id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13696v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13696v1 | On the Depth between Beam Search and Exhaustive Search for Text Generation | 2023-08-25T22:57:53 | 2023-08-25T22:57:53 | Yuu Jinnai, Tetsuro Morimura, Ukyo Honda | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Beam search and exhaustive search are two extreme ends of text decoding
algorithms with respect to the search depth. Beam search is limited in both
search width and depth, whereas exhaustive search is a global search that has
no such limitations. Surprisingly, beam search is not only computationally
cheaper but also performs better than exhaustive search despite its higher
search error. Plenty of research has investigated a range of beam widths, from
small to large, and reported that a beam width that is neither too large nor
too small is desirable. However, in terms of search depth, only the two extreme
ends, beam search and exhaustive search are studied intensively. In this paper,
we examine a range of search depths between the two extremes to discover the
desirable search depth. To this end, we introduce Lookahead Beam Search (LBS),
a multi-step lookahead search that optimizes the objective considering a fixed
number of future steps. Beam search and exhaustive search are special cases of
LBS where the lookahead depth is set to $0$ and $\infty$, respectively. We
empirically evaluate the performance of LBS and find that it outperforms beam
search overall on machine translation tasks. The result suggests there is room
for improvement in beam search by searching deeper. Inspired by the analysis,
we propose Lookbehind Heuristic Beam Search, a computationally feasible search
algorithm that heuristically simulates LBS with 1-step lookahead. The empirical
results show that the proposed method outperforms vanilla beam search on
machine translation and text summarization tasks. | [
0.0691148415,
0.0194809437,
0.0243328195,
0.0054304292,
-0.0129358349,
-0.0223419741,
-0.0016521795,
0.0295786392,
-0.0363705084,
0.0129079986,
-0.0051944894,
-0.0360750593,
0.0126625579,
0.0462352931,
0.0164579134,
-0.0719665661,
0.0215557665,
-0.0142286327,
-0.01066247,
-0.0016076763,
0.0125570893,
-0.00033703,
-0.0129638696,
0.0201231688,
-0.0000535949,
0.0478680953,
-0.0625553951,
0.0389482155,
0.0254794043,
-0.0326041579,
-0.0041715675,
-0.0362977535,
-0.0146317203,
0.0606888756,
0.00000234,
-0.0139118582,
-0.0424956121,
-0.0155239459,
0.0041704248,
0.0040261555,
0.0729198158,
-0.0790334344,
-0.0190086514,
0.0376281366,
0.0229635593,
-0.0314899869,
0.0709758699,
0.0169964265,
0.0400170162,
0.0693084896,
-0.0121330954,
-0.0561770014,
-0.0062969034,
-0.0317212865,
0.0317963772,
-0.1092779413,
-0.0134525495,
-0.0282946415,
0.0458256006,
0.0329156443,
-0.0084429672,
0.0557633825,
-0.0027896175,
-0.0325214453,
0.022748081,
0.0558721274,
-0.0371932611,
-0.0322991759,
0.0104255173,
0.0431297235,
-0.025447553,
-0.0152302207,
0.0303016119,
-0.0191274323,
-0.0355749764,
-0.0151564255,
-0.0096314577,
0.0489234328,
-0.0632733479,
0.0003770439,
0.0129726641,
0.0451932512,
0.0109358588,
-0.0065467255,
-0.0478711724,
0.0329489708,
0.0106178792,
-0.0561557971,
-0.0277174972,
0.0200138092,
0.0330757014,
-0.0460470282,
0.0888805911,
0.0302779078,
-0.0394656323,
0.0253075752,
-0.0491932109,
-0.0504421741,
-0.0056692939,
-0.0160322133,
-0.003383012,
0.0651324019,
0.0386285447,
0.009070185,
-0.0062394585,
0.0129699027,
-0.0007834173,
-0.0753468052,
-0.1155712754,
-0.0184668396,
-0.011142713,
-0.0127477478,
-0.0711548775,
-0.0020579463,
-0.0838254318,
-0.0663782582,
-0.03505091,
0.0183684472,
0.0820224509,
-0.0388433635,
-0.0291384589,
-0.0016043771,
-0.0389719456,
0.0072689722,
0.055481147,
0.0318289623,
-0.0338817574,
-0.0427360311,
-0.0138911325,
-0.0131912213,
-0.0253365692,
0.0400149338,
0.0193097107,
-0.0027378905,
-0.0218371358,
0.0554640666,
-0.0498738103,
-0.0120166624,
0.000269388,
-0.004818561,
-0.0382068455,
-0.0076451688,
0.014315269,
-0.0418125056,
0.0388837457,
0.0010468272,
-0.0368971303,
0.0248346366,
0.0300415978,
0.0389792435,
-0.0131136831,
0.0142601635,
-0.0192702897,
0.0171085019,
0.0643049255,
0.0028825428,
0.0054877438,
0.0504580885,
0.0251356885,
0.102738522,
0.007717282,
0.0072424617,
0.0091676367,
0.0581102148,
0.0194051228,
0.0028477057,
0.036601726,
-0.0259808134,
-0.0453024879,
0.0370721631,
0.0452252217,
0.0438781045,
-0.0706110001,
0.0431802869,
0.0148854423,
0.0440757722,
0.0649748296,
0.0048472369,
0.0464274511,
0.0552937686,
-0.0020442158,
0.0234575663,
0.0312926695,
0.0154231172,
-0.0641945079,
-0.0031949424,
0.0581971966,
-0.0267173741,
-0.0277699847,
-0.0048694168,
0.0122342333,
0.0334506482,
-0.0092597315,
-0.0111103598,
0.0000131263,
0.0225962587,
-0.1012245342,
0.0438714884,
-0.0119785126,
-0.0768648759,
-0.0057225684,
-0.014355449,
-0.0111069633,
0.0505275838,
0.0997726023,
0.0036271506,
0.0207009166,
0.0563590527,
-0.0103364708,
0.075878188,
0.0684672371,
0.009815162,
-0.0291873869,
-0.0691110045,
-0.0410456248,
0.0227260273,
-0.019341616,
0.0235637445,
-0.0168560781,
0.0118131442,
0.0167070962,
0.0266655907,
-0.0690812618,
0.0174920093,
-0.0217645317,
0.0218623187,
0.0004073523,
0.0102170175,
0.0080216443,
0.0137689384,
-0.0005210909,
0.0191863216,
-0.0007962615,
-0.0113975164,
-0.0266614985,
-0.0010784059,
-0.0236612186,
-0.0324773863,
-0.0473517515,
-0.0628744066,
0.0342905074,
-0.0074569765,
-0.0068315314,
-0.0457616188,
0.0145604312,
-0.0988446921,
-0.0228649694,
0.0037215766,
0.0343759246,
-0.0110159731,
-0.0077107917,
-0.0282722879,
0.0636047125,
-0.0017045062,
-0.0016350887,
-0.0173060521,
-0.0058791353,
0.0204024334,
-0.0454150662,
-0.0325180404,
0.0406792499,
0.0035104174,
-0.0290265549,
0.0408541113,
0.0350306444,
-0.0141383801,
-0.0407539085,
-0.067243591,
0.0266240947,
0.0023345044,
0.0089826463,
0.0414357632,
0.0322086513,
0.0092398748,
-0.0131374681,
-0.0158497673,
-0.0088585066,
0.0117077371,
0.0012202543,
0.0415446796,
0.0348865502,
-0.0082526626,
-0.0332016312,
-0.0247181989,
0.0036128445,
0.0130754421,
0.0455553234,
-0.0562130138,
-0.0714565068,
0.107223928,
-0.0182298608,
-0.050256297,
0.0000742349,
-0.0377486534,
0.0064238599,
-0.0230915938,
0.0360877886,
0.031303484,
0.0635996759,
0.0270448942,
-0.0099043353,
-0.0094687641,
-0.0279477779,
0.027193062,
-0.0238820165,
0.0513621941,
0.0199252497,
-0.0816937238,
0.068382062,
0.0394439213,
0.0374927819,
0.0457909405,
-0.0380441137,
-0.0102673126,
0.0131884012,
-0.0273705591,
-0.0422792658,
-0.0013619266,
-0.0134445848,
0.0237441435,
-0.0352726839,
-0.0014575215,
0.0274135917,
-0.0269900709,
0.0029856476,
-0.0766962692,
0.0126200421,
-0.0322614685,
-0.0028360519,
-0.0084125381,
0.0426752977,
-0.0582174398,
-0.0536601283,
0.0205093119,
0.0611014366,
0.0099411588,
-0.0338413753,
0.0213604625,
-0.0162561573,
0.0004262874,
-0.0546831265,
-0.0208512805,
-0.0437836945,
-0.0137293013,
0.0051380782,
-0.0230152346,
0.0739198029,
-0.0446509495,
-0.0763719454,
0.0128523717,
0.040845979,
0.0449977219,
-0.015455584,
-0.0278803911,
-0.0205245633,
0.0422235169,
-0.0035405918,
-0.0095925918,
0.0232082531,
-0.0218463596,
-0.0223807748,
0.044273816,
0.0229936894,
0.0069045904,
0.0117952498,
-0.0211801343,
0.0547624528,
-0.013727475,
-0.0441538244,
-0.0173798185,
0.0371896252,
-0.0307358764,
0.0089456914,
0.0436574854,
0.0153004881,
-0.0139450207,
-0.0122529631,
-0.012670083,
0.0233926401,
-0.008807091,
0.0410719775,
-0.0831001252,
-0.0212854352,
0.02387603,
0.0831919312,
-0.0149428174,
0.0032480985,
-0.0415113121,
-0.1013712212,
0.0400536954,
0.0184978694,
-0.0168601163,
-0.0210534316,
0.008732019,
-0.030397851,
0.0162956733,
-0.038716644,
0.0702791065,
-0.0100371046,
0.0066219345,
0.0028450077,
-0.0166425593,
-0.0262599234,
-0.0338273942,
0.0026251585,
-0.003700353,
0.0600101911,
0.0554809421,
0.0301912297,
0.0238674469,
-0.0165731572,
-0.0311678816,
0.0209658276,
-0.0398608819,
0.0155470185,
0.0018538191,
-0.0147553757,
-0.0345984325,
0.0077326233,
0.027204752,
0.0478627607,
0.0086778421,
-0.0003762155,
-0.0095827021,
-0.0056207585,
-0.0143849105,
0.0356413387,
0.0229436439,
0.0667543486,
0.0024597987,
-0.0207764972,
-0.0474006832,
-0.0580262132,
0.0021389383,
-0.1310968697,
-0.0514030382,
-0.0066812979,
0.0067548556,
-0.0039493185,
-0.0731784552,
-0.0198553987,
-0.0203552581,
0.0439534374,
-0.0119895162,
-0.013435307,
-0.0359098017,
-0.0271843933,
-0.0132105248,
-0.0471304767,
-0.0150362477,
0.0114316633,
-0.0263579804,
0.0205062628,
0.0082591502,
-0.0759137422,
-0.0004342901,
0.0644473508,
-0.0176885929,
-0.0257802084,
-0.0214952305,
0.0053038485,
0.0175312255,
0.0202881228,
-0.0260870848,
-0.0200461689,
0.0734979659,
0.0405900516,
-0.0300371442,
0.0247690789,
0.0145214191,
0.0077600852,
-0.02839889,
0.0032041466,
-0.0221176799,
0.0057201749,
-0.0355235077,
0.0534992628,
0.027879972,
-0.0328300446,
0.0169291236,
0.0380401313,
-0.0434837081,
-0.0394638628,
-0.0126204565,
-0.0205594841,
-0.0067390087,
-0.0193602014,
-0.0025687264,
-0.0407751314,
0.0308332089,
0.0226448793,
-0.0230166335,
0.0273133367,
0.0622693934,
-0.0209629778,
0.0095026139,
-0.0054534259,
0.0596800558,
0.0009516346,
0.0573886782,
0.0289318692,
-0.0083031999,
0.0083743259,
0.0022887893,
-0.0014675237,
0.0131641002,
-0.0189363081,
0.0051576081,
0.0420741588,
0.0148558551,
0.0001225346,
0.0463775173,
-0.0681024268,
0.0114481449,
-0.0379660651,
-0.0078609539,
0.0564676002,
0.0199990347,
0.056286566,
-0.0180389825,
0.015508485,
-0.0090904916,
-0.0132962624,
-0.002849831,
-0.0563534647,
-0.0343646668,
0.0258213412,
0.0145022431,
-0.0334597453,
0.0766827166,
-0.0370591357,
0.0518261939,
-0.0313835479,
0.0028295156,
-0.0426579677,
-0.0366025455,
0.0230121259,
0.0257302597,
-0.0289499201,
-0.0307731871,
-0.0432621464,
0.0294990577,
0.0617859848,
-0.0240373965,
0.0097310655,
-0.0166793093,
0.0603298955,
0.0347197615,
-0.0035007738,
0.0550016239,
-0.0370520763,
-0.0097701894,
-0.0378984362,
0.0084096808,
-0.0124255903,
-6.588060293e-33,
-0.0180704296,
-0.041938819,
0.0055565862,
0.0097035579,
-0.0602613688,
0.0154192373,
-0.0654579923,
-0.023177525,
0.0142840547,
-0.0276978109,
-0.0084366836,
0.017128367,
0.0234553721,
0.0001548193,
-0.0058503062,
0.0577808246,
0.0517044328,
-0.0274035875,
-0.0630315021,
0.0348822549,
0.0418196917,
0.0296586379,
-0.0128076635,
-0.0081877848,
-0.0146685224,
-0.0389512964,
-0.0427732281,
0.0010649986,
0.0311378464,
0.007413283,
-0.0224826131,
0.0325995572,
-0.0019682155,
-0.0530257002,
-0.0398223251,
0.0319889449,
-0.0280100033,
-0.0035389368,
-0.0043697627,
0.0016328654,
-0.0428390317,
-0.0491661616,
0.0091383653,
-0.0290726982,
-0.0273795091,
0.0224658046,
-0.0107504856,
-0.0451016463,
-0.0371776149,
-0.0546644777,
-0.0298937336,
0.0233044736,
-0.0138485655,
-0.0226019677,
0.0382387191,
0.0640684366,
0.034626212,
-0.0129424809,
-0.0447449461,
0.0745458081,
0.0110169277,
0.062640518,
0.0186538436,
-0.0176368207,
0.002140702,
0.0545368977,
0.062885657,
-0.04485083,
0.0009934172,
0.011446733,
-0.0022059681,
-0.0136164259,
-0.0041279369,
0.0426610596,
0.036470782,
-0.0030467864,
-0.0020090519,
0.0380077735,
-0.0307003055,
0.0318388157,
0.0344070084,
-0.0028809053,
-0.029759489,
-0.0071256901,
0.0003651829,
-0.0264359843,
-0.0323562063,
-0.0185745712,
0.015292149,
0.0735927969,
-0.0398928374,
-0.0273041297,
0.057910949,
0.0149455154,
0.0808049589,
0.0960809812,
-0.0380622298,
0.0202727765,
-0.0163378082,
-0.0161759295,
-0.0081341844,
-0.0387508795,
0.0346058011,
0.0013753576,
-0.0087150605,
0.0039440398,
-0.011732542,
0.0553856455,
-0.0257364996,
-0.0098470654,
-0.023468256,
0.0150392856,
-0.0152303614,
0.0336184576,
0.0160557739,
-0.0446628332,
-0.0062798047,
0.0212221928,
0.0015442781,
0.0353748277,
-0.0349650607,
0.0060930331,
0.0062163319,
0.0428313948,
-0.0447056256,
0.0552913174,
-0.0545896739,
-0.0072250934,
0.0047803107,
-0.0572149865,
-0.04211355,
0.0444015153,
2.99e-7,
0.0185937677,
0.0446731076,
0.0947184414,
0.0567977875,
0.0238697752,
0.0144017031,
0.0250386447,
0.0138621302,
-0.0404290557,
0.0408980921,
0.0150162289,
0.0026302426,
0.0617151819,
-0.0179839842,
-0.1073980927,
0.0180693623,
-0.0372777581,
-0.0028879072,
-0.0379913822,
-0.0132307531,
0.0656523854,
0.0431977995,
-0.0633639768,
-0.014209955,
0.0050110719,
-0.0066021653,
0.0434675701,
0.0793784782,
-0.0242334213,
0.0114021329,
0.0099506974,
0.0053077959,
-0.0377841927,
-0.0114145996,
-0.0332925841,
-0.0014576853,
0.0328090973,
0.0462383181,
0.0498427488,
-0.0124034034,
0.0530581065,
-0.0070469333,
-0.0143635878,
0.0280802026,
0.0087046307,
0.0009302979,
0.0178190898,
0.0332072861,
0.0058006938,
0.0122426674,
-0.0380584672,
-0.0407224819,
-0.0075251339,
0.0180456825,
-0.0018516512,
-0.0106039764,
-0.0033528022,
-0.027057169,
-0.0370984599,
-0.0441428199,
-0.0240491759,
0.0124590378,
-0.0530887283,
0.0215542,
0.0327529386,
-0.0501933508,
-0.0039254185,
2.851309173e-34,
0.0512603782,
-0.0318618864,
-0.0358697176,
-0.0245875735,
0.0226677097,
-0.0029559832,
-0.0667303652,
0.0376958251,
0.007659921,
-0.0286587942,
-0.0633616447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13687v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13687v1 | 1.5 million materials narratives generated by chatbots | 2023-08-25T22:00:53 | 2023-08-25T22:00:53 | Yang Jeong Park, Sung Eun Jerng, Jin-Sung Park, Choah Kwon, Chia-Wei Hsu, Zhichu Ren, Sungroh Yoon, Ju Li | cond-mat.mtrl-sci | cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.CL | The advent of artificial intelligence (AI) has enabled a comprehensive
exploration of materials for various applications. However, AI models often
prioritize frequently encountered materials in the scientific literature,
limiting the selection of suitable candidates based on inherent physical and
chemical properties. To address this imbalance, we have generated a dataset of
1,494,017 natural language-material paragraphs based on combined OQMD,
Materials Project, JARVIS, COD and AFLOW2 databases, which are dominated by ab
initio calculations and tend to be much more evenly distributed on the periodic
table. The generated text narratives were then polled and scored by both human
experts and ChatGPT-4, based on three rubrics: technical accuracy, language and
structure, and relevance and depth of content, showing similar scores but with
human-scored depth of content being the most lagging. The merger of
multi-modality data sources and large language model (LLM) holds immense
potential for AI frameworks to help the exploration and discovery of
solid-state materials for specific applications. | [
0.0365695022,
0.079678461,
-0.02694479,
0.029652955,
-0.0292135645,
-0.0188591201,
0.0046820799,
0.0080302414,
0.0352485515,
-0.0107369199,
-0.026456004,
0.0010082442,
-0.0101498384,
0.0662175864,
-0.0235930309,
-0.0103301052,
0.0247152429,
-0.0228344481,
0.063141264,
0.0022821659,
0.0200805571,
0.0050407867,
-0.0268426854,
0.0335507467,
-0.0055673346,
0.0066963066,
-0.0238720328,
-0.0014012923,
0.0404583588,
-0.0494809896,
0.0024969992,
0.0630605891,
0.0038508268,
0.0095498413,
0.0000020938,
-0.0504452102,
0.019224111,
0.0511587225,
0.0027749608,
-0.0216074865,
0.0818857476,
-0.052101437,
-0.0140428096,
0.0062968824,
-0.0493978523,
0.053025119,
0.0537189916,
0.028580362,
-0.0000206876,
0.0195694491,
-0.022103373,
0.0288376622,
0.0430982336,
0.0165112745,
0.0633339584,
-0.0317015126,
-0.002780915,
0.0499206819,
0.0551414974,
0.034888383,
0.0004246247,
0.0414391197,
-0.014068922,
-0.0304073207,
0.0429893024,
0.044753246,
-0.0575361364,
-0.0033817592,
0.0022057202,
0.1048841178,
0.061007753,
-0.0346914008,
-0.0157217477,
-0.0095894085,
-0.0266679637,
0.0154872304,
-0.0368304849,
0.0324517041,
-0.0178755615,
0.0004792915,
0.0055136592,
-0.0103039369,
-0.001569735,
0.0422942638,
0.025513947,
0.0387164429,
-0.0213493519,
-0.0168059953,
-0.0087638646,
0.0106104566,
-0.0101870326,
-0.0518931299,
0.0086742863,
0.0110205803,
-0.0084255077,
0.016104741,
-0.005759446,
0.0182332173,
0.0461837873,
-0.0479501002,
0.0305492375,
0.0696383715,
-0.0191089381,
0.0395100489,
-0.0119871646,
0.0123509383,
0.0548437238,
0.0009420907,
-0.0638515353,
-0.026421098,
-0.0637634173,
-0.0549214408,
-0.0279656928,
-0.0032277051,
-0.0131373098,
-0.0623062104,
0.009656365,
0.0180423986,
0.0007291765,
0.0081713405,
-0.0046288799,
0.0471732244,
-0.0425589755,
0.0003621025,
-0.0326294713,
0.0178896207,
-0.0056825927,
0.0385734327,
0.0272423234,
-0.0573365651,
-0.0117359571,
0.0007771573,
0.0043159113,
0.0178023819,
-0.0156984832,
0.1077497005,
-0.0234611277,
-0.0537863001,
-0.0015174376,
-0.0438638516,
0.0031911647,
-0.0509862006,
0.0178786237,
-0.0260308273,
0.0765287504,
0.0406649821,
-0.0056791622,
-0.0631012842,
0.0137887802,
-0.0064475271,
0.0027691242,
0.0879694298,
-0.0308191963,
-0.0536083132,
0.0209141411,
0.0108246543,
0.0206117779,
0.0069493083,
0.0509056039,
0.0479289405,
0.0067371754,
0.015136363,
-0.0009995878,
-0.0170981903,
-0.0194564126,
-0.0273455158,
-0.0100193759,
-0.0260079857,
-0.0335419402,
0.0611672103,
0.0035751313,
0.019125646,
-0.0077033276,
0.005203052,
0.0630685538,
0.0449940339,
0.0083095897,
0.0670927912,
0.0189247355,
0.0299720932,
0.0814609081,
-0.0281836763,
0.0120228315,
0.06905514,
-0.0205191728,
-0.0413097963,
0.0721641332,
0.0211276878,
0.0318163931,
-0.0531666502,
-0.0323465727,
-0.0275882594,
0.0581525192,
-0.0461611487,
0.0384715386,
-0.0480554365,
-0.042536363,
-0.0248373002,
0.0288572069,
-0.0568491742,
-0.021463424,
0.0033824891,
0.0486731529,
0.0895126164,
0.0260912664,
-0.0662589818,
-0.0400365181,
0.0369645171,
0.0083691142,
0.0413018726,
-0.00089641,
-0.0225261059,
-0.001367713,
-0.0237998646,
-0.0638577044,
-0.0596323758,
0.0168999359,
0.0014622837,
-0.0294993725,
-0.0182915647,
-0.0116243744,
-0.0352456011,
-0.0382302143,
0.0425386988,
-0.0404554233,
0.0005595589,
0.0021688212,
-0.0189453941,
0.0276886858,
0.0155310072,
0.0266664494,
0.0379816853,
0.0684732273,
-0.0340494253,
-0.062389303,
-0.0123155154,
-0.0155753978,
-0.0026776746,
0.040745113,
-0.0710353702,
0.0599366017,
-0.0094248643,
-0.0216705948,
-0.0161115471,
0.0264709443,
-0.0288499072,
0.0078264466,
-0.0093594696,
-0.0400915854,
0.0120760081,
0.055669196,
-0.0445514433,
0.0289005395,
0.0174674597,
0.0044613127,
0.0035617417,
0.0110389497,
0.0301076174,
-0.033053983,
0.0273779873,
0.0260627549,
0.0059966645,
0.0286761317,
0.0455537252,
-0.0309769381,
-0.0300889704,
-0.0163804833,
-0.0774978623,
-0.0304467455,
0.0096684368,
-0.0142459488,
0.0319024064,
-0.0433595926,
-0.0022542165,
0.0003099678,
0.0192650687,
-0.0209662989,
-0.026977215,
-0.0505796447,
0.0682817996,
0.022056425,
-0.0195008181,
-0.0236453433,
-0.023747053,
-0.0536774769,
0.0414406769,
0.0552268699,
0.0235936232,
-0.0510340594,
0.0178046692,
0.0009318842,
0.0053590955,
-0.0299461465,
-0.0451847129,
0.0195538215,
0.0053863828,
0.0358800218,
0.0276538637,
0.0270217583,
0.0515105799,
0.0532704368,
-0.0185643639,
-0.0212676767,
-0.0242307875,
0.0099711474,
0.0674633756,
0.022136908,
-0.0465422645,
0.0393381603,
0.0239592604,
-0.0159149822,
0.0408651493,
-0.0048622317,
0.0397457629,
0.0062659285,
-0.0425424837,
0.0249455422,
-0.006245648,
0.0140633155,
0.005658247,
0.0340686925,
-0.0197450481,
0.0729660094,
-0.0653178096,
0.0047156713,
-0.0592922755,
-0.0312635489,
-0.0148501573,
0.0401905626,
-0.0061449884,
0.0423926711,
0.0169730727,
0.0394154973,
-0.0220326297,
-0.0228421278,
0.0260146521,
-0.0062745544,
-0.0255795568,
-0.0552050434,
0.0352585465,
0.00644407,
-0.0572742932,
-0.0042297207,
-0.0127856331,
-0.0081084361,
0.044777859,
0.039664764,
-0.0698964819,
-0.0402365923,
0.0073964735,
0.0694723874,
-0.0085946945,
-0.0241463073,
-0.0025468073,
-0.0386037454,
0.0601065606,
0.0178097337,
0.0064531397,
0.0217969809,
-0.0015702414,
0.0232497845,
0.0653493926,
0.0133037651,
0.0062993676,
-0.0623052232,
-0.0133247618,
0.0262021646,
0.0350647159,
0.0028330374,
-0.0080151763,
-0.0224773027,
-0.0368384086,
0.0042126006,
0.0429529995,
0.0099800536,
-0.032747943,
0.0357463285,
0.0259423014,
-0.0266495384,
-0.0268588923,
0.0106654856,
-0.0777098462,
-0.0244364534,
-0.0017635664,
0.0123018762,
-0.0265120305,
-0.0394250713,
-0.0513321944,
-0.0762426779,
0.0368226878,
-0.021181969,
-0.0597952493,
-0.057934422,
-0.0682403743,
-0.0269713346,
0.0072923088,
-0.0044412622,
0.0470236428,
-0.0314466059,
-0.0151456725,
0.0133940699,
-0.0587331839,
-0.0788750052,
0.0186917502,
0.0137028815,
0.0239540059,
0.0564805679,
0.0741073638,
-0.041340787,
0.0079352707,
0.0283407699,
0.046103891,
-0.0015405786,
-0.0212905128,
0.0177909303,
0.0116884951,
0.0046261237,
-0.0186245199,
0.0790657848,
0.0101997852,
-0.0811221898,
-0.0209881477,
0.0670208558,
-0.0558655001,
0.0226017218,
-0.0304017644,
0.0033977688,
0.0315520205,
0.0572128445,
-0.024378743,
-0.031019561,
-0.094688341,
-0.016253639,
0.0084526148,
-0.0376062132,
-0.0028374884,
0.0030995288,
0.0013424665,
-0.0040662102,
-0.0397370867,
-0.0443818979,
-0.0182547476,
-0.0125832986,
-0.0113532916,
0.0096179266,
0.0119338911,
0.0114462208,
-0.0462458991,
0.0344127305,
-0.0363936685,
0.0272822492,
-0.0128918383,
-0.0452453233,
0.0025131982,
-0.0807930902,
-0.0245971642,
0.0340681709,
-0.0325154774,
-0.0222373307,
0.0044528418,
-0.0105498917,
0.0188980717,
0.0307979211,
-0.0064949417,
-0.076252766,
0.0769449547,
0.0421259217,
-0.0796897113,
-0.0153919347,
-0.0204242039,
0.0391417369,
-0.0150241693,
-0.0303190686,
-0.0109396912,
0.0111020524,
-0.0170520432,
0.0246790592,
0.014535157,
-0.0750853643,
0.0355063155,
0.0302240606,
0.0052803694,
-0.0022594747,
0.0283335727,
-0.0418996029,
-0.0246116817,
0.0045195338,
0.0193762686,
-0.0449071415,
0.0153229926,
0.0409226753,
-0.0403600968,
-0.0097147757,
0.0005419767,
-0.0191856287,
0.0420501269,
-0.006927311,
0.0612361133,
0.021073658,
0.0255550239,
0.0472533628,
-0.0213392302,
-0.0113324123,
-0.0000832887,
-0.0488226674,
0.0468039997,
-0.0466115624,
0.0397622027,
0.0395159051,
0.0271086507,
0.0014393607,
0.0900268257,
-0.077508688,
-0.0817585364,
-0.0729744807,
0.0162769984,
0.0179712009,
0.0234707966,
0.0296889581,
-0.0619229414,
-0.0120535186,
-0.0275938362,
0.0626850054,
0.000154078,
-0.0125079248,
0.0157946143,
0.0109950816,
-0.0227259491,
-0.0074920366,
0.0612270609,
0.021428775,
-0.0017183647,
-0.0222176518,
-0.0443960838,
-0.0313234627,
-0.0307344757,
-0.0110055674,
0.0046897051,
-0.0325377323,
-0.0374313928,
-0.0441337712,
-0.000896213,
0.0038081028,
0.0473156869,
-0.0290247444,
-0.0533273704,
0.0350340419,
0.0929999426,
-0.0198551379,
-0.0339297466,
-0.0341062881,
-0.0387328193,
-0.0412033908,
-0.0193969794,
-0.0074105165,
-6.131948649e-33,
-0.0083101587,
-0.0034759007,
-0.0050627086,
0.0136678442,
-0.0119774817,
-0.0200400744,
-0.0721087828,
-0.0166899525,
0.0253550708,
0.055894468,
-0.012321231,
-0.0018197879,
0.0270191319,
-0.0155881401,
0.0441040285,
0.02222207,
0.0164473876,
0.0334114283,
-0.0509073883,
0.0299543086,
0.0409564525,
0.032373637,
0.0566428825,
-0.0721809343,
0.0502778366,
0.0375280641,
0.006148607,
-0.052700527,
-0.026676096,
0.0602476373,
-0.0600035861,
0.0558238961,
0.0174988769,
0.0167271048,
-0.0141298231,
0.0184236951,
-0.0339735746,
-0.0197293833,
-0.0172844343,
-0.0039332472,
-0.0110228993,
0.0127284406,
-0.0230448339,
-0.0258698147,
-0.0389711633,
0.004827288,
0.0506131835,
-0.0389027558,
0.0283631328,
-0.0097027244,
-0.0993719921,
-0.007181331,
-0.0064593167,
-0.0095268954,
-0.0110986149,
0.0689644888,
-0.0190344434,
0.0318790413,
-0.033501517,
0.043679703,
-0.017576864,
0.0222924966,
0.0259745531,
0.007143646,
0.0150535665,
0.0131807197,
0.042344939,
0.0302075632,
-0.0111056622,
0.018236937,
-0.0100235557,
0.0793674141,
0.0730239451,
0.0697405264,
0.0122270109,
0.0000387669,
-0.0978856981,
0.010530103,
0.0113096256,
0.0137436092,
0.0258850362,
0.0356656238,
0.0006062897,
-0.0228546094,
-0.0160864126,
0.0458926,
0.0241425037,
-0.0322183296,
-0.0240812376,
-0.0054368703,
-0.0408091731,
-0.0458023064,
0.0226237588,
-0.0511915758,
-0.0081898579,
0.0531650633,
-0.0154867861,
0.0147234853,
-0.0252153706,
-0.0028920521,
-0.0921860859,
-0.0291841999,
-0.0019336292,
-0.0041953563,
0.0481963605,
0.0016948467,
-0.0165107828,
0.0379401594,
-0.0047229081,
0.0095992004,
-0.0551183298,
-0.0317953378,
0.0122425137,
-0.0048915837,
0.0000390927,
-0.0109804487,
-0.0151462583,
0.0066306647,
-0.0089897364,
0.066472508,
-0.0040389756,
-0.0344537497,
-0.0365126655,
-0.0226262677,
-0.0057206983,
-0.0109269572,
-0.0839598626,
-0.0174044482,
0.0337858088,
-0.0252303034,
0.0074197259,
0.0015955539,
2.926e-7,
0.0303307902,
0.0395347364,
0.0371087305,
-0.0081931381,
-0.0187765434,
0.0380335487,
-0.0330001898,
0.0016197134,
-0.0136917625,
0.0039997408,
0.0478458852,
0.0281072427,
0.0504777618,
0.0505232476,
-0.0857583284,
-0.013974796,
-0.0279789697,
-0.0815844834,
-0.0688763484,
0.0086333901,
0.0411897637,
0.0383757502,
-0.004243176,
-0.0503049977,
0.0123725599,
-0.0582415275,
0.0586146489,
-0.0416075028,
0.0039104922,
0.0657132566,
0.0279650539,
-0.053196013,
-0.0276242997,
0.0523781627,
-0.006879319,
-0.0202398431,
0.0151272211,
0.0221689511,
0.0182885174,
-0.0093286922,
-0.0024762014,
-0.0329580419,
0.0160782021,
-0.0041531678,
0.0291589033,
-0.005765378,
-0.0296090785,
0.0046466133,
0.0186540782,
-0.0051596803,
-0.0017886314,
-0.0250616837,
-0.0098356633,
-0.016106315,
-0.0269329026,
0.0395068191,
0.0287684184,
-0.0454003923,
-0.0105713615,
0.0201766789,
-0.0665334389,
-0.0399285331,
-0.0092506027,
-0.0193613023,
0.0370180756,
-0.0542182401,
0.0161136575,
2.663696831e-34,
0.0401185825,
-0.0002512103,
-0.0018551541,
-0.0007811776,
0.0521004759,
0.025095094,
0.0309619457,
0.0207107179,
0.0077655511,
-0.0831210688,
-0.0090055652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13676v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13676v1 | Rethinking Language Models as Symbolic Knowledge Graphs | 2023-08-25T21:25:08 | 2023-08-25T21:25:08 | Vishwas Mruthyunjaya, Pouya Pezeshkpour, Estevam Hruschka, Nikita Bhutani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Symbolic knowledge graphs (KGs) play a pivotal role in knowledge-centric
applications such as search, question answering and recommendation. As
contemporary language models (LMs) trained on extensive textual data have
gained prominence, researchers have extensively explored whether the parametric
knowledge within these models can match up to that present in knowledge graphs.
Various methodologies have indicated that enhancing the size of the model or
the volume of training data enhances its capacity to retrieve symbolic
knowledge, often with minimal or no human supervision. Despite these
advancements, there is a void in comprehensively evaluating whether LMs can
encompass the intricate topological and semantic attributes of KGs, attributes
crucial for reasoning processes. In this work, we provide an exhaustive
evaluation of language models of varying sizes and capabilities. We construct
nine qualitative benchmarks that encompass a spectrum of attributes including
symmetry, asymmetry, hierarchy, bidirectionality, compositionality, paths,
entity-centricity, bias and ambiguity. Additionally, we propose novel
evaluation metrics tailored for each of these attributes. Our extensive
evaluation of various LMs shows that while these models exhibit considerable
potential in recalling factual information, their ability to capture intricate
topological and semantic traits of KGs remains significantly constrained. We
note that our proposed evaluation metrics are more reliable in evaluating these
abilities than the existing metrics. Lastly, some of our benchmarks challenge
the common notion that larger LMs (e.g., GPT-4) universally outshine their
smaller counterparts (e.g., BERT). | [
0.066021651,
0.017502984,
-0.0167458951,
0.0538645126,
-0.0545400977,
0.0083254064,
-0.0280572362,
0.018463159,
0.0341988318,
-0.0707900077,
-0.0478279144,
-0.0341273881,
-0.0378251038,
0.0220539086,
-0.0007271228,
-0.0104879886,
0.0335882679,
-0.0084641222,
0.0325770825,
-0.0206109192,
-0.0053584776,
0.0357631296,
0.0185961314,
-0.0016131061,
-0.0184468459,
0.0102053769,
-0.0018529773,
0.0196377225,
0.0203275997,
-0.0247471482,
0.0118575217,
0.0102946423,
0.0068005323,
0.0526831187,
0.0000019508,
-0.0242673345,
0.0090623442,
-0.005907326,
-0.0183133613,
0.0194430612,
0.0153522547,
-0.0257876385,
0.0231230017,
-0.001242329,
-0.039746929,
-0.0209867451,
0.0226058476,
0.0213839915,
0.0288615376,
0.0611803979,
-0.0056593232,
-0.0362139456,
0.0287705585,
-0.0135343885,
-0.0129519524,
-0.0145661216,
0.0240717642,
0.0105859805,
-0.020655971,
0.0103605706,
-0.0119468197,
0.0290953685,
0.0393885113,
0.0439298712,
0.0116989762,
0.045830965,
-0.0648170039,
0.0206050668,
0.011004813,
0.0878381133,
-0.0025026232,
-0.0330686234,
-0.0029472543,
0.0008569396,
-0.0177584738,
0.0397004336,
-0.035141129,
0.0142074944,
-0.0396854691,
0.0185766518,
0.0148510188,
-0.0012731461,
0.0623666272,
0.0210185554,
-0.0263552051,
0.085631907,
0.0211323854,
-0.0423288904,
0.0237575732,
-0.0401230715,
-0.0679709986,
-0.0259519648,
0.0012456467,
0.047765784,
0.022929443,
0.0624713004,
-0.004356652,
0.0183040816,
0.0471930392,
-0.0805129483,
0.0404567011,
0.0291595794,
0.0095273238,
0.0932780579,
-0.0530503578,
0.0631989539,
0.0108250929,
0.0717094168,
-0.0599876344,
-0.0485410839,
-0.0590593815,
-0.0212606899,
-0.0577876717,
0.0382653363,
0.0041376143,
-0.0340406708,
0.0093477806,
0.048175551,
0.0025133751,
0.009978856,
0.0554125383,
0.0218709558,
0.0301364362,
-0.0239500385,
-0.0401503965,
0.0149086062,
-0.0383459218,
-0.0024611314,
-0.0207334701,
-0.0101291826,
0.0155550316,
0.0003731379,
0.0026804442,
-0.0487621203,
0.0336974412,
0.0850976631,
0.0468828157,
-0.0446996763,
-0.0278023966,
-0.0196192265,
-0.0065082381,
-0.0878014788,
0.0002074426,
-0.0524609983,
0.0435856469,
0.0471834019,
-0.0329694338,
-0.0216187686,
0.0355031826,
0.0183457527,
-0.0366804264,
0.0404420346,
0.0089142704,
0.0067079109,
0.0051228139,
0.0025179682,
-0.032761544,
0.0227450449,
0.0480042621,
0.0180800892,
0.0625281185,
0.0181145016,
-0.0394962654,
0.0061107446,
0.0263894573,
0.0284233484,
-0.0121998172,
0.064263925,
-0.0190017801,
0.0249249004,
-0.0066227945,
0.0846713856,
-0.0181045718,
-0.0754370391,
0.0632493347,
0.0643358827,
0.0089106234,
0.0013481049,
0.0494019389,
-0.0136731472,
0.0439854413,
-0.0431490242,
-0.0611627586,
0.0178583469,
-0.0426114425,
0.0285911839,
-0.0270280149,
0.0030069409,
-0.0227123909,
-0.0219730493,
-0.0523812547,
-0.0088381879,
0.0386456661,
0.0268984176,
0.0737555176,
-0.0171324089,
-0.0394148044,
0.0610490851,
0.0354435444,
-0.0309507027,
0.0074176667,
-0.0090444796,
0.0279055871,
0.0845026895,
0.0474418141,
-0.0289319549,
-0.0267898459,
0.0303803124,
-0.0375230424,
-0.02568198,
0.0431301706,
-0.0150081413,
-0.0083456375,
-0.0311542433,
0.0034641861,
-0.0182561353,
0.0096672531,
0.0360365212,
0.0371708199,
0.0094747469,
0.0253410377,
-0.1223470047,
-0.0152673339,
0.0182710998,
-0.0191990379,
-0.0043084524,
-0.0064596967,
0.0017802952,
0.0113442615,
0.0252273399,
-0.001317704,
0.0156791583,
0.0627122,
-0.0102960272,
-0.041708041,
0.0020280238,
-0.0347655974,
-0.0417184606,
0.0418505892,
0.0029078545,
0.0101411948,
0.0587308593,
-0.0329577886,
-0.0429633074,
0.0421096943,
-0.053904891,
0.0636379793,
-0.0548933819,
0.0030668087,
0.02326384,
-0.0354517512,
-0.0279871356,
0.1006042585,
-0.0161201805,
0.0345475599,
0.0012707693,
0.0114844404,
0.0346806087,
-0.0267994571,
-0.023677988,
0.0228468888,
0.0264288429,
0.0083138719,
0.0108055193,
-0.030367557,
-0.0441396125,
-0.021108292,
-0.1332155168,
0.02001114,
-0.0343850441,
0.0407409705,
0.0242477842,
-0.010212617,
-0.0028293275,
-0.008268158,
-0.0600648075,
-0.0128056118,
-0.0104222028,
0.0219003856,
0.0380883403,
0.0004737108,
-0.0224672873,
-0.0332669243,
-0.0401369296,
-0.0400864817,
0.0594578981,
-0.0042848201,
0.0261807498,
0.0064057456,
0.0189808644,
-0.0560979508,
0.0325614586,
-0.0422449969,
-0.0087908413,
-0.0130663179,
-0.0058985869,
0.0128008155,
0.0386346392,
-0.0063743833,
0.0185138565,
0.0334865302,
0.0094584022,
-0.0433871485,
-0.0041565388,
-0.0468756035,
0.0244499948,
-0.0042198794,
-0.0296191163,
-0.0105675627,
0.0341201127,
0.0284395795,
-0.0260706805,
-0.0579942726,
-0.0015616678,
-0.0240337048,
0.0474925004,
-0.0474379547,
0.0045845625,
-0.0042014481,
0.0275274999,
-0.0477118194,
-0.0457870923,
0.0676348433,
-0.0088099921,
0.0205772724,
-0.0051403972,
-0.0387513004,
-0.0719910786,
0.0970459431,
0.022389669,
0.020942213,
0.015988294,
-0.0072582965,
-0.0404563285,
0.0080540776,
0.0205660611,
-0.063136816,
0.003319826,
-0.0304844845,
0.0446373075,
0.0118904812,
-0.0205594916,
-0.01304862,
-0.0278410353,
-0.0222478304,
0.0517844856,
-0.015248199,
-0.0440049395,
0.0255781263,
0.008662995,
0.0023597805,
0.0297526363,
-0.0006599792,
-0.0144554265,
-0.0068262303,
0.0384607166,
0.0652249902,
-0.0294141825,
0.0286507215,
-0.0083592841,
-0.0006377377,
0.0346297622,
0.0367581025,
-0.0200213753,
-0.029030269,
-0.0214357991,
-0.0188455228,
-0.0499896221,
-0.0412962623,
-0.0077441689,
0.0196525957,
-0.0461304672,
-0.0084954295,
0.116829671,
0.0496888757,
-0.0129751246,
0.0089249173,
0.0033986035,
-0.0128527358,
0.024992492,
-0.0062428615,
-0.0985443741,
-0.0249132067,
-0.0108516002,
0.0046384879,
0.0164515506,
-0.0440917648,
0.0140770609,
-0.0928049833,
-0.0137321036,
-0.0238291528,
-0.0619638301,
-0.0647122115,
-0.0490022153,
-0.009172284,
-0.029807182,
0.0025165118,
0.0208866391,
-0.0193418395,
-0.0002294868,
0.0086811893,
-0.0196180996,
-0.021160854,
0.0864702389,
-0.0357325226,
0.0149825411,
0.0025631699,
0.0298017319,
0.0093057677,
-0.02299002,
0.0001071159,
-0.0353891216,
0.003486377,
0.0069740741,
0.0170196202,
-0.0292246323,
0.0039154738,
-0.0315922238,
-0.0032130198,
-0.0731556863,
0.0107832253,
-0.018590292,
0.0770324618,
-0.0097952439,
-0.0385426618,
-0.0158990454,
-0.0301742423,
-0.0540938005,
0.0956581607,
0.0026160928,
0.0093149394,
-0.0504319407,
-0.0032904488,
0.031758476,
-0.014857349,
-0.0109174475,
0.0175936986,
0.0243133325,
0.0257117078,
-0.0623024292,
-0.0667335242,
0.024898747,
0.0105179241,
-0.0201442763,
0.0224270672,
-0.0151880961,
-0.0212530699,
-0.0703027695,
0.0424531996,
-0.034636952,
0.0216798708,
-0.0063301558,
-0.0157186035,
0.009157802,
-0.0278998762,
-0.027224442,
-0.0095461328,
-0.0735977441,
-0.0607314594,
-0.0479724556,
0.0410357192,
0.0257016085,
0.0346624069,
-0.038839478,
0.0000299756,
0.0241186805,
0.0092514763,
-0.0404304788,
-0.0040093279,
0.0273694322,
0.0371129811,
0.0052140183,
0.0544757582,
-0.0820270851,
-0.0078859292,
0.0023512323,
0.0655133873,
-0.056316182,
-0.0211994126,
0.0315206535,
0.0177054275,
0.0110877734,
-0.0006345666,
-0.0236094724,
-0.0091780461,
0.0152965821,
-0.0315472931,
-0.0254207216,
-0.024209274,
0.0132082943,
0.037633568,
-0.0000459097,
-0.0425647497,
-0.0402447507,
0.0107523119,
0.0403231308,
-0.0361774415,
-0.0409889519,
0.0166904312,
-0.0141836209,
0.0235069524,
-0.0027363582,
-0.0506294221,
-0.000117986,
-0.0172329601,
0.0222171471,
-0.0069717956,
0.0342238657,
0.0274322201,
-0.0280184913,
-0.0341452472,
0.0213082992,
-0.0887255669,
-0.0187025201,
0.0065385089,
0.017432509,
0.0762809291,
0.0003956968,
0.0108190645,
-0.0500463285,
-0.0138361072,
-0.0132347438,
-0.0110196173,
0.0318432562,
-0.0225163847,
0.0357369594,
0.0470603369,
0.0184127986,
0.0250188746,
0.0818808228,
0.021462271,
0.0831093714,
0.0006105441,
-0.037717741,
-0.0203998741,
0.0009577589,
0.0208368246,
0.0378172621,
-0.0228744037,
0.0239200387,
-0.0846931264,
-0.0894792899,
0.0169721656,
-0.002161047,
0.0187663212,
-0.030030787,
0.0481054708,
0.0549586378,
0.0080418671,
-0.0251118261,
-0.0460010134,
-0.0038814892,
-0.031210294,
0.0172015559,
-0.0446577892,
-6.847854096e-33,
0.0011112931,
-0.0186373536,
-0.0017186219,
-0.0118238544,
-0.0094371056,
0.0009353142,
-0.02731755,
-0.0268642772,
-0.0484515242,
0.0133837378,
-0.0040307865,
0.0117622539,
-0.0201670956,
0.0067138546,
-0.0065806932,
-0.040284168,
-0.0252213068,
-0.0078402478,
-0.0160319731,
0.0065901526,
0.0615451857,
0.017327603,
0.0501463152,
-0.0288826972,
0.0213715471,
-0.0172349196,
0.0217814539,
0.0227222145,
-0.0275169779,
0.0603874251,
-0.0073165135,
0.0450356342,
0.0354203358,
-0.0050002919,
0.0255290344,
-0.019031642,
-0.0896256045,
-0.0457665883,
0.0538751855,
-0.0043488913,
-0.0426875018,
-0.020568924,
0.0362817496,
-0.0223187394,
0.0120625123,
-0.0284221247,
0.0383310057,
0.0156301018,
-0.0458405502,
-0.0587861501,
-0.0160669237,
0.0397370867,
0.0032177945,
-0.0128323743,
-0.0133842882,
0.0123242559,
-0.0001973902,
0.013618676,
-0.0392789282,
-0.0234132148,
-0.0202366319,
-0.0049870694,
0.0198280904,
-0.0045597856,
0.013857211,
0.0653949082,
0.0042070895,
0.0001774353,
-0.05333988,
0.0205950141,
0.0132812262,
0.0497408025,
0.0423046649,
-0.0156627893,
0.0268890057,
0.0323295482,
-0.0639190376,
-0.0121215656,
0.0106091658,
0.0382813215,
0.0227531977,
0.0130069731,
-0.0419149362,
-0.0061403713,
-0.0543872267,
-0.0190336481,
-0.0437231362,
-0.0215165578,
0.0230207965,
-0.0034352988,
0.0044481363,
-0.018347444,
-0.0067563867,
-0.0481296889,
0.0070940927,
0.0685107037,
-0.0012954221,
0.0279278811,
-0.0073239435,
0.0640087426,
-0.0603598543,
0.0063390573,
0.0131509323,
0.0172321964,
-0.0183715094,
0.0117454771,
0.0313681476,
0.0194004457,
-0.0103291143,
-0.0059038457,
-0.0398902558,
-0.0212091263,
-0.0325073563,
-0.0460690856,
0.0429094881,
0.077848658,
0.0097866813,
0.0420828313,
0.0416945592,
0.0347985104,
-0.0295895953,
0.0295069199,
-0.0011552083,
-0.0024708877,
0.0100973099,
0.0077129831,
-0.0183584839,
0.0076330337,
0.0051616039,
-0.0203897282,
0.0031475681,
0.0482899882,
2.78e-7,
0.0763111115,
0.0340312123,
0.0409472995,
0.0568930544,
0.0123335673,
0.0087310541,
0.0144414483,
0.0154385921,
0.0109496275,
-0.0331877917,
0.0050270851,
0.0491242073,
0.0222462751,
0.0270054024,
-0.0827765092,
0.0311854165,
-0.0917836651,
-0.0539852232,
-0.0248768162,
0.0421749763,
0.0641113743,
0.0900090113,
0.0326971412,
-0.0078562675,
-0.0336573496,
-0.0594388545,
0.0802249089,
-0.0272044819,
0.0170831103,
-0.0072161732,
0.0247795247,
-0.0059462772,
0.001331586,
0.0445953831,
0.0062647378,
0.0202419627,
0.0164978039,
0.0463855565,
-0.0259814225,
-0.0396261476,
-0.0114805372,
-0.0676944479,
0.0107962582,
-0.082537435,
0.1117663458,
-0.0312747285,
-0.0186584722,
0.0133740688,
-0.0371703953,
0.0085653588,
0.0336789079,
-0.0158332437,
-0.0393457972,
0.0284163505,
0.0023170989,
-0.0237437245,
0.0281146541,
-0.0849521086,
0.0011550803,
0.0122587606,
-0.0229402296,
-0.032212887,
-0.0198452082,
0.0173755996,
0.0256756097,
-0.0572904497,
0.0032679052,
2.537247159e-34,
0.0436650291,
-0.0266530681,
-0.0054656807,
0.0138347056,
0.0295357257,
-0.0234746728,
-0.0254074372,
0.0027961256,
0.0338472947,
-0.100291431,
-0.0073959189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13646v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13646v2 | GRASP: A Rehearsal Policy for Efficient Online Continual Learning | 2023-08-25T19:34:21 | 2024-05-01T17:25:52 | Md Yousuf Harun, Jhair Gallardo, Junyu Chen, Christopher Kanan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Continual learning (CL) in deep neural networks (DNNs) involves incrementally
accumulating knowledge in a DNN from a growing data stream. A major challenge
in CL is that non-stationary data streams cause catastrophic forgetting of
previously learned abilities. A popular solution is rehearsal: storing past
observations in a buffer and then sampling the buffer to update the DNN.
Uniform sampling in a class-balanced manner is highly effective, and better
sample selection policies have been elusive. Here, we propose a new sample
selection policy called GRASP that selects the most prototypical (easy) samples
first and then gradually selects less prototypical (harder) examples. GRASP has
little additional compute or memory overhead compared to uniform selection,
enabling it to scale to large datasets. Compared to 17 other rehearsal
policies, GRASP achieves higher accuracy in CL experiments on ImageNet.
Compared to uniform balanced sampling, GRASP achieves the same performance with
40% fewer updates. We also show that GRASP is effective for CL on five text
classification datasets. | [
-0.0070325886,
0.0695996881,
-0.0206414983,
-0.0421473421,
-0.0359591842,
-0.0005069293,
0.0067123962,
-0.0222068653,
0.0147479493,
-0.0042517511,
0.0057709399,
-0.034733057,
-0.033026699,
0.043962419,
-0.0303806607,
-0.0391780287,
0.005457412,
-0.0045001986,
-0.0415671729,
-0.0241663102,
-0.0095847147,
0.0033968491,
-0.0402210541,
-0.0170051195,
0.001183246,
-0.0327622704,
-0.0170883909,
-0.0124998866,
0.0013089826,
-0.0486511067,
0.0320617482,
0.013636631,
0.0513096601,
-0.017867716,
0.0000023896,
-0.0281132571,
0.0044792942,
-0.0346383043,
-0.0316298008,
-0.0172273237,
0.058820501,
0.0096084001,
-0.0095422016,
-0.0110333255,
-0.0181400664,
-0.000871094,
0.0322232097,
0.0031872184,
-0.0024386428,
-0.018101899,
0.0032297396,
0.0523158722,
0.0224800855,
-0.0338729173,
-0.008167265,
-0.0308523923,
0.0293845572,
-0.0022049427,
-0.0049861195,
-0.0270300191,
-0.0185473599,
0.0328920819,
0.071077466,
-0.0215931293,
0.0448812246,
0.0595114417,
-0.0222039279,
-0.0357303843,
0.0139028262,
0.0455898717,
-0.0449338034,
0.0038919484,
0.0270126853,
-0.0550603196,
-0.0144902784,
-0.0014835929,
-0.0272477735,
0.0238413382,
-0.0069227116,
0.0224316642,
-0.0615762137,
-0.0087955976,
0.0143249575,
0.0495237559,
-0.0276787411,
-0.0234705769,
-0.0293020513,
-0.011951549,
0.041251149,
0.0379286259,
-0.0644027367,
-0.0340833515,
0.0282306056,
0.0167641249,
-0.0406781323,
-0.008925545,
-0.0214710087,
-0.0077655846,
-0.0005811047,
-0.0184568111,
0.0441639759,
0.0174275562,
-0.0237249937,
0.0746149495,
0.0111062359,
0.0025962146,
0.0180737358,
0.0132442387,
-0.004840401,
0.0306370649,
-0.0802414641,
0.021203205,
-0.0337479711,
0.0697755739,
0.0374730676,
-0.032341674,
-0.0249652565,
0.0377067961,
-0.0235353056,
0.0059678904,
-0.045780845,
0.0113944346,
-0.063136138,
0.0375789888,
-0.0047723502,
0.0112479003,
-0.0317045823,
0.0365362465,
-0.0015506265,
-0.0359654985,
-0.0433175638,
-0.0049551646,
0.0123146977,
-0.0213432945,
0.0304829534,
0.0207775924,
-0.0293025095,
-0.0335110649,
-0.0416802242,
-0.0125169568,
0.0066456739,
0.0216478631,
0.0216107983,
-0.0110238334,
0.0345329195,
-0.0561365187,
0.0023711,
-0.0272374786,
-0.0086179161,
0.0342628993,
-0.0182805974,
0.0370872617,
0.0213166121,
-0.016138684,
0.0408586226,
0.0173080992,
-0.0229423959,
0.0540542901,
-0.0083777988,
0.0218159072,
0.0443662852,
0.0139697175,
0.0226596966,
0.0171563048,
0.0403330885,
0.01389495,
-0.0465799458,
-0.0204621665,
-0.0309324916,
0.0500147045,
0.0454232022,
-0.0232373271,
-0.0464037396,
0.0099597163,
0.0282276608,
0.0453221276,
-0.001399458,
0.0414862968,
-0.0014236917,
0.0112335989,
0.011816686,
-0.0137893939,
-0.0458075143,
0.0666433126,
0.0590918362,
-0.0063671358,
-0.0357292071,
-0.0021034314,
-0.0292774215,
-0.0248699691,
0.0265253615,
0.000662434,
-0.0417542718,
0.0476247258,
0.0416445397,
0.0324852429,
0.0032888623,
0.0402525254,
0.034397617,
0.021975616,
0.0100957798,
-0.0173848271,
0.0025414864,
0.046661526,
0.0400828011,
-0.0668346435,
-0.0535787977,
-0.0427970588,
0.0516764596,
-0.026180679,
0.0176193938,
-0.0007119791,
0.0533242859,
-0.0525966361,
-0.0362884067,
0.0134429391,
-0.0017132523,
0.0322565883,
0.0271514002,
0.0576416664,
-0.0181995761,
-0.0085109845,
-0.0506728515,
0.0439663641,
-0.0304062869,
-0.0308543574,
0.0737359673,
-0.0202465374,
0.0303745717,
-0.0249840301,
-0.0373546332,
-0.0470394976,
0.0264756009,
-0.0490010679,
-0.0036021939,
-0.0287719257,
-0.0630119741,
-0.0054214224,
0.0269552581,
-0.0037594668,
-0.0054414724,
-0.0138563821,
-0.0609815829,
-0.0076780603,
-0.0163423866,
0.0443104692,
0.0056383712,
-0.0318744369,
-0.0229373202,
-0.0127580259,
0.0327910781,
-0.012420441,
0.0273533426,
-0.0329031944,
0.0071497243,
0.00281738,
0.0028554325,
-0.0171113331,
-0.0832983628,
0.0117893098,
-0.0081433058,
-0.0125197191,
-0.0090481872,
0.0244782269,
0.0282733086,
-0.0215235278,
-0.0164558776,
-0.0433048271,
0.0153036341,
-0.0210437533,
-0.0120251682,
-0.0295570605,
-0.0156432018,
-0.0350415967,
-0.0401220173,
0.0112195667,
0.0232231133,
-0.073116608,
0.0259136464,
0.0149461199,
0.0014561362,
0.0107865771,
-0.0004398769,
-0.0342031494,
0.0384631976,
0.0386180133,
-0.006941969,
0.0361892246,
-0.002766236,
-0.0190778244,
-0.01803126,
-0.0017742036,
-0.0012027792,
-0.0036343108,
-0.0339850374,
-0.044437699,
-0.0870439485,
0.0556018502,
0.0337635279,
0.0311839934,
0.0321902521,
0.0167244375,
-0.0397340097,
0.0238488819,
-0.0092573725,
-0.0000145515,
0.0144223999,
0.0294927787,
0.0094754733,
-0.0016844213,
-0.0279632527,
0.0060845176,
0.0183772221,
0.002591352,
-0.0327156223,
-0.0084992861,
-0.0731185451,
0.0233691595,
-0.0211244188,
-0.0687328577,
-0.0172618814,
-0.0399577916,
0.0660431832,
0.0608111732,
-0.0032529107,
-0.029238075,
-0.0209954362,
0.0293385983,
0.047643844,
0.025357224,
-0.0152018974,
-0.0168944169,
-0.025459189,
-0.0302653685,
-0.0395588875,
0.046008572,
0.0026910419,
0.0155909611,
-0.0334234349,
0.0059453025,
-0.0279127974,
-0.0566743277,
-0.0824296176,
-0.0270322375,
0.003254123,
0.0044147694,
-0.0498307645,
-0.0125635304,
-0.0221174527,
-0.0384089872,
0.016622657,
0.0665712729,
-0.00132884,
-0.0553523488,
-0.0020955345,
0.0319811143,
0.026249988,
0.0524083786,
-0.0082102623,
-0.0045709861,
0.0197655428,
0.0611671247,
0.0771008357,
0.0254830848,
-0.0186710805,
0.0329846852,
0.0193121526,
-0.0335543267,
0.0134832021,
0.0128892018,
-0.0241964888,
-0.0527518839,
-0.005232912,
0.0552228801,
0.0279764161,
-0.0621110126,
-0.000303893,
0.025648877,
0.0400829054,
-0.0078483615,
0.0438566767,
-0.0557830073,
-0.0120847253,
0.0398433246,
0.0725378096,
0.004740499,
-0.0530253984,
-0.0002098043,
-0.0497863404,
0.0482517593,
-0.0143950209,
-0.0070667067,
0.0271667335,
-0.0270067435,
-0.0062904232,
-0.0261296555,
0.013292986,
0.01014903,
-0.0019038763,
-0.0152468961,
0.0644068718,
-0.0145952087,
-0.0414386764,
0.0327549092,
-0.0287685804,
-0.0021428834,
0.0167195201,
0.011768979,
-0.0267246105,
-0.0262571126,
0.1048630551,
-0.0579575896,
-0.0074830079,
-0.0081292158,
0.054098893,
0.0116387289,
-0.0091809323,
0.0045995759,
0.0702394918,
-0.024085911,
-0.027690284,
0.0276479926,
0.0333722793,
-0.0195705052,
-0.0234091617,
-0.0260532908,
-0.067889303,
0.0541301779,
0.0390897468,
-0.0206194092,
-0.0564809665,
-0.0092833806,
0.0031007039,
0.0021452424,
-0.0592136532,
0.0075171385,
0.0064039477,
-0.0154489735,
-0.0302583072,
-0.0129055372,
-0.00354141,
-0.0125611816,
0.0475540347,
0.0179949943,
-0.0217318628,
0.0399383605,
0.0353168882,
-0.048122298,
-0.001971462,
-0.0108281132,
0.0154736228,
-0.006937799,
-0.0092081744,
0.0620610714,
-0.0039123632,
-0.0450510308,
0.0076342742,
-0.0794604495,
-0.0117649045,
0.0520090088,
0.0047140373,
0.00822837,
0.0411311388,
-0.0158002023,
-0.0502453856,
0.0753514841,
0.0795346797,
0.000810378,
0.0152278431,
0.0123400018,
-0.0309408251,
-0.0036344437,
0.0202252362,
-0.0296164379,
0.0333838426,
0.0442453809,
-0.0095549133,
0.0082856501,
0.0530011579,
-0.0187368523,
-0.0336194597,
0.0088680144,
0.0157291703,
0.0026914738,
-0.0326707587,
0.038304396,
0.0916229263,
0.0199529976,
-0.0202357825,
0.038095288,
0.0127723943,
-0.0184457731,
-0.0406858772,
0.0376643762,
0.0608652867,
0.0048664324,
0.0079701822,
-0.0176442042,
0.0141120739,
0.0191674214,
0.0292570014,
0.0086268075,
-0.0417080745,
0.026975397,
-0.0105328588,
0.0641535744,
-0.0519248396,
0.0227128435,
0.0669128075,
0.0178965367,
-0.0244227778,
-0.0260620452,
-0.0602054521,
-0.0823070705,
-0.0383686945,
0.0411852188,
0.0690473914,
-0.0306028705,
-0.0087955082,
-0.0458296835,
0.0193264838,
-0.033688616,
-0.0230938718,
-0.0102945799,
-0.0375619046,
-0.0403364301,
0.0153193949,
0.0337741151,
0.0474139713,
0.0472737812,
-0.0202489737,
0.0281961188,
-0.0055648428,
0.0124673806,
-0.0289650727,
0.0089366147,
-0.0111930817,
0.0461022668,
0.011622224,
0.0030174463,
0.0133543117,
-0.020598283,
0.0679687485,
-0.0171010699,
0.0153790042,
-0.0181328375,
0.0297506023,
0.015841376,
-0.0077382573,
0.0070109703,
0.0073517095,
0.0595050789,
0.027683856,
-0.0056900633,
-0.01169548,
-7.022066767e-33,
0.0427419245,
0.0043766489,
-0.0090267388,
-0.023875026,
-0.0657209009,
-0.0085147806,
-0.0214683507,
-0.0343835205,
0.025951568,
0.0371579789,
-0.0439224765,
0.021476334,
0.0154381776,
0.0402255133,
0.0520393699,
-0.0512821786,
0.0472929627,
-0.0200518481,
-0.0277397707,
0.0636677966,
0.0435083136,
0.0735844746,
0.0027986642,
-0.0166863222,
-0.0419477932,
0.0311522279,
0.0340080708,
-0.022472918,
0.0221615825,
0.0377567746,
-0.0097395526,
0.0060627679,
0.0182393305,
-0.0077538663,
-0.0370412394,
-0.0334954299,
-0.089231208,
-0.0708564669,
-0.0990028307,
0.044969324,
-0.0345522612,
0.0111336317,
0.0310704876,
0.0222951137,
-0.0088204071,
0.0033578603,
0.025580056,
-0.0178741645,
-0.0909755826,
-0.0507983491,
0.028892884,
0.0047512352,
-0.0188118313,
-0.0175761748,
0.0158770159,
-0.0429389402,
0.0034296105,
-0.0462817214,
-0.1032673568,
-0.03353763,
0.0062799137,
0.0326675661,
-0.0347697698,
0.0127711426,
0.0477941483,
0.0698763132,
-0.0012424217,
-0.0369590335,
-0.0006590118,
-0.0114327455,
0.078909643,
-0.0377605483,
-0.0658333078,
-0.0137425251,
0.1278797984,
-0.083798103,
-0.0508313067,
-0.0298278742,
0.0700130463,
0.0554985516,
0.0495204851,
-0.0185765121,
0.0016267985,
-0.020541722,
-0.022389153,
-0.0266488474,
-0.0418232381,
0.0251346007,
0.0538852997,
0.0682732388,
-0.0333030708,
-0.0000848718,
0.0319766141,
-0.0244830642,
-0.0732609257,
0.004909764,
-0.0202793777,
0.0522532798,
0.033079993,
-0.0268792044,
-0.0498358682,
-0.0143711865,
-0.0395860747,
-0.0101951677,
0.0201399084,
0.015730055,
0.049056083,
0.0471714512,
-0.0256978385,
-0.0261082742,
-0.0055297012,
0.0499927215,
0.0512661599,
0.0239141844,
0.0297506806,
0.0212934371,
0.0145451725,
0.0429962911,
0.015133094,
-0.0507361516,
-0.0556866936,
0.0998492315,
0.0391534008,
0.0125746289,
-0.0110309748,
-0.0195230283,
-0.0335892811,
0.0061065666,
-0.0142406495,
-0.1245430782,
-0.0034760642,
0.0075948443,
3.052e-7,
-0.0302572474,
0.0255181883,
-0.0032705124,
-0.0379051082,
0.0689767078,
-0.0062300884,
-0.0255883709,
0.014221522,
-0.0276360158,
0.0283667855,
0.0134931225,
0.0284900982,
0.0288104974,
0.030643316,
-0.0695235655,
0.0160426591,
0.0096524572,
0.0386525765,
-0.0465398319,
-0.0519229323,
-0.0138363084,
0.0607397258,
0.0225283075,
-0.0195948612,
0.0704535395,
-0.0808680654,
0.0478989892,
0.0195891894,
0.1018958166,
0.011764857,
0.0353373885,
0.0540732369,
-0.0342019089,
0.0188763551,
-0.04199313,
-0.0144810034,
-0.0265639499,
0.0305669494,
0.0098574394,
-0.0250094179,
-0.0233132336,
0.0142229814,
0.0408406407,
0.0022000906,
0.071702905,
-0.1032530218,
0.0456462689,
0.0025992594,
0.0200479962,
-0.0147010162,
0.0274157505,
0.0337581187,
-0.040795844,
0.0316340327,
0.0312403478,
0.0133067872,
-0.0427312739,
-0.0941046476,
0.0480204523,
-0.0041866028,
-0.0442307591,
-0.0309920851,
-0.0712219924,
-0.0175180305,
0.0400313139,
-0.0385566466,
-0.0132104261,
2.571210221e-34,
0.0348061398,
-0.0189735591,
0.0059080464,
0.0261291396,
-0.0412955135,
-0.0032111243,
0.1226612926,
-0.0036417879,
0.0070392117,
-0.0229097493,
-0.0363614485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13517v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13517v1 | ChatGPT as Data Augmentation for Compositional Generalization: A Case Study in Open Intent Detection | 2023-08-25T17:51:23 | 2023-08-25T17:51:23 | Yihao Fang, Xianzhi Li, Stephen W. Thomas, Xiaodan Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Open intent detection, a crucial aspect of natural language understanding,
involves the identification of previously unseen intents in user-generated
text. Despite the progress made in this field, challenges persist in handling
new combinations of language components, which is essential for compositional
generalization. In this paper, we present a case study exploring the use of
ChatGPT as a data augmentation technique to enhance compositional
generalization in open intent detection tasks. We begin by discussing the
limitations of existing benchmarks in evaluating this problem, highlighting the
need for constructing datasets for addressing compositional generalization in
open intent detection tasks. By incorporating synthetic data generated by
ChatGPT into the training process, we demonstrate that our approach can
effectively improve model performance. Rigorous evaluation of multiple
benchmarks reveals that our method outperforms existing techniques and
significantly enhances open intent detection capabilities. Our findings
underscore the potential of large language models like ChatGPT for data
augmentation in natural language understanding tasks. | [
0.0666536838,
0.0672685578,
0.0014124864,
0.0439234637,
-0.0306966435,
0.0277833678,
0.0030369288,
0.0063263173,
0.0368334725,
-0.0545882806,
-0.0236932728,
-0.0671396032,
-0.0320774466,
0.0693107173,
0.0091890311,
0.0007309886,
0.0590343922,
-0.0005167228,
0.006204851,
0.0478448458,
0.0182174873,
0.0491624139,
0.0169879347,
0.062252596,
-0.0172765087,
-0.0100855045,
-0.0383248143,
0.0381924398,
0.0056528142,
-0.0218648855,
0.008145486,
0.0460798182,
0.055518508,
0.0693477094,
0.0000016776,
-0.0538954251,
-0.0195609406,
-0.0115957186,
-0.0574149676,
-0.0191368703,
0.0610073693,
-0.0028801723,
0.0101993186,
0.0341107994,
-0.0296558049,
-0.0168388933,
0.0432442762,
0.0482441559,
0.0397474132,
0.1000856608,
-0.0104991756,
-0.0194529258,
0.0142180556,
-0.0276113283,
0.0699148998,
-0.018749522,
0.0421351716,
0.0115186218,
-0.0249926094,
0.0303685945,
-0.0210203007,
0.005014048,
0.0257722028,
-0.0146951256,
0.0073569487,
0.0372027643,
-0.0170514304,
-0.006980516,
-0.0066511696,
0.0808969513,
-0.0169144962,
-0.0192893781,
-0.0037091344,
-0.0308412872,
-0.0101605821,
-0.0529141724,
-0.0154512487,
0.0281551778,
-0.0326493979,
0.0148088224,
0.0301736277,
-0.0183283836,
0.0202613994,
0.0213248562,
-0.0267602485,
0.0450681336,
0.0056960862,
-0.0336577334,
0.0292397402,
-0.0050110621,
-0.0066138944,
-0.0725985616,
0.0087022167,
0.0127840545,
-0.0240654778,
0.0326367766,
-0.0665369481,
-0.040318042,
0.0121833775,
-0.0363309123,
0.0045515108,
0.0588105917,
-0.0212540682,
0.0769465417,
0.0008150479,
0.0047787996,
-0.0211021472,
0.0400962085,
-0.0799692497,
-0.0069866735,
-0.0656125918,
-0.0155130317,
-0.0602591522,
0.0010816726,
-0.0459161215,
-0.0373872519,
-0.0273255426,
0.0423363447,
0.0282290522,
-0.0192025062,
0.0260492712,
-0.0003228604,
-0.0479510389,
-0.0119212894,
0.0190105159,
-0.012502701,
-0.0069311718,
0.0399048291,
0.0043433732,
-0.0735278353,
-0.04091952,
0.0445072465,
0.0217685048,
-0.0240056645,
0.0015752536,
0.0155081898,
-0.01021998,
-0.070606418,
-0.0262558609,
-0.0490850359,
-0.0104466537,
-0.0443984717,
-0.0292567704,
-0.027626209,
0.0366593748,
-0.0169416536,
-0.0195580777,
-0.0144312344,
0.0032789004,
0.0383707099,
-0.0087530427,
0.0687554553,
-0.0337967277,
-0.0158764105,
-0.0360743068,
0.0186420418,
-0.0217558257,
0.0929219425,
0.0035622579,
0.0349833183,
0.026118502,
0.0205023717,
-0.0045480267,
0.0217705872,
0.0167552382,
0.007588313,
0.0720694661,
0.0459397212,
0.027434608,
0.0487805046,
0.0057806028,
0.0424576141,
-0.052856043,
-0.0409861878,
0.0574616045,
0.0338844135,
0.0172622725,
0.0029906018,
0.073127009,
0.0586628169,
-0.0344093889,
0.0009551663,
-0.0235423837,
-0.0240208488,
-0.0465399362,
-0.0067410315,
-0.0172612648,
0.0192174911,
-0.0334771536,
-0.0220045932,
-0.0208127238,
-0.0157163162,
0.0482911468,
-0.0268744733,
0.0422953628,
0.0430837609,
-0.0349995084,
0.0121085607,
0.0331335217,
-0.0261539537,
0.0055945483,
-0.0524853617,
0.0459862873,
0.0211348888,
0.0357803702,
-0.0393683985,
-0.029908007,
-0.0552568287,
0.0036014724,
0.0171126891,
0.0231345687,
-0.0086154379,
0.0527328402,
-0.0423156396,
-0.0145456549,
-0.0307245068,
0.0001120293,
0.0114410408,
0.0124829831,
-0.0059188325,
0.0247324649,
-0.0496753603,
0.0162203815,
0.0325311944,
-0.002941784,
-0.0235968679,
0.039958328,
0.003994232,
0.0332083218,
0.0254058912,
0.0303660799,
-0.0179603435,
-0.0157408807,
-0.0128013548,
-0.0458793417,
0.0349417105,
-0.0341638476,
-0.0709285289,
-0.0067144898,
-0.0277698711,
-0.0651693717,
0.000441555,
-0.0534232333,
-0.0353106521,
0.0106704701,
-0.0362625159,
0.0241562147,
-0.0834429935,
-0.0413279645,
0.0243602414,
0.0140610337,
0.00670039,
0.0469268039,
0.0021196241,
-0.0256527141,
0.028895136,
-0.0212342143,
0.0572409183,
-0.016239522,
-0.0271496475,
-0.009386641,
-0.0320929363,
-0.0095659513,
-0.020089766,
0.043585781,
-0.0740866363,
-0.0232080668,
-0.120454587,
0.0167224705,
-0.0384613238,
0.0215481147,
0.0374605656,
0.0495105796,
-0.0094591184,
-0.0084440866,
-0.0354629233,
0.0046586553,
-0.0115267364,
0.0064206338,
0.0291820634,
-0.0020194538,
-0.0006300837,
-0.014574931,
0.0159586053,
-0.0260977969,
0.048845619,
0.0108703487,
0.0071434258,
-0.0510952957,
0.0116587551,
-0.0135552343,
0.0328899361,
-0.0290200394,
-0.0362463221,
0.0123473546,
-0.0164562147,
0.0065089366,
0.0565840565,
-0.0061760014,
0.0146130566,
0.0159121342,
0.0049328259,
-0.0379683338,
0.0318437554,
-0.02947204,
0.0011951443,
-0.0287472159,
-0.0284388326,
0.0171605293,
0.0574448444,
0.0107221426,
-0.0270462669,
-0.0591931529,
-0.0262816586,
-0.0139349038,
-0.0339449011,
-0.0604035072,
-0.0081905462,
-0.0302152578,
0.0194051228,
-0.0189830177,
-0.0558291674,
0.0640438125,
-0.0239359401,
-0.0351681411,
-0.0499068908,
-0.0194704458,
-0.0592286177,
0.0832090378,
-0.0062918793,
0.0309904143,
0.0266008507,
-0.0324064195,
-0.0204309151,
0.0152203469,
-0.0008181387,
-0.0020054234,
0.0331197679,
-0.0090251816,
0.0051433542,
0.0007137765,
-0.0161756855,
-0.0425339825,
-0.0814596415,
0.000660164,
-0.0121142138,
0.0289033242,
0.0006068212,
-0.0160135143,
-0.0027477853,
-0.0286235698,
0.0466964655,
-0.0100995386,
-0.0146304183,
-0.0301579535,
0.0153382299,
0.0313648954,
-0.0140135046,
-0.03985532,
-0.0203690957,
0.0196550861,
0.0511987992,
-0.0184997488,
-0.0148902461,
-0.0176423565,
0.0112317391,
-0.0037974003,
0.0116080651,
0.0042302893,
0.0096318433,
0.0748835355,
-0.0255177207,
-0.0270086899,
0.100613527,
0.0331458449,
-0.0312964134,
-0.0092070121,
0.0020800789,
0.0345033593,
0.0287860911,
-0.00643211,
-0.106534645,
-0.0498588718,
0.0033306333,
-0.0173872281,
-0.0212663803,
-0.0083128307,
-0.0625188574,
-0.1041542068,
0.0164007656,
-0.0304380041,
-0.0745740011,
-0.011292926,
0.0047811144,
0.0078775855,
-0.0456284732,
0.0024423257,
-0.0204405021,
-0.0044356436,
-0.012130551,
-0.002798039,
-0.0384266898,
-0.0376606323,
-0.0043290257,
-0.024265673,
0.0466081128,
0.0027711657,
0.0164685361,
0.0300443061,
-0.0044078445,
0.0384221934,
-0.0116737634,
0.000555428,
-0.0132699115,
0.0567849092,
-0.0329918116,
0.014894411,
0.0041034794,
0.0545497835,
-0.0594980307,
-0.0219538864,
0.0034370271,
0.0534112081,
-0.0016846688,
0.0113828052,
-0.0094891703,
0.0237083361,
0.0731539801,
0.0955460966,
0.0447663367,
-0.0484717824,
0.0007558868,
-0.0271391161,
-0.0318497233,
-0.0526097566,
0.0145111959,
0.0060273288,
0.0190700106,
-0.0008608417,
-0.0272616763,
-0.0665474907,
0.0548906848,
0.0055985795,
-0.0041544037,
0.0049650958,
-0.0134677282,
-0.0252455696,
-0.0288055167,
0.0332069136,
-0.0305366125,
0.029326275,
-0.0065542287,
-0.0194094647,
-0.0247209817,
-0.0868918672,
-0.0318380669,
0.0093949977,
-0.1410693377,
-0.025444109,
-0.0114219543,
0.0138791502,
0.017678583,
0.0463634953,
-0.0642947927,
-0.0173366815,
-0.0257575307,
0.0352905691,
-0.0076216939,
-0.0059168702,
0.0539419279,
0.026606895,
0.0147001874,
0.0312014688,
-0.0139244013,
-0.0036316733,
0.0542126745,
-0.0105243782,
-0.0319754668,
-0.002602556,
0.0543017462,
0.0122647835,
0.0315226987,
0.0121398335,
0.0339658298,
-0.0735050887,
0.0140399989,
-0.005165258,
-0.0206143279,
-0.0653114468,
-0.0023305784,
0.0386105962,
-0.0224387422,
-0.0316883922,
-0.0011662589,
-0.0705599338,
0.0283879675,
-0.0380065925,
-0.0049774111,
0.0464494005,
0.0130588878,
0.0210630391,
-0.0093543818,
-0.0348990522,
0.0417580418,
-0.0313941911,
-0.0001480942,
0.0028256413,
0.075674586,
0.0228301883,
-0.0037715225,
0.0276242644,
0.0230227802,
-0.0538027808,
-0.0062653846,
-0.0137959216,
0.0377988368,
0.0253834445,
-0.0018766999,
0.0141995233,
-0.0252700392,
0.0035624343,
0.0113693774,
0.0746729448,
-0.0324626081,
-0.0585482828,
0.0270280968,
-0.0014830562,
-0.0260060839,
-0.0122666275,
0.054706268,
-0.0496945977,
0.0621818714,
0.0220369212,
0.0134255858,
-0.0464872681,
0.0109484913,
0.0436847508,
0.0365937799,
0.0027277712,
0.0275231842,
-0.0305524953,
-0.0338062122,
-0.0233175382,
0.007792735,
0.0063060042,
0.0443960987,
0.0533931367,
0.0596077777,
-0.0034138358,
-0.0184090901,
-0.0062619979,
-0.0324216075,
-0.0167177618,
-0.0097665172,
-0.0216837451,
-5.883390001e-33,
0.0058744047,
0.0043847007,
0.0222820416,
-0.0108678667,
-0.0387967378,
0.0263945255,
-0.0164626539,
-0.0094918422,
0.0056654876,
-0.0036137963,
-0.0034181487,
0.0412880965,
0.0092687793,
0.044906728,
-0.0346938446,
-0.0188261513,
0.0472417101,
-0.0111874836,
-0.0055643967,
0.0261035543,
0.0412811376,
0.0137611954,
0.0657490194,
-0.0393359438,
0.0128499726,
0.0022119121,
-0.0478960909,
0.0297124982,
-0.020147074,
0.0798674077,
-0.0264111422,
0.0343107916,
0.0392571986,
-0.0024865807,
-0.0147294961,
0.0419270173,
-0.036019396,
-0.0146280685,
0.0303885955,
0.0037133265,
-0.0745088682,
-0.0027125394,
0.0003861701,
-0.038194079,
0.0348120071,
-0.0393328741,
0.0147516439,
0.0053559588,
0.0013672697,
-0.0127503015,
-0.068536371,
0.034337528,
-0.0197989475,
-0.009212953,
-0.0289688874,
0.0501795895,
0.0273698531,
-0.0165766608,
-0.0239070691,
0.0081920922,
-0.0282423124,
-0.0138057731,
0.0066384752,
0.0118894642,
-0.0025169991,
0.0537638329,
-0.0119485352,
0.0070179314,
-0.0561531857,
0.0063783219,
-0.0067314953,
0.0386043675,
0.0336689986,
0.0562134907,
0.0553276613,
0.0127206948,
-0.0442227125,
0.0093060248,
0.0090134582,
-0.0175061729,
0.0346501395,
0.0164454635,
-0.018039884,
0.020802306,
-0.0253996123,
-0.0114705032,
-0.0429948382,
-0.0258064214,
0.0479902029,
0.0419922024,
-0.0168865845,
-0.0138367219,
0.045601353,
-0.0503616706,
0.0523857921,
0.0233979914,
-0.0234177299,
-0.0044436823,
-0.0042109829,
0.0355752334,
-0.0603288561,
-0.0477494933,
0.0738736242,
0.0214213729,
0.0060810917,
0.0044057481,
0.068090111,
0.0102485353,
-0.0339643694,
0.0017430753,
-0.0476269647,
0.0453246795,
-0.061849121,
0.0389794968,
0.0650746226,
0.0216410942,
-0.032397557,
0.0781249925,
0.0348773412,
0.0258422643,
-0.063023597,
-0.0540920757,
-0.0072140736,
-0.005185714,
-0.0167005789,
0.0198324397,
0.0347146057,
-0.0707761347,
0.0301795211,
-0.0701709092,
-0.0030378625,
0.0408820435,
2.399e-7,
0.0611121207,
0.0214680694,
0.0234087761,
0.0653650463,
-0.000911527,
0.0296549033,
0.0005411009,
0.0534608141,
-0.0102526285,
-0.013933979,
0.0453466028,
0.0163125172,
0.0220843107,
0.0008068621,
-0.0769510269,
0.0365159363,
-0.069405295,
-0.0225189477,
-0.0548683666,
-0.0040200786,
0.1216561124,
0.1240761057,
0.0207512695,
-0.0148943951,
0.0412264392,
-0.0304534771,
0.0586515553,
-0.0191479307,
-0.0041686781,
0.009282426,
0.057743825,
0.0396081507,
0.0152350236,
0.0020058099,
0.0015160665,
0.0024104917,
-0.0054274313,
0.0319958106,
0.0139693534,
0.0091757951,
-0.0069916481,
-0.0151439542,
-0.0109411748,
-0.073375985,
0.0948731676,
-0.0429244414,
-0.0220850874,
-0.0344513953,
0.0099295285,
-0.0119219655,
0.0360465571,
-0.0128667578,
0.0097381109,
0.0230271332,
0.0251195189,
-0.0183294266,
0.0008323035,
-0.0952628851,
-0.0108013181,
-0.0390375331,
-0.051924713,
-0.0069075017,
-0.0223321244,
0.03641662,
0.0493629724,
-0.067669861,
-0.0216553304,
2.119829345e-34,
0.0379791148,
-0.0151011422,
0.0252668634,
-0.018108394,
0.0396717191,
0.0162796564,
0.0071461634,
-0.0312396344,
0.0072417036,
-0.0922782868,
-0.0146278664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13506v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13506v2 | Training and Meta-Evaluating Machine Translation Evaluation Metrics at the Paragraph Level | 2023-08-25T17:31:46 | 2023-08-28T17:46:59 | Daniel Deutsch, Juraj Juraska, Mara Finkelstein, Markus Freitag | cs.CL | cs.CL | As research on machine translation moves to translating text beyond the
sentence level, it remains unclear how effective automatic evaluation metrics
are at scoring longer translations. In this work, we first propose a method for
creating paragraph-level data for training and meta-evaluating metrics from
existing sentence-level data. Then, we use these new datasets to benchmark
existing sentence-level metrics as well as train learned metrics at the
paragraph level. Interestingly, our experimental results demonstrate that using
sentence-level metrics to score entire paragraphs is equally as effective as
using a metric designed to work at the paragraph level. We speculate this
result can be attributed to properties of the task of reference-based
evaluation as well as limitations of our datasets with respect to capturing all
types of phenomena that occur in paragraph-level translations. | [
0.0373632163,
0.0326555185,
0.0178473815,
0.0190362502,
-0.0387340784,
0.003576295,
0.0317016393,
-0.0014921307,
-0.0669339448,
-0.0308841355,
-0.0555349588,
-0.0194364004,
0.0732357204,
-0.0274348799,
0.0237711705,
-0.0597910248,
0.0041301195,
0.0298705772,
-0.008144903,
0.0311383381,
0.0201566964,
0.0015615829,
0.0033741288,
0.0400146767,
0.0015583369,
-0.0118721994,
0.04393664,
0.0448783413,
0.0768449157,
-0.0117299948,
-0.0036024482,
0.0098543661,
-0.0160531513,
0.0632545874,
0.0000015743,
-0.0274559706,
-0.0310583729,
0.018618105,
0.0058802487,
0.0200860314,
0.0715604126,
-0.0517133474,
-0.0068711364,
0.0192380194,
-0.0216451809,
-0.0544140376,
0.0461600944,
0.008519805,
0.0463055782,
0.0851618573,
-0.0186521094,
-0.029000273,
-0.0306893867,
-0.0678340197,
-0.0196477361,
-0.0485566594,
-0.0344896093,
-0.003867418,
-0.0573921353,
0.0149392141,
-0.003235166,
0.0350630395,
0.0206598546,
-0.0251150634,
0.0387498252,
0.0003841483,
-0.0608778298,
0.0268124677,
0.0168051943,
0.0582443886,
-0.0354346782,
-0.0064692711,
-0.0331354737,
-0.0069410442,
-0.0070075868,
-0.0226643421,
-0.025706891,
-0.0142921405,
0.0132607771,
0.0063368357,
-0.0352127664,
0.0601866059,
0.0353329219,
-0.0068825344,
-0.032570716,
0.0196153503,
0.0327139832,
-0.0396483131,
-0.0001081633,
-0.0025445437,
-0.0094680432,
0.0051728371,
0.0323752426,
-0.0267666131,
-0.006084552,
0.0052746157,
-0.0298563018,
-0.0509642698,
0.0066305068,
-0.0618460514,
0.0780156702,
0.0381869078,
0.0008780416,
0.0395903587,
-0.0276754983,
0.0944081545,
0.0123492721,
0.0173453204,
-0.0796131492,
-0.0029553818,
-0.0566604845,
0.0529816374,
-0.0525956377,
-0.0226779319,
-0.0156962182,
0.0058200536,
-0.055404149,
-0.0195030924,
0.0135906702,
0.0166772921,
0.0253342129,
-0.0322322249,
-0.0398010649,
-0.0281825084,
0.0040676752,
0.0503639132,
-0.0481140502,
-0.0127277225,
-0.0007780379,
0.0028366151,
-0.0372889154,
0.0220770352,
-0.0114139542,
-0.0428882167,
0.0003535619,
0.0806539431,
-0.0072600129,
-0.0254418999,
0.0296538454,
0.002436127,
-0.0473630354,
-0.0784057528,
-0.0186614469,
-0.0489952527,
0.0351262018,
-0.0115943868,
0.0210136194,
0.001173596,
0.0015458573,
0.0080299005,
0.0012278809,
0.0556633957,
0.0263678487,
-0.0030641439,
-0.0395566709,
-0.0140428003,
0.0010472151,
0.0556177907,
0.0807067975,
0.040370781,
0.0381542929,
0.0256080274,
-0.0025143682,
0.0407109074,
0.0139782112,
0.0246499944,
0.001030097,
0.0072411713,
0.0177725814,
0.0477155671,
-0.0078670988,
0.0500544831,
-0.0417571291,
0.0200704001,
0.0686192885,
-0.000804177,
0.0202850662,
0.0029594826,
0.0680049136,
-0.0095445095,
-0.0079988642,
0.0209242981,
-0.0268617086,
0.0293285251,
0.0296674687,
0.0000720239,
0.0614678562,
0.0264706928,
-0.0062602111,
-0.0584040768,
-0.0019752395,
-0.0110609112,
-0.0320367217,
-0.0371347144,
0.022014562,
0.0521711446,
-0.0249159615,
0.0135308327,
-0.0394056439,
-0.0788226053,
0.039883472,
-0.0058302265,
-0.0459046438,
0.0709206238,
0.0897592008,
-0.0141193718,
-0.0207194593,
-0.0132327927,
0.0208451822,
0.0605662838,
0.0428944975,
-0.0070105181,
0.0552254803,
-0.0473798327,
-0.015716007,
-0.0171064977,
0.0290005766,
0.0031981207,
0.0100395642,
0.0104960296,
0.0481697433,
-0.0989614353,
-0.0694013909,
0.0386990309,
0.0333492868,
-0.0087769926,
0.0431168042,
0.0319253132,
0.0041689971,
0.0094145713,
-0.0175442975,
0.0190965664,
0.000480256,
-0.0526991859,
-0.0123015251,
0.0230022445,
0.0006378256,
-0.0505112223,
0.0196226332,
-0.0770233274,
-0.0168845616,
0.0091903135,
-0.0588831939,
-0.0411286652,
-0.0307794958,
-0.0388469435,
0.0187349804,
-0.0043494981,
0.0377403945,
-0.0109881852,
-0.0015457264,
-0.0466408879,
0.0142991524,
-0.0071270857,
0.0395708755,
-0.0020179695,
-0.032636866,
0.065699555,
0.0029878328,
-0.0282389596,
-0.0113431439,
0.0102898879,
0.040190544,
0.0448511094,
0.0314114653,
-0.0378869772,
-0.0711325034,
-0.0496978536,
0.0434277803,
-0.0353813693,
0.0631318465,
0.0668215081,
0.0362692587,
0.0062983017,
-0.0016281628,
-0.0223808642,
-0.0144772055,
-0.0068306723,
0.008405759,
0.0445100442,
0.0096076801,
0.0264222044,
-0.0643886775,
-0.0187860932,
0.0096745519,
0.0712279975,
0.0105268424,
0.0246813092,
-0.0280190203,
0.0157710221,
-0.0203806702,
-0.0358232819,
0.0112877833,
-0.0770638809,
0.0151268486,
-0.0139278211,
0.0551798753,
0.0714389458,
-0.0028852392,
-0.0155390343,
0.0450931303,
0.0085416855,
-0.0470967218,
-0.0050204615,
-0.0313302986,
-0.0232455805,
-0.0295944531,
-0.0357878879,
0.0083281286,
0.0180059541,
-0.001108966,
-0.0094905933,
-0.0456547625,
0.0030592312,
-0.0250844024,
-0.0372659676,
0.0018394848,
0.0376919433,
0.0151296379,
0.0166826043,
-0.0563028418,
-0.048425518,
0.0660128668,
-0.0348843709,
-0.007071068,
-0.0317027196,
0.0183512643,
-0.0482186414,
0.0595430695,
-0.0124332663,
-0.0047592074,
-0.047393661,
0.0101851579,
-0.0289288815,
0.0022968829,
0.0303300582,
-0.0273523964,
0.034826722,
-0.0484779328,
-0.012389061,
-0.0363076329,
-0.0238935556,
-0.0140661411,
0.0065158834,
0.0196961407,
-0.0082703847,
-0.0337083526,
-0.0235014297,
-0.0401254147,
-0.0011476576,
0.0182605665,
0.0382106267,
-0.0457389131,
-0.0057071028,
-0.0154056503,
0.0329479426,
-0.0151982475,
-0.0111743445,
-0.0211764257,
-0.0396857299,
0.0236914344,
0.0069263172,
0.0101944422,
0.0137426239,
-0.0411748625,
-0.0378652029,
0.0136438105,
0.0069011971,
0.0138050877,
-0.0111902226,
0.0517181382,
-0.0518044308,
-0.0380573422,
0.1019407511,
0.0365051702,
-0.0340185016,
-0.0405419357,
0.0089922482,
0.0449557044,
0.0034884792,
-0.0151028633,
-0.0424904004,
-0.0238266792,
-0.0153501909,
0.0435973816,
0.0291750524,
0.0151793417,
-0.0134453177,
-0.0657426193,
-0.014900933,
0.0360601582,
-0.0315482207,
-0.0693592429,
-0.0116220387,
0.0084279245,
-0.0650596321,
0.0137622934,
-0.0172959678,
0.0038705396,
0.0276229084,
-0.0169857591,
0.0082792323,
-0.0322631672,
-0.0008960385,
-0.0656481832,
0.009385339,
0.0780849308,
0.062110018,
0.0202909485,
0.0055713775,
0.0339302197,
-0.0191424098,
-0.0224722773,
0.0264658555,
0.0768064633,
-0.0085983193,
0.0050278455,
0.0215653703,
-0.003971105,
-0.0150032472,
0.0197657309,
0.0236924794,
0.014979003,
0.0057992837,
0.0035697494,
-0.0016032481,
0.0114729274,
0.000178018,
0.0572049133,
0.0346298851,
-0.0541255102,
-0.0162056088,
-0.0159772001,
-0.0274033714,
-0.1099720299,
0.0038845388,
0.0190215353,
-0.0272794943,
-0.0139482133,
-0.1056217477,
-0.0759461224,
0.00691394,
0.0304316152,
0.0164712183,
-0.0080383085,
-0.0281277001,
-0.018894434,
-0.0342080966,
0.0157290008,
-0.0423277244,
0.040657606,
-0.0215556566,
0.0291281901,
0.0165398736,
0.0079219434,
0.021237243,
0.0326426812,
-0.0688334331,
-0.0360086635,
-0.0299458411,
0.0628404841,
0.0220626425,
0.0314850472,
-0.0437949933,
-0.0087762382,
0.0389412604,
0.0060805469,
-0.0338222235,
0.0159657001,
0.038199015,
0.0016422734,
-0.0164976269,
0.0518070497,
-0.0031621484,
-0.0023773897,
0.0371963233,
0.0494987108,
0.0160661805,
-0.0388748795,
0.031870123,
-0.0035284653,
0.0437555723,
-0.0320721455,
-0.0012815035,
-0.0034805131,
0.0101778926,
-0.0195577238,
-0.0354761332,
-0.0380834825,
-0.0213365983,
0.0607120395,
0.020170575,
-0.0319746844,
0.0382272154,
-0.0402067155,
0.0024385792,
-0.0152965859,
-0.0037073581,
-0.009087,
0.0365095548,
-0.0205503441,
0.0166833233,
-0.0277654082,
-0.0206534937,
-0.0166773256,
-0.0166625381,
-0.0073986072,
0.0036736822,
0.0264520459,
0.0163552202,
0.0217886586,
0.0701748058,
-0.0571070872,
0.0685708746,
-0.0290889982,
-0.0053964141,
0.0536801964,
0.0114369197,
0.1054325178,
0.0043166066,
-0.0163409505,
-0.0245821364,
0.0630327016,
0.0058079162,
-0.0064741429,
-0.0446443968,
-0.0118236858,
0.0263136234,
0.0176367257,
0.0532705598,
-0.0185202267,
0.0191138703,
-0.0094201993,
-0.0215297528,
-0.0277848579,
-0.0237217192,
-0.0627032816,
-0.045277562,
0.017568009,
-0.0274408478,
-0.0522980578,
-0.0389507413,
0.0109189367,
0.0724869147,
0.0125142569,
0.0155919762,
0.0010766268,
0.0530380458,
-0.0443599336,
0.0080976859,
-0.0603851564,
-0.0076264371,
0.0056764064,
-0.016883783,
-0.0637565851,
-5.023807553e-33,
-0.0396263786,
-0.0084135467,
-0.0034670939,
-0.006342778,
-0.0825418606,
-0.0018010131,
-0.0312436521,
-0.0164198298,
0.0078963386,
0.0339367911,
0.007374757,
0.012630837,
0.0190905221,
-0.0013306652,
0.0026519878,
0.0071112718,
0.0657004043,
-0.0037693968,
-0.0813861638,
0.011420262,
0.0266655665,
-0.0062297657,
0.0704799816,
-0.0308872629,
0.053926941,
0.0061053089,
-0.0464356095,
0.0066921823,
0.0299274195,
0.0277522672,
0.0277676936,
0.0168280825,
0.0473689325,
-0.0126414904,
-0.0242007095,
0.0011475256,
-0.0960013643,
-0.000765494,
0.0354231894,
0.0249311421,
-0.0377301276,
-0.0402094014,
0.0338121988,
-0.0346244201,
0.0043603717,
-0.0405276269,
0.0394856147,
-0.0760069713,
-0.0302223805,
-0.0096756192,
-0.0374676883,
0.0231280401,
-0.0250708703,
-0.0211364683,
0.0184200183,
0.0608874746,
-0.0062518502,
-0.0056292433,
-0.0203485079,
0.0074970094,
-0.0383396633,
0.0929690897,
0.00690223,
0.0108146807,
-0.0169423409,
-0.0017183095,
0.0142937871,
0.0108637447,
0.0242356658,
-0.0137148742,
0.0150603931,
-0.0201384351,
0.0794679597,
0.0798033848,
0.0369010381,
0.0180340782,
-0.0614827238,
0.0762855038,
-0.0523078106,
0.0184362121,
0.0077473097,
0.0028193223,
0.0155614978,
0.0290347263,
-0.0717750117,
-0.0471513905,
-0.0373391472,
-0.0071023214,
0.0216562282,
0.0309159867,
-0.0196784344,
-0.0254657678,
0.0533965901,
-0.0043735681,
0.0320122465,
0.0045214309,
-0.0263809208,
0.0348200649,
-0.0112896161,
0.000892095,
-0.0108960252,
-0.0035876343,
0.03750927,
0.0839546844,
0.0184555762,
-0.0602053814,
0.0902849957,
0.0178807359,
-0.0458963364,
0.0181999151,
-0.0455226414,
-0.0173140764,
-0.0431932844,
0.0067940452,
-0.0170371179,
-0.0099945571,
-0.0223530754,
0.0295481663,
0.0066722673,
-0.00255987,
0.0001848263,
0.0260326117,
0.032548517,
0.029200932,
-0.0617039986,
0.0247527398,
-0.0270452015,
-0.0004156552,
0.0266064107,
-0.03726881,
-0.0063591576,
-0.001167839,
2.108e-7,
0.0681480765,
0.0272194501,
0.0562136658,
0.0249544103,
-0.0001502736,
0.0016047581,
-0.0429426134,
0.0434706435,
-0.0059394687,
0.0388680585,
0.0551017188,
0.0039782752,
0.085507676,
0.0053060018,
-0.0851055682,
0.004517416,
-0.0301497057,
0.0098047964,
-0.0217796806,
-0.038418889,
0.0648838356,
0.0565861315,
0.013821546,
0.03008084,
-0.0173270926,
-0.0398826525,
0.092008926,
-0.0191090945,
-0.016223833,
0.0242287051,
0.0287167132,
0.0322311409,
-0.0474398881,
0.008167021,
-0.0335802361,
0.022346573,
0.0718493685,
0.0683637559,
0.0188796148,
-0.0155990878,
-0.0049085161,
-0.0402629822,
-0.0025275594,
-0.002764808,
0.0280289389,
-0.0516843088,
0.0013867604,
-0.0150964512,
-0.0152294794,
0.0463796407,
0.0469413213,
-0.0356692672,
-0.0588768348,
0.0347212739,
0.0450492278,
0.0024601719,
-0.0213597436,
-0.0534444973,
-0.0831104666,
-0.0026919879,
0.0171041023,
-0.0397438183,
-0.0059365048,
-0.0014770796,
-0.0161471218,
-0.0800659955,
0.0101110386,
1.583551832e-34,
0.0554461032,
-0.0450550988,
0.0074416231,
-0.0643288568,
0.0324768052,
-0.036049176,
-0.0384993739,
-0.0404413119,
0.0051823086,
-0.0451766402,
-0.0004106482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13590v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13590v1 | LSTM-based QoE Evaluation for Web Microservices' Reputation Scoring | 2023-08-25T17:23:12 | 2023-08-25T17:23:12 | Maha Driss | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Sentiment analysis is the task of mining the authors' opinions about specific
entities. It allows organizations to monitor different services in real time
and act accordingly. Reputation is what is generally said or believed about
people or things. Informally, reputation combines the measure of reliability
derived from feedback, reviews, and ratings gathered from users, which reflect
their quality of experience (QoE) and can either increase or harm the
reputation of the provided services. In this study, we propose to perform
sentiment analysis on web microservices reviews to exploit the provided
information to assess and score the microservices' reputation. Our proposed
approach uses the Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) model to perform sentiment
analysis and the Net Brand Reputation (NBR) algorithm to assess reputation
scores for microservices. This approach is tested on a set of more than 10,000
reviews related to 15 Amazon Web microservices, and the experimental results
have shown that our approach is more accurate than existing approaches, with an
accuracy and precision of 93% obtained after applying an oversampling strategy
and a resulting reputation score of the considered microservices community of
89%. | [
0.0443477035,
-0.0226341393,
-0.0288935322,
0.0237085372,
-0.0364197269,
0.0101727992,
0.0066484446,
-0.0179144517,
0.0363727771,
-0.0663795024,
-0.0473940857,
-0.0633554086,
0.0397031941,
0.0561209731,
-0.0240592901,
0.0082376432,
0.0217663217,
0.0441610813,
0.0265266001,
-0.0050964323,
0.0163777899,
-0.0299076345,
0.0167581029,
-0.0336382017,
0.02214792,
-0.0497039407,
0.0312954411,
-0.0249550138,
0.0426149704,
-0.0675727278,
0.004467159,
-0.0352700055,
-0.0296615511,
-0.0061641452,
0.0000019441,
-0.0275618229,
-0.0089207273,
-0.0239490662,
-0.0107846176,
0.0115194824,
0.0275776275,
0.0612974949,
0.0228948109,
0.0555004254,
-0.0313337557,
-0.0122029176,
0.0105859013,
0.013004642,
0.054956153,
0.0256733801,
-0.0235108323,
-0.005452116,
-0.0461376049,
-0.0222100634,
-0.0014601904,
-0.0103157097,
0.0121121453,
-0.0443665236,
-0.0693926513,
-0.0292924363,
0.0133460192,
0.0149702411,
0.005816774,
0.0066976077,
0.0508367717,
0.0177132227,
0.0577778146,
0.0531476438,
-0.0374750607,
0.0098940693,
0.0169807598,
0.0498791188,
-0.0159978177,
0.0267698988,
0.0071474081,
-0.0019429472,
-0.0388374515,
0.011195505,
0.0222476702,
0.014307023,
-0.0578651987,
0.0411130041,
0.0469406806,
0.0137042953,
0.0186709072,
0.0583219267,
0.0129568381,
-0.0449785441,
-0.0316071473,
-0.0123753352,
0.0104293376,
0.0106911659,
0.0167108104,
0.0036155235,
0.0015534876,
0.0141165545,
0.0590903535,
0.0335318632,
0.0354933143,
-0.0444742627,
-0.002858765,
-0.0094319442,
0.0076566576,
0.0585145652,
-0.055289451,
0.0207454003,
0.0634153113,
-0.0386593528,
-0.0028882872,
0.0308679566,
-0.0593637824,
0.01830706,
0.0555076897,
0.1073191911,
0.0323323905,
-0.005617023,
-0.0889452994,
0.0062432657,
-0.0310099646,
0.0194918551,
0.018749347,
0.0426092818,
0.0568708517,
0.0232620519,
-0.0515118763,
0.0075778272,
-0.0319453254,
0.0374824926,
-0.0484045893,
0.0127472719,
0.0429464653,
-0.0194312632,
0.014066047,
-0.0002795127,
0.0155141568,
0.1019730866,
0.0666380376,
-0.03372778,
-0.0568317845,
-0.0192627162,
-0.0190968625,
-0.0177054983,
-0.0198930986,
-0.0514088012,
-0.0443619713,
0.0056728423,
0.0092708515,
0.055546619,
0.0070523177,
-0.0034986846,
-0.0117455712,
0.0170280691,
-0.0112168752,
-0.0352249555,
0.0230758898,
0.0024522259,
0.0482249483,
-0.0331004634,
0.0537013188,
0.0412542485,
0.0523544773,
0.0052324855,
-0.0042892345,
0.0008828322,
-0.0157924928,
-0.0386502221,
0.0301571563,
0.0162610319,
-0.0423210151,
0.0097506316,
-0.013050844,
0.0583185144,
0.0075678411,
-0.0230112504,
0.0830381289,
0.0073514679,
-0.0139793716,
0.0599219687,
-0.0084034204,
-0.0561315715,
-0.0003076032,
-0.0748917088,
-0.0087753301,
0.0572288223,
-0.0076100929,
0.0254776794,
-0.0105867377,
0.057133127,
-0.0101967445,
-0.0175114311,
0.0105196545,
-0.0555257872,
0.0026610824,
-0.0260495655,
0.0210348573,
-0.0278087407,
-0.042869281,
0.0430024453,
-0.0190404132,
-0.0000392889,
0.0190224778,
-0.0477751829,
0.0543364286,
0.1059537306,
0.0152220977,
0.00003604,
0.0355001613,
-0.0511670895,
-0.1009597182,
0.0234633647,
0.0251087211,
-0.0014275528,
-0.035474252,
-0.0124812154,
0.0057068709,
-0.0173670631,
-0.0107926615,
0.0007801627,
-0.0381227136,
0.0853898078,
0.0216422267,
-0.0151976338,
-0.0380309224,
-0.0302508343,
0.0645013973,
-0.0024786734,
0.0403042249,
0.0122844279,
0.0354112498,
0.0707974061,
0.0356211253,
0.0263587516,
0.0323333964,
-0.0399041586,
-0.0710022002,
-0.0047968691,
-0.0051812604,
-0.0425806455,
0.01084523,
-0.0291174445,
0.0398696736,
0.0839019194,
-0.0239715558,
-0.034600012,
0.0053454731,
-0.0193798188,
-0.0212936681,
-0.0078014494,
-0.0151811074,
-0.0267911982,
-0.0154995332,
-0.016746534,
0.0236723293,
-0.0338519067,
0.02485843,
-0.0715146363,
0.0074550165,
0.0197420288,
0.0316738747,
-0.0525832064,
-0.0234795585,
0.0151889818,
0.0059881355,
0.0365434065,
-0.0208745021,
-0.0573855303,
0.0111211836,
-0.0984897017,
-0.0150707029,
0.0229628589,
0.0406476073,
-0.0209484715,
-0.0053448887,
0.0367994346,
0.0143740764,
-0.0307751261,
0.0118965097,
-0.0116788093,
-0.007546992,
0.0763008893,
0.0124966465,
-0.0047561876,
-0.0320398211,
-0.0189136304,
0.0077490201,
0.0290753953,
0.0068771783,
0.0122978045,
0.0104208337,
0.0006609661,
-0.0695886686,
-0.0517890491,
0.016979238,
-0.0671305656,
-0.0200674422,
0.0288564917,
0.0140851084,
0.0258302595,
0.0515454523,
-0.0282486547,
-0.0113239633,
-0.021488009,
0.0152599839,
-0.0332606658,
-0.0467446335,
-0.015680695,
-0.0165385287,
-0.0052723107,
-0.022441702,
0.0243906677,
0.0230676308,
-0.0022218276,
0.0051447693,
0.0044488972,
-0.0171543062,
0.0374425389,
0.0180051345,
0.0434405208,
-0.0170734655,
0.0044489163,
0.0200083405,
-0.04260372,
0.0561587811,
0.0225738827,
0.0585796572,
-0.0418662131,
0.013980465,
-0.0270336289,
0.015523646,
-0.0402308442,
0.002272336,
-0.0671999902,
-0.010673997,
0.0387482047,
-0.0064432221,
-0.004461797,
-0.0614070036,
-0.0187583156,
0.0586758181,
-0.0233669262,
0.0332820788,
0.0012993005,
0.0038169625,
0.0100477301,
-0.0413955711,
0.0102994116,
0.0315680839,
-0.0042790691,
0.0190938059,
0.0519199483,
-0.0002891528,
-0.0438151397,
-0.0282371789,
-0.0325468183,
0.0514197573,
0.0068218918,
0.0088919345,
-0.0455766357,
0.0707216337,
0.017488176,
0.025561275,
0.0018173325,
0.044214759,
-0.0205284711,
-0.0210499633,
-0.0330886059,
-0.008207825,
-0.0406642593,
-0.0200540461,
0.0012147927,
-0.0267411955,
-0.0438120849,
-0.0194039941,
0.1018704399,
0.020305017,
-0.0379951037,
-0.0195053574,
0.0166344456,
-0.0630847067,
0.0293187778,
-0.0397387631,
-0.0235311091,
-0.0119921127,
-0.0307629686,
0.0189584736,
-0.035698466,
-0.0472703576,
0.0005802233,
-0.0921384096,
-0.0078838971,
-0.0157625936,
-0.0138140535,
-0.0295760985,
-0.0477637835,
-0.0069380063,
-0.010688466,
0.0209347103,
0.0136034656,
-0.0101238554,
0.0181022417,
-0.0062130787,
-0.0593341887,
-0.0146979699,
0.0793688148,
-0.070575282,
0.0598049611,
0.0509719253,
0.0552308187,
-0.060852956,
-0.0522541814,
-0.0472302586,
-0.0097550424,
-0.0038805597,
-0.0062327208,
0.0336377658,
-0.0439902432,
-0.0141816447,
-0.0254752859,
-0.006105687,
-0.0620819926,
0.0543318391,
0.0015761595,
0.0112577239,
-0.0017741744,
-0.03860965,
-0.0215316284,
-0.0209094174,
0.0066504749,
0.0907092467,
-0.0269230157,
-0.0534405001,
-0.0103867361,
-0.0272939336,
-0.0606603175,
0.0211288147,
0.0133828595,
0.0223074965,
0.0086012138,
-0.0334751494,
-0.0977263749,
0.0046260031,
-0.0056801019,
0.0070336438,
0.0224569477,
0.0418883301,
0.0230025761,
0.0308410879,
-0.0519628935,
-0.0471078716,
0.0221438967,
0.0534430407,
-0.0326706916,
0.0619314015,
0.0875583589,
0.0060264859,
-0.0100708287,
-0.0529528186,
-0.0728750452,
-0.0073141963,
-0.0007291067,
0.0779288858,
0.01559301,
-0.024541324,
0.007605568,
-0.0177452378,
0.0873183683,
0.074538894,
-0.0638374463,
-0.0328201056,
0.0307876393,
0.0903719664,
-0.023493981,
0.006846535,
-0.0375852138,
-0.0340915285,
0.0093154218,
-0.0491099581,
-0.0044652824,
0.0027726393,
-0.0385937877,
-0.0064710998,
0.0315022208,
0.014606135,
0.0136083551,
-0.0059602298,
0.0091306316,
-0.0093672602,
0.0077601457,
-0.0107700899,
-0.0012131023,
0.0096627753,
0.0358698368,
-0.0409621671,
0.0045943996,
0.0268367752,
-0.0324869566,
-0.0087848548,
0.0269111339,
-0.0010183739,
0.0169246253,
-0.0034711231,
0.0009056009,
-0.0114704249,
-0.0683836415,
0.0148631856,
-0.0166402366,
-0.0066887848,
0.0150116794,
0.0161168575,
0.0109548671,
-0.0117564853,
0.0434776582,
0.0011598407,
-0.033530727,
-0.0032235282,
0.0012790831,
-0.0095582809,
0.000386858,
0.0378824249,
-0.0488533676,
0.0297171809,
-0.0067499382,
-0.0005463292,
-0.0127265779,
0.0048777401,
0.0016407209,
0.0129749635,
-0.0346143804,
0.0475610644,
0.0431809165,
-0.0365111791,
-0.022403961,
-0.0211459547,
-0.0607381724,
-0.0328122675,
0.0380123816,
0.0063867625,
0.0285104569,
-0.0289306846,
-0.0139311804,
-0.0500456057,
-0.0386326984,
0.0744330436,
0.0216008909,
0.0600054041,
-0.0273845103,
0.0417062268,
0.0381799117,
0.0275939424,
0.0427354611,
-0.0314595439,
-0.0192876533,
-0.0345913433,
-0.0079463515,
-0.0137874307,
-6.318103607e-33,
0.0143701797,
-0.0616246834,
-0.0249735713,
0.0466109738,
-0.000109637,
0.0117806019,
-0.0147732124,
-0.0136758136,
0.0292565282,
0.0182662699,
0.021706013,
0.0172781907,
0.0049152751,
-0.0094395196,
0.0546626784,
-0.0150285736,
0.0625895113,
0.0004414262,
0.0028505558,
0.0456763431,
0.018699646,
0.0310448259,
0.0608588532,
-0.0447745398,
0.0364655107,
-0.0179271232,
-0.0354689583,
0.0088233249,
-0.0097787054,
0.0490531027,
-0.0242655408,
0.0460857376,
0.0096436553,
-0.0403636694,
0.0503862724,
-0.014708668,
-0.0322088338,
0.0400270857,
0.037849959,
-0.0329243205,
-0.022650145,
0.0283313654,
-0.0082889916,
0.046116136,
-0.003615947,
0.0201709326,
0.0323420539,
-0.0296383426,
0.0219005551,
-0.1158825308,
0.0358747989,
-0.0185927469,
-0.0340619758,
-0.0011356615,
0.0011652685,
-0.050480321,
-0.0148678543,
0.0615141317,
-0.0896941051,
-0.005739687,
-0.0688285083,
0.0009609126,
0.0140615152,
0.0053491862,
-0.0325999334,
0.0500970893,
-0.0273122918,
0.0232429318,
0.0904483423,
0.0665705428,
0.0318544917,
-0.007226842,
0.0660538077,
0.0385092981,
0.0084929531,
-0.052236367,
-0.0707545131,
0.0002535917,
0.0686433837,
0.0344804376,
0.0555870719,
-0.026974516,
0.0065762349,
0.0148017649,
0.0159788728,
-0.0475279726,
-0.0611756481,
-0.0158148315,
-0.0188629068,
0.024993578,
-0.0202188473,
-0.0191839263,
0.0090011554,
-0.0242568105,
-0.0618192255,
-0.0168082025,
-0.0029242726,
0.0105013447,
0.004275274,
0.0008681592,
-0.0285491459,
0.027200222,
-0.0842136964,
0.0206016842,
-0.0158367604,
-0.0067431694,
0.0115679223,
0.0052119489,
-0.0421267189,
-0.0024843044,
0.0160157215,
-0.0245238263,
-0.0039730156,
-0.0387791917,
-0.0662780702,
-0.0075415676,
-0.0027917533,
0.0877054259,
-0.0069226711,
0.0309063122,
-0.0053938101,
-0.0184453242,
0.0205511339,
-0.0228836443,
-0.0431352295,
-0.0408337228,
0.0020786896,
0.0403364412,
-0.0101685068,
-0.0323847756,
-0.031868428,
-0.0147434641,
2.8e-7,
-0.0034797741,
0.0636787415,
-0.046028018,
-0.0045277718,
0.0613527671,
0.0567583181,
0.0286683161,
0.0317771025,
0.0269578602,
-0.0327425487,
0.0189302694,
-0.0339479409,
-0.0030359491,
0.0339197777,
-0.0919916406,
-0.0232990719,
-0.0538643897,
-0.0323406868,
-0.0206307098,
0.0610416308,
0.0481761806,
0.0396429747,
0.058917366,
-0.0237509385,
0.0122237541,
-0.0128997443,
0.0282979757,
-0.0246128719,
0.0016336831,
0.0036971534,
0.0702885091,
0.0248863231,
0.0017622572,
-0.0069221817,
-0.0198676307,
0.0262291729,
-0.0063389912,
-0.0440173149,
0.0032171293,
-0.0653531924,
0.0158122759,
-0.0031314876,
0.0432175882,
-0.0447001942,
0.017764112,
-0.0610466003,
-0.0403492376,
-0.0434912816,
-0.0046705357,
0.0019128838,
0.0568711944,
-0.016427923,
-0.0416475311,
0.0262037776,
-0.0461940691,
-0.0369785912,
0.0235409383,
-0.0716218129,
0.0209425576,
0.0439539924,
0.0015513788,
-0.055820331,
0.0354796313,
-0.0158138182,
0.0187356044,
-0.0311408229,
0.0263449252,
1.835309432e-34,
0.0705406815,
-0.0444126464,
-0.0062861643,
0.0484174155,
0.0281098429,
0.0017241254,
-0.0393858626,
-0.0251562223,
0.0062298775,
-0.0193125848,
-0.0253894664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13497v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13497v1 | Ngambay-French Neural Machine Translation (sba-Fr) | 2023-08-25T17:13:20 | 2023-08-25T17:13:20 | Sakayo Toadoum Sari, Angela Fan, Lema Logamou Seknewna | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In Africa, and the world at large, there is an increasing focus on developing
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) systems to overcome language barriers. NMT for
Low-resource language is particularly compelling as it involves learning with
limited labelled data. However, obtaining a well-aligned parallel corpus for
low-resource languages can be challenging. The disparity between the
technological advancement of a few global languages and the lack of research on
NMT for local languages in Chad is striking. End-to-end NMT trials on
low-resource Chad languages have not been attempted. Additionally, there is a
dearth of online and well-structured data gathering for research in Natural
Language Processing, unlike some African languages. However, a guided approach
for data gathering can produce bitext data for many Chadian language
translation pairs with well-known languages that have ample data. In this
project, we created the first sba-Fr Dataset, which is a corpus of
Ngambay-to-French translations, and fine-tuned three pre-trained models using
this dataset. Our experiments show that the M2M100 model outperforms other
models with high BLEU scores on both original and original+synthetic data. The
publicly available bitext dataset can be used for research purposes. | [
0.050452169,
0.072433807,
-0.007795617,
0.0507022478,
-0.0135567486,
0.0211791582,
0.0470647328,
-0.0365513898,
-0.0689631253,
-0.0103357602,
-0.0234073643,
-0.1073424891,
0.0419443287,
-0.0010763584,
0.059986759,
-0.0294100475,
0.0162618384,
0.0007491158,
-0.0275061019,
0.0066134483,
-0.0076542469,
0.0515013784,
-0.0024920616,
0.0277637895,
-0.0116965892,
0.0255445056,
-0.0058605741,
0.051801458,
0.0119929099,
-0.0210226085,
-0.0231637061,
0.026117513,
-0.0131539498,
0.0801915452,
0.0000022455,
-0.0647028834,
-0.023286378,
0.0073503796,
-0.0212477315,
0.0225565936,
0.0579181612,
-0.0446640588,
-0.0211192537,
0.0396855585,
-0.0221577864,
-0.0427112244,
0.0946364105,
-0.0051339203,
0.0776165277,
0.0801149085,
-0.0034435811,
-0.0304843057,
-0.0162257459,
-0.0662805066,
-0.0120765725,
-0.004281369,
-0.0106804091,
0.0006710878,
-0.0317241251,
0.0107222637,
-0.0098758303,
0.0504248589,
-0.0092610838,
-0.016541006,
0.0011520637,
-0.0184261426,
-0.0271469336,
-0.1126973778,
0.0103471177,
0.0820999295,
-0.0195576828,
0.0235446524,
-0.0530412011,
-0.0061793057,
-0.0160055179,
-0.0198681392,
-0.0640482306,
0.0224124659,
0.0198930521,
0.0110365786,
-0.0033628282,
0.0546387732,
0.0624484047,
-0.0426286645,
-0.0550351366,
-0.0276122447,
0.0070366948,
-0.0006760527,
0.0145960916,
0.0062456415,
-0.0403115377,
0.037586458,
0.025156552,
-0.0205627568,
0.0215161759,
-0.0069902544,
0.0202159546,
-0.0294277482,
0.0278243273,
-0.048787646,
0.0315243602,
0.0555545576,
-0.0088858847,
0.0271558426,
-0.0280594118,
0.0433285758,
-0.0551594831,
0.00331289,
-0.0542366132,
-0.0129716936,
-0.0415801331,
0.0326310843,
-0.0201272462,
-0.0116994549,
-0.0592669621,
0.0131720509,
-0.0289711449,
-0.009073019,
0.0320180766,
-0.0138213597,
0.044913251,
-0.0268451944,
-0.0482321568,
-0.0167551972,
-0.0011488092,
0.0446970575,
0.0077556381,
0.0257318467,
-0.0125379581,
-0.0976198912,
0.0002517007,
-0.0479349457,
-0.0313928463,
-0.0123875663,
0.0170901194,
0.0849975273,
-0.0379086807,
-0.044612769,
-0.0296303984,
-0.0015553355,
0.0016223181,
-0.0406252034,
-0.0077164778,
-0.0539529212,
0.0827382654,
0.0150943529,
0.073243171,
-0.0208993275,
0.0005987743,
-0.0255319681,
0.0055642123,
0.0817664042,
-0.0151791908,
-0.0242544003,
0.0675484166,
0.0219429135,
0.031725999,
0.068174392,
0.0336825438,
-0.0149197616,
-0.0106669953,
0.0068213721,
-0.0689410716,
0.0407918133,
0.0286131315,
0.021812927,
-0.019705005,
-0.0008045718,
0.0257828552,
0.0686348453,
0.0214084089,
0.0574976578,
0.0022505012,
0.0041667339,
0.0670114532,
0.0083972495,
0.0132769234,
0.0452789664,
0.0154400347,
-0.0006679614,
-0.0064805648,
-0.0537470169,
0.0429793298,
0.0027622106,
0.0182454642,
-0.0170060955,
0.0651798323,
0.0941806138,
-0.0085039316,
-0.023945434,
0.0140397698,
0.0008925241,
-0.0100643365,
-0.031262219,
0.0056082364,
0.0191014744,
-0.0309168007,
0.0116230464,
0.015697632,
-0.0697983801,
0.0110237701,
-0.0423419252,
-0.0250838548,
0.0117841726,
0.0385002717,
0.0340765156,
-0.0536813103,
-0.0472202301,
-0.0272159092,
0.0464331545,
0.0223900359,
0.0086415643,
0.0701289177,
-0.0605825596,
0.0137846665,
-0.019390421,
-0.0043692212,
0.0349508785,
-0.0020268653,
0.0604752004,
0.0322272517,
-0.0404171981,
-0.0436296165,
0.0473530143,
-0.0346477665,
-0.020826932,
0.012327956,
0.0172248073,
0.040926747,
0.0066728564,
-0.0039785625,
0.0115047721,
-0.0189099349,
-0.0493304022,
0.0145241702,
0.0266317036,
-0.0303210001,
-0.030721534,
0.033312954,
-0.0529421605,
0.0163514949,
0.0415120609,
-0.021251766,
-0.0437046811,
0.0174567048,
-0.0112585351,
-0.0118332626,
-0.0159269031,
0.0595667474,
0.0170588251,
0.0157677047,
-0.0093650213,
0.0174425412,
0.0096980277,
-0.0205947477,
0.0015965676,
-0.0036967359,
0.0553921089,
0.0065077785,
-0.0008178783,
0.0540836155,
0.0010932585,
0.0118384045,
0.0154123614,
0.0264327992,
-0.0105017284,
-0.0325066149,
-0.0474076048,
0.0049296804,
-0.0108855739,
0.0266700573,
0.0107268803,
0.0973650515,
-0.0137594789,
-0.0190843157,
0.0090505145,
0.0142296841,
-0.0172967128,
-0.0200101472,
-0.0096496316,
0.0183015093,
0.0127153862,
-0.0332256667,
-0.0042489138,
0.047536958,
0.0506901704,
0.0371133201,
-0.0151743563,
-0.0248855092,
0.0221968032,
-0.0443934165,
-0.0072959815,
-0.0039964374,
-0.0585837997,
0.0152480165,
-0.041928295,
-0.0212987233,
-0.0053394772,
-0.0091525968,
0.018786652,
0.0171308909,
0.0158427451,
-0.0431960523,
-0.0087655131,
-0.0402564034,
-0.0275464021,
-0.0310446005,
-0.0356081389,
-0.0067139273,
0.0612053238,
0.0157349855,
-0.0111363446,
-0.0353125744,
0.0248937383,
0.0107980743,
-0.0204683151,
-0.0125129241,
0.0597643778,
0.0290364791,
0.0267998017,
-0.0282679461,
-0.0294927638,
0.0538443401,
-0.0391112529,
-0.0175161455,
-0.015150656,
0.0012329326,
-0.0343987197,
0.0406860821,
-0.0357089937,
-0.0038531949,
-0.0193277337,
-0.0407580808,
-0.0229787901,
0.0338472873,
0.0393471196,
0.0074276612,
-0.0098062987,
-0.0695327818,
0.0087162061,
-0.0178105682,
-0.0276243854,
-0.0057486631,
-0.0354779065,
-0.0204840451,
-0.0128313396,
0.0575377084,
0.0097994767,
-0.0277885869,
0.0314612761,
0.008386381,
0.0783873722,
0.0227829963,
-0.001285355,
-0.0083596492,
0.0151421642,
-0.0502774417,
-0.019045325,
0.038389802,
-0.0639105216,
0.0094331643,
-0.008039522,
-0.0272987615,
-0.0228897259,
-0.065102227,
-0.0461164601,
0.0221345108,
0.0026947684,
-0.017048331,
-0.0308078025,
0.0311467368,
-0.0295338724,
-0.0213175174,
0.0778451115,
0.0074899695,
-0.023715267,
0.0001985935,
0.0043605715,
0.0261328425,
0.0066643395,
-0.0068069291,
-0.0415564515,
-0.0286847651,
0.0096510611,
0.0243105367,
0.0304688346,
0.0409368798,
-0.0392222777,
-0.0681371316,
-0.0050686626,
0.0608801581,
-0.0652424693,
-0.0086484579,
-0.0110277981,
-0.0525814705,
-0.0428690761,
0.02540824,
-0.0057626702,
0.0263678208,
-0.0208199136,
0.0299138762,
0.0331582762,
-0.1090637743,
-0.0300013814,
-0.0567273051,
0.0702113062,
0.0398669951,
0.0222139526,
0.0026048601,
0.0273960885,
0.0458449125,
-0.0247344449,
0.011449609,
-0.0172597934,
-0.0205832608,
0.0184485838,
-0.0378275588,
0.0137819406,
-0.0213762373,
-0.012808363,
0.0492329895,
0.0108986413,
0.0282838587,
-0.0585772358,
0.0287328251,
-0.0195859093,
-0.024192242,
-0.0006617149,
-0.0144968824,
0.0369653255,
-0.0188832078,
-0.0054799831,
0.0098556587,
-0.0271513127,
-0.0609451085,
0.0039091669,
0.0254474506,
-0.0254757702,
-0.0547836497,
-0.0654186681,
-0.0496551841,
0.0051887482,
0.0264175367,
0.0274732802,
-0.0159417819,
0.0854488462,
0.0143235689,
-0.0264493078,
0.0701240003,
-0.0065759672,
-0.0266836695,
-0.0528012402,
0.000988794,
0.0346605144,
-0.0384095646,
0.0143059287,
0.0143341189,
-0.1109270453,
-0.0619079843,
-0.0201792549,
0.0583175905,
0.0256676618,
0.0098324763,
0.0113399299,
-0.0316855237,
-0.0065456396,
0.0188097619,
0.0102894921,
-0.0207359921,
-0.0256586857,
-0.0214712843,
-0.0084499931,
0.0307604708,
0.030505497,
0.0320749991,
0.010618316,
0.0597247295,
-0.0197751373,
-0.0204238482,
-0.0014343773,
-0.02325215,
0.0551404506,
-0.0360351279,
-0.0289386045,
-0.0787412822,
0.0224049427,
0.0161190815,
0.044917088,
-0.0180687401,
-0.0108427964,
0.0628109202,
0.0304140747,
-0.0038668162,
-0.0523535199,
-0.0050697238,
-0.0293575153,
-0.0032147851,
-0.0071747587,
-0.0261075422,
0.0088813109,
0.0228577759,
0.0289160367,
-0.0107000303,
0.0438600145,
-0.0284313522,
-0.00377375,
-0.0408729129,
0.0434263311,
0.0059000659,
0.0321762078,
0.0004490021,
0.0562821552,
0.0110953841,
-0.0123277577,
-0.0533331819,
0.0097266026,
0.0808289051,
0.0149492016,
0.1071105227,
0.0131248599,
-0.0114001501,
-0.0055449642,
0.053012196,
-0.034011934,
-0.0233486351,
-0.0001887321,
-0.0230607521,
0.0004452479,
0.0411586203,
0.0384515785,
-0.0054708743,
-0.013643479,
0.0220673569,
0.0296678562,
-0.0041468008,
-0.0087053562,
0.0097064078,
-0.0428660549,
-0.0444176234,
0.0145295504,
-0.0056981016,
-0.0504329726,
-0.0023815648,
0.0081468541,
-0.0336174928,
0.0221288446,
0.0042299191,
0.0383451693,
-0.0006567619,
0.007568466,
-0.0394589268,
0.0085644051,
-0.0422319174,
0.00130731,
-0.0061466708,
-6.506224581e-33,
-0.0237514898,
0.0297369678,
-0.0083177863,
-0.049726937,
-0.0342953764,
-0.0276075378,
-0.0217491537,
-0.0090933982,
-0.0302549712,
-0.0131133338,
-0.0081772869,
0.0205834601,
0.0208791383,
0.0405792519,
0.0309645738,
0.0191562679,
0.0423589796,
0.0368644781,
-0.0426140428,
0.0053062732,
0.0392213091,
0.0736468956,
0.0924872607,
-0.0625401959,
0.0304155797,
-0.0600039363,
-0.0268875752,
-0.0023224652,
-0.0358939059,
0.0355580375,
-0.0249527469,
-0.0078970399,
0.0086626057,
-0.0197879616,
-0.0169368219,
-0.0383576229,
-0.0925924852,
0.0158031937,
0.0020224669,
0.0771563724,
-0.0404936783,
-0.0380036719,
0.0588974543,
-0.0141840819,
-0.0405735746,
0.0008975469,
-0.0103933029,
-0.0490514114,
-0.0140857128,
-0.0088441717,
-0.0533304214,
0.002106824,
0.0020632122,
-0.0086511262,
0.0239289291,
0.0595229268,
-0.0654760972,
-0.0420897864,
-0.0885040164,
0.0052675898,
-0.0091259154,
0.0724003389,
0.0622849092,
0.0257208087,
-0.0293263234,
0.0097081289,
0.021957228,
-0.0437973738,
0.0541911088,
0.0166029669,
0.0404705219,
-0.0665327311,
0.0572154857,
0.0465262197,
0.066961661,
-0.0426412188,
-0.0748109072,
0.0176528487,
-0.003053793,
0.0078037265,
0.0105367769,
-0.0013134715,
-0.0070861066,
-0.005267635,
-0.0468818918,
-0.0309015512,
-0.0297569558,
0.0041996711,
0.0155161647,
-0.0038919933,
0.0079248045,
0.00899023,
0.0605295599,
0.0159011446,
0.0076983068,
-0.0523132496,
0.0080946442,
0.0097431727,
-0.0213016868,
0.0388615578,
-0.0132139856,
-0.0317956582,
-0.0056312699,
0.0382036343,
0.0200913828,
-0.0266296007,
0.0247528348,
0.0165623557,
-0.0477955826,
0.0228019543,
-0.0693360865,
0.0089631667,
-0.0228922088,
0.0441141203,
0.0160790775,
-0.056013912,
0.0025918479,
0.0308738593,
0.0237117764,
-0.0154991718,
0.0129286498,
-0.0003115841,
0.0219731499,
0.0292837583,
-0.0669842586,
0.01803964,
-0.0379845127,
0.0213589109,
0.027427122,
-0.0309991632,
-0.0223215111,
0.0323331878,
2.982e-7,
0.0389431082,
0.0372762978,
0.0280324537,
-0.0017366079,
-0.0053570117,
0.0238063596,
-0.0401150398,
0.0018174232,
-0.0148535669,
0.054724548,
0.0122139556,
-0.0164375324,
0.1031823531,
0.0077339676,
-0.0663848817,
-0.0640271157,
-0.0118125901,
0.0440728217,
-0.0525151789,
-0.0368208922,
-0.0204731748,
0.1533287317,
-0.0512347743,
-0.007058097,
-0.0546606407,
-0.0398467146,
0.0780785903,
-0.0036322088,
-0.0226628054,
-0.0078308145,
0.0538861305,
0.072315909,
-0.0458650626,
-0.0036567785,
-0.0207311157,
-0.0139559619,
0.026956046,
0.0731892437,
-0.0086058574,
0.0148176719,
0.0277784131,
-0.0043476014,
-0.0308393892,
-0.0284030475,
0.0029681881,
-0.0181216151,
-0.0281694569,
0.0016945796,
-0.0153434798,
0.0004307815,
0.0836418867,
-0.078943029,
0.0255406275,
-0.0040574083,
0.0415786356,
-0.0436921231,
-0.0241362453,
-0.0256622788,
-0.0207800493,
-0.0099277096,
0.0127136149,
-0.0023992448,
0.0249994677,
0.0315961428,
0.0288961697,
-0.0087397248,
0.0055019092,
2.491814762e-34,
0.0271718726,
-0.0016891155,
0.0386927687,
-0.0076388158,
0.0147944121,
-0.0336946882,
-0.0012806803,
-0.0119461473,
-0.048398871,
0.0009661493,
-0.0172792766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13479v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13479v1 | Prompting a Large Language Model to Generate Diverse Motivational Messages: A Comparison with Human-Written Messages | 2023-08-25T16:35:06 | 2023-08-25T16:35:06 | Samuel Rhys Cox, Ashraf Abdul, Wei Tsang Ooi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly capable and prevalent, and can
be used to produce creative content. The quality of content is influenced by
the prompt used, with more specific prompts that incorporate examples generally
producing better results. On from this, it could be seen that using
instructions written for crowdsourcing tasks (that are specific and include
examples to guide workers) could prove effective LLM prompts. To explore this,
we used a previous crowdsourcing pipeline that gave examples to people to help
them generate a collectively diverse corpus of motivational messages. We then
used this same pipeline to generate messages using GPT-4, and compared the
collective diversity of messages from: (1) crowd-writers, (2) GPT-4 using the
pipeline, and (3 & 4) two baseline GPT-4 prompts. We found that the LLM prompts
using the crowdsourcing pipeline caused GPT-4 to produce more diverse messages
than the two baseline prompts. We also discuss implications from messages
generated by both human writers and LLMs. | [
0.0796287283,
0.0334533937,
-0.0116610834,
-0.014357619,
-0.0298674908,
-0.0005101191,
-0.0076469989,
-0.0004466124,
-0.0057752421,
-0.0085402317,
0.0118414564,
-0.0380668491,
0.001683454,
0.0103768613,
0.0170980133,
-0.0701595843,
-0.0207062121,
-0.0506781153,
0.0686573982,
-0.0208161101,
0.0232642237,
0.0496440157,
0.0182618797,
0.0643145442,
-0.016884895,
-0.0229863226,
0.0034905574,
0.0369636603,
0.0228674728,
-0.0324679166,
-0.0147007173,
0.0503901951,
0.0325269736,
0.0175576452,
0.0000020408,
-0.0616470203,
0.0375941843,
-0.0083098216,
-0.0555086173,
-0.0040121414,
0.0508532375,
0.0371624231,
-0.0391915627,
0.0010118199,
-0.0249770414,
0.0213405509,
0.0729863122,
0.0235093664,
0.0677184016,
0.0625814125,
0.008895007,
-0.0006009071,
-0.002932691,
-0.0083287647,
0.0427774712,
0.0336348228,
-0.0198232792,
-0.0258087758,
0.082413055,
0.0410267971,
0.042722661,
0.0212862659,
0.0065667708,
-0.0404478796,
0.0223804638,
0.0286882166,
-0.0354562551,
-0.0524465889,
-0.0089990012,
0.0294883754,
0.0165922977,
-0.0005812842,
-0.0035039987,
-0.0237209108,
0.0294258539,
0.0157589503,
-0.0581688173,
0.050489936,
0.0047525531,
0.0225263443,
-0.01431714,
0.0253557302,
0.000227551,
0.0002447876,
0.0541141033,
0.0073835789,
0.0196624845,
-0.0102400351,
-0.0066085928,
0.0430570729,
0.003706218,
-0.0754590631,
-0.0083619636,
0.0030118336,
-0.0252597611,
0.00811595,
-0.0053690071,
-0.0238883775,
0.0262938682,
-0.0356952623,
0.0654589161,
0.0119753582,
-0.0030908552,
0.0199312847,
0.0377611518,
-0.0065315603,
-0.0048470185,
-0.0030272861,
-0.0204804875,
0.0122609166,
-0.0660576075,
-0.0343009979,
-0.0613278858,
0.0197431985,
0.0108587556,
0.0052358089,
-0.0488027446,
0.027062783,
-0.0252008904,
-0.0095969383,
0.0090029668,
0.0076144668,
-0.0208997857,
-0.0223153345,
-0.0078262519,
0.0111734588,
-0.0434704386,
-0.0001890763,
0.0253221299,
-0.072559692,
0.0302755665,
0.0223172344,
0.0109182494,
-0.0275344569,
0.0252546072,
0.0503601842,
0.0090031233,
-0.0171255898,
-0.0419033132,
-0.0214883126,
0.0177189279,
-0.0131984754,
-0.0074361451,
-0.0695541278,
0.0160620548,
0.0115832621,
0.0140454248,
-0.0180544928,
-0.0029884826,
0.016867971,
0.0011152147,
0.0167454705,
-0.0338313095,
0.0339625254,
0.0610856228,
0.0006780988,
-0.0132710701,
0.0534637496,
0.0589234978,
0.0708742887,
0.0183895212,
-0.0259842239,
0.0520894378,
0.0306457598,
-0.0373371467,
0.0096127186,
0.0315575227,
0.0013265497,
-0.0197865218,
0.044866845,
-0.0095166648,
0.0704244375,
-0.006166501,
0.0968088359,
0.0933574811,
0.0831406564,
-0.001794578,
-0.0210756455,
0.0500357151,
0.047741808,
0.0026557099,
-0.023242522,
-0.0122204041,
0.0291463081,
0.0029206155,
0.0158209838,
0.0393995494,
0.0410021134,
-0.0367006063,
0.0026472944,
-0.0285067949,
0.0036444762,
0.0112533662,
0.0015477878,
0.0248108767,
-0.0114014102,
-0.0407364629,
0.0127890185,
-0.0040768296,
-0.090308927,
0.006398587,
-0.0186751131,
0.070389919,
0.0879334211,
0.0213029496,
0.0265566222,
0.0334668718,
-0.0540815108,
0.0145496698,
0.0689187422,
0.0204514991,
0.0084304186,
-0.0655388981,
-0.0299384724,
-0.0062262043,
-0.0078990441,
-0.0246707685,
0.0000068052,
0.0124301417,
0.0008741617,
0.0084924409,
0.0139666637,
-0.0814457387,
-0.0012574019,
0.0067574275,
-0.0246183779,
-0.0210259277,
0.0064242207,
0.0085036196,
0.0613611862,
-0.0383845121,
0.0121396398,
-0.0047477195,
-0.0293689277,
-0.0306842197,
0.0384362638,
-0.0314457454,
0.0534700975,
0.0157391112,
-0.0742826164,
-0.011112595,
-0.0165234245,
0.0172760673,
0.0047037886,
0.0389395505,
-0.0345986672,
0.0134916063,
-0.0138018047,
-0.0060796756,
0.0051005483,
-0.0305283014,
0.0029596162,
0.0434834436,
0.0464606807,
-0.0048505901,
0.0109032262,
-0.0172533672,
0.0055849967,
-0.0798649415,
-0.0016365184,
0.0373078585,
0.0153490063,
0.0428870991,
0.0352247693,
0.0241616834,
-0.0546543039,
-0.0462521724,
-0.0778645799,
-0.0373766087,
-0.0072569749,
-0.005946266,
0.0219398718,
-0.0023992246,
-0.0190889295,
0.0095518343,
-0.0724774823,
-0.0252005812,
0.0309289824,
0.0253256951,
0.0034015374,
-0.0103028994,
0.0228497777,
0.001570073,
-0.0025571263,
0.0007821987,
0.0083248485,
0.0922334716,
-0.0099382438,
-0.0788793787,
0.0228073709,
-0.0107341567,
-0.0546803251,
0.0124035524,
-0.0182788428,
0.0524131767,
-0.006968502,
0.1052700728,
-0.0088019418,
0.0237470772,
0.0140884891,
0.0093038119,
-0.0070070704,
-0.025819663,
-0.0185587369,
-0.0015745417,
-0.0170777105,
-0.0009494265,
-0.0814170465,
0.0407638811,
0.0020762798,
0.0319419317,
0.0193830337,
-0.0986816511,
0.0483945273,
-0.0465015769,
0.0048455521,
-0.0710023642,
-0.0735618994,
-0.0372278579,
0.0295497105,
0.0035385969,
-0.0683513284,
0.0504407696,
-0.0247807913,
-0.0258091819,
-0.0082975375,
-0.0164249931,
-0.0213542245,
0.0537376106,
-0.0448024496,
0.0283456147,
0.024038218,
0.0002633175,
-0.0052661644,
0.0069414792,
0.0056864922,
-0.0362339243,
0.0208533704,
-0.0539708845,
-0.0130351121,
-0.0200610626,
-0.019273771,
-0.0146581652,
-0.0312681682,
-0.0299573578,
-0.0136982771,
0.0643715039,
0.0098543121,
0.0225760601,
-0.0100047681,
0.0523944348,
0.015688153,
0.0286892857,
-0.0095229838,
-0.0041403729,
-0.0095760804,
0.0313567258,
0.0110785924,
-0.0085441368,
-0.0728649497,
-0.0199857522,
-0.0087906197,
0.008664432,
-0.0330751911,
-0.0142417215,
-0.0048284861,
0.0458079688,
0.0068858857,
-0.0250576921,
0.0234276224,
0.0914270282,
-0.0175943598,
0.0221831556,
0.0642965883,
-0.0170799978,
-0.0552022792,
-0.0043671825,
-0.0252269078,
0.0094750384,
-0.0108657768,
0.038419731,
-0.0778500289,
0.0120688183,
0.0046388581,
0.0297332443,
-0.0334391408,
0.0173653793,
-0.0273758359,
-0.1056726575,
0.0782805458,
0.0261161253,
-0.0250074174,
0.0321060196,
-0.0169159677,
-0.0393910818,
0.0275911,
-0.054434333,
-0.0104314424,
-0.0325890072,
0.0264632627,
0.0278062392,
-0.007066133,
-0.0710516348,
-0.0056092474,
-0.0316679962,
0.0901570246,
0.0854029357,
0.0195066053,
-0.0317670889,
-0.0725284666,
-0.008920406,
0.0079832748,
0.0179979298,
0.0187902246,
0.020297274,
0.0049937707,
-0.0143564194,
-0.0450193807,
0.0315119028,
-0.0747982785,
-0.0169517398,
0.0152504276,
0.0812587142,
0.019284483,
-0.0377868302,
-0.0150569109,
-0.0007669701,
0.034378916,
0.0747980997,
0.0200979784,
-0.0934483781,
0.0114739742,
-0.0574529581,
-0.0024648113,
-0.0305916239,
-0.0602166317,
-0.0278078225,
-0.0096389744,
-0.0074325805,
-0.0499417633,
-0.0518179871,
0.0321438946,
0.0145425936,
0.0355710089,
0.0062052808,
-0.0344882235,
0.0288791191,
0.0116621936,
0.0570051372,
-0.0005844328,
0.0303034317,
-0.107540153,
-0.0623239055,
-0.0553936325,
-0.0730286017,
0.0215397589,
0.0136718303,
-0.1053477824,
-0.0519237667,
0.0120092714,
0.0290006101,
0.0269043352,
-0.0377854295,
0.029795358,
-0.0627764165,
0.0060417312,
0.0512439385,
-0.0101562198,
0.0328844003,
-0.0173000637,
0.0611037649,
0.0132598113,
-0.006662549,
-0.0284707956,
0.0268619861,
0.0252181645,
0.0276214611,
0.0179619212,
-0.0435944349,
0.0258220751,
0.0703559294,
-0.0203376543,
-0.0625231192,
-0.0289155915,
-0.0484229028,
-0.0310430042,
0.0086406954,
-0.0357351862,
-0.0472062752,
-0.0150666293,
-0.0235230457,
-0.0432593264,
0.0202794913,
-0.0065369504,
-0.0251546409,
0.0206754692,
-0.0421763286,
0.0312424544,
0.0064590792,
0.0403560288,
0.0356648751,
0.0036823594,
-0.0118157035,
0.0295400936,
-0.0607623421,
0.0311378762,
0.0197799075,
0.0481629446,
0.0064777792,
-0.026920354,
0.0556238443,
0.0363247208,
-0.0428044796,
-0.0988031402,
0.0075530978,
0.0127696814,
0.0470733903,
0.013136968,
0.0644962341,
-0.0381641425,
0.0177881941,
-0.017446788,
0.0047487915,
0.0108903171,
-0.0253454298,
-0.0064530135,
-0.0071677701,
-0.0222517401,
-0.0548879653,
0.0447059721,
-0.076876007,
0.0040304777,
-0.0138380947,
0.0252370927,
-0.0388801657,
0.0254815239,
0.0216054153,
0.0009251274,
-0.0104153911,
0.0250547118,
-0.0697854608,
-0.01186225,
-0.0099736834,
0.0180206783,
0.0122769829,
-0.0252084974,
0.050277777,
0.0366257057,
-0.0397056714,
-0.0065044775,
-0.0419418067,
0.0257734396,
-0.0419852696,
0.0077060969,
-0.0251984894,
-6.209395359e-33,
-0.0017256803,
-0.0520260707,
0.0065297992,
0.0081657134,
-0.0102420598,
-0.0291170962,
-0.0447823927,
0.0402913131,
0.0327683128,
0.0344706252,
-0.0161191188,
-0.0311237909,
0.0046249391,
0.0003148182,
0.044185482,
0.0076117483,
0.0577141568,
-0.0008490152,
-0.0476399884,
0.0204128213,
0.0266142022,
-0.016009314,
0.032655213,
-0.060933888,
0.0768292844,
-0.0445333235,
-0.0390674435,
-0.0129678193,
0.0435001701,
0.0129017308,
-0.0151385535,
0.0434962809,
0.0173117239,
-0.0175167453,
-0.0168201812,
0.0228892881,
0.0367339216,
-0.0248902142,
0.0471078865,
-0.0439760312,
-0.0452171713,
-0.0747174695,
0.0026521122,
-0.0316283703,
-0.0413180329,
0.0280437805,
0.0370612741,
0.0104223331,
0.0194176938,
0.0024912751,
-0.0448083282,
0.0132139446,
0.0055987639,
0.0003570421,
-0.0132789109,
0.039471332,
-0.0237127617,
0.0400127061,
-0.0394187495,
0.080510743,
0.0058857794,
0.0014484554,
0.0444217548,
-0.0221131053,
-0.0092907725,
0.0577617735,
-0.002820838,
0.0055077584,
-0.0313801914,
-0.0020096875,
-0.0362368822,
0.0175549127,
0.072057724,
0.0912080407,
0.016055258,
-0.0102505451,
0.0426686928,
0.0278759599,
-0.0195440631,
-0.0522144772,
0.0397261418,
0.0067803995,
-0.0287952777,
-0.0231596548,
0.0096060969,
-0.0280790217,
-0.0124223027,
-0.0516650341,
0.0248207562,
-0.0181284044,
-0.0175141711,
-0.0304979812,
-0.00160965,
0.0069707711,
-0.0073395437,
0.0045181788,
-0.0276652891,
0.0321562104,
0.0099451477,
-0.0307810046,
-0.0674045756,
0.0235945452,
0.0044574295,
0.0480043553,
0.0301147848,
0.0702734217,
-0.00131359,
0.0313518196,
-0.060520988,
0.0242134053,
-0.018240951,
0.0415861569,
-0.0074149622,
-0.0748555139,
0.0150461337,
-0.0019109312,
0.0004443641,
0.0125557575,
0.0144903893,
-0.0448288061,
-0.0174998511,
0.0006976495,
-0.026902182,
0.005821337,
-0.0178251266,
0.0306489225,
-0.0302917473,
0.0424989872,
0.0776432827,
-0.0087058628,
-0.0165201947,
-0.0386448875,
2.832e-7,
-0.0136468466,
0.0265437849,
0.0174999367,
0.0361186415,
0.0113356421,
0.0350200832,
-0.034179382,
0.0131739089,
0.0161605459,
0.021782551,
-0.0106140347,
0.0187102742,
0.0483927689,
0.0320088416,
-0.1003355607,
0.0361358747,
-0.0676361024,
0.0195228159,
-0.050089743,
0.0373305045,
0.0983289629,
0.0049591325,
0.0323552415,
-0.0201429967,
-0.0174434688,
-0.0207871757,
0.0585730076,
-0.0654049143,
-0.0052553788,
0.001763388,
0.0187189579,
-0.0575277321,
-0.0223595984,
-0.0040558418,
0.0012232611,
-0.0472944416,
0.0162978806,
0.0330191217,
-0.0014924043,
0.0156628788,
-0.0001596333,
-0.0004149568,
-0.0045160442,
-0.0633997247,
0.0027278084,
-0.0004887083,
-0.0280631576,
-0.0431034453,
0.002013101,
-0.0437903367,
0.0046351659,
-0.0391198322,
-0.0241283942,
-0.0209421422,
0.0001487504,
-0.0014841506,
-0.0088559715,
-0.028100023,
0.0018314738,
-0.0361220911,
-0.0298826173,
-0.0739545971,
-0.0683838651,
0.0279929973,
-0.0202611387,
-0.0575650409,
0.0253597908,
2.096678764e-34,
0.0225922447,
-0.0014894363,
0.0175627992,
0.0026732611,
0.0397696458,
0.0415394716,
0.0003728072,
-0.0027473904,
0.014953238,
-0.0325227752,
-0.0269604418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13467v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13467v1 | Leveraging Knowledge and Reinforcement Learning for Enhanced Reliability of Language Models | 2023-08-25T16:11:08 | 2023-08-25T16:11:08 | Nancy Tyagi, Surjodeep Sarkar, Manas Gaur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | The Natural Language Processing(NLP) community has been using crowd sourcing
techniques to create benchmark datasets such as General Language Understanding
and Evaluation(GLUE) for training modern Language Models such as BERT. GLUE
tasks measure the reliability scores using inter annotator metrics i.e. Cohens
Kappa. However, the reliability aspect of LMs has often been overlooked. To
counter this problem, we explore a knowledge-guided LM ensembling approach that
leverages reinforcement learning to integrate knowledge from ConceptNet and
Wikipedia as knowledge graph embeddings. This approach mimics human annotators
resorting to external knowledge to compensate for information deficits in the
datasets. Across nine GLUE datasets, our research shows that ensembling
strengthens reliability and accuracy scores, outperforming state of the art. | [
0.0429423228,
0.0136833973,
-0.0165442731,
0.0537018105,
-0.0108513441,
0.0152572561,
-0.0650283694,
0.0064399177,
0.0016280314,
-0.0585243739,
-0.0272150915,
-0.0211002771,
0.0305251759,
0.0040859347,
0.0593080893,
-0.041891858,
0.0310324971,
-0.0188023578,
-0.010043988,
0.0067867162,
0.000394513,
-0.0047440827,
-0.0202025846,
0.0492160991,
-0.0113250501,
0.0251200702,
-0.0010386166,
0.0327352844,
0.0095887035,
0.0001495507,
0.0268935487,
0.0722030103,
0.0201338977,
0.0409006961,
0.0000016528,
-0.0556983873,
0.0035712812,
-0.002634675,
-0.0355026647,
-0.0125208478,
-0.0092799999,
-0.0284911729,
0.0235498678,
-0.0024790484,
-0.025586674,
0.0102137821,
0.0367694683,
0.0352447852,
0.0925638303,
0.0745100677,
0.0140243415,
0.0155434636,
0.0522103123,
-0.0114150122,
0.0519245565,
-0.0032282942,
0.0155728552,
0.0303156562,
-0.0186909903,
-0.0700811595,
-0.0210950356,
0.0138594043,
0.0178463105,
-0.0241749939,
0.0451560393,
0.0236132387,
-0.0353224427,
-0.033834476,
0.0036026696,
0.0695684329,
0.0048544127,
0.0227182582,
-0.0240028426,
-0.002494863,
0.013061665,
0.0712890029,
-0.0200350806,
-0.0223931484,
-0.005938597,
0.0021685385,
-0.0039145164,
-0.0399650782,
0.0479644388,
0.0029619713,
-0.0081057139,
0.1007138491,
0.0211024582,
-0.0249905027,
0.0063380003,
0.0269442834,
-0.0611582845,
-0.0212554205,
-0.0667510554,
-0.0050777937,
-0.0341474116,
0.0463339463,
-0.0553461649,
-0.0055296361,
0.032875713,
-0.0428586379,
-0.013413962,
0.0313252434,
0.0230020229,
0.0499783866,
-0.009486312,
0.048192665,
0.0351141691,
0.0602219887,
-0.0310587771,
-0.0226627458,
-0.0992188826,
-0.0061135343,
0.0001878876,
0.0355971269,
0.0349518619,
-0.0324078389,
-0.0413090624,
0.0224013813,
-0.0368713662,
0.0560815223,
0.005247884,
-0.0063529131,
-0.0059279893,
-0.0048704916,
-0.0751355663,
0.0148834819,
-0.0250924621,
0.0162931532,
0.0025744343,
-0.0368320048,
-0.007746682,
-0.0255484004,
-0.037509203,
-0.0478907414,
0.0020882552,
0.0357525013,
0.035702277,
-0.0364667922,
-0.0441631414,
-0.0102238981,
-0.0071093258,
-0.0376825742,
0.0253800768,
-0.0703560859,
0.024595134,
0.0141308634,
-0.0170537252,
-0.0665152296,
0.0178799443,
0.0077713309,
-0.0396730453,
0.1152117699,
-0.0458028466,
-0.0023166037,
0.0055691279,
0.0085214647,
-0.045812007,
0.085487023,
0.0396626815,
-0.0361205675,
0.0402669497,
0.0168560408,
-0.0315667577,
0.0173585564,
0.0197918564,
0.0199971814,
-0.0249444004,
0.0333963111,
0.0196087714,
0.0290401056,
0.0209021065,
0.05901419,
-0.0496265665,
0.0180767402,
0.0477816574,
0.0316165686,
0.0193006974,
-0.0290323906,
0.0115966285,
0.0110724606,
0.0200664122,
-0.0103010489,
-0.0476359501,
0.0132758627,
-0.0162021425,
0.0027790973,
0.0379876643,
0.0030957493,
-0.0042607058,
-0.0324248113,
-0.0475864001,
-0.0244962126,
0.0183953382,
-0.0028465576,
0.0596993826,
0.0181227978,
-0.0135524664,
0.0255689416,
0.0372288413,
0.0022198912,
0.0353560671,
-0.0542300567,
0.0233593863,
0.1139908358,
0.0801951811,
-0.0395878889,
-0.0500879027,
-0.0213064235,
-0.0403294526,
0.0261300132,
0.0193100479,
-0.0614604093,
0.0030935425,
-0.0442995206,
-0.0464303754,
-0.0121604651,
0.0045255637,
-0.0064804102,
0.0501247756,
0.003637027,
0.0092326729,
-0.0898053646,
-0.0015324119,
0.0498752259,
-0.0005340598,
0.0155262621,
-0.0329703577,
-0.0068517574,
0.0278917663,
0.0169065446,
-0.0223986078,
0.0190551188,
0.0152874989,
-0.0038999703,
-0.043073006,
-0.0128075713,
-0.0183585621,
-0.076526843,
0.0661751553,
-0.0535427332,
-0.048942145,
0.0230198149,
-0.0365356393,
-0.0584545061,
-0.0067969523,
-0.0342781357,
0.0704432577,
-0.0396592952,
-0.0341617167,
-0.0115281362,
-0.0157353301,
-0.0336072706,
0.0446736775,
-0.0271873269,
0.0581754409,
-0.0129637495,
-0.0205954779,
-0.0018859013,
-0.0005352302,
-0.0540007465,
0.0145112667,
0.0149331018,
0.0226593949,
0.0190319195,
-0.0051853121,
-0.0955212265,
-0.0033320019,
-0.0549492128,
-0.0190859456,
-0.0072555523,
0.0144985951,
0.004172306,
-0.0253849439,
0.006331556,
-0.0019568563,
0.0066516562,
-0.0088405646,
-0.0111146905,
0.0275877845,
0.0336023308,
0.0214375816,
-0.0033062003,
-0.0424410887,
-0.031886328,
-0.0093133515,
0.0668041706,
0.0107488614,
-0.0047645997,
-0.0385428816,
0.0030101291,
-0.0483854786,
-0.0039156755,
-0.0141520174,
-0.0100940987,
0.0179582797,
-0.0120491181,
0.0087237041,
0.0073054223,
0.0004188136,
0.0141652431,
0.0479374751,
-0.0173467733,
-0.0512344278,
0.001134261,
0.0034668252,
0.0006007496,
-0.0534374602,
0.0140823917,
-0.000828954,
0.0226535443,
-0.0226314254,
-0.0192340575,
-0.0450539701,
-0.0028128482,
-0.0256414898,
-0.0137483012,
-0.0621820651,
-0.0174841974,
0.0128001384,
0.0319315046,
-0.0518632829,
-0.0199193247,
0.1049517691,
-0.0081583979,
0.0119302133,
0.0018858339,
0.0207408424,
0.0063385018,
0.0492322482,
0.0224172585,
0.0185637474,
0.0106003331,
-0.0098475115,
-0.0589578189,
0.0173141658,
0.0541556142,
-0.0330246985,
0.0567341894,
-0.0383401401,
0.0329729505,
0.0292594023,
-0.0072228136,
-0.0612300001,
0.0072980421,
-0.0169156212,
0.0189022142,
0.0283954758,
-0.0203103032,
0.0040060403,
-0.0087961266,
0.0414804183,
-0.0119743533,
0.02170996,
-0.0381429717,
0.0121968025,
0.0416940525,
0.0367358029,
-0.0031753941,
0.0213323701,
-0.0352119952,
0.0208912827,
0.0095601445,
0.0545915663,
-0.0180409029,
-0.0034102316,
0.0033666792,
0.0219794773,
-0.0474421494,
-0.0166061241,
0.0059179501,
-0.0188081972,
-0.0322012529,
-0.0077697625,
0.1243609637,
0.0373069681,
-0.0303391032,
0.0020926858,
-0.0173029155,
0.0588581488,
0.0428397432,
0.0073142266,
-0.0566661954,
-0.0252320319,
0.0226107016,
0.0472394489,
0.0394920409,
-0.0684354007,
0.0101106288,
-0.1280819327,
-0.0001983291,
-0.0065982034,
-0.0408668406,
-0.0506901853,
-0.0852018744,
0.0061607403,
-0.0315524563,
0.0162175633,
0.0162565485,
0.0207831264,
0.0266594458,
0.0028237628,
-0.0422794633,
-0.1122454926,
0.0308385063,
-0.0496090278,
0.1093803868,
0.0472149439,
0.006574925,
-0.006697685,
-0.0207342152,
-0.0035085981,
-0.0149603244,
-0.0331791416,
0.0196509529,
0.0923142582,
-0.0395589732,
0.0005499191,
0.0034340154,
0.013877891,
-0.0464443751,
-0.0237470735,
-0.0325607248,
0.0714394748,
0.0029502558,
0.0164411478,
-0.011078693,
-0.058333762,
0.0148470309,
0.0859993398,
0.0213400312,
-0.0126175908,
-0.0005299873,
-0.038122084,
0.0053246263,
-0.0414263867,
-0.0175063405,
0.0493603051,
-0.0073601808,
0.0027192112,
-0.079653576,
-0.0431150608,
0.0588601865,
0.0110593578,
0.0134084458,
0.0114369635,
0.0180104747,
0.014982203,
-0.0431081466,
0.026266627,
-0.0151092736,
0.026299255,
-0.0150903137,
-0.0070546167,
-0.0029073819,
0.0076325103,
-0.0302926097,
0.0138277924,
-0.0167605616,
-0.0669626594,
0.0116790291,
0.0617392436,
0.0278037488,
0.069243297,
-0.0362124257,
-0.0176157411,
0.0441218913,
0.0567344949,
-0.0311494954,
-0.0431283638,
0.0022748874,
0.0199662708,
0.0094622681,
0.0463862494,
-0.0951473489,
-0.0454700366,
-0.020218024,
0.0572672002,
-0.0022303432,
-0.0050972984,
0.0158271771,
0.0374539793,
0.0287845377,
-0.0411829352,
0.0311140176,
-0.0705485567,
-0.0070788912,
-0.0061656083,
-0.0245317742,
-0.0331778042,
0.0098992148,
0.0255039744,
-0.0297417622,
-0.0079182675,
0.0090873903,
0.0049100639,
0.0215805508,
-0.0047693425,
-0.0371440127,
0.0698788613,
0.0126479976,
0.0459913611,
-0.0162798669,
0.0028738186,
-0.0166292749,
-0.0208211318,
-0.00375942,
-0.0293809976,
-0.0147726862,
0.0430450849,
-0.0299983807,
0.0002604192,
0.0120804235,
-0.0463942178,
-0.0465328805,
-0.0319121666,
0.0230592731,
0.0714609623,
0.0085285669,
0.068120487,
-0.0404384993,
-0.015099097,
-0.0055352841,
0.0007495488,
-0.0079746014,
0.0004172834,
0.0517051667,
0.0365076698,
-0.011786365,
0.0067562587,
0.0871134102,
-0.0115468586,
0.0597627722,
-0.0531975999,
-0.0369686186,
-0.046465192,
-0.0295657124,
-0.0172188226,
0.0524579734,
-0.031837903,
-0.0076637948,
-0.0342099927,
-0.1058159322,
-0.0124318823,
0.0510811433,
-0.0029214886,
0.0370292328,
0.0452114008,
0.0429849513,
0.0125487,
0.0385904722,
-0.01898266,
-0.0337809883,
-0.0388902724,
-0.0082697794,
0.0038355489,
-5.895227596e-33,
-0.0345344357,
-0.0014596363,
-0.006059383,
0.0235047434,
-0.0174383298,
0.0103387684,
-0.017064726,
-0.0039802068,
-0.0001480555,
0.0110158874,
0.0100289369,
0.0320555642,
-0.003523476,
0.0108246207,
0.0165603366,
-0.008723353,
0.0120514771,
0.0158091933,
-0.0200165119,
-0.0062432713,
0.0272824112,
0.0329149812,
0.0589626171,
-0.0243521538,
0.062102478,
0.0139757674,
-0.0062361509,
0.0281170588,
0.0084348945,
0.0382646732,
-0.0059578712,
0.0437792055,
0.0112357363,
-0.0482326373,
-0.004909311,
-0.029190857,
-0.0937539861,
-0.0486116596,
0.0043443451,
-0.0002557487,
-0.0472547933,
0.010465025,
0.0631313324,
0.008770843,
0.0488378517,
0.0007123962,
0.0567523725,
-0.0068368232,
-0.0262884572,
-0.002444362,
-0.0199363679,
0.0284378994,
-0.0143302893,
-0.0229974538,
-0.002671107,
0.012397239,
0.0338334031,
-0.0130561059,
-0.0828837827,
0.0166490823,
-0.0238143038,
0.0210930295,
0.0594008975,
0.0360814556,
-0.0050063687,
0.0958013833,
-0.0440648906,
0.0080155199,
-0.0086804703,
-0.0142619442,
0.0318715833,
0.0691725463,
0.0296696834,
0.0449017137,
0.0195111725,
-0.0222443268,
-0.0671515316,
0.0598165877,
0.0089507783,
0.0418783091,
-0.0119282082,
0.0179936308,
-0.0312727094,
-0.0323551409,
-0.0761770159,
-0.0346775055,
-0.030215567,
-0.0343181044,
0.0054421141,
-0.0097742435,
-0.0167802256,
-0.0275423229,
-0.0204257425,
-0.0350197256,
-0.0013675118,
0.0447570235,
-0.0217584986,
0.0102516683,
-0.000074642,
0.0241990965,
-0.0474419892,
-0.0289967172,
0.019844301,
0.0143382913,
0.0174201839,
0.0040913313,
0.0670000836,
0.0339005701,
-0.0409678705,
0.007177873,
-0.0408513509,
-0.0224895757,
-0.031717319,
-0.0444751382,
0.039846912,
0.0185565371,
-0.0224090125,
-0.0121873962,
0.0254703965,
0.0076644146,
0.0215351805,
-0.0270061251,
0.0034603898,
-0.0112488233,
-0.0057424787,
-0.0171825793,
-0.0079475613,
0.0085396776,
0.0237191338,
-0.0285922326,
-0.0006000191,
-0.017984841,
2.613e-7,
0.0672070682,
0.0573931038,
0.0069703702,
0.0257521011,
0.020615967,
0.0197483953,
-0.0398281664,
0.0292302165,
0.0065900814,
-0.0448294245,
0.0201460179,
0.0211794637,
0.0138625661,
0.0730660334,
-0.075741224,
-0.0380784199,
-0.0374257676,
0.0151814846,
-0.0169995483,
-0.001881581,
0.0483675525,
0.054103516,
0.0448771417,
-0.0259712171,
-0.0217813272,
-0.0695978552,
0.059441451,
-0.0402654596,
-0.0086102616,
-0.0035693492,
0.0532217175,
0.0752880722,
0.0262439679,
0.0639937744,
-0.0214058924,
0.0080693569,
0.0229533948,
-0.0048593348,
-0.0027425869,
-0.0329480283,
-0.0342773348,
-0.014074333,
0.0320959799,
-0.0669685677,
0.0673337132,
-0.0476461947,
-0.0074982387,
0.0268720686,
-0.0356564447,
-0.0477793179,
0.0568927303,
-0.0141423279,
-0.0390691124,
0.0184812378,
0.0059989267,
0.0161332898,
-0.0005853442,
-0.069947049,
-0.0168576427,
0.0283210315,
-0.0302971415,
-0.0551358424,
0.0007004855,
-0.0353994109,
0.0102199288,
-0.0759184211,
0.0254771356,
2.050283471e-34,
0.0379353389,
-0.0135727413,
-0.0050043296,
0.0174198337,
0.0537281334,
-0.0287482794,
-0.0347086452,
-0.0211206134,
-0.0086761303,
-0.0664647222,
-0.0126284752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13458v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13458v1 | ARTIST: ARTificial Intelligence for Simplified Text | 2023-08-25T16:06:06 | 2023-08-25T16:06:06 | Lorenzo Corti, Jie Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Complex text is a major barrier for many citizens when accessing public
information and knowledge. While often done manually, Text Simplification is a
key Natural Language Processing task that aims for reducing the linguistic
complexity of a text while preserving the original meaning. Recent advances in
Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) have enabled automatic text
simplification both on the lexical and syntactical levels. However, as
applications often focus on English, little is understood about the
effectiveness of Generative AI techniques on low-resource languages such as
Dutch. For this reason, we carry out empirical studies to understand the
benefits and limitations of applying generative technologies for text
simplification and provide the following outcomes: 1) the design and
implementation for a configurable text simplification pipeline that
orchestrates state-of-the-art generative text simplification models, domain and
reader adaptation, and visualisation modules; 2) insights and lessons learned,
showing the strengths of automatic text simplification while exposing the
challenges in handling cultural and commonsense knowledge. These outcomes
represent a first step in the exploration of Dutch text simplification and shed
light on future endeavours both for research and practice. | [
0.0111956177,
0.0033352668,
-0.0442399159,
0.0244682375,
-0.0743798241,
0.0032745362,
-0.0060511995,
0.014575569,
0.035661269,
0.013102944,
0.0488918163,
0.0361455195,
0.0392119177,
-0.0109714149,
0.0337734558,
-0.1081663594,
0.0430441648,
0.0106807789,
0.0082297008,
-0.0066557741,
0.0395398475,
0.0195815321,
0.0007537123,
0.0446913019,
0.0040243533,
-0.0069959308,
0.0242009182,
0.014377946,
0.0186568405,
0.023450451,
-0.0173502546,
0.0659515858,
-0.0356423706,
0.0328294933,
0.0000018077,
-0.0250950493,
-0.0014954424,
-0.0051715304,
0.0216754917,
0.0621353872,
0.0996217281,
-0.0280897897,
-0.0524596423,
0.0067578717,
-0.0304577928,
-0.0297040865,
0.0544091389,
0.0088745514,
0.0263534691,
0.0383787528,
-0.0350342952,
-0.0479201302,
-0.0340881236,
-0.0173573531,
-0.0045349705,
-0.0198961645,
0.0013042355,
-0.0043116966,
-0.0031884804,
-0.0069604246,
-0.0449970029,
0.0639082193,
0.0038130987,
-0.0554424748,
-0.0165204536,
0.0074753044,
-0.0258505084,
-0.0169075038,
0.0293619242,
0.0429508649,
-0.0074159214,
-0.0390228592,
0.0231027063,
-0.021274114,
0.0296157543,
0.0336256027,
-0.058511015,
-0.0281071104,
-0.0112176398,
0.0355469845,
-0.0025243852,
-0.0371188112,
-0.0125467321,
0.0388098471,
-0.0047409786,
0.0162446015,
0.0326039381,
-0.0099562751,
0.0007768156,
0.0002893788,
0.015352766,
-0.0685410425,
0.0401403904,
0.0228778906,
0.038703341,
0.0148400804,
-0.0438508354,
-0.0919390246,
0.0150135495,
-0.0118568167,
0.0388056599,
0.0290687196,
-0.032889992,
0.019197436,
-0.0244411305,
0.0336698778,
0.0033130222,
-0.0026814875,
-0.0201380197,
-0.0183524545,
-0.0189404804,
0.0115191508,
-0.0564072654,
0.0165005904,
-0.0605326146,
-0.0052744616,
-0.0352479517,
-0.0150011228,
0.0332016721,
-0.0202882439,
0.0208542217,
0.0095813675,
-0.0276487991,
-0.0429037064,
-0.0066772094,
0.050260298,
-0.0597811826,
0.0055423067,
-0.0254985541,
-0.0369998403,
0.0169197805,
0.0350243598,
0.049407158,
0.0075356974,
-0.027641084,
0.0128896851,
-0.0475511886,
0.0264782812,
-0.0508948565,
-0.0110311639,
-0.0032574695,
-0.0152364066,
-0.0110862125,
-0.0781828091,
0.0149592888,
-0.0077701705,
-0.0042726188,
-0.0710029826,
0.0002887821,
0.0155763198,
-0.0437142923,
0.0483268015,
-0.0638328493,
0.0211603995,
0.0131347813,
-0.0083424468,
0.0147508327,
0.0141016524,
0.0270203631,
-0.002113397,
0.0696721375,
-0.0296122581,
0.046060428,
0.0468550958,
-0.002154364,
-0.0275377985,
0.02431041,
-0.0573383421,
-0.0926018879,
-0.0053353081,
0.0702329576,
0.0734301209,
-0.0154632498,
-0.0129067376,
0.0447128266,
0.0501493104,
0.0196029898,
0.0525140613,
0.0663120821,
0.0606172495,
0.0514344946,
0.0504275486,
0.0227468051,
-0.0050232303,
-0.0240806602,
0.0371797234,
-0.013146515,
0.0478531681,
0.0052461112,
-0.0537256673,
0.034419585,
-0.0067122527,
0.072816439,
-0.0183528624,
0.0320397466,
0.059119083,
-0.0430780686,
-0.010469025,
0.0163729731,
-0.0633161962,
0.0141971698,
-0.0257487614,
-0.0286746752,
0.084764488,
0.0477538668,
0.0046710335,
-0.0007029661,
0.0225252677,
-0.0142375911,
0.0367840268,
0.0473989435,
-0.0240930524,
0.0041698646,
-0.06795647,
-0.0017447895,
0.0195752624,
0.0025668186,
0.0234767906,
0.0253832284,
-0.0035449425,
0.0330568664,
-0.0462896451,
-0.0181918684,
0.0280652177,
0.0014574156,
-0.0012788018,
0.0265345108,
0.0215263292,
-0.0152816493,
0.0481969751,
-0.008681491,
0.0137831876,
-0.0137957316,
-0.0328727476,
0.0140326833,
0.0311680008,
-0.0008644707,
-0.0484666973,
0.0115117664,
-0.0993499383,
-0.001119772,
0.052443821,
-0.0362783633,
-0.0287252087,
0.0077164187,
-0.0856881365,
0.0055350196,
-0.033757776,
0.0234129839,
-0.0061004576,
0.0146306716,
-0.0302496571,
0.0549470372,
0.0153344441,
0.010067232,
0.0157441068,
-0.0096777109,
0.0290880948,
0.0108711924,
0.042853225,
-0.0567033999,
-0.0275520962,
-0.0068306983,
0.0384398289,
0.0163747072,
-0.0057054069,
0.0254084934,
-0.0968142003,
-0.0366209298,
0.0024228701,
0.0165841412,
0.0349879563,
0.0440535136,
-0.014640525,
-0.025326753,
-0.0228195544,
0.0307928268,
0.0360586755,
-0.0077640079,
0.0648528859,
-0.0320665799,
-0.0434981324,
-0.0437149405,
-0.0070790974,
0.0132769337,
0.0270290896,
0.0364961065,
-0.081860289,
-0.0249366518,
0.0262361187,
-0.0171405263,
-0.016329892,
0.0279520899,
-0.0321502984,
-0.0435236655,
0.0108747929,
0.0842565149,
0.042338267,
0.0356542133,
-0.0026524195,
0.0021046507,
-0.0042130016,
-0.0339875743,
0.0053071496,
-0.0391279608,
0.0142417103,
-0.0167160816,
-0.0604059994,
0.0531462505,
0.0204741172,
0.0366410613,
0.0177593883,
-0.0243264046,
0.0163394157,
-0.0218312945,
-0.0358375572,
-0.0353050902,
-0.0062703355,
-0.015730869,
0.0533868298,
-0.0086921975,
-0.025424907,
0.0454084538,
0.0269466992,
0.0102341054,
-0.0592191517,
0.0006801175,
-0.037938118,
0.0448163226,
-0.0007022299,
0.0524438396,
0.0371166803,
-0.0329794027,
-0.0067731924,
0.0044113998,
0.0240790211,
-0.0086295689,
0.0310529321,
-0.0807044357,
-0.0004609722,
-0.0212860722,
-0.0619708337,
-0.0090150945,
-0.0400760025,
0.0138583137,
-0.0205544997,
0.083838284,
-0.0155583005,
-0.012250497,
-0.0155302351,
0.0361766741,
0.0694319159,
0.0173064582,
-0.0077274018,
-0.0113260392,
0.0683642179,
0.000340275,
-0.0152920997,
0.0057223202,
0.0185178686,
-0.0313896015,
0.0197911933,
-0.0168221649,
-0.0157680698,
0.0337177999,
-0.0020374525,
-0.0033661549,
-0.0565373488,
-0.0444524735,
0.0019085591,
0.0193439424,
-0.0503341369,
0.0195580665,
0.0709438175,
0.029204281,
-0.0021360666,
0.0228947587,
-0.0287618395,
0.0167030897,
-0.0219724253,
0.0377888046,
-0.1105645075,
0.0112336101,
0.0123414993,
0.0008018769,
-0.0085998671,
-0.0195602756,
-0.0189477,
-0.0897231847,
0.0649270564,
0.0113350851,
-0.0503054596,
-0.0311629474,
-0.0164583419,
-0.0078885211,
0.0025949501,
-0.0196657982,
-0.0123700378,
-0.0092945592,
0.0195882916,
-0.0391491801,
-0.0756109506,
-0.0652567148,
-0.0443352312,
-0.0012497631,
0.0358854383,
0.0371563174,
0.0606743023,
0.0067717182,
-0.0282858033,
0.0160733648,
-0.0215121191,
0.0240138769,
-0.0378996432,
0.0567017309,
0.0795431733,
-0.0023671405,
-0.065409489,
0.0371914059,
0.027773248,
-0.0305034053,
0.0407182761,
0.0296817571,
0.0264770444,
-0.045513235,
0.0034501988,
0.0057606786,
0.0030842274,
0.0475742146,
0.0621992797,
0.0106297508,
-0.0432892367,
-0.0731802061,
0.0058688996,
-0.1149743944,
-0.0805357769,
-0.0022368971,
-0.0301262438,
-0.0618958957,
-0.0842301026,
-0.0418068282,
0.0109124398,
0.0021922782,
0.0438801199,
-0.0156430751,
0.027074188,
0.0126748029,
-0.0576013811,
-0.0562412031,
-0.0337616429,
-0.0009103842,
-0.0231368933,
-0.0203265604,
-0.003521194,
0.0061219321,
-0.0020519765,
0.0052813506,
-0.036516238,
-0.0519634001,
0.0463767983,
0.0195787083,
0.0206440426,
0.0371970162,
-0.0069789463,
-0.0558700711,
0.013089207,
0.051314164,
-0.0410471633,
0.0333985873,
-0.0022242267,
-0.0107500572,
0.0105575267,
0.0396846607,
0.0011071833,
0.0672249794,
-0.015966814,
0.0146265943,
-0.0142765883,
0.0083430856,
-0.0003623781,
0.05311241,
-0.0472990535,
-0.0333825946,
0.0128341541,
-0.0207990874,
-0.037153855,
-0.0564855449,
0.0174294505,
-0.003347734,
0.0188956112,
0.0349094085,
0.0195761528,
-0.0165010542,
0.0693051293,
-0.0014657666,
-0.0257766489,
-0.0044788038,
0.0192198474,
0.0174623262,
0.020633895,
0.0080318544,
-0.0157718472,
0.0148157571,
0.0568048395,
-0.02941541,
0.0152371703,
-0.0144601865,
0.0116412034,
-0.0128756855,
0.0030263716,
-0.0540640578,
0.004621048,
-0.021533126,
-0.0192670692,
0.0069536758,
0.0746839419,
0.0565235987,
0.0179494116,
0.0954503492,
-0.0353021473,
-0.0262827091,
-0.0016426705,
0.0174568128,
0.0216176007,
-0.0303293653,
-0.0443604514,
-0.0128721613,
-0.0253169723,
-0.0212785378,
0.0778232142,
-0.0404666811,
0.0359764509,
0.0046377326,
-0.031532418,
-0.0504969917,
-0.0528834201,
-0.017445907,
0.0063786702,
0.0066860644,
-0.0234833937,
-0.0616816394,
-0.0446678139,
-0.034688592,
0.0302931201,
0.0264036842,
-0.0313842893,
0.0188250281,
0.0379134491,
0.0073254826,
-0.039361652,
-0.0290479995,
0.0378603227,
-0.0577716045,
-0.0579990931,
-0.0245928653,
-5.647830116e-33,
-0.0234213527,
-0.0050786855,
-0.0226948038,
-0.0170699302,
-0.025382217,
-0.0225256886,
-0.0869004652,
-0.0213232152,
-0.0068226098,
0.0534224994,
-0.0183353573,
-0.0058947415,
0.039054554,
0.0028184669,
0.0053706984,
0.0547768362,
0.0574438684,
0.0027884997,
-0.0082470374,
0.0163801964,
-0.0119462246,
0.0028687122,
0.0110487957,
-0.0776088461,
0.0044869459,
0.0082503688,
-0.0426436178,
-0.0082557928,
0.0701925009,
0.0222390294,
-0.0080175288,
0.0232697949,
0.01874833,
-0.0197514296,
-0.0411803164,
0.0583386756,
-0.118252784,
-0.0402307957,
0.0585032292,
0.0156149212,
-0.0456802398,
-0.0691044182,
0.0572866872,
-0.0342049114,
-0.0350059718,
0.0155997388,
0.0487662666,
-0.040176779,
0.0070603234,
-0.0713526011,
-0.0884433538,
0.032267876,
-0.0427920595,
0.0229862202,
0.0102309519,
0.0102270925,
-0.0122934943,
-0.0513245575,
-0.0182767138,
0.0537262261,
0.0381338373,
0.0276540443,
0.0559306219,
-0.0620958805,
0.0028217859,
-0.0008644804,
0.0152085405,
0.0346319303,
-0.0465676785,
0.0445117801,
0.0323140658,
0.0118170315,
0.0656692386,
0.0748969987,
0.0381303169,
-0.0363725014,
-0.0392232947,
0.0643712282,
-0.00525029,
-0.0098093404,
-0.0227788109,
0.0199788865,
-0.0245368779,
-0.0296444427,
0.0156621076,
0.003741198,
0.0149154793,
-0.0513554551,
0.005285854,
-0.0176187437,
-0.0296687055,
0.0055063842,
-0.0033049881,
-0.0370811857,
-0.0281330422,
0.0100428937,
0.0096184751,
0.0517711341,
-0.0139279198,
-0.0170180239,
-0.0328314826,
0.0193264224,
0.0203107074,
0.0669823512,
0.009978598,
0.0127315875,
0.0324722342,
-0.0107532367,
-0.0750327334,
0.022712443,
0.0184338801,
0.0170332473,
0.025917938,
-0.0312729888,
0.0285195652,
0.0139043424,
0.0058719446,
-0.0510077477,
0.0606416427,
-0.039411094,
-0.0139125129,
0.0074625998,
0.0355861261,
0.0247639641,
-0.0257241949,
0.0262482949,
-0.0321645997,
0.0044663306,
0.0366111845,
-0.0068209013,
-0.0306483693,
-0.013557354,
2.383e-7,
0.0877130255,
0.045363225,
0.0667461082,
0.0062339753,
-0.0143198678,
-0.0110176969,
0.061941158,
-0.0257294979,
-0.0569955632,
0.0395535491,
0.0623483546,
-0.002122171,
0.0302113332,
0.0103825508,
-0.0753100067,
0.0333093554,
0.0072752517,
-0.0386475325,
-0.0450025126,
0.005229339,
0.0449050516,
0.0318845958,
0.0047390009,
-0.0219824258,
-0.008140455,
-0.0283324476,
-0.002577632,
-0.0099246753,
0.0179475453,
0.0313200094,
0.0217488222,
-0.0187651515,
0.0011126854,
-0.0059586633,
-0.0045027891,
-0.0273458846,
0.000866033,
0.0541248508,
-0.0083838226,
0.0882978737,
0.0080893701,
-0.0701752007,
0.0051593217,
-0.0437923595,
0.0570124835,
-0.0161505248,
0.0058398424,
0.0068030907,
-0.0142025864,
0.0237158854,
-0.0005828026,
-0.0040143486,
-0.0628527403,
0.0263183638,
0.0252813939,
-0.0022681865,
-0.00292927,
-0.0658651516,
-0.0365100428,
-0.0014391289,
0.0142664965,
0.0208048094,
-0.0131171923,
0.0473327935,
-0.0074002468,
-0.0353482552,
0.0186548792,
2.075853688e-34,
0.0358034112,
0.0020341233,
-0.0057694097,
-0.0153769944,
0.040010009,
-0.0098575493,
-0.0054754745,
0.0236664359,
-0.0061619617,
-0.0285940077,
-0.0221724715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13449v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13449v1 | The Poison of Alignment | 2023-08-25T15:51:15 | 2023-08-25T15:51:15 | Aibek Bekbayev, Sungbae Chun, Yerzat Dulat, James Yamazaki | cs.CL | cs.CL | From the perspective of content safety issues, alignment has shown to limit
large language models' (LLMs) harmful content generation. This intentional
method of reinforcing models to not respond to certain user inputs seem to be
present in many modern open-source instruction tuning datasets such as
OpenAssistant or Guanaco. We introduce a novel insight to an instruction-tuned
model's performance affected by the presence of alignment in supervised
fine-tuning dataset. To be specific, we noticed that alignment acts as if it is
poisoning the instruction dataset. Experimentally, we demonstrate that aligned
answers significantly worsen the performance of the resulting fine-tuned
model's on various reasoning benchmarks such as Big Bench (BBH), Massive
Multitask Language Understanding (MMLU), Human Eval, and Discrete Reasoning
Over Paragraphs (DROP), performing worse than the counterpart tuned without
alignment by 4-33%. | [
0.0101570003,
0.0608976185,
-0.0222955588,
0.0342836045,
-0.0070531396,
0.0240612496,
0.0201333649,
-0.0195059069,
-0.0020377059,
-0.0292458497,
-0.0425147451,
-0.011323628,
0.0052379998,
-0.0072464347,
0.0307620652,
0.0082112812,
0.0844525769,
-0.0481270589,
0.0056649703,
0.0064737485,
0.0161119495,
0.0166441146,
0.0046673566,
0.0100529222,
0.0064609917,
-0.0502560735,
-0.0251571629,
0.0225737672,
0.0325834379,
0.0075665838,
0.0231922809,
0.0577928834,
-0.0163482651,
0.0679234937,
0.0000020294,
-0.0306379013,
-0.0238579363,
0.0023969125,
-0.0480265133,
0.0419458412,
-0.0102596283,
0.0091358973,
-0.0132792294,
0.0260530505,
-0.0444236323,
0.0190039463,
0.053727679,
0.0136810718,
0.0754659474,
0.1001279429,
0.0090633593,
-0.0087463036,
0.0343112014,
-0.0133478744,
0.005622976,
-0.0338017531,
0.0201005731,
0.0050706305,
-0.0148765417,
0.0183211714,
-0.0227244906,
0.0106786015,
0.0411260873,
-0.0125094568,
-0.0037092511,
0.0138259558,
-0.0564553887,
-0.0331284627,
0.0109121772,
0.0758220404,
-0.0044773635,
-0.0194319375,
-0.0039056998,
-0.0265059099,
0.0333245695,
-0.0016507821,
-0.0098407958,
0.0365375429,
-0.0109856874,
0.0077252733,
0.0480021909,
-0.0501063094,
0.0345214047,
0.0121425046,
0.0221222043,
0.0765783414,
0.0058821365,
-0.0505333468,
-0.0056044487,
-0.0002347964,
-0.0398729518,
-0.0704824477,
-0.0339023955,
0.0108257374,
-0.0643820688,
0.0325805768,
-0.0945878923,
-0.0311621521,
0.0357561968,
-0.0243252628,
0.0539044477,
0.0522479974,
0.0233978778,
0.0198844932,
-0.0179520007,
0.0600661263,
-0.0355347842,
0.0783994943,
-0.0295372047,
0.0514364913,
-0.0025275063,
-0.0357812345,
0.005997411,
0.0250094999,
-0.0378141254,
0.0168918204,
-0.0224491507,
0.0636022463,
-0.0289388411,
0.0507128946,
-0.0006979064,
0.0103347981,
-0.0312570184,
-0.0090888208,
-0.0209060721,
0.0185014922,
-0.0304279756,
0.0245106202,
0.032619264,
-0.0640060082,
-0.0374010317,
0.0039020951,
-0.0419910252,
-0.0324562006,
0.0045055575,
0.0605801567,
-0.0192608386,
0.0154319461,
0.0032381983,
-0.0696880892,
-0.0329947099,
-0.0671424344,
-0.0045452798,
-0.060898006,
0.034490753,
0.0179912541,
-0.0414074808,
-0.0804909244,
0.0081518963,
0.0351314694,
-0.0565038882,
0.0466765761,
-0.0112112481,
0.0112934327,
-0.0026146236,
0.020953333,
0.0071110646,
0.0706359595,
0.0133436164,
0.015395551,
0.0347977988,
-0.0504906625,
-0.0225341599,
0.0329595469,
0.02896576,
0.016233284,
0.0240262598,
0.0302064531,
0.0484447367,
0.0289050248,
0.0111540752,
0.0435258485,
-0.0048841005,
-0.0279839858,
0.0667072237,
-0.0018550925,
-0.0127058243,
0.0105093727,
-0.0117406305,
-0.0004276225,
-0.0081926454,
0.0577311926,
-0.0865914151,
0.0092220018,
-0.0446796045,
0.0194605682,
0.0542465262,
0.052119866,
-0.0167633276,
-0.0463293865,
-0.011018943,
0.0115801562,
0.0035370362,
0.0235501137,
0.0098081939,
-0.0077783922,
-0.0483924113,
0.0289484523,
0.0559038818,
-0.0273626335,
-0.0081181722,
-0.0423867181,
0.0489855446,
0.035676688,
0.0663236231,
-0.008346634,
-0.0638521984,
-0.0197799671,
0.0355250984,
0.0205780827,
0.0555518121,
-0.007152162,
0.0010166549,
-0.0385332331,
-0.0377653576,
-0.0569880232,
-0.0006033423,
-0.0184680987,
0.0444852188,
-0.0122746862,
0.0071946988,
0.0182027481,
-0.0497676395,
0.0353797525,
-0.0208032224,
-0.0500943549,
-0.0399121791,
0.025532553,
0.0090212924,
-0.0145938862,
-0.0224765521,
0.0090760039,
0.0297352802,
0.0070752921,
0.020820789,
-0.0414750241,
-0.049373921,
0.0118478676,
0.0451047458,
-0.0373540185,
-0.0472839698,
0.0144699505,
-0.0502263568,
-0.0226193145,
-0.0005007233,
-0.0168374088,
-0.0153771276,
0.011882796,
0.0426073931,
-0.0263156611,
-0.0018110416,
-0.0496700555,
0.0684098452,
0.0057096058,
0.0183812082,
0.0079170633,
-0.0002647123,
0.0111532426,
-0.028890878,
0.0012453997,
-0.0061045568,
-0.0091116438,
0.0115346713,
0.0231865123,
0.01221566,
-0.0543888174,
-0.0433413871,
-0.0509819761,
0.0355037116,
-0.018020615,
0.0420642681,
0.0602462888,
-0.006377975,
-0.0170266386,
0.0145589672,
-0.0382087007,
-0.02257731,
0.0101022897,
0.0319934264,
0.0293281414,
-0.0021218148,
-0.0106665241,
-0.0219302718,
-0.0223084819,
-0.0310943648,
0.0059089349,
0.0060144137,
0.0529948622,
-0.0726261511,
0.0363193899,
-0.0357796848,
0.0097393189,
-0.0019986844,
-0.0524673983,
0.0222787466,
0.0266714077,
0.0085114799,
0.1170371473,
-0.0004238149,
0.0236876123,
0.0496191941,
0.0259862971,
-0.042604249,
0.015618775,
-0.0050108945,
-0.0493629947,
-0.0349520631,
-0.0420688055,
-0.0207160395,
0.0812795013,
0.0054756957,
-0.015222922,
-0.0615468584,
0.0185602978,
-0.0202930421,
-0.0374082923,
-0.0080099655,
-0.0417945795,
-0.0222777165,
0.0177586135,
-0.0507398695,
-0.0839466751,
0.086050801,
0.0022194944,
0.0269661546,
-0.0224314854,
0.0210190937,
-0.0198937133,
0.0169669595,
-0.005025812,
0.0186014324,
0.0013488312,
-0.0051760031,
-0.1007181481,
-0.0013668061,
0.0521961339,
-0.0487168655,
0.0414295942,
-0.0428938307,
-0.0191421304,
-0.0459166691,
-0.0704814419,
-0.0529339425,
-0.0665179268,
0.0298662838,
-0.0217022523,
0.0450708307,
-0.0114259478,
-0.0223452244,
-0.0385284908,
0.0313586593,
-0.0380704701,
-0.0615643002,
0.0106628574,
-0.0312259048,
0.005506014,
0.0964182466,
-0.0097145494,
0.0219975505,
-0.0795395747,
0.0360692441,
0.087370351,
0.0118069248,
0.0041818293,
0.0132483719,
-0.0040712436,
0.0246766694,
-0.001497615,
-0.0132614272,
0.0380416326,
0.088007994,
-0.0382349864,
-0.0245152824,
0.0823028311,
0.018597139,
0.0129349716,
-0.0038125359,
-0.0140914628,
0.073150754,
0.019505877,
0.0338159762,
-0.0860594288,
-0.0271172728,
0.0151440427,
0.0406436697,
0.001513525,
-0.0255157799,
0.0076674279,
-0.1095933765,
0.0072018686,
0.0262263846,
-0.0411157683,
-0.0335816555,
-0.0166655835,
-0.0037786392,
-0.0070460108,
0.0544938855,
0.0213139411,
-0.014152457,
-0.0021106291,
0.0316106789,
0.0311436336,
-0.0193184707,
0.0193862282,
-0.0116418675,
0.0600764751,
0.0574234538,
-0.0065427185,
0.0117950104,
-0.0725069419,
0.0366771705,
-0.003830296,
0.0019258976,
0.0103401793,
0.0482480004,
-0.0075635519,
-0.0035131001,
-0.0145650543,
0.043350812,
-0.0148013514,
-0.0013052858,
0.0067799189,
0.0679367185,
0.0034237208,
0.0014205005,
-0.0226347744,
-0.0191374272,
0.0008425882,
0.0613614209,
0.0135456165,
-0.0479277186,
-0.0408679582,
-0.0412098058,
-0.004397939,
-0.0480859615,
0.001200097,
0.0435800664,
-0.0125637371,
-0.0103692329,
-0.0266735591,
-0.0335361809,
0.0250807703,
0.0082646701,
0.0326084457,
-0.0251053441,
-0.016689105,
-0.0147826765,
-0.0151517075,
0.0516081862,
-0.0260810237,
0.0161354244,
-0.0758043006,
-0.0143963378,
-0.0416829959,
-0.0162698515,
0.0074094008,
0.0184745118,
-0.1051773801,
-0.0957883745,
0.0184428431,
0.0566868335,
0.0217391569,
0.0544396602,
0.0018298291,
-0.0376958959,
0.0149944117,
0.0243112277,
-0.0616964176,
0.030509958,
0.0084030768,
-0.0560524352,
0.0170654524,
0.0263338555,
-0.0376596041,
-0.033359129,
0.0589774288,
0.0137738083,
-0.0266421624,
-0.0230750814,
0.0331961624,
0.0362162217,
0.0325203985,
-0.0147372782,
0.0130343847,
-0.0117799705,
0.0373009518,
-0.0196785368,
-0.0270773675,
0.016223168,
-0.0184562635,
0.0297667757,
-0.0517698079,
0.0217016842,
0.0341649167,
0.0051300703,
0.0618681274,
-0.0560611375,
0.0227627829,
0.0000100077,
0.0163119659,
0.0510884374,
0.0219331197,
-0.0281240903,
0.0502025113,
-0.0061480952,
0.0574060343,
-0.0036495137,
0.0687567666,
0.0314321555,
0.0566509925,
0.0058855684,
0.0347066186,
-0.0542572066,
-0.0476763248,
-0.0096620014,
-0.027235752,
-0.0066425153,
-0.0185267664,
0.0324247032,
0.0191753656,
-0.0303309504,
-0.0165299196,
0.0164408404,
0.0008009319,
-0.0410876758,
0.0362206548,
0.0260197651,
-0.0206597503,
-0.0219640005,
0.067641966,
-0.0302997082,
0.0333894417,
-0.0129477344,
-0.0000026005,
-0.0280109514,
-0.0280740857,
0.0193493553,
0.0160462763,
-0.0122199012,
-0.007140385,
-0.036880184,
-0.0749865845,
-0.0578813925,
0.044000715,
0.0133095523,
-0.0011878173,
0.0134788472,
0.0361145884,
-0.0186977629,
-0.0410046466,
-0.0242114328,
0.0081272023,
-0.0324681476,
-0.0186209157,
-0.0204722155,
-6.499882054e-33,
-0.0245842524,
-0.012037525,
0.0059404052,
0.0205832068,
-0.0254357662,
-0.0065698866,
-0.0097471327,
0.0096173398,
-0.0515693277,
-0.0073704324,
-0.0146525539,
0.0357361436,
-0.0070477771,
0.015496308,
0.0111973975,
-0.0610803142,
0.0120194526,
-0.0195333995,
-0.0564478077,
0.0399502739,
0.0494830608,
-0.0268935096,
0.0225795116,
-0.051997941,
0.0293117855,
-0.0081566926,
-0.0094978455,
-0.0041886298,
-0.0847016051,
0.0744702518,
0.0124131199,
0.0212814752,
0.0080528939,
-0.0175600201,
0.0131182186,
0.0232309606,
-0.0364939161,
-0.0326604135,
0.0393627658,
0.0000483874,
-0.0559952594,
-0.0807909146,
0.0568423383,
0.0054571121,
-0.0155245513,
-0.0599754564,
0.0108491266,
-0.0134958792,
-0.025124222,
0.0014746025,
-0.0686045438,
0.0052541802,
-0.0405101441,
-0.0300215799,
-0.0085197957,
0.0158664212,
0.0435770527,
0.0073179239,
-0.0243951771,
0.0048998143,
0.0489775054,
0.0526573546,
0.0908038914,
0.0289992783,
0.0019149928,
0.044162225,
-0.0316288993,
0.0073438007,
-0.024788348,
0.0138955414,
-0.0172985215,
0.0322913453,
0.0128419567,
0.0323684216,
0.0364290029,
-0.0287077781,
-0.0692731142,
0.0199260581,
-0.0383619405,
0.040182393,
0.0167208929,
-0.0059408452,
-0.0629686341,
-0.0065128189,
-0.0349078104,
0.0268056598,
-0.0316503532,
-0.0111775165,
0.0324227139,
-0.0093419375,
-0.0307826493,
-0.0253456943,
-0.0040683085,
-0.0303422865,
0.039066691,
0.030070696,
-0.030565815,
-0.0200986397,
-0.0059178644,
0.014537124,
-0.049498193,
-0.025470186,
0.0040901587,
-0.0345557928,
0.0526408851,
0.0450544097,
0.0644683093,
0.0302944183,
-0.0622620881,
0.007957234,
-0.0538409688,
0.0531560406,
0.0202472452,
-0.0138799883,
0.0592786893,
0.012835796,
-0.0063215797,
0.0341276824,
0.0442753397,
0.0322398245,
-0.0499758087,
-0.0112943035,
0.0014533147,
0.0029742923,
-0.0056660478,
0.0212648641,
-0.0024782266,
0.0193473268,
-0.0021367574,
-0.0783566535,
-0.0154118836,
0.0282449815,
2.746e-7,
0.0405051336,
0.0379006416,
0.0317140184,
0.0430201553,
0.0177385565,
0.0499992631,
-0.0227883104,
0.0254580677,
0.0153631894,
-0.018595567,
0.0056026964,
0.0226112604,
0.0664417371,
0.033665061,
-0.0241674799,
0.0568201132,
-0.0721599683,
0.0376723632,
-0.0727568641,
0.0116127795,
0.0623615459,
0.0792400092,
0.0131904613,
-0.0191593282,
0.0026176153,
0.0040544528,
0.0433491878,
0.0002920313,
0.0082844896,
0.0247815158,
-0.0000861479,
0.0054983827,
-0.0129131284,
0.0278202426,
-0.0157259814,
0.0074115074,
-0.040756043,
0.0549651012,
-0.0095020207,
-0.0148710329,
-0.0245199036,
-0.0778339654,
0.0075524403,
-0.0716254637,
0.0830381438,
-0.007172442,
-0.017172087,
-0.0372150205,
-0.0117996102,
-0.0177140962,
0.0180490687,
-0.0008744041,
0.0139527712,
0.0028279917,
-0.0016932907,
-0.0140273012,
-0.0011173498,
-0.0553128049,
-0.0472433046,
0.0200798009,
-0.0221811924,
-0.0636244789,
-0.0180705413,
0.0473212041,
0.0198581461,
-0.0806138143,
-0.0151777677,
2.716714382e-34,
-0.0248487666,
-0.0491525829,
0.0525875241,
-0.0011916505,
0.0346862376,
-0.0247246157,
-0.0147889256,
0.0059566614,
0.0104829324,
-0.0743522719,
-0.0302595384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12342v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12342v2 | Cultural Alignment in Large Language Models: An Explanatory Analysis Based on Hofstede's Cultural Dimensions | 2023-08-25T14:50:13 | 2024-05-08T14:48:39 | Reem I. Masoud, Ziquan Liu, Martin Ferianc, Philip Treleaven, Miguel Rodrigues | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG | The deployment of large language models (LLMs) raises concerns regarding
their cultural misalignment and potential ramifications on individuals and
societies with diverse cultural backgrounds. While the discourse has focused
mainly on political and social biases, our research proposes a Cultural
Alignment Test (Hoftede's CAT) to quantify cultural alignment using Hofstede's
cultural dimension framework, which offers an explanatory cross-cultural
comparison through the latent variable analysis. We apply our approach to
quantitatively evaluate LLMs, namely Llama 2, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4, against the
cultural dimensions of regions like the United States, China, and Arab
countries, using different prompting styles and exploring the effects of
language-specific fine-tuning on the models' behavioural tendencies and
cultural values. Our results quantify the cultural alignment of LLMs and reveal
the difference between LLMs in explanatory cultural dimensions. Our study
demonstrates that while all LLMs struggle to grasp cultural values, GPT-4 shows
a unique capability to adapt to cultural nuances, particularly in Chinese
settings. However, it faces challenges with American and Arab cultures. The
research also highlights that fine-tuning LLama 2 models with different
languages changes their responses to cultural questions, emphasizing the need
for culturally diverse development in AI for worldwide acceptance and ethical
use. For more details or to contribute to this research, visit our GitHub page
https://github.com/reemim/Hofstedes_CAT/ | [
0.0318108685,
0.0662859678,
-0.0401227735,
0.0106999259,
-0.0455410145,
0.0356537588,
0.0757591128,
-0.0234983154,
0.0213047266,
0.0121634221,
-0.0204464458,
-0.0599797294,
0.0210993383,
0.0408826061,
0.0081928484,
-0.03813494,
0.0288486704,
0.0104144486,
0.0350186639,
-0.0185498465,
0.020811934,
0.0341617279,
0.0297062267,
0.0534403287,
0.0127067398,
-0.0271731354,
0.0105660418,
-0.0264422242,
0.0583781265,
-0.0212924629,
0.0117560271,
0.0226666685,
0.0382367671,
0.023233505,
0.0000020896,
-0.0751438141,
0.0065014753,
-0.0111386925,
0.0317754969,
0.0612362809,
0.0825992152,
0.0082271416,
-0.0439696796,
0.0098642679,
-0.0456458442,
-0.0186412577,
0.0531632341,
0.0306271818,
-0.0108820358,
0.0241279546,
0.0055245608,
-0.0188624244,
-0.0045101987,
0.00434139,
-0.0683116764,
-0.02150934,
0.0300785247,
0.0428653769,
-0.021045858,
0.0215472914,
-0.017045239,
0.0228349958,
0.0189834666,
0.0052169226,
-0.0523502044,
-0.0132962931,
-0.0416290499,
-0.0425628088,
0.0388578959,
0.038379088,
0.0707062483,
-0.0049056234,
-0.0052405172,
-0.0035548504,
-0.0055279019,
0.0025785181,
-0.016806813,
0.0413935445,
0.0086212205,
0.0186272673,
0.0599913038,
-0.0075823176,
-0.0058909412,
0.0214340221,
0.0053662662,
0.0717416108,
-0.0002488999,
-0.0288993493,
-0.0439426489,
-0.0362523161,
0.0092583578,
-0.0386193097,
-0.0142131317,
0.0103172194,
-0.0166779812,
0.0095907953,
0.0204283427,
0.0424126424,
0.0172854587,
-0.0591027327,
0.0180597063,
0.087120764,
-0.0190624744,
-0.0044299942,
0.0414586365,
0.0973841101,
-0.0201486256,
-0.0173033141,
-0.0568160042,
-0.0052621579,
-0.0133260377,
0.006509799,
0.0454820618,
-0.0259580128,
0.0114530763,
0.000962518,
-0.0721406639,
0.0237219147,
-0.0467586406,
0.0498527028,
-0.0400511473,
-0.038557373,
0.0169634558,
0.0114938468,
-0.0180223938,
0.0738490969,
-0.0715382174,
-0.0016314177,
-0.0312823616,
-0.0452721342,
0.0578742698,
0.0153656667,
-0.0314213112,
-0.0227859505,
0.003268867,
0.0212570261,
0.0114358636,
0.0120415548,
-0.0225494727,
0.0339882597,
0.0031309058,
-0.074634105,
0.018060552,
-0.0445215926,
0.0072947922,
0.0252676345,
-0.0168236867,
-0.0548650138,
0.0087024886,
0.010655296,
-0.0111091388,
-0.0060245031,
0.0211524982,
0.063711971,
0.0718124658,
0.0089784842,
-0.0108782724,
0.0727331117,
0.0218069851,
0.0126163941,
0.0510024503,
-0.0543476045,
-0.0132465679,
0.0306376982,
-0.0524724349,
0.0369448178,
-0.0530167632,
0.0074974126,
-0.0154561019,
-0.0007042834,
0.0131282415,
0.0425600819,
0.0155110098,
0.0269216206,
0.0256697182,
0.0726868063,
-0.0042541088,
0.0365547948,
0.0257151425,
0.0081152031,
0.0128507363,
0.0143472636,
-0.0646970496,
0.0041957623,
-0.0194885936,
0.015686024,
-0.0116676223,
0.0754838809,
-0.0351501517,
-0.0188597906,
-0.017906284,
0.0173421893,
0.0613950528,
0.0232890937,
0.0271387249,
-0.0675958842,
0.0263377912,
-0.0367699824,
0.0099450042,
-0.0593573824,
-0.057985846,
-0.0436741263,
0.04452556,
0.0561176203,
-0.0161433127,
-0.0036634023,
-0.0090831229,
0.0047506262,
0.0032279226,
0.0192295145,
0.0615430474,
0.0022334093,
-0.0406347252,
-0.0300519187,
-0.0319836251,
-0.0150337769,
-0.0129457992,
0.0237944443,
0.0336972587,
0.0517518483,
-0.0094318846,
0.0149711268,
-0.0390097462,
-0.0145038292,
-0.0503287576,
0.0149161136,
-0.0741595924,
0.0156827122,
0.040400967,
0.0377628431,
-0.0217234772,
-0.0069742925,
-0.0186867584,
-0.0020149904,
0.0195484329,
0.0262233727,
-0.0352101065,
0.0973883048,
0.04322749,
-0.0184331629,
-0.0015006786,
0.0206696894,
0.0097539034,
-0.0120354854,
0.0438703038,
0.0361361578,
-0.0066193854,
-0.0194110684,
0.0145216845,
-0.0696813539,
0.0235987343,
-0.0214003976,
0.0220667869,
-0.0442165323,
0.0148758683,
-0.0172359403,
-0.0071323342,
0.060421139,
0.0234632622,
-0.0519764014,
0.0462074503,
0.0027777292,
0.006618896,
0.055348631,
0.006894981,
-0.0298340041,
-0.0209717304,
-0.0827225521,
-0.0019824342,
-0.0142807476,
0.0007717925,
0.0152103314,
0.0008584947,
-0.0468852855,
0.030488383,
-0.0912480131,
-0.0126938252,
0.0318996496,
0.0665652007,
0.0164113492,
-0.0530075319,
-0.025210036,
-0.0064646248,
-0.0119375335,
-0.0138691738,
0.002568759,
-0.013322359,
-0.0114345402,
-0.0232800469,
-0.0098770624,
-0.0616791621,
-0.0032672286,
-0.0396080911,
-0.0575425364,
0.0284777582,
0.068342261,
0.0453021154,
0.0355007946,
0.0121700019,
0.0319831334,
0.0481826439,
0.0249426439,
-0.0121896174,
-0.023850549,
0.0251255445,
-0.0183722489,
0.0005680275,
-0.1094057858,
-0.0497203879,
0.0467963107,
-0.0072925743,
0.015676951,
-0.0276851486,
0.0420320556,
-0.0705199912,
-0.0284338016,
0.0210314319,
-0.0295916758,
-0.0055593359,
0.0862407163,
-0.0198983457,
-0.0489290282,
0.0172801781,
0.0048697423,
0.0075357947,
0.0094214082,
-0.0255688094,
-0.0427496396,
0.0365356952,
-0.0147117544,
0.0405570567,
-0.0031274452,
-0.0091623003,
-0.0554351397,
-0.0167693477,
0.01940009,
-0.0492368154,
0.0539913848,
-0.0174046531,
-0.0347305425,
-0.0546009988,
-0.0039155828,
-0.0347981006,
0.0225498043,
-0.0089619355,
0.047681734,
0.0233878084,
-0.0321916901,
-0.001507623,
0.0082784807,
0.082631655,
-0.0034142518,
-0.0039443886,
0.0548478141,
-0.0042488417,
-0.0661774799,
0.0588919334,
0.0260774307,
0.0324304774,
-0.0152135286,
0.0479631424,
-0.0165708605,
0.0066307369,
-0.0255867206,
-0.0156611688,
0.011728744,
0.0573449023,
0.0060473257,
-0.0286689028,
0.0096658822,
0.0718241483,
-0.0240252595,
0.0557838343,
0.0735635906,
-0.0051706787,
-0.0346607529,
0.0084400661,
-0.0558920242,
-0.0109867016,
0.0385075212,
0.0334333032,
-0.0827875882,
0.0656075552,
0.0073671932,
-0.021175649,
-0.0637725294,
-0.0127859134,
-0.0016270342,
-0.0857526511,
0.0274280366,
0.0072633685,
-0.0743938386,
-0.0498864241,
0.0206548907,
0.0048660031,
0.0156343784,
0.0538910143,
-0.0080715846,
-0.0093399333,
-0.0362891257,
-0.0117544439,
-0.055672463,
-0.0532701686,
0.0382606946,
-0.0381364003,
0.0617670156,
0.0536282137,
0.021655906,
-0.011803221,
-0.0615352243,
-0.0175423399,
0.0078661637,
-0.0229361933,
0.0382925458,
-0.0381843634,
-0.0006673482,
-0.0093657514,
-0.0156748723,
-0.0160979722,
-0.0025134333,
0.0002834483,
0.0317612216,
0.0462882407,
-0.0107026389,
-0.0193705838,
-0.0104196025,
0.0050555966,
-0.0274763405,
0.0472985059,
-0.0069297729,
-0.057053972,
0.0096472027,
-0.0245999824,
-0.0443281941,
0.0572294742,
-0.0338432118,
0.0131292082,
-0.0395115949,
-0.0188235845,
-0.0039172885,
-0.0738328248,
-0.0208128467,
-0.0320999846,
0.0351632275,
-0.0045285588,
0.0216738414,
0.0038140889,
-0.0156190386,
0.0098946048,
0.0030212216,
0.016912045,
0.014198862,
-0.019499341,
-0.0093857097,
-0.053810183,
0.0282092392,
-0.0271096062,
-0.0016956115,
-0.0313393287,
0.0479437299,
0.0069458527,
0.0115443841,
-0.0191959366,
0.0445668846,
-0.0087701902,
-0.0075641144,
-0.0244932175,
0.0048157074,
0.0245278478,
0.014083243,
0.0398179591,
0.000532729,
0.0222555231,
-0.0161826815,
0.0252757855,
0.0298745446,
0.0138477841,
-0.0523879081,
-0.0282033663,
0.0192624796,
0.0279079452,
-0.0064727715,
-0.050587438,
-0.0231896508,
-0.0607965179,
-0.0506916381,
-0.0647857487,
-0.0371069647,
-0.020513555,
-0.0486290865,
0.0290440451,
0.0003571263,
0.0310726017,
-0.005107461,
-0.0063738697,
-0.0381735675,
-0.0457092933,
0.0637344643,
-0.0296811461,
0.0754959434,
-0.0209801737,
0.0311489664,
-0.0428892411,
0.0265311692,
-0.0362396315,
0.0250483193,
0.0062293261,
0.1334587485,
-0.0005387951,
0.0118750986,
0.0255878586,
0.0522443652,
-0.0140493419,
-0.0590382554,
0.0241295472,
0.0252641179,
0.039047204,
-0.053670913,
0.0446686707,
0.0051274966,
0.0032599994,
-0.0243561715,
0.0051850481,
0.0180792306,
-0.070230417,
0.0162782483,
0.0181916654,
-0.0419756286,
-0.0006465305,
0.0324690603,
-0.0110644996,
-0.0255842339,
0.0008279026,
-0.0206181146,
0.0074094832,
-0.037401408,
0.0735379234,
-0.0196082406,
-0.0655517429,
-0.0036999411,
-0.0970204324,
-0.0617340021,
-0.0400487594,
0.0038260536,
-0.0330291167,
-0.0304095112,
-0.0137166902,
0.0813657567,
-0.0348972231,
-0.0458521768,
-0.0631584451,
-0.0407020338,
-0.0499765165,
-0.0101596648,
0.0204677489,
-6.37808835e-33,
-0.0092526395,
-0.0166836046,
0.050338231,
-0.0166682843,
-0.0462136939,
-0.019698225,
-0.0226007756,
0.0503608882,
-0.0842916965,
0.0072007608,
-0.0306815039,
-0.0120498231,
-0.0012736544,
-0.031226486,
0.042127531,
0.0070756897,
-0.01378348,
0.006038412,
-0.0193305612,
-0.0071548517,
0.0079712737,
-0.0355946124,
0.0681920499,
-0.0845948011,
0.0464919284,
-0.0166000184,
-0.0028632525,
-0.010283201,
0.0175733995,
0.0354517885,
-0.0351253189,
0.0226279553,
0.0421557203,
-0.0314528979,
0.0185973998,
0.0109616257,
-0.0023230484,
-0.0200297516,
0.0438413732,
0.0184492543,
0.0463522673,
-0.0616202392,
-0.0201581661,
-0.0300063044,
-0.060256239,
0.038771756,
0.027302755,
-0.0482445695,
0.016803937,
0.0177477319,
-0.0768894181,
0.0125554521,
-0.0161530524,
0.0554603301,
-0.0238910038,
0.0570145994,
-0.0085302768,
0.0340501256,
-0.0361338034,
0.0000922081,
0.0166172534,
0.0015620078,
0.106596455,
0.0124279615,
0.0118407141,
0.0366254635,
0.0286786221,
0.0373561829,
-0.0435310043,
-0.0531829186,
0.0482459143,
-0.001008165,
0.0068640718,
0.0714946911,
-0.0294886213,
-0.0300208796,
-0.0303696766,
-0.0171717703,
0.0309540257,
0.0148735205,
0.0211255848,
0.0091155348,
-0.0746131092,
-0.0215787813,
-0.0057394723,
0.0038642257,
-0.0170740522,
-0.0396647863,
0.0294641834,
-0.0330580808,
0.0138941268,
-0.0237250663,
0.051861506,
-0.0448047742,
0.0298114922,
0.002756061,
-0.0118366005,
-0.0190046206,
0.022530077,
0.0270231422,
-0.0473661274,
-0.0312924981,
-0.0612921603,
0.011563139,
0.0165348276,
0.0358660556,
0.0002624448,
0.0117990794,
-0.0539073423,
-0.0008489243,
-0.0218457822,
-0.0212799422,
0.0203222074,
-0.0205906108,
0.0307204425,
-0.0155754257,
0.0176652558,
-0.0197330005,
0.062368691,
-0.0115897991,
-0.047664199,
-0.0396404266,
-0.0551151074,
0.0117494008,
-0.0284863748,
0.0093323942,
-0.0361372419,
0.0849646777,
0.0432858206,
-0.0133859962,
-0.0208960008,
0.0011276028,
2.862e-7,
-0.0061783735,
0.0194248669,
-0.0193070024,
0.0409529731,
0.0022689644,
0.0176372081,
-0.0210763384,
0.0217232835,
0.0181581639,
0.0112751815,
0.0463468134,
0.0191800687,
0.0576688573,
0.0260960367,
-0.0280132424,
0.0053366744,
-0.0417557284,
0.0267957821,
-0.0518548526,
0.0716276839,
-0.0137901334,
0.0489320494,
0.0055549033,
0.0131263901,
-0.0398740955,
-0.0104485052,
0.0189668015,
-0.0692185089,
0.0038231055,
0.0219270587,
-0.0160096474,
-0.0163471363,
0.0186950136,
-0.0004312946,
0.044516854,
0.0151600838,
0.0467582978,
0.1052755341,
0.0092895189,
0.0212188624,
0.0003370667,
-0.0200540777,
-0.0096527506,
-0.1236068308,
0.0602658466,
0.0142652709,
-0.0485343263,
-0.0417161025,
0.0006576799,
-0.0235293992,
0.0496311337,
-0.0067105973,
0.0156707931,
0.0177580528,
0.0259812195,
-0.0174047705,
0.024492342,
-0.0014095895,
0.0075960308,
-0.0218233801,
0.0113360155,
-0.0554452576,
-0.0124356449,
-0.011690475,
0.0114354715,
0.0316878781,
0.0109151341,
2.455514027e-34,
0.0054634805,
-0.0410874076,
0.0246105362,
0.0017886866,
0.0497087091,
0.0139918616,
-0.0136081809,
0.0161031764,
0.0001554324,
-0.0356506445,
-0.0146547016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13399v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13399v2 | EntropyRank: Unsupervised Keyphrase Extraction via Side-Information Optimization for Language Model-based Text Compression | 2023-08-25T14:23:40 | 2023-08-29T18:28:13 | Alexander Tsvetkov, Alon Kipnis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT | We propose an unsupervised method to extract keywords and keyphrases from
texts based on a pre-trained language model (LM) and Shannon's information
maximization. Specifically, our method extracts phrases having the highest
conditional entropy under the LM. The resulting set of keyphrases turns out to
solve a relevant information-theoretic problem: if provided as side
information, it leads to the expected minimal binary code length in compressing
the text using the LM and an entropy encoder. Alternately, the resulting set is
an approximation via a causal LM to the set of phrases that minimize the
entropy of the text when conditioned upon it. Empirically, the method provides
results comparable to the most commonly used methods in various keyphrase
extraction benchmark challenges. | [
0.0597694851,
0.0523799062,
0.005383125,
0.0206317678,
-0.0544597544,
0.0340395607,
-0.0164722521,
0.0689874589,
-0.0036563606,
-0.0635232776,
-0.0009181307,
0.012173309,
-0.0198667236,
-0.0155203557,
0.0224017538,
-0.0140131749,
0.0000193161,
-0.0318502672,
-0.0185946636,
-0.0127881635,
-0.0178925749,
-0.0096010612,
0.0290144831,
-0.0043593468,
0.0263445675,
0.0185080953,
-0.0071573793,
-0.00471596,
-0.0162758771,
0.0181742813,
-0.0329357125,
0.0327522606,
0.0158827752,
-0.0166099817,
0.0000021722,
-0.0476946644,
-0.0510738418,
-0.0043543908,
-0.0068599065,
0.0508425459,
0.0753949285,
-0.0241897516,
-0.0127651282,
0.0136649301,
-0.0279120151,
-0.0428123102,
0.0333852805,
0.0379409678,
0.03630374,
0.0522555523,
-0.036329139,
-0.0612528473,
-0.0052674175,
-0.0503401794,
0.0107044112,
-0.0419882759,
0.0559703819,
-0.0470504202,
-0.073803328,
0.0093078008,
-0.0062012756,
0.0379046649,
-0.0066765603,
0.0307230931,
0.066419743,
0.0139974356,
-0.005815859,
-0.0154233454,
0.0026469673,
0.0241192672,
-0.0311408807,
-0.0003166454,
0.0462446958,
-0.0257781129,
-0.033748854,
-0.0027108274,
-0.0383403897,
0.0358568095,
0.0152277639,
0.0025275433,
-0.006131772,
0.0137218917,
-0.000112464,
-0.0008685832,
-0.0549410619,
0.0315202549,
0.0307156574,
-0.0624062903,
0.0075269951,
-0.0444641039,
-0.0241043195,
-0.0421235524,
-0.0107232276,
0.0015973119,
0.1028005257,
0.0257352777,
-0.0249782596,
-0.0072904406,
0.0569570065,
-0.1226377189,
-0.0511813201,
-0.0225735344,
0.080510594,
0.0344208926,
0.0083810259,
0.0434189476,
-0.0017658795,
0.0366141312,
-0.0471453257,
0.017491525,
0.0061071957,
-0.0191399716,
-0.0071563837,
0.0487611778,
0.0475018509,
-0.0186153967,
-0.0226675887,
-0.014627465,
0.0653461069,
0.0290951226,
0.008346526,
0.0090230508,
-0.0126479473,
-0.0093879877,
0.0243850965,
-0.048729118,
-0.0047716261,
0.0096884994,
-0.0186925568,
0.0020080679,
-0.0115733799,
0.0567766279,
0.0587091818,
-0.0117828008,
0.0595990568,
0.0344399847,
-0.0028395222,
-0.0320806056,
-0.0189961027,
-0.0306152031,
0.0148807382,
0.0094344048,
0.00694814,
-0.0408387072,
0.0289177857,
0.0017133228,
-0.0007940906,
-0.042057272,
0.014789707,
0.0105890762,
-0.0743485093,
0.0370175689,
-0.0225321446,
-0.0218831506,
0.0369604491,
0.0109825293,
0.0823639929,
0.0514225736,
0.0245789085,
0.0780117363,
0.0538743287,
-0.0614898726,
0.0055546327,
0.0560092703,
0.0512467138,
0.0396669358,
-0.0230305046,
0.0031193974,
0.0149651263,
-0.056972798,
0.0045490125,
0.0437332764,
-0.0162175819,
0.0130755017,
0.0294525977,
0.0930920839,
0.0301334374,
0.0665957257,
-0.0391396731,
0.033138901,
0.0084594674,
0.0207326878,
0.0283093918,
-0.0480011068,
-0.0550864525,
0.017102737,
0.1156971976,
-0.0007960785,
0.0035390512,
-0.0576107651,
-0.0287481137,
-0.0236196443,
0.0197203588,
-0.0265718754,
0.0594773702,
-0.0073420485,
-0.0335904136,
0.0614593066,
0.0041285898,
-0.0580907427,
-0.015675813,
-0.01378024,
-0.0631616861,
0.0365012176,
0.0797140598,
-0.0262434185,
0.0356510468,
-0.019014759,
-0.0298017506,
0.0382153615,
-0.0211127382,
0.0220144577,
0.007047595,
-0.0632008687,
-0.0400951058,
-0.0009025235,
0.0075362227,
-0.0366556793,
0.0054012001,
0.030155139,
0.0372238904,
0.0012620247,
-0.0045628436,
0.0234309305,
-0.009884268,
-0.050500527,
0.0093721049,
-0.0203527883,
0.0593066253,
-0.0242014118,
-0.0659084544,
0.023529239,
0.0496991128,
-0.0784995332,
-0.0277158655,
-0.0193198491,
0.006216343,
-0.0056173783,
0.0259984843,
-0.0231366437,
0.0701608509,
0.0187917054,
-0.010088427,
-0.0090611177,
0.0013547268,
-0.0418206491,
0.0914632678,
-0.0382975452,
0.0106588509,
-0.0249134824,
0.0141004864,
-0.0449155495,
0.0783743635,
-0.0248891097,
0.0288644247,
-0.0691858828,
-0.1030101553,
0.0078879381,
-0.0045187557,
0.0206004791,
0.0444296934,
-0.0062799384,
-0.0054793702,
0.0430535562,
0.0171686728,
0.0291183125,
-0.029868558,
-0.0476560444,
0.0133062797,
-0.0043971646,
0.0064543537,
0.0176776368,
0.0232477114,
-0.0335228108,
0.0099747665,
-0.0166789703,
-0.0284792148,
-0.0007442414,
-0.0275776051,
0.010420111,
0.039447248,
0.0322329439,
-0.0339675844,
-0.0194154531,
-0.0002733019,
0.0693692639,
0.0112210847,
-0.0603738576,
0.0016863446,
0.1430544406,
-0.0020400148,
-0.0307891257,
-0.0002167988,
-0.0575917959,
-0.0391088985,
-0.0569785722,
0.0287457854,
0.0237504505,
0.0818890929,
-0.0264197197,
0.0406551883,
-0.0095444899,
-0.0501506887,
-0.0106327515,
-0.0313896388,
0.0124414675,
0.0042649689,
-0.0723668113,
0.0622608885,
0.0415438488,
0.0283003673,
0.0276837014,
-0.0372811183,
-0.0100084031,
0.0034309034,
-0.0232291855,
-0.0687620118,
-0.00341305,
0.0250555556,
0.0408060066,
0.0051819556,
-0.0373314656,
0.0137480916,
-0.0535606295,
0.0206059869,
-0.0303102117,
-0.0048728031,
-0.0506014228,
0.0317082144,
0.0174972881,
0.0339997187,
0.0303101372,
0.0097803231,
0.0245660879,
-0.0207845736,
0.0140796509,
-0.0671963766,
-0.0262339078,
0.0053109583,
-0.0034051668,
-0.0183297899,
0.008933017,
-0.0014846192,
-0.0561484247,
0.0182561576,
-0.0564340986,
0.0871149525,
-0.0080117779,
0.0254369993,
0.0456075929,
0.0439707674,
0.0264162477,
0.0205551833,
0.0209953561,
0.0190862305,
0.0172476228,
0.0725855306,
-0.0482496545,
0.0040259799,
-0.009928328,
0.0359854102,
0.0544147044,
0.0966640562,
0.0223487858,
0.036142204,
-0.0045688464,
0.0555320382,
-0.0287504233,
-0.0408289172,
0.0051844101,
-0.0189872459,
0.0202578884,
0.005807654,
0.1134698987,
0.0526297465,
-0.1104260385,
-0.0104883574,
-0.0234726015,
-0.0120312776,
-0.0177011918,
0.0196122583,
-0.0513600223,
-0.012865901,
0.0124875335,
0.0177652035,
-0.0239718556,
-0.021565564,
-0.033594083,
-0.0566569641,
0.0211444646,
0.0341567025,
0.0548966154,
-0.032699082,
-0.0568558536,
-0.0109207267,
-0.0340100527,
-0.0882604197,
0.0027788731,
-0.0337285846,
0.0001424826,
-0.0141481366,
-0.0768537372,
-0.0359642208,
-0.0088681784,
-0.0219480265,
-0.0010409463,
0.0768415779,
0.0008529856,
-0.0233596861,
0.0009286265,
-0.010971725,
-0.0134759331,
-0.0478319116,
-0.0379474871,
0.0302752517,
-0.0365223736,
0.0196003765,
0.0110594127,
0.0133258402,
-0.0241928324,
0.0095234932,
0.0617681555,
0.0146075012,
0.0069199502,
0.0044863941,
-0.0030585683,
0.0108588012,
-0.0267416239,
0.0793438405,
0.0287393723,
-0.025248656,
0.0025188471,
-0.0041231751,
0.0475722514,
-0.0424086861,
-0.0880688429,
-0.0558647402,
-0.0002119305,
-0.0249322187,
-0.0405425765,
-0.0005825429,
-0.0159723982,
-0.0028530119,
-0.0253418069,
0.0233570635,
-0.0034715647,
0.0105544319,
-0.0507125705,
-0.0559236743,
-0.009083637,
-0.0562537238,
-0.0597326681,
-0.0214915276,
0.0263926554,
-0.0201609861,
-0.0147176562,
0.0290141441,
-0.0126075819,
-0.0307253972,
0.005308094,
0.0318367854,
0.0145169096,
0.0500895567,
-0.0174080729,
-0.0249540154,
0.0709214285,
0.0536405146,
-0.0441633873,
0.0355741195,
0.0301133096,
-0.0340122133,
0.0123365792,
0.0247878116,
-0.05422429,
0.0139313024,
-0.004540123,
0.0323753692,
-0.0739385635,
-0.0865843296,
0.0216746703,
0.0427885577,
0.0247195661,
-0.0143713029,
-0.0471589342,
-0.0007871367,
0.0180734619,
0.0033469736,
-0.0162829366,
-0.0442306362,
0.0363147333,
0.0229752585,
-0.0082816612,
0.0066594346,
0.0555193946,
-0.0234470293,
-0.0363142453,
0.0103305643,
0.0052710045,
-0.036229182,
0.043565996,
-0.0115533341,
-0.0036506066,
-0.0141188372,
-0.0116357338,
-0.0131881312,
-0.0091804843,
-0.0330573618,
-0.0075433049,
-0.0041067642,
-0.0042064176,
-0.0236113649,
0.0740820989,
-0.0533172451,
-0.0287350621,
-0.0684443265,
-0.0130619491,
0.0475662164,
0.0034278259,
0.0020393471,
-0.0327236243,
0.0081733568,
-0.0028924388,
0.0025927257,
0.0275303628,
0.0027751385,
-0.0380133726,
0.0138581553,
-0.0532465689,
0.0213118475,
0.0712694749,
0.0606975853,
0.0417879522,
0.0043338309,
-0.0264288038,
-0.0322929472,
-0.0031015719,
0.0329112038,
0.0320514478,
0.0005221101,
-0.0024985573,
-0.015032284,
-0.0203811228,
0.0125785694,
0.0069440436,
-0.0025578658,
0.0164117422,
0.0319847725,
0.0776535794,
-0.0148440758,
0.0035527514,
-0.0511672236,
0.0408302359,
-0.0392718166,
-0.0346568339,
0.0452996679,
-6.601672518e-33,
-0.0254312716,
0.0117210671,
-0.0320264325,
0.0498482361,
0.0030794288,
-0.0024341773,
-0.0135479504,
-0.0231476892,
-0.0130222877,
-0.0391140319,
-0.0330244824,
0.0008031146,
0.0011976634,
0.0041566873,
0.0147708431,
0.0104265912,
-0.0049229087,
-0.0144070024,
-0.0329253525,
0.0336681306,
0.0162658989,
0.0183302835,
0.0365960225,
-0.0116773136,
-0.0060610389,
-0.0602689795,
-0.0085996855,
-0.0116155595,
0.0581302345,
0.0133989006,
-0.0513855033,
-0.0020480924,
0.0000629547,
-0.0981138647,
0.0168157108,
-0.0033814018,
-0.0104849618,
-0.0267006494,
0.0059780153,
-0.0272167865,
0.0107636359,
-0.0803705752,
0.0300951116,
-0.0252124164,
-0.0165335275,
0.017573135,
0.040870972,
-0.0061639934,
-0.0300421771,
-0.0908645391,
0.0160802267,
0.0335211866,
-0.024306858,
0.0021343883,
0.047632236,
0.051859118,
-0.0081661008,
0.0451969504,
-0.0270930082,
0.0426173694,
0.0577431358,
0.0604083426,
0.02897604,
0.0111800479,
0.0440870598,
0.031441275,
-0.0327881128,
-0.0644364059,
-0.0136744594,
0.0275996961,
0.0107995952,
0.0097108558,
0.0102989348,
0.0341850929,
0.0566861071,
-0.0422284007,
-0.0627441853,
0.0611601435,
0.0109182307,
-0.0262167919,
-0.0071599204,
0.0028622064,
-0.0585760921,
0.0032539456,
-0.009603804,
0.0121448925,
0.0010398916,
-0.0483866744,
-0.0033928233,
0.0303361211,
-0.0933061466,
-0.003587092,
0.0274203699,
-0.0047582155,
0.0272777751,
0.0463519171,
0.0273845196,
0.0299160164,
-0.0098778168,
0.0125894053,
-0.0481075905,
0.0038377543,
0.0338188373,
-0.0078243138,
0.0020169192,
-0.0131076947,
-0.0258806944,
0.0098302308,
-0.0356598273,
-0.0289528072,
0.0091251926,
-0.0264632534,
0.0025520581,
-0.054010734,
0.0014817837,
0.0188141018,
-0.0000869249,
-0.0140210027,
0.024937883,
0.0165153947,
0.0068504438,
-0.0043401252,
0.0142826913,
0.0425605401,
0.0343143865,
0.0088016503,
-0.0251556337,
-0.0205479991,
0.0138998078,
0.0150099033,
-0.0056714518,
0.003219215,
2.89e-7,
0.0322495662,
0.0348962434,
0.0239221379,
-0.021087328,
-0.0113684088,
0.0438507125,
-0.0176781733,
0.0230356604,
-0.0282753315,
-0.007347797,
0.0530759618,
0.0409371294,
0.0154910833,
-0.0079241311,
-0.0662779808,
0.0073279897,
-0.0164121389,
-0.0117006609,
-0.0152240163,
-0.0148437172,
0.0482461229,
0.0937828645,
-0.0007080409,
-0.0018490512,
-0.0404875278,
-0.0579348132,
0.0329471119,
-0.0884710699,
-0.0109932553,
0.0278242584,
-0.0065503018,
0.0320741013,
-0.0430895202,
-0.0063097263,
-0.024302911,
0.0000558862,
0.0062324256,
0.0304302946,
0.0228694081,
-0.0464759171,
-0.0001645992,
-0.0072039734,
-0.0053702639,
-0.0280638319,
0.0836525559,
-0.0013971904,
-0.0370371863,
-0.0191330165,
-0.0270601455,
0.010589716,
0.0193602908,
-0.0064768139,
-0.0350016616,
0.0089027034,
-0.0041717761,
0.0080499081,
-0.0169745963,
-0.0575682148,
0.0134569034,
-0.0219203047,
-0.0212820545,
0.0298981853,
-0.0437246971,
0.0373500958,
0.0063559129,
-0.0649292469,
0.0378122367,
2.565428488e-34,
0.0126076452,
-0.0070765046,
-0.0337768085,
0.0363698266,
0.019541204,
-0.0169885978,
-0.0282386765,
0.0253558755,
-0.0265959967,
-0.0700233579,
0.0111746257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13387v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13387v2 | Do-Not-Answer: A Dataset for Evaluating Safeguards in LLMs | 2023-08-25T14:02:12 | 2023-09-04T01:47:30 | Yuxia Wang, Haonan Li, Xudong Han, Preslav Nakov, Timothy Baldwin | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the rapid evolution of large language models (LLMs), new and
hard-to-predict harmful capabilities are emerging. This requires developers to
be able to identify risks through the evaluation of "dangerous capabilities" in
order to responsibly deploy LLMs. In this work, we collect the first
open-source dataset to evaluate safeguards in LLMs, and deploy safer
open-source LLMs at a low cost. Our dataset is curated and filtered to consist
only of instructions that responsible language models should not follow. We
annotate and assess the responses of six popular LLMs to these instructions.
