id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15727v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15727v2 | Quantifying and Analyzing Entity-level Memorization in Large Language Models | 2023-08-30T03:06:47 | 2023-11-05T13:44:55 | Zhenhong Zhou, Jiuyang Xiang, Chaomeng Chen, Sen Su | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have been proven capable of memorizing their
training data, which can be extracted through specifically designed prompts. As
the scale of datasets continues to grow, privacy risks arising from
memorization have attracted increasing attention. Quantifying language model
memorization helps evaluate potential privacy risks. However, prior works on
quantifying memorization require access to the precise original data or incur
substantial computational overhead, making it difficult for applications in
real-world language models. To this end, we propose a fine-grained,
entity-level definition to quantify memorization with conditions and metrics
closer to real-world scenarios. In addition, we also present an approach for
efficiently extracting sensitive entities from autoregressive language models.
We conduct extensive experiments based on the proposed, probing language
models' ability to reconstruct sensitive entities under different settings. We
find that language models have strong memorization at the entity level and are
able to reproduce the training data even with partial leakages. The results
demonstrate that LLMs not only memorize their training data but also understand
associations between entities. These findings necessitate that trainers of LLMs
exercise greater prudence regarding model memorization, adopting memorization
mitigation techniques to preclude privacy violations. | [
0.0314228758,
0.1107548922,
-0.0300479215,
0.0579198897,
-0.0424270853,
0.0137016503,
0.0576162115,
-0.0040682363,
0.040856488,
-0.0243177768,
-0.0180877149,
-0.0728897452,
0.0034246291,
-0.000661813,
0.0284884255,
0.0002958559,
0.0291192289,
-0.0411850438,
-0.0113329478,
-0.0364601165,
-0.0280435402,
0.0120633431,
0.021059081,
0.001681666,
0.0042397599,
-0.0194470286,
-0.007322825,
-0.0328482576,
0.0157222021,
-0.0248862598,
-0.0035643792,
0.049233254,
0.0193211548,
0.0362414531,
0.0000019993,
-0.0329440981,
-0.0778084174,
0.0149424812,
-0.073956877,
0.0467114374,
-0.0163461436,
-0.0201307647,
0.0119063715,
-0.0204376858,
-0.029477939,
-0.0088635851,
0.0382139683,
0.0194710847,
0.0530635044,
0.0514193289,
-0.0021607024,
-0.0101498691,
0.0108961388,
-0.0193730015,
-0.0050237835,
-0.0605322719,
0.0492156893,
-0.0324600488,
-0.0555645451,
0.0105504962,
-0.005290118,
0.0452881977,
0.0214842651,
0.0444726236,
0.0213230513,
0.0409895815,
0.0276611689,
0.0128194997,
0.007130458,
0.0290924888,
0.0638026819,
-0.0154046817,
0.0315202326,
0.0292782448,
0.0127898296,
0.0201106407,
-0.007872507,
0.0351270959,
-0.029386282,
-0.0138269942,
0.005463528,
-0.0309724417,
0.0399709307,
0.0103511084,
-0.008790778,
0.0159248766,
0.0200793706,
-0.0228353012,
-0.0302834101,
-0.0506072901,
0.0220567882,
-0.0795571059,
0.0549497418,
0.0133286146,
0.022136949,
0.0574518703,
-0.0489720665,
-0.0024873617,
0.0458745062,
-0.0455417894,
0.0308132134,
-0.0060408609,
0.050957907,
0.050778456,
-0.0232579838,
0.0631443635,
-0.0090106046,
-0.0016863857,
0.03192297,
0.001739343,
-0.032940615,
-0.0212907195,
-0.011848351,
0.0632916391,
0.0333084203,
0.0345292352,
-0.026568681,
0.0192885455,
-0.0224022791,
0.0599130541,
-0.0412513651,
-0.0035362761,
-0.017902758,
-0.0257925428,
-0.0329884589,
-0.0544307232,
-0.0367635451,
-0.0053887651,
0.0126600163,
-0.0443167575,
-0.0140588861,
-0.0777140111,
-0.0049378499,
-0.0282907709,
-0.0115158996,
0.0776007324,
0.039478343,
-0.0294222794,
-0.057923004,
-0.0721188337,
0.0180319827,
-0.0457207449,
-0.0101583004,
-0.0463506356,
0.0142809013,
0.0046567493,
0.0018108706,
-0.0746793672,
0.0001367463,
0.0124837793,
-0.0533772893,
0.0552362427,
0.0313095525,
-0.0047493819,
-0.0063514328,
0.0422659963,
0.0371907577,
0.0361460783,
0.0248582587,
0.0149831166,
0.0663467422,
-0.0347992368,
0.0181101635,
0.0169866607,
0.035277091,
0.0051015657,
-0.0172195807,
0.0243618768,
0.0288624857,
-0.043588616,
0.0092977211,
0.049852185,
-0.0062305927,
-0.0763355121,
0.0713659227,
0.068197608,
-0.022196468,
0.0218306947,
-0.0300922357,
-0.0201808847,
0.0267350581,
0.0265969709,
-0.0642624795,
0.0144108646,
-0.0354897231,
-0.0275914837,
-0.0094682928,
0.0172185078,
-0.0233048759,
0.0110455416,
0.0210943017,
-0.0316617638,
0.0162805635,
0.0363794118,
0.0037105705,
0.019889405,
0.0094118947,
0.0949185267,
0.0164678823,
-0.0504365265,
0.0099661276,
-0.0295143016,
0.0048785778,
0.0818163455,
0.0439270027,
-0.0212598741,
0.0223527476,
-0.0355757996,
-0.0047276593,
-0.0183050446,
0.0216031484,
-0.0199809205,
0.0562226959,
-0.0244254284,
-0.0328708403,
0.0193222221,
0.040132314,
0.0454698503,
0.0224632211,
-0.0021467104,
0.0191281047,
-0.0325087793,
-0.0145575432,
0.0378722921,
-0.0689045265,
-0.0598257147,
0.0042525381,
0.0255399663,
0.0031672481,
0.0475929081,
-0.0027213471,
0.004071963,
0.0175652746,
0.0241941288,
0.0317706503,
-0.0401918292,
-0.0416896269,
0.0337994248,
-0.0161542874,
0.0209150985,
0.0072206361,
0.01652468,
0.0147017986,
-0.0251781903,
-0.0079983743,
-0.0160886329,
0.0874006674,
-0.0127666621,
0.0214180481,
-0.0206269547,
-0.0034629344,
-0.0356494151,
0.0474517792,
-0.0377170406,
0.0175410304,
-0.0121377818,
-0.0128615396,
0.0063888361,
-0.0575477853,
-0.0252902322,
0.0119614396,
-0.009286209,
0.0345851816,
0.0423726141,
-0.0511184745,
-0.0449858643,
-0.0255458523,
-0.0510224141,
0.0174250789,
-0.0044872887,
0.0494034477,
-0.0054500271,
0.0048223748,
-0.0153094484,
-0.0191951822,
-0.0544453561,
-0.0271826871,
-0.0668651164,
0.0631829351,
0.0159085654,
-0.0028147418,
-0.0409478992,
-0.0134987477,
-0.0180460736,
-0.0161856189,
0.0608268231,
-0.0240846276,
-0.0018068359,
-0.0229203459,
0.0539474301,
-0.0299049318,
0.0125670545,
-0.0079400688,
-0.0197250973,
0.006622171,
0.01855582,
0.010058363,
0.0876782909,
0.0174913723,
0.0378736593,
0.0166289713,
-0.029283274,
-0.0618613251,
-0.0281455442,
-0.0269430913,
-0.0275461245,
-0.0323667191,
-0.0306631364,
0.0049330802,
0.0485340767,
0.0095061278,
-0.0340677239,
-0.0221029315,
0.0374770351,
-0.0247281529,
-0.031721618,
-0.0314612687,
-0.0064246897,
-0.0255401693,
0.0423437394,
-0.0156309064,
-0.0534742139,
0.0655365512,
-0.0133392559,
0.0231095031,
0.031756416,
-0.0036732478,
0.0026244873,
0.078367494,
0.0101291677,
0.0400557443,
0.0536245778,
-0.0656305104,
-0.0366478041,
0.0092984186,
0.046169769,
-0.0681667626,
0.0261877533,
-0.0046761176,
-0.0107652759,
0.0246757381,
-0.0276326779,
-0.0841968283,
-0.0220733527,
0.0076185558,
0.0035815074,
-0.0107960356,
-0.0396762304,
-0.0121280104,
-0.0305873137,
0.0463465974,
-0.0226279497,
0.0116779767,
0.0029866993,
-0.0010758797,
-0.0083984742,
0.014160037,
-0.0476349257,
0.0259353369,
-0.0406715423,
0.0105869677,
0.0754934251,
0.0604537763,
0.0113401152,
0.0280878209,
-0.0021638446,
0.0147506855,
-0.0513431169,
-0.0095272483,
0.0268469881,
0.0319336727,
-0.0643649325,
-0.0078253811,
0.0837964267,
0.0281147882,
-0.0353571251,
-0.0026132669,
0.0501197539,
0.0247174837,
0.0056194528,
-0.0201883335,
-0.086135976,
0.0279000122,
0.0265024733,
0.0412395075,
-0.0275168996,
-0.0859417245,
-0.0274153557,
-0.0929123461,
-0.0235649552,
0.0061894669,
-0.0314075425,
-0.02220897,
-0.0703847483,
0.0069353953,
-0.0177182853,
0.0226144902,
-0.0165832322,
-0.0260765757,
-0.0141570261,
0.0102671888,
-0.0204797834,
-0.0245142579,
0.0365511328,
-0.0354735591,
0.079518497,
0.056604635,
0.0299772937,
-0.0077780094,
-0.0403487459,
-0.0160113275,
-0.0103163226,
-0.026580479,
0.024745686,
0.0647911876,
-0.0257362425,
-0.0141035682,
-0.0031214152,
0.0438609906,
-0.0059693139,
-0.0099168811,
0.0191720556,
0.0317982174,
0.0014672271,
-0.0083200485,
0.0341041796,
-0.0458826423,
0.0285598878,
0.0832753479,
0.0164413098,
-0.0218350329,
0.015481594,
-0.0406577848,
0.0607474521,
-0.0233239066,
0.0032619524,
0.0134622399,
-0.0334039479,
-0.0405871049,
-0.0536136366,
-0.0421462394,
0.0104357265,
0.0084280167,
0.0538904667,
0.0142652076,
0.0388644747,
-0.0314008556,
-0.0366373546,
0.00753571,
-0.0764287114,
0.0275087077,
-0.0435764007,
-0.0449944027,
0.0085212979,
0.0289249234,
-0.0136131914,
0.0026603485,
-0.0817675665,
-0.0711775944,
0.0472993851,
0.0346251912,
0.0241353065,
0.0479623787,
0.0101085249,
-0.0496440306,
0.0500465296,
0.0200762469,
-0.0819409341,
-0.0038311635,
0.0475495718,
-0.0076963184,
-0.0085790502,
0.0371901542,
-0.0361198075,
-0.006490598,
0.0587569475,
-0.0162772592,
-0.0464700274,
-0.0560374483,
0.0030181652,
0.0362285264,
-0.0116037661,
0.0185365863,
0.0093775,
-0.0378494337,
0.0117003024,
-0.0189981405,
0.0024890553,
-0.0074141533,
-0.0064664916,
0.0385154039,
-0.0030463175,
0.0186300408,
-0.0371111594,
0.0323804244,
0.0342081301,
-0.0195484683,
-0.0038838645,
0.0202299822,
0.0185781214,
0.0339542255,
0.0063799149,
-0.0312558077,
0.0520492867,
0.0119904382,
0.0542979166,
-0.006943888,
0.0410675853,
-0.0040539964,
0.0042874818,
-0.0297008827,
0.0094260471,
-0.0482830144,
-0.0245595351,
0.0075882399,
0.0299779829,
0.0084998328,
-0.0224040095,
0.0086595565,
-0.043828994,
0.0121185211,
-0.0261865221,
-0.0146607673,
0.0017936956,
-0.0183526184,
-0.0087313345,
0.0291116331,
-0.0222357586,
0.0540035665,
0.0843836442,
0.0108616222,
0.0634861588,
-0.0162163116,
0.0008178654,
-0.0458815396,
-0.020195974,
0.0290042274,
0.0104908096,
-0.029271163,
-0.0354777165,
-0.0697694197,
-0.0804733634,
0.0017845989,
-0.0216982942,
-0.0148569206,
-0.0135891521,
0.0056037335,
0.0192799531,
-0.0050793462,
0.003110467,
-0.0686526075,
0.0048803794,
-0.0085207373,
-0.0171155948,
-0.0170054287,
-5.696596602e-33,
-0.0162811633,
-0.0108678639,
-0.0101879137,
0.0153786568,
0.0194939896,
0.0446682274,
-0.027184207,
0.0074374233,
-0.0249866471,
-0.0317029953,
-0.0362296142,
-0.015563068,
0.0094570043,
0.0114695411,
-0.0145203648,
-0.0305639058,
0.0435086265,
-0.0154485581,
-0.0097763538,
0.0547569878,
0.0654074699,
0.0472484231,
0.045291502,
-0.0914371908,
0.0842166245,
0.0018646689,
-0.0287117884,
0.0077022933,
-0.0149398707,
0.0637064576,
-0.0481914431,
-0.0104453163,
-0.0045045614,
-0.0539986938,
-0.0074656447,
0.0202264059,
-0.102428183,
-0.0176118948,
0.0062167151,
-0.0012239793,
0.0338095725,
-0.0680923238,
0.032953646,
-0.048673939,
0.0146061201,
-0.0123511553,
0.0087483665,
-0.0179022755,
-0.0476972163,
-0.0379894599,
0.001254443,
0.0064448607,
-0.0207909048,
0.0139148599,
0.0602198988,
-0.0157318581,
0.020917872,
-0.0235917196,
-0.066452913,
0.0209185239,
0.0522261672,
-0.0103653222,
0.0354719721,
0.033087261,
0.0472184829,
0.0815879181,
0.0433338843,
0.0487079918,
0.0004830004,
0.0100503545,
0.0337398238,
0.0066786082,
-0.0173358209,
0.0276239179,
0.023516003,
-0.02971722,
-0.0184714384,
0.0021081155,
-0.024776781,
0.016936399,
0.06018693,
-0.0150949126,
-0.0704822019,
-0.0267878659,
-0.0594994873,
0.0102485046,
-0.0366383977,
-0.0032736741,
0.0106127225,
-0.0172522534,
-0.0772289783,
-0.0138309551,
0.01670813,
-0.0474068038,
-0.0845086053,
0.0447090566,
0.0415793732,
-0.0274223723,
-0.0082445983,
0.0253328402,
-0.055184491,
-0.0128625501,
-0.0065205256,
-0.0481256209,
0.0333157666,
0.028155297,
0.0302590635,
0.0030968527,
-0.0854874849,
-0.0155957798,
-0.0285199881,
0.0377013795,
0.030393159,
0.0222304463,
0.0346506946,
-0.0075099869,
0.0131335128,
0.0035968891,
0.0634564906,
-0.0088990703,
-0.0330963507,
0.0655741394,
-0.0280359555,
0.0209257081,
0.013438982,
-0.0474948771,
0.0037361979,
0.0265543927,
0.0988754183,
0.0052939826,
0.0274772532,
-0.0402583815,
2.605e-7,
-0.0085666627,
0.0029716003,
0.0119271865,
-0.0047809989,
0.0016209767,
0.067338489,
0.0053745979,
0.0545149036,
0.0051701209,
-0.0365284234,
-0.0279751793,
0.0290900376,
0.0537976176,
0.0569098964,
-0.068847388,
-0.0098428344,
-0.0144255282,
-0.0025767693,
-0.0481993183,
0.0090088658,
-0.0012389719,
0.0841703489,
0.0576157048,
-0.007685354,
-0.0323284194,
-0.0490797348,
0.0412953869,
-0.0708421022,
-0.004734382,
0.0160262417,
0.0334582292,
0.0848587155,
0.0042787543,
0.0337797739,
-0.0171345547,
0.0195851196,
-0.0340214632,
0.0661599487,
0.0358189046,
-0.0219603181,
-0.0091474373,
-0.083900772,
-0.0314577147,
-0.0436197259,
0.0491195209,
-0.0120630516,
-0.0321866795,
-0.0043099951,
0.0223528147,
-0.0475200973,
0.0298702735,
0.0012973188,
-0.0006723335,
0.0249912404,
-0.0230602864,
0.0047719516,
0.0217739604,
-0.0621591173,
-0.0151953455,
-0.0388657153,
-0.0053515509,
-0.0352038667,
0.0166300386,
0.0019381428,
-0.0366828069,
-0.0612547696,
0.0629048795,
2.405465288e-34,
-0.0177718028,
-0.0128679369,
-0.0213026758,
0.0596469752,
0.0383691415,
-0.0307884831,
0.0249617994,
0.0290518496,
0.0092455009,
-0.0629027039,
-0.0084666098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15711v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15711v1 | Optimizing Factual Accuracy in Text Generation through Dynamic Knowledge Selection | 2023-08-30T02:22:40 | 2023-08-30T02:22:40 | Hongjin Qian, Zhicheng Dou, Jiejun Tan, Haonan Chen, Haoqi Gu, Ruofei Lai, Xinyu Zhang, Zhao Cao, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models (LMs) have revolutionized the way we interact with
information, but they often generate nonfactual text, raising concerns about
their reliability. Previous methods use external knowledge as references for
text generation to enhance factuality but often struggle with the knowledge
mix-up(e.g., entity mismatch) of irrelevant references. Besides,as the length
of the output text grows, the randomness of sampling can escalate,
detrimentally impacting the factual accuracy of the generated text. In this
paper, we present DKGen, which divide the text generation process into an
iterative process. In each iteration, DKGen takes the input query, the
previously generated text and a subset of the reference passages as input to
generate short text. During the process, the subset is dynamically selected
from the full passage set based on their relevance to the previously generated
text and the query, largely eliminating the irrelevant references from input.
To further enhance DKGen's ability to correctly use these external knowledge,
DKGen distills the relevance order of reference passages to the cross-attention
distribution of decoder. We train and evaluate DKGen on a large-scale benchmark
dataset. Experiment results show that DKGen outperforms all baseline models. | [
0.0557748936,
0.0142039685,
0.0002497454,
-0.0041532223,
-0.0251344722,
0.0061284644,
-0.0058324682,
0.0186382309,
-0.0053583751,
-0.0648399591,
0.0199032575,
-0.0301913265,
0.0238808468,
0.0165035818,
0.0495616235,
-0.0397173539,
0.0263453536,
0.0022324191,
0.0069183148,
0.0098147662,
-0.0179482326,
0.046479214,
-0.0133096632,
0.0303159524,
-0.0197289325,
-0.0048233848,
-0.0097519625,
0.016721759,
0.0083973436,
-0.0228051562,
0.0088584106,
0.0493002832,
-0.0280185621,
0.0083559295,
0.0000020983,
-0.0226628762,
-0.0117363855,
-0.0124656605,
-0.0251869559,
0.0149577279,
0.0395556465,
-0.007877388,
-0.0037029849,
0.014085792,
-0.0039098593,
-0.0081858812,
0.0259099714,
0.0353759602,
0.0605110712,
0.0629839674,
0.0237960462,
0.028614793,
-0.0121989828,
-0.0153739313,
0.0317256525,
-0.0260639507,
0.0176420193,
0.0360045582,
-0.0200283583,
0.0400278196,
0.0160896946,
0.0533581711,
-0.0064569945,
-0.0247446708,
0.0678945258,
0.0545072295,
-0.0249400511,
-0.0189073887,
0.0361462198,
0.078869231,
-0.0155794406,
-0.0413177982,
0.0358064845,
-0.0082757045,
-0.0155389309,
0.0010940424,
-0.0220948514,
0.0269244071,
-0.0383617282,
0.0234691426,
0.0066589657,
0.0069931885,
0.01446715,
0.0231944956,
0.0106377602,
0.0233110804,
0.0196489301,
-0.0153471539,
-0.0199607089,
0.0271149259,
0.0312990658,
-0.0935799405,
0.0125445714,
0.012187941,
-0.0057421732,
0.0208592601,
-0.0921268314,
-0.0302260127,
0.0298565999,
-0.0645802394,
-0.01210526,
0.0212892536,
0.0354350805,
0.0109477555,
-0.0298558101,
0.0347856022,
0.0255519394,
-0.005474132,
-0.0280991085,
0.0030676452,
-0.0213867761,
-0.0116786435,
-0.0184417982,
0.0240607727,
-0.0462173559,
-0.0116755832,
-0.0352557711,
0.0049700695,
0.0307009388,
-0.0097073968,
0.0120590106,
0.0192189049,
-0.0649893805,
0.0029419675,
-0.0411681011,
0.0136358328,
-0.0118311625,
-0.0002874935,
0.0095932856,
-0.0531440638,
-0.0075450363,
0.0075113573,
0.0071099345,
-0.0385575555,
-0.0460694246,
0.045149792,
-0.0488416068,
-0.0075502805,
-0.0803539231,
-0.0601760186,
0.0053146542,
-0.0494729131,
-0.0197295863,
-0.0438198075,
0.0185043812,
0.0133454865,
-0.0308466386,
-0.0418334752,
0.0273811463,
0.0517879575,
-0.0396666378,
0.0275788829,
-0.0259297844,
0.0267863218,
0.0422191247,
-0.009631481,
0.0558478981,
0.0713137984,
0.0497726463,
0.0247543044,
0.0244886987,
0.0486971438,
-0.0116249109,
-0.002383197,
0.0347976126,
0.0030823525,
-0.0227002837,
-0.0087523609,
-0.0274125971,
0.0386390053,
0.0602931194,
0.0597466081,
-0.0297981109,
0.0175135545,
0.0912737623,
-0.0445544347,
0.0197959598,
0.0425952226,
0.0709987059,
0.0567756891,
-0.004092115,
0.0240826271,
-0.0161536355,
0.043301601,
-0.0162241869,
0.0484002978,
0.0668795258,
0.0384471528,
-0.0166462585,
-0.0258772839,
0.0065821195,
-0.0097252792,
-0.0107792318,
-0.0127635356,
0.0317074209,
0.0602463111,
-0.0835338533,
0.0829304457,
0.0071447827,
-0.0619755499,
0.0403733328,
-0.0170561392,
0.0365175419,
0.0719180778,
0.1002071202,
0.0155420741,
-0.0187715068,
-0.0173423663,
-0.0119854845,
0.0707300007,
0.0451136678,
-0.0015005735,
-0.0240811352,
-0.0706524998,
-0.0397368744,
0.000516399,
0.0194978025,
-0.013509172,
0.0348188691,
0.0467756577,
0.0591924898,
-0.0680682585,
-0.0350404121,
0.0378816798,
-0.0292462744,
-0.0436885655,
0.0024759138,
-0.0019217001,
-0.0114445137,
0.0060572345,
-0.0204076562,
0.0241274461,
0.0099052424,
0.0034205734,
-0.0068546729,
0.0089103589,
-0.0270670187,
-0.0674579069,
0.0012714266,
-0.0519227162,
-0.0025238497,
0.0006356852,
-0.0203560777,
-0.0451030992,
0.0158224311,
-0.0669682175,
0.0173024051,
-0.036327716,
-0.0088599548,
0.0375627279,
0.0112684751,
-0.0269550364,
0.0987797081,
-0.005566888,
0.0053877942,
0.037396919,
0.0033834586,
-0.0021404184,
-0.0554589741,
0.0226758812,
-0.018028738,
-0.0047257897,
0.0073636994,
0.0255617704,
0.008464884,
-0.0313358493,
-0.0213828888,
-0.0324383117,
-0.0102928514,
-0.0072498233,
-0.0058010118,
0.0256101284,
0.0051747872,
-0.0034090008,
0.0027087503,
-0.0243874062,
-0.0128251966,
0.0151518583,
-0.0098130088,
0.0443173647,
0.0031987345,
0.0394412093,
-0.0206180997,
0.0084367506,
0.0107396254,
0.0519882366,
0.0576138496,
-0.0174776502,
-0.0458220914,
0.0739577413,
-0.0592174269,
-0.0294751842,
0.0084762927,
-0.0339335687,
-0.0203909762,
0.0271027498,
0.042769365,
0.0214803349,
0.0542773902,
-0.0280379597,
0.0099132629,
-0.0164401904,
-0.0591235533,
0.0074702306,
-0.024167452,
0.0170245208,
0.0049236184,
-0.0938338488,
0.0289082024,
0.0536767617,
0.0592045635,
-0.0121244993,
-0.0480520688,
0.0127782589,
-0.0033205515,
-0.0172568411,
-0.044058688,
-0.0077023399,
-0.0172876995,
0.0282714758,
-0.0406653434,
-0.0251717977,
0.0803667456,
-0.0393185616,
0.0241297781,
-0.0565641932,
0.0420430414,
-0.0104709892,
0.0102358572,
-0.0099377446,
0.0250360575,
0.035065107,
-0.007938575,
-0.0327036604,
0.0249252319,
0.028713312,
-0.0478149056,
0.0790446848,
-0.0563925765,
0.0053149611,
0.0079808198,
-0.0125317965,
-0.0733690336,
-0.0215031952,
0.0181913637,
-0.0039735544,
0.0314889923,
-0.0046485486,
-0.0409164578,
0.0079205064,
0.0570535064,
0.0257519167,
-0.0131990211,
-0.0140035031,
-0.0318141133,
0.0367568694,
0.0648940578,
0.0099416291,
0.0124816038,
-0.0213086512,
-0.020500727,
0.0345960446,
0.0223372113,
-0.0025449644,
0.0429016277,
-0.0237144362,
-0.0031455427,
-0.0349267758,
-0.0340885967,
0.0271607321,
0.0245826375,
-0.0555982701,
-0.0426479429,
0.1028127521,
0.0333553888,
-0.0342149362,
-0.0058900644,
0.0230443683,
0.0298223738,
0.0057646418,
0.0408802554,
-0.0834988728,
-0.0264273677,
0.0083249351,
0.0551144443,
-0.017006686,
-0.0320962593,
-0.0337838009,
-0.1302377582,
0.0189233851,
0.0204760209,
-0.0319729112,
-0.0510173887,
-0.0309799444,
-0.0124728605,
-0.0057349321,
-0.0062612146,
0.0561162867,
-0.0117600383,
0.0472216979,
0.0169956423,
-0.0198563319,
-0.0785287842,
-0.0329385921,
-0.020117173,
0.0390659831,
0.0829197317,
0.0499094874,
0.0328930169,
0.0024971419,
-0.0082320198,
-0.0502155982,
-0.0011958508,
-0.004180022,
0.0719917268,
-0.0352342427,
0.0083003473,
-0.0437113903,
0.014294629,
-0.0215594508,
0.0151097532,
-0.0165238623,
0.0429808199,
-0.0090448558,
-0.0165562071,
-0.0127640879,
0.0357124917,
0.0439696945,
0.0858729556,
0.049389936,
-0.0089584934,
-0.0391882844,
-0.0637349039,
0.0443996862,
-0.0902135298,
-0.0065764873,
0.026156744,
-0.028179707,
-0.0459088013,
-0.1167498976,
-0.0389307477,
-0.0014388688,
0.0140083209,
0.0125811296,
0.0166096371,
0.0436479002,
-0.0470477194,
-0.0322378948,
-0.0108034378,
-0.0266255625,
-0.0057765688,
-0.0161655005,
-0.0539662503,
0.005209954,
-0.0775483251,
0.0052224882,
0.0475473367,
-0.0581798814,
-0.0475675054,
-0.018008044,
0.0298070703,
0.0231660083,
0.0434316471,
-0.0274698585,
-0.0425279625,
0.0446548834,
0.047432635,
-0.0447889827,
0.0319981799,
-0.0289595965,
0.0149018234,
-0.0001558818,
0.0341354609,
-0.0573637895,
0.0054292078,
-0.0238450915,
0.0440619327,
-0.0281549245,
-0.0601527244,
0.0224921461,
0.0295896735,
-0.0178018045,
-0.0294021238,
0.0227429383,
-0.0417864248,
0.0126987593,
0.0047722375,
-0.0177018046,
-0.0395726524,
0.0398718379,
0.0148010347,
0.0077322978,
-0.0052288547,
-0.002597898,
-0.0449943617,
0.0290244706,
-0.0301682875,
-0.0469019413,
-0.0094359517,
0.0547055863,
0.0422066636,
-0.0348842479,
-0.0373411179,
0.015588481,
-0.0114596551,
0.0255628228,
-0.0251047444,
0.0150360269,
0.0232625976,
-0.004449307,
0.0042524952,
-0.0321214832,
-0.0422773547,
0.0325425081,
-0.0610411353,
-0.0162877031,
0.0291108619,
-0.0022441698,
0.0802965164,
-0.0364453606,
0.00870868,
-0.011349014,
0.0606339388,
0.0240203682,
-0.0272554643,
-0.0381537788,
-0.0079288622,
-0.0291830506,
-0.0089324852,
0.1195414588,
0.0059444085,
0.0349643193,
-0.0235445295,
-0.0373499356,
-0.0582642145,
-0.0366861671,
-0.0393095948,
0.009808558,
-0.0147382673,
0.0027533439,
-0.0548922122,
-0.057730455,
0.0455361605,
-0.0063931206,
0.0207886454,
-0.0230727512,
0.0584307946,
0.0410473198,
-0.0021427937,
-0.0140514495,
-0.0727444589,
0.0427023806,
-0.0118155787,
-0.0168499723,
-0.0400102399,
-6.537719013e-33,
-0.051815249,
-0.0506855696,
0.0074427389,
-0.0439192131,
-0.0416094922,
0.0164262801,
-0.0776826441,
-0.0369190015,
0.0297857467,
0.0210798662,
0.0065677194,
0.0077724573,
0.010723752,
0.0437011458,
-0.0238600317,
0.0060696695,
0.0606994592,
-0.0200206116,
-0.0442450196,
0.0572712161,
0.0711795911,
0.0418743007,
0.0102577265,
-0.0498338565,
0.0110884476,
-0.00873709,
-0.0091979736,
-0.0225413833,
0.0009755919,
0.0436925888,
-0.0178793147,
0.0444603674,
0.0098503865,
-0.0341608934,
-0.0421813652,
-0.0131471837,
-0.0651142746,
-0.0184858087,
0.0001763789,
-0.0091794636,
0.0048976545,
-0.0496790372,
0.0500205383,
-0.0130713703,
0.0086330213,
0.0005021893,
0.063002415,
-0.0368692726,
-0.0550230742,
-0.0594625287,
-0.0337288007,
0.0465156175,
0.0051818881,
-0.0080751227,
-0.0251457468,
0.0626699701,
0.0019236825,
-0.0054990267,
-0.0711208731,
0.0498633757,
0.0301133674,
0.0427117683,
0.062703073,
0.0051641902,
0.0110525964,
0.0638372749,
-0.0279158503,
-0.0187847223,
-0.0590546019,
0.003661033,
-0.0095670773,
0.0386830159,
0.006801873,
0.0717762187,
-0.0068363422,
-0.0404630303,
-0.0621831641,
0.0527531542,
-0.0079548527,
-0.0001196686,
0.043290358,
-0.0485172607,
-0.0289694145,
-0.0132286483,
-0.0346203484,
0.0098540457,
-0.0212005675,
-0.019558847,
0.0330823399,
0.0557794683,
-0.0329885483,
-0.0293762814,
0.0046920869,
-0.0064647496,
0.0011948654,
0.0403412767,
-0.0485104211,
0.0019762039,
-0.0097548375,
-0.0116036767,
-0.0671087205,
-0.0149721541,
0.0492234379,
0.0206931718,
-0.0270345919,
0.0345642641,
0.0068716439,
0.010128635,
-0.0385435112,
0.0190457441,
-0.0458730161,
0.0493490957,
0.0070729288,
-0.0058728503,
0.0182231665,
-0.0228021499,
-0.0202923659,
0.003428617,
0.0046424945,
0.0121766189,
0.012799127,
-0.030121373,
0.015668001,
0.0472899787,
-0.0415800624,
0.0142775998,
-0.0366849937,
-0.002676364,
0.0036448569,
-0.0463435315,
-0.0173494816,
0.037514478,
2.8e-7,
0.0227113012,
0.0331385471,
0.035242606,
0.0341210552,
0.0049016234,
0.0156608429,
0.0172102489,
0.0501028113,
-0.0070425239,
-0.0037871157,
-0.000061442,
-0.0014833977,
0.0563797615,
0.0255658347,
-0.0871955454,
-0.0309769437,
-0.0365582779,
0.0145976786,
-0.0418644324,
-0.0399419442,
0.0076380908,
0.045089595,
-0.0087482044,
-0.0021599461,
0.0293571595,
-0.03275197,
0.0719636455,
0.0195826553,
-0.0361420363,
0.0378012173,
0.0908274427,
-0.0086143417,
-0.0132922651,
0.0220992398,
-0.0725883543,
-0.0288312659,
0.0111755896,
0.0418783613,
0.0392730236,
-0.0565615483,
0.0237583518,
-0.0241878219,
0.0208934452,
-0.0397725478,
0.0599402934,
-0.0219754074,
0.0261131488,
0.0437625647,
-0.0379098505,
0.0227943119,
-0.0113592176,
-0.0398828983,
-0.0446986668,
0.0244464949,
0.0173426773,
0.0254527554,
-0.0127680954,
-0.033181157,
-0.0365652516,
0.0047680088,
-0.0697909743,
-0.0247617569,
-0.039174445,
-0.0155261243,
0.0304821283,
-0.0382940918,
0.0215997156,
2.731775862e-34,
0.0356074832,
-0.0039819614,
-0.0337642431,
-0.0169332754,
0.0295793656,
-0.0042203241,
-0.0085478071,
0.0232320316,
0.0125099141,
-0.0612993874,
-0.0295791663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08613v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08613v1 | Multimodal Recommender Systems in the Prediction of Disease Comorbidity | 2023-08-30T01:40:45 | 2023-08-30T01:40:45 | Aashish Cheruvu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | While deep-learning based recommender systems utilizing collaborative
filtering have been commonly used for recommendation in other domains, their
application in the medical domain have been limited. In addition to modeling
user-item interactions, we show that deep-learning based recommender systems
can be used to model subject-disease code interactions. Two novel applications
of deep learning-based recommender systems using Neural Collaborative Filtering
(NCF) and Deep Hybrid Filtering (DHF) were utilized for disease diagnosis based
on known past patient comorbidities. Two datasets, one incorporating all
subject-disease code pairs present in the MIMIC-III database, and the other
incorporating the top 50 most commonly occurring diseases, were used for
prediction. Accuracy and Hit Ratio@10 were utilized as metrics to estimate
model performance. The performance of the NCF model making use of the reduced
"top 50" ICD-9 code dataset was found to be lower (accuracy of ~80% and hit
ratio@10 of 35%) as compared to the performance of the NCF model trained on all
ICD-9 codes (accuracy of ~90% and hit ratio@10 of ~80%). Reasons for the
superior performance of the sparser dataset with all ICD codes can be mainly
attributed to the higher volume of data and the robustness of deep-learning
based recommender systems with modeling sparse data. Additionally, results from
the DHF models reflect better performance than the NCF models, with a better
accuracy of 94.4% and hit ratio@10 of 85.36%, reflecting the importance of the
incorporation of clinical note information. Additionally, compared to
literature reports utilizing primarily natural language processing-based
predictions for the task of ICD-9 code co-occurrence, the novel deep
learning-based recommender systems approach performed better. Overall, the deep
learning-based recommender systems have shown promise in predicting disease
comorbidity. | [
-0.0005696892,
0.0485332049,
-0.0068700314,
-0.0279369466,
0.0093460409,
-0.0098580848,
0.0398209803,
0.0270613898,
0.0478006415,
0.0394705571,
-0.043815963,
-0.0366089903,
-0.0228985734,
0.0612414666,
-0.0442737192,
-0.0024475509,
0.0162054673,
0.0274682511,
0.008326333,
0.0047333203,
-0.0146530364,
0.0099842902,
0.0021031108,
0.059931092,
-0.0336957201,
-0.0125889014,
0.0327270217,
-0.0376158692,
0.0015543869,
-0.0429955237,
0.0284758322,
-0.0109470841,
0.006695048,
-0.0293977428,
0.0000022422,
-0.0260097049,
-0.0082156388,
-0.0266803447,
0.0064407452,
-0.0490042157,
0.0284164902,
0.0242542811,
0.0368603431,
-0.0084566902,
-0.0252124444,
0.0004734637,
0.0265130457,
0.0790595263,
0.0082563329,
0.0026734732,
-0.0253574774,
0.023308279,
0.0340554006,
-0.0025851345,
0.0197773632,
-0.0203166138,
0.0555488691,
-0.0010656912,
0.0270168949,
-0.0496361144,
-0.0043867924,
0.0053059198,
0.019573262,
0.0325689353,
0.0559532158,
0.029688077,
0.0231050253,
-0.0258707833,
-0.0172640961,
0.0735413879,
-0.0265917871,
0.0134520428,
-0.0294373613,
-0.0055686813,
-0.010581255,
-0.0112198256,
-0.0088266451,
-0.0744911879,
-0.0284724217,
0.046711769,
-0.0129989507,
0.0281171966,
0.0687926412,
-0.012910964,
-0.0113470247,
0.0535888486,
-0.0133312438,
0.0067136604,
0.0217812061,
-0.0281985812,
0.015834542,
-0.0456820466,
0.0457296595,
0.0057144486,
-0.0437795445,
-0.0288315173,
-0.018644508,
0.0204736199,
0.0376454107,
-0.0378447212,
0.0292579737,
0.0144645162,
-0.0222893767,
0.0324491784,
-0.0015656867,
-0.0402240828,
-0.0223305039,
0.0111026866,
-0.0062687881,
0.0040458264,
-0.0499740988,
0.0127994968,
0.0227825623,
0.0726138577,
0.0180970859,
-0.0460138544,
-0.0623311922,
0.0009754837,
-0.0112649594,
-0.0051148585,
0.0060419375,
0.1194361597,
0.0294184051,
0.0351937637,
-0.0700678378,
0.0206251852,
-0.021990167,
0.0083195996,
0.0069233933,
0.007158896,
0.0989297107,
-0.0167245585,
0.0360408537,
-0.0482040532,
0.0530816168,
0.0222229101,
0.0200895574,
-0.0485832505,
0.0204920843,
-0.0252730474,
-0.0185498409,
0.0116520738,
-0.0253656097,
-0.057278391,
0.0259388499,
0.0129248938,
0.0192019846,
-0.0656975657,
0.0115350718,
-0.0236409474,
-0.0166750308,
0.0669258833,
-0.0251667257,
-0.0419516563,
0.0167326275,
-0.0025453281,
0.0001584187,
-0.0357902534,
0.0144621702,
0.0036271096,
0.0142022939,
-0.024249047,
-0.0110684242,
-0.0177880004,
-0.0114844386,
-0.0266608875,
-0.0029968864,
-0.0077606011,
-0.0574063174,
0.0495035648,
-0.002689553,
0.0437884592,
-0.0102470694,
-0.0577574782,
0.0262632445,
0.0075869337,
0.0891999453,
0.0616246238,
0.0119413445,
0.0021512546,
-0.0387297235,
-0.0288133547,
0.025948476,
0.050246086,
0.0148079628,
-0.0522373877,
0.0152208181,
0.0067937472,
-0.0241181441,
-0.0570825301,
0.0374725387,
-0.045082435,
0.0299802069,
-0.0025749817,
0.0151419602,
-0.0597741716,
-0.014707868,
-0.023601016,
0.0435239859,
0.0150353266,
-0.0173139479,
-0.0220816378,
0.0299873184,
0.0978531018,
0.0193184521,
-0.0076105427,
-0.0171000939,
-0.0118704848,
-0.0156433135,
-0.1097551733,
0.0129053146,
0.0047754049,
0.0244563296,
-0.0408873335,
-0.0267111566,
0.0272064842,
-0.0019536191,
-0.0061461856,
-0.0663030967,
0.0393157154,
-0.0391878784,
0.0338694341,
0.0178871211,
-0.0090645067,
-0.0110865058,
-0.0088506695,
0.041989807,
0.0265192036,
0.0640453845,
0.0263218246,
0.0188663937,
0.0201156195,
0.0050895591,
-0.0311369058,
-0.0752292871,
-0.0420670174,
-0.0617712773,
0.0021713772,
0.0085545685,
-0.0432465672,
0.0492398106,
0.0279958807,
0.0349105597,
-0.0286572985,
0.0105250627,
-0.0192966014,
-0.0060407398,
0.010840551,
-0.0305258688,
0.0370195694,
0.0164808165,
-0.0126613053,
0.0173236355,
-0.0170567017,
-0.0041731512,
0.0249928925,
-0.0195345823,
0.04758396,
-0.0095216949,
-0.0347523205,
-0.0110617653,
-0.0256940108,
-0.0221026056,
0.0050789462,
-0.0039765351,
0.0054799602,
0.00493296,
-0.0853324756,
0.0230653249,
0.0031097359,
-0.0424944796,
-0.042994868,
0.0323640071,
0.0207639206,
-0.03119177,
-0.0361883901,
0.0354820564,
0.0013362016,
0.0077042906,
0.0277079754,
0.0761692375,
-0.0111249443,
-0.0241618585,
-0.023521373,
-0.0534605123,
0.0248267576,
0.0150325429,
-0.0163631644,
0.0473507382,
-0.030023979,
-0.053790383,
0.0264688469,
0.0122200623,
0.0123737874,
0.000267652,
-0.0140528632,
-0.0379761718,
0.0019727715,
-0.0272564366,
0.0418529138,
0.0449188463,
0.0246564616,
-0.0617527552,
0.024561977,
-0.045234926,
0.010453403,
-0.0167481843,
-0.006097028,
-0.0279307216,
0.0208834782,
0.0280829053,
0.0005224561,
-0.0573366322,
0.0243341792,
0.0476183407,
-0.0002782737,
-0.055412259,
-0.0203972794,
-0.0179344788,
0.0470335372,
0.0087267859,
-0.033386983,
0.0783137977,
0.0276528727,
0.0187593643,
-0.0445129089,
-0.0834708214,
-0.0414396599,
-0.0537571087,
0.0209335629,
0.0063821366,
-0.0100071402,
0.0061765965,
-0.000030531,
0.0187057499,
-0.0270050187,
-0.0340729468,
0.0247534364,
0.0139747085,
-0.0188501086,
0.0245903451,
-0.0386694446,
-0.0372418575,
-0.013662748,
-0.0209876616,
0.0249463394,
0.0025795316,
0.0015510584,
-0.0088509358,
-0.0079597905,
-0.0393682271,
0.0597856194,
0.0367814675,
-0.0225651078,
0.0167101659,
0.0069684093,
0.0473547317,
-0.0365458988,
-0.0205012485,
0.029497996,
0.0253429934,
-0.0031110863,
-0.0046100933,
-0.002114106,
-0.0810331479,
0.0313859172,
0.0066442275,
0.031534791,
-0.0068265223,
0.0572641455,
-0.0337905549,
-0.0028491514,
0.0391743183,
0.0540679209,
0.0251361802,
-0.1153322607,
0.0289077405,
-0.0179101061,
-0.038766887,
0.0051764199,
-0.0288610049,
-0.0592340343,
-0.0467749089,
-0.0129140653,
-0.0262354892,
0.0005507874,
-0.0579950884,
0.026371818,
-0.0043365597,
0.0170100089,
-0.0264757555,
-0.0011022282,
-0.0309323836,
-0.0479023345,
-0.0045733941,
-0.0144191356,
-0.0290536378,
-0.0678657815,
0.0234306958,
-0.0179455243,
0.003940464,
-0.0606464818,
-0.0536472723,
0.0543851182,
-0.0280929934,
0.0120014874,
0.0719952658,
0.0284014475,
-0.0046809763,
-0.0145089114,
-0.0152165871,
0.012685705,
0.0302147996,
-0.0155546218,
0.0580412745,
-0.0231561456,
0.0062537547,
-0.0578995384,
0.0270081162,
-0.0424655229,
0.0138106076,
-0.0185800791,
0.1032343954,
-0.059234459,
-0.0351556055,
-0.064286083,
0.0143672647,
0.0315348394,
0.0148898847,
-0.0126888864,
-0.0428189375,
0.0163661446,
0.0305295587,
0.0455195531,
0.0055626226,
-0.0003802268,
0.0109885512,
-0.008339338,
-0.0077049271,
-0.0336345583,
-0.0266410392,
0.0306752063,
-0.0229894277,
0.0128230276,
0.0591027699,
0.0326038077,
-0.045488365,
-0.0128453076,
0.0591569953,
0.0602872409,
0.0302844476,
-0.04354522,
0.0124339573,
0.0334390439,
-0.0306053236,
0.015393177,
-0.0228554159,
-0.00882883,
0.0356866904,
-0.0554568358,
0.0672001392,
0.0104575986,
0.0514336936,
-0.0095792823,
-0.0825067982,
0.0068743816,
0.0330136195,
0.0108674029,
-0.0686510801,
-0.0028006267,
-0.037770696,
-0.0107348021,
0.0226712432,
-0.0411665775,
0.00254416,
-0.0405459441,
-0.0420326516,
-0.0029550041,
-0.0213501435,
0.0304101873,
-0.0160973798,
0.034236189,
-0.000163635,
0.0092420876,
0.0056371083,
0.0287789963,
0.0322212502,
0.0068173357,
-0.0451616123,
-0.0110558458,
0.0278906059,
-0.0186332092,
-0.0349295102,
-0.0398301631,
0.0127063468,
-0.0121391099,
-0.0368112028,
0.0943116322,
0.003878535,
0.0128091807,
0.0380787253,
0.0179875195,
0.0186256114,
-0.0001835876,
0.0396656618,
-0.0054297629,
-0.0102229528,
0.0456261635,
-0.0114666745,
0.0245836154,
-0.0092604887,
0.0329299197,
-0.0015227103,
-0.0343715362,
-0.009109878,
-0.0206989758,
0.0424234718,
-0.0222753659,
-0.0201224349,
-0.0297667868,
0.0144797964,
-0.0590226986,
0.0123526705,
-0.0460287482,
-0.015951883,
0.0617874563,
0.0122948596,
0.0050335918,
0.0080893217,
0.0765969157,
-0.0143416654,
-0.0163277481,
-0.0009321312,
-0.054370448,
-0.0365177356,
0.0228482168,
0.0663827136,
0.0952127352,
-0.0777703524,
0.0036786695,
0.0183566995,
-0.0332231969,
0.0588449091,
-0.0713297576,
-0.0116080819,
-0.0401134193,
0.0451508947,
0.0327356942,
-0.0031214142,
0.0026171594,
-0.0100530824,
0.013896903,
-0.0214280002,
-0.0262736473,
-0.0441151187,
-5.846939758e-33,
0.0483877026,
0.0020890858,
0.0333447494,
0.0143640507,
0.0262928605,
-0.0059073884,
-0.0034709959,
-0.0186679903,
0.0218723696,
0.0215837099,
-0.0042407741,
-0.0200647432,
-0.0044989143,
0.025434576,
0.0157352835,
-0.0450630635,
0.0483943745,
0.02941522,
0.0144985272,
0.0190327689,
0.0041781981,
0.1045467183,
0.0028859624,
-0.1041385829,
-0.0121416729,
0.0408579148,
0.0396408513,
-0.03252941,
-0.0085211638,
0.0591859221,
-0.0439188331,
0.0621744134,
0.0398683585,
0.0059116571,
0.0126358541,
0.0164584033,
-0.0744953975,
-0.0312832147,
-0.0332991295,
-0.0278342571,
-0.0207263995,
-0.0193810612,
0.0624310747,
0.0138738668,
-0.0052755643,
0.0104387561,
0.0503733866,
-0.0268284064,
-0.0269023124,
-0.030425597,
0.0399600863,
0.0252726357,
0.0099772029,
-0.0037228963,
-0.030347459,
0.0659644008,
-0.0332734585,
0.0676771179,
-0.0529882312,
-0.0038702916,
-0.0308846086,
0.0138923349,
-0.0243343282,
-0.0641925409,
-0.042436935,
0.0766894817,
0.030873375,
-0.0564674996,
-0.0262759738,
0.0177187137,
-0.0447896123,
0.0789564326,
0.0207115393,
0.0489952452,
0.0471265726,
-0.0245287921,
-0.0792330801,
0.0504032597,
-0.038662158,
0.0065441523,
0.0415846892,
0.0069453972,
-0.0315340757,
0.0019522769,
-0.0050927075,
0.0168641508,
-0.0449268222,
-0.0626701117,
0.0240615997,
0.0252466723,
0.0033179664,
0.0362892784,
0.0134049281,
-0.0602702014,
-0.0272248704,
-0.000322116,
0.0273099318,
0.0065364204,
0.021968307,
0.0145313945,
-0.0259474218,
0.0223882105,
-0.0049673654,
-0.0784305409,
0.0326063931,
0.0310658142,
0.0523329787,
-0.011713976,
-0.0010132887,
-0.0328868739,
0.0398675427,
-0.0620536096,
0.0071519022,
0.0683080107,
-0.005393032,
0.0502282158,
-0.0340712368,
0.0880850777,
0.0047381916,
0.0498956703,
-0.0429596677,
-0.1245499775,
0.0092415772,
-0.0370896235,
-0.0332322344,
-0.0600857809,
-0.0837911814,
-0.0014948588,
0.0485140607,
-0.0697347224,
-0.0132467281,
-0.0198256634,
3.029e-7,
0.042381376,
0.0160449762,
-0.0153675824,
-0.0678852946,
0.0203307755,
0.0307749305,
0.0115401223,
0.0290723667,
0.009302333,
0.0341130458,
0.0631738082,
-0.0180753339,
-0.023041036,
0.0370446816,
-0.0128813544,
-0.016412368,
-0.0547911897,
-0.0057445173,
-0.0497030504,
-0.0261557736,
0.0113626262,
0.1062793434,
0.0004465584,
-0.0548319444,
0.0894726589,
0.0167444777,
0.0276371408,
-0.0529022254,
-0.0053293812,
-0.0376706049,
0.034567941,
-0.0012635234,
0.0082718031,
0.0597202256,
-0.0320807919,
-0.0010428551,
-0.0156177701,
0.011948755,
-0.052111201,
-0.0302991234,
0.0166973006,
0.0224826969,
0.0078321118,
-0.0044163149,
0.0992653072,
-0.0223837811,
-0.0374931395,
0.0035911824,
-0.020044731,
-0.0020367985,
0.0795985684,
-0.0065551433,
-0.0227943733,
-0.0101805013,
0.0272254627,
0.0182527751,
-0.0044942428,
-0.064728424,
0.02279911,
0.0170921534,
-0.0318593048,
0.007064898,
-0.0345580913,
-0.0050827847,
0.0418522619,
-0.0393076576,
0.0055139735,
2.282057437e-34,
-0.0024313622,
0.0483245701,
0.0255916212,
-0.0454606488,
-0.0068251048,
-0.02422552,
-0.0341043845,
0.0101927258,
0.0296518244,
-0.0372488648,
-0.0508937687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.00642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.00642v1 | Extracting Mathematical Concepts with Large Language Models | 2023-08-29T20:54:50 | 2023-08-29T20:54:50 | Valeria de Paiva, Qiyue Gao, Pavel Kovalev, Lawrence S. Moss | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | We extract mathematical concepts from mathematical text using generative
large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT, contributing to the field of
automatic term extraction (ATE) and mathematical text processing, and also to
the study of LLMs themselves. Our work builds on that of others in that we aim
for automatic extraction of terms (keywords) in one mathematical field,
category theory, using as a corpus the 755 abstracts from a snapshot of the
online journal "Theory and Applications of Categories", circa 2020. Where our
study diverges from previous work is in (1) providing a more thorough analysis
of what makes mathematical term extraction a difficult problem to begin with;
(2) paying close attention to inter-annotator disagreements; (3) providing a
set of guidelines which both human and machine annotators could use to
standardize the extraction process; (4) introducing a new annotation tool to
help humans with ATE, applicable to any mathematical field and even beyond
mathematics; (5) using prompts to ChatGPT as part of the extraction process,
and proposing best practices for such prompts; and (6) raising the question of
whether ChatGPT could be used as an annotator on the same level as human
experts. Our overall findings are that the matter of mathematical ATE is an
interesting field which can benefit from participation by LLMs, but LLMs
themselves cannot at this time surpass human performance on it. | [
-0.0078714173,
0.090716593,
-0.0091823786,
0.0639891252,
-0.043029055,
0.0436410718,
-0.0062281876,
-0.0005181794,
-0.0556158125,
-0.0399846211,
-0.0265083313,
-0.0341537595,
-0.0287238341,
0.0103744371,
0.0214671232,
-0.0784259737,
-0.0016072514,
-0.0689586774,
0.0273205768,
-0.002123503,
-0.012224854,
-0.0325477533,
0.0030118213,
0.0066713621,
-0.0253627636,
-0.064206779,
0.0090032136,
-0.1047936752,
0.0085268393,
0.0016501414,
-0.0183879696,
0.038501773,
-0.0178969782,
0.0381514393,
0.0000017752,
-0.0675581843,
-0.036191877,
0.023798421,
-0.010752379,
0.0142692532,
-0.0103855832,
-0.0229460914,
-0.0018843819,
-0.0432983898,
-0.0480753705,
-0.0088232756,
0.0294818822,
0.0076683117,
0.0352686942,
0.0343117453,
-0.0135086495,
-0.1058648303,
0.0448490418,
-0.0187776163,
0.0652845502,
-0.0569683351,
0.0425103456,
0.032894101,
0.0257625785,
0.0502382554,
-0.0187184289,
0.0375506915,
0.037425641,
-0.0228758305,
0.0426468253,
0.0217090901,
-0.0270458441,
-0.0027638136,
-0.011158227,
0.0387697704,
0.0174584389,
0.0133852186,
0.072758019,
0.0265175477,
-0.013923889,
0.0749754533,
-0.0923155248,
0.0713868365,
-0.0302409623,
-0.009556843,
0.0245508011,
-0.0065178946,
0.0197883472,
0.0259597283,
-0.0530060939,
0.0773660839,
0.0383465439,
-0.0535347611,
-0.0076808413,
0.0091947392,
-0.1061869785,
-0.0498759449,
0.0179399494,
0.0094419699,
0.0703327507,
0.0138543835,
-0.0037459086,
-0.0434696712,
-0.0422783121,
-0.0713412017,
0.0069244979,
-0.0028354586,
-0.0013658501,
0.0508530661,
0.0353316404,
0.0143926814,
-0.0135782063,
-0.0142348241,
-0.0024268571,
0.0374641828,
-0.0550509542,
-0.0140560176,
-0.0144301122,
0.043204084,
0.0412705205,
-0.0084629217,
-0.0483111329,
0.0058671795,
-0.0384113714,
0.0071380455,
-0.0025341264,
-0.0597184636,
-0.0240601394,
-0.0269938335,
0.0139043136,
-0.0477971509,
-0.0263268743,
-0.0116355279,
0.0092517175,
-0.0441772602,
-0.0237201173,
0.0642250404,
0.0220540464,
-0.0589683987,
-0.0081987558,
0.0522551686,
0.0517846048,
0.0137039879,
0.0576798879,
-0.0131670516,
0.0027401985,
-0.0155932447,
0.0344412588,
-0.0737695247,
0.0254506189,
0.0023898771,
-0.0158454124,
-0.0142542925,
-0.01171536,
0.005766172,
0.0065023932,
0.0305322818,
-0.0355405323,
0.0010356475,
0.0415330902,
-0.0079140002,
-0.0399730988,
-0.0185818449,
0.0110282535,
0.0217659064,
0.0539985858,
-0.0289387256,
0.0565801188,
0.0535928495,
-0.0016122374,
-0.0361269936,
0.0003902282,
0.0122113219,
0.0242862534,
0.0124182096,
0.0277977213,
0.0721733123,
-0.0549439862,
0.0175045021,
-0.008246596,
0.0995283276,
0.0276353061,
0.0737699568,
0.0160335116,
0.0091869067,
0.0660220459,
-0.0024307102,
-0.0138282916,
-0.0205248781,
-0.0304202903,
0.0237617902,
0.0059725884,
-0.0143979266,
0.030813314,
-0.0517779998,
-0.0324713774,
0.0026591618,
-0.0479281358,
-0.0203739572,
0.1090045124,
-0.0119257635,
0.0607286803,
0.0217953175,
0.0230106786,
-0.0053710854,
0.0275367126,
-0.0403819866,
0.0132817542,
-0.0553176478,
0.0354693979,
-0.0461109802,
0.0106064947,
0.0058269263,
-0.0034712818,
0.0413474031,
0.0044738087,
-0.0227890722,
-0.0642904639,
-0.0083296448,
0.010958638,
0.0206327029,
0.0313897766,
-0.0168618187,
0.0213055238,
-0.003862734,
0.0247212853,
0.0176471565,
-0.0201141462,
0.0388399065,
0.0039483076,
-0.0747293904,
-0.0046501709,
-0.0343605094,
0.0268788543,
-0.0196772665,
-0.0447844192,
0.0471423939,
0.0065680626,
-0.0517343804,
-0.011952647,
0.0026422183,
-0.0253208298,
0.0022081665,
0.0741191655,
-0.0180504918,
0.0099497242,
-0.0332767703,
-0.0257893093,
0.0108381389,
0.0626275167,
-0.0137969144,
-0.0015345847,
-0.0311924461,
0.0272894166,
0.0294693504,
-0.0257670563,
-0.0432417654,
0.1020493433,
0.0343232192,
0.0212577917,
-0.0159180146,
-0.0746864453,
-0.036071334,
0.0013725744,
0.0053999517,
0.0406762585,
0.0303459205,
0.0515394397,
0.0147191323,
0.0026960142,
0.0033634065,
-0.024858959,
-0.0094844764,
0.0336309373,
-0.0029426415,
0.0692253709,
-0.0010148515,
-0.0395472944,
-0.0197187718,
0.0219037104,
-0.0065562027,
-0.0158095434,
-0.0410086401,
-0.0036301927,
0.0431888066,
0.016809823,
-0.0156209329,
-0.0383994654,
-0.0128671285,
-0.0220039356,
0.0439955778,
0.0431883335,
-0.01997656,
-0.0007676524,
0.0341816433,
-0.0236972384,
-0.0117448503,
-0.0171722267,
0.0504353121,
-0.0060582464,
-0.0631319284,
0.0138378674,
0.0276571941,
0.0206804685,
0.05309771,
-0.026599599,
-0.0283338483,
-0.0100729968,
-0.027417684,
-0.0362166688,
-0.0125549473,
0.0039519444,
0.0248358399,
0.0501223132,
0.1024664193,
-0.0199819542,
-0.0212992206,
0.0027580594,
0.0478595048,
-0.0593373142,
0.0271882489,
-0.0740866289,
0.0181634557,
-0.048865933,
0.0335285738,
0.0077484772,
-0.0411820561,
0.0068092272,
0.0062918686,
-0.0262759961,
-0.038595885,
-0.0175255369,
-0.0883306861,
0.0193733368,
-0.001648066,
-0.0200549141,
0.0137137081,
-0.0194434561,
0.0142321056,
0.0097362455,
0.0430414975,
-0.0314274766,
0.0127145154,
-0.027614221,
0.0421544015,
-0.0323779099,
-0.0061532049,
-0.0233166404,
-0.0098517006,
-0.0173616186,
-0.0023708742,
0.0284483377,
-0.0184585564,
0.0127578061,
0.0092540933,
0.0287961941,
0.0151397437,
-0.0418325476,
-0.005779624,
-0.0053541646,
0.0371899754,
0.0738752931,
-0.0154572288,
0.0019255643,
-0.0618541054,
-0.0148207163,
0.0403228104,
-0.0198588278,
0.0071677999,
-0.0134623582,
-0.0091325184,
0.0062877364,
-0.0709439591,
-0.0438997112,
-0.0002147705,
-0.0386397876,
-0.0473071598,
0.0024058279,
0.0891874284,
0.0257604383,
-0.0174350124,
0.0021571815,
-0.0464313291,
-0.0047346982,
-0.0339549258,
-0.0128585948,
-0.0943263695,
0.0200187955,
0.0085713044,
-0.0047416808,
0.0304970648,
-0.0357884802,
0.0199285727,
-0.07298287,
0.0370275639,
0.0144106802,
-0.0297595467,
0.0153119089,
0.0052845269,
0.0140874181,
-0.0139620611,
-0.046799235,
0.0171358902,
-0.0353078805,
0.0640344918,
0.0393533111,
-0.0209450889,
-0.0353969,
-0.0125338566,
-0.04691929,
-0.0344100073,
-0.0022792909,
0.027454786,
-0.0511804521,
-0.0480754375,
0.0553646572,
0.0215242617,
-0.0486700274,
0.006998939,
-0.0362161547,
-0.0283044018,
-0.0099358764,
-0.0224571377,
0.0663966313,
-0.0382081904,
-0.0322598666,
0.0605371334,
0.0853614509,
0.0094248299,
-0.0247621909,
-0.0137082813,
-0.0146060139,
-0.0503562391,
0.0585873723,
0.0285133533,
-0.0210162606,
-0.0225503575,
-0.0341238789,
-0.0127754947,
0.024504032,
-0.0784661695,
-0.0495161563,
0.0260998625,
-0.061832834,
-0.0415109508,
-0.0051870216,
0.0107337441,
0.0219566375,
0.0145354094,
-0.0151854726,
0.0247665867,
0.0140324933,
0.0061041089,
0.0554676689,
-0.0582856089,
-0.0338072181,
-0.041038245,
0.0112670027,
0.0207500551,
0.0019932589,
-0.0797672868,
0.0088597871,
-0.031158153,
-0.0325870141,
0.0135442857,
0.0254422668,
0.0192555375,
-0.0297505241,
0.0005198519,
-0.013358444,
0.0174474847,
0.0787816197,
-0.0198916048,
0.0117182871,
0.014633406,
0.0375882387,
0.0087315449,
0.020256361,
0.0056530326,
0.0407602973,
-0.0130746523,
0.0135154687,
-0.0428399816,
-0.0224263556,
0.0145118386,
0.0461180136,
0.015642399,
0.0066445181,
-0.0157810207,
-0.0017486258,
-0.0557171889,
-0.0244249403,
-0.0272296816,
-0.0485565662,
0.0134593183,
0.0084473351,
0.0104457997,
-0.0248452518,
-0.0017961446,
0.0414223149,
0.0331758708,
-0.0071926825,
0.0361091085,
-0.0104952455,
0.0186725464,
0.0249151178,
-0.0068090674,
0.0275549907,
-0.0221029129,
-0.0434341729,
0.0410415269,
-0.0021417225,
0.0091663413,
0.0263275914,
-0.0069354684,
0.0186250638,
-0.005932644,
-0.0385041833,
-0.0677332282,
-0.0138977095,
0.076804243,
0.0436734892,
0.018596733,
0.0109428652,
-0.0416988395,
-0.0253280625,
-0.0318636857,
0.0401602611,
0.0235334486,
-0.0006180722,
0.0171407126,
0.0310932323,
-0.0336660184,
-0.0928852856,
0.0422500521,
-0.0243966524,
-0.0104458192,
0.0310382787,
0.0244362913,
-0.0429823697,
0.011439424,
-0.0233947523,
-0.0441937037,
0.0132234711,
0.0123858089,
-0.0786459744,
-0.0290339272,
0.0275794342,
0.0200553518,
-0.0273915883,
0.0106993373,
0.0442290306,
0.083800599,
-0.054154925,
-0.0168280583,
-0.0452000983,
0.0769498125,
-0.0429633409,
-0.0392929725,
-0.0174666457,
-5.277471887e-33,
-0.0390617102,
-0.0057090744,
0.014276986,
0.0697002336,
-0.0080299024,
-0.0101261977,
-0.0123573793,
0.0200165063,
0.0374540202,
0.0122459745,
0.0007097254,
-0.000817485,
-0.006362997,
0.0021873666,
0.0368011668,
-0.0084300898,
0.0035840948,
-0.0247327164,
0.0038356851,
-0.0178335682,
0.0022477128,
0.0020901768,
0.0600295886,
-0.0534884669,
0.0472980291,
-0.012062924,
0.017490536,
-0.0138943642,
0.0444571115,
0.0539288558,
-0.0610832348,
0.0013252067,
-0.0054683643,
-0.0210256297,
-0.0082315309,
0.0178220235,
-0.0181940272,
-0.0218309592,
0.0130744996,
0.0017087543,
-0.0130795874,
-0.0823946074,
0.0351594426,
0.0102979662,
-0.0560608096,
0.0051423186,
0.0530103855,
-0.0235074107,
-0.0422308967,
-0.0277867131,
-0.0542534292,
0.0684264898,
0.0204597805,
0.0107740657,
0.0689389184,
-0.0186739005,
-0.0188519154,
0.0368792936,
0.0218595564,
0.0166169666,
0.0338918529,
0.0358501039,
0.0157427806,
-0.0049891104,
0.0556951724,
0.0513888597,
-0.0058310195,
-0.0417822301,
-0.0014565148,
0.0116469301,
0.0232957527,
0.0720583573,
0.0068360874,
0.0097831301,
0.1007176936,
0.0535725802,
-0.0139255133,
0.0091749178,
-0.012448851,
0.0183187965,
0.0086529208,
0.0142793292,
-0.0501373075,
0.0034068436,
-0.014491939,
0.0032346616,
-0.0097224079,
-0.0178533457,
-0.008844302,
-0.0221058298,
-0.0381359644,
0.0671639442,
0.0110705141,
-0.0370320641,
-0.0498703495,
-0.0346344337,
-0.0175304227,
0.0388105251,
-0.0196609087,
0.0004481485,
-0.0812700465,
-0.0349921621,
-0.0339511223,
0.0196126066,
0.0348998494,
0.0244314577,
-0.0067150975,
-0.0090355035,
-0.0109428028,
-0.0401092954,
-0.0309703425,
-0.0282265991,
0.0190102998,
0.071375303,
0.0330401808,
0.0662948415,
0.0244718865,
0.0311027728,
0.0274107791,
0.0185782239,
-0.0211752933,
0.0455219597,
-0.0039493078,
0.0006989345,
0.0103455829,
-0.0036027418,
0.0008386901,
-0.0168474764,
0.0519524589,
-0.0532474369,
0.0212119184,
-0.0251360163,
2.533e-7,
0.044678662,
0.0498986095,
0.0262335408,
0.009251629,
0.0222733244,
0.0052217571,
-0.0027738742,
-0.0117848935,
0.011969272,
-0.0074630291,
-0.0022347285,
0.0560528338,
0.0319347307,
0.0424370393,
-0.0741247162,
-0.0146475825,
-0.0627893731,
-0.0304241888,
-0.042838905,
-0.005607673,
0.0634438321,
0.0610505491,
0.0214508604,
0.0283755958,
-0.0187276006,
-0.0590713546,
0.0653730556,
0.006067269,
-0.027111223,
0.0668931678,
-0.0012520931,
0.0052090283,
0.0193572436,
-0.0324872844,
0.0326196253,
0.0457608066,
0.0740197301,
0.0576308183,
