0359820276,
0.0514059924,
0.0485797785,
0.0443924218,
-0.0543716587,
-0.0108029572,
0.0003550548,
0.0062217568,
-0.0207786467,
-0.0032461951,
-0.0223710705,
-0.0065492662,
-0.0116547681,
-0.0405091867,
0.0284964275,
-0.0459266417,
0.0629381165,
-0.0035773958,
-0.0244733412,
-0.035600055,
0.0002663137,
-0.0032964156,
0.0132339112,
0.0035441814,
0.0249822903,
-0.0570103005,
-0.0363017656,
-0.0102576073,
-0.0198677797,
-0.0141474353,
-0.02117154,
0.0492096283,
0.037625879,
-0.0224501956,
-0.0275857989,
-0.0534216054,
0.0341107622,
-0.0515293814,
-0.0093846871,
-0.0065561808,
-5.774110903e-33,
0.0067236191,
-0.0107196458,
-0.0008279301,
0.01136107,
-0.0177153479,
-0.015870871,
-0.0057391776,
0.0300192535,
0.0170343276,
0.0354776718,
-0.00036105,
0.0576395169,
-0.0037585702,
0.0319057219,
0.0029180516,
0.0093773482,
0.0338174291,
-0.0502396375,
0.0113608083,
0.0378728472,
-0.0069248653,
0.0697785839,
-0.0059780893,
-0.0845072791,
0.0175400395,
-0.0032281219,
-0.0268714819,
-0.000588009,
0.0536464415,
0.0339979902,
-0.0297066662,
0.0425147228,
0.0398685671,
0.0280794278,
-0.0092932433,
0.0312595367,
-0.0573896877,
-0.0254575964,
-0.0147530176,
-0.0252758041,
-0.0694332495,
-0.0301894005,
0.0422109291,
-0.0302448943,
-0.0100551965,
-0.0259591006,
0.0352693275,
-0.0583026409,
0.0359247774,
-0.0151139721,
-0.0231715217,
-0.0176688228,
-0.0285259672,
-0.0560817756,
-0.0314482152,
0.0680194795,
-0.048434075,
0.0136312461,
-0.029341381,
0.0283246599,
-0.0298770014,
-0.0334943868,
-0.0067267437,
-0.0597343184,
0.0344845951,
0.0442551561,
0.0505930893,
0.0233399365,
-0.0335327275,
0.0326415785,
-0.0085635688,
0.0568205416,
0.0610461421,
0.0374026224,
0.0091303233,
-0.0170874856,
-0.0586353242,
0.0242502913,
0.0175632332,
0.0277467053,
0.0467130393,
0.0100677358,
-0.0558644459,
0.0399688147,
-0.0105921663,
-0.0216880143,
-0.0083226906,
-0.0735459924,
0.0074902093,
-0.0026264193,
-0.0181184243,
-0.0981526822,
-0.0293633882,
-0.0545329824,
0.026564816,
-0.0136095276,
0.0000936249,
-0.0027974946,
0.0087547908,
-0.0119488603,
0.0065254178,
-0.0213242583,
0.055536747,
0.0375530496,
0.067565538,
-0.0135761732,
0.0030151044,
-0.0067842999,
-0.0171978604,
-0.0293427631,
0.0000698818,
0.0749890059,
0.0162587315,
-0.0011770589,
-0.0527841337,
0.035484951,
-0.0289575532,
0.0042757043,
0.0391673297,
0.0437133014,
-0.0505990088,
-0.0073727584,
-0.0020944267,
-0.0150929913,
-0.0651796758,
-0.0191453435,
-0.0462724157,
0.0281650387,
0.0587267466,
-0.0397357382,
-0.0235259105,
-0.0160710849,
2.786e-7,
0.0343062505,
0.0621000826,
-0.001779597,
0.0023981316,
0.0592933483,
0.005746291,
0.0234398004,
0.0397865884,
0.0286500212,
0.0064876801,
0.0362515934,
0.0374368466,
0.0567663424,
0.0283412468,
-0.0106695537,
-0.0163495727,
-0.0257485826,
-0.0371146947,
-0.0029776257,
0.0349217132,
0.0853259563,
0.0586408116,
0.002954416,
-0.0234224275,
0.0172266159,
0.0312865153,
0.0334220417,
-0.0627977923,
0.0087363739,
0.0222745035,
0.0188610516,
0.0060891709,
0.0406884365,
-0.0162206925,
0.0119070373,
-0.0250053182,
0.0152561497,
0.0671544448,
-0.01977586,
-0.0526635684,
0.0361784883,
0.0490673594,
0.0038372348,
-0.0243703295,
0.03979031,
-0.1039741114,
-0.0489584804,
-0.0209327955,
-0.007590882,
-0.0677098557,
0.0685547814,
-0.0434920006,
-0.0370068215,
0.0521994382,
0.0132188639,
0.0091969222,
0.0237322431,
-0.0204817317,
0.0069819787,
0.0397627167,
-0.0808737427,
-0.0624973215,
0.0069649136,
-0.0347622186,
-0.0270981342,
-0.011576225,
0.0316326246,
1.856076881e-34,
0.0204043947,
0.03928921,
-0.0125569915,
0.0308818277,
0.0276047681,
0.0307378806,
0.0007736051,
0.0197228268,
0.0157445893,
-0.0760230646,
-0.0026761645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07395v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07395v1 | Text Injection for Capitalization and Turn-Taking Prediction in Speech Models | 2023-08-14T18:28:04 | 2023-08-14T18:28:04 | Shaan Bijwadia, Shuo-yiin Chang, Weiran Wang, Zhong Meng, Hao Zhang, Tara N. Sainath | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Text injection for automatic speech recognition (ASR), wherein unpaired
text-only data is used to supplement paired audio-text data, has shown
promising improvements for word error rate. This study examines the use of text
injection for auxiliary tasks, which are the non-ASR tasks often performed by
an E2E model. In this work, we use joint end-to-end and internal language model
training (JEIT) as our text injection algorithm to train an ASR model which
performs two auxiliary tasks. The first is capitalization, which is a
de-normalization task. The second is turn-taking prediction, which attempts to
identify whether a user has completed their conversation turn in a digital
assistant interaction. We show results demonstrating that our text injection
method boosts capitalization performance for long-tail data, and improves
turn-taking detection recall. | [
0.02487625,
0.0132236714,
-0.0002799077,
0.032981988,
-0.0016713857,
0.0011240846,
-0.0168694519,
-0.0116463415,
0.0246701743,
-0.0551357046,
-0.0202000458,
-0.0210947264,
0.021573659,
0.0152711468,
0.0399951078,
-0.0314436741,
0.0447042361,
-0.0422930419,
-0.0083799846,
-0.0153255239,
0.0247107986,
0.0025137332,
-0.0008012566,
0.0509513915,
0.0013666973,
0.0412569158,
-0.0170041006,
0.0309223663,
-0.0004045253,
-0.0046666488,
0.0191891957,
0.0554115623,
0.019979462,
0.0474655442,
0.000001969,
-0.0608900413,
-0.0101682041,
-0.0051521887,
-0.0503011681,
-0.023959972,
0.0310729668,
0.0009483827,
0.009967003,
0.0921003968,
-0.0046438407,
0.0206607524,
0.0305079091,
0.0779351965,
0.0281026065,
0.0341360904,
-0.0137262326,
-0.0321199521,
0.0684202462,
-0.0107351178,
-0.0329195224,
-0.0035960902,
0.0109837754,
0.004146521,
-0.0323564634,
-0.0195574388,
-0.0089843227,
0.0293187853,
-0.0124737257,
-0.0140006663,
0.0301877223,
0.0613099746,
-0.0471515544,
-0.0158961881,
-0.0605685674,
0.0571224801,
0.0069751251,
-0.0278007332,
0.0208830908,
0.0159725025,
-0.0087795965,
-0.0086460123,
0.021601608,
-0.0208934154,
0.0069223042,
-0.0039021289,
0.0278626177,
0.0035500571,
0.0137892943,
-0.0340436921,
-0.0411435254,
0.0165864602,
0.0361027345,
-0.0738964826,
0.0159993395,
-0.0007266168,
0.0416007005,
-0.0574766994,
0.0536215454,
0.0181917865,
-0.0107793733,
0.025524918,
-0.0438364893,
-0.0393948108,
-0.0236685183,
-0.0573649071,
0.0018156931,
0.0420953669,
0.0063894014,
-0.005135153,
-0.0173357073,
0.0283463839,
0.0401310883,
0.0348039083,
-0.025600018,
-0.0015966024,
-0.0391568094,
-0.0274617635,
-0.0597799197,
0.0204332005,
-0.0171179287,
-0.045023378,
-0.0358639173,
0.0034857828,
0.0248973314,
-0.0149195874,
0.0536017269,
-0.0043359897,
-0.0411024243,
-0.0221992526,
0.0211162157,
0.0278325137,
0.0095832488,
0.0399160124,
0.0121900067,
-0.0496799126,
0.0114016365,
-0.0353338271,
0.0497788489,
0.0066924952,
0.0197963137,
0.0939833969,
-0.0187724978,
-0.0505620316,
-0.0402965844,
-0.0059728078,
-0.0405351073,
-0.0253620297,
-0.0268550031,
-0.0408697762,
0.0085495589,
0.0146662248,
0.009234691,
-0.0078439228,
0.0216349848,
0.01227694,
-0.0311315004,
0.0669335574,
0.0065722973,
0.0261391047,
0.0887617394,
-0.0121066952,
0.0381023362,
0.0479576811,
0.0607473068,
-0.0064895288,
0.0251921378,
-0.0278728902,
0.0416912138,
0.1020577699,
0.0076043056,
0.006262756,
-0.024629062,
-0.017213678,
0.0229824372,
0.0097236708,
0.0286818836,
0.0388445966,
-0.0070880144,
0.0169344638,
0.0646079332,
0.0432698503,
0.0401114039,
-0.036496345,
0.0092434539,
-0.01045937,
-0.0243713651,
-0.0034871777,
-0.0284111015,
-0.0290552992,
-0.0715310201,
0.0069124475,
0.037667349,
0.0241482053,
-0.0250925962,
-0.0098232497,
-0.0046416018,
-0.0239843391,
0.0083623314,
0.0139479218,
0.0410462841,
0.0242735948,
-0.0825287476,
0.0067138774,
0.0160186738,
-0.0549304001,
0.0200117249,
-0.0193975698,
-0.0352959931,
0.0712915882,
0.0145063642,
0.0290182885,
-0.0320792757,
-0.0303748511,
-0.052446723,
0.0261222292,
0.0075088562,
-0.0023092846,
0.0333335437,
-0.0631318092,
-0.0057216352,
0.0701928958,
-0.0104580894,
0.0464776941,
-0.0302889496,
0.0267263819,
0.0374731421,
-0.0037316047,
-0.0291203652,
0.021938337,
-0.0477785133,
-0.0477791466,
0.0173683967,
0.0258311573,
0.0183858946,
0.0137785394,
-0.0214706454,
-0.0042896746,
0.0305848643,
0.0010494527,
-0.0475789867,
0.0493796319,
-0.0478687882,
-0.0476887673,
0.0421899557,
-0.0109028062,
-0.005155602,
0.0334220827,
0.0438265875,
-0.0924227238,
0.0118333427,
-0.0313587375,
0.0682651922,
-0.0389464572,
0.0501355417,
0.0146372514,
0.0159548763,
-0.0098554017,
-0.0002295106,
-0.0062090573,
0.0014131457,
-0.0115815802,
-0.0487516671,
-0.013221344,
-0.0545647107,
-0.054774303,
0.0150258187,
0.0133813769,
0.0037035902,
0.0222216509,
-0.0049342131,
-0.0514722094,
-0.0350380614,
-0.1157718375,
-0.0085992636,
-0.0194541048,
0.0031171078,
0.024758514,
0.046004124,
-0.0195929501,
-0.0378382541,
-0.0240952913,
-0.064836517,
0.0140297106,
0.0018318893,
-0.0066134301,
-0.0101834526,
-0.0504350476,
-0.0202734508,
0.0112482831,
-0.036252182,
0.0100642554,
-0.0032767998,
-0.020546468,
-0.0432463661,
0.0206293873,
0.0420464315,
0.0452188104,
-0.0315185376,
-0.0313894227,
-0.0181779899,
0.024146717,
0.0833822787,
0.053795144,
0.020982692,
-0.0339359306,
0.0045384699,
-0.0296659768,
-0.0340791792,
-0.0154159544,
0.0090834461,
0.0022416487,
-0.0104479389,
-0.0369250216,
-0.00190187,
0.0637552366,
0.0191822518,
0.0404010676,
-0.0605212636,
-0.0213910118,
-0.028150646,
-0.0666584522,
-0.0116739953,
-0.0244984757,
-0.0740033612,
0.0099058757,
-0.0239472333,
-0.0380460285,
0.053714484,
-0.09179461,
-0.0481888913,
-0.021431759,
-0.0298783388,
-0.0182423908,
-0.0217255559,
0.0024275046,
-0.0137236863,
-0.0100226104,
-0.0831039697,
-0.0177689064,
0.0221857168,
0.0080087632,
-0.0333602689,
0.0567184389,
0.0050643617,
-0.0271830261,
0.0245639812,
-0.0294009205,
-0.0280689858,
-0.0248866063,
-0.0443772562,
0.0126914391,
0.0078751734,
-0.0335314646,
-0.0109122265,
0.0173388608,
0.0170399677,
0.0719461814,
-0.0292657837,
-0.0014114161,
-0.0170433261,
0.0301957019,
0.0482701585,
0.0228606928,
-0.0629592389,
-0.0305744,
0.0692614466,
-0.0319621451,
0.0674273744,
-0.0197686423,
-0.0305766929,
-0.0135662155,
0.0353256129,
-0.0124661038,
-0.0350955613,
0.0251464956,
0.02114092,
-0.0139522534,
0.0002677375,
0.1273459196,
0.0136347981,
-0.0481787026,
-0.0374658592,
-0.0053891842,
0.0031738656,
0.0483555235,
0.0155559285,
0.0032941767,
-0.0335473232,
0.044451572,
0.0384296626,
0.0225857552,
0.0024317384,
0.0037147589,
-0.146918565,
0.0202819481,
-0.0075353766,
-0.079534702,
-0.0147401225,
-0.0298386607,
0.0190105624,
-0.0047591287,
0.0460699312,
-0.0031671617,
-0.035135828,
-0.0311027784,
0.0429291539,
-0.0681032166,
-0.0286418013,
-0.0120390579,
-0.0320991725,
0.0773590431,
0.0375058278,
0.0033606361,
-0.0271658748,
0.0342912637,
-0.0009978422,
-0.0101882638,
0.0217334032,
-0.0163343381,
0.0844573602,
-0.0326923095,
0.010444859,
0.0123721678,
0.0463539213,
0.0126266507,
0.0138142975,
0.052909255,
0.0418350957,
-0.0066995025,
0.012115214,
0.0239967015,
0.016926486,
0.0470811278,
0.0427412838,
0.0027569828,
-0.0421703197,
0.0063799405,
0.0041006026,
0.0211823191,
-0.0401550196,
-0.0490897149,
-0.0226347595,
-0.0031584797,
-0.0236843619,
-0.0582059696,
-0.0538653508,
0.0484992415,
0.0172003675,
0.0588758737,
0.0239349119,
0.0027267444,
0.01138716,
-0.0337652229,
-0.0245321002,
-0.0245059673,
0.0397749767,
-0.0608166419,
0.0274916273,
0.003809267,
-0.0428916737,
-0.0244461875,
0.0254539754,
-0.0095772203,
-0.0824328512,
0.0310259108,
-0.0072480347,
0.0178353917,
0.0934377909,
-0.0292267967,
-0.0417419747,
0.0584211275,
-0.0213527773,
-0.0571006797,
0.0282341726,
0.0638833046,
0.0218342319,
-0.0118987868,
0.0112539493,
-0.0230402742,
0.0086386008,
-0.0358539298,
-0.0027266466,
-0.0477631502,
-0.0420958623,
-0.007007557,
0.0330197774,
0.0863417387,
-0.0114435079,
0.0086452272,
-0.052227594,
0.0551703088,
-0.0334042944,
0.0107241049,
-0.0204195082,
0.0021728245,
0.0029075076,
0.0489124544,
-0.0164885297,
-0.0248067826,
-0.0792251974,
-0.0253272336,
-0.0232913196,
0.0324256867,
0.0429992937,
0.0669568181,
0.0244267676,
0.0225615352,
0.0118730105,
-0.0083802836,
0.0724557638,
0.0297375601,
-0.021520827,
0.0094005056,
0.0053553088,
0.0020249868,
-0.0357451327,
0.0113290744,
-0.0486379117,
0.0282879006,
-0.0196585488,
0.0394522101,
0.012933895,
-0.0396691449,
0.0630558953,
-0.0068403492,
0.0305965226,
-0.0153738614,
0.0092679719,
-0.0287243966,
-0.0185315832,
0.0324298963,
-0.0177320056,
-0.0140972007,
0.036709059,
0.0743007138,
0.0095671704,
0.0248413496,
-0.0328617282,
0.0353017524,
-0.0476097874,
0.0202478115,
0.0543360598,
-0.0107274493,
-0.0397710055,
-0.0069907331,
-0.0226500928,
-0.0787445381,
0.0109620588,
-0.0038266222,
0.0049368828,
-0.0063121691,
0.0108492384,
0.0144678885,
-0.0129442969,
0.0153994234,
-0.0278701354,
-0.0221200977,
-0.0268554222,
-0.027235629,
-0.0108668767,
-6.693267038e-33,
-0.0253506806,
-0.0233121663,
0.003606559,
0.0602432378,
-0.0313247591,
0.0246246792,
-0.0034051952,
0.0367733575,
0.031463787,
-0.0144203138,
-0.0641630962,
0.0333186984,
0.0327208899,
-0.0108623859,
0.0333568938,
0.0288555976,
0.0616137907,
-0.0233418867,
-0.00900367,
-0.0191953797,
0.008535143,
0.0758962333,
0.0658048764,
-0.073798582,
0.0060765604,
0.0120048327,
-0.0000876337,
-0.015908936,
0.0040777652,
0.0333621539,
-0.0130397417,
0.0301153678,
-0.0010941902,
-0.0447371006,
-0.0000281461,
0.0856356621,
-0.0733985752,
-0.0127289407,
0.0139982896,
0.019292308,
0.0054259044,
-0.013863923,
0.0365606844,
-0.0466036126,
-0.0077667064,
0.0169994161,
0.045543313,
-0.0074532554,
-0.0096309138,
-0.0050943606,
-0.0315031409,
0.0055448958,
-0.0122499466,
-0.0297989585,
0.0379629359,
0.0225693639,
0.0218202583,
-0.0117051667,
-0.0317077339,
0.0302814022,
-0.0241140947,
0.0270001926,
0.0319082662,
0.0656657368,
-0.0161291715,
0.0259329434,
0.0298174117,
0.0031702686,
0.0085462769,
-0.0465242006,
0.0570956171,
0.0059821852,
0.0007902894,
0.0070082885,
0.032085225,
-0.0352500714,
-0.020829903,
0.0197607651,
0.0029990179,
0.0141766472,
-0.0021173321,
-0.0072656358,
-0.0846032053,
-0.0170033742,
-0.0617637187,
-0.0219987389,
-0.0325291678,
0.0045498805,
0.0376653895,
0.0441522747,
0.009045139,
-0.032626342,
0.0175061524,
-0.0414954945,
0.0091952011,
-0.0008203856,
-0.0165385809,
0.0089522181,
-0.0202935506,
0.0234489907,
-0.0625011921,
-0.018517293,
0.0433623791,
0.0614804924,
0.0059733051,
-0.0357262157,
-0.0045383591,
0.0335006677,
-0.088351354,
-0.0070970529,
-0.0191269182,
0.0265297722,
-0.0114415186,
0.0027874771,
0.0369438566,
-0.0046840878,
-0.0268364325,
0.0259868111,
0.0004335476,
0.0517865978,
-0.0428503454,
-0.0701727346,
0.0457087308,
0.0360058211,
-0.0334132724,
0.0131120877,
0.0211821403,
-0.0240812767,
0.0648327917,
-0.008557708,
-0.0129511431,
0.0124795251,
2.805e-7,
0.0096215401,
0.0814211592,
0.0265958384,
0.0143079413,
-0.0158035066,
0.0247544833,
-0.0403910987,
0.0289932042,
0.0803236291,
0.0463337377,
0.0368761048,
-0.0391454995,
0.0736301616,
-0.0014614749,
-0.1212944165,
-0.1038607955,
-0.0672743022,
0.0296155121,
-0.0135827055,
0.0041523618,
0.003087681,
0.0710285902,
-0.0031134535,
-0.0241546053,
-0.0491586328,
-0.0305742119,
0.0383103155,
-0.0396085493,
-0.0013590005,
-0.025465969,
0.042596437,
0.0298570003,
-0.0124387993,
0.0482160486,
-0.0515025407,
0.0673495978,
0.0135304565,
0.0015169283,
-0.0369740538,
-0.0337165333,
0.0121423602,
0.04251289,
-0.0626639351,
-0.0125561319,
0.0458587669,
-0.0409821011,
-0.0122860726,
-0.0247534346,
-0.0529278405,
0.0001552614,
0.0199497305,
0.0023046641,
-0.0201731808,
0.0182580594,
0.0168373846,
0.0115862954,
0.0004643083,
-0.0719927177,
0.0114854174,
0.032367453,
-0.0310441907,
-0.0112077966,
-0.0078444928,
-0.0449760221,
-0.0033461149,
-0.0311014093,
0.0107014002,
2.446602081e-34,
0.0323048681,
-0.0444455631,
0.0410862602,
0.0274327099,
0.0222892202,
-0.0312731154,
0.0551705696,
0.016707968,
0.0253927615,
-0.0926508084,
-0.0437122844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07393v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07393v1 | Using Text Injection to Improve Recognition of Personal Identifiers in Speech | 2023-08-14T18:26:27 | 2023-08-14T18:26:27 | Yochai Blau, Rohan Agrawal, Lior Madmony, Gary Wang, Andrew Rosenberg, Zhehuai Chen, Zorik Gekhman, Genady Beryozkin, Parisa Haghani, Bhuvana Ramabhadran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS, 68T10, I.2.7 | Accurate recognition of specific categories, such as persons' names, dates or
other identifiers is critical in many Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR)
applications. As these categories represent personal information, ethical use
of this data including collection, transcription, training and evaluation
demands special care. One way of ensuring the security and privacy of
individuals is to redact or eliminate Personally Identifiable Information (PII)
from collection altogether. However, this results in ASR models that tend to
have lower recognition accuracy of these categories. We use text-injection to
improve the recognition of PII categories by including fake textual substitutes
of PII categories in the training data using a text injection method. We
demonstrate substantial improvement to Recall of Names and Dates in medical
notes while improving overall WER. For alphanumeric digit sequences we show
improvements to Character Error Rate and Sentence Accuracy. | [
0.0211540796,
0.0958050638,
0.0082131308,
0.0173507053,
-0.0107043665,
0.0060054436,
0.0595763996,
0.0231164377,
0.0137278251,
-0.0376909301,
-0.009847994,
-0.0232763141,
0.0595755205,
-0.0134362038,
0.010431651,
-0.036303509,
0.0283888336,
-0.0196988285,
0.0465656333,
0.0052364734,
-0.0070765042,
-0.0072944215,
-0.0289703887,
0.0351376943,
-0.0077986522,
0.0464745015,
0.0045617186,
0.0007566643,
0.0450697131,
0.0096702147,
-0.0283229537,
0.0364961885,
0.0014130051,
0.0276427958,
0.0000018524,
-0.04294293,
-0.0374284387,
0.0502687655,
-0.0933256373,
-0.0085331639,
0.0330216438,
-0.0013292994,
-0.02807994,
0.0357491523,
0.0032542327,
-0.0167189091,
0.0271577705,
0.0783335939,
0.0248613656,
0.069709152,
-0.0245049726,
-0.020783348,
0.0473274402,
0.0086620208,
0.0293108132,
-0.0020390127,
0.0361686386,
-0.066536583,
-0.0046275263,
0.0018640953,
0.0506549478,
0.0291375555,
7.83e-7,
0.0062835822,
0.043215517,
0.0371871367,
-0.0576270297,
-0.0239009038,
-0.0078795962,
0.0287439935,
0.0090181567,
-0.0300314631,
0.0201773047,
0.0041181189,
-0.0021830096,
-0.0050196806,
0.0166189279,
-0.0094582969,
-0.0319000222,
-0.0203394648,
0.0137455408,
0.0300715864,
0.0162124485,
-0.0040995167,
-0.0043195514,
-0.0344554558,
0.0164263155,
-0.0567078404,
0.0270654615,
-0.0599733889,
0.0212257467,
-0.0116197187,
0.053377483,
-0.0056859138,
0.0585372411,
0.0085701523,
-0.0714059621,
-0.05174518,
-0.0068605165,
-0.0630107373,
0.0132478736,
0.0461168736,
-0.0056916359,
0.0012712812,
-0.0112703247,
0.075521864,
0.0208295844,
0.0057115285,
0.0011233138,
0.0035846944,
-0.0235805977,
-0.0153931081,
-0.0326305814,
0.0643639117,
-0.0043254304,
0.0076204049,
-0.0514941849,
0.0003414837,
-0.0187303089,
0.0197393801,
-0.0056596068,
0.0072125914,
-0.0246712789,
0.0061594644,
-0.0006491492,
-0.0372807905,
0.0117740193,
0.0114080841,
-0.0200636052,
-0.0475135632,
0.0230262466,
-0.0153574552,
0.0768420473,
0.0071764444,
-0.0034821492,
0.0610804148,
-0.0202787705,
-0.0369009711,
-0.0673349127,
-0.0365488641,
0.0026675924,
0.0123400558,
-0.0076440689,
-0.0185621195,
0.0019221198,
-0.0317905992,
-0.0186430532,
-0.0596526749,
0.0355293602,
0.0270180497,
-0.043583896,
0.0744878054,
-0.0501629412,
-0.0128162317,
0.053923808,
0.0263118092,
0.0319364481,
-0.0253891516,
0.0237985495,
-0.0359004773,
0.0077722771,
-0.0409971215,
0.0584473014,
0.0216836911,
-0.0011709592,
-0.0356113389,
0.0212012287,
-0.0246126372,
0.0044010123,
0.0037930128,
0.0043346202,
0.0452930406,
0.0101453615,
-0.0301482268,
0.0670847371,
0.0884552225,
0.0155225461,
0.0024559449,
-0.044162754,
-0.0004264963,
0.0178270936,
-0.0334937274,
-0.0250863284,
-0.0437615402,
-0.0116676306,
0.0066036223,
0.0035085776,
0.0101093594,
-0.0052457969,
-0.0056314096,
-0.0193772744,
-0.0639067292,
-0.0040662279,
0.0253952388,
0.0006891019,
0.0099248663,
-0.019816542,
0.0151371472,
0.0035116931,
-0.087875694,
0.0039788489,
-0.0143790785,
-0.0256746653,
0.1008617878,
0.0336319953,
-0.0315849558,
0.0041594426,
-0.0599092469,
-0.0567064807,
0.007686066,
-0.034770105,
-0.0051950323,
0.0520704128,
-0.0583682992,
-0.0068506589,
0.1043993011,
-0.0050390125,
0.0551542677,
0.0381269157,
0.0206800774,
0.0379601158,
0.0307186432,
0.0050718957,
0.0024062141,
-0.033404313,
-0.0979201794,
0.0354741476,
0.0189641211,
0.052862782,
0.07269907,
-0.0156589244,
-0.0090686623,
0.0465140715,
-0.0128617892,
-0.0068439352,
0.0059839166,
-0.0225950461,
0.0213417746,
0.0092612877,
0.0048618997,
0.0243215412,
0.0284951162,
0.0246278364,
-0.0418873765,
-0.0228338875,
-0.0244317837,
0.0237297006,
-0.0328318849,
0.0319549739,
0.0309610758,
0.0038565632,
-0.0151633359,
-0.006792441,
0.0108831497,
0.0055966079,
-0.0167079549,
-0.008963896,
0.0026398904,
-0.0715049133,
-0.0126018897,
-0.0041790088,
-0.0202858131,
0.0493481122,
0.01326661,
-0.0231430717,
-0.0018376935,
-0.0343103483,
-0.0888948217,
-0.0323968306,
0.0225960836,
0.0107341493,
-0.0138187166,
0.037458621,
0.0052847676,
-0.0174231231,
-0.0283784419,
-0.1066439599,
-0.0342700854,
0.0102985343,
0.000528089,
-0.0023010974,
-0.0156439412,
0.0165525451,
0.0126089528,
-0.0419338197,
0.0180356503,
-0.0156512,
-0.0679570809,
-0.0259040371,
-0.0001702968,
0.0254424401,
0.0373685658,
-0.0351078361,
-0.0083970362,
-0.0218479745,
0.0435380116,
0.0236791819,
0.0553229898,
-0.0016109571,
-0.0002790467,
-0.0231622122,
0.0060938802,
0.000244979,
-0.008376888,
0.0301793944,
0.069074735,
0.0275657717,
-0.0562397577,
-0.0025221717,
0.0158552174,
0.0322416537,
0.0216166526,
-0.0117402999,
0.0062331958,
-0.0219841972,
-0.0362199284,
-0.0314962752,
-0.0525007509,
-0.0530064404,
-0.0035515465,
0.009046129,
-0.0055340007,
0.0483588204,
-0.0732545629,
-0.0164024979,
-0.0035798796,
-0.0580665134,
-0.0103928568,
0.0043393704,
-0.0019328339,
0.0224173963,
0.0605833307,
-0.070028916,
0.0147205973,
0.0115052862,
0.0160972849,
-0.0667385012,
0.0395799838,
0.006645035,
-0.0299059357,
-0.0298709143,
-0.0506532788,
-0.0487866178,
-0.0698251724,
0.0005292405,
0.0161475707,
-0.010255442,
-0.0477138981,
-0.0110207815,
0.0059961188,
0.033242397,
0.0691765174,
-0.0002780709,
0.0249361508,
-0.018900767,
0.0386835635,
-0.0507534668,
-0.0279078204,
-0.0621265322,
0.0202872194,
-0.0048161149,
0.0081110839,
0.062132135,
0.0033711703,
0.0059359819,
-0.0111240875,
-0.0195123609,
-0.0233000964,
-0.0204814356,
0.0165439416,
0.006978313,
-0.0340970159,
0.0212413669,
0.0916851163,
0.0084946183,
-0.0244402848,
-0.048082117,
0.0354709104,
-0.0101334034,
-0.0058782799,
-0.002053628,
-0.0381666049,
-0.0048791342,
0.0548415668,
0.0590617619,
-0.0431146622,
-0.0119282398,
-0.0121772746,
-0.0719969422,
0.0146084083,
0.0299974866,
-0.0359264724,
-0.0401310362,
-0.0417446755,
-0.0093269506,
0.0197626315,
0.0167369768,
0.005085614,
-0.0255309213,
-0.0401219875,
0.0305334274,
-0.0780021027,
-0.0698288605,
-0.0396119617,
-0.0049671321,
0.0616611727,
0.0259040147,
0.0213601217,
-0.0344478041,
-0.0426493101,
-0.0079327663,
-0.018249318,
-0.0138465175,
-0.0014227203,
0.0830043182,
-0.0187125783,
-0.0010639675,
-0.0134046748,
0.0816393495,
0.0060961242,
-0.0601586588,
0.0079186484,
0.0102759097,
-0.0065665958,
0.0046137003,
0.0296785794,
-0.0035620823,
0.0011690857,
0.0434241928,
-0.0009571969,
-0.0065203272,
0.0202997494,
-0.0091208238,
0.0689914748,
0.0054772263,
0.0023674606,
0.0178083424,
-0.0257363822,
-0.1508198529,
-0.0374082699,
-0.0156332385,
0.0030563492,
0.0247223023,
0.0520483293,
0.0071513094,
0.0271706544,
0.029649023,
-0.0512839742,
0.0096070319,
-0.0585254468,
0.00348757,
-0.0551900342,
-0.0049239732,
-0.0052278433,
-0.0233239196,
-0.0220974181,
-0.0058971499,
0.0014331023,
-0.0654861555,
0.0631109551,
-0.0167094897,
0.0204860251,
0.0653558969,
-0.0240243282,
-0.0650142953,
0.0647818148,
0.0432205237,
-0.0272068437,
0.0123883532,
0.0614476092,
-0.0084637217,
-0.0174574163,
-0.0285592061,
0.0197606925,
-0.0067275944,
-0.0092404783,
-0.0791098326,
-0.0652656183,
-0.0381827541,
-0.0227948111,
0.0305922143,
0.0428093597,
0.0149799502,
0.0509265587,
-0.0318747237,
0.0634109154,
-0.014803702,
0.0220942441,
0.0190135613,
-0.0364839397,
0.0064557404,
0.0491874851,
0.0060779192,
-0.0368375629,
-0.0526186004,
-0.0222624596,
0.0225082338,
0.024198642,
0.0490683131,
0.0925553665,
-0.0102407923,
-0.0114314808,
-0.0130036613,
0.0587447062,
0.0376181118,
0.0278687626,
-0.011304033,
0.0030700078,
-0.0129484506,
-0.0059673931,
0.0020793497,
0.0131774787,
-0.0575907156,
0.0105023477,
-0.0273264162,
0.0297804698,
-0.0303018428,
0.0136143854,
-0.0247406084,
-0.0197669677,
0.020464696,
-0.009589416,
0.0055841347,
-0.0456981584,
0.0163361765,
-0.0032528632,
0.0070650973,
-0.0143428333,
0.0300001185,
0.0618380271,
0.0650667921,
0.0200737268,
-0.0393186696,
-0.014138124,
-0.0492635854,
-0.0076745339,
0.0335096791,
0.0221745744,
-0.0601271316,
-0.039110817,
-0.0342548676,
-0.033552628,
0.0854109377,
-0.026002612,
0.0361434706,
-0.0174209271,
0.0355852693,
-0.0279598981,
-0.0330601744,
0.0181160327,
0.002967495,
0.0075032199,
-0.0053030327,
-0.0376984961,
0.0096808244,
-6.081777815e-33,
-0.0032318116,
-0.0136596933,
-0.0204825979,
0.0445353948,
-0.002978551,
0.0320487954,
0.012832527,
0.025142923,
0.0398967564,
-0.0218821969,
-0.0513199158,
-0.0324863829,
0.0324435793,
0.0206574425,
-0.0195051972,
-0.015447069,
0.0715497881,
0.0307731666,
-0.0059536505,
-0.0171188172,
0.0303662792,
0.0445569195,
0.0459692031,
-0.091490671,
0.001911909,
0.0191756021,
-0.0070080804,
-0.037328843,
0.035292808,
0.0476713032,
-0.0015314788,
0.0078051346,
0.0082593402,
0.0198899936,
0.0375588946,
0.1252418905,
-0.1142094284,
-0.0033283785,
-0.01952409,
0.0440787748,
0.0511793457,
-0.0767616779,
0.0513945147,
-0.0659669042,
-0.0351375602,
0.0194206536,
0.0126862954,
-0.0072504338,
-0.0290493481,
-0.0474559925,
0.0161726866,
0.0366171859,
0.0094145956,
0.02335798,
0.0488335937,
0.0008892765,
0.0007403812,
-0.0082388641,
-0.0463987105,
-0.0030829646,
0.0420473963,
0.0267755464,
-0.0389765762,
0.0320480913,
-0.0331119336,
0.0160249416,
0.0620185398,
-0.0249339361,
-0.012882906,
-0.0611043386,
0.0138457147,
-0.021814907,
0.0573272258,
0.0717733353,
0.0615500957,
-0.0600335188,
-0.0227542371,
0.011234913,
-0.0241361521,
-0.0239061639,
0.0406827256,
0.0238156319,
-0.1068152189,
-0.0027269509,
-0.0526017919,
-0.0095843319,
-0.0336517245,
0.0296658836,
0.0110547896,
0.0005130437,
-0.0296351537,
0.0313118733,
0.0052779261,
-0.0289676283,
0.0147613119,
-0.0152436392,
0.0367467105,
0.0192611888,
-0.0437889025,
-0.0111090131,
-0.0412786119,
-0.0369395129,
0.0640800521,
0.0064582983,
0.0335808285,
-0.0260109156,
0.0393009596,
0.0115579069,
-0.119679369,
-0.0292550288,
0.0165558662,
0.051662758,
0.0482572801,
0.0413788147,
0.0311902482,
0.0009558636,
0.0250639915,
0.0163243338,
0.0094193695,
0.0450159423,
-0.0363596715,
0.0103046829,
-0.0140336687,
-0.0065922444,
-0.0056105433,
0.0124275275,
0.024225764,
0.0270506162,
0.028096687,
-0.0176797472,
0.0242843088,
-0.0109040504,
2.696e-7,
-0.0245162044,
0.0367808975,
0.0323041119,
-0.0447504669,
-0.0062182839,
0.054300379,
0.0232413784,
0.0244774465,
0.0191556793,
0.0343436077,
0.0240199752,
-0.0379181616,
0.0517776236,
0.0424710363,
-0.1361332238,
-0.0824265257,
-0.0267473906,
0.0057370905,
-0.0281497221,
0.0226522237,
0.0192391276,
0.0798627511,
0.0415424965,
-0.0538387895,
-0.0114296982,
-0.043445196,
0.0319488719,
-0.014638803,
0.0000104251,
-0.0150585184,
-0.0068736402,
0.0585218519,
0.0060090162,
0.0467353277,
-0.051329501,
-0.0003277511,
0.0011986238,
0.0445800237,
-0.0529215299,
-0.0098094987,
-0.0133324079,
0.0075164703,
-0.0496805683,
0.0202956665,
0.0504866131,
0.0463540293,
-0.010650767,
-0.034638416,
-0.0345196985,
-0.0348664634,
0.0231248271,
-0.0008256409,
-0.0199265052,
0.0353070833,
0.0266664047,
-0.0159634333,
-0.0204494633,
-0.0482504964,
-0.0006975603,
-0.0215536281,
-0.0056836596,
-0.0219751112,
0.0115002133,
-0.0050121807,
0.0154947117,
-0.0460854322,
0.0347912274,
2.480288488e-34,
-0.0211305004,
-0.0208773054,
-0.0245948769,
0.0315098092,
0.025568502,
-0.0174979344,
0.0030537527,
0.0268119089,
0.0394957699,
-0.0168706682,
-0.0151897687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07317v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07317v2 | Platypus: Quick, Cheap, and Powerful Refinement of LLMs | 2023-08-14T17:59:56 | 2024-03-14T20:56:23 | Ariel N. Lee, Cole J. Hunter, Nataniel Ruiz | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present $\textbf{Platypus}$, a family of fine-tuned and merged Large
Language Models (LLMs) that achieves the strongest performance and currently
stands at first place in HuggingFace's Open LLM Leaderboard as of the release
date of this work. In this work we describe (1) our curated dataset
$\textbf{Open-Platypus}$, that is a subset of other open datasets and which
$\textit{we release to the public}$ (2) our process of fine-tuning and merging
LoRA modules in order to conserve the strong prior of pretrained LLMs, while
bringing specific domain knowledge to the surface (3) our efforts in checking
for test data leaks and contamination in the training data, which can inform
future research. Specifically, the Platypus family achieves strong performance
in quantitative LLM metrics across model sizes, topping the global Open LLM
leaderboard while using just a fraction of the fine-tuning data and overall
compute that are required for other state-of-the-art fine-tuned LLMs. In
particular, a 13B Platypus model can be trained on $\textit{a single}$ A100 GPU
using 25k questions in 5 hours. This is a testament of the quality of our
Open-Platypus dataset, and opens opportunities for more improvements in the
field. Project page: https://platypus-llm.github.io | [
0.0075195357,
0.0583246686,
-0.0026297187,
0.0682642832,
-0.0030039046,
0.0321665592,
0.0000575603,
0.0143108256,
0.0115551073,
-0.0484757647,
-0.0615376085,
-0.031741064,
-0.001474737,
0.0320719518,
0.0598141775,
-0.0211554095,
0.0493446626,
-0.0613600351,
-0.0235252362,
-0.0101754032,
-0.0026041421,
0.0135232424,
0.0115003707,
0.0135495653,
0.0375275239,
-0.0315524638,
-0.0067573376,
0.0166630987,
0.0197157059,
-0.0150782103,
0.0129898041,
0.037898086,
0.0408702865,
0.0665667802,
0.0000021258,
-0.0388163589,
-0.0184886791,
-0.0026450462,
-0.0131780682,
0.0268283579,
0.0310270339,
-0.0169954915,
-0.0056056166,
0.0161756333,
-0.0561028719,
-0.0284039434,
0.0084016705,
0.0121398829,
0.0737055987,
0.0782568082,
0.0046013636,
-0.0206470191,
0.055531051,
-0.0488500781,
-0.0010794667,
-0.0406504795,
0.0102993073,
-0.0197945386,
-0.010154753,
0.0061079562,
-0.0176243149,
0.0210373234,
0.0400207788,
-0.0142637622,
-0.0344964787,
0.021677915,
-0.0334883183,
-0.0208132584,
-0.0258652959,
0.0899720863,
-0.0482976176,
-0.0159889553,
0.0052848775,
-0.0257853623,
-0.015900759,
-0.0379069969,
-0.0607642159,
0.0537830256,
0.0262664575,
0.0159469638,
0.0245722048,
-0.0491816737,
0.0619498044,
0.0228406042,
-0.0198392179,
0.0474861115,
0.0570215844,
-0.0210463889,
0.0233268049,
-0.0040896819,
-0.0172829088,
-0.0638793483,
-0.0090110293,
0.0505002737,
-0.0261587147,
0.0036615992,
-0.0646806881,
-0.0113839526,
0.0346664265,
0.0090389214,
0.0471697785,
0.0252453964,
-0.0287857167,
0.070483759,
-0.0302698556,
0.0316129811,
-0.0147806462,
0.0280396324,
-0.0435151421,
0.008328923,
0.0144769484,
0.0101102432,
0.0110851163,
0.0307135899,
-0.0523794107,
0.0016892977,
-0.0165112242,
0.0215874799,
0.0019329351,
0.0295253489,
0.0071745454,
-0.0047275447,
-0.0062169377,
-0.0140715437,
-0.0175996814,
0.0275358167,
-0.0275684036,
0.0190706644,
0.0083263954,
-0.0811817944,
-0.0302478243,
0.0517691039,
-0.0103134476,
-0.0227175597,
0.0477520488,
0.0709716976,
0.0072423681,
-0.0445494652,
-0.0253559463,
-0.0144487564,
0.0053830845,
-0.0767582729,
0.0122617166,
-0.0582751594,
0.0466611683,
-0.0131360842,
0.009716928,
-0.0251331255,
0.030577356,
0.023924524,
-0.012453747,
0.0644610971,
-0.0495999046,
-0.0134464847,
0.0067652711,
0.0186368302,
0.0116039095,
0.0699887127,
0.0384596214,
0.046600081,
0.0325639248,
-0.0198271051,
-0.0072506252,
0.0566540137,
0.0131165367,
0.0370354801,
-0.00897865,
0.0354795046,
0.0401782542,
0.033278238,
0.0516901277,
0.0428412259,
-0.010856377,
-0.0273695085,
0.0591991283,
0.0335583687,
-0.0023249045,
0.0329590105,
0.0272978693,
-0.0253098812,
0.0162553042,
-0.0133356377,
-0.0461073145,
0.0118184993,
-0.0376929529,
0.0098132826,
0.0335775614,
0.0402380712,
-0.0185013656,
-0.0463774912,
-0.0225703903,
-0.0200409424,
-0.0316367187,
0.0222009141,
0.0372675657,
0.004739529,
-0.0338447616,
0.0764000192,
0.0437707566,
-0.0581403933,
-0.0042885998,
-0.0380651951,
0.0820375532,
0.0284244493,
0.0311115365,
-0.0436779223,
-0.0775299743,
-0.0385548025,
0.018493237,
0.0548704974,
0.0415197238,
-0.0164820924,
0.0174691826,
-0.0759176612,
-0.0071344269,
-0.0464096665,
0.0151274428,
0.011466763,
0.022399839,
0.0145970825,
-0.0017968519,
-0.0187726151,
-0.0002167444,
0.0490165614,
-0.0530211106,
-0.0296515282,
-0.0134936152,
-0.0091414768,
0.0246308912,
0.0049745729,
-0.0033151908,
0.0000282018,
0.0676876009,
-0.0541430227,
0.005522856,
-0.0405732021,
-0.017225055,
-0.0194348246,
0.0794377252,
-0.0055057686,
-0.0509962998,
0.0553755127,
-0.0827930421,
-0.0127927959,
-0.0024650618,
-0.0054749814,
0.0277346969,
-0.037091136,
0.0275763497,
0.0072107203,
0.0299253613,
-0.0453122221,
0.0464869253,
-0.0273415279,
0.0193763021,
0.0319661126,
0.0124667957,
0.0227925684,
-0.0495287552,
-0.0122830514,
0.0098593794,
-0.0069837407,
0.0110920509,
-0.0181105956,
0.0237628799,
-0.0610257424,
-0.0362250246,
-0.0752359256,
0.0423724204,
-0.0266495906,
0.0336154997,
0.0217691921,
-0.0069293915,
-0.0314702056,
-0.0212718751,
-0.0282776691,
-0.0027095689,
-0.0070452015,
0.0003737407,
0.0430338569,
0.0018522512,
-0.0160438046,
-0.0492552072,
-0.0222099237,
-0.0086131524,
0.048252888,
-0.0144122019,
-0.0197150838,
-0.0422294624,
0.049324438,
-0.0514549576,
0.025592383,
-0.0287339091,
-0.0222819131,
0.014648689,
-0.0319003575,
0.0316055864,
0.0637827069,
0.0094976863,
-0.0339827128,
0.0617539957,
0.0009893287,
-0.0562556796,
0.024697911,
0.0060349624,
-0.0703420863,
-0.0342957415,
0.0044269902,
0.0001002846,
0.0669884682,
-0.0367701761,
-0.0199502613,
-0.0128194373,
0.0137474919,
-0.0185799859,
-0.0330940932,
-0.014309627,
0.0270302743,
-0.0043604281,
0.0246759206,
-0.026175078,
-0.0788835585,
0.0318505242,
-0.0507723093,
-0.0005052034,
-0.0117475912,
-0.0196640249,
-0.0790408701,
0.0653905272,
0.0016874201,
-0.0122787226,
-0.0190666579,
-0.0077273026,
-0.0486421548,
-0.0150560262,
-0.0165584367,
-0.0401546285,
0.0614697523,
-0.0713626742,
0.0180532914,
-0.0522017255,
-0.0716897026,
-0.0129819037,
-0.0190226696,
-0.0535705909,
-0.0040631499,
-0.0310260132,
-0.016689444,
-0.0223555397,
-0.0240928065,
0.0129498392,
0.0228810087,
-0.0158157125,
0.0211535506,
-0.0165863503,
0.02764499,
0.0832700208,
0.0493320301,
0.0362966731,
-0.0403752252,
-0.0059876642,
0.0739041641,
0.0237199645,
0.0220932104,
-0.0431142859,
0.0230118427,
0.0451321192,
-0.0126277599,
-0.0100676855,
0.0000401139,
0.0307477862,
-0.0645586699,
0.0091944123,
0.1243157014,
0.0003907666,
-0.0360957868,
-0.0262491293,
-0.0155912684,
0.0569335967,
0.0386379696,
0.0091784652,
-0.1047172919,
-0.0401652455,
0.005661068,
0.0023585507,
0.0335722379,
-0.0283535924,
-0.0049452274,
-0.1122440621,
0.0237715747,
0.0103301089,
-0.0279533248,
-0.0128169991,
-0.0381359905,
-0.0051838444,
-0.0161852073,
0.0324866809,
-0.0034279667,
-0.0226077698,
0.000909267,
0.0039025426,
0.0034237215,
0.000903905,
0.0171611756,
-0.0296062697,
0.0357833356,
0.036716748,
0.0232084673,
-0.013943485,
-0.0568105355,
0.0634541735,
0.0054791309,
-0.0176709443,
-0.0324598514,
0.0286695827,
-0.027212685,
-0.0211552493,
0.0051495354,
0.0356400013,
-0.0606864542,
-0.0045740851,
0.0195932798,
0.0625794232,
0.001430857,
-0.0271982495,
0.006970508,
-0.0218296889,
-0.0131516838,
0.05713211,
0.0484933667,
-0.0178765859,
-0.0299225021,
-0.0210257117,
-0.0273601562,
-0.0048570251,
-0.0345614441,
0.0120514818,
0.026543783,
0.0106467139,
-0.0404690094,
-0.0292887185,
0.0473973118,
0.0164211281,
-0.0097414311,
0.0324276462,
-0.0274610166,
-0.017113043,
-0.0624092072,
0.0864181444,
-0.0543570817,
0.0106429718,
-0.1060557738,
0.0043946281,
0.0273994524,
-0.0033019041,
-0.0246685762,
0.0589946024,
-0.1170353144,
-0.0683294013,
-0.020403441,
0.0480226725,
0.0245756377,
0.017143406,
0.0048601492,
-0.0579717681,
0.0325588174,
0.0322809778,
-0.0294746459,
0.0580247417,
0.0166607052,
-0.024968829,
0.0089953346,
0.0516987182,
-0.041075334,
-0.0198155027,
0.0438582897,
0.0303273145,
-0.0059171114,
-0.0318751633,
0.0019307402,
0.0145541364,
0.0280813519,
-0.0168876536,
-0.0217007995,
-0.0388016775,
0.0507925637,
0.0107397158,
0.0043891952,
-0.0404134318,
0.0073577082,
0.0377304591,
-0.0188892223,
-0.0009163667,
-0.0032407118,
0.0104387552,
0.0463577695,
-0.0472745486,
0.0339877866,
0.0352963991,
-0.0087352712,
0.0406016633,
-0.0068571651,
-0.025577819,
0.027214855,
-0.0312872864,
0.0566966236,
-0.0160608981,
0.0275443643,
-0.0071309935,
0.0100077242,
0.0055765528,
0.0614819489,
-0.0358589739,
-0.0836860761,
-0.0049890559,
0.0252589304,
0.0636878982,
0.0182888675,
0.0354266725,
0.0175967962,
-0.0346445218,
-0.014631385,
0.0135921491,
-0.0193499587,
-0.024145212,
0.0614004545,
0.0397075824,
-0.024439767,
0.0282630362,
0.0557947978,
0.000188624,
0.0648674294,
0.0468949117,
0.0743938833,
-0.0299959183,
-0.0252962559,
0.0170431621,
0.0000118478,
-0.0083337417,
-0.0017007166,
-0.0399936698,
-0.0798685402,
0.0121889403,
0.0236831587,
-0.0453191362,
0.0088669863,
0.0207032058,
0.0469131954,
-0.0071707843,
-0.0114656789,
-0.0162566155,
0.0365675539,
0.004221885,
-0.02261688,
-0.0039382982,
-6.531390445e-33,
-0.0290950332,
-0.0027433077,
0.0344202779,
-0.0204351898,
-0.0157716777,
0.0085721826,
-0.0173281636,
-0.0273317173,
-0.0204613078,
-0.0219101347,
-0.0264683086,
0.0089852167,
0.0082098823,
0.0203251485,
-0.0140050864,
-0.0321040377,
0.0097567346,
0.0089964317,
-0.003958832,
0.0143516986,
-0.0214687716,
0.05330538,
0.0626556501,
-0.0170528926,
-0.0135972528,
-0.01798141,
-0.0139511544,
0.0376301333,
-0.0529622771,
0.0653731823,
-0.0429694243,
0.0179654192,
0.007318818,
-0.0171769559,
-0.0057486137,
0.0066533294,
-0.0563194901,
-0.0278349575,
0.0282384846,
0.0096886652,
-0.0378781185,
-0.0307809543,
0.0534374267,
0.0038939998,
0.0264093056,
-0.0430484116,
0.0028404759,
-0.036451865,
-0.0339893438,
-0.0019194193,
-0.0364562795,
0.0269022509,
0.0100658406,
0.0139013696,
0.0232465267,
-0.0283923447,
0.0167531446,
0.0599392205,
-0.0373014621,
0.0059189252,
0.0323488377,
0.0597963594,
0.0894112214,
0.0057487739,
0.0080582313,
0.0590237416,
0.0214586928,
-0.0010136361,
0.0090906899,
0.005026069,
-0.0036749712,
0.0537397079,
0.0427876189,
0.049150791,
0.0205338467,
-0.0022565161,
-0.0997429341,
0.0194261763,
0.0496400222,
0.0185718853,
-0.0256819874,
0.0276112072,
-0.0024138691,
0.0039644148,
-0.055683665,
0.0228932109,
-0.0350152068,
-0.0100152288,
0.0224950276,
0.0150077594,
-0.0222454425,
-0.0205009971,
-0.0126285041,
-0.0309154224,
-0.0041289502,
-0.0255867001,
0.0246419087,
0.0027869039,
0.0132174697,
0.0562157668,
-0.032543961,
-0.0457488559,
-0.00778009,
-0.0427042171,
0.0285701063,
-0.010009964,
0.0085834404,
0.0226144847,
-0.0830790401,
0.0036023159,
-0.049552206,
0.0136212017,
0.0256455969,
0.0537397824,
0.0295491219,
-0.0043773451,
0.0071180179,
0.0541543961,
-0.0064384863,
0.0081851464,
-0.0311132558,
0.0117362328,
-0.0211841669,
0.0100044785,
-0.0134556005,
-0.0122198239,
-0.0030043165,
0.0230863411,
0.0463694222,
-0.0606191754,
-0.0046661845,
0.0057582599,
2.751e-7,
0.0368942097,
0.0415061899,
-0.0129727721,
0.0105226226,
-0.0145240035,
0.0241615381,
-0.0435668826,
0.0187789239,
0.0209148582,
-0.031846568,
-0.0396282896,
0.0100424392,
0.0419916548,
0.0112659987,
-0.1111340374,
0.0375999771,
-0.0268788375,
-0.0058481297,
-0.0459804237,
-0.0241083503,
0.0074663865,
0.1446076483,
0.0166137256,
-0.0364581272,
0.0101171331,
-0.0429926664,
0.0617597178,
-0.0456579439,
-0.0322689898,
0.0295248795,
0.0113269808,
0.0256808326,
-0.0343944617,
-0.0081294961,
0.0000254725,
0.0198944602,
-0.0051148362,
0.0729185566,
0.0227130763,
-0.0212751254,
0.01879628,
-0.0410379209,
-0.001341613,
-0.0703003034,
0.074411504,
0.0047959569,
-0.0283877775,
-0.057236217,
-0.0154351722,
-0.0372102819,
0.0316134021,
-0.0447446927,
0.0444281064,
0.0206538606,
0.0034397559,
-0.0332010053,
-0.024170531,
-0.0883364603,
-0.0307149496,
-0.0495362021,
-0.052362591,
-0.0643408746,
-0.0601509809,
0.0197983775,
0.0022524449,
-0.0685199946,
-0.0019891709,
2.753898804e-34,
0.027647255,
-0.0209306069,
0.0193953011,
0.0351869613,
0.0293669645,
-0.0085714357,
0.0247032605,
-0.0156112481,
-0.003875379,
-0.0938646197,
0.0069532534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07308v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07308v4 | LLM Self Defense: By Self Examination, LLMs Know They Are Being Tricked | 2023-08-14T17:54:10 | 2024-05-02T14:28:39 | Mansi Phute, Alec Helbling, Matthew Hull, ShengYun Peng, Sebastian Szyller, Cory Cornelius, Duen Horng Chau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are popular for high-quality text generation but
can produce harmful content, even when aligned with human values through
reinforcement learning. Adversarial prompts can bypass their safety measures.
We propose LLM Self Defense, a simple approach to defend against these attacks
by having an LLM screen the induced responses. Our method does not require any
fine-tuning, input preprocessing, or iterative output generation. Instead, we
incorporate the generated content into a pre-defined prompt and employ another
instance of an LLM to analyze the text and predict whether it is harmful. We
test LLM Self Defense on GPT 3.5 and Llama 2, two of the current most prominent
LLMs against various types of attacks, such as forcefully inducing affirmative
responses to prompts and prompt engineering attacks. Notably, LLM Self Defense
succeeds in reducing the attack success rate to virtually 0 using both GPT 3.5
and Llama 2. The code is publicly available at
https://github.com/poloclub/llm-self-defense | [
0.0296387672,
0.037448246,
-0.0146415643,
0.0379246883,
-0.0207491703,
-0.0020486726,
-0.0066879885,
0.0068371817,
0.0317749716,
-0.0319863148,
-0.0251847021,
-0.015230692,
-0.0005175263,
0.0435975082,
0.0560993627,
0.0000430379,
0.0403299704,
-0.0313908458,
0.0127866194,
-0.0128051462,
0.0093924012,
0.0028381958,
0.0098066609,
0.0226941165,
0.0066820863,
-0.0276957341,
-0.0149962343,
0.0187548194,
0.0274263788,
-0.0550565645,
0.0276033841,
0.0248167589,
-0.0048608021,
0.0754800811,
0.0000021548,
-0.0421785377,
-0.0258965213,
-0.0079067154,
-0.0102574052,
0.0457253121,
0.029324552,
-0.022221921,
-0.0508923866,
0.0488522761,
-0.0531245843,
0.0210608542,
0.0160117671,
0.064538084,
0.0983809382,
0.1126010567,
0.0103149693,
0.0065539661,
0.0541515313,
-0.040421363,
0.0215899739,
-0.0137879662,
0.0159910154,
-0.056213744,
0.0010960939,
0.0390634947,
0.0131954234,
0.0024009389,
0.0101961913,
-0.0312644206,
-0.0651362389,
0.0453196466,
0.0151051721,
-0.0253083482,
-0.0261389501,
0.0536273345,
-0.0429148003,
-0.0149355866,
0.024846958,
-0.0275277216,
0.0161484648,
-0.0200620312,
-0.0078272996,
0.0434765033,
-0.006347572,
0.013898435,
0.0163828842,
-0.0148048941,
0.0400415286,
0.0197053421,
0.0176971518,
0.0554194972,
0.0266629197,
-0.0380594805,
0.0028015634,
-0.0043312162,
0.0154660176,
-0.0697741136,
-0.0144621599,
0.0358148739,
-0.0354733951,
0.0129639823,
-0.0758340508,
-0.0228164867,
0.0654650703,
-0.019675307,
0.0246675778,
0.0232204814,
-0.015812315,
-0.005807451,
-0.0463308394,
0.0341793485,
-0.0371552333,
0.0529470183,
0.0107561946,
0.0566054843,
0.0164170377,
-0.0165223684,
-0.0099885697,
0.0254112333,
0.0192928873,
0.0120503372,
-0.0490355939,
0.057402771,
-0.0181590617,
0.0603360198,
-0.0344605967,
0.0037671381,
-0.0185952913,
0.0056930529,
-0.0141854193,
-0.0437813401,
-0.022640571,
-0.0146691641,
0.0071921642,
-0.0692313388,
-0.0382608473,
0.0241000168,
-0.0436733216,
-0.0195627157,
0.0017565502,
0.1061959043,
-0.0153831448,
-0.0241382793,
-0.0527171083,
-0.0727908388,
-0.0308523681,
-0.0472696424,
0.0194725581,
-0.0415283665,
-0.0158206616,
-0.026609771,
-0.0240255557,
-0.0467242151,
0.0298676006,
0.0345047936,
-0.0031513569,
0.0565803535,
0.0060797837,
-0.0309614036,
0.0358527452,
0.0394856445,
-0.0088070706,
0.0484825857,
0.0290385913,
0.0786830634,
0.0210468061,
0.001136004,
0.0470801704,
0.048057396,
0.0383698121,
0.0327902734,
-0.0090146121,
-0.0133911837,
0.0091466121,
0.0177165549,
0.0053825169,
0.0595315062,
-0.001944183,
-0.0228045471,
0.0913229138,
0.0198653787,
-0.061075218,
0.009841851,
0.036063876,
0.0171823818,
-0.0188971981,
0.0400141217,
-0.0647600517,
0.0200784728,
-0.0787265971,
-0.0099722352,
0.0218752064,
0.0224186685,
0.0074251178,
-0.0183737725,
0.0064201485,
-0.0156421047,
0.0002330569,
-0.0060424218,
0.009198714,
0.0205731802,
-0.058015082,
-0.0222338382,
0.0023872198,
-0.0341692157,
-0.0160741583,
-0.0809295848,
0.0625914186,
0.0501150601,
0.0582812056,
-0.0178528484,
0.0198430326,
-0.0462010875,
-0.0116700158,
0.0519418381,
0.0227240995,
0.0208174456,
-0.0225247014,
-0.0300708339,
-0.0103273373,
-0.039804887,
-0.0000896129,
0.0287398435,
0.0188111756,
0.0175577365,
0.015758371,
0.0393162295,
-0.0434275381,
0.054220356,
0.0038143534,
-0.0855058655,
0.0204929113,
0.0095072305,
0.0439808406,
-0.0075432775,
-0.0216837525,
0.0366083756,
0.0472371541,
-0.0189517252,
-0.0152745387,
-0.0467974059,
-0.0414174162,
-0.029487757,
0.0169619732,
-0.0155473882,
-0.0257542972,
0.0236417595,
-0.0530092232,
-0.0122403512,
0.0027068795,
-0.0510749333,
-0.0121287517,
-0.0453726053,
0.0064045805,
0.0173589364,
0.02506168,
-0.034015771,
0.0469232127,
-0.0087254439,
-0.0174200237,
0.0187166594,
0.0305288285,
0.0075435382,
-0.0355816819,
-0.0404585712,
-0.0107768588,
-0.0215596929,
0.0073182439,
0.0263979901,
0.0460179225,
-0.0150882546,
-0.0339973867,
-0.0105495043,
0.0067780777,
-0.0260535665,
0.0259470996,
0.0386864543,
-0.0282961186,
-0.0338038728,
-0.0062076021,
-0.0565226711,
-0.0018680068,
0.0440137237,
0.0137812402,
0.0381772332,
-0.0234877653,
0.0148461368,
-0.03350408,
0.0213050544,
-0.0245172195,
0.0291462317,
0.0138463769,
-0.0074834316,
-0.0403535627,
0.0423079766,
-0.0191922784,
0.0177155212,
-0.017215075,
-0.0619122311,
0.0440586358,
-0.004095335,
0.0203661826,
0.0648527741,
0.0581000708,
0.0206588581,
0.0789599344,
0.0365193523,
-0.0609133691,
0.0068505709,
0.0017053946,
-0.0350294299,
-0.0103894239,
-0.0578275174,
0.0526922084,
0.0596334152,
0.040489044,
0.0060091079,
-0.0434864871,
0.0624579564,
0.0047445139,
-0.0354980938,
-0.0003215739,
-0.0351743288,
-0.0657852665,
0.0175358783,
-0.013586021,
-0.0808028057,
0.0909440741,
-0.0543069281,
0.0176487304,
0.0041957046,
-0.016257111,
0.0121474667,
0.0414510295,
-0.0060606659,
0.0110029746,
0.0474400856,
0.0028906211,
-0.042519711,
-0.0249440093,
0.0333873369,
-0.0217104591,
0.03038585,
-0.033294566,
-0.0093234349,
-0.0059536495,
-0.0322435871,
-0.0889529362,
-0.0581634976,
-0.0119759599,
-0.0180683192,
-0.008466715,
-0.0079664784,
-0.002352614,
-0.0508826748,
0.0309846699,
0.002426872,
-0.044524543,
-0.0081765503,
-0.0384245627,
0.0372537598,
0.0659158379,
-0.0358308516,
0.015225593,
-0.0408759303,
0.0357491933,
0.07523074,
-0.012648196,
0.0306575689,
-0.0042920597,
-0.0107314717,
0.013665447,
-0.0135160526,
0.0040061213,
0.049216494,
0.0247076489,
-0.0337683111,
-0.011829868,
0.0770977139,
0.0122222798,
-0.0332901552,
0.0075430311,
-0.0135761155,
0.050661169,
0.0017609346,
0.0089256875,
-0.0875295624,
-0.0047400305,
0.0208279435,
0.0495912954,
-0.0338691249,
-0.0034912566,
-0.033469636,
-0.1176069081,
0.0231143869,
0.0016029668,
0.002806874,
0.0076438403,
-0.0136651434,
-0.0355344005,
0.034551017,
0.0227293335,
0.0041606883,
0.0028123634,
-0.0042391191,
0.0148492195,
0.0051940759,
-0.0108189629,
0.0047373734,
-0.012591254,
0.0567225665,
0.103110753,
0.0266066343,
-0.0279139429,
-0.0500750504,
0.0307995062,
-0.0204356946,
-0.0021394172,
-0.0014092801,
0.0175538752,
-0.0150896478,
-0.0193295665,
0.0012142697,
0.05186636,
-0.0008362141,
-0.0086494191,
0.0607869662,
0.04419351,
-0.021969907,
-0.0573018827,
-0.0288608205,
0.0160629507,
0.032885842,
0.0729206875,
0.0335499458,
-0.0425181687,
-0.0492398813,
-0.0728390664,
0.0095927287,
-0.0406450368,
-0.0575088412,
-0.0050700721,
0.0173606593,
-0.0010237981,
-0.0770255104,
-0.0265298802,
-0.0138633167,
-0.0040141395,
0.0157446992,
-0.0270218942,
-0.0463504121,
0.0010858965,
-0.0268881135,
-0.0176484548,
-0.0235710591,
0.0424959958,
-0.0698010996,
0.0261437874,
0.0091626514,
-0.0501143448,
-0.002583449,
0.0290399566,
-0.0599606223,
-0.0879923925,
-0.0005114484,
0.0887322351,
0.0149669107,
0.0184479244,
-0.0135929855,
-0.0540459938,
0.1067248359,
0.0460386984,
-0.0361279994,
0.022881072,
0.0455527492,
0.0194348805,
0.0077646207,
0.0116546778,
-0.0318735912,
0.0020284066,
0.0459674112,
-0.0050972071,
-0.0195190497,
-0.0381723866,
0.0095597599,
0.0353798047,
0.0416459851,
-0.0516427495,
0.0335921682,
-0.001760738,
0.0085006738,
-0.0001711197,
-0.0068918988,
-0.0083103795,
0.0278624035,
0.0180185027,
-0.0323240384,
0.0066754916,
-0.0140656522,
-0.0359147005,
0.0353511944,
-0.0155820251,
0.0129868062,
-0.0071342862,
0.054449942,
0.0435323752,
-0.008026002,
-0.0229811519,
0.0598214418,
0.0034559919,
0.0156890433,
0.0001093747,
0.0648774803,
-0.0002588619,
-0.0088355653,
0.0179862063,
0.0524465926,
-0.0420997702,
-0.037768662,
-0.0097446525,
0.0418796428,
0.0201691762,
0.0392849073,
0.0257252231,
-0.0361666642,
0.0006665732,
-0.0104627591,
-0.0062277592,
0.0096671199,
-0.0385544859,
0.0319859833,
-0.0094983252,
-0.0200691987,
-0.0159126967,
0.0691627413,
0.0074077738,
0.0492188931,
0.0251592044,
-0.0098057743,
-0.0383360647,
-0.0351720639,
0.0243135747,
0.005682766,
-0.032534603,
-0.0320433229,
-0.0377301611,
-0.059232492,
-0.016099168,
0.0463454798,
0.0166261233,
-0.0237035919,
0.0084467828,
0.0144670894,
-0.009196545,
0.0542570241,
-0.0426366813,
0.0343223289,
0.0115118092,
-0.0472100116,
-0.0081298323,
-6.219629507e-33,
-0.0081778551,
-0.0676056519,
-0.0146963298,
-0.0057612285,
0.0092724906,
-0.0082200486,
-0.0319053642,
-0.0109113371,
0.0053125811,
-0.0133998329,
-0.0223383401,
-0.0070751612,
-0.0044894149,
0.0176748093,
-0.0222045071,
-0.0428671241,
0.0361067876,
-0.0346417129,
-0.0509486459,
0.046485018,
0.0260205753,
0.0137202675,
0.0061384919,
-0.0515990034,
0.0546468981,
-0.0067884265,
-0.061194919,
-0.0062787086,
-0.0778432414,
0.0465006307,
-0.0254660789,
0.0383940637,
0.0080407253,
-0.0245166514,
0.0010286593,
0.0768520311,
0.0127969738,
-0.0473229699,
0.0109460307,
-0.0378504321,
-0.0372007079,
-0.0755640864,
0.0494442284,
-0.0288286265,
-0.0292912666,
0.0271015801,
0.0068783597,
0.0060586189,
-0.014700518,
-0.0364194512,
-0.0471279584,
-0.005253911,
0.0128867021,
-0.0282715894,
-0.0078510921,
0.0120264692,
0.018930003,
0.003278068,
-0.0441093817,
0.0382053778,
0.041905567,
0.0128642311,
0.0446869247,
-0.0103790388,
-0.0139453998,
0.0761692524,
0.0006201904,
-0.0003691106,
-0.03684026,
-0.0118769109,
0.0073611764,
0.0106051564,
0.0603322126,
0.0716097876,
-0.0023284238,
-0.044745028,
-0.0630015135,
0.0543875769,
0.0487888046,
0.00074251,
0.0497589298,
-0.0349570811,
-0.017843524,
0.000687869,
-0.0217798259,
-0.0254755672,
-0.0193803944,
-0.0298425723,
0.0296362117,
0.0296675898,
-0.0330159962,
-0.0774672329,
-0.0114722475,
-0.0345322564,
0.0077895694,
0.0304658934,
-0.0417806618,
-0.042510435,
0.0080993734,
0.0165377539,
-0.0134001551,
0.0100541944,
0.0157057345,
-0.0582748987,
0.0155240884,
0.0076928209,
0.0242566615,
0.0512613393,
-0.0806386769,
0.0197776631,
-0.0470674522,
0.0629933774,
0.0149174808,
-0.0088094948,
0.0168109089,
-0.0394547507,
-0.0011734215,
-0.0036791589,
0.0073529179,
-0.0216389876,
-0.0377802514,
0.0223310106,
-0.0151811298,
0.0369321406,
-0.0411129892,
0.0208010543,
-0.0037676191,
0.0628716499,
0.026859859,
-0.0765843093,
0.0007715499,
-0.0217627697,
2.852e-7,
-0.0218066107,
0.0324731804,
0.0242175274,
0.0524481609,
0.0408970714,
0.0763734207,
-0.0176879354,
0.0807476044,
-0.010975494,
-0.0261081997,
-0.0021597659,
-0.0143719586,
0.0314248987,
0.0343280248,
-0.0783365294,
0.0335139409,
-0.0866424218,
0.0104774628,
-0.0736160055,
-0.0108740665,
0.0758605674,
0.0704549551,
0.0016446959,
-0.025396904,
0.0221897699,
-0.0450241379,
0.0444845371,
-0.0114318598,
0.0009918013,
-0.0110970456,
0.0622351058,
0.0038424849,
-0.0066979364,
-0.0106249386,
-0.0254862886,
-0.0379929468,
-0.0484985076,
0.0704877153,
0.0354652777,
-0.0519753359,
0.0025167661,
-0.0250830837,
0.0251140464,
-0.0576193891,
0.0839579031,
-0.0001488205,
0.0003020308,
-0.04254511,
0.0071851164,
-0.0691300631,
0.0391588844,
-0.0679805353,
-0.0300898179,
0.0076012351,
-0.0075301514,
0.0249668062,
0.0114060491,
-0.0477832146,
-0.0351920016,
-0.0328698941,
-0.0180852227,
-0.0426617675,
-0.0580403395,
0.0557925962,
0.003830208,
-0.0397350974,
0.0024584809,
2.644791576e-34,
0.0034071929,
-0.0481369086,
0.0019062741,
-0.0066904691,
0.0136779202,
0.0357646048,
0.0261240732,
0.0101341009,
0.0352556594,
-0.018003406,
-0.0384691581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07305v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07305v1 | Neural Authorship Attribution: Stylometric Analysis on Large Language Models | 2023-08-14T17:46:52 | 2023-08-14T17:46:52 | Tharindu Kumarage, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) such as GPT-4, PaLM, and Llama have
significantly propelled the generation of AI-crafted text. With rising concerns
about their potential misuse, there is a pressing need for AI-generated-text
forensics. Neural authorship attribution is a forensic effort, seeking to trace
AI-generated text back to its originating LLM. The LLM landscape can be divided
into two primary categories: proprietary and open-source. In this work, we
delve into these emerging categories of LLMs, focusing on the nuances of neural
authorship attribution. To enrich our understanding, we carry out an empirical
analysis of LLM writing signatures, highlighting the contrasts between
proprietary and open-source models, and scrutinizing variations within each
group. By integrating stylometric features across lexical, syntactic, and
structural aspects of language, we explore their potential to yield
interpretable results and augment pre-trained language model-based classifiers
utilized in neural authorship attribution. Our findings, based on a range of
state-of-the-art LLMs, provide empirical insights into neural authorship
attribution, paving the way for future investigations aimed at mitigating the
threats posed by AI-generated misinformation. | [
0.040291924,
0.0732105821,
-0.0295973122,
0.0384548418,
-0.0787128881,
0.0096379649,
0.0680776685,
0.0044094394,
-0.0033247797,
-0.0325981528,
-0.0131597109,
-0.0659865066,
0.0438735075,
0.0364990532,
0.0554651506,
0.0529582091,
-0.0255086739,
0.0073044118,
0.0486348793,
0.0003689583,
-0.0076208436,
0.032282602,
0.0403396674,
0.0504073799,
-0.0346908197,
-0.046348203,
0.0257320777,
0.0291396528,
0.0021509458,
0.014360385,
0.0195631944,
0.0619155802,
-0.0107400529,
0.1388567537,
0.0000015589,
-0.0439260602,
-0.0061433241,
0.0220184196,
-0.0168352649,
0.0342623703,
0.063372083,
0.0136686098,
-0.036844857,
0.0022819492,
-0.0208451562,
-0.0065035117,
0.0199602153,
0.0553287268,
0.0156430341,
0.0940504894,
-0.0198817961,
-0.0484520309,
0.0617434569,
-0.0027808279,
-0.0160423163,
0.0474966876,
0.0342746153,
-0.0494865179,
-0.0212851204,
0.0298369341,
0.0302852988,
0.0344939195,
0.0300112013,
-0.0297426078,
-0.0294837933,
0.0072023598,
-0.0096296137,
0.0302058104,
0.0178483408,
-0.0071625197,
-0.0339655988,
-0.053667482,
0.0110167861,
-0.0035817318,
0.0127473418,
0.0244575888,
0.0040008468,
0.0556615256,
-0.0401475951,
-0.001121487,
0.0393329896,
-0.0098543791,
0.0501951985,
0.0195337776,
0.0265898202,
0.0514030717,
0.019676514,
-0.0176309478,
-0.027159581,
-0.0273389537,
0.0018452328,
-0.0631045103,
0.0467417203,
0.0164374039,
0.0507950597,
-0.0079744747,
-0.0529542305,
-0.05707011,
0.0368197598,
-0.0637860224,
0.0676360503,
-0.0183434281,
-0.0260408055,
0.0232195221,
-0.0452662036,
0.055337213,
-0.0298208389,
0.0314654149,
0.0018041937,
-0.0239969436,
-0.0280863605,
-0.0485931449,
-0.0045029237,
0.0019954073,
0.0208532289,
0.0004543636,
-0.0401083119,
0.0163793992,
0.0120741362,
-0.009790591,
-0.0174367577,
-0.0006974698,
-0.0262943674,
0.0093482584,
0.0005936587,
-0.0221456196,
0.0006485574,
0.0324339829,
-0.0110230334,
-0.0153517472,
-0.0208086595,
0.0634517968,
-0.005870624,
-0.0386945307,
0.0466485731,
0.0363570042,
0.0067073293,
-0.0336217582,
-0.015695665,
-0.0453700237,
-0.0243268944,
-0.0282894243,
-0.0146858832,
-0.0545231551,
-0.0216175001,
-0.0178071801,
-0.0324756093,
-0.0753137767,
-0.0163976904,
0.0243874602,
-0.0546776056,
0.0281578302,
0.0093912482,
-0.0115615819,
0.0565205365,
-0.0120465411,
-0.009811623,
-0.0354512259,
0.0654683486,
0.0803135931,
0.039088089,
-0.0009735044,
0.0547575615,
0.0392505974,
0.0154340155,
0.002744629,
0.0055992207,
-0.0355048142,
0.0025433667,
-0.0032466177,
0.0214567818,
0.0565522537,
0.008395453,
-0.065670833,
0.1011973843,
0.080337435,
-0.0005424412,
0.0444311723,
0.0644235611,
-0.014936096,
0.0251514167,
-0.007234131,
-0.0497349575,
0.0105866389,
-0.0666209087,
-0.0267205127,
-0.035897512,
0.0476580262,
0.004106754,
-0.008427063,
0.0195771717,
-0.0145195974,
0.0176972002,
-0.0198216178,
0.0219773259,
-0.0097655822,
-0.0188987851,
-0.0402574874,
-0.0080918148,
-0.0603634827,
-0.008771983,
-0.0518195741,
0.020323582,
0.0326987617,
0.0566765815,
-0.0139096137,
-0.0138022611,
-0.0402863584,
-0.035732314,
0.0497744791,
-0.0253452845,
-0.0152957523,
0.012501725,
-0.0116178012,
0.0093612941,
-0.0573785827,
0.0123830652,
0.0608447157,
0.0077611119,
0.0194162503,
0.0323704965,
-0.0227986947,
-0.0509128422,
0.0351498127,
-0.0263425168,
-0.0551417507,
0.0184749924,
0.0053153229,
0.0222846419,
0.0277567971,
-0.0295646731,
0.0015799663,
0.0208279192,
-0.055551663,
-0.045241002,
-0.0225338358,
0.0132951038,
0.0255254526,
0.0414540917,
0.0071575544,
0.0134343868,
0.0261816904,
-0.015642764,
-0.0348311998,
0.0216586925,
-0.0100145396,
-0.0099206548,
-0.084869884,
0.0047086868,
-0.0354250073,
0.017608339,
-0.0252040159,
0.0712826401,
0.0139937373,
-0.001300566,
-0.0348734707,
-0.0071641561,
0.0545382835,
0.0009639882,
-0.0144536914,
-0.0189709272,
-0.0255215112,
0.0187410768,
0.0184257794,
0.005535787,
0.0064332499,
-0.0704450533,
-0.0380509384,
-0.0003549645,
-0.0205188897,
0.0296219066,
0.0093933018,
-0.0292486008,
-0.0098381927,
0.0105852317,
-0.0367434509,
-0.0847136527,
-0.0150132487,
0.0008865811,
0.0459568836,
-0.0131331701,
-0.015182578,
-0.0237578712,
-0.0022769165,
-0.0209721569,
0.0414275825,
0.0476292185,
-0.0079134889,
-0.0524098165,
0.0127977766,
-0.026260335,
-0.0025775835,
-0.0230471175,
-0.0407760702,
0.0097320545,
-0.0125766229,
-0.0083037028,
0.0788733214,
0.0052104518,
0.025872115,
-0.0018867919,
0.0289506149,
-0.0064551653,
-0.0195735004,
-0.0167015474,
0.0377871357,
-0.0179404076,
-0.0484370366,
0.0259082466,
0.0324943028,
0.0088649681,
-0.0411716588,
-0.0133455787,
0.0289120656,
0.011407664,
-0.0111569539,
0.0571269058,
-0.0583156757,
-0.0110585215,
-0.0014508484,
-0.0325245894,
-0.0795841441,
0.0322594121,
-0.0890572295,
0.0238005519,
-0.0047646649,
-0.0402024537,
-0.0382238328,
0.0699736997,
0.0135123888,
0.0234405752,
0.0337924771,
-0.025631994,
-0.0248255432,
0.0100524407,
0.0374751054,
0.0135259479,
0.0021203954,
-0.0241682474,
0.0280572753,
0.0287928637,
0.0018068246,
-0.0144515252,
-0.0847213492,
-0.0081968345,
0.0082003344,
0.0073619625,
-0.0600198619,
-0.0066721812,
-0.0556728579,
0.0465018302,
0.0403592922,
-0.0320083275,
0.0087609701,
-0.0207527019,
0.0360784605,
0.0015396776,
-0.0569233745,
0.0234588254,
-0.0283486675,
-0.0461042933,
0.008026395,
-0.0209970269,
0.0341983847,
-0.0292500705,
-0.0181086566,
-0.0101386374,
-0.025346525,
-0.0647194609,
0.0038984667,
0.0458477065,
-0.0459312573,
0.0149268685,
0.1319878697,
-0.0024775884,
-0.0355843306,
-0.015319447,
0.0036598404,
0.0006616233,
0.0105025899,
0.014593224,
-0.0508219376,
0.0045044995,
-0.0052509117,
0.0114319837,
-0.0499653257,
-0.0271968395,
-0.0260167792,
-0.0734372362,
0.0385544635,
-0.0069008935,
-0.040289823,
0.0183411781,
-0.0265237223,
-0.0472058989,
0.0231978521,
-0.0287965499,
-0.0394058228,
0.0172694344,
0.0067895832,
-0.015743522,
-0.0069635184,
0.0056001348,
0.0282932278,
-0.0481754839,
0.0256295279,
0.0718265474,
0.0753434598,
-0.0340950266,
-0.0146366525,
0.009851913,
-0.0013360151,
-0.0078277336,
-0.0176020265,
0.0704651102,
-0.0155342445,
0.0058414182,
-0.0303555131,
0.0623131581,
-0.0362085812,
0.0019592089,
-0.0061190072,
0.0539108962,
-0.0068592541,
-0.0344153866,
-0.001727737,
-0.0431389436,
0.0292715225,
0.0507393181,
0.0183889773,
-0.0388026088,
-0.0704743266,
-0.0418088995,
0.024897648,
0.0013268897,
-0.0193440877,
0.0138036301,
-0.0003174019,
-0.0391616337,
-0.0722604096,
-0.0393779352,
-0.0290058125,
-0.0035992486,
0.029716976,
0.0348520167,
0.0156913605,
-0.0535728596,
-0.0456027798,
0.0116062118,
-0.0273476038,
0.0653045252,
-0.0323116183,
0.021528367,
-0.0015418052,
-0.0223991126,
0.0183430202,
0.009370842,
-0.0752892718,
-0.0499344617,
0.0098832352,
0.0273061823,
0.0202656016,
0.0146578429,
-0.0385342129,
-0.090418227,
0.0598660633,
0.0150694363,
0.0009603066,
0.0309469718,
0.0212920681,
-0.0299781393,
-0.0253864136,
0.0324777327,
-0.0229634959,
0.0334209949,
0.0641245171,
-0.0524216816,
-0.0200128816,
-0.0184286907,
-0.004386303,
0.0258699432,
0.0324560665,
-0.044801265,
0.021138059,
-0.0174303465,
-0.0144219371,
-0.0417863764,
-0.0032181703,
-0.0130079072,
-0.0052342871,
0.0373354852,
-0.0020906213,
-0.0265740119,
0.0250926334,
0.0024312094,
0.0839206725,
-0.0282788817,
0.0106806643,
-0.0090050027,
0.0753325224,
-0.0105502298,
0.0112959379,
0.0055103367,
0.0246059652,
-0.0274046846,
0.0807877854,
0.0013171512,
0.0215466619,
0.015390249,
0.0253527332,
-0.0180191901,
0.0474889502,
-0.0871518701,
-0.0172347389,
-0.0030930138,
-0.0251912698,
0.0175264124,
-0.0070882617,
0.0409405828,
-0.019540187,
-0.0005586974,
-0.0311350022,
0.0495519824,
0.0215362608,
0.0092146639,
-0.0426028222,
-0.0104394034,
-0.0429629497,
0.0462601334,
0.0844062716,
0.0286026169,
0.048752185,
0.0277917162,
-0.050846491,
-0.0057502789,
-0.0487313867,
0.0261944849,
0.0041557439,
-0.008385621,
-0.0323866494,
-0.0723956972,
-0.0562311709,
0.0745209381,
-0.0155594833,
0.033650659,
-0.0205172133,
-0.0350973159,
0.05050271,
-0.0171942879,
0.020851098,
-0.0578325056,
0.0156167839,
0.0078180078,
-0.0449866876,
-0.0061170491,
-5.013443733e-33,
0.0150703983,
-0.0611798838,
-0.0096899988,
0.0563404597,
0.0048423242,
0.0130492672,
-0.0111707998,
-0.038233608,
-0.0182466786,
0.0102462769,
-0.0271212514,
0.0276601017,
-0.0110263778,
0.0323744081,
0.0089485226,
0.0156774577,
0.0188435316,
0.0083458554,
-0.0298381951,
0.0435419604,
0.0643767565,
-0.0114283254,
0.0519666374,
-0.0884307995,
0.06090267,
-0.0338504948,
-0.0400425382,
-0.007040171,
-0.0614714324,
0.0307465531,
-0.0045481767,
0.0152275311,
0.023325162,
-0.0036478518,
0.0023888748,
0.0219038576,
-0.0139763998,
-0.0374167077,
-0.0187450685,
-0.0139262574,
0.0281750094,
-0.0800635144,
0.0365260914,
-0.0260239728,
-0.0086028464,
0.0073402957,
0.0574181564,
0.0051382668,
-0.0203368552,
-0.0801385492,
-0.0606293008,
0.0144492649,
-0.0066221496,
0.0071070665,
-0.0052805683,
-0.0103884498,
0.0079120472,
0.0116322841,
-0.0841432735,
-0.0190136191,
-0.0214723349,
-0.0249839537,
0.0056673354,
0.0413560197,
-0.0088976836,
0.0398783423,
0.0129001644,
0.0249328073,
-0.0391803496,
0.0168705583,
0.0360075906,
0.0301264785,
0.0777744874,
0.0786903054,
0.021900557,
-0.0027534259,
-0.0413426273,
0.0290883742,
0.0380454548,
-0.0412576683,
0.0146017252,
-0.0222755596,
-0.0455898531,
-0.0349483639,
-0.0362557583,
-0.0901549235,
-0.0238622054,
-0.0038318238,
-0.0033658154,
-0.033851359,
-0.0179725233,
-0.0040415293,
0.0173535459,
-0.0555087775,
0.0072139129,
0.0060530752,
-0.0459697396,
0.064057909,
0.019435145,
0.0183274355,
-0.01222408,
0.0044302475,
0.0041748541,
-0.0094987247,
0.0470168442,
0.0142039545,
0.1067937538,
0.0365678668,
-0.0520877913,
0.0048751398,
0.0006221282,
0.0337076597,
0.0502682589,
0.019712029,
-0.0176270697,
0.0060700835,
0.0284646805,
0.0022798306,
0.0439998172,
0.0442389138,
-0.0181720946,
0.0161920581,
-0.0102025187,
-0.0273590833,
-0.0226898082,
-0.0225073006,
0.0035864727,
0.025128847,
0.037293043,
-0.0454002395,
0.0205420274,
-0.0185461957,
2.249e-7,
0.0653386265,
0.0214280505,
0.0321172737,
0.0093561998,
0.0332774781,
0.0636069551,
0.0462677218,
0.0327559598,
-0.0219095834,
-0.0192474239,
-0.0121461293,
0.0092142792,
0.0790258273,
0.0183108672,
-0.0300087575,
0.0382197797,
-0.0442741066,
0.0153628197,
-0.0882592127,
0.0207253098,
0.0271730553,
0.0592867061,
0.0536436178,
-0.0619074702,
-0.0286063366,
-0.0823516026,
0.0551794544,
0.0045390232,
0.0102569424,
0.023201054,
0.0413370132,
-0.0218987614,
0.0214962065,
0.0182513967,
-0.0141476812,
0.0196897853,
-0.0304857567,
0.0490084104,
-0.023049159,
0.0054747928,
-0.0037797135,
-0.0601267815,
0.0213291515,
-0.0600563921,
0.0418560095,
0.0539022796,
-0.0186296534,
-0.0224679727,
-0.0011751356,
-0.0253820848,
0.0232948754,
-0.0236900412,
0.0283660907,
0.0249718949,
-0.0034757731,
-0.0243526436,
0.0134732397,
-0.0509761013,
-0.009668895,
-0.0176938344,
-0.018803509,
0.020773109,
-0.029900087,
-0.0051428443,
0.0758824721,
-0.0765490755,
0.0619197376,
2.281558311e-34,
0.0094310325,
-0.0076491358,
-0.0035664635,
0.0138900708,
0.0442236848,
0.0279219262,
0.0028063236,
0.0365945995,
-0.0122811981,
-0.0738679096,
-0.0095827188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07286v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07286v1 | The Devil is in the Errors: Leveraging Large Language Models for Fine-grained Machine Translation Evaluation | 2023-08-14T17:17:21 | 2023-08-14T17:17:21 | Patrick Fernandes, Daniel Deutsch, Mara Finkelstein, Parker Riley, André F. T. Martins, Graham Neubig, Ankush Garg, Jonathan H. Clark, Markus Freitag, Orhan Firat | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Automatic evaluation of machine translation (MT) is a critical tool driving
the rapid iterative development of MT systems. While considerable progress has
been made on estimating a single scalar quality score, current metrics lack the
informativeness of more detailed schemes that annotate individual errors, such
as Multidimensional Quality Metrics (MQM). In this paper, we help fill this gap
by proposing AutoMQM, a prompting technique which leverages the reasoning and
in-context learning capabilities of large language models (LLMs) and asks them
to identify and categorize errors in translations. We start by evaluating
recent LLMs, such as PaLM and PaLM-2, through simple score prediction
prompting, and we study the impact of labeled data through in-context learning
and finetuning. We then evaluate AutoMQM with PaLM-2 models, and we find that
it improves performance compared to just prompting for scores (with
particularly large gains for larger models) while providing interpretability
through error spans that align with human annotations. | [
0.0236354172,
0.0198830049,
0.0000878056,
0.054842338,
-0.0114626251,
0.0382804833,
0.0182833038,
-0.0098676551,
-0.0182919558,
-0.0470650457,
-0.0382083468,
-0.04047589,
0.0397512168,
0.0050564301,
0.036848288,
-0.0296173953,
0.0305804759,
-0.0302686784,
-0.0173199605,
0.0184561852,
-0.004806031,
0.014460599,
0.0226594545,
0.0441749096,
0.005966377,
-0.0222783312,
0.021992432,
0.0375213176,
0.0353877433,
-0.0543928333,
-0.0059468206,
0.0380487032,
-0.0117988121,
0.0788889006,
0.0000021963,
-0.0464110747,
-0.0405917801,
0.0327405371,
0.0011943058,
0.0387826264,
0.0415390991,
-0.0446315445,
-0.0151069332,
0.0096169598,
-0.0154216113,
-0.0213936344,
0.0316232219,
-0.011091223,
0.0704654604,
0.0333755612,
-0.0066870274,
0.0033208278,
-0.0189020988,
-0.0237784274,
-0.0276288018,
-0.0624752417,
-0.0227093454,
0.0256293248,
-0.0151744578,
0.031965699,
-0.0072306367,
0.0493260324,
0.0059893597,
-0.0188553873,
-0.0048847599,
-0.0276046433,
-0.0143449809,
-0.0380304605,
0.007706481,
0.0585908964,
-0.0049941409,
0.0106586572,
-0.0333312415,
-0.0158916861,
-0.0040937816,
-0.0095640756,
-0.0137523757,
-0.0066263955,
-0.0085249655,
-0.0163828526,
0.0219137035,
0.0340162143,
0.041845236,
0.0105596427,
-0.0505837575,
0.0096071837,
0.0161539596,
-0.023601573,
-0.0222129375,
0.0251811929,
-0.0122425789,
-0.0100069623,
0.0185883529,
-0.0034090506,
-0.0500430726,
-0.0013492256,
-0.0191696063,
-0.0254502688,
0.041907426,
-0.0340106562,
0.0706645474,
0.0358582176,
-0.0277232211,
0.0440004617,
-0.0098397005,
0.0594563894,
0.001917881,
0.0172696002,
-0.0637653247,
-0.0067332401,
-0.0107189082,
0.0254978873,
-0.0128971394,
-0.0237053707,
-0.0233353097,
0.0069588246,
-0.0323599167,
0.0156892352,
-0.0156486519,
0.0370516516,
0.0208761357,
-0.0442005955,
-0.0488565564,
-0.0277716368,
-0.0226507392,
0.0553179458,
-0.0206104144,
0.0020201851,
0.0161269736,
-0.0364962593,
-0.0163037255,
0.0222126395,
-0.0260640699,
-0.0183319841,
0.0104519203,
0.0825085416,
0.0162739996,
-0.0363722295,
0.0218348783,
-0.0292060878,
-0.0460207127,
-0.0576261282,
-0.0233356152,
-0.0608849674,
0.0158973709,
0.0210976582,
0.0309540685,
-0.001350094,
0.0034680015,
-0.0042266487,
0.0033732643,
0.0589460209,
-0.0092676729,
0.0048804865,
0.0260055866,
-0.0027635095,
-0.0388182029,
0.0556274205,
0.0617864095,
0.0115389284,
0.0275630243,
0.0065064491,
0.0139493318,
0.0485603884,
-0.0156032117,
0.0440931879,
-0.0143278884,
-0.0174693782,
0.0020073913,
0.0422616564,
-0.0028859871,
0.05900665,
-0.0209317263,
0.0654354766,
0.0523606576,
0.0386289805,
0.0112617407,
0.0198542364,
0.0806566253,
-0.0096773915,
-0.0092254803,
-0.0145977726,
-0.0167547651,
-0.0000799055,
-0.0178888664,
-0.0014969427,
0.0625591427,
0.041494146,
0.0154995769,
-0.0921720713,
-0.0236634947,
-0.0003516252,
-0.0044041332,
-0.017652275,
0.0702321902,
0.0146421278,
-0.0368069932,
0.009754058,
-0.0252600163,
-0.0478424542,
0.0245677084,
-0.0437426977,
0.0016983158,
0.0817651525,
0.0577127375,
-0.0054310197,
-0.0122697549,
-0.015865,
-0.0087181386,
0.0261384752,
0.0697772279,
-0.0131861838,
-0.003071028,
-0.031431336,
-0.0124853598,
0.0176516809,
0.0377918333,
-0.0012470933,
-0.0127429208,
0.0011445136,
0.0383971222,
-0.0526104905,
-0.1142503545,
0.0196619537,
0.000231897,
-0.0384914503,
0.0211342257,
0.0136711616,
0.0332071371,
0.0252259858,
-0.0073849997,
0.0106629031,
0.0150273023,
-0.0266147889,
-0.0171632431,
-0.0123516861,
-0.0155292321,
-0.0267082565,
0.0170543753,
-0.0140642468,
-0.0346606784,
-0.005017214,
-0.0666766316,
-0.0296917763,
-0.0319238864,
-0.033297658,
-0.0448381864,
-0.0274681151,
0.0499751754,
-0.0022694094,
-0.0204590019,
-0.05110199,
0.0183067229,
0.0027376476,
0.0177571401,
0.0216400586,
-0.0145371286,
0.0065067452,
-0.0055458779,
-0.0435955264,
0.0132054742,
0.0005647173,
0.0555102378,
0.0354259461,
0.0469637364,
-0.0390408225,
-0.0268712007,
-0.0810235813,
0.0162656195,
-0.0061669871,
0.0344837569,
0.0223580692,
0.0089945113,
0.0124555733,
0.0052554347,
0.0131620541,
-0.0307852626,
0.0226856694,
0.0058209868,
0.0260099266,
-0.0008629257,
0.018181676,
-0.0364329554,
-0.0012465111,
0.0059257462,
0.0478988066,
0.0338874608,
0.0148882773,
-0.092405878,
0.0154198771,
-0.0381161198,
-0.0280972384,
0.0338070951,
-0.0533865318,
0.0101932678,
-0.0314932391,
-0.0048940363,
0.0577095821,
-0.0125897815,
0.0473858751,
0.0365367346,
-0.0029030028,
-0.0581286065,
-0.0023674271,
-0.0247287918,
-0.0609121509,
0.0006695748,
-0.0549719296,
0.0031823984,
0.0403838716,
0.0012384997,
0.0119281998,
-0.0618832596,
0.0126504079,
-0.0370464288,
0.006376687,
-0.0026559208,
0.0081839096,
0.0129751321,
0.0710427389,
-0.0097448416,
-0.0640581697,
0.0831433758,
-0.0470385477,
0.0120764459,
-0.0474699698,
0.0316866189,
-0.0142256236,
0.0597898066,
-0.0413193069,
0.0225628056,
-0.0299007017,
0.005704008,
-0.0355387218,
0.0159154963,
0.0319694951,
-0.0447612777,
0.0338249579,
-0.0866937637,
-0.0230022985,
0.0010639179,
0.0014001387,
0.0011578663,
0.0021349066,
-0.0647109896,
-0.0173441377,
-0.0019733014,
-0.0128075052,
-0.0060127247,
0.0047462503,
0.0046829903,
0.0363099314,
-0.0101336595,
-0.034806896,
-0.008518626,
0.0066326032,
-0.0241425205,
-0.00749816,
0.0385660306,
-0.0685279816,
0.0611931309,
0.0190495811,
-0.0240999758,
0.0158529375,
-0.0198662858,
-0.016194256,
0.051379215,
0.0241975598,
-0.0379307345,
0.0030028359,
0.0861749575,
-0.0860982016,
-0.0265244562,
0.1161088347,
0.0343468301,
-0.0226929095,
-0.0058878143,
-0.0095210122,
0.0206268206,
0.0221784599,
0.0181329027,
-0.0605654418,
-0.0404086672,
0.0212901626,
0.0688545927,
0.0236892756,
0.0310498904,
0.0121703399,
-0.1086080074,
0.0431016162,
0.0435757227,
-0.0585258231,
-0.0423594005,
-0.0197839811,
-0.0139871491,
-0.0309078339,
0.0234950874,
0.0004267998,
0.0280183479,
0.0087395981,
0.017615892,
0.0054725804,
-0.0934760347,
0.0400274768,
-0.0519773625,
0.0408141948,
0.0785272419,
0.0307465587,
0.0046104151,
-0.0399241745,
0.0345087871,
-0.0242701899,
-0.0111426832,
-0.0170870293,
0.022171665,
-0.0037242316,
-0.0129117649,
0.017857248,
-0.0107541969,
-0.0095104575,
0.0219979864,
-0.0034648115,
0.0912237987,
-0.0056894571,
0.0247658528,
0.0314415991,
-0.0175753031,
-0.0128306812,
0.0504821725,
0.0279913917,
-0.0496237688,
0.0016847267,
-0.0374928378,
-0.0321989991,
-0.0324636325,
-0.0000648723,
0.0180135928,
-0.0554243512,
-0.0402682759,
-0.0818395317,
-0.0506349951,
0.0258481372,
0.0169480368,
0.0179944113,
-0.0159348343,
-0.0130220866,
0.0179625601,
0.0018570255,
0.0560518131,
-0.0124912085,
0.0282588862,
-0.0804096833,
0.0404928699,
0.0166759659,
0.0003546132,
-0.016592076,
0.0465845317,
-0.0655749738,
-0.0574806333,
-0.0343201309,
0.0763331726,
0.0188047495,
0.0110360142,
-0.0508480743,
-0.0488576964,
0.0029045073,
0.0245404802,
-0.0408582278,
-0.0201557875,
0.0497093312,
-0.0040703542,
-0.0309434365,
0.0483778603,
-0.0280992929,
-0.0076953261,
-0.0341715962,
0.0496144481,
-0.02236793,
-0.1009199619,
0.0156108849,
0.0188223161,
0.0561190881,
-0.0562909395,
-0.0575653836,
-0.0190418418,
0.0008977024,
-0.0004195856,
-0.0520990565,
-0.0502494201,
-0.0034710083,
0.0381953269,
-0.0444650948,
-0.0148819266,
0.0201701988,
-0.0079987179,
0.0051942226,
-0.0156253204,
0.009543512,
-0.0132411597,
0.0329826474,
0.0080783768,
0.0050257705,
-0.0320336483,
-0.0199990161,
-0.019636713,
-0.0005218139,
-0.0271610022,
0.0604713261,
0.0153898364,
0.0331442915,
0.0219839085,
0.0507445857,
-0.006609139,
-0.0654463917,
-0.0477756783,
-0.0059612631,
0.0681752041,
0.0047628828,
0.1153818443,
-0.0001348488,
-0.0288557261,
-0.0357176885,
0.0629256591,
0.0137792425,
-0.0122374296,
0.002736382,
0.000854853,
-0.003005103,
0.0120000653,
0.0373142734,
-0.0357342772,
0.0126314741,
-0.025850473,
-0.036447715,
-0.0288373102,
-0.0013393273,
0.0152672473,
-0.0256053768,
-0.0225177221,
-0.0170454103,
-0.0712765977,
-0.0688576549,
0.0238197129,
0.0546436645,
-0.0056362655,
-0.0108137792,
-0.0109092016,
0.0893635377,
-0.0340622626,
0.0417360254,
-0.0562226288,
-0.0316218734,
0.0068632141,
-0.0119999452,
-0.0249118228,
-6.453898184e-33,
-0.0439650565,
-0.046867881,
-0.0129935378,
-0.0366858356,
-0.0049090665,
-0.0128959715,
-0.0393412896,
-0.000375054,
0.0209406633,
0.0291835237,
0.0192380287,
-0.01352912,
0.0125915566,
-0.0198712107,
0.0442476682,
-0.0006197932,
0.0496692769,
0.0183409397,
-0.0473967642,
0.0039751641,
0.0185432769,
-0.0016283285,
0.0663569346,
-0.0700868219,
0.0895409659,
-0.0022376853,
-0.0652747601,
0.0240080077,
-0.0105116721,
0.0470012873,
-0.0027126803,
0.0044265781,
0.0125636384,
-0.0255734492,
-0.0256378986,
-0.02970572,
-0.0782741979,
0.0185637791,
0.0023161788,
0.017560659,
-0.0258344114,
-0.0210670587,
0.0275701862,
-0.0203871019,
-0.0363550261,
-0.010173738,
0.0218846798,
-0.0710535496,
-0.0265306421,
-0.0567524135,
-0.0435423516,
0.0372371301,
-0.0215233117,
-0.0536248572,
0.0181855578,
0.0613494739,
-0.0183001067,
0.0282061994,
-0.0359729528,
-0.0007903579,
0.0023652855,
0.0251432005,
0.091503039,
0.0147578036,
-0.0436722152,
0.017115552,
-0.028485043,
-0.0128317447,
0.0549150631,
-0.0205564778,
0.0468544997,
-0.0086336946,
0.0874136016,
0.0699402317,
0.0208844785,
0.0124848085,
-0.0449041277,
0.0706620514,
-0.0681952611,
0.0147241,
0.016306702,
-0.0096014133,
-0.040043693,
-0.0073835137,
-0.0844114199,
-0.0306470115,
-0.0511332862,
0.0013214077,
0.0018160358,
0.0084931981,
-0.0490073301,
-0.0127695985,
0.0613997132,
-0.0205790289,
0.0059760013,
-0.0212376341,
-0.0427239649,
0.0226484407,
-0.0224575642,
0.0351081043,
0.0056180311,
-0.0111415777,
-0.0072420002,
0.0357538685,
0.0338251181,
-0.0177432131,
0.0643603876,
0.0218061507,
-0.0652359575,
0.0401805453,
-0.0326833427,
-0.0063423403,
-0.0249178708,
0.0198831148,
0.0230355896,
-0.030919062,
-0.0222468302,
0.0692196488,
0.0013512578,
0.0293294918,
-0.0330712385,
0.0230836775,
0.0048593776,
0.002817241,
-0.0443339236,
0.0178730004,
-0.0136133675,
0.0163222812,
0.0393462181,
-0.0304350369,
-0.0261384547,
0.0033216535,
2.831e-7,
0.068707183,
0.0834041908,
-0.0211489573,
-0.0123148197,
-0.0122329583,
0.0611768775,
-0.0196685269,
-0.0062722112,
0.0294545498,
0.0423000678,
0.0571707785,
0.0107134497,
0.1093698069,
0.0486143306,
-0.0386889577,
-0.0112472447,
-0.044509314,
0.0462969951,
-0.0268069766,
0.0053662304,
0.0783658549,
0.0935288072,
-0.0029227019,
0.0100222891,
-0.0011321858,
-0.0521767251,
0.0811100602,
-0.0260711834,
-0.0141854472,
0.0148399007,
0.0601185746,
0.0340205915,
-0.0158879161,
-0.0060085012,
-0.0275147967,
-0.0194019713,
0.0302938595,
0.0696143061,
0.0213202741,
0.0183767937,
0.0044517987,
-0.0157929361,
0.0135925757,
-0.0646604523,
0.0385012627,
-0.0445634164,
-0.0017230973,
-0.0055475086,
0.0084555447,
-0.0049579642,
0.0597599111,
-0.0485278629,
-0.0403442942,
0.0338149592,
0.0263315439,
0.0051034675,
-0.0192281064,
-0.0442674346,
-0.0306091886,
0.0076574539,
0.0191097371,
-0.0617804602,
0.0058302041,
-0.0248572677,
-0.0008750416,
-0.0534362644,
0.0073079676,
2.725869692e-34,
0.0769981891,
-0.0321981534,
0.0152596114,
-0.0108292792,
0.0640862137,
0.0042827418,
-0.0156834126,
-0.012805461,
0.0077678976,
-0.0417894498,
-0.0068534832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07282v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07282v2 | Comparison between parameter-efficient techniques and full fine-tuning: A case study on multilingual news article classification | 2023-08-14T17:12:43 | 2024-04-08T13:01:17 | Olesya Razuvayevskaya, Ben Wu, Joao A. Leite, Freddy Heppell, Ivan Srba, Carolina Scarton, Kalina Bontcheva, Xingyi Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | Adapters and Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) are parameter-efficient fine-tuning
techniques designed to make the training of language models more efficient.