Based on our annotation, we proceed to train several BERT-like classifiers, and
find that these small classifiers can achieve results that are comparable with
GPT-4 on automatic safety evaluation. Warning: this paper contains example data
that may be offensive, harmful, or biased. | [
0.0092454795,
0.0680919439,
-0.0225788597,
0.0332454406,
-0.0240972806,
-0.0119417906,
0.0098974761,
0.0175157171,
0.0475945026,
-0.0678077266,
-0.0150285615,
-0.0067519373,
-0.0117959762,
0.0029026689,
0.0426976047,
0.0135297421,
0.0462598987,
-0.0430103242,
-0.0133424308,
0.0002134122,
-0.0123311616,
0.0294657908,
0.0115576582,
0.0836212933,
0.021390425,
-0.0171228163,
0.0301090535,
0.0180377755,
0.0198897924,
-0.0524013303,
0.0237420257,
0.0215580463,
-0.0058667911,
0.0430434383,
0.0000018547,
-0.0609518215,
-0.0145455636,
0.0367655829,
0.0019383142,
0.0415779687,
0.0059621371,
-0.0184946656,
-0.0330954492,
0.045821704,
-0.0200982802,
5.574e-7,
0.0553760491,
-0.0008789115,
0.0877760351,
0.0707572252,
-0.0006631492,
0.0141966948,
0.0344408043,
0.0035003158,
0.0148347132,
-0.0402709246,
0.0251439977,
-0.0247927774,
-0.0130208544,
0.023359891,
0.0207131691,
0.0031545283,
-0.0105523765,
0.0033709025,
-0.0568959266,
0.0166103318,
-0.0582020096,
-0.0234496389,
-0.0191897433,
0.0339105614,
-0.015733378,
-0.0417865589,
0.0160123464,
-0.0169508345,
-0.0019871155,
0.0195927806,
0.0112743946,
0.0343223549,
0.0009079794,
0.0061049624,
0.0069043064,
-0.0131013012,
0.0324719213,
-0.003025698,
0.0250358731,
0.0851994157,
0.0240721665,
-0.0100945104,
0.0107742995,
-0.0327728242,
-0.0067885444,
-0.0556796789,
-0.0259068403,
0.0059788297,
0.0102513945,
0.042436976,
-0.0663795546,
-0.0213470273,
0.0837639421,
-0.0920198634,
0.0006995255,
0.0236275773,
-0.023533782,
0.0068448749,
-0.03909266,
0.0271451473,
0.0045912541,
0.052077692,
0.021351032,
0.0242434088,
-0.0003548413,
-0.0163158197,
-0.0167088266,
0.0457972102,
0.032932952,
0.0541015156,
-0.0447061248,
0.0470961072,
-0.0189743508,
0.0699539557,
0.0151378317,
-0.0090468666,
0.0039666225,
0.0109673655,
0.0171921086,
-0.0449842401,
0.0013154516,
0.0134406816,
-0.0282898173,
-0.0931991935,
0.0077166064,
0.0096209543,
-0.0555051938,
-0.0355125293,
0.0092943814,
0.1254143566,
0.0625855848,
-0.0034355645,
-0.0666906387,
-0.0241155904,
-0.0274598859,
0.0016148471,
-0.0146305077,
-0.0608792417,
-0.0642089397,
0.0035950085,
-0.0089185154,
-0.0580911525,
0.0075132283,
0.0148146264,
-0.0301855169,
0.0568052754,
-0.0558047257,
-0.0199240409,
0.015916869,
0.0330270343,
0.002013843,
0.0641184226,
0.0288928319,
0.0316651464,
0.0433617719,
-0.0408211872,
0.0346156582,
0.066151455,
-0.0192411393,
0.0428367928,
-0.0324836969,
0.0239813365,
0.0255347397,
-0.041983258,
-0.0231069643,
0.0666398183,
0.0148692951,
-0.0361882076,
0.0518381111,
0.0442105606,
-0.0215268731,
0.0126111284,
0.0303860381,
0.0325427838,
-0.0155440299,
-0.053415969,
-0.0437181704,
-0.0135413995,
-0.078894116,
-0.0260738786,
-0.0265297219,
0.0237394571,
-0.0195526015,
-0.0257418547,
-0.0317989774,
-0.0145855015,
0.0039272164,
0.0037546942,
0.0270986743,
-0.0059701088,
-0.0295883957,
0.084297359,
0.0212289914,
-0.0562045313,
-0.0323104374,
-0.0765290409,
-0.0033923092,
0.0685944334,
0.0531068593,
-0.056999471,
-0.0604909547,
-0.0418066271,
-0.0211537965,
-0.0083383396,
0.0237482563,
0.0141192451,
0.0308440644,
-0.0377197154,
-0.0184145104,
-0.0042290953,
0.0245115869,
0.0157929678,
0.0334265642,
0.0053954441,
-0.0017146968,
-0.0449384078,
-0.0680388585,
0.0565730631,
0.0202409215,
-0.0726266056,
-0.0016537857,
-0.0004794014,
0.0172952339,
-0.008962526,
-0.0229648817,
0.0072759232,
0.0519478358,
0.0201172568,
0.0089141382,
-0.0230584648,
0.0111330412,
0.0284843165,
0.060526181,
-0.0193008929,
-0.0065738293,
0.0212303251,
-0.0480054542,
0.0065700943,
0.0290525537,
-0.0576845258,
0.0265111774,
-0.0083170608,
0.0246388335,
-0.0283979028,
-0.0130245676,
-0.0374967828,
0.0287823156,
-0.0134038012,
0.0227835663,
0.0000880978,
-0.017930828,
0.0349432006,
-0.0015289119,
-0.072942175,
-0.0000650339,
-0.0351987854,
0.0602951311,
0.0217948798,
0.0693737417,
-0.0047803028,
-0.0185739342,
-0.0591029935,
-0.0130654359,
-0.0231647789,
0.0526165552,
0.0155276358,
0.0107380264,
-0.0295266174,
-0.0149002401,
-0.0015409271,
-0.0550118871,
-0.0328889638,
0.0242074151,
0.027749883,
-0.0316543058,
-0.0603566915,
-0.0069564469,
-0.0147785014,
-0.0390028656,
0.0528204851,
-0.0288055073,
-0.0122936741,
-0.0499347821,
0.0238901097,
-0.0105635542,
0.0244904384,
0.0004760746,
-0.0764857531,
0.0226912443,
0.0021042919,
-0.0338525437,
0.0227780733,
0.0093563534,
0.0103044072,
0.0675110668,
0.0203596149,
-0.0786005259,
-0.0129748909,
0.0495874323,
-0.0667360872,
-0.0249188282,
-0.0587607734,
0.0408508591,
0.0371870697,
-0.0135365464,
-0.0291381944,
-0.0464506038,
-0.0279850587,
-0.0197225101,
-0.0305741802,
0.0183766074,
-0.0354406983,
-0.0375741906,
0.0161168445,
0.0268589333,
-0.0745236725,
0.0670231432,
-0.0544166006,
0.0079496996,
-0.0380321816,
-0.0256537702,
-0.0178184733,
0.0531012006,
-0.038547527,
0.0116862226,
0.0314708129,
-0.0527297705,
-0.0238980129,
-0.0170013662,
0.0487170257,
-0.0426519886,
0.0413610302,
-0.0616615042,
0.0146620795,
0.000745555,
-0.0089240419,
-0.0544177964,
-0.0429747812,
-0.0157200713,
-0.0045782584,
0.0185009204,
-0.0043575508,
-0.0054982114,
0.0102286264,
0.0109717986,
0.0135522122,
0.0294018872,
-0.0225371346,
0.000611164,
-0.0319451615,
0.009932261,
-0.0702013075,
-0.0005442337,
-0.0108383493,
0.0065789171,
0.054933615,
0.0431524962,
-0.0007448555,
-0.0508253388,
-0.002791275,
0.0599650815,
-0.0513491854,
-0.0192980617,
0.0755063295,
0.0472140424,
-0.0430691279,
-0.0024614553,
0.0679629743,
0.0265235472,
-0.0161564518,
0.0286590513,
-0.0097755864,
0.0314189158,
0.0373078398,
0.0215856321,
-0.0966965035,
-0.0153311705,
0.0088483859,
0.0392680578,
-0.0100607965,
-0.0151487477,
0.0053867432,
-0.1154961437,
0.0397787318,
0.0122197177,
-0.0196167026,
0.0087586557,
-0.0303030256,
-0.0168254618,
-0.025555579,
0.0206986126,
-0.0206785202,
-0.0083479658,
-0.0141243152,
0.0336747132,
-0.0961338356,
-0.0155626694,
0.0345833637,
-0.0290214717,
0.0412593,
0.0852642134,
-0.0066902558,
-0.0377862342,
-0.0242816042,
0.062173117,
-0.0272376128,
-0.0141797392,
-0.0004053679,
0.0411265232,
0.0001742147,
-0.0136717111,
0.0383616723,
0.0087131234,
-0.0333984829,
-0.0233318917,
0.048929289,
0.0503605567,
-0.0492637157,
-0.0062761344,
-0.0334547199,
0.0076146997,
0.0111689596,
0.0497316197,
0.0207600277,
-0.0353412181,
-0.0302881058,
-0.0630078912,
0.0022002468,
-0.0389015488,
-0.0174910706,
-0.0064684669,
-0.0099923536,
-0.0461708717,
-0.0701683909,
0.0104903439,
0.0029004137,
0.0086960597,
0.0486481041,
-0.0256237537,
-0.013958456,
0.0421153568,
-0.0190000068,
0.0046421327,
-0.0129700257,
0.0268650632,
-0.0615710057,
0.0177882258,
0.0160434451,
0.0299589764,
-0.0061062281,
0.0268114135,
-0.0438813418,
-0.0830518007,
-0.016789807,
0.1133619621,
0.0256948918,
-0.033810731,
-0.0457254834,
-0.0720063075,
0.0639957935,
0.0717576295,
-0.0525062643,
-0.030702915,
0.0633003712,
-0.0183510277,
0.0141049279,
0.0112089673,
-0.0634833872,
-0.0287860855,
0.0361909606,
-0.016204834,
-0.0627627447,
-0.0242884289,
0.0035871286,
0.041320242,
0.0243605543,
-0.0482593067,
0.0247081686,
0.0129910503,
0.0181974024,
-0.0108905872,
-0.0306822322,
-0.0073076431,
0.0629910231,
0.0150466384,
-0.0419495925,
0.0005900591,
0.0129590919,
-0.0344652459,
0.0375894308,
-0.0280433465,
0.0822790042,
0.0291700717,
0.0592077263,
0.0324080996,
-0.009524269,
-0.0176674351,
-0.0022696194,
0.0005630418,
0.0313678384,
0.0088828271,
0.018629482,
-0.021470679,
0.0404667296,
0.0258524586,
0.0498482026,
-0.0159153324,
-0.0628051683,
-0.0120419441,
0.0750701278,
0.0210366063,
0.0331799239,
0.0540810339,
-0.0205541626,
0.0118385591,
-0.051059138,
0.0088570863,
-0.0105954297,
-0.046914421,
0.0231377315,
0.0139398603,
-0.0423876122,
-0.0382237919,
0.0929320604,
0.0302963909,
0.0286332071,
0.005410017,
-0.0231786296,
-0.0569173321,
-0.0325777866,
0.0724510029,
0.028424643,
-0.0406645611,
-0.0302603282,
-0.0656410009,
-0.0662889257,
-0.0113634365,
0.0061367033,
0.032922294,
0.0057303254,
-0.0056503564,
0.0595029071,
0.0145051293,
-0.0308897253,
-0.055610653,
-0.032499887,
0.010793264,
-0.0240459591,
-0.0324708037,
-5.165723884e-33,
0.0019679384,
-0.0199841131,
-0.0251587033,
0.0040500951,
0.0375866927,
0.0199063141,
0.0034891032,
-0.0048036296,
-0.0280554425,
-0.0236169435,
0.0156574249,
0.0049681566,
0.0140153766,
-0.0052613243,
0.0295398626,
-0.0113289962,
0.0070124385,
0.0082657188,
-0.0417130738,
0.0265954789,
0.0294062048,
-0.0104431678,
0.0647834763,
-0.0710084662,
0.0413000435,
0.0165967196,
-0.0362709463,
0.0006171662,
-0.0426772051,
0.0543262139,
0.012600394,
0.035177853,
-0.0047991285,
-0.0298022144,
0.0105692409,
-0.010671976,
0.0074879876,
-0.0358310454,
0.0196335651,
-0.0184796713,
0.0183866788,
-0.0516113825,
0.0647512749,
0.0018981462,
-0.0273285657,
-0.0072374735,
0.0322124287,
-0.0147877717,
-0.0229477659,
-0.034492597,
-0.0216608793,
0.0388399959,
-0.0323794894,
0.0135606555,
0.0069547314,
0.0340143219,
0.0157856792,
0.0000653784,
-0.0307334494,
0.0224786494,
0.0359395035,
0.0126552712,
0.0856255069,
0.0071596601,
-0.0056273695,
0.0484547243,
-0.0205438603,
0.0051252777,
0.0271515362,
-0.0308938231,
0.0249127373,
0.0656693801,
0.0203400813,
0.0195413679,
-0.0015986183,
-0.0227806289,
-0.0522840954,
0.0547762476,
0.0226858091,
0.0600641593,
0.0311089568,
-0.002632082,
-0.0757093877,
-0.0223797038,
-0.0053935177,
0.0120379264,
-0.006678923,
-0.0148735559,
0.0149155157,
-0.0338951722,
-0.0400417708,
0.0163408238,
-0.0039245975,
-0.0465614572,
-0.0038739576,
0.0154791968,
-0.0068009701,
-0.015964888,
-0.0112461029,
0.0386438034,
0.0001335282,
-0.0157531518,
0.0097835595,
-0.0474588126,
0.0545912869,
-0.0064533115,
0.0243893303,
0.0296677705,
-0.0885436758,
0.0117992386,
-0.0216036532,
0.0391117781,
-0.0195590816,
0.0440591462,
0.0144598894,
-0.041553665,
0.0350257754,
-0.0081602326,
0.0203227084,
-0.0208074115,
-0.0254203621,
0.0385948904,
-0.0045128996,
0.0021154515,
-0.0237792004,
-0.011902662,
0.0027389685,
0.0517772548,
0.0367320962,
-0.0331891552,
-0.0293741114,
-0.0104026468,
2.662e-7,
0.0490109436,
0.0300028138,
0.0304852333,
0.0265974384,
-0.0191642791,
0.0676361397,
-0.0085734716,
0.0611908473,
-0.0067720255,
0.0041989661,
0.0130992504,
-0.0260694493,
0.0388715938,
0.0511453412,
-0.0396685936,
0.0010004485,
-0.0755800009,
0.0209952909,
-0.0724612772,
-0.0008960103,
0.0691484287,
0.07402125,
0.0091702687,
-0.0241086241,
-0.0166917164,
-0.0592295416,
0.0097086504,
-0.0476383269,
0.020052582,
0.0306124575,
0.0521884672,
0.0548044294,
0.0176395867,
0.0312481057,
-0.03647165,
-0.0149730612,
-0.0234318245,
0.0532196499,
-0.0158289336,
-0.0260318052,
-0.0048424033,
-0.0724143609,
0.0035908737,
-0.052015733,
0.0463372059,
0.0217883196,
-0.0087581528,
0.0074221278,
-0.0165249091,
-0.0286233947,
0.02301622,
-0.0209292788,
-0.0049683563,
0.0012553544,
0.0032911776,
-0.0327978991,
-0.024361752,
-0.0548131764,
-0.0353454724,
0.0226326659,
-0.0111021176,
-0.0718525499,
-0.0002782783,
0.0525278375,
-0.0142215546,
-0.0404316224,
0.0539306663,
2.543230701e-34,
0.0125278896,
-0.0570792556,
-0.0055203009,
0.0135223418,
0.0420723036,
0.021823328,
0.0200694948,
0.0166042838,
-0.0251113586,
-0.0029397269,
-0.0075704539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13383v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13383v1 | Assessing Keyness using Permutation Tests | 2023-08-25T13:52:57 | 2023-08-25T13:52:57 | Thoralf Mildenberger | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.AP | We propose a resampling-based approach for assessing keyness in corpus
linguistics based on suggestions by Gries (2006, 2022). Traditional approaches
based on hypothesis tests (e.g. Likelihood Ratio) model the copora as
independent identically distributed samples of tokens. This model does not
account for the often observed uneven distribution of occurences of a word
across a corpus. When occurences of a word are concentrated in few documents,
large values of LLR and similar scores are in fact much more likely than
accounted for by the token-by-token sampling model, leading to false positives.
We replace the token-by-token sampling model by a model where corpora are
samples of documents rather than tokens, which is much closer to the way
corpora are actually assembled. We then use a permutation approach to
approximate the distribution of a given keyness score under the null hypothesis
of equal frequencies and obtain p-values for assessing significance. We do not
need any assumption on how the tokens are organized within or across documents,
and the approach works with basically *any* keyness score. Hence, appart from
obtaining more accurate p-values for scores like LLR, we can also assess
significance for e.g. the logratio which has been proposed as a measure of
effect size.
An efficient implementation of the proposed approach is provided in the `R`
package `keyperm` available from github. | [
-0.0199452844,
0.0608946159,
-0.0270051025,
0.0215767212,
-0.0869887397,
0.0341668911,
0.0024433697,
0.0274114404,
-0.0197924748,
-0.0166609734,
-0.0117537566,
-0.0117174694,
0.0550369769,
-0.0274968371,
0.0169296619,
0.0144555811,
0.0511134267,
0.0073758001,
0.0000765538,
-0.0024245551,
0.025483273,
-0.0154912295,
-0.0189653076,
0.0505502596,
-0.0040629897,
0.0231539477,
0.0251282491,
-0.029461978,
0.0155502353,
-0.0048304284,
-0.0441862941,
0.0514924601,
-0.0416076854,
0.0503494442,
0.0000015679,
-0.0535148904,
-0.0097269434,
0.0264322571,
0.0215749517,
0.0011660563,
0.1051332206,
0.0349492095,
0.0093679074,
0.0191232897,
-0.0198928509,
-0.0189549569,
0.0657788813,
0.0031346928,
-0.0253775083,
0.0295156911,
-0.0112120183,
-0.0458688512,
0.0245981123,
-0.0327095538,
0.0050069215,
-0.0016256983,
0.0452879146,
-0.0389944278,
-0.0152450893,
-0.0566687584,
-0.0283606201,
-0.0030490318,
-0.0250117742,
0.0114693828,
-0.0422238261,
-0.0033500916,
-0.0312886797,
-0.0082925512,
0.0396447591,
-0.0039146561,
0.0915077925,
-0.0084017823,
0.0384446569,
0.0207528938,
0.0521090515,
0.1035498455,
-0.0447954908,
-0.0450931191,
-0.0330484882,
-0.01437613,
0.0683334321,
0.0015794893,
0.0093793375,
0.0435266048,
-0.0509148128,
0.0603450574,
0.0253776703,
-0.0351359323,
0.0187396649,
0.014218702,
-0.006638777,
-0.0499317646,
0.0002503798,
-0.0283984989,
-0.0151890162,
0.0014419218,
0.0187260415,
-0.0167723894,
0.0506088473,
-0.0447914712,
-0.03203528,
-0.0124348579,
-0.0077805514,
0.0142426603,
0.012657105,
-0.0085635893,
0.0056278072,
-0.0039473213,
-0.0059495289,
0.0288804658,
-0.0460915752,
0.0071862717,
-0.023203738,
-0.0110743362,
0.0099989194,
-0.0079610441,
-0.0688843578,
-0.0061562546,
0.0265963934,
-0.0703158751,
-0.0326604396,
-0.0226621032,
-0.0130630117,
0.0457645394,
-0.0240003075,
0.0139878551,
-0.0483649671,
0.0268168189,
-0.0345136337,
0.0073022884,
-0.0063943784,
0.0414617471,
0.020874789,
-0.044600293,
0.0103772599,
0.0066088345,
0.0673295259,
-0.0140774632,
0.0292326193,
0.0120034199,
-0.0321366973,
-0.0214824863,
-0.0154367117,
-0.0870448798,
-0.0104743671,
0.0052897511,
0.0227763448,
-0.0121529512,
-0.0198007729,
-0.0016957666,
-0.0226014964,
0.0082395198,
0.0375537723,
0.0029943283,
-0.0508498475,
-0.0660128519,
0.0137497112,
0.0501449518,
0.042211052,
-0.0428353474,
0.0508484207,
-0.0206138585,
-0.0158346053,
0.036707364,
-0.070451729,
0.0405342616,
0.0343894809,
-0.009696424,
-0.0450422131,
0.0016366214,
0.0368707441,
0.0413440354,
-0.0525261946,
0.0215964131,
0.0126082748,
0.1031752899,
0.0527436063,
-0.0589320026,
-0.0210702531,
0.0065854192,
0.0463249385,
0.0596183613,
0.0316838734,
-0.0524981022,
0.0268940646,
0.0319616348,
0.0305222441,
-0.0318460725,
0.0201288313,
-0.0059155333,
-0.0073128887,
0.0092145037,
0.0312682204,
-0.0354660936,
0.0780452117,
-0.0075204745,
0.0025131772,
0.0172086395,
0.0061598714,
-0.0151439877,
0.0281021576,
-0.0139091015,
-0.0105308462,
-0.0152518274,
0.0181363039,
-0.0183858462,
0.044195611,
0.0029903862,
-0.0198312774,
0.0795225427,
-0.0162534565,
-0.0146220205,
0.0187260062,
-0.0234489106,
0.0285855662,
0.0432926193,
0.0280765407,
0.0333859771,
-0.0211996157,
0.0325271524,
-0.011805255,
-0.0796350166,
0.0182177313,
0.0071807671,
0.020714514,
-0.0093594408,
0.0040917695,
-0.0239154398,
0.0346812569,
-0.0005649535,
-0.0361266434,
0.0521556437,
0.0124893654,
-0.0154049825,
0.0232833773,
0.0411709473,
0.0488181747,
0.03028607,
0.0299695078,
-0.0607000627,
0.0012438452,
0.0161325261,
0.0111003062,
-0.0211246088,
0.0514476299,
-0.053153988,
0.0909109414,
-0.0451104194,
0.0167207886,
-0.0426433831,
0.0179071873,
-0.0359170437,
0.0452920869,
0.0396999307,
0.0815180168,
-0.0295834187,
-0.0330418572,
0.0255045407,
-0.0618782416,
0.0236609038,
-0.0575945675,
0.0004825238,
-0.0064733345,
0.0410993397,
-0.011884951,
-0.0431849286,
-0.0440395214,
-0.0582359917,
-0.0047657941,
0.0006310454,
0.0670067742,
-0.0157088749,
-0.0332706943,
-0.0285790451,
0.0357155018,
0.0372842625,
-0.0246369522,
0.0422281213,
0.0569604412,
0.0432241224,
-0.0686155409,
0.0139445327,
-0.0267788973,
0.0007727577,
-0.0296309423,
0.0158978142,
0.0676679239,
-0.0078621851,
-0.0198726095,
-0.0232193358,
-0.0073922677,
-0.0245386418,
0.0177739225,
-0.0145693971,
0.0248574615,
0.0284584835,
0.0903838053,
0.0150380963,
-0.0043302733,
0.0133103346,
-0.016101636,
-0.0610364787,
-0.0265986416,
-0.048181396,
-0.0099137602,
0.0438074023,
-0.0491534919,
-0.0434973724,
0.053249497,
0.0151796797,
0.007415981,
-0.0012860432,
-0.0063426313,
0.0370417796,
-0.0483701862,
-0.0150063559,
-0.0179188158,
0.0136179924,
-0.0499196872,
0.0351051614,
0.008229035,
-0.0072704609,
-0.004153436,
-0.0253716838,
0.0249330178,
-0.0773453787,
0.0095615471,
-0.0370758921,
0.00413951,
0.0105909845,
-0.0189378113,
0.0124145309,
-0.0490066223,
-0.0182409808,
-0.0055575855,
0.0322198458,
-0.0126794716,
0.0242612809,
-0.0155938463,
0.0305518471,
0.0302700531,
-0.0081240907,
0.0262886118,
-0.1228445098,
0.0091917906,
-0.0025660417,
0.0694971904,
-0.0500508919,
-0.0288527086,
0.0461568236,
0.0478955507,
-0.0085647535,
-0.0045331451,
-0.0021927271,
-0.0082359686,
0.0513775833,
0.0314713679,
-0.0093790898,
0.0431590751,
-0.030992236,
-0.0571435615,
0.0011748786,
-0.0056960145,
0.0544739552,
0.0107772527,
-0.0265625212,
-0.0182325765,
-0.0814415365,
-0.0331516638,
-0.0017404298,
-0.025285257,
0.0182867143,
-0.024186885,
0.0827399343,
0.0305891652,
-0.0256988108,
0.0248770565,
-0.0043670307,
0.0115708439,
0.0145406341,
-0.0139285615,
-0.0525933765,
0.0148913683,
0.0262013115,
0.0107030272,
-0.0271859542,
-0.0515594669,
0.0107011404,
-0.0688803643,
0.0236860756,
-0.0347553082,
-0.0622190498,
0.0149295786,
-0.0890489891,
0.0292126108,
-0.0119832829,
-0.0262629781,
0.0248869192,
-0.0275308415,
0.0224778056,
0.0179021098,
-0.0303950366,
-0.0476418175,
-0.0351983085,
-0.0717455819,
-0.0210240055,
0.0029391586,
0.0461812653,
-0.0898371264,
-0.039375294,
-0.0233563948,
0.0189436916,
-0.051932659,
0.0079676323,
-0.0009004935,
0.0320131741,
-0.0185060687,
-0.0663259104,
-0.0111455144,
-0.0396045819,
-0.0145673901,
0.009693577,
-0.0237177387,
0.0322046652,
-0.0038819774,
-0.0002557581,
0.0399570428,
-0.0270615071,
0.0361635834,
0.0406298637,
0.0079376502,
0.0433404893,
-0.016850505,
-0.0213365555,
-0.0241750348,
0.0236310549,
-0.0331856906,
-0.0256975368,
-0.0320793986,
-0.090781033,
-0.0408717282,
0.0034510633,
0.0565965213,
-0.009285612,
0.0046762684,
0.0017931891,
-0.0357146785,
-0.0135380132,
0.0142989159,
-0.0184823852,
0.0126105081,
-0.077771157,
0.0357882269,
0.0539890155,
0.0338694528,
-0.0500640832,
0.0286293607,
-0.080771029,
-0.0617049858,
0.0753495395,
-0.0247181579,
0.0274956468,
-0.0632127672,
-0.0047674589,
0.0267805755,
0.0401545353,
0.0638614967,
-0.0052553504,
0.0510539412,
-0.0010499307,
-0.0517064035,
0.0050757746,
-0.0012946721,
-0.0473675765,
0.0048685488,
-0.0095867803,
0.0336026214,
-0.037574999,
0.0327607431,
0.0079394132,
0.047635369,
0.0353714898,
-0.0313463099,
-0.0039304877,
-0.0031344229,
-0.0115860216,
-0.0203228146,
-0.0104703763,
0.0334063768,
-0.0413485132,
0.0053397338,
-0.0051851193,
-0.0432231501,
0.0076456605,
-0.0388883017,
0.0257568005,
0.0424716622,
0.036355231,
0.0047782804,
-0.016531013,
0.0004382435,
-0.0084576979,
0.0104916748,
-0.0353505388,
-0.0261154827,
0.0808705017,
0.0125581427,
-0.020120848,
-0.0102008749,
-0.0263481941,
-0.0165877473,
0.0299777705,
-0.0615458973,
0.0392689705,
0.0114875697,
-0.0434265845,
-0.008812977,
-0.036292132,
0.0338758416,
-0.0350208655,
0.0094420006,
-0.0311478078,
-0.0023482102,
-0.0030823029,
0.0379857011,
-0.033333648,
0.0003824804,
-0.0220843311,
0.0073883813,
0.0714841038,
0.00476269,
-0.0446891673,
0.00599853,
-0.038327869,
-0.0222754106,
-0.0341600813,
-0.0248784665,
0.0396501459,
0.0091376025,
-0.0124891605,
-0.0765423626,
-0.0401674397,
0.0173752178,
0.0325343311,
0.0331067741,
0.0026574922,
-0.0342015289,
0.0521609858,
0.0188227315,
0.0565910004,
-0.0272248685,
0.0309040137,
-0.0351274945,
-0.0409554616,
-0.023330899,
-5.735308937e-33,
-0.0147041194,
-0.0420445427,
-0.0301949438,
-0.0073610665,
0.0243025459,
0.0028099928,
-0.0115489708,
0.0101919295,
0.0169875417,
0.0083501982,
-0.0153018991,
0.0185673051,
0.0167876128,
0.0034538377,
0.018434206,
0.0329396538,
-0.0174257644,
0.0235413052,
-0.0247611124,
-0.0628778934,
0.0650722906,
-0.0201548543,
0.1073389724,
0.048054833,
0.0726369619,
0.0026534284,
-0.0050656497,
0.0009284015,
0.0026106371,
0.0446163639,
0.0287779775,
0.0488576479,
0.0224115606,
-0.0050992533,
0.0102675641,
0.0146427359,
-0.0385990664,
-0.0667848065,
0.0750364661,
0.0181859657,
0.0861060023,
-0.0120187374,
0.0527009107,
0.0286769401,
-0.0504699275,
0.0015530038,
0.0237991307,
0.0140712885,
-0.0385526605,
0.0057572075,
-0.0258217007,
0.0320359506,
-0.0042492994,
0.0321331993,
-0.0068687196,
0.020429682,
-0.0258724447,
-0.0132967997,
-0.0174883287,
0.0300701708,
0.0134890201,
0.0318131223,
0.0028017592,
-0.0117168631,
0.0251808558,
0.0366847999,
0.0032671031,
-0.002967739,
0.0362904482,
0.0107803876,
0.0645068586,
-0.0218074545,
0.0256607737,
0.1099668369,
0.0939299539,
0.0188379083,
-0.027291052,
0.0371019058,
0.0714915469,
0.0546804518,
0.0239872839,
0.0021793931,
-0.052120015,
-0.0475768149,
-0.0420298874,
-0.0317960344,
-0.000053322,
-0.0051085209,
-0.0007997185,
-0.0460493937,
-0.0076259249,
0.0049677244,
0.0371972211,
-0.0285660233,
-0.0566558018,
-0.036395289,
-0.0139068123,
0.0547322594,
-0.0315947644,
0.0019074511,
-0.0271361973,
-0.0196793471,
0.0087826867,
0.075522922,
0.0455052033,
-0.0279901735,
-0.0111239962,
-0.0056522009,
-0.0811323449,
0.0001437203,
0.0271606948,
0.0076857298,
0.0149271758,
-0.0353673957,
0.0250066835,
0.0102158347,
0.0284500252,
-0.0366578475,
0.0484220423,
-0.0364100598,
-0.0041440274,
0.0088327164,
-0.006023108,
0.0371434651,
0.0278666224,
-0.0144204609,
0.003020803,
0.0469842032,
0.0830461383,
-0.0176526215,
-0.0110686608,
-0.0241541713,
2.467e-7,
0.0573756769,
0.0599227846,
0.0055125589,
0.0098613827,
-0.0190995708,
-0.0106834173,
-0.032827545,
0.0348972492,
0.0098592239,
0.0494556427,
0.0113975927,
-0.0032077418,
0.0121611888,
0.0383932143,
-0.0827130228,
-0.0199906547,
-0.1017780825,
-0.0008881633,
-0.0247285496,
0.0342362449,
-0.0540250801,
0.0610777698,
0.0148877595,
-0.0044449572,
-0.0305122919,
-0.0971415341,
0.0100366147,
-0.0197373126,
-0.0288219769,
0.0129644079,
-0.0287272539,
-0.0335255936,
0.0593441799,
0.0365381464,
0.004028067,
0.0079467492,
0.0122516742,
-0.0409604087,
-0.0107789626,
0.001829708,
-0.0054467367,
-0.0472479239,
0.0073463954,
-0.0200803187,
-0.003386785,
-0.0340630263,
-0.0359303951,
-0.0546113849,
-0.0575085133,
0.0085904244,
0.0343388356,
-0.0049577374,
-0.0592406131,
0.0267562009,
0.0318968035,
0.0017176607,
-0.0048088185,
0.0083533628,
0.0063084471,
-0.005346742,
-0.0275025405,
-0.0795162991,
0.0134296669,
-0.0004623806,
-0.0263211504,
-0.0456736982,
-0.0164840147,
2.261795542e-34,
0.0623014681,
0.0205459874,
-0.0145014348,
0.0373630859,
0.0606080294,
-0.0121851014,
0.0103382766,
0.0397137776,
0.0058103031,
-0.1105481684,
0.0099337492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13577v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13577v2 | Text Style Transfer Evaluation Using Large Language Models | 2023-08-25T13:07:33 | 2023-09-23T06:05:22 | Phil Ostheimer, Mayank Nagda, Marius Kloft, Sophie Fellenz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Evaluating Text Style Transfer (TST) is a complex task due to its
multifaceted nature. The quality of the generated text is measured based on
challenging factors, such as style transfer accuracy, content preservation, and
overall fluency. While human evaluation is considered to be the gold standard
in TST assessment, it is costly and often hard to reproduce. Therefore,
automated metrics are prevalent in these domains. Nevertheless, it remains
unclear whether these automated metrics correlate with human evaluations.
Recent strides in Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased their capacity to
match and even exceed average human performance across diverse, unseen tasks.
This suggests that LLMs could be a feasible alternative to human evaluation and
other automated metrics in TST evaluation. We compare the results of different
LLMs in TST using multiple input prompts. Our findings highlight a strong
correlation between (even zero-shot) prompting and human evaluation, showing
that LLMs often outperform traditional automated metrics. Furthermore, we
introduce the concept of prompt ensembling, demonstrating its ability to
enhance the robustness of TST evaluation. This research contributes to the
ongoing evaluation of LLMs in diverse tasks, offering insights into successful
outcomes and areas of limitation. | [
-0.0018962157,
0.0377373099,
-0.0178793315,
0.0244626384,
-0.049210526,
0.0023809855,
0.0171500538,
0.0244012903,
-0.0373320729,
-0.026635902,
-0.0690605864,
-0.073646456,
0.0350331813,
0.0139549561,
0.0402664877,
-0.0746953934,
0.0106471935,
-0.0579989888,
-0.0155061455,
0.0166602079,
0.0515974127,
-0.0012571757,
0.0131524615,
0.0127202356,
0.0248370115,
-0.0248239562,
-0.0078755161,
0.0464424193,
0.0281845927,
0.0231718998,
-0.0104830395,
0.0675911382,
-0.0255912412,
0.0322804675,
0.0000019839,
-0.0313401967,
-0.0201347377,
-0.014120983,
0.0361955836,
0.0716685578,
0.0983936116,
0.0097760996,
-0.0518660136,
0.0035955748,
-0.0037892098,
0.0174694173,
0.0360270999,
0.0148629975,
0.0989291146,
0.0800103843,
-0.0196143482,
0.0047951727,
0.0058845617,
-0.0300756302,
-0.0064176382,
-0.0185851958,
0.0363706797,
-0.0237986054,
0.0101475222,
0.0146498699,
0.0061834874,
0.0397015475,
-0.0052812858,
-0.0591635033,
0.0062399381,
-0.0138792368,
-0.027832916,
0.0407846384,
-0.014348641,
0.076755397,
-0.0030641635,
-0.0017145202,
0.0121386554,
-0.0043561142,
-0.0003234677,
0.0264315158,
-0.0952216908,
-0.003729092,
-0.0083092488,
0.0015374946,
-0.0444719829,
0.0058485032,
0.0058906209,
-0.0112005323,
0.0087123476,
0.0050802021,
0.0446778648,
-0.0378980674,
-0.0212226138,
0.0297262706,
-0.0062304735,
-0.0626585186,
0.0435748845,
-0.0082027568,
-0.0060313591,
-0.0122233061,
-0.0897221714,
-0.0554223172,
-0.0061438107,
0.0144078936,
0.0833933279,
-0.0017464641,
-0.0097420411,
0.0207573064,
-0.0553696081,
0.0896843001,
-0.0176624618,
0.0086056162,
-0.0439340249,
0.0219976529,
-0.0646294802,
0.0026374231,
-0.0197734218,
-0.0202074926,
0.0029278421,
-0.0208938178,
-0.003561259,
-0.0138789332,
-0.0042950832,
-0.0184134319,
0.0124009587,
-0.0272163637,
-0.0300801862,
-0.0376432836,
0.0185786095,
0.0261777472,
0.0128585156,
0.0163961425,
0.0408649519,
-0.0231956467,
-0.0195000768,
0.0354374833,
0.0279145427,
-0.029125696,
-0.0262199398,
0.0317053534,
-0.0599624179,
-0.0074935826,
-0.0276812408,
-0.0003043414,
-0.0065746573,
-0.0163425449,
-0.0076778596,
-0.0743504092,
-0.0087116193,
-0.0068067992,
0.0077469363,
-0.033349447,
-0.0192748923,
0.0266560037,
-0.0165793821,
0.021873571,
0.0044040564,
0.0433402508,
0.0273534525,
-0.0153435282,
-0.0178931132,
0.0234501902,
0.0365462489,
0.074885726,
0.0169907492,
-0.0244079921,
0.0079103652,
0.0625456944,
0.0154894907,
0.051420033,
-0.0416059978,
-0.0540355258,
0.0548740923,
0.040670719,
0.0791791528,
0.0963333622,
-0.0312632322,
0.0226996318,
0.1385367215,
0.0046198401,
0.0322492868,
0.0002044573,
0.0616601743,
0.027274305,
0.0256675202,
0.0329721048,
-0.0140727442,
-0.0048651271,
-0.0248246677,
0.0264637861,
0.0679724813,
0.0341559574,
-0.0104505736,
0.0161034204,
0.0063503664,
0.011213229,
-0.0100312782,
-0.0409922339,
0.0233727191,
0.035564255,
-0.0499126501,
-0.0156551041,
0.0041304547,
-0.0552465059,
0.0372410007,
-0.0408358425,
0.0146487011,
0.1222802401,
0.0594673865,
0.0408809446,
0.02904558,
-0.0040117423,
0.0352399796,
0.0331670642,
0.0351526029,
-0.0191539265,
0.0147055965,
-0.0480991118,
0.0063021728,
-0.0059238053,
-0.0058448953,
0.0247147735,
-0.013550058,
0.0302721467,
0.0222578142,
-0.024202669,
-0.025150368,
0.0355422646,
-0.0210686922,
-0.0526811741,
-0.0121330516,
-0.0107627613,
-0.0074053467,
-0.0063136448,
-0.0665862411,
0.0168787334,
-0.0351990499,
-0.0502468385,
-0.0147434091,
-0.0063189301,
-0.0619067922,
-0.0296281409,
-0.0217206664,
-0.0252316631,
0.0023428716,
0.0224430058,
-0.017116243,
-0.0547199771,
-0.0244612303,
-0.0276951417,
-0.0086882338,
-0.0276261214,
0.0337813832,
-0.0027465175,
-0.0033842484,
-0.0387978554,
0.0215691607,
0.0439917594,
-0.0128328567,
0.0231407695,
-0.0006386904,
-0.0081038848,
-0.0205418617,
-0.0110196574,
-0.0062921508,
0.0073240977,
0.0119906077,
0.0020872445,
0.0215886422,
-0.0365397818,
-0.0443751253,
-0.0734271482,
0.0177007597,
-0.0339842699,
0.0447212756,
0.0446599312,
-0.007374817,
-0.0281212181,
0.0246870555,
-0.0488059819,
-0.0271878317,
-0.0110101439,
0.0315495729,
0.0540168136,
-0.0195540302,
-0.0072069466,
-0.0535552204,
-0.0283549018,
0.0235321131,
0.0443733037,
0.0287277512,
-0.0060624452,
-0.0607969314,
0.0295471177,
0.0031497881,
-0.0452616997,
0.0326169394,
-0.0496476702,
-0.0148907462,
-0.0406331681,
0.0590628646,
0.0769466609,
0.0506492108,
-0.047039248,
0.0138355689,
-0.0185497869,
-0.0217596963,
-0.0327456035,
0.0057937582,
-0.0108861942,
-0.0010839732,
-0.0468083657,
0.0358428545,
0.0423575193,
0.0243900437,
0.017429471,
-0.0766822621,
0.0091875875,
-0.0158952009,
-0.0090068839,
-0.0241430923,
-0.0217802171,
-0.0335797034,
0.0294447411,
-0.0412142389,
-0.0449692532,
0.0431985147,
-0.0779376701,
-0.0098710377,
0.0194375794,
0.0112820053,
-0.0167434197,
0.0410427116,
-0.0079943454,
0.0194379278,
0.0102739623,
-0.0280395038,
-0.0362960137,
0.0206294749,
0.065676719,
-0.0267514028,
0.0107087055,
-0.0619617328,
0.0137033788,
-0.0021486077,
-0.0296962894,
0.0049144109,
-0.0457484871,
0.0075617516,
0.0049844985,
0.0511686765,
-0.0246752463,
0.0180816893,
0.0253119711,
0.022844607,
0.0697096437,
-0.0370449126,
-0.0066217096,
-0.0164567828,
0.0654577836,
0.0397010781,
-0.023964664,
-0.0106296763,
-0.0651691034,
0.001117107,
0.0308953449,
0.0187022183,
0.0392856598,
-0.0153043242,
0.003850983,
0.0168601405,
-0.0197341684,
-0.0366732553,
0.0163867567,
0.0907642767,
-0.0510838889,
-0.0133832106,
0.0981737897,
0.0218535773,
-0.0366211012,
-0.034749683,
-0.0177188609,
0.0429593995,
-0.0323500596,
0.0193758328,
-0.0660049319,
-0.0367903076,
0.0209251568,
0.030977603,
0.0111754779,
-0.0317707993,
0.0112013835,
-0.106576778,
0.0210405141,
0.0298163779,
-0.0521143563,
-0.0204143319,
-0.0241931751,
0.0336527191,
0.0068589337,
-0.0079904255,
0.0153820151,
-0.0329636782,
0.0018735699,
0.0221596938,
-0.0226478651,
-0.0670164898,
0.0201226436,
-0.0262766704,
0.0556007996,
0.086548686,
0.013675984,
0.0073468895,
-0.0795424879,
0.0147912567,
-0.0175706614,
0.0114585413,
0.0076259724,
0.0481508374,
0.0121571459,
0.0091380123,
-0.0172775742,
0.0133679202,
0.0025705637,
0.0089719091,
0.0275736731,
0.0243144501,
0.0124160359,
-0.0470353067,
-0.0064598592,
-0.0252074264,
0.0159129202,
0.055906672,
0.0707617402,
-0.058450222,
-0.0448367074,
-0.0543748811,
-0.0027622636,
-0.0692363232,
-0.0275473762,
0.0056221914,
-0.0424730442,
-0.0214354508,
-0.1322108954,
0.0050156582,
-0.0050481674,
0.0397529416,
0.0209771004,
-0.0277389884,
-0.033553116,
-0.0027976409,
0.0076120975,
-0.0022064785,
-0.0274934452,
0.0477053113,
-0.0687361732,
0.0146851074,
-0.0102919238,
-0.0484750234,
-0.0076679508,
-0.0067289555,
-0.0678126961,
-0.0388704129,
-0.0009694927,
0.0412501059,
0.015872607,
0.0088166986,
-0.021010384,
-0.076931648,
0.0504101887,
0.034085039,
0.0207500923,
0.0132511659,
0.0189381242,
-0.0191650074,
-0.0053616851,
0.027004553,
-0.0175397582,
0.0346641727,
0.0204724241,
0.0244401582,
0.0489742309,
-0.0533894747,
-0.0016976846,
0.0363926068,
0.026904786,
0.0020691438,
0.015191705,
-0.0103859929,
-0.0038095906,
-0.0172452722,
-0.0092288228,
-0.0615220964,
-0.0222183578,
0.0538695194,
0.0513214953,
-0.0095000621,
0.0159793049,
0.019139329,
0.0322378203,
-0.0617868789,
-0.0090202559,
-0.002313812,
0.0692603886,
0.0294263437,
0.0152472807,
-0.0160927232,
0.0000652277,
-0.0118623869,
0.039174106,
-0.0271404907,
0.0467208475,
0.0438550413,
0.0026346056,
0.0153648499,
0.048604928,
-0.0766548291,
-0.0070037721,
-0.0535866134,
-0.0090985103,
0.0433349907,
-0.0013204595,
0.1099317297,
0.0000777187,
0.002099151,
-0.0343132243,
0.0359640978,
0.0221497361,
0.0031252666,
-0.0390124023,
0.0073102452,
0.0215394776,
-0.0140284942,
0.0642694756,
-0.014988319,
-0.0054413434,
-0.0223017707,
-0.0126950191,
0.0051765996,
0.0004304588,
0.0107435938,
-0.0274006836,
0.0258273426,
-0.0315403864,
-0.0212209653,
-0.022925606,
0.0330383815,
0.0119590163,
0.0182277821,
-0.0157095958,
0.0225234553,
0.065071933,
-0.0365672149,
0.0081049902,
-0.0467898697,
-0.0049713496,
0.0198290963,
0.0040918584,
0.0017046223,
-6.047961781e-33,
-0.0368217975,
-0.0015744657,
-0.0142732523,
-0.0015870802,
-0.0537229925,
-0.0143932458,
-0.0602557696,
-0.0150780929,
0.0475469753,
0.0207194239,
-0.031571582,
-0.0313113555,
0.0166400056,
0.0186432078,
0.0288410708,
0.0242310073,
0.0700818598,
-0.002560453,
-0.0670333505,
0.0356472991,
0.0189342592,
0.0116053503,
0.0411347449,
-0.0251095071,
0.0077522313,
-0.0075980411,
-0.0116747972,
-0.0335686095,
0.026753176,
0.0150619624,
0.0224932712,
0.0101336073,
0.0180682112,
-0.0595421195,
-0.0467882045,
0.051390145,
-0.0288314018,
-0.0308034588,
0.0050583915,
-0.0180354994,
-0.0111668222,
-0.0231346898,
0.0432295129,
-0.0151067348,
-0.0021092689,
-0.0121404715,
0.0348664895,
-0.0350158736,
-0.016944427,
-0.0438776277,
-0.0516261011,
0.0371744931,
-0.0066054608,
-0.0380971543,
0.0225421973,
0.0516151637,
-0.0229968056,
0.0181006137,
-0.0473154038,
0.025515534,
0.003113356,
0.0366662182,
0.0425254591,
0.0181797948,
-0.0108272573,
0.0409312733,
-0.0210379958,
0.0449219942,
-0.0484084599,
-0.005178113,
0.037061926,
0.0200885441,
0.0466694497,
0.0612905324,
-0.008115516,
-0.0101539437,
0.0139112836,
0.0524359047,
0.0035176082,
-0.0045481124,
0.0034153522,
0.0417904966,
-0.0221612267,
-0.0229760967,
-0.054109931,
-0.0394195803,
-0.0164455064,
-0.0205370188,
0.0340926647,
-0.0161361899,
-0.019939037,
-0.0234297197,
0.0509976335,
0.0105861127,
-0.0314148553,
-0.0322288163,
-0.079833664,
0.0572423115,
-0.0411454588,
0.0044157677,
-0.0407202169,
-0.0220648553,
0.0594119057,
0.0483552665,
0.0055515626,
-0.0186640788,
0.0338929445,
0.0373403244,
-0.0690450668,
-0.0096484087,
-0.0039893347,
0.0136772972,
0.0081895869,
-0.0323763117,
0.0316657946,
-0.0179438144,
-0.0076230126,
0.0395621695,
0.0218729731,
-0.0317128748,
-0.0178680494,
-0.0303523466,
0.00179505,
-0.0177624039,
-0.0596956722,
0.0157390628,
-0.0377097987,
-0.0262593962,
0.0008996747,
-0.0260725133,
-0.0177077856,
-0.0041451761,
2.563e-7,
0.0197437312,
0.0515270904,
0.0128714163,
0.0043555787,
0.027964972,
0.0207162797,
-0.0322590582,
0.0532056242,
0.0257664341,
-0.0008921106,
0.0185870901,
0.0173471738,
0.1118485928,
0.0042868052,
-0.0865235105,
-0.0171306934,
-0.0797473043,
0.0203094408,
-0.0463626906,
-0.0152426185,
0.0625349656,
0.0050443979,
-0.0129048266,
-0.0214299057,
0.0457009301,
-0.0358143039,
0.0635982603,
-0.0122078145,
0.0152141759,
0.0201220345,
0.0545804873,
-0.0606134869,
-0.0296257846,
0.0328199267,
-0.0034364553,
-0.0219790004,
0.0774502531,
0.0916757509,
0.0181763303,
0.0398299098,
-0.0069405427,
-0.0074869343,
0.0155062545,
-0.0649445429,
0.0755014047,
0.0051028049,
0.0171516072,
-0.051833,
-0.0738984346,
-0.0230709687,
0.019045053,
-0.0101860091,
-0.0142641291,
0.0392265283,
0.0187739376,
0.049554348,
-0.0367676616,
-0.0612698048,
-0.0324358754,
-0.0183196478,
-0.0172839668,
-0.0572385937,
-0.0654486418,
-0.006530636,
-0.0063783266,
-0.0526878946,
0.022539461,
2.250852654e-34,
0.0250614285,
-0.0451304689,
0.0438353457,
-0.0079473313,
0.0267088655,
0.0039725639,
-0.0001478922,
0.0093093961,
0.0000645007,
-0.0908892453,
0.0030172304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13354v1 | On the Impact of Language Selection for Training and Evaluating Programming Language Models | 2023-08-25T12:57:59 | 2023-08-25T12:57:59 | Jonathan Katzy, Maliheh Izadi, Arie van Deursen | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PL | The recent advancements in Transformer-based Language Models have
demonstrated significant potential in enhancing the multilingual capabilities
of these models. The remarkable progress made in this domain not only applies
to natural language tasks but also extends to the domain of programming
languages. Despite the ability of these models to learn from multiple
languages, evaluations typically focus on particular combinations of the same
languages. In this study, we evaluate the similarity of programming languages
by analyzing their representations using a CodeBERT-based model. Our
experiments reveal that token representation in languages such as C++, Python,
and Java exhibit proximity to one another, whereas the same tokens in languages
such as Mathematica and R display significant dissimilarity. Our findings
suggest that this phenomenon can potentially result in performance challenges
when dealing with diverse languages. Thus, we recommend using our similarity
measure to select a diverse set of programming languages when training and
evaluating future models. | [
0.0026896116,
0.0586711615,
-0.043303296,
0.0475306734,
-0.0457617603,
0.0269186161,
0.008086253,
0.0195045397,
-0.0219981559,
-0.0378669202,
-0.0343899243,
0.0027192235,
-0.011964459,
0.0252730977,
0.0424090959,
-0.0496130884,
0.0795207396,
-0.0583048649,
-0.0438707508,
0.0130237043,
-0.0111992992,
0.0182044674,
0.0020682355,
0.0987323746,
-0.0022620114,
-0.0151675344,
0.0294451714,
-0.0145143149,
-0.0088852718,
-0.0087856473,
0.0011943169,
0.0211487077,
0.0156885646,
0.0437514745,
0.0000017846,
-0.0326195955,
-0.0135609331,
0.0092482464,
0.0342171267,
-0.0179788377,
0.0594259202,
-0.031090267,
0.0166083071,
0.0398551747,
-0.0101941107,
-0.0561774224,
0.070961833,
-0.0422117822,
0.0327920057,
0.0393199623,
0.0017185325,
-0.0166660715,
0.0014579141,
0.0200662296,
-0.0295689311,
0.008593753,
0.0022677495,
0.0277400557,
0.0043551209,
-0.0054622777,
-0.0306315888,
-0.011491389,
0.000536338,
0.0012159718,
-0.0008455531,
0.0280414615,
-0.0877975896,
-0.0181257911,
0.0148003995,
-0.0056972783,
-0.0702023506,
-0.0847816542,
0.0025928223,
0.0057871924,
-0.0072764773,
0.0050932756,
-0.0471889302,
0.0266189594,
0.014292486,
0.0141209168,
0.0310720075,
-0.003163107,
0.007605982,
-0.0293065235,
-0.0346152112,
0.056334842,
0.0381903127,
-0.0179735329,
-0.0118407803,
-0.0048281229,
0.0082993321,
-0.0539044775,
0.0021601978,
0.0170863103,
-0.0344440788,
0.0081400098,
-0.0256697275,
-0.0273003299,
0.0319962464,
-0.0367248058,
0.0093771359,
0.0597021803,
-0.0240047239,
0.0170123857,
-0.0788936615,
0.1098811477,
0.0253352337,
0.0282121617,
-0.0352087617,
-0.0334077552,
-0.0738605335,
-0.0350281037,
-0.0582592227,
0.0495560132,
0.0375289395,
0.0049986676,
-0.0324756131,
0.0527325571,
-0.0150707019,
0.0153891724,
-0.0138397515,
-0.0598931536,
-0.0293731336,
0.0375389382,
0.0133550735,
0.0182745792,
-0.0264267586,
-0.0258765407,
-0.0159037374,
-0.0627146065,
0.0100900633,
0.0277970377,
-0.0471773744,
-0.0485806353,
-0.0076899542,
0.0956153944,
0.0080034696,
0.0190082546,
0.0057722931,
0.0214010309,
0.0230413247,
-0.0046931426,
0.0109484689,
-0.1134445816,
-0.0072183702,
0.0657429248,
0.0288420375,
-0.0549313128,
-0.017650377,
0.0019595821,
0.0137558142,
0.0613439791,
-0.020370556,
0.0111252628,
0.0038929752,
-0.0254988968,
-0.0258807894,
0.0416764617,
-0.0018326541,
-0.0032846301,
0.0345999189,
-0.0646677241,
0.0270260572,
0.031173341,
-0.0592768975,
-0.0138492985,
-0.0218229089,
0.0260192417,
0.0595768988,
-0.0100109167,
0.0378515944,
0.0578400716,
-0.0220995508,
0.0038989456,
-0.0225864705,
0.068195425,
0.0309887603,
0.0428130291,
0.0713644102,
0.0075420323,
0.0039846567,
-0.0104579618,
-0.0586603954,
0.0185619127,
0.0106800236,
0.0281598065,
-0.0239842627,
0.0406222902,
0.004188797,
-0.0334654152,
-0.0308859274,
-0.0268758293,
0.0265243929,
-0.0543214753,
0.0599008836,
0.015914686,
-0.0312925465,
0.0882277265,
0.0195268132,
-0.0594971664,
-0.0345209986,
-0.0397959948,
-0.0166366864,
0.0179032683,
0.0197493248,
-0.0560378805,
-0.0031930683,
-0.0129390815,
-0.0023967789,
-0.0048979213,
0.071825929,
-0.0064497585,
0.0106552374,
-0.0438389592,
-0.0009792752,
-0.0252660122,
0.010906239,
0.0529413633,
0.0020088898,
0.018107364,
0.0015350425,
-0.0336717628,
-0.031384062,
0.0363397002,
-0.0152480733,
0.0152570661,
-0.0229000524,
-0.0078043379,
0.0118740993,
-0.0418253914,
-0.0402727015,
0.0363169983,
0.023115864,
-0.0329393931,
-0.0015732882,
0.0210467391,
-0.0474187434,
0.0004841618,
0.0563477539,
-0.0510541126,
-0.0046299947,
0.037127804,
0.0043396852,
-0.0088920174,
0.085087426,
-0.0334659927,
0.0742001608,
0.0112608559,
0.0667317882,
-0.0580158569,
-0.0336428992,
-0.0199157074,
0.0473986827,
0.0282506328,
0.0574957281,
-0.0088548362,
0.0164909661,
0.0472203046,
0.0035826797,
-0.0474316962,
0.0161439888,
-0.0304656625,
0.0381392911,
0.0488109551,
0.0133685796,
-0.0085254293,
-0.0389702171,
-0.0564293377,
-0.0288573094,
-0.0246171393,
0.0127722416,
0.020896012,
0.0097024785,
0.0141012119,
-0.0153087089,
-0.0227156412,
-0.0364323333,
-0.01989449,
0.0418186113,
0.0306416415,
-0.035918992,
-0.071787186,
-0.0441777483,
-0.034583617,
-0.0490473397,
0.1027637944,
-0.0277364943,
-0.0092129679,
-0.0608650707,
0.045925308,
-0.0054396321,
0.0089021316,
-0.0361574143,
-0.0364729241,
0.0257034395,
-0.0020159774,
0.0441235229,
0.0258755498,
-0.0110491076,
-0.011485301,
0.0408516116,
0.0236597974,
-0.0582767278,
-0.0354029126,
0.0130856177,
-0.0382365771,
-0.0017243095,
-0.0592990369,
0.0158091169,
0.063931331,
-0.0267835651,
0.0051052296,
-0.0463438891,
0.0023064523,
-0.0363901593,
-0.0053038229,
-0.0040783542,
-0.0171579793,
0.0026269637,
0.0277129132,
-0.0155644882,
-0.0781256407,
0.0741991624,
-0.0444458276,
-0.0084679862,
-0.0518831126,
-0.0054149823,
-0.0603504479,
0.0491392538,
0.0216097441,
0.0150691355,
-0.0163122471,
-0.0495198816,
-0.0372034125,
0.0233726483,
0.0045188991,
-0.0201962683,
0.0751726776,
-0.0019550459,
0.0045053279,
0.0145505127,
-0.0363820083,
-0.0334914066,
0.0303482637,
-0.0082077598,
0.0392795615,
0.0504390486,
-0.0109797046,
-0.015716115,
0.0362337679,
0.0067059547,
0.0439200439,
0.0277274009,
-0.0239748452,
-0.0072001126,
-0.0296565667,
-0.0225055423,
-0.0347662121,
0.0053429813,
-0.0232453924,
0.0097856624,
-0.0080172289,
0.039174065,
-0.0020648113,
-0.0656197071,
0.0112396851,
0.0421232805,
-0.0605742522,
-0.0581741519,
0.0117602535,
0.0364128016,
-0.0322494507,
-0.0281416867,
0.0803678483,
0.0264745466,
-0.0343499109,
0.0374655761,
-0.0582443997,
0.0191155989,
0.0696661323,
0.0289460644,
-0.055720035,
-0.0161849763,
-0.0254201051,
-0.0043476559,
0.0155427624,
-0.0036333234,
0.0284460727,
-0.0855761617,
-0.0022021427,
0.0002424998,
-0.0690133646,
-0.0637900904,
-0.0511751957,
-0.0086248713,
-0.0322154351,
0.0067543364,
0.0164971538,
-0.0342663303,
0.0151860295,
0.0362672769,
-0.0386462212,
-0.0220354442,
0.0131792119,
-0.0296422075,
-0.0074346992,
0.0679765195,
-0.0002027335,
-0.0268879328,
-0.0233213454,
0.0121092265,
0.0050038681,
0.0212963913,
-0.0066721276,
0.0039633387,
0.0291129518,
-0.0331198461,
0.0311608054,
-0.0251139775,
-0.0401039645,
-0.0302895252,
0.0080083683,
0.0690127611,
-0.0088566365,
-0.0348553732,
-0.0077693244,
-0.0193439666,
-0.0297410358,
0.0519128256,
0.0430541299,
-0.0095712831,
-0.0522991456,
-0.0650549158,
-0.0004603155,
-0.0077234204,
-0.0242302921,
-0.0368058123,
0.0076735993,
-0.0232732203,
-0.0185445528,
0.0057019703,
0.0344242267,
0.0205556396,
-0.0056950208,
0.0038471057,
0.0270966683,
-0.0155171296,
-0.0531791225,
0.0218033176,
-0.0063289278,
0.0349197127,
-0.0683125332,
-0.0383359008,
0.0121409381,
-0.0057661165,
-0.0525410958,
-0.0366491824,
-0.0991840288,
-0.0413124226,
-0.00707873,
0.0479771905,
0.0218661651,
-0.0008102176,
0.0037710527,
-0.0130983545,
-0.0581899248,
0.0267796535,
-0.0207174681,
-0.0149898818,
0.0263179801,
-0.0326623954,
0.0051752082,
0.0011638039,
-0.0464227982,
-0.0043620281,
0.0383087024,
0.0157269724,
-0.0309871472,
-0.0033339995,
0.0264909677,
0.0262943637,
0.0140207186,
0.0278126076,
-0.0287666861,
-0.0143920565,
-0.0181272235,
0.0010075995,
-0.0048661227,
-0.025577398,
0.0087328237,
-0.004347384,
0.0284709465,
0.0337996334,
-0.0259099267,
-0.0344810151,
0.0177996829,
-0.0127904871,
0.0884623006,
0.0264975429,
0.0690763816,
0.0313005075,
0.0054685511,
-0.0152556458,
-0.0265561864,
-0.0011942843,
0.0324066468,
-0.0642719492,
0.0192083232,
0.0095882853,
0.03947616,
0.0211978406,
0.0292363595,
-0.0451618619,
-0.0709216297,
-0.0035550178,
0.0017759944,
0.0376913212,
-0.0079536727,
0.0335050263,
-0.027538212,
0.0179490615,
-0.0096400175,
0.0284607559,
0.0331716463,
-0.0166728143,
0.0168270711,
0.0259241629,
-0.0131059419,
-0.0439908616,
0.1015590429,
-0.0210323278,
-0.0055397223,
-0.0024015878,
-0.0384654216,
-0.0191517137,
0.0253353603,
0.0591031462,
0.009466989,
-0.0220554844,
-0.0338922702,
-0.0434679165,
-0.0684373528,
-0.0011695607,
0.0340868458,
0.0358583331,
0.0065841349,
0.0389251001,
0.1017915457,
0.0118991686,
-0.0290342756,
-0.0196063779,
0.0087814946,
0.0491659157,
-0.0244445093,
-0.0259351432,
-4.831328434e-33,
-0.0313627161,
0.0188762117,
-0.0123575218,
0.0081515312,
0.0219958089,
0.0093556754,
-0.0247016419,
0.0153194787,
-0.0330315568,
-0.0214299411,
0.0297290701,
0.0065987087,
-0.0009580229,
-0.0360977352,
0.0510465913,
0.0153322695,
0.0417780206,
0.0452752598,
-0.0415120535,
0.0006065388,
0.0130866142,
0.0226230323,
0.0798313618,
-0.0534722134,
-0.0157718509,
-0.0090481844,
0.0543377213,
-0.0267804768,
0.0397722647,
0.0849978551,
0.0197846983,
0.0445264876,
0.0129263746,
-0.0612419918,
-0.0551735759,
-0.0446881503,
-0.0220990535,
-0.0441550985,
0.0339698344,
0.0453508794,
0.0502685606,
-0.0318280235,
0.0591888465,
-0.0177376419,
-0.0225886554,
0.0130913584,
0.0352046341,
0.0036539538,
-0.0147767263,
-0.0052151517,
-0.0927415863,
0.0160941668,
-0.0276178531,
0.0253140535,
0.0254483838,
0.0338629857,
-0.0245000236,
0.0473502241,
-0.0188338123,
0.0363885388,
-0.0119982455,
0.0648890361,
0.0975605771,
0.0139941806,
0.0070198891,
0.0430067368,
0.0540902466,
-0.0098154442,
0.0264222194,
0.0223036986,
0.0689945146,
0.0237462819,
0.0479821041,
0.0077298651,
0.0401238762,
-0.0135407001,
-0.0268961377,
0.0039079539,
0.0341373719,
0.0254579987,
-0.0001162314,
0.0387372337,
-0.017484311,
-0.0201721154,
-0.0248870384,
-0.0041351025,
-0.0120239463,
-0.0522842929,
0.0331955105,
-0.0374593362,
-0.0050970102,
0.0372048803,
0.0317998864,
-0.0290536024,
-0.0378624387,
0.0114886649,
-0.0263727605,
0.0450493544,
-0.0127567975,
0.0492284782,
-0.0225648861,
-0.0570917353,
-0.0086872829,
-0.0119408909,
0.0970373899,
0.0082202945,
0.032761991,
-0.024884304,
-0.0745705366,
-0.0022125361,
-0.022573404,
-0.0456966273,
-0.0099960137,
0.0348077007,
0.0270167477,
0.0059762062,
0.0198150557,
-0.0149103086,
0.0086830463,
-0.0693493783,
-0.0557934865,
-0.0003820395,
0.0033582547,
0.0251491219,
-0.0168150626,
-0.0458080992,
-0.0791320279,
0.058309786,
0.0283891074,
-0.0279397871,
-0.0507866666,
0.026116902,
2.43e-7,
0.0498053357,
0.0370503478,
0.0101215737,
0.0272291545,
-0.0109198699,
0.014075256,
-0.0326656438,
0.0125760976,
0.0207435396,
0.0429079421,
-0.0607268587,
0.003441313,
0.0111928498,
0.0559274368,
-0.0520577654,
0.015258614,
-0.0650555864,
0.0090122307,
-0.0617984831,
0.0350772403,
0.0428759605,
0.0941220522,
-0.0140135577,
0.020672515,
-0.040283531,
-0.034302976,
0.0045853849,
-0.0263470188,
0.0446602888,
0.0386983529,
-0.0409636088,
0.013632142,
0.0241567455,
0.0447010919,
-0.0108480072,
-0.0062301699,
0.0551824234,
0.0021026074,
-0.0100859189,
0.0530985817,
0.0340523534,
-0.027682621,
-0.0272744391,
-0.1150856614,
0.025210306,
-0.013709248,
0.0138810771,
-0.0244088192,
-0.0472520143,
0.05414965,
0.0048840423,
-0.0087822024,
-0.0130120451,
0.0520636812,
0.0304093454,
-0.0111864572,
-0.0225276705,
-0.0101125287,
-0.0368831493,
0.0105900215,
-0.0187236164,
-0.0470566414,
-0.0487742573,
0.0071886783,
0.0342668258,
0.0033589541,
0.0225914083,
2.505224122e-34,
0.0340799913,
0.005754678,
0.0357435532,
0.0229655914,
0.0249516107,
-0.0329911001,
0.0048364694,
0.0381991342,
-0.041248735,
-0.005520713,
-0.0205194931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13576v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13576v1 | An Ensemble Approach to Personalized Real Time Predictive Writing for Experts | 2023-08-25T12:45:46 | 2023-08-25T12:45:46 | Sourav Prosad, Viswa Datha Polavarapu, Shrutendra Harsola | cs.CL | cs.CL | Completing a sentence, phrase or word after typing few words / characters is
very helpful for Intuit financial experts, while taking notes or having a live
chat with users, since they need to write complex financial concepts more
efficiently and accurately many times in a day. In this paper, we tie together
different approaches like large language models, traditional Markov Models and
char level models to create an end-to-end system to provide personalised
sentence/word auto-complete suggestions to experts, under strict latency
constraints. Proposed system can auto-complete sentences, phrases or words
while writing with personalisation and can be trained with very less data and
resources with good efficiency. Our proposed system is not only efficient and
personalized but also robust as it leverages multiple machine learning
techniques along with transfer learning approach to fine tune large language
model with Intuit specific data. This ensures that even in cases of rare or
unusual phrases, the system can provide relevant auto-complete suggestions in
near real time. Survey has showed that this system saves expert note-taking
time and boosts expert confidence in their communication with teammates and
clients. Since enabling this predictive writing feature for QBLive experts,
more than a million keystrokes have been saved based on these suggestions. We
have done comparative study for our ensemble choice. Moreover this feature can
be integrated with any product which has writing facility within a very short
period of time. | [
0.0448670797,
0.0090624886,
-0.0099473968,
-0.037143331,
-0.0308386777,
-0.0148327053,
0.0378129855,
0.0216244552,
0.0229272023,
-0.0363170728,
0.01104395,
-0.0366671421,
0.0233945437,
0.0716105476,
0.0197313279,
-0.0487637296,
0.0056115105,
-0.0215079915,
-0.0029006172,
-0.0149880704,
0.0269821752,
0.0085175373,
-0.0092469258,
0.0671333894,
0.0074869785,
-0.0138565889,
-0.0228907149,
-0.037374042,
0.0047088438,
0.0204695053,
-0.0000190992,
0.0771105886,
-0.0095896404,
0.0143179866,
0.0000018626,
-0.0358640291,
-0.0301211439,
-0.0125135137,
-0.0312803984,
-0.0143927364,
0.017744774,
0.0393252596,
0.0220927764,
0.0314574502,
-0.0424926914,
0.0660420433,
0.0644729659,
0.0451044291,
0.0293410309,
0.0545681305,
-0.0282834377,
0.0194077753,
0.030334089,
-0.0223576482,
0.019004155,
-0.049190063,
0.0170210116,
0.0082591334,
-0.0059713661,
-0.0297437925,
0.0026410618,
0.0520398356,
-0.0156431589,
-0.0391254611,
0.0973466188,
0.0168792866,
-0.0131359193,
0.0044585476,
-0.0464085676,
0.0493781604,
-0.0165226758,
0.0213229507,
0.0246382616,
-0.0338816419,
0.0086938171,
0.0257990342,
-0.0130693614,
0.0005396965,
-0.0539796241,
-0.0127063058,
-0.0254916549,
0.0143585121,
0.0060827304,
0.0033723826,
0.013639275,
0.0249266364,
0.0133314785,
-0.0222957414,
0.0207361579,
0.0276893526,
0.0021989348,
-0.079331778,
0.0527621694,
0.0356239453,
-0.020164704,
-0.0150541868,
-0.0624539852,
-0.0461166129,
-0.0261762887,
-0.0450431593,
0.0721549541,
0.0220762566,
0.0367602818,
0.0332569331,
-0.0324818119,
-0.0051581208,
0.0171582401,
-0.0667408258,
-0.0093823951,
0.0022086911,
-0.0774631873,
-0.0126403635,
-0.0318229459,
0.0790344477,
-0.0376365669,
-0.0532308929,
-0.0722275749,
0.0224055778,
0.0134322373,
0.0094898585,
0.0494932309,
0.0290650055,
-0.0451100133,
-0.0232768301,
-0.0077143926,
-0.0085571287,
-0.0289671216,
0.0132499142,
0.0046017459,
-0.0242379829,
0.0460826047,
0.0327895842,
-0.0041733915,
-0.0147402128,
0.0109503623,
0.0432634689,
-0.0282215383,
-0.0244867168,
0.0056045544,
-0.0253346469,
-0.0336048082,
-0.0134398295,
-0.0372667089,
-0.051846046,
-0.0051444373,
0.0193683002,
-0.0437682681,
-0.0149116088,
0.025512103,
0.0203572977,
0.0098755369,
0.0456358194,
-0.0089871362,
-0.0029141405,
0.0460277796,
-0.041691605,
-0.0083502252,
-0.0020734463,
0.0468942598,
0.0585769713,
0.0095537519,
-0.0166956019,
0.0684601739,
0.0598601997,
-0.0330143832,
-0.0457963832,
-0.0194467288,
0.0102096163,
-0.0163484253,
0.0362896807,
-0.0053508277,
0.0247969087,
0.0042087617,
0.0558527745,
0.1008081362,
0.0269955322,
0.0503916293,
0.0546579137,
0.0066536916,
0.0416251868,
0.0122574707,
-0.0459993072,
-0.0076484056,
0.0679623187,
-0.0457177311,
0.0211672559,
0.028053863,
0.0028696039,
-0.0101172449,
-0.0461048558,
-0.0034989812,
-0.016668411,
-0.0496086814,
0.0094258543,
0.0610007942,
-0.0372060686,
-0.0631385148,
0.0306122769,
-0.0062869983,
-0.0412231274,
-0.0178976301,
-0.0177689977,
0.0212162323,
0.1328855455,
0.0275766179,
-0.0342972614,
0.0275360588,
-0.0487241894,
-0.0347545184,
0.0199447535,
0.0137167061,
0.0144037129,
-0.015252973,
-0.0717187971,
-0.0229665115,
0.0326171555,
-0.0175603051,
0.0300545897,
0.0023955563,
0.0483390279,
-0.00303775,
0.0378868729,
-0.0160267726,
0.024872208,
-0.0433263555,
-0.0462104417,
0.0391580462,
0.018933801,
-0.0235215146,
0.0005849501,
-0.0071687978,
-0.0004427197,
-0.0056470083,
-0.0326023996,
-0.0526777431,
0.0129369255,
-0.0506834462,
0.0063735778,
0.014407495,
-0.0253491774,
0.0143135265,
0.0011960893,
0.0066158529,
-0.0508036613,
-0.0601431876,
-0.0276722927,
0.0058503039,
-0.0329350568,
-0.0084614614,
0.0160594489,
0.0159443486,
-0.0179804415,
0.0360594839,
0.0042541525,
0.0118487682,
-0.0241991654,
-0.0156090269,
0.0119867064,
-0.058967188,
0.0052100192,
-0.008692869,
0.0023687379,
0.0577732734,
0.0299923588,
-0.0139827142,
-0.0151481191,
-0.0318326801,
-0.0963617563,
0.0006661015,
0.0148279602,
-0.0047038919,
0.0059682876,
0.0208328012,
-0.0072513614,
-0.030203579,
-0.0563990399,
0.0055150869,
0.0053595235,
-0.0254706834,
0.0518084243,
-0.0192331839,
-0.0029462022,
-0.0394474827,
-0.0153108994,
-0.0023031419,
0.0247501731,
0.0511248335,
-0.0856942385,
-0.0303470455,
-0.0285457242,
0.0285047498,
0.0011055411,
0.011605829,
0.0088108769,
-0.0218053516,
-0.0076690177,
0.0180923566,
0.0766267926,
0.0368432924,
0.0313323289,
0.0021687695,
0.0055914475,
-0.0003298566,
0.0185926333,
-0.0092184199,
0.0312597491,
0.0061769579,
-0.0073886826,
-0.0130061377,
0.0254734438,
0.0090812631,
-0.0033822001,
-0.0736780092,
0.01157704,
0.0198437348,
-0.0136886826,
-0.0355839096,
0.0146095697,
-0.0517446212,
0.0143359993,
0.0091506196,
-0.0513727926,
0.0413282029,
-0.0080252802,
-0.0225985348,
0.0044325036,
-0.0686796606,
-0.0116565339,
0.0582010336,
-0.0431736968,
-0.0084016081,
-0.0427877679,
-0.0252773184,
-0.0446213372,
-0.007878121,
0.0473928787,
-0.0174690392,
0.0042985245,
0.0042156051,
0.0225289781,
0.008315064,
-0.0204404928,
-0.018067224,
-0.0690256059,
-0.071009323,
0.0200840551,
0.0628503412,
-0.0763906017,
-0.0406867303,
0.0299661607,
0.0137461871,
0.0176182669,
-0.031160567,
-0.0234587919,
-0.022992624,
-0.0216656346,
0.0574693717,
-0.0121201444,
-0.0377971791,
-0.0543680191,
0.0347498171,
0.0038627542,
0.0162727349,
0.0037909041,
-0.0206401628,
-0.0494390614,
-0.0003919484,
-0.0687652826,
-0.0403112285,
0.0177821238,
0.0096938089,
-0.0272468813,
0.0091086552,
0.086599946,
-0.0126991952,
-0.0392963625,
-0.0217403136,
0.0139475036,
0.0027666609,
-0.0163973439,
0.0882338136,
-0.0640967637,
-0.0300690755,
0.0189404897,
0.0556611381,
0.0198487639,
-0.0389551185,
-0.0236117207,
-0.081624262,
0.027513111,
-0.0059189689,
-0.0159965418,
-0.0219756216,
0.0104831886,
-0.0100950142,
-0.0061773951,
-0.0081349816,
-0.0001978622,
-0.0111689316,
0.019190466,
0.0348830409,
-0.0845659375,
-0.0113013694,
0.0099796122,
-0.0053252941,
0.0116050551,
0.0898476914,
0.0488698035,
-0.0051211617,
-0.0139346132,
-0.0629719868,
0.0577502996,
0.0239145774,
0.0103658028,
0.0653021932,
-0.0193488803,
0.0024851973,
-0.0312401168,
0.0462249257,
-0.0221443679,
0.0414513685,
0.0555891618,
0.0226712413,
-0.0221754313,
-0.0311683659,
-0.0186097641,
0.0016325449,
0.0456055887,
0.0538846888,
-0.0108303195,
-0.1105136424,
-0.0591007248,
-0.0184642449,
-0.0051332195,
-0.070368275,
0.0095859356,
-0.0157741234,
0.0044773039,
-0.0170844905,
-0.1042829156,
-0.0610022359,
0.0567466952,
0.0755692199,
0.0077180504,
0.0664223358,
0.0123398695,
0.0222092345,
-0.0334841013,
-0.0134724891,
-0.0219563767,
0.0459712744,
-0.078450188,
-0.0004559181,
-0.0204334874,
-0.0691763163,
-0.0209480654,
-0.0103348643,
-0.0507796668,
-0.0548909344,
0.0097272238,
0.0765034929,
0.0202583782,
0.006555405,
-0.0156548414,
-0.0979368165,
0.0500807799,
0.0510196611,
-0.0100662904,
-0.002761164,
0.0340094343,
-0.0056339558,
-0.0293147955,
0.0287954863,
-0.0277820677,
-0.0123755308,
-0.0136039993,
0.0235159844,
-0.0035287121,
-0.0755775943,
-0.0151930992,
0.0040578581,
-0.0036306167,
-0.0235698875,
-0.0280794185,
-0.0203847308,
0.0173484348,
0.0220290665,
0.0082898727,
-0.0599186011,
0.0066012247,
0.0078792684,
-0.0109020546,
0.0326126441,
-0.0238217432,
-0.0034264396,
-0.0668126643,
-0.0022088396,
0.035126809,
0.0018641769,
0.0524594672,
0.054983303,
-0.0042347619,
-0.0072748661,
0.0300269444,
0.037889421,
0.0190365799,
0.017817745,
0.0127117261,
0.0132992398,
0.011549864,
0.0083116582,
0.0061286767,
-0.0568492115,
-0.0514730848,
-0.0249611381,
0.0661815703,
0.0527186096,
-0.0089762807,
-0.0196167193,
-0.0530450866,
0.0103065232,
-0.0428984612,
0.0739143565,
0.0117594227,
0.0181716569,
-0.039289996,
-0.0132557331,
-0.032348197,
-0.0190407671,
0.0905149877,
-0.0206207838,
0.0091453968,
0.0055868914,
-0.0300358646,
-0.0693108141,
0.0340545848,
0.0249585118,
0.0276370607,
-0.0069916793,
-0.0007060083,
-0.0392361805,
-0.0095096733,
0.0770545155,
-0.0327642113,
-0.0442246571,
-0.0284687839,
0.0471027941,
0.0429262631,
-0.0096081737,
0.0126375258,
-0.0513722487,
0.0568298548,
-0.0170334242,
0.0096202716,
-0.0416853353,
-5.679539811e-33,
-0.0102153253,
-0.052692201,
0.0243223887,
0.0115988152,
0.0278553627,
0.0030270396,
0.0138353044,
0.0193689615,
0.051497791,
0.0135942074,
-0.0565490834,
0.010768502,
0.0239337832,
0.0220072959,
0.0319305398,
0.0439478941,
0.0648345873,
-0.0053350599,
-0.0056330045,
0.0217881817,
0.0535029657,
0.088279739,
0.0611662716,
-0.0563755929,
0.0332515202,
-0.039010521,
-0.0075360122,
-0.0153120849,
0.01580205,
0.0312324017,
-0.0031310981,
0.0332082994,
-0.0078934059,
-0.0324481763,
-0.0091775525,
0.0378037319,
0.0095654484,
-0.0393231288,
-0.0060247621,
-0.0061904555,
0.0048492556,
-0.0188417882,
0.0400008,
-0.0350307301,
-0.0108752949,
-0.0010297844,
0.0746405721,
-0.0103485454,
-0.0480723158,
-0.0668519661,
-0.0448937528,
0.0323299021,
0.0148439771,
0.0031649971,
0.0086931679,
0.0472057536,
-0.005296899,
-0.067616947,
-0.0336478502,
0.0237913337,
0.0237506963,
0.0265060514,
0.0342856087,
0.0370880589,
-0.0041007181,
0.0334697403,
0.0089478996,
0.0054388801,
-0.012193297,
0.0025038165,
0.0019896126,
0.0641169176,
0.0653882027,
0.0611329414,
0.0166551284,
-0.026742056,
0.0125008961,
0.0404656194,
0.0524922572,
-0.0388820432,
0.0284288432,
-0.0039787092,
-0.0541657507,
-0.0096289767,
0.0092271073,
0.0052218088,
0.0059597464,
-0.0489547327,
0.0438927487,
0.0058638249,
-0.0007498362,
0.006132633,
0.0214151535,
-0.0113290753,
-0.0506891534,
-0.0400502197,
-0.0058114971,
0.0300791971,
0.0097390469,
0.0005727584,
-0.0587882288,
-0.0160703957,
-0.0437189937,
-0.0052000904,
0.0046895249,
0.0261549167,
0.0014010316,
0.012560077,
-0.0574278571,
0.0050222822,
0.0290048867,
0.0247453973,
0.0219357815,
0.0241750125,
0.0315254703,
0.0010605558,
-0.0162580628,
0.0395957008,
-0.0289560631,
-0.0015840658,
-0.0114643769,
-0.0655577108,
0.0276300926,
0.0131569458,
-0.0106044663,
0.0173877366,
-0.0356150754,
0.0241530519,
0.0388763398,
0.0156898126,
-0.0086368667,
0.0073187654,
2.558e-7,
0.0448426642,
0.0851932541,
-0.018235486,
-0.0287260748,
-0.0251068734,
0.0408342816,
0.0246517323,
0.0192122813,
-0.0234297831,
0.0506164618,
0.0411723144,
0.0096963011,
0.068519868,
-0.0175183285,
-0.0952956751,
-0.102858983,
-0.0782269686,
0.0692230985,
-0.0480666347,
0.0235840417,
0.0166700184,
0.0494168811,
0.0500023291,
-0.0162476245,
0.0232902691,
-0.0632157326,
0.0554156601,
-0.0382030345,
0.0140217086,
-0.0016529592,
0.0787375495,
-0.0057402933,
-0.0432369784,
0.0432914272,
-0.0213923305,
-0.009386179,
0.0447691232,
0.0513343401,
-0.0389117822,
0.0451091938,
0.015606638,
-0.0002264565,
-0.0022774935,
-0.0129564572,
0.0299926046,
-0.0433848165,
-0.0013264786,
-0.0510167591,
-0.0201754179,
-0.0315585695,
0.0349397212,
0.0219006818,
0.0340788104,
0.0064027486,
0.0093636196,
-0.0103676012,
-0.0046535647,
-0.0476848967,
-0.0103111165,
0.0217490401,
-0.0319721065,
0.015578148,
-0.0721016303,
-0.0136994701,
0.0193900149,
-0.0700261891,
0.0107077742,
2.18682839e-34,
0.0064555956,
0.0157958381,
-0.0073762834,
0.0368394516,
0.0113227274,
0.0061962418,
0.0413402207,
0.0493828729,
0.0595479272,
-0.0796101168,
-0.0436856747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13345v1 | Decoupled Structure for Improved Adaptability of End-to-End Models | 2023-08-25T12:31:12 | 2023-08-25T12:31:12 | Keqi Deng, Philip C. Woodland | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Although end-to-end (E2E) trainable automatic speech recognition (ASR) has
shown great success by jointly learning acoustic and linguistic information, it
still suffers from the effect of domain shifts, thus limiting potential
applications. The E2E ASR model implicitly learns an internal language model
(LM) which characterises the training distribution of the source domain, and
the E2E trainable nature makes the internal LM difficult to adapt to the target
domain with text-only data To solve this problem, this paper proposes decoupled
structures for attention-based encoder-decoder (Decoupled-AED) and neural
transducer (Decoupled-Transducer) models, which can achieve flexible domain
adaptation in both offline and online scenarios while maintaining robust
intra-domain performance. To this end, the acoustic and linguistic parts of the
E2E model decoder (or prediction network) are decoupled, making the linguistic
component (i.e. internal LM) replaceable. When encountering a domain shift, the
internal LM can be directly replaced during inference by a target-domain LM,
without re-training or using domain-specific paired speech-text data.
Experiments for E2E ASR models trained on the LibriSpeech-100h corpus showed
that the proposed decoupled structure gave 15.1% and 17.2% relative word error
rate reductions on the TED-LIUM 2 and AESRC2020 corpora while still maintaining
performance on intra-domain data. | [
-0.0107468562,
0.0694433302,
0.010517139,
0.0486605614,
0.0051503577,
-0.0137799578,
0.0266604684,
-0.036658112,
-0.0340684578,
-0.0354945362,
-0.0524645224,
-0.0184002277,
0.0390815064,
0.0473162867,
0.0222588442,
-0.0261239149,
0.0102902325,
-0.0431932397,
-0.0055677574,
-0.0049996781,
-0.0012526236,
-0.0113346297,
-0.0138313128,
0.0311280098,
0.0508264974,
0.0055792937,
-0.0339931585,
0.0103731574,
-0.0130197704,
0.0101152677,
0.0023305761,
-0.0105023105,
0.0336885713,
0.014286479,
0.0000023985,
-0.0089788903,
-0.0501903221,
-0.0210598111,
-0.0440842919,
-0.0341837145,
-0.0007535926,
-0.0263322722,
0.0074426066,
0.0454423055,
0.006057851,
-0.0500917882,
0.0575526245,
0.0457550585,
0.0361126401,
0.0703865215,
-0.0083905589,
-0.0510485247,
0.0297011398,
-0.0250897985,
-0.0807268098,
-0.0548330061,
-0.0009856177,
-0.0496903285,
-0.0408246666,
-0.0355984233,
-0.0603377409,
0.0240546055,
-0.0018259597,
-0.0009097676,
0.0391048379,
0.0072330371,
-0.0216706153,
-0.0354782566,
-0.0167868435,
0.0738121271,
-0.0081726396,
-0.0069569536,
0.0051469272,
-0.0030987791,
-0.0027493169,
0.0110035371,
0.0149013866,
0.0132732373,
-0.0066482844,
0.0031581039,
-0.0081671681,
0.0175040811,
-0.0044305059,
-0.0355101638,
-0.0660000667,
0.0161908269,
-0.0021549233,
-0.0078340862,
0.0197529458,
0.0106156543,
-0.0064155417,
-0.023308076,
0.0808103681,
0.0281691439,
0.0338243544,
0.0250701439,
-0.068598114,
-0.0800846219,
-0.06266734,
-0.0592488274,
0.0453550704,
0.0512769707,
-0.0579683408,
-0.0159837604,
-0.0382934846,
0.0593002327,
0.0006413144,
-0.0011417806,
-0.030434547,
-0.0231076777,
-0.0171957277,
0.0225972999,
-0.047639247,
0.0519905835,
-0.0291358437,
-0.0404295214,
-0.0110472357,
0.0189737119,
0.0026387924,
-0.0493321568,
0.0325916559,
-0.0099460194,
-0.0841263533,
-0.0243073869,
0.0059951851,
0.0536394753,
0.0331840925,
0.027793387,
-0.0028241479,
-0.0491501056,
-0.0121451542,
0.0161225349,
0.0247095115,
0.0015796253,
-0.0388254486,
0.0843634456,
0.0154318474,
-0.0386201739,
-0.0564006604,
0.046291057,
-0.0198603403,
-0.0361110456,
0.0632551461,
-0.0025364438,
0.0682550892,
-0.0047715399,
0.0130717009,
-0.1021350995,
-0.0061644185,
-0.0306199063,
0.0118316505,
0.0588653013,
0.0222439729,
0.0048591984,
0.0493100919,
-0.0315180309,
0.0197106171,
0.0731262043,
0.0409737416,
-0.0354912058,
-0.0098338341,
-0.0378059037,
-0.0176434517,
0.0423838384,
0.0298805684,
-0.0058270483,
-0.0294993389,
0.0037403055,
0.0161702186,
-0.0295909382,
0.0651697069,
0.0044622784,
-0.0139712719,
-0.009293586,
0.0470568538,
-0.0196700804,
0.0609876551,
0.0080242502,
0.0104360655,
-0.0007285727,
-0.0303478837,
0.0092171468,
-0.0043777097,
0.0106909378,
0.0094643105,
0.0190951657,
0.0419815294,
0.0133452816,
-0.0403182805,
-0.0148629975,
0.016317362,
-0.024210522,
0.0276965387,
0.0047736391,
0.076913029,
0.030841466,
-0.063728027,
0.0919570848,
0.0206565149,
-0.0296519808,
0.0342587084,
-0.0219289027,
-0.0441040844,
0.021118179,
0.0010959532,
0.0141172698,
-0.0468295403,
-0.0286691077,
-0.0036840946,
0.0877833217,
-0.0182856545,
0.009879983,
0.0437236577,
-0.0930686295,
-0.035712149,
0.0260376614,
-0.0010974425,
0.043353308,
-0.0436109863,
0.0263594836,
-0.0004789555,
-0.0321963206,
0.0187283438,
0.0027570592,
-0.0382020064,
-0.0034219157,
0.0107766269,
0.0221052114,
0.0509813018,
0.0049430816,
-0.0048635621,
-0.0131645827,
0.034724962,
-0.0237735417,
-0.0250645671,
0.0146240667,
-0.0659841001,
-0.0248648692,
0.0378787443,
-0.017164398,
0.0597427152,
0.0294840503,
0.0185658075,
-0.0737272948,
0.0550085306,
-0.0536385849,
0.0584870316,
-0.0109913517,
0.073738493,
0.0267170686,
0.0145613318,
0.0093312887,
-0.0031923668,
-0.0162556171,
-0.0340131409,
0.0001585093,
0.0039411555,
-0.0157000199,
-0.039100945,
-0.0106068496,
0.0124057699,
-0.0116699738,
0.0192516968,
-0.0033938522,
-0.016039025,
0.0055929483,
-0.0105101215,
-0.0149636492,
-0.0280300491,
-0.0377722271,
0.0405570045,
0.0161194131,
0.0415698066,
0.0166770089,
-0.0337026119,
0.0141880084,
0.0063847364,
-0.036645323,
-0.00658909,
-0.0196694098,
-0.0098037133,
-0.0098605268,
0.0119020399,
0.0049039931,
0.0301706493,
0.0322692953,
-0.0432991646,
-0.0648983046,
-0.1095114946,
0.0481554344,
0.0250399597,
0.0670403317,
-0.00162023,
-0.0329089575,
-0.0446366817,
0.0084853405,
0.0133966208,
0.0316065475,
-0.0073793558,
-0.031715095,
0.0424438119,
-0.0168981645,
-0.0712580532,
0.0154408831,
0.0066820965,
-0.0081936726,
-0.0015017292,
0.0217822772,
-0.0152549911,
0.0732600763,
-0.004605249,
0.0330330431,
-0.0658863112,
-0.0150204906,
-0.0131886071,
-0.0074552209,
0.0001608615,
-0.0305747446,
-0.0414910354,
0.0033072787,
-0.0238522701,
-0.0247720852,
0.0441389047,
-0.0360211805,
-0.0107061593,
-0.0941366702,
-0.0080663916,
-0.0041206582,
-0.0205341801,
0.0184361953,
-0.0075422972,
0.0751721933,
-0.0769123584,
-0.0246987622,
0.0036683725,
-0.0103458716,
-0.0265218932,
0.0802772641,
-0.0284667816,
0.0183514133,
-0.0086575914,
-0.0434958786,
-0.0249118544,
0.0251143947,
-0.0239609033,
0.0083724717,
-0.0092216851,
-0.0249771606,
-0.0464548692,
0.0363892578,
0.0206227489,
0.0672399923,
0.0028734799,
0.013824041,
-0.0196246374,
0.0757897496,
0.0405351706,
0.0679664239,
-0.0662840083,
-0.0179063175,
0.0174840651,
0.0001649318,
0.0020758556,
-0.0279073715,
-0.0496455766,
-0.0153947799,
0.0622737706,
0.0213196445,
-0.0032916213,
0.0057758945,
0.0339208096,
-0.0434404276,
-0.0259056855,
0.0829375982,
-0.027541548,
-0.0497636832,
-0.0228061508,
-0.0035625212,
-0.0186727904,
-0.0031942271,
-0.0042245858,
0.0133182425,
-0.0493039414,
0.0432886295,
0.0519207492,
0.0347561017,
0.0215646513,
-0.015616891,
-0.1234158948,
0.0121340649,
0.0244186129,
-0.0646928251,
-0.0535840578,
-0.0481884405,
-0.0038071133,
-0.0175782871,
0.0319285579,
0.0094568077,
0.0077323276,
-0.0319816135,
0.0384760872,
-0.062539205,
-0.0531514436,
-0.0325111374,
-0.0312226806,
0.0532638095,
0.1067843065,
-0.0009784291,
-0.0076810149,
0.0132490108,
0.079582803,
-0.0214801244,
0.0134722497,
0.0059295939,
0.0537646748,
-0.0040156618,
-0.0077264686,
0.0197273158,
0.030681029,
-0.0453817993,
0.036775507,
0.0181453452,
0.0815824643,
0.0060869022,
0.0088942684,
-0.0105740177,
-0.0076500005,
0.0011906581,
0.0391463861,
0.0116091734,
-0.0659264401,
-0.0173901375,
0.0046198014,
0.0059941006,
-0.0443459041,
-0.0034232147,
0.0252498183,
-0.0210280716,
-0.043445833,
-0.0328345336,
-0.0544323139,
-0.0180937815,
0.0091342917,
0.0449833609,
0.0008433358,
0.045598872,
0.016388217,
-0.0401958972,
-0.0124714468,
-0.0052746274,
0.002970811,
-0.0482961684,
0.0145890685,
0.0342317224,
-0.0513120517,
0.0109720994,
0.0438478664,
-0.0069902753,
-0.0381022505,
0.0240921434,
-0.0204703044,
0.0135725029,
0.0856088996,
-0.0323026478,
-0.0387703963,
0.0743091479,
-0.0340251401,
-0.0763748959,
0.0302577466,
0.056698747,
-0.017571222,
-0.0211084001,
0.0177595671,
-0.0634860396,
0.0252046138,
0.0183482431,
0.011118914,
0.0154400375,
-0.0491144396,
-0.0111097572,
0.0327887461,
0.0554362014,
0.0264361016,
-0.0100119011,
-0.022941608,
0.0706717372,
0.0100120362,
0.0535141081,
-0.0512886159,
0.0184600167,
0.0267688017,
0.0058539379,
0.0022258437,
0.0313365087,
-0.0039920043,
-0.0510191284,
-0.0133482814,
0.0718019605,
0.0200169329,
0.066419445,
0.0037482877,
-0.0001518182,
-0.0035982572,
-0.0114839859,
0.0517631806,
0.0365339778,
-0.0239715204,
0.0290910173,
0.0123262051,
0.0106804399,
0.0065566879,
0.0161427464,
-0.0193356611,
0.0110161342,
-0.0487254299,
-0.0332256071,
0.0083657242,
0.0079925051,
0.0711678416,
0.0420295298,
0.022349013,
-0.0444204845,
0.0114575839,
-0.0020793946,
0.0026947032,
0.0254472606,
-0.0192313604,
-0.0136070987,
0.017059423,
0.0501781628,
0.0273633078,
0.0158690102,
-0.0215027705,
0.0588998124,
-0.0277613662,
0.0021429269,
-0.0499190912,
-0.0110385073,
-0.0307483245,
0.0028036104,
0.004280346,
-0.0448037982,
0.0244704187,
-0.0546021946,
0.0481221676,
-0.0462629907,
0.0127177518,
-0.0069806711,
-0.0066115735,
-0.0103497794,
-0.0034641717,
0.000810243,
0.0001167494,
0.0143072559,
-0.0282634087,
-6.984808738e-33,
-0.0419905223,
0.0231894571,
-0.0082011446,
-0.0407679342,
-0.0483609736,
0.0202181768,
-0.0205903184,
-0.0208869185,
-0.0095129069,
-0.0396914966,
-0.0171729624,
0.0370350704,
0.0223133471,
0.0231382567,
0.0015710148,
-0.003098387,
0.0749852583,
-0.0441101827,
-0.0307643116,
-0.0009047387,
0.0614910759,
0.062863715,
0.0406109244,
-0.0652794689,
-0.0286202077,
0.0074169021,
0.0239294358,
-0.0097871069,
0.0449843369,
0.04745581,
-0.0044790669,
0.0450208001,
0.0007424405,
-0.0604380369,
-0.0546514206,
0.0110291624,
-0.1129544377,
0.0201728642,
-0.0294272155,
0.0502151251,
0.0091568772,
-0.0488295779,
0.07932996,
0.0354411006,
0.0113950279,
-0.0658141002,
0.0186710879,
-0.0463815033,
-0.0110184504,
-0.0038326336,
-0.0007912841,
0.0317235887,
-0.0044955816,
-0.0227558706,
0.0478053689,
0.0612756647,
-0.0175983794,
-0.0077423435,
-0.1094623506,
0.0186520927,
0.0058542378,
0.031586878,
0.0620570034,
0.0244152974,
-0.0369825251,
0.0129430667,
0.0396014787,
-0.0130363014,
0.0177895073,
-0.0462088175,
0.0239723641,
0.0214679297,
0.0123731876,
-0.029502606,
0.0469910651,
-0.0269484427,
-0.0484271646,
0.0031310809,
-0.0045434451,
0.0273099504,
0.049042929,
0.0282400381,
-0.0575512163,
-0.0128058456,
-0.0153530771,
-0.0278340653,
-0.0459494255,
-0.0314309597,
0.0502404459,
0.0031155529,
0.0236611422,
-0.0323267132,
0.0416556783,
-0.0268977657,
0.0405146703,
0.0203134976,
0.0290269367,
-0.012459578,
-0.0008851947,
0.0285630543,
-0.045146279,
-0.0129250465,
-0.0057512508,
0.0529496856,
-0.0077403076,
-0.0027903842,
-0.0147470087,
0.0428571664,
-0.0583267584,
-0.0258365031,
-0.0186727941,
-0.0098864138,
-0.007563747,
0.0759636387,
0.0501680672,
-0.012961912,
-0.008452422,
0.0670531318,
-0.019717928,
-0.0078511825,
-0.01728913,
0.0105860503,
0.0679690987,
0.0541448519,
-0.0141609116,
-0.0157081746,
0.0116764968,
0.036615286,
0.0391010009,
-0.0263537467,
-0.0109205702,
0.008639141,
3.232e-7,
-0.0021529694,
-0.017989004,
0.0330483727,
-0.0469990522,
0.0218549538,
0.0094988989,
-0.0223393962,
0.033803232,
0.0124519253,
0.0214718059,
-0.0324084349,
-0.0172095038,
0.0840940922,
0.000184302,
-0.0625250787,
-0.0289629381,
0.022291895,
0.0315852351,
0.0169426464,
-0.0034723463,
0.0091203721,
0.0850234479,
-0.0277496651,
-0.0061764871,
-0.0135651315,
-0.0050768969,
0.0290994644,
0.0085334629,
-0.0008027229,
-0.0149466554,
-0.0317560993,
-0.0010679003,
-0.0578173026,
0.0272031203,
-0.0372193083,
0.0642498657,
0.0087216478,
0.0454371572,
-0.0110280095,
-0.062231157,
0.0165829491,
0.0304633733,
-0.0260106381,
0.0336172357,
0.0371839441,
-0.081909813,
-0.0528438613,
0.027483644,
-0.0615123436,
0.0301573481,
-0.0208127163,
0.0130804619,
0.0159173161,
0.0123863975,
0.0030974366,
-0.023070313,
-0.0349834003,
-0.053873729,
-0.0021948183,
0.0002299731,
-0.0318153575,
-0.0123727396,
-0.0427306257,
-0.008139086,
0.054701291,
-0.0390680507,
0.0096656783,
2.528159807e-34,
0.0135686854,
-0.0211889446,
0.0130762113,
0.039964173,
-0.0189817566,
-0.0908404216,
0.0119955689,
0.0111527881,
0.0130196009,
-0.0681527182,
-0.0320872366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13317v1 | Transforming the Output of Generative Pre-trained Transformer: The Influence of the PGI Framework on Attention Dynamics | 2023-08-25T11:41:05 | 2023-08-25T11:41:05 | Aline Ioste | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper presents a novel approach named Persona-Grouping-Intelligence
(PGI), which has been crafted to tackle the challenges posed by GPT models when
applied to real-world business issues. PGI leverages the inherent capabilities
of the GPT model to comprehend intricate language structures and generate
responses that are contextually relevant. The experiment occurred in a business
scenario where human intelligence was being underutilized due to less optimized
business processes. The primary objective of this approach is to leverage GPT
models to reduce the workload on humans in tasks that are extensive,
monotonous, and repetitive. Instead, the focus is redirected toward
decision-making activities. Remarkably, the experiment yielded an accuracy rate
of 93.81% in validating 4,000 responses generated by the model, underscoring
the effectiveness of the PGI strategies. Effectively addressing the issue of
underutilized human intelligence, this paradigm shift aligns business
environments with dynamic machine intelligence, enabling them to navigate the
intricacies of real-world challenges. This approach facilitates the practical
utilization of these models to tackle actual problems. The methodology offers
an opportunity to reshape the fundamental structure of business processes by
seamlessly integrating human decision-making with adaptable machine
intelligence. Consequently, this optimization enhances operational efficiency
and elevates strategic decision-making across diverse business contexts. | [
0.057695128,
0.0496370159,
-0.0395407975,
-0.0225973707,
0.0073984256,
0.0095768487,
-0.0004610238,
0.0049894745,
-0.0334415846,
-0.0198872555,
-0.0379567109,
-0.0089256307,
-0.008405474,
0.0614316389,
0.0381444357,
-0.1076276079,
0.0270465594,
0.014683323,
0.0231148954,
0.0175251812,
-0.0132315885,
0.012845532,
0.0035441399,
0.04552719,
-0.02475187,
-0.0240067821,
0.0104746968,
-0.0072224867,
0.0617480688,
-0.0359888375,
0.0202656109,
0.0625485033,
0.0339971296,
0.0085417004,
0.0000025961,
-0.0569023602,
0.0145756258,
-0.022452198,
-0.0303594302,
-0.0202953704,
0.0136232069,
0.0440147445,
-0.0039038677,
0.0540703535,
-0.0677884668,
-0.0100024045,
0.0227972008,
0.0893568173,
0.0566715114,
0.0392249227,
-0.0360197723,
-0.0186360981,
0.0190122183,
-0.044854749,
-0.0255884062,
-0.0852301791,
0.0142075671,
-0.0426691361,
-0.0297735166,
-0.0063953898,
0.0001973406,
0.0117661599,
0.0117797498,
0.012323916,
-0.0018946248,
0.0468686894,
0.0033945604,
-0.0012966507,
-0.0154596129,
0.0552631207,
-0.0274925753,
0.0150383301,
-0.0279710945,
-0.0029724892,
0.0336633027,
-0.0080838669,
-0.033893805,
0.0207388904,
-0.0049168882,
-0.0080267899,
-0.0382642634,
0.0727675781,
-0.0238159131,
-0.0488596708,
-0.0442008264,
0.0045954692,
-0.0100230929,
-0.035550911,
0.0319587551,
0.0273860581,
0.0063311388,
-0.0490641221,
-0.0046011778,
0.0337669477,
-0.0495650694,
0.0017798871,
0.0199819747,
0.0020763834,
-0.032490138,
-0.0304789059,
0.0355459638,
0.0276090652,
0.0192542803,
0.0321329534,
-0.0007620343,
0.0623821616,
-0.0361729413,
-0.011676061,
-0.0465287454,
0.0096094729,
-0.0789370611,
-0.0330276899,
-0.0669039115,
0.0193804484,
-0.0193841401,
-0.033115916,
-0.0405239165,
0.0390857048,
-0.0473142378,
-0.0225031618,
-0.0016832122,
0.0550968572,
-0.0392980203,
-0.0031258685,
-0.0635112375,
0.0187568404,
-0.0416306034,
-0.0006544992,
-0.0157710854,
-0.0158379171,
0.0149988523,
0.011114575,
-0.0133087905,
-0.0002382783,
-0.0103943376,
0.0467392765,
-0.0256084148,
-0.0133726113,
-0.0674504712,
0.0053441324,
0.0254594702,
-0.0540466346,
-0.0035772552,
0.0114850039,
0.0337161943,
0.009850191,
-0.0312223975,
-0.0110248756,
-0.0162630323,
0.0120043345,
-0.0193583257,
0.0687224492,
0.0631329715,
0.0467760451,
0.0261369906,
0.0119199976,
0.0323444419,
0.0237578992,
0.0373782553,
0.0370890014,
-0.002165332,
-0.0485244989,
0.0693592802,
0.0420932844,
-0.0192834325,
-0.0214348938,
0.0690745935,
0.0104965214,
-0.0436149947,
-0.0243887361,
0.0592691563,
0.0316641405,
-0.0213741381,
0.0606903173,
0.0828655958,
0.0284453221,
-0.0093976865,
0.0861374661,
0.0532233939,
0.0524019711,
-0.035054177,
-0.0015093943,
-0.0311309379,
0.0517091826,
-0.0341635942,
0.0054525156,
-0.0269397125,
0.035229072,
-0.0479569025,
-0.0168347079,
0.0489783883,
0.0200143941,
0.0293244366,
0.0282135867,
0.0169559438,
0.013805992,
-0.095152624,
0.060861703,
-0.0117430249,
-0.0369641669,
-0.0410335623,
-0.0683360398,
-0.0251359604,
0.080721423,
0.0577666722,
-0.0317100361,
-0.0111651095,
-0.0376439542,
-0.0457173027,
0.040544346,
0.028570421,
0.0108157434,
-0.0806406662,
0.0039909119,
-0.0501032993,
0.0139177004,
-0.0198770408,
0.0423133075,
0.0280696303,
0.0144198872,
0.0032432673,
0.0440197177,
0.0153297074,
0.0232407972,
-0.0269932151,
-0.025387099,
-0.0088602165,
0.0236927811,
0.0466380604,
0.0205528606,
0.0102760075,
0.0037336349,
0.0158836953,
-0.0206947122,
-0.0136563787,
0.0314612165,
-0.0227818955,
0.0698885396,
-0.020003356,
-0.0288286246,
-0.015632404,
0.0099099921,
-0.0103848064,
-0.0483481884,
0.0253805909,
-0.0504817478,
0.0064993678,
-0.0244977511,
0.00254155,
-0.0171077438,
0.0334802642,
-0.043063499,
0.068351306,
0.006449779,
-0.0328795612,
-0.0121306898,
0.0067977565,
0.0256859846,
-0.0548765808,
0.0513470843,
0.0292457212,
-0.0107052308,
0.0026313234,
0.0606879778,
0.0091706822,
0.0023423003,
-0.0112842778,
-0.0852849409,
-0.0192024149,
0.0018008978,
0.0025583978,
0.012712121,
-0.0018981386,
-0.0325030163,
-0.0015688355,
-0.0628797188,
0.0256854929,
0.0174631458,
-0.01216882,
0.0380892083,
-0.00888607,
0.0175640434,
-0.0138655975,
0.0165237635,
-0.0048539103,
0.0245733168,
0.0375877693,
-0.0130135696,
-0.0681999326,
0.0069952607,
0.0045096586,
0.0166411493,
0.0070200372,
-0.0342123583,
0.0370734967,
0.0041612247,
0.1254941821,
0.039056316,
0.0354586057,
0.0288932454,
-0.0058852625,
-0.0097053852,
-0.0315914676,
0.0584886223,
-0.0496060699,
-0.019743422,
-0.0102452775,
-0.0334881917,
0.0622004196,
0.0395099446,
0.0044416403,
0.0023146195,
-0.0862321034,
0.0440275967,
0.006604088,
-0.033358492,
-0.0013973304,
-0.0217935722,
-0.0235580411,
0.0562578775,
-0.0100112837,
0.0078549059,
0.0377848335,
0.0440652519,
0.0017663863,
-0.0241057295,
0.0282759499,
-0.0172922611,
0.0544470325,
0.0016682469,
0.0026365097,
-0.0211741105,
-0.0289514661,
-0.0780273229,
0.0194955971,
-0.0057319584,
-0.0105699813,
0.0311425719,
-0.0249155685,
-0.0077090478,
-0.0115450434,
-0.0449494049,
-0.0708577335,
0.0176104419,
0.0066860444,
0.0217047166,
0.0498435535,
-0.0265207812,
-0.0855197012,
0.0209748056,
0.0291442238,
0.0294923633,
-0.0028449509,
-0.0502239354,
-0.0112927249,
0.0055599459,
0.024201449,
0.0370735489,
0.0371582136,
-0.0003646835,
0.0009070255,
0.0366837122,
0.0187315419,
-0.0681217909,
-0.0218460374,
-0.027440371,
0.008771725,
-0.047481928,
0.0231617969,
0.0188378803,
0.0054303035,
-0.0208775848,
-0.0241547525,
0.0943803266,
0.0132217035,
-0.0418159552,
0.0087367259,
-0.0084254043,
-0.013212271,
0.0159294233,
0.086329855,
-0.0000703721,
-0.0110281678,
-0.0174150355,
0.0286888108,
-0.0022338761,
-0.0371714905,
0.0137979072,
-0.107833229,
0.080424957,
-0.0305795372,
-0.0098390775,
-0.0381837264,
-0.0079482291,
0.00212273,
-0.0250128061,
-0.0030166327,
-0.0067688623,
0.0050308444,
-0.0158729479,
0.0005179438,
-0.0500884354,
-0.0141671589,
0.0490098819,
0.0057959533,
-0.033208631,
0.1098968685,
0.0191368312,
-0.006688206,
-0.0202620011,
-0.0207006447,
-0.0002342101,
0.0270843022,
0.0203819983,
0.0719507411,
-0.0069054449,
0.0146299917,
-0.0357062854,
0.0150552448,
-0.0629925355,
-0.0147303753,
0.0271491669,
0.0704236105,
-0.0135854688,
-0.0384852998,
-0.0331920944,
0.0140368892,
0.0243387185,
0.0717148855,
-0.0140275005,
-0.0763987303,
-0.0357388258,
-0.0208313707,
0.0614617206,
-0.0408848189,
-0.0651276708,
0.0272236541,
-0.009464574,
-0.0508603714,
-0.0564642139,
-0.0589470379,
0.0221930947,
0.0155814392,
0.0130982567,
-0.083903648,
0.0347327068,
0.0312888995,
-0.0305625331,
-0.0065660407,
-0.0082495017,
0.0272660516,
-0.0725753605,
-0.0403019115,
0.0019640878,
-0.0168384425,
-0.0070840064,
0.0257841609,
-0.0478269756,
0.0084395315,
0.0085744197,
0.0665925145,
0.0264309403,
0.0060102874,
-0.0096265934,
-0.017419761,
0.045071803,
-0.0122562936,
-0.0488509797,
-0.0066105127,
0.0111658238,
0.025827799,
-0.0252526011,
-0.0015918488,
-0.0293526147,
0.0748714656,
0.0123436721,
0.0009706801,
-0.0651273504,
-0.0686641335,
0.0162015818,
-0.0221224483,
0.0385394432,
-0.013502487,
-0.0245898385,
-0.0437113531,
-0.025748888,
0.0077309981,
0.0136056468,
-0.0462313406,
-0.0537251718,
0.0164615437,
-0.0123672001,
0.0203495435,
0.0150210541,
-0.0515837111,
-0.0695349425,
-0.0453918763,
0.0032387241,
0.014686645,
0.0261362996,
-0.0216362402,
0.0050240192,
-0.0023407626,
-0.0416514352,
0.0058914078,
0.0330782309,
0.0198402125,
0.0992093533,
0.0010963554,
0.0044360803,
-0.0009612694,
0.0198253896,
-0.0482917354,
-0.0320036486,
-0.0017394701,
0.0125599653,
-0.0205834415,
0.0100405235,
-0.0003257193,
-0.0365707427,
0.0026799168,
0.0006867711,
0.0009573799,
-0.0155924633,
0.0053672362,
-0.0399894342,
0.0248170793,
-0.0087672593,
-0.0333676748,
0.0581594408,
-0.0272413641,
-0.0177058056,
-0.0586947054,
-0.0435618535,
-0.0783378854,
-0.0545532629,
-0.0020537614,
0.0238621347,
0.0113878548,
0.0282521173,
-0.0765606686,
-0.0236733519,
-0.0331104286,
0.0057322062,
0.0009489632,
-0.0527646244,
0.024899587,
0.0363091528,
-0.0221612714,
-0.0449855626,
-0.0279184189,
0.0232899282,
-0.0404680036,
0.0199904665,
-0.0478426255,
-6.678688704e-33,
-0.0171441156,
-0.0543066561,
0.0444088951,
0.0086063882,
-0.0497092083,
-0.0214273296,
-0.0176832601,
-0.0043001012,
0.0167274475,
0.0259408746,
-0.0490980297,
0.0069068898,
-0.0092860917,
0.0117623173,
0.0093888855,
0.0292249713,
0.0583035313,
-0.0180349667,
-0.0139430165,
0.0728847682,
0.016761614,
0.0178312436,
0.028200455,
-0.071832642,
-0.016460523,
-0.0068479739,
-0.0178471971,
0.0198413935,
0.024516454,
0.0303308275,
-0.0330255069,
0.0155652817,
0.0363942124,
-0.0739748627,
-0.0028250909,
0.0663143247,
-0.0961669236,
-0.0345835872,
-0.0272735581,
0.0126274107,
-0.0062296786,
-0.0189187452,
0.0145917097,
-0.0152979102,
-0.0062124482,
-0.0325853974,
0.0466727763,
-0.0135383522,
0.0025060365,
-0.0312694572,
-0.1237041801,
0.0021266737,
-0.0249096509,
-0.0041192342,
-0.003125648,
0.0756393,
-0.0206866618,
-0.0041719507,
-0.0824379623,
0.0068210419,
0.0323841758,
-0.0560953133,
0.0431899168,
0.0525478162,
-0.000934334,
-0.001528723,
-0.0062340689,
0.0280927643,
-0.0441569388,
-0.016424872,
-0.0105262799,
0.0799594,
0.0302367806,
-0.0102895526,
-0.0057915333,
-0.0205610991,
-0.0318740122,
0.0590754449,
-0.0122670187,
0.0439217165,
0.0645290613,
0.0058884714,
-0.0366532728,
-0.0285145901,
0.0438225269,
0.0033614708,
-0.0030393484,
-0.0047386107,
0.0126390569,
0.0013683207,
-0.0359588936,
0.0243039969,
0.0337982401,
-0.0308967903,
0.0400859527,
-0.0212484952,
0.0034979836,
0.0325745642,
0.018890582,
-0.0087321382,
-0.0307729449,
-0.025218742,
0.0338148139,
0.0411690846,
0.0136125414,
0.0080066612,
0.0198733173,
-0.0050872406,
-0.021426728,
-0.0151253501,
-0.0094180908,
0.081524305,
-0.0086121196,
0.0028075865,
-0.0037218481,
0.0241827723,
0.0017823378,
-0.0208801609,
0.0056682187,
-0.0245672949,
-0.0077519347,
0.034549728,
0.0224925727,
0.0231560729,
-0.0291111078,
0.0112667773,
-0.0219273455,
0.0247025676,
0.0233002137,
-0.0439046584,
-0.0362430848,
0.0411512554,
3.187e-7,
0.0339823999,
0.0369288325,
0.0149894897,
0.0134804631,
0.0465338826,
0.0423517115,
0.0367351882,
0.0120092705,
0.0213877186,
0.0135538923,
0.0868314132,
0.0431589931,
0.0207169633,
0.0175850559,
-0.0504873917,
-0.077697739,
0.0102065699,
0.0135562783,
-0.0538563617,
0.0408437625,
0.0609211884,
0.0444944575,
0.0118110431,
-0.0085642645,
0.0120085925,
0.0121644661,
0.0484316684,
-0.0239850469,
0.0185491033,
0.0175468214,
0.0484593771,
0.0039573228,
-0.0080156615,
0.0428053364,
-0.0189868286,
0.0047871075,
0.0052174297,
0.0121998833,
-0.0330143608,
-0.0326262116,
0.0055847899,
-0.0075444407,
0.0280038826,
-0.0506392233,
0.0333321393,
-0.1422684342,
-0.0369411968,
0.0165380575,
-0.0369965173,
0.0044975765,
-0.0255578291,
0.0302224308,
-0.0247217715,
0.0077486411,
0.0067979628,
-0.0057835719,
0.0170448385,
-0.0603005104,
0.0548101813,
0.0148189096,
-0.0686333552,
-0.0023846817,
-0.0450194515,
-0.0226132236,
0.0354637727,
0.0186746735,
0.0259021074,
2.732437996e-34,
0.0167801045,
0.0369837768,
0.0083415806,
-0.0149395978,
0.0487339012,
-0.0035832948,
-0.0030528356,
0.0273163505,
0.0472579934,
-0.0810155794,
-0.0209028702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13315v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13315v2 | Construction Grammar and Language Models | 2023-08-25T11:37:56 | 2023-09-04T21:03:51 | Harish Tayyar Madabushi, Laurence Romain, Petar Milin, Dagmar Divjak | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent progress in deep learning and natural language processing has given
rise to powerful models that are primarily trained on a cloze-like task and
show some evidence of having access to substantial linguistic information,
including some constructional knowledge. This groundbreaking discovery presents
an exciting opportunity for a synergistic relationship between computational
methods and Construction Grammar research. In this chapter, we explore three
distinct approaches to the interplay between computational methods and
Construction Grammar: (i) computational methods for text analysis, (ii)
computational Construction Grammar, and (iii) deep learning models, with a
particular focus on language models. We touch upon the first two approaches as
a contextual foundation for the use of computational methods before providing
an accessible, yet comprehensive overview of deep learning models, which also
addresses reservations construction grammarians may have. Additionally, we
delve into experiments that explore the emergence of constructionally relevant
information within these models while also examining the aspects of
Construction Grammar that may pose challenges for these models. This chapter
aims to foster collaboration between researchers in the fields of natural
language processing and Construction Grammar. By doing so, we hope to pave the
way for new insights and advancements in both these fields. | [
0.0210796464,
0.1070133969,
-0.0616530403,
0.0201168116,
-0.0490416065,
-0.0021028058,
0.0010374025,
-0.0292814784,
-0.0416518413,
-0.0400796011,
0.0215321835,
-0.1118375137,
0.0098369513,
0.0327782929,
0.0277272295,
-0.0226439014,
0.0149074774,
0.0081827473,
0.0285228062,
0.0169059895,
-0.0130863236,
0.002225349,
0.0230534766,
0.0405257456,
-0.0814521462,
-0.0010261373,
-0.035331443,
-0.0216937307,
-0.0534344912,
-0.0117630111,
0.033820346,
0.052011475,
0.008053991,
0.0393413194,
0.0000021281,
-0.0231889319,
-0.0135486992,
-0.0363579616,
-0.0367900692,
0.0034335817,
0.0458702669,
-0.0390289761,
-0.0464780964,
-0.0270488504,
-0.0514210574,
-0.019555442,
0.0508170985,
0.0164589863,
-0.0109965345,
0.0724736005,
-0.0120624965,
-0.0589828901,
0.0223033167,
-0.0241825432,
-0.0297157876,
0.0125155728,
0.0523417257,
-0.044823762,
0.0038743627,
0.0086956341,
-0.0292611681,
0.0120543968,
0.0370427668,
-0.0132867023,
0.009948615,
0.0147139495,
0.0235737786,
-0.0430790484,
-0.0218529254,
0.037567582,
-0.0295562018,
-0.0129201906,
0.051388666,
-0.0090594785,
0.0097223939,
-0.0143340407,
-0.0363163687,
0.0530144796,
0.0131555656,
0.0302699618,
0.0460908711,
-0.044903826,
0.0085483734,
0.0223299544,
0.0182335433,
0.0600794479,
0.0057110102,
-0.0207667407,
-0.0379470289,
0.0355852991,
0.0035788596,
-0.0809322968,
0.0288820677,
0.0320418216,
0.0058508059,
0.0110461218,
-0.0390238687,
-0.0362527296,
0.0149338134,
-0.0077727381,
0.0440647788,
0.0028038858,
0.0080403024,
0.0351960026,
-0.0540064238,
0.0183867365,
-0.0123363174,
-0.017861627,
-0.0317138247,
0.0166834816,
-0.0332620963,
-0.0337585881,
-0.0239883251,
0.013733794,
-0.0228915662,
-0.0289706383,
-0.0355430059,
0.0132772829,
0.0128030227,
0.0343409255,
-0.0330831036,
0.0496452861,
-0.0293070935,
0.0249410756,
-0.0246885177,
-0.0536132082,
-0.0362473354,
0.0480541065,
-0.0090732342,
-0.0365914851,
-0.031756185,
0.0396651924,
0.0252132565,
-0.0071844812,
0.0011016654,
0.0209076889,
0.0023209669,
-0.0077591869,
0.0008940215,
-0.0474029928,
-0.0460726582,
-0.0262221918,
0.0406575128,
-0.0706952214,
-0.0011673056,
-0.0219812617,
-0.032959681,
-0.0773164853,
0.0133783519,
0.0169249624,
-0.0048747933,
0.0131296962,
-0.0409129895,
-0.0034445063,
-0.009723112,
-0.0100439526,
0.0395835452,
0.0380203947,
0.0551826991,
0.0480680875,
0.0000690456,
-0.0167133696,
0.0075740162,
0.0408799648,
-0.0280022603,
-0.044004418,
-0.0355098657,
-0.0532064475,
-0.0145577099,
0.0256362576,
-0.019444583,
0.0429508574,
0.0002833142,
0.0002811155,
0.034291584,
0.0719482824,
0.0248252731,
0.0549538769,
0.0694979504,
0.0166670904,
0.0046794815,
0.0368627198,
-0.0169854052,
-0.0243786499,
0.0037464784,
0.0013628247,
-0.0770934969,
0.034604013,
0.0032443933,
-0.0650709271,
-0.0158041939,
-0.0276982784,
0.0085819177,
-0.0543855913,
0.0524541661,
0.0589638762,
-0.0289625712,
0.0149891637,
0.0356693268,
-0.027166931,
-0.0022422741,
-0.0314253755,
0.0206955839,
-0.0106960516,
0.0073403786,
-0.0288136322,
0.0023281209,
0.009551717,
0.006397164,
0.0493355691,
0.0383543335,
0.0078104571,
-0.0199398417,
-0.0424148627,
0.0023501487,
-0.0378581807,
0.0549594425,
-0.0202190038,
-0.0275619086,
-0.002383132,
-0.0032330425,
0.0100495825,
-0.0368141085,
0.0501246341,
0.0507035926,
0.0011710258,
0.0006993281,
0.003383453,
0.0060207457,
0.0109170713,
0.0070212153,
0.0389343835,
0.0530562811,
-0.0359667353,
-0.0471096709,
0.0131678917,
-0.0550470836,
-0.0250879079,
0.0047118571,
-0.0398915298,
-0.0061042863,
-0.0296190698,
0.0059636924,
-0.0510682426,
0.0938793197,
-0.0631851777,
0.088906236,
-0.0240449682,
0.0375647172,
-0.0194873903,
0.0283968057,
-0.0630594939,
0.1041316763,
0.0155398697,
0.0305639952,
-0.0036695446,
0.0118273366,
-0.0007530542,
-0.025081655,
-0.0094005587,
-0.0543277748,
-0.0303568281,
-0.0378045477,
0.003779164,
0.0223509483,
-0.0444190688,
-0.0350926444,
-0.0389161631,
-0.0023049752,
-0.0452823192,
0.0393751264,
0.0083953366,
-0.031142341,
-0.0191214774,
0.0096961334,
0.0124170929,
0.0302918181,
0.0181938577,
-0.0162242949,
0.1010457948,
-0.0186966397,
-0.0184058771,
-0.0753194168,
-0.0257615019,
-0.0555248074,
0.0429149121,
0.0355975963,
-0.0267887693,
0.0024704228,
0.0167296212,
0.0084524695,
0.0099064307,
0.0230168048,
-0.0609888472,
0.0369577222,
-0.0349759459,
0.041981861,
0.050560683,
-0.0217100456,
0.0590943471,
0.0236468576,
-0.0231079943,
-0.0165709164,
0.0148865907,
-0.0404903591,
0.0310074389,
-0.0333270989,
-0.0022170171,
0.0007598222,
0.1109176502,
-0.0118442653,
-0.0136080142,
0.00794541,
0.1012146547,
-0.0144322664,
-0.0328768492,
0.0198820457,
-0.0463343002,
0.0011878853,
0.0533244424,
-0.0241069011,
-0.0153334839,
0.051912792,
-0.0179627836,
-0.0216822866,
-0.0099644875,
-0.0145133706,
-0.0240029693,
0.0486053675,
0.0796448216,
0.0033086985,
0.0570296235,
-0.0319537371,
-0.008468857,
0.055665873,
-0.0026834882,
0.0009094374,
-0.031819284,
-0.0580219515,
-0.0166413188,
0.0009453666,
-0.0501937754,
-0.0368945785,
-0.0246453118,
-0.0305226613,
0.0069160643,
0.0553834215,
-0.0048272372,
-0.0188681781,
-0.000342185,
-0.0398058705,
-0.0026003574,
0.0012067416,
0.025059443,
-0.0695372373,
0.0544209257,
0.0424149483,
0.0540742427,
-0.0045609693,
0.0230939221,
-0.0163586773,
0.0547371656,
0.0039702207,
0.0729725882,
-0.0269762706,
0.0550076477,
0.0273713246,
-0.002672039,
-0.05740178,
-0.0015798757,
0.0157280825,
-0.0936291739,
-0.0223622806,
0.0881562158,
0.0506453738,
0.004096841,
0.0299124327,
0.0042266259,
0.0160943922,
0.0090964269,
-0.0363732949,
-0.0702546313,
-0.0287554674,
0.0310456697,
-0.0506475903,
-0.0581822395,
-0.0357876346,
-0.0063059824,
-0.0960029215,
0.0477304421,
-0.0256308392,
-0.0010031746,
0.035082005,
-0.0758549348,
0.007828813,
0.0281885471,
-0.0735759288,
0.0079114363,
0.0002067261,
0.0173218772,
0.0223010108,
-0.0308828093,
-0.0533980802,
-0.0449918509,
-0.0585596859,
0.0286551956,
0.0426391177,
0.0583401434,
-0.0287125427,
-0.0061922404,
0.0267812461,
-0.0360192917,
0.0250210017,
-0.0125852879,
0.0154951895,
0.0475730151,
-0.0282953959,
-0.0217073634,
0.0390047953,
-0.0843594521,
0.0024625591,
-0.0093791662,
0.0772152767,
-0.0124403238,
-0.0384838432,
-0.0412448831,
0.0081678508,
0.0169577785,
0.0416218713,
0.0537328795,
-0.0453552715,
-0.050837066,
-0.0587491803,
0.0216809008,
-0.0572760887,
-0.0414488353,
0.0129130641,
0.0157908332,
0.0302272867,
-0.0759003609,
-0.0386172421,
0.0469116047,
0.0019535909,
0.0317031518,
-0.0248322375,
0.0255299546,
-0.0489141643,
-0.0532810539,
0.0378594361,
0.0219982956,
0.0203499813,
-0.0268248003,
-0.0152625702,
0.0437005721,
-0.0218144152,
-0.020565765,
0.024987828,
-0.0426014364,
-0.0486064702,
0.0141915837,
0.0318395197,
0.0187955685,
-0.0391218252,
-0.0288617779,
-0.0316462256,
0.0049208165,
0.0183577519,
-0.0137683265,
-0.0072199749,
0.0160859469,
-0.0688678026,
-0.0102336286,
0.0034722162,
0.0103842467,
0.0440341569,
0.0147392051,
0.0194962397,
-0.0642274618,
-0.0137309749,
0.0439795367,
-0.0090253772,
0.0542174987,
0.0219077915,
-0.0126082916,
-0.0154978922,
-0.0015778402,
-0.0021904511,
-0.0438470952,
-0.0385291837,
0.0040351888,
-0.0034036133,
0.0520340577,
-0.0276812278,
0.0136700645,
-0.016791001,
0.0769435018,
-0.0080172075,
0.0282720495,
0.0854028165,
-0.0041979649,
-0.0164119639,
0.0231776331,
0.0395708121,
0.0823749751,
-0.020302264,
0.045269832,
-0.0185586289,
-0.052248396,
-0.0152510442,
0.0045421952,
-0.0343871601,
-0.0112629347,
-0.0323701128,
0.0249113105,
-0.0390237607,
-0.0032650838,
0.0501890443,
-0.066582568,
0.0304472502,
-0.0422182456,
-0.0076790499,
-0.0198001899,
0.0028501346,
-0.000753446,
-0.0540530272,
-0.0118905846,
0.0155197363,
-0.0482138358,
-0.0465351567,
0.0427425615,
0.037287008,
0.020511806,
-0.0007947056,
-0.0046187127,
-0.0233950857,
-0.0259559453,
0.0223103464,
0.0475794785,
0.0169507526,
0.0211331546,
-0.0382591151,
-0.0300237983,
0.0246942788,
0.0106871901,
0.0495046154,
-0.0358863808,
0.04651374,
0.0597249754,
-0.0184816178,
-0.0188761335,
-0.0485629402,
0.0376237258,
0.0386283733,
-0.0106423032,
-0.0073733437,
-6.069356881e-33,
-0.0180745777,
-0.0454417355,
-0.0132306125,
0.0281784646,
-0.0068489481,
0.013418613,
-0.0289645437,
0.0381839275,
-0.0063045146,
0.0172613431,
-0.020091828,
0.0265881885,
0.0136309154,
0.0249738134,
0.0411894098,
0.0379021466,
0.0377411433,
-0.0410259478,
0.0224427767,
-0.017264355,
-0.0142916273,
0.0247914381,
0.0462734438,
-0.0297761746,
0.0132878656,
0.0121255489,
-0.0027795059,
0.00359015,
-0.0251681786,
0.041421093,
-0.0223950986,
0.0239005573,
0.0151139777,
-0.006230575,
-0.0154039925,
0.0335028134,
-0.0553739406,
-0.032172814,
-0.021849554,
-0.0016938513,
-0.0439240746,
-0.0494172052,
0.0635886788,
0.017508449,
-0.0195922889,
0.0320036709,
0.0704490915,
0.0030109147,
0.0286529884,
-0.0186094996,
-0.0960167423,
0.0189384818,
-0.0342869721,
0.0022361639,
0.0512419119,
-0.0392280668,
0.0261199623,
0.0376512073,
-0.0674226657,
0.0373189561,
0.0140087577,
0.0654221699,
0.0240765922,
-0.0078119999,
-0.0106796296,
0.0400357023,
0.0216653831,
-0.0141422721,
-0.0420042835,
0.0562416315,
0.0546203218,
0.0651219264,
0.030969765,
0.0584839135,
0.0606349185,
-0.0169141795,
-0.0705307871,
-0.002589534,
0.0218256451,
0.0460341945,
-0.0021594393,
0.000934917,
0.0234110001,
-0.0307041854,
-0.0441856235,
-0.0731981173,
0.0106759053,
0.0466037691,
-0.0184868649,
0.038786374,
-0.0338397101,
0.0074326671,
-0.0382076912,
-0.0133343805,
-0.0051110722,
-0.0129427416,
-0.0266221091,
0.0321583524,
0.0368273631,
0.0520631224,
-0.0552792437,
-0.0560282804,
-0.0132096279,
0.0343965292,
0.0528976656,
0.0220636539,
-0.0052826395,
0.0144955385,
-0.0206723567,
-0.0031222499,
-0.0054832594,
0.0006114458,
0.0005320783,
-0.0123349065,
0.0241527837,
0.0017357036,
-0.0164309088,
0.0063726953,
0.034813378,
0.0647102818,
-0.0397850089,
-0.0158338994,
-0.021805482,
0.0153083326,
-0.0324194916,
-0.0439837836,
-0.0118732881,
0.0209059324,
0.0955652148,
-0.0807009861,
-0.0069908127,
-0.0220311042,
2.76e-7,
0.0515705757,
0.0634233132,
0.0480556116,
0.0124953603,
0.0355211869,
0.0265790075,
-0.0222132821,
0.0238868296,
-0.0350956395,
-0.0334328786,
0.0123305302,
0.0066111912,
0.0238360967,
0.0113848681,
-0.0848063529,
0.0183908045,
-0.0459909588,
-0.0121427309,
-0.0564096421,
0.0104252174,
0.0078833234,
0.101367943,
-0.0083397049,
-0.054720521,
-0.0055294493,
-0.0475858711,
0.0252657458,
0.0134658562,
0.0119815068,
0.0660432279,
0.0387322418,
-0.0091749365,
-0.0244373754,
0.0342964679,
0.0041804444,
0.0280446839,
0.050025627,
0.0164475795,
0.0106955227,
0.053589534,
0.0143115884,
-0.0177204702,
0.0067978292,
-0.0206209105,
0.0476153456,
-0.0592063479,
-0.0011732603,
-0.0065736221,
0.0222004224,
0.0216264743,
0.0084321937,
0.0132975439,
0.0140658757,
-0.0153973158,
0.0267269406,
-0.0184043758,
-0.0112115555,
-0.072178185,
-0.0291139912,
0.015555948,
-0.0370137915,
-0.0079111485,
-0.0329167768,
-0.0104280878,
0.0147141898,
-0.0214308351,
-0.0220315978,
2.568915252e-34,
0.0167592205,
-0.0102373548,
0.0123969186,
0.0162865669,
0.0271597952,
0.0080736317,
-0.0211878847,
0.0170775726,
-0.0306137577,
-0.0793155581,
-0.0119116269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.00639v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.00639v1 | Misinformation Concierge: A Proof-of-Concept with Curated Twitter Dataset on COVID-19 Vaccination | 2023-08-25T10:06:05 | 2023-08-25T10:06:05 | Shakshi Sharma, Anwitaman Datta, Vigneshwaran Shankaran, Rajesh Sharma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | We demonstrate the Misinformation Concierge, a proof-of-concept that provides
actionable intelligence on misinformation prevalent in social media.
Specifically, it uses language processing and machine learning tools to
identify subtopics of discourse and discern non/misleading posts; presents
statistical reports for policy-makers to understand the big picture of
prevalent misinformation in a timely manner; and recommends rebuttal messages
for specific pieces of misinformation, identified from within the corpus of
data - providing means to intervene and counter misinformation promptly. The
Misinformation Concierge proof-of-concept using a curated dataset is accessible
at: https://demo-frontend-uy34.onrender.com/ | [
0.0540815778,
0.0346374363,
-0.0074290475,
0.0054886658,
-0.0360690095,
0.0151647665,
0.0041791177,
-0.0161097124,
-0.0133042634,
-0.0116829816,
0.0309094973,
0.0053557456,
0.0231634937,
0.0588870272,
0.0052581816,
-0.0550690144,
0.0479469821,
0.0351655968,
0.069017671,
-0.0116711613,
0.0232772958,
0.034732759,
-0.0436038747,
0.0686046332,
-0.0150662689,
-0.0379012823,
0.046394825,
-0.0090059591,
0.0473759547,
-0.0889249742,
0.0671883225,
0.0104536228,
0.0159923621,
0.0906750038,
0.0000016471,
-0.0204699244,
0.002622531,
0.0168608688,
-0.0401241966,
-0.0295628402,
0.0607856326,
-0.0586169735,
0.013916011,
0.048710309,
-0.0457050912,
0.0198342036,
0.0460410565,
0.0703135803,
0.0560963415,
0.0757709816,
-0.0061908853,
-0.0495949984,
0.0167895649,
-0.005253342,
0.0060393275,
-0.0110228471,
0.0335379764,
-0.0161117148,
-0.0195664335,
0.0412252471,
0.0403119698,
0.0194170009,
-0.0185845755,
-0.0231460966,
-0.00676452,
0.0098274592,
-0.0270776451,
-0.0468790717,
-0.0338090658,
0.0490290299,
0.0412065461,
-0.0573869236,
0.0370621681,
-0.0078111263,
-0.0104608992,
0.0304183569,
-0.0217117239,
-0.0258253682,
-0.0328508988,
0.0371044502,
0.0118966512,
-0.0042922855,
0.0598635152,
0.0358980298,
0.0362752303,
0.0670121834,
-0.0433630235,
-0.0366175324,
0.0036322633,
0.0085141007,
0.0478494801,
-0.0502435155,
0.0210114568,
0.014550928,
-0.040475551,
0.0082854973,
-0.0159313697,
-0.0732479095,
0.0626851395,
-0.0892577395,
-0.0181814898,
-0.0172563475,
0.0230574533,
0.0307768621,
0.0384217016,
-0.0461674891,
-0.0223922506,
0.0150482021,
0.0485611111,
-0.0229695924,
-0.0381714664,
0.0073116976,
-0.0152019737,
-0.0122053148,
0.0052750441,
0.0500284582,
-0.0563949533,
-0.0367450491,
-0.0656293705,
0.0050534816,
-0.0271756388,
0.0183164086,
-0.017084932,
-0.0035469511,
-0.0282034315,
0.0390028581,
-0.0315100178,
0.0302715544,
-0.006105287,
-0.0305662993,
-0.0000439843,
-0.0094955368,
0.0111675933,
0.0176226888,
-0.0044431328,
0.0072640236,
0.0249299966,
0.0146875791,
0.0079178438,
-0.0566225275,
-0.027014507,
-0.0335295759,
-0.0194022413,
-0.0798763633,
0.0126705701,
-0.00245951,
-0.0287399124,
-0.0225180537,
-0.0156454463,
0.0310036074,
-0.0910326019,
0.0347518921,
-0.0528773963,
-0.0165952966,
0.0833190978,
0.0455867611,
0.0222149361,
0.0514952466,
0.005878387,
0.0731113628,
0.0444401838,
0.0415129103,
0.011726005,
-0.0196623299,
0.0782739073,
0.0167113971,
0.0295896884,
-0.0194167402,
-0.02843008,
-0.0172073022,
-0.0194636043,
0.0371938683,
-0.0045050494,
-0.028758917,
0.0422211401,
0.0070189936,
-0.0525126792,
-0.0393787511,
0.0359883308,
0.0619070902,
0.0021613524,
-0.0359697118,
-0.0104652019,
0.0082218172,
-0.0450450778,
-0.0569170155,
0.0138183068,
0.0387606658,
0.0057214899,
-0.0082605155,
-0.0117615545,
0.0071315365,
0.0401358791,
-0.0153232226,
-0.0112721138,
-0.0251048058,
-0.0268835817,
0.0175294448,
0.0584419258,
0.0135487216,
-0.028167557,
-0.0314025097,
0.0226202793,
0.0488296933,
0.0301523227,
-0.0177510008,
-0.0390478112,
-0.0401358046,
0.0595704503,
0.0289845467,
0.0686056465,
-0.0297915973,
-0.0198444463,
0.0086459601,
-0.0012779186,
-0.0094102407,
0.0348203331,
-0.0188082363,
0.0525164716,
0.0474014319,
-0.0288381651,
0.0371936038,
-0.0418521017,
0.0144687323,
0.0259679016,
0.0117885675,
-0.0137121305,
0.0232721679,
0.0646978319,
0.035532169,
0.0271023586,
-0.0125818914,
0.0455626249,
0.0047393441,
-0.0093607875,
-0.0285474956,
0.001183008,
0.0086986134,
0.0201242827,
-0.0335223712,
-0.060759671,
0.0238071829,
-0.0610186532,
0.052128844,
0.0387218706,
-0.0233505629,
0.0096386829,
-0.0069289533,
-0.0415204577,
-0.0355489738,
0.0207375139,
0.0423196293,
0.0387210622,
-0.047478877,
-0.0193703771,
-0.0299767815,
-0.0431602076,
-0.0232107621,
-0.0079921084,
0.0571267903,
-0.0182995982,
0.011245382,
0.0032187947,
0.0363580137,
-0.0497599319,
-0.0053003388,
0.0256371237,
-0.0603722632,
-0.0511050299,
-0.0210375432,
0.0223301817,
0.0297470186,
0.0041706772,
0.0156868584,
-0.0063253986,
0.0044073062,
0.016881993,
0.0379668437,
0.0197647605,
0.040696688,
-0.0065882728,
0.0024964074,
-0.0091827624,
0.0310689751,
-0.0455014408,
-0.0070606684,
0.0271430593,
-0.0442101024,
-0.0076331808,
-0.0858331323,
-0.0529378802,
0.0023543751,
-0.0202052072,
-0.0298257396,
0.0327455886,
0.0436979234,
-0.023284303,
-0.0031067184,
0.0343507454,
0.0754911453,
0.0341115668,
0.0474111922,
-0.0034716153,
0.0086235749,
-0.0512882955,
0.0259095524,
-0.0385688283,
-0.0459305756,
0.0276596844,
0.0883160904,
0.0202882532,
0.0183222704,
-0.0281180069,
0.0602181405,
-0.0139170596,
-0.0402377099,
-0.0336265713,
-0.0273197647,
-0.0137285721,
0.0400836021,
-0.0425720625,
-0.0219398476,
0.0572348125,
0.0012304359,
0.0493791141,
-0.059827514,
-0.0452982076,
0.0176534709,
-0.0337260403,
-0.016149966,
0.030529581,
0.011719035,
0.0168951396,
0.0449516848,
-0.0424305648,
0.0307656396,
-0.0276252516,
-0.0214030705,
-0.0349245369,
0.0075122286,
0.0470188223,
-0.0254543759,
-0.0435395017,
-0.0870404318,
-0.0726619512,
-0.0303658862,
0.0148631325,
-0.0361471698,
-0.096367985,
-0.0587224215,
0.0207023583,
0.0413993299,
0.0365337133,
-0.0125687867,
0.040378429,
-0.0210638884,
-0.0002202659,
-0.0191581249,
0.0416252986,
-0.0197287276,
-0.0096093174,
0.0808818862,
-0.0408312678,
-0.0250871107,
-0.02391004,
-0.0367802903,
-0.0260485765,
-0.011850711,
0.0035230683,
-0.0002820494,
0.0423718467,
-0.0454731919,
0.0035952781,
0.0552172177,
0.0309374761,
-0.0056311605,
0.0086495746,
-0.0074815848,
0.0084079867,
-0.00394138,
0.0045925011,
-0.0636928678,
-0.0114983814,
-0.0041430662,
0.0238960944,
-0.0594064705,
-0.0313799195,
-0.0213766117,
-0.0268919747,
0.0553511158,
-0.0027523551,
0.0038419962,
-0.041215919,
-0.0514092892,
-0.006647021,
0.0200782493,
0.0030750441,
-0.0372858159,
0.0308077615,
-0.0073388983,
-0.0102745686,
-0.0597691648,
-0.0551992543,
0.0006217246,
0.0068183616,
0.0396051295,
0.0227469858,
0.0757325888,
0.0117938612,
-0.0338483602,
0.0031572238,
0.0279021598,
-0.0556355156,
-0.0307809133,
0.0938882381,
-0.0224161129,
0.0008406755,
-0.0552680567,
0.0176737774,
-0.0009460141,
-0.0538156033,
-0.010839181,
0.0568565205,
-0.0158684626,
-0.0399096422,
-0.0464069061,
0.0661820471,
0.0507440567,
0.0521694385,
0.0257216133,
0.0276149381,
-0.0177947488,
-0.0352955349,
0.0204438567,
-0.0441574715,
-0.0153780961,
0.0055628708,
0.0249037631,
-0.0564875789,
-0.0501866899,
-0.006224094,
-0.0033980536,
-0.023402961,
-0.0335894562,
-0.0329010934,
0.0336319134,
-0.0069896984,
-0.0406958945,
-0.0426683761,
-0.0130778523,
0.0398520529,
-0.0291327517,
-0.0404525772,
-0.0375048965,
0.0344483405,
-0.0250998344,
0.0454733968,
-0.0504529476,
-0.0722014755,
0.0218363591,
0.0054002791,
0.0203238651,
0.0300296582,
-0.0291681923,
-0.0162222534,
0.1043484285,
0.051391311,
-0.047652714,
-0.0431142598,
0.0162104629,
0.0003537289,
0.0379876457,
0.0129777817,
0.0048416532,
0.0155208167,
-0.0172119085,
-0.0210170653,
-0.0760836005,
0.0384261571,
0.000992372,
-0.0068991268,
0.0647881851,
0.0023304014,
-0.009638845,
-0.0330930836,
-0.017099373,
0.0015789302,
-0.0297541469,
0.026853865,
0.0094242655,
-0.0025915385,
-0.0345310867,
-0.0270667113,
0.051433336,
-0.040900629,
0.0054452489,
-0.033091072,
0.0186214726,
0.0029943159,
0.0565106198,
0.0434570499,
-0.0220482033,
0.0234414767,
0.0192634556,
-0.0048185037,
0.0201007668,
-0.0076331333,
-0.0290387738,
-0.0117737018,
-0.00801141,
0.0095156217,
-0.0124749634,
-0.0426127836,
-0.0417332202,
-0.0203200113,
0.0357638337,
0.0064717131,
0.0197649226,
0.0287540648,
-0.0091550834,
-0.0560278483,
0.0049513793,
0.0042991396,
-0.0347529314,
-0.0162571911,
0.0175968893,
-0.0266136788,
-0.0404414162,
0.0177941415,
0.0558295213,
-0.0213713311,
0.044487562,
0.0601932257,
-0.07857766,
-0.0243440736,
-0.03069661,
-0.0252511594,
0.0549072921,
-0.0053882604,
0.029669486,
-0.0525667444,
-0.0325063244,
0.0571691655,
-0.0178792328,
-0.0036171286,
0.0105588567,
-0.0283886772,
0.0460117124,
0.0217503179,
-0.0047343583,
-0.075724788,
0.0285702646,
0.0016585903,
-0.0537420809,
-0.0101754386,
-6.352266412e-33,
0.0203479193,
-0.0562782884,
-0.0108068474,
0.0082479585,
0.0119973999,
0.0249618068,
-0.0207905043,
-0.0180104766,
-0.0042141755,
0.0965260044,
0.0315700769,
0.0480871201,
-0.004702962,
-0.0076996023,
-0.0270734131,
-0.0042137112,
0.048498828,
-0.0196927041,
-0.0140047986,
0.0284201913,
0.039978385,
0.0137124937,
0.0201785229,
-0.0998685434,
0.0594481528,
-0.0197893921,
-0.0060830619,
0.0475276895,
-0.0063693291,
0.0492691286,
0.0078525776,
0.057830207,
0.0439712629,
-0.0097527485,
0.0184822138,
0.0519868582,
-0.0539259464,
-0.038677562,
0.0058729067,
-0.0402852111,
-0.058733467,
-0.0376605168,
0.0410690233,
0.026423825,
-0.0310189575,
0.024069624,
0.0062430059,
0.0048188693,
0.016899094,
-0.0051590386,
-0.0468037054,
0.013143504,
-0.021052748,
0.0190909076,
-0.0145314746,
0.0636444539,
0.0087533789,
0.0691381246,
-0.0798801556,
0.0168669559,
-0.0325429067,
-0.0156192938,
0.0194707345,
-0.0476071686,
-0.0245705321,
0.0497482195,
-0.0041240989,
0.0188185908,
-0.0621236935,
0.042668771,
-0.0360056981,
0.0202902053,
0.0329888947,
0.0773524567,
0.0166992173,
-0.0770671889,
-0.1039410979,
0.0263857879,
-0.0153406961,
0.0421078093,
-0.0092289951,
-0.0279711671,
-0.029317243,
0.0031780319,
0.0053202021,
-0.0401641615,
-0.0119192069,
0.0074349879,
-0.0361416377,
0.0306495912,
-0.0296205673,
0.0547898449,
-0.0371088013,
-0.016732756,
-0.0069720531,
0.0162972193,
0.0270544402,
-0.0331240483,
0.0467940234,
0.0389765352,
-0.0677226037,
0.0426341631,
0.0004446004,
0.006190286,
0.0189217124,
-0.0089012692,
0.0660833046,
-0.0221383572,
-0.0473805889,
0.0094355578,
-0.0121653816,
0.0669278502,
-0.0251163654,
-0.0081935721,
0.0414108746,
0.0261602942,
0.0128937606,
0.0163717978,
0.0001579335,
0.0364001356,
0.0126562556,
-0.0283675212,
-0.0498978868,
0.0204193331,
-0.0349113196,
-0.001049522,
-0.0316648819,
0.022062337,
0.0059033246,
-0.078365624,
-0.000436529,
-0.0362829491,
2.492e-7,
0.0690712631,
0.0856484771,
-0.0133959334,
-0.0168681089,
0.0513146482,
0.0220430214,
0.0004896182,
0.0128156189,
-0.0296937749,
-0.0714546889,
-0.0132684642,
0.0310629942,
0.0125585394,
0.0649063066,
-0.023234291,
-0.0034971987,
-0.0522438399,
-0.0021243417,
-0.044535242,
0.0035633398,
-0.0122224065,
0.0308383256,
0.0251796953,
-0.0118935676,
-0.0187608209,
0.0421691164,
0.0391861461,
0.0087581631,
-0.024663128,
-0.0022787591,
0.0419154428,
0.0020089408,
0.0235908274,
0.0039109169,
-0.0579576455,
-0.0382625386,
-0.0651222467,
0.0160972513,
-0.0036675469,
-0.0083891116,
-0.0345243104,
-0.0462875627,
0.0123623498,
-0.0317763165,
0.0123956697,
-0.0352742337,
-0.0641200095,
-0.0384710617,
-0.0319679379,
0.025194671,
0.0340219662,
0.0070114345,
-0.0456456579,
0.0195976309,
0.0032252723,
0.0266595334,
-0.0014140169,
-0.0477784388,
0.0264725611,
0.0242498368,
-0.0323088355,
-0.0302810874,
0.0381934159,
-0.0179753266,
0.0119198151,
0.0081393914,
0.0820660517,
1.803447336e-34,
0.0467528962,
0.0025866732,
-0.0286682881,
-0.0422174223,
0.042090565,
0.0033924712,
-0.0034968094,
-0.0287394598,
0.0250425842,
-0.0086087622,
0.0352377892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13259v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13259v2 | Knowledge-Driven CoT: Exploring Faithful Reasoning in LLMs for Knowledge-intensive Question Answering | 2023-08-25T09:23:55 | 2023-10-28T12:19:29 | Keheng Wang, Feiyu Duan, Sirui Wang, Peiguang Li, Yunsen Xian, Chuantao Yin, Wenge Rong, Zhang Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Equipped with Chain-of-Thought (CoT), Large language models (LLMs) have shown
impressive reasoning ability in various downstream tasks. Even so, suffering
from hallucinations and the inability to access external knowledge, LLMs often
come with incorrect or unfaithful intermediate reasoning steps, especially in
the context of answering knowledge-intensive tasks such as KBQA. To alleviate
this issue, we propose a framework called Knowledge-Driven Chain-of-Thought
(KD-CoT) to verify and modify reasoning traces in CoT via interaction with
external knowledge, and thus overcome the hallucinations and error propagation.
Concretely, we formulate the CoT rationale process of LLMs into a structured
multi-round QA format. In each round, LLMs interact with a QA system that
retrieves external knowledge and produce faithful reasoning traces based on
retrieved precise answers. The structured CoT reasoning of LLMs is facilitated
by our developed KBQA CoT collection, which serves as in-context learning
demonstrations and can also be utilized as feedback augmentation to train a
robust retriever. Extensive experiments on WebQSP and ComplexWebQuestion
datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of proposed KD-CoT in task-solving
reasoning generation, which outperforms the vanilla CoT ICL with an absolute
success rate of 8.0% and 5.1%. Furthermore, our proposed feedback-augmented
retriever outperforms the state-of-the-art baselines for retrieving knowledge,
achieving significant improvement in Hit and recall performance. Our code and
data are released on https://github.com/AdelWang/KD-CoT/tree/main. | [
0.0442422628,
0.0185056441,
-0.0013514017,
0.0523456223,
-0.0398305058,
0.01954953,
-0.0281914826,
-0.0070751924,
0.0243604593,
-0.0511304364,
-0.0283436999,
-0.0206593275,
-0.0353647321,
0.0072165597,
0.0325448215,
-0.0073534651,
0.0568078496,
-0.0432720408,
-0.0184646249,
-0.012722265,
-0.0116372909,
0.0169252567,
-0.0380281471,
0.0253219027,
-0.0202072673,
-0.0624045692,
-0.0237340871,
-0.0000255005,
0.0278223883,
-0.0283667557,
0.0266719013,
0.0466879345,
0.0232725646,
0.0200188998,
0.0000022444,
-0.0640395284,
-0.0199262165,
0.0068153054,
-0.060187649,
-0.023539057,
-0.0924981683,
0.0378541648,
0.0235735383,
0.0357643478,
-0.030635532,
0.0607321896,
0.0073218234,
0.059466444,
0.0675872937,
0.0639405772,
0.0179565027,
-0.030020142,
0.0250688642,
0.01102152,
0.0446447209,
-0.0487903468,
0.032915242,
0.0523678809,
0.0385145135,
0.0323733427,
0.0031793409,
0.0303331409,
0.0438736118,
-0.0020866117,
-0.0166714713,
0.0174764711,
-0.029067548,
0.0033872742,
-0.0016014155,
0.0772229508,
0.0147408294,
-0.0359771773,
-0.0029363022,
0.0262854844,
-0.0033029767,
-0.007224279,
-0.0524793155,
0.0404086038,
-0.0373132788,
-0.0156425778,
-0.0156656113,
0.0157791618,
0.0165477712,
0.0125116706,
-0.0609045811,
0.0698522404,
0.0007212673,
-0.0547605231,
0.0225640573,
0.0248890445,
-0.0287766438,
-0.0457106121,
0.0006644258,
0.0717535168,
-0.0361563265,
0.0404806025,
0.0157725811,
-0.0004335015,
0.0298281573,
-0.0222821478,
0.0055471398,
0.0349313803,
-0.0364835225,
0.0596786961,
-0.0484048538,
0.0490954109,
-0.0219569206,
0.042131912,
-0.0195696671,
-0.0243352316,
-0.069082059,
-0.0371971354,
-0.0233166628,
0.0775965899,
-0.0063590207,
-0.001368506,
0.0040199035,
0.0455290228,
-0.0125391195,
0.024410814,
0.0270820707,
0.0272682272,
0.0209222361,
-0.0358729735,
-0.065890111,
0.0175996274,
-0.0452856012,
0.01462078,
0.0431116372,
-0.0378952771,
-0.0417542048,
-0.011985749,
0.0033675437,
-0.0277223438,
0.0131676216,
0.0348118991,
-0.0159179363,
0.0004863906,
-0.0489435345,
-0.0478359461,
-0.0108197248,
-0.0596890189,
-0.0127108162,
-0.0680432394,
0.0398486443,
0.0068595503,
-0.0267697871,
-0.0240661204,
0.0301974509,
0.0623161085,
-0.0163363405,
0.0598591417,
-0.0231118798,
-0.0104692541,
-0.0127414009,
0.0267066695,
-0.0417557769,
0.0541294627,
0.0145672401,
0.0209908485,
0.0305268634,
0.0294516813,
0.0136715034,
-0.0152750267,
0.0340244062,
-0.0071118711,
0.0030907255,
0.0607127659,
-0.0094287116,
0.0225050598,
-0.0044698152,
0.0340982042,
-0.0219647773,
0.0191976856,
0.0356330723,
0.0062665329,
0.0051224898,
0.0116529176,
0.0297136437,
-0.0076039503,
0.022698734,
-0.0009385793,
-0.0543265305,
0.0519486815,
-0.0700357184,
0.0061197528,
0.0160713773,
0.006749155,
-0.0383265279,
-0.0432009399,
-0.0025364913,
0.0380163267,
-0.0219516158,
0.0551435351,
0.0317042992,
0.0240719616,
-0.0326781906,
0.0603567734,
0.0207442269,
-0.0139733134,
-0.015492307,
-0.0620170049,
0.0440906957,
0.0477300882,
0.0414486527,
-0.0245642103,
-0.0600272454,
-0.0080537936,
0.0121798292,
0.0327477157,
-0.0158034097,
-0.0165786967,
-0.0353974514,
-0.0298136063,
-0.0251077078,
-0.0270734224,
-0.0156236449,
-0.020815447,
0.0327158943,
0.0208733827,
0.0104694087,
-0.0411732942,
0.0330162905,
0.0160910506,
-0.0114940805,
-0.0153440284,
-0.0155699812,
0.0157362763,
0.0074714581,
0.0207678378,
0.0171806365,
0.0323801935,
0.0226591062,
-0.0307556707,
-0.0593755618,
0.0034708926,
-0.0442764759,
-0.066644676,
0.0487653129,
0.0206680615,
-0.0320240855,
0.009903932,
-0.0345816463,
-0.0355304182,
-0.0106576467,
-0.0301468261,
0.0242415965,
-0.04334452,
-0.0191556644,
0.03495555,
-0.0147124073,
-0.0260414612,
0.0971324891,
-0.0185820702,
-0.0046475874,
-0.0050465749,
0.0050522066,
-0.0003757593,
-0.0025254763,
0.0180418901,
-0.0090558371,
-0.0076849549,
0.0155726224,
0.0073490315,
0.0144871389,
-0.0763702691,
-0.0096206246,
-0.0737813041,
0.0250050947,
-0.0225745495,
0.0241950154,
0.0264490265,
0.0033870679,
0.0075459033,
-0.0048369435,
-0.0676836744,
-0.0059715649,
0.0122304652,
0.0125399707,
0.0224313214,
0.0200270414,
-0.0107449619,
0.0074501615,
0.0102636414,
-0.0325142145,
0.0282569658,
-0.0316987447,
-0.0070884372,
-0.0522052087,
0.0286683999,
-0.0617249645,
0.0146090938,
-0.011024761,
0.0052993982,
0.0323989727,
-0.0107310219,
0.0278958008,
0.0649136975,
0.0110973818,
-0.0266999993,
0.0276184641,
-0.0224906579,
-0.0600679517,
0.0577904843,
0.000166842,
-0.040788509,
0.0004339485,
-0.0058022309,
0.0067045563,
0.0607993454,
-0.008422236,
-0.012291545,
-0.0634783059,
0.0040664002,
0.0142150838,
-0.0030823962,
-0.0533403344,
0.0087366626,
-0.0056913309,
0.0471206121,
-0.0215992741,
0.0099934256,
0.0755497292,
-0.0082415566,
0.0085303793,
-0.0390842557,
0.0273810588,
-0.0258400906,
0.0679789931,
-0.0356137529,
0.0023805192,
-0.0106199356,
0.0064159771,
-0.0463918671,
-0.0183623619,
-0.0157679208,
-0.0541572794,
0.0411809608,
-0.043047864,
0.0256860685,
0.0120157283,
-0.0515800342,
-0.0899976566,
0.0304519534,
-0.0290646665,
0.0091925459,
-0.0412674807,
0.0028329208,
0.0089884689,
-0.016544411,
0.0633358657,
-0.0019401567,
-0.0234922059,
-0.0247178487,
-0.0181207396,
0.0498614758,
0.0880741775,
0.0271192752,
0.0624039099,
-0.0019047643,
0.0241980702,
0.0934793279,
0.0394359268,
0.0016709309,
0.0241201036,
-0.0069817794,
-0.0086188726,
-0.0018660877,
0.0034701526,
0.0121980533,
0.0537732989,
-0.0623301789,
-0.039483048,
0.10156928,
0.0512783118,
-0.0269959513,
-0.0132073639,
-0.04847496,
0.0360063948,
0.025328856,
0.0364626236,
-0.1043793559,
-0.0397448018,
0.0218588132,
0.0276638437,
-0.0187187865,
-0.0548776351,
0.0086617777,
-0.1296507269,
0.014864793,
-0.0207906943,
0.0057104845,
-0.035105478,
-0.0375555381,
0.0144882305,
0.0389807969,
0.021118341,
0.0604066066,
0.0160108991,
-0.0008198714,
0.0326539129,
-0.0038422435,
-0.0133016948,
0.0785392895,
-0.0182853024,
0.0091711022,
0.0405228063,
0.0069246641,
0.0273968913,
-0.061467804,
0.0062495102,
-0.0554105155,
0.0037756087,
-0.0016120339,
-0.0119135687,
-0.0090984982,
-0.0153858196,
-0.027596131,
0.0441586562,
-0.0612279959,
-0.0126012806,
0.0357949473,
0.1039856672,
-0.0419719741,
-0.0186851677,
-0.009137582,
-0.0011510088,
-0.0256528948,
0.0715397224,
0.0198042784,
-0.016164491,
-0.037503764,
-0.0178489853,
-0.0439586602,
-0.0469894968,
-0.0452610441,
0.055128295,
0.0437222943,
0.0611581728,
-0.0885846168,
-0.0595236868,
0.0457869098,
0.074114576,
-0.0284723788,
0.0194193739,
-0.0137563078,
0.0113567971,
-0.0346310623,
0.027509734,
-0.0787980929,
-0.0025693846,
-0.0237465855,
0.0121941427,
0.0100026457,
-0.0338614918,
-0.023853451,
0.0239646398,
-0.0729194283,
-0.0306719188,
-0.0381455645,
0.0656691119,
0.0162306242,
0.0580175817,
-0.022367252,
-0.003056603,
0.0162218604,
0.0112781888,
-0.0453677885,
-0.0062340251,
0.0173031539,
0.0229962356,
0.0023356478,
0.0384540893,
-0.0728335828,
-0.0127307009,
-0.0048269737,
0.0937385932,
0.0042203786,
0.0028562334,
0.058773078,
0.0241119601,
-0.0217406489,
0.0213586595,
0.0015150239,
0.0014567942,
0.0619345345,
-0.0318437591,
-0.0314254835,
-0.0365435369,
0.0303120669,
-0.0025051506,
-0.0523661338,
0.0084759286,
-0.0497578457,
-0.0075640492,
0.0167659577,
-0.0224998984,
-0.0343554616,
0.0154631715,
0.0301962905,
0.0450009331,
-0.0333439596,
-0.0309285391,
-0.013863395,
0.0275098085,
0.0750676543,
-0.009728577,
0.0743529201,
0.0663802922,
-0.0302743707,
-0.0605117492,
0.0150788222,
-0.0505801328,
-0.0742909536,
0.0051764231,
-0.0032147826,
0.0392554402,
0.0301622301,
0.0048617739,
-0.0302424114,
-0.002899254,
0.0160210673,
-0.0055645318,
0.0315127112,
-0.0084242579,
0.0275057312,
0.0352812745,
0.0035399138,
-0.0139176482,
0.0606475696,
-0.0415618829,
0.0345973261,
-0.009580683,
-0.0062776892,
-0.0363914147,
-0.0324847698,
-0.0351335779,
0.0112910094,
0.0038795038,
-0.0029096797,
-0.0416137353,
-0.0917087868,
0.0216983389,
-0.0138803832,
-0.0135855312,
0.0134348981,
0.0349101275,
0.0656190664,
0.0251810681,
-0.053457167,
-0.0070537874,
0.0097952867,
0.0113217095,
-0.0259639025,
0.0042323875,
-6.788323388e-33,
-0.0063993582,
-0.020005649,
0.0603099018,
-0.0008815033,
-0.0135363061,
-0.0288260877,
-0.0505046658,
-0.0227594115,
-0.0270548556,
0.0120588047,
-0.0196782034,
-0.0031422821,
-0.002045403,
0.0355660394,
0.0117455432,
-0.0384059362,
-0.0024004751,
0.0066823959,
-0.0019907882,
0.0282095429,
0.0497785695,
0.0176172275,
0.0375443138,
-0.03709938,
0.0137534188,
-0.0172276981,
-0.0032348938,
0.0594657362,
-0.0490994751,
0.0483571328,
-0.018619366,
0.0129040712,
0.0389928557,
-0.0205017962,
0.0107069528,
-0.0123876622,
-0.1002058759,
-0.0211889334,
0.0241826344,
-0.0112261204,
-0.0655372217,
-0.0149110639,
0.0183615163,
-0.0085369963,
0.0473679453,
-0.0336476192,
0.0048158932,
-0.0162933692,
-0.0026650245,
-0.0176928304,
-0.0232055336,
-0.0099107847,
-0.004243697,
-0.0355794504,
-0.0385547094,
0.0614049248,
-0.0027776433,
0.0043738661,
-0.0454763323,
-0.0221840721,
-0.0259322003,
0.0038844247,
0.0558537319,
-0.0030609414,
0.0109030288,
0.0477434844,
0.0035040001,
-0.009053167,
-0.071635291,
-0.0053753764,
-0.012978632,
0.055524338,
0.0485761873,
0.0223100707,
-0.0057588923,
0.0231689624,
-0.0968234539,
0.0065930905,
-0.0090660695,
0.0555609353,
0.0301957019,
-0.013159384,
-0.0384122282,
-0.0019437753,
-0.0414848104,
0.0504895374,
-0.0522633903,
-0.0239571501,
0.067857042,
0.01138712,
-0.0138467718,
-0.0225684773,
0.0219737515,
-0.0285655279,
0.0241466761,
0.0399135612,
-0.0181357879,
0.015039634,
-0.0149431406,
0.0349412076,
-0.027389599,
0.0068964483,
0.0261051096,
-0.0174439866,
-0.0123850806,
0.0348278359,
0.0431217961,
-0.0038508528,
-0.0322027206,
-0.0001757676,
-0.0857171491,
0.0526535511,
-0.0114634074,
-0.0150815649,
0.0343000665,
0.0448938459,
-0.0182478987,
0.0278069042,
0.0007123143,
-0.0063209669,
-0.0095658917,
0.028433742,
-0.0168969352,
0.0084562311,
-0.0233960133,
-0.005396002,
-0.0273040235,
0.0052966434,
-0.0387246758,
-0.0722794831,
0.005961197,
0.0303497203,
2.995e-7,
0.0115800193,
0.0436731242,
0.0123747448,
0.0377539322,
0.0199162103,
0.0058331075,
-0.0065685376,
-0.005482222,
0.0352054834,
-0.0910738483,
-0.0110025471,
0.058578711,
0.0249848273,
0.0423652008,
-0.0841321424,
-0.0123154419,
-0.0442531481,
-0.0573117472,
-0.0516509451,
-0.0325894579,
0.0660271347,
0.0431468524,
0.0043712067,
-0.0223677903,
0.0295744501,
-0.0353211239,
0.0493877791,
0.028459888,
0.0004500024,
-0.0094470931,
0.0308027547,
-0.0128194001,
0.0442416482,
0.0509712324,
0.0078469636,
0.0146974744,
-0.0162229519,
0.025500752,
-0.0075096395,
-0.0683010146,
-0.0454562195,
-0.0340022668,
0.0381896608,
-0.0881976262,
0.1007309631,
-0.0087250927,
0.0006322077,
0.0093418937,
-0.0190860219,
-0.0396396965,
-0.0331427865,
0.005839461,
0.0015716928,
0.0219220761,
0.0090413466,
0.0285177864,
0.0151845198,
-0.1044312641,
-0.0096283397,
0.0331660956,
-0.0350128897,
-0.0141820386,
-0.020457495,
-0.0316922367,
0.0016142735,
-0.0518099219,
-0.0050089601,
2.957941434e-34,
0.0127193574,
-0.0056243995,
0.0537066609,
0.0450847298,
0.0482316427,
0.0071735783,
0.0125431363,
-0.0051271208,
0.0251305606,
-0.0927380547,
-0.0221272819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13207v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13207v1 | LLM2KB: Constructing Knowledge Bases using instruction tuned context aware Large Language Models | 2023-08-25T07:04:16 | 2023-08-25T07:04:16 | Anmol Nayak, Hari Prasad Timmapathini | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advent of Large Language Models (LLM) has revolutionized the field of
natural language processing, enabling significant progress in various
applications. One key area of interest is the construction of Knowledge Bases
(KB) using these powerful models. Knowledge bases serve as repositories of
structured information, facilitating information retrieval and inference tasks.