0.0151157426,
0.0661488026,
-0.0296674781,
-0.0161406342,
0.0140523408,
-0.0192649402,
0.0514532626,
-0.0614963174,
-0.0374066234,
-0.0874733552,
-0.0216025747,
-0.0139196366,
0.0111194523,
-0.0030240007,
0.0151623189,
0.0137500139,
0.0347483158,
-0.0120688034,
-0.0328867212,
-0.0345583148,
0.0226385985,
0.0235983599,
-0.0677453205,
-0.0482326522,
-0.0333106965,
0.0142658902,
-0.0201528352,
-0.0130678965,
-0.0161743946,
2.181078799e-34,
0.0500514135,
0.0055733575,
0.0053093331,
0.0705743134,
0.0216021091,
0.0067463201,
-0.035461802,
0.0341386236,
-0.0166740585,
-0.0752266571,
0.0106039457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.06419v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.06419v1 | Radiology-Llama2: Best-in-Class Large Language Model for Radiology | 2023-08-29T17:44:28 | 2023-08-29T17:44:28 | Zhengliang Liu, Yiwei Li, Peng Shu, Aoxiao Zhong, Longtao Yang, Chao Ju, Zihao Wu, Chong Ma, Jie Luo, Cheng Chen, Sekeun Kim, Jiang Hu, Haixing Dai, Lin Zhao, Dajiang Zhu, Jun Liu, Wei Liu, Dinggang Shen, Tianming Liu, Quanzheng Li, Xiang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces Radiology-Llama2, a large language model specialized
for radiology through a process known as instruction tuning. Radiology-Llama2
is based on the Llama2 architecture and further trained on a large dataset of
radiology reports to generate coherent and clinically useful impressions from
radiological findings. Quantitative evaluations using ROUGE metrics on the
MIMIC-CXR and OpenI datasets demonstrate that Radiology-Llama2 achieves
state-of-the-art performance compared to other generative language models, with
a Rouge-1 score of 0.4834 on MIMIC-CXR and 0.4185 on OpenI. Additional
assessments by radiology experts highlight the model's strengths in
understandability, coherence, relevance, conciseness, and clinical utility. The
work illustrates the potential of localized language models designed and tuned
for specialized domains like radiology. When properly evaluated and deployed,
such models can transform fields like radiology by automating rote tasks and
enhancing human expertise. | [
0.0508513711,
0.0874566063,
0.0110417139,
-0.0271947626,
0.0105081629,
0.033537928,
-0.0072627789,
0.0305561349,
-0.0311355926,
-0.0053317924,
-0.0445389822,
-0.045372583,
0.0055126045,
0.0218435116,
0.024453558,
-0.1066652238,
0.0227095708,
-0.0114739304,
0.0141005302,
-0.0067664445,
0.0038491592,
0.0245243721,
-0.0249016639,
0.0182764232,
0.0148052061,
-0.0150924856,
0.0370914824,
0.0080681965,
0.0240652841,
-0.0492881164,
-0.041168306,
0.0422194712,
0.0163240489,
0.0147655606,
0.0000021247,
-0.0446234494,
-0.0031910583,
0.0208428167,
-0.0103566526,
0.0097318264,
0.1075409055,
-0.0502786301,
-0.0341814607,
0.0127033256,
-0.0125047285,
-0.0711051524,
0.0314560644,
0.0223685894,
0.0599398203,
0.0786842704,
-0.0134130884,
-0.0083663352,
0.0184620675,
-0.0441780426,
0.0127674537,
-0.0348246023,
0.0145608345,
0.0671024546,
0.0456730574,
0.014057762,
-0.0123736039,
0.0354182273,
0.016491374,
-0.0051226821,
0.0058121448,
0.0753226802,
-0.0046678241,
-0.0150655229,
0.0158149265,
0.0540842526,
-0.0165003538,
-0.0053959605,
-0.0005181627,
-0.0000519781,
-0.0215776563,
-0.0198062696,
-0.0622056238,
0.0387852527,
0.0079948623,
-0.0036621853,
0.0094531281,
-0.0065108594,
0.0168908089,
0.0172422342,
-0.0143845677,
-0.010919312,
0.0230827294,
0.0040507982,
0.0104628233,
0.0260028355,
-0.0165188964,
-0.0580063462,
0.0265012011,
0.0573384315,
-0.0625223964,
0.0300960224,
-0.0329611972,
-0.0029781975,
0.0942253768,
-0.0565174669,
-0.0105462465,
0.0033854891,
-0.0448117331,
0.0638244823,
-0.0236332081,
0.0447155684,
-0.0349463895,
0.0609035753,
-0.0532543771,
0.0050010281,
-0.0428939052,
-0.0150150731,
-0.0228569862,
0.0008185927,
0.0009438811,
-0.0164227951,
-0.0875255764,
-0.0032983529,
0.0115457438,
0.0187869277,
0.0515904389,
0.0473598316,
-0.076656729,
0.0207296591,
-0.0240541007,
0.0488452837,
-0.0142237023,
0.0156314019,
-0.0004988752,
-0.0336654782,
0.0204211492,
0.0427834392,
-0.0238683429,
0.0247077048,
-0.0053933505,
0.0357582048,
-0.0085959397,
0.0154123781,
0.0275571775,
-0.0563017875,
-0.0054241386,
-0.064348124,
0.0181518514,
-0.0842239559,
0.0204501767,
0.0226303004,
0.0395933427,
-0.0291017164,
0.0128850201,
0.0114765912,
-0.0071663782,
0.0312971026,
-0.0504147522,
-0.000806079,
0.0340285189,
0.0554683805,
0.0700235069,
0.0309774801,
0.021222461,
0.0146756582,
-0.0084561352,
-0.003557161,
0.0009873034,
0.0134417173,
-0.0196992531,
-0.0357430317,
-0.0256848317,
0.0111429021,
-0.0105382148,
0.0858229622,
0.0327628404,
0.053011477,
-0.0180220883,
-0.0090465322,
0.0009764521,
0.027636826,
0.0363166966,
-0.0143403085,
0.0645099655,
-0.0203768052,
0.0024683862,
-0.0185365025,
-0.0000562466,
0.050549224,
0.0396665782,
0.0030065633,
-0.0226842463,
-0.0001253557,
-0.0459984019,
-0.0408658907,
-0.0374407955,
0.0017463408,
-0.0510777347,
0.0033246048,
0.034948729,
0.004753375,
-0.0364153869,
0.0246060602,
0.0594863519,
-0.0234740339,
0.0178042278,
-0.0758154392,
-0.008893,
0.1099145636,
0.0792266279,
-0.0239212476,
-0.0488844961,
-0.0004029594,
0.0486049987,
0.0570408627,
0.0254960582,
-0.0201112181,
-0.0045813047,
-0.0561981276,
-0.0347689651,
0.0046262811,
0.0250724386,
0.0027088732,
0.0051117335,
0.0233824141,
-0.026709307,
-0.0490039401,
-0.0535283126,
0.0367210656,
-0.0666125566,
-0.0262691323,
-0.0258266348,
-0.017821217,
0.0097529432,
0.0012826568,
-0.0201839264,
0.0188323818,
0.0227942709,
0.0009729757,
-0.0100645954,
0.0074151093,
-0.057923656,
-0.0183277987,
0.0124724517,
-0.0675932392,
0.0020324497,
-0.0074664447,
-0.0598046184,
-0.0147743877,
-0.0261267778,
-0.0604736209,
0.0111998981,
-0.009359628,
0.0272666793,
0.0438484959,
0.009059499,
-0.0355471298,
0.0334297828,
-0.0319388211,
0.0085673733,
0.0482844934,
0.0015216146,
0.0115856035,
-0.049410928,
-0.030269498,
0.0094285738,
0.0218883082,
0.0148966936,
-0.033531744,
0.0465727895,
-0.027641248,
-0.0416006669,
-0.0544780605,
-0.0014891595,
0.0078217797,
-0.0083113639,
0.0671424493,
-0.0026552291,
0.0002029739,
-0.0218600705,
-0.0410252027,
-0.0330363028,
0.0528515838,
0.010424275,
0.0474548861,
0.0292317104,
-0.0128060384,
-0.0562931336,
-0.0259121396,
-0.0146837831,
-0.0144359162,
0.054485146,
-0.0024096044,
-0.0454790816,
0.0443598814,
-0.0342963412,
-0.01319867,
0.0032652207,
-0.0679838434,
0.0272421502,
-0.0388321914,
-0.0132023683,
0.0588574223,
-0.01487925,
0.0432887897,
0.0552182198,
-0.0042808191,
-0.0165804122,
-0.0107358219,
-0.0340887681,
-0.0498630628,
0.0176622402,
-0.0790401921,
-0.0233778413,
0.0686303303,
-0.0016277181,
0.0161490012,
-0.0206049029,
-0.0259302706,
-0.0443691276,
-0.0107570067,
-0.0036559664,
0.0000455222,
0.0061796103,
0.0333161391,
-0.01146066,
-0.0397366174,
0.0883121565,
-0.0099567976,
0.0322283879,
-0.08222498,
-0.0099757724,
-0.0409993231,
0.0108170649,
-0.0117915645,
0.0198782347,
0.0174694993,
-0.0295001306,
-0.0188482422,
0.023407843,
0.0012532691,
-0.0618829764,
0.0169930495,
-0.0282419305,
-0.0169579592,
-0.0064509124,
-0.0113072302,
-0.0352369323,
0.0108283693,
0.0060094032,
0.0197209176,
0.0126695717,
-0.0063482095,
-0.0881899595,
0.0241556913,
0.0087789232,
0.0384400673,
-0.0031586199,
-0.022515038,
-0.0020262678,
0.0276349131,
0.0424647741,
0.0136972405,
-0.0235804208,
-0.0391514227,
0.0051306705,
0.0636707023,
-0.0157011077,
0.0266010538,
-0.0282257609,
-0.0051876022,
0.0091330986,
-0.0159462485,
-0.0073155169,
0.0124750072,
0.0411747657,
-0.0468557961,
-0.0356017426,
0.0957292914,
0.0259631872,
-0.0424906164,
-0.0110410471,
-0.0084257275,
0.0027552636,
0.0101402393,
0.0216699094,
-0.0302057825,
-0.0020601819,
-0.0149707664,
0.0421635322,
0.0102695385,
0.0027028921,
0.0233760308,
-0.0397204459,
0.0542966686,
-0.0143449949,
-0.0589664169,
-0.033779908,
-0.0534617379,
-0.0101503385,
-0.003298698,
-0.0205121841,
-0.0046336362,
-0.0333048254,
0.008228668,
0.0285455808,
-0.0446071289,
-0.0977903977,
0.0316972099,
-0.0230936427,
0.0394499749,
0.0768063739,
0.0313386954,
-0.0148664359,
-0.0494798124,
-0.0364386328,
0.0330914147,
0.0250044614,
0.000071363,
0.0864980072,
0.0273664687,
-0.0069062379,
-0.0702974275,
0.0180050638,
-0.0156947132,
0.0228022896,
-0.0254161991,
0.0597486384,
-0.0119883241,
-0.0114864437,
-0.0548793375,
0.0470843874,
0.0171979386,
0.0319832489,
0.0085079093,
0.0166048463,
-0.0195754208,
-0.0135273291,
0.0695911497,
-0.0562279522,
-0.0517549738,
0.0399293341,
-0.0574473552,
-0.0838451833,
-0.0539632663,
-0.0278325379,
0.0446029417,
0.0035546829,
0.0064396993,
0.0099936426,
-0.0074403309,
-0.0380984321,
-0.0485760048,
0.0441008508,
0.0059513235,
0.0133142127,
-0.0662894174,
-0.0678133443,
0.0763326585,
0.0065608383,
-0.0183007512,
0.0343322866,
-0.0607497431,
0.0116033545,
0.0070846393,
0.0798715651,
0.025670018,
-0.0108755725,
-0.0082406951,
-0.035332866,
0.0527400114,
0.0545457453,
-0.04654238,
0.0114743169,
-0.0172751956,
-0.0346137695,
0.0006791429,
0.0087527856,
-0.0318643935,
0.0366286859,
0.024843799,
0.0299656261,
-0.0440569781,
-0.018683916,
0.0167152472,
0.0287067071,
0.0177030675,
-0.0403806679,
-0.0189878754,
-0.0343473814,
0.0110706985,
-0.0383994579,
0.0285013393,
-0.0246233568,
0.0252399668,
0.0580824129,
-0.0023982502,
-0.0058131572,
0.0206262358,
-0.0499717966,
-0.012872206,
-0.0448210649,
0.0744599625,
0.0451194905,
0.0052579828,
0.0569209754,
0.0001837297,
-0.0359676555,
-0.0373254716,
-0.0034352702,
0.0219615884,
-0.0055139055,
0.0635557175,
0.0108778896,
0.047288917,
0.0009218386,
0.0426773988,
0.0055528632,
-0.0370223336,
-0.032021407,
0.0297258198,
0.0471441336,
0.0287703145,
0.0332390405,
-0.0281175729,
0.0114093022,
-0.0145579567,
0.0579540357,
-0.0125049688,
-0.032499779,
0.0507850796,
0.007556702,
0.042429328,
-0.0240723994,
0.101056233,
-0.0058180345,
0.0458080843,
-0.0182725452,
-0.0350232236,
-0.0560668111,
-0.0230252277,
0.0111397337,
-0.0122778565,
-0.0499107055,
0.0140629951,
-0.0396255851,
-0.0598906167,
-0.0280484855,
0.0091626439,
-0.0300500859,
-0.0433954373,
0.0564871058,
0.0435423851,
0.0041023558,
-0.0138105536,
-0.0240586102,
0.048378583,
-0.0147104058,
-0.0205489695,
0.0230778027,
-6.265829374e-33,
-0.0189027451,
-0.0322710536,
0.0524600707,
-0.0364666954,
-0.0039266129,
0.0470339283,
-0.0427375212,
-0.0049754349,
-0.0000387547,
0.0294583682,
-0.0152736027,
-0.0125217922,
0.0188277401,
0.0283741821,
0.019275656,
0.0225728042,
0.0383560397,
-0.005982894,
-0.0129087362,
0.0337170511,
-0.0138780074,
0.0148396194,
0.0542167872,
-0.0886486918,
-0.0159491133,
0.005167108,
-0.0070977686,
-0.0192258675,
-0.0134005817,
0.0692109242,
-0.0412706323,
0.032579124,
0.0225839745,
-0.0507513545,
-0.0181667879,
-0.005969692,
-0.0947978273,
-0.0390835106,
0.0359352566,
0.0060248016,
-0.0644854978,
-0.0173248239,
0.0472561792,
-0.0238444526,
0.0073870104,
-0.0171793625,
0.0473276116,
-0.0136439381,
-0.0117873438,
-0.0000508317,
-0.0731584504,
0.0501584485,
0.0128736589,
-0.0303070992,
-0.0167029705,
-0.0284244157,
-0.0326165222,
0.0340857953,
-0.0456958674,
0.0032527675,
0.0607767329,
0.058732599,
0.0465716608,
-0.0142368926,
-0.0319883637,
0.0395487994,
0.0485605188,
-0.0099402033,
-0.0233209431,
0.0381194875,
-0.0288998354,
0.0375467166,
0.0229075551,
0.0271739122,
0.035874214,
-0.0281015411,
-0.1030839235,
0.0490135364,
-0.0183182582,
0.0937751085,
0.0167468563,
-0.0068128458,
-0.0411976092,
0.005067979,
0.012258783,
-0.0205522627,
-0.0177053604,
-0.0566856936,
0.029136816,
0.0281570964,
-0.0063002352,
0.0263836533,
0.0082787098,
0.0193994045,
-0.0069569414,
-0.0235124957,
-0.0001697415,
0.0412466265,
-0.0443551913,
-0.0004811141,
-0.0580752306,
0.0017857833,
0.0407417826,
-0.0006279482,
0.0440189764,
0.0230558868,
0.038173642,
0.0208024215,
-0.0686588511,
0.0165936667,
-0.0127518103,
-0.006962325,
-0.0111115128,
0.0220018104,
0.0230900832,
0.0017659161,
-0.0232225563,
0.0391248427,
-0.02829496,
-0.0091254823,
-0.0211524703,
-0.0676777214,
0.0061591459,
0.0156043079,
-0.0730005577,
-0.0038343214,
-0.041995801,
-0.0020530524,
0.0287272204,
-0.0339759849,
-0.0219682902,
0.0240084268,
2.744e-7,
0.0865100771,
0.0479272977,
0.026261989,
0.0276711248,
0.0097735859,
-0.0376995169,
-0.0349953733,
0.0111548482,
0.0172994398,
-0.0016826385,
-0.0022120571,
0.0160287097,
-0.0088968426,
0.0419427939,
-0.0888496265,
-0.0017334385,
-0.0335971266,
0.0111169154,
-0.0122323604,
-0.0578112826,
0.0573508665,
0.0875281543,
-0.0384087563,
-0.0402144939,
0.0021501174,
0.0054542623,
0.0278229937,
-0.0196577571,
0.0219760742,
0.0535265282,
0.0289141033,
0.0448392481,
-0.0053583304,
0.025869498,
-0.0122011015,
-0.0501323976,
0.0181685947,
0.1008229628,
-0.0419108532,
-0.0013798237,
0.0492193699,
-0.0115696266,
0.0096488371,
-0.0550092608,
0.0355999693,
-0.0369469821,
-0.0290720686,
-0.0039315242,
-0.0244307686,
0.0159595367,
0.0521564074,
-0.0470585302,
-0.0424754769,
0.0238322783,
0.0188219547,
0.0104301861,
-0.0607700907,
-0.0771114156,
-0.010302362,
-0.0073833945,
-0.0202824231,
-0.0370384268,
0.0137129771,
-0.0157063995,
-0.0195458923,
-0.047196582,
0.0022423943,
2.39421016e-34,
0.0438903235,
0.0135102011,
-0.0070820823,
-0.0010169005,
0.0147654647,
-0.018015353,
-0.0131065166,
0.0221065264,
0.023405904,
-0.0492678024,
-0.0234302506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15459v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15459v3 | ParaGuide: Guided Diffusion Paraphrasers for Plug-and-Play Textual Style Transfer | 2023-08-29T17:36:02 | 2024-02-22T23:38:26 | Zachary Horvitz, Ajay Patel, Chris Callison-Burch, Zhou Yu, Kathleen McKeown | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Textual style transfer is the task of transforming stylistic properties of
text while preserving meaning. Target "styles" can be defined in numerous ways,
ranging from single attributes (e.g, formality) to authorship (e.g,
Shakespeare). Previous unsupervised style-transfer approaches generally rely on
significant amounts of labeled data for only a fixed set of styles or require
large language models. In contrast, we introduce a novel diffusion-based
framework for general-purpose style transfer that can be flexibly adapted to
arbitrary target styles at inference time. Our parameter-efficient approach,
ParaGuide, leverages paraphrase-conditioned diffusion models alongside
gradient-based guidance from both off-the-shelf classifiers and strong existing
style embedders to transform the style of text while preserving semantic
information. We validate the method on the Enron Email Corpus, with both human
and automatic evaluations, and find that it outperforms strong baselines on
formality, sentiment, and even authorship style transfer. | [
0.0334135816,
0.0744337663,
-0.0096870065,
0.022092497,
-0.0466321148,
-0.0140895871,
-0.0135591254,
0.0153700318,
-0.025283467,
-0.016422743,
-0.0327581652,
0.0063619711,
-0.0119254254,
-0.0362337641,
0.0308753569,
-0.0568793304,
-0.026975017,
-0.0237492658,
-0.0046479767,
-0.0189295001,
0.0466907695,
0.0422300138,
0.027261503,
-0.0033680927,
0.0427182652,
-0.014747845,
0.0188351627,
0.0715264454,
0.0277348645,
0.0572712533,
0.0606192835,
0.0204995926,
0.0170505568,
-0.0295513626,
0.0000017684,
0.0071141203,
-0.0216167513,
-0.0253224596,
0.0713411868,
0.0408256799,
0.1109122187,
-0.0121425893,
0.0049341954,
0.0146039221,
-0.013582862,
-0.0093474314,
0.0366433896,
0.0198304299,
0.1111823097,
0.0849707425,
-0.0430943184,
-0.1007553563,
0.0195837971,
-0.0138052749,
0.0053163469,
-0.0162229296,
0.0236040521,
-0.0124595212,
-0.0464161374,
0.0172175132,
-0.0100621162,
0.0508448668,
-0.0351990461,
-0.0244572219,
0.0567605123,
-0.0310668629,
-0.0163433254,
0.0395260975,
0.0003015556,
0.0716697499,
0.0200744811,
-0.022688739,
0.0365392119,
0.0084915143,
0.026220683,
0.0536451265,
-0.0468930081,
-0.0458150469,
-0.0010503902,
0.0043256455,
-0.0262109693,
-0.0006655758,
-0.0055456022,
0.0159755275,
0.0155963106,
-0.0003871587,
0.0355594791,
-0.0136351939,
-0.0511275344,
0.0114401439,
-0.0011507383,
-0.0065823337,
0.0542045161,
-0.0142366644,
0.0347006842,
0.0112146223,
-0.0652420595,
-0.0564685687,
-0.0018575392,
-0.0388363786,
0.078384459,
-0.0154853826,
0.06854783,
0.0189744886,
-0.0512828454,
-0.0203734227,
-0.0543100201,
0.0352990739,
-0.0437713489,
-0.0224882085,
-0.0968074128,
0.0122147938,
-0.0505629964,
-0.0206407085,
0.0270733591,
0.0044640517,
-0.0248041153,
-0.0104247378,
-0.0011589966,
-0.0166405123,
0.0212161206,
0.0141031938,
-0.0212785099,
-0.0138150118,
0.0322295688,
0.0287282038,
-0.0012174145,
0.0301302057,
0.0134463776,
0.0364442654,
-0.0380039588,
0.0271526892,
0.0679583326,
-0.0426771082,
0.0000220859,
-0.011607416,
-0.0409177989,
-0.0099954167,
-0.0380409025,
-0.0023222985,
0.0041327486,
0.0001539936,
0.00218335,
-0.0667451546,
0.0079070497,
-0.0248036869,
0.0094842101,
-0.0322156996,
-0.0117817922,
0.019729849,
-0.0689183027,
0.0472140573,
0.0445991047,
-0.0264245402,
0.0235014297,
-0.0073505691,
-0.0006457146,
0.0065904227,
0.0423831232,
0.0617625564,
0.0166782774,
-0.0239220355,
-0.0164854676,
0.0194967892,
0.0358915776,
0.0587552264,
-0.0451965369,
-0.0304572191,
0.0190495718,
0.0361930542,
0.051717747,
0.0610226542,
-0.0110062947,
-0.0185269453,
0.0916646123,
-0.015561766,
0.0456706844,
0.023103185,
0.0682810098,
0.0483827926,
-0.0002634547,
0.0002801098,
0.0141551951,
-0.0175136533,
-0.0106253354,
0.0257933624,
-0.0101747867,
0.0140804658,
-0.0201653372,
-0.0030382231,
0.0283729397,
-0.0088077039,
0.0124333119,
-0.0161058065,
0.0017117561,
0.0594355576,
-0.0610092282,
0.0162401162,
-0.0179123096,
-0.0592410192,
-0.0228398535,
-0.0264393054,
-0.0025517282,
0.1155847013,
0.0623934157,
0.011794921,
0.03054961,
-0.0190740377,
0.036686983,
-0.0029336738,
0.0032146601,
-0.0097243721,
0.0503331125,
-0.0648743063,
0.0112282252,
-0.0093054231,
0.0014004149,
-0.0060896059,
-0.0115519939,
0.0399049595,
0.0184859466,
-0.0247658249,
-0.0535411425,
0.0336434059,
-0.0094702784,
-0.0437754802,
0.0370685682,
-0.0147900721,
-0.0176191013,
-0.0081982333,
-0.0343930684,
-0.0035787511,
-0.0447451249,
-0.0545552745,
-0.0350485332,
0.0313918963,
-0.0484105609,
-0.0295138266,
-0.0270751789,
-0.0396713503,
-0.0017751635,
0.0226801615,
-0.0624245442,
-0.02934663,
0.0221546404,
-0.0295798667,
0.0470598415,
-0.0422163196,
0.0061151856,
-0.0280699003,
0.0485033207,
-0.0115277683,
0.0147136468,
0.0234552864,
-0.0555611514,
-0.0245674364,
-0.0245090313,
-0.0137698157,
0.04421122,
0.0212460905,
-0.05143236,
0.0469838195,
0.0393424965,
-0.0147699537,
-0.0050258008,
-0.0350539982,
-0.05154787,
-0.0689518005,
0.0135725215,
-0.0164401717,
0.0190289896,
0.0287523437,
0.02771434,
0.0093128858,
0.0175025593,
-0.0160251223,
0.0186992679,
-0.0725404173,
-0.0039375499,
0.0639660209,
-0.0058449293,
-0.0174145307,
-0.0610528104,
-0.0207955725,
-0.0027580059,
0.0365349725,
0.0058585135,
0.032348007,
-0.0202291086,
-0.0094995787,
0.0138866985,
-0.0315989964,
0.0135761881,
-0.0448527597,
-0.0495275259,
-0.0468841307,
0.0241353568,
0.0710607842,
0.0657508299,
-0.0199543778,
-0.0161216706,
-0.0046765376,
-0.0373672359,
-0.0137627786,
0.0167643577,
0.0052596098,
-0.0241860636,
-0.0643621907,
0.0276235826,
0.0243256632,
0.0321622901,
-0.0213260222,
-0.0510802157,
0.0159140844,
0.0548227318,
-0.0239636712,
0.0465552583,
0.0060657244,
-0.0161153581,
-0.0388584286,
-0.030608274,
-0.0043953899,
0.0644189268,
-0.0272671673,
-0.0104592964,
-0.0242584608,
-0.0289470851,
-0.0348495878,
-0.018149728,
-0.0256325062,
0.0145005342,
0.0115438905,
-0.0220827442,
-0.0174699966,
-0.0328845903,
0.1014679968,
0.0043593976,
0.0181654915,
-0.0427533723,
0.030855203,
0.0079450505,
-0.0020764526,
0.0076703927,
-0.1016416028,
0.0070199603,
-0.0249499436,
0.0030456283,
-0.0399840772,
0.0144485207,
-0.0299178809,
-0.0255483128,
0.0530393384,
-0.0159073882,
-0.0284261126,
-0.0229409654,
0.0238954648,
0.0422367305,
0.0035057003,
-0.053695336,
-0.0281126052,
0.0116288075,
0.0246587656,
0.007538463,
0.0037021933,
-0.0604960211,
-0.0191925298,
-0.004881354,
-0.0395344868,
-0.0290129296,
-0.0370362438,
0.0940543562,
-0.0313026048,
0.0024678402,
0.0942203179,
0.0072635696,
-0.0490117036,
-0.0362123474,
0.009008551,
0.0714569092,
-0.0192576703,
0.0267302338,
-0.0531065017,
-0.0528182946,
-0.0112844622,
0.0285793543,
0.0222881921,
-0.0248355437,
0.0052791242,
-0.0385782309,
0.0151716666,
0.0285134576,
0.0011166123,
0.022392612,
-0.0173520911,
-0.0082234172,
0.0136148296,
-0.0160309877,
-0.0441979766,
-0.033415921,
-0.0009198905,
-0.0202418417,
-0.0150535703,
-0.0355684049,
-0.0091788108,
-0.0426398851,
0.0050213104,
0.0446598157,
0.0656293556,
-0.0001341676,
-0.0562976822,
0.0206748005,
-0.0396542512,
-0.0130006839,
0.0175987724,
0.0876228064,
-0.0074743466,
0.0098033492,
-0.0003213021,
0.0272852033,
-0.0405226089,
0.0240170602,
0.0509269647,
0.0117804147,
0.0179682449,
-0.0564233772,
-0.0121185435,
-0.0118392827,
0.0201119203,
0.043411687,
0.0284192376,
-0.0616680756,
-0.065932326,
-0.0341313891,
0.0267291423,
-0.0416325331,
-0.066858016,
-0.0268865153,
-0.0510343798,
-0.0265743174,
-0.1434708238,
-0.0029032237,
-0.0339700505,
0.0476787537,
0.0209831409,
0.0082851294,
-0.0170326587,
-0.0128541877,
-0.047489658,
-0.0097483983,
-0.0301999394,
0.034009479,
0.0137089044,
-0.0398836508,
0.0316369496,
-0.0082983989,
0.0197996087,
0.0078328289,
-0.0684931353,
-0.037049517,
-0.0189066436,
0.0363498591,
0.0031578739,
0.0258034095,
-0.0501663312,
-0.0420924202,
0.1012975723,
0.0544248521,
0.0397264361,
0.0113839265,
0.0520152301,
-0.0306888465,
0.0015892871,
0.0374394841,
-0.0267093051,
0.0168143492,
0.0083142687,
0.0127667142,
-0.010970721,
0.0137961376,
0.001234021,
-0.0116076274,
-0.0219483022,
0.0115129538,
0.0386942998,
0.0072295456,
0.0157113131,
-0.0087329717,
-0.0006869106,
-0.0493940301,
-0.0044850986,
0.0460685305,
0.0120260725,
-0.0289082061,
0.0142039461,
0.0214389563,
0.0184667762,
-0.0543345474,
0.0030876405,
0.0293908324,
0.0593410283,
-0.0111736646,
0.0032309366,
-0.0156644862,
-0.0129886335,
-0.00445783,
0.0346880108,
-0.0134456223,
0.0106701106,
0.0296560787,
-0.010203829,
-0.0590175465,
0.0316444412,
-0.09447705,
-0.0055989581,
-0.0172400437,
0.0084686093,
0.0285945926,
-0.0195963029,
0.1127395481,
0.0176654216,
0.0024502,
-0.0019646944,
0.0655917302,
-0.0088611543,
0.0364397131,
-0.0263807718,
-0.0060295765,
0.0232445709,
0.0181749165,
0.0293099247,
-0.00750429,
0.0290733203,
-0.0217194688,
-0.0334557928,
-0.0236619953,
-0.0462260358,
0.0281731132,
-0.0189010333,
0.0505686961,
-0.0130386213,
0.0014143196,
-0.0422660746,
0.0316670686,
-0.0306602083,
0.0200994145,
-0.0230399687,
0.0247842595,
0.0431539491,
-0.0149576487,
-0.0294490736,
-0.0625246987,
0.0291103609,
0.0330540203,
-0.0104448497,
-0.0291893445,
-5.771233513e-33,
-0.0058404063,
0.04463581,
-0.0502069667,
0.0443762392,
-0.0445507988,
-0.040500477,
-0.0337737054,
-0.0519240052,
-0.0031782973,
0.0399050899,
-0.0503739156,
0.0410761461,
-0.0007781328,
0.0272603817,
0.0396229662,
0.0127371736,
0.0643527582,
0.0125494841,
-0.0478623249,
0.0261009764,
0.050111033,
0.0133241666,
0.067841962,
-0.0674657598,
0.0091053676,
0.0001878562,
-0.0242788438,
-0.0381480269,
0.0532365255,
-0.0206510685,
0.0240581688,
0.0296315681,
0.0065800613,
0.0016144615,
-0.0459199846,
-0.0019598641,
-0.0680714995,
-0.0050876937,
0.0010295731,
0.001848055,
-0.0337475166,
-0.0500114784,
0.0797114745,
-0.0192333087,
0.0506179668,
-0.0096300449,
0.0715679601,
-0.0180767979,
0.0275672805,
-0.0369706154,
-0.0269853547,
0.0128675066,
-0.0164897293,
0.0062783817,
0.0004681948,
0.0239720717,
-0.0076797707,
0.0361571014,
-0.0616483092,
-0.0169601459,
-0.0541501865,
0.0053470121,
-0.0172654558,
0.0266512018,
0.0247859433,
0.0156977512,
-0.0358667523,
0.074815996,
-0.0249565877,
0.01583267,
0.0134978993,
0.0161326043,
-0.0069401581,
0.0783766434,
0.0223759972,
-0.0219235476,
0.0225183889,
0.0337884836,
0.0295057856,
-0.0023806756,
0.0083291568,
0.0472091287,
0.005463006,
-0.01342957,
-0.0275930222,
-0.0266686901,
0.0151269604,
-0.0154607976,
-0.0206163656,
0.0113334423,
-0.0487627648,
-0.0152591793,
0.0184636749,
-0.0242649615,
-0.0502547547,
-0.0282311104,
-0.0489637293,
0.0476722121,
-0.0086910212,
-0.016877573,
0.0102664502,
-0.0017797381,
0.0269632209,
0.0463052057,
0.016888177,
-0.006645089,
0.0441636182,
0.0177064594,
-0.0649810061,
-0.0289574713,
-0.0213098563,
-0.0023607502,
-0.0586681478,
-0.0368158072,
-0.0169087797,
0.0346144401,
-0.0005450054,
0.0470973291,
0.0271522515,
0.0223714188,
0.0078174034,
0.0160179604,
0.039079085,
0.0262259245,
-0.0448256433,
-0.0156949759,
-0.0142111331,
-0.0251799785,
0.0064023067,
-0.0703831911,
-0.0104895895,
-0.0104783224,
2.571e-7,
0.0471267216,
0.0132442135,
0.0170938745,
0.0119494209,
0.0095966756,
0.0528255366,
0.0344773978,
0.0566497967,
-0.0107063493,
-0.029053634,
0.0311484281,
0.0244659353,
0.0712283328,
-0.0392309912,
-0.1424727738,
-0.0517589673,
-0.0403408855,
0.0448437743,
-0.0238830764,
-0.0273160003,
0.0800548568,
0.0385460965,
0.0516406745,
-0.0124809556,
0.0154928016,
-0.0201461818,
0.0823406652,
-0.0217146762,
0.0028232515,
0.0276956931,
0.0227765702,
-0.0710040331,
-0.0278677493,
0.019127205,
-0.0197459757,
0.013711636,
0.0272945743,
0.0718529448,
0.0105628502,
0.020429004,
-0.0331161506,
-0.0301127415,
0.0340394564,
-0.0236500967,
0.0525472462,
-0.0034413503,
-0.0055572656,
-0.0234400947,
-0.0925962627,
0.005642252,
0.022998713,
0.0107836258,
-0.0312714018,
0.042914141,
0.0036986631,
0.0067597297,
-0.005183795,
-0.0658882186,
0.0136479456,
-0.0214375965,
-0.031011641,
-0.0154601857,
0.0136756916,
0.0265270118,
0.0162853301,
-0.0292396303,
0.0313506089,
2.017321646e-34,
0.0468331762,
-0.0257252231,
0.0205414612,
0.0469819233,
0.0331365727,
-0.0017841739,
0.0027758165,
0.0140329301,
0.0341008268,
-0.0687594935,
0.0120646683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15452v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15452v6 | When Do Program-of-Thoughts Work for Reasoning? | 2023-08-29T17:22:39 | 2023-12-18T16:15:33 | Zhen Bi, Ningyu Zhang, Yinuo Jiang, Shumin Deng, Guozhou Zheng, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SE | In the realm of embodied artificial intelligence, the reasoning capabilities
of Large Language Models (LLMs) play a pivotal role. Although there are
effective methods like program-of-thought prompting for LLMs which uses
programming language to tackle complex reasoning tasks, the specific impact of
code data on the improvement of reasoning capabilities remains under-explored.
To address this gap, we propose complexity-impacted reasoning score (CIRS),
which combines structural and logical attributes, to measure the correlation
between code and reasoning abilities. Specifically, we use the abstract syntax
tree to encode the structural information and calculate logical complexity by
considering the difficulty and the cyclomatic complexity. Through an empirical
analysis, we find not all code data of complexity can be learned or understood
by LLMs. Optimal level of complexity is critical to the improvement of
reasoning abilities by program-aided prompting. Then we design an
auto-synthesizing and stratifying algorithm, and apply it to instruction
generation for mathematical reasoning and code data filtering for code
generation tasks. Extensive results demonstrates the effectiveness of our
proposed approach. Code will be integrated into the EasyInstruct framework at
https://github.com/zjunlp/EasyInstruct. | [
-0.0193962753,
0.0223865677,
-0.0446348861,
0.0252025817,
-0.0436971486,
0.0378534086,
-0.0237581339,
-0.0125516923,
0.024495637,
0.0163487028,
0.004446608,
0.0151161803,
0.0278533734,
0.0523914099,
0.0268459413,
-0.0121540911,
0.0343774222,
-0.063730523,
0.0274512079,
-0.0136179589,
-0.0164354034,
0.0049028564,
-0.0291798972,
0.0244505517,
0.0288309623,
-0.0429001972,
-0.018837031,
-0.0269455127,
-0.0080506653,
-0.0671138614,
-0.064022243,
0.0061931508,
0.0066891331,
0.0086205238,
0.0000022776,
-0.05506422,
-0.0070385779,
0.0128095048,
-0.0308167655,
-0.0099260584,
-0.0112066157,
0.0111166639,
0.0262006186,
0.0269256756,
-0.0391134024,
0.0185235143,
0.0475654341,
-0.0372173488,
0.0411266126,
0.0454501994,
0.0028157656,
-0.0023194544,
0.0193212386,
0.043961037,
0.0697014853,
0.0174619034,
-0.0089928657,
0.0384055264,
0.028800169,
0.0067360331,
-0.0059216311,
0.0065598227,
0.0650246888,
0.0010870887,
0.0149288308,
0.0263362955,
-0.0218360573,
-0.0329972729,
0.0264417082,
0.019271316,
0.0074146497,
-0.015372673,
-0.0039605512,
-0.0032027403,
0.0208412334,
-0.0251155868,
-0.0387869366,
0.0445344858,
0.0002040907,
-0.005506624,
0.0303018428,
-0.0027083135,
-0.0017595262,
-0.0016145204,
-0.0459494479,
0.0639035553,
-0.0203743801,
-0.0350933187,
0.0013037749,
-0.0389911346,
-0.0283916127,
-0.0537769347,
-0.0211134925,
0.0629008934,
-0.0125145027,
-0.0036222176,
-0.0142161818,
-0.0001667408,
-0.0394179896,
-0.0158310551,
0.0590010174,
0.055166766,
0.0439147316,
0.0088698119,
-0.074121967,
0.0649994761,
0.0142310569,
0.0417568833,
-0.0269131958,
0.0287476778,
-0.0774033517,
-0.0244992208,
-0.0358401425,
0.0834727287,
0.0383791476,
0.0028558793,
-0.0294094793,
0.0287600458,
-0.0384448916,
0.0294433981,
-0.0451014116,
-0.0373708382,
0.02438033,
0.0000513512,
-0.043559406,
-0.0541996285,
-0.0304960627,
-0.020192394,
0.0154134277,
-0.0216510091,
-0.0128915673,
0.027635226,
-0.0072757602,
-0.0002706918,
0.0219505485,
0.0428297408,
-0.0069718491,
-0.0055978261,
-0.0136878388,
-0.0451656058,
0.0280889627,
-0.0422432125,
0.0421753265,
-0.0864469856,
-0.017039571,
0.019259613,
-0.0095631881,
-0.0417190902,
0.0038576182,
0.0065552914,
0.0197208766,
0.0690253899,
-0.036406517,
0.0251182634,
-0.0067161527,
-0.016451424,
-0.040886756,
0.0390143953,
0.0754714832,
-0.0151067758,
-0.020625541,
-0.0252996255,
0.0076991357,
0.000968044,
-0.0233132467,
-0.0326233804,
-0.0129482625,
0.0153463054,
-0.0158000793,
0.0057351836,
-0.050142549,
0.0189317409,
-0.0183788594,
0.0423076563,
-0.0093468865,
0.0188802592,
0.0031481576,
0.0208309591,
0.0563808568,
-0.0006462513,
0.0161214359,
-0.0118384697,
-0.0433318317,
0.089761287,
-0.038398128,
0.0069468962,
-0.0300222971,
0.0102873938,
-0.0075244992,
-0.0961854905,
-0.0080192033,
0.0199087635,
0.0401747674,
0.0243467912,
0.0447282568,
0.0066343187,
-0.0002304904,
0.0145389913,
-0.0229916442,
-0.0360311866,
-0.0439280942,
-0.0798165724,
0.0336467326,
0.0303530525,
0.031219393,
-0.0445279889,
-0.0036670915,
0.0069635161,
0.0236050282,
0.0106905662,
0.0005304459,
0.0037481547,
-0.0033773244,
-0.0381562337,
-0.0014783428,
-0.0358284488,
-0.0080425674,
0.0044495934,
0.0014828079,
-0.0272422582,
0.0115963425,
0.0100136967,
-0.028095521,
0.0193706285,
-0.0044998033,
0.0093401438,
-0.0407275259,
0.0219073445,
0.0236900169,
-0.0100698192,
-0.010422715,
0.0527817681,
0.0067105149,
-0.0298373029,
-0.0198910851,
-0.0157113038,
-0.0600383282,
-0.0224913321,
0.0248335805,
-0.0498818085,
-0.0319335237,
0.0084373355,
0.0004645581,
-0.0207627714,
0.0741932467,
-0.0865988731,
0.0138710598,
0.0048354757,
0.0441255607,
-0.0308214314,
-0.06370911,
0.0058390484,
0.0780873969,
-0.0066357227,
0.0317649581,
0.0595180765,
0.0313019268,
0.032902509,
0.0035910788,
0.022827426,
-0.0008835312,
-0.036629606,
-0.0055729244,
0.0190602709,
0.0391122289,
-0.0420364924,
-0.0242405273,
-0.0443033278,
-0.0280677062,
0.0025262369,
-0.0108127426,
-0.0002205831,
-0.007296117,
0.0088430271,
0.0104591306,
-0.0392147675,
0.0180299859,
-0.0179810375,
0.0361394584,
0.0484253243,
-0.0320150182,
-0.0885609388,
-0.0093332781,
-0.006659118,
-0.0632424504,
0.0511410199,
0.0289666113,
-0.0103915883,
-0.0395240746,
0.0906758085,
-0.0364063457,
-0.0088117048,
-0.0094204647,
-0.0305030514,
0.0620172955,
-0.0474417917,
0.0391337238,
0.0904311538,
-0.03649351,
0.0065522981,
0.072340183,
-0.0263819136,
-0.0428771451,
0.0297120027,
0.0135800811,
-0.000245934,
0.0005542912,
-0.0595544651,
0.0058766506,
0.0561924353,
-0.01494011,
-0.0001946401,
-0.0653542802,
0.0595881157,
-0.0025213561,
-0.0064899344,
-0.0011097972,
-0.0265986361,
-0.0021948754,
0.082075119,
-0.0293322522,
-0.0702279285,
0.0850611702,
-0.0205767006,
-0.0256075822,
-0.017289374,
-0.0016345155,
-0.0444180258,
0.0771691427,
0.0326070674,
0.0146267312,
0.0315587334,
-0.0113797104,
-0.0702722594,
0.0103409439,
0.0250132158,
-0.0160318017,
0.0020733753,
-0.0512841679,
-0.0112103643,
0.0172473583,
-0.0180147998,
-0.0309976414,
0.0629745498,
-0.0110783568,
0.0098490082,
0.0217848904,
-0.0169883817,
0.0302365199,
-0.0299887322,
0.0465007834,
0.0014988483,
0.0104042282,
-0.0528406315,
-0.0143354181,
-0.0504477844,
-0.0147352042,
0.0288312398,
0.0407779589,
-0.0399579667,
0.0651202723,
0.002574557,
0.0344696678,
0.0170406327,
-0.0541037284,
0.0394599847,
-0.0049226927,
0.0113408249,
-0.0158211719,
0.0642533377,
0.0673316419,
-0.041653093,
-0.0250968318,
0.10823185,
0.0388404094,
-0.0106296269,
0.0220193509,
-0.0489972308,
0.0435401946,
0.0876915306,
0.0209888835,
-0.0398643576,
-0.0186314471,
0.0073597548,
0.001041715,
-0.0437109731,
-0.0603232943,
-0.0159816686,
-0.1011070907,
0.0241911076,
0.0064640515,
-0.0074361423,
-0.0811268911,
-0.0041398001,
-0.0239752531,
0.0409956649,
-0.0978761762,
0.0320272148,
-0.0083618611,
0.0266619343,
0.0011715378,
-0.0610327311,
0.0126366308,
0.0472798273,
0.0134459082,
0.0236640535,
0.0554171763,
0.016668098,
-0.0075975866,
-0.0516905114,
0.0290041231,
0.0166684818,
0.020422088,
-0.0329697393,
-0.0005323086,
0.0325828046,
-0.0099807931,
-0.0175207481,
0.0311876815,
-0.0199790448,
-0.0197804831,
0.0350042917,
0.0937754959,
-0.0349519812,
-0.0259236731,
-0.0217168741,
0.0009838041,
-0.0808242783,
0.033565294,
0.0455567576,
-0.0011558374,
-0.0077202832,
-0.0764028281,
-0.028037196,
-0.0282434355,
-0.0172961894,
0.0164370593,
0.0356821455,
0.0140411798,
-0.0338704661,
-0.0167934168,
0.0664847642,
0.0186522435,
-0.0130034974,
-0.0457613729,
0.0195984207,
0.0141918613,
-0.0570056885,
-0.0057017561,
-0.0273679532,
0.0354640707,
-0.0154546192,
-0.0075270603,
-0.0098895822,
-0.0352237672,
-0.0134292813,
0.003673237,
-0.0366298594,
-0.0312091876,
-0.0246049576,
0.0691678151,
0.031944029,
-0.0007131632,
-0.0009733877,
-0.0137038091,
-0.0032823947,
0.005567431,
-0.031636592,
0.019427415,
0.0360816233,
0.0186137203,
0.0498868972,
0.0218358021,
-0.0439823791,
0.0182252936,
0.0102617312,
0.0095067183,
-0.0019134552,
0.0323271565,
0.0354262628,
0.0762325302,
-0.0119958092,
0.0292191226,
-0.0128274038,
-0.0182604566,
-0.0031739541,
-0.0315414406,
-0.0251552537,
-0.0724838078,
0.0200359952,
-0.0069256304,
0.0254754312,
0.0407367125,
-0.0126067335,
0.021571843,
0.0200720988,
0.0457759202,
0.0815230459,
0.0027700509,
0.0696600825,
0.045166973,
-0.0220626779,
-0.017494848,
0.0253799632,
-0.0488092154,
0.0145235155,
0.0044587785,
0.0847924501,
0.0203973502,
0.0191440471,
-0.0308017414,
0.0048552849,
-0.056754224,
-0.1071012095,
0.0403183401,
-0.0104244808,
0.0023826037,
0.0460465401,
-0.0119433701,
-0.0559520908,
0.0292261895,
0.0136104627,
0.0408499725,
0.0358478092,
-0.0671580359,
0.0167875178,
0.0492514521,
0.0181719474,
-0.0773431063,
0.0679708496,
-0.0192112997,
0.0111014713,
-0.0114771547,
-0.017203711,
-0.0356891826,
-0.0150180571,
-0.0247868784,
0.0237994008,
0.0050206608,
0.0202075336,
-0.0590936504,
-0.0804322883,
-0.0067531816,
0.0290848743,
0.0431923009,
0.0033702108,
0.0527263917,
0.0536791198,
-0.0052964492,
-0.0418655463,
0.0337941758,
-0.0152480733,
-0.0035357608,
-0.0314912833,
-0.0200671609,
-5.865541588e-33,
-0.0325663015,
-0.0407870784,
0.021701429,
0.0280335993,
0.0050010462,
-0.002214567,
-0.076875098,
0.0428061895,
-0.0115484372,
-0.0177578628,
0.0484933965,
0.019547876,
-0.0336373076,
-0.0020820696,
0.0432115719,
0.0184492916,
0.0098672286,
-0.0048671677,
-0.0376392081,
-0.0167912189,
-0.0266827736,
-0.0335443094,
-0.0127380099,
-0.0255389791,
0.0069304681,
0.0260384269,
0.018488206,
0.0103356699,
-0.046386376,
0.0433436558,
0.0172978025,
0.011246738,
0.0173335616,
-0.0044941246,
-0.017809011,
-0.0038397249,
-0.0030039365,
-0.0801805556,
0.025227638,
-0.0186988451,
-0.0451459475,
-0.0662865639,
0.0458972044,
0.0036725802,
-0.0301465504,
-0.0608171336,
0.0343418196,
-0.0307394024,
0.033996664,
-0.0267369188,
-0.0466464758,
0.0200341623,
-0.0656992719,
-0.0273181275,
0.0332978927,
0.0408481397,
-0.0215624589,
0.0289032571,
0.0044410904,
0.0126021793,
-0.0020416128,
0.0017512116,
0.0512594171,
-0.0073951492,
0.0320147388,
0.0200849678,
0.0651226118,
0.014768579,
-0.0620455667,
0.048010435,
0.0271599609,
0.0624908991,
0.0610154681,
-0.0089324256,
0.0278848,
0.0407327227,
-0.0897344798,
-0.0100346254,
-0.0176302195,
0.0480536185,
0.0285511315,
0.012358225,
-0.0602870882,
-0.0233348887,
-0.0345511436,
0.013812826,
-0.0348941386,
-0.0313218236,
0.0288531557,
-0.0420125872,
-0.0110557918,
-0.0489765853,
-0.0037503247,
-0.019029364,
-0.00016561,
-0.0007125758,
-0.0342750587,
0.0575148948,
0.0070021348,
0.0403535515,
-0.0116570313,
-0.0115924003,
0.0232162215,
-0.0068888473,
0.0845348611,
0.0180071723,
0.0212028287,
0.0397336073,
-0.0443735085,
-0.0500982329,
-0.0570899174,
-0.0219309647,
0.0082330741,
0.0254948996,
0.0121790925,
0.0248364024,
-0.0161367171,
-0.0122858919,
-0.0205119215,
-0.0300034173,
-0.0725301504,
0.0165425278,
-0.0240369774,
0.0194315594,
-0.0253546033,
-0.057448674,
-0.0550736748,
0.0149407852,
0.005725882,
-0.035337396,
-0.0481664278,
0.0255310945,
3.11e-7,
-0.0056273923,
0.0540172346,
-0.0158726983,
0.100588873,
0.0229069553,
0.0405039787,
-0.0214107558,
-0.0316968597,
0.0173225943,
-0.047977455,
-0.0249889288,
0.0669246987,
0.0373319611,
0.0268854015,
-0.0456894673,
0.0276487432,
0.0115112755,
-0.039851997,
-0.034702979,
0.0432610102,
0.1055832803,
0.0395244732,
0.0048057595,
0.0220524799,
0.0314189009,
-0.0253608171,
-0.0060697901,
-0.0215501022,
0.0442234315,
-0.0215188693,
-0.0554187782,
0.0149335451,
0.0062000593,
0.0464740023,
0.0179512482,
-0.0197615698,
0.0062450375,
0.0182713233,
-0.0107453205,
0.0602527224,
0.0366453454,
-0.0272614807,
-0.0059135435,
-0.0539363846,
0.0650403798,
-0.0529372841,
-0.0399348065,
0.0101049971,
-0.0015972944,
-0.0123729026,
-0.0015396187,
0.0225209892,
0.0127894124,
-0.0074234609,
-0.0105295666,
-0.0506921634,
0.0205272846,
-0.0373723321,
-0.0162180327,
-0.0015007906,
-0.0206109472,
-0.0595939979,
-0.0743870586,
0.040716324,
0.0206147656,
-0.0199046973,
-0.0018532313,
3.245782578e-34,
0.0152472146,
-0.0348407589,
0.0510899127,
0.0233011562,
0.0762078613,
-0.0074114483,
-0.0155760814,
0.0140199261,
0.0335123502,
-0.0513359457,
-0.038701348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15448v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15448v1 | Vulgar Remarks Detection in Chittagonian Dialect of Bangla | 2023-08-29T17:19:32 | 2023-08-29T17:19:32 | Tanjim Mahmud, Michal Ptaszynski, Fumito Masui | cs.CL | cs.CL | The negative effects of online bullying and harassment are increasing with
Internet popularity, especially in social media. One solution is using natural
language processing (NLP) and machine learning (ML) methods for the automatic
detection of harmful remarks, but these methods are limited in low-resource
languages like the Chittagonian dialect of Bangla.This study focuses on
detecting vulgar remarks in social media using supervised ML and deep learning
algorithms.Logistic Regression achieved promising accuracy (0.91) while simple
RNN with Word2vec and fastTex had lower accuracy (0.84-0.90), highlighting the
issue that NN algorithms require more data. | [
0.1140961125,
0.0351656824,
-0.0107420618,
0.0486245938,
-0.0107149463,
0.0300410334,
0.009737296,
0.0192673039,
0.0302859843,
-0.0207592491,
-0.02067177,
-0.0710434318,
0.0117026586,
0.043865215,
-0.0204580538,
-0.0295309834,
0.0026292093,
0.0606622659,
0.0409904532,
0.0117904376,
0.0324599259,
0.0033443402,
-0.0315892287,
0.014654953,
-0.0617829934,
0.0124447467,
0.0276686791,
0.0348694362,
-0.0268733334,
-0.0106144752,
0.0517656617,
0.0325012095,
-0.020844698,
0.0684690997,
0.0000017479,
-0.0712378472,
0.0452882014,
-0.0216622148,
0.0006876814,
0.0063069039,
0.0953752697,
-0.0129801165,
-0.0359067433,
0.0554186627,
-0.0492935553,
-0.015877964,
0.0951613039,
0.0615030304,
0.0491921194,
0.0734266341,
0.0047691632,
-0.0435990803,
0.0087173255,
-0.0058192774,
-0.0247302055,
-0.0133474339,
0.0347051322,
-0.0639017895,
-0.0192390736,
-0.0086647365,
-0.0228544138,
0.0277938321,
-0.0042693033,
-0.0275716558,
-0.0016126188,
-0.030125469,
-0.0210154988,
-0.0274670273,
0.034730576,
0.0357753336,
-0.0484432317,
0.0095928172,
-0.0339364596,
0.0091011254,
-0.0277780779,
-0.0551511459,
-0.0240717679,
0.0122182341,
-0.0283292811,
0.0376636162,
-0.018122891,
-0.0005687362,
0.0204777587,
0.0736578628,
0.0445139632,
-0.0091229938,
-0.0310000945,
-0.0344285145,
-0.0077478914,
0.0032477065,
0.003352711,
0.0206256043,
0.0453366414,
0.0090510016,
-0.0258030239,
0.0108179469,
0.0119353887,
-0.0536779501,
0.0288377386,
-0.0803860351,
0.0084281694,
0.0078086313,
-0.029277062,
0.0111487629,
-0.0146404309,
0.0083948495,
-0.0076072067,
0.0138603644,
0.034821976,
-0.0327075161,
-0.0189429019,
-0.0032968079,
0.0186891053,
-0.0022301399,
-0.0064327503,
0.0176269524,
-0.0945030749,
0.001567089,
-0.0311354846,
-0.0436023809,
-0.005791577,
0.0364152007,
-0.0247589312,
0.0036865904,
-0.0015869545,
-0.0176650248,
-0.0250801258,
0.0062784445,
-0.0453603454,
-0.0856559649,
0.0340858363,
-0.0142223639,
0.0151280733,
-0.000905798,
0.0284774117,
0.0534851886,
0.024205463,
-0.0460615307,
-0.0752730668,
-0.0001345244,
-0.0426595435,
-0.0258393772,
-0.0161281135,
-0.0735230818,
0.0205960143,
-0.0311210211,
-0.0606409013,
-0.0228087679,
0.015756689,
0.0100327795,
-0.052538313,
0.0462520383,
-0.0256871097,
-0.0172539558,
0.0505618341,
0.0151866423,
0.0272643827,
0.0407424308,
0.0125264702,
0.0339674801,
0.0381898731,
-0.0056738411,
-0.0221059378,
0.0322001465,
-0.0052269734,
-0.0157315861,
-0.0473175459,
-0.0222454946,
-0.0364292078,
0.0021765367,
-0.0214913022,
0.0281255692,
0.0235122237,
-0.0010498054,
0.0365064554,
0.0186471827,
0.0160776712,
0.0740463808,
0.0721459165,
0.0383663736,
-0.0137817264,
-0.0163208693,
-0.053320393,
-0.0217151958,
-0.0272772182,
-0.0629490912,
0.037153393,
0.0519479625,
-0.0141217262,
-0.0510986671,
0.0253575835,
-0.0202163905,
0.0324048437,
-0.0589324608,
0.064917922,
0.0215904526,
-0.0180696808,
-0.055942405,
0.0819345117,
-0.0251786727,
-0.0119179636,
-0.0061478396,
0.0541286245,
0.0603234284,
0.0075602522,
0.0091372915,
0.0046794377,
-0.0606273226,
0.0085904915,
0.0465498194,
-0.0298679564,
0.0155601595,
0.0244916435,
-0.049483344,
0.0138192559,
0.0546069033,
-0.0228807051,
0.0026583988,
0.0358066671,
0.0612844639,
0.0114349527,
0.0853998363,
-0.063391611,
0.016314581,
0.0167058054,
-0.0218329914,
0.0253848359,
0.0385419056,
0.0579520278,
0.0140812211,
-0.0092713591,
-0.0707819983,
0.0037483168,
-0.0115765138,
-0.0205178149,
-0.0138915209,
-0.0345879383,
-0.0202612057,
0.0191196706,
-0.0571214072,
0.0032825705,
0.0435569584,
-0.013353481,
0.004640983,
0.0885391235,
-0.0417981632,
0.038356673,
-0.018013116,
-0.0226487443,
-0.0817958117,
0.059451323,
0.0385413505,
0.0339312479,
-0.0128521696,
-0.0225809719,
0.051030308,
-0.0137216216,
0.0296962373,
0.035213992,
-0.082418628,
0.0009960863,
-0.039777752,
0.0199190676,
-0.000372681,
0.066875577,
-0.0119051635,
0.0012121375,
-0.0760649219,
0.0069522499,
-0.0211940315,
-0.0278511308,
0.0052543352,
0.0460064709,
-0.0270919818,
-0.008342973,
-0.0036947096,
0.0025256404,
0.0418657437,
0.0004323747,
0.0273187235,
-0.0272688121,
0.0007197815,
-0.0263005663,
-0.0261803549,
-0.0266898666,
-0.0003794443,
0.0247438066,
-0.0526511259,
0.0396720767,
0.0098864716,
-0.0159954596,
0.0507065207,
0.0249986686,
-0.084873952,
0.0067945467,
-0.0050012092,
-0.0314313546,
0.0744494125,
0.058819294,
0.065565452,
-0.0040188255,
0.0171119105,
-0.0183523279,
0.014881772,
-0.0054573882,
-0.0235477779,
-0.0031538124,
-0.0349764116,
-0.0094369035,
0.0403547101,
0.0096021872,
0.0257356539,
-0.030137714,
0.0192964617,
-0.0082821827,
-0.0246719345,
0.0031862098,
0.0038033102,
-0.0259270985,
0.0027258156,
0.0011983572,
-0.0590851828,
0.054889936,
0.0208026227,
-0.0065394226,
-0.0266710464,
-0.0380094461,
0.0086443517,
0.0204488281,
-0.0193288699,
0.033801686,
-0.035943117,
-0.0724632442,
0.0224765763,
0.0047353273,
0.0368561894,
-0.0026154241,
-0.0113754943,
-0.0174836982,
-0.0143140517,
0.00483257,
-0.021361148,
-0.047422532,
-0.0653450564,
-0.0221207775,
-0.0482498854,
0.0028702447,
-0.0192668736,
0.0142348679,
0.0286777802,
-0.0279238634,
-0.056373436,
-0.0167985521,
0.0014051717,
0.0032075893,
-0.0500846207,
0.0121063143,
-0.000768567,
0.0355673693,
0.0464928746,
-0.021078147,
0.0318590999,
-0.0521543324,
0.0133909862,
-0.0381181873,
0.0019916454,
-0.0050818799,
0.005957732,
0.0088100377,
-0.0004655946,
0.015096047,
-0.011840797,
-0.0399275497,
0.0747428834,
0.012664455,
-0.0328239389,
-0.0143470829,
-0.0188497212,
-0.0234438367,
-0.005782295,
-0.0124627063,
-0.0363023356,
-0.0139884651,
-0.0300866347,
0.0104250563,
-0.0441246517,
-0.0389279462,
-0.014300202,
-0.0838649645,
0.0006719987,
-0.0334941521,
-0.0250686351,
-0.051675424,
0.0102367103,
0.011273481,
0.0147975432,
0.0421737917,
-0.0198359918,
-0.0197740272,
-0.0362073407,
0.0264903158,
-0.0674077123,
-0.0420130938,
0.0242901277,
-0.045341868,
0.0266068112,
0.0075584012,
0.0620824993,
-0.0706931874,
-0.0032204739,
-0.0037772187,
0.0177524518,
-0.0315934531,
-0.0453357585,
0.0248443354,
-0.0029613171,
-0.0462124012,
-0.0305254646,
-0.0010199572,
-0.0129928542,
0.0564331822,
-0.0033028829,
0.0437164567,
0.0288131703,
-0.021945728,
-0.0452315323,
0.0585518815,
0.0285950489,
0.0141823543,
0.0411659665,
-0.0898943692,
-0.0012122224,
-0.0129994638,
-0.0330487676,
-0.0377913602,
-0.0426177718,
-0.0138716828,
-0.0462637283,
-0.0545642264,
-0.0433288701,
-0.0452781096,
0.032528162,
-0.0098620635,
0.0300386511,
-0.0028157961,
0.0228942726,
-0.0268900637,
-0.0306862295,
-0.0410677306,
-0.0012513605,
0.0164282527,
-0.0396218225,
0.019445397,
0.0132008865,
0.0056388848,
0.0046008723,
0.0158203878,
-0.0406234041,
-0.029828798,
0.0335299447,
0.0443621129,
0.0078854719,
0.0187229104,
-0.0508130006,
-0.064060621,
-0.0091518825,
0.0503317118,
0.0193730332,
-0.0322633572,
0.0498259813,
0.01368983,
0.0128624663,
0.030374106,
-0.0176401343,
0.0286468547,
0.0103927832,
-0.0429671109,
-0.0230936315,
-0.051564876,
-0.029544564,
-0.0209487174,
0.0274708327,
0.00962485,
-0.1171785593,
-0.0193110891,
-0.0289385486,
0.0510096997,
0.0014094162,
-0.0017164008,
0.0310798287,
0.0303401276,
0.0212652814,
-0.0294696186,
-0.0327218808,
-0.0305140428,
-0.0047298474,
-0.0233570952,
0.0529273003,
0.0440365635,
0.0469038337,
0.0324671827,
0.0287916884,
-0.0378210321,
0.0166235007,
0.0343690701,
-0.0055205524,
-0.0015153327,
0.0125372689,
0.002924578,
0.0221393723,
0.0108521534,
0.0042195427,
0.0504660085,
-0.0116356649,
-0.033631213,
-0.0249348078,
0.0353333987,
-0.0524399802,
0.0364687033,
-0.0200765878,
0.0187535752,
-0.0288488809,
0.0117072947,
-0.06395486,
-0.0297454875,
0.0472770855,
-0.0094987722,
-0.0275071189,
0.0253242906,
0.0305498652,
0.0015853284,
0.0039911252,
0.0891015455,
-0.0386845432,
-0.0346995965,
-0.0003970449,
0.0323743224,
0.0654991418,
0.0074861743,
0.0602046028,
0.0159066394,
-0.0385272503,
0.016913699,
-0.0679277256,
0.0209390689,
-0.0010006531,
0.0350424275,
0.0605124608,
0.0592543595,
0.0485758483,
-0.0407266319,
0.0043541966,
0.0284978785,
-0.0578991175,
-0.0340274274,
-5.708506931e-33,
0.0220672507,
-0.0324349552,
-0.010707031,
0.0392423049,
-0.0034682807,
-0.0406927392,
-0.0072507458,
0.0080056787,
-0.0243642498,
0.0207539722,
-0.0068210703,
0.0099773873,
0.0121014537,
0.0057308837,
0.0377080701,
-0.0372492969,
0.0154569624,
0.0267846566,
0.0118613979,
0.0336090215,
0.0519646816,
0.0444153994,
0.0697767586,
-0.0786448121,
0.0465476923,
-0.0231814496,
-0.002152181,
0.0127376588,
0.0118964966,
0.0638944581,
-0.0260585006,
0.0865525529,
0.0319564976,
0.0046805125,
-0.0050141579,
0.0744729266,
-0.0382677615,
-0.0109802764,
0.0216496345,
0.0510221645,
0.003726586,
-0.0086081801,
0.0786733702,
0.0254760236,
-0.0281169787,
0.003203589,
0.054187078,
-0.0057778056,
0.0074953674,
-0.0310344435,
-0.0695920289,
0.0016757603,
-0.0188558809,
-0.022039732,
-0.0048888237,
0.0176032539,
0.0002619672,
-0.028483808,
-0.0734472051,
0.002065799,
0.0016616056,
0.0017519485,
-0.0298841782,
0.0028590385,
-0.0067422199,
0.0116140833,
0.035287153,
-0.0103367632,
0.0183685813,
0.0234863628,
0.0609762557,
0.026918117,
-0.0158825032,
0.0351081863,
0.0522581264,
-0.1149851754,
-0.0768925771,
-0.0222834535,
0.0689709112,
0.0372165293,
0.015618437,
-0.0326364078,
-0.0780787691,
-0.0411561243,
0.0557408519,
-0.01320442,
-0.0103744511,
-0.0432123169,
0.0152777536,
-0.0365652554,
0.0064387233,
0.0223412551,
0.0188067332,
-0.0415514298,
-0.0159956049,
0.0044748699,
-0.0099124406,
0.0125462636,
0.0321314968,
0.0454803333,
-0.0385085568,
-0.012925691,
-0.0350560173,
-0.0249843765,
0.0117689697,
0.0261545107,
0.07535436,
0.0108130313,
-0.05722313,
0.0054320758,
-0.0182323679,
0.0417764187,
-0.0339814834,
0.0937230065,
-0.0269278511,
-0.0079672569,
-0.0184303392,
0.025939228,
0.0162682999,
0.0285767224,
-0.0085515641,
-0.0392974354,
0.0106161358,
-0.0326931253,
-0.0365823396,
-0.0192598719,
-0.0438776389,
0.0113244811,
-0.0024231486,
-0.081232883,
0.0157752316,
-0.0119950706,
2.479e-7,
-0.0053420374,
0.0706175417,
0.0286933277,
-0.0106858276,
0.0213234592,
0.0384061262,
0.0249786098,
0.0084494529,
-0.0078601707,
0.0327675827,
-0.0019101645,
0.0079077277,
-0.0019987668,
0.0348702371,
-0.0767496973,
-0.0017951067,
-0.1097802669,
-0.0140526304,
-0.0392550193,
-0.033586923,
-0.0114038885,
0.07045535,
0.046967417,
-0.072805889,
-0.0073900539,
-0.0201969407,
-0.0063810707,
-0.0146675184,
0.0044350768,
-0.00788345,
0.0494407192,
0.0676765069,
0.0211715214,
-0.0161531903,
0.0158997644,
0.0038805117,
-0.0004754968,
0.0178927239,
-0.0105564632,
0.0325555615,
0.0434214436,
-0.0178495292,
-0.0012960556,
0.0095240707,
0.0464891344,
0.0520565547,
-0.026313819,
-0.02957532,
0.043745175,
-0.0017018416,
0.0642030239,
-0.0709980354,
0.0021171561,
-0.0207813736,
0.0270796474,
-0.0728114918,
-0.0190652553,
-0.0504968576,
0.0466008447,
0.0417618714,
-0.0083047543,
0.002677097,
0.0050441693,
0.010164029,
0.0699135512,
-0.0006529099,
0.0834368467,
1.725497596e-34,
0.026847383,
-0.013549841,
0.0506569222,
-0.0084399665,
0.0232762396,
0.0542702824,
0.0132404026,
-0.0089051789,
0.0454741791,
-0.0158106964,
-0.0063121011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15517v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15517v1 | Document AI: A Comparative Study of Transformer-Based, Graph-Based Models, and Convolutional Neural Networks For Document Layout Analysis | 2023-08-29T16:58:03 | 2023-08-29T16:58:03 | Sotirios Kastanas, Shaomu Tan, Yi He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Document AI aims to automatically analyze documents by leveraging natural
language processing and computer vision techniques. One of the major tasks of
Document AI is document layout analysis, which structures document pages by
interpreting the content and spatial relationships of layout, image, and text.