Previous results demonstrated that these methods can even improve performance
on some classification tasks. This paper complements the existing research by
investigating how these techniques influence the classification performance and
computation costs compared to full fine-tuning when applied to multilingual
text classification tasks (genre, framing, and persuasion techniques detection;
with different input lengths, number of predicted classes and classification
difficulty), some of which have limited training data. In addition, we conduct
in-depth analyses of their efficacy across different training scenarios
(training on the original multilingual data; on the translations into English;
and on a subset of English-only data) and different languages. Our findings
provide valuable insights into the applicability of the parameter-efficient
fine-tuning techniques, particularly to complex multilingual and multilabel
classification tasks. | [
0.0515465587,
0.0230178945,
-0.0145905251,
0.0438597128,
0.0037486318,
0.0421661288,
0.025352912,
0.0142734982,
-0.0212390702,
-0.0851177722,
-0.0689881817,
-0.0159496311,
0.0164764896,
-0.0206187349,
-0.0009011086,
-0.0331227109,
0.0439783782,
-0.0374236256,
0.0385914929,
-0.02883045,
-0.0064581204,
0.042084638,
0.0313446037,
0.0074694711,
0.0596530102,
-0.0101856655,
0.0163341053,
0.0122722276,
0.0215742141,
0.0208383501,
0.0262461621,
0.0707488507,
0.0247763805,
0.0624895021,
0.000001727,
-0.0466634594,
-0.0274956208,
-0.020679133,
0.0142682716,
-0.0119412811,
0.0850292891,
-0.0440302044,
-0.0058718212,
0.0463823751,
-0.0006427641,
-0.0124627771,
0.0496775955,
0.0361212157,
0.0063476958,
0.0857712477,
-0.0274802223,
-0.0398815237,
-0.0045308382,
-0.0194560271,
-0.0432949923,
-0.0398164019,
0.037094228,
-0.04238097,
-0.0467341021,
0.037286181,
-0.0204708539,
0.0034527346,
-0.023422176,
0.0181950666,
-0.0677100047,
-0.0094309477,
-0.0491908938,
-0.0039013966,
0.0020115348,
0.0217405837,
-0.0648239106,
-0.05574793,
-0.0114104683,
-0.0052915732,
0.0279048756,
-0.0093538491,
-0.0044724522,
-0.0031932497,
-0.0006785846,
0.0073706009,
0.0662427768,
-0.0152831525,
0.0094930427,
0.030922737,
-0.0209509898,
0.0329409987,
0.0031777606,
-0.0203068405,
0.0634160936,
0.015659567,
0.0105565172,
-0.0273792874,
0.0000452154,
-0.0152737731,
-0.0041545411,
0.0031838343,
-0.0410465896,
-0.0437127315,
0.0156700257,
-0.1079232395,
-0.0093031088,
0.0243331939,
0.0300414898,
0.0430025682,
-0.0591526404,
-0.0255829748,
0.010610912,
0.0155029325,
-0.007630433,
-0.0096799582,
-0.0469539128,
0.0146366954,
-0.0373595543,
0.0123926969,
-0.030393308,
0.00470347,
-0.0475661419,
0.006391915,
0.018227458,
-0.0072190827,
-0.0441510342,
-0.0341926478,
-0.0253951401,
0.0006703452,
0.0130585898,
0.0743452907,
-0.0169708934,
0.0268191844,
-0.0266000982,
-0.0192105845,
0.0186318401,
0.0546041988,
0.0180066302,
-0.0508987606,
0.0592061058,
-0.0164965726,
-0.05188784,
-0.0390632153,
-0.0512618609,
0.0225930214,
-0.0356933773,
-0.0774734542,
0.0006449611,
-0.0583122596,
0.0051937993,
0.025362296,
0.0500511937,
-0.028013939,
-0.029758038,
-0.0131312441,
-0.0534103326,
0.0505527705,
0.0451260991,
-0.0189989079,
0.0505622514,
0.0100462558,
-0.0056612738,
0.134477213,
0.0027599151,
0.0428738333,
0.0307354238,
-0.0609066337,
-0.0114582954,
0.0522913933,
-0.0206356384,
0.0486565717,
0.0080814948,
-0.0077626877,
-0.0047562667,
0.0032891938,
0.0397598334,
-0.0320812836,
0.007228978,
-0.0092744548,
0.0321651213,
-0.007993022,
0.0641447604,
0.0423874557,
0.0083415406,
-0.0183136836,
0.0037701712,
0.0284625944,
0.0025137356,
-0.0052310028,
-0.0451748371,
-0.0229686741,
-0.0069426023,
0.0617108718,
-0.0489156768,
-0.0239134096,
-0.0163205694,
0.0076457486,
0.0287547372,
0.0003110908,
0.0651815161,
0.0118736597,
0.0010225938,
0.022445932,
0.0482424907,
-0.0085457023,
-0.0081232088,
-0.0546779409,
-0.0169546977,
-0.0017841951,
-0.0068226848,
-0.0359210856,
0.0063604638,
-0.042658139,
0.0477037579,
0.0109286448,
0.0926780105,
-0.0022500888,
-0.0032743805,
-0.028887555,
-0.0165811982,
-0.0052652019,
0.0151002547,
0.081786111,
-0.0313800052,
0.05626297,
-0.0066685406,
-0.0351177827,
-0.0819607377,
0.0087071415,
0.011200727,
-0.0377022624,
0.0380234569,
0.0301747173,
0.0321864784,
0.0169598088,
-0.0016014546,
-0.0684437156,
0.0131291067,
-0.0178741626,
0.0090610208,
-0.0054083378,
0.0137085682,
-0.0133689959,
0.0009086527,
0.0038895132,
0.0073220939,
0.0139490161,
-0.0072072204,
-0.0385961421,
0.0308884848,
-0.0023030338,
0.0247418769,
-0.0210733842,
0.00914378,
-0.0762974694,
0.0415451154,
-0.0177475102,
0.0305118617,
0.0443689264,
0.0390459709,
0.0040469323,
-0.0525722131,
0.0383543484,
-0.0047191433,
-0.0337158553,
0.0453079268,
0.0178980026,
0.0195084494,
0.0551871173,
0.0116472961,
-0.0013703337,
-0.0496863015,
-0.1005005315,
-0.005961169,
-0.0492463633,
0.0241340119,
-0.0051816991,
-0.0003478396,
-0.0137919402,
-0.0057091927,
-0.0578988977,
0.0067572026,
-0.0316595323,
0.0506168939,
-0.0101796379,
0.0034377153,
0.0120530901,
0.0020314381,
0.014281773,
0.0065254308,
0.0662241355,
-0.0025245626,
-0.0240696575,
-0.0660426691,
-0.0126696024,
-0.0217477679,
-0.006221896,
-0.0238302443,
-0.0479218997,
-0.0406503566,
0.0245188326,
0.0184475388,
0.055636365,
0.0082574869,
0.0225306675,
0.0689853728,
0.0769261718,
-0.0393432043,
-0.0021310544,
0.000105076,
-0.0318257287,
-0.0844954699,
-0.0216731243,
0.0204759687,
0.0259204805,
0.0008729263,
0.0050078938,
-0.0479984693,
0.0151112769,
0.0154612157,
-0.0122264195,
-0.0202718005,
0.0392257906,
0.0185608901,
0.0113579705,
0.0275170002,
-0.0020047179,
0.0647031218,
-0.0171940271,
0.0027404886,
-0.0738635957,
-0.0599385612,
-0.0284370631,
-0.0137996161,
-0.0181509908,
0.0654146969,
-0.0106558753,
-0.0105875786,
-0.02920237,
-0.0137624247,
0.0419384912,
-0.0077820164,
0.0346214399,
0.0202546548,
-0.0009325427,
-0.0270847753,
-0.0519235469,
0.0085643725,
-0.0551796034,
-0.0002294015,
0.0067199962,
-0.0007030713,
-0.0187511835,
-0.0641334727,
0.0147177735,
0.0199547671,
0.0550405197,
-0.0355894417,
-0.0179368909,
0.0339016318,
0.025285149,
0.0277336668,
0.0136132976,
-0.0149933323,
-0.0311918501,
0.0402990617,
-0.0104189645,
-0.0331331603,
0.0060363431,
-0.0123279272,
-0.0021829004,
0.0523558967,
-0.0238591526,
-0.0101616448,
-0.0181002393,
0.0185972117,
-0.0375218317,
0.0180620253,
0.0789680257,
0.0162477642,
-0.0689462721,
-0.0341086686,
-0.0405956656,
0.0610514097,
0.0416252688,
0.0435192399,
-0.0438317694,
-0.016706042,
0.0039993171,
0.0329090953,
-0.0113050221,
0.0042597717,
-0.0101951519,
-0.0654080585,
0.0332312211,
0.0093923416,
-0.0557658821,
-0.0142299933,
-0.0829014331,
0.0103702024,
-0.0140606537,
-0.0038648793,
-0.0457713902,
-0.0054964032,
-0.0232561976,
0.0157055259,
-0.0372384079,
-0.0604044981,
-0.0055076652,
0.0062138629,
0.0081505263,
-0.010943329,
0.0454526171,
-0.0637904927,
-0.0101419808,
0.0341585055,
-0.0298081674,
0.0012153444,
-0.0515830815,
0.0207463037,
-0.0134343812,
0.0087253097,
0.0619744696,
0.0059380103,
-0.0025556751,
0.0217842851,
0.0241459925,
0.0613848977,
0.0159695614,
-0.0421602912,
0.0205267724,
-0.0387130938,
0.0141822314,
0.0750908479,
0.0137932952,
-0.084174037,
0.0184190683,
-0.0290610064,
-0.0119872084,
-0.0165223498,
0.0013978292,
0.01123429,
-0.0584863834,
-0.0201702435,
-0.0138175329,
-0.0339334533,
0.0276934989,
0.027999809,
0.0163259227,
0.0555560999,
-0.0251387171,
-0.0049925246,
-0.0248567183,
0.0055529131,
-0.0068367133,
-0.0078507494,
-0.0256179441,
-0.0208297838,
0.0442436673,
-0.0649191886,
-0.0150260022,
-0.0353496186,
-0.0170779601,
-0.0543601662,
-0.020111056,
0.0148863839,
0.0127809122,
0.0543848947,
0.0178429987,
-0.0863364786,
0.0299601033,
0.0438529253,
0.0396277234,
0.0259673335,
0.0536145493,
-0.0080931149,
-0.0391784012,
0.0270982999,
-0.0405785032,
0.0271669161,
0.0511822812,
-0.0185101423,
-0.0265932567,
-0.004133495,
-0.0103046168,
-0.0016312677,
0.017738454,
-0.0514628515,
-0.0695791319,
-0.0259528942,
0.0275760684,
0.0121276621,
-0.0303966179,
0.0098484755,
-0.0453890003,
0.04408383,
-0.0120559186,
-0.0331720673,
0.0415152907,
-0.0019376929,
0.0063845473,
-0.0502891839,
0.0541448742,
0.0289799925,
0.0243324414,
0.0171982087,
0.0368494503,
-0.0301739573,
0.0338388309,
0.0575691052,
0.0252722893,
-0.0382743329,
0.0212863758,
0.0157126728,
0.0149117159,
0.0047589228,
0.0213518851,
-0.0060769496,
-0.0122175794,
-0.0239997245,
0.0254214033,
0.0480582565,
-0.0335511304,
0.0472518839,
-0.0110592926,
-0.0493373014,
-0.0140499994,
0.000125941,
0.0152055072,
0.0017294717,
0.0151566723,
0.0079676611,
-0.0315741263,
0.0477831662,
0.0558398142,
0.0096377395,
0.0253217313,
0.0221174229,
-0.0454821661,
-0.0378953926,
0.0239766836,
0.0153613258,
0.0214594025,
0.0046366001,
0.0072055464,
-0.0207481366,
-0.0262411255,
0.021032257,
-0.0484881997,
0.01352455,
-0.010999836,
-0.0073499274,
0.0987613723,
-0.0071547139,
0.0355353095,
-0.0667013451,
-0.0406824425,
0.0186948087,
0.0001604957,
0.028899163,
-6.107338572e-33,
-0.0031825339,
-0.0070231706,
-0.0296241995,
0.0337852985,
0.0385763459,
-0.0040402878,
0.0110304132,
0.0057984516,
-0.0148293171,
0.019989172,
-0.000442387,
-0.0052433251,
0.0025604856,
-0.0018322662,
-0.0144058447,
0.0025883641,
0.0543204136,
0.0131006539,
-0.066017881,
0.0124602392,
0.0592112765,
-0.0029193149,
0.0627810657,
-0.0446802117,
0.0208766218,
0.0178170819,
-0.0415469296,
-0.0236434713,
0.0254595745,
0.0768715665,
0.020903727,
0.0807554722,
0.0434351265,
-0.0274663195,
0.0351615362,
0.0556733347,
-0.0628105551,
-0.0313700065,
0.0372915044,
0.0282724611,
0.0518202037,
-0.0268108565,
0.0366379805,
0.0147433272,
-0.0094337631,
-0.0231084432,
0.0481738038,
-0.0531623363,
-0.0125248889,
-0.0421858542,
-0.0743729994,
0.0128441229,
-0.0015819238,
0.0278993584,
0.0427545458,
0.0594641306,
0.0002280559,
0.0604891777,
-0.0842789412,
-0.0135642616,
-0.0084225815,
0.0327406414,
0.0150309931,
0.0140657509,
-0.0680588633,
0.0112365885,
-0.0131598506,
0.0341237225,
0.0220074393,
-0.0002899647,
0.0613014624,
-0.0148921171,
0.0305502359,
0.0691517293,
0.0205654874,
-0.05264448,
-0.0980782509,
0.0314665549,
0.0371604748,
-0.0451138169,
0.040500205,
-0.0084114438,
-0.0497015901,
-0.0353739113,
-0.0751068145,
-0.027737936,
-0.0495771281,
-0.013221072,
-0.0001347743,
0.0118922191,
-0.0213017482,
-0.0066613485,
0.0385090783,
-0.0309880245,
-0.0343509354,
0.0005627262,
-0.0340007432,
0.0275605414,
0.0178738218,
0.0191671588,
-0.0088531263,
-0.0500806756,
0.0075512668,
-0.0123878,
0.0313916653,
-0.0325714983,
0.1103501841,
0.0230102353,
-0.0833442807,
0.0154483812,
0.0112035479,
0.025012169,
-0.0065077557,
0.0779444799,
-0.0272654016,
-0.0005770459,
0.0171062108,
0.0530491248,
0.0397602729,
-0.0004189941,
-0.0026194197,
-0.0454364307,
-0.0128114242,
0.0332652442,
-0.0445852391,
-0.0221021269,
0.0330403186,
-0.0102026016,
0.0311787818,
-0.0715810433,
-0.0289653596,
-0.0141251115,
2.592e-7,
0.0374283157,
0.0764267519,
-0.0909585804,
-0.0407668613,
0.0237545054,
0.0533596836,
-0.0228557177,
0.0383425318,
0.0218972266,
0.0112208445,
0.0014773562,
-0.0040074913,
0.0423032604,
0.0307771079,
-0.0800326839,
-0.0159230381,
-0.0493959226,
0.0334041081,
-0.0509014167,
0.0116534792,
0.0265907049,
0.0974214226,
0.0038184808,
-0.0220623333,
-0.0083604399,
-0.0303416066,
0.0757252276,
-0.0378202945,
-0.0270598624,
0.0192846265,
0.0423737764,
0.0246173237,
-0.0066308524,
-0.0000336086,
-0.0352001302,
0.0523109585,
-0.0108208302,
0.0431343168,
-0.0258285236,
0.0111081395,
0.0442739651,
0.009822729,
-0.0162883885,
-0.0785714313,
0.076037243,
-0.0418727808,
-0.0299270116,
-0.0384930447,
-0.0038898338,
-0.003848996,
0.0545716621,
-0.0495169125,
-0.0130213294,
0.0198401585,
0.0208250638,
-0.0058146543,
-0.0262704976,
-0.0603067987,
0.014789761,
0.043318104,
0.0020738645,
-0.0388377272,
-0.0026490386,
-0.0194021948,
0.0288982335,
-0.0840386152,
0.0421669409,
2.149010762e-34,
0.0588563308,
-0.0023900855,
-0.0130784353,
-0.0278091636,
0.0120141394,
-0.0133948829,
0.003983554,
-0.0033240886,
0.0177505072,
-0.086191766,
0.0075523145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07272v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07272v2 | Dialogue for Prompting: a Policy-Gradient-Based Discrete Prompt Generation for Few-shot Learning | 2023-08-14T16:58:50 | 2024-01-16T03:22:15 | Chengzhengxu Li, Xiaoming Liu, Yichen Wang, Duyi Li, Yu Lan, Chao Shen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Prompt-based pre-trained language models (PLMs) paradigm have succeeded
substantially in few-shot natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However,
prior discrete prompt optimization methods require expert knowledge to design
the base prompt set and identify high-quality prompts, which is costly,
inefficient, and subjective. Meanwhile, existing continuous prompt optimization
methods improve the performance by learning the ideal prompts through the
gradient information of PLMs, whose high computational cost, and low
readability and generalizability are often concerning. To address the research
gap, we propose a Dialogue-comprised Policy-gradient-based Discrete Prompt
Optimization ($DP_2O$) method. We first design a multi-round dialogue alignment
strategy for readability prompt set generation based on GPT-4. Furthermore, we
propose an efficient prompt screening metric to identify high-quality prompts
with linear complexity. Finally, we construct a reinforcement learning (RL)
framework based on policy gradients to match the prompts to inputs optimally.
By training a policy network with only 0.67% of the PLM parameter size on the
tasks in the few-shot setting, $DP_2O$ outperforms the state-of-the-art (SOTA)
method by 1.52% in accuracy on average on four open-source datasets. Moreover,
subsequent experiments also demonstrate that $DP_2O$ has good universality,
robustness, and generalization ability. | [
0.0441742092,
0.0156885833,
0.0083746631,
0.0157971289,
-0.0474228226,
0.004466665,
0.0604518019,
-0.0266472772,
0.0438360423,
-0.0106662186,
-0.044553306,
-0.0470589958,
0.0081339246,
0.0076847346,
0.0173491854,
-0.0518272966,
0.0748602971,
-0.0114608258,
0.0529917926,
0.0045304224,
0.0008723338,
0.0040700259,
-0.0482277535,
0.0526403747,
-0.0051972386,
-0.0388461761,
-0.0213784594,
0.0091518573,
0.0270473324,
-0.0458903238,
0.0229885466,
0.0598199405,
-0.0011926824,
0.0293148756,
0.0000020208,
-0.0577820875,
-0.0160361007,
-0.0161593258,
-0.0417180955,
-0.0309156869,
0.0089230593,
-0.0069036447,
0.0007498327,
0.0162111986,
-0.0138231367,
-0.0252018906,
0.0376137011,
0.0487491824,
0.0608140416,
0.0888212696,
0.0083512068,
-0.0416525789,
0.0232583247,
-0.032011427,
0.0377013348,
-0.0408254638,
-0.0203099009,
-0.0549004674,
0.0167738181,
0.0308365952,
-0.0229510926,
0.0409526303,
-0.0068097082,
-0.0117296297,
-0.007556838,
0.0466442034,
0.0133206546,
-0.0397697017,
-0.0724988431,
0.1067809537,
0.0060320836,
0.0125172818,
0.0135482214,
-0.0553747527,
0.0183356721,
-0.0382293426,
0.0000851367,
0.0078440458,
0.0014216334,
0.014123898,
-0.0126511808,
0.0182369594,
0.0001209352,
-0.0047199982,
0.0020997464,
0.0306046437,
-0.0003207492,
-0.0514857695,
0.0251645893,
-0.0211556982,
-0.0057475301,
-0.0377105549,
0.0063803256,
0.0245484449,
-0.0929704532,
0.0251924228,
-0.0546347238,
0.0209850911,
0.0206265282,
0.0549353026,
0.0634102896,
0.080404669,
-0.019917788,
0.0533845462,
-0.008769582,
0.0841857865,
-0.0076148566,
0.0256353617,
-0.0071028182,
0.0200077537,
-0.0283037834,
-0.0077435402,
-0.0584061332,
0.0366369709,
-0.0263609663,
-0.0578060932,
-0.0336004458,
0.0228937864,
0.0124145439,
0.0294132065,
0.0269443374,
-0.0109167174,
-0.0258759502,
-0.0166394524,
-0.0531100631,
0.0407034568,
-0.0523422323,
0.0196202695,
0.0424227566,
-0.0378241539,
-0.0324149914,
0.0059125172,
0.0235520247,
-0.0215675719,
-0.0065041943,
0.0554993786,
-0.0282680765,
-0.0578897074,
-0.0256264582,
-0.0043402207,
-0.0140413074,
-0.0499420278,
-0.0496672243,
-0.0275481809,
0.0460518561,
-0.0400216542,
0.0043047201,
-0.0234510023,
0.0042741266,
0.0222089831,
-0.0135731045,
0.086017698,
-0.0323241875,
0.0133255506,
0.0365489945,
-0.0219931342,
-0.0252080578,
0.0354652107,
0.0166382473,
-0.0022627562,
0.0422885232,
0.0036157789,
0.0070003909,
0.0292316359,
0.0230614115,
-0.0181429349,
0.028752137,
0.0056132153,
0.0035116666,
0.0644505173,
0.0282120798,
0.0350468047,
-0.0383177623,
0.0003563893,
0.0543948337,
0.0626217425,
-0.0067412774,
-0.0384517312,
0.0573111773,
0.0661435723,
-0.0108208479,
0.0050190217,
-0.0412700251,
0.0075098658,
-0.0083097182,
0.0166745503,
0.0627096742,
-0.0175824668,
-0.0408148207,
-0.0381761864,
0.0536234565,
0.0058172075,
-0.0038738367,
0.0110035334,
-0.0138359675,
0.0041547935,
-0.1089792475,
0.0046379771,
-0.0086191483,
-0.0154826734,
-0.0236831121,
-0.0250291619,
0.0713829398,
0.0726890936,
0.0220130682,
-0.0247901808,
-0.041554749,
-0.0377433561,
0.0428571478,
0.0540974513,
0.0415889099,
-0.0022166681,
0.0470703915,
-0.0607520714,
-0.0297405478,
0.0091961129,
-0.0021044242,
0.0451454669,
0.0020574108,
0.0137288971,
0.0134294834,
0.0704010054,
-0.0224880595,
0.0320645198,
0.0059495373,
-0.0613625385,
0.0581534654,
0.0232121423,
0.0355087668,
0.0250637159,
-0.0100090094,
-0.004013313,
-0.0082067,
0.0019103559,
0.0468398519,
-0.0253157429,
-0.0725420862,
-0.0838916674,
0.0041527296,
0.0055330535,
-0.0227572061,
-0.0050012507,
-0.0580774806,
-0.053018827,
-0.0585735887,
-0.0230088048,
-0.0135923289,
-0.0466119498,
0.0127502037,
0.0262392815,
-0.0020922674,
-0.0576955155,
0.0346861705,
0.0073043825,
0.0249766931,
0.0585043915,
0.0601669438,
0.0290911645,
-0.083671473,
-0.0251883753,
-0.0109202191,
-0.017186068,
0.0006242641,
0.0477915481,
0.065234378,
-0.0677729473,
-0.0067486316,
-0.0713817775,
0.0282267835,
-0.0125889713,
-0.0008980305,
-0.0056749089,
0.0077393753,
-0.0484740399,
-0.0475169122,
-0.0361522399,
-0.0003153365,
0.0052780653,
-0.0030793136,
0.0603878945,
0.0234954599,
-0.0114524271,
-0.0448116772,
0.002174736,
0.0060194107,
-0.0050122701,
-0.0021580262,
-0.0114926873,
-0.0459196121,
0.0154098282,
0.0132451123,
0.0044653206,
0.0028373543,
-0.0127310781,
0.0322136357,
0.0134860594,
0.0436794981,
0.0791342258,
0.0187344551,
0.0006842208,
-0.0110084293,
0.006708758,
-0.0670215711,
0.0425168872,
-0.0596916266,
-0.0438815057,
0.0089273881,
0.0078175589,
0.0496171415,
0.0540883802,
0.0431824848,
0.0318302177,
-0.0720579848,
0.0145748854,
0.0152953155,
-0.018735826,
-0.0560424142,
0.0141692273,
-0.0566444881,
0.0362332202,
-0.0232734215,
-0.0337529257,
0.0780933872,
-0.0425789952,
-0.0050192098,
-0.0498554744,
0.002455499,
0.0041669966,
0.0088660149,
0.0029822364,
-0.0030550337,
0.024976436,
-0.066664651,
-0.0492368303,
-0.0157916248,
0.0284674708,
-0.0057911067,
0.0072701727,
-0.0084273387,
0.0093829986,
-0.0191108752,
-0.0364513025,
-0.0561728291,
-0.084470585,
-0.0058143856,
-0.0063142478,
-0.0245711934,
0.0172230452,
0.0079146652,
-0.0047153309,
0.0182650127,
0.094046101,
-0.024824312,
0.0065902928,
-0.0550672114,
0.0424771234,
0.0148446383,
0.0219078436,
-0.0144913578,
0.0020500848,
0.0814125985,
-0.0215046369,
-0.0026761272,
0.0033086534,
0.0013601638,
0.0050025838,
0.0254862774,
-0.0354745127,
-0.0032130778,
0.0480338112,
0.0809902847,
-0.0596070103,
-0.0057186149,
0.1245845035,
0.0250341408,
-0.0482384823,
-0.0271854773,
0.0387500823,
0.0164838172,
0.0094972225,
0.0259357151,
-0.0728499442,
-0.050961934,
-0.0126133272,
0.0386965871,
-0.0362331308,
-0.0192257036,
-0.0338525139,
-0.1308230162,
0.0215322506,
-0.006187127,
-0.0114057204,
-0.0072262194,
-0.0219254903,
-0.0021741579,
-0.0007859231,
0.040021006,
0.0082788402,
0.0063146362,
-0.0082871579,
-0.0045939256,
0.0066241482,
-0.0481071249,
-0.0079551451,
-0.0086908741,
0.0595737733,
0.0996517092,
0.0192705244,
0.025590485,
-0.0017183999,
0.047894977,
-0.0124648316,
0.0131198522,
-0.0139144612,
-0.0036871419,
-0.030038422,
-0.0187921152,
-0.0080511076,
0.0552035496,
0.0065620481,
-0.0205846857,
0.0250979755,
0.0367669053,
-0.0251223389,
0.0141226286,
-0.003228242,
0.0286210682,
0.0624793582,
0.0805869848,
0.0296883918,
-0.0519953966,
-0.0212829132,
-0.0010479115,
0.0038083142,
-0.056747295,
-0.0017516174,
-0.0131143769,
0.0028072093,
0.0142617635,
-0.0511539206,
-0.0517333634,
0.0294454154,
0.0011338602,
-0.0076395916,
-0.0122067938,
-0.0087948991,
0.0280611664,
-0.0033677027,
-0.005293821,
-0.0087247705,
0.005351929,
-0.1178938746,
-0.013650191,
0.0203228462,
-0.0241607334,
-0.023005642,
-0.002005541,
-0.0672826841,
-0.04497182,
-0.0525761656,
0.0690022036,
0.0010411351,
0.039235834,
-0.0167535227,
-0.0342562683,
0.0670751259,
0.0595560223,
-0.0340690091,
-0.0160327405,
0.0041500828,
0.0462149829,
-0.0268340893,
0.0205680765,
-0.00079188,
0.019329166,
0.0163805801,
0.0384960845,
-0.004868737,
-0.0484075807,
0.018481778,
0.0075996956,
0.0746569708,
-0.0258973315,
-0.0262494124,
-0.0505191572,
0.0243061129,
0.0009344217,
-0.0066721844,
-0.0404286012,
-0.004953335,
0.0133526484,
-0.057850305,
-0.0062177274,
-0.0219189581,
-0.0254305359,
0.0382073559,
-0.0351178646,
-0.0014063895,
0.0101784403,
0.0057705166,
0.0029090506,
-0.0024896953,
-0.0405644327,
0.0670345277,
0.0044686655,
0.0116880229,
0.0098444838,
0.1151196435,
0.032286454,
0.0037655134,
0.015725974,
0.0444416367,
-0.0320386738,
-0.0418449976,
-0.0115935514,
0.0438878573,
0.024861319,
0.0072439769,
-0.0188213307,
-0.0043513519,
0.00347587,
-0.0299511924,
0.0411394835,
0.0124560297,
-0.0209541991,
0.0462379307,
0.0152209597,
-0.0134455832,
-0.0138575286,
0.0856433287,
-0.0242694765,
0.003304142,
0.0166174453,
0.0436803848,
-0.0621957071,
-0.0064137904,
-0.0075577125,
0.0525889993,
-0.0242001116,
0.0308281202,
-0.021090636,
-0.0077744992,
-0.022585053,
0.0095990663,
-0.0255065616,
0.0247704163,
0.0513716862,
0.0170839094,
-0.041539941,
-0.0048295842,
-0.0278043505,
-0.0056494474,
-0.0155013017,
-0.0415719338,
-0.0277085826,
-5.885764132e-33,
-0.0527134798,
-0.0261875894,
0.0223732851,
-0.0169353429,
-0.03366182,
-0.0063001057,
-0.0368782319,
-0.0158009939,
-0.0111313434,
-0.0068229674,
-0.0409632437,
-0.0130935349,
0.0223931372,
0.0381991751,
-0.0088962503,
-0.0220478904,
0.0536159761,
-0.0165707842,
-0.0559157319,
0.0214843825,
0.010257001,
0.0335425958,
0.0135439578,
-0.0043944824,
0.0321122892,
0.0188792832,
-0.0287957285,
0.025672324,
0.0260285586,
0.0454887338,
-0.0120851081,
0.0152409701,
0.0100521101,
-0.0617488883,
-0.0121465372,
0.0825736374,
-0.073778823,
-0.0580961779,
0.0138270985,
0.0066781002,
-0.0345698781,
-0.0456210896,
-0.017808035,
-0.0463331714,
-0.0063501024,
0.0026320871,
0.0101235993,
-0.0105261663,
-0.0126945246,
-0.0263796672,
-0.0382733531,
0.0057880478,
-0.0135598602,
-0.046888493,
0.0245125499,
0.0567995235,
-0.0137104196,
0.0359150842,
-0.0282778833,
0.0257260837,
0.001265039,
0.0270614196,
0.0120813036,
0.0175424535,
0.0049765892,
0.040135622,
0.0325262398,
-0.0287768487,
-0.0055113742,
0.0023166467,
0.0041478733,
-0.0063996674,
0.0059655425,
0.0713189021,
0.0274196528,
-0.0005744553,
-0.0491469726,
0.0267271753,
0.0211108439,
0.0026615919,
0.0258427504,
-0.0181339476,
-0.0160354953,
-0.0119928746,
-0.051069323,
-0.023604013,
-0.0325766057,
-0.019471284,
0.040589869,
0.0167905092,
0.0060401391,
-0.0158351529,
0.0661079586,
-0.0163345486,
-0.000813051,
0.0198189542,
-0.0088500651,
-0.0105835218,
-0.0090819886,
0.0061176349,
-0.0782407597,
-0.0368762165,
0.0202437136,
-0.0017729561,
-0.0006358121,
0.0243394338,
0.0094424551,
0.0051049064,
-0.0730809644,
0.0098426146,
0.0044806823,
0.0552586019,
-0.0366647877,
0.052269496,
0.0270112474,
-0.0084749823,
-0.0242640339,
0.0718629807,
-0.012253033,
-0.0379033722,
-0.001667003,
-0.0108125107,
-0.0199686214,
0.0384963416,
-0.0448602326,
0.0125520257,
0.0126720471,
0.0273138545,
-0.007212325,
-0.0308370497,
-0.0061480389,
0.0210506245,
2.662e-7,
-0.0408945791,
0.0327203274,
0.0327194259,
0.0307871476,
0.0077532991,
0.0310891699,
0.0008425732,
0.04821584,
-0.0208707955,
-0.0409750566,
0.049495995,
-0.0232584048,
0.0404087529,
-0.0201544371,
-0.1152859107,
0.0039271154,
-0.0591484457,
0.0335390307,
-0.0835197046,
0.0172748994,
0.0994665921,
0.0748444721,
0.0008575358,
0.0026141934,
0.0144646959,
0.0108017093,
0.0264889318,
-0.0403446294,
0.004500858,
0.01658988,
0.0502915345,
-0.003635905,
-0.0150851235,
0.0407495908,
-0.0134773729,
0.0346290022,
-0.0151231,
0.0739046782,
0.0335562974,
-0.0593413785,
0.00477139,
0.0159927625,
-0.0009550513,
-0.0463762768,
0.0650162473,
-0.0547378957,
-0.0057783402,
0.0089366278,
-0.0231257938,
-0.0402159505,
0.0363434181,
-0.0505691618,
-0.0338209979,
0.0082218535,
0.039960023,
0.0103694145,
0.0071699857,
-0.0816582739,
0.0061818552,
-0.0358769298,
-0.0097350115,
-0.01301286,
-0.0464889407,
-0.0157063864,
0.0257549565,
-0.0695237368,
0.0093812253,
2.126598998e-34,
0.0181659237,
-0.0420542434,
0.0404791832,
0.0021931974,
-0.0173793118,
0.0307214577,
0.0089362785,
-0.0102814091,
0.0507589951,
-0.0702781305,
-0.0332432836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07269v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07269v3 | EasyEdit: An Easy-to-use Knowledge Editing Framework for Large Language Models | 2023-08-14T16:52:42 | 2024-06-24T02:17:57 | Peng Wang, Ningyu Zhang, Bozhong Tian, Zekun Xi, Yunzhi Yao, Ziwen Xu, Mengru Wang, Shengyu Mao, Xiaohan Wang, Siyuan Cheng, Kangwei Liu, Yuansheng Ni, Guozhou Zheng, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.IR, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) usually suffer from knowledge cutoff or fallacy
issues, which means they are unaware of unseen events or generate text with
incorrect facts owing to outdated/noisy data. To this end, many knowledge
editing approaches for LLMs have emerged -- aiming to subtly inject/edit
updated knowledge or adjust undesired behavior while minimizing the impact on
unrelated inputs. Nevertheless, due to significant differences among various
knowledge editing methods and the variations in task setups, there is no
standard implementation framework available for the community, which hinders
practitioners from applying knowledge editing to applications. To address these
issues, we propose EasyEdit, an easy-to-use knowledge editing framework for
LLMs. It supports various cutting-edge knowledge editing approaches and can be
readily applied to many well-known LLMs such as T5, GPT-J, LlaMA, etc.
Empirically, we report the knowledge editing results on LlaMA-2 with EasyEdit,
demonstrating that knowledge editing surpasses traditional fine-tuning in terms
of reliability and generalization. We have released the source code on GitHub,
along with Google Colab tutorials and comprehensive documentation for beginners
to get started. Besides, we present an online system for real-time knowledge
editing, and a demo video. | [
0.0465291366,
0.0340935104,
-0.0335888043,
0.0490328297,
-0.062716119,
-0.010082948,
-0.0003076938,
-0.0032844369,
0.0049102111,
-0.0595633723,
-0.013458183,
-0.0008230102,
0.0228097066,
0.0418301225,
0.0298977047,
-0.0633894056,
0.0739406496,
-0.0323205628,
0.0141994879,
0.0053509371,
0.0393829085,
0.008183565,
-0.0161397941,
0.0204489268,
0.0222218353,
-0.0321481749,
-0.0172202177,
-0.0137744378,
0.0031898047,
0.0126746725,
-0.002052854,
0.0808003247,
-0.0063366978,
0.0434017032,
0.0000023147,
-0.0618664399,
-0.0434148088,
0.0002283478,
-0.0202409178,
0.0669546202,
0.0239706784,
-0.0114832763,
-0.0463157557,
0.0268009789,
-0.0193236787,
0.0302776694,
0.0640849769,
0.0200967472,
0.0748060122,
0.0630723163,
0.000453131,
0.0166599564,
0.0268234611,
-0.0373404026,
0.0028568543,
-0.0190055519,
0.0519922115,
-0.0021123395,
-0.0276786946,
0.0048499424,
-0.0052652396,
0.0476337001,
0.005074373,
-0.0465757288,
0.0094025005,
0.005769413,
-0.0550054684,
-0.0312137511,
0.0010660104,
0.0368723832,
0.0226279423,
-0.0407224335,
-0.002408867,
-0.0142125515,
0.0158767775,
0.0360617936,
-0.047283981,
-0.0014433238,
0.0191048812,
0.0096422099,
0.0119967945,
-0.1089494675,
0.0250917934,
0.0267672744,
0.0166080724,
0.0677168071,
0.0459011756,
-0.013161933,
-0.0394994132,
-0.0181255881,
-0.0032916081,
-0.1056518331,
0.00516618,
0.0522068255,
-0.0125237303,
0.0249014217,
-0.0448245779,
-0.0175068211,
0.0248658061,
-0.0700201616,
0.0269925464,
0.0420242883,
-0.0174902249,
0.0490631312,
0.0113908807,
0.0373871028,
0.02456435,
0.0104821203,
0.0015491621,
0.0074301115,
-0.0146729024,
-0.0199566353,
-0.0351098068,
-0.0010985791,
-0.0411718003,
0.0294052027,
-0.0442708954,
0.0224737804,
-0.0159096997,
0.0283069126,
0.0043707225,
-0.0125904549,
-0.0140518174,
-0.0247778296,
-0.0383455269,
0.0484570153,
-0.0023044581,
0.0155627877,
-0.0054463693,
-0.041124925,
0.0053257812,
-0.0177202839,
-0.0118683353,
0.0075130127,
-0.0092078988,
0.0309485868,
-0.0174135864,
-0.0140866218,
-0.0549787953,
-0.0386736356,
-0.0245670564,
-0.0633192956,
-0.0311600808,
-0.0897263214,
0.0142644439,
-0.0025649294,
-0.0186939966,
-0.08099626,
0.0133445421,
0.0147040132,
-0.0380136557,
0.0643945709,
-0.0543649197,
0.0276611727,
0.0615111031,
0.0313868634,
-0.0315262191,
0.0772950575,
0.0375432186,
-0.0038980485,
0.0689318329,
0.0168036167,
-0.0026595502,
0.0602734536,
0.0061134356,
0.0167048052,
-0.0324650779,
0.0018756046,
-0.0251503326,
0.0253984556,
-0.0047784597,
0.0182890166,
-0.0065613738,
0.0278701726,
0.1057356596,
-0.0103097539,
0.0277036708,
0.0299404357,
0.0017040692,
-0.0127049023,
0.0212539844,
-0.0296979789,
-0.0614763647,
0.0351700708,
-0.024707783,
0.0043453951,
-0.0142723024,
0.0502790064,
0.0151718715,
-0.0183250289,
-0.0186818335,
0.0054303422,
-0.0016408722,
0.0019322111,
0.053705845,
0.006333305,
-0.0107350973,
0.0689314306,
0.0442343727,
-0.0244046133,
0.017161116,
-0.0466671288,
0.0290175658,
0.0690187439,
0.0695658922,
-0.0518289991,
-0.0474319272,
-0.0068519884,
-0.0089889802,
0.0266210437,
0.0648915917,
-0.0220234878,
-0.0444340669,
-0.0304442812,
-0.0112202,
-0.0262533501,
0.0376491249,
-0.010462231,
0.0487051569,
0.0192030519,
0.0175401159,
-0.0226295646,
-0.0039638486,
0.0016235089,
-0.0319442078,
-0.0036155633,
-0.0418831594,
-0.011096458,
0.0034681919,
-0.0011821465,
-0.008398178,
-0.0103773912,
0.0055185664,
0.028509127,
-0.0114906337,
0.0001205449,
-0.0049090162,
-0.0083049117,
0.0806230307,
0.0039628828,
-0.0176931098,
0.0193040334,
-0.0318323486,
-0.0182026625,
-0.0046242522,
-0.0231433529,
0.0667894259,
-0.0411872678,
0.0428028554,
-0.0258337036,
-0.0163978711,
-0.0057140505,
0.0506050773,
0.0022822942,
-0.0222734585,
0.0361221954,
-0.0308391694,
-0.0249728505,
0.0016827574,
-0.0139578087,
0.0349472277,
0.0246212892,
-0.0195118692,
-0.0095926384,
0.0041521708,
-0.035834197,
0.0062914076,
-0.0952030718,
0.0144081349,
-0.0219384003,
0.0230294149,
0.0418524258,
0.0334340259,
-0.036279276,
0.0149410293,
-0.0019587404,
0.0230248161,
-0.0019917961,
0.036500331,
0.0089933053,
0.0110133216,
-0.0093104942,
-0.0529848002,
0.0326146632,
0.0048318594,
0.0101750549,
0.0244651753,
-0.0502577983,
-0.0498228334,
0.0595889539,
-0.066646859,
0.0200771019,
0.0104462355,
-0.0411773361,
-0.0236591585,
0.0128323669,
0.0709666535,
0.0182237253,
-0.0309469141,
0.0456141382,
0.0822089761,
-0.0543807596,
-0.022799354,
0.0014236508,
0.006327746,
-0.0141176581,
-0.0276869144,
-0.0238386188,
-0.0316592939,
0.0592388734,
0.0310753305,
-0.0233580153,
-0.0267033633,
0.0364980288,
-0.0346636586,
-0.0144156506,
-0.0175665524,
-0.0179458577,
-0.0523274243,
0.0299436972,
-0.0487406887,
-0.0625875145,
0.0646536946,
-0.0401005708,
0.0285283122,
-0.0319429934,
-0.0127660111,
-0.0237962343,
0.0595530793,
0.0025919173,
0.02119077,
-0.013442874,
0.0177994538,
-0.0656851381,
-0.009164907,
0.0363177434,
-0.0416282751,
0.0506526008,
-0.1178114563,
-0.0112049002,
-0.0193025619,
-0.0168915614,
-0.0174350478,
0.0063506016,
-0.0563129932,
0.0147601636,
0.0313765109,
-0.0496121198,
0.0033341723,
-0.0088497242,
0.0550762601,
0.0742525607,
-0.018416753,
0.0037062617,
-0.0145505453,
-0.0004180665,
0.061427258,
0.0195967741,
0.018491637,
-0.011414269,
0.0155186951,
0.0668252856,
0.0111049432,
-0.0452182852,
-0.0039603952,
-0.0375336483,
-0.0003506281,
-0.0872550681,
-0.0216222964,
-0.0083799604,
0.0500380844,
-0.0758439153,
-0.0048332145,
0.1246632487,
0.0375005603,
-0.0420843624,
0.0105919652,
-0.0524016097,
0.0005564828,
0.0378108062,
0.0404159725,
-0.1034199819,
-0.0312704258,
0.0371594764,
0.0231008381,
-0.0126539683,
-0.0399690568,
-0.0257128477,
-0.0910424665,
0.0316536129,
0.0077358605,
-0.0256489273,
-0.0353184529,
-0.0337601677,
0.0322269686,
0.0203926433,
0.0167134237,
0.0228685066,
-0.0101614827,
0.0024561009,
-0.0324619077,
-0.03679014,
-0.0550796986,
0.0117517598,
-0.025300635,
0.0987016037,
0.0386337228,
0.0199357495,
0.0083565488,
0.0022023013,
0.0415011607,
0.0283709876,
-0.0144386999,
-0.0294658132,
0.0243653227,
0.0153346192,
0.0074332207,
-0.0199128576,
0.025933424,
0.0266126283,
-0.0440937392,
0.0334700383,
0.1144431606,
-0.0109730596,
0.0024156389,
0.0080411639,
-0.0384708419,
-0.0071759853,
0.0712532848,
0.0354340188,
-0.0112965871,
-0.0043441132,
-0.0652141199,
-0.0345478691,
-0.0066831918,
-0.0276160054,
-0.0108565213,
-0.0235790666,
-0.0160657912,
-0.0731379539,
-0.037037313,
0.0708592162,
-0.0211547036,
0.0553959683,
0.0232160073,
0.0290918835,
-0.0130729424,
-0.0301316399,
-0.0125549017,
-0.0641823933,
0.0276575685,
-0.0271273777,
-0.0283353608,
0.0289595518,
-0.0243484527,
-0.0109002059,
0.0263982918,
-0.0571250357,
-0.085653916,
0.0049704984,
0.0263688453,
0.0329623334,
0.0597669333,
-0.0130974669,
-0.0747506917,
0.0363647304,
0.0264305528,
-0.0399711691,
0.0449652821,
-0.0214803889,
-0.0035378586,
0.0105346795,
0.0482091196,
-0.06107134,
-0.0295566097,
0.0052331416,
0.0168186743,
-0.035249453,
-0.0456712805,
0.00427823,
0.0174362846,
0.0125787873,
-0.0037248731,
-0.0113162342,
-0.0617403984,
0.0493904985,
-0.0384458341,
-0.0177392941,
-0.0116802547,
0.0279140975,
0.0028129534,
-0.0105485097,
-0.0037948948,
0.0141763268,
-0.0167593621,
0.0127621377,
-0.0230006129,
0.0083188666,
0.010761817,
0.0154186804,
0.0653794259,
0.0057139611,
-0.0094679724,
0.0262575671,
-0.0223923847,
0.0132499915,
-0.0360322744,
0.0574275032,
-0.0020007899,
-0.0492162928,
-0.0268979818,
0.0064445273,
-0.023522893,
-0.0506762043,
-0.0180231333,
0.0580773577,
0.0692200959,
0.0151933199,
0.0674540401,
-0.0619650632,
-0.0349863805,
-0.0186255723,
0.0291787051,
0.0127283819,
-0.0141787846,
0.0076172976,
-0.0045818444,
-0.0117742075,
0.0378894247,
0.0576296821,
-0.0076317736,
0.1035407633,
-0.0097144814,
-0.0516565517,
-0.0317316093,
-0.0394110382,
-0.0011365466,
-0.0031709038,
-0.0512365811,
-0.0366815701,
-0.0589428768,
-0.0548179336,
0.0070147058,
0.0096160816,
-0.0468204394,
-0.0165007357,
0.0104837297,
0.0516962707,
-0.0049866154,
0.0004984285,
-0.0364165418,
0.0273885243,
-0.0175428148,
-0.0055605834,
0.024785256,
-6.569303077e-33,
-0.0252579655,
-0.0360965431,
0.0181110278,
0.0097138425,
-0.0169678889,
-0.0248333905,
-0.0478507802,
0.0059004738,
0.01217023,
0.0197696816,
-0.0143952779,
0.0139175737,
0.0126257706,
-0.015485038,
-0.0069302125,
0.0061329943,
0.0628613234,
0.0110837435,
-0.019670682,
0.0364955924,
0.0331782736,
0.0240946878,
0.0861867368,
-0.0522074923,
0.0654821694,
0.0210646372,
-0.0269840658,
0.0277523715,
-0.0613836795,
0.0529049188,
-0.0163593739,
0.0341081917,
0.0114570856,
-0.0425289795,
-0.0170155484,
-0.0122020226,
-0.0354697816,
-0.0110309813,
0.0537655093,
0.0410585962,
-0.002152785,
-0.0572147928,
0.0518349819,
0.0113273077,
-0.0160759389,
0.0252693538,
0.0298048779,
-0.0414606258,
0.0091867596,
0.0098898001,
-0.0695167929,
0.026309045,
0.0053175418,
-0.0169635061,
-0.0254792497,
-0.0187400132,
0.0272571314,
-0.008758652,
-0.0846118331,
0.008642504,
0.0534864217,
0.0436310992,
0.0854194686,
-0.0261007063,
-0.0214021038,
0.0405640565,
-0.0331857838,
-0.0218281988,
-0.020725118,
0.0032898171,
0.0135975834,
0.0346359722,
0.036548093,
0.0654667616,
-0.0109001119,
-0.034979362,
-0.0647482648,
-0.0025731644,
-0.0008175068,
0.0411086529,
-0.0032461518,
0.0309113283,
-0.0054317936,
0.0035703955,
-0.0338003375,
-0.0055819824,
-0.0457695536,
-0.0354861133,
0.0285351053,
0.0111012226,
-0.0147059001,
0.0005049547,
-0.0003617478,
-0.0114327576,
-0.017798461,
0.0193550456,
-0.0213947576,
0.0446975753,
-0.0037586619,
0.0112610366,
-0.0567187369,
0.0396264642,
-0.0015457905,
-0.007118817,
0.0038829059,
0.0227154847,
0.008192515,
0.037902873,
-0.0698807389,
0.0379468538,
-0.0369428694,
0.0176142417,
0.0131041734,
-0.0134514403,
-0.0037906414,
-0.0133168241,
0.0005934737,
0.035268046,
0.0672043785,
-0.0085247075,
-0.030867165,
0.0047061378,
0.0008744031,
-0.000302864,
-0.0261943247,
0.0077810786,
-0.0157357156,
0.0281486567,
0.0108984597,
-0.0218010973,
-0.000652338,
-0.014012415,
2.917e-7,
0.0645255148,
0.0801922604,
-0.0141221602,
0.0176923964,
0.0299616419,
0.0269335825,
-0.0242224373,
0.006358231,
0.0172721315,
-0.0022085467,
-0.0173119828,
0.0183639284,
0.0327677913,
0.0466665588,
-0.0695040673,
-0.0173286777,
-0.0257884525,
-0.0047541768,
-0.0761942342,
-0.0142967785,
0.0296716988,
0.0713471249,
0.05519839,
0.009479125,
-0.0320547298,
-0.0546205826,
0.0442195758,
-0.0252690017,
-0.0287508685,
0.0268050823,
0.0509922467,
0.0321286954,
-0.0080435788,
0.0133987367,
-0.0452896655,
-0.0132647362,
-0.0375791751,
0.0751738101,
-0.0153773511,
0.0381544121,
0.0054587801,
-0.0294562392,
-0.0059888205,
-0.0737723112,
0.0717321411,
-0.0200273748,
0.0103976242,
-0.0179434586,
-0.005076122,
-0.0218491144,
0.0055901115,
-0.0399293602,
-0.0115418462,
-0.0016477619,
-0.0040476983,
0.0263785403,
-0.0646516159,
-0.0374004543,
-0.0371284522,
0.0098173684,
-0.0297147036,
-0.0642440394,
-0.0603352301,
-0.0481586605,
-0.0077947122,
-0.085389398,
0.0304479282,
2.712192172e-34,
0.0060322736,
0.0089435084,
-0.0024075015,
0.0413481407,
0.0608910061,
-0.004508554,
0.0105402125,
0.0126330191,
-0.0028445551,
-0.0722419471,
-0.0280954763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07213v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07213v2 | Human-centered NLP Fact-checking: Co-Designing with Fact-checkers using Matchmaking for AI | 2023-08-14T15:31:32 | 2024-01-23T04:59:29 | Houjiang Liu, Anubrata Das, Alexander Boltz, Didi Zhou, Daisy Pinaroc, Matthew Lease, Min Kyung Lee | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.CY | While many Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques have been proposed
for fact-checking, both academic research and fact-checking organizations
report limited adoption of such NLP work due to poor alignment with
fact-checker practices, values, and needs. To address this, we investigate a
co-design method, Matchmaking for AI, to enable fact-checkers, designers, and
NLP researchers to collaboratively identify what fact-checker needs should be
addressed by technology, and to brainstorm ideas for potential solutions.
Co-design sessions we conducted with 22 professional fact-checkers yielded a
set of 11 design ideas that offer a "north star", integrating fact-checker
criteria into novel NLP design concepts. These concepts range from pre-bunking
misinformation, efficient and personalized monitoring misinformation,
proactively reducing fact-checker potential biases, and collaborative writing
fact-check reports. Our work provides new insights into both human-centered
fact-checking research and practice and AI co-design research. | [
0.0798103735,
0.040208526,
-0.0199870691,
0.0413984098,
-0.0629206821,
-0.0364685431,
0.028493477,
-0.0146248722,
0.0331365056,
-0.0442798845,
0.0206083395,
0.0148166968,
0.0152073642,
0.0542889424,
-0.0136234658,
0.0002945828,
0.0183679741,
0.0220517926,
0.0741404518,
0.0064578527,
0.0326135606,
0.0669063926,
-0.0362056643,
0.0622328818,
-0.0688803941,
-0.0291387718,
0.0141640613,
-0.0206158664,
0.0109882681,
-0.0525795408,
0.0116606066,
0.0319045894,
-0.0152819036,
0.0650600344,
0.0000017584,
-0.0338215083,
-0.0115621807,
0.0387208015,
-0.0810707211,
-0.0231172573,
0.0181251913,
0.0072650085,
-0.0130719235,
0.0146382852,
-0.0323151909,
0.0222988352,
0.0557965972,
0.0633325353,
0.066783309,
0.0381509066,
-0.013889309,
-0.0176870525,
0.0092146331,
0.0224494915,
-0.0238019302,
-0.0082374038,
-0.0033802353,
0.019578917,
0.0016072004,
-0.0052363044,
0.0216909759,
0.0318185613,
0.0221114382,
-0.0245970339,
0.0169831291,
0.0238226987,
-0.0384322032,
-0.0444091111,
-0.0408592522,
0.01814734,
0.0643587485,
-0.0185096804,
-0.0215574857,
-0.0244147368,
0.0152342794,
0.0381518342,
0.0150761493,
0.0182148498,
-0.0668954477,
-0.0260622762,
0.0145809725,
-0.0088887187,
-0.002233794,
0.0261856206,
0.0501388907,
0.0632318631,
-0.0116698639,
-0.033480145,
0.0078185182,
0.0382745191,
0.0632113367,
-0.0584659949,
0.0179466177,
0.0044179233,
-0.0384467915,
-0.009195067,
-0.0148029318,
-0.0279973149,
0.0291328747,
-0.0257848129,
0.0279220585,
0.0023242095,
-0.0278615244,
0.0360964909,
0.019118011,
0.0098231249,
0.0300749969,
-0.0167781953,
-0.0045934743,
-0.0141437985,
-0.0256012734,
0.0127300341,
-0.0253364388,
0.0093126772,
-0.0165604688,
0.0121323289,
-0.0214640591,
-0.0237985216,
-0.0614188537,
0.0472025238,
-0.0144406157,
0.0613448806,
-0.0101124039,
-0.0194309335,
-0.0872102976,
0.011014346,
-0.0303190909,
0.0162304826,
-0.012524439,
-0.054328043,
0.0027172887,
0.0283728912,
-0.0215867329,
-0.0378820859,
0.017823318,
-0.0145466933,
-0.0135038774,
-0.0163492318,
-0.0127658555,
-0.0430965982,
-0.0126503957,
-0.0260041207,
0.0004438892,
-0.0605462007,
0.0113291573,
-0.0246271193,
-0.0073407847,
-0.048289381,
-0.0178089868,
0.0350969657,
-0.0434680693,
0.0688246638,
-0.0325317048,
0.0022938983,
0.0268715788,
-0.0129328761,
-0.0029876826,
0.0344678201,
0.0380872674,
0.0337410271,
0.0682619214,
0.0400426947,
0.0180068761,
-0.0267244615,
0.0129618244,
-0.0235606879,
0.0479565784,
0.0165798515,
-0.0396069027,
0.0195291657,
-0.0003475071,
0.0504092351,
0.0041824244,
-0.0184901562,
0.0520690344,
0.03468455,
0.0190917533,
0.0251336992,
0.0453044362,
0.0120389331,
0.0175670087,
0.0210356265,
-0.0134973265,
0.0468922406,
-0.0449920334,
-0.0332490727,
-0.0147680268,
0.0775539577,
-0.0177957788,
-0.0465749092,
-0.0289968401,
0.004074567,
0.0299637597,
0.0353058837,
-0.0381101146,
0.0279583447,
-0.0207191035,
-0.0277225152,
-0.0178150255,
-0.0427092239,
-0.002452659,
-0.0617711954,
0.0081616966,
0.0925486311,
0.0504384972,
-0.0081269117,
-0.0007641539,
-0.0163181201,
-0.0023818153,
0.0581899434,
0.1049404666,
-0.0252855513,
-0.0294042975,
0.0044101733,
-0.0206168592,
-0.0237770509,
-0.0019601015,
-0.0047326051,
0.050150536,
0.0278418362,
-0.0094459765,
0.0214203782,
-0.0595176518,
0.0571594834,
0.00792732,
0.0051721167,
-0.010741719,
0.0225590877,
-0.0021218893,
0.0488510989,
-0.0060427599,
0.0147058601,
0.0477756187,
0.0084352689,
-0.030449817,
0.0494044945,
0.0429325476,
0.0182562564,
0.0177897345,
-0.0622635446,
-0.0700103939,
0.0451926552,
-0.0114912232,
0.0088252705,
-0.0100707673,
-0.0482790694,
-0.007092637,
-0.0201170575,
-0.0168319643,
0.0106899999,
0.0090282541,
-0.0032873258,
0.0315175168,
-0.0023052262,
-0.0212190766,
-0.0382362008,
-0.0158276018,
0.0168134701,
-0.0451496467,
-0.0293619614,
0.0442550853,
0.0234894324,
0.0252849199,
0.0619139522,
-0.0145802712,
-0.0432136282,
-0.008880035,
-0.0395469144,
-0.0072425837,
0.0090393275,
-0.0036703481,
-0.0046935673,
-0.0266547445,
0.0000645013,
-0.0018202136,
0.0041540107,
-0.0383744612,
0.003285412,
0.0123241777,
0.0634317696,
-0.0076427353,
-0.0001141159,
-0.0179198235,
0.0252046231,
-0.041345682,
0.002297122,
0.0856909156,
-0.0272365734,
-0.0740986839,
-0.0045913984,
-0.0488530099,
0.0039523635,
0.0372895077,
0.018588528,
0.0595433451,
0.0497148,
-0.0087575754,
0.0378660895,
0.0293603316,
0.0525721461,
0.0341597982,
-0.0142684793,
0.0007052933,
0.0202047285,
0.0053311992,
0.0227084123,
0.0264074262,
-0.0230106283,
0.0512930676,
-0.0208383873,
0.0008124046,
-0.0051967534,
-0.0381397046,
0.0539324135,
-0.0114965066,
-0.0185693502,
0.0258247778,
-0.0460985601,
-0.0078704059,
0.0778415427,
-0.0112557989,
-0.0170179289,
0.1011568978,
-0.0179022048,
0.0528416559,
-0.0666384548,
-0.0249333996,
-0.0176527426,
0.0265379418,
-0.0618864447,
0.0296739023,
0.0330103301,
0.0276959334,
-0.0159109253,
-0.0374771729,
0.0597904474,
-0.0250192266,
0.0191976111,
-0.0531551763,
0.0071517713,
0.0436085016,
-0.0457762592,
-0.065112628,
-0.0552810207,
-0.0775583908,
-0.0128424121,
-0.0051339716,
-0.0352282561,
-0.0903168321,
-0.0219872184,
0.0453802831,
0.0122452807,
0.0353724696,
-0.0255671777,
0.0314486884,
-0.0014016384,
0.0186544806,
0.0899669454,
0.0544188172,
0.0265560243,
-0.013491598,
0.0593047589,
-0.0018250194,
0.0030421133,
-0.0087841582,
-0.0367324539,
0.0071315356,
-0.0440285802,
0.0335196443,
-0.0021304719,
0.0413132235,
-0.0404046588,
0.0123193506,
0.0525269471,
0.0420983806,
-0.0092732161,
-0.0011782396,
-0.0008769339,
-0.0035479625,
0.0118443044,
0.0362382047,
-0.0766277388,
-0.0027749627,
-0.0353874862,
-0.013195998,
-0.0542370342,
-0.0385774821,
-0.0455992632,
-0.1035558954,
0.0296009853,
-0.0354585201,
0.0232955292,
-0.0512527153,
-0.0344329625,
0.0007207184,
0.0244367737,
-0.001784429,
0.0040834444,
0.0064249053,
-0.0107338177,
-0.00946513,
-0.0659169778,
-0.0377654284,
0.048787389,
-0.0404493921,
0.054480359,
0.0531207435,
0.087367855,
0.0046185106,
-0.0446165539,
-0.048002068,
0.0166564211,
0.0128502855,
-0.0029039097,
0.0682512,
-0.0314968787,
0.0092197135,
-0.0607889183,
-0.0055012843,
0.0164073743,
-0.0340002663,
0.0060904035,
0.0306226816,
-0.0172641929,
-0.0005869482,
-0.03238675,
0.0344258621,
0.0199979711,
0.0789717734,
-0.0217372142,
-0.0146009438,
-0.0156220635,
-0.0307047646,
0.016372012,
-0.0547527,
-0.0491281375,
0.0276744813,
-0.0065961471,
-0.0075799017,
-0.0794751495,
-0.0493475869,
0.0252152309,
0.011484961,
0.003084545,
-0.0321829841,
0.0470817164,
0.0131928716,
0.0061769383,
0.002814593,
-0.0284659434,
0.0581580624,
0.0203784555,
-0.0220386256,
-0.0385152698,
-0.0107178548,
0.0352074131,
0.0931404084,
0.0098729432,
-0.0260582455,
0.028781455,
-0.0152759356,
0.0223681629,
0.0363100767,
-0.0457803719,
-0.0284430254,
-0.036313083,
0.0658178553,
-0.0225181077,
-0.0196658652,
-0.0109206829,
-0.011498563,
0.0032181577,
-0.0157713201,
-0.0054454436,
-0.017051205,
0.0020703785,
0.002221246,
-0.0234975815,
-0.0357241035,
0.0614604838,
0.0512953326,
0.0170586649,
-0.0476894937,
0.0514763221,
-0.0456856266,
-0.03972831,
-0.0180829018,
-0.0445474088,
0.0171991028,
-0.0068587246,
-0.03581018,
-0.0233967248,
0.0003678995,
0.0449493341,
-0.0802196413,
0.0388183035,
-0.0399989188,
0.0231104176,
0.0151665127,
0.0302058998,
-0.0429140553,
-0.0198644102,
0.0051811696,
0.0081815133,
-0.0133773414,
0.0507908091,
0.0395900533,
-0.0089211706,
0.0217539538,
-0.0346777923,
-0.0007139416,
0.0005150353,
-0.0752266496,
-0.0095302127,
-0.0127805062,
0.0017901142,
0.0086159725,
0.0023782859,
-0.0082028871,
-0.0089562982,
-0.0240614004,
0.0324214958,
-0.0105902944,
0.0219371542,
-0.0028465658,
-0.0069298702,
0.0230291951,
-0.0409206599,
-0.047052104,
0.0069539365,
-0.0311348867,
0.0331378803,
-0.0083055384,
-0.0757586509,
-0.0323327258,
-0.0513276979,
-0.0618218109,
-0.0123017309,
-0.0011073358,
-0.020723056,
-0.1406913698,
-0.0460406318,
0.0426128283,
0.0228392482,
0.0436583273,
-0.0036268439,
-0.0015380534,
0.0502067097,
0.0256714914,
-0.0309200957,
-0.0421544202,
0.0135511598,
-0.0113090351,
-0.010308885,
-0.0372169502,
-5.819805675e-33,
-0.0095578702,
-0.0926795378,
0.0431462787,
0.0069471672,
0.0103060612,
0.0398891568,
-0.0026147359,
-0.0014171358,
-0.0634441301,
0.0451318733,
-0.0036918479,
0.0326036625,
0.0127327563,
-0.0538608767,
-0.0035570303,
0.0034964518,
0.05999019,
-0.0012761212,
-0.0513926372,
-0.0437506475,
0.0049870578,
-0.052679576,
0.0133511536,
-0.1007840931,
0.0571010448,
0.0052948226,
-0.0590053983,
0.0260737762,
-0.0113253836,
0.0396365337,
0.0176791959,
0.0596719906,
0.0254097283,
0.0027055957,
0.0200126991,
-0.0111739635,
-0.0372754224,
-0.0201037377,
0.0507907569,
-0.0118902195,
0.0235590339,
0.0105504887,
0.0098605584,
-0.0030142076,
-0.0355267189,
0.0257262886,
0.0365493521,
-0.0027445483,
0.0563673042,
0.03484888,
-0.0506592169,
-0.0023458365,
0.0088434378,
-0.0127124209,
-0.0269431192,
0.0243414082,
0.0303410031,
-0.0162449852,
-0.1290053427,
0.0293411892,
-0.0271891244,
-0.0420251526,
0.0354091525,
-0.0348839536,
-0.033417359,
0.0572280325,
-0.0065607335,
0.0794071034,
-0.0705039799,
-0.0054528359,
0.0021955289,
0.0325199664,
0.0712869838,
0.1197505295,
0.0107370038,
-0.0673938319,
-0.0303451307,
0.0459294543,
0.0538591333,
0.0296219289,
-0.0061475337,
-0.0177511051,
-0.0718822777,
-0.0064880913,
-0.0115436399,
0.0061675082,
-0.0405011214,
0.0139717348,
-0.0196818337,
0.0196829196,
-0.0332584716,
0.0561561622,
-0.0472674444,
-0.0410748869,
0.0493042432,
-0.0238579828,
-0.0388739668,
-0.0213615131,
0.0058127199,
-0.0278385188,
-0.0633311868,
0.0364983082,
0.0100492947,
0.0739180669,
0.0305335335,
-0.0136011736,
0.0326801166,
0.0081418827,
-0.0365396813,
0.010260555,
-0.0100547271,
0.0448389351,
0.0115197692,
-0.0965349898,
0.0187637005,
0.0400155112,
-0.0359309241,
-0.0422340482,
0.0252741612,
0.0228576604,
-0.0386399329,
0.0173492078,
0.0011675669,
0.0043245251,
-0.0005737431,
-0.0003616941,
-0.025390761,
-0.0030767319,
0.0383676142,
-0.0462860614,
-0.0285493992,
-0.017540101,
2.497e-7,
0.0200297069,
0.0461100973,
0.0130650708,
0.0077264616,
0.0087941131,
0.0380393565,
0.0479660928,
0.0128098475,
-0.0166166537,
-0.0495457575,
-0.0205618031,
0.0385217816,
0.0304816347,
0.0824354813,
-0.0271130539,
-0.0043334882,
-0.0239100493,
0.0042687193,
-0.0505403504,
-0.0166779179,
0.039644517,
-0.0448688306,
0.0406871215,
-0.0351818539,
-0.052085828,
-0.0032151425,
0.0110917604,
0.0353454947,
-0.0417844914,
-0.0012567472,
0.0486232974,
-0.0242459178,
0.0125274863,
0.0659117028,
-0.02642381,
-0.0248138066,
0.0088184653,
0.0003450098,
-0.0129190711,
-0.0315791629,
-0.0356788412,
-0.0082595004,
-0.0231824908,
-0.0133398203,
0.0170021225,
0.011250671,
-0.0298920888,
-0.0652538985,
-0.0252950303,
0.019096069,
0.0004115193,
-0.0151883317,
-0.0375762321,
0.0311907809,
-0.0135216871,
0.0267095044,
0.0061950698,
0.0152900303,
0.0033946945,
0.0071474249,
-0.0093450826,
-0.0320186839,
0.0195169318,
-0.0242246035,
0.0323445313,
-0.0406576395,
0.0401427597,
1.565569524e-34,
-0.0000198471,
0.0212032311,
0.0053311395,
-0.026398642,
0.0909843147,
0.0615787804,
-0.0298205689,
-0.0056341165,
0.0339110382,
0.0119167296,
-0.0156660378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07201v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07201v1 | ChatEval: Towards Better LLM-based Evaluators through Multi-Agent Debate | 2023-08-14T15:13:04 | 2023-08-14T15:13:04 | Chi-Min Chan, Weize Chen, Yusheng Su, Jianxuan Yu, Wei Xue, Shanghang Zhang, Jie Fu, Zhiyuan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text evaluation has historically posed significant challenges, often
demanding substantial labor and time cost. With the emergence of large language
models (LLMs), researchers have explored LLMs' potential as alternatives for
human evaluation. While these single-agent-based approaches show promise,
experimental results suggest that further advancements are needed to bridge the
gap between their current effectiveness and human-level evaluation quality.