Our paper proposes LLM2KB, a system for constructing knowledge bases using
large language models, with a focus on the Llama 2 architecture and the
Wikipedia dataset. We perform parameter efficient instruction tuning for
Llama-2-13b-chat and StableBeluga-13B by training small injection models that
have only 0.05 % of the parameters of the base models using the Low Rank
Adaptation (LoRA) technique. These injection models have been trained with
prompts that are engineered to utilize Wikipedia page contexts of subject
entities fetched using a Dense Passage Retrieval (DPR) algorithm, to answer
relevant object entities for a given subject entity and relation. Our best
performing model achieved an average F1 score of 0.6185 across 21 relations in
the LM-KBC challenge held at the ISWC 2023 conference. | [
0.0829697773,
0.0255581141,
-0.0088468036,
0.0795645788,
0.010431082,
0.04088974,
-0.0191292651,
0.0274733305,
0.0678010881,
-0.0649283081,
-0.0297112763,
-0.0339680612,
-0.0352245122,
0.0025866432,
0.0098656798,
-0.0344890133,
0.0277464893,
-0.0291443858,
-0.0005089409,
-0.0123252822,
-0.0201079994,
0.0135520138,
-0.010700684,
-0.0252049435,
0.0325312093,
0.0087167798,
-0.0055993828,
0.0179018434,
0.0015243343,
-0.0275700297,
0.0333988592,
0.033983022,
0.0370252989,
-0.0074349409,
0.0000021292,
-0.066148974,
-0.0147300577,
-0.0077162157,
-0.082208775,
0.015154914,
0.0203950107,
0.0024603391,
0.0073603997,
0.0031855041,
-0.0078719584,
-0.0085851569,
0.0315213464,
0.0573605075,
0.0645700619,
0.0944049656,
-0.0058271512,
-0.0575944036,
0.040073175,
-0.0162558891,
0.05213622,
-0.0488741025,
0.0515945554,
0.0006272244,
-0.0050834562,
0.053585615,
0.0000732684,
0.0152150989,
-0.012550313,
0.0002860098,
0.0490596779,
0.0283922292,
-0.0122934915,
-0.0160875693,
-0.0040627937,
0.1016450524,
0.0277513471,
0.0090251192,
0.0060669254,
0.026197277,
-0.0063462644,
0.0043287994,
-0.0334990956,
0.0067237518,
-0.0215970781,
-0.0089517646,
0.0410424359,
-0.0310944431,
0.0204056334,
0.0199642349,
-0.0437776335,
0.0588783436,
0.0469850712,
-0.0287012253,
0.0231375732,
-0.0098392293,
-0.0392455161,
-0.041740071,
-0.0093799923,
0.065892309,
-0.0302362256,
0.0302305967,
-0.0224712659,
0.0256438516,
0.0270492174,
-0.0799954385,
-0.0167625602,
0.034848094,
-0.008833603,
0.0649952218,
-0.0364724211,
0.0346576124,
-0.0391269326,
-0.0003766458,
-0.0333952866,
0.0143912621,
-0.0353475958,
0.0146356365,
-0.0109138135,
0.0514286309,
-0.0777953118,
-0.0176818203,
-0.0130879004,
0.0529559627,
0.0246647559,
0.004119894,
0.0141694881,
-0.0058301031,
-0.0298703872,
0.0062256809,
-0.0609133728,
0.0196190476,
-0.0194409713,
0.0201878175,
-0.0250843968,
-0.0339523368,
0.0039687646,
-0.0077118487,
0.0303693712,
-0.0348399878,
0.0387785658,
0.0632448122,
0.0098364055,
-0.0458580256,
-0.0555518456,
-0.0059179426,
0.0045966157,
-0.0652957931,
0.007513335,
-0.0596023574,
0.041177582,
0.0180135034,
0.0157615114,
-0.0394110233,
0.0374916457,
0.020724168,
-0.0629174262,
0.0661361292,
-0.0272514187,
-0.0206155423,
0.0336837023,
0.0321096294,
-0.001852666,
0.078525193,
0.0105775157,
0.0042064437,
0.0472250432,
0.0129325185,
-0.0605529286,
0.0085094608,
0.0138197197,
0.0262547452,
0.0197614525,
0.0488024279,
0.0182153359,
0.0315916315,
0.0247052312,
0.0334844738,
-0.0120900208,
0.0014791336,
0.0267568324,
0.0319397561,
0.0329999737,
0.0331761837,
0.0401329212,
-0.0012814393,
0.024130743,
-0.0231974088,
-0.0413714424,
0.0098167639,
-0.0473529585,
0.0048404974,
0.0093334299,
0.0444842875,
-0.0193021372,
-0.0082516391,
-0.0012436458,
0.0124921966,
-0.0562574603,
0.020080559,
0.0467347987,
-0.0103840344,
-0.0422722474,
0.0749173611,
0.0647677183,
-0.0375181064,
0.0065711467,
-0.0448966585,
0.0365143605,
0.0786377713,
0.0295498539,
-0.0397474766,
-0.0591114797,
0.0024414151,
0.0255178884,
0.0359736271,
0.0137522956,
-0.0465018488,
-0.0081009781,
-0.0384537466,
-0.0208989102,
-0.0025262835,
0.0046555642,
0.0203063656,
0.0377430804,
0.0042092605,
0.0181135945,
-0.0206357129,
-0.0008148457,
0.033445891,
-0.0414339602,
-0.029327048,
-0.0162979886,
0.0062613916,
0.0195764862,
0.0362258926,
-0.0068210308,
-0.0125583792,
0.0648861825,
-0.049585335,
-0.0024730081,
-0.0419812687,
-0.0214432944,
-0.0581634715,
0.05071529,
0.0246673133,
0.0284233987,
-0.0040641963,
-0.0267101154,
-0.0300823897,
-0.004301447,
-0.0149743585,
0.0630628765,
-0.0026461333,
0.0169566311,
-0.0014883976,
0.0104442053,
-0.0496750101,
0.0985384881,
-0.0026619411,
0.0289160497,
0.0763692036,
0.0080007222,
-0.0108906887,
-0.0206742715,
-0.04195337,
0.0198535994,
0.0170198288,
0.0030859604,
-0.0005701537,
0.0112406127,
-0.0826657414,
-0.0296207871,
-0.1038622335,
0.0373458341,
-0.0105220769,
0.0315006077,
0.0340803526,
0.0151666626,
-0.0072817006,
-0.006707008,
-0.0087518599,
0.0143137062,
-0.0327858739,
0.0257385205,
0.0182234868,
0.0426030681,
-0.0380414501,
-0.0438148156,
-0.0227955095,
-0.0167163666,
0.0363186412,
-0.0023092038,
-0.0077345297,
-0.045218844,
0.0794095024,
-0.0186628606,
0.0157984626,
-0.0215905439,
-0.0061778426,
-0.0072943955,
-0.033352457,
0.0478069857,
0.0676351339,
0.0022502942,
0.026738679,
0.0257455651,
-0.0237197261,
-0.0428043269,
0.0263391268,
0.0012243292,
-0.027333688,
-0.043787729,
-0.0089536645,
-0.0127110509,
0.0461733267,
-0.0319181122,
-0.0146577675,
-0.0474295132,
0.0060919812,
0.0005921729,
-0.0030608242,
-0.0513270758,
0.0105368402,
0.0017820256,
0.0059779063,
-0.041253034,
0.0127380108,
0.0497290716,
-0.0216579009,
0.0184300579,
-0.0405007377,
0.0069848215,
-0.0399771668,
0.0281487498,
-0.0070893639,
0.0260410681,
-0.0267388523,
0.004689625,
-0.0499476269,
0.0456507206,
0.0131837856,
-0.0437976792,
0.0472200476,
-0.028497085,
0.0216587521,
-0.0237035621,
-0.0287981089,
-0.0460752696,
-0.0309570841,
-0.0154246949,
0.0001419424,
0.0059877858,
-0.0168801863,
-0.0015362005,
0.000190906,
0.0261810031,
-0.003122424,
0.0012649259,
-0.0024196003,
-0.0257424749,
0.0478993207,
0.071597904,
0.0115740253,
0.020403713,
0.0023724525,
0.070017986,
0.0237323605,
0.0185086448,
-0.0281855799,
0.0211091302,
0.0450556092,
0.0331679136,
-0.0586299561,
-0.0259082355,
0.0182982497,
0.0254605189,
-0.0389038771,
-0.0245995391,
0.1029870287,
0.0156705379,
-0.0572875403,
-0.0256416313,
-0.0128207197,
0.0166197773,
0.0537391081,
0.0446717553,
-0.0655429661,
-0.0127195669,
-0.0029199154,
0.0166349169,
0.0079899244,
-0.0468955711,
0.0030160001,
-0.1346214116,
-0.0081892768,
-0.0057625244,
-0.0328668319,
-0.0429089516,
-0.0649110004,
0.0211183112,
0.011101014,
-0.0127366381,
0.0339595675,
-0.032994695,
-0.0155487638,
0.0121031487,
0.0251420699,
-0.0619669221,
0.0279517751,
-0.0259689745,
0.0903550312,
-0.0012572679,
0.0200865176,
-0.01077154,
0.0085099144,
-0.0147237079,
-0.0577735715,
-0.0207352899,
-0.0046713245,
0.0477025025,
-0.0163139105,
-0.0134061687,
-0.0264717303,
0.0107043078,
-0.0379773453,
0.0045630247,
-0.0086659687,
0.081737645,
0.0116760097,
0.0107984664,
-0.0027557805,
-0.0302367713,
0.0129571864,
0.0568004847,
0.0230969936,
-0.0178468022,
0.0149728805,
-0.0082923435,
-0.0186524577,
-0.0213593189,
-0.0351748951,
0.0116616134,
-0.0651571825,
0.0039958898,
-0.0767164826,
-0.010421088,
0.0267382786,
0.0172398482,
0.0223054625,
0.0237671155,
-0.0022817964,
-0.00293536,
-0.0398606732,
0.0257317722,
-0.0357670896,
-0.0003009946,
-0.0487873852,
-0.0203661043,
0.0410241783,
-0.0292169861,
-0.0087115392,
-0.0179151651,
-0.0511814877,
-0.0679095089,
0.0202677045,
0.0541835204,
0.0126791531,
0.03268997,
-0.0140290568,
-0.0419051871,
0.0546615236,
0.0318454765,
-0.0607233495,
0.0249972343,
-0.0116726095,
0.0231562443,
-0.0159792043,
0.0341974795,
-0.0694575906,
-0.0070776814,
0.0125030074,
0.0481837839,
-0.0137947248,
-0.0572804436,
-0.0002994243,
0.021507645,
-0.0144945197,
0.0120792016,
-0.0564490929,
-0.0503224395,
0.0598325841,
-0.0214184858,
-0.0155780464,
-0.0088157514,
-0.011720934,
0.026839925,
-0.038791582,
0.0000248774,
-0.017924035,
0.0216618646,
0.0535917878,
-0.0349664874,
0.006211258,
0.049381841,
0.0251074508,
0.0412602387,
0.0039039324,
-0.030008249,
-0.0149421003,
0.0177984592,
0.0386498384,
-0.0592700467,
0.0410141721,
-0.0021344817,
-0.0469022952,
-0.0301172547,
0.0160034038,
-0.0369010009,
-0.0374502242,
-0.0306013711,
0.0363223515,
0.0801056027,
0.0047995532,
0.0567037277,
0.0052982923,
-0.0412657857,
-0.008073315,
-0.0110748271,
0.0012117858,
0.0029813738,
0.0708655939,
0.0558575131,
0.0161299612,
0.0365932584,
0.0582776144,
0.0465279035,
0.0843381137,
0.03055414,
-0.0117488904,
-0.0323670916,
-0.0087084081,
0.0074143708,
0.0376978144,
-0.0237836596,
0.0028142624,
-0.0352319442,
-0.0762646943,
0.0246470496,
-0.0326602608,
-0.025919145,
-0.000668131,
0.0303414576,
0.0471420102,
0.0397875421,
-0.0380694903,
-0.0325439721,
0.0262885578,
-0.0487187654,
-0.0137505895,
0.0065532755,
-6.916345009e-33,
-0.0589260757,
-0.0010072115,
0.0123207113,
-0.0122514647,
-0.0429835953,
0.0031984432,
-0.0292030778,
-0.0142329223,
-0.0429863147,
-0.0033423991,
-0.0350454934,
0.0111920303,
0.0015699448,
-0.0033935276,
-0.0177695267,
-0.0196654107,
0.0146696763,
0.0237536728,
-0.007943063,
0.031900268,
0.0357367806,
0.0495145582,
0.0299828239,
-0.0446333475,
0.0250515155,
-0.0209474359,
0.0377731249,
0.0211059116,
0.0097053014,
0.0748170689,
-0.0548539534,
0.0727632269,
0.0288867187,
-0.0325233489,
0.0318132564,
0.0342457928,
-0.1123420522,
-0.0387349017,
0.0264392197,
-0.0160028208,
0.0152706075,
-0.0601039156,
0.0244383216,
0.0046947822,
0.041713126,
-0.0097856726,
0.0384775996,
-0.0315017849,
-0.008732073,
0.008014922,
-0.0505831614,
-0.0015981088,
0.0135667669,
0.0091436356,
-0.0165186487,
0.0010382874,
0.0359534621,
-0.0046391673,
-0.051843442,
0.0220269747,
-0.0131817516,
0.0719670802,
0.01395032,
0.0174904577,
-0.0112506133,
0.0321297571,
-0.020833768,
-0.0113655841,
-0.0079588825,
-0.0276847593,
-0.0149250366,
0.0592812188,
-0.0171923283,
0.0650042146,
-0.0013151896,
-0.0211997163,
-0.1134837046,
0.0109733222,
0.0179856233,
0.0682452396,
0.0212809928,
-0.0103458101,
-0.0490380973,
-0.0271032639,
-0.0500398502,
0.0115804495,
-0.0589883327,
-0.0344549008,
0.0305566695,
0.0114141917,
-0.0375910476,
-0.016842125,
0.0082131494,
-0.0572971031,
-0.0057774298,
0.0390510671,
-0.0016411735,
0.0108915325,
-0.0051244483,
0.020414887,
-0.0653878152,
-0.0548055433,
0.0348764658,
-0.0508806743,
0.0006294847,
0.0162301678,
-0.0029155631,
0.0086379005,
-0.054828018,
-0.0161388386,
-0.0514390506,
-0.0261987075,
-0.009391875,
0.0692031011,
-0.0133762788,
0.0212693289,
0.0008350375,
0.0527639911,
0.0479273908,
0.0256076492,
-0.0170572642,
-0.0692041516,
0.0085359747,
0.0036394484,
-0.0253753327,
0.0149013205,
-0.0129813738,
0.0462481268,
-0.0250527374,
-0.0576575249,
-0.012177296,
0.0032604397,
2.996e-7,
0.0232235324,
0.0477693044,
-0.0108143194,
0.0123140216,
-0.00132959,
-0.0011364317,
0.0064548352,
0.0371132828,
0.0338902809,
-0.0551543981,
-0.0043408354,
0.0435392745,
-0.0202455353,
-0.0010824078,
-0.0940435901,
-0.0653665513,
0.0032807651,
-0.0184845924,
-0.0644345507,
-0.0488910675,
0.0667282939,
0.0801646486,
0.0009495288,
-0.0193923842,
-0.0294266474,
-0.0093816314,
0.0481142476,
-0.0341750532,
-0.0225463789,
0.0294077769,
0.0437315814,
0.0573036,
-0.025598513,
0.035359975,
-0.0176928621,
0.0500856675,
-0.0263032895,
0.0731211752,
-0.0096799945,
-0.0150812436,
0.0115801534,
-0.0210951287,
0.014740888,
-0.0404409766,
0.0917371139,
0.0019856913,
-0.006922978,
0.0138350697,
-0.0245507881,
-0.0495480001,
-0.0323039666,
-0.0393419899,
-0.0236704685,
-0.0129614631,
-0.0020994085,
-0.0131985676,
-0.0122815436,
-0.0944998339,
0.00170413,
0.0202660523,
-0.0289938021,
-0.0744879842,
-0.0247966293,
-0.0337181203,
0.0120891482,
-0.0723451898,
0.0452529527,
2.914334038e-34,
-0.0024548648,
0.0089827944,
0.0063721766,
0.0518905409,
0.0458525084,
-0.0202601813,
-0.0376898795,
-0.0035863647,
0.0157504603,
-0.1436233819,
0.0114290556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13198v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13198v2 | Journey to the Center of the Knowledge Neurons: Discoveries of Language-Independent Knowledge Neurons and Degenerate Knowledge Neurons | 2023-08-25T06:26:05 | 2023-12-20T11:05:17 | Yuheng Chen, Pengfei Cao, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models (PLMs) contain vast amounts of factual knowledge,
but how the knowledge is stored in the parameters remains unclear. This paper
delves into the complex task of understanding how factual knowledge is stored
in multilingual PLMs, and introduces the Architecture-adapted Multilingual
Integrated Gradients method, which successfully localizes knowledge neurons
more precisely compared to current methods, and is more universal across
various architectures and languages. Moreover, we conduct an in-depth
exploration of knowledge neurons, leading to the following two important
discoveries: (1) The discovery of Language-Independent Knowledge Neurons, which
store factual knowledge in a form that transcends language. We design
cross-lingual knowledge editing experiments, demonstrating that the PLMs can
accomplish this task based on language-independent neurons; (2) The discovery
of Degenerate Knowledge Neurons, a novel type of neuron showing that different
knowledge neurons can store the same fact. Its property of functional overlap
endows the PLMs with a robust mastery of factual knowledge. We design
fact-checking experiments, proving that the degenerate knowledge neurons can
help the PLMs to detect wrong facts. Experiments corroborate these findings,
shedding light on the mechanisms of factual knowledge storage in multilingual
PLMs, and contribute valuable insights to the field. The code is available at
https://github.com/heng840/AMIG. | [
0.0326857381,
0.0127423219,
-0.028663164,
0.0795364231,
-0.0279849879,
-0.0124317305,
0.0276963543,
-0.0433296412,
-0.013573478,
-0.0174473468,
-0.0739447325,
-0.0352408849,
0.0355625041,
0.0047698445,
0.0391425602,
0.0104028182,
0.0912296697,
-0.0015368207,
0.0151071353,
-0.0351915844,
0.0042247614,
-0.0049847546,
0.0099801952,
-0.0043710135,
-0.0370206274,
-0.0129303187,
-0.01517253,
-0.0377338715,
-0.0084884651,
0.025571771,
0.0249203555,
0.0544431135,
0.0195562169,
0.0780919716,
0.0000021126,
-0.0264272131,
0.0054675667,
-0.0173148829,
-0.031872008,
0.0121231945,
-0.0166942813,
0.0044224476,
-0.0288819261,
-0.0467039011,
-0.0319444984,
-0.06336274,
0.0402466059,
0.0441978388,
0.0402683094,
0.0985152647,
-0.0039287573,
-0.0236571766,
0.0301643629,
-0.0346997418,
0.0370006412,
-0.009977934,
0.0199930035,
0.0022980836,
-0.080262877,
0.0030511355,
-0.0091319522,
0.0473553538,
0.0379532799,
0.0107994201,
-0.0155379046,
0.0519657284,
0.001859323,
-0.0275213365,
-0.0025399623,
0.0222425312,
-0.0663186982,
-0.0456771143,
-0.0319337249,
0.0033612433,
0.0082125301,
-0.0582976677,
-0.0319346189,
0.0278539583,
0.0082986513,
0.0402453281,
0.0177625977,
-0.027228564,
0.0475958027,
0.0104832062,
-0.0102714794,
0.0737407282,
0.0087161288,
-0.0240048114,
-0.0238942839,
0.0184529871,
-0.0002909066,
-0.0606987663,
0.0180811081,
0.0267989673,
0.0115382196,
0.0261486787,
-0.0273441765,
0.0021914735,
0.0073922086,
-0.0705253929,
0.055501502,
0.0403962508,
-0.0463511087,
0.0597099848,
-0.0718064234,
0.0496630892,
-0.015239045,
0.0319418944,
0.0022290035,
-0.001573687,
-0.0004103472,
-0.0341473371,
0.0039410833,
0.0134401908,
-0.0053051072,
0.009518113,
0.0046637622,
0.0023636692,
-0.0309885591,
0.0246885996,
-0.0293889903,
0.0157045182,
-0.0157403704,
-0.0065434454,
-0.0605171919,
0.056255728,
-0.0334510654,
0.0267422255,
-0.0230123438,
-0.046207197,
-0.0357275568,
0.0133279543,
-0.0141920224,
-0.007384412,
0.0408163555,
0.0185032878,
-0.0365949236,
-0.0138658294,
-0.0856785178,
-0.0225586779,
0.0211716332,
-0.0821457282,
0.0305695459,
-0.0599602386,
0.0640159249,
-0.0096346447,
-0.0349179283,
-0.0688380972,
0.0127351219,
0.0287038423,
-0.0306758694,
0.0630915314,
-0.0200383142,
0.0105608804,
0.0348539799,
0.0021995124,
-0.0213148538,
0.0436804257,
0.0116547849,
0.0216584709,
0.0476645604,
0.0238549523,
-0.0056099347,
0.0120876161,
0.0813554227,
-0.0326883085,
0.0030689463,
-0.0341776945,
0.0096333707,
0.0143934134,
0.044683855,
0.011989465,
-0.0230152868,
-0.0250170249,
0.1150466874,
0.0241191033,
-0.010129733,
0.0435128212,
0.0408961885,
-0.0617481098,
0.0364576206,
0.0217881501,
-0.0609973781,
0.0444752499,
-0.0382020287,
0.0072312378,
-0.0193817522,
0.0547604337,
-0.0280943122,
-0.0367358029,
0.0316464417,
0.0067345463,
-0.019188961,
-0.0076957541,
0.0352445953,
0.0232879091,
-0.0272861868,
0.0441913456,
0.0252706409,
-0.0172390547,
0.0123856803,
-0.0134287281,
0.0229756087,
0.0201939009,
-0.0058581056,
-0.046016816,
-0.0480626635,
0.0215801727,
-0.0079340041,
0.0421191156,
0.0717995316,
0.0064692101,
0.0295782778,
-0.0254364163,
0.0015843395,
-0.0749828592,
0.0187157076,
0.0339861438,
0.0438381955,
0.0287229735,
-0.0020916043,
-0.0173047148,
-0.0111806979,
0.0300317295,
-0.0440871157,
0.0225029886,
-0.0114123188,
-0.0000079875,
-0.0230646431,
-0.0137992557,
-0.0268815309,
0.0176880751,
0.0166107006,
-0.0297987722,
-0.0061899778,
0.020615153,
-0.0595455542,
-0.0591552667,
0.0708235577,
0.0053210598,
-0.0204011239,
-0.0206667576,
-0.0047172601,
-0.0142146843,
0.0344173685,
-0.0241148248,
0.0591248907,
-0.0616483726,
0.0021991541,
0.006853492,
0.028254265,
0.0255540442,
0.0877412856,
-0.0217606723,
0.0002347938,
-0.0129515687,
-0.0105607314,
0.0201808363,
-0.0143570192,
-0.0429100469,
0.0117805526,
0.0046908977,
0.0198699664,
-0.0194841195,
-0.0004443182,
-0.0017198462,
0.0165392198,
-0.0810342208,
0.0137268063,
0.0014977686,
-0.010010724,
0.014637202,
-0.0255261939,
0.0010613533,
-0.008825697,
-0.0517299697,
0.020580031,
0.0080945734,
0.0182350948,
0.0438176952,
-0.008707745,
0.029107796,
-0.0430086777,
0.0008175387,
-0.0209698789,
0.0609481484,
-0.0167062599,
-0.0180756114,
-0.0260890238,
0.0350381285,
-0.082805872,
0.0422418974,
-0.0224556904,
-0.0418567359,
0.0087611256,
0.0142094297,
0.0410716943,
0.0708326101,
-0.0359040275,
0.0180636179,
0.0822446942,
-0.0334991068,
-0.0212106276,
0.0293843579,
-0.0212194845,
0.0435873717,
-0.0139386645,
0.0307379458,
-0.0260298532,
0.0596318282,
0.0452733897,
-0.0424969904,
-0.0253029503,
0.0223997347,
-0.0138484165,
-0.0543947369,
-0.0156174935,
0.0059587727,
-0.0174515322,
0.0487367511,
-0.0616325811,
-0.0451513566,
0.0708629861,
-0.0398203135,
0.0039577843,
-0.0205835979,
0.0005364146,
0.0317275077,
0.0395667404,
-0.0002936817,
0.0544849001,
-0.0038689212,
0.0314467959,
-0.0702829286,
0.0024551107,
0.0109349098,
-0.0522359796,
0.0135229649,
-0.0329637229,
-0.0352616422,
0.0231689569,
-0.0243264455,
-0.0534585528,
-0.0041598021,
-0.0050895591,
0.0050773788,
-0.0101122987,
-0.0280771963,
-0.0309256278,
-0.0432687178,
0.0734552443,
0.0940776989,
-0.0232255701,
0.0064580711,
-0.0131791215,
-0.0094631864,
0.0020330732,
0.0263730641,
0.0579527728,
-0.0173694529,
-0.0300338734,
0.0573165603,
-0.0328519531,
-0.0226454735,
-0.016421631,
0.017366806,
-0.0028137569,
-0.0180402268,
-0.032092154,
-0.045115497,
0.0414579958,
-0.0341037959,
-0.0186646841,
0.0951726586,
0.0200676583,
-0.0423816293,
-0.0065104123,
-0.021865692,
-0.0250849891,
0.0556446798,
0.0463468842,
-0.0751357749,
-0.0053250245,
-0.0023528915,
-0.0467819981,
0.0014863791,
-0.009562796,
-0.0424027555,
-0.1090286672,
-0.0205181092,
0.0116530983,
-0.0105669349,
-0.0704434514,
0.0271413419,
-0.0252837148,
0.0515517481,
0.0162297543,
0.0233218987,
0.0516619384,
-0.0143710971,
-0.0380116105,
-0.0063249855,
-0.0576544218,
0.0356147997,
-0.0382488258,
0.0492383949,
0.0574949346,
0.0342051797,
-0.0096732322,
-0.0302826203,
0.0111518512,
0.0238074735,
0.0049021891,
-0.00706121,
0.0380200148,
0.0028076011,
-0.0273412094,
-0.0083981352,
0.0033133237,
-0.0149924932,
-0.0420850962,
-0.023263298,
0.0899204165,
-0.0044636885,
-0.016654158,
0.0289727133,
0.007992344,
-0.02955609,
0.0635404661,
0.0399210304,
-0.0260943249,
0.004394575,
-0.0308755226,
0.0071278331,
-0.0291263368,
-0.035365615,
0.0242937803,
0.0154451514,
-0.0246190019,
-0.0730782524,
-0.0198178012,
0.0302255955,
0.0161198676,
0.0042510931,
-0.0390090309,
0.0403373614,
-0.0553879589,
-0.0404805094,
0.0091039483,
-0.0115970559,
-0.0076810201,
-0.0149360616,
-0.0304541215,
0.0075222305,
-0.0722928867,
-0.0099157272,
0.0029789188,
-0.054850392,
-0.0853028446,
0.0162332971,
0.0783327594,
0.0134673519,
0.0295238681,
-0.0154823083,
-0.023235837,
0.0855070725,
0.0128651829,
-0.0217969418,
0.0411792994,
0.0372192226,
-0.0332058296,
0.0163189732,
0.0367110856,
-0.0011941228,
-0.0052461107,
0.0439305939,
0.0023518591,
-0.0102750193,
0.0118760439,
0.0358536169,
-0.0095258728,
0.053120371,
0.0142379701,
0.0140782557,
-0.0747344494,
0.0025782371,
-0.0165906418,
-0.0356212109,
-0.0172711033,
-0.0210313499,
0.0265488848,
0.0162176229,
-0.0014601122,
-0.0029206721,
0.051448524,
-0.0180936642,
0.0140233012,
-0.0668489933,
0.0466597751,
0.0140597979,
-0.0045050494,
0.0246018153,
-0.0112951417,
0.0626852065,
-0.0462986156,
0.0123194382,
-0.037996918,
0.0499343164,
0.0100435745,
-0.0297188237,
-0.054527387,
-0.0023853066,
-0.0444756262,
-0.0222933255,
-0.00108509,
0.0009757864,
0.1082751006,
-0.0201932117,
0.0303687584,
-0.0420551263,
-0.0300271194,
0.00466129,
0.003804056,
0.0209016968,
-0.0153614692,
0.0209700614,
-0.0072583882,
0.0033395879,
-0.0193932354,
0.0798539296,
-0.0266720299,
0.0792768076,
-0.0249450151,
-0.0199164189,
-0.0104006259,
-0.0295055527,
-0.0008779034,
-0.007840394,
-0.0493699685,
-0.0022945656,
-0.0360317528,
-0.0864632875,
0.0033559301,
0.0595056415,
-0.0194419157,
0.0078264391,
-0.0123786088,
0.0686690137,
0.030980505,
-0.0212555025,
0.000858922,
0.0416890047,
0.0128501514,
0.0123625891,
0.0013202358,
-6.560278954e-33,
-0.0376615673,
0.0028076293,
0.015257,
0.0077907508,
0.0004476212,
0.0261306483,
-0.0460299589,
-0.0028409096,
-0.0374231935,
0.0559233762,
-0.0138729168,
0.0180891864,
-0.001433508,
0.0067455894,
-0.0162957981,
-0.0009420066,
0.0218470916,
-0.0043081916,
-0.0188092869,
0.0065388656,
0.063994877,
0.0132767875,
0.1211889237,
-0.0163591299,
0.0459747538,
0.002359394,
0.0002267989,
0.0679422691,
-0.0801357478,
0.0282103252,
-0.0357143171,
0.0496496856,
0.0094419699,
-0.0257238578,
-0.0262393598,
-0.0387908369,
-0.0482371636,
-0.0767970979,
0.0435605086,
0.0331599489,
-0.0099332677,
-0.0178103745,
0.0541261882,
-0.0362703986,
0.0157197565,
0.0025137134,
-0.0033387723,
-0.0043119304,
0.014194469,
-0.0134084886,
-0.0796732157,
-0.0184246693,
0.0318547748,
-0.0211780407,
0.0053013698,
-0.053583689,
0.0263710897,
-0.0617286749,
-0.1238748506,
0.0126455864,
-0.0335538536,
0.0479650721,
0.0576379225,
-0.0064436193,
0.0245733745,
0.0478106029,
0.0358257331,
0.0345795862,
-0.0335347466,
0.0315425098,
0.0520204529,
-0.0185986608,
0.0465667509,
0.0690541491,
0.0141355321,
-0.0203819163,
-0.0474663377,
-0.0357772447,
0.0478660055,
0.0143513819,
0.0224597342,
-0.017980272,
0.0411772169,
-0.0201209038,
-0.0367801972,
-0.0191308409,
-0.0213670135,
-0.0106838392,
-0.0054226811,
0.0047962144,
0.0294221602,
-0.0118982568,
0.0077236593,
-0.0329959355,
0.0179372299,
0.049555406,
-0.0165441651,
0.0179804713,
0.0194379482,
0.0092234844,
-0.0723007694,
0.0106188674,
-0.0259180404,
-0.0117776068,
-0.005309762,
0.0387271866,
0.0532958917,
0.0500309356,
-0.0014946386,
0.0264117904,
-0.0478753746,
0.0058723134,
0.0413180217,
0.0261333566,
0.0119936941,
-0.0028161062,
-0.0501858294,
-0.0256736558,
0.0502633378,
0.0220664404,
-0.0458016433,
0.0092943143,
-0.0018826036,
0.0751229003,
-0.0266417935,
0.0027979419,
-0.086554639,
0.0061921831,
0.0193459522,
-0.0651528463,
-0.0016439044,
0.0249946546,
2.936e-7,
0.0379770696,
0.0359380208,
-0.0054960665,
0.0283128172,
0.0302958544,
0.0345642529,
-0.047960829,
0.0084171807,
-0.023422366,
-0.0648969412,
-0.0251808017,
0.0810150728,
0.0028831596,
0.0513756499,
-0.0543884449,
-0.009135385,
-0.0282315891,
0.0085538505,
-0.0344466679,
-0.0310319085,
-0.015272365,
0.068431817,
0.0449866466,
-0.0179863162,
0.0103344014,
-0.0227528755,
0.0753935277,
0.015372985,
-0.0047172494,
-0.0131733119,
0.0582948774,
-0.0088114087,
-0.0163157526,
0.0146308001,
-0.0088589136,
0.0241664238,
-0.0119601637,
0.0263925046,
0.0036303527,
0.0004011813,
-0.0210820045,
-0.0142377177,
-0.0417532623,
-0.0823471099,
0.0460911579,
-0.0348203182,
0.0043856599,
-0.0371432267,
0.0338260904,
0.0192578845,
0.0267415568,
-0.021552667,
-0.0258456003,
0.0023709273,
0.008812163,
0.0435202904,
-0.0191854089,
-0.055856321,
-0.0688351467,
0.0273116194,
-0.0277087055,
-0.026744077,
-0.0303398762,
-0.0511167832,
0.0373188667,
-0.0590833947,
0.029965505,
2.513372456e-34,
-0.0203010514,
-0.0126269003,
0.0075637,
-0.0058990004,
0.0389930643,
-0.0127295619,
-0.0110155577,
-0.0307903681,
-0.0105396602,
-0.0096296873,
-0.0323876031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13192v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13192v1 | Formalising Natural Language Quantifiers for Human-Robot Interactions | 2023-08-25T06:05:57 | 2023-08-25T06:05:57 | Stefan Morar, Adrian Groza, Mihai Pomarlan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO | We present a method for formalising quantifiers in natural language in the
context of human-robot interactions. The solution is based on first-order logic
extended with capabilities to represent the cardinality of variables, operating
similarly to generalised quantifiers. To demonstrate the method, we designed an
end-to-end system able to receive input as natural language, convert it into a
formal logical representation, evaluate it, and return a result or send a
command to a simulated robot. | [
0.0229764786,
0.0665073767,
-0.0068940562,
0.0055962857,
-0.0163466204,
-0.0309103113,
-0.0127364798,
-0.0138076404,
0.0422048979,
-0.0537625588,
0.0467523001,
0.0190648865,
-0.0411973707,
0.0580077618,
0.0186964832,
-0.0519669317,
0.0748326704,
-0.0100920601,
0.0670786425,
0.0220368057,
0.0070961355,
0.0204565953,
-0.0508943088,
0.0229170769,
-0.049644351,
0.0046098158,
-0.0326913036,
-0.0441170521,
0.0366200767,
-0.0361687802,
-0.0600023605,
0.0102203097,
0.0470958687,
-0.0300390907,
0.000001607,
-0.0619877316,
-0.0224153828,
0.0349021144,
-0.0247662533,
-0.0736043081,
-0.0018877278,
-0.0067895125,
-0.0089069596,
0.0183225311,
-0.0465105623,
0.0001676666,
0.0496067256,
0.0268685315,
0.0467651375,
0.0436290875,
-0.0213550329,
-0.0199337807,
-0.0001575424,
0.0615055412,
-0.0050451006,
-0.0291642044,
0.0161571819,
0.0514616668,
0.0738286078,
-0.007111798,
0.0271142609,
-0.0122287162,
0.0614173152,
-0.0257110894,
0.0126494421,
0.0106260022,
-0.0191725455,
-0.0195747893,
-0.0440133661,
0.018379271,
0.041846443,
-0.0181334503,
0.003937358,
0.0189027376,
0.0608243831,
-0.0086598303,
0.0101227881,
0.0521233119,
-0.0317091458,
-0.0232711118,
-0.0757036582,
0.0161031429,
0.0072915275,
0.0003756922,
-0.0442313366,
0.1096136272,
-0.0040040128,
-0.0021993748,
0.0051110242,
-0.023650866,
-0.0209053475,
-0.0362777673,
0.055846259,
0.0423632786,
-0.041872751,
-0.0043355813,
-0.0641330853,
0.0235575978,
0.0121726906,
-0.0428222008,
-0.0375860073,
0.0230702721,
0.0224457998,
0.0102003235,
0.0239545964,
0.0769962668,
-0.0020124004,
0.0465148799,
-0.0312436912,
-0.0045242282,
-0.0560535826,
-0.0362894908,
-0.0725889206,
0.0277908389,
0.0262035597,
0.0003831119,
-0.0116168167,
0.0589948408,
-0.0186161604,
0.036195416,
-0.0427994952,
-0.0005071469,
-0.0017656686,
0.0328702591,
-0.0378772989,
-0.0060803541,
-0.043932341,
0.028000867,
-0.0047103376,
-0.0730424896,
0.0227567665,
0.0042092442,
0.0147884293,
-0.0119390832,
-0.0066120401,
0.0924059451,
-0.0021235473,
0.0058597187,
0.0839227811,
-0.0489126109,
0.0124119697,
-0.0557500385,
-0.0000152702,
-0.047825139,
0.0151607534,
-0.0000266345,
0.0013771643,
-0.0155752515,
0.0139381997,
0.0259165652,
0.0365166403,
0.0721481293,
-0.004347946,
0.0098572997,
-0.047860384,
-0.02079097,
0.0149146728,
0.0330917276,
0.0660389885,
0.0136513701,
0.0204195455,
0.0089079412,
0.0067525241,
0.0162217263,
-0.0586293973,
-0.0741589367,
0.0024835542,
0.0160612706,
-0.0069685662,
0.0666386187,
-0.0475330874,
0.0351763554,
-0.0265561659,
-0.0069164969,
0.0185585599,
0.032534916,
-0.0075566019,
-0.0258195363,
0.0320280194,
0.0458051749,
0.0266163144,
-0.0209825095,
-0.0371175818,
0.0179445464,
-0.0154085699,
-0.0046050004,
-0.0474478416,
0.0030815292,
0.0035727748,
-0.0678015947,
-0.0207838882,
0.0231559835,
0.0610325783,
0.0073232618,
0.0364682078,
-0.010750005,
0.0117616253,
0.0063029835,
-0.0458002649,
-0.074286826,
-0.0155377425,
-0.0334206372,
-0.0286925435,
0.058304701,
-0.0202194285,
-0.0574513413,
-0.0265453048,
-0.0001572984,
-0.0019942652,
0.0351073332,
0.0129541457,
0.0096341753,
0.0468709916,
0.0110733872,
0.0000489103,
0.0229526516,
0.0171656907,
0.0328218378,
-0.0048597143,
0.0007652972,
-0.0067307721,
-0.0091025829,
0.0346673951,
0.0511795878,
0.0718189254,
-0.0102338912,
0.0013535125,
0.0302855149,
0.0237136297,
0.0534685478,
-0.0203236584,
0.0332943052,
0.0175275132,
0.014906276,
-0.0410982296,
0.0186886471,
0.043632865,
0.0308392588,
0.0453504585,
-0.0531647727,
-0.0533912592,
0.0505653545,
-0.0414313674,
0.0106648821,
-0.0115664089,
0.0044286046,
-0.0000477029,
0.0107704988,
-0.0287706815,
0.0013147682,
-0.0358234495,
-0.0059937267,
-0.0228814539,
0.0299861003,
-0.0415875763,
0.0023524137,
-0.0010620798,
0.0100327237,
-0.0445822217,
-0.0113433609,
0.0107147591,
-0.0194053091,
0.039348349,
0.0404756404,
0.0476410128,
0.004093084,
-0.0119053842,
-0.0345881842,
0.0027131222,
0.0009127205,
-0.0016397412,
-0.0213756934,
-0.0240212642,
0.0138506955,
-0.0108638834,
0.0044311821,
-0.0226725433,
0.0268351138,
-0.0090705734,
-0.0079553248,
0.0197584871,
-0.0552155487,
0.0021620737,
0.0102562848,
-0.0605498776,
-0.0139483344,
0.0448403209,
-0.0263825078,
-0.02452158,
0.0087659042,
-0.0530942231,
0.0259512048,
-0.013485522,
-0.0104446905,
0.0618687943,
-0.0408078469,
-0.0661710948,
0.0518775769,
-0.0409288518,
0.0166776367,
0.0879597664,
-0.0089239785,
-0.0229260419,
0.0060579968,
0.0310925804,
-0.0207677856,
-0.0069504115,
-0.009574227,
0.0448219664,
-0.0031080239,
0.0186298359,
-0.0068300883,
-0.0398606248,
0.0338841379,
-0.0055782492,
-0.0248522535,
-0.0308635496,
-0.0089335032,
-0.0371678993,
0.0446715951,
0.0260615721,
-0.0183851458,
0.0727841035,
0.0247682929,
-0.015162738,
-0.0132607184,
-0.0163898449,
-0.0067061284,
0.0509992205,
0.0087298388,
0.0167659074,
0.0722519979,
0.0033636829,
-0.0089704925,
-0.0323604941,
-0.0059438255,
-0.0108280051,
-0.0311944447,
-0.0736323968,
0.0119562726,
0.011280206,
-0.0029657693,
-0.0349739827,
0.0272959657,
-0.0355672948,
0.0633804426,
-0.0518094487,
-0.0408522263,
0.0110912668,
-0.0086777154,
-0.0018977871,
-0.0113044167,
-0.0073100403,
-0.0224989597,
-0.0573406555,
-0.0173429102,
0.0151986135,
0.0514243282,
-0.0202598125,
0.0444649346,
-0.0117607461,
0.0354618058,
-0.0047395229,
0.006146193,
-0.042644389,
-0.0031216384,
-0.0119049894,
0.0078268666,
0.0477889366,
0.0637607276,
0.014070523,
-0.0434254147,
-0.0048849899,
0.0617514215,
0.0176803228,
0.0484436117,
0.0236691479,
-0.0339104719,
-0.0088714492,
-0.0036105879,
0.0452162325,
-0.0760842487,
-0.0116610099,
-0.0190308765,
-0.0418968871,
-0.0156385731,
-0.0227689911,
-0.02181351,
-0.0668777898,
0.0212156698,
0.0070954436,
-0.0624789558,
-0.078405343,
-0.03876229,
0.0037477363,
-0.0145981526,
-0.0313903056,
0.02583424,
0.0122193173,
0.004667961,
-0.0324445479,
0.0138515234,
-0.0028572818,
0.0176335964,
-0.0251862034,
0.0034137303,
0.0411983877,
0.0660335273,
-0.0467058495,
0.0094652604,
-0.066537559,
0.072779648,
-0.0111878812,
-0.0249540489,
-0.0448113084,
-0.0074509536,
0.0056147538,
-0.0160160679,
0.0050582974,
-0.0254319552,
-0.0116630085,
0.0088586025,
0.0586869568,
-0.0217718724,
-0.0093987109,
-0.0333098955,
0.0010761784,
0.0072413119,
0.0279541519,
-0.0211167168,
0.0310747121,
-0.0326950364,
-0.0626922324,
-0.0526975207,
-0.0176283717,
-0.0551483072,
-0.0054920274,
-0.0217136871,
-0.0852019787,
-0.0638093725,
-0.0221919827,
0.0550670959,
0.0069116242,
-0.0120484,
-0.0429695882,
0.0740239024,
0.0189917814,
-0.0405624732,
0.0230227094,
-0.0035127713,
0.0485369675,
0.0272213127,
0.0335659198,
-0.0084834266,
0.0113222227,
-0.0194841549,
0.0578651614,
0.0158501603,
-0.038100481,
-0.0017107321,
0.0940941498,
0.0162062887,
-0.0531172194,
-0.0152226714,
0.002472976,
-0.0143087609,
0.0499239676,
-0.0430312976,
0.0043665362,
0.0313070007,
0.0090419259,
0.0220290944,
0.0307268202,
-0.0393565223,
-0.0081980191,
-0.087471202,
0.0410359912,
-0.0686684623,
-0.0605313741,
0.0217524786,
0.0275060702,
-0.0093926592,
0.0327347629,
0.0195231531,
0.0109459106,
-0.0290486757,
-0.0980063528,
-0.0108332429,
-0.0686071068,
0.0502787046,
-0.0414554626,
0.018100271,
0.0340965651,
-0.0339385495,
-0.0222291518,
0.0037922163,
0.0673901886,
-0.0027212822,
0.0377799012,
0.0436008088,
0.0139349345,
-0.0080825379,
-0.000897562,
-0.0167234186,
0.0054337801,
0.0191497672,
0.0069457148,
0.0220715161,
0.0267956425,
-0.0212900806,
-0.0729421079,
0.0212830808,
-0.0291318577,
-0.1050607562,
0.0423743352,
-0.0194868259,
0.0192255601,
0.0500728488,
0.0128169758,
-0.0905567035,
0.0149784973,
0.0126122413,
0.0553532206,
0.0243582428,
-0.0205129236,
0.0042840829,
0.0264522694,
0.002114614,
-0.0194708295,
-0.0058511663,
-0.0179869104,
0.0038407701,
-0.001201616,
-0.0304370467,
-0.0599036403,
-0.0305064321,
-0.0211152043,
0.0141052082,
-0.0093812309,
0.0267921742,
-0.0396410041,
-0.0387992859,
-0.001622436,
0.0565697737,
0.0304328334,
-0.008033677,
0.065574415,
0.0010153361,
-0.0066473475,
-0.0870564803,
-0.0015208574,
-0.0266037267,
0.0067280494,
-0.0157145113,
-0.0522576869,
-4.847054712e-33,
-0.0459139049,
-0.0689134374,
0.0391281731,
-0.0220250245,
-0.0072195432,
-0.0576325059,
-0.0023406721,
0.0035916835,
-0.0028875091,
0.0154758859,
0.0099682137,
0.0244339909,
0.025648864,
-0.0218677297,
0.0270149764,
-0.0096540768,
0.0399304815,
-0.0096289227,
-0.0115200328,
-0.0384107381,
0.0311810151,
-0.0400163233,
0.0615833439,
-0.0651031658,
0.0612484366,
0.0541895702,
-0.0288536604,
0.0571890511,
-0.0343863852,
-0.003959788,
0.0174434818,
0.0284834895,
-0.0210646521,
0.0094867144,
-0.0231901705,
0.0814349577,
-0.0344595909,
-0.0442505665,
0.0123264072,
0.0482459664,
-0.0263969228,
-0.0191350784,
0.030290002,
-0.0432285368,
0.0018187951,
0.0070083858,
0.0483288541,
-0.0111651104,
0.0337206312,
-0.0203760061,
-0.0493930615,
0.0030898687,
-0.0257910434,
-0.0379184522,
0.0133845834,
0.0549221896,
-0.0444256589,
-0.048283428,
0.0123591041,
-0.0005354474,
0.0155560551,
-0.0475946032,
-0.0003832182,
-0.0442642272,
0.0506581664,
0.0299832616,
0.0205755215,
-0.0280358847,
-0.0080827978,
0.0353131965,
0.0133694233,
0.062263418,
-0.0140685225,
0.0607021861,
0.0450509414,
0.0528894961,
-0.0615024492,
0.0203384683,
-0.0470703356,
0.1076752245,
-0.0341968909,
0.0209883992,
-0.0353779495,
0.0218760222,
-0.0015601097,
0.0184386894,
0.0030245406,
-0.0531978495,
0.0089038946,
-0.0407320298,
-0.0508400276,
-0.050517384,
0.0458022505,
-0.0503493845,
-0.0347720124,
0.0074927709,
0.0289612245,
0.0024021871,
-0.0044093938,
0.0345652811,
0.0205383264,
0.0040274248,
0.0174624138,
-0.0290215984,
0.0558773838,
0.0307849292,
-0.0506239012,
0.0358171724,
-0.0048638303,
0.0135372235,
-0.0193165746,
-0.0668261722,
0.0229769908,
0.0162371602,
0.0361438692,
0.0253752712,
0.0064488966,
0.0606526621,
-0.0505181924,
-0.0801661909,
-0.0648632646,
0.058623977,
0.01674968,
-0.0266968198,
-0.0417877287,
-0.0459116437,
-0.0808922499,
-0.0103692329,
0.0013857736,
-0.0133427801,
-0.0064395783,
-0.0299577434,
2.547e-7,
-0.0228234194,
0.0206819475,
0.0234954152,
0.1046894938,
-0.0305600911,
0.0229580291,
0.0361768268,
0.056102667,
-0.0033479447,
-0.0132297985,
0.0027582848,
0.0397380628,
-0.0291009955,
-0.007093573,
-0.0460609607,
0.021478476,
0.0355534479,
-0.0704424083,
0.0033003336,
0.0291025694,
0.0900036842,
0.0153548578,
0.045678474,
0.0301353801,
-0.0000193717,
-0.0566830114,
-0.0145367021,
-0.0049264496,
0.0416070633,
0.0377733819,
0.0123130074,
-0.0076018306,
0.032621555,
0.0323108882,
0.0367888473,
-0.013350673,
-0.0078169815,
0.09791895,
-0.0492559969,
-0.0152537664,
-0.0292485747,
-0.0245205723,
-0.0319402516,
0.0091879321,
0.0295543652,
-0.0649421364,
0.0172685292,
-0.0168363396,
-0.0016286068,
-0.044998318,
-0.0235415716,
0.0100487992,
-0.0054586167,
0.0084296018,
0.0052892938,
0.0034852985,
0.0312951691,
-0.0084568141,
-0.0299138613,
0.0002855232,
-0.0412703678,
-0.032963708,
0.0287461579,
-0.0062823617,
-0.004811707,
0.008493484,
-0.0078172665,
1.679661352e-34,
0.0193004906,
0.0150532275,
0.0397833623,
0.0590969101,
0.0536884107,
0.0345680751,
-0.0966348276,
0.0329160094,
0.0790542886,
-0.0314026996,
-0.0249799173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13191v1 | Chunk, Align, Select: A Simple Long-sequence Processing Method for Transformers | 2023-08-25T05:52:05 | 2023-08-25T05:52:05 | Jiawen Xie, Pengyu Cheng, Xiao Liang, Yong Dai, Nan Du | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Although dominant in natural language processing, transformer-based models
remain challenged by the task of long-sequence processing, because the
computational cost of self-attention operations in transformers swells
quadratically with the input sequence length. To alleviate the complexity of
long-sequence processing, we propose a simple framework to enable the
offthe-shelf pre-trained transformers to process much longer sequences, while
the computation and memory costs remain growing linearly with the input
sequence lengths. More specifically, our method divides each long-sequence
input into a batch of chunks, then aligns the interchunk information during the
encoding steps, and finally selects the most representative hidden states from
the encoder for the decoding process. To extract inter-chunk semantic
information, we align the start and end token embeddings among chunks in each
encoding transformer block. To learn an effective hidden selection policy, we
design a dual updating scheme inspired by reinforcement learning, which regards
the decoders of transformers as environments, and the downstream performance
metrics as the rewards to evaluate the hidden selection actions. Our empirical
results on real-world long-text summarization and reading comprehension tasks
demonstrate effective improvements compared to prior longsequence processing
baselines. | [
0.0014824262,
0.0347578265,
0.0119306557,
-0.0035845705,
-0.0107500777,
0.0111438781,
-0.0007477766,
-0.0219060127,
-0.0354257822,
-0.0501584262,
-0.021900015,
-0.0112640457,
0.0198334325,
0.004424199,
-0.012998376,
-0.0792357326,
0.0497002266,
-0.0134868678,
0.0002332396,
0.0349604189,
0.0034131981,
0.0041261259,
-0.0160156414,
0.0312751047,
0.0268827975,
-0.0206664503,
-0.0170660727,
-0.0388539881,
0.0430948772,
-0.0619771183,
0.0181847662,
0.0008711927,
0.0215003453,
0.0184050966,
0.0000020835,
-0.0367461778,
-0.0413307771,
-0.0182972997,
-0.0061885118,
-0.027081972,
-0.015109391,
-0.0456890948,
0.0035032756,
-0.0004827928,
-0.0178618804,
-0.0210846849,
0.0293256808,
0.0729276016,
0.0520403124,
0.0694902241,
0.0046606893,
-0.0401652902,
0.0017015324,
-0.036709439,
0.000367629,
-0.0149791138,
0.0117252721,
-0.0292650554,
0.0103968261,
-0.0059958086,
-0.0592320748,
0.0200000554,
0.036017213,
-0.0043736165,
0.0050134961,
0.0698886588,
0.0159641579,
-0.0100828614,
-0.0183224175,
0.0698164701,
-0.0386914611,
0.001218857,
0.0153282778,
-0.0063528977,
-0.0131078558,
-0.0293463152,
-0.0292674415,
0.0316678919,
-0.0008895229,
0.0452003293,
0.006247486,
0.0467900336,
-0.0004506622,
0.0050910763,
-0.0665700287,
0.0366653129,
-0.0076266243,
-0.0400192738,
-0.0178800058,
0.015254721,
0.0059717819,
-0.0507160425,
0.044822786,
0.0530056059,
-0.02926239,
0.0023810966,
-0.0373898149,
-0.0498020314,
-0.0286767296,
0.0323578566,
-0.0175572317,
0.0652505532,
0.00985933,
0.0317816809,
-0.0209538061,
0.0609307401,
0.0028206515,
0.0647334158,
-0.0395416915,
0.0381250381,
-0.0070091537,
-0.0009129625,
-0.0486132465,
0.0295658,
-0.0587093197,
-0.0457183868,
-0.0391825773,
0.0158394985,
0.0241313614,
-0.0099516157,
0.0242175702,
0.0168953799,
-0.047163751,
0.021404352,
-0.0191820487,
0.0624754727,
-0.0433978774,
-0.0268982965,
0.0448591858,
-0.0007893484,
-0.0481419265,
0.0003497205,
0.0160454605,
-0.0357612409,
-0.0259897131,
0.076769799,
-0.0451327711,
-0.0564334728,
-0.0053205765,
0.0032078237,
-0.0205190759,
-0.0263704043,
0.0308492873,
-0.0174725018,
0.0194759816,
-0.0028499968,
0.0171872992,
-0.0083657457,
-0.0036957134,
0.0511093847,
0.0177622885,
0.0577938482,
-0.0008986875,
-0.0498394333,
0.0071212053,
0.0321112461,
0.0342205614,
0.0372714289,
0.0432764553,
0.0468585752,
0.0280137509,
-0.001002299,
0.0138704861,
0.0028303473,
0.0029733402,
-0.0267276634,
0.0082303006,
0.0069398913,
-0.009937251,
0.0196063779,
0.0561038628,
0.0214642901,
-0.0482337214,
-0.0261578728,
0.0475327969,
0.0630538315,
0.0202759355,
0.0118253045,
0.0181277562,
0.0595096052,
-0.012104651,
0.0316541791,
0.0040199412,
0.081538111,
0.0070368666,
0.0371869244,
0.0358697772,
0.0279264748,
-0.0263210312,
-0.035730917,
0.0317984037,
-0.0263528284,
0.0375972427,
0.0017171894,
0.0430811271,
0.0295282137,
-0.0943569317,
0.0798908547,
0.0034659314,
-0.0443737246,
0.0150996586,
-0.033582557,
0.0406073965,
0.0388205275,
0.044860255,
-0.0372520685,
-0.0161139593,
-0.034035068,
-0.0318823792,
0.0352165811,
-0.018868506,
-0.0055482653,
0.0061515141,
-0.0718512312,
-0.0449261144,
-0.0152590768,
-0.0199017823,
-0.0084023094,
0.0131797092,
0.0109069739,
0.0250561815,
0.0155078145,
0.0042357021,
0.0465306789,
-0.0322383828,
-0.0290083196,
-0.0033133016,
0.0236335769,
0.0368056372,
-0.0106223281,
0.0049490323,
-0.0067171482,
0.0307065099,
-0.0367759392,
-0.0119526209,
0.0051000598,
-0.0868864581,
-0.0640259311,
-0.0136075374,
-0.0540612862,
-0.0036972922,
0.0699559897,
-0.0148628112,
-0.0324563161,
-0.0061479802,
-0.0780497044,
0.002804243,
-0.0184894688,
0.002723827,
0.0210869219,
0.0522844829,
-0.051175788,
0.0351061709,
-0.0205938779,
0.0105541945,
-0.0049237697,
-0.0318143182,
-0.0280461125,
-0.016883757,
-0.0174990147,
0.0271082148,
-0.0171693619,
-0.0248987153,
0.0390105546,
0.0040011085,
-0.0382015482,
-0.0416101702,
-0.0452016294,
0.0030348885,
-0.0361148752,
0.0317553952,
0.0081092454,
0.0283417609,
-0.0076939249,
-0.022743417,
-0.0158649348,
-0.0309202131,
-0.0022748925,
-0.0095157865,
0.0347355418,
0.0214497671,
0.016036069,
-0.0187208559,
-0.0298088416,
0.0056443508,
0.0549546853,
-0.0087828236,
0.0018074933,
-0.0676689371,
-0.0313230045,
0.0069716261,
-0.0174340326,
-0.0265039653,
-0.0578787029,
-0.0046802633,
-0.0068309307,
0.0529127717,
0.0711455569,
0.0555598773,
0.0523963459,
0.0260689035,
-0.0120723369,
-0.0176527966,
0.0420331173,
-0.0464688838,
0.0497432984,
-0.0578526817,
0.0125082768,
0.032959152,
0.0932445452,
-0.0258761961,
0.0044498621,
-0.0288937856,
-0.0153178703,
-0.0127204657,
-0.0143129313,
0.0119833034,
-0.0203850809,
-0.0357836895,
0.0240172204,
-0.0362942256,
-0.0099053578,
0.0806341767,
-0.0186033733,
-0.0236745328,
-0.0882406831,
0.0088486131,
-0.0502953306,
0.0407166965,
0.0337983146,
-0.0027625477,
-0.0317782983,
-0.0546799079,
-0.0089181997,
-0.0084772948,
-0.0070870216,
-0.0220925789,
0.0804945529,
-0.0003179673,
-0.0005954018,
-0.0389422365,
-0.0388389416,
-0.0387347117,
-0.0092125442,
-0.0210380107,
-0.005261085,
0.0407834016,
-0.0225555506,
-0.0698659793,
0.0061729532,
0.0488326773,
0.0814503506,
-0.0216586404,
-0.0051287115,
-0.0428731814,
0.0427631438,
0.0313309655,
0.0434868857,
0.0322792716,
-0.0497054718,
0.0344441906,
0.0542046279,
0.0319805928,
0.0045567197,
0.008412417,
0.003590778,
0.0541835688,
-0.0833321139,
0.0361976847,
0.0277017318,
0.0411254875,
-0.0760270953,
-0.0261242017,
0.114695847,
0.0243775137,
-0.062462531,
-0.0066190306,
0.0158903953,
0.0131227346,
0.0095963841,
0.0189728383,
-0.0753490701,
-0.050307706,
0.0157159586,
0.0140164774,
0.0222705733,
-0.0131961163,
-0.0060567637,
-0.0857032835,
0.0053705554,
-0.0128628174,
-0.0634852201,
-0.012823618,
-0.0364620723,
0.0065228213,
-0.0073067904,
0.0439562835,
0.0260702632,
-0.0438844785,
-0.0248927828,
0.0208005067,
-0.0166791659,
-0.0157336723,
-0.0160293542,
-0.0066421493,
-0.0264756233,
0.0733863488,
0.0262783952,
-0.0014434585,
-0.0205554143,
0.0141817546,
-0.0289340131,
-0.006912542,
0.0126306182,
0.0566995665,
-0.0355575867,
-0.0154937496,
-0.0331325084,
0.0349897482,
-0.0286892969,
-0.0215191282,
-0.0268909689,
0.0342180692,
-0.0081910668,
-0.0340897329,
-0.0067776171,
0.0110066598,
0.0024631969,
0.0643530786,
0.0197529513,
-0.0456085801,
-0.0749220252,
-0.005564258,
-0.0140992869,
-0.0812606215,
-0.032706283,
0.0084760431,
0.0195947159,
-0.0397637598,
-0.0609840155,
-0.068668291,
0.0402005762,
0.0083501227,
-0.0028333794,
-0.0196891427,
0.056979686,
0.0202576928,
-0.0698801428,
-0.0041411389,
-0.016224511,
0.0093880547,
-0.0573454276,
0.0322826877,
0.0202286001,
-0.0349712335,
-0.0283635557,
-0.007711668,
-0.0674216449,
-0.0202171598,
0.0290852413,
0.0311471634,
0.006489662,
0.0622646324,
0.0029493272,
-0.0099609653,
0.084325023,
0.0372368842,
-0.0512595177,
0.0164188072,
0.0165247731,
-0.0095195975,
-0.0131787891,
-0.0010848762,
-0.0142755825,
0.0243907161,
-0.0065360749,
0.0411609635,
-0.0062201335,
-0.0078933779,
0.0162817445,
-0.0175559931,
0.0300522819,
-0.0084221968,
0.0660770237,
-0.0142548848,
0.0390366353,
-0.0001988326,
0.021769587,
-0.0156863146,
-0.0058748405,
0.0119792409,
-0.0185679384,
0.0020599763,
0.0934668779,
0.0167900007,
-0.0331939757,
-0.0245035812,
0.0349124558,
-0.024862526,
0.0176414549,
0.0026690164,
0.0130024347,
-0.0253175106,
-0.0389345214,
0.0127818724,
0.0328111798,
-0.0114428867,
0.0407180078,
0.0559322238,
0.0167271588,
-0.0196183659,
0.0353479683,
-0.0631489158,
0.0610268451,
-0.0187740996,
-0.0205365308,
0.0164155848,
-0.0464129746,
0.0453628339,
0.0274986085,
0.0023110495,
-0.01635384,
0.02241005,
-0.0287175328,
-0.0183862559,
-0.0270479657,
0.0181568246,
0.009305561,
-0.0316004828,
0.0818455666,
-0.0353873856,
0.0169529673,
0.0192031004,
-0.0023432872,
-0.0482973084,
-0.0464319438,
-0.026199488,
0.0351630449,
-0.0127991047,
-0.0085491184,
-0.0161158293,
-0.0187601093,
0.0309961103,
-0.0158813316,
0.0082142716,
-0.0138248587,
0.0611938834,
0.0128166005,
-0.0067845001,
-0.0358965993,
-0.0225223154,
-0.0096713556,
-0.0077826316,
-0.0199659262,
0.0055347695,
-6.380974923e-33,
-0.0154189086,
-0.012090981,
0.0202832259,
-0.0045499108,
-0.0664955974,
0.0105696404,
-0.0507126376,
-0.0424236506,
0.0391814671,
0.0099303247,
-0.0179468244,
-0.0091236895,
0.0104335872,
0.0838692412,
-0.0186230857,
-0.0263703503,
0.0691137388,
-0.0055076722,
-0.0432986505,
0.0250368677,
0.0437840484,
0.0525357202,
0.0620263331,
0.0154441958,
-0.0299761575,
0.0119571192,
0.0333922915,
-0.0154408701,
0.0244779177,
0.0563680679,
-0.0247351825,
-0.0057900129,
0.0371470824,
-0.0759761035,
-0.0324447155,
0.0527286455,
-0.1279894412,
-0.0130281281,
-0.0255322531,
0.0245862212,
-0.0783995613,
-0.0436303765,
0.0428461991,
0.0118475948,
0.0277317688,
-0.0398108438,
0.0415698141,
-0.0273171943,
-0.0274960753,
-0.0287587028,
-0.0499877818,
0.003036811,
-0.0400322191,
-0.0305622295,
0.0396757983,
0.0499334186,
0.0154422261,
0.0631078333,
-0.0747648478,
0.0101289963,
0.0278330091,
0.0554551594,
0.0264777634,
0.0395673662,
0.0126187857,
0.0614146478,
-0.009466554,
-0.0437843129,
-0.0419476442,
-0.0030209546,
0.0177632887,
0.0048045679,
-0.0167912859,
-0.0250094719,
0.0779397264,
-0.0027713168,
-0.0929136798,
0.0315583572,
-0.0129474476,
0.052344095,
0.0377563313,
0.004085388,
-0.0087028919,
0.0150061939,
-0.0245321058,
0.0456180759,
-0.0087466836,
-0.0072839228,
0.0264922176,
0.058976274,
-0.0254927296,
0.0098033482,
0.0552365743,
-0.0178159233,
0.0189313181,
0.0196685512,
-0.0175194852,
-0.0040552896,
0.0005675425,
-0.0186709408,
-0.041160997,
0.0034606187,
0.0345330127,
-0.0145335579,
-0.0169190876,
-0.0082402565,
0.0262514483,
0.0262998156,
-0.0677883402,
0.0072451783,
-0.0202417187,
0.0388855301,
-0.0114457654,
0.0388162956,
0.0386091955,
0.0235040579,
-0.0263574161,
0.0773678645,
-0.0334160365,
-0.0053147152,
-0.023452729,
0.028327968,
0.0209914204,
0.0441219173,
-0.0192072894,
0.0032362782,
-0.0426618569,
0.0380027555,
-0.0066244742,
-0.0966532826,
-0.0033060899,
0.0605144203,
2.806e-7,
0.0071157934,
0.0474045761,
0.0919902474,
-0.0038468812,
0.0257425774,
0.0093695354,
0.0145297404,
0.0545395836,
0.0072713317,
0.0161700267,
0.0092053963,
0.0287429467,
0.046298705,
-0.0064255437,
-0.1108362079,
-0.020147644,
-0.0709307045,
-0.0028566371,
-0.0367913693,
-0.0307794083,
0.0570735894,
0.0763751119,
-0.0056456262,
0.0192027614,
0.0323950946,
0.0124648297,
0.0472571105,
0.0080379937,
0.0301593468,
0.0348582827,
-0.0040863892,
0.0118297804,
-0.0097423205,
-0.0387710668,
-0.0239466764,
0.0115916375,
0.0115517387,
0.0494991466,
0.0287641007,
-0.0638002083,
0.0125784576,
0.042416729,
0.0047894586,
0.019179767,
0.048933588,
-0.1278869212,
-0.0279842485,
0.016338814,
-0.0581468157,
-0.0094751557,
-0.0125205135,
0.0204166584,
-0.0262720622,
0.0452266559,
0.0271147173,
0.0201119483,
-0.0001696689,
-0.116981566,
-0.0141641274,
-0.0038764975,
-0.040744368,
0.0113230534,
-0.0696134418,
-0.0294926353,
0.0413229354,
-0.0397281833,
-0.0253570452,
2.439084197e-34,
0.0066655497,
-0.0241044201,
-0.0193861201,
0.0184583943,
-0.007065767,
-0.0283175837,
0.0194025971,
-0.0180328581,
0.0203983821,
-0.0719622672,
-0.0302204061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13569v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13569v1 | Discovering Mental Health Research Topics with Topic Modeling | 2023-08-25T05:25:05 | 2023-08-25T05:25:05 | Xin Gao, Cem Sazara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Mental health significantly influences various aspects of our daily lives,
and its importance has been increasingly recognized by the research community
and the general public, particularly in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. This
heightened interest is evident in the growing number of publications dedicated
to mental health in the past decade. In this study, our goal is to identify
general trends in the field and pinpoint high-impact research topics by
analyzing a large dataset of mental health research papers. To accomplish this,
we collected abstracts from various databases and trained a customized
Sentence-BERT based embedding model leveraging the BERTopic framework. Our
dataset comprises 96,676 research papers pertaining to mental health, enabling
us to examine the relationships between different topics using their abstracts.
To evaluate the effectiveness of the model, we compared it against two other
state-of-the-art methods: Top2Vec model and LDA-BERT model. The model
demonstrated superior performance in metrics that measure topic diversity and
coherence. To enhance our analysis, we also generated word clouds to provide a
comprehensive overview of the machine learning models applied in mental health
research, shedding light on commonly utilized techniques and emerging trends.
Furthermore, we provide a GitHub link* to the dataset used in this paper,
ensuring its accessibility for further research endeavors. | [
0.0231032185,
0.061163865,
-0.0247683041,
-0.0301100928,
-0.0044753589,
-0.0121326502,
-0.0028758056,
-0.0322115347,
0.0195555184,
-0.0488865413,
0.0226908028,
0.0133045707,
-0.0215860363,
0.0234686099,
0.0012552734,
-0.0506602973,
0.0269152541,
0.0331081897,
0.0455705263,
0.013465994,
-0.006330017,
-0.0056659477,
-0.0236186683,
0.051215291,
0.0527645089,
-0.0484223366,
0.0102487113,
0.0132649457,
0.0377048925,
-0.073157832,
0.0191344488,
0.047561191,
0.0138313798,
-0.0038392367,
0.0000020208,
-0.0204563662,
-0.0590877272,
-0.0141452812,
0.0711846203,
0.0099187186,
0.0132864174,
-0.053071592,
0.0176470727,
0.0206666011,
-0.0072979843,
0.0064368974,
0.0255772676,
0.1036783382,
0.0295416228,
0.0358578116,
-0.0184112713,
0.0035025715,
0.0448264889,
-0.0116094165,
0.014415089,
0.0207969137,
0.0628190488,
-0.0065035485,
0.0212401524,
0.0019426392,
0.0003801111,
0.0073836073,
-0.055756025,
0.0043483935,
0.0441082232,
0.0289730616,
-0.0516453274,
-0.014600588,
0.0154879233,
0.0761527717,
0.0148402415,
0.0194095373,
0.0656443462,
-0.0031098973,
-0.0387419052,
0.0441166982,
-0.0534648336,
-0.0182117354,
0.000765487,
0.0085111894,
0.0512293577,
-0.0162489153,
0.0349712595,
-0.0172607917,
0.0241713803,
0.0508308299,
0.0150578441,
-0.0399838388,
0.0109813344,
-0.0383667238,
-0.0528436452,
-0.0538158379,
0.0323617272,
0.0022507114,
-0.0167679023,
0.0013780529,
0.0094985878,
-0.1071855202,
0.0480991043,
-0.0164169166,
-0.0300968308,
0.0124704475,
-0.0260865167,
-0.0203679502,
0.0739198327,
-0.0195800662,
-0.0174407102,
0.0073230485,
-0.0248622987,
0.0121699376,
-0.0633679852,
-0.0011330907,
-0.0353088677,
0.0060079414,
0.0584983639,
-0.0510021932,
-0.0286165606,
-0.0097801937,
-0.0272093359,
-0.0037551245,
-0.0422925577,
-0.0199899543,
-0.0316054337,
0.0143687613,
0.0453379899,
0.033414524,
-0.0553131327,
0.0193514228,
-0.026407972,
0.0321889818,
0.003273302,
-0.010004852,
0.0068547865,
-0.0082920166,
0.0110357199,
-0.0022455978,
0.0378277451,
-0.0703251809,
-0.030913936,
-0.0059159901,
-0.0179059692,
0.0189212877,
0.0458377413,
-0.0784021318,
-0.005222592,
0.0101046618,
0.0131314164,
0.0108763864,
0.0256026182,
0.0229889359,
-0.0515486561,
0.0216710623,
-0.0723678246,
-0.0222776495,
0.0651017204,
0.0273981821,
0.0280978978,
0.0456275977,
0.0228618383,
0.0049706651,
0.0475038327,
0.0049426733,
-0.00195295,
-0.0192801747,
0.0047793733,
-0.0331091657,
0.0348098613,
0.0044045001,
-0.0316617973,
0.0727005824,
-0.0286844298,
0.011498631,
-0.0195656177,
0.0395856313,
0.0041315313,
0.1133135334,
-0.0256140921,
0.0476245806,
-0.039035026,
0.0618399978,
0.0176179428,
-0.0332603343,
0.0422496647,
-0.0067389221,
0.0372238643,
-0.0084964307,
0.0332996324,
0.0325531475,
-0.0447223373,
-0.0278089885,
-0.0620085187,
-0.0163339786,
-0.0226594862,
-0.0482225716,
0.0230704416,
-0.0304704681,
0.0059327809,
0.0422143303,
0.0439828411,
0.0052273404,
-0.0168047249,
0.015644867,
0.0223244317,
0.0456266738,
0.0757928938,
-0.0767881572,
-0.0419480838,
-0.0494096875,
0.033348944,
0.032112062,
-0.0492610224,
-0.0016174733,
-0.0103608994,
-0.0121515505,
0.0070567443,
0.0039409297,
0.0286513157,
-0.023019813,
-0.0193803385,
0.010280625,
-0.0439768508,
-0.0520604923,
0.0264770389,
0.0635208488,
-0.0159810632,
0.0153129194,
0.0377606004,
-0.034985099,
0.0577134229,
0.0274624303,
-0.0046557807,
0.0490050353,
0.035220392,
-0.0542826355,
-0.0620276108,
-0.0122245904,
0.0357312001,
-0.0019921041,
0.006765563,
-0.0754480511,
0.0266202167,
0.0552425534,
-0.0239072647,
0.0041420385,
0.0305479467,
-0.0431664772,
0.0267446153,
0.0150692184,
-0.030902382,
-0.025501769,
0.0022360808,
-0.0205332953,
0.0514116362,
-0.0576437972,
0.048751954,
0.0112247942,
-0.0567797981,
0.0037837646,
-0.0085862214,
-0.0257976968,
-0.0088975551,
-0.0135767935,
0.0202855859,
0.017237097,
-0.0217211451,
0.0224727876,
-0.0208834875,
-0.1208711639,
0.0334118716,
-0.0081308922,
-0.026404541,
0.024659615,
-0.0233501848,
-0.0092618382,
-0.0116008194,
-0.004717737,
-0.0119059347,
0.0105454717,
0.0201059654,
0.0346914008,
-0.0121163884,
0.006773713,
-0.0645716637,
-0.0357590131,
-0.0571239926,
0.0608882308,
-0.02786435,
0.0026462988,
-0.0011710069,
-0.0112828026,
-0.0238347147,
-0.0319280662,
-0.0249991324,
0.0050792969,
0.0088399881,
0.0299694818,
0.0917326361,
0.0148661472,
0.0243720077,
0.0700903237,
0.0713213459,
0.0149071105,
0.0008203246,
0.0013992019,
-0.0198786557,
0.0492298305,
-0.0034018208,
-0.063007161,
0.0718800128,
0.0412854515,
0.0207454432,
0.0128617203,
-0.0161533412,
-0.008625675,
-0.0164318159,
0.0443197787,
-0.0579242297,
-0.0159409661,
0.0089917677,
-0.0008671533,
-0.0027461022,
-0.0206174143,
0.0387274735,
0.0111817336,
0.0470810458,
-0.079544358,
-0.0052001588,
-0.0465714894,
-0.0293807052,
0.0060186177,
0.0141032012,
0.0056509003,
0.0025630195,
0.0178302377,
-0.0123295626,
-0.0228974037,
-0.0058767744,
0.0319242217,
-0.0329144485,
-0.0033605897,
0.0243195463,
-0.0204033162,
0.0015425129,
-0.0411110297,
-0.035143096,
0.0235405806,
0.0581082068,
-0.0291457921,
-0.0478629321,
-0.0309789535,
0.0496534966,
0.0093471501,
-0.0113118626,
-0.0396583974,
-0.0210065097,
0.0569452159,
0.1000117138,
-0.0893643275,
0.0285863634,
0.0075379335,
0.0028521982,
0.0208369512,
0.0263015926,
0.0300135966,
-0.0165941268,
-0.0032841265,
-0.0028550576,
-0.0560575798,
-0.0011429768,
0.0062383777,
0.0004240052,
0.020817861,
-0.0143988142,
0.0979631543,
0.0414771661,
-0.0133558502,
0.0206569973,
-0.0616967231,
-0.0059544756,
-0.004481459,
0.0134157678,
-0.0218662303,
-0.0061580311,
-0.0229914468,
0.0479571298,
0.0010555537,
-0.0370505378,
-0.0057356986,
-0.018496586,
0.032950718,
-0.0194452927,
0.0463700257,
-0.0045205811,
-0.0721233934,
0.010882969,
-0.0118835364,
-0.0479637086,
-0.0344403647,
-0.021797305,
0.0170213338,
0.016671963,
-0.0824983791,
-0.0410756245,
0.0202843752,
-0.0297919903,
0.032032989,
0.0152013497,
0.0562034585,
-0.0336478241,
-0.0332551897,
-0.0413294248,
-0.0021791386,
-0.0628616437,
0.006132964,
0.0705944523,
-0.0184456669,
0.0246362835,
-0.0504289791,
0.0498433039,
-0.0543620102,
-0.0497147813,
0.0227361862,
0.1114633605,
-0.0255411454,
-0.0127992956,
-0.0591483191,
0.0184813347,
0.0052097095,
0.0608421266,
0.0063192742,
-0.0346390456,
0.0135525465,
0.0070515182,
0.0503309481,
0.0388513431,
0.0007557845,
-0.026600305,
-0.033840999,
-0.0051644766,
-0.0516253859,
-0.0345484912,
0.0546287261,
-0.0353455544,
0.0042486419,
0.0159236733,
0.0468408652,
-0.0121773155,
-0.0679519624,
0.0333933607,
0.0516890399,
-0.0056761964,
-0.0182585549,
-0.0273460597,
0.0335877724,
0.0202683508,
-0.0279956963,
-0.0007638576,
-0.0516061299,
-0.0071438006,
0.0260618813,
-0.0375461876,
-0.0026984813,
-0.0181402657,
-0.0047229519,
-0.0386680067,
0.0390206389,
0.0188201908,
-0.0284375139,
-0.0265489575,
0.0106109101,
0.0169713423,
0.005198691,
0.0149621805,
-0.0220197719,
0.0321772173,
-0.0184154101,
0.0293758083,
-0.0327467322,
-0.00324754,
-0.0160131808,
-0.0091546327,
0.07140214,
-0.0041032727,
-0.014343679,
-0.0728648081,
-0.0417215563,
-0.0059961108,
0.0236933548,
-0.0291137844,
0.0084907357,
0.0021439157,
-0.0252403673,
-0.0677397996,
-0.0020351748,
-0.0509807244,
0.018461341,
-0.0512805022,
0.0553634726,
-0.033203572,
0.0282425545,
-0.0056384206,
-0.0196821019,
-0.0060038976,
0.0036672296,
-0.0391051918,
0.010013124,
-0.0119985361,
0.0366841257,
0.0015912561,
-0.0260112695,
0.0271274112,
0.0251255836,
-0.0888683498,
-0.0675467923,
-0.0324304253,
-0.0021003976,
0.0263229646,
0.0082461936,
0.0502994247,
-0.0482147448,
-0.0163108911,
-0.0219520554,
0.0468561985,
-0.0114223706,
-0.0121940179,
0.0299840253,
0.0367689133,
-0.0465643555,
-0.0245456025,
0.0620229542,
0.0252000894,
-0.000185439,
0.0463519432,
-0.0469699614,
-0.0190416593,
0.017684726,
0.0314617753,
0.0733056962,
-0.0454426222,
0.0149984965,
-0.0371246077,
0.0213349052,
0.07875368,
-0.0472454801,
-0.0334682129,
-0.0232700817,
0.0170610175,
0.0516215712,
0.0139833791,
-0.0191539805,
-0.0576761514,
0.0420322604,
-0.0645977482,
-0.0648396909,
-0.0133267306,
-5.818410142e-33,
0.0026506663,
-0.0209277999,
-0.0132294931,
-0.0122873681,
0.0124149406,
0.0479222983,
-0.0443485752,
0.0040169312,
0.0002787423,
0.0270640831,
0.0106001645,
0.0778574571,
-0.0159959774,
0.012178557,
0.0374011137,
0.0091404049,
0.0407073461,
-0.0083773145,
-0.0057755699,
0.0091707408,
0.0109745562,
0.0635343343,
0.0481635965,
-0.0642442405,
0.0157694686,
-0.0058172755,
0.0295374859,
-0.0128836259,
0.0766525567,
0.0380601026,
-0.0619845241,
0.028914066,
0.0336204953,
-0.0215785448,
0.0175224207,
0.0144872377,
-0.0306735672,
-0.0535898805,
-0.0116338069,
-0.0518021844,
-0.043069087,
-0.0098581742,
0.0059575508,
0.0202295072,
0.0179570727,
-0.0177510791,
0.0805631652,
-0.0270849001,
-0.0132465018,
-0.062714234,
-0.0371711142,
0.0177350342,
-0.0358945169,
0.0343667679,
-0.024647573,
-0.0012692901,
-0.0074408529,
0.0786636472,
-0.0306978133,
-0.0026806497,
0.0382639468,
0.0373019837,
-0.000031343,
-0.0856156573,
0.0169385858,
0.0797663704,
-0.062941879,
-0.0086763492,
0.0241537001,
-0.0089074392,
0.0227645393,
0.0540886708,
0.0400189869,
-0.0066328309,
0.0399130397,
0.0216159299,
-0.0580718741,
0.0289851073,
0.0252787229,
0.0144988112,
0.0551226474,
-0.0048464071,
-0.0018131033,
-0.0001731803,
-0.0001948096,
-0.0176940858,
0.004305745,
-0.0085467296,
-0.0091652507,
-0.0057017617,
-0.0161508173,
-0.012895192,
-0.0138969244,
0.0032237216,
-0.0246297214,
0.0551557057,
-0.0192107968,
0.0042617884,
0.0348881669,
0.0259759352,
-0.0843588114,
-0.0087395506,
-0.0051950128,
-0.0047702529,
0.0239232238,
-0.0054416358,
0.0309807695,
-0.0533092283,
-0.0322076045,
-0.0238582436,
0.0299811363,
-0.025692774,
-0.0368024819,
0.0561807677,
-0.0256561097,
0.0260549784,
0.0079445001,
0.0390942469,
0.0567747355,
0.0418425947,
-0.0166722368,
-0.039944239,
-0.0275339838,
0.0099610314,
0.0327981524,
-0.0224135388,
-0.0293334294,
0.0316926762,
0.0514171422,
-0.0758663267,
-0.0034205245,
-0.0512887724,
2.806e-7,
0.051500462,
0.0821879283,
-0.0286924969,
0.0031204622,
0.038248729,
0.0321515314,
-0.0240855068,
0.0309317503,
0.005374311,
0.0029925059,
0.0156321544,
-0.0003748178,
-0.0003588421,
0.0518984199,
-0.0319600962,
-0.0426795222,
-0.0686328188,
0.0004272189,
-0.0793056935,
-0.0208666027,
0.0248616785,
0.0735486597,
-0.0007827444,
0.0121812606,
-0.0291248653,
0.0267940927,
0.0394594818,
-0.0397924706,
-0.008867275,
0.0669304356,
0.0723713785,
0.0363780409,
0.0054196417,
-0.0398337729,
-0.0327138528,
0.0212911963,
0.0004558369,
0.0097340373,
-0.0041600689,
0.0093569644,
0.0317084417,
-0.0133704301,
-0.0293479674,
-0.0120304693,
0.0427304022,
-0.0779571757,
-0.039861057,
-0.036283575,
-0.0367153585,
-0.0053472011,
0.067796804,
-0.0314491689,
-0.0270146746,
0.0172993094,
-0.0172296185,
-0.0177021809,
0.0366137251,
-0.0520901494,
-0.0112493597,
0.0410130247,
-0.053699661,
0.0219781809,
-0.0353343301,
-0.0269334484,
-0.0034444197,
-0.0792934522,
0.0513266735,
2.802065603e-34,
0.0299141724,
0.0155591816,
-0.0358145945,
0.018808987,
-0.0085045118,
-0.0199763253,
-0.0384453423,
-0.0065075587,
-0.0271792263,
-0.062185917,
0.019543767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13177v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13177v2 | How to Evaluate the Generalization of Detection? A Benchmark for Comprehensive Open-Vocabulary Detection | 2023-08-25T04:54:32 | 2023-12-18T07:29:55 | Yiyang Yao, Peng Liu, Tiancheng Zhao, Qianqian Zhang, Jiajia Liao, Chunxin Fang, Kyusong Lee, Qing Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Object detection (OD) in computer vision has made significant progress in
recent years, transitioning from closed-set labels to open-vocabulary detection
(OVD) based on large-scale vision-language pre-training (VLP). However, current
evaluation methods and datasets are limited to testing generalization over
object types and referral expressions, which do not provide a systematic,
fine-grained, and accurate benchmark of OVD models' abilities. In this paper,
we propose a new benchmark named OVDEval, which includes 9 sub-tasks and
introduces evaluations on commonsense knowledge, attribute understanding,
position understanding, object relation comprehension, and more. The dataset is
meticulously created to provide hard negatives that challenge models' true
understanding of visual and linguistic input. Additionally, we identify a
problem with the popular Average Precision (AP) metric when benchmarking models
on these fine-grained label datasets and propose a new metric called
Non-Maximum Suppression Average Precision (NMS-AP) to address this issue.
Extensive experimental results show that existing top OVD models all fail on
the new tasks except for simple object types, demonstrating the value of the
proposed dataset in pinpointing the weakness of current OVD models and guiding
future research. Furthermore, the proposed NMS-AP metric is verified by
experiments to provide a much more truthful evaluation of OVD models, whereas
traditional AP metrics yield deceptive results. Data is available at
\url{https://github.com/om-ai-lab/OVDEval} | [
0.0310000982,
0.0267308932,
0.0304503813,
0.0719785318,
-0.0033967963,
0.0097551011,
-0.0243456084,
0.0384409577,
-0.0091383737,
-0.0687420666,
-0.022127118,
-0.0287722591,
-0.0082634753,
0.0442979634,
-0.0481935255,
0.0225916132,
0.0425419398,
0.0048119817,
-0.0300033931,
0.0381286107,
-0.0200438686,
-0.0111882091,
-0.0089153349,
0.0316754021,
0.0040147305,
0.0079129916,
0.025135681,
-0.0006933668,
0.0355405957,
-0.0254858732,
-0.0111757535,
0.0307342988,
0.0500963368,
0.0361591242,
0.0000019429,
-0.0692739189,
0.0314007364,
0.0124548273,
-0.0062071057,
-0.0029221415,
0.032886073,
-0.0272707157,
0.0365556963,
0.0011298496,
-0.0014632858,
-0.0428651422,
0.0642206594,
0.0382026955,
-0.0075748218,
0.0407641605,
-0.0054469509,
-0.0397742726,
0.0556311086,
-0.0054648053,
0.0277331192,
-0.0638223663,
0.0239677578,
0.0047649397,
-0.0312739313,
-0.0302152131,
-0.0291256122,
0.019254243,
0.007220231,
0.0375002772,
0.0532282963,
0.0560953729,
-0.0583338924,
-0.0370823927,
0.0057721282,
0.1093934104,
-0.0202312395,
-0.0089898286,
-0.0269902386,
-0.0220275726,
-0.0093492167,
-0.0063782618,
-0.0321599543,
0.0175419487,
-0.001692362,
0.0089299651,
-0.0403487459,
0.0069735525,
-0.0005292519,
0.0437122062,
-0.0142692644,
0.0161784533,
0.0032671508,
-0.0037974752,
0.0806264058,
0.0078767641,
-0.0624585785,
-0.0313704051,
-0.0076637254,
0.0069590402,
-0.0158771351,
0.0156435333,
-0.0434047654,
-0.0536241569,
0.0188756362,
-0.0584938973,
0.0711062253,
-0.0030713456,
-0.092087768,
0.0616276003,
-0.0532083847,
0.0651603341,
-0.0485061109,
0.0680459961,
-0.0095897019,
-0.0045008282,
-0.0301514752,
0.0514616147,
-0.0082949949,
-0.0015318666,
-0.0176585652,
-0.0411593467,
0.0006080915,
-0.0243501421,
-0.0199277699,
0.0084023234,
-0.0023536838,
0.0075452016,
-0.0035316511,
-0.0066649788,
-0.011433227,
0.0267739166,
0.0012717665,
0.0108400984,
-0.0336525626,
-0.0678762272,
-0.0168704409,
0.0290652867,
0.0385051966,
-0.0185973011,
0.0080644116,
0.0574940294,
-0.0376282074,
-0.0935650542,
-0.0182025768,
-0.0038633661,
-0.010963208,
-0.033883594,
0.0190903358,
-0.0481222272,
-0.0285483934,
-0.0041636261,
0.0104909651,
-0.0255818274,
0.0191848502,
0.0031146861,
-0.0187210031,
0.0539250299,
-0.0439906381,
-0.0334211029,
-0.0194323957,
0.0185350943,
0.0495164432,
0.0868973136,
-0.0224537477,
0.0186456125,
0.044218041,
0.0372801907,
0.0165594909,
0.0297807734,
0.0124782017,
0.0385080837,
-0.0265973248,
0.0207339562,
0.0303281099,
0.0340235494,
0.0312755629,
0.0064588035,
-0.0278521068,
-0.0668514445,
0.0502012148,
0.0071197967,
-0.0309836809,
-0.0367807001,
0.028561743,
0.0220967103,
0.0058300556,
-0.0065814895,
-0.024280414,
-0.0038780947,
-0.0407496169,
-0.0224421248,
-0.0290792119,
-0.0178719703,
-0.026471911,
-0.0138518419,
-0.0268283654,
-0.0283475537,
0.0078118867,
-0.0210567713,
0.0878881067,
0.0174055286,
-0.0274714902,
0.0194572844,
0.0488189086,
-0.0125295417,
-0.0236324631,
-0.0791869015,
0.0628322586,
-0.0469803028,
0.0234546755,
-0.0341797583,
0.0038101163,
0.0028489695,
0.017353829,
0.047699172,
0.0228185598,
0.01399667,
0.0376417227,
-0.0461334661,
-0.0339113325,
-0.0215485878,
0.0099800266,
0.0260008089,
0.0329785496,
-0.0060314899,
0.0498698466,
-0.0908462629,
-0.0228303038,
0.0516685285,
0.0694826692,
-0.0075037344,
0.0052170558,
0.0107473377,
0.021898577,
0.0093793459,
-0.0252840538,
-0.0197901111,
0.0252006948,
-0.0105897086,
0.0257858932,
0.00573387,
-0.0201405324,
0.0279045627,
0.0372811817,
-0.0475284159,
-0.0552832894,
0.0766567215,
-0.0433697961,
0.0008156974,
0.0168568622,
0.0027938969,
0.0172788855,
-0.0326389968,
-0.0054091509,
-0.0365098417,
0.0321357287,
0.0129468124,
0.0675689802,
-0.0346144401,
0.0291888174,
-0.0021947077,
-0.014043319,
0.0702715665,
-0.0280006658,
-0.0259986669,
-0.0162825324,
-0.02962506,
0.0217742864,
0.0201547258,
0.026116278,
-0.0637259632,
0.0157237053,
-0.0463661589,
-0.0127077466,
-0.0373433642,
-0.0182465818,
-0.0092694629,
-0.029924104,
0.0082251551,
-0.0155079905,
0.0146893878,
0.0675932914,
-0.0093287928,
0.0197909083,
0.0118725328,
0.0304488353,
-0.0338102393,
-0.0049185157,
0.0047063422,
0.0277324542,
0.0532473624,
0.0272151791,
0.0041833469,
-0.0030766837,
0.0395056829,
-0.020155238,
0.0609058551,
-0.0142928688,
-0.0137912231,
0.0297835767,
-0.0139234578,
-0.0110908793,
0.1244902909,
-0.0203306582,
-0.0113850944,
0.0237406678,
0.0077941646,
-0.036659129,
-0.0238173492,
0.020634193,
-0.0854149163,
-0.0207963604,
0.0009180439,
-0.0231761225,
0.0561381429,
-0.0345760658,
-0.0248443093,
-0.052000463,
-0.0380422324,
-0.0250079017,
-0.0710623041,
-0.0982108787,
0.0312981047,
0.0012363481,
0.0446544215,
-0.0361287147,
-0.0551111698,
-0.0057106223,
-0.0335141607,
-0.0009858556,
-0.0013388515,
0.0050761122,
-0.0460948832,
0.0665897578,
0.0509356447,
0.0103146061,
0.0024788768,
0.0061920085,
-0.0473962389,
0.0026399074,
-0.0322476141,
-0.0033919709,
0.0572402701,
-0.0464888141,
0.0215334278,
-0.0295931548,
0.0057531954,
-0.0298239589,
-0.0157767218,
-0.0236632787,
0.0061470624,
-0.0475057289,
-0.0305800606,
-0.0782398358,
0.0118740397,
-0.0218529422,
0.0720117316,
0.0202444829,
-0.0070925797,
-0.0176614169,
0.0053618723,
0.0238513034,
-0.012813597,
-0.0071844934,
-0.0371577665,
-0.0244180877,
0.0716838762,
0.0318153426,
-0.024739081,
-0.0527303666,
0.0271726586,
0.0224262588,
0.0171299521,
-0.0161828976,
0.0494272746,
0.0304855611,
-0.0224933177,
-0.0368075259,
0.0547118299,
0.0261530392,
-0.0350687653,
-0.0187411308,
-0.0030630426,
0.0127620939,
0.0425757878,
-0.0500835665,
-0.0796162337,
-0.0549778529,
-0.0167477615,
-0.0182252657,
0.0100622019,
-0.0509619266,
-0.0273429304,
-0.1212961823,
0.0150840329,
-0.0194094833,
-0.0863371268,
-0.0478146784,
0.0175182484,
0.0425235853,
-0.0682919547,
-0.0258439463,
-0.0199337918,
0.0132147502,
-0.0207866579,
-0.014772865,
0.0384261794,
-0.0372406468,
0.0439632796,
-0.0820314512,
0.0235945284,
0.0229742397,
0.0114563843,
0.0013214969,
-0.0820307657,
0.0307768248,
-0.0206536278,
-0.0034752924,
0.0105054574,
0.0300725885,
-0.040417131,
-0.0102642262,
0.0422564894,
-0.0013776248,
-0.0302126836,
-0.0305504091,
0.0006171954,
0.0361067355,
0.0393838175,
-0.0074351113,
-0.0403074995,
-0.0178118143,
0.0170207489,
0.0608211607,
0.0203087721,
-0.0104280924,
0.0048896102,
0.0269861594,
-0.0057991236,
-0.0144044412,
-0.0167531166,
0.0061174287,
-0.0261237286,
-0.0563179292,
-0.0422382876,
0.0158478487,
0.0253772438,
0.0265086889,
-0.0136871459,
-0.0709146783,
-0.0238288995,
0.0169287696,
-0.0573263988,
0.0591725148,
-0.0374527387,
0.0205677077,
-0.0759622008,
-0.0016016436,
-0.0164937619,
-0.0388374105,
-0.0664312541,
0.0612903275,
-0.0716923624,
-0.0193555448,
0.0113454191,
0.0269550476,
0.019344667,
0.0224013124,
-0.0038430998,
-0.0598219223,
0.033096157,
0.0293650441,
0.0156592391,
0.0328029357,
0.0187620521,
-0.0597053319,
0.0000560827,
0.0120339496,
-0.0300025083,
0.010430417,
0.0687498748,
-0.039006196,
-0.0087853624,
-0.010220373,
0.018274704,
0.0088738026,
0.0704465583,
-0.0014452337,
0.0424201228,
-0.0460451134,
0.009835477,
0.0364454761,
-0.0005209839,
-0.0703279153,
-0.0009807789,
0.0440097153,
-0.0157235209,
-0.0139471404,
0.0553989969,
-0.0238477718,
0.0586915202,
-0.0241386443,
-0.0175439902,
0.0481493324,
0.0406574681,
0.020554224,
-0.0100814737,
-0.0397195294,
0.0009697195,
-0.0254889466,
0.051096648,
0.0425390229,
0.0599093959,
0.0068938853,
0.0104603032,
0.0045712055,
0.0080529461,
-0.0127483541,
0.0120857637,
-0.0381272659,
0.0935844406,
0.0120885652,
-0.034018632,
-0.0082152719,
-0.0364580676,
-0.0201098304,
-0.0191265922,
0.0089583397,
-0.0191307664,
-0.0320597179,
0.0376062021,
0.0106740557,
0.0255894046,
-0.00531905,
0.0591150336,
0.0113604935,
0.0167627428,
-0.0028797113,
0.0245357212,
-0.0271815397,
0.005023072,
0.0419975594,
0.0376018845,
0.0223512948,
0.0721909404,
-0.0387662463,
-0.0526410416,
-0.0200783517,
0.0183012411,
-0.0013941228,
0.0700318813,
0.0288615469,
0.0469386503,
0.0207140092,
-0.0473353155,
-0.0024205116,
-0.0629193857,
-0.0227551144,
0.0262347031,
0.0085459454,
-5.744096492e-33,
-0.0368397906,
-0.0006622124,
-0.0033256277,
-0.0240155738,
-0.005835379,
0.0399518348,
0.0160396602,
0.0030582552,
-0.0323500149,
0.0182901509,
0.0104879076,
0.0341997445,
0.001749874,
0.0108483788,
-0.0354637466,
-0.0191855542,
0.0162298996,
-0.004082195,
-0.0347667336,
-0.0214872845,
0.0254135206,
-0.0019185783,
0.1037312821,
-0.0673798993,
0.0117382556,
0.0201553311,
-0.0258559193,
0.0358780138,
0.0056998054,
0.0510582626,
-0.0013729857,
0.063520439,
0.0052159471,
-0.0105452649,
-0.0218167678,
0.0145572722,
-0.0626783296,
0.0045182882,
0.0422334485,
0.0511721224,
-0.0635211393,
0.0284585245,
0.0262731612,
-0.007285988,
0.0039497884,
-0.0292910505,
0.0241917986,
-0.046194233,
0.0095465695,
0.0375470929,
-0.025558915,
0.0394780673,
0.006024213,
-0.0337612703,
0.022021303,
-0.0089493934,
0.0071527632,
-0.0023895674,
-0.0530683473,
0.0262387451,
0.026304096,
-0.0026706406,
0.0413680635,
0.0380033404,
-0.0098489029,
0.0823724717,
0.0310459901,
-0.0255003534,
-0.0051724003,
-0.0437243804,
0.0286972653,
0.0682306215,
0.0286056884,
0.072619617,
0.0672593191,
0.0312118866,
-0.0740049109,
0.012840434,
-0.0786850005,
0.0742674619,
0.0092425346,
0.003090156,
-0.0246935505,
0.0236770976,
-0.0419348553,
-0.0159822386,
-0.0742574707,
0.0187788904,
0.0483088493,
0.0337062404,
-0.0441319719,
0.0139193404,
0.0422026403,
-0.0187302064,
0.0383974425,
0.0350293443,
-0.0038664446,
0.0270948652,
-0.0013804697,
-0.0126899751,
-0.0933781862,
-0.0482052006,
0.0664638877,
-0.0129345562,
0.0018075957,
-0.0164926481,
0.0451517515,
0.0046744952,
-0.0502946079,
-0.0038776929,
-0.0396168195,
-0.0101913475,
0.0242586955,
0.0283062346,
0.0532147437,
0.003184591,
-0.0408646204,
0.0895922258,
0.0062199379,
-0.0160700511,
-0.0169699602,
-0.0401562117,
0.0221616328,
0.0102961361,
-0.0054736603,
0.0093116295,
0.0072474754,
-0.0716205239,
0.0417787507,
-0.0288195256,
0.0053800908,
0.0294486415,
2.647e-7,
0.0288292877,
0.0019025357,
-0.0152674457,
0.04446752,
-0.0296056103,
0.0548367575,
-0.0063035083,
0.0431724526,
-0.0183454752,
-0.0521300994,
-0.0034153862,
0.0366165191,
-0.0043751756,
-0.0081280516,
-0.0401770696,
0.0502702817,
-0.0285597928,
-0.006994308,
-0.0509451106,
-0.0112740276,
0.0167336743,
0.070256792,
-0.0082445936,
-0.0265849624,
0.0283035245,
-0.0725708008,
0.0566131771,
-0.0423098356,
0.0236000586,
-0.0223556608,
0.0435120538,
0.0601683185,
0.0034594014,
0.0656025037,
0.0155486949,
0.0284500886,
0.0635914356,
-0.0124074994,
-0.0085640391,
0.0213987492,
-0.0091359951,
-0.0142919729,
-0.0366608314,
-0.0544556454,
0.081886068,
-0.0523303524,
-0.0338210724,
-0.0300624277,
-0.0219772197,
-0.0407517292,
0.0559810475,
-0.0121460194,
0.022322895,
-0.0123316143,
-0.008328693,
-0.0369450599,
-0.0339197144,
-0.0691366717,
-0.0025281864,
0.0133002186,
0.0010257908,
-0.0468688682,
-0.0147768389,
-0.0040260865,
0.0228224713,
-0.0253219698,
-0.0341479294,
1.814373694e-34,
0.0215443447,
-0.0020527574,
-0.0057161776,
-0.0216593556,
0.0284618437,
-0.0174907465,
-0.0331716798,
-0.0214711614,
-0.0203234609,
-0.0391888805,
0.0372876078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13173v1 | DISGO: Automatic End-to-End Evaluation for Scene Text OCR | 2023-08-25T04:45:37 | 2023-08-25T04:45:37 | Mei-Yuh Hwang, Yangyang Shi, Ankit Ramchandani, Guan Pang, Praveen Krishnan, Lucas Kabela, Frank Seide, Samyak Datta, Jun Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | This paper discusses the challenges of optical character recognition (OCR) on
natural scenes, which is harder than OCR on documents due to the wild content
and various image backgrounds. We propose to uniformly use word error rates
(WER) as a new measurement for evaluating scene-text OCR, both end-to-end (e2e)
performance and individual system component performances. Particularly for the
e2e metric, we name it DISGO WER as it considers Deletion, Insertion,
Substitution, and Grouping/Ordering errors. Finally we propose to utilize the
concept of super blocks to automatically compute BLEU scores for e2e OCR
machine translation. The small SCUT public test set is used to demonstrate WER
performance by a modularized OCR system. | [
-0.0053694854,
0.0282089021,
0.0536098406,
0.0599344335,
-0.0260531493,
0.0009351558,
0.0604975447,
0.0314471722,
0.0199854001,
-0.0172242075,
0.0312660858,
-0.0206371583,
0.0794342533,
0.0370063409,
-0.0309350193,
-0.0515905619,
-0.0140693253,
-0.0475212596,
-0.0358622633,
-0.0017750922,
-0.0081110047,
-0.0270246118,
-0.0153643675,
-0.0234801639,
0.0281278528,
0.0209590327,
0.004509957,
0.0559416041,
0.0629397109,
-0.0239051469,
-0.043954879,
0.0187428333,
-0.0157062095,
0.0777786002,
0.0000020334,
-0.0809783563,
-0.0618878938,
0.0419024788,
-0.0180556849,
0.0279988647,
0.0486382432,
-0.030611461,
-0.0529458337,
-0.0303104892,
0.0291641094,
-0.0062701744,
0.0908424556,
0.0472633168,
-0.0250808969,
0.0503042638,
-0.0425680391,
-0.0173137914,
-0.012611703,
-0.0093722753,
0.0031910453,
-0.0094382418,
0.0104168309,
0.019498013,
0.0116207544,
-0.0174335651,
-0.0300068073,
0.0155984815,
-0.0121341525,
-0.0399913378,
0.010225757,
0.020647889,
0.0114860982,
0.0054095797,
-0.0225827619,
0.0620709322,
-0.0385871604,
0.0140756425,
-0.0434112772,
-0.0180487968,
-0.0364310816,
-0.0068289116,
-0.00353921,
0.0215290934,
-0.0334507599,
-0.0380648188,
-0.0313327685,
0.0518880375,
0.0113010434,
-0.0292933974,
-0.0344258547,
0.017664222,
0.0294838771,
-0.0585414916,
-0.0032929231,
0.0056711719,
-0.0008520074,
-0.0258186981,
0.0463220626,
0.0072899186,
0.0596708916,
-0.0210385378,
-0.0502471998,
-0.0385423377,
-0.0130543448,
-0.003259307,
0.0774994493,
0.0341906771,
-0.0361337811,
0.05185524,
-0.0359001607,
0.1158207133,
0.0033843112,
0.0402732007,
-0.0028173279,
0.0058986396,
-0.0267294608,
0.0254770443,
-0.0048049451,
-0.0401494168,
-0.04850493,
-0.0335522704,
0.0029142515,
-0.004551569,
0.003824895,
0.0055836439,
0.0283495262,
-0.0683358163,
0.0077530709,
-0.069038637,
-0.0188281089,
-0.029566925,
0.0333211198,
-0.0149042718,
-0.0157595295,
-0.016222991,
0.0024939962,
0.0284734368,
0.0646931827,
0.0007683436,
0.0002435153,
0.0801939666,
-0.0279506724,
-0.042534627,
0.0368469059,
0.0388567783,
-0.0733638927,
-0.0515081696,
-0.0105711119,
-0.0531087108,
-0.0016550096,
0.0042056176,
0.0114154276,
-0.0081059197,
0.0186259914,
0.0084582437,
-0.0035242522,
0.0620255284,
-0.0382194296,
-0.0407206304,
0.0626288429,
0.0097471327,
0.006582024,
0.0116438745,
0.0182621796,
0.0495524146,
0.0340872183,
0.0003026981,
0.055515863,
0.0681261048,
-0.0488331802,
-0.006881095,
-0.0144481035,
-0.0376888253,
0.0934297964,
0.002611185,
0.0163244661,
0.0845636502,
-0.0346412733,
0.0201170798,
0.0390592664,
0.0064490293,
0.0033651714,
0.0243984107,
-0.0291341804,
-0.0057931887,
-0.0011646673,
-0.032507766,
-0.0081730252,
0.0226776414,
0.0009225878,
0.0117980121,
0.0363687202,
0.043154791,
0.0207668878,
0.0048661632,
-0.0402984358,
0.0073951348,
-0.0154865105,
-0.0273645651,
0.0896980166,
-0.0315336622,
-0.0848823488,
-0.0025167833,
-0.0372946113,
-0.0967813283,
-0.0055150194,
-0.0374876522,
0.0318871997,
0.0420862697,
0.1278115809,
-0.0329378843,
0.0632339194,
0.0447655432,
-0.0487468392,
0.0622173436,
0.0031838175,
0.0166813359,
0.0520310365,
-0.0657608211,
-0.0301394723,
0.0590695404,
-0.0307478886,
0.0317622907,
-0.0159490183,
0.0281614698,
0.0181413069,
-0.0280099735,
-0.0929100215,
0.040613573,
0.029276263,
-0.014705468,
-0.0339321233,
0.0204381254,
-0.0108504668,
0.0009957142,
-0.0342318043,
-0.0288286563,
0.017417375,
-0.0205646083,
0.010789766,
-0.0057912394,
0.0091352575,
-0.0139147686,
0.0598430783,
-0.0574720912,
0.0033339425,
0.0653765947,
-0.0118274977,
-0.0245277435,
-0.0452182591,
-0.0050559514,
-0.0203770604,
-0.0427027941,
0.036787305,
-0.0370268524,
-0.0325672217,
-0.0179180782,
0.0242374782,
0.0026683416,
0.0038020029,
0.0280309152,
-0.05224723,
0.0301379822,
-0.0525766648,
-0.0143109877,
0.0052376818,
-0.0237722266,
0.0257708244,
0.016302634,
0.0389275923,
-0.0285458677,
-0.0552868731,
-0.0586022846,
-0.0526500009,
-0.0245392304,
0.0049413675,
0.0482249036,
0.004445456,
-0.0082844784,
-0.0364216305,
0.0349378102,
0.0175115075,
-0.0322895497,
-0.0665687695,
0.0110512786,
-0.0189217813,
-0.0579367131,
0.001364431,
-0.0158509035,
0.0418427587,
0.0167856142,
0.0171119869,
-0.0701196194,
-0.0741764307,
0.0649844185,
0.0090138577,
-0.0054397904,
-0.0098356819,
-0.011804224,
-0.0077074249,
-0.012093571,
-0.0153962644,
0.0788597241,
0.0000980595,
-0.0570229553,
0.0269265082,
-0.0104971407,
0.0188285913,
-0.0106886029,
0.0132552311,
-0.0064609847,
0.0383246392,
-0.0414909422,
-0.032439582,
-0.0272225086,
-0.0323190466,
0.0527610406,
0.0027577311,
-0.0372312069,
-0.0026836325,
0.0005653798,
-0.0357767008,
-0.0181953572,
0.0177046601,
0.0231309496,
-0.0352793634,
-0.049539797,
-0.0172888301,
-0.0888703316,
-0.0317463838,
-0.0061663967,
0.025353631,
-0.0228936467,
0.0258134641,
0.0080958912,
0.0107341586,
-0.027917238,
-0.0579038598,
0.0131343184,
-0.0245393142,
0.0152532374,
-0.0230110008,
0.027051799,
-0.0674872398,
0.0696954355,
-0.0263456963,
-0.0286190342,
0.0045962329,
0.0331351124,
-0.0334828272,
-0.0167908929,
-0.0262697339,
-0.0504302979,
-0.0282585993,
0.0717318058,
0.0227949489,
0.0852491185,
-0.0105896797,
-0.0065769609,
-0.018956719,
0.0741714537,
-0.0419186316,
-0.0008703876,
0.0039054751,
-0.0517371036,
0.0204296466,
0.0046077301,
0.040737249,
-0.0087256161,
-0.0117577845,
0.0087184245,
0.0261587873,
0.039844919,
0.0460963845,
-0.0093514482,
0.0552611388,
-0.0412314609,
-0.0308930669,
0.0679764375,
-0.0135640213,
-0.0177112054,
-0.0745838583,
-0.0452551767,
0.0272725336,
-0.0039002774,
-0.0033170665,
-0.0226027556,
-0.0290397033,
0.0187238958,
0.076515995,
0.0198560525,
0.0061085024,
-0.0060891481,
-0.0437382609,
0.0316852331,
0.0591139719,
-0.0420990065,
-0.055078432,
0.0048730061,
-0.0040332666,
-0.0247021969,
-0.0375232659,
0.0216151644,
0.0150184091,
-0.0626473874,
-0.0171362255,
-0.0133505855,
0.0049109105,
0.0080772741,
-0.0119709037,
-0.0311827529,
0.0635177568,
-0.0012663759,
-0.0122856814,
-0.0047470443,
0.0434036143,
-0.0048946724,
0.0292417165,
-0.0140776811,
0.0615127496,
-0.0026667232,
-0.0025467358,
-0.0058889831,
0.0016467532,
-0.0016388999,
-0.0114812972,
-0.0178726111,
0.0038939128,
0.0191067923,
0.0217850972,
0.019386312,
-0.0063851164,
0.0156119727,
-0.0192009397,
-0.0070057805,
-0.0152624482,
-0.0375659764,
-0.0199275315,
-0.007410571,
-0.0760672316,
0.0470658615,
-0.0090070255,
-0.0347045884,
-0.0145640215,
-0.0176644791,
-0.0093382159,
-0.0021759782,
0.0574838482,
-0.0068575949,
-0.0631254762,
-0.0190240648,
0.0511908941,
-0.0440026708,
-0.0354611911,
-0.0194326248,
0.0114334328,
-0.0762634054,
0.0671309829,
-0.0389347263,
0.0062961704,
-0.022424113,
0.0056002224,
-0.0146027859,
-0.0259253699,
0.0654672459,
0.0705035105,
0.0282358453,
-0.0310973879,
0.0248282645,
-0.045972269,
0.0395821743,
0.0192207992,
0.047095608,
-0.011707467,
-0.029569909,
-0.0482520089,
-0.0381315388,
0.0060218479,
-0.0165064819,
0.0097410157,
0.0176662356,
-0.0270446353,
0.0016911397,
-0.0274312962,
-0.0007593209,
-0.0046567242,
0.0033135035,
-0.0202461239,
0.0033957756,
-0.041865699,
0.057151664,
0.0252453014,
0.0281619634,
-0.0165100936,
0.0000722926,
0.0221753474,
-0.0224196017,
0.0220691394,
0.0790365264,
0.0116441585,
-0.0271406434,
0.0029036147,
0.0174763724,
0.0103671206,
0.0605841652,
0.0048126597,
-0.0146938404,
0.0069729337,
-0.0076771346,
0.0288278442,
0.0549767129,
-0.0057694139,
0.0663743839,
0.0053446209,
0.0155489258,
0.0087411171,
0.0511854701,
-0.0476265028,
-0.0114478962,
-0.0713330954,
-0.0107644899,
0.0521103591,
0.0043016872,
0.0387369283,
-0.0352484919,
0.0031461159,
-0.0833079815,
0.0020149797,
-0.0128255645,
0.005689247,
-0.056804195,
0.0231272839,
0.0109420745,
0.0584869385,
0.0327899083,
-0.0020315473,
-0.0405701511,
-0.0036914917,
0.022025438,
-0.0319796018,
0.0219000559,
0.0296907462,
-0.0234284475,
-0.0389558896,
-0.0286631174,
-0.0013223991,
-0.0044373036,
0.0486207083,
0.0321230218,
0.037798889,
0.0097526219,
-0.0123157222,
0.0145379761,
-0.0262220111,
0.0464132465,
0.0216564666,
-0.0224330723,
-0.0248268656,
0.016632583,
0.0040441873,
-5.814693009e-33,
-0.0187922958,
-0.0817860365,
-0.0009775228,
-0.0340165012,
-0.0258577336,
0.0172696542,
0.0230788756,
-0.0140552148,
0.0116603011,
-0.0015635076,
-0.0077060312,
0.0026967432,
0.0573459901,
0.0108923102,
-0.0494254157,
0.0253255013,
0.0252590962,
0.0014430642,
-0.0656902716,
-0.0533751957,
0.0516191423,
0.0514740534,
0.0367754512,
-0.0416613966,
0.0249305107,
-0.0067893635,
-0.0227217451,
-0.0576247796,
0.0399059728,
-0.0186745636,
0.0074559781,
-0.0094726942,
0.001725966,
0.022340687,
0.013710686,
0.0316053443,
-0.05635456,
0.0392036028,
-0.0610802434,
0.0494490266,
-0.0409703068,
0.0213469919,
-0.0166557301,
-0.0078971544,
-0.0481057055,
-0.0551130623,
-0.0045489809,
-0.0323558003,
-0.0266655553,
0.0269005485,
-0.0433518514,
0.0436634012,
-0.0045371978,
-0.0236520283,
0.0769449025,
-0.0109579479,
0.0301989373,
-0.0156734791,
-0.0731299222,
0.0171532817,
0.014532635,
0.0437136963,
0.0529299639,
0.0014639032,
-0.0379347615,
-0.0048536747,
0.0342484377,
0.0010473378,
0.0484382212,
-0.0389017947,
0.0237077046,
-0.0071922019,
0.0553948171,
0.0457775481,
0.0883252099,
0.0031790992,
-0.0591842905,
0.0269923676,
-0.0535355397,
0.0208100751,
0.0117226643,
-0.000143257,
-0.022983063,
0.0218182355,
-0.0084236227,
-0.0165110473,
-0.0388065539,
0.0147792837,
0.0089668203,
0.0359258391,
-0.0160720218,
-0.0550874099,
0.0414096117,
-0.0147279818,
0.0309817195,
-0.0513426401,
0.0105075678,
0.0618181378,
-0.0132431947,
-0.0168484729,
-0.0365315899,
-0.0382151194,
0.0157685429,
0.0873920172,
-0.0079006646,
-0.0304680541,
0.0009386261,
0.0647136942,
-0.0650144741,
0.0096992748,
-0.0030760234,
-0.0173494238,
0.0541339926,
0.0609448254,
0.0064998548,
-0.0413862653,
0.0328505971,
0.0397645235,
-0.0020414162,
0.0137941437,
0.0157975201,
-0.0084361658,
-0.0054436112,
0.0188072361,
-0.0207801908,
0.0305909105,
-0.005682379,
-0.0540929213,
-0.0038643954,
0.0371958762,
-0.0070670396,
0.0422011279,
2.625e-7,
0.0562448204,
0.0903848335,
0.0669558942,
0.0096218418,
-0.0144973714,
0.0072759711,
-0.0318102129,
-0.0010049209,
-0.0047080093,
0.0172199178,
0.0573784895,
-0.0495043285,
0.1019981056,
-0.0369222909,
-0.0251545981,
0.0007844613,
0.0334955715,
-0.0062998938,
-0.0245576594,
-0.0275412854,
0.0446899831,
0.0093290424,
-0.0432681404,
-0.0300375614,
-0.0138725452,
-0.0531311035,
0.0541843921,
0.0143338516,
0.0378190205,
-0.0153292557,
0.0138157085,
-0.001813571,
-0.062874727,
0.0572149381,
0.0370335765,
0.0207692031,
0.0795278549,
0.0011574322,
-0.0580340885,
-0.0018107429,
-0.0002385491,
0.0142054725,
-0.0229343977,
-0.0704129934,
0.0100902822,
0.0645899624,
0.0307327304,
-0.01706177,
-0.0033479475,
-0.0044599148,
0.0661605448,
-0.0433747247,
-0.0128862886,
0.0151084727,
0.049599424,
-0.0087765558,
-0.0241017491,
-0.0319194831,
0.0175593812,
-0.0456585065,
0.0335467793,
-0.0379206762,
-0.0413729288,
0.0024163825,
0.0555687994,
-0.0339388475,
0.0034638362,
2.064095989e-34,
0.0195228402,
-0.011769698,
-0.0136594158,
0.0139780818,
0.0190108567,
-0.0217406787,
-0.0070188455,
-0.0400371216,
-0.0564986877,
-0.0421110317,
-0.0118910512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13170v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13170v2 | Measuring Spurious Correlation in Classification: 'Clever Hans' in Translationese | 2023-08-25T04:19:58 | 2024-06-11T19:38:28 | Angana Borah, Daria Pylypenko, Cristina Espana-Bonet, Josef van Genabith | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work has shown evidence of 'Clever Hans' behavior in high-performance
neural translationese classifiers, where BERT-based classifiers capitalize on
spurious correlations, in particular topic information, between data and target
classification labels, rather than genuine translationese signals.
Translationese signals are subtle (especially for professional translation) and
compete with many other signals in the data such as genre, style, author, and,
in particular, topic. This raises the general question of how much of the
performance of a classifier is really due to spurious correlations in the data
versus the signals actually targeted for by the classifier, especially for
subtle target signals and in challenging (low resource) data settings. We focus
on topic-based spurious correlation and approach the question from two
directions: (i) where we have no knowledge about spurious topic information and
its distribution in the data, (ii) where we have some indication about the
nature of spurious topic correlations. For (i) we develop a measure from first
principles capturing alignment of unsupervised topics with target
classification labels as an indication of spurious topic information in the
data. We show that our measure is the same as purity in clustering and propose
a 'topic floor' (as in a 'noise floor') for classification. For (ii) we
investigate masking of known spurious topic carriers in classification. Both
(i) and (ii) contribute to quantifying and (ii) to mitigating spurious
correlations. | [
0.0143185183,
0.0474818647,
-0.0330480523,
0.0624033697,
-0.0277218372,
0.0148941604,
0.006766519,
0.0184251331,
-0.0700164512,
0.0028567244,
-0.0501514189,
0.0110934321,
0.0498470701,
-0.0298618544,
-0.0023547544,
-0.0048321402,
0.0282815285,
0.0128486976,
0.0381119698,
-0.0375868604,
-0.0191829689,
-0.0211403724,
0.027668871,
0.0322780199,
0.00039377,
-0.0118206702,
0.038764935,
0.0276518594,
0.0243502185,
0.0470577776,
0.0147910574,
0.0504332148,
-0.0155912768,
0.0878158957,
0.0000015459,
-0.0346249901,
-0.0272184741,
-0.0016977219,
0.0381976925,
-0.0134682236,
0.0302207097,
-0.0403515734,
-0.0053657237,
-0.0112008639,
-0.0178954899,
0.0157523379,
0.0279067829,
0.0777380019,
0.0014100234,
0.0583799854,
-0.0098979194,
-0.0184389465,
0.0324375108,
-0.0257095266,
0.0579723604,
-0.0431367904,
0.0092730811,
-0.0182533935,
-0.0641751662,
0.0451963656,
-0.0254670382,
0.0308588184,
-0.0096152136,
0.02204106,
0.0203891359,
0.0203489531,
-0.063022323,
-0.0310835168,
0.0558458157,
0.0256111529,
-0.0132336151,
-0.0206418056,
0.0251011681,
0.0269882083,
0.0182483532,
0.0210448951,
-0.0007819937,
-0.0278271958,
-0.0023715226,
-0.0004435481,
0.0877098292,
0.0382422656,
0.0364412293,
0.0118291928,
-0.0137586938,
0.0224596374,
0.0148589211,
-0.0515368283,
0.0002807066,
0.033958979,
-0.0031264469,
-0.0450043902,
0.0321270451,
-0.0072367867,
0.0215843935,
-0.0015739813,
-0.0166462585,
-0.0989462584,
0.0134014804,
-0.0982074738,
-0.0593802556,
0.0225747116,
-0.0296503734,
0.0428356752,
0.0384847298,
0.0196330193,
-0.0292826053,
0.041380845,
-0.0593728311,
-0.0135525689,
-0.0015461101,
0.0156041123,
-0.0150484387,
-0.0073373532,
0.0101352111,
-0.025543239,
-0.0579674207,
-0.0076988563,
-0.0231715422,
0.0074526691,
-0.0421765782,
0.0162461735,
-0.0520327799,
0.0203531794,
0.0023278254,
0.0250567738,
-0.0052248328,
0.0240277573,
-0.0403945483,
0.0376690477,
0.0078938222,
0.0444044806,
-0.0241021439,
-0.0541645847,
0.0301844217,
0.0252947975,
0.012896331,
-0.0357685834,
0.0019622564,
-0.0204747841,
-0.0437476188,
-0.0272189211,
0.0214872267,
-0.0581457652,
0.0166953411,
0.0233442262,
0.0056272536,
-0.0124790743,
-0.0266808197,
-0.0045506521,
-0.0569817349,
0.0419097096,
0.0212491658,
-0.0072185085,
0.0680340007,
0.0191179961,
-0.0260667559,
0.07735423,
0.030992398,
0.0452518538,
0.0666868091,
-0.0011720455,
-0.0168529619,
0.0207833052,
0.0211046208,
0.016177088,
-0.0264215171,
-0.0274274629,
0.0502996854,
0.0118375961,
0.0479817986,
0.0127176475,
-0.0192487966,
-0.0107661998,
0.0626695603,
0.0451039672,
-0.0149090607,
0.0519445315,
-0.0124050137,
-0.0126010757,
-0.0165060535,
0.0638765171,
-0.0080279522,
0.0069521554,
-0.0557189994,
-0.0166379698,
0.0244643316,
0.0165933333,
-0.0231473707,
-0.0506661609,
-0.0004125641,
0.0072889342,
-0.0098035373,
-0.0195760876,
0.0426277705,
0.0243072212,
0.0282604489,
0.0097249132,
-0.0105797909,
-0.0079356432,
0.0387214534,
-0.0038771045,
-0.0282626469,
0.0382194296,
0.0334871039,
-0.0141546028,
-0.0172241218,
-0.0004656771,
-0.0046118582,
0.0172711834,
-0.0001666309,
0.0029571697,
0.0176150706,
-0.0102643482,
-0.0312777758,
0.0229172725,
0.0308550056,
-0.0092947735,
-0.0501459166,
0.0211191606,
-0.0017508538,
-0.0681159943,
-0.0428106226,
0.0344326161,
0.0032517358,
0.0122851506,
0.0374607444,
0.0325788669,
0.0519900694,
0.0052292095,
-0.0287261885,
-0.02667946,
0.0211054403,
-0.0432404652,
-0.0369279943,
0.0394355468,
0.0304712653,
-0.0240693763,
0.0064642844,
-0.0458900444,
-0.0212891754,
-0.0118054915,
-0.0132507812,
-0.0164739098,
0.0279594362,
-0.0345426686,
0.0206831098,
-0.0349030234,
0.0264013577,
-0.0377793312,
0.0332777649,
-0.03049816,
0.0716204569,
-0.0062292661,
0.081104055,
0.0180335585,
-0.068223916,
0.0493957326,
-0.0098890215,
0.0013594026,
0.0064968728,
0.0190433636,
0.0251503997,
0.0685592517,
0.0001226349,
0.0144025097,
-0.0691299662,
-0.0590304695,
-0.0080690226,
-0.0394212939,
0.0134757245,
0.0320770107,
-0.0056121787,
0.0227285307,
0.0086205322,
-0.0301658381,
-0.0189544056,
-0.0199468359,
0.0076446282,
0.0134268068,
-0.0084734773,
-0.0170717053,
-0.0084137283,
0.007717473,
-0.018460352,
0.0617698617,
0.0292203277,
-0.0330442041,
-0.0695881099,
0.0193265788,
-0.0468107387,
-0.0013500752,
0.0058005857,
-0.0427884161,
-0.0151097868,
0.011816347,
0.0262906905,
0.030012643,
0.0253058728,
-0.0038275267,
0.0377100296,
-0.0117669525,
-0.022490304,
-0.0238593407,
-0.0373523384,
0.0483128317,
-0.0220682472,
-0.0553627126,
0.0277345236,
0.0207371898,
0.0315617807,
-0.0255281124,
-0.0254647769,
-0.0188840441,
-0.0318669677,
-0.0098768314,
-0.0381767042,
-0.0095249554,
-0.0028785248,
0.0469649807,
-0.0314467251,
-0.0234743785,
0.0535739027,
-0.0133478222,
0.0225536153,
-0.0736899227,
0.0085201422,
-0.0070447605,
0.0116589498,
0.0043086349,
0.0394375026,
-0.0168323908,
-0.0379648916,
-0.0315133817,
0.0092656938,
0.0135843633,
-0.0226507932,
-0.0123869563,
-0.0339419208,
0.0023092343,
-0.0030677265,
-0.0126156742,
-0.0447571091,
-0.0531178638,
0.0454958491,
-0.0258317944,
0.0185358915,
-0.0505435467,
-0.0385854356,
-0.0396248847,
0.005129985,
0.0377375111,
-0.0103775039,
-0.0349744,
-0.0052976599,
0.0710496232,
0.0125866504,
-0.0493180826,
0.0132791372,
-0.0571865961,
-0.0215376858,
0.0121992147,
-0.0434332453,
0.0024461872,
-0.0191188157,
-0.0102179656,
0.0634129494,
-0.0019855045,
-0.0395381376,
-0.0009298461,
0.0329850875,
-0.0126445116,
-0.0159939528,
0.1212675497,
0.0285305101,
-0.0298196953,
-0.0020770992,
0.0072287852,
0.0445587337,
0.0041301409,
0.004203049,
-0.0095020784,
0.0286351778,
0.0179508198,
0.0247345921,
-0.0106933098,
0.0018827865,
-0.0136474473,
-0.0319755375,
0.0377662927,
0.0371434912,
-0.0812075064,
-0.0311616175,
-0.0353926197,
-0.0110991308,
-0.0406227596,
0.0453377888,
-0.0488715954,
0.0441665761,
0.0098274574,
0.0128287012,
-0.0265538879,
-0.0683480874,
-0.0242191143,
-0.0357304476,
0.0410600901,
0.0363823846,
0.0596613549,
-0.0359785929,
-0.0507687628,
-0.0163343512,
-0.0278935879,
-0.0036810332,
0.0067300443,
0.0718040615,
-0.0046391501,
-0.0180806387,
-0.0199839268,
0.0046747141,
-0.0421118587,
0.0165146254,
-0.013166938,
0.054658249,
-0.0611409657,
0.0039407196,
0.0026192938,
0.0171885807,
0.0043920679,
0.0602485463,
0.0190531891,
-0.0510556996,
0.0356772691,
-0.0019054672,
0.0289171711,
0.0315609574,
0.0080437427,
0.0262776706,
-0.0332536697,
-0.1237964928,
-0.1025240272,
-0.0778731331,
-0.0154850008,
0.0521767735,
0.0277510658,
0.0645968691,
-0.0448764376,
-0.0475090519,
-0.0219964031,
0.0139721865,
0.0118072843,
0.0008289894,
-0.0266346615,
0.015194173,
-0.0037774127,
-0.033775188,
-0.0147679634,
-0.0255080573,
-0.0902960822,
-0.0658602342,
0.0209841188,
-0.0026089309,
0.0317468867,
0.0495623983,
-0.0497814231,
-0.0571410842,
0.0076289112,
0.1034549028,
-0.0489458628,
0.020992551,
0.0336120166,
-0.0510704182,
0.0088569494,
0.0197127443,
-0.0338649638,
0.0259370543,
0.0260918997,
-0.0126511501,
-0.097942248,
-0.0377252772,
0.0121821221,
-0.0088164089,
0.1088047624,
-0.0573275052,
-0.043682687,
-0.0267940592,
-0.0143191442,
0.0053118113,
-0.0266832002,
0.0136519521,
-0.0540107414,
0.0543736629,
0.0286154319,
-0.0407614149,
0.0806793422,
-0.0397495441,
0.009716209,
-0.0194004048,
-0.0253651254,
-0.0621314831,
0.0576480962,
-0.019940909,
0.0361098461,
0.0014345808,
0.0067154174,
0.049508784,
0.0498031713,
-0.0058695278,
0.0361512303,
0.0351489708,
0.0395550132,
0.0010050987,
-0.005867749,
-0.0848331004,
0.0070255869,
-0.014866272,
0.0082280701,
0.0402284749,
-0.0181065071,
0.0499172732,
-0.0052082408,
-0.0235301107,
-0.0239751805,
0.0269380808,
0.0128602907,
-0.0313970372,
-0.0185285863,
-0.0201809201,
0.0053178733,
0.0446554162,
0.0631441846,
-0.0656379908,
-0.01879628,
-0.0079802154,
-0.0504667237,
-0.0124439811,
0.0095830364,
0.0592580549,
-0.0162960794,
-0.0194016527,
-0.0081386762,
-0.064595744,
-0.0505862162,
0.0364366993,
-0.0210706033,
0.025507912,
0.01009057,
0.01769628,
0.1126886457,
-0.0682028234,
0.0205121711,
-0.0316774063,
-0.0089799166,
0.0289462116,
-0.0155618982,
-0.0342554711,
-5.801137355e-33,
0.0130632985,
-0.0633478537,
-0.0321503915,
0.0046197153,
0.0274507273,
0.0148498286,
-0.0119931633,
-0.0215156283,
0.0058597978,
0.0291404258,
0.0040656375,
0.0180692617,
0.0152115542,
-0.0253401678,
-0.0197459906,
-0.0090332339,
0.0520306528,
0.0102636227,
-0.0432829782,
0.0288535152,
0.0677410886,
0.0119430665,
0.052963227,
-0.1015935913,
0.0582988784,
-0.0105479863,
-0.0234762523,
0.0184863135,
0.0475611314,
0.0106489118,
-0.0013642927,
0.0462284908,
0.0205024257,
-0.0067866165,
0.0228029005,
-0.0288541,
-0.0461220704,
-0.075704284,
-0.0088486569,
0.0563049614,
0.0202920754,
-0.0419664495,
0.0863852799,
-0.0154408487,
-0.0515084751,
0.0082241241,
0.0905352905,
-0.031735763,
-0.0590812936,
-0.0499417409,
-0.058918342,
0.0182748064,
-0.0152314827,
0.0021709586,
0.0196089894,
-0.0030442472,
0.0091659073,
-0.0156360678,
-0.0828759298,
0.0050476152,
-0.0344403349,
0.0391934626,
0.0246365741,
-0.0050811847,
-0.0246580001,
0.0611653514,
0.0341725834,
0.0584195219,
0.0462463684,
0.0130474865,
0.053638529,
0.0080171963,
0.0471815206,
0.0347204842,
0.0762624517,
0.0026680492,
-0.0571492836,
0.086535342,
0.0016251382,
-0.0440051742,
0.0042912699,
-0.0159936436,
-0.0801771358,
-0.0272455011,
-0.0040698037,
-0.0004877357,
-0.0316653885,
0.0003986568,
-0.0401423909,
-0.0097691929,
-0.0217191316,
-0.0277350303,
0.0202685073,
-0.0255300552,
0.0010162606,
0.0201301388,
-0.0323298089,
-0.0162457302,
0.0209846478,
0.015479493,
-0.0117015429,
-0.055731561,
0.0290767252,
0.0401295684,
0.0343635678,
-0.0197173171,
0.1006312668,
0.0130427862,
-0.0471618697,
0.005353326,
-0.0204814952,
-0.0166170746,
-0.0022080289,
-0.0196635015,
0.0259200688,
-0.0241585784,
0.0017480152,
0.0296192281,
0.0627454892,
0.0586323477,
-0.034235049,
0.025753947,
-0.0316883624,
0.021287445,
-0.0403484702,
-0.0054728207,
0.0324983522,
0.0093076164,
0.0374051146,
-0.0955905691,
-0.0349409953,
-0.0533273816,
2.56e-7,
0.0398109965,
0.0398798771,
-0.0314364135,
-0.0085504446,
0.0223113149,
0.0531663038,
-0.0465372279,
0.0481990688,
-0.0022955311,
-0.0041799801,
0.0395528227,
-0.0017366454,
0.0328765363,
0.0560092144,
-0.0559313819,
0.0028178182,
-0.0329804681,
0.0179888904,
-0.0544460043,
0.0139476731,
0.0178621896,
0.0751493126,
0.0220063906,
-0.0336118676,
0.030208027,
-0.0344686359,
0.0828064978,
-0.0280733388,
-0.0267132893,
0.0081368992,
0.0713577345,
-0.0152552873,
0.0037975882,
0.0178851318,
-0.027691517,
0.0324334875,
0.0344729088,
0.0017924489,
-0.0278677475,
0.0101411063,
-0.0304564442,
-0.0506976433,
-0.013345859,
-0.032493446,
0.0297698658,
-0.0121781444,
-0.0351223461,
0.0228381585,
-0.0122300815,
0.0282333046,
0.0598526858,
0.0096115563,
-0.0412938669,
0.015747359,
0.0218020529,
-0.006529083,
0.0128403967,
-0.0385151505,
-0.0107407896,
0.0086080916,
-0.0300203785,
-0.0390982404,
0.022232255,
0.0439697802,
0.0249029249,
-0.0127918953,
0.0397022329,
2.52873332e-34,
0.0594014488,
-0.0285787024,
-0.0183387883,
-0.0527414158,
0.0000093034,
-0.0258970298,
-0.0212693196,
-0.0088346638,
0.0103207575,
0.0039673205,
0.0150268134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08609v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08609v3 | Media of Langue: The dictionary that visualizes Inter-Lingual Semantic Network/Space | 2023-08-25T03:54:20 | 2024-01-27T09:08:08 | Goki Muramoto, Atsuki Sato, Takayoshi Koyama | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | This paper introduces "Media of Langue," a novel dictionary visualizing
Inter-lingual semantic network/space. Our proposed Inter-lingual semantic
network/space is formed solely from the accumulation of translation practices
between two or more language systems, in contrast to existing semantic
networks/spaces that explicitly use "intra"-lingual relations. By visualizing
this network/space for humans, an Inter-lingual dictionary can be realized that
points to the semantic place of many words at once with a chain of mutual
translation, which also contains the functions of existing dictionaries such as
bilingual and synonym dictionaries. We implemented and published this interface
as a web application, focusing on seven language pairs. In this paper, we first
describe Inter-lingual semantic network/space with its basic features and the
way to develop it from bilingual corpora, then details the design of "Media of
Langue," with a quick analysis and illustrative examples of use cases. Our
website is www.media-of-langue.org. A demonstration video is available at
https://youtu.be/98lXuX4yjsU. | [
0.0036253349,
-0.0227499232,
-0.0526549667,
0.0591446273,
-0.0326952897,
-0.0098320106,
-0.012790082,
0.0240679011,
0.004990479,
0.0096577695,
-0.064241387,
0.0084931152,
0.0390967429,
-0.0356225222,
0.0186335631,
-0.0853161216,
0.0169356614,
0.0360538773,
-0.0513701588,
-0.0072429548,
-0.0007384571,
0.0351249203,
-0.0132449334,
0.0048826076,
-0.0212966055,
-0.0018713777,
0.0028631643,
0.0120234787,
0.0339810476,
-0.0590204671,
-0.0678386763,
0.0181254484,
0.020047849,
0.0635994822,
0.0000022083,
-0.0409630239,
0.0103976298,
-0.0174635444,
0.0167057347,
-0.0350545272,
0.0384719856,
-0.0172244925,
0.0271755941,
-0.0303724483,
-0.0516462512,
-0.0348259434,
0.0574799739,
-0.0097446106,
0.0169117786,
-0.0219434351,
-0.0278628692,
-0.0842484906,
-0.0351971835,
0.006213387,
0.0217783339,
-0.02466527,
-0.0620756783,
0.0421110019,
0.0255727097,
0.0043761092,
-0.0338562392,
0.0529353507,
-0.0154363532,
-0.0212566163,
0.011071166,
-0.0019544368,
-0.0001689255,
-0.0909824893,
0.0096020913,
0.0592557937,
-0.0145622855,
-0.0349581949,
-0.0224788692,
0.0312587991,
-0.0141384667,
0.0441643745,
-0.0431062132,
0.0049823369,
-0.0097835148,
0.0055823633,
0.0083859153,
0.0206617229,
0.0361571722,
-0.0272520874,
-0.0350894332,
-0.001999889,
0.050117854,
0.0156043172,
0.0051388722,
0.006433893,
0.0565900505,
-0.0402595215,
0.05340055,
0.0162644554,
-0.0227924027,
0.040635962,
0.014506055,
-0.0407152437,
0.0296350755,
-0.0727054551,
-0.0047773016,
-0.0033204963,
-0.0246220399,
0.0410708748,
-0.0246534161,
0.003011445,
-0.0194185767,
-0.0067026513,
-0.0370722637,
-0.047532402,
-0.0370949581,
0.0174746066,
-0.0151841464,
-0.0305867568,
-0.0794270113,
-0.0171847008,
-0.0333969779,
0.0294757225,
-0.0253037363,
0.0194093306,
-0.0041868347,
-0.0051271948,
0.0281528719,
-0.0004056341,
-0.051845327,
0.0348625034,
-0.052387055,
-0.0185505655,
-0.0392549969,
-0.0130581418,
0.0507007502,
0.0147546381,
-0.0015348439,
-0.0229284931,
-0.0484180823,
0.0664652586,
0.0149989724,
0.0041904161,
0.0148214083,
-0.0288191177,
0.0137348128,
0.0011724249,
-0.003567883,
-0.082768172,
0.049192965,
0.0365722887,
0.0415259935,
-0.0386053212,
0.0122418851,
-0.0055009415,
-0.0161319356,
0.085651502,
-0.0631038174,
-0.0163333323,
0.041345492,
0.0071587334,
0.0362053588,
0.0286550913,
0.0242426284,
-0.0033936286,
0.0642649159,
-0.0150088966,
-0.0710456595,
-0.0046743886,
-0.0215180013,
0.0050241831,
-0.0621670112,
-0.0244313609,
0.0147777507,
0.0394926257,
-0.0347836167,
0.0275435895,
-0.0261501558,
-0.0132517582,
0.004658483,
0.075525865,
0.0575627461,
0.0311656184,
0.0087113082,
0.0207540728,
0.00194744,
0.0016799133,
0.0463656075,
0.0502129458,
0.0219613202,
-0.0160316397,
-0.005307788,
0.0525942519,
-0.014881351,
-0.0029724594,
0.0086453455,
0.0098325331,
0.0739146024,
-0.0187860951,
0.0364518426,
0.0106275063,
0.0208523478,
0.0527613834,
0.0386597514,
-0.0507248193,
0.039258603,
0.0127119105,
-0.0263055786,
0.1103421673,
0.0014659646,
0.0078308135,
0.0304080024,
0.010287134,
-0.0058478918,
0.042566184,
0.0331475772,
-0.0205783732,
-0.0355554558,
-0.0472881235,
-0.0220337063,
0.0111361248,
-0.0273696277,
0.0303481445,
-0.0101448502,
0.0924364701,
0.0104428269,
-0.0481571294,
-0.0196009744,
-0.0087191425,
0.0028194981,
0.0785672888,
-0.0321490169,
0.0383650735,
-0.0500415824,
0.0737559497,
-0.0140054263,
-0.0141131142,
0.0333764814,
-0.0360613801,
0.0239435341,
0.0448899232,
0.0142670982,
0.0401103422,
0.0444778651,
-0.1025272235,
0.0288916845,
-0.0359592512,
0.028805403,
-0.0359723382,
0.0153557714,
-0.0336478688,
0.072864078,
-0.0001524458,
0.0022458686,
-0.0183831956,
0.0195389409,
-0.0232233535,
0.0396415964,
0.0243535377,
0.0162387881,
-0.0278076585,
0.0195497312,
0.035784997,
0.0290364157,
0.0039739092,
0.0585486293,
0.0109174186,
0.0103361653,
0.0437574349,
-0.0011642918,
-0.0383381359,
-0.0190629847,
-0.0744807646,
-0.0296491832,
-0.0144702811,
0.0116240112,
0.0359774716,
0.0171635076,
0.0107852342,
-0.0391094834,
-0.0030376681,
0.0954704583,
-0.0127471518,
-0.0246654134,
0.0191639699,
-0.0051437728,
-0.0084470911,
-0.0091720494,
0.0080628879,
0.0343947709,
0.0298511796,
0.0181653444,
-0.089223519,
-0.0242604855,
-0.0264801104,
-0.058518514,
-0.0264886711,
0.0323748849,
-0.0215378124,
0.0369934551,
0.016477583,
0.0287318584,
-0.016059434,
0.0027196256,
0.0470592566,
0.0767526403,
-0.0571869761,
-0.0198287219,
0.0008767765,
0.0066528339,
0.0268014427,
-0.0355291031,
-0.0267033484,
-0.0016199695,
-0.0272586551,
0.0148937255,
0.0273903683,
-0.0205896944,
-0.0231778249,
-0.0281403009,
0.0122956503,
-0.0470575839,
0.0219624154,
-0.0224805959,
0.0779523924,
0.000480659,
0.0136369709,
0.022988325,
-0.0093249148,
0.0426034927,
-0.0533953905,
-0.0209806729,
-0.0085297143,
0.0913602784,
-0.0369404554,
0.0377387404,
-0.061955791,
-0.0113925431,
-0.0099131903,
0.0170686878,
0.0415247306,
-0.034787178,
0.0344476327,
-0.0635071099,
-0.032789208,
-0.0301770233,
0.0068031619,
-0.0191857778,
0.0641599298,
-0.0448769592,
-0.0405605473,
0.0418226123,
-0.0309483707,
0.0125402398,
0.0206847433,
0.0385703035,
0.0398222059,
0.0566712394,
0.0009632309,
0.0153303053,
0.0397632197,
-0.0144830011,
0.0057149748,
0.0029384252,
0.0198582057,
0.0143787693,
-0.0012949632,
-0.0489580706,
-0.0335832536,
0.0011226182,
0.0016228933,
0.0507507585,
0.0134813003,
-0.0779711232,
-0.0371735208,
-0.0014820823,
0.0095350333,
0.0249005985,
0.0756731033,
0.0625225455,
-0.0954474285,
0.0044839149,
-0.0297028534,
-0.0350550376,
0.045961041,
0.0155935539,
-0.1290137023,
0.0176138319,
-0.00411367,
-0.0713282004,
0.0516473465,
-0.0093253832,
-0.0146486061,
-0.0355529375,
-0.0053831767,
0.0170745309,
-0.0428764671,
-0.016792411,
-0.0077321222,
-0.0055960896,
0.0212119091,
-0.029381305,
-0.0342374668,
0.0245561562,
-0.027568493,
-0.026497459,
0.0419974811,
-0.0144458162,
-0.0226045549,
-0.0438524969,
-0.0213733744,
-0.0068470165,
0.1086912528,
-0.0215103328,
-0.0807818994,
0.0129802935,
-0.011057293,
0.024037892,
-0.0171451047,
0.0001011959,
0.0408924706,
-0.0356630981,
-0.0515947603,
-0.0372330435,
0.01580479,
-0.0210393928,
0.0095149912,
0.0527687706,
-0.0186857376,
0.0533642136,
-0.0029665148,
0.0011137438,
-0.005114628,
-0.0273390524,
0.0111425724,
-0.0221006032,
0.0180699807,
-0.0179288145,
0.0080488371,
0.0004693209,
-0.0533710122,
0.0234118402,
-0.0597946085,
-0.084165588,
-0.0533540212,
0.0008667732,
-0.0049046595,
0.0316732302,
0.0437970199,
0.0220812187,
0.0047458592,
0.0077972738,
-0.0351136476,
-0.0380078256,
0.0165918972,
0.0287484266,
0.0183266271,
-0.0299551077,
-0.000862051,
-0.0078074834,
0.015374383,
0.0313402936,
-0.0004950232,
-0.017309906,
0.0158690661,
0.0085285176,
0.0191042889,
-0.0054412973,
-0.0076110405,
-0.0403390862,
0.0294070169,
0.0129602253,
-0.056478288,
-0.0336516388,
-0.05823211,
-0.007641471,
0.0204770695,
0.0145470742,
-0.0095930044,
-0.025357917,
-0.066557385,
0.006150791,
-0.0440849699,
-0.0687011182,
0.0164049529,
-0.0352934338,
0.0234601907,
-0.0284293983,
-0.0167792961,
-0.0336117335,
0.0040633976,
-0.0450121872,
-0.0217650887,
0.0338369906,
-0.0067605791,
0.0529441014,
-0.0712932721,
0.0245006084,
0.0335506387,
0.0110015264,
-0.0327681303,
0.0478998199,
0.0408183485,
0.0398114026,
0.0140367532,
-0.0049742279,
0.0729027465,
0.0041561751,
-0.0135147581,
-0.026789356,
0.0264441762,
-0.0384640321,
0.0283559859,
0.0017422001,
-0.0540955067,
0.0068246601,
0.0372322537,
0.0259334259,
-0.0139809651,
0.0470953658,
0.0295607373,
0.0992380083,
0.0120304404,
0.0815812647,
-0.0109941019,
-0.0186111275,
0.020623073,
0.0304471701,
-0.0178153608,
-0.0368485525,
-0.0178752579,
-0.010782796,
0.0168813113,
-0.0129593285,
0.0376796611,
-0.0722577497,
-0.0437954701,
0.0151837002,
-0.0299921166,
-0.0120060723,
0.0168595519,
0.0032015056,
0.0331839584,
-0.0333739556,
-0.0029172192,
-0.0644046441,
-0.0729097649,
-0.002964163,
0.0025863519,
0.0036102817,
0.0246557035,
0.0391642414,
0.057418108,
0.0307096839,
0.0198599398,
-0.0221920479,
0.0602036379,
-0.0534339994,
-0.0236478634,
-0.0293920375,
-6.101139676e-33,
-0.0083379475,
-0.0776101723,
0.0075119175,
0.018967161,
-0.0217873454,
-0.0456036441,
-0.0245946813,
0.0260559227,
-0.0448201299,
0.046791736,
0.0148203149,
0.013869158,
0.022967102,
-0.0130614219,
0.0120487316,
0.0294925552,
0.012725627,
0.0310292002,
0.010598029,
-0.0048481375,
0.0676575527,
0.0167529918,
0.075712271,
-0.0932499617,
0.0170242842,
0.0091784447,
0.0254149027,
0.017109191,
0.0520313755,
0.0167861115,
-0.0169339627,
0.0501104519,
0.0040914472,
0.0112118376,
-0.0053684777,
0.0159669276,
-0.0608759299,
-0.0779453591,
0.0283230841,
0.0652925819,
-0.0167071875,
-0.0377615094,
0.0143622113,
-0.0327628478,
0.0009949149,
0.0302896351,
0.0194271579,
-0.0084961168,
-0.0450816154,
0.0359532647,
-0.0315885991,
0.0205141436,
-0.0015277055,
-0.0071891556,
0.0312759615,
-0.0096558155,
-0.0060255006,
-0.0728101209,
-0.0966477394,
0.04992247,
-0.0695177317,
-0.0046359459,
0.0771038756,
0.0143794455,
0.0052208588,
0.0397969596,
0.0354453363,
-0.0136017157,
0.0690992549,
0.0364972651,
0.0211315509,
0.0091387741,
0.0176786873,
0.0381189585,
-0.0298553761,
-0.0568782389,
-0.0518735237,
-0.0058528897,
-0.0165720228,
0.0229052342,
-0.0331374966,
0.029696865,
0.0457828827,
-0.0057505677,
-0.0319402814,
-0.0242444966,
-0.0156831518,
-0.042913124,
-0.0187780317,
-0.0601711944,
0.0313612409,
0.0032840979,
-0.0092203915,
-0.0066000717,
-0.0193148125,
0.0418535434,
0.0070622396,
0.0082750646,
0.0026099978,
-0.0047246427,
0.0225768499,
-0.0375804417,
-0.0602015927,
0.0460023955,
0.0067199436,
-0.0065696319,
-0.0039931885,
-0.0147894686,
-0.016303651,
0.0034316995,
-0.0141291842,
-0.0630464032,
-0.0144407228,
-0.0529937707,
0.0341254994,
0.0023528566,
-0.0298595652,
0.0204216857,
0.0433281697,
-0.0014174656,
0.0247300901,
-0.0570355132,
-0.0254866444,
0.0300946161,
-0.0197115671,
0.0183624979,
-0.0961501747,
0.0353659652,
0.07096342,
-0.0422783419,
-0.0372545533,
-0.0017644715,
2.958e-7,
0.058645431,
0.026744822,
0.0078705037,
0.0421918221,
0.0254828241,
-0.046657756,
0.0096768178,
0.050240539,
-0.043008212,
-0.0188539475,
-0.0252780374,
0.0048048995,
0.0247374084,
0.0752762109,
-0.0668714941,
0.0293547306,
0.0016325188,
-0.0420422442,
-0.0432066582,
0.0207109936,
0.080180414,
0.0191580858,
0.0112562785,
0.0180721506,
-0.0452485234,
-0.0093229404,
0.0471798219,
-0.029794462,
0.0254675988,
-0.0486746393,
-0.0274004396,
-0.0029568705,
-0.0230597332,
0.0052619739,
-0.0315801688,
-0.006090505,
0.0116202896,
-0.0329015143,
-0.0310133286,
0.0341841541,
0.0020378171,
-0.076875098,
0.0000040243,
-0.0618766285,
0.0195026882,
0.0101841288,
0.019366568,
0.0477480665,
0.0319127813,
0.0477520041,
0.048705887,
-0.0321599916,
-0.0606862903,
0.0241324939,
0.0019350301,
0.0007245362,
-0.0206775423,
-0.0110837203,
-0.0234917942,
0.0483381115,
0.0335867666,
0.0083166817,
-0.0392681919,
-0.0271891002,
-0.0223525595,
0.0573304482,
0.012999583,
1.738215435e-34,
-0.0085025579,
0.0028737877,
0.0102802021,
-0.0210014191,
0.0542318039,
-0.0436998978,
-0.02794897,
0.0440637656,
0.0164374541,
-0.0011225693,
-0.0234677456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13149v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13149v1 | SciEval: A Multi-Level Large Language Model Evaluation Benchmark for Scientific Research | 2023-08-25T03:05:33 | 2023-08-25T03:05:33 | Liangtai Sun, Yang Han, Zihan Zhao, Da Ma, Zhennan Shen, Baocai Chen, Lu Chen, Kai Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, there has been growing interest in using Large Language Models
(LLMs) for scientific research. Numerous benchmarks have been proposed to
evaluate the ability of LLMs for scientific research. However, current
benchmarks are mostly based on pre-collected objective questions. This design
suffers from data leakage problem and lacks the evaluation of subjective Q/A
ability. In this paper, we propose SciEval, a comprehensive and
multi-disciplinary evaluation benchmark to address these issues. Based on
Bloom's taxonomy, SciEval covers four dimensions to systematically evaluate
scientific research ability. In particular, we design a "dynamic" subset based
on scientific principles to prevent evaluation from potential data leakage.
Both objective and subjective questions are included in SciEval. These
characteristics make SciEval a more effective benchmark for scientific research
ability evaluation of LLMs. Comprehensive experiments on most advanced LLMs
show that, although GPT-4 achieves SOTA performance compared to other LLMs,
there is still substantial room for improvement, especially for dynamic
questions. The data and codes are now publicly available. | [
-0.0018629594,
0.0504945777,
-0.0017489102,
0.0387904085,
-0.0669003576,
0.0060074991,
0.0359831601,
-0.0065189777,
0.0124558145,
-0.0289204828,
-0.0629223958,
-0.0362008661,
0.0150569649,
0.0512893759,
0.0237738099,
-0.0044288286,
0.0447033532,
-0.045001246,
0.039003022,
-0.0228052679,
-0.0111327618,
-0.0363952257,
0.0055648405,
-0.0026589411,
0.0433664694,
-0.0324343629,
0.0262847822,
-0.0481858402,
0.0083212964,
-0.0540177934,
-0.0015256826,
0.0642131418,
-0.0165606346,
0.0638810396,
0.0000019089,
-0.0760190636,
-0.0325294062,
0.0722336397,
0.0150230825,
0.0718201026,
0.0725933462,
0.0211920384,
-0.003170748,
0.0159588382,
-0.0115990434,
0.0047693606,
0.0317569673,
-0.0236533545,
0.0322900116,
0.0197775904,
0.011280207,
-0.0490613505,
0.0366277993,
-0.0190812033,
-0.0046044225,
-0.0296754371,
0.0388011262,
0.0376783125,
0.0269671064,
0.0609558709,
-0.0098396214,
0.0552478172,
0.0086181527,
-0.0288356096,
-0.0015735197,
0.0179805309,
-0.0744371265,
0.0129614091,
0.0330219865,
0.0546997227,
0.0432161875,
-0.0000330439,
-0.0041886754,
0.0047909208,
-0.0224860087,
0.0263176225,
-0.0647545829,
0.0004450441,
0.0155857196,
-0.0227803793,
0.0092606042,
0.0347275101,
0.0337677076,
0.0220458377,
0.0047186916,
0.1310724169,
0.046975553,
-0.0511853583,
-0.0007260052,
-0.0237877183,
0.0252418332,
-0.0269134864,
-0.0182351265,
-0.0026743859,
-0.0248411037,
0.0178787243,
0.0298517756,
0.0042403573,
0.0598616265,
-0.0473094843,
0.0247239955,
0.0008879302,
0.0264335349,
0.0524781458,
0.011331073,
0.080404073,
-0.0276388563,
-0.0102893682,
-0.00218629,
-0.0220417064,
-0.03942753,
-0.0280979201,
0.0218507238,
0.0247850604,
-0.0042068539,
0.0202705357,
-0.0477336794,
-0.015839193,
-0.0097228894,
-0.0255647618,
-0.0195919517,
-0.0328599215,
-0.0209878683,
0.0151881892,
-0.0203615371,
0.0217319485,
-0.007821708,
0.0180488527,
-0.0038602811,
-0.0416205227,
-0.0024377124,
0.0163708013,
-0.0106733683,
-0.0224202815,
0.0233594365,
0.0373196378,
0.0415474698,
-0.0284071881,
0.0041233161,
-0.0335173309,
-0.0122577343,
-0.0914649665,
0.0215781592,
-0.0666361973,
0.028757032,
0.0207259879,
-0.0057280976,
-0.0114461547,
-0.0179032311,
0.0001934365,
0.0010282241,
0.0269576162,
-0.0394911505,
-0.0025267277,
0.0205876268,
0.0241511241,
0.0185090844,
0.0498914048,
0.0113401227,
-0.0083091166,
0.040361993,
-0.0358183458,
0.002100735,
0.0107446779,
0.0065182997,
0.0408496447,
-0.02731172,
0.0767981187,
-0.0076550767,
0.0434236862,
-0.01181754,
0.0903223008,
-0.0314156115,
-0.0015332525,
0.0468793921,
0.0777800605,
-0.0082913954,
0.0380665511,
-0.0006935999,
-0.0046979617,
0.03698989,
-0.0164759438,
-0.0032855051,
0.035704881,
-0.0147070931,
0.0026980615,
0.0538630746,
0.0231943242,
-0.014006353,
-0.0288951863,
-0.0353774093,
0.019983435,
-0.0111055672,
-0.0136297885,
0.0447265953,
-0.0516325161,
-0.0070318012,
0.0208277721,
-0.0102359513,
-0.0603811815,
0.0048295078,
-0.0316821672,
0.0413264669,
-0.0047456473,
0.0525192209,
-0.0382202193,
-0.0463827066,
-0.0148240076,
0.0077824518,
0.0559948385,
0.0519079641,
-0.0045155943,
-0.0200239923,
-0.0021002197,
-0.0182713009,
-0.0351260379,
0.0092846323,
-0.0049333181,
-0.0058380733,
0.0154836392,
-0.0110146776,
-0.0583458319,
-0.0416870825,
0.0207889825,
-0.0585962199,
-0.0082091475,
-0.015779091,
-0.0651528835,
0.0645659417,
-0.0101764612,
-0.0422299728,
0.0484738871,
0.0382604748,
-0.015411634,
-0.0228616036,
-0.0071346476,
0.0141700236,
0.0011108405,
0.0239638332,
-0.0585415624,
0.0006147074,
0.0399474874,
-0.000997972,
-0.0259302221,
0.045363225,
-0.0228151437,
0.0055444613,
-0.0266240221,
0.0176288895,
-0.0828707442,
0.0065429704,
-0.0234594587,
0.0509656481,
-0.0193533786,
0.0948954672,
0.0083148954,
-0.0014507921,
0.0494973548,
-0.0268497262,
-0.0662723109,
0.0297233369,
0.0023992811,
0.0109027652,
0.042208232,
-0.0199811272,
-0.061971806,
-0.0400068611,
-0.0502296351,
0.0028728468,
-0.0051096408,
0.0260005239,
0.0159842987,
-0.0377750099,
-0.0076919962,
0.0434875004,
-0.0187173318,
-0.0254439469,
-0.0059143421,
0.0085604144,
0.0363325104,
-0.0123797646,
0.0029421116,
-0.0601108931,
-0.0286442507,
-0.0325939506,
0.0613479838,
0.0200558845,
0.0464920662,
-0.0365333222,
0.0261728447,
-0.0423434377,
0.0010703182,
-0.0160269886,
-0.0362349488,
0.0347577669,
-0.0056013176,
0.0165969413,
0.044298172,
0.007876399,
-0.0294300932,
0.0529701971,
-0.0219513923,
-0.029754132,
-0.0073686866,
-0.0024895924,
-0.0036157756,
-0.0174608044,
-0.0254428741,
0.0342200734,
0.0174636319,
-0.0216475818,
-0.0233752299,
-0.0157430507,
0.0423758142,
-0.0646429956,
-0.0077375537,
-0.0220000707,
0.0157948043,
-0.0298267193,
0.0510367565,
0.0066548153,
-0.0666021779,
0.0361263864,
-0.0575476028,
-0.0106366072,
-0.0911990926,
0.0296049882,
-0.0600269921,
0.0431225412,
-0.0356279574,
-0.007017632,
0.001372406,
0.0221000649,
-0.0265087653,
0.0039766994,
-0.0168387126,
-0.0474225171,
0.0191844292,
-0.0363638774,
0.0237293392,
0.0047664596,
-0.0115983859,
0.0022385567,
-0.0043162918,
0.000509194,
0.0549697801,
0.0538367517,
-0.0474874526,
-0.0228358023,
0.0119527169,
0.0553097352,
0.0258120652,
-0.0357115641,
-0.0119451452,
-0.0103003467,
0.0085120862,
0.0597134009,
-0.0014079596,
0.0561748035,
0.0010522332,
0.0419604033,
0.039550934,
0.0235768892,
0.0244331323,
-0.0229406934,
-0.0248799846,
0.0228995793,
-0.0305750649,
-0.0111028496,
0.0190191921,
0.0583513305,
-0.0518995561,
-0.0293037947,
0.1083029434,
0.0323824137,
-0.0329811946,
-0.0143591436,
-0.0420419201,
0.021153124,
0.0396249406,
0.0276232082,
-0.0423763059,
0.0199977048,
-0.0311778802,
0.0160489194,
-0.010862669,
-0.0500462912,
-0.0171726979,
-0.12864393,
0.0394937955,
-0.0125553468,
-0.05274323,
-0.0010657985,
-0.0775340199,
0.0200047232,
-0.0123201804,
-0.0055121672,
0.0339008942,
0.0095398938,
-0.0213689357,
0.0086670388,
-0.0357010141,
-0.094309099,
0.0808442533,
-0.0408455878,
0.0641889498,
0.0155364657,
0.0634191856,
-0.052392602,
-0.035240069,
0.0197771918,
-0.0333370194,
-0.0314681791,
-0.0032897161,
-0.001568374,
0.0386630893,
0.0018728658,
-0.0265015177,
0.0106498143,
-0.0344359353,
0.0372648649,
0.0158175305,
0.1113350019,
-0.0059925634,
-0.0073706973,
-0.0516391583,
-0.0090474915,
-0.0268875062,
0.0922508836,
0.0022854903,
-0.0309852585,
-0.0272875894,
-0.0147573436,
-0.0074743573,
0.0061401734,
-0.0547662415,
-0.010500011,
-0.0101671061,
0.0153131457,
-0.0485230424,
-0.0067148879,
0.0035711525,
-0.0019996648,
-0.0102830464,
0.052492477,
0.0137384553,
-0.0141286254,
-0.0207137857,
0.0173102319,
-0.0028879282,
0.0267864652,
-0.0526121594,
0.0167559534,
0.0878462121,
0.0208507665,
-0.0290464424,
0.0211813655,
-0.030533744,
-0.0727070794,
-0.0295574646,
0.0416447856,
0.024161078,
-0.0447899699,
-0.0325426646,
-0.0775588155,
0.013563415,
0.002053149,
-0.0078053297,
0.0252346639,
-0.0070545208,
-0.0118071614,
-0.0061976262,
-0.0021380582,
-0.0205058828,
-0.0030205718,
-0.0140998717,
0.0140779186,
-0.0237995703,
-0.0347970687,
0.0110975392,
0.0626755133,
0.0451899245,
-0.0234935358,
-0.0443533473,
0.0244548228,
-0.0154333841,
-0.0549323484,
-0.0208276883,
-0.0307690799,
0.0110608591,
0.0176710952,
0.0152973095,
-0.0130700422,
0.0001036504,
-0.0319872759,
0.0252021514,
-0.0266454201,
0.0533417054,
0.0053514559,
0.0026577536,
0.008671849,
-0.0003454937,
-0.01650149,
-0.046691265,
-0.0660279319,
0.0498927869,
-0.0160058886,
0.0543530658,
0.0075639337,
0.0142216329,
0.0338997617,
0.0428658687,
-0.0762257278,
-0.0266361795,
-0.007218502,
0.0278482698,
-0.0126177454,
0.0761415511,
0.0468994118,
-0.031336464,
-0.0140281748,
-0.0721284673,
0.0140827931,
-0.017763216,
-0.0140082128,
0.0733805299,
0.0380731933,
-0.0322008841,
-0.0068634572,
0.0668554902,
0.0444264859,
-0.0177425612,
-0.0129014039,
0.0040469579,
-0.0205661524,
-0.0274049733,
-0.0370094478,
-0.0048211827,
-0.015831491,
-0.004092704,
-0.1006826311,
-0.058602035,
0.025436718,
0.0224005692,
0.0223661214,
-0.0268176012,
0.0114523806,
0.0631352961,
-0.0267859697,
0.0027507402,
-0.0345643125,
-0.003032346,
-0.0385919884,
-0.046210438,
0.0028996696,
-6.582618489e-33,
0.0089351796,
-0.0259643085,
0.0238671247,
-0.0267715976,
-0.0277350452,
0.0604534633,
-0.0352299102,
0.0139372302,
-0.0468643382,
0.001319402,
-0.0113164792,
0.0133559695,
-0.0129266512,
-0.0172438379,
0.016868595,
-0.0044717407,
0.0080383448,
-0.0157427713,
-0.0417763814,
0.0173816029,
0.0283220261,
-0.016731197,
0.037376713,
-0.0669543818,
0.0315519273,
-0.0214775372,
-0.0141789112,
0.0110439723,
-0.0186192356,
0.0620419681,
-0.0388744622,
0.0096018603,
0.0028266318,
-0.0679577291,
0.0179633237,
-0.028667517,
-0.0038259514,
-0.0252947249,
0.0300137643,
-0.0346541703,
-0.0128221987,
-0.0166846272,
0.0219676439,
0.0181559622,
-0.0499323569,
-0.0432903729,
0.0190736074,
-0.0093556456,
-0.0246125907,
-0.0361401327,
-0.0308726858,
0.0344474986,
-0.0111684138,
0.037448097,
-0.0132601596,
0.01536291,
-0.0196445361,
0.0722264349,
-0.0039935815,
0.0329668559,
0.0229699053,
0.0071604219,
0.0579450466,
-0.0249557383,
0.0321097076,
0.0704547167,
0.0218853205,
0.0320892259,
0.0418916568,
-0.0406519994,
0.0546845458,
0.040022321,
0.0925301537,
0.0868621841,
0.0214487854,
0.0428844206,
-0.0814715102,
0.0105169388,
0.0276005361,
0.0249645468,
0.025973957,
0.0153919309,
-0.0045952732,
-0.016387675,
-0.0542091243,
0.0252151098,
-0.0160758495,
-0.0107522141,
0.0178947113,
-0.0621233247,
-0.0393817313,
0.0195207186,
0.0648835674,
-0.0493545122,
-0.02288986,
0.0563048422,
-0.0099824648,
0.0724021271,
0.011999392,
0.0652002171,
-0.0761327073,
0.0079152863,
-0.0060318811,
0.0134190926,
0.044445917,
-0.005293,
-0.01612252,
0.0277939476,
-0.0421740338,
-0.020298874,
-0.0137423519,
-0.0234175138,
0.0155509599,
0.0249158815,
-0.0096445139,
0.0101855854,
0.018729819,
0.0355500765,
0.0510291494,
0.0571940094,
-0.0219781511,
0.0280582551,
0.0046528857,
0.007583675,
0.0019350912,
-0.0121826343,
-0.0166335274,
0.02577346,
0.0168311931,
-0.0394858681,
-0.0037805678,
0.0057170186,
2.794e-7,
0.0782571584,
0.0714773685,
-0.0253469646,
0.0199695174,
0.0446394309,
0.0193596072,
-0.053395275,
0.0106544979,
0.0280492567,
0.0212632883,
-0.026503114,
-0.0420405604,
0.0479432233,
0.0504280552,
-0.0648409054,
-0.0243313033,
-0.0649466291,
-0.0434779972,
-0.0424792022,
-0.0296537951,
0.0002037254,
0.0451284386,
0.00941425,
0.0066855578,
-0.0273904093,
-0.0482278951,
0.0564707853,
-0.0144959306,
-0.0019080149,
0.0689513534,
-0.0012519386,
0.0196799468,
0.0247210097,
0.0212410893,
0.0025284039,
0.0210774634,
0.0121235428,
0.0345142931,
0.0221079309,
-0.038552694,
0.0647620708,
-0.0249079373,
-0.0170917213,
-0.0845589116,
0.0531155653,
-0.0178512149,
-0.0594390668,
-0.0328461938,
-0.0223531034,
-0.0130486097,
0.0791312978,
-0.0477465838,
-0.0040812045,
0.0188480411,
-0.0252953023,
-0.0165065322,
-0.030093573,
-0.0129936896,
-0.0151380971,
0.0014896772,
-0.0694617033,
-0.1025162861,
-0.0256153364,
-0.0214425437,
0.002500844,
-0.0743170604,
0.0447990112,
2.790550809e-34,
0.0583675615,
-0.0218447577,
0.0102582313,
0.0168978591,
0.032184504,
0.0110814217,
-0.0115485592,
0.010765898,
0.0032303859,
-0.0883279741,
0.0099361641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13139v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13139v2 | MatchXML: An Efficient Text-label Matching Framework for Extreme Multi-label Text Classification | 2023-08-25T02:32:36 | 2024-03-11T14:50:03 | Hui Ye, Rajshekhar Sunderraman, Shihao Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The eXtreme Multi-label text Classification(XMC) refers to training a
classifier that assigns a text sample with relevant labels from an extremely
large-scale label set (e.g., millions of labels). We propose MatchXML, an
efficient text-label matching framework for XMC. We observe that the label
embeddings generated from the sparse Term Frequency-Inverse Document
Frequency(TF-IDF) features have several limitations. We thus propose label2vec
to effectively train the semantic dense label embeddings by the Skip-gram
model. The dense label embeddings are then used to build a Hierarchical Label
Tree by clustering. In fine-tuning the pre-trained encoder Transformer, we
formulate the multi-label text classification as a text-label matching problem
in a bipartite graph. We then extract the dense text representations from the
fine-tuned Transformer. Besides the fine-tuned dense text embeddings, we also
extract the static dense sentence embeddings from a pre-trained Sentence
Transformer. Finally, a linear ranker is trained by utilizing the sparse TF-IDF
features, the fine-tuned dense text representations and static dense sentence
features. Experimental results demonstrate that MatchXML achieves
state-of-the-art accuracy on five out of six datasets. As for the speed,
MatchXML outperforms the competing methods on all the six datasets. Our source
code is publicly available at https://github.com/huiyegit/MatchXML. | [
0.0305636972,
-0.0036635217,
0.0109329494,
0.0303156599,
0.0077278088,
0.0109127648,
-0.0506290831,
0.0226536356,
0.0409621671,
-0.0686891079,
-0.0189967994,
0.0154935755,
-0.0357545204,
0.0253567193,
-0.0086832074,
-0.0032538199,
0.0052648904,
0.0211350676,
0.0284702834,
-0.0022150343,
0.0297370292,
0.0491516441,
0.0356114767,
0.0105319163,
-0.0515105985,
-0.0147904186,
0.0136053748,
0.0392511673,
0.0521019921,
-0.0257793553,
0.0506905057,
-0.0098942397,
0.0487208851,
-0.0042988081,
0.0000019559,
-0.0313228182,
-0.034196049,
-0.0189938247,
0.0134561984,
0.0137603329,
0.0263100918,
-0.0170920752,
0.031591434,
0.0091154082,
0.0026692837,
-0.0161005892,
0.006766215,
0.0675406381,
0.0762532279,
0.0325026624,
-0.0541152172,
-0.0649813265,
0.0549746715,
0.0165327396,
0.0007045449,
-0.0546464846,
0.0381259657,
-0.0173437297,
0.0176816694,
0.0649794862,
-0.0029478259,
0.0008055606,
0.0147477482,
0.0249201059,
0.0631334633,
0.0407615937,
0.0033768083,
0.002572512,
0.0206802152,
0.0892346874,
0.00478554,
-0.0551878847,
0.003355037,
0.0122986343,
-0.0234806109,
-0.0365751684,
-0.0124661084,
-0.0049526212,
0.0081253434,
0.0472260453,
0.0073147919,
0.0070850081,
0.0079146642,
0.0082189171,
0.0041409717,
0.0118953139,
0.0234883334,
-0.0624683201,
0.0147304172,
0.0285084676,
-0.0669780374,
0.0027740635,
0.0425560959,
0.0169691462,
-0.0244129263,
-0.03475051,
-0.0755184889,
-0.0711756945,
0.0399321839,
-0.0645396039,
-0.0156768169,
-0.0122608533,
-0.0141951526,
0.0343250372,
-0.0467558131,
-0.0097862538,
0.0121810222,
0.0209298171,
-0.0658575296,
-0.0513498671,
-0.065761596,
-0.0103982231,
-0.0614597574,
0.0293457899,
-0.0152534191,
-0.0179743189,
-0.0384112708,
-0.0111657428,
-0.0019490981,
0.0388105139,
-0.0265805945,
0.0224545039,
-0.0060584745,
-0.0003060246,
0.0413216725,
0.0103375362,
-0.046639964,
0.0357346758,
-0.0494184867,
0.0275806319,
0.0118682673,
0.0507910885,
0.034081053,
-0.0361661911,
0.0312200952,
0.014554237,
-0.0420389809,
-0.0595722012,
-0.0035333922,
-0.0009989245,
-0.0109450025,
-0.0118241711,
-0.0319463462,
-0.0383800864,
0.0224457961,
0.0176737309,
0.0232512634,
0.0100164935,
0.005791578,
0.0051844195,
-0.0493737161,
0.0509187356,
0.0127111021,
-0.0047197985,
0.0926814973,
0.0102182142,
0.0417337008,
0.0173160788,
0.0073819803,
0.0301788542,
0.0443237685,
0.0087651918,
-0.0048840567,
0.0396892019,
-0.0258198306,
0.0090363408,
-0.0134191038,
0.0097002424,
0.0372979864,
0.0347046778,
0.0234994292,
0.0383849069,
-0.0164174251,
-0.0364620313,
0.0526256524,
0.0025811801,
-0.0303446539,
-0.0178828463,
-0.0012234375,
0.0401361473,
-0.0490450375,
-0.0355865322,
0.0335773043,
0.0109743029,
-0.0153822638,
-0.0208003335,
0.0622288138,
0.0053120623,
-0.0392466187,
0.0013531042,
-0.0154602723,
-0.0150937708,
-0.0019574959,
-0.0170974229,
0.0565158315,
-0.018063765,
-0.0163557958,
0.0614878312,
0.0412180685,
0.0064040828,
-0.0354055949,
-0.0191276297,
-0.0380013734,
0.0137933493,
0.0317840166,
-0.0046551051,
0.0440291986,
-0.0044652163,
0.0282715634,
0.0060323784,
0.0299720876,
-0.0135063175,
-0.0211070441,
-0.0509343892,
-0.044075001,
0.0088399025,
0.0031210051,
0.00725014,
-0.0104449531,
0.0602934696,
0.028460687,
-0.0453704111,
-0.0271296389,
0.0457106344,
0.0043351767,
0.0063780267,
0.0414510928,
0.0109333722,
-0.0034074986,
0.0057545919,
-0.0198221896,
-0.0152373901,
0.0590770021,
-0.0374104679,
-0.0101931291,
-0.0872741416,
-0.0302917119,
-0.0321802422,
0.0383250415,
-0.0537989698,
-0.00932399,
0.0500770211,
-0.0616985448,
-0.0387761071,
-0.0447572581,
-0.0052664201,
-0.0050342982,
-0.0349429511,
-0.0070531936,
-0.0320121832,
0.0334628411,
-0.0198768433,
0.0603224188,
0.0338911861,
0.0528300256,
-0.0562126637,
-0.032642521,
0.0197336599,
-0.0032258155,
-0.0537485443,
0.0000204267,
-0.0186071657,
0.0375484005,
-0.0091253612,
0.0186093524,
-0.0309012812,
-0.0288440827,
-0.0942992046,
0.0109250657,
-0.0107492162,
-0.0396414883,
-0.0024094332,
-0.0275527947,
0.0311943926,
-0.0096991714,
-0.0592490286,
0.0277940594,
-0.0112119988,
0.0120945657,
0.0276230387,
-0.0219994932,
-0.0391423106,
0.0202245545,
-0.0191571712,
-0.0113173742,
0.0507221669,
-0.0174590275,
-0.0273611993,
-0.0123021305,
0.003270112,
-0.0247078054,
-0.0218875576,
0.0007899458,
0.0075724991,
-0.0104864193,
0.0021752201,
-0.0018617389,
0.0142926527,
0.0504020266,
-0.0004789045,
0.0242519639,
0.0452651642,
-0.0080206031,
0.0037721798,
-0.0125480136,
0.0091364635,
-0.0644353479,
-0.0016753147,
-0.0227920134,
0.0481762365,
-0.0162706133,
-0.0037636627,
-0.0206956882,
-0.0534868799,
-0.0065741949,
0.0034840605,
-0.0697064027,
-0.0081023257,
0.0051067988,
-0.0102867559,
-0.0144385034,
-0.006105904,
0.06547454,
-0.0182615947,
-0.0239805002,
-0.0263362974,
-0.0780384317,
-0.0206111968,
0.031523291,
0.0287058931,
0.0416754112,
0.0185705572,
0.0170461331,
-0.030074425,
0.0021640148,
0.0143697541,
-0.0125782993,
0.0010527804,
0.045224566,
0.0244447291,
-0.0510946326,
-0.0637884215,
-0.018030908,
-0.0663888827,
0.0011444009,
0.0257000122,
-0.0168275628,
0.0014884339,
-0.1023673266,
-0.009341062,
-0.0152457505,
0.0306166075,
-0.0042929598,
-0.0327531062,
-0.008912106,
0.0973634273,
0.0898649022,
-0.0135454126,
-0.0381611027,
-0.0220946055,
-0.0233635679,
0.0769095868,
-0.0016065453,
-0.0074722986,
-0.0020356127,
-0.0051394445,
0.049561616,
-0.0058532194,
0.0115028219,
-0.0051512378,
0.0295049231,
0.0211401284,
0.0045678206,
0.0811202526,
0.0572451502,
-0.0513834357,
-0.0026053716,
-0.0084506283,
0.0850923136,
0.0230656713,
-0.0088273669,
-0.0500904508,
-0.0269754585,
0.0127075985,
0.0033414713,
0.0022187,
-0.0228175316,
0.020244699,
-0.0686876774,
-0.0044380818,
-0.0063212137,
-0.0044629327,
0.0043532471,
-0.0300861336,
-0.0238151234,
0.0127504403,
-0.0200489108,
-0.0342823304,
0.0222948045,
-0.0352097899,
-0.0001863598,
-0.0176310614,
0.0054769781,
0.0968182161,
-0.0147439027,
0.0048629311,
-0.0000073146,
0.0819983408,
-0.0150161646,
-0.0284792855,
0.0296924002,
-0.0229766518,
-0.0313957147,
0.0013829463,
0.0384880602,
-0.0475954972,
0.0060044322,
-0.0000102361,
0.0103252893,
-0.0485800952,
-0.0184949618,
0.031436611,
0.0896847099,
0.0035306637,
-0.0131758843,
-0.0398594625,
-0.0264115278,
-0.0122830141,
0.0364520065,
-0.0175470412,
-0.074410148,
-0.0224452727,
-0.0161036327,
0.0399721675,
-0.0166252926,
-0.0232991595,
0.0331727825,
-0.0238916632,
-0.0236203559,
-0.0398980193,
-0.0240904111,
0.0282964688,
0.0361890569,
-0.0361653827,
-0.0107069109,
-0.0719565079,
-0.028662594,
-0.028952498,
0.0097765615,
-0.035964001,
0.0342478715,
-0.023683276,
-0.0024665555,
0.0590378381,
-0.0252136979,
-0.0418719538,
0.003711649,
0.0032002011,
-0.0533339344,
-0.043131467,
-0.0343211778,
-0.0004930295,
0.0418244079,
-0.0115298489,
-0.0477110147,
0.0484446287,
0.0625197962,
-0.0566853285,
0.0077539254,
0.0013615335,
-0.0577313602,
-0.0199054275,
0.0465282351,
-0.0487329476,
0.0620811544,
0.012007962,
0.0346406661,
-0.0238801502,
-0.1014992744,
0.0148562603,
0.014127438,
0.0726857185,
-0.0163881388,
0.0032159088,
-0.0279478803,
0.0120461304,
0.01828596,
-0.0302474592,
-0.0099047255,
0.0111447312,
0.0429126285,
-0.0020935105,
-0.0272681508,
0.0284608454,
0.0439008996,
0.0358631909,
0.0044545499,
0.0222634748,
-0.0162239876,
0.0086935209,
0.0152512575,
0.0090903351,
-0.031629283,
-0.0480973683,
0.034466099,
0.0276450459,
-0.0301771984,
0.0268018488,
0.0354009978,
0.0307693537,
-0.0329204164,
-0.0045777825,
-0.0433969051,
0.0508637242,
-0.0743845403,
-0.0518434122,
0.0818570256,
0.0063147303,
0.0154097117,
-0.0181584395,
-0.0301715918,
-0.0346169844,
0.0352077521,
-0.0194495935,
-0.0623569451,
0.0053755268,
0.0062790215,
-0.034600962,
0.0461419001,
0.0438300557,
0.0735025033,
-0.004146934,
0.0080102393,
-0.0291689429,
-0.0359067433,
0.0258956254,
0.031079432,
0.0049209148,
0.0308266077,
-0.0006036196,
0.0321613997,
-0.0316936336,
0.0672139451,
-0.0658648461,
-0.0540111363,
0.009535728,
0.038373176,
0.0253191628,
0.0422215946,
0.0137289688,
-0.0238927957,
-0.0159345455,
0.04303848,
-0.0321047865,
-0.0030561956,
-6.265661866e-33,
0.0181065407,
-0.0152077992,
-0.0444548354,
-0.0046205427,
-0.0190556962,
-0.0093133021,
0.0077052764,
-0.0191372279,
-0.0117995506,
0.025761405,
-0.0088131791,
-0.0024111136,
0.0071908454,
0.0526970476,
0.015921507,
0.0235928539,
0.0363994353,
-0.002303127,
0.0167294648,
0.0151712522,
0.029966455,
0.0534591153,
0.0444556922,
-0.1160639524,
-0.0087540513,
-0.0479110554,
0.0229918528,
-0.0157659091,
0.0577596948,
0.0279853866,
-0.0245450977,
0.0710397437,
0.0436586849,
-0.0239937995,
0.0284875818,
0.0288713351,
-0.0891281068,
-0.0109506268,
-0.0635225996,
-0.0077345897,
0.0193077456,
-0.0108163841,
0.0069089835,
0.0189992618,
0.0147118662,
-0.0202508401,
0.0863078907,
-0.0381027088,
-0.040042337,
-0.0595330372,
-0.0355445594,
0.0289326459,
-0.002472969,
0.0529557504,
0.019254243,
0.0394942611,
0.0202006716,
0.0733617917,
-0.0750698596,
-0.0021650591,
-0.0528053567,
0.0168003757,
-0.0159900039,
0.0147526506,
-0.018722048,
0.0431278571,
-0.005260563,
-0.0220212638,
0.0085733552,
0.0488438308,
-0.0063618212,
0.019161867,
-0.0004699682,
0.0683942959,
0.0582975298,
-0.0595799312,
-0.0793939084,
0.0563260987,
-0.0521231368,
-0.0106306588,
0.0309665203,
0.0304848794,
-0.0333129168,
-0.0189643111,
-0.0208793692,
0.0296472162,
-0.0538640022,
-0.0109811826,
0.031716913,
0.0370742418,
0.0215003174,
0.0370804854,
0.0094524203,
-0.0311521813,
-0.0610593036,
0.0241628513,
-0.0292154197,
0.0469031408,
-0.0014207335,
0.0123465816,
-0.0177988112,
-0.0686841607,
0.0437542759,
-0.0358135104,
0.0020155951,
-0.0382002555,
0.0692521185,
-0.0144811692,
-0.0589484647,
0.0190178137,
0.0268682055,
-0.058924593,
-0.0267088879,
0.0344683193,
-0.0050796289,
0.0165469777,
0.0014073617,
0.0813017935,
0.0115977721,
0.0029507519,
-0.0116735091,
-0.0699583218,
0.0276041869,
0.0071633095,
-0.0069002826,
0.0012138782,
-0.0342465155,
-0.0056302841,
0.0464785695,
-0.0657516122,
0.017893685,
-0.0070254821,
2.737e-7,
0.0302335713,
0.0160654839,
-0.0196503233,
-0.0672879741,
0.0087053105,
0.0721446574,
-0.0219432656,
0.0762371942,
-0.0265488923,
-0.0390134752,
0.0285627265,
0.0164534338,
0.0611692928,
0.0343944542,
-0.0692003742,
0.0120826401,
-0.0881349072,
-0.0134353023,
-0.0692446828,
0.022642497,
0.1040645912,
0.1077096686,
0.0170338079,
-0.0271544587,
-0.0057448964,
-0.0340260454,
0.0610529147,
0.000333277,
0.0154538667,
-0.0003059921,
-0.020550916,
-0.0049969577,
-0.0150694232,
0.017765142,
-0.0413662009,
0.0433336608,
0.0517098941,
0.075376451,
-0.0455003455,
-0.0217071883,
0.0207276344,
0.0244871378,
-0.0306737274,
-0.0088606412,
0.0768373907,
-0.0449360684,
-0.0372575,
0.0251376778,
-0.0492167324,
0.0147166448,
0.0079549393,
0.0037968976,
0.0045036399,
0.0100301877,
0.0275438819,
0.0095042707,
-0.0241491627,
-0.1099413037,
0.0290537141,
0.0559173226,
-0.0426411927,
-0.0029197729,
-0.0249241553,
0.0631894693,
0.0608120151,
0.0110719828,
0.031793531,
2.39709035e-34,
0.0115650566,
-0.0143395811,
-0.0242016371,
-0.0095158452,
-0.014561194,
-0.0271271393,
-0.0310576055,
0.015150548,
-0.0095300535,
-0.0563643537,
0.0178946052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13137v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13137v3 | OmniQuant: Omnidirectionally Calibrated Quantization for Large Language Models | 2023-08-25T02:28:35 | 2024-03-18T05:33:22 | Wenqi Shao, Mengzhao Chen, Zhaoyang Zhang, Peng Xu, Lirui Zhao, Zhiqian Li, Kaipeng Zhang, Peng Gao, Yu Qiao, Ping Luo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing
tasks. However, their practical deployment is hindered by their immense memory
and computation requirements. Although recent post-training quantization (PTQ)
methods are effective in reducing memory footprint and improving the
computational efficiency of LLM, they hand-craft quantization parameters,
leading to low performance, especially in extremely low-bit quantization. To
tackle this issue, we introduce an Omnidirectionally calibrated Quantization
(\textbf{OmniQuant}) technique for LLMs, which achieves good performance in
diverse quantization settings while maintaining the computational efficiency of
PTQ by efficiently optimizing various quantization parameters. OmniQuant
comprises two innovative components including Learnable Weight Clipping (LWC)
and Learnable Equivalent Transformation (LET). LWC modulates the extreme values
of weights by optimizing the clipping threshold. Meanwhile, LET tackles
activation outliers by shifting the challenge of quantization from activations
to weights. Operating within a differentiable framework using block-wise error
minimization, OmniQuant can optimize the quantization process efficiently for
both weight-only and weight-activation quantization. For instance, the LLaMA-2
model family size 7-70B can be processed with OmniQuant on a single A100-40G
GPU within 1-16 hours using 128 samples. Extensive experiments validate
OmniQuant's superior performance across diverse quantization configurations
such as W4A4 (4-bit weight, 4-bit activation), W6A6, W4A16, W3A16, and W2A16.
Additionally, OmniQuant demonstrates effectiveness in instruction-tuned models
and delivers notable improvements in inference speed and memory reduction on
real devices. Codes are available at
\url{https://github.com/OpenGVLab/OmniQuant}. | [
0.0028083874,
0.1021322981,
0.0197932664,
0.0543736182,
-0.0113911042,
0.0074222153,
0.0095396237,
0.0157853682,
-0.0225769095,
-0.0378661491,
-0.0262103453,
-0.0484538525,
-0.0199293215,
0.0253779329,
0.0140998522,
0.0022791114,
0.0475058444,
-0.0388718806,
0.0022539287,
-0.0140356729,
-0.0090749655,
-0.0113610728,
0.0179259405,
0.012879543,
0.0180578157,
-0.0088673206,
0.0044435398,
0.0147893364,
-0.009454052,
-0.0223134533,
0.0146827316,
0.0469493195,
0.0148439892,
0.043016497,
0.0000022652,
-0.0211424027,
-0.0193955824,
-0.0067559341,
-0.0242163669,
0.0198346134,
0.0169648342,
-0.0251425058,
-0.0427765772,
0.0031108025,
-0.0099826008,
-0.0049251425,
0.0728953853,
0.0167220794,
0.0522145852,
0.0587463453,
-0.0102712205,
-0.0409123041,
0.0575020649,
-0.0303627402,
0.0010171165,
-0.0387760587,
0.0138534224,
0.0172488876,
-0.0522531122,
-0.0172561556,
-0.0442346595,
0.0329934582,
-0.0037411849,
0.006643401,
-0.0083212368,
0.0181402396,
-0.0492937677,
-0.0217641219,
-0.0221088193,
0.0687275976,
-0.106164217,
-0.0399777628,
-0.0164959487,
0.0143548585,
-0.0435922667,
-0.090264149,
-0.0327043645,
0.0429205522,
0.058415629,
0.055690065,
-0.0238833223,
-0.038872458,
0.0503785796,
0.0153640918,
-0.0483582169,
0.0600826107,
0.0168277938,
-0.0034748863,
0.0017618986,
-0.0035793672,
-0.1036959365,
-0.0340224281,
0.0181083623,
0.0003073847,
0.0035352793,
-0.0118514914,
-0.0593387634,
-0.0371067375,
-0.0216324646,
-0.0087032514,
0.0229619518,
0.069818534,
-0.0159482099,
0.0294426605,
-0.0370772183,
0.0620478243,
-0.0113924397,
0.0190082528,
-0.0460429303,
0.0001202001,
-0.023885455,
0.0152682876,
-0.0386694893,
0.0178197846,
-0.0548082329,
-0.034631893,
-0.0627497435,
-0.0125033474,
-0.0360269584,
-0.0319642313,
0.0193295199,
0.0265076701,
-0.0236456115,
-0.0043654237,
0.0389052145,
0.0367500558,
0.0055135894,
0.0021546055,
0.0071566929,
-0.0603549033,
-0.0207185298,
0.0523191169,
0.0151500078,
-0.0285516605,
0.0381622128,
0.0178618021,
-0.0090914704,
-0.0490537249,
0.0077253822,
0.0208220556,
-0.012451753,
-0.0553918183,
-0.0262170024,
-0.068026036,
-0.0003364242,
-0.0153355664,
0.0099440543,
-0.0454356,
0.0450594164,
0.0147306118,
-0.0103575168,
0.0808751807,
-0.0216063149,
-0.0181282517,
0.0150339724,
0.0114358701,
0.036457967,
0.0738360211,
0.0360077843,
0.0426382795,
0.0081269676,
0.0281215534,
0.0072176298,
0.0524625294,
0.0376430489,
-0.0104699433,
-0.074088484,
-0.0290182959,
-0.0193975661,
0.0494638272,
0.1239563376,
0.0916096196,
-0.0671852455,
-0.013810141,
0.0361268483,
0.0251297895,
0.0272206869,
0.012776196,
-0.0181270521,
-0.0129618431,
-0.0093564847,
-0.0343311429,
-0.0340877324,
0.0259940159,
0.0011377868,
-0.0105424263,
0.0411736742,
0.044196032,
-0.022189362,
-0.0096835103,
-0.0119979344,
-0.0257396027,
-0.0082988236,
-0.011185525,
0.024474673,
0.009224264,
-0.0157853141,
0.1068796515,
0.0319338925,
-0.0570303388,
-0.0310246479,
-0.0903487653,
-0.0219977554,
0.0174890179,
0.0393328108,
0.0024026576,
0.0073715639,
0.0112940436,
-0.0268542916,
0.0298576448,
-0.0316171832,
0.0103763184,
0.0180338938,
-0.0900431424,
-0.010915407,
0.0103292409,
0.0030184505,
-0.0104128299,
0.0408532545,
0.0149773639,
-0.0087965466,
-0.0190134067,
-0.0250491351,
0.0309506413,
0.0226624794,
-0.0747771189,
0.0472881757,
-0.0160252973,
0.0205412079,
0.0076443404,
-0.00463627,
-0.0000947202,
0.0339770652,
-0.0612982623,
0.0226069093,
-0.0416663177,
0.0005859449,
-0.0380769745,
0.0781741068,
0.013053868,
0.0439097248,
0.04687085,
-0.0316877179,
-0.0619751438,
0.0307500139,
-0.0155143831,
0.0169564858,
-0.0588616841,
0.0261255503,
-0.0090563735,
0.0552601181,
-0.0374068655,
0.0246197749,
-0.0382503234,
0.010677658,
0.0128537575,
-0.0099526923,
-0.0112363761,
-0.0233326517,
-0.0388939865,
-0.0017887916,
0.0062565543,
0.0491998382,
-0.0282500964,
-0.0176827814,
-0.0089842761,
-0.0291463062,
-0.0977485776,
0.0290217269,
-0.0484308228,
0.0391733088,
0.0386898667,
0.0429724157,
0.0077515421,
-0.0111086108,
-0.023666719,
-0.0084135616,
-0.0161932204,
0.0150648309,
-0.0017240501,
-0.0043495391,
0.005475041,
-0.0418252535,
-0.0424615443,
0.0215456244,
0.0406634584,
-0.0600255169,
-0.0614996925,
-0.0504770949,
-0.0284857228,
-0.0168000069,
0.0604123771,
0.0013238974,
-0.028508788,
-0.0116828447,
0.0005369536,
0.0170940273,
0.0661597922,
-0.0044264435,
-0.010965989,
0.0865606442,
0.0150524573,
-0.0265744422,
0.0289595183,
0.0091731381,
-0.048503615,
0.0060638296,
-0.0138124032,
-0.0252404492,
0.0791003779,
-0.0266785845,
-0.0109487195,
-0.0076477006,
0.0286013931,
-0.0066021588,
-0.0274122953,
-0.0313704386,
-0.0063297427,
-0.0427062884,
0.0364328586,
-0.0061012278,
-0.0592762791,
-0.0015324638,
-0.026213631,
-0.0001814841,
-0.0278732162,
0.0014080557,
-0.0170622803,
0.0388441496,
0.0339388028,
0.048030708,
-0.0370389037,
-0.0132369902,
-0.0266539548,
-0.0253935177,
-0.0055044261,
-0.0326255001,
0.0022239832,
-0.0208243728,
0.0583829768,
-0.0412294082,
-0.0165016931,
0.0129420059,
0.0200580433,
-0.016677754,
0.0205492899,
0.0072500217,
-0.0396995731,
0.0040010414,
0.0659803078,
-0.0232473183,
0.0576407053,
-0.0320011713,
0.0126089193,
-0.0232741609,
0.0494786091,
0.0457832031,
0.0145719945,
0.0405199677,
-0.004014065,
-0.0309065655,
0.038369,
0.0178035125,
0.0224750508,
-0.0387141779,
0.0166568812,
0.0430973433,
-0.0073068882,
-0.0052065356,
-0.0168026257,
0.060237702,
-0.0292043034,
0.0023142511,
0.0679798946,
0.037274383,
-0.0770490319,
-0.0003612361,
0.0087802196,
0.0189133268,
0.0051809647,
0.0071021905,
-0.1164834052,
-0.0466179512,
0.0161184873,
0.0204125494,
0.0077720676,
-0.0047643362,
-0.0105832629,
-0.0700207278,
0.0325769223,
0.0157978553,
0.0226952955,
-0.0333386511,
0.0167054795,
-0.0091186613,
-0.0577557571,
0.0547032058,
0.0438165739,
-0.0062257815,
0.0127224866,
0.013967311,
0.0024954334,
-0.015123737,
0.0330088586,
-0.0241743866,
0.0463190004,
0.0526943244,
0.0228286292,
0.0080774585,
-0.0064413222,
0.0399821624,
-0.0164131466,
-0.000491122,
-0.0050239256,
0.0257113762,
0.029319169,
-0.0180012453,
-0.00250282,
0.0180692505,
-0.0188159812,
-0.0292001441,
-0.0319227315,
0.0446840152,
0.0037840579,
-0.0108948797,
-0.00785862,
-0.0332670771,
0.0039756838,
0.040192984,
0.0139066549,
-0.0148044666,
-0.0724185482,
-0.0159338601,
-0.0017527799,
-0.0477368906,
-0.0182352159,
-0.0285028554,
0.0100225154,
-0.088195093,
-0.0603583865,
0.0172232296,
0.0045142258,
0.0326905213,
-0.0288972743,
-0.0157177057,
-0.0122066187,
0.0032861542,
-0.0767078772,
0.0213594455,
-0.0442856289,
0.0077905911,
-0.0365190431,
0.0134315677,
0.0282591581,
0.0090329926,
-0.0099636521,
0.0239785742,
-0.1235623285,
-0.0689519644,
0.0064050555,
0.0001194948,
0.0220882893,
0.040973749,
0.0030241786,
-0.0625298694,
0.0452670008,
0.0825029835,
-0.023278892,
0.0493452065,
0.0155916773,
-0.0132670226,
-0.0144178979,
0.0503519252,
-0.0022710445,
0.0406559706,
-0.0069733621,
0.0621245354,
-0.0537365712,
-0.0385878794,
-0.0017583299,
0.0040658992,
0.0678650513,
0.0040656421,
0.0090533318,
-0.017921757,
0.023541417,
0.0271505956,
0.0255984794,
-0.0544682369,
0.0115566477,
0.0636041909,
-0.0070651355,
-0.0222963095,
0.004521403,
0.0269932598,
-0.0468932539,
0.0103698038,
0.0230802875,
-0.0479336753,
0.0222583897,
0.0236994941,
-0.0153666278,
-0.0146879964,
0.019968031,
0.006407164,
0.0362827294,
-0.0285822824,
-0.0093467757,
-0.0119389752,
0.0196314659,
-0.065483205,
0.0446931869,
-0.0138901984,
-0.0151557857,
-0.0543437377,
0.0017598006,
0.0831233561,
0.0283977985,
0.069662787,
0.0276658405,
-0.0408134647,
-0.0032453774,
0.0031082958,
0.0137258135,
0.0033254893,
0.0481862798,
0.0032848038,
-0.0106902653,
0.0134188952,
0.0482425541,
-0.0075535593,
0.0307092238,
0.0171488151,
0.0054091769,
-0.0093837921,
-0.0341336392,
-0.0574923642,
0.0001979395,
-0.0211969092,
-0.0046717306,
0.031925384,
-0.0309448298,
0.0117903398,
0.015478312,
-0.0247814916,
-0.0317444019,
0.0115478719,
0.0182798859,
0.0017307157,
-0.0425241292,
-0.0339242443,
-0.0315165594,
0.0172115099,
-0.0186748616,
-0.0006245231,
-6.754222297e-33,
-0.0120620113,
0.0265133902,
0.0284376536,
-0.0193517823,
-0.0283754915,
0.0000250596,
-0.0033549254,
0.0079382462,
-0.0235184077,
-0.0266063716,
-0.0250141807,
0.0193922408,
0.03053605,
0.0112005901,
-0.0172925405,
0.0282029957,
0.0638490766,
-0.0270703156,
-0.0102844806,
0.0309166946,
0.0041780835,
0.0389703698,
0.0627560839,
0.0138085103,
-0.0225322135,
0.0251392312,
-0.0309554301,
0.0004162253,
0.0260717403,
0.0149771245,
-0.0596880727,
0.0354282185,
0.0012394824,
0.031363681,
-0.0190405697,
-0.0343964286,
-0.0646581948,
-0.0041849213,
0.0249649882,
0.0267429817,
-0.0097520072,
-0.0359044522,
0.0693694502,
0.0161326099,
-0.0348258093,
-0.0262937341,
-0.0305334348,
-0.0286934227,
-0.0297895744,
-0.0472261347,
-0.0256979633,
0.0518110283,
0.0160464477,
0.015172096,
0.084297359,
-0.0179881155,
-0.0317775086,
-0.0150615098,
-0.0915272087,
-0.0174200572,
0.0496493839,
0.0918085352,
0.0539078377,
0.051421985,
0.0251067001,
0.0327185094,
0.0621604733,
-0.0515124276,
-0.0000919915,
0.0526577719,
0.0507823378,
0.0234489609,
0.0416410267,
0.0161175933,
0.1193091869,
-0.0215909872,
-0.0752653852,
-0.0248293597,
0.0068362113,
0.012268696,
0.0318197608,
0.0764613375,
0.0001307127,
-0.0310520809,
-0.0193558633,
-0.0312263612,
-0.0567619652,
-0.0261952933,
0.0096127735,
0.0263943933,
-0.0444025323,
0.001727119,
0.0109062437,
-0.0333560295,
-0.0073646959,
-0.0202690177,
-0.0001130103,
0.0249294117,
0.0101181874,
0.0328638814,
-0.025615653,
-0.0066712177,
-0.0022509745,
0.0014121658,
0.0114110829,
0.0000596323,
0.0273938775,
0.0529710464,
-0.0798496902,
-0.0289266463,
-0.0416531339,
0.0272498932,
0.0017653484,
0.1022058502,
0.0056432439,
0.0181643106,
0.0191578381,
0.0329732969,
-0.009769178,
0.0207714718,
-0.0277428199,
0.0143133858,
0.0259482805,
0.0368905626,
-0.0661725178,
0.0086758742,
-0.0307736639,
0.0470504351,
0.0280290227,
-0.0791616291,
-0.0368727706,
0.0572522134,
2.964e-7,
0.0605029911,
0.0326641127,
0.0104630766,
-0.016944468,
-0.0072567458,
-0.0187148675,
0.0012246456,
0.0070707197,
0.0130040552,
-0.0046726912,
-0.0100954194,
0.0271964185,
0.0001755047,
0.0165673103,
-0.0518616177,
0.034189824,
-0.0188347399,
0.0085671442,
-0.0211108699,
-0.0414062589,
0.00770385,
0.1259683967,
-0.0357451588,
-0.0334366783,
0.0394724943,
-0.0127894543,
0.0355548821,
-0.0000362632,
0.0117625361,
0.0418395847,
0.0456353202,
0.0267440919,
-0.0099036833,
-0.0341380201,
0.0150342854,
0.0131340446,
-0.0222926028,
0.0851126239,
-0.0461697765,
-0.0229854714,
0.0038837423,
0.0011471317,
-0.0108908266,
-0.0390476659,
0.0633909032,
-0.0162959844,
-0.0118718995,
-0.1193478927,
-0.0167786684,
-0.0032529696,
0.0238931552,
-0.0261977911,
0.0253013875,
0.0297427457,
0.0386331826,
-0.0006733271,
-0.0354909785,
-0.0777030513,
-0.0462210365,
-0.0025948761,
-0.0120956879,
-0.031772688,
-0.0688229129,
0.0019139453,
0.0087389452,
-0.0616850965,
0.014639182,
2.767307704e-34,
0.0347546749,
-0.0057803383,
0.0220901873,
0.007086928,
-0.0015868532,
-0.0231984053,
-0.0040630237,
0.0178758688,
-0.0484474413,
-0.0783413053,
-0.0289535653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13566v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13566v2 | MLLM-DataEngine: An Iterative Refinement Approach for MLLM | 2023-08-25T01:41:04 | 2023-09-11T08:28:40 | Zhiyuan Zhao, Linke Ouyang, Bin Wang, Siyuan Huang, Pan Zhang, Xiaoyi Dong, Jiaqi Wang, Conghui He | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Despite the great advance of Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) in both
instruction dataset building and benchmarking, the independence of training and
evaluation makes current MLLMs hard to further improve their capability under
the guidance of evaluation results with a relatively low human cost. In this
paper, we propose MLLM-DataEngine, a novel closed-loop system that bridges data
generation, model training, and evaluation. Within each loop iteration, the
MLLM-DataEngine first analyze the weakness of the model based on the evaluation
results, then generate a proper incremental dataset for the next training
iteration and enhance the model capability iteratively. Compared with previous
data collection methods which are separate from the benchmarking, the data
generated by MLLM-DataEngine shows better targeting, quality, and correctness.