This task can be image-centric, wherein the aim is to identify and label
various regions such as authors and paragraphs, or text-centric, where the
focus is on classifying individual words in a document. Although there are
increasingly sophisticated methods for improving layout analysis, doubts remain
about the extent to which their findings can be generalized to a broader
context. Specifically, prior work developed systems based on very different
architectures, such as transformer-based, graph-based, and CNNs. However, no
work has mentioned the effectiveness of these models in a comparative analysis.
Moreover, while language-independent Document AI models capable of knowledge
transfer have been developed, it remains to be investigated to what degree they
can effectively transfer knowledge. In this study, we aim to fill these gaps by
conducting a comparative evaluation of state-of-the-art models in document
layout analysis and investigating the potential of cross-lingual layout
analysis by utilizing machine translation techniques. | [
0.0675597414,
0.0389727987,
0.0044171014,
0.0509058908,
-0.0514795817,
0.0155891366,
0.0420493297,
0.0115937507,
0.0140883885,
-0.0204545483,
-0.0254079066,
-0.0081157843,
0.0164733026,
0.0291593485,
-0.0091473758,
-0.0307292081,
-0.0199568514,
-0.033509098,
0.0010711435,
0.0228726305,
-0.0048846705,
-0.0063547497,
0.0248821843,
-0.0209271982,
-0.0313523263,
-0.0321197845,
-0.0374951623,
0.0280265734,
-0.0078117801,
0.0231827497,
-0.0189139433,
0.0294535663,
0.0151742473,
0.0480765887,
0.0000018407,
0.0241003856,
-0.0284228753,
-0.003983465,
0.040655233,
-0.0069112079,
0.0577337109,
-0.0800359026,
-0.0104793394,
-0.058444526,
-0.0247426536,
-0.0115177827,
0.0591552518,
0.0772129893,
0.0010432793,
0.0803830326,
-0.0407759137,
-0.054921668,
0.0406940021,
-0.0095516574,
0.0147121791,
-0.0284532364,
0.0120243123,
-0.0164726097,
-0.0072173793,
-0.0053979857,
-0.0498319194,
0.0317381732,
0.0187124405,
-0.1012668908,
0.0182359535,
0.0045172772,
-0.0360770151,
-0.0116753122,
-0.0185348596,
0.0690223798,
-0.0518668517,
-0.0096796919,
0.0009622469,
-0.0254950486,
-0.0277126767,
0.0353476368,
-0.0450594872,
-0.0139007857,
-0.0492120907,
-0.0175580718,
-0.0208950099,
0.0146512846,
-0.0138351712,
0.003493387,
-0.041199673,
0.0343371816,
-0.0069995504,
-0.0135862855,
0.0248365961,
0.0224553682,
0.040824417,
-0.034662772,
0.044813104,
0.0522821806,
0.0461961329,
-0.002334821,
-0.0290012248,
-0.0781606138,
0.0043591792,
-0.0345980451,
-0.0125532756,
-0.0417893268,
-0.0245507285,
0.0726303682,
-0.0332600437,
0.0969083607,
-0.0360475481,
0.0682636872,
-0.0611637682,
0.005398578,
-0.0070952955,
0.003511392,
-0.0149885723,
0.0036874206,
-0.0068691727,
-0.0728565603,
-0.0051299562,
0.0172559358,
0.0136902314,
0.0343604647,
0.0180076696,
0.0136824902,
-0.0390369482,
-0.042197533,
0.0337159559,
0.0190122481,
0.0215545148,
-0.0131592108,
-0.0382076837,
-0.0038687298,
0.0423825495,
0.0555082671,
0.0400841683,
-0.0060197106,
-0.014018585,
0.0333411098,
-0.0170389749,
-0.0330398194,
-0.0226247609,
0.0150181642,
-0.0286693778,
-0.053451281,
0.080771625,
-0.0700635985,
0.0208057202,
-0.0132820727,
-0.0133179743,
-0.0237294696,
-0.0176124126,
0.0002539933,
-0.0514368862,
0.0523907691,
0.0378956608,
0.0410366282,
0.0763655975,
-0.0058032935,
0.0095447563,
-0.0004912454,
0.0305442791,
0.0914133042,
0.0433094092,
-0.0256150197,
0.0193145406,
0.0513637103,
-0.0234281961,
-0.0442779511,
0.0165966172,
-0.0136158597,
-0.0413449258,
-0.0157744419,
-0.0329052322,
0.0264534466,
0.0030359365,
0.0020258138,
0.0653987974,
0.0751552507,
0.0153368358,
0.0509630255,
0.0285954755,
0.0298425872,
0.0100457119,
0.0181256924,
-0.0252561457,
0.0002476041,
0.0673601106,
0.0285685472,
-0.0376669876,
0.010095831,
-0.0161685515,
-0.0321709514,
0.0003827467,
-0.0113009242,
0.0513912849,
-0.038391199,
0.116849862,
0.0307947751,
-0.0571804978,
-0.0110928407,
-0.029763272,
-0.0566123985,
-0.0324229002,
0.004890094,
-0.0045179208,
0.0504759736,
0.0398012623,
-0.0351693593,
-0.0274488144,
0.0227978006,
0.0093915211,
0.0425850376,
0.0531948395,
-0.0046692728,
-0.0057336856,
-0.0542855375,
-0.0350478217,
-0.0126697943,
-0.0348153636,
0.046333842,
0.0170828085,
0.0370772853,
0.0226721857,
-0.0545663796,
-0.0596004985,
0.0403889716,
0.0061878343,
-0.0176833682,
0.0191940367,
0.0359403417,
-0.0170839913,
0.013148779,
-0.0143828029,
-0.0121995797,
0.0373824984,
-0.0347334184,
0.0078745643,
0.0123987971,
-0.0193220228,
-0.0151251163,
0.0007447301,
-0.0427448377,
-0.017689053,
0.0172106158,
-0.0590425357,
-0.0355975255,
0.0302211493,
-0.0087977732,
0.0174839906,
0.0147353653,
0.0025900376,
-0.0199139789,
0.0130989989,
-0.0377854444,
0.0642982498,
0.0251980256,
-0.0097742723,
-0.0032844476,
-0.0049844454,
0.0115865692,
-0.0159316957,
0.0100998804,
-0.0028171097,
-0.0053819292,
-0.005248141,
0.0363538973,
0.0542202815,
0.0104640611,
-0.0418639332,
-0.0947969779,
-0.0095206751,
-0.023237193,
0.0207427423,
0.015749488,
-0.0109760957,
0.0085799787,
-0.0384599753,
-0.0653479174,
0.0220866501,
-0.0204034913,
-0.0299892947,
0.0363273099,
-0.0181120876,
0.0292802267,
-0.0038716607,
-0.01706497,
-0.0062641073,
0.0356123783,
0.0819999725,
-0.084463425,
-0.0103207296,
0.029136572,
0.0310555715,
0.0086574461,
-0.0142399855,
-0.0190286096,
-0.0039841207,
-0.0254545417,
0.0174944345,
0.1287278533,
-0.0001878078,
0.0443824977,
-0.021078242,
0.0114800576,
-0.0155837974,
0.0122521138,
-0.0141955176,
0.0321734622,
0.00655312,
-0.0374579281,
-0.0199809652,
0.0245087873,
-0.0130868033,
0.0271059927,
-0.0215363223,
-0.0265910178,
-0.0317443162,
0.0032985057,
-0.0016855986,
-0.0234343968,
0.04028951,
0.0415223688,
-0.0515394062,
-0.0421215668,
0.0128900157,
-0.046122279,
-0.0111603718,
-0.0263336562,
-0.0089840824,
-0.0675144643,
0.0918174684,
0.0623059832,
0.0222266112,
-0.0178406481,
-0.026582934,
-0.020683188,
0.0038419496,
0.0186345279,
-0.0147296106,
0.0136555787,
-0.0458387956,
0.0489609092,
-0.0218081009,
-0.0318960547,
-0.0152136628,
0.0036069755,
0.0321743973,
-0.0230286531,
0.0028515563,
-0.0361204222,
-0.0532458946,
0.0608983338,
0.0098469034,
0.0908199549,
-0.0250904281,
-0.0060387468,
-0.0193806887,
0.0895323008,
0.0363069847,
-0.0344791487,
-0.0157869719,
-0.0346788839,
-0.0062260409,
0.0479638726,
-0.052433908,
0.0258399788,
-0.035691347,
0.0142816463,
-0.0147843407,
-0.0056692953,
-0.0041301125,
-0.0410471521,
0.0360141285,
-0.0794584304,
-0.0258235056,
0.0772446841,
0.0165223721,
-0.0719401985,
-0.0684353411,
-0.0280145872,
-0.0403787829,
-0.0207474306,
0.0367400348,
-0.0324507654,
0.02142011,
-0.0090894541,
-0.017500896,
0.0236555114,
0.0185952745,
-0.0003847444,
-0.0479225703,
0.0429618619,
0.0069072512,
-0.047557462,
-0.025251735,
-0.0425348841,
0.0020794396,
-0.0132983923,
-0.0344793424,
-0.0585273504,
0.0045909444,
-0.0594370179,
-0.0274964105,
-0.0359608121,
0.0103476765,
-0.0358099379,
0.0023112711,
-0.0631054565,
0.0390016884,
0.069323495,
-0.0240272619,
-0.0285218768,
0.0302902702,
0.0464943238,
0.0154002579,
-0.0165961627,
0.0655417442,
0.0040341774,
0.0154527919,
-0.0228769388,
0.0084641334,
-0.0195817612,
-0.0164972786,
0.0017102004,
-0.0007372516,
0.0062340586,
-0.023521632,
-0.0316881724,
0.0006527012,
0.0000741136,
0.0057468801,
0.0216726828,
-0.0198999569,
-0.1031019911,
-0.0434027389,
0.0682743266,
-0.0630236343,
0.0100354664,
0.0126151647,
-0.0632104576,
-0.0721321553,
-0.0636396185,
-0.0189214051,
0.00449317,
-0.000424457,
0.040817041,
-0.0366805866,
0.0361419283,
-0.0383291841,
-0.0638358667,
-0.0083446559,
0.0317658149,
0.0290992875,
-0.0276995748,
0.0207265262,
0.0134704765,
-0.0292937886,
-0.0090796063,
0.0076491451,
-0.069947049,
-0.0160386153,
0.0091427239,
0.0361700729,
0.0124035608,
0.0420130379,
-0.0173154604,
-0.0055013183,
0.0289905127,
0.0040748813,
-0.0183459241,
-0.0384095646,
0.013045433,
-0.0317007452,
-0.0283290017,
-0.0064624273,
-0.0440792292,
0.0342172496,
0.0361809582,
-0.0440271012,
-0.0390588716,
-0.0494944528,
-0.0513981134,
-0.0229361802,
-0.0039029999,
0.0077440389,
0.0091533158,
-0.0312781408,
0.0292821098,
0.0029312538,
-0.0068111066,
-0.012580473,
-0.0372060202,
0.0390480645,
0.0350448266,
0.0067107133,
0.0322515778,
0.0143723134,
0.0166072678,
-0.0105930585,
0.018455321,
0.0096339323,
0.0069340067,
0.0033227142,
0.0350869708,
-0.0142704239,
0.0231188461,
0.0200436655,
0.0555482432,
0.0006000672,
0.0180530231,
0.0151329599,
-0.0253667794,
-0.0215468295,
0.0486671887,
-0.0719827712,
-0.0197227411,
-0.0284987073,
0.0168457888,
0.0284011737,
-0.0625115037,
0.0376788005,
-0.0268576648,
-0.0099752611,
0.009839939,
0.02908835,
0.0531919301,
-0.0031763865,
-0.0315551125,
0.0177523531,
0.0469180532,
0.0020718852,
0.0436038673,
0.0406209305,
-0.0169019476,
0.0073767458,
-0.0707778111,
-0.0479193889,
0.0240534395,
0.0516628958,
0.0097152246,
-0.0039576418,
0.0024423522,
-0.0238909479,
0.0060464735,
0.0467446968,
0.0068471385,
0.0045711347,
0.0221177489,
0.013892849,
0.0552335829,
0.0240631066,
0.0013043919,
-0.0680412352,
0.0259784535,
-0.032979425,
-0.0175823905,
0.0042668092,
-5.144512823e-33,
-0.0099015851,
-0.1037266776,
0.0039132554,
0.0698717684,
-0.0456429422,
0.0001508763,
-0.0384152867,
-0.0417866744,
-0.0013538772,
0.0493018255,
-0.0170602035,
-0.0095068812,
0.0512839556,
0.0265734699,
-0.0070724962,
0.018238537,
0.0160343517,
0.0087794773,
-0.0167190991,
0.0306072589,
0.0041912477,
0.0419415794,
0.0628299788,
-0.0544521697,
0.012994146,
-0.0161652341,
0.060331054,
-0.0133673353,
0.0146446042,
0.0102262143,
0.0203243792,
-0.037299931,
0.0419605263,
-0.0164467152,
0.0208672043,
0.0784135312,
-0.1024913639,
-0.0021577848,
-0.0286987498,
0.0776761547,
0.0060259285,
-0.0201845691,
0.051543247,
-0.0293492749,
0.0508875288,
-0.0417920016,
0.094677031,
-0.0077711493,
-0.0184157901,
-0.0290259272,
-0.0754355565,
0.0360769108,
-0.0304051191,
-0.0084167747,
0.0679799393,
-0.0065892795,
0.0006002207,
0.0398067832,
-0.0947797671,
0.0116180126,
-0.0213729106,
0.0272211209,
0.0778419897,
0.0275546107,
-0.0325705782,
0.0173262022,
0.0068275533,
0.0236043911,
-0.0256855451,
-0.0176009852,
0.0205638148,
0.0538499281,
0.0345335379,
-0.0035288567,
0.007255258,
0.0213228241,
-0.0446532853,
0.0613216124,
-0.0187771861,
0.0697840527,
-0.0039163479,
-0.0004698297,
-0.0322538465,
0.0098056579,
0.0278403275,
-0.0280729719,
-0.0269942563,
-0.0051199831,
0.0120803276,
0.0130666737,
-0.0243413243,
0.0207462925,
0.0378137454,
-0.040735662,
0.0074053691,
0.0318465568,
-0.0110021504,
0.0740427449,
-0.0408644751,
-0.0242105871,
-0.0395639688,
-0.0537310466,
0.0052500125,
0.0650086328,
0.0202247929,
-0.0073678903,
0.0728243291,
0.0215941183,
-0.0262113716,
-0.0048969775,
-0.0189763252,
-0.0214294456,
0.0063547278,
0.0475156493,
-0.0037335169,
-0.0066426382,
-0.0170702878,
0.0290217493,
0.0249243788,
0.0261498485,
0.0052095312,
-0.032943856,
0.0158656873,
-0.003478454,
-0.0374165289,
-0.0351079814,
-0.03728614,
0.0303260013,
0.0422403105,
-0.034541022,
-0.0035134782,
0.0311113708,
2.345e-7,
0.0791082531,
0.0403983109,
0.0815051794,
-0.0176339541,
0.0440191664,
0.0066325194,
-0.0148675209,
-0.0065439832,
-0.0310023632,
0.0290239733,
0.0455469377,
0.0226691049,
0.073023811,
0.0109561626,
-0.0825663731,
0.0562103726,
-0.0631333888,
-0.0436690561,
-0.0536268726,
0.0131772459,
0.0157501977,
0.0239685774,
-0.0381697901,
-0.0585770644,
-0.0035315547,
-0.0496656448,
0.0208158903,
-0.0110715441,
0.0272588693,
0.0226817504,
0.0467602015,
-0.0174880605,
-0.075728558,
0.0412095413,
-0.0152025372,
0.0194389001,
0.0670138225,
0.0274969488,
-0.0170367006,
0.0518386103,
0.0014453819,
-0.0130399447,
-0.0087143444,
-0.0911689103,
0.0404536985,
-0.0280256327,
0.0096604126,
-0.0294854101,
-0.0098749204,
0.0028917738,
0.0043400051,
-0.0109676942,
0.0365445018,
0.0442738719,
0.0486592911,
-0.0506190546,
0.0033344112,
-0.0306499526,
0.0023357861,
-0.0144005548,
0.0190488491,
0.05688015,
-0.0550133437,
-0.0131615633,
0.0066893008,
-0.0212146994,
-0.0148630543,
1.810783729e-34,
0.005673374,
0.0204351246,
-0.0292616989,
-0.0024407387,
0.0090687238,
-0.0194225777,
-0.0266887192,
0.0120364213,
-0.0473863892,
-0.052410692,
0.0130501594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15419v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15419v1 | Characterizing Learning Curves During Language Model Pre-Training: Learning, Forgetting, and Stability | 2023-08-29T16:24:09 | 2023-08-29T16:24:09 | Tyler A. Chang, Zhuowen Tu, Benjamin K. Bergen | cs.CL | cs.CL | How do language models learn to make predictions during pre-training? To
study this question, we extract learning curves from five autoregressive
English language model pre-training runs, for 1M tokens in context. We observe
that the language models generate short repetitive phrases before learning to
generate longer and more coherent text. We quantify the final surprisal,
within-run variability, age of acquisition, forgettability, and cross-run
variability of learning curves for individual tokens in context. More frequent
tokens reach lower final surprisals, exhibit less variability within and across
pre-training runs, are learned earlier, and are less likely to be "forgotten"
during pre-training. Higher n-gram probabilities further accentuate these
effects. Independent of the target token, shorter and more frequent contexts
correlate with marginally more stable and quickly acquired predictions. Effects
of part-of-speech are also small, although nouns tend to be acquired later and
less stably than verbs, adverbs, and adjectives. Our work contributes to a
better understanding of language model pre-training dynamics and informs the
deployment of stable language models in practice. | [
0.0027534526,
0.0406613462,
-0.0221730806,
-0.005882408,
-0.0348767266,
0.0006331042,
-0.0109359575,
-0.0078902524,
-0.0444989428,
-0.0624449626,
0.0036212066,
-0.0637094229,
0.0067056972,
0.0148563851,
0.0209926367,
-0.0343981199,
0.0758220479,
-0.0574498177,
-0.0110295368,
-0.027109148,
0.0181246437,
-0.0269658137,
-0.0100184856,
0.0445478484,
-0.0718960539,
-0.0137579683,
-0.0118610756,
-0.0408581831,
-0.0527386256,
-0.0391059332,
0.02748584,
0.0580073334,
0.0012755104,
0.013393173,
0.0000018812,
-0.0878454372,
-0.026540542,
-0.0144926254,
-0.0269547608,
0.0266914796,
0.0695306137,
0.0299111903,
-0.0171924531,
0.0421455987,
-0.0221310575,
-0.0064482051,
0.0368190147,
-0.0005015768,
0.0154805444,
0.0088972514,
-0.0026559955,
0.0095459241,
0.0169200785,
-0.0231364015,
0.0148618435,
-0.0490218401,
0.0206080768,
-0.017085636,
-0.0467076488,
-0.02495935,
-0.0481459796,
0.017613681,
0.0011249082,
0.0415069312,
-0.0116221309,
0.0700534731,
0.00461618,
-0.0283327345,
-0.0295578465,
-0.0058655036,
-0.0113720074,
-0.0443428829,
0.0108649684,
-0.0069661532,
0.0049802633,
0.001974233,
-0.0373714343,
0.0289983898,
0.0096666161,
0.0172404591,
0.0482240021,
-0.0554241277,
0.0080764825,
0.0003620478,
-0.0196572952,
0.0623178259,
0.0199172236,
-0.0576375499,
0.0202690624,
-0.0004789839,
-0.0213295463,
-0.0588330366,
-0.0040725684,
0.0228374582,
0.0135979522,
0.0691773966,
-0.0526308231,
-0.0004172576,
0.0328650847,
-0.0174081326,
0.0362065099,
0.0074407347,
-0.0162476003,
0.0118469326,
-0.0551788695,
0.0438848399,
0.0240895823,
-0.0146208256,
-0.0125986096,
0.0156580526,
-0.0459037051,
-0.0283211358,
-0.0690563247,
0.0314529091,
0.0226390734,
-0.0004458344,
-0.0586196929,
-0.0011865945,
0.0233279429,
-0.0380405858,
-0.0102679813,
-0.0071677733,
-0.0380002521,
0.0285789352,
-0.0536961369,
0.0016435474,
-0.0338551179,
0.0360466316,
0.0134796789,
-0.0560546927,
-0.0154221402,
-0.0271428581,
0.0185858048,
-0.0048819277,
0.0037287206,
0.0349830203,
-0.0065720566,
-0.0316386931,
-0.08838626,
-0.0429672226,
-0.0496905409,
-0.0489851013,
0.0001935819,
-0.0414033867,
-0.0282651298,
0.0466820858,
0.008400131,
-0.0516723022,
-0.0177333821,
0.0153655773,
-0.0417650416,
0.0280204117,
-0.0098687634,
0.036482852,
0.0109675853,
-0.0223504193,
0.0098895542,
0.0762653798,
0.0141862975,
-0.0091829086,
0.0312676616,
-0.0157405827,
-0.0073077781,
0.0519103669,
0.0613005608,
-0.000353763,
-0.027437849,
-0.056937322,
0.0337271281,
-0.0114158774,
0.0384547301,
0.048132401,
-0.0053797099,
0.0193921495,
0.0362523906,
0.0958978683,
0.0085552037,
0.0152027495,
0.0532694459,
-0.0155436285,
0.0236681867,
0.0337044112,
-0.0520042516,
-0.0161274169,
-0.0143183256,
0.0310536772,
-0.0086732684,
0.02233647,
-0.0157045741,
-0.0332659334,
-0.0455855057,
-0.0234201811,
0.0112301055,
-0.0390519947,
0.037115708,
0.037680611,
-0.0410519503,
0.0914620161,
0.0484514609,
-0.0438150689,
0.0173322894,
-0.0344848596,
0.0227264091,
0.0258447956,
0.0033847031,
0.0005648736,
-0.0216122009,
0.011335982,
0.0194598678,
-0.017293727,
0.0500414521,
0.0021860078,
0.0163637344,
-0.0291478708,
0.0011300592,
0.0221607387,
0.0385100506,
0.0021076892,
0.0209725462,
0.0228358097,
0.0033221089,
-0.0254374333,
-0.0504870191,
0.0534309819,
-0.0900351331,
-0.0167444777,
-0.0325981379,
-0.0005990048,
0.0395934694,
-0.024349317,
-0.0064338152,
0.0291761979,
0.0421030112,
0.0053841355,
0.0350106731,
0.0548322946,
-0.0837952644,
0.0186695009,
0.0633716285,
0.0552137718,
0.0433313474,
-0.0305033419,
0.0268381238,
-0.0331145115,
0.030454576,
-0.0233273506,
0.1035810113,
-0.017088173,
0.0633327737,
-0.0283707902,
0.0037860645,
-0.0198021363,
0.034779232,
-0.0223561153,
0.029024506,
-0.0201314799,
0.018695537,
0.0056021754,
-0.0096872812,
-0.0251770616,
-0.0240639132,
-0.0370983146,
0.0078671137,
0.0155945281,
-0.0264712404,
-0.062002033,
-0.0191518888,
-0.0683757588,
-0.0373674184,
-0.0030124062,
0.0203128252,
0.0149005428,
-0.0376412123,
-0.0371645838,
0.0090744551,
0.0025167442,
0.0203976426,
0.0060567297,
0.0515681431,
0.007619692,
-0.0093074106,
-0.0192509964,
-0.0563425794,
0.0021329131,
-0.0274008438,
0.0496291257,
-0.0144915432,
0.013956531,
-0.0372042842,
0.0653106198,
-0.0242770631,
0.0151721798,
0.0077988566,
-0.0604505874,
0.0244119968,
0.0151992626,
0.1092734709,
0.0456521697,
0.0124343671,
0.0589838736,
0.0427314751,
-0.0306387227,
-0.0358602777,
-0.0183163136,
-0.0281812269,
-0.0429114141,
-0.0298534781,
-0.0094182622,
0.0024907365,
0.1383682936,
0.023832757,
-0.0081241298,
-0.0244119558,
0.0219965652,
-0.081816107,
-0.0016493205,
-0.0097688809,
-0.0157697871,
-0.0645274743,
0.0383429751,
-0.0086170267,
-0.0802552849,
0.0408634134,
-0.0158396084,
0.0128635196,
-0.0436776057,
0.0168424491,
0.0081662722,
0.0412936956,
0.0151387155,
0.0091320528,
0.0468563624,
-0.0266183037,
-0.0480762534,
-0.0081998007,
0.0331051648,
-0.0193709712,
0.0694592819,
-0.0364078358,
0.0022088799,
0.0372771583,
0.0071032615,
-0.0582699515,
-0.0339321978,
-0.0392785035,
0.0051411772,
0.0270125195,
-0.0028837728,
0.0135961827,
-0.0092029013,
0.0025756147,
0.0262465104,
-0.0143103488,
-0.0008391773,
0.0050505856,
0.0059052613,
0.0354270376,
-0.025269758,
0.005459392,
-0.075219661,
0.0152066229,
0.0146394502,
0.0532335304,
0.0259403456,
-0.0256786682,
0.0149060423,
0.0092885066,
-0.0535552353,
-0.0227270443,
0.0755366609,
0.0424853973,
-0.0370881818,
-0.0580658391,
0.0796302631,
0.0278926603,
-0.0185282249,
0.0295604449,
-0.010164774,
0.0941099152,
0.0444220379,
-0.0105193201,
-0.0260694027,
-0.005547496,
0.0180923454,
0.0114113828,
0.0096810469,
-0.0021541549,
-0.0238837618,
-0.0920544565,
-0.0159377772,
0.0214080866,
-0.0876810029,
0.0653118342,
-0.0172302891,
-0.0190038271,
0.0004790074,
0.0412269607,
0.0351872146,
-0.0678973719,
0.0305207968,
0.0530531667,
-0.0452374108,
-0.0441573188,
0.002863111,
-0.0501707047,
0.0674708188,
0.0528409742,
-0.0172237139,
-0.0195195898,
-0.0332023501,
0.0980288386,
-0.0092930738,
0.0249306951,
-0.0189572554,
0.0261607431,
0.0173422284,
0.0148926359,
-0.0043229354,
0.0233710911,
-0.0027052071,
-0.03849319,
0.0120236715,
0.0550246425,
0.0336856022,
-0.0506688356,
0.0000417667,
0.0100262454,
-0.0099238744,
0.0907590389,
0.0467897281,
-0.05048576,
-0.0332142711,
-0.0155822178,
0.0536265224,
-0.0103892861,
-0.0307504013,
0.0179070346,
-0.045278158,
0.0194867533,
-0.0647541285,
-0.0179201122,
0.032425493,
0.0468018651,
0.0327225439,
0.0288946405,
0.0107434532,
-0.0110845538,
-0.0315615125,
0.0187018234,
-0.0058423439,
-0.0258542262,
-0.1106500924,
-0.0247050989,
0.0500430726,
-0.016196914,
-0.0336845741,
-0.0399836786,
-0.077954255,
-0.0594216213,
0.0884165913,
0.0310184807,
0.0297135413,
0.0404517241,
0.0387083553,
-0.038924329,
0.0577941574,
-0.0045562433,
-0.0189071968,
0.0266714282,
0.0152914869,
0.01053333,
-0.0014639795,
0.0112078674,
-0.0233321991,
0.0171651803,
0.0162793919,
0.0241702497,
0.0147265662,
0.009420258,
0.0277769659,
0.0071739089,
0.0311668757,
-0.0382149369,
-0.0158835817,
-0.035560891,
-0.02031512,
0.0367872231,
0.0202794094,
0.0062748855,
0.0093150055,
0.001896691,
0.016672777,
-0.0149907637,
-0.0393841937,
-0.0094515737,
0.0554692298,
0.0038177499,
-0.0497632474,
-0.0058127907,
0.0278122518,
0.0394713096,
0.0284580514,
-0.0165515933,
-0.0001451464,
-0.0596238151,
0.0171297677,
-0.0086924555,
0.0438827388,
-0.0173749551,
0.0127086835,
-0.0208559018,
-0.0201556757,
-0.0326702446,
-0.0000451257,
-0.0296569336,
-0.0018462832,
0.050009653,
-0.0600116178,
0.0474597774,
-0.0496036038,
0.0291042179,
-0.0322076567,
-0.0135766808,
-0.0292080678,
-0.0147497458,
0.0310886633,
-0.0046552527,
-0.037627507,
-0.0058863447,
0.080605939,
0.0442503802,
0.0450767465,
0.0116896741,
0.0194324404,
-0.0147359362,
0.0083191684,
0.0029824572,
0.0026856372,
-0.0336132161,
0.0016737243,
-0.0712703615,
-0.049815964,
-0.001230907,
-0.010844755,
0.0194539148,
-0.0182183404,
0.0344524868,
0.0792747363,
-0.0441057235,
0.0084068561,
-0.0239177812,
0.0029748781,
0.0259319935,
0.0172676835,
-0.0211788565,
-6.516609338e-33,
-0.0101681324,
0.0023713864,
0.0182848219,
-0.0064933072,
-0.0075640972,
0.0176848881,
-0.0343100503,
0.0330664702,
-0.0091294413,
0.0037549776,
-0.0229477696,
-0.0195512194,
0.0128287692,
0.0084753856,
0.0291372519,
-0.0091198012,
0.0394929126,
-0.0362275727,
-0.0156257115,
0.0024558278,
0.0387248285,
0.0466754697,
0.0534250475,
-0.0034925276,
0.0224367119,
0.0267657414,
0.0166702829,
-0.0084947143,
-0.0191048719,
0.0729581788,
-0.0223480742,
0.0214773975,
0.0294017512,
-0.021655146,
-0.0525965318,
-0.0203581098,
-0.0652085766,
-0.0383860432,
0.0493763164,
-0.0062062116,
-0.0169616379,
-0.027571125,
0.0444575325,
-0.0309241898,
-0.0664039999,
0.0152299041,
0.0213839076,
0.0110944305,
-0.0415685847,
-0.0177401081,
-0.0513698831,
-0.0136178592,
0.0294360034,
-0.0171361398,
-0.0071102665,
-0.0243047215,
0.0051885215,
-0.0058416128,
-0.0325878076,
0.0311979298,
0.0214937776,
0.0726677999,
0.0279534906,
0.0156250764,
0.0233134143,
0.0641662255,
0.0507043935,
0.0157564618,
0.0345977694,
-0.0091229891,
0.0998207852,
0.0090758214,
0.006531612,
-0.0233200509,
0.0830152929,
-0.0650909171,
-0.0241184942,
-0.0280958023,
0.0194276143,
0.0664560795,
0.0269872416,
0.0021634535,
-0.0297698285,
-0.0480024703,
-0.0593837425,
-0.012259814,
-0.0258516297,
-0.0366862454,
0.0489869714,
0.0187276583,
0.0037655775,
-0.0465042107,
0.0225189961,
-0.0014449818,
-0.059465982,
0.0094056064,
-0.0090748658,
-0.002521358,
-0.0280388128,
0.0547685698,
-0.0792637691,
-0.0267562084,
-0.0285885669,
0.0145360585,
0.0026926761,
0.0280715674,
-0.0030280352,
0.0269647222,
-0.0756671205,
0.0110448115,
-0.0251936261,
0.0220249072,
0.0341965295,
-0.030241156,
0.0592635386,
0.0179401208,
0.0023039926,
0.0482857935,
0.0324917473,
-0.0436257459,
-0.0511914268,
0.0022043695,
0.0016270174,
0.0765005946,
-0.0215548836,
-0.0288272277,
-0.0360382311,
0.0392967127,
0.0634085312,
-0.0314796418,
-0.0037749286,
0.0120557388,
2.554e-7,
0.0116969673,
0.0749075189,
0.0150194298,
-0.033250235,
0.0353420153,
0.0056190901,
-0.0586664267,
-0.0252784491,
0.0119893448,
0.0228437055,
-0.0525679924,
-0.0029307916,
0.0244062077,
0.0159087386,
-0.0480316803,
-0.0374218114,
-0.0872146413,
0.0592152365,
-0.0338265896,
0.0298779625,
0.0046276152,
0.0603418089,
-0.0024633636,
-0.0047432724,
-0.0341026038,
-0.0535312369,
0.0431797691,
-0.0270154178,
0.0114924526,
0.0255770497,
-0.010474666,
0.0355884135,
0.0252672229,
0.0043943767,
-0.0350555964,
0.0288299657,
-0.0427542366,
0.0140287513,
0.0144250225,
-0.0135293324,
0.0201985836,
0.0061492971,
-0.0348832309,
-0.0444173962,
0.0507077575,
-0.0537270606,
0.0033877036,
-0.0494979434,
-0.0016264237,
-0.0057917354,
0.0120106675,
-0.0049610003,
-0.0257468559,
0.0142627647,
0.0118780807,
0.0396404825,
-0.0284359325,
-0.0567117408,
-0.0312204342,
0.0499617606,
0.0010036943,
-0.0530745573,
-0.0477070212,
0.01024816,
0.0172180366,
-0.0697793663,
-0.0015136494,
2.440964759e-34,
0.0446290933,
-0.0355306789,
0.0555664375,
0.0538412817,
0.0130075244,
-0.0368865766,
0.0785856247,
0.0398846343,
0.0125227133,
-0.0288022216,
-0.0070571457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15399v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15399v2 | Rethinking Machine Ethics -- Can LLMs Perform Moral Reasoning through the Lens of Moral Theories? | 2023-08-29T15:57:32 | 2024-07-01T15:33:51 | Jingyan Zhou, Minda Hu, Junan Li, Xiaoying Zhang, Xixin Wu, Irwin King, Helen Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Making moral judgments is an essential step toward developing ethical AI
systems. Prevalent approaches are mostly implemented in a bottom-up manner,
which uses a large set of annotated data to train models based on crowd-sourced
opinions about morality. These approaches have been criticized for
overgeneralizing the moral stances of a limited group of annotators and lacking
explainability. This work proposes a flexible top-down framework to steer
(Large) Language Models (LMs) to perform moral reasoning with well-established
moral theories from interdisciplinary research. The theory-guided top-down
framework can incorporate various moral theories. Our experiments demonstrate
the effectiveness of the proposed framework on datasets derived from moral
theories. Furthermore, we show the alignment between different moral theories
and existing morality datasets. Our analysis exhibits the potential and flaws
in existing resources (models and datasets) in developing explainable moral
judgment-making systems. | [
0.0529221892,
0.106550701,
-0.0273433644,
0.0502736829,
-0.0486228243,
0.0161657017,
0.0282919109,
-0.0195274223,
-0.0190408584,
-0.0268587228,
-0.0346052125,
-0.0196955074,
-0.0069102515,
-0.0066265892,
-0.0152364047,
-0.0056317295,
0.0169061385,
0.0090845395,
0.0768822357,
-0.0118946601,
0.0147183295,
0.0489178635,
0.0541073941,
0.0053474982,
0.0176873561,
0.0226077549,
-0.0093116891,
-0.0174794588,
0.0327349603,
0.0074778134,
0.0073520616,
0.0151887266,
0.0505048707,
0.0075293966,
0.0000017077,
-0.0225390382,
0.0023969163,
0.0369913094,
0.0325180069,
0.0079029333,
0.0853742361,
-0.0164124649,
0.0215441287,
0.0072099948,
-0.0368278548,
0.0545236655,
0.0233246461,
0.0412877612,
0.0256642476,
0.0693908259,
-0.0012176947,
-0.0247297753,
0.0156084206,
0.0007637094,
-0.0079674227,
-0.0232401919,
0.0287473816,
0.0445025638,
-0.0154774636,
0.0188089553,
0.0034713948,
-0.016675951,
0.0158673115,
-0.0205764063,
-0.0258412436,
-0.0498186164,
-0.0167264827,
-0.0315180011,
0.0002008694,
0.0503257737,
0.0159350503,
-0.0320150852,
0.0425747596,
-0.0024159169,
0.0006359816,
-0.0220135767,
0.0233656578,
0.068724364,
-0.0255963113,
0.0385737866,
0.0460380986,
0.0001758018,
0.041875124,
0.0801676959,
0.0420737565,
-0.0117736151,
-0.0433018357,
-0.0141090211,
0.0258423742,
-0.0014144538,
-0.0461810157,
0.0258710161,
0.0113895871,
0.0308518969,
-0.0040896554,
0.041400414,
0.0077773267,
0.0643245876,
0.0479068123,
-0.0361878946,
0.030201938,
0.0349610634,
0.022181157,
0.026956154,
0.0279686525,
0.0174993202,
0.0002960321,
0.0472712368,
-0.0324984901,
-0.0008886077,
-0.0040837377,
0.0171892755,
0.0360526368,
0.0294622313,
-0.003089994,
0.0721644983,
-0.0169221442,
-0.0092476057,
-0.0628763065,
-0.0160773899,
-0.0118196784,
0.0227921866,
0.0056390944,
-0.0222442504,
-0.0538852662,
-0.0163608994,
-0.0420587622,
0.023165945,
-0.0111930845,
-0.0001898384,
0.0364834778,
-0.0151263895,
-0.0368385985,
0.0164014529,
0.0439876318,
0.1111921966,
0.0247453935,
-0.0068848161,
-0.0292030759,
-0.0175150931,
-0.0246323254,
-0.0596579202,
-0.0188143421,
-0.0179403722,
0.0134249497,
-0.0153763248,
-0.0349378251,
-0.0423683152,
0.0354351066,
0.0351660624,
-0.0466569364,
0.0660534278,
0.0079273386,
-0.0011438053,
-0.0095222434,
0.0200269166,
-0.0086946608,
0.0325705037,
0.0197321381,
0.0208248105,
0.0498726703,
-0.0084782997,
-0.0041131773,
-0.0415656343,
0.0079807099,
0.0235370528,
-0.0527178235,
0.0111319004,
-0.0777550787,
0.0141300345,
0.0138903372,
0.0492607281,
0.0138467718,
-0.0251908321,
0.0298828166,
0.1015779227,
-0.020033611,
0.0184371062,
0.0452449881,
-0.0112753762,
0.0023606189,
-0.0226738248,
-0.0635366887,
0.0090202419,
-0.0026124106,
-0.0333102606,
-0.0623031855,
0.026669126,
-0.0119573437,
-0.0725982115,
0.0028828867,
-0.0276365075,
0.0343731865,
0.0205971133,
0.0054044151,
-0.0209840462,
-0.0046269353,
-0.080797635,
0.0611889139,
-0.0702055022,
0.0031763802,
-0.0609468929,
0.0965080708,
0.0973268151,
0.0703286454,
-0.025608629,
-0.0188620724,
-0.0409611277,
-0.023255175,
0.0044301222,
0.0095421588,
-0.0296332892,
-0.0132185938,
-0.0697932094,
-0.0373494811,
-0.010543853,
-0.0163565632,
0.0062444033,
-0.0261071175,
-0.0479072779,
0.0177229736,
-0.0061887791,
-0.0362669565,
0.0562484413,
0.0120921247,
0.0545665249,
-0.0456766225,
0.0059200702,
0.0235872939,
-0.0121359639,
-0.0027035766,
-0.028102912,
0.0175114609,
0.0271161981,
0.0044073476,
-0.0225947406,
-0.0231479779,
0.0235572141,
0.0117097581,
-0.079501614,
-0.0156542119,
0.0341681987,
-0.020627318,
0.0500319675,
-0.0818283036,
-0.0233922601,
0.0034970888,
-0.0609448403,
-0.0136359511,
-0.0760570467,
-0.026284365,
-0.0137353614,
0.0680700019,
-0.044132188,
0.0181277115,
-0.0013163612,
-0.0265858229,
0.0346326157,
0.005534065,
-0.0280324854,
-0.0102479439,
-0.0233948156,
0.0454496145,
0.027365366,
0.0603758991,
0.0004992198,
-0.0421355963,
-0.0621192418,
-0.0179937705,
0.0303792153,
-0.0143640796,
-0.015925115,
-0.0227222871,
0.017332403,
0.0293419026,
-0.0291482266,
0.0209311657,
0.0017611944,
-0.0029086452,
0.0484784357,
-0.0389607586,
-0.0133760571,
-0.0314483047,
-0.0042308276,
-0.0256317221,
-0.0103980014,
0.0151696708,
0.0143259503,
-0.0382081866,
0.0527066961,
-0.0807370096,
-0.0085186483,
-0.0028950346,
-0.0722554773,
-0.0226576813,
0.0494297296,
-0.037984509,
0.0763081014,
0.0458878092,
0.0439332873,
0.0287696756,
0.092567265,
-0.0269038789,
-0.025445139,
0.0027370485,
0.0137974853,
-0.0468509868,
-0.0322236232,
-0.0356164239,
0.0534646437,
-0.0185513888,
-0.0050684144,
-0.0407025777,
0.040511854,
-0.0326572843,
-0.0667849258,
0.0049416889,
-0.0768320039,
-0.003688453,
0.0464171171,
-0.0508334488,
-0.0589165762,
0.0766509399,
0.0349395424,
0.0235589352,
0.0220134817,
-0.0069492473,
-0.0226556081,
0.0174983777,
0.0079059387,
0.0270604771,
-0.0229207445,
0.0032596332,
-0.0067647304,
0.0065271584,
0.0320245437,
-0.0414486267,
0.0628459677,
-0.0367524102,
0.0110197086,
0.0309210103,
-0.0642422289,
-0.0373542868,
-0.0422840752,
-0.0292397961,
-0.0376804285,
0.0140960189,
-0.0116271283,
0.0474842303,
-0.0152240759,
0.0220814701,
-0.0524926484,
0.0028485788,
0.0093631158,
-0.0150530534,
-0.0779488161,
0.0043802876,
-0.0200651232,
0.0566619895,
0.0280764624,
0.0314299576,
0.0117341327,
0.0064891912,
0.0060073151,
0.0231182259,
0.036620982,
-0.005940997,
0.0230969079,
-0.0009396749,
0.0171857104,
0.0429338925,
0.0124782184,
0.0253539905,
0.0811182335,
0.0045863576,
-0.0584968664,
0.0169474892,
0.0065865288,
-0.0302515756,
0.0149707319,
-0.0037028748,
-0.0551117957,
-0.010142223,
-0.0146596879,
0.0317706093,
-0.0756089091,
-0.0691884607,
0.0294476841,
-0.0821913704,
0.0171212554,
0.0056489198,
0.0012492314,
-0.0695291683,
-0.0315046832,
-0.009291199,
-0.0490912013,
0.0353803895,
0.0144106979,
0.0119976224,
-0.0476400293,
0.0161253698,
0.0324148834,
0.0057994192,
0.0855610669,
-0.025545828,
0.0759731531,
0.0738658234,
0.0744489655,
-0.0377945602,
-0.04918826,
-0.014074753,
0.0303659681,
0.0074631167,
0.0341610722,
0.0213630162,
-0.0286852792,
0.0002055224,
-0.0536710285,
0.0322575457,
0.0026079668,
-0.0266689043,
-0.0178296678,
0.0635466874,
0.0051356605,
-0.0405285656,
-0.0036603941,
0.0160193257,
-0.0211816374,
0.0767159238,
-0.002548317,
-0.0431881696,
0.0109625598,
-0.0382209122,
-0.0493494309,
-0.0286052395,
-0.0576088019,
-0.0204014461,
-0.0083291689,
-0.0216854308,
-0.0417780317,
-0.0576238073,
-0.0399548002,
-0.0189092085,
0.0453786403,
-0.0657770634,
0.0361804813,
0.0226222705,
-0.0142144542,
0.0075016236,
-0.0186976809,
-0.0191579852,
0.0107138921,
0.0273386016,
0.0134107973,
-0.0338144749,
0.0041076378,
-0.0126400338,
0.0381766893,
-0.028427761,
0.036507871,
0.0497010201,
0.0082051298,
0.021058755,
-0.0408635288,
-0.0038943454,
0.0088423835,
0.0444599278,
-0.0982384607,
0.03168476,
0.0741183683,
0.020879373,
-0.0193619318,
0.0217754822,
-0.0283818878,
0.0102848476,
0.0202941541,
-0.0383501761,
-0.0374092348,
0.0069458135,
0.0362012386,
0.0262318626,
0.0023597232,
-0.0039570793,
-0.0204097759,
-0.0510150939,
-0.046282392,
-0.0127537511,
-0.0491270199,
-0.0327417329,
0.0191708971,
0.0431679599,
-0.0341511779,
-0.0243545566,
-0.008745824,
-0.0528770834,
-0.0152576603,
0.0011732861,
0.0201885719,
-0.0050333277,
0.0950358063,
-0.029867541,
0.0048247948,
-0.0351275504,
0.0377431251,
-0.0205515735,
0.013644984,
-0.0205759611,
0.077087,
0.0289635248,
0.0100922212,
0.0051278421,
0.0110228723,
-0.0698344335,
-0.0016937257,
-0.0331362002,
-0.0123315845,
-0.0286287498,
0.0509903617,
0.0091950689,
0.0143634705,
-0.0042651827,
-0.0095299501,
0.0417007394,
0.001286187,
-0.0256975833,
-0.0157952681,
0.0288359523,
-0.0313699655,
0.0028800534,
0.0314481594,
-0.0381524116,
0.0163493399,
0.0281927045,
-0.0193120055,
-0.005841183,
-0.0334206335,
0.0552966259,
-0.0167562421,
0.0133980103,
-0.0136692384,
-0.0493092723,
-0.0440544561,
-0.0445171483,
0.0141193056,
0.0152114127,
-0.0276664533,
-0.021427419,
0.0698279515,
-0.0350772031,
0.0337519795,
-0.0692051649,
0.0122759063,
-0.010988065,
0.0239950325,
-0.062721923,
-4.655177667e-33,
-0.0103051942,
-0.0185888279,
-0.0288462508,
-0.0074982299,
-0.0156817306,
-0.0229198467,
0.0244076978,
0.0003758885,
-0.0655095354,
0.0602208264,
-0.0068042385,
0.0469507128,
-0.014522762,
-0.0087928167,
0.0004768541,
-0.0661172792,
-0.0060234084,
-0.001676978,
-0.0143579086,
0.0406842716,
-0.0139126424,
-0.0199554414,
0.0278906338,
-0.0735471398,
0.0707509667,
0.0215906333,
-0.0314769186,
0.0231618006,
-0.0424875878,
0.0346604399,
-0.0024021016,
0.0707150996,
0.0266226195,
-0.0075436649,
0.0104425438,
0.03452456,
-0.0067700199,
0.0156871341,
0.0527458116,
-0.0179086309,
-0.0181264859,
-0.0649375841,
0.0131118493,
-0.0144115323,
-0.0246113203,
0.0135437576,
0.0539297909,
-0.0330411717,
0.0226501264,
-0.0217356794,
-0.0380041637,
-0.0094580958,
-0.0532534793,
-0.0308017209,
-0.0466007553,
0.0278151166,
-0.0245591942,
0.0629294068,
0.0404566899,
0.0341159403,
0.0001839937,
-0.0462212823,
0.01434475,
-0.0566037856,
0.0258629527,
0.0850021988,
-0.0058853561,
0.0262102745,
-0.0645320117,
-0.0188774038,
-0.0100157019,
0.0425858758,
0.0600688867,
0.0543339662,
-0.0324365124,
-0.0575455129,
-0.0363884121,
-0.0194044989,
0.0284113828,
-0.027602464,
0.009683921,
-0.018944392,
-0.0413357429,
0.0099576265,
-0.0337313525,
-0.1043781936,
-0.0181761906,
-0.0087527484,
-0.00278005,
-0.0372593477,
-0.0497196652,
-0.025780376,
-0.0203959197,
-0.0610157624,
0.0550257191,
0.053972993,
0.0132153397,
-0.0218595378,
0.0022474932,
0.0134811876,
-0.0292476658,
-0.0312592871,
0.0156954397,
-0.012883909,
0.0454092026,
-0.0265232511,
0.0699302256,
0.0172468945,
0.0097672436,
-0.0173071641,
-0.0435538106,
0.0110088335,
0.0062842644,
-0.0251246486,
-0.0122314543,
0.0497079976,
-0.0007316576,
-0.0011451985,
0.0148544786,
0.0079862196,
-0.0395529568,
-0.0300874617,
-0.0236625299,
0.0288401619,
-0.0170829967,
-0.0170949604,
-0.0313290507,
0.0247658007,
0.0216051452,
-0.0378370062,
-0.0240908116,
0.0429772027,
2.274e-7,
0.0237272885,
-0.0073338873,
0.0150384121,
0.0035123152,
-0.0422990918,
0.0512538627,
0.058753524,
0.0494099818,
0.0264198408,
-0.0673350692,
0.0309538618,
0.0382165574,
0.0498097129,
-0.0097872596,
0.0110504506,
-0.0188616645,
-0.0210384373,
-0.0556455031,
-0.0289287344,
0.0599102676,
0.0298073962,
0.0757681727,
0.0451927669,
-0.0161878932,
0.0312525108,
0.0220819823,
0.0104718702,
-0.0767779052,
-0.0421541333,
-0.0082829436,
-0.0245415457,
-0.0130162518,
0.0128558893,
0.0048116855,
0.0328546166,
0.0011790023,
0.0117912423,
0.0626469627,
-0.03260478,
-0.0373784155,
-0.0203802511,
-0.0220530257,
-0.0048136488,
0.0023718772,
0.0721774623,
0.001702436,
-0.0132143311,
-0.0216423888,
0.0341025852,
-0.0406094268,
-0.0035526194,
-0.0027499753,
-0.0012472272,
-0.0045591919,
-0.0048803296,
-0.0161029696,
0.0117407665,
-0.0474264733,
0.0095157698,
-0.0185772832,
0.0128160408,
-0.0752998441,
0.0488057397,
0.0179247838,
0.0570387915,
-0.0632589906,
0.0135631505,
1.621033227e-34,
0.0132568805,
-0.0458379127,
0.0146582387,
0.0160860904,
0.0634523481,
0.0736221075,
-0.012901783,
0.0007671625,
0.031125769,
-0.0193615146,
-0.0088022156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15363v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15363v4 | Text-to-SQL Empowered by Large Language Models: A Benchmark Evaluation | 2023-08-29T14:59:54 | 2023-11-20T13:59:16 | Dawei Gao, Haibin Wang, Yaliang Li, Xiuyu Sun, Yichen Qian, Bolin Ding, Jingren Zhou | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as a new paradigm for Text-to-SQL
task. However, the absence of a systematical benchmark inhibits the development
of designing effective, efficient and economic LLM-based Text-to-SQL solutions.