Recognizing that best practices of human evaluation processes often involve
multiple human annotators collaborating in the evaluation, we resort to a
multi-agent debate framework, moving beyond single-agent prompting strategies.
The multi-agent-based approach enables a group of LLMs to synergize with an
array of intelligent counterparts, harnessing their distinct capabilities and
expertise to enhance efficiency and effectiveness in handling intricate tasks.
In this paper, we construct a multi-agent referee team called ChatEval to
autonomously discuss and evaluate the quality of generated responses from
different models on open-ended questions and traditional natural language
generation (NLG) tasks. Our analysis shows that ChatEval transcends mere
textual scoring, offering a human-mimicking evaluation process for reliable
assessments. Our code is available at https://github.com/chanchimin/ChatEval. | [
0.0519168042,
0.0214177836,
-0.0078414762,
0.0182792712,
-0.0505837463,
-0.003741693,
0.0455982238,
-0.0170836039,
0.0141940061,
-0.0726624802,
-0.0461862981,
-0.039709039,
-0.0185469668,
0.0183348358,
0.0340123959,
-0.0213441998,
0.0006216241,
-0.0355997086,
0.0529207923,
-0.0155514721,
0.015209862,
-0.006640702,
-0.0137077179,
0.0601990297,
0.0004404336,
0.0009917737,
-0.0263638645,
-0.0280552246,
0.0154828979,
-0.027738126,
0.0046864618,
0.0762076601,
-0.0056986148,
0.0151404617,
0.0000020041,
-0.0484015308,
0.0069263685,
0.0105620213,
-0.0028019936,
0.0070912857,
0.0801232681,
0.0651964694,
0.0063860901,
0.0057920478,
-0.0622311234,
0.0006964891,
0.0212085079,
0.0087581342,
0.1061871275,
0.0477980822,
0.0198224559,
0.0209447052,
-0.0040779584,
0.008710118,
-0.0128179286,
-0.042983599,
-0.0139492732,
0.0204380341,
0.0444287211,
0.0144213717,
0.024391707,
0.0187381692,
0.0184726212,
-0.044774387,
0.0209980663,
0.0045754947,
-0.0373977385,
-0.0378066711,
-0.0244771373,
0.0737420171,
0.0483587645,
0.0104752127,
-0.0175968967,
0.0075286194,
0.0352579653,
0.0262217652,
-0.0341842882,
0.0497262739,
-0.0009750111,
-0.0084765349,
-0.0043423022,
0.0150743183,
0.000091259,
0.0285511352,
0.014561424,
0.0524064153,
-0.0022120159,
-0.0192117896,
0.0190531965,
0.0335005745,
-0.0194611717,
-0.0938503444,
-0.0056880284,
0.0534626953,
-0.0809213072,
-0.0044690124,
-0.0205256194,
-0.0327244066,
0.0399037786,
-0.0452529527,
0.0441806912,
0.0157963391,
0.0030596771,
0.02080773,
-0.0067138262,
0.0662095249,
0.0214170814,
0.0324948207,
-0.0272300262,
-0.0067395149,
-0.0671229884,
-0.0149218589,
-0.0212664548,
0.0462584496,
-0.0215594955,
-0.0040203831,
-0.0313229673,
0.0179593433,
-0.0534970909,
0.0188718066,
0.0143399145,
0.0517469011,
-0.0072459206,
-0.0020824333,
-0.0606457852,
0.0117427297,
-0.0413531549,
0.0075054872,
0.0522134341,
-0.0489490591,
0.0064026425,
0.055641517,
-0.0111952145,
0.0051203989,
0.0009825631,
0.0646845922,
-0.0078764893,
0.0001543913,
0.0092075588,
-0.0520716384,
-0.0088491794,
-0.0841069892,
-0.0401477814,
-0.0826440379,
0.0118165361,
-0.0024055536,
-0.0310362205,
-0.0407663547,
0.025114866,
0.0416775681,
0.0227581058,
0.0390144289,
-0.0261938311,
0.0035102426,
0.0480464622,
0.0166564342,
-0.0611792319,
0.0477753915,
0.0368360914,
0.0290787611,
0.0196564328,
0.0064891009,
0.0431863107,
0.0301911719,
-0.0121916384,
0.0063756313,
0.0263425317,
0.0189021789,
-0.0382801704,
0.0512845926,
0.0005020612,
0.0858851224,
-0.0343433283,
-0.0070351511,
0.0611005537,
0.0562809929,
-0.0044648726,
0.0263158511,
0.0728929043,
0.0370945558,
0.0163862109,
0.0074050608,
-0.0199249424,
0.0405330174,
-0.0100983633,
-0.0130223092,
0.0297976211,
0.0257340036,
-0.0038769839,
-0.0710208118,
-0.0065644169,
0.0061332104,
0.0234311875,
0.0063971621,
0.0164672993,
0.0033195997,
-0.0268331915,
0.0065967077,
-0.0028050772,
-0.0739745125,
0.0086878929,
-0.0785290897,
0.056464877,
0.0740693435,
0.0686014742,
0.0107591907,
-0.0373899043,
-0.0168859735,
0.0131454365,
0.0684394687,
0.0719152242,
-0.0377043411,
-0.0400249399,
-0.0380653776,
-0.0337678008,
-0.0171144363,
-0.0041430909,
0.0233558025,
0.0115849068,
-0.020925317,
0.0122706806,
-0.0157955848,
-0.0782919228,
0.0341072939,
-0.0107550733,
-0.0007682374,
-0.0069465474,
-0.0074586258,
0.0272906534,
0.032487575,
-0.0316263102,
0.0419920869,
0.0270456914,
-0.0357921384,
-0.0577933751,
0.0116024781,
-0.0069929026,
-0.0348075852,
0.0227524955,
-0.0349452868,
-0.0011497082,
-0.0000279608,
-0.0095095383,
-0.0286681354,
0.0147568425,
-0.0362403877,
-0.0206821281,
-0.0492767803,
0.0005392232,
0.0044497699,
-0.0175259858,
-0.0565340817,
0.065190047,
0.0104061654,
-0.0008448209,
0.0327652879,
0.0366388299,
0.0196922179,
-0.0570994243,
-0.009027469,
0.0050728703,
0.0150882192,
0.0370704308,
0.0593769737,
0.0418182425,
-0.0489579178,
-0.0524765402,
-0.1155912504,
-0.0040727975,
-0.0300296824,
0.0299151875,
0.0081865964,
-0.0318797864,
0.0154971089,
0.03062311,
-0.0870044306,
0.0013431913,
0.0633050725,
0.0067641065,
0.0404008627,
-0.0062089683,
-0.001481298,
-0.0383580886,
0.0308267158,
-0.0062029269,
0.039989721,
0.0653056949,
0.0124374684,
-0.0514678136,
0.005749024,
-0.0517026857,
-0.0154388724,
0.0337920301,
-0.0402137004,
0.0541700274,
0.005264644,
0.008729009,
0.0417595357,
0.0152061051,
0.0482287332,
0.0240905993,
-0.0173599739,
-0.0727405027,
0.0092254365,
0.0160156004,
0.0214615297,
-0.0238032006,
-0.0142392414,
0.0043619601,
0.0517419279,
0.0073961504,
0.002592888,
-0.0451212302,
0.0779672265,
-0.0349750109,
-0.0564458854,
-0.0158276837,
-0.0324142426,
-0.0203329138,
0.0438685566,
-0.0156165939,
-0.0272838809,
0.0880321786,
-0.0312777497,
-0.0124285603,
-0.047164306,
-0.0138971088,
-0.0623245351,
0.0731321797,
-0.0197155867,
0.0191180762,
-0.036253646,
0.0319903009,
-0.055384852,
0.0097719152,
0.0306840539,
-0.0402490646,
0.0285310559,
-0.0726052746,
0.0074782888,
-0.0109688751,
-0.0275460798,
-0.031334389,
-0.0394369848,
-0.0331004485,
0.0218554512,
0.0254666153,
0.0087076416,
-0.0388529003,
0.0119260009,
0.0085726781,
-0.0207606778,
-0.0306095518,
-0.0070981686,
-0.0144863445,
0.0426525138,
0.019803945,
0.0399401262,
0.0296945348,
-0.0476099141,
0.0562268868,
0.0708641484,
0.0056245304,
-0.0013572548,
-0.0166440289,
-0.0233887099,
0.0144426515,
-0.0317662954,
0.0009168814,
0.0178701375,
0.0716892555,
-0.0662041903,
-0.0143124908,
0.1039139777,
0.0334877297,
-0.0367187969,
-0.0030569257,
-0.0471983962,
0.0443785414,
0.0031838224,
0.0311547965,
-0.0640441403,
-0.0293418132,
-0.0148694664,
0.0245862734,
-0.0302202553,
-0.0311191324,
-0.0133701786,
-0.1086432487,
0.060625013,
0.0035872119,
-0.0173490904,
0.0316178761,
0.0108498046,
-0.006697949,
-0.0209391825,
0.0008012805,
0.0289548431,
0.0246318523,
0.0272611044,
0.0323277414,
-0.0120804012,
0.0014093257,
0.0386771001,
-0.0652987063,
0.0856516212,
0.0518299527,
0.0319606587,
0.0227305237,
-0.04770099,
0.0195216555,
0.0099633206,
0.0184797961,
0.0095580053,
0.0237078834,
0.0041333213,
0.0067675877,
-0.0304987989,
0.0080550164,
-0.0279781185,
-0.0096684275,
0.0378618613,
0.0375749692,
-0.0354053415,
-0.0040805433,
-0.0142622273,
0.0424868912,
0.0087168114,
0.0741045251,
0.0311073139,
-0.0727830231,
-0.0685110316,
-0.0382155329,
-0.0102602774,
-0.079754822,
-0.0476296283,
0.0203909948,
-0.0009659556,
-0.0140710576,
-0.096154131,
-0.0778715014,
0.0253770258,
0.0209400281,
0.0021286381,
-0.0298300888,
-0.007054396,
0.0254153498,
0.0297599491,
0.0178201571,
-0.015754465,
0.0242662486,
-0.0221701227,
-0.0252345093,
0.0067795999,
-0.0315124542,
-0.0143082812,
0.0598756373,
-0.0721992776,
-0.0519785918,
-0.0070621828,
0.0570134111,
0.025801491,
0.0107733998,
-0.0109335212,
-0.0503352508,
0.0200732276,
0.0174743365,
-0.0483616143,
0.0108584184,
-0.0029857215,
0.0409392081,
-0.0160624515,
0.0254873671,
-0.0206039641,
0.026074674,
-0.0181950834,
0.051755771,
-0.0100272335,
-0.0771247894,
0.0202662572,
0.0130878417,
-0.0264588762,
-0.0203642361,
0.0144188842,
-0.0174107086,
-0.0251255594,
-0.0261184871,
-0.0453696176,
-0.0595187545,
-0.015879469,
-0.0256682634,
-0.0310269352,
0.0402546339,
0.0143205682,
-0.0191528574,
0.055040624,
0.0078632981,
0.0284742024,
0.0156065673,
0.008671348,
-0.0211220197,
-0.006321935,
-0.0339312404,
0.0057085757,
-0.0336599723,
0.0404848866,
-0.0029230372,
0.0745863095,
-0.0137226144,
-0.01692749,
0.0465552285,
0.0375830419,
-0.05595221,
-0.0265774503,
-0.0115370099,
0.0473599136,
0.0351458155,
0.077336289,
0.0517932363,
-0.0256394129,
0.002150588,
-0.0085494937,
0.0067104325,
0.0124721127,
-0.0135291768,
0.0198036116,
0.0208118707,
-0.021580521,
-0.035330195,
0.0648721084,
0.0130690839,
-0.0072127073,
-0.0161566604,
-0.0271358043,
-0.0535706654,
-0.0607294738,
-0.0228315685,
-0.0033795286,
0.0065517882,
-0.0031491753,
-0.0690106973,
-0.0218268596,
-0.0155679202,
0.0644449145,
0.0120086381,
-0.0305847749,
0.0338638574,
0.0655217096,
-0.018425405,
-0.0075472221,
-0.0780981258,
0.0133967586,
-0.0167285781,
0.0035814862,
-0.0336368307,
-6.009424301e-33,
-0.0471932366,
-0.0867513865,
0.0590799004,
-0.0001705049,
-0.0305902846,
-0.0280972458,
-0.0331910662,
0.0316999406,
0.0190277118,
0.0257106833,
0.0149661712,
-0.0157768168,
-0.0046320697,
-0.0043023471,
0.0332651176,
-0.0438513719,
0.0286499038,
-0.0126370508,
-0.0421026163,
0.025817493,
-0.0112008331,
-0.0141546307,
-0.0087094354,
-0.0401901528,
0.0708344206,
-0.0124966446,
-0.0317352563,
0.0141698141,
-0.0255671237,
0.067634061,
-0.0141391708,
0.0377391391,
0.0249583423,
-0.0328745469,
-0.0103817005,
0.0090565877,
-0.0124305664,
-0.012430992,
0.0108138639,
-0.0209037438,
-0.053720478,
-0.0420664884,
0.0502742641,
-0.004887681,
-0.0458023399,
0.0185322277,
0.0326552615,
-0.0166101027,
0.0055492832,
-0.0209789034,
-0.0506442189,
0.0390704907,
-0.0257395711,
-0.0396054983,
-0.0155583741,
0.0574410111,
-0.0236372966,
-0.0142732533,
-0.0497548133,
0.033585187,
0.0049435827,
-0.0177317355,
0.0667583123,
0.0008587834,
-0.0294299386,
0.0714037269,
0.0084413998,
0.0173649918,
-0.0427876785,
-0.0419884883,
-0.021883104,
0.0574256107,
0.0771046728,
0.0879220292,
-0.045531217,
0.0173906963,
-0.0419555306,
0.0769494101,
0.0423284136,
0.0147729451,
0.0069479714,
-0.0205647629,
-0.019546276,
-0.007961222,
-0.0518275574,
-0.0179243814,
-0.0394575447,
-0.0455644764,
0.0375640951,
-0.0140831517,
-0.0134592513,
-0.0527092405,
0.0216718204,
-0.0458905958,
0.0202634316,
-0.0134620909,
-0.0360254832,
0.0379328728,
-0.0074214698,
-0.0057421732,
-0.0325867236,
0.0183125883,
-0.0027908667,
0.0563360862,
0.0256707575,
0.0024712265,
0.008418303,
0.0069526895,
-0.0292084329,
0.013357277,
-0.0487408563,
0.0340674482,
-0.0057344302,
-0.0042715957,
-0.0057897992,
-0.020380808,
-0.0313800573,
0.047078222,
-0.0040079798,
0.0060560559,
-0.021897275,
-0.0158922989,
0.0258820802,
-0.0192599706,
-0.0425328463,
0.0263164043,
-0.0285655204,
0.0036405788,
0.0061902255,
-0.003860672,
-0.0016001763,
-0.0006004339,
2.615e-7,
0.032631401,
0.0442713015,
0.0032524832,
-0.0107375868,
0.0243798625,
0.0466306135,
-0.0076637678,
0.0122245569,
0.0086070467,
-0.0080083758,
0.0160885807,
0.0286911465,
0.054905884,
0.0471401773,
-0.0730138645,
-0.0232270416,
-0.0723004416,
0.0017480931,
-0.029449299,
-0.005110811,
0.0814567506,
0.0246895049,
-0.0012425241,
-0.0104355197,
-0.0312659517,
-0.052790001,
0.0730110705,
-0.0019907597,
-0.0478452519,
0.0483396053,
0.0665552244,
-0.0196463652,
0.0191954095,
0.0291526448,
0.0148134297,
-0.0000686562,
0.0241005849,
0.0647309124,
0.0203183424,
-0.0333955809,
0.0072173299,
-0.0257318243,
0.0302615594,
-0.0477118529,
0.0479989536,
-0.0590670295,
-0.0370934568,
-0.0468390808,
-0.0085323676,
-0.0362804495,
0.0189066064,
-0.0388196707,
-0.0129482811,
0.0233080182,
-0.0084927026,
-0.0152174076,
0.0001116924,
-0.014244738,
-0.0400249995,
-0.0147997867,
-0.0393850505,
-0.0700612217,
-0.0286355484,
0.0109904548,
-0.0187899321,
-0.063466318,
0.0012420566,
2.148391102e-34,
0.0391479433,
-0.00505313,
-0.0073096543,
0.0265859589,
0.068255879,
0.0404327847,
-0.0273110997,
-0.013793014,
0.0296804551,
-0.063514322,
-0.0098472163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07179v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07179v1 | Incorporating Annotator Uncertainty into Representations of Discourse Relations | 2023-08-14T14:39:02 | 2023-08-14T14:39:02 | S. Magalí López Cortez, Cassandra L. Jacobs | cs.CL | cs.CL | Annotation of discourse relations is a known difficult task, especially for
non-expert annotators. In this paper, we investigate novice annotators'
uncertainty on the annotation of discourse relations on spoken conversational
data. We find that dialogue context (single turn, pair of turns within speaker,
and pair of turns across speakers) is a significant predictor of confidence
scores. We compute distributed representations of discourse relations from
co-occurrence statistics that incorporate information about confidence scores
and dialogue context. We perform a hierarchical clustering analysis using these
representations and show that weighting discourse relation representations with
information about confidence and dialogue context coherently models our
annotators' uncertainty about discourse relation labels. | [
0.0230266619,
0.0119488928,
-0.0150666675,
0.0290474258,
-0.0158648491,
0.0096012941,
-0.0066407965,
-0.0430839695,
-0.0007997254,
-0.0965499505,
-0.0594088174,
-0.0111070201,
0.0353974029,
-0.0240658093,
-0.0045388364,
-0.0969576761,
0.0222343244,
-0.0253157578,
0.0577933528,
-0.0185222663,
0.0061135227,
-0.0210040025,
-0.071690239,
0.0451352559,
-0.0691601187,
-0.0317079574,
0.0050060102,
0.014581481,
0.0295913611,
-0.034417484,
0.0154858222,
0.0662579387,
0.0246026628,
0.0610336065,
0.0000013652,
-0.013461058,
-0.0026955025,
-0.0290094111,
-0.0243531615,
0.0132366018,
-0.0010713675,
0.0273907706,
-0.0018319848,
-0.0047798525,
-0.0235993583,
-0.0192986373,
0.0289227888,
0.0326046683,
0.0399362408,
0.0059215506,
-0.0108803995,
-0.0207249224,
-0.0162719619,
0.017658418,
-0.0329350904,
-0.0615742132,
-0.0213738102,
0.0958598852,
-0.0305813644,
0.0641169921,
-0.0188441463,
0.0345881879,
-0.0228928439,
-0.0397022665,
0.0104801776,
0.0319419019,
-0.0526875556,
-0.0140637308,
0.0103256395,
0.0457873121,
0.1012435406,
0.0168753434,
-0.021446798,
0.0187753513,
0.0111366818,
0.0283650048,
-0.0243351106,
-0.0034681747,
-0.0193669591,
0.0073140748,
-0.0268387776,
0.0185220279,
0.0001247948,
-0.0354613438,
0.0377258621,
0.0664120838,
-0.0251389015,
0.0184421334,
-0.0062987055,
0.0149294976,
-0.0491949953,
-0.0356140435,
0.0261134021,
0.0006383506,
-0.0488870852,
0.0036096997,
-0.0314157531,
-0.0010227272,
0.0075136181,
-0.0670595169,
-0.0054331454,
-0.0012976609,
-0.022610629,
0.0553865395,
0.0157246161,
0.0205716435,
0.0041373726,
-0.0623313338,
0.0135983285,
-0.0324499607,
-0.0530213155,
0.0123070264,
-0.0217567012,
0.0324305668,
-0.0495527945,
-0.0143732391,
-0.0619648397,
0.0227942206,
-0.0215066597,
0.0323166549,
0.0047799889,
0.0147472536,
-0.0083141029,
0.0024134233,
-0.0090371044,
0.0283465106,
-0.0389141776,
0.0376481861,
-0.034769956,
-0.0481565371,
0.0137121705,
0.0540677086,
0.0236905217,
-0.0052497555,
-0.0508323647,
0.0467508547,
-0.0006612118,
-0.0179752614,
0.0038982225,
-0.0242676008,
-0.0416944623,
-0.0062849196,
-0.0255340412,
-0.0444261767,
-0.0143557424,
0.0097452356,
0.0077101067,
-0.0113920439,
0.0359637663,
-0.0237656739,
-0.0299292505,
0.0625630021,
-0.0116913738,
0.0108223148,
0.0549566969,
-0.0034718979,
-0.0417533703,
0.0367931128,
0.0700339898,
-0.0308686718,
0.0613284223,
0.0011242378,
-0.0000786418,
-0.0242982693,
-0.0306087751,
-0.0085267695,
0.0464156494,
-0.0152174383,
-0.0155000491,
0.0070755626,
0.0059888111,
0.0725462511,
-0.0459606647,
-0.035123799,
0.0664710626,
0.0730013698,
-0.0324379057,
-0.0379542634,
0.0335460678,
0.0012564502,
0.0165008456,
0.0775095075,
-0.0073337238,
0.0082103051,
-0.010778971,
-0.0206557475,
0.0494540893,
-0.023371445,
-0.002717562,
-0.0605963655,
-0.0114195794,
-0.0134918448,
-0.0072330469,
-0.0268768519,
0.0057537211,
-0.0046808678,
-0.0218961798,
0.005148659,
0.0171879288,
-0.0384910293,
-0.0105518755,
0.0021043099,
-0.0096618291,
0.0202240329,
-0.0031465609,
-0.0210329704,
-0.0372515023,
-0.0285787676,
0.0202472173,
0.0156258624,
0.0079411212,
-0.0498765633,
0.004874914,
-0.0294663608,
-0.0200716201,
0.0291960277,
0.0389652923,
0.0258513391,
0.0022129286,
-0.0331625305,
0.0018570643,
-0.0284575,
-0.0001624092,
-0.0262537282,
0.0316753238,
-0.002043105,
0.0125309797,
-0.0008581083,
0.0478214845,
0.0462008491,
-0.0172206461,
0.0034938571,
0.0483515188,
0.0082318475,
-0.0160711408,
0.0534765348,
-0.046323508,
-0.0517245308,
0.029333245,
-0.0657520592,
-0.070115678,
-0.0779559985,
0.002013077,
-0.0703640878,
0.0257103425,
-0.0526035428,
0.0253088549,
-0.0304560363,
-0.0093255853,
0.0194686614,
-0.0025740829,
-0.031123979,
0.0528298691,
0.013477454,
0.0201990623,
0.0357859991,
-0.0078951577,
0.0393952131,
-0.0457844473,
-0.0041175904,
-0.0311625823,
0.0215925388,
0.009313779,
0.0480931364,
-0.0461643785,
-0.0263430085,
-0.0114394045,
-0.1274441928,
-0.0150251398,
-0.0065368805,
0.0172635522,
0.022701839,
-0.0382790901,
0.0228193067,
-0.0527660958,
-0.0234980751,
-0.0132306917,
-0.0208234414,
0.0425613672,
0.0371277146,
0.0051964824,
0.0038734491,
-0.0546969101,
0.0199062936,
-0.0318198986,
0.0365168788,
0.0466133878,
-0.0276234802,
-0.0314803161,
-0.0068504559,
-0.0228537712,
0.0248409007,
0.0082388055,
-0.008284091,
0.0475950465,
0.0482248515,
0.0267977566,
0.0032137018,
0.0172469243,
0.0753315166,
0.011323262,
-0.0668992922,
-0.0305028576,
0.0156695265,
-0.01572093,
0.0167415477,
-0.0641261786,
-0.0030443398,
-0.0138804214,
0.0654449388,
0.0184950531,
0.0005439977,
-0.0459600128,
-0.0423880219,
-0.0358454511,
0.0122599844,
-0.0178086441,
-0.0216865428,
-0.0002727927,
0.0453217402,
0.0040276726,
-0.0112225516,
0.0637649074,
-0.0668283999,
0.0103795994,
-0.014774696,
-0.0271318872,
-0.005486981,
0.0496531017,
-0.0079572583,
-0.0085101975,
-0.0078708408,
-0.0666908473,
-0.044487223,
0.0068829921,
0.0875176042,
-0.027251346,
0.0239614528,
-0.0592077374,
0.007940026,
0.0160911046,
-0.015866505,
-0.0257857759,
-0.0381380022,
-0.0375623405,
0.0138609447,
0.0240555052,
-0.0341953412,
-0.0221249945,
0.0428230986,
0.0190877449,
0.0144379297,
0.0073948908,
-0.0028913077,
-0.0150558706,
0.0680174455,
-0.0034930808,
0.012277076,
0.0015519151,
-0.0016366184,
0.019484574,
0.0469641462,
-0.0241927709,
0.0004555683,
-0.0315400101,
-0.0335977077,
0.005672608,
-0.0193235595,
-0.0648780912,
-0.0082449643,
0.0754094794,
0.0088433549,
-0.0062612426,
0.1348689348,
0.0183915645,
-0.01383173,
-0.0168807171,
-0.0285014492,
0.0513328463,
0.0344564952,
-0.0024533977,
-0.0702610239,
0.0096769165,
-0.0009847815,
0.0157733783,
0.0009616755,
-0.0728608072,
0.0407171361,
-0.0551521257,
0.036976099,
-0.0148724141,
-0.0548922457,
-0.0122950692,
-0.0699090287,
0.043157123,
-0.0004116983,
0.0317891426,
-0.0271030832,
0.0173388012,
0.0332240127,
0.0583696477,
-0.0512392446,
-0.0368757248,
-0.0005179283,
-0.0009552988,
0.0712042376,
-0.0044508372,
0.0683203042,
0.020628877,
0.0125770271,
-0.0110614635,
-0.0191820096,
-0.0177556183,
-0.0089747105,
0.0466466323,
-0.0210614242,
-0.0068573691,
-0.0158422552,
0.0149026308,
-0.0084705902,
-0.0584477596,
0.0016480183,
0.0374840647,
-0.0353587046,
0.0390159041,
-0.0034746279,
0.0452857055,
0.0223675426,
0.0461427867,
0.0496081784,
0.0095846215,
0.0356856436,
-0.0366599448,
0.0641601682,
0.0272243954,
0.0142407715,
0.0161395706,
0.0204303358,
0.0066064647,
-0.0932300091,
-0.0452894233,
0.0266044997,
0.0151624251,
-0.0150301531,
0.017378306,
0.0695138425,
-0.0005292813,
-0.0269744378,
-0.0192924235,
-0.0258285608,
-0.0010028654,
-0.0393418558,
-0.0171085894,
0.0734487697,
0.0238567721,
-0.0351702794,
0.001459526,
-0.0268752966,
-0.0642149523,
-0.0112680085,
0.0266105887,
0.0263031125,
0.0324103273,
-0.0255905744,
-0.0220184438,
0.0160048716,
0.0207350161,
-0.0207276978,
0.0015437723,
0.0418752134,
0.0502735749,
-0.0241210591,
0.0399762094,
-0.0237250812,
0.010823491,
-0.0317038335,
0.0380946435,
-0.1189738512,
-0.0985847116,
-0.0017960699,
-0.0355909318,
0.0982280299,
0.0172441863,
0.0453776792,
-0.0221478567,
0.024778014,
-0.0417381041,
-0.0347118489,
-0.0016647489,
0.0083536254,
0.0111893415,
-0.0572741479,
-0.0282621272,
0.0125522427,
-0.0146731921,
0.0691761523,
-0.0068122461,
-0.0029842255,
0.0896644816,
-0.0214979444,
-0.0388799906,
-0.0090722088,
0.0001357559,
-0.00243926,
0.0274540894,
0.0284522567,
0.0420361869,
0.0305152722,
-0.0004370204,
-0.0293273367,
0.0378449149,
-0.0108823273,
-0.0892688185,
0.0245037545,
0.0145323491,
0.0323134325,
0.0383985154,
-0.028575616,
0.0630133301,
-0.0054233191,
0.0147355162,
-0.0114385672,
0.0807201713,
-0.004459356,
-0.0178378094,
0.0413522646,
0.0118080936,
-0.0167013779,
0.0777050406,
0.1074198708,
-0.0476560406,
0.0387244597,
-0.0052850279,
-0.0500595756,
-0.0467016362,
-0.0544414781,
-0.0306127947,
0.0427338742,
0.0008447719,
0.0229922812,
-0.0291167349,
-0.0352222137,
0.0607521348,
0.002644184,
0.0033927944,
-0.0120835816,
0.018805718,
0.0180431902,
0.0031840827,
0.0033122501,
-0.0738411322,
-0.0181031413,
0.0223450363,
0.0146718314,
-0.0656815618,
-5.632648974e-33,
-0.0835709646,
-0.0757347196,
-0.0295758713,
0.0357696488,
0.0023530438,
0.0149582028,
-0.0264390539,
0.0501557998,
0.0103203906,
0.0584451295,
0.0059626624,
0.0415259413,
0.0308986027,
0.0259159319,
0.0185493995,
-0.0135135213,
0.0518314205,
0.0208003428,
-0.0063737337,
-0.0019536763,
0.0662375912,
-0.012186043,
0.0497906245,
-0.1140576899,
0.0419135317,
-0.0027224566,
0.0068336031,
0.0561418049,
0.0227418747,
0.0469492935,
-0.0018771858,
0.0225967821,
-0.0027088039,
0.0161430538,
-0.0054051639,
0.0009858523,
-0.0532091968,
-0.0271722246,
0.0332694054,
0.0487632081,
-0.0204376522,
-0.0197780896,
-0.0032282812,
0.0079364805,
0.0089795198,
-0.0040630819,
0.0498140492,
-0.0137136569,
-0.0332991742,
-0.0116800247,
-0.0159846004,
0.0400865711,
-0.0535019524,
-0.0232739523,
0.0042097638,
0.033096984,
0.0580025613,
-0.080824703,
-0.0550763458,
0.0222396087,
-0.0706820861,
0.0061994186,
0.0175090861,
0.0224672426,
-0.0026397312,
0.0609727651,
-0.0206891075,
0.0246176943,
-0.0242629051,
0.0044180839,
-0.0120624583,
-0.004512744,
-0.0165836588,
0.0473553613,
-0.0734516308,
0.0436215773,
-0.0413964055,
0.0070319958,
-0.0011637403,
0.0240988787,
-0.0100393826,
0.039589487,
-0.0326534063,
-0.0207903534,
-0.0676083639,
-0.0751531124,
0.0094087934,
-0.0129765067,
-0.030648347,
-0.0414722115,
-0.0227025785,
0.0431248732,
0.0212083869,
0.0059275483,
-0.0625691116,
-0.0168189928,
0.0015218868,
0.0402072966,
-0.0026100434,
0.0327564515,
0.0048591718,
-0.021707831,
0.0268743206,
0.0134943519,
0.0437086746,
0.018300565,
0.0620893054,
-0.0047115772,
-0.0519322976,
-0.0143311359,
0.0081686815,
-0.0286038853,
-0.0610209256,
0.0070746066,
0.0325215459,
0.035080459,
-0.0256444085,
0.0525871404,
-0.0211347453,
0.0543832369,
0.0052660392,
-0.0162407309,
-0.0354294404,
-0.0001833339,
-0.0125733819,
-0.0433179736,
0.02126728,
0.0240136981,
-0.0024169858,
-0.0119165815,
-0.0049332292,
-0.0007758326,
2.147e-7,
0.053796079,
0.0594629385,
0.0486099645,
-0.0247064251,
0.0326204784,
0.018779438,
0.0207223576,
-0.0146649992,
0.0341869742,
-0.0785108954,
0.0089039924,
-0.0010074523,
0.0205306187,
0.0645329133,
-0.0588196516,
-0.0939401612,
-0.0797902718,
-0.0105675794,
0.0107276961,
0.0097082425,
0.0832384601,
0.0497108884,
0.0112685999,
0.0337629244,
-0.0352398828,
0.0171250533,
0.0634035096,
-0.0166643616,
-0.0107133202,
0.0243750177,
0.0078357654,
-0.0061940942,
0.0053503858,
0.0700243711,
0.0003185992,
-0.0027704923,
0.0267296936,
0.0332505703,
0.0179510117,
-0.0268601011,
-0.0360928997,
0.0295659583,
0.0122304996,
0.0316483863,
0.0043426519,
-0.0512095615,
-0.0484918356,
0.0086818356,
-0.0284525398,
-0.0074954578,
0.041431427,
0.0119089494,
-0.0150576299,
0.025389893,
-0.0152421147,
0.0103210369,
0.0007225436,
-0.0249745715,
-0.0013845118,
0.0020116756,
-0.0357402191,
-0.026645232,
0.0381567739,
-0.0508461818,
-0.0039532925,
-0.0120115206,
0.0423707217,
1.197091534e-34,
0.0385446846,
0.0108959367,
-0.0047123032,
0.0217286758,
0.0479347631,
-0.0347864218,
-0.0105281528,
0.0131311417,
0.03715856,
-0.0365385301,
0.0059905164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07124v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07124v2 | OctoPack: Instruction Tuning Code Large Language Models | 2023-08-14T13:53:54 | 2024-02-18T09:46:06 | Niklas Muennighoff, Qian Liu, Armel Zebaze, Qinkai Zheng, Binyuan Hui, Terry Yue Zhuo, Swayam Singh, Xiangru Tang, Leandro von Werra, Shayne Longpre | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Finetuning large language models (LLMs) on instructions leads to vast
performance improvements on natural language tasks. We apply instruction tuning
using code, leveraging the natural structure of Git commits, which pair code
changes with human instructions. We compile CommitPack: 4 terabytes of Git
commits across 350 programming languages. We benchmark CommitPack against other
natural and synthetic code instructions (xP3x, Self-Instruct, OASST) on the 16B
parameter StarCoder model, and achieve state-of-the-art performance among
models not trained on OpenAI outputs, on the HumanEval Python benchmark (46.2%
pass@1). We further introduce HumanEvalPack, expanding the HumanEval benchmark
to a total of 3 coding tasks (Code Repair, Code Explanation, Code Synthesis)
across 6 languages (Python, JavaScript, Java, Go, C++, Rust). Our models,
OctoCoder and OctoGeeX, achieve the best performance across HumanEvalPack among
all permissive models, demonstrating CommitPack's benefits in generalizing to a
wider set of languages and natural coding tasks. Code, models and data are
freely available at https://github.com/bigcode-project/octopack. | [
0.0223651119,
0.0950901061,
-0.0262059905,
-0.0000380781,
0.0035528408,
0.0232633445,
-0.039941486,
0.0051031723,
-0.0093274973,
0.0021886581,
-0.0078823995,
0.0289075747,
0.0169339161,
0.0380672626,
0.0285171811,
-0.0323879607,
0.051320821,
-0.0440312251,
0.0023330476,
0.0229439549,
-0.0276862625,
0.0163043533,
0.0100646233,
0.0440716259,
0.0210424345,
-0.031747926,
-0.0143463984,
0.0227378737,
0.0250060726,
0.0212223809,
0.0106090875,
0.0276055802,
0.0042854212,
0.0179350767,
0.0000022008,
-0.0084542101,
0.0053329561,
0.0045085563,
0.0026528628,
0.0501702763,
-0.0035113564,
-0.0679476038,
-0.0301226042,
0.0324856229,
-0.0205723476,
-0.0074088941,
0.0648813918,
-0.0490822233,
0.0903868824,
0.0866562426,
0.0226512384,
-0.0268295277,
0.0200491231,
-0.0004076809,
0.026344901,
0.0142412866,
-0.0195326917,
0.0223462507,
-0.0150669264,
0.0159102436,
-0.0056269853,
0.0027379314,
0.0509339981,
-0.0077182492,
0.0393923894,
0.0579653122,
-0.0053058928,
-0.0071453084,
-0.0050335438,
0.034782812,
-0.0931583792,
-0.033652246,
-0.0064382958,
-0.010888163,
-0.0110099884,
-0.0502251722,
-0.033833459,
0.065583542,
-0.0051349043,
0.0038296769,
0.0035049573,
-0.0578504354,
0.0253951233,
0.0001814256,
-0.0023174153,
0.0449116342,
0.0061151241,
0.0091763595,
-0.0392895639,
-0.0302730706,
-0.0499191955,
-0.0802086294,
-0.0180817004,
0.0769693702,
-0.0339884162,
-0.0047577838,
-0.0414369255,
-0.0113162762,
0.0174195226,
-0.058590252,
0.0405319631,
0.0611700788,
-0.0431400649,
0.008887196,
-0.05223196,
0.0851761475,
0.0024452372,
0.0348299965,
0.000049509,
0.001087014,
-0.0558893532,
0.0208473075,
-0.0317017473,
0.0106888376,
-0.0102076102,
0.0325836129,
-0.0110757928,
0.0332606137,
0.0044814115,
0.0520035736,
0.0160607193,
-0.0338027403,
-0.0626944304,
-0.0015710214,
0.0166185983,
-0.0138521865,
-0.0594467074,
-0.0524176657,
0.0019524626,
-0.0444401167,
-0.0419653542,
0.0158845726,
-0.0511070043,
-0.0463483259,
0.0240635648,
0.02820432,
0.0201057661,
0.0295289215,
-0.0369597748,
-0.0474529378,
0.0002931572,
-0.0691155717,
-0.0158776138,
-0.0637989193,
-0.0255239923,
0.0005597477,
0.0047928188,
-0.1015431657,
-0.0024314297,
0.0078011453,
-0.0217343196,
0.0311540868,
-0.0463648699,
0.010668206,
-0.0194007885,
0.0156370811,
-0.0023626036,
0.012972231,
0.0346666463,
0.0335555412,
-0.0047328253,
-0.0629932433,
0.0511728451,
0.0067529166,
-0.0092921862,
0.02139383,
0.0170920379,
0.0285791848,
0.0237521362,
0.0167632755,
0.0859350786,
0.0665752888,
-0.0031834794,
-0.026917832,
0.014307525,
0.0024153155,
-0.0077516283,
0.0491289832,
0.0639638603,
0.0161697734,
0.0030058972,
-0.0126721831,
-0.0568838716,
0.0653579831,
0.0033843501,
0.0122242821,
-0.0124741467,
0.0251379386,
-0.0287631899,
-0.0339322612,
-0.0061259558,
-0.0251554921,
-0.0186075829,
-0.0049826698,
0.011242439,
-0.0194060709,
-0.0472783446,
0.0042110151,
0.0137761524,
-0.0754646733,
-0.0275438763,
-0.0678610802,
0.0258349776,
0.0454352386,
0.0473601967,
-0.0453723446,
-0.0350533277,
-0.0135273589,
0.0092832921,
-0.0152335363,
0.0403480232,
0.0031123259,
0.0133161182,
-0.0438234173,
-0.0032643178,
-0.0691548213,
-0.0112737305,
0.0145267174,
0.0491645075,
-0.0324797407,
0.0148601662,
0.0098902825,
-0.045858603,
0.0325620323,
-0.011246183,
-0.0142484885,
-0.0010375235,
-0.0175801627,
0.0160348676,
-0.0224517398,
-0.0471159481,
0.0042179916,
0.0436430238,
0.0060428712,
-0.0090608886,
-0.0230855104,
-0.01679153,
-0.0089373104,
0.0387205258,
-0.0037452993,
-0.0330697782,
0.031124698,
-0.0485337377,
-0.018289784,
0.0551913492,
-0.0410481319,
0.0212273803,
0.0156218847,
0.0096426858,
-0.0248453859,
0.007235839,
-0.0215317421,
0.034230262,
-0.0077903201,
-0.0036600465,
0.0008804353,
0.0270823538,
0.0127791623,
0.006427974,
0.0148831224,
0.0131748272,
-0.023861913,
0.0347716808,
0.0040134243,
0.0410940722,
-0.0096952962,
-0.0643805489,
-0.0718788803,
0.0226447843,
-0.0433685146,
-0.0008472379,
0.0305085629,
0.0098060649,
0.0044225603,
-0.0181362573,
-0.0036648065,
0.0163390301,
-0.0213242993,
0.0213875975,
0.006953002,
-0.0029641739,
-0.0639318749,
-0.0522571057,
-0.0140878558,
-0.0180866905,
0.0123983454,
-0.0014133276,
-0.0160411671,
-0.0919023231,
0.0341596454,
0.0015978182,
0.0408990607,
-0.0020345321,
-0.0858667791,
0.0225467775,
-0.0339154191,
0.0703488067,
0.0821104571,
-0.0300333351,
-0.0056693689,
0.071137175,
0.0113608269,
-0.0365536809,
0.0162338745,
0.0227631107,
-0.0737163499,
-0.0205145013,
-0.0402570702,
-0.0026852556,
0.0760008544,
0.0037230281,
-0.0161469728,
-0.0776256695,
-0.0077207289,
0.0172510333,
0.0024091902,
0.0490028597,
-0.0305090137,
0.0157993846,
0.0350565687,
-0.0448780321,
-0.0926721394,
0.0538605042,
-0.0169453751,
-0.0152799794,
-0.002217965,
-0.0160939265,
-0.0515338667,
0.0722110495,
0.0269250888,
0.0138277113,
0.0153613677,
-0.0281724371,
-0.009651891,
0.01401971,
-0.0252379365,
0.0000884954,
0.0078235716,
-0.0686776936,
-0.000443523,
-0.0091124848,
-0.0453162678,
-0.0042949906,
-0.0283743795,
-0.0261287987,
0.0045199245,
0.0326171108,
-0.061064139,
0.0166895539,
-0.010660843,
0.0213022325,
0.0476660952,
0.0028261633,
-0.0331469364,
-0.0314630046,
-0.058294937,
0.0053970977,
0.003276848,
-0.0161593761,
-0.0162215643,
-0.0155133521,
0.0203257501,
0.0420498699,
0.0142209744,
-0.0916485712,
0.0150489453,
0.0318261161,
-0.0266689323,
-0.0401894487,
0.0513464808,
0.0792548805,
-0.0476060361,
-0.0433607027,
0.0939096659,
0.0304765888,
-0.0558566339,
0.0249943417,
-0.0111281602,
0.047405608,
0.0395857506,
0.0570505299,
-0.0919553861,
-0.044674851,
0.00984006,
0.0251023918,
0.0186428372,
-0.0132103544,
0.0015869193,
-0.0902230144,
0.0342126749,
0.0178672522,
-0.0426972657,
-0.0634219497,
-0.0501170941,
-0.0208822303,
-0.0224181544,
-0.0287654996,
0.0489222147,
-0.0169564057,
0.0393583588,
-0.0030957728,
0.003731265,
0.0166460965,
0.0692768842,
-0.0284649152,
0.0550011322,
0.0858441442,
-0.0077512171,
0.0482792519,
-0.0039228536,
0.0864265487,
0.0099648554,
0.0310699847,
-0.0208082013,
0.0635930151,
0.0221858695,
-0.0240209773,
0.0353016183,
0.0284159537,
-0.0544770621,
0.0132804392,
0.0112725142,
0.0528735742,
-0.0202129874,
-0.0166226123,
-0.0135821737,
-0.0245966259,
-0.0205231402,
0.028408125,
0.038604375,
-0.0180662535,
-0.0552098453,
-0.0693628117,
0.0027265747,
-0.0670846105,
-0.0281228311,
-0.0060498891,
0.0123231784,
-0.0440429263,
-0.04303037,
-0.0265239701,
0.0083148321,
0.0026367055,
0.0526769273,
-0.0702052638,
0.0339953825,
0.0067000003,
-0.0650308058,
0.0249964129,
-0.0285859164,
0.022212483,
-0.0786214843,
-0.0376734063,
0.0095713539,
0.0025706815,
-0.0024270022,
-0.0111239376,
-0.0674175993,
-0.0447279327,
-0.0118521973,
0.0965913534,
0.0201166812,
0.0440825261,
-0.0275677945,
-0.0768789276,
-0.089814201,
-0.0000014132,
-0.0335796662,
0.0318129882,
0.0221833512,
-0.0271713231,
0.0232194848,
0.0072889603,
-0.0210999995,
0.0051748278,
0.0180901848,
-0.0012884651,
-0.0314489566,
-0.0112817399,
0.0376329534,
0.0051737409,
0.0229672119,
0.0352695361,
-0.0188058168,
0.0096195424,
-0.0019278672,
0.0259145144,
0.0074765314,
-0.0451225154,
0.0217825714,
0.0365669206,
-0.0286652129,
0.0279521011,
0.051040668,
-0.0267824493,
0.0310099386,
-0.0138012301,
0.0109498035,
0.0231869202,
0.0842690691,
0.0432658121,
0.0031174147,
-0.0133447722,
0.0291849766,
0.0034274769,
0.0424204618,
-0.0202879459,
0.0443471335,
0.0146404877,
0.0459438823,
0.00009623,
0.0094360709,
-0.0564867519,
-0.0624971688,
-0.0075189727,
-0.0274111684,
0.0473989397,
0.0526478365,
0.0522382967,
-0.0069706794,
-9.887e-7,
-0.0333281979,
0.0548432432,
0.0019833627,
-0.0338728279,
-0.0191085506,
0.0178828798,
-0.0210328307,
-0.0225674883,
0.0783832967,
0.0111513119,
0.0540244505,
-0.0030999801,
-0.0057755592,
-0.0143257538,
-0.0000946992,
-0.020298332,
-0.031469088,
0.0034434949,
-0.0103089008,
-0.000829467,
-0.0454422012,
-0.0334146954,
0.0445624925,
0.0331332572,
-0.011963008,
0.0319910459,
0.0475352928,
-0.0159382839,
-0.0447498709,
-0.0265821144,
0.0251740851,
0.0104460008,
-0.0574865155,
-0.0316563621,
-6.100846537e-33,
-0.0208494868,
0.0086943358,
0.0274018981,
0.0234320294,
-0.012906244,
-0.008495572,
-0.0824430957,
0.0002834288,
-0.0497272722,
-0.0200396236,
0.0063533797,
0.0485914983,
-0.0060988897,
-0.0204054061,
0.058796823,
0.0283055995,
0.0698598474,
0.0152956853,
-0.0561197102,
0.0529499203,
0.0045766747,
0.0008293188,
0.0269443672,
-0.0365931913,
-0.0376827233,
0.0446547568,
0.009051837,
0.000023072,
-0.0133447004,
0.0227497313,
0.0078398809,
-0.0005589256,
-0.0066537964,
-0.0130305551,
-0.0350148939,
-0.0245727748,
-0.038860023,
-0.0050364649,
0.0085537499,
0.0110466713,
-0.0150266038,
-0.0985252857,
0.0480502844,
0.0109436102,
-0.0301501565,
-0.0193475671,
0.0168902799,
-0.013968301,
-0.0132276947,
0.0075980714,
-0.0487752371,
0.0314593017,
-0.041216772,
-0.0528538115,
0.0148479789,
-0.0004148428,
0.0201537777,
0.0470707342,
0.0030916641,
0.003078833,
0.0283789057,
0.078493163,
0.0509451479,
-0.0318948366,
-0.0157773159,
0.0223585702,
0.0465186797,
0.026031239,
-0.0155003322,
0.075557515,
0.0321938396,
0.057416603,
0.0477481559,
-0.0108788628,
0.0305878073,
-0.0015784577,
-0.0368979722,
0.0062724752,
0.019639343,
0.0482467227,
-0.0237609558,
0.0492427871,
-0.0217129104,
0.0040235156,
-0.030598551,
-0.0042491932,
-0.0300606973,
-0.0112662595,
0.0287545826,
-0.0081596952,
-0.0260663815,
0.010077402,
0.0224810317,
-0.0250466689,
0.0470515378,
0.0335200131,
-0.0670755208,
0.0649814606,
0.0040168036,
0.0167176202,
-0.0289059114,
-0.0342124999,
0.0244209152,
0.0252773259,
0.0981879458,
0.0273512974,
0.0230354797,
0.0418005064,
-0.0520014763,
0.0066639017,
-0.0660093501,
0.0080480268,
-0.0332228094,
0.0245879181,
-0.0080942549,
0.0245273057,
0.02223612,
0.04031175,
-0.027717907,
-0.0187442843,
-0.0572122484,
0.0347395688,
0.0265983585,
0.0127350213,
-0.0127686495,
-0.0139683597,
-0.0445011929,
0.0323887393,
-0.0333378129,
-0.0569754876,
-0.054706119,
0.0501737073,
2.802e-7,
-0.0131479343,
0.065436326,
0.0237608757,
0.0478486232,
0.0157948229,
0.0305608176,
-0.0272229854,
0.0007190477,
0.0206554644,
-0.0110751186,
-0.023989724,
0.0237490628,
0.032947775,
0.0171953347,
-0.0189213026,
-0.0106750373,
-0.0363920406,
0.0083766142,
-0.0803465471,
-0.0130865695,
0.0011238646,
0.07963413,
0.0169624612,
-0.0002197256,
0.0525039956,
-0.0138579933,
0.0001776649,
0.0307362191,
0.0263187494,
0.0381051898,
-0.0868448839,
0.0349318273,
-0.0278602242,
-0.0270988736,
-0.0281250477,
-0.0490681529,
-0.0239788741,
0.105380401,
-0.026942987,
0.017028505,
0.0451555513,
-0.0109780142,
-0.0099210683,
-0.0374505259,
0.0456191264,
-0.0135542192,
0.0157711543,
0.0052948915,
-0.0079978919,
0.017045958,
0.0309489071,
-0.0272652153,
0.0159460623,
0.0201581735,
0.0182872768,
-0.0178271327,
-0.0408137888,
-0.0417671092,
-0.0510385446,
0.0217909776,
-0.0032076915,
-0.0299459454,
-0.0535676293,
0.0389155149,
0.0189160425,
-0.0554074906,
0.0035170903,
2.804077259e-34,
0.047517892,
-0.0470136441,
0.0231741648,
0.0070830812,
0.0581188276,
-0.0122678913,
-0.0428802483,
0.0229293387,
0.0118885292,
-0.0139868166,
-0.0511516966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07134v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07134v5 | Language is All a Graph Needs | 2023-08-14T13:41:09 | 2024-02-06T03:08:44 | Ruosong Ye, Caiqi Zhang, Runhui Wang, Shuyuan Xu, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | The emergence of large-scale pre-trained language models has revolutionized
various AI research domains. Transformers-based Large Language Models (LLMs)
have gradually replaced CNNs and RNNs to unify fields of computer vision and
natural language processing. Compared with independent data samples such as
images, videos or texts, graphs usually contain rich structural and relational
information. Meanwhile, language, especially natural language, being one of the
most expressive mediums, excels in describing complex structures. However,
existing work on incorporating graph problems into the generative language
modeling framework remains very limited. Considering the rising prominence of
LLMs, it becomes essential to explore whether LLMs can also replace GNNs as the
foundation model for graphs. In this paper, we propose InstructGLM
(Instruction-finetuned Graph Language Model) with highly scalable prompts based
on natural language instructions. We use natural language to describe
multi-scale geometric structure of the graph and then instruction finetune an
LLM to perform graph tasks, which enables Generative Graph Learning. Our method
surpasses all GNN baselines on ogbn-arxiv, Cora and PubMed datasets,
underscoring its effectiveness and sheds light on generative LLMs as new
foundation model for graph machine learning. Our code is open-sourced at
https://github.com/agiresearch/InstructGLM. | [
0.0389122739,
0.0512635075,
0.0017581347,
0.0358842798,
-0.0194570851,
0.004471716,
0.0046086065,
0.0059277546,
0.0584682673,
-0.0240547825,
-0.0175692737,
-0.0304615442,
-0.0036400205,
0.049686294,
0.0364833474,
-0.0407233462,
-0.0074424776,
-0.0281535387,
0.0087964889,
-0.0209527016,
-0.0115056178,
0.0533983335,
0.031026395,
0.0172213838,
-0.0170045439,
-0.0100776833,
-0.0049709314,
0.0403517485,
-0.0397465341,
-0.045243226,
-0.0215833411,
0.0336963534,
0.0513746068,
0.0276143122,
0.0000018966,
-0.0088077821,
0.0200461149,
0.0054463227,
-0.0084696524,
0.0072523206,
0.0406193361,
-0.0462014042,
0.0230853725,
0.0053089126,
-0.0553335696,
-0.0669580474,
0.0576860867,
0.0270859171,
0.0522718765,
0.087730594,
-0.0258859619,
-0.0602938123,
0.0216891952,
-0.0586571321,
0.0041555963,
-0.0428708382,
0.0334624909,
0.0146648437,
0.0026982308,
0.0316270664,
-0.0787704438,
0.0181895662,
0.0196929015,
-0.0211026333,
0.0405168347,
0.0417248495,
0.0064238519,
0.0015158626,
-0.00352617,
0.1305247098,
-0.0257295705,
-0.0218715239,
0.0336846337,
-0.033088766,
-0.0091572404,
0.0333654508,
-0.0387379117,
0.0023020713,
0.0203366857,
0.0276610181,
-0.0357724242,
-0.0345129222,
0.0619120561,
-0.0139749357,
-0.0163881294,
0.0382933319,
0.0158272274,
0.0139380926,
-0.0068575176,
0.0043784562,
-0.0356794782,
-0.0419574641,
-0.0256447028,
0.0416746475,
-0.0365814529,
0.0019935495,
-0.0326045342,
-0.0079925396,
-0.0004284136,
0.0066348561,
0.0675310344,
-0.0472982079,
0.0107398275,
0.0391187817,
-0.0082086166,
0.0471186712,
-0.0510232486,
0.0761444196,
-0.0457615182,
-0.0091500152,
-0.0276187956,
0.0156559404,
-0.0641166195,
-0.0098903505,
-0.0041754888,
-0.0607622825,
-0.0360780507,
0.0319259427,
0.0030392485,
0.0064405994,
0.0414565317,
0.0402388647,
-0.0118061369,
-0.0359838568,
0.0084873857,
0.011752855,
-0.0026789315,
0.0024755849,
-0.0223393552,
-0.029654298,
-0.0032710102,
0.0390882194,
0.068739213,
-0.0213694926,
0.0252082329,
0.0934100896,
0.0317152962,
-0.0412245877,
-0.002403798,
-0.0046681347,
-0.0191031452,
-0.0674660355,
0.0480847806,
-0.0878560171,
0.0523522459,
0.0126256458,
-0.0125359669,
-0.0610367283,
0.0235703606,
-0.0016697724,
-0.0524955243,
0.0667062625,
-0.0276965797,
0.0261830576,
-0.0069028274,
-0.0336784646,
0.0243398231,
0.0004818384,
0.0562213734,
0.0407350697,
0.0267200675,
-0.0024359229,
0.0211963542,
0.0387392081,
0.0403664485,
0.0023653263,
0.0224578436,
-0.0177969746,
-0.0541255958,
0.0247160327,
-0.0094504114,
0.104048565,
-0.0208296664,
-0.0218560342,
0.034876518,
0.0490047187,
0.0003514292,
0.0173562169,
0.0733563155,
0.0500188619,
-0.0358510911,
-0.021774888,
-0.0568078123,
0.0189637169,
0.0338187329,
0.0254671481,
-0.0142517528,
-0.0217776783,
-0.0180852618,
-0.0122853685,
0.0036357292,
-0.0364010856,
0.0712438226,
-0.0047242101,
0.0834043026,
0.0543775558,
-0.0645989031,
0.0004985796,
0.0264090635,
-0.0254122484,
0.0084551359,
-0.0123855574,
-0.0157219898,
0.0453548655,
0.0430817604,
0.0147369867,
-0.0187169518,
0.0015865967,
0.0123823397,
0.0177630745,
0.0377026238,
-0.0125394622,
-0.0130575197,
-0.0585383251,
-0.0139623601,
-0.0199951604,
-0.0107377544,
0.0086298399,
0.0263511185,
-0.0121315727,
0.0181052405,
-0.0776147693,
-0.0623850189,
0.014741281,
0.0079090474,
-0.0148285236,
0.0249268953,
-0.0000885853,
-0.0045396937,
0.0162735321,
-0.0054968316,
0.0323190391,
0.0246304292,
-0.0083729932,
-0.0219252631,
-0.0219618436,
-0.0358124711,
-0.0449359939,
0.0269235689,
-0.0419070609,
-0.0342093706,
-0.0102618784,
-0.0776626989,
-0.0319602005,
0.0531390384,
-0.0667009428,
0.0292835217,
0.0004986505,
-0.0187821575,
0.0104578286,
0.0254372451,
-0.0162095875,
0.0485849343,
0.0067380038,
0.0123358546,
0.0140490886,
0.0353854969,
-0.0116558615,
-0.036982026,
-0.0324761979,
0.0058241738,
0.0152446199,
0.0135759357,
0.0207185056,
0.0183715839,
-0.0145395221,
0.0055237161,
-0.0682598129,
-0.0055370233,
-0.0090370048,
0.0131025678,
-0.011336158,
0.0078007346,
0.0071890862,
-0.0370318182,
-0.0455193073,
0.0486949123,
0.0347433686,
0.0056572831,
0.0386168659,
-0.0288347192,
-0.0228678565,
-0.0217003971,
-0.061814744,
-0.0152900284,
0.0878452286,
0.0513343401,
-0.0129025923,
-0.0107546533,
0.0384907946,
-0.0295640454,
0.0341738164,
-0.0097608939,
-0.0180559102,
0.0090662353,
-0.0397819728,
0.06502489,
0.0473496132,
-0.0100747477,
0.0398713425,
0.0231580343,
-0.0083364807,
-0.008170967,
-0.0190178249,
-0.0821524486,
-0.0398897603,
-0.0429665186,
-0.0340033062,
-0.005831731,
0.028528301,
0.0009744529,
-0.0166436881,
-0.0485619083,
-0.0174143482,
-0.004586847,
0.0266802292,
0.0011990952,
-0.0127516771,
0.0061493977,
0.0023935877,
-0.0359533429,
-0.0422138683,
0.0576780848,
-0.0344754234,
-0.0084972549,
0.0418221094,
-0.0246099681,
-0.0565980785,
0.093608968,
0.0817427188,
0.0192980394,
0.0096262936,
-0.0286429338,
-0.0366494879,
0.0188376363,
0.0296951421,
-0.031078143,
0.0157498978,
-0.0152468327,
0.0381812118,
0.0048627779,
-0.0195125714,
-0.0092880232,
0.0159337837,
-0.0158456918,
0.023438042,
0.0419873036,
-0.0560625009,
0.0022323432,
-0.0054364908,
-0.0196839701,
0.0236043222,
-0.007426389,
0.0109526087,
-0.0397597998,
0.0520854741,
0.0484734327,
-0.0037385875,
-0.0138750281,
-0.047301285,
-0.0193453915,
0.0377069153,
0.0001098037,
0.0101892129,
-0.0463741496,
0.0093234973,
-0.0025962053,
0.0322269425,
-0.0020653894,
0.0035876667,
0.0398408994,
-0.0311324429,
-0.0196585637,
0.0784831792,
0.0028462654,
-0.0457463562,
-0.0056129238,
0.0553102121,
0.0249665566,
0.017936375,
0.0153790861,
-0.1045256779,
-0.0043797507,
-0.0131292306,
0.0050952975,
0.0295043662,
-0.0507071093,
-0.0169781614,
-0.1091744602,
0.0296397489,
0.0099349543,
0.0072230892,
-0.0463428758,
-0.0422569625,
-0.0322291255,
-0.0079669431,
-0.0262310021,
-0.0412949063,
-0.0257796142,
-0.0016854011,
0.007363556,
-0.0111270314,
-0.0289314669,
0.0109248748,
-0.043957673,
0.0243098885,
0.0086571444,
0.0430756658,
0.0183578301,
-0.0158859063,
0.0546563715,
0.0292799324,
-0.0130243348,
-0.0077750734,
0.0556461923,
0.0087871058,
-0.0203526169,
-0.0335509144,
0.0258746464,
-0.0524844825,
-0.034521196,
-0.0389099866,
0.0585024022,
-0.0132453712,
-0.0527415946,
-0.0013036679,
-0.0024777027,
0.0020683014,
0.0153281903,
0.0492512546,
-0.0109826922,
-0.0662474185,
-0.048464898,
0.0542121865,
-0.0634333193,
-0.0754770413,
0.0181041099,
-0.0164688751,
-0.0007158595,
-0.0494616553,
0.0030722104,
0.0312161352,
-0.0108316289,
0.0092402035,
-0.0371236354,
0.0830899104,
-0.0377751961,
-0.0778383613,
0.0099057434,
-0.0490666479,
0.0309696794,
-0.0533232018,
-0.043946635,
0.0532968454,
0.0038896017,
-0.011992611,
0.0447469391,
-0.0882929862,
-0.0748522133,
-0.0272291917,
0.0293705501,
0.0062258723,
0.015599587,
-0.0225790534,
-0.0159215797,
0.0422955044,
0.0457588956,
-0.0051734736,
-0.0055665122,
-0.0011616051,
-0.0175706372,
-0.0251274221,
0.0345875174,
-0.0486993566,
0.0423894189,
0.0416890569,
0.031394057,
-0.011547734,
-0.0487710163,
-0.0066491193,
0.0448036417,
0.0371947736,
-0.003903246,
0.0293987785,
-0.0691343248,
-0.0444908664,
-0.0124614388,
-0.0124308886,
-0.0372343548,
-0.0249472931,
0.0212175418,
0.0068232086,
-0.0118237147,
-0.0102637867,
0.0126774246,
0.0334227718,
-0.0211241525,
-0.0007876515,
0.0008636756,
-0.049075108,
0.0692040473,
0.0074114799,
0.0016694618,
0.0494321473,
-0.0132918442,
0.001129174,
0.0061164708,
0.0085336277,
0.02978535,
-0.0124381529,
-0.0536111444,
0.0099244732,
-0.0443552844,
-0.0505840406,
-0.0195067916,
0.0272543728,
0.057614468,
0.0217667595,
0.0280140955,
-0.0300758444,
-0.0031066893,
-0.0364616998,
0.082686305,
-0.0212064423,
-0.0803005025,
0.0546509437,
0.0103803705,
-0.0135092055,
0.0131231826,
0.071694307,
0.0832016915,
0.0114890542,
0.0081047369,
-0.0227364227,
-0.0337929949,
-0.0455452204,
-0.0354646407,
0.0012358193,
0.004676763,
0.0361210108,
-0.014612386,
-0.1050554067,
-0.0082507497,
0.0086669605,
0.0065922807,
0.0101002166,
0.0377834998,
0.0170499086,
0.0252140313,
-0.011434529,
-0.0439296924,
0.0737283751,
-0.0091453847,
-0.0416349806,
-0.0032781994,
-6.101109922e-33,
0.0066793314,
-0.0955340788,
0.0122710327,
0.0257994048,
-0.0451475531,
0.0062267869,
-0.0573369414,
0.0018611195,
-0.0164904501,
0.0362255275,
0.0005119815,
0.0155012626,
-0.0091621932,
0.0645094663,
-0.0235687234,
-0.0180294309,
0.0403323956,
-0.0141797112,
0.0089421598,
0.0652851462,
0.0155198798,
0.007479216,
0.037291117,
-0.0582361855,
0.0016718714,
-0.0489115268,
0.0116598876,
0.027382778,
-0.0008543983,
0.0234888252,
-0.0198459607,
0.0431746878,
0.0234014038,
0.008313505,
-0.0103050498,
0.0467646234,
-0.0794917047,
-0.0107308915,
-0.0059469286,
0.0119680762,
-0.0742454529,
-0.0194255318,
0.0513503738,
-0.0140577368,
0.0180621538,
-0.027129963,
0.0531003587,
0.0234790687,
-0.0273388922,
-0.0122644668,
-0.040784277,
0.0212726463,
-0.0030211166,
-0.0219762661,
0.008658546,
-0.0180982873,
0.0153527763,
0.0248503126,
-0.0338750109,
0.0445835143,
-0.0359062962,
0.0004731566,
0.0102545656,
0.0358505957,
0.0306846406,
0.0340593196,
-0.0030786451,
-0.0077523957,
-0.0379103757,
0.0106826099,
0.012421797,
0.0898041502,
-0.0012951524,
0.0147542469,
-0.0336710885,
-0.0165136755,
-0.0684009641,
-0.017558096,
-0.0444188863,
0.0216554273,
0.0046273065,
0.0120262923,
0.031333182,
-0.0488727354,
-0.0198165756,
-0.0336128809,
-0.0155780148,
-0.0159649588,
-0.0095711872,
0.0089759827,
-0.0297780298,
0.028194027,
0.0126506146,
-0.0674110651,
-0.0505670272,
0.0777858719,
-0.0028810988,
0.0445588641,
-0.0273755807,
0.0236491617,
-0.061559923,
-0.0372367091,
0.029623419,
-0.023488868,
0.0097385524,
0.0175461676,
0.0448890254,
0.0267938804,
-0.0476843677,
-0.0078691961,
-0.0422860384,
-0.008726066,
-0.0210571587,
0.0023082034,
0.0394746102,
0.06561286,
-0.0234598424,
0.057384029,
0.0230776686,
0.0203948002,
-0.0098628374,
0.0346511714,
0.0099723879,
0.0312298387,
-0.0446259789,
-0.0056947218,
-0.0546916388,
0.0288000759,
0.0532289892,
-0.0659055412,
-0.0318726487,
-0.0114917755,
2.656e-7,
0.0638860092,
0.0550664254,
0.0781515017,
0.0621325336,
0.02509108,
0.0192485452,
0.0129536297,
0.0316016562,
-0.0127902068,
0.0014860419,
0.0401242897,
0.0644406825,
-0.0108147478,
0.0133834248,
-0.0628642812,
0.0862436071,
-0.0954461619,
-0.0204380546,
-0.0361413583,
0.0054571028,
0.0319891497,
0.0662488118,
0.0204428975,
-0.0064401021,
-0.0039199404,
-0.036922425,
0.068754755,
-0.0197470095,
0.001822315,
0.0233509652,
-0.0243985876,
0.0056044837,
-0.0479010008,
-0.0005467776,
-0.002347315,
-0.0010863898,
0.0392814055,
0.050407052,
-0.0029643441,
0.0145682422,
0.0214813072,
-0.0268893633,
-0.0015646369,
-0.0090389261,
0.0490321778,
-0.0920889527,
-0.0348238274,
-0.0385341793,
-0.0038488677,
-0.0101069631,
0.0219801553,
-0.0243195314,
-0.0172066446,
0.0229892749,
0.0435980856,
-0.0179670993,
0.0212950818,
-0.0642230213,
0.0148284454,
0.0166831166,
-0.0329443663,
-0.0241704751,
-0.0247690678,
0.0093876999,
0.0124852778,
0.0050393576,
0.032344725,
2.202781364e-34,
0.0301828086,
0.0100495061,
-0.0220586732,
-0.0199286677,
0.0374802165,
-0.0270289462,
-0.0066520204,
0.0291684475,
0.0067596007,
-0.1153621301,
-0.029511923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07120v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07120v2 | Position: Key Claims in LLM Research Have a Long Tail of Footnotes | 2023-08-14T13:00:53 | 2024-06-01T15:20:25 | Anna Rogers, Alexandra Sasha Luccioni | cs.CL | cs.CL | Much of the recent discourse within the ML community has been centered around
Large Language Models (LLMs), their functionality and potential -- yet not only
do we not have a working definition of LLMs, but much of this discourse relies
on claims and assumptions that are worth re-examining. We contribute a
definition of LLMs, critically examine five common claims regarding their
properties (including 'emergent properties'), and conclude with suggestions for
future research directions and their framing. | [
0.0302263815,
0.0554008037,
-0.038439393,
0.0378465578,
-0.0399702266,
0.0175727494,
0.002512313,
0.0201121606,
0.0094877565,
-0.0447683595,
-0.0310600419,
-0.044215437,
0.0105302911,
0.0191574246,
0.0418389812,
-0.0144319152,
-0.0065956372,
-0.0462949276,
-0.0088096047,
-0.0349525884,
-0.0081272861,
-0.0231479611,
0.0495524965,
0.036773745,
0.0277065132,
0.0186418593,
0.0146419453,
-0.0295148231,
-0.0431939736,
0.0050724773,
-0.0422984324,
-0.0070951162,
0.0148372604,
0.0321853831,
0.0000017599,
-0.0818407834,
0.0189730693,
-0.0082558161,
-0.029840298,
0.0276257638,
0.0256713834,
-0.0257304087,
-0.0138931237,
0.0018169016,
-0.0116288671,
-0.015304002,
0.036358159,
-0.0235383268,
-0.0257506464,
0.0604727529,
-0.0077360817,
-0.0688543469,
0.0207288377,
-0.0364913382,
-0.0142843183,
-0.007803028,
0.062639229,
0.0103757922,
0.0255955029,
-0.0081834989,
-0.0244827159,
0.0451113917,
0.0125670666,
-0.0180912949,
-0.0053900806,
0.0333970971,
0.0048855608,
-0.0315131098,
0.0103171151,
0.0244114604,
0.0129784178,
-0.0192969926,
0.0163159147,
-0.0153236063,
0.0067070904,
0.0022257215,
-0.0465621576,
0.0890296623,
0.003001733,
0.059361089,
0.0376266465,
-0.0038465166,
0.078451775,
-0.0026771906,
-0.0467262082,
0.0903597176,
0.007430674,
-0.0151652778,
-0.0225386024,
-0.0022994012,
-0.0175681319,
-0.0482854322,
-0.0190046746,
0.0462066419,
0.0067229485,
0.0460648388,
-0.01866786,
0.0392792933,
0.0276503619,
-0.0580207184,
0.0468104295,
-0.0212022308,
-0.0016802439,
0.060472317,
-0.0186641216,
0.0225916803,
-0.0506896302,
-0.0112540824,
-0.0395435952,
-0.0191209372,
-0.025159277,
-0.0082125021,
-0.0011364468,
0.051654499,
-0.0062222579,
-0.0025493971,
-0.0003792703,
0.0693862364,
0.0203840062,
0.0342117772,
-0.0564050749,
-0.0565737784,
0.0264408514,
-0.0187163595,
-0.029359404,
0.0077424501,
0.0363029316,
0.0210938398,
-0.0356207229,
-0.0502039008,
0.0573878512,
0.0374736674,
-0.0055304375,
-0.0037495566,
-0.0090476852,
0.0730023757,
0.0335707366,
-0.0124750808,
-0.0559675395,
-0.0002408297,
-0.0249308143,
-0.063633129,
-0.0277355146,
-0.0852633491,
-0.0074153389,
0.0543546304,
0.0081879748,
-0.0484251454,
-0.0156120528,
-0.0108239437,
-0.0541636311,
0.0326391049,
-0.0150406286,
0.0312940627,
0.0183544271,
-0.0039650621,
0.0475087985,
0.0754138678,
0.0210154075,
-0.0125441952,
0.0492140688,
-0.019050546,
0.0180419199,
0.090037778,
-0.0123715401,
0.0140806856,
-0.0489012636,
0.0229022037,
-0.0051362258,
0.0177907497,
0.0030514058,
0.0641083047,
-0.0072083259,
-0.0124143148,
0.076879099,
0.075668402,
0.0135084558,
0.0276345648,
0.0207185335,
-0.0259176847,
-0.0021574621,
0.0230589509,
-0.0113130528,
-0.0253139101,
-0.0287515037,
0.0035673352,
0.0103687169,
0.0027759252,
-0.0369164534,
-0.0384019725,
-0.0511408821,
-0.0227502324,
-0.0176485144,
0.0028116582,
0.0758310556,
-0.024264507,
0.0116893156,
0.0369066261,
0.017341828,
-0.009166033,
0.0135909393,
-0.0835958719,
0.0224114899,
0.0265758429,
0.0384820104,
-0.0152000999,
0.0194781572,
-0.0054100635,
0.0037977393,
0.048748821,
0.0314270817,
-0.0127309943,
-0.0076204585,
-0.0070889583,
0.0280675031,
-0.015277476,
0.0092209643,
0.007170632,
-0.0166608896,
0.0028366325,
-0.0159852803,
-0.02256939,
-0.0406517796,
0.0118224686,
-0.0492313504,
-0.0063124634,
-0.0125244856,
-0.0201091506,
0.0496933199,
-0.0048648384,
-0.0126276901,
0.0029596426,
0.0179095399,
-0.0426035859,
-0.0223132428,
0.0079321498,
0.0167537313,
0.0419420041,
0.0513817929,
0.0235047955,
0.0288525,
-0.0146210277,
0.0020651419,
-0.0149708735,
0.0237281751,
-0.0138680656,
0.1025291458,
-0.0204590484,
0.0557061397,
-0.0517873503,
0.0017310367,
-0.0540737621,
0.0430403613,
-0.0338860266,
0.0381630063,
0.0077835508,
0.0252041724,
0.0123095764,
-0.0043939878,
-0.0390183963,
0.044312492,
0.0179540198,
0.0280538313,
0.0316794217,
-0.0347335935,
0.000742748,
-0.0520569496,
-0.0455398746,
-0.0239060689,
-0.017672563,
-0.0062681884,
0.0208312571,
-0.0058669941,
-0.0260334406,
0.0303515941,
-0.0232930258,
0.0167344715,
0.0452625342,
0.0365846939,
0.0471948199,
0.0117377685,
-0.0569350608,
-0.0352637656,
-0.016994739,
0.0077654454,
0.0570927523,
-0.0174732041,
-0.0463058315,
-0.0794447362,
0.0722809806,
-0.0339031629,
0.0361634754,
-0.0387695692,
-0.0021767174,
0.0108662806,
-0.012667763,
0.0541579388,
0.0293768514,
-0.0252211876,
0.0278684888,
0.0551925674,
-0.017860055,
-0.0330617949,
-0.0324501581,
-0.0256292727,
-0.0489216857,
-0.0844694525,
-0.0373266973,
0.0135540757,
0.056965515,
-0.0061963364,
-0.0156870261,
0.0037777598,
0.0190579798,
-0.0460602604,
-0.0158310086,
-0.0065684333,
-0.0085350815,
-0.0239542145,
0.0661233738,
-0.0120224254,
-0.1095626354,
0.0209120642,
-0.031784106,
0.0074360603,
-0.0003031513,
-0.0608153567,
-0.0723315105,
0.0650603399,
0.0243671015,
-0.0012070653,
-0.00468279,
-0.0268802494,
-0.0078889523,
-0.0136268502,
-0.0231524464,
-0.0226348359,
0.1030195653,
-0.0353261754,
0.0425583161,
-0.0004817373,
-0.0337837487,
-0.0257259123,
-0.0306568574,
-0.0488944426,
0.0005292591,
0.027623361,
-0.0322008431,
-0.0339646786,
0.0437951311,
0.0059887255,
0.0204723254,
0.0191768743,
-0.015113906,
-0.005186073,
-0.0076831551,
0.0233144928,
0.0208662786,
0.0358333699,
-0.0529199205,
0.0275688302,
0.0246175434,
0.0260721724,
0.0125893373,
-0.0197056271,
-0.0229246113,
0.0606778078,
-0.0408701524,
-0.0625705048,
0.0152869187,
0.0129629001,
-0.0319705382,
0.0076496014,
0.1068031043,
-0.0034082315,
-0.0161872562,
0.0263586845,
-0.0174339842,
0.0468071774,
0.0314760059,
0.0145630455,
-0.0705416352,
0.0279011894,
-0.0128652174,
0.0094072204,
-0.0173870474,
-0.0210857671,
-0.0303916615,
-0.08895123,
0.0388537124,
0.0120772133,
-0.0352226868,
-0.018450303,
-0.0304422602,
0.003912671,
-0.0105992891,
0.0440613925,
0.0175318718,
-0.0501148365,
-0.0238378029,
0.0312445313,
-0.0531703345,
-0.0491203405,
-0.0164227281,
-0.0569333099,
0.0673399493,
0.0449328832,
0.0085661598,
-0.0381328762,
-0.0061622863,
0.0228464603,
0.0071251523,
-0.0136853792,
-0.0114995167,
-0.0070686592,
0.0203614086,
-0.0205806885,
-0.0185923856,
0.0047041439,
-0.0326788127,
-0.014868523,
0.021717798,
0.0543609038,
-0.0252595861,
-0.0527434237,
-0.0038501639,
-0.032161992,
-0.0536264926,
0.0705216676,
0.024254851,
-0.0674912408,
0.0052714627,
-0.0353354998,
-0.0224798061,
0.0472920164,
-0.0654810518,
0.0230247881,
0.01612412,
-0.0042202575,
-0.017079046,
-0.0070082266,
0.0061257314,
0.0257334616,
0.0231839214,
0.0549329333,
0.0203797389,
-0.0483441129,
-0.0195266753,
-0.0053229667,
-0.0416861251,
-0.0198507998,
-0.0566038266,
-0.0183252282,
0.0610163137,
-0.0172345452,
0.0151023734,
-0.0282276589,
-0.1072101966,
-0.080954358,
0.0123186931,
0.026301872,
0.0272573773,
0.0036151141,
0.021758344,
-0.0915323794,
0.0369446613,
0.0351532437,
-0.009161233,
0.0663233623,
0.0157280527,
0.0202079099,
0.0177928787,
0.0543383397,
-0.0324891172,
-0.0111708706,
0.0195304062,
-0.0103173554,
-0.0307781212,
-0.0379176959,
0.0094663668,
0.0141060054,
-0.0026402876,
-0.0149126621,
0.00450854,
-0.0165862273,
-0.0105307493,
-0.0166310277,
-0.0006283256,
-0.0483005084,
-0.0188779943,
0.0222060475,
0.0471101813,
-0.0443089046,
-0.0017807347,
-0.0252122823,
0.0630056188,
-0.0526274852,
0.0572241098,
-0.0139867878,
-0.0166258886,
0.0713289604,
0.0089082327,
0.0025764287,
0.0513329245,
-0.041578114,
0.0292138029,
0.0225277096,
0.0208783858,
-0.0016622418,
-0.000582777,
0.0148464274,
0.010407662,
-0.0303587485,
-0.0883105472,
0.0270125009,
0.0612059236,
0.0590944737,
-0.0100669432,
0.0597801134,
-0.0519860424,
0.0022144008,
-0.0484733693,
-0.0174273159,
-0.0058501167,
-0.0463824235,
0.0169641227,
0.021513937,
-0.0635503829,
0.051385466,
0.0664128736,
0.0274123009,
0.0332884789,
0.0004819644,
0.0138974357,
-0.0312045962,
-0.0336365737,
0.015295594,
-0.003177847,
-0.0135064581,
0.0147141647,
-0.0757244751,
-0.0630248785,
-0.0012336808,
0.0077768192,
0.0070920256,
-0.0297084246,
-0.0287282337,
0.0886067972,
0.0115461294,
0.011095468,
-0.05732942,
0.0285733473,
-0.0021254299,
-0.0151923401,
0.0409305394,
-5.732934071e-33,
-0.0066101896,
-0.0423787534,
0.0352952741,
0.0234168023,
0.000998847,
0.0110286986,
-0.0011699226,
0.055415418,
-0.0176288411,
-0.0251677986,
-0.0015335475,
-0.0019459471,
-0.0002756065,
0.0209363997,
0.0375609249,
0.0163765531,
0.025733348,
-0.0098596681,
0.0160399806,
0.000619815,
0.0069147674,
-0.0003563843,
0.0294562541,
-0.0568612628,
0.0306158103,
-0.0259291325,
0.0015320093,
0.0188395455,
-0.000917614,
0.0616906509,
-0.0339797512,
0.0642308295,
0.0293156132,
-0.0333857238,
-0.0283909161,
-0.0194044113,
-0.0148487082,
0.0155697716,
0.0611139312,
0.0206573475,
0.0214539915,
-0.0289896652,
0.0722880736,
-0.0283255242,
-0.0257514864,
0.0319539644,
0.0232362505,
-0.047962036,
-0.0294409972,
-0.001014435,
-0.0447738394,
0.0430102237,
0.0232341755,
0.0429312252,
0.0279601049,
-0.0335674323,
-0.0186385289,
0.0396232158,
-0.0515635982,
0.0227713957,
0.042111408,
0.051393196,
0.0626978725,
0.0485660732,
0.0460079163,
0.0631459877,
0.0540342331,
0.0165651999,
-0.0226183552,
-0.0192206055,
0.0388295539,
0.0151675167,
0.0118564535,
0.019127937,
-0.0488299094,
0.0035607729,
-0.0782237798,
-0.0423475727,
0.0338316523,
-0.0323950537,
0.0299519151,
0.0230107438,
-0.0226859059,
-0.0613217726,
-0.022903882,
-0.0196418427,
-0.0040344223,
0.0096092103,
0.0105271246,
-0.0148585765,
0.0181851573,
-0.0147744119,
0.0275791008,
-0.0574705563,
-0.0988831967,
-0.0126328394,
0.0033245904,
0.0442550518,
0.0000217276,
0.0355348885,
-0.0948018283,
-0.0451262556,
-0.0721187145,
-0.0131739723,
-0.0095560662,
0.014616115,
-0.0208118856,
0.0459986106,
-0.0602087937,
-0.0199946146,
-0.0224751104,
0.0110973427,
0.0345316492,
-0.0108599747,
0.0522749387,
-0.0196804013,
0.0198466163,
0.0388024412,
0.0369166471,
-0.0311738402,
-0.0154697588,
0.0084197847,
-0.0176791195,
0.014384117,
-0.0264123064,
-0.0182714425,
-0.0196945481,
0.0715877786,
0.0594186187,
-0.0359850004,
0.0006914398,
-0.0087935366,
2.48e-7,
0.056318216,
0.0373859443,
-0.0040469267,
-0.0016114849,
0.056055408,
0.0199665781,
-0.0417803973,
-0.003442711,
-0.0058825216,
-0.0187727846,
-0.0048684818,
0.0318846814,
0.0214340612,
-0.0007245669,
-0.0745022371,
0.0146953752,
-0.0536410287,
0.0172721967,
-0.0537616648,
0.0002821248,
-0.0147218788,
0.0861976966,
0.0306229219,
-0.0173744131,
-0.0307355318,
-0.0602203608,
0.0586144291,
-0.0709788203,
0.0027626862,
0.0493852794,
0.0208977833,
0.0338375121,
-0.0065387343,
-0.0111891665,
0.0241271891,
0.0557629205,
-0.0347595066,
0.0684351623,
0.0481377952,
0.010096618,
0.0349946246,
-0.0378871337,
-0.0311413836,
-0.0775655136,
0.0737331137,
-0.0611738972,
-0.0615804903,
-0.0569774732,
0.0360698812,
-0.0202737171,
0.0066766017,
-0.005366391,
-0.0121554956,
0.0298939496,
0.0209872797,
-0.0466566198,
0.0129718445,
-0.0630723312,
-0.0202879254,
-0.0070482944,
-0.0550115481,
-0.0704658553,
-0.0286625344,
0.0064080209,
0.0063619982,
-0.0101675894,
0.0203636959,
2.218260925e-34,
0.0460030138,
-0.0075076823,
0.0158426557,
0.0241805241,
0.0077527477,
0.0036703253,
-0.0349608921,
0.0179603063,
0.0243863985,
-0.088824369,
-0.0002134728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07107v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07107v3 | Large Language Models for Information Retrieval: A Survey | 2023-08-14T12:47:22 | 2024-01-19T16:01:28 | Yutao Zhu, Huaying Yuan, Shuting Wang, Jiongnan Liu, Wenhan Liu, Chenlong Deng, Haonan Chen, Zhicheng Dou, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | As a primary means of information acquisition, information retrieval (IR)
systems, such as search engines, have integrated themselves into our daily
lives. These systems also serve as components of dialogue, question-answering,
and recommender systems. The trajectory of IR has evolved dynamically from its
origins in term-based methods to its integration with advanced neural models.
While the neural models excel at capturing complex contextual signals and
semantic nuances, thereby reshaping the IR landscape, they still face
challenges such as data scarcity, interpretability, and the generation of
contextually plausible yet potentially inaccurate responses. This evolution
requires a combination of both traditional methods (such as term-based sparse
retrieval methods with rapid response) and modern neural architectures (such as
language models with powerful language understanding capacity). Meanwhile, the
emergence of large language models (LLMs), typified by ChatGPT and GPT-4, has
revolutionized natural language processing due to their remarkable language
understanding, generation, generalization, and reasoning abilities.