For targeting, we propose an Adaptive Bad-case Sampling module, which adjusts
the ratio of different types of data within each incremental dataset based on
the benchmarking results. For quality, we resort to GPT-4 to generate
high-quality data with each given data type. For correctness, prompt design is
critical for the data generation results. Rather than previous hand-crafted
prompt, we propose an Interactive Prompt Optimization strategy, which optimizes
the prompt with the multi-round interaction between human and GPT, and improve
the correctness of generated data greatly. Through extensive experiments, we
find our MLLM-DataEngine could boost the MLLM capability in a targeted and
automatic manner, with only a few human participation. We hope it could be a
general solution for the following MLLMs building. The MLLM-DataEngine has been
open-sourced and is now available at
https://github.com/opendatalab/MLLM-DataEngine. | [
-0.0043714354,
0.0617133789,
-0.0256194919,
0.0443999842,
-0.0354485288,
0.0075730751,
0.0133208595,
-0.0152268466,
0.0048180432,
-0.0597438663,
-0.0454362594,
-0.0347370505,
-0.0037749049,
-0.0067593665,
0.0457445085,
-0.0588061623,
0.052305337,
-0.0571836904,
-0.044462949,
0.0095216371,
-0.0050835325,
0.0257401504,
-0.0042410721,
0.0396513566,
-0.0103469677,
-0.029958846,
-0.0325579271,
0.0245802719,
-0.0029327795,
-0.0509697348,
-0.0113225738,
0.0669561252,
0.0341972597,
0.0038908147,
0.0000025636,
-0.0596711338,
0.0030352527,
-0.0193336047,
-0.023972353,
0.0245845169,
0.0629572421,
0.0008428552,
-0.0302115139,
0.0262587741,
0.0086269854,
-0.0290900264,
0.0260131415,
-0.0090132859,
0.0867839307,
0.0525295734,
0.015959641,
-0.0104266191,
0.0273192599,
0.0281111915,
-0.0173159596,
-0.0154949045,
0.0131423334,
0.0446899086,
0.0278731044,
-0.014334498,
-0.0189153291,
0.0153604643,
0.0371226445,
-0.0115543818,
-0.0439712778,
0.0299514607,
0.0073481244,
-0.0265142992,
-0.0371398553,
0.0795951933,
-0.0419069417,
-0.0140837487,
-0.0356923901,
-0.0235571433,
0.0195445716,
-0.0287766755,
-0.0315577462,
0.0648768321,
-0.0288698152,
0.0084102293,
0.0212559719,
-0.0145453978,
0.0126596931,
-0.0104098078,
-0.0234222729,
0.0266256854,
0.0254884642,
-0.0423075855,
0.0140948985,
-0.0281018503,
-0.0247975681,
-0.0216571949,
-0.0121882902,
0.0383787043,
-0.0663649887,
0.0406863615,
-0.0609904341,
-0.0523021445,
0.0151183242,
-0.0272310954,
0.0766871572,
0.0332896784,
-0.0169330239,
0.0140435733,
-0.0101073664,
0.034206558,
0.0168096218,
-0.0185176972,
-0.0415742248,
0.0184442122,
-0.0271668322,
0.0137724159,
-0.0664530843,
0.018064823,
-0.0332838185,
0.0094702179,
-0.0409272462,
0.057004109,
-0.0147883641,
0.0128575675,
0.0060351943,
-0.0355645865,
-0.026089238,
0.0201397818,
-0.0066814334,
0.0213493463,
-0.0369346403,
-0.0249088816,
0.0050404123,
-0.0850551873,
0.0280892607,
0.0229170416,
-0.0199533384,
-0.0452870615,
0.0202710032,
0.0832365453,
-0.0367299579,
-0.0151575198,
-0.0936355889,
-0.0309528299,
0.0043163411,
-0.0533756837,
-0.0064166612,
-0.0943737328,
0.0157329533,
0.0017142217,
-0.0004810607,
0.0076049673,
0.0051124096,
0.0290055592,
0.0332556367,
0.0485549159,
-0.0081359437,
0.0194265861,
0.0391177461,
-0.0173713565,
-0.0011211324,
0.0935608745,
0.0322095565,
0.0055598724,
0.0342462398,
-0.0551929139,
0.0099131437,
0.0932911038,
0.0218019057,
0.0194916017,
-0.0391616933,
0.0051392396,
0.0095529035,
0.0385094397,
0.0211710837,
0.0413602144,
-0.0262385625,
0.0201003831,
0.0537655279,
-0.007053596,
-0.0040410785,
-0.0119457692,
0.0507486053,
0.0415854454,
0.0068063759,
-0.0019222065,
-0.016009789,
0.005964125,
-0.043399632,
0.0184994154,
0.0020628439,
0.0609263852,
-0.0160064306,
-0.0336403772,
-0.0024556024,
-0.0174691305,
-0.0083279926,
0.028178256,
0.0637283698,
-0.010997707,
-0.0650881231,
0.0200357139,
0.0476906709,
-0.04780953,
-0.0189363789,
-0.0811963007,
0.0295342188,
0.0666407198,
0.0552804731,
-0.0059548714,
-0.0440673456,
-0.0138941556,
0.0183782764,
0.0126049155,
0.037588641,
-0.0234172605,
-0.0145655684,
-0.0610783137,
-0.0414392017,
0.0248766951,
-0.0170529597,
0.0410585925,
0.0175134465,
-0.024238199,
0.0075653438,
-0.0059592822,
-0.0501477346,
0.0325764343,
-0.0276612677,
-0.0308230817,
-0.0070948889,
0.0053782188,
0.0520398095,
0.017389819,
-0.0242074858,
-0.0015484609,
0.0483997576,
0.0103239492,
0.0278222635,
-0.0253111478,
-0.0550824367,
-0.0145088816,
0.0439438745,
-0.0003793713,
-0.0337595604,
0.0334217139,
-0.0324075222,
-0.0493170656,
-0.0266516842,
-0.0403365307,
-0.0113771856,
-0.0357335135,
0.0440762825,
-0.0282827448,
-0.0138943037,
-0.0540380627,
0.0519513153,
0.0072783302,
0.0021795917,
0.0375424735,
0.0585180223,
0.0174073372,
-0.0524676144,
-0.0517380647,
0.0194627643,
0.0018018256,
0.0400099456,
0.0075389068,
0.0414646529,
-0.056004528,
-0.0104361176,
-0.1129916832,
0.0029710683,
-0.022436507,
-0.0059537287,
0.0309735797,
-0.0057580075,
-0.0284011997,
0.0028055224,
-0.006370178,
-0.0045467513,
0.0094969803,
0.0196651295,
0.0027716083,
-0.0007039628,
-0.0305102747,
-0.0192298796,
-0.0269149393,
-0.0249453969,
0.0184851307,
-0.0010246142,
-0.0044977977,
-0.061331246,
0.0252651349,
0.0056411424,
0.0353376232,
-0.0068550073,
-0.0407924503,
0.0254296791,
-0.0355920456,
0.0639975891,
0.0382323265,
0.0070517394,
0.027556913,
0.0347016677,
-0.0207585841,
-0.0688414648,
0.0326587409,
-0.0073652137,
-0.0420156941,
-0.0285864417,
-0.0335379653,
-0.0049780528,
0.0582045838,
0.024430003,
0.0054683038,
-0.0295982789,
-0.0082563059,
-0.0265614577,
-0.0272149462,
-0.0394499302,
0.0084156152,
-0.0354999565,
-0.0044944505,
-0.017319141,
-0.0728027895,
0.0655992702,
-0.0446883403,
-0.0094855987,
-0.0356282257,
0.0022225096,
0.0000136407,
0.0653677583,
0.0193688031,
0.0215549823,
-0.0023902382,
-0.0156906545,
-0.027918864,
0.0190642066,
-0.0070577189,
-0.0227295924,
0.0548544414,
-0.0768224448,
-0.0123900063,
-0.0192924477,
-0.0119164847,
-0.0368000157,
-0.009935841,
0.0053099068,
-0.0234526806,
0.0224527661,
-0.010912356,
-0.0000678998,
0.0082261842,
0.0258570276,
0.0290388819,
-0.036528226,
-0.002143326,
-0.0197051186,
-0.0122932401,
0.0329891108,
-0.0005167515,
-0.0337652899,
-0.0562710352,
0.0538872667,
0.0183076337,
0.0537660904,
0.0193932801,
-0.0610821135,
0.0119070942,
0.0288245436,
0.0051107593,
-0.0121239489,
0.0627521724,
0.0685927495,
-0.0777760074,
0.0213681366,
0.1099901199,
0.0218058173,
-0.0369702093,
-0.0094953561,
0.013207824,
0.0610105172,
0.0201802738,
0.0417706519,
-0.0644705445,
-0.0395375863,
-0.0106920907,
0.0470020436,
-0.0185579639,
-0.0104854954,
-0.0034864927,
-0.1609590948,
0.0577075519,
0.0031774449,
-0.0436721295,
-0.0182345342,
-0.036796242,
-0.0258519985,
0.0141698346,
0.0537763275,
0.0461395122,
-0.0097312815,
-0.0024764684,
0.0536127687,
-0.0091255428,
-0.0703999475,
0.0341341197,
-0.02711205,
0.0607039034,
0.0588037036,
0.0179619323,
-0.0029198111,
-0.0016368385,
0.0701755285,
0.0182377286,
0.0033730005,
-0.0228493121,
0.03577004,
0.0088279303,
-0.0152273281,
-0.0030097961,
0.0320067182,
-0.0060443063,
0.0162405986,
0.042705141,
0.0950196758,
-0.0061640916,
0.0238656048,
-0.0242599435,
-0.0306900311,
0.014361308,
0.0459762737,
0.0374780409,
-0.073331669,
0.0016174908,
-0.0135555565,
-0.0240146108,
-0.0544505976,
0.0108228233,
0.043527063,
-0.0631829947,
0.015760418,
-0.0290686972,
-0.0495150797,
0.0528507568,
0.0598972887,
0.0238266923,
-0.0236023236,
0.0131726395,
-0.0003148604,
-0.0375809968,
0.0340971462,
-0.0211630072,
0.0444068462,
-0.1173323691,
-0.0398406275,
0.01042403,
-0.0195329897,
0.0116377743,
0.0601260848,
-0.0689858198,
-0.0517356023,
-0.0185586754,
0.0501478352,
0.0112319728,
0.0383620448,
-0.0063651442,
-0.0533713251,
0.0162344053,
0.0344423391,
-0.019546574,
-0.0068889051,
0.0081447372,
-0.0064506647,
-0.0219672602,
-0.0081641013,
-0.0184675939,
0.030643452,
0.0283981618,
0.019647276,
-0.0039636483,
-0.0033018321,
0.0333884209,
0.0790279061,
0.014955001,
-0.0455009416,
-0.0309100412,
-0.0416826345,
0.0161777027,
-0.0289204456,
-0.0265439227,
-0.058340814,
0.0279654302,
0.0200420301,
-0.0407511368,
0.020102106,
-0.0673101544,
0.0002338594,
0.0138341878,
-0.0585202277,
0.035652943,
0.0026894619,
0.0305498596,
0.0705434829,
-0.0059323972,
-0.0126848444,
-0.0061056959,
0.0128810313,
0.0153333442,
0.0024965126,
0.0948712006,
0.004891498,
-0.0098667843,
-0.000798343,
0.0191546958,
0.0044568102,
-0.0317027792,
-0.0777431279,
0.0315388963,
0.0666827336,
0.0196667351,
0.050749775,
-0.0193357188,
0.0121946726,
-0.0467249416,
0.0392983928,
0.0027828419,
-0.0557270236,
0.0291497037,
0.0320795365,
-0.0001111151,
-0.0347460769,
0.0541188084,
0.0025590167,
0.0445063859,
-0.0171649996,
0.0056895539,
-0.0572364144,
-0.0171155874,
0.0586462878,
0.0026306587,
-0.0260843616,
-0.0076442957,
-0.0260382332,
-0.0576459765,
-0.058436729,
0.0693666637,
0.0061479798,
0.0007584267,
0.064204663,
0.0608626902,
-0.0371362567,
-0.0011817347,
-0.0502711833,
0.02366025,
0.0160656329,
-0.0220722761,
-0.0151570737,
-6.450125582e-33,
-0.0421607718,
-0.0176193565,
0.0490918867,
0.0046911607,
-0.0010908669,
-0.0162396748,
-0.0117414994,
0.0221579112,
0.015406929,
-0.0139763011,
-0.0017592231,
-0.0268479642,
0.0088913441,
0.0343086682,
0.0202478431,
0.012519856,
0.0250451807,
-0.0289637949,
-0.0338726118,
0.0363042876,
0.0208719783,
0.018104434,
0.0489883199,
-0.0356473736,
-0.002549656,
0.0043904628,
-0.0077402699,
0.0241651107,
-0.0340249129,
0.0749337971,
0.0132811526,
0.0785813481,
0.0142361922,
-0.0623369515,
-0.0455341376,
0.0188427996,
-0.0437450707,
-0.0337378792,
0.0146035217,
0.0397024155,
-0.0104058282,
-0.0084071327,
0.0167593826,
-0.0252791476,
-0.0363829099,
0.0167046767,
0.02790487,
-0.0038432598,
-0.0253128633,
-0.0055771493,
-0.0491047576,
0.0290304534,
-0.0139513658,
-0.0196323153,
0.0067783967,
0.0582627878,
-0.0117400233,
-0.0011167884,
-0.0354945287,
0.033961948,
0.0592147261,
0.0291297771,
0.1082482859,
0.0448541641,
0.0296983067,
0.0219979715,
0.0466807745,
0.0098672267,
0.0122491932,
0.0424878411,
0.0419133939,
0.0464998037,
0.0104596587,
0.0606079996,
0.0058896649,
-0.0072357911,
-0.0309499893,
0.0239375122,
0.046608422,
0.0060114628,
0.0352482609,
-0.00933454,
-0.0419719666,
-0.0250643417,
-0.0609838702,
0.0184139758,
-0.0268651154,
-0.0183824208,
0.0529921055,
-0.0241287146,
-0.0199594777,
-0.0374688357,
0.0621234626,
-0.0108920317,
-0.0451583788,
-0.0247626398,
-0.0302402508,
0.0495922305,
-0.0189889949,
0.0142083056,
-0.027977759,
-0.0638899803,
0.0265298132,
-0.0294265058,
0.0386604443,
0.0220139567,
0.0050171358,
0.0353644006,
-0.05323999,
0.0157622024,
-0.0625093356,
0.0057471893,
0.0026019826,
0.0108716832,
0.0399832055,
-0.0234244335,
-0.0148023814,
0.0585966744,
0.0180750675,
-0.0494669266,
-0.0584701747,
-0.0537380055,
-0.0190661289,
0.0013639467,
-0.0091492366,
0.0064940304,
-0.0510122217,
-0.0238631163,
0.0293866284,
-0.0472656712,
-0.0067220298,
0.0285901465,
3.067e-7,
0.0066461959,
0.0418807641,
0.0079391086,
0.0403540656,
0.010086487,
0.0305576809,
-0.0313699357,
-0.0015445021,
0.0251744539,
-0.0027361491,
0.0021215496,
0.0007125749,
0.0380486883,
0.052314546,
-0.0549874865,
-0.0208394174,
-0.0299002714,
0.0252805632,
-0.0732316598,
0.0446304679,
0.0517756455,
0.077417925,
0.0008366163,
-0.0383186862,
0.02718875,
-0.0057689971,
0.0042380146,
-0.0336595178,
-0.0485946871,
0.0301825739,
0.0183496121,
0.0154404808,
0.0080957711,
0.0346113518,
-0.0159869511,
-0.0277100988,
-0.0293528792,
0.0533387214,
-0.0083203092,
0.0016109229,
0.0695804358,
-0.0249458067,
-0.0343857147,
-0.0640069991,
0.0507502407,
-0.0026063884,
0.009743426,
-0.0165262502,
-0.0006773709,
-0.0506272316,
-0.0118157445,
-0.054104235,
0.0071101859,
0.0312360022,
0.0265302882,
-0.0292816423,
-0.0025806322,
-0.0202519502,
-0.0219778139,
-0.0197145697,
-0.0505915657,
-0.0744355097,
-0.0442903899,
-0.0205885805,
0.0160693526,
-0.0448686779,
-0.000778997,
3.169754267e-34,
0.0324473567,
-0.0278803594,
0.0373795405,
0.0074645798,
0.0371234603,
-0.0069455886,
-0.0325183421,
0.0430305004,
-0.0112918047,
-0.0589469895,
-0.0504005887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13565v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13565v1 | DARWIN Series: Domain Specific Large Language Models for Natural Science | 2023-08-25T01:40:48 | 2023-08-25T01:40:48 | Tong Xie, Yuwei Wan, Wei Huang, Zhenyu Yin, Yixuan Liu, Shaozhou Wang, Qingyuan Linghu, Chunyu Kit, Clara Grazian, Wenjie Zhang, Imran Razzak, Bram Hoex | cs.CL | cs.CL, cond-mat.mtrl-sci, physics.app-ph | Emerging tools bring forth fresh approaches to work, and the field of natural
science is no different. In natural science, traditional manual, serial, and
labour-intensive work is being augmented by automated, parallel, and iterative
processes driven by artificial intelligence-based experimental automation and
more. To add new capabilities in natural science, enabling the acceleration and
enrichment of automation of the discovery process, we present DARWIN, a series
of tailored LLMs for natural science, mainly in physics, chemistry, and
material science. This series relies on open-source LLM, incorporating
structured and unstructured scientific knowledge from public datasets and
literature. We fine-tuned the models using over 60,000 instruction data points,
emphasizing factual correctness. During the fine-tuning, we introduce the
Scientific Instruction Generation (SIG) model, automating instruction
generation from scientific texts. This eliminates the need for manual
extraction or domain-specific knowledge graphs and efficiently injects
scientific knowledge into the model. We also explore multi-task training
strategies, revealing interconnections between scientific tasks. DARWIN series
not only achieves state-of-the-art results on various scientific tasks but also
diminishes reliance on closed-source AI models. Our research showcases the
ability of LLM in the scientific domain, with the overarching goal of fostering
prosperity within the broader AI for science community. | [
0.0089853369,
0.0176579282,
0.002105206,
0.0206748713,
-0.0291320216,
0.0099521158,
0.0361660719,
0.00643986,
0.0410906263,
-0.0235749613,
-0.0326744877,
0.0324179605,
-0.0259559918,
0.0444670878,
-0.0080103818,
-0.0261117518,
0.0484986193,
-0.0480440222,
0.0264878199,
-0.0351547152,
-0.0182437636,
-0.0122773862,
-0.0261954088,
-0.0093329707,
0.0360910669,
-0.0326664746,
0.0012700108,
-0.0199628267,
0.0536276549,
-0.0416063666,
0.0164020006,
0.0489229299,
0.0411494784,
0.0410511047,
0.0000020031,
-0.0734058917,
0.0100585641,
0.0475844704,
-0.0240695588,
0.0348562561,
0.0339579694,
-0.0172264446,
0.0195430461,
-0.0100635495,
-0.0195790473,
0.0211084355,
0.0519438088,
-0.0236740578,
0.0115943123,
0.0082100546,
0.0179546438,
-0.0253569838,
0.0466463231,
0.002869854,
0.0536690205,
-0.0042219446,
0.0571362711,
0.062853314,
0.0490828492,
0.0737346783,
0.0087812906,
0.0539414324,
0.0114299199,
-0.0357037187,
0.047941871,
0.0347468965,
-0.0072931484,
-0.0175632723,
-0.012593409,
0.0706664026,
0.0352411531,
-0.0574138574,
-0.0042457343,
-0.023615893,
-0.0399506539,
0.0291689616,
-0.0755092502,
0.0541609079,
-0.0084703322,
-0.0247559883,
0.0291118026,
-0.018504981,
0.0180018395,
0.0208484307,
0.0020566829,
0.0780511945,
0.0156233534,
-0.0424372777,
-0.004190194,
0.0073058796,
-0.0014035495,
-0.0467008986,
0.005233252,
0.0253576674,
0.0034680334,
0.022881262,
-0.0125904409,
-0.0423269458,
0.0479330383,
0.005649691,
0.0478766821,
0.019015532,
0.0081078243,
0.0410702154,
-0.0099350568,
-0.0067518498,
-0.0185672492,
0.0195779242,
-0.0130582843,
-0.0009078505,
-0.0915541425,
-0.032245297,
0.0132083818,
0.0084115257,
-0.0258794781,
0.0195410419,
-0.0028538306,
0.0043151523,
-0.0039641801,
-0.0138105145,
0.0316465944,
0.0130610242,
-0.0491420515,
-0.0076470911,
-0.0396841429,
0.0286583416,
-0.013676892,
0.0272314791,
0.0049253255,
-0.0045401198,
-0.0437019765,
0.0226861779,
-0.0081068631,
0.0194983929,
0.0129072871,
0.0842933804,
0.012492232,
-0.0224309638,
-0.0141427303,
-0.0642346367,
0.0086914934,
-0.0561352372,
0.0300259218,
-0.0363215394,
0.0618296899,
0.0437161028,
-0.0155937653,
-0.0252269041,
0.0226281155,
-0.0151514094,
-0.0246925484,
0.0622607581,
-0.0396528915,
-0.0221274681,
0.0423674732,
0.0243118014,
0.007250132,
0.0166438352,
0.0112944879,
-0.0067469627,
-0.001462487,
-0.0115986839,
0.0020850622,
0.006054169,
0.012160412,
0.0029637408,
0.0020214547,
0.0080238981,
-0.0264046453,
0.0639368817,
0.0268516988,
0.0037166767,
-0.0083331978,
0.0202183258,
-0.0011509408,
0.0328152478,
-0.0078290887,
0.0426323563,
0.0496452339,
0.0115609523,
0.0506746359,
-0.0305723883,
-0.0062618502,
0.0907813087,
-0.0209677648,
0.0079983473,
0.0240759496,
0.0287864152,
-0.0043877321,
-0.056809999,
-0.0167677794,
0.0184501316,
-0.0053750509,
-0.0399100035,
0.0775239021,
-0.007056172,
-0.0351758897,
0.0028487237,
0.0626956299,
-0.0456361622,
0.0028378288,
0.0006065284,
0.0636224747,
0.0636297837,
0.048504293,
-0.0793166682,
-0.0717997923,
0.007511436,
0.043866612,
0.0696672499,
0.0204835124,
-0.0258316677,
-0.042115964,
-0.0410963073,
-0.0429632552,
-0.0626353547,
0.0043838988,
0.0037167284,
0.0050527179,
-0.0253372751,
0.0004245753,
-0.0192153938,
-0.0668185726,
0.0364149399,
-0.096813865,
-0.0562968291,
-0.0016286988,
-0.0567413718,
0.0379817337,
0.0050526215,
-0.000974129,
0.0157777611,
0.0792994276,
-0.0305405501,
-0.0278808307,
-0.0013313988,
0.0181045625,
-0.0277401041,
0.0495206863,
-0.0594787188,
-0.0231344886,
0.0122019788,
-0.0302118659,
-0.0230214242,
0.0303565674,
0.0163621623,
-0.023465151,
-0.0118132383,
-0.0063133761,
-0.0123221558,
0.0068289819,
-0.0229231063,
0.0368905962,
0.0058098296,
0.0235322639,
0.0360611826,
-0.0025570372,
0.0163113382,
-0.0238583572,
0.0181747656,
-0.0568140298,
0.0337675437,
-0.0032780736,
0.0424545482,
-0.0172816273,
-0.0245280489,
-0.0030995826,
-0.0225546099,
-0.0001665689,
0.0022282572,
0.0082851732,
0.0313515738,
-0.0242273528,
-0.0047340472,
0.0162266698,
0.0361442082,
0.036908932,
-0.0124613671,
-0.0406650156,
0.0655927956,
0.0050381529,
-0.0232363213,
-0.0606429912,
-0.0061795004,
-0.0690363646,
0.029141482,
0.0665529892,
0.0291552618,
-0.0875975862,
0.0396734774,
0.0067766826,
0.018523708,
-0.0065395343,
-0.0312669612,
0.0391803235,
-0.0308178216,
0.0135616213,
0.0496515222,
-0.0032970766,
-0.0016208015,
0.055737678,
-0.0129019981,
-0.0434982218,
0.0078065619,
-0.0413001329,
0.0056227269,
0.0181660205,
0.0062753591,
0.0120996675,
0.0269928202,
-0.0274589173,
-0.0212800521,
-0.0081549399,
0.0316818841,
-0.0104369037,
-0.0524390563,
0.0167782027,
0.0128750037,
0.0008204518,
-0.0086443732,
0.0267675798,
-0.0317250676,
0.077125527,
-0.0114694936,
0.0003887197,
-0.0742777511,
-0.016547516,
-0.0236314218,
0.0394110344,
0.0165696628,
0.0176051408,
0.0303046554,
0.0318198986,
-0.0243376698,
0.0379312485,
-0.0005922365,
0.0221303031,
-0.0092164017,
-0.0737126246,
0.0011961346,
0.0230553318,
-0.0101737939,
-0.0193580631,
0.0059400508,
-0.0209501684,
0.0442023501,
-0.0043473253,
-0.0895804539,
-0.0414709374,
-0.0226186384,
0.0916781202,
-0.0125465076,
-0.0412633084,
-0.0141912019,
-0.0583459474,
0.0012954618,
0.0518998764,
-0.0160765331,
0.0089407628,
-0.0496486686,
0.006825408,
0.0349337459,
-0.0207113493,
0.0225484911,
-0.0327748246,
-0.0336034521,
0.0109869558,
-0.0441652834,
0.03241257,
0.0088975821,
0.0259927623,
-0.0451175347,
-0.0210308488,
0.0660882816,
0.0086830668,
-0.0420753025,
-0.0042380211,
-0.0141295139,
-0.0230142027,
0.0232264418,
0.040252395,
-0.110079132,
-0.0262246486,
-0.0320738479,
0.0214850549,
0.0140288621,
-0.0493477471,
-0.003773351,
-0.074912183,
0.0536652207,
0.0250102021,
-0.0362268761,
-0.0390736945,
-0.1117602512,
-0.0238684602,
-0.025510544,
-0.032221552,
0.0414377116,
-0.01628468,
-0.004087491,
0.0342326015,
0.0259654503,
-0.0826461539,
0.0478824414,
-0.0354584418,
0.0284240153,
0.0268690996,
0.0039342907,
-0.0344214998,
-0.0313592292,
0.000534367,
0.0123503534,
0.016490275,
-0.0232705548,
0.002438314,
0.0322192945,
0.0113710202,
-0.010957934,
0.0974395424,
-0.0637570173,
-0.0098707005,
0.036826428,
0.1353059709,
-0.0232133903,
-0.0293369032,
-0.0625699162,
-0.022349054,
0.0347865932,
0.0972341448,
-0.0191260017,
-0.0234388933,
-0.0508791879,
-0.0386152901,
-0.0085902186,
-0.0253236257,
-0.0277655888,
-0.0007823838,
-0.0337269679,
0.0216009915,
-0.0396724381,
0.0103966286,
0.0513023511,
-0.016806975,
0.0212417543,
-0.0389932655,
0.0172930788,
-0.03078942,
-0.0534530021,
0.015615481,
-0.0464219674,
-0.0010970926,
-0.0503443778,
-0.0632067099,
0.0673272163,
-0.0247230325,
-0.012225505,
0.0249379259,
-0.0444018245,
-0.0594325364,
-0.0261089783,
0.067805931,
0.016016271,
0.0279879663,
-0.0047094813,
-0.0468799099,
0.0635167211,
0.0508540049,
-0.0250907727,
0.0250231512,
-0.0194555651,
-0.0104210787,
-0.016125096,
-0.0423213914,
-0.0206937864,
0.0390026011,
-0.0265631564,
0.016391864,
-0.0309409611,
-0.0528182425,
0.0222224891,
0.0420781076,
0.0401180908,
-0.018466685,
-0.028624054,
-0.0330842957,
-0.0134781394,
0.0192359742,
0.0032924565,
-0.0301431827,
0.0426748395,
0.0086473795,
-0.0364147536,
0.0288314559,
0.0113415644,
-0.0096533317,
0.0162364338,
-0.0604826026,
0.0537105277,
0.0048467685,
0.0223250743,
0.05897104,
-0.0134094078,
-0.0253280215,
-0.0052888501,
-0.0526400991,
0.0341285504,
-0.0037890873,
0.026945537,
0.0354139023,
0.0543527417,
-0.0423572995,
0.0197141245,
-0.0744422898,
-0.0263202339,
-0.0458891317,
0.0256415792,
0.035142865,
0.0397617035,
0.0083856136,
-0.0906385258,
-0.0393140353,
-0.0263509247,
0.0386781953,
-0.0011418584,
0.0217005331,
0.065428704,
0.0478620864,
-0.0237519834,
-0.0312689766,
0.070059374,
0.0476856604,
0.0592226721,
-0.0025287534,
0.0015127159,
-0.0311617795,
-0.0433020629,
-0.0223568436,
-0.0156807881,
0.0049819853,
-0.0406188257,
-0.0225611459,
-0.0126428511,
0.0208496992,
0.0519346632,
-0.01785619,
-0.0326169729,
0.0617046542,
0.0212994646,
-0.0339496471,
-0.052820228,
0.0256560687,
0.0352248177,
-0.02255347,
-0.0586093627,
-0.0088807801,
-5.893411825e-33,
0.0229777787,
-0.0172693729,
0.0341415815,
0.0493165255,
0.0080414293,
-0.0047279983,
-0.0538880378,
-0.0558433384,
0.0158603471,
0.0688558742,
0.0155539932,
0.012239432,
-0.0093312059,
-0.0386968553,
0.0787488818,
0.0271139909,
0.0454176813,
-0.0288767032,
-0.0011734739,
0.051626727,
0.0735474229,
0.0155093102,
0.0385950953,
-0.0555475317,
-0.0023012285,
0.0094947331,
0.0133492583,
0.0146525297,
-0.0668671131,
0.0454930626,
-0.0251896344,
0.0228140987,
-0.0317075476,
-0.0514334887,
-0.0314949304,
-0.0069396859,
-0.0671840236,
-0.0077336738,
-0.0135082901,
-0.0457045771,
-0.0467334613,
-0.0295893531,
0.0287870821,
0.0130048301,
-0.0307762176,
-0.0219055433,
0.0487294495,
-0.030085979,
0.0014857983,
-0.0348815732,
-0.0778838396,
0.0009927391,
-0.0196146015,
0.0041125319,
0.0257870033,
0.000545172,
0.0111313974,
0.0287650581,
-0.0208984092,
0.0767817199,
0.048774492,
0.0043477081,
0.0609157756,
-0.0063388944,
0.0394003093,
0.0402835198,
0.0121171251,
0.00790824,
-0.0027674739,
0.0179140531,
0.0107690878,
0.0608283915,
0.0265377201,
0.0275102835,
-0.0064027151,
0.0191065837,
-0.1309593916,
0.025681274,
0.0146736512,
0.0160673335,
0.0001236713,
0.0298104864,
0.0323388353,
-0.0516056456,
-0.008562617,
0.0264229421,
0.0086953947,
-0.0213745926,
-0.0281228852,
-0.0474613383,
-0.0661445409,
-0.0111686355,
0.0293516442,
-0.0427608825,
0.0039920504,
0.0519169345,
0.0172912925,
0.0386896431,
0.0128806103,
0.0096169692,
-0.1076262519,
-0.0607427917,
-0.0128553854,
-0.0006442642,
0.0418703966,
0.0229632761,
-0.0226129275,
0.0350417681,
0.0160509683,
0.0007442538,
-0.0290194973,
-0.0263150278,
0.0426516049,
0.0145952087,
0.0080375429,
0.0327246003,
0.0185401719,
0.0560992882,
0.01561411,
0.01484707,
0.0232432764,
0.0412038304,
-0.003854665,
0.0228754915,
-0.0384587981,
-0.0473841354,
-0.0565834269,
-0.002408169,
-0.0088168951,
-0.0642418563,
0.0003461402,
0.0443753675,
2.793e-7,
0.0257183369,
0.0794871897,
0.0173703134,
0.0235190466,
0.013268115,
0.0125503307,
-0.0083646392,
-0.0072574853,
-0.0092304172,
-0.0295200776,
0.0035616956,
-0.0024231512,
0.0113708843,
0.0149186766,
-0.0834991187,
-0.0506384969,
-0.0059625567,
-0.0195898302,
-0.0697437078,
-0.0243073478,
0.0016701391,
0.0001270269,
0.0126225976,
0.0018859195,
0.0237141475,
-0.0304161031,
0.0522224903,
0.0113254199,
0.0327137858,
0.079825297,
-0.0312551335,
-0.0069349548,
-0.0139008975,
0.0462083891,
-0.0241003614,
-0.0181690585,
-0.0222967062,
0.0486968681,
0.0044971891,
0.0187302828,
0.0457764044,
-0.01963537,
0.035899736,
-0.0111834938,
0.0027757015,
-0.0557371527,
-0.0170849413,
0.00882948,
-0.0144834593,
-0.0200780667,
-0.0179944467,
-0.0423581824,
0.035654217,
-0.0045371391,
-0.0508695841,
0.0101796603,
-0.0256025754,
-0.0414616987,
-0.0133295935,
0.0379431918,
-0.0466181561,
-0.0631698743,
-0.0001019941,
-0.0125690736,
0.009712426,
-0.0394166112,
0.0129084792,
2.712720915e-34,
0.057727579,
-0.0108817732,
-0.0127139892,
-0.0008763449,
0.0073419679,
-0.0013835842,
-0.0217259023,
0.0170739423,
0.0286847055,
-0.0838665813,
-0.0233402289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13563v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13563v1 | Large Language Models in Analyzing Crash Narratives -- A Comparative Study of ChatGPT, BARD and GPT-4 | 2023-08-25T00:09:16 | 2023-08-25T00:09:16 | Maroa Mumtarin, Md Samiullah Chowdhury, Jonathan Wood | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | In traffic safety research, extracting information from crash narratives
using text analysis is a common practice. With recent advancements of large
language models (LLM), it would be useful to know how the popular LLM
interfaces perform in classifying or extracting information from crash
narratives. To explore this, our study has used the three most popular publicly
available LLM interfaces- ChatGPT, BARD and GPT4. This study investigated their
usefulness and boundaries in extracting information and answering queries
related to accidents from 100 crash narratives from Iowa and Kansas. During the
investigation, their capabilities and limitations were assessed and their
responses to the queries were compared. Five questions were asked related to
the narratives: 1) Who is at-fault? 2) What is the manner of collision? 3) Has
the crash occurred in a work-zone? 4) Did the crash involve pedestrians? and 5)
What are the sequence of harmful events in the crash? For questions 1 through
4, the overall similarity among the LLMs were 70%, 35%, 96% and 89%,
respectively. The similarities were higher while answering direct questions
requiring binary responses and significantly lower for complex questions. To
compare the responses to question 5, network diagram and centrality measures
were analyzed. The network diagram from the three LLMs were not always similar
although they sometimes have the same influencing events with high in-degree,
out-degree and betweenness centrality. This study suggests using multiple
models to extract viable information from narratives. Also, caution must be
practiced while using these interfaces to obtain crucial safety related
information. | [
0.0288780387,
0.0118917711,
-0.0374454521,
0.0375089496,
-0.0747828856,
0.0351518206,
0.0116751697,
0.0161625668,
0.0237600878,
-0.0669455975,
0.0743516162,
-0.0393920764,
-0.0244641956,
0.0309922136,
-0.006511033,
-0.0458693765,
-0.0370163694,
-0.0015402361,
0.0649571121,
0.0424411371,
0.0314494111,
0.0506523177,
-0.0053154286,
0.0396043546,
-0.0510238744,
0.0166861024,
-0.0176477563,
-0.0093253329,
0.034499418,
-0.0647144839,
-0.0142614804,
0.0343115218,
0.0454873145,
0.0378781743,
0.0000020342,
-0.0337357372,
-0.0003923837,
0.0264169089,
0.0100370217,
-0.0156517942,
0.01075124,
0.0461791754,
0.0096704857,
0.0525659472,
-0.022080496,
-0.0475343615,
0.0266357176,
0.0599693656,
0.0229005273,
0.0484164245,
-0.0334428251,
-0.0681822747,
0.0060545783,
0.0394519717,
-0.0109302066,
0.0107273357,
0.0394265614,
0.0763528049,
0.0625926331,
-0.0306333508,
0.008163318,
0.0263926722,
0.0291780792,
-0.0263224635,
-0.0063305805,
0.0316769592,
-0.0011409112,
-0.0282262489,
0.0342201814,
0.0757654607,
0.0279212445,
-0.0387397073,
0.0191047993,
0.0011542216,
0.0205355119,
0.0548056625,
-0.06052972,
0.029593328,
-0.0209375471,
0.0084426543,
-0.011916738,
0.0302463826,
-0.0068728565,
-0.0345622785,
-0.0178534538,
0.0026493617,
-0.009831151,
-0.0290788598,
0.0061655147,
-0.0039162133,
-0.0081491778,
-0.0172783695,
-0.0012184749,
0.021223342,
-0.0273809209,
0.0162127372,
0.0409034453,
0.0113453371,
0.0428369306,
-0.1060385108,
0.019361414,
-0.0077530774,
-0.0140204085,
-0.0033232984,
0.0132784974,
-0.0127696237,
0.0277918335,
-0.0113001084,
-0.0396282449,
0.0029178576,
-0.0596758984,
-0.0118977958,
-0.0100570563,
0.0456964858,
-0.013416796,
0.0374802873,
0.0106336726,
0.0346083716,
0.0360925235,
-0.0267311167,
-0.0483261347,
0.0127128987,
0.0066202157,
0.0091412337,
-0.0065895882,
-0.0036180983,
-0.0243429765,
0.0599008314,
-0.0119018164,
-0.0033439952,
0.0461764485,
0.0413582101,
0.0366161093,
-0.0074535278,
-0.0141814239,
0.0628795698,
-0.035734009,
-0.0142368898,
-0.0853967592,
-0.0433930643,
-0.0038940439,
-0.0249178391,
-0.0658767819,
-0.067545712,
0.0112406081,
0.0446881689,
-0.0567423962,
0.0030304263,
0.0143846218,
-0.0009074596,
-0.0492002182,
0.0025180504,
-0.0212352592,
0.0428129882,
0.0498901978,
0.0117316265,
0.0860542729,
0.0365601368,
0.0424256288,
0.0190241616,
0.0165649466,
-0.0063498472,
0.0246808473,
-0.0004126117,
-0.0373091549,
0.0404983908,
-0.0288615264,
0.0270844419,
-0.0019005603,
0.0335358083,
-0.0213544611,
0.0525750108,
-0.0178505238,
0.03217474,
0.0548255853,
0.0995838195,
0.0138900923,
0.0271473397,
0.0201087501,
0.0298611708,
0.0011299673,
-0.0096846158,
0.0193711147,
-0.0095464233,
-0.0227345526,
-0.0035383017,
0.0236442443,
0.0164494682,
-0.0360101946,
-0.0031265549,
-0.0327107869,
0.0262178108,
0.02343929,
-0.0054197372,
-0.0135253575,
-0.072559014,
-0.0185847059,
0.0124662425,
-0.006292799,
-0.0217152834,
0.0059910072,
-0.0072012711,
0.0050926721,
0.0646689832,
0.0206396207,
-0.0074009346,
-0.0262463,
-0.0361276343,
0.0202265959,
-0.0093504898,
-0.0068467292,
0.0186433084,
-0.0247398503,
-0.0148395607,
-0.0121888407,
0.0237938482,
0.0226288196,
-0.0434537232,
-0.0401830673,
0.0378945582,
0.0015539954,
0.0078808991,
-0.0724529997,
0.0117508387,
-0.0228803065,
0.013298085,
-0.0702295899,
0.0028970866,
-0.0009579727,
0.0104468251,
-0.0210164189,
0.0120008783,
0.0405201726,
-0.0117116915,
-0.0648996904,
0.0494152382,
-0.0048689558,
0.0420528278,
0.0093837278,
-0.0818639174,
0.0301850904,
0.0015772978,
-0.0079399217,
-0.0358636528,
-0.0218565278,
-0.0620726347,
0.0093532223,
0.0013337837,
0.0062127691,
-0.0003954184,
-0.0705298334,
-0.0350789763,
0.0483261608,
0.0204608999,
0.0229346137,
-0.0625517741,
-0.0346551873,
0.0426216125,
-0.0143049248,
-0.0148651963,
0.0462306775,
-0.0296657886,
0.0291281231,
0.0252729096,
-0.0263336636,
-0.0327559635,
-0.0204442628,
-0.0729473978,
-0.0023205753,
-0.0328045227,
0.0030620182,
0.0309460964,
0.0044587436,
-0.0461325236,
0.018020004,
-0.0303535257,
0.0312553234,
0.0270660929,
-0.001513741,
0.0274026953,
0.0238410812,
-0.0040242709,
-0.0151508842,
-0.0170860142,
-0.0412805639,
0.0579830855,
0.0631277859,
-0.0813619569,
-0.0581840649,
0.0395494029,
-0.0285039674,
0.0035638048,
0.0021770704,
-0.0508857258,
0.0221156459,
-0.0040354058,
0.0327672958,
0.0283572152,
0.0392462313,
0.0151935536,
-0.0133746974,
-0.0332569554,
-0.032579314,
-0.0204069912,
-0.0506492667,
-0.0082444465,
-0.0283422805,
-0.0789265782,
-0.0100461552,
0.0169001296,
0.021051053,
0.0095752021,
0.0015021731,
-0.0475214534,
-0.0443250798,
0.0176252462,
-0.0310191661,
-0.0797691941,
0.0080423485,
0.0323335081,
0.030742893,
-0.0135895098,
0.0207070708,
0.0060840244,
0.0626932979,
-0.0588064976,
-0.0472296812,
-0.0576710775,
0.1243958324,
0.0006809331,
0.0116311274,
0.041629076,
-0.0281630605,
-0.0002244815,
-0.0280760098,
0.0107100904,
-0.0068807271,
0.0506800115,
-0.0593945831,
0.0341426805,
0.0011238017,
-0.0194525402,
-0.0162675641,
-0.0775613412,
-0.0080891987,
-0.018288387,
0.0369542092,
-0.0024859775,
-0.0275893807,
0.0841200948,
0.0367904231,
0.0098291477,
-0.0019358258,
0.0180861782,
-0.0031227637,
0.0304960199,
0.038779486,
-0.0024839514,
0.042440895,
0.0020492992,
0.061783962,
0.0670771301,
-0.0009909922,
-0.0156536549,
-0.0051682256,
-0.044319693,
-0.00156662,
-0.0227502007,
-0.0399328619,
0.0315558389,
0.022676887,
-0.0169835407,
0.0134594282,
0.064396821,
0.0235090293,
-0.0293809827,
0.0169566162,
0.0005280667,
-0.0170602519,
0.0075999005,
0.0025534311,
-0.0401041731,
0.0145297935,
-0.015910916,
-0.0085799498,
-0.030588787,
-0.0640406013,
0.0325779878,
-0.0602135584,
0.0440458804,
-0.0002878689,
-0.0297118668,
-0.0127573041,
-0.0418354124,
0.0112272678,
0.0099714734,
0.0273076184,
0.0119061116,
-0.0244625602,
-0.0133633055,
0.0277587809,
-0.0730575547,
-0.0436986461,
0.0166509859,
-0.0350680798,
0.0411716625,
-0.0302437972,
0.0116033703,
-0.0721567422,
0.0506041236,
0.0427501649,
0.0020823742,
-0.0029437735,
-0.0041883411,
0.0403263606,
0.0013378131,
0.0093816193,
-0.0818748325,
0.0282941759,
0.0258093122,
0.0017689556,
0.0292344932,
0.074262917,
-0.0506229848,
-0.0367849246,
-0.0359056555,
0.0335479528,
-0.0098770931,
0.0362497978,
0.0170379262,
0.000771339,
-0.0272537228,
0.0055880649,
-0.0337025374,
0.0104531925,
-0.0499915183,
-0.0187862739,
0.0203371644,
-0.0393048413,
0.000953683,
-0.0536762811,
0.0212930255,
-0.0036893273,
0.0020378812,
0.0431598015,
0.0852701217,
-0.0544374883,
-0.0628060475,
0.0163332764,
0.0062678698,
0.0160912648,
0.0147941569,
0.0758126751,
0.0264297519,
0.0134712504,
-0.0183309093,
-0.0081644626,
-0.0167429931,
-0.0432634428,
0.0317448601,
-0.031614732,
0.0206220914,
-0.0307127684,
-0.0119947968,
-0.0952109993,
-0.0054028286,
0.0336274579,
-0.0630422235,
-0.0021237961,
-0.0739976391,
0.0005487911,
0.0244932231,
0.0033135617,
-0.0250298642,
0.0118166469,
-0.0172504336,
0.0004494961,
-0.0515524596,
-0.0146841789,
0.0132032372,
0.0517301597,
-0.0032572527,
0.0315076038,
0.0278077535,
-0.04142363,
-0.0055828365,
-0.0401024036,
-0.0125113428,
-0.0189592727,
0.0290870871,
0.0113683343,
-0.0054907454,
-0.0220170431,
-0.068400614,
-0.0237807818,
0.0020955296,
-0.0252184253,
0.0563404709,
0.0114447642,
-0.0065429639,
0.0138127906,
-0.0234878119,
-0.0205083136,
-0.02745107,
-0.0030802619,
0.0295650512,
0.0198889095,
0.0504771806,
0.0085618403,
-0.0271541215,
0.0046386248,
0.0127681773,
-0.0478889234,
-0.0488877483,
-0.0463436358,
0.006203189,
0.0295980684,
0.0249504894,
0.017476093,
-0.03508389,
0.0230075791,
-0.0097006401,
0.0225747358,
0.0287021417,
-0.0025805319,
0.0544611886,
0.0008443199,
-0.0528735556,
-0.0129247513,
0.0592930764,
0.0453424715,
-0.0051164734,
0.0152575085,
-0.036770694,
-0.0237067044,
-0.0319020823,
0.0924443603,
-0.0085462909,
-0.0274349526,
-0.0651813075,
-0.0982855856,
-0.0126323383,
0.0002756654,
-0.0188711826,
-0.0013204288,
-0.0193582941,
-0.0307610128,
0.0099451672,
0.0817331746,
-0.0266398471,
-0.0044962913,
0.0443839543,
-0.0590930656,
-0.0000953831,
0.0170571525,
-6.449449673e-33,
-0.0121318251,
-0.0603186786,
0.0126084443,
-0.0165659543,
-0.0611978136,
0.0017546181,
-0.0101661682,
0.0344613306,
-0.0008795712,
0.0136676561,
0.0383881442,
0.0432299599,
0.0046316539,
-0.0143493377,
0.0423601903,
-0.039043095,
-0.0272658151,
0.026973512,
-0.0004751774,
0.0296867341,
0.0202901065,
-0.0063257948,
0.0212075934,
-0.0829356387,
0.0471134037,
-0.0548411608,
-0.004127779,
0.0300821681,
0.0038790447,
0.0385208242,
-0.0025556923,
0.035012994,
0.0493196025,
-0.034057565,
0.0039587501,
0.0498311557,
-0.0013008441,
-0.0283114873,
0.0786991343,
-0.0370295867,
0.007066282,
-0.032713104,
0.0621025115,
-0.0054617617,
0.0057733809,
-0.0182705149,
0.0468050577,
-0.0072328355,
0.0079774773,
0.0071581546,
-0.0560418516,
0.0116438922,
-0.0246274807,
0.0353317037,
-0.0209035035,
0.0412782915,
-0.0172129571,
-0.0056935139,
-0.0199985839,
-0.0342141688,
-0.0221204683,
0.0019958387,
-0.0182974357,
-0.0218404699,
-0.0113392742,
0.0591637939,
-0.0396081619,
-0.0243045278,
-0.0766152143,
0.0019286926,
-0.0029886591,
0.0722214058,
0.0494135171,
0.0749905929,
-0.0505369045,
-0.0483883359,
-0.1334973574,
-0.0055723549,
-0.0118325157,
0.0069160308,
0.0612011701,
-0.0273868535,
-0.0895388126,
-0.0384076461,
-0.0331834033,
0.0378192328,
-0.0297853388,
-0.0120991031,
0.0153680434,
-0.0168295987,
0.0144113703,
0.0171031468,
0.0231057443,
-0.0143598355,
0.0128541533,
-0.0139507446,
-0.0156649165,
0.0284312051,
-0.0225215349,
0.0585850887,
-0.0882371739,
0.0363945737,
-0.0205136836,
0.0090067228,
0.0123448279,
-0.0127778109,
-0.0011177838,
0.0013559957,
-0.0190136563,
-0.0179796554,
0.0077463193,
-0.0412810594,
-0.0003481588,
-0.0217628013,
-0.0037888526,
0.0436004847,
0.0301204938,
-0.0303157121,
0.0430072509,
-0.0148743354,
-0.0091408761,
-0.0848295093,
-0.0429927632,
-0.0352177881,
0.0190377627,
0.0273125898,
0.0136173982,
0.0034723985,
0.0277911499,
-0.0235084556,
-0.007148128,
0.0084134014,
2.703e-7,
0.0554815903,
0.0489035472,
0.0042059333,
0.0205964204,
0.0188633092,
0.0301814657,
0.0495136008,
0.0160129834,
0.0749450624,
0.0148220127,
0.0156369917,
0.0330380164,
0.0140932286,
0.0669761747,
-0.0209881645,
0.023269793,
-0.0484304316,
-0.0603309199,
-0.0733297095,
0.0408967324,
0.1388429701,
0.0258691106,
-0.0154880313,
0.0229526628,
-0.0372584499,
-0.0143655278,
0.0041318354,
-0.0471350513,
-0.049543146,
0.0390777476,
0.0177559834,
0.0499612838,
0.0034850473,
0.0733438432,
0.0330532789,
-0.0096491827,
-0.0043342547,
0.0217401218,
-0.0037779915,
-0.0038597323,
0.0241190661,
-0.0907675028,
0.0393632725,
-0.0798251182,
0.0621712282,
-0.0370362736,
-0.0309496354,
0.0241416134,
-0.0383700095,
-0.0451706573,
0.0019857981,
-0.0068645524,
0.0131531321,
0.0300845224,
-0.006024126,
0.0038787469,
0.0103905862,
-0.0224689413,
0.0194311813,
0.062000405,
0.0168330371,
-0.0805613473,
-0.0125474166,
0.0443905331,
0.0246447287,
-0.0371428058,
0.0352814011,
2.241529285e-34,
0.0045542233,
0.0318879709,
-0.0114592398,
-0.0213425606,
0.0453661196,
0.0361420959,
-0.0257223267,
0.0108623449,
-0.0294271037,
-0.0994209573,
-0.0080346242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13116v1 | Sentence Embedding Models for Ancient Greek Using Multilingual Knowledge Distillation | 2023-08-24T23:38:44 | 2023-08-24T23:38:44 | Kevin Krahn, Derrick Tate, Andrew C. Lamicela | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Contextual language models have been trained on Classical languages,
including Ancient Greek and Latin, for tasks such as lemmatization,
morphological tagging, part of speech tagging, authorship attribution, and
detection of scribal errors. However, high-quality sentence embedding models
for these historical languages are significantly more difficult to achieve due
to the lack of training data. In this work, we use a multilingual knowledge
distillation approach to train BERT models to produce sentence embeddings for
Ancient Greek text. The state-of-the-art sentence embedding approaches for
high-resource languages use massive datasets, but our distillation approach
allows our Ancient Greek models to inherit the properties of these models while
using a relatively small amount of translated sentence data. We build a
parallel sentence dataset using a sentence-embedding alignment method to align
Ancient Greek documents with English translations, and use this dataset to
train our models. We evaluate our models on translation search, semantic
similarity, and semantic retrieval tasks and investigate translation bias. We
make our training and evaluation datasets freely available at
https://github.com/kevinkrahn/ancient-greek-datasets . | [
-0.0028128519,
0.0300970729,
-0.0075803213,
0.0681915432,
-0.0305316914,
0.0167257898,
0.0166219082,
0.0214840434,
0.0068971049,
-0.0542153083,
-0.00680626,
-0.0094710095,
0.0233625956,
-0.0467799641,
0.0331612565,
-0.0166108608,
0.0206017848,
0.0338662788,
0.0049224379,
-0.0022952019,
0.0055804118,
0.0159148518,
0.0279940423,
-0.00903334,
-0.0029417314,
-0.023103701,
0.0070444453,
0.0365679488,
0.0533707924,
0.0175744444,
-0.009514669,
-0.0071722656,
0.0534400009,
0.0624270327,
0.0000015614,
-0.0248051416,
-0.004287676,
-0.0162897781,
-0.004902353,
0.0310855396,
0.0042311521,
-0.0100255739,
-0.0050740116,
-0.028147608,
-0.0241527464,
0.0066098874,
0.0180484094,
0.0111683793,
0.0369831845,
0.1056885123,
-0.0286493115,
-0.0531343631,
0.0117855659,
-0.0265000947,
-0.0049729566,
0.0215709601,
0.0106862988,
-0.0065293405,
-0.0404813774,
0.0317931585,
-0.0109764198,
0.0511765182,
-0.0056739012,
0.0417665094,
-0.0458308496,
-0.0202344973,
-0.0714334324,
0.0068120109,
0.0050819558,
0.0015281572,
0.0188003574,
-0.0164155737,
0.0178389084,
0.0237627178,
-0.0123641249,
0.0119771175,
-0.0298067834,
0.0066475249,
-0.0148477247,
0.0346873701,
0.0357690118,
-0.0270094387,
0.027091058,
-0.0102510909,
-0.0378749557,
0.0230243206,
0.0894511417,
-0.0603147857,
-0.0258513186,
0.0253664684,
-0.0892359316,
0.0164106023,
0.0058477339,
0.0064335987,
0.0057446472,
-0.0134363519,
-0.0275001265,
-0.0717078224,
0.0265321527,
-0.0302798655,
-0.0004710687,
0.0244082045,
-0.0156038376,
0.0285156332,
-0.0610166751,
0.0586649217,
0.0325654857,
0.0187145788,
-0.0319350101,
-0.0148203522,
-0.0190442577,
0.013709004,
-0.0506505445,
-0.0129342489,
-0.0292780492,
-0.0022550267,
-0.0284255855,
0.0140975416,
0.0563957728,
0.0040753945,
-0.0005788833,
-0.0570853464,
-0.0184336472,
-0.0020884848,
0.0133821722,
0.0183629952,
-0.0029941704,
0.0099893594,
-0.0392743759,
-0.0423066206,
-0.0274903271,
0.0141902091,
0.052092202,
-0.0479426123,
0.0371316485,
0.0093969163,
-0.0144885713,
-0.0757758319,
0.0001318078,
0.0108490298,
-0.0410284922,
-0.0551016964,
-0.0195135716,
-0.0229881797,
0.0394883603,
-0.0102312714,
0.0213158559,
-0.0029100764,
-0.0042337943,
0.0496140383,
-0.0304578841,
0.0461799949,
0.0149392271,
0.0168351512,
-0.0146340076,
-0.0440516509,
0.0351066813,
0.0089098262,
0.051105503,
-0.0076455972,
0.0500857234,
0.0544223599,
-0.0445017889,
0.0299196169,
0.0067318701,
0.0437022373,
-0.0081078596,
0.0122102676,
0.0531216934,
0.05343128,
-0.0226340145,
0.0388314947,
-0.0242648926,
0.0482849106,
0.0606728867,
0.0143231088,
-0.0086296406,
-0.0025960279,
0.0222169962,
-0.0272136349,
-0.0067064641,
0.0044806758,
-0.0347375795,
-0.0143648079,
0.0586620346,
0.0491424873,
-0.0036613035,
0.0474169031,
-0.0088534271,
0.0072752507,
-0.0130061125,
-0.034511853,
-0.0198806301,
-0.0039194259,
0.0581904277,
0.0142885968,
-0.0448039621,
0.0644600242,
0.0163876433,
-0.1179306582,
-0.0214626994,
0.0301027671,
0.0391711444,
0.0647005513,
0.0692873746,
-0.061643105,
0.0004702907,
0.0098888082,
0.0381532274,
0.0737995133,
-0.0149676874,
0.0084450515,
0.023094913,
-0.0848030895,
-0.0182761457,
-0.0301765557,
0.0361599363,
-0.0177471731,
-0.0104908049,
0.0464320816,
0.0394656211,
-0.0677153915,
-0.0317787752,
0.07358668,
-0.0402821563,
-0.0076075662,
-0.0511652343,
0.0505813956,
-0.0261024311,
0.0127013521,
0.001288795,
-0.002738954,
0.0317990854,
-0.0930714607,
0.0214284379,
0.0101457406,
-0.0347530432,
-0.0918658152,
0.0838302374,
-0.0534667969,
-0.0205122624,
0.0353549533,
-0.0203389116,
-0.0549850389,
0.0051929578,
-0.018230604,
0.0437022857,
-0.0045305705,
0.0272543989,
-0.0065241684,
-0.0053778701,
-0.0166325159,
0.0636838526,
0.0284930766,
0.0639404356,
0.0189784411,
-0.0593261905,
0.0637514144,
0.0125925383,
-0.0892921314,
-0.0576630943,
-0.0005027129,
-0.0208743811,
0.0347580276,
0.0028809181,
0.0142229693,
-0.0454535745,
-0.1090833172,
0.0525606871,
-0.061142236,
0.0528589413,
0.0129656568,
0.0398039781,
-0.0009549594,
-0.0063908147,
-0.0469521172,
0.0053644641,
-0.031867791,
0.0114584975,
0.0589498021,
-0.0296499804,
-0.0334867798,
-0.0401330031,
-0.0036372724,
0.0047492087,
0.0749602765,
0.0364781879,
0.0139405308,
-0.0170081407,
-0.0079164887,
-0.0180473886,
-0.0083497725,
-0.0215972755,
-0.0210272297,
-0.001204046,
-0.0020177367,
0.08217033,
0.0197277367,
-0.0261316858,
-0.0358749926,
0.022851279,
0.0018833774,
-0.0136230923,
-0.0104920994,
-0.0319006518,
-0.018487256,
-0.0772207379,
-0.0330013186,
-0.0041480516,
0.0377656594,
-0.0281570274,
-0.0132127916,
-0.0555303022,
-0.019155575,
0.002411498,
0.0558936931,
0.0223008841,
0.0129273664,
0.0022846963,
0.002063592,
-0.0204657186,
-0.0227979664,
0.0385916419,
-0.0184554309,
-0.0019379199,
-0.0546804033,
-0.0029334372,
-0.0601379536,
0.0441151448,
0.0157664232,
0.0289308857,
-0.013222076,
0.0179525744,
-0.0545656681,
0.0353122316,
0.0762546882,
-0.021611046,
0.0549296848,
0.0131804924,
-0.0015624954,
-0.0358617492,
-0.0371509753,
0.0223462768,
-0.0310524423,
-0.018041471,
0.0092802355,
0.0066509512,
-0.0138249425,
-0.0702552944,
-0.0470534116,
-0.0221982356,
0.0511504635,
-0.002412918,
0.0186051503,
-0.0420192219,
0.0838899612,
0.0218403395,
-0.0010375819,
-0.0553547926,
-0.0231078304,
0.014430495,
-0.0234458633,
0.0345308557,
-0.0127703259,
-0.0398817286,
-0.0309230499,
0.0132862302,
-0.0558644533,
-0.0415932797,
-0.0616876595,
-0.0099170227,
-0.0173868071,
0.0186745226,
0.0744189024,
0.0104603088,
-0.0284725893,
-0.0208162107,
-0.0248383321,
0.010626059,
0.03108331,
-0.00693405,
-0.0950810239,
-0.0414413661,
-0.0063865245,
-0.0106326891,
0.0536103658,
0.0059237331,
0.0071325591,
-0.068465285,
-0.0160841364,
0.0029628736,
-0.0393105559,
-0.0652759224,
-0.014069289,
-0.0119372178,
-0.0367143266,
-0.0090056472,
0.0062210276,
-0.0111068701,
0.0318077914,
-0.0160628278,
0.0066255177,
-0.0506566837,
-0.0330387391,
-0.0763043165,
0.0139958793,
0.0295607336,
0.1039763689,
-0.0294885226,
-0.0239964481,
0.0035645165,
-0.0160224959,
-0.0436168462,
0.0194217172,
0.0695035458,
-0.035437949,
-0.010419542,
0.0145977978,
0.0137189617,
-0.0339796431,
-0.0464198366,
0.045409821,
0.0637026355,
0.0253904667,
0.0063508754,
0.0200553518,
-0.033588551,
0.0162149481,
0.0738854855,
0.0128498999,
-0.0137621062,
-0.0423403047,
0.0114744985,
0.0402031802,
-0.0227306206,
0.0020723105,
0.0148972329,
0.0144038536,
-0.0009901605,
-0.0991185755,
-0.0195339546,
-0.0044046054,
-0.0019619458,
0.0431392007,
0.0003165628,
-0.0615416504,
-0.0185879227,
-0.0552218743,
0.0136612048,
-0.0367505625,
0.0361369774,
-0.0113747343,
0.0329727121,
0.0062577995,
0.0034275926,
-0.0102215325,
0.0218058042,
-0.0681386888,
-0.0574443527,
-0.0138510978,
-0.0050967201,
0.0002931338,
0.0581028163,
-0.0047183321,
0.005896911,
0.0399890617,
0.0188884195,
-0.0014042505,
0.0396585912,
0.0430162363,
0.0111698592,
-0.0149738742,
0.0718073249,
-0.0303180926,
-0.0201732144,
0.0421903655,
0.0551828369,
-0.011644627,
-0.0556414947,
0.0238243118,
0.0319734626,
0.035865441,
-0.0618504658,
0.0209047813,
-0.0343569033,
0.0283493102,
-0.0168594122,
0.0015088771,
-0.033184018,
0.0411695018,
0.0239252299,
-0.0116448598,
0.0211842973,
0.0283314176,
0.0119258352,
0.0119933002,
-0.0547433384,
0.042100817,
0.0348926485,
-0.0226755515,
-0.0142213786,
0.0282357577,
-0.000190958,
-0.0020740288,
-0.0515669994,
0.0333590955,
-0.0237600077,
-0.0121323522,
0.0277884658,
-0.0146192107,
0.0192870218,
0.0189082734,
-0.0620259643,
-0.0045536952,
-0.0012012145,
-0.0136624547,
0.0901913941,
-0.0149999233,
0.1256752759,
-0.0485424437,
-0.0227628779,
-0.0031058858,
0.0625733808,
0.0155646317,
0.0121461265,
-0.0491842628,
-0.0027021901,
-0.0247574877,
0.0230677165,
0.0746509358,
-0.0035985974,
0.0516480245,
0.0130726425,
-0.0235382095,
-0.0302285384,
-0.0234133322,
0.0163272489,
-0.0120939137,
-0.0205638744,
-0.0357704796,
-0.0311119054,
-0.0447883718,
-0.0005416439,
0.0315083452,
-0.0490420908,
-0.0048002996,
0.012819198,
0.026891157,
-0.0305963308,
0.0097685736,
-0.0366529897,
0.0229568891,
-0.0361933373,
-0.0264508203,
-0.0562675148,
-4.554558657e-33,
0.0088833477,
0.0846068412,
0.0094350828,
-0.0064926222,
-0.0346616283,
0.012992953,
-0.0345807113,
-0.0216163583,
-0.0058255293,
0.050283242,
-0.003190022,
-0.0087858941,
0.0042135478,
0.0479038134,
-0.000752883,
-0.0048360624,
0.0511654802,
0.0088185892,
-0.007934588,
0.0029975444,
0.0709277689,
0.0355990678,
0.1049551666,
0.0052201604,
0.0241837166,
-0.0352625772,
0.0018182676,
0.0133525738,
0.027440289,
0.0407123864,
-0.0015975832,
0.0221090317,
0.0005203275,
-0.0054481588,
-0.0130648091,
0.0551991239,
-0.0363036022,
-0.0091654351,
0.0073927287,
0.0465322919,
-0.0116157085,
-0.0182593074,
-0.048978582,
-0.0204190165,
0.0270776376,
-0.0019113511,
0.077442646,
-0.0379124507,
-0.0497175679,
-0.0483565181,
-0.0355469361,
0.0355078578,
-0.0109582925,
-0.0263417829,
0.044500716,
0.057835985,
0.0220150277,
0.0383729152,
-0.0329511091,
0.0046781953,
-0.0633390024,
0.0235667042,
-0.0061730053,
0.0091474252,
0.0071222573,
0.0399392284,
-0.0226373263,
-0.0261313189,
0.0366238467,
0.0045258803,
0.0119960876,
0.0415922254,
0.0384115353,
0.0646749362,
-0.0147801731,
-0.0140707847,
-0.0507471114,
-0.0149070695,
-0.0002338814,
-0.0161157157,
0.0341543704,
-0.0212458409,
-0.0297009237,
-0.0086186733,
-0.0462522805,
-0.0678478479,
0.0201153792,
0.0138728442,
0.0139100384,
-0.0003976431,
0.0017973043,
0.0113286627,
-0.0019827692,
-0.0683784559,
-0.0118566509,
0.0477140583,
-0.0490852892,
0.0204013754,
-0.0093787173,
0.0036604533,
-0.0290991403,
-0.0124414181,
0.0217052475,
0.004154589,
-0.0140720662,
-0.018809706,
0.0690271407,
0.011496203,
-0.0387318134,
0.0256954357,
-0.0167334247,
-0.0618844889,
-0.0477787256,
0.0361050144,
0.0135932565,
0.0189050082,
0.0274442211,
-0.0152664622,
0.0564045645,
-0.0138442693,
-0.0125103872,
0.0057311077,
0.0094531607,
0.0036907482,
0.0088157915,
-0.0086022187,
-0.0186446272,
0.0527373143,
0.0175446607,
-0.0248016436,
0.0237350352,
-0.0010455793,
2.326e-7,
0.0477119908,
-0.0091995001,
0.0317898467,
-0.0034783527,
-0.0140434019,
0.0489911288,
-0.0259757433,
0.0436253659,
-0.0339022242,
-0.0219379961,
0.0580813102,
0.0082619721,
0.0822440758,
-0.0148393307,
-0.1080789864,
0.0004473526,
-0.0825831667,
-0.0603626668,
-0.0537600592,
-0.0054222737,
0.0255096126,
0.0988129452,
0.0386611409,
-0.0417015031,
-0.039331302,
-0.0293355025,
0.0609159768,
-0.053672608,
-0.0290905107,
0.032199949,
0.0139424196,
0.0085777454,
-0.0058734985,
0.0376320928,
-0.0380534939,
0.0473733693,
0.0188314598,
0.0457852632,
0.0262940992,
0.0322725661,
-0.0137980795,
-0.011270009,
-0.0383056216,
-0.0433224365,
0.0406536423,
-0.0017041559,
0.0057927449,
-0.0296989176,
-0.0531101637,
0.0473626144,
0.0341496542,
0.0277288649,
-0.036706429,
0.0246003959,
0.0645622537,
-0.0136827249,
-0.000293519,
-0.069406718,
-0.0178405717,
0.013517892,
-0.0608048849,
-0.0304082371,
-0.0292081535,
-0.0143405898,
0.0419706963,
-0.047894828,
-0.0187503546,
2.132633509e-34,
0.0242193565,
-0.0387148261,
-0.0010913041,
0.0366022103,
-0.0320428051,
-0.0483861379,
0.0109328646,
-0.004431494,
-0.0129910605,
-0.0327297188,
0.0273290351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13089v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13089v1 | Towards a Holistic Approach: Understanding Sociodemographic Biases in NLP Models using an Interdisciplinary Lens | 2023-08-24T21:19:48 | 2023-08-24T21:19:48 | Pranav Narayanan Venkit | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid growth in the usage and applications of Natural Language Processing
(NLP) in various sociotechnical solutions has highlighted the need for a
comprehensive understanding of bias and its impact on society. While research
on bias in NLP has expanded, several challenges persist that require attention.
These include the limited focus on sociodemographic biases beyond race and
gender, the narrow scope of analysis predominantly centered on models, and the
technocentric implementation approaches. This paper addresses these challenges
and advocates for a more interdisciplinary approach to understanding bias in
NLP. The work is structured into three facets, each exploring a specific aspect
of bias in NLP. | [
0.0759280771,
0.0705143958,
-0.0470671542,
0.015722217,
-0.026649572,
0.0152515378,
0.0127128148,
-0.0243184213,
0.0355515629,
-0.1100829318,
0.0510988757,
0.0248157419,
0.043643713,
-0.0055814809,
0.0002430425,
-0.0554475486,
0.0070524295,
0.0665136501,
0.0234522615,
-0.0149353324,
0.0432797074,
0.0667395145,
0.0129243899,
0.0741086006,
-0.0163408574,
-0.0016255314,
0.0777135119,
0.0016771469,
-0.0344473831,
-0.0194448028,
0.0358006731,
0.0457089432,
-0.0458471589,
0.0119917085,
0.0000017229,
-0.0714537129,
-0.0192599948,
0.0186374262,
-0.0120714894,
-0.0127609046,
0.067024149,
-0.0083965203,
-0.0288075861,
0.0230375938,
-0.0406904221,
0.0294201244,
0.0693043694,
0.0018372042,
0.0183012355,
-0.0137617057,
-0.0155624002,
-0.0356110297,
-0.0458049513,
0.0406331196,
-0.0541647673,
-0.0034387072,
0.0364574045,
-0.0200957395,
0.0057222042,
-0.0256199837,
-0.020785762,
0.0282750968,
-0.0117526939,
0.0203051604,
0.0254254714,
-0.0006364931,
-0.0172392633,
-0.0375109315,
0.0007066036,
0.0258328561,
0.0363445282,
0.013200243,
0.0002917836,
-0.0116346199,
0.0180887859,
0.0357116684,
-0.0240847599,
0.0379881747,
-0.0134646064,
0.0029520807,
-0.0036454995,
0.0148340296,
0.0068945675,
0.0585303605,
0.0060378029,
0.0696317405,
-0.002103131,
-0.0296167303,
0.0068441299,
0.0228618793,
0.044787325,
-0.0246427841,
0.0525625348,
-0.0025924556,
-0.0046091848,
0.0283229463,
0.0132480692,
-0.0042481394,
0.0374367759,
-0.068744719,
0.0165411532,
0.0138486624,
0.0110812066,
-0.0059445212,
0.0519251563,
-0.0232490841,
0.0025849466,
-0.0029291394,
0.010848877,
-0.0060643377,
-0.0543755107,
-0.0316483378,
-0.0081346864,
-0.0230774581,
-0.0058926097,
0.0380380601,
-0.0069516646,
-0.018655004,
-0.0598066188,
-0.007584244,
-0.0159748197,
0.0463667177,
-0.0098480377,
0.001351748,
-0.0445020087,
0.0117877694,
-0.0396429636,
0.0437133648,
-0.0479052141,
-0.0932743922,
0.0501727127,
-0.0157319102,
-0.0166081507,
-0.0469249263,
0.0015975272,
0.0140063632,
0.0228944272,
-0.0091269081,
-0.0596554764,
-0.0597486459,
-0.0047927448,
-0.0090087643,
-0.0238823835,
-0.0410504751,
-0.0181753375,
0.0566150919,
0.0217652414,
-0.0469759814,
-0.0216013305,
0.0336376764,
-0.0904365033,
0.0576973744,
0.0152015397,
0.003318425,
0.0556587167,
-0.0045548826,
0.013642855,
0.0804420933,
0.0157631114,
-0.0208419021,
0.0509822667,
-0.0033200805,
-0.003051596,
0.0065247626,
-0.0129804555,
-0.0129226781,
-0.0200143661,
0.0289266724,
-0.057816986,
-0.0169570893,
0.0521213375,
0.033977285,
0.0111192642,
0.0192278102,
0.0179917607,
0.0882764608,
0.011360636,
0.0296979938,
-0.0094362032,
0.0393622294,
-0.0276503675,
-0.0019752271,
-0.0535570569,
-0.0218483824,
-0.0246969722,
-0.0410431288,
-0.0064931228,
0.039131511,
-0.0090064621,
-0.0155043826,
-0.0335605964,
0.070316352,
0.0778261498,
-0.0121146441,
-0.0121601382,
0.034398742,
0.0251311027,
0.0519609936,
0.0208258331,
0.005914195,
-0.0038600049,
-0.0468746722,
-0.0494036302,
0.0495517552,
-0.0078498712,
0.0102648409,
0.0276666973,
-0.0115542663,
-0.0378093161,
0.0606624,
0.0151482811,
-0.0002071879,
-0.0390419289,
-0.0075065056,
-0.0156030031,
0.060399197,
0.0168284047,
0.0071238489,
0.0501564927,
0.0386838876,
-0.0060050981,
-0.0223440137,
-0.0603739433,
0.038837757,
0.0121375723,
-0.02476147,
-0.0533747785,
0.0274390969,
0.0030586121,
0.0452770405,
-0.0255362187,
0.0197438821,
-0.0433179699,
0.0192369241,
0.0083160577,
0.0118373679,
-0.0095122056,
0.0386252329,
0.0083304206,
-0.0944970101,
-0.0301417559,
0.0348492153,
0.0290313587,
0.0171697158,
0.05479059,
-0.0223661922,
0.0479533486,
0.0116709154,
-0.0188526511,
-0.0372138098,
0.0172546748,
-0.0567678101,
0.0118336435,
-0.0219978169,
-0.0274828821,
0.0039044137,
-0.0360806212,
0.0064273993,
-0.0028003145,
-0.0099039758,
0.0508307852,
-0.0124681732,
0.0107360296,
0.0479211956,
-0.0160003621,
-0.0154985078,
0.0026089738,
-0.0516564026,
-0.0342997275,
-0.0022330871,
-0.011964838,
-0.0127277169,
-0.0000756466,
-0.0384243727,
-0.0163859054,
0.0043876092,
-0.0529828109,
-0.0045025484,
0.0522856414,
0.0082484307,
-0.0242975708,
0.0122616123,
-0.0095591908,
-0.0338671952,
-0.0290516894,
0.0609956905,
0.0308781285,
-0.0357612781,
-0.0499926358,
-0.0304083489,
-0.0039501386,
-0.0207085051,
0.0207235478,
0.0269913599,
0.0323040895,
0.0710594803,
-0.0032294327,
0.0159496982,
-0.0013416901,
0.0285527334,
0.011161183,
-0.0154712293,
-0.0379466377,
-0.0337241739,
0.0033341565,
0.0253238026,
0.0139917908,
-0.0988789797,
-0.0041467212,
0.0290404968,
0.0316362157,
-0.0264922976,
-0.0301667619,
0.0685215741,
-0.0942832008,
-0.0228368416,
-0.0330247656,
-0.0550090149,
-0.0156213976,
0.0208199006,
-0.0278862566,
-0.0377048776,
0.012599037,
0.0397055335,
0.031388361,
-0.0735939294,
-0.0134693636,
-0.0291214883,
0.0553634465,
-0.0238410011,
0.0450367592,
0.0695617869,
-0.0616859496,
-0.0272357836,
-0.0454693548,
0.0312766433,
-0.0222513638,
0.020942729,
-0.0125696212,
0.0138007645,
-0.0014725904,
-0.0256945081,
-0.0194072276,
-0.0460298918,
-0.0441804901,
0.0251400284,
0.0642998517,
0.0132115008,
0.0050840708,
0.0096799573,
0.0120791933,
-0.0045455932,
0.0115943681,
-0.0284400936,
-0.0004836052,
0.0022865916,
0.0041017858,
-0.0228491649,
0.0727730095,
0.0481033735,
-0.0334445611,
0.03349296,
0.0097973803,
-0.0096571194,
0.0185910948,
0.0282249656,
0.0555569828,
-0.0634531528,
-0.0189720262,
0.01397835,
0.0374561287,
-0.0228194669,
0.0556928776,
0.041329097,
0.014371234,
-0.0198792182,
0.0171997007,
0.0072185812,
-0.0167458169,
0.0335398205,
0.0059056785,
-0.0566011928,
0.0224092081,
0.0270012841,
0.0013786899,
-0.0876412615,
-0.0403437503,
-0.0287711546,
-0.0934616551,
0.0020401503,
0.0055047013,
-0.0095885275,
-0.0096195992,
-0.027774686,
-0.0103994245,
-0.0121266954,
0.0549507961,
-0.0371145755,
-0.0318117328,
0.0254660342,
0.0334506556,
-0.1053656265,
-0.0486146547,
0.0189693868,
-0.037643183,
0.0377842747,
0.0380583182,
0.0475736633,
-0.045127593,
0.027103018,
0.0450735129,
-0.0197832137,
0.0041115452,
-0.0411885194,
0.0163410902,
-0.0421262532,
0.014511371,
-0.0502007119,
0.0078453394,
-0.0029918479,
0.0045104185,
-0.0134526994,
0.0138378218,
0.0348469391,
-0.0249324068,
-0.0734004453,
-0.0220833905,
-0.0067744693,
0.0511637926,
0.0158960242,
-0.0248505753,
-0.0011742999,
-0.0681666955,
0.0011213565,
0.0466625765,
-0.0971732661,
0.0322215222,
-0.0018412175,
-0.0346008465,
0.0125974687,
-0.0908622816,
0.0183077995,
0.0046824436,
0.042505566,
-0.0398499481,
0.0581720509,
-0.0334544964,
-0.0274031032,
0.0443365723,
-0.0117820948,
0.0464141816,
0.0484724157,
-0.0337679908,
-0.010860906,
0.0130215622,
0.0008775755,
-0.0145287924,
0.0068591121,
-0.0375036635,
0.0579153895,
-0.0169785898,
0.026221754,
0.0098180911,
0.0096126022,
-0.0890729949,
0.0298179556,
0.041647505,
-0.0184698198,
0.0009978674,
0.0190525968,
0.0135401366,
0.0104726022,
0.0175075103,
0.0066894931,
0.0327238441,
0.028144829,
0.0047239712,
-0.0417885892,
-0.0087358169,
0.0217065737,
-0.022872502,
0.0254460927,
-0.0486317836,
0.0199419428,
-0.0352076702,
-0.0816666782,
0.0148744648,
-0.0380300172,
-0.0015855017,
-0.0396985263,
0.0315225497,
0.0452308506,
-0.069914259,
-0.0091003515,
-0.0713090524,
0.0266909767,
-0.0280981977,
0.059853632,
0.0217134207,
0.0178589821,
-0.006937135,
-0.0006320663,
0.0149334176,
0.0180436,
-0.0305825938,
0.046923276,
0.0489991717,
0.0293370858,
0.0164900795,
0.0120906336,
-0.0289847367,
-0.0100253224,
-0.0379662998,
-0.0236112028,
-0.0025937399,
-0.0126813687,
0.0171621554,
-0.0811528787,
0.0068998002,
0.014592642,
0.0083492305,
0.0319205634,
-0.0493124165,
0.035114605,
-0.0147329429,
0.0275175106,
-0.0201789569,
-0.0334237665,
0.0011890641,
0.0334559754,
0.0276558623,
0.0363925099,
-0.01292085,
-0.066049315,
0.0168842152,
-0.0413565785,
0.047498364,
-0.0136224497,
-0.0247745253,
-0.0109632174,
-0.1150918007,
-0.0428796932,
-0.0114685623,
-0.0505609959,
0.0442451239,
-0.0131379208,
-0.0030412748,
0.0639419854,
0.0022176995,
-0.0765833631,
-0.0229463242,
0.0026063905,
-0.0392504558,
0.0016375157,
0.0042279763,
-5.885947068e-33,
-0.0108912773,
-0.070465818,
-0.0133004123,
-0.0429910384,
0.006268803,
-0.0176645536,
0.0238726232,
0.0364586301,
-0.04440118,
0.0258266591,
-0.0122953234,
0.0163425338,
0.0222317744,
-0.005107116,
0.0543358326,
0.0099542607,
0.0267877355,
0.0227502622,
0.0075398632,
-0.0399691388,
-0.0399731882,
-0.0098169772,
0.0339045003,
-0.0729854181,
0.1214657873,
0.0327538513,
-0.0198975261,
-0.0027720055,
0.0384826362,
-0.0081754616,
-0.0324150845,
0.0861399472,
0.0345396698,
-0.0504275747,
-0.006656256,
0.0702086091,
-0.0172900353,
-0.0109471716,
0.0504080132,
0.0484392494,
0.0409846716,
-0.0281986725,
0.0424222685,
0.0139692174,
-0.0987266228,
0.0255464502,
0.0636371374,
-0.0105868392,
0.0420158245,
0.0196437296,
-0.053332597,
0.023617046,
-0.0422011614,
0.0581176952,
0.0078698071,
0.0089191347,
0.005845496,
0.0080779409,
-0.0524350405,
-0.0007330322,
0.0175635982,
-0.0227482598,
0.0603734963,
0.0080302106,
-0.0103153866,
0.0519857109,
0.0502703227,
0.0451199263,
-0.0248953998,
-0.0676805601,
0.0362981595,
-0.0426185019,
-0.0108453445,
0.0424054153,
0.029886527,
-0.0194919836,
0.017132923,
-0.0299392994,
0.0069479267,
0.0182168856,
0.0298444051,
-0.0128588742,
-0.1100330204,
-0.0657404438,
-0.0291628223,
-0.0646472946,
-0.010528937,
-0.0156699866,
0.0237733405,
-0.0091591002,
-0.0036454725,
0.0592599884,
-0.0213560667,
-0.0740055665,
-0.0555105992,
-0.0337098949,
-0.0118548702,
-0.0423155725,
0.015695123,
0.0160172451,
-0.0665710494,
0.0113730188,
-0.0314177349,
0.0522410646,
0.0111622801,
0.0095687388,
-0.0227662697,
0.0054236469,
-0.0674949437,
-0.0178196281,
0.010041764,
-0.0061833733,
0.0148403067,
0.0031341438,
0.0589440502,
0.0261026733,
0.0117041273,
-0.0092004966,
0.0651146099,
0.0230262429,
0.0011330557,
0.006938383,
-0.0447094478,
0.0082809692,
-0.0193772502,
-0.0109661641,
-0.0301170498,
0.0292104166,
0.0450000539,
-0.0011453048,
-0.0200552978,
-0.0709988251,
2.272e-7,
0.0346350111,
0.079034619,
-0.0096406303,
0.0085847015,
0.0075530005,
0.0131167434,
0.0494059026,
0.0344939493,
0.0207246691,
-0.0013770163,
-0.0477859117,
0.0105128633,
-0.0064521339,
0.0345917344,
-0.0643300191,
0.0015198194,
-0.0430224687,
0.0649250597,
-0.0366169699,
0.0346610062,
0.0149384439,
0.0346141495,
0.0103508662,
0.0058785514,
-0.0809212029,
-0.0200263765,
-0.020694457,
-0.0193304438,
0.0232406445,
0.0166020729,
0.0319365263,
0.0314648226,
0.0392159149,
0.047053989,
0.0153887654,
0.0077301688,
0.0186554752,
0.0191763826,
-0.02674447,
0.0302382018,
-0.0392643623,
-0.0432890169,
-0.0211524274,
-0.0579917207,
0.0478633493,
0.0136843603,
-0.0429848991,
-0.0512496568,
-0.0345460959,
-0.0187363606,
0.04090387,
-0.0044007972,
-0.0357130542,
-0.0060298136,
0.0272237305,
-0.0121435821,
-0.0169596653,
-0.0586489215,
-0.0144250449,
-0.0294034909,
0.0232068691,
-0.0320590101,
0.0144129312,
0.0536369346,
0.0276128165,
-0.0187158547,
0.0338170119,
1.809686295e-34,
0.0030690348,
0.013066153,
0.0563858598,
-0.0208304115,
0.0244087167,
0.0339505598,
-0.0015697599,
-0.0141571891,
0.0286478922,
-0.0000838782,
0.014763616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13081v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13081v3 | Formal specification terminology for demographic agent-based models of fixed-step single-clocked simulations | 2023-08-24T20:57:07 | 2023-10-20T14:05:12 | Atiyah Elsheikh | cs.CL | cs.CL, math.DS | This document presents adequate formal terminology for the mathematical
specification of a subset of Agent Based Models (ABMs) in the field of
Demography. The simulation of the targeted ABMs follows a fixedstep
single-clocked pattern. The proposed terminology further improves the model
understanding and can act as a stand-alone protocol for the specification and
optionally the documentation of a significant set of (demographic) ABMs.
Nevertheless, it is imaginable the this terminology can serve as an inspiring
basis for further improvement to the largely-informal widely-used model
documentation and communication O.D.D. protocol [Grimm and et al., 2020,
Amouroux et al., 2010] to reduce many sources of ambiguity which hinder model
replications by other modelers. A published demographic model documentation,
largely simplified version of the Lone Parent Model [Gostoli and Silverman,
2020] is separately published in [Elsheikh, 2023c] as illustration for the
formal terminology presented here. The model was implemented in the Julia
language [Elsheikh, 2023b] based on the Agents.jl julia package [Datseris et
al., 2022]. | [
-0.0128234634,
0.0067185229,
-0.0383569039,
-0.0781712383,
-0.0673152283,
-0.007850742,
0.084119752,
-0.0162060857,
0.0169149209,
0.0064474191,
0.090295881,
-0.0495108031,
0.004137293,
0.0340751,
-0.0037117649,
-0.0390004627,
0.0654690489,
-0.0444394834,
-0.0045859879,
-0.0115369009,
-0.024582684,
-0.0172602162,
0.0109600564,
0.041238144,
0.0098478459,
-0.0049033146,
-0.0172268189,
0.028621668,
-0.0070399195,
0.0103669884,
0.0461231098,
0.0373782441,
0.0418866463,
-0.0015731645,
0.0000025974,
-0.0237267874,
-0.002065667,
0.0586245246,
-0.0841469914,
0.0148825021,
0.0827711672,
-0.001555911,
-0.0301127695,
-0.0351519473,
0.0254592095,
0.0190305132,
0.0499266088,
-0.0714551434,
-0.0055383146,
-0.0784239247,
-0.0065715541,
0.0155018969,
0.0094030751,
-0.0080377441,
-0.0521931648,
0.028415205,
0.0535747036,
0.054731492,
0.0546386093,
-0.0093692467,
-0.0159934741,
0.0392121449,
-0.0098336665,
-0.0341723561,
0.0361761115,
0.0043965834,
0.0777064785,
-0.0300329756,
-0.0267409366,
-0.0063603241,
0.1492983997,
0.040904887,
0.0229384582,
0.0310818031,
0.002750746,
0.0427678339,
-0.0614507012,
0.0143717378,
-0.0425080582,
-0.0465072282,
0.0036459076,
0.0192490444,
0.0087404661,
-0.0321782306,
-0.0042454079,
0.0793311894,
0.0189446621,
-0.016210055,
-0.0619700812,
-0.0299081206,
0.0343192369,
-0.0184921622,
0.0265853871,
0.0248600263,
0.0168596134,
-0.0288937502,
0.0198801048,
-0.0017267033,
0.0612091161,
-0.0293987785,
0.0067284312,
-0.0025021948,
0.0287453067,
0.0298020914,
0.074127689,
-0.0289740451,
-0.0192976277,
-0.0152216377,
-0.0014332723,
0.0298730973,
-0.0372933298,
-0.0092235133,
-0.0238339622,
-0.0676411614,
0.048644565,
0.0342107005,
-0.0233301688,
0.0133553604,
-0.0210779328,
-0.0413761176,
-0.0008568947,
-0.0336262286,
-0.0319606662,
0.0050550704,
-0.0516955927,
-0.0003420588,
-0.0498942286,
-0.012282121,
0.0452958904,
-0.0539870523,
-0.0260211285,
-0.0020880948,
-0.0009797128,
0.0017478239,
-0.059100043,
0.0127838189,
0.0570928045,
0.0421262868,
-0.0075063831,
-0.012908387,
-0.0022994822,
-0.0227778703,
-0.0170012359,
-0.0862821341,
0.0518104993,
-0.0139201833,
0.0238274168,
-0.0047723195,
-0.0111316759,
0.028708782,
-0.0121598877,
-0.0335490033,
-0.0238028094,
-0.0051650009,
0.0081495177,
0.0044180173,
0.0173745938,
0.0288269296,
0.0169261452,
-0.0660188943,
0.0066039609,
-0.0225474983,
0.0302103162,
0.0170619506,
0.0148181869,
0.0797555,
0.0171135198,
-0.0033951378,
0.0234919768,
-0.0072569689,
0.016501762,
-0.0358440131,
-0.0448555648,
-0.0238221418,
-0.0036749304,
0.0462826677,
-0.0088594584,
0.0773654804,
0.0694145337,
0.0469711684,
-0.0038905365,
-0.00658313,
-0.0369105674,
0.0394923724,
0.0082113622,
-0.0307390746,
-0.060043674,
0.0483712032,
-0.0199131817,
-0.0087058898,
0.0510013178,
-0.0056618499,
0.0266422126,
-0.0757318586,
0.0297617763,
-0.0121076694,
0.0238972288,
0.016332943,
0.0171103794,
0.0195295569,
-0.0220974386,
-0.064189449,
-0.0267826505,
0.0044070911,
0.0045992341,
0.0274803415,
-0.0617553666,
-0.0454917848,
0.0331775881,
0.0466704592,
0.0037573487,
0.039039623,
-0.0531607419,
-0.0085352557,
-0.0201705843,
0.045218043,
0.012590888,
-0.0096991798,
0.0075786607,
-0.0361312069,
0.0154918991,
0.0479551852,
-0.0014385801,
-0.0157869104,
-0.0766248778,
0.0168680679,
-0.0543031208,
-0.0297773667,
0.0375310071,
-0.0035285642,
-0.003645648,
-0.0175988115,
-0.0112917097,
0.0547535941,
0.0196047667,
0.0324451178,
0.0538256206,
0.0705773011,
-0.038385272,
0.0174014959,
0.0203643516,
-0.0203764234,
0.0158172864,
0.0593137927,
0.0556990355,
0.0342392996,
0.0208134204,
0.0262932479,
0.0032417709,
-0.0018762772,
0.0178932995,
0.0505870096,
-0.0003975674,
-0.0212431066,
-0.0624603368,
0.0269360859,
-0.0292459521,
-0.0127717424,
-0.0609799959,
0.0088140452,
-0.0496358983,
-0.0036650728,
-0.0010185631,
0.0209099911,
-0.0021028912,
-0.0091201495,
0.0175295081,
-0.0060981303,
0.0181928277,
0.0263312981,
0.0246225409,
-0.0198671948,
-0.0346918926,
-0.0440128818,
0.0751500204,
0.0351664349,
0.0479486845,
0.0090172049,
0.008507709,
-0.0087175984,
-0.0511592999,
-0.0870365053,
0.0005801888,
-0.0177120063,
-0.027229147,
-0.0292340498,
0.0269356444,
0.0198830962,
0.0228625257,
-0.04244598,
-0.0597919561,
-0.0113427984,
-0.03928129,
0.0032734603,
0.0132131055,
-0.0195703059,
0.0535232499,
-0.0387443788,
-0.0306689721,
0.0581400618,
-0.0312087703,
-0.0252928939,
-0.0107995234,
0.0049608187,
-0.0605056211,
0.0291210301,
-0.0015614908,
-0.076756753,
-0.0277643166,
0.0326515734,
-0.0209630579,
-0.0023551323,
0.0100013847,
0.0138633968,
-0.0372237675,
0.02663875,
-0.0061899871,
0.0477603041,
0.0112473052,
-0.0161833055,
-0.0351540409,
-0.0503718406,
0.0020046176,
0.0116352122,
0.0186790712,
-0.0026862668,
-0.0507417656,
0.0146574629,
-0.0457720235,
-0.0002764573,
-0.0514231436,
0.0406692363,
0.0670567602,
-0.0233507268,
-0.0056869551,
-0.0274651181,
-0.0043603941,
-0.0119024925,
-0.0080301026,
-0.001310257,
0.0202488713,
0.0206787698,
0.0465032533,
-0.0620346069,
0.0156842675,
0.0434179679,
-0.0313850828,
0.0181839876,
-0.0505758487,
0.0400842503,
0.0788749903,
-0.0365875214,
-0.0204838421,
0.0023062888,
-0.0565189533,
-0.0351786204,
0.0259863194,
-0.0130550908,
-0.0252898689,
-0.0657479391,
0.0344301499,
-0.0192132667,
-0.0177058186,
0.0305004232,
-0.0300832279,
-0.0172778983,
0.0004543421,
0.0126422569,
-0.0372765064,
0.030155465,
-0.0596695356,
-0.0184102952,
0.0282098372,
0.0304394271,
-0.0417978279,
0.0203445964,
-0.0095407534,
-0.0710076243,
0.0742173642,
0.0240259878,
-0.0004384952,
-0.0269499626,
0.0748971999,
-0.0038278059,
-0.0357997492,
-0.0233842321,
0.0274944045,
-0.0035646711,
0.0308041591,
0.0529994331,
0.0425875373,
-0.0107661933,
0.0416438393,
-0.0304958615,
0.0200489387,
-0.0103207575,
0.0032902951,
0.0094207413,
0.0037902922,
-0.0201201364,
0.0047028051,
-0.0701531619,
-0.0159752425,
0.0048143552,
-0.067601867,
0.0900884122,
0.0238451306,
0.0490582548,
-0.0315246508,
0.0194822643,
0.0112545919,
0.0272180717,
-0.0167473108,
0.0176298972,
-0.027646929,
0.0191989094,
0.0274194852,
-0.0751313344,
-0.0425015986,
0.0207908377,
-0.0026981735,
0.0467064679,
0.0397166535,
0.0265368633,
-0.0427035727,
-0.0520026833,
0.0613943934,
0.0165817793,
0.0416235104,
0.0300539639,
0.0112540564,
-0.023015365,
-0.0524238199,
-0.0124961939,
-0.0072074193,
-0.0253869686,
-0.0182176884,
-0.0416522846,
-0.0129651483,
0.069404386,
0.0144648859,
-0.0010819851,
0.038265191,
0.0275693033,
-0.0507534482,
0.0697655231,
-0.0512518734,
0.0190784,
-0.015024595,
-0.0701290965,
0.0027828889,
-0.0054165754,
-0.0639765337,
-0.0373592153,
-0.0066570053,
-0.027380392,
0.0076048207,
-0.0518691093,
0.0071679447,
0.062684685,
0.0698491484,
0.0289810915,
0.034746699,
-0.0150270406,
0.0416969173,
-0.0066030929,
-0.0221411511,
0.023930436,
0.020164337,
-0.0556663834,
0.0170949828,
0.0202625338,
-0.0217298456,
0.0331302546,
-0.0013132539,
-0.0519459918,
0.015512811,
-0.0663461685,
-0.0031270122,
-0.0615175739,
-0.0261020567,
-0.0073987981,
0.0280272327,
-0.0118339555,
-0.0001470462,
0.002376074,
-0.0325256735,
0.0045738276,
0.0024965329,
-0.0738755912,
-0.0033041365,
-0.018526556,
-0.0014995805,
0.0068716593,
0.0028424934,
-0.030299671,
0.0269090552,
0.0116199274,
-0.0008991074,
0.0536531731,
-0.018160129,
0.0332502425,
0.0207465775,
0.0372488685,
-0.0674828589,
0.0483174697,
0.039553009,
-0.0085407104,
-0.0645725131,
-0.0223886948,
0.0296328049,
-0.025726337,
0.0088576684,
-0.0316091143,
-0.0493063554,
-0.0264876131,
-0.0297536105,
0.0071815508,
0.0406556912,
-0.0307686329,
0.006116637,
-0.0761535093,
-0.0081462758,
0.0140901627,
-0.0062114154,
-0.0457194187,
0.0127335126,
-0.0158647653,
-0.0345643498,
-0.0009430826,
0.0756666511,
0.0330607221,
-0.0497166961,
-0.0222198199,
-0.014603843,
-0.0134743256,
0.0058731805,
-0.0371075645,
0.0285688974,
-0.0517942868,
-0.0749351904,
-0.0452233963,
-0.0157347377,
0.0137261972,
0.0400895849,
-0.009956711,
-0.0222713184,
-0.0386399925,
-0.0289161764,
-0.0390391313,
-0.0167350434,
0.028195871,
-0.0341447294,
-0.0130097875,
0.0095346821,
-6.876942438e-33,
-0.0645072982,
0.0216487981,
0.0623706132,
-0.0010605884,
-0.0597946756,
-0.0499977283,
-0.0435114689,
-0.0273968913,
0.0030965216,
-0.0125131533,
0.0660619885,
0.0083606569,
0.0274386015,
-0.0161218159,
-0.0101400102,
0.0095306225,
0.0039071059,
-0.0488126166,
0.0461784601,
-0.0389835238,
-0.0360500105,
-0.0285989922,
-0.0078642946,
0.0662870556,
0.0623639897,
-0.0367201902,
-0.0342865624,
0.0021547999,
-0.003718826,
0.0578955896,
0.0065011373,
-0.0218459591,
0.0016204899,
-0.0181981344,
0.0309233963,
0.0478329137,
-0.0457463153,
-0.0115614403,
0.0231324341,
-0.0036503877,
-0.0069212387,
-0.0781399012,
0.0179319959,
0.0628042221,
-0.0594858192,
-0.0082786949,
0.0388252586,
-0.0080534723,
0.0038056721,
0.0657274276,
-0.0289263371,
0.0213192943,
-0.0288702548,
0.0483472496,
-0.0203545988,
0.0445158109,
-0.0416974388,
-0.042682685,
-0.0429821424,
0.0352964029,
0.0642547086,
-0.0238120314,
0.0162072778,
0.0155405393,
0.0950578526,
-0.0181355402,
0.0231205225,
0.0458355471,
-0.0843993425,
-0.0136806183,
0.0322136655,
-0.0078669908,
-0.0086101349,
0.0512311533,
-0.0015345516,
0.010944793,
-0.0422413275,
0.0228784904,
0.0483561531,
-0.0010012734,
0.0013046744,
0.0093015395,
-0.0020476314,
0.0211174283,
-0.0281485729,
-0.0397345126,
-0.0044100522,
-0.0584769547,
-0.0077916733,
-0.0540230311,
-0.0156536605,
-0.016993219,
0.0431023166,
0.0038043815,
-0.0136988396,
-0.0795520991,
0.0519959219,
0.003831292,
0.0168436728,
0.0164553318,
-0.0155699998,
-0.0212178808,
-0.0250791162,
0.0361119173,
0.0475659259,
0.0559599549,
-0.0385165736,
-0.0029060612,
-0.005908906,
0.0163014829,
0.015970666,
-0.0048219282,
0.0792959854,
-0.0626123175,
0.036150232,
-0.0119729256,
0.0268854499,
-0.0011020284,
0.0520794727,
0.0172231812,
0.0367445312,
0.0659093782,
-0.0265837293,
-0.0125911981,
0.0499186516,
0.0113328388,
-0.0156255346,
-0.011970791,
0.0073853522,
0.0034120625,
0.0038706979,
-0.0296531264,
3.228e-7,
0.0048377654,
0.0321635976,
0.0158982556,
-0.0071826815,
0.0783403739,
-0.0101293763,
-0.0326482616,
-0.0081480108,
0.0246021766,
-0.0541377105,
0.0386890471,
0.0428611599,
0.0143109821,
-0.0487611331,
-0.0023667426,
0.0235174727,
-0.0028913205,
0.0491547473,
-0.0028231086,
-0.0154361324,
-0.0549869016,
-0.0384728126,
0.0506958999,
0.0520570651,
-0.0506677292,
0.0349934138,
0.0194207896,
-0.0155585632,
-0.0294760969,
0.0580384657,
-0.069347553,
-0.0135951554,
0.0026060743,
0.014539049,
0.0148731684,
-0.0404331125,
-0.0118718939,
0.0647616684,
-0.0014342443,
0.0954678655,
0.0360104591,
-0.0310853925,
0.0203756485,
-0.0173333883,
0.0293836556,
0.0076180701,
-0.0429597609,
-0.0409894139,
-0.0840805471,
0.0128643857,
0.0255306419,
-0.0191240255,
-0.0426007025,
-0.0150661357,
0.0059819217,
0.0181579497,
0.009827205,
0.0764888972,
-0.0004207683,
0.0190208703,
-0.0450474769,
-0.0811168328,
-0.0164257865,
0.0443650633,
0.025109563,
-0.0156402383,
0.0159485135,
3.429772699e-34,
0.0578849353,
0.0247101542,
-0.0086369384,
-0.0285885278,
0.0082788002,
-0.0002579162,
-0.0001188051,
0.0171129052,
0.0297510717,
-0.0164567679,
-0.016172098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13067v1 | Causal Parrots: Large Language Models May Talk Causality But Are Not Causal | 2023-08-24T20:23:13 | 2023-08-24T20:23:13 | Matej Zečević, Moritz Willig, Devendra Singh Dhami, Kristian Kersting | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Some argue scale is all what is needed to achieve AI, covering even causal
models. We make it clear that large language models (LLMs) cannot be causal and
give reason onto why sometimes we might feel otherwise. To this end, we define
and exemplify a new subgroup of Structural Causal Model (SCM) that we call meta
SCM which encode causal facts about other SCM within their variables. We
conjecture that in the cases where LLM succeed in doing causal inference,
underlying was a respective meta SCM that exposed correlations between causal
facts in natural language on whose data the LLM was ultimately trained. If our
hypothesis holds true, then this would imply that LLMs are like parrots in that
they simply recite the causal knowledge embedded in the data. Our empirical
analysis provides favoring evidence that current LLMs are even weak `causal
parrots.' | [
0.0141778924,
0.0736217722,
-0.0432401821,
0.0054371902,
-0.0261364989,
0.0268891156,
0.0143520059,
0.0096140979,
-0.0013833471,
-0.0646478757,
0.0204016455,
0.0444371775,
0.0217915196,
0.0433871374,
0.044844348,
-0.0187428538,
0.0291034486,
-0.03565358,
0.0154802082,
-0.0150242001,
-0.0451544933,
-0.033205092,
0.0121699972,
0.0343028419,
-0.0095511666,
0.0367050618,
-0.0051565315,
-0.0190766361,
-0.0265125614,
-0.0061516822,
-0.0370248444,
-0.0013685392,
0.0207681116,
0.0458005965,
0.0000018495,
-0.0468557365,
0.0421899892,
-0.0002011482,
-0.0339420028,
0.0045418171,
-0.0333689712,
-0.0330408104,
0.0316921137,
0.0029606533,
-0.021561062,
-0.026798619,
0.0439460129,
0.0388859399,
0.0029801012,
0.0982604474,
-0.002122103,
-0.093437627,
0.0556889698,
-0.0312671736,
0.0530821681,
-0.0020748503,
0.0474020764,
0.0151912477,
-0.0169335827,
0.0188952684,
-0.0428900979,
0.0146439169,
0.0386696458,
0.0114041409,
0.0109325908,
0.0233078226,
0.0007569093,
-0.0258318149,
0.0307041612,
0.0474212468,
0.0596552081,
-0.0491747335,
0.0193385836,
-0.001760716,
0.0247373413,
0.0577569753,
-0.0496918634,
0.055023808,
0.0118869422,
0.0235097054,
0.0705337003,
0.0018699679,
0.0804819018,
0.0256423,
-0.0543877222,
0.0677685738,
0.0104428595,
-0.0317490846,
-0.0363546535,
0.0339970067,
0.0288280342,
-0.0449126028,
-0.0526519157,
0.0143425167,
-0.0451709963,
0.0501468815,
-0.0075947815,
0.0153863532,
0.0067302291,
-0.0614959449,
0.0189972576,
0.0251978002,
-0.0001139882,
0.0456259511,
-0.0564549938,
0.0553468242,
-0.0608350262,
0.0429628007,
0.0010495465,
0.0127504673,
-0.0535132624,
-0.0279472135,
0.0140316449,
0.0340280943,
0.0170828812,
-0.0040679788,
-0.0299338792,
0.0306445956,
-0.0228644796,
0.0277099703,
-0.0193222854,
-0.0157558993,
0.0031618637,
-0.0098585682,
-0.0309219453,
0.0044601988,
-0.0391537324,
0.0769544989,
-0.0352352671,
-0.0346381813,
0.0092209084,
0.028486535,
0.0093827378,
-0.0198155902,
0.0012609124,
0.1010964811,
0.0382219888,
-0.0191610847,
-0.038166184,
-0.0314937755,
0.0034612217,
-0.0516104922,
-0.0018875032,
-0.0311925765,
-0.0014106286,
0.036455065,
0.0132135274,
-0.0035938213,
0.0169421434,
-0.0071406099,
-0.0917191207,
0.0507948436,
0.0139368186,
0.0267559793,
-0.01471454,
-0.0203093048,
0.0371693224,
0.0561885238,
0.0484735928,
0.0046282103,
0.0063399146,
-0.0190912001,
0.0032016023,
0.0195335802,
0.034407258,
0.0149139771,
-0.0507580936,
-0.0467190742,
0.0406261049,
-0.0099515794,
-0.0208280254,
0.0386237837,
0.0055815927,
0.0207561292,
0.0561280884,
-0.0016539838,
-0.0274443552,
0.0136126177,
0.075385958,
-0.0824482888,
-0.0035399594,
0.0482679568,
-0.0780749395,
-0.0063956669,
-0.0577894524,
-0.0009052805,
0.018851554,
-0.0403259732,
-0.0293329488,
-0.0563392229,
-0.0201884247,
-0.0176714174,
-0.0132656824,
0.0111761568,
0.0789703801,
0.0252428818,
0.0056433389,
-0.0020930944,
0.0151136303,
-0.01246903,
0.0139493393,
-0.03812626,
0.0184351355,
0.0231479239,
0.0505513512,
-0.0279462654,
0.0137880025,
0.0036209282,
0.0236979257,
0.0267028939,
0.0275426768,
-0.0071108895,
-0.0207602233,
-0.0114899566,
-0.0008256503,
-0.009845362,
0.0509414896,
0.0077601299,
-0.0106519386,
-0.0043530888,
-0.0126601011,
-0.0031192927,
-0.0317178257,
0.0508778915,
-0.0270054862,
-0.0325945504,
-0.0194406435,
0.0003223204,
0.0520428978,
0.0093400078,
-0.0491829067,
0.0236715823,
0.0263038296,
-0.046576675,
-0.0688228831,
0.0560755134,
-0.0237100367,
-0.0101485429,
-0.0033115004,
-0.0413341559,
0.0008083789,
0.0291104317,
-0.026359817,
-0.0574747659,
0.0970863402,
-0.0136335455,
0.0598134287,
0.0199839901,
0.0321654454,
-0.0078232484,
-0.0129270516,
-0.0113385757,
0.0708627328,
0.0089040585,
0.0154941846,
-0.0188994706,
0.014986285,
0.0140228057,
-0.018952705,
0.000040137,
0.0145507436,
-0.0082295993,
-0.0074924766,
0.0590591431,
-0.0564106591,
-0.0199660026,
-0.0247116908,
-0.0475532524,
-0.0245192926,
-0.0137978876,
-0.0090966178,
0.0007790845,
0.0031258631,
0.0150115257,
-0.0360770412,
-0.0181310978,
0.0088906316,
0.0172822159,
0.0344734639,
0.0284535158,
-0.0131495334,
-0.0136503465,
-0.0503053628,
0.0025744676,
-0.0548388399,
0.0367562138,
0.0734411627,
-0.0352562331,
-0.0355798826,
0.0281029157,
-0.0063197846,
0.0082511343,
-0.035593342,
-0.0367231257,
0.0033208448,
-0.0426054448,
-0.0003576388,
0.093226932,
-0.0163035318,
0.0078885052,
0.0540470406,
0.0118673602,
-0.0476013198,
-0.0183164142,
-0.0524326116,
-0.0129483733,
-0.0585489906,
-0.0492267013,
0.0021511542,
0.0842874274,
0.0076605571,
-0.0066404035,
-0.0416740887,
0.0283811744,
-0.0040689288,
-0.0286852363,
-0.0314307213,
-0.0447666086,
-0.0198131744,
0.0364986546,
-0.0185934287,
-0.0962689966,
0.0219158567,
0.012542096,
0.0302593522,
0.0254678447,
-0.0065111453,
-0.0622800961,
0.0792520493,
0.0566943996,
-0.0049291677,
0.0179266408,
-0.0092323991,
-0.04057464,
-0.0260548443,
0.0276200548,
0.0345613025,
-0.0061422335,
-0.0778231546,
0.060653206,
0.0092526181,
-0.0650432855,
-0.051658541,
-0.0244063102,
-0.056725245,
-0.0094517665,
0.0060540936,
-0.0279448405,
-0.0421299934,
-0.0344194248,
0.0393929891,
0.0127330776,
-0.0038604615,
0.0017498048,
-0.0238539744,
-0.0241338648,
0.0258944761,
-0.046624627,
0.0084159486,
-0.0516694635,
0.0158594139,
-0.0131421778,
0.0020832312,
0.0272380281,
-0.0293333549,
0.007028942,
-0.0227557328,
0.0028842897,
-0.0415534973,
0.0108570736,
-0.0042524296,
-0.0336445868,
0.0040584281,
0.1037747115,
0.0233235359,
-0.0007225338,
0.0188246686,
0.0218004677,
-0.0140010901,
0.0402230918,
-0.0153414914,
-0.0743391514,
-0.0192105472,
0.0210861135,
-0.0350949503,
-0.0239361841,
-0.0460454039,
0.0074753105,
-0.0977807492,
0.0092441272,
0.0003233434,
-0.033451058,
-0.0078237401,
-0.0436508469,
-0.015009555,
-0.0534037612,
-0.05789949,
-0.0258791503,
-0.0147062633,
0.0088677462,
0.0006181533,
-0.007359134,
-0.0190441087,
-0.0247835387,
-0.0235804096,
0.0611057281,
0.0539980903,
0.0164797492,
-0.0551052243,
0.0031683571,
0.0476553328,
0.0309326481,
0.0169296246,
0.0035490312,
0.0450582057,
0.0141799944,
-0.0171871204,
-0.012531017,
0.0302912649,
-0.0332416371,
0.007078554,
0.0329406634,
0.0535998791,
-0.0291027855,
-0.0525444187,
0.0066689537,
-0.0140232826,
-0.0461394638,
0.0705450997,
0.0103987427,
-0.0130292485,
-0.0481085069,
-0.0240769982,
-0.0506981052,
0.0116376318,
-0.0554629751,
-0.0081294635,
0.0336450636,
-0.0194395259,
-0.0842091516,
-0.0524454005,
-0.0020963389,
0.0025378752,
0.0254867412,
0.0349188223,
0.0005868924,
-0.0292721651,
-0.0086992113,
0.0023177904,
-0.0446153022,
-0.0009994925,
-0.0387514681,
-0.0040162015,
0.0161735993,
-0.0368090272,
-0.0010765718,
-0.0347524174,
-0.0694953725,
-0.0805530399,
0.019487774,
0.0725039393,
0.0294408686,
0.0425565466,
-0.0098670991,
-0.0602608398,
0.0365224443,
0.0115643414,
-0.0340323895,
0.0408820026,
0.046032656,
-0.0228545908,
0.0052285688,
0.0579611063,
-0.0438342355,
0.0236462075,
-0.0001423597,
0.0102780238,
-0.0199253876,
0.027975874,
0.0285286196,
0.0078208968,
0.0360037275,
-0.0100298161,
0.0063017071,
-0.0095867338,
0.0160847101,
-0.0293335151,
-0.0253067333,
-0.0138520105,
0.0427302085,
0.0297773331,
0.0539528765,
-0.0007547223,
-0.0565224886,
-0.0187503975,
0.0103701875,
0.0153601849,
0.0354913287,
-0.0073760743,
0.0214775782,
0.0315651111,
0.0243148413,
0.010269925,
0.0610897727,
0.0054711988,
0.0505173579,
0.015813211,
0.0364202783,
0.0372478403,
0.0321066454,
-0.0477844216,
-0.0500014201,
-0.1121602952,
-0.0497183762,
0.0776719525,
0.0143784732,
0.0626665279,
-0.0059820497,
0.0213758349,
-0.0503314771,
-0.0032508827,
-0.0030730281,
0.0378875136,
0.0387352146,
-0.0061326451,
0.0176187046,
0.0067522544,
-0.0536436439,
0.0401392318,
0.0751178563,
0.0349072404,
0.0965867043,
-0.0245122202,
0.0138697624,
-0.0024625976,
-0.0513018072,
-0.0011393351,
-0.0027742095,
-0.0191635303,
0.0284365192,
-0.0612896346,
-0.079431124,
-0.0249386597,
-0.0080640195,
0.0353987627,
-0.0250121895,
-0.0208333153,
0.0046648369,
-0.0029052568,
0.002607726,
-0.0366524607,
0.0176616088,
-0.0357855484,
-0.0081996005,
-0.0027141673,
-6.210272572e-33,
-0.028770728,
-0.0200846698,
0.0196798593,
0.017226059,
0.0510539301,
0.0250375718,
-0.0384996831,
0.0139174415,
-0.0459635258,
0.0402132794,
0.0008445893,
0.030322073,
0.0133232316,
0.0128201386,
0.0529868565,
-0.0177211147,
0.0341074131,
-0.0043834494,
-0.0078022107,
-0.0009451053,
0.0360149816,
0.0029059609,
0.022634197,
-0.078461282,
0.0484278277,
0.0001517921,
-0.0134408958,
0.0208540559,
-0.0584233589,
0.028018903,
-0.003144956,
0.0050353548,
0.0412093662,
-0.0287906975,
-0.0032100831,
0.0287056565,
-0.0458994098,
-0.0469958261,
0.0748352855,
0.007823688,
-0.0359923728,
-0.0326379724,
0.0219213814,
-0.0292427354,
-0.0228071976,
0.0308846161,
0.0380092375,
-0.032899484,
-0.0120953089,
-0.0132296355,
-0.0750055611,
0.0176269487,
-0.0201373659,
0.0174828172,
-0.0114981476,
0.0041390616,
-0.0087862378,
0.0235017296,
0.0245789643,
0.0311577152,
0.0104924329,
-0.0016219546,
0.0202735234,
0.0432635956,
0.0362058058,
0.0694016218,
0.0425093882,
0.0309982169,
-0.0454578251,
-0.0002191703,
0.0182626974,
0.039629627,
0.0519837514,
0.0351606682,
0.0015858969,
0.0158784781,
-0.0817228779,
-0.0299945436,
0.0321308561,
0.0165764187,
0.0132412342,
-0.0121524772,
-0.0495046116,
-0.0386684239,
-0.0724589229,
-0.0209836364,
-0.0385473035,
-0.0030586554,
0.012760045,
0.0382500105,
0.0220871586,
-0.0428476594,
0.037962582,
-0.0609919503,
0.000279961,
0.0474454165,
-0.0153197292,
-0.0001216933,
-0.0147732133,
-0.0243082196,
-0.0705676973,
-0.0184578188,
-0.0043639373,
0.0337943919,
0.0461762361,
0.0164334141,
0.0473283008,
0.004839221,
-0.0345446318,
-0.0184994414,
-0.0227074306,
-0.0598047078,
0.04254454,
-0.0449362695,
0.077981405,
0.0343296677,
-0.005560481,
0.04793901,
0.0265819263,
0.0192827601,
-0.0165667199,
-0.020257799,
-0.0401098281,
0.021204235,
-0.048236493,
-0.0288264249,
-0.0416498967,
0.0324252993,
0.0353497006,
-0.0588851832,
-0.0067662601,
-0.0088698212,
2.554e-7,
0.0292781834,
0.0623314865,
0.0099616451,
0.0357534401,
0.0443726778,
0.0339768529,
-0.0047445279,
0.0132359313,
-0.0103500197,
0.02022117,
0.0314804278,
0.0190684889,
0.0565556251,
-0.0260869283,
-0.0528330319,
0.0342025757,
-0.060402099,
-0.0437718593,
-0.0264043938,
0.0044395016,
0.0215986483,
0.0908650979,
0.0469000302,
0.0165020339,
0.0010781517,
-0.0549515486,
0.0613761172,
-0.0375269614,
-0.0008263142,
-0.0188875031,
-0.052567482,
0.0263884738,
-0.0500562936,
0.0312397499,
0.0022231254,
0.0093571832,
-0.0395212844,
0.0445870347,
0.0037025299,
0.0461902618,
-0.0435303263,
-0.0435504429,
0.0041331579,
-0.0344933458,
0.0840198398,
-0.0438276641,
-0.0784609988,
0.0124912746,
0.018427508,
0.0191809926,
0.0090827029,
0.0267647021,
-0.0055299075,
-0.0072398833,
-0.0226270296,
0.0071161594,
0.009006015,
-0.0793463811,
-0.0343739875,
0.0038564133,
-0.016414687,
-0.066921249,
-0.0121654198,
0.0042214403,
0.0223401021,
-0.0370674022,
0.0011477682,
2.206199022e-34,
0.0304098558,
-0.0116772018,
0.0176121965,
-0.0221996829,
0.0269202441,
-0.021212114,
-0.0449566692,
0.03682556,
0.0672428906,
-0.101743862,
-0.0005801742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13056v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13056v2 | Lexical Diversity in Kinship Across Languages and Dialects | 2023-08-24T19:49:30 | 2023-10-26T12:54:30 | Hadi Khalilia, Gábor Bella, Abed Alhakim Freihat, Shandy Darma, Fausto Giunchiglia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Languages are known to describe the world in diverse ways. Across lexicons,
diversity is pervasive, appearing through phenomena such as lexical gaps and
untranslatability. However, in computational resources, such as multilingual
lexical databases, diversity is hardly ever represented. In this paper, we
introduce a method to enrich computational lexicons with content relating to
linguistic diversity. The method is verified through two large-scale case
studies on kinship terminology, a domain known to be diverse across languages
and cultures: one case study deals with seven Arabic dialects, while the other
one with three Indonesian languages. Our results, made available as browseable
and downloadable computational resources, extend prior linguistics research on
kinship terminology, and provide insight into the extent of diversity even
within linguistically and culturally close communities. | [
0.036075782,
0.0609003007,
-0.0555530302,
0.0291981623,
-0.0527989827,
0.0175840799,
-0.0003003794,
0.0222675707,
-0.0119765429,
-0.0014597245,
-0.0102678407,
-0.1126543209,
0.0785844848,
-0.0229992419,
0.0212493241,
-0.0829556137,
0.0220376682,
-0.0106368633,
0.0016534987,
-0.0185432211,
-0.0029476881,
0.0438958406,
0.0279130414,
0.0167347137,
-0.016292192,
0.0055309953,
0.0133469738,
-0.0171142276,
0.0269518327,
0.0091054058,
0.0065158042,
0.0344409868,
-0.0532439537,
0.0219606552,
0.0000019218,
-0.0649321154,
-0.0050596716,
-0.0260721333,
-0.0005000248,
-0.0060501895,
0.0647067353,
0.0055237375,
0.0126136569,
-0.0281946342,
0.0044549988,
0.0003123178,
0.0964472592,
-0.0532441363,
-0.0214668997,
-0.01643751,
0.008933112,
-0.0675682575,
-0.0081645837,
-0.0031851034,
0.0142107038,
0.031728588,
0.0055285115,
-0.0135681164,
0.0152531425,
-0.0638821572,
-0.0578129664,
0.0370323546,
-0.0263254605,
0.0089748399,
0.0007991,
0.0090002697,
-0.0287675876,
-0.0386226103,
0.0596026704,
-0.0185942557,
0.0474695042,
-0.017494861,
0.000788592,
0.0271304119,
-0.0275077205,
0.0655397102,
0.0032258653,
0.0364883319,
-0.0541402064,
-0.0001925794,
0.0439439751,
0.0016846951,
-0.0183709431,
0.0015396079,
-0.0413222536,
0.0689693019,
0.0384065285,
-0.0215619151,
-0.0274868868,
-0.0246985145,
0.0029566339,
-0.0199785959,
0.0078652687,
-0.024050083,
-0.0081151119,
0.0545303524,
0.0489931405,
-0.0167586412,
0.0491335951,
-0.0485981256,
0.0200429652,
-0.0061293119,
-0.0338261351,
0.0022027784,
0.0231206622,
-0.0260789003,
0.0379025899,
-0.0384957753,
-0.0242558438,
-0.0330951624,
-0.0858929753,
-0.0225404836,
0.0109039992,
-0.0167611316,
-0.0321075842,
0.0484546535,
-0.0361032672,
0.0163878761,
-0.03129806,
-0.0308537427,
0.0258790422,
-0.0138215413,
-0.0447245315,
-0.0266673639,
-0.07624273,
-0.0253219176,
-0.077276282,
0.0037683269,
-0.0381955244,
-0.1034192592,
0.0388184935,
-0.0040890551,
-0.0015265376,
0.0073850984,
0.0020515251,
-0.0557697751,
0.0253697895,
-0.0305675585,
0.0067675821,
0.0168553218,
-0.067020677,
-0.0012534647,
-0.0190333296,
-0.0708026811,
0.0741911456,
0.0180565007,
0.0285494234,
-0.0461409986,
-0.0167891011,
-0.0227792021,
-0.0377350673,
0.015589973,
-0.0051972773,
0.023895232,
0.0555604436,
-0.0005193897,
0.0279259514,
0.0368215702,
-0.0057314737,
-0.0902601406,
0.0954690948,
0.0128126154,
-0.040356271,
-0.0296006929,
-0.0007623689,
0.003912237,
-0.045589745,
-0.0066105244,
0.0122807771,
0.0047690198,
-0.0183194596,
0.0657866821,
0.0016095849,
-0.038848538,
0.0093876729,
0.1282088459,
-0.0102164857,
0.0727693588,
-0.015956156,
0.0359794311,
-0.0187434647,
-0.0027080858,
0.0286132134,
-0.042005714,
0.0712247491,
-0.0196443014,
0.0413678624,
0.0678995475,
0.0105141709,
-0.007510066,
-0.0283332132,
0.0163657311,
0.0305058695,
-0.024469113,
0.0473643355,
-0.0221495703,
0.0502111688,
0.0333015658,
0.0841798335,
-0.0202466175,
-0.0037495836,
0.0051960689,
-0.0032723614,
0.0517707691,
-0.0263995547,
0.0129064685,
0.0079583852,
0.0380995497,
0.0222193915,
-0.0024127588,
-0.0284221899,
-0.0096364291,
0.0364212729,
-0.0440511145,
0.0029556758,
0.0490420461,
0.010657764,
0.062209405,
0.0181128457,
0.0210611224,
0.0201311205,
0.0008329552,
-0.0140194092,
-0.0000415867,
-0.0630512908,
0.0509340502,
0.0135437259,
-0.0080901394,
0.0241194088,
0.0396254547,
-0.018586617,
0.0053432854,
0.0056272382,
-0.02722569,
0.0171762314,
0.047708746,
-0.01529497,
0.0500866733,
0.0316849649,
-0.0884556472,
0.0216281377,
-0.0289852265,
0.0320352986,
-0.020435052,
0.0632213876,
-0.0107269445,
0.0169952922,
-0.0190652665,
0.0393638723,
-0.0594867431,
0.0187114924,
-0.00438033,
0.0588328727,
-0.0021447532,
0.0144697679,
-0.0580905415,
-0.0407449752,
0.026046684,
0.0185581651,
0.0174671765,
-0.006824282,
0.0132668726,
-0.0251742303,
0.0109090218,
-0.0151718846,
-0.0280362982,
-0.0178942643,
-0.1117549017,
-0.0104041034,
0.0103051346,
0.0577610545,
-0.0508001633,
0.0358979329,
-0.0254134089,
0.0135018658,
0.0200054273,
-0.0008599597,
0.0096858302,
0.0526524857,
-0.0107047958,
-0.0150270872,
-0.0013562395,
0.0368533432,
-0.0344323441,
0.0425815582,
0.0475233607,
-0.01907189,
-0.0213103928,
0.0408888683,
-0.0606568977,
-0.1132746786,
-0.0097734947,
-0.0174036808,
0.0199116766,
-0.014263479,
0.01410056,
-0.0125084519,
-0.0478984043,
-0.0248592999,
-0.0465676859,
0.0217494573,
-0.0343666635,
-0.007794199,
-0.0226722397,
0.0062161325,
0.0506036356,
0.0141224498,
-0.0567404218,
-0.0429622419,
0.0125430739,
0.0016284317,
-0.0345831364,
-0.0203199014,
-0.0114116268,
-0.0500591137,
0.0051066838,
0.0107115321,
-0.0494093262,
-0.0376395173,
0.0734156594,
-0.0224140547,
-0.0322868675,
0.0184720121,
0.0292920191,
0.0276483074,
0.0039201551,
-0.0332391262,
-0.0333365984,
0.073290363,
-0.0499473922,
-0.00274322,
-0.0099061374,
-0.0144647285,
-0.0300516542,
0.0068055969,
0.062610656,
-0.0079571661,
0.0611437745,
-0.0536644906,
-0.0087113697,
-0.006407809,
-0.0427708402,
0.0034012655,
0.0555374213,
-0.006191507,
-0.0120064942,
0.1072873995,
-0.0026722383,
0.0875205174,
0.0139569659,
-0.0194828063,
-0.0461604111,
-0.0097599151,
0.0202646591,
0.0121159879,
0.0256375093,
-0.0169538986,
0.0015848406,
0.0146081159,
0.0333053134,
-0.0319220312,
-0.0046321661,
-0.0190638248,
-0.0347112045,
0.0495327115,
0.018157851,
0.0285982136,
-0.0237100814,
-0.0553113073,
-0.0393312648,
-0.0169526618,
-0.0019374908,
0.0133680534,
0.0422199182,
0.0512540005,
-0.012678341,
0.0276209358,
-0.0910494998,
0.0294201709,
0.0448930562,
-0.0112730581,
-0.0691028982,
0.082552813,
0.0130270598,
-0.010136527,
-0.0119778011,
-0.0349205546,
0.0060110926,
-0.088391766,
-0.0533670224,
0.013633823,
-0.0338223055,
-0.056576997,
-0.004821057,
-0.0083336113,
0.020802971,
-0.0251183994,
0.0182176381,
0.0017889319,
0.0024829898,
0.0401407927,
0.0104696592,
-0.048542697,
0.0199972354,
-0.0518998019,
-0.0020405233,
-0.017277034,
0.0373806395,
-0.0434205271,
-0.0326060206,
-0.0081114499,
-0.0371920578,
-0.0421664789,
-0.0171406958,
-0.0388523713,
0.0488994494,
0.0017185765,
-0.0310257282,
-0.059828084,
-0.0094055794,
0.007822955,
0.0232652202,
0.0345172435,
0.0235242303,
-0.0016687455,
0.0165256485,
-0.0085217943,
0.0030001232,
0.0169185456,
-0.0016414729,
-0.0173460003,
0.014475625,
0.0093857525,
-0.0147002125,
0.031129187,
-0.0290566012,
0.038307704,
-0.0285565816,
-0.0647744834,
-0.0555879921,
-0.0749034807,
-0.0112537211,
0.0208730269,
0.0445041768,
-0.0011627011,
0.00026025,
0.0176332723,
-0.0533641204,
-0.0002401391,
-0.0039738398,
-0.0160219017,
0.0150552988,
-0.0185410772,
0.0041186064,
-0.0112633519,
0.0117023541,
-0.0230450388,
-0.007963364,
-0.0224178303,
0.0304042418,
-0.0115397163,
0.0168575123,
0.0394572876,
0.0160109885,
-0.0525367185,
0.0185084268,
0.0423412547,
0.0100275679,
0.0178934168,
0.0065414915,
-0.0363039896,
-0.0119525744,
0.0531640016,
0.0040065674,
0.0188976545,
-0.0232954398,
0.0012246683,
-0.0244281758,
-0.0704511553,
0.0092597064,
-0.0612106435,
0.0120553765,
-0.1078043878,
-0.0481806956,
-0.0506779738,
-0.0305301193,
-0.012490686,
-0.0070731007,
0.0154365553,
-0.0083164824,
0.026382653,
-0.0200278834,
-0.0163020343,
-0.0163085684,
0.0183479264,
0.0229262821,
-0.0013929459,
0.0297864731,
-0.0020780168,
0.0629932061,
-0.0108118206,
0.0479479097,
0.0157186929,
-0.0060464805,
-0.0704181269,
0.0471891239,
-0.0437045619,
-0.0114955315,
-0.0073515405,
-0.0241676457,
0.0151099972,
0.0081174625,
0.0352645442,
-0.0032375671,
-0.0075785639,
0.0036111213,
0.0236652214,
-0.0193544049,
0.0030708797,
-0.009596834,
-0.0122582102,
-0.023266213,
-0.0167739559,
0.0075230892,
-0.0321887247,
-0.0019491789,
0.0175009929,
0.0015838024,
0.0719829872,
0.0324925706,
-0.045792181,
0.0118574919,
0.0400784761,
-0.0351902507,
0.0246384162,
-0.0337795392,
0.0133122653,
-0.0020090144,
-0.0024737851,
0.0133007439,
-0.1164745763,
-0.0494522154,
0.0574848913,
0.0020161325,
0.0408549756,
0.0236026514,
0.0411104336,
0.0638245046,
0.0354950689,
0.0129575133,
-0.0387193523,
0.0198177937,
-0.0411677621,
0.0012106419,
0.0464114398,
-5.985389482e-33,
-0.0216348283,
-0.0403105654,
-0.0079686008,
-0.0701889843,
0.0111243427,
-0.0168295912,
0.0116149411,
0.0410516821,
-0.0385129414,
0.0072647813,
-0.034601856,
0.0236900505,
0.0158445537,
0.0045030066,
0.0949717835,
0.0319429189,
-0.0212475099,
0.0095409583,
0.0373742767,
-0.0132125625,
0.0770415962,
-0.0343614109,
0.0717515796,
-0.0291395523,
0.0679495856,
-0.010821281,
-0.0100608803,
0.0190636069,
0.025658872,
0.0212147105,
-0.0383334905,
0.0466338471,
0.0215586796,
0.0179601591,
0.0121159274,
-0.0441413298,
-0.0449132398,
-0.0555437617,
0.0320445858,
-0.0218766928,
0.027475372,
-0.0418191925,
0.0156837534,
0.0288014021,
-0.0340534374,
0.0274915304,
0.0072560059,
-0.0122887567,
-0.0516328029,
-0.0003667513,
-0.0365480445,
0.0483671464,
-0.019348897,
0.0202043932,
0.0242138691,
0.0377914235,
-0.0277294181,
-0.0595025197,
-0.031707149,
0.0312789157,
0.0299403369,
0.0416342691,
0.048370488,
0.0245594587,
-0.0043054353,
-0.0063327653,
0.0277739801,
0.0039572241,
0.0662719533,
0.0335222594,
0.0202595722,
0.0073296842,
-0.0514250323,
0.0864451453,
-0.0011316711,
-0.0477415286,
0.0284760017,
-0.0253533777,
-0.0167950299,
-0.0168366786,
-0.0196903311,
0.0126959374,
-0.045694299,
-0.0414206833,
0.0056060944,
-0.0451054387,
0.0118874684,
-0.0141046764,
0.0006646785,
-0.0082677295,
-0.0058198343,
0.0859476998,
0.0164143536,
-0.0134296026,
-0.0302573852,
-0.0177126452,
0.005873051,
-0.0188720971,
0.0177606065,
0.0242918506,
0.0288877245,
-0.035608381,
-0.0147519289,
0.0238112248,
0.0059723048,
0.0031430817,
0.0000730308,
-0.0204734951,
-0.0494719818,
-0.0007297563,
-0.0200970229,
-0.0066734669,
-0.0295588914,
0.0015584781,
0.0273412522,
0.0227597971,
0.0180468876,
-0.0051199985,
0.1200833097,
-0.0090186642,
-0.0061699469,
0.0118304295,
-0.0624058731,
-0.0393178202,
-0.0003270528,
0.0429279394,
-0.0379183479,
0.00138759,
0.0523383133,
0.0328265131,
-0.0102288378,
-0.0159076918,
2.791e-7,
0.0291129891,
0.0666327104,
0.0345313028,
-0.011294066,
0.0361445285,
-0.0396256521,
0.0245647356,
-0.0008417756,
-0.0442321934,
-0.0186824929,
0.0334502608,
0.0040537016,
0.0663165301,
0.0549219809,
-0.0466316566,
0.0328180827,
-0.065108344,
-0.0288231578,
-0.0591175929,
0.0104860421,
0.0023944748,
0.1033713669,
0.0097040255,
-0.0299242511,
-0.0482167341,
-0.0015673395,
0.0133975595,
-0.0713418052,
-0.0063331323,
0.0209726859,
0.0059584244,
-0.0532091558,
0.0371390171,
-0.0096208602,
-0.0154817924,
0.0241373889,
-0.012945747,
0.0111167515,
-0.0141013786,
0.0643053651,
0.0329236761,
-0.050619822,
-0.0140655059,
-0.0604511201,
0.0375102311,
0.0969995111,
-0.02084562,
-0.0141236512,
0.0186286643,
0.0603353754,
0.0721397772,
-0.0292134136,
0.000622129,
0.0147019215,
-0.0023187031,
-0.0217063148,
-0.032892473,
-0.0120493807,
-0.007315733,
0.0258079767,
0.0071654487,
-0.0239571929,
0.0395156071,
0.0204555001,
0.0107859103,
0.0389804058,
0.0259235706,
2.056703002e-34,
0.0099721896,
0.028245816,
0.0055582519,
0.0023935859,
0.0726747289,
-0.0466918312,
-0.060832914,
0.0500336289,
0.0150198312,
0.0226063691,
-0.0016205709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13032v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13032v2 | Financial News Analytics Using Fine-Tuned Llama 2 GPT Model | 2023-08-24T18:58:10 | 2023-09-11T05:39:05 | Bohdan M. Pavlyshenko | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.IR, cs.LG | The paper considers the possibility to fine-tune Llama 2 GPT large language
model (LLM) for the multitask analysis of financial news. For fine-tuning, the
PEFT/LoRA based approach was used. In the study, the model was fine-tuned for
the following tasks: analysing a text from financial market perspectives,
highlighting main points of a text, summarizing a text and extracting named
entities with appropriate sentiments. The obtained results show that the
fine-tuned Llama 2 model can perform a multitask financial news analysis with a
specified structure of response, part of response can be a structured text and
another part of data can have JSON format for further processing. Extracted
sentiments for named entities can be considered as predictive features in
supervised machine learning models with quantitative target variables. | [
0.0429826751,
0.0281636529,
-0.0186728369,
0.0199139882,
-0.0007802272,
0.0392698869,
-0.0502730086,
0.0299670324,
0.0365785323,
-0.0554391295,
-0.0307135414,
-0.0404977687,
-0.0336668752,
0.0659984276,
0.0118186232,
-0.0305447411,
0.0294305123,
-0.0099588344,
0.0730775893,
-0.0015654223,
0.044747021,
0.0212340336,
0.0479611866,
-0.003965545,
0.0426569097,
-0.0151637029,
-0.0068623628,
-0.021569537,
0.0168552194,
-0.0081082312,
0.0034705733,
-0.0148365814,
-0.0013259692,
0.0052823857,
0.0000020359,
-0.0414560996,
-0.0412289649,
-0.0132949604,
0.060431771,
-0.010273545,
0.074390687,
-0.0233791154,
0.0087833963,
0.0322027318,
-0.038867496,
-0.0054172915,
0.0219687913,
0.0973945409,
0.0701767355,
0.0671304688,
-0.0278647617,
-0.0645286739,
0.058358144,
-0.043748688,
-0.0013919795,
-0.055020608,
0.0272476226,
-0.00586699,
-0.0098359063,
0.0189171825,
-0.0034202491,
-0.006688653,
-0.0208770875,
0.0129756359,
-0.0079468442,
-0.0090362225,
-0.0312540196,
0.0003453263,
-0.0329681635,
0.0278921258,
-0.0171086136,
0.0421352424,
0.0385277979,
-0.0369066447,
-0.047112748,
0.000805039,
-0.0542339273,
0.0283847842,
-0.0180952214,
0.0359288007,
0.0530983284,
-0.0351020396,
-0.0316142291,
-0.0012743338,
-0.0463020131,
0.0825283229,
-0.0299940351,
-0.006311289,
0.0292807706,
0.0409473851,
-0.0294919163,
-0.0098364186,
0.0022642505,
0.015298631,
0.0305356886,
0.0118028345,
0.0191146582,
-0.0330945961,
0.0318315402,
-0.1298974007,
0.0089852912,
0.0262796767,
-0.0111584952,
0.0287770331,
-0.0205507427,
-0.0371184871,
-0.0044656722,
-0.0321405977,
-0.0173688382,
-0.0182711743,
-0.064549163,
-0.015073549,
0.0080558974,
0.1487964094,
-0.0310616195,
-0.0312265679,
-0.0485524349,
0.016527934,
0.0054452536,
-0.0073035602,
0.0016365477,
-0.0581197217,
-0.0110086966,
0.0151790101,
-0.0381818265,
0.0270274691,
-0.0391106196,
0.0527254902,
-0.0458763503,
-0.0177462604,
0.0366795622,
0.0238478947,
-0.0154677387,
-0.005352098,
0.0203234013,
0.0852174535,
0.0311652906,
-0.0545748919,
-0.0913313776,
-0.0527291745,
0.0182938166,
-0.0468500517,
-0.0120620793,
-0.0231521875,
0.0186497886,
-0.0133127533,
-0.0116462167,
0.0416346565,
-0.0091557596,
0.012095945,
-0.0397116393,
0.0424246676,
0.0265759025,
-0.0193253849,
0.0274579599,
-0.0444128774,
0.0513642803,
0.1212622896,
0.0176009461,
0.0592795126,
0.0174466427,
0.0110597061,
-0.0300018471,
0.061231643,
-0.013966891,
-0.0508082584,
-0.0274979006,
0.0356311053,
-0.0193356723,
-0.0709414855,
0.0450797155,
0.0142592471,
0.0053996565,
0.0652093142,
0.0487071387,
0.0144062974,
0.053483285,
0.0294492692,
-0.0354160778,
0.0190744288,
0.0348089412,
0.0023424502,
0.0461780466,
0.0331876688,
-0.038527526,
0.0273569711,
0.0000520941,
0.0558820404,
-0.0358650014,
-0.018327428,
0.0185372662,
-0.0349367559,
-0.0255174786,
-0.0044663697,
0.0417371728,
-0.0654166564,
-0.0758325383,
0.0313540325,
0.0388757735,
-0.0058710645,
-0.0017757538,
-0.0541636311,
0.0667068064,
0.0448599681,
-0.0079858582,
-0.0387284756,
0.0014048647,
-0.0329815447,
-0.0238651354,
0.0213298593,
0.004317285,
0.0183495507,
-0.0616544485,
-0.0458308235,
-0.0270218328,
0.0058532171,
0.0166759882,
0.0114592016,
-0.0345575996,
0.0467009023,
-0.0203365795,
0.0172421578,
-0.0034752933,
0.0028385883,
0.0486598499,
0.0078399489,
0.0081363451,
-0.0320337974,
0.0355720185,
0.0462725498,
0.0103006726,
-0.0100556221,
0.0224935897,
-0.0198945403,
-0.0217683613,
-0.017353408,
0.0182967484,
0.0120720752,
-0.0283960253,
-0.0213944018,
0.0256248079,
0.0633715391,
-0.0335177332,
-0.030786708,
-0.0527422242,
-0.0275618136,
0.0191975217,
-0.0475929603,
-0.0279006716,
-0.0190037116,
0.0377578661,
-0.0192363746,
0.0399694368,
-0.0125498362,
0.0050453059,
-0.0539444201,
-0.0320240594,
-0.0131798089,
-0.0151107786,
-0.0075487327,
0.0427434705,
0.0221413672,
0.0350584984,
0.0438720323,
0.0082252631,
-0.0025263107,
-0.0625160187,
-0.0565627366,
0.0042606979,
-0.0017494907,
0.0601000302,
0.0216613095,
0.0170824621,
-0.0209245272,
-0.0028451979,
-0.0494657904,
0.0294551142,
-0.0007772201,
0.0251119919,
0.0682049543,
0.0054249335,
-0.0101329582,
-0.0344315208,
0.0128930537,
-0.0063961609,
-0.0064096055,
0.0630182177,
-0.0758075118,
-0.008615585,
0.0262022913,
-0.0144405924,
-0.0111950692,
-0.0049558943,
0.0140247717,
-0.0096576316,
-0.0189775527,
0.028331127,
0.0480448753,
-0.0090803104,
0.034174338,
-0.0420767963,
-0.0055631893,
-0.0123060076,
0.0109515786,
-0.0328881368,
0.0106775118,
-0.006602284,
-0.0051327967,
0.0363064781,
0.0287974477,
-0.0090283779,
-0.016021261,
-0.0469576456,
0.0021649543,
-0.0307302866,
0.0362801552,
0.0231589451,
-0.0105431005,
-0.0040729707,
0.0227520037,
0.0061164135,
-0.0387602821,
0.0258684661,
0.0018713572,
0.0160325579,
-0.0443343967,
-0.0353049189,
-0.1187684759,
0.029913431,
-0.0322782956,
0.0059675407,
-0.0653688237,
-0.0501120314,
-0.0120293815,
-0.0426548161,
-0.010260216,
-0.0394455455,
0.0682187825,
-0.0001239631,
0.0151240416,
-0.0088129481,
0.015546239,
0.0341369845,
-0.0386893153,
-0.0469318032,
0.0078495834,
0.0500208326,
-0.0206992775,
-0.027148651,
0.0557020195,
-0.0124210455,
-0.0327291675,
-0.0286899339,
-0.0053569241,
0.0053276881,
0.0155295162,
0.087508522,
-0.0106970025,
-0.0010230799,
-0.028247783,
0.0278420709,
0.0087850727,
-0.010171189,
0.0095593408,
0.0107545098,
0.0037808304,
0.0056275963,
-0.0308131427,
-0.0280753803,
-0.023351565,
-0.0135047017,
-0.0311254393,
0.0464709774,
0.0916428417,
0.0078301979,
-0.0315111093,
-0.0188908037,
0.0124252811,
-0.0196070615,
-0.02266315,
0.0606934652,
-0.0447398573,
-0.0050271256,
-0.0019023314,
0.013355758,
0.0103701269,
-0.0299109519,
-0.0076397764,
-0.1296160817,
0.0352014937,
-0.0263137799,
-0.0018981927,
-0.0345404372,
-0.0597086251,
-0.0051605976,
-0.0588425957,
-0.012047858,
-0.0229393113,
-0.0179559756,
0.0385228433,
0.0094423182,
-0.054595124,
-0.0103597259,
-0.007475887,
0.0194991566,
-0.0298704822,
0.0530219935,
0.023264328,
-0.0626849458,
-0.0029595334,
-0.020697942,
-0.0211620182,
-0.0177003499,
-0.0120832464,
0.0267970115,
-0.0308811162,
-0.0425551832,
-0.0133032911,
0.0542041399,
-0.0004761262,
0.0661601797,
0.0055500078,
0.0165897831,
-0.0102949906,
-0.0382992662,
-0.0222036522,
0.0156596284,
-0.0117872432,
0.048115246,
0.0022318913,
-0.0590293631,
-0.0213031489,
-0.006397218,
-0.0343444757,
-0.03130408,
-0.0099321464,
-0.0155608878,
0.0057783248,
0.003313201,
-0.0688067079,
-0.0525929928,
0.0192899797,
0.0245239772,
-0.011481557,
0.0749759898,
0.0400366373,
-0.0155464057,
-0.0201410707,
-0.0070887413,
-0.0100472169,
0.0328483619,
-0.0174124632,
0.0175696164,
0.0809198096,
0.0018825927,
-0.0613713786,
0.0364293158,
-0.0914848223,
-0.0325281173,
-0.0167013463,
0.0031944346,
0.0178803708,
-0.0378416255,
0.0047550616,
-0.0077095632,
0.0168439429,
0.0610097721,
-0.0786393136,
0.0090294536,
0.0235324744,
0.06738545,
0.0018649681,
0.009529978,
-0.0229001306,
0.0404126421,
-0.0216471069,
-0.0017756794,
0.0018673458,
-0.0167024173,
-0.0323787555,
0.0405765064,
0.0227815751,
0.0379255302,
-0.0442782119,
-0.0500270277,
0.0101005686,
0.0126946354,
0.0283500608,
-0.048641026,
-0.0233611446,
0.0207835026,
-0.0344428755,
-0.0570756942,
0.0204529911,
-0.0016080432,
-0.0393190831,
-0.0420140512,
0.0592900254,
-0.0369911753,
0.0107976794,
-0.0127743902,
-0.0075278557,
-0.0008074858,
-0.0592278391,
0.0437198617,
-0.0134943305,
-0.0038339479,
0.0004252168,
0.0206223913,
0.010565863,
0.0141894417,
0.0092272284,
-0.0191732254,
-0.0036327685,
-0.0273112319,
0.0446503796,
0.0200923774,
-0.0352464803,
0.0278964005,
-0.0092961546,
0.019009864,
0.0211070981,
0.0190865174,
0.0036837049,
-0.0051763128,
0.0551415756,
-0.011141629,
-0.0456475653,
-0.0423005894,
0.0856194198,
0.0186074674,
0.0118978946,
-0.012729181,
-0.0082405321,
-0.0623908043,
-0.0076476522,
0.0906277075,
0.0250277836,
-0.0072546625,
0.0057374262,
-0.0459354483,
-0.0324784182,
0.0530963801,
-0.0381185934,
-0.0077983141,
-0.0343465768,
0.0376807302,
0.0509475432,
0.019444989,
0.0505808592,
-0.0318629332,
-0.0227363221,
-0.0220720712,
-0.0054925443,
0.0099641085,
-6.668032847e-33,
-0.0294564627,
-0.000076223,
0.0032496906,
0.0627420023,
-0.0223366339,
0.0091915075,
0.0073299077,
-0.0475077778,
-0.0076325466,
-0.0206071027,
0.0263341498,
0.0262296945,
0.0166148804,
0.0105060227,
0.017904358,
0.0106140664,
0.0165612474,
-0.0399813876,
0.0337427445,
0.0097382786,
0.0218107011,
0.0648138598,
0.0425412282,
-0.0341403782,
0.0351661444,
-0.0022818169,
-0.0602100268,
-0.0216441154,
0.0457880273,
0.0509844013,
-0.0272804946,
0.0506303497,
0.0301931743,
-0.0886804536,
-0.0054278621,
0.0444672741,
-0.0142372148,
-0.0735761151,
0.0448902026,
0.0060075824,
0.0368775576,
0.0196678992,
0.0680101439,
0.0030882952,
0.0214820132,
0.0104503855,
0.0328230411,
-0.0121782525,
-0.000454299,
-0.0351945981,
-0.0540098883,
0.024920607,
0.0106263207,
0.0760077387,
0.0506074727,
0.0217352342,
0.0167642627,
0.0524958558,
-0.0215541329,
0.0096257757,
0.0410192832,
0.005118418,
0.0008051844,
-0.0055778218,
-0.0134389894,
0.054730121,
-0.0307604764,
0.0017692414,
-0.0216604359,
0.0529265702,
0.0185109787,
0.0312275141,
0.0045150318,
0.0252161697,
-0.0192425363,
-0.0515931807,
-0.0866875127,
0.0414395258,
0.0364322588,
0.0203435346,
0.0361383371,
0.0004170766,
-0.0122332508,
-0.0265707504,
0.0099436622,
0.0113242725,
-0.0370297544,
-0.0234040245,
0.015541493,
0.019084068,
-0.0357065238,
0.0423202105,
-0.0119388374,
-0.0560699143,
-0.0676979348,
0.0112045621,
-0.0490293428,
0.0610407181,
-0.0006549968,
0.0033713963,
-0.0500265807,
-0.0663318112,
-0.0418471359,
0.0066178613,
-0.0191553514,
-0.0243360065,
0.0245557036,
0.0244203229,
-0.0850213766,
-0.0164721422,
0.0048375442,
0.0215752907,
0.0138596389,
0.0428925008,
0.0050686547,
-0.0017911384,
-0.0026274025,
0.0464784354,
0.0112702856,
0.0153793311,
0.0020001766,
-0.0200989619,
-0.0037495762,
0.0547605753,
0.0105385697,
-0.0027721419,
0.0447237231,
0.0155121237,
0.0252328627,
-0.0339664929,
-0.0142369578,
0.0319392309,
2.826e-7,
0.0404844508,
0.0730184093,
-0.0262865517,
0.0145489434,
0.0122461515,
0.0178665444,
-0.0054896981,
0.0453787558,
-0.0053904755,
0.0139734745,
0.0084708873,
0.0007481045,
-0.0056078541,
0.023586357,
-0.113078475,
0.0148609672,
-0.031164391,
0.0142904259,
-0.0889115557,
0.0487938151,
0.0574225634,
0.0896858647,
-0.00481214,
-0.0254382119,
-0.0123362504,
-0.0381265767,
0.0454711132,
-0.0342675634,
-0.0531459823,
0.022163609,
0.0197304003,
0.0469565354,
-0.0244993567,
0.0025158073,
0.007179419,
0.024868967,
0.0324545652,
0.0305895936,
0.0136415651,
0.0270844046,
0.0667099729,
-0.0019209996,
-0.0066264113,
-0.0298531409,
0.0996017605,
-0.0451292433,
-0.0757888705,
-0.0542502701,
-0.0140264854,
-0.0169749409,
0.0213935934,
-0.0140916193,
0.0020857535,
0.026058048,
-0.0098793237,
-0.0400796533,
0.0036866963,
-0.0164650362,
0.0031355729,
0.0292469934,
-0.020110935,
0.0150685972,
-0.0561992303,
-0.0183734205,
0.0179634951,
-0.0452565514,
0.0375505276,
2.480965316e-34,
0.0599868745,
-0.0357930809,
-0.0356458947,
0.0489512645,
0.0247597452,
0.0163005888,
-0.0426860228,
0.0460846424,
-0.022641005,
-0.1062375978,
0.0216024816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12966v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12966v3 | Qwen-VL: A Versatile Vision-Language Model for Understanding, Localization, Text Reading, and Beyond | 2023-08-24T17:59:17 | 2023-10-13T02:41:28 | Jinze Bai, Shuai Bai, Shusheng Yang, Shijie Wang, Sinan Tan, Peng Wang, Junyang Lin, Chang Zhou, Jingren Zhou | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | In this work, we introduce the Qwen-VL series, a set of large-scale
vision-language models (LVLMs) designed to perceive and understand both texts
and images. Starting from the Qwen-LM as a foundation, we endow it with visual
capacity by the meticulously designed (i) visual receptor, (ii) input-output
interface, (iii) 3-stage training pipeline, and (iv) multilingual multimodal
cleaned corpus. Beyond the conventional image description and
question-answering, we implement the grounding and text-reading ability of
Qwen-VLs by aligning image-caption-box tuples. The resulting models, including
Qwen-VL and Qwen-VL-Chat, set new records for generalist models under similar
model scales on a broad range of visual-centric benchmarks (e.g., image
captioning, question answering, visual grounding) and different settings (e.g.,
zero-shot, few-shot). Moreover, on real-world dialog benchmarks, our
instruction-tuned Qwen-VL-Chat also demonstrates superiority compared to
existing vision-language chatbots. Code, demo and models are available at
https://github.com/QwenLM/Qwen-VL. | [
0.0532583855,
0.0348533317,
0.0008430695,
0.0699118152,
-0.0226715151,
0.0165487994,
0.0294837989,
-0.0116964867,
0.0686268881,
-0.0562448874,
-0.0617978722,
-0.0245674849,
0.0109170061,
0.0733192414,
0.0213907547,
-0.0679218397,
0.0278612282,
-0.0435454175,
-0.022569865,
0.0007130455,
0.0569737814,
0.0020020483,
-0.0091074426,
0.0322261825,
0.000334219,
-0.0477186553,
-0.0232650749,
0.0115223657,
0.0209009089,
0.003139474,
-0.0324262306,
0.0341203436,
0.0429563262,
0.0025063702,
0.0000018035,
0.0198745523,
0.0245986786,
-0.0138525711,
0.0033406625,
-0.0076023494,
0.0311301984,
-0.0663762987,
0.0080429632,
0.0155493757,
-0.0322409049,
-0.0170147028,
0.0672594532,
0.045357544,
0.0915263966,
0.0649349466,
-0.0139501449,
-0.0102474885,
0.0281585157,
-0.0046583,
0.0342070162,
-0.0725713372,
-0.0094191665,
0.0639970154,
0.018388873,
0.0067610992,
-0.0735222474,
0.0598506257,
0.0289038122,
-0.0445661806,
0.0092028817,
0.0473178141,
-0.0185300633,
-0.0360265411,
-0.0467725955,
0.105155766,
0.0060545281,
0.0022531273,
-0.031147426,
0.0241583548,
0.0241782088,
-0.0450724326,
-0.0470235907,
0.0357305445,
-0.0027668788,
0.0033515492,
-0.052740179,
-0.0153122991,
-0.0194463655,
0.012619446,
0.0092902556,
-0.0238750428,
-0.0067807105,
0.0107379286,
-0.0274696164,
0.0324559622,
-0.0576032586,
-0.0388049334,
-0.0019717461,
0.031510666,
0.0002319114,
0.0139686745,
-0.0247210506,
-0.0206871089,
-0.0318150297,
-0.0567386821,
0.0052809785,
0.0231606234,
-0.0657176301,
0.0852594227,
-0.0063574556,
0.0866722539,
0.0025425116,
0.0315161161,
-0.0381715558,
-0.0343213789,
-0.0046616397,
-0.0128986044,
-0.0401722379,
-0.0159983318,
-0.0595801622,
-0.0856822729,
-0.0112758493,
0.0438569188,
0.0049488475,
-0.0065567507,
0.0024815605,
0.0260416083,
-0.0360228084,
-0.0161092095,
-0.0169383697,
0.0430509448,
-0.0156760681,
0.0016213316,
-0.0231311284,
-0.0749607384,
-0.022545062,
0.0665394515,
0.0344790742,
-0.0142707024,
-0.0272222366,
0.080089286,
-0.0423327312,
-0.0500845201,
0.0119416043,
0.0075195078,
-0.0438979752,
-0.0287253261,
0.0010517108,
-0.0340349488,
0.0235768594,
-0.0202261191,
0.0177174527,
-0.0189367607,
-0.0051769456,
0.0329943188,
-0.0031381329,
0.1088052914,
-0.0015987669,
-0.0075991163,
0.0077171619,
0.0230718292,
-0.0152953425,
0.0593561195,
0.015360795,
0.0483427718,
0.014618705,
0.0035773723,
0.0249758139,
0.029333869,
-0.027438879,
-0.0129328519,
-0.037301641,
0.0084427865,
-0.0106691001,
0.028242413,
0.0358993411,
0.0433243141,
-0.0436685085,
-0.0393245332,
0.0767121017,
0.0474841669,
-0.0220441129,
-0.0100683905,
-0.0009263426,
0.0254867319,
0.0194965824,
-0.0193951242,
-0.0609221086,
0.0652600005,
0.0151594616,
0.0040362226,
-0.0015313964,
-0.0012196098,
-0.0360718518,
-0.0368197113,
0.0160927288,
-0.0130970078,
0.0103549976,
0.0127895214,
0.0409249403,
0.0070683174,
-0.0450036749,
-0.0061835325,
0.0148886135,
-0.0167812426,
-0.0252980981,
-0.0081769163,
0.0131659973,
0.0603173226,
0.0329294279,
0.0190794021,
-0.0362727791,
0.0038792682,
0.0334780551,
0.0821066201,
0.008968723,
0.0147203729,
0.0328007415,
-0.0511904582,
-0.0444629528,
-0.0116240028,
-0.0190225989,
0.0089019779,
-0.0009118196,
-0.010001367,
-0.006756783,
-0.0199738573,
0.001439717,
0.0401655585,
0.0155722909,
-0.0061573149,
-0.0452599339,
0.0087229675,
0.0017594565,
-0.0072364956,
-0.021612579,
-0.0201551374,
0.0030618031,
-0.0384488665,
0.0053211106,
0.0510222651,
-0.0507437922,
-0.064540334,
0.0287858304,
-0.052725222,
-0.0218471084,
0.0303688776,
-0.0354469121,
-0.0128160315,
-0.0037180453,
-0.0412683487,
-0.0240586419,
-0.0626055822,
0.0036488511,
0.0171971712,
0.0168309566,
-0.0219067913,
0.0226634182,
-0.0264891982,
-0.0256984998,
0.0131507423,
0.015517028,
-0.0037495077,
-0.0365430899,
-0.0357477404,
-0.0072517572,
0.0066292877,
0.0143590095,
0.0126132397,
0.0383438244,
-0.0464323871,
-0.0105959997,
-0.1108014211,
-0.029252965,
-0.0336292386,
-0.0472010076,
0.0099097993,
-0.0136531955,
-0.0015462361,
-0.0547644272,
-0.0481263362,
0.0295926593,
0.0226596072,
-0.0002815385,
0.0464696884,
0.0037554768,
0.0027264468,
-0.0327703319,
0.0216252748,
0.030209424,
0.0509001687,
0.0286380276,
-0.0157196634,
-0.0506286547,
0.0150139937,
-0.0319212154,
0.0463726968,
-0.0190331191,
-0.0400614738,
0.0006523897,
-0.0084041776,
0.0132564558,
0.0982955918,
0.0130015584,
0.0258272663,
-0.0155408373,
0.0083615072,
-0.0407341607,
0.0225112084,
0.015180002,
-0.0554958321,
-0.0222744998,
-0.0182208065,
-0.0506555364,
0.0421884023,
-0.021430362,
0.0261619966,
-0.0716576874,
0.0497745089,
0.007856193,
-0.0472038835,
-0.0738947168,
0.0250713602,
-0.0124962041,
0.0337051973,
-0.0720059201,
-0.0800755396,
0.0369127654,
-0.0379889943,
-0.0283917934,
-0.0142865963,
-0.0150453569,
-0.0189750362,
0.0720855296,
0.0319934599,
0.0336413756,
-0.0166805945,
-0.0215854924,
-0.0489247069,
-0.0211225506,
-0.0186069347,
0.0018901108,
0.0368367769,
-0.034626998,
0.0199788623,
-0.0284583531,
-0.0337190107,
-0.0429845713,
0.0078756362,
-0.0394153781,
-0.0212503504,
-0.0371283367,
-0.0028342146,
-0.0198943466,
0.0449663736,
0.0293432847,
0.0439650118,
-0.0112541728,
-0.000238465,
-0.0189956799,
0.0315220021,
0.0680839717,
0.0341278128,
-0.0152101154,
-0.0588381663,
0.0378256738,
0.071630545,
0.0130139068,
-0.0055229049,
-0.0219669566,
0.0110156471,
0.0153022576,
0.0420208238,
0.0151322512,
-0.0055379183,
0.051843293,
-0.0497598238,
-0.0272562262,
0.0809836462,
0.0117624886,
-0.0418075025,
-0.0298561864,
0.013801733,
0.0331259444,
0.034923844,
0.0280209277,
-0.0904460326,
-0.0515881516,
-0.0075118067,
-0.0192407481,
0.0476447232,
0.0158229247,
-0.0446921363,
-0.0546958745,
0.0501533225,
0.0038578273,
-0.017321758,
-0.0726416111,
0.0587008148,
-0.0295647103,
-0.0187003836,
0.0117736328,
0.0268779173,
0.0013756583,
-0.0116919,
-0.002261525,
0.0318287686,
0.0267868787,
0.0242421553,
-0.042702131,
0.0067199939,
0.0424448326,
0.0194485225,
0.0097742258,
-0.0303702876,
0.0190379471,
0.0260561854,
0.0095773153,
0.0228640642,
0.0513685942,
-0.0471229441,
-0.0601611026,
-0.0016796063,
0.0292936433,
-0.0178241041,
-0.0033684005,
-0.0231142901,
0.0050722649,
-0.0074320138,
-0.0111005288,
-0.017700715,
0.0420233719,
-0.0183619913,
0.0546921417,
0.0196661744,
-0.0425426625,
-0.0647341833,
-0.0201812014,
-0.0152138341,
-0.0435521379,
-0.0492672436,
-0.0051190532,
0.0205814783,
-0.0077244714,
-0.0706944242,
-0.0511598587,
0.032720454,
0.0450196564,
-0.0242259055,
-0.0182858184,
0.0116042327,
0.0271866322,
-0.0286718719,
0.0710442737,
-0.0310350917,
0.0167896952,
-0.043654114,
0.0174059272,
0.0319558457,
-0.0380067974,
-0.0341206416,
0.0231586825,
-0.0867656246,
-0.0172128621,
-0.037031021,
0.0708415806,
0.0124691604,
0.041229032,
0.0142072747,
-0.0104022585,
-0.0097937947,
0.0134458216,
0.0264976081,
0.0267815981,
-0.0074839476,
0.0034981731,
-0.0063484968,
0.0261456184,
-0.0182612985,
0.0185647234,
-0.0046569705,
0.0187093057,
-0.0229865685,
-0.0216892343,
0.0019690495,
-0.0087739248,
0.0109071005,
0.0183474254,
0.0183035601,
-0.0293875672,
0.0184831452,
0.0019056322,
-0.0075733694,
-0.0919524878,
0.0112107415,
0.0118393609,
0.0066062906,
0.011511025,
-0.008308691,
0.0020144004,
0.0284328051,
0.0076792543,
-0.0207197312,
0.035819795,
-0.0385496393,
-0.0083782515,
0.0174464285,
-0.0128679881,
0.0304121114,
-0.0289890319,
0.0536277853,
0.0227001514,
0.0904448181,
0.033280503,
-0.0460266545,
0.0011111079,
0.0302266814,
-0.0245707855,
-0.0523074642,
-0.0286213346,
0.0902814493,
0.037774086,
0.0335251242,
0.0035117017,
-0.0190499071,
-0.0086435936,
-0.0195253678,
0.0473439805,
-0.001548438,
-0.0563577078,
0.053680215,
0.0135025773,
-0.0053588548,
-0.0217641499,
0.0554628298,
0.0226403698,
0.0298042558,
0.0153110484,
-0.0107477019,
-0.0433256179,
-0.0184959248,
0.0388288982,
-0.0004464683,
0.0003949988,
0.0783188194,
-0.0207146835,
-0.0642503798,
-0.0109278597,
0.0344806612,
-0.0061679715,
0.020803418,
0.0511538796,
0.0411166809,
0.0208744891,
-0.018467471,
-0.0314102843,
-0.0087227086,
-0.0228338242,
-0.0074918065,
0.0136867333,
-5.641995991e-33,
-0.0444320701,
-0.0277552754,
0.0465442203,
0.0030164435,
-0.0150566716,
0.0206438918,
-0.025081154,
0.0155484891,
-0.033171691,
0.0122179491,
0.0435099863,
0.0183205772,
0.0057369159,
0.0591033287,
-0.0342633128,
-0.0091166142,
0.0121936714,
-0.0210708361,
0.0059973691,
-0.0050881556,
0.0151937241,
0.0333437137,
0.0370359048,
-0.0288841408,
0.0065286513,
-0.0011473665,
-0.0144110946,
0.0522375219,
0.0285317805,
0.0434477404,
-0.0403136984,
0.0048597967,
0.0193217304,
0.0085039437,
-0.0350340344,
0.050111711,
-0.0853025615,
0.0170507543,
0.0234360192,
0.0681702048,
-0.0747519657,
0.0278295279,
0.0371158049,
-0.0607089661,
0.0391735733,
-0.044161614,
0.0376610644,
-0.0194372106,
-0.0038103708,
0.0451798923,
-0.0309482403,
0.0032670731,
-0.0179437045,
-0.0789531097,
0.0222789124,
0.0539319813,
0.0275701527,
0.0474912375,
-0.0419019237,
-0.0087758824,
-0.0078999577,
0.0014759358,
0.0848151073,
0.0473644286,
0.0238027386,
0.066763781,
0.0230221786,
-0.0260296464,
-0.0344165079,
-0.0363113135,
0.038473852,
0.0380074382,
0.0399626605,
0.0529309921,
-0.0118325837,
0.0277454145,
-0.0423886441,
-0.0040892675,
-0.0173013173,
0.0666501597,
0.0079203956,
0.0045637479,
-0.0158184599,
0.0118567487,
-0.0371035039,
0.0052500172,
-0.0614705309,
-0.0012539949,
0.0606784672,
0.0240117703,
-0.0190968718,
-0.007905324,
0.08781486,
-0.0595264696,
0.0237386432,
0.04848703,
-0.0143679995,
0.0531579517,
-0.0086825229,
0.0453699157,
-0.0428011827,
0.0046614795,
0.0311172418,
-0.0029706375,
-0.0272634178,
0.0213658493,
0.0231778417,
0.0029037588,
-0.0342006423,
-0.0107349567,
-0.0410881974,
0.016500527,
-0.0260882508,
0.0750103593,
0.0077093723,
0.0207329672,
-0.069165878,
0.0388562568,
-0.0329014398,
-0.0099673532,
-0.0219689682,
-0.0477986448,
-0.0223619901,
0.012803385,
-0.0315414034,
0.0100507084,
-0.0365029201,
-0.0041515487,
0.0100172032,
-0.064575702,
-0.0017272885,
0.0474715494,
2.4e-7,
0.0289444886,
0.0180770811,
0.0489854962,
0.0489491336,
0.0250108838,
0.0653739274,
-0.0165627431,
0.0456185229,
0.0045728073,
-0.0333341174,
0.0006578309,
0.0730050057,
0.0393378884,
-0.0548763536,
-0.0601879284,
0.0257426742,
-0.0561322607,
-0.027323693,
-0.0259162616,
-0.0198518094,
0.0431217216,
0.1029821932,
-0.0589846596,
-0.0111847306,
0.0507681519,
-0.0706020966,
0.077647917,
-0.0269497652,
-0.01309299,
0.0053869477,
0.0153335193,
0.020427214,
-0.0149827451,
0.0054784832,
0.0404703021,
-0.0129681407,
0.050348375,
0.0553992875,
-0.01906031,
-0.0228967275,
-0.0280972738,
0.0340515152,
-0.0446183532,
-0.0653648078,
0.058589872,
-0.0479508191,
-0.0289362799,
-0.058452189,
-0.0355532989,
-0.0299048014,
0.0292485058,
-0.0119960662,
-0.0374807864,
0.0340951346,
0.0434224047,
-0.049566865,
-0.0180349015,
-0.0739833191,
-0.0265454762,
-0.0270999968,
-0.0266263429,
-0.0124586737,
-0.0677207559,
-0.027312994,
0.0399664305,
-0.0179626141,
-0.0484269261,
1.426472267e-34,
0.0315427072,
-0.0230362806,
0.002871468,
0.0472859778,
0.035787046,
-0.0081940228,
0.0079363436,
-0.0131893121,
0.0138815129,
-0.0539398119,
-0.0116738277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12950v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12950v3 | Code Llama: Open Foundation Models for Code | 2023-08-24T17:39:13 | 2024-01-31T19:47:26 | Baptiste Rozière, Jonas Gehring, Fabian Gloeckle, Sten Sootla, Itai Gat, Xiaoqing Ellen Tan, Yossi Adi, Jingyu Liu, Romain Sauvestre, Tal Remez, Jérémy Rapin, Artyom Kozhevnikov, Ivan Evtimov, Joanna Bitton, Manish Bhatt, Cristian Canton Ferrer, Aaron Grattafiori, Wenhan Xiong, Alexandre Défossez, Jade Copet, Faisal Azhar, Hugo Touvron, Louis Martin, Nicolas Usunier, Thomas Scialom, Gabriel Synnaeve | cs.CL | cs.CL | We release Code Llama, a family of large language models for code based on
Llama 2 providing state-of-the-art performance among open models, infilling
capabilities, support for large input contexts, and zero-shot instruction
following ability for programming tasks. We provide multiple flavors to cover a
wide range of applications: foundation models (Code Llama), Python
specializations (Code Llama - Python), and instruction-following models (Code
Llama - Instruct) with 7B, 13B, 34B and 70B parameters each. All models are
trained on sequences of 16k tokens and show improvements on inputs with up to
100k tokens. 7B, 13B and 70B Code Llama and Code Llama - Instruct variants
support infilling based on surrounding content. Code Llama reaches
state-of-the-art performance among open models on several code benchmarks, with
scores of up to 67% and 65% on HumanEval and MBPP, respectively. Notably, Code
Llama - Python 7B outperforms Llama 2 70B on HumanEval and MBPP, and all our
models outperform every other publicly available model on MultiPL-E. We release
Code Llama under a permissive license that allows for both research and
commercial use. | [
0.007640583,
0.0849843398,
0.0039143027,
0.0153745878,
0.0126490341,
0.0181810297,
-0.0436295494,
-0.0039534918,
-0.0035955883,
-0.0195748061,
-0.0246266183,
0.0295922346,
-0.0318147615,
0.0655093119,
0.0515283532,
-0.0283322614,
0.0504060127,
-0.0582434088,
-0.0140891988,
0.0194790903,
-0.0102900676,
0.0100696571,
0.0004037898,
0.0280866362,
0.0148388008,
-0.0397775881,
-0.0182082225,
0.0402028859,
-0.0163160041,
-0.0440192483,
0.0293501131,
0.0046303519,
0.0170936268,
-0.0056049582,
0.0000022648,
-0.0139347594,
0.0105563393,
-0.0139783937,
-0.0306016896,
0.0571166687,
0.014121376,
-0.0300120469,
-0.0090787113,
0.0274113286,
-0.0086270282,
-0.0009141164,
0.0581594147,
-0.0133142136,
0.0751860589,
0.0687804818,
0.0170404427,
-0.0296145715,
0.0426113531,
-0.0216319356,
0.0019724909,
-0.0108632948,
0.0172727052,
-0.0146392127,
0.0362951234,
0.0040773763,
0.0017141174,
-0.0033255222,
0.0394608416,
-0.0094146766,
0.0252968241,
0.0496747643,
-0.0356992073,
-0.0059056343,
-0.0267485157,
0.0480152741,
-0.0847615227,
-0.0493867733,
-0.0081170667,
-0.0181181524,
-0.0274562594,
-0.0990277827,
-0.0663803443,
0.0465100594,
0.0111303749,
0.0169174522,
0.0519871451,
-0.0137636364,
0.0293381643,
0.0038707452,
-0.0289108269,
0.0702279657,
0.0029740285,
-0.0164823439,
-0.0448386781,
-0.0175391473,
0.0054904814,
-0.0790654793,
-0.0042549288,
0.0928105265,
-0.0014025654,
0.0042325724,
-0.0622489229,
0.0016755183,
0.0301958621,
-0.0189326387,
0.0499531366,
0.0661461651,
-0.0621767603,
0.0233150776,
-0.0485701784,
0.0577980801,
-0.048020184,
0.0467382111,
-0.0335448682,
0.022681376,
-0.0161378849,
0.0227731988,
-0.0376728624,
0.0656467155,
-0.0255407039,
0.0089783557,
-0.030807877,
0.0613616295,
-0.0019413549,
0.0562310256,
-0.0173148159,
-0.0090485364,
-0.0052336669,
0.028423911,
0.018810166,
-0.0004914299,
-0.0336335711,
-0.0132468836,
0.0097000562,
-0.0626789927,
-0.0205580313,
0.0340450369,
-0.0337057933,
-0.0284507237,
0.0433671102,
0.0823312998,
0.0189337637,
-0.0054822573,
-0.0443671532,
-0.0354449451,
0.0556644797,
-0.047658015,
-0.0159407202,
-0.0995876566,
-0.0309262201,
0.0055278242,
0.0118719414,
-0.0516565293,
0.0264966246,
0.0296218451,
-0.0014366423,
0.034080524,
-0.0222477652,
-0.0113363639,
0.0010587865,
0.0190172326,
-0.010223954,
0.0266654342,
0.0256186761,
0.0335002467,
0.0097633079,
-0.0263582636,
0.0143730519,
0.0375100039,
0.004474455,
0.0035693771,
0.0146827688,
0.0337262452,
0.0484980457,
-0.0056884238,
0.0549634732,
0.0545709431,
-0.0048212577,
-0.0039014122,
0.0097152861,
0.0387103483,
-0.0044512381,
-0.0150164301,
0.0744311735,
-0.011062122,
0.0390307866,
-0.0300920364,
-0.0696215183,
0.0638786405,
0.0329730734,
0.0106365671,
0.0062131728,
0.0249942187,
-0.0261934921,
-0.0465136878,
-0.0146071734,
-0.0522270836,
-0.026254613,
-0.0085282559,
0.0149444826,
-0.029725004,
-0.0652139634,
0.0348754562,
0.0227256473,
-0.0477110147,
-0.0477001853,
-0.0708458424,
0.0498791113,
0.0447647274,
0.0306845829,
-0.0678228587,
-0.0708469003,
-0.0132691637,
-0.005776207,
-0.0176923797,
-0.0150886029,
-0.0137847802,
0.018280888,
-0.0493182391,
0.0081006717,
-0.0574145392,
-0.0078393305,
0.0388313606,
0.0393848717,
-0.0369230099,
0.0068971184,
0.0359073691,
-0.028831128,
0.0610988885,
-0.0082788859,
-0.0309604071,
-0.0214103088,
-0.0136674894,
0.0458126441,
-0.0122660948,
-0.0204250813,
0.0183936059,
0.0702890605,
-0.0169886444,
0.011039813,
-0.0551167876,
-0.0801500157,
-0.0046774703,
0.0325013474,
0.0043537184,
-0.0128299501,
0.0272051971,
-0.0369544625,
-0.0130488714,
0.0448497199,
-0.0075938944,
0.0553890206,
0.001938803,
0.0292598698,
0.0035460342,
0.0085103465,
-0.0152878584,
0.0206689499,
-0.0111107118,
0.0117575172,
0.0356981382,
0.0505393371,
0.013103107,
-0.0217202269,
-0.0182885956,
0.016850939,
-0.0326686502,
0.0462972373,
-0.0509996191,
0.0442328118,
-0.0184705704,
-0.0381592475,
-0.075663574,
0.0633273944,
-0.0266478509,
0.027172884,
0.0188282914,
0.0189558957,
-0.0026629085,
-0.0144128166,
0.0061799865,
-0.0395384878,
-0.0195154008,
0.0067192279,
0.003353782,
0.011392111,
-0.0694705322,
-0.0487733372,
-0.0144711817,
-0.0353018939,
0.0153914941,
-0.0483366325,
-0.0093461238,
-0.0517537855,
0.0335956588,
-0.0011737827,
0.0394481719,
-0.0244234409,
-0.0597695522,
0.026552584,
-0.040392261,
0.0380798988,
0.0630414933,
-0.0594857186,
0.0087001696,
0.0527836494,
0.0048204293,
-0.0316407941,
0.0174099952,
0.0392867811,
-0.0449246801,
0.004026012,
0.0003431019,
0.0065937913,
0.090349637,
-0.0326299146,
-0.0088758403,
-0.0297828615,
-0.0065886304,
0.0180497561,
-0.0038255041,
0.0278554484,
-0.0312556103,
-0.0149915153,
0.0263834428,
-0.0400935113,
-0.0889971331,
0.0310917776,
-0.0413652807,
-0.0123425983,
-0.0028457276,
-0.0390102193,
-0.0813527852,
0.0026884957,
0.0315827876,
-0.0028306451,
0.0007494004,
-0.0438656621,
-0.0189209767,
0.0232961457,
-0.0570552647,
-0.0240639541,
0.06254033,
-0.0377049111,
-0.0018349673,
-0.0045195986,
-0.0321779251,
-0.0420196801,
0.0025362782,
-0.0261369236,
0.0378063321,
-0.0006106879,
-0.0303551462,
0.0140672857,
-0.0163687356,
-0.0129781421,
0.0639898032,
0.0112492368,
0.0173701253,
-0.032758642,
-0.0242747962,
-0.0308772009,
-0.0541793332,
-0.0202639159,
-0.0241060853,
-0.0100030741,
0.0300618727,
0.0572959036,
0.0119735999,
-0.0609252304,
0.015265042,
0.0438635908,
-0.03161107,
-0.0574201383,
0.065155305,
0.0567132831,
-0.069212988,
-0.0216849037,
0.0912275389,
0.021637043,
-0.0352672823,
0.013916227,
-0.0247253571,
0.0347348265,
0.0767885149,
0.033608485,
-0.0704361945,
-0.0337368585,
-0.0019897826,
0.0313071832,
0.00362844,
-0.0116218701,
-0.0119059924,
-0.0814249068,
0.0187018644,
0.0091632865,
-0.0168597251,
-0.0262161344,
-0.0484041609,
-0.0039111073,
0.0050317501,
-0.0502313226,
0.048121199,
-0.026610544,
0.0228656475,
0.0350388065,
0.0256800279,
0.0161983129,
0.0357718244,
-0.0460956246,
0.0459503978,
0.073826693,
-0.029503772,
0.0055768476,
-0.0223078784,
0.0460180044,
-0.033405602,
0.0035312388,
-0.0322709903,
0.0228713993,
-0.0028955233,
-0.0191586483,
0.0467224829,
0.03271861,
-0.0638807416,
-0.0075244089,
0.0311956313,
0.0672466308,
0.0064965766,
0.0166028291,
-0.0467296205,
-0.0399522521,
-0.028357707,
0.0264379233,
0.0404635295,
-0.0063482532,
-0.0402434692,
-0.0656345338,
-0.0498364717,
-0.0352626927,
0.0193201918,
0.01252547,
-0.0100880833,
-0.0346538275,
-0.0446566455,
0.0034820791,
0.0088015413,
0.0387478843,
0.0193393398,
-0.0261182208,
0.0114032961,
-0.053952463,
-0.0664892644,
-0.0057952199,
-0.0284154024,
0.0318400301,
-0.1066499054,
0.0021534567,
0.0175217707,
-0.004151497,
-0.0216834173,
0.0070932969,
-0.132752955,
-0.0465667583,
-0.0031240263,
0.1081959903,
0.0189813618,
0.0070456387,
-0.0209878162,
-0.0224318188,
-0.0067865546,
-0.0014262955,
-0.030786816,
0.0279532149,
0.0277998894,
-0.0071592811,
0.039051421,
-0.0043774364,
-0.0309229549,
0.0146806631,
0.0274487454,
-0.0192202833,
-0.0344498865,
0.0125525203,
0.0222104397,
0.0037501287,
-0.0159051176,
0.0330109857,
-0.0471218601,
-0.002917998,
0.0417027026,
0.0176193621,
-0.0060121478,
-0.0289335493,
0.0294635668,
0.028701311,
-0.0166502502,
0.018617535,
-0.0203981847,
-0.009382573,
0.0652384833,
-0.0139029855,
0.0768394023,
0.0087021803,
0.0534548871,
0.0618009903,
-0.0009657454,
-0.0231494065,
0.0108810337,
-0.0231184214,
0.0463759936,
-0.0403541811,
0.0256602485,
-0.0123611428,
0.047554642,
-0.0137977935,
0.0286718626,
-0.045697201,
-0.0361296199,
-0.0083236936,
0.0250045545,
0.0286907777,
0.0203908924,
0.0021643925,
-0.0062959325,
0.0177373942,
-0.0258336607,
0.0563633144,
-0.0090599908,
-0.0624183007,
0.0187800769,
0.0341304317,
0.0094211549,
-0.0311493687,
0.0702774674,
0.0067531439,
0.0724148601,
0.0133858975,
0.0280260649,
-0.0441820174,
0.0290563647,
0.0694008172,
0.0251753777,
-0.0005337218,
-0.008398206,
0.0184577685,
-0.0473074764,
0.0265668519,
0.0283142868,
0.0056551425,
-0.0260536298,
0.024755897,
0.0646854863,
0.016542362,
-0.0198198296,
-0.0114018722,
0.0000112577,
0.024749374,
-0.0614510775,
0.0016370286,
-6.47721338e-33,
-0.0230492074,
-0.002411617,
0.0290753357,
0.0080709029,
-0.0172419641,
0.0317771845,
-0.0298079792,
-0.0236508604,
-0.0256913938,
-0.0485704765,
-0.0074086762,
0.0397648364,
0.0028422102,
-0.0263459459,
0.0421546288,
0.0218876377,
0.027301766,
0.0092236279,
-0.0304938946,
0.0377597325,
-0.0129916044,
0.0221500359,
0.0332133472,
-0.0289761703,
-0.0253701583,
-0.023216024,
0.0182656869,
-0.000937001,
-0.0163514949,
0.0537074916,
-0.0063539688,
-0.0028648993,
0.0177826528,
-0.025661217,
-0.0141317956,
-0.0005781397,
-0.0386479832,
-0.0322151631,
0.0192629974,
0.0138841067,
-0.0172724929,
-0.095998317,
0.0574004427,
0.0066765668,
-0.0036991057,
0.0103547862,
0.008297665,
-0.0061448324,
0.0049670865,
0.0227444302,
-0.0623570494,
0.0213368144,
-0.0183628071,
-0.024892481,
-0.0097811734,
-0.030451091,
-0.0122744916,
0.043635428,
0.0105277319,
0.0103550963,
0.0108945249,
0.0768665001,
0.0567888804,
-0.0055712541,
-0.0219297595,
0.0062461402,
0.0219996013,
-0.0067867651,
-0.0190129951,
0.0203207433,
0.0074159224,
0.0473378226,
0.007809178,
-0.027943179,
0.0119643193,
0.0019843329,
-0.0676250309,
0.0030570603,
0.0461395569,
0.0649855211,
-0.0037468097,
0.0425509214,
-0.0322031677,
0.0059239352,
-0.0215726122,
-0.0385721698,
-0.0151244067,
-0.018761104,
0.044346638,
0.0127143683,
-0.0322974101,
0.0035800971,
0.0285431128,
-0.0211929325,
0.0116527202,
0.0332942307,
-0.0275096484,
0.0422215797,
-0.0180974975,
0.0303869471,
-0.0791167095,
-0.0433314145,
0.0232572593,
-0.0301768463,
0.0925577208,
0.0121504162,
0.0396263041,
0.0313529484,
-0.0671757311,
-0.0083067445,
-0.0691900998,
0.0102889007,
0.0130418055,
0.0664008185,
0.0363260955,
-0.0015538892,
0.017235266,
0.0554686375,
-0.0174552687,
-0.0530967824,
-0.0456503555,
-0.0266173873,
0.0190678649,
0.0243325066,
-0.0566455871,
-0.0097285816,
-0.0686120167,
0.0492770188,
-0.0313865468,
-0.0425737202,
-0.0420350879,
0.0389291346,
2.898e-7,
0.0147305829,
0.0399679206,
0.0353280343,
0.0664556026,
0.0038625482,
0.0199974775,
-0.0446020216,
0.0098604206,
-0.0013353841,
-0.0156695694,
-0.024987286,
0.0095317354,
-0.0118891411,
0.0151840951,
-0.0670601055,
0.0222392436,
-0.0150535014,
0.010322487,
-0.0579488017,
-0.035927847,
0.027788857,
0.0981491134,
0.0063250307,
-0.0166561455,
0.0306358449,
-0.0120917596,
-0.0043008989,
0.0308410786,
0.0138098784,
0.0206747856,
-0.0694795698,
0.0479002707,
-0.0271681119,
-0.0294221323,
0.008180676,
-0.0142898187,
-0.0022332189,
0.0857306719,
-0.0208376199,
0.0244415626,
0.0597074255,
-0.0094494931,
-0.0099758673,
-0.0614630394,
0.0505857617,
0.0340976566,
0.0033108755,
-0.0291746631,
-0.0189405959,
0.0121777346,
-0.0074248537,
-0.0114006158,
0.0383130945,
0.0202558413,
-0.0016486835,
-0.0512406081,
-0.0512800179,
-0.0470891632,
-0.0502206087,
-0.0330222137,
-0.0026786188,
-0.0207065474,
-0.0835676417,
0.0245038327,
0.0110648656,
-0.0613784529,
-0.0083109466,
2.931906071e-34,
0.0217695422,
-0.0600649901,
0.0461373031,
0.0700578019,
0.012785689,
-0.0021750461,
-0.0331910923,
0.0217150468,
0.0088905124,
-0.0257689096,
-0.0321767107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12898v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12898v2 | Can Linguistic Knowledge Improve Multimodal Alignment in Vision-Language Pretraining? | 2023-08-24T16:17:40 | 2023-08-25T12:22:53 | Fei Wang, Liang Ding, Jun Rao, Ye Liu, Li Shen, Changxing Ding | cs.MM | cs.MM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | The multimedia community has shown a significant interest in perceiving and
representing the physical world with multimodal pretrained neural network
models, and among them, the visual-language pertaining (VLP) is, currently, the
most captivating topic. However, there have been few endeavors dedicated to the
exploration of 1) whether essential linguistic knowledge (e.g., semantics and
syntax) can be extracted during VLP, and 2) how such linguistic knowledge
impact or enhance the multimodal alignment. In response, here we aim to
elucidate the impact of comprehensive linguistic knowledge, including semantic
expression and syntactic structure, on multimodal alignment. Specifically, we
design and release the SNARE, the first large-scale multimodal alignment
probing benchmark, to detect the vital linguistic components, e.g., lexical,
semantic, and syntax knowledge, containing four tasks: Semantic structure,
Negation logic, Attribute ownership, and Relationship composition. Based on our
proposed probing benchmarks, our holistic analyses of five advanced VLP models
illustrate that the VLP model: i) shows insensitivity towards complex syntax
structures and relies on content words for sentence comprehension; ii)
demonstrates limited comprehension of combinations between sentences and
negations; iii) faces challenges in determining the presence of actions or
spatial relationships within visual information and struggles with verifying
the correctness of triple combinations. We make our benchmark and code
available at \url{https://github.com/WangFei-2019/SNARE/}. | [
0.0270845685,
0.0443469919,
0.0038519325,
0.0811157301,
-0.0532377101,
-0.0102940993,
-0.0084169749,
-0.0309464037,
-0.0578310303,
-0.0608531833,
-0.0729126483,
-0.019500643,
0.0306608472,
0.0208783839,
0.0253263898,
-0.0542911477,
0.0540480688,
0.0198036283,
-0.0241451748,
0.0220154338,
0.0457366295,
0.0104081882,
-0.0356773846,
0.0143824238,
-0.0765952319,
-0.0438455418,
-0.019956585,
0.0423337482,
0.0297920853,
-0.0230143536,
-0.0189170837,
0.0231992491,
0.0151194884,
0.0237729028,
0.0000017842,
-0.0457722135,
0.0330311134,
-0.0132021019,
0.0215402525,
-0.0068312148,
0.0316214077,
-0.0450498797,
0.0123162959,
-0.034438204,
-0.0599068254,
-0.011563194,
0.1121794283,
0.0102046505,
0.057013724,
0.0484965183,
-0.0304792598,
-0.0105099166,
-0.0172923859,
0.002830117,
0.0129386177,
-0.0250389706,
0.0030637165,
0.0024982099,
-0.0411509499,
-0.009438796,
-0.0881061032,
0.0290009789,
0.0155347874,
0.0080982978,
0.0165053383,
0.041318167,
-0.0364993326,
-0.0500092544,
-0.0277038552,
0.0820185095,
-0.0334301852,
-0.0307626855,
-0.0369902104,
0.0051167114,
-0.0008911862,
-0.007373319,
-0.0105248513,
0.0317316353,
-0.0060990751,
0.0285273604,
-0.0414812937,
-0.0075379284,
0.0151103409,
-0.0132332379,
0.0092434147,
0.0493597537,
0.0125355376,
0.0137835341,
0.0086842496,
0.0185706299,
0.0036126287,
-0.0612824112,
-0.0171878356,
-0.0060774786,
-0.0078458525,
0.0016563437,
-0.0683138072,
-0.0126381218,
-0.0180731192,
-0.0523340292,
0.0626151338,
0.0596008003,
-0.0694481358,
0.0742160603,
-0.043086268,
0.064518936,
-0.0308691673,
0.0620198213,
-0.0336401947,
0.0004923714,
-0.0205292758,
-0.0154403998,
-0.0204188135,
-0.0329063386,
-0.0435608104,
-0.0718923658,
-0.0148530295,
0.0072772317,
-0.0086161522,
0.0462520123,
-0.0499534979,
0.028011648,
-0.0057328604,
-0.0003475106,
-0.0283685327,
0.0494912155,
-0.0248962604,
0.0399782881,
-0.0283528604,
-0.0623711683,
-0.0128164152,
0.0727966502,
-0.0138332052,
-0.0480913296,
-0.0116180684,
0.0563075542,
-0.0370633751,
-0.0293403864,
-0.0160762649,
-0.0171288233,
-0.0481088907,
-0.0401508883,
0.0698421672,
-0.0416871533,
0.045379851,
0.0070785405,
-0.0077235145,
-0.0620501526,
-0.0001539414,
-0.0018422154,
0.0149171213,
0.0869708881,
-0.028295286,
-0.0024902862,
-0.0242873002,
-0.0219314843,
0.0246282108,
0.0563479848,
0.0262220446,
0.0136459908,
0.0050724652,
-0.0018919875,
-0.0244380869,
0.040763326,
0.0071099987,
0.0104939556,
-0.0819184184,
-0.0229798425,
0.0368102118,
0.032962326,
0.0651358739,
0.0384355411,
-0.0064083538,
-0.0652329773,
0.0641658977,
0.0346985236,
-0.014116616,
-0.0256162118,
0.0512234084,
-0.0200636499,
0.0081671048,
0.0082787815,
-0.055332765,
0.069755435,
-0.023986984,
0.0078473324,
-0.0247522425,
0.043863371,
-0.0233556479,
-0.0245898981,
-0.0225866064,
0.0037052471,
0.0180344004,
0.0017386957,
0.0330516845,
0.0205128472,
-0.0223460719,
0.0374627151,
0.011083954,
-0.0250748005,
0.0084635271,
0.0175282229,
-0.0115713952,
0.0061623785,
-0.0125116371,
-0.0139520951,
-0.0531356335,
0.031801749,
0.0154761281,
0.0769118145,
0.0065486613,
0.0369108692,
0.0575295836,
-0.0489955209,
-0.0597807094,
-0.0524928942,
0.0068754302,
0.0077916998,
0.0072552119,
-0.0212813132,
-0.0016390261,
-0.0295229796,
0.0242069419,
0.0542082563,
0.0416392349,
0.0094622327,
-0.0691905394,
0.0395195261,
0.0345276594,
-0.0031962499,
-0.0318783075,
-0.0064781732,
-0.0045768912,
-0.0372608602,
0.0319293775,
0.0313242525,
-0.0430978872,
-0.0530615598,
0.0491372719,
-0.058908239,
-0.0266512167,
0.0183143895,
-0.0209313873,
-0.0137975691,
0.0038720535,
-0.024458332,
-0.0012445423,
-0.0256537441,
0.0055422168,
0.0066784602,
0.0304170307,
-0.0322606154,
0.028142143,
-0.0077277021,
-0.0072109229,
-0.0386674665,
-0.0082132854,
0.0508968942,
-0.0137992967,
-0.0362477899,
-0.0120852254,
-0.0306724943,
0.0063296887,
-0.001738659,
-0.0211474039,
-0.0626520142,
0.0209105425,
-0.0864665955,
-0.0020219951,
-0.0131152635,
0.006373175,
0.0233366266,
-0.0125738168,
-0.0025219156,
-0.0538164452,
-0.0308466628,
0.0439115167,
-0.0024269077,
0.0188246015,
0.0450035259,
-0.0089561278,
-0.0155988652,
-0.0361760184,
-0.0053830938,
-0.0279776137,
0.0794507414,
0.0062963888,
-0.0248835254,
0.0009072119,
0.0116663491,
-0.06581036,
0.0114643034,
-0.0031982756,
-0.0452857278,
0.0380345695,
-0.0026694254,
0.0026889325,
0.0579592288,
-0.0190374441,
0.0001628294,
0.041084893,
-0.0335607231,
-0.0250391699,
0.0061237938,
0.0011037784,
-0.0330920666,
-0.0314546749,
0.0208008513,
-0.0114251142,
0.073784247,
-0.0019023062,
-0.0018180549,
-0.0721557364,
0.015654536,
-0.0010341167,
-0.0452469997,
-0.0293539688,
0.0074567231,
0.0116150603,
0.0502668619,
-0.0662517622,
-0.0307473093,
0.0354409218,
-0.0608314537,
-0.0364846811,
0.00610345,
0.0160713047,
0.0054190145,
0.0716251582,
0.0446897075,
0.0677280426,
-0.0035138119,
-0.004420673,
-0.0708873719,
-0.0416246653,
0.0294010695,
0.023275964,
0.0259208307,
-0.033625111,
0.0216966122,
-0.0324918218,
-0.018824013,
-0.0257792827,
-0.004041696,
-0.020911105,
-0.0149738165,
-0.0444797277,
0.0149234738,
-0.0149333943,
0.0087845912,
0.0432932675,
0.0119372271,
0.0108799078,
-0.0177106336,
-0.0142046921,
0.0281045996,
0.0267116856,
0.0235329606,
-0.0184219815,
-0.044575233,
-0.0446210317,
0.0449499935,
0.0138511155,
0.0159856491,
-0.0841728076,
0.0432177372,
0.0189316813,
0.0267776549,
-0.0143811107,
0.0224108305,
0.0454181768,
-0.0272799861,
-0.000016579,
0.0512646623,
0.0227797609,
-0.0034366939,
-0.000632055,
0.0123718036,
0.0130458223,
0.0461126678,
-0.0091301426,
-0.0919661298,
-0.0490193181,
-0.0116196182,
-0.0644070208,
0.0582187064,
-0.0110728005,
-0.0255790502,
-0.0785947815,
0.0095792478,
0.0095077856,
-0.0640842542,
-0.009501935,
0.0224777106,
0.004776814,
-0.0109942788,
0.002864534,
-0.0141104748,
0.0106831687,
0.0031276599,
-0.0002856878,
0.0223843902,
-0.0175695457,
-0.0077882591,
-0.0625152886,
0.0040512765,
0.0471274592,
-0.0140304919,
-0.0103363143,
-0.0403958261,
0.0238207411,
0.0221873466,
0.0177381113,
0.0132629555,
0.0559482239,
-0.0415326357,
-0.0703301579,
0.034885142,
0.0037404583,
-0.0308972951,
-0.0156679545,
-0.0494529828,
0.018507991,
-0.0018397396,
0.0210137237,
-0.0308706723,
0.0359621458,
-0.0310737099,
0.032957118,
0.0211779233,
-0.0276805311,
-0.0235629566,
0.0168475714,
0.0105709517,
-0.0230960809,
-0.0396156721,
0.0317991376,
0.0084465034,
-0.0022150036,
-0.0341565534,
-0.0327030458,
0.0174171459,
0.0640761256,
0.004518765,
-0.0420536548,
0.0302837063,
-0.0129450765,
-0.0807305872,
0.0903986394,
0.002645921,
0.0251843538,
-0.0135588897,
0.0025851575,
0.0080218883,
-0.0101271635,
-0.0196012836,
-0.0120643908,
-0.0624288805,
-0.0498087704,
-0.0098091951,
0.0379249193,
0.0148181049,
0.0443173274,
0.0281050578,
0.0079698227,
-0.0145325782,
0.0512618385,
0.0062039844,
0.0682886392,
-0.0076370258,
-0.0451797396,
-0.0039593363,
0.0032871703,
-0.0302670468,
0.0084379958,
0.0451965183,
0.0381487794,
-0.0110410554,
-0.0327655226,
0.0277108774,
-0.014239382,
0.0911623463,
-0.0006213742,
0.0392472371,
-0.0302872695,
-0.0337494314,
0.0128912106,
-0.0182837024,
-0.067899853,
-0.0350359827,
0.0292661712,
0.0378099158,
0.0229574703,
0.0204353817,
0.0142006082,
0.0412730053,
0.009590649,
-0.046474196,
0.0062652789,
-0.0431713462,
-0.0220315754,
0.0499439724,
-0.0112357726,
0.0190414339,
-0.0249451455,
0.015713077,
0.0039728503,
0.0412944406,
0.0655293539,
0.0149773322,
-0.0491363108,
0.0384125523,
0.0232733432,
0.0235291235,
0.0020879684,
0.01550892,
0.0903630853,
-0.0483585261,
0.0315409936,
-0.0192288049,
-0.0060385945,
-0.0051034926,
0.0530337356,
0.0047568935,
-0.0423955098,
0.0654657707,
0.000528426,
0.0002654119,
-0.0411287621,
0.0405400991,
-0.0046833246,
0.0235650688,
0.0009422437,
0.0116732158,
-0.0345031433,
-0.0432561636,
0.0413506888,
0.001959584,
-0.0095376894,
0.0267480575,
-0.03120148,
-0.0712038353,
0.0064987736,
0.0411040932,
-0.0151292263,
0.0216249507,
0.0658170953,
0.0435148105,
0.0173654221,
-0.0431104563,
0.0304256696,
-0.0655301288,
0.0083244778,
0.0087354491,
0.0199430175,
-5.570267693e-33,
-0.0565776192,
-0.0035936749,
0.039455656,
0.0063110692,
-0.0347292237,
0.0150102451,
-0.0191954877,
0.0311091971,
-0.0254503377,
0.0347433798,
0.0423239805,
0.0065579368,
0.0058918139,
0.0364568606,
0.0065054349,
-0.0004190754,
0.0244272407,
-0.0052297302,
-0.0196172744,
-0.053487245,
0.0296888966,
0.0054970607,
0.0612042956,
-0.044832781,
-0.0428463407,
0.0514413863,
-0.0455304384,
0.0281713493,
-0.0041212845,
0.0619139075,
-0.0230839867,
0.0041193855,
0.0116467457,
0.0204314142,
-0.0117005138,
0.0085476916,
-0.0346322693,
-0.0489329733,
0.0509914495,
0.0708369389,
-0.0900055468,
0.0046987929,
0.0776004642,
-0.0233459063,
-0.0147458902,
-0.0183617622,
0.0496745333,
0.0016251748,
0.0091845803,
0.0027190377,
-0.0874418691,
-0.0114573222,
-0.0229227971,
-0.0284397453,
0.04276767,
0.0082156714,
0.015257353,
0.019321898,
-0.0512279384,
0.0010255141,
-0.0673739836,
0.0403665118,
0.095328398,
0.0865423903,
0.0110128131,
0.067182526,
0.0494413339,
-0.0480019674,
-0.0096016759,
0.0365574621,
0.0646559745,
0.0177022256,
0.0197282378,
0.0690716207,
-0.0020649044,
0.046648562,
-0.0373408645,
-0.0056645074,
-0.0466250107,
0.0699422285,
-0.0039693136,
0.0215416234,
0.0018190335,
-0.0007609066,
-0.0462990813,
0.0206743125,
-0.0451785177,
-0.0051359655,
0.0578398854,
-0.0111875953,
0.0230687819,
0.0258345194,
0.0561561994,
-0.0228446722,
-0.0027133431,
0.0106443148,
-0.0320973508,
0.0682141855,
-0.0036379399,
0.0380527303,
-0.0333836377,
-0.0222720858,
0.0247214045,
0.0019210876,
0.0378586166,
0.0157755837,
0.0444188714,
0.0280808862,
-0.0246751402,
-0.0073755221,
-0.0257405043,
-0.0322145335,
-0.022752272,
0.0059260973,
0.0755797029,
0.0243810453,
-0.0615955815,
0.0290346518,
0.0171305481,
-0.0278800577,
-0.0170273371,
-0.0578435957,
-0.0085903369,
0.0214975104,
-0.0163279474,
0.0096381046,
-0.0535075553,
-0.0519496948,
0.0185814351,
-0.0561705455,
-0.0227650944,
0.0353626758,
2.558e-7,
0.0534740351,
0.0329553224,
0.0257610809,
0.0304142609,
-0.0018333613,
0.0676197335,
-0.0365500152,
0.0467747077,
-0.0504378192,
-0.0553786904,
-0.0169572774,
0.0508652702,
0.0151100541,
-0.0093858726,
0.0008188018,
0.0459478572,
-0.0277027749,
0.007381496,
-0.0584504418,
0.0564330406,
0.0627077222,
0.0569630526,
-0.015878953,
0.0051919529,
0.0355794467,
-0.0620178729,
0.0775591135,
-0.0124217905,
-0.0106836017,
0.0040374594,
0.0202389266,
-0.0125962002,
-0.0349170044,
0.0313266478,
0.0209821425,
-0.0087206215,
0.0230732039,
0.0114951385,
-0.0507383049,
-0.0172000565,
-0.0319135077,
0.0288578849,
-0.0296429656,
-0.0544128567,
0.0565001555,
-0.0488395467,
-0.0183150768,
-0.004274454,
-0.0481006317,
0.0286002941,
0.0350558087,
0.0056149256,
-0.0425287001,
-0.0076834657,
0.0504055992,
0.0071504503,
-0.0864135176,
-0.0646518171,
-0.0411660112,
0.0402124487,
-0.0273859818,
0.0118436832,
-0.0445480905,
0.0198450219,
0.0697219595,
-0.0195238963,
-0.0562323071,
1.906578598e-34,
-0.0107393442,
-0.0113725839,
0.0459419973,
-0.0209349561,
0.0056088497,
-0.022370236,
-0.0435901061,
0.014358256,
-0.0182719547,
-0.0305960011,
0.0062356237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12896v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12896v3 | Beyond Document Page Classification: Design, Datasets, and Challenges | 2023-08-24T16:16:47 | 2023-10-31T10:35:39 | Jordy Van Landeghem, Sanket Biswas, Matthew B. Blaschko, Marie-Francine Moens | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper highlights the need to bring document classification benchmarking
closer to real-world applications, both in the nature of data tested ($X$:
multi-channel, multi-paged, multi-industry; $Y$: class distributions and label
set variety) and in classification tasks considered ($f$: multi-page document,
page stream, and document bundle classification, ...). We identify the lack of
public multi-page document classification datasets, formalize different
classification tasks arising in application scenarios, and motivate the value
of targeting efficient multi-page document representations. An experimental
study on proposed multi-page document classification datasets demonstrates that
current benchmarks have become irrelevant and need to be updated to evaluate
complete documents, as they naturally occur in practice. This reality check
also calls for more mature evaluation methodologies, covering calibration
evaluation, inference complexity (time-memory), and a range of realistic
distribution shifts (e.g., born-digital vs. scanning noise, shifting page
order). Our study ends on a hopeful note by recommending concrete avenues for
future improvements.} | [
-0.0116243772,
-0.0116893686,
0.0074855261,
0.0059791245,
-0.0168270208,
0.0424151011,
0.0336419307,
0.0376233831,
-0.00752343,
-0.070243679,
-0.0306470823,
-0.0090201246,
0.0137084499,
0.0060161888,
-0.0149974264,
-0.0150548881,
0.0069634523,
0.0169325341,
-0.015815746,
0.0394745357,
-0.003920963,
-0.0058402969,
0.0071510416,
-0.0225252248,
-0.0089183087,
-0.0423604399,
-0.0364180617,
0.0429783873,
-0.0053723687,
-0.0060719675,
0.0132026188,
0.0057731904,
0.0560650341,
0.0521819554,
0.0000018536,
-0.0362054706,
-0.0417090394,
0.0217816997,
-0.0115931937,
0.0461847484,
0.098758243,
-0.0489129126,
0.0120258685,
-0.0237720739,
0.0044979844,
-0.0171702635,
0.0288272165,
0.053822007,
-0.0029809242,
0.0594973899,
-0.0277638417,
-0.0251155403,
0.0288166534,
-0.0185173098,
0.0745018795,
-0.0334093571,
-0.0122128017,
0.0044678403,
0.0152455131,
-0.0100488365,
-0.035186097,
-0.003862171,
0.0227527637,
-0.0158790201,
0.0111700995,
0.027402956,
-0.0193515196,
0.0203124546,
-0.0012820973,
0.0296579469,
-0.003439083,
-0.0329950489,
0.0140033253,
-0.0354580358,
-0.0436703339,
0.0090946211,
-0.0312720053,
-0.0207244419,
-0.0418418236,
-0.0068878173,
-0.0216032024,
0.0444470868,
0.0008500908,
-0.011948945,
-0.0526748598,
0.0028777188,
-0.0147280283,
-0.0317970775,
0.0457676202,
0.0342984386,
0.0574895553,
0.0252416618,
0.0186213646,
-0.038280189,
0.0503121912,
-0.0207400899,
-0.0470723137,
-0.0827199444,
0.0671875328,
-0.0946322083,
0.0076843332,
-0.0279323719,
-0.0107561192,
0.0824067667,
0.007491577,
0.0194371454,
-0.0052839485,
0.0227971859,
-0.0122020645,
0.0440261662,
-0.0195052251,
0.0159834139,
0.011254672,
0.0132330749,
0.0545647778,
-0.0517363772,
-0.0394643024,
0.0314450823,
0.0083563672,
0.022362493,
0.0088858018,
-0.027111927,
-0.0330680199,
-0.0186356399,
0.0152832381,
-0.012302666,
-0.0214757007,
0.0339015499,
-0.0302317981,
-0.0153603163,
0.0289252251,
0.027996663,
-0.0077429404,
-0.0016323325,
0.0048760264,
0.0197645221,
-0.0078324648,
-0.0691493601,
-0.0583062656,
0.0006670432,
0.0042810976,
-0.0331984572,
0.0297572799,
-0.0201125201,
0.0266089588,
0.0174845271,
0.0007932641,
0.0560647584,
-0.0466944054,
-0.0079506095,
0.0034049999,
0.051215332,
0.0430902317,
-0.0052261525,
0.0743633509,
0.0145339714,
-0.0399050824,
0.0605300441,
0.018296985,
0.0313242413,
0.0527690575,
-0.0557386316,
0.0187886544,
0.0217428561,
-0.000781458,
-0.0423255526,
0.0519360043,
0.0056583574,
0.0007636743,
-0.0213967767,
0.0138710225,
-0.016895337,
-0.0318205804,
-0.033506956,
0.0167701803,
0.0204704534,
0.0090514366,
-0.0244663917,
-0.0308805965,
0.0369400568,
-0.0166095179,
0.0288962591,
0.0180222988,
-0.0099044098,
0.0071705175,
0.0082895001,
0.0379439294,
-0.031302806,
-0.0451120324,
-0.0247042235,
-0.0266769286,
-0.0058484389,
0.0590581894,
-0.0080849053,
0.070029512,
0.0053381934,
-0.0144623825,
0.0276433881,
-0.0040288512,
-0.0435999222,
-0.0217385236,
-0.0201204233,
0.0194792598,
0.0353531651,
0.0605072565,
-0.061179962,
0.0014427924,
-0.0140371099,
0.0267273784,
-0.0257131588,
0.0943412483,
-0.026050739,
0.0163054504,
-0.0649459958,
-0.0216936562,
-0.0185415223,
-0.0000105284,
0.0172109026,
0.0197331291,
0.022566393,
0.0336123519,
-0.0988628864,
-0.043566715,
0.0433590561,
0.0395669714,
-0.0273883156,
0.0332646109,
0.0177226458,
0.0389663093,
0.0336748883,
-0.0253836811,
-0.0270522498,
0.0544421934,
-0.0021212501,
0.0209228806,
-0.0489905365,
0.018810343,
0.0638448894,
0.0035733611,
-0.015083367,
-0.001386283,
0.0383820459,
-0.0471799374,
-0.0245328248,
-0.0151905604,
0.0107910484,
0.0141742108,
-0.0108811175,
0.0394190699,
-0.0027065598,
0.0596547872,
-0.0459092036,
0.0414629988,
0.043350745,
0.0530850515,
-0.016935518,
-0.0223394688,
0.0359020382,
0.0080205891,
-0.0096065421,
0.0190510098,
-0.0388671234,
0.0218376871,
0.0567446649,
0.0136020593,
-0.0273821764,
-0.0121747144,
-0.055855453,
0.0103304181,
-0.0089205774,
0.0346646756,
0.0006149738,
-0.0343714468,
0.0007941079,
-0.0446744636,
-0.0335742049,
0.0271205809,
-0.0279762037,
0.005890687,
0.0215208475,
-0.027779229,
0.0233599544,
0.0231192317,
-0.0282058418,
0.0058009061,
0.0408987626,
0.0358712226,
-0.0475721136,
-0.0465200953,
0.0424983464,
0.0257158708,
-0.0301694181,
-0.0261402875,
0.0148639856,
-0.0105546201,
-0.0336458646,
-0.0288348235,
0.0913239345,
0.0040945755,
0.0413243361,
0.0268284809,
0.0174968243,
-0.0649566576,
0.0142746288,
-0.0202626679,
0.0317760557,
-0.0151912794,
-0.0019891888,
0.0068330159,
-0.0127574438,
-0.0282102097,
0.0267169774,
0.008197315,
-0.0223827567,
-0.0156037854,
0.0040601767,
-0.0138141727,
0.0082823178,
0.0384616703,
0.023489939,
0.0151682002,
-0.0292337332,
-0.001003543,
-0.0262041055,
0.0036458175,
-0.0669609308,
0.0209137835,
-0.0356135629,
0.0545672439,
-0.0201261826,
0.0015330196,
-0.0201809071,
-0.0088617736,
0.0022809412,
0.0242804904,
0.0447120704,
-0.0429014824,
0.0203140415,
-0.0022789398,
0.0349106193,
-0.0611627586,
-0.0430264734,
-0.0038078509,
-0.0336056836,
0.0291406233,
-0.0512972027,
-0.0182906967,
-0.0037554698,
-0.0852416307,
0.055821605,
0.0019899928,
0.0915146917,
-0.0235520732,
-0.0342792794,
0.0207414031,
0.0826317146,
0.0029331173,
-0.0221583657,
-0.0078122485,
-0.0284486022,
-0.0216564648,
0.0590741038,
-0.0108153177,
0.0368391871,
-0.0178297665,
-0.0015991436,
0.0188816916,
-0.0509745069,
-0.0111147733,
-0.0245295074,
-0.0177819505,
-0.0675544739,
0.0061914623,
0.0705018267,
0.0552259684,
-0.1220344529,
-0.0656969845,
-0.0133813741,
-0.0089553269,
-0.00687407,
0.0031655838,
-0.0455649905,
0.0181666743,
-0.0109445322,
0.0450171195,
0.013043548,
0.033714544,
0.0077687232,
-0.0406442657,
0.0493446961,
0.0169674214,
-0.0231474303,
-0.006295484,
-0.0911268219,
-0.0105383461,
0.0152339758,
-0.0217719134,
-0.0499644689,
-0.0071277856,
-0.0507871583,
-0.0049314252,
-0.0350419097,
-0.0244084653,
0.0043926365,
0.0512632392,
-0.0290126912,
0.0310045518,
0.0315823779,
-0.0182927419,
-0.0376125611,
0.0597489625,
-0.0470224731,
-0.0419219881,
-0.0358782783,
0.1076047122,
-0.0236340817,
0.0555505939,
0.0051975362,
0.0221279878,
-0.0022506437,
0.0160185862,
0.0109213013,
0.0139262313,
-0.039115034,
-0.0418071412,
-0.0445734449,
-0.0422352292,
-0.0013275128,
0.0357439816,
-0.0047597447,
-0.0582494028,
-0.0854443684,
-0.0121850129,
0.0610887408,
-0.0013499326,
0.0556030422,
-0.0079856589,
-0.0476121791,
-0.1159128547,
-0.0298586749,
-0.0042828559,
-0.0293719973,
0.0187192634,
-0.0124326227,
-0.0556244887,
-0.0016677392,
-0.021706963,
-0.0687767863,
-0.0246367287,
0.0303946976,
0.0186411832,
-0.0415480919,
-0.0176519752,
0.0544192567,
-0.0231916998,
-0.0338758416,
0.0264198314,
-0.0934850499,
-0.0303752515,
0.0164716877,
-0.0114381956,
0.0259107687,
0.0308077373,
-0.0087515302,
-0.0194437876,
0.0221933555,
0.0066434876,
-0.0207004193,
-0.0251841713,
0.0469959229,
-0.0126346219,
-0.0655952021,
-0.0266195759,
-0.0536251441,
0.0348504297,
0.0012664837,
-0.084243305,
-0.0178728793,
-0.031174155,
-0.0565291755,
-0.0269064382,
0.0014905977,
-0.0082302289,
-0.0126939919,
-0.002224521,
0.0637648478,
0.0071219211,
-0.0258797687,
0.0148885641,
-0.0476086251,
0.0536958799,
-0.0273766108,
-0.0364902504,
0.0892138556,
0.0649996623,
0.0526075363,
-0.0379731506,
-0.0196485259,
0.0315863937,
0.0165107008,
-0.0504435487,
-0.0021713185,
-0.0461004265,
-0.0133035593,
0.0254089069,
0.0569208376,
0.0011888501,
0.0638758764,
-0.011595685,
0.0381294861,
-0.0254050251,
0.0271953251,
-0.0959675238,
0.0370443463,
-0.013271031,
0.0447640941,
-0.0001006091,
-0.0400867946,
0.0510225147,
-0.0289277621,
-0.0441588946,
-0.0199366007,
0.0130860163,
0.0515890568,
0.0184312575,
-0.0322666019,
0.0240084752,
0.0007037311,
0.0291674715,
0.0594238304,
0.0374401286,
-0.0471392758,
-0.0104050646,
-0.0411809199,
-0.0525331162,
0.019789109,
0.0289028566,
0.0348628163,
0.0309562776,
-0.0282733049,
-0.0471128784,
0.0174065698,
0.0874449536,
0.0000336818,
0.0291858744,
0.012300564,
0.0212017819,
0.0854398608,
0.025920257,
-0.0029610123,
-0.043533776,
-0.0127348965,
-0.0346278735,
0.0243427083,
-0.0178203695,
-5.59531858e-33,
0.0104663381,
0.0075410628,
-0.0404224247,
0.0327620842,
-0.0188904852,
0.0249386616,
0.0062631569,
-0.0455438197,
0.0328304991,
-0.0172487143,
-0.0373385474,
0.0284642559,
0.0360124223,
0.0037873434,
0.0226580799,
-0.0122462893,
0.0262519456,
-0.0367371924,
-0.0610562861,
0.0749146566,
0.0284599308,
-0.0007602152,
0.0206609685,
-0.0571943745,
0.0091411406,
-0.0211991742,
-0.0059796395,
-0.0861609206,
0.0116202813,
0.0471768342,
-0.0400073119,
-0.0129150981,
0.0413832068,
-0.0084519535,
-0.0068234,
0.0635428727,
-0.0716989115,
-0.0194129571,
-0.0340909101,
0.0722759962,
0.0547548905,
-0.0132017657,
-0.0066076214,
0.003098879,
-0.0269903392,
-0.0471868291,
0.0587726608,
-0.0062029678,
-0.034256652,
-0.061336685,
-0.0150020886,
0.0396390893,
-0.0296136048,
-0.0000094164,
0.0546587631,
0.026985107,
0.0032679276,
0.042607069,
-0.1250942796,
-0.0049514193,
-0.0329090543,
0.0101496754,
0.0444986299,
0.010074188,
0.0138009451,
0.0249462631,
0.0397536308,
0.0616702996,
0.0229936466,
-0.0250814594,
0.0483974107,
-0.0125201344,
0.0031532682,
0.0110895187,
0.0812964886,
-0.0291020107,
-0.0397634991,
0.0716939494,
0.0621238537,
-0.015996838,
0.0371523611,
-0.0089706546,
-0.0747996643,
-0.0238891877,
0.0242971107,
-0.0028803435,
-0.0144031877,
0.0062686363,
0.0118328054,
0.0203231443,
-0.0020189548,
-0.0109367799,
0.0206247494,
-0.0238590855,
-0.0488996319,
0.0395026244,
-0.0043028877,
0.0681171939,
0.0032564651,
-0.0755575895,
0.0009763657,
-0.0642288998,
0.0229063407,
0.0095149288,
-0.0051288242,
-0.0449816622,
0.0735543594,
0.0314393789,
-0.0556377359,
0.0015041033,
0.0210730862,
-0.0440412164,
0.020640472,
0.0531713739,
0.0141058331,
-0.0061506447,
0.0117307594,
0.0431119427,
0.0112634767,
0.0386000536,
0.0206570346,
-0.0500874333,
-0.0090789692,
0.020851694,
0.0062136571,
-0.0201634299,
-0.0132704899,
-0.0199929141,
0.0059084296,
-0.0721017346,
0.0049272692,
0.0177095775,
2.519e-7,
0.0672763214,
0.029485859,
0.0515407994,
-0.0086820684,
0.0416070856,
-0.0060864775,
-0.0164223351,
0.0363401733,
-0.0573824383,
-0.0060039428,
0.0232212711,
-0.0046845837,
0.0600514226,
0.0277505573,
-0.0623568371,
0.0043187547,
-0.0363008343,
0.0225951448,
-0.0562842637,
0.0070559978,
0.05676331,
0.0433306918,
-0.0297552422,
-0.0327333696,
0.0330017731,
-0.0157260466,
0.0362013057,
-0.014083745,
0.028495159,
0.0452697016,
0.0694427118,
-0.0075435783,
-0.0303253569,
0.0133016063,
-0.0219660718,
0.0528016798,
0.0228795074,
0.0334111676,
0.0050029713,
-0.016312642,
0.0013138764,
-0.0096812146,
0.019253986,
-0.0302766468,
0.0643267557,
0.0315766111,
-0.0179192461,
-0.024799265,
-0.0341906622,
-0.0273754392,
0.0421864055,
0.0259817932,
0.0249679741,
0.0324878208,
0.010416884,
-0.0383067206,
-0.004093491,
-0.0523698442,
0.0055277105,
-0.0047652447,
0.0150796818,
0.011400464,
-0.0282109901,
0.0076523987,
0.0354988091,
-0.0280436594,
-0.015757855,
2.221662053e-34,
0.0643377155,
-0.0079477159,
-0.0106639499,
-0.0310926381,
-0.0186982341,
-0.0390738696,
0.0313226283,
-0.0229972452,
-0.0106675522,
-0.0828886554,
0.0435223505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12890v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12890v3 | Large Language Models Vote: Prompting for Rare Disease Identification | 2023-08-24T16:09:13 | 2024-01-23T13:42:03 | David Oniani, Jordan Hilsman, Hang Dong, Fengyi Gao, Shiven Verma, Yanshan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The emergence of generative Large Language Models (LLMs) emphasizes the need
for accurate and efficient prompting approaches. LLMs are often applied in
Few-Shot Learning (FSL) contexts, where tasks are executed with minimal
training data. FSL has become popular in many Artificial Intelligence (AI)
subdomains, including AI for health. Rare diseases affect a small fraction of
the population. Rare disease identification from clinical notes inherently
requires FSL techniques due to limited data availability. Manual data
collection and annotation is both expensive and time-consuming. In this paper,
we propose Models-Vote Prompting (MVP), a flexible prompting approach for
improving the performance of LLM queries in FSL settings. MVP works by
prompting numerous LLMs to perform the same tasks and then conducting a
majority vote on the resulting outputs. This method achieves improved results
to any one model in the ensemble on one-shot rare disease identification and
classification tasks. We also release a novel rare disease dataset for FSL,
available to those who signed the MIMIC-IV Data Use Agreement (DUA).
Furthermore, in using MVP, each model is prompted multiple times, substantially
increasing the time needed for manual annotation, and to address this, we
assess the feasibility of using JSON for automating generative LLM evaluation. | [
0.0184222795,
0.061818298,
0.0097904429,
-0.0106687946,
-0.0139541999,
0.0460226834,
0.0234475713,
0.0074592466,
0.0168998633,
-0.0475449935,
0.0140281208,
-0.0496868491,
-0.0227495898,
0.0185332615,
-0.017210966,
-0.030338224,
0.0320048817,
-0.0149790505,
0.0433431752,
-0.0206182189,
-0.0501720458,
0.0186162163,
0.0012696374,
0.0372897647,
0.0481701419,
-0.0412316844,
0.0236356258,
-0.0127723161,
0.0249481034,
-0.0746977404,
-0.0130378129,
0.0588567108,
-0.0129899681,
0.0373527743,
0.0000020905,
-0.0538031198,
-0.0102715194,
0.0354593322,
-0.0620301366,
-0.0218447372,
0.0389382616,
0.0124045536,
0.021858288,
0.0203437507,
-0.0393967479,
-0.0645666271,
0.0397475474,
0.019790506,
0.0196021926,
0.0529857017,
-0.0078365905,
0.004944202,
0.0169426464,
-0.0252135284,
0.0602970757,
-0.0245195217,
0.0517116114,
-0.0371587873,
0.0293344799,
-0.0080150627,
0.0180202406,
0.0470103249,
-0.0110073043,
0.004308884,
0.0105667999,
0.0444225557,
-0.0410579406,
-0.0484164804,
-0.0025218937,
0.0501406565,
-0.0133293457,
-0.0111528914,
0.0166663975,
-0.0087561784,
-0.0064490628,
0.0518301539,
-0.0486235209,
0.0178763717,
-0.0141626932,
0.011575236,
0.0149317039,
0.0000435934,
0.0410734825,
-0.0074653779,
-0.0195569992,
-0.0033434078,
0.009024688,
0.0001129905,
-0.0381105952,
0.0032489675,
-0.0148983821,
-0.0795141235,
-0.0344466716,
0.0363936424,
-0.0685087368,
-0.0197660234,
-0.0063513592,
-0.0551520288,
0.1011303887,
-0.0111518335,
0.0889295042,
-0.0255063102,
-0.0405918173,
0.0519968458,
0.0016029486,
-0.0238066856,
-0.0154949706,
0.0384224318,
-0.0014014136,
-0.0000959358,
-0.048749011,
0.0156205837,
-0.0001078957,
0.0248083696,
-0.0112762153,
0.0049300911,
-0.0722376406,
0.0118053304,
0.0008793139,
0.0230700355,
0.0194475204,
0.0133692613,
-0.0259294752,
0.0092494646,
-0.0143644623,
0.0074517666,
0.0197960697,
0.0026484986,
-0.0034386839,
-0.0636594146,
0.0166142136,
0.0136349462,
0.0358805433,
-0.0219992939,
0.043153204,
0.0598131008,
0.0504080951,
-0.0572198443,
-0.0095257042,
-0.0195464287,
-0.0264159143,
-0.0339938514,
-0.0242664833,
-0.0744582936,
0.0188903976,
0.0137567837,
0.0091286134,
-0.0153368339,
-0.0068994346,
0.0108454721,
-0.0189814828,
0.05993196,
-0.0358509757,
0.0117065981,
0.0185342599,
-0.0096158739,
-0.0073407232,
0.0570561104,
0.0185516197,
0.0048405337,
0.0241128709,
-0.0187513549,
0.0585844293,
0.0123963384,
0.016927423,
0.0140703302,
-0.012940635,
0.0138672367,
0.0220035557,
0.0341425613,
-0.0298248716,
0.0365694389,
0.0060410001,
-0.0075196479,
0.0640238747,
0.0825665444,
0.0282479748,
-0.0337828621,
0.0231789052,
0.0032584837,
-0.0335579738,
-0.048966594,
0.0111073367,
0.0333797522,
-0.0352027155,
-0.0037007672,
0.0156453587,
0.0522591472,
-0.0113492636,
-0.0371087827,
-0.0359609462,
-0.0152184255,
-0.048155807,
0.0451517142,
0.0479263552,
-0.0233968701,
0.006175301,
0.0046050241,
0.0522019826,
-0.0287535097,
-0.0370946638,
-0.0836056396,
0.041843079,
0.0684454441,
0.0472568013,
-0.0078560831,
-0.0629773885,
-0.0205127709,
0.002106234,
0.0177421886,
-0.0017192161,
-0.0206897929,
0.014456505,
-0.0163887702,
-0.0129488111,
0.0504553691,
0.0147488285,
-0.0366026796,
0.0038036364,
0.015961444,
-0.039481055,
-0.0436722413,
-0.0274268519,
0.0354043432,
-0.0542488359,
-0.0352497101,
0.0364587605,
0.0081165256,
0.0417357497,
0.0153745422,
-0.0202340111,
0.0180169642,
0.0111593651,
-0.0519321561,
-0.0534197539,
-0.0042362162,
0.0232185796,
-0.0444334,
0.0177214257,
0.0304876491,
-0.0202228837,
-0.0303230882,
-0.047260128,
-0.0236552842,
-0.0440915413,
-0.0194715839,
0.0106634907,
-0.0145128863,
0.0110156192,
0.002926504,
0.0028531356,
-0.0336435921,
0.0542677119,
-0.0130506037,
-0.0124308346,
0.0122273974,
-0.049804531,
0.0053023351,
-0.046300441,
-0.0376712903,
0.0215766747,
0.013996399,
0.0150986919,
0.002506349,
0.013367936,
0.0039090193,
-0.0086915009,
-0.0765509233,
0.0151907494,
0.0195576102,
0.0121379634,
-0.0097080572,
0.0339220054,
-0.0291746296,
-0.0275611915,
-0.0373869948,
-0.0100583117,
0.025018245,
0.0390012003,
0.0335528404,
-0.0028940616,
-0.0552768409,
-0.0339055508,
-0.0045700716,
-0.0272891428,
0.0599572994,
0.0301388036,
-0.0108859511,
-0.0081082638,
-0.0011425256,
-0.0398168117,
-0.0000758174,
0.0354316719,
-0.0042991312,
-0.0014833743,
-0.038694419,
-0.0185790081,
0.061650835,
-0.0019376674,
0.0177499559,
0.0649977103,
0.0284728855,
-0.0539358705,
-0.0031001403,
-0.0388712883,
-0.0287586749,
0.0129964389,
-0.0332437977,
0.0021615531,
0.0505381674,
0.0084350761,
0.0005845832,
-0.0350647531,
0.0435297303,
0.0167018678,
0.0068072425,
-0.035927657,
0.0215744842,
-0.0158346724,
0.0612016134,
-0.0046004523,
-0.0698239133,
0.0716205761,
-0.0229638536,
0.018791208,
-0.0487505309,
-0.0172007531,
-0.0255878214,
0.0493232347,
-0.0043103131,
0.0312416032,
0.0004273241,
-0.0117801502,
0.0049865665,
-0.0054008886,
0.0102618868,
-0.0707838833,
0.0425206684,
-0.0057353596,
0.0237680618,
0.0063875485,
-0.0470072143,
-0.0283114184,
-0.0312101934,
-0.0635628551,
-0.0053600995,
-0.0254084319,
-0.0259520262,
-0.043708954,
0.0168384537,
-0.0015536586,
0.0533855595,
0.0204391535,
-0.0202547126,
0.0083892234,
0.0019055891,
0.0374160707,
-0.0127083994,
-0.0164659675,
-0.0124980463,
0.0784876049,
0.0534078628,
0.0082830815,
0.0646339133,
-0.0359568894,
-0.0053963177,
0.025523087,
-0.0275710057,
0.0076784501,
0.0335176848,
0.0281352121,
-0.0554337762,
0.0054874439,
0.1081297919,
0.0078956168,
-0.0845244005,
0.0103726741,
-0.0158840865,
0.0180978961,
-0.0071878722,
0.0400792547,
-0.1081448421,
-0.0310300607,
0.0242327414,
0.0494795963,
-0.043408975,
-0.0529836975,
0.0177460052,
-0.0788440928,
0.0857492015,
-0.0019558612,
-0.0061353063,
-0.0186383072,
-0.0543345325,
0.0070118145,
-0.0213398263,
-0.0014812058,
-0.0241999216,
-0.0082440367,
0.0042552636,
0.0027621097,
-0.0097210575,
-0.1245030388,
0.0455323011,
-0.0345108137,
0.082480751,
0.0939303339,
-0.0026907236,
0.008568462,
-0.0219892878,
0.0007773992,
0.0511104725,
0.0044077765,
-0.037099205,
0.0704717413,
0.000101997,
-0.0380031466,
-0.0593785346,
0.0276103243,
-0.0395765752,
-0.0275795907,
-0.0122566475,
0.1112212241,
-0.0497340597,
-0.0223983414,
-0.0500042029,
-0.0369527936,
0.029820146,
0.0786413923,
0.0432473607,
-0.0286654383,
-0.0022058282,
0.0075496081,
-0.0003970098,
-0.0085491119,
-0.0146487541,
0.0620528199,
-0.0330346376,
-0.0408778675,
-0.0546089225,
-0.0110500269,
0.0693308339,
0.011662405,
0.0161938109,
0.0686733201,
0.0087332735,
0.0048955539,
-0.0449149981,
0.0322991051,
0.0077731987,
0.0016859036,
-0.0626201779,
-0.0620302483,
0.0758801922,
0.0127290171,
-0.0160161294,
-0.0225868691,
-0.0600171238,
-0.0402611829,
-0.0090698898,
0.0249471087,
0.0242168251,
-0.0021465612,
0.0019517201,
-0.0595764928,
0.0740176067,
0.1034146324,
-0.0004026557,
-0.0053470051,
-0.0052950033,
-0.029562084,
-0.0145195425,
0.0283850376,
-0.0280763526,
0.0339496247,
0.0185388625,
0.0286889486,
-0.0279812254,
0.0135344332,
0.0130606778,
0.0642299578,
0.0597647503,
-0.0519270748,
-0.0684492439,
-0.0284820143,
0.0246074144,
0.0072199041,
0.0023776584,
-0.0385979861,
0.0010762903,
0.0061531472,
-0.0263893399,
-0.0328889266,
0.0171200726,
-0.0154738771,
0.030653229,
-0.0750788301,
0.0838720351,
0.0070626717,
-0.0029466732,
0.067705363,
-0.0176605973,
0.004752438,
0.0461832955,
0.0030883795,
0.0070874202,
-0.0082451124,
0.0226940699,
0.0179386921,
0.0256077982,
-0.0266415793,
0.0332373008,
-0.0331348032,
-0.0636056215,
-0.0232603438,
0.0301279332,
0.0429875739,
-0.0009047951,
0.0356403813,
0.0087162629,
-0.0116427252,
-0.0280054919,
0.0090298615,
-0.0345679149,
-0.0110306144,
0.0406767242,
0.0125678862,
-0.0367558636,
-0.0188556127,
0.1061660424,
-0.0159909334,
0.0650673807,
0.0069190185,
-0.0243342537,
-0.0444916263,
-0.0079230834,
0.0716639608,
-0.0360278711,
-0.0520493798,
0.0031811614,
-0.0510907583,
-0.0603502691,
0.0239559356,
-0.0186748523,
-0.0247409455,
0.0115833143,
0.0093352189,
0.0418470204,
0.0274437852,
-0.0208395198,
-0.0235308576,
0.0160353817,
-0.0311995894,
-0.0459162742,
0.0163431708,
-6.726967726e-33,
0.0075971154,
-0.0391405784,
0.0350302458,
-0.0500172824,
0.0411302112,
0.0148253003,
-0.0090803169,
-0.0238627307,
0.014787971,
0.0201871749,
-0.0232151281,
-0.0190191213,
0.010001082,
0.0413810164,
0.0454258583,
-0.0330954418,
0.044692453,
-0.0200230815,
-0.0143579859,
0.0414805003,
0.0077545717,
0.0279828012,
0.0141817397,
-0.0562823676,
-0.0019374866,
0.0131088626,
-0.0078226374,
0.0266969632,
-0.0308032464,
0.0666331798,
-0.033432804,
0.0340840742,
0.0327310003,
-0.0316579901,
-0.032526724,
0.0108965803,
-0.0329870023,
-0.0220535062,
-0.0249697529,
-0.0196574386,
-0.0028485241,
-0.0288208891,
0.0310647525,
0.003071442,
-0.0269533191,
-0.0043078135,
0.0086763864,
-0.0498652123,
-0.0589999259,
-0.0637763515,
-0.0147163859,
0.0369390026,
0.0181782171,
-0.0135074593,
0.0145092653,
0.0005020196,
-0.0119271437,
0.0658572614,
-0.0074767107,
0.0157571696,
0.0397440232,
-0.0018583371,
0.0355041474,
0.0167219322,
-0.0026373677,
0.0814114138,
0.0482488088,
-0.0315843597,
-0.0357496515,
0.0247638971,
-0.0191747062,
0.0480757132,
0.0389217064,
0.0492783897,
0.0336853042,
0.0069653522,
-0.0778879002,
0.0408384018,
-0.0427036881,
-0.0010808622,
0.0534169599,
-0.0250879675,
-0.0328645892,
-0.0006603699,
-0.0499670506,
-0.0061981333,
-0.0451439358,
-0.0108747594,
0.0271394923,
-0.0080290008,
-0.0218343195,
-0.0107834376,
0.0300332904,
-0.0253470093,
-0.0562578775,
0.012159463,
0.0563417189,
0.016652016,
-0.0173600391,
-0.002548143,
0.0049333014,
-0.0242612604,
0.007266473,
-0.0118630212,
0.0303134434,
0.0457954742,
0.0568023659,
-0.0060178237,
-0.1033181772,
-0.0027158933,
0.00199221,
0.0149112251,
0.007605107,
0.0289594401,
0.0359172598,
0.0188534819,
0.0174799841,
0.0724319667,
0.0078858687,
0.011227129,
-0.0311614573,
0.0199696887,
-0.0435771197,
-0.0224430263,
-0.0206979904,
0.0032175633,
-0.0281875543,
0.0032861519,
0.0400514603,
-0.0336980931,
0.006459957,
-0.019739205,
2.907e-7,
0.0698818266,
0.0722106397,
-0.0360143408,
-0.0224899575,
0.0120921684,
0.0405269936,
0.0007535716,
-0.0098476019,
-0.007196581,
0.0124397147,
0.0387831852,
0.0253014471,
0.0292220078,
0.0608418323,
-0.0917275921,
0.0120330956,
-0.1039849445,
0.0273685828,
-0.0555571429,
0.0070535969,
0.0433432907,
0.1011041701,
-0.0117135951,
-0.046454832,
0.0522759296,
-0.0408882909,
0.0135314828,
-0.0511036702,
-0.0102832066,
0.019975353,
0.0298679844,
-0.0001657958,
0.0401320532,
0.029297743,
-0.027309984,
-0.0177603886,
-0.064747639,
0.0562202334,
-0.0292534381,
0.0022180197,
-0.0018925786,
-0.0122179696,
0.0198738854,
-0.0316107012,
0.0725897104,
-0.0714290142,
-0.0457446054,
-0.0566199683,
0.0199875664,
-0.025909828,
0.0337765552,
-0.0280172825,
0.0016875998,
0.0299113486,
0.0132463574,
-0.0229747966,
-0.018871095,
-0.0473170914,
-0.0099095013,
0.0047559133,
-0.0386567339,
-0.0476747602,
0.0171137396,
-0.0068945144,
-0.0158396084,
-0.0512250848,
0.0163820386,
3.04890082e-34,
0.0342709459,
0.0183441881,
-0.0111972075,
0.0452442504,
0.0078028995,
-0.010065373,
-0.0070425393,
-0.0013713664,
0.0035569724,
-0.1024657562,
-0.0088203764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12888v1 | Inducing Causal Structure for Abstractive Text Summarization | 2023-08-24T16:06:36 | 2023-08-24T16:06:36 | Lu Chen, Ruqing Zhang, Wei Huang, Wei Chen, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The mainstream of data-driven abstractive summarization models tends to
explore the correlations rather than the causal relationships. Among such
correlations, there can be spurious ones which suffer from the language prior
learned from the training corpus and therefore undermine the overall
effectiveness of the learned model. To tackle this issue, we introduce a
Structural Causal Model (SCM) to induce the underlying causal structure of the
summarization data. We assume several latent causal factors and non-causal
factors, representing the content and style of the document and summary.