To address this challenge, in this paper, we first conduct a systematical and
extensive comparison over existing prompt engineering methods, including
question representation, example selection and example organization, and with
these experimental results, we elaborate their pros and cons. Based on these
findings, we propose a new integrated solution, named DAIL-SQL, which refreshes
the Spider leaderboard with 86.6% execution accuracy and sets a new bar. To
explore the potential of open-source LLM, we investigate them in various
scenarios, and further enhance their performance with supervised fine-tuning.
Our explorations highlight open-source LLMs' potential in Text-to-SQL, as well
as the advantages and disadvantages of the supervised fine-tuning.
Additionally, towards an efficient and economic LLM-based Text-to-SQL solution,
we emphasize the token efficiency in prompt engineering and compare the prior
studies under this metric. We hope that our work provides a deeper
understanding of Text-to-SQL with LLMs, and inspires further investigations and
broad applications. | [
0.0228907559,
0.0428027064,
-0.0171818566,
0.0212250128,
-0.0441110171,
0.0032707741,
0.0128382547,
0.0243861992,
0.041835472,
-0.0528172664,
-0.0030412811,
-0.0232648887,
-0.0368514992,
0.0652235597,
0.0421040431,
-0.0541664027,
0.0372038372,
-0.0275675002,
-0.0243022628,
0.0232742503,
-0.0173499025,
0.0097309183,
0.0031989128,
-0.0044721579,
0.0091848662,
-0.0108142691,
-0.0322590172,
0.0312233083,
-0.0251534227,
-0.0311672743,
-0.0556988083,
0.0429184586,
0.0091328761,
0.02044167,
0.0000020001,
-0.0846058577,
-0.0589587875,
0.0100380508,
-0.0707442164,
0.0187870525,
0.0194074567,
0.0022245101,
0.0097845877,
0.0563971512,
-0.0195336584,
-0.0137760108,
0.0214078985,
0.006254808,
0.0698127523,
0.0811744481,
-0.0133562321,
-0.0121664004,
-0.0008736829,
-0.0087555554,
0.031186318,
-0.0301275086,
0.0153145222,
0.0216867495,
0.0721695721,
0.0313306153,
0.0014617976,
0.0177599769,
-0.0100589572,
-0.0362263918,
0.0097877961,
-0.0068721236,
-0.0401910618,
0.0237040017,
-0.013702604,
0.0511508137,
-0.0016941444,
-0.0066541969,
0.0145087251,
-0.0069115874,
0.0163016636,
0.016085634,
-0.0314712934,
0.0170733519,
0.0028207412,
-0.0230552424,
-0.0223842151,
-0.0046437997,
-0.0150880888,
-0.0101816049,
-0.0656115264,
0.0313495323,
0.0038989491,
-0.0361110792,
0.0340011232,
-0.0341589898,
-0.0033239287,
-0.0481143333,
0.0507374369,
0.0500607342,
-0.0905704647,
0.0285052713,
-0.03812363,
-0.0245734043,
0.0230456032,
-0.0254458133,
0.0220235363,
0.0502058789,
0.0068888194,
0.0631160513,
-0.0022076943,
0.0487380438,
0.0412977785,
0.0127688423,
-0.0425945595,
-0.0167923756,
-0.0542997569,
0.0183036234,
-0.0681631491,
0.0361305438,
-0.0776955187,
-0.0102869486,
-0.0044697057,
0.0485055372,
0.0306317098,
0.0644048154,
0.0475094989,
0.0011192106,
0.0055036061,
0.0014311762,
-0.0469096713,
-0.0255037863,
-0.0130461054,
-0.02347547,
0.0117369667,
-0.0731018111,
-0.0072936472,
0.0066641984,
0.013649663,
-0.0281879622,
0.0217946284,
0.073961854,
-0.0162054542,
0.0059740432,
-0.0458627529,
-0.0611481778,
-0.0320320018,
0.0141898943,
-0.0437088422,
-0.0538852923,
0.0627828911,
0.0211355723,
-0.0170534179,
-0.0087088011,
-0.0008018107,
0.0489983447,
0.0004079452,
0.0427918956,
-0.0257163141,
0.0274218805,
0.037359789,
-0.0191693567,
0.0023172235,
0.0465818867,
-0.0046122042,
0.0505663976,
0.021607887,
-0.0203571375,
0.0018610918,
0.0557946227,
-0.0013598531,
0.0160463918,
-0.0603649914,
0.08055114,
0.0320125483,
0.0600868575,
-0.0247264262,
0.0756476969,
0.0216026977,
0.0142771062,
0.0661757886,
0.0478261486,
0.0261254758,
-0.0004217321,
0.0293973181,
0.0397056453,
0.0032748824,
-0.0434888713,
-0.023363363,
0.0142209465,
0.0062548826,
0.0265779719,
0.0418222174,
0.0013561846,
-0.0335268416,
-0.0290389266,
-0.0119839385,
0.0037804714,
-0.0571887903,
0.0459838249,
0.0148508083,
0.0065345629,
-0.0337366611,
0.019387288,
-0.0241958108,
-0.0318818539,
0.0119865024,
-0.0226479582,
-0.026420081,
0.0841492563,
0.0331067964,
-0.0484522916,
-0.0047056484,
-0.025341168,
0.0207947623,
0.0280747823,
0.0433616564,
-0.0213185493,
-0.0365395136,
-0.0240156446,
-0.0062273475,
0.054061383,
-0.0018983559,
-0.009878844,
0.0079006813,
-0.0041790069,
0.0011652831,
-0.0219161082,
-0.0582483374,
0.0259980541,
-0.0149931274,
-0.0351562649,
0.02431852,
0.0004228173,
-0.001828689,
0.0378473736,
-0.0165913571,
0.0380901471,
0.0385570191,
-0.0032689075,
-0.0294731278,
-0.0551778972,
-0.0030352823,
-0.0309643727,
0.0185019486,
-0.0029741924,
-0.0120293926,
-0.0221685581,
-0.0529779159,
-0.0506551564,
-0.0442471355,
-0.0227147415,
-0.0114422338,
-0.0323660672,
0.0402832553,
-0.0142204808,
-0.0554534756,
-0.075769335,
0.0537820086,
0.0178493727,
0.0258077811,
0.0121966917,
-0.0294681545,
0.0169654023,
-0.0809746981,
0.0345903002,
0.0216239877,
-0.0126161352,
0.0200943556,
-0.0249305256,
0.0003484253,
-0.057585746,
-0.0245753229,
-0.0849991366,
0.0362372585,
-0.0191187244,
0.0265918579,
0.0290038325,
0.0397492237,
-0.0181316901,
-0.0092137437,
-0.0756926984,
-0.0381378159,
0.016976051,
0.0224552322,
0.0318408534,
0.0014356981,
0.0038263623,
-0.0175652299,
-0.0286989901,
-0.0329256319,
0.0454288684,
-0.0356232524,
-0.0446237773,
-0.0256343111,
0.04269851,
-0.0055296971,
0.0012962378,
0.0192657635,
0.023864286,
-0.0057325526,
-0.0346024372,
0.0500979573,
0.0455880091,
0.021073712,
-0.0471660011,
-0.0057705585,
-0.0061706295,
-0.0439111441,
0.0009712212,
0.0058204718,
-0.0027128805,
0.0178069472,
-0.0502339713,
0.0561134405,
0.000902647,
0.0118151894,
-0.0138542755,
-0.0144164674,
0.0043403893,
0.0244258288,
0.0285238866,
-0.0938554183,
-0.0061955191,
-0.0074579525,
0.0184927564,
0.0022901597,
0.0014148434,
0.0562932044,
-0.035334222,
0.0060068509,
-0.0403163768,
-0.0080353543,
-0.0707275942,
0.0561368391,
0.0085368119,
0.0364645422,
-0.0434217229,
-0.0679943785,
-0.0465158485,
-0.0139708286,
-0.0017319269,
-0.0302197356,
0.0852277353,
-0.0271839984,
-0.0094684204,
-0.0240200534,
-0.0240705851,
-0.0281241089,
-0.0321772918,
-0.0392246321,
0.0337129161,
0.0524999462,
0.0022984194,
-0.0070534605,
0.007005773,
0.005620054,
0.047029011,
-0.0119125508,
-0.0194965005,
-0.0115684438,
-0.0004796885,
0.0095522441,
0.0227062888,
0.0127065126,
-0.0308031552,
0.0617613681,
0.0348011591,
0.0449197963,
-0.0452061705,
0.0209948719,
0.007274223,
-0.0064113229,
-0.0649273619,
-0.0182143375,
0.0492677875,
-0.0123642059,
-0.0382269993,
-0.0032091436,
0.103213273,
0.0472504124,
0.0151149984,
-0.0133561566,
0.0081058554,
0.0314171724,
0.0416664965,
0.0674990267,
-0.0917262062,
-0.0235996917,
-0.011031935,
0.0437575653,
0.0177756399,
-0.0442852639,
-0.0217863359,
-0.1341904253,
0.0233244579,
-0.0230901353,
-0.0386406891,
0.0206538551,
-0.0162352882,
-0.0184337664,
0.0119405892,
-0.0114014242,
0.092125617,
-0.0302929152,
-0.0111336894,
0.0139791574,
-0.0158357732,
-0.0318234414,
0.0143773463,
-0.0422792807,
0.0174848251,
0.0546637513,
0.0076525016,
0.0306868274,
-0.0113999741,
0.0369567648,
-0.0247288458,
0.0001486958,
-0.0199786481,
0.0745137781,
0.000318335,
0.0091547128,
0.0110239983,
0.00533809,
-0.0161819328,
0.0297967345,
0.0465212166,
0.0951081067,
-0.0272119939,
0.0432130694,
-0.0056897216,
-0.0381380208,
0.0047894549,
0.0688361675,
0.010757952,
-0.0505778715,
-0.0580586866,
-0.0257956199,
-0.0313129611,
-0.0478867069,
-0.0028676318,
0.0436283946,
-0.0411161445,
-0.048442971,
-0.0395187251,
-0.0113059981,
0.0851675719,
0.0687233284,
0.0154058607,
0.0259450153,
0.0045372662,
-0.0104542878,
-0.0109539293,
-0.0214454923,
-0.0515238941,
0.0189588275,
-0.0840075761,
0.0262498576,
0.0104841078,
-0.0572633259,
-0.0091932882,
-0.0486494116,
-0.0356676467,
-0.0207327195,
0.0111476928,
0.0068344437,
0.0234756898,
-0.0361037999,
0.0128931953,
-0.0617258586,
0.0019093718,
0.0473813154,
-0.0207575317,
-0.0426104814,
-0.0436078757,
0.02669123,
-0.018158149,
0.0111086359,
-0.0605309904,
0.0001795906,
-0.0143446391,
0.0052967402,
-0.0013383082,
-0.0085704299,
0.053022448,
0.0784425735,
-0.008036769,
0.0332432315,
-0.0364168324,
0.0032511631,
0.0666846931,
-0.0770072863,
-0.0607038438,
-0.014309749,
0.0148520479,
0.0153761161,
-0.0108694471,
0.027883945,
-0.0068273898,
-0.0179102886,
0.0583719574,
-0.0314564705,
0.0009047058,
0.0075463839,
0.0213457793,
0.047277838,
-0.0288226064,
-0.0202462617,
0.0502280183,
0.0168500077,
0.0637671575,
-0.0235015899,
0.0382953472,
0.0125968065,
-0.0033977644,
-0.0148734767,
0.0075396588,
-0.0620070994,
-0.0509874523,
-0.0086244354,
0.0350684635,
0.0130685354,
0.0004142853,
-0.0113245621,
-0.0006109395,
-0.0208990816,
-0.0333232768,
-0.0103412429,
0.0621591061,
-0.0096629038,
0.0271326248,
0.0208682232,
-0.0225272141,
-0.0294054318,
0.0399093479,
-0.0085719051,
-0.0168663785,
0.0071340492,
-0.0538904779,
-0.0470408127,
-0.0046250848,
0.0347441398,
0.0077619003,
-0.023686897,
-0.0519195683,
-0.0684041977,
0.0032535235,
0.0363976397,
0.0285843164,
-0.0109185232,
-0.0070811342,
0.0679195151,
0.0658175051,
0.0541341379,
-0.0015687007,
-0.0463351868,
0.0306914002,
-0.0326621123,
-0.0649981722,
0.0092698494,
-5.550445185e-33,
-0.038103018,
-0.0592832156,
0.0279836003,
-0.0094496775,
0.0260218158,
-0.0286844,
-0.0054582893,
-0.0137281585,
-0.0291181244,
-0.0124229211,
-0.0428174324,
0.0080100447,
0.0408934653,
0.0365159586,
0.0231287684,
-0.0252897721,
0.0385752991,
-0.0244815163,
-0.0020258264,
0.0051503913,
0.0458178073,
0.0225203428,
-0.0129921148,
-0.0112150339,
0.0281454567,
-0.0134348217,
0.0140381781,
0.029408941,
0.0225512311,
0.0198257491,
0.0017778149,
0.0160270799,
0.0137435105,
-0.0318820998,
-0.0106267333,
0.0038050141,
-0.0642819256,
-0.0303603075,
0.0061837165,
-0.0143722352,
-0.0014742259,
-0.0117646148,
0.0330124199,
-0.0432136767,
-0.032325279,
0.0104702432,
0.0020037531,
-0.0343578979,
-0.0321176946,
-0.0542605817,
-0.0166080315,
0.0214377567,
0.0321473964,
0.0195512045,
0.0096374517,
0.0638369098,
-0.0072274413,
0.029721139,
-0.0205539446,
0.0367758013,
0.0342024527,
0.0549237393,
0.0415529162,
0.0511417203,
-0.0257052258,
0.0031534277,
0.0243849959,
0.0167816281,
0.0240791477,
0.045888558,
-0.0226012822,
0.0463372692,
0.0548323542,
0.0458220281,
-0.0029904218,
-0.0043891426,
-0.0728470311,
0.0518641062,
-0.0069598015,
-0.0328948721,
0.0074592354,
0.0048374897,
-0.0631206408,
-0.0435290895,
-0.0376370437,
0.0587257594,
-0.0558035858,
-0.0233027935,
0.0635718256,
-0.0317364521,
-0.0095494948,
-0.0161113478,
0.0469045341,
0.0168518685,
-0.0647662953,
-0.0150182582,
-0.0287053473,
0.0000634303,
-0.0222359877,
0.0335796513,
-0.0521960333,
-0.0159073956,
0.0298416708,
-0.0016703876,
0.0098829297,
0.0429826528,
0.0016574537,
0.0121535668,
-0.1012513191,
0.0347368456,
-0.0014374311,
0.0368419066,
-0.0262048785,
0.0065326821,
0.0061743809,
-0.0255535226,
0.039517533,
0.0720823109,
0.0124881854,
-0.0756403655,
-0.0201983284,
-0.0115094436,
0.0086540747,
0.0072101415,
0.011895448,
0.0483097881,
0.0023279411,
0.0113239996,
0.0262296423,
-0.01729545,
0.0015425597,
0.0376660787,
2.652e-7,
0.0875854641,
0.0640346929,
0.0150139695,
0.0463759005,
-0.0020816159,
0.0186407026,
-0.0059228879,
0.0170555711,
0.034102384,
0.0168167055,
0.0148069449,
-0.0154859871,
0.0421609059,
0.0436264649,
-0.1058557034,
-0.0174590219,
-0.0434871167,
0.0077516399,
-0.084346503,
0.0238905624,
0.1105842367,
0.0677087158,
-0.0404750295,
0.0063279378,
-0.0000859163,
-0.061000552,
-0.0053098253,
-0.0188921113,
-0.0448432118,
0.0512098111,
0.0175805464,
-0.0270461813,
-0.0282414015,
0.0514817201,
-0.0102691688,
0.0036429418,
0.0079676481,
0.0615480095,
-0.0058747786,
0.0090760551,
0.0160637908,
-0.0694198534,
0.0189633761,
-0.0449976958,
0.0830048919,
-0.0284383465,
0.0136670489,
0.0615647919,
-0.0186690018,
-0.0597132929,
-0.0016752544,
-0.0041974476,
0.0063572763,
-0.0276077427,
0.0269233938,
0.0165571459,
-0.0005540408,
-0.0367873125,
-0.0470121354,
0.012872206,
-0.0211406928,
-0.0529820621,
-0.0269310884,
0.0322924629,
-0.0294921752,
-0.0524333678,
-0.0293221772,
3.244021403e-34,
0.0216902476,
0.0111010633,
0.0214029942,
-0.0006978497,
0.0467520691,
0.0104572214,
-0.009946581,
0.0146126067,
0.0157129802,
-0.108207576,
-0.0362791307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15352v1 | Historical patterns of rice farming explain modern-day language use in China and Japan more than modernization and urbanization | 2023-08-29T14:47:08 | 2023-08-29T14:47:08 | Sharath Chandra Guntuku, Thomas Talhelm, Garrick Sherman, Angel Fan, Salvatore Giorgi, Liuqing Wei, Lyle H. Ungar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI, physics.soc-ph | We used natural language processing to analyze a billion words to study
cultural differences on Weibo, one of China's largest social media platforms.
We compared predictions from two common explanations about cultural differences
in China (economic development and urban-rural differences) against the
less-obvious legacy of rice versus wheat farming. Rice farmers had to
coordinate shared irrigation networks and exchange labor to cope with higher
labor requirements. In contrast, wheat relied on rainfall and required half as
much labor. We test whether this legacy made southern China more
interdependent. Across all word categories, rice explained twice as much
variance as economic development and urbanization. Rice areas used more words
reflecting tight social ties, holistic thought, and a cautious, prevention
orientation. We then used Twitter data comparing prefectures in Japan, which
largely replicated the results from China. This provides crucial evidence of
the rice theory in a different nation, language, and platform. | [
0.0356893204,
0.0820934251,
-0.0271986201,
-0.0005390536,
0.0223147161,
-0.0014916265,
0.0236731861,
0.0117357466,
0.0314587802,
-0.0039612828,
0.0588599518,
-0.0052327467,
0.0522663668,
0.0249128956,
0.0187648796,
-0.0496374257,
0.0195806157,
0.0785124451,
0.0317610577,
0.0236384049,
0.0317897871,
0.0123204291,
0.0610862151,
0.0309323911,
-0.0494184047,
0.0405971408,
0.0360209569,
-0.0338546671,
0.0057075177,
-0.0265734289,
0.0463010035,
0.0138918227,
-0.0095601082,
0.008792568,
0.0000017466,
-0.0188165959,
-0.006950994,
-0.0334713794,
0.0128857056,
0.0758660883,
0.0587813109,
0.0042022737,
-0.0066985195,
0.0205147676,
-0.0228952747,
-0.0153165953,
0.0523442887,
0.0390702412,
-0.0072472403,
-0.0158301275,
-0.0027533062,
-0.0357602201,
-0.0270951986,
-0.0072005228,
-0.0474826135,
0.0639625341,
0.0358319692,
-0.004974199,
-0.0165917128,
-0.0101120733,
-0.0508410893,
0.0195299145,
0.000379931,
0.0127024269,
-0.0353909209,
0.0282332301,
0.0075387028,
-0.0328759775,
0.0352277085,
0.0302253924,
0.0325798281,
0.0026644242,
0.028772153,
-0.0099979443,
-0.0467850305,
0.0463605225,
-0.0000070588,
-0.021018846,
-0.0158086177,
0.0213673897,
0.0249693301,
-0.0129730161,
-0.0015406518,
0.0556653515,
-0.0343580469,
0.0989817381,
-0.0023448726,
-0.0413405821,
-0.0586100295,
-0.0176703949,
0.0344482437,
-0.0514018126,
0.0306558441,
0.0392476693,
0.0244582612,
0.0269651245,
0.0458241031,
0.0102886846,
0.0033921176,
-0.0426068157,
-0.0385947563,
0.0054690843,
-0.0351909474,
-0.034668956,
0.0443962105,
-0.0268505178,
0.0199832823,
-0.0250241105,
0.0167409908,
-0.0113910306,
-0.0606467687,
0.0166705754,
0.0236250721,
-0.0276067369,
0.0185307655,
0.0201475732,
-0.0117225237,
0.0081460234,
-0.0301581286,
-0.0342184566,
-0.0406808928,
-0.0133886579,
0.0217095725,
0.0127671985,
-0.0289727952,
0.0647806376,
-0.060922686,
0.0154122943,
-0.0161200464,
-0.0476137549,
0.0273011718,
-0.0245617349,
0.045447927,
0.0140307462,
-0.0080910036,
-0.022812698,
-0.0023901651,
0.0186228156,
-0.0119752595,
-0.0035197691,
-0.0678065345,
0.0043230946,
-0.003939651,
-0.0327740274,
-0.0061489521,
0.0256038271,
0.0242597368,
-0.0499351211,
0.0236978754,
0.0267033912,
-0.0470638312,
-0.0151680447,
-0.0033177086,
0.0277665295,
0.0240716916,
0.0117714284,
0.0177466962,
0.019959243,
0.0527863242,
0.0229327418,
0.0976895839,
0.0046711005,
0.0022028654,
-0.0105214724,
-0.0309384223,
0.0034744125,
-0.0349995978,
-0.0203387905,
-0.002658505,
-0.065799512,
0.0023780109,
0.029933786,
0.0129687926,
0.0589413196,
0.0637403056,
0.0955961198,
-0.0056171957,
0.0248086117,
0.0148107111,
0.0720557347,
-0.0446052141,
0.0013994556,
-0.0125575112,
-0.0377387889,
-0.0305187348,
-0.0135616008,
0.0436483286,
-0.0131809618,
-0.0127297267,
-0.0332197547,
-0.0225699041,
0.0148248374,
0.0801064819,
-0.0078952927,
0.0347822495,
-0.0246526189,
0.02926201,
0.0249533262,
0.0552289747,
-0.0363822207,
-0.0287694577,
0.009735994,
0.0342329964,
0.0645897016,
-0.0391658321,
0.0171901099,
0.133212924,
0.0556260273,
0.0715939924,
0.071868889,
0.0333431289,
-0.0063158739,
-0.0124436542,
0.0102537191,
0.0051507,
0.0359661132,
-0.0078828111,
-0.0405632332,
0.018079184,
0.0580248535,
0.0162416417,
-0.0094428165,
-0.0138113173,
-0.0061924569,
0.0312040336,
0.0259027202,
-0.0505117401,
0.0192863252,
-0.0257592667,
0.0255936645,
-0.0189242512,
0.004059081,
-0.021507835,
-0.0295335595,
-0.0505083613,
0.0859561265,
-0.0066716904,
0.081963487,
-0.0050980747,
-0.0056704506,
-0.0275579505,
-0.0063546337,
-0.0138455173,
-0.0040824525,
0.0812390298,
0.0151716545,
0.0675638989,
-0.0315826423,
0.0194870215,
-0.0713942572,
0.0554880686,
-0.016504189,
0.0394161604,
-0.0326807313,
0.0049088006,
-0.0813978314,
-0.0402665101,
0.0386188515,
0.009197589,
0.0241470821,
0.0127790077,
0.0076345829,
0.0011593758,
0.0125219552,
0.0123291574,
-0.036745023,
-0.0030549844,
-0.0348624773,
-0.0043555875,
-0.0207506586,
-0.0227359459,
-0.0096267229,
-0.0056866058,
-0.0196433924,
0.0409093574,
0.0042111808,
0.1112882122,
-0.009434388,
0.0271165669,
0.0200110115,
-0.0521734282,
0.0334211551,
-0.0028090612,
0.0087174363,
-0.0320228636,
0.0155616235,
0.0148188276,
-0.0968185589,
0.0179552194,
-0.0813081563,
-0.0439882129,
0.013679646,
-0.0381454974,
-0.0603183545,
-0.0282986891,
-0.0063763736,
-0.0627975911,
-0.032745529,
-0.0030445245,
0.023367051,
0.0038686476,
-0.0226059593,
-0.0076815737,
-0.0300167389,
-0.0019992071,
-0.0031789434,
0.0008116037,
-0.082442902,
-0.0295102168,
0.0689328387,
0.0497104861,
0.0344277397,
0.0104153221,
-0.0266012941,
-0.0709280893,
0.0122496253,
0.0003589258,
0.003036611,
-0.016909264,
0.0471614674,
-0.0369897932,
-0.0471650809,
-0.0107042836,
0.044543419,
0.0235011466,
0.0025261841,
-0.0606613755,
0.0215825066,
0.0589138493,
0.0382703729,
0.0176527109,
0.0480276346,
-0.0351055264,
-0.0127080139,
0.0015303253,
-0.0122570228,
-0.0295579825,
0.0125422385,
-0.0352173634,
0.0096737184,
-0.0082108006,
-0.0092197089,
0.0351522714,
-0.0530351549,
-0.0525522642,
0.0275617577,
0.0608924702,
-0.0412441306,
0.0644647107,
0.0613010935,
-0.0206731986,
-0.0565640703,
0.004992845,
0.0127318203,
0.0035241926,
0.0145073654,
0.0041755871,
0.0102173369,
-0.0267095398,
0.0338613242,
0.0161912236,
0.0177792292,
0.0135679916,
-0.0210483354,
0.0469611101,
0.0036676852,
0.008986067,
-0.0625073612,
0.0124786682,
0.0076887617,
0.0651576817,
-0.0262746513,
0.0370908827,
0.057435669,
0.0341392644,
0.0428257249,
0.0425378531,
-0.0272964444,
-0.0104908505,
0.0456957258,
0.0182330199,
-0.0944542512,
0.0301330816,
-0.0183801353,
-0.0436121523,
-0.024890909,
-0.0132037131,
-0.025578035,
-0.1336734295,
-0.0099979658,
-0.0072967056,
-0.0143083623,
-0.0224301554,
0.0004121785,
-0.0062740203,
0.01251873,
0.016136514,
-0.0249682888,
-0.0350660831,
-0.00386133,
0.0044705477,
-0.0792119429,
-0.0129230339,
0.0398881808,
-0.0573331527,
0.0227927994,
-0.0206930283,
0.0334538072,
-0.0341055617,
-0.0075087859,
0.033624474,
0.0313950554,
0.0127035594,
-0.0242412835,
0.0474959761,
0.0260833111,
-0.017251512,
-0.0023971915,
-0.0497878231,
-0.00079125,
-0.0254048556,
0.0540837236,
-0.0084042493,
0.0307275802,
-0.0837895349,
0.0368555561,
0.023338249,
0.0294528753,
0.0006078484,
0.0203472916,
-0.0791192576,
-0.0060649994,
-0.0304664019,
-0.032811638,
0.0329381004,
-0.0522635095,
-0.0143444538,
-0.0572253801,
-0.061967846,
-0.0608990379,
-0.0768076926,
0.0193505082,
-0.0032505996,
0.0425774492,
-0.0230970085,
0.082106784,
-0.0319050513,
-0.0657098517,
0.0087753432,
-0.0012233545,
-0.00954838,
0.0353199504,
-0.0513838418,
0.0247820988,
0.0050101485,
0.0283277817,
-0.0062314714,
-0.028565662,
-0.0233587213,
0.0080166254,
-0.0337317362,
0.0140837263,
0.0195914358,
0.0178857408,
-0.0368714444,
0.0308497623,
0.0090129813,
0.0070586116,
0.0165467281,
0.0064601237,
-0.0217983183,
0.0164006762,
0.007535201,
-0.0177108608,
0.0110115828,
0.0174897388,
-0.0049432237,
-0.0903718919,
0.0154107967,
0.0014428118,
-0.0327094048,
0.0545269586,
-0.0132916439,
-0.0346659906,
-0.0442720018,
-0.0519275367,
-0.0206297245,
-0.0247207507,
-0.0092475181,
-0.0566690415,
0.0131399576,
0.0497392826,
-0.0331345536,
-0.0107627939,
-0.0128227277,
0.016415121,
-0.0436909012,
-0.0065911617,
-0.0543695539,
0.0759166926,
-0.0649688318,
0.012952432,
0.0260618441,
-0.0069691725,
-0.0007045317,
0.0291252714,
-0.0123030515,
0.0399885699,
-0.0459048152,
-0.0135345617,
0.0248110443,
0.0049710069,
-0.0149916792,
-0.0980301946,
0.0100346245,
-0.038627632,
0.0148740821,
-0.0770533159,
0.0472345576,
0.0111456094,
-0.0317772776,
-0.0236356482,
0.0077691558,
-0.0331247672,
-0.0856442824,
-0.0136996126,
-0.0190456416,
-0.0475905128,
0.0439242721,
0.0543230399,
0.0045039728,
0.0234892946,
0.0574889481,
-0.0374669991,
0.0184216443,
-0.0027012331,
0.025362568,
0.0159172118,
-0.0117310369,
-0.0030923465,
-0.0767337456,
-0.0456185602,
-0.0041323197,
-0.0398960561,
-0.0031756326,
0.0436986759,
-0.0225574039,
-0.001995272,
0.008675308,
0.0444862023,
-0.0539726019,
0.007848328,
-0.0223871078,
0.0020686416,
0.035395667,
-6.255869263e-33,
0.0098183984,
-0.0688446909,
0.0158255249,
-0.0350023955,
0.0014078051,
0.0140170539,
-0.0522618555,
0.0510959774,
-0.0609275363,
0.0406079851,
-0.0185154565,
-0.0080328919,
0.0104148183,
-0.0023793194,
0.0560666025,
0.0093260603,
-0.0382924415,
0.0206663944,
0.0368288457,
-0.0156197343,
0.0446958207,
-0.027776977,
0.0349105522,
-0.0896391794,
0.0383441336,
0.0183784459,
-0.031234486,
0.0119738355,
0.0613018908,
-0.0117902271,
0.0042630518,
0.0541551076,
0.0451697335,
-0.021495251,
-0.0299738292,
0.040769808,
-0.0459441356,
-0.0881761536,
-0.0236239042,
-0.0154856136,
-0.0115086483,
-0.0194552951,
-0.0166849494,
-0.0028129192,
0.0093348483,
0.0111900726,
0.0544379875,
0.031398952,
0.0138507262,
0.0294587482,
-0.0373725481,
0.0129917059,
-0.0331154466,
0.0350858457,
-0.056540262,
0.0131511874,
0.0312873274,
0.0109929433,
-0.0572049096,
0.0067568254,
0.019162897,
0.0355865434,
0.0115177194,
0.0135311736,
-0.0109323496,
0.0215948187,
0.032969594,
-0.0133294696,
0.0020380118,
-0.0471730307,
0.0334763303,
-0.0070787808,
-0.0166674294,
0.0468450785,
0.0574362464,
-0.124943316,
-0.009569481,
-0.0284080748,
0.0457005352,
0.0068189986,
-0.025577981,
0.0016202118,
-0.0005117969,
-0.0388905555,
0.0097576845,
-0.0511628129,
-0.0285692159,
0.007616011,
-0.0125662759,
0.0124567337,
0.0386281051,
0.0201759022,
0.0312926695,
-0.0486025885,
-0.0441221781,
0.0120651778,
-0.0515975617,
-0.0360187851,
0.013949939,
-0.0208830591,
-0.0604899861,
-0.0304669533,
-0.0750661045,
0.0765358135,
-0.0088007515,
0.0290466622,
-0.001688418,
0.0160844754,
-0.028587617,
-0.0153940776,
-0.0090971095,
-0.0682197884,
0.0152509464,
-0.0611210316,
0.0395615213,
0.0259369295,
-0.0135081643,
-0.0506270118,
0.1090821475,
0.0055772066,
0.0047216471,
-0.0192831252,
-0.0165228508,
-0.0504053682,
0.0057445462,
0.0123520875,
-0.0122995451,
0.0656045377,
0.0483227745,
-0.0138837323,
-0.0109684318,
-0.0362531506,
2.603e-7,
0.059593264,
0.0623435974,
-0.0208942071,
0.0240614638,
0.0223192591,
-0.0188444611,
0.0329960361,
0.0076672677,
-0.045136869,
0.0188423824,
0.0243517142,
-0.003505969,
0.0835592374,
0.0076435315,
-0.0493601896,
0.010022983,
-0.0686177611,
-0.0081660664,
-0.0442496315,
0.0183427818,
-0.0175457932,
0.0340964086,
0.0079367077,
0.0156426802,
-0.0408267975,
-0.0190072358,
0.0160054546,
-0.0328067206,
0.0435204916,
0.0196195301,
-0.0059343316,
-0.021332534,
-0.0150433285,
-0.0197170507,
-0.0391374119,
0.0020235563,
0.0399813987,
0.0355033316,
0.0024293659,
0.0243522841,
0.0013985677,
-0.0613609739,
0.0320543684,
-0.0336360522,
0.0466285758,
0.0350792706,
-0.0455920063,
0.0070535084,
0.0427532494,
0.0172316041,
0.0299819596,
-0.0181671642,
-0.010850857,
0.0329009332,
-0.0288860667,
-0.0066808215,
-0.0205627196,
-0.0141460048,
-0.0344014354,
-0.0118137412,
-0.0017981076,
-0.0567339957,
0.0368194655,
0.0026447792,
0.0118194958,
0.0389180407,
0.003101029,
1.867121018e-34,
0.0018988156,
-0.010644556,
0.0037184511,
-0.0291962065,
0.054995086,
0.0260184761,
0.0144129535,
0.0166545864,
-0.0134978658,
-0.0095598921,
-0.0038702039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15334v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15334v1 | A Framework for Responsible Development of Automated Student Feedback with Generative AI | 2023-08-29T14:29:57 | 2023-08-29T14:29:57 | Euan D Lindsay, Aditya Johri, Johannes Bjerva | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | Providing rich feedback to students is essential for supporting student
learning. Recent advances in generative AI, particularly within large language
modelling (LLM), provide the opportunity to deliver repeatable, scalable and
instant automatically generated feedback to students, making abundant a
previously scarce and expensive learning resource. Such an approach is feasible
from a technical perspective due to these recent advances in Artificial
Intelligence (AI) and Natural Language Processing (NLP); while the potential
upside is a strong motivator, doing so introduces a range of potential ethical
issues that must be considered as we apply these technologies. The
attractiveness of AI systems is that they can effectively automate the most
mundane tasks; but this risks introducing a "tyranny of the majority", where
the needs of minorities in the long tail are overlooked because they are
difficult to automate.
Developing machine learning models that can generate valuable and authentic
feedback requires the input of human domain experts. The choices we make in
capturing this expertise -- whose, which, when, and how -- will have
significant consequences for the nature of the resulting feedback. How we
maintain our models will affect how that feedback remains relevant given
temporal changes in context, theory, and prior learning profiles of student
cohorts. These questions are important from an ethical perspective; but they
are also important from an operational perspective. Unless they can be
answered, our AI generated systems will lack the trust necessary for them to be
useful features in the contemporary learning environment.
This article will outline the frontiers of automated feedback, identify the
ethical issues involved in the provision of automated feedback and present a
framework to assist academics to develop such systems responsibly. | [
0.0816828683,
0.0392078385,
-0.0495543107,
0.0025234632,
-0.0670195594,
0.0075220466,
0.0291154329,
-0.0535125174,
0.0495220535,
-0.0670847669,
0.0035872648,
0.0043860315,
-0.0323168524,
0.0205641948,
0.0172542557,
-0.0507467911,
0.0007040548,
-0.0191764478,
-0.0015216745,
0.0182012394,
-0.0132091995,
0.0168002155,
-0.0110535584,
0.0518145077,
-0.0368886553,
-0.0360712595,
-0.0064418209,
-0.0401831046,
-0.0103095891,
0.0178994685,
0.0153363245,
0.0672019273,
-0.007043954,
0.0355762355,
0.0000022149,
-0.0667279214,
0.0128311533,
0.009276595,
-0.043086648,
0.0104472348,
0.0575936027,
0.0709052086,
-0.011804984,
-0.0057361638,
-0.0756342486,
0.0446964651,
0.0454239883,
-0.0164850466,
0.0209890492,
-0.0045878286,
0.0026750003,
-0.0081680119,
0.0295311566,
0.0345368609,
0.0303334948,
0.0120158354,
0.0360348821,
-0.0083669359,
0.0130473198,
0.0286058038,
-0.0209018961,
0.0428569652,
0.0094196294,
-0.0791336596,
0.0485602468,
-0.0182029158,
0.0116111888,
-0.0350201316,
-0.0132801989,
0.020784799,
0.04418125,
0.0016696035,
-0.0155439135,
-0.0002515357,
0.0392520875,
0.0284594055,
-0.03302674,
0.0507867113,
-0.0262090117,
0.003517173,
0.0068574208,
-0.0288824476,
-0.0075004464,
0.0632213876,
0.0223607812,
-0.0137443813,
-0.0049752472,
-0.0229076594,
-0.0259673577,
0.0570166744,
-0.0031934786,
-0.0137489438,
0.0117059825,
0.0816027895,
-0.0413701497,
0.0192455221,
-0.0117654875,
-0.0460064709,
0.0269795377,
-0.0148874214,
0.0527457036,
0.0038287234,
-0.0014949681,
-0.0085140625,
0.0201513171,
0.0500774346,
-0.0073033627,
0.0576370545,
-0.0148040233,
0.0196163487,
-0.0442008674,
-0.0154995248,
0.0112953763,
0.064278394,
0.0104662478,
0.0382818505,
-0.0185797792,
0.0200623311,
-0.0746143386,
0.0566718914,
-0.0318169519,
0.0336457565,
-0.0280201193,
0.0309393685,
-0.0433347225,
0.000589797,
-0.0062732394,
0.0091213947,
-0.0143851908,
-0.0239973478,
0.0207759459,
0.0116852205,
-0.0285366047,
0.0477366298,
0.0084375916,
0.0819432214,
0.0258635487,
0.0015343498,
-0.0485998355,
-0.0473420508,
-0.0045390972,
-0.0463767275,
0.0004868828,
-0.0229112078,
-0.0169501193,
-0.0097200042,
-0.0259181168,
-0.038311027,
0.0014914302,
0.0211509485,
0.0278602093,
0.0507399216,
0.0138405617,
0.006872186,
0.0384788178,
0.0118831508,
0.0157541148,
0.0025843799,
0.0347902402,
0.0299278162,
0.050074432,
-0.0131616117,
0.062401209,
0.0020515572,
0.0027549476,
-0.0053256107,
-0.002455795,
-0.0193523075,
-0.0307239499,
0.0206011273,
-0.0533260256,
0.0561482497,
0.0269654281,
0.038664721,
0.0486722998,
0.0800769925,
-0.031978175,
0.0427034572,
0.0214517061,
0.0069425618,
0.0102538662,
0.0353121907,
-0.0132758021,
0.0009227366,
0.0079732435,
-0.0123416511,
-0.0288993381,
0.0114888633,
0.0181865878,
-0.1092988402,
-0.0112798093,
-0.0356539711,
0.0012394657,
0.0933405012,
0.0278941505,
0.0025458869,
0.0048072711,
-0.0425613485,
0.0316842757,
-0.0684459284,
0.0328012742,
-0.0942221209,
0.0935967937,
0.1168902069,
0.0287369546,
-0.0163880028,
0.0023487995,
-0.0505841188,
-0.0442119613,
0.0396534763,
0.0194567405,
-0.0530418791,
-0.0457053743,
-0.0094693825,
-0.0200619176,
0.0091371881,
-0.0107376985,
0.0070686433,
0.0055518858,
-0.0173455738,
-0.0046803653,
0.0302786883,
-0.1137998775,
0.0329503119,
-0.0452795066,
-0.0720827058,
-0.009054509,
0.0148119815,
0.0092679467,
0.0506785065,
-0.001665973,
0.0181936659,
0.0217318386,
0.0205222405,
-0.0250926111,
-0.0443061069,
-0.0436430834,
0.0579485223,
0.041037038,
-0.0309896022,
-0.0068909419,
0.0059097665,
-0.0416620784,
0.008850798,
0.0187434163,
-0.0160304084,
0.0089061642,
-0.0213351883,
0.0105048176,
-0.0707883611,
-0.0355137549,
-0.0758100599,
0.0023900184,
0.0165543724,
0.0158748869,
0.0007596191,
0.0119961286,
0.0073127761,
0.0135142868,
-0.0280956179,
0.0359553881,
0.0300982613,
0.0415260866,
0.0343893282,
-0.0113654686,
-0.0401144736,
0.0048705353,
-0.0471497737,
-0.0444887839,
0.0148987966,
-0.0042462572,
-0.0384049043,
-0.0293238219,
-0.0004560159,
0.0008925365,
-0.0238258541,
-0.0382407643,
-0.0023560377,
-0.0204352979,
-0.0001942725,
-0.0064502861,
0.0189254954,
-0.0198998861,
-0.0088981781,
-0.0297963098,
-0.0020956395,
0.1172425598,
-0.0099469284,
-0.0452948399,
0.0243718103,
0.0060862107,
0.0139936302,
0.0269009136,
0.0046409117,
0.0182112101,
0.0092504332,
0.0361984037,
0.0658895969,
0.026965417,
0.0593603365,
0.0373838022,
0.0226692818,
-0.0503716394,
-0.0072264974,
-0.0166745465,
-0.0428526439,
-0.0055923294,
-0.0008123504,
0.0184408035,
-0.0118970145,
0.0536499172,
-0.053208638,
-0.0082221162,
0.0559707917,
-0.0748507828,
-0.0065152184,
-0.0249483883,
-0.0728055611,
-0.0368713997,
0.0204661805,
0.0101330038,
-0.0475786813,
0.1139786914,
0.0278681312,
0.0345895067,
-0.0496462844,
-0.0098053394,
-0.0199833978,
0.0420528315,
-0.0239413921,
0.0236493517,
0.038315963,
0.003234087,
-0.0094512552,
-0.0073126797,
0.0679255426,
-0.0697065592,
0.0469064862,
-0.0478350632,
-0.0136577282,
0.0159215257,
-0.0158653017,
-0.0541357584,
0.0170128141,
-0.0104672695,
0.0083344653,
0.0335255153,
-0.0171812326,
0.010863469,
-0.0504312813,
0.0399554521,
-0.008445153,
-0.0242831074,
-0.0428585522,
0.0186551698,
-0.0174107291,
0.0006118988,
-0.0217646789,
0.012400399,
0.0107925972,
0.0217382144,
0.0483915508,
0.0248022676,
0.0135527439,
0.0155138504,
-0.008585277,
0.0430747941,
-0.0353603959,
0.0491964184,
0.0257943328,
0.0034146078,
-0.0761140883,
-0.0043117255,
0.0769888163,
0.0171894059,
-0.0758859068,
0.0017399937,
-0.0394303948,
-0.0628343299,
-0.0019982941,
0.0327242427,
-0.0906374082,
0.0290763192,
-0.0313678943,
0.0626407713,
-0.0758091956,
-0.0317565389,
0.0237165,
-0.0796583891,
0.0881952569,
0.0027547316,
0.0172729995,
-0.017799139,
-0.0162238311,
-0.030663142,
-0.0024807509,
0.0203210115,
-0.0383530855,
0.0070010712,
0.0040224604,
0.0754402503,
-0.0021389085,
-0.0272116475,
0.0283677541,
-0.0063070017,
0.0412553512,
0.0757312104,
0.0258745216,
-0.0180042554,
-0.058360301,
-0.0114200208,
0.0395585522,
0.0118115079,
0.0112611307,
0.016863307,
-0.0236823317,
0.001886628,
-0.0725423619,
0.0318119824,
-0.0089779431,
-0.0022544961,
0.0658838153,
0.0737542138,
-0.0249312278,
-0.0135902232,
-0.0717003942,
-0.0148127424,
0.0285671763,
0.0427853987,
0.0267805103,
-0.0570527688,
0.0214463715,
-0.0405251831,
0.0138566345,
-0.0284361392,
-0.0578941815,
-0.0069237212,
0.0066792266,
0.0141413566,
-0.0383378565,
-0.0720764324,
0.0396160595,
-0.0066588861,
0.0390105918,
-0.0014721241,
0.0344747566,
0.0015565635,
-0.0304442756,
0.006444728,
-0.0126613872,
-0.0069864229,
-0.0509173796,
-0.0740436688,
0.01604346,
-0.0317544192,
0.0250562485,
0.0051738438,
-0.0012632131,
-0.0578253679,
0.0381296165,
0.0776068419,
0.0168348867,
0.0289085358,
0.0199304353,
-0.021518087,
0.0355805717,
0.01630475,
0.00121121,
0.0065201558,
0.0064817253,
0.0037503447,
-0.0214902293,
-0.021526875,
-0.001573329,
0.0209535006,
0.0110973101,
-0.0413326547,
-0.0270741358,
-0.0330363661,
0.0485907532,
0.0575002395,
0.0034472453,
-0.0507062525,
-0.0285407919,
-0.0192235895,
-0.0240599196,
-0.0015280737,
-0.0571618825,
-0.0124919536,
-0.0191152655,
0.0228489451,
0.008023669,
-0.0121733695,
-0.020023806,
-0.0578997955,
0.0146207772,
-0.0287264194,
0.0481785759,
-0.0129985083,
0.0504303016,
0.0221983623,
0.0158589501,
-0.0345077589,
0.0165292602,
0.0078257713,
0.0466363542,
0.0259353165,
0.0739772022,
0.0303782988,
0.0109193139,
0.0562261008,
0.0170077737,
-0.0228475854,
-0.0636795834,
-0.0518037602,
0.0248714574,
-0.0152199259,
0.0518218167,
0.0004676001,
-0.0302727688,
0.0181626827,
0.0093159769,
0.0276410896,
-0.0269756559,
-0.0464580134,
-0.0377842784,
-0.0060570696,
0.0101838326,
-0.0158342253,
0.0162752979,
-0.0286283977,
0.03744464,
-0.0354196131,
-0.0244869497,
-0.0008541244,
-0.0401968434,
0.0173133295,
-0.0554659814,
0.0291315839,
-0.0120422244,
-0.0436721258,
-0.0455369204,
-0.0165609252,
0.0371014252,
0.0290858317,
-0.0475847125,
0.0218133666,
0.0288578533,
-0.012116598,
-0.0066291229,
-0.0463049822,
0.0619208999,
-0.0298581216,
-0.0289751403,
-0.023345612,
-5.854561369e-33,
-0.0190415699,
-0.088540189,
0.0127359442,
0.0323067121,
-0.0301993862,
-0.0363382623,
-0.0094657801,
0.0057841912,
-0.008898098,
0.0237102211,
0.0073192054,
-0.0086016254,
-0.0183368027,
0.0355701968,
0.0609746575,
-0.0201696698,
0.0584767796,
-0.0257986188,
0.0259735975,
0.0581572987,
-0.009957674,
-0.0100335926,
0.0455717556,
-0.0803402215,
0.0988417342,
-0.0377431549,
-0.0042652073,
0.0007150793,
-0.0961717665,
0.0100168111,
-0.0052452795,
0.1107498482,
0.0081571555,
-0.0302531924,
0.006589714,
0.0356243812,
-0.0153449457,
-0.0556883365,
0.0054446729,
-0.0028929058,
-0.0138128186,
-0.0569933057,
0.0486800224,
-0.0207759496,
-0.0444097407,
0.0051339273,
0.0624124594,
0.0012966631,
-0.0015291851,
-0.0401102342,
-0.0904297531,
-0.0255292822,
-0.0293174349,
-0.0185841247,
-0.00013332,
0.0611321926,
-0.0024075916,
-0.0386715494,
-0.0162603036,
0.0746359155,
0.0539034717,
-0.0423213392,
0.0591693819,
0.006074972,
0.004984586,
0.0231160112,
0.0196281541,
0.0270670764,
-0.0427527353,
-0.0400734656,
0.0190249514,
-0.0008005946,
0.0782859623,
0.0488919355,
-0.0292319804,
-0.0417679958,
-0.0025256961,
0.0165394414,
0.0225145984,
0.0226346776,
0.0080156103,
-0.0550466739,
-0.0702174678,
-0.0411980711,
-0.0228284858,
-0.055974368,
-0.0131267048,
-0.0226485375,
0.0247800518,
-0.0497922078,
-0.0459610149,
0.0026217569,
-0.0342248753,
-0.0504786745,
-0.0154964384,
-0.0202577133,
0.0271521825,
0.015916096,
-0.028720146,
-0.0441015624,
-0.00999761,
0.0192448106,
0.0059732338,
-0.0149124386,
0.0325502828,
0.0129474737,
-0.0100487201,
0.053508997,
0.0154618211,
0.0050584571,
-0.0377411954,
0.0383862518,
0.0587116294,
-0.0250211619,
0.0090154968,
0.0432176702,
-0.0074203429,
0.036745023,
-0.0042906851,
0.0142558822,
-0.0253485832,
0.014624266,
-0.0199955646,
-0.0163126141,
-0.0444615968,
-0.0206570793,
-0.0203806814,
0.057616543,
0.0350751206,
-0.0358308107,
-0.0030804297,
-0.0293675177,
2.881e-7,
0.0074724574,
0.0352432169,
0.0192598067,
-0.060939461,
-0.0503810607,
0.0445226952,
0.0427297987,
-0.0028284746,
0.0361052565,
0.0218500551,
0.0107762218,
0.0045742188,
0.005519277,
0.0233771801,
-0.0543644018,
-0.0509138852,
0.0027231553,
-0.0113416966,
-0.0536742061,
0.0721162409,
0.0771049708,
-0.0131838005,
0.0542342961,
-0.0331840292,
-0.0143541843,
-0.0061427187,
-0.0085161524,
-0.0349953771,
0.0077311019,
0.0100491671,
0.0286721326,
0.0121627161,
0.0364728309,
0.0265934113,
0.0003955104,
-0.0393566079,
-0.0283542443,
0.0386861116,
0.0052711358,
-0.0328051262,
-0.0214123707,
-0.0038324967,
0.0310592577,
-0.0236642957,
-0.0017048339,
-0.0249794181,
-0.0098376144,
-0.0507043488,
0.0283410288,
-0.0559895225,
0.0178187769,
-0.0399573185,
0.0178334769,
0.0072975527,
0.0081846537,
-0.0109848119,
0.0267036259,
-0.0316078849,
0.0115780551,
-0.0327407904,
-0.01422136,
-0.0295143761,
0.0218607169,
-0.0156677999,
-0.0160667729,
-0.0283757262,
0.0385620743,
2.308862382e-34,
-0.0060041547,
-0.0146125052,
0.0444429368,
0.0325951129,
-0.011347224,
0.0740756914,
-0.0070073023,
0.0072289794,
0.0324873626,
0.0042095068,
-0.0490442179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.12981v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.12981v2 | Wordification: A New Way of Teaching English Spelling Patterns | 2023-08-29T14:14:01 | 2023-11-10T10:49:12 | Lexington Whalen, Nathan Bickel, Shash Comandur, Dalton Craven, Stanley Dubinsky, Homayoun Valafar | cs.OH | cs.OH, cs.CL, K.3 | Literacy, or the ability to read and write, is a crucial indicator of success
in life and greater society. It is estimated that 85% of people in juvenile
delinquent systems cannot adequately read or write, that more than half of
those with substance abuse issues have complications in reading or writing and
that two-thirds of those who do not complete high school lack proper literacy
skills. Furthermore, young children who do not possess reading skills matching
grade level by the fourth grade are approximately 80% likely to not catch up at
all. Many may believe that in a developed country such as the United States,
literacy fails to be an issue; however, this is a dangerous misunderstanding.
Globally an estimated 1.19 trillion dollars are lost every year due to issues
in literacy; in the USA, the loss is an estimated 300 billion. To put it in
more shocking terms, one in five American adults still fail to comprehend basic
sentences. Making matters worse, the only tools available now to correct a lack
of reading and writing ability are found in expensive tutoring or other
programs that oftentimes fail to be able to reach the required audience. In
this paper, our team puts forward a new way of teaching English spelling and
word recognitions to grade school students in the United States: Wordification.
Wordification is a web application designed to teach English literacy using
principles of linguistics applied to the orthographic and phonological
properties of words in a manner not fully utilized previously in any
computer-based teaching application. | [
0.0133251464,
0.0097073466,
-0.0241263136,
0.0151523957,
-0.0350179896,
0.0090107666,
0.0383585691,
0.019385485,
0.0286153834,
-0.040741019,
0.00319908,
0.0170229934,
0.0666888058,
-0.001543776,
0.0164433252,
-0.0795377195,
0.0151296826,
0.002579686,
-0.0378726423,
0.005878502,
0.0346694402,
0.0307831801,
-0.0499799475,
0.0237769298,
0.004214983,
-0.0635155141,
0.0154093057,
-0.035073325,
-0.0358140878,
-0.0296353363,
0.0080187181,
0.0881431773,
-0.0288360193,
0.0391960815,
0.0000020327,
-0.05059525,
0.0120208776,
-0.0343411677,
0.0046556601,
0.0600736849,
0.063379094,
0.0023533031,
-0.0099433968,
0.0398423634,
-0.0211412925,
0.0217053294,
0.0496490486,
-0.0051535373,
0.0141714336,
-0.0343341492,
-0.0145316869,
-0.0104898252,
0.0382919051,
0.0153459636,
0.0184587818,
0.0381408632,
-0.0004629643,
-0.0205850247,
0.0714865327,
-0.0494323298,
-0.0381360166,
0.0503106266,
-0.0407548249,
-0.0323155299,
0.0359264165,
0.0235516988,
0.0199299827,
-0.0290603824,
-0.0022839878,
0.0247545019,
0.0335922353,
-0.0246729814,
0.0221197587,
0.0315501392,
-0.0055416999,
0.0519536808,
-0.0081662871,
0.0107354056,
-0.0033946736,
0.0108593451,
0.0402994007,
-0.0261055455,
-0.0107977698,
0.0572897345,
0.055720713,
0.0329420716,
0.0462117828,
-0.0491289683,
-0.04181372,
0.0438766815,
0.0501723178,
-0.0488389358,
0.0565845333,
0.0048980284,
0.0172479507,
0.0296258647,
-0.0411606282,
-0.0839813501,
0.0272618756,
-0.0515496656,
0.0363168456,
0.0071568275,
0.01665649,
0.0007220043,
-0.0063033695,
0.0232857447,
0.0851519257,
0.0147756776,
-0.022305239,
0.0797282606,
-0.035277985,
-0.0073984405,
-0.0293990504,
0.0309685841,
-0.0127385985,
-0.0143535696,
-0.0654972643,
-0.0130043961,
-0.0157645121,
-0.0173051804,
-0.0022235962,
-0.0006470159,
-0.0008293057,
-0.0245021041,
0.0171157047,
0.028289007,
-0.0220361222,
0.0233560447,
-0.0300594922,
-0.0291732065,
0.0378496908,
-0.02179626,
0.0358976945,
0.0160449538,
0.0148632592,
-0.0131324306,
-0.0510084592,
-0.0463816114,
-0.0429884493,
-0.0144111123,
-0.0303805228,
0.0357795693,
-0.0649828315,
-0.0785134062,
-0.0362307653,
-0.001177865,
0.048258055,
-0.0381028801,
0.0101093305,
0.0130611332,
-0.0049736872,
0.0577838197,
-0.0550630838,
-0.0055918223,
0.0568041131,
0.0273158066,
0.0635764599,
0.0118470667,
0.0458761379,
-0.0084430994,
0.0378205776,
-0.0411407463,
0.0183620136,
0.0233866312,
-0.0822008476,
0.0001540855,
0.0047493433,
-0.0944613963,
-0.0086364625,
0.0439971015,
-0.0181785673,
0.0629867166,
-0.0121144941,
0.0647855029,
0.0552169979,
0.1045480669,
0.0204972811,
0.0267976746,
-0.0253144689,
0.000366532,
0.0531773493,
0.0027139441,
-0.0068398025,
-0.0326520465,
-0.0378476717,
0.0069396552,
0.0161286145,
0.0136883026,
-0.0018589008,
-0.0546618849,
-0.0298326537,
0.0128714601,
0.0314618386,
-0.0210741702,
0.0398744941,
0.0183459744,
-0.0075943661,
0.0048037167,
0.0261015128,
-0.0490511395,
0.0637601763,
-0.0209999587,
0.045225352,
0.1063637435,
0.1017147899,
-0.0094147092,
0.0148961758,
0.0156038096,
-0.0258596931,
0.0690841079,
-0.0304332934,
-0.0157048572,
-0.0233807229,
-0.0112381289,
0.0049141021,
0.0581365116,
0.0065753958,
-0.0370944813,
0.0142746903,
0.0366962925,
0.0146828936,
-0.0180160701,
-0.0501816384,
0.0366359092,
-0.016045073,
-0.0178447384,
-0.0503459573,
0.0199493039,
-0.0143760983,
0.0337744392,
-0.023621982,
0.0192657728,
-0.0246934295,
-0.0002982963,
0.0297869574,
-0.067265451,
0.0023218587,
0.0182651673,
0.0588063933,
-0.089404121,
0.0388647355,
0.0324383862,
0.053867396,
-0.0353762396,
0.037638329,
-0.0698336959,
0.0492703319,
-0.0339655541,
0.0356093384,
-0.0306135602,
-0.0183743723,
-0.0056618294,
-0.0039172382,
-0.0045689247,
0.0066167791,
-0.0868129954,
0.0126766935,
-0.0335917287,
0.0154238269,
-0.0451677777,
-0.012042311,
-0.0222149435,
0.0441085286,
0.0118253678,
0.0248412434,
-0.0475509278,
-0.0300973263,
-0.0382661559,
-0.0320145302,
0.0361643024,
0.0224168915,
0.0306253955,
-0.0007034017,
-0.0103990678,
-0.0168473162,
0.0059070759,
0.01585095,
0.010190757,
0.0080541587,
0.0140772844,
-0.0422808193,
-0.020518247,
-0.0388284773,
-0.0266129971,
-0.0013530288,
-0.0014178825,
0.0562030226,
-0.0950754732,
-0.048173327,
0.0302588902,
-0.0146311661,
-0.0247011427,
0.0561279617,
-0.0454481244,
0.0376940891,
-0.0110977134,
0.0548668839,
0.0389511473,
0.0335260555,
0.0266264491,
0.0527533665,
-0.0284024347,
0.0041730558,
-0.046617303,
0.040608298,
0.0477850214,
0.012332472,
-0.0635442063,
0.0095006898,
0.0337145627,
0.0152419219,
0.0026081193,
-0.0082631391,
0.0161852986,
-0.0539505184,
0.0036663176,
-0.1060475037,
-0.0534535758,
-0.0591523349,
-0.0250633825,
-0.0183186457,
-0.0382442847,
0.0328449197,
-0.0279143732,
0.0283361357,
-0.0699850246,
0.0168132149,
0.0371788144,
-0.0439636894,
-0.0479099415,
0.0100152949,
-0.0211853292,
-0.0707082227,
0.0004567051,
0.0159718487,
0.0649506748,
-0.0599544495,
0.0300009064,
-0.0762154013,
-0.0135380458,
0.0158600397,
-0.0235121809,
-0.0202584714,
0.006955985,
-0.0130279325,
-0.0465582125,
0.0339035466,
-0.0293168481,
-0.0070181736,
0.0090135783,
0.0385363735,
0.0650835186,
0.0137341097,
0.014756483,
0.0033504383,
0.0087976325,
0.0289339293,
-0.0347440504,
-0.0190905444,
-0.0248818714,
0.0059124953,
0.0372150317,
0.0136031946,
-0.0415465161,
0.0362336151,
0.0281829834,
0.0563829131,
-0.0620918721,
-0.0495257489,
0.0323668756,
-0.002836535,
-0.0288549494,
-0.0312050153,
0.0657682195,
0.0461663827,
-0.0663404986,
-0.018497454,
0.0137546072,
-0.023127038,
-0.0415633246,
0.0210104268,
-0.046868626,
-0.0069993278,
0.0039838678,
0.0462965816,
0.0262912698,
-0.0226102117,
0.0097183743,
-0.0601065755,
0.0157784987,
0.0113191614,
-0.0082141412,
-0.0066048331,
0.0005533177,
-0.0004368547,
0.0646127686,
-0.0171573795,
0.0035384228,
-0.0503728017,
0.0039891596,
0.0225506574,
-0.0397246256,
0.0089093987,
-0.0159798432,
-0.0011744288,
0.0117127113,
0.0153381191,
0.0140172802,
-0.0153535176,
-0.0999458656,
-0.0411519483,
-0.0191900544,
-0.0289687663,
0.0060314629,
0.0038099522,
0.0321155526,
0.0082360655,
-0.0663748384,
0.0380319394,
0.0095443344,
-0.0302482732,
0.0186827481,
0.0405026451,
0.0296094492,
0.0100865569,
0.0013306482,
0.0213127509,
0.0323655196,
0.0250079986,
0.0226801261,
-0.0676126257,
-0.0231333505,
-0.029315887,
-0.0003116408,
-0.0452327468,
-0.0632988662,
0.0046202266,
-0.0421128795,
-0.0460244082,
-0.0763690695,
-0.0298583396,
0.0428873897,
0.0617704056,
0.0317635052,
0.0251151323,
0.0439765267,
0.0240002498,
-0.0090677319,
-0.018473763,
-0.0033269869,
0.0095577678,
-0.1041188613,
-0.0300153252,
-0.0707318634,
-0.0271020103,
0.0098982668,
0.019985998,
-0.0079566548,
-0.0019934874,
0.1019013599,
-0.004265564,
0.0224530231,
-0.0180172194,
-0.0076907841,
-0.0518130809,
0.0523455665,
0.0100057339,
0.0359676406,
-0.0002837435,
-0.0489553511,
-0.0222594682,
0.0116223041,
-0.026490014,
0.0228651147,
0.0237937681,
-0.0075552156,
-0.0064691557,
-0.0178716108,
-0.0179093461,
0.0160172097,
0.0570079014,
0.050957229,
-0.0728757232,
0.0184748285,
-0.0658790767,
-0.0707644001,
-0.0179488938,
-0.005088889,
0.0068623591,
0.0128622307,
0.0172046237,
-0.0080554085,
-0.0260765012,
-0.033488296,
-0.0286397394,
-0.0288806371,
0.0121763069,
0.0898158029,
-0.0083889803,
0.032828927,
0.0162452441,
-0.0135675259,
0.003828381,
0.0301110968,
-0.0394635573,
0.0573920161,
-0.0028516909,
0.0139955459,
-0.0224936865,
-0.0007635112,
-0.0292160027,
0.0212144684,
0.0079806615,
0.0447659269,
-0.0466394424,
0.0455298349,
-0.0160477608,
-0.0079916045,
0.0336753391,
-0.0213522557,
0.0036993355,
0.0046234224,
0.005213948,
-0.0247449409,
-0.0217240509,
0.0161875356,
0.0043227803,
0.0373263992,
-0.0582173355,
0.0201975107,
-0.0443620533,
-0.0411153249,
0.0195554961,
-0.0543427132,
-0.0306603108,
-0.0121688182,
-0.0198091846,
0.0526964217,
-0.0398384742,
0.0029654624,
-0.0587093979,
-0.0262236018,
-0.0329081975,
0.046525538,
0.01678087,
0.0011484561,
-0.0006002251,
-0.0016736386,
-0.0100348592,
0.0127702774,
-0.0386823937,
0.0336892866,
-0.0101256035,
-0.0661414117,
0.0094214622,
-5.709697486e-33,
-0.0006641779,
-0.0447951593,
-0.009091137,
0.0189132635,
-0.0026655665,
0.0014890254,
-0.0323876143,
0.0744672716,
-0.0093392394,
0.0281447433,
-0.0206960328,
-0.0236802455,
0.0238234568,
0.024706535,
0.023818301,
0.0403821692,
-0.0001893838,
0.0022263802,
-0.0149684241,
-0.0098418742,
0.0444277041,
0.0182301421,
0.088222973,
0.007930317,
0.048153758,
-0.0175006445,
-0.0329790041,
-0.0380036905,
0.0341875367,
0.0108166058,
-0.0353430174,
0.0638296604,
0.0001542095,
-0.023641834,
0.0133425575,
0.0594042614,
-0.0503444634,
-0.0190433729,
0.0186650511,
0.0068588941,
-0.0402945764,
-0.0315334797,
0.0256393496,
0.0091930786,
-0.0381384715,
0.0361993685,
0.042431403,
-0.0178056899,
-0.0285250973,
0.0410038643,
-0.0726696551,
0.0148217324,
0.0090614138,
-0.0276150331,
-0.0075460253,
-0.0275568757,
0.0004720819,
-0.0507691577,
-0.0853941813,
0.068815209,
0.0761262327,
0.0424792916,
0.0440077297,
0.017888898,
-0.0368997678,
0.0425307192,
-0.0185291395,
-0.0235033706,
0.0022208577,
0.0270247143,
0.0640373975,
-0.0256739929,
0.0811014026,
0.0430938043,
0.0712086633,
-0.054264836,
0.0173971448,
0.040705014,
0.036681477,
-0.0210236646,
-0.0156220188,
-0.0151566928,
-0.0748246685,
-0.0593893975,
0.0150198108,
0.0124660274,
-0.0164807271,
0.0151461326,
0.0154186478,
-0.0282576904,
-0.0146701466,
-0.0191773269,
-0.0377554782,
0.0110430475,
-0.0459196307,
0.0022747077,
0.0126725174,
0.0200070161,
-0.0312774591,
-0.0411744416,
0.0016375384,
-0.0234550461,
-0.0247194804,
0.0499976762,
0.0013740471,
0.0206732787,
-0.0169042069,
-0.0313580632,
-0.0462111682,
0.0147698186,
-0.0178317074,
0.0276599247,
0.0870990604,
-0.0606383495,
0.0387506969,
-0.0452152714,
0.0097172521,
-0.0301141813,
0.0431251228,
-0.0340856798,
0.0150525346,
-0.0400458574,
-0.0074806088,
-0.0055075288,
-0.0265863333,
0.0113429595,
-0.0419031195,
0.0479319766,
0.0434645899,
-0.0250260029,
0.0263909549,
-0.0149636287,
2.597e-7,
0.0432304889,
0.0449362397,
0.0239721462,
-0.0414752401,
0.0004654131,
0.0056667309,
-0.0017787006,
0.007803672,
0.0056291106,
0.0454791002,
0.0181993153,
-0.0163990464,
0.0583195388,
0.0227431748,
-0.0594312586,
-0.0162365437,
-0.0077128354,
0.0716816559,
-0.058159668,
0.0209594127,
0.0597439222,
-0.0126539813,
0.028740529,
-0.0416918732,
-0.0611963421,
-0.0233805738,
-0.0286623649,
0.0108551756,
0.0330748335,
-0.0138457371,
0.0422837511,
-0.0134123256,
0.0307693537,
-0.0069516599,
-0.0636085719,
-0.0112296231,
0.0394454636,
-0.0099764979,
-0.0293515269,
0.0780272111,
0.0186309554,
-0.0246530361,
-0.0047191586,
-0.0414303876,
0.0458483547,
0.0487871468,
0.0426690988,
0.035703551,
-0.0465224907,
0.0186738204,
-0.0264966674,
-0.0143120391,
-0.0424526893,
0.0134949433,
0.0147181628,
-0.0293934941,
-0.0063871527,
-0.0123375216,
-0.0093684532,
0.0146151436,
0.0023921032,
0.0067627309,
-0.040890336,
0.0123599442,
-0.0196328685,
-0.0335854553,
0.0029805175,
1.846731931e-34,
-0.0239043981,
-0.0127718663,
0.0468418151,
-0.0250211135,
0.0118567972,
0.0056599565,
0.05715077,
0.0040349141,
0.0313866623,
-0.0600715466,
0.0008096513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15299v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15299v1 | TaskLAMA: Probing the Complex Task Understanding of Language Models | 2023-08-29T13:36:45 | 2023-08-29T13:36:45 | Quan Yuan, Mehran Kazemi, Xin Xu, Isaac Noble, Vaiva Imbrasaite, Deepak Ramachandran | cs.CL | cs.CL | Structured Complex Task Decomposition (SCTD) is the problem of breaking down
a complex real-world task (such as planning a wedding) into a directed acyclic
graph over individual steps that contribute to achieving the task, with edges
specifying temporal dependencies between them. SCTD is an important component
of assistive planning tools, and a challenge for commonsense reasoning systems.