Consequently, recent research has sought to leverage LLMs to improve IR
systems. Given the rapid evolution of this research trajectory, it is necessary
to consolidate existing methodologies and provide nuanced insights through a
comprehensive overview. In this survey, we delve into the confluence of LLMs
and IR systems, including crucial aspects such as query rewriters, retrievers,
rerankers, and readers. Additionally, we explore promising directions, such as
search agents, within this expanding field. | [
0.0877071545,
0.0344719328,
-0.0149825308,
0.0615021735,
-0.0204619747,
-0.0097974362,
-0.0312805548,
0.0136326514,
0.0246701352,
-0.0472253412,
-0.0506291874,
-0.0643889681,
-0.0479698256,
0.0224654227,
-0.0127227195,
-0.0057887919,
0.0363995098,
-0.0100623555,
0.0230263993,
0.0088789072,
0.0180834867,
0.0243856665,
0.0385859236,
0.0401829071,
0.0072163674,
-0.004154284,
-0.010759321,
0.0294516087,
-0.0356842317,
-0.0189805366,
0.0450038016,
0.0237624217,
0.0698834434,
0.0901396796,
0.0000017734,
-0.0195702165,
-0.0311966632,
0.0031805576,
-0.0419227928,
0.0121079171,
0.0411160365,
0.0179623757,
0.0377067365,
-0.0016508737,
-0.0642874911,
-0.0359782018,
0.0278583262,
0.025184799,
0.0479461998,
0.0820573419,
0.0027202815,
-0.0433661379,
0.0296570696,
-0.0432885289,
0.0399919264,
-0.0745228976,
0.0268585812,
-0.0104731144,
0.0307394844,
0.0764961541,
-0.0018426258,
0.0273036268,
0.0065397862,
-0.0102958363,
0.0221352484,
0.0247871019,
-0.0282704923,
0.0045603421,
-0.0043859375,
0.0676605925,
-0.0032205854,
-0.0263496283,
-0.0008197,
0.0410460271,
-0.0028081168,
0.0260866303,
-0.0605299771,
0.0167017058,
0.0053124265,
0.0197691992,
-0.0039077601,
-0.0141388075,
0.0351273157,
0.0362057015,
-0.0391255766,
0.0712266937,
0.0166078527,
-0.0445185639,
-0.0019903039,
-0.0107627101,
-0.0290772263,
-0.0140532693,
0.0373446271,
0.0507583767,
-0.0215388443,
0.0281506311,
0.0075940853,
0.0112564825,
0.0328176357,
-0.0483924523,
-0.0311584044,
0.0312807821,
-0.0059114485,
0.0717026219,
-0.018039884,
0.0471784174,
-0.0263717454,
0.0107282428,
-0.0811984241,
-0.0432256125,
-0.0442698486,
-0.0498309359,
-0.0472775437,
0.0508692116,
-0.0458593145,
-0.0374721326,
-0.031799905,
0.0431487672,
0.0318543166,
-0.0427254401,
-0.0043425891,
0.0403892137,
-0.0460860617,
-0.0093406392,
-0.0703224167,
0.0337681063,
0.013904403,
-0.0014989743,
-0.002960121,
-0.0412753709,
-0.0069988864,
0.0102589624,
0.0124806715,
-0.0567331128,
0.004675644,
0.0327461399,
-0.0056185089,
-0.0542888157,
-0.0212772731,
-0.0244564954,
-0.019201586,
-0.0341244638,
-0.0217122082,
-0.0471551307,
0.0407574177,
0.0005743112,
-0.0200641789,
-0.0422775708,
0.0248795263,
0.0529456027,
-0.0391656533,
0.0604084246,
0.0054957429,
0.0105706099,
0.0453633964,
0.0239533521,
0.0178726371,
0.0384225734,
-0.0004810393,
0.0511000641,
0.0550411493,
0.0095938062,
0.020697562,
0.0075739818,
-0.0081764897,
-0.0058658533,
-0.0051464629,
0.0455298126,
-0.0039373804,
0.0216125529,
0.0224453285,
0.0749497414,
-0.0691556036,
-0.0452228375,
0.0615644231,
0.0748538971,
0.0379460193,
0.0124329925,
0.0511448085,
0.0132799428,
-0.0352349803,
-0.0082000624,
-0.0341638699,
0.0162763167,
-0.0258274227,
-0.0048031006,
0.0394046195,
0.0181250181,
-0.0335774869,
-0.0385470465,
0.0108268317,
0.0340239182,
-0.0085441051,
0.0279167239,
0.0474864505,
-0.0338260606,
-0.020082403,
0.0015153938,
0.0305088423,
-0.0250136051,
0.0222294796,
-0.0662624091,
0.02050904,
0.0820618793,
0.0698034614,
-0.0317038186,
-0.0231627245,
0.0217420869,
-0.017265128,
0.0196961612,
0.0344008133,
-0.0211027134,
-0.0176406186,
-0.0365309678,
-0.0168481357,
0.0094178449,
-0.0001877513,
0.0102364002,
0.0157552157,
0.0001333153,
0.0412434153,
-0.0216315929,
-0.0286244005,
0.0165044684,
-0.0068610869,
-0.0435774773,
0.0018820367,
-0.0007920184,
0.0257223714,
0.0100591108,
-0.0081874728,
0.0155576281,
0.0516653322,
-0.0078113382,
-0.0395042039,
-0.0277347509,
-0.0336983204,
-0.0372019596,
0.0320188217,
0.0036025648,
0.0332303233,
0.0414837562,
-0.0136252362,
-0.0320240781,
-0.0097324876,
-0.031912677,
0.0409642272,
-0.0845689178,
0.0014972584,
-0.0078421431,
0.015177995,
-0.0845391378,
0.0795216486,
0.0118366694,
0.0123507027,
0.0083575156,
0.0073793801,
0.0015541982,
-0.0644585863,
-0.06053124,
0.0186816044,
0.0046898844,
0.0289822984,
0.0418366902,
0.0016017981,
-0.038719289,
-0.010989774,
-0.101660423,
0.0371880643,
-0.02175368,
-0.0133361248,
0.0146103511,
0.024650624,
0.0172219761,
-0.0160064176,
-0.0429409482,
-0.0192963462,
0.0361766405,
0.0431990363,
0.0197797939,
0.0392600261,
-0.0382366329,
-0.0572448783,
-0.0499034338,
-0.0047387001,
0.0427755974,
0.0088103814,
-0.0154645331,
-0.0369072631,
0.0158776417,
-0.0548839271,
0.0357264094,
-0.0202591307,
-0.0015531699,
-0.0032576639,
-0.0756543353,
-0.0050624292,
0.0569684468,
0.0215068925,
0.0504268557,
0.0154615203,
-0.0171231236,
-0.0597873069,
0.0274919719,
-0.0676552653,
-0.0459521972,
-0.0097786011,
-0.0365163796,
0.0191381332,
0.0277814884,
-0.0047651674,
-0.0256459452,
-0.0445380546,
0.0122760357,
0.0085944729,
-0.0092739072,
-0.0678806752,
-0.0003944147,
0.0174902212,
0.0465160422,
-0.0369311832,
-0.0260031521,
0.0609566756,
-0.0120237162,
-0.0018297004,
-0.0373825058,
-0.0346791893,
-0.0652414933,
0.0533938929,
0.0008209975,
0.0363665037,
-0.0204470418,
-0.016392,
-0.0172369592,
0.0118616866,
-0.0058126962,
-0.0647051036,
0.0630393922,
-0.0151430853,
0.0430954657,
0.025417272,
-0.0512909479,
-0.0285476651,
-0.0612558685,
0.0173339527,
0.0019895742,
0.0166331679,
-0.0090815844,
-0.0379734151,
0.0400523841,
0.0134630455,
0.0235349927,
-0.0288386997,
-0.0272436142,
-0.0150037315,
0.0555458702,
0.064799428,
-0.0133756232,
0.004540117,
-0.0019137865,
0.0203501005,
0.0664967597,
0.0409286395,
-0.038763918,
-0.0172985326,
-0.0249692891,
0.0432036705,
-0.0351226628,
-0.0080985194,
-0.0092341024,
-0.001037937,
-0.0391369425,
-0.0513676405,
0.107421428,
0.0308315307,
-0.0803655908,
-0.0217555258,
-0.0287662894,
0.0298312735,
0.0230823793,
0.0504231937,
-0.0414962955,
-0.0178503618,
-0.0067038629,
0.0163458511,
-0.0169649962,
-0.0079627968,
-0.0022797685,
-0.0981395617,
0.0459102355,
-0.0137552414,
-0.0091841267,
-0.030003285,
-0.0347509347,
0.0139945485,
0.0005318724,
0.0259605125,
0.0638722852,
-0.0187283084,
-0.0094142435,
0.0042634625,
0.0434201211,
-0.0135723809,
0.0240036976,
-0.0343457535,
0.0229710639,
0.0509858988,
0.0248938911,
0.0062697749,
0.0005711368,
0.0080146184,
-0.0289711133,
0.0059081549,
-0.0111971842,
0.0276006944,
-0.024426613,
0.0081957476,
-0.0324221924,
-0.0030352322,
-0.033672981,
0.0157321468,
-0.0231398828,
0.0551984236,
-0.0251410455,
0.0124978246,
-0.0296987109,
-0.008004142,
-0.019780999,
0.0843101069,
0.0049471767,
-0.0097727198,
-0.0337173529,
-0.0285710376,
0.015116184,
0.0101508563,
-0.0602442026,
0.0071067978,
-0.0016345145,
0.0188391171,
-0.0407445729,
-0.0507698581,
-0.0048899068,
-0.0009515731,
0.0048292126,
0.0587312654,
0.0068466272,
-0.0256633926,
-0.0315457508,
0.052813381,
-0.0471519567,
-0.017600704,
-0.0428314246,
0.000001103,
0.0300035514,
-0.0781913698,
-0.0252063051,
-0.0081429398,
-0.0538252331,
-0.0494354479,
-0.0227535162,
0.0219191089,
0.0240771621,
0.0263901986,
-0.0319408141,
-0.050482057,
0.0268987548,
0.0361832082,
-0.0253913887,
-0.0052308948,
-0.0309059396,
0.0372576043,
-0.0061721331,
0.0315564051,
-0.069669418,
0.0198758505,
0.000055513,
0.057954371,
-0.0286046267,
-0.0495541915,
0.0753946975,
0.0115658101,
0.0361849703,
0.043601647,
0.0052837334,
-0.0391329192,
0.0064219879,
-0.0347244777,
-0.0272546262,
-0.0312276725,
-0.0070098722,
0.0485115536,
0.0124972565,
-0.0204322822,
-0.0373444594,
-0.0054177064,
0.0591919571,
-0.0611220337,
-0.0389980078,
-0.0030789247,
-0.0403998643,
0.0201579556,
0.0043603573,
-0.0246856138,
0.0358349718,
-0.0126344869,
0.0460435227,
-0.0257817861,
0.0489113219,
0.028496515,
-0.0554964058,
-0.0286645442,
0.0294627193,
-0.1106785908,
-0.0704975054,
-0.006253839,
0.0090906266,
0.0429737419,
-0.0067015006,
-0.008270029,
-0.0227744225,
-0.0053657121,
-0.0227178596,
-0.0238898993,
0.0318135843,
-0.0150948353,
0.0220972188,
0.041271951,
-0.0075531378,
0.0236988571,
0.0902713984,
0.0172754787,
0.0191772562,
0.0104469461,
-0.0664062351,
-0.0051498115,
-0.0265793726,
0.0346690491,
0.0374331027,
-0.0488981716,
0.002896653,
-0.0234402884,
-0.0323432758,
0.0172843486,
-0.0140631767,
-0.0004470682,
-0.0376045741,
0.0408458747,
0.1103775427,
0.0163375512,
-0.0223164707,
-0.0597147048,
0.033069443,
-0.0617018864,
-0.0144010447,
-0.0228347983,
-6.559912346e-33,
-0.0099890269,
-0.0135764992,
0.0371178836,
-0.0097344322,
-0.0391428471,
0.0013743929,
-0.0116166472,
-0.0264802687,
-0.034636829,
0.0071291905,
-0.021270087,
0.0307575185,
-0.0070934445,
0.0274306443,
-0.0173234027,
-0.0143429842,
0.0314167961,
0.0169827454,
0.0183027014,
0.0274082385,
0.0534755476,
0.0482768416,
0.0085098669,
-0.0546553619,
0.0045361537,
-0.0345177241,
0.0337252542,
0.0918367803,
-0.0215947367,
0.0655731559,
-0.0280773193,
0.0527402051,
0.0479205325,
-0.024992438,
0.0408110842,
0.0284332633,
-0.0656836927,
0.0051684948,
0.0182677228,
-0.0178163387,
0.0023954094,
-0.0219872855,
0.0545029044,
-0.0424366631,
0.014185762,
0.021348957,
0.0233449973,
-0.0008624386,
-0.0393968485,
-0.0174917951,
-0.040091414,
0.0056905802,
0.0173216891,
-0.0193817876,
0.0011651035,
0.0372700542,
-0.0127293309,
0.0756359771,
-0.0345567688,
0.0098852869,
-0.0422654897,
0.0581689849,
-0.0014669996,
0.0282061398,
-0.0051192944,
0.0560525469,
0.0189879052,
-0.0047447584,
-0.0216915421,
-0.0465951152,
-0.0019031349,
0.0242147036,
-0.0092725493,
0.0328674205,
0.022716729,
0.0184764042,
-0.058431115,
0.0178991742,
0.0162216015,
0.0480594859,
0.061011672,
0.0433300026,
-0.0577145144,
-0.0159083307,
-0.029233465,
0.026051674,
-0.0733235404,
-0.0127982218,
0.0362654068,
0.0259832647,
0.0163215417,
0.0052273646,
0.048280742,
-0.0381734036,
-0.0085180765,
0.0293502677,
-0.0021180667,
-0.0149305016,
-0.0108107096,
0.0486742668,
-0.0250107702,
-0.0084817186,
0.0073685031,
-0.0240993947,
-0.0568306111,
0.0130292773,
0.0027348031,
0.0074237385,
-0.0004424685,
-0.0236892384,
-0.0401546694,
-0.0165301319,
-0.0382948406,
0.0078660613,
0.0177879781,
0.0497886464,
-0.0019612131,
0.0413703583,
0.0613736548,
0.0260100774,
-0.0401108041,
-0.0642862692,
0.0126555208,
-0.0234690793,
-0.002296376,
0.0336114317,
-0.0079382565,
0.0306220092,
-0.0009922016,
-0.073556833,
-0.0016580269,
0.0135955559,
2.641e-7,
0.0399692766,
0.0460785702,
-0.0148759773,
0.0265164506,
0.0174524076,
0.0108622005,
0.0036469866,
0.0191062335,
0.034472473,
0.0006654284,
0.0283400621,
0.0609950982,
-0.0071110171,
-0.0026318962,
-0.0685556084,
-0.031999398,
-0.0468463674,
-0.0373018496,
-0.0524081476,
-0.0255222321,
0.0599158294,
0.1105425581,
-0.0083254231,
-0.0250355713,
-0.00659391,
-0.0792126581,
0.0725765824,
-0.0149355521,
-0.0197007619,
0.0364939161,
0.0443641767,
0.0165106263,
0.0134146204,
0.0020994139,
0.032601513,
0.0335819721,
0.0333808362,
0.0595716424,
-0.0210008528,
-0.0182164479,
0.0100805545,
0.0027501425,
0.0089454222,
-0.0757980645,
0.07938274,
-0.0424391069,
-0.0022036005,
0.0116622364,
-0.0298152957,
-0.0141414702,
-0.0187695883,
-0.0449420065,
-0.0294393748,
-0.0061678607,
0.0059125293,
0.014563323,
0.0059230546,
-0.1042611077,
0.0204681046,
-0.0046499982,
-0.0667375624,
-0.0328610241,
-0.0523251109,
0.0091085304,
-0.0028170783,
-0.0364294834,
0.0179654472,
2.567970495e-34,
0.0437618941,
0.0204171687,
-0.0124343345,
0.0325464755,
0.0397417359,
0.0264376123,
-0.0213053711,
0.0233611129,
0.0080678314,
-0.1374494135,
-0.0227149352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07102v1 | Temporal Sentence Grounding in Streaming Videos | 2023-08-14T12:30:58 | 2023-08-14T12:30:58 | Tian Gan, Xiao Wang, Yan Sun, Jianlong Wu, Qingpei Guo, Liqiang Nie | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM | This paper aims to tackle a novel task - Temporal Sentence Grounding in
Streaming Videos (TSGSV). The goal of TSGSV is to evaluate the relevance
between a video stream and a given sentence query. Unlike regular videos,
streaming videos are acquired continuously from a particular source, and are
always desired to be processed on-the-fly in many applications such as
surveillance and live-stream analysis. Thus, TSGSV is challenging since it
requires the model to infer without future frames and process long historical
frames effectively, which is untouched in the early methods. To specifically
address the above challenges, we propose two novel methods: (1) a TwinNet
structure that enables the model to learn about upcoming events; and (2) a
language-guided feature compressor that eliminates redundant visual frames and
reinforces the frames that are relevant to the query. We conduct extensive
experiments using ActivityNet Captions, TACoS, and MAD datasets. The results
demonstrate the superiority of our proposed methods. A systematic ablation
study also confirms their effectiveness. | [
0.0092295762,
0.0412662923,
-0.002794744,
0.0208493378,
-0.0304596554,
0.0005607131,
-0.0028180694,
0.0008110551,
-0.0280435588,
-0.0780045018,
0.0210309606,
-0.0541792326,
-0.0151007464,
0.0549907573,
-0.0096106436,
-0.0599210709,
0.0482784919,
0.0104805045,
-0.0048204474,
0.0500207953,
0.0431140102,
0.0083232792,
0.0137051828,
0.0330543369,
-0.0396477953,
0.0221020728,
-0.0297327023,
-0.00095261,
0.0616657734,
-0.0328161158,
0.0045791701,
0.0477491245,
0.082490027,
-0.0078804791,
0.0000017588,
0.014628957,
0.0003328675,
-0.0344186798,
-0.0115130395,
-0.0019669384,
0.0361855589,
-0.0095236609,
0.0082326587,
0.0117132142,
-0.0660275444,
0.0175542161,
0.0304238591,
0.0251399912,
0.0580368452,
0.0451614708,
-0.0454776138,
-0.0217578579,
-0.0001200574,
-0.0155018624,
0.0204131864,
-0.03890232,
-0.0026974953,
0.0041907523,
0.0019522791,
0.0134953354,
-0.0168892164,
0.0289200842,
0.0279376637,
-0.0026463724,
0.0261154305,
0.0118084401,
-0.086172156,
0.0000789833,
0.0029556027,
0.0392820016,
0.0154236117,
-0.0018337171,
-0.0006443518,
0.0266605839,
-0.0082344003,
-0.0274309125,
-0.0704663023,
-0.007276251,
0.0264842976,
0.0379738286,
-0.0316170081,
0.0298092794,
-0.0172547046,
0.0352892876,
-0.0104486886,
-0.0027347542,
0.0224543754,
0.0269150846,
-0.0371424109,
0.0335479602,
-0.0151977548,
-0.0423642956,
0.0452960469,
-0.0087191258,
-0.0066638137,
-0.0064593456,
-0.041722808,
-0.0342456847,
-0.0511392988,
-0.0716161728,
0.0090560727,
0.0263176821,
-0.0394586474,
0.0425993837,
-0.0380269475,
0.027128635,
-0.0316873975,
-0.0150411017,
-0.0464655831,
0.0057250326,
-0.0468064286,
-0.002323854,
-0.0312851332,
0.0246222261,
-0.0550996326,
-0.0370038897,
-0.0175215192,
-0.0035766379,
0.002391482,
-0.0490849726,
-0.0478979573,
0.0367367454,
-0.0291299,
-0.0253735725,
-0.0059316177,
0.0146649843,
-0.0177666303,
0.0636882633,
-0.0131539674,
-0.0723200589,
-0.0422192737,
0.036184568,
0.0217136312,
-0.0181040149,
0.0108927172,
-0.0416681692,
-0.0455025807,
-0.046072416,
-0.0263057426,
-0.0114332149,
-0.0368640274,
-0.0180426817,
0.0141745927,
-0.0659815073,
0.0084409397,
-0.0175243299,
-0.0102329273,
-0.0081490772,
0.0222988315,
0.0042887167,
-0.0243819896,
0.0870420262,
0.0229846109,
0.0083537111,
-0.0351948515,
0.0014189621,
0.043100249,
0.0824329332,
0.0180874486,
0.0384192057,
0.0378992856,
0.0784966722,
0.0017554642,
-0.0005749643,
0.0038157557,
0.0446232073,
-0.0833206773,
-0.0039350786,
0.0108558014,
-0.0094432272,
-0.0058524869,
-0.0082361689,
-0.0005869143,
0.0236495584,
0.0687830672,
0.0294381045,
-0.0840914324,
-0.041471146,
0.0772409588,
0.0111485766,
-0.0426997133,
0.0460942872,
-0.0132689979,
0.0696658269,
0.0238113888,
-0.0164785162,
-0.0288905613,
0.0134560391,
-0.0802385956,
-0.0574703813,
0.0090408633,
-0.002988219,
0.0397976004,
-0.007767396,
0.0420300774,
0.0094190771,
-0.0378544442,
0.0788315833,
-0.0185930282,
-0.0124625415,
0.0128960125,
-0.0328369774,
-0.0391655304,
0.0696310401,
-0.0108559104,
-0.0054600812,
-0.0703162476,
-0.0099758077,
0.0857435316,
0.025329195,
-0.0036627576,
-0.0039094836,
0.0225789621,
-0.0642561316,
-0.0394605175,
0.0153771583,
0.018366985,
0.0294409003,
0.0021306777,
0.0405809991,
0.048489891,
-0.0062379488,
-0.0323416181,
0.0329943374,
0.0415319726,
0.0100079058,
-0.0036909215,
0.0153126474,
0.0152040962,
0.0136935534,
0.0046010748,
-0.0115302717,
0.0609872788,
-0.030129347,
-0.0119583318,
0.079101637,
-0.0602031387,
-0.0467445999,
0.0272532068,
-0.0583747327,
0.008351828,
0.1043682545,
-0.0382008962,
-0.054605417,
0.0302015413,
0.007931021,
0.0294742975,
-0.0469236411,
-0.0188172292,
0.0118920645,
0.0341790803,
-0.0067551183,
0.0156435631,
0.0182003509,
-0.0373133123,
0.0008577826,
-0.0675098747,
0.0137603134,
-0.0493929461,
-0.0186699517,
-0.0055548106,
-0.0063268892,
-0.0205288902,
0.0597353652,
0.0224857926,
-0.0476591699,
0.0067801019,
-0.1111828163,
0.0099645248,
-0.0595746748,
0.0147811007,
-0.001677587,
0.034705162,
-0.0223384909,
-0.0727689788,
0.0014821007,
-0.010621924,
-0.0083656199,
0.0066135097,
0.0164860524,
0.04019868,
-0.0403122082,
0.0112677561,
-0.0204491578,
0.0015728656,
0.0471751057,
-0.0184628479,
-0.1130174622,
0.0017531227,
0.0292723235,
-0.0016208561,
0.0144534642,
-0.0235939119,
-0.0054027499,
-0.0103187189,
0.0032598297,
-0.0051480555,
0.0497123003,
0.0192859638,
0.0234388895,
0.0087493956,
-0.0224921964,
0.0081456462,
0.0445222408,
-0.0300920419,
-0.0266453959,
-0.0430509634,
0.0117668584,
-0.0194596816,
-0.0179764051,
-0.016689375,
0.021354517,
-0.0606367253,
-0.0274539068,
-0.0204075333,
-0.0114918333,
-0.0529273972,
-0.016645167,
-0.0218478814,
0.0202640668,
-0.0129253129,
-0.068849273,
0.0336843058,
0.0066336803,
-0.0420879275,
-0.0227084327,
-0.0089752283,
-0.0344159864,
0.0825267732,
0.0463812388,
0.0296488535,
-0.0061571458,
-0.0440168865,
-0.0468226001,
-0.0430797227,
0.0121880863,
0.0142233819,
0.0468037464,
-0.0278927572,
0.0179037359,
-0.00284264,
-0.0106073739,
-0.044494167,
-0.0406004339,
-0.0414723046,
-0.022209283,
-0.0595384799,
0.0199797042,
-0.030515274,
0.0150651205,
-0.0300340615,
0.031843055,
-0.0292854551,
0.0088081043,
-0.0158367567,
0.0668398812,
0.0716191977,
0.0045235003,
-0.0322890058,
-0.0113531034,
0.0272221975,
0.0588448457,
0.0500853881,
-0.0129542593,
-0.0381045863,
0.0342113413,
0.0155526493,
-0.0035094665,
-0.032649897,
0.0273266919,
0.064674899,
-0.045861125,
0.0214870628,
0.0883498192,
0.0350936949,
-0.0250073113,
-0.0043954719,
0.037814822,
-0.0054697166,
0.0472012088,
0.0227714237,
-0.0445523635,
-0.0411202908,
0.0004223515,
-0.0371079259,
0.0170186311,
-0.0100393593,
-0.0520890541,
-0.0548136644,
0.0497375429,
0.0436221808,
0.0182099007,
-0.0069187311,
-0.0028100382,
0.0104360096,
-0.0007131042,
0.0041247783,
-0.0225371774,
0.0272916388,
-0.0078385854,
0.0209343936,
-0.0205544401,
-0.052551493,
0.0127925659,
-0.0204404537,
0.0326227769,
0.0175616071,
0.0385945253,
-0.0166631117,
-0.0321945883,
0.0073369034,
-0.0317323171,
0.0044711628,
-0.0118068177,
0.0369826481,
-0.0355358012,
-0.0085255848,
-0.0010076714,
0.034511026,
-0.0239470005,
-0.0529974923,
-0.0147439763,
0.0681250691,
-0.0289891362,
0.0354250222,
-0.0272443965,
-0.0060917009,
0.0436473563,
0.0371298082,
-0.0218964033,
-0.0024574059,
0.0301879309,
0.0348017402,
-0.0487989299,
-0.0574748702,
-0.0398472548,
-0.0331233777,
0.0130497934,
0.0027556713,
-0.0311665572,
-0.0014280775,
0.0204386897,
0.0259017888,
-0.0249444973,
0.052379638,
0.021831749,
0.0335835628,
-0.0623446256,
0.0359060839,
0.0020043976,
0.028660452,
-0.0087795733,
0.0161851291,
0.0525680035,
-0.0111370664,
-0.0226682965,
0.0482970364,
-0.093372725,
-0.0252876729,
-0.0419313647,
0.0056385226,
0.0163871199,
0.0797816291,
-0.0199622195,
0.0576610826,
-0.0078725442,
0.044640597,
-0.0233139377,
0.0171651989,
0.0426439494,
-0.0646304935,
-0.0397430845,
0.0423424616,
-0.0347886458,
0.0203868952,
-0.0072812755,
0.0211974736,
-0.0070831189,
0.0066774422,
0.0421545208,
-0.0261452384,
0.0811758712,
-0.0290376488,
0.0027031738,
-0.0221549366,
0.0149330981,
0.003367254,
0.0009842314,
-0.0633140057,
0.0535545126,
-0.0267671328,
0.0368736088,
-0.0156063596,
0.0465141162,
-0.0243160427,
-0.037094634,
0.0112552559,
-0.0282903165,
-0.0363500454,
-0.0455180332,
-0.0096517624,
0.0329497792,
0.0332000256,
0.0081657609,
0.0281061605,
0.0056740264,
-0.0296274051,
0.0004192101,
0.0244017802,
0.0154708643,
-0.0317931809,
0.065656431,
-0.0651063025,
0.0672601163,
-0.0470132194,
0.0353385843,
0.0592858456,
-0.0725880265,
0.0247145407,
-0.0214536078,
-0.0012134338,
-0.0244044997,
0.0396386087,
0.016022956,
-0.0498732291,
0.0235344898,
-0.0089326547,
-0.0430258028,
0.0587759688,
0.0631839707,
-0.0029891413,
0.0295576937,
0.0541470796,
-0.0597840548,
-0.0201886147,
-0.0205322392,
-0.0018198141,
-0.0015933176,
-0.0201464482,
0.0226095635,
-0.0259770229,
-0.0379123166,
0.0229280554,
-0.0515471846,
-0.0247958507,
0.0076533603,
0.0563900284,
0.0601440221,
0.0042003277,
-0.0119498204,
-0.0063552642,
-0.0310996529,
-0.0183413569,
-0.0115693277,
-0.0099982424,
-5.668804609e-33,
-0.0260181967,
-0.0015598162,
0.002936542,
0.0261244327,
-0.0447681472,
0.0507975668,
-0.0140364189,
-0.0029710182,
-0.0038415315,
0.0280739013,
-0.0017610545,
0.0484533347,
0.0388882793,
-0.0024872664,
0.0043029035,
-0.0567277223,
0.0478538014,
-0.0315353237,
0.0132731525,
-0.0002825927,
0.0230513737,
0.0317063555,
0.0652900115,
-0.0474270433,
-0.0194994975,
0.0095144249,
-0.0290205106,
0.0274120253,
0.0666248351,
0.0618695915,
0.0198788028,
0.0155256363,
0.0061190114,
-0.0526207127,
-0.0565632805,
0.0221892279,
-0.0541047677,
-0.0186614376,
0.0117076822,
0.0466704667,
-0.0337466598,
-0.0185155049,
-0.0112931747,
0.0065733958,
-0.0330859795,
-0.0176521484,
0.0314065069,
-0.046767354,
0.0215052348,
-0.0413295403,
-0.0236398093,
0.0101948138,
-0.0134440623,
-0.044776924,
0.0252342336,
0.0287398677,
0.0154986084,
-0.0571296476,
-0.0183385294,
0.0396519862,
-0.0335662179,
0.0681882799,
0.0527382754,
-0.0184278805,
0.011100742,
0.0597365275,
-0.0292273741,
-0.0590320006,
-0.0178616587,
-0.0007579243,
0.0340109244,
0.0408651195,
0.0330487415,
0.0015802513,
0.0309487954,
-0.0084365476,
-0.0660845414,
0.0062511046,
-0.0174036492,
0.0776544511,
-0.0013893039,
0.0287628844,
0.0058117048,
-0.0093785841,
0.0075003295,
-0.0247361474,
0.008173747,
-0.0332659185,
0.0327526778,
0.0652494952,
0.0138768498,
0.0193929356,
0.0633499697,
-0.0597137362,
0.0435614996,
0.0419639722,
-0.0393338315,
0.0181849692,
0.0451148786,
0.0298351347,
-0.015397043,
0.0115635972,
0.0277740583,
0.039717488,
-0.0063887183,
-0.0453175418,
0.018558342,
0.0696420297,
-0.0130233336,
-0.0133573972,
0.0000903953,
-0.00479083,
-0.0117492639,
0.0093343416,
0.0289140735,
0.0422528386,
-0.0547209904,
0.087572448,
-0.0035411192,
-0.0152891334,
-0.0216910001,
-0.0381214544,
0.0272758957,
0.056840986,
-0.0271040481,
0.0296107866,
-0.0362142697,
0.0115564233,
0.0390989631,
-0.0487332754,
-0.0505499579,
0.0189010203,
2.566e-7,
-0.0158001073,
0.0258627292,
0.0187763944,
-0.0201671869,
-0.0053271591,
0.0371160284,
-0.0110969367,
0.046327576,
-0.0111824926,
-0.0328662582,
0.0552776344,
0.0447732024,
0.0549685061,
0.0253418572,
-0.0788971335,
0.008102892,
-0.0449436568,
-0.0299155004,
-0.0595339239,
-0.0338752978,
0.0601713024,
0.1022047475,
0.0254395381,
-0.0044986177,
0.0437127501,
-0.0959750116,
0.0512577184,
0.0119625349,
-0.0542566404,
-0.0127358688,
-0.0141090928,
0.0100947451,
-0.0559037291,
-0.0077951979,
-0.0179893505,
-0.0029164448,
0.042460233,
0.031624645,
-0.0369976386,
-0.0090303095,
-0.0561822206,
0.0454670005,
-0.0247856304,
0.0237249229,
0.0901001766,
-0.0001839218,
0.0054322341,
-0.0201838389,
0.0070229685,
0.0269047599,
0.0001017411,
0.0429878198,
-0.0397816002,
0.0223716162,
0.0460291021,
0.0267215073,
-0.0510477014,
-0.1179002821,
-0.0011293599,
-0.0233303457,
-0.0304850191,
-0.008130867,
-0.0503919311,
0.0424343981,
0.0653430149,
-0.0205441173,
-0.0327460654,
2.284878165e-34,
0.0223049186,
0.023566572,
-0.0140754124,
-0.0069773104,
-0.0353132524,
0.0186175611,
-0.0361428522,
0.0017445578,
0.002414681,
-0.0390126072,
-0.0177194551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07081v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07081v1 | Aesthetics of Sanskrit Poetry from the Perspective of Computational Linguistics: A Case Study Analysis on Siksastaka | 2023-08-14T11:26:25 | 2023-08-14T11:26:25 | Jivnesh Sandhan, Amruta Barbadikar, Malay Maity, Pavankumar Satuluri, Tushar Sandhan, Ravi M. Gupta, Pawan Goyal, Laxmidhar Behera | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sanskrit poetry has played a significant role in shaping the literary and
cultural landscape of the Indian subcontinent for centuries. However, not much
attention has been devoted to uncovering the hidden beauty of Sanskrit poetry
in computational linguistics. This article explores the intersection of
Sanskrit poetry and computational linguistics by proposing a roadmap of an
interpretable framework to analyze and classify the qualities and
characteristics of fine Sanskrit poetry. We discuss the rich tradition of
Sanskrit poetry and the significance of computational linguistics in
automatically identifying the characteristics of fine poetry. The proposed
framework involves a human-in-the-loop approach that combines deterministic
aspects delegated to machines and deep semantics left to human experts. We
provide a deep analysis of Siksastaka, a Sanskrit poem, from the perspective of
6 prominent kavyashastra schools, to illustrate the proposed framework.
Additionally, we provide compound, dependency, anvaya (prose order linearised
form), meter, rasa (mood), alankar (figure of speech), and riti (writing style)
annotations for Siksastaka and a web application to illustrate the poem's
analysis and annotations. Our key contributions include the proposed framework,
the analysis of Siksastaka, the annotations and the web application for future
research. Link for interactive analysis:
https://sanskritshala.github.io/shikshastakam/ | [
0.0489934981,
0.0256073792,
-0.0720731094,
0.0794493631,
-0.0437127762,
0.0302893184,
-0.0630710497,
0.0161920078,
0.0043560113,
-0.0419757441,
0.005013145,
-0.0019067703,
0.037195079,
-0.0153245386,
-0.0119440937,
-0.0692539811,
-0.0101088742,
-0.01848552,
0.0452225469,
0.0553402379,
0.042922873,
0.0077096671,
-0.031669084,
0.0368996225,
-0.003124157,
-0.0528487079,
-0.0132037736,
0.0197905898,
0.0115539562,
-0.0183160827,
-0.0138542419,
0.0311790649,
-0.0124254841,
0.049198743,
0.0000014546,
-0.0531434715,
-0.0005387929,
-0.0545924716,
0.0457968488,
-0.01684363,
0.0439433344,
-0.0086368863,
0.0236822609,
-0.0606299788,
-0.0053472486,
0.0544672869,
0.0880195796,
-0.0073785423,
0.0544667579,
0.10293369,
-0.0175075661,
-0.0868075714,
0.0311327539,
0.0223865584,
-0.0412523001,
0.0257857796,
0.0051348074,
0.0065918444,
0.0190388598,
0.0048929485,
-0.0633636042,
0.0137230381,
-0.0259558503,
0.0037372569,
0.0204314385,
-0.0199042093,
-0.0367816985,
0.0068384097,
0.0448667407,
0.01117096,
0.0074229585,
-0.0313644074,
0.0438537449,
0.0032609992,
-0.0860257372,
-0.0357889198,
-0.0140908714,
0.0260956734,
-0.0249686595,
0.0637946948,
0.0700773895,
0.010119725,
-0.0398686938,
0.0284770764,
0.076280348,
0.0073169796,
0.0104359649,
0.0019485662,
0.0052315579,
0.0052538021,
-0.0109336181,
-0.0400944725,
-0.0032857049,
0.0223318543,
-0.0298709311,
0.0401874296,
0.0168643612,
-0.0971597061,
0.0101903435,
-0.0023143226,
0.0424530208,
0.0182556901,
0.0266066957,
0.0123788724,
0.0119475182,
-0.0049524698,
0.0029815843,
0.0071550687,
-0.042085737,
0.0094773928,
0.0131699843,
-0.0416104682,
-0.0362220742,
-0.0134991035,
0.0052152518,
-0.0061071082,
-0.0438607968,
-0.0240598228,
0.0043707998,
-0.0297767948,
-0.0175225027,
-0.0233900174,
-0.0323342718,
-0.0202245452,
0.0089402087,
-0.0126321139,
-0.0049017766,
-0.0015688594,
-0.0405303538,
-0.0094534392,
0.0277972315,
0.0350874513,
-0.0012430956,
-0.0258544013,
-0.0362335071,
-0.0209522918,
0.0442582779,
-0.0361191332,
-0.0544106551,
-0.0168466941,
0.0002434076,
-0.0341083966,
0.0028085674,
-0.0440536849,
0.0212412477,
0.009239343,
-0.009886533,
-0.0388775356,
0.0086670453,
0.010666755,
-0.0010877412,
0.0459013022,
-0.026048502,
0.0068271491,
-0.0243768506,
0.0186777059,
0.0621995255,
0.0183578506,
0.0441889204,
0.0592202917,
0.0533401519,
-0.0121590393,
0.0270981453,
0.0150827309,
-0.061312858,
-0.0208060816,
-0.0456842184,
-0.0348467827,
-0.0333342664,
0.0352281556,
-0.0331962332,
0.027221581,
0.0389003828,
0.006494469,
0.0062734112,
0.0549772531,
0.0135744605,
0.0784059316,
0.0372045226,
0.0155889345,
0.0649484023,
0.0339969546,
0.0043760678,
0.0199311245,
0.0810503513,
0.0219762605,
-0.0015702945,
-0.0154515728,
0.0479429364,
-0.0166632421,
-0.0642381459,
-0.0379713997,
-0.0039455928,
-0.0411131755,
0.0257303491,
0.0045162016,
-0.0199266355,
-0.018739108,
0.0513026007,
-0.054196056,
0.0330864526,
-0.0045584296,
0.0643814355,
0.0574534871,
0.0291618221,
-0.0706636533,
0.0856503248,
0.0526229329,
0.0027274468,
0.0285182986,
-0.006652825,
-0.0138361566,
-0.0037418029,
-0.0028866308,
0.0557539091,
0.01328729,
0.0083756987,
0.0153179625,
-0.0767642781,
0.047277838,
-0.0179076903,
0.0259637665,
-0.0429039821,
0.0409030952,
0.0150275528,
-0.027806228,
0.0080274967,
0.0188723523,
0.042771142,
0.0244354326,
-0.020810714,
0.0314820968,
0.0059914803,
-0.0136172641,
0.004538619,
0.0622273982,
0.0520414114,
0.0074335397,
0.0116259651,
-0.0818696916,
0.019433083,
0.0427522585,
0.0046592443,
-0.0390849002,
0.0680453628,
-0.0214696899,
0.017029481,
-0.0097266538,
0.0225622542,
0.006708493,
0.0110475281,
-0.0106776245,
0.0067793285,
0.0494808666,
0.0293702018,
-0.042911429,
-0.0182971098,
0.0376496427,
-0.0289521348,
-0.0279572438,
-0.0027831991,
0.0422745273,
0.0080426307,
-0.0128510427,
-0.0428984985,
-0.0658963993,
-0.0435627624,
-0.1055130959,
-0.0218406208,
0.0001834585,
0.0026439007,
-0.0156092728,
0.0013017991,
-0.0275125001,
0.0047313115,
-0.0111886729,
0.0132935308,
0.0382435061,
0.0011698969,
0.0291875415,
-0.0336638764,
-0.0016803315,
-0.031448286,
-0.0314886495,
-0.0373565406,
0.0293203257,
0.0417962559,
-0.0509836562,
-0.0101764016,
-0.0302307922,
-0.0270311739,
-0.0480455719,
-0.0151194548,
-0.0440153554,
-0.0240522567,
-0.0501068383,
-0.0263290256,
0.0401012972,
-0.0122323632,
-0.0064536287,
0.0151553061,
-0.0340287313,
0.07588128,
-0.0362338498,
0.0352530926,
0.0535278544,
0.0314042009,
-0.00444808,
0.0278397296,
0.0433348231,
0.0051475014,
-0.0373703651,
0.0274050962,
0.0291438736,
-0.0522763729,
0.0708205253,
0.0043993057,
0.0043101497,
-0.0289660618,
0.0832294524,
0.0089130886,
-0.0160209071,
0.0657730922,
-0.0125602251,
-0.0116774077,
-0.0663742051,
0.0113708535,
-0.0666013882,
0.0546021163,
-0.0044725104,
0.0114814341,
0.0105437683,
-0.0027405887,
-0.0149511788,
0.0196637623,
-0.0029794511,
-0.0236637667,
0.0204205159,
-0.0520883501,
0.0116932709,
-0.0313883014,
0.0120414384,
0.0245735366,
-0.0140736187,
-0.0192958768,
-0.0435261875,
0.0627941489,
0.0126942284,
0.0598197356,
0.0145006897,
-0.0778177679,
-0.033717487,
-0.0171878897,
0.0291077513,
-0.013745849,
0.0560513102,
0.050766699,
0.0081034685,
-0.0062083383,
0.0582627133,
-0.0047628367,
-0.021090921,
-0.0168668218,
0.0112397401,
-0.014825305,
0.0289486311,
0.0156210782,
-0.0356533229,
0.010245271,
-0.0192068145,
-0.0219565667,
-0.0457967706,
0.0133451978,
0.0372721627,
0.046747189,
-0.0139082186,
0.0160519388,
-0.0656550601,
-0.0433755256,
0.0006168334,
0.0262650382,
-0.0713744909,
0.0086421771,
0.0199915227,
0.0042870571,
0.0079743341,
-0.0301243942,
-0.012375786,
-0.0358221047,
-0.0221422464,
-0.0061019333,
-0.0093995053,
0.0478346869,
0.0287975054,
-0.0318013132,
-0.0316450633,
-0.0714649707,
-0.0043950723,
-0.0299459882,
0.0345562287,
0.0055308226,
-0.0046343431,
0.0073731337,
-0.0216650069,
-0.0313540213,
-0.0154459998,
0.0102865091,
0.0530420206,
-0.0262637231,
-0.0434797741,
-0.0232859012,
-0.0454967618,
-0.0073700254,
0.0032644421,
0.0119997328,
0.0309417453,
-0.02928905,
-0.0358803719,
0.0007018165,
-0.0100321099,
-0.0323765725,
0.041577518,
0.0353461355,
0.0031841232,
-0.0082295183,
-0.0274652541,
0.0079802759,
0.0271598436,
-0.0173735805,
0.0275147986,
-0.0054891435,
-0.0414981805,
-0.066532746,
0.030835785,
-0.0318673067,
-0.0925410688,
-0.010443382,
-0.0150837451,
-0.0390767157,
-0.072863698,
-0.0655112043,
-0.02278479,
0.0177771989,
0.0700012296,
0.0505323783,
-0.0086963605,
0.0138279991,
-0.078499265,
0.0035322111,
-0.0165066924,
0.0303520691,
-0.0070392042,
-0.01616087,
0.0260729771,
-0.0324924402,
0.006178013,
-0.0049784752,
-0.0225229487,
-0.058331307,
0.0174566433,
0.0400591791,
0.0226681493,
-0.0387929976,
-0.0406556651,
-0.0717697889,
-0.0243639238,
-0.0173477773,
0.0255259983,
0.0376902707,
0.0258030724,
-0.0039383457,
-0.0207364708,
0.0355894268,
0.0027096521,
0.0194334928,
-0.0094949855,
-0.0173310786,
0.0372617766,
-0.0057123033,
0.0326453522,
0.0282901172,
0.0403392427,
-0.057846766,
-0.0154000167,
0.0033104413,
-0.0556670576,
-0.0117309922,
-0.0269324854,
-0.0202404466,
-0.0172347017,
0.0262375232,
0.0393047296,
-0.0501544997,
-0.0026170458,
0.0127271283,
-0.0200212225,
0.0180458389,
0.0598391593,
0.0566990077,
0.0381634086,
-0.0383249968,
0.0104434192,
0.0087852543,
-0.0348283798,
-0.043967735,
0.0249446835,
0.0210883375,
-0.0080182962,
0.0291543566,
-0.0051567662,
-0.0006334482,
0.0306691956,
0.0481907986,
0.0211612787,
0.0382978395,
-0.0481819734,
0.069171913,
-0.0485865399,
0.0720348507,
-0.0430516265,
0.0046201735,
0.0027691557,
0.0468287729,
0.0270179976,
-0.0103645464,
-0.024821924,
0.0275169741,
-0.0142878247,
-0.0128961401,
0.0362154543,
-0.0838398784,
-0.0332081318,
0.0754455253,
-0.0510122962,
-0.008055428,
-0.0376137868,
-0.0558388904,
-0.0115855187,
0.0693984851,
0.006281706,
-0.0719085559,
-0.0489031449,
0.0310529694,
-0.0033624296,
0.0374343321,
-0.0349405296,
0.016989179,
0.0352885425,
0.0349418223,
0.0203317162,
-0.0736330077,
0.0099056605,
-0.0927843079,
-0.0206933655,
0.017385425,
-4.82749118e-33,
-0.0569417998,
-0.007436322,
-0.0328176394,
0.048204992,
-0.0326639414,
-0.0201472938,
-0.0736783966,
0.0070986026,
0.0162941311,
0.0359759293,
-0.0218925774,
-0.0052276254,
-0.0129832383,
-0.0295640398,
0.057092946,
0.0190786421,
-0.01289979,
0.0147096086,
-0.0302686859,
-0.0223044734,
0.0646718442,
-0.0171250645,
0.0550641231,
-0.0736035705,
0.0868095309,
-0.0363815427,
-0.0157835651,
0.0075256331,
-0.0010682567,
0.0275325421,
-0.0410848558,
0.050306771,
0.0327569507,
-0.0024590737,
-0.0051693767,
0.0084738731,
-0.0378120542,
-0.0279818811,
0.0170768648,
0.0641958043,
0.0254431665,
-0.0690516829,
0.0257437397,
-0.0310066622,
-0.0183291119,
0.0241841394,
0.0340747945,
-0.0256773494,
0.0151253715,
-0.0740724057,
-0.0645941943,
0.0021562944,
-0.0605289936,
-0.0153388493,
0.0411865115,
-0.0491546802,
0.0194668863,
0.0433739498,
-0.0246305764,
0.0380402729,
-0.0160229113,
0.0341226161,
-0.0018026314,
0.0085089505,
-0.0162949711,
0.0151250986,
0.0386735238,
-0.0615171827,
0.0153306862,
0.0890740752,
0.0012934757,
0.0333974697,
0.0546422601,
0.0384710394,
0.066505596,
-0.0349025317,
0.0134165538,
-0.0088969031,
0.0003320668,
0.0301276222,
-0.0116707236,
-0.0120897032,
-0.0456042774,
-0.0359161906,
0.0712132528,
-0.0711983368,
-0.0019000738,
-0.0034384597,
-0.0107722059,
-0.038986586,
-0.0149662318,
0.0578130931,
-0.0251751225,
-0.0843088105,
0.004966984,
0.0188407004,
-0.0271391496,
0.0667338446,
-0.0023625123,
-0.0164449029,
0.0391832627,
-0.020183282,
-0.0099146813,
0.016330922,
0.0291543808,
-0.0266735908,
0.0303032454,
0.0364711545,
-0.0087436521,
-0.0049563055,
0.0069631333,
0.026434999,
-0.0013994895,
0.0235164445,
0.0046310914,
-0.0016131232,
0.0177890062,
0.0207536034,
0.0663717464,
0.0430285856,
-0.0227644593,
0.0045730034,
0.0005172513,
-0.0094163967,
0.0036429949,
0.0119514298,
-0.0015580872,
-0.0263629127,
0.0169866979,
-0.0276989136,
0.0086733745,
-0.0092845205,
2.477e-7,
0.0168183912,
0.0360389315,
0.0410695337,
-0.0136378268,
0.0216464903,
0.0136175994,
-0.0824113041,
0.008247613,
-0.0384883806,
0.0318217725,
0.0351636261,
0.0106241684,
0.0494535603,
0.0232720394,
-0.1334087849,
0.0188211929,
-0.0573135465,
-0.0273249689,
-0.0894038305,
0.0234338772,
0.0016295291,
0.0442218222,
0.0335267149,
-0.0154055674,
0.0012562062,
-0.0016021196,
0.0143605657,
-0.0126755722,
0.0501359105,
0.0105413357,
0.0182725601,
-0.0834047049,
-0.0026209364,
-0.0416903608,
-0.0034386632,
0.0237012301,
0.049762588,
0.0741721168,
-0.0000866904,
0.0351180471,
0.0374912582,
0.0047167074,
0.0268462859,
-0.0136887636,
0.0447834954,
0.0687005073,
-0.0443873927,
-0.0011857372,
0.0114940666,
-0.0085808057,
0.0014097003,
-0.0004395153,
-0.0456959866,
-0.0027640741,
0.00867627,
-0.0757703558,
0.032476455,
-0.0449483879,
-0.0231723431,
0.0128905848,
-0.0069355229,
-0.0193382706,
0.0294447467,
0.0150213353,
0.0385057256,
-0.0985060334,
-0.0208070651,
1.702536886e-34,
0.059261065,
-0.029485086,
0.0267613307,
0.0091204597,
0.0120394975,
0.0145251164,
0.0135504548,
0.0459728725,
0.0236313753,
-0.0470396951,
-0.0301140398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07074v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07074v2 | #InsTag: Instruction Tagging for Analyzing Supervised Fine-tuning of Large Language Models | 2023-08-14T11:16:28 | 2023-08-15T07:37:32 | Keming Lu, Hongyi Yuan, Zheng Yuan, Runji Lin, Junyang Lin, Chuanqi Tan, Chang Zhou, Jingren Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Foundation language models obtain the instruction-following ability through
supervised fine-tuning (SFT). Diversity and complexity are considered critical
factors of a successful SFT dataset, while their definitions remain obscure and
lack quantitative analyses. In this work, we propose InsTag, an open-set
fine-grained tagger, to tag samples within SFT datasets based on semantics and
intentions and define instruction diversity and complexity regarding tags. We
obtain 6.6K tags to describe comprehensive user queries. Then we analyze
popular open-sourced SFT datasets and find that the model ability grows with
more diverse and complex data. Based on this observation, we propose a data
selector based on InsTag to select 6K diverse and complex samples from
open-source datasets and fine-tune models on InsTag-selected data. The
resulting models, TagLM, outperform open-source models based on considerably
larger SFT data evaluated by MT-Bench, echoing the importance of query
diversity and complexity. We open-source InsTag in
https://github.com/OFA-Sys/InsTag. | [
0.0587594919,
0.0186416954,
-0.0425218642,
0.0248609222,
-0.0147155728,
0.039557986,
-0.0192488395,
-0.004168937,
0.0320624486,
-0.0625033006,
-0.046707537,
-0.0032926318,
-0.0044035777,
0.0124179339,
0.0182983931,
-0.0412499793,
0.069297567,
-0.043273326,
-0.0033471338,
0.0187126528,
0.0092503419,
0.0282763317,
0.0100701656,
0.0624587759,
0.0327013321,
0.0014217454,
-0.020267304,
0.0090782708,
-0.0412397906,
-0.0191255249,
0.0541961379,
0.0776538029,
-0.0092258826,
0.0127270818,
0.0000020952,
-0.0437966511,
-0.023848569,
-0.0283170994,
-0.0089866566,
0.0274350941,
0.0356106423,
0.043387115,
0.0062467023,
0.0197495297,
-0.0485827029,
0.011598479,
0.0388653651,
0.0029540455,
0.0491037518,
0.0370368436,
0.016469324,
-0.0178355351,
-0.0097897621,
-0.0056702807,
0.0406310968,
-0.0241076183,
0.0147342859,
-0.0016519488,
0.0406224132,
0.0396520793,
-0.0276956074,
0.0123101594,
-0.0118257944,
-0.0161269251,
0.0177780595,
0.0041245022,
-0.0512676425,
-0.0221982766,
-0.0008977499,
0.0680843592,
-0.0081539154,
-0.0089079812,
0.0185073577,
-0.0151019627,
0.0121309794,
0.0038035023,
-0.0315836631,
-0.0018713144,
-0.0138424952,
0.0003209529,
0.0464549288,
-0.0354622714,
0.0122671006,
0.0180131923,
-0.0031718276,
0.0747909471,
0.012398323,
-0.0193073805,
-0.0006609279,
-0.0117655583,
-0.0551655516,
-0.0679719299,
-0.0059788278,
0.0077307262,
-0.0537331589,
0.0294476002,
-0.0694980919,
-0.0304701105,
0.0368699059,
0.0119131897,
0.0674899295,
0.0494582579,
0.0109458463,
0.0545530133,
0.0001459876,
0.0223405417,
0.0120385326,
0.046320904,
-0.0470883958,
0.0091305682,
-0.0816551596,
0.0069082109,
-0.0542383678,
0.0080826432,
-0.0410246216,
0.0141433813,
-0.0426297039,
0.0365210176,
0.0065491842,
-0.0286013447,
0.0212780721,
-0.0312985033,
-0.0379689969,
0.0236579236,
-0.0315962434,
0.0149283279,
-0.0664976537,
0.0097284401,
0.038223315,
-0.0745005608,
0.0098021701,
-0.0034085563,
-0.0099246865,
-0.0244913902,
0.0385932736,
0.0115371244,
0.0193048865,
-0.0299770329,
-0.0687885135,
-0.0439556986,
-0.00674961,
-0.0380600132,
0.0106153851,
-0.0811246857,
0.013974282,
0.038125217,
0.0047826865,
-0.0278906878,
-0.0136099327,
0.0474540256,
-0.0317157656,
0.0393414982,
-0.0245593265,
0.0269732177,
0.0103143845,
-0.0032557889,
0.0022416213,
0.0746271312,
0.0053123501,
0.0070992843,
0.0728013143,
-0.0539156981,
0.0039624749,
0.0397682972,
-0.0079961559,
0.0213505309,
-0.0032857407,
0.000343407,
0.0381275453,
-0.0248449668,
-0.0080174953,
0.0267560855,
-0.0091039389,
-0.0047858027,
0.0299099479,
0.0442342572,
0.0128259119,
-0.0364409834,
0.062161617,
0.0274866745,
0.0048730979,
0.0043229996,
-0.0294383988,
0.0279708058,
-0.0306472182,
0.0079840599,
0.0030191496,
0.0312619843,
-0.0075422148,
-0.0487965234,
-0.0024533574,
0.0062692612,
0.0233860388,
0.0133870281,
0.0538517348,
0.00612516,
-0.0415356383,
0.0196016598,
0.0633634552,
-0.0196940973,
-0.0047755395,
-0.0666259155,
-0.0011050327,
0.0835031122,
0.0581516251,
-0.0356752425,
-0.0437761657,
-0.0096644554,
0.0695953071,
-0.0315558761,
0.0573612824,
-0.0107861031,
-0.0114511736,
-0.063130796,
-0.0473966971,
-0.0163259245,
0.0192432255,
-0.0027574641,
0.032416556,
-0.0453144312,
-0.0043614912,
-0.0340957493,
-0.0611026771,
0.0476972945,
-0.0179388169,
-0.0248196423,
-0.0187963285,
0.002602017,
-0.0023059556,
-0.0028175707,
0.025275588,
0.0168480612,
0.0286303051,
0.0298433993,
0.0510765687,
-0.064988181,
-0.0095243827,
0.0162752606,
0.0231031366,
0.0059742387,
-0.013650625,
0.0091180848,
-0.0339962952,
-0.0419882722,
-0.0067240959,
-0.0185828842,
0.0178243052,
-0.0164847896,
0.0430103987,
-0.0385625809,
-0.0269284751,
-0.0588418581,
0.0260664728,
0.0047816862,
0.0565526001,
0.0457133688,
-0.0041290801,
0.0190628003,
-0.0041683735,
-0.0403089188,
0.007294246,
-0.0246225633,
0.0174432416,
0.0301744398,
0.0479911789,
-0.0828741491,
-0.0216131173,
-0.097195752,
0.0266037639,
-0.0297913477,
0.0288639702,
0.0361839272,
0.0136169931,
-0.0171371531,
0.0055483538,
0.0043390868,
-0.0182761513,
-0.0031468354,
0.0371564813,
0.0023623575,
0.0351855122,
-0.0440680608,
-0.0514205284,
-0.0426445976,
-0.0226923451,
-0.0133164842,
0.0130052939,
-0.001095164,
-0.0320536941,
-0.013475379,
-0.0048231632,
0.0057473402,
-0.0116902664,
-0.0715781897,
0.0304971393,
-0.0382675789,
0.0127212256,
0.0898294821,
0.0071757743,
0.0060686735,
0.0368199386,
-0.0147267533,
-0.0577652492,
0.0087061515,
-0.0289235506,
-0.0643404275,
-0.0508854724,
-0.0388060026,
0.0302188862,
0.0915570483,
0.000821246,
0.0020599915,
-0.0688439757,
-0.0148347579,
-0.0554666445,
-0.0078887083,
-0.0299449917,
0.0344659537,
-0.0083950805,
0.0374113023,
-0.0086498354,
-0.0701027885,
0.0680057332,
-0.005155276,
-0.0097795725,
-0.056827303,
-0.0213685073,
-0.0181664173,
0.0314579457,
-0.0001870271,
0.0263706185,
0.0544717833,
-0.0123971729,
-0.0590140186,
0.0203611441,
0.0362976156,
-0.0187035277,
0.0353496782,
-0.0569112971,
-0.0140688578,
0.0221510157,
0.0104777934,
-0.0240637865,
-0.0689416751,
-0.0095298188,
-0.0139528681,
0.0756022334,
-0.0423277505,
-0.0081353001,
-0.0304932073,
0.0134922834,
0.0355083905,
-0.0369830243,
-0.0175288469,
-0.0262629241,
-0.0402507111,
0.0770372972,
-0.0470769927,
-0.0149261337,
-0.0236218199,
0.0066061355,
0.0259715226,
0.0370569825,
-0.0338172875,
0.0040758313,
0.0309265032,
0.0638576373,
-0.045351997,
-0.0482562296,
0.0726515129,
0.0571791865,
-0.0652462095,
-0.0199298672,
0.1185517237,
0.0540734082,
-0.022397304,
-0.0029221128,
-0.0104876757,
0.0656511262,
0.0578146465,
0.0434547178,
-0.0392942466,
-0.0500670597,
0.0062300819,
0.0703058988,
-0.012808823,
-0.0235592294,
0.0085149733,
-0.1036504358,
0.0255109705,
-0.0057675443,
-0.0253710672,
0.0004749632,
-0.0367153324,
0.0086183054,
0.0133997174,
-0.0234601125,
0.0090587568,
-0.0429624952,
0.0187963601,
0.0364706144,
0.0037963227,
-0.0723891109,
0.0477076136,
-0.0241910852,
0.0746851265,
0.0625422224,
-0.0079735713,
0.0095888339,
-0.0377536267,
0.077279076,
-0.0339826271,
0.0016255161,
-0.0381966643,
0.0566697977,
-0.0190409739,
-0.0164449029,
-0.0162121858,
0.0242852774,
-0.0246464312,
0.0181654505,
0.0118683986,
0.0858619288,
-0.0081305886,
0.0475165509,
-0.0096845794,
-0.0344013087,
0.0077680289,
0.0657706037,
0.0561226159,
-0.0591545776,
0.000727163,
-0.0600210987,
-0.0422615372,
-0.0514833853,
0.0054111644,
0.0429500788,
-0.0649144277,
-0.0269085038,
-0.049572181,
-0.0477449112,
0.0925258622,
-0.0031555374,
0.0182069689,
0.0279142801,
0.0404800139,
-0.0207433924,
-0.0295678508,
0.0449533053,
-0.0405931734,
0.0272910465,
-0.1203115806,
-0.0793391913,
0.0342074148,
0.022148842,
-0.0045712227,
0.0118656531,
-0.0448558666,
-0.0746058747,
0.033834897,
0.0674476475,
0.0186950471,
-0.0040031313,
-0.0156259891,
-0.0655778944,
-0.0535515659,
0.0295956042,
-0.0618272647,
-0.0025131507,
0.0282722022,
-0.064284198,
-0.0221815221,
0.0232220814,
-0.0504650883,
0.0087821698,
0.0059780963,
0.0223119389,
-0.0261236746,
-0.0106633659,
0.0341412202,
0.0254303794,
0.0355976,
-0.0234450158,
-0.0101122567,
-0.0303717479,
-0.0028754934,
-0.0019285617,
-0.027248729,
-0.0361084938,
-0.0256176852,
0.0128902961,
-0.036903277,
-0.0006071128,
-0.0149403419,
-0.0241567772,
0.0425593592,
-0.043071039,
0.045024801,
-0.0253267679,
0.0257142801,
0.0319471657,
0.0114296135,
-0.0006872223,
0.0024095643,
0.0141724544,
0.0402848274,
-0.0159884449,
0.0857227966,
0.0198537689,
0.0205304641,
0.0016314916,
0.0434530154,
-0.0270292033,
-0.0452755168,
-0.0027745548,
-0.0108785294,
0.0144151049,
-0.0426211096,
0.0401067808,
-0.0044031674,
-0.0151778311,
-0.0440285429,
0.0390306525,
0.012757157,
-0.0290057361,
0.0095088026,
0.0364174396,
-0.0207768921,
-0.0273073409,
0.0850308239,
0.0015837207,
0.0506310053,
0.0189311169,
-0.0240389295,
-0.0240104124,
0.0097818244,
0.025855707,
0.0308963228,
-0.0258793123,
0.0056137536,
-0.029873386,
-0.0345737599,
-0.0488040224,
0.0012045758,
-0.0001951712,
-0.0069572139,
0.0606326647,
0.0447657816,
-0.0112174312,
-0.0136532579,
-0.07222794,
-0.0108131971,
-0.0170926005,
-0.0192697588,
-0.0200614762,
-6.547343373e-33,
-0.0437006764,
-0.0225759894,
0.0048907278,
-0.0117739895,
0.0286920089,
-0.0252051745,
-0.0285030901,
0.015026941,
-0.0244058724,
-0.0067292806,
-0.0110041248,
0.010228008,
0.0073140431,
0.0153662441,
0.069459334,
-0.0140517773,
0.0303810053,
-0.0028600865,
-0.0333661214,
0.0436289422,
0.0260393415,
-0.0095921513,
0.0465748943,
-0.0356025212,
0.0303802453,
-0.0174121689,
0.0118796658,
0.0012416017,
-0.0267352778,
0.1019795537,
0.0318683125,
0.0320021249,
0.0147813624,
-0.0449147075,
-0.03138455,
0.0091920691,
-0.0510338247,
-0.0383426659,
0.0425257869,
0.0122961951,
-0.0003233028,
-0.0330451317,
0.0128302965,
-0.0217845384,
-0.0066116359,
-0.0046511367,
0.0348649845,
-0.0084282979,
-0.0005696104,
0.0070685693,
-0.0440568775,
0.0178491659,
-0.0109012369,
-0.0344040655,
0.0110295601,
0.0499825552,
0.0053021009,
0.0216041729,
-0.0104052639,
0.0433978699,
0.0465302095,
0.0682533234,
0.094610922,
0.039287284,
0.0242089052,
0.0238480624,
-0.0133964587,
0.0482034758,
0.0491151959,
0.0228305236,
0.0450269468,
0.0629758835,
0.0284331106,
-0.014450077,
0.0133902775,
-0.0107320426,
-0.0243922491,
0.0244575609,
-0.0123862308,
0.0286330637,
-0.0014971612,
0.0038677584,
-0.0796901733,
-0.0328952745,
-0.0417376459,
0.0278969035,
-0.0279819891,
-0.0175467078,
0.0580644235,
-0.0245336946,
-0.0331371762,
-0.0084591685,
0.0391056612,
-0.019341955,
-0.0155744553,
-0.0163718034,
-0.0317656025,
0.0337752625,
-0.0116201416,
0.0145442337,
-0.0490186103,
-0.0502387062,
0.0210021604,
-0.0436949246,
0.0361277349,
0.026020512,
0.0209629424,
0.0102320658,
-0.0628102273,
0.0094275745,
-0.0177739989,
0.0316887386,
-0.0147635881,
-0.0024938206,
0.0461585298,
0.0097954273,
-0.0127036357,
0.0831023157,
0.0211891718,
-0.0027535984,
-0.0707265958,
-0.0526160672,
-0.0013271846,
0.0000579156,
0.0018627957,
0.0156968907,
-0.0626783967,
0.0166120976,
0.004814541,
0.0107286172,
-0.0138952024,
-0.001648549,
2.765e-7,
0.0484398156,
0.0710538179,
-0.0198706035,
0.0427440219,
-0.0237308275,
0.051589936,
-0.0082091512,
-0.0237333365,
0.0256473348,
-0.0260280762,
-0.014416053,
0.0062599848,
0.0162566174,
0.0016999826,
-0.0540110916,
0.0215649549,
-0.0074461405,
0.02530149,
-0.0607324429,
0.0012618673,
0.0381790251,
0.0708938837,
0.009283795,
0.0274502095,
-0.0157594196,
-0.0375706553,
0.0008659104,
-0.028503269,
-0.0071270135,
0.0598551892,
0.0202923231,
0.0522908457,
0.0003679788,
0.0172636807,
-0.058317598,
-0.0180767477,
-0.0357774422,
0.0519191362,
-0.0251507871,
0.0216400381,
0.0113029694,
-0.0492244363,
-0.0116540436,
-0.0773556158,
0.0562359951,
-0.0260339975,
0.0004008455,
0.0051158895,
0.0040437044,
-0.0130896298,
-0.0014376242,
-0.0315973759,
0.0027458821,
0.0042488542,
0.0134628899,
-0.0276080053,
-0.0274060518,
-0.0517799631,
0.0054509998,
0.0303205382,
-0.00104321,
-0.0625904128,
-0.061974626,
0.0231061745,
0.0048545511,
-0.0429084376,
0.0033630212,
2.831821911e-34,
0.0235126186,
-0.0125217782,
0.0531319492,
0.0115391202,
0.0526328199,
0.0040319199,
-0.0652370378,
0.0458189733,
0.026269855,
-0.0990122259,
-0.0261156894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08488v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.08488v2 | Improving Audio-Visual Speech Recognition by Lip-Subword Correlation Based Visual Pre-training and Cross-Modal Fusion Encoder | 2023-08-14T08:19:24 | 2024-03-09T01:36:06 | Yusheng Dai, Hang Chen, Jun Du, Xiaofei Ding, Ning Ding, Feijun Jiang, Chin-Hui Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | In recent research, slight performance improvement is observed from automatic
speech recognition systems to audio-visual speech recognition systems in the
end-to-end framework with low-quality videos. Unmatching convergence rates and
specialized input representations between audio and visual modalities are
considered to cause the problem. In this paper, we propose two novel techniques
to improve audio-visual speech recognition (AVSR) under a pre-training and
fine-tuning training framework. First, we explore the correlation between lip
shapes and syllable-level subword units in Mandarin to establish good
frame-level syllable boundaries from lip shapes. This enables accurate
alignment of video and audio streams during visual model pre-training and
cross-modal fusion. Next, we propose an audio-guided cross-modal fusion encoder
(CMFE) neural network to utilize main training parameters for multiple
cross-modal attention layers to make full use of modality complementarity.
Experiments on the MISP2021-AVSR data set show the effectiveness of the two
proposed techniques. Together, using only a relatively small amount of training
data, the final system achieves better performances than state-of-the-art
systems with more complex front-ends and back-ends. | [
-0.0069120661,
0.0225388836,
0.0276328921,
0.0236135982,
0.0097543895,
-0.056524463,
0.0204446297,
-0.0138195259,
-0.0152372262,
0.001232896,
-0.0964219198,
-0.0371209234,
0.0530337766,
0.0204828288,
0.0287011992,
-0.0752361342,
-0.0207275674,
-0.0290427431,
-0.0092597846,
-0.0218260568,
0.0621627308,
-0.0072762286,
-0.0347081199,
0.0290888157,
-0.0640947148,
-0.0172773134,
-0.019746352,
0.0235675927,
0.0407162756,
-0.0044899997,
-0.0690104738,
-0.0090555698,
0.0179878753,
-0.0318789706,
0.0000017724,
-0.0145030133,
-0.0126096383,
0.0151677392,
-0.0204901546,
0.0113885049,
0.0141755948,
-0.0654181242,
-0.0369664282,
0.0745466575,
0.0118661979,
-0.0082736863,
0.0641698241,
0.0152645698,
0.0487355776,
0.016584849,
-0.0303865094,
-0.022404464,
0.0408129133,
-0.0224629026,
-0.0284596197,
-0.0377499945,
-0.0181705095,
0.0196391903,
-0.002185578,
-0.0924410746,
-0.0710565969,
0.0634487718,
-0.0247002505,
0.0172444433,
0.0238415059,
0.0178487115,
-0.0474166125,
-0.0412421227,
-0.0249319095,
0.0674899593,
-0.0077747563,
-0.0086679347,
-0.0368218236,
0.0036412664,
-0.0126953153,
0.035678409,
0.0149030294,
0.009895551,
0.0087660057,
-0.0163933113,
-0.0366204418,
0.0153109357,
0.0099542011,
-0.0347308107,
-0.0234978329,
-0.0662896857,
0.0316843092,
-0.0214055423,
0.0106679052,
-0.0316371322,
0.0012586886,
-0.0163000952,
0.0353523716,
0.0263154805,
0.0238617901,
-0.0387891605,
-0.0339532495,
-0.0419315621,
-0.0447307788,
0.0251099188,
0.0086256089,
0.0324856937,
-0.0999517292,
0.0255545862,
-0.00906689,
0.0543003157,
-0.0386459492,
0.0408399142,
-0.0087515535,
-0.0510998368,
0.0027566631,
0.0004242218,
-0.0430254228,
-0.0184675083,
-0.0236328822,
-0.0282409191,
-0.0357725881,
-0.0046370309,
-0.0475096554,
-0.0003552609,
0.0334860906,
0.0371545888,
-0.0245202426,
-0.0371853188,
-0.0378198735,
0.0608033501,
0.0234911889,
0.0573620461,
-0.0393771604,
-0.0495495871,
-0.0008986704,
0.0412699804,
0.036182709,
0.0070997719,
0.0661674291,
0.0736510754,
-0.0265779458,
-0.0290619694,
0.0026080566,
0.0306833014,
-0.0529614389,
-0.0126841888,
0.0023864103,
-0.0603503436,
0.0293831117,
-0.0156259127,
-0.0000173457,
0.0247747954,
-0.0083814347,
-0.0377301872,
0.0192188639,
0.0676093027,
0.0071283281,
0.0093912296,
0.0138968779,
-0.0220495816,
0.038368009,
0.0472524799,
0.0658058226,
-0.0163812544,
-0.0192812886,
0.0072869216,
0.0152699696,
0.0326683111,
-0.0037363432,
0.0226437692,
-0.0907500312,
-0.0305760372,
0.0336583592,
0.0262902062,
0.0423350409,
0.0907877982,
-0.0209779106,
-0.0247554202,
0.0703356043,
0.01058238,
0.0326392725,
-0.0193792935,
0.0113943825,
-0.0065693511,
0.005290994,
-0.002481916,
0.0280413553,
0.0385010503,
0.0011656855,
0.0542471744,
0.0367807001,
0.0408170186,
-0.0495867617,
-0.0233273823,
-0.0117356824,
-0.0299928524,
-0.0090445681,
0.054585617,
0.0292446315,
-0.0097097,
-0.0653687641,
0.0104760053,
-0.032106977,
-0.0276013725,
0.0225521605,
-0.0203654692,
-0.0100908112,
0.033925619,
-0.007247075,
-0.0226846449,
-0.0290615149,
0.001147715,
-0.0128327878,
0.0055771964,
-0.0243141055,
-0.0296783336,
0.0505003855,
-0.0774462149,
-0.0128359785,
0.0388446338,
-0.0196598154,
0.0197255295,
-0.0342630446,
0.0438982807,
-0.0277062152,
0.0089169834,
0.0604694597,
-0.0086733131,
0.0047576604,
0.0429576561,
-0.0404058062,
0.0729320943,
0.0307751223,
0.0175830424,
-0.041999761,
0.0269736424,
0.021236835,
-0.0299184043,
0.0557196364,
0.0469186455,
-0.0291738044,
-0.0017824067,
0.0793578625,
-0.0586224608,
0.030417623,
0.0269727539,
0.0448269695,
-0.0719084218,
0.015591383,
0.0172449127,
0.0946120769,
-0.0762395337,
0.0431441516,
0.0302512199,
0.0097766258,
0.0316120461,
-0.0362116285,
-0.0055213259,
-0.0243832581,
0.0418941006,
0.0310750976,
-0.0032422731,
-0.0269184448,
-0.0292220395,
0.0555228628,
-0.0126819583,
0.0288414303,
-0.0225913636,
-0.0137289753,
-0.0080520697,
-0.060805507,
-0.0925225616,
0.0025896211,
-0.0146864075,
-0.0323055722,
-0.0327528641,
0.0129599804,
0.0081691407,
-0.0272212047,
0.0018256812,
0.0090092737,
-0.0150203248,
-0.0151823973,
-0.0429018177,
0.0092197191,
-0.0146032963,
-0.0125729199,
0.0060782679,
0.0252540279,
-0.027525045,
-0.0305631757,
-0.0459238924,
0.0307436138,
-0.0124426847,
0.0067611705,
0.0513831489,
-0.0119627994,
-0.0385321863,
-0.0188023299,
0.0204133149,
0.0775863081,
0.0340725817,
0.0145207271,
-0.0029928598,
0.0261826906,
-0.0126381051,
-0.0061597228,
0.011635202,
0.0560661443,
-0.0007235254,
-0.0085985605,
0.0475432649,
-0.1048547775,
-0.0276496448,
0.0090366295,
0.0511708967,
-0.0676851571,
-0.027067963,
0.0428291857,
-0.0139955105,
-0.0120717101,
-0.0093013411,
-0.03707923,
-0.0046220063,
-0.0459233075,
-0.0577387773,
0.0137740765,
-0.0772778615,
-0.0716995448,
0.0090815434,
-0.0160442926,
-0.016936969,
0.0070246076,
-0.0209948253,
-0.0197716746,
-0.0163689423,
-0.0539357103,
-0.0779720619,
0.0155168381,
0.0180378649,
-0.0202960819,
0.0559553094,
0.007198011,
-0.016424099,
-0.0479467697,
0.0280453246,
-0.0391250476,
-0.0056667435,
-0.0691534877,
0.0027350429,
-0.0187883917,
-0.0037239282,
0.0115412613,
0.0506234728,
0.0381446294,
0.0154175274,
0.0150961271,
0.0475488491,
-0.0309899841,
0.0427859128,
0.0186276566,
0.0568003953,
-0.0598796904,
-0.0496451333,
0.0411366969,
-0.010213173,
0.0421972685,
-0.0261230394,
-0.0325275399,
-0.000186023,
0.0382689498,
0.0697353855,
-0.017222397,
0.0284447875,
0.0349351913,
-0.0473434851,
0.0437155329,
0.0371370837,
-0.0139742745,
-0.0340216644,
-0.0404280722,
0.0712366104,
0.0093209641,
0.038342122,
-0.0324154086,
-0.0343759134,
-0.0444022119,
0.0578598119,
-0.0317837298,
0.0453566015,
0.092590265,
-0.0204799119,
-0.0707966834,
0.0320108309,
0.0198213067,
-0.0094983522,
-0.033403933,
-0.0141353374,
-0.0107224556,
-0.0192759279,
0.0429974422,
-0.0222307891,
-0.0330341086,
-0.0202776045,
0.054922279,
0.0066130888,
-0.0203409661,
-0.0109540289,
-0.0721350834,
0.0125029692,
0.0391107537,
0.0426026098,
-0.0219273176,
-0.0550992191,
0.0610626563,
-0.0116726961,
0.004118043,
0.0190985966,
0.0427928045,
-0.0250679124,
-0.0333726667,
0.0587223098,
-0.0063926857,
0.0218752455,
-0.0009094892,
0.0032775665,
0.0261623673,
-0.00507145,
0.0443070419,
0.009295621,
0.0598493628,
-0.051166106,
0.0450606756,
-0.0162989218,
-0.0231305473,
0.0384017527,
0.0752179995,
0.0331024304,
-0.0051418925,
0.0057702889,
0.0221497137,
0.0076617589,
-0.0360773392,
-0.0050247754,
-0.0006430582,
-0.0002355566,
0.0479649007,
0.0267126579,
0.0007457345,
0.0007511029,
0.0696496814,
-0.0170167387,
0.0303485859,
0.0179806501,
0.0593222827,
-0.0821108818,
0.007590773,
-0.003373137,
-0.0646379218,
0.0323776305,
0.0231388025,
-0.0327991396,
-0.0434224866,
-0.0367956087,
-0.0356375463,
0.0034348806,
0.1067041829,
-0.0095779048,
0.0044785314,
0.0150667103,
-0.0175437015,
0.0016304973,
0.025774803,
0.0452435613,
-0.0673877895,
-0.0178767443,
-0.0033157261,
-0.0215322077,
-0.0173679534,
-0.0205298942,
0.0030907097,
-0.0070810639,
-0.0604505911,
-0.0008214184,
-0.0059220428,
0.0481399335,
-0.0128853144,
0.0490294024,
-0.0857035071,
0.0302181672,
0.0175250769,
0.0557526536,
-0.0511380807,
-0.0208355784,
0.0326050483,
0.0212648213,
0.0000163491,
0.0143359378,
0.0184982102,
-0.0529960543,
0.0183001049,
0.079705514,
-0.0302518532,
0.0274996758,
-0.0221740343,
0.0126078492,
0.0424349196,
0.0236536246,
0.0273702648,
0.0091109304,
0.0072134361,
-0.0025391562,
-0.0015415146,
-0.0160196703,
-0.0151779009,
0.0428681746,
0.0097273104,
0.0085704457,
-0.0332887582,
0.0354425274,
0.0452282839,
-0.0458995365,
-0.0278786626,
0.036313612,
-0.0046765949,
-0.0264942981,
0.037482053,
-0.042492453,
-0.0272955671,
0.0414016731,
-0.013843325,
-0.0336086154,
0.0068644243,
0.0078311963,
-0.0062100105,
0.0168652236,
-0.0399490669,
0.03820296,
-0.021194445,
-0.0110438988,
0.0145685626,
-0.005165352,
-0.053992264,
0.0190979857,
-0.0182303395,
-0.0948775485,
0.0620404035,
0.0163677894,
0.0198859386,
0.0279723406,
0.0191948824,
-0.0513904803,
-0.0040843128,
0.0359995477,
0.0359468423,
-0.0703075901,
0.0330632403,
0.0148170562,
0.0473105125,
-5.10552241e-33,
-0.0111138029,
0.0306574553,
0.0398138314,
-0.0145976124,
-0.0463637188,
0.0165755935,
0.0052905898,
0.044662375,
-0.0044592433,
-0.0054472741,
0.0044338536,
0.0297530014,
0.0207784194,
0.0029566854,
-0.0244164318,
-0.0129139107,
0.0635828599,
-0.0235574897,
0.0228688549,
-0.0341035463,
0.0395910181,
0.0254132021,
0.0190316662,
-0.0554524437,
-0.0757848173,
0.0379382744,
-0.0156148523,
-0.0201996844,
0.0008814178,
0.0688203424,
0.0158381928,
0.0024243535,
-0.0357828923,
-0.0066432045,
0.0153881079,
-0.0207956005,
-0.0696418583,
0.0554014444,
-0.0111266766,
0.0438545346,
-0.059973374,
0.0038338876,
0.0406711884,
0.0076404139,
0.0149641661,
-0.0370173976,
0.0665872842,
-0.0631733164,
-0.0055562137,
-0.0233948361,
-0.0334638841,
0.022635242,
-0.0170829147,
-0.0350630879,
0.0803288817,
0.041499339,
0.026033558,
-0.0139961522,
0.0027718933,
0.0173686892,
-0.0151522215,
0.0398256369,
0.0514847599,
0.0583137646,
0.0025611755,
-0.0087961797,
0.0189868305,
-0.1122187227,
0.044816941,
-0.0204406809,
0.0578735918,
0.0314530917,
-0.0006213542,
0.0242501572,
-0.0240355581,
-0.0496856086,
-0.0054320367,
-0.0010859978,
-0.0212391969,
0.0058353753,
-0.035466738,
0.0334536508,
0.0083008958,
0.0241301432,
-0.0296714455,
-0.0266475081,
-0.0590922832,
0.0173414964,
0.0202518906,
0.0450384915,
0.0000659564,
0.0400601514,
0.0773623288,
-0.0198790655,
0.0563746318,
0.0130682411,
-0.0181295965,
-0.002178886,
0.0218434054,
0.025404213,
-0.054862611,
-0.0022870242,
0.048461087,
0.0177814215,
0.0038582869,
-0.0095236106,
-0.0067644245,
0.0274791773,
-0.0569828823,
-0.0181981791,
0.0255927797,
-0.0040673492,
0.0156985559,
0.0433139652,
0.0335969031,
-0.0030615681,
-0.0197203662,
0.0312131923,
-0.0232431684,
0.0109194098,
-0.0366995633,
-0.0228391476,
-0.0102510126,
0.0125945928,
-0.0159208588,
0.0519855134,
-0.0118348608,
-0.0625728369,
0.0172934439,
-0.0064714169,
-0.0251341946,
0.0424612835,
2.63e-7,
-0.0112828631,
-0.0425321944,
0.060995616,
-0.0121072,
0.0067564198,
0.0078170141,
-0.0396075584,
-0.0186765008,
0.0190612916,
-0.0466666855,
0.0389501452,
-0.0002667097,
0.0413829051,
-0.011646023,
-0.0246870127,
0.0288945567,
-0.0093768388,
-0.0038525704,
0.0238567777,
0.0208012667,
-0.000621537,
0.0868011117,
-0.0385118909,
-0.0199141391,
0.0277977604,
0.0115274554,
0.0387579463,
0.0223396402,
-0.0152787417,
-0.0316057913,
0.0039057024,
-0.0103072356,
-0.0465502441,
0.039401833,
-0.0364524014,
0.0345784649,
0.0452978164,
-0.0223047063,
-0.0335920043,
-0.0804081336,
-0.0409800448,
0.0863891691,
-0.0622744597,
0.0411032364,
0.0498359129,
0.0405853502,
-0.0237554274,
-0.0413248539,
-0.0314441174,
0.0318703316,
0.0409146547,
-0.0010244269,
-0.0349154919,
0.0109392405,
0.026626518,
-0.0172766652,
-0.0309444088,
-0.0473357551,
-0.0056771617,
-0.002946777,
-0.0496031083,
0.0050700898,
0.005937906,
-0.0083928695,
0.0226819124,
-0.0033873853,
-0.0546899103,
1.51988389e-34,
0.0125846062,
-0.0656400919,
0.0329406299,
-0.0542682186,
-0.009826107,
-0.0423403718,
-0.0409187973,
-0.0194947571,
-0.0134509327,
-0.0076828911,
-0.0633153394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06975v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06975v3 | Can Knowledge Graphs Simplify Text? | 2023-08-14T07:20:49 | 2023-10-25T00:57:54 | Anthony Colas, Haodi Ma, Xuanli He, Yang Bai, Daisy Zhe Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge Graph (KG)-to-Text Generation has seen recent improvements in
generating fluent and informative sentences which describe a given KG. As KGs
are widespread across multiple domains and contain important entity-relation
information, and as text simplification aims to reduce the complexity of a text
while preserving the meaning of the original text, we propose KGSimple, a novel
approach to unsupervised text simplification which infuses KG-established
techniques in order to construct a simplified KG path and generate a concise
text which preserves the original input's meaning. Through an iterative and
sampling KG-first approach, our model is capable of simplifying text when
starting from a KG by learning to keep important information while harnessing
KG-to-text generation to output fluent and descriptive sentences. We evaluate
various settings of the KGSimple model on currently-available KG-to-text
datasets, demonstrating its effectiveness compared to unsupervised text
simplification models which start with a given complex text. Our code is
available on GitHub. | [
0.0265435353,
0.0056718648,
-0.0071090367,
0.0150090195,
-0.0435728431,
0.0005553592,
-0.0271125641,
0.0277014747,
0.0399335437,
-0.0329529345,
0.0299584605,
0.0742611215,
0.0322465263,
0.0281372089,
0.042898383,
-0.0729616359,
0.0229237415,
0.0054199458,
0.0097991358,
-0.0157513339,
0.021145083,
0.0371626467,
-0.022752909,
0.0044251271,
-0.0202782042,
-0.0128717264,
0.0183019787,
0.0187887419,
0.0124616772,
0.0253114793,
0.0150875207,
0.03314621,
-0.0082481867,
-0.0415840261,
0.0000019043,
-0.0001763906,
-0.0046031196,
-0.000061664,
-0.0041787112,
0.0389840156,
0.0653020665,
-0.0464602821,
0.0383689068,
0.0266138446,
-0.0329354703,
0.0016168165,
0.0086483136,
0.0421082489,
0.0293676816,
0.0805447698,
-0.0355974548,
-0.0381242372,
-0.0321761668,
-0.0220392812,
-0.0233037602,
-0.0246172585,
0.0266594645,
0.036283914,
-0.0459922254,
0.0048942552,
-0.0405617803,
0.0548640862,
0.013501158,
-0.0362877734,
0.0685890466,
0.038184423,
0.019424025,
0.0075587207,
0.0469540581,
0.0936277881,
-0.0059107784,
-0.0450945422,
0.0515305698,
-0.0246724114,
0.018839594,
0.0177881029,
-0.0173887555,
-0.0239915345,
-0.0073139784,
0.0208886303,
-0.0462702066,
-0.014900865,
0.0328348167,
-0.0015281946,
0.0095200799,
0.0183908977,
0.0296528246,
-0.0016955052,
0.0124323536,
0.0144834332,
-0.0116721718,
-0.0638752803,
0.0391981341,
0.0388837531,
-0.01036477,
0.0229039378,
-0.065172784,
-0.0365466848,
-0.0086686378,
-0.0230876002,
-0.008533475,
0.0047264476,
0.0419248939,
0.0275628157,
-0.0378896482,
0.0102361599,
0.0272055063,
-0.0206991173,
-0.043973323,
0.0105543919,
-0.0500771254,
-0.0053006904,
-0.0519466922,
0.0327387787,
-0.0388390347,
-0.0250183307,
-0.0418813154,
0.0265513882,
0.0099159908,
-0.0108245723,
0.0144809326,
0.0283245649,
-0.0003478017,
-0.0305324495,
-0.0114147281,
0.0439940542,
-0.0502710231,
0.0070619108,
0.0234840978,
0.0202244278,
-0.0078308713,
0.0118559562,
0.0755403787,
0.0071231062,
-0.0314171948,
0.0084902439,
-0.0384242982,
0.0187185258,
-0.0643272772,
-0.0795442611,
0.029134145,
-0.0329487734,
-0.0177362077,
-0.0560775213,
0.0615983866,
0.0074646557,
-0.0244648997,
-0.0810608044,
0.006363932,
0.0054742941,
-0.0668400377,
0.0356904157,
-0.0897754282,
0.0267496929,
0.0190751255,
0.0110284407,
0.0027456973,
0.023989765,
0.0364353545,
0.01022371,
0.0455009677,
0.0045995167,
0.0070136902,
-0.0029127654,
0.0666658878,
0.0037552908,
0.0398898572,
-0.0137396986,
-0.0884996578,
0.0429024696,
0.0477649383,
0.0696526244,
-0.0349022374,
0.0370527841,
0.0447547287,
-0.0088581536,
-0.0017526526,
0.0289165843,
0.0794732347,
0.0615094043,
0.0271810815,
0.0517890304,
-0.0088997111,
-0.0103256032,
-0.0266901981,
0.0333677568,
0.0120839998,
-0.0156708639,
-0.0299831405,
-0.0327534862,
0.0424788781,
-0.0333186202,
0.0462552719,
-0.0077105849,
0.0123622371,
0.0549652167,
-0.0535593964,
0.0424925312,
0.0200492498,
-0.055903554,
0.048845116,
0.013915617,
0.0003122295,
0.0804253742,
0.0174493026,
0.0291300025,
-0.0173658505,
0.005240886,
0.0046137925,
0.0104271537,
0.0260070376,
-0.0331894197,
0.0146293771,
-0.0560778715,
-0.0426172167,
-0.01349549,
0.0064878426,
-0.0415324531,
0.0357797034,
0.0020286937,
0.0704027787,
-0.0772879496,
0.0000667391,
0.0323183611,
-0.0186485667,
0.0102416696,
0.0215813462,
0.0147952186,
-0.0340527222,
0.0366173238,
0.0196219012,
0.0166789815,
0.0094810622,
0.0033992617,
-0.0323552229,
0.0027740749,
-0.0413098708,
-0.0982826203,
0.0198951829,
-0.0302818399,
-0.0091372561,
0.0124718668,
-0.0569165908,
-0.0617707856,
-0.0075369212,
-0.0281535629,
0.0333457962,
-0.0063545648,
0.008283685,
0.0241639968,
-0.0175189264,
-0.0051469146,
0.0652455986,
0.0347628668,
-0.0115981037,
0.007822901,
-0.0346632823,
0.0095975408,
-0.0005218196,
0.035476353,
-0.0774317831,
-0.0166008975,
0.0018036357,
0.054542128,
0.0116762687,
-0.0459118523,
0.0107228626,
-0.0994472131,
-0.0099589853,
0.0224371459,
0.0148933781,
0.0454230942,
0.0425584689,
0.0123611111,
0.0107033988,
-0.0519535728,
0.0165322274,
0.0125512145,
0.0116703147,
0.0542592891,
-0.0128655965,
-0.0126172947,
-0.0087990835,
-0.003781917,
0.0123099862,
0.0516333878,
0.0374159664,
-0.029849859,
-0.0121740531,
0.0687734783,
-0.0454557948,
-0.0319736339,
0.016217595,
-0.0023712844,
-0.0566122793,
0.0232473742,
0.0781238303,
0.0354172513,
0.0193430036,
0.0291389748,
-0.002643791,
0.0097289532,
-0.0460478328,
-0.0015954896,
-0.0301635023,
0.0487802587,
-0.0235506315,
-0.034660425,
0.0488960184,
0.0263191517,
0.047484044,
-0.0200774856,
-0.063479647,
-0.0040672682,
0.0054053445,
-0.0160630252,
-0.0556533523,
0.0007223249,
0.0216056481,
0.0042075599,
-0.035420116,
0.0148915695,
0.0385324471,
0.0169367455,
0.0462272651,
-0.0060886033,
0.0230471939,
0.0006999126,
0.0199968945,
0.004907107,
0.0510294177,
0.02091638,
0.0087314136,
-0.0418776609,
-0.0037485,
0.0234673433,
-0.0033894917,
0.0090709291,
-0.0663174614,
0.0186753944,
0.0054773963,
-0.0432250425,
-0.0047563887,
-0.0006839505,
0.0120921656,
0.0202400945,
0.0649123415,
-0.0117167057,
-0.008692828,
-0.0145976823,
0.0127277886,
0.0287359264,
-0.0153119611,
-0.0257005934,
-0.0147636915,
0.0707678944,
0.0691398829,
-0.0202638954,
0.0007461411,
-0.0098361839,
0.0114182811,
0.0619890615,
-0.0194279049,
-0.0185067132,
0.0223717988,
-0.0308895111,
-0.0583924502,
-0.0808460563,
-0.0317129977,
0.0144826369,
0.0233021937,
-0.0252673291,
0.0183789451,
0.0842029676,
-0.0021929704,
-0.0012306954,
0.0130886724,
0.0546401329,
0.0430244096,
-0.0241935886,
0.0045085032,
-0.1055855379,
-0.0122992918,
-0.0140091879,
0.0191658493,
0.0304707792,
-0.0605027303,
-0.0094949594,
-0.0651383847,
0.0138829891,
0.0052569644,
-0.0383367985,
-0.0670544282,
-0.0132505856,
-0.0200867038,
0.0017913757,
-0.0350325927,
0.0313855261,
-0.036041595,
0.0544354878,
-0.0205648728,
-0.0586716272,
-0.0711297393,
-0.0282837469,
-0.0296512898,
0.0351314284,
-0.0163547024,
0.051634863,
0.0529315434,
0.0186991524,
0.0012360296,
0.0119814537,
-0.0152900666,
-0.0154837389,
0.0463974141,
0.0155377826,
0.0193311516,
-0.0307943001,
0.0228530411,
-0.0554739013,
-0.0023462786,
0.0340927243,
0.028828457,
0.0179448016,
-0.0693525523,
0.0113245966,
-0.0004342092,
0.0041674748,
0.0722607225,
0.0529779904,
0.027726192,
-0.0472520292,
-0.0256977063,
0.0082591716,
-0.0828833207,
-0.0145707093,
0.018727418,
-0.0375508107,
-0.004779764,
-0.1148486435,
-0.0485188589,
0.0530021936,
0.0093448404,
0.008945466,
0.0101097692,
0.012572974,
-0.0293378346,
-0.0640743077,
-0.035022106,
-0.0570826046,
-0.005637432,
-0.0131512759,
-0.0188060105,
-0.0223231316,
-0.0116916494,
-0.0075615495,
0.0350917988,
-0.0714690536,
-0.0533988476,
-0.0262054428,
0.032835409,
0.0096307462,
0.058269266,
-0.006045653,
-0.011982983,
0.0736168846,
0.0312804505,
-0.0963572189,
0.0469731577,
0.0009806257,
0.0073610153,
-0.0042106998,
0.0616421103,
-0.0645631328,
0.0090799499,
-0.0102961119,
0.0625412017,
-0.0313187353,
-0.046238143,
-0.0035797714,
0.0609339736,
-0.0226134006,
-0.0304088611,
0.0243219119,
-0.019347379,
-0.020029135,
-0.0421666168,
-0.0033439037,
-0.0514592677,
0.0535855033,
0.001200675,
0.0460331589,
-0.0148775084,
0.0309020132,
0.0212449357,
-0.0004465682,
0.0043634335,
-0.0604249313,
-0.0084065702,
-0.0031188549,
0.0412290543,
-0.0286605433,
-0.0449261442,
0.0313001238,
-0.0430834331,
-0.0282545052,
-0.0318576619,
-0.0028066828,
0.0197864939,
0.0082188156,
-0.0678113997,
0.0067968951,
-0.029009793,
0.0088165989,
-0.0285057221,
0.0230580494,
0.0544580221,
0.0199212208,
0.0714765266,
-0.052458331,
-0.0250648484,
-0.0168224145,
0.0811547488,
0.0049533532,
-0.0207852274,
0.0036207661,
-0.0185433012,
-0.0240229648,
-0.0010245743,
0.0865018219,
0.029056279,
0.058811307,
-0.003106589,
-0.0247954633,
-0.0562843308,
-0.0506386273,
0.0156670567,
0.033310324,
0.0114824865,
-0.0116837816,
-0.0096738338,
-0.0748093128,
0.0228319671,
-0.0146224461,
-0.0093468195,
-0.0146659836,
0.0680514798,
0.0037838914,
-0.0042980444,
-0.0452189557,
-0.0426841192,
0.0126477145,
-0.0341510847,
-0.0410067402,
-0.0183843486,
-6.137290536e-33,
-0.0250189677,
-0.0235731304,
0.0073712375,
0.0226443857,
-0.0375433564,
-0.0068129529,
-0.0640788227,
-0.0367783867,
-0.0074732923,
0.0701745376,
-0.0076286225,
0.0196850765,
-0.0043434985,
0.0297777969,
-0.0256541558,
0.0321050733,
0.058470957,
-0.0085535664,
-0.0164383557,
0.0636689514,
-0.0004104341,
0.046391122,
0.0363201611,
-0.0856036469,
-0.0073577161,
-0.0040989839,
-0.0440182164,
-0.0080646267,
0.0361509062,
0.0036623536,
-0.0046055173,
0.0389805771,
0.018753849,
-0.0038618401,
-0.0154836467,
-0.0220333114,
-0.1184481233,
-0.0147036593,
0.0395946354,
-0.0243090596,
-0.0772636384,
-0.0672678053,
0.0550810061,
-0.0359933376,
0.0398901254,
-0.0425762571,
0.0456305481,
-0.0305796787,
-0.0371550694,
-0.089192763,
-0.038992051,
0.0267042164,
-0.0170411505,
-0.0078273341,
-0.0235164836,
-0.0075913812,
-0.0132964067,
-0.0516737476,
-0.0194686539,
0.0242407899,
0.0529119,
0.033614248,
0.0293616224,
-0.0128231244,
0.0264967661,
0.0259826388,
-0.0246352535,
-0.0049027316,
-0.0600671284,
0.044252295,
-0.0131011605,
0.031231923,
-0.0024821851,
0.0472740754,
-0.0334504135,
-0.0481036752,
-0.0517510399,
0.034218356,
-0.0300023928,
-0.0122991847,
-0.0315604731,
-0.0163471308,
-0.0138181308,
-0.0502230376,
-0.0196032524,
0.010415284,
0.009481132,
-0.0388787352,
-0.0065599815,
0.0233085528,
-0.0459752083,
-0.0178693775,
-0.0151359821,
-0.0330885984,
-0.0226196796,
0.0514547005,
-0.0076358169,
0.0242559612,
0.0017426618,
-0.0209561139,
-0.0500516444,
-0.0049808831,
0.0470635965,
0.0287925377,
-0.0020289009,
0.0344538502,
0.0255661234,
0.0073021133,
-0.0424477272,
0.0210263953,
0.0006790046,
0.0061072758,
-0.0117123183,
-0.0402772799,
0.0014191032,
0.0398179293,
0.0076364935,
0.0158506855,
0.0376574621,
-0.0188189577,
-0.004486606,
0.0508967787,
0.0656590685,
0.0416841246,
-0.0072010225,
-0.0133654084,
-0.0343012363,
-0.0212980881,
0.0240925383,
-0.024551807,
-0.0105708763,
0.0059032403,
2.494e-7,
0.0669847131,
0.0127726533,
0.0382424556,
0.0135039035,
0.0002893094,
0.0158139579,
0.063647531,
0.002753007,
-0.0428308807,
0.0121944351,
0.0628002957,
0.0073426631,
0.0175156202,
-0.0042083971,
-0.0924558043,
0.0317639746,
-0.0384735577,
-0.0641841143,
-0.0189975873,
-0.0325695239,
0.0566356741,
0.0112915915,
0.0190171506,
0.0062827212,
0.0015043212,
-0.0376690514,
0.0689117834,
0.0004429186,
0.0046297912,
0.0519522689,
0.0348417982,
-0.0339296423,
-0.0237635951,
0.0445765778,
-0.0321145877,
-0.0246137641,
0.0052431892,
0.1160710752,
0.0018587766,
0.0449496917,
-0.0054544779,
-0.0700033233,
0.0193193592,
-0.0295110755,
0.0522816926,
-0.0546947271,
0.0279862229,
0.035896346,
-0.0226736721,
0.0037813766,
-0.0101412954,
-0.0002216441,
-0.0364543833,
0.0228002258,
0.0330229662,
0.0253510792,
-0.0148161622,
-0.0664364472,
-0.0335039869,
-0.0100440448,
-0.0123391878,
0.0023189522,
-0.0145683456,
0.0194670614,
0.0163132362,
-0.033604458,
0.026901165,
2.126610478e-34,
0.027084671,
-0.0049644965,
-0.0204314161,
-0.0309668798,
0.0413423739,
-0.0484587476,
-0.0096350769,
0.0139369406,
0.002473959,
-0.0604572557,
-0.0058262371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06966v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06966v2 | EcomGPT: Instruction-tuning Large Language Models with Chain-of-Task Tasks for E-commerce | 2023-08-14T06:49:53 | 2023-08-28T04:12:30 | Yangning Li, Shirong Ma, Xiaobin Wang, Shen Huang, Chengyue Jiang, Hai-Tao Zheng, Pengjun Xie, Fei Huang, Yong Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, instruction-following Large Language Models (LLMs) , represented by
ChatGPT, have exhibited exceptional performance in general Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks. However, the unique characteristics of E-commerce data
pose significant challenges to general LLMs. An LLM tailored specifically for
E-commerce scenarios, possessing robust cross-dataset/task generalization
capabilities, is a pressing necessity. To solve this issue, in this work, we
proposed the first e-commerce instruction dataset EcomInstruct, with a total of
2.5 million instruction data. EcomInstruct scales up the data size and task
diversity by constructing atomic tasks with E-commerce basic data types, such
as product information, user reviews. Atomic tasks are defined as intermediate
tasks implicitly involved in solving a final task, which we also call
Chain-of-Task tasks. We developed EcomGPT with different parameter scales by
training the backbone model BLOOMZ with the EcomInstruct. Benefiting from the
fundamental semantic understanding capabilities acquired from the Chain-of-Task
tasks, EcomGPT exhibits excellent zero-shot generalization capabilities.