Theoretically, we prove that the latent factors in our SCM can be identified by
fitting the observed training data under certain conditions. On the basis of
this, we propose a Causality Inspired Sequence-to-Sequence model (CI-Seq2Seq)
to learn the causal representations that can mimic the causal factors, guiding
us to pursue causal information for summary generation. The key idea is to
reformulate the Variational Auto-encoder (VAE) to fit the joint distribution of
the document and summary variables from the training corpus. Experimental
results on two widely used text summarization datasets demonstrate the
advantages of our approach. | [
0.0204347447,
0.0740205571,
-0.0060416004,
-0.0127662132,
0.0030163499,
0.0267247017,
-0.0289170314,
-0.03649823,
-0.0340515673,
-0.0281376634,
0.0576427467,
-0.0222592279,
0.0090758288,
0.0511274561,
0.0503025874,
-0.0789994001,
-0.0025641005,
-0.0129096908,
-0.0054180515,
-0.0043317126,
0.0414490663,
-0.0161249302,
0.0243179426,
0.0141527876,
-0.0063184011,
0.0291677751,
-0.0123188887,
-0.0060638706,
0.0306783468,
-0.0061448715,
0.0134904282,
0.0294126961,
0.0433917977,
-0.0288339388,
0.0000019445,
-0.0291800555,
-0.0314005353,
-0.0026091579,
0.0314419754,
0.0000096891,
0.0110976426,
-0.0593940765,
0.0150937764,
0.0117389569,
-0.0118136797,
-0.001414143,
0.0297162682,
0.0513104163,
0.0613991022,
0.0833308324,
-0.0330964439,
-0.0882479623,
0.0503416024,
-0.0416238531,
0.0086586867,
0.0107933469,
0.0193845592,
0.0502732396,
-0.0336903557,
-0.0061530881,
-0.0296806507,
0.0142265363,
0.0344382226,
-0.023048101,
0.047762461,
0.0148319304,
0.0006280166,
-0.0163306613,
0.0405027121,
0.0681071356,
0.0335849896,
-0.0483806245,
0.0431513079,
-0.0098864036,
-0.0113227339,
0.0547110811,
-0.0563460812,
0.0601115189,
0.0115831643,
0.0028900912,
0.0514497608,
0.0585385524,
-0.00572656,
0.0155768059,
-0.0283727013,
-0.0269518383,
0.0270227939,
-0.0266961921,
-0.0640031472,
0.0198352952,
-0.0128518362,
-0.0409924313,
0.0017033201,
0.0345978029,
-0.0240528192,
-0.0157329738,
-0.0442347266,
-0.0916284323,
-0.011593001,
-0.0398235135,
-0.0008287706,
0.0111371493,
0.0347764976,
0.0033242661,
-0.0157961752,
0.0408293866,
0.0002275884,
0.0035746212,
-0.0667754933,
-0.01077668,
0.0111761447,
-0.0039443839,
-0.0309867151,
0.0157421045,
-0.0166315492,
-0.0288331397,
-0.0508872792,
0.0380836353,
0.0133589869,
-0.0150608253,
-0.0218291748,
0.0323795564,
-0.0217741057,
0.0086368145,
0.0319117047,
-0.0158579145,
-0.0395087898,
-0.0066513638,
0.015922172,
0.0511384346,
-0.0163698308,
0.035384424,
0.0527236499,
0.011310623,
-0.0075029554,
0.0257899128,
-0.0316106118,
-0.0125433914,
-0.0174343251,
-0.0345174782,
0.0216553882,
-0.0112443427,
0.0063156253,
-0.0390230156,
0.0018729968,
0.0127452342,
-0.0270814635,
0.0188711807,
-0.0060965633,
0.0026572379,
-0.0547436178,
0.0163529906,
0.0085320286,
0.0072849211,
0.0448820218,
0.0033489645,
0.0562123209,
0.020224683,
0.0560354553,
0.0326448269,
-0.0025953865,
0.0125409616,
0.0079509728,
0.030075429,
0.0418377519,
0.0213683546,
0.0169188045,
-0.0556882843,
-0.0543512069,
-0.0126401661,
0.036948394,
0.0315114595,
-0.0461239144,
0.0400963649,
0.0499781333,
0.0131196762,
0.0033360075,
0.037460383,
0.057891611,
0.0184126962,
0.0036397227,
0.0610984415,
-0.0048099654,
0.0382739529,
-0.0133166788,
0.073070474,
0.0789302364,
-0.01828143,
-0.029102141,
-0.0678897947,
0.0243953019,
-0.0072461395,
0.0139813796,
-0.039091263,
0.0349483937,
0.0545644835,
-0.0652703866,
-0.0009454727,
-0.0157660954,
-0.0454055183,
0.0406030007,
0.0291290581,
0.0254715383,
0.021792816,
0.0550909229,
-0.0084655527,
0.0004533872,
-0.0137968147,
0.0045406027,
0.0232424643,
0.0039080894,
-0.0317327678,
-0.0469529815,
-0.0476475321,
-0.0504807606,
-0.02096528,
0.0210707393,
0.0066027148,
-0.0305741038,
-0.0392714143,
0.0496205837,
0.0181201547,
-0.0456102788,
0.0370953903,
-0.0461904295,
-0.0247351825,
-0.006806246,
0.0149176195,
0.0148094175,
0.0324154608,
-0.0161755607,
0.0291400682,
0.0002628175,
-0.0468216166,
-0.0363577455,
0.0520735234,
-0.0470893234,
-0.0430977717,
-0.0183589421,
-0.0885386243,
0.0262007322,
0.0291230548,
-0.0243261438,
-0.121142976,
0.0751723722,
-0.0514464006,
-0.0016432049,
-0.0360789262,
0.0068483292,
0.0445785262,
-0.0037706792,
-0.0072901258,
0.0507440493,
-0.0152616622,
0.002576689,
0.0616968982,
0.0214380436,
0.0082115103,
-0.0106597254,
0.0061040171,
-0.0373781174,
0.0192389265,
-0.0162983835,
0.0937169567,
-0.0139664449,
-0.0149000157,
-0.0095226001,
-0.0558152273,
-0.0233694427,
-0.0468656309,
-0.0055944561,
0.0776902437,
0.0455026552,
0.0077852649,
-0.0063921129,
-0.0398179963,
-0.0233258288,
0.0178995766,
0.0101848487,
0.033721298,
-0.0012883362,
0.0235810541,
-0.0477227829,
-0.0060726563,
-0.0143650901,
0.0434044972,
0.0337650366,
-0.0157801993,
-0.0123189529,
0.0084481798,
0.009476291,
-0.0344976783,
-0.0246494599,
-0.0247836635,
-0.0279474594,
-0.0275115184,
0.05355037,
0.0247273836,
0.0591282882,
0.019070724,
0.0270772763,
0.0141529273,
-0.0120339701,
-0.0214098021,
-0.0880049244,
0.0573458523,
0.0143716633,
-0.0526337773,
0.0329008438,
0.077267006,
0.0175106563,
0.0220154803,
-0.0402368158,
0.008383099,
0.0065183062,
-0.0052622589,
-0.0238573477,
-0.0492576584,
-0.0216475874,
0.0163549334,
-0.0263542831,
-0.0334118977,
0.0425532088,
-0.0041528475,
0.0274754092,
-0.0337629542,
0.0200192351,
-0.0480407365,
0.0216171388,
0.0711247548,
0.0254246294,
0.0117847566,
-0.0389504433,
-0.0408017077,
0.0108139236,
0.0531017035,
0.0350884981,
0.0243261848,
-0.0318700075,
0.0284154546,
-0.0092683295,
-0.0132932523,
-0.0179427247,
-0.042657759,
0.0313093141,
0.0318764895,
0.0623630658,
-0.0039014658,
-0.0262812711,
0.0205778684,
0.0121984659,
0.077969566,
-0.0403777026,
-0.0115907183,
-0.0240962449,
0.0712700784,
0.0912942737,
-0.045707494,
0.0094208242,
-0.0720271096,
0.0120849712,
-0.0045536123,
-0.0169178285,
-0.0201165974,
-0.0126317469,
0.0029184741,
-0.0302012004,
-0.0535467751,
0.0189308599,
-0.006642858,
0.0318455622,
-0.0087312674,
-0.0194412656,
0.0947236419,
-0.0053570378,
-0.0407961942,
-0.0042921612,
0.0289545693,
0.0464549996,
0.0026132762,
-0.0120882327,
-0.0561018847,
0.0228790529,
-0.0131241232,
0.0096876202,
0.0202027187,
-0.0214304365,
0.0089240586,
-0.0333887264,
0.0121973176,
0.028144259,
-0.075512208,
-0.0138964085,
-0.0174575038,
-0.0102213733,
-0.0423344187,
-0.0105006164,
0.0039702686,
-0.0248566903,
0.0212720837,
0.0417736582,
-0.0470679812,
-0.0000952076,
-0.0926510766,
-0.0254539158,
-0.0062440145,
0.0838313252,
0.0216912981,
-0.0181356762,
0.0447239392,
0.0274827853,
-0.0457188226,
-0.0062018544,
0.0085298456,
0.0666258708,
-0.0032579494,
0.0295735989,
-0.007895777,
0.0790929571,
-0.0046280092,
-0.0085825883,
-0.0086127687,
-0.0042893239,
-0.0116842305,
-0.0152332,
-0.0689681247,
0.0161839034,
-0.0241267215,
0.0526923016,
0.0497208014,
-0.0168513767,
-0.0380261391,
-0.0378636122,
0.0141849592,
-0.0708676279,
-0.0258726347,
-0.0583274774,
-0.0069489852,
-0.0314186215,
-0.1115808263,
-0.0646234676,
-0.0098758051,
-0.0250612069,
-0.0004984097,
0.0125953779,
-0.0004026628,
-0.0532263592,
-0.0238383319,
-0.0162880179,
0.0177181754,
-0.0198940542,
-0.0190188996,
-0.0446510166,
0.0255229101,
-0.0702591613,
-0.0236771647,
-0.0196838565,
-0.0483831614,
-0.0628651902,
-0.0226675794,
0.0786024481,
0.0159334,
0.095411092,
-0.0060768598,
-0.038156826,
0.0735757202,
-0.0108038345,
0.0165029839,
0.0292179398,
0.0105523644,
0.0238574706,
-0.0219273269,
0.0076557524,
-0.0470564552,
0.0396581925,
-0.0252223182,
0.0642036349,
-0.023494767,
0.0128646176,
0.0207298025,
-0.0156717841,
0.0115794772,
-0.0552287512,
0.018864315,
-0.0500950441,
-0.0296882167,
-0.0284755342,
-0.0102558611,
-0.0434723608,
0.078410171,
-0.0108359195,
0.0425837822,
-0.0203897711,
0.0221850164,
-0.00520752,
0.0145403678,
-0.0416188799,
0.0120718023,
-0.0213972684,
0.0053681447,
-0.0268666558,
0.0095370803,
-0.0182711743,
0.0036441756,
-0.0150997164,
0.0223142058,
-0.0179063305,
0.0237446893,
0.0323579051,
0.045997303,
-0.0080147544,
0.0078530302,
-0.1133887023,
0.0254709888,
-0.0630576611,
-0.0214477014,
0.0383885875,
-0.0572198257,
0.0874398127,
-0.0180895999,
0.0175087191,
0.0018159229,
0.0655997396,
0.0281609241,
-0.0094817616,
-0.0206727181,
0.0061786151,
0.0184254907,
0.0045882673,
0.0808330849,
0.0101569574,
0.0078531923,
-0.0162114799,
0.0073120277,
-0.0235030372,
-0.0370790884,
0.0191464834,
0.0350020044,
-0.0211717095,
-0.0358801372,
-0.0122958887,
-0.0301711075,
0.0038722933,
0.001158919,
0.0367659219,
-0.0060466076,
0.0507814847,
0.0174613819,
-0.031316299,
0.0037231084,
-0.0624081902,
0.0036792059,
-0.0027071559,
-0.0193690173,
-0.030731177,
-5.916868815e-33,
-0.0387995243,
-0.0011147825,
-0.0142919123,
0.0169358253,
-0.0218265597,
0.0217657425,
-0.1129301414,
-0.0206040237,
0.0237747356,
0.0082351146,
-0.0076867742,
0.0124055566,
0.0001302731,
0.0474168882,
0.0239251815,
0.0206874982,
0.057260368,
0.0032164883,
-0.0288397763,
0.0624262281,
0.0304942708,
0.0044276165,
0.0178435277,
-0.0560382344,
0.0397813097,
-0.058085043,
-0.0156065254,
-0.0234877095,
0.0467342287,
0.0263902191,
0.0056308289,
-0.0268375035,
0.0276162326,
-0.0188542977,
-0.0542097352,
-0.0051708003,
-0.0849924162,
-0.028909957,
0.0231729243,
-0.0225584824,
-0.0642182902,
-0.0527721904,
0.0354955941,
-0.0379606225,
0.0284063108,
-0.0269007105,
0.0816578194,
-0.0227824263,
-0.0183067527,
-0.1256018877,
-0.0511363,
0.0137439119,
-0.0431541391,
-0.0005090549,
0.0125122275,
0.0290730353,
-0.0025702869,
-0.0026837308,
0.0131099373,
0.0495056249,
0.0471881926,
0.0322515517,
0.0279736239,
0.0516651571,
0.0108079528,
0.0336989835,
-0.0211792607,
-0.0139764659,
-0.0561274365,
0.0458488725,
-0.0162750408,
-0.0034345612,
0.0191874597,
0.0212694053,
0.0359776802,
0.0376277715,
-0.0479614884,
0.0920308083,
-0.0209363215,
0.005639731,
0.0124379918,
0.0006172875,
0.0144756101,
-0.0284241866,
-0.0471385457,
-0.0389384814,
0.0026014426,
-0.0168263204,
-0.023691047,
0.0487383753,
-0.0349680893,
-0.0489844419,
0.0288174693,
-0.041027572,
0.0258828942,
0.0567287132,
-0.0425710417,
0.0248174109,
-0.0107161412,
-0.0317150652,
-0.0658059791,
0.0163508356,
0.0268416665,
-0.01125398,
-0.004075855,
0.0300131198,
0.0527846776,
0.0038652609,
0.0068433615,
-0.0129072424,
-0.0015672179,
-0.0137127945,
-0.0267584566,
0.0166355819,
0.002084028,
0.0226558335,
-0.0044947239,
0.0556099862,
-0.009206092,
0.041147951,
0.0049833436,
0.002657227,
0.0237523448,
0.0578919575,
-0.0325213149,
0.0133612948,
-0.0275107604,
0.0205132179,
0.058070261,
-0.0630988255,
-0.0199265704,
0.0071714013,
2.456e-7,
0.0489939824,
0.0170431081,
0.056458503,
0.0074083041,
-0.0002558655,
0.0066205538,
0.0100395894,
0.036523167,
0.0277049299,
0.0197054818,
0.0768914074,
0.0107105142,
0.0352622159,
-0.0142201902,
-0.0937059447,
-0.0073356973,
-0.0678772703,
-0.0442272946,
-0.0056102825,
0.0019052367,
0.0404680967,
0.0450284295,
-0.0306091309,
0.0114749661,
0.0091103297,
0.0099100871,
0.07058613,
0.0003374615,
-0.0291585512,
0.0181188788,
-0.003338146,
-0.0414120033,
-0.0417010374,
-0.0066786516,
-0.0425864942,
0.0072008953,
0.027548641,
0.0151701001,
0.0251816381,
-0.0090755047,
-0.0002578378,
-0.0203289408,
0.0417367965,
0.0195457209,
0.0242033452,
-0.0419322774,
-0.0156820342,
0.0277136602,
-0.083738327,
0.0501745641,
-0.0343048796,
0.0057449178,
-0.0415591411,
0.0447739027,
0.0133515308,
0.0147274304,
0.0207415838,
-0.0498308353,
-0.0409579426,
-0.0017364869,
0.012098602,
-0.0094000408,
-0.0237851571,
-0.0004872087,
-0.0031655035,
-0.0319907591,
-0.0373482853,
2.435183944e-34,
0.0887895897,
-0.0003607178,
-0.0287568253,
-0.0139786666,
0.0254689101,
-0.035539683,
-0.0112050958,
0.028351251,
0.024394311,
-0.0892742723,
-0.0389646664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12842v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12842v1 | Text Similarity from Image Contents using Statistical and Semantic Analysis Techniques | 2023-08-24T15:06:04 | 2023-08-24T15:06:04 | Sagar Kulkarni, Sharvari Govilkar, Dhiraj Amin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Plagiarism detection is one of the most researched areas among the Natural
Language Processing(NLP) community. A good plagiarism detection covers all the
NLP methods including semantics, named entities, paraphrases etc. and produces
detailed plagiarism reports. Detection of Cross Lingual Plagiarism requires
deep knowledge of various advanced methods and algorithms to perform effective
text similarity checking. Nowadays the plagiarists are also advancing
themselves from hiding the identity from being catch in such offense. The
plagiarists are bypassed from being detected with techniques like paraphrasing,
synonym replacement, mismatching citations, translating one language to
another. Image Content Plagiarism Detection (ICPD) has gained importance,
utilizing advanced image content processing to identify instances of plagiarism
to ensure the integrity of image content. The issue of plagiarism extends
beyond textual content, as images such as figures, graphs, and tables also have
the potential to be plagiarized. However, image content plagiarism detection
remains an unaddressed challenge. Therefore, there is a critical need to
develop methods and systems for detecting plagiarism in image content. In this
paper, the system has been implemented to detect plagiarism form contents of
Images such as Figures, Graphs, Tables etc. Along with statistical algorithms
such as Jaccard and Cosine, introducing semantic algorithms such as LSA, BERT,
WordNet outperformed in detecting efficient and accurate plagiarism. | [
0.0507274717,
-0.0050149481,
-0.0186707582,
0.1169125363,
-0.0834666565,
0.0173065793,
-0.0061110822,
0.0526653565,
0.0171793476,
-0.0448769554,
-0.0077172546,
0.0833131894,
0.0149145722,
-0.0491946638,
0.0241259988,
0.0143275186,
0.0028092808,
0.0451157093,
-0.0153294215,
0.0116607724,
0.0421392508,
-0.0056800181,
0.0486382656,
0.0292062517,
-0.0428808294,
-0.0068464098,
0.0229966473,
0.0166368335,
0.0336691774,
0.0122694671,
-0.0183715466,
0.0263283849,
-0.0179157443,
0.0515545644,
0.0000014356,
-0.0486206897,
-0.0262709279,
0.0082425317,
0.0544172302,
-0.0073371176,
0.0967657641,
0.0132149542,
0.0125433877,
-0.0493114442,
-0.0096791433,
0.032159254,
0.0313967355,
0.0816578269,
0.1076504514,
0.0240895376,
-0.0608729385,
-0.03673888,
-0.0037521704,
0.0466787443,
0.0078164497,
-0.0199256893,
0.0165549722,
0.0398959629,
0.0309022944,
-0.0012203994,
0.0024446107,
0.0557808541,
-0.0437595993,
-0.0010628736,
-0.0189920682,
-0.0179096404,
-0.0289656278,
0.0178627428,
0.0180974193,
0.013828259,
-0.0829367787,
-0.0783497542,
0.0306400992,
-0.0145308925,
-0.0123700667,
0.0597669557,
0.0018261053,
0.0238639936,
-0.0333166383,
0.0299559161,
0.0023510263,
0.0067148618,
-0.0432326384,
0.0016932437,
0.0436686464,
-0.0118476711,
0.0321146697,
-0.0384088196,
-0.0444741659,
-0.0266360529,
0.0338752568,
-0.0305728279,
0.0270279925,
0.0182324369,
0.0537890233,
-0.032757923,
-0.0407592803,
-0.0994810984,
0.0230990686,
-0.0467905812,
0.015713362,
0.03579247,
-0.0298541877,
0.0525150001,
-0.0335464627,
0.0596887469,
0.0048871315,
0.0510368831,
-0.0253435988,
-0.0362769365,
-0.0405424498,
-0.0067816358,
-0.0253579132,
0.0247498769,
0.0073178611,
-0.0551310889,
-0.0310351159,
0.0229715724,
-0.0021925042,
0.0503951572,
-0.0098682698,
-0.0210170764,
0.0447408631,
0.0375478044,
-0.005699419,
-0.0143461749,
0.0404032432,
0.0378155932,
-0.0734140575,
0.0009165768,
0.041584108,
0.0658495277,
0.0587059595,
0.0094663519,
0.0149201276,
0.0593448915,
0.009913669,
-0.0136059793,
-0.0567376204,
-0.0696909428,
0.0045947381,
-0.0127244778,
-0.0061187469,
-0.066663079,
-0.001062746,
-0.0520909317,
-0.016974356,
-0.0215876978,
-0.0227126572,
0.0485999696,
-0.0753569901,
0.0569167137,
-0.0270025153,
0.0170678552,
0.0227145683,
0.0024852261,
-0.0186047498,
-0.0198581982,
-0.0112086022,
0.034977641,
0.0812395439,
0.0296142418,
0.0021315415,
0.0295757707,
-0.0083330711,
-0.0047469083,
0.0134037128,
-0.0170780849,
0.0056715123,
-0.0056315302,
0.0161799639,
0.0404047482,
-0.0614875145,
-0.0160296913,
0.0393653475,
0.0952574387,
-0.0362116806,
0.028987648,
0.025834782,
0.0187831204,
0.0186077561,
0.0154247871,
-0.0259711463,
-0.0005993164,
0.0183900502,
0.0025834539,
-0.0141735738,
-0.0042492873,
0.0217624605,
0.0361091495,
0.0114347851,
-0.0162946377,
-0.0085759778,
-0.0508050919,
-0.0379958041,
0.026961023,
-0.0406728573,
0.0154417735,
-0.0346837603,
-0.0290369205,
-0.0498062931,
-0.0333177075,
0.0524902977,
0.0571507365,
0.0792123452,
-0.0035412048,
0.0764917731,
0.0038898254,
-0.0270268861,
0.0211539473,
-0.0487336554,
-0.0174432453,
-0.0401122943,
-0.0462261774,
-0.0731011331,
-0.0006166315,
-0.0443315692,
-0.0009962287,
0.0192859955,
0.0530282483,
0.0485975556,
0.0068535497,
-0.053451445,
0.0341395065,
0.0268389694,
0.029367961,
-0.015943747,
0.0300485697,
0.012269198,
0.008497104,
-0.0223213863,
0.0441525877,
-0.026498599,
-0.0154016716,
-0.0094974628,
0.0136820953,
0.0578727163,
0.0044938405,
0.0805259421,
-0.1039313525,
-0.0019050849,
0.0146685541,
-0.0260559302,
0.026791675,
0.0331642851,
-0.0034629649,
0.0197136104,
-0.0735322088,
0.0340921246,
-0.058009319,
0.073229976,
-0.012798937,
0.0577947684,
0.0147719923,
0.0250215381,
0.0393206179,
-0.0304510426,
0.096084632,
-0.0242207684,
-0.0315411724,
-0.0404944941,
0.0221819356,
0.0246222746,
0.0004815006,
0.0311237052,
-0.0021204145,
0.0055070529,
-0.036784444,
-0.0109194852,
0.0158843808,
0.0106156645,
0.0405427702,
-0.0136409495,
-0.0160727818,
0.0013050219,
-0.0014733456,
0.0204658154,
-0.006720088,
-0.0137100145,
0.0651769564,
-0.0205352362,
-0.0272613503,
-0.0206847042,
0.0047708363,
-0.0035723452,
0.0400944315,
0.0396175124,
-0.047696203,
-0.0414988585,
0.0650052428,
-0.010410293,
-0.0044831918,
0.0152767543,
0.025320882,
-0.0370730907,
-0.0165003445,
-0.0095164673,
0.0265434831,
0.0126502775,
-0.0771893784,
-0.0437947959,
0.0110925231,
-0.0270390399,
-0.0353074595,
-0.0170852523,
0.0156812817,
0.0296615548,
-0.0432990789,
0.059030775,
-0.0720980093,
0.0132472152,
0.0088801682,
0.0194367282,
-0.0050669052,
-0.0158774629,
0.0095645329,
-0.0141792968,
-0.029858388,
0.0155747076,
-0.0405993797,
-0.0155628538,
-0.0224477611,
0.0071758926,
-0.0520682186,
0.0348754153,
-0.0294882786,
0.0139770284,
-0.0172877926,
0.0156511441,
0.0199631006,
0.0495749749,
0.0079715112,
0.0055690715,
-0.0115968585,
-0.0021342523,
0.1127653122,
0.0167015437,
-0.0002962883,
0.0210204236,
0.0309624728,
-0.0117160063,
0.0086096711,
-0.0278486349,
-0.0134487702,
-0.00797565,
-0.0162934624,
-0.0264797918,
-0.0025122068,
0.0044456623,
-0.0152094681,
0.0228153002,
0.0049997582,
-0.0068855593,
0.005415129,
-0.0231016297,
0.0978734344,
0.0083143422,
-0.0690461546,
-0.0141445156,
0.0035152091,
-0.0530710891,
0.0010368087,
-0.0155076692,
0.0146373063,
-0.0214022286,
0.0183578338,
-0.0548480898,
0.0066205692,
0.0246609244,
0.0013390103,
-0.0297990758,
-0.0203726012,
0.0224408153,
0.0380302519,
0.0076537086,
-0.0035741823,
-0.054573223,
-0.0526038148,
-0.0639810264,
0.0198375285,
-0.0070870793,
-0.0547432639,
-0.0158410296,
-0.0211566798,
-0.0176281109,
-0.0469519198,
0.0013750474,
0.0095731858,
-0.0449734032,
0.0221650787,
-0.0314606503,
-0.0202556457,
-0.0665316284,
-0.0097375326,
-0.0340048894,
0.0306490436,
-0.0613016561,
-0.0368789099,
0.0063906545,
-0.0292110536,
-0.0396164209,
-0.0310465228,
-0.0041499194,
-0.0345813371,
-0.0659193769,
-0.0506159142,
0.0324936286,
0.0600042902,
-0.0478174761,
-0.0629802346,
0.0137163773,
-0.0036113628,
-0.0295203216,
-0.0159360766,
0.0251914281,
-0.0091630733,
-0.0053522545,
0.00155256,
0.0229374152,
0.0406653434,
-0.0169338975,
-0.0040389807,
0.0570151918,
0.0162153896,
-0.0241407473,
-0.0433150008,
0.0105786324,
0.042421408,
0.0022656515,
0.0524807125,
0.069028832,
-0.0647621825,
0.0168438628,
-0.0409575701,
-0.0389277861,
-0.0084998459,
0.0418377556,
-0.029339727,
-0.0106502874,
-0.0785182118,
0.0325808786,
-0.071723491,
-0.0418234989,
0.0186280645,
0.0413437225,
0.0004621293,
-0.0273168981,
-0.0685187131,
-0.0700901598,
-0.0355841741,
0.0597929768,
0.0201469567,
0.0391019247,
0.015628919,
0.0348616764,
-0.0304018315,
-0.0018771673,
-0.0558857732,
-0.0061493269,
-0.0331244878,
-0.0030346154,
0.0014585889,
-0.0081377234,
-0.0029561641,
0.007605264,
0.0828203484,
0.0524083674,
0.0134319076,
-0.0070142159,
-0.0097378241,
-0.0465000495,
-0.022925185,
0.0153962355,
0.0048258509,
0.0086066453,
0.0377741009,
-0.0385545492,
0.0038213779,
-0.0238277018,
-0.0150561053,
0.0600699559,
-0.0379709899,
-0.0125934994,
0.0388294347,
-0.0080024572,
-0.0349608399,
0.0105916504,
-0.0083079142,
0.0009357781,
0.0204478595,
0.0015218591,
0.0264405701,
0.0188913811,
0.0400242209,
-0.0093889441,
-0.0004687464,
0.0475947484,
0.0437474735,
0.0170553457,
0.0533894785,
-0.0453979485,
-0.0234537143,
0.0053056516,
-0.0369767807,
0.0072805947,
0.0262215063,
-0.0167505108,
0.0469691157,
0.0613574572,
-0.0194253754,
-0.0242312793,
0.0584153719,
-0.031249648,
0.0049693547,
-0.012261942,
0.0109824603,
0.0694094077,
-0.0420748405,
0.0072744242,
-0.04145566,
-0.004245406,
0.0107625155,
0.0143847214,
-0.0376901999,
-0.0068743029,
0.007683991,
-0.0168616232,
0.0184720885,
0.0461577252,
0.0445227921,
0.0062097628,
-0.0086221378,
-0.0211279728,
-0.089852415,
-0.0252216831,
-0.0018003964,
0.0598962456,
-0.0147779193,
-0.0425129086,
-0.0182763599,
0.0074195904,
-0.0376543663,
0.0393432081,
0.0740679651,
-0.0062144552,
0.0671299547,
0.0458757468,
0.0353724398,
0.0328145735,
0.0279692411,
-0.0219405647,
0.0200062823,
0.0076262443,
-0.0149731813,
-0.0139754936,
-4.150718675e-33,
0.0287747625,
-0.0541652888,
0.0112418281,
0.0497362502,
-0.0179090109,
-0.0016274675,
-0.0165012609,
-0.0628713593,
-0.0248645134,
0.0314963944,
0.0064681331,
0.0120306863,
0.0042986609,
-0.0265495386,
-0.0030560128,
-0.0067831469,
0.0080865193,
0.0278246701,
0.0041909069,
-0.0260689408,
-0.00807958,
-0.0058618928,
0.0100342724,
-0.0733795837,
0.0012165281,
-0.041677773,
-0.0095054926,
-0.0441693068,
0.0369565785,
-0.0007512399,
-0.0117576988,
-0.0108942073,
0.015739562,
-0.005808007,
-0.0334881172,
-0.0048065041,
-0.0232436582,
-0.022172777,
0.0087507572,
0.0188309774,
-0.0084894178,
-0.010019944,
0.0346505381,
-0.0387545042,
-0.0083362469,
0.0175864212,
0.0817489251,
-0.0230356902,
-0.0174217932,
0.0037795524,
-0.0531579815,
0.0181019604,
-0.0109445779,
0.0543308742,
0.0638093576,
-0.0100644119,
0.0063669337,
0.052948311,
-0.0628938302,
0.028358059,
-0.0649060458,
-0.0111024287,
-0.0082632434,
-0.021142412,
0.0544508658,
0.0127688935,
0.0314214192,
-0.0932155848,
0.0570319481,
0.0146113914,
-0.0158571359,
0.0438405164,
0.0544609874,
0.0816797838,
0.0077525065,
-0.0614947192,
-0.0125655243,
0.0545948669,
-0.0234530009,
0.0304357298,
-0.0156358685,
-0.0247855354,
-0.0281112902,
0.0075696241,
0.0274480116,
-0.0400544703,
-0.036000073,
-0.0212074313,
0.0323844738,
0.0163374692,
0.0138177788,
0.0718690306,
0.0230449103,
-0.0514574759,
-0.0224363338,
-0.0324596241,
-0.0140132364,
0.0070993071,
0.0004999501,
0.0008407803,
0.0004028333,
-0.0352667235,
-0.0011526633,
0.0021784008,
0.0429827608,
-0.000416062,
0.0830063969,
0.0020876885,
-0.0464664027,
0.0172151439,
0.050055299,
-0.0691439211,
0.0018187948,
-0.0323041789,
-0.052693516,
0.0064086849,
0.0285753123,
-0.0459819399,
0.0183895882,
0.0100135859,
-0.021200357,
-0.0428441949,
0.004432858,
-0.0108833695,
0.0028382777,
-0.0048925737,
-0.0592991561,
0.0689556673,
-0.0194980968,
-0.0368819498,
0.012253657,
0.0162413809,
2.142e-7,
0.0025605983,
-0.0294361543,
0.0414973348,
-0.0583794005,
0.0139745725,
0.0352771878,
-0.0234213639,
0.0056336918,
-0.039617572,
0.0313628241,
0.0387296453,
-0.0295366012,
0.0018293983,
-0.031826973,
-0.0733595341,
0.0324858911,
-0.0322147943,
-0.0901393071,
-0.0612969398,
0.0225661919,
0.067380853,
0.0241144244,
0.0209705401,
-0.0517434552,
-0.0125929257,
-0.062307924,
0.0179275647,
0.0049496661,
0.0050551766,
-0.0073159439,
0.0118333306,
-0.0148337251,
0.0110671446,
0.024676118,
-0.0011771433,
0.0211244915,
0.0715570077,
-0.046566084,
-0.0145714311,
0.0335594267,
-0.0452850088,
-0.0642230064,
-0.0200872906,
-0.0595760308,
0.0423677266,
0.0376674645,
0.0251781885,
-0.0433059335,
-0.0326338001,
0.0142146172,
0.0197438784,
0.0047043408,
-0.0766840056,
0.0165557098,
0.0246404652,
0.0386818163,
-0.0223305468,
-0.0563153289,
0.0532076061,
-0.034281224,
-0.0154539989,
0.0109112831,
-0.0194925349,
-0.0042110137,
0.1033650786,
-0.0181319341,
0.0374183282,
1.515627544e-34,
0.018180836,
-0.0112291696,
0.0202878863,
0.0103690708,
-0.0121621052,
0.0049913842,
-0.0447639935,
0.0172349773,
-0.0573480017,
0.036996536,
0.0181678068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12833v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12833v1 | Use of LLMs for Illicit Purposes: Threats, Prevention Measures, and Vulnerabilities | 2023-08-24T14:45:50 | 2023-08-24T14:45:50 | Maximilian Mozes, Xuanli He, Bennett Kleinberg, Lewis D. Griffin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | Spurred by the recent rapid increase in the development and distribution of
large language models (LLMs) across industry and academia, much recent work has
drawn attention to safety- and security-related threats and vulnerabilities of
LLMs, including in the context of potentially criminal activities.
Specifically, it has been shown that LLMs can be misused for fraud,
impersonation, and the generation of malware; while other authors have
considered the more general problem of AI alignment. It is important that
developers and practitioners alike are aware of security-related problems with
such models. In this paper, we provide an overview of existing - predominantly
scientific - efforts on identifying and mitigating threats and vulnerabilities
arising from LLMs. We present a taxonomy describing the relationship between
threats caused by the generative capabilities of LLMs, prevention measures
intended to address such threats, and vulnerabilities arising from imperfect
prevention measures. With our work, we hope to raise awareness of the
limitations of LLMs in light of such security concerns, among both experienced
developers and novel users of such technologies. | [
0.0327172428,
0.094611004,
-0.0182044227,
0.0707014874,
-0.0777835473,
-0.0251780357,
0.0599340647,
-0.0015806124,
0.0422884226,
-0.0196607262,
-0.0258377399,
-0.031119749,
0.0275858864,
0.0281810127,
0.0724468604,
0.0301876273,
0.0466907173,
-0.0642887428,
-0.0009115696,
-0.0095941601,
-0.0004630483,
0.0164320841,
0.0231894627,
0.0426746309,
0.0160009321,
-0.0486027226,
-0.0151587604,
-0.0003367991,
0.0219317097,
0.0130262719,
-0.01491886,
0.0368373878,
-0.0262106974,
0.0853010342,
0.000002061,
-0.0506787188,
-0.0330292992,
0.0521538481,
-0.0434990078,
0.0470722839,
0.026088018,
-0.0186288785,
-0.0369674861,
0.0167104509,
-0.0560919978,
0.0539482571,
0.0403737426,
-0.0050407103,
0.0615069196,
0.050491862,
-0.0061699608,
-0.0027954574,
0.0592531785,
0.0038678951,
-0.0178124607,
-0.0380201079,
0.0289323106,
-0.0118516525,
0.0115859648,
0.0264959577,
0.0383523479,
0.0007939833,
-0.0239550173,
-0.0309998915,
-0.0062414147,
0.0259628333,
-0.0255391672,
-0.0435185805,
0.0000415426,
0.0263366606,
-0.0331548192,
-0.0272173826,
0.0239061415,
0.010729339,
0.0223305877,
0.0215023495,
0.0366748236,
0.0524234027,
-0.0156426262,
-0.0023078006,
0.0436058007,
-0.0222000871,
0.0444790497,
0.0303807147,
0.0164923221,
0.0214707833,
0.0291694887,
-0.0409784056,
-0.0342803188,
-0.0458070897,
0.0343589224,
-0.0795118287,
-0.0190914739,
0.0218306221,
0.0026019767,
0.0313906856,
-0.069894284,
-0.0364352688,
0.0385856479,
-0.055098772,
0.0031647552,
0.0334705114,
0.0230083857,
0.0087095117,
0.0029867666,
0.0602962971,
-0.0425333269,
0.0425521992,
0.0280981194,
0.018122809,
0.0141198663,
-0.0237593856,
0.0031957082,
0.0186093133,
0.019853184,
0.033635851,
-0.0332076252,
0.0708862543,
-0.0421369746,
0.0756883249,
-0.0491526723,
-0.0145595241,
0.0394328311,
-0.0064384476,
0.0214219727,
-0.0298555456,
0.0391740985,
-0.008876224,
-0.0300756991,
-0.0583704226,
0.0034252058,
0.0282164142,
-0.0954427794,
-0.032785818,
-0.0017773864,
0.1169751361,
0.0410094559,
0.0223785918,
-0.049999658,
-0.0789611116,
-0.0053953817,
-0.0304302871,
-0.0013548074,
-0.0754795671,
-0.0242349859,
-0.0027524726,
-0.0293208174,
-0.0774596483,
-0.0039056097,
-0.0095052011,
-0.0563841909,
0.0347786024,
-0.0505128242,
0.0232537556,
0.0286903586,
0.0345649756,
0.0072157905,
0.0215265602,
0.0203750804,
0.0372425951,
0.0285162572,
-0.0514854155,
0.0423961543,
0.0475899503,
-0.0103270309,
0.0116109438,
-0.0177012477,
0.0172639731,
0.0436016731,
-0.0168903135,
-0.0237981733,
0.0591759272,
-0.0050105639,
-0.0419310257,
0.0826382041,
0.068055883,
-0.0523104817,
0.0264561083,
-0.0115360189,
-0.0183740687,
0.0094987368,
-0.0126061868,
-0.0665167719,
0.0002303821,
-0.0652665943,
-0.0120332995,
-0.0327811837,
0.0791344419,
0.0020700558,
-0.0058066435,
-0.0140802413,
-0.0451920964,
-0.0009423415,
0.0112671265,
0.0072132116,
0.0014157436,
0.0147672938,
0.0086094681,
0.0050475942,
-0.0394869484,
-0.0237536579,
-0.1086578593,
-0.0115729561,
0.1016646549,
0.0674702674,
0.0144010214,
-0.0364100933,
-0.019097263,
-0.0424548127,
0.016571898,
-0.0017265346,
0.0031204748,
-0.0020781562,
-0.0187883675,
-0.0076500783,
-0.0131421322,
-0.0137948859,
0.0115080969,
0.009566593,
0.00414471,
-0.0081149302,
-0.0188034978,
-0.0452175178,
0.002730869,
-0.0483963303,
-0.0315727927,
-0.0227561127,
0.0375509709,
0.0049962606,
0.0160698593,
-0.0371937864,
0.0268663615,
0.0591096841,
0.0214903466,
0.0136268372,
-0.0208495576,
0.0226205736,
0.1017123461,
0.0459669493,
-0.0174133535,
0.0098505039,
0.0186793059,
-0.0139464717,
0.0044592936,
0.048504822,
-0.028492406,
0.0338210687,
0.0084911976,
0.0331985541,
-0.0351234227,
0.0287289433,
-0.0552177392,
0.0261201542,
-0.0103746317,
-0.0135400416,
0.0203421749,
-0.0123591265,
0.0281919613,
-0.0121651376,
-0.0461287871,
0.0107757133,
-0.0058295843,
0.0385056213,
0.0103522027,
0.0004546767,
0.0008474453,
-0.0359852053,
-0.0259872675,
-0.0099862684,
0.0043711127,
0.0452816039,
0.041402325,
0.0170334615,
-0.0502623767,
-0.0303951371,
-0.0184427053,
-0.0440117046,
-0.0009214805,
-0.0062817945,
0.0410145186,
-0.0460524522,
-0.0659865662,
-0.0021812213,
0.0000702448,
-0.0181695279,
0.0311987735,
-0.0104395486,
-0.0343374759,
-0.0622824989,
0.0646046773,
-0.0335719772,
0.0183295663,
-0.0033992389,
-0.0042487956,
0.0262609292,
-0.0086003095,
-0.0045454456,
0.0541817024,
0.0047673071,
0.0132187828,
0.074195087,
0.0187335759,
-0.0510315038,
-0.0429219492,
0.0559204407,
-0.0236226451,
-0.042488113,
-0.0445603095,
-0.0014855502,
0.0194401778,
0.0182412211,
-0.0151827773,
-0.0018303652,
0.034358751,
0.0016369105,
-0.0245365724,
0.0259167049,
-0.0775932819,
-0.0303165242,
0.0084786732,
-0.0191635247,
-0.1103691086,
0.059738677,
-0.0945682749,
0.0223284233,
-0.0118063763,
-0.0456057079,
-0.0044154604,
0.0277228672,
-0.0267302059,
0.0237316657,
0.0373683386,
-0.0388126448,
-0.0320538431,
-0.0096364524,
0.0164578781,
-0.0437244736,
0.0270844903,
-0.0162486341,
0.0110765472,
-0.0176729504,
0.0015541137,
-0.0618154034,
-0.0380699225,
-0.0045215762,
-0.0204908699,
0.0061762906,
-0.0223210994,
-0.0043218178,
-0.0204836838,
0.0412397385,
-0.013351474,
0.0141332401,
-0.0088477135,
-0.0235267337,
-0.0048643211,
0.0202936474,
-0.0619173609,
-0.0173936263,
-0.0131043363,
0.0147199156,
0.0363563076,
-0.0147727774,
0.0021185849,
-0.0275786687,
-0.0327607915,
0.0587919913,
-0.0049892925,
0.000458051,
0.035669595,
0.0168519169,
0.0035428738,
-0.0018193126,
0.0688625872,
0.0152001856,
-0.02082224,
0.0107978117,
-0.0351460129,
0.0204714835,
0.0057893014,
0.0296102371,
-0.0828859806,
0.0386348888,
0.0181249026,
0.0412370339,
-0.0375292636,
-0.0183258727,
-0.0061857183,
-0.0939185247,
0.0191536434,
0.0246740077,
-0.0506796837,
-0.0285543576,
-0.0240382403,
-0.0190090947,
0.0104312412,
0.0556901097,
-0.0462049805,
0.0007941847,
-0.014085033,
0.0337507837,
-0.0689770952,
0.0028528334,
-0.0038831371,
-0.0238046907,
0.0762755126,
0.086147815,
-0.0017169735,
-0.0185009334,
-0.010542959,
-0.0037365321,
0.0391450599,
0.0166310649,
0.0389460176,
0.007117182,
0.0164922383,
-0.0268555246,
-0.0085485969,
0.0161119793,
-0.0243176166,
-0.0362226255,
0.0314087383,
0.0754040256,
-0.0693948716,
0.0019139164,
-0.0464823507,
-0.0481108911,
0.0344916545,
0.0348774157,
-0.0125657143,
-0.0283268038,
-0.0097312452,
-0.0397672281,
0.0117117306,
0.0124914683,
-0.0317028426,
0.0236519966,
0.0024922516,
-0.0406582169,
-0.0234908424,
-0.0233762972,
-0.0464332029,
0.0072942381,
0.0688335672,
0.0015402446,
0.0212220736,
-0.0079031168,
-0.0116321333,
-0.0282920469,
-0.0429478772,
0.0670185611,
-0.0273443386,
0.0255941227,
-0.0274731331,
-0.0253118277,
0.0164439939,
0.0067159589,
-0.0639981851,
-0.0810661092,
0.014129472,
0.053301163,
0.0323717557,
-0.0070370357,
-0.0349860229,
-0.0365392826,
0.0599654876,
0.0116264503,
-0.0245171785,
0.0218700152,
0.0271455236,
-0.0405823402,
0.0098179206,
-0.0099026365,
-0.0342060588,
-0.0195938312,
0.0734162033,
-0.0472836308,
-0.0893236175,
-0.0389055088,
0.021400908,
0.0766723454,
-0.0034722341,
-0.04562556,
0.0616100654,
0.0122741573,
0.0013726397,
-0.0317738876,
-0.0149488049,
0.0123871928,
-0.0227972604,
0.0382192805,
0.0061465828,
0.0714294836,
0.0043979404,
-0.01961134,
-0.011101176,
0.0191941522,
0.0565635934,
0.000336199,
0.06335935,
0.0597052723,
0.0251942854,
0.0008871451,
0.0795274079,
-0.0307242312,
0.0505607985,
-0.0003301679,
0.034145005,
-0.0194053259,
0.0293908771,
-0.0011774272,
0.0544355921,
-0.0553625971,
-0.069009982,
0.0234688353,
0.0518825687,
0.020372998,
0.0384623148,
0.0195389148,
-0.0117028207,
0.0311590023,
-0.0313442424,
-0.0023417526,
-0.0100206584,
-0.0561438538,
-0.0322713368,
-0.0054028318,
-0.0225027334,
0.0108936364,
0.0661361963,
-0.0147339301,
0.0363643542,
-0.0242861193,
-0.0288733691,
-0.0143800443,
-0.0381620117,
0.0295873024,
-0.0186092518,
-0.0505762585,
-0.0542388447,
-0.0563880019,
-0.0806886107,
0.008731233,
-0.0137226209,
-0.0058839153,
-0.015480957,
-0.0054335874,
0.0635677874,
0.010022697,
0.0376461148,
-0.0737145394,
0.0107764993,
0.0049636816,
-0.0649136677,
-0.0357781723,
-5.010324265e-33,
0.0281993244,
-0.041922871,
-0.0080221575,
0.0183343738,
0.014833129,
0.0154676642,
-0.0088533601,
0.0080832113,
-0.0636580884,
-0.0425527617,
-0.0142726628,
-0.004930133,
0.012347389,
-0.0086812731,
-0.0066569252,
0.0154114785,
-0.0338873416,
0.0072608576,
-0.0002460539,
0.0184335094,
0.0429569148,
-0.0162513983,
0.019768497,
-0.0963979736,
0.0619568191,
-0.0196787212,
-0.0313488096,
-0.0100310147,
-0.0537127629,
0.0505333692,
0.0081812926,
0.0113756834,
0.0028108291,
-0.0085291145,
-0.0109413806,
0.0445476919,
0.0445484743,
-0.0083439182,
0.0248952471,
0.0234673396,
0.0404374674,
-0.0894742161,
0.0633250996,
-0.0369862318,
-0.0376406871,
0.0285367332,
0.0250336379,
-0.0163588431,
-0.0369662233,
-0.0008865928,
-0.0542211346,
-0.0050475942,
-0.0461998768,
0.0380435698,
0.0237838645,
-0.0118152555,
0.0270272922,
-0.0246353764,
-0.0514584333,
0.0719669759,
0.016904695,
-0.0149778407,
0.0871826783,
0.0219265372,
-0.0044757286,
0.0584693886,
0.0154186469,
-0.0231871027,
0.000112757,
-0.0029107993,
0.0078106006,
0.0540659614,
0.0261102766,
0.0462840535,
-0.0108117135,
-0.0309256855,
-0.0273651797,
0.0247503873,
0.0310465004,
-0.0008039557,
0.0352860466,
-0.01306233,
-0.0810068697,
0.002094748,
0.0140562262,
-0.0156426262,
-0.0295934062,
-0.0248033497,
-0.0046493863,
-0.0350027494,
0.0019900214,
-0.0318101831,
0.0101026651,
-0.0798787177,
0.0066412375,
0.0215206463,
0.0098321866,
-0.0221309792,
-0.0099451374,
0.0206963066,
-0.0196612906,
-0.0333386473,
-0.0176716056,
-0.0254143011,
0.0622689798,
0.0127920648,
0.0245220978,
0.0237762891,
-0.0550474748,
0.0122312615,
-0.0164610986,
0.0426450036,
0.0355595946,
0.0161904115,
0.0399520807,
-0.0252252091,
0.0277885888,
-0.0138925174,
0.0323128067,
0.0058812057,
-0.0263501853,
0.0422852933,
-0.0168739725,
0.0036883564,
-0.0025551245,
0.0187973883,
-0.0137207052,
0.0597580932,
0.070528768,
-0.0369804688,
-0.0134789823,
-0.0352707058,
2.867e-7,
0.0055992259,
0.0007766909,
0.0311674997,
0.0134231327,
0.0153030558,
0.0511413105,
-0.0070063015,
0.0723109841,
-0.0243625045,
-0.0275182258,
-0.011237449,
0.0040314677,
0.0505885631,
0.0167008378,
-0.0412049145,
0.0288320538,
-0.061025396,
-0.0125321485,
-0.07880041,
0.0298768207,
0.0438014977,
0.0775895044,
0.0143054444,
-0.0585956722,
-0.0277961958,
-0.0730309114,
-0.0175602231,
0.0117875487,
0.0020957156,
-0.0013225408,
0.0227826498,
0.0381545648,
0.0064006248,
0.0445726104,
-0.0210752245,
-0.0014055484,
-0.0541913696,
0.0400035493,
-0.0273365546,
0.0168387592,
-0.0169717111,
-0.0980672315,
-0.0074611842,
-0.0201323722,
0.0359096564,
0.041966252,
-0.0312417224,
-0.021740526,
-0.0240920912,
-0.028932564,
0.0065771937,
-0.0052533932,
0.0250921026,
0.0074274587,
0.0061042942,
-0.0116616851,
0.0055870428,
-0.040658433,
-0.0202790126,
-0.0123237027,
-0.0010954394,
-0.033083804,
0.0243975576,
0.0260256045,
0.0180199873,
-0.0097373072,
0.0361160003,
2.779846234e-34,
-0.0394513607,
-0.0536426641,
0.0113502312,
0.0394450203,
0.0020056213,
0.0155778984,
-0.032246165,
0.0452282578,
-0.0114013376,
-0.0046095899,
-0.0113401655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12770v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12770v3 | WavMark: Watermarking for Audio Generation | 2023-08-24T13:17:35 | 2024-01-07T07:05:37 | Guangyu Chen, Yu Wu, Shujie Liu, Tao Liu, Xiaoyong Du, Furu Wei | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Recent breakthroughs in zero-shot voice synthesis have enabled imitating a
speaker's voice using just a few seconds of recording while maintaining a high
level of realism. Alongside its potential benefits, this powerful technology
introduces notable risks, including voice fraud and speaker impersonation.
Unlike the conventional approach of solely relying on passive methods for
detecting synthetic data, watermarking presents a proactive and robust defence
mechanism against these looming risks. This paper introduces an innovative
audio watermarking framework that encodes up to 32 bits of watermark within a
mere 1-second audio snippet. The watermark is imperceptible to human senses and
exhibits strong resilience against various attacks. It can serve as an
effective identifier for synthesized voices and holds potential for broader
applications in audio copyright protection. Moreover, this framework boasts
high flexibility, allowing for the combination of multiple watermark segments
to achieve heightened robustness and expanded capacity. Utilizing 10 to
20-second audio as the host, our approach demonstrates an average Bit Error
Rate (BER) of 0.48\% across ten common attacks, a remarkable reduction of over
2800\% in BER compared to the state-of-the-art watermarking tool. See
https://aka.ms/wavmark for demos of our work. | [
-0.0002727512,
0.0070544998,
-0.0012281628,
0.0101753604,
-0.014866123,
-0.0191312134,
0.058003895,
0.0307504106,
-0.0565365367,
-0.0185006019,
-0.0083341002,
0.0069152461,
0.0100793662,
0.0023658655,
0.0463427454,
-0.0332307592,
-0.0077774581,
-0.0091259442,
0.0353373066,
0.0067108679,
0.0275708344,
0.0004132071,
-0.0208678488,
0.0226820111,
-0.0463983528,
-0.0126745002,
0.0017680845,
0.0556009822,
-0.0000649978,
0.0072806128,
-0.0354250707,
0.0414241478,
0.0395704471,
0.0891629457,
0.0000019721,
-0.0243050233,
-0.0184540004,
0.0340277255,
-0.0397532508,
0.0535661615,
-0.0234392714,
0.040211983,
-0.08525078,
0.0483624451,
-0.008642707,
0.0072149225,
0.0174318161,
0.0386710502,
0.0695725903,
0.0297592562,
-0.0216505434,
-0.017973002,
0.01224765,
0.0072458112,
0.069710888,
0.0165233798,
-0.0257835463,
0.0016934465,
0.0173020978,
-0.011161414,
0.0253151525,
0.0482564904,
-0.0344912559,
-0.0375333726,
-0.0392568894,
0.0160530731,
-0.0663733259,
-0.030220326,
0.0285899825,
0.0279425308,
-0.035751503,
-0.0077349674,
0.0087798117,
0.0139775444,
0.0214118063,
-0.0037241131,
0.0088820457,
0.0074816719,
0.0164511558,
0.008303958,
-0.082906507,
0.0408517495,
0.0277621765,
-0.0545779057,
0.0622921698,
-0.0650583804,
0.0458904989,
0.0088534011,
-0.0448986292,
-0.0340085812,
-0.0070778551,
0.0006329155,
0.0209790878,
-0.0207924899,
0.0348224118,
-0.0536084957,
-0.1172367707,
-0.0371052474,
-0.0342938527,
-0.0199044757,
0.0668238103,
0.0080139581,
-0.0127347475,
0.0128353275,
-0.0377110504,
0.0192055292,
-0.0174718611,
-0.0417726189,
0.0353414118,
-0.0094488999,
0.0092803072,
-0.0301039051,
-0.0097818496,
0.0142283542,
-0.0306461807,
-0.0152768986,
-0.0246393718,
-0.0101029389,
-0.0264998898,
0.0509856045,
-0.0327800103,
0.0181759931,
-0.0033056363,
-0.0238667578,
0.071804449,
-0.0314196944,
0.0403103605,
0.0516811572,
-0.0378419571,
-0.030179495,
-0.0124503383,
0.0135589847,
0.0346009508,
0.0421324596,
0.0146489423,
0.052267503,
0.0302016847,
-0.0273302924,
0.0194175355,
-0.0466309339,
0.0233530272,
0.0104649831,
-0.0024621468,
-0.0523522981,
-0.0035675277,
-0.0585274659,
-0.020249106,
-0.004870309,
0.0130549846,
0.0289586745,
0.0210519806,
0.0214630794,
-0.0239704624,
0.020625012,
0.0232147835,
0.0146792792,
-0.018849859,
-0.0013689758,
0.0752707347,
-0.0374091193,
0.0395621508,
-0.0128123602,
0.0117945345,
0.0242081434,
0.0313859321,
0.0111488579,
0.0089609995,
-0.0436985455,
0.0241193566,
-0.0057664737,
0.0035361091,
-0.0056634694,
0.0192902852,
-0.069762513,
0.0679637268,
0.0285065453,
-0.0133110685,
-0.0421609916,
0.0174564384,
0.0320034809,
0.0137461061,
-0.0494020395,
0.061703179,
0.0093984567,
-0.0121490769,
-0.0327777527,
0.0424829386,
-0.0369576067,
-0.0032211097,
0.0430275202,
-0.0104010096,
-0.032638669,
-0.0333783403,
-0.0180564355,
-0.044928465,
0.0335513428,
-0.0148238391,
0.0544789135,
-0.0609256364,
-0.024321476,
-0.0122570116,
-0.0432217494,
0.0409760512,
0.0266277269,
0.029339334,
0.0008124734,
0.1266162694,
-0.0506878458,
-0.0382022262,
0.0404270254,
-0.0487153158,
-0.0287250485,
0.0402784832,
-0.0285755396,
0.0044652242,
-0.0359728709,
-0.0283118561,
0.0504220687,
0.017624937,
0.0393117182,
0.0453497954,
-0.0169156101,
0.0539158434,
-0.0683206469,
0.0371785499,
-0.0902730897,
0.0364069492,
-0.0246143937,
0.0614663884,
0.0328682996,
-0.0338476673,
0.0327323563,
0.0160111506,
-0.0270068664,
-0.0053531895,
-0.0089361267,
0.0142586716,
0.0126830656,
0.0521666668,
-0.0582923964,
0.0226494204,
0.0596111752,
0.0034837455,
-0.0032759842,
0.0414973833,
-0.0406539403,
-0.0020015538,
-0.0408797488,
0.0130493119,
-0.0099290563,
0.0365495458,
0.0206279736,
-0.0399123989,
0.0495136566,
-0.0078727594,
0.0095467856,
0.0515799895,
0.0002381044,
-0.0226814188,
-0.0475671329,
-0.0207811911,
-0.0436713696,
0.020479802,
-0.0423591211,
-0.0225197561,
-0.0243659224,
0.0168385524,
-0.0240330454,
0.0016839165,
-0.0029886079,
-0.0026221867,
-0.02911341,
-0.0107010696,
0.0010149365,
-0.0207694061,
-0.0291532315,
-0.1037731692,
0.0015651592,
-0.0279753283,
-0.0398566574,
-0.0316341817,
-0.0475877598,
0.0351658911,
0.0203162674,
0.0176265631,
0.00078752,
-0.0139211994,
-0.0107733924,
-0.0323756784,
-0.0341972969,
0.0091699632,
0.0040553198,
0.0185873602,
0.0298793167,
-0.0038764908,
0.0461906977,
-0.017166663,
-0.0080643268,
0.0214310139,
-0.0529199317,
0.0002651816,
0.0499086976,
0.0082755666,
-0.0162404198,
0.0169096794,
0.0402371921,
-0.0098168701,
0.0101383543,
-0.0009682673,
-0.0575105846,
0.0547946803,
0.0244864244,
0.0003735693,
0.0557096079,
0.0083571104,
-0.0160135608,
0.0283027291,
-0.0182314385,
-0.0204621181,
-0.0296095572,
-0.0124649927,
-0.0213089176,
-0.0237877909,
-0.0587906204,
-0.0277725775,
0.0506883711,
-0.0519503057,
0.0005095822,
0.0181138273,
-0.0330096707,
0.0244134665,
-0.0078071612,
-0.0243596267,
0.0065410314,
-0.0126619339,
0.0638771206,
-0.0868574455,
-0.0870661587,
0.0014051284,
-0.0322313532,
-0.0163899716,
0.0402979739,
0.0004355873,
-0.0449615195,
0.0092656137,
0.0408368967,
-0.0064727594,
-0.0242125876,
0.017615607,
0.0001589491,
0.0531549156,
0.0359883085,
0.0129311932,
0.0200803466,
-0.0446190275,
0.0887041613,
-0.0178691093,
-0.0231469534,
-0.0143793067,
0.0200404506,
0.0079733366,
0.0207565334,
0.0438723303,
0.0273425672,
0.0167655125,
-0.0043208171,
0.0070635537,
0.0153289959,
-0.0078649446,
0.0122489678,
0.0387436301,
0.011789714,
0.0366572626,
0.0550753474,
-0.0097165275,
0.0093732672,
0.0126662552,
0.0254065506,
0.0035836014,
0.0172469392,
-0.0548891798,
-0.0460495055,
-0.0281120446,
0.057486631,
0.0618151315,
-0.0222042352,
0.0282242727,
-0.0480467305,
-0.0441388264,
0.0284677614,
0.0246914513,
0.004459966,
-0.0281792432,
-0.0188905559,
-0.0425239205,
0.0521433838,
0.0071823322,
-0.0270616654,
0.0278522447,
0.0063318978,
0.0477649532,
-0.0220156256,
-0.0326824635,
0.0175785832,
-0.0383877344,
0.0871382579,
0.0617580004,
0.03067258,
-0.0148851061,
-0.0343703255,
-0.0650644451,
-0.0270694792,
-0.0050100447,
0.0221379548,
0.050475549,
0.0175007936,
-0.0120534655,
0.0231820419,
0.0284094457,
0.0323390961,
-0.0415867306,
0.0157048218,
0.0058669862,
0.0363359451,
-0.0001606481,
0.0064789867,
0.0181445591,
0.0255972352,
0.044411514,
0.0116866417,
-0.0231900178,
-0.0016718705,
-0.0084112054,
0.0494724289,
-0.0618944727,
-0.0625037849,
-0.0012628582,
0.0130342003,
-0.0571546108,
-0.0053150058,
0.0405579023,
-0.0502245501,
0.0383152589,
0.0278479941,
0.017584756,
-0.0134789683,
-0.006434083,
-0.10284964,
-0.0558025949,
-0.0696588531,
0.0762169883,
-0.0121275522,
0.0006547908,
0.0091365278,
-0.0011501171,
-0.0090123434,
0.0453059785,
-0.0711480379,
-0.0183228999,
0.0162325967,
0.0015073844,
0.0189400353,
0.0172733106,
0.0069074584,
-0.0186753329,
0.059815079,
0.0006580332,
0.0056206179,
0.0448909178,
0.103398256,
-0.0269821845,
-0.0006839427,
-0.001924092,
-0.0541329682,
0.0277581047,
0.0494051687,
-0.0179168675,
-0.0039445241,
-0.0049926913,
-0.0017917671,
0.0242852625,
-0.0445618555,
-0.0320230238,
0.0948649347,
0.0102382125,
0.0484708473,
-0.0353686325,
-0.0033944973,
-0.0431673005,
0.0050993497,
0.0157567021,
-0.0227934718,
0.0026062613,
0.0164841376,
-0.0247212183,
-0.0251819715,
0.0091009578,
0.0220099743,
-0.0118572013,
-0.0271799155,
-0.0050303899,
0.0044793291,
0.0077511454,
0.0767607689,
0.048617173,
0.0048042536,
0.0227345377,
-0.0026874363,
-0.0045046532,
0.0058655641,
0.0006126318,
0.025760971,
-0.0385096744,
0.0031629137,
-0.0164809097,
0.0298485216,
0.0337603278,
0.0154563962,
0.0183990411,
-0.0031421394,
0.0246587899,
-0.013098171,
0.0429304205,
-0.0753613785,
-0.0557344593,
-0.0548080318,
-0.0142025873,
-0.0370933264,
0.0418526903,
0.0027714905,
-0.0059664105,
0.0230408218,
-0.0419071503,
-0.0090443138,
-0.0279434193,
-0.0233347751,
-0.0157016162,
0.0166496392,
-0.020750463,
-0.0156555362,
-0.0383372009,
-0.022608351,
0.0145685188,
-0.038793169,
0.0407417901,
0.0059363386,
-0.0142626595,
-0.0197551977,
-0.0153754987,
0.025833251,
0.0019719044,
-0.0464679189,
0.0042098537,
-0.0423629172,
0.0210626666,
-5.132793879e-33,
0.0196070485,
0.002410721,
-0.0378337242,
-0.0449870788,
0.0150999166,
0.0699643493,
0.0137544721,
0.0036538295,
0.0315204635,
-0.0354019515,
0.0069187619,
0.0083610713,
0.0064566787,
-0.0150729669,
-0.045368202,
0.0096618775,
0.0521327369,
-0.0119822118,
-0.005841183,
0.0172068942,
0.0832930729,
-0.0248865336,
-0.0287921857,
-0.055857081,
-0.0298478436,
-0.0248228405,
-0.06748458,
-0.0676700249,
-0.0038374327,
0.0192636643,
0.0219581574,
0.0035927782,
-0.0484454706,
0.0183466915,
-0.032323759,
0.0160908159,
-0.0094810836,
-0.0341446437,
-0.0171331223,
0.0249757748,
0.0588645749,
-0.0481429994,
-0.0150103895,
0.0078819022,
-0.063147001,
-0.0035361308,
-0.0121148601,
0.0002694025,
-0.0095267603,
-0.0649977848,
-0.0323201567,
0.0071995314,
-0.0407489054,
-0.0169641413,
0.0135215437,
0.0503390916,
0.0095088044,
-0.0436585173,
-0.1107574627,
0.0385646857,
-0.0133350771,
-0.0173786636,
-0.0010989528,
0.0011204639,
-0.0075816615,
0.0460382439,
0.0391957238,
-0.0735211968,
0.0279215425,
0.0178026371,
0.0381912105,
0.0128376931,
0.0684968308,
0.056001883,
0.0976480842,
-0.0422957465,
0.0086356197,
0.0339484625,
-0.0254709814,
-0.0633985549,
0.0356452204,
0.0515353903,
-0.0320820622,
-0.0020137015,
-0.0630356297,
-0.0462877452,
0.0032363369,
-0.0384786911,
0.0554123335,
0.0191111006,
-0.0342905298,
-0.0015192891,
0.0381122269,
-0.0360308848,
0.0243426412,
-0.0516450591,
-0.0181849673,
0.0184973329,
0.0026290785,
-0.0192149412,
0.0689660683,
0.0119671114,
0.1554494351,
-0.0493331663,
0.0427618474,
-0.0432202704,
0.0475308113,
0.070038259,
-0.0649726018,
-0.0255302545,
0.0244848914,
0.0231659114,
0.0311226696,
-0.0032796634,
-0.0164116193,
0.0167915281,
-0.0128118945,
-0.0596519522,
-0.0113119837,
0.0001295532,
0.0165808871,
0.0017648791,
-0.0825228915,
0.0151801119,
-0.0315788761,
0.0543946736,
0.0181192905,
0.0268098228,
0.0331007317,
-0.0165367592,
-0.0251940396,
-0.025316976,
2.769e-7,
-0.0579107925,
-0.0159987062,
0.0322989188,
-0.0234306045,
0.0229516719,
0.0514045693,
0.0123264501,
0.0276478976,
-0.0263231043,
-0.0110948421,
-0.0218087435,
-0.0404309183,
0.0932991505,
-0.0023213017,
-0.0893570706,
-0.0237180814,
-0.0084761372,
0.012114387,
-0.0406397209,
0.0085869487,
0.0506265983,
0.0663785487,
0.06908115,
-0.0672226325,
0.0407041572,
-0.0418105461,
0.0202986524,
0.013968328,
0.0116002215,
-0.0938673094,
-0.0024808063,
-0.0205703322,
0.0193586815,
-0.0089512225,
-0.0656245947,
-0.0026306575,
0.0146482335,
0.0607616529,
0.0018908491,
-0.0347722359,
-0.0567462258,
0.0128432205,
0.0005745812,
0.0339849889,
0.0125847412,
0.1020660251,
-0.0408181772,
-0.0386271067,
-0.1040598378,
0.0009643826,
-0.0118018985,
0.0086051393,
0.0034541506,
-0.0335577577,
0.0043072728,
0.0404442847,
-0.0173624903,
-0.0185368173,
-0.0067596701,
-0.0536845475,
0.0127587738,
-0.0110013038,
-0.0213228762,
-0.0118501438,
0.0601346605,
-0.0217452031,
0.019474417,
2.185179025e-34,
-0.0137448926,
-0.0484790802,
0.0112728914,
0.0134992078,
0.0193964615,
0.0289857592,
0.0530783199,
0.0090143625,
0.0139134163,
-0.0066064619,
-0.0297255646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12734v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12734v1 | Real-time Detection of AI-Generated Speech for DeepFake Voice Conversion | 2023-08-24T12:26:15 | 2023-08-24T12:26:15 | Jordan J. Bird, Ahmad Lotfi | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG, eess.AS | There are growing implications surrounding generative AI in the speech domain
that enable voice cloning and real-time voice conversion from one individual to
another. This technology poses a significant ethical threat and could lead to
breaches of privacy and misrepresentation, thus there is an urgent need for
real-time detection of AI-generated speech for DeepFake Voice Conversion. To
address the above emerging issues, the DEEP-VOICE dataset is generated in this
study, comprised of real human speech from eight well-known figures and their
speech converted to one another using Retrieval-based Voice Conversion.
Presenting as a binary classification problem of whether the speech is real or
AI-generated, statistical analysis of temporal audio features through t-testing
reveals that there are significantly different distributions. Hyperparameter
optimisation is implemented for machine learning models to identify the source
of speech. Following the training of 208 individual machine learning models
over 10-fold cross validation, it is found that the Extreme Gradient Boosting
model can achieve an average classification accuracy of 99.3% and can classify
speech in real-time, at around 0.004 milliseconds given one second of speech.
All data generated for this study is released publicly for future research on
AI speech detection. | [
-0.0077962126,
0.0712803453,
-0.0042101489,
-0.0030270517,
-0.0007274275,
-0.0335549526,
0.0404055975,
-0.001146785,
-0.0528483279,
-0.0154745141,
-0.0604309663,
-0.0052191708,
0.0019265075,
0.0471976176,
0.0003584086,
-0.029659275,
0.0424145125,
-0.0134877628,
-0.0012229899,
-0.0008383386,
-0.0290712956,
0.0139768589,
-0.0399286672,
0.0517682619,
-0.0557749569,
0.0002118306,
0.0082915034,
0.0183411818,
0.0295411572,
0.035617739,
-0.019458726,
-0.0497980528,
0.0283141229,
0.0743533149,
0.0000019541,
-0.01772983,
-0.0415451452,
-0.0084575694,
-0.1115310192,
-0.0263559371,
0.0061183316,
0.0355945565,
-0.0267365035,
0.0310069937,
-0.0575272106,
-0.0157110933,
0.0001472322,
0.029082194,
0.0354545824,
0.0726010203,
-0.0224701688,
-0.0311059058,
0.0767549798,
0.0041191443,
-0.0243426356,
-0.0382319763,
-0.0202520862,
-0.0420041159,
-0.0273672976,
0.0024422214,
0.0233163573,
0.0206403993,
0.004164381,
-0.0151691483,
0.000017343,
-0.0210160613,
-0.0573060289,
-0.0488655232,
0.0002876964,
0.0593241975,
-0.0618779659,
-0.0016967903,
0.0312154144,
0.0167949144,
0.0307911411,
-0.0190973952,
0.0175086856,
0.0243165083,
0.0086094905,
0.025535861,
-0.0205573142,
0.0119246636,
0.0368327275,
-0.0144749479,
0.0201310273,
0.0138991969,
0.0026400227,
0.009428353,
-0.0091663385,
-0.0516000986,
-0.0039114389,
0.0029337155,
0.0428925306,
0.0097927507,
-0.0604415648,
-0.043085441,
-0.0648467541,
-0.0344113819,
-0.0291332603,
0.0144332331,
0.043499168,
0.0302431006,
-0.0693008974,
0.0008490894,
0.005119476,
0.0497047305,
-0.0259061456,
-0.0185594764,
0.0023784193,
0.0089910654,
-0.0285159256,
0.0178129487,
-0.0333888382,
0.0056526996,
-0.0237974916,
-0.0285356864,
-0.0552812554,
-0.0167203713,
-0.0574525446,
0.0234586727,
-0.0295407977,
0.0129788555,
-0.0623869523,
0.0076198797,
0.0294082314,
0.0008380216,
0.0220257305,
0.0814410225,
-0.0013999358,
-0.0905076414,
0.0059345965,
0.0194969382,
0.0211953595,
0.013309231,
0.0572983213,
0.0471466854,
-0.0000928107,
-0.0024958702,
0.0078565041,
-0.0214482769,
0.0071174712,
-0.0414512344,
0.0010996042,
-0.0542654023,
-0.008936543,
-0.0716864243,
0.0028253375,
-0.0076796208,
-0.0106876772,
-0.02105744,
0.0345687568,
0.0389865153,
0.0103722857,
0.062001422,
0.0780109093,
-0.0074730585,
-0.0475596674,
0.0104022864,
0.0631311238,
0.0076033603,
0.0327112861,
-0.0407369658,
0.0467684865,
0.0554107204,
0.0157101303,
0.0180393383,
-0.0294544343,
-0.026486136,
-0.0696190745,
0.0315321684,
0.0571668372,
0.0085987691,
0.0003324768,
-0.0597005114,
0.0401600786,
0.0441042222,
0.0155143309,
0.0233983286,
0.0389826261,
0.0343893841,
0.009411999,
-0.0360890701,
-0.0002410924,
-0.0142568406,
0.0090201255,
-0.0281706024,
-0.0150914686,
0.0339884497,
-0.0328835957,
0.0059283501,
0.0536811054,
-0.0544529632,
-0.0580655448,
0.0012343265,
0.0227720961,
0.0283381343,
-0.0205842983,
-0.0046600006,
-0.0726910904,
-0.0422457568,
0.0041095,
-0.0746064186,
0.0332975984,
0.0087283337,
-0.0040572379,
-0.0087638544,
0.0559307523,
-0.0707463399,
-0.0418351479,
-0.0022974557,
-0.0415204018,
-0.0112868082,
0.0627583563,
0.0095619308,
-0.004082087,
0.0170771386,
-0.0071416809,
0.0353381783,
-0.0252126958,
0.0279731769,
0.0282566007,
0.0088486634,
0.0165292118,
-0.0045471294,
-0.0282023437,
-0.0127050858,
0.0466047376,
0.002803952,
0.0455136001,
0.0275001824,
-0.0360749662,
0.001054598,
0.0080407672,
-0.0465712957,
-0.0291991867,
0.0313773267,
-0.0023812312,
0.0077414177,
0.0320298709,
-0.0903941095,
0.0278050732,
0.0946552381,
-0.0025556383,
-0.080798924,
0.0210761651,
-0.0060894205,
0.0217819549,
-0.0390683636,
0.0315656811,
-0.0243542604,
0.0338873304,
0.028930299,
-0.0064159199,
0.0513537191,
-0.0650684759,
0.0229238309,
0.023805989,
0.0529482327,
-0.0705424696,
0.0186474267,
0.0291826893,
-0.0105304094,
0.0259307288,
-0.02235814,
-0.0473914407,
-0.046617493,
0.0273973867,
-0.056769643,
0.0175328963,
-0.0000769344,
-0.0014581905,
-0.0181499738,
-0.0036558609,
-0.010630291,
-0.009451245,
-0.0524043404,
-0.0137903746,
0.0097643351,
-0.0332797803,
-0.0417643301,
-0.0212362055,
-0.0016837224,
-0.0349727161,
0.023672035,
0.0106101511,
-0.0061603817,
-0.0053769867,
0.0086193392,
-0.0063099749,
-0.0077780746,
0.0505264439,
0.0421805419,
0.0113682803,
-0.0275138579,
-0.011890417,
0.0130837876,
0.0273669735,
0.0812228173,
0.0372636542,
-0.0480115823,
0.0013475412,
0.0593661293,
-0.0570498146,
0.0003080007,
0.048755154,
0.0169948582,
-0.0313240997,
0.0223652646,
-0.0129093891,
-0.0179928672,
0.0561930686,
0.0185951311,
0.0133927744,
0.0107366377,
0.0046100323,
-0.0442474894,
0.0316683426,
-0.0213550925,
-0.0369128585,
0.0325976796,
0.0067401496,
-0.039699968,
-0.0003868232,
-0.0462749787,
-0.0288422201,
0.0144429682,
-0.0690053478,
0.0136898533,
-0.0158714093,
-0.030724572,
0.025708029,
-0.0465701297,
-0.0110542988,
-0.0109913517,
0.0309308246,
0.0135422805,
-0.0844693035,
0.007500933,
0.0059982981,
0.0044357753,
-0.0383607186,
-0.0066858483,
-0.0690640807,
-0.0284163933,
-0.003924943,
0.0060648099,
0.0073310365,
-0.0751849785,
-0.0007367116,
0.0117013119,
0.0023261714,
0.0689892769,
-0.0078048599,
0.0044995779,
-0.0076610935,
0.0790599734,
0.0503122061,
0.002143261,
-0.0050808275,
0.0180713143,
0.0292538758,
-0.0172920506,
0.0364033915,
0.0674093142,
-0.0732653663,
-0.0245699696,
-0.0144102843,
0.0342043005,
-0.0064084427,
-0.0095808376,
0.022364635,
-0.0194005892,
0.0236279219,
0.0624796636,
-0.0118579706,
-0.0746463835,
0.0167141389,
0.0134120258,
-0.0415494181,
-0.0018181917,
-0.0294278134,
-0.0434854515,
-0.0166750606,
0.0502391085,
0.0577991009,
-0.0456793495,
0.0159133952,
-0.0083288494,
-0.0604305156,
0.0308707692,
0.0151363257,
-0.0112549169,
-0.0474015251,
0.0147769982,
0.0146962628,
-0.0046985787,
0.042725794,
-0.0461641662,
0.0153645435,
-0.0024996174,
0.0118534053,
-0.0337006412,
-0.0350784846,
0.0416015796,
-0.0241753776,
0.1086531356,
0.0698364303,
0.0539962612,
-0.043896459,
-0.0118951341,
-0.0331946574,
0.0448569916,
0.006635495,
0.008872278,
0.047241509,
0.0268924721,
-0.0182859935,
0.0508965477,
0.0537464544,
-0.0239671804,
0.043789424,
0.0308805257,
0.0433652401,
-0.032667052,
-0.0326791741,
-0.0414161906,
-0.0181785356,
0.0567751639,
0.0762061402,
0.023879109,
-0.0436712541,
0.0264828056,
0.0319643542,
0.0443989784,
-0.0444707759,
-0.0549028888,
0.0461606383,
0.0131409401,
-0.0380359665,
-0.0587367862,
0.0297389179,
-0.0437345579,
0.0536431707,
-0.0096205967,
-0.0069684116,
-0.0077830791,
0.0260881986,
-0.0283735525,
0.0157578345,
0.0025736643,
0.0706771314,
-0.013721684,
-0.0066640452,
0.0556725338,
-0.0227810442,
-0.0024389175,
0.0312777087,
-0.0122575508,
-0.0053355577,
0.0049253535,
-0.0110801309,
0.0262979679,
0.0249296185,
-0.0214762557,
-0.0007228425,
0.0469523706,
0.0231351275,
-0.0218744297,
0.0131759979,
0.1025290936,
-0.0362327099,
-0.0362162031,
0.0289755054,
-0.008327581,
0.0507711247,
0.0028288076,
-0.0454509258,
-0.0362989828,
-0.067407921,
0.0048440392,
0.0444226004,
-0.0126798255,
-0.0321998671,
0.0471720099,
-0.0146958185,
-0.0231467038,
0.0064630313,
0.0520811677,
-0.0685081705,
-0.0118899532,
0.0659150928,
-0.000215318,
0.0383464955,
-0.0035672234,
0.0065110498,
0.0098315636,
-0.0235581789,
0.0443160459,
-0.0023746453,
0.0570254065,
-0.0217408985,
0.0034709652,
0.009540597,
0.0506753549,
0.0177433901,
0.0211678557,
-0.0001516609,
0.0059049674,
0.0007132511,
-0.0058427174,
0.003291161,
0.0362604931,
-0.0385898314,
-0.0711112544,
0.0010459776,
0.0078671388,
0.0259906854,
-0.0169332083,
0.0685070753,
-0.0142901195,
0.0211653411,
-0.0115810651,
0.0234717615,
-0.0541557707,
-0.0006684998,
-0.0169974063,
0.0021729767,
-0.0054990607,
0.0303652771,
0.0609280057,
0.0087257633,
0.0303518157,
-0.0586630479,
0.0390165895,
-0.016118275,
-0.0088953171,
-0.0046778959,
-0.0403450504,
0.0089628855,
-0.0193954296,
0.0411125906,
-0.0437088013,
-0.0149880797,
-0.0293541029,
0.0014227582,
-0.0111388918,
0.0043444741,
0.0037238251,
-0.0406347774,
-0.0014014646,
-0.0179069322,
-0.0116440589,
0.0348263159,
-0.0124510843,
-0.0235305782,
-5.399900358e-33,
0.0125748422,
0.010408177,
-0.0127358353,
-0.0239401627,
-0.0727262795,
0.0063123396,
-0.01595884,
-0.0046223993,
-0.0304499902,
-0.0170494262,
-0.0383935384,
0.0567644313,
0.0135940462,
0.0188742802,
-0.014097265,
-0.0086240629,
0.0938362554,
-0.0355455503,
-0.0118354708,
0.0746941864,
0.0549456105,
0.0190414824,
0.0191992112,
-0.1196280867,
-0.07823883,
0.0016349303,
-0.0390640385,
-0.021211477,
-0.0085673984,
0.0135028847,
0.023560077,
0.0376546346,
0.0015690657,
-0.060875617,
-0.0171635281,
0.0174081679,
-0.0501852408,
0.0123742297,
-0.0653144941,
0.0389645249,
-0.0192433577,
-0.0334318019,
0.0442685783,
0.0134246144,
-0.0121487593,
-0.006619561,
0.0252008792,
-0.0828216895,
0.0102621587,
-0.0805732831,
-0.0298838671,
0.0020147725,
-0.0359908901,
0.0028796778,
0.0742477477,
0.0886990502,
-0.0385112651,
-0.0526513904,
-0.0502401777,
0.0305503737,
0.0064099492,
-0.0260757301,
0.0327814855,
0.0307105016,
0.0110160736,
0.0160493329,
0.0606631264,
-0.0652791336,
0.0230482016,
-0.0085420953,
0.067569308,
0.0741446912,
0.0307911951,
0.0517057814,
0.0522613823,
-0.0913144052,
-0.0167150889,
0.0187485758,
0.030717982,
-0.0391929932,
0.0142393503,
0.0366636254,
-0.0289946999,
0.0175338481,
-0.0468384773,
-0.0348028317,
0.0062582381,
-0.0174763594,
0.0229131952,
0.0108174235,
-0.0203166753,
-0.0037797526,
0.0521855317,
-0.0634818599,
0.0564652048,
0.0095993159,
-0.0150145246,
-0.0113442894,
0.006372706,
-0.0068698679,
0.0177998003,
-0.0579691045,
0.0824846327,
0.0188456848,
0.0542743169,
-0.0042927195,
-0.0000894227,
0.0623739026,
-0.0354350321,
-0.0142321009,
0.0489795431,
0.0424163938,
0.0094244927,
0.0389475785,
0.0072779427,
-0.0120769572,
0.0189289283,
-0.0047975099,
-0.0175632872,
0.031314522,
-0.0198646206,
0.0016052284,
-0.000907473,
0.0316331424,
-0.0786044672,
0.0056323237,
-0.0387834162,
-0.034269318,
0.0496224128,
-0.0737799555,
0.0039527151,
-0.028748814,
2.758e-7,
-0.0691587329,
-0.025654722,
0.0233910494,
-0.0511905625,
0.021690188,
0.046542421,
0.0185820796,
-0.0058404556,
-0.0222137682,
-0.0215548985,
0.0286702178,
-0.0081194732,
0.0778334737,
0.0440598428,
-0.0378922895,
-0.0411449522,
-0.0360661484,
0.0206781272,
-0.0634786487,
0.0088832956,
0.0255196895,
0.0730687678,
0.0082206978,
-0.0979471728,
0.0574769974,
-0.0296343882,
0.0063287737,
0.0039435034,
0.0399517454,
-0.0143859014,
0.0456201993,
0.0186746679,
0.0087583354,
0.0213180054,
-0.014106215,
0.0350797027,
0.0200670734,
0.0438567065,
-0.012414352,
-0.0504183136,
-0.0282989368,
0.0218002237,
-0.0069053695,
0.0113875251,
0.038425345,
-0.0204570536,
-0.0072316951,
-0.0902972817,
-0.0512480475,
-0.0092023565,
-0.0084759453,
-0.0268345606,
0.0630244911,
0.0167114958,
0.009351179,
0.011560956,
0.0041598422,
-0.0332054421,
0.0078675169,
-0.0007877799,
-0.0742645785,
0.0051942291,
-0.0142296171,
0.0176072083,
-0.0363434143,
0.0143205253,
0.0102054691,
2.014889612e-34,
-0.0241257213,
-0.0067115673,
0.0442433618,
-0.0065152915,
-0.0135681517,
0.0018684785,
0.0148134353,
0.0092189098,
-0.0211599767,
-0.0195076447,
-0.0472040735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12711v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12711v1 | Harnessing the Power of David against Goliath: Exploring Instruction Data Generation without Using Closed-Source Models | 2023-08-24T11:07:47 | 2023-08-24T11:07:47 | Yue Wang, Xinrui Wang, Juntao Li, Jinxiong Chang, Qishen Zhang, Zhongyi Liu, Guannan Zhang, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction tuning is instrumental in enabling Large Language Models~(LLMs)
to follow user instructions to complete various open-domain tasks. The success
of instruction tuning depends on the availability of high-quality instruction
data. Owing to the exorbitant cost and substandard quality of human annotation,
recent works have been deeply engaged in the exploration of the utilization of
powerful closed-source models to generate instruction data automatically.
However, these methods carry potential risks arising from the usage
requirements of powerful closed-source models, which strictly forbid the
utilization of their outputs to develop machine learning models. To deal with
this problem, in this work, we explore alternative approaches to generate
high-quality instruction data that do not rely on closed-source models. Our
exploration includes an investigation of various existing instruction
generation methods, culminating in the integration of the most efficient
variant with two novel strategies to enhance the quality further. Evaluation
results from two benchmarks and the GPT-4 model demonstrate the effectiveness
of our generated instruction data, which can outperform Alpaca, a method
reliant on closed-source models. We hope that more progress can be achieved in
generating high-quality instruction data without using closed-source models. | [
0.0265400577,
0.0555952266,
-0.0256502181,
0.0463555492,
-0.0280347895,
0.0029694806,
-0.0016653545,
-0.0294062328,
0.0083812159,
-0.0442983508,
-0.0344821773,
-0.0128053613,
-0.0059750248,
-0.0200507082,
0.0178943332,
-0.0588398799,
0.0466180705,
-0.0517630503,
-0.0780871361,
0.0178039987,
-0.0144889383,
0.0234830827,
-0.0071873795,
0.0609666668,
0.0111857988,
-0.0177018736,
-0.0322349668,
0.005874061,
-0.004338121,
-0.009282547,
0.0127411466,
0.0717341974,
0.0129643474,
0.013201762,
0.0000020875,
-0.0253054071,
0.0014169854,
-0.0088896202,
-0.0314128883,
0.0436398573,
0.0355373695,
0.011187315,
-0.0292354934,
0.021542104,
-0.010135618,
0.0090674972,
0.0291277505,
-0.0299130734,
0.0975959972,
0.056870997,
0.0306332894,
-0.008241565,
0.0139882741,
0.0183921661,
0.0248421002,
-0.0158913657,
-0.004354992,
0.0249242466,
0.0327488221,
0.0300879013,
-0.0111187305,
-0.000021094,
0.0494173579,
-0.0009315506,
-0.0185109917,
0.0279561598,
-0.0392974764,
0.0005644572,
-0.0338943303,
0.081706591,
-0.0128756119,
-0.0195731893,
-0.0097899409,
-0.0222591776,
0.0047456459,
-0.0192160234,
-0.0304131806,
0.0653543547,
-0.0172837451,
0.0244286153,
0.0275653135,
-0.0086683901,
-0.0039723152,
-0.0100370655,
0.0327134654,
0.0646144673,
0.0128256129,
-0.0216047131,
-0.0022769009,
0.0050927131,
-0.0410650633,
-0.0435300097,
-0.0041381028,
0.0526533388,
-0.0152389538,
0.0314040482,
-0.0937350392,
-0.0212330669,
0.0224151369,
-0.0133945346,
0.1108260825,
0.0616551898,
-0.0144594368,
0.0039629643,
-0.0206776671,
0.0525785461,
-0.0097213695,
0.0217870995,
-0.0284499414,
0.0373660699,
-0.0655899569,
0.0140725709,
-0.0511440784,
0.0352472663,
-0.0579616912,
0.033162646,
-0.0423466116,
0.0732439831,
-0.0112760914,
0.0019041018,
0.033863917,
-0.0166406762,
-0.0570881478,
0.0092406543,
-0.0237891041,
-0.0216378756,
-0.0342633389,
-0.0119360117,
0.0028015464,
-0.0718904957,
0.0128804361,
0.0191802252,
-0.031652052,
-0.0163884703,
0.0152551839,
0.0791547447,
0.0006244347,
-0.0027831141,
-0.0636296123,
-0.0452280231,
0.0158235915,
-0.0603724867,
0.0135299116,
-0.068423368,
0.0233664196,
0.016704876,
-0.0188632347,
-0.0361192413,
0.0293639787,
0.0465105623,
-0.0105821081,
0.0294855814,
-0.0271027852,
0.0220061485,
0.0052289204,
-0.0064137178,
-0.0048323721,
0.0445937142,
0.038959194,
0.0197060723,
0.0296405293,
-0.0420185663,
0.0266709886,
0.0571269765,
0.0152150095,
0.0054016644,
0.0135605624,
-0.0028944614,
0.0087470384,
0.0117053548,
0.0217551216,
0.0554210171,
-0.0108395731,
0.0052108578,
0.0358267352,
0.0329329669,
-0.033657819,
0.0063355835,
0.1200959384,
0.0323478766,
0.0398081653,
0.0295958817,
-0.0675708503,
0.0163900666,
0.0026471077,
0.0012492051,
-0.0001444156,
0.0172316507,
-0.0291179568,
-0.0616066158,
0.0062993891,
-0.0232374463,
-0.0003225341,
-0.0072209197,
0.0452949516,
-0.0112514291,
-0.0668433905,
0.028428629,
0.0542493984,
-0.047722131,
0.0005082094,
-0.0690543428,
0.0275640506,
0.0818472579,
0.0508987084,
0.0032077683,
-0.0341044739,
-0.0007184314,
0.0494845137,
0.0161672775,
0.0330240615,
-0.0273167733,
-0.000426108,
-0.0712592825,
-0.0357146561,
-0.0037415766,
0.0070060003,
0.017734386,
0.0412236564,
-0.054481443,
0.0272509307,
-0.0247565415,
-0.0821013078,
0.0555231683,
-0.0425165258,
-0.0641200021,
-0.0180703681,
0.0064173136,
0.0213743057,
0.0271855704,
0.0025471931,
0.0218991786,
0.0473483391,
0.0125371162,
0.0366808362,
-0.0282437466,
-0.0620997548,
0.0180587117,
0.014058549,
-0.0183338113,
-0.0301725883,
0.032619074,
-0.0400779732,
-0.0352825895,
-0.035534624,
-0.0505148135,
0.0206788089,
-0.016071111,
0.0114443395,
0.0210818946,
-0.0379599743,
-0.0364959799,
0.0350526832,
-0.0249019414,
0.0187705513,
0.057949651,
0.0011387998,
0.0049039982,
-0.0360609777,
0.002046898,
-0.0120202256,
-0.0128860343,
0.0445212312,
-0.0041654524,
0.0458785594,
-0.0482487604,
-0.0145055791,
-0.0762916058,
0.0237699952,
-0.0123181734,
0.0231569298,
0.0451141335,
-0.0199172869,
-0.0045649349,
-0.0109874588,
-0.0287456922,
-0.0363075435,
-0.0007421321,
0.0174880885,
0.0142752016,
0.0179623105,
-0.0345292576,
-0.0346509591,
-0.0159132108,
-0.0252839159,
-0.0284087509,
0.0086565372,
0.0450197197,
-0.084210813,
0.0314671136,
0.018270256,
0.046239987,
0.0007272658,
-0.0378305428,
0.0470293164,
0.0069846488,
0.0280962642,
0.0641219765,
-0.0100609912,
0.0413342416,
0.0282642469,
0.0008393874,
-0.0689607114,
0.0291617699,
-0.0409923643,
-0.0513665564,
-0.0158714298,
-0.0653930679,
0.0103726462,
0.0723981336,
0.0056453152,
0.0118581364,
-0.0749581382,
-0.0006291086,
-0.0251547862,
-0.0238069259,
-0.0281061903,
0.0204896256,
-0.0296376031,
-0.0036323592,
-0.0315068141,
-0.0762237608,
0.0595248193,
-0.027538456,
0.0146503318,
-0.0251458045,
0.0037938482,
0.0001006828,
0.0352677628,
0.0183688719,
0.0113678686,
-0.0072699501,
-0.0057291472,
-0.0541131832,
0.0530283339,
0.0131003838,
-0.0335460007,
0.0357070565,
-0.0885606632,
-0.0302847046,
0.0040680137,
-0.0061626802,
-0.0617175736,
-0.0027843942,
0.0151654743,
0.0092062987,
0.0426763184,
-0.0225609466,
-0.0008499669,
-0.0048014452,
0.0169598367,
0.0353928469,
-0.0233715475,
0.0032709276,
-0.0434964225,
-0.0258707199,
0.0380267426,
-0.0454084128,
-0.0523300245,
-0.0546423644,
0.0083632367,
0.0432432853,
0.0506305248,
-0.0034610021,
-0.0111710131,
-0.0000249949,
0.0323794112,
-0.0364402346,
-0.0280813761,
0.074339509,
0.0777538493,
-0.0764238089,
-0.0082335761,
0.1103294119,
0.0405144617,
-0.0188630074,
0.0052812234,
0.0066513545,
0.0200810991,
0.0086943917,
0.0340812579,
-0.0739078149,
-0.0290782694,
-0.0086630164,
0.086928688,
-0.0040316596,
-0.0326020606,
-0.0058469013,
-0.1373167038,
0.0423862264,
0.0196720622,
-0.0475381464,
-0.0106894188,
-0.0350186042,
-0.0194402225,
-0.0144476071,
0.0063489205,
0.0210305229,
-0.0177963693,
0.0287508257,
0.0538900644,
-0.0205462016,
-0.0582213029,
0.0452657826,
-0.0240331683,
0.0682628155,
0.0631177127,
0.003213655,
0.0326796733,
-0.0532424524,
0.0479751229,
-0.0024610842,
0.0145498458,
-0.0132159991,
0.0586162396,
-0.0168794747,
-0.0151343569,
-0.0168855675,
0.0546488315,
-0.0459655821,
0.0199763793,
0.0134329712,
0.0731256753,
-0.0226657894,
0.032332778,
-0.0274653826,
-0.0320944861,
0.0389870368,
0.0589326099,
0.0228959303,
-0.0747859702,
-0.0324150734,
-0.0496630333,
-0.0192400478,
-0.0917210728,
-0.0261501838,
0.0370391756,
-0.0656873286,
-0.016175976,
-0.0547445044,
-0.0882312208,
0.0685383826,
0.0015307398,
0.010681835,
-0.0314912871,
0.0369703472,
-0.0139863752,
-0.0345671438,
0.0320094191,
-0.0601901002,
0.0231784508,
-0.1146694869,
-0.0899873078,
-0.0062963176,
-0.0017086957,
-0.0020563016,
0.0437310897,
-0.0574879982,
-0.0561271347,
0.0172776245,
0.110655494,
0.0179608464,
0.0430504493,
0.0029692091,
0.001741856,
-0.024517782,
-0.0016810109,
-0.015646372,
-0.020472005,
0.0161006916,
-0.0135831311,
-0.0102327643,
-0.0017644578,
-0.0262452252,
0.0452308692,
0.0213637687,
0.0302191712,
-0.0327263176,
-0.0188539848,
0.0529222749,
0.0236847103,
0.029950466,
-0.033994548,
-0.0170004554,
-0.0093583344,
-0.0064683398,
-0.0189808682,
-0.0139971199,
-0.0577984676,
0.0163449943,
0.0041712164,
-0.0156522039,
0.0259992871,
-0.0300681703,
-0.033990372,
0.053798493,
-0.0290920027,
0.0140068978,
0.0088587422,
0.0589751601,
0.040539775,
0.0146554699,
-0.0202317536,
0.014941249,
0.0070979916,
0.0571377315,
0.0166928731,
0.0731742829,
-0.0052418462,
0.0378302746,
0.0224356446,
0.0432335958,
-0.0091565493,
-0.0117461421,
-0.083820112,
0.0177386198,
0.028370915,
0.0070335702,
0.0254884381,
-0.03505807,
0.0000317756,
-0.0325921737,
0.0529830493,
0.0100412332,
-0.0325703993,
0.008590702,
0.030934697,
0.0037816612,
-0.0453629419,
0.0923101455,
0.0159207005,
0.0744276121,
-0.0252397377,
-0.0080973897,
-0.0544867814,
-0.0190061871,
0.014914358,
-0.0055615278,
-0.0110162925,
0.0123026697,
-0.0369721353,
-0.0560803302,
-0.0518816113,
0.0643136725,
0.021667121,
-0.0142225781,
0.0689608455,
0.0220237803,
-0.0483083241,
-0.0220219679,
-0.0603195578,
-0.0071617709,
-0.0264592879,
-0.0335510671,
-0.0219392106,
-5.807379965e-33,
-0.0593688227,
-0.020785166,
0.0428813174,
0.0109089557,
0.0136334095,
-0.0100183943,
-0.0230566692,
0.0003742913,
-0.0114830928,
-0.0148833338,
0.020188285,
-0.0283519216,
0.0116337212,
0.0193468202,
0.0393365361,
0.0068777376,
0.0360814035,
-0.0422229916,
-0.0372269824,
0.0477235839,
0.0374328271,
-0.0148801422,
0.0417376757,
-0.0450090244,
0.0229713693,
-0.0353553593,
0.0036600058,
0.0163259171,
-0.0094279451,
0.0763598159,
-0.0097642634,
0.0272053201,
0.0146317994,
-0.0400822759,
-0.0195732769,
-0.0072307587,
-0.0298363268,
-0.0261473767,
0.0150805591,
-0.0038491911,
-0.057718616,
-0.0580366366,
-0.0021816953,
-0.022198068,
-0.0334931724,
0.0093631409,
0.0377917439,
-0.0072052279,
0.0071326862,
0.0088576125,
-0.0783018991,
0.0135188783,
0.0088397972,
-0.0582645237,
-0.013998081,
0.0529602617,
0.0031672469,
-0.0291053597,
-0.0231051538,
0.0464605838,
0.066574432,
0.0493733957,
0.0910943151,
0.0251817387,
0.0167862847,
0.0119923828,
0.041471988,
0.0227004457,
-0.0104270233,
0.0357300565,
0.0130524598,
0.0614763014,
0.0185266323,
-0.0035592353,
-0.0047837333,
0.0094994707,
-0.0091164028,
0.0403747931,
0.0029637329,
0.0089731766,
0.0067210239,
-0.021707302,
-0.0565273948,
-0.0055431654,
-0.027015958,
-0.0055045788,
0.0033267327,
-0.0350474566,
0.0510739423,
-0.0001528846,
-0.0466449112,
-0.0048614214,
0.0203713235,
-0.0168103315,
0.0091952505,
-0.0211297758,
-0.0196978617,
0.0327501334,
-0.0156792775,
-0.0052414746,
-0.0389591232,
-0.07057973,
0.0344027579,
-0.0318061039,
0.0444265008,
0.0335346982,
0.0163890813,
0.0412711352,
-0.0437945165,
0.0150839742,
-0.0734969974,
0.0435978584,
0.0145834833,
-0.0288757365,
0.035095308,
-0.0159144476,
-0.0239079837,
0.0713127702,
0.0021226981,
-0.0246724002,
-0.0253657661,
-0.044163119,
0.0123938881,
0.0106908111,
-0.0269089472,
0.0083003892,
-0.0282635037,
0.0087491749,
-0.0093855094,
-0.0198838226,
-0.0036796345,
0.0082894973,
2.621e-7,
0.0258738995,
0.0258041378,
0.0384112075,
0.0281096026,
-0.00487096,
0.0224331375,
-0.0077257957,
-0.0136019299,
0.0075598494,
-0.0185362529,
-0.0086996742,
0.0123905586,
0.0457803346,
0.0207749698,
-0.0502274595,
-0.0060739992,
0.0023827921,
0.0100291502,
-0.066207312,
0.0195963383,
0.0369578265,
0.0535226502,
-0.0033702087,
0.0015815496,
0.0022596992,
0.0102320919,
0.0202531423,
-0.015356726,
-0.0172138698,
0.030359026,
0.0172517858,
0.0268771891,
-0.0111853182,
-0.0037040163,
-0.0223681871,
-0.0287239812,
-0.0061078821,
0.0958536193,
-0.0153304385,
0.0029330628,
0.0442927219,
-0.0551775619,
-0.0095278323,
-0.0194239132,
0.0313071273,
-0.0317226425,
0.0283709466,
0.0047509712,
-0.0130700264,
-0.012834874,
-0.0287961215,
-0.0330974907,
0.0102684824,
0.001353358,
0.0087443776,
-0.0337098464,
0.0039858455,
-0.0279028844,
-0.0113423998,
-0.0020051773,
-0.031994272,
-0.0773563981,
-0.0439710245,
0.0020641319,
-0.0002387249,
-0.0278008934,
-0.0052782749,
2.49433312e-34,
0.0113317361,
-0.0207693446,
0.0670807287,
0.0209014639,
0.0090118814,
0.0138596613,
-0.017378144,
0.0281565618,
0.0133613031,
-0.0486976206,
-0.0451051295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12674v1 | Improving Translation Faithfulness of Large Language Models via Augmenting Instructions | 2023-08-24T09:32:29 | 2023-08-24T09:32:29 | Yijie Chen, Yijin Liu, Fandong Meng, Yufeng Chen, Jinan Xu, Jie Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) present strong general capabilities, and a
current compelling challenge is stimulating their specialized capabilities,
such as machine translation, through low-cost instruction tuning. The standard
instruction-following data is sequentially organized as the concatenation of an
instruction, an input, and a response. As the attention mechanism of LLMs has
limitations on local focus, LLMs tend to focus more on the words or sentences
nearby at each position. This leads to a high risk of instruction forgetting
during decoding. To alleviate the above issues, We propose SWIE
(Segment-Weighted Instruction Embedding) and an instruction-following dataset
OVERMISS. SWIE improves the model instruction understanding by adding a global
instruction representation on the following input and response representations.
OVERMISS improves model faithfulness by comparing over-translation and
miss-translation results with the correct translation. We apply our methods to
two main-stream open-source LLMs, BLOOM and LLaMA. The experimental results
demonstrate significant improvements in translation performance with SWIE based
on BLOOMZ-3b, particularly in zero-shot and long text translations due to
reduced instruction forgetting risk. Additionally, OVERMISS outperforms the
baseline in translation performance (e.g. an increase in BLEU scores from 0.69
to 3.12 and an average improvement of 0.48 percentage comet scores for
LLaMA-7b) with further enhancements seen in models combining OVERMISS and SWIE
(e.g. the BLUE scores increase up to 0.56 from English to German across three
different backbones), and both exhibit improvements in the faithfulness metric
based on word alignment. | [
0.0230921283,
0.0413361676,
0.0121677602,
0.0301561318,
-0.0178658888,
0.0306583419,
0.0297715105,
-0.0368579924,
-0.0197634585,
-0.0230477694,
-0.0471781865,
-0.0477918796,
0.0213961788,
-0.0001964594,
0.0339707211,
-0.0247461293,
0.0618657693,
-0.0247723963,
-0.0398421809,
0.0054435721,
0.0328207165,
0.0132135656,
0.0237637572,
0.0342019498,
0.0562209748,
-0.008919281,
-0.0117172049,
0.037045978,
0.0419321321,
-0.0197579134,
-0.0142007302,
0.0286465641,
0.036767967,
0.0488938279,
0.000002289,
-0.0217601508,
-0.0362546071,
0.0036670447,
-0.0159437042,
0.0648611188,
0.065768607,
-0.0693878904,
-0.0265189316,
0.038168259,
0.0249532275,
0.0160844177,
0.0697240159,
0.0401189514,
0.061606966,
0.082855314,
-0.0097710695,
-0.0459435992,
0.0328809321,
-0.0444359072,
0.0025489526,
-0.021078812,
0.0074482816,
0.0094600981,
-0.0308359005,
0.0539284162,
-0.036388386,
0.0582267158,
0.0218868237,
0.0122861341,
0.0110664461,
0.0125138825,
-0.0035280287,
-0.0142793031,
-0.0077552521,
0.0757311955,
-0.0560838245,
-0.0191128757,
-0.03549961,
-0.0114824241,
-0.0179126561,
-0.0464923978,
-0.074808307,
0.031504605,
0.0472478643,
0.0106816096,
0.026469864,
0.0001775319,
0.0236298572,
-0.02131816,
-0.0449228659,
0.0031999859,
0.0428939648,
-0.055220224,
-0.0487002805,
-0.0058005829,
-0.0438723862,
-0.043551974,
0.0330778211,
0.0130821737,
-0.0150084076,
0.0396743938,
-0.0635975525,
-0.0220918972,
0.013675971,
-0.0358343236,
0.1021211371,
0.1106152833,
-0.0347158127,
0.0332936458,
-0.0284544993,
0.0903885141,
-0.0268409494,
0.0236554444,
-0.0734267384,
0.0128884604,
-0.0414997935,
0.0358843878,
-0.0142551707,
0.0107934251,
-0.0433216691,
-0.0310742538,
-0.015943855,
0.0553219877,
0.0091830203,
0.0107027069,
0.0185474921,
-0.0348906294,
-0.0516590439,
0.0042233896,
0.0033665048,
0.0500967614,
-0.010511484,
-0.0122245634,
-0.0091800103,
-0.0473092571,
-0.0327536315,
0.0202427786,
0.002639605,
-0.0428041182,
-0.0027025226,
0.0360257626,
-0.011338843,
-0.0394920073,
-0.0140811456,
0.0072868615,
0.0071462817,
-0.0444519222,
-0.0115197068,
-0.052936893,
0.059688352,
0.0089845303,
0.0085221697,
-0.0281399563,
0.025801938,
0.0286020078,
-0.043584846,
0.0438422412,
0.0235712528,
-0.0034790155,
-0.0377369896,
0.0102684619,
0.0375236906,
0.0462653488,
0.0202242993,
0.0042641489,
0.0189784281,
0.0129022719,
-0.0429376401,
0.0442052409,
0.0245166123,
0.0578107014,
-0.0282779541,
0.0265334025,
0.0354462899,
0.0258049928,
0.0544564202,
0.0516178496,
-0.0253703631,
-0.0108522484,
0.0795315504,
0.0128627708,
-0.0237126928,
0.0207620468,
0.0476067439,
0.0278395247,
-0.0173922163,
0.0259352569,
-0.0473494977,
0.0397671089,
0.0007860389,
0.0240876265,
0.0466764681,
0.0399503037,
-0.0447637066,
-0.0277999211,
-0.0263644028,
-0.0226072948,
-0.001131531,
0.006602616,
0.0198988076,
-0.0167739969,
-0.07753589,
0.0578045547,
0.0232628174,
-0.0664674863,
0.0006055522,
-0.019382257,
0.0010797462,
0.0909882188,
0.0434552841,
0.0052152434,
-0.0395537987,
0.0082740784,
0.0397304967,
0.0341496989,
0.0375537723,
0.0303899311,
0.0379629843,
-0.0720958859,
-0.0267619025,
-0.0093005532,
-0.0122599611,
0.034323018,
0.0176873785,
0.0021839207,
0.017998362,
-0.0002314551,
-0.0625513643,
0.0497452728,
-0.0476955585,
-0.0292959958,
-0.0316951647,
-0.0079749804,
0.009486055,
0.0081863813,
-0.0141451014,
0.0093270503,
0.0381691754,
-0.0438728593,
0.0304896664,
-0.0073425425,
-0.0612433106,
-0.0502132326,
0.0248219203,
0.0031379792,
-0.0083955219,
0.0074232481,
-0.0466463082,
-0.0483562239,
0.0052788318,
-0.0317850597,
0.038880147,
-0.0184494276,
0.0409882031,
0.000519814,
0.0286067389,
-0.0456863567,
0.0199217126,
-0.0413282104,
0.0171500053,
0.0120921489,
-0.0132664992,
0.0158951338,
-0.0439968519,
-0.0141365854,
0.0078900298,
0.0031593191,
0.0202523936,
-0.0064660842,
0.0115406187,
-0.0336162262,
-0.0210274328,
-0.0896681473,
0.0411211513,
-0.0157102551,
0.033805985,
0.0447618067,
0.0432573073,
0.0012479776,
-0.0004480127,
-0.0120606013,
-0.019794371,
-0.0215637963,
0.0144142304,
-0.0044812192,
-0.0306173246,
-0.0268638209,
-0.0286161788,
-0.0199592207,
0.0085234055,
0.0143684456,
-0.0141478796,
0.009935597,
-0.0854097679,
0.0269207079,
-0.0411093272,
0.0091886073,
0.014630571,
-0.0819526762,
-0.008141608,
-0.0028712077,
0.0601351336,
0.0942870378,
-0.0237281006,
-0.0213931948,
0.0588595904,
-0.0052357353,
-0.0554371774,
-0.0116353016,
-0.0279458072,
-0.0338285156,
-0.0062280735,
-0.0545483641,
-0.0091873547,
0.0680243075,
-0.0030096858,
-0.0053990148,
-0.0547850765,
-0.0305858236,
-0.0078666164,
0.0075459685,
-0.0035364837,
0.001754642,
-0.0107108708,
-0.0069316751,
-0.0408555008,
-0.0716796592,
0.0503756963,
-0.0682047531,
-0.0163442697,
-0.0525224321,
0.0085313162,
-0.0333070531,
0.0240878575,
-0.0004032227,
0.0253819581,
-0.0465544052,
-0.0024715553,
-0.0435225628,
0.0364176668,
-0.005281508,
-0.0218124706,
0.0274532661,
-0.0464551337,
-0.0058521298,
-0.0246415399,
0.0055573066,
-0.0384056643,
-0.0227684136,
0.0067284615,
0.0075295237,
0.0247421153,
-0.0219975729,
-0.0446743816,
0.0075002974,
0.0568152219,
0.0498004183,
-0.0463990495,
0.0113528948,
-0.0465966873,
-0.0086831814,
0.0095263608,
-0.0193912257,
0.0218788069,
-0.056863565,
0.0125664715,
0.0413817614,
0.0335759707,
-0.0292079113,
-0.0362918414,
-0.0017816796,
0.0485159457,
0.0005643332,
-0.0051996796,
0.0125845205,
0.0891505182,
-0.0691031739,
-0.0249565542,
0.1150865257,
0.0432903804,
-0.0453889556,
-0.0071117179,
-0.025503099,
0.050397791,
0.0232952777,
0.0302428156,
-0.0698652938,
-0.0446047746,
0.0190194063,
0.0413452014,
0.028770078,
0.036748752,
-0.0188102033,
-0.1172266901,
0.0275791138,
0.0681160986,
-0.018807305,
-0.0512789562,
-0.0282619763,
-0.0158613771,
0.0166777819,
0.0369833633,
0.0061783618,
0.0141490977,
-0.0096487207,
0.0125601972,
0.0173084829,
-0.0640198812,
0.0141676161,
-0.0418281667,
0.0457179099,
0.0832271501,
0.0167054832,
0.0313514546,
-0.0337627679,
0.0479018316,
-0.0228959229,
-0.0136447689,
-0.0104771378,
0.0120276995,
-0.0130499937,
-0.0017266653,
0.0028945748,
0.0153349964,
-0.0391088687,
0.001083591,
-0.0118669085,
0.0645820498,
-0.0148452967,
0.0294660721,
-0.0209653378,
-0.028816158,
-0.0108871013,
0.0774522647,
0.0376254022,
-0.0380661115,
-0.0110421116,
-0.0327545591,
-0.0146079259,
-0.0666379184,
-0.0029927543,
0.0285301246,
-0.0814614147,
-0.036107488,
-0.0617738739,
-0.0325834602,
0.0188318491,
0.0249928981,
0.023553865,
-0.0090181315,
0.0103540486,
-0.0425152667,
-0.0418142229,
0.0457573757,
-0.050780125,
0.0240177419,
-0.077373676,
-0.0152884237,
-0.0067719514,
-0.0126425968,
0.0041209497,
0.0167111419,
-0.0909102783,
-0.0623452254,
0.0031794072,
0.0528242514,
0.0118535813,
0.044963669,
-0.0272090212,
-0.0360039733,
0.0129788024,
0.0091460515,
-0.0329540372,
0.0266284142,
0.0175585207,
-0.0158779286,
0.0195717737,
0.0352280512,
-0.013830605,
0.0182428379,
0.0179622602,
0.063794218,
0.0076879757,
-0.0051413965,
0.0134871025,
0.0346923918,
0.0286553521,
0.0039031201,
-0.0075043202,
-0.0140838297,
0.0484709367,
-0.00667021,
0.0078538675,
-0.0448368229,
-0.0130951023,
0.0595988519,
-0.0121674361,
0.0077196625,
0.0427053198,
-0.0300929546,
-0.0233209021,
-0.0259390157,
0.0283410307,
-0.0182554256,
0.0229604319,
0.0111976983,
0.0261330102,
-0.0406247154,
0.0024739464,
-0.0060885563,
0.0236955285,
-0.042089209,
0.0542816855,
-0.0108883809,
0.0205320138,
-0.0288224816,
0.0547774695,
-0.0406277739,
0.0081278812,
-0.0248926282,
-0.0090025058,
0.0468652062,
-0.0018973303,
0.0911919549,
0.015538211,
-0.0132155782,
-0.0303259194,
0.0533832796,
-0.0236315634,
-0.0405695103,
0.0060335174,
0.0152989486,
-0.0206192769,
0.0231301971,
0.0455014482,
0.0002604923,
0.0078175394,
-0.0179347843,
0.0022870398,
-0.0107098296,
-0.0147685949,
0.0292415023,
0.0112670455,
-0.0481824949,
-0.007471473,
-0.0328019708,
-0.0519922003,
-0.0118542463,
0.0174416024,
-0.0266095903,
-0.0338854976,
0.0008651868,
0.0265648123,
-0.0453110263,
-0.0022648843,
-0.0303756576,
0.0074174404,
-0.0285420083,
-0.0437611267,
0.0024955394,
-7.104960424e-33,
-0.0352084227,
0.0201954935,
0.0057483129,
-0.0850402936,
-0.0497313589,
0.0214986112,
-0.0415918604,
-0.027295189,
0.0016135315,
-0.016313171,
-0.0037251066,
0.0034290585,
0.0164189097,
0.0134801492,
-0.0054380624,
0.0056356881,
0.0469062254,
0.000540407,
-0.0388473533,
0.0323420539,
0.0525556728,
0.0117160073,
0.0462560318,
-0.0278675519,
0.0426436551,
-0.0372354127,
0.0095007252,
0.0081408862,
0.0034023214,
0.0678868368,
-0.0168734938,
0.0150181232,
-0.0071739685,
-0.0125760147,
-0.0551290736,
-0.0041774572,
-0.0782519802,
-0.0058094892,
0.0262041539,
0.0124187283,
-0.0354133733,
-0.040455129,
0.0473819077,
-0.0177051891,
-0.0113928234,
-0.0464709476,
-0.0037297462,
-0.0332703777,
-0.0453393348,
0.0420270599,
-0.0834628865,
0.0003211407,
0.0007235184,
-0.022299068,
0.0211986769,
0.0431760848,
0.0184650552,
0.0298655909,
-0.0678898692,
0.0142096123,
0.0069198348,
0.0701910332,
0.0783655569,
0.0137689216,
0.0126512926,
0.0070144646,
0.0322725438,
-0.0180001594,
0.0137490593,
-0.0075547691,
0.0507741943,
-0.0098723108,
0.0384086706,
-0.0138689866,
0.032786902,
0.0000465587,
-0.0622427128,
0.0149171185,
0.0186991449,
0.0216131806,
0.041798491,
0.0335296057,
-0.0341656655,
-0.0147963287,
-0.0185511597,
-0.0265301373,
-0.0492076054,
-0.0132404296,
0.0448422432,
0.0306671131,
-0.0281665362,
-0.0110572213,
0.0906354561,
-0.0063237194,
0.025845388,
-0.0039171702,
-0.0246404167,
0.027260866,
-0.0074012442,
0.0596763194,
-0.0697713196,
-0.0536376387,
0.0154161537,
-0.0516040549,
0.0071887416,
0.008657122,
0.0562123917,
0.0275120232,
-0.048672922,
0.0003681145,
-0.0617979057,
-0.0178827625,
-0.0079295933,
0.0306234267,
0.0166335143,
0.0066997041,
0.0069542532,
0.0812842399,
0.0160301756,
0.0074135815,
-0.0246062018,
-0.0294121467,
0.0017298629,
0.0515850447,
-0.0652735904,
0.021027226,
-0.0486473106,
0.0152979121,
-0.0029762578,
-0.0564006716,
-0.0528883785,
0.0296262875,
2.983e-7,
0.0359108113,
0.0712068975,
0.0138038686,
0.0290857572,
-0.0049408618,
0.0155943371,
-0.0426368453,
0.023456905,
0.0129327588,
0.0249161106,
0.0149273789,
0.0288524348,
0.0637535676,
-0.0040455372,
-0.0719885826,
-0.0015574307,
-0.0239925645,
0.0400630534,
-0.0649971962,
0.0074158837,
0.036084339,
0.128791213,
0.0058706477,
0.0444055051,
0.0255440976,
-0.0023924508,
0.0572847351,
0.0055025374,
-0.0283803754,
0.0010967606,
0.0031276813,
0.0549966656,
-0.0535482801,
-0.0221529305,
-0.0154318223,
0.0055433516,
0.0099272216,
0.096916914,
-0.0181205813,
-0.0334701203,
0.0219296068,
-0.0299612582,
-0.0210864134,
-0.0462146327,
0.0608035251,
-0.027531147,
-0.0024932262,
0.0124149267,
-0.0110571794,
0.0167147648,
0.0156059386,
-0.0149410861,
-0.0236756317,
0.0219066851,
0.0547836088,
-0.0251098536,
-0.0422265455,
-0.0559967756,
-0.030441612,
-0.0142750563,
-0.0076857782,
-0.0508017913,
-0.0444865264,
0.0308631659,
0.0228047483,
-0.063531138,
-0.017460458,
3.392654398e-34,
0.0296968911,
-0.022446461,
0.029512018,
-0.0016438497,
0.0476102568,
-0.0458299294,
-0.0046436326,
0.0197473764,
0.0018368954,
-0.0760084987,
-0.0379767045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12648v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12648v1 | From Chatter to Matter: Addressing Critical Steps of Emotion Recognition Learning in Task-oriented Dialogue | 2023-08-24T08:46:30 | 2023-08-24T08:46:30 | Shutong Feng, Nurul Lubis, Benjamin Ruppik, Christian Geishauser, Michael Heck, Hsien-chin Lin, Carel van Niekerk, Renato Vukovic, Milica Gašić | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotion recognition in conversations (ERC) is a crucial task for building
human-like conversational agents. While substantial efforts have been devoted
to ERC for chit-chat dialogues, the task-oriented counterpart is largely left
unattended. Directly applying chit-chat ERC models to task-oriented dialogues
(ToDs) results in suboptimal performance as these models overlook key features
such as the correlation between emotions and task completion in ToDs. In this
paper, we propose a framework that turns a chit-chat ERC model into a
task-oriented one, addressing three critical aspects: data, features and
objective. First, we devise two ways of augmenting rare emotions to improve ERC
performance. Second, we use dialogue states as auxiliary features to
incorporate key information from the goal of the user. Lastly, we leverage a
multi-aspect emotion definition in ToDs to devise a multi-task learning
objective and a novel emotion-distance weighted loss function. Our framework
yields significant improvements for a range of chit-chat ERC models on EmoWOZ,
a large-scale dataset for user emotion in ToDs. We further investigate the
generalisability of the best resulting model to predict user satisfaction in
different ToD datasets. A comparison with supervised baselines shows a strong
zero-shot capability, highlighting the potential usage of our framework in
wider scenarios. | [
0.0432061553,
0.0383921117,
-0.0023456332,
0.0195149146,
-0.0013415165,
0.0430015884,
-0.0181515571,
-0.0255665574,
0.0411608703,
-0.0321206003,
-0.0719261989,
-0.005841759,
-0.0370635949,
0.027689226,
-0.013090821,
-0.0543840192,
0.010828807,
0.0587308519,
0.0324711129,
0.0192739088,
0.0414828807,
0.0323863886,
-0.0013291868,
0.0554928333,
-0.0529430769,
-0.010617516,
-0.061545644,
0.0350978374,
0.0279971454,
-0.0016166811,
0.0931547284,
0.0477483422,
0.0049384157,
-0.0025445849,
0.000002036,
-0.0305811632,
-0.0054687406,
-0.0377870947,
-0.0261840131,
-0.0449035168,
0.0803666711,
0.0150653627,
-0.0112628043,
0.0091902576,
-0.0159304906,
0.0126070604,
0.0654624924,
0.1123610437,
0.0923492908,
0.0984479487,
-0.03653761,
0.0171873327,
-0.0045865825,
-0.0182886478,
0.0621453077,
-0.0490833372,
0.0048056175,
0.033946652,
0.0073551559,
-0.0291350167,
-0.0064395992,
-0.0139441779,
0.013765038,
-0.0135872606,
0.0184470117,
0.0036702049,
-0.0166778676,
-0.0388662592,
-0.0221682303,
0.0896870941,
-0.0183759239,
0.0223169792,
-0.0040927581,
0.0145313097,
0.0148252537,
-0.0404739603,
-0.0414428525,
-0.0593198426,
-0.0071385014,
0.0113555361,
-0.012766188,
0.0339106433,
-0.0193284247,
0.037775442,
0.0069300975,
0.0021494301,
-0.0460190587,
-0.0266526695,
0.021618627,
0.0188875999,
0.0028975236,
-0.011621316,
-0.0056940252,
-0.0108634392,
-0.0164787415,
0.0083729727,
-0.0315888189,
0.0069358656,
-0.0185700599,
-0.0512748882,
-0.0200871062,
0.0447693542,
-0.0384556167,
0.0472702272,
0.0282057095,
0.0258199163,
0.0234762151,
-0.0189734213,
-0.0406792834,
-0.0065545221,
-0.0849139616,
0.0085049774,
-0.0270860568,
0.0358952917,
-0.0152490409,
-0.02924053,
-0.0694679171,
0.0349971317,
-0.0382885225,
0.0133254984,
0.0530437119,
0.0248369407,
-0.0225961749,
-0.0041611856,
-0.0072009778,
0.0252856519,
0.0046314155,
0.04067377,
0.0201142803,
-0.034040235,
-0.0276768766,
0.0198024102,
0.0052868025,
-0.008245633,
0.0211695861,
0.0329598784,
-0.0012861373,
-0.0640290454,
0.0166770443,
-0.0178805757,
-0.0423818789,
-0.0810911283,
-0.004032833,
0.0044462513,
0.0558298714,
-0.0264305193,
0.0049289721,
-0.0028298323,
-0.0009323639,
-0.0142811937,
-0.0146614257,
0.0670142993,
-0.0083700251,
-0.0285871048,
-0.0127670998,
0.028466966,
-0.0246178135,
0.0589125603,
0.0080920737,
0.0792002827,
0.0260718167,
0.0051011327,
0.0226885006,
0.0090680551,
-0.0143171465,
-0.0142821837,
0.0622040145,
0.0020905689,
-0.0031343228,
0.015153694,
0.0408801474,
0.0215510558,
-0.0546829179,
-0.0160613675,
0.0474859141,
0.0407992341,
-0.0319654942,
0.0256512295,
-0.0177900568,
0.0593369082,
0.0095216222,
-0.0191315096,
-0.0260639992,
0.0420813821,
-0.0193837769,
-0.0177639835,
0.0396577865,
-0.0182233006,
-0.0671615899,
-0.0565635711,
0.0191246569,
-0.0489529371,
0.0176883414,
0.0153694255,
0.0268768985,
-0.0214985721,
-0.0738843307,
-0.0036587052,
0.0184038151,
-0.0672397241,
-0.0222120341,
-0.0446662381,
0.0084128417,
0.0780406818,
0.0179702975,
-0.0599971414,
-0.0555631854,
-0.032472536,
-0.0095821898,
0.0278346855,
0.0235463083,
-0.0260690041,
0.057102859,
-0.0606514253,
0.0033343912,
-0.0131435338,
-0.0017618411,
0.0038055272,
-0.0209556632,
-0.0033860912,
0.0031217011,
-0.0163542069,
0.0090517886,
-0.0257683787,
-0.0084874695,
0.0136375045,
0.0316176303,
0.0252331793,
0.0346977711,
0.0210060589,
0.0201755464,
-0.0350733399,
0.0067443396,
-0.0001519643,
-0.0278426744,
0.0239947233,
-0.0137549825,
-0.0605131648,
0.0353014581,
0.0371056311,
0.0004842866,
0.0584549643,
-0.0405905358,
-0.0213306658,
0.0215789564,
-0.0226935856,
0.0284085926,
-0.0366934836,
0.0333563946,
0.0117157912,
0.0353229977,
0.0037561848,
0.0294707734,
-0.006327793,
-0.0089945653,
0.011248461,
-0.0471221991,
0.0115663819,
-0.0255309436,
-0.022539828,
-0.0107092885,
0.0088009303,
0.0167014301,
0.0140492655,
0.0258729849,
-0.0707624555,
-0.0651677772,
-0.1181469411,
-0.0034698772,
-0.0056362464,
0.003523493,
-0.0012360964,
0.0018302893,
-0.0123740183,
-0.0183126461,
-0.0309588164,
0.0279482212,
0.0304908846,
-0.0112227472,
0.0300791152,
-0.0113477698,
-0.0057361294,
-0.0716736987,
0.0189915486,
0.0117056528,
0.0079851979,
-0.0276579764,
-0.0150407646,
-0.0231474973,
0.0398541763,
-0.0462299138,
0.0371062383,
-0.0262524504,
-0.0321817957,
-0.0051300041,
-0.0029791857,
0.0181411263,
0.0634922758,
0.0054628882,
0.0916559324,
-0.036926616,
-0.0217291806,
-0.0579269454,
0.0582045875,
-0.0478753969,
0.0340818428,
-0.0317830965,
-0.022750495,
0.0120795332,
0.0450446755,
-0.017468866,
0.0280055497,
-0.0831151977,
0.0242411699,
0.0349282622,
-0.033508122,
0.0046248678,
-0.0062139425,
0.0019360197,
-0.0201141015,
-0.0289033055,
-0.0554703549,
0.0547615513,
0.0328651592,
-0.0197673291,
-0.0724933967,
-0.0149929831,
-0.0357411392,
0.075337708,
-0.0462772995,
-0.0050232103,
0.051408153,
-0.0087990798,
-0.0302083679,
-0.0231802799,
-0.03468512,
-0.0380316824,
-0.0089678466,
-0.0040467042,
-0.0127542373,
0.0191182774,
-0.0603511557,
-0.0276866108,
-0.0179981086,
-0.0196890049,
0.0062967758,
0.0036288758,
-0.0064361682,
-0.037270721,
-0.0215737112,
0.0007370457,
-0.0470052436,
0.0017981153,
-0.0222240705,
-0.0007347905,
0.0194181297,
0.0718765035,
0.0132929906,
-0.0063862768,
-0.0409833193,
0.0580044985,
0.0496676713,
0.0409750789,
-0.038201794,
0.0092416015,
0.0157364048,
0.0325378142,
0.0221608412,
-0.0221887194,
-0.0307919607,
0.0643177405,
-0.0100999884,
0.0206737202,
0.1446862221,
0.0208016001,
-0.0396111608,
-0.0072501064,
-0.0154883992,
0.0275218729,
-0.0013540346,
0.0219652876,
-0.029498117,
-0.0500216596,
-0.0157507323,
0.0104127424,
0.0022901674,
-0.0345684215,
-0.0109405937,
-0.0586828217,
0.02782044,
-0.0189783089,
-0.0001607734,
-0.0329779983,
-0.0111873057,
0.0294607077,
-0.0440221913,
-0.0041090813,
-0.0503752455,
0.0300327539,
-0.0290798955,
0.0405990779,
-0.0127357785,
-0.033137273,
0.0432855263,
-0.0190553069,
0.0537822843,
0.0300458539,
0.1121724769,
0.031658031,
0.0174545646,
0.0047498103,
0.0417348482,
-0.0295266304,
-0.0041660098,
0.0719196051,
-0.0385523848,
-0.0093844673,
-0.0235621538,
0.0278271008,
-0.0305685606,
0.0037635867,
-0.0137830013,
0.0396969914,
-0.0512969755,
-0.0033313138,
-0.0061995559,
0.0157655496,
0.0491095558,
0.0620737448,
-0.0177089144,
-0.0614956766,
-0.038103085,
-0.0054953559,
0.0032791789,
-0.0183393955,
-0.0084926756,
-0.0414526276,
-0.0166610312,
-0.0281906724,
-0.039458815,
-0.0967795998,
0.016307326,
0.0153014027,
-0.0357674919,
-0.0474569425,
-0.0116940783,
0.0099355159,
-0.0061505632,
0.0295771137,
0.0072544157,
0.0061426475,
-0.0293782167,
-0.0010164221,
0.042860996,
-0.0436138213,
0.0153040169,
0.0040818658,
-0.0879120007,
-0.0465053469,
-0.0299338475,
0.0675749481,
0.015228007,
0.014777597,
0.018382391,
-0.0256121848,
-0.0075657107,
0.0196653642,
-0.0526429415,
-0.0158081148,
0.0817970857,
0.0476887189,
-0.0170314834,
0.0318938904,
-0.0332670175,
0.0366475396,
0.0016438176,
0.0100371707,
-0.0254161339,
-0.0599532947,
0.0027503017,
-0.0265793838,
0.0546734184,
0.0347610712,
-0.0331337005,
-0.0300181396,
0.0003467732,
-0.0146694081,
-0.0063776853,
-0.0773107633,
-0.0233208705,
-0.0181400031,
0.0051210481,
-0.0285829008,
-0.0070292605,
-0.0246750116,
0.0022308945,
-0.0384181589,
-0.0154032921,
-0.0075050704,
-0.0220261291,
0.0051547009,
-0.0018199692,
-0.0123127578,
-0.0039746729,
0.0477638543,
-0.0105636613,
0.0016839084,
0.0689232126,
0.009244442,
0.0027507779,
0.0262267124,
0.0608853027,
-0.0238749739,
0.0007865223,
-0.0252312552,
-0.0043878532,
-0.0039453302,
-0.0077396971,
0.0539752319,
-0.0674140155,
0.0252328403,
-0.0320364423,
0.0493306927,
-0.022580009,
-0.0399603248,
0.0059931399,
0.0200621001,
-0.0350919627,
-0.0034862906,
0.047194954,
-0.0605553575,
0.0531552397,
-0.0148043483,
-0.0336286463,
-0.0451588668,
-0.0230197869,
0.0732972845,
-0.0040535987,
0.0042214775,
0.0407160968,
-0.0486201644,
-0.0443673953,
0.0177494809,
-0.0334034041,
-0.0169109888,
-0.0159670468,
0.0484501459,
0.0353132114,
-0.0391055197,
0.0301760212,
-0.038918566,
-0.0497378148,
-0.0498776846,
-0.0264622346,
-0.0128084738,
-5.738133062e-33,
0.0190849248,
0.0119464258,
-0.0004524161,
0.0294403676,
-0.0339141861,
0.0291928537,
-0.0203128606,
0.0223238841,
-0.0175280198,
0.0199896656,
-0.0022535424,
0.0387665369,
-0.0007056668,
0.0173234697,
-0.0261696987,
-0.0079382639,
0.0407435969,
-0.0033766087,
0.0141106071,
0.044688005,
0.0385367274,
0.0038188086,
0.0427159779,
-0.0724556372,
0.0500168838,
0.0111365467,
-0.0336753167,
0.0227047857,
0.0933588669,
0.0322135724,
-0.012149225,
0.0656295717,
0.0144726448,
-0.020592574,
0.0053591491,
0.0189402569,
-0.0246655121,
-0.0067891204,
-0.0433651097,
-0.0172323454,
-0.0396734849,
-0.0180707108,
-0.0206291899,
0.0339043885,
-0.0122315716,
-0.0284887888,
0.0136778876,
0.0098687112,
0.0051360172,
-0.0197000466,
-0.0436411761,
0.0156220039,
-0.0439500287,
-0.0975487679,
0.0108772218,
0.0998043641,
0.0242537744,
-0.0478923656,
-0.0016851488,
0.0175755639,
-0.051669348,
-0.0101191374,
0.0058715409,
-0.0065724989,
-0.0030479389,
0.07996241,
0.0440997705,
0.0697194636,
-0.0137178646,
0.0247657001,
0.0022535243,
0.0658547804,
0.0100943195,
-0.0028973746,
-0.0316192098,
0.00587495,
-0.0298562534,
0.068992056,
0.0718564615,
0.0501967482,
0.0446563996,
0.0184935033,
-0.0470847376,
-0.0098923752,
0.0352077372,
0.0388631336,
-0.0064329496,
-0.031679105,
0.0294634569,
0.0157174245,
0.0176434536,
-0.0308291763,
-0.0000111339,
-0.0295978338,
0.0306787491,
0.0573794134,
-0.0600287579,
0.0143167712,
0.004447348,
-0.0197497495,
-0.0349087492,
-0.0298728477,
0.0494214557,
0.0219692737,
0.0322023891,
-0.0020815071,
-0.0038800128,
0.0424653888,
-0.0317085162,
-0.0124316653,
-0.0271249488,
0.0699035376,
-0.0291007329,
0.069971174,
-0.010354165,
0.0162907206,
-0.0258347765,
0.0649538487,
-0.0159424711,
0.0196250826,
-0.033729922,
-0.0254126154,
0.0236037467,
0.0031991992,
-0.0436197743,
-0.0087760352,
-0.013248181,
-0.0508162156,
-0.0301323961,
-0.0103167165,
-0.0157059319,
-0.0121780802,
2.759e-7,
-0.0404386297,
0.027308248,
0.0329737514,
0.0057549397,
-0.0014911138,
0.0742140189,
-0.0058208555,
0.0490974262,
0.0203016773,
-0.027715791,
0.0721623227,
0.0121665224,
0.0893267319,
-0.0087499814,
-0.1211811602,
-0.0486318097,
0.0072725634,
-0.0089350175,
-0.0004975921,
0.0039617349,
0.0787919909,
0.0754877776,
0.0461764187,
-0.0016561712,
0.0141817098,
0.0453480184,
0.0502194911,
-0.0395697057,
-0.0265542343,
0.0409627296,
0.0190160163,
-0.0246117115,
-0.0180824231,
-0.0005192746,
-0.0104742125,
-0.0005679184,
0.0406397805,
0.0641742423,
0.0106557552,
-0.081441462,
0.0034883292,
0.0388161354,
0.0038762563,
-0.0024100167,
0.0298714228,
-0.0622296818,
-0.0380560309,
-0.0251223743,
-0.0032760373,
0.006738273,
0.0396525897,
-0.0094692688,
-0.0582814664,
0.0119551187,
0.0117649212,
-0.0291578788,
-0.0032085304,
-0.0942880139,
0.0180638246,
0.0214009229,
-0.0641846508,
-0.0478895009,
-0.0072190147,
0.021008363,
0.0236274265,
-0.0225962326,
0.010566039,
1.999341633e-34,
0.0132588428,
-0.0161080677,
-0.0009995968,
0.0623898134,
0.0138472775,
-0.0017764855,
-0.0516048931,
-0.0241288617,
0.0825623646,
-0.0486745797,
0.0108554307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12643v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12643v1 | Probabilistic Method of Measuring Linguistic Productivity | 2023-08-24T08:36:28 | 2023-08-24T08:36:28 | Sergei Monakhov | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper I propose a new way of measuring linguistic productivity that
objectively assesses the ability of an affix to be used to coin new complex
words and, unlike other popular measures, is not directly dependent upon token
frequency. Specifically, I suggest that linguistic productivity may be viewed
as the probability of an affix to combine with a random base. The advantages of
this approach include the following. First, token frequency does not dominate
the productivity measure but naturally influences the sampling of bases.
Second, we are not just counting attested word types with an affix but rather
simulating the construction of these types and then checking whether they are
attested in the corpus. Third, a corpus-based approach and randomised design
assure that true neologisms and words coined long ago have equal chances to be
selected. The proposed algorithm is evaluated both on English and Russian data.
The obtained results provide some valuable insights into the relation of
linguistic productivity to the number of types and tokens. It looks like
burgeoning linguistic productivity manifests itself in an increasing number of
types. However, this process unfolds in two stages: first comes the increase in
high-frequency items, and only then follows the increase in low-frequency
items. | [
0.0439854637,
0.042429924,
-0.0278984718,
0.0143402219,
-0.080203481,
-0.0253284983,
-0.0047751726,
0.0275314506,
-0.0720748827,
-0.0286985952,
0.0356293842,
-0.0702034831,
0.0436249487,
0.0220874939,
0.0709609538,
-0.0105140805,
0.045003999,
-0.0082195727,
0.0073791104,
0.0015676552,
0.0128227239,
-0.0037542747,
0.0000919308,
0.0313240066,
-0.0371996686,
0.0437592193,
0.0311075244,
-0.0670390129,
-0.0219626781,
-0.0017993215,
-0.043603681,
0.0299850125,
-0.0726611242,
0.0622774251,
0.0000015651,
-0.0969778746,
-0.0128240129,
-0.0035543491,
0.0186704602,
0.0036772706,
0.1015603989,
0.0393788032,
-0.0562535636,
0.011693581,
-0.0185549818,
-0.0071662799,
0.0480055213,
-0.0278485436,
-0.0283553079,
0.0209822524,
-0.0025028328,
-0.0277165864,
0.0246854406,
-0.0155278435,
-0.0099823885,
0.0271233432,
0.0178015903,
-0.0542054847,
-0.0243373103,
-0.0041719656,
-0.0172495004,
0.0161736812,
-0.0350279808,
-0.0310110301,
0.0035108281,
0.0048620501,
-0.0369391888,
-0.0284617674,
0.0384040065,
-0.0076576509,
0.0050316812,
-0.0020226829,
0.0465527922,
0.0121644791,
0.0420087092,
0.0220070854,
-0.0367176868,
-0.0029835177,
-0.0171076804,
-0.0075160391,
0.0898943692,
-0.0067854426,
-0.0085144062,
0.0274538398,
-0.0074236691,
0.0422498025,
0.0480862781,
-0.0119598145,
0.0177939255,
-0.0117339902,
0.0045156679,
-0.0423051938,
-0.0063975421,
-0.0180196483,
-0.0279353373,
0.0565230586,
0.0032624691,
-0.0286917686,
0.0317182541,
-0.046456974,
-0.0108256442,
-0.0190170836,
-0.0039237919,
0.0452515483,
-0.0575995781,
-0.0135309966,
0.0320104882,
-0.0724933669,
-0.0279046856,
-0.0015824424,
-0.0516439863,
-0.0114130294,
-0.0357384533,
-0.0132148005,
0.0455541611,
-0.0063167005,
-0.0586520806,
0.0091204764,
0.0150759136,
-0.0259363167,
-0.0115990266,
-0.021643674,
-0.015808247,
-0.0006507068,
-0.0366983563,
-0.0255899616,
-0.0536968373,
0.0093144802,
-0.0317722596,
-0.0110219372,
0.0539996363,
0.033587832,
0.0277716033,
-0.0377329253,
-0.0033623106,
-0.0001723872,
0.0215270277,
-0.0292400327,
-0.0159004349,
-0.0276814494,
-0.0701624677,
-0.014401448,
-0.0192135144,
-0.0928296149,
-0.0264225472,
-0.0339280926,
-0.0133543769,
-0.0212420765,
0.0091783004,
-0.0053076036,
-0.0659074336,
-0.0038022604,
-0.0481027253,
0.0172640961,
-0.0287672691,
-0.056874793,
0.0025567177,
0.0319148786,
0.0670858547,
-0.0180357508,
0.0653298125,
-0.0384058841,
0.0038749846,
0.030872032,
-0.005133566,
0.0288502462,
-0.0265496988,
-0.0201667659,
0.0036074228,
0.0014256767,
0.0336899981,
0.0635371655,
-0.0042759497,
0.0293054059,
0.0309056584,
0.0590391085,
0.0268995725,
0.0222773459,
0.0161335915,
-0.0382067561,
0.0153067866,
0.0054469947,
0.0307337418,
-0.0345947184,
-0.0011742598,
0.0071017775,
0.0499985814,
-0.0004863029,
0.0095067276,
-0.0355480574,
0.0012330981,
0.0172391161,
0.0483502448,
-0.073255226,
0.0638569072,
0.0071944115,
-0.0002614874,
-0.0130148809,
-0.0118599907,
-0.0163279325,
0.0181049537,
-0.0596674643,
0.0181380883,
0.0220664181,
0.0288425069,
0.005016326,
0.0451068096,
0.0309881549,
-0.02342798,
0.0873591304,
-0.0096651297,
0.0119515369,
-0.0066573829,
0.0048491443,
0.0373668112,
0.0111170569,
0.0138701191,
0.0065299417,
0.0007515866,
0.0445251167,
-0.0076388591,
-0.0501665212,
-0.0264999401,
0.0066170823,
0.0145360148,
0.0238430817,
0.0105575109,
-0.0079003125,
0.0089356992,
0.0341171362,
-0.0190533008,
0.0659596846,
0.0046476438,
-0.0266716275,
-0.0481392965,
0.0415060744,
0.0608432628,
0.0515715703,
0.0412615389,
-0.00816816,
0.0323639661,
-0.0907688439,
0.0498445556,
-0.0252737664,
0.080382742,
-0.0897201598,
0.1238350272,
-0.031041095,
0.0578970313,
-0.0234483182,
0.0214136764,
-0.0255116336,
0.0677354261,
0.0061210296,
0.0581527576,
-0.0306448266,
-0.0557643734,
0.0399448723,
-0.0005218841,
-0.0139012681,
-0.0336977914,
-0.0014248625,
-0.0031310732,
0.07951013,
-0.0286309253,
-0.0554872602,
-0.0674924925,
-0.0487323292,
-0.021689415,
0.008520985,
0.0451598875,
-0.0273819473,
-0.0040598856,
-0.0079109287,
0.0481347367,
0.005400551,
0.0088638868,
0.0139121721,
0.0727835223,
0.042311132,
-0.0179600362,
-0.0470646173,
-0.0169016961,
-0.0006730375,
0.0138352662,
-0.0081857014,
0.0398629196,
0.0105236592,
-0.0341081321,
-0.0086111175,
-0.0400698185,
-0.0466602035,
-0.0075537348,
-0.0473651737,
0.0132515999,
-0.0012529609,
0.0366638489,
-0.0349212177,
0.0146444496,
-0.0307177883,
0.0129199717,
-0.0250239447,
-0.0104563255,
-0.0627783611,
-0.0391214453,
-0.0067833075,
-0.0109802866,
-0.0133639304,
0.0025483801,
0.0133068319,
0.0299656093,
-0.0131604513,
-0.0116619943,
0.0423062555,
-0.0546121597,
-0.0263986737,
0.0092095081,
-0.0050579989,
-0.0708230883,
0.0632803738,
0.0092779053,
-0.0362324901,
-0.0040415428,
-0.0011041961,
0.023704255,
-0.0288114846,
-0.0235456713,
0.0010123418,
0.0243499577,
0.0203441344,
0.0010373238,
0.0576759204,
-0.0521669872,
-0.0503982753,
-0.0085688801,
0.0404658727,
-0.0300291572,
0.0389391482,
-0.032209415,
0.0143614179,
0.0307266936,
-0.002254715,
0.0016367123,
-0.0875043944,
0.0228591152,
0.0063763512,
0.0641385168,
-0.0238355845,
0.0187566876,
0.004908903,
0.0167667512,
0.0106439674,
0.0029810271,
0.0080604404,
0.0091431793,
0.0211876296,
0.0348273441,
0.0364939868,
0.0047286665,
0.019296091,
-0.0586721748,
0.0074377581,
-0.0136898821,
0.0536236428,
-0.0160306301,
-0.0294718016,
0.0030431128,
-0.0296604447,
-0.0479286835,
0.0209351368,
-0.0293221939,
-0.0010884349,
0.0193677992,
0.0674246177,
0.0439155139,
0.0332742967,
0.0470752791,
0.0109481681,
0.0004889102,
0.0130766388,
0.0185563341,
-0.0578602888,
0.0355879813,
-0.0150349699,
-0.0177836977,
-0.0559127592,
-0.0273599308,
-0.0199665651,
-0.1144961566,
0.0225257371,
-0.0141472276,
-0.0634053499,
0.0501519926,
-0.0247068722,
0.0105749294,
0.0052649095,
-0.0647326559,
0.0093125645,
-0.0133151542,
0.0262544435,
0.0204050969,
-0.0754918456,
-0.0460452214,
-0.0537594557,
-0.0410974361,
0.0477748029,
0.0124801779,
0.0619102083,
-0.0988567024,
-0.0421242081,
-0.000903494,
0.0219209064,
-0.0461456589,
0.0246289279,
0.0365471542,
0.0602737181,
-0.0166864507,
-0.0175429955,
-0.0210525375,
-0.0128466347,
-0.0181951467,
0.0115876785,
0.0434144139,
0.0238494612,
-0.0080280006,
-0.0134940445,
-0.0035741387,
0.0098731946,
0.04024731,
0.0250514615,
-0.0251835305,
0.0659926087,
-0.0115065137,
0.0010568036,
-0.0234588534,
-0.0169680454,
-0.0535267964,
-0.0375013873,
-0.0518537574,
-0.1148504838,
-0.0299142078,
-0.0077345669,
0.0868423283,
0.0178730842,
0.0533075482,
-0.0388914235,
-0.0142260808,
-0.0108295446,
0.0070730271,
0.0286219865,
0.0243392605,
-0.0911400616,
-0.0243653953,
0.0078884214,
0.0197237283,
-0.0367979147,
-0.0126757631,
-0.0214683283,
-0.0444806367,
0.0311646406,
-0.0133622438,
0.032102596,
-0.0617415048,
0.0022237611,
0.0058997446,
0.0314925909,
0.0399584025,
0.0007210035,
0.0308321696,
0.0129039288,
-0.0288143028,
0.0136139542,
0.005534918,
-0.0207656715,
-0.0330041051,
-0.015454269,
0.0299676936,
-0.0187873691,
-0.0309104137,
0.0068342453,
0.019233482,
0.0622682534,
-0.0959553272,
0.0463840105,
-0.0149347335,
-0.0462331325,
0.0100340219,
-0.0240066051,
0.002300174,
-0.0144896731,
0.0367777161,
0.0098397499,
-0.0288127717,
0.0470693819,
-0.04000514,
0.0353246816,
0.0361740105,
-0.0427095257,
-0.0146566024,
0.0292633008,
-0.0112071382,
0.0215243045,
0.0303592496,
0.0159224235,
-0.0218826048,
0.0429457761,
-0.0368882492,
-0.0200239606,
-0.0236578379,
-0.0267180894,
0.0021625815,
0.0348053277,
-0.0155528355,
-0.0053405049,
0.022713339,
0.0302292909,
0.0231506899,
-0.0254680775,
0.0646064281,
-0.0361000784,
-0.001185207,
-0.0266815796,
0.0208460782,
-0.0226104651,
-0.0252607912,
-0.009251982,
-0.0011051522,
-0.0437341109,
-0.0333058611,
0.0400349982,
-0.0406012051,
-0.0445823446,
-0.0111680403,
-0.0053938432,
0.0167126469,
-0.0215960424,
-0.0322216488,
0.0098669035,
0.0009101516,
0.0532104261,
-0.1088648513,
-0.0312540606,
0.0040591927,
0.0130823385,
0.0082883267,
0.0132371495,
0.0306713786,
0.0427517854,
-0.0054565431,
0.0503124818,
-0.075794816,
0.0137048392,
0.0131210657,
0.0088610696,
0.0330786929,
-5.466604887e-33,
-0.0093888361,
-0.0431635231,
-0.0014370658,
0.0260687396,
-0.0162755158,
0.0007735407,
0.0032826646,
0.0382459685,
0.0002310874,
0.0009057107,
-0.0060253139,
-0.0202958621,
0.0239562616,
-0.0216457527,
0.0502160601,
0.0595677048,
-0.041442398,
0.002034788,
-0.0176019426,
-0.0583460219,
0.0740813166,
-0.0320304036,
0.0779880136,
-0.0035579484,
0.0804683566,
0.0567058548,
-0.0260364618,
0.0001768537,
0.066998221,
0.033946272,
0.0077378699,
0.0464836694,
0.0153012723,
-0.0660432428,
-0.0026597581,
0.004572127,
-0.0057587889,
-0.0625047609,
0.0673332214,
-0.0033083756,
0.0276802704,
-0.0272673853,
0.0018398762,
0.0135537218,
-0.0495202243,
0.0389004238,
0.0271311551,
-0.0100869387,
-0.0478709154,
0.029732585,
-0.0787060782,
0.0421036743,
0.0308170002,
0.0378742777,
-0.0250222571,
-0.0471491702,
-0.0000903621,
-0.0582966916,
-0.0433794633,
0.0485394634,
-0.0292298608,
0.0763169378,
-0.0096274754,
0.0029175067,
-0.0115310755,
0.0281309281,
0.0208369754,
0.0196220689,
0.0713829696,
0.0302798282,
0.0576827265,
-0.0038033733,
0.0229476038,
0.0959021896,
0.0814929828,
-0.0067082131,
0.0035129169,
-0.0059171873,
0.0832303017,
0.0068004476,
-0.0039758938,
-0.0279616844,
-0.0408449247,
-0.0402971432,
-0.0145621961,
0.0257089511,
-0.0105536282,
-0.01165637,
0.0004416975,
-0.0096671274,
0.0234659985,
-0.0023324618,
0.0146054225,
-0.0027507879,
-0.0439339839,
-0.0050088917,
-0.0133302482,
0.025870895,
-0.0205597077,
0.0288427044,
-0.0131400023,
-0.0256971736,
-0.0191223752,
0.0457695238,
0.0255278349,
0.0213827677,
-0.0083603561,
0.041728247,
-0.0829334781,
0.0051743705,
-0.0114253005,
-0.0228133984,
0.0094121471,
-0.0599822365,
0.0082905767,
0.0241724346,
0.0163274128,
-0.0103062037,
0.0640450716,
0.0000492934,
-0.0161884557,
-0.011230249,
0.037039414,
0.0094042569,
-0.0275219232,
0.0031579316,
-0.027297413,
0.0495702848,
0.0581985563,
-0.0086056534,
-0.0035447925,
-0.0090956837,
2.583e-7,
0.0558137186,
0.0247586891,
-0.0407438576,
-0.0031059703,
0.0332411528,
-0.0003816347,
-0.0399257913,
0.0011623953,
-0.0127202291,
0.0146817602,
-0.0208392926,
-0.0424239971,
0.0377673209,
0.0547510199,
-0.07724832,
-0.013208759,
-0.0571646392,
-0.0126603916,
-0.0449046195,
0.0256987046,
0.0210229475,
0.0696895942,
0.0570289083,
-0.0241914839,
-0.0753102526,
-0.1056200787,
0.0295208283,
0.0123972036,
-0.0501731485,
0.0122674806,
0.0405871421,
0.0342607945,
0.0368280672,
0.009290929,
-0.0224491749,
0.0516437851,
0.0456182621,
-0.0110387253,
-0.0067889774,
0.0403774045,
0.0217764303,
-0.0723135471,
0.0015313874,
0.0004020156,
0.0220666211,
0.0174522083,
-0.0116962381,
-0.0213904008,
-0.0404071845,
0.0533518568,
0.0087217279,
-0.0261153188,
-0.0536682233,
-0.0010173131,
0.0432779044,
0.0108285211,
-0.0136242751,
-0.0339081362,
-0.0098995371,
0.0194817986,
-0.0207373835,
-0.0779165253,
0.0251331925,
0.0274104923,
-0.0038157881,
-0.0108786756,
-0.0007984934,
2.050437296e-34,
0.0581975281,
0.0188639909,
0.0164937209,
0.0107434001,
0.0414323658,
0.0045209355,
0.0241216421,
0.0433543809,
0.0066251503,
-0.0487010479,
-0.0190318245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12635v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12635v1 | Advancing Hungarian Text Processing with HuSpaCy: Efficient and Accurate NLP Pipelines | 2023-08-24T08:19:51 | 2023-08-24T08:19:51 | György Orosz, Gergő Szabó, Péter Berkecz, Zsolt Szántó, Richárd Farkas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, stat.ML, 68T50, I.2.7 | This paper presents a set of industrial-grade text processing models for
Hungarian that achieve near state-of-the-art performance while balancing
resource efficiency and accuracy. Models have been implemented in the spaCy
framework, extending the HuSpaCy toolkit with several improvements to its
architecture. Compared to existing NLP tools for Hungarian, all of our
pipelines feature all basic text processing steps including tokenization,
sentence-boundary detection, part-of-speech tagging, morphological feature
tagging, lemmatization, dependency parsing and named entity recognition with
high accuracy and throughput. We thoroughly evaluated the proposed
enhancements, compared the pipelines with state-of-the-art tools and
demonstrated the competitive performance of the new models in all text
preprocessing steps. All experiments are reproducible and the pipelines are
freely available under a permissive license. | [
0.075542815,
0.0010360995,
0.0087870583,
0.0133763207,
-0.0459808595,
0.0107052159,
-0.0096604694,
-0.0129015846,
0.0335296169,
-0.0367629565,
0.0034897027,
0.0244308375,
-0.0143096577,
-0.0014321904,
-0.0071163238,
-0.0581091382,
0.0670018271,
-0.0187332872,
0.0078061782,
0.0206167214,
0.0315770134,
0.0250173677,
-0.0132474713,
0.0143831028,
-0.0203483384,
0.0068978602,
-0.0052989488,
-0.0010860577,
0.0104060369,
-0.0238533225,
0.0178237893,
0.0196092743,
-0.0572679602,
0.0336183235,
0.0000017979,
-0.0397931561,
-0.0202358998,
-0.005951561,
0.0283743162,
-0.0338464864,
0.0779582858,
-0.0402544886,
-0.0482089482,
0.0334724709,
-0.0025144804,
-0.0017242337,
0.0319331512,
0.0639396906,
0.0443856642,
0.0536755621,
-0.0197377224,
-0.068242535,
0.0692396536,
0.0339835286,
-0.0372620709,
0.0061643599,
0.0191121772,
-0.0656409264,
0.0191429332,
0.006639312,
0.0328223258,
0.0253573898,
-0.0106728328,
-0.0239383373,
0.0366093591,
-0.0130512789,
-0.1010578424,
-0.0617229417,
-0.014147643,
0.0009327092,
-0.0217965655,
-0.0317956135,
0.0365493149,
0.0187008176,
-0.0138258766,
-0.0189529136,
-0.025255112,
0.0122112408,
-0.0234141387,
0.0236508492,
0.0956337824,
0.0306724086,
-0.0147395041,
0.015571367,
0.0127604576,
0.0762693658,
0.0148424404,
-0.0019069245,
0.0356569961,
0.0239118505,
0.0431863442,
-0.0681995824,
0.0808006674,
0.0324396379,
0.0195127409,
-0.0218644347,
-0.0148476148,
-0.0005591168,
0.050155133,
-0.06654457,
-0.0682513565,
0.0322229974,
0.0048861746,
0.0272558257,
-0.0576604493,
-0.0084887538,
0.0045543397,
-0.0188077707,
-0.0137740886,
-0.0222075246,
-0.0459085703,
-0.0115926545,
-0.0876681954,
0.0300196223,
-0.0292276498,
-0.0164589398,
-0.040676441,
0.0097940993,
0.0311059374,
0.0280344952,
0.0391956903,
-0.0240781046,
0.0009599195,
0.0337729938,
-0.0249893721,
0.0536303148,
-0.0512854606,
-0.0029425183,
-0.0318672322,
-0.05436166,
0.0258389972,
0.0090588927,
0.0136099923,
-0.0217710081,
0.0459963642,
0.0414304659,
0.0136985099,
-0.035870634,
-0.044517342,
-0.0105674174,
0.0195728131,
-0.070401296,
-0.0121639343,
-0.0724738315,
0.0072023659,
0.0295385364,
0.0105918599,
-0.0013055057,
0.0059174695,
0.0648191124,
-0.0707350299,
0.0547011346,
-0.0487230122,
-0.0175619889,
0.0085790446,
-0.0151495719,
0.0305774584,
0.0499339737,
-0.0046293158,
0.084644407,
0.0570707805,
0.0113383932,
0.016200982,
0.0417590775,
-0.0500080995,
-0.0422298424,
-0.020170467,
0.0222431105,
-0.064678967,
-0.0221035089,
0.0605912358,
0.0699708834,
0.025546819,
0.0284494795,
0.0344360806,
0.0903266668,
0.022532424,
0.0068342048,
0.0067324233,
0.0369845219,
0.040500246,
0.0015196743,
0.0016366644,
-0.04252363,
0.008449127,
0.0293382872,
-0.0342486762,
0.0378094427,
0.013777582,
0.0003642128,
-0.0177784096,
-0.030817287,
0.0082932552,
-0.0549259968,
0.0659437031,
0.0043113306,
-0.0447760336,
0.029430544,
0.0435101427,
-0.0269586742,
0.0056005036,
0.0186046101,
0.0042950376,
0.08670149,
0.056988474,
-0.0114463391,
0.0245656446,
-0.0168880243,
0.0001855876,
0.0423431434,
-0.0055276761,
-0.0392755419,
-0.0170831792,
-0.0305212904,
0.0314155892,
0.0270388499,
0.0213945098,
-0.0172540024,
-0.0080477679,
0.0031450568,
0.0072590564,
0.0528653376,
0.0053753462,
0.0367929451,
0.0063442155,
0.0157990791,
-0.0359310284,
-0.0137260696,
-0.0193037596,
0.0364001729,
-0.0079474645,
0.0146586522,
0.0447804593,
-0.0090061976,
0.0248990078,
0.0017082283,
0.0135264164,
-0.0365304537,
0.0171957165,
-0.0238639731,
-0.016975157,
0.0068600825,
0.0198124386,
-0.0214795563,
0.0038297717,
-0.0100075593,
0.0312484037,
-0.0464881137,
0.0616565049,
0.0049978234,
0.0188214369,
-0.0617332309,
0.0287610646,
0.0051908232,
0.0092308987,
-0.0166186336,
0.0075929677,
0.0011291642,
-0.0239190832,
-0.0481509753,
0.0536877997,
-0.0168324467,
-0.046306964,
-0.0126622422,
-0.0164559148,
-0.022640869,
0.0244581699,
-0.1015665308,
0.0250955876,
-0.0072352462,
0.042520836,
0.0155240828,
0.0154468743,
-0.0139637319,
-0.0377968997,
-0.0062482851,
-0.0158320908,
0.0467507876,
0.0033085726,
0.0287752952,
-0.0071118749,
-0.0293263774,
-0.0159319267,
0.0242966376,
-0.0112770991,
-0.0146553721,
0.0148973046,
-0.0187386274,
-0.0548105948,
0.0316981114,
0.0064680623,
0.0570311807,
0.0357938558,
-0.0159476884,
-0.0220943708,
0.0015444707,
0.0527695641,
0.0121182045,
-0.0335418172,
0.0367220156,
-0.0012196825,
-0.0258248225,
0.0147493156,
-0.0122560877,
-0.0328885354,
0.0732771382,
-0.0548049882,
-0.0228749197,
0.0185933802,
0.0567349195,
-0.0358345397,
0.0130453864,
0.0119323945,
-0.0569507964,
-0.0612623952,
0.0309704356,
-0.0004543161,
-0.0382358357,
-0.0242267177,
0.0375971049,
0.0271106623,
-0.0070419437,
0.0093445228,
-0.0722682029,
-0.0215817094,
-0.0511441641,
-0.0288323313,
-0.0326158032,
0.0379839987,
0.0267614536,
0.015167119,
-0.0351793729,
-0.0629719198,
0.0068821781,
0.0332518965,
-0.0001598622,
-0.0089070862,
-0.0060410332,
-0.034039326,
-0.0012899666,
-0.0405667424,
-0.0041430658,
-0.0245610271,
-0.0065560802,
-0.0340181924,
0.0084695723,
0.0250417106,
0.0097148176,
0.0054155118,
0.0341828726,
-0.0326501727,
0.0690099224,
-0.0038006725,
0.0142308697,
-0.0253324714,
0.0677070469,
-0.019752128,
-0.0802647397,
0.0219376124,
0.016514143,
0.0104917483,
0.0707360208,
0.043836534,
-0.053026896,
-0.001217827,
-0.0290965922,
0.0451829545,
-0.0939944088,
-0.0267978851,
-0.0695114881,
0.0192572027,
-0.0549982376,
-0.0237409584,
0.09715271,
0.0343949534,
-0.0228498038,
-0.0045240447,
0.008776241,
0.0058394466,
0.0187360179,
0.0393201932,
-0.0388636701,
-0.0219750572,
0.0607549213,
0.0152935255,
-0.0490240678,
-0.0329607055,
0.0485383831,
-0.0994581804,
0.000024931,
-0.0174499862,
-0.0141034508,
-0.0314787328,
-0.0599368885,
-0.0168356393,
-0.0349789932,
-0.0336428806,
0.0171546638,
-0.0498100035,
0.0207012482,
0.0270944703,
-0.0475259088,
-0.0117814755,
-0.0280547515,
-0.0120602101,
0.0412546471,
0.0482231118,
0.0074575455,
-0.0352644883,
0.0027330944,
0.0407501273,
-0.0255149826,
-0.0200276077,
-0.0394434594,
0.0103092184,
0.0141344666,
-0.0238042586,
-0.0533930771,
-0.0190515164,
-0.0148536777,
-0.0195785426,
-0.0037474225,
0.0264622495,
0.0009173304,
0.0332011618,
0.0167592596,
0.0163831264,
0.0158436745,
0.0530810356,
-0.0050514163,
-0.0115117831,
-0.0608182102,
-0.0434450842,
-0.0649827644,
-0.0114049176,
-0.018593641,
0.0401919857,
-0.0410259701,
-0.0779713094,
-0.0603195503,
-0.0759413913,
0.0763058513,
0.0255987961,
-0.0130557232,
0.0138449641,
0.0037601353,
0.034059871,
-0.0238777138,
0.016093323,
0.0184195172,
0.0145460935,
-0.0904496685,
0.0281414054,
0.0215909295,
0.013740954,
-0.0371319205,
0.0339893475,
-0.053650517,
-0.0422672406,
0.0490882359,
0.0073479176,
0.0210285801,
-0.0143353213,
-0.0396559536,
-0.0340418033,
-0.0123713203,
0.0004410333,
-0.0963602737,
-0.0315110087,
-0.0022806325,
-0.0135971522,
0.002847835,
0.0208301619,
0.0499088727,
0.0595065281,
-0.0196792204,
0.0213983301,
0.0027926716,
0.0067006163,
-0.0034380162,
0.0245072749,
0.0448019542,
-0.0168352555,
0.0238709264,
-0.0178050548,
0.0267262906,
-0.0290945489,
0.0011541824,
-0.0008481908,
0.0166419894,
0.0082004629,
0.010147335,
-0.0231000278,
0.0028749814,
-0.026347274,
0.0036257051,
-0.0228524841,
0.0093818903,
-0.0394054763,
0.0768134221,
0.009711328,
-0.0208192859,
0.0000677143,
0.0430741645,
-0.0012301654,
0.0209041014,
-0.0396080539,
-0.0186738353,
-0.0172201544,
-0.0449726842,
-0.0186824948,
0.0205974746,
-0.0225432701,
0.0717908442,
-0.0450800471,
0.0513915084,
0.0571072027,
-0.0354607292,
0.0733896568,
-0.0274623688,
-0.0255927667,
0.0116723469,
-0.0114414794,
-0.0183613878,
-0.0210898798,
-0.0033800076,
-0.0123675494,
-0.0316106528,
-0.0692727044,
0.016572265,
0.0307171792,
0.0309294388,
0.0162177216,
-0.0622043237,
-0.0074458951,
-0.0451021083,
0.0077348151,
-0.0015646252,
-0.045162946,
-0.0200307313,
-0.0390530676,
-0.0455923863,
-0.0094914408,
0.0045636841,
0.000427983,
-0.0194416493,
0.0346738659,
0.0060388348,
0.0571121015,
0.0006964764,
-0.0548746251,
0.0278530512,
0.0183888748,
-0.0253120326,
-0.0066257413,
-5.787845453e-33,
-0.0310185812,
-0.017940104,
0.0078263143,
-0.0091615748,
0.0003447066,
-0.0455238484,
-0.0002499587,
-0.0051803091,
0.0135925673,
-0.0012996243,
-0.0237634256,
-0.0078968601,
0.0485010408,
0.0060564755,
0.0285652205,
0.0264882687,
0.0529030077,
0.0072739702,
-0.0028549584,
0.0098333489,
0.0646101832,
0.0543250442,
0.1002737507,
-0.0115325013,
-0.028105529,
-0.0200896263,
-0.0372712389,
0.0223171152,
0.0569859296,
0.0319905356,
-0.0098403059,
0.0042026122,
0.0300044566,
-0.0492596664,
0.0196911562,
0.0075091231,
-0.0891194716,
0.0084261233,
0.0099796737,
0.0729614794,
-0.0111515904,
-0.0171867833,
0.0166117828,
-0.0122287897,
-0.0180140641,
0.0957743302,
0.0109023815,
-0.0459134057,
0.02533211,
0.0288376864,
-0.0851743594,
0.0429824032,
0.0140279438,
0.0389958508,
0.052892033,
0.0460160337,
0.0264494158,
0.0108008124,
-0.0647149459,
-0.0078345565,
0.0025801195,
0.0287829842,
0.034613356,
-0.0227839611,
-0.0186193883,
0.0360907912,
-0.0186791215,
-0.0835706592,
0.0065996172,
0.0604492538,
0.0020011177,
0.0256382246,
0.045198746,
-0.0151217729,
0.0261084177,
-0.0420964137,
-0.0707263201,
0.027893573,
0.0336825512,
0.0524091497,
-0.0408734716,
0.0031924574,
-0.0243103169,
-0.0036687679,
0.0361999534,
-0.0027378229,
-0.0094921375,
-0.0236089192,
0.0340075046,
0.0080952998,
-0.0368749201,
0.094943963,
0.0227485392,
0.006243886,
-0.03323799,
-0.0271237083,
-0.0054634041,
0.0478926003,
-0.0399224274,
0.0361089408,
-0.0579125509,
-0.0462910607,
0.0077967276,
-0.0067725494,
-0.0004260726,
-0.0080079222,
0.0176880807,
-0.0117648309,
-0.0896849632,
0.0387885347,
-0.0063967207,
0.0749458745,
0.0116742281,
0.0942743644,
0.0158770848,
-0.0440781899,
0.0125291003,
0.0308528952,
0.0472398698,
-0.0073927646,
-0.0635266006,
0.0256636627,
0.0348766632,
-0.0007443579,
-0.0235710423,
0.0348073207,
-0.0231166296,
0.0396627486,
0.0106022498,
-0.0219477639,
0.0115262438,
-0.0147557631,
2.555e-7,
0.0370287262,
0.0194760114,
0.0260352734,
-0.0212662704,
0.0094551658,
-0.0268780924,
-0.0159334093,
0.0375273675,
-0.0399739854,
0.0839158148,
-0.0338024981,
-0.027786117,
0.0169554781,
0.03997292,
-0.1213486418,
-0.0283903126,
-0.0456705913,
-0.0345769301,
-0.0744044781,
0.0380270593,
-0.0004051983,
0.0849421695,
-0.0080752103,
-0.0135079548,
-0.0239869151,
-0.0199184082,
0.0077987406,
0.043418929,
-0.0025056868,
0.0421876721,
0.0209523458,
0.0497691557,
-0.0216392316,
-0.0076430845,
-0.0203755517,
0.0271582007,
0.0052074036,
0.0696511567,
-0.036661204,
0.0229360946,
0.0599289425,
-0.0659005269,
0.0069240979,
-0.0595732629,
0.0649658367,
-0.0195389856,
-0.0177404769,
-0.0439390838,
-0.0055973711,
-0.0006884141,
-0.0437266901,
0.0022494551,
-0.0509870984,
0.0282071196,
0.0189536884,
-0.038604714,
-0.0389025249,
-0.0650183856,
-0.0257618614,
-0.043721538,
-0.0145389698,
-0.0219068751,
-0.0301190112,
-0.0112157241,
-0.0126807541,
-0.004323883,
-0.0083671799,
2.628841357e-34,
-0.0095437374,
0.0278570801,
-0.0261296667,
0.0425179116,
0.0068497523,
0.0021381488,
-0.0063135363,
0.0485781692,
-0.033444725,
-0.0371239893,
0.0009816136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12604v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12604v2 | PromptMRG: Diagnosis-Driven Prompts for Medical Report Generation | 2023-08-24T07:10:31 | 2024-01-12T06:50:28 | Haibo Jin, Haoxuan Che, Yi Lin, Hao Chen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Automatic medical report generation (MRG) is of great research value as it
has the potential to relieve radiologists from the heavy burden of report
writing. Despite recent advancements, accurate MRG remains challenging due to
the need for precise clinical understanding and disease identification.
Moreover, the imbalanced distribution of diseases makes the challenge even more
pronounced, as rare diseases are underrepresented in training data, making
their diagnostic performance unreliable. To address these challenges, we
propose diagnosis-driven prompts for medical report generation (PromptMRG), a
novel framework that aims to improve the diagnostic accuracy of MRG with the
guidance of diagnosis-aware prompts. Specifically, PromptMRG is based on
encoder-decoder architecture with an extra disease classification branch. When
generating reports, the diagnostic results from the classification branch are
converted into token prompts to explicitly guide the generation process. To
further improve the diagnostic accuracy, we design cross-modal feature
enhancement, which retrieves similar reports from the database to assist the
diagnosis of a query image by leveraging the knowledge from a pre-trained CLIP.
Moreover, the disease imbalanced issue is addressed by applying an adaptive
logit-adjusted loss to the classification branch based on the individual
learning status of each disease, which overcomes the barrier of text decoder's
inability to manipulate disease distributions. Experiments on two MRG
benchmarks show the effectiveness of the proposed method, where it obtains
state-of-the-art clinical efficacy performance on both datasets. The code is
available at https://github.com/jhb86253817/PromptMRG. | [
0.0270812865,
0.0378984474,
0.013497577,
-0.0252080727,
0.0254342854,
0.0305724572,
-0.008022422,
0.0461204387,
-0.0202117506,
-0.0078538051,
0.0196290296,
-0.036600247,
0.0021797784,
0.0741488934,
-0.0149645219,
-0.0741222799,
0.0177237596,
0.0130052678,
0.0362467207,
0.003327877,
-0.0094915964,
0.0162217449,
-0.002363496,
0.0496201701,
-0.0358249806,
-0.0160184763,
0.0067945994,
0.0257829558,
0.0344248898,
-0.0681287423,
-0.0091665676,
0.0167383067,
-0.0079126386,
-0.0172534529,
0.0000022923,
-0.0369765349,
-0.0235781446,
0.0151695842,
-0.0162326023,
-0.0544573702,
0.0424187854,
-0.0855531842,
0.0078808162,
0.0201333575,
-0.0015839871,
-0.0553244576,
0.045181036,
0.0738056973,
0.0431246273,
0.0639852583,
-0.0087999823,
0.0267420281,
0.0257987045,
-0.030081775,
0.0463991463,
-0.0119198496,
0.0056808763,
-0.0149047803,
-0.0073130107,
-0.0350934975,
-0.01513517,
0.0436808653,
0.0253188014,
0.0034840212,
0.0120737348,
0.0722199976,
0.0455499925,
-0.0361640304,
-0.0238315593,
0.0332777426,
-0.0303865802,
0.0057629915,
-0.0033120567,
-0.0336634293,
0.0229623206,
-0.0071372711,
-0.0078730397,
0.009253921,
-0.0449945368,
0.0041767149,
-0.0193748847,
0.0156795904,
0.003502483,
-0.0155947525,
-0.0123842796,
-0.0323117152,
-0.0068303808,
0.002412677,
-0.0100017572,
0.029226264,
0.0153652709,
-0.0598851852,
0.0429853201,
0.0430869311,
-0.0832852647,
-0.0136790192,
-0.042406179,
-0.0284143519,
0.067849651,
0.0002249223,
-0.0177036747,
-0.006222323,
-0.0280796085,
0.0215770844,
-0.022531135,
0.0095809633,
-0.0132056959,
0.0657488927,
-0.0197636411,
0.0039986013,
-0.0230417959,
-0.0165909734,
-0.0467798412,
0.0015604108,
0.0151682841,
-0.0003591138,
-0.0726906732,
-0.0175689943,
-0.0000759037,
0.0145144761,
0.0470964164,
0.0662390217,
-0.0847303793,
0.0214026291,
-0.0132357413,
0.0402868614,
0.0169584863,
-0.0330045074,
0.0506290197,
-0.0214753486,
0.0144741628,
0.0323048197,
0.0104374494,
0.0198413003,
0.0257258713,
0.0233443044,
-0.0321368873,
-0.0161536988,
0.0139197633,
-0.0770495757,
-0.0521091074,
0.0080842748,
-0.0045475364,
-0.0365142114,
0.0389560647,
0.0383672938,
0.0127108442,
-0.0173167493,
0.0017074593,
0.0047859675,
-0.0046986029,
0.0443161651,
-0.0720214918,
-0.0156436749,
0.0518033989,
0.0249837656,
0.0151217636,
0.0115242042,
0.0221097805,
0.0144486232,
-0.0156041607,
0.0093318122,
0.0270771459,
-0.0093569579,
0.0240590982,
-0.0492675528,
-0.0067981835,
-0.0119595947,
-0.0176829193,
0.0641282946,
0.0418272093,
0.0438733213,
0.008054072,
-0.0032455593,
0.0239065494,
0.0256171189,
0.0473165251,
-0.0097729154,
0.0305638071,
-0.024856152,
-0.0579462834,
-0.0074794372,
0.0150491148,
0.0346992649,
0.0040218304,
-0.0118285278,
-0.0087662116,
0.0126845362,
-0.0441261828,
-0.0482406206,
-0.0184250735,
-0.0003983691,
-0.0323974602,
0.0065113888,
0.0371984579,
0.0028228706,
-0.0251207296,
0.0373399965,
0.0330398604,
-0.0219579693,
-0.0067503522,
-0.0866704807,
0.004720476,
0.0642559379,
0.0568512157,
-0.0169299711,
-0.0297701284,
-0.0059301192,
0.002587646,
-0.0053631323,
0.0284771156,
0.0005848303,
0.0303860418,
-0.0475272126,
-0.0389638357,
0.0386847742,
0.0187736675,
-0.0019903632,
-0.0270582773,
0.0427596942,
-0.0170877539,
-0.0303917471,
-0.0265814792,
0.0271866918,
-0.004073529,
-0.0271744821,
0.0470176227,
0.0209966283,
0.0051570651,
-0.0084025422,
-0.0175480936,
0.0206068307,
0.0037905644,
-0.0186789483,
-0.0406201743,
0.0129073039,
-0.0584221669,
-0.0564822964,
-0.0169296823,
-0.0467931442,
-0.0184141323,
-0.0421239659,
-0.0471905321,
-0.007794417,
-0.0585596524,
-0.0621914081,
0.0019387202,
-0.0290328525,
0.0099818092,
0.0699869916,
-0.0116904993,
-0.0064095673,
0.0531532504,
-0.0093100183,
-0.022473773,
0.029374592,
-0.0414938517,
0.018455524,
-0.0557274073,
-0.0167496577,
0.0190710649,
-0.0226798914,
-0.0043519256,
0.0139684044,
0.0236486159,
-0.0125224004,
-0.0104765929,
-0.0832852945,
-0.0144181475,
0.0027000252,
-0.02671271,
0.0285250675,
0.0464820229,
0.0004641586,
-0.0532313436,
-0.0540316366,
-0.0199707802,
0.0765970349,
0.0249138102,
0.0523947813,
0.049560871,
-0.007148779,
0.0104475925,
-0.0002497192,
-0.0186703689,
0.0088473782,
0.0514174737,
-0.0347878747,
-0.0371285938,
0.0012524275,
-0.0167004056,
-0.001059123,
0.0237812381,
-0.0248980355,
0.0096214991,
-0.0152357118,
-0.0332123041,
0.0696641207,
0.0175784174,
0.0562870614,
0.0339897163,
0.0194431264,
-0.0276179481,
0.0189118795,
-0.054535687,
-0.0231880154,
0.0402882807,
-0.0782983974,
0.0295671392,
0.0252653807,
0.0226075631,
0.0380253755,
-0.051827807,
-0.0201379191,
0.0091407271,
-0.0209908597,
-0.0681665242,
-0.0007001106,
-0.0300089717,
0.0404741503,
-0.0096269874,
-0.0399495363,
0.087668553,
0.0059845117,
0.0161935426,
-0.0504074246,
0.002519005,
-0.0178481005,
0.0299583022,
-0.0036945499,
0.0455756932,
0.0500407144,
-0.053725142,
-0.0112956706,
0.0231044963,
0.0172887594,
-0.0618408509,
0.0082882382,
-0.0009974597,
-0.0054906211,
-0.0134033775,
-0.0384411253,
-0.0355145223,
-0.0165538825,
0.0286409538,
-0.0155268749,
-0.0193454344,
0.002137102,
-0.0762872025,
0.036192894,
-0.0269485358,
0.0645238087,
-0.0105983298,
-0.0278570391,
0.0056131082,
0.0325463414,
0.0217122305,
0.0246392395,
-0.018179208,
-0.0576969571,
0.0256113466,
0.0835237652,
-0.0298201926,
0.0364968553,
0.0062780404,
0.0159495566,
-0.0196000822,
0.0080536231,
0.004980464,
0.0485100336,
0.0467700548,
-0.0641943067,
-0.0302321948,
0.0767716914,
0.029883517,
-0.0843467489,
-0.0000776786,
0.0102962209,
0.0184273757,
-0.0288291089,
0.014938971,
-0.0524133742,
-0.0453590713,
0.0084821554,
0.0496491492,
-0.0384638645,
-0.0139703713,
0.0141529813,
-0.0175892636,
0.0504638366,
-0.0159809608,
-0.0263368618,
-0.0909564719,
-0.0339626856,
-0.0396698602,
0.0020107364,
-0.015469227,
-0.0172261018,
-0.0071491837,
-0.0008343321,
0.0339527167,
-0.0396070629,
-0.0981225073,
-0.0194274355,
-0.0237626377,
-0.0178916045,
0.0973970741,
0.005066847,
0.0115950117,
-0.0228739977,
-0.0368111134,
0.0318853296,
0.0389829762,
-0.020483138,
0.1186421067,
-0.0204790588,
-0.0046630986,
-0.0600370131,
0.0176185649,
-0.0119196149,
0.0000614053,
0.001226973,
0.0726889968,
-0.0384400785,
-0.0212791562,
-0.0786853507,
0.0035122943,
0.0358789563,
0.0503770746,
0.0122663556,
0.0046897181,
-0.0357499979,
-0.0032473828,
0.0746263266,
-0.0382352062,
0.0168010443,
0.0519223846,
-0.0348008424,
-0.0944772214,
-0.03283941,
-0.0368222706,
0.0332825631,
0.009650399,
-0.0011917236,
-0.0159360468,
-0.0311708543,
0.0143045466,
-0.08621905,
0.0379518569,
0.0256323107,
-0.0175025612,
-0.0726366788,
-0.0278487373,
0.0392395034,
-0.0042041079,
-0.0032961729,
0.0095173949,
-0.0316846147,
0.0049507669,
-0.0271138344,
0.0327358693,
0.0229092091,
0.00163598,
0.0002085062,
-0.0331906453,
0.096239008,
0.1181220561,
-0.0225236006,
-0.0085430732,
-0.0092673041,
-0.0701445937,
-0.0432686955,
-0.0031756465,
-0.0356210656,
0.0007923688,
0.0128814084,
0.0170506556,
-0.0047723711,
-0.0271445177,
0.0454146303,
0.0249191523,
0.0506792106,
-0.0427508056,
-0.0540219471,
-0.0231765471,
0.0129283145,
-0.0004729716,
0.0094483644,
-0.0351204015,
0.0443645008,
-0.0036977932,
-0.0155513687,
0.0018065997,
0.0331732519,
-0.0304434169,
-0.0236382969,
-0.0719041154,
0.0463385433,
0.0034971747,
-0.004350537,
0.0578382388,
-0.0066820453,
-0.0046203737,
-0.0171082076,
0.0486175604,
0.0026959113,
0.0055525932,
0.0580896065,
0.0274672564,
0.0712156743,
-0.0043719546,
0.0455365367,
-0.031991329,
-0.0157690495,
-0.0555954278,
0.0158106722,
0.0144150965,
0.02629981,
-0.0058275266,
-0.032379102,
0.0135034416,
-0.0226213224,
0.0485564321,
0.0111145377,
0.0061479607,
0.0631559789,
-0.0357400626,
0.012038934,
-0.0539278835,
0.0793692023,
-0.049680613,
0.0376044661,
-0.029142309,
-0.0553857759,
-0.0495736413,
0.0017753603,
0.0685158819,
-0.0163295176,
-0.0411201306,
0.0095032835,
-0.0305699538,
-0.0272519179,
0.0312480349,
-0.0142101878,
-0.0077742948,
-0.0048666331,
0.056822814,
0.0546003319,
-0.0004365407,
-0.0199930761,
0.0065191239,
0.0445130318,
-0.0604849309,
-0.0189304482,
0.0045330748,
-6.303371725e-33,
-0.0267583281,
-0.0280359108,
0.025818551,
-0.0567195714,
0.029373426,
0.0436438918,
-0.0363889001,
-0.0135649005,
0.0359404087,
0.0398522429,
-0.0310082845,
-0.0233793017,
0.0179967694,
0.0613597445,
0.005086733,
-0.0257071182,
0.0686286837,
-0.0034392383,
-0.042293448,
0.0462825559,
0.0081758359,
0.0299783461,
-0.0029332298,
-0.0627319813,
-0.0432231948,
0.0341011584,
-0.0150515353,
-0.020078836,
0.0085760253,
0.0422797874,
-0.0236781165,
0.0275325011,
0.0405031256,
-0.0062712631,
-0.0154114673,
0.0435302854,
-0.0706791133,
-0.0306302235,
-0.0449142903,
-0.006324891,
-0.0181665123,
-0.0274238493,
0.0290959645,
-0.0141124679,
0.004489786,
-0.0228681657,
0.0366416834,
0.0015599469,
-0.0079168053,
-0.0693837926,
0.0164363924,
0.0554383807,
0.0135272685,
-0.0326292999,
-0.0125894258,
0.0427387804,
-0.011944348,
0.0298861898,
-0.010304709,
0.0166480374,
0.0508879162,
0.026941631,
0.0231969077,
0.0073796553,
-0.055348713,
0.0706158131,
0.065541856,
-0.0534513444,
-0.0377553664,
0.0406566374,
-0.0681194216,
0.0153178619,
0.0416371264,
0.0312064644,
0.0796831176,
-0.033710584,
-0.0576387718,
0.0839276612,
-0.0588345565,
0.0276447684,
0.027838815,
-0.0177787859,
-0.033404056,
-0.0071297907,
0.0155334212,
-0.0181799512,
-0.0168270785,
-0.0425864309,
0.0733205155,
0.0465719625,
-0.0100927781,
0.0196234249,
0.026599111,
0.025635127,
0.007501259,
-0.02417106,
0.0539047718,
0.0144978594,
-0.0476136692,
-0.0238617025,
0.0198192187,
-0.0254009087,
0.0661623105,
-0.0097567923,
0.0235033166,
0.0388475023,
0.0401344746,
-0.0015195133,
-0.0512393452,
0.0075736465,
0.0381325297,
0.0362087004,
-0.037495289,
0.0569600984,
0.0118128005,
0.0143646104,
-0.0242830366,
0.0419121534,
-0.03053445,
0.0075647864,
-0.0605588146,
-0.0458368063,
0.003405978,
0.0212800801,
-0.0430064723,
-0.0096084904,
-0.0397627316,
-0.0237080492,
0.0459743179,
-0.0472502373,
-0.0302822869,
0.0111788055,
2.959e-7,
0.0690496042,
0.0078458069,
0.0338938609,
-0.0287737474,
0.0250951853,
0.0196311623,
0.0045496207,
0.0306957588,
0.0204106625,
-0.0272775348,
0.0302603114,
-0.0002028341,
0.0006219295,
0.0208635852,
-0.0680164769,
-0.0179687925,
-0.0588966534,
0.0424902029,
0.0003014145,
-0.0012397509,
0.0854711086,
0.051842317,
-0.0607243702,
-0.0582703464,
0.0534891859,
0.001413036,
0.0251390338,
-0.0119553795,
0.0136305615,
0.0013655353,
0.0172763169,
0.0060121012,
0.0304102153,
0.0476419479,
-0.0332135111,
-0.0429363251,
-0.0288520437,
0.0561138913,
-0.0370856076,
-0.0237509236,
0.0189971104,
0.0492906906,
0.0350278653,
-0.0131500866,
0.0460795611,
-0.0484123267,
-0.0064492011,
-0.0085953595,
-0.0179624334,
0.000756216,
0.0458582379,
-0.0543570928,
-0.0762623325,
0.0285521187,
0.0305140074,
0.0429030508,
-0.0403659232,
-0.0893215165,
0.0036186138,
-0.0159303695,
-0.0255453978,
-0.0322803706,
0.0078282412,
0.0117160575,
0.0032820415,
-0.0644683093,
-0.0265707374,
3.019923736e-34,
0.0460340157,
0.0250834152,
-0.0064337188,
-0.0123627279,
0.0137419496,
-0.0256500728,
0.0432003848,
0.001306796,
0.0178642478,
-0.0337759927,
-0.0543508679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12578v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12578v1 | Mind vs. Mouth: On Measuring Re-judge Inconsistency of Social Bias in Large Language Models | 2023-08-24T05:35:58 | 2023-08-24T05:35:58 | Yachao Zhao, Bo Wang, Dongming Zhao, Kun Huang, Yan Wang, Ruifang He, Yuexian Hou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent researches indicate that Pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs)
possess cognitive constructs similar to those observed in humans, prompting
researchers to investigate the cognitive aspects of LLMs. This paper focuses on
explicit and implicit social bias, a distinctive two-level cognitive construct
in psychology. It posits that individuals' explicit social bias, which is their
conscious expression of bias in the statements, may differ from their implicit
social bias, which represents their unconscious bias. We propose a two-stage
approach and discover a parallel phenomenon in LLMs known as "re-judge
inconsistency" in social bias. In the initial stage, the LLM is tasked with
automatically completing statements, potentially incorporating implicit social
bias. However, in the subsequent stage, the same LLM re-judges the biased
statement generated by itself but contradicts it. We propose that this re-judge
inconsistency can be similar to the inconsistency between human's unaware
implicit social bias and their aware explicit social bias. Experimental
investigations on ChatGPT and GPT-4 concerning common gender biases examined in
psychology corroborate the highly stable nature of the re-judge inconsistency.
This finding may suggest that diverse cognitive constructs emerge as LLMs'
capabilities strengthen. Consequently, leveraging psychological theories can
provide enhanced insights into the underlying mechanisms governing the
expressions of explicit and implicit constructs in LLMs. | [
0.0522846803,
0.0364352427,
-0.0621261895,
0.0206614062,
-0.0334047675,
0.0310044363,
0.0041115559,
-0.0099639203,
0.0670399517,
-0.0709754303,
-0.059092734,
-0.009543824,
0.0187034719,
-0.0172744803,
0.0661948472,
-0.0182448067,
0.0639755279,
0.0062528173,
0.0662324503,
-0.0483655073,
0.012471078,
0.0134773422,
0.0133511377,
-0.0012908229,
-0.0018553219,
-0.0020977058,
0.0225270558,
-0.0254278202,
-0.0374924354,
-0.0450642593,
0.0164940488,
0.0718095601,
0.0154556548,
0.0396640562,
0.0000018691,
-0.0806385949,
0.0260784123,
-0.0296089724,
-0.0186872333,
0.047273837,
0.0232744683,
0.0101354979,
0.0156603847,
-0.0007335359,
-0.0387198254,
-0.02154007,
0.0034582932,
0.0540263131,
0.0227900688,
0.0238801837,
-0.0023502158,
0.0108856941,
-0.0354871079,
-0.0258393493,
-0.0110199936,
-0.0312516317,
0.0696520358,
-0.0095130466,
-0.0954605117,
-0.0005862311,
-0.0180408899,
-0.0172873065,
-0.004215701,
0.0174869914,
-0.0043529021,
0.0034959835,
-0.0284943935,
-0.0531611033,
-0.0102636144,
0.0306061916,
0.0578717031,
-0.0347719342,
0.0072164317,
-0.0230797306,
0.0376804508,
0.0209741294,
-0.0224358421,
0.0374444351,
0.0051298649,
-0.0117964577,
-0.0131423026,
-0.0170996357,
0.0139311347,
0.0349702537,
0.0147490473,
0.0658089668,
0.0007293383,
-0.0344607532,
0.0291178599,
0.0387093015,
-0.0091824979,
-0.0789868906,
-0.029348731,
-0.0041979947,
-0.0100907981,
0.0238332599,
-0.0080326777,
0.0318668857,
0.0369217955,
-0.0514715761,
0.0180341937,
0.0204756781,
-0.0183780678,
0.0191630181,
-0.0154206147,
0.0227521379,
-0.0230522081,
0.0168474447,
0.0007368972,
0.0049405931,
-0.0023399603,
-0.0524211153,
0.0038730092,
-0.0000271502,
0.0448929854,
0.0301423818,
-0.0446820781,
-0.0115227029,
-0.0507493652,
-0.0332195722,
-0.0262082107,
0.0108119156,
-0.0096646501,
-0.0051205405,
-0.082852371,
0.0136062121,
-0.0232910216,
0.0490842946,
-0.0427238606,
-0.0995884985,
-0.0003342349,
-0.0080852155,
-0.0107510146,
-0.0103597017,
-0.0238428321,
0.0258719511,
-0.0203487184,
-0.0072891926,
-0.0174735282,
-0.0127856703,
-0.0348727927,
-0.0801929906,
-0.0119603481,
-0.013691402,
-0.000703575,
0.0264589228,
0.0009699955,
-0.0275889356,
0.0054522702,
0.0185740069,
-0.059606567,
0.0398842022,
0.0415051505,
0.0421492159,
0.0509757549,
0.0178772956,
-0.0085641844,
0.0615453087,
-0.0031869893,
-0.0236612428,
-0.0035143341,
-0.0024074696,
-0.0145191057,
0.0142534208,
0.0359853506,
-0.0037897136,
-0.0599613748,
0.0205316003,
-0.0135214599,
0.0289229769,
0.0779482946,
0.0496860854,
-0.0291365199,
-0.0209588688,
0.0776707605,
0.0302905124,
-0.0050233705,
0.0416396745,
0.0102209123,
0.0113544175,
0.038529478,
0.0414869785,
-0.0741657838,
0.0185041986,
0.0009235895,
-0.0425842032,
0.0008216588,
0.025112601,
-0.0158223324,
-0.0052348119,
-0.0166023187,
0.0403571054,
0.0290021822,
-0.004176443,
0.0125340661,
0.0127860326,
-0.0081118494,
0.0373532884,
0.04451029,
-0.015921656,
0.000863786,
-0.0807095841,
0.0438683257,
0.0076975562,
-0.00483442,
0.0133504244,
0.0013207588,
0.000382482,
-0.035274893,
0.0633535385,
0.1226575375,
-0.0015573892,
-0.0449825302,
-0.0110502588,
-0.0094337463,
-0.0002586326,
0.0291875862,
0.0039643059,
0.0248167571,
0.037114013,
-0.0153934909,
-0.0186168551,
-0.0203998331,
0.0308800023,
-0.0082492335,
-0.021437075,
-0.0649555251,
0.0027457899,
0.0268794466,
-0.0081576454,
-0.0074182982,
0.0043867589,
-0.0038325919,
0.0495016947,
-0.0126825031,
0.0262307841,
-0.0875082985,
0.0114582973,
0.00907363,
-0.0086854873,
-0.0522329621,
-0.0025295783,
0.016736649,
0.0092230234,
0.0431091487,
-0.0283138361,
0.0597196855,
-0.0383564048,
0.0118005844,
-0.0626961514,
0.0206980761,
-0.0282836407,
0.0343572795,
-0.006503812,
-0.0391001068,
0.0221081339,
-0.0277489182,
0.0051277368,
-0.0295401122,
-0.0011612802,
0.0013005204,
0.0222748872,
-0.0326919109,
0.0052506905,
-0.0543377101,
-0.0598629117,
-0.0316843353,
-0.0834431872,
-0.0529648364,
0.0268721115,
-0.0364827737,
0.0188380387,
-0.0369630195,
-0.027140744,
0.0019892156,
-0.0131246513,
0.0195592977,
0.0087415148,
0.0590179972,
0.0319467895,
-0.0416883454,
0.0272645038,
-0.0427169949,
0.0145471245,
-0.0544420592,
0.0231108759,
0.0469233319,
-0.0121349553,
-0.073921971,
0.028807871,
-0.0490909927,
0.0231953729,
0.0023789906,
-0.0503079742,
0.0349684432,
0.0644870922,
0.044315882,
0.0958036706,
0.0329461768,
0.0244140513,
0.0882305503,
-0.0189582556,
-0.064517051,
-0.0190827269,
0.0042391862,
-0.0032983762,
-0.0165003892,
-0.0505754948,
-0.0134979682,
0.0580851324,
0.0736970752,
-0.0059660138,
-0.0310934912,
0.0698887631,
-0.0425895452,
-0.0782653466,
0.0143777346,
-0.075399451,
-0.0293164738,
0.0278046485,
-0.0244012848,
-0.0801582932,
0.052719593,
0.0066691842,
0.012744559,
-0.0048303278,
0.0356856138,
-0.0198633987,
0.054772839,
0.0123803439,
0.0202120431,
0.0347770043,
-0.0203909855,
-0.0901655182,
-0.0584897995,
0.0184102133,
-0.020365471,
0.0042408318,
-0.0365032032,
-0.0075563788,
0.0195504818,
-0.0216657873,
-0.0470668338,
-0.0448691808,
-0.0470012352,
-0.0319045633,
0.0029714103,
-0.0123812268,
0.0136733996,
-0.0119469259,
0.0291814804,
0.0015371788,
-0.019235611,
-0.0075183362,
0.0077189608,
-0.0334947295,
0.0263615288,
0.0223336127,
0.06973885,
-0.019268807,
0.0132084331,
0.0282577574,
-0.0124871954,
0.0397728384,
-0.0173870828,
-0.001722366,
0.014090661,
0.0047093704,
0.0004826078,
0.0091839116,
0.0465131886,
-0.0130719263,
0.0370241627,
0.0876733586,
0.0035278408,
-0.0631766394,
0.004317848,
-0.0180852506,
-0.0026498418,
0.0581335053,
-0.0111652277,
-0.0574876033,
0.0048893755,
0.0246016514,
-0.0342288762,
-0.0647460893,
-0.0427337214,
-0.0206535161,
-0.1236816645,
0.0268450323,
0.0048530311,
0.0054108067,
0.0103438366,
0.0007740809,
0.029217042,
0.0063908766,
0.0311058704,
0.0386777036,
-0.0223526303,
0.0115097621,
-0.0023498863,
-0.0388243794,
-0.0141896168,
0.0402263999,
-0.0318188258,
0.0780669004,
0.0200300533,
0.0459912382,
0.0013398674,
-0.0122054834,
0.0892698094,
-0.0233382396,
0.0122119868,
-0.0345399156,
0.0161860436,
-0.0350056775,
0.0024222222,
-0.0422912128,
0.0161909889,
0.027405465,
-0.0009785368,
-0.0105392905,
0.0551993139,
0.011620068,
-0.0617426522,
-0.0092875799,
0.0036747518,
-0.0122665586,
0.0893080533,
0.0166144073,
-0.0125506585,
0.0096894531,
0.0153405648,
0.0068279086,
0.0843935013,
-0.0657791793,
0.0185778663,
0.0192377493,
0.0152023248,
-0.0456447341,
-0.0472173132,
0.0021216711,
-0.0367188938,
0.0177427251,
-0.0361806266,
0.051205229,
-0.0279155355,
-0.0240423977,
0.0248868242,
-0.0273240842,
-0.002448888,
0.026992565,
-0.0357252508,
-0.0061079795,
-0.0420854837,
-0.0144370459,
0.0016625409,
-0.0116744703,
-0.0430685058,
0.0620664768,
0.0066277953,
0.0273359362,
0.031754259,
0.0037339029,
-0.0526442081,
0.0330331214,
-0.0154044628,
-0.0346455202,
0.0847618356,
-0.0057287537,
0.0306858532,
0.0091430107,
0.0432075448,
0.0011872945,
0.0255089961,
0.0315216817,
-0.0336849093,
0.0028389629,
-0.0541900732,
0.0424747951,
0.0088449102,
0.0524143279,
-0.0068509374,
0.0522481315,
-0.0442169495,
-0.0342945121,
0.0013404944,
-0.0562757291,
0.0015839187,
-0.0394690856,
0.0390288569,
0.0285455249,
-0.0415736102,
-0.0548405536,
-0.0461310446,
0.0327578597,
0.0114442362,
-0.011062487,
0.0245168637,
0.038394399,
0.0047427639,
0.0133856609,
-0.007672742,
0.0354124196,
-0.0736333132,
0.0121985013,
0.0293348618,
0.0676792488,
0.030423291,
-0.0248288643,
-0.0285549145,
-0.0312399343,
-0.0446518771,
-0.0274119359,
0.0248847641,
0.0088983849,
0.0037781927,
-0.0341095738,
0.0259295385,
-0.0134388488,
0.0064133946,
0.00196815,
-0.0233499762,
-0.0264184456,
-0.0001286008,
0.046007514,
-0.0017103401,
-0.0335798711,
0.0372880921,
0.0485248528,
0.0017417484,
0.069434844,
-0.0351702012,
-0.0341470726,
-0.0050036348,
-0.0270017236,
0.0374751873,
-0.0198589042,
-0.0398306735,
0.0071381014,
-0.0799964368,
-0.0400066711,
-0.0106440149,
-0.0007086188,
0.0362801105,
-0.0695760325,
-0.0142144002,
0.0986222401,
-0.0280962978,
-0.0472238436,
0.018159885,
0.0268149674,
-0.0029517871,
0.0355306454,
-0.0405367501,
-6.368729945e-33,
-0.0319163911,
-0.0362274162,
-0.0156482607,
-0.0287467614,
-0.0460115857,
-0.0045732767,
-0.0240102019,
0.0201796871,
-0.0057205642,
0.0306680109,
-0.0104275225,
0.057525672,
0.0194790494,
-0.0539820418,
0.0492726788,
-0.0100702178,
0.0579762571,
-0.0224752948,
-0.0154483523,
-0.0373833701,
-0.0135470321,
-0.0173288286,
0.0329434015,
-0.0499812886,
0.0638623536,
0.0025235212,
0.0061239195,
0.0042537134,
-0.0499374233,
0.0043536481,
-0.039371144,
0.0300214142,
0.0364120305,
0.0124274381,
-0.0024067892,
0.0534709953,
0.0061261598,
-0.0292917863,
0.0631337017,
0.0152240423,
0.0059314677,
0.0019984248,
0.016696481,
-0.021318756,
-0.0915981382,
0.0226527061,
0.0251511373,
-0.0001835002,
0.0794406459,
0.0707645714,
-0.0530867428,
-0.0045698183,
0.0040326254,
0.0248609297,
-0.0409992933,
-0.0101132011,
-0.0080118012,
0.0036735204,
-0.0564114004,
0.0295510553,
-0.0039283116,
0.0026700397,
0.0315909944,
0.011218519,
0.0323180482,
0.0801986828,
0.0774703249,
0.0616198927,
-0.0371008255,
-0.0427651852,
0.0321069993,
-0.0185486116,
0.0108061926,
0.0521201976,
0.0127391499,
-0.037133269,
-0.0140662594,
-0.0755537823,
0.05503086,
0.018511977,
0.0489049181,
0.0004633417,
-0.0060237455,
-0.0465530939,
-0.057104446,
-0.0876397416,
-0.0346259736,
-0.0109018525,
0.0370347239,
0.0277998969,
0.0191376973,
-0.0185751617,
-0.0048258076,
-0.0092940638,
-0.0151812388,
-0.0324916132,
-0.0404866785,
-0.0105939517,
0.017906338,
0.024966279,
-0.0581951812,
-0.0004660878,
-0.0115342401,
0.0519416705,
0.0050645652,
0.030934291,
-0.0234296396,
0.0128548965,
-0.043539267,
0.0084602479,
-0.002922486,
-0.029851621,
-0.0062329392,
-0.0560747385,
0.0534363836,
0.0337629281,
-0.0361559205,
-0.0195201803,
0.0310268104,
-0.0107565485,
-0.0688512996,
0.0117204804,
-0.0101674115,
0.0542268828,
-0.0089576729,
-0.0203162469,
-0.0163308773,
-0.0150239859,
0.0264991149,
-0.0348803736,
-0.013084081,
-0.015954785,
2.641e-7,
-0.0200049318,
0.0941495523,
-0.023727037,
0.008359151,
0.0389689691,
0.0323239975,
-0.0039774608,
0.0179818589,
0.05627691,
-0.0132268174,
-0.0458342433,
0.0457516499,
-0.0010830336,
0.0185261909,
-0.0055477927,
0.0179706588,
-0.0724984184,
0.0092278998,
-0.0106633706,
0.0180796664,
-0.0062327501,
0.0165472794,
0.034017656,
0.0071414933,
-0.0388398506,
-0.0346577615,
0.0742359981,
-0.0068587624,
0.0112086432,
0.0028334965,
0.0096775079,
0.0037837296,
0.0340518653,
0.0668120086,
0.0558202192,
0.0117842294,
-0.0055540991,
0.0362138227,
0.0048438888,
0.049839858,
-0.0317365788,
0.0157957226,
-0.0295906104,
-0.0750150755,
0.0421363264,
-0.0669923201,
-0.0446254052,
-0.0472116843,
0.0049247323,
-0.038275741,
0.0544465967,
-0.0045148451,
-0.0156095931,
0.0128596397,
0.026105551,
0.0308180377,
-0.0105830887,
-0.0583660193,
-0.0288467612,
-0.0296100322,
-0.0303368475,
-0.0751458108,
-0.0200862605,
0.0285481811,
0.039993342,
-0.0297486652,
0.0449849926,
1.960719756e-34,
0.0162289552,
0.0156868249,
0.0511410199,
-0.0308506768,
0.050544668,
0.0083839344,
0.0009990622,
0.0257421099,
0.0520165041,
-0.0539763607,
0.0035746749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12568v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12568v4 | A Small and Fast BERT for Chinese Medical Punctuation Restoration | 2023-08-24T05:15:43 | 2024-06-28T15:44:36 | Tongtao Ling, Yutao Lai, Lei Chen, Shilei Huang, Yi Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In clinical dictation, utterances after automatic speech recognition (ASR)
without explicit punctuation marks may lead to the misunderstanding of dictated
reports. To give a precise and understandable clinical report with ASR,
automatic punctuation restoration is required. Considering a practical
scenario, we propose a fast and light pre-trained model for Chinese medical
punctuation restoration based on 'pretraining and fine-tuning' paradigm. In
this work, we distill pre-trained models by incorporating supervised
contrastive learning and a novel auxiliary pre-training task (Punctuation Mark
Prediction) to make it well-suited for punctuation restoration. Our experiments
on various distilled models reveal that our model can achieve 95% performance
while 10% model size relative to state-of-the-art Chinese RoBERTa. | [
0.0092215156,
0.0466416776,
0.0127302492,
-0.0383705869,
-0.0173510816,
-0.0031342704,
0.0144557152,
0.0152869374,
-0.0185692534,
-0.0198874734,
-0.0531858802,
-0.0297773965,
0.033567246,
0.0001040375,
0.0333168767,
-0.0948218778,
0.0273952242,
0.0068846419,
0.0298915189,
0.0054370943,
0.0466400459,
-0.0303919427,
-0.0354315378,
0.0497936681,
0.0001251388,
-0.0267536733,
0.0065595154,
0.0476282611,
0.0496378541,
-0.0659241304,
0.0241122358,
0.0421133824,
-0.0597083159,
-0.0137634054,
0.0000017223,
-0.0454052202,
-0.0430193953,
0.0358478241,
-0.0097762942,
0.0359650403,
-0.0417532958,
-0.0343816057,
-0.0323952138,
0.0625250787,
-0.0078773145,
-0.0308686141,
0.0198699906,
0.0648291856,
0.0362294279,
0.0828154087,
-0.0241893642,
-0.0121832257,
0.0157826208,
-0.0120364688,
-0.044614967,
0.0181480534,
0.0253573507,
0.0053874971,
-0.037052881,
-0.0638682395,
-0.0051552174,
0.034985289,
-0.018802233,
0.0310190096,
-0.0480007418,
0.0054456885,
-0.0799301788,
0.0036645988,
-0.0438563451,
0.0425165333,
-0.0136372373,
-0.008868752,
0.0104486551,
-0.0081233112,
-0.0080358395,
-0.0475562885,
-0.0233426634,
-0.0377409942,
-0.0139825139,
0.0083061345,
0.0134168342,
-0.0326150246,
0.0045189629,
-0.0279247258,
-0.0363419577,
-0.0681780055,
0.0244092885,
-0.0402141698,
-0.0281265974,
-0.0066218888,
-0.041176796,
-0.0071131508,
0.0569416992,
-0.0156623535,
-0.0094841048,
-0.0256539304,
-0.0536388084,
-0.05652209,
0.0271312371,
-0.0135988835,
0.0136319613,
0.0412518084,
-0.0583843142,
-0.0011461654,
-0.013084434,
0.0137024457,
-0.0265237316,
0.0162390824,
-0.0009641481,
-0.0062040142,
0.0066235303,
0.0180981848,
-0.0508329868,
0.0355984755,
0.014718662,
-0.0177898481,
-0.078162089,
-0.0393808782,
0.0022142343,
0.0000869176,
0.0476933569,
-0.0101668593,
-0.0443811566,
-0.027236376,
0.0136502255,
0.0298595186,
0.0015296704,
0.0340212807,
-0.0250544325,
-0.0250985418,
-0.0015935021,
0.0282565877,
0.0459571891,
0.0018449011,
0.0332787223,
0.0239325203,
-0.0137319304,
-0.0226190388,
-0.0374986753,
0.0087904064,
-0.0434525907,
0.003885028,
-0.0187629182,
-0.0123669142,
-0.0456189662,
0.0062451581,
0.021761043,
-0.007990119,
0.0098562213,
-0.0342348106,
-0.0058779442,
0.0583790913,
-0.0571503416,
-0.0204126723,
0.0177851003,
-0.0388359837,
-0.0069605941,
-0.0201926865,
0.0636823177,
-0.0484799854,
0.0057402262,
0.0083467467,
0.016772652,
0.056830667,
-0.0158805717,
-0.0621819049,
-0.0673211515,
-0.0017646943,
-0.0001799369,
0.0230855457,
0.0062627872,
0.0950649604,
-0.0093465662,
0.0380834974,
0.0524825789,
0.0283538271,
0.043758098,
0.0439284742,
-0.0089768618,
-0.0292083882,
0.0267995335,
0.0304597709,
0.0035842026,
-0.015528799,
0.0094394395,
0.0462599434,
0.0652673095,
-0.0047179586,
-0.0180544406,
-0.0417565368,
0.0089739012,
-0.0209907331,
-0.0146400416,
-0.0084223412,
0.0345537849,
0.0115075419,
-0.0711133853,
0.0339005925,
0.0270525943,
-0.0371769853,
-0.0328889862,
-0.0544649549,
-0.029694397,
0.0806235448,
0.0660918579,
-0.0534265786,
-0.0347010382,
-0.0376967676,
-0.0262826215,
0.0198090132,
-0.0035839437,
0.0128220217,
0.0495860726,
-0.0720207915,
0.0094944909,
0.0714514554,
0.0011132065,
0.0023042758,
-0.0156112192,
0.0247459244,
0.0059104864,
0.0013782633,
-0.0341555141,
0.0275784284,
-0.0213912521,
-0.0217054114,
0.0116759194,
0.0006318445,
0.0263807904,
0.0214919485,
-0.0774382427,
0.016926514,
0.0087266332,
-0.0661284104,
0.0576570332,
0.0240886193,
-0.0750146583,
-0.0771308318,
0.0224735662,
-0.0288014561,
0.0414922014,
0.0619871169,
0.0255007576,
-0.0655516237,
-0.0857748985,
0.0064665782,
0.0541287996,
-0.0449457318,
0.066702947,
0.0394819491,
0.0195625126,
0.0057032122,
-0.0330116786,
-0.0106756473,
0.0062376275,
0.0037667369,
0.0095740994,
0.0393845364,
-0.0065977448,
-0.0390551016,
-0.0162210241,
-0.0249167848,
0.0296262521,
0.0111069009,
0.0008206314,
-0.0146620981,
-0.0190427285,
-0.0993510857,
0.0103984848,
-0.0392264128,
-0.0131419292,
0.0088983625,
0.0169002973,
-0.0167718977,
-0.0392582193,
0.0214268416,
-0.0154584842,
-0.0300882291,
-0.0316569731,
0.0345260948,
0.0045273206,
0.0059949541,
-0.0419292115,
0.0213151146,
-0.0062441942,
-0.0132182399,
-0.0188345276,
-0.0517783202,
-0.0283574183,
0.0475212075,
0.0374677628,
0.0435043722,
0.0266007222,
-0.1011604816,
0.0394145288,
-0.0022795072,
0.0591194518,
0.0606361516,
-0.0026587476,
-0.0238933749,
-0.0215234254,
0.0073262127,
0.0229459144,
0.0214242395,
0.0331347436,
0.0415598936,
-0.0110017937,
0.0019869795,
-0.0129328026,
0.079510048,
0.0022313914,
0.0370099433,
-0.0426810458,
-0.0678916946,
0.0357658155,
-0.0004054119,
0.0420164466,
0.0027397641,
-0.0640923083,
-0.0075277225,
0.0075649004,
-0.004759673,
0.0487837829,
-0.0274153352,
-0.0051370864,
-0.0557877012,
0.0097171338,
0.0087209567,
-0.0146125704,
-0.0106555903,
-0.0046439501,
0.0297857691,
-0.0652358308,
-0.028662201,
0.0223019551,
0.0113705136,
-0.0493344665,
0.0033866228,
0.0105313798,
0.0131096756,
0.0067795683,
-0.0527787618,
-0.0222763419,
-0.0239528213,
-0.0242183302,
0.0445652157,
0.0324349254,
-0.0288832225,
-0.0243638679,
0.0298177358,
-0.0076903827,
0.1192484498,
0.0214448497,
0.0264464207,
-0.0211414527,
0.0368684046,
-0.0129980315,
0.0099017471,
-0.0063592819,
-0.0548948534,
0.0527098477,
0.0225458182,
0.0379983559,
0.0339328535,
0.0047030491,
-0.0215405338,
0.0116939284,
-0.0193830989,
-0.0377986617,
0.0230164006,
0.0520553701,
-0.0383151881,
0.008435851,
0.1116609573,
0.0017369492,
-0.0191603526,
-0.0281066187,
0.0343232416,
-0.0050607235,
-0.0038603952,
-0.0413948409,
-0.0739649981,
-0.0445157029,
0.0397436693,
0.0318939574,
0.0330592319,
0.008454469,
0.0267576817,
-0.0455380306,
0.0279316176,
0.0183344651,
-0.0529534332,
-0.0363779776,
-0.0002354975,
0.0091605252,
-0.0127919493,
0.0269682705,
0.0170969199,
-0.0185526144,
0.0051280456,
0.040848963,
-0.0757015347,
-0.0576449297,
-0.0145169701,
-0.0556983016,
0.0330831707,
0.0869125798,
0.0338888392,
-0.0077525373,
0.0081569385,
0.012300021,
-0.0284997597,
-0.005098688,
0.0012037654,
0.079133071,
0.0083802622,
-0.0438245609,
-0.0038724618,
0.0358471535,
0.0073728501,
-0.0252497047,
0.0208838917,
-0.0443123206,
-0.0153658222,
0.0331031829,
0.005723522,
0.0330272466,
0.0089432457,
0.0410565659,
0.0118026454,
-0.0379879847,
-0.0320351273,
-0.0024978791,
0.0758184195,
-0.0725435913,
0.0261687562,
0.0131546073,
-0.065539442,
-0.016155215,
-0.0767096803,
-0.0114635043,
0.0307562035,
0.0074121966,
0.016903365,
0.0245950576,
-0.005001341,
0.0690153241,
-0.0339415409,
-0.0131546697,
0.0511674359,
-0.0199520327,
-0.0926638618,
-0.0539677963,
0.011708756,
-0.01540187,
-0.0111021018,
-0.0317440219,
0.0081857648,
-0.0303829648,
0.0514307506,
0.0679071397,
0.0043387082,
0.0219437461,
0.0253958367,
0.012626349,
0.0347064696,
0.0551268049,
-0.0205613934,
-0.0079723075,
0.0408918522,
-0.0155295236,
-0.0161065739,
0.0049767094,
0.0130120562,
0.012820174,
-0.0115356063,
0.0759115964,
-0.0520950593,
-0.0455175713,
0.02434838,
0.0282223802,
0.0795241296,
-0.0227165353,
-0.0109665403,
-0.0471659116,
0.0547520705,
-0.0157482326,
0.037975952,
-0.0510238707,
0.0043448447,
0.0004353896,
0.008785639,
-0.0503587984,
-0.0065401997,
-0.0507726222,
-0.0586255677,
-0.0509406216,
0.02492374,
0.0096219173,
0.0239628181,
0.030414544,
-0.0316295289,
0.0198794361,
0.0259791594,
0.036259044,
0.0306835696,
0.0152105456,
0.0371521153,
-0.0091253445,
0.0370698906,
-0.0190770514,
0.0129202772,
-0.0089787645,
-0.0102257803,
-0.0547183491,
0.0548818298,
0.0584516153,
-0.0003350473,
0.0421666615,
-0.0202297159,
0.0118956016,
-0.0236388221,
0.0114925327,
-0.0361050293,
0.0732358769,
-0.052711267,
-0.0125046503,
-0.0111967912,
0.006182285,
0.0643231124,
-0.0129966149,
0.0207836721,
0.0068628923,
-0.008411278,
-0.0509331822,
0.0003319693,
0.063327536,
-0.0043266388,
-0.0373102948,
0.0102086607,
0.0136184627,
-0.041162096,
0.0407262035,
0.0044683847,
-0.0083306506,
-0.0283978209,
0.0205087792,
-0.0057169632,
-0.0442334861,
-0.0027864173,
0.0036470371,
-0.0213048942,
0.0433737412,
0.0093748979,
0.0454794355,
-5.744959378e-33,
0.0205834787,
0.0383590311,
-0.0087184478,
-0.0139148924,
0.0095548797,
0.0280451551,
-0.0226577409,
-0.0108138155,
-0.0106126405,
-0.0016249978,
-0.0538415462,
0.0261788704,
0.0345696472,
0.0323368758,
0.0005596782,
0.0051133302,
0.0989801213,
-0.0130368136,
0.0071220333,
-0.0168337021,
-0.0159319211,
0.0924341232,
0.0495175496,
-0.0488105044,
-0.0470950119,
0.0117316013,
0.0075307149,
-0.0184330046,
0.0210937746,
0.0145809203,
0.0174829103,
-0.0259400494,
-0.002413362,
0.0260271933,
-0.022925118,
-0.0005691349,
-0.1105541587,
0.0072285905,
-0.0036985057,
0.0311888587,
-0.0393001437,
0.0022415319,
0.0449948162,
-0.0248354767,
0.024914939,
0.0211922862,
0.006529395,
-0.0564967059,
0.0187583156,
-0.0254678987,
0.0019123257,
0.0443101749,
-0.0090052541,
-0.0456580818,
0.0438816585,
0.0172487125,
-0.0312936641,
-0.0058955825,
-0.0312580168,
-0.0291820019,
0.0874820575,
0.0644804165,
-0.0319652334,
0.0073528546,
-0.0050359727,
0.0268546697,
0.0691187233,
0.0134832598,
0.0471361503,
-0.0453674532,
-0.0039770356,
0.019358648,
0.0060767168,
0.0101023205,
0.0411434621,
-0.0254627168,
-0.0894100964,
0.0223410092,
-0.01679915,
-0.0085856235,
-0.0062623308,
0.0388260819,
-0.0476880297,
0.0139361462,
0.0071167191,
-0.0043843691,
0.0020750426,
-0.0049348199,
0.0292066075,
0.0003001823,
-0.0172819588,
0.0326237269,
0.0645776615,
-0.0105622495,
0.0330134183,
-0.0292588174,
0.0128056556,
-0.004058321,
-0.0626356974,
-0.0020529532,
-0.0691462904,
-0.0431438461,
0.0334403403,
-0.0100556854,
0.0100742215,
0.0063523026,
0.0027323032,
0.0149417697,
-0.0836921185,
0.0037061563,
0.0677706078,
-0.0197527409,
0.0247399732,
0.0238856599,
0.0258136354,
0.0348134078,
0.0396333635,
0.0117581915,
-0.0009062101,
-0.0022435351,
-0.0263051409,
-0.0601061136,
0.0222308785,
0.0157589018,
-0.0453851521,
-0.0305952244,
-0.0313065723,
0.0461990498,
-0.0193629786,
-0.0381930992,
-0.0275001004,
-0.0092988331,
2.475e-7,
0.0553166755,
0.0226697531,
0.0332552046,
-0.0155239673,
-0.0062623522,
-0.0047894544,
-0.0166705325,
0.0319600403,
0.0080016134,
0.0333345719,
0.0732027143,
-0.0363086201,
0.0921562091,
-0.0120586231,
-0.0868349597,
-0.0294739176,
-0.0386766195,
-0.007408984,
-0.0092147263,
-0.0122563615,
-0.0084182927,
0.041240558,
-0.0611414015,
-0.0092120254,
0.0121910069,
-0.0338597372,
0.0282951631,
-0.0123431068,
-0.0099826045,
0.0507317297,
0.0216796435,
0.0201497599,
-0.0252259057,
0.0253561828,
-0.020102445,
0.0211236086,
0.0332253128,
0.0685885921,
-0.0278711673,
-0.0091577368,
0.0390768908,
0.0656705275,
-0.0264537074,
-0.0019093675,
0.0384835079,
-0.011086965,
0.0144342603,
0.0045465827,
-0.0467590801,
-0.0217425283,
0.0830398574,
-0.0373662822,
-0.0224239174,
0.0454368852,
0.0172134861,
0.0418646336,
-0.0620605163,
-0.0141744129,
-0.0564681664,
0.0260764305,
-0.00782804,
-0.015540625,
0.0188510343,
-0.063087292,
-0.0198921487,
-0.0664222166,
0.0306867454,
2.095477097e-34,
0.0369280316,
-0.0713766962,
0.0294179507,
0.0873152688,
0.0104733789,
-0.0601748526,
0.0161483362,
0.032357417,
0.0171413906,
-0.0591384619,
-0.0456008986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12539v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12539v2 | CALM : A Multi-task Benchmark for Comprehensive Assessment of Language Model Bias | 2023-08-24T03:53:55 | 2024-01-24T01:09:01 | Vipul Gupta, Pranav Narayanan Venkit, Hugo Laurençon, Shomir Wilson, Rebecca J. Passonneau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | As language models (LMs) become increasingly powerful and widely used, it is
important to quantify them for sociodemographic bias with potential for harm.