We probe how accurately SCTD can be done with the knowledge extracted from
Large Language Models (LLMs). We introduce a high-quality human-annotated
dataset for this problem and novel metrics to fairly assess performance of LLMs
against several baselines. Our experiments reveal that LLMs are able to
decompose complex tasks into individual steps effectively, with a relative
improvement of 15% to 280% over the best baseline. We also propose a number of
approaches to further improve their performance, with a relative improvement of
7% to 37% over the base model. However, we find that LLMs still struggle to
predict pairwise temporal dependencies, which reveals a gap in their
understanding of complex tasks. | [
0.0295930207,
0.0411042757,
-0.0215576906,
0.0336617604,
-0.0588446669,
-0.004252194,
-0.0175483264,
-0.0104074832,
0.0485849641,
-0.0179647133,
0.0160645582,
-0.010293548,
0.022512326,
0.0056990478,
-0.0207252279,
-0.0656170398,
0.0145028587,
-0.0442336835,
0.0023524931,
0.0195854865,
0.0003948391,
0.0293176938,
-0.0452041589,
0.0638148934,
-0.0000023702,
-0.0230618976,
-0.0182189289,
-0.0227709897,
0.0026739761,
-0.0144206118,
-0.0243632216,
0.0586691871,
0.0337084047,
-0.0060669412,
0.0000022157,
-0.0330460742,
0.0138827246,
-0.0420967378,
-0.0328451917,
0.0037893744,
0.0264243372,
-0.0096325446,
0.0154797751,
0.0155809484,
-0.0295293145,
0.0055578249,
-0.0170074105,
0.0614730008,
0.014111625,
0.0556975082,
0.0050403452,
-0.0059690522,
0.0120715769,
-0.0313499346,
0.0040781801,
-0.0509423949,
0.0124759693,
0.012478333,
0.0321404636,
-0.0005788513,
-0.0176693238,
0.0205322392,
0.0161400679,
-0.0236973241,
-0.0172978602,
0.0231595915,
-0.0078598261,
-0.0115726432,
-0.0034343987,
0.0643842742,
0.0170065425,
-0.0054879808,
0.0501284525,
0.0011645864,
-0.004642644,
0.0650500879,
-0.0484737568,
0.0068622972,
0.0177940279,
0.0220848117,
0.0252030008,
-0.0189482607,
0.0251881815,
0.0087182242,
0.0269680377,
0.0957350209,
-0.0263293181,
-0.0207997635,
-0.0054491633,
-0.0028856697,
-0.0247635227,
-0.0555125289,
0.0444028638,
0.0419254042,
-0.0561182238,
0.0141457748,
-0.0049567195,
0.0042630336,
-0.0047918456,
-0.0267772265,
0.0715052933,
0.0461869724,
0.0212635696,
0.0306475386,
0.03407548,
0.0611966327,
0.0085852118,
-0.0155379968,
-0.0676155537,
0.0154700968,
-0.0858659148,
0.0201425087,
-0.0097627398,
0.0230939854,
-0.094064571,
-0.0085160192,
-0.0241225213,
0.0211012773,
-0.0133775435,
0.0002972882,
0.0463234372,
0.0425509736,
-0.0167673342,
-0.0218573641,
-0.0768761188,
-0.0022104296,
-0.0478405431,
0.063792631,
-0.0193814095,
0.0093458686,
-0.0016640134,
0.0001085091,
0.0435935371,
-0.0288550798,
-0.0287866835,
0.0152833331,
-0.0221472327,
-0.0082290452,
-0.0329503193,
-0.0628568977,
-0.0141197601,
-0.0438281931,
0.0124866003,
-0.0651436448,
0.0579076,
0.0019875031,
-0.0205812603,
0.0066493261,
0.0180200543,
0.0215926822,
-0.0359407999,
0.0738024041,
0.0405393504,
0.0563033521,
-0.0081775161,
0.0238622446,
-0.0020030907,
0.03984515,
0.0155351926,
0.0292944387,
0.0132281147,
0.0468700044,
0.0164682716,
0.0335301124,
-0.0104753915,
-0.0127902469,
0.0204866547,
0.0091367429,
-0.0513531379,
0.0123638343,
0.0329052508,
0.0175224841,
-0.0115379617,
0.0284271482,
0.0568881892,
0.0697466284,
-0.0017398933,
0.0143881775,
0.0328990147,
0.0292137917,
-0.0037502926,
0.0111403903,
-0.0662469193,
0.0055857599,
-0.0425141975,
-0.0338688865,
-0.0334475935,
-0.0029132213,
-0.0211290531,
-0.0272739716,
-0.0067129065,
-0.0242894143,
0.0497230738,
-0.0147113269,
0.0469495654,
-0.0086265467,
-0.0400104821,
0.0481983349,
0.0146018164,
-0.0500928573,
0.0159827657,
-0.0192011297,
0.0078483867,
0.1081096753,
0.0340077206,
-0.0370839275,
-0.0360073,
0.0308588054,
0.0378898792,
-0.0004731159,
0.000907057,
-0.0387287252,
-0.0024966793,
-0.0491571762,
-0.0410873033,
0.0288669355,
0.0195678193,
-0.0334873758,
0.0360763706,
-0.0540216751,
0.0013512173,
-0.0153609198,
-0.0099425223,
0.0042969841,
-0.0437400341,
-0.0008945705,
-0.0423539281,
0.0103188176,
0.0129856998,
0.0300821625,
0.0251292456,
0.0226558037,
0.044373855,
-0.0613492802,
-0.0089136036,
0.0484100804,
-0.0521746948,
-0.0633822232,
0.0238121692,
-0.0301541463,
-0.0248295814,
0.055440262,
-0.0203034934,
-0.0564392582,
0.0403956138,
-0.026982896,
0.0166270845,
-0.0153188836,
0.0028982887,
0.0211370569,
-0.0566710271,
-0.0074161799,
0.0957502648,
-0.0570849925,
-0.0092479559,
0.0089823836,
-0.0313980877,
-0.0360478759,
-0.0287075639,
-0.0237957202,
-0.0100758281,
0.0110793952,
-0.0001316351,
0.0134032844,
0.0307019241,
-0.0390237458,
-0.020356033,
-0.1341365427,
-0.0132546369,
-0.0177605487,
0.0310627799,
0.0032420272,
-0.0291244723,
0.0238009598,
0.0060231206,
-0.0308797956,
0.0312204007,
-0.0069853831,
-0.018535858,
0.0125617497,
0.0112532405,
-0.0345460847,
-0.0202078037,
-0.0083217854,
-0.0491493493,
-0.0017899565,
0.0291609205,
-0.0160580818,
-0.0141517026,
0.021090664,
-0.0032082014,
0.032869406,
-0.0213558804,
-0.0132337697,
0.0022093789,
-0.0115608033,
0.0823818892,
0.0438693687,
-0.0252804104,
0.0251307879,
0.0470170006,
-0.0396782048,
-0.0438273251,
0.0189243238,
-0.0439409763,
0.0448032953,
-0.0328238159,
-0.0592030063,
-0.0262511801,
0.0658657551,
-0.0089700175,
0.0242973529,
-0.0797005072,
-0.0479287654,
-0.0261770841,
0.0067740092,
-0.0084707281,
0.0098090926,
-0.01345779,
0.0612431951,
-0.035629075,
-0.0203892607,
0.0432691984,
0.0036768266,
-0.0004356562,
-0.0081263836,
-0.0054254816,
-0.0399313644,
0.1037382111,
0.0061062556,
0.0163603518,
0.016752176,
-0.0125908433,
-0.0732968375,
0.0114532728,
-0.0054703066,
-0.0368623212,
0.0578579009,
-0.0962205827,
0.0028217696,
-0.0126037225,
-0.0555921644,
-0.0129031492,
-0.0177123863,
-0.0149130607,
0.0314163752,
0.0266061388,
-0.0201635417,
-0.0112828631,
-0.030385239,
-0.0166701972,
0.0227462575,
0.0132706193,
-0.0117196823,
-0.0365927145,
0.0435570441,
0.0503611341,
0.0464247912,
-0.0102345292,
-0.0001691094,
-0.0079688411,
0.0293938257,
0.084697172,
-0.0228966996,
-0.0046439893,
0.0294476561,
0.0367565565,
-0.0061921095,
-0.0152741671,
0.0462118611,
0.0533412695,
-0.0356264375,
-0.0217790063,
0.1018741429,
0.0368982032,
-0.0494710319,
0.0235926565,
-0.0356411673,
-0.0119937127,
0.0226621795,
0.0047073048,
-0.0603604689,
-0.0386121273,
0.0104792397,
-0.0038692919,
0.0096828723,
-0.0845558792,
0.0163572691,
-0.1087322682,
0.019221196,
-0.0060672984,
-0.0113278897,
-0.0003337988,
-0.0394083299,
-0.0125406431,
-0.0111362627,
-0.0112129282,
-0.0112422239,
-0.0041932384,
-0.0123555763,
0.0190517642,
-0.063336134,
-0.0680131987,
0.069849737,
-0.047998555,
0.1022812128,
0.0333774239,
0.0638386533,
0.0097918008,
-0.020563215,
0.0363477096,
0.0386129506,
0.0052003991,
-0.0197470263,
0.0026430732,
0.0483713448,
0.0126862368,
-0.0310273655,
0.0393788069,
-0.0825843886,
-0.0478536636,
0.0301863104,
0.1485740393,
-0.0286947079,
0.0107905436,
-0.0183808021,
0.0123634897,
0.0136180688,
0.1054724455,
0.021975426,
-0.0279720668,
-0.0342869647,
-0.0364146344,
-0.0150296343,
-0.0569983274,
-0.0511956364,
-0.0045632306,
0.0219062679,
0.0187864508,
-0.0693628863,
-0.0393300392,
0.0740317702,
0.0287106298,
-0.0000696829,
0.0034721913,
0.0639702305,
0.0167371482,
-0.0738951564,
0.057139568,
-0.046380464,
0.0151895275,
-0.0325082093,
-0.0232010931,
-0.0449804328,
-0.007168897,
-0.007764813,
0.0264572017,
-0.0753862709,
-0.0377962217,
0.0029745207,
0.0448805653,
0.0251718536,
0.022620393,
-0.0335699208,
-0.0527733937,
-0.0176132787,
-0.016840579,
-0.0531332195,
0.0174538214,
0.009475912,
0.031957183,
0.0155868046,
0.0779370666,
-0.013605359,
0.0155313322,
-0.0231086463,
0.0745572448,
-0.0544617288,
-0.0098771024,
-0.0078726932,
0.0245111883,
0.0497854277,
-0.0097084371,
-0.0126470271,
-0.0459313728,
-0.0145482663,
-0.037340153,
-0.0263135768,
-0.0628343895,
-0.0011885322,
0.0294188317,
0.0146852462,
0.0049062646,
0.0405551456,
-0.0054181456,
-0.0133331614,
-0.0473241061,
-0.0043089543,
0.0254191794,
0.0000884756,
0.0219263192,
0.0073412261,
0.0128838113,
-0.018697815,
-0.025856616,
0.0096516805,
0.0097843651,
0.0414897203,
0.0032684999,
-0.0001450014,
-0.0396612659,
0.0036097607,
-0.0116835572,
-0.0377286896,
0.0343167856,
0.0265988782,
0.0584272817,
-0.0386035219,
0.0546686612,
-0.0255891643,
0.013777663,
-0.0087060072,
0.0375630483,
0.0321036763,
0.0040885666,
0.0547919534,
0.025042126,
-0.004053683,
-0.0133170616,
0.0918785483,
-0.0190342534,
0.033688847,
0.014231435,
-0.0276453067,
-0.0253050085,
-0.0674350187,
-0.0166179948,
0.0240655392,
-0.0478842519,
0.0065173376,
-0.0827200711,
-0.0394715518,
0.0201070867,
-0.0155344745,
-0.0031627226,
-0.0414347053,
0.0466378406,
0.0176188853,
-0.0097090574,
-0.0379292406,
-0.0321389027,
-0.0202962738,
-0.0345770605,
-0.0235903859,
-0.0211484544,
-6.548773803e-33,
-0.0360510387,
-0.0550599471,
0.0606103018,
-0.0241986569,
0.0030888135,
0.0211405773,
-0.0572345071,
0.0358623713,
-0.0044383784,
0.0307224169,
-0.0016435598,
0.0159866214,
0.0062692845,
0.0278358553,
0.0378343537,
-0.0158548485,
0.0081558982,
-0.0203866027,
-0.0214756466,
0.0090587633,
0.0655199885,
-0.010558119,
0.0240039546,
-0.0553220473,
0.0126872892,
0.0092870845,
-0.0021770182,
0.0571552329,
0.014005499,
0.0385883488,
-0.0408999063,
0.0271161497,
0.0418919474,
-0.0289510041,
-0.0038192458,
0.067897208,
-0.0937547013,
-0.0472128652,
0.0673083141,
-0.0246239994,
-0.0728372782,
-0.0166187976,
-0.0030065097,
0.0342471041,
-0.0276265275,
0.019935498,
0.0271858629,
-0.0205050036,
0.014641026,
0.0267709699,
-0.0180396084,
0.0024161732,
-0.0202204492,
-0.0468974523,
0.0539525859,
0.0330498405,
-0.0120371152,
0.0052829981,
-0.0330721401,
0.0205194205,
-0.041559279,
0.0205753688,
0.0350961387,
-0.0065496136,
-0.0001756378,
0.0583161451,
-0.0160103571,
0.0099873198,
-0.0746921524,
0.0295553468,
0.0159325916,
0.118103914,
0.0328657664,
-0.0026364825,
0.0035309542,
0.0344432481,
-0.0546507016,
0.043989867,
0.0313026831,
0.0348388292,
0.0258951411,
0.0115971398,
-0.0311002992,
-0.0273299459,
-0.0242883675,
-0.0222545993,
-0.0309514273,
0.0231116284,
0.0172032062,
0.0323389284,
-0.0052295718,
0.0151774641,
0.0144512635,
-0.0184632223,
-0.0114975749,
0.023175979,
-0.0045045642,
-0.0025333716,
0.0086629521,
0.0195987057,
-0.0815911368,
-0.0222337116,
0.0141778579,
-0.0042833514,
0.0258095078,
0.0400528386,
0.0256934352,
0.0140468143,
-0.0155752208,
-0.0265109893,
-0.0683767796,
0.0032489006,
-0.0197157394,
0.0092429733,
0.0760185122,
-0.0020845528,
-0.0203863885,
-0.005519527,
0.030689897,
-0.0043810201,
-0.0005101928,
0.0241002385,
0.001457582,
-0.0140706673,
0.0098855058,
-0.0216838997,
-0.0479888171,
-0.0343848057,
0.0266292803,
-0.0082254075,
-0.0253547337,
0.0173305478,
2.838e-7,
0.0221297443,
0.0623599105,
-0.0064520417,
0.0566691495,
0.010095262,
0.0258582309,
-0.0285814181,
-0.0002194272,
-0.033033058,
-0.0037749887,
0.0396675877,
0.0347992107,
0.0465864278,
0.0193778016,
-0.0521215126,
-0.0231407695,
-0.0357253142,
-0.026835734,
-0.0444219336,
-0.0092996852,
0.0287911836,
0.0517880991,
0.0517653786,
0.0106774932,
-0.0243600775,
-0.0246168412,
0.037938647,
-0.0661708191,
-0.0210859068,
-0.018708935,
-0.0031655983,
-0.0279405713,
-0.0243292525,
0.0197817329,
-0.0262038205,
-0.005183802,
0.0107058464,
0.1099039912,
-0.0132630393,
-0.0152817992,
-0.0074972976,
-0.0615996383,
0.0038513532,
0.0025754124,
0.0752138272,
-0.0518654957,
-0.0214871,
0.0027863111,
0.0180105604,
0.0157312471,
-0.0222360995,
0.046000015,
0.0247453209,
0.0017757876,
0.0088272709,
-0.0281215347,
-0.003372896,
-0.081385605,
-0.0045866803,
0.0561194308,
-0.0257523488,
-0.0324093401,
-0.0448397137,
-0.0002765226,
-0.0191864185,
-0.0711790025,
-0.009822987,
2.876769876e-34,
0.0045952233,
0.0514171235,
-0.0111795608,
0.0052018748,
0.051706247,
-0.0310946628,
-0.0469269902,
0.0321054906,
0.0251479689,
-0.0693848357,
-0.0127555002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15298v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15298v1 | KGConv, a Conversational Corpus grounded in Wikidata | 2023-08-29T13:35:51 | 2023-08-29T13:35:51 | Quentin Brabant, Gwenole Lecorve, Lina M. Rojas-Barahona, Claire Gardent | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present KGConv, a large, conversational corpus of 71k conversations where
each question-answer pair is grounded in a Wikidata fact. Conversations contain
on average 8.6 questions and for each Wikidata fact, we provide multiple
variants (12 on average) of the corresponding question using templates, human
annotations, hand-crafted rules and a question rewriting neural model. We
provide baselines for the task of Knowledge-Based, Conversational Question
Generation. KGConv can further be used for other generation and analysis tasks
such as single-turn question generation from Wikidata triples, question
rewriting, question answering from conversation or from knowledge graphs and
quiz generation. | [
0.0591150038,
0.0193493068,
-0.0067130784,
0.0480609313,
-0.0412589721,
0.029174367,
-0.0204723161,
0.0046759299,
0.0381219201,
-0.0188511107,
0.0317780599,
-0.0202017762,
-0.0053361976,
0.0428090394,
0.0342208557,
-0.0230991244,
0.0052249865,
-0.0167113654,
0.0086321738,
0.0031325941,
-0.0036603801,
-0.0019192386,
-0.0403995924,
0.0282018967,
-0.0490493625,
-0.0286693871,
-0.0337647051,
0.0100552011,
-0.030041419,
-0.0046723182,
0.0933224708,
0.0413735174,
0.0299242213,
0.0110687492,
0.0000016877,
-0.0411366187,
0.0305119958,
-0.0193796009,
-0.0310456008,
-0.0237164292,
-0.0352938175,
-0.0149169397,
0.0339938812,
-0.0019694755,
-0.0720148236,
0.0278149471,
-0.0049093654,
0.0653735176,
0.0877501667,
0.0890674442,
0.0012466911,
-0.0355747081,
0.0320838802,
-0.0122587299,
0.0647157952,
-0.0120698037,
-0.005056466,
0.052442044,
-0.0186455566,
-0.0059406543,
0.0146229304,
0.0177947767,
0.0340680182,
-0.0522145852,
0.0079750065,
0.0184388552,
-0.0308396667,
-0.0123243043,
-0.0048783086,
0.1210370511,
0.0327794254,
-0.0178149678,
0.0176828131,
0.0300564598,
0.0513230823,
-0.010684289,
-0.0549085476,
0.0247457232,
0.0111404452,
-0.031660907,
-0.0101446351,
0.0094731785,
0.0090123788,
-0.0005749539,
0.0065185358,
0.0788287669,
0.0254490301,
-0.0107279131,
-0.0445714258,
0.0137502775,
0.0036559938,
-0.1071578115,
-0.0008569413,
0.0376291759,
-0.0278817508,
-0.006219496,
-0.0647132099,
0.012583633,
0.0229158755,
-0.0290000513,
-0.0422294773,
0.0339512713,
0.034084335,
0.0172186699,
-0.0086339694,
0.0218104571,
-0.0250566881,
-0.0280240253,
-0.057857655,
-0.006597776,
-0.0352267176,
-0.0149677973,
-0.0400901549,
0.0326230973,
-0.0655141994,
-0.0207190607,
-0.0205713939,
0.0658983216,
0.0554748103,
0.0199578833,
0.0053962194,
0.032241229,
-0.029667316,
0.0157758947,
-0.011807655,
0.038285125,
-0.0447776802,
0.0001660561,
0.0411662385,
-0.0044147368,
-0.0055414871,
0.0203590393,
0.0262476411,
-0.0208107401,
-0.0188719202,
0.0327806361,
0.001323605,
0.0079910764,
0.0271854289,
-0.0960721597,
-0.003365132,
-0.0151771447,
-0.0042032753,
-0.0372154415,
0.0608082227,
0.015040474,
-0.0351513475,
-0.0357596986,
0.0176480114,
0.0415473282,
-0.0076792468,
0.0635839775,
-0.0128652304,
-0.0041037672,
0.0754591078,
0.0203572083,
-0.0357701927,
0.0373556837,
0.0622892454,
0.0260286387,
0.0311843101,
0.0284579527,
-0.0097359205,
-0.0054417588,
0.0258546453,
-0.0014127078,
0.0335994624,
0.0608695596,
0.012801582,
0.0567696914,
0.0067832479,
0.0345347747,
-0.0261386149,
-0.0088453768,
0.0693625063,
0.0057589295,
-0.0065147677,
0.0351585522,
0.052470237,
0.0248638093,
-0.012862049,
0.0381377228,
-0.0393853225,
0.0242068991,
0.0018792184,
0.0170067437,
-0.0122362571,
0.0041123908,
-0.0270189028,
-0.011423653,
0.0314128362,
0.013914505,
-0.0112632979,
-0.0051062689,
-0.0254995767,
0.0272472091,
-0.0425176546,
0.0787292197,
0.0165538788,
-0.0806019232,
0.0161016248,
-0.0222422667,
0.0523849204,
0.0312048662,
0.0585576184,
0.0057111336,
-0.0932481512,
-0.0041057901,
0.012076891,
0.0369553715,
0.0619370677,
-0.0383651331,
0.000351923,
-0.0556979328,
0.0141680939,
-0.0546300597,
0.0086517846,
-0.0121435067,
0.0126600703,
-0.0062961858,
0.0464576855,
-0.0513066016,
0.0022074294,
0.0238015056,
-0.0028241733,
-0.0064182342,
0.0148127601,
0.0105626276,
-0.0270396248,
0.0130088311,
0.0121083762,
0.03358173,
0.023770256,
-0.0363468975,
-0.0318990201,
0.0473566651,
-0.0429788381,
-0.1227884293,
0.0375897326,
-0.0198975112,
-0.0010096875,
-0.0177055411,
-0.0284492541,
-0.0574617572,
0.0023954308,
-0.0348598696,
0.0536844283,
-0.0462634042,
-0.0273793656,
0.0591247156,
0.016603237,
-0.0169853792,
0.0501220711,
0.0068038641,
-0.0373647399,
-0.0097334534,
-0.0250676386,
0.0060259313,
-0.0225839354,
0.0098069496,
-0.0175684076,
-0.0390057713,
-0.0024263877,
0.0130740609,
0.0197541472,
-0.0717721656,
-0.0361137763,
-0.088482745,
0.0448507518,
-0.0287975073,
0.0127319833,
0.0329901427,
0.0402703471,
0.0025139095,
-0.0151909273,
-0.1185626611,
0.0323120244,
0.0138399554,
0.0064197462,
0.0769238248,
0.028551532,
0.0461802743,
-0.0104732774,
-0.0094114793,
-0.0087069226,
0.031610731,
0.0247155875,
0.0519232228,
-0.0428692028,
0.006349666,
-0.0612905882,
-0.0141190616,
0.008414492,
-0.0154104494,
0.0101373661,
-0.0374337547,
0.0693499222,
0.0366371721,
0.0020170021,
0.0079722945,
-0.019304283,
-0.0524192043,
-0.0135899317,
0.0487681329,
-0.0144403437,
0.0325781628,
-0.0090655228,
-0.0002660017,
0.0186231844,
0.0275843386,
-0.0010269507,
-0.0331825018,
-0.0393502153,
0.0453570485,
0.0194303058,
0.0134390704,
-0.0605314821,
-0.021118084,
0.0002313701,
0.0211444777,
-0.0259650704,
0.0118315173,
0.0440208353,
-0.0052334815,
-0.0157943405,
-0.0698352009,
0.0018005561,
-0.0114004081,
0.0487027764,
-0.0115125123,
0.0163624138,
-0.0158770774,
-0.0104208393,
-0.0578803867,
-0.0001502298,
0.003658534,
-0.0254722834,
0.032267537,
-0.0549656339,
0.0174526926,
-0.0105682882,
-0.0463442989,
-0.0580453463,
-0.0314132385,
0.0085635297,
-0.0187075567,
0.0096687851,
-0.0234316438,
0.002734947,
-0.0134822344,
-0.0003406141,
0.0517733246,
-0.0214999337,
0.0059775501,
-0.0278971829,
0.1218070537,
0.0619949624,
0.0500379354,
0.0134302238,
0.0061197737,
0.0463608094,
0.0445807762,
0.0254250206,
0.0179179367,
0.0193116721,
0.0012934457,
-0.0144123416,
-0.0416790619,
-0.0244263858,
-0.0072925407,
0.0781592801,
-0.0714273304,
-0.0570744388,
0.1016695574,
0.0550498441,
-0.0312101115,
-0.0026709405,
-0.014577412,
0.0544461235,
-0.0108992932,
0.038123522,
-0.0740762427,
-0.0216173772,
-0.0010585135,
0.0115580875,
-0.0044902968,
-0.060896188,
-0.0067315432,
-0.073981829,
0.0114146955,
-0.0105442628,
0.006351891,
0.0048643923,
0.0138678681,
-0.0390150547,
0.0199966151,
-0.005099542,
0.0125373211,
0.0334254391,
0.0303078759,
-0.0124918343,
0.0042938399,
-0.0242447425,
0.0360091515,
-0.0311010201,
0.0382661931,
0.0340103433,
0.0573585667,
0.0305976141,
-0.009009989,
-0.0125678359,
-0.021602463,
-0.0075784363,
0.0080865733,
0.0361004435,
0.0069547938,
-0.0282847974,
-0.0624788404,
0.0708656609,
-0.0524535365,
-0.0015744379,
0.039665319,
0.0274460725,
-0.0308974423,
-0.0212086737,
-0.0081001632,
0.007430946,
0.0334827714,
0.0732444227,
0.0600394122,
-0.003286843,
-0.0139203789,
-0.0516699813,
0.01879788,
-0.0987326652,
-0.0045217574,
-0.014940856,
0.0549313985,
0.043167565,
-0.1526568979,
-0.0735578835,
0.0228654854,
0.014292405,
-0.0148295611,
-0.027004879,
0.0092916097,
-0.0323282667,
-0.0686154589,
0.0041787652,
-0.031935364,
-0.0064105536,
-0.0170823317,
-0.012167464,
0.0424403995,
-0.0484562404,
-0.0278947875,
0.039791476,
-0.0872975439,
-0.0701543763,
-0.0170498695,
0.0759957433,
0.0169857722,
0.0329918601,
-0.0387778617,
-0.0023078988,
0.0274839345,
0.0149567258,
-0.0496929027,
-0.0149145285,
-0.0057897246,
0.0180304237,
0.0012576371,
0.0536320135,
-0.0375655107,
-0.0169969108,
-0.0502426587,
0.0740399361,
-0.0370329693,
-0.0249652006,
0.00656291,
-0.0021066635,
-0.0480944738,
0.0102057606,
0.0109536201,
-0.0069448999,
0.0421249382,
-0.032637272,
-0.0144995591,
-0.0408588722,
0.0050183334,
0.0062829223,
-0.0095800227,
-0.0023724518,
-0.0017631886,
-0.0390492231,
0.031944938,
-0.011478004,
-0.0488201454,
0.0380280018,
0.0032112284,
0.0361549743,
-0.027260514,
-0.0223563779,
0.0271685272,
-0.0108363973,
0.0479030497,
-0.0179059636,
0.0421626121,
0.0105870124,
-0.0423924401,
0.0022813254,
0.0421375521,
-0.0706484318,
-0.0047236863,
0.0068941293,
0.0494253412,
0.0079356795,
0.010620445,
0.0305591188,
-0.0225708224,
-0.0194284152,
0.0232898444,
0.0480133295,
-0.0027561819,
-0.0077606332,
0.0401757173,
0.0065653715,
-0.0248216875,
-0.0039327918,
0.054308638,
-0.0355380215,
0.0651025772,
0.0434959568,
-0.0002461865,
-0.0669437274,
-0.0241064467,
0.004037526,
0.0246390831,
-0.0163955595,
0.0380557962,
-0.0398390479,
-0.0462920293,
0.0059230672,
0.0023455988,
-0.0016265215,
0.0091723558,
-0.0049195085,
0.0504998602,
0.0051194252,
-0.0286088921,
-0.037658114,
0.050633356,
-0.0763259381,
-0.0458703823,
-0.0300357193,
-5.987103133e-33,
-0.0174492858,
-0.0245369002,
0.0235025287,
0.006323501,
-0.0476017259,
-0.0182866137,
-0.0440380983,
-0.0213364698,
-0.0257075727,
0.004352232,
-0.0140770143,
0.017963754,
-0.0112669505,
0.0443131067,
-0.0088923993,
-0.0331843272,
0.0301061738,
-0.0041966806,
-0.0263923556,
0.0750217214,
0.0338143297,
0.0431976169,
0.0312302466,
-0.020290304,
0.0394094065,
-0.0706585422,
0.0119370557,
0.0458726361,
-0.0047072894,
0.0060646553,
-0.0596892759,
0.0206006672,
0.0290066339,
0.0132852215,
0.005705215,
0.012452771,
-0.0254493393,
-0.0405889899,
-0.0080089457,
-0.0133678913,
-0.0196995176,
-0.0534445792,
0.0280431081,
-0.0200793799,
0.0844757259,
0.0039098226,
0.003803306,
0.0130514698,
0.0003902741,
0.0040736515,
-0.0371314064,
-0.0152118215,
-0.0055508418,
-0.0785617605,
-0.0819639787,
0.0465046875,
0.0418259315,
-0.0402466021,
-0.0824746192,
0.0283847339,
-0.0014348581,
0.0095050652,
0.002245025,
-0.0361195803,
-0.0152029693,
0.0327899531,
-0.0054544741,
0.0007775511,
-0.0227776058,
0.0234068409,
-0.0228694566,
0.0685524866,
0.0494886301,
0.0724304467,
-0.0013794602,
-0.0011705114,
-0.0557764135,
0.0420909673,
0.0030634853,
0.0179760754,
-0.0550444387,
-0.0465212986,
-0.0249089282,
-0.0027725759,
-0.0279776491,
0.0072635105,
-0.0207063649,
-0.018769443,
0.0408118702,
-0.0320843384,
-0.0194418058,
0.0078995833,
0.0197674595,
-0.0163073223,
0.0331776738,
0.0322404318,
-0.0128484666,
0.0102347611,
-0.0065681036,
0.0216724537,
0.0026863513,
0.0253933538,
0.035521131,
0.0173016228,
-0.0024634756,
0.0662949383,
0.0222973656,
0.0284598749,
-0.0115045626,
-0.0199904777,
-0.0182770994,
0.0259845089,
-0.0205065142,
0.015463857,
-0.0114267413,
0.068907246,
-0.026104318,
-0.0045063705,
0.0176057015,
0.017212376,
-0.0491157211,
-0.0502892472,
0.0332647264,
0.0392465703,
-0.016803991,
0.0148420986,
-0.013665203,
0.0353469215,
-0.0088074505,
-0.0229703803,
0.0236356072,
-0.0137642575,
2.422e-7,
0.020653557,
0.0343714878,
0.0209719799,
0.0313216671,
0.0002156467,
0.0194992293,
0.0192831121,
0.0412750617,
-0.0070449682,
-0.0497800149,
0.0176355522,
0.021554783,
0.0102580627,
0.0066543007,
-0.1060751081,
-0.0476850569,
-0.0399546437,
-0.0490869433,
-0.0432521962,
-0.0590083227,
0.0664928034,
0.0498529151,
0.0081861801,
-0.0182277448,
0.0157915242,
-0.0236370452,
0.0429356806,
-0.0074180118,
-0.0270103626,
0.0159890354,
0.0407377854,
-0.0110719604,
-0.0026571397,
0.0402170718,
-0.0319950692,
0.0024350467,
0.0006086298,
0.0417158566,
0.0093327537,
-0.0239100903,
-0.0254766047,
-0.0225542244,
0.0252091512,
-0.0818701759,
0.0551433116,
-0.0448007584,
-0.0043200506,
0.0148248337,
-0.007084643,
-0.0310331229,
0.0076663569,
-0.0476888977,
-0.0047417674,
0.0018851135,
0.0105611784,
0.0048272763,
0.0704068542,
-0.0198063236,
-0.0283819325,
-0.0232834201,
-0.0512249358,
-0.0223672334,
-0.0597620197,
-0.0669959337,
-0.015151659,
-0.0200624522,
0.023303045,
1.739575404e-34,
0.0258052461,
-0.0026757603,
-0.0085656662,
0.0298525915,
0.0215814803,
-0.0208146702,
0.0073040496,
-0.0173995718,
0.0369655937,
-0.0995230675,
-0.0137751084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15262v1 | Enhancing OCR Performance through Post-OCR Models: Adopting Glyph Embedding for Improved Correction | 2023-08-29T12:41:50 | 2023-08-29T12:41:50 | Yung-Hsin Chen, Yuli Zhou | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | The study investigates the potential of post-OCR models to overcome
limitations in OCR models and explores the impact of incorporating glyph
embedding on post-OCR correction performance. In this study, we have developed
our own post-OCR correction model. The novelty of our approach lies in
embedding the OCR output using CharBERT and our unique embedding technique,
capturing the visual characteristics of characters. Our findings show that
post-OCR correction effectively addresses deficiencies in inferior OCR models,
and glyph embedding enables the model to achieve superior results, including
the ability to correct individual words. | [
-0.0100345872,
0.0630700141,
0.0390665606,
0.05427818,
-0.0307151098,
-0.0245756377,
-0.023525307,
0.0262532178,
-0.0220575258,
-0.0035486808,
0.0369070694,
-0.0070343283,
0.0782260373,
0.0086056804,
0.0097473571,
-0.0520440489,
0.0157071389,
-0.0604547784,
-0.0332787298,
-0.0038356311,
0.0240610149,
0.0144415777,
-0.0060935467,
0.0169104561,
0.0060376404,
-0.0085352752,
-0.024501821,
0.0517939888,
0.0240499247,
-0.001400089,
-0.065110378,
0.036959473,
0.0120929768,
0.0559258014,
0.0000015143,
-0.0376542136,
-0.0282959845,
0.0422868803,
0.0052183038,
0.0311896484,
0.0926432386,
-0.0659981221,
-0.0511273257,
0.0234360695,
0.0617333576,
0.0160135068,
0.0644896254,
0.0436169989,
-0.008442671,
0.0079221921,
-0.0457038023,
-0.0053002462,
0.0085453782,
0.0129278759,
-0.0270504747,
0.0104835248,
0.00129632,
0.0054598921,
0.012846237,
0.0159457792,
-0.0355144478,
0.0437762365,
-0.0277548544,
-0.0656768307,
0.0130141471,
0.0440966599,
0.0387038067,
0.0266390648,
-0.0485941656,
0.0220253356,
-0.0637794957,
-0.018125806,
-0.0388258398,
-0.0147292847,
0.018060647,
0.0204126034,
-0.0205686837,
-0.0376639999,
-0.0183404889,
-0.0005370326,
-0.0512130633,
0.0403871201,
-0.0035042588,
-0.030658029,
-0.0308153257,
-0.0345478803,
0.0281215236,
-0.0634346977,
-0.0438143462,
0.0186150782,
-0.0060123624,
0.0120554492,
0.0594701804,
0.0307767875,
0.0761839524,
-0.0086913025,
-0.0832673088,
-0.027162591,
0.0144398557,
-0.0262052361,
0.0909664109,
0.0492383167,
-0.0471092574,
-0.0073911385,
-0.0565455928,
0.083571285,
-0.0415179878,
0.0415260382,
-0.0035864743,
0.00426309,
-0.0412360914,
-0.0261538979,
-0.0597619265,
-0.0073430585,
0.0269776229,
-0.032489419,
-0.0054251258,
0.0098824324,
0.0106977951,
0.0096030636,
-0.001514952,
-0.0046460181,
0.0019708234,
-0.0263236761,
-0.0138163855,
0.0206356775,
0.0252657235,
-0.0160661433,
-0.0218085088,
-0.0181261897,
0.0158513226,
0.00140281,
0.0749397501,
0.025516279,
0.0098109283,
0.0708349645,
-0.0445389114,
-0.0085113579,
0.0522084758,
0.0130074807,
-0.0279153381,
0.0005133469,
-0.0245227981,
-0.0451992825,
-0.0230185576,
-0.0124254674,
0.0128619643,
-0.0357388929,
0.0200381204,
0.0326342769,
-0.0379342362,
0.1193319038,
-0.0356897153,
-0.003974291,
0.0407890305,
-0.0211615637,
0.0149538852,
-0.0105145117,
0.019466199,
0.0082159685,
0.0309805311,
-0.0380231813,
0.0299175307,
0.0488031656,
-0.0416316502,
-0.0498714708,
-0.0119225513,
-0.0395085216,
0.05170203,
0.0588646978,
0.0637585819,
0.0723709613,
-0.0372290425,
-0.0158692691,
0.0856178924,
0.0840109065,
0.0524151772,
-0.0115477443,
-0.0358705632,
-0.0104141915,
0.0287064072,
0.0246732142,
-0.0227592736,
-0.0103943869,
0.0267413668,
0.0211043023,
-0.0124499407,
0.0485072844,
0.0170441214,
-0.0086914841,
-0.0151892072,
-0.0181157645,
-0.0056177299,
-0.0311139338,
0.085098803,
0.0093475524,
-0.1032903567,
-0.0403373539,
-0.0384967364,
-0.0509829521,
-0.0274382886,
-0.0625608936,
0.008925207,
0.1057858914,
0.1509731412,
-0.0124889649,
0.0092118662,
0.0211848021,
-0.0683065131,
0.0318928771,
0.0097648371,
0.0130645642,
-0.0097644906,
-0.0740648061,
-0.0057033794,
0.0386159755,
-0.0223381277,
0.0370396413,
0.0217367075,
0.025571499,
-0.0031352849,
0.0135291507,
-0.0455538779,
0.0465417132,
0.0221519805,
-0.0060099992,
-0.0886742324,
0.0108675444,
-0.0238693766,
0.0011062729,
-0.0438603498,
0.0194238517,
0.0178967677,
-0.0195922647,
0.012916198,
0.0074271075,
-0.0113555305,
-0.001140245,
0.0527837723,
-0.0040215128,
0.0144409584,
0.0141307944,
0.0569910631,
0.0118410829,
-0.0427065939,
-0.0300486982,
0.037098527,
-0.0657031834,
0.0447126813,
-0.0402583629,
-0.0386117585,
-0.0354664624,
-0.010366464,
0.0053757345,
-0.0282066744,
0.0075120861,
0.0003055108,
-0.0059192255,
-0.0415094979,
0.0125444727,
0.0309858918,
-0.0056809387,
0.0202060267,
-0.0280410536,
-0.0082201865,
0.0088866716,
-0.0595676452,
-0.0387140699,
-0.0512108244,
0.0113345729,
-0.0144290058,
0.0088882092,
-0.0066483216,
0.0227391794,
-0.0234771222,
0.0191700254,
-0.0088691656,
0.0059193745,
-0.0204920843,
0.0596347526,
-0.0494748726,
-0.0363341421,
-0.0084106512,
-0.0158551317,
0.013127693,
0.018707376,
0.0206886753,
-0.0841662809,
-0.0800750554,
0.0121504664,
-0.0051238835,
0.0082414122,
0.0045182845,
-0.0404289663,
0.0136104412,
-0.0226645395,
0.0099809989,
0.0520964712,
0.0013820361,
0.0016141593,
-0.0077187605,
-0.0323516987,
0.0168296751,
-0.0225766934,
0.009593403,
0.0154553717,
0.025492331,
-0.0103781568,
-0.0204007514,
-0.0009063807,
-0.0691286325,
0.063524954,
-0.0116929216,
-0.0219510738,
0.0048492462,
-0.0214201026,
-0.0614673607,
-0.0456041135,
0.0000205046,
-0.0143641466,
-0.0547263101,
-0.0519176163,
0.0292107575,
-0.0569874123,
0.004903446,
0.0179248974,
0.0311133806,
0.0119131003,
0.0232203268,
0.008198753,
0.0212038122,
-0.0009981914,
-0.0767178461,
-0.0259088911,
0.0092744809,
0.0224485807,
-0.071657382,
0.0421523452,
-0.0092568174,
0.0481918938,
0.0018576393,
-0.0068813553,
-0.0001703917,
-0.0032383457,
-0.0114527727,
-0.0147072347,
-0.0086989701,
-0.0725607499,
-0.0313182063,
0.0896997824,
-0.0172548499,
0.0581945702,
0.0071231164,
-0.008414275,
-0.0299953632,
0.0567483678,
-0.062635459,
-0.0161391217,
-0.0105040083,
-0.061671745,
0.0166020133,
0.0013107439,
0.0050973906,
-0.0475234874,
0.0229466297,
-0.0011013593,
0.0380560681,
-0.0107911089,
0.003897198,
-0.0266392026,
0.0123022348,
-0.0577116869,
-0.0163911544,
0.0448270887,
0.0066036065,
-0.0129245557,
-0.0517326556,
-0.0045292038,
-0.0033676527,
-0.0268463083,
-0.0082733966,
-0.045114655,
0.0035597328,
0.0567400716,
0.0307977367,
0.0019875129,
0.0346265882,
-0.016851563,
-0.0784270391,
0.0546686687,
0.0313540623,
-0.0099441595,
-0.0621726513,
0.0196103435,
-0.0036411451,
0.0198568385,
-0.0475602038,
0.0401460417,
-0.0246657059,
-0.0508282371,
0.0152365351,
-0.0592453368,
-0.0002273325,
-0.064696312,
-0.0160846114,
-0.0268122703,
0.0864320546,
0.0167479701,
0.0304524954,
-0.0200679637,
-0.0097220568,
-0.0042501912,
0.0317105576,
-0.0118792308,
0.0850026682,
0.025655549,
-0.0230841134,
-0.0401070006,
0.0025280386,
-0.0161268506,
-0.02033839,
-0.0429267101,
-0.0192580223,
-0.0118020615,
0.0348417833,
-0.0135562364,
-0.0303461067,
-0.0453295074,
-0.0116500119,
0.0062864656,
-0.0133028515,
-0.0637145936,
-0.0441730879,
0.0524727516,
-0.058212772,
-0.0201903172,
0.0029908193,
-0.0130490754,
-0.04667769,
-0.0066824132,
-0.0302549805,
0.0317225978,
0.0479072668,
-0.0153919719,
0.0072943936,
0.0035193106,
0.0502727926,
-0.0616470017,
-0.052817896,
-0.0448770449,
0.0185528379,
-0.0719686151,
0.0273677129,
-0.0251353364,
0.0106490012,
-0.0001263354,
-0.0339705944,
-0.0129087009,
-0.0300629418,
0.04315193,
0.0473443121,
0.0247475486,
-0.0089697978,
-0.0323430188,
-0.0495827235,
0.070531249,
0.0149084888,
0.0526317954,
0.0037013888,
-0.0154645815,
-0.0402726121,
-0.0046404325,
-0.0147673553,
0.0320793167,
-0.0085452525,
-0.0386350937,
-0.0424908288,
0.0108122425,
-0.0253799111,
0.0326857902,
-0.0262358934,
-0.0059067486,
-0.0246320888,
0.0247939564,
-0.0380119495,
0.0214921981,
-0.0319887921,
0.0212851521,
-0.031900987,
-0.0020168265,
0.0261010956,
0.0132201565,
-0.011359348,
-0.0227963645,
-0.0271856338,
0.0066357288,
-0.0463116094,
0.0197334588,
0.0153649589,
0.0468673855,
0.0155264912,
0.0241184831,
0.0517429449,
0.0346656181,
-0.0242471565,
0.0112379231,
0.0002707418,
-0.0039732782,
-0.0217815693,
0.018119717,
-0.0059210062,
0.0224381946,
-0.070066914,
0.0127839092,
-0.0618681163,
0.0429635234,
0.0659376904,
0.0288685858,
0.0184761416,
-0.0139449816,
-0.0264026001,
-0.0243005995,
-0.0292894039,
0.0092397304,
0.0219707359,
-0.0384330153,
0.0343009308,
0.0147972591,
-0.0539118461,
0.0407106429,
0.0012841115,
0.0094471984,
-0.029546449,
-0.0282038525,
-0.0185664371,
0.0150663098,
0.0476319753,
-0.0217752811,
-0.0363280959,
-0.048143018,
0.0139299966,
-0.0374685228,
0.0750655979,
0.0269044563,
0.0291669257,
-0.0038118025,
-0.0292357989,
-0.0262923967,
-0.0222088918,
0.0171741974,
0.0261093024,
-0.0056522256,
-0.0198908057,
-0.0484012514,
0.0430118069,
-4.515829424e-33,
-0.0030647705,
-0.0379515886,
-0.0284745656,
-0.0143593261,
-0.0087460661,
0.0332873017,
0.0242041349,
0.0031177704,
0.0264606345,
0.0209202152,
-0.0004898129,
0.0103516439,
0.0488210507,
-0.0082159434,
-0.0005305852,
0.0312046781,
0.0774922073,
-0.0048515797,
-0.0060753864,
-0.0546548963,
-0.0060426705,
0.0581185706,
0.006470541,
-0.0550727285,
-0.0053528827,
-0.0254852492,
-0.037725471,
-0.0510875098,
0.0583075397,
0.0375719033,
0.0237497576,
0.0453495421,
0.0198133402,
0.045512706,
-0.0024273603,
0.0802324265,
-0.0700583979,
0.0583300106,
-0.0515994057,
0.0602462627,
-0.0091599133,
-0.0233264863,
-0.0224510133,
-0.0450295135,
-0.0180737786,
-0.0240799636,
0.0155687686,
-0.0177750532,
-0.0130646667,
0.0365304798,
-0.0507162139,
0.0168229006,
0.0188138783,
-0.0257733744,
0.0879596844,
-0.0356969275,
0.0457461886,
0.0166991651,
-0.0442291424,
0.0143912835,
0.0471653007,
0.0184373483,
0.0217661597,
0.0420703143,
-0.0235334784,
-0.0135766249,
-0.0116150454,
0.0205216203,
-0.004291459,
-0.0114667676,
0.0381649956,
-0.020178983,
0.0807291269,
0.0253986139,
0.0779028162,
-0.0317974836,
-0.0225585066,
0.0237255078,
-0.0569745079,
0.0087372651,
0.0280140303,
0.0324134603,
-0.0103308288,
0.0131642455,
-0.013155967,
-0.0106348684,
-0.0010057094,
-0.0088656778,
0.0439770222,
0.0229724459,
0.0024528955,
0.0263758637,
0.0426044799,
-0.0386981256,
0.004357649,
-0.0572990775,
0.0074708145,
0.087476477,
-0.0509934016,
-0.0059575853,
-0.0159635842,
-0.0223852154,
0.0293894242,
0.0387887508,
-0.0191584732,
-0.0332670324,
0.0088166976,
0.0185157917,
-0.0755072832,
0.0024789476,
0.0015335638,
-0.0031012162,
0.0557745136,
0.0456226654,
0.0292279515,
-0.034950275,
0.0390570536,
0.0079787737,
0.0379741304,
0.0180073455,
0.0063152546,
-0.0318521224,
-0.012509834,
-0.0211791154,
-0.0075662946,
0.0230135862,
-0.0181129985,
0.001989099,
-0.0329728387,
-0.0187045168,
-0.0022201815,
0.006063831,
2.003e-7,
0.0669139698,
0.0533965677,
0.0942169353,
0.020954052,
0.0022446185,
-0.034036871,
0.0087566767,
-0.0068124626,
0.0048942231,
-0.0262366589,
0.0780685991,
0.0026520919,
0.1027951986,
-0.0142838415,
-0.0162068233,
-0.0200482737,
0.0048161494,
0.0149340546,
-0.0210587494,
-0.0004426378,
0.0602440946,
-0.0031481842,
-0.0517675392,
-0.0352913439,
0.005293183,
-0.0305780638,
0.0750265792,
-0.0062448001,
0.0276888125,
-0.0342381783,
0.0441780314,
0.0270151142,
-0.0222872533,
0.0368984118,
0.0093388706,
-0.0044996724,
0.0624156892,
-0.0339019038,
-0.0903043002,
0.0355253033,
-0.0369624496,
0.0036574025,
-0.0269670282,
-0.0463380069,
0.0195610821,
0.0369231068,
0.0341156274,
-0.0388341323,
-0.0406038724,
-0.0145652611,
0.0636054799,
-0.0238779448,
-0.0566738024,
0.0388378538,
0.0430699065,
0.0112391058,
-0.0096938442,
-0.0248014387,
0.0102060661,
-0.0213524532,
0.0344080627,
0.0269705337,
-0.0469228476,
-0.0276399851,
0.0622439124,
-0.0234175697,
-0.0088899406,
1.611834295e-34,
0.0182065256,
-0.0186442453,
0.0237856489,
0.0576550961,
0.0169246979,
-0.0202108212,
0.0484287925,
-0.0017286221,
-0.014153827,
-0.0289217718,
-0.0196774099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15246v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15246v2 | A Classification-Guided Approach for Adversarial Attacks against Neural Machine Translation | 2023-08-29T12:12:53 | 2024-02-22T09:27:09 | Sahar Sadrizadeh, Ljiljana Dolamic, Pascal Frossard | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural Machine Translation (NMT) models have been shown to be vulnerable to
adversarial attacks, wherein carefully crafted perturbations of the input can
mislead the target model. In this paper, we introduce ACT, a novel adversarial
attack framework against NMT systems guided by a classifier. In our attack, the
adversary aims to craft meaning-preserving adversarial examples whose
translations in the target language by the NMT model belong to a different
class than the original translations. Unlike previous attacks, our new approach
has a more substantial effect on the translation by altering the overall
meaning, which then leads to a different class determined by an oracle
classifier. To evaluate the robustness of NMT models to our attack, we propose
enhancements to existing black-box word-replacement-based attacks by
incorporating output translations of the target NMT model and the output logits
of a classifier within the attack process. Extensive experiments, including a
comparison with existing untargeted attacks, show that our attack is
considerably more successful in altering the class of the output translation
and has more effect on the translation. This new paradigm can reveal the
vulnerabilities of NMT systems by focusing on the class of translation rather
than the mere translation quality as studied traditionally. | [
0.0113599561,
0.0724021122,
-0.0271707587,
0.0637857243,
-0.0561797507,
0.0046318229,
0.0260361079,
-0.0005910735,
-0.0270093232,
-0.0282499138,
-0.0147112589,
0.0120509751,
0.0389830694,
-0.0027265782,
0.0772561207,
-0.0041360348,
0.0510950908,
0.0246421546,
-0.08177609,
0.0112444963,
-0.0248420369,
-0.0202247389,
0.0441073924,
0.0313183144,
0.0108185178,
-0.009318715,
-0.0117784711,
0.0435501076,
0.0236742683,
-0.0021588646,
0.028420398,
0.0124502368,
0.0089520747,
0.1233468577,
0.0000021074,
0.0083919205,
-0.0630851761,
0.037097849,
0.0066036088,
0.0193822887,
0.0171410926,
-0.0590935759,
-0.0217492636,
0.0116630336,
-0.0389312729,
-0.0195912328,
0.0461639501,
0.0280376878,
0.0868700147,
0.1255564988,
-0.0008698111,
-0.0372074842,
0.0251520406,
-0.0766839758,
-0.0135936597,
-0.0465694852,
0.0053230776,
-0.0203538314,
-0.0840969086,
0.0257865582,
0.0001524275,
0.0667859241,
0.0161405243,
0.0229423586,
-0.0419231653,
-0.0039261193,
-0.0100986464,
-0.0084320633,
0.0129276365,
0.0496347919,
-0.0841913745,
0.0045730746,
-0.0203630421,
0.0093578836,
0.0396894254,
-0.0264393575,
0.0190147758,
-0.0130458334,
0.0388486274,
-0.0056122541,
0.0225892458,
0.0160481296,
0.0577302314,
-0.0162063185,
-0.0167156328,
-0.0089383861,
0.0276721176,
-0.0321496539,
-0.029513441,
-0.0151377376,
-0.0066870367,
-0.0095042968,
0.0295135509,
-0.004322737,
0.0208585523,
0.0274008866,
-0.0734800175,
-0.0552438907,
0.0068449411,
-0.0657501668,
0.047412701,
0.0475004986,
0.0037288384,
0.0251008905,
-0.0142442659,
0.0453918949,
-0.0325606465,
0.0829170793,
-0.056817472,
0.015155361,
-0.0148058534,
-0.0025509088,
-0.003629033,
-0.0184133872,
-0.0077222288,
0.0175072923,
-0.0339337811,
0.0146516617,
-0.0123374965,
0.0358481407,
-0.0449915342,
-0.0075520873,
-0.0657029152,
0.0100216884,
0.0172167346,
0.009156893,
0.0215594415,
-0.0332178958,
-0.0012684308,
-0.0709243864,
-0.0507593714,
0.0054057944,
-0.102402851,
-0.0241324194,
-0.009003723,
0.1428904533,
-0.0059141642,
-0.05786369,
-0.0374476649,
-0.0457413457,
-0.0268643331,
-0.0429224968,
0.0070371972,
-0.026126802,
0.0214281213,
-0.0315879621,
-0.0061345031,
-0.0484933257,
0.0189638175,
-0.000031874,
-0.0092840828,
0.0993701443,
0.027375469,
-0.0332569219,
0.055032488,
0.0375547037,
-0.0270638373,
0.02404253,
0.0290787127,
0.0455468521,
0.0281183813,
-0.0203464851,
0.0016734571,
0.0537816808,
0.0224555768,
0.0007559871,
-0.0370564982,
-0.0002995681,
0.0125273103,
0.0301500652,
-0.0361912251,
0.0514494069,
-0.0199892372,
-0.0475995094,
0.096162267,
-0.0136500262,
-0.0090882946,
0.0797542781,
0.0309414733,
-0.0320335925,
-0.0193879902,
0.0095203752,
-0.0407294556,
-0.0083362097,
-0.0679832101,
-0.032943204,
-0.0071058981,
0.0327318572,
0.0037459731,
-0.0569950119,
0.0344610848,
-0.0040175179,
0.0167592205,
-0.0155120259,
-0.0032935834,
0.0526798256,
-0.0169111621,
0.0234779976,
-0.0067284498,
-0.0177852064,
0.0095290085,
-0.0771088451,
-0.0605162308,
0.0011688845,
0.068417199,
-0.0355355479,
-0.0045172409,
-0.0347881503,
-0.0481910743,
0.0438933894,
0.0647792444,
0.028581718,
0.0087711914,
-0.0305085462,
0.0298006237,
-0.0508809015,
0.0206856988,
0.0449506827,
0.0038350429,
0.0334224626,
0.0411999524,
-0.0312851183,
-0.07400769,
0.0325587913,
0.0345055982,
-0.078480877,
0.052592326,
0.032990478,
0.0339183919,
-0.0106469039,
-0.0330306515,
0.0242043212,
0.0440228917,
-0.012136491,
-0.0284379721,
-0.0074505806,
-0.0013419384,
-0.0512146726,
-0.0069849268,
-0.0237623733,
-0.006047938,
0.0293583442,
-0.058852572,
-0.0084135151,
0.0306509752,
-0.0600098819,
-0.0007789007,
-0.005250589,
0.0397166573,
-0.004803618,
0.019480275,
-0.0424397849,
0.039419543,
-0.020915648,
-0.0372482762,
-0.0058968267,
-0.0091372812,
0.0014310123,
-0.009454011,
-0.0445199683,
0.062164709,
0.0009324316,
0.0272052716,
0.0145261521,
0.0107570114,
0.0125514641,
-0.0517494455,
0.0274865292,
-0.0076456796,
-0.0250166859,
0.0092731519,
0.055947464,
0.0325072221,
0.0021455328,
0.002358604,
-0.0274924953,
0.0224713106,
-0.039184045,
0.0094821639,
-0.0090663861,
-0.00208517,
0.0246712696,
0.009592616,
-0.0137541266,
0.0040356065,
0.0733836517,
-0.0160131473,
-0.0159590617,
-0.0872917026,
0.004489061,
-0.0133507559,
0.0204813089,
-0.0311542954,
-0.0688874647,
0.0228808057,
0.018766487,
-0.0019594547,
0.0943790153,
0.0168751068,
0.0424641706,
0.0482848212,
0.0311478861,
-0.0354783051,
0.0018091539,
-0.0046993112,
-0.012524019,
-0.0256489255,
-0.0419859998,
0.0175244138,
0.0307550635,
0.0454232395,
-0.0018254988,
-0.0219335463,
0.0327133052,
-0.0055821552,
-0.06452021,
-0.0042390656,
0.0165993348,
-0.0102195302,
-0.040010713,
-0.0134722004,
-0.0534209087,
0.072984606,
-0.0287478231,
0.0221674405,
-0.0457530655,
-0.053544756,
0.0112208445,
0.0423597135,
-0.0080558099,
0.0190626588,
0.0151317753,
0.0040250779,
-0.0218892191,
-0.0336652659,
0.0137434518,
-0.0152240703,
0.0193455238,
-0.0479515642,
-0.0421244018,
-0.0007236608,
-0.0024346437,
-0.0242260825,
-0.0148601169,
0.01682657,
0.0022569969,
-0.0069231461,
-0.0251608938,
-0.0419353098,
-0.0274083465,
0.0203431863,
0.0259122569,
-0.0191664193,
-0.0025789794,
-0.0357975028,
0.0182306617,
0.0232628938,
-0.0357778706,
0.0428437889,
-0.0312276594,
0.0296201278,
0.0481201373,
-0.0524113327,
-0.0004181123,
-0.055198092,
-0.0326924808,
-0.0015798628,
0.0042829406,
-0.028759744,
-0.0164688285,
0.0056660711,
-0.0560889766,
-0.022060005,
0.0462245122,
-0.0053501441,
-0.0128123052,
0.0193909165,
0.0342474096,
0.0112607796,
-0.0052408157,
0.0271312241,
-0.0517002717,
-0.0233270694,
0.0262907241,
0.0635854155,
-0.0053963321,
0.0073690927,
-0.0326669849,
-0.059288051,
-0.0177505389,
0.0595899783,
-0.0727458149,
-0.0436153449,
0.0315440334,
-0.0410236083,
-0.04845725,
0.0371856466,
-0.0259670839,
0.0749865249,
-0.0267624147,
-0.0314154364,
0.0461679101,
-0.0341951028,
-0.0124239903,
-0.0210533161,
0.0082873758,
0.0811713561,
0.0278933235,
-0.0126943346,
-0.0085077975,
0.0423443988,
-0.0313159153,
-0.0024853984,
0.023565352,
0.0376641341,
0.000694292,
-0.026569657,
0.0607702285,
-0.0091378503,
0.0058915378,
0.0248003975,
0.0210986882,
0.0371539108,
-0.0098032551,
-0.0210749973,
-0.0085453559,
-0.0284347236,
0.0250241309,
0.0437644906,
-0.0012611408,
-0.0444802642,
-0.0205334239,
-0.0678892955,
-0.0062466203,
-0.0258777756,
-0.0349305682,
0.0009154163,
-0.0158606358,
-0.0664433688,
-0.0776056498,
-0.050577648,
-0.029972747,
0.0327354446,
0.0199080072,
-0.0079308283,
0.0092427041,
0.0016372047,
-0.00994852,
0.0188412499,