Extensive experiments and human evaluations demonstrate that EcomGPT
outperforms ChatGPT in term of cross-dataset/task generalization on E-commerce
tasks. | [
0.0683768019,
0.0158699844,
-0.0075941468,
0.0353861786,
-0.0271050259,
0.0446802191,
0.0169243403,
-0.0359568372,
0.0170014091,
-0.0823056698,
-0.0526128821,
-0.0339671373,
-0.0385279059,
0.0436052978,
-0.0087937135,
-0.0265490394,
0.0278119352,
0.0029189209,
-0.0183678418,
0.0211326387,
0.0324430168,
0.0447408222,
-0.0080398517,
0.0355281942,
0.0457948707,
-0.0375568122,
-0.0111505557,
0.0084321043,
0.0046493546,
-0.0212245993,
0.0532757491,
0.0264314935,
0.0512013584,
-0.0257836115,
0.0000019927,
-0.0439144149,
-0.0228349585,
-0.0240346454,
-0.0654518977,
-0.0181020238,
0.0345209017,
0.0173897017,
0.0255023763,
0.0335202962,
-0.0190392379,
0.018228827,
0.0433213674,
0.1047092751,
0.0411538184,
0.0935710296,
-0.0019434561,
-0.0488072261,
0.0035766002,
-0.0241116323,
0.0321675204,
-0.0256549455,
0.0295120459,
-0.007400048,
0.0142069217,
0.047779046,
0.0029124646,
-0.014644742,
0.0163293406,
0.02836827,
0.0027601006,
0.0223122295,
0.0128630279,
-0.0050284653,
-0.0347794518,
0.0944364071,
-0.0084706834,
0.0003691818,
0.001030274,
0.0019642406,
0.0044894502,
-0.0417021029,
-0.0294703674,
0.0199074578,
0.013123868,
0.0173575915,
0.0149138672,
-0.0071445,
0.0105702439,
0.0215229988,
0.0004444134,
0.0620199628,
-0.0140793268,
-0.0294862725,
0.0058785593,
0.0018154881,
-0.0670399293,
-0.0050000483,
0.0037505201,
0.0267393216,
-0.062937282,
0.0322236754,
-0.0091551803,
0.0188002791,
-0.0030472856,
-0.0297582503,
0.0606516264,
0.0336540081,
-0.013030828,
0.0722836182,
-0.0093471762,
0.0525615811,
0.0083213216,
-0.0061749509,
-0.0616538748,
0.0249290876,
-0.1076186597,
-0.0004910521,
-0.0349850617,
0.0469140559,
-0.0478512794,
-0.028108852,
-0.0476501249,
0.007316303,
-0.0110770222,
-0.0158314519,
0.0597400814,
0.0154458573,
-0.0482736528,
-0.0067720325,
-0.0296571366,
0.0108652608,
-0.0366521813,
0.0400298536,
-0.006760959,
-0.0261475928,
0.0100386087,
-0.0060390295,
0.0005243632,
-0.0417217165,
0.0399043523,
0.0366186462,
0.0060671102,
-0.0484459475,
-0.090852879,
-0.0193751287,
0.0016348592,
-0.0720626935,
-0.0080732629,
-0.0433930233,
0.0630564392,
0.0155084934,
0.0023770004,
0.0313234888,
-0.0046620383,
0.032312151,
-0.027468672,
0.0821936801,
0.0352367386,
-0.0209898911,
-0.0278336797,
-0.0085982326,
0.0082757557,
0.0761493966,
-0.0136716673,
0.0133581599,
0.0312238,
0.0097823767,
-0.0314218365,
0.0242654663,
-0.0254958458,
-0.0175643209,
0.0141844125,
0.0283012949,
-0.0171160679,
-0.0048475284,
0.0349837951,
0.0285673328,
-0.0435811393,
-0.0106930165,
0.0468275286,
0.0140265394,
-0.0102216369,
0.0364942923,
0.0504318923,
0.062991336,
0.0001143237,
0.0007680831,
-0.0334239267,
-0.001986295,
-0.0181900188,
-0.021793155,
-0.0296739582,
0.0161735378,
-0.0542767607,
-0.011367294,
0.0105092451,
-0.022180032,
0.0229079649,
0.0128040947,
0.0338651612,
0.0083705233,
-0.0579835251,
0.0261978842,
0.0298270509,
-0.0245474279,
-0.010222625,
-0.0442087017,
-0.0061344043,
0.1083148867,
0.0266215634,
-0.0292106699,
-0.0629178956,
-0.0308967661,
0.035069719,
0.0508340523,
0.0019595164,
-0.0426729433,
0.00169378,
-0.0605442524,
-0.0541343205,
-0.0440013409,
-0.0128747635,
0.0128643308,
0.0347534306,
-0.053863164,
0.0038817783,
-0.0091817854,
-0.0043634633,
0.0225436129,
-0.0197776258,
-0.0382124707,
0.0023667095,
0.0125182318,
0.0417159982,
0.0164237302,
0.0059438637,
-0.0130724097,
0.0082640722,
-0.0393624119,
-0.0455316305,
-0.0162289571,
-0.0221230872,
-0.0232147016,
0.0480311476,
-0.0248270202,
-0.0011253729,
0.0191920511,
-0.0659455433,
-0.0429299474,
-0.0154414335,
-0.019430764,
0.0536174998,
-0.0091658626,
0.0043210317,
0.0030504595,
-0.0001728344,
-0.0169200283,
0.0425218828,
-0.0006228426,
0.0255699959,
-0.005223196,
-0.0142990695,
-0.0115780933,
-0.0129445288,
-0.0364743248,
-0.0046701632,
-0.0201126859,
0.0242161807,
0.0367976539,
0.0432820171,
-0.0539305806,
-0.0168414675,
-0.0981331989,
0.0202617589,
0.0021878236,
0.05235333,
0.0444123372,
-0.0040412233,
-0.0004649164,
-0.0106659336,
-0.0264852792,
0.0466096774,
-0.0242640208,
0.027142467,
0.0289736856,
0.0048925504,
-0.0171640553,
-0.0029240432,
-0.0194235183,
-0.0140398275,
0.0083878487,
0.002022631,
-0.0139682768,
-0.0570988469,
0.0085868193,
-0.0033983276,
0.0154773286,
-0.0099740559,
-0.0089561138,
-0.0278676786,
-0.0247132741,
0.0611594282,
0.0489311218,
-0.0279757176,
-0.001384574,
0.014332477,
-0.0436597914,
-0.0606007017,
0.0231262576,
-0.0364935771,
-0.007625544,
-0.040522147,
0.0015170176,
-0.0068935724,
0.1272186637,
-0.0380206406,
-0.0077116499,
-0.0522089228,
-0.0377563536,
-0.0289108101,
0.0034476575,
-0.0384427682,
0.0038796251,
-0.0073666978,
-0.0213041883,
-0.0512725338,
-0.0160830449,
0.0635054708,
0.0170894656,
-0.0066012917,
-0.0947080478,
0.0099706743,
-0.0433080122,
0.0481160805,
-0.0017201465,
0.0217237845,
0.0046696998,
-0.0531600788,
-0.04869565,
0.0355570912,
0.0230773259,
-0.0154789053,
0.0327084139,
-0.0331577957,
0.0154198483,
-0.024741726,
-0.038813021,
-0.0392731801,
-0.0199959371,
-0.0005855878,
0.0129367299,
0.0463792346,
-0.0049519134,
-0.0824068412,
-0.0070384014,
0.0065313946,
0.0293071549,
-0.0113953827,
-0.0290311687,
-0.0275349617,
-0.0159106106,
0.0594168417,
-0.0247620791,
-0.0107149146,
-0.0355968587,
0.0108689247,
0.0368037745,
0.0341517031,
-0.0548692644,
-0.0168859996,
0.0157178845,
0.0438399687,
-0.0636105835,
-0.0039631254,
0.0449525006,
0.0232710559,
-0.0648945794,
-0.0024231328,
0.1149373949,
0.0262636598,
-0.050210394,
-0.0103678778,
0.0355929099,
-0.0093729421,
0.0387494154,
0.0292814113,
-0.0704589114,
-0.0419670716,
-0.0023787853,
0.0001080089,
0.0197668485,
-0.0346028171,
-0.0198782347,
-0.1155479848,
-0.00921892,
-0.022712715,
-0.006059228,
-0.0155771235,
-0.061240714,
-0.0051196283,
-0.0259832181,
0.063201502,
0.0061700623,
-0.0406931452,
-0.0166452285,
0.0395153016,
0.0245785583,
-0.0574729778,
0.0599979647,
-0.039930176,
0.0457942374,
0.0169507489,
0.0047440329,
0.0112982625,
0.0469561145,
0.0446097255,
-0.009088845,
-0.0251691304,
-0.0147807011,
0.0471262299,
-0.0223350618,
-0.0017790224,
0.0061485823,
0.0243965443,
-0.0518438481,
0.0009642174,
0.0030501618,
0.050569728,
0.0106431358,
0.0107906619,
0.0025080938,
-0.0395114198,
-0.0305267125,
0.0860033706,
0.0031618366,
-0.0671164095,
-0.036274299,
-0.0293267164,
-0.0758741945,
-0.0662821159,
-0.0163759775,
0.0363737755,
-0.010817064,
-0.0090146363,
-0.0638267845,
-0.0468729846,
0.0571377911,
0.0086626979,
0.0322378129,
-0.0337370448,
0.0424666703,
0.0141969435,
-0.0425817072,
0.02853835,
-0.0513574146,
0.025440529,
-0.0786633343,
0.0092653595,
0.0290984027,
-0.0257013571,
-0.0208363589,
0.0129355621,
-0.0833762363,
-0.0407402217,
0.0011069985,
0.0309218019,
0.0119358879,
0.0361259766,
-0.0228786357,
-0.0557799377,
-0.0100741852,
0.0565220676,
-0.0462508649,
-0.0401911922,
0.0322631672,
0.023026498,
-0.0006461583,
0.0267179236,
-0.0561056137,
0.0428216942,
0.0236774776,
0.0728790835,
0.0101747941,
0.0072748852,
0.0458029062,
0.0104634566,
0.022513818,
0.0040068063,
0.0308392979,
-0.058159858,
0.0289074071,
0.0206718296,
-0.0127462279,
-0.0555479936,
0.000118015,
0.0458210744,
-0.0297325291,
-0.0003140118,
0.0281660557,
-0.0097746206,
-0.0064458135,
-0.0400121212,
0.0097545795,
-0.0110639026,
0.0195291359,
0.0178049095,
-0.0124992291,
-0.009143413,
-0.0006978253,
0.0447694622,
-0.0007970536,
-0.0072026597,
0.0811076909,
0.0191538632,
-0.0048218523,
-0.0482339449,
0.0345651321,
-0.0042433953,
0.0160050169,
-0.0515231714,
-0.0059102094,
0.0411274247,
-0.0283042993,
0.0526186377,
-0.0339836441,
-0.0192949306,
-0.0200801063,
0.0416144691,
-0.0248456988,
-0.0030167866,
0.0252720229,
0.0339097343,
-0.0231349841,
0.0273010917,
0.0926484764,
-0.0090400185,
0.0529270023,
0.0286386386,
-0.0311014075,
-0.0570814237,
-0.0261738189,
-0.0046750638,
0.0016738485,
-0.0363470688,
0.0399813652,
-0.0090714134,
-0.0466404594,
-0.0250841975,
-0.0148918638,
0.0156849474,
0.0108705675,
0.0639333501,
0.0607797243,
-0.0108355032,
-0.0027286345,
-0.0274734236,
-0.0087272059,
0.0186676979,
0.0099114869,
-0.0325224735,
-6.284605692e-33,
0.0125191575,
0.010834855,
0.0215009321,
0.0180288907,
0.0210988298,
0.0374229476,
-0.0197120514,
0.0135370428,
0.001840943,
0.0004733537,
0.0042779441,
0.0162541401,
0.016573457,
0.0477395765,
0.0205559526,
-0.0332296826,
0.0511559956,
-0.0129964715,
0.006537552,
0.057018321,
0.0256588161,
0.0470729098,
0.0860999227,
-0.0375790112,
0.045839157,
-0.0091115609,
-0.0083942031,
0.0444890633,
0.0320823975,
0.0877338946,
-0.0436093323,
0.0590441488,
0.041980572,
-0.073087886,
-0.0217651371,
0.0048050839,
-0.10575293,
-0.0219365582,
0.0228440929,
0.0112627521,
-0.0370347425,
-0.001319708,
0.022210896,
0.0050984556,
0.0093649607,
0.0003118369,
0.028499173,
-0.0190538056,
0.0093139438,
-0.0172275305,
-0.0605180562,
-0.0018497498,
-0.0132048884,
-0.0342705958,
0.0492585413,
0.0764945373,
-0.0225690082,
0.0081898915,
-0.0175197572,
0.0404218659,
-0.014025378,
0.0276991576,
0.0383376256,
0.0119802253,
-0.0039360188,
0.0439533703,
-0.0009994366,
0.0213332921,
0.0048324531,
0.0071158316,
0.0050454806,
0.0611104183,
0.0080331415,
0.0078611681,
0.0306440275,
0.0527873747,
-0.0674346611,
0.009219043,
0.0857472867,
0.0460293144,
0.0297280122,
0.0023380115,
-0.0316991396,
-0.0210845154,
0.0072384626,
0.0058017438,
-0.0398774706,
-0.0167520549,
0.0480083674,
0.0242592879,
-0.0298265498,
-0.0042009098,
0.0312337875,
-0.0515067019,
-0.0671215951,
0.0129106734,
0.0012353478,
-0.0039249463,
0.0376068279,
0.0089588678,
-0.0930761918,
-0.0784063041,
0.008407495,
-0.0455582887,
-0.0095882304,
-0.0038986944,
0.0618012249,
0.0175525863,
-0.0443788692,
0.0049673468,
-0.0436814986,
0.0124586942,
-0.0130037023,
0.0782317445,
0.0304996967,
0.0294492953,
-0.0289821681,
0.0943682864,
0.013707702,
-0.0196090192,
-0.0147490287,
-0.0198800936,
0.0066536539,
0.024675047,
-0.0006974795,
-0.0136651183,
-0.0486831032,
0.0111682396,
-0.01569359,
-0.0663277879,
-0.0305116661,
0.028918352,
2.769e-7,
0.0294312313,
0.0601979382,
-0.0120316567,
0.0158309974,
0.0130906068,
0.0325090699,
-0.0071372734,
0.0293418244,
0.0066737467,
-0.0276316758,
0.0169883985,
0.0242903009,
0.0386584066,
0.0001268222,
-0.1001712456,
-0.0130660813,
-0.0356638357,
0.0055464157,
-0.0506872684,
0.0201562773,
0.0306355059,
0.0972019061,
0.0123335319,
0.0047514639,
-0.0038426367,
-0.0278149229,
0.0430530421,
-0.0303985048,
-0.0183079969,
0.0177604798,
0.0131483497,
0.0639100671,
-0.0099459393,
0.0106291343,
-0.0149301747,
0.0408728793,
0.0009486204,
0.0877268836,
0.014647874,
0.0114273271,
0.0123025645,
-0.0388277583,
-0.0242835209,
-0.0231152866,
0.0717212036,
-0.0995406881,
-0.0316368192,
-0.0015824164,
-0.0049226149,
-0.0249500461,
-0.0159513783,
-0.0062011839,
0.004670897,
-0.0051136855,
0.0221291911,
-0.0504758544,
-0.0442862846,
-0.0690146238,
0.0212828554,
0.0393430591,
-0.0255667195,
-0.0073653255,
-0.0124463215,
0.0224132165,
0.0136760306,
-0.0535468794,
0.0093671167,
2.810382914e-34,
0.0422620401,
-0.0213708468,
0.0349095874,
0.0048408816,
0.0206855293,
0.0001603149,
-0.065148294,
-0.0005619727,
-0.0019335177,
-0.0867951289,
-0.0210597031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06953v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06953v3 | Thresh: A Unified, Customizable and Deployable Platform for Fine-Grained Text Evaluation | 2023-08-14T06:09:51 | 2023-10-16T14:51:08 | David Heineman, Yao Dou, Wei Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fine-grained, span-level human evaluation has emerged as a reliable and
robust method for evaluating text generation tasks such as summarization,
simplification, machine translation and news generation, and the derived
annotations have been useful for training automatic metrics and improving
language models. However, existing annotation tools implemented for these
evaluation frameworks lack the adaptability to be extended to different domains
or languages, or modify annotation settings according to user needs; and, the
absence of a unified annotated data format inhibits the research in multi-task
learning. In this paper, we introduce Thresh, a unified, customizable and
deployable platform for fine-grained evaluation. With a single YAML
configuration file, users can build and test an annotation interface for any
framework within minutes -- all in one web browser window. To facilitate
collaboration and sharing, Thresh provides a community hub that hosts a
collection of fine-grained frameworks and corresponding annotations made and
collected by the community, covering a wide range of NLP tasks. For deployment,
Thresh offers multiple options for any scale of annotation projects from small
manual inspections to large crowdsourcing ones. Additionally, we introduce a
Python library to streamline the entire process from typology design and
deployment to annotation processing. Thresh is publicly accessible at
https://thresh.tools. | [
0.033436317,
-0.0135811949,
0.0075250859,
-0.0030896168,
-0.003619598,
0.0226339698,
0.0079274932,
-0.022111129,
0.0025589117,
-0.0566958413,
-0.0411886871,
0.0137341945,
0.018534597,
0.0173164662,
0.0418324769,
-0.0635942817,
0.000004147,
0.0028685927,
0.0141709,
0.0259337127,
0.0396647491,
0.0292711761,
-0.0053486968,
0.0777149945,
-0.0096856114,
0.0026420278,
0.0056669703,
0.0099195056,
0.0482640229,
-0.0364263058,
0.0206659026,
0.0723573938,
-0.001338203,
0.0477115102,
0.0000020831,
-0.0278644189,
0.0062144008,
0.0073194993,
0.0208120942,
0.0165550858,
0.0699975789,
0.004175147,
0.0272179153,
-0.0015759451,
-0.0379194804,
-0.0147845149,
0.0510114729,
0.0096240751,
0.0960852504,
0.0435608998,
-0.0003539906,
-0.0018649704,
-0.0280601326,
-0.0347039402,
-0.02099826,
-0.0199549254,
-0.0238813031,
0.006753155,
0.0171070918,
-0.0140969064,
0.0392804518,
0.0106889242,
0.0173113104,
-0.0274900328,
0.046519693,
0.0152482595,
-0.0638585836,
-0.054181017,
-0.0230935793,
0.0861491784,
0.0229269639,
-0.0444486029,
0.0209992044,
-0.0008030963,
0.0026544083,
-0.0171499997,
-0.057788182,
0.0276448131,
0.0218563266,
0.0064462372,
-0.0075852913,
0.0123533634,
-0.0018547135,
0.0366489366,
0.0398870707,
0.0286977943,
0.0008821124,
0.0269341543,
-0.0315649137,
0.0706766099,
-0.0296232421,
-0.0761811137,
0.0182203427,
0.0247608721,
-0.0359085202,
-0.0460979715,
-0.0529058427,
-0.0930165648,
0.0567395873,
-0.0236108173,
0.0432306156,
-0.0042298432,
-0.0281079225,
0.0340506956,
-0.0094016958,
-0.0037814225,
0.0355769023,
0.0026820486,
-0.024683835,
0.0062397635,
-0.0671984106,
0.0159266572,
-0.0364991836,
0.0377142578,
-0.0183551535,
-0.012682437,
-0.0581892096,
-0.0033262675,
-0.0483434647,
0.0228034053,
0.0152777797,
0.0176362023,
-0.0359801017,
0.0113031687,
0.006169064,
0.033479657,
-0.0895528421,
0.0096191736,
0.051739186,
-0.0336271524,
-0.0095151719,
0.0382580869,
0.0216486715,
-0.0069088279,
0.0004811262,
0.0240229797,
-0.0173099898,
0.0000590224,
-0.0324127339,
-0.0686631873,
-0.0184084456,
-0.0599401668,
-0.0259931702,
-0.1138733774,
0.0142819127,
0.0148493806,
0.0079286052,
-0.0253896248,
0.0015404106,
0.0328484513,
0.0052696299,
0.0225353185,
-0.04856655,
-0.0368096419,
0.0288960673,
-0.0056962217,
-0.0014994505,
0.0708840266,
0.0421731584,
0.0807877183,
0.0261595808,
0.0064107939,
0.0088773547,
0.0108508859,
0.0105268341,
0.0058626249,
0.038678918,
-0.012004205,
-0.026486963,
0.0336976498,
-0.0060443892,
0.0498210862,
-0.0216987859,
0.0582301281,
0.05635323,
0.0114250667,
-0.00530665,
-0.0233573038,
0.0688916519,
0.0453974605,
-0.0032848348,
0.0090543665,
-0.0195436906,
0.048797965,
-0.0502271876,
0.0072114798,
0.0532287732,
0.0403179228,
-0.0030079579,
-0.041516874,
-0.0256026927,
-0.0222822409,
0.01632444,
-0.0171983,
0.0270741191,
0.0225875285,
-0.0185930841,
0.0396579616,
0.036227949,
-0.0847411156,
0.0657767206,
-0.0071488512,
0.0284780171,
0.0695833042,
0.0483475812,
-0.0152836256,
-0.0194364693,
-0.0323908292,
0.0332092084,
0.0320302136,
0.0399684533,
-0.0345070921,
-0.0241584294,
-0.0420872793,
-0.0204165354,
-0.0349582806,
0.0170787312,
-0.0052919821,
0.0149582159,
-0.0315852612,
0.0362742431,
-0.0426374637,
-0.0754977614,
0.0507799909,
0.0156982262,
-0.0106108701,
-0.0164996106,
-0.0082752872,
0.008011559,
0.0484965369,
-0.0126658864,
0.0207509436,
0.0179095697,
-0.0199546609,
-0.0094881468,
0.0133107333,
0.0293335803,
-0.0256663337,
0.0170427822,
-0.0816718265,
-0.0107131749,
0.0338448919,
-0.0530647449,
-0.0380844623,
-0.0123942178,
-0.0288641155,
-0.0386573635,
-0.0353793688,
0.0000183754,
0.0086442679,
0.0028202105,
-0.0308704544,
0.0527974069,
0.0355169997,
0.0127625745,
0.017462682,
-0.0357539989,
0.009485309,
-0.0120909484,
-0.0354058817,
-0.0337950215,
-0.0030934601,
0.0088652745,
0.0515824221,
0.055507943,
-0.0578010045,
-0.006107877,
-0.1221931875,
0.014169422,
-0.0258277487,
0.031995073,
0.0364834033,
0.0110012358,
0.0128818732,
-0.0045240219,
-0.0385329463,
0.0057184086,
0.0098715331,
0.0169807598,
0.0526068769,
0.0081782583,
0.0626338124,
-0.044516556,
0.0030716965,
0.0187646393,
0.0479102805,
0.0683391839,
-0.0300763771,
-0.028960729,
-0.0069745448,
-0.024992615,
-0.0349126086,
0.055792693,
-0.0266400911,
0.020551132,
0.0123258745,
0.0196914151,
0.0272008963,
0.0237596072,
0.0328788422,
0.0438859798,
0.0162513088,
-0.027860472,
-0.0055744303,
-0.0010463597,
0.0141722243,
0.0126095796,
-0.0198490787,
0.0059258374,
0.0454753153,
-0.0036905755,
-0.0076355697,
-0.0661251545,
0.0325605683,
-0.0577193648,
-0.0278000124,
-0.0254260991,
0.0039287722,
0.0016945808,
0.0348775014,
-0.0233902074,
-0.0256962758,
0.0835745409,
-0.0146793239,
-0.0005374683,
-0.037438713,
0.0040112212,
-0.0537529886,
0.0469583832,
-0.006765279,
0.0075135352,
-0.0046376949,
-0.0019550901,
-0.0341575295,
0.0214059297,
0.0447298959,
-0.0224703588,
0.0278212614,
-0.0626580045,
-0.0113297123,
-0.0444714874,
-0.0341789089,
0.0192410499,
-0.0127850454,
-0.0536852479,
0.0147505859,
0.052584894,
-0.012819292,
0.0059745302,
-0.0113393031,
0.0221098959,
0.037324883,
-0.0185776241,
-0.0134949889,
0.0051743994,
0.0491834506,
0.0351120159,
0.0329876393,
0.0076624127,
-0.0394925214,
-0.0278660879,
0.0437652022,
0.0084527293,
0.0178637337,
-0.0109112775,
-0.0203120019,
0.0343462117,
-0.0500491932,
-0.0087543931,
-0.0002870881,
0.0809402391,
-0.0608434863,
0.0014307346,
0.1075750738,
0.0245781858,
-0.0231175143,
0.0031653948,
0.0121441772,
0.0829505846,
0.0207092278,
0.0120620187,
-0.1061943099,
-0.0442865938,
-0.0041488227,
0.0613272078,
0.0154637648,
-0.027495062,
0.0069971648,
-0.0883929953,
0.0384039693,
0.006302671,
-0.0523055121,
0.0175003093,
-0.0367421918,
0.0112478901,
-0.0458354689,
-0.0165500138,
-0.0101746684,
-0.0089724828,
0.0411986262,
0.0359049998,
-0.0523952059,
-0.0380899049,
0.0003470585,
-0.0448920839,
0.0335380137,
0.0359861851,
0.0429372229,
-0.0027692767,
0.0024723765,
0.0080161365,
0.0073216432,
0.0011663124,
-0.0278217085,
0.0821901187,
0.0093110725,
-0.0232715122,
-0.0176440254,
0.0331039578,
-0.0165013745,
-0.0190368518,
0.0136787482,
0.0238076858,
0.0169455614,
0.0078811878,
-0.0067867436,
0.0182511173,
0.0300793611,
0.0737632141,
0.0510259904,
-0.0433860086,
-0.050111562,
-0.0286107454,
-0.005112431,
-0.1265419871,
-0.0372154079,
-0.0022089046,
-0.0195576418,
-0.0391506441,
-0.1327555329,
-0.0585443005,
0.0621521324,
0.0253234152,
0.0284674447,
-0.0179567318,
-0.0186084453,
0.0093508428,
-0.0436606891,
0.0336552151,
-0.0138950907,
0.0040545138,
-0.0346684158,
-0.047376506,
0.001877813,
-0.0331847146,
-0.0128365494,
0.1044312567,
-0.1139641479,
-0.0478115454,
-0.0039509372,
0.0398493595,
0.0146257933,
0.0265314039,
-0.0196080673,
-0.0545040555,
0.0271027572,
0.037404079,
-0.0568728186,
-0.0016959546,
0.0161162596,
0.0017654585,
-0.0181412268,
0.0195688158,
-0.049840346,
0.0054445947,
-0.0357708782,
0.0319689438,
0.0300809871,
-0.027728511,
0.0100777401,
0.0348110497,
0.0169542562,
-0.0663194284,
-0.0211796742,
-0.0343305618,
-0.0397675484,
-0.00921035,
-0.0430423133,
-0.0482869446,
0.0103485957,
-0.0083866101,
-0.0067539518,
0.0132241221,
0.0789380744,
0.0279870518,
0.0555493571,
-0.0732806697,
0.038888555,
0.0032137588,
0.0135578085,
-0.0161020588,
-0.0038313975,
-0.0537116379,
-0.0289143138,
-0.049884636,
0.0312579013,
-0.0196725726,
0.0052633933,
0.0172636323,
-0.0129809109,
0.0317827649,
0.0587119348,
-0.0384359844,
0.0092956778,
-0.0541407801,
0.0326588266,
0.0524890982,
-0.0044250237,
0.1119301319,
-0.0221784748,
-0.0309905875,
-0.0213251561,
0.0644862279,
-0.0007086839,
-0.0256880634,
-0.0433007181,
0.0005294686,
-0.014868496,
-0.0153675405,
0.0863122419,
-0.0304537602,
0.0188883245,
0.0077711069,
-0.0180918388,
-0.055754222,
-0.0348304734,
-0.0386628844,
0.0337335877,
0.0000415488,
-0.0209196713,
-0.0522759631,
-0.0277089532,
-0.0052430579,
0.0321787857,
0.0023606189,
0.0017273353,
0.0619286783,
0.0466703549,
-0.011443099,
0.0177941117,
-0.0743318722,
-0.0122214146,
-0.0039813113,
0.0077049639,
-0.011223427,
-6.574444395e-33,
-0.0490261801,
-0.0477463603,
-0.0155436397,
0.0054805065,
-0.0179535579,
0.0058650691,
-0.0408609472,
0.0167056732,
0.0252226386,
0.0105639119,
0.03128995,
-0.0340855755,
0.0152642308,
0.0257918313,
0.0261739958,
0.007460075,
0.0490783118,
0.0202344041,
-0.0600010194,
0.0508072712,
0.0370805599,
0.0063039144,
0.0546833351,
-0.0399014056,
0.056456957,
-0.0104136607,
-0.0627738312,
-0.0281342845,
0.0052336659,
0.0433299989,
-0.0009124864,
0.02813817,
0.031324327,
-0.0479417145,
-0.019834511,
-0.0002057135,
-0.0572637171,
-0.0167073645,
0.0038369731,
-0.0292845871,
-0.077337198,
-0.0230806097,
0.0575646907,
-0.0297217704,
0.0032363797,
0.0011078324,
0.0584838651,
-0.0412564129,
-0.0037896652,
-0.0423730351,
-0.0777179003,
0.0257885344,
-0.0316961221,
-0.0369220637,
0.0041979617,
0.0542992204,
-0.0054798401,
0.0113407923,
-0.0558135621,
0.0393748134,
-0.0045309691,
0.0230229124,
0.0591477752,
0.0081771445,
-0.0327177458,
0.066235587,
-0.0284422226,
0.0226595365,
-0.0220278557,
0.0155833354,
0.0004971536,
0.0435901135,
0.0660300776,
0.0695498586,
-0.0076975999,
0.0161375143,
-0.0350169614,
0.083248727,
0.0275217332,
0.0103128599,
0.0033318216,
-0.0134819625,
-0.0020172428,
-0.0022602063,
-0.0428157374,
-0.0160907339,
-0.0240473542,
-0.0129997209,
-0.0118276086,
0.0149028711,
-0.0571426898,
0.0251862742,
0.0015610574,
-0.0009551273,
0.0192641318,
0.016988229,
-0.01675882,
0.0442595929,
-0.0020018318,
-0.0189871229,
-0.0211689379,
0.0028149935,
0.0238217115,
0.0283355061,
0.0342233069,
-0.0169000197,
0.0809755549,
0.0131991142,
-0.0331913494,
0.0340268016,
-0.0294665657,
0.0445285551,
-0.0390277058,
-0.0147493854,
0.0065148775,
-0.0150141679,
-0.0136136496,
0.0050964649,
0.0241948087,
0.0088165319,
-0.0087997606,
-0.0026373989,
0.0313412398,
-0.0096005714,
-0.0356244408,
0.0243870206,
-0.0191827677,
-0.0020905775,
0.0093169892,
0.0082840351,
-0.0159116779,
-0.0183836948,
2.693e-7,
0.0541369431,
0.063338697,
0.041308742,
-0.0129851177,
-0.0070287818,
0.0122128502,
-0.0102331229,
0.0415478125,
-0.0228270963,
-0.0045845765,
0.0153426332,
0.0099639921,
0.0749138147,
0.0345855281,
-0.083958663,
-0.0114937555,
-0.0641764477,
0.0312402993,
-0.034744177,
-0.0237875488,
0.0467908904,
0.0126741473,
0.0213797037,
0.0042280387,
0.010757043,
-0.0035658029,
0.0493799038,
-0.0201625433,
-0.0133132786,
0.0470867008,
0.0353091545,
-0.0114541547,
-0.0088127479,
-0.0029120424,
-0.0485766865,
-0.0426990613,
0.0302185565,
0.0348747969,
0.0208551195,
-0.0150029929,
0.0077130771,
-0.0368670151,
0.047750596,
-0.0634086728,
0.0491440333,
-0.0422218367,
-0.0300334189,
-0.049230244,
-0.0043798964,
0.0089776935,
0.0055757719,
-0.0113057178,
-0.0297172088,
0.0162567049,
-0.0085976589,
-0.0112853404,
-0.0511757843,
-0.0489960238,
-0.062044818,
0.0185704865,
-0.0278908182,
-0.0411001146,
-0.031115409,
-0.0344106928,
-0.0399756841,
-0.07952784,
0.0057811299,
2.326067303e-34,
0.044534374,
-0.0151042165,
-0.0040743998,
-0.0187978763,
0.0407355018,
0.0106178904,
-0.0489335507,
-0.0359792449,
0.0271583851,
-0.0145322476,
0.011128271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06942v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06942v1 | Approximating Human-Like Few-shot Learning with GPT-based Compression | 2023-08-14T05:22:33 | 2023-08-14T05:22:33 | Cynthia Huang, Yuqing Xie, Zhiying Jiang, Jimmy Lin, Ming Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT | In this work, we conceptualize the learning process as information
compression. We seek to equip generative pre-trained models with human-like
learning capabilities that enable data compression during inference. We present
a novel approach that utilizes the Generative Pre-trained Transformer (GPT) to
approximate Kolmogorov complexity, with the aim of estimating the optimal
Information Distance for few-shot learning. We first propose using GPT as a
prior for lossless text compression, achieving a noteworthy compression ratio.
Experiment with LLAMA2-7B backbone achieves a compression ratio of 15.5 on
enwik9. We justify the pre-training objective of GPT models by demonstrating
its equivalence to the compression length, and, consequently, its ability to
approximate the information distance for texts. Leveraging the approximated
information distance, our method allows the direct application of GPT models in
quantitative text similarity measurements. Experiment results show that our
method overall achieves superior performance compared to embedding and prompt
baselines on challenging NLP tasks, including semantic similarity, zero and
one-shot text classification, and zero-shot text ranking. | [
-0.0033841627,
0.0588741004,
-0.0012529119,
-0.0157567989,
-0.0324452072,
0.0279833227,
0.0184789244,
0.0800145566,
-0.0391371325,
-0.0208366904,
-0.0403523184,
0.0084610237,
-0.004937856,
-0.0459450446,
0.0264849253,
-0.033664044,
0.0036119896,
0.0649929717,
-0.0176925398,
-0.0054956358,
0.0029400326,
-0.0211385489,
0.0294095706,
0.0203124564,
0.0172059629,
-0.0199047215,
-0.0322423987,
0.005028368,
0.0292095952,
-0.0266244616,
-0.0313187614,
0.0454069488,
0.018790938,
0.0302736107,
0.0000022377,
-0.0288599432,
-0.0168971214,
0.0236776043,
-0.0520761721,
-0.0083370963,
0.0298202019,
-0.0107893236,
0.0089042708,
-0.0042090574,
-0.0263566691,
-0.0677146167,
0.0571273118,
0.0644855872,
0.0230899435,
0.0665567219,
-0.0211213902,
-0.0454483964,
0.0038090283,
-0.0503246561,
0.0491474047,
-0.0047176313,
-0.0079780938,
-0.0231438652,
-0.0195702203,
0.0351127572,
-0.0471863821,
0.036478363,
0.0360971168,
0.0387486331,
0.0075935107,
0.043817658,
-0.0239063371,
-0.0094688768,
0.0213171281,
0.0638084114,
-0.064208962,
-0.0890397951,
-0.0060089668,
-0.0218532067,
-0.0001279745,
0.0025749109,
-0.0457659587,
0.0095887603,
-0.0036729856,
0.0437002331,
-0.0288421866,
0.067162171,
0.0075213402,
-0.034494482,
-0.0179489106,
-0.0215868503,
0.0100693414,
-0.0312120281,
0.0018443577,
0.017226493,
-0.0258504245,
-0.0353804864,
-0.021814594,
0.0023861572,
0.0347124077,
-0.0217918735,
-0.0631706938,
-0.0541529134,
0.0262378547,
-0.0282220375,
0.0604379214,
0.0322688036,
0.0171936918,
0.0426042043,
-0.0765083507,
0.0606394224,
-0.0106094992,
0.0253874157,
-0.020179227,
0.0008666287,
-0.0534770302,
-0.0055980324,
-0.0415406674,
0.0236258898,
0.0050166105,
-0.0238065254,
-0.0215410478,
0.0152696148,
0.0290494729,
0.0052194232,
0.0035485579,
-0.0019361712,
-0.0232489239,
-0.027386643,
-0.0008672221,
0.0133487005,
-0.0701899827,
0.026540976,
-0.0077252183,
-0.0252894219,
-0.0221596006,
0.0416331664,
0.0206236634,
-0.0196076985,
0.0099434536,
0.0220421273,
-0.0097731352,
-0.0608059615,
-0.0267934725,
0.0026231504,
0.0264894739,
-0.0400945693,
0.0123420525,
-0.0635039732,
0.0279549211,
-0.0221692976,
0.0004190599,
-0.0307569932,
-0.0257959217,
0.0205052774,
-0.0266554784,
0.0562695637,
0.0011814104,
-0.0136067104,
0.005788066,
0.0130740274,
0.0329723321,
0.0540921241,
-0.0158171244,
0.023903789,
0.0289759468,
-0.0069343308,
-0.0125116138,
0.0099331941,
0.0646148995,
0.014783252,
0.0049972693,
-0.0106349867,
0.006164697,
0.0273655988,
0.0538749062,
0.0403176844,
-0.0870262384,
-0.0402551778,
0.0378680192,
0.0723461658,
0.0750182644,
0.0507944189,
0.0391489714,
0.0463093184,
-0.0139629235,
0.0179068577,
-0.0145595307,
0.0459790267,
-0.0570586845,
-0.0043309564,
0.0641554818,
0.0217546802,
-0.0562980212,
-0.0273074768,
0.030302925,
-0.0350374877,
-0.0179928821,
-0.0504459627,
0.0132906288,
0.0271870941,
-0.0222945269,
0.0432994999,
0.0097472118,
-0.0596276857,
-0.0331808776,
-0.0349196605,
0.0011718747,
0.0122746099,
0.0537575595,
0.0031798144,
0.0035486652,
-0.0014673524,
-0.0027763732,
-0.0029218514,
-0.0029530802,
0.0056752409,
-0.0022507268,
-0.0368066318,
-0.0346483923,
0.0077923001,
0.0126447519,
0.0031890792,
0.0297055077,
0.0537685901,
0.0423933677,
-0.0421610363,
0.0431306362,
0.0235034041,
-0.0379285589,
-0.0606159829,
0.0217711311,
0.0271775983,
0.0195207354,
-0.0129143456,
-0.0308532808,
-0.0019822265,
0.0038531965,
-0.0431509577,
-0.0359723344,
-0.0075785248,
-0.0206856169,
-0.0784112141,
0.0079878671,
-0.0460332483,
0.0689196512,
0.0112468461,
-0.0515776947,
-0.0210906062,
-0.0105696665,
-0.0023385552,
0.0454861075,
-0.0567890517,
-0.0065403469,
0.0001841508,
0.0119122099,
-0.0221450031,
0.0499829948,
0.0112655526,
0.0390825309,
-0.0036719323,
-0.015413153,
0.0528810099,
-0.0054018623,
-0.0145972632,
0.0064027947,
-0.0142034451,
0.00512625,
0.0443428755,
0.0245468225,
-0.0074375467,
0.0051656873,
-0.0696868226,
0.0016833182,
0.0007360688,
0.0303169414,
0.0422750302,
0.0129054766,
-0.0166574586,
-0.0282511003,
-0.045451466,
0.0227430221,
0.007587295,
0.0013523645,
0.0271677244,
-0.0210806187,
0.0215885658,
-0.0174911097,
-0.0362566784,
0.0207943749,
0.0942712575,
-0.0177884717,
-0.0029373274,
-0.0190943554,
0.0367136672,
-0.0125712389,
0.0019302863,
0.0130585274,
-0.0685406253,
0.0013227339,
-0.0309962779,
0.0350603983,
0.0669986457,
0.0155987181,
0.0113336155,
0.0350406952,
0.0286396574,
-0.0536426678,
-0.0070287324,
-0.0602769777,
-0.0116969384,
-0.0209877659,
0.0082903234,
0.0195172522,
0.0749851763,
-0.0295492839,
-0.0254688952,
-0.0978880897,
-0.0062506478,
0.0128921764,
-0.0097089959,
-0.0215812158,
0.0327365063,
0.0160839129,
0.0112394877,
0.0023499106,
-0.0222507343,
0.056032449,
-0.0285329744,
0.0340886414,
-0.0039570071,
-0.0108520258,
-0.0090513723,
0.0599692538,
0.0414587148,
0.0352834575,
0.0375848338,
0.0534118377,
-0.0568499677,
0.0513719469,
0.0289388318,
-0.0151826553,
-0.0335556716,
0.0167124216,
0.0045352229,
-0.0408516005,
-0.0414013378,
-0.0121398643,
-0.0474614315,
0.0156167112,
-0.0035078444,
0.0071657184,
-0.0060459245,
-0.0435015038,
-0.0078062592,
-0.0016444351,
0.0655859932,
0.0023683538,
-0.0353369303,
0.0038653722,
0.0549449399,
0.0077370768,
-0.0418219753,
0.0038770291,
0.0236243159,
0.0481026471,
0.0732484758,
0.0166213196,
0.0457471833,
-0.0033701062,
-0.0038642341,
0.0005685171,
-0.0364365727,
-0.0558030978,
0.0332659744,
0.040660385,
0.0013900964,
-0.0093924589,
0.1130540147,
0.0326022319,
-0.0665906668,
0.000599092,
0.0055994121,
0.0292580873,
-0.0022659355,
0.046338845,
-0.1044486314,
-0.0408494584,
-0.0080948649,
0.0118103819,
-0.0321244411,
-0.0232104268,
-0.0056704651,
-0.0926653147,
0.0008493871,
0.0065449248,
0.0345427319,
0.0018266053,
-0.0593525581,
0.0092585254,
-0.0043237498,
-0.055650156,
-0.0146099431,
-0.0103353932,
0.0261659157,
0.0155417863,
0.0049054716,
-0.0622703023,
0.0212165974,
-0.0087839542,
0.0099934628,
0.0365081243,
0.0256585889,
0.0319629051,
-0.048261404,
-0.0536394715,
-0.0129700247,
-0.0146256639,
0.0062627415,
0.0781042501,
-0.0077533163,
0.0175446253,
-0.0092230337,
0.0337124653,
0.0095865652,
-0.0226137191,
-0.0418595262,
0.0475562923,
-0.0057377592,
-0.0397397876,
-0.0113821169,
-0.0244833082,
-0.0289404113,
0.0657250807,
0.059288688,
-0.0177400969,
-0.0367435589,
-0.0070130201,
0.044897791,
-0.0182483587,
-0.0700097978,
-0.0116948085,
0.0149076581,
-0.0391233116,
-0.0791798905,
-0.0056474679,
-0.0054697399,
0.0549975708,
-0.0536843501,
-0.0490732081,
-0.0309623033,
-0.0181024671,
-0.05642768,
-0.052124083,
-0.0173510518,
-0.0108289104,
-0.0712264851,
0.0239018872,
0.0609028153,
-0.0068654828,
-0.0383946672,
-0.0205334332,
-0.0934213623,
-0.0283033121,
-0.0370387957,
0.0471888632,
0.0153955119,
0.0254791752,
-0.0184392743,
-0.0326234065,
0.1131127104,
0.1275143027,
-0.0415715799,
0.0187312756,
0.0506178737,
-0.0629213452,
0.0115022911,
0.0355305895,
-0.0076503819,
0.0559297502,
-0.0076557165,
-0.0113794049,
-0.0195626486,
-0.0244542025,
0.0270549618,
-0.0001614498,
0.0827661827,
-0.0139853191,
-0.0079891765,
0.0107494639,
-0.003046097,
0.0073899562,
0.0245864391,
-0.0369014069,
-0.0362992063,
0.047892686,
0.0202795472,
-0.01394198,
0.0602004044,
0.0150820427,
0.0378402807,
-0.0463642441,
-0.0161903687,
0.0005899076,
0.005307232,
-0.0187370386,
0.0156960506,
-0.0252082031,
-0.0519215874,
0.0347773246,
0.0093846498,
-0.0666894093,
0.0324542783,
0.0211558565,
0.0327598341,
0.0005157153,
0.0703138635,
-0.0539141037,
0.0029736592,
-0.0439835303,
0.01782736,
0.0223942567,
-0.0161622223,
0.0001735834,
-0.0336980112,
-0.0019759049,
-0.0031903468,
-0.0075204223,
-0.0161062926,
-0.006716961,
0.0111464793,
0.0060591409,
0.0089293597,
-0.0136783784,
0.121061638,
0.0164251179,
0.0361593589,
-0.0099811396,
-0.0017995322,
-0.020826919,
-0.0255036969,
-0.0097730001,
0.022914499,
0.0494410507,
-0.0174254514,
-0.0244295783,
-0.0413908474,
0.0070441724,
-0.0054911124,
-0.0091237668,
0.0143979257,
0.0587824173,
0.0224413145,
-0.0142189926,
-0.0045181257,
-0.0020592075,
-0.0323845297,
-0.0013689217,
-0.0069788396,
0.0130669279,
-6.690826417e-33,
-0.0233429931,
0.0083511285,
0.012980721,
-0.0188043136,
-0.0215707999,
-0.0176028125,
0.0018787453,
-0.0328209065,
-0.0174974147,
0.0152264852,
-0.0168138444,
0.0086893113,
-0.009185697,
0.0117843812,
-0.0279705022,
0.0209462177,
0.0559684746,
-0.0225579869,
-0.0313229039,
0.0397483148,
0.010432086,
0.0019953528,
0.0400576703,
0.0091467379,
-0.0538119897,
0.0130796563,
-0.008106689,
-0.0381433927,
0.046724733,
0.0481706858,
-0.0444690697,
0.0046087978,
0.0124105075,
-0.0798147619,
-0.015205171,
0.0131398607,
-0.0822935477,
-0.0853364244,
-0.0277780425,
-0.0215447247,
0.0131374151,
-0.0324249864,
0.0351937711,
-0.0201824866,
-0.0138654476,
-0.0623608045,
0.0158520415,
0.0059900209,
-0.006421478,
-0.0782469437,
-0.0240188688,
0.0246572345,
-0.0158033818,
-0.0118661448,
0.0602535158,
0.0505284704,
-0.0271642972,
0.0506784953,
-0.0444491655,
0.0264273565,
0.0065892152,
0.0511545874,
0.000299848,
-0.0367338546,
0.04222624,
0.0335546359,
-0.0147939278,
-0.0552324541,
-0.0597937405,
0.0238089375,
0.0334286392,
-0.0051953145,
0.0341257155,
0.0813145787,
0.0956925377,
-0.0214976352,
-0.0790797696,
0.0615642555,
-0.0152920447,
0.0320856534,
0.0065398868,
0.0230710637,
-0.0178100746,
-0.0235091895,
-0.0326353461,
-0.050385721,
-0.0050849421,
-0.0613390319,
-0.0003219961,
0.0261164326,
-0.0234840065,
0.0112691959,
0.0405175835,
-0.0424088724,
0.0066175396,
0.0267586689,
-0.0305051692,
0.0381483845,
0.0084580965,
0.0045195068,
-0.0597576685,
0.0014541252,
0.056000635,
-0.0018708195,
0.0230952054,
-0.0134198768,
0.0727794617,
0.0418341942,
-0.0850351751,
-0.0137399565,
0.0080867698,
-0.0461850911,
0.0241869763,
-0.0191102773,
0.0137861092,
0.027570961,
0.0040149558,
0.0331617557,
0.0056136791,
-0.0255352631,
-0.0059001632,
-0.0104878731,
0.0122434823,
0.0182725079,
-0.0145588284,
0.0006466752,
-0.0698264688,
0.0170255303,
0.0122223794,
-0.077319853,
-0.0359358564,
0.0208648257,
2.972e-7,
0.0091594728,
0.0321195051,
0.0187631156,
-0.0214565303,
0.0113188615,
0.0240040794,
0.0449639037,
0.0652317852,
-0.0368339606,
-0.0017285279,
0.0602174103,
0.0226990804,
0.0046783276,
0.0269408189,
-0.0814367682,
0.036616303,
-0.0896890759,
-0.0150034949,
-0.0417495072,
-0.0325914957,
0.0811316743,
0.0958183855,
0.0254732147,
0.0219569728,
0.0623099431,
-0.0073105935,
0.0830337852,
-0.0465862118,
0.0441906229,
-0.0004678746,
0.0305017717,
0.0108967647,
-0.0021812376,
-0.0008015308,
-0.0267771166,
-0.0158322696,
0.007838415,
0.0478989743,
-0.0019889628,
-0.0187339578,
0.0156186279,
-0.0272846855,
-0.0055866619,
-0.0378014743,
0.0983011499,
-0.0532618128,
-0.0116792982,
0.0290917195,
-0.0434254557,
-0.0194283277,
0.0193646718,
-0.0120637035,
-0.0098765492,
0.0193949621,
0.0278512035,
0.0383483022,
-0.0007951453,
-0.0742756277,
0.0051964857,
0.0117024006,
0.0017525768,
0.0026418571,
-0.0709665492,
-0.0341221727,
0.0377507433,
-0.0189362504,
0.0136734815,
2.574350307e-34,
0.0122716036,
0.0284008272,
0.02280345,
-0.0267346296,
-0.0220395923,
-0.0273742788,
0.0125981243,
-0.0033172974,
0.0346876346,
-0.0989074335,
-0.0020032888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.10822v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.10822v2 | A Novel Ehanced Move Recognition Algorithm Based on Pre-trained Models with Positional Embeddings | 2023-08-14T03:20:28 | 2023-12-15T09:30:43 | Hao Wen, Jie Wang, Xiaodong Qiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The recognition of abstracts is crucial for effectively locating the content
and clarifying the article. Existing move recognition algorithms lack the
ability to learn word position information to obtain contextual semantics. This
paper proposes a novel enhanced move recognition algorithm with an improved
pre-trained model and a gated network with attention mechanism for unstructured
abstracts of Chinese scientific and technological papers. The proposed
algorithm first performs summary data segmentation and vocabulary training. The
EP-ERNIE$\_$AT-GRU framework is leveraged to incorporate word positional
information, facilitating deep semantic learning and targeted feature
extraction. Experimental results demonstrate that the proposed algorithm
achieves 13.37$\%$ higher accuracy on the split dataset than on the original
dataset and a 7.55$\%$ improvement in accuracy over the basic comparison model. | [
0.0249203015,
0.0228398535,
0.0309436247,
0.0295849256,
0.0169707127,
0.0015843717,
0.0215582382,
-0.0124023361,
-0.0109862713,
-0.0382517688,
-0.0200854968,
-0.0124473842,
-0.009175471,
0.0569823757,
0.0016350239,
-0.0505095758,
0.0575346127,
0.0051090033,
0.0126153557,
0.0267544333,
0.0057854047,
-0.0472790897,
0.007234266,
-0.0002114837,
0.0501538627,
-0.0151314475,
-0.0443838015,
-0.0079260711,
0.0769917294,
-0.0514413528,
0.0138738276,
0.0397310555,
0.0607784241,
0.0505540036,
0.0000020154,
-0.040000733,
-0.0354735926,
0.0014476413,
0.0098983496,
-0.002410627,
0.0410294719,
-0.0531473234,
-0.0082248719,
-0.0219265763,
0.0004094117,
-0.0636729449,
0.0215440616,
0.084109202,
0.0391138531,
0.0908892453,
-0.0320934914,
-0.0493940078,
0.0630753785,
-0.0086410958,
-0.0023469462,
-0.0396448411,
0.0128712123,
0.0119819213,
0.0082616275,
0.0482717231,
-0.0440732799,
0.0335880816,
0.0153615167,
-0.0287238471,
0.0386745036,
0.0289348904,
-0.0395082869,
0.0494023934,
-0.0305761416,
0.0759911388,
-0.0821104124,
-0.0003699491,
0.0026480758,
-0.053677626,
-0.0152234333,
0.0121330628,
-0.0400037058,
0.0053719548,
0.034667138,
-0.0185762793,
0.0146283899,
0.0317169577,
0.0139074456,
0.0156005966,
-0.046140451,
0.0247391257,
-0.0078124828,
-0.0362069979,
-0.0008224373,
-0.0395700037,
0.036131274,
-0.0146636479,
0.0581148006,
0.0549998768,
0.0462420695,
0.0186693128,
-0.0290288255,
-0.0874351785,
-0.0088727996,
-0.0486929715,
-0.0692928284,
0.0089458823,
0.0208828002,
0.0547866859,
-0.01242192,
0.0061234585,
-0.0347618982,
0.0415288173,
-0.0394244008,
0.0065872306,
0.029691916,
-0.0364887603,
-0.0320772305,
0.077019684,
-0.0070111472,
-0.1014694497,
-0.0155876195,
-0.0033461775,
0.0257019028,
0.0241849665,
-0.019643832,
0.0201257728,
-0.0241317507,
-0.0428110287,
0.0441177376,
-0.0122693786,
-0.0416423976,
0.0160006508,
0.018761944,
0.0235394444,
-0.0195443928,
0.0391759053,
0.036018759,
-0.0039308611,
0.00363538,
0.0009275365,
-0.0001373146,
-0.0641476288,
0.013807741,
0.0216536745,
0.0149857895,
0.0042014495,
0.0436325073,
-0.0389627703,
0.0111903688,
-0.0048539639,
0.006637028,
-0.0052090879,
0.0096905548,
0.0224651992,
-0.0198116656,
0.0327838138,
-0.0034673852,
-0.0197242275,
0.0110948393,
0.0179702099,
0.0225280058,
0.0375140458,
0.0333930105,
0.0546460934,
0.0498908423,
-0.0009430028,
0.0056741992,
0.0224675797,
-0.0086807162,
-0.0474192537,
0.0762517005,
-0.0361579396,
-0.0227770917,
0.0365575701,
0.0296943299,
-0.0245636813,
-0.0385651849,
-0.0141271278,
0.004885802,
0.1053758711,
-0.0272100326,
0.03332996,
-0.0240471568,
0.0255930424,
-0.0203228854,
-0.0019773087,
0.0153915808,
-0.0074549429,
0.0160303526,
-0.0066411761,
0.0193597898,
-0.010415351,
-0.0277947374,
0.0020350532,
0.0280358493,
0.011332754,
0.0071584983,
-0.0374971367,
0.0470762439,
-0.0043843472,
-0.0377840102,
0.0333618037,
0.0025823275,
-0.0022960941,
-0.019927077,
0.0285803676,
0.0084149446,
0.0191469956,
0.0401259437,
-0.0591399111,
-0.0534658693,
-0.0087554408,
0.0180003587,
0.0728148073,
0.0346428826,
0.0111375041,
-0.0472788475,
-0.0779641867,
-0.0423068106,
-0.0219220649,
-0.0141122937,
-0.0009233694,
-0.0016125895,
0.0550514832,
0.0314700082,
-0.0206233636,
-0.0421281084,
0.0298608765,
-0.0035930767,
-0.0202033818,
-0.0398444273,
0.011045834,
0.0292468499,
0.0206210762,
-0.0071549406,
0.0108585935,
0.0344476178,
-0.0291397125,
0.0321002677,
0.0129569629,
-0.058142025,
-0.0090545742,
0.014084422,
-0.045612216,
-0.0074045584,
0.0359950215,
-0.0347948931,
-0.0520938411,
0.0091088172,
0.0403090678,
-0.0000773252,
-0.0366635285,
0.0284873992,
0.0242429432,
0.0420939326,
-0.0153584182,
0.0421656221,
-0.0288793854,
0.0446410328,
0.0338386409,
0.0013451139,
0.0066761328,
-0.0434534177,
-0.0432500616,
0.0188191701,
0.005336097,
-0.0097681582,
0.0293717608,
-0.0126257017,
-0.0247341674,
0.030275654,
-0.0698463395,
0.0260549597,
-0.0127241425,
0.0256867148,
0.0686978996,
0.009080952,
-0.0073484001,
-0.0147640537,
-0.0371064208,
0.0076881037,
-0.0274168663,
-0.0662362278,
0.0267063808,
-0.0084070526,
0.0238142572,
-0.0215148292,
-0.0007231694,
-0.0197119433,
0.0339342281,
0.0415672027,
-0.0571880452,
-0.0459054373,
0.0056749471,
0.059925165,
0.0349971652,
-0.0176705997,
-0.0132296709,
-0.0165905431,
-0.0318501107,
-0.055247847,
0.0674194843,
0.0281649698,
0.0623178668,
0.0094819786,
-0.0002906726,
-0.0227475408,
0.0104525983,
-0.0309616942,
0.0974571034,
-0.0111786136,
0.015316993,
0.0420173369,
0.0293706935,
-0.0236046221,
0.0267122444,
-0.0078754816,
-0.0559021235,
-0.0020207025,
-0.0091403518,
-0.0304160882,
0.0387732908,
-0.0258998442,
-0.0128756408,
-0.0233962778,
0.0083272634,
0.0035529733,
-0.0112387286,
-0.008069478,
-0.0834296122,
0.0111307232,
-0.0340825729,
0.0322120376,
-0.0032561272,
0.0394381136,
-0.0336536095,
-0.0499121174,
-0.007227405,
0.0034353735,
-0.0268536787,
-0.0141000226,
-0.0425346345,
-0.0056805117,
0.0479516052,
-0.0244046226,
0.019028442,
-0.0006198156,
-0.0287438501,
0.0212703999,
0.0343893655,
0.0306694806,
-0.0470342115,
-0.0215802845,
0.0563036613,
0.0013958038,
0.0840225518,
-0.0123097794,
0.0237256307,
-0.0394076742,
0.0585067272,
0.0808580592,
0.0183764976,
-0.0033118965,
-0.0199642126,
0.0487036929,
0.0752234012,
-0.0153195979,
-0.0328307375,
-0.0531944335,
-0.0247366149,
0.0237806085,
-0.0890111402,
0.0198447555,
-0.0428678319,
0.0185344703,
-0.0677052289,
-0.0164051894,
0.0752632692,
0.0187292676,
-0.0343635976,
-0.0333337039,
0.0139047103,
0.0028985748,
-0.0267964788,
-0.0049297218,
-0.0648295209,
-0.00706125,
-0.0049543311,
-0.0180251617,
0.0488893576,
-0.02495832,
0.0120604038,
-0.0702033788,
0.0606792234,
0.0079143196,
-0.084178105,
-0.0845740363,
-0.0146240909,
0.0220848881,
0.0343078636,
-0.005618745,
-0.0090784738,
0.0020127632,
-0.0629697144,
-0.0031031922,
-0.0703617632,
-0.0332327485,
-0.0212819129,
-0.0110142529,
-0.0373350494,
0.0349889584,
0.0364750363,
-0.0393263362,
0.0092163831,
0.0577605516,
-0.0364831463,
-0.0390600488,
0.0107463971,
0.0467151962,
-0.0799745396,
-0.0011635899,
0.0191648882,
0.0546560138,
-0.0204574112,
-0.0375812761,
-0.0108486442,
0.0427975133,
-0.0449350812,
-0.0133611839,
-0.0707623735,
-0.0290285349,
-0.0140624866,
0.0262583159,
-0.0065734908,
-0.0354467034,
-0.0543934368,
-0.0100014554,
0.0298721138,
-0.0026399875,
0.003677886,
-0.0211608838,
-0.0260068327,
-0.0107178725,
-0.0784635916,
-0.0697136149,
0.0220284294,
0.0241809655,
0.0161527544,
0.0242579505,
0.0466075279,
-0.0426663198,
-0.0801997781,
-0.0111298161,
-0.0035161329,
-0.0036815428,
-0.013755098,
-0.0168062579,
0.0511135794,
0.0084692184,
-0.0316788368,
-0.0093184719,
0.0231942274,
-0.0292686876,
0.0015579382,
-0.0100056464,
0.0039958758,
0.039339453,
-0.0644164309,
0.0069912374,
0.0812088475,
-0.036081627,
0.0353423804,
-0.0510714538,
0.0482481793,
-0.035395503,
-0.0417863466,
-0.0268332679,
0.0007858481,
0.0311726406,
-0.0007020307,
0.0226193462,
-0.043285422,
-0.0006330751,
-0.0127075966,
-0.0353467278,
0.0532593727,
0.0340603478,
0.0045830319,
-0.0674951226,
0.044728864,
-0.0060452358,
0.0139647042,
-0.0267332066,
0.0016520041,
0.0528503545,
-0.0254172347,
0.0078078839,
0.0843001604,
0.033056967,
-0.0737789273,
0.0024130782,
0.0322935767,
-0.0434313975,
0.0464051999,
-0.0269150361,
0.0079236822,
-0.0295860805,
-0.0078095216,
-0.0227792691,
0.0510161854,
0.0200247355,
0.0272665564,
0.0663498417,
-0.0228585675,
-0.0042289575,
0.0337290131,
-0.1022445932,
-0.0219625682,
-0.0896481276,
0.017564917,
0.0555252843,
-0.0635228455,
0.0225910842,
-0.0226745978,
-0.0318874903,
-0.0005700587,
-0.0066459123,
0.0141677624,
-0.0020175986,
0.0051091323,
0.0226505529,
0.0247870926,
0.0190674961,
0.0370618403,
-0.0139962705,
0.0173815843,
0.0349988453,
-0.0434587151,
-0.0335110314,
0.0045912694,
0.0582557693,
0.0293721594,
-0.0175399408,
0.0246658158,
0.0119608752,
-0.0036530816,
0.0050887321,
0.0142968958,
-0.0197611284,
0.0172600709,
0.0600914247,
0.0440359227,
-0.0158852544,
0.0067632273,
-0.041780889,
0.0164688211,
-0.030691551,
-0.0154403709,
-0.0198280718,
-6.275603609e-33,
-0.0050074654,
-0.0187422521,
-0.0091491202,
0.0217346139,
-0.0264202524,
-0.0080766408,
-0.073925741,
-0.0343455225,
-0.0253385846,
0.0301424842,
-0.0082629332,
0.015169031,
0.0222103726,
0.0304293744,
-0.0319828726,
0.0083979554,
0.0094223414,
-0.0127266319,
-0.0222595036,
0.0032598262,
0.0581073686,
0.0573540702,
0.0665994212,
-0.032407999,
0.0089174025,
-0.0316764191,
0.0261136405,
-0.0245120954,
0.035249792,
0.0126932831,
-0.0283266995,
-0.0417997055,
0.0305495486,
-0.0264072362,
-0.0139763644,
0.0467248522,
-0.0853505805,
-0.0409210697,
-0.0400114842,
0.0359220132,
-0.0293796193,
-0.0134876529,
0.0384051502,
-0.0105403475,
0.0198154822,
0.0017122063,
0.0560099185,
-0.0325719714,
-0.0184866842,
-0.0836342201,
-0.0553480275,
0.0308957621,
-0.0290119238,
0.0422979817,
0.046447143,
-0.0162557904,
-0.0045979423,
0.0186349843,
-0.0486296602,
-0.007349608,
0.0430443957,
0.0446916334,
0.0302308891,
0.0203827079,
0.0187419821,
0.0615456924,
-0.0174549371,
-0.0474750623,
0.0476099402,
0.0395159684,
0.0598929711,
0.0065943636,
0.0056263595,
-0.035587512,
0.0492871925,
0.0254982635,
-0.0584793538,
0.0473131947,
-0.0341415629,
0.0748985708,
0.0406296551,
0.0174966529,
-0.0163861196,
0.0130166467,
0.0246106088,
-0.0007865587,
0.0151616437,
-0.0539006367,
0.0418489762,
0.0168924108,
-0.0484004468,
0.0200681798,
0.0431888103,
-0.0457373559,
-0.0221364237,
0.0138555299,
0.0278045665,
0.0420351513,
0.0043353597,
-0.0072251549,
-0.0524273962,
-0.0622853339,
0.0054682246,
-0.0110009564,
-0.0151044074,
-0.0025153209,
0.0321755596,
-0.0004289561,
-0.0161843561,
-0.0103285229,
0.0339782648,
-0.0610351861,
-0.0415933356,
0.0394497588,
-0.0035919743,
-0.0320720933,
-0.0010476217,
0.0836752877,
0.0078466367,
0.051160641,
-0.0070126178,
0.0133314831,
-0.0031738891,
0.0459520295,
-0.0256687645,
-0.002831616,
0.0060695312,
0.074585259,
0.0236540996,
-0.0501280613,
0.0112744467,
0.0133702513,
2.766e-7,
0.0776060596,
0.0149823977,
0.053440325,
-0.0115312934,
-0.0033305541,
-0.032552287,
-0.0086019719,
0.0410060808,
-0.0057233782,
0.0012796602,
0.0830166712,
0.0291452277,
0.0007950413,
-0.0449056663,
-0.0863024443,
0.0148163885,
-0.0233529266,
-0.0246351492,
-0.0363196842,
-0.0094258357,
0.0230608452,
0.0710610449,
-0.0599296242,
0.0345655233,
0.0024688768,
-0.0053614504,
0.0299951136,
-0.0301323142,
0.0296215843,
0.020605376,
0.0270674247,
0.0436789691,
-0.0769582838,
-0.0289710425,
-0.0145790838,
0.0589576215,
0.0704501048,
0.0221272372,
-0.0292665176,
-0.0125790965,
-0.0206061937,
-0.0358037651,
0.0410450883,
-0.0381358787,
0.0420581996,
-0.0610274002,
-0.0140919993,
-0.0621224605,
-0.0829629973,
0.0095013892,
-0.0000568825,
-0.0060395137,
0.0025633527,
0.0049928119,
0.0063699861,
-0.0404620431,
-0.001050734,
-0.098660253,
0.0068661976,
0.0252690986,
0.0142738298,
-0.0092691164,
-0.0121372575,
-0.0793982968,
0.0102622965,
-0.032728117,
-0.0163586102,
2.322494902e-34,
0.0695290864,
0.002316097,
-0.019672364,
0.0426223576,
0.0082706697,
-0.0200865027,
0.0142711205,
0.0021847887,
0.0110748187,
-0.0407340005,
-0.0184672605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07937v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07937v1 | Automated Testing and Improvement of Named Entity Recognition Systems | 2023-08-14T03:17:24 | 2023-08-14T03:17:24 | Boxi Yu, Yiyan Hu, Qiuyang Mang, Wenhan Hu, Pinjia He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE, D.2.5; I.2.7 | Named entity recognition (NER) systems have seen rapid progress in recent
years due to the development of deep neural networks. These systems are widely
used in various natural language processing applications, such as information
extraction, question answering, and sentiment analysis. However, the complexity
and intractability of deep neural networks can make NER systems unreliable in
certain circumstances, resulting in incorrect predictions. For example, NER
systems may misidentify female names as chemicals or fail to recognize the
names of minority groups, leading to user dissatisfaction. To tackle this
problem, we introduce TIN, a novel, widely applicable approach for
automatically testing and repairing various NER systems. The key idea for
automated testing is that the NER predictions of the same named entities under
similar contexts should be identical. The core idea for automated repairing is
that similar named entities should have the same NER prediction under the same
context. We use TIN to test two SOTA NER models and two commercial NER APIs,
i.e., Azure NER and AWS NER. We manually verify 784 of the suspicious issues
reported by TIN and find that 702 are erroneous issues, leading to high
precision (85.0%-93.4%) across four categories of NER errors: omission,
over-labeling, incorrect category, and range error. For automated repairing,
TIN achieves a high error reduction rate (26.8%-50.6%) over the four systems
under test, which successfully repairs 1,056 out of the 1,877 reported NER
errors. | [
0.0483906716,
0.0760338306,
-0.0057849977,
0.0137989493,
0.0214649197,
0.0522192679,
0.0104026254,
-0.0009256158,
-0.0028475064,
-0.0225650724,
0.0051021506,
-0.0367512405,
0.0287778582,
0.031809371,
0.0118850861,
-0.0172127243,
0.0362468697,
0.0217429474,
0.0337150246,
-0.0017519593,
-0.0132585457,
0.0088467197,
-0.022849204,
0.0206797738,
-0.0138927419,
0.0003860855,
-0.0198331829,
0.0158082694,
0.0310912188,
-0.0344763137,
0.0498081595,
0.0593810417,
-0.0450586788,
0.0628475621,
0.0000018604,
-0.060185574,
-0.0312690139,
0.0127996802,
-0.0418934859,
-0.0285924654,
0.0228018444,
-0.0169407856,
-0.0252579153,
0.0199425835,
-0.0100841615,
-0.0376106203,
0.0436762311,
0.0494967662,
0.0493968278,
0.0592826009,
-0.0009673675,
0.0093002291,
0.045897346,
0.0112557271,
0.0018949915,
-0.0332966112,
0.0463867076,
-0.037867818,
-0.0311187413,
-0.0195873808,
0.0172008034,
0.0121751744,
0.0050369962,
0.0109302914,
-0.0249682125,
0.0274318494,
-0.0434703007,
-0.0195796564,
0.0079302201,
0.0556396283,
-0.0239511747,
0.0238501076,
0.0360667109,
0.0031815153,
-0.0242918786,
-0.0284230877,
0.0171660054,
0.0000869205,
-0.0366481319,
-0.0165634565,
-0.0051934603,
-0.0367585421,
0.0203437079,
0.0148299709,
-0.0131261945,
0.0357751101,
0.0126784006,
-0.0541250557,
0.0096616475,
0.0308780614,
0.018605683,
-0.0548420101,
0.0450780354,
0.0088452995,
-0.0312914625,
0.0212973207,
-0.0538783036,
-0.0426269881,
0.0365072079,
-0.0428768098,
0.0117163621,
0.002073027,
-0.029536197,
0.0330781005,
-0.0442715362,
0.0387863405,
0.0433653556,
0.0226674564,
0.0539837368,
-0.0388110578,
-0.0520910658,
-0.0100581991,
-0.0095711146,
0.0368962772,
-0.0061111003,
-0.000634301,
-0.042873539,
0.0069516115,
-0.0512657501,
0.059783306,
-0.0040139714,
0.0426687971,
-0.0067779515,
0.0047216569,
-0.0709638298,
0.0025782958,
-0.0036002351,
-0.0053382828,
-0.0168817993,
-0.0646299943,
0.0074748904,
-0.0296567343,
0.0191299878,
-0.0204861518,
0.047075551,
0.0631643981,
0.0265893638,
-0.0607679747,
-0.0728540942,
-0.0201668609,
0.0046319794,
-0.0246414058,
-0.0192861464,
-0.0292777773,
0.0283811204,
-0.0215103347,
-0.0063989772,
-0.084758617,
0.0162822083,
0.015604551,
-0.0529734083,
0.1030523703,
-0.0468100011,
-0.0143160615,
0.0479129888,
-0.0004763153,
0.0385313593,
0.0164126586,
0.0485471152,
-0.0048318212,
0.061941307,
0.0135976877,
0.0360875838,
0.0066150744,
0.0092398738,
-0.0198061969,
0.0189986359,
-0.0060488614,
-0.0671499819,
0.0366439857,
0.0344313756,
0.0674880594,
0.0268967208,
-0.0462365597,
0.0234540161,
0.0482920706,
0.0198330376,
0.0351627544,
0.0214213263,
-0.0191916917,
0.0148628578,
-0.0382236205,
-0.0949966088,
0.0020422607,
-0.0407488197,
0.0032524939,
0.0193684641,
0.0513784476,
-0.0180647038,
-0.0259521585,
-0.0205620732,
-0.0120724272,
-0.0170480199,
0.0013738031,
0.0581683032,
0.0060757017,
-0.0643504336,
0.0687524229,
0.0129418327,
-0.0291547664,
0.013070845,
-0.032779295,
0.0184617732,
0.1054530814,
0.0360447578,
-0.0533010066,
-0.0614025295,
-0.024965981,
-0.0734939277,
0.0554315448,
0.0326123461,
-0.0276029687,
0.0121513009,
-0.0344888568,
0.0079597412,
0.0419673026,
0.0209557358,
0.0310262442,
0.0521765202,
0.065972425,
0.0377072617,
-0.0240704995,
-0.0457712747,
0.0441489592,
-0.0339212157,
-0.0421336181,
0.0226706918,
0.0425957106,
0.022621857,
0.070713982,
-0.0167370364,
-0.0370848663,
-0.0015384243,
0.0138072688,
-0.0619476847,
-0.0297192987,
-0.004663357,
-0.022483604,
0.0122500686,
-0.028165197,
-0.049336642,
0.0556094907,
-0.0621623285,
-0.0547115728,
-0.0185771659,
0.0038764153,
-0.0402515531,
-0.0346133821,
0.0034661272,
0.0218006801,
0.0359601229,
-0.0064682602,
0.0432859659,
-0.0263069198,
0.0261417888,
-0.0047999038,
0.0181290358,
0.0048646666,
-0.0586495474,
-0.059176717,
-0.0034138453,
-0.0345480554,
0.0051796148,
-0.0107074417,
-0.0018539332,
-0.0709412619,
0.000935353,
-0.0709399283,
0.0148335025,
-0.0252662767,
0.0592115037,
0.0131037673,
0.0339678749,
-0.0321421474,
-0.0058419798,
0.0009289898,
-0.0062765693,
0.011221786,
0.0210606549,
0.0572223775,
-0.0178167447,
-0.0261247903,
-0.0213762615,
0.001456128,
-0.0657417998,
0.035548497,
0.0162289813,
-0.0494354889,
-0.0736465007,
0.0249649175,
-0.0441840999,
0.0246161595,
0.0237523504,
0.0031888417,
-0.0134220095,
0.0282986518,
-0.0269777253,
0.04927852,
-0.0054726326,
0.009439487,
-0.0258670822,
0.0177355353,
-0.0327360258,
0.0291998964,
0.0093005877,
0.027658144,
0.0363363028,
-0.0559313335,
-0.008242636,
0.0411994494,
-0.0331473388,
0.0123858303,
-0.0303090997,
0.0367648639,
-0.0264477096,
0.0016334616,
-0.0202711336,
0.0153721608,
0.0073147952,
-0.0102461334,
-0.0278428327,
0.0122956242,
0.0834600255,
-0.0238949805,
-0.012097463,
-0.0277594905,
-0.0111973397,
-0.0312734358,
0.0439094417,
0.0160340033,
-0.0058307918,
0.0502031893,
-0.0941208676,
0.0172150359,
0.0061305049,
-0.0219243839,
-0.0397585072,
0.0499900281,
-0.0175974332,
0.0308398455,
-0.0075836987,
-0.0346158557,
-0.0458611324,
-0.0141617954,
-0.0419358648,
0.0159581769,
-0.0050001452,
-0.0164930336,
-0.0161892343,
0.0204165708,
-0.019582158,
0.0461617373,
0.0186816286,
-0.027487319,
-0.0251456946,
0.0260221269,
0.0069307308,
0.014139872,
0.0474232808,
-0.0128069501,
-0.0293654483,
0.0317546763,
-0.0182781182,
0.0182744656,
-0.0548799932,
-0.0144815994,
-0.0011343018,
-0.0671961382,
0.0164993517,
-0.0250642393,
-0.0084364023,
-0.0558059514,
-0.00724279,
0.103518717,
0.0059644007,
-0.028781129,
-0.010647892,
0.0043984228,
-0.0181877892,
0.0114526674,
0.0296864007,
-0.102444984,
-0.0374436341,
0.0447477587,
0.0314765349,
-0.0097534051,
-0.0847729072,
0.003359607,
-0.1195056885,
0.0061561866,
-0.0512914062,
-0.0620022044,
-0.0168615747,
-0.0547851324,
0.0151838399,
-0.0349232368,
0.0630826876,
-0.0026037607,
0.0043041259,
-0.0053106379,
0.009646168,
-0.0347433724,
-0.087359786,
0.0360841677,
-0.0599736869,
0.0766738951,
0.0612382293,