Prior measures of bias are sensitive to perturbations in the templates designed
to compare performance across social groups, due to factors such as low
diversity or limited number of templates. Also, most previous work considers
only one NLP task. We introduce Comprehensive Assessment of Language Models
(CALM) for robust measurement of two types of universally relevant
sociodemographic bias, gender and race. CALM integrates sixteen datasets for
question-answering, sentiment analysis and natural language inference. Examples
from each dataset are filtered to produce 224 templates with high diversity
(e.g., length, vocabulary). We assemble 50 highly frequent person names for
each of seven distinct demographic groups to generate 78,400 prompts covering
the three NLP tasks. Our empirical evaluation shows that CALM bias scores are
more robust and far less sensitive than previous bias measurements to
perturbations in the templates, such as synonym substitution, or to random
subset selection of templates. We apply CALM to 20 large language models, and
find that for 2 language model series, larger parameter models tend to be more
biased than smaller ones. The T0 series is the least biased model families, of
the 20 LLMs investigated here. The code is available at
https://github.com/vipulgupta1011/CALM. | [
0.0488564335,
0.0781306773,
-0.0216267016,
0.0318899862,
-0.0112354029,
0.0295658074,
0.0436305851,
0.0027679857,
0.0265792347,
-0.0738626495,
-0.0209102128,
-0.0338629037,
0.0186611246,
-0.0007997102,
0.0283070337,
-0.056053713,
0.0425934903,
0.0264833514,
0.0444470011,
-0.0407308526,
0.0203596465,
0.0247636996,
0.0266229082,
0.0447898246,
0.0022945001,
-0.0198735073,
0.066013515,
0.0157138053,
0.0153506985,
0.0087819211,
0.0589698516,
0.0946570113,
-0.0391226783,
0.0390813276,
0.000001807,
-0.0782657415,
0.0182141401,
-0.0039547407,
-0.0102769583,
-0.0008984577,
0.0828237161,
0.0041538114,
0.0020099361,
0.0354517177,
-0.047385484,
-0.0192780998,
0.0400254689,
0.018096799,
0.0330029614,
0.0260735471,
-0.002053458,
0.0002828969,
-0.0445685536,
-0.0237831436,
-0.0130413426,
-0.0166791491,
0.0521757379,
-0.0126432115,
-0.0342280567,
-0.0042266082,
-0.0069485269,
0.0250705834,
-0.0056565576,
0.0249013882,
0.0301627964,
0.0125534572,
-0.0273937657,
-0.0291289221,
0.0217799116,
0.0640714914,
-0.0004708697,
-0.0367756635,
-0.0008987565,
-0.0024753762,
0.0299482215,
0.0360243283,
-0.0397053771,
0.0170424152,
0.0178287514,
-0.0055091861,
0.0173234232,
-0.009097077,
0.0426345356,
0.0660178363,
0.0246114917,
0.0704676583,
0.0349101983,
-0.0201183967,
0.0057513001,
0.0340984464,
0.0278182384,
-0.0662725568,
-0.0008964743,
-0.0443683192,
-0.0296449102,
0.0218946487,
-0.0258266069,
-0.0203923862,
0.0437428318,
-0.0874776617,
0.0188761298,
0.0063900026,
0.0068502249,
0.0386376455,
-0.0005770776,
0.0094611384,
-0.0048715589,
0.0108485157,
-0.0116041228,
-0.0429209024,
-0.0142153287,
-0.0053627724,
0.0196535252,
-0.0165659394,
-0.0117092496,
0.0342486054,
-0.033356566,
-0.0020739981,
-0.0608566329,
-0.0218377691,
0.0144790383,
0.026088791,
-0.00086084,
0.0046303747,
-0.0546906106,
0.0157574378,
-0.0657248497,
0.0196550824,
-0.021233201,
-0.1022097692,
0.0054473602,
-0.0149486391,
-0.00267392,
-0.0597283617,
0.0072623817,
0.0245272424,
0.0374623872,
-0.0303753857,
-0.0279652663,
-0.0140681211,
-0.0089950738,
-0.0515635051,
-0.0344145112,
-0.0768031031,
0.0460825935,
0.0374836065,
0.0155961644,
-0.0448914506,
-0.0076165362,
0.0415773764,
-0.0797603577,
0.0348058343,
0.0128923636,
0.0263559241,
0.0476684682,
0.0170213785,
-0.0181510597,
0.1097483709,
0.0047256928,
-0.0237812717,
0.0590968728,
-0.0093081584,
0.0007466094,
0.03905553,
-0.0082417857,
0.0311908089,
-0.0111324452,
0.0229304433,
-0.0080977865,
-0.0296788178,
0.0588511378,
0.0504241399,
0.0006935019,
-0.0480554812,
0.0491183102,
0.0484983586,
-0.0141745266,
0.0370399877,
0.0154102901,
0.0159481838,
0.014178955,
-0.0187499151,
-0.0598099567,
-0.0089170784,
-0.0505923033,
-0.0366836712,
0.0152504742,
0.0378053747,
-0.0261672754,
-0.0041014166,
-0.0314973108,
0.02469166,
0.0420561247,
0.0132918311,
0.0062728589,
-0.0057394877,
0.0134798633,
0.0819568262,
0.0421791486,
-0.0524791479,
-0.0016123205,
-0.0207154341,
0.0096578281,
0.0329548605,
-0.0037682308,
-0.0002720708,
-0.0117447209,
-0.0203875862,
-0.0101601789,
0.0315326639,
0.058992099,
-0.0061344146,
0.027792614,
-0.0349961035,
-0.0070304642,
0.0555796772,
0.0484961644,
0.0292945988,
0.099842824,
0.0297469515,
0.0181990638,
-0.0604073144,
-0.0567819662,
0.0165124796,
-0.0255443603,
-0.0317532569,
-0.0017351263,
-0.0122369276,
0.0435601696,
0.0275639147,
-0.037537083,
-0.0061859996,
-0.0232361834,
0.0012596365,
-0.0094207469,
0.004218393,
-0.04802946,
-0.027741218,
0.0079054981,
-0.0627861694,
-0.0586282685,
0.0675983727,
-0.0348940231,
-0.0093335267,
0.0394870639,
-0.0170905255,
0.0112040248,
-0.0103994086,
-0.0110590961,
-0.0403183736,
0.040079318,
-0.043475993,
0.0596528277,
-0.0150201693,
0.0295266788,
0.0330649689,
-0.0011818522,
-0.0088266656,
-0.0452866778,
-0.0543103479,
-0.0099600311,
-0.009388647,
-0.011081594,
0.0351990536,
-0.0204082839,
-0.0518554226,
-0.0234312788,
-0.1090274677,
0.0017614554,
-0.0242223255,
0.0024055198,
0.0227458589,
0.0246003028,
-0.0379115976,
-0.0167142246,
-0.0292163491,
-0.0346544124,
0.0167029444,
0.0707945153,
0.0115637016,
-0.0328158624,
0.0123195723,
-0.0624914058,
-0.033327356,
-0.0358827524,
0.0762608349,
0.0176058877,
-0.0112388181,
-0.0272086263,
0.0057931999,
-0.0479710326,
-0.0045394073,
0.0067057014,
-0.0230068117,
-0.0067315386,
0.0443648845,
0.0500754304,
0.0785697922,
0.0347873867,
-0.0270064436,
0.0233140569,
-0.0054493635,
-0.0607618392,
-0.0276730135,
-0.0045508663,
0.0084288465,
0.0080290791,
-0.0886171609,
-0.0064709443,
0.0565319993,
0.0214814357,
-0.024535859,
-0.0460765399,
0.0171949118,
-0.0441866517,
-0.0414650068,
-0.0256249383,
-0.00939014,
-0.019537013,
0.0092209335,
-0.0632495284,
-0.0625947863,
0.0308347717,
0.0028068384,
0.0138541181,
-0.0129527068,
-0.0147132976,
-0.0626245886,
0.0306312665,
-0.0118047073,
0.0166611671,
0.0070796851,
-0.006680205,
-0.0525695458,
-0.0437179022,
0.0246199369,
-0.0373726301,
0.0336086638,
-0.0170283131,
-0.0020745755,
-0.0037489743,
-0.0436129458,
-0.0426416285,
-0.0584739186,
-0.0461748019,
0.0097635118,
0.0508607253,
-0.0138102127,
0.0244334862,
-0.0293770768,
0.0019687139,
-0.0176610649,
-0.0179828051,
0.0074580009,
0.0142802075,
0.038220983,
0.0519502349,
-0.0107495077,
0.0493803248,
-0.0124377767,
0.0014755413,
0.0170438476,
0.0301868971,
0.0184037555,
-0.0124265198,
0.0064067189,
0.0432140008,
-0.0434887558,
-0.01980385,
-0.0054285275,
0.0580136441,
-0.0192306414,
0.0293127839,
0.1174927354,
0.0062850234,
-0.0640761331,
-0.0009273843,
-0.0106645674,
0.0318730772,
0.0369960479,
-0.0086101154,
-0.0601640418,
-0.0110927429,
0.0331863835,
-0.0062145204,
-0.0199395139,
-0.0507527553,
-0.0091127539,
-0.1224021465,
-0.007661399,
-0.015917534,
-0.0189725999,
0.0082310848,
-0.0606122315,
0.0315851644,
-0.0401495583,
0.0336977728,
-0.0166590624,
0.0079316664,
0.017841503,
0.0070202625,
-0.0732788518,
-0.0590454862,
0.0682619736,
-0.0596900806,
0.0534998216,
0.036967665,
0.0449822135,
-0.0368312895,
-0.0062738298,
0.067464143,
-0.0154531235,
-0.0191126,
-0.0334345289,
0.0499411114,
-0.0402356088,
-0.0080894586,
-0.0590118393,
0.0387765877,
-0.017861126,
0.0229434557,
-0.0107019702,
0.0239768252,
0.0635476857,
-0.0293720979,
-0.0417072549,
-0.0128287487,
6.636e-7,
0.1001939178,
0.0267888419,
-0.0301313922,
-0.0267319493,
-0.0345762894,
-0.0141131561,
0.0170287229,
-0.0526464768,
0.0049246014,
0.0014096244,
-0.0413272902,
-0.0182786677,
-0.0461471938,
0.0239112359,
-0.004482273,
-0.0092358626,
-0.0067302263,
0.0053036273,
-0.0165883135,
-0.0289001316,
0.0623226874,
-0.034093909,
0.0396816693,
-0.0201106854,
-0.0121824238,
0.0027102155,
0.0094969394,
-0.0272104237,
-0.0006026014,
-0.0977069959,
-0.064166069,
0.062032789,
0.029003147,
0.0205526371,
0.0320919044,
-0.0163192861,
-0.0775683075,
0.0435955077,
0.0282156728,
0.0028241854,
0.0306832939,
0.0101002548,
0.0085306875,
0.0284868442,
0.0437103584,
-0.0549539477,
0.026158981,
0.0486193635,
0.0162324142,
-0.0185507666,
-0.0539475866,
-0.0289104432,
0.0159370229,
0.0408265851,
-0.0146721937,
-0.0109439082,
-0.0248896759,
-0.0538229421,
0.0000801472,
-0.0427707508,
0.0060806298,
-0.0058072275,
0.0293444153,
0.0097003253,
-0.0429845937,
0.0056596869,
-0.0354520269,
0.0363370962,
-0.0348897055,
0.0370220542,
-0.0204948038,
0.0094812019,
0.00405112,
-0.0023299975,
-0.0308397692,
0.0188192073,
-0.035844814,
0.022093026,
0.0309091005,
0.0270777754,
-0.0011591025,
0.0076361983,
-0.0084880739,
0.0086291479,
-0.0642374381,
-0.0166947413,
0.0044894051,
0.0157760046,
0.0364567377,
-0.044917468,
0.0565191358,
0.0042441254,
-0.0084007969,
-0.0177085288,
-0.0184626933,
0.0109244352,
-0.0120080654,
0.0327436477,
0.0046671405,
-0.021594245,
0.0282492768,
0.0795598924,
0.0222480483,
0.0270695928,
0.0155492127,
-0.0500975102,
-0.0066188718,
-0.0080600725,
0.0230625328,
-0.01840421,
-0.0266936235,
-0.0208705906,
-0.0945976004,
-0.0754170641,
0.0140405223,
-0.0169221498,
0.0289696753,
0.0080745313,
0.0137317954,
0.0640019476,
-0.0132056959,
-0.0046524294,
-0.0395087712,
0.0131050898,
-0.0331347026,
0.0010197347,
-0.0269012861,
-6.640010531e-33,
-0.0019350039,
-0.0165918954,
-0.0471684076,
-0.0493351743,
-0.0130118402,
0.0259118062,
-0.0162627771,
0.0387941413,
-0.0599949248,
0.0284133628,
-0.0119982297,
0.0298994668,
0.0204622932,
0.0136521719,
0.0084500611,
-0.0368665867,
0.0236868169,
0.0281885955,
-0.0107969819,
-0.0150859784,
-0.0016556145,
0.0251595862,
0.0359311663,
-0.047116138,
0.0814995542,
0.0009326002,
0.0262967404,
0.0074244738,
-0.0043857419,
0.035068851,
-0.0176726207,
0.0954651833,
0.0442308523,
-0.0288903397,
-0.0020281405,
0.0532447882,
-0.0506286174,
-0.0511682257,
0.0350485407,
0.0203451645,
0.0013511941,
-0.0217001438,
0.028768776,
0.0248997733,
-0.0821560472,
-0.0188412666,
0.0453587994,
-0.0042761788,
0.0242605004,
-0.0024106172,
-0.0078294519,
0.0475636534,
-0.002513757,
0.0143742636,
-0.0374640934,
0.0428985879,
0.0014698202,
0.0349004641,
-0.0322020873,
-0.0029103155,
0.0166600756,
0.0032295175,
0.0389122367,
0.0314171799,
0.0184126589,
0.064238824,
0.0452007875,
0.0623526834,
-0.0387339443,
-0.058593493,
0.0224135909,
-0.0081638061,
0.0344336592,
0.0800887123,
0.0249097906,
0.0062224111,
-0.0357576869,
-0.0076692388,
0.0429585613,
0.0287505873,
0.0597523972,
-0.0290246401,
-0.0745704919,
-0.041496858,
-0.0589881204,
-0.0590737164,
-0.0260127354,
-0.0089600291,
0.0483520813,
-0.0003318235,
-0.0220341049,
-0.016991334,
0.0125750126,
-0.0508880168,
-0.0162037499,
0.0430472642,
-0.0059624254,
-0.0354731753,
0.0399888121,
0.034954112,
-0.0467125028,
0.0264568385,
-0.0120362258,
0.0466593318,
0.0107639115,
-0.0061760461,
-0.0063994844,
-0.0067496691,
-0.0744173005,
-0.0084014963,
-0.0159834139,
-0.0115467655,
-0.0141504696,
0.0284334701,
0.0462115631,
0.0157668144,
-0.0072252196,
0.0061784019,
0.0518246926,
0.0170215927,
-0.0034491397,
0.0031006036,
-0.0210319757,
0.0235777479,
-0.0192445256,
-0.0136891482,
-0.023299804,
0.0107002836,
0.0309726447,
-0.0155256717,
-0.0096702268,
-0.0274084173,
2.456e-7,
0.0222621579,
0.0649970099,
-0.0127744032,
0.0365633667,
0.0111784087,
0.0361927301,
0.0352631472,
0.0521294698,
0.0429420434,
0.006926537,
-0.0494905226,
0.0198268276,
0.0396609604,
0.036148008,
-0.0849229023,
0.0074187284,
-0.1055583805,
0.0383876339,
-0.0079531176,
0.0051788525,
0.013482295,
0.0829731151,
0.031515561,
0.0110459458,
-0.0325418711,
-0.0203011893,
0.037123397,
-0.0632505417,
-0.0096979849,
0.0069130552,
0.0222383328,
0.0066753575,
0.0461464338,
0.0377508551,
-0.0037179759,
0.0195293091,
0.0009229907,
0.0318076797,
-0.0131867267,
0.0142827695,
-0.0267726108,
-0.0360228643,
-0.0101339044,
-0.0893116519,
0.0874237046,
0.0189622901,
-0.0196286943,
-0.0867551565,
-0.027343927,
0.0103338547,
0.0745081082,
-0.0154164517,
-0.0400829241,
-0.0064924476,
0.0304145049,
-0.0122367796,
-0.0370017029,
-0.0610252693,
-0.0378112458,
-0.0165777523,
-0.018848991,
-0.0811394602,
-0.0026967518,
0.0356728025,
-0.0070138988,
-0.0349834822,
0.0416259728,
2.249898943e-34,
0.0113768755,
0.0288441721,
0.0284941383,
-0.0126148472,
0.0467272848,
0.0035725888,
-0.0224225894,
-0.0206990261,
0.042435538,
-0.0560214035,
0.0157752428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12531v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12531v2 | CARE: Co-Attention Network for Joint Entity and Relation Extraction | 2023-08-24T03:40:54 | 2024-03-27T13:46:37 | Wenjun Kong, Yamei Xia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Joint entity and relation extraction is the fundamental task of information
extraction, consisting of two subtasks: named entity recognition and relation
extraction. However, most existing joint extraction methods suffer from issues
of feature confusion or inadequate interaction between the two subtasks.
Addressing these challenges, in this work, we propose a Co-Attention network
for joint entity and Relation Extraction (CARE). Our approach includes adopting
a parallel encoding strategy to learn separate representations for each
subtask, aiming to avoid feature overlap or confusion. At the core of our
approach is the co-attention module that captures two-way interaction between
the two subtasks, allowing the model to leverage entity information for
relation prediction and vice versa, thus promoting mutual enhancement. Through
extensive experiments on three benchmark datasets for joint entity and relation
extraction (NYT, WebNLG, and SciERC), we demonstrate that our proposed model
outperforms existing baseline models. Our code will be available at
https://github.com/kwj0x7f/CARE. | [
0.0281246062,
0.0461549424,
0.0223993436,
0.0691017658,
-0.001737612,
0.0487825312,
-0.0170195624,
-0.0168994702,
0.0192826577,
-0.0124207977,
-0.0547356531,
-0.0154798571,
-0.022514455,
0.0241226293,
-0.0002606309,
-0.0286023524,
0.0484586619,
0.0272006951,
0.0393776856,
0.0341084525,
-0.0144109894,
0.0126990275,
-0.009775619,
-0.02472312,
-0.0247053951,
-0.0339302383,
0.0154221309,
0.0033935115,
0.0364741795,
-0.0429814458,
0.0439656153,
0.0286253151,
-0.0030298424,
0.0338454992,
0.0000017415,
-0.0273805745,
-0.0109410305,
0.0158048254,
-0.0330565907,
-0.0104014995,
-0.0260768887,
-0.0457224771,
0.0198757946,
-0.0250340067,
-0.0366039202,
-0.0691619664,
0.0240693446,
0.0674297214,
0.0269571338,
0.0433247276,
-0.0140369134,
-0.0206892733,
0.0588307455,
-0.0672204345,
-0.0041184961,
-0.0319734067,
0.0279173739,
-0.0039998158,
-0.0371553972,
0.0085782465,
-0.0021532897,
0.0464757383,
0.0440973863,
0.0148351071,
0.0297358073,
0.0768024474,
-0.0305518918,
-0.0327992924,
-0.0126850354,
0.120594047,
-0.0245010499,
0.0337020345,
0.0144137265,
0.0104373032,
0.004160217,
-0.0059592677,
-0.004150786,
-0.0235938076,
-0.0313244984,
0.0170165766,
0.0126316156,
0.0163793787,
0.0307000838,
0.0048918966,
-0.0269471109,
0.018170245,
-0.0087595591,
-0.0264355037,
0.0249561816,
0.0416538753,
0.0018211501,
-0.0196713619,
0.0501328111,
0.0272825565,
0.0092856344,
0.0218447875,
-0.0335032865,
-0.0537906103,
-0.0043841531,
-0.0849619806,
-0.0104824165,
0.0060434244,
-0.0460172556,
0.0851664245,
-0.0684918165,
0.0030289148,
-0.0177524034,
0.0063850349,
0.0171932857,
-0.0241540261,
-0.021836143,
0.0079004364,
-0.0243601687,
0.0647665113,
-0.0470553152,
-0.0095011713,
-0.0249183439,
-0.0046224864,
-0.0179591682,
0.0409241989,
0.0311055873,
0.0147306714,
-0.0301563796,
-0.0322410688,
0.0298691001,
0.0340035148,
-0.0599641614,
-0.0004761601,
-0.0032015308,
-0.0090932148,
-0.0417738818,
-0.0134496018,
0.0402167886,
-0.0632107779,
0.0168343261,
0.1042255163,
0.0156644359,
-0.0439665727,
-0.0105058532,
-0.0310027599,
0.0143000986,
-0.0611207373,
0.0196387339,
-0.005522727,
0.0913714245,
0.0143711511,
-0.0171576068,
-0.0159873776,
0.0278000776,
-0.0136071015,
-0.0908836797,
0.0546692535,
-0.0165997725,
-0.0523958877,
-0.0060136444,
0.0281886421,
0.0233474858,
0.0689254552,
0.054025434,
0.0149551686,
0.0298547037,
0.028378645,
-0.0505634844,
0.0093997614,
0.0388781652,
-0.036383681,
0.0577922575,
0.0261782948,
0.0272704605,
0.0134707438,
0.078690365,
0.041471947,
-0.0226417519,
-0.0439283624,
0.0063717118,
-0.0119427824,
0.0433309451,
0.0476454161,
0.0622933991,
-0.0146810021,
-0.0036226269,
0.0186324976,
-0.0708012357,
0.0477185845,
0.0036386061,
0.029488977,
-0.0138843711,
0.0785685033,
-0.0279153883,
0.0054735048,
0.0520529747,
-0.0381348394,
-0.0199633874,
0.0216011684,
0.0670090392,
0.023723783,
-0.0575265661,
0.0474423394,
0.0673362762,
-0.0166166611,
0.0122512113,
0.0132438289,
-0.0022862165,
0.0239473861,
0.0132281948,
-0.0403652266,
-0.0500727482,
-0.0221898127,
-0.0362318605,
0.0120707415,
0.026811216,
-0.016932901,
0.0514206998,
-0.034465827,
-0.0409357995,
0.0134471254,
0.0087295668,
0.0035831374,
0.0280592386,
0.0154571515,
0.0410646982,
0.0387171507,
-0.0015654843,
0.02464086,
-0.041915793,
-0.0254022926,
-0.0166165121,
0.0346350297,
0.0117879948,
0.0475580245,
0.0057928753,
-0.0103043457,
0.0442252792,
-0.0360971764,
0.0166997444,
-0.0078342706,
-0.0460086428,
-0.0687678829,
0.0150265116,
0.0143716391,
-0.0464657396,
-0.010454813,
-0.0122184064,
-0.0113810608,
-0.0102341855,
0.02844413,
0.0565623529,
-0.0069942502,
-0.0196521301,
0.0654976517,
0.0390241854,
-0.0252051447,
0.0878087953,
-0.0188879259,
-0.0128106577,
0.0287851039,
-0.0504438169,
-0.0360238776,
-0.0006646289,
-0.0122087011,
0.0065672537,
0.0028808624,
-0.0450220741,
-0.0213287808,
-0.00126116,
-0.0887708217,
-0.0347574055,
-0.0346369147,
0.0214734543,
-0.0000730486,
0.0648566261,
-0.0034992907,
0.0339838266,
-0.0105331205,
-0.0109468391,
0.0013179643,
0.01624557,
-0.0627534091,
-0.0084134024,
0.0203437302,
0.0406840518,
0.0213699751,
-0.0286880229,
-0.0214597117,
-0.0306928121,
0.0559929535,
0.0145264585,
-0.0471565202,
-0.0198770631,
0.0142943813,
-0.0149982944,
0.0207281671,
0.0032549885,
0.0047752624,
-0.0528582409,
-0.0062661199,
0.003888045,
0.0467021428,
-0.0211663805,
0.0627362579,
-0.0231617615,
-0.0286330134,
-0.0446351394,
0.0629145429,
-0.0311115589,
0.0638503134,
0.0027343114,
0.0153586399,
-0.0059771673,
0.0857297033,
-0.0454179458,
0.0118014757,
-0.0232839547,
-0.0045233625,
0.0341530479,
0.0025947606,
0.0121484809,
0.0429432839,
-0.0014302558,
-0.0412829593,
-0.074380599,
0.0092622908,
0.0907657221,
0.0004179614,
-0.0359822735,
-0.0074494728,
0.0322387889,
-0.0602715425,
0.0663282573,
-0.0084863398,
0.0108946059,
0.0089498442,
-0.0591798611,
-0.0346064009,
0.0288935211,
-0.0071872859,
-0.0157319494,
0.0283490233,
0.021091599,
0.0092729554,
-0.0242535714,
-0.0082378611,
-0.0313241854,
-0.0140377264,
-0.046297498,
0.0265654512,
-0.0133756381,
-0.0177932102,
0.0016634505,
-0.0035399501,
0.0011291667,
0.0329716578,
-0.0101231169,
-0.0010054206,
-0.0341437273,
0.0552696772,
0.040236,
0.0389510356,
0.0067520132,
-0.0011757525,
0.0003343227,
0.0595906973,
-0.0002453575,
-0.0189793389,
0.022971753,
-0.007407411,
0.0109377829,
-0.0624657199,
0.0158118736,
-0.0475809537,
0.0225408413,
-0.0691203699,
-0.0111291967,
0.0845410675,
0.0050960989,
-0.0555078089,
-0.0048294654,
0.0315342881,
0.0111715477,
0.0185743328,
0.0336648151,
-0.066398792,
-0.0419072285,
-0.0162880085,
-0.0140187023,
0.0654642358,
-0.0581845231,
-0.0103096096,
-0.0626219213,
-0.024821775,
0.0067513897,
-0.0457327627,
-0.0501227155,
-0.0387549289,
0.0353098139,
-0.0040901843,
0.000900952,
0.0201130323,
-0.0277419798,
-0.0020598099,
-0.0061033699,
0.0368336812,
-0.0548689365,
0.0177826937,
-0.0476213619,
0.0455751456,
0.0398829095,
0.0207350887,
-0.0017926348,
0.0094259344,
-0.0002857615,
-0.0621702373,
-0.0350007154,
-0.0339961722,
0.0816377476,
-0.0679206401,
-0.010558255,
-0.023333665,
-0.0011563149,
-0.0621371791,
-0.0094960844,
0.0151907187,
0.0697501749,
0.0165054519,
-0.044451721,
0.0201149415,
-0.0259307735,
0.032849852,
0.0727136284,
0.0451068319,
-0.0131897684,
-0.0191142019,
0.0183565244,
0.0009308519,
-0.0531475842,
0.0099193444,
-0.0202664826,
-0.0397920907,
-0.0256251581,
-0.0312386695,
-0.0964042023,
0.042409461,
-0.0109703597,
0.0044112476,
-0.0028295789,
0.0276383646,
-0.003056509,
-0.059548445,
0.032415133,
-0.0120298173,
-0.003759528,
-0.012210587,
-0.0126227811,
0.0082040373,
-0.0205147993,
-0.0346581563,
-0.0153660085,
-0.0618550293,
-0.0385030247,
0.0013827689,
0.0286936574,
0.0119135287,
0.0679517612,
-0.0286923647,
-0.0224404149,
-0.0176535975,
0.0377549231,
-0.0891587883,
-0.0191119611,
0.0240048356,
-0.022349,
-0.009972658,
0.0350699052,
-0.0232339855,
0.0107825045,
0.014172079,
0.0456801467,
-0.0478103235,
-0.0350367203,
-0.0134936944,
-0.0185132008,
0.0790856481,
0.0082178367,
0.0292760488,
-0.0699853748,
0.0331044123,
0.002519276,
0.010947492,
-0.0445166156,
0.0148421396,
-0.0063382722,
-0.02391758,
-0.0103474455,
0.0235714205,
0.0202717427,
-0.0198346712,
-0.0477535166,
-0.0077551692,
-0.0143045587,
0.0205888916,
0.0086189304,
-0.0322279334,
-0.0100126993,
0.0202567503,
0.0344157293,
0.0204845704,
-0.0346024111,
-0.0026740066,
0.0144246118,
-0.0176034383,
-0.012459944,
0.0009599662,
-0.0480251573,
0.0371003896,
-0.0390249491,
0.0472107157,
0.0527909808,
-0.0264857654,
0.0308507271,
-0.005890667,
-0.0076991776,
0.0152076427,
0.0291805211,
-0.0314583629,
0.0162922572,
0.0193959661,
0.0085711665,
-0.0239928775,
-0.0121286456,
0.0822697282,
-0.0180542637,
0.0472404882,
0.0289029628,
-0.0184301361,
-0.0461859182,
-0.024998486,
-0.0203417502,
0.0047166473,
-0.050480742,
0.021148134,
-0.0295380466,
-0.0532027557,
0.0057411818,
-0.0328027643,
-0.032737948,
0.0200054441,
0.0159640703,
-0.014281949,
0.0246679671,
-0.0562687628,
-0.0222035386,
0.0472369827,
-0.0036241137,
-0.0261763092,
0.006229694,
-6.256214565e-33,
-0.0614603236,
-0.0045932736,
0.0153676923,
-0.0027865116,
-0.0595351756,
0.0476499125,
-0.0418320708,
-0.0091583673,
-0.0442586169,
0.0099208746,
-0.0051610381,
0.0233046282,
0.0084638409,
0.0114438944,
-0.0057417732,
-0.0429194644,
0.0259698834,
0.0382934175,
0.0236791428,
0.0365022868,
0.0125031713,
0.083663635,
0.0846641213,
-0.1023378223,
0.0282584839,
0.000667654,
0.04077667,
0.0066616489,
0.0242144763,
0.0505504794,
-0.0192209352,
0.0068184347,
0.0279142205,
-0.013339648,
0.0040305909,
0.0287248585,
-0.1923691928,
-0.0223121606,
-0.0330566391,
-0.0011532817,
-0.0607848689,
-0.0369820818,
0.0325199664,
0.0203917306,
0.0891841874,
-0.0743189901,
0.0248420574,
-0.013921557,
-0.0171972029,
-0.0362530202,
-0.0347430371,
0.0280734152,
0.0252768844,
0.0060590999,
0.0507282503,
0.0130734611,
0.0453152992,
0.0166102275,
-0.0615723729,
-0.048080489,
-0.0259654764,
0.0110379141,
0.0253361072,
0.0292974208,
-0.02376201,
0.0492463708,
-0.0225251373,
-0.0063607558,
-0.0338039994,
-0.0050441669,
-0.0159467533,
0.0551883653,
-0.0241869111,
-0.0095828194,
0.0176777653,
-0.0067796172,
-0.0990239605,
0.0029233859,
0.030911658,
0.0612987503,
-0.0358091816,
-0.0187028684,
-0.0153332669,
0.0185588524,
0.0168067608,
0.0036490448,
-0.0313474089,
-0.0214191042,
-0.0177420769,
0.0106794471,
-0.0247405153,
0.0782685354,
-0.0020702309,
-0.0294003692,
-0.0308073815,
0.0315855369,
0.0354734808,
-0.0042587756,
0.0090348031,
-0.0027017535,
-0.0543397665,
-0.0200796481,
-0.0109715192,
-0.0093353195,
0.0111349057,
0.0292475857,
0.0866220593,
-0.0605288967,
-0.0334733389,
-0.0317552127,
-0.0359782241,
0.0131765185,
0.0013718202,
0.012919751,
0.0177830197,
0.0218317732,
-0.0174820404,
0.0162637308,
0.0738693327,
0.0449913666,
-0.0359524526,
0.0426277891,
0.0302123632,
0.0407195389,
0.0254279915,
-0.0168065764,
-0.0216138866,
0.0118465954,
0.0012630268,
-0.0572765991,
-0.0230956711,
0.0177589096,
2.455e-7,
0.0389630161,
0.0121820094,
0.0441067405,
-0.0007242512,
0.012785323,
0.0256991535,
0.0288993362,
0.0647917762,
-0.0073091006,
-0.0256998036,
-0.000250386,
0.0101779504,
-0.0035395373,
0.0080348821,
-0.0616973117,
-0.0510190502,
-0.0375150852,
-0.0190896057,
-0.0517103262,
-0.023716528,
0.0528347567,
0.0534154847,
0.0264673941,
0.0208187066,
-0.0079467762,
0.0074049905,
0.0589641221,
-0.0032564786,
0.011003213,
0.0515362136,
-0.0124319978,
0.0155898407,
-0.0337936878,
0.0371054187,
-0.0360141657,
0.0294169672,
0.0325343199,
0.0619432554,
-0.0000258967,
-0.0230875704,
0.0148998378,
-0.0152002899,
0.010834964,
-0.0042611118,
0.0732810795,
-0.0876758173,
-0.0229412653,
0.0059351935,
-0.0355027914,
0.0363492258,
-0.0263952054,
0.0200303663,
-0.0027580762,
0.0267706309,
0.0189263597,
-0.0208354928,
-0.0402275138,
-0.079575561,
-0.0140047641,
0.0456417613,
-0.0135524254,
-0.0066488297,
-0.0273301993,
-0.0569508001,
0.0193096604,
-0.0410965905,
-0.0074137487,
2.068411798e-34,
-0.0283864737,
0.0143898008,
-0.0037625965,
0.0592394769,
0.0003222978,
-0.0505825058,
-0.0681721717,
0.0031708386,
0.0104220705,
-0.0447879732,
0.0056590401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12519v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12519v2 | Rational Decision-Making Agent with Internalized Utility Judgment | 2023-08-24T03:11:45 | 2024-01-17T13:09:30 | Yining Ye, Xin Cong, Shizuo Tian, Yujia Qin, Chong Liu, Yankai Lin, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable advancements and
have attracted significant efforts to develop LLMs into agents capable of
executing intricate multi-step decision-making tasks beyond traditional NLP
applications. Existing approaches to LLM-based decision-making predominantly
build upon the manually-designed external performance metrics to guide the
decision-making process. However, reliance on the external performance metrics
as prior is problematic in real-world scenarios, where such prior may be
unavailable, flawed, or even erroneous. For genuine autonomous decision making,
it is imperative for the agent to develop its rationality from its posterior
experiences to judge decisions independently. Central to the development of
rationality is the construction of an internalized utility judgment, capable of
assigning numerical utilities to each decision. This paper proposes RadAgent
(Rational Decision-Making Agent), which fosters the development of its
rationality through an iterative framework involving Experience Exploration and
Utility Learning. Within this framework, Elo-based Utility Construction is
devised to assign Elo scores to individual decision steps to judge their
utilities via pairwise comparisons. Consequently, these Elo scores guide the
decision-making process to derive optimal outcomes. Experimental results on the
ToolBench dataset demonstrate RadAgent's superiority over baselines, achieving
over 10% improvement in Pass Rate on diverse tasks. It offers higher-quality
solutions and reduces costs (ChatGPT API calls), highlighting its effectiveness
and efficiency. | [
0.0078130206,
0.0582569279,
-0.0046258331,
0.0114733214,
-0.0295096543,
0.0109904986,
-0.0326772667,
-0.0127264876,
0.0376459844,
-0.0301637109,
-0.05653565,
0.0125070577,
-0.0259629972,
0.0378343239,
-0.0124827577,
-0.0189678352,
0.0147169847,
-0.0333326682,
0.0687381104,
-0.0186106209,
-0.0191728454,
-0.0225710031,
-0.0086594885,
0.0387667939,
0.032878384,
0.0190177839,
-0.0010683903,
-0.0373426229,
0.0388219804,
-0.044175148,
0.0033218735,
0.0385056771,
0.0374730527,
0.021385245,
0.000002377,
-0.0734190792,
-0.0325174369,
-0.0304529406,
-0.0306527875,
-0.0316922329,
0.0865402147,
0.0612987988,
0.0071802186,
0.014661463,
-0.079793267,
0.0250776093,
0.0068483478,
0.0232512616,
0.0435704775,
0.0343341082,
-0.0025921904,
-0.016388461,
-0.0154756242,
-0.0101107061,
-0.038697999,
-0.0370282345,
0.0055518821,
0.029017983,
-0.0022810095,
0.0060785394,
-0.0071918843,
-0.0134571949,
0.0295344628,
-0.0038263637,
0.0182793476,
0.0473635346,
0.015673181,
-0.0210808516,
-0.0278548412,
0.0466678701,
-0.0102063362,
0.0151927415,
0.0112538924,
-0.0171071757,
0.011726046,
-0.0312684141,
-0.0192342922,
0.0151157575,
0.0049481904,
0.049374152,
-0.0192572568,
0.0323597789,
0.0136193158,
0.041583918,
-0.0409166925,
0.089261122,
-0.0330034196,
-0.0100067714,
0.062452618,
0.0117789628,
-0.0066589778,
-0.0616192706,
0.0100636762,
0.0678073168,
-0.0498002619,
0.0234288163,
0.0278987251,
0.0179403163,
0.000442402,
-0.0758605078,
0.0359229036,
0.0360977314,
0.0399964489,
0.0143992407,
-0.055186823,
0.0577321723,
0.0461137518,
0.0137378965,
-0.0369743928,
0.0457265489,
-0.0217279792,
-0.0123473629,
-0.0114341108,
0.0621711239,
-0.0399482027,
-0.021187447,
-0.0607662611,
0.0108560761,
-0.0323973671,
0.0287027042,
0.0037000026,
0.0112023512,
0.0021497516,
-0.0010148709,
-0.1273636073,
-0.0264905337,
-0.0205942504,
0.0311753936,
0.0099467412,
0.0157020465,
0.0405944772,
-0.0262128301,
-0.032488998,
-0.0081054308,
0.0183956102,
0.1149685383,
-0.0072456966,
-0.0414080285,
-0.048074007,
-0.0150382584,
0.0144370906,
-0.0693425015,
-0.0214866307,
-0.0640742704,
-0.0091376593,
-0.0066151042,
-0.0198951792,
-0.060810823,
0.0175798927,
-0.00466388,
-0.0025142124,
0.0693113431,
0.041999314,
0.0006096996,
0.0107853813,
-0.011117938,
0.0109687485,
0.074808605,
0.0525000915,
0.055683706,
0.0085399384,
-0.0114288339,
-0.0016318704,
0.0084776357,
-0.0220688973,
0.0083479518,
-0.0491371192,
0.0033603467,
-0.0412024744,
0.0390023366,
0.0333896242,
0.0049927975,
-0.0320958719,
0.012354929,
0.0821344033,
0.0193965677,
0.0404404961,
-0.0259399209,
0.0072136777,
0.030010961,
-0.0142300986,
-0.0399888232,
-0.0229682382,
0.0479427502,
-0.0104606235,
-0.003261708,
0.0242755413,
0.0090500144,
-0.0150380516,
-0.0582197532,
0.0387300551,
-0.0161742214,
0.0532743372,
0.0415850431,
0.0397914201,
-0.0461999364,
-0.047997918,
-0.030911807,
0.0229600742,
-0.0157221407,
-0.0367763564,
-0.1011534706,
0.0571381859,
0.0969162062,
0.0428915843,
-0.0004583089,
0.0035051892,
-0.0071324538,
-0.0631925836,
0.0295952018,
0.0619042814,
-0.0341724157,
-0.0229117237,
-0.0626978651,
-0.0663804114,
0.0003120795,
-0.0076688007,
0.0523722544,
0.0136662973,
0.034766227,
-0.0111273304,
-0.0363727063,
-0.0229387805,
0.0227681417,
-0.0306078475,
-0.0581437163,
0.0136889899,
-0.0138233239,
0.0437723063,
-0.0009153489,
0.0271684472,
0.0284071174,
0.0025843694,
0.0348547101,
-0.0632778332,
0.0291220285,
-0.0267165564,
0.0172932427,
0.0437993221,
-0.0148555068,
0.0097942287,
0.0188477803,
-0.0138715236,
-0.036919564,
-0.0082011316,
-0.0200154707,
0.0227821693,
-0.0286552478,
0.0124010453,
-0.0392292254,
-0.0001292807,
-0.0551775396,
0.068605274,
-0.0116206193,
0.0019353059,
-0.0031277458,
0.0231577177,
-0.0096539361,
-0.0502862558,
0.0199280903,
-0.0107070934,
0.0426556729,
0.0551065914,
0.0264625344,
0.0437782742,
-0.0172200147,
-0.0134600494,
-0.0571019277,
-0.0056244461,
0.0137006193,
0.0061603733,
-0.000477335,
-0.0599197522,
0.0042720358,
0.001770182,
0.003492841,
0.0276841316,
0.0099710338,
0.0319391005,
0.0269713588,
0.0021634693,
-0.0116376244,
-0.0451283716,
-0.01188662,
-0.0037068045,
-0.0001954221,
0.0218179934,
0.0573849194,
-0.056849245,
0.0325764678,
-0.0308445729,
0.007614831,
-0.0183557291,
-0.0406669863,
0.0127896238,
-0.0064301323,
0.0512168333,
0.074212797,
0.0291844029,
0.0334845185,
0.0852972269,
-0.0055128369,
-0.1017525122,
0.0125971586,
-0.0448626168,
-0.0062202178,
-0.0378370509,
-0.009138112,
-0.0020058018,
0.0519997105,
-0.021780489,
0.0168293789,
-0.0559853986,
0.035919562,
-0.0207801368,
-0.0730842054,
-0.0342199765,
0.0043722475,
-0.0196772665,
0.0554630682,
0.0110616796,
-0.0301993303,
0.0882829502,
0.0410200916,
0.0406326577,
-0.0693988577,
-0.0089069884,
-0.0379489213,
0.0579439178,
0.0046752915,
0.0019265314,
-0.0569119304,
-0.0025157349,
-0.0162489358,
-0.0448321402,
0.0066312905,
-0.0490115434,
0.0892805457,
-0.06850335,
-0.0015274156,
0.0053527001,
-0.0395892225,
-0.0275363717,
0.0000769315,
-0.0378201827,
0.0142564131,
0.011357815,
-0.022411095,
-0.0219354499,
0.0128932446,
0.063927941,
0.0318931341,
-0.0038640285,
-0.0353613906,
-0.0011463794,
-0.0393545367,
0.0384713151,
0.0240790676,
0.0794169828,
-0.0005477875,
0.0739867613,
0.0384665541,
0.0366682895,
-0.034324266,
-0.0259044338,
0.0215353388,
0.0160155836,
-0.059086509,
0.0138393929,
0.0556256995,
0.0269034002,
-0.0477100797,
-0.0122476993,
0.1034346744,
0.0087649198,
-0.0491412617,
0.0080944803,
-0.073612839,
0.0027090192,
0.0183310919,
0.0260398723,
-0.0240090173,
-0.0345862322,
0.0121483477,
0.0203485098,
-0.0392197818,
-0.0600901954,
0.0306479894,
-0.144157052,
0.0475010313,
-0.0109771574,
-0.0035903775,
0.0141990129,
-0.0543886758,
-0.0048355111,
-0.0463639982,
0.0027232985,
0.0289474968,
-0.0165271275,
-0.0098686684,
0.0078219147,
0.0095111774,
-0.0124568185,
0.0708336234,
-0.0116689997,
-0.0025284269,
0.0453137383,
0.0458323658,
-0.0330697224,
-0.0221360773,
-0.0114960596,
-0.005515507,
-0.0041123782,
0.0099864416,
0.0032001312,
-0.0046932921,
0.0157790408,
-0.0429313369,
0.0470687859,
-0.021600062,
-0.0148658399,
-0.0110756299,
0.0647130683,
-0.0330598205,
-0.028662771,
-0.0076786471,
0.0096130185,
0.019541394,
0.0569327027,
-0.0288926605,
-0.0777960494,
-0.0778008401,
-0.0453840308,
-0.0497548468,
-0.0503959246,
-0.0697059259,
0.0358834118,
0.00393464,
-0.0142400078,
-0.0453417711,
-0.0538477525,
0.0195070673,
0.0017533498,
0.0199168604,
-0.0260816999,
0.0091771306,
-0.0014468173,
-0.0185766239,
-0.0005333613,
-0.0195402429,
0.0382760465,
-0.0576179698,
0.0386706777,
0.0552900806,
-0.0588993952,
-0.031821236,
0.0428469516,
0.0272125304,
-0.0449900366,
0.0012426991,
0.0769025013,
0.0368230455,
-0.0035030674,
-0.0145658264,
-0.0205668341,
0.0332807228,
0.0154586136,
-0.0442367159,
0.0006448007,
0.0522721894,
0.0607092865,
0.014563797,
0.0369414799,
-0.033520963,
0.0349333026,
-0.0012505678,
0.0383121036,
-0.0265976824,
-0.0446200967,
0.0358088799,
-0.011773169,
-0.008612616,
-0.0326458178,
0.0016947313,
-0.0320691317,
0.0105657643,
-0.0145511925,
0.0026647316,
-0.0277647991,
-0.0176674686,
0.0131105548,
0.0211755931,
0.0322816148,
-0.0057886587,
0.0030654341,
-0.0316601768,
0.0078217154,
0.0416090712,
0.0515791476,
0.0298696849,
0.0456509069,
-0.0139783183,
-0.0066226567,
-0.0319812633,
0.0007088118,
0.0296117552,
0.0028616618,
0.0863449574,
0.0189766698,
-0.0308162682,
-0.005373877,
0.0222661681,
-0.0239398256,
-0.0631878227,
0.0030867234,
-0.0209860653,
0.0050119408,
0.0132754557,
0.0359503143,
-0.0750987232,
0.0112786656,
-0.0273142438,
-0.013782898,
-0.0264064949,
-0.0226104818,
0.0128618022,
0.0328680724,
-0.0229449943,
0.0027691398,
0.0625991374,
-0.0291566271,
0.0395686217,
-0.0581284761,
-0.0023861006,
-0.0472133383,
-0.0596919134,
0.0070187123,
-0.0130662052,
-0.038790457,
-0.0399777591,
-0.0650410652,
-0.0491183698,
-0.05986204,
0.0642709732,
0.0002963351,
-0.071953617,
0.0470178202,
0.0487841964,
-0.0226255115,
0.006361186,
-0.0515397079,
0.011211426,
-0.0694670603,
0.0206617694,
-0.0546895154,
-6.352048211e-33,
0.0116471574,
-0.0241868403,
0.0673425719,
-0.0145003395,
0.0190689173,
-0.030030882,
-0.0019260967,
0.0214009788,
-0.0110566979,
0.0102760317,
-0.0032491027,
-0.0126193231,
0.0117038582,
-0.0221115835,
0.0555680059,
0.0133077325,
0.0325784907,
-0.0168116502,
-0.0215368886,
-0.0301946979,
0.0107859531,
-0.0082024066,
0.0379127339,
-0.0314977318,
-0.004458,
0.0520715155,
-0.0153095275,
0.0376908183,
-0.0274198968,
0.0733016282,
-0.0139799397,
0.0149035482,
0.0147603825,
-0.0746522322,
-0.0294003058,
0.0089858053,
-0.0452634394,
-0.0262961853,
0.0024830801,
0.0017454219,
-0.0087015051,
-0.015439705,
0.0241014641,
0.0285475068,
-0.0746572092,
0.0167761855,
0.0057459008,
-0.0436206535,
-0.0112649836,
0.0113113075,
-0.026089685,
0.027260188,
-0.0021243233,
-0.0208385624,
0.0266736019,
0.0593005382,
-0.0406295322,
0.0299111083,
-0.0617590249,
0.0572249442,
0.0069803111,
-0.0188758653,
0.0682217628,
-0.0024877538,
-0.0039834604,
0.0484616719,
0.0126941465,
-0.0190079082,
-0.015971696,
0.0029745996,
0.0125240004,
0.0632458851,
0.0219783075,
0.0148109319,
-0.0164288208,
-0.0240993965,
-0.065420866,
0.0531194173,
0.0407592058,
0.0406224951,
0.057240393,
0.0405585431,
-0.0359109864,
0.0018575191,
-0.0477318987,
-0.0123140821,
-0.0307440124,
-0.0495605096,
0.0466910005,
0.0222648289,
0.0208665095,
-0.0329945199,
0.0188964214,
-0.0400270112,
-0.014850148,
-0.015932899,
-0.0357518047,
0.0351458043,
0.001119874,
0.0220981892,
-0.0670033023,
-0.0348933861,
-0.0213957392,
0.0163412895,
-0.010382833,
0.0016285871,
-0.0412521325,
0.034807276,
-0.0303721353,
0.0233975295,
-0.0304339621,
0.005008433,
0.012690573,
0.0214682352,
0.0227688868,
-0.0114259217,
-0.0112576494,
0.0452351831,
-0.0395433791,
-0.011933675,
-0.0133994492,
-0.0332148112,
0.0115892589,
0.0422060862,
-0.007396318,
0.0077755605,
-0.0404809527,
0.0050436701,
-0.0007026595,
-0.0069026081,
-0.0115398662,
0.0363947414,
3.103e-7,
-0.0140706887,
0.039925646,
-0.0181734152,
0.0088933948,
-0.0139821852,
0.0796909705,
-0.0123205539,
0.0127064371,
-0.0007622213,
-0.0113591282,
0.0330688432,
0.0228247978,
0.0228102114,
0.0353855751,
-0.0605067387,
-0.0679227337,
-0.0021220876,
-0.0085180774,
-0.0253098477,
-0.0191950742,
0.0490342043,
0.0566621274,
0.0148371411,
-0.0019936666,
-0.0032109725,
-0.0170201641,
0.0456275307,
-0.0527101569,
-0.0088082403,
0.0109566534,
0.017391352,
0.0073660105,
-0.000839231,
0.013013362,
0.0099591324,
0.0215583555,
-0.0085227108,
0.1107893512,
0.0127754081,
-0.0657484978,
0.0151932081,
-0.0264794901,
0.0269764941,
-0.0367377177,
0.0601270907,
-0.0528931618,
-0.0659648404,
0.0055989348,
-0.0121237887,
-0.0101181557,
-0.0073016705,
-0.0322535262,
-0.0214648023,
-0.0045706374,
0.011570422,
0.0141001446,
0.0028233612,
-0.0715476796,
-0.0050400519,
0.0431089774,
-0.0352043882,
-0.0375053175,
-0.0400423966,
0.0519860573,
0.0224279109,
-0.063212961,
0.0055928826,
2.610494232e-34,
0.0147966398,
0.0125202034,
0.0004353386,
0.0097986814,
0.0351113826,
0.0409291647,
-0.0133501906,
0.032300394,
0.0573214553,
-0.0359553471,
-0.0190502163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12490v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12490v2 | MultiPA: A Multi-task Speech Pronunciation Assessment Model for Open Response Scenarios | 2023-08-24T01:24:09 | 2024-06-05T02:16:42 | Yu-Wen Chen, Zhou Yu, Julia Hirschberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Pronunciation assessment models designed for open response scenarios enable
users to practice language skills in a manner similar to real-life
communication. However, previous open-response pronunciation assessment models
have predominantly focused on a single pronunciation task, such as
sentence-level accuracy, rather than offering a comprehensive assessment in
various aspects. We propose MultiPA, a Multitask Pronunciation Assessment model
that provides sentence-level accuracy, fluency, prosody, and word-level
accuracy assessment for open responses. We examined the correlation between
different pronunciation tasks and showed the benefits of multi-task learning.
Our model reached the state-of-the-art performance on existing in-domain data
sets and effectively generalized to an out-of-domain dataset that we newly
collected. The experimental results demonstrate the practical utility of our
model in real-world applications. | [
-0.0238941405,
0.0344211757,
0.0057754293,
-0.0274473485,
-0.0315597393,
-0.0143682603,
0.0368614681,
-0.024601778,
-0.0441888198,
0.0075173741,
-0.0759178996,
-0.0578288473,
0.0775355771,
0.0016637766,
0.00391086,
-0.0143608041,
0.002052763,
-0.0604793951,
0.0289001148,
-0.0112600708,
0.014661897,
0.0252791587,
-0.0895902961,
0.069462955,
0.0129613504,
-0.0228400603,
-0.0001912264,
-0.0050555994,
0.0183129143,
-0.0002801288,
0.0125309685,
0.0499970242,
-0.0136409663,
-0.0119787725,
0.0000016549,
-0.0420491099,
0.002043044,
-0.001116065,
-0.0167848468,
0.0196740068,
0.0453221463,
0.0658243671,
-0.0017596015,
0.0560469925,
-0.0284004044,
-0.0321980454,
0.0568993911,
-0.0331033207,
0.0203907453,
0.0314859711,
-0.0051258137,
0.0023427482,
0.0263476167,
-0.0240278747,
-0.0372451991,
-0.0017843924,
0.0064046178,
-0.0358564742,
-0.0105621256,
-0.0838414505,
-0.0147529161,
0.0265263058,
-0.0043678801,
0.0517921261,
0.0122588938,
0.0211740956,
0.0277949926,
-0.0476609729,
-0.0390738137,
0.0759033486,
-0.0159804989,
-0.0295813084,
-0.0189299602,
-0.0130537236,
-0.0676771402,
-0.0123567246,
-0.0271888841,
-0.0018287128,
0.0125883799,
-0.0123048415,
0.0104544749,
0.0059722606,
-0.0159472041,
-0.02738511,
0.014576531,
0.0375310034,
0.0080803419,
-0.0583898351,
0.0412085652,
0.0335674547,
0.0034083051,
-0.0028271936,
0.0496183261,
0.0172455981,
-0.0640353337,
0.0073121134,
-0.0111816023,
-0.07615944,
0.0235920884,
-0.0067774896,
0.0853570774,
0.0297637228,
-0.0473639779,
-0.0170946792,
-0.0012628083,
0.0307211038,
0.0285682883,
-0.0054117665,
-0.0104284724,
-0.0120200068,
-0.0447739698,
0.0221331492,
0.0094976472,
-0.0164072569,
-0.0543888696,
0.0084976815,
-0.0505920798,
-0.0041112425,
-0.0516928658,
-0.0043181092,
0.0701395497,
0.0002069904,
-0.0710738301,
0.0242139827,
-0.0050308546,
0.0629711673,
-0.00003893,
0.081142284,
-0.0131083345,
-0.0443644188,
-0.0159511864,
-0.017031271,
0.0257955585,
0.0161075667,
0.02547401,
0.0466641225,
-0.0069357599,
-0.0050927512,
-0.0045482321,
-0.0218290295,
-0.0361257978,
-0.0591170937,
-0.0294244923,
-0.0497997589,
0.0046981862,
-0.0221137404,
0.0245365221,
-0.0403501987,
-0.0370679833,
0.0184230246,
0.007063983,
0.0643104464,
0.0137341395,
0.0617186613,
0.0267264023,
-0.0227530561,
0.0253167525,
0.0725133568,
0.0410683043,
-0.0460067056,
0.0055403486,
-0.0245795175,
0.0140034314,
0.0693642497,
0.0485530794,
-0.009966746,
0.039058622,
0.0090377918,
0.0189296529,
0.0210916009,
0.0318233296,
0.0411949642,
-0.0246104617,
0.0123588648,
0.0573955327,
0.027203111,
0.0497558452,
-0.032227762,
0.026692383,
0.0366353095,
-0.0050871558,
-0.0140221352,
-0.0056543658,
-0.026215693,
-0.0075069712,
0.0496327877,
0.0199839529,
0.0732922778,
-0.0420255512,
-0.0243997779,
-0.006609052,
-0.0309818797,
-0.0048350804,
0.0312191173,
0.0488722622,
0.0200047083,
-0.0609069429,
0.0115954503,
0.0432169996,
-0.0439694636,
0.0267658606,
-0.0285402536,
0.0530104637,
0.0417649262,
0.0065773372,
-0.0278086197,
-0.0330669209,
-0.0291838814,
-0.0094579961,
-0.0084461998,
-0.0180489291,
-0.0263597202,
0.0736787468,
-0.0652164891,
-0.0039453837,
0.057369642,
-0.0032359899,
0.0430711284,
-0.0132251382,
-0.0011908555,
-0.0198221672,
-0.0134235434,
0.0363905169,
-0.017405035,
-0.0207274891,
0.0023027016,
0.0464901142,
0.0262471251,
0.0440041237,
0.0481304824,
-0.0057604467,
-0.008493999,
0.0432875827,
0.0031488594,
0.0477645546,
0.0100736264,
-0.0247905497,
-0.0077849063,
0.0519402139,
-0.0255833566,
-0.0143661574,
0.0813866034,
0.0264100563,
-0.0732187629,
0.0226512477,
-0.0176697616,
0.0169660766,
-0.0800819173,
0.0004648247,
0.0004803738,
0.0243949201,
-0.0204574019,
-0.0149961421,
-0.0145477057,
0.0299564116,
0.0265999623,
-0.030695267,
-0.0084518325,
-0.0829423666,
-0.0629732609,
-0.0315466672,
-0.0410943814,
0.0791360289,
-0.0429746434,
0.0500972383,
-0.0398495235,
-0.0346982777,
-0.0885244533,
0.022492975,
-0.0163601674,
0.0297575146,
0.0496264733,
0.0178899784,
-0.0260211639,
-0.0062942724,
-0.0164392628,
-0.006900745,
0.0308613554,
0.0125645073,
-0.0216483939,
-0.031587746,
-0.0236864127,
-0.025343677,
-0.0033220588,
0.0002225915,
-0.0091857594,
-0.0046211807,
0.0390586071,
-0.0264065526,
-0.0162337683,
0.0111556621,
-0.0169680919,
0.0478781834,
0.0136520239,
0.0170950163,
0.0144597311,
0.0958469883,
0.0101982476,
-0.0468643717,
-0.0000795765,
0.0355030186,
-0.0517864004,
-0.0356931537,
-0.0051386803,
-0.0109043317,
-0.0122644501,
-0.0093092127,
0.017422108,
-0.0396763012,
0.0258172508,
0.0496976599,
0.0233913679,
-0.0560439713,
-0.0326446071,
-0.0631807074,
-0.0466163084,
-0.0280138161,
-0.0154722854,
-0.0381645113,
0.0097533111,
-0.0137927756,
-0.0274323169,
0.030558303,
-0.061620947,
-0.0396658555,
-0.0674133077,
-0.0285362806,
0.000095022,
0.0395232476,
-0.0689408332,
-0.0308997594,
0.0003638681,
-0.044601921,
-0.024482809,
0.0474807844,
0.00711961,
-0.0647054985,
0.0617751405,
-0.0671025813,
-0.0318782553,
-0.0087791011,
-0.0153912269,
-0.0055503501,
-0.0020304683,
-0.0190527346,
0.0209829416,
-0.009842433,
-0.0097120702,
0.0094426833,
-0.0118908659,
-0.0068397061,
-0.0220927652,
-0.002135776,
0.0214199144,
0.0035163544,
0.03410431,
0.064295873,
0.0617969707,
-0.0578424372,
-0.0246699061,
-0.0143188676,
0.0160191488,
0.0967218652,
0.0333497562,
-0.0021976065,
0.0328741148,
0.0639153346,
0.0102391727,
0.026208723,
0.0682288334,
0.0445108227,
0.0074927495,
-0.0198965315,
0.075826481,
0.0243921466,
-0.0148337148,
-0.0015763835,
-0.0085475538,
0.0719146132,
-0.0120709613,
-0.0012792252,
-0.0492960922,
-0.0322306566,
0.0130595416,
0.0303993281,
-0.0056580696,
0.0103750378,
-0.0070919562,
-0.0980757102,
0.0219044276,
0.0089368746,
-0.0344654992,
0.0036656281,
-0.0217961464,
0.0114758741,
-0.0596534312,
0.0113985324,
0.0114784017,
0.030725548,
-0.0139364405,
0.0559117645,
-0.0269846804,
-0.0836462304,
0.0641552657,
-0.0400478989,
0.081366539,
0.0310758762,
-0.0026114201,
-0.0103295892,
-0.0816304311,
-0.0120379906,
-0.010981421,
-0.0117481388,
-0.0457822457,
0.0085440949,
0.022633601,
0.0090741646,
-0.0297004506,
0.0346990861,
-0.0476573855,
0.0193624664,
0.0598499291,
0.0677789375,
0.0051009106,
0.0383651927,
-0.0066595082,
0.0089263674,
0.0784400254,
0.0216147993,
-0.0020271281,
-0.0988915265,
-0.0310102794,
0.0118996184,
-0.0311053228,
-0.0494087785,
-0.0043804212,
-0.0141134914,
0.0449944027,
-0.0065503661,
-0.0435984731,
-0.0048971567,
0.0545043312,
0.038222596,
0.0272759125,
-0.0100615891,
-0.0288526975,
0.0137440255,
-0.041516602,
0.0034895267,
0.0118157035,
0.103193529,
-0.0484311506,
-0.0093789715,
0.0287662633,
-0.0383259691,
-0.0409557596,
0.0543274544,
-0.101964213,
-0.0467097349,
0.0226719268,
0.0109415939,
0.0266646706,
0.0257179812,
-0.0397752449,
-0.0415035523,
0.026656881,
-0.0198138691,
-0.1050322875,
0.0273338929,
0.0642785802,
-0.0149214854,
0.0172559712,
-0.0067887614,
-0.0212756768,
0.0175771285,
-0.0212896019,
0.025568733,
0.0097072246,
-0.0846061632,
0.0111960359,
0.0438829176,
0.088700898,
0.0242782384,
-0.0451780632,
-0.0499244295,
0.0202009398,
0.0481724292,
0.0542417243,
-0.0168194938,
-0.0446655154,
0.0378654711,
-0.0138480477,
-0.017088294,
0.0119694825,
-0.0101244161,
-0.0116961384,
-0.0291328579,
0.0020272974,
0.0588484108,
0.0286591463,
-0.0224408228,
0.0039641974,
-0.0311909225,
-0.020204531,
0.003940938,
0.0178682338,
0.0301288646,
0.0059704441,
-0.0481691808,
-0.0021877571,
0.0251177009,
0.0208682977,
-0.0124053061,
0.0550036356,
-0.0045608357,
-0.0033089386,
0.0432088226,
0.0337164067,
0.0411027335,
0.0246797111,
0.0484129041,
-0.0485555828,
0.0250600185,
-0.0658782274,
0.012428401,
0.0384760238,
-0.0247597974,
0.0046051955,
-0.0105220191,
0.0424587578,
0.0119622163,
-0.0147075821,
-0.0467127785,
0.0487903655,
-0.0467762649,
-0.0466922708,
-0.04675458,
0.048283536,
-0.041784618,
-0.0172176734,
-0.0552104115,
-0.0257940013,
0.0445764214,
0.0586035065,
0.0330677256,
-0.016624799,
0.0061411387,
-0.0001864632,
-0.0643941909,
-0.0216869768,
-0.0277760886,
-0.0627044141,
0.0101929074,
-0.0199799631,
0.0193422902,
-5.58115424e-33,
-0.0273764934,
-0.0085249357,
0.038047079,
0.0023341095,
-0.0191280823,
0.0114813885,
0.0044144662,
0.0361352526,
-0.0317819118,
-0.0422036685,
-0.0062111402,
-0.030347703,
0.0347371772,
0.0083566103,
0.0132839335,
0.0208390206,
0.0527358577,
-0.0150574194,
0.0231791791,
-0.0009039551,
0.0164283607,
0.0277399868,
0.0410843715,
-0.0309754647,
0.0400509089,
0.0013479079,
-0.0327700302,
-0.0323230363,
-0.0136960484,
0.0796910077,
-0.0144369183,
0.0717278719,
-0.0034168186,
-0.0514919721,
-0.0213997364,
0.0504467823,
-0.0830505043,
0.0095533738,
0.0355073102,
0.0133806225,
-0.0380274244,
0.0548299924,
-0.0110042412,
0.0599525236,
-0.0044021518,
-0.0489591286,
0.0322286449,
-0.0244386382,
0.0101485588,
0.0047810329,
0.0052277157,
0.0073407697,
-0.0130728148,
-0.0489000529,
0.0045568985,
0.0551228039,
-0.0386087745,
-0.0537390225,
-0.0731935129,
0.0465135574,
-0.0018402564,
0.0115451505,
0.0499073379,
0.0169248581,
-0.0339314044,
0.0104531422,
-0.0150869172,
-0.0673953742,
0.0129993036,
-0.0139248259,
0.0299919285,
0.0426514111,
0.0322826877,
0.0461431369,
-0.0101848356,
-0.0391948335,
-0.0430478454,
0.0312102865,
0.0221247207,
-0.0298673734,
0.0237975959,
0.0054492955,
-0.0193116982,
0.0003180893,
-0.0492630377,
0.0560744703,
-0.0536250584,
0.0136750629,
0.079585664,
-0.0157058593,
-0.0042008883,
0.0272084363,
0.0385830067,
-0.0338699818,
0.0499225892,
-0.0089778705,
-0.0094163036,
0.0108278217,
-0.0109000839,
-0.0103489263,
-0.0830545053,
0.011504137,
0.024332637,
0.0479532927,
-0.0010594652,
-0.0309090465,
-0.0194781292,
0.025943175,
-0.0724097639,
0.0021473269,
-0.0092262831,
0.0598252751,
0.0243571792,
0.0143380817,
0.0458279699,
-0.0015127979,
-0.0359885208,
0.0577154048,
-0.0123914555,
-0.0382176563,
-0.0133930873,
-0.0436475277,
-0.0097369356,
0.0110416394,
-0.009804613,
0.018809028,
0.0396032594,
-0.0711340308,
-0.012917147,
0.0021977799,
-0.0032606157,
0.045426257,
2.346e-7,
-0.0127500044,
0.0237530507,
0.0011406648,
0.0143808043,
-0.001449661,
-0.0138941947,
-0.0499818958,
0.0340468325,
0.0125120757,
0.0189620424,
0.0093105361,
-0.0275560208,
0.0879109725,
0.0121997576,
-0.0654165745,
-0.0223213844,
-0.0175662637,
0.0788451955,
-0.0123840962,
0.022186365,
0.0244044196,
0.0175906233,
-0.0101873083,
-0.0421867631,
-0.0013408836,
0.0087464992,
0.0233826321,
-0.004422518,
-0.0085941581,
-0.0315905437,
0.0420289785,
-0.0275832321,
0.0303335544,
0.0613279864,
-0.0326050967,
0.0373980664,
0.0303755663,
0.0340332948,
-0.0032756722,
-0.0560235046,
0.0232208576,
0.0090353703,
-0.0445956662,
-0.0084592989,
0.0368797146,
0.0030682015,
-0.013255612,
0.0239247289,
-0.0025418608,
0.0054167253,
0.0338413566,
-0.0211877748,
0.0240906626,
-0.0064912234,
0.0039164149,
-0.0100799454,
-0.0431073792,
-0.0136146154,
-0.00053884,
0.0312298536,
-0.0429832488,
-0.0273334738,
0.0136785191,
-0.0343399197,
-0.0157345105,
-0.0784322023,
-0.0034150295,
1.348425182e-34,
-0.0019953644,
-0.0269929711,
0.0370743759,
0.0201818738,
-0.0160737149,
-0.0355472937,
0.0555579215,
-0.0100164078,
0.0263481624,
-0.0555528291,
-0.0421116576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12488v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12488v1 | GPTEval: A Survey on Assessments of ChatGPT and GPT-4 | 2023-08-24T01:17:16 | 2023-08-24T01:17:16 | Rui Mao, Guanyi Chen, Xulang Zhang, Frank Guerin, Erik Cambria | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The emergence of ChatGPT has generated much speculation in the press about
its potential to disrupt social and economic systems. Its astonishing language
ability has aroused strong curiosity among scholars about its performance in
different domains. There have been many studies evaluating the ability of
ChatGPT and GPT-4 in different tasks and disciplines. However, a comprehensive
review summarizing the collective assessment findings is lacking. The objective
of this survey is to thoroughly analyze prior assessments of ChatGPT and GPT-4,
focusing on its language and reasoning abilities, scientific knowledge, and
ethical considerations. Furthermore, an examination of the existing evaluation
methods is conducted, offering several recommendations for future research in
evaluating large language models. | [
0.045969896,
0.0650119707,
-0.0232164413,
0.0143301766,
-0.104635857,
0.0194582772,
0.0229088161,
0.0161538217,
0.0320439227,
-0.0534402542,
-0.0188429412,
-0.0532056168,
-0.0069047962,
0.0372756198,
0.0349257253,
-0.0411202274,
0.0466900505,
-0.0090794545,
0.0290182438,
0.0111630438,
0.0163611881,
0.005455412,
0.0007740243,
0.0447433591,
0.0068578329,
-0.0286367834,
0.0158315543,
-0.0485281684,
0.0178889502,
-0.0213711802,
-0.020169571,
0.0548496246,
-0.0076126088,
0.0977984592,
0.0000021853,
-0.0573472083,
-0.0278976616,
0.022780139,
0.0122092199,
0.0497295409,
0.0720452741,
0.0345928259,
-0.0095654549,
0.0205624066,
-0.0696113333,
-0.0214958899,
0.0445343517,
0.027682934,
0.0325500108,
0.0646411255,
-0.024513552,
-0.0329966061,
0.0505260639,
-0.0015530779,
-0.0287210792,
-0.0342776962,
0.0238406807,
0.0299203452,
0.037994083,
0.0279261097,
0.0145237381,
0.0275781248,
0.0350693949,
-0.017376205,
-0.0369011946,
0.0215108152,
-0.0793114156,
-0.0373456106,
-0.0038828,
0.0282997303,
0.0489593819,
-0.0235238094,
-0.0008088031,
0.0127997426,
-0.0073011122,
0.0072387378,
-0.051766973,
-0.0023581756,
0.0056559532,
0.0149902906,
0.0320333429,
0.0196233075,
0.0082873069,
0.002152835,
0.003968236,
0.0802482739,
0.0211391654,
-0.0502111726,
0.0048940312,
0.0010376659,
-0.0559794828,
-0.0429583602,
-0.0162182376,
-0.0069463863,
-0.0065338444,
0.0181957632,
0.0183755886,
0.0409534983,
0.0367606804,
-0.0688655451,
-0.0091764582,
0.0694119036,
0.0185032878,
0.0186601244,
0.0252622683,
0.0482200831,
-0.0215887912,
0.0093636429,
-0.0095071206,
0.0111825811,
-0.0980420113,
-0.024685096,
-0.0305572581,
0.0257190689,
-0.031657923,
-0.0152326701,
-0.0459893644,
0.0046387133,
-0.0039112875,
-0.0309541523,
0.0025652912,
-0.0343270153,
0.0135474456,
-0.0014225111,
-0.0332225487,
0.006457618,
-0.0372907408,
-0.0006724421,
0.0121103991,
-0.0702964589,
0.0463630855,
0.0027632874,
-0.0373487696,
-0.0236405712,
-0.0270754322,
0.0931303203,
0.015293085,
-0.0359071456,
-0.0141209615,
-0.0246615745,
-0.0544659309,
-0.0978224203,
-0.0094450889,
-0.0647112578,
-0.0170127694,
0.0168511476,
-0.0340624973,
0.0198425371,
-0.0024721189,
-0.0006349813,
-0.0212099161,
0.0303392969,
0.005649419,
0.0074824775,
0.0033761985,
0.0222788472,
-0.0082882941,
0.0686038062,
0.0104231434,
0.0022619569,
0.0248541255,
-0.0224122237,
0.0027334951,
0.0312326532,
-0.0432460792,
0.0168685,
0.024683889,
0.0357920527,
-0.0035877335,
-0.0096746273,
-0.0361081176,
0.0922670662,
-0.040362522,
0.0033922014,
0.0861103386,
0.0665902421,
0.0042396397,
0.045850195,
0.0241316259,
0.0126286792,
0.0287818126,
0.0127309263,
-0.0453028902,
-0.0301379487,
-0.0434768088,
-0.0173117463,
0.0089235185,
0.0211401749,
0.0162146296,
-0.0321595967,
-0.0118098874,
0.022211263,
0.0837075338,
-0.0029834101,
0.0451972894,
-0.0520251505,
-0.0369633622,
-0.0225459859,
0.0030266866,
-0.0481637381,
-0.0399839059,
-0.0930966064,
-0.0096992813,
0.0282785781,
0.0428313464,
0.0264044758,
-0.0321014263,
-0.0059043611,
0.0082291076,
0.0518160947,
0.0477850847,
0.0273547824,
-0.0334895179,
-0.0250270534,
0.0106988288,
-0.00393165,
0.0105328159,
0.0178877246,
0.0109435432,
0.0435546376,
0.0017290792,
-0.0163144171,
-0.0056503937,
-0.0146665964,
0.0137457363,
0.0025109309,
-0.0601617023,
-0.0126993917,
0.0583156794,
0.0242387988,
-0.0164692011,
0.0337334424,
0.0077783028,
0.024852559,
-0.0144850034,
0.0242953878,
-0.0238210354,
0.0329943672,
0.0388919599,
-0.0519684516,
-0.0115668494,
0.0389689058,
0.0079867858,
-0.0275873076,
0.0388488322,
-0.0352288596,
0.0631768256,
-0.0594522245,
0.0164227113,
-0.0525331236,
0.0100110015,
-0.0232024211,
0.0627742708,
0.0239098016,
0.0158961006,
-0.0188003518,
0.01936711,
0.0597432479,
-0.0454823524,
-0.0599899106,
0.0326152146,
0.0062323809,
0.0177191421,
0.0576370619,
0.0383497886,
-0.0489689931,
-0.0418041833,
-0.1074056923,
-0.0031392823,
-0.0165436566,
0.0597976968,
0.0304758511,
-0.0284677967,
-0.010524068,
0.0367960446,
-0.0396311283,
0.0073637166,
0.0367808342,
0.0307667684,
0.0065652556,
-0.0255970974,
-0.0391634963,
-0.0104811545,
-0.0096170586,
-0.0247168709,
0.0037165845,
0.062624298,
-0.0234037321,
-0.0004386702,
-0.0087430114,
-0.0538587309,
-0.0111121498,
-0.0100721233,
-0.0694503859,
0.0508565418,
0.0191242304,
0.0284955464,
-0.0036264847,
-0.0051423688,
0.0456549302,
-0.0237141382,
-0.0241461601,
-0.0080102803,
-0.0188720431,
-0.0217384603,
-0.0296353139,
-0.0216732118,
-0.0412537567,
-0.0331057869,
0.0667926595,
0.026955802,
-0.003821743,
-0.066405192,
0.0287820864,
-0.0748086274,
-0.0117047327,
-0.0186984725,
-0.0233798064,
-0.0316905677,
0.0564675964,
-0.0091699958,
-0.0455389991,
0.0363237932,
-0.0254363827,
-0.0122347027,
-0.0549849719,
-0.0090356292,
-0.0316648781,
0.0665185228,
-0.0032694377,
0.0189112257,
0.0086931353,
-0.0304641202,
-0.0402337499,
-0.0122037744,
0.0290765185,
-0.0205182843,
0.0381753221,
-0.0459061563,
0.0421696901,
0.0055906838,
-0.0009268067,
0.0041275318,
-0.0149539914,
0.0044152131,
0.0556458645,
0.072746329,
-0.0055219885,
-0.0252296645,
0.0690169036,
0.0097869644,
-0.0099805761,
-0.0116002355,
0.0016823084,
-0.0023753955,
-0.0147658531,
0.0100915283,
-0.005686271,
0.0512813479,
0.0323878042,
0.0030911884,
0.0716952831,
0.003870103,
0.005391025,
-0.0088706557,
0.0229037013,
0.0191423129,
-0.0352888368,
-0.0490804426,
-0.0027667677,
0.0385675691,
-0.0545192733,
-0.0100314086,
0.1007807255,
0.0164515469,
-0.0045176786,
0.0135567253,
0.0108784996,
-0.0003438517,
-0.0096950717,
0.0085917618,
-0.0973822922,
0.0100538982,
0.0013826237,
-0.0096731503,
-0.043966867,
-0.037343625,
-0.0022305823,
-0.0912857577,
0.0492449366,
0.0083076414,
-0.0544952713,
0.0001596819,
-0.0250152014,
-0.0017125312,
-0.0205920152,
0.0417464338,
0.014934076,
0.0022459859,
0.0113455625,
0.0121502643,
-0.0804211721,
-0.0426331349,
0.0696324855,
-0.0028529456,
0.0560722053,
0.0653453395,
0.05374391,
-0.0373450965,
-0.032313209,
0.0520915054,
0.0097177271,
-0.0420086794,
0.0146552557,
-0.0047851689,
0.0069563147,
-0.0040158182,
-0.0553448088,
-0.002926267,
-0.0160168801,
0.0086937808,
0.0173838027,
0.0814242139,
-0.0222617816,
-0.0423624702,
0.0053401669,
0.0165913161,
0.007338373,
0.0634564608,
0.0121239424,
0.0098560406,
-0.0570267104,
-0.0302882846,
-0.0096069695,
0.0059757419,
-0.0505989641,
-0.0022005099,
0.0453019589,
-0.0385439917,
-0.0421337523,
-0.0722007677,
0.0198961962,
0.0010980027,
-0.0108831925,
0.0114846481,
0.0138854021,
0.0068028746,
-0.0001765757,
-0.0084598055,
0.0117901359,
0.0013943824,
-0.0741532966,
-0.0046659545,
0.0029415106,
0.010819328,
-0.0288375299,
0.0194786172,
-0.0473214276,
-0.0710242391,
0.012459971,
-0.0099861789,
0.0435208268,
-0.0393056758,
-0.0522489697,
-0.0081314556,
-0.0077906479,
0.0173563976,
-0.0428478904,
0.0032927024,
0.0141192954,
0.0134364609,
0.0274428874,
0.0192204639,
0.0122848842,
0.0324047096,
-0.0295299422,
0.0310087427,
-0.0125651062,
0.0081611527,
0.0312998369,
0.0608252548,
0.039505098,
-0.032295689,
-0.0197734851,
-0.0141786067,
-0.0451540239,
-0.0831580237,
-0.0014363107,
-0.0638071299,
-0.0106179835,
0.0391740166,
0.0273375455,
-0.0287216343,
-0.0218636487,
-0.0530324578,
-0.0151598677,
-0.0144343786,
0.0515596084,
-0.0096003897,
0.0047740079,
0.0060401801,
-0.0088375108,
-0.0135721117,
-0.0175023843,
-0.0377516858,
0.0248338785,
-0.031638436,
0.0707944259,
0.0113706663,
-0.0107287373,
0.0617762245,
0.0498969927,
-0.0665215924,
-0.066801168,
0.0078744264,
0.0585647933,
0.0287056193,
0.0362306833,
0.0630416498,
-0.0476479828,
-0.000573447,
-0.0243809279,
0.0084487572,
0.0076692225,
-0.024193095,
-0.0125526469,
0.0124608539,
-0.0492087342,
0.0034145138,
0.0439574756,
0.0088488478,
-0.0027867698,
0.0269441959,
-0.0378299989,
-0.031382259,
-0.0504943132,
-0.0242231712,
-0.0003459362,
-0.0138960313,
0.0057926015,
-0.0968136266,
-0.0556913875,
-0.0898948908,
0.024633674,
-0.0012183955,
-0.0005314283,
0.0294777248,
0.0730065778,
-0.0116641251,
-0.0155937867,
-0.044248227,
-0.0199301392,
-0.0367335379,
0.0061861994,
0.0059571238,
-7.004103744e-33,
-0.0039194995,
-0.0239967089,
0.055097457,
0.0180497169,
-0.0429394245,
-0.0380152427,
-0.0185126066,
0.0350907855,
-0.0357352756,
0.0240036231,
-0.0040902668,
-0.0074243639,
0.0171509311,
-0.0106788594,
-0.0020423399,
-0.0180748533,
-0.0139502259,
-0.0083797397,
-0.0137122339,
0.0310176928,
0.02488566,
-0.0128591666,
0.1192436889,
-0.0497246869,
0.0732129812,
-0.0135490745,
-0.0213451087,
-0.0084477561,
-0.02942257,
0.0461988598,
-0.0166026279,
0.0325844213,
0.028140204,
-0.0479985811,
0.0139295347,
0.0044106785,
-0.0040167836,
-0.0226286035,
0.0673907176,
-0.0054051378,
-0.0030855483,
-0.009578404,
0.0135037266,
-0.026738273,
-0.0444714315,
-0.0102227898,
0.0069459397,
-0.0126557741,
-0.0059515722,
0.049877964,
-0.0642120838,
0.0398119204,
-0.021086771,
0.0264473334,
-0.028116392,
0.0305764973,
-0.0393822081,
-0.0133089665,
-0.0270302296,
0.0189570803,
0.026658617,
-0.0046090754,
0.0493288413,
-0.0446208119,
0.0225486718,
0.0525308959,
0.0297317598,
-0.0087410444,
-0.0135343717,
-0.0287810471,
0.0393505096,
0.0275878161,
0.0383453593,
0.0426525399,
0.0170204844,
-0.02086238,
-0.0415357128,
-0.0242380425,
0.0581788495,
0.0188369155,
0.0206075888,
-0.0182486046,
-0.0635700077,
-0.0483372137,
0.0009650291,
-0.0071495953,
-0.0280234627,
-0.0648168772,
0.0642911196,
-0.0570166297,
0.0159329288,
0.0293120593,
0.048828017,
-0.0484094471,
-0.0040533724,
-0.0046069641,
-0.0248075277,
0.0325415619,
-0.0018525813,
0.0665127784,
-0.063351348,
0.0150073795,
-0.0038988555,
0.0429471545,
0.0235229898,
-0.0321126543,
-0.0221938547,
0.0122786332,
-0.0431807153,
0.0029473479,
-0.0274062026,
0.040023867,
0.0228403974,
-0.0347176977,
0.0227274764,
-0.0168502498,
0.0168860462,
-0.0183510743,
0.039090924,
0.0177069083,
-0.0352598913,
0.0299678501,
-0.0263394471,
-0.008427063,
0.0001503078,
0.0144324424,
-0.0196583606,
0.0432721861,
0.0324735455,
-0.0160290431,
-0.0041168099,
0.0167572405,
2.942e-7,
0.0687864348,
0.050980445,
-0.004187251,
-0.0059752762,
0.0099774739,
0.0103073502,
-0.0185243208,
0.0129424632,
0.0365452059,
0.0198605619,
0.0165753234,
0.0104148444,
0.0560574532,
0.0406835265,
-0.0381067097,
-0.0201368388,
-0.0796949938,
-0.0463303328,
-0.0510947667,
0.0447139032,
0.0665649921,
0.0534057356,
0.0169083644,
0.0157407131,
-0.0405338928,
-0.0479275361,
0.0578273684,
-0.0394040644,
-0.0372166261,
0.0288114883,
0.0280320887,
0.0295519475,
0.0173590221,
0.0426415913,
0.0367883034,
-0.0089785345,
0.0256331172,
0.0558272116,
0.0008680857,
0.0007279565,
-0.0008021891,
-0.0415958539,
-0.0003994497,
-0.116134204,
0.0923538581,
-0.0591499954,
-0.0704868585,
0.0199020915,
-0.0431140438,
-0.0368816294,
0.0443818867,
0.0093771145,
-0.0640169904,
0.0192115344,
0.0172255207,
-0.0049664984,
-0.0030612173,
-0.0337709934,
0.0290071368,
-0.0022069728,
-0.0249148216,
-0.0983100384,
-0.0168482177,
0.0229400154,
0.0229387041,
-0.0205183197,
-0.0061713383,
2.767016815e-34,
0.0318100527,
-0.010886644,
0.0449960157,
-0.0295506772,
0.0530393757,
0.0484265275,
0.04467218,
0.0080399625,
-0.0088371653,
-0.0699357614,
-0.0105805183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12477v1 | American Stories: A Large-Scale Structured Text Dataset of Historical U.S. Newspapers | 2023-08-24T00:24:42 | 2023-08-24T00:24:42 | Melissa Dell, Jacob Carlson, Tom Bryan, Emily Silcock, Abhishek Arora, Zejiang Shen, Luca D'Amico-Wong, Quan Le, Pablo Querubin, Leander Heldring | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, econ.GN, q-fin.EC | Existing full text datasets of U.S. public domain newspapers do not recognize
the often complex layouts of newspaper scans, and as a result the digitized
content scrambles texts from articles, headlines, captions, advertisements, and
other layout regions. OCR quality can also be low. This study develops a novel,
deep learning pipeline for extracting full article texts from newspaper images
and applies it to the nearly 20 million scans in Library of Congress's public
domain Chronicling America collection. The pipeline includes layout detection,
legibility classification, custom OCR, and association of article texts
spanning multiple bounding boxes. To achieve high scalability, it is built with
efficient architectures designed for mobile phones. The resulting American
Stories dataset provides high quality data that could be used for pre-training
a large language model to achieve better understanding of historical English
and historical world knowledge. The dataset could also be added to the external
database of a retrieval-augmented language model to make historical information
- ranging from interpretations of political events to minutiae about the lives
of people's ancestors - more widely accessible. Furthermore, structured article
texts facilitate using transformer-based methods for popular social science
applications like topic classification, detection of reproduced content, and
news story clustering. Finally, American Stories provides a massive silver
quality dataset for innovating multimodal layout analysis models and other
multimodal applications. | [
0.0101473685,
0.1129935086,
0.0191883985,
0.0308338087,
-0.0183074679,
0.0261053257,
0.0447902866,
0.0056268414,
-0.0130703375,
-0.0401946306,
0.0055222032,
-0.0128871202,
0.0180766471,
0.0372897573,
-0.0523246229,
-0.0262326691,
-0.0069269054,
0.0035965601,
0.010220469,
0.0243383944,
-0.005825053,
0.0264569297,
0.0019889714,
-0.019680474,
-0.0411485583,
-0.0215599686,
-0.0203083865,
0.0367226787,
0.0091564925,
-0.027953025,
-0.0264346842,
0.0217471495,
0.0553113148,
0.0552655831,
0.0000019054,
0.0036661299,
-0.0250586011,
-0.0244757868,
0.0425591767,
0.0019049562,
0.1264177263,
-0.0496637039,
-0.0242635515,
-0.0519370735,
-0.0253962055,
-0.0358788259,
0.0593962632,
0.0868703946,
0.0222526286,
0.0639830753,
-0.032386139,
-0.0444115065,
0.0414463691,
0.012462562,
-0.0050484501,
-0.0102543999,
0.0201886669,
-0.008815879,
0.0013833763,
0.0224628635,
0.0025902984,
0.0320829861,
0.0488656014,
-0.0318044908,
-0.0641919672,
0.0116421767,
-0.0284987669,
-0.0085906275,
-0.0146921771,
0.0457130298,
-0.0297261272,
-0.0381248556,
0.0218938477,
-0.0163982585,
-0.0478326455,
-0.0094546825,
-0.0358119234,
0.0147068612,
-0.0315726697,
0.0172893181,
-0.05791495,
-0.0315380171,
0.0167508647,
0.0032864546,
-0.0247885715,
0.0255220402,
0.0071616042,
0.0198442265,
-0.0290592145,
0.0146018174,
0.0191432666,
-0.0215376988,
0.0616292506,
-0.0037384864,
0.0372102633,
0.0010431672,
-0.0482888408,
-0.0643188432,
-0.0204445794,
-0.04653975,
-0.0307104178,
-0.0201592892,
-0.0595926382,
0.051767461,
0.0138058858,
0.0467012599,
-0.0459484123,
0.0367981084,
-0.0161199458,
0.0248156004,
-0.0143065965,
0.0155540062,
0.0028656002,
-0.0121271843,
-0.0380858034,
-0.06055535,
-0.0056183985,
-0.0299328882,
0.0271671358,
0.0180401579,
-0.0400357731,
0.0376578383,
-0.0342580117,
-0.0335108079,
0.0229487419,
0.0542138293,
0.0078487536,
0.0096328631,
-0.0088286437,
-0.0273979232,
0.0302820187,
0.0242178086,
0.0332854986,
-0.0005955157,
-0.0204368029,
0.0187489316,
-0.0560357086,
-0.021147307,
-0.0762934834,
0.0032375397,
-0.0328909606,
-0.0235729571,
0.0539167635,
-0.0835981295,
0.0304748956,
-0.0371018909,
0.0174734704,
-0.0448176935,
-0.0058850623,
0.0223753825,
-0.0323510431,
0.0549106561,
0.0250055715,
-0.0222739391,
0.0709646121,
0.0272111725,
0.0611400679,
0.0483272299,
0.067540437,
0.1100803167,
0.0732789859,
-0.0059229773,
-0.002676676,
0.0390535034,
-0.0254949965,
-0.0301788133,
0.0127724204,
-0.0304012951,
-0.0193194933,
0.0317684039,
0.0230984576,
0.0150046935,
-0.0091032581,
-0.0166318174,
0.0724040568,
0.0570539013,
0.0228645485,
0.0452338718,
0.0071747326,
0.0365106016,
0.0109503577,
0.0053667468,
-0.045730371,
0.0007239168,
0.0162114445,
-0.0193756148,
0.0086058341,
0.0531402566,
-0.0193736702,
-0.0245685037,
0.0038189681,
-0.0188051518,
0.0398620889,
-0.03286542,
0.0850384086,
-0.0013592545,
-0.0593157746,
0.0245100297,
0.0185070485,
-0.0377667733,
-0.0047022826,
0.0014552659,
0.0273710229,
0.0541064143,
0.0781362057,
-0.0322360694,
0.0559002757,
-0.0073607787,
0.0481852219,
0.0546861067,
0.0081442827,
0.0088849645,
0.0368930101,
-0.0721479133,
-0.0552069992,
0.0046624872,
0.0059515387,
0.0181877669,
0.0262990277,
0.0454145633,
0.0058594462,
-0.0186665412,
-0.0458939299,
0.0422083586,
0.0171366818,
-0.0374407284,
0.013458957,
0.036849197,
0.003445022,
0.0449988656,
-0.0215623137,
-0.0496180914,
0.0312477518,
-0.0187340323,
0.0081095938,
-0.0014702262,
-0.0494056866,
0.0122143459,
-0.0139153413,
-0.0791945457,
0.0024470766,
0.0523000434,
-0.0316297337,
-0.0351530313,
0.0186803844,
-0.0086126486,
0.0236136839,
-0.0086329477,
-0.0005978447,
-0.0177083444,
0.0288615134,
-0.0502128936,
0.0736053512,
0.0033433065,
0.0040813526,
0.0012893638,
-0.0669192895,
-0.003419725,
-0.0013201542,
-0.0229900051,
0.0030404986,
-0.0378345959,
0.0142495306,
0.0377178453,
0.0105724307,
-0.0335057974,
-0.0106324228,
-0.0672733337,
0.0103363944,
-0.0230783802,
-0.0001203376,
0.0245122276,
-0.004400454,
0.0156178009,
-0.0417763367,
-0.0086083366,
0.0037762355,
-0.0284092575,
0.0056932918,
0.0073974826,
0.0040189018,
0.01251199,
-0.011048194,
-0.0237814356,
-0.0187376235,
0.0554093532,
0.0413115881,
-0.0224246904,
-0.0102924583,
0.0072953678,
0.0210661739,
0.008310697,
-0.0082391761,
-0.0115728024,
0.0340580083,
-0.0109200291,
-0.0102788424,
0.108892642,
0.0099977665,
0.0395707898,
-0.005740311,
-0.0060548154,
-0.0272079874,
0.0034868659,
-0.0256635956,
0.0186014865,
-0.0057523069,
-0.0311099924,
0.0020468612,
0.0161251388,
-0.013152645,
0.053995803,
0.0085917423,
-0.0425094031,
-0.0061881966,
-0.0038024436,
-0.0056289663,
0.0184283424,
0.0245210826,
0.0718544573,
-0.0576146245,
-0.0448985361,
0.0225369912,
-0.0270369444,
0.0072353561,
-0.0224170256,
0.0100178905,
-0.0221847873,
0.0712208673,
0.0236954968,
0.0357044823,
-0.0188240707,
-0.0669113547,
-0.0143372249,
-0.0028633154,
0.006790258,
-0.0299935844,
0.0354400538,
-0.0478553511,
0.002111411,
-0.0136640668,
-0.0392001942,
-0.0181440152,
-0.0365414694,
-0.0005202307,
-0.0590128154,
-0.0168489274,
-0.0500148088,
-0.0962190256,
0.0376282372,
0.0291146096,
0.0871827677,
-0.0031374812,
0.0182695538,
-0.0067336597,
0.1081917062,
0.0172229577,
0.0036382002,
-0.0249819718,
-0.0130344275,
-0.0349556766,
0.0346551351,
-0.0061306073,
0.0555498451,
-0.0293008778,
0.0341726281,
0.030495612,
0.0022875071,
-0.0106553063,
-0.0185757093,
0.0361839235,
-0.0646389499,
-0.018606998,
0.0731249973,
0.0272036269,
-0.082346186,
-0.0399199352,
0.0065025524,
-0.0325246453,
-0.0187555347,
0.0145649677,
-0.1054814011,
-0.0024680612,
-0.0165362712,
-0.0197183806,
0.0333802029,
-0.0043900544,
-0.0143941715,
-0.0588323995,
0.0153062111,
0.0142656574,
-0.0487074591,
-0.0349532589,
-0.0649075583,
-0.0118681351,
-0.0296877064,
-0.0303080641,
-0.0204855893,
0.0003943384,
-0.067198284,
-0.0411952771,
-0.0222970769,
-0.0384905487,
-0.0321358442,
-0.004813069,
-0.0345178619,
0.0488163531,
0.0549308322,
-0.0056695151,
-0.0348753333,
0.0065227663,
0.0294868369,
-0.007186858,
-0.0240661781,
0.0716660619,
-0.0020116214,
0.0069933808,
-0.0437433422,
0.0566321462,
-0.0016855409,
-0.0155990291,
0.0055190027,
0.0093324212,
0.0031248529,
-0.0089545362,
-0.0313083008,
-0.0082895318,
0.0082500987,
0.0131458873,
0.0120832818,
-0.0273723099,
-0.0490052439,
-0.0514282659,
0.0531924963,
-0.0809529647,
-0.0227691047,
0.0341834165,
-0.058785677,
-0.0753072575,
-0.0378172137,
-0.0103728482,
-0.0114962794,
0.0369945318,
0.0298536122,
-0.0514091812,
0.0425322987,
-0.0075168977,
-0.0973333195,
0.0221954696,
-0.028821962,
-0.0185216069,
-0.0275013763,
0.0153276082,
0.0035963247,
-0.0307153407,
-0.0102843037,
0.0271658972,
-0.0881971046,
-0.017709868,
0.046693977,
-0.0220982358,
0.0149827134,
0.0404339954,
0.0131072225,
-0.0527975,
0.0641301051,
0.0396004841,
-0.0116929542,
-0.0550975055,
-0.0205672458,
-0.0289250556,
-0.0185013451,
0.0019503272,
-0.0162040796,
0.0294185355,
0.0102727832,
-0.0499141589,
-0.0332713686,
-0.0154633094,
-0.0390714332,
-0.0340584293,
0.0303178988,
-0.013446006,
-0.0372619294,
-0.0425186306,
-0.0003925875,
0.0012686477,
0.0190988015,
-0.0139053967,
0.0114794122,
0.0057142377,
-0.0010278303,
-0.0180684384,
0.0662463307,
0.0346508101,
0.0633878261,
-0.0555160567,
0.0518099666,
0.0255309958,
0.0244198143,
-0.0298717692,
0.01604902,
0.0015224229,
0.0891406685,
-0.022264054,
0.0654105842,
0.0033184669,
0.0193369966,
0.0119386595,
0.0014925163,
-0.0056496328,
0.0478541777,
-0.0536496639,
0.0117920162,
-0.0579372682,
0.0408398844,
0.0467752442,
-0.0525017157,
0.0440072529,
0.0187523197,
-0.0292886384,
-0.0022289704,
0.0181873087,
0.0318668485,
-0.028074095,
-0.0185038093,
0.0351448655,
0.0191060584,
0.033190269,
0.0344469659,
0.0033083351,
-0.0248103701,
0.0794329122,
-0.0414347202,
-0.0451094173,
0.0098666884,
0.0615253597,
0.0470010005,
-0.0090256557,
-0.0373900458,
0.0279948544,
0.0107198469,
0.0211279001,
0.0302713308,
-0.0023696851,
0.0173787158,
0.0011736881,
0.0542608909,
0.0009891138,
0.0031336027,
-0.018455185,
0.0088267913,
-0.0240134429,
-0.0340439677,
0.0165081564,
-5.848528879e-33,
0.0051832115,
-0.0501753278,
-0.0075202319,
-0.0292544328,
-0.0470927507,
0.0229133517,
-0.0385466628,
-0.0168319717,
-0.0005927589,
0.0164690241,
-0.0153062707,
-0.0093818624,
0.0428976901,
0.0453269035,
-0.022774674,
0.0314765833,
0.0465370826,
-0.0020281347,
-0.0338994265,
0.0266143382,
0.0373935327,
0.0288760681,
0.0495644026,
-0.0549740158,
-0.013267112,
0.0007883102,
-0.0202476401,
-0.0341690443,
0.0653141961,
0.045177497,
-0.012610374,
-0.0078212181,
0.0356838144,
-0.0563917197,
0.0014838594,
0.1078525186,
-0.1100178361,
0.0038818005,
-0.0191818643,
0.0786951557,
0.0117025729,
-0.0106695127,
0.0665563717,
-0.0305022541,
0.0033833447,
-0.0266371723,
0.0795081258,
-0.0292646643,
0.0114919441,
-0.0253294054,
-0.0273234937,
0.0224753805,
-0.0199934896,
-0.0164424665,
0.0359398648,
-0.0091595706,
0.0083058802,
0.0746583268,
-0.0953962356,
0.0088676503,
-0.0118011236,
0.0351943858,
0.0712529048,
0.0092916237,
-0.0274897926,
0.0379605666,
0.0147931101,
0.0003203429,
-0.0564420149,
0.0064533041,
0.0584372282,
0.0243486967,
0.0125682941,
0.0756565556,
0.0759916976,
-0.0279389564,
-0.0492603257,
0.0492477491,
0.0021883708,
0.0307349674,
0.0113777798,
0.0273589883,
-0.0074465275,
0.0152843064,
-0.0038820549,
-0.0328723192,
-0.0360978916,
-0.0322490148,
0.0076788086,
0.0093979351,
-0.02312278,
0.0520362668,
0.0655167773,
-0.0343439952,
-0.0303453803,
0.0293962844,
-0.0023224428,
0.0589151047,
-0.0283105727,
-0.0099377893,
-0.0445542261,
-0.0444358066,
0.0239213519,
0.0340572372,
0.003202568,
-0.0372370295,
0.0636952594,
0.0142186191,
-0.0398341529,
0.0086205909,
0.0062175193,
-0.0375454426,
0.0203315821,
0.0578995161,
0.018679902,
-0.0177749433,
-0.0141237229,
0.0382572524,
0.0090048546,
0.014910765,
0.0107316906,
-0.0449785329,
0.0109735699,
0.0230777767,
-0.0301324185,
-0.0369233899,
-0.0416032225,
-0.0129121151,
0.0202658605,
-0.0668624789,
-0.0055196965,
0.0059791505,
2.528e-7,
0.0190071538,
0.0250278898,
0.0621040203,
-0.0107203517,
0.0095226634,
0.0215585623,
0.0264308155,
0.032082241,
-0.0565658174,
-0.0280666053,
0.03964784,
0.0199548434,
0.0767678097,
0.0264600199,
-0.0853213593,
0.0404651277,
-0.0542699881,
0.0040819449,
-0.0628250167,
0.0003993762,
0.0455359109,
0.0621265806,
-0.0118145403,
-0.0515470877,
0.0292101,
-0.0088080009,
0.0102779474,
-0.0224121213,
-0.0150622139,
-0.016353013,
0.0239873044,
0.0241561066,
-0.0538060144,
-0.0202472024,
-0.0100111011,
0.0058162352,
0.0309052281,
0.0336644016,
-0.0084679862,
0.0044344598,
0.0090314541,
-0.000719765,
-0.0428005308,
-0.0537840761,
0.05342279,
-0.0137637844,
0.0008104758,
-0.050322704,
-0.0336294584,
-0.013673299,
0.0110415602,
0.0088947583,
-0.0034367291,
0.0234700479,
0.0408038795,
-0.0179714784,
-0.0017731675,
-0.0656925738,
-0.0086164325,
0.0032585077,
-0.022823317,
0.0391349457,
-0.0515077822,
-0.0191826206,
0.0107093332,
-0.038126979,
0.0084980251,
2.214652709e-34,
0.0230906177,
0.0057869051,
-0.0235072225,
0.0012759331,
0.0084844511,
-0.0153558021,
-0.0114807812,
-0.0416982695,
-0.0433673561,
-0.0774551779,
0.0253674593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12339v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12339v1 | Considerations for health care institutions training large language models on electronic health records | 2023-08-24T00:09:01 | 2023-08-24T00:09:01 | Weipeng Zhou, Danielle Bitterman, Majid Afshar, Timothy A. Miller | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT have excited scientists across
fields; in medicine, one source of excitement is the potential applications of
LLMs trained on electronic health record (EHR) data. But there are tough
questions we must first answer if health care institutions are interested in
having LLMs trained on their own data; should they train an LLM from scratch or
fine-tune it from an open-source model? For healthcare institutions with a
predefined budget, what are the biggest LLMs they can afford? In this study, we
take steps towards answering these questions with an analysis on dataset sizes,
model sizes, and costs for LLM training using EHR data. This analysis provides
a framework for thinking about these questions in terms of data scale, compute
scale, and training budgets. | [
0.0153855057,
0.0864072815,
-0.0094546862,
-0.0215280987,
-0.0167299714,
0.049124945,
0.0238677096,
0.0409823284,
0.0475145765,
-0.0008855464,
-0.0034342606,
-0.0661871508,
0.0096821459,
0.0498527065,
0.0093020918,
-0.0358141698,
0.0399862714,
0.0067438828,
0.0000961102,
-0.0176747143,
-0.0256140474,
0.0048041381,
-0.0227638222,
0.0338638313,
0.0358694457,
0.0265718065,
-0.0097132204,
0.0072723445,
-0.0139552904,
-0.0611583218,
-0.0045025018,
0.0183301773,
0.0043690521,
0.0341805667,
0.0000017679,
-0.0673682392,
-0.0492175892,
0.0480222739,
-0.0595255457,
-0.0006338588,
0.0654614419,
-0.0496534742,
-0.0299481079,
0.0334777161,
-0.0041774865,
-0.03908794,
0.0565138273,
0.0134012392,
0.0143580446,
0.0686174557,
-0.0133828288,
0.0008543703,
0.01307768,
-0.0404147543,
-0.0031204806,
-0.0114575457,
0.0501618125,
0.0185728539,
0.0177492984,
-0.0113157704,
-0.0032536404,
0.0379610434,
-0.006280663,
0.0447865911,
-0.0110147782,
0.0435991548,
-0.0482265539,
0.0207798108,
-0.0146935657,
0.0186378807,
0.0351291075,
0.0068621864,
0.0482674092,
0.0093570324,
-0.0240311474,
-0.0133323846,
-0.0225633606,
0.0192043819,
-0.0011190731,
0.0223385226,
-0.0030027903,
-0.0435840786,
0.0439074375,
-0.006822322,
-0.0180661995,
0.010188845,
0.0164224543,
-0.0458958335,
0.0367831029,
-0.0033638494,
-0.0106155118,
-0.0156247457,
0.0103361625,
0.0239765402,
-0.0020643952,
0.0194551665,
-0.0227835495,
0.0240673628,
0.0828565359,
-0.0308863297,
0.0202838555,
-0.0016388758,
0.01322807,
0.0435083099,
0.0255318061,
-0.0145631833,
-0.0377717614,
0.0256929882,
-0.0363365598,
0.0280041229,
-0.0341177694,
0.0220349748,
-0.0219744276,
0.0096405922,
-0.0030154143,
0.0228555594,
-0.1152205318,
-0.0206072591,
0.0366832018,
0.0163750779,
0.0337446779,
0.0094203679,
-0.0265891142,
0.0084979031,
-0.0140764071,
0.0285923835,
0.0445657,
0.0378522128,
-0.0199995656,
-0.0770559907,
0.0225451756,
0.0133856842,
0.0056523187,
-0.0132397218,
0.0371038616,
0.0613570102,
0.0410767943,
-0.0348621793,
-0.0255527571,
-0.0156468134,
-0.0385771245,
-0.0473840348,
0.0001047675,
-0.0725683346,
0.0155294333,
0.0155499708,
0.0136316745,
-0.0548516773,
0.0085467231,
-0.0105096968,
-0.0667905509,
0.0558658801,
-0.0720417276,
0.011825474,
0.0351363458,
0.0039965352,
-0.0027674551,
0.0576615632,
0.0342627913,
-0.0577001683,
0.0003235471,
-0.0463783555,
-0.0217789747,
0.0565777607,
0.0126861436,
0.022584606,
-0.0001470776,
0.0090256101,
0.0541175529,
0.0657808557,
-0.030248696,
0.0674357414,
-0.0121515961,
-0.0120980721,
0.0320518352,
0.0978473425,
0.0491259508,
-0.0081395889,
-0.0143874139,
-0.0211334731,
0.010158753,
-0.0743147954,
0.0010615884,
-0.0298027098,
0.012437433,
-0.0048020077,
-0.0152249476,
0.0068792142,
-0.0612305962,
-0.0243447144,
-0.0459521264,
-0.0160639156,
-0.0246952046,
-0.0345797241,
0.0730825737,
-0.0527977385,
-0.005057991,
0.089265503,
0.0590157546,
-0.0469241552,
-0.0170363579,
-0.0785080791,
-0.0377888046,
0.0517879725,
0.0245390497,
-0.0181016289,
-0.0154137332,
-0.0439359583,
0.0210436787,
0.006632173,
0.05185939,
0.0123331333,
0.0204502735,
-0.051124759,
0.0052033393,
0.0308947805,
0.0100697307,
-0.0161851216,
0.0200727098,
0.040454518,
-0.0142426658,
-0.0309149716,
-0.0611461326,
0.0364826545,
-0.0994796604,
0.002162098,
-0.0187710281,
-0.0030332149,
0.0699141845,
0.0093903476,
-0.0096428236,
0.0118042538,
0.021704698,
-0.0244514421,
0.0032753162,
-0.0192204099,
0.013891547,
0.0016201697,
0.0080529964,
-0.0004844674,
0.0418482348,
-0.0548883118,
-0.0193201583,
-0.0304161496,
-0.0295100268,
-0.0478353761,
0.0558601283,
-0.0212145355,
0.0475072525,
0.008819459,
0.0041881506,
-0.0302144811,
-0.0078438222,
-0.0569229834,
0.030349277,
0.0070331902,
-0.0383717827,
0.0344113968,
-0.0454449058,
-0.0361460187,
0.0016331178,
-0.0072459448,
0.0387470312,
-0.0303512458,
0.0125294402,
-0.0290976353,
-0.0412125699,
-0.1039616317,
0.0017353382,
0.0034229287,
0.0416717976,
0.037415769,
0.0408831798,
-0.0145693719,
-0.0039320257,
-0.0302819628,
-0.0057338895,
0.0414094478,
0.0254680198,
-0.0032290972,
0.0100012999,
-0.0412732065,
-0.0320710093,
-0.0151892975,
-0.0255786646,
0.025329452,
-0.0011024178,
-0.030101601,
-0.0301560387,
0.0095423898,
-0.0082497466,
-0.0005690549,
-0.0145903947,
-0.0382851772,
0.0114815067,
-0.0130635565,
0.0208616368,
0.0158657711,
-0.0364004001,
0.0099054528,
0.0387926884,
0.0011457884,
-0.0417732634,
0.0013746023,
-0.0267827362,
-0.0377877541,
-0.0207666568,
-0.0611636564,
0.0056009423,
0.0928965062,
-0.0139916185,
0.0182921309,
-0.0031238901,
-0.0238893591,
-0.037140362,
0.012784807,
-0.0554389916,
0.067684941,
-0.0453872681,
0.0449131243,
0.031181369,
-0.0630005747,
0.027261408,
-0.0237987209,
0.045942802,
-0.0597526729,
-0.047858052,
-0.0490882248,
-0.0071987021,
-0.0285069291,
0.0086091431,
-0.0011048556,
-0.0261302944,
0.0146147311,
0.0077177663,
-0.0014800908,
-0.0562981665,
0.0509063937,
-0.0268651061,
0.0609974004,
-0.015654169,
-0.0391172767,
-0.0360516757,
-0.0047255219,
-0.0372982547,
-0.0080784271,
0.0122460555,
0.0086099589,
-0.0373807736,
0.041945897,
-0.0056499895,
0.0979928002,
0.0319811516,
-0.0038968192,
0.0317955315,
0.0077263433,
-0.0018316741,
-0.010137016,
-0.0090035703,
-0.0426008068,
0.0379908793,
0.0238487124,
0.0387170278,
0.0344030634,
0.0085677495,
-0.0024931885,
0.0433248132,
-0.025319621,
-0.0181373507,
0.0460656062,
0.0415337309,
-0.0197788253,
-0.0080195293,
0.1045759991,
0.009674455,
-0.0770577341,
0.0241105352,
-0.0236838721,
-0.002304049,
-0.011227442,
0.0061438251,
-0.0772167891,
0.0094365701,
0.0051350933,
0.0441347845,
-0.0164019503,
-0.0308744498,
-0.0008763057,
-0.0399415568,
0.0187836345,
0.0122803897,
-0.0483278073,
-0.0066554369,
-0.0394738317,
-0.0026552521,
-0.0420473143,
0.0120517351,
0.0103945341,
-0.0425450392,
-0.0295065101,
0.0215629302,
-0.0598548613,
-0.0840271935,
0.0182805285,
-0.0253887773,
0.0883568451,
0.0582567863,
0.0157385878,
-0.0469029807,
-0.0272707064,
0.0364060402,
0.0219939165,
-0.0048585334,
-0.0128767779,
0.0938393846,
0.0435183793,
-0.0034368339,
-0.0380354747,
0.0439272039,
-0.0436126329,
-0.004040014,
0.0230422914,
0.0601039305,
-0.0506433547,
-0.01392393,
0.0161940455,
0.0000711408,
0.0118899336,
0.0309762657,
-0.007867462,
-0.0352677517,
-0.0244583357,
0.0175257642,
0.01300867,
0.0348758213,
-0.0201473255,
0.0589176007,
-0.0363969728,
-0.0199115947,
-0.0152899008,
-0.0050673792,
0.0449679941,
0.0044294428,
-0.0015521199,
0.0162403509,
0.0532435551,
0.0142380986,
-0.0468019247,
0.0466123596,
-0.0176813677,
0.0233978387,
-0.0948578864,
-0.059447147,
0.0355348699,
0.0104703596,
0.0016999673,
-0.0238695331,
-0.0384940989,
-0.0289478768,
0.0362286754,
0.0315952115,
0.031178588,
0.0206359178,
0.0196878668,
-0.0026816733,
0.006571833,
0.0381768271,
-0.0690532997,
-0.00915852,
-0.0147317136,
0.0226395205,
-0.0326716192,
0.0141450725,
0.008621023,
0.0217222925,
0.0320656039,
0.0060750218,
-0.0096896309,
-0.0357247144,
0.0005968723,
0.0682783499,
0.0374139585,
-0.0202996004,
-0.0094518131,
-0.0371440426,
0.0188753773,
-0.0078831166,
0.0538151525,
-0.0404768549,
-0.0371330529,
0.0283496324,
0.0167134255,
-0.0351183526,
-0.0150884036,
-0.0465685278,
-0.0393297635,
-0.0670424625,
0.0678661466,
-0.0113860713,
0.0132768154,
0.0918763503,
-0.0188442115,
-0.009010734,
0.0535429716,
-0.016467642,
0.0289576761,
0.0101219779,
0.0769754797,
-0.032418523,
0.0427492447,
0.0124826878,
0.0460254252,
-0.014551851,
-0.0698781386,
-0.0105705354,
0.04903768,
0.0238630511,
0.0235270783,
0.0566197932,
-0.0323342457,
0.0101908846,
-0.0485754088,
0.0278593656,
-0.0222731512,
0.0249824282,
0.0521692112,
0.0079236832,
-0.0391454808,
0.0111935884,
0.1061773896,
0.0479160808,
0.0678213388,
-0.0068682954,
-0.0147095919,
-0.0317334384,
-0.0188294481,
0.0346151441,
-0.0304852165,
-0.0686737597,
-0.0022051048,
-0.0578337796,
-0.0678703859,
-0.0006021516,
-0.024872167,
-0.0286032371,
-0.0227214694,
0.0339527167,
0.0166862458,
0.0055063129,
0.0032151835,
-0.0152933253,
0.0384276398,
-0.0351666696,
-0.0412665904,
0.0492638983,
-5.486868573e-33,
0.0266521797,
0.0225374904,
0.0303999595,
-0.0104402136,
-0.0020569169,
0.0549473949,
0.0055183596,
0.0076397108,
-0.0036109029,
-0.0206060018,
-0.0240678899,
0.0069258702,
0.0217457395,
0.0365790129,
0.0213686265,
-0.0174289811,
0.0197533835,
-0.0134572955,
0.0054671066,
0.0178839229,
-0.034339197,
0.0393883847,
0.0647688508,
-0.0474543907,
0.0068233632,
0.0184144489,
0.0170882195,
0.0046418039,
-0.0179323666,
0.0341503844,
-0.0537405796,
0.0368973501,
0.0210174546,
-0.0563088618,
0.0194074251,
-0.0240341481,
-0.0612132363,
0.0171604995,
0.0037577648,
-0.0025734759,
-0.006215882,
-0.0448987447,
0.0337465182,
-0.017292656,
-0.061558336,
-0.0015406588,
-0.0214436129,
-0.0449589007,
-0.0312007852,
-0.0051280013,
0.0089703519,
0.0616395473,
-0.0031331994,
0.0411703996,
-0.0008670805,
-0.0239482634,
-0.0758159533,
0.0068848799,
-0.0383080766,
-0.0035071655,
0.0613400675,
0.0165525693,
0.0046013361,
-0.0194881577,
0.0012873539,
0.0441761538,
0.0208858643,
0.0192290489,
-0.0193094481,
0.0149166975,
-0.0042091948,
0.0257701371,
0.0279093198,
0.0114769284,
0.0039352118,
-0.043576207,
-0.0969202369,
0.0195074975,
-0.0180275571,
0.0022453147,
0.0246464107,
-0.022347983,
-0.0310116783,
-0.0438347757,
-0.0351139195,
0.0020217411,
-0.0026101442,
-0.036474254,
0.0319379829,
0.004037411,
0.0273959953,
0.0099162394,
0.018898055,
-0.0306167547,
-0.0223714411,
-0.0293332357,
0.0389217734,
0.0054785614,
-0.0430056453,
0.0275177211,
-0.0901834443,
-0.0306657217,
-0.0009658998,
0.0128067546,
0.0405608825,
-0.0082523301,
0.0160122905,
-0.0092460848,
-0.0782589242,
-0.0026815091,
0.0163477641,
0.0190903265,
-0.0046942425,
0.0127397887,
0.0469235517,
-0.0188016426,
0.028027337,
0.0642494634,
-0.0033241268,
-0.0289264061,
-0.0445084795,
-0.0255077071,
-0.0008683502,
0.0205776487,
-0.0529819168,
0.0133847268,
-0.0543873273,
0.0282745101,
0.0332915932,
-0.0198491458,
-0.001408964,
-0.0173492879,
2.485e-7,
0.0882693529,
0.0461687036,
0.0122828595,
-0.0302082356,
0.005841109,
-0.0096269613,
-0.0094599165,
-0.0039612455,
-0.0145380124,
-0.0005503055,
0.0398699678,
-0.0053023733,
0.0830985308,
0.0220797472,
-0.0600102618,
-0.0253145583,
-0.1010467112,
-0.0061584045,
-0.0324623622,
-0.0235831644,
0.0198643096,
0.070153676,
-0.026988117,
-0.0514470413,
-0.0093688769,
0.0187708698,
0.0415509976,
-0.0817166865,
-0.0022279995,
0.0218249988,
0.0030515161,
0.0161473453,
0.0063461638,
0.030523669,
0.0007919684,
-0.0082277423,
-0.025217535,
0.1336419731,
-0.0517404117,
0.0654272363,
0.0637260228,
-0.025581833,
-0.0264687128,
-0.0387669802,
0.0657363087,
-0.0520815589,
-0.0560752265,
-0.0128884604,
-0.0049682604,
-0.041094318,
0.0661205873,
-0.0336191803,
0.011109774,
0.0220207758,
0.0265264567,
-0.005399514,
-0.035384886,
-0.0244241543,
0.0090370961,
0.0330702811,
-0.0201234855,
-0.0706936717,
0.0276101008,
0.0173638482,
-0.006667872,
-0.0672493353,
0.0365438052,
2.341821912e-34,
0.0341841914,
-0.012244706,
0.022733571,
0.003461879,
0.0245926175,
-0.0172534734,
0.0610427633,
0.0069839414,
-0.0140682776,
-0.105722025,
-0.0003623334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12466v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12466v2 | Are ChatGPT and GPT-4 Good Poker Players? -- A Pre-Flop Analysis | 2023-08-23T23:16:35 | 2023-12-21T15:14:46 | Akshat Gupta | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.GT | Since the introduction of ChatGPT and GPT-4, these models have been tested
across a large number of tasks. Their adeptness across domains is evident, but
their aptitude in playing games, and specifically their aptitude in the realm
of poker has remained unexplored. Poker is a game that requires decision making
under uncertainty and incomplete information. In this paper, we put ChatGPT and
GPT-4 through the poker test and evaluate their poker skills. Our findings
reveal that while both models display an advanced understanding of poker,
encompassing concepts like the valuation of starting hands, playing positions
and other intricacies of game theory optimal (GTO) poker, both ChatGPT and
GPT-4 are NOT game theory optimal poker players.
Profitable strategies in poker are evaluated in expectations over large
samples. Through a series of experiments, we first discover the characteristics
of optimal prompts and model parameters for playing poker with these models.
Our observations then unveil the distinct playing personas of the two models.
We first conclude that GPT-4 is a more advanced poker player than ChatGPT. This
exploration then sheds light on the divergent poker tactics of the two models:
ChatGPT's conservativeness juxtaposed against GPT-4's aggression. In poker
vernacular, when tasked to play GTO poker, ChatGPT plays like a nit, which
means that it has a propensity to only engage with premium hands and folds a
majority of hands. When subjected to the same directive, GPT-4 plays like a
maniac, showcasing a loose and aggressive style of play. Both strategies,
although relatively advanced, are not game theory optimal. | [
-0.0029698387,
0.008099854,
-0.0462642834,
-0.0178109556,
-0.0388425142,
0.0010899141,
-0.0294586606,
0.0362880975,
0.0393881463,
0.0216541234,
-0.0233678147,
-0.0106691616,
0.0149479322,
0.0577133372,
0.0639220327,
-0.0298063178,
-0.0018157648,
-0.0033540605,
0.0671947375,
-0.0035987762,
-0.0085285669,
-0.0635403022,
-0.0131388344,
0.0378708169,
0.0198153369,
-0.0140320351,
-0.0291491803,
-0.0116729997,
0.0005465143,
-0.0545479767,
0.0207218882,
0.0068382402,
0.0021611215,
0.0190976821,
0.0000022929,
-0.0325162001,
0.0050348854,
-0.0440884829,
-0.0030733892,
0.032979168,
0.0108329644,
0.0554913543,
0.0424822792,
0.0276875515,
-0.0396516882,
-0.0217996221,
0.0408345535,
0.0691394731,
-0.0035905382,
0.0394096337,
0.0123326061,
0.07611949,
0.0278160293,
-0.0708083957,
-0.0115277795,
-0.0626108125,
0.018025592,
0.0026015299,
-0.0340354331,
-0.0359545238,
-0.0151290074,
-0.037906684,
-0.0043393378,
0.0278604273,
-0.0386841074,
0.0317247063,
-0.0160707533,
0.0397475846,
-0.0095050018,
-0.0231771339,
-0.0390573218,
0.0144210635,
0.0177960694,
-0.0366459638,
0.0690098479,
-0.0362909734,
-0.0161656924,
0.0046869102,
0.0052282955,
-0.0008393562,
0.0077261929,
0.0402291939,
0.0097897006,
0.0034869504,
0.0408932827,
-0.010844999,
-0.0097939605,
-0.0351458788,
-0.0065610162,
0.018455809,
-0.018120002,
-0.0788018629,
-0.0495024621,
0.0171537735,
-0.0692595169,
0.0170048401,
0.0485257655,
0.0779309347,
0.0057357089,
-0.0275354963,
0.0246720836,
0.0852733552,
0.0541730113,
0.0025683786,
0.0087687466,
0.0176273733,
-0.0196533203,
0.0027994644,
-0.0127749937,
0.0739961788,
-0.0335306823,
-0.0362820365,
-0.0131856557,
0.0204653181,
-0.0076425956,
-0.0232322663,
-0.04928229,
-0.0033844437,
-0.0242862087,
0.0090691587,
0.0026646177,
0.0278572273,
0.0151097775,
0.022748569,
-0.0527256839,
0.0213840548,
-0.0583116747,
-0.0027066492,
0.0283319894,
-0.0632466674,
-0.0037949726,
-0.0259808283,
-0.0452524163,
-0.0089423424,
0.0363652855,
0.04453668,
-0.0012145925,
-0.001127383,
-0.0006723767,
0.0150928553,
0.0185527038,
-0.0996712595,
0.0077160443,
-0.0235634111,
0.0173688978,
-0.0299419314,
0.0020952364,
0.0285736155,
0.0066435514,
-0.0340266414,
-0.0028518445,
0.0643399432,
0.0543267168,
0.0252886042,
0.0325556658,
0.0059530386,
-0.0809148848,
0.0646151975,
-0.0000022125,
0.0031569779,
-0.0096905082,
-0.0579527505,
0.0315454304,
0.0527954809,
-0.0415253863,
0.0114912,
0.0273578148,
-0.0054819994,
0.049446255,
0.0392080098,
0.0073921303,
0.0196281746,
-0.061741434,
0.0354221538,
0.0967345312,
0.01081979,
0.0574557595,
0.0250750985,
0.044823125,
0.009624335,
0.014459285,
0.0129109006,
-0.0265440512,
-0.0084347529,
-0.0070771496,
0.0265717674,
-0.0103092389,
-0.0191102568,
-0.0040276712,
-0.0269960389,
0.0163155496,
-0.0080307415,
0.0256335884,
0.0216919202,
-0.0283207372,
-0.0744328275,
-0.0533648133,
-0.0389629118,
0.0251126736,
0.0200724732,
-0.0609940439,
-0.1001902893,
0.0039010562,
0.0334421024,
0.0319797583,
-0.0005330069,
-0.032731384,
-0.0219809581,
-0.0777050406,
0.0051501924,
0.087165162,
0.0160202011,
-0.0117103541,
-0.0089838086,
-0.0188126098,
0.0252462868,
0.0197976511,
0.1068586484,
0.0056861858,
0.0166600179,
-0.0071094818,
0.0592983849,
0.0212915652,
-0.02055775,
-0.0301593747,
-0.097333394,
-0.0340784676,
-0.0260193441,
0.0475363135,
-0.0158902556,
0.015988471,
0.0191355459,
-0.0219952874,
0.0402879938,
-0.0144651663,
-0.0019983568,
-0.0229106639,
0.0652190596,
0.0035760358,
-0.0015486632,
0.0231643748,
-0.0081369253,
-0.0017997408,
-0.0038224135,
-0.0128632504,
0.023182869,
0.0805122033,
-0.0098990826,
-0.0112576215,
-0.0233173799,
0.0232270639,
0.0355044492,
0.0642710626,
0.0413241908,
-0.0119072655,
-0.0154854786,
-0.0549856983,
0.0014867651,
-0.1074967459,
0.0475346036,
0.0209922194,
-0.0188797954,
0.0101473331,
0.059769351,
0.0940055102,
-0.0472174548,
-0.0002558887,
-0.0783932582,
0.014463787,
-0.0031770715,
-0.0005851904,
0.0193720292,
-0.0525229238,
-0.0461146943,
0.0249324534,
0.0164239742,
-0.0213530324,
0.0553785563,
0.0360852405,
-0.0067781047,
0.0335615054,
-0.0050673913,
-0.0200918969,
0.0005520415,
-0.0255672727,
-0.0198961161,
-0.019646218,
-0.0321134813,
0.0144612575,
-0.0062182434,
0.0028790387,
0.0050902702,
-0.0267303344,
-0.0253336579,
0.0202372745,
-0.0120733203,
-0.0117417304,
0.04255208,
0.0010294154,
0.0662934408,
-0.0045706099,
-0.0268462971,
-0.0075636278,
0.0376602039,
-0.010072628,
-0.0437848009,
-0.0594020411,
-0.0605466589,
0.0196134578,
0.0910170302,
0.0069259326,
0.0328741595,
-0.0581343621,
-0.0184200369,
0.0215758104,
-0.038117189,
-0.0047439206,
-0.0020209355,
-0.0346719846,
0.002194426,
-0.0088012563,
0.0185618363,
0.0119701875,
0.0219855364,
-0.0060712988,
0.0065269889,
0.0194499735,
0.0145549783,
0.0567372106,
0.0424800292,
-0.0342122726,
0.0178001449,
-0.0207164157,
-0.0478557609,
-0.072156541,
0.0424845926,
-0.0065742759,
-0.0207055397,
-0.0013139512,
-0.0298133623,
-0.0178009626,
-0.0249792859,
0.0042011049,
-0.0310501847,
-0.0215549842,
0.023481492,
0.0890443251,
-0.0105802892,
-0.0522271283,
-0.018530596,
0.0238359179,
-0.0163496304,
-0.0260154102,
-0.0320126601,
0.0012698971,
-0.0493940264,
0.0379168354,
0.0093175713,
0.0483547412,
-0.03507559,
0.0484782867,
0.0297588035,
-0.0388512388,
-0.0099742524,
0.0310053416,
0.0254996456,
0.0173135046,
-0.0115827806,
-0.0611539558,
0.0880142972,
-0.0279287938,
-0.0428208634,
0.042464532,
0.0556166843,
-0.0145578654,
0.0217646603,
-0.0028127569,
-0.0070885685,
0.049541574,
-0.0130445501,
0.0269821677,
-0.0679837242,
-0.0096687153,
-0.0107579567,
0.0378726423,
-0.0534700714,
-0.0277977157,
0.0156411026,
-0.1205984354,
0.0198289827,
-0.0129079232,
-0.0613032505,
0.0522306152,
0.0236616023,
-0.0027842175,
-0.0531177521,
0.0431484878,
0.0290680472,
-0.0116503863,
-0.0055739814,
0.0118301669,
-0.018040536,
0.036512848,
0.0314275436,
-0.0242710821,
-0.0009815219,
-0.0001263081,
0.0215561278,
-0.0134920953,
-0.0256937016,
-0.0024035377,
0.0303193927,
0.0018410739,
0.0375236422,
0.0496414118,
-0.0534152798,
0.0354732201,
-0.0266618691,
0.0144772213,
0.0431255698,
0.0353525579,
0.0490201488,
0.0094585149,
-0.0117167737,
-0.0728157163,
0.0445536189,
-0.0146796079,
0.0262837652,
0.0339238718,
-0.0023326373,
-0.0183540117,
-0.0378344208,
-0.0008395246,
0.0421825238,
-0.0131597305,
-0.0353796519,
-0.0638316423,
0.0836438164,
-0.0499719866,
-0.0255601071,
-0.0780582875,
-0.0385248922,
0.015854774,
-0.0107503384,
0.0447718464,
-0.0566182323,
0.0339613482,
0.0020171534,
0.0012395229,
0.0026121221,
-0.0522778928,
-0.0574471913,
-0.0329958797,
-0.0129801175,
-0.112875618,
-0.020077737,
-0.0026491696,
0.0253695957,
0.0173528492,
0.0399699733,
0.0693105459,
0.0363965109,
-0.0545745306,
-0.0010628669,
0.0422284491,
-0.0413200706,
0.027579993,
-0.0431635305,
0.0239034463,
0.0301219765,
0.0163952466,
0.0047148042,
-0.0035019945,
0.0067325202,
0.0154930465,
0.0158275217,
0.0393898189,
-0.0181728434,
-0.0094589666,
0.0098004425,
0.0162333343,
0.0610858686,
-0.021156244,
-0.0135068484,
0.0315121487,
-0.0332106501,
-0.0509223938,
0.0024501972,
0.0053298017,
-0.0816824362,
0.0110638207,
0.0473696925,
0.0077004652,
-0.0376355387,
-0.0056858691,
-0.0043671266,
-0.0293169525,
-0.0079302732,
0.0245457385,
-0.0213677604,
-0.0169332456,
-0.0103892703,
0.0103255371,
0.0102737499,
0.0012507079,
0.0187609494,
0.0261756629,
0.0439909436,
0.0264535584,
-0.05685528,
0.0217794329,
-0.0026226928,
-0.0348344222,
-0.1060373858,
0.046237886,
0.0729909539,
0.024537418,
-0.0366070643,
-0.0435627997,
-0.0761155114,
0.0021567771,
-0.0178580973,
-0.0414841175,
0.0111786686,
-0.0324098207,
-0.0105752125,
0.0128865391,
-0.0375304036,
-0.0462795123,
0.0058580199,
0.016342232,
0.0417280979,
-0.0286843404,
-0.0286899116,
-0.0326323062,
-0.0219448544,
0.0330991596,
0.0517103449,
-0.0488115661,
0.0162412114,
-0.0910078138,
0.0321011841,
-0.0667851791,
0.0482585914,
-0.0218691509,
-0.0133673362,
0.001763071,
0.0332531482,
-0.0375657193,
0.0050115981,
-0.0041673938,
0.0428025387,
-0.0394231491,
0.0258996449,
-0.0351417027,
-6.265703008e-33,
0.0205756016,
0.0088258712,
0.0525439158,
0.0050970358,
-0.0171324518,
-0.0215032604,
-0.0372194275,
0.0282328073,
0.001778656,
-0.0213873796,
-0.0445967354,
-0.0180646945,
0.0115106953,
-0.0431216322,
0.0593186207,
-0.0686641484,
0.012884438,
-0.0069157765,
-0.0510037839,
-0.0113066994,
-0.0197360702,
0.0054154061,
0.087299794,
-0.009407863,
0.0041255862,
-0.0365935974,
-0.0161423609,
-0.0317931473,
-0.0323438458,
-0.0189573187,
-0.009602312,
-0.0413232744,
0.0120872045,
-0.0848146304,
0.0394702703,
-0.0109940814,
0.020804245,
-0.0063357977,
0.0053714793,
-0.0340562388,
-0.0038265826,
-0.0210396685,
-0.00797744,
0.0188648608,
-0.0395300984,
-0.0315706916,
0.0114738317,
-0.001078499,
0.032017488,
0.0208971091,
-0.0004204729,
0.0119930478,
-0.03074052,
-0.0135381958,
-0.0301109385,
0.0432683043,
-0.0413115732,
-0.0152859567,
-0.0418321788,
0.0337844938,
0.0209062006,
-0.003966256,
-0.0107760308,
0.0232989602,
0.0789535567,
0.0020864985,
0.0233314242,
0.0588768758,
-0.027784558,
-0.0463211015,
-0.0098248711,
0.0595486984,
-0.0086940685,
0.0074176234,
0.0474313833,
-0.0507152528,
-0.0045942799,
0.0373909064,
0.0979738012,
0.0398520604,
0.0013095435,
0.028081039,
-0.0734210461,
-0.0111124339,
0.0181574319,
-0.053370975,
0.0086272284,
-0.0527859591,
0.0139708109,
-0.0002010682,
0.0360105895,
0.0141493203,
0.0611244328,
0.015148825,
-0.0148103237,
-0.0379327573,
-0.0088511966,
0.0618140586,
0.0025951092,
-0.0250516683,
-0.0297296923,
-0.0258941669,
-0.0025944754,
-0.0006329448,
0.0270659532,
0.0066557992,
-0.026754545,
0.033282049,
-0.011121382,
0.0059953863,
-0.0109385513,
0.0588787459,
0.0403480865,
-0.0597958975,
0.0267894082,
-0.0069729788,
0.0316972174,
-0.0664330423,
0.0002177267,
-0.0300896522,
-0.031477835,
0.032726068,
-0.0327693224,
-0.0026138171,
0.0583541915,
0.0426441506,
-0.0382931307,
0.0577496812,
-0.015161898,
0.0058200629,
-0.0270997025,
-0.0310867783,
3.121e-7,
-0.0097632809,
0.0395236872,
-0.0417172201,
0.0097117415,
-0.0018935762,
0.0932701007,
-0.0302225817,
-0.0067935395,
0.0422065705,
-0.038396135,
0.0837956443,
0.0496152341,
0.0362204164,
-0.0132188257,
-0.0333541222,
-0.0702194348,
-0.0348095782,
-0.0023397037,
-0.0032159707,
0.0354305282,
0.0145201422,
-0.0178791061,
0.0283127408,
-0.00823652,
0.0294991657,
-0.002583242,
0.0258442573,
-0.0717133507,
0.0238759741,
0.013231392,
-0.0012415121,
-0.0068801218,
-0.0427282751,
0.0315032117,
0.0052675656,
0.0080943145,
-0.0070965192,
0.0585501157,
0.0138570853,
0.0297623128,
-0.0182829984,
-0.0090742288,
0.0052581122,
-0.0791001543,
0.0486545227,
-0.0354304723,
-0.0444285907,
-0.0040340596,
-0.0653334558,
0.001792671,
0.0188316312,
-0.0361315161,
-0.0166427661,
-0.000948054,
-0.0152468411,
0.0092540095,
0.0136351362,
0.0018075431,
-0.0042618024,
0.0260413494,
-0.0281340107,
-0.0423991457,
-0.0070948368,
0.0082510579,
0.037945047,
-0.0874966606,
-0.0055638491,
2.717524371e-34,
-0.0031322043,
0.0205417667,
0.0374128036,
-0.0598727986,
0.0501805842,
0.017889034,
0.0626057759,
0.0139589254,
0.054901123,
0.0239525959,
-0.007708461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05935v1 | Vulnerability Clustering and other Machine Learning Applications of Semantic Vulnerability Embeddings | 2023-08-23T21:39:48 | 2023-08-23T21:39:48 | Mark-Oliver Stehr, Minyoung Kim | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Cyber-security vulnerabilities are usually published in form of short natural
language descriptions (e.g., in form of MITRE's CVE list) that over time are
further manually enriched with labels such as those defined by the Common
Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS). In the Vulnerability AI (Analytics and
Intelligence) project, we investigated different types of semantic
vulnerability embeddings based on natural language processing (NLP) techniques
to obtain a concise representation of the vulnerability space. We also
evaluated their use as a foundation for machine learning applications that can
support cyber-security researchers and analysts in risk assessment and other
related activities. The particular applications we explored and briefly
summarize in this report are clustering, classification, and visualization, as
well as a new logic-based approach to evaluate theories about the vulnerability
space. | [
-0.0161888674,
-0.00111152,
-0.016726872,
0.0085003506,
-0.0393572375,
-0.0364315957,
-0.0019925181,
0.0009690729,
0.0702341348,
-0.0548796691,
0.0578048453,
0.0244950596,
-0.0157923494,
0.0405932069,
0.0581781939,
-0.0423586927,
0.0784874558,
-0.0017991796,
0.0019466589,
0.0460195541,
-0.0212719422,
-0.0092323348,
-0.0451302528,
0.0773114339,
-0.0162365343,
-0.0094962306,
-0.0072145225,
-0.0119070886,
0.0718744323,
-0.059629485,
-0.0540760569,
-0.0131625421,
0.0224206541,
-0.0245108008,
0.0000017829,
-0.0466810651,
-0.0172895566,
0.0357371047,
0.015662469,
0.0042624329,
0.0330248103,
-0.0422279835,
0.0062643378,
0.0488753505,
0.0012556892,
-0.0241022799,
0.0417659692,
0.0520960353,
0.0676478446,
0.0589664616,
-0.004942385,
-0.0159361903,
0.040940173,
0.0289642569,
-0.0132447425,
-0.0480532534,
0.0022040715,
-0.0061682672,
-0.0066294218,
0.0164776351,
0.0164668504,
-0.0076080579,
0.0063762865,
0.0231164973,
0.0346552171,
0.0438204668,
-0.0123933414,
0.0186023787,
-0.0020385606,
0.0123863667,
-0.0154341608,
0.0254000518,
-0.025732452,
0.0039141234,
0.0038830969,
0.0005305866,
0.0424812771,
0.0083695091,
0.0007470038,
-0.0168858748,
0.0403222889,
0.0448135361,
0.0139818881,
-0.0248369947,
-0.0160696357,
0.0537047051,
-0.0194721147,
-0.0006953182,
0.0086209383,
-0.0809333324,
0.0194953904,
0.0115211904,
-0.0020617745,
0.0029049048,
-0.0017161515,
0.0228961669,
-0.040223524,
-0.0013213049,
0.0648009852,
-0.0367664099,
-0.0144988392,
-0.0047972337,
0.0169575587,
0.0057964372,
0.0164440554,
0.0162299033,
0.0242438894,
0.028907571,
-0.0153347887,
-0.0020276941,
-0.0947821811,
-0.0361790992,
0.0106680756,
0.0477552637,
0.059327811,
0.005669219,
-0.0429450944,
0.0095315455,
-0.0699583143,
0.0423858017,
-0.0249505974,
0.0092231734,
0.0056998045,
0.0508051291,
-0.0190050211,
-0.024877103,
-0.0456361808,
-0.0034645209,
-0.0512244962,
-0.0331268124,
0.0071215741,
-0.0065688472,
-0.0311915316,
-0.0131626576,
-0.0441705734,
0.1015812978,
0.0764528587,
-0.0010925196,
-0.0459113754,
-0.04587055,
-0.0113648474,
0.0549735911,
-0.0259299185,
-0.0279436577,
-0.0400923304,
-0.0055995332,
0.0107260533,
-0.031133268,
-0.0267404169,
0.0027200491,
-0.0507889986,
0.0826905072,
-0.0244848114,
-0.0182112772,
0.048594553,
0.0056698532,
0.0441655517,
-0.0132544376,
0.0190605968,
0.0231855381,
0.0129883094,
-0.0272773299,
0.0267852861,
-0.0391052626,
-0.0099068619,
0.0037173023,
0.001084189,
0.0226819925,
0.0228534378,
-0.0176810361,
-0.0206007976,
0.0111618387,
0.0115376813,
-0.043126069,
-0.0077632973,
0.0506171063,
0.0344441012,
0.0216109995,
0.042708382,
0.0385743529,
-0.0244584605,
-0.0356623866,
-0.0388287306,
0.0225387849,
-0.0446307473,
-0.0435058624,
-0.0166679434,
0.0069117304,
0.0003020734,
-0.0225381441,
-0.0505504422,
0.0006241354,
0.0105085447,
-0.0678880215,
0.005121727,
0.0212005768,
0.0248527918,
0.0018291124,
0.0358988121,
-0.008791104,
0.0033206032,
-0.0462742262,
-0.0606810227,
0.0644198954,
0.0185460579,
-0.0807489231,
-0.0579213202,
-0.0033292603,
-0.0527211428,
-0.0349836722,
0.0285313483,
0.0032213831,
-0.0335377306,
-0.039632611,
0.0250190366,
-0.0428187586,
0.0303574782,
0.0164565053,
-0.0301218145,
0.0091712251,
0.0048219669,
-0.0489736274,
-0.0236813948,
0.05117568,
0.0887437984,
-0.0055194129,
0.0104184784,
0.0378487632,
0.0793500841,
0.0157181025,
0.0106441472,
0.0574670359,
0.0574945994,
-0.0028493509,
-0.0542756431,
-0.0152796069,
0.0237131715,
0.0291362461,
0.0158923138,
-0.0671793073,
0.0500444174,
0.0136354901,
-0.0674357042,
0.0198277123,
0.0649110004,
-0.0812723786,
-0.0330892801,
0.0034703063,
-0.0149674416,
0.0084951958,
0.0062240711,
-0.0482465401,
0.0750424936,
0.0124650057,
0.0015013999,
-0.060397964,
0.0085193617,
0.0280477386,
-0.0311275609,
-0.0130068632,
-0.0258067511,
-0.0489047915,
0.0332255326,
0.0143604912,
-0.0156779867,
0.015907364,
0.0055843405,
-0.074763827,
-0.0175912902,
0.0116936723,
0.0264032222,
0.0200685132,
-0.0652612969,
-0.0152469939,
-0.0023652781,
0.000797114,
-0.0176856406,
-0.018706819,
0.0014435779,
0.0387667827,
-0.021754913,
0.0014366544,
-0.0253136661,
-0.0081675341,
-0.0606803969,
0.0719898716,
0.0312717184,
0.0067545841,
-0.0315993205,
0.042956382,
-0.0373653769,
-0.0043954281,
0.0031236748,
-0.0583822206,
0.0183314346,
0.0082447883,
-0.029806504,
-0.0344385281,
0.0277952887,
0.1173888445,
0.0717425346,
0.0131829986,
0.0099124312,
0.0142830815,
-0.0121916933,
-0.0136918975,
-0.0406282954,
-0.0295917206,
0.0414630994,
-0.0113595072,
0.0608777776,
-0.0237759631,
-0.0454038009,
-0.0007761536,
-0.0382345468,
0.0099712154,
-0.0257479977,
-0.0679046512,
0.0375387743,
0.0042317943,
0.003014595,
-0.0511183441,
0.0789144635,
0.0158799421,
0.0489535332,
-0.106568642,
-0.067485176,
-0.0442840531,
0.0538160875,
0.0030998623,
0.0336843245,
0.0444830991,
-0.0109150577,
-0.0266070478,
-0.029396981,
-0.0216247886,
0.0120035885,
-0.0268478226,
-0.0113149034,
-0.0235195607,
0.014068272,
0.0205921996,
-0.0406248234,
-0.018092934,
-0.0148080457,
0.0246467441,
-0.0081394818,
-0.0022450215,
-0.0268627536,
0.0218220502,
0.0296815597,
-0.0346293971,
0.0804731622,
-0.0471909344,
-0.0118340217,
-0.0239835642,
-0.017233992,
-0.0608659051,
0.0090382099,
0.0641294941,
0.0068366989,
0.0286326483,
0.0579970516,
0.0227068886,
-0.0614167601,
-0.00317701,
-0.0302388258,
-0.086370334,
0.0102502489,
0.0435685664,
-0.0295488331,
-0.0151266875,
0.0107035609,
0.0582448207,
0.0729858726,
0.0050741159,
0.0647566691,
-0.011224281,
-0.0499801748,
0.0335896984,
0.0115974369,
-0.0024303333,
0.0131023899,
0.0163593795,
-0.0137949223,
-0.0050291442,
-0.0296510123,
0.0286160987,
-0.0645812452,
0.0270953327,
-0.0138120307,
-0.0308768563,
-0.0189973358,
-0.0775594115,
-0.0355273373,
0.0086436812,
-0.0264417194,
-0.0227686074,
0.0222723298,
0.0029383611,
-0.0000389839,
-0.0829614773,
-0.0521493331,
0.0267677978,
-0.0357919037,
0.0278636403,
0.0280394703,
0.0487899333,
-0.0601635762,
0.0164037719,
0.0315801203,
-0.0391632542,
0.0477640256,
0.0082690502,
0.0762950331,
0.0063194293,
-0.005601028,
0.0308193862,
0.016203478,
-0.0278077312,
-0.0294128917,
0.0706207231,
0.0350364037,
-0.0501800664,
0.0267710071,
-0.0507195331,
0.0012862929,
0.0045114616,
0.0261613596,
0.0160931814,
-0.0208959617,
0.0288828015,
-0.0189317651,
0.073935464,
0.0180773884,
-0.0304867662,
0.0306505039,
-0.0146775348,
-0.0630388707,
-0.0551428385,
-0.0551689565,
-0.0021920721,
0.0052873846,
0.0380067714,
-0.0711864308,
0.0286673345,
0.011848283,
-0.0628177747,
0.0009885004,
0.0224600006,
0.0512019061,
0.01398216,
0.0299512651,
0.0057260226,
0.0456685498,
-0.067821309,
0.0135640055,
-0.0211684778,
-0.0390794054,
-0.0201266762,
0.01256816,
0.0077376426,
-0.0555420034,
-0.0584830493,
-0.0412515849,
0.0891842693,
0.0267064143,
-0.0548856147,
-0.0223354492,
0.0138795394,
-0.056991592,
0.0106270956,
-0.0103120487,
-0.0001332382,
0.0059879008,
-0.0285549313,
-0.012731757,
-0.0358066149,
0.0048577809,
0.0036419693,
0.0032175048,
0.0749894008,
0.0329496525,
-0.0119008683,
0.0144286724,
-0.0055521722,
-0.0094198603,
-0.0195902381,
0.0521835424,
0.0078877108,
-0.0018853226,
-0.0125552742,
0.0258019362,
-0.0071158395,
-0.0219445452,
-0.0139737315,
0.0672426671,
0.0502764583,
0.1031064689,
0.0545536168,
0.0065391213,
0.0218016952,
0.0229782481,
-0.0380975716,
-0.0332028605,
-0.0204647556,
-0.0001141038,
-0.0268168394,
-0.0159643162,
0.0082693081,
-0.0445621647,
0.0472284816,
-0.0281583369,
-0.0171142444,
0.0535851829,
0.0152950883,
0.0357087441,
0.0573370084,
-0.0377608351,
-0.0365719795,
-0.0130245471,
-0.0072651189,
0.0182719231,
-0.0126190018,
-0.0579680316,
0.0511390604,
0.0076501328,
-0.0253271814,
-0.014995357,
0.0344294868,
0.000124766,
0.0486665741,
-0.0120861791,
-0.0677511021,
-0.014519549,
0.0015578874,
-0.0041078408,
0.0506180264,
-0.0163446516,
-0.0014431101,
-0.0842121914,
-0.0651052743,
0.0798515603,
-0.0026268773,
0.0342353359,
0.02862533,
0.0125980852,
0.0408191122,
0.0121600889,
0.0209793393,
-0.0532847419,
-0.0310244244,
-0.0734499618,
-0.0507903844,
-0.0104259793,
-5.158982791e-33,
0.0133540351,
-0.0580701567,
-0.0080743292,
-0.0004506326,
0.0164572783,
0.0200875942,
0.0010388045,
-0.0072839498,
-0.0074073169,
0.0002746368,
0.031187851,
-0.0061308867,
-0.0086784242,
-0.0028941955,
-0.0141529953,
0.0020360525,
-0.0105657522,
0.0046877335,
0.000304203,
0.0023418593,
0.0514426902,
-0.0203290023,
-0.0162343271,
-0.1065516695,
0.0302026458,
0.0411194116,
0.0036976375,
-0.0030370818,
0.005218456,
0.0252780188,
-0.0129836174,
0.0470249616,
0.024484165,
-0.0008339945,
0.0404849164,
-0.0168505684,
-0.019840207,
-0.054014314,
-0.0381082185,
-0.0379729494,
0.0218985695,
-0.0450691395,
-0.0022655844,
-0.0001195213,
0.0364054516,
-0.012977805,
0.0590129197,
0.0196690075,
-0.0032451837,
-0.0222912449,
-0.0218864828,
0.0221523698,
-0.0878292322,
0.0432223901,
-0.0263906419,
-0.0150057152,
0.0501454808,
-0.0028816322,
-0.0389612317,
0.0291208308,
0.0040857634,
-0.0038629326,
0.034977898,
-0.0062926696,
-0.0343416892,
0.0280828159,
-0.0331171118,
-0.0500678308,
-0.0017158819,
0.0448357202,
0.0195172355,
0.0447309986,
0.0471666157,
0.0125676384,
0.0006046939,
-0.0271186382,
-0.0788609758,
0.0306232087,
-0.0429026745,
0.0555276237,
0.0097808409,
0.0187660437,
-0.0891393349,
-0.0036503735,
-0.054476928,
-0.0390206613,
-0.025848018,
-0.0254254267,
0.0074253972,
-0.055285573,
-0.0638044924,
0.0406343006,
-0.0428671129,
-0.011823019,
0.0093519837,
0.0200413279,
0.0334602594,
0.0145870894,
-0.0207309108,
0.0138431853,
0.0141153373,
-0.0171813201,
-0.0008496836,
0.0121626817,
0.0409830213,
-0.0432432815,
0.0267262049,
0.0061163628,
-0.0488937497,
0.0338449553,
0.0112515837,
-0.0181475487,
-0.0077261454,
0.0653323904,
0.0188065618,
0.024066275,
-0.0040580747,
0.0074110259,
0.0286747515,
0.0069675581,
0.0111955693,
0.0504586548,
-0.0517653115,
0.0070874421,
0.0059124851,
-0.0029544143,
-0.0126300706,
0.04000891,
0.035307385,
-0.0337104388,
-0.0147047127,
-0.0110075325,
2.658e-7,
0.059016753,
0.0221035816,
0.0387522876,
0.0240032505,
0.0012534859,
0.0543277934,
0.0224126168,
0.0660550147,
-0.0281518716,
-0.0018248056,
-0.0035979704,
0.0309556052,
-0.0223543476,
0.0305447672,
0.0157797188,
0.0179354288,
-0.0190139264,
-0.0142135266,
-0.0539377928,
0.0383052863,
0.1074727997,
0.0531224012,
0.0274531152,
-0.0006917822,
-0.044346977,
-0.0763176829,
-0.0454737842,
0.011330938,
0.0148397703,
0.0246696249,
-0.015211856,
0.0652201772,
0.0212837122,
0.0561068021,
-0.0268843509,
-0.0298366249,
-0.0211910382,
-0.0505514145,
0.0265498124,
0.0049379454,
-0.0473325588,
-0.0135156419,
-0.0068806279,
-0.0263852607,
0.0303280838,
-0.0393524952,
-0.0345072523,
0.0363717079,
-0.0098565463,
0.0450684763,
0.0442860909,
-0.0336618833,
-0.0191933867,
-0.0066549582,
-0.0242975708,
-0.031085588,
0.046339564,
-0.0841168091,
-0.0018726815,
0.0047009662,
-0.0301984288,
0.0222651847,
0.0538617447,
0.0464919098,
0.0704037547,
-0.0069849784,
0.0006097584,
2.335095192e-34,
-0.002592609,
-0.0352465883,
-0.0245155711,
-0.0534975044,
0.0284517389,
0.0081020957,
-0.0430668108,
0.0181903001,
-0.0136220148,
0.0084121414,
-0.0119740516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12420v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12420v2 | Evolution of ESG-focused DLT Research: An NLP Analysis of the Literature | 2023-08-23T20:42:32 | 2024-02-05T16:06:14 | Walter Hernandez, Kamil Tylinski, Alastair Moore, Niall Roche, Nikhil Vadgama, Horst Treiblmaier, Jiangbo Shangguan, Paolo Tasca, Jiahua Xu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | As Distributed Ledger Technologies (DLTs) rapidly evolve, their impacts
extend beyond technology, influencing environmental and societal aspects. This
evolution has increased publications, making manual literature analysis
increasingly challenging. We address this with a Natural Language Processing
(NLP)-based systematic literature review method to explore the intersection of
Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT) with its Environmental, Social, and
Governance (ESG) aspects. Our approach involves building and refining a
directed citation network from 107 seed papers to a corpus of 24,539
publications and fine-tuning a transformer-based language model for Named
Entity Recognition (NER) on DLT and ESG domains. Applying this model, we
distilled the corpus to 505 key publications, enabling an inaugural literature
review and temporal graph analysis of DLT's evolution in ESG contexts. Our
contributions include an adaptable and scalable NLP-driven systematic
literature review methodology and a unique NER dataset of 54,808 entities,
tailored for DLT and ESG research. Our inaugural literature review demonstrates
their applicability and effectiveness in analyzing DLT's evolution and impacts,
proving invaluable for stakeholders in the DLT domain. | [
0.062181171,
0.0492858849,
-0.0006177025,
-0.0064775487,
0.0079636173,
0.016438894,
0.0456018448,
0.0378122367,
0.0200957283,
-0.0423266217,
-0.012844976,
0.0609263815,
0.0275514871,
0.0596070774,
0.0893485621,
-0.0259033367,
0.0357611105,
0.0584408753,
0.0630984157,
-0.0028910821,
0.0074375183,
-0.0085253241,
0.0281494632,
0.0214416143,
0.0676969737,
-0.009214499,
0.0058105094,
0.022638388,
0.0074205757,
-0.0656907931,
-0.001701436,
0.0339187719,
-0.0203681234,
0.0642304346,
0.0000023299,
-0.0398738571,
-0.0795876682,
0.0319454111,
-0.0282426085,
-0.0022661418,
0.0638610646,
-0.0258045439,
-0.0074220952,
0.0042670676,
-0.0138142249,
-0.0925236493,
0.0437531807,
0.0613563359,
-0.0266439114,
-0.0062960451,
-0.0094132125,
-0.0373227969,
0.0477813259,
-0.0154496673,
-0.0279029962,
0.0209075604,
0.0387226231,
0.0403289571,
0.0489578098,
0.0256837569,
0.0051329103,
0.0455933735,
-0.0336414315,
0.0078251902,
0.0741554052,
0.0359243639,
-0.0264586974,
0.026193548,
-0.0336586908,
0.0263224505,
0.0560715348,
0.0267060306,
0.0709195659,
-0.0371994413,
-0.0491433814,
0.0419871882,
-0.0329650566,
0.0226849876,
-0.0311683845,
-0.0032639869,
0.0019843862,
0.0132344002,
0.0263150409,
0.0498253964,
0.0088925455,
0.0328768641,
0.0051776734,
-0.0429471582,
0.0014265922,
0.024651207,
0.0289201308,
-0.036829114,
0.0059849364,
-0.0334423706,
0.0327998102,
0.0103230057,
0.0612738915,
-0.0129312705,
0.0628112182,
-0.0101136286,
0.0092657255,
-0.0483349301,
0.0112190023,
0.0174397361,
-0.008289705,
-0.0113773691,
-0.0471184291,
0.0024992193,
0.0272697192,
0.0112789413,
-0.041328907,
-0.0370023847,
-0.0227080416,
0.0127010588,
-0.0378901511,
0.0139974449,
-0.0391430035,
-0.0156969018,
-0.0052840197,
-0.0047634104,
0.0206095334,
0.0240366813,
0.0327239893,
-0.0082592051,
0.0095073041,
0.012130172,
-0.0185459666,
0.0146439141,
-0.0049162749,
0.0485130996,
0.0111360317,
-0.0093536694,
0.0314058438,
-0.006879542,
0.0417103693,
0.1192035675,
0.0866612718,
-0.0568000674,
-0.0600823574,
-0.0164118242,
0.0099580465,
0.0113244923,
0.0170463081,
-0.0355183855,
-0.0059372452,
-0.0222093854,
0.0138911661,
0.0072453385,
-0.0174372736,
0.0046837693,
-0.0721910968,
0.0335669927,
-0.0985736996,
-0.0556143932,
0.0153280459,
-0.0124213267,
0.0398264118,
-0.0512588695,
0.0482184775,
-0.0313738398,
0.0551548675,
-0.0164987259,
0.0063718185,
-0.0100502409,
-0.0066541517,
-0.074114807,
0.0724872872,
0.0017440483,
-0.0117634889,
-0.0326425061,
-0.0051968498,
0.0176150408,
-0.02058932,
-0.0039142249,
0.050447192,
0.0861070231,
-0.0003149427,
-0.0034759501,
-0.0038028785,
0.057286974,
0.0087077226,
-0.0325353704,
-0.040427085,
-0.0041040261,
0.0305869859,
0.0003812332,
-0.0253995545,
0.0324651785,
-0.0167119466,
-0.002608197,
-0.0382040739,
0.0182778835,
0.0286036581,
0.0001597891,
0.0099015823,
0.0096807322,
-0.0535940006,
0.0581910014,
0.0209775548,
0.0192351881,
-0.0032383767,
-0.042041529,
0.008641284,
0.0411501601,
0.0952897817,
0.0260335002,
0.0205480102,
-0.0259945747,
-0.0707242414,
0.0650825202,
-0.0753923804,
-0.0065051797,
-0.0406273678,
-0.0070996173,
-0.015143943,
0.0484967232,
-0.0075888075,
0.0221788883,
0.0026250912,
0.0046542222,
-0.0096945092,
-0.0667556822,
-0.0110867294,
0.0288276132,
-0.0165079236,
-0.0359488241,
-0.0071676653,
0.0104088411,
-0.0114008822,
0.015904434,
-0.0043327766,
0.010459369,
0.0041757822,
0.0411287956,
-0.0696138293,
-0.002631109,
0.0496225208,
0.0841063187,
0.0166855156,
-0.0424962975,
0.0319188759,
-0.0131896436,
0.0138308415,
-0.0353949405,
0.0191945098,
0.0226306133,
-0.0155960592,
-0.0031139208,
-0.0520206541,
-0.0169199258,
-0.0031087301,
-0.0514233746,
0.0342025533,
0.0318368599,
-0.0001317098,
-0.0516333356,
-0.0451429226,
0.0420171544,
0.0218436942,
0.0119599253,
0.0185663588,
-0.0568969883,
-0.0087493435,
0.059178587,
0.0115608312,
-0.0299379043,
-0.0277649239,
-0.0111299017,
-0.0094150333,
0.0329663008,
0.0558346584,
0.004376845,
0.0172835384,
-0.0232861768,
0.0235421769,
0.0115900319,
-0.0178201851,
0.0060499706,
-0.0380047858,
0.0301504768,
0.0071776262,
0.0023716046,
-0.027614126,
-0.0071249371,
-0.0211551357,
0.0474059209,
0.0325878598,
-0.0181822535,
-0.0205485076,
0.0096667176,
-0.0237739533,
-0.0212833546,
-0.0131197022,
0.0633243844,
0.0341010652,
0.0839180797,
-0.0090243118,
0.0083243009,
-0.0053431927,
0.0315778255,
-0.008903455,
-0.0516200438,
-0.0064914487,
-0.0136047881,
0.0077792392,
0.0478481725,
-0.0071120774,
-0.0150607415,
0.0390485525,
0.0446612388,
-0.0169896018,
0.0019382671,
-0.0346493982,
-0.0152189797,
-0.0050876271,
0.0110876532,
-0.0153245376,
-0.0311173853,
-0.0097837541,
-0.0053180866,
-0.0002865484,
-0.0112079354,
0.0339143649,
-0.0419246554,
0.0049414458,
-0.0293764286,
-0.0123397512,
-0.0429023392,
0.0405625589,
-0.0003787547,
-0.0060862489,
0.0378293805,
-0.0546832792,
0.0242950488,
-0.0085946415,
0.0325334929,
0.0069076871,
-0.0242999941,
-0.0184461847,
0.0213312116,
-0.0014228112,
-0.0148173822,
0.0222951155,
-0.0310662948,
-0.0397492647,
0.0755311847,
0.0394407064,
-0.0252821762,
-0.0023866403,
0.0284453519,
0.0315708369,
-0.011358439,
0.0155260246,
-0.0379692614,
-0.0495514348,
0.0114429127,
0.0035185304,
-0.0796277747,
0.0884260312,
0.0590819716,
-0.0057487977,
0.018656984,
-0.0130317323,
-0.0492845811,
-0.0098168878,
-0.0306009129,
0.0139372628,
-0.0711270943,
0.0083460193,
-0.0194741599,
0.0027751387,
-0.0054900083,
0.0128941089,
0.0627083331,
-0.0002886865,
-0.027346395,
-0.0100229271,
-0.0137388743,
-0.0247636754,
-0.0070212185,
0.0271714628,
-0.1161016151,
0.0124407066,
-0.0026035774,
0.0257492214,
-0.0083966376,
-0.0810324028,
-0.0190782733,
-0.0159514882,
0.0710707158,
-0.0260972437,
-0.0078432439,
0.0413361788,
-0.0404836386,
-0.0189680904,
-0.0446702056,
-0.004474578,
-0.0591977015,
-0.0723422021,
-0.0008816117,
0.0260647293,
-0.0345570892,
0.0211754963,
0.0140922237,
-0.048011072,
0.0543513112,
0.0587143898,
0.0159605034,
-0.0284474548,
0.0325919241,
-0.0102344071,
-0.0353525616,
-0.0384330861,
0.0206233654,
-0.0091686938,
0.0121187922,
0.0196994171,
0.0012323826,
-0.0074140932,
-0.0587861091,
-0.0393775627,
0.0255522653,
0.0500627309,
-0.0000127806,
-0.0192267951,
-0.0154527798,
-0.0204703845,
0.0164679885,
0.0171908047,
0.0013355039,
-0.0008596365,
-0.0244250111,
0.0148443114,
0.0267281849,
0.0411877558,
0.003990043,
-0.0284224339,
-0.0306218956,
-0.024662517,
-0.0079256603,
-0.0524953045,
-0.0283352993,
-0.0335722342,
0.0028813554,
0.0247267708,
0.1701644361,
-0.0525695458,
-0.0074580973,
0.0002492874,
-0.0652716085,
0.011796358,
-0.0283255689,
0.0425685756,
0.0151201133,
0.043028634,
-0.0333063975,
0.0316766761,
-0.0572285615,
-0.0036781733,
0.0259392094,
-0.0673179254,
0.0149967643,
-0.0587928556,
-0.0410181507,
-0.0121298358,
0.024192838,
0.0340640098,
-0.001454786,
-0.0425354056,
0.0478008911,
0.0107173063,
-0.0431262068,
-0.0233199429,
-0.025095854,
0.0273772441,
0.0134501355,
-0.0162853394,
-0.0322590955,
-0.0126965214,
-0.0007445335,
0.0251076799,
0.0899960473,
-0.0616778247,
0.0530564561,
-0.0152730225,
-0.0509704612,
0.02385219,
0.0373733118,
-0.0355969742,
-0.0530658849,
-0.0148728332,
-0.0179228634,
-0.0449332409,
0.0784522891,
-0.0471894406,
0.0140238749,
-0.0551977865,
0.0748192966,
-0.0534322709,
0.0597262159,
0.0020115434,
-0.0275387634,
0.0275412537,
0.0049810293,
0.0090483371,
0.0185350627,
0.0074455095,
-0.02289721,
0.0121902553,
-0.0160539206,
-0.0499010608,
0.039500948,
-0.0376127325,
-0.038641341,
0.0358854942,
0.0050700707,
0.0254910812,
0.0429730155,
-0.0003687613,
-0.0357664526,
-0.021926593,
0.0080424054,
0.0185882971,
-0.0269804057,
-0.0328185111,
-0.007251733,
0.0222311039,
-0.066326268,
-0.0146778254,
0.0396213047,
0.0143041164,
-0.02192601,
-0.0175326858,
-0.0205691829,
-0.0121267159,
-0.0601046532,
-0.0336789563,
-0.0273031667,
-0.0172229912,
0.0152945574,
-0.0335472375,
0.0090485523,
0.012436348,
-0.0087606609,
-0.0073429518,
-0.0114217671,
0.007213864,
0.0013126293,
0.0288801976,
-0.0126093617,
-0.0070561189,
-0.0157818813,
-0.0406191498,
-0.0676304623,
-0.0184458736,
-6.931907819e-33,
0.0172196981,
-0.0671758354,
0.0587679222,
0.0150603866,
-0.0093279583,
0.0181810893,
-0.0258944705,
0.0280977599,
-0.0142776333,
0.0399168655,
-0.0445767455,
0.0012735995,
0.0157781579,
0.0373161435,
0.0119903469,
-0.0000704039,
0.0171791073,
0.0035645196,
0.0023375836,
0.0099700755,
-0.0009853351,
0.0122596426,
0.0825795755,
-0.0728693977,
0.111501269,
0.0194445178,
-0.0106265005,
-0.0335594825,
0.0089954035,
0.0209964011,
-0.0361238234,
0.0010975294,
-0.0016112934,
-0.0820098966,
-0.0202073827,
0.0114913723,
-0.1137520745,
0.0329234153,
-0.005590064,
0.0181476865,
0.0172231421,
-0.0360686742,
0.0117873941,
-0.0244466364,
-0.0497052148,
0.0370126031,
0.031251885,
-0.0088094948,
-0.0390960015,
-0.0703484863,
-0.019449668,
0.0322729051,
-0.0115232943,
0.1010604277,
-0.0075995093,
0.0197442416,
0.0021038665,
0.0837564021,
-0.1077324301,
0.0013774962,
-0.0099466303,
-0.0589127503,
-0.0035536573,
-0.0159650762,
-0.0104217185,
0.0484423898,
-0.0600396432,
-0.0203042347,
-0.0110344021,
-0.019729523,
0.0070340377,
0.0162003785,
0.0383029096,
-0.0087732086,
0.0323805809,
-0.0253858287,
-0.0387513936,
0.0254342631,
-0.0238480195,
0.0253609475,
0.0189448241,
-0.0093379114,
-0.0049137129,
-0.032332249,
0.0047778408,
-0.0799570531,
-0.0014975731,
-0.0010749801,
-0.0214226954,
-0.0073293662,
-0.0214959737,
0.0084730582,
-0.0088885101,
-0.0852150247,
-0.0701365247,
0.0351096392,
0.0130353495,
0.0262708869,
0.0372930728,
0.0128214741,
-0.0628318414,
-0.0467870273,
-0.0114067001,
0.0367417224,
-0.001485373,
-0.0353029296,
0.0278386697,
-0.0313267522,
-0.0555611216,
0.0552091226,
0.0236100648,
0.0280571617,
-0.0146555435,
-0.0166346822,
-0.0437888838,
-0.0111014554,
0.0440023616,
-0.0280594751,
0.0347867906,
0.0095438892,
0.0546720549,
0.0866420865,
-0.0145594003,
0.056180317,
0.0331379622,
0.0421017483,
-0.0351090319,
0.0183057599,
0.0220520813,
0.0130496193,
0.0033722774,
-0.0063482155,
3.133e-7,
0.0421955325,
0.0260101985,
0.0160987694,
-0.0229959898,
0.0248575024,
0.0379189849,
0.0497853719,
0.0427460074,
-0.053490717,
0.0105019575,
-0.0145522673,
-0.0109280273,
0.0336985774,
-0.0214522984,
-0.0629429594,
-0.0501137488,
-0.0521840304,
0.0099811247,
-0.049752485,
0.0128686074,
-0.0688069314,
0.0108256154,
-0.0162086152,
-0.0128877647,
-0.0299340971,
-0.0409635715,
-0.0093460949,
-0.0467088148,
0.0366958007,
-0.0039976118,
0.0361001939,
0.0460651889,
0.0209842529,
-0.0306686964,
-0.0028691427,
0.0151786692,
-0.0291850232,
-0.000135596,
0.0261587761,
0.0578811467,
0.0118637597,
-0.0814249292,
0.0147111956,
-0.0181368832,
0.0182515364,
-0.0516097024,
-0.05655073,
-0.0232971441,
-0.0668862462,
0.0058749528,
0.0379832275,
0.000269545,
-0.0096233729,
-0.0116397776,
0.0072280937,
-0.044611305,
0.004173134,
-0.0344829783,
0.0541937202,
0.0313976109,
0.0238255803,
0.0526512079,
0.0041098581,
-0.0064986865,
0.0396115258,
-0.0195107125,
0.0554683395,
2.650502826e-34,
0.0107478863,
-0.0203113947,
-0.007120207,
0.0223693959,
0.0306888334,
0.0047695138,
-0.0477436483,
0.0075808368,
-0.0040296349,
-0.0815817192,
0.0410836153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12419v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12419v1 | Toward American Sign Language Processing in the Real World: Data, Tasks, and Methods | 2023-08-23T20:38:19 | 2023-08-23T20:38:19 | Bowen Shi | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Sign language, which conveys meaning through gestures, is the chief means of
communication among deaf people. Recognizing sign language in natural settings
presents significant challenges due to factors such as lighting, background
clutter, and variations in signer characteristics. In this thesis, I study
automatic sign language processing in the wild, using signing videos collected
from the Internet. This thesis contributes new datasets, tasks, and methods.
Most chapters of this thesis address tasks related to fingerspelling, an
important component of sign language and yet has not been studied widely by
prior work. I present three new large-scale ASL datasets in the wild:
ChicagoFSWild, ChicagoFSWild+, and OpenASL. Using ChicagoFSWild and
ChicagoFSWild+, I address fingerspelling recognition, which consists of
transcribing fingerspelling sequences into text. I propose an end-to-end
approach based on iterative attention that allows recognition from a raw video
without explicit hand detection. I further show that using a Conformer-based
network jointly modeling handshape and mouthing can bring performance close to
that of humans. Next, I propose two tasks for building real-world
fingerspelling-based applications: fingerspelling detection and search. For
fingerspelling detection, I introduce a suite of evaluation metrics and a new
detection model via multi-task training. To address the problem of searching
for fingerspelled keywords in raw sign language videos, we propose a novel
method that jointly localizes and matches fingerspelling segments to text.
Finally, I will describe a benchmark for large-vocabulary open-domain sign
language translation based on OpenASL. To address the challenges of sign
language translation in realistic settings, we propose a set of techniques
including sign search as a pretext task for pre-training and fusion of mouthing
and handshape features. | [
-0.0503316931,
0.0247928426,
0.010773181,
0.0156724993,
-0.0248763505,
0.0287223831,
0.0350792222,
-0.0083177462,
0.0451173596,
-0.0294323936,
-0.0491792373,
-0.0524527133,
0.0402129851,
0.0298030041,
0.0155651001,
-0.0404279046,
0.0148576088,
0.0015836409,
-0.0579434708,
-0.0055275047,
0.0396559611,
0.0231666546,
-0.0612323582,
0.0713080317,
-0.0635252893,
0.0185682513,
0.0057018101,
0.0100536095,
0.0219770335,
0.0051460215,
-0.0721909553,
-0.0005460473,
0.0499932505,
0.0078220619,
0.000002228,
-0.0051391274,
0.0062922728,
-0.0153772412,
0.0181635022,
0.0126207257,
0.0304328054,
-0.0609141663,
-0.0275837835,
0.0651134849,
-0.0177637693,
-0.0725682974,
0.0589409694,
0.0614167936,
-0.0128979171,
0.0113022979,
-0.0070400173,
0.0102121597,
0.0263185613,
-0.0178680923,
0.0101569835,
0.0353750512,
0.0070692101,
-0.0501222685,
0.0326932147,
-0.0690712184,
-0.0226679668,
0.0883323625,
0.0095531205,
-0.0632718056,
-0.0076970267,
0.0164683945,
-0.0162387267,
0.0000341723,
-0.00637373,
0.0410966016,
-0.036835514,
-0.0025898896,
0.0412802696,
-0.0241057072,
0.0161056388,
0.0160446968,
0.0002673086,
0.0534191169,
-0.0118665881,
-0.0222169571,
-0.0387533084,
0.003889147,
0.051431857,
-0.026912285,
0.0140699511,
0.0359861366,
0.0237390045,
-0.0177324023,
-0.0077133458,
-0.0398537852,
0.0314863697,
-0.0245529674,
0.0884491578,
-0.0139988875,
-0.0301993694,
-0.0271925926,
-0.0325788334,
-0.0258747637,
-0.042174492,
-0.0656727254,
0.0329895504,
0.0565627366,
-0.0165678244,
-0.0098997196,
0.0368423462,
0.0044076862,
-0.0390371121,
0.0808578953,
-0.0375938565,
0.0322827771,
-0.0260021668,
0.00281937,
-0.0496920384,
-0.0592615008,
-0.0097031305,
-0.0343153961,
0.0017237078,
-0.0193914156,
-0.003019609,
-0.0601620041,
0.0300337411,
0.0283190887,
0.0291121621,
-0.0185523387,
0.044039607,
0.0709809214,
-0.010967955,
0.0447213948,
-0.0223306715,
-0.0235419814,
-0.0059888558,
0.0443813428,
0.0498475507,
0.0087806368,
0.0292523634,
0.0373966061,
0.0021926828,
-0.0246098712,
0.0265605375,
0.0285943393,
-0.0056835548,
0.0140016899,
-0.0187395439,
-0.0347448997,
0.0184630435,
-0.0300611537,
-0.0063305437,
-0.0828873739,
-0.0132031264,
-0.014912935,
0.0437725112,
0.0789073557,
-0.0012046334,
0.0006408424,
0.0449095778,
-0.0281138066,
-0.0196111631,
-0.0118241282,
0.0339320749,
0.0139955552,
0.0062716734,
-0.0409974866,
0.0267363098,
0.086307168,
-0.0324142426,
-0.0098471688,
0.0238478966,
-0.0167291444,
0.0190021731,
0.0483274609,
-0.0119974669,
0.0301298499,
-0.0251457486,
-0.0333718657,
0.0351177454,
0.0992375612,
0.0358599164,
-0.0466799997,
0.0138596874,
0.0441653468,
0.004953857,
-0.0560899116,
-0.0230588671,
0.0375341736,
0.0216530915,
-0.0477562472,
-0.0380093753,
0.0021705965,
-0.0547030754,
-0.0080056135,
0.0092853252,
-0.0212310255,
0.014731992,
0.0304107126,
0.0484941527,
0.0255398136,
-0.0543912686,
-0.0290916488,
-0.0158084314,
-0.0308959242,
0.0111225657,
-0.0429666191,
-0.0368358158,
0.0254745297,
-0.0169116985,
-0.0073337387,
-0.0033860262,
-0.0225898847,
-0.0056718532,
0.022037033,
-0.0371759646,
0.0052441079,
0.0360525437,
-0.0413672961,
-0.0204677153,
0.0723078996,
0.0039910376,
0.0362685844,
-0.0569353215,
0.0405913293,
0.007837317,
-0.0032431467,
-0.0105074476,
0.0529492386,
0.0034031682,
-0.0267673526,
0.041091945,
0.0090276422,
0.0337418877,
0.0094032353,
-0.0108980369,
-0.0186291113,
0.0034071398,
-0.0360341445,
-0.0081806304,
0.0387245826,
-0.0521807,
-0.0100924345,
0.0471583679,
-0.0990876481,
-0.0286283456,
0.039639838,
0.034122631,
-0.0544707328,
0.0544170737,
-0.0180124268,
0.0348119698,
-0.0162515771,
0.0340864956,
0.0090210438,
-0.0226032566,
-0.0128153218,
-0.0159361325,
-0.0153051671,
-0.0629334003,
-0.0608067587,
-0.0239700302,
0.0065754843,
-0.0874613822,
-0.009532663,
0.0033623329,
-0.0592344999,
0.0431798175,
0.0318552107,
0.0416398309,
-0.0087454757,
0.0010915105,
-0.0504260287,
0.0030929905,
-0.0347024761,
0.0266698897,
-0.0108730141,
0.0127783287,
0.0108082313,
-0.0365476683,
-0.0026364857,
0.0107004447,
0.0363743007,
-0.0700531453,
-0.0439923927,
-0.0112936283,
-0.0327415094,
-0.0084810108,
-0.0273424312,
0.0011446077,
-0.0149356499,
0.0190260895,
-0.0649430007,
-0.0347038023,
-0.0338390134,
0.0520120375,
0.0293538962,
0.0019874289,
-0.0117103988,
0.0432548523,
-0.0070100906,
-0.0412681736,
0.0211549159,
-0.0282838345,
0.0316206105,
0.0158134047,
-0.0131449439,
-0.0156678781,
-0.0074570808,
0.0057142386,
0.0609121285,
-0.0592120551,
0.0138520328,
0.0116666621,
0.0352319218,
0.0216003228,
0.0333058871,
-0.0665353313,
-0.074956961,
-0.0102870939,
-0.0465091281,
-0.0264470689,
0.0104681961,
-0.0463903956,
-0.0598929934,
-0.004560424,
-0.0629101247,
-0.005907381,
-0.0478179492,
-0.0313701443,
0.0513716303,
-0.0004395191,
0.0056183538,
0.0363562964,
0.0214942191,
0.0100283204,
-0.0301313922,
-0.0575778149,
0.0007071779,
0.0534752682,
0.0073721558,
-0.0029271597,
0.0194357373,
-0.0134989144,
0.0079592578,
-0.0035587333,
0.0248723626,
0.0078846198,
0.0415384509,
-0.0418172032,
-0.017456973,
-0.0028909855,
-0.0890079886,
-0.0691720918,
-0.0182130635,
0.0202838406,
0.0787711591,
0.0329239704,
-0.0003951357,
-0.0249340795,
-0.0514808074,
0.0302627143,
0.0134589076,
-0.0126688341,
-0.0313394368,
-0.0102598649,
0.0254508965,
0.0059295404,
0.0082084965,
-0.0285704564,
-0.0076739523,
0.0496702939,
0.0122889569,
-0.0025412906,
0.0346046165,
0.025261566,
-0.0357572325,
0.0214332119,
0.0772334188,
0.0274923407,
-0.0571360178,
-0.0058472739,
0.0309537221,
-0.0387035199,
-0.0282757115,
-0.0261842757,
-0.056688495,
-0.0663630292,
0.0221130718,
0.0543465875,
0.059854608,
-0.0028835242,
-0.0159851946,
-0.0289492775,
0.0166552328,
0.0047889054,
-0.0590192266,
-0.041584935,
0.0189816207,
0.0032792916,
0.0014788429,
0.0424965136,
0.0220219474,
-0.0114312042,
-0.0062284553,
0.0207346845,
-0.0035066023,
-0.0848208815,
0.0266090352,
-0.0225649308,
0.054481145,
0.0270972922,
0.0196198449,
0.0246323496,
-0.0835798159,
0.0283101685,
0.0195940137,
0.0046442607,
-0.0395904295,
0.003022138,
-0.0124236699,
-0.033931151,
-0.0132436752,
0.0790156126,
-0.104134798,
0.0289690737,
0.0545841306,
0.054686714,
-0.036678385,
0.0220301244,
0.0170917027,
-0.0496531241,
-0.0134600233,
0.0422413051,
-0.0159430038,
-0.0535393581,
-0.013719989,
-0.0090210726,
-0.006642201,
0.0369106904,
-0.0535703488,
0.0129078636,
-0.0261019282,
-0.0554938652,
-0.0011737696,
0.0024793437,
0.0470555313,
0.0510078892,
0.0155843059,
-0.0238876007,
0.0808105394,
0.0098230559,
-0.0450482517,
0.0631996468,
-0.0334403738,
0.0768098831,
-0.0868504941,
0.0074280654,
-0.0547943376,
-0.0465302654,
0.0249385554,
0.0522161312,
-0.0599744134,
-0.038226787,
0.0268805493,
0.0071056765,
0.0121853976,
0.005254718,
-0.037296731,
-0.0565498918,
-0.0513567999,
0.0016738254,
0.0123554207,
0.0137032075,
0.0361266993,
-0.1032385603,
0.0078298822,
0.0178565104,
0.0259446297,
0.0329283848,
-0.005357733,
-0.0074516702,
-0.0705693588,
-0.0304977633,
-0.0089417426,
0.0402665138,
0.0228413064,
-0.019058723,
-0.0266841706,
-0.06590873,
0.009565495,
0.0174439996,
0.0516788363,
-0.0820751339,
-0.01289583,
0.0376238488,
0.0248563718,
-0.002270929,
0.0405541435,
0.0161637329,
0.0186232571,
0.0041898759,
0.0921249911,
0.0302760173,
0.0258534811,
-0.0000622496,
0.0277159922,
0.0334002487,
0.0795492157,
0.0135781765,
0.0226221103,
0.0280795097,
0.0020466703,
0.0193703808,
0.0164799262,
0.0463435501,
0.0120472172,
0.0066441204,
-0.0301372055,
-0.0052940194,
0.0427961089,
0.0018349553,
0.0006129321,
0.0474405251,
-0.0120363394,
0.0341541767,
-0.0519124493,
0.0429138131,
-0.0127378693,
-0.045831088,
0.033465445,
-0.0228118282,
-0.0209399853,
-0.0095027993,
0.0025603508,
-0.0526618995,
-0.0056429366,
-0.016322406,
-0.0052185222,
-0.0383213013,
-0.013959988,
0.0033483675,
-0.0004111633,
-0.044046469,
0.0168445688,
-0.0145317195,
-0.0221228004,
-0.0021917268,
-0.0106479106,
-0.007928811,
0.0123206377,
0.0109823924,
-0.0670809746,
-0.0051186327,
0.0092513049,
0.0203791484,
-0.0635040849,
-0.031866543,
-0.0312505662,
0.0011374119,
-5.498929145e-33,
-0.0251055956,
-0.0464587361,
-0.0116144288,
-0.0037961192,
-0.045494169,
0.0362064205,
-0.0145849492,
0.0428127013,
-0.0136604169,
0.0318699814,
-0.0064721946,
0.0216321684,
0.0000896823,
-0.0045968536,
0.0087804347,
-0.0263829213,
0.0385047384,
-0.0342463069,
-0.0018874782,
0.0102180047,
0.0287822131,
0.0121264895,
0.0975424796,
-0.0757048354,
-0.0299207252,
-0.0153440814,
-0.0608091839,
-0.0063060811,
-0.0167026483,
-0.0067572012,
-0.0255929697,
0.0174304843,
-0.0254334193,
0.0077123526,
0.0004559643,
0.0551512502,
-0.0639998168,
0.0246739835,
-0.049036976,
0.0983558446,
-0.004872832,
0.0373599418,
0.0303457212,
0.0160059519,
-0.0464449152,
0.0115489792,
0.0452943444,
-0.0317137428,
0.0049215136,
-0.0180990156,
0.0062682489,
0.0391628668,
-0.0182298161,
-0.0683744997,
0.0244407207,
-0.0072622974,
-0.0277572609,
-0.0961797461,
-0.0352826193,
0.0330551825,
0.0203222018,
0.0182246882,
0.0517849959,
-0.0234498326,
0.0383473784,
0.0189492218,
0.021964781,
-0.0683887228,
0.0188455377,
-0.0867957398,
0.0845335871,
0.0223793611,
0.0105745513,
0.0622388981,
0.0468017869,
-0.0342272185,
-0.0029162832,
-0.0001006225,
0.0442927703,
0.0490804575,
-0.016281832,
0.0328621455,
-0.0008954844,
0.009988511,
-0.0399190299,
0.04404651,
0.0118822781,
-0.0033826565,
0.0590564683,
0.0249540769,
0.0126591818,
0.0119926762,
0.0742365867,
-0.0225318503,
0.0164692439,
0.0131610464,
0.0139080007,
0.0215215478,
0.0172883868,
0.0037147922,
-0.0740210637,
-0.015830433,
0.0553993173,
-0.0024642942,
0.0224837586,
0.0171563122,
-0.0075632767,
0.0803157985,
-0.0425132141,
0.009239045,
-0.0163440481,
0.0187949743,
0.0071374145,
0.0275605489,
0.0778594762,
-0.0449610166,
-0.0163353141,
0.0608221814,
-0.0132108079,
-0.0050681895,
0.005229102,
0.0143307913,
0.0018614609,
0.0388401039,
-0.0542324074,
0.0343779251,
-0.0240367148,
-0.0626808032,
0.035856951,
-0.0679960772,
-0.0053586783,
0.0140273646,
2.859e-7,
0.0098084053,
0.0329782479,
0.0248479433,
0.0523905791,
0.0293347798,
0.0312814005,
0.0114737255,
0.0226515904,
-0.0023857104,
0.0258611478,
0.0401358455,
-0.0152268438,
0.0603502095,
-0.0101076737,
-0.0529538207,
0.0379303098,
-0.0336093158,
0.041201368,
0.0074222684,
0.0278644077,
0.0252488423,
0.0485695302,
0.0158069544,
-0.0249274969,
0.0341799781,
-0.0824254751,
0.0273862407,
-0.0250072405,
0.0541578904,
-0.0507637374,
0.0490255319,
-0.0362706296,
-0.0324746668,
-0.0051254691,
-0.0123957256,
-0.0130770914,
0.0284520667,
-0.0044601555,
-0.0678773299,
0.0185629595,
0.0231453106,
0.0117228841,
-0.0595179982,
-0.0148366531,
0.0441692658,
-0.0153012127,
0.0082734721,
-0.0535982624,
-0.0051600551,
0.0058043851,
0.0061935871,
0.0150011769,
0.0657975748,
0.0210843366,
0.0141281961,
-0.0515168421,
-0.0199539308,
-0.0449951477,
-0.0182455909,
-0.0185965691,
0.0043339613,
0.0395993516,
-0.0368130058,
0.0134503236,
-0.0223665945,
-0.0376107097,
-0.0557118207,
2.077782463e-34,
0.0160085335,
-0.015702419,
0.0314499252,
-0.0169189014,
-0.0125555554,
-0.0280318931,
0.0487306491,
0.0329334475,
0.0044846847,
-0.0158828497,
-0.0175111257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12383v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12383v1 | With a Little Help from your own Past: Prototypical Memory Networks for Image Captioning | 2023-08-23T18:53:00 | 2023-08-23T18:53:00 | Manuele Barraco, Sara Sarto, Marcella Cornia, Lorenzo Baraldi, Rita Cucchiara | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM | Image captioning, like many tasks involving vision and language, currently
relies on Transformer-based architectures for extracting the semantics in an
image and translating it into linguistically coherent descriptions. Although
successful, the attention operator only considers a weighted summation of
projections of the current input sample, therefore ignoring the relevant
semantic information which can come from the joint observation of other
samples. In this paper, we devise a network which can perform attention over
activations obtained while processing other training samples, through a
prototypical memory model. Our memory models the distribution of past keys and
values through the definition of prototype vectors which are both
discriminative and compact. Experimentally, we assess the performance of the
proposed model on the COCO dataset, in comparison with carefully designed
baselines and state-of-the-art approaches, and by investigating the role of
each of the proposed components. We demonstrate that our proposal can increase
the performance of an encoder-decoder Transformer by 3.7 CIDEr points both when
training in cross-entropy only and when fine-tuning with self-critical sequence
training. Source code and trained models are available at:
https://github.com/aimagelab/PMA-Net. | [
0.0298902802,
0.0583135076,
-0.0006763818,
0.029540034,
0.0082822014,
0.0066940919,
0.004188735,
-0.0622404628,
-0.0381554849,
-0.0315764807,
-0.0200772211,
-0.0380934253,
0.013349764,
0.0481031127,
0.0224603098,
-0.0820151567,
0.0106515475,
0.0093693472,
-0.038350001,
0.0149934245,
-0.0013282746,
-0.0229424555,
-0.0045608073,
0.04367375,
-0.017679166,
-0.0237840433,
-0.0227689836,
-0.0127106262,
0.0163757149,
-0.0313605405,
-0.0041761817,
0.0599977113,
0.0356509574,
-0.0318732671,
0.0000022258,
0.0051751002,
0.0082328105,
-0.0288269464,
0.0129632624,
-0.0091793938,
0.0198835228,
-0.0298433937,
-0.0110218013,
-0.0117600216,
-0.013246702,
-0.0670883209,
0.1000081897,
0.0645518079,
0.077053979,
0.0319985338,
-0.0205003154,
-0.0736740679,
0.0435937978,
-0.0665649101,
0.02545546,
-0.0095160613,
0.0075497977,
0.0127201462,
-0.0218245778,
-0.0397157967,
-0.0321256034,
0.0560031608,
0.0285236519,
-0.0098589277,
0.0196908861,
0.0634805113,
-0.0141500579,
-0.0216396227,
-0.0180243626,
0.0908789337,
0.0055419854,
-0.0042690118,
-0.0262156986,
0.0019465535,
-0.0071034483,
-0.0498096049,
-0.0384342074,
0.0213096961,
0.0173521712,
0.0119850365,
-0.0465055555,
0.0483872257,
-0.0188225918,
0.0120008541,
-0.0092112031,
-0.0492906943,
0.0052784155,
0.0111038843,
-0.0156798158,
0.006371534,
-0.0146838417,
-0.0092065977,
0.0191942975,
0.0173666961,
0.0454684906,
0.0105561251,
0.0016284952,
-0.0631128103,
-0.0025987406,
-0.0627903119,
0.0174232516,
0.0088430997,
-0.053685572,
0.0516335964,
-0.0370959826,
0.0878712535,
-0.0424884334,
0.0581361242,
-0.0386000387,
-0.0151457842,
-0.0557435043,
-0.0264430754,
-0.0654831827,
0.0501769446,
0.0416170433,
-0.0199699849,
-0.0560658425,
0.024386188,
-0.0093562547,
0.0122427829,
0.0252211336,
0.0433899872,
-0.0201515406,
0.0069590993,
-0.019004887,
0.0348331071,
-0.0026480185,
-0.0148527296,
0.0033799685,
-0.0447750054,
-0.0397872515,
0.0447268002,
0.0218011569,
-0.0055915597,
-0.0122407926,
0.0662212297,
-0.0251681376,
-0.0389059894,
-0.0274758618,
0.0034490789,
-0.034324564,
-0.0218232181,
0.0349697508,
-0.0340136215,
0.022532979,
-0.0188160464,
-0.0145509783,
-0.045276165,
0.0043501817,
0.0150144659,
-0.0015491985,
0.0845958516,
0.021371901,
-0.0625346452,
0.0080700815,
0.0216684379,
0.0026173524,
0.0643654987,
0.0546458028,
0.0456514694,
-0.0057877149,
-0.0112508247,
0.0124026109,
0.0126536796,
0.019111963,
-0.0305707157,
-0.0229636356,
-0.0147999059,
0.0109324269,
0.0183398593,
0.0615465157,
0.0451014675,
-0.0135397334,
-0.017503649,
0.0728161186,
0.0245036706,
-0.0290415119,
0.0662316605,
0.0367016681,
-0.0056790896,
-0.0145428674,
-0.0086954031,
-0.0518636368,
0.1013759226,
0.0519835353,
0.0028850918,
-0.0205820426,
-0.0090404302,
-0.0773396119,
-0.0434443243,
0.0349210799,
-0.0239401478,
-0.022068385,
-0.0096619045,
0.0387683697,
0.0293015484,
-0.0658586994,
0.0865943059,
-0.024370363,
-0.0320252478,
-0.0106416689,
-0.0280728303,
-0.022254033,
0.0582410321,
0.0107999612,
-0.0215662289,
-0.0214313213,
-0.0175538007,
0.0227762368,
0.0381058231,
0.015878832,
0.0273875482,
-0.0074018524,
-0.058849249,
-0.0161901638,
-0.0355582461,
0.0138288941,
0.0442561321,
-0.0059666191,
0.0101866415,
0.0311879832,
0.0422423258,
-0.0022385758,
0.0220155008,
0.0627753213,
-0.024440689,
-0.0171594881,
0.007428458,
0.0306015555,
0.0107730022,
-0.0144099817,
0.0312256087,
0.0288395062,
-0.0365980789,
-0.0302667283,
0.0721807331,
-0.0879089087,
-0.0389334708,
0.0210588984,
-0.0827735886,
0.0227848608,
0.0308018122,
-0.0384570695,
-0.0514773875,
0.0518046618,
-0.059300974,
0.0255974848,
-0.0655765533,
-0.0002402247,
0.0306897499,
0.0364305638,
0.0386400409,
0.0610798039,
-0.0277492143,
-0.006055261,
0.0180227924,
-0.0116080036,
-0.0075479741,
-0.0401787795,
-0.0254478827,
-0.0234811641,
-0.0099929962,
0.0257060509,
-0.0246043503,
-0.0003607059,
-0.0369581394,
-0.0031978483,
-0.0164610147,
-0.0176588222,
-0.0154554928,
-0.015725702,
0.0240313653,
0.0233814344,
0.0433222353,
-0.0201350134,
-0.0395027548,
0.031865783,
-0.0234260708,
0.0160079971,
0.0370903201,
0.0156549625,
0.0013911626,
-0.0274745226,
-0.0056580729,
0.0199611578,
0.0675417408,
-0.0047411574,
-0.0341111645,
-0.0205040425,
0.0176520701,
0.0126111768,
0.0278071407,
-0.0304474682,
-0.0481087454,
-0.0134852445,
-0.0110983634,
-0.0171959624,
0.0489537679,
0.0264370516,
0.0125804897,
0.0104135955,
0.0018453567,
-0.017075764,
0.0145173455,
-0.0240712613,
-0.0297277477,
0.0335044526,
0.0018209715,
-0.0280254949,
0.0847244263,
-0.0215296596,
0.0404844694,
-0.0629245266,
-0.0284844749,
0.0005263309,
-0.0275316145,
-0.0187697783,
0.0043734065,
-0.0216492955,
-0.010886224,
-0.0566595159,
-0.0120107858,
0.053172227,
-0.0190466568,
-0.0471997187,
0.0206608642,
0.02668144,
-0.0190754011,
0.0752681568,
0.0176665597,
0.0196189769,
0.0241459087,
-0.0288993567,
-0.0098043634,
-0.0244779717,
0.0017889936,
-0.0120408796,
0.0550571382,
-0.0190128926,
0.0140047874,
-0.0235117003,
-0.0369852893,
-0.0430068932,
-0.0036364035,
-0.0206784643,
0.0190842338,
-0.0244964808,
0.0140936691,
-0.0451418906,
0.0599764697,
0.0167470053,
0.0660489053,
0.0086361095,
0.0210519843,
-0.0157285165,
0.0581018887,
0.0308073517,
0.041349411,
-0.0213843696,
-0.0099097909,
0.026378803,
0.042404294,
0.003555167,
-0.0117020486,
-0.0669975281,
0.0228703972,
-0.0225956365,
-0.0162633788,
0.0437312908,
0.0056096464,
0.0221523046,
-0.0547699742,
-0.0369219966,
0.0749702156,
0.003283099,
-0.0959765911,
-0.0289493985,
0.0519833937,
-0.0109807998,
0.0263673589,
-0.004603934,
-0.0478346422,
-0.0470619984,
-0.0529682338,
-0.0125348512,
0.033048939,
-0.0078280196,
-0.0405707546,
-0.0838302746,
0.0178516265,
0.0149386832,
-0.0425495692,
-0.0801551044,
-0.018261604,
-0.0308935922,
-0.0061334362,
-0.0206646305,
-0.0190689359,
0.0276354998,
-0.0179061629,
0.0164213572,
0.0052727968,
-0.0464082435,
0.0194356982,
-0.032174781,
0.0046294616,
0.0413204469,
-0.0076594343,
-0.0108916862,
-0.0400213748,
-0.0276209731,
-0.0561054759,
0.0188283361,
0.0359912179,
0.0751886815,
-0.0465797782,
-0.0267464593,
0.0193885732,
-0.0083762342,
-0.0503744036,
-0.0092142979,
-0.0266116019,
0.0271056071,
-0.002646873,
0.007656551,
-0.0184536353,
0.0376788937,
0.0005712393,
0.0583408251,
0.0373860709,
-0.0097931493,
-0.0247879103,
-0.0026108392,
0.0156471506,
-0.0946053714,
-0.0055962633,
0.0084303478,
0.0555624664,
-0.07165692,
-0.0523662642,
-0.0295519736,
0.0284909252,
-0.0146740023,
0.0106936609,
-0.0520476773,
0.0343349092,
0.0096485633,
-0.0964462906,
0.0352962688,
-0.0502399728,
-0.0170590449,
-0.0392688066,
-0.0027456256,
0.1076018959,
-0.0106919324,
-0.0199362449,
0.0464623496,
-0.1042026952,
-0.0059657418,
-0.0003760559,
0.0863666758,
0.0079354346,
0.0439683348,
-0.0115329707,
-0.0130574591,
0.0180303343,
0.014836072,
-0.0059475964,
0.0160588995,
0.0043971459,
-0.0068630073,
-0.0130835054,
0.0076097474,
-0.048342105,
0.0407366343,
-0.0118175978,
0.0109310895,
-0.0248668119,
-0.0553602204,
0.0271324571,
-0.0610846616,
0.0426472723,
-0.0158819351,
0.0227458086,
-0.0157656111,
0.0403597094,
0.0134097654,
0.0208024625,
-0.0515183993,
0.0047346191,
-0.005817153,
0.0163598116,
-0.0019052257,
-0.0516079515,
-0.0105558606,
-0.0062647169,
0.0349944942,
0.0338320397,
0.0161326006,
-0.0104792556,
-0.0215046834,
0.0163898095,
-0.0360102504,
-0.0238843914,
-0.0152396299,
0.0371572785,
-0.0288147572,
0.0176677778,
0.0175120439,
-0.0029496199,
-0.0099946689,
0.0355342329,
-0.0365469009,
0.0299303643,
-0.0622667782,
0.0072655948,
0.0841272995,
-0.0061047287,
0.0015545322,
0.0074771144,
0.0011906922,
0.0067203767,
0.0197187588,
-0.0063655064,
-0.0336664654,
0.0561006367,
0.0276154205,
0.0432427973,
-0.0126999449,
0.048975084,
-0.0245015938,
0.0395641848,
0.0012547398,
-0.000068219,
-0.0453904718,
0.004092515,
-0.0449182764,
0.0013086566,
-0.0124518443,
0.0187641364,
-0.0333857052,
-0.057173416,
0.0226364266,
-0.0094924998,
0.0124492943,
0.0441175252,
0.0922214985,
-0.0192773789,
0.0197280627,
-0.0101153385,
-0.0020700076,
0.0034902326,
-0.0103982249,
0.0147650111,
-0.0325007662,
-6.085069567e-33,
-0.0507358164,
-0.0134606855,
0.0147410817,
0.0072575966,
-0.0348373167,
0.0033827198,
-0.0598775335,
0.0135208117,
-0.0147092817,
-0.0094972309,
0.0068752524,
0.0011572624,
0.0202438273,
0.0390709341,
0.0028204741,
-0.0267887861,
0.0493122116,
-0.0205765292,
0.0080612833,
0.0350814275,
-0.0025512923,
0.0142416023,
0.0673268214,
-0.0144591127,
-0.0298189856,
0.0156853497,
0.0021159099,
0.0053897132,
0.0624677688,
0.0497789271,
-0.0270791296,
0.0363003947,
0.0271627624,
-0.041921176,
-0.0212557409,
0.0188138485,
-0.1112266481,
-0.0173538923,
0.0220706202,
0.0475137793,
-0.0001079088,
-0.0585945696,
0.0341942273,
-0.0257195961,
0.0235144813,
-0.0405429676,
0.0467256755,
0.0017771319,
-0.0202502441,
-0.0263912287,
-0.0002183724,
0.0079119932,
-0.0156726055,
-0.0241814125,
0.035544917,
0.0282342471,
0.0062893755,
0.0154646346,
-0.0915745571,
0.0304473322,
-0.0183529146,
0.0447844639,
0.0654573739,
0.0736718476,
-0.0019124835,
0.0407475941,
0.019639736,
-0.0209523756,
-0.0403991081,
0.0165905468,
0.0046921894,
0.022147147,
0.0564879514,
-0.0120215286,
0.0347185954,
-0.0072606043,
-0.0181818567,
-0.0096112406,
-0.0609097369,
0.0689891651,
0.0348278917,
0.0013291701,
0.003006296,
0.015154561,
-0.0368780307,
0.0092758443,
-0.0381933041,
-0.0143741239,
0.0183026418,
0.0181445051,
-0.0265988689,
0.0482054278,
0.0486382395,
-0.0279394966,
0.0387145616,
0.0150688803,
0.0308343433,
0.0589827001,
-0.007860844,
0.0101811048,
-0.0472708903,
-0.0104261553,
0.0400113612,
0.0496416874,
0.02971505,
0.0325376578,
0.0452093966,
0.0416708589,
-0.0359928757,
-0.0212538466,
-0.034588784,
0.0037622023,
-0.0379908867,
0.013803985,
-0.0001263349,
0.0349083394,
-0.0731738359,
-0.0103315609,
-0.0284886323,
-0.0060935412,
0.0079977857,
-0.002812109,
0.0310592707,
0.0549638979,
-0.0284086075,
0.0167596471,
-0.0470402204,
0.0268189218,
0.0532928221,
-0.0628062934,
-0.008119911,
0.0664095581,
2.918e-7,
0.0028230445,
0.0035239146,
0.0509037413,
-0.0163408127,
0.039281629,
0.0099895066,
-0.0168354195,
0.0385005213,
-0.0033114916,
-0.0581287369,
0.0394880027,
0.0558307171,
0.0184240136,
-0.0411661528,
-0.1042910069,
0.0043286351,
-0.0172029361,
-0.0020913612,
0.008599503,
-0.004476204,
0.0808008015,
0.1162926853,
-0.0181359872,
0.0134047,
0.001745372,
-0.0651131123,
0.0865238234,
0.0135082658,
0.0387713462,
-0.026592331,
0.0110712387,
0.0575680844,
-0.0674075559,
0.011819168,
-0.0073496946,
-0.0377484821,
0.0170546565,
0.0229498968,
-0.0290874168,
-0.0389686264,
-0.0187331531,
0.0415280014,
-0.0261261389,
-0.018814994,
0.0596877337,
-0.1206024215,
-0.0376025401,
-0.0011040687,
-0.0239948109,
0.0370080434,
0.0065651713,
-0.00881394,
-0.0305211917,
-0.0077700363,
0.0356853716,
-0.0049655922,
-0.0246319808,
-0.1052455679,
-0.0198062006,
0.0035472156,
-0.0201855116,
-0.0013122141,
-0.0720087141,
-0.0583359711,
0.0682415813,
-0.03447707,
-0.0052392334,
2.211276147e-34,
0.0379403345,
-0.0275346357,
-0.0015839235,
0.012715688,
-0.0137086548,
-0.0154433912,
0.0033453177,
-0.0067593358,
0.0076120696,
-0.0482266545,
-0.0182100516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12372v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12372v1 | Vision Transformer Adapters for Generalizable Multitask Learning | 2023-08-23T18:40:48 | 2023-08-23T18:40:48 | Deblina Bhattacharjee, Sabine Süsstrunk, Mathieu Salzmann | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | We introduce the first multitasking vision transformer adapters that learn
generalizable task affinities which can be applied to novel tasks and domains.