-0.0327445827,
0.0379705168,
-0.0160701778,
0.0023189425,
0.0214532185,
-0.0222114753,
0.0160488356,
0.0056799906,
-0.0789334103,
-0.0846077427,
-0.016144203,
0.0552715547,
0.0132955257,
0.0568086728,
-0.0567453019,
-0.0358558632,
0.0407979377,
0.0378883928,
0.0187747385,
0.0004317312,
0.0554219,
-0.0237929448,
-0.000020615,
0.0503542088,
-0.0133911688,
-0.0028017419,
0.0521730147,
0.0156930126,
-0.0543749742,
0.0025916011,
0.0504575558,
-0.0069042025,
0.0543365702,
0.0023689426,
-0.007330189,
0.0336444341,
0.0190037489,
-0.0119611174,
-0.0268969834,
-0.0262548458,
-0.002894084,
0.04656405,
0.0238128658,
0.0207795035,
-0.0149226207,
0.0116435112,
-0.0175854247,
-0.0037389547,
-0.0362787023,
-0.0017221541,
0.0255949963,
-0.0020205514,
0.032419771,
-0.0014244756,
0.0554434247,
-0.0042064241,
0.0305245463,
-0.0181952175,
0.0506573468,
0.017997073,
0.0129747065,
-0.0101580294,
0.0376520343,
-0.0485736132,
-0.008776336,
-0.0193811934,
0.029248802,
0.0259708464,
-0.0064747618,
0.0105384327,
-0.0082387198,
-0.0149661191,
-0.0107065197,
-0.0055737682,
0.0343202651,
-0.0251379684,
0.0044985255,
-0.009389529,
0.0164545812,
0.0249043647,
0.0226253103,
-0.0270361993,
0.0454062894,
0.0043883161,
-0.0368911102,
-0.0392648242,
-0.012805054,
0.0350133367,
-0.0443380773,
-0.0128945699,
-0.0299385693,
-0.0206910241,
-0.0751598328,
-0.0005061136,
0.0220089965,
0.0719104707,
0.011701256,
-0.0229663923,
0.0690188631,
-0.0209421851,
0.0358512253,
-0.0698887557,
0.0437068939,
0.014930564,
-0.0600082763,
-0.0058341548,
-5.911597457e-33,
-0.0064802361,
0.0050174608,
-0.0359694511,
-0.0110259,
0.0073137414,
0.0034727086,
-0.0065138154,
-0.0187397376,
-0.0280389208,
-0.0086143445,
0.0165659264,
0.0189244896,
-0.0131653771,
-0.0064576943,
-0.0245340839,
-0.0398646183,
0.0323386453,
0.0223488118,
-0.0453466102,
0.011596431,
0.0612296499,
0.0021923934,
0.0900175422,
-0.0658540204,
0.0512868613,
0.0090775155,
-0.0564030744,
0.0044001471,
-0.0683715791,
0.0021949254,
0.0145855108,
0.0141118793,
-0.0016927017,
0.0065488741,
-0.0126708383,
-0.0115080364,
-0.0040341341,
0.0167445671,
0.0100237634,
0.048155237,
-0.021065874,
-0.065199919,
0.0594659671,
-0.0375863053,
-0.0287236068,
-0.0061888392,
-0.0257713608,
-0.0278187431,
-0.0341201834,
-0.0084738163,
-0.0434848666,
0.0050350903,
-0.0188271366,
-0.0345073305,
0.0051587448,
0.0151272323,
0.0049059824,
-0.033702828,
-0.1105376258,
0.0134405093,
0.0283247363,
0.0351588763,
0.0486411825,
0.0218301378,
-0.0051426124,
0.0098612588,
0.0510412604,
0.0038965393,
0.0342673771,
0.0339583047,
0.0136548923,
-0.0046025803,
0.1317138374,
0.0428130627,
0.0675448403,
-0.0337994322,
-0.0424091406,
0.0030654939,
-0.018419899,
-0.0187237654,
0.0155598139,
0.0158016235,
-0.0471751355,
0.0265534706,
-0.0287379697,
-0.0973388255,
-0.0290287323,
-0.0102793137,
0.0013588293,
0.0263413955,
-0.0255149435,
-0.0098987818,
0.0228645243,
-0.0363598056,
0.0579505824,
-0.0090857297,
-0.0465152375,
-0.0361294895,
0.0032292546,
0.0177717973,
0.0357281901,
-0.0107962536,
0.0256570932,
-0.0278054904,
0.0342101231,
-0.0051218923,
0.0625707731,
0.0360730961,
-0.01155122,
-0.0104279807,
-0.0274600387,
0.016749721,
0.0235001333,
-0.0131192049,
0.0305288807,
-0.0208482165,
-0.0146200312,
-0.0044276714,
0.045229435,
0.0280497279,
-0.0223036259,
0.0702732876,
-0.0060094791,
0.0188580938,
-0.048491206,
-0.0015315065,
0.0050804061,
0.0361509621,
0.0588940904,
-0.0816392452,
-0.0116169127,
-0.038305115,
2.941e-7,
0.0267686024,
0.0398362242,
-0.0340204276,
0.0157482941,
0.025922101,
0.0691780522,
-0.0273858402,
0.0686665103,
-0.0016546542,
-0.0096341232,
-0.0041451007,
-0.0187260862,
0.0864285603,
0.0007427317,
-0.0607146472,
0.0101557216,
-0.047363352,
0.0402449816,
-0.0534029156,
0.0265474189,
0.054601483,
0.12403512,
0.0101972101,
-0.0128645655,
-0.021389503,
-0.062995702,
0.0355618298,
-0.0036263776,
-0.0151550183,
-0.019191131,
0.065354526,
0.0576367229,
-0.0148218945,
0.0025727421,
-0.0451568589,
-0.0200048555,
0.0317807645,
0.0471769795,
0.0070920489,
0.0065886048,
-0.0365026146,
-0.0259265359,
0.0142206168,
-0.0216620676,
0.048033122,
-0.0240458567,
-0.0051099109,
-0.005113204,
-0.0168110803,
0.0200807322,
0.0837102383,
-0.0421750508,
-0.0200801063,
0.0017533959,
0.0205248594,
0.0191054828,
0.0090322336,
-0.0482212529,
-0.0271863267,
-0.0329300128,
-0.0210091658,
-0.0019851972,
-0.0231579132,
0.0134808645,
0.0203805771,
-0.0123177161,
-0.0409507714,
2.550269892e-34,
0.0006299685,
-0.0390219837,
0.0231616329,
-0.024319483,
0.0494616106,
-0.0079847956,
-0.0124934418,
-0.0136583578,
-0.0140541913,
-0.0425860398,
-0.0446928926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15235v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15235v1 | PronounFlow: A Hybrid Approach for Calibrating Pronouns in Sentences | 2023-08-29T11:46:27 | 2023-08-29T11:46:27 | Nicos Isaak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.0; I.2.3; I.2.7; I.5.1; I.5.4 | Flip through any book or listen to any song lyrics, and you will come across
pronouns that, in certain cases, can hinder meaning comprehension, especially
for machines. As the role of having cognitive machines becomes pervasive in our
lives, numerous systems have been developed to resolve pronouns under various
challenges. Commensurate with this, it is believed that having systems able to
disambiguate pronouns in sentences will help towards the endowment of machines
with commonsense and reasoning abilities like those found in humans. However,
one problem these systems face with modern English is the lack of gender
pronouns, where people try to alternate by using masculine, feminine, or plural
to avoid the whole issue. Since humanity aims to the building of systems in the
full-bodied sense we usually reserve for people, what happens when pronouns in
written text, like plural or epicene ones, refer to unspecified entities whose
gender is not necessarily known? Wouldn't that put extra barriers to existing
coreference resolution systems? Towards answering those questions, through the
implementation of a neural-symbolic system that utilizes the best of both
worlds, we are employing PronounFlow, a system that reads any English sentence
with pronouns and entities, identifies which of them are not tied to each
other, and makes suggestions on which to use to avoid biases. Undertaken
experiments show that PronounFlow not only alternates pronouns in sentences
based on the collective human knowledge around us but also considerably helps
coreference resolution systems with the pronoun disambiguation process. | [
0.0477737747,
0.036419604,
-0.039664194,
0.0169903338,
-0.0235844236,
0.0017253653,
0.0149697931,
-0.048877608,
0.0116158566,
-0.0190530997,
0.0131577086,
-0.0103801182,
0.0146468226,
-0.0247817878,
0.021595737,
-0.0189431906,
0.0363973081,
0.0272517875,
0.0107280174,
-0.0121549526,
0.0112621356,
0.0435883775,
-0.0010827646,
0.0282334797,
-0.0309058074,
-0.0285415612,
-0.0051193824,
0.0378996581,
0.0144553827,
0.0471761413,
0.0128544439,
0.036161501,
-0.0001998001,
0.0485647954,
0.0000020235,
-0.0580177568,
0.0330953673,
-0.0057879714,
-0.022868067,
-0.0189337768,
-0.0137636904,
0.027640881,
-0.0106043071,
-0.0144671639,
-0.0150560737,
0.0169618018,
0.0348017961,
0.0093190866,
0.0478395671,
0.0413422585,
-0.009278968,
-0.0119018741,
-0.0344975218,
-0.0122499848,
-0.0236737859,
-0.0530851968,
0.0006049365,
-0.0620072968,
-0.0080584539,
-0.0438269265,
-0.0365211405,
0.0538592897,
0.0563487709,
-0.0123827597,
0.019906925,
0.0202428363,
-0.0125949867,
-0.0533305369,
-0.0300700143,
0.0686549917,
0.0413022898,
-0.0060313372,
0.0245109741,
0.0084129293,
-0.0010105197,
-0.0432812013,
0.020202117,
0.0181160942,
-0.0153444093,
-0.0127686271,
-0.0256715547,
-0.0622835979,
-0.0008166016,
0.0406346992,
-0.0246581398,
0.088781096,
-0.0125765288,
-0.0269265436,
0.0806123763,
0.041240178,
-0.0091051972,
-0.0568875708,
0.0831930563,
0.0217635296,
-0.0270100981,
0.0170843061,
-0.0192746762,
-0.0376341082,
-0.0162380058,
-0.060614977,
0.0164200217,
0.0192956142,
-0.0148887672,
0.0321880281,
-0.0098266741,
0.0302094352,
-0.0129667781,
0.0444695242,
-0.0386574678,
-0.0357849412,
-0.0430526212,
-0.0190468132,
-0.0619357489,
0.0326167457,
-0.0379712321,
0.0089698592,
-0.0410592109,
0.0061151539,
-0.0264885221,
-0.0085439868,
-0.0179833584,
0.0364173204,
-0.0110424347,
0.0158744846,
-0.0027688895,
0.1006863788,
-0.0795326456,
0.0236027408,
-0.0457938164,
-0.0558733307,
0.0131453611,
0.0146915978,
-0.0241896287,
-0.0263725445,
-0.0076108053,
0.0460848361,
-0.0018125471,
-0.0128954249,
0.0017844004,
-0.0708910152,
-0.044025898,
-0.0695437789,
-0.0208299663,
-0.0565454215,
0.0301935244,
0.0296662524,
0.0189144015,
-0.1017296389,
0.0354093052,
0.0031162263,
-0.008224098,
0.0346916132,
0.0003193623,
0.0134313069,
0.039971631,
0.0123759117,
0.0132845026,
0.0563763678,
0.0801946372,
-0.0063583087,
0.0203364342,
0.019157486,
-0.0142182503,
0.0105698016,
0.0131605929,
-0.0294033196,
0.0129862037,
-0.0135685196,
-0.0459329672,
0.0766829029,
0.0523983166,
0.0559444241,
0.0306797121,
-0.040431194,
0.0367561318,
0.0390309393,
-0.0094691571,
0.0113147916,
0.0262415111,
-0.0259132609,
0.0289405249,
0.0355710909,
-0.0532967485,
0.0137088681,
0.0113324933,
-0.0447771363,
-0.011949623,
0.023036126,
-0.004486131,
-0.0415399559,
0.0079464791,
0.0230190922,
-0.0158029646,
-0.0117548285,
0.0238218307,
0.0163334049,
0.045436509,
0.0549760163,
0.0255743936,
-0.0579549931,
0.0371525958,
-0.008155141,
-0.0040384,
0.0201700255,
0.0088174613,
-0.0056967246,
-0.009043253,
-0.0242548641,
0.0126050636,
0.0197812375,
0.0518130884,
0.0021102703,
0.0385102853,
-0.0191803575,
0.0003623772,
0.0513659827,
0.0063988655,
0.0117486492,
-0.0074545001,
0.0366064347,
0.0166520458,
-0.0162095279,
-0.0191355851,
0.0312866755,
0.0100206006,
-0.0087482966,
0.0409837775,
0.0446791314,
0.0085300086,
0.0282657538,
-0.0242776219,
-0.0070529669,
0.0259985328,
-0.0066143968,
-0.0370887257,
0.0445902832,
-0.0271486696,
0.0080132894,
0.0326415561,
-0.0655235574,
-0.0692709088,
0.0314296521,
-0.030593371,
-0.044473514,
0.053770382,
-0.0803444088,
-0.0181479882,
-0.0214366484,
0.0069572204,
0.0101765087,
-0.0144637888,
-0.0105733136,
0.0213602688,
0.0053610811,
-0.0101703973,
-0.0196525529,
-0.0004393188,
0.0097300969,
-0.0411114953,
-0.0283997599,
0.0145691568,
0.002631546,
0.0216671526,
0.014438835,
-0.0289435368,
-0.0455806218,
-0.026262179,
-0.0410517827,
0.0017816179,
-0.0081759663,
-0.0026003285,
-0.0027443736,
0.0090542724,
-0.0004959418,
-0.0216327216,
0.0164757166,
0.0359083004,
-0.0027675536,
0.0130997496,
0.0211692769,
0.0051215775,
0.0037703281,
-0.0006517752,
0.004636494,
-0.0963427573,
0.0303270686,
0.0443171337,
-0.0306354277,
-0.0151736122,
-0.0205335431,
-0.0514717288,
-0.0089951102,
0.0382169448,
-0.0011783564,
0.0308462977,
0.0157911852,
0.0343829319,
0.0839083269,
-0.0177697279,
0.0354837552,
0.0301569179,
-0.0389757231,
-0.0306828115,
0.0227243267,
0.0182786025,
-0.0659030974,
-0.0352676734,
-0.0401891991,
-0.0055803061,
0.0529093258,
0.0239232611,
-0.0242292155,
-0.0086452411,
0.0641349554,
-0.0553292893,
-0.0507649705,
-0.0229717847,
-0.0295644533,
-0.0218959097,
0.0428739265,
-0.0518829152,
0.0161711331,
0.1037922204,
0.0329541191,
-0.0195713788,
-0.0508970805,
-0.0035544066,
-0.0259194355,
0.0518339761,
-0.0147816138,
0.0403225161,
0.0622053482,
-0.0559254363,
-0.0562895872,
-0.0144815696,
-0.0073829754,
-0.0048925234,
0.0484523475,
-0.0800751895,
0.0196467377,
-0.0067855869,
-0.0465193987,
-0.0146997403,
0.0082591847,
-0.0490989909,
-0.0073288823,
-0.0187507365,
-0.0069292579,
-0.018889796,
-0.0206448194,
0.0223685484,
0.0047530439,
-0.0037635795,
-0.0068599447,
-0.0374772996,
0.0245483797,
-0.0006610779,
0.0365961678,
0.0326830111,
0.0039891573,
-0.008434711,
0.0497973822,
0.0207041111,
-0.0008209405,
-0.0285085551,
0.0210965928,
0.0130554605,
-0.0722147301,
0.0047501512,
-0.0039049375,
0.0540775545,
-0.0981306434,
-0.0177457463,
0.0935255215,
0.0390043706,
-0.0468383729,
0.0046183849,
-0.0125983087,
-0.0183066744,
0.0270756595,
0.0200126301,
-0.0802466571,
-0.0140065029,
0.0233594663,
-0.0057891766,
-0.019627288,
-0.0557741337,
-0.018418923,
-0.0900119618,
0.0149254762,
0.0030911562,
-0.0945621431,
-0.045056425,
-0.0206590313,
0.0226605292,
-0.0226370022,
-0.0013599043,
0.022631079,
0.0060199853,
0.0115039628,
-0.0188250151,
0.0166590977,
0.0150846187,
0.0024942476,
-0.0905379131,
0.0233646352,
0.0439967848,
0.0804071873,
0.0074914978,
0.0277895592,
0.0076192068,
-0.0448473692,
-0.0032043094,
-0.0167484861,
0.0064424593,
-0.0090269791,
-0.0274087917,
-0.0508607365,
0.0536774732,
0.0062804879,
0.004838007,
0.031926129,
0.0527948774,
0.006788488,
-0.0356412567,
-0.013581696,
0.0291095991,
0.006959938,
0.0531698912,
0.0456137098,
-0.0369346999,
-0.0473266244,
-0.0500743426,
0.0127616683,
0.0122044506,
-0.0549221188,
-0.0040189712,
0.029871067,
-0.0582861789,
-0.042763792,
-0.0619292222,
0.0284323227,
0.0254226737,
0.0409369022,
-0.0470115505,
0.0459227785,
-0.0118965553,
-0.0542230941,
0.0081096618,
-0.0530599318,
0.0456609651,
-0.0131229311,
0.0160822868,
0.0085857781,
0.0601493455,
-0.0289672669,
0.0549852774,
-0.0185046624,
-0.0481105708,
0.0112494957,
0.0260997284,
0.0272696931,
-0.007734532,
-0.0629801303,
-0.0682409033,
0.0069207139,
0.0584750399,
-0.0409878306,
0.0352322124,
0.0063670846,
0.016694624,
-0.0195393376,
0.0589079931,
-0.0010439709,
0.0126558691,
0.000713482,
0.0131438626,
-0.0475265607,
-0.0745882541,
0.0278681256,
-0.0008904443,
-0.0337891988,
-0.0019848533,
0.0248571951,
-0.0326356366,
-0.0047629145,
-0.0112660201,
-0.0358478799,
0.0279012937,
-0.015644731,
0.0069351615,
0.03661732,
0.0024926357,
-0.0370649695,
0.0061812918,
0.0352514908,
0.0321144126,
-0.0045090327,
0.0907295197,
0.0244976711,
-0.0328550339,
0.0111990739,
0.0144820884,
0.010276882,
0.0126079367,
0.0584244505,
-0.0111498162,
0.0024063766,
0.0135060241,
-0.020680096,
-0.0131086679,
-0.0395713635,
-0.0721112192,
-0.0222010259,
0.0045059198,
-0.010096834,
0.0610758401,
0.0121086976,
0.0337008052,
-0.0085631004,
-0.0133419093,
-0.0020175031,
0.0033578186,
-0.0186042804,
0.0162444655,
-0.0164403208,
0.0032966938,
0.0222628657,
-0.0286774524,
0.000986025,
0.0014765473,
0.0346398577,
0.0504454784,
-0.0146713937,
-0.0275008585,
-0.0440047048,
-0.0704186335,
-0.0353992805,
-0.011290757,
0.0300020017,
-0.0823725238,
-0.0446715839,
0.0707647726,
-0.0248872973,
0.0499950275,
-0.0194902681,
0.0131605547,
0.0234622452,
0.0157686565,
-0.0920236781,
-0.0249228813,
0.0376250781,
-0.0244804565,
-0.0207532626,
-0.0508015044,
-6.25750467e-33,
-0.0828989819,
-0.0267419778,
-0.0114524411,
-0.0183714703,
-0.0469158366,
-0.0022458038,
-0.0466507673,
-0.0060937265,
0.0000255078,
0.0453941748,
-0.0273162909,
0.0357410833,
0.0231663678,
-0.0160658062,
0.0232374854,
-0.0129323853,
0.0517059527,
0.0152155282,
-0.0223438162,
-0.0150068235,
0.0453455523,
0.0494440533,
0.063579604,
-0.0827287957,
0.020493973,
0.0384246036,
-0.0167195108,
0.0435792953,
-0.0349963233,
-0.0086210398,
0.036540769,
0.0801948309,
-0.0021324928,
0.0024058816,
0.0206291918,
0.0931967348,
-0.1099093333,
-0.0547570959,
0.0379058532,
0.0573758371,
0.0225747395,
-0.0470772013,
0.0787831545,
-0.0289003085,
0.0003297732,
-0.003318002,
0.0802255347,
0.0024674193,
0.0425467081,
-0.0320054851,
-0.0277137086,
-0.0253561344,
-0.038801726,
-0.0089891562,
-0.0325304344,
0.0307075121,
-0.025227977,
-0.0479906835,
-0.1185092032,
-0.0007698461,
-0.046550747,
0.0014488413,
-0.0001349693,
0.0010313361,
0.0097641936,
0.0086787008,
0.035050448,
-0.0122966561,
-0.0610183328,
0.0176468492,
0.039848242,
0.0051693227,
0.0428040028,
0.0549279787,
0.0120904744,
0.0020636593,
-0.050407514,
-0.0319713764,
0.0490310602,
0.0552123748,
0.0057637845,
-0.0338290408,
-0.0267660078,
-0.0368179306,
-0.0644410104,
-0.1184065118,
-0.0341188014,
-0.0160370544,
-0.0206709132,
-0.0505562723,
-0.0391459391,
0.0334892385,
-0.0122065805,
-0.0640403181,
-0.0572682656,
-0.0072063664,
0.0451923758,
0.0305961333,
0.0347744375,
0.0391479544,
-0.0364698209,
0.0207724236,
0.00216229,
0.048898112,
0.0540178306,
0.0120210787,
0.0175566766,
-0.0077808951,
-0.0220899824,
-0.0114266919,
-0.0369587392,
0.0171461366,
-0.011900384,
0.0078295274,
0.0413809493,
0.0475852787,
-0.0243283138,
-0.0141776642,
0.0517737158,
0.0403120182,
-0.0500285737,
0.0071761128,
-0.0205650274,
0.0531092845,
-0.0193683561,
-0.0097302478,
-0.0209049564,
0.0444132537,
0.0718066245,
-0.0531433001,
-0.0021489656,
-0.0286901183,
2.796e-7,
0.0289882161,
0.0122663714,
0.0580452494,
0.0047033755,
0.0134912226,
0.0087812608,
0.0128143998,
0.0318021514,
0.0192907676,
-0.0509424955,
-0.0279624462,
0.0757892206,
0.0312617868,
0.0332295261,
-0.0693889111,
-0.0027434791,
-0.0263820086,
0.052768264,
-0.0530332699,
0.0585683063,
0.0122977272,
0.0634410754,
0.110862188,
-0.0286221579,
-0.0323670655,
-0.007666314,
0.0019266992,
0.0289037935,
0.0677903295,
0.0283180475,
0.0319812261,
-0.0026891551,
0.0330737196,
0.0427201018,
0.0264489185,
0.0060856463,
0.0092011318,
0.0337673165,
-0.0110002058,
-0.0054129041,
-0.0412446856,
0.0046749073,
0.011886741,
-0.0039820592,
0.0406872705,
-0.0565984361,
-0.0223818999,
-0.0131655158,
0.0057021007,
-0.010714978,
0.0412362963,
-0.0105244145,
-0.0272012297,
0.0341366567,
0.0044148639,
-0.0080573428,
0.0148156956,
-0.078596063,
-0.0426075794,
-0.0010596676,
-0.0060338434,
-0.0126078455,
0.0156976078,
-0.0100994883,
-0.0058743372,
-0.0526894853,
-0.0119233131,
1.906486763e-34,
0.0024164889,
0.0080492953,
0.0204323903,
0.0243492257,
0.0170113668,
-0.0016485088,
-0.0227196068,
0.0002403706,
0.0184723716,
0.038190376,
-0.0042853244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15232v1 | Classification-Aware Neural Topic Model Combined With Interpretable Analysis -- For Conflict Classification | 2023-08-29T11:40:24 | 2023-08-29T11:40:24 | Tianyu Liang, Yida Mu, Soonho Kim, Darline Larissa Kengne Kuate, Julie Lang, Rob Vos, Xingyi Song | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR | A large number of conflict events are affecting the world all the time. In
order to analyse such conflict events effectively, this paper presents a
Classification-Aware Neural Topic Model (CANTM-IA) for Conflict Information
Classification and Topic Discovery. The model provides a reliable
interpretation of classification results and discovered topics by introducing
interpretability analysis. At the same time, interpretation is introduced into
the model architecture to improve the classification performance of the model
and to allow interpretation to focus further on the details of the data.
Finally, the model architecture is optimised to reduce the complexity of the
model. | [
0.0431382433,
0.0262798034,
-0.0245948192,
0.073507309,
-0.0213827025,
-0.0137148174,
0.0110325208,
-0.0276964698,
-0.0579513013,
0.0020784196,
0.0228966288,
0.0042059519,
-0.0353547186,
0.0545892119,
-0.033553049,
-0.0212706644,
0.070511587,
-0.0010843845,
0.0506397337,
0.036372371,
-0.0225683581,
-0.0379946679,
-0.0101684323,
0.0259595588,
-0.0452168845,
-0.0091605168,
-0.0451825671,
-0.0100777438,
0.0273642521,
-0.0146783832,
0.0005585652,
0.0366329141,
0.0405950807,
0.0314210244,
0.0000022778,
-0.0384029672,
-0.0508075431,
-0.015791731,
-0.0341745466,
0.0017788814,
0.0543936007,
-0.0154991839,
0.0050350837,
-0.0083165206,
-0.0159024466,
0.0288326778,
-0.0057977727,
0.1210702509,
0.0683474094,
0.0510266051,
-0.0148567222,
-0.0187142249,
0.0476824939,
-0.0288214479,
-0.0254686382,
-0.0276749693,
0.0132215926,
0.0094555281,
-0.0298969969,
0.0450394489,
-0.0096009308,
0.015531145,
0.0134145496,
-0.0189981908,
-0.010518414,
-0.0058729621,
0.0097718844,
0.0058304705,
0.0116904862,
0.0248282123,
-0.0066165929,
-0.0023374727,
0.0384090319,
-0.0207549613,
-0.012745969,
-0.0099408831,
-0.0014428137,
-0.0035100316,
-0.0036901634,
0.0305311456,
0.0881956145,
0.0450667553,
0.0199135914,
0.005422784,
-0.0006932486,
0.0162124317,
-0.04351243,
0.0330125988,
-0.0612721778,
-0.0219461974,
0.0244911294,
-0.0177519415,
0.0383414626,
0.007974809,
-0.0124844508,
0.009119913,
0.0019684387,
-0.0448823236,
-0.005086313,
-0.1080143005,
-0.031104479,
0.00797169,
-0.0285848491,
0.0474207737,
0.0726853833,
-0.0018778378,
-0.0292815324,
-0.0059845657,
0.0018914865,
-0.0074667707,
-0.0644733682,
0.0144700771,
-0.0031744603,
0.0265111141,
-0.0051038456,
0.0009833432,
-0.0010277161,
0.0170401949,
-0.0444536433,
-0.0379154943,
-0.0288065095,
-0.0167524591,
-0.0152413994,
0.0005387716,
-0.0444024093,
-0.0126897842,
-0.0388246477,
0.0351870805,
-0.0495859869,
-0.0113062225,
0.0115541602,
-0.0081304871,
-0.0096708359,
0.0125812627,
-0.0414814055,
0.0370717533,
-0.0067231026,
-0.0332043171,
-0.1108863652,
-0.0244947318,
-0.0023825567,
0.0047616996,
0.0308193937,
-0.0319912806,
0.0603037886,
-0.0543554276,
-0.0031506282,
-0.0267965663,
-0.0275006741,
-0.0358803719,
-0.0075483671,
0.0476822928,
-0.0546792075,
-0.0004028734,
0.0698810518,
0.0575332455,
0.0019487467,
0.0568802319,
0.0471688397,
0.0185130201,
0.0591228455,
0.0335861668,
-0.0095845237,
-0.026742192,
0.0144866137,
-0.0222714785,
-0.0273625478,
0.007893079,
-0.0471143983,
-0.0301647056,
0.0178607125,
0.0009856044,
-0.0490111485,
-0.0993655697,
0.0080713825,
-0.0067694695,
0.012725627,
0.0519972667,
-0.0334905274,
0.0399106406,
-0.0255181119,
-0.0157993119,
0.0298227072,
0.020488359,
-0.0517207906,
-0.0585458688,
0.0156224594,
-0.0305413697,
-0.0364399441,
-0.066343911,
0.0120846601,
-0.0309622902,
-0.0057712733,
-0.0384546518,
0.0476455688,
-0.0558243543,
0.0267675854,
0.0454216711,
0.0392643102,
-0.0140950279,
-0.0072504659,
-0.0631350651,
0.0500916131,
0.0303532109,
0.0259014741,
-0.0649933219,
-0.05785634,
-0.0513125844,
-0.0338160917,
-0.0099415546,
-0.004974341,
0.0060231467,
0.0210399404,
-0.0170386862,
-0.0072339675,
-0.0125410305,
0.0400513671,
0.0172629692,
-0.040948201,
-0.0103656556,
-0.0043434389,
0.0260175336,
-0.0430439487,
0.0135030765,
0.0266014189,
0.0243426133,
-0.0004230803,
0.0118379341,
0.0671889558,
0.0231023412,
0.0123584699,
-0.0141762691,
0.0404156111,
-0.0530761704,
-0.0187511034,
0.0013490085,
0.0186391864,
-0.0019645686,
0.0039602974,
-0.0412690155,
0.0085512986,
-0.0248515215,
-0.0259376094,
-0.018084174,
0.0566677935,
-0.0452653505,
-0.0472932607,
-0.0207735002,
-0.0018272592,
-0.0335047655,
-0.0293929316,
-0.0281094685,
0.0503917411,
-0.0426719375,
-0.0301683061,
0.0059372257,
-0.0230414066,
0.0786062106,
-0.0441105925,
-0.002761639,
0.0419838205,
-0.0075230626,
-0.003849708,
0.0246100854,
-0.0724706277,
0.0335831121,
-0.0300857499,
-0.025011044,
-0.0065206243,
0.0039788382,
0.0043244343,
0.0485901833,
-0.0604657941,
0.0027798235,
0.0473012142,
0.0194657985,
0.0029773007,
-0.0359980054,
-0.0098854732,
0.0202229973,
0.0083116526,
0.0169570576,
-0.0319847055,
-0.0101533905,
-0.046437636,
0.0936975256,
0.0211630855,
-0.0732986853,
-0.0403263941,
0.0552723594,
-0.0225148778,
0.0138038946,
-0.0701890886,
-0.025700368,
0.016335031,
-0.0029198772,
0.0215046294,
-0.0201778971,
0.0215214472,
0.1392632723,
0.0643977523,
-0.0462387912,
-0.0330526605,
-0.0110620353,
-0.0002102538,
0.0116695203,
-0.0017467482,
-0.0976098627,
0.0107044699,
0.0854077637,
0.0095199179,
0.0198965985,
-0.0478289463,
0.0149838729,
-0.0429087058,
0.0140431644,
-0.0619140044,
-0.0412037224,
0.0194337685,
0.0477312133,
-0.0115234349,
-0.0316863619,
0.0522078909,
0.0154957259,
0.0602568574,
-0.0630409494,
-0.0178910978,
-0.0364105552,
0.061204005,
-0.0112125007,
-0.0109580029,
0.025471732,
-0.0111797163,
0.0009393169,
-0.045086313,
0.0007107665,
-0.0086409738,
0.044944942,
-0.0543571375,
-0.0028467833,
-0.0161777958,
0.045920033,
-0.0210214164,
-0.0158483405,
0.0292460825,
0.0379299596,
0.0385146886,
0.0387127884,
-0.0041645486,
0.0283683855,
0.0262468699,
0.0001298747,
0.015255807,
-0.0089970743,
-0.014619329,
0.0312665664,
0.0098944521,
-0.0295996685,
0.004007644,
0.0071051517,
-0.0206481908,
0.0141446432,
-0.0056337845,
-0.0556222238,
-0.0879132897,
0.010546227,
-0.0038327943,
-0.0130834868,
-0.0052631022,
-0.0325358994,
-0.0177784581,
-0.0758440122,
0.0455017537,
0.0590821393,
0.0366649963,
-0.0295899827,
0.0323998369,
-0.0484764762,
-0.0619449615,
-0.0197093431,
-0.0045278082,
-0.0258966461,
0.0265447497,
-0.0181544367,
-0.0107778115,
-0.02481585,
-0.0580294095,
-0.0078771682,
0.0183658898,
0.0238046627,
-0.0028169481,
-0.0119522503,
-0.0650673434,
-0.0122712879,
-0.0217056908,
-0.052919548,
-0.0504990965,
0.0127977356,
0.0516963489,
-0.0050067529,
-0.0084188413,
-0.0196545497,
-0.04229974,
-0.0139257759,
0.0034202936,
0.028005112,
0.0093520721,
0.0338393822,
-0.0180602632,
0.0247988235,
-0.0043953592,
-0.0236666277,
0.0128209526,
-0.0121410796,
0.064057,
0.0172388405,
-0.0289011914,
-0.0123758782,
-0.0099030714,
0.0207848921,
-0.0352591686,
-0.0033357607,
0.0649651513,
-0.0674419105,
-0.0017173089,
-0.0167315193,
-0.0365918688,
0.0291112494,
0.0708222389,
0.032911364,
0.0027216212,
-0.0144076161,
-0.0045009935,
0.024397837,
0.0162789356,
0.0578597821,
-0.0152380485,
0.0171270259,
-0.0940759405,
-0.0228649992,
-0.0446907878,
-0.0289070439,
0.0046792198,
-0.0453665033,
0.0024116826,
0.0458544642,
-0.0248948801,
-0.0417142063,
0.058129672,
0.0323053338,
-0.0030808453,
-0.0284149572,
-0.0283551086,
0.0549417846,
0.0237217378,
-0.0404143259,
0.0354110785,
-0.0426154919,
-0.010737041,
0.0075145997,
-0.0047723413,
0.020513881,
0.0102808261,
0.002196922,
-0.0391120017,
-0.0432859175,
0.014268335,
-0.0026328948,
0.0041465941,
0.0482656807,
0.0302796867,
-0.0047133449,
0.0072070817,
-0.0085432744,
0.0627221838,
0.0138594462,
-0.0056232275,
-0.1164740473,
-0.0476659834,
-0.030349819,
-0.046016898,
0.0660717636,
0.062780492,
-0.0897486508,
-0.0902184993,
0.00808933,
-0.0269856583,
0.0357025601,
-0.0369419046,
0.0229155347,
-0.0420997329,
-0.0159499086,
-0.0456189215,
-0.0221722126,
-0.0208906047,
-0.0290629677,
0.0334430225,
0.0185993277,
0.000500792,
0.0567628741,
-0.0455324054,
0.0307030212,
-0.0117494669,
0.0224804636,
-0.0280328766,
-0.0006108102,
-0.0078866202,
0.0583089776,
0.0176556055,
-0.007079232,
-0.0208454169,
0.0232378766,
0.0023951279,
0.0133549469,
0.0209389329,
0.0195890404,
0.0374542624,
0.0233501103,
-0.0126953227,
-0.0199631453,
0.0101877386,
-0.0186188538,
0.0681030825,
0.0059333164,
-0.0258474983,
0.0288095772,
0.0295251012,
-0.0123374611,
0.0063622966,
0.0701808035,
0.0085440809,
-0.0109621203,
-0.0102969874,
-0.0353542157,
-0.0139572155,
0.0198210496,
0.0435396507,
0.0618674494,
-0.0413010828,
0.0190768484,
-0.0425283015,
0.0061889607,
0.0728817359,
0.0015734459,
0.0175906997,
-0.0011431142,
0.0289756935,
0.051237464,
-0.0124020902,
0.0075072306,
-0.0260401331,
0.0127203288,
-0.0191550702,
-0.0057676621,
-0.0084009385,
-6.096245579e-33,
-0.0288344603,
-0.0311792474,
-0.0059363521,
-0.0452946275,
-0.0087333266,
0.0237984974,
-0.0668742284,
-0.0232675802,
-0.029251771,
0.0107261613,
0.0466912389,
0.04083395,
-0.0002255429,
-0.0268954113,
-0.0122926878,
-0.0365976058,
0.0582185127,
0.0231299512,
0.0427049324,
0.0537575968,
0.0854860693,
0.0235433467,
0.0022436422,
-0.1176616102,
0.0152276978,
-0.0007436107,
0.0411406755,
0.0008346326,
0.0467299893,
0.0614659153,
-0.027157627,
0.0126627572,
0.0635277256,
-0.0664135665,
0.0223354902,
-0.0526567288,
-0.0076138023,
-0.066813387,
-0.0025908565,
-0.0165647399,
0.0112512317,
-0.0551115982,
0.0166084208,
0.0273256041,
-0.0093437899,
-0.0061966195,
0.0414665826,
-0.0276795328,
0.0151976617,
-0.0475231297,
-0.0485702492,
0.0600933991,
-0.0246888753,
0.001762395,
0.006054794,
-0.049343247,
0.0302263424,
0.0462046787,
-0.0982641429,
-0.0027055321,
0.0534799583,
0.0107641099,
0.0054641631,
-0.0472522452,
-0.0228077229,
0.04933431,
-0.0348517932,
0.0216029529,
0.0013977767,
-0.0147154517,
-0.000635457,
0.0716533586,
0.0527173877,
0.0271377303,
0.0027112956,
0.0004862809,
-0.1059299409,
0.0230407659,
0.0183884259,
0.0195561554,
0.0385157838,
0.0378929637,
-0.0251174252,
-0.0337508023,
0.0289567858,
-0.0575920679,
-0.0368969701,
-0.0097654387,
0.0144590791,
-0.0255881306,
0.0012989894,
0.0583955124,
0.0484387092,
-0.0254292544,
0.0395368412,
0.0496980548,
0.0387653671,
0.0290233083,
0.0252457112,
-0.002284569,
-0.0336921886,
-0.0203784853,
0.0007254834,
-0.0328090489,
0.0407985263,
0.0223084278,
-0.0095631015,
-0.0413670316,
0.0233908817,
-0.0110165169,
0.0122993616,
-0.0503172725,
-0.0182602517,
0.0072681289,
-0.01682657,
0.00378246,
0.0054276455,
0.067818664,
0.0324812718,
0.0443049334,
0.0276772436,
0.0224188771,
-0.0462309755,
0.0377803743,
0.0333853476,
-0.0065247975,
0.0216766112,
0.0805903524,
0.012933284,
-0.0257025752,
-0.0102349157,
-0.0527607724,
2.902e-7,
0.0278252643,
0.0213016178,
0.0205220953,
-0.0373827554,
0.0649722889,
0.0507830903,
-0.0037164462,
0.025363341,
-0.0151666412,
-0.0229577534,
0.0322132707,
0.0140934009,
-0.0066157542,
0.0559611768,
0.0321056731,
0.0048816181,
-0.0110250292,
-0.0128159467,
-0.0729370639,
0.0204539038,
0.0908238441,
0.0297643226,
0.0528283902,
0.0360368267,
-0.0144332452,
0.0208091196,
0.0187089369,
-0.0255942661,
-0.0382695124,
0.0516602844,
0.069905363,
-0.0081713749,
-0.0188339837,
0.0278321486,
-0.0085817948,
0.0434640497,
-0.0099532921,
0.0314694531,
-0.0065537011,
0.0231064241,
0.0088821342,
-0.0361664705,
-0.0341138691,
-0.0709459037,
0.0425382555,
-0.0771671608,
-0.0475253761,
-0.0130246822,
0.025894681,
0.0043015052,
0.020987602,
0.0134451678,
0.0039004893,
-0.015068003,
-0.0344729908,
-0.038618952,
0.0213412251,
-0.0343416817,
0.0067103473,
0.020035537,
-0.0284239575,
0.0153051708,
-0.0432102345,
-0.0090824673,
0.0620732829,
0.0385016426,
0.0390382037,
2.08298701e-34,
0.0290421527,
0.0172249936,
-0.0447773226,
0.0041298075,
0.0318296254,
0.0237549972,
-0.0924800336,
0.0162330791,
0.0178503767,
0.0048374063,
0.0064434269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15231v1 | Multi-party Goal Tracking with LLMs: Comparing Pre-training, Fine-tuning, and Prompt Engineering | 2023-08-29T11:40:03 | 2023-08-29T11:40:03 | Angus Addlesee, Weronika Sieińska, Nancie Gunson, Daniel Hernández Garcia, Christian Dondrup, Oliver Lemon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | This paper evaluates the extent to which current Large Language Models (LLMs)
can capture task-oriented multi-party conversations (MPCs). We have recorded
and transcribed 29 MPCs between patients, their companions, and a social robot
in a hospital. We then annotated this corpus for multi-party goal-tracking and
intent-slot recognition. People share goals, answer each other's goals, and
provide other people's goals in MPCs - none of which occur in dyadic
interactions. To understand user goals in MPCs, we compared three methods in
zero-shot and few-shot settings: we fine-tuned T5, created pre-training tasks
to train DialogLM using LED, and employed prompt engineering techniques with
GPT-3.5-turbo, to determine which approach can complete this novel task with
limited data. GPT-3.5-turbo significantly outperformed the others in a few-shot
setting. The `reasoning' style prompt, when given 7% of the corpus as example
annotated conversations, was the best performing method. It correctly annotated
62.32% of the goal tracking MPCs, and 69.57% of the intent-slot recognition
MPCs. A `story' style prompt increased model hallucination, which could be
detrimental if deployed in safety-critical settings. We conclude that
multi-party conversations still challenge state-of-the-art LLMs. | [
0.0480714068,
0.0205442663,
-0.0046770847,
0.0175029952,
-0.0446075574,
0.0089623518,
-0.0157009326,
-0.0187099129,
-0.0203808881,
-0.0387824178,
-0.0478431508,
-0.0537887886,
0.0038034883,
0.0297584254,
0.0018509964,
-0.0530754626,
0.0705310553,
-0.0126754791,
0.0230020601,
0.018841207,
-0.0033616035,
0.0413119644,
-0.0478440709,
0.0811995938,
-0.0300280116,
-0.0089324499,
-0.0411178581,
0.0010659695,
0.0328404009,
-0.0469851904,
-0.026022613,
0.0459610261,
0.0495285131,
0.0268837586,
0.0000021449,
-0.0508569069,
-0.036936529,
-0.0203360859,
-0.0352303088,
-0.0750878751,
0.0420256108,
0.0045048017,
-0.0032031804,
0.0148218451,
-0.0315891616,
0.0080778785,
0.0143391239,
0.0817150846,
0.0499153957,
0.0764102414,
-0.0061946064,
-0.0105509618,
-0.013745755,
-0.0012880042,
0.014578226,
-0.0846953914,
-0.0039849435,
-0.0018729639,
0.0438588709,
-0.0271684062,
0.0265358686,
0.0029848246,
-0.0023868808,
-0.0067213424,
0.014956844,
0.0235524084,
-0.0324294791,
-0.0434993133,
-0.0366750136,
0.0646415502,
0.0102227498,
0.0207952149,
0.0312323105,
-0.0105606532,
-0.0044115563,
-0.0171192661,
-0.0216851085,
-0.0048849774,
-0.0241860934,
-0.0028796773,
-0.0229082555,
-0.0042458861,
0.0176827181,
-0.0117331939,
-0.0162050761,
0.0597208664,
-0.0010033323,
-0.009399455,
0.0199205521,
-0.0003686316,
0.0150518725,
-0.068622686,
0.018556755,
0.0469692722,
-0.0555024445,
0.0270090364,
-0.0374006145,
0.0515915602,
0.0151254879,
-0.0189233031,
-0.0060498859,
0.0461226515,
-0.003478565,
0.0364691652,
0.0293036625,
-0.0050247093,
0.0101098055,
0.0334915891,
-0.029472582,
0.0059034051,
-0.0707807317,
0.0132911187,
-0.0448317267,
0.0244241469,
0.0019490254,
-0.0437441729,
-0.0362416506,
0.049398683,
0.0128593156,
0.0217871722,
-0.0006604812,
-0.0133617846,
-0.0206076242,
-0.0025498653,
-0.0058158035,
0.0276049674,
-0.0134676322,
0.0320172422,
0.0071117948,
-0.06992127,
0.0039163791,
0.0190967787,
0.0014521448,
-0.0080878176,
-0.0284843035,
0.0302033331,
-0.0172754284,
-0.0672215968,
0.0174616873,
-0.0445231535,
-0.040372923,
-0.0668742508,
-0.0041971654,
-0.0252502598,
0.0261549857,
-0.0148226712,
-0.0038720032,
-0.0205868501,
0.0292203408,
-0.0024435641,
0.0013358784,
0.0741372183,
-0.0179111138,
0.0072947037,
0.0052099866,
0.0387799256,
-0.0469997637,
0.0632762462,
0.0455272868,
0.0168251675,
0.0004225024,
-0.0202083159,
-0.0016062558,
0.0369799137,
0.0001582899,
-0.0322748348,
0.0458243787,
0.0066605737,
0.0313128158,
0.0354003906,
-0.0236671474,
0.0509123392,
-0.0161443017,
0.0076537016,
0.0710557625,
0.0694786087,
0.0155980466,
-0.0393847935,
-0.0083784079,
0.0146941757,
-0.0106826751,
-0.0029416776,
-0.0243096165,
0.0064658378,
-0.017376164,
-0.0327969044,
-0.0058044079,
-0.0036605538,
-0.0511506386,
0.0109674484,
-0.0151574025,
-0.0334984884,
0.0175934024,
0.0024414682,
0.0529891476,
-0.0343894139,
-0.0557814129,
0.0147937862,
0.0018705034,
-0.0445366353,
-0.0062724077,
-0.0501941592,
0.0077797873,
0.0794283003,
0.0516124442,
-0.0190528836,
-0.0676661953,
-0.0469788648,
-0.0144353639,
0.0161193796,
0.0436277688,
-0.0227316562,
0.0344169848,
-0.0353264362,
-0.0289908927,
0.0205990914,
-0.0180216711,
0.0184468422,
-0.0248309765,
-0.0174447987,
-0.0070018349,
0.0455565751,
0.0339851044,
0.0330946296,
-0.0308624431,
0.0352131203,
-0.0395353027,
-0.0005080106,
0.0634607673,
0.0620541051,
-0.0023317502,
-0.0030082432,
0.0269226059,
-0.0122047998,
0.0086522028,
0.0590702593,
-0.0620194525,
-0.0103553794,
0.044034563,
0.0240818113,
-0.0520439968,
0.0089750476,
0.009663891,
-0.0529116653,
-0.0261289533,
-0.0495539382,
0.0043496331,
-0.0547764301,
0.0417794399,
0.0227852948,
-0.0212029889,
-0.0145282615,
0.0276117679,
0.0008294368,
-0.029663479,
0.0093756681,
-0.0132720927,
0.007333905,
-0.0617652312,
0.0031060048,
0.0438145287,
0.0167878605,
-0.0108469231,
0.0171512067,
0.0191789791,
-0.0616493002,
-0.0435599051,
-0.1228055954,
-0.0202786643,
-0.0290945321,
-0.0039040134,
-0.0109203449,
0.0156562831,
-0.0184796415,
-0.0246252231,
-0.0226177126,
0.0336909518,
0.0203940235,
-0.0099743214,
0.0012755479,
0.0482111387,
-0.0530708022,
-0.0136288553,
0.0503871739,
-0.0338425413,
-0.0401882716,
0.0151558034,
-0.0710422099,
-0.0484565645,
0.0379420891,
-0.0137977703,
0.0296775978,
-0.034843266,
-0.0061178203,
0.0727165565,
-0.012547846,
0.0790836513,
0.015679108,
0.0120275365,
0.0401820168,
0.0372897759,
-0.0211708546,
-0.0523696207,
0.0157512669,
-0.0331420712,
-0.0073815212,
-0.0284058861,
-0.0268702414,
0.0220544171,
0.0452457666,
0.0113761993,
0.0425472185,
-0.0767336711,
-0.0336164981,
-0.0022170735,
-0.0449531712,
-0.0103196939,
0.0052373954,
-0.0670176372,
0.0319056027,
0.040602684,
-0.0205741767,
0.0622796007,
-0.0374644585,
-0.0255241655,
-0.0166594759,
-0.0299996715,
-0.0249222443,
0.0538874678,
-0.0361876115,
0.009669886,
0.0353112109,
-0.0465400517,
-0.0014512932,
0.0007357915,
-0.0240787826,
-0.0386546366,
0.0707311258,
-0.0614312254,
0.0254902951,
-0.0191408377,
-0.009958487,
-0.0309676491,
-0.0629101619,
-0.04828481,
0.0104092211,
-0.0371964127,
-0.0014632161,
-0.0224766843,
0.0258915816,
0.0233052056,
0.0411122702,
0.0213916227,
-0.0002059521,
-0.0459261872,
-0.0098713348,
0.0478401892,
0.0096135354,
-0.0225541815,
-0.0528232455,
0.0653361678,
0.046439562,
0.0631778464,
0.0050927987,
-0.0270548258,
-0.0307982638,
0.0210432392,
0.0061164615,
-0.0172670912,
0.0394844264,
0.1060105339,
-0.0077607562,
0.0020331349,
0.1365605891,
0.0036505146,
-0.064319782,
0.003128289,
-0.0250462797,
0.0194944907,
-0.0066713453,
-0.0186516419,
-0.0766062364,
-0.0491652265,
0.0231820773,
0.0192418713,
-0.0081998277,
-0.0369773209,
-0.0277550146,
-0.0724217296,
0.0270461477,
0.0034497089,
-0.0307906177,
-0.0226091202,
-0.004426559,
0.0355171412,
0.0175795648,
0.0276695546,
0.0003633195,
0.0233266149,
-0.0423926972,
0.0006916467,
-0.0535185263,
-0.0496158339,
0.0503192022,
-0.0353187099,
0.1105033979,
0.0793588758,
0.0387291312,
0.0185385291,
0.0066889627,
0.0235915743,
0.0379087701,
0.0234038569,
-0.0136202713,
0.0145574305,
-0.0484319851,
0.024566941,
0.0113347368,
0.0250066798,
-0.0359458774,
-0.0193900131,
0.0263288058,
0.0598990023,
-0.099016495,
-0.0006975023,
0.0076168342,
0.0531234965,
0.0347565524,
0.0901494175,
0.0058587245,
-0.0250291266,
-0.0013496252,
0.011812998,
-0.005814516,
0.0148881469,
-0.0241777226,
0.0078845937,
-0.03580584,
0.0058872546,
-0.0217556134,
-0.0865717679,
0.073631078,
0.0162072852,
-0.0028050148,
0.0084437476,
0.0152479075,
0.0427059121,
0.0101909591,
0.0268661082,
-0.0257929824,
0.0298618227,
-0.0606239364,
-0.0252821837,
-0.0110504767,
-0.0199088473,
0.0382912233,
0.0209808685,
-0.0389997549,
-0.0343459919,
-0.0125472639,
0.032861907,
0.0261477157,
0.0305198859,
0.0112340301,
-0.023403395,
-0.0656671077,
-0.0001525286,
-0.0104690259,
0.0179431289,
0.0070922631,
0.0488649048,
-0.0256882776,
0.0279259998,
-0.0158710163,
0.0285271853,
-0.0083224075,
0.0416530743,
-0.0621716492,
-0.0771956816,
0.0220364202,
0.0127235446,
0.0477924533,
-0.0242764503,
-0.0153431017,
-0.0175736658,
-0.0036664843,
-0.061154034,
0.0155113898,
-0.0722584799,
-0.0327293016,
-0.0066730874,
-0.0423125513,
0.0298202187,
-0.0412423573,
-0.076632753,
0.0002840813,
-0.053448569,
0.0053903111,
0.0007827084,
-0.0056257672,
0.0145519217,
-0.0097108996,
-0.0140126804,
0.0089324787,
0.0101722991,
0.0165743623,
0.0423193276,
0.1129495129,
0.0084469682,
-0.0333842039,
0.0381334834,
0.0456035025,
-0.0492774174,
-0.055330243,
0.0187421367,
0.0432510339,
0.0330552198,
0.058062911,
0.0358598568,
-0.039496243,
0.0349453911,
-0.0341420658,
0.0644845068,
0.0010125769,
-0.0034538459,
0.0314555764,
0.0080845263,
-0.0348628126,
-0.0234946031,
0.0555248149,
-0.039495416,
0.0150556518,
0.0086978329,
0.0066048987,
-0.0685191527,
-0.0117060021,
0.045627173,
0.0181623939,
-0.0475819744,
-0.0028951787,
-0.0656875521,
0.0165013447,
-0.0000371861,
-0.0124779884,
-0.021630438,
-0.0346974097,
0.0733606219,
0.0028590676,
-0.0497469455,
-0.0389732681,
-0.0233578719,
-0.0126811443,
-0.0138392011,
0.0164753869,
-0.0012378513,
-6.077279345e-33,
-0.0333642811,
-0.0328460112,
0.0439523235,
0.0099625662,
-0.0398024693,
0.0134540461,
-0.0511192605,
0.0105067482,
-0.0289811287,
-0.0301816463,
0.0023359051,
0.0251113996,
0.0188962799,
-0.0191428494,
-0.0103690131,
-0.0253689606,
0.0264478251,
-0.017232364,
-0.0277149882,
0.0335680395,
0.028527569,
0.0376102477,
0.0316594839,
-0.0797446668,
0.0278998911,
0.0335016586,
-0.0304907151,
0.0155145377,
0.0211892705,
0.0101475008,
-0.0113018258,
-0.0168253556,
0.0153057827,
-0.0375409834,
-0.0270508267,
0.070585236,
0.0026847026,
-0.0119377729,
0.017255554,
0.0168356635,
-0.0547603332,
-0.031758111,
-0.0148067819,
-0.0303058885,
-0.0280085411,
-0.0092790546,
0.0087560918,
-0.0014248504,
-0.0071276389,
0.0332250409,
-0.0355516225,
0.0290915798,
-0.0028795353,
-0.0732029527,
0.0279124156,
0.0638015717,
-0.009685087,
0.0053869868,
-0.0443451516,
0.0270324145,
-0.0477728844,
-0.0066305147,
0.0387997329,
-0.0028659932,
0.0080734994,
0.0956542641,
0.0602534264,
0.0164583065,
-0.0287879016,
-0.0163927525,
-0.0287393574,
0.091972433,
0.0485169701,
0.0090772239,
-0.028029684,
0.0237738732,
-0.0466738082,
0.0324120633,
0.0370926745,
0.0120626446,
0.0386323817,
0.0356193855,
-0.0421779305,
0.0027473606,
0.0103927692,
0.033064466,
0.0060502011,
-0.0310221482,
0.0293790624,
0.0136012472,
0.008609442,
-0.0089106197,
0.0704218298,
-0.0173396003,
0.0535747856,
-0.0095619811,
0.0008372826,
0.0244685467,
-0.0298647061,
0.0053027552,
-0.0641341433,
-0.0101802433,
0.0578075014,
-0.0003230842,
0.0608550236,
0.0165337827,
-0.0252020247,
0.0129144182,
-0.0098216161,
-0.0233820006,
-0.0228490811,
0.031107109,
-0.0268653911,
0.0087869205,
0.0763320476,
-0.0149828093,
-0.0192640405,
0.071845077,
0.0024046425,
-0.0412467569,
-0.0455535501,
-0.010518535,
-0.0076794666,
-0.016251931,
-0.0171919111,
0.0024393061,
-0.0376319401,
-0.004960421,
0.0339024179,
-0.000936896,
-0.0002113276,
-0.0125695523,
2.937e-7,
0.0028686461,
0.0356349535,
0.0494734831,
0.0456413664,
0.0161722805,
0.0577962771,
-0.0067024166,
0.0682399124,
0.0109447418,
-0.0480003506,
0.0274467859,
0.0050016814,
0.0660178065,
0.0254618749,
-0.0579415336,
-0.0307485498,
-0.0233095866,
-0.0302265976,
-0.0272929892,
0.026869284,
0.0711002275,
0.0271295626,
0.0013804588,
-0.0046269437,
0.0130662089,
-0.0052834852,
0.06391,
-0.0903953835,
-0.0432236865,
0.0393149965,
0.0262451991,
-0.0435212888,
-0.0135829346,
0.0364708789,
0.0128499558,
-0.0049020546,
-0.0160274208,
0.0945919901,
-0.0465126112,
-0.0522559956,
0.0031897603,
0.022021886,
-0.0158933699,
-0.0338804722,
0.0402604006,
-0.0559775457,
-0.052862104,
0.0001486462,
0.0140759982,
-0.0560639203,
0.013907209,
0.0251677539,
0.0094325533,
0.0118571455,
0.0151066193,
0.0035843591,
-0.033295244,
-0.0566615164,
0.0189278126,
-0.0034332834,
-0.0728278533,
-0.0547329858,
0.0144290738,
-0.0301939417,
-0.0257118307,
-0.0792278647,
-0.0333561115,
2.304022422e-34,
0.0014971647,
-0.0035226662,
-0.004763891,
0.060233742,
0.0338816419,
0.0084614297,
-0.034324158,
0.0379534774,
0.0674633607,
-0.0479945578,
-0.0156032015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15226v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15226v1 | CLIPTrans: Transferring Visual Knowledge with Pre-trained Models for Multimodal Machine Translation | 2023-08-29T11:29:43 | 2023-08-29T11:29:43 | Devaansh Gupta, Siddhant Kharbanda, Jiawei Zhou, Wanhua Li, Hanspeter Pfister, Donglai Wei | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | There has been a growing interest in developing multimodal machine
translation (MMT) systems that enhance neural machine translation (NMT) with
visual knowledge. This problem setup involves using images as auxiliary
information during training, and more recently, eliminating their use during
inference. Towards this end, previous works face a challenge in training
powerful MMT models from scratch due to the scarcity of annotated multilingual
vision-language data, especially for low-resource languages. Simultaneously,
there has been an influx of multilingual pre-trained models for NMT and
multimodal pre-trained models for vision-language tasks, primarily in English,
which have shown exceptional generalisation ability. However, these are not
directly applicable to MMT since they do not provide aligned multimodal
multilingual features for generative tasks. To alleviate this issue, instead of
designing complex modules for MMT, we propose CLIPTrans, which simply adapts
the independently pre-trained multimodal M-CLIP and the multilingual mBART. In
order to align their embedding spaces, mBART is conditioned on the M-CLIP
features by a prefix sequence generated through a lightweight mapping network.