0.0148150427,
-0.0188580491,
0.0127405031,
0.0368391052,
-0.0218218938,
0.0055233338,
-0.0137807177,
0.0781934708,
-0.0211019516,
-0.022052886,
-0.0135669932,
0.0243474152,
-0.060650561,
0.0071983445,
-0.0193783604,
0.0126474798,
-0.0015811193,
-0.0114386044,
-0.0146078104,
-0.0198610239,
0.0503996536,
0.062240988,
0.0016231436,
-0.0075001288,
-0.0426547006,
-0.0042309226,
-0.0186470542,
-0.0478805229,
-0.0023935689,
0.0231011529,
-0.0298427716,
-0.035283424,
-0.0398930013,
-0.0780806988,
0.0293134749,
0.0149780689,
-0.0053443238,
-0.0523729399,
0.0324059017,
0.0480989479,
-0.0508092195,
0.0325371213,
-0.0078462027,
0.0327424929,
-0.0456793122,
0.0201290771,
0.023254497,
0.0268548541,
-0.0465178043,
-0.0061633801,
-0.0478449985,
-0.0471589826,
0.0326405764,
0.0296261236,
0.0151198832,
0.0259188283,
-0.0285380054,
-0.0531969182,
0.0470495559,
0.0817034096,
-0.0135924742,
-0.0168982949,
0.0124897044,
0.0132973874,
-0.0216443427,
0.0165262818,
-0.0436977819,
0.0201295801,
-0.0209499821,
0.010106572,
-0.0008443407,
-0.0198401585,
-0.0062911757,
0.0271592531,
0.0391213633,
0.0220362376,
-0.0336211883,
-0.035156589,
0.0390951261,
0.041032657,
-0.0059568579,
0.0117530795,
-0.0013981537,
-0.0063539241,
-0.0093218433,
-0.0161206033,
0.0390371867,
-0.0143715311,
0.0041923332,
-0.0254112612,
-0.0091322921,
0.0393958949,
0.0815657303,
0.0073789959,
-0.0486151166,
0.0030447459,
0.0223316625,
0.0534884259,
0.0758515894,
-0.0374381654,
-0.0001317326,
0.0021150624,
0.0289316047,
-0.0449846722,
0.0131986439,
-0.0317502171,
-0.0135096814,
-0.0316018835,
0.04905314,
0.0507827699,
0.0322627686,
0.0226974934,
-0.0220115427,
-0.0020387636,
-0.0021659536,
-0.0406096801,
-0.0048163412,
0.0246488731,
0.0051894444,
0.0127734113,
0.0197118577,
-0.0034814698,
0.0414990671,
0.0034437266,
0.0515320972,
-0.0111917071,
-0.0479759611,
-0.0410977267,
0.0078000561,
-0.0070205103,
-0.0229324289,
-0.0446828902,
-0.0407605618,
0.0032413499,
-0.0744393766,
0.0530855581,
-0.0001163875,
0.0295420084,
0.0365283974,
0.0104174819,
0.0448425785,
0.0319093503,
0.0106347324,
-0.0096060922,
-0.0077147218,
-0.0022495741,
-0.0501341075,
-0.0122388331,
-6.464001558e-33,
-0.0199369024,
-0.0362538137,
0.0221861936,
-0.0397740193,
-0.016419353,
0.019030055,
-0.0297013074,
-0.0049562557,
0.0229964089,
0.0112640113,
-0.0178577118,
0.0210452247,
0.0371329412,
0.0216069166,
0.0182609167,
-0.0452415422,
0.0675747246,
0.0419875458,
-0.0232131071,
-0.0120401541,
0.0537210219,
0.0824658573,
0.055236496,
-0.0963194817,
0.0507592,
0.0416556709,
-0.0069050733,
0.0139644248,
0.0360492207,
0.0590587109,
-0.0036450326,
0.0273300782,
0.0279319752,
-0.0396658704,
0.0079165585,
0.0150774596,
-0.1677784026,
-0.0307131391,
-0.056439124,
0.0501236655,
-0.009799608,
-0.0013304403,
0.0841794312,
-0.0089920973,
0.0031682332,
0.0300065055,
0.0435471386,
-0.0094037969,
0.0282054394,
-0.0416397564,
-0.034880206,
0.0443006195,
0.0025627625,
0.0323595479,
0.0084753828,
0.0182023142,
0.0339062475,
-0.0001830732,
-0.1179570779,
-0.0243529137,
0.0184778012,
-0.0092058219,
0.0305720828,
0.0171618275,
-0.0506061576,
0.044669643,
0.0495175458,
0.0081793778,
-0.0424101055,
-0.0352269486,
0.0413280576,
-0.005848452,
0.0277099982,
0.0451630689,
0.0532026961,
-0.0512256697,
-0.0445299186,
0.0450267643,
0.0021076247,
0.0193110257,
-0.0074406858,
-0.0351387225,
-0.0868889019,
0.0036297839,
-0.0081793955,
-0.0401077121,
-0.0775099397,
-0.0224257205,
0.0199511983,
0.025764484,
-0.0552871935,
0.0506014377,
-0.0241760127,
-0.0405399352,
-0.034833163,
0.0005869911,
0.0351315625,
-0.0129776783,
-0.0161393974,
-0.0057679536,
-0.0173406098,
-0.0485003442,
-0.0440253578,
0.0109021906,
0.0396904014,
-0.008006501,
0.0466497429,
0.0240624268,
-0.0725721121,
0.0187387597,
0.0195412915,
0.0453792587,
-0.017578762,
0.0267147776,
-0.0099750347,
0.0080407085,
0.005664784,
0.0048669782,
0.0838837102,
0.025660295,
-0.0313794427,
0.0211577024,
0.0396324247,
0.0101577062,
-0.0200760644,
-0.0223815888,
-0.0057955673,
-0.0107593173,
-0.0109034646,
-0.0639885515,
0.0140553927,
-0.0117121208,
2.693e-7,
0.009890411,
0.0469707437,
0.0139564946,
-0.003916,
0.0017104147,
0.0261364952,
0.0388404466,
0.0547313429,
-0.0158362892,
0.0027275374,
0.0066586225,
-0.0267688446,
0.0072995168,
0.0602604002,
-0.0799148679,
-0.0504185669,
-0.022698598,
0.0069766999,
-0.0467250012,
0.0367281362,
0.00599994,
0.0665672496,
0.0270282254,
-0.0622276701,
-0.0199681409,
-0.0336271562,
0.0061548436,
0.0237457007,
0.0301498454,
0.0392379537,
0.0281553399,
0.0625592843,
0.0119378082,
0.0491897278,
-0.0187870823,
0.0069574555,
-0.0168617815,
0.0240753274,
-0.0223862082,
-0.0119277146,
-0.0199684165,
-0.0397246927,
0.0378968641,
-0.0213513914,
0.0638491139,
-0.0109394975,
0.0214241147,
-0.0222629625,
-0.0209969487,
-0.0329764225,
0.0496311188,
-0.0068615628,
-0.0212391429,
0.0426162109,
0.0139228515,
-0.0123065151,
-0.0014306462,
-0.0976742432,
0.0517112277,
0.0189204961,
0.0000162867,
-0.0069462154,
0.0303009879,
-0.021502886,
0.0173828602,
-0.0702490881,
0.0063683651,
2.430011998e-34,
-0.0022969656,
0.0387380645,
-0.0047153868,
-0.0041598226,
0.0125515182,
0.0117955739,
-0.0045849299,
-0.002240523,
-0.0179139711,
-0.0080445297,
-0.0192151461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06912v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06912v3 | CausalLM is not optimal for in-context learning | 2023-08-14T03:14:38 | 2024-02-20T22:48:06 | Nan Ding, Tomer Levinboim, Jialin Wu, Sebastian Goodman, Radu Soricut | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Recent empirical evidence indicates that transformer based in-context
learning performs better when using a prefix language model (prefixLM), in
which in-context samples can all attend to each other, compared to causal
language models (causalLM), which use auto-regressive attention that prohibits
in-context samples to attend to future samples. While this result is intuitive,
it is not understood from a theoretical perspective. In this paper we take a
theoretical approach and analyze the convergence behavior of prefixLM and
causalLM under a certain parameter construction. Our analysis shows that both
LM types converge to their stationary points at a linear rate, but that while
prefixLM converges to the optimal solution of linear regression, causalLM
convergence dynamics follows that of an online gradient descent algorithm,
which is not guaranteed to be optimal even as the number of samples grows
infinitely. We supplement our theoretical claims with empirical experiments
over synthetic and real tasks and using various types of transformers. Our
experiments verify that causalLM consistently underperforms prefixLM in all
settings. | [
-0.0197167844,
0.0386269018,
-0.0218113512,
0.0053782254,
-0.0097938236,
0.0127157792,
0.0205412991,
0.0018365463,
-0.0276995916,
-0.0141718602,
-0.0030883229,
-0.0303476397,
0.0157039016,
-0.0268811621,
0.0313032232,
-0.0453640372,
0.0413185842,
-0.0542167313,
-0.0492250994,
-0.0244103763,
-0.0310927406,
-0.0363048092,
-0.0103706131,
0.0561060533,
-0.0104230959,
0.0006476377,
0.009566796,
-0.0188921168,
-0.0022743992,
0.0029642181,
0.0061608627,
0.0186982211,
0.0168040302,
0.0082523394,
0.0000019875,
-0.0513748154,
0.0085651986,
-0.0169536453,
-0.0167551003,
-0.078685075,
-0.0334766544,
-0.0126884617,
0.0047236606,
0.0513268784,
-0.0248947907,
-0.0094176866,
0.0401734449,
0.0326522626,
0.0264892317,
0.0781530887,
-0.012896576,
-0.0210383683,
0.0346239768,
-0.0228887666,
0.0093254922,
-0.0130011961,
0.0194848683,
-0.0223897006,
-0.024262134,
-0.0188491289,
-0.0507123359,
0.0631005764,
0.0406257585,
0.0279508736,
0.0273884647,
0.0525670275,
0.0302897412,
-0.0160198249,
-0.0198571868,
0.0431956314,
-0.0527424775,
-0.0400533415,
0.0138755627,
0.0091731129,
-0.0046989066,
-0.0041194963,
-0.0545319505,
0.0633200631,
-0.0200916436,
0.0209877118,
0.0028113057,
0.006127601,
0.025094036,
-0.0192760304,
-0.0478707999,
0.0932234824,
-0.0128484135,
-0.05953582,
-0.0111743631,
0.0251312926,
0.0013088775,
-0.0339632742,
-0.0088753216,
0.0445512645,
-0.0638612062,
0.0359705985,
-0.0302778687,
-0.0608220622,
-0.0306967553,
-0.0155322989,
0.056783285,
0.0451777019,
0.0094960043,
0.0326822139,
-0.0198341124,
0.0788469166,
-0.000103992,
0.0122812241,
-0.0137921665,
-0.0000941075,
-0.0291030202,
0.0006888502,
-0.060845539,
0.0197644942,
-0.0316590741,
0.0060055456,
-0.0338593535,
0.0758194029,
-0.0033580074,
-0.0224824063,
0.0179307368,
-0.0365123525,
-0.0657733157,
0.005149777,
-0.0023804773,
0.0219035577,
0.0094997426,
0.017312523,
-0.0147998054,
-0.0513423644,
-0.0074409405,
0.0110285841,
-0.0039975634,
-0.0151606984,
-0.0321354941,
0.1130340546,
-0.0048122876,
-0.0502734743,
-0.0262540765,
-0.0018827114,
0.0169880111,
-0.0425640419,
0.0113623561,
-0.060581971,
-0.0086509641,
0.0444014072,
0.0114969891,
-0.027533412,
-0.0102120284,
0.0142868599,
-0.0128877154,
0.0374468863,
0.0319872685,
0.0371760316,
0.0136487111,
-0.0228603743,
-0.0051257433,
0.074796997,
-0.0110039869,
-0.0029369621,
-0.0192480236,
-0.0026474004,
0.0142653165,
0.0519916303,
0.0361011177,
0.0269979611,
-0.0545557402,
-0.037124265,
0.0294054337,
0.0190515053,
0.0014310208,
0.0484477766,
-0.0320234001,
0.0293432605,
0.0893623754,
0.0566329695,
0.0543213822,
0.0128299333,
0.0259377658,
0.0085237799,
-0.0392296389,
-0.0034463045,
-0.0750574246,
0.011854941,
-0.0181157887,
0.012968489,
-0.0283829179,
-0.0073764878,
-0.0328348242,
-0.0514559634,
-0.0076998258,
-0.0188818239,
-0.0331165828,
0.0176814459,
0.0811820552,
0.032354299,
-0.0731402263,
0.0377263315,
0.0155382585,
-0.0203550681,
0.0069713416,
-0.0518411659,
0.0026482488,
0.0138679333,
0.0178695247,
-0.0225084126,
-0.0415920243,
-0.0449298285,
0.0239300374,
0.0154275214,
-0.0461244732,
0.0086259795,
0.0036109099,
-0.0057860212,
-0.0297637191,
0.0497353375,
-0.0165362135,
-0.0049359757,
0.0172440559,
0.0151090138,
-0.0187385399,
-0.0024772852,
-0.0044939844,
0.0554739833,
-0.076324746,
-0.0197799448,
-0.015345444,
0.0198984891,
0.0336318538,
-0.026569359,
0.0092859715,
-0.0120886462,
0.0205321182,
-0.0297619607,
-0.0303167403,
0.0429038182,
-0.0726866126,
-0.0327289104,
0.014154247,
-0.0534805581,
-0.0075242738,
0.0490598902,
0.0093669044,
-0.0383116975,
0.0134203956,
-0.0486770682,
0.0775573552,
-0.0039872085,
0.0370288529,
-0.0210188311,
0.0105702002,
-0.0532812662,
0.0281234365,
-0.0366344862,
0.0263595134,
0.0314676091,
0.015138912,
-0.0368501917,
-0.0300678052,
-0.0236388054,
-0.0263072364,
-0.0239716414,
-0.0044136168,
0.0133335991,
-0.0288896281,
-0.0123312455,
0.0008563402,
-0.0532425866,
-0.029673567,
-0.0655328482,
-0.0039398968,
0.0031318665,
0.0142129231,
0.0005733433,
-0.0298551098,
-0.0018144477,
0.0095552048,
0.0048026922,
0.0369039103,
0.0132233435,
-0.0106856534,
0.0039028127,
-0.0105709545,
-0.033204291,
-0.0030119286,
0.0406143852,
0.0016840675,
-0.0349689387,
-0.0863697082,
-0.0253966749,
0.0398668572,
0.034731973,
-0.0321978927,
0.0054952973,
-0.0055954647,
-0.0298481174,
0.0808043256,
0.084658511,
0.0204064772,
0.0377581306,
0.0350641981,
0.0229986627,
-0.0601131879,
0.0126137761,
-0.0354319476,
-0.0163053833,
-0.0487272218,
0.0087493854,
0.0392110832,
0.1130646765,
-0.0175155122,
0.0067764488,
-0.0392428152,
0.0027215411,
-0.0311554205,
-0.0256623756,
-0.0379199944,
-0.0085787708,
-0.0554606915,
0.0343175866,
0.0037507662,
-0.0742879063,
0.0671444014,
0.0158094149,
-0.0161773805,
-0.0191461388,
-0.0073579103,
-0.0098955426,
0.0226999819,
0.0207627434,
-0.0027571903,
0.0148168979,
-0.0639631972,
-0.0514225438,
0.021946406,
0.0205539633,
0.0067284796,
0.1043490395,
-0.0164921694,
0.0177844875,
-0.0121150129,
-0.0148319183,
-0.0663228258,
-0.0232299976,
-0.0109851956,
0.0011943408,
-0.0121319359,
0.0128182387,
-0.041706942,
0.0495211445,
0.013008412,
0.057666637,
-0.0031819383,
-0.0346765034,
-0.0063442863,
-0.0017046761,
0.0231421143,
-0.0056995139,
0.0099283336,
-0.0487814732,
0.0118082892,
-0.0032142291,
0.0610154755,
-0.0391087532,
-0.0275886077,
-0.0173501149,
0.041771125,
-0.0488747619,
-0.0213606786,
0.0597443655,
0.0025278197,
-0.0385778397,
-0.0388397835,
0.1029669419,
0.0135848448,
-0.0602060407,
0.006319725,
0.0069300244,
0.0093375156,
0.0249128286,
0.0195279885,
-0.0581181385,
-0.0084707187,
0.0020583004,
0.032283809,
0.0268153735,
-0.0201280881,
0.0143561754,
-0.087577641,
0.0087204445,
-0.0280517638,
-0.064423427,
0.0166182388,
-0.0297241174,
-0.000327814,
-0.0287107192,
0.027613759,
0.0257337317,
-0.0512556136,
-0.0178657267,
0.0302274134,
-0.0170738269,
-0.0319818929,
-0.0060615013,
-0.0261988156,
-0.0022674843,
0.0539119281,
-0.0198396649,
-0.0156023223,
-0.0504070371,
0.0765202418,
0.0164210405,
0.0203336179,
-0.0013310378,
0.014738475,
-0.0089071728,
-0.0228280518,
-0.0074177324,
0.0322257094,
-0.034296684,
0.0242298767,
-0.0034711419,
0.0904298946,
-0.0149621954,
-0.0031451455,
-0.0055016396,
-0.0212111864,
0.0432490036,
0.0407014713,
-0.0087469257,
-0.0703862011,
-0.0615719259,
0.0212619435,
-0.0096076187,
0.0302618239,
-0.0606574081,
-0.0039519034,
-0.0077246395,
-0.0446586125,
-0.0692536905,
-0.0238383543,
-0.0121948943,
0.0752657056,
0.003837435,
-0.0060758865,
0.0338404849,
0.0186542142,
-0.0416246466,
0.0365762673,
-0.0082798153,
0.0188807249,
-0.0954491571,
0.0191077255,
0.0558204465,
-0.0394380614,
-0.0019242263,
-0.0266124569,
-0.1155800819,
-0.0434782468,
0.0494179688,
0.0495675728,
0.0239838827,
0.0807415992,
-0.0155820772,
-0.0476702154,
0.0391839333,
0.0084993616,
0.0137381293,
0.0470814146,
0.0545384437,
-0.0261345617,
0.0095494119,
0.0460549295,
-0.055488456,
0.0275220163,
0.0382091962,
0.0182201117,
-0.0309415627,
0.0277410559,
0.0239498429,
-0.0447730683,
0.0993699282,
-0.0140290931,
0.0094634751,
-0.0061823679,
0.039304819,
0.0388574749,
0.0121351462,
-0.0361632109,
-0.0129166413,
0.0088765221,
0.045498129,
0.009088479,
0.0056203073,
-0.0099870814,
-0.0291845072,
-0.037460871,
0.0460404828,
-0.0267067943,
0.0110906735,
0.0598126277,
0.0595716573,
-0.0055214823,
-0.0121008176,
0.032106787,
0.0388653465,
0.0085454248,
0.0539914407,
0.0148519017,
0.0371539779,
-0.0329406857,
-0.0369958356,
-0.0852054581,
-0.0287349969,
0.0017504293,
0.0053848242,
0.05620832,
-0.0278484877,
0.0295350589,
-0.0219730642,
0.0292118434,
-0.0247224346,
0.0260978602,
-0.0379852764,
-0.0108474018,
0.0076865759,
0.0018503785,
0.0193912145,
0.0455890484,
0.0807263702,
-0.0117650265,
0.0091640623,
0.0076938109,
0.0491268113,
-0.0299307723,
-0.039383404,
0.0201755278,
-0.0005128538,
-0.010695844,
-0.0129457861,
-0.0234575775,
-0.0706512928,
0.0254789926,
-0.0212331023,
0.0239370726,
-0.0670519546,
0.0513330959,
0.0168289319,
0.0086930096,
0.0052233641,
-0.0282512475,
0.0310372766,
-0.000081256,
-0.0053102397,
-0.0113663785,
-6.26489559e-33,
-0.0262626447,
-0.0350275859,
0.0171467066,
0.0423259474,
-0.0121597182,
0.0083035203,
-0.0428230129,
0.0248706862,
-0.0227878187,
-0.0217638947,
-0.035261225,
0.0335085168,
0.0176813807,
0.0514569953,
0.0299014393,
-0.017577244,
0.0295400303,
-0.0010766422,
0.0006386434,
-0.0037541345,
0.023620246,
0.0503870174,
0.052715037,
-0.0416012071,
-0.0073786289,
-0.0337497927,
0.0471875854,
0.0256561358,
0.022989247,
0.0606998093,
0.0021957683,
0.0397014059,
0.0263585635,
-0.1129328758,
-0.0196970217,
0.0188730489,
-0.0688300133,
-0.0186479762,
-0.0151694296,
0.0390878022,
-0.0483225025,
0.0103839198,
0.0668810681,
0.0013990274,
-0.0441961512,
-0.0080016768,
0.0587248541,
-0.0046122917,
-0.0890085697,
-0.0857357681,
-0.0696394742,
0.0044270623,
0.0101681091,
0.0088050477,
0.0231798012,
0.0644393936,
-0.0127481604,
0.0248058606,
-0.0171430074,
0.011912358,
-0.0030716038,
0.0177276824,
0.0725258216,
0.0634119585,
0.0288294777,
0.0106970016,
0.0132255005,
0.0335137323,
0.0145742018,
-0.0249422062,
0.0412933566,
-0.0044282638,
0.0190405399,
-0.0053390642,
0.028941201,
-0.0158239976,
-0.0423614532,
-0.0185718425,
0.0188169256,
0.0274325851,
0.0421906896,
0.0061996966,
-0.0173610486,
-0.0245947037,
-0.0496457331,
-0.0098087126,
-0.0234772097,
-0.0059037944,
0.0356957056,
0.0331143886,
0.0094110789,
-0.0156929903,
0.0646389946,
-0.0548514985,
0.0053263828,
0.0216660202,
-0.0013740899,
0.0414256565,
-0.0020982076,
0.0194844622,
-0.0823650658,
-0.0095896767,
-0.049349498,
0.0617210008,
0.0158791933,
0.0010893326,
0.0502586998,
0.0130929276,
-0.0640072748,
-0.023222873,
-0.0351107307,
0.0224942509,
0.0258631483,
0.0323266014,
0.0998085514,
-0.0130649591,
-0.0133218579,
0.0930192918,
0.008733009,
-0.0513508692,
-0.0120905545,
0.0148651386,
-0.0080921967,
-0.0052679051,
-0.0353683941,
-0.0251067225,
-0.0466071181,
0.0813838318,
0.0173376985,
-0.0701219514,
-0.0117181279,
0.0198933538,
2.766e-7,
-0.0001950229,
0.0411690548,
0.0185516309,
-0.0007961178,
0.0275044069,
-0.0223340113,
0.0046818317,
0.0203822572,
0.009423703,
0.0463041887,
0.013953153,
-0.0127524734,
0.0344021358,
-0.0124415271,
-0.0949604884,
-0.0484642982,
-0.0751093179,
0.0612593442,
-0.0232599974,
0.0315130353,
-0.0000831298,
0.0488262996,
-0.0094040008,
-0.0079611056,
-0.0037045635,
0.0209916867,
0.0738122612,
-0.0320450068,
0.0510504507,
0.0002090528,
-0.0105284154,
0.022450665,
-0.018137062,
-0.0070796409,
-0.0038218026,
0.0296959709,
-0.0228579901,
0.0319608152,
-0.0014930548,
-0.0400030501,
0.0209079627,
-0.0009122005,
0.012602943,
-0.0415363051,
0.0487347469,
-0.1099850982,
-0.0004187037,
-0.0052599474,
-0.0016826844,
-0.0077936621,
-0.011941093,
0.0073135048,
0.0025187342,
0.0020993336,
0.015804626,
0.0016160186,
-0.0134094283,
-0.0916304886,
-0.035292998,
0.0338941254,
-0.037612278,
-0.0317071266,
-0.0438899621,
0.0015795922,
0.0339984857,
0.0175803136,
-0.0228254851,
2.433300857e-34,
0.0161004867,
-0.001165611,
0.0437383614,
0.0216076933,
-0.0424689613,
-0.0310004,
0.0104331486,
0.0365620032,
0.0615954883,
-0.0604582615,
-0.0154856527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06911v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06911v3 | GIT-Mol: A Multi-modal Large Language Model for Molecular Science with Graph, Image, and Text | 2023-08-14T03:12:29 | 2024-02-06T09:03:53 | Pengfei Liu, Yiming Ren, Jun Tao, Zhixiang Ren | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, q-bio.BM | Large language models have made significant strides in natural language
processing, enabling innovative applications in molecular science by processing
textual representations of molecules. However, most existing language models
cannot capture the rich information with complex molecular structures or
images. In this paper, we introduce GIT-Mol, a multi-modal large language model
that integrates the Graph, Image, and Text information. To facilitate the
integration of multi-modal molecular data, we propose GIT-Former, a novel
architecture that is capable of aligning all modalities into a unified latent
space. We achieve a 5%-10% accuracy increase in properties prediction and a
20.2% boost in molecule generation validity compared to the baselines. With the
any-to-language molecular translation strategy, our model has the potential to
perform more downstream tasks, such as compound name recognition and chemical
reaction prediction. | [
0.0356200561,
0.076652132,
0.0158109069,
0.017661741,
-0.0220114086,
0.0014583368,
0.0282202512,
0.0300015323,
0.0356102772,
-0.0273297299,
-0.0302408785,
-0.0623247325,
0.0032536187,
0.0821898431,
0.0611250438,
0.004162116,
-0.0105885398,
-0.0398989432,
0.009207096,
-0.0238638725,
0.0207011569,
0.0158023871,
0.0548746809,
0.0025162182,
0.0128624747,
-0.0220740624,
-0.0321668312,
0.014427742,
0.0202524289,
-0.0328268781,
-0.048693683,
0.0565270409,
0.04163469,
0.0513454713,
0.0000015329,
-0.0221960712,
-0.0252955966,
0.0333008766,
0.0289123673,
-0.0158276446,
0.0947982445,
-0.0614997521,
-0.0006014719,
-0.0194699299,
-0.0252406728,
-0.0062541161,
0.1004417464,
0.0326537937,
0.0193129424,
0.0585643835,
-0.0079206936,
-0.051200185,
0.0623734556,
0.0026623099,
0.0787601098,
-0.0052599018,
0.0658588335,
0.0391427949,
0.0240210835,
0.0301232021,
-0.0330614746,
0.0451295637,
-0.0294159576,
-0.0431250259,
0.0053150142,
0.0352158621,
0.0296921805,
-0.0407541804,
-0.0113720298,
0.1088000536,
-0.0201678872,
-0.0567595512,
-0.0472472049,
0.0026046231,
-0.038698446,
0.0411596745,
-0.0553340763,
0.0197699256,
0.026601579,
0.0182760898,
0.0175543781,
-0.0278747827,
0.0469669625,
0.0156615097,
0.0018733225,
0.0154201193,
0.023611661,
-0.0138576264,
-0.0252473447,
0.0080471663,
-0.0669223592,
-0.0343959369,
0.0053088185,
0.0154857682,
0.0154808983,
0.017169524,
0.0043409355,
-0.0379839428,
0.0282890778,
-0.0605253242,
0.0069263666,
-0.0009835965,
0.0005760988,
0.0501175113,
-0.0109673766,
0.0192884542,
-0.0620471872,
0.0161654446,
-0.0456672609,
-0.0275433809,
-0.0773201063,
0.005504976,
-0.0234551802,
0.0014331533,
-0.0398134179,
-0.0510185361,
-0.0429632179,
0.0339173935,
0.0281668399,
-0.0225990508,
0.0399396829,
0.0311251823,
-0.0534565598,
0.0015038991,
-0.0113694444,
0.0543249287,
0.0378230959,
-0.0197570473,
-0.0122955665,
-0.0307341814,
-0.0340942778,
0.0253218152,
0.0189585742,
-0.04793166,
-0.0032895,
0.0740449056,
-0.0122405924,
-0.0303462632,
0.0502852239,
-0.0611583143,
-0.0303073581,
-0.0564425625,
0.0585856773,
-0.0740122423,
0.0630781204,
0.0379670151,
0.0025622793,
-0.0566037968,
0.02067817,
-0.0049890587,
-0.0590156205,
0.1174152344,
-0.0191985276,
-0.0576219857,
0.0125953946,
0.0015132693,
0.0165275261,
0.0044606891,
-0.006256734,
0.0006508746,
-0.0083132861,
-0.0016016909,
0.0008694299,
0.0076257256,
0.0010115037,
-0.0270821527,
0.0058837328,
-0.008090361,
0.0133441016,
0.0430234708,
-0.0070456122,
0.0335078947,
-0.0077232658,
-0.0111545008,
0.04347964,
0.0264147185,
0.0481687449,
0.0323228054,
0.0046542296,
0.0473766997,
-0.0028101769,
-0.0341750793,
-0.0440839715,
0.0616545156,
-0.0147404661,
0.0327946655,
0.0273443926,
0.0515498668,
0.0074670459,
0.0245008729,
-0.0056528896,
-0.0163531508,
0.0032302241,
-0.057899069,
0.0516494811,
-0.034952119,
-0.0919666365,
0.0057528592,
0.0555559844,
-0.0260186754,
0.0091547789,
-0.0025733162,
0.0073041669,
0.0523213781,
0.0332126766,
-0.0290879086,
-0.0112806167,
0.0102371704,
-0.0197199844,
0.0373529643,
0.0061589223,
0.0016903725,
-0.0034258543,
-0.0288063753,
-0.0541496389,
-0.0125734303,
0.0021492469,
0.0071838819,
-0.0255175214,
0.007022656,
0.0010323757,
-0.0499659888,
0.0046832683,
0.0117970472,
0.0322034173,
-0.0066444706,
-0.0280914549,
-0.0195160974,
0.030946305,
0.0041306405,
-0.0111157363,
0.0501312651,
0.0552366227,
-0.0339027643,
-0.0256103743,
-0.0012791166,
-0.0041240994,
-0.0604087897,
0.06318333,
-0.0154936034,
0.0137716308,
-0.0162837002,
-0.0358591005,
-0.053324569,
0.0519137494,
-0.0238085594,
0.0180151872,
-0.0244108401,
-0.0122969421,
0.0085211964,
0.0582205467,
-0.0328085497,
0.0604998209,
0.0249342229,
0.0016300736,
0.0224063117,
0.0093030278,
0.0085498383,
-0.0089116413,
-0.0133676855,
0.0336552486,
0.0598057061,
0.0340315327,
0.0434729084,
-0.0173060037,
-0.0067539569,
-0.0096028177,
-0.0687536597,
-0.0266871247,
-0.0076404274,
0.0189004354,
0.0228176452,
0.005935248,
0.0273310523,
0.0197473243,
-0.0291952677,
0.0180314742,
-0.01257018,
0.0071837096,
0.020796299,
-0.0069331639,
-0.0522109605,
-0.026274642,
-0.0430872738,
-0.0450024866,
0.1024977043,
0.0064911353,
-0.0638721958,
-0.0064842985,
-0.0128425565,
-0.0169140697,
0.044289425,
-0.0000837359,
-0.0200231131,
0.0080236085,
-0.0375904292,
0.0516619012,
0.0168618541,
-0.0075205392,
-0.0164756719,
0.0768277273,
-0.0060963975,
-0.0161822326,
-0.0180158466,
-0.0355072282,
-0.009187256,
0.0171684679,
-0.0100807967,
-0.0403132141,
0.0616942421,
-0.0062196581,
0.0117234411,
-0.0419103354,
-0.0038365077,
-0.0001053208,
-0.0153013263,
-0.0138956793,
0.0128277354,
-0.0099244481,
-0.0077397712,
0.0080397502,
-0.0582958423,
0.0672321916,
-0.0620413683,
-0.0048342315,
-0.0093375957,
0.0231831502,
0.0049592578,
0.0298315212,
0.0451525524,
0.0351453722,
0.0014042106,
0.0023902247,
-0.0247220714,
0.007516026,
0.0323740058,
-0.0277654529,
0.011061159,
-0.0387258865,
0.0332432836,
-0.0032329177,
-0.0145148663,
0.0322458111,
-0.0019931647,
-0.0343249999,
0.0320514701,
0.0321509242,
-0.0696952492,
-0.0328234844,
0.0317530818,
0.0164263286,
-0.0219715331,
-0.031452775,
0.0130358413,
-0.0423081778,
0.0588559993,
0.0598389991,
-0.0503338538,
-0.0024770414,
-0.0389528051,
0.0413963459,
0.0432913266,
-0.0159872156,
0.0005047507,
-0.0306789912,
0.0133381113,
0.0058594071,
0.0438259467,
-0.0446147472,
0.0113276131,
0.0141752101,
-0.0164997745,
-0.004201822,
0.108859852,
0.0224166624,
-0.0638423488,
-0.0173878875,
0.009835368,
0.0211265367,
-0.0235608071,
0.0268782564,
-0.0997226834,
-0.0458797105,
-0.0479604639,
-0.0165618267,
0.0181816965,
-0.0252814125,
-0.0028399189,
-0.0309332609,
0.0352279507,
0.0477906428,
-0.0377054103,
-0.0514305569,
-0.0495341048,
-0.0477074832,
-0.0291604996,
-0.0143345473,
0.0101761939,
0.0018135678,
-0.0183304474,
0.0192156974,
0.0420516655,
-0.0403712615,
0.0106377369,
-0.0189555436,
0.0069505759,
0.0268597938,
0.052213937,
0.004027674,
-0.0081674466,
0.0232635271,
0.035543941,
0.0118714953,
-0.0156740751,
0.0418374687,
0.0071864272,
-0.0066189393,
-0.0281568579,
0.0203607604,
-0.0460207798,
-0.0497119464,
-0.0782718956,
0.1199010387,
-0.0002152416,
-0.0103993258,
-0.0355742536,
-0.0000926161,
-0.0268481206,
0.0343917683,
-0.0010816256,
-0.0155915832,
-0.0849515647,
-0.0069468007,
0.0247928854,
-0.0106457006,
-0.0194244124,
-0.0135331275,
-0.0336128883,
-0.0221600588,
-0.0327754878,
-0.0134765357,
0.0134963514,
-0.009254585,
-0.0222649965,
0.0281714685,
0.0099564232,
-0.05469523,
-0.0659979209,
0.0454004295,
-0.0190641172,
0.0189609695,
-0.0328038372,
-0.0229742397,
0.0453944616,
-0.0304502863,
-0.0040055937,
0.0481978357,
-0.0935116634,
-0.0897225589,
-0.0472391844,
0.0016642957,
0.0194022339,
0.0284129772,
0.0059141745,
-0.0568717346,
0.0512918904,
0.0223718919,
-0.0082530258,
-0.0359960683,
-0.0234694891,
-0.0273296479,
-0.022151567,
0.0125361281,
-0.0077442247,
-0.0090433583,
0.0014598791,
0.027183935,
0.0246228222,
-0.0401787907,
0.0522219054,
0.0225938391,
0.0595199354,
0.0071539711,
0.0087118344,
-0.03127262,
-0.0373214036,
0.0015481203,
-0.0129744345,
-0.028076021,
-0.0012025265,
0.055724889,
-0.0153797455,
-0.0122780204,
-0.0006209811,
-0.0112517513,
-0.0186834913,
-0.0024318791,
0.0059725763,
0.0229352918,
-0.011442286,
0.0837756023,
-0.023820471,
0.008916215,
0.0019781278,
-0.0267805625,
0.0129562328,
-0.029904101,
0.0212020967,
0.0054015885,
0.0279500131,
-0.0290337577,
0.0188987609,
-0.0284562726,
-0.0083127897,
-0.0585882626,
0.0335042961,
0.0698088109,
0.0071389764,
0.0856409147,
-0.0238736924,
-0.0211937223,
-0.0268925186,
0.0436235964,
0.0227250364,
-0.0260350537,
0.0994188413,
0.0035806731,
-0.0155517254,
-0.0194281787,
0.0631109178,
0.0569446385,
0.0136676263,
-0.0069451057,
-0.0631673858,
-0.0095808664,
-0.0025435567,
-0.0335358344,
-0.0079614781,
-0.0361295789,
0.0060797436,
-0.0243249107,
-0.0596858226,
0.0300768688,
0.0270643849,
-0.0305225477,
0.0334448479,
0.0202942733,
0.0496560857,
0.0189689882,
-0.0713722631,
-0.0302109905,
0.0389650725,
0.0165003389,
-0.0168081839,
-0.0358903259,
-5.517016697e-33,
0.0012645185,
-0.0331915356,
0.0074539972,
0.0057814089,
-0.0003500368,
0.0119652897,
-0.064235568,
-0.0073233591,
0.014132957,
0.083217293,
0.0227323789,
-0.001896083,
0.0068336204,
-0.0113951536,
-0.0011109682,
0.0192830749,
0.0033351965,
0.0052752928,
0.0085806381,
0.0543117896,
0.0480182804,
0.0449026898,
0.0726243258,
-0.0326426998,
0.0065330006,
0.0279504526,
0.0059691882,
-0.0279998407,
-0.0093993181,
0.0454212576,
-0.0263560172,
0.0408923626,
-0.0104849031,
0.0022995481,
-0.0374338254,
0.0151758511,
-0.0292417854,
0.0207981151,
0.0331807509,
0.0078209415,
-0.0245070606,
-0.0054591745,
0.0244180933,
-0.0310947075,
-0.0009309288,
-0.0339791104,
0.0404627621,
-0.0073372866,
-0.0384816043,
0.0094167795,
-0.0769193172,
0.0379786752,
0.0223418027,
0.0343427062,
0.0377125442,
-0.0053605828,
0.030703675,
0.0269979518,
-0.0218976419,
0.0448591523,
-0.0150715187,
0.0293899942,
0.0729354843,
0.0219810698,
0.0012246235,
0.0342684798,
0.004405716,
-0.0249896031,
-0.0130313607,
0.0211948324,
0.0003836497,
0.0612571798,
0.0268918443,
0.0301947184,
-0.0029152324,
0.0186582189,
-0.0796193704,
0.0047749272,
-0.0475299768,
0.0397646837,
-0.0062097418,
0.0500142574,
0.0251421481,
-0.0251025818,
-0.0326489024,
0.0072567225,
-0.021119941,
-0.0213294234,
-0.0294949245,
-0.0335037485,
-0.0390418284,
0.0346751958,
0.0492047183,
-0.0480360165,
-0.0514446907,
0.0610674396,
-0.0264310353,
0.0447468944,
-0.0489731468,
0.0224773511,
-0.0512718223,
-0.0650582165,
0.041601412,
-0.0466460027,
-0.0026448737,
-0.0250474047,
0.0137498109,
0.0335750058,
-0.0475576445,
-0.0170936286,
-0.0946436971,
-0.0339130089,
0.0257496536,
0.0295899678,
0.0239447765,
0.0065138238,
-0.0087304264,
0.0496561974,
0.0240447577,
-0.0002519243,
0.0186582617,
0.0062760129,
0.0278210677,
0.0147201428,
-0.0944582671,
0.0118661541,
-0.0547738858,
-0.014488739,
0.0514893048,
-0.0655254871,
-0.0257553961,
0.0265524648,
2.458e-7,
0.1070246324,
0.0553837754,
0.0352019556,
-0.0024170254,
0.0011592684,
0.0381251983,
-0.0071773101,
0.0469277985,
-0.0165757518,
-0.0159689281,
0.0207156371,
-0.0186729059,
-0.0080695786,
-0.0101538999,
-0.0133989397,
0.0185864549,
-0.043021936,
-0.0381486602,
-0.0692652762,
0.0175023861,
0.0256135315,
0.1286176592,
-0.0102311783,
-0.0178918634,
0.0102529982,
-0.0613760166,
0.0964653715,
-0.0197267774,
-0.0078279516,
0.0282735899,
-0.0405772626,
-0.0474232212,
-0.0275796093,
0.0350382105,
-0.0264537316,
-0.0201386455,
0.0210960805,
0.029359566,
-0.0428217128,
0.003819691,
0.0395902246,
-0.0259668138,
-0.0068426854,
-0.0286553316,
0.0164633561,
-0.0445713997,
-0.0500091203,
-0.0217997003,
-0.0351112708,
0.0022270181,
0.0160522349,
-0.0013883174,
-0.0041136439,
0.0415280275,
0.0181212332,
0.0015990131,
-0.0018155549,
-0.040407829,
-0.0381615087,
-0.0125414692,
-0.0316743739,
0.0121238185,
-0.0410009734,
-0.0152016012,
0.0346085802,
-0.0472684503,
-0.0171464439,
2.354931429e-34,
0.0604153797,
-0.0206542462,
-0.0030301535,
-0.0096572628,
0.0604679324,
-0.0221370962,
0.0284061003,
0.0311106499,
-0.0258553103,
-0.1175195277,
-0.0513282195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06907v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06907v1 | Generative Interpretation | 2023-08-14T02:59:27 | 2023-08-14T02:59:27 | Yonathan A. Arbel, David Hoffman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG, econ.TH | We introduce generative interpretation, a new approach to estimating
contractual meaning using large language models. As AI triumphalism is the
order of the day, we proceed by way of grounded case studies, each illustrating
the capabilities of these novel tools in distinct ways. Taking well-known
contracts opinions, and sourcing the actual agreements that they adjudicated,
we show that AI models can help factfinders ascertain ordinary meaning in
context, quantify ambiguity, and fill gaps in parties' agreements. We also
illustrate how models can calculate the probative value of individual pieces of
extrinsic evidence. After offering best practices for the use of these models
given their limitations, we consider their implications for judicial practice
and contract theory. Using LLMs permits courts to estimate what the parties
intended cheaply and accurately, and as such generative interpretation
unsettles the current interpretative stalemate. Their use responds to
efficiency-minded textualists and justice-oriented contextualists, who argue
about whether parties will prefer cost and certainty or accuracy and fairness.
Parties--and courts--would prefer a middle path, in which adjudicators strive
to predict what the contract really meant, admitting just enough context to
approximate reality while avoiding unguided and biased assimilation of
evidence. As generative interpretation offers this possibility, we argue it can
become the new workhorse of contractual interpretation. | [
0.033097662,
0.0933683515,
-0.018093396,
0.0163640901,
-0.0746097416,
0.0182169508,
0.0273680091,
0.0126010533,
-0.0181864593,
-0.052256342,
0.0149419615,
-0.0151865669,
-0.0060295779,
0.0236884244,
-0.0172929671,
-0.0024106009,
0.0042169476,
0.0255963616,
0.0450612828,
-0.0017088809,
0.0019597108,
0.0128667941,
0.0180450901,
0.0359989554,
-0.0810708031,
-0.0285857301,
-0.0046054679,
-0.0045106434,
-0.0267320797,
-0.0043079397,
-0.0801869109,
0.0412614085,
0.0314398818,
0.0469050817,
0.0000019787,
-0.0852212757,
-0.0416201316,
0.0005991833,
-0.0415510088,
0.0665155947,
0.0229068082,
-0.0609741919,
-0.0093134809,
-0.0272697955,
-0.0519714132,
0.0697211251,
0.0216908511,
-0.0241447054,
0.004275016,
0.0729429275,
0.0001134308,
-0.045979023,
0.0208564289,
-0.0358439013,
0.0194175616,
-0.0625018477,
0.0332942866,
0.0245871693,
0.0208493229,
-0.0315180086,
-0.0085779047,
0.0591995418,
0.0518250577,
-0.0503757559,
-0.0330601819,
0.0157472994,
-0.0210158788,
0.0359732397,
0.006080898,
-0.0013378657,
0.111058794,
0.0045648976,
0.0205065478,
-0.0148672005,
0.0253741164,
0.013036822,
-0.0192424785,
0.1013617665,
-0.0201093499,
0.0243118908,
0.0345115289,
0.025005538,
0.0334619768,
0.0140825957,
-0.0519699305,
0.0864142999,
-0.0261607151,
-0.0184505042,
-0.0094829816,
0.0202999283,
-0.0132417874,
-0.0506740659,
0.0375736542,
0.0277179442,
0.002118408,
0.0680330247,
-0.0378129706,
-0.0055724797,
0.0345641784,
-0.0622858405,
-0.0152816866,
-0.0012053918,
-0.04195299,
0.0627181754,
0.0009934254,
-0.0213090479,
-0.0272710714,
0.0071274308,
0.0073440964,
-0.0015853331,
-0.0035368274,
-0.025605198,
-0.0446959734,
0.0345224813,
-0.0760495514,
-0.0048046964,
-0.0057111126,
0.0047561931,
-0.033287771,
0.0331102833,
0.000425674,
-0.016692603,
-0.0225287527,
-0.0366073325,
-0.0753692091,
-0.0618798546,
-0.040613804,
0.0492950082,
-0.0253014434,
-0.032914415,
0.0143390968,
0.0029459137,
-0.0005861567,
0.0028913976,
0.0022745612,
0.10459245,
0.0380642675,
-0.0244469456,
-0.0227321312,
-0.0923024267,
-0.0335552059,
-0.0554538183,
-0.0618068203,
-0.047482606,
0.0080936914,
-0.0018111866,
-0.0221606605,
-0.1070245728,
-0.0067296438,
0.0041998713,
0.0004379677,
0.0232025255,
-0.017795125,
0.0048215934,
-0.0565937944,
0.0063769068,
-0.0070266263,
-0.017487783,
0.0406860709,
0.044935558,
0.03088817,
0.0300153941,
0.0497188643,
0.0420458056,
-0.0201734304,
0.0171817746,
0.0053141238,
-0.0056349109,
-0.0074708457,
0.0012596957,
-0.0204518195,
0.0291205943,
0.0050161178,
-0.0008957557,
0.0320731997,
0.0543393046,
-0.0227462184,
0.0313958637,
0.0336190574,
0.0021551969,
0.0191478375,
-0.0171073321,
-0.0355321392,
0.0099459449,
0.0062050391,
-0.0324801952,
-0.0502049737,
-0.0103615876,
0.0093129585,
-0.0774307847,
0.0456217304,
0.0006534063,
0.0082556568,
0.0265664887,
0.0554761402,
-0.0058410764,
0.0153263863,
0.0253282581,
0.014855667,
-0.0018981355,
-0.0107798539,
-0.0357410163,
-0.004699647,
0.0324096791,
0.0433710702,
-0.030329464,
0.0572472215,
-0.0135037797,
-0.0131665375,
0.0299322121,
0.0180836152,
0.0071418793,
-0.0091027319,
-0.0060650664,
-0.025285881,
-0.0073222341,
0.0447997823,
0.0301384293,
-0.0536584258,
-0.0179167297,
0.0159755293,
-0.0584246926,
0.0136134056,
0.0041415975,
0.0010627925,
-0.041879613,
0.0096483044,
-0.0020002448,
0.0165562183,
0.0366198905,
-0.0013425172,
0.0060299188,
0.0240356252,
0.0094501488,
0.0032102456,
0.057728041,
-0.0113922702,
0.0550473854,
0.0018470259,
-0.0575888753,
-0.0326424837,
-0.0705444366,
-0.0270871092,
-0.0006186228,
-0.0071940436,
-0.045610819,
0.0326194018,
-0.0328385904,
0.0169423539,
-0.0283101369,
-0.0329823643,
-0.0158584882,
0.0535101779,
-0.0125863273,
-0.0550819784,
-0.0196950026,
-0.0217436403,
0.0430297814,
-0.0141106937,
-0.020760525,
0.0060511078,
0.0021002979,
0.0091591645,
0.0110540884,
-0.0112303412,
-0.0030964939,
-0.0219304506,
-0.0442691743,
0.0251568109,
-0.0215026084,
-0.000179215,
0.0065008588,
-0.0160350297,
0.0022265392,
0.0259313285,
0.0034665705,
-0.0447762683,
-0.0234305337,
-0.0043909508,
-0.0004870817,
0.007496011,
-0.0566901788,
0.0110070473,
-0.0183542911,
-0.0525790416,
0.043901585,
0.063403368,
0.0075750737,
-0.0526820607,
0.0263211988,
-0.0139031131,
-0.0168090649,
-0.0305850562,
0.0280925445,
-0.0067316815,
0.0090419222,
-0.0494825058,
0.0248996858,
-0.0017154507,
0.0864943266,
0.0235580858,
-0.0108746821,
-0.0338115916,
-0.0356388018,
-0.0016753653,
-0.0033897166,
-0.049311731,
-0.0571096912,
0.0104317162,
0.0250221509,
0.0232583005,
0.0013443549,
-0.0230529141,
0.0442827009,
-0.0369579755,
-0.0313109942,
0.0269762836,
-0.0171022322,
-0.0304178149,
0.0963041633,
0.0077047767,
-0.0497500151,
0.031397149,
0.007275207,
0.072357133,
-0.0243484005,
-0.0202122647,
-0.0558993965,
0.1141338795,
-0.0179935787,
0.0077789929,
0.0242515542,
-0.0285099167,
0.0194128994,
0.0217266548,
0.0944443569,
-0.0370959528,
0.0933192,
-0.0586729124,
0.025240181,
0.0259059481,
-0.0085940175,
-0.0061067827,
-0.0416188464,
-0.0272064302,
0.030988235,
0.0705592111,
0.0235288367,
-0.0371398292,
-0.023047721,
0.0201108996,
-0.0013608566,
0.0331166238,
-0.0048595201,
-0.0364288092,
-0.0437762365,
-0.0226433203,
-0.0289278533,
0.0365890823,
-0.0287400484,
-0.0600798614,
0.0130362622,
-0.041685909,
0.0144056482,
0.0054554497,
0.026026072,
-0.0342870764,
-0.027815925,
-0.0118674356,
0.0454665832,
-0.0010181965,
-0.0450688154,
0.0029293403,
0.0643793195,
0.0013444549,
-0.0101983082,
0.0458922498,
-0.0046127522,
-0.028444754,
0.01314958,
0.0055160662,
-0.1624829173,
0.0345639698,
-0.0201641414,
-0.0142314816,
-0.0591121279,
-0.0713233575,
-0.0378004201,
-0.0375350602,
0.0883982405,
0.013345384,
0.021990696,
0.0014408184,
-0.0002694865,
-0.0060724705,
-0.0260465834,
-0.0289570689,
-0.0076706051,
0.0123025095,
0.0123101305,
0.0165798832,
0.0345399417,
0.0302030277,
0.0252355114,
-0.0194716286,
0.0229569431,
0.0101827988,
0.0119004156,
-0.0222718176,
-0.005283026,
-0.0093380678,
0.0418661609,
-0.0200928096,
0.0372449346,
-0.0047891941,
0.043315161,
0.0178105831,
-0.023312483,
0.0184252951,
0.0070242202,
-0.0365460217,
0.0418217778,
0.0319562033,
-0.0409570523,
-0.0043801032,
0.0038369945,
-0.0432889163,
0.0083468305,
0.0406189747,
0.0216035414,
-0.0016123825,
-0.043078173,
-0.0483039767,
-0.020319188,
0.0109222196,
-0.0428720973,
0.0123885218,
-0.023827035,
-0.0484181121,
-0.0067551611,
-0.0296650659,
-0.0110413516,
0.074095957,
0.0307048261,
-0.0234205034,
0.0608430989,
-0.0223465078,
-0.0128828268,
0.0048298547,
-0.0549361296,
0.0128656412,
0.0194922239,
0.0189037956,
-0.0334430486,
-0.009350582,
-0.0255565085,
-0.0045644157,
-0.0224888958,
-0.0134535022,
0.0131849116,
0.0048363116,
0.0373190194,
0.0009525383,
-0.0170959365,
-0.0237788185,
-0.0216712356,
0.055815205,
0.0061512608,
0.0324649177,
0.0504793413,
0.0229591299,
-0.0161783621,
-0.0019833108,
-0.0273872018,
0.010321429,
0.0102182766,
0.0271622986,
-0.0359872207,
0.0113955224,
0.0561351702,
0.0343825407,
-0.0599898137,
-0.0190630574,
-0.0391236134,
0.0080463961,
-0.0104211979,
-0.0316267982,
-0.0071723838,
-0.0343092903,
-0.0190194044,
0.0139994361,
-0.01227591,
-0.0536372624,
0.0737906098,
-0.0135679739,
0.0385887958,
-0.0193634778,
0.0376993977,
0.0354308896,
-0.0301694609,
0.034237437,
-0.0486157984,
0.0208567232,
0.0289397221,
-0.0248392913,
0.0607815012,
-0.0005478564,
0.0114988722,
0.0442579351,
-0.0136701223,
-0.0318139829,
0.0030971805,
-0.0376445502,
-0.0635060072,
0.0377824567,
0.0572671071,
0.0192443188,
0.0035765916,
0.0054396903,
-0.046572987,
0.0189582482,
0.0084135067,
0.02257316,
0.0178365875,
-0.0772405714,
0.0052829296,
0.0213721506,
-0.0020318404,
0.017740313,
0.016563477,
-0.0409636311,
0.0862597227,
-0.0562243424,
-0.0184263568,
-0.0128357075,
-0.0801116154,
-0.0428504609,
-0.0208328608,
-0.0129422983,
-0.0356274247,
-0.1241101921,
-0.0244124718,
-0.0325264633,
0.0146917701,
0.018736545,
-0.0157822277,
-0.0313478261,
0.0527983159,
0.0156465676,
-0.0391838178,
-0.0329504944,
0.060666129,
0.0001194725,
-0.0315991342,
-0.0196027569,
-5.45238912e-33,
-0.0122797973,
-0.0490219817,
0.0136637567,
0.0067499918,
-0.0035141027,
-0.0038910338,
-0.0421312042,
-0.0050037219,
0.0182241518,
0.0346702076,
-0.0262107961,
0.0139801307,
0.0232412778,
-0.0225745235,
0.0171615258,
-0.0119834812,
0.011272897,
0.0075303768,
-0.0037331204,
0.0048642615,
0.0024136954,
-0.021306403,
0.0289927404,
-0.1112679392,
0.0682366118,
0.0042345943,
-0.056427896,
-0.014944721,
-0.0695131645,
0.0331226513,
-0.0080593219,
0.0194502175,
0.0062472015,
-0.0445763394,
0.0163171887,
-0.0050540552,
-0.0234707575,
0.0190476701,
0.043168854,
-0.0022879252,
0.0081736892,
-0.0280767605,
0.0351479799,
0.0222187657,
-0.0667722523,
0.0144523717,
0.0400600471,
-0.0526481643,
-0.0273983646,
-0.0843041167,
-0.0846245959,
0.0531923026,
-0.0320847631,
0.0223360453,
0.0437617376,
-0.0212823562,
0.0031536038,
0.024460895,
-0.0334465541,
0.004330297,
-0.0242104176,
-0.0475511365,
0.0433563665,
-0.0807112083,
0.005394157,
0.0558460727,
-0.0008416633,
0.0143567063,
-0.0230848212,
-0.0387761705,
0.043790929,
0.0610512868,
-0.0260227807,
0.0633950084,
-0.006860306,
-0.011211466,
-0.0535082929,
-0.0056945304,
0.0240629148,
0.0097436141,
0.0286758952,
-0.0212034136,
-0.0320789889,
-0.0290882103,
-0.0521397814,
-0.0692136139,
-0.0052253776,
0.0150682451,
-0.0134835159,
-0.0045754365,
0.0104967887,
0.0320094973,
0.0140288817,
-0.0571998395,
-0.0354255773,
0.0275889449,
0.0173308589,
0.0168747269,
-0.0041174609,
0.007481202,
-0.0123342481,
-0.0301415622,
0.0225450043,
0.0137601448,
0.0634728074,
0.0095091797,
0.0450436771,
-0.0117905894,
0.0203518681,
0.0126803741,
-0.0336406827,
0.0262980778,
0.0403583087,
-0.0552012771,
0.0416000932,
0.0412084833,
0.0106771812,
0.0135207986,
0.0362644494,
0.0075652949,
-0.0291877165,
0.0243659597,
-0.0157913379,
0.0029768888,
-0.0486172624,
0.0034992266,
0.0456086844,
0.0082973996,
0.0839775205,
-0.0115146115,
-0.0007220791,
0.0311877299,
2.672e-7,
0.081062682,
0.0402220413,
0.012483892,
0.0383614749,
-0.0172738396,
0.0616222732,
0.0190686639,
0.0388447158,
-0.002504271,
-0.0754967555,
0.0351777039,
0.0008938561,
0.0241988301,
0.0162118562,
-0.0077221114,
0.0464597382,
-0.0369423777,
-0.046129398,
-0.0691580251,
0.0235894732,
0.1020907685,
0.044944711,
0.0335339122,
0.0058852159,
-0.0048571182,
-0.0008320482,
0.0355877094,
-0.0374822393,
0.0128901945,
0.0093370965,
0.0517625846,
-0.0582961142,
0.0101619074,
0.0105344951,
0.0054083504,
0.0436807834,
-0.0248992871,
0.0766328275,
0.0009255815,
0.0523899496,
-0.0213118717,
-0.0552764609,
0.0209560208,
-0.02352136,
0.0325876512,
-0.0066209347,
-0.0375068411,
-0.0357175209,
-0.0202287696,
-0.0258964915,
-0.024204338,
0.0657982603,
0.0226860791,
0.0029731502,
0.0086248713,
-0.0157348812,
0.0213677138,
-0.0659887642,
0.0119025819,
0.0532059707,
-0.0290616173,
0.0200853013,
0.0149416225,
0.0391377732,
0.0573001504,
-0.0717441291,
0.0160164814,
2.105488084e-34,
0.0447184332,
-0.0186880212,
0.023237193,
0.0641360208,
0.0445186459,
0.048478581,
0.0068605905,
0.0217070021,
0.0177353099,
-0.0555095859,
0.0043897633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06873v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06873v2 | SpeechX: Neural Codec Language Model as a Versatile Speech Transformer | 2023-08-14T01:01:19 | 2024-06-25T18:38:28 | Xiaofei Wang, Manthan Thakker, Zhuo Chen, Naoyuki Kanda, Sefik Emre Eskimez, Sanyuan Chen, Min Tang, Shujie Liu, Jinyu Li, Takuya Yoshioka | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Recent advancements in generative speech models based on audio-text prompts
have enabled remarkable innovations like high-quality zero-shot text-to-speech.
However, existing models still face limitations in handling diverse audio-text
speech generation tasks involving transforming input speech and processing
audio captured in adverse acoustic conditions. This paper introduces SpeechX, a
versatile speech generation model capable of zero-shot TTS and various speech
transformation tasks, dealing with both clean and noisy signals. SpeechX
combines neural codec language modeling with multi-task learning using
task-dependent prompting, enabling unified and extensible modeling and
providing a consistent way for leveraging textual input in speech enhancement
and transformation tasks. Experimental results show SpeechX's efficacy in
various tasks, including zero-shot TTS, noise suppression, target speaker
extraction, speech removal, and speech editing with or without background
noise, achieving comparable or superior performance to specialized models
across tasks. See https://aka.ms/speechx for demo samples. | [
-0.0031636474,
0.0485756695,
0.0446955413,
-0.0072393958,
0.0240410008,
-0.026412515,
0.0479236022,
-0.0006949954,
-0.0939867571,
-0.0226068366,
-0.0656756461,
-0.0264391657,
0.0015757061,
0.0575471111,
0.0366248861,
-0.0500437021,
0.0063157743,
-0.0510668382,
0.0320886485,
-0.0028447951,
-0.0069871652,
-0.0124290958,
-0.0408408642,
0.0062484564,
-0.0470545925,
-0.0215653591,
0.0044290428,
0.039266739,
-0.020026017,
0.012949721,
0.0139431814,
0.0326560326,
0.0228253696,
0.0539975911,
0.0000018887,
-0.0229125172,
-0.0138253588,
0.0039328295,
-0.0399422757,
-0.015939787,
0.042941533,
0.028943019,
-0.0596937649,
0.0131798461,
-0.0273172893,
-0.0216114707,
0.0839141458,
0.0343613066,
0.0675940514,
0.0749690607,
-0.0258888602,
-0.0269633569,
-0.0015776713,
-0.0018832781,
0.0083562322,
0.0355004184,
-0.0191998351,
-0.0532094166,
0.0307937115,
-0.0052230833,
-0.0106858453,
0.0485842638,
0.0130531825,
-0.0615992956,
0.0178990886,
0.010190513,
-0.0195046607,
-0.0636970177,
-0.0222540349,
0.0709680691,
-0.0295036845,
0.0245156772,
-0.0021894386,
0.0261896849,
-0.0108439457,
-0.0531432629,
-0.0563879274,
0.0270100217,
0.0756973103,
-0.0002748367,
-0.0569421463,
0.0340334997,
0.0165359285,
-0.0403289907,
0.024560215,
0.0177992936,
0.0149149951,
-0.0171830487,
-0.0132971099,
0.0057557486,
0.0165095124,
-0.0316614844,
0.030468842,
0.0386120901,
-0.0438374393,
-0.0165375769,
-0.0411356278,
-0.0711009502,
-0.0378072336,
-0.0211744606,
0.0347148478,
0.0499713793,
-0.0724202543,
0.0178848431,
-0.0527079105,
0.0390296951,
0.0236040838,
-0.0141299441,
-0.0227496382,
-0.0367494933,
-0.0026132453,
0.0110483747,
-0.0407322273,
0.0464157462,
-0.060502965,
-0.021798037,
-0.016718071,
0.0066107833,
-0.0458417721,
0.0145848589,
0.0528873689,
0.0478051193,
-0.0628926381,
-0.0257576928,
0.02734828,
0.03544062,
0.0036704906,
0.0678832307,
0.0097125256,
-0.0281741936,
-0.0265248045,
0.0224360246,
0.04260296,
0.0118913278,
0.0218627863,
0.0599557236,
-0.0114359204,
-0.0083598727,
-0.0388157666,
-0.0288841166,
-0.0140569033,
-0.0326046348,
-0.000336197,
-0.0529877655,
0.0234233923,
-0.0311060864,
-0.0134342993,
-0.0090162652,
0.005548887,
-0.0041693933,
-0.0030493536,
0.0513995364,
-0.0227777921,
0.0018055143,
0.0650943741,
-0.0062457887,
-0.018140668,
0.0468140319,
0.0618296117,
-0.0152280908,
0.0263666827,
0.0028237288,
-0.0007596437,
0.072081387,
-0.0140371053,
-0.0046321265,
-0.0370574743,
-0.0145683549,
0.0109952576,
0.0118466597,
0.0757018477,
0.0532881767,
-0.0321494266,
0.0040732021,
0.0999542549,
0.0333811417,
0.0326515809,
-0.0082077701,
0.0428354405,
0.0216882154,
-0.0380768515,
-0.0211430825,
-0.018016059,
0.0453842022,
-0.0336823836,
0.031262517,
0.0222346857,
0.0107762618,
-0.0464717597,
-0.027260296,
0.0354482345,
-0.0565628223,
0.017813839,
-0.0137740066,
0.0268657524,
0.0610139817,
-0.0636605173,
0.0225121211,
0.0029969381,
-0.1140057594,
0.0149703175,
-0.0162645914,
0.0127211912,
0.0388204381,
0.0148821287,
-0.0017290307,
-0.0246741362,
-0.0833221674,
-0.0199317932,
0.0761075988,
-0.038616091,
-0.0403522067,
0.0635397434,
-0.0786962956,
-0.0056582997,
0.018084893,
-0.0049031959,
-0.0011706131,
-0.0408927128,
0.0101483762,
0.0128134452,
0.0418737903,
0.0204750225,
-0.0117587214,
-0.0311526489,
-0.0500991568,
0.0680276453,
-0.0040259613,
0.0374224149,
0.0407359265,
-0.0623192452,
0.0038572811,
0.0119834067,
-0.0579365641,
0.0041633202,
0.0286439583,
-0.0723654479,
-0.0296347849,
0.061219234,
-0.0281416271,
0.054252021,
0.0614437163,
0.0055485717,
-0.0936896279,
0.0505210161,
-0.0018571059,
0.017782066,
-0.0249088574,
0.0404686667,
0.0034719496,
-0.0150568802,
0.0150848692,
-0.0313234814,
0.0389115959,
-0.0299281403,
0.0632970557,
0.0293006413,
-0.0253545064,
-0.0498145409,
-0.0347666666,
0.0029712014,
-0.0298797619,
-0.0007388282,
-0.0306295101,
0.0216470249,
-0.0052902247,
-0.0238229204,
-0.051062759,
0.0409804992,
-0.0189984776,
-0.0375239886,
0.0199525747,
0.0345316455,
0.0081134355,
-0.0349701531,
-0.0462358408,
-0.021183446,
0.0143165654,
-0.0094592292,
-0.0216847453,
-0.0068248846,
0.001592968,
-0.0261043981,
0.0002111066,
0.02700698,
0.000763281,
-0.0457048081,
-0.0575056188,
0.0022438846,
0.0533037893,
0.0080448678,
0.0495057106,
0.0231482703,
-0.0068412642,
-0.0056105643,
0.0140625937,
0.0555607826,
-0.000656662,
-0.0023695175,
-0.0464244671,
-0.0077840583,
-0.0353228636,
-0.0198126733,
0.0083047962,
0.0312002469,
0.0304015055,
-0.024717873,
0.0228519104,
-0.0142528145,
0.0383460037,
0.047997307,
-0.0030908298,
-0.054410398,
-0.0146529023,
-0.0349774249,
-0.0187486261,
-0.0136571638,
-0.0278788209,
-0.0297420919,
0.0031698642,
-0.0221092869,
-0.013156672,
0.0112279505,
-0.0678151771,
-0.0717888996,
-0.0292504113,
-0.0492903143,
-0.0235627312,
-0.0142846592,
-0.0098600145,
0.0141218081,
0.0328040607,
-0.0112182833,
-0.0363878161,
0.0015265365,
-0.0163025074,
-0.054456722,
0.0346444808,
-0.024466075,
-0.0019529418,
-0.0312644467,
0.0048850281,
-0.018056225,
0.0030233371,
0.003354586,
0.0605863705,
-0.0054322979,
-0.0607796125,
0.015098487,
0.0392905772,
0.0093034543,
0.0683339909,
-0.0294484217,
0.0023517723,
-0.0364432968,
0.0544233769,
0.0573010221,
0.0316505581,
-0.0293930396,
0.0013567158,
0.0217449814,
0.0137216151,
0.0443422832,
0.0247404817,
-0.0558254011,
0.0169237666,
0.0435115099,
0.0145277241,
-0.0060699843,
0.0206008852,
0.0583215505,
-0.0311679468,
0.0229176637,
0.1136518046,
-0.0037967947,
-0.0349235572,
-0.0043536075,
-0.0180065371,
-0.0069267428,
0.0181065444,
-0.0182142314,
-0.0641899556,
-0.0191338658,
0.0490215905,
0.0613419749,
0.0105515178,
0.0342514403,
-0.0334862471,
-0.0750114247,
0.0660489053,
0.0270219054,
-0.0109223127,
-0.0256024431,
-0.0161827598,
0.0106794881,
-0.0279475134,
0.0433211736,
0.0159075819,
-0.0001559309,
-0.0122691421,
0.0157271605,
-0.0083466256,
-0.0445668027,
-0.0255638938,
-0.040455617,
0.116878517,
0.0804223716,
0.0240866486,
0.017767638,
-0.0003257699,
-0.0196678862,
0.0274406746,
-0.0118418578,
0.0071261874,
0.0547195859,
0.0108365212,
-0.0049647423,
0.0230757669,
0.0771578401,
-0.0166638512,
0.018254634,
0.018674925,
0.0193544943,
0.023963742,
0.0240283161,
-0.0230755098,
0.0327886157,
0.0150292516,
0.0587004498,
0.0115479631,
-0.0542281121,
-0.0028563193,
-0.0487084687,
0.0114788897,
-0.0916485935,
-0.0308264531,
-0.0017065658,
0.002512089,
-0.0543818697,
-0.0227684639,
-0.0136299757,
0.0310965627,
0.0383778475,
0.0032460303,
-0.0237008408,
0.0141268484,
-0.0078031044,
-0.0430467315,
-0.0179760233,
0.0072716046,
0.0286557786,
-0.045232106,
-0.0247563217,
0.0308057405,
-0.0443378165,
0.0233215448,
0.0204632096,
-0.0786309764,
-0.0570389591,
-0.0415809005,
0.018892074,
0.0172197651,
0.0601559207,
-0.0194459651,
-0.027243467,
0.0439280495,
-0.0023762735,
-0.0556713566,
0.0503024235,
0.0745933801,
-0.0120539563,
-0.0135248434,
0.020139968,
-0.0539821386,
0.0376770534,
-0.0080097681,
0.0301746354,
-0.036580123,
-0.0508237667,
-0.0018994041,
-0.012815576,
0.0092370575,
0.0149678336,
0.0433377884,
-0.0517314076,
0.0162251312,
-0.0427658968,
0.0513336584,
-0.065721266,
-0.0019923663,
0.0325175785,
-0.0015753248,
-0.0024649934,
0.0007244824,
-0.0612937249,
0.0264267139,
-0.0368579663,
0.0295900349,
-0.0058288663,
-0.0270482991,
0.0272615496,
-0.0052815862,
0.0138441371,
0.0276491344,
0.0254065618,
-0.0150630679,
0.0018939864,
0.0387268513,
-0.006082125,
0.0038235055,
0.0303902011,
0.0265250113,
-0.0396136753,
0.0119116204,
-0.0407174863,
0.0132304784,
0.016790675,
0.0074523538,
0.074998647,
0.0298089758,
0.0254098512,
0.0092740934,
0.0118998978,
-0.0076401383,
-0.0140956836,
0.0242908057,
-0.0152825434,
0.014584586,
-0.0017381909,
0.0607521906,
-0.0119467638,
0.023109993,
-0.0249216072,
0.0757962167,
-0.0359047465,
-0.0106609417,
-0.0208395012,
-0.0107381707,
-0.0101887938,
-0.0137232644,
0.0091226306,
-0.0308218263,
0.0251557976,
-0.0318202451,
-0.0068867877,
-0.072233066,
0.0338734761,
-0.0403561816,
-0.0263784826,
-0.0050867973,
0.0116674053,
-0.056567885,
0.0309156496,
-0.0342968442,
-0.0483835451,
-5.713927796e-33,
-0.0296380743,
0.0516438894,
0.0295463875,
0.0004330923,
-0.0266357791,
-0.0253750701,
-0.0339855775,
-0.0070195724,
-0.0163106509,
-0.0259083826,
-0.023562083,
0.0413843095,
0.0175680928,
0.0714693815,
-0.0160377435,
0.0366252996,
0.1173403636,
-0.0732366145,
0.0151319997,
0.0245185997,
0.031976793,
0.0377751067,
0.0111753838,
-0.0577726327,
-0.0170026086,
0.0027113219,
0.0043925713,
-0.0137850121,
0.0697434843,
-0.0041485219,
0.0151135214,
0.0465792716,
-0.0261650365,
-0.0776214227,
-0.0312460568,
0.0561106727,
-0.0619220361,
-0.0086326851,
-0.0210251063,
0.0305428728,
-0.0317209288,
-0.0460770242,
0.0333931409,
0.0358429514,
-0.0048862724,
-0.0252537653,
0.019954484,
-0.0377483815,
-0.0009020962,
-0.0615197606,
-0.0426685996,
0.0171211753,
-0.0289419964,
-0.0641747341,
0.0701710433,
0.0907370448,
-0.0193947833,
-0.0319072269,
-0.0746985972,
0.0621253885,
0.0134209478,
0.0491112433,
0.0325744338,
0.0412667617,
-0.0292754769,
0.0097562531,
0.0209883023,
-0.0480599999,
0.0023166058,
0.0181788206,
0.0117177488,
0.0562186912,
0.0320189707,
0.0107725831,
0.0303771403,
-0.0334151424,
-0.0119490661,
0.0099880798,
0.0203475971,
-0.0190898534,
0.0239386111,
0.0323241651,
0.0080736531,
-0.0075314716,
-0.0370435528,
-0.0346117206,
-0.0149155613,
-0.0276879407,
0.0369141772,
0.0061938702,
0.0038797958,
-0.042821195,
0.0590556562,
-0.0134754553,
0.0532300286,
0.030255273,
-0.0447779745,
0.014307241,
0.0005071373,
0.0076334164,
-0.0378843583,
0.000260362,
0.1045990437,
0.0413242467,
0.0056561353,
0.0139308292,
-0.0134794144,
0.0728629977,
-0.019596301,
-0.0202201325,
0.0042925621,
0.0837900415,
0.0264569074,
0.0615793131,
-0.0161946043,
0.0038319954,
-0.0098609757,
0.0292648133,
-0.0348528065,
-0.0008264944,
0.0156787895,
0.009115492,
0.0033965306,
0.0041870177,
-0.0617967099,
0.0326405726,
-0.0082942257,
0.0239821188,
0.0523977876,
-0.0418642201,
-0.0180353764,
0.0188894011,
2.687e-7,
-0.0457738526,
0.0004268444,
-0.0005350693,
-0.0094092805,
0.025935933,
0.0224203914,
-0.0146253835,
0.0088532912,
0.0112997843,
0.001877125,
-0.0220226813,
-0.0143888006,
0.0629312471,
0.0369333066,
-0.0630113855,
-0.0705002621,
-0.0589209273,
0.0214612335,
-0.0002960644,
-0.0080641164,
0.0347669199,
0.0791273192,
-0.0160866454,
-0.0445296504,
0.0283361878,
-0.0149861258,
0.0109247668,
0.0165003613,
-0.0090357745,
-0.0253497493,
-0.0026904931,
-0.0130639626,
-0.0405559354,
0.0001784658,
-0.0294801295,
0.0210171528,
0.0170532819,
0.0713462308,
-0.0154514685,
-0.0579262525,
0.0131469797,
0.0374459252,
-0.0390304253,
0.0260130931,
0.0685911924,
-0.0200435873,
-0.0004689125,
-0.0187564902,
-0.0521224178,
0.0769371241,
-0.0274235383,
-0.0569587052,
0.0147229349,
-0.0377951376,
0.0251115244,
0.0156046785,
-0.0130114025,
-0.0260593388,
-0.0200776309,
-0.0194028374,
-0.0362706482,
-0.0202433076,
-0.0451926142,
-0.0369482413,
0.0244653542,
-0.0273545291,
0.0011958926,
1.944278217e-34,
0.0056594433,
-0.0282016769,
0.0420547985,
-0.0195939466,
-0.0412857383,
0.001925664,
-0.0134262927,
0.0004549192,
-0.0015248738,
-0.0427898243,
-0.0759637058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13534v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13534v1 | Building Trust in Conversational AI: A Comprehensive Review and Solution Architecture for Explainable, Privacy-Aware Systems using LLMs and Knowledge Graph | 2023-08-13T22:47:51 | 2023-08-13T22:47:51 | Ahtsham Zafar, Venkatesh Balavadhani Parthasarathy, Chan Le Van, Saad Shahid, Aafaq Iqbal khan, Arsalan Shahid | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Conversational AI systems have emerged as key enablers of human-like
interactions across diverse sectors. Nevertheless, the balance between
linguistic nuance and factual accuracy has proven elusive. In this paper, we
first introduce LLMXplorer, a comprehensive tool that provides an in-depth
review of over 150 Large Language Models (LLMs), elucidating their myriad
implications ranging from social and ethical to regulatory, as well as their
applicability across industries. Building on this foundation, we propose a
novel functional architecture that seamlessly integrates the structured
dynamics of Knowledge Graphs with the linguistic capabilities of LLMs.