Integrated into an off-the-shelf vision transformer backbone, our adapters can
simultaneously solve multiple dense vision tasks in a parameter-efficient
manner, unlike existing multitasking transformers that are parametrically
expensive. In contrast to concurrent methods, we do not require retraining or
fine-tuning whenever a new task or domain is added. We introduce a task-adapted
attention mechanism within our adapter framework that combines gradient-based
task similarities with attention-based ones. The learned task affinities
generalize to the following settings: zero-shot task transfer, unsupervised
domain adaptation, and generalization without fine-tuning to novel domains. We
demonstrate that our approach outperforms not only the existing convolutional
neural network-based multitasking methods but also the vision transformer-based
ones. Our project page is at \url{https://ivrl.github.io/VTAGML}. | [
-0.0308774468,
0.0085267769,
-0.0138581181,
0.0208228528,
-0.0005877896,
-0.012360868,
0.0568729937,
-0.0190290976,
-0.0119876834,
-0.0011394577,
-0.0493003204,
-0.017883705,
-0.027742397,
0.0176421907,
0.0297220405,
-0.0702964514,
0.0155448094,
0.021873707,
-0.0304281041,
0.0370651037,
-0.0045208111,
-0.0003786188,
0.0340302475,
0.0554857701,
-0.0326858126,
-0.0056641721,
-0.0077190856,
0.0217812713,
0.0696420372,
0.0249319822,
0.0366456173,
-0.0126798656,
0.0064999047,
-0.0046693725,
0.000002146,
-0.0044454415,
-0.0034769629,
-0.0348280519,
0.0530175492,
-0.0654904023,
0.0300280377,
-0.0115190744,
0.0216035098,
0.0046626972,
-0.0311440788,
-0.0147107728,
0.0822258145,
0.0351163261,
0.0207705852,
0.0247852392,
-0.0493554734,
0.0276952665,
0.0271590743,
-0.0219528768,
0.0037586032,
-0.0393943973,
0.0082417419,
-0.0110469377,
-0.0268727615,
-0.0518096872,
-0.0501731783,
0.0271751657,
0.0391403362,
0.0197829306,
0.0494703092,
0.0055021942,
-0.0265118238,
-0.0446335636,
-0.0282087028,
0.0460542515,
-0.1008460522,
-0.0114414552,
0.0088430997,
0.0021362868,
0.0172965843,
0.0029170911,
-0.0573900528,
0.0028602383,
-0.026510885,
0.021690812,
-0.0333771259,
0.036527101,
0.0224863216,
-0.0285826214,
-0.033261694,
0.0078039817,
-0.0062243934,
0.0565878712,
0.0219211187,
0.0574361086,
-0.0493458286,
0.0005816408,
0.0128338663,
0.00944662,
-0.0740604326,
-0.0463734418,
-0.1079394072,
-0.0599460639,
-0.0483199991,
0.0279692616,
0.1099975482,
0.0308872536,
-0.0608848035,
0.0469421074,
-0.0482213236,
0.0280834362,
-0.0746565014,
0.0397230536,
-0.0717157871,
-0.0716447085,
-0.0716928095,
0.0196718927,
-0.0462170243,
0.0259086825,
0.0194797777,
-0.0316887647,
0.0077595715,
0.0369796194,
-0.0474077649,
-0.0574573129,
0.0375499539,
0.0433045551,
-0.0688595921,
-0.0329999328,
0.0434629731,
0.0303478688,
0.0013363092,
0.0654362589,
0.0006573687,
-0.0198120698,
-0.0159433037,
0.0563865304,
0.0252023395,
-0.0434599407,
-0.0092306221,
0.0577419028,
-0.0330632776,
-0.0140712271,
-0.030667901,
0.0444188975,
0.0173126254,
-0.0158152897,
0.0324920937,
-0.0070034917,
0.0459567159,
-0.0344802774,
0.0140790725,
-0.008898437,
-0.01711802,
-0.0049322513,
-0.0152337784,
0.0683246031,
0.038839139,
0.0093442211,
0.0146703701,
-0.0009378457,
-0.0548619442,
0.0475834906,
0.0176565405,
-0.0100096324,
-0.0209823512,
-0.0129298996,
0.0108814659,
0.0284003373,
-0.0309915543,
-0.0061735045,
0.0430138372,
-0.0075362646,
0.01120154,
-0.0182507094,
0.0646664798,
0.0039080395,
-0.0327014104,
-0.0059840446,
0.048953224,
-0.0020478473,
0.0276090037,
0.0251149815,
0.0617924668,
-0.0025667581,
-0.0556729846,
0.0051667066,
-0.0879446417,
0.1047090143,
0.0385010168,
-0.0273704864,
-0.0549472719,
0.0712833628,
-0.0599876866,
-0.0199932605,
0.050941579,
-0.0162003245,
0.0232698489,
0.0099891927,
0.0472320169,
0.0520648807,
-0.0505697541,
0.0188576505,
0.0017720282,
-0.0235048793,
0.0052671442,
-0.0578101575,
-0.0287989005,
0.0114333229,
0.0007807392,
-0.0299340766,
-0.0473366342,
-0.0443061031,
0.0844449252,
-0.019265011,
-0.0288597792,
0.027278088,
0.0725993142,
-0.0257615726,
-0.0486862287,
-0.0129165035,
-0.0008065394,
-0.003380487,
0.0418077521,
0.0066722208,
0.0116783176,
0.0044637965,
0.0138048045,
0.0385926589,
-0.0195666943,
0.0285358038,
0.0557964593,
-0.0020383752,
-0.005103956,
-0.0276627541,
0.000302457,
-0.0329841264,
0.015312599,
-0.0776640847,
0.0127781844,
0.0244309027,
-0.017204091,
0.0608822145,
0.007812161,
-0.072240442,
-0.0090413373,
0.0915451422,
0.0015189715,
-0.0246915892,
0.0125554344,
0.0418361388,
0.0062721153,
0.0356387608,
0.0103363432,
-0.0021389469,
0.0363419428,
0.0097921239,
0.00144631,
0.0237081777,
-0.0312088449,
-0.0112971235,
-0.0557597578,
-0.0063872267,
-0.0153842084,
0.0020471716,
-0.0685228556,
-0.0195123479,
0.0114973355,
-0.0009538135,
-0.0043360791,
-0.0047607757,
-0.0308726411,
-0.0363775343,
0.0316278227,
-0.027031932,
-0.0156385861,
0.0027001323,
0.0318066776,
0.0277157333,
-0.0178235006,
-0.0137771918,
0.0802488774,
-0.0268422812,
-0.0089349346,
0.0122898677,
-0.0233156458,
0.0385645479,
-0.0184299611,
0.0168541428,
0.0193930808,
0.0029652421,
0.0103989905,
-0.0168325733,
-0.0272762086,
-0.0016573136,
0.0557856224,
0.0221260469,
-0.0054395595,
0.0234982185,
-0.0089353276,
-0.0283588115,
0.0101135252,
0.0976426303,
-0.002532921,
-0.0120990807,
0.0359460413,
-0.0031784992,
-0.0085381269,
0.0247762948,
-0.0097194891,
-0.0036412387,
-0.0346899554,
0.0351355113,
0.0039614248,
0.0530233756,
-0.0473097973,
-0.0406082422,
-0.0446290188,
-0.0133971963,
0.0079977456,
-0.0443423614,
-0.0157101955,
0.0403598435,
-0.0023993726,
-0.0537779555,
-0.028072359,
-0.0342177041,
0.0205335561,
0.0468176976,
-0.0382980369,
-0.0060194228,
0.0074584163,
0.004178144,
0.0388409756,
-0.0011853944,
0.011483415,
0.028538812,
-0.0048954743,
-0.064799659,
0.0266368836,
-0.0070662699,
0.0202911329,
0.101782389,
0.0001856915,
-0.019170206,
-0.0291235019,
-0.0488223322,
-0.0218483787,
0.0275321994,
-0.0099534756,
0.0313246958,
-0.0222876854,
-0.0228675865,
-0.111079894,
-0.0326500684,
0.0160641074,
0.0520731248,
-0.0039915782,
-0.0393945426,
-0.0114842644,
0.0426812768,
0.0502495803,
0.0744048432,
-0.0313602425,
-0.0187309906,
-0.0243061408,
0.0732293874,
0.044541996,
-0.0279233418,
-0.0509574562,
0.0055952026,
0.0458591506,
0.0130087584,
-0.007191712,
-0.0058039422,
0.0417217873,
-0.0503949299,
-0.0034881781,
0.02602599,
-0.0166102927,
-0.0526094995,
-0.0016072211,
0.0020467839,
-0.005242506,
0.0508490242,
0.0247749742,
-0.0479851812,
-0.0621988997,
-0.0208946355,
0.0109138424,
0.0610487312,
-0.0034685414,
0.0005167459,
-0.0197708476,
0.0276808236,
0.0043073096,
-0.0079443632,
0.0176679138,
0.0432490632,
0.0354593322,
-0.0494268611,
-0.0250836536,
-0.0296606701,
0.0077929446,
-0.0331869312,
-0.0048998608,
0.0336407088,
-0.0059681046,
-0.0028893396,
-0.0384272859,
-0.0188365355,
0.0309147444,
-0.015588942,
-0.0238954965,
-0.028261926,
-0.0185014512,
0.0143866856,
-0.0052925437,
0.0195227619,
0.0174291674,
-0.0415719971,
-0.0369003005,
0.0118277483,
0.0380397327,
-0.0524430312,
-0.013712828,
0.0218350012,
0.0678867772,
0.0101397149,
-0.0365222022,
-0.0413883328,
-0.0599055998,
0.0254787225,
0.01456152,
-0.0188693665,
-0.0524533316,
-0.0191121362,
0.0017068298,
-0.0315760411,
-0.0788755268,
-0.0401726142,
-0.0268926658,
0.0018057422,
-0.0409076661,
-0.0221138503,
0.0293412656,
0.0417224541,
0.0308964308,
-0.0002989061,
-0.053616643,
0.021647919,
-0.0055228057,
-0.0710805804,
0.0087894369,
-0.0050756591,
0.0173077043,
-0.0233850013,
-0.0090531027,
0.0442335792,
-0.0377399661,
0.0032702393,
0.0228696037,
-0.1364546865,
-0.0074625164,
-0.0194124077,
0.0693237782,
-0.001512993,
0.0650564134,
-0.0256825071,
0.0254734829,
-0.0105533097,
0.0280013233,
-0.0035328912,
0.052591078,
0.0624067448,
-0.0709648803,
0.0062301145,
0.0205826834,
-0.0581553653,
0.0355970226,
0.0150963524,
-0.0162857193,
-0.0230074506,
0.0213598032,
-0.0171025135,
-0.0474610105,
0.0638745874,
0.0240819529,
0.0821496472,
-0.0197990071,
0.0073667266,
0.0621626414,
-0.0002238215,
-0.092270568,
0.0093825823,
0.0022038468,
-0.0013330663,
0.0301892441,
0.0501429215,
0.0563316531,
-0.0090640904,
-0.0818339959,
0.0188569352,
-0.033600904,
0.0012971296,
-0.0018542696,
0.0171906073,
0.0217144173,
-0.0149135441,
0.0605813041,
0.0152322678,
-0.0189226568,
-0.0185579807,
0.0225171503,
0.0041927295,
-0.0387804247,
0.0399292409,
-0.0597193465,
-0.02814053,
-0.0256138686,
0.017063411,
0.0232018884,
-0.0150068784,
0.0423933938,
0.0341368914,
-0.0135319671,
-0.0599309355,
0.0371057056,
-0.0025544139,
0.0333700627,
-0.0113398237,
-0.0048943469,
0.0270117652,
0.0000875296,
0.0714769959,
-0.0481084324,
0.0111237606,
0.0103107262,
0.0086253118,
-0.0346372202,
-0.0338867567,
0.0092214383,
0.0030942226,
0.0303117707,
-0.0150197055,
0.0271542612,
-0.0065588476,
0.0136376377,
-0.0538526177,
0.002123412,
-0.0229134448,
0.0113529796,
0.0042099846,
0.0026818577,
-0.0455595963,
0.0011861387,
-0.0611719266,
0.0312674977,
0.0029866551,
0.0341225043,
-5.945407246e-33,
0.0114853792,
0.0177358259,
-0.0043434147,
-0.0005748484,
-0.0051396755,
0.0078692324,
-0.0140515948,
-0.018731216,
-0.0562982261,
0.0028677799,
0.0101549383,
0.0301911328,
0.0168580636,
0.0305167083,
0.0488534793,
-0.0227250438,
0.0615123659,
0.0230617709,
0.0179233346,
0.0350685306,
0.0110875135,
0.0301485155,
0.0494371206,
-0.0505906418,
-0.0403576717,
0.025103908,
0.007274481,
-0.0460896641,
0.0452100411,
0.0378153585,
0.0189583134,
0.0349013731,
0.0133937076,
-0.0396207161,
-0.0439106449,
0.0230047852,
-0.0998338908,
-0.011507595,
-0.0540190786,
-0.0130170602,
-0.0682572201,
-0.0101522775,
0.0543619916,
0.0298839305,
0.0179168396,
-0.0901302248,
0.0390392058,
-0.0178666003,
-0.0103854323,
-0.0056272591,
-0.038370505,
-0.0195539426,
-0.0116320523,
-0.0408611223,
0.0282529779,
0.0683670789,
-0.0307600163,
0.0024167169,
-0.0696752816,
0.0185036436,
-0.0592310764,
-0.003966338,
0.0378996208,
0.0354321375,
0.0056272396,
0.0111446977,
-0.0052249613,
-0.0335609391,
-0.0180164892,
-0.001508892,
0.0255648494,
0.0753153637,
-0.0021884385,
0.0271027125,
0.0127124218,
-0.0411798283,
-0.0206055827,
0.0145145059,
-0.0256592184,
0.0442129336,
0.0259078518,
0.0212088823,
0.0231530834,
-0.0108644012,
0.037405394,
0.0317925997,
-0.0165456757,
0.0053461818,
0.0514669009,
0.013611,
-0.0255314671,
0.0639377758,
0.0345609225,
-0.0646954626,
0.0624053478,
0.021001216,
-0.0002500771,
0.0460778885,
0.0183955673,
0.0007873378,
-0.0274352897,
-0.0353240147,
0.0320731103,
0.0255267583,
0.0087935422,
0.0392047875,
0.0421630405,
0.0347702205,
-0.030816406,
-0.0406937674,
-0.0316200405,
0.0182545688,
0.0385092981,
0.0637244731,
0.0190990921,
-0.0095072044,
-0.0177650638,
0.0252100192,
-0.0237212572,
-0.0468798019,
-0.0102934428,
0.0206499789,
0.0235011913,
0.0225986466,
0.0099662142,
0.0060293367,
-0.0656087473,
-0.0430719331,
0.0036452448,
-0.0600385405,
-0.0266152602,
0.0080932211,
2.748e-7,
-0.0203799251,
-0.0077500679,
-0.0417532586,
-0.0619791895,
-0.0062426515,
0.0377444699,
0.0110446429,
0.0824827477,
-0.0260812584,
0.0157565884,
0.0047061038,
0.0491450131,
0.0434654094,
0.0169331431,
-0.0536420532,
-0.0412855409,
0.0152267693,
0.0398697071,
-0.0137854973,
0.0178913195,
-0.0064018737,
0.0668550059,
0.0201130547,
0.0057551465,
0.0779841989,
-0.0302155316,
0.0236035977,
-0.0030071463,
0.0494152158,
-0.0279503949,
-0.0298715066,
0.0292523634,
-0.0253645964,
0.0482110456,
-0.0202527586,
-0.0046725948,
0.0369179621,
0.0257034767,
-0.0230120867,
-0.0041130921,
-0.0192636475,
0.0182903688,
0.012971024,
-0.0337880552,
0.0695402324,
-0.0857081339,
-0.00955116,
-0.0328090042,
-0.0189376324,
0.0420945249,
-0.0160728078,
0.0269679409,
0.0226761904,
-0.0464263745,
0.0326104946,
0.0098216599,
-0.0699229464,
-0.0418766886,
0.0002741062,
0.0127822189,
-0.037966691,
0.0002177475,
-0.02372499,
-0.0677257106,
0.0469289124,
-0.0166403241,
-0.0366810709,
1.996357668e-34,
-0.0185241792,
0.0323127769,
0.0396267921,
0.0264542382,
-0.0254520215,
-0.0136880716,
-0.0849304944,
-0.0263226666,
0.0197779741,
-0.0041618692,
-0.0329822004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12284v1 | D4: Improving LLM Pretraining via Document De-Duplication and Diversification | 2023-08-23T17:58:14 | 2023-08-23T17:58:14 | Kushal Tirumala, Daniel Simig, Armen Aghajanyan, Ari S. Morcos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Over recent years, an increasing amount of compute and data has been poured
into training large language models (LLMs), usually by doing one-pass learning
on as many tokens as possible randomly selected from large-scale web corpora.
While training on ever-larger portions of the internet leads to consistent
performance improvements, the size of these improvements diminishes with scale,
and there has been little work exploring the effect of data selection on
pre-training and downstream performance beyond simple de-duplication methods
such as MinHash. Here, we show that careful data selection (on top of
de-duplicated data) via pre-trained model embeddings can speed up training (20%
efficiency gains) and improves average downstream accuracy on 16 NLP tasks (up
to 2%) at the 6.7B model scale. Furthermore, we show that repeating data
intelligently consistently outperforms baseline training (while repeating
random data performs worse than baseline training). Our results indicate that
clever data selection can significantly improve LLM pre-training, calls into
question the common practice of training for a single epoch on as much data as
possible, and demonstrates a path to keep improving our models past the limits
of randomly sampling web data. | [
0.0261118151,
0.0959339216,
-0.0076325964,
0.0170590244,
-0.005004161,
0.0185626466,
0.0115671959,
0.0270733163,
0.0220364723,
-0.0770207122,
-0.0458543934,
-0.0288787,
-0.0284030698,
-0.0249497071,
0.0322692469,
-0.0174280964,
0.0437696762,
-0.0371910445,
-0.0150422184,
-0.0248449706,
0.0181773752,
0.0102530438,
0.0250211153,
0.0066903783,
-0.0068873144,
-0.0019718427,
-0.0068299631,
0.0198038481,
-0.0398707315,
-0.0488957129,
0.0093041155,
0.0529152192,
0.0451668687,
0.0225452781,
0.0000018713,
-0.0420818068,
-0.0283654183,
-0.0252041984,
-0.0554797575,
0.0324378051,
0.0381138697,
0.005953745,
0.0234544389,
0.0232254695,
-0.0130624324,
-0.0415641554,
0.0186279062,
0.0586472526,
0.0256161075,
0.0780304372,
-0.0003661799,
-0.0054343394,
0.0376574658,
-0.0334767252,
-0.0129090277,
-0.0268480051,
0.0160548817,
-0.0168235991,
-0.0259767305,
0.0306467712,
-0.015599669,
0.0131761609,
-0.0049405145,
0.0152844936,
0.0095651653,
0.0576619171,
-0.0296977591,
-0.0064802761,
-0.0089493301,
0.0959678888,
-0.0483286381,
-0.0284148417,
0.0180319715,
-0.004049697,
-0.0137279229,
0.0069016567,
-0.0525398962,
0.0262844022,
0.029409688,
0.0598825105,
0.0113109527,
-0.0178204998,
0.0634920523,
0.033856459,
-0.0337588266,
0.002758333,
0.0290788226,
-0.0236612689,
0.0470086485,
0.0340848379,
-0.0239326637,
-0.0352684706,
-0.0256412961,
-0.001633925,
-0.0161657296,
0.0269032307,
-0.0564710014,
-0.0285278577,
0.0317607112,
-0.0030226039,
0.0545625463,
0.0246795677,
-0.019817112,
0.0719265044,
-0.0232964605,
-0.0016054306,
-0.0125012044,
0.0214568805,
-0.0397631042,
-0.0091042118,
-0.0320948474,
-0.0017090507,
-0.025443526,
0.0579317212,
0.0060265758,
-0.0453779809,
0.0055885399,
0.0103440555,
0.0003475225,
-0.0104132835,
0.021073889,
-0.0101438677,
-0.0255869757,
-0.0057622655,
0.0195796806,
-0.0002824152,
-0.0325434469,
0.0220347978,
-0.0078858566,
-0.0802808255,
-0.0216752123,
0.0095760291,
0.0187712274,
-0.0304379817,
0.0140332924,
0.0448733419,
-0.0100903921,
-0.0385141484,
-0.0565667786,
-0.009263562,
0.0152577953,
-0.0282364227,
0.0137958219,
-0.0533606671,
0.0710925087,
-0.0058215931,
0.0281938724,
-0.0375188887,
0.0028316944,
0.021811733,
-0.0343850479,
0.0687993392,
-0.032775227,
0.0240607336,
-0.0067448006,
-0.0083694747,
0.0008903458,
0.0931866765,
0.0029693081,
0.0059677283,
0.0791639909,
-0.0050763283,
-0.00865776,
0.0324741527,
0.0299612693,
0.0196229368,
0.0045679854,
-0.0080450699,
0.0133398818,
0.0351122916,
0.0500528216,
0.0404011942,
-0.062774837,
-0.0143298861,
0.0648916438,
0.0593625642,
0.0099741286,
0.0134539418,
0.0154816797,
0.031755846,
0.0206963159,
0.0034676495,
-0.0434363969,
-0.0072852084,
0.0090288697,
-0.0064398409,
0.0327517651,
0.0261011645,
-0.0551429689,
-0.0001008942,
-0.0250994209,
-0.0296169594,
-0.0002049336,
0.010134954,
0.0420557112,
0.0144595569,
-0.0100944797,
0.0849201679,
0.0558629073,
-0.043471273,
0.0135895358,
-0.0162420757,
-0.0080282986,
0.0541965365,
0.0455854051,
-0.0277167093,
-0.0071836011,
-0.0242954101,
0.0559830107,
0.0083471974,
0.0503170267,
-0.0267391261,
0.0447422303,
-0.0747141764,
-0.0388061069,
-0.0206104554,
0.0049703782,
0.0146272732,
0.0504713356,
0.0128905978,
0.0122620864,
-0.0584844574,
0.001682954,
0.0470035151,
-0.0618570708,
-0.0344811976,
0.0093713608,
0.0085672252,
0.026178902,
-0.0141375763,
-0.0253959019,
0.0113993045,
0.0439047664,
-0.0482227802,
-0.0201745927,
-0.024716612,
-0.0450316854,
-0.0268715937,
0.0567294545,
-0.0029701402,
-0.0067267236,
0.058291208,
-0.0459846631,
-0.0141907353,
-0.0085846828,
-0.0215561707,
0.0785839707,
-0.0462931842,
0.0233078524,
-0.001684924,
0.0442283116,
-0.0198775511,
0.0304774363,
-0.0113013713,
0.0164711103,
0.0005498562,
-0.0120878015,
0.0227405429,
-0.03355119,
-0.0450578444,
-0.0014813406,
-0.0009157976,
0.0191608593,
0.0074478812,
0.0209805928,
-0.0556465276,
-0.0057902746,
-0.119496949,
0.0065032644,
-0.0257115141,
0.0211848766,
0.0031209737,
0.0025696135,
-0.0076884776,
-0.021241121,
-0.0315154307,
-0.0270904768,
-0.0247961096,
0.0431084186,
0.0244089905,
-0.0296646133,
0.0001125785,
-0.0255030394,
-0.0499182083,
0.0116036525,
0.059895236,
-0.0340580158,
-0.0229232218,
-0.0191110019,
0.0049119219,
-0.0131770484,
0.0082278959,
-0.0186681431,
-0.009875197,
-0.0184737351,
-0.0292602796,
0.0200121682,
0.0295614004,
-0.0003247529,
0.0308617949,
0.0388140716,
0.0145590985,
-0.0922225788,
-0.0156572983,
0.0055712261,
0.0079766447,
-0.0469597876,
0.0069147958,
0.0058863377,
0.0255646594,
-0.0245108549,
-0.0047166054,
0.0013387635,
-0.0005901302,
-0.0243259519,
-0.0157277603,
-0.044505205,
0.0076156263,
-0.0266942549,
0.0287678093,
-0.0062900339,
-0.0462258272,
0.0377320908,
-0.0244379342,
0.0094810249,
-0.0274182539,
0.0143256318,
-0.012331483,
0.0598660037,
-0.0087074889,
0.0071610962,
-0.0130924303,
-0.0211186111,
-0.0276596472,
0.01201702,
-0.007434532,
-0.0312014483,
0.0565954,
-0.0140761547,
0.0330862626,
-0.0167115033,
-0.0722750202,
-0.0525726303,
-0.0569986254,
-0.0060874601,
0.0019738616,
0.02027441,
0.0190226752,
-0.0203781389,
-0.017964121,
-0.0009237792,
0.0475340858,
-0.0126846591,
0.0041372865,
-0.0125061981,
0.0636511967,
0.0400256738,
-0.0055439817,
0.0311578121,
-0.0328120962,
-0.0020711503,
0.0628827661,
0.0683293566,
-0.0158095453,
-0.0092467628,
0.0239699576,
0.0497828051,
-0.0516549982,
-0.0240343139,
-0.0053572776,
0.026741283,
-0.0334352367,
-0.0041401493,
0.1156228408,
0.0085809063,
-0.0562391058,
-0.0032052475,
0.0284333676,
0.023936756,
0.0198989417,
0.0173053928,
-0.0710080266,
-0.0475092009,
0.029922884,
0.0105299121,
0.0352932774,
-0.0291112736,
-0.013992914,
-0.1286479533,
0.0099914474,
-0.0017794318,
-0.0001854106,
0.0080113374,
-0.076213479,
-0.0037312408,
-0.0126908291,
0.0432076305,
0.010929659,
-0.035384614,
-0.0106285494,
0.0306642428,
-0.0321997032,
-0.0716405883,
0.0184643306,
-0.0593894273,
0.0305562839,
0.003773219,
0.0203172769,
0.0019836836,
-0.0221424773,
0.0593213476,
-0.0173863024,
-0.0062728059,
-0.0261224359,
0.0749912336,
-0.0197862145,
-0.0070191002,
0.0028854208,
0.0185935255,
-0.0309497565,
-0.0075166691,
-0.0178661682,
0.0815394968,
0.0041101561,
-0.0222887974,
-0.0061112409,
-0.0471113473,
-0.0028994689,
0.0850595012,
0.0286737196,
-0.0444694571,
-0.0363896675,
0.0063028987,
-0.0055836053,
-0.0326405987,
0.0087728947,
0.0209069047,
-0.028146496,
-0.0063677472,
-0.0737311989,
-0.0358743109,
0.0328036733,
0.0379939564,
0.0141214253,
0.0489716269,
-0.0004618635,
-0.0065033934,
-0.0373435244,
0.0416082628,
-0.0669188946,
-0.0214179829,
-0.0595919602,
-0.023231132,
0.01891312,
-0.009300489,
-0.0138404472,
0.0032105262,
-0.1093198657,
-0.0650584772,
0.0024410286,
0.0032324994,
0.0166624729,
0.0765968934,
0.0036698433,
-0.0634994879,
0.0571226291,
0.0178132448,
-0.0685853958,
0.017406255,
0.0376287177,
-0.014716302,
0.0176395457,
0.0637994483,
-0.0546849743,
0.0009240906,
0.0513516441,
0.0406908467,
0.0113064637,
0.0266582165,
-0.0016440053,
0.0575631522,
0.0410112366,
-0.0161454994,
0.0314339474,
-0.0580591932,
0.020445019,
0.0187224261,
-0.0042577526,
-0.0364214554,
0.019122269,
0.0239596441,
-0.0071196235,
-0.0356490873,
0.0355147459,
0.0102322949,
0.0250999201,
-0.0154624134,
-0.0295236204,
-0.0124961836,
-0.0040205,
0.0396720283,
-0.0069763684,
-0.0262875669,
0.0068685482,
0.0062236339,
-0.0040163193,
-0.0684771463,
-0.0263465978,
0.0173109677,
0.0146449739,
-0.0649690628,
0.0219479781,
-0.0579952039,
-0.0834997818,
-0.0139422724,
-0.0028391499,
0.0750553086,
-0.0540978536,
0.0686842874,
-0.0238135159,
-0.0177980773,
-0.0347937271,
-0.002756953,
-0.0078375824,
-0.0068340427,
0.0182998907,
0.0100337071,
-0.046286393,
0.0435345508,
0.1240109429,
0.0081241205,
0.0425160713,
0.0007843174,
0.0077650445,
-0.0288314335,
-0.0162691772,
0.0406930931,
0.0415685065,
-0.0301199183,
-0.0023384748,
-0.0004275321,
-0.0712170601,
-0.0008623115,
-0.0214244127,
-0.0235038605,
0.0143357338,
0.0435143113,
0.0746448264,
0.0159258526,
0.0179155283,
-0.0436714701,
0.0059374818,
0.0407354124,
-0.0455731787,
0.0089113321,
-6.569486748e-33,
0.0398531407,
0.0324355699,
0.0011477369,
-0.0339475647,
-0.0174460933,
0.0246386789,
-0.0284844209,
-0.0220297128,
-0.0382757857,
0.0066039469,
-0.053289447,
-0.0024134475,
0.0219265334,
0.0590506159,
0.0235786848,
-0.0015318324,
0.0647018179,
-0.009400948,
-0.0054795076,
0.0289045479,
0.0376908667,
0.0502349027,
0.0502297953,
-0.0067779291,
-0.0223458577,
-0.0001887769,
0.0138972066,
0.0113897966,
0.034873981,
0.0454150885,
-0.0341505706,
0.0335793458,
0.0382714942,
-0.0336722471,
-0.0465425588,
-0.0147290668,
-0.097957328,
-0.0482069664,
-0.0017336613,
0.0063165468,
-0.0030728579,
-0.0016927285,
0.0434683263,
-0.0159477759,
0.0034777594,
-0.0168597549,
0.0037772271,
0.0084185684,
-0.0725491121,
-0.0124140279,
-0.0366039313,
0.0230345111,
0.0135319643,
0.0267756172,
0.0297602788,
-0.0100884307,
-0.0040535727,
0.0533978045,
-0.0663509667,
0.0222680066,
-0.0096922787,
0.0312715285,
0.0333052538,
-0.0131755499,
0.0333253741,
0.0929729789,
0.0327286497,
-0.0112874322,
0.0198014956,
-0.0091757951,
0.0511646308,
0.0275831241,
0.0059276423,
0.0137751317,
0.0676238835,
-0.0371783823,
-0.0879914984,
0.0024500389,
0.0393274352,
0.0123494966,
0.0298597962,
0.0193340816,
-0.0231822245,
-0.0349532664,
-0.0461968742,
0.0131131038,
-0.0151320715,
-0.0222571213,
0.0439308248,
0.0418559872,
-0.0157036521,
-0.0116006928,
0.0443123281,
-0.0593249761,
-0.0732363611,
0.0390596092,
0.0034890154,
-0.0096398266,
0.0079951938,
0.0054085213,
-0.0515320785,
-0.050260514,
-0.0080141267,
-0.0330957696,
0.0052131326,
-0.0095010009,
0.0679075718,
0.0093713664,
-0.0879703388,
-0.0012016955,
-0.036915876,
-0.0147633925,
0.0376800522,
0.0378790535,
0.0519948527,
0.0046696728,
0.017823983,
0.057929039,
0.0457173362,
-0.0059353691,
-0.0324093886,
-0.0270403586,
0.0084192986,
0.0150671406,
-0.006296597,
-0.0038312299,
-0.0584340468,
-0.0031328404,
0.0377219394,
-0.0680731833,
-0.020363776,
0.0132672098,
2.566e-7,
0.0310001373,
0.041104313,
-0.0096548935,
-0.0138395634,
0.0286890157,
0.0086928336,
-0.0445780903,
0.0311515387,
-0.0299061872,
0.0148004368,
-0.0030728481,
0.0278001279,
0.0695850477,
0.0229877904,
-0.1099721342,
-0.0064852452,
-0.0695096329,
0.0174221843,
-0.0485942438,
-0.0432243235,
-0.0037904796,
0.1358151883,
0.0246850159,
-0.0296146665,
0.0057443809,
-0.0405795984,
0.0722181126,
-0.0441239327,
-0.0039497917,
0.0269767754,
0.0285740048,
0.033010494,
-0.004253827,
-0.0260720383,
-0.0589508899,
0.0060272026,
0.0133319078,
0.0607457012,
0.0188107993,
0.0055781617,
0.0092794048,
-0.0474617183,
-0.0081038699,
-0.0421333276,
0.0963999107,
-0.0219969004,
-0.0141703906,
-0.0325185321,
0.0024587689,
-0.0449560843,
0.0270150695,
-0.0328612924,
-0.0230930001,
0.0495474525,
0.0270226318,
-0.0032393192,
-0.0334994011,
-0.1025287583,
0.0013653971,
-0.0101475613,
-0.0599821098,
-0.0334282517,
-0.0303510241,
-0.0071411827,
0.0504633412,
-0.0532492213,
0.0166070834,
2.585843749e-34,
0.0511840135,
-0.010925266,
0.024891628,
0.031097563,
0.0158506073,
-0.0251440797,
0.0092313476,
-0.0045897746,
-0.0234028958,
-0.0809436738,
-0.0106464606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12272v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12272v1 | Simple is Better and Large is Not Enough: Towards Ensembling of Foundational Language Models | 2023-08-23T17:40:35 | 2023-08-23T17:40:35 | Nancy Tyagi, Aidin Shiri, Surjodeep Sarkar, Abhishek Kumar Umrawal, Manas Gaur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Foundational Language Models (FLMs) have advanced natural language processing
(NLP) research. Current researchers are developing larger FLMs (e.g., XLNet,
T5) to enable contextualized language representation, classification, and
generation. While developing larger FLMs has been of significant advantage, it
is also a liability concerning hallucination and predictive uncertainty.
Fundamentally, larger FLMs are built on the same foundations as smaller FLMs
(e.g., BERT); hence, one must recognize the potential of smaller FLMs which can
be realized through an ensemble. In the current research, we perform a reality
check on FLMs and their ensemble on benchmark and real-world datasets. We
hypothesize that the ensembling of FLMs can influence the individualistic
attention of FLMs and unravel the strength of coordination and cooperation of
different FLMs. We utilize BERT and define three other ensemble techniques:
{Shallow, Semi, and Deep}, wherein the Deep-Ensemble introduces a
knowledge-guided reinforcement learning approach. We discovered that the
suggested Deep-Ensemble BERT outperforms its large variation i.e. BERTlarge, by
a factor of many times using datasets that show the usefulness of NLP in
sensitive fields, such as mental health. | [
0.0377235077,
0.0704781339,
-0.0286780838,
0.0298114177,
-0.0428972915,
0.0195793565,
0.0041676746,
-0.0390987694,
-0.013837588,
-0.0500260033,
-0.0127308192,
-0.0723238662,
0.0083633224,
0.0120355561,
0.0015502917,
-0.0736973211,
0.0291534793,
-0.0067845345,
-0.0073580905,
-0.0272533447,
0.0065391525,
-0.0092682205,
-0.0119429762,
0.0794299021,
0.0102346679,
0.0209043808,
-0.0214867163,
-0.0027954841,
0.0139489723,
-0.0066193934,
0.0330399349,
0.0874399394,
0.0452337936,
0.0512955338,
0.0000020793,
-0.059928894,
-0.0362134129,
-0.0287407711,
-0.0054622265,
-0.0197175909,
-0.0097371479,
-0.0087957177,
0.0000590234,
0.0024338525,
-0.0354770385,
-0.0098983431,
0.050898362,
0.0919402912,
0.0673706606,
0.0554452389,
0.0063391752,
-0.0445975699,
0.0225431658,
-0.0220860615,
-0.0153719736,
-0.0126461992,
0.0515043065,
-0.0415616445,
0.0030049637,
-0.0213749334,
-0.0280700773,
0.0186555907,
0.0161446463,
0.0315617062,
0.009430917,
0.0512233377,
-0.0730342045,
-0.031021446,
-0.0089392206,
0.1029314995,
-0.0258320868,
-0.0153205926,
0.0041617705,
-0.0008382029,
-0.0050128121,
0.0175339561,
-0.0255919304,
0.0407706127,
0.0088036601,
0.0505424589,
0.0293868482,
0.011042349,
0.0424470082,
0.0441839024,
-0.0302475523,
0.0715615824,
-0.0107483584,
-0.0308036041,
0.009332858,
0.0191349108,
-0.0477001444,
-0.0478382446,
0.0097217066,
0.0124686537,
-0.0295110978,
0.0157616157,
-0.0448197573,
-0.0429100581,
0.039325349,
-0.0359269902,
0.0035336786,
0.0231178086,
-0.0320368148,
0.0303386357,
-0.0062282323,
0.0334761105,
-0.0099535277,
0.0306734499,
-0.0382074714,
-0.0051300651,
-0.0926861912,
-0.0161347482,
-0.0490688384,
0.0486948192,
-0.0288804751,
-0.0469993576,
-0.0582089275,
-0.0006742087,
-0.0243119914,
-0.0061851041,
-0.0043651117,
0.041229248,
-0.018354658,
0.0073801288,
-0.013200867,
-0.0006806692,
-0.0264728386,
0.0218688864,
0.0220462419,
-0.0757292211,
0.0036853082,
0.0006547419,
-0.0205659904,
-0.0207495056,
0.0149980234,
0.0169915631,
0.0212343466,
-0.0512940995,
0.0037433757,
-0.0188395157,
-0.0440062322,
-0.0583665781,
0.0102918856,
-0.0999832824,
0.0377754569,
0.0047602332,
0.0054687113,
-0.036547523,
0.0264573451,
-0.0103925224,
-0.0266723968,
0.0825160891,
-0.0252818726,
-0.0090774912,
0.0234304406,
0.0209835432,
0.0066575999,
0.0902347788,
0.0369590335,
0.0291219633,
0.0082858233,
-0.0000941831,
0.0155543955,
0.0059734136,
0.0017336316,
-0.0323283374,
-0.0377825424,
-0.0165771898,
-0.0373998955,
0.0295506399,
-0.0185856521,
0.0468642451,
-0.0270548239,
0.019832626,
0.0659987852,
0.0489342138,
0.0438081175,
0.035183765,
0.0058590891,
-0.0060360553,
0.0000346511,
-0.0106568104,
-0.0399906933,
0.036397472,
-0.0232980028,
-0.011061837,
0.0233554672,
0.0466551147,
-0.0289486907,
-0.0332655869,
-0.0327945016,
-0.0093207434,
-0.0101775341,
-0.0028742158,
0.0290702283,
-0.0282568391,
-0.0259879194,
0.0641442165,
0.034412127,
-0.0144336168,
-0.0045755534,
-0.0546353646,
0.0126633998,
0.0934627429,
0.0538216829,
-0.0443410799,
-0.0133079523,
-0.0272488985,
-0.0108813057,
0.0489340909,
0.0389142893,
0.0004105781,
0.0168519355,
-0.0572604686,
-0.0203203037,
0.0061744559,
0.0282416977,
0.0237293523,
0.013373821,
-0.0074551497,
-0.023228541,
0.0136744734,
-0.0209938213,
0.0537340492,
-0.0060645328,
-0.0106079681,
0.0006983688,
0.0035712158,
0.0608734041,
-0.00033305,
-0.0318798423,
0.0250254311,
0.0342643633,
-0.038452819,
-0.0836393088,
0.0137608871,
-0.0603899285,
-0.0634118244,
0.0053538294,
-0.0219279341,
0.0384868309,
0.0080164308,
-0.0333124772,
-0.0605309643,
0.0187751967,
-0.0360397473,
0.0434846394,
-0.0480330475,
0.0228131916,
-0.0113915959,
0.047250811,
-0.0405753143,
0.0929602012,
-0.0443777926,
0.0170196518,
-0.0096160294,
0.0047954395,
-0.0169595797,
-0.0362906717,
-0.0406307951,
0.0235413779,
0.0098523786,
0.0213079918,
0.0118074594,
-0.0119090956,
-0.0234653018,
-0.0388132297,
-0.1098598018,
0.0228396002,
-0.0340869017,
-0.0076289759,
0.0014469199,
0.0085032005,
0.0001577075,
0.0054315683,
-0.003313246,
-0.0003167913,
0.0372619443,
0.0268348437,
0.0140380729,
0.0251173899,
-0.0420106761,
-0.0511024669,
-0.0130063621,
-0.0169768184,
0.0401253104,
-0.0294885319,
-0.0567403547,
-0.0307263061,
-0.0252943262,
-0.0241586808,
0.02340631,
-0.0130825639,
-0.0301928408,
0.0037000142,
-0.0314983577,
0.030455919,
0.0411624089,
0.0096694343,
0.085916087,
0.0607080758,
0.01593557,
-0.035604205,
0.0312898643,
-0.042991627,
0.022591643,
-0.0220675543,
-0.0137823541,
0.0124608222,
0.0725628287,
0.0136650288,
-0.0062988414,
-0.0679130331,
0.0148452464,
0.0113119185,
-0.0320292078,
-0.02364669,
-0.0294353496,
-0.0240021348,
0.0166255161,
-0.0350133143,
-0.0548890643,
0.0907845274,
-0.0016569399,
-0.0099173533,
-0.0630769134,
-0.0040272716,
-0.0340930149,
0.0378101952,
0.018562993,
0.0222865567,
0.0039534238,
-0.015304056,
-0.0157185588,
-0.0202097464,
-0.0148893818,
-0.0295232981,
0.0527853109,
-0.0532871112,
0.0241613463,
0.0192854367,
-0.0255063884,
-0.0716426447,
-0.0392321311,
-0.0454368554,
0.0463125296,
0.0230139326,
-0.0084151383,
-0.0653700903,
0.0067873392,
0.041142527,
0.0324107148,
-0.0050093597,
-0.0087277461,
-0.0126765631,
0.0373659357,
0.0365371704,
0.0095485616,
0.0654754043,
-0.046076607,
0.0354344212,
0.0111899329,
0.059622068,
0.0426219329,
-0.0191933401,
0.0059622587,
-0.0043144352,
-0.0353301577,
-0.0332234837,
0.0141402734,
0.0384788141,
-0.0501681119,
-0.0226379,
0.1311533451,
0.0284615755,
0.0016299138,
0.027633125,
0.0105138011,
0.0285248961,
0.0112040611,
-0.0057934178,
-0.0250041112,
-0.0422978178,
0.0077843466,
0.0184495766,
-0.0159868225,
-0.0475224145,
0.0113686593,
-0.0900085345,
0.0150791379,
0.0201735757,
-0.0396776088,
-0.0095664477,
-0.0386408605,
0.0023223998,
0.00309778,
0.0098109059,
-0.004005393,
0.0201619714,
-0.0036132089,
0.0214808583,
-0.0471377559,
-0.1070753038,
0.0276851896,
-0.0639530644,
0.0870157927,
0.0848311484,
0.0206270963,
-0.0231485907,
-0.0106831901,
-0.0151085658,
-0.0408875272,
-0.0039287019,
-0.00970178,
0.0648808777,
0.0103285788,
-0.0061030295,
-0.025667645,
0.0391946398,
-0.0564820729,
-0.010683638,
-0.0280275121,
0.060528893,
-0.0509703532,
-0.0448461026,
-0.030990243,
-0.0038480298,
0.0343809798,
0.094817102,
0.0147601925,
-0.0488549545,
-0.0420173593,
-0.0155860614,
-0.0038332362,
-0.0666568801,
0.0061046733,
0.0474016778,
0.018334236,
-0.0110489074,
-0.0711709261,
-0.0453554094,
0.0514031276,
0.0157286767,
0.0107588749,
0.0272628926,
-0.0105707971,
0.0202617645,
-0.0310769007,
0.0383115895,
0.0212188158,
0.0256677456,
-0.024191739,
-0.0531796589,
0.041155234,
-0.0168985073,
-0.0244434793,
0.019686928,
-0.0465020463,
-0.0662391707,
0.0347921439,
0.0389818996,
0.0263919961,
0.0117850862,
0.014295456,
-0.0685033202,
0.0693477318,
0.0745748654,
0.0262524318,
-0.0019250566,
0.0059971418,
-0.011477639,
0.0005830231,
0.0519450605,
-0.037466079,
0.0431311578,
0.0066573415,
0.0590501949,
-0.0156578533,
-0.0266559701,
0.0100498116,
-0.025018461,
0.0223181508,
-0.0385661162,
-0.0268785618,
-0.0317733362,
-0.0186992679,
0.0062913075,
-0.0160158239,
-0.0414851047,
-0.0116815008,
0.0370742567,
0.0124366079,
0.0048504146,
0.0291563757,
-0.0070278882,
0.0090906546,
-0.0190592036,
0.0331125855,
0.0303536747,
0.0266535208,
0.0381339565,
0.0063794297,
-0.0163246542,
0.0204115603,
-0.0385161713,
0.0170704369,
-0.0103443665,
0.0397587009,
0.0248591341,
-0.0194867272,
-0.0304664057,
0.0323030129,
-0.0795570761,
-0.0619157255,
-0.0493358113,
0.0490143895,
0.0455204099,
0.0042224638,
0.0422244333,
-0.0486223139,
-0.0002414368,
-0.0262796804,
0.0191599317,
0.0036667404,
-0.0214531608,
0.0449385419,
0.0332937315,
-0.0254737213,
-0.0070951618,
0.0754145309,
-0.0018810981,
0.0470486172,
0.0134723531,
0.0125297792,
-0.0622032434,
-0.0102278162,
0.0292590167,
0.0366280526,
-0.0417376608,
0.0497027375,
-0.0421448164,
-0.0300584286,
0.0519508421,
-0.0076495083,
0.0172377396,
-0.0220486652,
0.0572989956,
0.0465519205,
-0.0070351455,
-0.0049918904,
-0.0317024365,
0.0166085623,
-0.0140865659,
-0.008491016,
-0.0360880643,
-6.628996884e-33,
-0.019051386,
0.0035260841,
-0.0058493586,
-0.0572918467,
-0.0070315236,
-0.0075619309,
-0.0364561938,
0.0084165707,
-0.004551331,
0.0113290641,
0.0100568244,
0.0218918007,
0.0024614735,
0.0623792149,
0.0012664833,
-0.0172922164,
0.040156804,
-0.0121959075,
-0.0081043793,
0.0194818135,
0.0292855464,
0.0495156646,
0.0665169582,
-0.0462286845,
-0.0044046659,
-0.0054101949,
-0.0120883649,
0.0345936082,
-0.0092116753,
0.0594762042,
-0.0309089553,
0.0331820883,
0.037460085,
-0.0261770971,
-0.0150870457,
0.0262256563,
-0.0506991558,
-0.0264430679,
0.0095180385,
0.0012469016,
-0.0404255763,
-0.004760704,
0.0671307594,
0.0022660573,
0.00479245,
0.0124168741,
0.0351878628,
-0.0568889119,
-0.0137645295,
-0.0240953993,
-0.0377500877,
0.0024597552,
-0.0001992713,
-0.0259882547,
-0.0075456989,
0.0122376159,
-0.0448651016,
0.0213485975,
-0.0538294725,
-0.002333594,
0.039007742,
0.0117695946,
0.0346651487,
0.0392985456,
0.0175953973,
0.092066817,
0.0179547593,
-0.0215368923,
-0.0606244989,
-0.0397936329,
0.0527643077,
0.0882359371,
0.0532679297,
0.0193828959,
0.0188810006,
0.0292290002,
-0.073303014,
0.005613918,
0.0396546274,
0.0081156949,
0.072855182,
0.0170984101,
-0.0532785654,
-0.0236563943,
-0.0269463994,
-0.0271736775,
-0.0118387016,
0.0019172761,
0.0307745561,
0.0182980727,
-0.0415352881,
-0.022467522,
0.0351073034,
-0.0558759123,
-0.0301679913,
0.0458012037,
-0.0030158933,
0.0093857916,
0.0168452896,
0.0214132834,
-0.0720922649,
-0.0296520628,
0.0275940821,
0.0305807702,
0.0003974963,
0.0081196604,
0.0357666351,
0.0183971711,
-0.0272461567,
0.0016564146,
-0.0279448498,
0.016354898,
-0.0067350697,
0.0423185229,
0.0242577549,
0.0169509966,
-0.0139882332,
0.0075175855,
0.0173753146,
-0.0245587304,
-0.0198379867,
-0.002340507,
-0.0066695423,
0.0228061453,
-0.0118818656,
-0.006047558,
-0.0496516898,
-0.0004853448,
0.0501242876,
-0.0461080633,
-0.0141013367,
0.0018927344,
2.833e-7,
0.022843495,
0.0495194495,
0.016875606,
-0.0154545242,
0.0446056575,
0.0410967059,
-0.0254461132,
0.0477971621,
-0.0190628562,
-0.0504018962,
0.0014745716,
0.0605298616,
0.053505633,
0.0133801997,
-0.0506254286,
-0.0172073208,
-0.0689862818,
0.0173772052,
-0.0440006927,
-0.0257689618,
0.0465985835,
0.1262509674,
0.0309609268,
-0.0291156191,
0.0040211561,
-0.0211153943,
0.0644529313,
-0.0241404343,
0.028269412,
0.045639731,
0.0058547668,
0.0319977291,
-0.0334864073,
0.0303742532,
0.0170579478,
0.0295478962,
-0.0092969052,
0.0389958806,
-0.0247883014,
-0.0396661721,
0.001141253,
-0.0117353648,
0.0081609022,
-0.0622256398,
0.0733584538,
-0.0941543654,
-0.0323171541,
-0.0104554361,
-0.017089637,
-0.0161803644,
0.0131325927,
0.0033909816,
-0.0263851881,
0.0158605035,
0.0001482739,
-0.006455556,
0.0010951471,
-0.1061747298,
-0.0187365226,
0.0270376094,
-0.0870331749,
-0.0259370226,
-0.0300038699,
-0.0080862092,
0.021321848,
-0.0687596798,
0.0140937567,
2.992286073e-34,
0.0330673866,
0.0128028877,
0.0148911793,
0.011313064,
-0.003920442,
-0.0205287449,
-0.0100808525,
0.0088917576,
-0.0040970212,
-0.0781478807,
-0.021054877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12261v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12261v1 | Prompt2Model: Generating Deployable Models from Natural Language Instructions | 2023-08-23T17:28:21 | 2023-08-23T17:28:21 | Vijay Viswanathan, Chenyang Zhao, Amanda Bertsch, Tongshuang Wu, Graham Neubig | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) enable system builders today to create competent
NLP systems through prompting, where they only need to describe the task in
natural language and provide a few examples. However, in other ways, LLMs are a
step backward from traditional special-purpose NLP models; they require
extensive computational resources for deployment and can be gated behind APIs.
In this paper, we propose Prompt2Model, a general-purpose method that takes a
natural language task description like the prompts provided to LLMs, and uses
it to train a special-purpose model that is conducive to deployment. This is
done through a multi-step process of retrieval of existing datasets and
pretrained models, dataset generation using LLMs, and supervised fine-tuning on
these retrieved and generated datasets. Over three tasks, we demonstrate that
given the same few-shot prompt as input, Prompt2Model trains models that
outperform the results of a strong LLM, gpt-3.5-turbo, by an average of 20%
while being up to 700 times smaller. We also show that this data can be used to
obtain reliable performance estimates of model performance, enabling model
developers to assess model reliability before deployment. Prompt2Model is
available open-source at https://github.com/neulab/prompt2model. | [
0.0587597862,
0.0303707495,
-0.009497297,
0.0302180238,
-0.0332405716,
0.0041211182,
-0.0065002139,
-0.0392168537,
0.0150776748,
-0.0719514936,
-0.0133175328,
0.0196153894,
-0.0166564863,
0.0542587489,
0.021195583,
-0.0315882824,
0.037271101,
-0.031004956,
-0.020119762,
0.0421387218,
0.0025299583,
0.0417728163,
-0.0092720482,
0.075287275,
0.0056166151,
-0.0207016878,
-0.035747055,
0.0251301974,
-0.0143983122,
-0.0493661724,
0.009172312,
0.046909336,
0.0448996425,
-0.0121544674,
0.0000020662,
-0.0535991788,
-0.0073893256,
0.0166689735,
-0.0772932619,
-0.0156140151,
0.0328382328,
-0.0125349304,
-0.012470657,
0.0346886925,
-0.0193079319,
-0.0022492819,
0.0346281976,
0.0540104434,
0.0844649225,
0.0865764841,
0.009142993,
-0.0054610698,
-0.0015543452,
-0.0193922594,
0.0108170295,
-0.0605680346,
-0.0082799746,
-0.0133784683,
0.0117254928,
0.0505118147,
0.0316549651,
0.0138025628,
0.003747825,
0.0282927454,
-0.0038631617,
0.0160635859,
-0.0172240753,
-0.034849599,
-0.0732410178,
0.0895322859,
-0.0170293376,
-0.0088272933,
0.0045001879,
-0.0185408518,
-0.0076422505,
-0.0180024244,
-0.0331390724,
0.0244260132,
0.0117860073,
-0.0073879459,
-0.0175517928,
-0.0134738041,
-0.0013252369,
-0.0235680491,
0.0174242631,
0.0635307953,
0.0018345034,
-0.0152834589,
0.005029107,
-0.0199383684,
-0.020063661,
-0.0728110373,
-0.0023090569,
0.0562252663,
-0.0614969991,
0.0262638684,
-0.046801459,
-0.0096020354,
0.0366260596,
-0.0008848188,
0.0619147606,
0.0225448534,
-0.0332627557,
0.0618690625,
-0.036996156,
0.0659601763,
0.030081965,
-0.0022981169,
-0.0188891739,
0.0100324955,
-0.0913145468,
-0.0041266363,
-0.0583981574,
0.0183711387,
-0.0281740036,
-0.0483652353,
-0.0243119784,
0.0467321761,
-0.0104735792,
0.0327945575,
0.0605833791,
0.0340475142,
-0.0666642711,
-0.0075657503,
-0.0380694382,
-0.0148409829,
-0.0265960079,
0.0245505851,
0.0280872341,
-0.0774342269,
0.004762874,
-0.0074079554,
0.0062795235,
-0.0069572716,
0.0157958418,
0.0967305526,
0.0300357901,
-0.0399099663,
-0.0528621189,
-0.0183486305,
-0.0004298008,
-0.0539774112,
-0.0500058047,
-0.0718043074,
0.0377550498,
0.0146707604,
0.0161559321,
-0.0263409391,
0.0190615803,
0.0399894081,
-0.0178233311,
0.0954204798,
-0.0308092497,
0.0428701006,
0.0088581713,
-0.0092297466,
-0.0242932029,
0.0577093698,
0.014107707,
0.033181496,
0.0454317108,
-0.0001355346,
0.0343066342,
0.0280940421,
-0.030296335,
-0.0013337603,
0.0156097803,
0.0415694043,
0.0144941406,
0.0237278212,
0.0123463413,
0.0356615335,
0.0303169284,
0.0270860475,
0.0636926442,
0.0524122491,
-0.0199860986,
-0.0223930851,
0.0924257934,
0.0634452328,
-0.0263820048,
-0.0498294793,
-0.0783694461,
0.0146893924,
-0.0395610221,
0.0011360705,
-0.023005629,
0.0493866131,
-0.0358577855,
-0.0267684311,
-0.0264401957,
-0.0379877053,
0.0093442015,
0.0079440186,
0.0351464525,
0.0247271135,
-0.0637503117,
0.0484483913,
-0.0029662717,
-0.0385192856,
-0.0244646277,
-0.0576476157,
0.0316059664,
0.0700539127,
0.0445959717,
-0.0369644016,
-0.0242333021,
-0.0209514834,
0.0353607461,
0.003794244,
0.0474829897,
-0.018908035,
0.0136633012,
-0.0237955283,
-0.0437010899,
-0.0177117009,
0.0161884483,
-0.0056805597,
0.0413520001,
-0.0056142909,
0.0206444375,
-0.0050290413,
-0.0574018806,
0.0613889061,
-0.0254204217,
-0.0618242845,
0.0215656143,
-0.0036453411,
0.0346599445,
0.0047716489,
-0.0055938452,
0.0084314337,
0.0464769416,
0.0089833094,
-0.0133819757,
-0.0310485549,
-0.0129301436,
-0.008940734,
0.0273467656,
0.0216288008,
-0.0015357982,
0.0379655324,
-0.0873532519,
-0.0235344525,
-0.0285894573,
-0.0313939005,
-0.0121123847,
-0.0047212602,
0.0329664387,
0.0238738861,
-0.0165132098,
-0.0402866304,
0.0235322788,
0.0389986932,
-0.0106759481,
0.0101958029,
0.0266063269,
0.0074853469,
-0.0194634777,
-0.0227522701,
0.0003728692,
-0.0362335891,
0.0112146623,
0.0313502699,
0.0517866015,
-0.0409926586,
-0.0300456434,
-0.1032168046,
0.0341322832,
-0.0171667207,
-0.0041236002,
0.0258219913,
0.0170357618,
-0.0255714022,
-0.0228454843,
-0.0280541219,
0.0010730616,
0.0196178295,
0.0181728639,
0.0323843099,
0.0014848375,
-0.0168869309,
-0.0521423519,
0.0087611154,
0.003272251,
0.0153872315,
-0.0151681919,
-0.0003836556,
-0.0734597519,
0.0350432433,
-0.0067733121,
0.0367049649,
0.0172862634,
-0.0387767181,
0.0170161873,
-0.017848812,
0.0441774875,
0.0485538729,
-0.0049570473,
0.0193145555,
0.0366858542,
0.0152259618,
-0.0508452952,
0.0229499582,
-0.0416134968,
-0.076180689,
-0.0151565373,
-0.0323752984,
0.0308451764,
0.0485554636,
0.015006925,
-0.0105382046,
-0.0555505715,
0.0061839544,
-0.0052940613,
-0.0041774944,
-0.0373403057,
-0.0059698639,
-0.0161987003,
0.0321395919,
-0.0199482422,
-0.0606814064,
0.0438213311,
-0.046041891,
0.0045298268,
-0.0437911041,
-0.0468402021,
-0.037705157,
0.0890349299,
0.0232882407,
0.0083861807,
0.0512078442,
-0.0097303456,
-0.0199980326,
0.0012941706,
-0.0095228748,
-0.0213735029,
0.0317238756,
-0.0663891286,
0.0043500438,
-0.0090212049,
-0.0351953879,
-0.0366894305,
-0.0486565493,
-0.0539878979,
0.003891411,
-0.0112417368,
-0.0100129545,
-0.007037844,
-0.0096957767,
0.0326164104,
0.0583750196,
-0.011304385,
-0.0359012634,
-0.0500397868,
-0.0032283738,
0.0684062168,
0.0060288315,
-0.0068074604,
0.0078778118,
0.0287360903,
0.03472431,
0.0489246063,
0.0286337938,
-0.0712634921,
0.0077364533,
0.0181893446,
-0.0374544114,
-0.0018602314,
0.0698982924,
0.0694833174,
-0.0718609318,
-0.0026307718,
0.1325179189,
0.041547671,
-0.0092419619,
0.0153717836,
0.0262165274,
0.0169317778,
0.0557470955,
0.0289504267,
-0.0525978915,
-0.0723236427,
0.0323800705,
0.0177107789,
-0.0101617733,
-0.0011841339,
-0.0280083772,
-0.1351046264,
0.0340542756,
-0.0381902531,
-0.0077363015,
-0.0214635916,
-0.0638328642,
0.0020913607,
-0.0275754798,
-0.0064000185,
0.0032832571,
-0.0252104141,
0.0085854735,
0.0125059476,
-0.0525817461,
-0.0643803477,
0.0649780631,
-0.0552944466,
0.078530699,
0.0820592716,
0.0012889202,
0.009998736,
-0.0027295151,
0.0464698076,
0.0194673557,
0.0302388072,
0.013528591,
0.0664589852,
-0.0238691289,
-0.003717144,
0.0024435148,
0.0259079318,
-0.0696733296,
-0.0130207147,
0.0409277342,
0.0693762451,
-0.0082254307,
0.0048073158,
-0.035217911,
-0.0112640085,
0.0459791832,
0.084708035,
0.0229702052,
-0.0510211885,
-0.0358161852,
-0.0257599335,
-0.0139467465,
-0.0326802731,
-0.0517862253,
0.0075382623,
-0.0140183978,
0.0076584024,
-0.0711783469,
-0.0379294567,
0.0729419887,
0.0219121277,
0.0419110768,
0.0015481258,
-0.0023825637,
0.0393969044,
-0.0211583301,
0.0559463203,
-0.023556361,
0.0320590138,
-0.0809152275,
-0.0152556393,
0.0436383598,
-0.0056015123,
-0.0098149218,
0.0151543329,
-0.0668426529,
-0.0361509658,
-0.0347995088,
0.0785651579,
0.0239728559,
0.013132209,
-0.035691835,
-0.0460048132,
0.0078897243,
0.0410098471,
-0.0679142103,
-0.0256681237,
0.0028605317,
0.0045369258,
-0.0055108042,
0.0314115435,
-0.0691315234,
0.0169856828,
-0.0069467686,
0.0224165469,
0.0059270626,
-0.0403345004,
0.0321450345,
0.0184934083,
0.0513541847,
-0.0177364051,
-0.0156558957,
-0.0174228866,
-0.0099759819,
-0.012359702,
-0.0342583284,
-0.057201162,
0.0664167479,
0.0079887426,
-0.0151887219,
0.0167584047,
-0.0384521261,
-0.0210878383,
0.050739754,
-0.0342454873,
-0.0208235849,
0.0310127102,
0.0072285561,
0.033758495,
0.0040657436,
-0.0364364721,
-0.0052542645,
-0.0295066256,
0.0031744288,
-0.011899516,
0.0611651726,
0.0080738952,
0.0044994252,
-0.0029903944,
0.0527587458,
-0.0391139723,
-0.0585079975,
-0.0288391206,
0.0314233303,
0.0421752147,
0.0043117781,
0.0210937075,
-0.026673032,
-0.0102742817,
-0.0419397019,
0.0421325751,
0.0096820174,
-0.013670166,
0.0318302028,
0.0396043509,
-0.0393195339,
-0.0087764161,
0.0605565608,
0.0158309732,
0.0419301465,
0.0056693708,
-0.0313519873,
-0.0537184551,
0.000764486,
0.011547925,
0.0097796954,
-0.019965034,
0.0217564106,
-0.017186502,
-0.0594954416,
-0.0161930136,
0.0374818668,
0.0032502965,
-0.0287473779,
0.060066022,
0.0746473074,
0.0008672136,
-0.0188141298,
-0.0532884374,
-0.022245707,
-0.0306316577,
-0.036940679,
-0.0294080731,
-5.836240188e-33,
-0.0234535914,
0.0016222501,
0.027548112,
-0.0107242698,
0.0060194656,
0.006397319,
-0.020738082,
-0.0037917315,
-0.0146755176,
-0.0032172641,
-0.0272353813,
-0.0078234123,
0.0183470026,
0.0195083953,
0.0216001198,
0.0019507662,
0.0401865393,
-0.0284806099,
-0.0348411724,
0.0365286581,
0.0342880115,
0.0115769031,
0.0095236255,
-0.0494384393,
0.0238070861,
0.0083944816,
-0.0237467382,
0.0228899568,
-0.0017860876,
0.0632726178,
-0.0258160718,
0.0352262557,
0.0159906726,
-0.0662670061,
-0.0176071655,
0.0417679474,
-0.0313961841,
-0.0181429219,
-0.0061777239,
-0.0110862246,
-0.0440662801,
-0.012941095,
0.0057820897,
-0.027427936,
-0.0096843718,
0.0129406685,
0.0618826747,
-0.0196008626,
-0.0003829689,
-0.0008536436,
-0.0562906191,
-0.0077198963,
0.0076479083,
-0.0499044396,
-0.0086866152,
0.065871954,
-0.0138814524,
0.0376667827,
-0.0188393854,
-0.0224133283,
0.0200507268,
0.0590381697,
0.0509148501,
0.006744103,
-0.0131983291,
0.0383578315,
0.0001919854,
-0.0036153907,
-0.013695308,
0.0159110632,
-0.0191774797,
0.077933073,
0.0507373326,
0.0277907625,
0.0114160692,
0.0128864869,
-0.0291073956,
0.0318638682,
0.0032774189,
0.0262500662,
0.0347101763,
-0.0084314328,
-0.0343994275,
0.0055207433,
-0.0488501079,
0.002411695,
-0.0246421862,
-0.0202782862,
0.0723910704,
0.0389556251,
-0.0114119314,
-0.0111205177,
0.03368048,
-0.0105550522,
-0.0117971981,
0.0150436228,
-0.0255039092,
0.0274738353,
-0.0102176853,
0.0161182154,
-0.0287324954,
-0.0136189898,
0.0310441479,
-0.0026652685,
0.03759747,
0.0067929076,
0.0133910403,
0.061368037,
-0.0696546063,
0.0173278414,
-0.0429379418,
0.0492415614,
-0.0261835996,
0.0364660956,
0.012022024,
-0.0103582852,
-0.0258625001,
0.0586803779,
-0.0177725591,
-0.0560463183,
-0.0208492689,
-0.019623369,
0.0008633378,
0.0003570612,
-0.0394799076,
-0.0060415273,
-0.0512502864,
0.0257473513,
0.0220983457,
-0.0171764176,
-0.0192998536,
0.0176556893,
2.691e-7,
0.0077035031,
0.0226865429,
0.0113089504,
0.0365872197,
0.0032254809,
0.0590696037,
-0.0257539134,
0.047210779,
0.0184336938,
-0.039841637,
-0.0219810288,
0.0324185789,
0.0434216894,
-0.0072743255,
-0.0986016765,
0.0019617439,
-0.0475339144,
0.0275574438,
-0.0888968334,
0.0111551806,
0.0731357932,
0.1134229302,
0.0144745288,
-0.0008380654,
-0.0118787335,
-0.0233298019,
-0.0058048479,
-0.0372139774,
0.0016810738,
0.0280434713,
0.0433469191,
0.0203266311,
-0.0207922533,
0.0008674797,
-0.0310287308,
-0.0127128139,
-0.0098664546,
0.0908915773,
-0.001462148,
-0.0258431472,
0.0090842778,
-0.0215818863,
0.001007729,
-0.0417663343,
0.0814699084,
-0.067451261,
-0.0126930932,
-0.0326340869,
-0.025253037,
-0.0268185064,
-0.0268139467,
-0.0241148546,
-0.0019355859,
-0.0039375643,
0.0169170424,
-0.0164530352,
-0.0364653543,
-0.1025890112,
-0.0057500531,
0.004821823,
-0.0244968999,
-0.0266303066,
-0.0426906012,
-0.0071655777,
0.0101573272,
-0.0652661324,
-0.0042337263,
2.664125014e-34,
0.0098473309,
-0.0006676285,
0.0306277964,
-0.0066245347,
0.0404017083,
0.0051653339,
-0.0144316517,
-0.0021981641,
0.0062663462,
-0.0628560334,
-0.0274011753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12247v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12247v1 | How to Protect Copyright Data in Optimization of Large Language Models? | 2023-08-23T16:48:04 | 2023-08-23T16:48:04 | Timothy Chu, Zhao Song, Chiwun Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) and generative AI have played a transformative
role in computer research and applications. Controversy has arisen as to
whether these models output copyrighted data, which can occur if the data the
models are trained on is copyrighted. LLMs are built on the transformer neural
network architecture, which in turn relies on a mathematical computation called
Attention that uses the softmax function.
In this paper, we show that large language model training and optimization
can be seen as a softmax regression problem. We then establish a method of
efficiently performing softmax regression, in a way that prevents the
regression function from generating copyright data. This establishes a
theoretical method of training large language models in a way that avoids
generating copyright data. | [
0.01559979,
0.1142988801,
-0.0242112465,
0.0773500353,
-0.0211642329,
0.0034521837,
0.0597118996,
-0.0032515512,
-0.0336289667,
-0.0343124159,
-0.0327745602,
-0.0507305264,
-0.0019942001,
0.0122396545,
0.0343329161,
0.0218867995,
0.0113030002,
-0.0328231417,
-0.0238165576,
-0.0403280556,
-0.0058377106,
-0.0042778803,
0.0560485907,
0.0276137702,
-0.0533830598,
0.0039889184,
0.0253020227,
-0.0175329112,
0.0002924287,
0.0222060643,
0.0165488534,
0.0526314788,
0.0182702318,
0.0782882124,
0.0000016979,
-0.0375729464,
-0.0019443152,
0.017238196,
0.0039632292,
0.0638106689,
0.0462638289,
-0.0357442684,
0.0123078814,
-0.0052608517,
-0.0236921515,
0.0156166526,
0.0428175442,
0.0321054421,
0.080628626,
0.0854862407,
-0.018095199,
-0.0598348007,
0.0229755882,
-0.0506684482,
-0.0032008425,
-0.0866143331,
0.0308652744,
0.0044177151,
-0.0134290932,
-0.0183635298,
-0.0132431118,
0.0812535584,
0.0167047996,
0.0174979288,
0.0145716332,
0.0225691199,
-0.0387570001,
0.002603991,
0.0098644169,
0.0702333227,
-0.0560864322,
-0.0556236096,
0.0399493389,
-0.0013952862,
0.0335084796,
0.0115555646,
-0.0119909868,
0.0615590177,
0.0372966714,
0.0528765209,
0.0124243759,
-0.0340547599,
0.0367962494,
0.0279158726,
-0.019375883,
0.0257071722,
0.0016186556,
-0.0316285715,
-0.0133475456,
0.0006474113,
-0.0483310409,
0.0017872798,
0.030394841,
0.0008653769,
0.0028033056,
0.0136173777,
-0.093122229,
-0.0598729141,
-0.0087984214,
-0.0914622098,
0.0518600456,
-0.0144367944,
0.0375443436,
0.0355345123,
-0.0348540209,
0.0591801032,
-0.058108516,
0.0242913961,
0.0059923804,
-0.0109962588,
-0.0138811814,
-0.0057869763,
-0.058916755,
0.0627110302,
-0.020746652,
-0.006373948,
-0.0166810397,
0.0206279978,
-0.0495897532,
-0.005528572,
-0.0209524129,
0.0351783223,
-0.0400494672,
-0.0232448727,
0.0129393535,
-0.0137189813,
0.015446824,
0.0396537408,
-0.0195419956,
-0.0631842464,
0.0011774213,
0.0055542928,
0.0118193273,
0.001196321,
0.0054213898,
0.0768212005,
0.0024907135,
0.0027698667,
0.0048049684,
-0.0588269159,
-0.0010528743,
-0.0228176266,
0.0252925232,
-0.0663384199,
0.0255304128,
-0.019083729,
0.0072430125,
-0.0770101249,
-0.0097535038,
0.011962642,
-0.0708889365,
0.0466420017,
0.0323863328,
0.0246858299,
0.0055720434,
-0.0052790479,
0.0040527564,
0.0338992216,
0.0269708578,
0.0217458624,
0.0231861211,
-0.0180961452,
0.0504717827,
0.0638517141,
0.032942608,
0.0228493735,
-0.0235622711,
-0.0196121838,
0.0276116319,
-0.0150614483,
-0.0102450699,
0.0783953518,
-0.0025638288,
-0.0248389561,
0.0874569044,
0.0442552976,
0.0100089749,
0.0936004966,
-0.0010821458,
-0.0108710341,
-0.0159974862,
-0.0283875261,
-0.0499123931,
-0.0110869082,
0.0031364982,
-0.0230351854,
-0.0346776173,
0.0223290939,
-0.007185447,
0.0123647014,
0.0231862981,
-0.0195432398,
-0.0141882505,
-0.0260243062,
0.0304150432,
0.0027420518,
-0.0172212347,
0.0929459184,
0.0047534616,
-0.0278939754,
0.0283072926,
-0.0691818967,
-0.000665427,
-0.0160766412,
0.0315146074,
-0.0205098279,
0.0317797139,
-0.021689197,
-0.0501891412,
0.0247130599,
0.0298705269,
-0.0021436044,
-0.0026254477,
-0.0338698216,
-0.0106509356,
-0.0090011153,
0.0093375733,
0.0263654515,
-0.0180799682,
0.0384466834,
0.0565417856,
0.0100245913,
-0.0668571964,
0.0187159143,
-0.0204586145,
-0.0480773188,
0.0197463762,
0.0054601869,
0.0559548549,
0.0196433831,
-0.0308630709,
0.0159017425,
0.0157924201,
-0.0255272668,
-0.0461660586,
-0.0293023605,
-0.0319889039,
0.0231232475,
0.0342571549,
-0.0670605376,
0.0390820689,
0.0722207725,
-0.0230157394,
-0.0230421256,
0.0429568775,
-0.0433678217,
0.0170856044,
-0.0428907275,
0.0225966014,
-0.0420111008,
0.0599787049,
-0.034810815,
0.023562599,
0.0139992367,
0.0183315799,
0.0475179255,
-0.0584570132,
0.0307803769,
-0.0349935479,
-0.0559477732,
0.0227726232,
-0.0407914743,
0.0475672036,
-0.0054965909,
-0.0056526749,
0.0149789723,
-0.0166226178,
0.0079063894,
-0.0176274739,
-0.0181551147,
0.003109819,
0.012006986,
-0.0063281343,
0.000368701,
-0.0086142318,
-0.0271386318,
-0.0028257843,
0.002350806,
-0.0234913249,
-0.0012813748,
0.0127508454,
-0.0293309782,
0.0103522288,
-0.0474320129,
-0.0072138375,
0.0570571162,
-0.0021276406,
-0.0032882786,
-0.0647666305,
0.0370177068,
-0.0178549904,
0.06449797,
0.0103376471,
-0.0237503592,
-0.0172850005,
-0.0238697529,
-0.009680843,
0.0982393995,
0.0182434656,
-0.0348508656,
0.0387418941,
0.0129589671,
-0.0427591726,
0.0003715296,
-0.0513756573,
-0.047597494,
-0.0442003645,
-0.0298138522,
0.0414555036,
0.0317884721,
0.0066763861,
-0.0608008131,
-0.0371614918,
0.047934819,
-0.0185349714,
-0.0386775248,
0.0091656474,
-0.0024916395,
-0.0348408744,
0.0107437195,
-0.0069754319,
-0.0476181991,
0.0369613282,
-0.0643972158,
0.0296965428,
-0.0155489175,
0.0085843727,
-0.0253956299,
0.0134932445,
0.0234332643,
0.0205257162,
0.0034906536,
-0.0099541806,
-0.0247214325,
0.0198776796,
0.0608128086,
-0.0385883413,
0.0534976572,
0.0262246933,
0.0167816617,
-0.0236858055,
-0.0220318642,
-0.0247834325,
-0.0707355961,
0.0180605054,
0.0235163067,
0.0376562625,
0.0220420659,
-0.028834125,
-0.0017764693,
0.0263989624,
0.035647776,
0.0047701253,
0.0193875972,
-0.031651374,
0.0336523429,
0.0525892116,
0.0117683187,
-0.0133353863,
-0.0134992786,
-0.0323420465,
0.011867227,
0.011966479,
0.0605602972,
-0.0177329332,
-0.0033400934,
0.0340520144,
0.0175520796,
0.0194229353,
0.0161187947,
0.0267708804,
-0.0257068537,
-0.0025168776,
0.0755156651,
-0.0141697219,
-0.0437021814,
0.0053797909,
0.0315906815,
-0.0149393566,
0.0148321548,
0.0170575734,
-0.0482775345,
-0.0042726123,
0.0022513825,
0.0328349583,
-0.0214361865,
-0.04200802,
0.0139981033,
-0.0982341245,
-0.0081002414,
0.0082700308,
-0.0342710689,
-0.055708617,
0.0016198809,
-0.004930485,
-0.0212371089,
-0.0324456021,
-0.0431785472,
0.0143746035,
-0.0285979323,
0.0162905194,
0.0451246239,
-0.0125530064,
-0.0163087361,
-0.0524958298,
0.0372161083,
0.0873913988,
0.0293720849,
-0.05584611,
-0.0188617818,
0.0262749419,
0.0033956573,
-0.0245144945,
0.0345047489,
-0.0008646201,
0.0160019696,
-0.0371042937,
0.0050806911,
0.0644600689,
-0.000283401,
0.0069377534,
-0.0071539339,
0.082223475,
0.0185375754,
-0.0573038943,
0.0097278543,
-0.0273971651,
0.0254876819,
0.0454591587,
0.0417219996,
-0.0293605141,
0.0004373137,
-0.0491855331,
-0.0149411699,
-0.0407722481,
-0.0478774942,
0.0095932884,
-0.0190581996,
-0.0412802659,
-0.0709136501,
0.0092108725,
-0.0440566391,
0.0379704013,
0.0334724747,
-0.0384888165,
0.0830062851,
-0.0332805589,
-0.0303973258,
0.0138307456,
-0.058030352,
-0.0023156351,
-0.037453711,
0.0085519273,
0.0571009815,
0.0029444068,
-0.0294474643,
0.0115881618,
-0.0839436352,
-0.089414604,
0.0187192708,
0.0545855463,
0.0192057062,
-0.0094157718,
-0.0283038542,
-0.0746771842,
0.1146877185,
0.1049618497,
-0.0223252773,
0.0270251967,
0.0481848903,
-0.0697502941,
-0.0090953531,
0.0514518879,
-0.0320058689,
0.0095837833,
0.0633551106,
-0.013256195,
-0.0080314577,
-0.0401500836,
0.0007445159,
0.028470289,
0.0013781239,
-0.0087995064,
0.031403143,
-0.034250129,
0.0138057526,
0.0195809361,
-0.0118631916,
-0.0468811467,
-0.0133796902,
0.0384809636,
-0.0036539263,
-0.0021391078,
0.0128995553,
0.04550495,
-0.0029236788,
-0.0468816832,
0.0234181788,
-0.001363703,
-0.0217380282,
0.0418114401,
0.022464795,
-0.0115962252,
0.0275971107,
0.0173851699,
0.0312076956,
-0.0237417333,
0.0270663202,
0.0335847586,
0.0376622416,
-0.0177266672,
0.002341148,
-0.0264777355,
-0.0639321655,
-0.03190488,
0.0087778363,
0.0389049873,
-0.0163896382,
0.0191224031,
-0.0617487133,
-0.0228569899,
-0.014485158,
0.0262864605,
-0.0261472408,
-0.0484271273,
-0.0029297927,
-0.0146065401,
0.000163856,
-0.0076970127,
0.0764608383,
0.0117760999,
0.0279584341,
-0.0201330222,
-0.0351065546,
-0.0136672556,
-0.0275806524,
0.0059853173,
-0.0381189808,
-0.0089619365,
0.0117277354,
-0.0004553436,
-0.1023425683,
-0.0048645968,
-0.0101631936,
0.0286942814,
-0.0127178738,
0.0122946994,
0.0163818281,
-0.0104904603,
0.0016651241,
-0.0524299964,
0.0452521481,
-0.0069726836,
-0.0224132538,
-0.0311865136,
-5.694904257e-33,
0.009355478,
-0.0059274728,
-0.0517648272,
0.0323906951,
-0.0399000943,
0.0285223834,
-0.0054944833,
-0.0165338367,
-0.0179704744,
-0.0097063677,
-0.0417670533,
0.0063536814,
-0.0055781384,
0.0509005338,
-0.0126908906,
-0.0392581858,
0.0018452422,
-0.0294628311,
-0.0207940601,
0.0097359987,
0.0035201022,
0.0163047872,
0.0486792773,
-0.0314970613,
-0.0062015974,
-0.0245953575,
-0.0322479531,
0.0033271131,
-0.0326930359,
0.0591243096,
-0.0115829529,
0.0199328996,
0.0276367106,
-0.1169298291,
-0.0007901822,
0.0274122525,
-0.0220285431,
0.0094664255,
-0.005182703,
0.0042468635,
0.0412895977,
-0.0339831375,
0.0989749283,
-0.0049095368,
-0.0166680105,
-0.0147136375,
0.0387556925,
-0.0258960966,
-0.020782005,
-0.0707518756,
-0.0478136055,
-0.0220265985,
-0.0165064707,
0.0287062414,
0.0577891804,
-0.019992603,
-0.0099960966,
0.0275239311,
-0.035278853,
0.0263638236,
0.027758697,
0.0324762166,
0.0615962632,
0.0545956269,
0.0500582866,
0.0176454484,
0.0229234025,
-0.0021359173,
-0.0440869853,
-0.0175875556,
0.0448004864,
0.0228458811,
0.0524713024,
0.0522198193,
0.0431481339,
-0.0286120847,
-0.0370937511,
-0.0097101144,
-0.0401194766,
-0.0038066509,
0.0620055646,
-0.0124364197,
0.0144238239,
-0.0092832744,
-0.0728993043,
-0.0385421552,
-0.0284746103,
0.0335853733,
-0.0091069657,
0.0157170855,
-0.0407834835,
0.0450418256,
0.0544177219,
-0.0963196382,
-0.0016502239,
0.0083109988,
0.0218202751,
0.020029949,
-0.0040439768,
-0.0100920908,
-0.054786481,
-0.0287670325,
-0.0109139681,
0.0001648936,
0.063045308,
0.0044918638,
0.0545196719,
0.0365032963,
-0.0376010314,
-0.0036221913,
-0.0374553762,
0.0282515492,
0.0299644284,
0.0625132993,
0.0270813983,
-0.0212834161,
0.0167787746,
0.0220724232,
0.0141622964,
0.017927289,
0.003211377,
0.0266342089,
0.033154238,
0.003815185,
-0.0491270833,
-0.0114181004,
-0.0387546793,
0.0592586361,
0.0733290389,
-0.0572279505,
-0.0412535146,
-0.0148091605,
2.506e-7,
-0.0004277232,
0.002566302,
-0.0011847479,
0.02587891,
0.0245631859,
0.0761711299,
0.0099148294,
0.0904553235,
-0.0040600798,
0.0139561472,
0.0192718487,
0.0010650009,
0.0193480756,
-0.0054366249,
-0.1104260087,
-0.0402800515,
-0.0455402024,
0.0193574745,
-0.0512289628,
0.0030203243,
0.0001590611,
0.1019754782,
0.0190981645,
-0.0283401571,
0.0047505419,
-0.0531243868,
0.0300266221,
-0.018998893,
0.0228782352,
0.0235712342,
0.0459810942,
0.004509096,
-0.0333016515,
-0.0170434825,
-0.0107644917,
0.0398730412,
-0.0122284312,
0.0530246869,
0.0259111524,
-0.0314268209,
0.000412743,
-0.0541757606,
-0.0085253716,
-0.0397752263,
0.0390280597,
-0.0159955304,
-0.0398627408,
0.0004186427,
0.0029593937,
-0.0254738946,
-0.0334994718,
-0.0616003163,
0.0601399057,
-0.0110564362,
-0.0117293615,
0.0096495524,
0.0149031794,
-0.0753302425,
0.0204904638,
-0.011634184,
-0.0603512339,
-0.0095328251,
-0.0058425046,
-0.0128181996,
0.0443836562,
-0.0401791893,
0.0720229968,
1.92476834e-34,
-0.0074899774,
-0.0256971922,
0.0267501008,
-0.0075778444,
0.0136664016,
-0.0060874261,
0.0057219937,
0.020383209,
-0.0071103028,
-0.0720462427,
-0.0381460711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12219v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12219v2 | Diffusion Language Models Can Perform Many Tasks with Scaling and Instruction-Finetuning | 2023-08-23T16:01:12 | 2023-08-25T16:32:31 | Jiasheng Ye, Zaixiang Zheng, Yu Bao, Lihua Qian, Quanquan Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The recent surge of generative AI has been fueled by the generative power of
diffusion probabilistic models and the scalable capabilities of large language
models. Despite their potential, it remains elusive whether diffusion language
models can solve general language tasks comparable to their autoregressive
counterparts. This paper demonstrates that scaling diffusion models w.r.t.
data, sizes, and tasks can effectively make them strong language learners. We
build competent diffusion language models at scale by first acquiring knowledge
from massive data via masked language modeling pretraining thanks to their
intrinsic connections. We then reprogram pretrained masked language models into
diffusion language models via diffusive adaptation, wherein task-specific
finetuning and instruction finetuning are explored to unlock their versatility
in solving general language tasks. Experiments show that scaling diffusion
language models consistently improves performance across downstream language
tasks. We further discover that instruction finetuning can elicit zero-shot and
few-shot in-context learning abilities that help tackle many unseen tasks by
following natural language instructions, and show promise in advanced and
challenging abilities such as reasoning. | [
-0.0010627977,
0.0417661332,
-0.0317803062,
0.0139932213,
-0.0024439818,
0.0321387537,
0.0438197292,
-0.04165015,
0.0037447859,
-0.0229995623,
-0.0473344289,
-0.0358813703,
-0.0033504041,
0.0342144147,
0.0368659981,
-0.0451054722,
0.0339040235,
-0.0655352771,
-0.0458863601,
-0.0173413567,
-0.0221663397,
0.0126304794,
-0.0103661325,
0.0030643938,
0.0086212456,
-0.0062157027,
-0.0011884612,
-0.009674117,
0.0140572367,
-0.03016744,
0.0142535502,
0.0250907913,
0.0641860068,
0.0155250337,
0.0000020173,
-0.0369560011,
0.0249625463,
-0.0080609899,
-0.0266338997,
-0.0233788453,
0.0383937694,
-0.0111244451,
-0.0125935469,
0.010450975,
-0.0397720635,
-0.0319256335,
0.0550518706,
0.0223238319,
0.057858739,
0.0768013299,
-0.0004357004,
-0.0863678902,
0.0321959071,
-0.0573457591,
0.0424443372,
-0.0417393334,
0.0316318609,
0.0435312092,
0.0215437561,
0.0049242959,
-0.0585800931,
0.0347598121,
0.0349319614,
-0.0153257949,
0.02376418,
0.0757598132,
0.0374636762,
-0.0168237425,
-0.0022527089,
0.0964786187,
-0.0488194972,
-0.0193404555,
0.0146628749,
-0.0177321397,
0.0069673648,
0.030883912,
-0.038213782,
-0.0093442993,
0.0423037894,
0.0262932144,
0.0133793382,
-0.0353200696,
0.0584990904,
-0.002892379,
-0.0329269208,
0.0600764453,
0.0062298034,
-0.0017484445,
0.0071780584,
-0.0230338704,
-0.0228617918,
-0.0644595772,
-0.0038435571,
0.0415974222,
-0.0052914228,
0.0318595171,
-0.0570202544,
-0.041509822,
-0.0008417499,
0.0161547698,
0.0633514524,
0.0263858605,
0.0263779853,
0.0622945726,
-0.075865373,
0.016666675,
-0.0303908326,
0.0084700398,
-0.0305264145,
-0.0126295062,
-0.0521428473,
0.0052974382,
-0.0496024713,
0.0289883744,
-0.0508898422,
-0.0006410007,
-0.0248539839,
0.0180827156,
-0.0032529333,
0.0079916837,
0.0283594746,
-0.0267717242,
-0.0502530225,
-0.0525387749,
-0.0126696881,
0.017270308,
-0.0425559171,
0.0111359134,
0.0366427638,
0.0073592472,
-0.0414281934,
-0.0129408929,
0.0302722864,
-0.0345528014,
0.0333771259,
0.037013825,
-0.0218589921,
-0.0222031157,
-0.0442327149,
0.0012733262,
0.0034541804,
-0.0687157214,
0.0083812801,
-0.0714867935,
0.0275846757,
-0.0170133151,
-0.0009588492,
-0.0580246337,
0.0217002966,
-0.006117051,
-0.0494158566,
0.0780158266,
0.010062607,
0.0158385001,
0.037183594,
-0.0032568215,
0.001034628,
0.0475049205,
0.0320264921,
-0.0063903243,
-0.0212561172,
-0.0091202268,
0.0161747932,
0.0045082932,
0.0534781367,
0.0325967148,
0.016510129,
-0.0069302702,
0.0036915538,
0.0022587706,
0.0666436553,
0.0339927562,
-0.0394537821,
0.00185584,
0.071836859,
0.0555915236,
-0.013138161,
-0.01844736,
0.0650251508,
0.0103786206,
-0.0560358204,
-0.0061801658,
-0.0422269478,
0.0272199363,
0.0238404684,
0.0114271743,
-0.007257971,
0.0293607004,
-0.0597863905,
-0.0430375077,
0.0107323881,
-0.0087811518,
0.0669966564,
0.0393779874,
0.0613084845,
0.0564067811,
-0.0505125374,
-0.0063422681,
0.0301254112,
-0.0178059731,
0.0048345663,
-0.0505030677,
0.0265174955,
0.0426562615,
0.0299079046,
-0.0133368801,
-0.0042179544,
-0.0246425476,
0.0522989444,
0.0230794959,
0.0355331227,
-0.0039953743,
-0.0023728295,
-0.0439809151,
0.0211213175,
-0.0128041692,
0.0210011657,
0.0276961774,
-0.0151925916,
0.0231494494,
0.0082855774,
-0.0229713246,
-0.0208692309,
0.0256701671,
-0.0766566396,
-0.0560261495,
0.0253231879,
0.0010359089,
-0.0005459993,
-0.0363075845,
-0.0342760012,
0.0088598672,
-0.0107890628,
-0.0397821888,
-0.0299189966,
0.0077477768,
-0.0403254628,
-0.02136226,
0.0058600781,
-0.0237810519,
-0.0180431474,
0.0102128321,
-0.0317748226,
-0.0241656564,
0.0457568839,
-0.0019012176,
0.0170216691,
-0.022566596,
0.0213035122,
0.0135318842,
0.0474799462,
-0.0105777839,
0.0661419854,
-0.0304529462,
-0.0020164445,
-0.0184248202,
0.0543517023,
-0.0141653148,
-0.018742729,
0.0052358569,
-0.0402048603,
0.0157023184,
0.0185400471,
-0.0138801532,
-0.0077613271,
-0.0316861272,
-0.0225517862,
-0.0460344478,
0.0279421192,
-0.0303433053,
0.0067164088,
0.0270832945,
0.0061117322,
-0.0057092407,
-0.0104741165,
-0.0316131748,
0.0190005936,
0.008085778,
0.0091623496,
0.0259256549,
-0.0077592428,
-0.0101088807,
-0.043307405,
-0.0224687494,
-0.0053343792,
0.0090457266,
-0.0077529578,
0.0214422252,
-0.049040582,
0.0412886664,
-0.0015879865,
0.0341373459,
-0.0314082429,
-0.0305749327,
0.0055920561,
-0.011866604,
0.0637493804,
0.0991862491,
-0.0124778273,
0.0461817198,
0.0522117838,
-0.0275167096,
-0.0278177373,
0.0365017056,
-0.0384492651,
-0.0040807151,
-0.0495783538,
-0.0277790371,
-0.035063047,
0.0794683173,
0.010741978,
-0.0353209525,
-0.0666180849,
0.0069289459,
-0.007285736,
-0.0398268998,
-0.0349624977,
-0.0005656842,
-0.0051004644,
0.0064104497,
-0.0526250936,
-0.0449906662,
0.0567037985,
-0.0010998069,
-0.0051025674,
-0.0661193207,
-0.0425908491,
0.012794517,
0.0349046402,
0.0196035281,
0.0298302099,
0.0132598011,
-0.01878573,
-0.0573602021,
-0.0008182196,
0.009914563,
-0.0085364422,
0.0158958714,
-0.0555601344,
0.0177102648,
0.0021036528,
-0.0227493066,
-0.0336479433,
-0.0666148141,
0.0165683441,
0.0182606187,
-0.0080864476,
-0.0244450998,
-0.029880112,
-0.0201801453,
0.0463034958,
0.0508338287,
0.0156366304,
-0.013522991,
-0.0236359052,
-0.0074858381,
0.0719637051,
0.0079659354,
0.0052066459,
-0.0510386266,
0.0405318066,
0.0102647552,
0.0628847107,
-0.0097786691,
-0.0127094975,
0.0173105728,
-0.0194489863,
-0.0154663967,
0.0032276926,
0.0275327433,
0.0929683968,
-0.0566724502,
-0.025583433,
0.0746848658,
0.0141624864,
0.0135481097,
0.0080607012,
0.0094259288,
0.0674827322,
0.0210514888,
0.0354088135,
-0.095408313,
-0.0153013058,
0.0063334112,
0.0031180703,
0.015190674,
-0.0420301594,
-0.0066210097,
-0.1253605932,
0.0463746674,
0.0228626318,
0.0010213803,
-0.0059444671,
-0.0600809306,
-0.0102238096,
0.0290563907,
0.0147556411,
-0.0224214029,
0.0047572311,
-0.0049421377,
0.0014261001,
0.0647059828,
-0.072484605,
0.0567344837,
-0.03154286,
0.0487080291,
0.0622030646,
0.000347147,
0.0034365063,
-0.0599393547,
0.0514526628,
-0.0155992461,
-0.0013293512,
0.0145456716,
0.0471310914,
0.009259156,
-0.0358757712,
0.0223405473,
0.0682431161,
-0.0397489145,
-0.0197103526,
-0.0222015399,
0.068570435,
0.0017245349,
-0.0670807213,
0.0099679548,
-0.0267122388,
0.046550516,
0.056340877,
0.0368521996,
-0.0538311452,
-0.045705691,
-0.0295469165,
0.011580023,
-0.0193659533,
-0.0568170473,
0.0482590571,
-0.0021410491,
-0.0475448668,
-0.0836290643,
-0.0265616942,
0.0407464877,
0.0565730222,
0.0237753298,
0.0025104184,
0.0451061018,
-0.0273199938,
-0.0296040904,
0.0304877441,
-0.0504946224,
0.0219640527,
-0.0478681363,
-0.0487580299,
0.0420608632,
-0.017654134,
-0.0233021174,
-0.0141547574,
-0.1225963682,
-0.0935906842,
-0.0059212358,
0.0428951494,
0.0202470981,
0.0325612463,
-0.0462931208,
-0.0732172728,
0.095502831,
0.0061951703,
0.0063852621,
0.0243297182,
0.0269730575,
-0.0386947952,
0.0130034415,
0.0402855389,
-0.033591684,
0.0556248538,
0.039318189,
0.0251902733,
-0.046632316,
0.0899894089,
-0.0007193667,
-0.0154945878,
0.0026177948,
-0.0054337848,
0.0445250086,
-0.0485033505,
0.0065212934,
-0.0091946451,
-0.0179855414,
-0.0312109552,
-0.0325089991,
0.0473131649,
-0.0111142239,
0.0062841987,
-0.0071843094,
0.0207427107,
0.0117635,
-0.032175336,
-0.0071976655,
0.0144388378,
0.0339716487,
0.0407573506,
0.0074393018,
0.0000808035,
0.0129272258,
-0.0067875958,
0.0500598922,
0.0046951105,
0.0328305811,
0.0161121394,
-0.0063562347,
-0.0562027469,
0.0088342838,
-0.0581791997,
-0.0593181737,
-0.0063184486,
0.0084275771,
0.0655810386,
0.0089833299,
0.0147974063,
-0.0266089998,
-0.0085348617,
-0.0119540691,
0.0083710281,
-0.0096631777,
-0.0207110308,
0.0232967269,
0.0213394295,
-0.0040721949,
0.0161124654,
0.0695065856,
-0.005773975,
0.0691282451,
0.002625806,
0.0384492651,
-0.0289753135,
-0.0324670635,
-0.0497814715,
0.0195925087,
0.0117064677,
0.0641635582,
-0.0194870662,
-0.1089533567,
-0.0582111701,
0.0281833094,
-0.0033129237,
-0.0065931929,
0.0265684985,
0.0005721339,
-0.0129117528,
-0.0106679434,
-0.0526697263,
0.0326974727,
0.0318022929,
-0.0195218101,
-0.0060572047,
-6.842106663e-33,
-0.0157912802,
-0.0041878186,
0.031657923,
-0.0289982501,
0.0021054936,
-0.043691285,
-0.062436942,
0.0076016081,
-0.0552408062,
0.033294972,
-0.0172440205,
0.0398653336,
0.0010971004,
0.0476121418,
-0.0201592203,
0.0040730233,
0.0540533699,
-0.0285332128,
-0.0142619461,
0.0413038209,
0.0375923924,
0.0066672638,
0.0206167325,
-0.0588346645,
0.0076596783,
-0.0057048104,
-0.0099106682,
0.0267876238,
0.014695826,
0.0210816301,
-0.0280075558,
-0.0033804013,
0.0202610176,
-0.0209362805,
-0.0590077527,
0.0197712556,
-0.1086444706,
-0.0201076306,
0.0027715489,
-0.0212304331,
-0.0516114496,
-0.0395816602,
0.076520212,
-0.0008156773,
0.0101810824,
-0.0015543649,
0.0201098286,
-0.0134649072,
0.0039548948,
0.0307237338,
-0.0557443835,
0.0214974284,
-0.0173174944,
-0.0217351969,
0.0046009957,
-0.0371900387,
-0.0028089543,
0.0201813243,
-0.0754878819,
0.0063498789,
0.0057831118,
0.0372090042,
0.0592563674,
0.005974445,
0.0459861308,
0.0430004373,
0.0282089524,
0.0425193496,
0.0132618435,
-0.0050068526,
0.0502835773,
0.0396536663,
-0.0112176957,
0.013183522,
0.0540199913,
-0.0322362036,
-0.0667225346,
-0.0076014255,
-0.0408128537,
0.0128421513,
0.0159466062,
0.0124802515,
-0.0141524738,
-0.0156082595,
-0.0619985089,
0.0035791188,
-0.0146412002,
-0.0161206387,
0.0375039987,
0.0242559798,
0.0050816559,
-0.0083940262,
0.0437888056,
-0.0257105734,
-0.0448009633,
-0.0240063556,
-0.0035080016,
0.0133508816,
0.012622077,
0.0167647172,
-0.0680209175,
-0.0307036117,
-0.0031734505,
0.0443429537,
0.0070421444,
0.040980015,
0.0324193873,
0.0199567769,
-0.0766561851,
0.0047561829,
-0.0385446325,
0.0297772586,
0.0256679878,
0.0284614433,
0.0139998123,
0.0376359485,
-0.0109881973,
0.0318782702,
0.0116391294,
-0.0311468039,
0.0053513185,
0.0392352901,
-0.0193396267,
0.0299855303,
-0.0515743308,
-0.0080722319,
-0.0262491293,
0.0575480536,
0.0863213912,
-0.0565391779,
-0.0192659143,
0.041197598,
2.838e-7,
0.02015361,
0.0149025703,
-0.0160025693,
0.0620961338,
0.0158133525,
0.0446702577,
-0.0295040701,
0.0238013919,
0.0119749755,
-0.0557422712,
-0.0109496666,
0.0604589395,
0.0379912257,
-0.0003159056,
-0.0615920722,
-0.0120649897,
0.010401655,
0.0338186435,
-0.028655706,
-0.0146961771,
-0.0085308244,
0.1118997633,
0.0425874703,
0.001433701,
0.0428089127,
-0.0427990519,
0.0707712695,
0.0138067706,
0.0229540616,
0.0239231586,
-0.049962014,
0.012807711,
-0.0313209407,
0.026540542,
-0.0404184721,
0.0505058318,
-0.0263098497,
0.0573154464,
-0.022756204,
-0.0141071919,
0.0007761448,
0.003414005,
-0.0157859102,
-0.0327835083,
0.0725131854,
-0.0805826709,
-0.0309774969,
-0.0054215202,
-0.0277790781,
-0.0030638583,
0.0256431717,
-0.0204602163,
-0.0432982557,
0.0175994467,
0.0185635407,
0.0095008714,
0.0040965178,
-0.0936554298,
-0.0005468429,
0.0238721911,
-0.0460024923,
-0.0551655069,
-0.0156866778,
-0.0105526233,
0.0213745013,
-0.0214102175,
0.0155151663,
2.443869745e-34,
0.0252653323,
-0.0100229066,
0.0004055187,
0.0312198494,
0.0345162489,
-0.012250009,
-0.0571542941,
-0.0012368034,
0.0535732992,
-0.0950012133,
-0.0367799439
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12215v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12215v3 | The Challenges of Machine Learning for Trust and Safety: A Case Study on Misinformation Detection | 2023-08-23T15:52:20 | 2024-06-19T20:33:53 | Madelyne Xiao, Jonathan Mayer | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY | We examine the disconnect between scholarship and practice in applying
machine learning to trust and safety problems, using misinformation detection
as a case study. We survey literature on automated detection of misinformation
across a corpus of 248 well-cited papers in the field. We then examine subsets
of papers for data and code availability, design missteps, reproducibility, and
generalizability. Our paper corpus includes published work in security, natural
language processing, and computational social science. Across these disparate
disciplines, we identify common errors in dataset and method design. In
general, detection tasks are often meaningfully distinct from the challenges
that online services actually face. Datasets and model evaluation are often
non-representative of real-world contexts, and evaluation frequently is not
independent of model training. We demonstrate the limitations of current
detection methods in a series of three representative replication studies.
Based on the results of these analyses and our literature survey, we conclude
that the current state-of-the-art in fully-automated misinformation detection
has limited efficacy in detecting human-generated misinformation. We offer
recommendations for evaluating applications of machine learning to trust and
safety problems and recommend future directions for research. | [
0.051001884,
0.035995625,
-0.026202064,
0.0430046022,
-0.033632271,
-0.0052982755,
0.0253868662,
-0.0055279629,
0.0350492746,
-0.0254692957,
0.0114440834,
-0.0152554074,
0.0334104821,
0.0507293306,
-0.0005868506,
0.0002336022,
0.056886483,
0.0151272258,
0.0446094871,
0.0233787801,
0.0130531155,
0.0282017663,
-0.015201726,
0.015449835,
-0.0323886648,
-0.0407301858,
0.0041178376,
-0.0162890106,
0.0572168566,
-0.0580038652,
0.0189812146,
0.0119242296,
0.019037053,
0.0451918729,
0.0000020261,
-0.0438809134,
-0.0247130282,
0.0227034427,
-0.0616746619,
0.0202208813,
0.0251429863,
-0.0265243817,
0.0175505821,
0.0605021007,
-0.0102172811,
0.0127668772,
0.0503886789,
0.062215656,
0.0488919243,
0.0755423009,
-0.0277360454,
0.0269410368,
0.0331904925,
0.0041643945,
-0.0045457771,
-0.0352296233,
0.0718014911,
-0.0350662284,
-0.055510994,
0.0110659804,
0.0267144162,
0.0099703185,
-0.0023520985,
-0.0056454903,
0.0041470169,
0.0210753847,
-0.021924749,
-0.0301338863,
-0.039041549,
0.0361893773,
-0.0018720067,
-0.0254954509,
0.0225413516,
-0.011478845,
0.0007368345,
0.0449526682,
0.0448783822,
0.0253361389,
-0.0477797836,
-0.0301462281,
-0.0363902859,
0.0113812098,
0.0747358873,
0.0401724353,
0.0101243518,
0.062413089,
-0.0236649308,
-0.0415872447,
0.0386018157,
-0.0123956827,
0.0385290831,
-0.0499086119,
0.0181253105,
0.0029333343,
-0.0100384671,
0.0065455195,
-0.0305472575,
-0.0136118168,
0.0684807897,
-0.0475717895,
0.0013516556,
-0.0335806161,
-0.0062559494,
0.0136895608,
0.0417151526,
-0.0001892149,
0.025709359,
0.0137163633,
0.0108818822,
0.0123699931,
-0.0154213682,
0.0135545405,
-0.0076387329,
-0.0017494111,
0.0276116598,
0.0404316075,
-0.0803069621,
0.0235883929,
-0.0561642386,
0.0624032542,
-0.0234462563,
-0.0053791651,
-0.0131105902,
0.0235655773,
-0.0336626321,
-0.0263212342,
-0.0080601666,
0.0641468987,
-0.0217541866,
-0.0483950824,
0.0042901845,
0.0100972913,
-0.0368183963,
-0.0020955885,
-0.0167847164,
0.0513161011,
0.0282405671,
-0.026075922,
-0.0631019324,
-0.0805194676,
-0.0619770549,
-0.0167104769,
-0.0155303897,
-0.0467306897,
-0.0023818854,
-0.0268929061,
-0.0131270206,
-0.0170930345,
-0.0202774107,
-0.000643592,
-0.0671935081,
0.0626240671,
-0.0805566534,
-0.0059643704,
0.0317284912,
0.0248896405,
-0.0383945182,
0.0074182013,
0.0095246406,
0.0643948764,
0.0759172738,
0.0130900946,
0.0558025427,
-0.0067368331,
0.0528331548,
-0.017394634,
0.0667477623,
0.0160879157,
-0.036371462,
-0.0190811139,
-0.0252532065,
0.0489620753,
-0.008814496,
-0.0481072292,
0.0704845935,
0.0053300685,
-0.0642123148,
-0.0006325366,
0.0170755498,
0.0551800169,
0.0036706107,
-0.0384367146,
-0.0474652275,
-0.0241973735,
-0.0557529181,
-0.0266588982,
-0.0387497768,
0.0373073928,
-0.0100241862,
-0.0277971234,
-0.0374412835,
-0.0417396501,
0.0384190492,
0.007980695,
0.0202534329,
0.0192518551,
-0.0280357487,
-0.0054899896,
0.0151776113,
0.0161479712,
-0.0228766669,
-0.0364047922,
0.0092610857,
0.0768535286,
0.022774715,
-0.0062577417,
0.0083950888,
-0.0549815819,
0.0146601563,
-0.0440618023,
0.0390555337,
-0.0105823241,
0.0125029171,
-0.0333723649,
0.0036438159,
0.015430768,
0.0002898067,
-0.0129783573,
0.0516908988,
0.0121203959,
0.0054408796,
-0.0173077993,
-0.0553080775,
0.0306576993,
0.01139843,
0.0396535806,
-0.0158431996,
0.0320934355,
0.047240898,
0.0128167951,
0.0182574391,
-0.0125153502,
0.0577814877,
0.0354303159,
-0.051567886,
-0.0147352964,
0.0140051581,
0.0569527559,
0.0116321901,
-0.0557305776,
-0.025943011,
0.0476102605,
-0.0591993369,
0.0526719019,
-0.0024343715,
-0.051304549,
-0.0280045494,
-0.0273467153,
-0.0099567743,
-0.0086117368,
0.0179584473,
-0.0028497963,
0.0587103665,
-0.0453067943,
-0.0348103009,
-0.0525220335,
0.0028891708,
0.0173233561,
-0.0011991597,
0.0219160691,
-0.0479033403,
-0.0291444007,
0.0485577397,
0.0324267149,
-0.0249071289,
-0.0164742358,
0.0115471566,
-0.0143176476,
-0.0579380617,
-0.0196949951,
0.004173927,
0.0265777335,
-0.0248289052,
0.0087081026,
-0.0232278015,
0.0239635259,
0.0175885092,
-0.0088446038,
0.0158862676,
0.0610931851,
-0.0064759143,
-0.01561308,
0.0139096482,
0.0126302028,
-0.0332409702,
0.014936802,
0.0458943397,
-0.0438815989,
-0.0499402657,
-0.0024588946,
-0.0442261882,
-0.0085681751,
-0.018315129,
-0.026019102,
-0.0045699803,
0.068260394,
-0.0467972308,
-0.0044538849,
0.0602074303,
0.0577277578,
0.036633756,
0.0385509469,
0.0151349977,
-0.0356260911,
-0.0155513231,
-0.0306188539,
-0.0148430914,
-0.0588216037,
0.0403615683,
0.0100911455,
0.0434216969,
0.0018461219,
-0.0075941021,
0.0109234946,
-0.0015641828,
-0.0636554584,
-0.0240148827,
-0.0714966357,
0.0082445182,
0.0774443522,
-0.0165615231,
-0.0482561514,
0.1025804654,
-0.0159294661,
0.0481082685,
-0.0478367545,
-0.0371037498,
0.0331161544,
-0.0196108539,
-0.0152710034,
0.0479898117,
0.0526749641,
0.0000337384,
0.0200440455,
-0.0273539703,
0.0503454879,
-0.018421486,
-0.0210223831,
-0.0343125835,
-0.0030264412,
0.0703105479,
-0.0470334254,
-0.0607613884,
-0.0840435103,
-0.0426134504,
-0.0419262275,
-0.0070291432,
-0.0456418693,
-0.0467201658,
-0.0471862145,
0.0003251206,
0.0131123401,
0.0295349061,
-0.0251340307,
-0.0182887111,
-0.0292464234,
0.0158926975,
-0.0522619449,
0.0825447738,
-0.0315741077,
-0.0085567692,
0.0737089589,
0.0171587169,
-0.0249456689,
-0.036920853,
-0.0220940448,
-0.0121765295,
-0.0353801474,
0.0328050666,
0.0400793031,
0.0074240365,
-0.023897877,
-0.0000608473,
0.0459662341,
0.0379336998,
-0.0194864608,
0.006068713,
0.0124058975,
-0.0197477806,
-0.0020157069,
-0.0261911228,
-0.0618042238,
0.0057066302,
0.013850471,
0.0617711134,
-0.0520379655,
-0.0305058993,
0.0150742624,
-0.0498803183,
0.057439249,
-0.0021896712,
-0.0209379438,
-0.060512837,
-0.059042152,
-0.04845367,
-0.0116384774,
0.0244132187,
-0.0294927433,
-0.0094926441,
-0.0406440943,
-0.0001526491,
-0.0646950975,
-0.0787514001,
0.0238106009,
-0.0633735731,
0.0464929901,
0.0729690865,
0.0106369238,
-0.0296552647,
-0.0556164496,
-0.0113064833,
0.0396498144,
-0.0211546887,
-0.0017269182,
0.1257178187,
-0.018121412,
0.0106488075,
-0.0250779018,
0.027439313,
-0.0023442567,
-0.0202361532,
0.0154211307,
0.0369537771,
-0.0292717293,
-0.0350840911,
-0.0172614921,
0.0202362016,
0.0456561558,
0.050648082,
-0.0205910746,
0.0070441905,
-0.0091568828,
-0.0199195221,
0.0236990172,
0.0506433509,
0.0182626769,
0.0451567024,
-0.0141383149,
-0.0414143912,
-0.0503495596,
-0.0106038228,
-0.0337817036,
-0.0393727906,
0.0204777401,
-0.031391412,
0.0626637191,
0.0188596901,
-0.0763190836,
-0.0291535407,
-0.0280625857,
0.0613533929,
0.0035368688,
0.0555770695,
-0.0181759484,
-0.0235449858,
0.0107780285,
0.0457412191,
-0.0300444085,
-0.0410852246,
-0.0007547516,
0.048106119,
0.019352112,
0.0380462483,
-0.0665276572,
-0.0278196763,
0.0645219237,
0.0380636379,
-0.0309959743,
-0.0356272683,
0.0341448486,
-0.0243525244,
0.0065888949,
-0.0247372687,
-0.026219504,
-0.0006587101,
-0.0069794445,
-0.0771728978,
-0.0824948624,
0.0221553687,
0.0375895798,
0.0161457825,
0.0486773625,
-0.0058807307,
0.0418764427,
0.000993688,
-0.0088371383,
0.0009197132,
-0.0114686079,
0.0031476843,
0.0127855474,
0.0261653513,
-0.00206173,
0.0124036605,
0.0086106956,
-0.0156668164,
0.018387666,
-0.0044152415,
-0.0255054049,
0.0374730267,
0.0782671943,
0.0376233682,
-0.0231763404,
0.012203224,
0.0208761655,
0.014857146,
0.0313635767,
0.0313006938,
-0.0102524292,
-0.0028608281,
-0.013863828,
-0.013193625,
-0.008777746,
-0.0512829646,
-0.0399330817,
-0.0176243763,
0.022806406,
0.0202146471,
0.0089232763,
0.0128547382,
-0.032021556,
-0.0128008369,
-0.021996418,
0.0077028642,
0.0041578393,
-0.0159441605,
0.0067248419,
0.0020009752,
-0.043477606,
0.0320060067,
0.0599008538,
-0.003022809,
0.0374260359,
-0.0527399294,
-0.1209194511,
-0.0275456421,
-0.0029133798,
-0.0110611813,
0.0409439839,
-0.0416706204,
-0.0579406954,
-0.0825122744,
-0.0531771667,
0.0197628289,
-0.0092519317,
0.0581000745,
0.0180183183,
-0.0143174995,
0.0751212537,
0.0163955986,
0.0142958816,
-0.0702237561,
-0.0326069109,
0.0053913123,
-0.0177244227,
-0.0058328174,
-5.889476123e-33,
0.0379765481,
-0.0901981443,
-0.0281684119,
0.0225654356,
0.0163215492,
0.048546277,
0.0004565788,
-0.034429621,
-0.0130204726,
0.0663997978,
0.0082691992,
0.0373215787,
-0.0072610457,
-0.0185026061,
0.0056598722,
-0.0146563202,
0.0336252823,
-0.0265363492,
-0.0182728786,
-0.0004234823,
0.0545532554,
-0.0138159767,
0.018497711,
-0.1306456774,
0.0741240755,
-0.0292746183,
-0.0490126275,
0.0424054377,
-0.0515923463,
0.0313213281,
0.0045307996,
0.046830602,
0.0266010463,
-0.0063866843,
0.0105559612,
0.0268379264,
-0.0422215015,
0.0014631788,
-0.0128136808,
-0.0026121347,
-0.0131391017,
0.000543392,
0.0321380273,
-0.0167771019,
-0.0206896011,
0.0220019575,
0.0283463839,
-0.0058125006,
0.0023038667,
-0.0305607505,
-0.0246430449,
-0.0153701892,
-0.0030105414,
0.0036990561,
0.0185611676,
0.1095764562,
0.0144358482,
-0.0040923716,
-0.0965663642,
0.0115831858,
0.0008889264,
-0.0614150129,
0.0260963775,
-0.0388914607,
-0.0691633597,
0.0488125458,
-0.0007247626,
-0.0116419187,
-0.0269086491,
0.0156303383,
-0.0169675015,
0.0296453424,
0.0541329309,
0.08391238,
-0.0170432515,
-0.0677008852,
-0.1057504639,
0.0097520612,
0.0252831634,
0.0197285283,
0.0367955342,
-0.0582467318,
-0.0584986098,
-0.0030319854,
-0.0141076902,
-0.0005383752,
-0.0386400633,
-0.003883404,
-0.00119356,
0.0285208672,
-0.035897214,
0.0554277785,
-0.0418382548,
-0.0729397759,
-0.0058998652,
0.0152608901,
0.0315282345,
-0.0189302936,
0.0291676819,
0.0066577881,
-0.0661255419,
-0.0071336231,
0.0104913106,
0.0024553074,
0.0240564719,
-0.0197632536,
0.0710040554,
-0.0050528813,
-0.0142981634,
0.0181311648,
0.0247331262,
0.0393604487,
0.010557293,
-0.0196254831,
0.0264970623,
0.0128866844,
-0.0151066212,
0.0024215076,
0.0267372094,
0.0373388119,
-0.0043539465,
0.0242131278,
-0.0424379371,
0.0353940167,
0.0058787921,
-0.0119589735,
-0.0318712741,
-0.0333732255,
0.0305410866,
-0.0425849892,
-0.0021271566,
-0.0287043303,
2.86e-7,
0.0034680951,
0.0398482904,
0.0044328333,
0.0007995499,
0.0266859885,
0.0594100766,
0.0076068561,
0.0323763005,
-0.0190536696,
-0.0419362336,
0.0259084739,
0.018481113,
0.032884445,
0.0464726686,
-0.0035668565,
-0.0643256083,
-0.0603294894,
-0.0116175963,
-0.045128312,
0.0244256798,
0.0181741137,
0.0344134197,
0.0490026996,
-0.0505160764,
0.0033481726,
0.0077895564,
0.0039805053,
0.0061901892,
0.0067406511,
-0.0047696535,
0.0762226284,
0.0072148005,
0.0118914815,
0.0694883317,
-0.033483807,
-0.0350482501,
-0.051427599,
0.0188770071,
0.0058255,
0.0344758742,
-0.0315155499,
-0.0125546772,
0.0439307615,
-0.0577911921,
0.005725353,
-0.0229422916,
-0.0278045125,
-0.0391461365,
-0.0438941717,
-0.0024096253,
0.0504542589,
0.0116111012,
0.0016739016,
0.0313838758,
-0.0057344134,
0.018231269,
0.0102579193,
-0.0163096022,
0.0350684039,
0.0132048903,
0.0197978392,
-0.0275962483,
0.0545793809,
0.0042251302,
0.0228451639,
-0.0371127799,
0.0283559039,
2.317278416e-34,
0.0343299843,
-0.0381742008,
-0.0235342439,
-0.0057667252,
0.0377648659,
0.0295362268,
-0.0212824587,
-0.0167994499,
-0.0062265485,
0.0543996878,
0.0371619277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12202v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12202v1 | Curriculum Learning with Adam: The Devil Is in the Wrong Details | 2023-08-23T15:39:42 | 2023-08-23T15:39:42 | Lucas Weber, Jaap Jumelet, Paul Michel, Elia Bruni, Dieuwke Hupkes | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Curriculum learning (CL) posits that machine learning models -- similar to
humans -- may learn more efficiently from data that match their current
learning progress. However, CL methods are still poorly understood and, in
particular for natural language processing (NLP), have achieved only limited
success. In this paper, we explore why. Starting from an attempt to replicate
and extend a number of recent curriculum methods, we find that their results
are surprisingly brittle when applied to NLP. A deep dive into the
(in)effectiveness of the curricula in some scenarios shows us why: when
curricula are employed in combination with the popular Adam optimisation
algorithm, they oftentimes learn to adapt to suboptimally chosen optimisation
parameters for this algorithm. We present a number of different case studies
with different common hand-crafted and automated CL approaches to illustrate
this phenomenon, and we find that none of them outperforms optimisation with
only Adam with well-chosen hyperparameters. As such, our results contribute to
understanding why CL methods work, but at the same time urge caution when
claiming positive results. | [
0.0579828061,
0.0277395025,
-0.0301452167,
0.002687563,
-0.0277830008,
0.0236585476,
0.014406221,
-0.0425456166,
-0.0318723954,
-0.0336394981,
0.0029042806,
0.0577214994,
0.0087730903,
-0.0330399573,
-0.0096450904,
-0.022803599,
0.0411716476,
0.0039145616,
0.0320036039,
-0.0007983355,
-0.0280004814,
0.0043858443,
-0.0126576172,
0.0608306825,
-0.0075007444,
-0.020626707,
0.0062224455,
-0.0108287809,
0.0459912419,
0.010703844,
0.0624832138,
0.0219094977,
-0.0022619953,
0.0103858905,
0.0000022186,
-0.0679551288,
-0.0410582498,
-0.0150180338,
-0.0338039659,
-0.0095053865,
0.0237134378,
0.0417165011,
0.0123589076,
0.0326936617,
-0.055333063,
0.0502566919,
0.0103101926,
-0.03304502,
0.0608006194,
0.0669664741,
-0.0072474172,
-0.0387819484,
-0.0043114927,
0.0024289743,
-0.0546060242,
-0.0333373211,
0.0386143848,
-0.0048131547,
0.0330818519,
0.0182791185,
-0.0427174829,
-0.0002153748,
0.0199949034,
0.00931489,
0.0755941272,
0.0165867582,
-0.0705890134,
-0.02185506,
-0.0157262459,
0.0322049037,
-0.0365501046,
-0.0140226828,
0.0346726663,
-0.0265577938,
-0.0091171023,
-0.0623317473,
-0.0315796137,
0.0298888776,
-0.0207043588,
0.0234346539,
0.0062052137,
-0.014276403,
-0.0298829507,
0.0249916371,
0.0008244154,
0.0343787521,
-0.0117702186,
-0.0113187488,
0.0659712106,
0.0407241695,
-0.0148579236,
-0.0044856714,
0.0361247696,
0.0565452315,
-0.0302138738,
0.0231722817,
-0.0578781962,
-0.0172475036,
0.0109273372,
-0.0417466387,
0.0731839091,
0.0349681675,
0.0033412769,
0.0308525767,
-0.0118892984,
0.1042531878,
0.0507408045,
0.0308779404,
-0.0173950158,
0.0469680689,
-0.0778364763,
0.0122734616,
-0.0619666837,
0.0281227101,
0.0078687649,
-0.023383759,
-0.0709881485,
0.0168072637,
-0.0117006637,
0.0434733927,
0.0452610031,
0.0464566611,
-0.0649724305,
0.0441902019,
-0.0105421413,
0.0071271379,
-0.0577873923,
0.0350230038,
-0.0248090141,
0.019774029,
0.0065622195,
-0.0132727083,
0.0044811601,
-0.01281456,
0.0136948349,
0.0427216962,
0.0109948022,
-0.0243988279,
-0.0515757613,
-0.0154853696,
-0.0398073569,
-0.0164211746,
0.0444621481,
-0.0597763583,
-0.0067315246,
-0.0270627625,
0.0130108008,
-0.0350319594,
-0.0061223581,
0.007232538,
-0.0277622472,
0.0187674165,
0.0048155324,
-0.0316401422,
0.0223128721,
0.0166462064,
0.0589084364,
0.0713413879,
0.032224834,
0.0521197692,
0.0492380038,
-0.0022523312,
-0.024671806,
0.0275978446,
0.0228603091,
-0.0408873931,
-0.0105871679,
-0.0019697121,
-0.0104925763,
0.0540084727,
0.0110808685,
0.0142970067,
-0.0182205718,
-0.0498572998,
0.0273696743,
0.0318047218,
-0.0072391047,
0.0007835746,
0.0357445553,
0.0130252773,
0.0697914511,
-0.0162041374,
-0.0361901708,
-0.01362905,
-0.009769096,
-0.0119852349,
0.0054819509,
0.0174680315,
-0.0047230506,
-0.0941102728,
0.0053346981,
-0.0314856209,
-0.0273117032,
-0.0161251556,
0.0049926974,
0.0157376211,
-0.0178495236,
-0.0741862878,
0.0622752495,
-0.0081054205,
0.0270432997,
-0.024166448,
-0.0180908199,
0.0549061969,
0.0538497269,
-0.0444481671,
-0.0892653465,
-0.0012449563,
0.031982787,
0.0297565907,
-0.0086647877,
-0.0697418153,
0.0190576967,
-0.0641986504,
-0.0460972041,
-0.0291990507,
0.0104995575,
0.0054822913,
0.0601311252,
-0.0066576386,
-0.0222117342,
0.0471841097,
-0.07103578,
0.0597091503,
-0.0732381195,
-0.0807058811,
0.0400538296,
0.008498624,
0.0194886122,
0.0090861293,
0.0093453424,
-0.0306555908,
0.0080807311,
0.0010832966,
-0.0077083781,
-0.0160166807,
-0.0525609851,
-0.055021733,
0.0282388572,
-0.0392960049,
0.0015054317,
0.0363087282,
-0.0663419217,
-0.0101898033,
-0.0077888831,
-0.0211005509,
0.0288060084,
0.0236363821,
0.0525624156,
-0.0199518036,
-0.0223725997,
-0.0731170252,
0.0448067933,
-0.0090996027,
-0.0194233879,
-0.0129887694,
-0.0441908203,
-0.0000855513,
-0.0080275442,
-0.006369208,
-0.0098232459,
-0.0063843275,
0.0114537477,
0.0118719675,
0.0205249302,
-0.075413458,
0.0075021749,
-0.0910976008,
0.002586643,
-0.0119448658,
-0.010009707,
0.0058393022,
-0.0582288317,
-0.0052166171,
-0.008162709,
-0.010869097,
0.0303085744,
-0.0601128414,
0.0050420128,
0.0289351195,
0.0062642251,
-0.0001402408,
-0.044939328,
-0.0135839982,
-0.0384620242,
0.0345629714,
0.0160507578,
0.0762989521,
-0.0152063631,
-0.0178394616,
-0.0198504701,
-0.001540485,
-0.0156931635,
0.01714403,
0.0057789125,
-0.0110734608,
-0.0295044854,
0.0868881345,
-0.002226616,
0.0371931084,
0.011057633,
0.0250786562,
-0.0598906837,
0.0362715796,
-0.0253405441,
0.011111835,
-0.0407259613,
-0.0040622847,
0.0219584834,
0.064982377,
-0.0100587243,
0.0013732489,
-0.0508243889,
0.0766989216,
-0.0306342468,
-0.0428124741,
-0.0550294966,
-0.0254082382,
-0.0031912401,
-0.0135421734,
-0.0188119356,
-0.0137480972,
0.0617338046,
0.0036198273,
0.0283926595,
-0.098702915,
0.0094894711,
-0.0347297452,
-0.0008184403,
0.0122627812,
-0.0028185605,
0.0202164538,
-0.042691607,
-0.0457027517,
0.0001090085,
0.0611171685,
-0.0392220803,
0.0307292286,
-0.0377701074,
-0.0240954738,
0.0171010196,
-0.0528841056,
-0.0782795399,
0.0470158346,
-0.0069364901,
0.0466869809,
0.0280106943,
-0.0144957798,
-0.0292924102,
-0.0750172883,
-0.0501059592,
0.0429860428,
-0.0128322514,
-0.0382244512,
-0.0206575226,
0.0058317799,
0.0352718793,
-0.0146217262,
0.0176207833,
-0.0209864248,
-0.0087705133,
0.0364837795,
0.0587566793,
0.006189222,
-0.042098023,
0.0633457005,
0.0173717383,
-0.0812405497,
0.0033682894,
0.0386771522,
-0.0074413037,
-0.0492126681,
-0.0328249596,
0.0921459794,
0.0534116291,
-0.0541649461,
0.0254944544,
0.0155277001,
-0.0069622635,
0.0485233292,
0.0181145947,
-0.0066806669,
-0.0258319136,
0.0060048951,
0.0825013295,
-0.0206876677,
-0.057313554,
-0.0069728321,
-0.0662329048,
-0.025402043,
0.0025148895,
-0.008160023,
0.0422224626,
-0.0599772073,
-0.0107162558,
-0.0692797378,
0.0242967401,
-0.0316624977,
-0.0522950739,
0.0111567043,
0.0563632213,
0.0047121197,
-0.0487516783,
0.0232636016,
0.0023897963,
0.057691142,
0.0423684753,
0.0409315266,
-0.0097750798,
0.0229884945,
0.052887965,
0.0273993667,
0.0142548345,
-0.0312177408,
-0.0008916367,
-0.0242922883,
0.0044796309,
0.0011472112,
0.0351946615,
0.0056776963,
-0.0065880143,
0.0575771928,
0.0542030931,
0.0103493035,
-0.0014024372,
-0.0338156857,
0.0047396901,
0.0011540498,
0.0473103374,
0.0228045974,
-0.0624790825,
-0.0316705965,
-0.0092054792,
-0.0192989763,
-0.0588360168,
-0.0312066898,
0.0176405422,
-0.0007687861,
-0.0043493523,
-0.0897606611,
-0.0561128184,
0.0704216585,
0.0356200784,
0.0289275181,
-0.0485219955,
0.0445774533,
0.0256032459,
-0.0473589525,
-0.0052443263,
-0.0140031902,
-0.0109525174,
-0.0650393143,
-0.0106778871,
-0.0246454179,
-0.0198402163,
-0.0442470983,
-0.0120887682,
-0.071879603,
-0.0637404174,
0.0320499912,
0.0657304525,
0.0133025106,
0.067501843,
0.0036581326,
-0.0420735069,
0.0733858347,
0.058686737,
0.0127090057,
-0.0133112213,
0.0516269915,
0.013479759,
-0.0306966025,
-0.0032273096,
-0.0076022651,
0.0240670964,
0.0416616797,
0.061813049,
0.0053866659,
0.0184923634,
0.0270764418,
0.0095102619,
0.0264350884,
-0.0237287488,
-0.0444691665,
-0.0296005514,
0.0164286643,
0.0121937841,
-0.0019843366,
0.022508217,
-0.0212626755,
0.0088427793,
0.0387266427,
-0.0226699542,
0.0296362825,
0.0202320572,
0.0114073604,
-0.0791370347,
0.0217383485,
-0.0072341138,
0.0438812897,
-0.0068753958,
0.0091439029,
-0.0240613762,
0.0703676492,
0.0513817444,
0.0724285543,
-0.0207810067,
0.045545321,
-0.0045353258,
0.0522655398,
-0.0076491693,
0.0115912715,
-0.0637993738,
0.0255140588,
-0.0740342662,
0.0235413071,
0.0440556742,
-0.0603799745,
-0.0028027175,
-0.0398431048,
0.0035321368,
-0.0074478318,
-0.0129140597,
-0.0072181192,
-0.0318638869,
0.0058720508,
0.0001642779,
0.0253364462,
-0.0294105131,
0.0618433915,
0.0079703555,
0.0479816422,
-0.0315395445,
0.0040980163,
-0.0633297414,
-0.0573128127,
0.0481736772,
0.0130266687,
-0.0235987529,
0.0257869512,
-0.0053331889,
-0.0381498113,
0.0163761061,
-0.0188653227,
0.0366224013,
-0.0325962156,
0.0312978551,
0.0377970524,
-0.0159384832,
-0.0266148876,
-0.0209720433,
-0.01139485,
-0.0323141888,
-0.0278769732,
-0.0046258187,
-5.756272776e-33,
-0.0251007304,
0.008843069,
0.0425900668,
0.0373149887,
0.0269257985,
0.021367766,
0.0002234648,
-0.0032823051,
-0.0046697212,
0.01117473,
-0.0288237743,
0.0135574648,
0.0130047258,
0.0084669627,
0.0327244252,
0.0120293722,
0.0279133432,
-0.0234753992,
-0.0487762876,
0.0223143883,
0.0098027661,
0.024355242,
0.04067114,
-0.0108735422,
-0.0228638295,
0.0581647716,
0.0247096997,
0.0123848421,
0.0002216495,
0.0613114871,
0.0067942152,
0.0387486108,
0.0297928136,
-0.0118180467,
0.0160410814,
-0.0179492831,
-0.0989829525,
-0.0713654608,
0.0046275058,
0.0250625368,
-0.0305647105,
-0.0412495323,
0.0349623598,
-0.0094320439,
-0.0403585471,
-0.0074859313,
0.0581801981,
-0.0192381013,
-0.030108355,
-0.0830058083,
-0.0954084545,
0.0040702238,
-0.0358340219,
0.0120181432,
0.0190911815,
0.04678341,
-0.0072391741,
0.0178443603,
-0.0305567887,
0.0349133797,
0.0282808393,
0.0540450774,
0.0237922817,
0.0245441217,
-0.0281114895,
0.0585107282,
0.0007242876,
0.024441367,
-0.013154381,
0.0098506846,
0.0724589825,
0.0353992917,
0.032111872,
-0.0010492797,
-0.0179576091,
-0.01061517,
-0.0485521182,
0.0469050147,
0.0523513034,
0.0384849422,
-0.007236524,
-0.0400835946,
-0.0623253249,
-0.002386309,
-0.030362865,
-0.0059413286,
-0.0151245305,
0.0374730267,
0.0262052957,
0.0342140123,
-0.0687602386,
0.0396541953,
-0.012889416,
-0.0526679195,
0.0161795504,
0.0357052833,
0.0020705385,
-0.0247172546,
0.0264788158,
0.0313293971,
-0.0884252414,
-0.0562556759,
0.0168596376,
-0.0298065953,
0.0693257526,
-0.0102311159,
0.0728240311,
0.0261380468,
-0.0433193371,
-0.0159822125,
-0.0243656822,
0.0416618474,
0.0409069955,
0.005235611,
0.0170322545,
0.0186802503,
-0.0159299094,
-0.0027433101,
0.0448177047,
0.0143131707,
-0.0217383988,
-0.0136655923,
0.02462673,
0.0186705533,
0.0009842578,
-0.0323122665,
-0.0141620208,
0.0161398649,
-0.0228846427,
-0.0882914886,
-0.0228904914,
-0.0071103419,
2.64e-7,
0.0034330904,
0.092424877,
-0.0118965199,
-0.0380437113,
0.0213923156,
-0.002862602,
-0.0297562797,
0.0264786854,
-0.0050194152,
0.0265775584,
0.0242753625,
0.0181635432,
0.0351376384,
0.0258681271,
-0.0447044969,
-0.0059758979,
-0.0292453244,
-0.0003546703,
-0.0774587393,
0.0050403364,
0.0473705865,
0.0370156206,
0.0275676064,
-0.0277309045,
-0.0082212128,
-0.0124219162,
0.0024792049,
0.0312794596,
0.0473645292,
0.0408406146,
-0.0127977086,
0.0360210724,
-0.0217923447,
0.0227273777,
-0.0281465519,
0.0554185808,
-0.0260563511,
0.0919583142,
-0.0048661521,
-0.0357209221,
0.0010740666,
0.004738735,
0.0035217681,
-0.0499822721,
0.0488232672,
-0.0547631904,
0.0128015606,
-0.0017670356,
-0.0156684611,
0.0138116572,
0.010833011,
-0.0019369136,
0.0137812933,
-0.0333041735,
0.0043218303,
-0.010340983,
-0.0036873992,
-0.0985266119,
0.0360609703,
0.0153879905,
-0.0034095678,
-0.0119743459,
-0.0287527256,
0.0045657763,
-0.0137591045,
-0.0449622236,
0.0122509487,
2.263074352e-34,
0.021956291,
-0.0129586048,
0.0547723621,
-0.0364460461,
-0.0294433404,
0.021118449,
0.0269396584,
-0.0020270268,
0.0151817417,
-0.0470093042,
-0.0414080285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12157v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12157v1 | Evaluation of Faithfulness Using the Longest Supported Subsequence | 2023-08-23T14:18:44 | 2023-08-23T14:18:44 | Anirudh Mittal, Timo Schick, Mikel Artetxe, Jane Dwivedi-Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As increasingly sophisticated language models emerge, their trustworthiness
becomes a pivotal issue, especially in tasks such as summarization and
question-answering. Ensuring their responses are contextually grounded and
faithful is challenging due to the linguistic diversity and the myriad of
possible answers. In this paper, we introduce a novel approach to evaluate
faithfulness of machine-generated text by computing the longest noncontinuous
substring of the claim that is supported by the context, which we refer to as
the Longest Supported Subsequence (LSS). Using a new human-annotated dataset,
we finetune a model to generate LSS. We introduce a new method of evaluation
and demonstrate that these metrics correlate better with human ratings when LSS
is employed, as opposed to when it is not. Our proposed metric demonstrates an
18% enhancement over the prevailing state-of-the-art metric for faithfulness on
our dataset. Our metric consistently outperforms other metrics on a
summarization dataset across six different models. Finally, we compare several
popular Large Language Models (LLMs) for faithfulness using this metric. We
release the human-annotated dataset built for predicting LSS and our fine-tuned
model for evaluating faithfulness. | [
0.0686578006,
0.0820781589,
0.0149099724,
0.0243150517,
-0.0516893417,
0.0008079367,
-0.0258817766,
-0.0054781726,
-0.0024371392,
-0.0464766026,
0.0087069059,
-0.0431812443,
0.031364765,
0.0252052471,
0.0235682074,
-0.0363673456,
0.0362053588,
0.0111548332,
0.015502654,
0.0016607386,
0.0214536916,
0.0032124396,
0.0179405604,
0.055663839,
-0.0155682033,
-0.0146440975,
0.0197060145,
-0.0091133285,
0.0435829423,
-0.0148455491,
0.0282094274,
0.0434125066,
-0.016015511,
0.0489289351,
0.0000018984,
-0.048718594,
-0.0311075896,
0.006125689,
-0.0083892951,
0.0177617446,
0.0174192954,
-0.0208575949,
0.0000765473,
0.0196759012,
-0.038580142,
0.0550451875,
0.0413315184,
0.0140934307,
0.0674134791,
0.0748100281,
-0.0016811773,
-0.0016304007,
0.043436408,
-0.0207206775,
-0.024729643,
-0.0399625115,
0.0154994605,
0.0326734893,
0.0089528095,
0.0104233203,
0.0011283483,
0.0159400199,
0.0324548408,
-0.0032074798,
-0.013859855,
0.0008730171,
-0.0498314835,
-0.0114412503,
0.0353597403,
0.0549055412,
0.0028383632,
-0.0461877398,
0.0108191334,
0.0033386801,
-0.02596597,
0.0369328894,
-0.0374495573,
0.0483348332,
-0.0068803136,
-0.0006232953,
0.0083751995,
0.0228113197,
-0.0012143182,
0.0224517174,
-0.0189453922,
0.0593083091,
0.0166816488,
-0.0446263999,
-0.0246820692,
-0.0095352447,
-0.0745077431,
-0.0913492963,
0.0109656686,
0.0069736182,
-0.0258871857,
0.0267549884,
-0.0599919856,
-0.0009069495,
0.0582646281,
-0.0298251212,
-0.0077692783,
0.0008707514,
-0.014566713,
0.0302356109,
-0.0263478626,
0.0439655371,
0.0063432278,
-0.0030458868,
-0.044391457,
-0.02072924,
-0.0543956943,
0.0065860366,
0.0151857212,
0.0083945291,
0.0036455784,
-0.0226803515,
-0.0572687611,
0.0213770028,
-0.0257606059,
0.0443540588,
-0.0114505878,
0.0117637981,
0.0124260252,
-0.0196689554,
-0.0365668796,
-0.0011881852,
-0.0543428361,
0.0210408811,
0.0369213037,
-0.0478015989,
0.0031205576,
0.0319082029,
-0.0068493355,
-0.0141554335,
0.0045027956,
0.0149584739,
0.012745142,
-0.0438953638,
-0.0194868445,
-0.061878331,
-0.061058104,
-0.0539649501,
-0.0362277813,
-0.0727981925,
0.0045866286,
0.0088059036,
-0.0133215403,
-0.0552665368,
-0.0066423467,
0.0611547939,
-0.0310806334,
0.0204860494,
-0.0229551177,
-0.0035452745,
-0.0078056552,
-0.0101309884,
0.0110773565,
-0.0021651618,
0.0457140245,
0.0495947711,
0.0865635648,
0.0296420958,
-0.0184279922,
0.0104264468,
0.0164280254,
-0.0143241249,
-0.0043787826,
0.0289638415,
-0.0306073539,
-0.0091999266,
0.005058045,
0.0586506911,
-0.0054651666,
-0.0411522239,
0.061224509,
0.0637962446,
-0.0051844367,
-0.0041669179,
0.0425607674,
0.032090269,
0.0195874162,
0.0713279545,
-0.0561643876,
-0.0126811694,
-0.0382615253,
0.0377808325,
0.0662041381,
0.0061460841,
0.0157901663,
-0.0592298321,
-0.044078473,
-0.0319851115,
0.0006129986,
-0.0003199718,
-0.0050865989,
-0.0095100068,
-0.0113021508,
0.0474599674,
0.0231883507,
-0.0597219504,
-0.0099465391,
-0.012432537,
0.0768736824,
0.0525439456,
0.0307659302,
-0.0164914504,
0.0032105455,
-0.0123772863,
0.0631560758,
0.0359342843,
0.0431395173,
-0.0064451136,
-0.0037610577,
-0.0295951851,
-0.014153026,
0.0210859273,
0.0383397005,
-0.009882845,
0.0343999863,
-0.0051615695,
0.0423395894,
-0.0645649955,
-0.0392917842,
0.0482163988,
-0.0307714567,
-0.0005397074,
-0.0214282703,
-0.0021188562,
0.0258360822,
0.0340930149,
-0.0377957076,
0.0428422689,
0.0333362073,
-0.0246547293,
-0.0214879252,
0.0077328277,
-0.0648365915,
0.0140422042,
0.0509912372,
-0.0578050278,
-0.0435164422,
0.0492739044,
-0.0395884961,
-0.0436054878,
-0.0182853565,
-0.0659834668,
0.002747508,
-0.0525057539,
0.0205269773,
0.0041913628,
0.0095041608,
-0.0342603214,
0.0548786372,
-0.0080687832,
0.0317159556,
0.010144176,
-0.0189163685,
0.0426301695,
-0.0373263247,
-0.0049630646,
0.011889183,
-0.0037808926,
0.0145247411,
0.0738692358,
-0.0077502923,
-0.0322018564,
-0.0268025212,
-0.0887037814,
-0.0053754547,
-0.0325926393,
0.0213367399,
0.0274318065,
-0.0131213721,
-0.001708813,
0.0034379254,
-0.0545106381,
-0.0427392945,
0.0450333133,
0.0030028836,
0.0303962082,
-0.0321122631,
0.0129268467,
-0.0754664987,
-0.0025943909,
-0.0111527052,
0.0629205778,
0.0060797222,
0.0198352616,
-0.035966713,
-0.0175405219,
-0.0631313026,
-0.019384006,
0.0304499883,
-0.0195107944,
-0.0019024732,
0.0316225365,
0.0075264676,
0.0336874574,
0.070519954,
-0.0396520272,
0.0118166143,
0.0338102244,
-0.0239046253,
-0.0470528975,
-0.0266787577,
-0.0007805845,
0.0281925239,
-0.0349717736,
0.0470650159,
0.0694879442,
0.0231705196,
-0.0065579419,
-0.0342853963,
0.0270286426,
-0.0007915524,
0.0034891553,
0.0129885059,
-0.0315258391,
-0.03135667,
0.0576020367,
-0.0420508496,
-0.0450795107,
0.0898839086,
-0.0653358549,
0.0430138782,
-0.0266851652,
-0.0230815206,
-0.0331485011,
0.0436824411,
0.0161924828,
0.0122119784,
0.0322797857,
0.0369871482,
-0.0174449626,
-0.0083998162,
0.0553782433,
-0.0358163305,
0.0609753244,
-0.0441595465,
0.023332851,
0.0170213133,
-0.0023408094,
-0.0591036677,
-0.0590059273,
-0.0467441231,
0.0167729761,
-0.0094993627,
0.0032648591,
-0.0399905257,
0.00103406,
0.0467533953,
0.0451381356,
-0.0073839398,
0.00199335,
-0.0157576278,
0.0750330165,
0.0716850311,
0.0307074711,
0.0451909304,
-0.0142673701,
0.0134658711,
0.0731339753,
-0.00759354,
0.0586285777,
-0.0171976928,
-0.0334822945,
-0.0248257108,
-0.0515484996,
0.0016214633,
0.0189746134,
0.0675534159,
-0.045368433,
-0.0073780385,
0.11873772,
0.0421383828,
-0.0042316201,
0.0278634094,
-0.0057664891,
0.0381303839,
0.0161232427,
-0.009364441,
-0.089568682,
-0.0488547795,
0.0047660805,
0.031598974,
0.0045934692,
-0.0460796542,
-0.0081935069,
-0.0924388245,
0.0167094283,
0.002894426,
-0.0361658111,
-0.0418216549,
-0.0530134104,
0.0259147547,
0.0122310659,
0.0211480018,
0.0290123057,
-0.0072221542,
0.0082518766,
0.0102711394,
-0.0662049055,
-0.0466256253,
0.0286970865,
-0.0378721282,
0.0326799266,
0.0740301237,
0.0102529703,
0.0060635479,
-0.0432498977,
0.0218130667,
-0.0319010355,
-0.0331510901,
0.0376003571,
0.0366522819,
-0.0279595684,
0.0185218677,
0.0056285635,
0.0310046561,
-0.0242946055,
-0.0181148257,
0.0514130555,
0.0382229574,
0.0164386164,
-0.006655395,
-0.0386302918,
0.0107770879,
-0.0235868599,
0.1053305343,
0.0535548404,
-0.0056852149,
-0.0136842579,
-0.0202954598,
0.004549609,
-0.0414469093,
-0.0199258346,
0.0047827293,
-0.0184628461,
0.0401745029,
-0.1244542375,
-0.0491158329,
-0.0080228988,
-0.0155701442,
-0.0150376875,
-0.025349237,
0.0233490951,
-0.0215177294,
-0.0611617491,
0.0095150648,
-0.0420993157,
0.0447490104,
-0.057306692,
0.0345128216,
0.011020991,
-0.0130819585,
-0.0141958976,
0.0345357694,
-0.0618591681,
-0.0462067835,
-0.0236959048,
0.0233945474,
0.0217563938,
0.03933933,
-0.0052900747,
-0.0260622259,
0.0259916838,
0.0054462729,
-0.0354867242,
0.0104719857,
0.023174569,
0.00836585,
-0.0138826054,
0.019195484,
-0.0410998575,
0.0185400173,
-0.0133960694,
0.0308827497,
0.0070351418,
-0.0637502298,
0.0299470909,
0.030546885,
0.0139190583,
0.0029108624,
0.00816085,
0.0051536337,
-0.0089554042,
-0.0214487426,
-0.006137155,
-0.0218214002,
0.0417233557,
-0.0049143098,
0.0065085539,
-0.0074596019,
-0.00919089,
-0.0608138703,
0.0530022345,
-0.0503139682,
-0.004737372,
-0.026681425,
0.0261204708,
-0.0406365283,
-0.0248472188,
-0.047676269,
-0.0202841684,
-0.0583599545,
0.0523398779,
-0.0325046591,
0.004975453,
0.0196851529,
-0.0167492181,
0.0157022811,
0.0415121242,
-0.0840272009,
0.0072206231,
-0.06247833,
0.0062961481,
0.0533370227,
-0.0439159945,
0.0514521003,
-0.0003895662,
0.0057336478,
-0.0365047976,
0.0343801454,
0.0228006653,
0.0030975116,
-0.0391459465,
0.0414583459,
-0.039419394,
0.0410784334,
0.0704396367,
0.0219208598,
-0.0036505242,
-0.0236854013,
-0.0454979874,
-0.0457144752,
-0.0332935303,
-0.0556408875,
0.0643197969,
-0.014785585,
-0.0275927875,
-0.0638915002,
-0.0753025785,
0.0690422058,
0.0219684001,
0.0237304717,
0.0062900861,
0.0274446942,
0.0504707582,
-0.012282473,
0.0403412543,
-0.0339678042,
-0.0122651085,
0.0128005762,
0.0106914742,
-0.0412663296,
-5.8995086e-33,
0.0103767402,
-0.0471890308,
-0.0387822539,
-0.0073334659,
-0.0187769178,
0.0228907615,
-0.0703282431,
-0.0159635767,
0.0056142285,
0.0130177308,
-0.0049863872,
-0.0034982045,
0.0032882257,
0.0314101577,
0.0036778741,
-0.0007091222,
0.0263450351,
0.0194942914,
-0.0573468208,
-0.0190400369,
0.0341929011,
-0.0238399394,
0.0296003241,
-0.0694878176,
0.0850324929,
-0.0299896318,
-0.0107779978,
-0.0061006462,
-0.0073110182,
0.0812024921,
-0.0056688306,
0.045381885,
0.0426064283,
-0.0299661849,
-0.0165642146,
-0.0016313073,
-0.0715242177,
-0.0179133769,
0.0405927449,
-0.0590921268,
-0.0758667588,
-0.0039929939,
0.0599539205,
-0.0269825421,
-0.0034876249,
-0.0110057993,
0.0601794198,
-0.0645472184,
-0.0254973974,
-0.0382631756,
-0.0481906496,
0.0517055988,
0.0018918409,
-0.0376601554,
-0.0116768125,
0.0659249276,
0.004162461,
0.0640257448,
-0.030286232,
0.0314954333,
-0.0251285862,
0.0468848869,
0.0473586656,
-0.0429041423,
-0.0072352611,
0.0823585615,
-0.0033210178,
-0.0314377397,
-0.0247729179,
0.0023555846,
-0.0212327261,
0.0134323286,
0.0748170093,
0.0864820853,
0.0408360288,
-0.0065877037,
-0.0436350033,
0.0386516228,
0.0259051919,
0.0126712471,
0.0020402477,
-0.0108498996,
-0.02435055,
0.0084558995,
-0.0514650643,
-0.010621273,
-0.0284127835,
-0.0150792487,
0.0224506222,
0.00754304,
-0.0535152517,
0.0018331088,
0.0132759269,
-0.0295081995,
0.0125173833,
0.0161502715,
-0.0318715014,
-0.0285457987,
0.0292643625,
0.0217109472,
-0.0443115011,
0.0300481692,
0.0006351949,
0.000224397,
0.01112343,
-0.0050648856,
0.0610176437,
-0.0160270408,
-0.0393168405,
0.0222953614,
0.0006278965,
0.0180596933,
-0.0353304148,
-0.0113534294,
0.042452231,
0.0156028718,
0.0001665116,
0.0581892617,
-0.0170568358,
-0.0106966859,
-0.0314115994,
0.0098874047,
-0.0034880324,
0.0444816761,
-0.0448114127,
-0.0074238828,
-0.0100421794,
0.0152510079,
-0.0168115422,
-0.025440501,
0.0151547771,
-0.0013576448,
2.405e-7,
0.0260389149,
0.0482664108,
0.0792673156,
-0.0215572156,
0.0021017736,
0.0140530923,
0.0104151005,
0.0045030243,
-0.0106337434,
-0.0620206594,
-0.0221378393,
0.001497239,
0.0752328783,
0.025127057,
-0.0633271635,
0.009519536,
-0.1024540439,
-0.0172960944,
-0.0252900999,
0.005965265,
0.0890595764,
0.0875954702,
0.0046701636,
0.0020510301,
-0.0162635408,
-0.0336107835,
0.0286855381,
-0.0087403506,
-0.0356193818,
-0.0129106352,
0.0439510569,
-0.0027036946,
0.0043394226,
0.0056434516,
-0.0170943681,
0.0173920672,
0.0340967737,
0.0675264671,
0.0276882052,
-0.0353728533,
-0.0406863317,
-0.0450255983,
0.0295397062,
-0.0433678366,
0.0607156605,
-0.0454491451,
0.0099941324,
-0.0457094945,
-0.0455121249,
0.0025500627,
0.0217820108,
0.0174129922,
-0.0372756347,
0.0350393467,
0.0243014153,
0.0414924994,
-0.0051452741,
-0.0474810936,
-0.0753754228,
-0.0192182213,
-0.0444543213,
-0.0277087893,
-0.0175145753,
-0.0100006536,
0.034103971,
-0.0494248681,
0.0025329869,
2.29863076e-34,
0.0730667338,
-0.0085980073,
0.0069780634,
-0.01493394,
0.0519459657,
-0.0155462334,
0.0066652293,
0.0013765382,
0.0194631536,
-0.0520431064,
-0.0063743745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12131v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12131v1 | Semantic Change Detection for the Romanian Language | 2023-08-23T13:37:02 | 2023-08-23T13:37:02 | Ciprian-Octavian Truică, Victor Tudose, Elena-Simona Apostol | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatic semantic change methods try to identify the changes that appear
over time in the meaning of words by analyzing their usage in diachronic
corpora. In this paper, we analyze different strategies to create static and
contextual word embedding models, i.e., Word2Vec and ELMo, on real-world
English and Romanian datasets. To test our pipeline and determine the
performance of our models, we first evaluate both word embedding models on an
English dataset (SEMEVAL-CCOHA). Afterward, we focus our experiments on a
Romanian dataset, and we underline different aspects of semantic changes in
this low-resource language, such as meaning acquisition and loss. The
experimental results show that, depending on the corpus, the most important
factors to consider are the choice of model and the distance to calculate a
score for detecting semantic change. | [
-0.0001503525,
0.0658292696,
-0.0259652194,
0.0434005372,
-0.051752191,
-0.0076537742,
-0.0624604113,
0.0232287068,
-0.0214885622,
-0.0342903771,
0.0543970466,
-0.0264539327,
0.0252551083,
-0.0188520495,
0.0056833904,
-0.0121646216,
0.1065196171,
0.0155078899,
-0.0533647388,
0.0170465242,
0.0197031964,
-0.0355746001,
-0.0006949348,
-0.0114266099,
-0.0244287532,
-0.0119077973,
-0.0247901715,
-0.0318622924,
0.0334216803,
-0.0103186928,
-0.0171471052,
0.0211625323,
0.0398323312,
0.0609816872,
0.0000018822,
-0.0780676529,
-0.0453763753,
-0.0227651242,
-0.0095230844,
0.0282017626,
0.0842401013,
-0.0260086916,
-0.0310958419,
-0.008705168,
-0.0374235474,
-0.0320483334,
0.0310106874,
-0.0046964642,
0.0506761782,
0.0579320863,
-0.011030376,
-0.0223810356,
-0.0007636233,
-0.0257020239,
-0.0082102614,
-0.0003253613,
0.0569821931,
0.0136221386,
-0.064519912,
-0.0125248907,
-0.0735743567,
0.0340733007,
-0.0263305567,
-0.0213772766,
0.0045702355,
0.0284502208,
-0.0366872847,
0.0022458218,
-0.0113565931,
-0.0006037422,
-0.0306062475,
-0.025950145,
-0.0055459556,
0.0301373713,
-0.018289702,
0.0361207724,
-0.0180604588,
-0.0472965613,
0.0213210993,
0.0019853998,
0.0514591485,
0.0076348144,
0.0127357319,
0.0451433137,
-0.0048099249,
0.0160920396,
0.0376116633,
-0.0470865667,
-0.0175584443,
-0.0112866824,
0.0074355179,
-0.0247637872,
-0.0125763975,
0.0275800861,
-0.003455095,
0.0494735949,
-0.0095877573,
-0.0473820567,
0.0220844857,
-0.1002674848,
-0.0255535431,
0.005747566,
-0.0249816068,
0.070443511,
-0.0674633533,
0.0080084438,
0.0150371222,
-0.0357914194,
-0.0292903949,
-0.0208608527,
-0.0433031581,
0.0084825074,
-0.0561382174,
0.0034232992,
-0.0198843479,
-0.0242944285,
-0.0092979809,
0.0562103353,
0.0240015667,
-0.0047381013,
-0.0398571789,
-0.0328773223,
-0.024594117,
0.0490565673,
-0.0278364494,
0.0076359427,
-0.0427386761,
0.0011237111,
-0.0630488768,
-0.056219887,
-0.0004977167,
0.0006164287,
0.0159883574,
0.0012504073,
-0.009781627,
0.046491012,
-0.0084149847,
-0.0491208397,
-0.0184458587,
-0.0009254772,
-0.0241138078,
-0.024826074,
-0.0507688262,
-0.0424088649,
0.0201889612,
-0.0215476919,
0.0081806444,
-0.0546057522,
-0.0066339704,
0.0110968472,
-0.052063223,
0.0668780357,
-0.0406550281,
-0.0057042362,
0.0191235133,
-0.0095830895,
0.0440586358,
0.0762819573,
0.0125514315,
-0.0211048722,
0.0886303782,
0.0208017863,
-0.05521084,
0.0034689349,
-0.0090912413,
0.0568825789,
-0.0198051091,
0.032727696,
0.0367064215,
0.0829528719,
0.0085737882,
0.0501544438,
-0.0153050674,
-0.0417456441,
0.0178101379,
0.0159139168,
0.0695422441,
0.0055286721,
0.0201723427,
-0.0046091899,
-0.01925065,
-0.0089035966,
0.0271604881,
-0.0530751422,
-0.0076604709,
-0.0352745466,
-0.0446311012,
-0.0391205996,
-0.0215887055,
-0.0066419872,
0.0030998096,
-0.0278229266,
0.0431940295,
-0.0853214115,
0.0399226323,
0.0210785735,
0.0043379078,
0.0573635958,
0.0461004302,
-0.0340829715,
0.0303138942,
-0.0125859408,
0.0774438903,
0.0616422668,
0.0594993755,
-0.0428600796,
0.0319642983,
-0.0237617325,
0.005076848,
0.0097021246,
0.0212325472,
-0.0572487041,
0.0130896177,
-0.0364422277,
0.0128938565,
-0.0151747819,
0.0247820504,
-0.0018711147,
0.0005748085,
0.0660328269,
0.0067708087,
-0.0278187767,
-0.0008730813,
0.0627269149,
-0.0356445312,
0.0347197317,
-0.001020839,
0.0095900809,
-0.022456212,
-0.0001842799,
0.0185138267,
-0.0142736221,
0.0439421125,
-0.0263214093,
-0.0165406745,
0.0289263539,
-0.005185293,
-0.0291476175,
0.0455642901,
-0.0147164408,
0.0463129841,
0.0068229311,
-0.028397996,
-0.0086990409,
0.0352401696,
-0.057731986,
0.0573187955,
-0.0377727933,
0.0374255553,
-0.0735082701,
0.0728478804,
-0.0253218897,
0.0578653924,
-0.0464187525,
-0.0159696024,
0.0132092535,
0.0635303631,
0.0324305184,
-0.0064479061,
-0.0413117036,
0.0516347885,
0.0265129879,
-0.0190534946,
0.018352529,
-0.0210719164,
-0.0348577127,
0.0117366491,
-0.059711691,
0.0170303173,
-0.0476969592,
0.0230525136,
0.0560783371,
0.0262045227,
-0.0033146609,
-0.0163271222,
0.0080664298,
0.02757385,
-0.0539967678,
0.0456382334,
0.0635636747,
-0.0041865436,
-0.0000272947,
-0.0683110058,
-0.0045998744,
0.0088935299,
0.0522204526,
0.0065951063,
-0.0259182118,
-0.0755327791,
0.0189209823,
-0.0479334481,
0.0200111177,
-0.0063353367,
-0.0019724681,
-0.0256331563,
0.0037942852,
0.0801588595,
0.0239682067,
0.0612655617,
0.0817495584,
0.0698838457,
-0.0046021342,
-0.0238604043,
-0.0425809845,
-0.0289043542,
0.0281195473,
-0.0494231433,
-0.0174914841,
0.0192386154,
0.0186370127,
-0.007043343,
0.0010829438,
-0.0320557505,
-0.0029943902,
-0.0643816888,
0.0023287637,
-0.01943128,
0.0019406173,
-0.0575206429,
0.0048142541,
0.0120682921,
-0.0013508288,
0.0222413186,
0.0103682186,
0.0356751531,
-0.0729280561,
-0.0381683856,
-0.0522017926,
0.0359517969,
-0.0073612407,
-0.0061055836,
-0.0327898599,
0.0094219428,
-0.0404972397,
-0.0293687806,
0.0565638207,
-0.0272903647,
0.0423721746,
-0.0591266006,
0.0133369565,
0.0113438079,
0.0236733239,
-0.0152511876,
-0.0751585886,
-0.0077215084,
0.0184313003,
-0.0122919707,
-0.0028823761,
0.0234511625,
0.0204374082,
-0.0374166258,
0.0599589683,
0.0135434,
-0.0220293365,
-0.0182921086,
0.0364702083,
0.0432238616,
-0.0172373075,
-0.0081546204,
0.015671866,
0.0376224257,
0.0122256037,
-0.0085890274,
-0.0285213254,
-0.0848867446,
-0.0286940914,
-0.0158051904,
-0.051627636,
0.0049167932,
-0.0389399044,
-0.0360801816,
-0.0058995872,
-0.0190608948,
0.059089601,
0.0138624283,
-0.0351048298,
0.0325816981,
-0.0463112444,
-0.0329153165,
0.0272369515,
-0.0299768094,
-0.0647578686,
-0.0342065468,
0.001027126,
-0.0088338405,
0.0005794337,
-0.0409489013,
-0.0000628536,
-0.0510483272,
-0.0383856408,
-0.0129414452,
-0.0346499756,
0.0368825682,
-0.0300559532,
0.0626525208,
-0.0387225226,
-0.0331051089,
-0.0198578183,
-0.0100710914,
-0.0159749985,
0.0032922968,
-0.0614742003,
-0.0732068792,
0.0110733826,
-0.0070519592,
0.0275918338,
0.0432140566,
0.0498548262,
-0.0333301313,
-0.0374325179,
0.0821523517,
-0.0478432849,
-0.0246628076,
-0.0367003977,
0.0434739403,
-0.0004742946,
0.0136579173,
0.0274308901,
-0.0281193685,
0.0389100201,
-0.0068595423,
0.0351391472,
0.0635053515,
-0.0125173898,
-0.0227935389,
-0.0171255171,
-0.0419942364,
0.0286235344,
0.0236858372,
-0.0033375223,
-0.0136025259,
0.0247986019,
0.034712974,
-0.000176352,
0.0543664657,
-0.0331058055,
-0.0425271615,
-0.0371900573,
-0.038412109,
-0.0823258385,
-0.027827939,
0.0009237608,
-0.0244445428,
0.0348027647,
0.0306546558,
0.000078752,
-0.0011541506,
-0.0826992244,
-0.0156780984,
-0.0099510951,
0.0467981324,
-0.0135442372,
-0.0117246257,
0.0592783913,
0.0426211953,
-0.0229573715,
-0.0082550524,
-0.0825377628,
-0.0172702465,
0.0356794372,
-0.0411063507,
0.006609072,
0.0596940219,
-0.0350569189,
-0.0062139481,
0.047996562,
-0.013659128,
-0.0099222613,
0.0276966412,
-0.0054557319,
0.0091654928,
-0.0127325542,
0.0445764773,
-0.0182682946,
-0.0081054829,
-0.0074128071,
0.0251494478,
-0.0248312112,
-0.00094216,
0.0001483346,
-0.0186872091,
0.0322878398,
-0.010981475,
-0.0328604095,
-0.0133139966,
0.0120989997,
0.0040691984,
0.0103248283,
0.0385613069,
-0.0073951883,
0.0066338312,
-0.0045737536,
-0.0477337837,
0.0350479744,
-0.0265481062,
-0.015053086,
0.0008083048,
-0.0019438146,
0.0471309498,
0.0709572062,
0.0317828804,
0.0578301772,
-0.0005582463,
-0.0043969066,
-0.0211956389,
-0.002285725,
-0.0306855701,
0.0116380872,
0.0151402149,
-0.0282527469,
0.0069406303,
0.0499416739,
-0.0127103329,
0.0530306995,
0.0110740177,
0.0116086369,
0.0384984426,
-0.0237947088,
0.0794618875,
-0.0280286036,
-0.00408644,
-0.0391897634,
0.0001490253,
0.0035985548,
-0.0229447559,
0.025196733,
0.0050328444,
-0.0173649173,
0.0565398075,
0.0082797017,
-0.0436742529,
0.0588599816,
-0.0466842242,
-0.002952144,
-0.0188460033,
0.0362263881,
0.0157316998,
-0.0039637615,
-0.0395370759,
-0.0075906008,
-0.0601817928,
-0.0245768279,
0.0121990889,
-0.0208749827,
-0.0266573094,
0.0532795563,
0.032893084,
0.0390659906,
0.0319818556,
0.0594360568,
-0.0516593754,
0.0474981442,
-0.0284824055,
-0.0045090117,
-0.0472373553,
-5.552845765e-33,
0.0005196463,
0.0068965806,
-0.0208631046,
0.0031101606,
-0.0442934036,
0.0298429597,
-0.0315906145,
-0.0257086866,
-0.0060931691,
0.0168514233,
0.0256824642,
0.043529883,
0.0067104148,
-0.0491530523,
0.0150574157,
-0.0388575122,
0.0696429461,
0.0192680359,
-0.0175659582,
-0.0108380234,
0.0830533803,
0.0103491684,
0.0809871405,
-0.0456265695,
0.0616960712,
0.0072694169,
0.0246477202,
0.041390799,
0.0464354083,
0.034591835,
-0.0245246887,
0.0551004037,
0.0135746049,
-0.0081313075,
-0.0344056822,
-0.0123460907,
-0.0833106786,
-0.0495083407,
0.0261052568,
0.0472561792,
-0.0366971232,
-0.0242970623,
-0.0161928609,
0.0191291329,
-0.0184578858,
0.0558720827,
0.0431379452,
-0.0375777297,
-0.0433119014,
0.0134828249,
-0.0676817298,
0.0546977967,
-0.0158779882,
0.0050506503,
0.011545903,
-0.0035688842,
0.0689683184,
-0.0403093286,
-0.0663382784,
0.0107438648,
-0.0431721285,
0.0223276522,
0.0029887406,
-0.0233760104,
-0.0028229328,
0.0600088499,
-0.0180958621,
-0.059586037,
0.0447500236,
0.0121768555,
0.0647241101,
-0.0228460059,
0.0316489041,
0.045527339,
0.0294922385,
-0.0573311262,
-0.0455671921,
-0.0335466862,
0.0596651882,
0.0888263956,
0.0324886516,
0.0046416582,
-0.0215641949,
0.0059387013,
-0.0252699014,
0.0079005947,
-0.0233183578,
-0.0367470942,
0.022902159,
0.0264484771,
-0.0102155153,
0.0102967545,
-0.0167495199,
-0.0428952202,
-0.031316746,
0.0259270035,
-0.0551416352,
-0.0068152705,
0.0160788279,
0.0440559238,
0.0211835261,
-0.0256327558,
0.0160619225,
0.0211398061,
0.010464849,
-0.0280094463,
0.0096426159,
-0.0050587063,
-0.0286324769,
0.0058694398,
0.0052255723,
-0.071114175,
-0.0502429083,
-0.025976086,
-0.0308147762,
0.0140036177,
-0.0177814718,
0.039931532,
0.069926545,
0.0202572271,
0.0016895009,
-0.0366554596,
0.0381405689,
0.0428823829,
-0.028043285,
0.0140172662,
-0.0060007041,
0.0753415376,
0.0389432833,
-0.0304654017,
0.0187374372,
-0.0217994414,
2.592e-7,
0.0618191101,
0.06398651,
0.0003862981,
-0.0152473729,
0.0298790969,
-0.0246497616,
-0.0511162803,
0.0212619379,
-0.0569674969,
0.0509168431,
-0.0009226021,
-0.0045859502,
0.0199343413,
0.0240783263,
-0.0263374876,
-0.0069417236,
-0.0657081231,
-0.0136805493,
-0.0665134937,
0.0110046761,
0.054563649,
0.0904961824,
0.0519972779,
0.0019003461,
-0.0690222234,
-0.0190300383,
0.0450865366,
-0.0067852302,
-0.0117129441,
0.0062323166,
0.0141060865,
0.0722904652,
0.0211199075,
0.0152427908,
-0.011796372,
0.0352038704,
0.0198959857,
0.0108601563,
-0.0130090155,
0.0513621978,
0.0000631556,
-0.0316526815,
-0.0249202531,
-0.0091229063,
0.0902200639,
0.0013889562,
0.0124513339,
-0.0802290291,
-0.0072466503,
0.0478050373,
0.088069953,
0.0016021397,
-0.0701271072,
0.0095020607,
0.0102311904,
0.0392855294,
-0.0627487227,
-0.0809632391,
0.0170496311,
-0.016292084,
-0.0025457747,
-0.0274252146,
-0.0207951218,
-0.0143670272,
0.0203505233,
-0.0148353679,
0.0374459215,
1.598960795e-34,
0.0223284904,
0.0660444424,
-0.0291148387,
0.0101188272,
0.0161940474,
-0.0359729975,
0.0501963943,
0.009573671,
-0.0003775042,
-0.0368460231,
-0.0022634536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12097v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12097v1 | Instruction Position Matters in Sequence Generation with Large Language Models | 2023-08-23T12:36:57 | 2023-08-23T12:36:57 | Yijin Liu, Xianfeng Zeng, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are capable of performing conditional sequence
generation tasks, such as translation or summarization, through instruction
fine-tuning. The fine-tuning data is generally sequentially concatenated from a
specific task instruction, an input sentence, and the corresponding response.
Considering the locality modeled by the self-attention mechanism of LLMs, these
models face the risk of instruction forgetting when generating responses for
long input sentences. To mitigate this issue, we propose enhancing the
instruction-following capability of LLMs by shifting the position of task
instructions after the input sentences. Theoretical analysis suggests that our
straightforward method can alter the model's learning focus, thereby
emphasizing the training of instruction-following capabilities. Concurrently,
experimental results demonstrate that our approach consistently outperforms
traditional settings across various model scales (1B / 7B / 13B) and different
sequence generation tasks (translation and summarization), without any
additional data or annotation costs. Notably, our method significantly improves
the zero-shot performance on conditional sequence generation, e.g., up to 9.7
BLEU points on WMT zero-shot translation tasks. | [
0.0281725377,
0.0364279822,
0.0119429082,
0.0090200631,
-0.0108189778,
0.016300505,
0.0324675962,
-0.0463423841,
-0.0295950714,
-0.0594129302,
-0.0301796664,
-0.0530328229,
0.004640928,
-0.0181964263,
0.0486502834,
-0.0473948009,
0.0427934267,
-0.0416400209,
-0.0165451858,
0.0175360758,
-0.0167947449,
-0.009469185,
0.0038125787,
0.0238529798,
0.0372989438,
-0.0012482798,
-0.0185693707,
0.0095679089,
0.02189463,
-0.0549313799,
0.0063400832,
0.0635700151,
0.0058489195,
0.0230621994,
0.0000018898,
-0.024194926,
-0.0041762977,
-0.0172182806,
0.004256594,
0.0244372655,
-0.0015743085,
-0.0217820164,
-0.0126443719,
0.027947193,
-0.0215168539,
-0.0070340382,
0.0374493599,
0.0194834787,
0.0602873899,
0.0931814387,
0.0097514018,
-0.0319980383,
-0.00631849,
-0.0739611983,
0.0312818103,
-0.0210223217,
-0.0047577396,
-0.005474227,
-0.0217733923,
0.0570993982,
-0.0148833916,
0.0478929207,
0.0365528353,
0.0117796045,
0.0063374387,
0.0486775823,
0.0032556145,
-0.0301274545,
-0.0128940018,
0.0445628278,
-0.0426286981,
-0.0142224999,
0.0013064982,
-0.0026436592,
0.0296542142,
-0.0391778871,
-0.0743804798,
0.0736936554,
0.0239751581,
0.0113901431,
0.0083114551,
0.0042451341,
0.005324123,
0.0059794732,
-0.052313704,
0.0237351879,
0.0150609696,
-0.0399702117,
-0.053439308,
0.0005697846,
-0.035692744,
-0.0624776781,
-0.0090362551,
0.0654412583,
-0.0276931617,
0.0217233021,
-0.0675547719,
-0.0116000716,
0.029468989,
-0.0211223867,
0.0922381356,
0.0698993653,
-0.0059452965,
0.0138513353,
-0.0498465076,
0.077355139,
0.0029978461,
-0.0073041706,
-0.0601636469,
0.0458371527,
-0.0350395851,
0.0106447125,
-0.0144435382,
0.0072222878,
-0.0585005172,
-0.0110134138,
-0.0476596802,
0.0406186059,
0.0365981311,
0.0006088732,
0.0108267665,
0.0055025364,
-0.0653231218,
-0.0105951866,
0.0141806137,
0.047829289,
-0.0180111993,
-0.0051152306,
0.0477591716,
-0.036247883,
-0.0531199276,
0.0151546951,
0.016900681,
-0.0351477638,
0.003547899,
0.0570259877,
-0.0196440816,
-0.0535494387,
-0.0328953862,
-0.0310568362,
-0.0314070098,
-0.0812450871,
0.0467228517,
-0.0464419983,
-0.0008574773,
-0.0010252969,
-0.0141967824,
-0.0098191919,
0.0414995216,
0.0183927175,
-0.0185418054,
0.037578728,
0.0366612598,
-0.0073217475,
-0.0034019139,
-0.0024122242,
0.0352594182,
0.0473201945,
0.0285127386,
0.0452924035,
-0.006948621,
0.0021719129,
-0.0024548001,
0.0235877484,
0.0288586281,
0.0231792051,
-0.0155939525,
-0.0047016959,
0.0120777488,
0.0187253095,
0.0748052374,
0.0239216369,
-0.0212017559,
0.0226404238,
0.0764624774,
0.0292239618,
0.0025543857,
-0.0043589184,
0.0809195265,
0.0330885015,
-0.0407356247,
0.0561737828,
-0.0549965389,
0.0571573749,
-0.0131199481,
0.0658866689,
0.0643109381,
0.020086363,
-0.0513084158,
-0.0484951437,
-0.0082959784,
-0.0153985312,
-0.0004167344,
0.0154301161,
0.018265849,
0.0411013477,
-0.0730056465,
0.04041785,
0.0252566375,
-0.0635882244,
-0.004883742,
-0.0324674174,
0.0247531533,
0.0593973733,
0.0119386725,
-0.0002454065,
-0.0714295805,
-0.0004135682,
0.0125654507,
0.0641207919,
0.0239451323,
0.0205604471,
0.0009804323,
-0.0501887985,
-0.0241619144,
-0.0368915237,
0.0076505588,
0.0119479541,
0.0126739312,
-0.0239584651,
0.0488916226,
0.0282830726,
-0.0497799143,
0.0309404675,
-0.0570075586,
-0.0656030998,
-0.0003621054,
0.0056946552,
0.0345102735,
-0.0044248952,
0.0008388449,
0.0389754362,
0.038068451,
-0.0455517955,
0.0080848653,
-0.010648069,
-0.0855773613,
-0.0643021464,
0.0277954098,
0.0051319022,
0.0074254028,
-0.0199904535,
-0.021963371,
-0.0589880943,
0.0197429378,
-0.0359393246,
-0.0029267906,
-0.0268705059,
0.0487653539,
0.04741133,
0.0185277164,
-0.0590491965,
0.0350685753,
-0.0363501832,
0.0165861174,
0.0387878045,
0.0124427928,
-0.0202648584,
-0.0467054769,
0.0114258099,
-0.0230209492,
0.013823268,
-0.0013758335,
0.0188598931,
0.0410925671,
-0.0368016325,
-0.0379811488,
-0.0741043538,
0.0309203435,
-0.0314405225,
0.034488555,
0.0419850908,
0.0226469748,
-0.0044216914,
-0.0136027075,
-0.0396364853,
-0.0056672255,
0.0236725584,
0.0112588825,
0.0365877934,
0.0151034202,
-0.0164254997,
-0.054944586,
-0.0096464753,
0.0149195371,
0.0192570128,
-0.0128387483,
0.0215165336,
-0.0531594791,
0.0431397669,
-0.0255623292,
0.0095443372,
0.0095557896,
-0.0684998333,
0.0110530453,
-0.010206366,
0.0702953339,
0.0805897042,
0.001136482,
0.0076325871,
0.0570494495,
-0.0152458651,
-0.0237110537,
0.0107736066,
-0.0358450525,
-0.0195721444,
-0.0108234948,
-0.0376670696,
-0.022566231,
0.1041541323,
-0.0023483583,
0.0101213697,
-0.0687820837,
0.0143883433,
0.012172401,
-0.0273321904,
0.0040374626,
0.005751831,
-0.048620522,
0.0263750069,
-0.037939664,
-0.0389781334,
0.0317678377,
-0.0464595631,
0.001812267,
-0.0507196002,
0.017549606,
-0.0373892076,
0.0330463573,
0.0327960849,
0.0214553066,
0.0224870164,
-0.0068580881,
-0.0679827854,
0.0151911834,
-0.0017465198,
-0.0083714398,
0.034724649,
-0.0443929546,
-0.0150634954,
-0.0289207846,
-0.0163831618,
-0.0336401053,
-0.0081686396,
0.0066075451,
0.0209954828,
0.0028005023,
-0.0066669504,
-0.0322273225,
0.0018121949,
0.0602856614,
0.0732548535,
-0.0499365032,
0.0071477969,
-0.0475376956,
0.023727702,
0.0510205626,
0.0049476521,
-0.0136244521,
-0.0436368696,
0.0129960887,
0.023326626,
0.0338312909,
0.0076305876,
-0.0077291797,
-0.0095991306,
0.0228243619,
-0.0353057049,
-0.0045587393,
0.0497073121,
0.0781913251,
-0.0694672987,
-0.0369261317,
0.1338550448,
0.0341503918,
-0.0082935393,
0.0157967322,
0.0188544653,
0.0495243296,
0.0376697034,
0.0148035279,
-0.0634261444,
-0.0269688796,
0.0010880817,
0.0163449664,
-0.0035261519,
0.0152712604,
-0.0182977915,
-0.1226724908,
0.0165001098,
0.0429434776,
-0.0494132526,
-0.0218745936,
-0.0107874945,
-0.0118813794,
0.0230545811,
0.0413631573,
0.0434852093,
-0.0323220901,
0.0086716525,
0.0337672643,
0.0140376268,
-0.0587401353,
-0.0010230769,
-0.0335699581,
0.0311638732,
0.0800712034,
-0.005176858,
0.0181711353,
-0.0018072414,
0.020129621,
0.0064650024,
0.0391768515,
0.0070094327,
0.0494916365,
-0.0088638095,
-0.0088523338,
-0.0023785161,
0.0367754512,
-0.0061982921,
0.0009525159,
0.0105935587,
0.0359502919,
-0.0130281476,
-0.0072574606,
-0.0080256341,
0.0114007927,
-0.0163511857,
0.0486811399,
0.0709990785,
-0.0508255102,
-0.040882621,
-0.0333217271,
-0.0277293958,
-0.1024436355,
-0.0210353546,
0.0086828321,
-0.0204005446,
-0.0342499837,
-0.0968761221,
-0.0894860402,
0.0228094906,
0.0321788974,
0.0041986937,
-0.0132473828,
0.0109675117,
-0.0238314737,
-0.0262756385,
0.0193357784,
-0.0246980414,
-0.0233882125,
-0.0692106262,
-0.0195044093,
0.0300585162,
-0.0320852064,
0.0078597739,
0.0136695467,
-0.0958467573,
-0.074381806,
-0.0134147648,
0.0921911299,
0.0144387409,
0.058233913,
0.0364373028,
-0.0266223717,
0.0294499919,
0.0128748994,
-0.0302962102,
0.0336744748,
0.0436246209,
-0.0024716128,
-0.0200794023,
0.0301483218,
-0.0097853355,
0.0343508087,
0.0237440784,
0.0663807243,
-0.0227514505,
-0.0301818289,
0.0217407867,
0.0063342461,
0.0333783776,
-0.0356554687,
0.017994171,
-0.0152524635,
0.0199940819,
-0.0299182404,
0.0015367765,
-0.0310713612,
-0.0038864438,
0.0206135176,
0.0049512787,
0.0189852007,
0.0001675135,
-0.0292053241,
0.0028699606,
-0.0481261164,
0.0085120676,
-0.042570401,
0.0048091058,
0.001800825,
-0.0004695795,
-0.0390000008,
0.0214911066,
-0.0082976213,
0.0152034974,
-0.0155983008,
0.064372994,
0.0016162243,
0.0311141219,
-0.0284971949,
0.0416260846,
-0.0480257347,
0.0185804162,
-0.0212687626,
0.0066479952,
0.0828767121,
-0.0161557831,
0.074754782,
-0.0142244771,
-0.017131744,
-0.0161282457,
0.0491211489,
-0.0166552458,
-0.0359123014,
-0.0194917917,
0.0314025618,
0.0024314809,
-0.0082638608,
0.0982077345,
0.0272645373,
0.0126065398,
0.0270723235,
0.0224884208,
-0.0455551371,
-0.0426349528,
0.0186196659,
-0.028957909,
-0.0195296425,
0.0390982889,
-0.0298119634,
-0.0506298319,
-0.0000027757,
0.0100295944,
-0.0013153413,
-0.0420197621,
0.0571119078,
0.0153187104,
-0.0387171432,
-0.0303766392,
-0.054812789,
0.0121332332,
0.0144540025,
-0.0298467185,
-0.0273964703,
-6.470112659e-33,
-0.0465880111,
-0.0126763759,
0.043954879,
-0.0201673619,
-0.0293407794,
-0.0128710475,
-0.0468312204,
0.0274390262,
0.0145178707,
-0.0305209979,
-0.0189415962,
-0.0201265961,
0.0108648511,
0.0547701754,
0.0357873142,
0.0215133838,
0.0641806573,
-0.0221996624,
-0.0216980483,
0.0375856124,
0.0171998683,
0.0218818896,
0.0386121087,
0.0164647512,
0.0272406116,
-0.0278907698,
0.0033983372,
-0.0059700292,
-0.0196270011,
0.0445159562,
-0.0076148896,
0.0040510762,
0.0169247314,
-0.0519888587,
-0.0704184026,
0.0014135306,
-0.0488974676,
-0.0102793314,
0.020122407,
-0.0193498675,
-0.0549586341,
-0.0842916593,
0.0431435108,
-0.0323039405,
-0.0147932824,
-0.0480878875,
-0.0070194313,
-0.0337677673,
-0.0548396856,
0.0079485001,
-0.083643645,
-0.0011435765,
0.0001975739,
-0.0586380213,
0.0275380127,
0.0567338131,
-0.0173260402,
-0.0240398888,
-0.0206589345,
0.011297184,
0.0475087576,
0.0891153812,
0.0485441312,
0.0479946472,
-0.0008395984,
0.0114193065,
0.0122793661,
0.0058207083,
0.0009092358,
0.0103782034,
0.0063262666,
0.0079254154,
0.0310539734,
-0.0064513036,
0.0260794405,
0.0252710301,
-0.0585326068,
-0.0006347196,
-0.0120897051,
0.0392376259,
0.0593899079,
0.0028534546,
0.0018749087,
-0.0191296339,
-0.0284986217,
0.0077113663,
-0.0206530355,
-0.0143029755,
0.0358478464,
0.0449875258,
-0.0092657749,
-0.0139245307,
0.0621982552,
0.0143436538,
0.0233245809,
0.0280945785,
-0.0290432237,
0.0099623017,
-0.0072584893,
0.0189297237,
-0.0933352411,
-0.0009472834,
0.0419663042,
-0.0077023441,
-0.0187775251,
0.0366712846,
0.0639903545,
0.0073038545,
-0.0470254533,
-0.0112433499,
-0.0478985533,
0.0373467952,
-0.0106806671,
0.0279715862,
0.0278044641,
0.0078150909,
-0.0151560297,
0.0753850862,
-0.015443366,
-0.0465003923,
-0.0219459515,
0.0192846637,
-0.0025688841,
0.041605223,
-0.0334593952,
0.040417619,
-0.050479386,
0.0593745559,
-0.000111952,
-0.0478990674,
-0.0469586775,
0.0260388944,
2.62e-7,
0.0124103772,
0.0356252082,
0.0269416738,
0.0404727645,
0.0032743325,
0.0260350779,
-0.0343924016,
0.0367358737,
0.034719158,
0.0224168859,
0.0351798125,
0.0289489329,
0.0411794558,
-0.0141428914,
-0.0862063915,
-0.0009921934,
-0.0528562367,
0.0248013269,
-0.0457968004,
-0.0258281361,
0.0157826561,
0.0801195949,
-0.0432506725,
0.0141667696,
0.0371296518,
-0.0042906976,
0.0590964183,
0.0119644552,
-0.0364407822,
-0.0082376404,
-0.0189117249,
0.0297323111,
-0.033637017,
-0.0239565931,
-0.0123265535,
-0.0139099015,
-0.0244784225,
0.0708337724,
0.0072495076,
-0.0302781612,
0.0297516044,
0.0002243109,
-0.0095385239,
-0.0180715807,
0.0484157279,
-0.0978936404,
-0.0163956154,
0.0272870604,
-0.0135695431,
0.0418073051,
-0.015613039,
-0.0370079614,
-0.0230025388,
0.0107644387,
0.0315366201,
0.0098017175,
-0.0069810352,
-0.0511128791,
-0.0205192529,
0.0252816956,
-0.0276623443,
-0.0217944011,
-0.0643591806,
-0.0043485118,
-0.002643628,
-0.04934128,
-0.039444197,
2.71387368e-34,
0.0163703114,
-0.0343140699,
0.0359100513,
-0.0056487587,
0.0120216021,
-0.0228279512,
-0.0624573305,
0.029290244,
0.0451370031,
-0.07792826,
-0.0618828088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12086v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12086v2 | Out of the Cage: How Stochastic Parrots Win in Cyber Security Environments | 2023-08-23T12:11:27 | 2023-08-28T09:42:59 | Maria Rigaki, Ondřej Lukáš, Carlos A. Catania, Sebastian Garcia | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have gained widespread popularity across diverse
domains involving text generation, summarization, and various natural language
processing tasks. Despite their inherent limitations, LLM-based designs have
shown promising capabilities in planning and navigating open-world scenarios.
This paper introduces a novel application of pre-trained LLMs as agents within
cybersecurity network environments, focusing on their utility for sequential
decision-making processes.
We present an approach wherein pre-trained LLMs are leveraged as attacking
agents in two reinforcement learning environments. Our proposed agents
demonstrate similar or better performance against state-of-the-art agents
trained for thousands of episodes in most scenarios and configurations. In
addition, the best LLM agents perform similarly to human testers of the
environment without any additional training process. This design highlights the
potential of LLMs to efficiently address complex decision-making tasks within
cybersecurity.
Furthermore, we introduce a new network security environment named
NetSecGame. The environment is designed to eventually support complex
multi-agent scenarios within the network security domain. The proposed
environment mimics real network attacks and is designed to be highly modular
and adaptable for various scenarios. | [
0.0303492174,
0.047212176,
-0.0056546768,
-0.0042575276,
-0.060509529,
-0.0380436629,
0.0436026379,
-0.0353797302,
-0.0175579302,
-0.047261931,
-0.0108040413,
-0.0236612055,
-0.0281794779,
0.057753697,
0.0284025818,
-0.0211687312,
0.0526830852,
-0.0635501817,
0.0136341704,
0.0191069078,
0.0080017289,
-0.0260224789,
-0.0287844874,
0.0609582402,
0.0376056395,
-0.0084025525,
-0.0497259237,
-0.0090181474,
0.0605987981,
-0.0479229912,
0.0349698775,
0.0074724443,
0.0571439341,
0.0501735732,
0.0000020173,
-0.0349549092,
-0.0306153186,
-0.0207089391,
-0.0194401331,
0.0282877292,
0.0304782074,
-0.0102778021,
-0.0201079343,
0.0356655121,
-0.0515414588,
-0.0081642522,
0.0252137613,
0.0630022734,
0.0648849607,
0.1147701889,
0.0120001696,
-0.0302540641,
0.0126809515,
-0.0174479019,
-0.0391087271,
-0.0711450279,
0.0173782352,
-0.0086700711,
0.0452121496,
0.0045536915,
0.0162531566,
-0.0400568917,
-0.0069669345,
-0.0072209151,
-0.0642880946,
0.074687019,
-0.0086898766,
0.0243233051,
-0.0499172583,
0.0195612796,
-0.054493323,
0.0307209101,
0.0351575315,
0.0063168858,
0.0001064343,
-0.0105450666,
0.0018273016,
0.0271522366,
-0.0040885555,
-0.0148169473,
0.0156828724,
0.0188998673,
0.0022793573,
0.0176512618,
-0.048866868,
0.031685032,
-0.0063727163,
-0.0212599766,
-0.0087181814,
-0.0461166725,
0.0239239372,
-0.0492874868,
-0.0030316073,
0.0627696738,
-0.0641056597,
0.0119756432,
-0.0572588742,
-0.0219827332,
0.0219811965,
-0.0265435055,
0.0193322785,
-0.0298321676,
0.0088186031,
0.0154690249,
-0.0440219156,
0.0519153364,
-0.0256798659,
0.019398937,
-0.0100319507,
0.0062410864,
-0.0668438971,
-0.0302850828,
-0.0187353157,
0.0547888689,
0.0339099765,
-0.047108341,
-0.0489658378,
0.0279032495,
-0.055241894,
0.0541980118,
-0.0114034461,
-0.0066926181,
0.0040106145,
-0.0010471252,
-0.0306116641,
-0.0452830829,
-0.0529396161,
-0.0001566065,
0.004839621,
-0.0056137689,
-0.0241734199,
0.0019441178,
-0.0143596148,
-0.0217261482,
-0.0200132374,
0.1335210502,
0.0007800096,
-0.021522304,
-0.0186574217,
-0.0371904895,
0.0116203008,
-0.0132873245,
-0.028013289,
-0.0402044505,
-0.0066867569,
-0.0205148701,
-0.0191359092,
0.0086994329,
0.004399999,
-0.0165811237,
-0.0246813614,
0.0859489888,
0.0160002429,
0.0023359132,
0.0005702798,
-0.0178269688,
0.0168588758,
0.026100317,
0.0308264885,
0.0545506887,
0.0138392933,
0.0171352383,
0.0505202077,
0.0092389844,
0.0000265496,
0.0043996875,
0.0023720264,
0.0334035568,
0.0484426692,
0.0137403635,
-0.0103271119,
0.0238698144,
-0.030931402,
-0.0101507967,
0.0808605924,
0.0294793211,
-0.0077893469,
-0.0001957627,
0.0583802685,
0.0683501586,
-0.0164078325,
-0.0364234261,
-0.0205545612,
0.0274216998,
-0.0364163145,
0.0069420943,
-0.0090403669,
0.0429149121,
-0.0151885655,
-0.0097371638,
0.0045732488,
-0.056716159,
0.0299449768,
-0.0011215318,
0.0393452533,
0.0064134272,
-0.0597373284,
-0.0551754944,
0.0187560506,
0.0070928428,
-0.0061580162,
-0.0855358914,
-0.0082218545,
0.0836849585,
0.0338419527,
-0.0494685806,
-0.057408724,
-0.0399001241,
-0.0281115379,
0.0501854308,
-0.0206281822,
0.0098418137,
-0.0297528729,
-0.0331459045,
-0.0111858826,
-0.0165011194,
0.030753389,
0.0592677891,
0.0056590955,
0.0043701064,
0.0109530352,
0.0369750187,
-0.0674513206,
0.0261586867,
0.0346792936,
-0.02818406,
0.007712096,
-0.0056704492,
0.0804183632,
-0.0377084389,
-0.0361717232,
0.0491727032,
0.0202777721,
0.0011581279,
-0.039499402,
-0.0261465032,
0.0028366342,
0.0096679581,
0.0222082287,
-0.0221213344,
0.0609946139,
0.0564035177,
-0.0218927432,
-0.0304713268,
0.0462666117,
-0.0466276854,
0.0000881039,
0.0090012383,
-0.0024841242,
-0.0235959422,
0.0132131865,
-0.0251561776,
0.049578201,
0.0334591828,
-0.0683290288,
-0.0397897772,
0.0261797272,
0.0055484436,
-0.0446167886,
-0.0108209196,
-0.0088884654,
-0.0197279658,
0.0349716619,
0.0519510508,
0.0210834071,
0.0099591957,
-0.0627344921,
-0.0469158739,
0.0251017418,
-0.0249747075,
0.0106540034,
0.0276783779,
-0.0360305794,
-0.0278355181,
-0.019732669,
-0.009959396,
0.0137090934,
-0.0073367776,
0.0101405019,
0.0010718646,
0.0057481364,
-0.0609218813,
-0.0279708859,
-0.0107540991,
-0.0009093782,
0.0557155348,
0.0187764224,
0.001757122,
-0.0232939832,
0.0493804701,
-0.0477488115,
-0.0093560116,
-0.0127603821,
-0.0452656336,
0.0644329935,
-0.0418060608,
-0.0136318635,
0.0274030659,
0.0546456948,
0.040477436,
0.0898238122,
-0.0099939667,
-0.0533849224,
0.0217214543,
-0.0442426018,
-0.0521893091,
-0.1044034287,
0.0102709886,
0.0358159952,
0.0775244832,
0.0327507369,
0.0279186964,
-0.029636316,
0.0317950696,
0.024177568,
-0.0207559224,
-0.0399906188,
-0.0740211308,
0.001360151,
0.0134597346,
0.0110481968,
-0.030973101,
0.1075655743,
-0.0017407305,
0.0333519801,
-0.0324157663,
-0.0596530475,
-0.0333963819,
0.0266066231,
0.0103734117,
0.0239800774,
-0.0072576567,
-0.0121657504,
-0.0408582911,
-0.0681976303,
0.0362018682,
-0.0263063125,
-0.0089406567,
-0.0211752132,
0.0134388963,
0.0062550032,
-0.0115567194,
-0.0538866632,
-0.0193178579,
-0.0802433491,
-0.0029656163,
-0.026528351,
-0.0455993228,
-0.0446817875,
0.0046976809,
0.0703027323,
0.0138895232,
0.0055694729,
-0.0176616926,
-0.0112650348,
-0.0207103696,
0.049108576,
-0.0394921713,
-0.0056650331,
-0.0240574125,
0.0447169505,
0.0207755789,
0.0532277524,
-0.0311068818,
-0.0325092599,
-0.0072961352,
0.0023196987,
-0.0755214691,
0.0111062052,
0.0515747629,
0.0308324676,
-0.0528575666,
-0.0038287023,
0.0790486038,
0.0190521013,
-0.0042848573,
0.0151769919,
-0.0363253914,
0.00792161,
0.0113866758,
0.0546695925,
-0.0306065101,
-0.0092428224,
-0.013264874,
0.0240499191,
-0.0210691746,
-0.0601459518,
-0.0129963337,
-0.1017807424,
0.0118452692,
0.0130497543,
-0.0424586274,
0.0074966289,
-0.0559332371,
-0.0154855428,
-0.001124658,
0.0140480855,
0.0045494828,
0.0242833793,
-0.0080698002,
0.0167245455,
-0.0301448796,
0.0105020916,
0.0229654368,
-0.0321212187,
0.063206695,
0.0672263205,
0.0068094595,
-0.0272037741,
0.0253298171,
0.018914802,
-0.00998013,
0.0361566804,
0.0255061984,
0.0187197924,
0.0083189607,
-0.0132546769,
-0.0135796582,
0.0321408175,
0.0106928665,
-0.0449356399,
0.0682647154,
0.0413267985,
-0.0388454422,
-0.0177514516,
-0.0283559505,
0.008980602,
0.0433241799,
0.0385768712,
0.0039648372,
-0.0634474456,
-0.0691024885,
-0.0280085839,
-0.0431906506,
-0.0539789498,
-0.0511289872,
0.0009913621,
0.0080978647,
-0.0053731697,
-0.0535053201,
-0.062076591,
0.0106388731,
0.0041013164,
0.0037434883,
-0.0349803567,
0.026542969,
0.036565382,
-0.0196823236,
-0.0573541187,
-0.015246599,
0.0476209186,
-0.0430232249,
0.0200686045,
0.0051912959,
-0.0480563976,
-0.045555599,
-0.0068362672,
-0.0171119254,
-0.0686351582,
0.0063006612,
0.0673939958,
0.017275257,
0.0139154876,
-0.0236948989,
-0.0035953324,
0.1160118952,
0.0029250309,
-0.0244670473,
-0.0028970037,
0.0778470114,
-0.004955044,
0.0246656165,
0.0221312679,
-0.0508232266,
0.0262535345,
0.0183255449,
0.0057046465,
-0.0427995585,
-0.0202858243,
0.0254268758,
0.0055842958,
0.0003842059,
-0.0298150796,
0.0060847406,
0.0202044938,
0.0228115283,
-0.0282116681,
-0.0025535112,
0.0333434679,
0.0003806943,
0.0135944616,
-0.0015349422,
0.0621480867,
0.0221713167,
0.020671865,
-0.0168943591,
0.0294308029,
0.002677144,
0.0399441384,
0.0152018126,
0.0489827916,
-0.0159747265,
-0.0106390491,
0.03563039,
-0.0026279239,
0.0286312066,
0.0179033652,
0.03318277,
0.0117810545,
-0.0248892307,
-0.0426078737,
0.0230015442,
-0.0809296817,
-0.0622455142,
0.0593058169,
0.0310834646,
0.0457494333,
0.0447524413,
0.016287839,
-0.0487334765,
0.0388872325,
-0.0146856364,
0.0100000007,
-0.0181620046,
-0.0341760516,
0.0202961117,
0.0264785942,
-0.0033799654,
0.0262563583,
0.0800346285,
0.0136840912,
0.0644950718,
-0.0019099427,
-0.0318770744,
-0.0234889984,
-0.0235220287,
-0.0523753576,
0.0438033752,
-0.0434314609,
-0.0239604302,
-0.0496309251,
-0.0178578887,
-0.0022224076,
0.0341049917,
0.0275508575,
-0.019550737,
0.0256866124,
0.0104782339,
-0.0155291166,
0.0702714771,
-0.0782665685,
0.0139668714,
-0.0011641184,
-0.0306487232,
0.025353549,
-5.527758879e-33,
0.0408368148,
-0.0081420634,
0.0372328721,
-0.0118043534,
-0.0120977033,
0.0078271767,
-0.0307348147,
-0.0195848849,
-0.0037073155,
-0.0243296437,
-0.0032834446,
-0.0185117852,
0.0091236699,
0.0201377943,
-0.0281274058,
-0.0050509549,
0.0225504078,
-0.0067917644,
-0.008839285,
0.0303077064,
0.0701375306,
0.007428831,
-0.0018060819,
-0.0655350834,
0.0221803393,
0.002968441,
-0.0102152461,
-0.018090833,
-0.043025773,
0.0374026261,
-0.0065667778,
0.0268887337,
0.0012524272,
-0.0263239499,
-0.013575173,
0.0264415238,
0.0213878397,
-0.023538474,
-0.0342906974,
-0.0214854423,
0.0078081023,
-0.0478364006,
-0.0040639024,
0.0099073406,
-0.0048914053,
0.0157280937,
0.0070418767,
-0.0163284037,
-0.0218235701,
-0.0242866408,
-0.0440761484,
0.0046334621,
-0.0377103426,
-0.0040669641,
-0.0235843658,
-0.0244519282,
-0.006627311,
-0.0220450442,
-0.043596074,
0.0777751505,
0.0299866684,
0.0066851466,
0.0308614504,
0.0609783977,
0.0007002719,
0.0598725416,
-0.002376178,
-0.0088283783,
-0.0421394221,
0.0252245367,
0.0038476198,
0.0464685299,
0.0439548083,
0.0511844717,
-0.0138565982,
-0.0366508886,
-0.0842858925,
0.023879014,
0.0523843542,
0.046920646,
0.0654487163,
0.0124381268,
-0.0191075075,
0.0151456567,
-0.0176283792,
0.0149687668,
-0.000162254,
-0.0474770665,
0.0211445447,
0.0205925964,
-0.0329409838,
-0.0321889371,
0.030472355,
-0.0120185064,
-0.0004141019,
0.0306886584,
-0.0083892262,
0.0124860592,
-0.0320840999,
-0.0044301259,
-0.0143514527,
-0.0435976945,
0.0170119759,
-0.0381835215,
0.002794029,
-0.017706411,
-0.0043622535,
0.0473793112,
-0.0497107729,
0.0122949798,
-0.0016019092,
0.0495364293,
0.0103998547,
0.0287378188,
0.0414148048,
-0.0001913175,
0.001212613,
-0.0083306478,
0.0132037587,
-0.0953303501,
0.0008410956,
0.0371873304,
-0.0362593345,
0.0357339643,
-0.0241393503,
0.0538960621,
-0.068361938,
0.069509849,
-0.0036974363,
-0.0466720164,
-0.0024001165,
-0.01079241,
2.851e-7,
-0.0352511294,
0.0273856185,
0.0274908822,
0.0528929122,
0.0025079078,
0.0889898986,
-0.0085836211,
0.0896319449,
-0.0604011752,
-0.0463239588,
0.0178401135,
0.0368841849,
0.0164705496,
0.0311679021,
-0.0270226672,
-0.002181428,
-0.0641250536,
0.002468077,
-0.1146050766,
-0.0149609577,
0.0692996457,
0.0755556673,
0.0201839786,
-0.0071465322,
0.0030135133,
-0.0903206021,
0.037725389,
0.0026274857,
-0.0286031365,
0.0075944588,
0.0096145431,
0.0421897024,
-0.0226064157,
0.070655711,
0.002012633,
0.0056505851,
-0.0324648023,
0.0410356633,
0.0417472795,
0.013850512,
-0.0187971257,
-0.0319911465,
-0.0095415423,
-0.0361620523,
0.064593792,
-0.0738991722,
-0.0222743656,
0.0137392767,
-0.0237703845,
-0.0277871601,
-0.0232270639,
-0.0607681051,
-0.0111464486,
-0.002236719,
-0.037391752,
0.0010663413,
0.072878927,
-0.0811617151,
0.0103266099,
0.0194826927,
-0.0268609114,
-0.0229203962,
-0.0322909392,
0.0375181623,
0.0828321949,
0.0057029482,
0.0037154276,
2.402382371e-34,
-0.0000923568,
-0.0144356098,
-0.0328764431,
0.0120958695,
0.0154212089,
0.0423162766,
-0.0162216108,
0.0191682912,
0.0422402993,
-0.0240953546,
-0.0323615074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12067v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12067v2 | InstructionGPT-4: A 200-Instruction Paradigm for Fine-Tuning MiniGPT-4 | 2023-08-23T11:27:30 | 2023-10-11T14:49:26 | Lai Wei, Zihao Jiang, Weiran Huang, Lichao Sun | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Multimodal large language models are typically trained in two stages: first
pre-training on image-text pairs, and then fine-tuning using supervised
vision-language instruction data. Recent studies have shown that large language
models can achieve satisfactory results even with a limited amount of
high-quality instruction-following data. In this paper, we introduce
InstructionGPT-4, which is fine-tuned on a small dataset comprising only 200
examples, amounting to approximately 6\% of the instruction-following data used
in the alignment dataset for MiniGPT-4. To achieve this, we first propose
several metrics to access the quality of multimodal instruction data. Based on
these metrics, we present an effective and trainable data selector to
automatically identify and filter low-quality vision-language data. By
employing this method, InstructionGPT-4 outperforms the original MiniGPT-4 on
various evaluations. Overall, our findings demonstrate that less but
high-quality instruction tuning data is efficient in enabling multimodal large
language models to generate better output. Our code is available at
https://github.com/waltonfuture/InstructionGPT-4. | [
0.0219487697,
0.0958328396,
0.0076251016,
0.0667183399,
-0.0194184948,
0.0227711443,
0.0213278402,
-0.0028150058,
-0.0162466988,
-0.0699404106,
-0.0764086619,
-0.0212314799,
0.0218101088,
-0.020615492,
0.0728393644,
-0.0636935085,
0.0304376949,
-0.0428955033,
-0.055191014,
0.0189876109,
0.0484989397,
0.040811725,
-0.0067000398,
0.0455099009,
-0.0338567272,
-0.0318087339,
0.012360232,
0.0386805721,
0.0276629813,
-0.0159529019,
0.0244545024,
0.0492927767,
0.0271673836,
0.0183641575,
0.0000018957,
-0.0125030642,
0.0065656425,
-0.0061693811,
0.0211784188,
0.0018600076,
0.0437132083,
-0.0506586358,
-0.0191765353,
-0.0111462129,
0.0126286894,
-0.0360566117,
0.0927525684,
0.0358372256,
0.0922201574,
0.0742449611,
-0.0181415286,
-0.0265970416,
-0.0033516302,
-0.0257784203,
0.0119652292,
-0.0236403979,
0.0250732042,
0.0286660939,
-0.0212553628,
0.0246989485,
-0.0584083721,
0.0336010978,
0.0015447342,
-0.0092311688,
-0.0165246371,
0.0249523092,
-0.0277047493,
-0.0473304167,
-0.0160942059,
0.089040637,
-0.0235755183,
-0.0010353915,
-0.0269617718,
-0.0077549657,
-0.0200330466,
-0.0200613867,
-0.0353626311,
0.0240040272,
0.0000899147,
0.0291113164,
-0.0268465653,
-0.0233162679,
0.0070874267,
-0.0033368932,
0.0201619584,
0.0003126159,
0.035603933,
0.0102312192,
-0.0161191355,
-0.005597197,
-0.0646514148,
-0.0376363061,
-0.0339881815,
0.0024568969,
-0.0079064174,
-0.0078911996,
-0.0826384351,
-0.0090258941,
-0.0099776303,
0.0169186965,
0.0800262392,
0.0348730385,
-0.0427190401,
0.0635023192,
-0.0224214979,
0.0770761147,
-0.0258432794,
0.0648289695,
-0.030285988,
-0.001374032,
-0.0306587778,
0.0272838399,
-0.0290503446,
-0.0191576779,
-0.0417301506,
-0.0334087349,
-0.0275040306,
0.0143578565,
0.0013438839,
0.0011358913,
0.0140616288,
-0.0224281382,
-0.0784852877,
-0.0099383797,
0.0153829399,
0.0574963726,
-0.0087822136,
0.0099213291,
-0.0257453043,
-0.057941664,
0.0030282594,
0.0556478575,
0.0204100609,
-0.041866038,
0.0087868525,
0.0792449489,
-0.0350785963,
-0.0450557023,
-0.0327885933,
0.0141033875,
-0.034326721,
-0.0750618204,
0.0187138431,
-0.0399466902,
0.0159140248,
-0.002364109,
0.0273290835,
-0.0090969605,
0.0033185882,
0.0038149767,
-0.0097345905,
0.0768670365,
-0.0134505201,
-0.0032794829,
-0.0061921035,
-0.009787417,
0.0317181349,
0.0674416795,
0.0472322181,
0.0280031282,
0.0350590199,
-0.0363945328,
-0.0217268839,
0.0733894482,
-0.0048504211,
0.0215919949,
-0.0202559158,
-0.0120056476,
0.043764919,
0.0373149142,
0.0471989252,
0.0501322411,
-0.0188498199,
-0.0160672404,
0.0739332214,
0.002925656,
0.0094430493,
-0.0140723055,
0.0407597199,
0.0105015058,
-0.001013391,
0.0091498168,
-0.081437245,
0.0586636551,
-0.007861156,
0.0072583919,
0.0192230456,
0.0394113809,
-0.0277790762,
-0.0066814041,
0.0122308461,
-0.0042202165,
0.0021273098,
-0.0046767732,
0.0351298898,
-0.0151669774,
-0.0607672818,
0.0041334676,
0.0408654474,
-0.0124018602,
0.0064786966,
-0.0282614194,
0.0200105254,
0.0415374003,
0.0285458826,
0.0172289219,
-0.0432408303,
-0.0028834383,
0.0690713376,
0.0390480906,
0.0041886414,
-0.0003404257,
0.0383880138,
-0.093978852,
-0.0371256918,
-0.0037464099,
-0.0062975707,
-0.0020800503,
0.014572341,
-0.0095829824,
-0.0000011041,
-0.0011801964,
-0.0344655029,
0.0546163321,
0.0346555486,
-0.010087817,
-0.0430602394,
0.0362934545,
0.0093750777,
-0.024532374,
-0.0253659412,
-0.0341422334,
0.0129281301,
-0.0293117594,
0.0841636062,
-0.0204474181,
-0.0321720839,
-0.0368276536,
0.0197153073,
-0.0337035991,
-0.034715686,
0.0098190773,
-0.0622717068,
-0.018339891,
-0.0278752372,
-0.0528634712,
-0.0224326681,
-0.0326134004,
0.0063058422,
0.0195183605,
-0.0156516246,
-0.0597125255,
0.0061221537,
0.0018122079,
0.018173201,
0.0061025159,
0.0174047835,
0.0085167643,
-0.0190186687,
-0.0221650917,
0.0126756029,
0.0065432475,
0.0307677444,
0.0123159895,
0.0638200641,
-0.0399964005,
-0.0379896052,
-0.072567299,
0.0242920611,
-0.031686794,
0.0063201566,
0.0191900935,
-0.0087520173,
0.0045660208,
-0.0344219469,
-0.0120028947,
0.0268920306,
0.0011812401,
0.0060943817,
0.0300530996,
0.0119521273,
-0.0061472491,
-0.0380142964,
-0.0080444142,
0.0211409107,
-0.0043364163,
0.0105512608,
0.0053438013,
-0.0727588981,
0.0098927533,
-0.032597784,
0.0399456806,
-0.0161969475,
-0.1005434245,
0.0166548546,
-0.0102734072,
0.0187495127,
0.0694440529,
-0.0104669938,
-0.002516069,
0.0012178142,
-0.0058220108,
-0.0265424177,
-0.0009938768,
-0.0037829021,
-0.067742981,
-0.0465520583,
-0.0117777698,
-0.0459485613,
0.0491529219,
-0.0090289107,
0.0223813727,
-0.0975665823,
0.0272146594,
-0.0048379176,
0.0089522386,
-0.020069005,
0.0487561859,
-0.0165762566,
-0.0092906766,
-0.0739649683,
-0.0750077516,
0.0453917161,
-0.0357225537,
-0.0414998122,
-0.0083069652,
0.0160822682,
-0.0026561068,
0.0447120517,
0.0432253107,
0.0347989984,
-0.022885032,
-0.0183660109,
-0.0775263235,
-0.0107339574,
0.0213169213,
-0.0030646808,
0.0689176619,
-0.0544476807,
0.0188849773,
-0.0459464677,
-0.0305366516,
-0.0035276751,
-0.015962204,
0.0091705583,
-0.0250036176,
0.0204638764,
-0.0405274518,
-0.0364243723,
0.0129805151,
0.0200952869,
0.0474606454,
-0.0244809594,
0.0122553054,
-0.044676017,
0.0028711027,
0.083064124,
0.0135299023,
-0.0503891334,
-0.0588699616,
-0.0260482207,
0.0401376002,
0.0292728897,
-0.0035144577,
-0.0393888801,
0.0195854139,
0.0327721015,
0.0452801809,
0.0110294148,
0.0147776827,
0.092702195,
-0.0459119789,
0.0081015741,
0.0769327208,
-0.012667465,
-0.0370103046,
-0.0353450328,
0.0678290948,
0.0351335369,
0.0225697514,
-0.0046472047,
-0.0759355351,
-0.0565879941,
-0.0137650073,
0.012804863,
0.0408998244,
0.0085316477,
-0.0296464115,
-0.0622275919,
0.0487068035,
0.0405701399,
-0.0497774109,
-0.0661403537,
0.0126775727,
0.0295321494,
-0.0326736048,
0.0088009546,
0.0024558334,
-0.0379126742,
0.0016757377,
0.0177058708,
0.0174734648,
-0.0628446639,
0.0201772731,
-0.0468132012,
0.0213375222,
0.0629401729,
0.0157231987,
0.0184284262,
-0.0575893335,
0.0473461486,
-0.0238006804,
-0.0179829523,
-0.0181556661,
0.059634991,
-0.0339338742,
-0.0593167804,
0.0144394636,
0.0455821194,
0.0033086776,
0.0229137205,
-0.0210369602,
0.0379022323,
-0.0110165616,
0.0203878544,
0.0125840204,
-0.0134999715,
0.016275119,
0.0338728316,
0.0067872475,
-0.0446283966,
-0.0218734611,
-0.009651199,
0.0102525884,
-0.0639183819,
-0.0103235617,
0.0264723245,
-0.054427959,
0.0055443719,
-0.0494240373,
-0.0312833004,
0.0598549023,
0.0468545705,
0.0049014003,
-0.032571774,
0.0055743791,
-0.0042217057,
-0.0440635905,
0.0823780447,
-0.0364192054,
0.0385751687,
-0.0947469547,
-0.0425899476,
0.0147461183,
0.0027461562,
0.0077187461,
0.0310309678,
-0.0990607142,
-0.0592964292,
-0.0269201621,
0.0835694745,
0.0033828365,
0.0436648838,
0.0197933055,
-0.0439080372,
-0.0186804887,
0.041687537,
-0.0031676928,
0.0208155923,
0.0213137493,
-0.0450179055,
-0.02438109,
0.0312333275,
-0.0199442748,
0.0290792771,
0.0234210044,
0.0180868823,
-0.0112469029,
0.0016710786,
0.0119459918,
0.0105301114,
0.0620146729,
-0.0415059142,
0.0198835991,
-0.0597832166,
-0.004365874,
0.0099285776,
-0.0066744396,
-0.0771074519,
-0.0147969043,
0.017037591,
0.0028007042,
-0.0089952471,
-0.013196107,
0.0115571516,
0.0328107141,
-0.0631671622,
0.0488285385,
-0.0104105119,
0.0077172383,
0.0496227108,
0.0429227836,
-0.0000663411,
0.034555234,
0.0065227752,
0.0308708567,
-0.0160288736,
0.0774819776,
0.0421422496,
0.0073987055,
-0.0051365737,
0.0420432277,
0.0372325331,
-0.0187798664,
-0.0547810458,
0.0140889417,
0.0583811402,
-0.0193935297,
0.0551731214,
-0.0009412034,
-0.0395358615,
-0.0480122417,
0.0734460875,
-0.005650545,
-0.0192440581,
0.0512851216,
0.013447349,
-0.0024386647,
-0.0049555185,
0.0728534982,
0.002686227,
0.0506363884,
0.0075734165,
0.0168402921,
-0.0551716015,
-0.0122494241,
0.0273884274,
-0.019815987,
0.0034545069,
0.0532116778,
0.0236043762,
-0.0508829504,
-0.0592319593,
0.0212506931,
-0.0355851687,
0.0056610033,
0.0557697751,
0.0232316051,
-0.0181642398,
-0.0235568471,
-0.0368527062,
-0.0384830348,
0.0065991404,
-0.0201318264,
0.0053153038,
-6.115202262e-33,
-0.0445144475,
-0.0204775296,
0.0258956514,
-0.0156498533,
-0.0391400345,
0.0103812832,
-0.020052541,
-0.0065377709,
-0.0104498276,
0.0152138826,
0.0579325072,
-0.0258475859,
0.0048108976,
0.0381577052,
-0.0029495049,
0.0221477598,
0.0360875055,
-0.019121211,
-0.0148800882,
0.0254767481,
0.0174562242,
0.0040011411,
0.0643817037,
-0.0413305648,
-0.0283120777,
0.0092175417,
-0.0389488749,
0.0047227023,
-0.0068019251,
0.0885284245,
0.0015997286,
0.0132429386,
0.0043154531,
0.0112967016,
-0.0119864736,
0.0024985885,
-0.0507798791,
-0.0045609139,
0.017497642,
0.0513702743,
-0.0826316699,
-0.0252598058,
0.0220982805,
-0.0595166236,
-0.0236647371,
-0.0352796763,
0.0381582975,
-0.0240874458,
-0.0050882478,
0.0354296118,
-0.059215378,
0.017495282,
-0.0164615344,
-0.0524990149,
0.0375049971,
0.0399566218,
0.0337526239,
0.0112355473,
-0.0415836312,
0.0206295867,
0.0031051899,
0.0778037757,
0.0638708398,
0.0610413849,
0.0096859243,
0.049113933,
0.0105958702,
-0.0282946788,
0.0390191227,
-0.0019503973,
0.0352415629,
0.0585223287,
0.0255056825,
0.0401731506,
-0.0027791087,
0.0198566969,
-0.0391940363,
-0.0050508222,
-0.0299412832,
0.0522800833,
0.000128127,
0.0112669226,
-0.0197047219,
0.012035897,
-0.0110547375,
-0.0189415924,
-0.0351469964,
0.0004514347,
0.0433060117,
0.0299177319,
-0.0301934816,
0.033384122,
0.0880898759,
-0.0150544085,
-0.0258400105,
-0.0005513119,
-0.0502525046,
0.0330499709,
-0.0184892472,
0.0228512511,
-0.0567529909,
-0.0600356348,
0.0566024631,
-0.024762895,
0.0389357433,
0.0056656389,
0.0399383605,
0.0266461801,
-0.0615966767,
0.0053686057,
-0.0372522473,
0.03230213,
-0.0358569399,
-0.0022474041,
0.0419677459,
-0.0152258864,
-0.0340870917,
0.0734218433,
0.0212074928,
-0.0246819705,
-0.0210425891,
-0.0582823604,
0.0076987753,
0.0238467325,
-0.0191028342,
0.0328770094,
-0.0326086991,
-0.0543459766,
-0.0100084422,
-0.0388338044,
-0.0128697632,
0.0272202473,
2.502e-7,
0.0256193485,
0.048605036,
0.0067235255,
0.0279594753,
0.018891843,
0.03809762,
-0.0377172455,
-0.015408881,
0.0181812569,
-0.0242986772,
-0.0047892812,
0.0263753105,
0.0769950524,
-0.0148190632,
-0.0186192673,
0.049569089,
-0.0176292062,
0.0051719211,
-0.0578901023,
0.0092913006,
0.0346856266,
0.1021995693,
-0.0246907342,
-0.0054161865,
0.0329771787,
-0.0077330223,
0.047568284,
-0.0205493607,
-0.0256866757,
0.0164242107,
-0.0083991243,
0.0241405945,
-0.0338619314,
0.0128712244,
-0.0073067257,
-0.0357533544,
0.020252075,
0.0690024272,
-0.0432380289,
0.0070844512,
0.0005393636,
0.0280376971,
-0.0419371352,
-0.0517511778,
0.053734459,
-0.0557116605,
-0.0029028307,
-0.0247302521,
-0.0156925432,
0.003004509,
0.0158337671,
-0.0417507477,
-0.0519491881,
0.0260355677,
0.0703118369,
-0.024790369,
-0.0395527147,
-0.0503344722,
0.0067243343,
0.0263434835,
-0.0321072228,
-0.0377127863,
-0.0459646285,
-0.005143703,
0.0186051819,
-0.0366373658,
-0.0471924171,
2.125309857e-34,
0.0151366498,
-0.0387601331,
0.0545047596,
-0.0189069267,
0.0366401225,
0.0006307457,
-0.0134522021,
-0.0000657465,
-0.0226918627,
-0.063101843,
-0.0181122683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12060v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12060v3 | FlexKBQA: A Flexible LLM-Powered Framework for Few-Shot Knowledge Base Question Answering | 2023-08-23T11:00:36 | 2024-01-26T12:49:04 | Zhenyu Li, Sunqi Fan, Yu Gu, Xiuxing Li, Zhichao Duan, Bowen Dong, Ning Liu, Jianyong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge base question answering (KBQA) is a critical yet challenging task
due to the vast number of entities within knowledge bases and the diversity of
natural language questions posed by users. Unfortunately, the performance of
most KBQA models tends to decline significantly in real-world scenarios where
high-quality annotated data is insufficient. To mitigate the burden associated
with manual annotation, we introduce FlexKBQA by utilizing Large Language
Models (LLMs) as program translators for addressing the challenges inherent in
the few-shot KBQA task. Specifically, FlexKBQA leverages automated algorithms
to sample diverse programs, such as SPARQL queries, from the knowledge base,
which are subsequently converted into natural language questions via LLMs. This
synthetic dataset facilitates training a specialized lightweight model for the
KB. Additionally, to reduce the barriers of distribution shift between
synthetic data and real user questions, FlexKBQA introduces an executionguided
self-training method to iterative leverage unlabeled user questions.