We train this in a two-stage pipeline which warms up the model with image
captioning before the actual translation task. Through experiments, we
demonstrate the merits of this framework and consequently push forward the
state-of-the-art across standard benchmarks by an average of +2.67 BLEU. The
code can be found at www.github.com/devaansh100/CLIPTrans. | [
0.0249666758,
0.0560258068,
0.0007986781,
0.0413072966,
-0.0173981506,
-0.0119089959,
0.0176459569,
-0.0019287897,
-0.0430631116,
-0.0323215313,
-0.0635068193,
-0.0157668442,
0.0106198797,
0.0338559002,
0.0580098331,
-0.0604976229,
0.0126982685,
-0.0170404036,
-0.0594451502,
0.0125578493,
0.0264036451,
0.0338814557,
0.0029667856,
0.0252094418,
-0.0397262312,
0.0032078228,
-0.0091252029,
0.043870002,
0.0376542881,
-0.0100068701,
-0.0251708031,
0.0382674411,
0.0232812185,
0.0257139001,
0.0000019922,
0.0004663841,
0.00536587,
0.0164551605,
0.0555642284,
-0.0277901608,
0.0370429084,
-0.0714599714,
0.0112210335,
-0.0076904348,
-0.0366757065,
-0.0157891456,
0.0907163247,
0.011140313,
0.0675329939,
0.0547686853,
-0.0434847549,
-0.004854823,
-0.0127268815,
-0.0452652797,
0.0140994405,
-0.0313496031,
-0.0373665355,
0.0091443788,
-0.0497600771,
0.016995376,
-0.0374985002,
0.0694993734,
0.0173682142,
-0.0013068735,
-0.0037540407,
0.0343588442,
0.0031003917,
-0.0547487549,
-0.042448245,
0.0888945684,
-0.0684726611,
0.0176945385,
-0.0344297364,
-0.0087167174,
-0.005081119,
-0.0220880806,
-0.0473183282,
0.0320767015,
0.0194278713,
0.0134489667,
-0.0587561354,
0.0194630343,
0.0392163731,
-0.01115942,
-0.0173134021,
-0.0173329376,
0.0347559415,
0.0342137702,
0.0084446678,
0.023177458,
-0.031331867,
-0.0234683901,
0.0113880234,
-0.0030614226,
0.0215018522,
0.01568841,
-0.0403550565,
-0.0385960713,
-0.0136812627,
-0.040286541,
0.0511974581,
0.0637084469,
-0.055800315,
0.0538235344,
-0.0433987491,
0.0331512094,
-0.0376748182,
0.0410830379,
-0.0482219569,
-0.0256773066,
-0.0272277724,
0.0056030652,
-0.028502129,
-0.0385283753,
-0.0445875823,
-0.0333617702,
-0.0221443698,
-0.0012242584,
-0.0113679906,
-0.0138139948,
0.0088768434,
-0.0155012254,
-0.0594988689,
-0.0160764884,
-0.0069615501,
0.0550042205,
-0.0222402588,
0.005508624,
0.006681595,
-0.0552048236,
-0.0424159728,
0.0499579012,
0.0023482835,
-0.0474408306,
-0.0106539819,
0.1185057387,
-0.0653515384,
-0.0487204827,
-0.0262608454,
-0.0094320029,
-0.0393347219,
-0.0613234229,
0.0604655556,
-0.0383249745,
0.0608307719,
-0.0276804566,
0.0054215123,
-0.0341469646,
0.001847553,
0.0043715499,
0.0008664255,
0.1078901514,
0.0074905842,
-0.0203866921,
0.0044277357,
0.0152725726,
-0.0349616446,
0.0564007461,
0.0354947411,
0.0409077518,
0.0059398906,
0.0105081694,
-0.0080757476,
0.0781159624,
0.0342787765,
0.020072449,
-0.0256025884,
-0.0348708518,
-0.003689121,
0.021893857,
0.0700016841,
0.0193662364,
-0.0308181401,
0.014271725,
0.0766152292,
0.0149220303,
-0.0376670286,
0.0270068496,
0.0707052201,
-0.0129500255,
-0.0137642706,
-0.0123151178,
-0.0387184918,
0.049010206,
0.0115022017,
-0.0150179937,
0.0335859805,
0.0747132972,
-0.0194286797,
-0.0134289023,
0.015524881,
-0.0190899204,
-0.000968081,
-0.0076989508,
0.0272642113,
0.0509536825,
-0.0386615172,
0.0395058282,
-0.0109210135,
-0.0290169977,
0.0273085628,
0.0042959843,
-0.047106877,
0.0154082989,
0.023137005,
0.0092840614,
-0.0400831103,
0.0083812512,
-0.0082492149,
0.0409098454,
0.0373549722,
0.0240757,
0.072093308,
-0.0542512722,
-0.0406015478,
-0.010217269,
0.0038499357,
0.0311692078,
0.0153814983,
0.0257057846,
0.0363324471,
-0.0272487868,
-0.010986967,
0.043690756,
0.0044006384,
-0.0070862002,
-0.0153085152,
0.0181011576,
0.0343826935,
-0.0129805095,
-0.0204791017,
-0.0065088025,
-0.0086825574,
-0.0460421219,
-0.0048513259,
0.0692522675,
-0.0603086092,
-0.0476209931,
0.0324105173,
-0.0790785775,
-0.0136107132,
0.009532853,
-0.0470523797,
-0.0452716574,
-0.0023788672,
-0.0165422894,
-0.0030030159,
-0.0522886254,
0.0046402714,
0.0522478446,
0.0206229575,
-0.0057433024,
0.0041567842,
-0.0308320262,
-0.03201022,
0.0116842557,
-0.0380548164,
0.0015419434,
0.0080821281,
-0.026325766,
0.0126443114,
0.0193797518,
0.032610368,
0.0168897565,
0.0299300421,
-0.0312935673,
0.0003390062,
-0.0781728253,
0.0152953081,
-0.0123873381,
0.0069584479,
0.0121163102,
0.0393001512,
0.0068602483,
-0.0444373749,
-0.0460009649,
0.0143258274,
0.0100098317,
0.0149253132,
0.0130599793,
0.0339468159,
0.0735027194,
-0.0151972612,
0.0035247384,
0.0303073395,
0.0584503338,
-0.0140650086,
-0.0269514602,
-0.0240332354,
-0.0091777081,
-0.0303933546,
0.0227345154,
-0.0347181521,
-0.0321395025,
0.0036761705,
-0.0325611867,
0.0625182539,
0.0048549827,
-0.0186146256,
-0.0036116678,
0.0048594866,
-0.0173546951,
-0.0320996158,
0.0186695457,
-0.0015188893,
-0.0249591805,
-0.0238102768,
-0.0117387297,
-0.013887668,
0.0334783234,
-0.0208198372,
0.0034902976,
-0.0766702518,
0.017850183,
0.0326879546,
-0.0551154166,
-0.0440741219,
0.0548340008,
0.0137945265,
0.0101561565,
-0.0423942432,
-0.0673476532,
0.0187343284,
-0.0730734915,
-0.0241339151,
-0.0096187945,
0.013104124,
-0.0056615216,
0.0731952563,
0.0108178183,
0.0451589227,
-0.0282070432,
-0.0088331634,
-0.0611825176,
-0.0008030401,
0.00680213,
0.0043215901,
0.0216395147,
-0.0634242818,
-0.0101733031,
-0.0398478098,
-0.002828256,
-0.0092237405,
0.0118488995,
-0.0179968569,
-0.0155099845,
0.0178697836,
-0.0186744221,
-0.0174300317,
0.0213289671,
0.0268160738,
0.0815595537,
-0.0010596003,
0.0069524255,
-0.0203046501,
0.0332855992,
0.0173504222,
0.0318613648,
-0.0193502251,
-0.0666143894,
-0.0425739549,
0.0402908362,
-0.0035312502,
-0.0427103117,
-0.0505172424,
0.0208406989,
0.0384133197,
0.0260693207,
-0.0023522957,
0.0065610074,
0.0677117258,
-0.0479485802,
0.009650181,
0.0370801762,
-0.0053406702,
-0.0543078817,
-0.0320166051,
0.025148904,
0.0544175506,
0.0297783297,
0.029068796,
-0.0879976228,
-0.0683498606,
-0.007639511,
-0.0108895013,
0.0538285747,
0.0251362342,
-0.0780542716,
-0.0858933255,
0.023914285,
0.0327789225,
-0.07450293,
-0.0456987284,
0.0285878386,
-0.0234106034,
-0.0074937777,
-0.0052048988,
-0.0409912989,
0.0146665666,
0.0013055586,
-0.0019913104,
0.0452668332,
-0.0721306577,
-0.021207422,
-0.0518000312,
-0.0064317202,
0.0529255792,
0.0165307987,
-0.0018792785,
-0.0258261468,
0.0387551896,
0.0292161126,
0.0163912233,
0.0039620562,
0.049148649,
-0.0364124328,
-0.0291883536,
0.0367888436,
0.0235170294,
0.0140773319,
0.0126217576,
0.003655005,
0.0414861664,
-0.0106895175,
-0.0026820656,
-0.0069924886,
0.0003488284,
0.0041641523,
0.0288645476,
0.0219158716,
-0.0396004803,
-0.00048576,
-0.0049952627,
-0.0014027926,
-0.0594506599,
-0.0255260281,
-0.0086014234,
-0.0115404986,
-0.0239718854,
-0.0798344985,
-0.0381062143,
0.0290794689,
0.0629939288,
0.016307503,
-0.0385006666,
0.0064452835,
0.0200092588,
-0.0347187556,
0.0833098069,
-0.0577790774,
0.0047630733,
-0.0236928742,
0.0172871556,
0.0119916759,
-0.0515491888,
0.0025151977,
0.050587602,
-0.0983709171,
-0.0399864726,
-0.0799862519,
0.110660933,
0.0139239812,
0.0662994832,
0.0004897562,
0.0020921708,
0.0225492548,
0.0093734935,
0.0229482949,
-0.0144075826,
0.0428645611,
-0.052664388,
-0.0143192504,
0.0191653427,
-0.0087579535,
0.024537852,
-0.0037056736,
0.0643112436,
0.0270308796,
-0.0113844154,
0.0071499837,
-0.0181413852,
0.0474908762,
-0.0544257313,
0.0306701176,
-0.0507200249,
-0.0110215144,
0.019712314,
-0.0199102517,
-0.0941667855,
0.0029482911,
0.0308641493,
0.0314173177,
0.0147399679,
-0.0345704742,
0.0265036467,
-0.0035165823,
-0.0031533651,
-0.0308411717,
-0.0063508512,
-0.0238118786,
-0.005994698,
0.0362183675,
0.008731897,
0.0378701873,
-0.0354825705,
0.0040407777,
-0.0417264849,
0.0600342341,
0.0232637972,
-0.0075938804,
0.0069968388,
0.0474890769,
0.0005214963,
-0.0065610805,
-0.0428893752,
0.0329005122,
0.0800189003,
-0.0142415967,
0.0907837078,
-0.0185545888,
-0.0172460191,
0.0120114638,
0.0624449886,
0.0049128574,
-0.0254231766,
0.0387246236,
-0.0304617267,
0.0131354118,
-0.0002448449,
0.0634212196,
-0.0055714739,
0.015278534,
-0.0120416349,
-0.013581112,
-0.0228910483,
-0.0366349518,
0.046810396,
-0.0231313296,
-0.0026735913,
0.0133986268,
0.002141661,
-0.0572193563,
-0.0154478876,
0.0049564796,
-0.0436540358,
0.0252886917,
0.0601984598,
0.0551862866,
-0.0121449884,
-0.0142577868,
-0.0143468315,
-0.0209031906,
0.0280394219,
-0.001741407,
0.0140953921,
-6.021755237e-33,
-0.0330262519,
0.0058256052,
0.0411836654,
-0.0351929516,
-0.047208719,
-0.0154126314,
-0.0293244794,
0.0114730224,
-0.017524723,
0.0219686609,
0.0332328714,
-0.0153946616,
0.0231511425,
0.0431417637,
0.0081224414,
0.0367472731,
0.0432893224,
0.0207954645,
-0.0055262647,
0.0182079189,
0.011669728,
0.030740533,
0.1039187387,
-0.0121103637,
-0.0039754868,
0.0132127376,
-0.0373266712,
0.0306770559,
0.0075199152,
-0.0016303969,
-0.0186018422,
-0.0056675607,
0.0024957492,
-0.0211927239,
-0.0410862416,
-0.0187565964,
-0.0795253143,
0.0013642953,
0.0223202426,
0.0391200297,
-0.0699921995,
-0.0194541104,
0.0606015697,
-0.0485324077,
0.0373239256,
-0.0322597176,
0.0246976726,
-0.0287947655,
-0.0013249062,
-0.0172316749,
-0.0431535132,
0.0150295505,
-0.0125254309,
-0.0180088244,
0.0395805873,
0.0696610957,
0.0253955927,
-0.0028353294,
-0.0575274825,
0.0075258198,
-0.0323207751,
0.0372707695,
0.1040532589,
0.0352518111,
-0.0155634796,
0.0267375838,
-0.0062296372,
-0.0499199182,
0.0158895608,
0.0145730637,
0.0420099497,
0.0220592171,
0.0519935302,
0.0315055363,
0.0472153835,
0.0213423893,
-0.0148179196,
0.0312569998,
-0.0395618565,
0.0307038501,
0.0153923901,
0.0115937833,
0.0455251411,
0.007525234,
-0.0429784134,
-0.0314249247,
-0.0259061679,
-0.0285436008,
0.0299137961,
0.0183417145,
0.0081708133,
0.0414414108,
0.1142215952,
0.0025891066,
0.0152062969,
-0.0117739066,
-0.0250324756,
0.0302595701,
-0.0314765386,
0.0467587076,
-0.029442627,
-0.0367759019,
0.0320065916,
-0.0105781155,
0.0123455804,
-0.004813775,
0.0638966039,
0.0503545552,
-0.0264297891,
-0.0037715258,
-0.0604882874,
0.0112646455,
-0.0191426352,
0.0642945245,
0.0247895047,
-0.008384509,
-0.0605866797,
-0.000958572,
0.0161117297,
0.0094182463,
-0.0215241574,
-0.0266937725,
0.0228382871,
0.0386429057,
-0.0404793695,
0.0276473816,
-0.0584637597,
-0.0252394062,
0.0254522692,
-0.0722517446,
-0.0345239602,
0.0423822924,
2.692e-7,
0.0531557724,
0.0019986231,
0.0062257517,
0.0037275979,
-0.001099114,
0.0304461271,
-0.042252969,
0.0474390276,
-0.0229403116,
-0.0003915893,
0.0229780208,
0.0289950222,
0.06426768,
0.0161104817,
-0.0205116048,
-0.059316773,
-0.0242948607,
0.0035868934,
-0.0297182277,
-0.0111230556,
0.0305687077,
0.0901985988,
-0.0313107409,
-0.0221274868,
0.0210493822,
-0.0461220071,
0.1037697941,
-0.0155518642,
-0.0045427717,
-0.0246152114,
0.0314823985,
0.0379349664,
-0.0598292835,
-0.0012832364,
-0.0244494826,
-0.0186775122,
0.06875965,
0.0559487306,
-0.0102221817,
0.0012905472,
0.0017162932,
0.0442293324,
-0.0339376181,
-0.0181370042,
0.0484038889,
-0.0780710801,
-0.0213447027,
-0.0268679224,
-0.0349406973,
0.0123643447,
0.0269931592,
-0.0335187465,
-0.0485298224,
0.0494214967,
0.072843641,
0.006873718,
-0.0523881912,
-0.0718843415,
-0.0367210582,
-0.0084677599,
-0.0198829267,
-0.010233392,
-0.0632879362,
-0.0488413759,
0.0086614154,
-0.0330307037,
-0.0537542589,
2.072177972e-34,
0.0227086339,
-0.0220725667,
0.0218972582,
-0.0166348685,
0.0232402943,
-0.0104233641,
-0.0149000362,
-0.0069076028,
-0.020678889,
-0.0225618836,
-0.0535506792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15214v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15214v2 | FurChat: An Embodied Conversational Agent using LLMs, Combining Open and Closed-Domain Dialogue with Facial Expressions | 2023-08-29T11:08:40 | 2023-08-30T13:13:19 | Neeraj Cherakara, Finny Varghese, Sheena Shabana, Nivan Nelson, Abhiram Karukayil, Rohith Kulothungan, Mohammed Afil Farhan, Birthe Nesset, Meriam Moujahid, Tanvi Dinkar, Verena Rieser, Oliver Lemon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.RO | We demonstrate an embodied conversational agent that can function as a
receptionist and generate a mixture of open and closed-domain dialogue along
with facial expressions, by using a large language model (LLM) to develop an
engaging conversation. We deployed the system onto a Furhat robot, which is
highly expressive and capable of using both verbal and nonverbal cues during
interaction. The system was designed specifically for the National Robotarium
to interact with visitors through natural conversations, providing them with
information about the facilities, research, news, upcoming events, etc. The
system utilises the state-of-the-art GPT-3.5 model to generate such information
along with domain-general conversations and facial expressions based on prompt
engineering. | [
0.0421573818,
0.0273085684,
-0.0278028063,
0.0261346232,
-0.0140267806,
-0.004669013,
0.0027826,
0.0146410884,
0.0489322804,
-0.0134794107,
-0.0564481877,
-0.0498464443,
0.0034420427,
0.0966103375,
0.0389660001,
-0.0870979205,
0.024841873,
-0.0419308729,
0.01179549,
-0.0001984574,
0.021211328,
0.0178857613,
-0.0573133938,
0.0523341261,
-0.0750579089,
-0.0148945749,
-0.0788997784,
0.0369029976,
0.027861705,
-0.0165074971,
-0.0091739567,
0.0160662327,
0.0762757882,
0.0193429198,
0.0000019119,
-0.0258419793,
0.0137382364,
-0.0075663379,
0.0023708101,
-0.0234381445,
0.0753900856,
0.0351932086,
-0.0265869144,
0.0262873787,
-0.0140241655,
-0.0024658029,
0.0664536655,
0.0490508042,
0.0587320775,
0.0661282316,
-0.0234151892,
-0.020346513,
0.0122530777,
0.0040551084,
-0.0120565007,
-0.0449929349,
0.0085156932,
0.0220850259,
0.0488988794,
-0.034252163,
-0.029163437,
0.0035577407,
0.0109698894,
-0.0560907796,
-0.0032459993,
0.0588377155,
-0.0168431476,
-0.0753853619,
-0.0343008265,
0.077391237,
0.0553574637,
0.0402830876,
0.032353498,
0.0188005473,
0.0472586453,
-0.0112046143,
-0.0246235766,
0.0475750826,
-0.0031304096,
0.0098418202,
-0.0666974261,
0.0023153627,
-0.0334719718,
0.0286210477,
-0.0025262083,
0.0351105109,
0.0158445686,
-0.0002296597,
-0.0196756814,
-0.0375549793,
0.0138752423,
-0.0409281179,
0.0138378385,
0.077095896,
-0.0371575244,
0.037679553,
-0.051956065,
0.0145421876,
-0.0021151481,
-0.0021570236,
-0.0557448417,
0.0351041369,
-0.0174325351,
0.0228957254,
0.0210172422,
0.0668603033,
-0.0174731351,
-0.0163801555,
0.0162732042,
0.0161649734,
-0.0111826537,
-0.0159650836,
-0.0443656556,
0.0020802112,
-0.0509767011,
-0.0686270893,
0.0002199914,
0.071113959,
0.0243356489,
0.0192964096,
-0.0037738092,
0.0050423522,
-0.0116447024,
0.023972081,
-0.0483412221,
-0.0086692944,
-0.0018800127,
0.0241196211,
0.0201226473,
-0.0622823052,
-0.0160552338,
0.0376849025,
-0.0034802658,
0.0186947137,
-0.0354587771,
0.0918622985,
-0.0083017033,
-0.0338491015,
0.0164033957,
0.0159408823,
-0.0198915526,
-0.0691358075,
0.0067488621,
-0.0133841345,
0.0124091068,
-0.0288422778,
0.0016756379,
0.0030835704,
0.0268541798,
0.002871952,
0.0378246903,
0.0420109816,
-0.0374042839,
0.0178063679,
0.0501232184,
0.001660327,
0.018533431,
0.0396952517,
0.0235588141,
0.0497401655,
-0.0013991483,
-0.0083026243,
0.0335185193,
0.0430433825,
-0.0414091833,
-0.0009363233,
0.0162819792,
-0.0231119636,
0.0415364802,
0.0489429906,
0.006048935,
0.0579699278,
-0.018550083,
0.02750846,
0.0586312488,
0.0165480841,
-0.0494164526,
-0.0095794648,
-0.0115286624,
0.039085418,
0.039597135,
-0.012596665,
-0.0048532132,
0.0461149663,
-0.0405079275,
-0.0065205721,
-0.0258831345,
0.0207479335,
-0.0501480475,
-0.0069089634,
0.0215661358,
-0.0176583137,
0.0622132607,
0.0083236843,
0.0369146951,
-0.0180561673,
-0.0679820329,
0.0191507395,
0.0111142173,
-0.05079877,
-0.0231101364,
-0.0351081304,
0.007719609,
0.0812996477,
-0.0056219548,
-0.023739161,
-0.0256213732,
-0.0298725851,
-0.0135315368,
0.103117533,
0.0439162962,
0.0020900981,
0.0232843086,
-0.0223977827,
0.0130731715,
-0.0191670358,
0.007479548,
0.028362995,
-0.0410560817,
0.047343649,
0.0074584102,
0.0497192852,
0.0339645594,
0.0168641098,
-0.0637851059,
0.0142226145,
-0.0472348966,
-0.0130033344,
0.0136744529,
0.0192733146,
-0.0392753892,
-0.0115249166,
0.0310346987,
0.0184340551,
-0.000968651,
0.0256450623,
-0.0307366811,
-0.0105688209,
0.0510663912,
-0.0219990686,
-0.0351756923,
0.0175270997,
-0.0242207851,
-0.0450890213,
0.0063487813,
-0.0712220669,
0.0366434343,
-0.0430025645,
0.0495641604,
0.0030566456,
0.0013433218,
-0.0019739158,
0.010586503,
0.0170814618,
-0.0194475725,
0.0312377457,
0.0236424524,
0.0133676371,
-0.0908702984,
-0.0361230001,
0.0559542738,
0.016203098,
0.0142245796,
0.0131124519,
0.0328145064,
-0.068530336,
-0.0308343116,
-0.1133907735,
-0.0398217216,
0.0311843865,
-0.0534340888,
0.0028909708,
-0.0157435872,
-0.0197554771,
0.0135737993,
-0.0575496033,
0.0335556045,
0.0041755927,
-0.0295136087,
0.0406226963,
0.0000568928,
-0.0834389403,
-0.0443692282,
0.0171442404,
-0.0010697,
-0.0043982365,
0.0378546678,
-0.0215053167,
-0.0379840247,
0.0347497053,
-0.0349166542,
0.0608478785,
-0.0312889367,
-0.0743797645,
0.0487685241,
-0.0217151474,
0.0362696946,
0.0383100063,
0.0389707237,
0.0098179979,
0.0266000554,
-0.03227726,
-0.0436632559,
0.0243816916,
-0.0044350629,
0.0201903395,
-0.0444874093,
-0.0181895345,
0.01734538,
-0.0210018978,
0.0084408158,
0.0431604236,
-0.0681138262,
0.0418051817,
0.0274335667,
-0.0670390725,
-0.0159840416,
-0.007791739,
-0.0654798076,
0.0250517707,
0.0042053885,
-0.041689463,
0.0341400504,
-0.0276990645,
-0.0329677351,
0.0182484481,
0.0097407885,
-0.0109756943,
0.0742497072,
-0.0372376852,
0.0148046147,
0.0287784059,
-0.0499455109,
0.0099455826,
-0.0144824954,
-0.0490603857,
-0.0429337434,
-0.0200373121,
-0.0454540178,
0.0033025281,
0.0119109312,
-0.0244041309,
-0.0291818026,
0.0139615489,
-0.0288587753,
0.0072920849,
-0.0289358627,
-0.0412582085,
-0.0523535386,
0.0254976209,
0.0308502167,
0.0146535905,
-0.0209918953,
0.0203609839,
-0.0344982855,
-0.0347648673,
0.0517706536,
0.0986281708,
-0.0235995818,
-0.0264342427,
0.0384755693,
-0.0097417878,
-0.0256339945,
-0.0149608431,
-0.0227790792,
-0.0108415363,
0.0144018847,
0.0198664423,
-0.0266502034,
0.0042877528,
0.0465615876,
-0.0062641902,
0.0331837833,
0.1193060875,
-0.0108731892,
-0.0319502987,
-0.0089086387,
-0.0346921161,
0.0042294059,
0.0163576081,
0.0032888104,
-0.0251604971,
0.0049141487,
0.0284827147,
-0.0028132901,
0.0047532888,
-0.0086005069,
0.0003027635,
-0.0911128446,
0.0629168823,
0.0180895533,
-0.0415454805,
-0.0475964919,
0.0202155467,
0.03688813,
0.0307618007,
-0.0023415505,
0.0226939861,
-0.0019924149,
-0.0161467027,
0.0124758165,
0.0075536799,
0.0043239654,
0.0078891562,
-0.0062906267,
0.04162319,
0.0222400129,
0.0888058618,
-0.0166883245,
-0.0556945838,
-0.0137751894,
0.0296857841,
0.0312378313,
-0.0142312916,
0.0099417148,
-0.0069346507,
-0.0171599891,
-0.0185922086,
0.0194061399,
-0.0251046028,
0.0132715972,
0.0149328196,
0.0215361249,
-0.0686232671,
0.0353661999,
-0.0338882245,
0.0124020074,
0.0113125117,
0.0552715771,
-0.0119059468,
-0.0404397175,
-0.0314445533,
-0.0151997833,
-0.0161869824,
0.0617610142,
-0.0555034652,
-0.0104685826,
-0.0123214386,
-0.0662982985,
-0.070002757,
-0.0085858824,
0.0312669091,
0.0474191345,
0.0114173917,
-0.0311608724,
-0.020355735,
0.0666245073,
0.0145596052,
0.0351118147,
-0.0139467856,
0.0232654326,
-0.0551170111,
-0.0172819998,
0.0138691729,
-0.0827396512,
-0.0070960484,
0.019960884,
0.0404866003,
-0.0464546978,
-0.0074853096,
0.0402344018,
0.0291431714,
0.0082052182,
0.0183232725,
-0.0087030781,
-0.0133169759,
0.0144886617,
-0.0107479114,
0.0409146212,
0.0194775537,
0.0429987572,
-0.0066219713,
0.0029166783,
-0.0501519181,
0.000967984,
-0.0537718348,
0.0204825979,
0.0015840596,
-0.1123907343,
0.006795879,
0.0683076009,
0.015010423,
-0.0074614845,
-0.0145407543,
-0.0341959894,
-0.0045328308,
-0.0320345014,
0.0216542985,
-0.0734068006,
-0.0141727598,
-0.0251859501,
0.0259605926,
0.0279133487,
-0.0362826809,
-0.0332577862,
0.0427433774,
0.021387171,
0.0138939517,
0.025725618,
-0.0029157826,
-0.0133805424,
0.016541576,
0.0053531933,
0.0263646431,
-0.0381568633,
0.016849298,
0.0234793462,
0.0773837864,
0.0017179343,
-0.0356645025,
0.0289738365,
0.0592734516,
-0.020324748,
-0.0978026241,
0.0067503848,
0.0518547818,
0.0156204524,
0.0372086056,
0.0321692675,
-0.0590870455,
0.0157712661,
-0.0349302515,
0.0337301083,
0.0190823115,
-0.0332132839,
0.0530177094,
-0.0087980451,
-0.026174115,
-0.0395266265,
-0.0022967663,
-0.0048305225,
0.0276534483,
-0.0076955864,
-0.0001757095,
-0.0474910103,
-0.0127206296,
0.051276397,
-0.0352800265,
0.0188976433,
0.0054690009,
-0.0547306202,
-0.0316975228,
0.0055496613,
0.0185083896,
-0.0219445098,
-0.0522729121,
0.0801662952,
-0.0039089909,
-0.0162993334,
-0.0096289236,
-0.0288206525,
0.0170848668,
-0.0002665026,
0.0008056694,
-0.0162845887,
-5.330265542e-33,
-0.04638483,
-0.0159136225,
0.008873892,
0.0379055403,
-0.0925524309,
-0.0103012351,
-0.036663387,
0.0078922361,
-0.0257294364,
-0.0282532629,
0.0026507596,
-0.0039327582,
0.0055051357,
-0.0084550474,
-0.0310286283,
-0.0116939703,
0.0430215672,
0.0164143462,
-0.00190869,
0.0289001465,
0.0222144686,
0.0231739394,
0.0129909385,
-0.0818062425,
-0.000811255,
-0.0035178596,
-0.0512992889,
0.0081418017,
0.0155786835,
0.0106328065,
-0.0354214683,
0.0462654121,
-0.0186271723,
0.0116223032,
-0.0119339889,
0.0566160604,
-0.0167223942,
0.0049246717,
0.0155649642,
0.017939901,
-0.0184132531,
-0.0294972844,
-0.001944046,
-0.0378192961,
-0.0341320895,
0.019146271,
0.0177684352,
-0.0205150228,
0.0220586937,
0.0202753022,
-0.0631225407,
0.0084077818,
-0.0056050024,
-0.0670706034,
0.0034898769,
0.0692052171,
0.0111811077,
0.0168373808,
0.0092346529,
0.0457781851,
-0.007430362,
-0.0407228321,
0.0462715477,
0.003370581,
0.0713096932,
0.0779604837,
0.0317905322,
0.0243252926,
-0.0222854521,
-0.0372986421,
0.0213932004,
0.062894173,
0.0066011259,
0.0147209102,
-0.0505785234,
-0.030708421,
-0.0145399822,
0.0186549537,
0.0282095522,
0.0598974526,
0.0083898138,
0.0478457473,
-0.0155388769,
0.0201902352,
-0.0322413854,
0.0373264961,
0.0036421085,
-0.0440155268,
0.0147892227,
0.0029222586,
0.0105601251,
-0.0761149004,
0.027982492,
-0.0135769425,
0.012651965,
-0.0143259941,
-0.0308490787,
0.0221629515,
-0.0116610052,
0.0037381034,
-0.0190475918,
-0.0498117879,
0.0454366542,
0.0122690918,
0.0362439007,
0.0414825268,
-0.1077867746,
0.0581597909,
-0.0112660145,
0.002764385,
-0.0041467957,
0.0243043676,
0.0063298126,
0.0175506454,
0.0125858029,
-0.0308851711,
-0.0424615704,
0.0338981934,
-0.0327741802,
-0.0103474446,
-0.0424085408,
-0.0311557204,
-0.0155389123,
0.0225224067,
-0.0595617555,
0.0055745337,
-0.017031284,
-0.019185951,
0.022542771,
-0.0562744662,
-0.0060941922,
0.0052685356,
2.739e-7,
-0.0323921591,
0.0303599797,
-0.002135535,
0.0585816205,
0.061937999,
0.0389532484,
-0.036622759,
0.0623854846,
0.0234748479,
-0.0773250759,
-0.0034394581,
0.0216198433,
0.0439668633,
-0.0322494693,
-0.102534391,
-0.0044777673,
0.0030264272,
-0.0659306645,
-0.0384133719,
0.0567978434,
0.0518172979,
0.0751747042,
0.0166090187,
-0.0159083195,
0.0202511586,
-0.015521965,
0.0284273345,
-0.0458119735,
-0.018274622,
-0.0277189221,
0.0328791402,
-0.0069005843,
-0.0114940442,
0.004434308,
0.0143548315,
0.0049802568,
0.0164285749,
0.0706709847,
-0.0211675949,
-0.0165062994,
0.0517068729,
0.0483457819,
-0.0352642387,
-0.0035831407,
0.0422804765,
0.0133408587,
-0.0252276212,
-0.0143165421,
-0.0178627856,
-0.0440378189,
0.015546469,
-0.0368107408,
-0.0164308138,
0.0221036114,
-0.0242938679,
-0.0453291312,
0.0181500502,
-0.0432537422,
0.0265517682,
-0.0686898679,
-0.1222920045,
-0.0962684378,
-0.020251004,
-0.0219890978,
-0.0086690094,
-0.0066550584,
-0.0069022272,
1.819244878e-34,
0.0235315431,
-0.0007667824,
-0.0155510688,
0.071338214,
0.0362712517,
0.0349748135,
0.0128314616,
0.0203074478,
0.0535515696,
-0.0650206506,
-0.0263015218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15209v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15209v1 | Shared Lexical Items as Triggers of Code Switching | 2023-08-29T10:55:44 | 2023-08-29T10:55:44 | Shuly Wintner, Safaa Shehadi, Yuli Zeira, Doreen Osmelak, Yuval Nov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Why do bilingual speakers code-switch (mix their two languages)? Among the
several theories that attempt to explain this natural and ubiquitous
phenomenon, the Triggering Hypothesis relates code-switching to the presence of
lexical triggers, specifically cognates and proper names, adjacent to the
switch point. We provide a fuller, more nuanced and refined exploration of the
triggering hypothesis, based on five large datasets in three language pairs,
reflecting both spoken and written bilingual interactions. Our results show
that words that are assumed to reside in a mental lexicon shared by both
languages indeed trigger code-switching; that the tendency to switch depends on
the distance of the trigger from the switch point; and on whether the trigger
precedes or succeeds the switch; but not on the etymology of the trigger words.
We thus provide strong, robust, evidence-based confirmation to several
hypotheses on the relationships between lexical triggers and code-switching. | [
-0.020517718,
0.0176573936,
-0.062816225,
0.0397025868,
-0.0346418507,
0.0107159279,
-0.0267681889,
-0.0089218915,
-0.0035069713,
-0.0116301412,
-0.0562507026,
-0.0202336758,
0.057992734,
-0.0157046691,
0.0328975208,
0.0145464232,
0.0319466777,
-0.0197198596,
-0.0216644052,
-0.025998896,
0.0008534361,
0.014089372,
0.0001281225,
0.0152688958,
0.0260175951,
0.0235487521,
0.0316015072,
-0.0060773194,
-0.0079794833,
0.0149646262,
-0.0145792142,
0.0522354059,
-0.0312235486,
0.0498927347,
0.0000015292,
-0.0505076572,
0.0296385642,
-0.0367102511,
-0.0123960422,
-0.0075766672,
-0.0195652973,
-0.0224074814,
0.0252676178,
-0.0294192545,
-0.0163947418,
-0.0350922458,
0.0449018143,
-0.0318177305,
-0.0498778298,
-0.0246960279,
0.0040354943,
-0.031937059,
-0.0121891666,
-0.0164277647,
0.0377778262,
-0.0089251036,
0.0343042873,
-0.0194604043,
-0.0038470116,
-0.0333438665,
-0.0689533502,
0.0355201066,
-0.0097369086,
0.0279514138,
-0.0636063367,
0.0240209177,
-0.0617094971,
0.017387338,
0.0295567401,
0.0011130824,
-0.0283426512,
-0.0835388824,
0.0176744293,
0.0093323281,
-0.0150283258,
0.0120065315,
0.0241364837,
-0.0238985289,
-0.0062992168,
0.0225333888,
0.0687298179,
-0.0258352254,
0.012924795,
-0.0182587299,
-0.0506322421,
0.0765399486,
0.0172562245,
-0.0375839025,
-0.0012912034,
0.0177993868,
0.0896739066,
-0.0767295286,
0.0055155912,
-0.0367248543,
-0.0333103463,
0.0315045938,
0.0081482735,
-0.0271268282,
-0.0285228211,
-0.0304679219,
-0.0015739857,
0.0134968031,
-0.0544987693,
0.0118278479,
-0.0344306827,
0.0175741483,
-0.0279856008,
-0.0221085548,
0.0146087501,
-0.0010212365,
-0.0363409296,
-0.0255505443,
-0.0162655041,
-0.0299344528,
0.0285928156,
0.0272305831,
-0.0260830168,
0.0071370108,
-0.0080094859,
-0.0263024829,
-0.0492730178,
-0.0395234264,
0.0093927588,
0.0229998026,
0.0162085965,
0.009506477,
-0.0305878147,
-0.0001112153,
-0.037850596,
-0.0647276044,
0.0295253117,
-0.0120718805,
-0.0220060274,
-0.0044853808,
-0.0009696176,
0.029653864,
-0.0328748748,
-0.030650327,
0.0230197273,
-0.005549965,
-0.0216590483,
-0.0120388567,
-0.0078564528,
-0.0744322762,
0.0450553671,
0.042715203,
0.0200078916,
-0.0514414608,
-0.0113515137,
-0.0149993189,
-0.0788155794,
0.055710163,
-0.0054774173,
0.0308796167,
0.0524340943,
-0.0108483741,
-0.0030745286,
0.0555739887,
0.0135686751,
-0.0840724856,
0.0608462729,
-0.0520972721,
-0.0195631031,
0.0193734951,
0.01231563,
-0.0038588401,
0.0073124818,
-0.0290578417,
0.0632395074,
0.0187394395,
0.0629401207,
-0.0091930609,
-0.0442818217,
-0.0457241423,
-0.0029608794,
0.0584697574,
0.0113612879,
0.024074642,
0.0196620356,
0.0017345882,
-0.0222795885,
0.0307957847,
0.0207866002,
-0.0108562484,
-0.0228808261,
-0.0215373579,
0.0239626765,
0.0265573561,
-0.0306228343,
0.0431066938,
-0.015349241,
0.0119860871,
0.0500795431,
-0.019341832,
0.0005770251,
-0.0024647384,
0.0266650952,
0.0401126705,
0.0116449296,
-0.0249762703,
0.0120801283,
0.0011469779,
-0.0344790407,
0.0299837161,
-0.0446558781,
0.0411275066,
0.0238460321,
0.0022098713,
-0.0003222419,
0.0257226396,
0.0105573619,
0.021368647,
0.0422151834,
-0.0143391723,
0.0346794203,
0.0179237407,
-0.0303209573,
0.0249026027,
-0.0056994278,
0.0489447303,
-0.0389621705,
0.0372658186,
0.0223656148,
-0.0063832742,
-0.0699070394,
0.0192008968,
0.0047375136,
-0.0078653945,
0.0043744226,
-0.0058941473,
-0.0266887043,
0.0253261551,
-0.0425387584,
0.0151300272,
0.0290490557,
0.0677582398,
-0.0018577474,
-0.008847354,
0.0019239301,
-0.0281392206,
0.0099791689,
-0.0697223023,
0.0438460037,
-0.0315313116,
0.0426660851,
-0.0322472788,
0.0797660574,
0.018731039,
0.0324943848,
-0.0423249453,
0.0495067239,
0.0004810492,
0.0097321086,
0.0031724924,
0.0798610747,
-0.0028330223,
0.0049564019,
0.039420817,
-0.0100304605,
-0.0272707231,
0.0310523883,
-0.0203928705,
-0.0096892128,
-0.0020381454,
-0.0147331534,
-0.0185355935,
-0.0143671706,
-0.0433032624,
-0.0502971336,
0.0167592149,
0.0143499486,
0.019486744,
-0.0382755212,
-0.0310984757,
0.0085888086,
0.005723739,
0.0264623556,
-0.0183628965,
0.0649612844,
-0.0228486061,
-0.037741717,
-0.0236894935,
-0.0347868055,
-0.0070190188,
-0.0086523481,
0.0327905938,
-0.0107714524,
-0.0396619439,
-0.0733908787,
0.0080239577,
-0.0483260714,
-0.0112708528,
0.0001070445,
-0.033474762,
0.0522829778,
0.0297445375,
0.0734405369,
0.0287750531,
-0.0345688909,
-0.0452285223,
0.0537704118,
-0.095076561,
-0.0453754924,
-0.0606988855,
-0.0027799557,
-0.0067082923,
-0.0534849167,
-0.0545731485,
0.0018390017,
0.0950382799,
0.0311031118,
-0.0138448058,
-0.0484347455,
-0.0604055561,
-0.0377034396,
-0.0506617911,
0.0212829225,
-0.0437111594,
-0.0355274007,
0.1063979417,
-0.0203414392,
-0.0314702727,
0.0359200053,
-0.0169784613,
-0.0043193894,
-0.0490645058,
0.0285064522,
-0.0033690194,
0.0352559686,
0.0003697099,
0.0013283545,
0.0369431637,
-0.0450762548,
-0.032844767,
-0.024862241,
0.0086198244,
0.0116998749,
0.0408575609,
-0.0505395792,
-0.0062217442,
0.0425637439,
-0.0465427153,
0.0020963016,
0.0483380035,
-0.0316357426,
-0.0054343888,
0.0460752062,
-0.0373560786,
0.0867034942,
-0.0163158588,
0.0223613512,
-0.0023981719,
0.0164200999,
0.0032251487,
0.0163312592,
0.009080776,
-0.0364105962,
-0.0084447525,
0.0098680574,
0.0128167775,
-0.0360709354,
-0.0151692526,
0.0111473585,
0.0478175357,
-0.001265911,
0.0152979158,
0.0889368132,
0.0048370394,
-0.0808067098,
-0.0167926326,
0.0059738536,
0.0092471829,
-0.0210447367,
0.0010972997,
0.0314674973,
-0.0367565975,
0.0075310515,
-0.0686222091,
0.0152550414,
0.0452604666,
-0.0037299024,
-0.0639771149,
0.025051767,
0.0032124051,
-0.0460439958,
-0.027783474,
-0.0103806192,
-0.0177304633,
-0.0940238535,
-0.0356852375,
0.0177467428,
-0.0785940811,
-0.0093942955,
0.0203188583,
0.0467209481,
0.0301182959,
-0.0495867431,
0.0186818074,
-0.018046774,
-0.0155884074,
0.0231757928,
0.0053058355,
-0.0027046683,
-0.0159372427,
-0.016792655,
0.010171135,
0.0224207174,
0.0221434552,
-0.0338539183,
-0.0603985265,
0.0218669716,
-0.0695282221,
-0.0164939407,
-0.0245570578,
0.0152896261,
0.0371438675,
-0.0033086881,
-0.0114587937,
0.0022316612,
0.0081571145,
-0.0405062176,
-0.0041297534,
0.0407117493,
-0.0118051423,
-0.0403216816,
0.0630542487,
0.0565669611,
0.0009970886,
0.0095528523,
0.0650424808,
-0.0627663583,
0.0510369502,
0.0155582624,
0.0342218652,
0.0047649778,
-0.0480344221,
-0.0231557898,
-0.0067930887,
-0.0763982013,
-0.0601884387,
-0.0361187868,
-0.013760726,
0.0088875005,
0.0386592224,
0.0535516627,
-0.0350585207,
-0.0227692891,
0.0118719256,
0.0033904091,
0.0076409043,
0.0302020367,
-0.0366618074,
0.0025236458,
0.0145571325,
-0.045419205,
0.0030160646,
0.0194418151,
-0.0706881359,
-0.0610274561,
0.0427774861,
-0.0346915349,
0.0175810289,
-0.0065049436,
0.0138775585,
-0.0587235168,
-0.0523827486,
0.0069365576,
0.0101724295,
0.0462411791,
0.0117984107,
0.0135719273,
0.013810751,
0.0216664169,
0.0406293571,
-0.040598616,
0.0239230394,
-0.0378057957,
-0.076348491,
-0.0194055494,
0.0039034167,
-0.0547898896,
0.0351925232,
-0.0494310223,
0.0195137858,
-0.0247814022,
-0.0035418903,
0.0298073236,
0.0062145311,
0.0308328066,
-0.0664940774,
0.0233967509,
-0.0019876917,
-0.0294792969,
-0.0015050226,
-0.0103191324,
0.0159665495,
0.0430493653,
0.0122010931,
0.0044235601,
0.1084577516,
0.0296691023,
0.0385061912,
0.0217876621,
0.0625370443,
-0.0129270712,
0.0195140764,
-0.0510853603,
0.0560421161,
0.0315011442,
-0.0148803284,
0.0165925659,
-0.0115752211,
0.0104312934,
-0.0797667354,
0.0940508395,
-0.0225290153,
0.0420336574,
-0.022754373,
0.059881784,
-0.018327916,
-0.0008379453,
0.0017057412,
-0.0010715381,
-0.0281676538,
-0.0218041595,
0.0461991243,
-0.0187055673,
-0.017101204,
-0.0177341793,
0.036564339,
-0.0551553816,
-0.0116504915,
-0.0152588142,
-0.0163769796,
0.0485238805,
0.0125627145,
0.0223188903,
-0.0110567231,
-0.0090253772,
-0.0338025875,
-0.0739284828,
-0.0429352671,
0.0301051158,
-0.002016149,
0.0316362567,
0.0037623735,
0.0423964933,
0.0910811424,
0.0207625832,
0.0137654468,
-0.0087909177,
0.049118761,
0.0748078898,
-0.0304960199,
-0.0284220129,
-4.840838918e-33,
0.0148669425,
-0.0144890212,
-0.001850056,
0.0332730785,
-0.0057722577,
-0.0070451573,
-0.0322759561,
0.0407731459,
-0.0120262448,
-0.0393136367,
0.0030453119,
0.0067679766,
0.0099539934,
-0.0251999572,
0.0873517841,
-0.0065047247,
-0.0102706607,
0.0101538338,
0.0003556072,
-0.0344282389,
0.0668590814,
-0.0244069286,
0.0620471984,
-0.0606365465,
0.0545102172,
0.0285067372,
0.0386441872,
-0.0359972976,
-0.0170473307,
-0.0029816269,
-0.0083546061,
0.0118770543,
0.0310166441,
-0.007428654,
-0.0089166788,
0.0414513685,
-0.0101600643,
-0.0658416748,
0.1043145657,
0.0142730931,
0.0092733493,
-0.0440659299,
0.0416483581,
-0.0247244127,
-0.0482417047,
0.0307261758,
0.0102119623,
0.0099466564,
-0.006159551,
0.0350317955,
-0.0888973251,
0.018660102,
0.0210149232,
0.0219046939,
0.0288458038,
0.0443305373,
-0.0169921909,
-0.0453970954,
-0.0832255706,
0.0501544774,
-0.0210434161,
0.0366770625,
0.0297125597,
0.0254674051,
0.0228815414,
0.0004394554,
0.1251711696,
0.025925776,
0.0715963393,
0.0288095493,
0.0845239908,
-0.0226413421,
-0.0038951293,
0.057315819,
0.0269634128,
-0.0551992916,
0.0441776589,
-0.0871641487,
0.026060747,
-0.0417507216,
0.0040001702,
0.0059455638,
-0.005660729,
-0.0768444389,
-0.0135040674,
-0.0680081025,
0.0077929301,
-0.0359038599,
0.0097945761,
-0.0349127539,
0.0626986921,
0.0264096037,
0.0770167336,
0.0196328741,
-0.0555608571,
-0.0235929359,
0.0029987327,
0.0348831005,
0.0234167408,
0.0474384725,
-0.0494797528,
0.0084900046,
-0.0284331404,
-0.0084936647,
0.0510135628,
0.0367240049,
-0.0036361946,
-0.0156349186,
-0.0385362096,
-0.0087757474,
-0.01637863,
-0.0266292151,
-0.0144831603,
-0.0298010819,
0.0339533761,
0.0524737425,
0.0031979822,
-0.0350552425,
0.0772777274,
-0.0336268246,
-0.06385158,
-0.0339817405,
-0.0410844609,
0.0764438957,
-0.0043239347,
0.0078516221,
-0.0555535331,
0.0543508008,
0.0414163582,
-0.0062832809,
-0.0325022005,
0.0232279208,
2.328e-7,
0.056568183,
0.0298368614,
-0.0319297425,
0.0147756673,
0.0070498139,
-0.0350048468,
-0.0191690214,
-0.0144025572,
0.0672118366,
0.0396067388,
-0.0604721829,
-0.0146299014,
0.0358499289,
0.0636870936,
-0.0226228312,
-0.0075903251,
0.0174205173,
0.0122592654,
-0.0527383611,
-0.0163837485,
0.0281552486,
0.0195332412,
0.0193989817,
0.0068426277,
-0.0259441957,
0.0230748337,
0.0240824614,
-0.0489843488,
0.0388474464,
-0.0023397855,
-0.0541746877,
-0.0117882919,
0.003614482,
0.0443656929,
0.0008345163,
0.0208277982,
-0.0021379183,
-0.0585368909,
0.0143218338,
0.0290662535,
0.020045232,
-0.0576400608,
-0.0589044727,
-0.0709573627,
0.0067464802,
-0.0008200548,
0.0170672536,
0.0405034386,
0.0283029024,
0.0339962281,
0.0511149988,
-0.030550709,
-0.038541846,
0.0382796861,
0.0340677276,
0.053734988,
-0.0318769999,
-0.0028559165,
-0.0087340232,
0.0682491064,
-0.0047249654,
-0.0125928568,
0.0186955053,
0.0021549168,
0.0051837279,
0.0086652311,
-0.0015186488,
1.509458495e-34,
-0.0465866514,
0.0107369777,
0.0467393361,
-0.012049743,
0.0428005792,
-0.034916155,
-0.0156407077,
0.0737032965,
0.0095515866,
0.0089866258,
0.0051270546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15202v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15202v1 | Benchmarking the Generation of Fact Checking Explanations | 2023-08-29T10:40:46 | 2023-08-29T10:40:46 | Daniel Russo, Serra Sinem Tekiroglu, Marco Guerini | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fighting misinformation is a challenging, yet crucial, task. Despite the
growing number of experts being involved in manual fact-checking, this activity
is time-consuming and cannot keep up with the ever-increasing amount of Fake
News produced daily. Hence, automating this process is necessary to help curb
misinformation. Thus far, researchers have mainly focused on claim veracity
classification. In this paper, instead, we address the generation of
justifications (textual explanation of why a claim is classified as either true
or false) and benchmark it with novel datasets and advanced baselines. In
particular, we focus on summarization approaches over unstructured knowledge
(i.e. news articles) and we experiment with several extractive and abstractive
strategies. We employed two datasets with different styles and structures, in
order to assess the generalizability of our findings. Results show that in
justification production summarization benefits from the claim information,
and, in particular, that a claim-driven extractive step improves abstractive
summarization performances. Finally, we show that although cross-dataset
experiments suffer from performance degradation, a unique model trained on a
combination of the two datasets is able to retain style information in an
efficient manner. | [
0.0375453644,
0.0424759425,
0.0310507081,
0.005106437,
-0.0420967638,
0.0336200595,
0.0006991678,
-0.0457460769,
-0.040718127,
-0.0537978746,
0.0456452891,
-0.0362283401,
0.043428272,
0.0244970173,
0.0207484774,
-0.0459962115,
0.0197925642,
0.0328845307,
0.0725654811,
0.0098194145,
0.0386193357,
0.0542550124,
-0.0309215765,
0.0294618979,
-0.0354273282,
0.0021777414,
0.0199419018,
-0.0145157883,
0.058634121,
-0.0139714433,
-0.0052099396,
0.0218141451,
0.0432291701,
0.0522087887,
0.0000016986,
-0.0199738611,
-0.0038274955,
0.0272527933,
-0.025805071,
0.0220333636,
0.0107288128,
-0.0500265397,
0.0172479842,
0.0318378843,
0.0206508189,
-0.0155239282,
0.0106265349,
0.087875098,
0.1011775956,
0.1074480042,
-0.0069924844,
-0.0426848717,
0.0182764083,
0.0002497819,
-0.0535019897,
-0.0111756753,
0.0111093707,
0.0403373726,
-0.0452121459,
-0.0063759903,
0.0437652096,
0.0093061412,
0.0049506589,
-0.0334843658,
-0.0330531932,
0.0189207792,
-0.066991657,
-0.0157158859,
0.0266636126,
0.0440616459,
0.0225224122,
-0.0686582997,
0.0413046665,
-0.0152882719,
0.0094350893,
0.0492139235,
-0.0140834842,
0.0738122687,
-0.0493739247,
0.0251572076,
0.0274972916,
0.0065152468,
0.0084943073,
0.0362381078,
0.0094581731,
0.0011014964,
-0.007919318,
-0.0224026833,
-0.0047464315,
0.0029329848,
-0.0147290993,
-0.076438956,
-0.0146562979,
0.0203615241,
-0.010178824,
-0.0054735728,
-0.0581346825,
-0.0463140905,
0.039986793,
-0.048805479,
0.0152003914,
-0.007714774,
-0.025328625,
0.039703805,
-0.0527653843,
0.010834951,
0.0155134136,
0.0196409952,
0.0215465408,
-0.0242051426,
-0.0489728339,
0.0122784125,
-0.0182735492,
0.0309504624,
-0.0453406461,
0.0082734525,
-0.0281640496,
-0.0336632244,
-0.0220128037,
0.0365015082,
-0.0135741718,
0.0207053125,
0.0221282858,
-0.0104512479,
-0.0336137749,
-0.0050762813,
-0.0312807858,
0.0105057368,
0.0523774326,
-0.0168230459,
-0.0170966815,
0.0391212776,
0.0098739322,
0.0288672931,
-0.0063073076,
-0.0198448449,
-0.0238061957,
0.0247556809,
-0.0453323945,
-0.0471631065,
-0.0005055803,
-0.0618578978,
-0.0073655583,
-0.0410582609,
-0.0045921383,
-0.0233357605,
-0.0455507524,
0.0054805665,
-0.0068286192,
0.0394264199,
-0.0187323205,
0.0270311832,
-0.0226076618,
-0.0188847408,
0.0476508066,
-0.0045126947,
0.0081374422,
0.0485128462,
0.0346037932,
0.053351216,
0.0719504505,
0.0182102062,
0.0176113658,
-0.049089089,
0.0689708143,
0.0227129553,
0.0482513495,
-0.0007022838,
-0.042441491,
-0.0027316834,
0.0269202255,
0.017021006,
-0.0150706526,
-0.0057752673,
0.0544192195,
-0.0237347037,
0.0127145601,
0.0033298151,
0.0679939911,
0.0131402304,
0.0206465498,
0.0310172644,
-0.023124963,
0.0270388443,
-0.0651232526,
0.0372477435,
0.0341251791,
0.0396510065,
-0.0288928337,
-0.0654233396,
-0.0198216625,
0.0084532518,
-0.004073055,
0.0227230303,
0.0145048788,
0.0252108946,
-0.0331893936,
0.037238434,
0.0384633653,
-0.0419910885,
-0.0331352726,
-0.047995504,
0.0479369052,
-0.0008960944,
0.0133181382,
-0.0114725456,
0.0250054523,
-0.0230275784,
0.0378505997,
0.0480464771,
0.0659967884,
-0.0429397561,
-0.0007943847,
-0.0173118785,
-0.0273524169,
-0.0747844502,
0.0286625046,
-0.0010254828,
0.0342189409,
-0.0133280791,
0.0462438464,
-0.0206353404,
-0.0663212761,
0.0428340323,
-0.0006662668,
-0.0158837773,
0.020675648,
0.0165403523,
-0.0079589123,
0.0405404642,
-0.0234149825,
-0.0120784184,
0.0092271222,
-0.0035024057,
-0.0438786671,
0.0287702344,
0.0054336647,
-0.0519348942,
0.0099456068,
-0.0221771561,
-0.0358848087,
0.0280371141,
-0.0535096675,
-0.0374504626,
0.0158445686,
-0.0391155109,
-0.0162838269,
-0.0557447486,
-0.0196568705,
0.0029082007,
-0.0196379367,
0.0061030248,
0.0929407701,
0.0082574887,
-0.0016645362,
0.0113636199,
-0.0018947797,
0.0254764874,
-0.019146964,
0.0402789973,
-0.0194827616,
-0.0157263521,
0.0235910881,
0.0450120717,
-0.0340992771,
-0.0105807697,
0.0086049652,
-0.0582115017,
0.0133306812,
-0.0462143235,
-0.0047893552,
0.0519211292,
-0.0367844999,
0.0062690806,
0.0174719542,
-0.0492817387,
-0.0203707013,
0.0191600341,
0.0199371148,
0.0512816831,
0.0034726267,
0.0112579819,
-0.0328101479,
0.0188681595,
0.0062376074,
0.0445841625,
0.0277259573,
-0.0109655168,
-0.0508226305,
-0.0053653494,
-0.0576578043,
-0.0199972074,
-0.0264758561,
0.0039678216,
0.0131191062,
0.025037149,
-0.03915466,
0.0384173393,
0.0584150963,
0.0334746912,
0.0236895774,
0.0714957044,
-0.0079957685,
-0.0166876577,
-0.0459065214,
0.0605818294,
0.0372836776,
-0.0593381785,
0.0493531972,
0.0529133938,
0.0322816111,
0.0110748066,
-0.0268993918,
0.0234439187,
0.0185926892,
-0.0121508231,
0.0113204494,
-0.0230249409,
0.0191941354,
0.0485339537,
-0.0396565385,
-0.0469765402,
0.076009281,
-0.0329043306,
0.0496585034,
-0.0235799085,
-0.0510222055,
-0.0283807535,
0.0259181969,
-0.0348240137,
0.0201283786,
0.0138639836,
0.0105750049,
0.0126382001,
-0.0562640876,
0.0813255906,
0.007622763,
0.0376441926,
-0.0531723984,
0.0454264842,
-0.0097016292,
-0.0220417343,
-0.0262517557,
-0.0970207676,
0.0105087664,
0.0103100985,
-0.0286182053,
-0.0201458447,
-0.0651970133,
-0.0001946694,
0.06638515,
0.0614303425,
-0.0074877306,
0.0050144447,
0.0259820446,
0.0372598544,
0.0232564248,
0.0054399697,
0.0508901626,
-0.017738767,
0.0073929233,
0.037825983,
-0.0413361825,
0.0262200199,
-0.0255960245,
-0.061616715,
-0.0520395301,
-0.0570682697,
-0.0086510321,
-0.0285640676,
0.0620330535,
-0.0491982698,
0.0136274109,
0.0638051108,
0.0150524694,
0.042492006,
-0.0066243978,
0.0257293712,
0.0025995853,
0.0110301264,
-0.0152434856,
-0.0618244372,
0.0077017588,
-0.0132985255,
0.0189332645,
-0.0199376326,
-0.0053798375,
-0.005507614,
-0.0852722824,
0.0460777134,
-0.0107195769,
-0.0489387475,
-0.0726755932,
-0.0597668514,
0.0031614208,
0.0117287179,
-0.0119845942,
0.0205227006,
0.019616941,
0.0025220828,
0.0392325222,
-0.0456856117,
-0.0242200866,
-0.0078299809,
0.0139174983,
-0.0027980267,
0.0250532087,
0.0473167934,
0.0082959831,
-0.0250534266,
0.0054017045,
-0.0144378711,
-0.0246878508,
0.0137879336,
0.0919799358,
0.0023338632,
0.0078084874,
-0.0129008563,
0.0437597483,
0.0218176935,
-0.0311764758,
0.0067371121,
0.0134957638,
-0.0070593711,
-0.0527627207,
-0.0314420797,
0.0299844295,
0.0277385823,
0.0753563121,
0.0457764566,
0.0424473248,
-0.0262219422,
-0.0445070751,
-0.0262063593,
-0.1050814986,
-0.0011646675,
0.0277933702,
-0.0151514076,
-0.0097299702,
-0.0902169347,
-0.0387341529,
-0.0288296584,
0.0112151299,
-0.0346820392,
-0.0414002277,
-0.0063381949,
-0.0031539353,
-0.0555039123,
0.0042882902,
0.0063222903,
0.0315738209,
0.0271316301,
-0.0733832419,
0.0115540018,
-0.0356937237,
-0.0185887478,
0.0235112887,
-0.0193836112,
-0.0593189262,
-0.0502735227,
0.0050295591,
0.0165024046,
0.0895358622,
0.0309394579,
-0.0159855448,
0.0630340353,
0.0230370928,
0.01067401,
0.0000367065,
0.0418366045,
-0.012304646,
0.012887978,
0.0059559969,
-0.0273186676,
0.0402694829,
-0.011485015,
0.0077388422,
-0.0265857633,
0.015320722,
0.037256401,
0.0415913053,
0.009577102,
-0.0182918143,
-0.0128551954,
-0.0358540565,
-0.0284161717,
-0.0596607067,
-0.0399624705,
-0.0264846887,
0.0661597699,
-0.0349945091,
-0.0316362791,
-0.0001166951,
0.0069481125,
-0.0394968987,
0.0256424621,
-0.0366971195,
-0.0044700904,
-0.0409216024,
0.032656543,
-0.0358562097,
-0.0032812722,
-0.0868807882,
-0.0279577319,
-0.02030956,
0.0449336506,
-0.0006213826,
0.004535981,
0.0459304936,
0.0184521545,
0.0101226922,
-0.0386953317,
-0.077665098,
0.0153461555,
-0.0538916886,
-0.0198712796,
0.0176805053,
-0.0379207917,
0.0468327068,
0.0141605577,
-0.0413772538,
0.0183152389,
0.0489629768,
0.0259568635,
-0.0343419053,
-0.0119234202,
0.0168332886,
-0.0341608562,
-0.012692905,
0.0611577109,
-0.0069679827,
0.0225939956,
0.0158916004,
-0.0631417856,
-0.0375779048,
-0.0481204987,
-0.0261116009,
0.033853583,
0.0194781683,
-0.0485821068,
-0.0642267168,
-0.0440800823,
0.0095628323,
0.0324767865,
0.043651402,
0.0137342084,
-0.0092719207,
0.0583375879,
0.0422847271,
-0.0243203379,
-0.0688470602,
0.0222178455,
-0.0157873556,
0.0248272885,
-0.0113520492,
-5.615064681e-33,
-0.0063173426,
-0.0252842829,
-0.0159257855,
0.0002127353,
0.000347447,
0.0335873477,
-0.0665831193,
-0.0536965802,
-0.0327656269,
0.0797185749,
0.0264862739,
0.0420560986,
0.0040672212,
0.0276436415,
-0.0245239977,
0.0165007561,
0.0447365195,
0.0093669668,
-0.0664519519,
0.0490190051,
0.0690849647,
-0.0343146697,
0.0515006445,
-0.0715857148,
0.053471636,
-0.0090614585,
-0.0264942665,
-0.0038512305,
-0.015868051,
0.0317767598,
0.0261553898,
0.0480639637,
0.0305833742,
-0.017991133,
0.0030093144,
0.0029806111,
-0.062007919,
-0.0167778917,
0.0650371984,
-0.0508051142,
-0.0448434241,
0.0072331955,
0.0167845562,
-0.0011485581,
0.0176942199,
-0.0524963662,
0.0337572284,
-0.0369638987,
-0.0102629559,
-0.0891045928,
-0.0581154898,
0.0375191905,
-0.0205541719,
-0.018068552,
-0.0415191315,
0.032955464,
0.0141886882,
0.0174707063,
-0.0619478859,
0.0182131901,
-0.0013684221,
0.0169049054,
0.0231215991,
-0.0272449777,
-0.0400774777,
0.0792936385,
-0.0229003429,
0.0385558009,
-0.0710247904,
0.0579025,
-0.0473577939,
0.0220867004,
0.050672058,
0.0529674292,
0.0445883311,
-0.0123148998,
-0.0959954485,
0.0427608341,
0.0015463578,
-0.0211174879,
0.0129667968,
-0.0455756262,
-0.0181422438,
0.0144405682,
-0.0382956155,
-0.0078047402,
-0.0025436603,
0.0187650528,
-0.0248038843,
0.0504053831,
-0.0415542498,
0.0253002271,
-0.0296611153,
-0.0167955104,
0.0408983305,
0.017244067,
-0.0562708154,
-0.009464086,
0.0059279143,
-0.0263980553,
-0.0564371534,
0.0281031057,
0.0117971208,
0.0515274182,
0.0096682599,
0.0087159341,
0.0924701318,
-0.008823283,
-0.038102176,
0.0427122675,
-0.0293416176,
0.0472180396,
-0.0543274544,
-0.0077857142,
-0.0039396309,
0.0310731065,
-0.0238242224,
-0.0122397495,
-0.0284623485,
-0.0062584886,
-0.0077443854,
0.0181332603,
0.013676784,
0.0341566727,
-0.0104795489,
-0.001866553,
-0.016818637,
-0.0002594179,
0.0330892168,
-0.0647798926,
0.0087067839,
0.0161999092,
2.364e-7,
0.0126465941,
0.0245034136,
0.0493104644,
0.0148387672,
-0.0079673287,
0.0340617113,
0.0357819945,
0.0072977291,
-0.0084244208,
-0.0773366988,
-0.0190333091,
0.0339363925,
0.0431352928,
0.0519026294,
-0.0305771343,
-0.0053564007,
-0.0615828969,
-0.0584332719,
-0.0311144833,
-0.0079998616,
0.0680106506,
0.0101360921,
-0.0064386427,
-0.0283145439,
0.010983821,
-0.0118276309,
0.0686145276,
0.0416587479,
-0.0331955962,
0.0099625643,
0.0821261629,
-0.015738355,
0.006799907,
0.019866569,
-0.0443026796,
-0.0025767137,
-0.0254930072,
0.0364449397,
0.0019056876,
0.00127816,
-0.0283037741,
-0.0425728634,
0.0426760018,
-0.0248352643,
0.0445211269,
-0.0468771607,
-0.0263451245,
-0.0549917705,
-0.070654422,
0.0318040587,
-0.0100130523,
-0.0070499657,
-0.0113995643,
0.0596605875,
-0.0313892253,
0.0025895571,
0.035031449,
-0.0755416602,
-0.0385123938,
0.0288229231,
-0.0227697939,
0.0007329427,
0.041532293,
-0.0024477032,
0.0448376238,
-0.0623793229,
0.0222861171,
2.048354467e-34,
0.0596588999,
-0.0036361283,
-0.0164881703,
-0.0376244336,
0.0555798225,
0.0156217739,
-0.0147020863,
-0.0403481759,
0.0166910626,
-0.0144728739,
-0.0071176006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15192v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15192v1 | Enhancing Psychological Counseling with Large Language Model: A Multifaceted Decision-Support System for Non-Professionals | 2023-08-29T10:20:53 | 2023-08-29T10:20:53 | Guanghui Fu, Qing Zhao, Jianqiang Li, Dan Luo, Changwei Song, Wei Zhai, Shuo Liu, Fan Wang, Yan Wang, Lijuan Cheng, Juan Zhang, Bing Xiang Yang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | In the contemporary landscape of social media, an alarming number of users
express negative emotions, some of which manifest as strong suicidal
intentions. This situation underscores a profound need for trained
psychological counselors who can enact effective mental interventions. However,
the development of these professionals is often an imperative but
time-consuming task. Consequently, the mobilization of non-professionals or
volunteers in this capacity emerges as a pressing concern. Leveraging the
capabilities of artificial intelligence, and in particular, the recent advances
in large language models, offers a viable solution to this challenge. This
paper introduces a novel model constructed on the foundation of large language
models to fully assist non-professionals in providing psychological
interventions on online user discourses. This framework makes it plausible to
harness the power of non-professional counselors in a meaningful way. A
comprehensive study was conducted involving ten professional psychological
counselors of varying expertise, evaluating the system across five critical
dimensions. The findings affirm that our system is capable of analyzing
patients' issues with relative accuracy and proffering professional-level
strategies recommendations, thereby enhancing support for non-professionals.