Validated using real-world AI news data, our architecture adeptly blends
linguistic sophistication with factual rigour and further strengthens data
security through Role-Based Access Control. This research provides insights
into the evolving landscape of conversational AI, emphasizing the imperative
for systems that are efficient, transparent, and trustworthy. | [
0.0851874873,
0.0801368803,
-0.0253018141,
0.0792941749,
-0.0285708085,
-0.0262247752,
0.0460032858,
-0.0051904288,
0.074778147,
-0.006308774,
-0.0201315489,
-0.0052708713,
-0.0036955338,
0.0911941454,
0.0027355689,
0.0033057977,
0.0192789938,
-0.0367642939,
0.0476393662,
-0.0188591983,
0.0116760451,
0.0523559898,
0.0042233435,
0.0368990079,
-0.0104999673,
-0.0018476199,
-0.0053987913,
-0.0134051796,
-0.0017324128,
-0.0053967964,
-0.0220773723,
0.0274022073,
0.0187964514,
0.0598656312,
0.000002088,
-0.0602287054,
-0.0236952957,
0.021241229,
-0.0680659637,
-0.0349232256,
0.0057692113,
-0.00683884,
0.0034142847,
0.0087117562,
-0.0552006699,
0.0386681221,
0.0502993613,
0.022845624,
0.0337083116,
0.0593330897,
-0.028240025,
-0.002003039,
0.0282519199,
-0.0182410982,
0.0069998438,
-0.0800483078,
0.0217476524,
-0.0010027877,
-0.0106536876,
0.0169717576,
0.0166456625,
0.040861737,
0.0157615039,
-0.0407395065,
0.0150957704,
0.0121224988,
0.0140493819,
-0.0513613671,
-0.0187034961,
0.0744347051,
0.0467801206,
-0.0210411157,
0.0203165691,
0.0115667814,
0.014625215,
0.035943415,
-0.0285516884,
0.0294183027,
-0.035843119,
-0.0014070641,
-0.006843254,
-0.0023484614,
0.0475424938,
0.0397365019,
-0.0006990753,
0.0945417508,
-0.0151566043,
-0.0062605334,
-0.0065727527,
-0.0426574387,
0.0404013544,
-0.0712721348,
0.0306126717,
0.0427592173,
-0.0441206433,
0.0574951209,
-0.0438814126,
0.0421514623,
0.015351899,
-0.0453315079,
-0.0391017906,
0.0044904482,
0.0176421627,
0.0548097156,
0.0370798744,
0.0534277149,
0.0195545945,
0.0214397311,
0.0174994189,
-0.0660265237,
-0.0364401639,
-0.0236031543,
0.0120202666,
0.0223815572,
-0.0447080433,
-0.0346602686,
-0.0259707235,
0.0641326755,
-0.0527555421,
0.0735520348,
0.0286580957,
0.0196427442,
0.0086439168,
-0.035055656,
-0.0448207296,
-0.0361256674,
-0.0030536323,
0.0291726291,
0.0033006424,
-0.0678532273,
0.0046845283,
-0.0006239574,
-0.0147511391,
0.0152432276,
-0.0363319106,
0.070076704,
0.0260049105,
-0.0388193168,
-0.011868502,
-0.0696887597,
0.0002153283,
-0.0352602601,
-0.0338847078,
-0.0446264409,
0.0610187277,
-0.0000671152,
-0.0019286812,
-0.0652056932,
0.0325613134,
0.0074109845,
-0.0551324748,
0.0673995763,
-0.0523612797,
0.0131621799,
-0.0175996572,
0.0611277893,
-0.0149992909,
0.0147592947,
0.0522111244,
0.0299207084,
0.0915891901,
0.0088042207,
0.039218422,
-0.0072014774,
0.0092902798,
-0.0184249338,
0.0375919193,
0.0277376715,
-0.0671112686,
-0.0222152062,
-0.0038377757,
0.0440534726,
-0.000901214,
-0.0315572023,
0.0974658653,
0.0874879882,
-0.0240333173,
0.0292784683,
-0.0086085992,
0.0391126797,
0.0148429899,
-0.0317755826,
-0.059088245,
0.0232639238,
-0.0385355912,
-0.0392790474,
-0.043556612,
0.0054765162,
-0.0157008991,
-0.0340041183,
0.0267247241,
-0.0543118753,
0.0508607328,
0.0386841819,
-0.0055917804,
0.0043662689,
-0.0131476186,
0.0146774966,
0.0094039282,
-0.0608811229,
-0.0162929017,
-0.0635397881,
0.0431032814,
0.1150967702,
0.0584650785,
0.0143570416,
-0.0083427783,
-0.0054381303,
-0.0204383098,
0.0524128266,
0.0021847894,
-0.0046315156,
0.0355545096,
-0.0453427918,
-0.0298221335,
0.000812211,
0.0094541339,
-0.0049356893,
-0.0015221993,
-0.015849961,
-0.0098120859,
-0.0363680162,
-0.0331678689,
-0.0052649975,
-0.0228710882,
0.0133453654,
-0.0095016332,
-0.0026813534,
0.0322402418,
0.0579554662,
0.0214160122,
-0.0004389559,
0.0224001128,
0.0214543436,
-0.0206856299,
0.0351177156,
-0.0209325552,
0.026166182,
0.0059821471,
-0.0101994835,
0.0151823219,
0.0196437463,
-0.0165626667,
-0.0380360037,
-0.0082928091,
-0.0245605595,
0.0702596307,
-0.0411729068,
0.0126428986,
-0.0243989211,
0.0147946337,
0.0025797859,
0.0088458555,
-0.0377655923,
-0.05261885,
-0.038658917,
0.0153457448,
-0.0173350777,
-0.0198946241,
0.0089251045,
0.0127569884,
0.0019078521,
0.0302854851,
0.0165540446,
-0.0191562921,
-0.0324494317,
-0.0026766213,
-0.0770385712,
-0.0134855118,
-0.0007698844,
0.0042583616,
0.0138682649,
0.0266013928,
0.0079048723,
-0.0147945881,
-0.0515302643,
0.0326315425,
0.0100096669,
-0.0071844314,
0.0319605768,
-0.0285453666,
-0.0618321784,
-0.0183502547,
0.0198744647,
0.0011591414,
0.0298999045,
0.0029574074,
-0.0193043742,
-0.0284493305,
0.046371527,
-0.0674301684,
0.0073054465,
-0.0313582458,
-0.0091962591,
0.0067657228,
0.055198513,
-0.0350489207,
0.0043471227,
0.0106478566,
0.0534507968,
0.009494707,
-0.0108129634,
-0.0473831221,
-0.0289941803,
0.0005038326,
-0.001483375,
-0.0693873912,
-0.0272145141,
0.0258389395,
-0.0045128665,
0.020653829,
0.0028889987,
-0.0334090814,
0.0395184718,
0.0192772169,
-0.0613636672,
0.0096902931,
-0.0727852806,
-0.0119200684,
0.05465905,
-0.0228108373,
-0.0465734415,
0.0689259395,
-0.0567022674,
0.0202039685,
0.0073927399,
-0.0543396771,
-0.0175901987,
0.0530667603,
-0.009191676,
0.0227351692,
0.0175599661,
-0.0378951766,
-0.0080092726,
-0.0362164564,
0.0123381205,
-0.0527054407,
0.0243417788,
-0.0351641923,
0.0035728444,
0.0685089678,
-0.0246631522,
-0.044044558,
-0.0086700944,
-0.0535308644,
0.0219974201,
0.0286295786,
-0.083183296,
-0.0013819071,
-0.0153540326,
0.0381295308,
0.0053937375,
0.0115316026,
-0.0093103545,
-0.0287326127,
-0.0129479524,
0.0375386924,
0.015169085,
0.0245768856,
0.0168888345,
0.0552066639,
0.061530333,
0.034858536,
-0.0265660565,
-0.0045290864,
-0.0531924367,
0.0038337975,
-0.0135297487,
0.0033268991,
0.0027912383,
0.0554933921,
-0.039165996,
0.0023498132,
0.1097973362,
0.0130159967,
-0.0593236089,
0.0134605281,
0.011822558,
-0.0074151182,
-0.0040836018,
0.0073222066,
-0.0955125466,
-0.0006235616,
0.0062544742,
0.0503024794,
-0.0246888585,
-0.0541843697,
-0.0297998302,
-0.0684086159,
0.0131674306,
-0.017211644,
-0.0068504862,
-0.0532419086,
-0.0659926161,
-0.0091607766,
-0.0027674122,
0.024799766,
-0.0299089663,
0.00510005,
-0.0235173535,
-0.0196698215,
-0.0468058139,
-0.0256780423,
0.0265962891,
-0.0464584418,
0.0779685602,
0.045849517,
0.0542885214,
0.0073550767,
-0.0271082968,
-0.0212712809,
0.0619869605,
-0.0230347924,
0.0055958889,
0.0334984623,
-0.0049649156,
0.016713202,
-0.0418880321,
0.0412790217,
-0.0280950535,
-0.0114385057,
0.0169192385,
0.0335189961,
-0.044879593,
-0.0092668002,
0.00460468,
-0.009935949,
0.0308702216,
0.096464783,
0.0243789833,
-0.007415209,
0.0018715132,
-0.0254622977,
0.0162449796,
-0.0194897708,
-0.012260939,
0.017648356,
-0.002813031,
-0.0232477747,
-0.0515764207,
-0.0306014307,
-0.026639035,
-0.0077882935,
0.0187909231,
-0.0064093471,
0.0872251689,
-0.023109965,
-0.0163963363,
-0.0104800276,
-0.0775470585,
0.0268782582,
-0.0013062439,
0.0181101207,
-0.0014238787,
-0.0413328558,
0.0119421426,
0.0262101013,
-0.0169321112,
-0.0408500582,
-0.0048964405,
0.0434341878,
0.0305276047,
0.0419811234,
-0.0348146111,
-0.050577458,
0.0532782003,
0.025119137,
-0.0646727756,
-0.0055213417,
0.0532021709,
0.0144669004,
0.0262466613,
0.0599192008,
-0.0590530373,
-0.0202634949,
-0.0057177432,
-0.0016907118,
-0.0476231687,
-0.0589747615,
0.0129625006,
0.0349684358,
-0.0099241147,
0.0486156009,
0.0343675129,
-0.0501384214,
0.0233145989,
-0.0462951586,
-0.0061486638,
-0.0480507463,
0.0211633537,
0.0100364555,
-0.0275156479,
0.0336599723,
-0.0403115526,
-0.0182044338,
0.0063034743,
-0.0094746733,
0.0196209922,
0.0051446133,
0.0198105648,
0.0040427842,
-0.006129202,
-0.0042310683,
0.07577537,
-0.0081846761,
0.0422003418,
0.0215155073,
0.0576876216,
-0.0079682004,
-0.0566608012,
-0.0120501537,
0.0402141474,
-0.0859680027,
-0.0876115188,
0.0414733551,
0.0243051685,
0.0115801208,
0.031089535,
0.0543972589,
-0.0525674522,
0.0160732586,
-0.0136239929,
0.03077076,
0.0168333836,
-0.0483386442,
-0.0117419949,
0.008399182,
-0.0378415585,
0.0215225946,
0.0639262348,
-0.0132383471,
0.0250338726,
-0.0252537783,
-0.0411931686,
-0.0363556258,
-0.0556539595,
0.0235910881,
0.0531353913,
-0.0337914564,
-0.0389866494,
-0.0513695143,
-0.0760194063,
-0.0101636406,
-0.0281301737,
-0.0000113015,
-0.0157953519,
0.0279601794,
0.0588590614,
0.0224920399,
-0.0252428483,
-0.0683144704,
-0.0173283163,
-0.028045468,
-0.0146600455,
-0.0010395655,
-5.647638364e-33,
0.0221580304,
-0.0748675689,
-0.0035869773,
0.0254267287,
0.0012797292,
0.0307920408,
-0.0494022928,
0.0043982887,
-0.049157735,
0.0189080276,
-0.0158425197,
0.0474505648,
0.0179613139,
0.0241760891,
-0.0441538543,
0.0057213991,
0.0404767208,
0.0117513584,
0.0237740912,
0.0631307587,
0.0647432506,
0.0033989355,
0.0266210381,
-0.1044313014,
0.0882619843,
0.0149492063,
-0.048340857,
0.0436744206,
-0.015144418,
0.0620745383,
-0.0071820864,
0.0621778555,
0.0097066229,
-0.0008133955,
0.0043093511,
0.0313290916,
-0.0481955111,
-0.0159331709,
0.0392139144,
-0.0079125063,
-0.0087357135,
-0.0212098192,
0.0178980641,
-0.0509553254,
-0.0061304867,
0.0429474227,
0.0032823388,
-0.0225844756,
-0.0161807854,
-0.0200332627,
-0.0179732963,
0.0055837194,
-0.0179477911,
-0.0141240945,
0.0222816207,
0.0040552765,
0.0224162545,
-0.01955745,
-0.0588721968,
0.0226220675,
-0.0299388263,
-0.048627913,
0.0596826263,
-0.012572255,
-0.0001521295,
0.0431844145,
0.0521271937,
0.0130247343,
-0.0469814688,
0.0000994668,
-0.0206575673,
0.0736491531,
0.0325114951,
0.0313675106,
-0.0696841851,
-0.0468754321,
-0.042677559,
-0.0051783323,
0.0296666659,
0.0208239518,
0.0273938961,
0.0152483974,
-0.0825151205,
-0.0030772963,
-0.0316748247,
-0.0147226788,
-0.0471134707,
-0.0100593204,
-0.0018618882,
-0.0151945613,
-0.0360813029,
0.0125328647,
-0.0135451164,
-0.0752798617,
-0.0105565069,
0.0539881513,
0.0498616323,
-0.0411739498,
0.0087391194,
0.0130863963,
-0.0391795374,
-0.000113119,
0.0082395822,
-0.0164014585,
0.011231008,
0.0205338225,
0.0163419377,
-0.0052650436,
-0.0136687923,
0.0031604704,
-0.0417332202,
0.0060955677,
-0.0056030215,
-0.0186507776,
0.0246542003,
0.0075891842,
-0.0205823965,
0.051116664,
0.0320989788,
0.0290337931,
-0.0251595397,
0.0096488968,
-0.0422144197,
0.0113405734,
-0.0325215086,
-0.041310817,
-0.0232520513,
-0.0109840725,
0.065693453,
-0.0111228302,
0.0029645164,
-0.0489811189,
2.783e-7,
-0.0030135801,
0.0200065468,
-0.0223754607,
0.0330655724,
0.0334459618,
0.0481629334,
0.0514596365,
0.0492234379,
-0.0368392542,
-0.0417196527,
0.0102530131,
0.0318783708,
0.0411278568,
0.0458155423,
-0.0176034328,
-0.0236406792,
-0.0465353802,
-0.0466884486,
-0.0650805607,
0.0328566767,
0.0402699932,
0.0446053147,
0.0580373555,
-0.0174334738,
-0.0206503291,
-0.0427606292,
-0.0115512135,
-0.039750278,
-0.0076909363,
-0.0048368163,
0.0686247125,
0.0268275756,
0.0206749309,
0.0128963161,
-0.0123417173,
0.040006496,
-0.0609698743,
0.0592461899,
-0.0042265723,
-0.0187443644,
0.0033213706,
-0.057328891,
0.0121846264,
-0.0710929632,
0.0441422909,
-0.0129758567,
-0.0591538846,
-0.0168972649,
0.0029592635,
-0.04825598,
-0.0090576829,
-0.0149183227,
0.0018920846,
0.0131756607,
-0.0109316753,
-0.0039494606,
0.0174435992,
-0.0468430966,
0.0066449875,
-0.0528893024,
-0.0144932708,
-0.0359151699,
-0.0146575421,
-0.0154752666,
0.0030168761,
-0.0322982967,
0.0621253997,
2.310331291e-34,
-0.0010174745,
0.0100513278,
-0.0306661427,
0.0338865444,
0.075680241,
0.0272850953,
0.008567282,
0.0217789132,
0.0502514429,
-0.0540435612,
-0.0124374926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06834v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06834v1 | Diagnostic Reasoning Prompts Reveal the Potential for Large Language Model Interpretability in Medicine | 2023-08-13T19:04:07 | 2023-08-13T19:04:07 | Thomas Savage, Ashwin Nayak, Robert Gallo, Ekanath Rangan, Jonathan H Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | One of the major barriers to using large language models (LLMs) in medicine
is the perception they use uninterpretable methods to make clinical decisions
that are inherently different from the cognitive processes of clinicians. In
this manuscript we develop novel diagnostic reasoning prompts to study whether
LLMs can perform clinical reasoning to accurately form a diagnosis. We find
that GPT4 can be prompted to mimic the common clinical reasoning processes of
clinicians without sacrificing diagnostic accuracy. This is significant because
an LLM that can use clinical reasoning to provide an interpretable rationale
offers physicians a means to evaluate whether LLMs can be trusted for patient
care. Novel prompting methods have the potential to expose the black box of
LLMs, bringing them one step closer to safe and effective use in medicine. | [
0.0416425169,
0.0360286459,
0.0109650092,
-0.0047366666,
-0.0241395626,
0.0295200162,
0.0357801095,
0.0602785684,
0.0313996971,
0.0227408186,
0.0316963717,
-0.0465896167,
0.0049129543,
0.0255396087,
0.0117162904,
-0.0187908281,
0.0032203267,
-0.0250373259,
0.074138239,
-0.0097484421,
-0.0208945815,
0.0231656265,
-0.0252902061,
0.0330891758,
0.0413242392,
-0.0577683449,
0.0289970487,
-0.0342289321,
-0.0000872592,
-0.0759267136,
-0.0645624548,
0.0178500433,
0.0006377747,
-0.0026711086,
0.00000197,
-0.0748217106,
0.002091727,
0.0134742847,
-0.0675186738,
-0.0294152647,
0.0071799359,
-0.0307657905,
0.0199291278,
0.0245727953,
-0.019399032,
-0.0309057161,
0.0396141224,
0.0431636758,
0.0164122283,
0.0510822423,
-0.0097940303,
-0.0162036754,
0.0131035065,
-0.0214364827,
0.0404451638,
-0.0398797207,
0.0540753938,
0.032968659,
0.0778913349,
0.0140452906,
0.0072561624,
0.0177468006,
0.0207524449,
0.0075707524,
-0.0482061021,
0.0261073336,
0.0319135487,
-0.0481777079,
0.0215130933,
0.0229080357,
0.0345003717,
-0.0098538762,
0.0117491446,
0.0036437924,
-0.0071112085,
0.0179001354,
-0.0324945897,
0.007996981,
-0.0196329337,
0.0191330817,
0.0494508594,
-0.0035590592,
0.0558189452,
-0.0200476516,
-0.0388357788,
0.0474437997,
-0.0043594181,
0.0036516588,
-0.0002327792,
-0.0195877533,
-0.0322410502,
-0.0315678157,
0.0069930963,
0.0417998843,
-0.0597589128,
0.0181838982,
0.0305242576,
0.0433234684,
0.0867468044,
-0.0204082038,
0.0020228133,
0.0100846859,
0.0058616954,
0.0229585618,
-0.0255973879,
0.0071166847,
-0.0642066076,
0.0373608693,
-0.0448926054,
0.0261850934,
-0.0455862992,
-0.0500516854,
-0.0057169944,
-0.0155879008,
0.0120271547,
-0.0079649249,
-0.0781546384,
0.0088991616,
-0.0329462364,
0.0216150004,
-0.0049113105,
0.0097987857,
0.0095750792,
-0.0162849799,
-0.0487392955,
0.0122750746,
-0.0044942289,
0.0187276695,
0.0039186981,
-0.0314033367,
0.0034827485,
0.004301975,
-0.0126325851,
-0.0035386984,
0.0174456798,
0.0729701295,
-0.0014215873,
0.0175210293,
-0.000545189,
-0.0633674115,
-0.0583106317,
-0.0449370779,
0.0184557345,
-0.0478557348,
-0.0073088729,
0.0451108404,
0.0151559729,
-0.0505285822,
0.0061901198,
-0.0056051421,
-0.0445038229,
0.0636397004,
-0.0599050485,
0.0094357934,
-0.0302823335,
0.0403925218,
-0.013926371,
0.0032900008,
-0.0024632926,
-0.0493695475,
-0.0028427334,
-0.0339484327,
0.0294109005,
-0.0157732032,
0.0066732741,
0.0009918226,
-0.0127135599,
-0.0033446164,
0.0039194277,
0.0638724416,
-0.0540324301,
0.0448224582,
0.0102766985,
0.0374123417,
0.0388298109,
0.0605886988,
0.0214320142,
0.009608184,
0.0307949148,
-0.0579499677,
-0.0309015252,
0.027225716,
-0.0137179,
-0.0068268622,
-0.0350982137,
0.0004360434,
-0.022326421,
-0.0241245404,
-0.0127425538,
-0.0300627016,
-0.0709051639,
-0.0084003033,
-0.0055815349,
0.0149906399,
0.01624153,
-0.0395872146,
0.0047613941,
0.0405510925,
0.0241613034,
-0.0195491016,
-0.0377712436,
-0.0971154273,
0.0380503312,
0.0889437497,
0.0098692831,
-0.0087925736,
0.002460106,
-0.023779884,
0.0201717187,
-0.0048481715,
0.0262195207,
0.0040024659,
-0.0094827376,
-0.0282257926,
0.0069244117,
0.0244821776,
0.0302605461,
-0.022289075,
-0.051708933,
0.031535022,
-0.0252506752,
-0.0380193703,
-0.0010816907,
0.0179626327,
-0.0334505998,
-0.0399676003,
-0.0101798708,
0.0043267929,
0.012214548,
0.0126737114,
0.0241750032,
0.0430720933,
0.0227888878,
-0.0329429321,
-0.0098488089,
0.0351468623,
-0.0467478074,
-0.0066531328,
-0.0099053225,
0.0047691944,
-0.0214908272,
-0.045171544,
-0.0420309529,
-0.0379450433,
-0.0203334093,
-0.0409417823,
0.0483582653,
0.0088595524,
0.0081482409,
0.0183400903,
-0.0040202374,
-0.0342136584,
0.0194701236,
0.0202630628,
0.0187882781,
0.0279126279,
-0.0046473499,
0.0099444343,
-0.032878641,
-0.03550978,
0.0594595782,
0.0256094746,
-0.0057518813,
-0.0250782315,
0.0109419329,
-0.0237363223,
-0.0097286701,
-0.0795931071,
-0.0324887596,
0.0280542485,
-0.0011945782,
0.0253186747,
0.0054442077,
0.0025575683,
0.0087482231,
-0.024437014,
-0.0140678398,
0.0472930446,
0.0463844389,
0.0313483514,
0.0184625369,
-0.0335249193,
0.0259869155,
-0.0243370254,
-0.0651635528,
0.0536788665,
0.0093099102,
0.0347811654,
-0.0391082428,
-0.0099603999,
-0.0272407327,
-0.007200765,
0.0073263845,
-0.0124775609,
0.0438568182,
-0.0330681577,
-0.0322009958,
0.0643422082,
-0.0427696109,
0.0284862407,
0.0391569026,
0.0025059215,
-0.0212817639,
-0.0079801753,
-0.032665018,
-0.0477142669,
0.0123378485,
-0.0740391985,
-0.0261426046,
0.0784263611,
0.0187706426,
0.001098003,
-0.0573628396,
0.0349662229,
-0.0210323986,
0.0113548031,
-0.0377910659,
-0.0304943919,
-0.0348420367,
0.0827297196,
0.0218017939,
-0.0289128795,
0.1080949679,
-0.0118517419,
0.0133428369,
-0.0538187623,
-0.0092583327,
-0.0205629952,
0.0309521966,
-0.0292808115,
0.0158877838,
0.0496112444,
0.0010467088,
0.0393554233,
-0.0372530408,
-0.0001851698,
-0.0432913117,
0.087175183,
-0.065968439,
0.0195307508,
0.023666298,
-0.0371419676,
-0.0253049918,
0.0311705768,
-0.0436369181,
-0.0089633456,
-0.004128872,
0.0192447659,
-0.0256086364,
0.0404566452,
0.0044081421,
0.0368408114,
-0.0006512123,
-0.0176743232,
-0.0047893492,
-0.0570157878,
-0.014557438,
0.0046460633,
0.0149968555,
-0.0376076624,
0.0686657205,
0.0443040952,
-0.0157901049,
0.0110362712,
-0.0274298973,
0.0538015477,
0.0036859077,
0.0076589375,
-0.0308574922,
0.0317275301,
0.0365741923,
-0.0476204567,
-0.0139219966,
0.1133343801,
0.0175999105,
-0.0459533744,
0.0265023559,
-0.0398396775,
-0.0386607312,
-0.0306680761,
-0.0049037533,
-0.075553596,
-0.0407866649,
-0.0117940251,
0.03026025,
-0.043571353,
-0.0047826017,
-0.0025153086,
-0.0031883765,
0.0561719835,
0.0237153582,
-0.0049241683,
-0.008740711,
-0.0537602007,
-0.0042904797,
-0.0061904821,
0.023096364,
0.0071021034,
0.0101381512,
0.0121274535,
-0.0078353686,
-0.0756018236,
-0.0666323677,
0.0722522587,
0.0329761468,
0.0456297621,
0.0428474918,
0.0251772329,
-0.0085408324,
-0.0688296407,
-0.0212540645,
0.0032177377,
0.027551474,
-0.0188027937,
0.0289296135,
0.0632302091,
-0.0047938209,
-0.0705435053,
0.0357523821,
-0.0476886518,
-0.0340420231,
-0.0137983002,
0.1188334003,
-0.0633147657,
-0.0602993332,
-0.0167293753,
0.0332076959,
0.0280263666,
0.0554274581,
0.0208922252,
-0.0083948318,
-0.0267901532,
0.0147096282,
0.0170211084,
0.0233457964,
-0.0430235714,
0.0231707636,
0.0305383615,
-0.0177575983,
-0.013915862,
-0.007463722,
0.0331686772,
0.0119375,
0.0218036734,
0.030032495,
-0.0211222973,
-0.0036359583,
-0.0140569918,
0.0738695934,
0.0626216754,
0.0271334331,
-0.0487975664,
0.0086291889,
0.046457421,
-0.0118975909,
-0.0195242539,
0.0060976651,
0.0472932979,
-0.0001896313,
0.0034863697,
0.0094140405,
0.0402826481,
-0.031979017,
-0.0141026322,
-0.0184208937,
0.0000642621,
0.0021144699,
-0.0091832699,
-0.0155029912,
-0.0039341599,
0.0281805489,
0.0143621238,
0.0122315018,
-0.0183393378,
0.0285139773,
-0.003633762,
0.0184247643,
-0.026658006,
0.0000437638,
0.073367767,
0.0489121079,
0.0387932584,
-0.0023871763,
-0.0098890588,
-0.0101340571,
0.0017679293,
-0.0299500618,
0.0054889377,
0.0039494797,
0.0210650638,
0.0262769517,
-0.0243998095,
-0.0158068016,
-0.0672390535,
-0.0704595447,
-0.063184686,
-0.0193985216,
0.0691565052,
0.0028677646,
-0.0033063665,
0.0590855591,
-0.009927161,
-0.0016900611,
0.0257051289,
-0.047869429,
0.0362233557,
0.0034008278,
0.1070288345,
0.0070452634,
0.0287044439,
-0.0084289871,
0.0334195942,
-0.0464760773,
-0.1164704934,
0.047236558,
0.0105017284,
0.0145198107,
-0.0199846998,
0.0389145501,
-0.0418091714,
0.0239360984,
-0.0139634777,
0.0104077738,
0.0298765097,
-0.0002602681,
0.0450252369,
0.0098143173,
-0.0054140883,
-0.0633180812,
0.048273392,
-0.0498890541,
0.0186838582,
-0.0439528972,
-0.0474001169,
-0.0296092276,
-0.0471828505,
0.0103742257,
0.0081352219,
-0.0566714928,
0.0016529487,
-0.0904427171,
-0.0351197273,
-0.0266479701,
-0.0135715315,
-0.0341234282,
-0.0248189252,
0.0066938144,
0.0803280994,
0.0043310174,
-0.0626094341,
-0.0112446109,
0.0580282845,
-0.0256351288,
0.0102592371,
-0.0133003145,
-5.674349269e-33,
0.0265115723,
-0.0181787461,
-0.0003292569,
-0.0414891019,
0.0331496932,
0.0204519443,
-0.0686272159,
0.0292960387,
-0.0004417042,
0.0750374645,
-0.028578857,
-0.005276802,
0.011914229,
0.0286873765,
0.0199157521,
-0.0317874178,
0.0129274335,
0.0483461916,
-0.0182858668,
0.0220939573,
0.0269921217,
-0.011101448,
0.0147914952,
-0.0685829893,
0.0495540015,
0.00099893,
0.0260107536,
0.0128436852,
-0.0775342137,
0.0547770672,
-0.0014300694,
0.0257928409,
0.0380070619,
-0.0210319385,
-0.0020467013,
0.0248399489,
0.002093754,
-0.0189346708,
0.0528067797,
-0.0458644852,
-0.0652072504,
-0.0392172821,
0.0400772952,
-0.0152238989,
-0.0143516697,
0.0120324846,
-0.0109130638,
-0.0549782552,
0.020736726,
-0.0037392715,
-0.0104952734,
0.0212471187,
-0.0157911293,
0.0142410025,
-0.0137664098,
0.0000886567,
-0.0586900637,
0.0057208464,
-0.0043292767,
0.0086544622,
0.0461847372,
-0.0197128858,
0.0251876414,
-0.0183020458,
-0.032136403,
0.0600237101,
0.0018291073,
-0.0079711387,
-0.0538442768,
0.0022280116,
-0.0551338419,
0.0413949825,
0.0775803924,
0.006164846,
-0.0061919368,
-0.0140127791,
-0.0846458226,
-0.0093594221,
-0.0607786737,
0.0463062152,
0.0772031024,
-0.0275395922,
-0.0730995312,
-0.0543791242,
-0.0307221022,
0.0001273506,
-0.0521690995,
-0.0534027368,
0.0191126838,
-0.0495809354,
0.0023910811,
0.0054545626,
0.030815579,
-0.0021344945,
0.0095320996,
-0.0351225361,
0.0382508226,
-0.0068411385,
-0.0379979797,
0.0033854085,
-0.0242564604,
-0.0132430159,
0.0041796616,
-0.0057974854,
0.0426502898,
0.025175048,
-0.006964901,
-0.0359778367,
-0.0393274575,
0.0097474121,
-0.0333380401,
-0.0016734252,
-0.0051252963,
-0.004834543,
0.0470726937,
0.03503545,
-0.0018473177,
0.0477930307,
0.009923026,
-0.0470709354,
-0.0472550727,
0.008929858,
-0.0493256487,
0.017062258,
-0.0491452254,
-0.0276763998,
-0.0141562913,
0.0661079064,
0.0550886802,
-0.0415567234,
-0.0062442524,
-0.0066712061,
2.753e-7,
0.0862115547,
0.0372832306,
-0.0158019792,
-0.0089038964,
0.0522594526,
0.0362922549,
-0.0241947584,
-0.002796632,
0.0293557905,
-0.0560576469,
0.0271501262,
0.0165397041,
0.0240603779,
0.0346136875,
-0.0120890476,
0.0022035274,
-0.0531929731,
-0.0369866714,
-0.0287314337,
0.0047945115,
0.0891616046,
0.0285131484,
-0.0177966002,
-0.0390213542,
0.0580603331,
-0.0294249915,
0.0094710989,
-0.0527939871,
0.0420745797,
0.0213738456,
0.0211011469,
-0.0272834189,
0.0447952822,
0.1079605147,
0.0055087623,
-0.0533768758,
-0.0435429774,
0.0960797817,
-0.0603839755,
0.0163620133,
-0.0151184229,
-0.0230874494,
0.0383714549,
-0.0747202113,
0.0511719659,
-0.0476159751,
-0.0663975328,
0.0353762172,
0.0286356173,
-0.069580771,
0.0584978797,
-0.0162352882,
-0.0258229543,
0.041565042,
-0.0147789326,
0.0423632823,
-0.0107382527,
-0.0438986905,
0.0000136421,
0.027819233,
-0.0356469415,
-0.0374790467,
0.0177623313,
-0.0075084907,
0.0269437619,
-0.0896677598,
-0.0095495721,
2.535891667e-34,
0.03654024,
0.0366951749,
0.023188496,
-0.0093472172,
0.0497573726,
0.0155621739,
0.0411917791,
0.0318345018,
0.0458069108,
-0.0825865343,
-0.0137396026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06828v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06828v3 | An Ensemble Approach to Question Classification: Integrating Electra Transformer, GloVe, and LSTM | 2023-08-13T18:14:10 | 2023-10-29T21:07:54 | Sanad Aburass, Osama Dorgham, Maha Abu Rumman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Natural Language Processing (NLP) has emerged as a crucial technology for
understanding and generating human language, playing an essential role in tasks
such as machine translation, sentiment analysis, and more pertinently, question
classification. As a subfield within NLP, question classification focuses on
determining the type of information being sought, a fundamental step for
downstream applications like question answering systems. This study presents an
innovative ensemble approach for question classification, combining the
strengths of Electra, GloVe, and LSTM models. Rigorously tested on the
well-regarded TREC dataset, the model demonstrates how the integration of these
disparate technologies can lead to superior results. Electra brings in its
transformer-based capabilities for complex language understanding, GloVe offers
global vector representations for capturing word-level semantics, and LSTM
contributes its sequence learning abilities to model long-term dependencies. By
fusing these elements strategically, our ensemble model delivers a robust and
efficient solution for the complex task of question classification. Through
rigorous comparisons with well-known models like BERT, RoBERTa, and DistilBERT,
the ensemble approach verifies its effectiveness by attaining an 80% accuracy
score on the test dataset. | [
0.0496139191,
0.0385120399,
-0.0124314344,
0.045904126,
-0.0195266325,
0.0376129299,
0.0031187427,
-0.0247677788,
0.0056090853,
-0.0629649311,
-0.0123989414,
-0.0589895323,
-0.0124641228,
0.0233304482,
0.0003618585,
-0.051207602,
0.0346580595,
0.0204178169,
-0.0595828183,
0.0248324163,
0.0045796307,
0.010374249,
-0.0004475662,
0.0603025258,
0.0562046692,
-0.0087976325,
-0.0269360952,
0.0065395664,
0.0156498123,
-0.0234347172,
0.0530968495,
0.0628642663,
0.0376844704,
0.0390990376,
0.0000017357,
-0.0467934571,
-0.030575579,
-0.030361725,
-0.023139691,
-0.0496330522,
0.0011402934,
0.0378861986,
0.056841772,
0.0438854918,
-0.0682357028,
-0.0292919427,
0.0093054287,
0.0697340295,
0.0638780966,
0.0584108941,
0.0069213528,
0.0093566449,
0.0354126692,
-0.0038859069,
-0.0039788289,
0.0141477026,
0.0067895027,
-0.0710194781,
0.0263322666,
0.0104836095,
0.0027730165,
0.0428183973,
0.0526415221,
-0.0149216084,
0.0246649254,
-0.0081557557,
-0.0341132656,
0.0115735633,
-0.0143883433,
0.0715826452,
-0.0011797829,
-0.0146234455,
-0.0127168745,
0.0310306139,
0.0202707034,
0.0257318839,
-0.0223902147,
-0.0193183199,
-0.0323120654,
-0.0296795405,
-0.0036485638,
0.0193623677,
0.0003585017,
0.0173840225,
-0.0264550969,
0.0523910932,
0.0194283761,
-0.0415645353,
0.0003355029,
0.0112919034,
-0.007879016,
-0.069421567,
0.0502019487,
0.0411935374,
-0.0074836644,
0.0007503903,
0.0025836569,
-0.0444322601,
0.0238978099,
0.0149241965,
0.0001262301,
0.0233841464,
-0.007687577,
0.0464471094,
-0.009160419,
0.0238768496,
-0.018688539,
0.0050287447,
-0.037295565,
-0.0064176563,
-0.0791012719,
-0.0304382425,
-0.0183155108,
0.0482446849,
-0.0323248245,
-0.0054674633,
-0.031598527,
0.0485866405,
0.0386166275,
-0.0285337288,
0.0271878056,
0.0327638015,
0.00307588,
0.0200136006,
-0.0432815924,
0.0417507589,
-0.043834541,
0.0382267535,
0.0048945677,
-0.0436840206,
-0.0147289606,
0.0149198016,
0.0135904197,
-0.0380096957,
0.0117609873,
-0.0113770775,
0.0037940575,
-0.0788952038,
0.0163111091,
-0.0133886477,
0.0032433937,
-0.0253573526,
-0.0038753678,
-0.039842926,
0.0076308991,
0.0058239046,
-0.0165286791,
0.0092482381,
0.0006524785,
0.0241243616,
0.024770584,
0.0819104537,
0.0044828942,
-0.0542455129,
0.0729634166,
0.0204935186,
0.022614859,
0.0254235379,
0.0120024979,
0.020873405,
0.0342494808,
-0.0134598669,
0.0664058477,
0.0035361599,
-0.0057908916,
-0.0223771669,
-0.0046010176,
0.0621085279,
-0.023144966,
0.0204200391,
-0.0376088992,
0.0236813314,
-0.0018370013,
-0.0195997227,
0.0592573211,
0.0332278199,
-0.0058931843,
0.0313507393,
0.0172432195,
-0.0176667124,
0.0038458291,
-0.0150796585,
-0.0245752223,
0.0227986537,
-0.032734476,
-0.0062087504,
-0.0066468986,
0.0269336049,
-0.0410337299,
-0.0556675419,
-0.0068066148,
-0.0113800252,
-0.0069639091,
0.0347531661,
0.0306779239,
-0.0044392063,
-0.0528618768,
0.0587240085,
-0.0186083894,
-0.0428741686,
-0.0149933798,
-0.061249394,
0.0494366139,
0.017693758,
0.0213478878,
-0.057490956,
-0.0765560567,
-0.0563273281,
-0.0162043516,
0.0551463217,
0.0249653198,
-0.0075783832,
-0.0032499263,
-0.0484187715,
-0.0323553793,
0.0131496796,
-0.0180798881,
0.0165812988,
-0.0018111354,
0.0382229984,
0.0070191855,
-0.040998362,
0.0169952828,
0.0408129133,
-0.0081128599,
-0.0392204933,
0.0322081782,
0.0218174458,
0.038656868,
0.0079070767,
0.005005145,
0.0029204707,
0.0486168899,
-0.0476578176,
-0.099158518,
0.0018450612,
-0.0591983609,
-0.1124639362,
0.0039166599,
-0.0003157952,
-0.0238590054,
0.061778985,
-0.0430778079,
-0.0416743979,
-0.0165650565,
-0.0388946421,
-0.0221267007,
-0.0628981739,
0.0180857684,
0.0160781853,
0.0427459776,
-0.0631219223,
0.0335174426,
-0.0147508066,
-0.0000330107,
-0.0385949276,
-0.0048754308,
0.0305661056,
-0.0397477001,
-0.0208553765,
0.0106789134,
0.0096653486,
0.0095688319,
0.0391283184,
-0.0036050815,
-0.0548953377,
-0.0348164886,
-0.1052389741,
0.0336011164,
-0.0097889621,
0.048996754,
0.004606619,
0.0319087952,
-0.0045369323,
-0.0238079205,
-0.0539595857,
-0.0353609286,
0.0135142487,
0.0123316692,
0.0460034087,
-0.003581167,
-0.037599586,
-0.0140370773,
0.0005909388,
-0.032478489,
0.0611338839,
-0.0027856517,
0.0026501343,
-0.0316365957,
-0.0670249164,
-0.0306892116,
0.0185894854,
0.0151052959,
-0.012985358,
-0.0238498747,
-0.0335606188,
-0.0088813324,
0.0380275287,
0.0327434056,
0.0101165101,
-0.0090769418,
0.0396740064,
-0.0431198701,
0.0426112562,
-0.028998008,
0.0409778245,
0.0069139241,
0.0062028007,
0.0273885466,
0.0742506385,
0.0004921915,
-0.0110110687,
-0.0190924332,
0.0058588334,
-0.0090612127,
0.0037982278,
-0.0371443257,
-0.007501943,
-0.0059298174,
0.0052536926,
-0.0111691058,
-0.0248218477,
0.0968175605,
0.0089010987,
-0.0280527752,
-0.1132802218,
-0.0370943882,
-0.0855102614,
0.0706452429,
-0.0010664938,
-0.007559387,
0.0176958404,
-0.0248352531,
-0.0294431057,
-0.0502619334,
-0.0124166524,
-0.0180150419,
0.0358111858,
-0.0308662448,
0.0136567615,
-0.0064761755,
-0.04481088,
-0.0374068357,
-0.069628723,
-0.0255884305,
0.0050647012,
-0.022285467,
-0.0054294802,
-0.0446331613,
0.0230686143,
0.0109140286,
0.0434939899,
-0.044948671,
-0.0303821713,
0.0003962087,
0.114968352,
0.0640276968,
0.0336463153,
0.0216157548,
-0.010477135,
0.0739126801,
0.0422707684,
0.0205596667,
0.0104284501,
-0.0447741039,
0.0116228899,
0.0302849151,
-0.0671494827,
-0.0075418833,
-0.0041995696,
0.0381329916,
-0.0723940283,
-0.025354825,
0.1326316893,
0.0398173593,
-0.0272061843,
-0.041109141,
0.0089715207,
-0.0015887151,
0.0223271139,
0.0476926491,
-0.0283379592,
-0.0429252014,
-0.0407094583,
0.0177700073,
-0.0200029891,
-0.0259614903,
0.01283067,
-0.0791783109,
0.0046084281,
-0.0476804487,
-0.06991373,
0.0030362993,
-0.0524773076,
-0.003456214,
0.0319582038,
0.0166058168,
-0.0056105098,
-0.0151616214,
0.0002364492,
0.0353648067,
-0.0434099287,
-0.00042443,
0.0371572971,
-0.0340697132,
-0.0215478223,
0.054950837,
0.0244849753,
-0.0291530006,
-0.0022732271,
0.0093774395,
-0.066661559,
0.0048084701,
-0.0198767912,
0.0430350713,
0.0018667411,
-0.0031119434,
-0.0132606272,
0.0220365189,
-0.0762035549,
0.0416198075,
0.0314559042,
0.0635710359,
-0.0362011157,
-0.0127228256,
-0.0279383343,
-0.0325482637,
0.0141751971,
0.0420044996,
0.0330326296,
-0.0457767695,
-0.0329966806,
-0.004094251,
-0.050026942,
-0.0362443142,
0.0064506684,
0.0029574833,
0.0288307536,
-0.017308848,
-0.0635674521,
-0.0765837952,
0.0450536534,
0.0253665783,
-0.0229423884,
0.0234713238,
0.0138661666,
0.0326411389,
-0.0613238253,
0.0314970873,
0.0103953639,
0.0076812608,
-0.0391168594,
0.0149804763,
0.0316269286,
-0.0354795605,
-0.0389124714,
-0.0050843349,
-0.0470029265,
-0.0188038219,
-0.0060531385,
0.0491625108,
0.018026216,
-0.0229367781,
-0.0019578161,
-0.0386052057,
0.0485294051,
0.0428920463,
0.0126504339,
0.0005628323,
-0.0029594863,
-0.0001084447,
-0.0239026956,
0.032339789,
-0.01931528,
0.0225411337,
0.0097388299,
0.019111881,
-0.0470477752,
-0.0570385233,
0.0211602822,
-0.0174890272,
0.0293058828,
0.0302775092,
-0.0199527908,
-0.0119686816,
0.0313585512,
0.0402787589,
0.0052609681,
-0.0289240368,
-0.0047328062,
0.0288283564,
-0.0346109457,
-0.0299313031,
0.0208420157,
-0.0266769025,
0.0102322875,
-0.04593293,
0.0236062929,
0.0415879227,
0.0310921557,
-0.00691556,
0.0107335271,
-0.04432429,
-0.0156692676,
0.0346975625,
0.0483876579,
0.0176445358,
0.0683300644,
0.0055376296,
0.0075605796,
-0.0060749636,
0.0577804819,
-0.0831997544,
-0.0350489505,
-0.0046777502,
0.03703418,
0.0205517877,
0.0042494661,
-0.0084756929,
0.0265267678,
-0.021845255,
0.0019259835,
0.0213099457,
0.0225594509,
0.0145311253,
0.0555285253,
0.0226264205,
-0.0200119987,
0.0108171273,
0.0171935447,
-0.0300065521,
0.0411059298,
0.0701848269,
-0.0225514323,
-0.0660728216,
0.0368800312,
0.046328105,
-0.0262162071,
-0.0044732736,
0.0425460115,
-0.0251811128,
-0.0389491878,
0.0567994379,
-0.0367879793,
0.0045120027,
-0.0131382924,
0.0613921955,
0.0263290573,
0.0281572249,
-0.000968476,
-0.029165253,
0.0482091755,
-0.0424886681,
-0.0229552966,
-0.0379310921,
-5.900265692e-33,
-0.0025527256,
-0.0184446685,
0.0092012854,
-0.0212025624,
0.0031334234,
0.0072756344,
-0.0356703773,
-0.0138421981,
-0.0350949951,
-0.0073588677,
-0.0115452902,
0.0274158549,
-0.0059069009,
0.0490988083,
0.0245645009,
-0.0590288006,
0.0294139292,
0.0202245321,
-0.0174658764,
0.0183034558,
0.0367171429,
0.0720554739,
0.0665415898,
-0.0461416058,
0.0164740793,
-0.0455775596,
0.0099080186,
0.0367945172,
0.0031224506,
0.0729191601,
-0.0228492301,
0.0431299806,
0.0383173488,
-0.0912917182,
0.0467440747,
0.0504891947,
-0.064990811,
-0.0647210777,
-0.0464203693,
-0.0011199506,
-0.0452159196,
-0.0056685312,
0.0207837019,
0.0150706396,
0.0355128869,
-0.0050053475,
0.0519200787,
-0.0053899414,
-0.0032074507,
-0.0890914351,
-0.0075958935,
0.006381759,
-0.0138338227,
-0.0645417273,
-0.0422901958,
0.0419374071,
0.0003445657,
0.0390374586,
-0.0278868694,
-0.0348611996,
0.0018644426,
0.0209537521,
0.0143043157,
0.0067552668,
-0.0489051528,
0.0214820374,
-0.0033383674,
-0.0170532316,
-0.0113710081,
-0.0241861586,
-0.0350031964,
-0.0019565341,
0.0580621064,
0.0160014853,
0.037475761,
0.0569023825,
-0.064741075,
0.0547155663,
0.0844003633,
0.0450678617,
-0.0248986185,
-0.0242354181,
-0.0327638164,
0.0266355723,
-0.02181229,
0.0228144769,
-0.0403431915,
0.0144671341,
0.0442850962,
0.0007670288,
-0.0228523314,
0.0252908226,
0.0151972594,
-0.017544562,
-0.0035766654,
-0.0036337948,
0.0322687142,
-0.0101371128,
0.0402520001,
0.0371855833,
0.0057315668,
0.0084249731,
0.0014794657,
-0.0057225963,
-0.0101513192,
-0.0031537076,
0.0067927297,
0.0104278401,
-0.0580899417,
-0.0103326812,
-0.0003362538,
0.0266780742,
-0.0302727018,
0.0568233207,
-0.0062226001,
0.0598303452,
-0.0088310624,
0.0587372705,
-0.0045846947,
-0.0182754863,
-0.0402134024,
-0.0000859646,
0.0342603214,
0.0280078016,
0.0060755908,
-0.0220215935,
-0.000796847,
0.0205104165,
-0.03114314,
-0.0860774592,
0.0209203027,
0.0080776317,
2.434e-7,
0.0497834757,
0.033122953,
0.0062077441,
-0.0138222948,
-0.0154484389,
0.0351316407,
0.0197533071,
0.028052723,
0.0290349815,
0.007334826,
0.0027564061,
0.0115258032,
0.0424248986,
0.0223288611,
-0.0959173515,
-0.058006376,
-0.0483073592,
0.0362144783,
-0.0253812913,
0.0324164703,
0.1074532643,
0.1204950586,
0.0272324029,
-0.0342267267,
-0.0286278054,
-0.0670290664,
0.0466440953,
0.0191410538,
0.0210994519,
0.0218871385,
0.0336495563,
0.0005886033,
-0.0012207114,
0.0450266488,
-0.0046993122,
0.0331680924,
-0.0022375784,
0.0087900544,
-0.0249548368,
-0.0424446762,
0.012932295,
-0.0105733844,
0.015582189,
-0.0753654763,
0.0684706569,
-0.0602636002,
0.0027771972,
0.0267026592,
-0.039239049,
-0.0295613743,
0.0609680526,
-0.0004582148,
-0.0005932463,
0.0169346612,
0.0202410761,
-0.0361042656,
0.0160228387,
-0.1031506509,
0.0094333356,
-0.0103283422,
-0.0470885634,
-0.0073649311,
-0.0289029013,
0.0044896863,
0.0240519159,
-0.063991785,
-0.003145145,
2.376853251e-34,
0.0180963203,
0.0154370777,
-0.0216504503,
0.0664721951,
0.0145811616,
-0.0060535627,
0.0137430737,
-0.0234160777,
0.0372725949,
-0.103848882,
0.0006038852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06795v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06795v2 | Robust Infidelity: When Faithfulness Measures on Masked Language Models Are Misleading | 2023-08-13T15:44:39 | 2024-05-31T22:41:54 | Evan Crothers, Herna Viktor, Nathalie Japkowicz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | A common approach to quantifying neural text classifier interpretability is
to calculate faithfulness metrics based on iteratively masking salient input
tokens and measuring changes in the model prediction. We propose that this
property is better described as "sensitivity to iterative masking", and
highlight pitfalls in using this measure for comparing text classifier
interpretability. We show that iterative masking produces large variation in
faithfulness scores between otherwise comparable Transformer encoder text
classifiers. We then demonstrate that iteratively masked samples produce
embeddings outside the distribution seen during training, resulting in
unpredictable behaviour. We further explore task-specific considerations that
undermine principled comparison of interpretability using iterative masking,
such as an underlying similarity to salience-based adversarial attacks. Our
findings give insight into how these behaviours affect neural text classifiers,
and provide guidance on how sensitivity to iterative masking should be
interpreted. | [
0.017536249,
0.0520007163,
-0.0349752568,
0.0431983732,
-0.0233184732,
0.0306982659,
0.0192532688,
0.0195829645,
-0.030154733,
-0.030648306,
-0.0251061916,
-0.0068455529,
0.0314953551,
0.0298627056,
0.0164716747,
-0.0063906657,
0.0221113022,
0.0040318728,
-0.0508605763,
0.0103589222,
-0.0101729417,
-0.0160370432,
0.0303580146,
0.0507677309,
0.0344751291,
-0.0268449821,
0.0129475472,
0.010391484,
-0.0030388313,
0.0049534212,
0.0176336337,
0.0171167608,
-0.0006456709,
0.0941386074,
0.0000019053,
-0.0084476937,
-0.0236180611,
0.0118309362,
-0.043349985,
0.0291340556,
0.0361661725,
-0.0845324695,
0.0161136277,
-0.0216323771,
-0.0175303817,
0.0345502757,
0.0413247645,
0.0570257343,
0.0421643071,
0.0641105622,
-0.0012602321,
-0.0053156349,
0.0183065683,
-0.0329114124,
-0.0499657765,
-0.0169343129,
0.0055346549,
-0.0463463143,
-0.0779190287,
0.0382042564,
-0.0370185226,
0.0455734283,
0.0487207063,
0.0215342809,
0.018598957,
0.0181205515,
0.0059497654,
-0.0282356516,
0.0174822751,
0.0111044096,
-0.0463717245,
-0.0247233994,
-0.0133441361,
-0.0156160705,
0.0014629397,
0.0032485002,
-0.0101277875,
-0.0152908843,
0.0273139644,
0.0270783752,
-0.008162247,
0.034876015,
0.0657076836,
-0.0013106727,
-0.0213375296,
0.0444323756,
-0.0086394912,
-0.0304431263,
-0.0256118793,
-0.0000530054,
-0.032569956,
-0.0366591848,
0.0270220786,
-0.0097414814,
0.0066700429,
0.0259278975,
-0.0673100948,
-0.057259962,
0.0154065629,
-0.0437496342,
0.0379243046,
0.0245704316,
-0.0341883041,
0.009567041,
-0.0237175114,
0.0805199593,
-0.0220322497,
0.0873378217,
-0.0272153635,
-0.027556546,
-0.0358826704,
-0.0531124547,
0.0248692129,
0.0180409141,
-0.0286145192,
-0.0250387192,
-0.0179066937,
0.0101934588,
-0.0353765786,
0.0350727737,
-0.0394198149,
-0.0210634768,
-0.0397986546,
0.022827208,
0.0206202436,
-0.0169385411,
0.00224706,
0.0160808899,
0.0079269735,
-0.0471954457,
-0.0401411913,
0.0218834523,
-0.0376570001,
-0.0336620584,
-0.0093402667,
0.0740456134,
0.0112497406,
-0.0459840409,
-0.0076436931,
-0.018147368,
-0.0376618616,
-0.0278616566,
0.0264456403,
-0.0066816839,
-0.0038048897,
0.0182080586,
-0.0004011322,
-0.0882111266,
-0.0164222457,
0.0147646125,
-0.0157870874,
0.0949463844,
0.0318395868,
-0.045436535,
-0.0009255635,
0.0366778038,
-0.0227341726,
0.0312638916,
0.0149060637,
0.0479500368,
0.0498216227,
-0.029693393,
0.0155143626,
0.011620502,
0.0278751235,
0.02080057,
-0.0070349639,
-0.0165907387,
0.0133095337,
-0.017811507,
0.0246290471,
0.0275389012,
-0.0201413929,
-0.0586727448,
0.0888293162,
0.0156214749,
0.0026242682,
0.036493849,
0.0108171022,
0.0253910888,
-0.0323936939,
0.0661588684,
-0.065100655,
0.0011605435,
-0.0442102961,
-0.0288594346,
-0.0125599327,
-0.032599289,
-0.0139070442,
-0.0748331696,
-0.0144195054,
0.0039023671,
0.0135134468,
-0.0128004001,
0.0597658232,
0.0241833273,
-0.0481029339,
0.0120070847,
0.0190376341,
-0.0374416448,
0.0234069638,
-0.0433682092,
0.023614157,
0.0247143172,
0.0234060958,
-0.0177559443,
0.0399972051,
-0.0026016843,
0.0185275935,
0.020834446,
-0.0168481059,
0.0149019593,
0.0675297081,
-0.026073521,
-0.0264654141,
-0.0707165822,
0.0248661321,
0.035877008,
-0.0417597219,
-0.019167088,
0.0168720838,
-0.0402915403,
-0.0184803605,
0.0737866014,
-0.0183564238,
-0.06312453,
0.0022517517,
0.0127742849,
0.0322167836,
-0.0106264716,
-0.0233810581,
0.009170033,
0.0294717196,
-0.042753119,
-0.0124555938,
-0.0055445284,
-0.0473109633,
-0.0265166052,
-0.0182904024,
-0.0400149673,
-0.0232985802,
0.0796671882,
-0.0392457396,
0.0013552257,
0.0086734621,
-0.047329165,
0.0099914419,
-0.0095470836,
0.0145763773,
-0.0629102811,
0.0537164398,
-0.0364613496,
0.0334175304,
-0.0277542453,
0.0243893489,
-0.0157102309,
-0.0150848804,
0.0294130128,
-0.0221036188,
-0.0212599449,
0.0174423829,
-0.0077977441,
-0.0231563095,
-0.0162203405,
-0.028815845,
-0.0089438045,
-0.0290958378,
-0.0421030708,
-0.0218580142,
-0.0469047837,
0.0050721462,
0.030127462,
-0.037019413,
0.0190116558,
-0.0164719392,
0.0027659507,
-0.0581565611,
-0.0401924811,
0.0103511112,
0.0143776648,
-0.0062279063,
-0.016622521,
-0.016647324,
-0.0318135023,
0.0002595557,
0.1035695672,
0.0000786121,
-0.0225829631,
-0.0976569876,
0.004374234,
0.012399829,
-0.0044622524,
-0.0330371074,
-0.034831576,
0.0127149271,
0.0453232154,
-0.0266395714,
0.0796875656,
0.0224293545,
0.0736112148,
0.0280493572,
0.0643910095,
-0.0439719558,
-0.0447606705,
-0.0175269507,
-0.0096515846,
-0.0167323072,
-0.0573300906,
0.0419703685,
0.0633376837,
0.0109995063,
-0.0063766101,
-0.0569663011,
0.02592187,
-0.0431813635,
-0.0327623896,
-0.0128549505,
-0.0167676099,
-0.0135737555,
0.0311454311,
-0.0172546189,
-0.0618974008,
0.0762697533,
-0.0532340333,
-0.0126133831,
-0.0308572762,
-0.0457650125,
0.0076517966,
0.0515468307,
0.0256183352,
0.0074957418,
0.0557970516,
-0.0326904505,
-0.0251864642,
-0.0096711488,
0.0061496822,
0.0007797984,
0.0556791313,
-0.0104290098,
-0.0291302223,
0.0279206242,
-0.0149043314,
-0.0545968078,
-0.0634195507,
0.0100039858,
0.0283118468,
0.0139934234,
0.0024721338,
-0.034717869,
-0.0152173685,
0.0122494902,
0.0157644413,
-0.0119495494,
-0.0238107964,
-0.0341380239,
0.0171137862,
0.0225134138,
-0.0171938688,
0.0636126623,
-0.0268436633,
0.0164408144,
0.060612902,
-0.0000687413,
0.0607775412,
-0.0256436784,
0.0188631751,
0.010959181,
-0.020372346,
-0.0122229764,
-0.0059929299,
0.0407148339,
-0.0685996637,
-0.0398861393,
0.0869664475,
0.0051982747,
0.0065909876,
0.0455962047,
-0.0273659751,
0.0413315408,
0.0011048601,
-0.0215569902,
-0.0367922448,
-0.0132215973,
0.0296122674,
0.0653206632,
-0.0199554097,
0.0009754851,
0.0115063181,
-0.0647405237,
0.0158613697,
0.0007037863,
-0.0444054194,
-0.0474336706,
-0.0611178167,
-0.0195406172,
-0.021913711,
0.0581254028,
0.0043383152,
0.0439166576,
-0.0059104827,
0.025774885,
0.011859661,
-0.0389232561,
0.0067258915,
-0.0198684987,
-0.0032907659,
0.0845879093,
0.0303702056,
-0.0318254866,
-0.0629080757,
0.0236357376,
-0.0126272887,
0.0037331108,
-0.0007067546,
0.0755944774,
0.0021912691,
-0.013365617,
-0.0100085028,
0.0263154581,
-0.014322998,
-0.0129295094,
-0.0093271499,
0.021213254,
-0.0029945464,
-0.0506720431,
-0.0066843671,
-0.0181984995,
0.0085441191,
0.0813092366,
0.0650238767,
-0.0405133106,
-0.0431700796,
-0.0665090829,
0.0361574031,
-0.0276772976,
-0.0297329035,
0.0633771792,
0.0093421321,
-0.0084102685,
-0.0462745354,
-0.0433564261,
-0.0423687585,
0.0205795988,
-0.0137416236,
-0.0258692428,
-0.0173464995,
-0.0474103689,
-0.0325056799,
0.0223697778,
0.0000141744,
0.0068575973,
-0.0401009545,
-0.0190630686,
0.0002461234,
-0.0164998379,
-0.0406551659,
0.0004296415,
-0.0585874394,
-0.0195485391,
0.0337181799,
0.0314047337,
0.023238102,
0.0617972203,
-0.0185428802,
-0.0418021642,
0.0813410357,
0.0168489963,
0.0045962287,
0.0462891944,
0.0601495504,
-0.0457951576,
0.0119776484,
0.0395121537,
-0.0267891027,
0.0088977143,
0.0664318576,
-0.0062402962,
0.0175318997,
0.0392144769,
0.0206622742,
-0.0166062843,
0.0615624674,
0.000501854,
-0.0089565516,
0.0276756343,
0.0178312566,
-0.0018113641,
-0.015498559,
-0.0296520684,
-0.0162109043,
0.0264561027,
0.036018014,
-0.0303105805,
0.0537646413,
-0.0298766103,
0.0229339544,
-0.0635501444,
0.0053714099,
-0.0039080367,
0.0558362454,
0.0057784687,
0.036717955,
-0.0333949253,
0.0222084504,
0.0001266356,
0.042992238,
0.0137051651,
0.0250260904,
0.0402074344,
0.0232626498,
-0.0380766504,
0.0307882428,
-0.0875053108,
-0.0060704644,
-0.0184695087,
-0.0384194702,
-0.0056811306,
-0.032861311,
0.0178382564,
0.0039484259,
0.0022313935,
-0.0089228088,
0.0169132724,
0.035028819,
-0.0258972086,
0.0097724972,
-0.0130090946,
-0.0131402966,
0.021077415,
0.0700200945,
0.0091453176,
0.0285185259,
0.0009709321,
-0.0280744508,
-0.0279316381,
-0.0233017169,
0.0507815778,
0.0499497466,
-0.0166448243,
-0.0269420091,
-0.0160507057,
-0.0638333037,
0.0465908684,
-0.0228046235,
0.0508315675,
-0.0241591223,
-0.0220158827,
0.0526401214,
-0.0227543302,
-0.0106390771,
-0.0501052216,
0.0096756024,
0.0264686663,
0.0052301558,
-0.0179926585,
-6.20494097e-33,
-0.0074958736,
-0.0423772447,
-0.0458767228,
0.0315750353,
0.0389425159,
0.0140467724,
-0.0535722189,
-0.0296993535,
-0.0164829604,
0.0174638573,
0.0223582666,
0.0300296471,
0.0039936653,
0.0407418832,
-0.0228267107,
-0.0590002164,
0.0515669957,
0.0379201807,
-0.0325094797,
-0.0204601847,
0.0530240536,
0.0314241312,
0.059049353,
-0.120340243,
0.0735288262,
0.0086445715,
-0.0151641322,
-0.021494966,
-0.0384969972,
0.0607371777,
-0.0045095021,
0.0495962352,
0.0241636839,
-0.0496370196,
-0.0126037728,
0.0076239314,
-0.0342874713,
-0.0162104163,
0.0067504086,
0.0491756611,
-0.0233270973,
-0.0284273289,
0.0941447392,
-0.0339083672,
-0.0165321454,
-0.0427774228,
0.0274051353,
-0.0141981794,
-0.0155717023,
-0.0282491129,
-0.0626550317,
0.0148099316,
-0.0045413286,
-0.0280243512,
0.0310149752,
0.0465106703,
0.0218287744,
0.072388351,
-0.0995134264,
-0.0338211432,
0.0032569848,
0.0025120846,
0.0551553145,
0.0188034996,
0.014240155,
0.094246462,
0.0531023517,
0.0109747974,
-0.0178743508,
-0.0147262784,
0.0413103178,
0.0128596621,
0.1077931896,
0.0312866084,
0.0709817037,
-0.0082760397,
-0.0838945657,
-0.0102146557,
-0.0706850216,
-0.031990774,
0.0553759933,
0.0332997628,
-0.0484236255,
-0.0135036213,
-0.045831047,
-0.0633098707,
-0.0414473675,
-0.0226746686,
0.0341336355,
-0.0244533513,
-0.0247725993,
0.0456626266,
0.0153206652,
-0.0446530655,
0.0085231978,
0.0189475976,
-0.0233101863,
-0.0064949454,
0.014615478,
0.0054165772,
-0.0088638272,
-0.0121639473,
0.0109816138,
-0.0088696843,
0.057316374,
-0.0056084921,
0.0963792056,
-0.0002863708,
-0.0248455293,
-0.0235391669,
-0.02521489,
0.0125410529,
0.0195120219,
0.0425839312,
0.0512064882,
0.0092725707,
-0.0269118436,
0.0227824617,
0.0278774016,
0.0118221007,
-0.0488276854,
0.0718276352,
-0.0324693508,
0.0125241708,
-0.02976612,
-0.0527022071,
-0.0075762426,
0.0148290712,
0.0319292918,
-0.0729636922,
-0.0070717214,
-0.0195045527,
2.617e-7,
0.0270771384,
0.0295782909,
-0.0066380203,
-0.0447796062,
0.0348329507,
0.0647330508,
-0.0160225984,
0.0416686349,
-0.0229436997,
-0.0141211385,
-0.0200842563,
-0.0156123424,
0.0645807162,
0.014232195,
-0.0169237424,
-0.0250002574,
-0.0646561161,
0.0160199702,
-0.0170128662,
0.0576649606,
0.047774177,
0.1044522226,
0.0377057604,
0.0043631336,
0.0463271141,
-0.0460911319,
0.0495986119,
-0.0413775221,
0.0457089283,
0.0050015855,
-0.0043746852,
-0.0035239183,
0.034495879,
0.0317774974,
-0.0218637977,
0.008985443,
0.0420926139,
0.060431093,
-0.0082971342,
-0.0170319136,
-0.0584167354,
-0.0069393306,
0.0016435343,
-0.0880011171,
0.0576716103,
-0.0576765575,
-0.0495034307,
-0.0228094552,
-0.0413815938,
-0.0062594544,
0.0486790016,
0.019837169,
-0.0078087524,
0.0245405845,
0.0157726984,
0.0194852203,
-0.0123886988,
-0.0576786734,
-0.0282031745,
-0.0360140204,
-0.058313258,
-0.0021072142,
-0.0481545106,
0.0124115366,
0.0510135815,
-0.0448401421,
-0.0093819294,
2.324502885e-34,
0.0014510156,
-0.0172388162,
0.0273080859,
0.0285062902,
0.0335406251,
0.0120553458,
0.0286416598,
0.0050349808,
0.0175190791,
-0.0419525467,
0.0000692537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06788v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06788v2 | Modeling the Dashboard Provenance | 2023-08-13T15:03:31 | 2023-09-16T11:42:49 | Johne Jarske, Jorge Rady, Lucia V. L. Filgueiras, Leandro M. Velloso, Tania L. Santos | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.GR | Organizations of all kinds, whether public or private, profit-driven or
non-profit, and across various industries and sectors, rely on dashboards for
effective data visualization. However, the reliability and efficacy of these
dashboards rely on the quality of the visual and data they present. Studies
show that less than a quarter of dashboards provide information about their
sources, which is just one of the expected metadata when provenance is
seriously considered. Provenance is a record that describes people,
organizations, entities, and activities that had a role in the production,
influence, or delivery of a piece of data or an object. This paper aims to
provide a provenance representation model, that entitles standardization,
modeling, generation, capture, and visualization, specifically designed for
dashboards and its visual and data components. The proposed model will offer a
comprehensive set of essential provenance metadata that enables users to
evaluate the quality, consistency, and reliability of the information presented
on dashboards. This will allow a clear and precise understanding of the context
in which a specific dashboard was developed, ultimately leading to better
decision-making. | [
0.0087601095,
0.0603015572,
-0.0262504984,
-0.0066323406,
-0.0429599844,
-0.0072507826,
-0.0098833879,
0.0326470584,
-0.0193756316,
0.0261168312,
0.0133639025,
0.0572458543,
0.0280297995,
0.0550895631,
-0.0252229236,
-0.0715921745,
-0.0147499526,
0.0393872187,
0.0032261857,
0.0360603854,
0.0140597625,
0.0153079452,
0.0161219556,
0.0180020817,
-0.0536778532,
-0.0363534167,
0.0134987747,
0.008956925,
0.0155655807,
-0.0331763066,
-0.0422328264,
0.0274533257,
0.0020723983,
0.0241872892,
0.000002155,
-0.0008020893,
-0.0117697129,
0.0013100154,
-0.1003951058,
0.0494370013,
-0.0082142372,
0.015471112,
-0.0158686433,
-0.0147054587,
0.0094414903,
0.0195407216,
-0.0040973811,
-0.0321498513,
-0.0028411276,
-0.0900501758,
0.0055536912,
0.0279311705,
-0.0313906111,
0.0205887929,
0.0088200811,
0.0388299711,
-0.0337908864,
0.0820383132,
0.0207669903,
0.0204470698,
-0.0179337747,
0.0635312125,
-0.0173496231,
0.0146453399,
0.0137969172,
0.0277315788,
0.0929475948,
-0.0270984415,
-0.0134030152,
0.0175927561,
0.0719901547,
0.0136520509,
0.0033491913,
-0.0000841813,
-0.0046666232,
0.0155254435,
-0.0541083962,
0.0215491615,
-0.0138122467,
-0.0146257328,
-0.0551040322,
0.0278518908,
0.0161924809,
-0.0065670917,
-0.0084171705,
-0.0207092259,
-0.0092147375,
0.0157270953,
-0.0727793202,
-0.012486686,
0.0576264188,
-0.031292066,
0.0144041367,
0.0149643486,
-0.002193013,
0.0040186848,
0.0588500686,
-0.0092411935,
0.0406351313,
0.0385862701,
0.0050361548,
-0.0151392985,
-0.0559918582,
0.0531616881,
0.0527668633,
0.0514917597,
-0.0342923924,
-0.0416091532,
0.0636265352,
-0.0283666551,
-0.0095360829,
-0.0178393181,
0.030004682,
-0.0702112913,
-0.0388738699,
0.013426125,
0.0177887864,
0.0438276529,
-0.0304147806,
0.0577983111,
0.0209383424,
-0.0091275638,
0.0028242932,
0.0057671466,
-0.0448526107,
-0.0510152541,
-0.0493924469,
0.0066397549,
-0.0082475515,
-0.0196744539,
0.0077144331,
0.001593415,
0.0560929179,
0.0056082117,
0.0012620593,
-0.0196188185,
0.0562887266,
0.066148214,
-0.0497733504,
-0.0895844251,
0.000969653,
0.0198655166,
-0.0293129217,
0.0121129025,
0.0468934029,
0.0139730023,
-0.0207292866,
0.0222611763,
-0.0433341749,
0.0165227987,
-0.0297461171,
-0.0216052495,
-0.0957215503,
0.0270852074,
0.0059612505,
0.0055642682,
-0.0473248735,
-0.0716403127,
0.0075825136,
0.0288459733,
0.0372177474,
-0.0006861693,
0.0474112816,
-0.0243538078,
0.0080943136,
-0.0058554141,
-0.0068027247,
0.0615638979,
-0.0435413457,
-0.0200626422,
-0.0388767757,
-0.0175753217,
-0.0347332992,
0.0341463126,
0.0228475556,
0.0231295247,
0.0653304085,
-0.0300583988,
0.0144127905,
0.0252354201,
0.0133081051,
-0.0749022737,
0.010625043,
0.0328563005,
0.0545714647,
-0.015073576,
-0.0879674926,
0.0099469768,
-0.0176347699,
-0.0307439007,
0.0085018659,
0.015867088,
-0.0490845293,
-0.009740999,
-0.0030261141,
0.0155093856,
0.0116986129,
-0.0187281091,
-0.0380674265,
-0.004469418,
-0.0008595116,
0.0096785929,
0.0850797221,
0.0703607798,
0.049282629,
-0.0007085068,
0.0077209896,
-0.0276899394,
0.0114051895,
0.0209895205,
0.0112022934,
-0.0214002151,
-0.0474152826,
-0.0082128597,
-0.0606818423,
0.0046332711,
0.0127189178,
0.029688416,
0.0055638487,
0.0449848101,
0.0047550509,
-0.0736272484,
0.021153735,
0.0049395924,
0.0652555674,
0.0388857722,
-0.0129109109,
0.0405809507,
0.0058878628,
0.0722830743,
0.0337312669,
0.0097005554,
0.0355653986,
0.0376954712,
-0.0096911984,
0.0560112521,
0.0710595176,
0.0924232826,
0.002010142,
0.0096086347,
0.0302497614,
-0.0243559666,
-0.0118546151,
-0.0278422367,
0.006908739,
-0.0437902212,
-0.0392577536,
-0.0127224727,
-0.0192018766,
-0.0165971722,
0.0042802682,
-0.0156352129,
0.0607671849,
-0.0193221513,
-0.0285295639,
-0.0236486923,
-0.0007472084,
0.0402900092,
0.0059604212,
0.0426485166,
-0.0067134816,
-0.0283833183,
0.0463325605,
0.016055271,
-0.0832550675,
-0.0530204363,
0.0618866272,
0.0202582087,
-0.0148573844,
0.0187521409,
0.0270238444,
-0.0076259705,
-0.0125432564,
-0.0210513193,
-0.0045796279,
0.005421035,
-0.0193703752,
-0.000751372,
-0.0291775409,
0.0552229024,
0.0262710378,
-0.0020797332,
-0.015231871,
0.0126423761,
0.0092506083,
0.0120858913,
0.0389648117,
-0.0183529202,
-0.0127693564,
-0.0959330425,
-0.0364540033,
-0.0404005349,
0.0189720131,
0.0532380678,
0.0365241021,
0.0069650155,
0.0013713856,
-0.0348408483,
-0.0347286053,
0.0262058787,
-0.0183690526,
-0.0512786508,
-0.0191315338,
-0.0139862392,
-0.0122971628,
0.0533085391,
0.0646677837,
0.009549561,
0.0343655162,
-0.0992205665,
-0.0201703105,
0.02883224,
-0.0070152348,
-0.005669591,
0.0303010028,
0.060182672,
-0.0284833536,
-0.0322192423,
0.0025267382,
0.0649678335,
-0.0159552619,
-0.0106854476,
-0.0505173318,
-0.0189861991,
0.0338550322,
0.0452960208,
-0.0400129259,
-0.0093684299,
0.0624560826,
-0.0528279766,
-0.0132403569,
-0.0631390586,
-0.012074287,
0.0418639742,
-0.0258173589,
0.0238723457,
-0.0618465729,
-0.0735412836,
-0.0031107643,
-0.0650858209,
0.0473483801,
0.0141728474,
-0.0060514025,
0.0425508283,
-0.0052664634,
-0.0181596465,
-0.0086532999,
0.010841744,
-0.0557617284,
0.0257505327,
0.0513185225,
0.0411359519,
0.0549841039,
-0.0119609376,
-0.0249777902,
-0.0422816314,
-0.0745525211,
0.0061131478,
-0.0012773665,
-0.0057487153,
-0.0269406904,
0.0057811551,
-0.002151998,
-0.0102406507,
-0.016002968,
-0.0411989875,
-0.0542880595,
0.0184083115,
0.018019719,
0.0003138395,
-0.0679002032,
0.0124837924,
0.0391835459,
-0.021815734,
0.0302249622,
-0.0323316604,
0.0227977782,
0.0194587559,
-0.0473651141,
0.0024767763,
0.0037879972,
-0.0540339537,
0.0657460019,
-0.0279771537,
0.0229151919,
-0.0104636988,
-0.052448649,
-0.0016866021,
0.0159322899,
0.0689412504,
-0.002090201,
-0.0303436015,
0.0065992689,
-0.0657931864,
0.0121469256,
-0.0253561027,
-0.0301244706,
0.0055234609,
0.0167587921,
-0.0005130957,
0.0054343422,
-0.0711728483,
-0.0706743523,
-0.0113284271,
-0.0248196758,
-0.0297323186,
-0.0224976558,
0.0443861373,
0.0003425793,
-0.0225708466,
-0.0648143217,
0.068514213,
0.012840271,
-0.0266133919,
0.0776006579,
0.0107731773,
-0.0000803331,
-0.0514739342,
-0.0176864862,
0.0226825587,
0.0082247127,
-0.0120070223,
0.0739650056,
-0.0309288185,
0.0553771853,
-0.0350571349,
-0.0528226085,
0.0485051088,
0.0141758192,
0.0383901782,
-0.0147577245,
-0.009426631,
-0.0176829603,
0.0442532748,
0.0098820766,
0.0261691064,
-0.006644988,
-0.0626992956,
-0.042760767,
-0.0582543984,
-0.0320924744,
-0.0073901392,
0.0586066321,
-0.0182394385,
-0.0438436829,
-0.0142455483,
-0.0493881814,
-0.0456514135,
-0.0068223975,
-0.0468319654,
0.0533617921,
-0.0061034099,
0.0327675529,
0.0192314815,
0.0330916569,
-0.019175157,
0.0102540953,
0.0482039191,
0.041628588,
-0.0199873429,
-0.0052531869,
0.0233545862,
-0.0254468508,
0.0117640486,
0.0106573822,
-0.0044832956,
0.0269860364,
-0.0283420254,
-0.0863364562,
-0.0721245259,
0.0294342767,
-0.0506026223,
-0.0228044521,
-0.0199378114,
-0.0191777907,
-0.0026853513,
0.0113063129,
-0.036181733,
0.0710118711,
0.0012632947,
0.0047983169,
0.0454809256,
0.0222760346,
-0.0237156991,
0.0216222312,
-0.0252267942,
-0.0224691201,
-0.0122694224,
0.0304876957,
0.036759194,
-0.0030547318,
-0.0456058048,
0.0039711026,
0.0425884426,
-0.0008553764,
-0.0137861921,
-0.1047942638,
-0.0120524103,
-0.0160784069,
0.0246963296,
-0.0247577932,
0.0007013732,
-0.0308839958,
-0.0350416638,
-0.0135845803,
0.0372785665,
0.0300094187,
-0.0373612829,
0.0092459321,
-0.0049690031,
-0.0096497443,
0.0039734053,
-0.042452015,
0.0044416529,
0.047370743,
-0.0408461951,
0.0189958159,
0.037793532,
0.018489942,
-0.0247754958,
-0.0248232353,
-0.0066110245,
0.006810593,
0.050953716,
-0.0047000898,
-0.0431292132,
0.0055402722,
-0.0133811487,
-0.0140409963,
-0.0179795884,
-0.0215077866,
-0.0151793649,
-0.1300086528,
-0.0460519604,
-0.041863095,
0.0151438937,
0.0028580255,
0.0033018992,
-0.0068052281,
-0.0276720356,
-0.0853306279,
-0.0111349775,
0.0341577344,
0.0373272933,
-0.0069442494,
0.0093397237,
-0.0227467939,
0.0121292314,
0.0269064661,
-0.0115239033,
0.0130533557,
-0.0020614557,
-0.072221905,
-0.0103584575,
-0.037783619,
-5.870577112e-33,
0.0369610675,
-0.0468864851,
0.0191781167,
0.004940067,
0.0049356297,
0.0281974059,
0.0043706074,
-0.0372052006,
-0.0365517735,
-0.0088691171,
-0.026833782,
-0.0005294713,
0.0196467098,
-0.0277980808,
0.0023166027,
0.0439259373,
0.0367571823,
0.0244611073,
-0.0387089029,
0.0048404345,
0.0503207855,
-0.0220662002,
-0.0021986708,
-0.1439326406,
0.0437650122,
-0.0256955046,
-0.0449389592,
0.0408120789,
0.0394945703,
0.0298720654,
-0.000010497,
-0.019419603,
-0.0003186891,
-0.004089565,
-0.0140154837,
0.0089110145,
-0.0196374618,
-0.0074305474,
0.018791303,
0.0095321564,
0.0208341498,
0.0123129701,
-0.0249077044,
0.0252182372,
-0.003232924,
0.0123563465,
0.0154753029,
-0.0015590907,
-0.03975638,
0.034891244,
0.0094977496,
0.0093196332,
-0.0217947681,
0.0585178509,
0.050474707,
0.0384837128,
0.0185450111,
0.0131555777,
-0.0874248818,
0.0136142662,
0.0247548353,
-0.1050326973,
0.0391235203,
0.041381672,
0.0048742387,
0.0014938792,
-0.0294070933,
0.030964043,
-0.0092627984,
0.0922961533,
-0.0300560705,
0.0973164737,
0.0702147409,
-0.0209395736,
-0.0694733784,
-0.0161795057,
-0.0118883066,
0.0382832102,
-0.0117471656,
-0.0187335014,
0.007939335,
-0.0161071941,
-0.0335303508,
0.0064894864,
0.0078795711,
-0.0454307459,
-0.0362440571,
0.0428373739,
0.019838905,
0.0047296961,
-0.0313519202,
0.029341884,
-0.0250243992,
-0.003453817,
-0.0325283296,
0.0237476639,
0.0235812049,
0.0210665166,
0.018088121,
-0.0268304404,
0.003332586,
0.001814898,
-0.0190338288,
0.0591893792,
0.0089384681,
0.0092703542,
0.0367084295,
-0.004570873,
-0.014885338,
0.0327391736,
0.0239229389,
-0.0291582569,
-0.0288995411,
-0.1006442159,
0.0207232647,
0.0101090791,
0.0054972479,
0.0030250649,
0.0310422126,
0.0320036709,
0.0685584545,
0.0065577216,
-0.060156364,
-0.0051959055,
0.0359606966,
-0.0314818136,
0.023558015,
-0.0197480042,
0.0903702155,
0.0252256375,
-0.0004262982,
-0.0015078968,
2.7e-7,
0.039202828,
0.0279244557,
0.0419189073,
-0.0284273308,
0.0556837805,
-0.0096990699,
-0.0162047241,
-0.0059781913,
-0.0586738661,
-0.0393997245,
0.0335005708,
-0.0328793675,
0.0363133177,
0.0593724176,
0.0240091719,
-0.0878004357,
-0.0144054955,
-0.042556785,
-0.094508253,
0.0419826917,
0.059195146,
-0.0482596941,
0.0433619916,
-0.0096115759,
0.0068982784,
0.0107118813,
-0.0201343447,
-0.0255385693,
0.0610339083,
-0.00410396,
0.0143596865,
0.0660950914,
-0.0143725583,
-0.0001416302,
-0.0017209997,
0.0000642206,
-0.0549617372,
0.0042101517,
0.0179865658,
0.0484329499,
0.017581271,
-0.0771674663,
0.0217037052,
-0.019769758,
-0.0356467701,
0.0565924011,
-0.0108884303,
0.0549834818,
-0.0540164635,
0.0223935489,
0.0293014999,
0.004112449,
-0.0305675771,
-0.0176209453,
-0.0361079425,
0.0435030721,
0.0099017797,
-0.0061586834,
0.0609470755,
-0.0097101014,
-0.0154338647,
0.0019162234,
-0.0018202591,
0.0339068435,
0.0359048806,
0.0156221734,
0.0322965048,
2.197838089e-34,
0.0141562214,
-0.0117892204,
0.0187394787,
-0.0573115423,
0.0735457763,
0.0178706404,
0.0391939804,
-0.0008144272,
0.00231943,
-0.0223875456,
-0.0115195736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06744v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06744v4 | Token-Scaled Logit Distillation for Ternary Weight Generative Language Models | 2023-08-13T11:07:55 | 2023-12-03T03:29:37 | Minsoo Kim, Sihwa Lee, Janghwan Lee, Sukjin Hong, Du-Seong Chang, Wonyong Sung, Jungwook Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative Language Models (GLMs) have shown impressive performance in tasks
such as text generation, understanding, and reasoning. However, the large model
size poses challenges for practical deployment. To solve this problem,
Quantization-Aware Training (QAT) has become increasingly popular. However,
current QAT methods for generative models have resulted in a noticeable loss of
accuracy. To counteract this issue, we propose a novel knowledge distillation
method specifically designed for GLMs. Our method, called token-scaled logit
distillation, prevents overfitting and provides superior learning from the
teacher model and ground truth. This research marks the first evaluation of
ternary weight quantization-aware training of large-scale GLMs with less than
1.0 degradation in perplexity and achieves enhanced accuracy in tasks like
common-sense QA and arithmetic reasoning as well as natural language
understanding. Our code is available at https://github.com/aiha-lab/TSLD. | [
-0.0065402379,
0.0742589086,
0.0098700952,
0.0064538349,
-0.0234791394,
0.0219972134,
0.0251673348,
0.002583348,
-0.0403961577,
-0.0150702558,
0.0201009307,
-0.0534426123,
-0.0339700282,
0.0499635004,
0.0566288792,
-0.0247352086,
0.0361841954,
-0.0393950082,
0.0149159031,
-0.0261240583,
-0.0017030402,
0.0235020854,
-0.0179546084,
-0.0016619825,
-0.0333443359,
-0.0411665142,
-0.0226647295,
-0.0036674037,
0.0278516021,
-0.008453507,
-0.0152696194,
0.0448271073,
0.0613272376,
0.0316302627,
0.0000022277,
-0.020733472,
-0.0052340245,
-0.0005676048,
-0.0408585481,
0.0328355618,
0.0042214431,
0.0049679754,
0.019651955,
0.0387309529,
-0.042068556,
-0.0341082402,
0.0590215921,
0.0436763987,
0.0484874025,
0.049972102,
0.0057334681,
-0.0535928644,
0.0450719111,
-0.0362970605,
0.0265656281,
-0.0339361243,
0.002410454,
0.0562720783,
-0.0349747166,
-0.0176629946,
-0.0420904793,
0.0189371668,
0.045941852,
0.0051547489,
-0.0074680015,
0.052073285,
-0.0687249899,
-0.0227732658,
-0.0115145631,
0.0533140898,
-0.0264089406,
-0.0392032154,
0.0090346318,
0.0141841136,
-0.0176848043,
-0.0811369568,
-0.0348897688,
0.0201868769,
0.0160536822,
0.0479805842,
-0.0061109513,
-0.0518679321,
0.0166571718,
-0.0082042152,
-0.08180134,
0.0383769609,
0.0153468782,
-0.012937611,
-0.0140636638,
-0.0193851311,
-0.0972464979,
-0.053253863,
-0.0252064094,
-0.0041604009,
0.0072267861,
-0.0154391862,
-0.028453419,
-0.0155210448,
-0.0057202922,
0.0391136408,
-0.0066086743,
0.0412167013,
0.0282531083,
0.0010678426,
-0.01007907,
0.0842339545,
0.044242423,
0.0488421582,
-0.0295704883,
0.0080579212,
-0.0589591302,
-0.0138512058,
-0.0761347711,
0.0426429659,
-0.0376958326,
-0.0109995445,
-0.0562627167,
-0.0285342764,
-0.0337144211,
-0.0393433534,
0.0371337906,
0.0341854133,
-0.0363603719,
-0.0165889133,
0.0308957193,
0.0737091452,
-0.0395157412,
0.0046893097,
0.0418495685,
-0.0643805712,
-0.026429737,
0.0136786448,
0.0117186764,
-0.0172381196,
-0.0125980787,
0.0100247767,
-0.0304585025,
-0.0375614502,
-0.0176132191,
-0.0050683292,
-0.0369008183,
-0.0914039314,
-0.0178757589,
-0.075067848,
0.0244476646,
-0.0302719269,
0.004464047,
-0.0293563511,
-0.0002537653,
-0.029611174,
0.0328045525,
0.0526289046,
-0.0200293232,
-0.0080385953,
0.0096925115,
0.0205877349,
0.0260500759,
0.0872266591,
0.0287612062,
0.04302793,
-0.0301344469,
-0.0025723618,
-0.0423468202,
-0.0061184354,
0.0471465364,
-0.0031111029,
-0.0402211323,
-0.0127841076,
-0.0457864255,
0.0201534238,
0.0882930383,
0.076652959,
-0.0949753597,
0.0295815691,
0.0489563681,
0.0095345443,
0.0520531014,
0.0102233663,
0.0264261272,
0.0345532373,
-0.0172597207,
0.0066757957,
-0.0306895077,
0.0114194481,
0.0232670642,
0.0106997825,
0.0689683184,
0.0683477968,
-0.0357574821,
-0.0630879998,
0.0102474391,
-0.0030160393,
0.0117576662,
-0.0033456157,
0.0495240837,
0.0183762014,
0.0063858377,
0.0554080419,
0.042327825,
-0.0619099326,
0.0415884964,
-0.0648237094,
0.0116728442,
0.0347812921,
0.0278980713,
0.0056685661,
-0.0283732619,
-0.0095818192,
0.0235744603,
0.0058042966,
0.0075148209,
-0.0031596699,
0.0356693938,
-0.0532671101,
-0.0254200362,
-0.024379693,
0.0106547941,
0.0108371144,
0.0109391492,
0.041754555,
0.0115324548,
-0.0854815319,
0.0083357571,
0.0249413792,
-0.0047444436,
-0.0947393328,
0.0281253755,
-0.0044177347,
0.0154786864,
0.0001419433,
-0.0221527778,
0.0023582159,
0.011262022,
-0.0370827056,
-0.0221399833,
-0.0089490311,
-0.0162324011,
-0.0625744462,
0.0695459619,
-0.0334541015,
0.0246675014,
0.0292100571,
-0.0721381083,
-0.0482861437,
0.0491649471,
-0.0047691776,
0.0567157529,
-0.0654295832,
0.009202891,
0.0319815353,
0.0182804614,
-0.0369966403,
0.0401217937,
-0.0339636803,
-0.0344013348,
-0.0588721968,
-0.009631278,
0.0165833309,
-0.0084157679,
-0.0091128182,
0.020341808,
-0.0074666427,
0.030847257,
-0.0016892188,
0.0266556013,
-0.0064220992,
-0.0117398007,
-0.108715333,
-0.001173277,
-0.0503868386,
0.0253400672,
0.0204389058,
0.0310595706,
0.0055114701,
0.0202998836,
-0.0705564022,
-0.0179565474,
0.0036062682,
-0.0142548895,
-0.0044753943,
0.0072928066,
0.0004900733,
-0.0092362622,
-0.0033399099,
-0.0113235898,
0.0349710174,
-0.0263890661,
0.0355027169,
-0.047810141,
0.0210302211,
-0.0421446897,
0.0178987775,
0.0050900606,
-0.0127303721,
0.0318608321,
-0.0093124695,
0.0548006631,
0.0363463797,
0.0261585824,
0.0117244516,
0.052472394,
0.0112355687,
-0.0581314526,
0.0482687391,
-0.0245359782,
-0.0214696452,
0.006937569,
-0.0375362262,
-0.0140522029,
0.0559078231,
-0.0048164288,
-0.0279492661,
-0.0766340122,
0.0355607346,
-0.0053579798,
-0.0472562835,
-0.0360456705,
0.0413595438,
-0.0096786153,
0.0352344811,
-0.0197981764,
-0.0336593837,
0.0576466657,
-0.031060731,
-0.0120921535,
-0.0666986406,
0.0060570673,
-0.007168998,
0.0346014649,
0.0092841387,
0.0432830043,
-0.0029051104,
0.0074101561,
-0.0521480888,
-0.0091680652,
-0.0154952751,
-0.0048394687,
0.0353610963,
-0.0351272114,
0.0150577147,
-0.0137761254,
-0.0472590402,
-0.0152812107,
0.0067234281,
0.0215100609,
0.0299133174,
0.0134783369,
-0.033086475,
0.011816198,
0.0080980295,
-0.0028934774,
0.0319497548,
-0.016823072,
-0.0235733595,
-0.0202203412,
0.0410046689,
0.0704756975,
-0.0080634328,
0.0512610003,
-0.0079701263,
-0.0018930716,
0.0467439964,
0.0485531129,
0.042040024,
-0.0236312523,
0.0034514298,
-0.0043523721,
-0.0135069545,
-0.0064697983,
0.0214038193,
0.0603465922,
-0.0187119097,
-0.0429323316,
0.0942418054,
0.0148288356,
-0.0004765733,
0.0286655724,
0.0098201791,
0.0912767053,
-0.0104794148,
0.0131047927,
-0.1282427013,
-0.0267655775,
-0.0154103469,
0.0183307678,
0.0364891365,
-0.0123078274,
-0.0138044041,
-0.0720266029,
0.0338980854,
0.0410955772,
-0.0255205948,
-0.044515308,
-0.0103424992,
-0.038611453,
-0.025476478,
0.0418234505,
0.0338161886,
-0.0296914633,
0.0433261804,
0.0533078127,
0.0243216623,
-0.0472542495,
0.0154597238,