Furthermore, we explore harnessing the inherent reasoning capability of LLMs to
enhance the entire framework. Consequently, FlexKBQA delivers substantial
flexibility, encompassing data annotation, deployment, and being domain
agnostic. Through extensive experiments on GrailQA, WebQSP, and KQA Pro, we
observe that under the few-shot even the more challenging zero-shot scenarios,
FlexKBQA achieves impressive results with a few annotations, surpassing all
previous baselines and even approaching the performance of supervised models,
achieving a remarkable 93% performance relative to the fully-supervised models.
We posit that FlexKBQA represents a significant advancement towards exploring
better integration of large and lightweight models. The code is open-sourced. | [
0.0363921598,
0.0062537091,
0.006472073,
0.0430050567,
-0.0199761484,
0.0346007571,
0.0086223269,
-0.0328537524,
0.0265890639,
-0.0807451084,
-0.0083571291,
0.0396050885,
-0.0653029308,
0.0105428444,
0.0237549767,
0.0055082529,
0.0252596792,
-0.0363254249,
-0.0105361501,
0.0034660958,
0.003627199,
0.0507139266,
-0.0226637051,
0.0077156993,
0.0070682373,
-0.0256087072,
-0.0081121549,
0.0088343928,
-0.0220050644,
0.0125145335,
0.0175505262,
0.0634256378,
0.0337796696,
0.0053066271,
0.0000020521,
-0.0466687754,
0.0037399747,
0.0276294295,
-0.0736766085,
-0.004053867,
-0.0280116107,
0.026694661,
0.0313087851,
0.0136033595,
-0.054696627,
-0.0109581845,
0.0111023234,
0.0101503953,
0.0663585067,
0.0427174345,
0.0128150955,
-0.0421456657,
-0.010927042,
0.0021163565,
0.0329793915,
-0.0633336753,
0.0093264487,
0.020631168,
0.0180175956,
0.0301190689,
0.01706375,
0.0240373667,
0.0135133024,
0.0202349033,
0.0233837012,
0.0084153702,
-0.0724430531,
0.0140169542,
0.0004057366,
0.1055136025,
0.0203616954,
-0.0169783924,
0.0299247578,
0.0224290807,
0.0076547093,
-0.0065321587,
-0.0411919057,
-0.0020007363,
-0.0040239291,
-0.034943793,
-0.0199910235,
-0.0003601992,
0.0102068679,
0.0124546392,
-0.0457430631,
0.0586653315,
0.018744342,
-0.0094838748,
0.020067215,
-0.0007248234,
-0.0066755908,
-0.0486007817,
-0.0334726013,
0.088418819,
-0.0254445709,
0.045943372,
-0.0242438167,
0.0000469989,
0.0428250358,
-0.0402719006,
0.0006661849,
0.0503929593,
-0.0026808996,
0.0997792855,
-0.0521279275,
0.0364281163,
-0.0032154894,
-0.002146956,
-0.0264095888,
-0.0497580059,
-0.068189539,
-0.0319943614,
-0.038432043,
0.0557845831,
-0.0372068472,
-0.028359415,
-0.0122223767,
0.0594357476,
0.0228133537,
0.0132961245,
0.0262929592,
0.04124384,
-0.0090738367,
0.0054717287,
-0.0632497445,
0.0540201776,
-0.0545597263,
-0.0001509154,
-0.0006414087,
-0.0645988882,
-0.0204746127,
0.006646107,
0.0036245496,
-0.0539666787,
0.0104026431,
0.0544096567,
0.0081448331,
-0.0207928885,
-0.0678628683,
-0.0494128615,
0.0129418317,
-0.0368729755,
-0.009238204,
-0.0976370126,
0.0496754013,
0.0097889453,
-0.0217017066,
-0.0191925708,
0.0172334202,
0.0337147713,
-0.0175357219,
0.0806241333,
-0.051837109,
0.0101209059,
0.0456909388,
-0.0015810061,
-0.0239307862,
0.1145767793,
0.0024947117,
-0.0083542131,
0.0289509222,
-0.0050184075,
-0.0125782825,
0.0339579508,
0.0214255396,
0.0018469299,
0.0010630848,
0.070099093,
-0.0193411838,
0.016783921,
0.0305691455,
-0.0007241811,
-0.0122340033,
-0.0160792191,
0.0027671254,
0.072894983,
-0.0183831956,
0.0218445472,
0.0475286841,
0.0332837701,
0.0211800579,
-0.030371733,
-0.0490588769,
0.0658615753,
-0.0354446284,
0.0008292928,
-0.0098389201,
0.0415427312,
-0.0536163151,
-0.0066244463,
-0.0009532271,
-0.0001688095,
-0.0277678929,
0.0413128771,
0.0618898384,
0.0330677256,
-0.0200645179,
0.1090219617,
0.0004359448,
-0.016627742,
0.0019719324,
-0.0181855205,
0.0329661183,
0.0667818785,
0.0304250512,
-0.0414113961,
-0.0577764027,
-0.0215664804,
0.0217611827,
0.0236716494,
0.0220630076,
-0.0202751569,
0.0083136251,
-0.0207411721,
-0.028461149,
-0.0301172864,
0.0127886934,
-0.0073627527,
0.0469799414,
0.0214099996,
0.0267516226,
-0.0732754245,
0.0270067491,
0.0345974378,
-0.0382351242,
-0.0421575978,
0.0086053861,
0.0068683168,
0.0094235986,
0.0303650796,
0.0105378153,
0.0211090706,
0.043772608,
-0.0183930974,
-0.0418246873,
-0.0329266079,
0.0271976031,
-0.0931468457,
0.0467076898,
0.0034981456,
-0.020314388,
0.0061000092,
-0.0770305097,
-0.0361331701,
0.0029507868,
-0.0156627409,
0.0134100886,
-0.050008975,
-0.0535777099,
0.0451273397,
-0.0225864891,
-0.0528273359,
0.05981379,
0.0115274778,
0.0145802461,
-0.0066688554,
-0.0134767191,
0.0237087309,
-0.0374069698,
0.0045548324,
-0.0536916442,
-0.0193391498,
0.0056305896,
-0.009437657,
0.0040389639,
-0.0758081079,
0.0162717607,
-0.1028526425,
0.0354063138,
-0.0161142424,
0.0288866572,
0.0312879309,
0.0327324942,
0.0048151487,
-0.0188849978,
-0.058471702,
-0.0170454029,
0.0042427774,
0.0245037507,
0.0410746709,
0.0248540957,
0.010012107,
-0.0102870055,
0.0008497693,
-0.0262118876,
0.0397740081,
-0.0300808437,
-0.0042965668,
-0.0283049308,
-0.0126605034,
-0.0488159135,
0.0170618799,
0.0075738863,
-0.007224936,
-0.0153585523,
-0.0269717406,
-0.0127769886,
0.0441594347,
-0.0163000133,
-0.0258591715,
0.0047439965,
0.0126390755,
-0.0728569552,
0.0417638347,
0.0191120412,
-0.0163276643,
-0.0195230264,
-0.0103574814,
0.0257732756,
0.0284902006,
-0.0086428626,
-0.0045117051,
-0.0444398895,
0.0496038683,
0.0258385781,
-0.0117305405,
-0.0562731177,
0.0388763361,
0.0173997674,
0.0226631463,
-0.0171666089,
0.0332594588,
0.0642550141,
0.0052138846,
-0.0069421753,
-0.0113200098,
0.0132448291,
-0.0552940294,
0.0454722531,
-0.0317335539,
0.0111160856,
-0.0195449349,
0.000451692,
-0.0338649005,
-0.0122964,
-0.0104826661,
-0.029704174,
0.0326813608,
-0.0382283032,
0.0406682938,
-0.0094791418,
-0.0107310386,
-0.0276440065,
-0.0127261886,
-0.0589140169,
0.0155397467,
-0.026264701,
0.0256075338,
0.0217584278,
0.0031903612,
-0.0102620292,
0.0107169375,
-0.0114878789,
-0.0088834083,
-0.0182588156,
0.044870194,
0.0757289156,
0.0154243372,
0.0162418373,
0.0397486947,
0.0209666528,
0.0535027012,
0.0136078764,
-0.0133012459,
-0.0156570468,
-0.0012232462,
0.0151239708,
-0.0607008487,
0.0026781559,
0.002580947,
0.0510950796,
-0.0539072379,
-0.0090677273,
0.1199773997,
0.0327555202,
0.0196571238,
-0.0181602966,
-0.0292298254,
0.0326196998,
0.0543461666,
0.0643027201,
-0.1253726482,
-0.0798804238,
-0.0320479833,
0.0363467745,
0.0206243936,
-0.0410001688,
-0.0010609237,
-0.1229472086,
0.0162328314,
-0.0239684209,
-0.0595351271,
0.0050007859,
-0.0398529954,
-0.0020709771,
-0.0362271294,
-0.0130686713,
0.0227619689,
-0.0166599471,
0.0234722886,
0.0130251972,
0.0042487816,
-0.0365988426,
0.0528283194,
-0.0390685834,
0.0365374163,
0.0310311858,
0.0116598438,
0.0064874026,
0.0058625857,
-0.0080841705,
-0.0366412625,
0.0175776891,
-0.0141847143,
0.0585970916,
-0.0114869392,
-0.0241580196,
-0.0143307624,
0.020983573,
-0.0726133138,
0.0130039211,
0.0314991586,
0.0834371373,
-0.004438011,
0.0070754644,
-0.0161500648,
-0.0321398675,
-0.0137541965,
0.0921083316,
0.0277118441,
0.00389429,
-0.0586753935,
-0.0076696635,
-0.0564622767,
-0.0580884703,
-0.0402372479,
0.0238861665,
-0.0003184534,
0.0155435568,
-0.0655386522,
-0.033145763,
0.1006049588,
0.0347399712,
-0.0231388193,
0.0207005497,
-0.0203687288,
0.0421659686,
-0.044669766,
0.0291623734,
-0.0677016526,
0.0101255449,
-0.0097090052,
-0.0139897503,
0.0306073688,
-0.0128502604,
-0.0236205868,
-0.0089526167,
-0.079527624,
-0.0327936709,
-0.0298226848,
0.0658015385,
0.0179901067,
0.0083615389,
-0.0399628542,
-0.0520993546,
0.0476484001,
0.0453888886,
-0.0614860095,
-0.0188645124,
0.0141169215,
0.0139205363,
-0.0122767137,
0.0464255698,
-0.1061196104,
-0.0369223021,
-0.0328155011,
0.0616979897,
-0.0474603772,
-0.0322904252,
0.033270184,
0.0062684678,
-0.0280457102,
0.0199391507,
0.0097980443,
0.0208939184,
0.0243895184,
-0.0046694442,
-0.0358429477,
-0.0355414562,
0.022616202,
0.0046617873,
-0.0395470671,
0.0199525338,
-0.0220130179,
-0.0324969925,
0.0445354618,
-0.018384302,
-0.0524172857,
0.0674695224,
-0.0111200856,
0.0214206539,
-0.014578687,
-0.0414240435,
0.0198037978,
0.0075032897,
0.0364356227,
-0.0329088308,
0.0294408202,
0.0166596789,
0.0157160703,
-0.0301508624,
0.0036117777,
-0.0424371772,
-0.0859917775,
-0.0067608296,
0.0207784232,
0.0531258881,
0.0223035868,
0.0167548321,
0.0081616826,
-0.040622659,
0.0022253988,
-0.0168919936,
-0.007994297,
0.0177291539,
0.0563704297,
0.0442668423,
-0.0261554495,
-0.0143190725,
0.0848624483,
0.0300430525,
0.0616110526,
0.0104229376,
-0.0133708091,
-0.038827002,
-0.0460140184,
0.0172286369,
0.0216356944,
-0.0162822213,
-0.0041901735,
-0.0399066471,
-0.0758242384,
0.0135641554,
-0.0318046212,
-0.0404084921,
0.0004497155,
0.0574014597,
0.0542549603,
0.034591265,
-0.0435809828,
-0.0366785564,
0.0250637699,
-0.0184659474,
-0.0370943435,
0.004069245,
-6.405431817e-33,
-0.0299196411,
-0.0192662291,
0.0372523069,
-0.03421624,
0.0018195426,
-0.0352254845,
-0.0193062928,
-0.0209696647,
-0.0480707511,
-0.0132723348,
0.0043812748,
0.0012241275,
0.0020017498,
0.0181132164,
0.0132222762,
-0.0459463485,
0.0063227876,
-0.003816491,
0.010857149,
0.0147804432,
0.0330536552,
0.045801077,
0.0220002849,
0.0061494694,
-0.0005680039,
-0.0177060924,
0.0022069814,
0.0575297512,
-0.0042892927,
0.0717221126,
-0.0138441958,
0.0233541299,
0.0218740758,
-0.028128922,
0.0121115511,
-0.0139305657,
-0.1081236526,
-0.0238749515,
0.0301644504,
-0.0053665694,
-0.0130570699,
-0.0175520647,
0.0391014405,
-0.022066135,
0.0548067354,
-0.0183944311,
0.0422201678,
-0.023197962,
-0.0022733749,
-0.0787693188,
-0.0232991409,
0.0065613273,
-0.0239954963,
-0.0115843415,
-0.0340068601,
0.0423049033,
-0.0147403236,
0.0496908762,
-0.0360002965,
-0.0135963419,
0.0005995005,
0.0266245529,
0.0690544397,
0.0149686635,
0.0122201834,
-0.0038156947,
-0.0089136558,
-0.0275927708,
-0.0160632208,
0.002321525,
-0.0116965668,
0.0449261814,
0.0382985957,
0.0736726224,
0.0390783399,
0.0291849636,
-0.0816411823,
0.0314156972,
0.0048153745,
0.0323329829,
-0.0116204126,
-0.0051200404,
-0.0064658909,
-0.0167383123,
-0.0549938418,
0.0342941955,
-0.0505323149,
-0.0213425551,
0.0540472306,
-0.006858835,
-0.0184532553,
0.0061565535,
0.028625736,
-0.055211138,
0.0037668936,
0.0382162146,
0.0044210977,
0.0026521536,
0.0145138493,
0.0477993935,
-0.0381740294,
0.0139000285,
0.0350998417,
-0.0264073871,
0.0027394642,
0.0341642499,
0.0182792637,
-0.0068968609,
-0.0445656888,
-0.0153431483,
-0.0489772372,
0.0144255375,
-0.0317955762,
0.0374109037,
-0.0053896648,
0.0362023041,
-0.0116788168,
0.0399289466,
0.0116878161,
-0.0082171513,
-0.0068370863,
-0.0086718174,
0.0041823676,
-0.0044948622,
-0.0293276496,
-0.001296029,
-0.0185119268,
0.0289744865,
-0.0528462566,
-0.0516843945,
-0.0169624239,
0.0176366568,
2.7e-7,
0.0651305914,
0.0168328006,
-0.0024631147,
0.0326451324,
0.0048256381,
0.0190592445,
0.0060861404,
0.0407608077,
0.0265984908,
-0.0596532412,
-0.0042135632,
0.0348782688,
0.0110146068,
0.0303090923,
-0.0957520455,
0.0026605364,
-0.0159095693,
-0.0278976224,
-0.0637074113,
-0.032074891,
0.0433714278,
0.0631721765,
0.0251924712,
-0.0054716761,
0.008846852,
-0.0488114581,
0.0440663807,
0.0222775005,
-0.0178255364,
0.025599936,
0.0192551427,
0.0283615701,
0.0004870133,
0.0263191685,
-0.0069169374,
0.0267724581,
0.0067714308,
0.0772479326,
-0.0274001062,
-0.0467207693,
-0.0231244527,
-0.0767004341,
0.0547667108,
-0.0471333973,
0.1093458757,
-0.0737691894,
0.0130799124,
0.0287685785,
-0.0509123951,
-0.0096526351,
-0.0117750764,
-0.0224266406,
0.0112053826,
0.0032980628,
0.0213212408,
-0.0109573882,
-0.0099494243,
-0.0774885416,
0.0076421141,
0.0205700714,
-0.03008339,
-0.0218033232,
-0.0184299592,
-0.0031504331,
-0.0155104063,
-0.0416908711,
0.0163140837,
2.515654338e-34,
0.0093192011,
0.0353246145,
0.0181900132,
0.0612595156,
0.0284212064,
-0.0022595017,
-0.0466717035,
-0.0219063982,
0.0362106562,
-0.0676173344,
0.0198416989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12050v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12050v2 | Aligning Language Models with Offline Learning from Human Feedback | 2023-08-23T10:41:07 | 2023-12-10T03:27:10 | Jian Hu, Li Tao, June Yang, Chandler Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Learning from human preferences is crucial for language models (LMs) to
effectively cater to human needs and societal values. Previous research has
made notable progress by leveraging human feedback to follow instructions.
However, these approaches rely primarily on online learning techniques like
Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO), which have been proven unstable and
challenging to tune for language models. Moreover, PPO requires complex
distributed system implementation, hindering the efficiency of large-scale
distributed training. In this study, we propose an offline learning from human
feedback framework to align LMs without interacting with environments.
Specifically, we explore filtering alignment (FA), reward-weighted regression
(RWR), and conditional alignment (CA) to align language models to human
preferences. By employing a loss function similar to supervised fine-tuning,
our methods ensure more stable model training than PPO with a simple machine
learning system~(MLSys) and much fewer (around 9\%) computing resources.
Experimental results demonstrate that conditional alignment outperforms other
offline alignment methods and is comparable to PPO. | [
0.0362297297,
0.0832059532,
-0.0049931379,
0.0056208037,
-0.0213707592,
0.0086817145,
-0.0098785404,
-0.0062755998,
-0.0133892596,
0.0172131602,
-0.0347772874,
-0.041893892,
0.019498935,
0.0169383902,
0.0152258212,
-0.052934926,
0.0378750041,
-0.0004345488,
0.0189742055,
-0.029411098,
0.0445158556,
0.0343503356,
-0.006255745,
0.0425476134,
0.0242450088,
-0.006214241,
-0.0021039459,
0.0180233195,
0.0369980596,
0.0129825613,
0.0387753248,
0.0336863883,
0.0176366027,
0.0122335348,
0.0000018478,
-0.0373461172,
-0.0107229361,
-0.0204784404,
0.0148119982,
-0.0263963677,
0.0470396392,
0.009684965,
-0.029750431,
0.0256441981,
-0.0237541571,
0.0332483016,
0.0770384222,
0.0062210434,
0.0414524265,
0.0588803589,
0.006745745,
-0.0094961273,
-0.014281719,
-0.0303602647,
-0.0176196136,
-0.0192653928,
0.0228944011,
-0.0178770591,
-0.0261881445,
-0.0650370046,
-0.0165733043,
0.0131451273,
-0.0138067827,
0.0156461261,
0.0151775414,
0.022367496,
-0.0136779472,
-0.0605504066,
-0.0106642088,
0.0923242569,
-0.0328481868,
-0.0498100035,
0.0106277838,
-0.0443123206,
-0.011619539,
0.0017687527,
0.0001563756,
-0.0139818471,
0.0024878492,
0.0524666384,
-0.0071872836,
-0.0397549011,
0.0306707229,
0.0419509746,
-0.0018220947,
0.0991168469,
0.0086592389,
-0.042688556,
-0.0000133092,
0.004606836,
-0.0576437712,
-0.0251704101,
0.0234092157,
0.0084672552,
-0.0654049069,
0.0165906455,
-0.0605191253,
0.0105919829,
-0.0078763738,
-0.0227848943,
0.0572853908,
0.0546217188,
0.0369908288,
0.0328995548,
0.0335160904,
0.0795948133,
-0.0159598757,
0.0040812632,
-0.0259768348,
0.0333776288,
-0.0377127975,
0.0014911687,
0.0097881062,
0.0241652764,
-0.035710495,
-0.0105072455,
-0.0354568474,
0.0241708197,
-0.0288781747,
0.0542613566,
0.011941676,
0.0247891378,
-0.056857124,
-0.0172365922,
-0.0342465974,
0.078462325,
-0.022174608,
0.0160600785,
0.0047871508,
-0.0058164489,
0.027616322,
0.0222143661,
-0.0035403844,
0.0001697601,
0.0050620819,
0.0672448277,
-0.0078683244,
0.0111960135,
-0.007329402,
-0.0043473667,
-0.019664932,
-0.0607153215,
-0.0503181703,
-0.0510918349,
0.0128228571,
-0.0226344559,
-0.0118486276,
-0.0914293975,
0.0052575227,
0.0081563871,
-0.0275791753,
0.0394049436,
0.0082458491,
0.0079313833,
0.033965189,
-0.044901289,
-0.0048631718,
0.0728781,
0.0535611585,
0.0204358716,
0.0206440296,
-0.007590231,
-0.0256167371,
0.0556214638,
0.0365801044,
0.0300167743,
-0.0823785067,
0.0008504279,
0.0161925294,
0.0549742989,
0.0489674918,
0.0361633375,
0.0075205127,
0.0255255811,
0.0998508185,
0.0316565335,
-0.0033761598,
-0.001386075,
-0.0184967779,
0.0793454498,
-0.0406247079,
-0.0161321703,
-0.0589411072,
0.0159942247,
-0.0078081992,
0.0288630445,
0.0295095034,
0.0622421727,
-0.0220715124,
-0.035274528,
-0.0044852393,
-0.0170887578,
0.0007797672,
0.0304935053,
0.0601746663,
-0.0296976846,
-0.0338012427,
0.0195716824,
0.0604633205,
-0.0231516175,
0.0207539704,
-0.0279362202,
0.0415594615,
0.0886945873,
0.0406730436,
0.0008194887,
0.0000803458,
-0.0198786147,
0.0020360104,
0.0588990189,
0.0239944775,
-0.0251616351,
-0.0078121969,
-0.0529951416,
-0.0410353839,
0.0738689005,
-0.0036644344,
0.0107676573,
0.0387457013,
-0.0155563997,
0.0007512536,
0.0128485644,
-0.0728546605,
0.0356222615,
-0.0263338219,
-0.0194008704,
-0.0197894033,
0.0336593911,
0.0188951585,
-0.0111412564,
-0.0017473273,
-0.0122967735,
-0.0012982362,
-0.0018019715,
0.0139844147,
-0.0125677055,
-0.0359895527,
-0.0088702757,
0.0578633547,
0.0013387173,
-0.0108747492,
0.0743809715,
-0.0327343568,
-0.0268262755,
-0.0235406812,
-0.0154319713,
0.042660065,
-0.0138212545,
0.0256293695,
-0.0307913795,
-0.0291846897,
-0.0690547153,
0.0191793423,
-0.0164418444,
0.0325875655,
-0.0113003682,
-0.0163510069,
-0.0120471306,
-0.0614144802,
-0.0258505363,
0.0100822952,
-0.0207490288,
0.0381121822,
0.0506126173,
0.0504304655,
-0.0421222895,
-0.0105784135,
-0.0281318091,
-0.0024224096,
-0.0237485096,
0.0131458109,
0.0174086913,
-0.0010460367,
-0.0206799898,
-0.0552311875,
-0.0375872068,
0.0060578305,
-0.0221104827,
0.0176868252,
0.0405724719,
-0.0070527038,
-0.0434371531,
-0.0666955486,
-0.0024927366,
0.0068434658,
-0.0178174563,
-0.0260965675,
0.0152261034,
-0.0487795137,
0.0010478587,
-0.0590936095,
0.0241651963,
0.0126877148,
-0.0438492969,
-0.0007805616,
0.0124548664,
0.0210350323,
0.0999778435,
0.0144326715,
0.0178298689,
0.0569079109,
0.0530840494,
-0.0820454881,
-0.005511438,
-0.0557469688,
-0.0470735133,
-0.0438668504,
-0.0025183177,
-0.0060185031,
0.0782811269,
-0.004689733,
0.0192187596,
-0.092166014,
0.0223420355,
-0.0142057501,
-0.0169382263,
-0.0463744067,
0.0156817939,
-0.0622555502,
0.0169606116,
-0.0368589498,
-0.107801035,
0.0944004282,
0.003455899,
-0.0038441571,
-0.0329615995,
-0.0355149731,
0.0205322318,
-0.0196987223,
-0.0017045041,
0.0312550366,
-0.0427363627,
-0.0212078001,
-0.0863019153,
-0.0411535874,
0.0580686107,
-0.0522302538,
0.0110760089,
-0.0479698442,
0.0199513175,
0.0049966616,
-0.0610255636,
-0.0412352011,
-0.0714787543,
-0.0267147515,
-0.0190208834,
-0.0075111189,
-0.0424976498,
-0.0232934412,
0.0163327698,
0.0203978121,
0.0214405134,
-0.0119562009,
0.0036003354,
-0.0245419927,
-0.0154606821,
0.1167935953,
0.0175346844,
-0.0334210768,
-0.0317163169,
-0.0024549705,
0.0163311549,
0.0768458098,
-0.0218589492,
0.0098505327,
0.0060579432,
0.060493499,
-0.013580041,
0.0221142694,
0.0546663366,
0.0325023308,
-0.0158952903,
-0.0004358465,
0.0895320922,
0.019601237,
-0.0867170766,
0.0031054958,
-0.0073356209,
0.0898222923,
0.0227535125,
0.034963198,
-0.013978675,
-0.0223023985,
0.0222490486,
0.0874690488,
0.0017318253,
0.01149558,
-0.0204742942,
-0.1020237803,
-0.0441735648,
0.0325109735,
-0.0389891528,
-0.0220606644,
-0.0179338921,
0.0257024597,
-0.0386804529,
0.0361845605,
0.0144598177,
0.0038392597,
-0.0120214308,
0.0153808277,
-0.0133493645,
-0.0510719642,
-0.0054418561,
-0.0422846302,
0.0657424703,
0.113456443,
0.025190929,
0.021874547,
-0.0548375994,
0.0489361696,
0.0398685224,
-0.01800346,
-0.0153418053,
-0.0227393713,
-0.0317758657,
-0.0032217701,
-0.0218220539,
0.0627902076,
-0.0157541316,
0.0042251158,
0.0018750397,
0.0656643212,
-0.0047756569,
0.0298889801,
0.0184484124,
0.0109972944,
0.0554722995,
0.0557183884,
0.0010882941,
-0.0881463662,
-0.0008796157,
-0.0158465356,
-0.0517978035,
0.0169844516,
-0.0332074538,
-0.0301340893,
-0.036586687,
0.0098038334,
-0.0513917617,
-0.0283113327,
-0.0096643092,
0.0501396321,
0.0191447698,
-0.0247062612,
0.0299270134,
0.0001671814,
-0.0174563527,
0.0302468929,
-0.042935431,
0.018500749,
-0.0498783737,
-0.0154849095,
0.0088897776,
-0.0216709748,
-0.0116166724,
-0.0285263136,
-0.0828680843,
-0.1095821559,
0.0060680094,
0.0343174078,
0.0213425271,
0.0742092878,
-0.0015997555,
-0.0646441504,
0.0419036336,
0.043364279,
-0.029060008,
0.0208178684,
0.0173425507,
-0.0076505891,
-0.0063549895,
0.0434697159,
-0.024190899,
-0.0119743804,
0.0130600063,
0.0433956012,
0.0053272829,
-0.0394154862,
0.0157901086,
-0.0118795494,
0.0567435734,
-0.0515580401,
-0.0932963714,
-0.0410370678,
0.0130293332,
0.0326873288,
-0.0242163558,
-0.0080103083,
-0.0393904671,
0.036214713,
-0.0046452251,
0.0144964494,
-0.0022400329,
0.0162370913,
0.0149605442,
-0.0059628738,
-0.0069719902,
-0.0249711648,
0.0258203465,
0.0614426062,
0.0283372253,
-0.0141713517,
0.0379896313,
0.0103884609,
0.0395714901,
-0.0069968393,
0.0489426665,
0.0471080877,
0.0288064573,
-0.0060699414,
0.0062524867,
-0.0081708524,
-0.0338101611,
-0.0660020933,
-0.00986451,
0.0533277243,
-0.0249155238,
0.0597317256,
-0.01702342,
-0.0116936853,
-0.0319158994,
0.0229474436,
-0.0431920812,
-0.0133694187,
0.0220376831,
0.0035261738,
-0.0352419354,
0.0272024125,
0.0576296337,
0.0324554853,
-0.0080766557,
-0.0415147841,
0.0367540866,
-0.0274997689,
0.0040021725,
-0.0001760146,
0.0309090912,
-0.050926961,
-0.0169684514,
-0.0161598306,
-0.0484534688,
-0.0456599519,
0.0391808338,
-0.0439898707,
-0.0319961756,
0.0478429608,
0.0386744216,
-0.0673387647,
0.0095330942,
-0.0504965372,
-0.0045305709,
-0.0141979968,
-0.0075058555,
-0.0378125943,
-6.475396507e-33,
-0.0342642106,
-0.0422938652,
0.0135384565,
0.0084201954,
-0.0481133126,
-0.0488850698,
-0.0001094225,
0.0142412949,
0.0122586731,
-0.0070887371,
-0.0073140394,
0.0051378715,
0.0183366388,
0.0070221466,
0.020766668,
-0.0034834854,
0.0331546739,
-0.0227324329,
-0.049884893,
0.0029592826,
0.026734747,
0.0175476857,
0.0083079292,
-0.0430075675,
0.0357808545,
0.0094848266,
-0.0307981633,
0.0328098051,
-0.0036739507,
0.0548342168,
0.0037182686,
0.0226664878,
0.0009690975,
-0.0079773152,
-0.0015950352,
0.0248006564,
-0.0325034,
-0.0096278135,
0.0133001134,
0.0073714582,
-0.002723647,
-0.009694621,
0.0421253182,
-0.0159634836,
-0.0444874875,
0.0338753276,
0.0409276187,
-0.0300859977,
-0.0451685078,
0.0347504653,
-0.064388819,
0.0073675704,
-0.0096020503,
0.0032396161,
0.0161825344,
0.0292269625,
0.0025924824,
0.026734272,
-0.0421678089,
0.0374849364,
-0.0222848654,
0.0502217561,
0.1269460469,
0.0542204231,
0.0076006171,
0.0288965311,
0.0069082733,
-0.0158227216,
0.0135776065,
-0.0172987469,
0.0639945492,
-0.0127957622,
0.0124144861,
0.0375571661,
0.002906902,
-0.0136940368,
0.0020540692,
0.0171000678,
-0.0182616301,
0.0259158816,
0.0245031323,
0.0412621088,
-0.0602979958,
-0.0323865861,
-0.0372606814,
-0.0255861077,
-0.0266995318,
-0.0344118662,
0.0204943046,
0.0219159499,
-0.0307365004,
-0.0246245861,
0.0068149404,
-0.0354367755,
-0.0226605441,
-0.0023280685,
-0.0102193346,
-0.0167090092,
0.0008809901,
0.0183909032,
-0.1075034738,
-0.0375153534,
-0.047778517,
-0.0125085218,
-0.00476069,
0.0171625782,
0.0165461414,
0.0093471557,
-0.0680289045,
0.0185567643,
-0.0209289771,
0.0021584795,
0.002581381,
0.0324595943,
0.071874693,
-0.0304045305,
0.0030324177,
0.074309431,
0.0141509539,
-0.0289411433,
-0.0180644616,
-0.0324087106,
-0.0234663598,
0.019776443,
-0.0358853154,
0.0082013914,
-0.0352503769,
0.0271586943,
0.0111891963,
-0.0159411225,
-0.0095052971,
-0.0024095122,
2.507e-7,
-0.0016335092,
0.0480511598,
0.0279203448,
-0.0068229991,
-0.0149894273,
0.047354769,
-0.0233898181,
0.0070335725,
0.0042147869,
-0.001778346,
0.0393364131,
0.0077253897,
0.0934742242,
-0.0152702658,
-0.0853444561,
0.0302192457,
-0.0672833994,
0.0483473167,
-0.0378110111,
0.0097980192,
0.0097803967,
0.0815378875,
0.0393774062,
-0.0072160754,
0.0156294797,
0.0163154565,
0.0485218801,
-0.0367410108,
-0.0141075822,
-0.0244573019,
-0.000282928,
-0.0233301669,
-0.0341310389,
-0.0024875039,
-0.0116341254,
0.0286904257,
-0.0501573309,
0.0895489901,
-0.0096577983,
-0.0245191045,
-0.021860119,
0.0428464711,
0.0074144006,
-0.037455041,
0.0439774133,
-0.0526337214,
0.0072927838,
-0.0124674458,
0.0356556512,
-0.0288381651,
0.0221019983,
-0.0394060314,
-0.0322261341,
-0.0063852686,
0.0335690975,
0.0051813642,
-0.022513235,
-0.0377442203,
-0.0324036703,
0.0179970637,
-0.0276657604,
-0.0775798708,
-0.0265779477,
0.0503689088,
0.0045895125,
-0.0294357799,
0.0117794983,
2.128770678e-34,
0.0224542357,
-0.0148381628,
0.0219349507,
-0.0040335348,
0.0008112811,
0.0108865984,
0.0073868092,
0.0085262945,
0.045440387,
-0.0732714906,
0.0014164948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12045v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12045v1 | CgT-GAN: CLIP-guided Text GAN for Image Captioning | 2023-08-23T10:25:37 | 2023-08-23T10:25:37 | Jiarui Yu, Haoran Li, Yanbin Hao, Bin Zhu, Tong Xu, Xiangnan He | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM | The large-scale visual-language pre-trained model, Contrastive Language-Image
Pre-training (CLIP), has significantly improved image captioning for scenarios
without human-annotated image-caption pairs. Recent advanced CLIP-based image
captioning without human annotations follows a text-only training paradigm,
i.e., reconstructing text from shared embedding space. Nevertheless, these
approaches are limited by the training/inference gap or huge storage
requirements for text embeddings. Given that it is trivial to obtain images in
the real world, we propose CLIP-guided text GAN (CgT-GAN), which incorporates
images into the training process to enable the model to "see" real visual
modality. Particularly, we use adversarial training to teach CgT-GAN to mimic
the phrases of an external text corpus and CLIP-based reward to provide
semantic guidance. The caption generator is jointly rewarded based on the
caption naturalness to human language calculated from the GAN's discriminator
and the semantic guidance reward computed by the CLIP-based reward module. In
addition to the cosine similarity as the semantic guidance reward (i.e.,
CLIP-cos), we further introduce a novel semantic guidance reward called
CLIP-agg, which aligns the generated caption with a weighted text embedding by
attentively aggregating the entire corpus. Experimental results on three
subtasks (ZS-IC, In-UIC and Cross-UIC) show that CgT-GAN outperforms
state-of-the-art methods significantly across all metrics. Code is available at
https://github.com/Lihr747/CgtGAN. | [
0.0339360461,
0.070270665,
0.0217873137,
0.0292843748,
0.0031188063,
0.0085655116,
-0.0045309607,
0.006088133,
-0.0198185388,
-0.0253504086,
-0.0610755198,
-0.0145759331,
-0.0213125981,
0.041088514,
0.0396236628,
-0.0590127222,
0.028821297,
-0.0057785632,
-0.0106292563,
-0.0011951172,
0.0412111282,
0.0097293556,
-0.0005045769,
0.040660277,
-0.0161072798,
-0.0020867267,
-0.002487134,
0.0124370521,
0.033838056,
-0.0384592786,
0.0085474309,
0.0454975292,
0.0693071932,
-0.0021200459,
0.0000018556,
0.0170994941,
0.0221619215,
0.0132603785,
0.0134002259,
0.0132363373,
0.0603007339,
-0.0280874632,
0.0066186553,
0.0103773922,
-0.0257263351,
-0.0408301353,
0.0668371171,
0.0814052448,
0.0801398382,
0.0517063551,
-0.0279061683,
-0.0493273437,
-0.0130220316,
-0.089143157,
0.0105221048,
-0.0412096307,
-0.0284468327,
0.0834107399,
-0.0120610073,
0.01758839,
-0.0216894764,
0.0532428324,
0.0229683798,
-0.0291944724,
0.0091692917,
0.0942141563,
-0.0239527952,
0.0033278298,
-0.021713838,
0.0749386624,
-0.0012717281,
0.000191557,
-0.0305717941,
-0.0063941171,
-0.0032936656,
-0.0199008454,
-0.0350233093,
0.0214354265,
0.0274848845,
0.0336575434,
-0.0286740214,
0.0468906537,
0.0025249987,
0.0021097478,
0.0092044119,
-0.0606081411,
0.0251742695,
0.0387815051,
-0.0201295149,
0.0268645361,
-0.0837205052,
-0.0583787858,
0.0086947922,
-0.0007284057,
-0.0187603049,
-0.0131607186,
-0.0500926524,
-0.0133614019,
-0.0013057524,
-0.0045195655,
0.0262547638,
0.009616442,
-0.047621686,
0.0637604669,
-0.0234273039,
0.0337793827,
0.0049723,
0.0232490711,
-0.0442210957,
-0.0132414186,
-0.0029516544,
-0.0265716184,
-0.0555014871,
-0.0058662058,
-0.0644369647,
-0.0764952824,
-0.0424506217,
-0.0314738937,
-0.0280990135,
0.0331033729,
0.0108565297,
0.0641708896,
-0.0454354808,
0.0070216381,
-0.012516587,
-0.0174406841,
-0.029749563,
0.0044669658,
0.0006122955,
-0.0167151596,
-0.0290428363,
0.0431962647,
0.0279726628,
-0.0184860528,
0.0168503504,
0.0814475715,
-0.0656986311,
-0.0134061575,
0.0034567027,
-0.0187227167,
-0.0565910526,
-0.0341173671,
0.000617909,
-0.0146257179,
0.0146326404,
-0.0347625874,
-0.0248777159,
-0.0579572879,
0.0054860665,
0.0194821991,
0.0348725803,
0.1102386937,
0.0291685816,
-0.0443801992,
0.0050443006,
0.0398194529,
-0.0164833125,
0.0250242483,
0.0248619113,
0.0655881688,
0.0093016988,
0.0394435711,
0.028047191,
0.018039722,
0.0431344807,
0.0117802713,
-0.0229362119,
-0.006862381,
0.0033066447,
0.0256127305,
0.0704028308,
0.0622106306,
-0.0502673313,
-0.0042055855,
0.0708521754,
0.0411508121,
-0.0201853178,
0.0363370627,
0.0301644728,
0.0605217442,
-0.0086439392,
-0.0159036256,
-0.0481067672,
0.0779108033,
0.0106297219,
-0.006242421,
0.0292796884,
0.0191922691,
-0.0408982486,
-0.039278537,
0.0125594353,
-0.0173944887,
-0.0016429734,
-0.0251244977,
0.0287502874,
0.0123243807,
-0.0575908199,
-0.0153153352,
0.0104791084,
-0.0208451245,
0.0009546276,
0.0015167032,
0.0211764667,
0.0319553055,
0.0452915281,
0.0030937011,
-0.031054236,
0.0156304911,
-0.0008526096,
0.0536872409,
0.0179130789,
-0.0005773963,
0.0032001752,
-0.032679826,
-0.0363287926,
-0.0321499184,
-0.0037969113,
0.0537216254,
0.0208135583,
0.0185687803,
0.0442300849,
0.0299225394,
-0.0595148392,
0.0366229713,
0.0285301469,
-0.0251949225,
-0.0078230007,
-0.0077313776,
0.0050062048,
-0.0076647392,
-0.0642579272,
0.0090436768,
0.0004871883,
-0.0288527422,
-0.0509120151,
0.0479073673,
-0.0779371411,
-0.0928454474,
-0.0155919539,
-0.0832825676,
1.819e-7,
0.007134079,
-0.0412843451,
-0.0189384017,
0.0141692692,
-0.0341547281,
-0.007288516,
-0.0972123742,
-0.0186817572,
0.0400032997,
0.0215067547,
0.0076877386,
0.0543354377,
-0.0070240069,
-0.0296715703,
0.0532484017,
0.024186749,
0.0069746231,
-0.0288411546,
-0.0408472419,
-0.0147743886,
0.0199553221,
0.0252296198,
0.0268803034,
0.0453654975,
-0.0436520763,
0.0190743618,
-0.0722422898,
0.0006753061,
-0.002936098,
0.0073353895,
0.0294433143,
-0.0275410693,
0.0113129187,
-0.0300618783,
-0.0596166849,
-0.0184459537,
0.0243133828,
-0.0213063378,
0.0475786924,
0.0104434518,
0.0416236781,
-0.0511662997,
0.0260950793,
0.0333493389,
0.0616701916,
0.0218862034,
-0.0060039614,
-0.0367442667,
0.0361509435,
-0.0108328983,
0.0258005448,
-0.0287664067,
-0.0468961671,
-0.0224946775,
0.0192686338,
0.0157154445,
0.0252138637,
-0.0012372149,
0.0175947603,
0.0008799997,
0.0052261087,
-0.020176651,
-0.0015907459,
0.0085646547,
-0.0389022157,
0.026522968,
-0.0111475838,
-0.0156345349,
0.033689864,
-0.0017275757,
0.0354267694,
-0.0686912611,
0.0375189222,
-0.0261647515,
-0.0599666201,
-0.0433675237,
0.0393912047,
-0.0044564814,
-0.0412016697,
-0.0648417398,
-0.0523556732,
0.0384350754,
-0.0422550589,
-0.0657141581,
-0.0224208012,
-0.0022139603,
-0.0069715404,
0.070520483,
0.0086584548,
0.0314181931,
0.0177765749,
-0.0206365157,
-0.0295926873,
-0.0212491304,
0.0158807244,
-0.0160990022,
0.0357937887,
-0.0163763538,
0.001612438,
-0.0181662291,
-0.0472441539,
-0.039981056,
-0.0324331075,
-0.0122650322,
0.0154130626,
0.0298862886,
-0.0266242828,
0.0039629866,
0.0267196056,
0.0141508691,
0.0651411638,
-0.0221813321,
0.0024599619,
-0.0167542808,
0.0600641295,
0.0505590551,
0.0229199454,
-0.041647464,
-0.0228103139,
0.0022548963,
0.056338191,
-0.032804992,
-0.0035433832,
-0.0388068594,
0.008910819,
-0.0118099861,
0.0341952816,
0.009055973,
0.0170318875,
0.0691782087,
-0.0289925002,
-0.0263428763,
0.0725861564,
-0.0014255638,
-0.0357968733,
-0.0214010477,
0.0445461497,
0.0495366417,
0.0219328739,
0.0134200994,
-0.0878757238,
-0.0731660128,
-0.0260697398,
-0.0132599464,
0.0490091927,
0.0381223224,
-0.05647064,
-0.0687277988,
0.0327877998,
0.0122475373,
-0.0178843774,
-0.0314237438,
0.0418966711,
-0.0091231372,
-0.0138459112,
-0.0110268211,
-0.0272914004,
0.0074929022,
0.0186130535,
0.0273669008,
0.0037246649,
-0.0497582294,
-0.0066546574,
-0.0527457222,
0.0120266248,
0.0747702345,
0.0360862873,
-0.0042377436,
-0.0366366245,
-0.0060647186,
-0.011974683,
0.020544583,
0.0038612529,
0.0982813314,
-0.0241236854,
-0.0135845905,
0.0097764079,
0.0466271825,
-0.004301907,
-0.0088217398,
0.0244864728,
0.0015847869,
0.001952323,
-0.0129381381,
-0.0279122703,
0.0532297194,
0.0288402028,
0.0673311427,
0.0388273522,
-0.0284284353,
-0.0275717862,
-0.0117429467,
-0.0003640901,
-0.086952962,
-0.0370634608,
-0.0117838522,
0.0235887468,
-0.00079554,
-0.0845468491,
-0.0450543053,
0.0492457934,
0.0020217071,
0.0104949288,
-0.0320842378,
-0.0391745009,
0.0143732289,
-0.0386206955,
0.0162692945,
-0.0658167601,
0.009047145,
-0.0042350548,
-0.0051804227,
0.0570096672,
-0.0375180505,
-0.0484738834,
0.0456744991,
-0.0568686165,
-0.0191469211,
-0.051355958,
0.0729343519,
0.0020513872,
0.0516667813,
0.0034402527,
0.020766994,
0.0647063851,
0.0624486506,
0.0055293837,
0.0102461874,
0.0263870861,
-0.0046790419,
-0.0086052902,
0.0026322966,
-0.0130852945,
0.0469343588,
0.0024435341,
0.0280305669,
0.0256104041,
0.0221930202,
0.0095306328,
-0.0294162985,
0.01605694,
-0.0464426763,
0.0761934742,
-0.0573278889,
-0.009102813,
-0.0077983332,
-0.0094850613,
-0.0749409497,
0.0100335069,
0.0062539387,
0.030778164,
-0.0258596577,
0.0174930822,
0.0147162015,
0.0145797376,
-0.038179718,
-0.0273089539,
0.0310435612,
0.0014601479,
-0.024999816,
0.0178640224,
0.0094355764,
-0.0295769963,
-0.0354156159,
0.0176449362,
-0.0274996292,
0.0609157719,
0.0591200329,
-0.0439110845,
-0.0034476253,
0.0577805378,
-0.0046262075,
0.0095728934,
-0.0644645169,
0.0225128848,
0.0914286673,
-0.0211392324,
0.0260934755,
-0.0177389532,
-0.0055846716,
0.0110968621,
0.0279286336,
-0.0320194885,
-0.0527452864,
0.0343431942,
-0.011525346,
0.0129599292,
-0.0093663475,
0.0569657534,
0.0008250967,
0.0225281306,
-0.0120479781,
-0.0240153521,
-0.0357885994,
-0.0302245002,
0.0336752199,
-0.0203214157,
-0.0089888386,
0.0326104276,
-0.0075997012,
-0.0535454042,
-0.0284018554,
0.0290876403,
-0.0278365016,
0.0290820319,
0.0870602801,
0.0023199925,
0.0126234805,
-0.0193862151,
0.0036229531,
0.0005501513,
-0.0022890011,
0.0200015847,
-0.0148791485,
-5.756680893e-33,
-0.043035388,
-0.0307573993,
0.028040424,
-0.0375013053,
-0.0473480709,
0.012594481,
-0.075511232,
-0.0085722236,
0.0350807458,
0.0185425337,
0.0107054375,
-0.0016616494,
0.0126882177,
0.0437998772,
-0.0029677853,
0.0072354469,
0.0724965557,
-0.0094483746,
-0.02624874,
0.047830157,
0.0104522333,
0.004923482,
0.0557003878,
-0.0446930081,
0.0174962711,
-0.0108793899,
-0.0340369605,
-0.0003635516,
0.0503865406,
0.0194659196,
-0.0244811811,
-0.0205611121,
-0.0030226007,
-0.0314371027,
-0.0265629701,
-0.0061489465,
-0.0835009441,
-0.0228343606,
0.0097009735,
0.0030209031,
-0.0851851627,
-0.0034172432,
-0.0213377811,
-0.0640559271,
0.0146052316,
-0.000655676,
0.0516470037,
0.0031808889,
0.0295252148,
-0.0099480096,
-0.0373915508,
0.0106177339,
-0.0183265004,
-0.0266541149,
0.0167125873,
0.0393422768,
0.0278169829,
0.0219159387,
-0.0369490422,
0.0033031327,
-0.0030735172,
0.021180246,
0.0619002208,
0.0576936677,
0.0060191136,
0.0652695671,
-0.0285976231,
-0.0619235821,
-0.0657949001,
-0.0115965661,
0.0078675114,
0.024764305,
0.045881737,
0.0422391742,
0.0642558858,
0.0063694902,
-0.0368583687,
0.0491072088,
-0.077178292,
0.0258425865,
0.0232028402,
0.0168730747,
0.0029232118,
-0.0108203935,
-0.0300684124,
-0.0461971685,
-0.0240829177,
-0.0481464118,
0.050259538,
0.0448526405,
-0.0415118895,
0.0328573585,
0.0567402132,
-0.0188794918,
0.003736638,
0.0194727909,
-0.0206319597,
-0.0043604928,
-0.0228007026,
-0.0011183274,
-0.0507567562,
-0.0369816571,
0.0660628229,
0.0092111016,
0.0051552854,
-0.007632535,
0.0847279206,
0.0238559972,
-0.0269701052,
0.0129038272,
-0.0362301767,
0.0256709848,
-0.0406984799,
0.008292581,
0.015786469,
0.0213329699,
-0.0656764656,
-0.0137801785,
0.0019373504,
0.0059254328,
-0.0393705927,
-0.015475858,
0.0017653974,
0.0042173597,
-0.0281360317,
0.0462738462,
-0.0400453806,
-0.0162616093,
0.0328465104,
-0.0846266747,
-0.0364521183,
-0.002970638,
2.444e-7,
-0.0008406017,
-0.0073158536,
0.0484586097,
0.0456907749,
0.0161257479,
0.0414721444,
-0.0154992556,
0.0382480659,
-0.0165404603,
0.0017177104,
0.0700085536,
0.0431407094,
0.0249093249,
-0.0282637365,
-0.0262442548,
0.045644924,
-0.0697892383,
-0.0046790829,
-0.0076455688,
-0.036217019,
0.039236106,
0.087059617,
-0.0028247035,
-0.0066158501,
0.0290251952,
-0.0750026852,
0.080837518,
-0.0134988502,
0.0176730137,
-0.004600158,
0.0104551129,
0.0525094531,
-0.050037466,
-0.0202130433,
-0.0181601327,
-0.0048450055,
0.0764951035,
0.0437401868,
0.0017827019,
0.0247664936,
-0.0526916273,
0.0399893932,
-0.0057349694,
-0.0090089943,
0.0638228729,
-0.1123836562,
-0.0218419842,
-0.0367498845,
-0.0319830775,
-0.0073030228,
0.0174487196,
-0.0116144074,
-0.0486890785,
0.0135687403,
0.0416413695,
0.0187685806,
-0.0323817506,
-0.0773444846,
-0.0238884203,
0.0015729496,
-0.0354606472,
-0.0034065321,
-0.0761879086,
0.0028614937,
0.00340767,
-0.0271827523,
-0.0049529742,
1.748785127e-34,
0.0359469876,
-0.0184334833,
-0.0183541458,
-0.0380879566,
0.0444020964,
0.0176889915,
0.0164064132,
-0.0404613875,
0.0154800713,
-0.0240152441,
-0.0417695232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12043v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12043v1 | IncreLoRA: Incremental Parameter Allocation Method for Parameter-Efficient Fine-tuning | 2023-08-23T10:08:10 | 2023-08-23T10:08:10 | Feiyu Zhang, Liangzhi Li, Junhao Chen, Zhouqiang Jiang, Bowen Wang, Yiming Qian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | With the increasing size of pre-trained language models (PLMs), fine-tuning
all the parameters in the model is not efficient, especially when there are a
large number of downstream tasks, which incur significant training and storage
costs. Many parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) approaches have been
proposed, among which, Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) is a representative approach
that injects trainable rank decomposition matrices into every target module.
Yet LoRA ignores the importance of parameters in different modules. To address
this problem, many works have been proposed to prune the parameters of LoRA.
However, under limited training conditions, the upper bound of the rank of the
pruned parameter matrix is still affected by the preset values. We, therefore,
propose IncreLoRA, an incremental parameter allocation method that adaptively
adds trainable parameters during training based on the importance scores of
each module. This approach is different from the pruning method as it is not
limited by the initial number of training parameters, and each parameter matrix
has a higher rank upper bound for the same training overhead. We conduct
extensive experiments on GLUE to demonstrate the effectiveness of IncreLoRA.
The results show that our method owns higher parameter efficiency, especially
when under the low-resource settings where our method significantly outperforms
the baselines. Our code is publicly available. | [
0.041982051,
0.0561124608,
-0.0103352051,
0.0222739466,
0.0508622937,
0.0287224539,
-0.0128048863,
-0.0132438513,
-0.0191025529,
-0.0465825126,
-0.0792035013,
0.0138461199,
0.0019627255,
-0.004038332,
0.0510832928,
-0.0626918525,
0.0502423532,
-0.047303807,
-0.0110642184,
0.008997309,
-0.0056454386,
0.0183673371,
0.0051521426,
0.0197567381,
0.0711761191,
0.0209989883,
-0.0187225398,
0.013530598,
0.0139709683,
0.0372635759,
0.0182004664,
0.0809602886,
0.0171786845,
-0.0121320859,
0.0000020331,
-0.0387784205,
-0.0366509445,
-0.0331898555,
-0.0046782298,
0.066960521,
0.0325173624,
0.0151006309,
-0.0250268504,
0.0499141142,
-0.0140599385,
-0.0079322839,
0.044035051,
-0.013637023,
0.0548352674,
0.0921474546,
-0.0072123501,
-0.0028943813,
-0.0013759318,
-0.043722298,
-0.0519928932,
-0.0466284566,
0.0134932203,
-0.0102491435,
-0.0351616181,
-0.0252762549,
-0.0258224458,
0.0199417546,
-0.0223229695,
0.0128711024,
0.0085213017,
-0.0006357604,
-0.0468931645,
-0.0072282958,
0.0027712479,
0.0886486694,
-0.1225056127,
-0.0330661312,
0.0146846417,
-0.0436836705,
0.0065287985,
-0.0284796283,
-0.0342230126,
-0.0013812013,
0.043841064,
0.0199103691,
0.0311299413,
-0.0228275508,
0.020387277,
0.0097073466,
-0.0332354754,
0.0212239381,
0.0369577743,
0.0050094193,
-0.0110553522,
-0.0435165241,
-0.0347216129,
0.0006233438,
-0.026112156,
0.0220110547,
-0.02088774,
0.0069307019,
-0.0751914009,
-0.0493013896,
0.0113699194,
-0.0390773751,
0.0735481232,
0.0414108858,
0.0371548757,
0.0359763391,
-0.0494043864,
0.0327736065,
0.0190872345,
0.0494892672,
-0.0545579307,
-0.0004095959,
-0.0106365364,
0.0278005991,
-0.0522130653,
0.025260374,
-0.0369464755,
-0.010035336,
-0.006004659,
0.0379529744,
0.0331106111,
-0.0228810646,
0.0121367089,
-0.0317793451,
-0.0349472351,
-0.0339970961,
0.0063496246,
0.0539221354,
-0.0052814516,
0.0252333246,
-0.0490863286,
-0.0286419187,
-0.0281284619,
0.0247026905,
0.0465317592,
-0.0167693999,
0.0559139438,
0.015654752,
-0.0437823087,
-0.0684222728,
-0.0477497652,
0.0202536322,
0.0121758562,
-0.0723489597,
0.0079246983,
-0.0353251174,
0.0304807797,
-0.0040211924,
0.021787731,
-0.0330059342,
-0.027928777,
-0.0055480823,
-0.0803553089,
0.0190326869,
0.0044264789,
0.0120934453,
-0.0093767736,
-0.0011891666,
0.0127852373,
0.0600349084,
0.0299669188,
0.038652353,
0.0048441682,
-0.0436579548,
-0.0337079428,
0.038871102,
0.0079568662,
0.0430959426,
0.0069958745,
0.0037452381,
0.0270589292,
-0.0293949097,
0.0517854542,
-0.005897121,
-0.00337093,
0.011012705,
0.0575030297,
-0.0014499006,
0.0487175323,
0.0495469011,
0.0078366417,
-0.0136985565,
0.0216415636,
-0.0024395692,
-0.0502738692,
0.0152365277,
-0.0453026183,
0.0039890977,
0.0434037149,
0.0671072453,
-0.0550555959,
-0.024041092,
-0.0105561307,
-0.0145159028,
-0.0045742625,
0.0040021627,
0.0550747439,
-0.0000469845,
-0.0505463146,
0.0220403746,
0.0352685861,
-0.0476880372,
0.009215977,
-0.0355706327,
0.0059594987,
0.0364799313,
0.0166481994,
-0.0472671911,
-0.0426124707,
0.0156700779,
0.0502397753,
-0.0431402847,
0.0248810276,
0.0177207328,
0.0553209186,
-0.0431469418,
-0.0052081281,
-0.0015666425,
0.0246280804,
0.0305603966,
0.0028742345,
-0.0019887174,
0.0187548455,
-0.0056241159,
-0.0380723402,
0.0268795695,
-0.028482696,
0.0072531723,
0.0193514526,
-0.0057840464,
0.0286621507,
-0.0132422671,
-0.0057728076,
-0.0205807481,
0.042208638,
-0.0203378014,
0.0557644442,
-0.0278838482,
-0.0238391757,
-0.0082000624,
0.0205008592,
0.000727424,
0.0255739391,
0.0644794926,
-0.042236235,
-0.05303533,
0.0422503762,
-0.018483486,
0.0310264416,
-0.0413835347,
0.036186628,
-0.0472906679,
0.0433099605,
-0.0224599931,
0.0271959715,
0.0066773961,
0.0020253393,
0.0436604954,
0.0327984095,
0.0189453941,
-0.0199287832,
-0.0469264202,
0.0111422203,
0.0001170912,
0.047669217,
-0.0033260421,
0.0080095278,
-0.017652126,
-0.035105098,
-0.0578263775,
0.0496212579,
-0.037123885,
0.0276444759,
0.0351682231,
0.0131529002,
0.0030650345,
-0.0344390608,
0.0171558186,
0.0231903866,
-0.0107350536,
0.0019919188,
-0.0098145613,
0.0105538825,
-0.0052246591,
-0.0688460544,
-0.0222185403,
0.0187602155,
0.0295198299,
-0.0245975554,
-0.0081851389,
-0.0790180787,
0.0253471807,
-0.0291729122,
0.0429749303,
-0.016214747,
-0.0924153402,
-0.0489966758,
-0.0454404652,
0.0528649464,
0.0581205525,
-0.0132290414,
-0.0068675345,
0.0936276689,
0.0181409605,
-0.0108498,
-0.0034035053,
-0.0164780952,
-0.0311446823,
-0.0326293893,
0.0134761976,
0.0141021432,
0.0418449119,
-0.0280327927,
-0.0194848552,
-0.0798718631,
0.0330894589,
0.0159548167,
0.009393679,
-0.0122538125,
0.0209328644,
-0.0314258374,
-0.0044073686,
0.0093709324,
-0.0346032232,
0.035536781,
-0.0467878543,
-0.0343516581,
-0.043425791,
-0.0334709883,
-0.0280272607,
0.004877972,
0.0237328745,
0.0257717837,
-0.0252985526,
-0.0112819029,
-0.0585847087,
0.0379305333,
0.0227669105,
-0.0159515981,
0.0332791694,
-0.0230516847,
0.0045031728,
-0.0521004014,
-0.0180856772,
0.0019276334,
-0.0651150644,
0.0098776035,
0.0342977121,
0.0148422094,
-0.0313276798,
-0.0185612738,
0.0146452049,
0.0082683852,
0.0682113245,
-0.0138213076,
0.0257092156,
-0.0425795093,
-0.0017634202,
0.0569002405,
0.0550219268,
0.0255244933,
0.0109091597,
0.0236278009,
-0.0092921657,
0.024980722,
-0.0096896375,
-0.0382058956,
0.037960723,
0.0107902354,
-0.0059846058,
-0.0097559644,
0.0179723352,
0.0184868202,
-0.0213859566,
0.0131283291,
0.0788879171,
0.025706321,
-0.0435944945,
0.0065940195,
0.0154572707,
0.0819350183,
0.0359780602,
0.0518915839,
-0.00718639,
-0.017487593,
0.0064832205,
0.033169698,
0.0236695707,
-0.0144307259,
-0.0157801136,
-0.116969727,
0.0291707106,
0.0387848914,
-0.0093411691,
-0.0220698081,
-0.0470732227,
0.0125051308,
0.001545429,
0.0289720502,
0.0349346846,
-0.0449581407,
-0.0105652921,
0.0187208317,
-0.0219692048,
-0.0859714895,
-0.0068426426,
-0.0285347663,
0.0555148646,
-0.0109945964,
0.0102135325,
-0.0021224373,
-0.0091823861,
0.0407096557,
-0.0689372048,
-0.0112175085,
-0.0406156778,
0.0274960212,
0.0186814051,
-0.0294482093,
0.0422262736,
0.0141917598,
-0.0117499148,
0.0128868707,
-0.0167275537,
0.0742797256,
-0.013528171,
0.0104639735,
0.0256190039,
-0.0305200741,
-0.0286434274,
0.0500883088,
0.0306632463,
-0.0325116478,
0.0112637347,
0.0273703001,
-0.0280997939,
-0.0125790099,
-0.0151268747,
0.0145524163,
-0.0676094443,
0.0084279599,
-0.0445814431,
0.0017932388,
0.0620922111,
0.0367414989,
-0.0183848962,
0.0198038537,
-0.031457033,
0.0164784156,
-0.0324300528,
0.0245258566,
-0.0233172607,
-0.042932786,
-0.0429231711,
-0.0372392423,
0.0444288589,
-0.0141050648,
-0.0207642019,
-0.0201205965,
-0.0435251519,
-0.0513626635,
-0.0142618269,
0.0796288103,
0.0159670468,
0.0520258136,
-0.0262909811,
-0.1034810394,
-0.0108156232,
-0.0129068242,
0.0073838094,
0.0594923496,
0.0412689596,
-0.0556495599,
-0.0194301419,
0.0327090584,
-0.0650871545,
0.0090969056,
0.0337337852,
-0.0068218084,
-0.0068809162,
-0.0412210897,
-0.0246748645,
0.0270199943,
0.0147594167,
0.002069518,
-0.0235030018,
-0.0464410111,
0.0662526041,
-0.0174230412,
0.0059587089,
-0.042418126,
0.0105970101,
0.0041520689,
0.0050936039,
-0.0288759246,
-0.0084718065,
0.001990458,
0.0320506617,
-0.0128479386,
0.0071505248,
-0.0083847092,
-0.0036398552,
0.0367302373,
0.0158319026,
-0.0318376571,
0.045763921,
0.0196726881,
-0.0075442232,
-0.0557262227,
-0.0230003633,
0.0092498735,
0.0106262127,
-0.0809326023,
0.0627409592,
-0.0298670158,
-0.1065507308,
-0.0601182207,
0.0131744472,
0.0494023748,
0.0159838088,
0.0924943089,
0.0189099442,
-0.0127528012,
-0.0208606981,
-0.0035295039,
-0.007934493,
0.0211206004,
0.004678647,
0.0135987513,
-0.0126019744,
0.0443203449,
0.0683843195,
0.0519153997,
0.0455037802,
-0.0170209762,
0.0077208653,
-0.0266490709,
-0.0060727508,
-0.0214900915,
0.0405354798,
-0.0249863975,
0.0035944001,
0.023299098,
-0.0480778329,
-0.0388711952,
-0.0108272126,
-0.0049441434,
-0.0185220968,
0.0212708376,
0.02782345,
-0.026962107,
0.0248570573,
-0.0190669615,
-0.0595687665,
0.0089212777,
-0.0121303601,
0.0336426571,
-6.718803918e-33,
-0.0423669107,
0.046151828,
-0.0022174576,
0.0365701914,
-0.0085342787,
-0.0213441961,
-0.0294492561,
0.024252573,
-0.0076950481,
-0.0332826301,
-0.0125625031,
-0.0115149338,
0.0099260267,
-0.0047802906,
-0.0073812236,
0.0144091016,
0.05200978,
-0.0005636393,
-0.0243858602,
0.0488404557,
0.013118065,
0.0283761844,
0.0668740496,
-0.014721591,
-0.069189541,
0.0081916004,
-0.0349476822,
0.0077198884,
-0.0068203923,
0.0494946726,
0.008771779,
0.0320942886,
0.0258641113,
-0.0073966892,
-0.0383487158,
0.019508766,
-0.0700596496,
-0.0370249823,
0.0414831787,
0.0007702561,
-0.0160104148,
-0.0290311724,
0.0384381786,
0.0057386914,
-0.0067666741,
-0.0183096156,
0.0313056558,
-0.0415623076,
-0.0228120275,
-0.0155814104,
-0.0470687002,
0.0066510802,
0.0051091723,
-0.0037729985,
0.0424070098,
0.0357171334,
-0.0093333246,
0.0360639133,
-0.0344597772,
-0.0167216547,
0.0483963639,
0.1037168652,
0.0234237257,
0.0183993801,
-0.0373588875,
0.0192697346,
-0.016473664,
0.0065577361,
0.0534528755,
-0.0003466747,
0.081182003,
0.0514499955,
0.0608423688,
0.0192124993,
0.0097431066,
-0.0050390428,
-0.0744052976,
0.0108351037,
0.0468505807,
0.004074967,
0.0218764655,
0.0327835418,
0.0200610701,
-0.0164165478,
-0.0678534657,
-0.0124613745,
-0.0569617264,
-0.0251685549,
0.0411357768,
0.0395195372,
-0.0489048772,
0.0055643446,
0.0665160269,
-0.0244369376,
0.0128225852,
0.0088485004,
-0.0429972932,
0.0264900085,
0.0078014904,
0.0220784973,
-0.0556267835,
-0.0732655972,
0.0556735992,
-0.0489224605,
0.0209159181,
-0.0390128978,
0.024870364,
0.047500357,
-0.0523520783,
-0.003233474,
-0.0032658428,
0.0160561055,
-0.0072409105,
0.0791047662,
-0.0033344519,
-0.0173853841,
0.0043834224,
0.0306414925,
0.0175305195,
0.0029526546,
-0.0249061957,
-0.0274559297,
0.0442825258,
0.0318656154,
-0.0231193732,
0.0082662059,
-0.03692073,
-0.0053109163,
0.0518146195,
-0.0659512058,
-0.0190489031,
0.0116401659,
2.82e-7,
0.0334433801,
0.042487327,
-0.0454332978,
-0.0484785587,
0.0246404577,
0.0076330868,
-0.0501803532,
0.0233759377,
0.0284256581,
0.0365515202,
0.0271366276,
0.008620237,
0.0243898071,
-0.0243064389,
-0.0684392899,
0.0011058454,
-0.0905461013,
0.0255881604,
-0.049407497,
-0.0343802348,
-0.0170627534,
0.1184961945,
0.0224377811,
-0.0217154305,
-0.0266395491,
-0.017735729,
0.0287768394,
-0.0224980917,
-0.0205386672,
0.0207106099,
0.0458476543,
0.0493348725,
-0.0518350154,
-0.0135331769,
-0.0226430539,
0.0712243617,
-0.034435343,
0.0804397017,
-0.0362798013,
-0.0098495567,
0.0584655739,
0.0141259553,
0.0045993077,
-0.0695029199,
0.0908948854,
-0.0650650412,
0.0005601735,
-0.0108484011,
-0.0030656718,
-0.0042765094,
-0.0107374564,
-0.0343644507,
-0.0179095306,
0.0376750566,
0.0433329046,
-0.0224762801,
-0.0207650289,
-0.1064018086,
0.0156214461,
0.0361805223,
-0.0357786827,
-0.071456477,
-0.0314331912,
-0.0440522991,
0.0593267158,
-0.0782489255,
0.0169091821,
2.71609541e-34,
0.0338028893,
-0.0336543955,
0.0377393626,
0.0171149857,
0.0361786895,
-0.0035889647,
-0.0195439998,
0.0239067934,
0.017591849,
-0.1094785705,
-0.0241084564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12039v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12039v1 | Hybrid Retrieval and Multi-stage Text Ranking Solution at TREC 2022 Deep Learning Track | 2023-08-23T09:56:59 | 2023-08-23T09:56:59 | Guangwei Xu, Yangzhao Zhang, Longhui Zhang, Dingkun Long, Pengjun Xie, Ruijie Guo | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Large-scale text retrieval technology has been widely used in various
practical business scenarios. This paper presents our systems for the TREC 2022
Deep Learning Track. We explain the hybrid text retrieval and multi-stage text
ranking method adopted in our solution. The retrieval stage combined the two
structures of traditional sparse retrieval and neural dense retrieval. In the
ranking stage, in addition to the full interaction-based ranking model built on
large pre-trained language model, we also proposes a lightweight sub-ranking
module to further enhance the final text ranking performance. Evaluation
results demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed approach. Our models
achieve the 1st and 4th rank on the test set of passage ranking and document
ranking respectively. | [
0.0566935763,
-0.0131206093,
-0.0093511874,
0.0274292119,
0.0173992831,
-0.0243669003,
0.0079660639,
0.0060340874,
0.0444464833,
-0.0639588758,
-0.047436025,
-0.0493653826,
-0.0169345234,
0.0554633364,
0.0111101307,
-0.0422594585,
0.0293878037,
0.0023119568,
0.0156705845,
0.0293905735,
0.0062049842,
0.042757798,
0.0284130555,
0.0129175354,
0.049885422,
0.0030716709,
-0.0220832024,
0.0005503221,
0.0351511911,
-0.0371287838,
0.0368108675,
0.0121637732,
0.0597901233,
0.0663467497,
0.0000018935,
-0.0410049744,
-0.0563921407,
-0.0047467658,
-0.0136407502,
0.0255516805,
0.0362172201,
0.0617814511,
0.0404543579,
-0.0095489882,
-0.0481294654,
0.0056323218,
-0.0179132111,
0.0509337448,
0.0423276722,
0.0595719516,
-0.0133436946,
-0.0304632038,
0.0197288692,
-0.0335982516,
-0.0117793735,
-0.0719699487,
0.0187570155,
-0.0298182201,
0.0435506739,
0.0877962261,
0.0296099782,
0.0025526113,
-0.000950843,
-0.0161427502,
0.057686992,
0.0115017761,
-0.0293278154,
0.0131244548,
-0.0023887123,
0.0966694728,
0.0019100941,
-0.0101202363,
-0.0165928043,
0.0102596842,
-0.0066264989,
-0.0303139221,
-0.0402604304,
-0.0267132651,
0.014195323,
0.0047127134,
-0.0258903336,
0.0527666882,
0.0157702435,
0.0313089527,
-0.0399841927,
0.0380252302,
-0.0049616094,
-0.0603832267,
0.0276012234,
-0.0206568167,
0.0269909706,
-0.0011447393,
0.078033708,
-0.0132113453,
-0.0090037491,
-0.020759983,
0.0330151767,
-0.0182566177,
-0.0055219331,
-0.0766154602,
-0.0298711956,
0.0145784747,
-0.0113025308,
0.0676352903,
-0.0342244096,
0.0401176736,
-0.0023800803,
-0.0228213873,
-0.0333196446,
0.0065836944,
-0.0057651922,
-0.0375426114,
-0.0016380457,
0.0813341439,
-0.0484984331,
-0.0229370575,
-0.037141379,
-0.0326752067,
-0.0087935142,
-0.0138349384,
0.0448125526,
0.0642588735,
-0.0478622578,
-0.0127842464,
-0.0400956571,
0.0271783452,
0.0050781849,
-0.0195439309,
-0.019203335,
0.0246125665,
0.0110830041,
-0.0120316427,
0.0102977939,
-0.0373681374,
0.0229094643,
-0.0042663221,
-0.0398398601,
-0.041132357,
0.0151224965,
-0.0124197081,
0.0418969505,
-0.0420522206,
-0.0265948568,
-0.0298179425,
0.0120714577,
-0.0194030385,
-0.0008282327,
-0.0043228935,
0.0165060293,
0.0342660174,
-0.0659644008,
0.0247780047,
0.0199552402,
-0.0528825931,
0.0318894461,
0.040068455,
0.0661725253,
0.004017822,
0.0019952692,
0.0453084782,
0.0474951155,
0.0321346857,
-0.0263325274,
0.005613178,
0.0115968511,
-0.0422300547,
0.0014210559,
0.0150105311,
-0.0497274809,
0.0330538712,
-0.0071559255,
0.0302592795,
-0.0382238999,
-0.0086954925,
0.0219978727,
0.0425207429,
0.0540983938,
0.0335137472,
-0.0000078354,
0.0468362235,
-0.0115786949,
-0.0249086581,
0.0262589566,
0.0170994177,
-0.0270629544,
-0.0237600263,
0.0876642093,
0.0179324746,
-0.0321939103,
-0.0080544362,
0.025503343,
0.0429256484,
-0.0084036607,
-0.0050875056,
0.0497169271,
-0.0406221785,
-0.0737869963,
0.0043385657,
-0.0016747155,
-0.0501112603,
0.0048114397,
-0.0113319764,
-0.0331496,
0.078821674,
0.0549488552,
-0.06160504,
0.0015615475,
0.0127317868,
-0.0015749054,
0.0108914226,
0.0278965551,
-0.0213944912,
0.0023492451,
-0.0557159595,
-0.0303279702,
-0.0031673564,
-0.0297953952,
0.0341340378,
-0.0242444593,
0.0438487642,
0.0374567099,
-0.0195871182,
-0.0095997658,
0.020183662,
0.0099893212,
-0.0114119211,
0.0159023236,
0.0190043971,
0.0111603281,
0.0630161613,
-0.0066828248,
-0.020258382,
0.0385742337,
-0.0090323491,
-0.0160537418,
-0.0536134541,
-0.0419908464,
-0.0109933382,
0.0177898239,
0.0157434791,
0.0199103318,
0.0921587422,
-0.0147522911,
-0.0365961753,
-0.0087326411,
0.0353630669,
-0.0031037943,
-0.017112406,
0.0125470012,
-0.0194513835,
0.0009791271,
-0.0623693243,
0.0762721002,
0.015772406,
0.0658728331,
0.0300510228,
-0.0030792698,
-0.0001719048,
-0.0293487646,
-0.0651838705,
0.0110583771,
-0.0088669434,
0.0262183212,
0.0530383736,
0.0103668179,
-0.003995535,
0.0097496137,
-0.0789720491,
0.0370248556,
-0.0067798132,
-0.0174110029,
-0.0126270037,
0.0088039748,
0.0185350683,
-0.0315307379,
-0.0309295766,
0.0051237298,
0.0119951069,
-0.0099281576,
-0.0109973522,
0.0286608618,
0.0218580086,
-0.0569197126,
-0.0285311509,
0.0123958951,
0.0698830709,
-0.0056892047,
-0.0327986032,
-0.0187376309,
0.0603660904,
-0.0335301124,
0.036868602,
-0.010527065,
-0.0098625412,
-0.0275659002,
-0.0415300541,
-0.0188143104,
0.0468609855,
0.0017065182,
0.0293326713,
0.011176208,
-0.0021388996,
-0.0794589743,
0.0270358715,
-0.0048043346,
0.0361226983,
0.0094414577,
0.0088117328,
-0.015405505,
-0.0120108668,
-0.0218987409,
-0.0102697946,
-0.0226612613,
-0.0004725287,
-0.0020148314,
0.0040633818,
-0.0777404159,
0.0157949179,
0.0027434828,
0.0342004038,
-0.015117621,
-0.0075437119,
0.0453105122,
0.0000469578,
-0.009477145,
-0.0749532431,
-0.0185326133,
-0.0324726105,
0.0581162013,
0.0043190145,
0.0073694238,
-0.0854399949,
-0.0314276069,
-0.0383666307,
0.0137733342,
0.0003037516,
-0.0561657622,
0.0097921593,
0.0196896307,
0.0383226573,
-0.0332047455,
-0.057209827,
-0.0199371371,
-0.0312399846,
0.0191376656,
0.0276960377,
0.0586629584,
-0.0127457669,
-0.0418128148,
0.0389179103,
0.0218867175,
0.0618887693,
-0.0229518414,
-0.0306574516,
0.0161472447,
0.0834371597,
0.0445831157,
-0.0370323658,
-0.0018797888,
0.0068581137,
0.0212846976,
0.0474176295,
0.0259992257,
-0.0231261496,
-0.027293941,
-0.038749136,
0.0620057844,
-0.05276509,
-0.0037992769,
-0.0070183109,
-0.0468741395,
-0.0311027057,
-0.0233769789,
0.0741641447,
0.0491297543,
-0.0776437446,
-0.0332579091,
-0.0041965437,
0.0168360006,
-0.002424936,
0.0567814782,
-0.0608768649,
0.0426319875,
0.0054243789,
0.0204023197,
0.0075469855,
-0.0112868845,
0.0009617039,
-0.0937145799,
0.0233332999,
-0.0277368296,
0.011257058,
-0.0032735511,
-0.0268459506,
0.0040555038,
0.0043155518,
-0.0097708246,
0.0329532325,
-0.0082801702,
-0.0267961249,
-0.0103040263,
0.0208273437,
-0.0150360381,
0.0228869263,
-0.0204967745,
-0.0145749506,
0.0369203053,
0.0573776551,
-0.0217510425,
0.0187499598,
0.017825149,
-0.0317260511,
-0.010913115,
-0.0255308766,
0.0366945155,
-0.0190874543,
0.0219397247,
-0.0476781651,
-0.0102090407,
0.0146778012,
0.0374370292,
-0.0311889518,
0.0382064544,
-0.0244135968,
0.0004813681,
-0.0411086008,
0.0197826959,
-0.0226403438,
0.0473171994,
-0.0544600561,
-0.0145960832,
-0.0356315635,
-0.0389040411,
0.0387710817,
-0.0605967641,
-0.0594548434,
0.0008762072,
-0.0133702066,
0.0193530452,
-0.0580035597,
-0.049506817,
-0.0099750366,
0.0175957605,
-0.0127265835,
0.0574309863,
-0.0349172615,
0.005194765,
-0.0266946126,
-0.0046806522,
0.0188219845,
0.0084597543,
-0.0339934267,
0.0474346988,
0.056283243,
-0.0523266569,
-0.04603149,
-0.0355376266,
-0.0029300416,
-0.0358204693,
-0.0410734788,
0.038044434,
0.0105873318,
0.0186489299,
-0.0060840067,
-0.081381157,
0.0988008454,
0.0153255844,
-0.0445221104,
-0.0097622899,
0.012381861,
-0.0160634685,
-0.06065147,
0.010171528,
-0.0779840872,
0.0159453526,
-0.0185262654,
0.0483505316,
-0.0013487707,
-0.0730170682,
0.0084864255,
-0.0082062408,
0.049519185,
0.0588691272,
0.0043830387,
-0.0689852461,
0.0510444529,
-0.0223676413,
-0.0226445124,
-0.0317930095,
0.0330999568,
0.045837488,
-0.0046536247,
-0.0182945821,
0.0301187709,
0.039416451,
0.0507455803,
-0.0721677989,
-0.0024852131,
0.0014113747,
-0.0081238486,
-0.0056624613,
-0.0041123205,
-0.0328027755,
0.0035707778,
0.0011943171,
0.0426677093,
-0.0375273302,
0.0058562802,
0.0302591622,
-0.0200085845,
-0.0253323261,
0.0529823154,
-0.0758897811,
-0.005870786,
-0.0458361208,
-0.0301216468,
0.058633361,
0.0175605509,
0.0385458693,
0.0128984051,
-0.0111968061,
-0.0000864365,
-0.0309917666,
0.0112396283,
-0.0038566068,
-0.0361574478,
0.027328087,
0.0195702389,
0.0928407535,
0.0555305518,
0.0264256094,
-0.0421786308,
0.0407166108,
-0.0658745989,
-0.0140670538,
-0.0166368689,
0.02842604,
0.1050250083,
-0.0089558903,
-0.0084096752,
0.0115796821,
0.0003802184,
0.0384603851,
-0.0163365621,
-0.0414397568,
-0.0487154983,
0.0645735562,
0.0754133984,
0.0050694435,
0.0066289599,
-0.0470298082,
-0.0118851243,
-0.0042073787,
-0.0253082123,
-0.0416343585,
-6.262289666e-33,
-0.0159945823,
-0.007241609,
-0.0086042015,
-0.0028105236,
-0.0331145674,
0.0269630514,
0.0169831719,
-0.0439034998,
-0.0180268213,
0.0096727088,
-0.0228962842,
0.0217551719,
0.0064573302,
0.0297621991,
-0.0053982693,
0.0118021658,
0.0383888446,
-0.0103023145,
0.0205214769,
0.0334585495,
0.0435719043,
0.0801359937,
0.0266024526,
-0.060840372,
0.0261961408,
-0.0308193993,
0.0280228946,
-0.0239923839,
0.0281735174,
0.0448825359,
-0.013367027,
0.0155456671,
0.0468049385,
-0.0755466074,
0.0407671034,
0.0399588384,
-0.060915865,
-0.0345617831,
-0.0178346429,
-0.0241150279,
-0.022021316,
0.0102371173,
0.0213548224,
-0.0018737306,
0.0128681418,
-0.0118861999,
0.0600083061,
0.0230976883,
-0.032022167,
-0.0980441794,
-0.0442792848,
0.0186360478,
-0.0225170795,
0.0189843476,
0.0213181786,
0.0896510929,
0.0092987493,
0.0454145409,
-0.1056702137,
-0.0016932391,
-0.0602619238,
0.0561510473,
-0.0025613885,
0.0030587814,
-0.0532920733,
0.0459429286,
-0.0203841235,
-0.0005943572,
-0.010856471,
-0.0331027657,
0.0165284798,
0.0112764612,
0.0203097593,
0.0347118787,
-0.0071525532,
-0.0094228704,
-0.0843843669,
0.0765355378,
0.0465602949,
0.021041736,
0.0340001993,
0.0256452169,
-0.0556468628,
-0.0245450605,
0.0066912253,
0.0184981972,
-0.0465462916,
-0.0353783295,
0.0391554609,
0.0146209337,
-0.0224654321,
0.0301013961,
0.051561974,
-0.0471597649,
-0.0325345807,
0.0451172963,
-0.0137129612,
0.0247961618,
-0.0056567523,
0.0494689755,
-0.0356200673,
-0.0341719911,
-0.0072089699,
-0.0089207878,
-0.030294273,
-0.0325853042,
-0.0153665552,
-0.0160664357,
-0.0272752848,
-0.0034085079,
0.0449163057,
-0.0239835773,
-0.0273980312,
0.089094691,
-0.0234324504,
0.0052946187,
0.0268867817,
0.0722291842,
0.0379142873,
0.030357834,
-0.0195223112,
-0.0314855501,
0.0409985967,
-0.0308202133,
0.0022969216,
0.0318966061,
-0.0420634411,
0.0528067052,
0.0150248259,
-0.0630942136,
-0.0084028468,
0.033966478,
2.642e-7,
0.0206293724,
0.015392174,
-0.0269437637,
-0.0191162191,
-0.0096541923,
-0.0000235135,
0.0504514687,
0.0465473011,
0.0374176987,
0.0300932918,
0.0271984637,
-0.0073626447,
-0.0056685074,
-0.0000475686,
-0.0959719643,
-0.0863173008,
-0.0730497241,
-0.0619593412,
-0.0717356279,
-0.0586003587,
0.0199926216,
0.0898755193,
0.006708256,
0.0088387327,
-0.0151751647,
-0.0477949642,
0.0405918099,
0.0042177932,
-0.0052488581,
0.0206598844,
0.0449023992,
0.0317518003,
-0.0503279939,
0.0031870143,
-0.0077680289,
0.0673116297,
0.0516691096,
0.028978426,
-0.0364569128,
-0.0381891578,
0.0346653238,
-0.0076314057,
-0.0019080829,
-0.0503065772,
0.0603218004,
-0.0271589253,
0.0007214699,
0.0445915982,
-0.0442687608,
-0.0071610073,
0.0022466173,
0.0002898098,
-0.0162268002,
0.0308887027,
0.0093106041,
-0.0063503929,
-0.0002343355,
-0.0995142758,
0.0284908004,
-0.0077301571,
-0.0229889639,
-0.0152235692,
-0.0010527294,
-0.0266911667,
-0.0051647141,
-0.03263418,
0.0328304358,
2.471324885e-34,
0.0439816527,
0.0030843029,
-0.0069523822,
-0.0090242336,
0.0139962304,
-0.0014758253,
-0.0112841409,
0.0180231333,
0.0196877494,
-0.1091954336,
-0.0142333554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12038v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12038v3 | Large Multilingual Models Pivot Zero-Shot Multimodal Learning across Languages | 2023-08-23T09:55:41 | 2024-03-22T02:24:57 | Jinyi Hu, Yuan Yao, Chongyi Wang, Shan Wang, Yinxu Pan, Qianyu Chen, Tianyu Yu, Hanghao Wu, Yue Zhao, Haoye Zhang, Xu Han, Yankai Lin, Jiao Xue, Dahai Li, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Recently there has been a significant surge in multimodal learning in terms
of both image-to-text and text-to-image generation. However, the success is
typically limited to English, leaving other languages largely behind. Building
a competitive counterpart in other languages is highly challenging due to the
low-resource nature of non-English multimodal data (i.e., lack of large-scale,
high-quality image-text data). In this work, we propose MPM, an effective
training paradigm for training large multimodal models in non-English
languages. MPM demonstrates that Multilingual language models can Pivot
zero-shot Multimodal learning across languages. Specifically, based on a strong
multilingual large language model, multimodal models pretrained on English-only
image-text data can well generalize to other languages in a (quasi)-zero-shot
manner, even surpassing models trained on image-text data in native languages.
Taking Chinese as a practice of MPM, we build large multimodal models VisCPM in
image-to-text and text-to-image generation, which achieve state-of-the-art
(open-source) performance in Chinese. To facilitate future research, we
open-source codes and model weights at https://github.com/OpenBMB/VisCPM.git. | [
-0.0166236721,
0.0794155747,
0.0330523551,
0.0682218671,
-0.0050279214,
0.0039906115,
0.0357235447,
0.0001183014,
-0.0518958382,
-0.0541547425,
-0.075518854,
-0.0717590153,
0.0206910763,
-0.0017944745,
0.0465949774,
-0.0989929438,
-0.0030932953,
-0.0275901984,
-0.0410277061,
-0.0037148339,
0.0466781668,
0.0264653917,
-0.0039187386,
0.0104432441,
-0.0333489329,
-0.0429540053,
-0.0042800317,
0.0466380678,
0.0214141812,
-0.0408781022,
0.0013955804,
0.0338307433,
0.0223063137,
0.039803829,
0.0000018342,
-0.0038417978,
0.0094687063,
-0.0094709313,
0.0727064982,
0.0109759942,
0.054555092,
-0.0766341984,
-0.0184625071,
-0.0256269723,
-0.0155094489,
-0.0295730475,
0.0806928128,
0.0467130989,
0.0752288699,
0.0631833225,
-0.0379034989,
-0.0382580534,
-0.0156258605,
-0.0350540616,
0.0283248387,
-0.0182355754,
-0.0214922894,
0.0040280498,
-0.0311522093,
0.0042764838,
-0.0585669391,
0.0170670673,
0.0233344045,
0.0012101725,
-0.0357141569,
0.0589954741,
0.0125364689,
-0.0316645019,
-0.002996061,
0.1019257605,
-0.0678975061,
-0.0019832568,
-0.0311835557,
-0.0030245418,
-0.0222054496,
-0.0011624144,
-0.0651204288,
0.0704059675,
0.0090112612,
0.0396164507,
-0.0557218567,
-0.0086479243,
0.0104787881,
0.0055548539,
0.0037194609,
-0.0215321593,
0.0213563386,
0.0123858768,
-0.0159346666,
0.0003165724,
-0.0233844314,
-0.0347602777,
0.0027019344,
0.0264768545,
0.00122527,
0.0005578136,
-0.0350530297,
-0.0367914326,
0.0119825769,
-0.0351836793,
0.0665619299,
0.0313284695,
-0.0465757214,
0.030337831,
-0.048350811,
0.0216497052,
-0.0238993783,
0.0296539553,
-0.04321279,
-0.0378505625,
-0.0165234562,
-0.0147130191,
-0.0148107857,
-0.0187775083,
-0.0358414128,
-0.0312285703,
-0.0503412224,
0.0102440165,
-0.0014255042,
-0.0077459468,
-0.0111255022,
0.010530835,
-0.0554358624,
-0.0388046093,
0.0153914625,
0.0913849846,
-0.0065586935,
0.0233010892,
-0.0095649948,
-0.0207795985,
-0.0075638504,
0.0495494902,
0.0298409853,
-0.0326043814,
-0.008236886,
0.0802177936,
-0.0658783689,
-0.0267212354,
-0.0302481931,
-0.0069158273,
-0.0248800926,
-0.0674121231,
0.031420432,
-0.049643185,
0.0282301102,
-0.0160747133,
0.0414990373,
-0.006664353,
0.004337695,
0.0147330295,
0.0156596284,
0.0630456582,
0.0128759621,
-0.0078137284,
0.0199141782,
0.0048280098,
0.0021914043,
0.0993807763,
0.0255977567,
0.051559303,
0.0296997949,
0.0101415087,
0.0022244314,
0.0626519546,
0.0134628015,
0.0409698226,
-0.0211224426,
-0.0465881899,
0.0435704663,
0.0169580802,
0.067677252,
0.0248267446,
-0.0390495285,
0.0103582526,
0.0868676826,
-0.010719548,
0.0138791632,
-0.0099959476,
0.0605326258,
-0.0343194976,
-0.02452562,
0.0029575515,
-0.020758424,
0.0650209337,
0.0053212568,
0.0254046526,
0.0462192856,
0.0618757866,
-0.0559972525,
-0.0103389826,
0.0302804243,
-0.0405714884,
-0.0108804191,
-0.0184140913,
0.0467463769,
0.0392277911,
-0.0436324105,
0.0062978021,
0.0304307863,
-0.0507159494,
0.0338178426,
0.0157854538,
-0.0047047269,
0.0360522419,
0.0130238142,
0.0218483545,
0.0046103317,
-0.0020022683,
0.0302159786,
0.085638538,
-0.0174298305,
-0.0060130437,
0.0591223165,
-0.0664030463,
-0.0185682774,
-0.0140457517,
-0.0055086687,
0.0424295031,
-0.026665438,
0.0407046489,
0.0049631097,
-0.0005773364,
-0.0125063201,
0.0346435346,
-0.0160169452,
-0.0078212498,
-0.0024400891,
0.0199988,
-0.0043475502,
-0.0208807494,
-0.0256885886,
-0.0031968057,
-0.0076686866,
-0.0777610391,
-0.0102426084,
0.0437877066,
-0.0267945956,
-0.0726315454,
0.0170371477,
-0.0638938844,
0.0106666908,
-0.005715467,
-0.0465975478,
-0.032213185,
0.0125618111,
0.034186054,
-0.0142698484,
-0.0572617501,
-0.0029476099,
0.0329970978,
0.0287427884,
-0.0032981895,
0.0178738963,
-0.0177076217,
0.0209615994,
0.0126669323,
0.0205677971,
0.007637925,
-0.0110625401,
-0.0363856815,
0.0275896043,
0.0066063721,
0.0285892449,
0.0117520224,
0.0360138975,
-0.0181450378,
0.0143856332,
-0.0887968764,
0.0112924539,
-0.0089465519,
-0.0073012849,
-0.0014000649,
0.0139981201,
0.016501341,
-0.0351268873,
-0.0489930287,
0.0245205611,
0.0129222712,
0.0199739281,
0.0330016539,
-0.0066848481,
0.0526485778,
-0.0129660461,
0.0034217678,
0.0369260274,
0.0703998953,
-0.024315102,
0.0002344745,
-0.0269898064,
0.0058844937,
-0.0496586077,
0.0057972693,
-0.0103741316,
-0.0467258207,
0.0244962722,
-0.021952631,
0.0522760004,
0.0488463826,
0.0101865781,
-0.0073419134,
0.0136414282,
-0.0044549434,
-0.0289863814,
0.0036439996,
0.0149188945,
-0.0091798389,
-0.0075867879,
-0.0398086011,
-0.0127150919,
0.0659139603,
0.0037625015,
0.0095462967,
-0.0547364727,
-0.0085273394,
-0.0083043221,
-0.039519731,
-0.0423863232,
0.0502516851,
-0.0088827442,
-0.0014791619,
-0.0505414568,
-0.0390351079,
0.0174486544,
-0.0531057194,
-0.0450939499,
0.0159634948,
0.0262282416,
-0.0225678235,
0.0548033714,
0.0161119364,
0.076587148,
-0.0066179438,
0.0236621257,
-0.0530171506,
0.0097353356,
0.0282098129,
0.0148117598,
0.024684526,
-0.0137085998,
0.0106249498,
-0.0611699894,
-0.0235787239,
-0.0162623152,
0.0008224628,
-0.0082291979,
-0.0041195061,
-0.0322666466,
-0.0056513599,
0.0075457008,
0.0219705049,
0.0286173522,
0.0412480757,
-0.0050653243,
-0.0151315238,
-0.0110549945,
0.0459067933,
0.0247618314,
0.0058379881,
-0.063401863,
-0.0811408535,
0.0114741251,
0.0664010495,
0.0102188522,
-0.0023306152,
-0.0272193961,
0.0215705503,
0.022923924,
0.0506212898,
-0.0183543395,
0.0003762617,
0.0617904328,
-0.0231011175,
0.0185861476,
0.0518595502,
0.0009848875,
-0.0465659089,
-0.0166275259,
0.0299047008,
0.0645589754,
0.017005099,
-0.0115663698,
-0.1184434295,
-0.0509873293,
-0.0406367108,
-0.0222934298,
0.0294470657,
0.0158315059,
-0.0320011936,
-0.1184659451,
0.0285811219,
0.0246436447,
-0.0577591397,
-0.0115092089,
-0.0179871842,
-0.0076130978,
0.0017061749,
-0.0028560411,
-0.0021792224,
0.0094372639,
0.0010261533,
0.0093281278,
0.0289239027,
-0.0694994479,
-0.0083762733,
-0.0485329628,
-0.0100757256,
0.0330448002,
0.0348219164,
0.0056619765,
-0.0131083084,
0.0188839138,
0.030255843,
-0.0137870768,
-0.0133406725,
0.0643502846,
0.0002007277,
-0.0295333806,
0.0262583047,
0.0397705324,
-0.0229065567,
-0.0112204365,
0.0075937817,
0.0269303583,
0.0204490721,
-0.0089543108,
-0.0217934586,
-0.0008585218,
0.0040250081,
0.0243546199,
0.0131735168,
-0.0673064739,
-0.0317027904,
-0.0376204029,
-0.0113748908,
-0.0772020146,
-0.0107459016,
0.0239187982,
-0.0421746783,
-0.0307429507,
-0.084878251,
-0.004742254,
0.0003406754,
0.0758295581,
-0.0226126406,
-0.0087918844,
-0.0245973505,
0.0222116709,
-0.0255309846,
0.0052115927,
-0.0247757677,
0.0296090953,
-0.0381592549,
-0.0060631819,
0.0271315556,
-0.0325791091,
0.0233753938,
0.0034656031,
-0.0610297434,
-0.0473574661,
-0.0705312639,
0.055234842,
0.0044671055,
0.0252997614,
0.0336908475,
-0.0369128473,
0.0304255877,
0.0374376327,
0.0130348643,
0.002940187,
0.0393285342,
0.0035256918,
-0.0079157632,
0.0400486216,
-0.0180876777,
0.0397277325,
0.0020099271,
0.0469366424,
0.0024923047,
0.0065007489,
0.0120455427,
-0.0064709894,
-0.0157641452,
-0.0723454952,
0.0181635562,
-0.0477419756,
-0.0227502976,
-0.0443772487,
-0.0487479493,
-0.0816623941,
-0.0053723212,
0.0571435541,
0.0061368137,
0.0071837367,
0.0050269333,
0.0356050953,
0.0413711369,
-0.0216268655,
-0.0026345474,
0.0261868648,
0.010623578,
0.010442053,
0.0343202502,
0.0057827318,
0.0207381416,
-0.0399574824,
0.013731583,
-0.0297718458,
0.079845503,
0.0227797832,
-0.0001111613,
-0.0193216801,
0.0152547238,
0.0084884446,
0.0127151674,
-0.0567077622,
0.0312434919,
0.0835229382,
0.0342964567,
0.0890239701,
-0.0255038682,
-0.0257254615,
-0.0128249284,
0.0656099394,
0.0014687615,
-0.0510020033,
0.0186268426,
-0.0106961709,
0.0142068127,
-0.0207127593,
0.1120400578,
-0.0012900302,
0.0185598098,
-0.0012963772,
0.0253967252,
-0.0346302837,
-0.008574293,
0.0558872223,
-0.0088151321,
0.0100122951,
0.0284857899,
-0.011852216,
-0.0532397553,
-0.0110273603,
0.0081809871,
-0.0223475471,
0.0161559526,
0.0329800285,
0.0358192287,
0.0225198027,
0.0208046846,
-0.0521207713,
0.0030826577,
0.0272559933,
-0.0040097297,
0.0132851033,
-5.599198446e-33,
-0.041956462,
-0.004211457,
0.0142737506,
-0.0392896235,
-0.0362346582,
-0.0154633848,
-0.0238553528,
0.0256350525,
0.0031363086,
0.0027462405,
0.0335554555,
-0.0373889804,
-0.0048953569,
0.0697762072,
0.0106227659,
0.0415107831,
0.0346299633,
-0.0103424434,
-0.0137917539,
0.0200048722,
0.0513753556,
0.0330557823,
0.0667157322,
0.0085692704,
-0.0185356885,
-0.0117466329,
-0.0680651367,
0.0134475548,
0.0435164496,
0.0252744127,
-0.0360054262,
0.0281417146,
0.0127170067,
-0.0132753942,
-0.0278126653,
-0.0107159279,
-0.0509991497,
0.012563129,
-0.0238320511,
0.0332823284,
-0.0757896304,
-0.0100220144,
0.0237653516,
-0.0337907784,
0.018240368,
-0.0263177156,
0.0260686465,
-0.0457029603,
-0.0058188583,
-0.0123527963,
-0.0656845272,
0.008061178,
-0.0199638736,
-0.038864743,
0.0090576811,
0.0611684248,
0.0076837586,
0.0265443623,
-0.0447426476,
0.0185119417,
-0.0139374314,
0.0221721306,
0.0543186218,
0.0690889582,
0.0037825133,
0.04391912,
0.0393736288,
-0.0128220981,
0.0144416252,
0.0381724909,
0.0528735183,
0.047057353,
0.0039897179,
0.1156222746,
0.0353631303,
0.0203756746,
-0.0618201196,
0.0555169918,
-0.0026314559,
-0.0053815669,
0.0207105298,
0.0181272067,
0.0396752656,
-0.0236495044,
-0.0242579151,
-0.0474328846,
-0.0406717621,
-0.0231256075,
0.0139945559,
0.0376645848,
-0.0165233053,
-0.005068168,
0.0850370899,
-0.0198611189,
-0.0500898734,
0.0130465971,
-0.052126199,
0.056859538,
-0.0110520823,
0.0088870935,
-0.0470360704,
-0.0519211143,
0.0313062258,
0.0052919327,
0.0045921812,
0.0149102109,
0.0747432038,
0.0426462218,
-0.0443353094,
0.007972816,
-0.0435401425,
-0.0106967511,
0.0192357693,
0.0705816746,
-0.0127713187,
-0.0463573411,
-0.0619560406,
0.0406516045,
0.0027748914,
-0.0133228106,
-0.0299622416,
-0.0623962358,
-0.0036408994,
0.0182416458,
-0.0334996991,
0.0341452472,
-0.0433115996,
-0.0511582531,
0.0515526421,
-0.0730130523,
-0.0263038091,
0.0156887714,
2.392e-7,
0.0337561406,
-0.015665926,
-0.0185909029,
0.0120440414,
0.0174497087,
0.0465369262,
-0.0664621145,
0.0448824577,
0.0048128832,
0.0127583928,
-0.0054506254,
0.0396008156,
0.051588621,
0.0304553229,
-0.021206351,
0.0141941216,
-0.0435926765,
0.0162408724,
-0.0311279576,
-0.0195557643,
0.0102026584,
0.0739313439,
-0.0482951663,
-0.0269712713,
0.0373149477,
-0.0371935815,
0.1300581098,
0.0065529095,
-0.0244082715,
-0.0091065606,
-0.0142589295,
-0.0031791015,
-0.0290525164,
-0.0456600599,
-0.0002414283,
-0.0276493747,
0.0664376467,
0.0322499499,
-0.0039580232,
-0.0329292901,
0.0264840219,
0.0317829363,
-0.0417898148,
-0.0286952592,
0.063185662,
-0.0396044441,
-0.0234928671,
-0.0222717337,
-0.0036104384,
0.0339005254,
0.0329232737,
-0.0572750494,
-0.0647484064,
0.0394997001,
0.0594760254,
0.00537143,
-0.0471141376,
-0.0206366945,
-0.0897362903,
-0.0062736492,
-0.0253125448,
-0.0274327025,
-0.0430407189,
-0.0362693518,
-0.0130259255,
-0.0320916697,
-0.0253093634,
1.590830484e-34,
0.0202960707,
-0.0290685985,
0.0072800629,
-0.0102442931,
-0.0071877441,
-0.0247574951,
-0.0311393421,
-0.0152052315,
-0.0185810681,
-0.0350038707,
-0.0388745591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12033v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12033v1 | PREFER: Prompt Ensemble Learning via Feedback-Reflect-Refine | 2023-08-23T09:46:37 | 2023-08-23T09:46:37 | Chenrui Zhang, Lin Liu, Jinpeng Wang, Chuyuan Wang, Xiao Sun, Hongyu Wang, Mingchen Cai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As an effective tool for eliciting the power of Large Language Models (LLMs),
prompting has recently demonstrated unprecedented abilities across a variety of
complex tasks. To further improve the performance, prompt ensemble has
attracted substantial interest for tackling the hallucination and instability
of LLMs. However, existing methods usually adopt a two-stage paradigm, which
requires a pre-prepared set of prompts with substantial manual effort, and is
unable to perform directed optimization for different weak learners. In this
paper, we propose a simple, universal, and automatic method named PREFER (Pompt
Ensemble learning via Feedback-Reflect-Refine) to address the stated
limitations. Specifically, given the fact that weak learners are supposed to
focus on hard examples during boosting, PREFER builds a feedback mechanism for
reflecting on the inadequacies of existing weak learners. Based on this, the
LLM is required to automatically synthesize new prompts for iterative
refinement. Moreover, to enhance stability of the prompt effect evaluation, we
propose a novel prompt bagging method involving forward and backward thinking,
which is superior to majority voting and is beneficial for both feedback and
weight calculation in boosting. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our
PREFER achieves state-of-the-art performance in multiple types of tasks by a
significant margin. We have made our code publicly available. | [
0.0236091651,
0.0436936319,
0.0227533579,
0.0187422652,
-0.0389740169,
0.0133021018,
-0.0162436981,
-0.0277029816,
-0.0032527021,
-0.0489463918,
-0.0405308716,
-0.0687886029,
0.0196991116,
0.0011007886,
0.0233508293,
-0.0299044158,
0.0430313349,
-0.0459094159,
-0.0232803766,
-0.022869423,
-0.0238259677,
0.0168185569,
-0.0106745036,
0.0907808542,
0.0318189412,
-0.0365071483,
-0.0074220779,
0.0035636423,
-0.0034298135,
-0.0240162425,
0.0222634487,
0.105729185,
0.0010230084,
0.0376458801,
0.0000022183,
-0.0513212681,
-0.0309156105,
-0.0116551435,
-0.0395607799,
0.0012699363,
0.0118172709,
0.0416737869,
-0.0087104533,
0.0174665973,
-0.0291328672,
-0.0277215298,
0.0416033231,
0.0259995237,
0.0562018976,
0.0647838712,
0.0213977061,
0.0257657729,
-0.0103980582,
-0.0395353921,
-0.0143366111,
-0.010542294,
0.0449472293,
-0.0660111234,
0.0132299792,
0.0058437493,
-0.011529767,
0.0364648513,
0.0145993857,
-0.0420898944,
0.0308799222,
0.0055331448,
-0.0723267794,
-0.0178016126,
-0.0382866822,
0.075567551,
-0.0026413845,
-0.0192472581,
-0.0348228961,
-0.0038458456,
0.0165005233,
0.0041064862,
-0.0305823125,
0.0005565888,
0.0023872994,
0.0343793742,
-0.0119124651,
0.0185230337,
0.0422605835,
0.0281537306,
-0.0216089655,
0.0626152307,
0.0029952198,
-0.0261262879,
0.0083082961,
0.0313916765,
-0.0522713624,
-0.025812665,
-0.0143198362,
-0.0027971757,
-0.0532181486,
-0.0030797326,
-0.0132067241,
-0.0226071123,
0.0001223612,
0.0402911603,
0.0834089294,
0.0240151025,
-0.0594813265,
0.0611972995,
-0.0289354846,
0.0253514182,
0.0370516106,
0.0109500755,
-0.03465591,
0.0287129488,
-0.0535062626,
0.0166209526,
-0.0482218824,
0.0199223515,
-0.019357089,
-0.0211074222,
-0.0282683112,
-0.0017074663,
-0.0255412254,
0.0143907871,
0.0389769599,
-0.0046162475,
-0.0123831118,
-0.00137551,
0.0233375989,
0.0408790931,
0.0079661878,
-0.0013015551,
0.0209535174,
-0.0878451467,
-0.0185244493,
0.0148159126,
-0.0286434833,
-0.0150700388,
0.0024512929,
0.0050132032,
-0.0099690538,
-0.0438894555,
-0.0074127167,
0.0253893659,
-0.0239757001,
-0.0526278242,
-0.0465655588,
-0.0634440929,
0.0201110989,
0.0069575398,
0.0278503709,
0.0038932408,
0.0143449865,
-0.0027805849,
-0.0032793786,
0.0555884019,
-0.0219767503,
0.0307448022,
0.0052693095,
-0.0047961315,
-0.0616950877,
0.0726807415,
-0.0054921387,
0.0334538072,
0.0138615649,
0.0137814237,
0.0309914034,
0.0460408106,
0.0124428328,
0.012426652,
-0.0153513514,
-0.016632,
0.0114834392,
-0.0038293898,
-0.0125200376,
0.0413091294,
-0.0348456278,
0.0200331379,
0.0743496642,
-0.0186873302,
0.0206017252,
-0.012127229,
0.0335341319,
0.0022375539,
0.0075136982,
-0.0027148691,
-0.0585086457,
-0.0082665998,
-0.0642962158,
-0.0177204721,
0.0080947038,
0.0643172637,
-0.0224327147,
-0.0301418658,
0.0103053497,
0.0065073306,
-0.0361811072,
0.060410887,
0.0525117256,
0.0280841459,
-0.044609081,
0.0118570812,
0.02580918,
-0.0320622213,
-0.0009642383,
-0.0714934468,
0.0578505136,
0.0681235492,
0.0489421114,
-0.0238276888,
0.0031976027,
-0.0386797339,
0.0294166058,
0.0048125824,
0.0331951603,
-0.0270801038,
0.0253883582,
-0.0559548065,
-0.0312320516,
0.0376682691,
0.0183074009,
0.0285709426,
0.0225807056,
-0.0228220001,
-0.0134986211,
0.0268258024,
-0.037701495,
0.0536063686,
0.0206671041,
-0.0184235666,
0.0257999953,
-0.0007183023,
0.0335857421,
0.018167261,
-0.0169993993,
0.0143677406,
0.0080825472,
-0.0320961177,
-0.0382690057,
0.0006793795,
-0.0701549575,
-0.0945473611,
0.0358090773,
0.0549433269,
-0.0140165901,
0.0121832881,
-0.0480298102,
-0.0506004877,
-0.0129336175,
-0.0051162001,
-0.0072725806,
-0.0539844856,
0.0760056451,
-0.0454937518,
0.0018314145,
-0.0688907281,
0.0460149199,
-0.0028758084,
0.0200321004,
0.018451808,
0.0357434079,
0.0123701431,
-0.0388424098,
-0.0584084764,
0.0351155475,
0.0054091602,
0.0000118312,
0.0183765572,
-0.0100547569,
-0.0347714163,
-0.0164482519,
-0.097313799,
-0.0159973465,
-0.0507461764,
-0.0221398026,
-0.0178398192,
0.0071088341,
-0.0301270131,
-0.0370280333,
-0.0074803215,
-0.0261808056,
-0.004206337,
0.0096582128,
-0.0148082161,
0.0182181299,
-0.0198645294,
-0.0143940262,
-0.015320085,
0.0149508398,
0.0457115509,
-0.0217010472,
-0.0610332452,
-0.0734731406,
-0.0083534783,
-0.0004142618,
0.0060923141,
-0.0088296393,
0.0124732731,
0.0061854254,
-0.0520401485,
0.0606141351,
0.0545887761,
0.0354735889,
0.0001521111,
0.052357208,
0.0195991285,
-0.0717994422,
0.0042848368,
-0.0330079682,
-0.015810702,
0.0012615852,
-0.0024147336,
0.024581898,
0.0400735699,
0.0131329512,
-0.0132799363,
-0.0617509969,
0.0038863556,
-0.0187288597,
-0.0263337176,
-0.0677040219,
-0.0392852537,
-0.0100518325,
-0.0086511644,
-0.0244798474,
-0.0653954372,
0.0986807197,
-0.0375285521,
-0.0311408062,
-0.0501465686,
-0.0064687575,
-0.0368111506,
0.0351756886,
-0.0139409322,
0.0064827758,
0.0332303159,
-0.014747072,
-0.0333520509,
-0.03227368,
0.011374387,
-0.045585908,
0.0514516756,
-0.0356531069,
0.0287599657,
-0.0046282071,
-0.0629694834,
-0.052765727,
-0.0717713088,
-0.0100638196,
0.0230006278,
-0.0096775116,
-0.0228364617,
-0.006441013,
0.018276656,
0.005828097,
0.0442119837,
-0.0593360327,
0.0042870375,
0.0039640693,
0.0148607381,
0.0432198048,
0.0162374582,
0.014631696,
-0.0535683781,
0.0743200853,
0.0150266103,
0.0657374114,
0.0155293196,
-0.0684863552,
0.0034947286,
0.0485946089,
0.0052798842,
-0.0005705894,
0.0010693998,
0.0895645842,
-0.0412906148,
0.0139488904,
0.0947251767,
0.0309413802,
-0.0734706372,
0.0050985608,
-0.0145234959,
0.0592625476,
0.0205039307,
0.0322971866,
-0.0234849174,
-0.0471174158,
0.0188082997,
0.0619360097,
-0.0160902701,
-0.0248840787,
-0.0060279993,
-0.1336352974,
0.0532709323,
0.030720856,
-0.038206026,
0.0176472683,
-0.0296876393,
0.0137036545,
-0.0291576441,
0.0216695648,
0.0350133926,
0.0103496183,
0.0126964059,
0.0417235307,
0.0133684585,
-0.0703174025,
0.0005561654,
-0.0562273115,
0.0680331588,
0.1026165411,
-0.0017606153,
0.0262353886,
0.0049009016,
0.0104844291,
-0.0263318978,
0.0092527866,
-0.0261357501,
0.0228312574,
0.0100487061,
-0.0110074487,
0.0243151132,
0.0389581397,
-0.0210918318,
0.0008853415,
0.0236654952,
0.0556174889,
-0.0412531607,
-0.0020342285,
0.0027745441,
-0.0218512844,
0.0635752082,
0.0812556148,
0.0307251122,
-0.0581763424,
-0.0008871169,
-0.0080460943,
-0.0335212052,
-0.0430458337,
0.004082555,
0.0270439778,
0.0111118192,
0.0177469421,
-0.0710798874,
0.0004191686,
0.0571210459,
0.058853481,
-0.005416444,
0.0495474301,
-0.0754585639,
0.0311624371,
0.0013601331,
0.0738631636,
-0.0125685474,
0.0470388271,
-0.0717564449,
-0.0374681465,
0.0397930853,
-0.0011029055,
0.0026234956,
0.0211943481,
-0.0376310423,
-0.0571999177,
0.0058870553,
0.0553534403,
0.0181825068,
0.0285663381,
-0.0277547017,
-0.0603790134,
0.0597581565,
0.0725862384,
0.0188800227,
0.0110787852,
0.0124970814,
-0.0216876324,
-0.032461036,
0.0413858406,
-0.0228984281,
0.0402078368,
0.0332223549,
0.0497314744,
0.013738662,
0.0025740101,
0.0256131925,
0.0235003307,
0.0274149384,
-0.0612697899,
-0.0289734993,
-0.0383052714,
0.0115611656,
0.0269553866,
-0.0380223989,
-0.0599356256,
0.0475338213,
0.047531005,
-0.0471404046,
0.0023435468,
0.0065197712,
0.0090609798,
0.0373749509,
-0.0691257045,
0.0436981283,
0.0022157629,
0.0126339654,
0.0488189086,
0.019347474,
-0.0199840702,
0.0149056027,
0.0174812451,
-0.0015580341,
-0.0008496764,
0.0655496791,
0.0329721719,
-0.0127674546,
-0.0074038496,
0.0511498749,
-0.0707856715,
-0.0529330149,
-0.0427004248,
0.0583665371,
0.0278426372,
-0.0076222452,
0.0499957316,
-0.0005270854,
-0.0008181032,
-0.0368408635,
-0.0154037317,
0.0216562971,
-0.0309041329,
0.0329610854,
0.0307897404,
-0.0126847271,
0.0467895232,
0.0625141561,
-0.0597298406,
0.0249842461,
-0.0035873756,
0.0244589467,
-0.0512516648,
-0.0244091712,
0.0265226122,
0.0021068077,
-0.0439371914,
0.0199233983,
-0.0215175152,
-0.0149257714,
-0.0086169709,
-0.0178728476,
-0.008945372,
-0.0098814229,
0.0306157172,
0.0451479293,
-0.0353278778,
0.006865622,
-0.0621667802,
-0.0055977749,
-0.0085205492,
-0.0043948144,
-0.0438068435,
-6.678243485e-33,
-0.0235047676,
-0.0076527088,
-0.0061503076,
-0.0357956253,
-0.0191163756,
-0.0107018491,
-0.0273154955,
0.0062034815,
-0.0017369671,
-0.0120093022,
-0.0417772643,
0.0060169655,
0.0255019478,
0.0324141979,
0.0048595169,
0.0027529502,
0.074691847,
-0.0040847599,
-0.0572751388,
0.0336443707,
0.0222388282,
0.047013998,
0.0020205949,
-0.0468126684,
0.0198201183,
0.0018327923,
-0.0621584505,
0.0250328127,
-0.0260121264,
0.0369617715,
0.0064956518,
0.0201406106,
0.0030490172,
-0.074951008,
-0.0364683867,
0.01740974,
-0.037227992,
0.0025598365,
-0.0054765306,
0.0117021129,
-0.0320734978,
0.0156823583,
0.0050148359,
-0.0209939107,
-0.0048270463,
0.0227675457,
-0.0032301822,
-0.0548984855,
-0.038615305,
-0.0060024844,
-0.0268579945,
0.0311574731,
0.0127322339,
-0.0384585932,
0.0079482179,
0.0653287843,
-0.0314188674,
0.047071591,
0.0065878076,
0.0268552937,
0.0319377109,
0.0426670648,
0.044661101,
0.0630071461,
0.0022263243,
0.0540293045,
0.0261505246,
-0.0242388453,
0.0065334518,
-0.0377841406,
0.0306380577,
0.0278725494,
0.0836765468,
0.0282949191,
0.0325804539,
0.0363117792,
-0.0244577099,
0.0283306558,
0.0752708763,
-0.0251746252,
0.0465681478,
0.0097777583,
-0.0250646062,
-0.0355400518,
-0.0475237742,
-0.0388487466,
-0.0385360718,
-0.0237284731,
0.0286463704,
0.0383085385,
-0.0556183755,
-0.0055032345,
0.0507775359,
-0.0275314189,
-0.0350005962,
0.0078957332,
-0.0124019636,
0.0179603025,
0.0074600801,
0.011073566,
-0.0489374101,
-0.0279292036,
0.0552217811,
0.0017197556,
-0.0149789406,
-0.0031593246,
0.0618382543,
0.0521681271,
-0.0549427867,
-0.00240146,
-0.0133490944,
0.0311309099,
-0.0014505133,
0.0691988096,
0.0298755504,
-0.0001537505,
0.0004738812,
0.0371102653,
-0.0005873449,
-0.0011479516,
-0.0112753194,
-0.0264776722,
-0.0105349123,
0.0239835083,
-0.0193948951,
0.0013500554,
-0.0063534244,
-0.0169481747,
0.0228180494,
-0.032447271,
-0.0095059872,
0.0124829495,
2.824e-7,
0.0113482829,
0.0216978695,
-0.0075545833,
-0.0436753891,
-0.0010017769,
0.016241705,
-0.052939564,
-0.019423699,
0.0117387902,
-0.0136180716,
0.0020893544,
0.004160644,
0.0776113644,
0.0046948637,
-0.1225481629,
-0.002326949,
-0.0639012828,
0.0244373884,
-0.0683316067,
-0.0147209605,
0.0103285452,
0.1112446487,
0.0041687256,
-0.0304603167,
0.0009488869,
-0.0331371799,
0.0470580831,
-0.0292885453,
-0.0107383607,
0.0325777791,
0.0764454901,
-0.0299182851,
0.0066998433,
0.0166095868,
-0.0029727404,
0.0284513496,
-0.0083108572,
0.030580245,
0.001531302,
-0.011483673,
-0.0029749207,
0.0272347853,
0.0245783348,
-0.0414144807,
0.0629823878,
-0.0592017323,
-0.01303948,
-0.0667736977,
0.0132069383,
-0.0303309765,
0.0277564172,
-0.0347349271,
0.0115319369,
0.057907477,
0.0268778987,
-0.011609681,
-0.0249845218,
-0.0853015184,
-0.0405151062,
-0.031568408,
-0.0370178781,
-0.0466694273,
-0.0191593729,
0.0097559663,
-0.0342042074,
-0.0716471747,
0.0083908718,
2.836795262e-34,
0.0650491044,
-0.0214911886,
-0.0026251646,
0.0413625948,
0.0093139354,
-0.0176613014,
0.0196224954,
0.0259941332,
0.0049974555,
-0.0745538175,
-0.0096611278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12032v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12032v5 | From Quantity to Quality: Boosting LLM Performance with Self-Guided Data Selection for Instruction Tuning | 2023-08-23T09:45:29 | 2024-04-06T03:52:04 | Ming Li, Yong Zhang, Zhitao Li, Jiuhai Chen, Lichang Chen, Ning Cheng, Jianzong Wang, Tianyi Zhou, Jing Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the realm of Large Language Models (LLMs), the balance between instruction
data quality and quantity is a focal point. Recognizing this, we introduce a
self-guided methodology for LLMs to autonomously discern and select cherry
samples from open-source datasets, effectively minimizing manual curation and
potential cost for instruction tuning an LLM. Our key innovation, the
Instruction-Following Difficulty (IFD) metric, emerges as a pivotal metric to
identify discrepancies between a model's expected responses and its intrinsic
generation capability. Through the application of IFD, cherry samples can be
pinpointed, leading to a marked uptick in model training efficiency. Empirical
validations on datasets like Alpaca and WizardLM underpin our findings; with a
mere $10\%$ of original data input, our strategy showcases improved results.
This synthesis of self-guided cherry-picking and the IFD metric signifies a
transformative leap in the instruction tuning of LLMs, promising both
efficiency and resource-conscious advancements. Codes, data, and models are
available: https://github.com/tianyi-lab/Cherry_LLM | [
0.0186071359,
0.083642289,
-0.0058823624,
0.0577111915,
-0.0153544648,
0.0242696106,
-0.0152558973,
0.0036556348,
-0.0161940027,
-0.0579996407,
-0.0590938516,
-0.0101411687,
-0.0413339436,
-0.0253447704,
0.0212155916,
-0.0137874084,
0.049552355,
-0.0555658527,
-0.0530501418,
-0.0077633667,
-0.0261619445,
0.0315857194,
-0.0190092139,
0.0210905112,
0.0023676662,
-0.0120684886,
-0.0083464347,
0.0433415063,
-0.0125157246,
-0.0358838513,
0.0276902579,
0.0579422861,
0.0094859684,
0.0395714715,
0.0000022157,
-0.0614808314,
-0.0102402642,
-0.0131526859,
-0.0377155729,
0.0429841205,
0.0348013267,
-0.0208183732,
-0.0280204285,
0.0356694087,
-0.0109771397,
0.0292177163,
0.0182720702,
0.0044067423,
0.0373520367,
0.0920751467,
0.0287572686,
0.0032134808,
0.0202835165,
-0.0064504505,
0.0275688544,
0.0066420021,
0.0102839526,
0.0063417139,
-0.013628372,
0.0175657012,
-0.029599892,
0.0031559551,
0.0292685945,
0.0178927984,
-0.0399387144,
0.0195988659,
-0.0474739224,
-0.0173953995,
-0.0169608351,
0.0610323213,
-0.0083988234,
-0.0020685811,
-0.0261371154,
-0.0187617857,
0.0006537403,
-0.0011794412,
-0.0261118673,
0.0529665723,
0.0194964763,
0.0403364561,
0.0235381126,
-0.0138800554,
0.0180863366,
-0.0034468663,
-0.0191346072,
0.0478405543,
0.0260274056,
-0.0371417217,
0.0115577215,
-0.0005849509,
-0.0114330426,
-0.0126475906,
-0.0239110384,
0.0471888967,
-0.0325467288,
0.0214192737,
-0.0754258409,
-0.0037983917,
0.0378079712,
-0.0110963723,
0.0784266144,
0.0394427404,
-0.0339163356,
0.014828572,
-0.0211232118,
0.0316596963,
0.0301476661,
0.0729854405,
-0.0249883048,
0.0258727446,
-0.0316791087,
0.0240553189,
-0.0355987772,
-0.0033134713,
-0.0255557504,
0.0282224752,
-0.0483447649,
0.0249826238,
-0.0164296366,
-0.0066047818,
0.0385866463,
-0.0354880281,
-0.0573046468,
0.0164604839,
-0.0128121153,
-0.0061032027,
-0.0380828157,
0.007126824,
0.0046383129,
-0.0700512752,
-0.0160363372,
0.0238327626,
-0.0150771812,
-0.0212555975,
0.034640789,
0.1069133505,
-0.0061151055,
-0.0374328792,
-0.0742592737,
-0.0179277286,
0.0014611793,
-0.0600314438,
-0.0057641463,
-0.0665957406,
0.00818522,
0.0033273958,
0.0117299538,
-0.0268571321,
0.0170612819,
0.0080936877,
-0.0078663621,
0.0026441596,
-0.0212873258,
0.010337906,
0.0068983678,
0.0090186791,
0.0137739023,
0.0831064135,
0.0404054038,
0.0046751592,
0.0583514608,
-0.0144020319,
0.0071081058,
0.0379272848,
0.0158556439,
0.0272338428,
-0.0266524851,
0.0079574538,
0.0181052964,
-0.0040648296,
0.081629701,
0.0398708619,
-0.0130739035,
-0.0339572728,
0.0679950565,
-0.0041177301,
0.0188280046,
-0.0013577738,
0.0639049932,
0.0247155391,
0.0096486034,
0.0431373902,
-0.0524049774,
0.0211504325,
-0.0287595373,
0.0199596826,
0.0299202595,
0.0469617471,
-0.0330314264,
-0.0806055218,
-0.0172983836,
-0.0050970404,
-0.0369290076,
0.0216207039,
0.0453917086,
-0.0048967162,
-0.0452768877,
0.0228107348,
0.0545454994,
-0.0415547788,
-0.0155562907,
-0.0751109496,
0.029143475,
0.0401198156,
0.0306757074,
-0.0289607979,
-0.0200773831,
0.0074856193,
0.0170699861,
0.0266605951,
0.0297402199,
-0.0195867606,
0.0295147114,
-0.0525734201,
-0.016183747,
-0.0181402806,
0.031223299,
0.0053685787,
0.0425040349,
-0.0054155518,
0.0122444769,
-0.0312162191,
-0.0650129616,
0.0686754286,
-0.0396074951,
-0.0740260631,
-0.008562916,
-0.0065532285,
0.0253081638,
-0.0133543732,
-0.0090740444,
-0.0099277813,
0.0450554155,
-0.0013037369,
0.0301578417,
-0.03847057,
-0.0391906425,
-0.0269308612,
0.0271687601,
0.0143045252,
-0.0306312516,
0.0393105336,
-0.0844354331,
-0.02839428,
0.0011619575,
-0.0409551077,
0.0156508349,
-0.0413979888,
0.0418630987,
0.0027297863,
0.0150885209,
-0.0467681997,
0.0401874669,
-0.0321180187,
0.0394784212,
0.0149357626,
0.0000191539,
0.0134579744,
-0.050408531,
-0.0043751197,
-0.0253715944,
-0.0233819205,
0.0421168059,
-0.0008204645,
0.0604672246,
-0.0556222498,
-0.0477049015,
-0.0561838448,
0.0135300718,
-0.0478453673,
0.022939695,
0.0334951282,
-0.0273918975,
-0.0439237282,
-0.0071564782,
-0.0091473367,
-0.0237155408,
0.0057409178,
0.00841452,
0.0293989945,
0.0233558938,
-0.0373661071,
-0.0581122562,
-0.0147631308,
0.0089721205,
-0.0047907215,
-0.0177953783,
0.0504516996,
-0.0731243044,
0.0514593497,
-0.0076232925,
0.0295558348,
-0.0225546546,
-0.0520214885,
0.0144917956,
-0.0102813775,
0.0288728066,
0.0627452657,
-0.0023879658,
0.0302911941,
0.0574422143,
-0.0112253884,
-0.0726042241,
0.0223699193,
-0.0177427717,
-0.0522117801,
-0.0422014184,
-0.0602141656,
0.007725866,
0.1048486754,
-0.0039804787,
-0.0340950824,
-0.0102321617,
0.0016788456,
-0.0082060266,
-0.0059626666,
0.0000439405,
0.0409833416,
-0.0021552085,
0.0218474865,
-0.0209446978,
-0.0900605023,
0.0581016168,
-0.050980445,
0.0038473813,
-0.0420262925,
-0.0240922309,
-0.0468377583,
0.021836102,
0.0224062018,
0.0125695849,
-0.0067290245,
0.0057076658,
-0.0662501156,
0.0309484415,
0.0013820576,
-0.0131272292,
0.0457380973,
-0.0758728459,
-0.0087996284,
-0.0129243983,
-0.0167389438,
-0.0380382761,
-0.0266279019,
0.0215551332,
0.0032664991,
0.0187245496,
-0.0391865,
-0.0009570462,
-0.0391818434,
0.0006594337,
0.0449781716,
-0.0123287281,
-0.0156096872,
-0.0304353796,
-0.0112737603,
0.0322806574,
0.0091131171,
0.0257699173,
-0.0547068156,
0.0270828288,
0.0377445854,
0.0508104227,
0.0149610834,
-0.0140728392,
0.0317924917,
0.0455292985,
-0.0440277867,
-0.0070717391,
0.0522708744,
0.0825138837,
-0.0575000346,
-0.0266321655,
0.1249310449,
0.043490082,
-0.032413248,
0.0215495583,
-0.0007991797,
0.061851345,
0.0439685509,
0.0567373,
-0.0575136542,
-0.021146765,
-0.0031195534,
0.0669502616,
-0.0272783376,
-0.0075891376,
0.0026493566,
-0.1395888776,
0.0749497935,
0.0062333909,
-0.052686099,
-0.009232318,
-0.0502095819,
-0.0265225023,
-0.0099131605,
0.0353612937,
0.0227827076,
-0.0624151677,
0.0152147133,
0.0501410514,
-0.0065299566,
-0.0814511999,
0.0261852015,
-0.0132820997,
0.0715744272,
0.0310942475,
0.0084833996,
0.0157860927,
-0.0081532793,
0.043406561,
-0.00698255,
-0.012320797,
-0.0219475683,
0.0687861815,
0.0054619373,
0.0010077555,
0.011961381,
0.0391593017,
-0.0242106281,
0.023971783,
0.0161574371,
0.0443479829,
0.0062714345,
0.0062496755,
-0.0206764825,
-0.0269364156,
0.0178188737,
0.0707824081,
0.0540769584,
-0.0398830883,
-0.0242774207,
-0.0565778799,
-0.0279895868,
-0.0809451789,
-0.0050537759,
0.0704556555,
-0.057280872,
-0.025489971,
-0.0554926433,
-0.0519424044,
0.0456441641,
0.0082519548,
0.0032513307,
-0.0221422408,
-0.0418107994,
-0.0085067404,
-0.0291633699,
0.041900564,
-0.0448896438,
-0.0046266718,
-0.122631751,
-0.0718959793,
0.0265447814,
-0.0029617064,
-0.0138121406,
0.0068262187,
-0.0796171352,
-0.0541468151,
-0.0000010146,
0.0858358815,
0.0164316408,
0.0470556989,
0.0325983725,
-0.0411634967,
0.0394949131,
0.0365024433,
-0.0330543071,
0.0254890788,
0.0472764894,
-0.0136680156,
-0.014590227,
0.0207919274,
-0.0323467553,
0.0573450103,
0.0304315072,
0.0551494136,
-0.0488217585,
0.0036573422,
0.0197995752,
0.0081173517,
0.0210288074,
-0.0118107423,
0.0192599222,
-0.0405678637,
0.0384945869,
-0.0015781595,
0.0091741094,
-0.065270111,
-0.0084491288,
0.0005918281,
-0.0254817754,
-0.01237504,
-0.0158067066,
-0.0116388425,
0.0448789634,
-0.0554226339,
0.0242314972,
0.0025413241,
0.0539380312,
0.0287160575,
0.0115639372,
-0.0160890892,
0.0187418666,
0.0097327521,
0.0440333821,
0.0101329219,
0.059481822,
-0.0144556146,
0.0489390977,
-0.0009026979,
0.0036795868,
-0.0358999483,
-0.0311380811,
-0.0598351844,
0.0221079253,
0.0393463261,
-0.0355162621,
0.051944878,
-0.018610863,
0.0028028728,
-0.0280275904,
0.0111993952,
-0.0083527593,
-0.0311073363,
0.0225983188,
0.0298478715,
-0.0134674264,
-0.0050717657,
0.0969936103,
0.0425605848,
0.0632771924,
-0.0056357761,
0.0255220775,
-0.0388646945,
-0.0351966769,
0.0407712087,
-0.0228438415,
-0.0024415646,
0.0066721821,
-0.0327404179,
-0.0679922178,
-0.0190927107,
0.0428244062,
0.0221362468,
-0.0207744595,
0.0410909951,
0.040889252,
-0.0371393077,
0.0085216193,
-0.057496123,
-0.0288844481,
-0.0100895278,
-0.0342650488,
-0.0109543875,
-6.492995126e-33,
-0.0487905592,
-0.0136044044,
0.0347503684,
0.0119141918,
0.012760899,
-0.0048665507,
-0.0264652707,
0.0161576606,
-0.0110009471,
-0.0036997069,
-0.0018795701,
-0.0149531579,
0.0040741577,
0.0380901881,
0.0207133424,
0.0255945213,
0.043896731,
-0.034106005,
-0.0300433431,
0.0150290709,
0.0092392238,
0.022277575,
0.0392902717,
-0.0270457901,
-0.0077287247,
-0.0122991316,
0.0084258309,
0.0081876013,
-0.0344249271,
0.0676027238,
-0.0031497222,
0.047613591,
0.0085576503,
-0.0315371267,
-0.0365652181,
-0.055548735,
-0.0463042744,
-0.0534192063,
-0.0131994365,
0.0114618605,
-0.0154769076,
-0.0257912036,
0.0121698948,
-0.0038310064,
-0.0408347957,
-0.0222347621,
0.0233583134,
-0.0370586626,
-0.0430525318,
-0.0030238123,
-0.0434335619,
0.0210668445,
-0.0143766059,
-0.0316846222,
0.0034968413,
0.0475364178,
0.0093730148,
0.0177516658,
-0.0331042372,
0.0320589803,
0.0427612849,
0.081086114,
0.0740117207,
0.0228992272,
-0.0020549302,
0.0326859839,
0.0105896397,
-0.0156821627,
0.0259990823,
0.0191055201,
0.0529014505,
0.0699912384,
0.0135155432,
0.0254358575,
0.045334626,
0.0054526539,
-0.0982574373,
0.0497300625,
0.0146713313,
-0.0010084388,
0.0137397796,
0.00752177,
-0.0377816409,
-0.0056148814,
-0.0315083973,
0.004203965,
-0.0194184147,
-0.0210077446,
0.0587398224,
0.0227919351,
-0.05572078,
-0.0398150347,
0.0262225252,
-0.0119593544,
-0.0394776352,
-0.0200246964,
-0.037303824,
0.0356982276,
-0.0125937574,
0.0127142742,
-0.0509373881,
-0.0645336732,
0.0044979034,
-0.049574811,
0.0412656553,
0.0112566352,
0.0482816808,
0.0226533562,
-0.0794119611,
0.0159705151,
-0.0382867269,
0.0504469573,
-0.0011141252,
0.0368734524,
0.004745292,
-0.0344445929,
-0.0007623085,
0.0575273484,
-0.0126632545,
-0.0314496905,
-0.0521501638,
-0.0164945796,
-0.0146937175,
0.0193004385,
-0.0192062631,
0.0037470649,
-0.0233994611,
-0.0100884894,
-0.025996007,
-0.0470977686,
-0.0102116615,
0.0094342008,
2.728e-7,
0.0251561254,
0.0372152776,
0.0069622109,
0.0458599553,
-0.0041405759,
0.0114726266,
-0.0483763553,
-0.0045242258,
0.0061814808,
-0.0191763528,
-0.0093000568,
0.0501117036,
0.079868339,
0.0463414043,
-0.063171491,
0.0227608345,
-0.018555792,
0.0289393235,
-0.0503861308,
-0.0124218399,
0.0068671387,
0.0743250698,
-0.0155248716,
-0.0136823198,
0.0032651573,
-0.0145278601,
0.029646717,
-0.0385105833,
0.0041234936,
0.047678411,
0.0297986194,
0.0373000205,
-0.0084902933,
-0.0078671621,
-0.0392428562,
-0.0073047956,
-0.0479204282,
0.0761293694,
0.0110184392,
-0.0477974787,
0.0504966117,
0.0028749495,
-0.0052218158,
-0.0480301157,
0.0426162966,
-0.0171287823,
-0.0054789088,
0.0087542646,
0.0312892869,
-0.0341472253,
0.0234492254,
-0.0633544102,
0.0082083857,
0.0291112177,
0.0335597172,
-0.043840453,
-0.0145126572,
-0.0654247776,
-0.007409879,
-0.0094346702,
-0.0349429697,
-0.0628600121,
-0.0633090436,
0.0157404225,
-0.0003866957,
-0.0183225609,
-0.007538659,
2.924120487e-34,
0.0503247567,
-0.006622605,
0.0419786349,
0.0453118533,
0.0274196472,
0.0084854811,
0.0053318455,
0.0280257799,
-0.0224238858,
-0.056142956,
-0.0196270291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12030v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12030v2 | Prompt-Based Length Controlled Generation with Reinforcement Learning | 2023-08-23T09:43:10 | 2023-09-30T07:54:22 | Renlong Jie, Xiaojun Meng, Lifeng Shang, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT and GPT-4 have attracted great
attention given their surprising performance on a wide range of NLP tasks.
Length controlled generation of LLMs emerges as an important topic, which
enables users to fully leverage the capability of LLMs in more real-world
scenarios like generating a proper answer or essay of a desired length. In
addition, the autoregressive generation in LLMs is extremely time-consuming,
while the ability of controlling this generated length can reduce the inference
cost by limiting the length. Therefore, we propose a prompt-based length
control method to achieve high-accuracy length controlled generation. In
particular, we adopt reinforcement learning with the reward signal given by
either trainable or rule-based reward models, which further enhances the
length-control ability of LLMs by rewarding outputs that follows pre-defined
control instruction. To enable rule-based inference, we also introduce standard
prompt extractor to collect the standard control information from users' input.
Experiments show that our method significantly improves the accuracy of
prompt-based length control for summarization task on popular datasets like
CNNDM and NYT. Both the standard prompt extractor and the RL-tuned model have
show strong generalization ability to unseen control prompt templates. | [
0.0522534885,
0.0125875408,
0.0140232248,
-0.0055718212,
-0.0486260355,
-0.0144647798,
-0.001416354,
-0.0157884918,
-0.0144261839,
0.0071102483,
0.0265752338,
-0.0161255859,
-0.0225776285,
0.0328153037,
0.012551561,
-0.0829047561,
0.0458967984,
-0.0389510989,
0.0301984847,
0.0033243329,
0.0156552196,
-0.003058492,
0.0091346456,
0.0430825278,
-0.0204837508,
-0.0043752375,
-0.0321724527,
-0.0293587856,
-0.0033633602,
-0.0260588843,
0.0214365665,
0.0355990604,
0.011793361,
0.0246120822,
0.0000020206,
-0.0502839498,
-0.0471540578,
-0.0274139605,
-0.0013024247,
-0.0052881665,
0.0328261331,
-0.0227758884,
0.0125651909,
0.0377764069,
-0.0141961118,
0.0141725224,
0.022046851,
0.0550812073,
0.0740820095,
0.0957386121,
0.0151802078,
-0.0172563307,
0.0343701877,
-0.061803665,
0.0303127952,
-0.0244526304,
0.0124034118,
-0.0165152308,
0.0449795723,
0.0107205361,
-0.0342680551,
0.0151473107,
0.0474122465,
-0.0140726445,
-0.0156370196,
0.0252061449,
0.0230447333,
-0.0112597849,
-0.0206664596,
0.0579870157,
-0.0217805058,
-0.0143091716,
0.0447158329,
-0.0087707611,
0.0369080268,
0.0101337424,
-0.0515300184,
0.045327384,
-0.0089191198,
0.0175412819,
-0.0011078502,
0.0123234587,
-0.0180268809,
-0.0021875745,
-0.0303149708,
0.0369212069,
0.0021365199,
-0.0517329238,
-0.0319970325,
-0.0168962087,
-0.0120215304,
-0.0640008301,
-0.0087031368,
0.058354862,
-0.0645744652,
0.008402952,
-0.0698788166,
-0.0276353173,
0.0198741015,
0.0259426348,
0.0037171794,
0.0131249055,
0.0336591378,
0.0199697819,
-0.0492003001,
0.0742343888,
0.0049269679,
0.0318575613,
-0.0442675278,
-0.0005823081,
-0.0306436345,
-0.0130847953,
-0.0575291216,
0.0339390635,
-0.0351575762,
-0.0443629064,
-0.054418508,
0.0367797464,
0.0035159148,
0.0370399505,
0.010605678,
-0.0042129243,
-0.0242430083,
-0.0002213303,
-0.043684233,
0.0188597348,
-0.0556006692,
-0.0435026698,
0.0507005677,
-0.02174831,
-0.0133787896,
-0.0247871876,
0.0250620265,
-0.0083362972,
-0.0043526646,
0.0822173879,
-0.0300434828,
-0.0327257589,
-0.0084548695,
-0.0624334738,
-0.0410965718,
-0.0441520102,
0.0013371325,
-0.0757293254,
0.0076843197,
-0.0140225524,
-0.0195356421,
-0.0082139634,
0.0178301092,
0.0414353162,
-0.0267524347,
0.0213463008,
-0.0021261238,
0.0035405115,
0.0198085234,
-0.0130408918,
-0.0046062148,
0.0506456494,
0.0399853289,
0.066129081,
0.0397390462,
0.0330889449,
0.0283876453,
0.0316687115,
0.0376231484,
0.0054086237,
-0.0016572303,
-0.0078761335,
0.0222617481,
0.0103280554,
0.0478883423,
0.0683841035,
-0.018589437,
0.0178684406,
0.0531863198,
0.0503439456,
0.0234840121,
-0.0179600418,
0.0689435899,
0.0266166553,
0.0052271099,
0.0541079976,
-0.0349593498,
0.023834778,
-0.0221260488,
0.0598937981,
0.0771895051,
0.0204961672,
-0.0094098803,
-0.0477600135,
0.0187929068,
-0.0131367091,
-0.003358548,
0.0269613173,
0.0125360526,
0.0037995905,
-0.0498878509,
0.0031121781,
0.0235122796,
-0.036560867,
0.0028331825,
-0.0338843726,
0.0780449882,
0.0552302711,
0.0521549322,
-0.026895009,
-0.0059725731,
-0.0511504412,
0.0037631604,
0.0632946044,
0.0496120937,
-0.0024926544,
-0.0462357178,
-0.0241052471,
-0.0229296479,
-0.0031962437,
0.0009213436,
0.0183339454,
0.0404039659,
0.0114170304,
0.0290095378,
0.0374308415,
-0.0504497401,
0.0213022456,
-0.0179126803,
-0.0577313825,
-0.0029447584,
0.001932816,
0.0147529868,
0.0002277062,
-0.0083841588,
0.0317398682,
-0.0117966561,
-0.0263794307,
-0.0276458878,
-0.0321934447,
-0.0883498639,
-0.0620826893,
0.0369307362,
-0.0538322404,
0.0149909323,
0.0014865986,
-0.0319080018,
-0.0748849288,
-0.0064224368,
-0.0649452209,
0.025160443,
-0.0276975092,
-0.0063163657,
0.0333110616,
-0.0006971885,
-0.0493371263,
0.0601065718,
0.0002489343,
0.0193963125,
0.0618364364,
0.0087692477,
-0.0093161743,
-0.0599923208,
-0.0143953077,
0.0242978912,
0.0107242595,
0.0061045876,
0.0861652419,
0.0397575311,
-0.0227869824,
-0.0572711788,
-0.0349395685,
0.0206065606,
-0.0297470894,
-0.0004776591,
0.0107146539,
0.0238496568,
-0.0351256467,
-0.0217722617,
-0.0709042698,
-0.0614770576,
0.0466012247,
-0.0095235966,
0.0239175856,
0.010882386,
0.0083263321,
-0.0487140827,
-0.0119855125,
0.0023636241,
0.0255581085,
0.0123171601,
-0.0091404589,
-0.0354847573,
0.0162028503,
-0.0218345448,
0.0268580709,
0.0037327197,
-0.0179222655,
-0.0192784723,
-0.0445975773,
0.0847350061,
0.0450198501,
0.0570575111,
0.0179744717,
0.0137492046,
0.0146956882,
-0.049415011,
0.0400412939,
-0.0721838325,
-0.0302461144,
0.0133393174,
-0.0022302317,
0.0623101555,
0.0626541004,
0.0268294252,
0.0001256496,
-0.0670352057,
0.022594383,
-0.0003266019,
-0.0068118917,
-0.0317627005,
0.033106111,
-0.0522484295,
0.0267774556,
-0.0414225161,
-0.0474076644,
0.0676246285,
-0.0259837899,
0.0222960226,
-0.0533381887,
-0.0095548984,
-0.0487355702,
0.0432089344,
0.0416242927,
0.0249322895,
0.0044565178,
-0.0128546571,
-0.0344566032,
0.0060951547,
0.0375602916,
-0.026122978,
0.0529686511,
-0.0269166809,
0.0026327714,
-0.0174713302,
-0.0157842319,
-0.0478742458,
-0.0419280976,
-0.0014268481,
0.0173997656,
0.0344468802,
-0.0119318701,
0.0208074953,
-0.0061093522,
0.0648669749,
0.0476354733,
-0.0650212839,
0.0027715547,
-0.0402531922,
0.0292978566,
0.1161178574,
-0.0165489316,
-0.001155503,
-0.0526566878,
0.0241180528,
0.0145711405,
0.0071136523,
0.0177658424,
0.0005206771,
-0.0060952576,
-0.0024140947,
-0.087283209,
0.0022897068,
0.0605965815,
0.0555855259,
-0.057240326,
0.0024211621,
0.1233036742,
0.0349763297,
-0.0414737239,
-0.012230196,
0.0101987002,
0.049465958,
-0.0032739395,
0.0433243066,
-0.0686245039,
-0.0223956686,
0.0127406884,
0.035456229,
-0.0235829819,
-0.0392112471,
-0.0414568447,
-0.1312190592,
0.0096908454,
-0.0066733561,
-0.0489284918,
-0.0303154141,
-0.0097432267,
-0.0015626564,
0.0324231274,
0.0237357523,
0.0560662933,
-0.0418119282,
0.0253123231,
0.0341646336,
-0.0450790748,
0.0101025971,
-0.0225504786,
-0.0281943846,
0.0348134749,
0.0807369575,
0.0018446385,
0.0061692526,
-0.0156035982,
0.0088206409,
0.0105867917,
-0.0055066682,
0.0010966929,
0.0389169082,
-0.0087927235,
-0.0091600269,
-0.0115553429,
0.0827881843,
0.0254803617,
0.0192873515,
0.0370357409,
0.058017578,
0.0135602513,
-0.0141276913,
-0.0351410247,
0.0091933673,
0.0054161628,
0.075404942,
0.0467224307,
-0.0367772914,
-0.087114349,
-0.0387607552,
-0.0363677181,
-0.088413462,
0.004066329,
-0.0358244069,
-0.0174145158,
0.0046152854,
-0.0761791989,
-0.048341848,
0.0395601429,
0.010517315,
-0.0226466339,
-0.0088014845,
-0.0115209445,
0.0079884771,
-0.0271537472,
-0.0208811015,
-0.0423788279,
0.0179731809,
-0.0946134105,
-0.0028375578,
-0.0139271365,
-0.0574595332,
-0.0158068035,
0.0203809589,
-0.0623185746,
-0.0558964014,
-0.0306908023,
0.062961705,
0.0122229084,
0.0633483604,
0.0033042447,
-0.0054381434,
0.0726297423,
0.0268487111,
-0.0362913907,
0.0014321045,
0.0011483153,
0.0789935961,
-0.0120227039,
0.0231902096,
-0.0525585525,
0.0349176861,
0.0050208811,
0.0456382371,
0.015996512,
-0.0294290017,
0.0356153212,
0.0301193353,
-0.0019924347,
-0.0127252471,
0.0159386937,
-0.0339128822,
-0.0258695073,
-0.0165633988,
-0.0073749861,
-0.0316206738,
0.0397502631,
-0.0265823472,
-0.0176467542,
0.0206184033,
-0.0325273201,
-0.0010291121,
0.0207428504,
-0.0572244301,
0.0001913036,
-0.0321439132,
-0.0139096864,
0.0184885189,
-0.0004043902,
-0.0200362075,
-0.0095845163,
-0.0143570863,
0.0205804557,
-0.0093902694,
0.0581138283,
0.0512016714,
0.0019331666,
-0.0016102671,
0.0146872383,
-0.0759538114,
-0.0090202009,
-0.0249592923,
0.0644059926,
0.0507409349,
-0.0013713711,
0.0072225137,
-0.017464418,
-0.0032171868,
-0.0244525112,
0.042834606,
0.0136656621,
0.000842053,
0.0041918219,
0.0248897858,
-0.0060620098,
-0.0435526036,
0.083990097,
-0.0050230725,
0.0061546676,
0.0161877126,
-0.0102018435,
-0.0464264676,
-0.0038978953,
-0.0132972971,
0.0156365931,
0.0078659942,
-0.0005764147,
-0.0337177366,
-0.0205752719,
0.0033861666,
0.0414024442,
0.015911309,
-0.0087056467,
0.0654119477,
0.017565731,
-0.028738983,
-0.0219881795,
-0.0568917692,
0.0033171622,
0.0201023016,
-0.0170471538,
-0.0144486576,
-5.871515304e-33,
-0.0334828757,
-0.0139734549,
0.0308338758,
0.0253267139,
-0.050914526,
0.0234249681,
-0.0341425575,
-0.0232370328,
0.039229013,
-0.0110416738,
-0.0492420346,
-0.0340538099,
-0.002297502,
0.0534101985,
-0.0014065322,
-0.0239728391,
0.0463800468,
-0.0093432823,
-0.0439303443,
0.0424850732,
0.0467087515,
0.0332427286,
0.0195284635,
0.0224284213,
0.032059107,
0.0090151206,
0.0041999631,
-0.0022371933,
0.0128725125,
0.0434259772,
0.0066314954,
0.0247829854,
0.0200448018,
-0.0892068371,
-0.0544381402,
0.0627496764,
-0.094890818,
-0.0445324481,
0.0159314852,
-0.0410017744,
-0.0785740912,
-0.0536230914,
0.0203868132,
-0.0217113327,
0.0039252662,
-0.0265076384,
0.0429822952,
-0.0264524221,
-0.0268658306,
-0.0443608835,
-0.0276680328,
0.003568283,
0.0131267244,
-0.040263854,
0.006332526,
0.0388836712,
-0.0142217102,
0.0106459772,
0.023719253,
0.0317310989,
0.0689374804,
0.0560744703,
0.0278314222,
0.0335814245,
0.0056026718,
0.0356640927,
-0.0161815006,
-0.0346655585,
-0.0409491062,
0.0206345767,
-0.0064491397,
0.0071022869,
0.0212498661,
0.0174969267,
0.0294991247,
0.0021436466,
-0.0192575119,
0.0213308111,
0.0440622829,
0.0457952023,
0.0361763425,
-0.0198196694,
-0.0178307518,
-0.0039035701,
-0.0472135916,
0.0191662591,
0.0036611911,
-0.037280459,
0.0428587459,
0.0579096563,
-0.0167896599,
-0.0536090359,
0.0438310392,
-0.0060082399,
0.0057939393,
0.0277183261,
-0.0301043335,
0.0065133465,
-0.0070081293,
-0.0230022725,
-0.0484823696,
0.032523457,
0.0204513241,
-0.0299179778,
-0.0339030996,
0.0287678223,
0.0204225853,
0.0202590618,
-0.055119954,
0.0303033441,
-0.0358653404,
0.0613984205,
-0.021323638,
-0.0089786584,
0.0190887675,
-0.011343969,
-0.0071759075,
0.0296213422,
-0.0264860466,
-0.0505029671,
-0.0193283129,
-0.0140805505,
0.0081421323,
0.0251254272,
-0.0481837913,
0.0244854279,
-0.0340915993,
0.0627554357,
0.0196050312,
-0.0454829745,
0.0149613386,
0.0040074368,
2.65e-7,
-0.0166729782,
0.0360848941,
0.0802021623,
0.0549017228,
0.0102680912,
0.0030996872,
0.015937401,
0.0384009667,
0.0082413619,
0.0121550784,
-0.0069850069,
0.0139292255,
0.0313618369,
-0.0120099215,
-0.1074034795,
-0.0093951877,
-0.0935872346,
0.012447346,
-0.0493813008,
-0.0364146382,
0.0542619191,
0.0609059259,
0.0191122796,
0.0157267768,
0.0116803301,
-0.0000867523,
0.0166401509,
-0.0056387731,
-0.0312005449,
0.0133800358,
0.0724719092,
-0.0184309036,
0.0020991014,
-0.0112864552,
0.0047619413,
0.0043308409,
0.0029968454,
0.0615464002,
0.0536292195,
-0.0038749878,
0.0044303867,
-0.0271905884,
0.0007347844,
-0.036327824,
0.0652839318,
-0.0547466427,
0.041427128,
-0.0358488038,
-0.0193564277,
-0.0395989642,
-0.0249982718,
-0.01526595,
-0.0185731295,
0.03443937,
0.0089316014,
0.0231285971,
0.0323486663,
-0.0600996204,
-0.0202844534,
-0.0012767225,
-0.0292799212,
-0.0253616441,
-0.0686571598,
0.0101961959,
-0.0222013276,
-0.0942495167,
-0.0292047206,
2.857756484e-34,
0.0392819382,
-0.0311765932,
-0.0042067668,
-0.0421736538,
-0.0009196161,
-0.0144917667,
0.0162179954,
0.0325194523,
0.0577611886,
-0.0608740076,
-0.0627737194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12025v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12025v1 | Knowledge-injected Prompt Learning for Chinese Biomedical Entity Normalization | 2023-08-23T09:32:40 | 2023-08-23T09:32:40 | Songhua Yang, Chenghao Zhang, Hongfei Xu, Yuxiang Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Biomedical Entity Normalization (BEN) task aims to align raw,
unstructured medical entities to standard entities, thus promoting data
coherence and facilitating better downstream medical applications. Recently,
prompt learning methods have shown promising results in this task. However,
existing research falls short in tackling the more complex Chinese BEN task,
especially in the few-shot scenario with limited medical data, and the vast
potential of the external medical knowledge base has yet to be fully harnessed.
To address these challenges, we propose a novel Knowledge-injected Prompt
Learning (PL-Knowledge) method. Specifically, our approach consists of five
stages: candidate entity matching, knowledge extraction, knowledge encoding,
knowledge injection, and prediction output. By effectively encoding the
knowledge items contained in medical entities and incorporating them into our
tailor-made knowledge-injected templates, the additional knowledge enhances the
model's ability to capture latent relationships between medical entities, thus
achieving a better match with the standard entities. We extensively evaluate
our model on a benchmark dataset in both few-shot and full-scale scenarios. Our
method outperforms existing baselines, with an average accuracy boost of
12.96\% in few-shot and 0.94\% in full-data cases, showcasing its excellence in
the BEN task. | [
0.0239401851,
0.0444330797,
0.0406690203,
-0.0467301086,
0.0221779384,
0.0106848041,
-0.0039897477,
0.0199645236,
0.0222053211,
0.0227305647,
-0.0183631796,
-0.0238543563,
0.0275384523,
0.0419736318,
-0.0059488225,
-0.0400564373,
0.0452649482,
0.0851311311,
0.0075558065,
0.0066378918,
-0.0083304485,
-0.0141601777,
0.0106365569,
0.0339221023,
0.0180680603,
-0.0036899659,
0.0157140009,
0.0200602934,
0.057519678,
-0.0475334413,
0.0085492451,
0.0335386172,
-0.0199575406,
-0.0448529869,
0.0000019316,
-0.0570814721,
-0.0427605398,
0.0205580313,
-0.0382540487,
-0.0259649456,
-0.0281904563,
-0.0633054525,
0.0063876817,
0.0095056947,
-0.0172903221,
-0.0544151142,
0.0268105846,
0.0720612034,
0.030237956,
0.0525816716,
-0.0224141162,
0.0098059829,
0.0283543542,
-0.0219404921,
0.0203221571,
-0.0418334901,
0.0612042546,
-0.0214732923,
-0.0158192273,
-0.0016967575,
0.007656808,
0.0283252187,
-0.01574081,
0.0248888321,
0.0622788109,
0.0537972338,
0.0262917671,
-0.0070960261,
0.0054574516,
0.0923320577,
-0.0266587939,
0.0102387611,
0.0397660136,
-0.0184954107,
-0.0043027578,
0.0103613697,
-0.0135858972,
-0.0296480618,
-0.0402021967,
0.0053857099,
-0.0045784391,
-0.0214230269,
0.0428003855,
-0.0202876329,
-0.0271992404,
-0.0194782782,
0.0148902312,
-0.0212933794,
-0.0083411038,
-0.0056691924,
0.0088686142,
-0.0362238772,
0.0102848066,
0.0574231409,
-0.0424692109,
0.0161775649,
-0.0122119728,
-0.0005935277,
0.0269526374,
-0.0028825752,
-0.016222842,
0.0187371913,
-0.0184286181,
0.053686168,
-0.0486576185,
-0.0176545437,
-0.0088874269,
0.0390574895,
-0.0347130001,
-0.0218611881,
-0.046500314,
0.0016693714,
-0.005770152,
0.0588730946,
0.0006474222,
0.0103806537,
-0.0702096522,
-0.0345426872,
-0.031617485,
0.060360875,
0.0261071697,
0.0387495533,
-0.0067422632,
-0.0037930126,
-0.0268463027,
0.0280998424,
-0.0297444519,
0.0020864552,
-0.0390429236,
-0.0122616719,
0.005509581,
-0.0259415284,
0.0418252535,
-0.0143721038,
0.020289816,
0.0009133004,
0.0189822614,
-0.01210423,
-0.0331449322,
-0.0297662783,
0.0172134452,
0.0044103758,
-0.0261004977,
-0.0192368682,
0.0462870225,
-0.0083101457,
-0.0065042949,
-0.0663976818,
0.0131462617,
-0.0027314625,
-0.0604488291,
0.0947305784,
-0.080379121,
-0.0061576054,
-0.0095153134,
0.0333108343,
-0.0102292383,
0.0100561995,
-0.0041469,
-0.072657451,
-0.012571401,
-0.0138883675,
0.0004130296,
0.0075685382,
0.0583340488,
-0.0791282654,
0.0147447176,
0.0249727368,
0.0402426831,
0.0717552602,
0.0164393373,
0.0230246782,
0.0006696346,
-0.0126259979,
-0.0012830464,
0.0145534202,
0.0048460392,
-0.0374961831,
0.0096151037,
-0.0086043896,
-0.0201977044,
-0.005428419,
-0.0346182026,
0.022992136,
-0.0164105073,
0.0055673663,
-0.0078211995,
0.057630375,
-0.0505709387,
0.0012273183,
0.0189206749,
-0.036191918,
-0.0360191837,
0.0149255106,
0.0175361708,
0.010232795,
0.0051448219,
0.0682955384,
0.0450962223,
0.0068360064,
0.0026822202,
-0.0015653274,
-0.012876913,
0.052088026,
0.0416828357,
-0.0499357097,
-0.0806178749,
-0.027762413,
-0.0422748625,
-0.0000664262,
0.0063540344,
-0.0523990951,
0.0072542676,
-0.0367550254,
-0.0394798219,
0.0746279955,
-0.0036912293,
-0.0160615537,
0.0154265538,
0.0385134853,
0.0140769482,
-0.0059384368,
0.0072357659,
0.0481824093,
-0.1051008701,
-0.0273260586,
0.0066421558,
0.03935422,
0.0038000999,
0.0491711982,
-0.0211328547,
0.0188151654,
0.0238083359,
-0.0278318841,
-0.0394868329,
0.0033308868,
-0.0228050612,
-0.0477186404,
0.0582389161,
-0.0089782961,
-0.0145558212,
-0.0397927687,
-0.0410232432,
-0.0544967428,
-0.0631671697,
0.053364668,
-0.0143433018,
-0.0285296142,
0.0207955148,
0.012663817,
0.0022201464,
-0.0228965562,
0.0259181242,
-0.0291292854,
0.0260987561,
0.0365200602,
-0.0526012816,
0.0284906551,
0.0156592056,
-0.0234355181,
-0.0128019424,
-0.0000217394,
0.0004768561,
-0.0024355517,
-0.0158070941,
-0.0608461946,
0.0214961637,
-0.0804864392,
0.0294807553,
0.0388736241,
0.0109631065,
0.0178528465,
0.0544440262,
0.0121613685,
-0.0319789052,
-0.0758242384,
-0.0252789035,
-0.0022906079,
-0.0174461082,
0.0664828494,
0.0246145539,
-0.0094740009,
0.0052941842,
0.031302765,
-0.0536200516,
-0.010131103,
-0.0086232042,
-0.0318284817,
0.0033115968,
-0.0004621404,
-0.0549354926,
0.0010601737,
0.0068332762,
0.0103701912,
-0.0151080545,
0.0278003961,
0.008019615,
0.0353178345,
-0.0159476977,
-0.0111552859,
0.0076131853,
0.0177256595,
-0.0249270573,
0.0195786022,
0.0056235292,
0.0120024355,
0.0176221412,
-0.0412636288,
-0.0119661186,
0.0504045151,
0.0037312885,
-0.0202019364,
-0.0509543531,
0.0078926515,
0.0249998178,
0.0179497469,
-0.0713288486,
0.0381346159,
-0.0167667214,
0.0174823515,
-0.0392584912,
0.025387371,
0.121428974,
-0.0045644818,
0.037162248,
-0.0044606165,
0.0094326399,
-0.0325508006,
-0.021242097,
-0.0219152439,
0.0233248547,
0.0242469385,
-0.0148635386,
-0.0336411931,
0.0312662348,
-0.0056705568,
-0.0571278557,
0.0351424217,
0.0295360349,
0.0215404835,
-0.0179302692,
-0.0577494875,
-0.0648102611,
-0.0075608613,
0.0035113981,
0.0533496886,
-0.0004117337,
-0.0092612607,
-0.0149474218,
0.018674124,
-0.0079049366,
0.0515682511,
0.0479652993,
-0.020034181,
-0.0147950789,
0.0250375923,
0.0420611389,
0.0065227658,
0.0070945453,
0.0067491597,
0.0485851541,
0.0546467118,
0.0164934136,
0.0024334581,
0.0297944564,
0.0118043888,
-0.0158780944,
-0.0568483397,
0.005194013,
0.0211797152,
0.0413858704,
-0.0208925195,
0.0366842598,
0.1045390815,
0.0316063017,
-0.032378979,
0.0070808772,
0.0264140051,
-0.0258346666,
0.0208829716,
0.014320977,
-0.0937378332,
-0.0283666588,
-0.0069412412,
0.0093680797,
0.0096202241,
-0.1023336574,
0.0303947981,
-0.0745516792,
-0.0040338263,
-0.0065332176,
-0.0527946837,
-0.0457418412,
-0.0809596702,
0.0359576605,
-0.0088839121,
0.0176417734,
0.0075665824,
-0.0036628181,
-0.0117811346,
-0.0200270414,
-0.0294421446,
-0.09290272,
0.0251571592,
-0.0852457732,
0.0866098776,
0.0378866568,
0.0363314934,
-0.0089303022,
0.024855461,
-0.0408141837,
0.0028326802,
-0.0377961136,
0.0153959123,
0.0746696368,
-0.0108188596,
-0.0286854748,
-0.0297520794,
0.0247662794,
-0.0358397625,
-0.000345168,
-0.0046761958,
0.0805898905,
0.0013814328,
0.0010601548,
-0.0370109528,
-0.0207267832,
0.032599099,
0.0944157466,
-0.0088289352,
-0.0220664963,
0.0178040061,
0.018571537,
0.0264569521,
0.0096581941,
0.0124921333,
0.0662511513,
-0.0742357671,
-0.0211650841,
-0.092083402,
-0.0566833653,
0.0725058764,
-0.0107131591,
0.0276489556,
0.0353920236,
0.0059077376,
-0.0267305654,
-0.0607909709,
0.0196576566,
0.0049662376,
0.0057605891,
-0.0288403351,
-0.0258568805,
0.0194092151,
-0.0165442489,
-0.0109601226,
-0.0130909057,
0.0078965817,
-0.0210480709,
-0.0326723047,
-0.0172993578,
0.0047392696,
0.0320612825,
-0.0333862379,
0.0307503324,
0.0525148213,
0.0616343878,
-0.0627669692,
-0.0518737137,
-0.0327522084,
-0.0039759181,
-0.0192010906,
0.025205005,
-0.0133770891,
0.010377394,
0.0164095387,
0.0343670994,
0.0035548988,
-0.0494355485,
0.0449979641,
0.0854726359,
0.0331783332,
-0.0085881297,
-0.0041362341,
-0.0472759381,
0.0108632976,
-0.013033201,
-0.0001732827,
-0.0208605137,
-0.0049794526,
0.044341445,
0.0150056584,
-0.0033023707,
0.0301776677,
-0.0184599254,
-0.0088123884,
-0.0612096563,
-0.0208755024,
-0.0096962964,
0.0209792033,
0.0310724098,
-0.0408967808,
0.0136808176,
0.0390504487,
0.0380425304,
-0.0005088496,
-0.0458591133,
0.0032424901,
0.030119909,
0.0964431316,
-0.035896983,
0.0154735558,
-0.0382379442,
-0.0092420625,
-0.0319460034,
0.0387562141,
0.0426819734,
0.0143231191,
0.0118069435,
-0.0071412241,
-0.0066143456,
-0.0110025965,
0.0130480481,
-0.0390829667,
0.0088926274,
0.0454409346,
0.0164535232,
-0.0216410831,
-0.0351301208,
0.0824718475,
-0.03850637,
0.0909391493,
-0.0296413116,
-0.0415090509,
-0.0611211471,
0.0230218899,
0.0545241162,
-0.004767919,
-0.0712435618,
0.0075936718,
-0.0619576387,
-0.0562216379,
0.0439812951,
-0.0257776342,
-0.07275334,
0.0408159643,
0.0272697974,
0.0049873674,
0.0326591171,
-0.0273314863,
0.0196750462,
-0.0009180253,
-0.0300346874,
-0.0555820614,
0.0742025077,
-6.192627667e-33,
-0.0341811739,
-0.0112765208,
0.0226964969,
-0.0455420911,
0.0117607964,
0.013967949,
-0.0155515317,
-0.0455450639,
-0.0263601448,
0.0095014758,
-0.0418733098,
-0.0079816449,
0.000265951,
0.0003026134,
0.0086948182,
-0.0236825086,
0.0415539443,
0.0270061865,
-0.0023781932,
0.0212503877,
0.0163832717,
0.0888016745,
0.045309756,
-0.0627051443,
0.0155578181,
0.0376261063,
0.0019223307,
0.0239087511,
0.0340221077,
0.0431837142,
-0.0314085595,
0.019533921,
0.0331635885,
-0.0198441762,
-0.0150136147,
-0.0140893729,
-0.1586507112,
-0.0182231907,
-0.0427571051,
-0.0143097918,
-0.0191999581,
-0.0115530482,
0.0166642144,
-0.0387804918,
0.0469945036,
-0.0369823873,
0.0408913791,
-0.0378663465,
-0.0217879545,
-0.0483855717,
-0.0132782115,
0.0333015919,
0.003446837,
0.0279720668,
0.0044427435,
-0.0267134178,
-0.0115779247,
0.037055742,
-0.0436701067,
-0.021413682,
0.0442705378,
0.0425839163,
-0.0219583828,
-0.0189709682,
0.0076175276,
0.0362319164,
0.0296118874,
-0.0361453407,
-0.0452986695,
0.0356915034,
-0.0073833875,
0.0184204988,
-0.0172677636,
0.0473092534,
0.0414420217,
-0.0370884873,
-0.0952468589,
0.1064953431,
0.0013971135,
0.010241664,
-0.0550059266,
-0.0282602143,
-0.0126610445,
-0.0149780288,
-0.0187716093,
-0.002103758,
-0.0281707868,
-0.0297210366,
0.0153680369,
0.0187366251,
-0.0291007292,
0.0285813641,
0.0110202385,
-0.0445876792,
-0.0148420073,
0.034489695,
0.0494132079,
-0.0220420565,
-0.0149377147,
-0.0061663389,
-0.0750769302,
-0.0430537648,
0.0582697764,
-0.0463170707,
0.0347135216,
0.070828408,
0.0465919934,
-0.039529264,
-0.0653679073,
-0.002955535,
0.0262095984,
-0.0266225208,
-0.0239302665,
0.0114771659,
0.0180177018,
0.0233664792,
0.0104492353,
-0.0102313319,
0.0776720122,
0.0182005093,
-0.0390585214,
0.0133669991,
0.0111251976,
0.0021139455,
-0.0180141926,
0.0139733804,
-0.0362430029,
-0.008508753,
0.0280088689,
-0.0491747707,
-0.0194576811,
-0.0214284714,
2.704e-7,
0.0673124567,
-0.0137564428,
0.0489725024,
0.0078629907,
-0.0135382377,
0.0095769949,
-0.0113284374,
0.0378231183,
-0.0306646973,
-0.0249997731,
0.0853318796,
-0.0241663046,
0.0018584916,
0.028644491,
-0.0947103128,
-0.0126883192,
-0.0533061326,
-0.0232270565,
-0.0124393962,
-0.0048108115,
0.0089330412,
0.0523309968,
-0.0168860815,
-0.0172722433,
0.0424483158,
0.0107728364,
0.0356804319,
-0.003660203,
0.0101624848,
0.0707326531,
0.0327972062,
0.0021588244,
0.0110248486,
0.0586577989,
-0.0113503858,
0.0229438283,
0.030100327,
0.0801168978,
-0.0230145101,
0.0203863345,
-0.024527004,
-0.0202200226,
0.0362197869,
-0.0356777236,
0.0627840832,
-0.0382083096,
-0.0212473087,
0.0129521312,
-0.0449279323,
0.0173603222,
0.0392644405,
0.0140827606,
-0.0039288574,
0.0522584505,
0.0434408262,
0.0520480648,
-0.0215549562,
-0.0778914839,
-0.0388973989,
0.0465358943,
0.005241117,
-0.0363751017,
0.0553684495,
-0.0419532396,
0.0064943526,
-0.0736568496,
0.0248653796,
2.56459554e-34,
-0.0092369569,
-0.0042264396,
-0.0015599735,
0.0357974209,
0.0167941228,
-0.0633847117,
-0.0254789628,
0.0041679642,
-0.0138978502,
-0.0483336374,
-0.0060657645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12022v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12022v2 | Reranking Passages with Coarse-to-Fine Neural Retriever Enhanced by List-Context Information | 2023-08-23T09:29:29 | 2024-03-21T09:11:22 | Hongyin Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Passage reranking is a critical task in various applications, particularly
when dealing with large volumes of documents. Existing neural architectures
have limitations in retrieving the most relevant passage for a given question
because the semantics of the segmented passages are often incomplete, and they
typically match the question to each passage individually, rarely considering
contextual information from other passages that could provide comparative and
reference information. This paper presents a list-context attention mechanism
to augment the passage representation by incorporating the list-context
information from other candidates. The proposed coarse-to-fine (C2F) neural
retriever addresses the out-of-memory limitation of the passage attention
mechanism by dividing the list-context modeling process into two sub-processes
with a cache policy learning algorithm, enabling the efficient encoding of
context information from a large number of candidate answers. This method can
be generally used to encode context information from any number of candidate
answers in one pass. Different from most multi-stage information retrieval
architectures, this model integrates the coarse and fine rankers into the joint
optimization process, allowing for feedback between the two layers to update
the model simultaneously. Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of the
proposed approach. | [
0.0358237438,
0.0123946751,
-0.0134348432,
0.0377298743,
0.0086408695,
0.0219823997,
-0.0120568927,
-0.0105341952,
0.0341877192,
-0.0440774076,
0.001252251,
-0.0352685861,
-0.0275438502,
-0.0136044696,
0.0072984356,
-0.0370097123,
0.0372822583,
-0.0138598345,
0.0590535663,
0.0171722248,
0.0107574593,
0.0005689182,
0.0364891738,
-0.010525424,
0.052052699,
-0.0202629138,
-0.0164023861,
-0.0085530402,
0.0499690585,
-0.0566009954,
0.0423533767,
0.0022199063,
0.0383793227,
-0.0131286522,
0.0000022116,
-0.0224011224,
-0.0363212153,
0.012354387,
-0.026718203,
-0.0147020509,
0.0444587991,
0.0200311262,
0.0312710963,
-0.0314585492,
-0.026896162,
0.0497230887,
0.0087702451,
0.0417417176,
0.0664259493,
0.0505469888,
0.0084904106,
-0.0538145266,
0.0242069494,
-0.0272212196,
0.0638836324,
-0.0882659107,
0.0010730674,
-0.0333308503,
0.0451485366,
0.0816017985,
-0.0143376067,
0.0366407037,
0.036572922,
0.0014573878,
0.0333747454,
0.0193618461,
-0.0246795602,
0.0569075197,
-0.0140923848,
0.0619293451,
-0.0124843381,
-0.0170716513,
-0.0066003967,
-0.0005891499,
0.0232625641,
-0.025431823,
-0.0455013067,
-0.0006316417,
-0.0236200355,
0.0120156007,
0.0272026062,
0.0250285193,
0.0013402367,
0.0108716246,
-0.0653972104,
0.0169796217,
-0.0070726252,
-0.0298226792,
0.0040721172,
-0.0143536925,
-0.0249041859,
0.0028150252,
0.0587953925,
0.0433159061,
-0.0502873696,
-0.0000197654,
-0.0240666345,
-0.0108082211,
0.0094819674,
-0.0247296523,
0.0070079439,
0.0131103434,
0.0059031039,
0.0446068868,
-0.0225418396,
0.0348974913,
-0.0142844198,
0.0106668156,
-0.0917069763,
-0.0106893834,
-0.0060957079,
-0.0246802382,
-0.0392973945,
0.0736402646,
-0.0234874263,
-0.011402363,
-0.0224772114,
-0.0032582998,
-0.0027935125,
-0.0004738659,
-0.0190105475,
0.0257907379,
-0.0436155014,
-0.0127439592,
-0.0465497486,
0.0421875715,
-0.0526319258,
-0.0345338471,
0.0337207131,
0.0312921293,
-0.0045715012,
-0.0402585082,
0.011565743,
-0.0270116162,
0.0169384666,
0.0306292921,
-0.0276142377,
-0.0205322653,
-0.028075505,
-0.0044829915,
0.0072670369,
-0.0346655697,
-0.0171510763,
-0.0451545529,
0.020047348,
0.0100043844,
-0.0187586676,
-0.0011586406,
0.0212261453,
0.0667622611,
-0.0540854558,
0.0391424373,
0.0471630841,
-0.0613639541,
0.0539513975,
0.033989504,
0.052608896,
0.032292325,
0.0230979882,
0.0255475603,
0.0330995843,
0.0213662535,
-0.0166554302,
-0.0239032824,
0.0099066589,
-0.0151375644,
-0.0020352784,
0.0473947823,
-0.0202076901,
0.0208024625,
0.0141587853,
0.0284193624,
-0.0513341315,
-0.0527772009,
0.0214308575,
0.0669738054,
0.0476567037,
0.0137643255,
-0.0047831642,
0.0054116175,
-0.0156132309,
0.0492426232,
-0.0355713107,
0.06663277,
0.0166856106,
0.0117983175,
0.0386382416,
0.0235693268,
-0.0155991213,
-0.0381121226,
0.0390801542,
0.0230762251,
-0.0076807546,
0.0507305898,
0.0326172486,
0.0192740243,
-0.0331556126,
0.0234043263,
0.0252195261,
-0.0133384503,
0.0127945179,
-0.0053221732,
0.0020479665,
0.0734139755,
0.0405856892,
-0.078551501,
-0.0608394518,
-0.0121209072,
-0.0049836962,
-0.0203636624,
0.0198433697,
-0.0220334213,
-0.0210088976,
-0.0562399775,
0.0022285886,
-0.0244143624,
-0.0164982472,
0.0222496595,
0.0065328465,
0.0156509485,
0.0358622521,
-0.0167427547,
-0.0013532996,
0.0269946475,
0.0176257007,
-0.0315620862,
0.0150708249,
-0.0051900269,
0.0131889731,
0.0215166844,
0.0113689844,
0.0116252815,
0.0470867567,
-0.053098496,
0.0215422604,
-0.0626952276,
-0.0892674476,
-0.0035895701,
0.0176561475,
-0.0129089132,
-0.0034365472,
0.0337207168,
-0.0255445112,
-0.0106255049,
-0.0322913937,
-0.0151779549,
-0.0160345268,
-0.0135814175,
-0.0029949204,
0.0324359089,
-0.0073621487,
-0.0987128094,
0.0895564333,
0.0023933935,
0.0733371824,
0.0531976782,
0.0377663746,
-0.0142167108,
-0.0457451455,
-0.0195456948,
0.015750207,
-0.0317857042,
-0.0051432974,
0.0274065118,
-0.0000412697,
-0.0549337789,
-0.0134025272,
-0.0621182919,
0.0111122299,
-0.0120006865,
-0.0021587589,
0.0115399212,
0.0149381505,
0.0220423937,
-0.0281808358,
-0.0471408851,
0.0261764061,
-0.0275858473,
0.0300563145,
0.0169428103,
0.0185574908,
0.0264782868,
-0.0361128561,
-0.0466749929,
0.0016489747,
0.0327084772,
-0.001535507,
0.0115365945,
-0.054909002,
0.0122230444,
-0.0060857767,
0.0417415313,
-0.0372328348,
0.0033996266,
0.0033354443,
-0.0618836582,
-0.0060473224,
0.100561887,
0.0286505576,
0.0096115414,
0.0156274028,
-0.0347930528,
-0.0696287751,
0.0530357882,
-0.0154408002,
0.0035161385,
-0.0122375609,
0.0137701482,
0.0169746727,
0.0175246112,
-0.0298113283,
-0.0250264406,
-0.0004765126,
-0.0017364861,
0.0036641774,
0.0027423252,
-0.0746926591,
-0.0009857152,
-0.0237286389,
0.0034234624,
-0.0173528399,
0.0130431671,
0.0579570159,
0.0100990199,
-0.0030629979,
-0.0879794061,
0.0121291839,
-0.0614158809,
0.0423727371,
0.0135985604,
0.0117980931,
-0.0307001844,
-0.0405690931,
-0.0675811321,
0.0226342771,
0.0060690502,
-0.047404848,
0.0486662164,
-0.0119736968,
0.0125131086,
-0.0442529768,
-0.0561007522,
-0.0422445945,
-0.0392825082,
0.0326245576,
0.0255345367,
0.0242815726,
0.0051927837,
-0.0222731028,
0.0127608785,
0.0307650454,
0.0741626546,
-0.0292873047,
-0.0168386307,
-0.0047364156,
0.0695678592,
0.0667408183,
0.0421643555,
0.0230320506,
-0.0239000674,
0.0268385094,
0.0723304152,
0.0534076616,
-0.0334274657,
0.0318037011,
0.0073945071,
0.0575060099,
-0.0712141469,
0.0025358011,
0.0257841311,
0.0216343757,
-0.0916089565,
-0.0719918683,
0.0728449747,
0.0355489664,
-0.1095700189,
-0.0337058119,
-0.0121986633,
-0.0031272375,
0.0258150455,
0.0402944833,
-0.0554424636,
0.0025640035,
0.0179371126,
0.0264203027,
0.022099629,
-0.0219820216,
0.0081015276,
-0.0958645046,
0.026643673,
-0.0161802657,
-0.0582865961,
-0.0323770903,
-0.0172798969,
0.0003041073,
0.0548263602,
-0.0158379562,
0.064250432,
-0.0277889706,
-0.0256437268,
-0.0221907292,
0.0525476225,
0.0186703634,
0.0120471967,
-0.0234784968,
-0.0129413977,
0.0496578142,
0.0184483118,
0.0051594754,
0.0362648852,
0.0302142836,
-0.1187907606,
-0.0029284782,
0.0184745211,
0.0117102768,
-0.0153301321,
0.0070318682,
-0.0440062322,
0.0469483994,
0.0293702465,
-0.010050457,
-0.0054521682,
0.0277094748,
-0.0106580686,
0.0053710216,
-0.0447450988,
-0.0016982774,
-0.0136661343,
0.0265590064,
0.0090668797,
-0.0222563632,
-0.0338669941,
-0.0354830548,
0.0113152936,
-0.0417908505,
-0.0205714498,
0.0296328403,
0.0029238313,
0.0496105701,
-0.0681007281,
-0.0353449397,
-0.0198698901,
0.0209365897,
-0.0131621165,
0.0343807191,
0.0276684817,
-0.0310271122,
-0.0302473959,
-0.0048189419,
-0.0169078056,
-0.0080682142,
-0.0183565374,
0.0134261297,
0.0058223857,
-0.031131994,
-0.0372752286,
0.0093046101,
-0.0578285642,
-0.0173029751,
0.0102499481,
0.0533867814,
0.0033534328,
0.0207133051,
-0.0318447053,
-0.0472085886,
0.076447621,
0.0176869072,
-0.0599673465,
0.0053982125,
-0.0214573517,
0.0307978969,
-0.0221268404,
0.0122352084,
-0.0560559295,
0.0119885467,
0.0066351737,
0.0467062555,
-0.0134979142,
-0.0460890941,
0.0092558423,
-0.0237220023,
-0.0081097577,
0.0480265953,
-0.0003225672,
-0.0317155048,
0.0841262862,
-0.0065181958,
-0.0339692347,
0.0027585141,
0.0028310451,
0.0201308653,
-0.0612187758,
-0.0088511379,
-0.0103507042,
0.0623029545,
0.0343572013,
-0.0878181756,
0.0228935499,
0.0253536329,
-0.0271093566,
-0.0112754423,
0.0261643399,
-0.034086626,
-0.0036119807,
0.0100016333,
0.0939685255,
-0.0321254991,
0.0701012239,
0.0433587506,
-0.0258024484,
-0.0324269049,
0.0303612705,
-0.1197798327,
0.0197594296,
-0.0536683984,
-0.0048233108,
0.025234174,
-0.0226400103,
0.0161825884,
0.0446860678,
-0.0285421945,
-0.0236169174,
-0.0220908448,
0.0025698703,
-0.0051375995,
-0.0077191335,
0.0604595691,
0.0341631323,
0.0250308551,
0.0620032512,
-0.0242481828,
-0.0231514294,
0.0421163216,
-0.0270753875,
-0.0332597531,
-0.0113558462,
-0.0446864367,
0.087125577,
0.0176619925,
-0.0210526325,
-0.0094745895,
-0.0087026339,
0.0226476118,
0.0026898426,
0.0292339288,
-0.0208459608,
0.0253054108,
0.0327885151,
0.0000882689,
-0.0359633081,
-0.0456369035,
0.0347685702,
-0.05037475,
-0.0300437268,
-0.0417902395,
-6.532509369e-33,
-0.0592323616,
-0.0206951872,
0.0117269745,
-0.0187120605,
-0.0579234511,
0.0061766426,
-0.0117025943,
-0.0531447195,
-0.0142512657,
0.0082558226,
-0.0413291454,
0.0045547956,
0.0116803488,
0.0230495464,
0.0126500586,
-0.0178602971,
0.027902646,
0.0251329727,
-0.0196615867,
0.0337843634,
0.0592570454,
0.053915415,
0.0218705349,
-0.0336231999,
-0.0023715766,
-0.0225534867,
0.0490577295,
-0.024603337,
-0.015517123,
0.049822595,
-0.0108825183,
0.0055147605,
0.0527739078,
-0.075017564,
0.0018903844,
0.0430020802,
-0.1301708221,
-0.0515152179,
-0.0314220153,
-0.0277022533,
0.030537121,
-0.0270057451,
0.0235744454,
-0.0012814219,
0.0682833344,
-0.042625159,
0.0384745635,
-0.0228770096,
-0.0292393956,
-0.0507150553,
-0.0216871407,
0.0187126454,
-0.0142625533,
0.0125844767,
0.0020994623,
0.0717054605,
-0.0088060843,
0.0470177308,
-0.0596097074,
-0.0270145219,
-0.007418267,
0.0931949168,
-0.0182006732,
0.0071987575,
-0.0302496366,
0.0377431437,
0.0136096943,
-0.003404221,
-0.0064655803,
-0.043682918,
-0.0013224243,
0.0086950576,
0.0302750897,
0.0302836243,
0.0452259257,
0.0206533335,
-0.0889349133,
0.0402579606,
-0.0050587086,
0.0686193407,
0.037225388,
0.0154277096,
-0.0079610562,
-0.0341613069,
-0.0415205322,
0.0179513413,
-0.0628906563,
0.0170966536,
0.0351119079,
0.0170820821,
-0.0133812642,
0.0472724289,
0.0496058203,
-0.02098215,
-0.0050140619,
0.0278364755,
0.0153583055,
0.0107926838,
0.0226446819,
0.016604377,
-0.0463812575,
0.0216361117,
0.001269317,
-0.0383356772,
-0.0197592489,
-0.0017340231,
0.0258210469,
-0.0292404853,
-0.0425477624,
0.0104474667,
-0.0041570296,
-0.0143902916,
-0.0139468778,
0.0742570236,
-0.0011507005,
0.0035845099,
0.0002953075,
0.0982027873,
0.0211154763,
0.0281145703,
-0.0252997596,
-0.0087500606,
0.0059245857,
-0.0142059792,
0.0009190764,
0.0454897322,
0.0008845319,
0.098505035,
-0.005798188,
-0.049116917,
0.0058256416,
0.0503530875,
2.87e-7,
0.0253429115,
0.0138890091,
0.0143757984,
0.0017370339,
0.0084814448,
0.0085931579,
0.0324968509,
0.0444272384,
0.0600361526,
0.0055848924,
0.0200311765,
0.018674301,
-0.0056068571,
0.0256754812,
-0.1086836755,
-0.0412333235,
-0.0326921828,
-0.043749243,
-0.0106169684,
-0.0660598874,
0.0459255353,
0.070568271,
-0.014907198,
0.007698081,
0.0056916107,
-0.0053077694,
0.0202400498,
-0.0159590356,
-0.0064748051,
0.0135599012,
0.0229661688,
0.0109873526,
-0.0353355594,
-0.0053539411,
-0.0038689885,
0.0541545786,
-0.0019595837,
0.0349246077,
0.0088701239,
-0.0917966291,
0.0028944914,
0.0106167523,
0.0080453632,
-0.0623803847,
0.0645708218,
-0.0675125122,
-0.001719881,
-0.0081516057,
-0.0475443192,
-0.0204342883,
-0.0201601442,
0.0139632728,
-0.0002311734,
0.0202023406,
-0.0112699252,
-0.0106828883,
0.0125987027,
-0.1210278943,
-0.0181883164,
0.0200719703,
-0.0216378234,
-0.0071777953,
-0.0381666049,
-0.0449205115,
-0.0093327556,
-0.0620768555,
-0.0049203592,
2.684162601e-34,
0.0240486972,
-0.0178217702,
0.0001540314,
0.0196835957,
0.0207485259,
0.0153428745,
-0.0313268751,
0.028976813,
0.0220754873,
-0.104264386,
-0.0316033326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.12014v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12014v2 | From Instructions to Intrinsic Human Values -- A Survey of Alignment Goals for Big Models | 2023-08-23T09:11:13 | 2023-09-04T03:32:05 | Jing Yao, Xiaoyuan Yi, Xiting Wang, Jindong Wang, Xing Xie | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Big models, exemplified by Large Language Models (LLMs), are models typically
pre-trained on massive data and comprised of enormous parameters, which not
only obtain significantly improved performance across diverse tasks but also
present emergent capabilities absent in smaller models. However, the growing
intertwining of big models with everyday human lives poses potential risks and
might cause serious social harm. Therefore, many efforts have been made to
align LLMs with humans to make them better follow user instructions and satisfy
human preferences. Nevertheless, `what to align with' has not been fully
discussed, and inappropriate alignment goals might even backfire. In this
paper, we conduct a comprehensive survey of different alignment goals in
existing work and trace their evolution paths to help identify the most
essential goal. Particularly, we investigate related works from two
perspectives: the definition of alignment goals and alignment evaluation. Our
analysis encompasses three distinct levels of alignment goals and reveals a
goal transformation from fundamental abilities to value orientation, indicating
the potential of intrinsic human values as the alignment goal for enhanced
LLMs. Based on such results, we further discuss the challenges of achieving
such intrinsic value alignment and provide a collection of available resources
for future research on the alignment of big models. | [
0.028237883,
0.0790241659,
-0.0072861472,
0.0218736753,
-0.0234589223,
0.0304662734,
-0.0448949337,
-0.0349777862,
-0.0437936597,
0.0174704865,
-0.0630208403,
-0.0157864261,
-0.0070069432,
0.0088260993,
0.0124357687,
-0.0742967725,
0.0780023783,
-0.0019308199,
0.0071120583,
-0.0015764389,
0.001529436,
0.0112763355,
0.0202056356,
0.034999188,
0.0081809238,
0.0145741515,
0.0011143697,
0.0158217251,
0.0773091167,
0.0042836629,
-0.0010193551,
0.0128669851,
0.0155462259,
0.0496601649,
0.0000018393,
-0.0720652863,
0.0303553715,
0.003646431,
-0.0307140294,
0.0199537314,
0.0485732332,
-0.0107649108,
-0.0327230692,
0.0065682866,
-0.0279540699,
0.0161269046,
0.051949203,
0.0476269722,
0.0156595185,
0.0718623176,
-0.010775812,
-0.0346852615,
0.0184404179,
-0.0143017713,
-0.0093151787,
-0.0533338264,
0.023577176,
0.0372542813,
-0.0257720314,
0.0283008777,
0.0008972274,
0.0270648561,
0.0061970023,
0.0090752281,
0.047328718,
0.0261258017,
-0.0137932431,
-0.0672286004,
-0.0176412407,
0.0712076947,
0.0006887821,
-0.0259560402,
0.0148744695,
-0.0143077876,
0.0222187955,
-0.0224234015,
-0.0068292352,
0.0195082892,
0.0254815295,
0.0410211422,
0.0170825273,
-0.0081864344,
0.0415600613,
0.0424362868,
-0.0069286306,
0.0266060494,
0.0146295847,
-0.0186804254,
0.0096986266,
0.0249729436,
-0.0200758092,
-0.0638667494,
0.0002267916,
0.0368937328,
-0.0282429811,
0.0103689767,
-0.0666803494,
0.0251106769,
0.0155326389,
-0.075379014,
0.0455297306,
0.0646595508,
0.0223901495,
0.0379663073,
0.0076792864,
0.0502017364,
-0.0634851605,
0.0312678739,
-0.0500790775,
0.0212414823,
0.006179323,
-0.0034777366,
-0.0045955661,
-0.0262978058,
-0.0208948236,
-0.0114222914,
-0.0147732738,
0.0536822602,
0.0052726576,
0.0450335927,
-0.0149034802,
0.0041987882,
-0.0196192693,
-0.0262551177,
-0.0262482632,
0.0468864031,
-0.0417200141,
0.021136187,
0.00856792,
-0.0171008501,
0.0299594253,
0.0101393033,
-0.0106590642,
-0.0382238403,
0.0279058274,
0.0469646715,
0.0069912905,
0.0140011525,
-0.0159105342,
0.0014328,
0.0131216953,
-0.0698759258,
-0.0122328158,
-0.0220120568,
0.0165565647,
-0.0164577868,
-0.0133284833,
-0.0538939051,
-0.0133388629,
0.0252430867,
-0.0213715974,
0.0286600199,
-0.0025411947,
0.034198951,
0.0403028615,
-0.0057447637,
0.013082928,
0.0349502005,
0.0335409939,
0.0345177241,
0.0172180887,
-0.0506281368,
-0.0123332469,
0.0285815038,
-0.0058565252,
-0.0171308387,
-0.0435534418,
0.0394403674,
0.0422480665,
0.0736338496,
0.0565656945,
0.0703225285,
-0.0261472855,
0.0020457422,
0.1150824055,
0.0423545614,
-0.0018408064,
0.0119850542,
-0.0045609376,
-0.0057906983,
0.0102071781,
-0.0289669149,
-0.0780764073,
0.0277026035,
-0.0233499091,
0.0356330089,
-0.0075683282,
0.0532154851,
-0.0395448841,
-0.0379577652,
-0.0119902138,
-0.0057672672,
0.0283345561,
0.0283438712,
0.0304976273,
-0.044700101,
-0.0146356719,
-0.0288767051,
0.0013622394,
-0.0510210358,
0.0036778529,
-0.06117329,
0.0408977717,
0.0725044087,
0.0286388658,
0.0248419456,
-0.0149356294,
0.0006904981,
-0.0312537551,
0.028083045,
0.0618924834,
-0.0314355232,
-0.012605832,
-0.0633835942,
-0.0345431082,
0.0039781528,
-0.023258958,
-0.0215135645,
0.0235477928,
-0.0006420161,
-0.0036222823,
-0.0123603987,
-0.0872379392,
0.037633419,
-0.0339693315,
-0.006511535,
-0.0443039984,
0.0342014059,
0.0237676334,
0.0289016087,
-0.0050011459,
0.0106179956,
0.0111912536,
0.0155837461,
0.0096557457,
0.0153535791,
-0.0534075312,
0.0488056391,
0.0354994312,
-0.0325271748,
-0.0250554029,
0.0687682107,
-0.0119452626,
0.0019346747,
-0.0363727584,
-0.0390531123,
0.0159532372,
-0.0228068642,
0.0306936707,
-0.0359784625,
-0.0111645507,
-0.0592633337,
0.0500033572,
0.0052017299,
-0.0330261476,
-0.0043753986,
-0.0242643431,
0.0090074968,
-0.0469111577,
-0.0373394862,
0.0220211949,
0.0004223687,
0.0642394274,
0.0560517646,
0.0153004667,
-0.043415688,
-0.0103045804,
-0.0908394307,
0.0024433795,
-0.0096589113,
0.0319656618,
0.0265575778,
0.0127894348,
-0.0169966184,
-0.0066246972,
-0.0442718305,
-0.0122206919,
0.003489295,
0.0067875749,
0.0673331991,
-0.0004260278,
-0.0508413427,
-0.036828313,
-0.0011309822,
-0.0090088667,
-0.0289648026,
-0.0108049065,
0.0087324446,
-0.059438467,
0.033156611,
-0.0229193773,
0.0127065443,
0.0022549501,
-0.0514822006,
0.016713772,
0.048605442,
0.0602493286,
0.1362952441,
0.0381424837,
0.0327301063,
0.0145156477,
0.0529515222,
-0.0540280789,
-0.0082830479,
-0.046756424,
-0.0453397892,
-0.0402702689,
-0.0193172488,
0.0152289793,
0.0792039856,
-0.0368533134,
0.0184416529,
-0.065980278,
0.0222444478,
-0.0204603784,
-0.0502031222,
-0.000875405,
-0.0382812135,
-0.0413818918,
0.033175908,
-0.0461329967,
-0.077763617,
0.0566537343,
0.008950673,
0.0181901548,
-0.0244384184,
-0.029416224,
-0.0226460807,
0.0452191643,
-0.012581964,
0.0469545312,
-0.0156634338,
-0.026095327,
-0.0609939247,
-0.0019965221,
0.0328862816,
-0.0461724252,
0.048648566,
-0.0194099899,
-0.0028810559,
-0.0214878879,
-0.0609691776,
-0.0511004627,
-0.0286204666,
-0.0484430976,
-0.0085688541,
-0.0022015409,
-0.0252341442,
-0.0427130759,
-0.0385592207,
0.0560038649,
-0.0140954237,
0.0058140876,
0.0020584739,
-0.0119049428,
-0.047267735,
0.0874559656,
0.0213162191,
0.0338160843,
-0.0372877382,
0.016875444,
0.0304003581,
0.0266739838,
0.0078336569,
-0.0182983559,
-0.0119339703,
0.0532396436,
-0.0093374457,
-0.0064935987,
0.0209896937,
0.0754410103,
-0.0048225741,
0.0091296444,
0.0946440324,
-0.0045067626,
-0.0220107008,
0.0248444621,
-0.0359871052,
0.0226823762,
-0.000527468,
0.0125130089,
-0.0518550873,
-0.019436961,
-0.0020588257,
0.0115754409,
-0.0320282131,
-0.0034762132,
0.0069540869,
-0.0945757255,
-0.0083236387,
0.0380833894,
-0.0487472825,
-0.0425926708,
0.0212394278,
0.015835559,
-0.0474114753,
0.0744638219,
0.0125795854,
0.0035929987,
-0.0362158827,
0.0332047604,
0.0021260285,
-0.0776990503,
0.0064027593,
-0.075178355,
0.0672605783,
0.101367496,
0.0400516056,
0.021642141,
-0.0772128552,
0.0054315487,
0.0471056141,
0.0219978932,
0.043229226,
0.0095044607,
-0.0584246144,
-0.0063627618,
-0.0520115755,
0.0680430606,
0.0042804005,
-0.0131968604,
-0.0362527557,
0.0557381362,
-0.0190065503,
-0.0178951304,
-0.0201242045,
-0.011756598,
0.0014087484,
0.0860888213,
0.0031341945,
-0.0869990289,
0.0023235518,
0.0170214903,
-0.0509734973,
-0.0136380177,
-0.0783492401,
0.0335507914,
-0.0309467241,
-0.0377935022,
-0.0358409435,
-0.0737196356,
0.0049359184,
0.0203804169,
0.0209810436,
-0.0634785369,
0.0227672532,
-0.0032538699,
-0.0326718837,
0.0477469824,
-0.0296803676,
0.0329025872,
-0.0803188905,
0.0009357254,
0.0116958106,
-0.0420611985,
0.0055031874,
-0.006526195,
-0.0653982833,
-0.0886105374,
0.0355957784,
0.0343238078,
0.0227000434,
0.0548444502,
0.0253111124,
-0.0760984644,
0.0365112238,
0.0332809128,
-0.0351198576,
0.0250048172,
0.0178529974,
0.0038329386,
-0.0110693546,
0.0141947512,
-0.0119240899,
0.0105666071,
0.0184462816,
0.0141967423,
-0.0019163771,
-0.0391094312,
0.0304133594,
0.0248270612,
0.0233106092,
-0.0355591886,
-0.0200443286,
-0.0295760185,
-0.0293738693,
-0.0002605512,
-0.035326533,
-0.0148128029,
-0.0374686457,
0.0593844727,
0.0362724476,
-0.0091608483,
-0.0204407237,
0.0116705084,
0.0168770831,
-0.0628968328,
-0.0071251737,
-0.03635877,
0.0698415041,
0.0304731429,
0.0264766682,
-0.0515442789,
0.0408861786,
-0.0133350389,
0.060985636,
0.0276968274,
0.0595756397,
0.0485623442,
0.027259348,
0.0040436466,
0.0368235223,
-0.0522500128,
-0.0649313331,
-0.0472693183,
-0.0267513879,
0.0163886584,
0.0044519557,
0.0479688086,
-0.0309851822,
-0.0080449134,
-0.031713672,
0.01174819,
-0.0210428592,
-0.0255711749,
-0.0074481936,
0.0226412304,
-0.0404077545,
-0.0259186067,
0.0173974894,
-0.0416925475,
0.028716255,
-0.0519451909,
0.0079507651,
-0.0096473331,
-0.0156068346,
0.0263995044,
-0.022919897,
-0.0507294312,
-0.0295666475,
-0.0500287898,
-0.0505419895,
-0.026290236,
0.0682289824,
-0.03864545,
-0.0314774103,
0.0311036333,
0.0238163993,
-0.0573845915,
-0.0257547069,
-0.010539446,
-0.0318318605,
-0.0570229366,
0.0165981483,
-0.0234721135,
-6.016172373e-33,
-0.0044628223,
0.0012770059,
0.0348426104,
-0.0147789698,
-0.0698493868,
-0.0265758242,
0.0009103392,
0.0283685178,
-0.0561852902,
0.012983717,
0.0071599027,
-0.0017138965,
0.0058160159,
-0.0106224464,
0.030385796,
-0.0188489426,
0.0317628346,
-0.0206004977,
-0.0407268815,
0.0123374378,
0.0036854337,
-0.0199353043,
0.0601389632,
-0.045917958,
0.0173472445,
0.0231551006,
-0.0330864117,
0.023495052,
0.0098384079,
0.0646472275,
-0.0283342525,
0.0108553804,
0.0150841353,
-0.0082917744,
-0.0113088321,
0.0574260354,
-0.0130212754,
0.0035265994,
0.0407059677,
0.0301662181,
-0.0233721044,
-0.0551349483,
0.0347017273,
-0.040284209,
-0.0650667176,
0.0124071538,
0.0234215166,
-0.0115981214,
-0.0050981338,
0.0089743799,
-0.0881849229,
0.0034910962,
-0.0211466029,
-0.0081013795,
0.0089279795,
0.007176307,
-0.0074000945,
0.0031468358,
-0.0409822688,
0.0210677218,
-0.0127159702,
0.006668231,
0.0931920707,
0.0586312786,
0.0381389037,
0.0557402521,
0.0146453045,
0.0019325842,
-0.0341250449,
-0.0087383501,
0.0412845165,
0.0386270396,
0.004156834,
0.0422006585,
-0.0310869459,
0.0041150795,
-0.0272475835,
0.029588744,
0.0004491164,
0.0239886735,
0.0205628481,
0.054268226,
-0.0556987748,
-0.0011495082,
-0.0169040598,
-0.006673099,
-0.0207684394,
-0.0049614124,
0.0224868208,
-0.0029065735,
-0.0176881347,
0.02580438,
0.0450594164,
-0.04319809,
0.0044362997,
0.0073280944,
-0.0267759152,
0.0366438404,
-0.0078430204,
-0.019740859,
-0.0937004089,
-0.0422738455,
0.0033048377,
0.0306687895,
0.0235503707,
0.0292046927,
0.0175599232,
0.0145418011,
-0.0241372678,
-0.0039014469,
-0.025129715,
-0.0004295282,
0.0079199923,
-0.0264572091,
0.0745600313,
0.0026033069,
0.0011821778,
0.0541521907,
0.0030231059,
-0.0066402485,
-0.0401423238,
0.0019587276,
0.0251501445,
-0.0027508803,
-0.0011431789,
0.0140382387,
-0.0312686376,
0.0009295179,
0.0404109098,
-0.0285443142,
-0.013640956,
0.0117972447,
2.563e-7,
-0.0063554375,
0.0188838001,
0.0573150814,
0.0240430087,
-0.0365087427,
0.0754131302,
0.0171521064,
0.0370093137,
0.0012308744,
-0.0049802307,
0.0844023451,
0.0244871899,
0.0635480285,
-0.0285318214,
-0.0495841615,
-0.0024087871,
-0.0730428472,
0.0129927173,
-0.0355605483,
0.0324870907,
0.0217162408,
0.047949221,
0.0032244695,
0.0057538408,
0.0324605331,
0.0267929994,
0.0559150949,
-0.0763116106,
0.0070945825,
0.0244814791,
-0.0122028794,
0.0040668687,
-0.0294275209,
-0.0234728027,
0.0180695839,
0.021337539,
0.0153607372,
0.0941877514,
-0.0434524044,
-0.0200169049,
-0.0487515926,
0.0021012349,
-0.0113508683,
-0.058827132,
0.0342440307,
-0.0484145731,
-0.0468365327,
-0.0345918164,
-0.0096321935,
-0.0031229041,
0.0135451024,
0.0062222946,
-0.0066818404,
0.0022945958,
0.0416102335,
0.0193023495,
-0.0395662673,
-0.0733807459,
0.0078438064,
0.0104528898,
-0.0328049064,
-0.0801065341,
-0.0195999127,
0.0405908115,
0.0210344531,
-0.0357688814,
-0.0089092301,
1.871644605e-34,
-0.0153046418,
-0.0298869926,
0.0599389598,
-0.004861678,
0.0264456216,
0.037335787,
-0.0236984715,
0.0081846481,
0.0362394936,
-0.0856016725,
-0.0012257108
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.