-0.02632064,
0.0357475467,
0.0514269471,
0.0336430706,
0.0019327704,
-0.0450786762,
-0.0088841291,
0.0183204059,
-0.0236558504,
0.0074375179,
0.0219759978,
0.0093539655,
-0.0025530246,
0.0378146619,
0.0484050699,
-0.0311910789,
-0.0256514437,
0.0113454293,
0.0458576679,
-0.0005442278,
-0.0558736511,
0.0005154426,
-0.0113570644,
-0.0024224669,
0.0572740287,
0.0385192558,
-0.0225215163,
-0.0957178921,
-0.0418710075,
0.0196813848,
-0.0392535888,
0.0223841127,
-0.0239623245,
0.0185826216,
-0.0525114387,
-0.0540541373,
-0.0097978888,
0.0444226898,
0.0586326271,
-0.03667726,
-0.0137090869,
-0.0253084786,
0.0177047979,
-0.0613808334,
0.0084923478,
-0.0226366762,
-0.0192011762,
-0.0472168289,
-0.020938402,
-0.0183636453,
-0.0225884207,
-0.0331340991,
0.0080655664,
-0.1259855777,
-0.086637415,
-0.0153477881,
0.0197870228,
0.0204225201,
0.0574585125,
-0.0015879804,
-0.0317352302,
0.0521028414,
0.0704245269,
-0.0102510396,
0.0441000611,
0.0106085176,
0.0023747748,
0.0164846648,
0.0471870042,
-0.0109751374,
0.0380104072,
0.0009995558,
0.0829726607,
-0.0349785015,
0.0369360484,
0.0013504644,
0.0353633836,
0.0337273404,
-0.0230430048,
0.0354512744,
-0.0290641449,
0.0204618014,
-0.0089545297,
0.0260845069,
-0.0622497424,
0.0074512693,
0.0295011085,
0.0353290178,
-0.0121668242,
0.0020075485,
0.0378396176,
0.020930199,
-0.0084599825,
-0.0237927716,
-0.0115811992,
0.0266073383,
0.0463286117,
-0.0429669879,
0.0017169167,
-0.0124273421,
-0.0029114441,
0.0504859574,
-0.0263776369,
0.0333668664,
0.0224285908,
0.0315614454,
-0.0125359455,
0.0279419459,
-0.0471006334,
-0.0643551201,
-0.0560738333,
0.0105868503,
0.0395583436,
0.0686086491,
0.0505605377,
-0.0274646617,
-0.0101144537,
0.0009398945,
-0.001928843,
0.0007236504,
0.0019386414,
0.0178172942,
0.0311833024,
-0.0120754996,
-0.0149970325,
0.0789029598,
0.0453526378,
0.0361578241,
-0.0182612427,
0.0371266417,
-0.0235295333,
-0.0557574481,
-0.0234162975,
0.0374176502,
0.0337176099,
0.0172952041,
-0.0314093269,
-0.066522263,
0.0074019521,
0.0291236714,
0.0045979791,
-0.0223442689,
0.0524284467,
0.0475928783,
-0.0353964791,
-0.0684919655,
-0.0204952117,
-0.0375532098,
0.0316466503,
-0.0140443528,
-0.0154117793,
-7.027882525e-33,
-0.0020115054,
0.0201421492,
0.0383892916,
-0.00495139,
-0.0303015057,
0.0129174944,
0.0034514656,
-0.0206205975,
-0.0155482842,
0.0275120214,
0.0046490263,
0.0313750952,
0.0074377041,
0.0447678901,
-0.0281923506,
0.0310051292,
0.0752079487,
-0.0119091673,
-0.0195031334,
0.0703781396,
0.0122545566,
0.0251488462,
0.0363890417,
-0.0138409734,
-0.0070973793,
0.0229194071,
-0.0232731253,
-0.0209261309,
-0.0320345946,
0.011819304,
-0.0398163274,
0.0326781757,
0.001781647,
-0.0024211789,
-0.0378812328,
-0.0311557855,
-0.080929786,
-0.0364927091,
0.0325921588,
-0.0147108622,
-0.0048223874,
-0.0158286281,
0.046829816,
-0.0105870366,
-0.0223607291,
-0.0204417426,
-0.0098930113,
0.0097500673,
-0.0150695816,
-0.0772221386,
-0.0414152928,
0.0030458116,
-0.0133465882,
0.0118014431,
0.0143837268,
0.0075770719,
-0.0302035287,
-0.0102491677,
-0.053427048,
0.0138473604,
0.0729058757,
0.059791442,
0.0443805903,
0.0397041552,
0.0182270408,
0.0454427674,
0.0292290207,
-0.0510507263,
-0.0574472398,
0.020004347,
0.0590630434,
0.0400021672,
0.0104506928,
0.0291874595,
0.1091416106,
-0.0127546862,
-0.0912411287,
0.0036277741,
-0.0087478012,
0.0348290429,
0.0199410412,
0.0224066824,
-0.0073665716,
-0.0276436191,
-0.0478690825,
-0.0264186375,
-0.0327294879,
-0.0324217901,
0.0442317314,
0.0180273186,
-0.037540067,
-0.047754582,
0.0129777035,
-0.0427069813,
-0.024288265,
0.0282603856,
-0.0234688632,
0.0066529382,
-0.0073750517,
0.0326672606,
-0.0456086062,
-0.0232172329,
0.0348817259,
0.0374608412,
0.0044579506,
-0.0109637659,
0.0316095836,
0.0289404336,
-0.0613039844,
0.005695282,
-0.0393643565,
0.0453287661,
0.0184900127,
0.0432529673,
0.0198738798,
0.0048918785,
0.0203714427,
-0.0178911164,
0.0126861902,
-0.0305602178,
-0.0279026348,
0.0458223484,
0.0310098249,
0.0451601744,
-0.0415797308,
-0.0043601878,
-0.0202648602,
-0.0273835547,
0.0370112807,
-0.0575145856,
-0.0343423374,
0.0296755936,
2.876e-7,
0.024588285,
0.0203641076,
0.0224297754,
-0.0442542173,
-0.0061036376,
-0.0034195681,
0.0268507041,
0.0147193018,
0.0113310106,
-0.0135363834,
0.0061707045,
0.069499962,
0.0021651126,
0.0149912313,
-0.0733007416,
0.0310481954,
-0.0449866615,
-0.0251419973,
-0.043343842,
-0.0300894007,
0.0402439386,
0.0867714435,
-0.0046781092,
-0.0166360009,
0.0593195967,
-0.0190443471,
0.0280860569,
0.0291803889,
0.0436661951,
0.0438918993,
0.0127176372,
0.0046926457,
0.014029297,
-0.0103657702,
-0.0001809268,
-0.0006746642,
-0.0419198349,
0.1020213887,
-0.0400181785,
-0.0199812073,
-0.0020329524,
0.0034936657,
-0.0113873035,
-0.0578132868,
0.0634776279,
-0.0479550622,
0.0182143841,
-0.0477516912,
-0.0408812761,
-0.0117822913,
0.0319429226,
-0.0292436983,
-0.0013016807,
0.0346541032,
0.0098957038,
-0.0068374188,
-0.0094714109,
-0.0835361853,
-0.0097371442,
0.0002893234,
-0.0430209599,
-0.0504244603,
-0.0347423218,
0.0019867187,
0.0031910732,
-0.005688685,
0.0035292909,
2.740160443e-34,
0.0559363626,
-0.0114848725,
0.0247319378,
-0.0099025015,
0.031577263,
-0.0137322471,
-0.0624775849,
0.0028489444,
-0.0047448971,
-0.0506721362,
-0.0126200886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07935v1 | Transforming Sentiment Analysis in the Financial Domain with ChatGPT | 2023-08-13T09:20:47 | 2023-08-13T09:20:47 | Georgios Fatouros, John Soldatos, Kalliopi Kouroumali, Georgios Makridis, Dimosthenis Kyriazis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.IR, 68T01, 68T50, 91B28, 91B30 | Financial sentiment analysis plays a crucial role in decoding market trends
and guiding strategic trading decisions. Despite the deployment of advanced
deep learning techniques and language models to refine sentiment analysis in
finance, this study breaks new ground by investigating the potential of large
language models, particularly ChatGPT 3.5, in financial sentiment analysis,
with a strong emphasis on the foreign exchange market (forex). Employing a
zero-shot prompting approach, we examine multiple ChatGPT prompts on a
meticulously curated dataset of forex-related news headlines, measuring
performance using metrics such as precision, recall, f1-score, and Mean
Absolute Error (MAE) of the sentiment class. Additionally, we probe the
correlation between predicted sentiment and market returns as an additional
evaluation approach. ChatGPT, compared to FinBERT, a well-established sentiment
analysis model for financial texts, exhibited approximately 35\% enhanced
performance in sentiment classification and a 36\% higher correlation with
market returns. By underlining the significance of prompt engineering,
particularly in zero-shot contexts, this study spotlights ChatGPT's potential
to substantially boost sentiment analysis in financial applications. By sharing
the utilized dataset, our intention is to stimulate further research and
advancements in the field of financial services. | [
-0.0008884491,
0.0699511766,
-0.0098435767,
0.013392386,
-0.0220135376,
0.0229998343,
0.0295922086,
0.0168079827,
0.0327347219,
-0.0248875096,
-0.036771521,
-0.072268337,
-0.0464262404,
0.0616497584,
-0.0025548306,
-0.0275319535,
0.0239041615,
0.0243100952,
0.0654701293,
-0.0176720321,
0.0316603333,
-0.0087845828,
0.0016834653,
0.0259022526,
-0.0081461715,
-0.0417361595,
-0.020011209,
0.0031473429,
-0.0035048795,
-0.0202364828,
0.0370887034,
0.0323676579,
-0.0067714155,
0.0669791847,
0.0000017949,
-0.0250351988,
0.001855341,
-0.0216021687,
-0.0134320203,
-0.0236558579,
0.045526918,
-0.0488243401,
0.0202071872,
-0.0050453446,
-0.0677141994,
-0.031693805,
0.0669165105,
0.0827509612,
0.060291782,
0.0985881388,
-0.0187405292,
-0.0127280802,
0.0012286449,
-0.0672363788,
0.0378816016,
-0.0542820618,
0.0084357681,
-0.0000700495,
-0.0445927046,
0.0251772124,
-0.0114533817,
0.0281052161,
0.0058914577,
0.0080467407,
-0.0195006374,
-0.0100232037,
-0.0438874848,
0.0001000903,
-0.0524308681,
0.0468007028,
0.0009602711,
0.0402692556,
-0.0270388238,
-0.0112442672,
-0.0126403542,
-0.0149022853,
-0.0521074906,
0.0082710795,
0.0038306029,
0.0118006095,
0.010949851,
0.03594511,
0.0192601755,
-0.0053457608,
-0.0116187008,
0.0141576845,
-0.0339248963,
-0.0259191711,
0.0456714034,
0.0370698832,
-0.0021677732,
-0.0155217387,
-0.013677326,
-0.0082808584,
0.0047986074,
-0.0004635182,
0.0328197107,
-0.0214176048,
0.0017498278,
-0.1002643779,
-0.0037368741,
0.0560237542,
-0.0423306525,
0.0602010861,
-0.0520521402,
0.0290590841,
0.0400925651,
-0.0320496485,
-0.0016906997,
0.0133088874,
-0.0811533332,
-0.0078238808,
-0.0155094815,
0.0406522527,
-0.0265174545,
-0.0331320539,
-0.0928094164,
-0.0049448828,
-0.0156873092,
0.0265300609,
0.0062119081,
-0.0027564305,
-0.005684834,
-0.009409748,
-0.0146520054,
0.0341197625,
-0.0332070254,
0.0264635123,
-0.0008050321,
-0.047626894,
0.0093135815,
0.0283576455,
-0.0464998409,
0.0015268285,
0.0061835255,
0.0878190175,
0.031120915,
-0.0426781438,
-0.0295710992,
-0.0617791004,
0.0048128976,
-0.0184697062,
-0.0088236788,
-0.0232072659,
-0.0104141599,
-0.0290986896,
-0.0074834642,
0.0495162643,
0.0043263086,
-0.0260487292,
-0.0099742245,
0.0768194646,
0.015650278,
-0.0527460352,
-0.0097254831,
-0.0160336904,
0.0023263099,
0.0640799329,
-0.0437135957,
0.0608312562,
0.0511846542,
-0.0026979011,
0.0000310195,
0.0252747145,
0.0130344722,
-0.0562689938,
-0.0043075592,
0.008364806,
0.0081638377,
-0.0235432554,
0.0462369919,
-0.0000960947,
-0.0124626104,
-0.0277873892,
0.0511712804,
0.0258617327,
0.0400371589,
0.0268764868,
0.0079044327,
-0.0014101114,
0.0049288478,
-0.0330286659,
-0.0039275535,
-0.0027918823,
-0.0276599173,
0.0284128133,
-0.0177705679,
0.004005929,
-0.0534883924,
-0.0283790007,
0.0079954658,
-0.035746213,
0.0060495334,
-0.0067525804,
0.0210610311,
-0.0567746088,
-0.0662320256,
0.0239010416,
0.0454430282,
-0.0252120681,
-0.0231244136,
-0.0370631181,
0.0294680167,
0.0813070908,
-0.015215476,
0.0043650856,
0.0104717109,
-0.0245504435,
-0.0175179336,
0.0507755391,
0.0497483648,
0.0126128858,
-0.0100616282,
-0.0398413055,
0.0051379935,
0.0123399226,
0.0356286801,
0.0417384133,
-0.0325712822,
0.042944856,
-0.0100200782,
0.0358654149,
-0.0029026861,
-0.0145681659,
0.0353607386,
-0.0705854222,
0.0333299041,
-0.01939415,
0.014518355,
0.0311203301,
-0.0145904273,
-0.0114590731,
-0.0058329897,
-0.0127495015,
-0.0718897432,
0.0263513848,
-0.0582821704,
-0.0437988825,
-0.0087146945,
-0.0076885093,
-0.0051134774,
0.0104339411,
-0.0622052737,
-0.0163733698,
-0.0016740696,
-0.0248301197,
0.0135977995,
-0.056868311,
-0.0604211502,
0.002233838,
0.0386738479,
0.0092458213,
0.0520261005,
-0.0136422664,
0.0087151704,
-0.0219558608,
-0.003834757,
0.021976741,
-0.0055131549,
-0.0104994215,
0.0077910074,
-0.0034869192,
0.0455751047,
0.0539078228,
0.0226233266,
0.0072132936,
-0.014610257,
-0.1153639257,
-0.023054339,
-0.0097962599,
0.0268960781,
0.0195653681,
0.0199455675,
-0.0149101885,
-0.0220204759,
-0.0645807981,
0.0063757822,
-0.0035589999,
0.0217418279,
0.0705024451,
-0.0045572068,
0.0075850841,
-0.0444064066,
-0.0060021486,
-0.0040552635,
0.0222794879,
0.0430490039,
-0.0116823716,
0.0066473922,
-0.0198498387,
-0.0451181643,
0.0059354957,
-0.0201281663,
-0.0023773583,
-0.0019913516,
-0.0265245512,
-0.0118106259,
0.0417959876,
0.0102690859,
0.0689016953,
-0.0537180081,
0.0171803348,
-0.0265196357,
0.0160305817,
-0.0440860167,
-0.0028822704,
0.0021409388,
0.006880173,
-0.0220371112,
0.0524436086,
-0.0058520366,
-0.0013730527,
-0.0941426083,
0.0272839591,
0.0148948971,
0.0334033668,
-0.0670323297,
0.0275865328,
0.0076096943,
0.0544268601,
0.0143274786,
-0.0533958226,
0.0467523634,
0.0281959083,
-0.0276602823,
-0.0442374274,
-0.0299422983,
-0.0787520334,
0.0425425693,
-0.04102825,
-0.0007773101,
-0.0182511657,
-0.0154566895,
0.0056277844,
-0.0436942428,
-0.0001304423,
-0.0298423376,
0.0184588023,
-0.0034590818,
0.0208085347,
0.0001634302,
-0.00578793,
-0.0112769902,
-0.0739687681,
-0.0545668527,
0.0328860655,
0.0440651067,
-0.0314465053,
-0.0214659795,
0.0259977374,
-0.0225413144,
-0.036754448,
-0.0186264012,
-0.0427869745,
0.018995747,
0.0295059886,
0.0552272648,
-0.0061959499,
0.0279998034,
-0.0206888765,
0.0497561283,
0.0244087651,
0.0005046222,
0.0269243345,
-0.0369486064,
0.0054473104,
-0.0114595713,
-0.0006444501,
-0.0103422571,
-0.0130624399,
-0.0035661596,
-0.0368136205,
0.0217140242,
0.1190970242,
0.0041768663,
-0.0270630606,
-0.0078243921,
0.0114487046,
0.0196082927,
-0.042981144,
0.0110916533,
-0.1015018672,
-0.0439736955,
-0.0158760156,
-0.0021466943,
0.0034197378,
-0.0434369519,
-0.0166552942,
-0.1204168573,
0.0516667217,
-0.0234983414,
-0.0103741772,
-0.024359636,
-0.0564369,
-0.0182343852,
-0.0376824625,
0.0324118026,
-0.0110808024,
-0.0054844958,
0.0260236282,
0.0047003338,
-0.0633355528,
-0.0239525028,
0.0287655294,
-0.0014640526,
-0.0092852181,
0.0373191908,
0.0114192218,
-0.0258335304,
-0.0168516506,
-0.0274630021,
-0.009567651,
0.0155795356,
-0.0186859425,
0.0900218189,
-0.0156131871,
-0.0590254441,
-0.0029969281,
0.022820035,
-0.0458941199,
0.0787994415,
-0.0146597782,
-0.0022723882,
-0.0149299428,
-0.0535751022,
-0.0239799451,
0.0607536808,
0.021750886,
0.0692835003,
0.0066923061,
-0.0566261932,
-0.0389117151,
-0.0520447232,
0.0023472658,
-0.0556073897,
-0.0275292024,
-0.0193878748,
0.0323671773,
-0.0381149985,
-0.0853113458,
-0.0654844716,
0.0085344007,
0.0169792287,
-0.0320087373,
0.0000540833,
-0.001741871,
0.0132580372,
-0.0294251889,
0.0423778296,
0.0060139103,
0.007256933,
-0.0194573961,
0.0427513868,
0.0462293997,
-0.0005919552,
-0.0457415804,
0.0213330332,
-0.0633579418,
-0.0145251015,
0.0051865648,
0.0306848809,
0.0210492034,
-0.023078518,
-0.0106619606,
0.0423299707,
0.0228304099,
0.1157789156,
-0.0425070822,
-0.0325954184,
0.0843644291,
0.0693601295,
-0.012283125,
0.0191696752,
-0.0185148679,
0.0405159146,
-0.0228870101,
-0.0089335004,
-0.0306110848,
-0.0037629001,
-0.0068127937,
-0.0010867522,
0.056709785,
0.028626889,
-0.0293482877,
-0.0005294954,
-0.02754879,
0.0266222656,
0.0243136305,
-0.0277199913,
-0.0334079377,
0.0262510441,
-0.0226328745,
-0.0431413688,
0.0226251557,
-0.0301436186,
-0.0307844542,
-0.0301761795,
0.0236965511,
0.0216726065,
0.0337628461,
0.0061521977,
0.0109917773,
-0.0129412021,
0.0017426297,
0.0517128073,
-0.0182210319,
-0.017155787,
0.0121098934,
0.0350703746,
0.0430294238,
0.0097316355,
-0.0129125491,
-0.0499125533,
-0.0256757196,
0.0182336401,
0.0703845471,
0.01940386,
-0.0329191126,
-0.0046544634,
-0.0554421768,
0.0263483301,
0.0167633928,
0.0184642728,
-0.0207829624,
-0.0244253334,
0.010861842,
-0.0120191285,
-0.0496014804,
-0.0298424326,
0.0870625079,
-0.0616952181,
0.0441951044,
0.0290135927,
-0.010999999,
-0.0493960381,
-0.0085695451,
0.1036416143,
-0.0157606155,
0.0099244704,
0.0335869342,
-0.0544039682,
-0.0624843985,
0.0532259159,
-0.001804503,
0.0101713873,
0.0158619937,
0.0489186905,
0.0636005029,
0.0009594136,
0.0714020729,
-0.003424014,
0.0192312077,
-0.0420996919,
-0.0255875494,
-0.0786492229,
-5.886307064e-33,
-0.0026800323,
0.0130542219,
0.0164311249,
0.0480230637,
0.0013159125,
0.0338574983,
-0.0467592068,
0.0196965691,
-0.0006596572,
0.0511902161,
0.0071218708,
0.025643317,
0.0050880425,
0.0341708995,
0.0201562885,
-0.0224717986,
0.0331931598,
-0.0205816422,
0.0354445651,
0.0194993373,
0.0447271876,
0.0693178475,
0.0442467444,
-0.058906395,
0.0654283613,
-0.0057970989,
-0.0583812371,
-0.0087753693,
0.0676544383,
0.0397031493,
-0.0087685063,
0.0825358555,
0.0313501395,
-0.0503310487,
-0.005240974,
0.0291553773,
0.0115968436,
-0.0701300725,
-0.006851994,
0.0215804446,
0.0034875795,
0.0143008577,
0.0112926494,
-0.0020592702,
-0.0004074878,
0.0013291052,
0.0162766147,
0.0198327713,
0.0033766192,
-0.0537705608,
-0.0544345714,
0.0147139179,
-0.0092029264,
0.0152065745,
0.0241538007,
0.113390483,
0.022619525,
0.0360222198,
-0.0344625153,
0.0212476794,
-0.017277848,
0.0067181229,
-0.0143100787,
-0.0163986757,
-0.0243635252,
0.0712373406,
0.0165055078,
0.0049357009,
-0.0088145416,
0.0504741482,
0.0507946871,
0.0166824367,
0.0529417694,
0.0680190399,
0.045648545,
-0.0465927199,
-0.0545243807,
0.0237941127,
0.0632744953,
0.0033879855,
0.029315006,
0.003044514,
-0.0387860537,
-0.0285151117,
0.0232148394,
-0.0010284941,
-0.0214997008,
-0.0340011977,
0.0102771325,
0.0030478847,
0.0127477273,
-0.0068904385,
0.0256673601,
-0.0600073263,
-0.0632566288,
0.0122060552,
-0.0257557407,
0.0288814139,
0.0076245614,
-0.0165285226,
-0.0190983191,
-0.0308591668,
-0.0355495885,
0.0328203663,
-0.0063803573,
-0.0144571038,
0.0464805253,
0.0276524238,
-0.0551716164,
-0.0221996661,
-0.00132444,
0.0408169888,
-0.0049446188,
0.0489863232,
-0.0179540627,
0.0106926272,
-0.0189679917,
0.028743716,
-0.0196077134,
0.0426608697,
-0.0000452481,
-0.0203215238,
-0.0119290063,
0.0381971598,
-0.0068545206,
-0.0232535228,
0.0191679765,
0.0552700646,
0.0070680971,
-0.0530758463,
-0.008008902,
0.0269582644,
2.56e-7,
0.0297705121,
0.0785077289,
-0.0045060948,
0.0294658821,
0.0142533155,
0.0721495524,
-0.0304695498,
0.0275556613,
-0.0013748012,
-0.0102489507,
0.0497405268,
0.0072191609,
0.0350475274,
0.0253036134,
-0.1047383994,
-0.0436672121,
-0.0665499195,
0.0048898142,
-0.0278488323,
0.0713661313,
0.0667785853,
0.0961349159,
-0.008980358,
-0.0422976539,
0.0257214047,
-0.0282644797,
0.0587349944,
-0.0541699529,
-0.0164148118,
0.0050875312,
0.0117333159,
0.0191816557,
-0.0016733131,
0.0030915206,
0.0146717858,
-0.0091288537,
0.00707332,
0.0201214179,
0.0083778352,
-0.0078877257,
0.0142667918,
0.0081360675,
0.0017526145,
-0.0423614196,
0.04130302,
-0.1093927547,
-0.0236768294,
-0.072531119,
-0.0391144119,
0.0318695307,
0.0921806619,
0.013205125,
-0.0349986739,
0.0262306072,
0.0139087001,
-0.0286615007,
-0.0003705155,
-0.0392777659,
-0.0095008332,
0.015660625,
-0.0469953045,
0.0198761392,
-0.0194113646,
0.0203699227,
0.0237656552,
-0.0320410021,
0.0157392416,
1.984003268e-34,
0.0930772275,
-0.0338800959,
-0.0261425357,
0.0364946797,
0.0261448491,
0.0097014159,
-0.0073102135,
0.0181458145,
0.0260996856,
-0.0496366881,
-0.0122384531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06696v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06696v1 | MACO: A Modality Adversarial and Contrastive Framework for Modality-missing Multi-modal Knowledge Graph Completion | 2023-08-13T06:29:38 | 2023-08-13T06:29:38 | Yichi Zhang, Zhuo Chen, Wen Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM | Recent years have seen significant advancements in multi-modal knowledge
graph completion (MMKGC). MMKGC enhances knowledge graph completion (KGC) by
integrating multi-modal entity information, thereby facilitating the discovery
of unobserved triples in the large-scale knowledge graphs (KGs). Nevertheless,
existing methods emphasize the design of elegant KGC models to facilitate
modality interaction, neglecting the real-life problem of missing modalities in
KGs. The missing modality information impedes modal interaction, consequently
undermining the model's performance. In this paper, we propose a modality
adversarial and contrastive framework (MACO) to solve the modality-missing
problem in MMKGC. MACO trains a generator and discriminator adversarially to
generate missing modality features that can be incorporated into the MMKGC
model. Meanwhile, we design a cross-modal contrastive loss to improve the
performance of the generator. Experiments on public benchmarks with further
explorations demonstrate that MACO could achieve state-of-the-art results and
serve as a versatile framework to bolster various MMKGC models. Our code and
benchmark data are available at https://github.com/zjukg/MACO. | [
0.0262469817,
0.0757863,
0.0061608991,
0.0393678285,
0.0070717777,
-0.0273191463,
-0.0218370035,
-0.0153231705,
0.0461688079,
-0.0022350361,
-0.0021316085,
0.0295331553,
-0.0154837696,
0.0128137777,
0.0429182462,
-0.0101735862,
0.0399275571,
0.0317104086,
-0.0399677008,
-0.0173990149,
-0.0173301287,
0.0502961054,
0.0052555925,
0.0020300969,
-0.0024636781,
-0.0070613618,
-0.0443297513,
0.0049915258,
0.000901258,
-0.0272287577,
0.0036185416,
0.0273757428,
-0.0029216364,
-0.0366280228,
0.0000021606,
-0.0119234277,
0.00246766,
-0.0139456699,
0.0048572249,
0.0133273955,
0.0080471551,
-0.0125176562,
0.0520876125,
-0.0080788825,
-0.0186544117,
-0.0332270861,
0.0202099513,
0.082777299,
-0.0100277327,
0.0296815988,
-0.0209020134,
-0.000453281,
0.0427094102,
-0.0549088493,
0.025923444,
-0.034071926,
0.0470365807,
0.0406763107,
-0.0000591613,
0.0242513549,
-0.017179355,
0.0355073288,
0.0109107075,
0.0212022234,
0.0145178102,
0.0349821337,
0.0595256686,
0.0266280547,
0.0144346161,
0.111930117,
0.0332430787,
0.0368234552,
0.0280607156,
-0.004797074,
0.0333976559,
0.0174253974,
-0.0357184932,
-0.0683427975,
-0.0262729786,
-0.0169753637,
-0.0399461538,
-0.0477778204,
0.0640185624,
0.0003199955,
0.0187210944,
-0.0217417926,
0.0114493389,
0.0033687723,
-0.0220065787,
-0.0036226287,
-0.0537894405,
-0.0387593508,
0.0250987168,
-0.0036954922,
-0.0078332219,
-0.0165056046,
-0.016901888,
-0.0058924537,
0.0215585176,
0.0293103401,
-0.026397733,
-0.0056992322,
-0.0396152101,
0.0522510968,
-0.0310331285,
-0.0249619521,
-0.0541275851,
0.019413026,
-0.0231350064,
-0.0356315523,
-0.0508269668,
-0.0028584716,
0.0151138809,
0.0441214181,
-0.0272613093,
-0.0034983682,
-0.0249361936,
0.014519088,
-0.0469967946,
0.0287770685,
0.0086110588,
0.0367997959,
-0.0316492952,
-0.0378346331,
-0.0372065268,
0.0395650342,
-0.0376862958,
0.0672328919,
-0.0242282841,
0.0010024195,
-0.0048869359,
-0.0072302222,
0.0156045249,
-0.0313655324,
0.0226779599,
0.0855491534,
-0.0213681292,
-0.0312553681,
-0.0718789622,
-0.0489317589,
-0.0195583981,
-0.0590628386,
0.0052622892,
-0.0351620987,
0.0491605178,
0.0045493366,
-0.0186077654,
-0.0174085964,
0.014912256,
-0.045792982,
-0.0305875819,
0.0516776368,
-0.0130585004,
-0.0365547761,
-0.0072064381,
0.0120375035,
-0.0378797501,
0.0503632538,
-0.0115066282,
0.0132647334,
0.0052327369,
0.0114470245,
-0.040061105,
-0.0029189102,
0.0825854763,
0.0071324273,
0.0194642227,
-0.0042442116,
-0.0396908782,
0.0488351956,
0.0482493304,
0.0256735943,
-0.0367196649,
-0.0180573352,
0.0133787375,
-0.0651108995,
0.0403967984,
0.0776128247,
0.0216599908,
-0.017382456,
-0.0366639681,
0.029591741,
-0.0371440873,
0.0351470634,
-0.0587288961,
-0.001836731,
0.0445706472,
0.0677007884,
-0.0252875108,
-0.0202754829,
0.0765344203,
-0.0225828812,
0.0360636376,
0.0253696162,
0.0761019513,
0.0172114484,
-0.0211453754,
0.0088680228,
0.0384883024,
-0.0006548642,
0.0418043137,
0.0022385337,
0.0040928675,
0.0362704918,
0.05273908,
-0.038390141,
-0.0105129583,
-0.0085552391,
-0.0072714412,
-0.0406803265,
0.0080162017,
-0.0406698138,
0.039109312,
-0.0439545698,
-0.0728175566,
-0.0035397809,
0.0083281528,
0.0203459449,
0.0103890235,
0.0338669233,
0.0335847028,
-0.1108580232,
0.068718873,
-0.0053544831,
-0.0317008235,
0.0338365622,
0.0235069953,
0.0097704176,
0.0060792863,
0.0310504846,
0.0391243435,
0.0126314787,
0.035575036,
-0.0129296295,
-0.0421175025,
-0.0154537885,
0.0002727512,
-0.0619340427,
0.0855276957,
-0.0315609798,
-0.0129813226,
0.0166564435,
-0.0253426731,
-0.0332154036,
0.0492259338,
0.0128765143,
0.060222771,
0.0022744511,
-0.0259155631,
0.0301400535,
-0.0085591646,
0.0193439331,
0.1025450677,
-0.0359968543,
-0.005867579,
0.0413841009,
-0.0127549833,
0.0075930208,
0.0119143613,
-0.0188590325,
0.0173923727,
-0.0152884573,
0.0269130971,
-0.0065903631,
-0.0568012185,
-0.0634993836,
-0.0238131937,
-0.1432134658,
0.0284222569,
0.033956416,
-0.0093829529,
-0.0200040508,
0.0261665341,
0.0302689895,
-0.0211791396,
-0.005463643,
0.042325411,
-0.0312924758,
0.0312379301,
0.0123774679,
0.0358356237,
-0.0230678301,
0.0078615863,
-0.0305428803,
-0.0073685055,
0.0540998876,
-0.0136611126,
0.0179647878,
0.0077432138,
0.0455035605,
-0.0623057149,
0.0218764525,
-0.0565523617,
0.0236539971,
-0.0222288743,
-0.0247550104,
0.0319139101,
-0.0012185897,
-0.0244767312,
0.0041704075,
0.0238419399,
-0.0189964604,
-0.0369080938,
0.0197534338,
-0.0303917248,
-0.0031239886,
-0.055504147,
0.0184446964,
-0.0503748171,
0.0172245838,
0.0278047863,
-0.0269932132,
-0.043552056,
-0.0170567296,
0.0570104048,
-0.029989522,
-0.0069240211,
0.027770238,
0.0335807987,
-0.0005593069,
-0.035515666,
0.018448038,
0.0787517875,
0.0146522895,
0.0069291596,
0.0225357637,
0.029771883,
-0.0060278983,
0.0467171371,
-0.0243990049,
0.0120102726,
0.0414563194,
-0.0349870697,
-0.064262636,
-0.0142091969,
0.0458177626,
-0.0094290618,
0.0195667464,
0.0129017644,
0.0237252843,
0.018863868,
-0.0107813533,
-0.0006693155,
-0.0166283455,
-0.0114207175,
0.011154552,
0.0367457196,
-0.0093538668,
-0.0114809554,
-0.0658594742,
0.0094505819,
-0.0117919035,
0.0113156624,
-0.0278606582,
-0.0235083047,
0.0790240541,
0.0379746705,
-0.015024187,
0.015591884,
-0.0310133994,
-0.0259222239,
0.063281931,
0.0104094921,
-0.0093708234,
-0.0013440226,
0.0021959683,
-0.017434353,
0.0299277455,
-0.0451587774,
0.0090020718,
0.0368980579,
-0.0088825645,
0.0607498065,
0.0453081913,
-0.0225743521,
-0.0340327919,
0.0082737925,
0.0374611914,
0.0216182228,
0.0183479451,
-0.0069168471,
-0.1115889549,
-0.0318952687,
0.0016504204,
0.0194917805,
0.0241117477,
-0.0519256331,
0.0107980911,
-0.0615424179,
0.0228472613,
0.0083134593,
0.0074205403,
-0.065627858,
-0.0381102897,
0.0224746298,
-0.027940724,
-0.0434764214,
-0.0135289757,
-0.0092582274,
-0.0072583444,
-0.0154159972,
0.0533523075,
-0.063333489,
0.0176795088,
-0.0441502705,
0.0486824736,
-0.0397678725,
0.0317640267,
-0.0056217136,
-0.0101298159,
-0.0099303033,
0.0161706563,
-0.0078410236,
-0.0052714208,
0.0602729432,
-0.0267111771,
-0.0083110118,
-0.057541728,
0.0328652337,
-0.0196396224,
-0.0208141748,
-0.0122207729,
0.0888658017,
0.0366379954,
-0.0200758483,
-0.0059578135,
-0.0055420864,
0.0213389173,
0.0128121581,
-0.0039070086,
0.0059390692,
0.007719602,
-0.0237331316,
0.0495288298,
-0.0283315927,
0.0183653608,
0.030041106,
0.0016441625,
0.0152071873,
-0.0087843435,
-0.0674559772,
0.052769497,
-0.0112398099,
-0.0098137427,
0.0341336131,
-0.0329662189,
-0.0374263451,
-0.0547482632,
0.0259925444,
-0.0352985412,
0.0215649195,
0.0119693661,
0.0179239921,
0.007235752,
-0.058604721,
-0.0169626754,
-0.0154967308,
-0.0898707509,
-0.0699950904,
-0.0730980411,
0.020545857,
-0.0059070569,
0.0694401488,
-0.0255731959,
-0.0312580802,
0.0365878381,
0.0666841194,
-0.0515835546,
0.0072906571,
0.0422507934,
-0.0342565179,
-0.0031352828,
0.0361331105,
-0.0488865562,
-0.0261695106,
0.0215870552,
0.0437100567,
-0.0172870699,
-0.0106643494,
0.0112467669,
-0.0058208774,
0.0064825453,
-0.0133455088,
0.0256936848,
-0.0672210976,
-0.009296149,
0.0231119022,
-0.0170598533,
-0.0474031195,
-0.0116855288,
0.05411404,
-0.001614409,
0.0361443758,
-0.0222357251,
0.0262461472,
0.0380272083,
-0.0406500064,
-0.0104511455,
0.0512583442,
-0.0324537717,
0.0735780299,
-0.0090609947,
-0.010653357,
0.0233578254,
0.0196758024,
0.0082448861,
-0.0422023386,
0.0616200939,
-0.0007533494,
-0.0378857069,
-0.0236934647,
-0.0164436456,
-0.0095825084,
0.0178795047,
-0.0704594404,
0.0594610758,
0.064528957,
0.0199409984,
0.0185133815,
0.0065097888,
-0.0137556056,
-0.0300965551,
0.0506569222,
-0.0543122031,
-0.0153064709,
0.0240209028,
0.0168720204,
-0.0048708753,
0.0431668907,
0.0866196826,
0.0186100341,
0.1053541377,
-0.0422361977,
-0.0166735463,
-0.0478556529,
-0.0228958186,
0.0721865147,
0.050382629,
-0.0404509343,
0.0492980443,
-0.0075563136,
-0.0633208454,
0.0257646739,
-0.049595926,
-0.0793026015,
0.0130406236,
-0.0020244895,
0.0328146815,
0.0103978431,
-0.0641776994,
-0.0499908254,
0.0068951705,
0.0001544464,
-0.0019776085,
-0.0052254712,
-6.337670446e-33,
-0.0365556441,
-0.0564129539,
0.0177932847,
-0.0234966446,
-0.0256243646,
-0.001481803,
-0.0228621755,
-0.0124464799,
-0.0207360685,
0.0328163207,
0.0182694159,
0.0177886114,
-0.0247934014,
0.0182093848,
0.0158045813,
-0.0074630068,
0.0756963417,
0.0391958691,
0.0361926407,
0.039385166,
0.0171360727,
0.0169467274,
0.0489546135,
-0.1167900711,
0.0321293622,
-0.0118001439,
-0.0189536493,
-0.0163270868,
-0.0153828813,
0.0584721752,
-0.0188737158,
0.043237336,
0.0174415857,
0.0077604032,
-0.0130256396,
-0.0550589152,
-0.1078082845,
0.006360597,
-0.017280275,
0.007251312,
-0.0381549485,
-0.0315535367,
0.0173804257,
-0.0012829064,
0.0919086933,
-0.0639732331,
0.0406997167,
-0.0101641081,
-0.0569339432,
-0.0006866695,
-0.0041813268,
0.0274162218,
-0.018262459,
-0.0144050205,
0.0081441216,
0.0167706683,
0.0704887658,
-0.0369929858,
-0.0480013117,
0.0146698076,
-0.0061317077,
-0.0108192628,
0.0013779569,
0.0000527509,
0.0111897606,
0.025170289,
0.0182964355,
-0.0025945695,
-0.0174089875,
0.0086577218,
-0.0172406472,
0.0675958544,
-0.0247617215,
0.0986995324,
-0.0221715886,
-0.0411088094,
-0.057985153,
-0.0064835991,
-0.0359809697,
0.0338648073,
-0.0117120305,
0.0262165032,
-0.0291717723,
-0.0292329434,
-0.0406263247,
-0.0651787743,
-0.0257066619,
-0.039506536,
-0.0032467812,
0.0404548869,
-0.0338988788,
0.0141687971,
-0.0032887687,
-0.0549496822,
-0.0392500684,
0.0758830085,
0.0177923366,
0.0162503365,
0.00030181,
-0.0057368008,
-0.0451444499,
-0.0361347571,
0.0680954456,
-0.0726164803,
-0.0074848616,
0.0109125115,
0.0142620448,
0.0178848635,
-0.0253023673,
-0.0192302819,
-0.0315354243,
-0.0220918953,
0.007118945,
-0.0116825867,
0.0430879518,
0.0283998083,
-0.0364996381,
0.0046972409,
0.0810420066,
0.0785783157,
-0.0288125891,
-0.0385131016,
0.0104057482,
0.0111495275,
0.0115979426,
-0.0162366368,
-0.0605755374,
-0.0918768793,
0.0406687409,
-0.0227671936,
-0.0378504582,
-0.0462950543,
2.92e-7,
-0.0068321456,
-0.0211882684,
0.0340597481,
-0.0139737176,
-0.0127465744,
0.0620277524,
0.0165385604,
0.0216628555,
0.0070410701,
-0.0380100235,
0.046061527,
-0.0131322788,
-0.0028852462,
0.0409750603,
-0.0468418896,
0.0375807583,
-0.0030098092,
-0.0140960617,
-0.0260881502,
-0.0259480625,
0.0271093268,
0.0401078351,
0.0443260111,
0.0175939184,
0.0184107907,
-0.0690852478,
0.0918162093,
0.0085951136,
-0.0365666747,
0.028366562,
0.0474635363,
0.0492148213,
0.0062300754,
0.0500620641,
-0.007969846,
0.0246125013,
0.0562287681,
0.0465454087,
0.0209176894,
-0.0194894746,
-0.0147866234,
0.0082459133,
-0.0261925552,
0.0083277561,
0.090199247,
-0.0246057566,
-0.0035701662,
-0.0192453489,
-0.0726946071,
0.0054499004,
-0.012105302,
0.0185512807,
-0.0155961243,
-0.0396160558,
-0.0114523806,
0.0125285015,
-0.0273365155,
-0.0411567241,
0.0261004455,
0.0257977564,
-0.052319929,
-0.0455662385,
0.0071028261,
-0.0604423545,
0.0229069609,
-0.0483229943,
0.0085131815,
2.494896761e-34,
0.0006072012,
-0.009045708,
0.012464256,
-0.0275291633,
0.0297735762,
-0.0419905186,
-0.0259988401,
-0.0262827706,
0.0158372633,
-0.0616259724,
-0.0099992342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06610v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06610v1 | Bio-SIEVE: Exploring Instruction Tuning Large Language Models for Systematic Review Automation | 2023-08-12T16:56:55 | 2023-08-12T16:56:55 | Ambrose Robinson, William Thorne, Ben P. Wu, Abdullah Pandor, Munira Essat, Mark Stevenson, Xingyi Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Medical systematic reviews can be very costly and resource intensive. We
explore how Large Language Models (LLMs) can support and be trained to perform
literature screening when provided with a detailed set of selection criteria.
Specifically, we instruction tune LLaMA and Guanaco models to perform abstract
screening for medical systematic reviews. Our best model, Bio-SIEVE,
outperforms both ChatGPT and trained traditional approaches, and generalises
better across medical domains. However, there remains the challenge of adapting
the model to safety-first scenarios. We also explore the impact of multi-task
training with Bio-SIEVE-Multi, including tasks such as PICO extraction and
exclusion reasoning, but find that it is unable to match single-task
Bio-SIEVE's performance. We see Bio-SIEVE as an important step towards
specialising LLMs for the biomedical systematic review process and explore its
future developmental opportunities. We release our models, code and a list of
DOIs to reconstruct our dataset for reproducibility. | [
0.0510862507,
0.0471970774,
0.0095945727,
-0.0298605803,
-0.0108127948,
0.0394123606,
0.0115009714,
0.0277688373,
-0.0253443327,
-0.0509496219,
-0.050514143,
-0.0229289085,
-0.0059028994,
0.0598778687,
-0.0017304055,
-0.0127663137,
0.033308804,
-0.0198109318,
0.0688652471,
-0.0094223237,
-0.0435743779,
-0.004217871,
0.0009718956,
0.0355474092,
0.1094799265,
-0.0287589468,
0.0389798917,
-0.0200632326,
0.0098541295,
-0.0535036847,
0.0174819957,
0.0474154316,
-0.0068676635,
0.0300448313,
0.0000020621,
-0.0334912278,
-0.0158573948,
0.0470626466,
0.0142407827,
-0.0049962057,
0.0420243442,
-0.0289625023,
-0.0160483979,
0.0228907,
0.0168938022,
-0.0430615284,
0.0335856378,
0.0418654718,
0.0339650884,
0.0626715869,
-0.0023175434,
0.0171969682,
0.0469124578,
-0.0463038459,
0.0203438289,
-0.0018461052,
0.0613769889,
0.0228249654,
0.064206332,
0.048904255,
0.0313910954,
0.0231805462,
-0.0062636584,
-0.0121173766,
0.0000333511,
0.038577687,
-0.0419143215,
-0.0302818455,
0.0121797668,
0.0183787886,
-0.0601866581,
-0.0254915077,
0.0381984599,
-0.0012905918,
-0.0409164205,
0.0088439453,
-0.0526860803,
0.0370479859,
-0.012509672,
-0.0166185182,
0.0599484332,
0.0036624374,
0.0330031589,
0.0231211931,
0.0260824151,
0.0121748094,
0.0141922589,
-0.0310455933,
0.0605102889,
0.0294278152,
0.0616453737,
-0.0554525331,
0.0216392465,
0.0403036252,
-0.0418205038,
-0.0365873799,
0.0346308388,
0.0098153949,
0.0952405334,
-0.0394092165,
0.0090941694,
-0.0282848496,
-0.0097324159,
0.0471609756,
-0.0081379004,
-0.0324427038,
-0.0059212307,
0.0543264449,
-0.0174187757,
0.0169143081,
-0.0404341631,
-0.0159401968,
-0.0084822467,
0.0069643571,
0.011878103,
0.0151447915,
-0.0790537745,
-0.0167014245,
-0.0443046056,
0.0077363704,
0.0256658513,
-0.0142968958,
-0.057519868,
-0.0162081718,
-0.0053400882,
0.0151380496,
0.0029232851,
0.0321544297,
-0.037991114,
-0.0049894359,
-0.002850407,
0.0048133074,
0.0056589479,
-0.0241671335,
0.0350375697,
0.0131399464,
-0.0176285282,
-0.0322015211,
0.008028226,
-0.02235041,
-0.0118215904,
-0.0728777125,
0.0202855058,
-0.069039695,
0.0166118592,
-0.0277856346,
0.0366526283,
-0.008270123,
-0.0034531727,
0.0160803795,
-0.0039924127,
0.043567922,
-0.0350513197,
-0.046952676,
-0.0159608424,
0.0209335331,
-0.0006821702,
0.055153016,
-0.0119058816,
-0.0161176398,
-0.0043293429,
-0.0155360065,
0.0117093567,
-0.0034469939,
-0.0219139084,
-0.01415041,
0.0232155025,
0.0274064764,
0.0120745627,
0.0481237248,
0.0144999446,
0.052076757,
-0.0324303769,
0.0050340174,
0.0105146952,
0.076722376,
0.017824864,
0.0259987377,
0.0226512104,
-0.0182833392,
0.0255433694,
-0.0314210244,
-0.0090970164,
0.0150757991,
0.0257483106,
-0.0036121986,
0.0018047721,
0.0348404348,
-0.0369824879,
-0.0379714929,
-0.0233499575,
-0.0070729558,
-0.0483952984,
-0.0274314024,
0.0588077009,
0.0038137028,
0.007629625,
-0.0016662722,
0.0425865948,
-0.0052449661,
-0.0030464132,
-0.0452242494,
-0.0148324762,
0.0103260363,
0.089661397,
-0.0497482568,
-0.0251003578,
-0.0310841147,
-0.0408146083,
0.0054861358,
0.0133705074,
-0.0397768877,
-0.006473559,
-0.0473499484,
-0.0403206795,
0.0253898334,
0.0202949028,
-0.0307727456,
0.009359167,
0.0287600663,
-0.0195061266,
-0.0390946008,
-0.0728735998,
0.0371121168,
-0.0725927055,
-0.0286936592,
-0.010044422,
-0.0539815873,
0.0551572293,
-0.0186919756,
-0.0260046646,
0.0358080715,
0.0429994948,
-0.0364781432,
-0.0235141404,
0.007525987,
0.0052774395,
-0.0127358856,
0.0208261125,
-0.0653838813,
-0.020793451,
0.029037036,
-0.0490628369,
-0.0108835865,
-0.0123611791,
0.0003550361,
-0.001341756,
0.0055489508,
0.0130823757,
0.0042622439,
-0.014254448,
-0.0269258991,
0.0272144061,
-0.0074936026,
-0.0031554648,
0.0131968958,
-0.0816417262,
0.0069561033,
-0.0362169966,
-0.0154557917,
0.0433182865,
-0.0022041032,
0.017012883,
0.001445115,
0.0512841642,
-0.0185857583,
-0.0473469794,
-0.101453729,
0.0346810259,
0.0055665439,
0.0113759339,
0.0055564679,
-0.0177952517,
0.0097590238,
-0.0003413477,
-0.0189501755,
-0.0002473273,
0.0037353386,
0.0324920192,
0.0261679403,
0.0162663031,
0.0132886367,
-0.0685008168,
-0.0496755391,
-0.0258674957,
0.0477593169,
0.0364644602,
0.0231779851,
-0.0030330883,
0.0146946777,
-0.0281884335,
0.0014613876,
-0.0017131622,
0.0013246314,
0.0112694371,
-0.0163411479,
-0.035228733,
0.0458017997,
-0.014386747,
0.0055090012,
0.1046379507,
0.0196647104,
-0.0130619342,
0.0132017368,
-0.0090025254,
0.0035327114,
0.0128762173,
-0.0542308278,
0.0339298807,
0.0438181721,
-0.0322277322,
-0.0019872333,
-0.0281575751,
-0.0142037245,
-0.0195979606,
-0.0151309362,
-0.0327446312,
-0.0106514776,
-0.0118949143,
0.0292356964,
-0.0243261848,
-0.0256093573,
0.0741822645,
-0.0047025662,
0.0241541918,
-0.1221232787,
0.0047927392,
-0.0560865253,
-0.0050010034,
0.0095113581,
0.0103047201,
0.0197155606,
0.021284461,
-0.0093737515,
-0.0271024406,
0.0154714352,
-0.0149975177,
0.0180427302,
-0.0505663604,
0.0557322726,
-0.0077300263,
-0.0477567501,
-0.0058131092,
0.0174970254,
-0.0306466054,
0.0373146497,
0.0262574945,
0.0059961989,
-0.0909229144,
0.029361384,
0.0313105583,
0.0869801715,
-0.0042421008,
-0.0258203782,
-0.0141337914,
-0.0335227549,
0.0621762946,
-0.0806543231,
0.0005735555,
-0.0227318611,
0.0458869673,
0.0830765218,
0.0307689495,
-0.0018076638,
-0.0244045611,
0.0013957846,
0.0050295019,
-0.0774195567,
0.0025301524,
0.0019451091,
0.0212739613,
-0.0493585765,
-0.0272009149,
0.0861221924,
0.0201132353,
-0.1193185672,
-0.0105956485,
-0.0473831408,
-0.0158072263,
-0.0142479502,
0.0321410261,
-0.042680297,
-0.0250394568,
0.0198508184,
0.0325453468,
-0.0123467827,
-0.0203106906,
0.0095911715,
-0.0608573779,
0.0677919611,
0.0103903264,
-0.0074618007,
-0.0361751392,
-0.0454377681,
0.012068334,
-0.0639393255,
-0.0401825085,
0.0154387495,
-0.0715395063,
0.003687796,
0.0081813969,
-0.0416318998,
-0.061402522,
0.0596198104,
-0.022720417,
0.0343636647,
0.0148248589,
0.0152834356,
-0.0213078391,
0.0039360798,
0.0797269493,
-0.0524012782,
-0.0070644272,
-0.034560129,
0.0834054202,
0.0140139489,
0.0390399098,
-0.0105630709,
0.0221452452,
-0.033803612,
-0.0296880212,
0.0255940221,
0.1182321832,
-0.0304743629,
-0.0475246459,
-0.0471755154,
0.0344940126,
-0.0116381254,
0.060827896,
-0.0159899667,
-0.0043236809,
-0.0337395817,
-0.001527033,
-0.0078942711,
0.0093477592,
-0.0382646918,
0.0149455909,
-0.0333641395,
-0.0690753609,
-0.0441987514,
-0.0347559378,
0.0635951161,
0.0092302859,
0.0093409531,
0.0226007942,
0.0560975485,
-0.0120774209,
-0.0157969967,
0.0629986599,
-0.0025259531,
-0.0086766817,
-0.0515124351,
-0.0046664705,
0.0668107495,
0.0027677778,
-0.01021118,
0.0105936788,
-0.0164461043,
-0.0162185617,
-0.0445545688,
0.0587255806,
0.0284572393,
0.0084812576,
-0.0180431493,
-0.0407980792,
0.0400706232,
-0.0221387167,
0.0096922098,
-0.0309181027,
0.0047073294,
-0.0311293174,
-0.0012669548,
-0.0193742067,
-0.041689828,
0.0412328765,
-0.0280826744,
0.0021683946,
-0.0261812806,
0.0358666256,
0.0297723692,
0.0231520683,
0.0398048386,
-0.0130302319,
0.0133757731,
-0.0599875897,
0.0125861149,
-0.0064563686,
0.0139012001,
-0.0347251222,
0.0459939092,
0.0357564129,
0.0004409989,
-0.0092732115,
-0.0084572984,
-0.058747761,
-0.006404567,
-0.0505615994,
0.0651774704,
0.0197520871,
0.0487371869,
0.0466847643,
-0.041342143,
-0.0242111553,
-0.0070478409,
-0.0263251811,
0.0304095354,
-0.0257325973,
0.0340995528,
0.0063880412,
0.0330848545,
-0.0445527956,
0.0281744208,
-0.0678709075,
-0.0339212529,
-0.0199680198,
-0.0161970053,
0.0237852708,
0.0001968004,
0.0268005449,
-0.0345892124,
0.0056861793,
-0.0529162884,
0.0405241624,
-0.0051498436,
0.0326252058,
0.0300272871,
0.0365831144,
-0.0104115289,
-0.0594853088,
0.0890192017,
0.0143263107,
0.034628313,
0.0175346714,
-0.0565762669,
-0.0431760997,
-0.0611358359,
-0.0279371236,
0.033938501,
-0.0338949747,
-0.0098244585,
-0.0510016493,
-0.0353432707,
-0.0219154339,
-0.0001812922,
-0.0147891454,
-0.0124456305,
0.0237178635,
0.037274126,
0.0246547088,
-0.0161033403,
-0.0312422812,
0.0144332005,
0.006258918,
-0.0356168672,
-0.0046513057,
-6.031026214e-33,
0.0320207849,
0.0036187584,
0.0342807546,
-0.0135216303,
0.022388136,
0.0257411767,
-0.0571625978,
-0.0242596082,
0.024232056,
0.0631063804,
-0.0161042549,
0.0235578083,
-0.0037713363,
-0.018473547,
0.0584508218,
0.0197852552,
0.0476578251,
-0.0054577286,
0.0013092782,
0.0391549096,
-0.0019911169,
-0.0032991308,
0.018533498,
-0.0196464658,
0.0082821269,
0.0702497885,
0.0004127027,
-0.0128334798,
-0.0251843613,
0.0604150295,
-0.0247422457,
0.0048958184,
0.0277183317,
0.0050091548,
0.0012993853,
-0.0016197218,
-0.0681422949,
-0.0279964861,
0.0016930515,
-0.0333605632,
-0.0240145773,
-0.0386144221,
0.0543448776,
0.0043284968,
-0.0287120398,
-0.0268264785,
0.0312841535,
-0.0487472787,
-0.0381012484,
-0.0728201568,
-0.0652194172,
0.0635958463,
-0.0125658577,
0.0137662543,
0.0191286094,
0.0410346836,
-0.0170377437,
0.0245644394,
0.0127432188,
0.0311550647,
0.0457361601,
0.0425305739,
0.0024530697,
-0.0407184213,
-0.0491701365,
0.0709157735,
-0.0394359455,
-0.0086147645,
0.0427525714,
0.0017232524,
-0.0170445982,
0.033249855,
0.0146663813,
-0.0043155006,
0.0570548698,
0.0256427173,
-0.107586816,
0.0634135753,
-0.0406147949,
0.1107360125,
0.0548532046,
-0.0140041839,
-0.0031834198,
-0.0051780981,
-0.0181688126,
-0.0179628115,
-0.0192134678,
0.0224611051,
0.0219158549,
0.0232698843,
-0.0289133023,
-0.005133952,
0.0263708495,
-0.0129583739,
0.009824059,
0.0358899869,
-0.0072970027,
0.0046349731,
0.0153007098,
0.0028983047,
-0.0666961372,
-0.0299291294,
0.0156348031,
0.0069862432,
0.0410994366,
-0.0047442652,
0.0387657061,
-0.006741317,
-0.0684512854,
-0.0129344491,
-0.0218769517,
0.0322794393,
0.0184205435,
0.0754145458,
0.0022110373,
0.0101729836,
0.0239672326,
0.0311223026,
0.0138637051,
-0.0278356597,
-0.0190961231,
0.0557298623,
-0.008333263,
0.0097614536,
-0.0108653344,
0.0148124211,
-0.0400339179,
0.0076233307,
0.0566738471,
-0.0528615154,
0.0048094988,
0.0120405834,
2.842e-7,
0.0871251449,
0.0694218203,
-0.0261500347,
-0.0111659728,
0.0616388507,
0.0230657682,
-0.0153593756,
-0.0078625809,
0.0257238913,
0.0581527911,
0.043069642,
0.0129180886,
0.0289013684,
0.0399680771,
-0.0514990464,
-0.0324402824,
-0.059049204,
-0.035190817,
-0.0560313351,
-0.0586536005,
-0.0197205544,
0.0564656518,
-0.0413161032,
-0.0069718864,
-0.0215701349,
-0.0324029922,
0.0260021687,
-0.0268725734,
0.0041083521,
0.0514515825,
0.0352508388,
-0.0016807741,
0.0239127018,
0.0127245719,
-0.0356412567,
-0.0063321693,
-0.0273478683,
0.0991864055,
-0.0337050222,
0.0446503721,
0.0789919868,
0.0024135159,
0.0351603664,
-0.0590578318,
0.0491734855,
-0.0544949286,
-0.034271799,
-0.0568288602,
-0.0213258099,
-0.004449686,
0.0712136701,
-0.0166858435,
-0.0322511308,
0.0399360545,
-0.0009747803,
0.0031641885,
-0.0667577982,
-0.0477021523,
-0.0145406025,
0.0564731508,
-0.0297304075,
-0.0492734797,
0.0030624133,
-0.0551158749,
-0.0075150258,
-0.0868661553,
0.0243346803,
2.859568399e-34,
0.0759920552,
-0.0242056213,
-0.0081926845,
0.0046954905,
0.0157823507,
0.0085290354,
-0.0680016801,
0.0290341713,
0.0054750978,
-0.0483420156,
-0.0072341575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07342v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07342v1 | Emergent communication for AR | 2023-08-12T16:45:39 | 2023-08-12T16:45:39 | Ruxiao Chen, Shuaishuai Guo | eess.SP | eess.SP, cs.CL | Mobile augmented reality (MAR) is widely acknowledged as one of the
ubiquitous interfaces to the digital twin and Metaverse, demanding unparalleled
levels of latency, computational power, and energy efficiency. The existing
solutions for realizing MAR combine multiple technologies like edge, cloud
computing, and fifth-generation (5G) networks. However, the inherent
communication latency of visual data imposes apparent limitations on the
quality of experience (QoE). To address the challenge, we propose an emergent
semantic communication framework to learn the communication protocols in MAR.
Specifically, we train two agents through a modified Lewis signaling game to
emerge a discrete communication protocol spontaneously. Based on this protocol,
two agents can communicate about the abstract idea of visual data through
messages with extremely small data sizes in a noisy channel, which leads to
message errors. To better simulate real-world scenarios, we incorporate channel
uncertainty into our training process. Experiments have shown that the proposed
scheme has better generalization on unseen objects than traditional object
recognition used in MAR and can effectively enhance communication efficiency
through the utilization of small-size messages. | [
0.0287143793,
0.0366957486,
0.001731941,
0.0075918697,
-0.0045525571,
-0.0241276901,
0.0162232686,
-0.0070282207,
0.0005337822,
-0.0442860536,
0.0230348073,
0.0466668382,
0.0181924533,
-0.0042068791,
0.0072152531,
-0.0392387733,
-0.0288892388,
-0.013557177,
-0.0591630116,
-0.0086486284,
0.0244035982,
-0.0419454947,
-0.0177867357,
-0.0043504504,
-0.0201373659,
-0.0040659187,
-0.053951297,
0.0335550793,
0.0506249256,
-0.0931354091,
-0.0334725715,
-0.0182138048,
0.0357340239,
0.0271666516,
0.0000022114,
-0.0044057416,
0.0210876353,
-0.002839495,
-0.0010247809,
-0.0300316736,
-0.001250164,
0.0135403657,
0.0024921121,
0.0001102975,
-0.0225047283,
-0.0599138513,
0.0836292803,
0.0041004368,
0.0438676104,
0.0001128743,
0.0007535664,
0.0175752118,
0.0530740209,
0.0144961728,
0.0494194105,
-0.0410920493,
0.0016515279,
0.0409631617,
0.0326316804,
-0.0030802675,
-0.0261502862,
0.0313377827,
0.0246462598,
0.0435945243,
0.0576792508,
0.0504445657,
0.0374280699,
0.0136663709,
-0.0476034246,
0.0320664272,
-0.0093459152,
-0.0266495086,
0.0382614695,
0.0074002193,
0.0021100079,
0.0284311865,
-0.0413607918,
0.0093204929,
-0.0261485074,
-0.0277476851,
-0.0456464551,
0.0132929543,
-0.0103575876,
-0.0127229569,
0.0100769261,
-0.0023908825,
-0.0028120517,
0.0265240297,
-0.0593417846,
0.0126363281,
-0.0579139069,
-0.0297824852,
0.0057945903,
-0.0144363623,
-0.004240049,
-0.0030936624,
-0.0472600758,
-0.0242085569,
-0.061952047,
-0.0478611104,
0.0610240065,
-0.0200510193,
-0.007160834,
0.0524610393,
0.0152904131,
-0.0017086676,
0.0209826846,
-0.0098020565,
-0.0070862132,
0.0362137295,
-0.0524507947,
0.0056102411,
-0.0207566395,
0.0189046375,
-0.0415189825,
-0.0295726694,
0.0080772461,
0.0067582182,
-0.0244593546,
-0.0076682321,
-0.047871884,
0.0199674983,
-0.0293354336,
-0.0027039798,
-0.0326475762,
0.0245638397,
0.0195885897,
0.0418458506,
0.0165982675,
-0.0784114152,
0.0276827291,
0.0206757896,
0.0333782136,
0.0465060025,
-0.012821801,
0.0538042039,
-0.0391793475,
-0.0233158022,
0.0109396568,
0.0018856125,
0.068733491,
-0.0044258796,
0.04456909,
-0.0181375276,
0.0124336425,
-0.0337377414,
0.0165273156,
0.0079370672,
0.0187440757,
-0.001486423,
-0.003758919,
0.1024330035,
-0.0727498233,
0.0282682665,
0.0542558953,
0.0351089127,
-0.0007439617,
0.0081621725,
0.0568342358,
0.03639175,
-0.0036129141,
0.0094899954,
0.0238295197,
0.0161514413,
0.0386427604,
-0.0134469373,
0.0103881536,
-0.0431656651,
-0.0358527638,
0.0959482118,
-0.0676997826,
0.0188775491,
-0.0739063919,
-0.0329663083,
0.0596752204,
0.0249246284,
0.0120574692,
-0.0096094953,
-0.0094496105,
0.0358060934,
0.0079516927,
-0.0795684382,
-0.0280477926,
0.0680326372,
-0.0819107294,
-0.0013218441,
0.0091434792,
-0.0127223637,
-0.0388816595,
-0.0324067324,
-0.0004052102,
-0.0453014784,
0.0877309963,
0.011444035,
0.0234857388,
0.0035022446,
-0.0392285325,
-0.0568525046,
-0.0100097917,
0.0051736725,
-0.036360465,
-0.0372351408,
0.0338431858,
0.0247512124,
0.0536364913,
0.0388898142,
-0.0165933874,
0.0146678146,
0.0434385501,
0.0322084166,
0.0031963764,
-0.0174256824,
0.0457287729,
-0.0294881966,
-0.0141711067,
0.0419950448,
-0.0102309585,
0.0078140646,
0.0022002761,
0.0156463981,
-0.028757887,
0.0002181832,
-0.0326289274,
0.009873596,
-0.0058370661,
-0.0396839269,
0.031083094,
0.0002702407,
-0.0092699416,
-0.0134485941,
0.0221978147,
-0.0175813381,
0.0308135971,
-0.0086219767,
0.0443479158,
0.0256361756,
-0.0058057155,
0.039421767,
0.0162564367,
-0.0720575005,
0.0580998696,
0.0167302806,
-0.0117689325,
0.0026941262,
0.0427084863,
0.033718098,
0.0322328247,
0.0260747336,
-0.0137394648,
0.0367084444,
-0.0072116866,
0.0048411912,
-0.0110096233,
-0.0182105862,
-0.0224218257,
-0.0756540671,
0.0473661311,
0.0092659555,
-0.0135760913,
0.0482198223,
-0.0309568718,
0.0278127193,
0.0442632958,
0.028277766,
-0.0079955431,
-0.0033030612,
0.0309783854,
-0.0759103298,
-0.0425263532,
-0.0194588732,
-0.0240916088,
0.0176927205,
-0.0129110683,
-0.0032365145,
-0.0482719243,
-0.0091921911,
0.1145676747,
0.0066441316,
0.0293588806,
0.0163432807,
0.0481590778,
-0.0283825789,
-0.0166302007,
0.004225581,
0.0340099446,
0.0465005115,
0.065278925,
-0.011349855,
-0.0533999093,
-0.0268854406,
-0.0113477251,
0.0146223502,
-0.0231053904,
-0.0180095676,
0.016911922,
-0.0443862602,
-0.062684238,
0.0127421487,
-0.0100668324,
0.0480931997,
0.0041435077,
-0.0126201157,
-0.0153636793,
0.0038889418,
0.001312845,
0.0075246333,
-0.0423567221,
0.0162406415,
0.0156364255,
0.0648271814,
-0.0610690601,
0.005347569,
-0.0190852471,
0.0041166507,
0.0315263644,
-0.0860679969,
-0.0113304686,
0.0224052016,
0.0145490961,
0.0122115426,
-0.0158230346,
0.0094307614,
0.0369382538,
0.0060253493,
-0.0119361123,
-0.017669104,
0.0052930214,
0.0307223629,
0.0420004651,
-0.0052984389,
0.0125521235,
-0.0152214421,
0.0125528034,
0.0306439437,
-0.0348895602,
0.0322773643,
0.0000723245,
-0.0089046583,
-0.0741333887,
0.0010755471,
-0.0062573692,
-0.0398202799,
-0.0023906289,
0.0510348268,
-0.0383390859,
-0.0108170379,
-0.1140352339,
-0.0357162692,
-0.0543409102,
-0.0043273848,
-0.0340110734,
0.0069157649,
0.0013616702,
-0.0610869229,
-0.0101020411,
-0.0038980839,
0.017554801,
0.0425673723,
-0.0176954791,
-0.0576201677,
-0.0215143841,
0.0308742281,
-0.014499886,
-0.0134893833,
-0.0695081949,
0.0054343082,
0.0483317599,
0.036245551,
-0.0239444505,
0.0585297719,
0.0131366272,
-0.020995874,
-0.0160017945,
0.0005047284,
-0.0028804126,
-0.0092943376,
0.0011339025,
-0.0187841393,
0.0397082642,
-0.0213133488,
0.0138711641,
-0.1207659096,
-0.0646790341,
-0.0174542814,
-0.0207156856,
0.0240707863,
-0.0364945792,
0.0109290062,
-0.0355901606,
-0.0136896512,
0.0073285322,
-0.0192565732,
-0.0360812396,
-0.0002135604,
0.0006847067,
-0.0160441045,
-0.0204362459,
-0.0062869322,
-0.0065300241,
0.0225095097,
-0.0022512584,
0.0205812789,
0.0236128923,
0.0202253442,
-0.0100793652,
0.0359204113,
0.0280430615,
0.022858642,
0.0346600898,
-0.0889075622,
-0.0044058859,
0.0547657497,
-0.0096876184,
-0.0387758687,
-0.040463794,
-0.0113533549,
0.0133180059,
0.0342007317,
0.0182230249,
0.0288396534,
-0.0225350987,
0.0069839442,
0.0423151068,
0.017558597,
-0.0046505886,
0.0110169901,
0.0039549833,
0.0533121191,
-0.0080576539,
-0.0239262301,
-0.0106378747,
-0.0417487174,
-0.020775985,
0.0693612099,
0.0271802396,
-0.0527534299,
-0.0090742763,
0.0415912382,
-0.0616009757,
-0.0908071846,
-0.0019731484,
0.0229532458,
0.068206884,
-0.0067500575,
-0.0153863169,
-0.0005413227,
0.0825863108,
-0.049005989,
-0.0225997921,
0.0067222719,
-0.0337072127,
-0.0157754142,
0.0241580382,
-0.004084033,
-0.1207046956,
-0.0038372348,
0.0231172312,
-0.0565387942,
-0.0386533663,
0.027078636,
0.0322831906,
0.0149648879,
0.046387244,
-0.0004714392,
-0.0615383163,
0.0160294175,
0.1165881231,
0.0089116609,
0.0230674483,
0.0478368066,
0.0487425998,
0.0211695712,
0.0114609096,
-0.0403347239,
0.0202754159,
-0.0074542444,
-0.0088352468,
-0.0522891469,
-0.0374179557,
-0.0104830517,
-0.0054963697,
0.0542607866,
-0.0070734117,
-0.0360666737,
0.002110804,
0.0129017578,
-0.0109293284,
0.0555873886,
-0.0684652701,
0.0190160573,
-0.065178588,
0.0226482693,
0.0653492436,
0.0161451884,
0.0827107877,
0.0430510119,
0.0206101742,
0.0020441914,
0.0001493475,
-0.0076200324,
-0.0043502124,
0.0296930335,
0.032897979,
0.006006802,
-0.0046128798,
0.0525538921,
-0.0126175554,
0.0306003802,
0.0584518053,
-0.0567649864,
-0.0079515669,
0.0526248291,
0.0112348003,
-0.0604628511,
0.0192679483,
0.1237719655,
0.0439954996,
0.0734472722,
-0.0076056286,
-0.0862873569,
0.0482262149,
-0.0595659502,
0.0220930856,
-0.0291675795,
-0.043821279,
0.0539952256,
0.030022515,
0.0259340983,
0.0167623367,
-0.0293084998,
-0.0074570333,
0.0048432793,
-0.0284848232,
-0.0066119242,
-0.0275222491,
0.006681758,
0.0223724879,
0.0384095572,
-0.006309025,
0.071502015,
0.0147185707,
0.0353624895,
-0.0584286489,
0.0787521154,
0.0226399135,
-0.0372271463,
0.0419897027,
0.0214676745,
-0.0124266939,
-0.0136275226,
-0.0261242557,
-0.0485540144,
-0.0067322361,
-0.0077833636,
0.0253900196,
-6.405558183e-33,
0.0096037397,
-0.0267034117,
0.0568265654,
-0.0054275347,
0.0184852313,
-0.0216630753,
-0.0039079105,
-0.0129431793,
-0.0101318024,
0.0020012385,
-0.0296693873,
-0.0309185293,
-0.0105232047,
0.0360978022,
-0.0336365551,
-0.0004360362,
0.0307982098,
0.020148322,
-0.037196435,
-0.0019544729,
0.0169087369,
0.0002669398,
-0.0012564866,
-0.0403208844,
-0.0478631668,
0.0182769056,
-0.0140715111,
-0.030751707,
-0.0118783228,
0.0033028978,
-0.0400494486,
-0.0319376513,
-0.0008307757,
0.0073763505,
-0.0044543264,
-0.0223977156,
-0.0711482242,
-0.0142687839,
-0.0341789909,
0.0200168565,
-0.0933204815,
-0.0003945181,
-0.0175366122,
0.0088056801,
-0.0735678226,
-0.0031959892,
0.0070662117,
-0.0320920497,
-0.0641956329,
0.0468160808,
0.0255017411,
0.0168471728,
0.0140491053,
-0.0321746357,
0.0806749985,
-0.0318825357,
-0.0015746015,
-0.0172235426,
-0.0896918699,
0.0776359513,
-0.0569225028,
-0.0182602797,
0.0282708574,
0.0176127069,
0.0478152148,
0.0381451584,
0.0414593257,
-0.0418539308,
-0.0226783659,
0.0246031843,
-0.0180919096,
0.0144676603,
0.003307682,
0.0233380031,
0.0850284174,
-0.0011849256,
-0.0155450199,
-0.0120776435,
0.0149786901,
0.039833203,
-0.0181643348,
0.0407137498,
-0.0618387796,
0.0040034233,
-0.0000733698,
0.0041852812,
0.026431663,
-0.0228046458,
0.0123860911,
0.0729059801,
-0.021575911,
0.0418898351,
0.0515541472,
-0.0491665006,
-0.0620408021,
-0.06231663,
0.0336697921,
0.0658833683,
0.0054995366,
-0.040106453,
-0.0539922677,
0.0045015709,
0.0235657524,
-0.0049347393,
0.0274377037,
0.0072436118,
-0.0057038208,
0.0604180731,
0.0169283058,
-0.0055117998,
-0.0022357279,
0.0654714182,
0.0624567531,
-0.1028913036,
0.0287738685,
-0.0087664509,
0.001497114,
0.0538960472,
-0.0489314385,
-0.0275518149,
0.0121711222,
-0.0242228657,
-0.0304612517,
0.0128707113,
-0.0539741255,
0.0063716802,
-0.1010786295,
-0.0014280345,
0.0161205474,
-0.0722778365,
-0.0446643196,
0.0101339603,
3.233e-7,
-0.1011984497,
0.0246833283,
-0.015803989,
-0.0071524163,
0.011114453,
0.0648380741,
0.0224439912,
0.0754886344,
-0.0307619702,
-0.0046518533,
-0.0016487177,
0.0435490236,
0.0198740251,
-0.0470624752,
-0.0599880703,
-0.0370955467,
-0.0033684131,
0.0110556511,
0.0028297717,
-0.009463286,
0.0139852511,
-0.0200910121,
0.0231689736,
0.0068285051,
0.0983857289,
0.0445058048,
0.0268930644,
-0.0034665056,
0.029357139,
-0.0065919063,
0.0539419614,
-0.0171799529,
-0.039156314,
-0.0271558166,
-0.0053637256,
-0.0374435037,
-0.0207473207,
-0.0083549432,
-0.0477734506,
0.0074688657,
0.0007034657,
0.0125065586,
-0.0236846097,
0.032890562,
0.0370775945,
-0.0156776533,
-0.0321267843,
0.0150782531,
-0.0291447081,
0.0044212025,
-0.0456751399,
0.0072657117,
-0.0698240027,
-0.0732062757,
-0.026817156,
-0.0002774281,
-0.0011462385,
-0.0287546422,
0.0342329405,
-0.030782653,
0.0086493306,
-0.0281849448,
-0.0525389947,
0.011438462,
0.0141010871,
-0.0151641639,
-0.043782495,
2.154870556e-34,
0.012358061,
0.0169100445,
-0.0200792849,
0.0200821757,
0.0004085565,
-0.0363646261,
0.056283962,
0.0176715888,
0.0509954691,
-0.0119736046,
-0.0023292594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06595v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.06595v4 | VisIT-Bench: A Benchmark for Vision-Language Instruction Following Inspired by Real-World Use | 2023-08-12T15:27:51 | 2023-12-26T15:57:47 | Yonatan Bitton, Hritik Bansal, Jack Hessel, Rulin Shao, Wanrong Zhu, Anas Awadalla, Josh Gardner, Rohan Taori, Ludwig Schmidt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | We introduce VisIT-Bench (Visual InsTruction Benchmark), a benchmark for
evaluation of instruction-following vision-language models for real-world use.
Our starting point is curating 70 'instruction families' that we envision
instruction tuned vision-language models should be able to address. Extending
beyond evaluations like VQAv2 and COCO, tasks range from basic recognition to
game playing and creative generation. Following curation, our dataset comprises
592 test queries, each with a human-authored instruction-conditioned caption.
These descriptions surface instruction-specific factors, e.g., for an
instruction asking about the accessibility of a storefront for wheelchair
users, the instruction-conditioned caption describes ramps/potential obstacles.
These descriptions enable 1) collecting human-verified reference outputs for
each instance; and 2) automatic evaluation of candidate multimodal generations
using a text-only LLM, aligning with human judgment. We quantify quality gaps
between models and references using both human and automatic evaluations; e.g.,
the top-performing instruction-following model wins against the GPT-4 reference
in just 27% of the comparison. VisIT-Bench is dynamic to participate,
practitioners simply submit their model's response on the project website;
Data, code and leaderboard is available at visit-bench.github.io. | [
0.0309627708,
0.0540368184,
-0.0115866857,
0.054224439,
-0.0046299766,
0.0184339285,
-0.010968036,
0.0022157528,
0.0149956886,
-0.076132521,
-0.0203816257,
-0.0216187853,
0.0003401187,
0.0173886288,
0.0256684031,
-0.1050224155,
0.0335234851,
-0.0459847488,
-0.0702670068,
0.0299943853,
-0.0120137101,
0.007399051,
-0.0438766144,
0.0621502399,
-0.0012015431,
-0.0344803445,
-0.0183430817,
0.0522221476,
-0.0052842461,
-0.064425543,
0.0017333825,
0.0458847657,
0.0304167066,
-0.0224649105,
0.0000020068,
-0.0321514718,
0.0279621202,
-0.0290311836,
0.0302979294,
-0.0036537964,
0.0414084233,
0.0059299562,
0.0186271425,
0.0182519909,
-0.0137370238,
-0.0005537925,
0.0524538308,
-0.0051182918,
0.0748172998,
0.0484154634,
0.0044097938,
-0.0017421324,
-0.007585478,
-0.0110414214,
0.0538288541,
-0.0528163053,
-0.0140753509,
0.0238020625,
0.0098819053,
0.0045255069,
-0.0455840006,
0.0365440696,
0.0152377142,
-0.0012003508,
0.0377850384,
0.0235283319,
-0.0322376266,
-0.0019877674,
-0.0328755789,
0.1019830033,
0.0001216353,
0.030115502,
-0.0137666455,
0.0173562188,
0.0241316464,
-0.0009358384,
-0.0542050675,
0.0146089895,
0.0055846823,
-0.0099215144,
-0.044038184,
-0.0082787694,
-0.0059541794,
-0.0112368409,
0.0384112895,
-0.0110509424,
-0.0038412742,
-0.0034256401,
0.0039687138,
0.0178762041,
-0.00923,
-0.0443833843,
-0.0182552747,
0.019330591,
-0.0277691595,
0.0237704422,
-0.0609791949,
0.0274926163,
0.0058881305,
-0.0282230023,
0.1186687052,
0.0572695173,
-0.0504047014,
0.0565107688,
-0.0371402837,
0.0949922577,
-0.0012054896,
0.0336452536,
-0.0509171039,
0.0442222022,
-0.0637516305,
0.0118698161,
-0.0436840355,
0.0050721783,
-0.0789752454,
-0.0134362634,
-0.0328590199,
0.0510446467,
-0.005676731,
0.0153989829,
0.0230979752,
0.0297712293,
-0.0284252558,
0.0250584502,
-0.0478520095,
0.0116789173,
-0.0246616416,
-0.0014042974,
-0.0180064682,
-0.0780878589,
0.0080464054,
0.029599404,
-0.0067780549,
-0.003432611,
0.0034968802,
0.0955533087,
-0.0352278128,
-0.0387282483,
-0.0435367301,
-0.040775992,
0.0055134315,
-0.0324116834,
0.0291733015,
-0.0486847423,
0.0157665536,
-0.0298970342,
0.0170386508,
-0.0272154566,
0.0173099805,
0.0575884879,
-0.0013189781,
0.0746217445,
0.0176772755,
0.0159021746,
-0.0039470359,
0.0292838626,
0.0123565551,
0.0754350647,
0.0370210595,
0.0364322923,
0.0411018431,
-0.0050912173,
0.0170558412,
0.0353223644,
-0.0155270994,
0.0132709872,
-0.0337134935,
0.0125875603,
0.0042821234,
0.0448600501,
0.0038071042,
0.0494052656,
-0.0012727538,
-0.0204357486,
0.0581967123,
0.0276026167,
-0.0187338851,
-0.039090503,
0.0654204488,
0.0065193544,
0.0075119329,
-0.0026597071,
-0.0474155359,
0.0541757196,
-0.0133488867,
0.0035187465,
-0.0121090924,
0.0172890257,
-0.0283647459,
-0.0487042218,
0.0001765279,
-0.0057359007,
0.0058061755,
-0.0128284739,
0.0300751068,
-0.0057460885,
-0.0845658854,
-0.0177211426,
-0.0034311661,
-0.0574505627,
0.0137477657,
-0.0554054342,
-0.0151226809,
0.0851215273,
0.0479558446,
0.011716472,
-0.0480303727,
0.0122706722,
0.0479418896,
0.034644369,
0.0315791108,
-0.0195416752,
0.0305238497,
-0.0469036922,
-0.0636791661,
-0.0131570091,
-0.0014977918,
0.0123617649,
0.0033454464,
-0.0104831932,
0.0199035816,
-0.0366767123,
-0.0412954688,
0.0578510016,
0.0201035812,
-0.0432288572,
-0.0284622535,
0.0058451681,
-0.0026833282,
0.010057522,
0.0007517863,
0.001962726,
0.0229161903,
-0.008229604,
0.0477303118,
0.0371195264,
-0.0627447963,
-0.0408673957,
0.0231441744,
-0.102665782,
0.0095640197,
0.0239528641,
-0.045891203,
-0.0131117273,
-0.0057347044,
-0.0497820452,
-0.0186915491,
-0.0121643981,
0.0170511473,
0.0124713127,
-0.0476552881,
-0.0128468461,
0.0486519262,
-0.0469169654,
-0.0055594915,
0.0402697399,
-0.0094053186,
-0.0021164538,
-0.0488184057,
-0.0073023424,
0.0119897379,
-0.016844796,
0.0208810046,
-0.0040067392,
0.0552939698,
-0.0725180209,
0.0142083718,
-0.0967627689,
-0.0137741286,
-0.0188443288,
-0.0065779653,
0.0123982336,
-0.0345833898,
-0.0058947382,
-0.0431579128,
-0.0214101076,
0.0142889153,
-0.0215629693,
0.0161379799,
0.0353544056,
0.0076470366,
-0.0092577739,
-0.0350284278,
-0.0067144618,
-0.0108055798,
0.0344459563,
0.0282909833,
0.0258853976,
-0.0413109921,
0.0073353369,
-0.0145841073,
0.0351780318,
-0.012665431,
-0.0309449341,
0.0351526998,
0.001194985,
0.020167578,
0.0636602491,
0.0108464519,
0.0046628062,
0.0251048747,
-0.0276522748,
-0.044687368,
0.0250829197,
-0.00203606,
-0.056190718,
-0.0248783678,
-0.0713629797,
0.0032920507,
0.048135221,
-0.0181450956,
0.0264306851,
-0.0930944234,
0.0341999643,
-0.012642011,
-0.0275760107,
-0.0671507344,
0.0194997061,
-0.0068096044,
-0.0002754679,
-0.0408435762,
-0.0656024367,
0.056395255,
-0.038886141,
-0.0144510064,
-0.0127520524,
0.0256493129,
-0.0156972855,
0.0758888945,
0.0203530136,
0.0175738949,
-0.0024157539,
-0.0120721534,
-0.0514351577,
0.021392351,
0.0225148238,
-0.0312125925,
0.0753610283,
-0.108191818,
-0.0085348515,
0.0030419112,
-0.0127296234,
-0.0521662757,
0.0077460418,
-0.010618791,
-0.0179600921,
0.0087267756,
-0.0113350451,
-0.0404836088,
0.0129011115,
0.0145513387,
0.0370137431,
0.0184452124,
-0.0293975938,
-0.0323881619,
-0.0077263638,
0.0616878793,
0.0247311499,
-0.0551317073,
-0.0528265983,
-0.0018267502,
0.0598792061,
0.0608000159,
-0.0410071872,
-0.0211966578,
0.0349038616,
0.0460414514,
-0.0107842321,
-0.0089094844,
0.0666711777,
0.0636882931,
-0.061004784,
-0.0119563192,
0.0825163871,
0.0216240268,
-0.0399130918,
-0.0047218073,
0.0320217684,
0.0162775833,
0.0415003896,
0.0119124614,
-0.0885529295,
-0.0489313416,
-0.0081355097,
0.0730102062,
0.010707452,
-0.0096125137,
-0.0314616486,
-0.1087572053,
0.0511916205,
0.0047184839,
-0.0218273848,
-0.0167240687,
-0.0097603295,
-0.0030089533,
-0.0120974621,
-0.0260793157,
0.0246537793,
-0.0529612079,
0.019545678,
0.0240602363,
-0.0005913101,
-0.0423411019,
0.0362197272,
-0.0469550118,
0.0161474477,
0.0810355395,
-0.0016490732,
0.0296761487,
-0.0796950534,
0.0100652948,
-0.0412324257,
0.0361434929,
-0.0266781431,
0.0734956935,
-0.051828783,
-0.0149254212,
0.0062657106,
0.0209815502,
-0.0469384901,
-0.0031339366,
0.0157961827,
0.0244485326,
-0.0118618254,
0.004711966,
-0.0532153733,
0.012688145,
-0.0211886894,
0.0668958053,
0.0082798926,
-0.0180843193,
-0.0185248926,
-0.0477464013,
0.0046292706,
-0.0826041922,
-0.0397429839,
-0.0069627399,
-0.0285879541,
0.0078241974,
-0.0947168544,
-0.0441546254,
0.0364029445,
0.0556402728,
-0.0076834913,
-0.0334185585,
0.007660192,
0.0146402,
-0.0524947345,
0.050408978,
-0.0326444469,
0.0163475797,
-0.0981756598,
-0.0350599177,
0.0098624257,
-0.0271301754,
-0.015992431,
0.0163593441,
-0.0380199924,
-0.0221139155,
-0.0169945974,
0.0949914306,
0.0183609761,
0.0087890839,
0.0245471057,
-0.0333148912,
-0.0297839902,
0.0510177501,
0.0483012646,
0.0215653013,
-0.0015290612,
-0.0321201831,
-0.0040626,
-0.005290363,
-0.0501477793,
0.0157066211,
-0.0244476236,
0.0541894697,
-0.0017245152,
0.0005134958,
0.0212706011,
0.0099888379,
0.0484934263,
-0.0264896639,
0.015607262,
-0.0107793296,
0.0222082734,
-0.0083656451,
0.0004075031,
-0.0760060027,
0.0193310808,
0.0222920477,
0.0040898924,
0.0138088446,
-0.0053149089,
-0.0256613214,
0.0179735683,
-0.065032497,
0.0216466635,
0.0388737507,
0.0020621514,
-0.0125853289,
0.0127977869,
-0.0019532784,
0.0251919329,
-0.0167868827,
0.0589529537,
0.0197294652,
0.0781656876,
0.0178558156,
0.0007458816,
0.0074939001,
0.0344466828,
0.0011730134,
-0.0145462453,
-0.0484380238,
0.034519732,
0.0569207743,
0.0140312267,
0.0012216216,
-0.0035449895,
0.0098836068,
-0.0153064486,
0.0183949322,
0.0201610308,
-0.0488477461,
0.0402263887,
0.0346249156,
0.0230425783,
-0.033971034,
0.0633622631,
0.0145982066,
0.0477724113,
0.0010624191,
-0.0157729089,
-0.0383859985,
-0.0163032748,
0.0337923653,
0.0255929343,
-0.0080795791,
0.0359192975,
-0.0441401303,
-0.0480197072,
-0.0095052095,
0.0417235345,
0.0298789702,
-0.0003963513,
0.0824639276,
0.026622517,
0.0097672213,
-0.0453318171,
-0.0313300975,
-0.0156780761,
-0.0542925373,
0.0036550427,
-0.0045645139,
-6.032982677e-33,
-0.0398436002,
-0.0357010029,
0.0476899818,
-0.0234498344,
-0.0035647135,
0.0060963905,
-0.0312752761,
0.0210133456,
-0.0212762915,
-0.0037272885,
0.0432552695,
-0.0219156332,
0.0074128401,
0.035325285,
0.0048709451,
-0.0214391779,
0.045956742,
-0.0067022699,
-0.0353166647,
0.0151086375,
-0.0014109572,
-0.0147480126,
0.0505038053,
-0.0628518462,
0.0172322076,
-0.0106085166,
-0.0259203762,
0.0259565916,
0.0288875587,
0.073852852,
-0.0081414543,
0.0252303984,
0.0261455905,
0.0083478428,
-0.0166982487,
-0.0145693934,
-0.0427136905,
-0.0280225184,
0.0284613445,
0.0286303777,
-0.1064905152,
0.0000110516,
0.0347715169,
-0.0128432075,
-0.0547567979,
-0.0297730807,
0.0447551236,
-0.0186552703,
0.0059622554,
0.0178869739,
-0.0472438037,
0.0047401045,
-0.00768233,
-0.0495937467,
0.0118912933,
0.0845114961,
0.028335426,
0.0268377569,
-0.0321808718,
0.0444448031,
0.0178007931,
0.0253792815,
0.1272093505,
0.0252803154,
-0.0017841873,
0.0383309163,
0.0166460928,
-0.0234130733,
-0.0233692937,
-0.021498384,
0.0376180895,
0.0916950479,
0.0399625674,
0.0323723443,
0.0298589449,
0.0263337083,
-0.0211489834,
0.06031394,
-0.0263920799,
0.0647593662,
0.0015777643,
0.0139202215,
-0.069895491,
0.0211701095,
-0.0462999642,
0.0021701823,
-0.0492582992,
-0.023502171,
0.0790158734,
0.0252440087,
-0.0151597923,
0.0160131566,
0.0376805961,
-0.0195137709,
-0.0063369325,
-0.0068089599,
-0.0325663947,
0.0473528989,
-0.0101900939,
0.0217745807,
-0.0263899341,
-0.0385223702,
0.0542774834,
-0.0140685262,
0.0331996307,
0.0059161414,
-0.0120927384,
0.0166841112,
-0.0505463108,
0.0116771627,
-0.036448434,
0.0080541642,
-0.0248258039,
0.0092466818,
0.039800752,
-0.0129022328,
-0.0696459711,
0.0693700761,
-0.0178812351,
-0.021341728,
-0.0421458967,
-0.0536942072,
0.0029104815,
0.0396325588,
-0.011922827,
0.0201099496,
-0.0346431471,
-0.0182728507,
-0.0014451724,
-0.0398874506,
-0.0251669679,
0.0302971918,
2.63e-7,
0.0185453892,
0.0607484058,
0.0077304798,
0.0397918783,
-0.0113157341,
0.0364480801,
-0.0269459505,
0.0198265053,
0.0029494753,
-0.0124862874,
0.0147800194,
0.0363905318,
0.0284559485,
-0.0022020671,
-0.0286101848,
0.016120784,
-0.001396489,
0.0088519957,
-0.0546991043,
0.0153824463,
0.0572368316,
0.0361443721,
-0.034484107,
0.0016229338,
0.0455655381,
-0.055961486,
0.040020857,
-0.0358520895,
0.0140172979,
-0.0042151716,
0.0284610819,
0.0439495184,
-0.0137413815,
0.0069883224,
-0.0428033732,
-0.0386931524,
0.0365091264,
0.0560786128,
-0.0173821151,
-0.0172464959,
0.0076193875,
0.0148021029,
-0.0057924716,
-0.040234331,
0.0553210564,
-0.0043286677,
0.0240748338,
-0.0025047427,
-0.0508034602,
-0.0038515751,
0.0140578514,
-0.0164444242,
-0.0344657153,
-0.0100228852,
0.0258006323,
-0.0298368894,
-0.0388172604,
-0.052851133,
-0.0069576795,
-0.0063054371,
-0.0126044545,
-0.0301613808,
-0.0753064081,
0.0096147219,
-0.0333877988,
-0.0315316021,
-0.0642132089,
2.316710184e-34,
0.0261265486,
-0.0098441066,
0.0400189646,
-0.0147126932,
0.0174093619,
0.0231067035,
-0.0307792109,
0.0050186552,
0.0132143488,
-0.0662686303,
-0.017862875
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.