This research serves as a compelling validation of the application of large
language models in the field of psychology and lays the groundwork for a new
paradigm of community-based mental health support. | [
0.1129102632,
0.0300897732,
-0.0248558037,
-0.0255218092,
-0.0423999988,
0.0117957303,
0.0402746871,
0.0157013554,
0.0762446076,
-0.0290029161,
0.0022250961,
-0.0156725999,
-0.0649385154,
0.0315255746,
-0.0186696798,
-0.0674876869,
-0.0451513641,
0.0236624964,
0.1051356941,
0.0013136036,
0.0619097687,
0.0323460065,
-0.026958771,
0.0664552227,
0.0195631906,
-0.0044698827,
0.0483080521,
-0.0042627654,
0.0136737321,
-0.0579488389,
-0.0011159476,
0.028178107,
-0.0028024511,
0.0002476643,
0.0000020512,
-0.0225964766,
0.001202019,
0.00850699,
-0.0142695773,
-0.083588399,
0.0620966628,
-0.0556836426,
-0.0020267679,
0.0200358909,
-0.0180553794,
-0.0150671555,
0.0509109609,
0.0473058447,
0.0584687628,
0.0621388778,
-0.0257693473,
-0.0289472155,
-0.0155832721,
0.0155365793,
-0.0761025622,
0.0221187975,
0.0314001516,
-0.0206150562,
0.0483086966,
0.0097414088,
0.0075697135,
0.0286031943,
-0.0331244096,
-0.0170967244,
-0.0234526563,
-0.0101584867,
-0.0173892323,
-0.0726135299,
0.0135172037,
0.0666784048,
0.0264477842,
0.0116817346,
0.017688727,
-0.0210394002,
0.0144503824,
0.045672901,
-0.0223659799,
0.0155392671,
-0.0152642448,
-0.0166640915,
0.0359437168,
0.0130361412,
0.0140027655,
0.0089859134,
0.0364736691,
0.0463705324,
-0.0239461735,
-0.0186395328,
0.0361719579,
0.0268321242,
-0.0495130904,
-0.0470501557,
0.0670091063,
0.0263727736,
-0.075070858,
0.0272503328,
0.004296138,
-0.04780671,
0.0013776376,
-0.0536877885,
0.0424072966,
0.0381797999,
0.019623464,
-0.0131766098,
0.0668664947,
-0.0482521169,
0.0097120795,
0.0073763304,
-0.0087244306,
0.0364477076,
-0.0965210274,
0.010986058,
-0.0372931138,
0.0051052086,
-0.0004890129,
-0.0182644706,
-0.0561359972,
-0.000599129,
-0.0565677769,
0.0008331047,
-0.0206625778,
-0.0062482669,
0.0112318154,
-0.0115003437,
-0.0333476737,
0.046169389,
-0.0443471931,
0.0208186898,
-0.0108775906,
-0.0462866612,
0.0866985619,
0.0036350165,
0.0004155145,
-0.0260523502,
0.0189806987,
0.0365693085,
0.0279775932,
0.0087881284,
-0.0445747823,
-0.0222516153,
-0.0447610915,
-0.0189170577,
-0.0379904471,
-0.0326791406,
0.0152342962,
0.0265934039,
0.0172195807,
-0.0350587144,
0.0321298502,
0.0077323844,
-0.0594949201,
0.0818631276,
-0.0605798513,
0.0423905961,
0.0397166312,
0.0268457923,
0.0122510344,
0.0301208012,
-0.0132273594,
0.0273334309,
0.0408078395,
-0.0432016253,
0.0157816578,
0.0030638871,
-0.031438902,
-0.0405960828,
-0.0411377102,
-0.0209413134,
-0.0498252697,
0.0408807695,
-0.0540118255,
0.0319805965,
-0.0052492372,
0.0158030428,
0.0555418618,
0.0777975172,
0.0126510067,
0.0732404888,
0.0390597954,
0.0523584373,
-0.0229161549,
-0.0431364961,
-0.0249282029,
-0.0070734727,
-0.0398333743,
-0.0353742354,
-0.0007277924,
-0.0284969658,
-0.0167537909,
-0.0668404549,
-0.0247437097,
-0.0278091654,
-0.0164541621,
0.0427558646,
-0.0001153084,
-0.0228565726,
0.0299136713,
-0.0139962062,
0.0320527703,
-0.0032231507,
-0.017951386,
-0.0483395196,
0.0248224214,
0.1168481335,
0.010227778,
-0.0476273447,
-0.0099396063,
-0.0246861055,
0.0200176425,
0.0483455323,
-0.0031295009,
0.0031264143,
-0.0375181213,
-0.019411739,
-0.0141054681,
0.0446381532,
-0.0132601736,
-0.0154606085,
-0.0121334502,
0.0286822394,
-0.0286854021,
0.0360932834,
-0.069953382,
0.0187612493,
-0.0030526053,
-0.0185029302,
-0.0132213049,
0.0271850228,
0.0474571213,
0.043253731,
-0.0079603679,
0.029042298,
-0.0154999308,
-0.0421338081,
-0.0555639677,
-0.0210364982,
-0.0095535768,
0.0519767143,
0.0247315355,
-0.0336442627,
-0.0031561188,
0.0132664936,
-0.0031442449,
-0.0039077704,
0.0624470562,
-0.0563397631,
0.018572839,
0.011316021,
-0.0209276471,
-0.0258590858,
-0.027747361,
-0.0114429016,
0.030346036,
-0.0041917223,
0.0320443437,
-0.0187168084,
-0.0222104061,
-0.0408294238,
-0.0076568741,
-0.0318833888,
-0.0160496831,
0.0136389835,
0.0130926296,
0.0257584862,
0.0004756738,
-0.0307129808,
-0.0409318544,
-0.1164029166,
-0.0050437925,
-0.0134247188,
0.0004923267,
0.0075138151,
-0.0438206084,
-0.0179997794,
-0.0031756139,
-0.0509065129,
0.0267047249,
0.0340549238,
0.0379286073,
-0.0000515117,
0.0378808826,
-0.0051145228,
-0.0229508691,
-0.0214843638,
-0.0183546208,
-0.0155630717,
0.0359612219,
-0.0624216497,
-0.0257549696,
0.0129416268,
-0.072844021,
-0.0145566128,
0.0089920135,
-0.0555569157,
0.0281375777,
-0.0172836185,
0.0670456067,
-0.0121131539,
0.0247424543,
0.0566205457,
0.0285797175,
0.0561296046,
-0.0215334706,
-0.0112809697,
-0.0279252045,
-0.066430673,
-0.057723511,
-0.0332225151,
0.0026972562,
0.0129778488,
0.0049260571,
-0.0117142033,
-0.0598835759,
0.0175418127,
-0.0374078415,
0.006431249,
-0.0145914592,
-0.03558366,
0.0223451145,
0.0161063466,
0.0060613942,
0.0004760405,
0.0605145134,
0.0529241189,
-0.0031357564,
-0.0217025355,
-0.0930502489,
-0.0255264957,
0.0177623648,
0.0158363562,
0.0460215062,
0.020484861,
-0.0197653417,
0.0586097427,
-0.0398262888,
-0.0219899099,
-0.0475755893,
-0.0190564469,
-0.0340041742,
-0.0005297096,
0.0542302541,
-0.0125689777,
-0.0084054228,
-0.058463227,
-0.0904878303,
-0.0272406898,
0.0072708591,
0.005939458,
-0.0233411193,
-0.0155127523,
0.0366424844,
0.0283747856,
0.0126465214,
-0.0501185805,
-0.0069011245,
-0.0154447136,
0.0157908257,
-0.0055402014,
0.0403012596,
-0.0193613991,
0.0495628826,
0.0663826913,
-0.0325492173,
-0.0177117437,
-0.0149804046,
0.0004940785,
-0.0054898718,
0.020492617,
-0.0046723215,
0.0366118141,
0.0101955552,
0.0119415009,
-0.0009817946,
0.0902476683,
0.0131107476,
-0.0665492564,
0.0200950149,
-0.0668212548,
-0.0314836912,
0.023292847,
-0.0282050706,
-0.0154765481,
-0.0088605527,
-0.0505172238,
0.0229083765,
-0.0581345521,
-0.0150268003,
0.0206310172,
-0.0584206432,
0.059534926,
-0.0074668685,
0.0260007288,
0.0114309266,
0.0020047636,
0.0158634186,
0.0064163147,
-0.0218378417,
-0.0483035035,
0.0000938157,
0.0052986862,
0.0132125644,
-0.0752015635,
-0.0627521798,
0.0148390168,
-0.0252981521,
0.0810289383,
-0.0011033383,
0.0453099795,
-0.0363804959,
-0.0192377754,
-0.020941427,
0.05027619,
0.00172971,
0.0191112533,
0.0287704002,
0.0026421316,
0.0197727717,
-0.079497546,
0.0635004565,
-0.0456985943,
-0.0124416184,
0.0207271464,
0.0796112865,
-0.0061511295,
-0.0440687276,
-0.0040110694,
0.0751869082,
0.0589108244,
0.0164864138,
0.0255666934,
-0.0785161704,
0.0196545701,
0.019704381,
0.0084772548,
0.0499915294,
-0.05954412,
-0.0080488725,
0.0104928408,
-0.0028671226,
-0.0282340366,
-0.0202209577,
0.0453411005,
0.0223025419,
-0.0014876976,
-0.0356186368,
0.0403479449,
0.0204680227,
-0.0172767118,
0.0644211471,
-0.0041150162,
0.0461816452,
-0.0445795171,
0.0146325119,
-0.0103338491,
0.0108220978,
0.0087069813,
-0.0004601577,
0.0221676044,
-0.0128239337,
0.0417146049,
0.0376814418,
0.0175921936,
-0.0679524839,
-0.0037309267,
-0.0886173397,
-0.0063304976,
0.0363220312,
-0.0385805964,
-0.0445878394,
-0.0064021959,
0.0382328369,
0.0163516384,
0.0280117001,
0.0256903172,
0.0704084411,
0.0431734957,
-0.003730525,
-0.0709150881,
0.0032830562,
0.005571303,
0.0435588397,
-0.0072327629,
-0.0049597509,
-0.0215568319,
0.0054410263,
-0.068926312,
0.0001971292,
-0.0235290434,
-0.0198264085,
-0.0155083928,
0.0454441532,
-0.0063130436,
0.0052046222,
-0.0532061644,
-0.0514553934,
-0.0421879403,
-0.024164658,
0.038165912,
0.030676879,
0.0303621702,
0.0084801046,
0.0056920527,
-0.0185391847,
0.013011937,
-0.0108159008,
0.0466306098,
-0.0321017317,
0.0881655961,
-0.0060989452,
0.0081635872,
0.0445634723,
0.0238712169,
-0.0037954587,
-0.1231092066,
-0.0031048728,
0.0280295871,
0.0323447362,
0.0277806763,
0.0143813649,
-0.0367210284,
-0.0035525803,
-0.0120475795,
0.0166962929,
-0.0232931972,
-0.0622231998,
0.0096750464,
0.0011535367,
-0.0207715183,
0.0040966175,
-0.0130203143,
-0.0375680104,
-0.0067449464,
0.0097517762,
-0.031716533,
-0.0114659434,
-0.0181536339,
-0.0226050764,
0.0556524657,
-0.0486234277,
0.0203565992,
-0.0551582091,
-0.0348682739,
-0.0114186341,
-0.0254520886,
-0.0231267102,
-0.0338360965,
0.003952262,
0.0016596635,
0.0164023433,
-0.0005994751,
-0.0649077222,
0.0601520017,
-0.0195793137,
0.0080537694,
-0.0257793628,
-5.369362484e-33,
0.0276208594,
-0.0625323579,
-0.0062701027,
-0.0323513448,
0.0115491804,
-0.0129070329,
0.0330821536,
0.0293414854,
0.0306628793,
0.0591021888,
0.0302434042,
0.05206782,
-0.0016605868,
0.0098918565,
0.0321289785,
0.0227162968,
0.0181601048,
-0.0084707821,
0.0077312565,
0.0158117861,
-0.0247501135,
0.0289426446,
0.0168836098,
-0.1069949344,
0.0522118546,
0.0068539302,
-0.0039434494,
0.0488056429,
0.0312326197,
0.0205757841,
-0.0040780497,
0.0537566543,
0.0527343228,
-0.0066071521,
0.0267426427,
0.0534842312,
-0.0192831773,
-0.0279268473,
0.0287514683,
-0.0295319129,
-0.0571882948,
-0.0106434077,
0.0201854724,
-0.0236872099,
-0.0248278044,
-0.0177349914,
0.0151753621,
-0.048352886,
0.0480038114,
0.008035521,
-0.015356564,
-0.0106588127,
-0.0014919717,
0.0408387966,
-0.0235807002,
0.0573048815,
-0.0810868666,
0.0135650458,
-0.026883129,
0.0153252445,
0.0024748861,
-0.0205391757,
0.0024347475,
-0.0392775275,
-0.056357991,
0.0285458993,
-0.0130125098,
0.0035004565,
-0.048766423,
-0.0239202417,
-0.0205494128,
0.0371766314,
0.0468699746,
0.0340378806,
-0.008278003,
-0.0182930846,
-0.0247117523,
-0.0146889621,
0.0278696194,
0.0059534437,
0.0472248979,
-0.0032567189,
-0.0558954999,
-0.0249231532,
-0.0194782522,
-0.0472396314,
-0.0240434855,
-0.0418110602,
0.0009758126,
-0.0241979212,
-0.0219602045,
0.0098657394,
-0.0308407303,
-0.0389098115,
0.0076734251,
-0.0166647006,
0.0342144147,
0.0630130693,
0.0052834125,
0.0188585836,
-0.0635769293,
-0.0037134755,
-0.0256622247,
-0.0272913594,
0.0410165079,
-0.0018501659,
0.0178076606,
-0.0164573099,
-0.0199564062,
-0.0223107953,
0.0112505974,
0.0473956056,
0.0231147092,
0.0074638491,
-0.0013200421,
0.0258521345,
-0.0125647876,
0.0435034782,
0.0284092966,
-0.0015332006,
-0.0197182857,
-0.0164012704,
-0.0342759416,
-0.0154756848,
-0.04440137,
-0.0451925658,
-0.0336006247,
0.0426252298,
0.0364744328,
-0.0085132243,
-0.0048264796,
-0.0374430232,
2.683e-7,
0.0243623983,
0.0796688497,
-0.0240567122,
0.0029102566,
0.0168675687,
0.0018752827,
0.0432432368,
0.0383079909,
0.0348173343,
-0.0057054223,
0.037484657,
0.036410816,
0.020950852,
0.0361972786,
0.0119378399,
-0.0221754536,
-0.0134252161,
-0.0257277265,
-0.0726834238,
0.0394532681,
0.0943239778,
0.0346251428,
0.0212593116,
-0.0339410529,
-0.0163828079,
-0.0111041451,
0.0234497413,
-0.0584885664,
0.0009522275,
0.0268246699,
0.0415706821,
0.0214456841,
0.0213831943,
0.0377134457,
0.0257991366,
-0.0174303111,
-0.0077541415,
0.0936520249,
-0.0483304821,
0.0406575762,
0.0034688227,
0.0289278459,
0.0301197469,
-0.0116420211,
0.013074738,
-0.1002308279,
-0.0582068376,
-0.031664487,
-0.0247864258,
-0.0753787085,
0.0040722885,
-0.0235843752,
-0.0509674661,
0.0557988472,
0.0324742757,
0.0001720692,
0.0291323792,
-0.044089742,
0.0160370227,
0.0417719632,
-0.0263051409,
-0.0140460208,
0.0032434566,
0.0235573798,
0.0011000502,
-0.0368311852,
0.0710956156,
1.696102087e-34,
0.0003011554,
0.0660027042,
0.0467005633,
-0.0376970246,
0.033610817,
0.061908599,
-0.027069902,
0.0196480788,
0.0143951299,
-0.064808622,
-0.0001712451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15154v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15154v2 | The Anatomy of Conspirators: Unveiling Traits using a Comprehensive Twitter Dataset | 2023-08-29T09:35:23 | 2024-02-05T10:11:37 | Margherita Gambini, Serena Tardelli, Maurizio Tesconi | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL | The discourse around conspiracy theories is currently thriving amidst the
rampant misinformation in online environments. Research in this field has been
focused on detecting conspiracy theories on social media, often relying on
limited datasets. In this study, we present a novel methodology for
constructing a Twitter dataset that encompasses accounts engaged in
conspiracy-related activities throughout the year 2022. Our approach centers on
data collection that is independent of specific conspiracy theories and
information operations. Additionally, our dataset includes a control group
comprising randomly selected users who can be fairly compared to the
individuals involved in conspiracy activities. This comprehensive collection
effort yielded a total of 15K accounts and 37M tweets extracted from their
timelines. We conduct a comparative analysis of the two groups across three
dimensions: topics, profiles, and behavioral characteristics. The results
indicate that conspiracy and control users exhibit similarity in terms of their
profile metadata characteristics. However, they diverge significantly in terms
of behavior and activity, particularly regarding the discussed topics, the
terminology used, and their stance on trending subjects. In addition, we find
no significant disparity in the presence of bot users between the two groups.
Finally, we develop a classifier to identify conspiracy users using features
borrowed from bot, troll and linguistic literature. The results demonstrate a
high accuracy level (with an F1 score of 0.94), enabling us to uncover the most
discriminating features associated with conspiracy-related accounts. | [
0.0477390476,
0.0526457354,
-0.0193820875,
-0.0146404458,
-0.0561826564,
0.0012918495,
0.0304528605,
-0.0012031415,
-0.0021176813,
-0.0212865602,
0.0270070788,
-0.0140068121,
-0.0088387802,
0.033601962,
-0.0075987522,
-0.018283749,
0.0212430302,
0.025391154,
0.0535813645,
-0.0378774665,
0.0385036618,
0.042976249,
-0.040267285,
0.0195715632,
-0.02967925,
0.001771725,
0.0430018604,
-0.0075591025,
0.045869533,
0.0225489661,
0.0355603434,
0.0414362215,
0.0209382828,
0.1122427583,
0.000001888,
-0.0182303693,
-0.0480406508,
-0.0358227715,
-0.0156963412,
-0.0267037675,
0.0725385994,
-0.0047760992,
0.0135879833,
0.0411064923,
-0.0508204401,
0.0540441349,
0.027518332,
0.035578046,
0.0387854688,
0.0837231353,
-0.0280131865,
-0.0187147558,
-0.0030839371,
0.0161147472,
0.0179527365,
0.0260809772,
0.0387456231,
-0.0051526115,
-0.0589732751,
0.0090335989,
0.0412990078,
0.0090126889,
-0.0063589187,
-0.0009617257,
-0.0350714289,
0.0044424357,
-0.0347411297,
-0.0214088112,
0.0361241773,
0.0050237174,
0.0265792422,
-0.0514901802,
0.0552607998,
0.0374025963,
0.0033488381,
0.0457169451,
-0.0141154015,
0.0153637882,
-0.0522270501,
0.0019019983,
0.0454394706,
0.0166318733,
0.0268810801,
0.0554144792,
0.0168708656,
-0.0103391623,
-0.0324708037,
-0.0283630323,
-0.0469011143,
-0.0405625515,
-0.0036794813,
-0.0426349491,
0.0280667599,
-0.0147278346,
-0.0265677739,
-0.00209986,
-0.0623768494,
-0.0667479262,
0.0260717366,
-0.0504364893,
-0.0425702035,
0.0067884056,
0.0178530011,
0.0639290288,
0.0156244952,
-0.0020006823,
-0.0120101627,
0.0234806575,
0.0185169782,
-0.0211634301,
-0.0526837632,
0.007412767,
0.0362361297,
-0.0118219825,
0.0378157161,
0.0152411265,
-0.0494757257,
-0.0263183638,
-0.0232855622,
-0.0176020972,
-0.0538127385,
0.007675142,
0.0107342461,
-0.0217826236,
-0.0113287987,
0.0152059998,
-0.0560501851,
0.0244476069,
-0.0193299409,
-0.0247184299,
-0.0099677667,
0.0420394763,
0.0458025895,
-0.0004516164,
0.0172662102,
0.0166281853,
0.0370207243,
-0.0155678373,
-0.0131122647,
-0.028978806,
0.0174534172,
-0.0236745216,
0.0043530599,
-0.0393264517,
0.0163022913,
-0.0014442435,
-0.0194207337,
0.0025023457,
0.0031706719,
0.0347706825,
-0.0157625023,
0.0309436005,
-0.0256260037,
0.0352116376,
0.059089534,
0.0389656089,
-0.038271904,
0.0461864918,
-0.0149167357,
0.0973931924,
0.0728415176,
-0.0105445338,
0.0300528761,
0.0172662847,
0.0220182184,
0.0062945117,
0.0235145111,
-0.0110310903,
-0.0344893672,
-0.0348901674,
-0.0158851724,
-0.0042686276,
-0.0049940408,
-0.0032620789,
0.0200567264,
0.0592998564,
-0.0186731741,
-0.019404579,
0.0145753659,
0.0079363743,
0.0116248466,
-0.0621187501,
0.00924493,
-0.0160539858,
-0.0725171864,
-0.0720309541,
0.0002254114,
0.0568028167,
-0.0094190957,
-0.014088843,
-0.0352237709,
-0.0005131149,
0.0469739176,
-0.0243847296,
-0.0154475514,
-0.025639005,
-0.00996684,
-0.0399244986,
0.0197950546,
0.013366811,
-0.023183018,
-0.0612150766,
-0.0032090789,
0.0657234415,
-0.0097545227,
0.0167669784,
-0.0241867099,
-0.0432390384,
0.0746920258,
0.0411750823,
0.0224912222,
-0.0116759259,
-0.0533924103,
-0.0068016439,
0.0070230369,
-0.0066120937,
0.0037587022,
0.0415857993,
0.0481103547,
0.0351239443,
-0.0105437767,
-0.0061692982,
-0.0131393373,
0.0131267738,
-0.0494285338,
-0.0211549494,
-0.0300659593,
0.0201562699,
0.0546805635,
0.0095664393,
0.0032287033,
-0.0363293663,
0.019879153,
-0.0016025978,
-0.0498214327,
-0.011107903,
0.0429606922,
0.0810015276,
0.0078965118,
-0.0157251209,
-0.0278277714,
0.0257920511,
0.016943993,
0.0109357536,
0.0991372615,
-0.0307537522,
-0.0083619943,
-0.0136448648,
-0.0467049219,
-0.0604254343,
0.0249726232,
-0.0024540357,
0.0803558975,
-0.0308203809,
-0.021552464,
0.0362654813,
-0.0934448242,
0.0287421048,
0.0320971385,
0.0125815365,
-0.0515028425,
-0.0329127125,
0.0385109708,
0.0379818566,
-0.0357237682,
-0.0506036319,
-0.0028996307,
-0.0455324128,
-0.0082002757,
-0.0404529683,
0.0132275065,
0.0313176811,
0.0109127015,
-0.0175073948,
0.0230998807,
0.0092859222,
0.0075796223,
-0.0030878077,
0.0219184831,
0.0061842138,
-0.0436053276,
-0.0511339791,
-0.0286942534,
0.0128829684,
-0.024948461,
-0.0021379662,
0.0465697348,
-0.0314500034,
0.0381520875,
-0.0338344499,
-0.0537754633,
-0.0305911694,
-0.0401947349,
-0.0164542422,
0.0269177593,
-0.0331875868,
-0.0491832867,
0.0179775432,
0.0595334582,
0.1033427045,
-0.0126003595,
0.0530120358,
-0.0317948423,
-0.032013271,
-0.0465981439,
0.0108239697,
-0.0402951874,
-0.0324515291,
-0.0031720283,
0.0504471883,
0.0071057482,
0.0212704204,
-0.0399577133,
0.0378667042,
-0.0277162809,
-0.0261834431,
0.0183977038,
-0.0244983621,
0.0180735979,
0.0370875038,
-0.0084184445,
-0.0368059799,
0.0670286044,
0.0175439026,
0.0777123123,
0.0000536345,
-0.0854077712,
-0.0007477168,
0.0241257474,
0.0342102721,
-0.010678824,
0.0395706296,
0.0159164201,
0.0242632478,
0.0039211451,
0.0350941308,
-0.0182904452,
-0.053637512,
0.0017370421,
0.0252250638,
0.0416371301,
0.0223286431,
-0.0505000427,
-0.1152611598,
-0.0561210029,
-0.0331990756,
0.0117212143,
-0.0866360292,
-0.0525252931,
-0.0311281979,
0.0328546576,
-0.033947438,
0.0247638058,
-0.0159952585,
0.0332412608,
-0.0273804702,
-0.0046418449,
-0.0021162604,
0.0187183581,
-0.0221341513,
-0.0368399099,
0.0203498621,
-0.0501680113,
0.0083669405,
-0.0035881971,
-0.0519199893,
0.0004399231,
-0.0138654998,
-0.0079302546,
-0.0192628428,
0.0331751183,
0.0068337666,
0.0497482829,
0.1026916951,
0.0327533484,
0.0480074286,
-0.0084758373,
0.0178741943,
0.014554318,
0.0111653879,
-0.0276024025,
-0.0608948022,
0.0011896491,
-0.0299055167,
0.0319084637,
-0.0574726723,
-0.0626167506,
-0.0097092446,
-0.0425242037,
-0.0115482155,
-0.0218640734,
-0.0050538373,
0.004542639,
-0.0900789797,
-0.003056631,
-0.0294078961,
0.0113068372,
-0.038559217,
0.0394177921,
-0.0067265923,
-0.0027258331,
-0.0666806623,
-0.0255923476,
0.0467336588,
-0.0014953334,
0.0167425778,
0.0151228076,
0.0339224786,
-0.0165903755,
-0.0262893084,
-0.0053129029,
0.0181047488,
-0.0181486011,
-0.0218995176,
0.1062380895,
-0.017109694,
-0.0009109362,
-0.0416979454,
0.048944097,
-0.0510081798,
-0.0098132128,
-0.0147844758,
0.0351907797,
0.0228881165,
-0.0447261631,
-0.0245738905,
0.0216084514,
0.0393023603,
0.0162248537,
0.0158462226,
-0.0311320908,
0.0005512998,
-0.0452042744,
-0.013426126,
-0.0683804154,
-0.0311245956,
-0.0094571486,
0.0328212641,
-0.0436619297,
-0.0197912715,
-0.0416757576,
0.0012879146,
-0.0182647537,
-0.0337620787,
0.0003943926,
-0.0419098102,
0.0007108313,
-0.0524951071,
-0.0070358063,
0.0134326126,
0.0556347705,
0.0153882513,
-0.0250579361,
-0.0132268686,
0.0110016763,
-0.0093512619,
-0.0022832418,
-0.0747371912,
-0.0406161435,
0.0662813038,
-0.0076091108,
0.021445971,
0.015360347,
-0.0337458029,
-0.0016612242,
0.0545164756,
0.0188998841,
-0.0411380827,
-0.0013931906,
0.0160428137,
0.0116683915,
0.0230687242,
0.0011855123,
-0.0039197798,
0.0232559182,
0.0053213262,
-0.0758168027,
-0.1303182691,
0.0431325734,
0.0089258915,
0.0269355029,
0.0751359016,
0.0037908223,
-0.0562092699,
-0.0042690434,
-0.0606544279,
-0.0122419531,
-0.0298862457,
0.0588800572,
-0.0032799109,
0.0305170771,
-0.0229873117,
-0.0266905278,
0.0109242769,
-0.0299655292,
0.0194217693,
-0.0328222066,
0.011407556,
-0.0187688824,
0.0554938875,
0.0194121487,
-0.0236206241,
0.0022736492,
0.019111203,
0.0085240267,
0.026619548,
-0.0223909169,
-0.0402864218,
-0.0230910294,
0.0096127335,
0.0211035889,
-0.0151268356,
-0.0383855402,
-0.0605981462,
0.0389065184,
-0.0025278351,
-0.0159947164,
0.0045448774,
0.0488524958,
-0.013538979,
-0.0076289587,
0.0074052815,
0.0323632322,
-0.0111090317,
-0.0086815385,
-0.0008479829,
0.024544144,
-0.0428361185,
0.0194783062,
0.0238789301,
-0.0113187879,
0.0036028784,
0.052844625,
-0.0463832878,
-0.0122241154,
0.0086100427,
-0.0476394445,
0.0466795228,
0.0347575881,
0.0211437065,
-0.0489079021,
-0.0316041559,
0.050314445,
-0.0345398933,
0.0207484327,
0.0267199948,
-0.0495786853,
0.0644872263,
-0.0139015997,
0.0458848737,
-0.0435222052,
0.010845636,
-0.0105204657,
-0.071557641,
0.0099550327,
-6.177379301e-33,
0.0486374758,
-0.0777109638,
0.0074550924,
0.0090496698,
0.0155095132,
0.006560754,
0.0165469479,
0.0016644042,
-0.047163263,
-0.009640052,
0.0082655484,
0.0442251824,
0.0027325046,
-0.017218424,
-0.0132018561,
-0.0129268561,
0.0204945095,
-0.0011474198,
-0.0103271715,
0.0108073736,
0.1064765155,
-0.0240486879,
0.0211446751,
-0.0935766846,
0.0424410813,
-0.0224628188,
-0.0051639886,
0.0128906909,
0.0377343372,
0.0304811168,
-0.0037789659,
0.0765262321,
0.0470914617,
0.0106095979,
0.0256504491,
0.0191576462,
0.0015527712,
-0.0129605895,
-0.0089774337,
-0.0213723965,
0.0205584615,
-0.0356101207,
-0.0404788852,
-0.0098526618,
-0.0260865875,
-0.020247899,
0.06471508,
0.0240460727,
0.0468523651,
0.0282636695,
-0.0416357294,
0.0339259543,
-0.0491271578,
0.0039139674,
-0.0225655865,
0.0474346876,
0.0546791703,
0.0132847382,
-0.0865774229,
0.0739796683,
-0.0721133426,
-0.0276233573,
0.0105137005,
-0.0066363239,
-0.0219703726,
0.0483360402,
0.0374118537,
0.0608675778,
-0.0646103993,
0.0183734614,
-0.0118021853,
0.0449069627,
0.0382734425,
0.0907564089,
0.0727832839,
-0.0949137136,
-0.0653767213,
0.00354419,
0.0557870679,
-0.0006410168,
0.0028935263,
-0.0234360546,
-0.0505317599,
-0.0013622313,
0.0007471324,
-0.0349038504,
-0.0193008073,
0.0066117258,
-0.0387574434,
0.0175828915,
-0.0650208592,
-0.0066569308,
0.0474853814,
-0.0108095445,
0.0557241924,
0.0617647395,
-0.0390102565,
0.0073804134,
0.0113323973,
0.0555893146,
-0.0433537886,
0.0019330912,
0.0188466646,
-0.0239365995,
0.0545361675,
-0.0282388609,
0.0368355364,
0.0291445572,
-0.0157296173,
-0.0009134221,
0.0117231505,
0.0274976771,
-0.0624945462,
-0.0197589304,
0.0140164411,
0.0667520389,
0.009059757,
-0.0532115698,
0.0419252999,
0.0036463218,
0.0263945274,
-0.0044622016,
-0.0524190068,
-0.0247934852,
0.0031173492,
-0.0044208965,
-0.0264934935,
0.0162350945,
0.0148946811,
-0.0904831067,
0.0128961932,
-0.0773256198,
2.656e-7,
0.0341800079,
0.0596787073,
-0.0019303929,
0.027606789,
0.0205346886,
0.0509182923,
0.0776735842,
0.0180640519,
-0.037155021,
-0.078636691,
-0.0065531055,
0.0322876386,
0.0497276373,
0.0369155332,
-0.014019656,
-0.0469340421,
0.0188939087,
-0.005941127,
-0.073563017,
0.0142765008,
0.008461671,
-0.0077353627,
0.0458864048,
-0.0241722874,
-0.0107151298,
-0.0469069481,
0.0236142911,
-0.0297752507,
-0.0053654136,
0.0409081317,
0.028395934,
-0.0138057703,
0.0154328113,
0.0384449847,
-0.0406946726,
0.0100729819,
-0.0210817978,
0.0002321893,
0.0282213595,
-0.0018823278,
-0.0057723727,
-0.0466429517,
0.0220927577,
0.0012365381,
0.0331172571,
-0.0031820345,
-0.0571749844,
-0.0221220031,
-0.0292291176,
0.0184186324,
0.0442966446,
-0.0070527778,
-0.0213017315,
0.0101100039,
0.0069080698,
0.0068795751,
-0.0170343127,
-0.027844267,
0.032710392,
0.0207511801,
-0.0846864507,
-0.0173841733,
0.0132846246,
-0.0154580008,
0.0813134164,
0.0507831611,
0.0442794971,
2.27963895e-34,
0.0114481747,
0.0032088959,
-0.0104711382,
-0.0504423901,
0.0415506586,
0.0236338973,
0.0014080954,
-0.0192402471,
0.0408559777,
-0.0578470565,
0.0173148643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15126v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15126v3 | Evaluation and Analysis of Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models | 2023-08-29T08:51:24 | 2023-10-10T11:57:26 | Junyang Wang, Yiyang Zhou, Guohai Xu, Pengcheng Shi, Chenlin Zhao, Haiyang Xu, Qinghao Ye, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Jihua Zhu, Jitao Sang, Haoyu Tang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) have recently achieved remarkable
success. However, LVLMs are still plagued by the hallucination problem, which
limits the practicality in many scenarios. Hallucination refers to the
information of LVLMs' responses that does not exist in the visual input, which
poses potential risks of substantial consequences. There has been limited work
studying hallucination evaluation in LVLMs. In this paper, we propose
Hallucination Evaluation based on Large Language Models (HaELM), an LLM-based
hallucination evaluation framework. HaELM achieves an approximate 95%
performance comparable to ChatGPT and has additional advantages including low
cost, reproducibility, privacy preservation and local deployment. Leveraging
the HaELM, we evaluate the hallucination in current LVLMs. Furthermore, we
analyze the factors contributing to hallucination in LVLMs and offer helpful
suggestions to mitigate the hallucination problem. Our training data and human
annotation hallucination data will be made public soon. | [
-0.0067611956,
0.0365865082,
0.0102817332,
0.049026493,
-0.050042145,
0.0375894047,
0.0158961229,
0.0242915582,
0.0414648764,
-0.0347660407,
-0.022370331,
-0.061559502,
0.029816078,
-0.0180715807,
0.0231755953,
-0.0614690445,
-0.0009451954,
-0.0912291631,
-0.0599579178,
-0.0176543482,
0.0024909221,
-0.0261979513,
0.010968213,
0.0450788997,
-0.0201816205,
-0.0452960245,
0.0057803281,
0.0081647234,
0.0246313065,
0.003948451,
-0.0443244055,
0.0529012159,
0.0220831707,
0.0397926457,
0.0000020643,
-0.0498319864,
0.0170735065,
0.0196241997,
0.0137425149,
0.0280556064,
0.0285143238,
-0.0080509046,
0.0105761858,
0.0155521175,
-0.0048082648,
-0.0085925879,
0.0698534697,
0.05758081,
0.0446733125,
0.0275262538,
-0.0025735786,
-0.0291572362,
0.0125384871,
0.0041713323,
0.0624284409,
-0.0035322912,
0.0521828383,
0.0300425086,
-0.0220412072,
-0.042204652,
-0.0354575738,
0.0459831953,
0.0360078774,
0.0102224294,
0.0015217948,
0.0400761329,
-0.0845289901,
-0.0311482903,
-0.0246078074,
0.0423722751,
-0.0559465587,
-0.0325979963,
0.0226422586,
0.0237521864,
0.0062041371,
-0.0205178894,
-0.0294528566,
0.0245331489,
-0.0009022931,
0.0089936955,
-0.0339129344,
-0.0089252908,
0.0380584337,
-0.0081745209,
-0.0182567351,
0.039452251,
0.0248309858,
-0.0108412635,
0.0144674135,
0.0002216769,
-0.0161797628,
-0.048455067,
0.0212043598,
0.0037991859,
-0.0267971288,
-0.0254840069,
-0.0606166795,
0.009563271,
0.0217540823,
-0.092988655,
0.0462278612,
-0.0122740101,
-0.0809137151,
0.0730795562,
-0.045830287,
0.0870426223,
-0.0315937363,
0.0631266609,
-0.0109218061,
-0.0105663808,
-0.0073134806,
0.0046115038,
-0.019065287,
-0.0024466896,
-0.036223501,
-0.0437933542,
-0.0234836265,
0.0083306665,
-0.0454971008,
0.0160837565,
-0.0178014841,
0.0080286954,
0.0043153591,
-0.0509114489,
-0.0041690925,
-0.0137530919,
0.0307567846,
-0.012414163,
-0.0120122833,
-0.0951569155,
0.0082637286,
0.0448663048,
-0.012356163,
0.0092892339,
-0.0056949817,
0.0775575936,
0.0299647022,
-0.0127070583,
-0.0108847655,
-0.0010778002,
-0.0195644181,
-0.0547019057,
0.0260764323,
-0.0826383084,
0.0081532244,
-0.009559338,
0.0097798044,
-0.0198323615,
0.023148885,
0.002028916,
-0.0138168298,
0.0922016948,
-0.0242398921,
0.0103988266,
0.0162554029,
0.0269552693,
-0.0177159663,
0.0691813752,
0.0175849702,
0.0589614511,
0.0044594579,
-0.0300485566,
0.0818846524,
0.0354565494,
-0.0338063091,
0.0175761692,
-0.0679575875,
-0.0212877933,
0.0362540893,
0.0100020654,
-0.0115718422,
0.0972625017,
-0.0307634138,
-0.0558957197,
0.062235862,
0.0435840115,
0.0312139038,
-0.0282295886,
0.0110947108,
0.0206532981,
0.0014329709,
-0.0071435664,
-0.0713740066,
0.0304098986,
-0.0520571508,
-0.0193517637,
0.0195050016,
0.0182249751,
-0.0360418521,
-0.0454129204,
-0.0276033599,
-0.0259824581,
0.0181679409,
0.0398711227,
0.04172552,
-0.0118825855,
-0.0319444053,
0.0119452663,
0.0302697811,
-0.029349139,
0.0135830939,
-0.0586584583,
-0.0076140692,
0.1000963002,
0.0427600034,
0.0040042391,
0.0239355676,
-0.037364807,
0.0489616059,
0.0535552688,
0.0018339698,
0.0240221005,
0.0453065485,
-0.0656178445,
-0.0349060297,
0.0451014973,
0.0199401323,
0.0072221919,
-0.0205533206,
-0.0160366576,
0.0196069311,
-0.0225963052,
-0.0391389094,
0.0551820025,
0.0127681848,
0.0082413768,
-0.0368334651,
-0.023315873,
0.0095657324,
-0.0153959552,
-0.0217330642,
0.0221153498,
0.0147220325,
-0.0393535346,
-0.0060622571,
-0.0056184265,
-0.0112328175,
-0.0079730302,
0.0367145091,
-0.057590127,
0.0204692166,
0.0196275394,
-0.0114607541,
-0.0116434032,
-0.0211518351,
-0.0473517403,
0.0222007427,
-0.0428293347,
0.0397391059,
-0.0149283493,
0.02008521,
-0.0229174979,
0.0446427129,
-0.0623537749,
0.0081665469,
0.0068512228,
-0.000652179,
-0.0147984307,
-0.0334480479,
-0.0500407927,
0.0163951553,
-0.0090327496,
0.0211940221,
-0.0252395049,
-0.007345214,
-0.0439900048,
-0.0077065215,
-0.0856299549,
-0.0360185504,
-0.0478031375,
-0.0353665985,
-0.0073443134,
-0.0269623678,
-0.0022047826,
-0.0332479142,
-0.0063513103,
0.0289666913,
-0.0129679805,
0.0451203063,
-0.0205148384,
-0.0100762472,
-0.0574850962,
0.0132882688,
-0.017183939,
0.0259283315,
0.0518983379,
-0.0016155243,
-0.0682209507,
-0.0815279484,
0.0489902422,
-0.0128868734,
0.0412722342,
-0.017925106,
-0.0118214749,
0.0051394347,
-0.0088630635,
0.0297814067,
0.0608534589,
0.0064985077,
-0.0037690022,
0.0683747008,
-0.0176298507,
-0.0199633334,
-0.0270585753,
0.0003072315,
-0.0221644156,
-0.0327316485,
-0.0302428342,
-0.0292586237,
0.0057450063,
-0.0108960085,
0.033944197,
-0.0767717659,
0.0281867255,
-0.0498243421,
-0.0804251209,
-0.038746763,
0.0013275989,
-0.0364664607,
0.0380968153,
-0.0251288079,
-0.0803309679,
0.0282797292,
-0.0471246988,
-0.0134568289,
0.029182421,
0.0303552579,
0.0106393676,
0.0456830934,
0.0251861028,
0.0156692825,
-0.0464786366,
-0.0155649474,
-0.0353995562,
0.0010025293,
-0.029575184,
-0.0570660606,
0.0472928137,
-0.0534759015,
0.0017959253,
-0.0070029208,
-0.0081593804,
-0.0439384766,
-0.0133353509,
-0.0150657091,
-0.0156872384,
-0.0694593564,
0.0199186374,
-0.0322656967,
0.0569982268,
-0.0033964326,
0.0048117829,
-0.0026793431,
-0.0031940655,
-0.0035257062,
-0.0092121335,
0.0493254066,
0.0128140002,
0.0340297632,
-0.0359320976,
0.003254805,
0.0759595633,
0.0570464954,
0.0534842424,
-0.034479782,
0.0003237088,
0.038045615,
0.0321476646,
-0.0267768987,
0.0290109273,
0.0359521359,
-0.0528441556,
0.00635425,
0.0815243572,
0.0111889048,
-0.062534973,
-0.0110883294,
-0.024031356,
0.0523227267,
0.0054195365,
-0.0203062333,
-0.0808836743,
-0.0080296239,
-0.0147261014,
-0.0187469535,
0.0033004417,
-0.0018833095,
-0.0028701788,
-0.0643615872,
0.073921144,
0.0455238596,
0.00136786,
-0.0459024869,
0.0141000003,
0.0158275589,
-0.0140112536,
0.0115738688,
-0.0049986471,
-0.0081238067,
-0.0411165096,
0.0161786955,
-0.0519746505,
-0.0099789659,
0.035671588,
-0.0384791344,
0.0334677584,
0.0836014897,
-0.0076964283,
-0.0052008652,
-0.1112713814,
0.0392274112,
0.0043024663,
-0.0022521936,
0.0080190469,
0.0568245761,
0.0060864547,
-0.0054016337,
0.0091171367,
0.0177599937,
-0.0088860756,
-0.0147507172,
-0.0026954955,
0.0339661017,
-0.0514540225,
-0.0258884244,
-0.0069116005,
0.0249931272,
-0.0073315701,
0.0656219497,
0.0259622931,
-0.0561919399,
-0.0478013977,
-0.0144699821,
0.0331173614,
-0.0276314002,
-0.0680144951,
0.0385276899,
0.0669427663,
-0.046688471,
-0.0448819213,
-0.011140001,
0.0311585143,
0.0333021283,
-0.0102450857,
0.0293130837,
-0.0315378644,
0.0128151616,
-0.0218888186,
0.0380251929,
-0.053122703,
0.0139024006,
-0.0414567441,
0.0278712306,
0.0093559381,
-0.0132035827,
0.000179779,
0.0431258678,
-0.1112385392,
-0.0494111888,
0.0433987193,
0.058613278,
0.0294135399,
0.0475334078,
-0.0209740959,
-0.0679556727,
0.061388731,
0.033041168,
0.0547174104,
0.0493104942,
0.0141547592,
0.0014411395,
0.0091060642,
0.0329819843,
-0.0211569965,
-0.0130030159,
0.0334607624,
0.0030473098,
-0.0158551764,
0.007954685,
-0.0060286252,
-0.008288525,
0.047064323,
-0.0267420765,
0.0163730234,
-0.001831025,
0.0126085319,
-0.0138006909,
0.0011817194,
-0.0593514256,
-0.0106320484,
0.0529252179,
0.0046568289,
0.0216439869,
-0.0118913502,
-0.0145574166,
-0.024341723,
-0.0545980036,
0.0005993184,
0.0475349389,
-0.0390689783,
0.0516988896,
0.0043930076,
-0.0279785898,
0.033627253,
-0.0139890397,
0.0269423779,
0.039738521,
0.0485158898,
-0.0098977974,
-0.0255560856,
-0.0184802897,
0.0438108258,
-0.0055467123,
-0.1036535949,
-0.0432718769,
0.083408609,
0.0430954508,
0.0447571017,
0.0460493825,
-0.0277017057,
0.0104588252,
-0.0600293055,
0.0195901319,
0.0334177427,
-0.0512350872,
0.0245930441,
0.0236655641,
-0.0411672853,
-0.0155218858,
0.0695345774,
0.0176507719,
-0.0043478822,
0.0075609358,
-0.0024273398,
-0.0316870809,
-0.0524845682,
-0.0256137326,
-0.0093889348,
-0.0358911008,
0.0065323967,
-0.0471569188,
-0.0487322211,
-0.0107018752,
0.0039295345,
0.0271525402,
0.0045530605,
0.0290952474,
0.0441192016,
-0.027843982,
-0.0152051793,
-0.0229812562,
-0.0508447662,
0.0479620285,
-0.0220598262,
0.0263076238,
-6.13027761e-33,
-0.0038873595,
-0.0186995771,
0.0332285576,
-0.0167211518,
-0.0075150896,
0.005087147,
0.02063426,
0.0241265576,
0.0050875559,
-0.0043505747,
0.0173500646,
0.0118883774,
0.0307179689,
0.0255353767,
-0.00947545,
-0.0300118234,
0.034889169,
0.0103418259,
-0.0241351444,
-0.0013544746,
-0.0078698434,
-0.0020029799,
0.0208121892,
-0.0752577037,
0.0083865235,
-0.008264875,
-0.0388186984,
0.0013749913,
-0.0171301831,
0.0655232146,
-0.0501679592,
0.0266586356,
0.0215092264,
-0.0077907848,
-0.046122577,
0.0109971156,
0.0102825807,
0.0081902547,
0.0031403184,
0.0612272285,
-0.0758661255,
0.0025504974,
0.0587056577,
-0.0243160184,
-0.0297742076,
-0.0365056656,
0.013977482,
-0.0543336459,
-0.0537376106,
0.0421203896,
-0.0263824537,
0.0154527472,
0.0383219458,
-0.0263455734,
0.0785689652,
0.0434310474,
-0.0219164193,
0.0074443244,
-0.0709226206,
0.0076893186,
0.012602469,
-0.0194522701,
0.0909394771,
0.062303137,
0.0374697633,
0.0748530403,
0.0680017173,
-0.0230460074,
-0.0103028743,
-0.0565232299,
0.0279372893,
0.0580537245,
0.0602304079,
0.0133848162,
0.0210651103,
0.0145141939,
0.000148587,
-0.0123478016,
-0.0852128863,
0.0379852019,
0.0899266303,
0.0322962627,
-0.0407837369,
-0.0301492959,
-0.0181615595,
0.0169662498,
-0.0376030914,
-0.0056601604,
0.0543334372,
0.0120701538,
-0.0370165966,
0.0197527073,
0.0744619668,
-0.0456395485,
-0.0006689846,
0.0143342996,
0.0164758842,
0.0441092364,
-0.0002286372,
0.0144943474,
-0.0112180039,
-0.008446523,
0.0367143638,
-0.0038929519,
0.0265300423,
-0.0301231444,
-0.000211071,
-0.0039061168,
-0.0549542122,
-0.0091227945,
-0.0340676904,
0.0010049937,
0.0464480296,
0.0226204041,
0.0665364712,
-0.0306736995,
-0.0125745041,
0.0148014352,
0.0000770665,
-0.0082342587,
0.0151082296,
0.0148907918,
-0.0436376855,
0.0037987181,
-0.0149632003,
-0.0033245489,
-0.0324509069,
-0.023325149,
0.0477778241,
-0.0103728091,
-0.015911879,
0.0042161061,
2.653e-7,
-0.018890623,
0.0228831619,
-0.0073757237,
-0.0092614414,
0.0094068106,
0.0237589367,
0.0155800954,
0.025669422,
0.0192232225,
-0.0568582192,
-0.0105790766,
0.0425908566,
0.0754261911,
-0.0042492202,
-0.0475899838,
-0.0070375064,
-0.002014603,
0.0166441482,
-0.0484162457,
-0.0210110173,
0.0402542427,
0.0696782917,
-0.0022694804,
-0.0172350686,
0.041508399,
-0.0551136322,
0.0745516047,
-0.0648042038,
-0.0087982174,
0.0019877583,
0.0360746905,
0.0599223524,
0.0115668569,
0.0489612035,
0.0080141658,
-0.046528291,
0.0524903834,
0.0332499482,
-0.0223129485,
-0.024456393,
-0.0227901004,
0.012041131,
-0.0148800239,
-0.0694140494,
0.0734067485,
-0.0185948871,
-0.0051152799,
-0.0065860101,
-0.007552213,
-0.0412959754,
0.0797362924,
-0.0187017433,
-0.0059257057,
-0.0108111696,
0.0217412263,
-0.0013413111,
-0.031019697,
-0.0515872389,
-0.005544621,
-0.0365768149,
-0.0354757123,
-0.0257735364,
-0.0318446979,
0.0259399898,
-0.0064497958,
-0.0434618592,
-0.0209837984,
2.358747194e-34,
0.0229578968,
-0.015658319,
0.0450421199,
0.0251589809,
0.0139739728,
0.0106027387,
0.0386779867,
0.027016541,
-0.0368998125,
-0.0506752655,
0.0103975665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15122v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15122v4 | SpikeBERT: A Language Spikformer Learned from BERT with Knowledge Distillation | 2023-08-29T08:41:16 | 2024-02-21T13:20:21 | Changze Lv, Tianlong Li, Jianhan Xu, Chenxi Gu, Zixuan Ling, Cenyuan Zhang, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Spiking neural networks (SNNs) offer a promising avenue to implement deep
neural networks in a more energy-efficient way. However, the network
architectures of existing SNNs for language tasks are still simplistic and
relatively shallow, and deep architectures have not been fully explored,
resulting in a significant performance gap compared to mainstream
transformer-based networks such as BERT. To this end, we improve a
recently-proposed spiking Transformer (i.e., Spikformer) to make it possible to
process language tasks and propose a two-stage knowledge distillation method
for training it, which combines pre-training by distilling knowledge from BERT
with a large collection of unlabelled texts and fine-tuning with task-specific
instances via knowledge distillation again from the BERT fine-tuned on the same
training examples. Through extensive experimentation, we show that the models
trained with our method, named SpikeBERT, outperform state-of-the-art SNNs and
even achieve comparable results to BERTs on text classification tasks for both
English and Chinese with much less energy consumption. Our code is available at
https://github.com/Lvchangze/SpikeBERT. | [
0.0010607142,
0.0186357107,
0.0264988616,
0.0412041694,
0.0105460919,
0.010782972,
0.0064647654,
-0.0141754458,
0.0013020213,
-0.0196705852,
-0.0457383431,
0.0219777487,
-0.0012954192,
0.0436052047,
0.0086289151,
-0.0418551937,
0.0460693538,
-0.0038750272,
0.0033288032,
-0.0051678373,
0.0095859729,
-0.0070494879,
-0.0258255266,
0.031266734,
-0.0115067735,
0.0032149653,
-0.0158272218,
-0.0023257211,
0.0418840572,
-0.0057262024,
0.0700354278,
0.0480903797,
0.0122111505,
0.0831262097,
0.0000020469,
-0.0177951176,
0.0140782204,
-0.0051266653,
-0.0343467593,
0.0456554629,
-0.0135608483,
-0.0143396566,
-0.0201872755,
-0.0099801701,
-0.0249901395,
-0.015436871,
0.0695446059,
0.060786061,
0.0432921387,
0.0617694408,
-0.0110927029,
-0.0201736093,
0.0618564039,
-0.0212509315,
0.021391714,
0.0026116774,
-0.0131074693,
-0.0659664571,
-0.0193579514,
0.0006974648,
-0.0310229566,
0.0517673157,
0.039553944,
-0.0114654796,
-0.0125202993,
0.044879809,
-0.1222235635,
-0.0051749214,
-0.0096674524,
0.0805449933,
-0.0520124026,
-0.0222340319,
-0.0002906784,
0.008002759,
-0.0096943816,
-0.0057372204,
-0.0145790065,
-0.0104295602,
0.0266441759,
0.0398769863,
0.0020449169,
-0.0231286883,
0.0575795434,
-0.0023489618,
-0.023953855,
0.0550311208,
-0.0049858536,
-0.0276997071,
0.0343619026,
-0.0141768595,
0.0002366827,
-0.0362357199,
0.0624829233,
0.0162739959,
0.0114742592,
-0.0163166206,
-0.0276231598,
-0.0467135347,
-0.0041589867,
-0.0805055499,
0.0097517623,
0.0486408845,
-0.0174834803,
0.0184209067,
-0.0400669128,
0.0264636409,
-0.0251385197,
0.0585896298,
-0.0470024087,
-0.0076330914,
-0.0837699547,
-0.0094013289,
-0.0732753798,
0.0369387828,
-0.0518031977,
-0.032872729,
-0.0389136709,
0.0167463161,
-0.011050784,
-0.0068849279,
0.0108602569,
0.0485714637,
-0.0216864757,
-0.0070033055,
-0.0073168776,
0.07399261,
-0.0186322685,
-0.0174199939,
-0.0054772259,
-0.0399861075,
-0.0277922265,
0.0278422832,
0.0187023897,
-0.0259144194,
0.0381010249,
-0.0148625541,
-0.0539791174,
-0.0349831767,
-0.0436542816,
0.0578272976,
-0.0358721241,
-0.0071359831,
0.0232121125,
-0.0922261775,
0.0311670769,
-0.0022136848,
-0.0106913541,
-0.0120422561,
0.0334825031,
0.0036017667,
-0.0079013379,
0.0697362944,
-0.0371601023,
-0.029061636,
0.0211032964,
0.0142454235,
-0.0460737869,
0.0583841279,
0.0564963669,
0.0309858192,
0.0004780845,
-0.0135669187,
0.0281978603,
0.0484120511,
0.0326050259,
0.0051809074,
-0.0127426945,
-0.0449564047,
-0.0320427269,
-0.0276108496,
0.0446794704,
0.05165492,
-0.0395000204,
-0.0015835549,
0.0637431294,
0.0196109675,
-0.013053935,
0.0480289757,
0.0224724393,
0.020130096,
-0.0014197285,
-0.0085042091,
-0.0464201272,
0.0228651576,
0.0104690967,
-0.029579943,
-0.0549618565,
0.0266761407,
-0.0496383123,
-0.0192636028,
0.0285174418,
-0.0359670967,
0.0297972336,
0.0293697827,
0.0527338237,
0.0304938331,
-0.0268330872,
0.1557829976,
0.0059847506,
-0.0228161775,
-0.01949195,
-0.0421231575,
-0.0341376849,
0.0478809252,
0.0212014131,
-0.0337511227,
-0.0344303548,
-0.0000183281,
-0.0333046801,
0.0311005004,
0.035789825,
-0.0252326969,
0.0486968309,
-0.0606336817,
-0.0142162647,
-0.0125321746,
0.0157319903,
-0.0101461578,
0.0162551124,
0.0162725113,
0.0170505606,
-0.0469749719,
-0.0225291513,
0.0116049005,
-0.0300532021,
-0.0543477349,
0.0204115789,
0.0083088307,
0.0052166362,
-0.0358928144,
-0.0137508176,
-0.0050002984,
0.0183742549,
-0.0505574457,
-0.0000265332,
0.0107286992,
-0.0185486302,
-0.0693399161,
0.0225534439,
-0.0101249916,
-0.0034580515,
0.0710713044,
-0.0114563974,
-0.0331753269,
-0.0251077618,
-0.0326846428,
0.0606059246,
-0.0330458172,
0.0240450539,
-0.0183319468,
0.0018947126,
0.0189246498,
0.0441659056,
0.0002727931,
-0.0052327784,
-0.0328959227,
-0.0023946492,
0.01968701,
-0.025087133,
-0.0595649332,
-0.0033977658,
-0.0329428203,
-0.0183913428,
0.0083375135,
0.0152875092,
-0.0412785821,
-0.0382364802,
-0.1204065233,
-0.0062300782,
-0.0320349857,
0.0110463621,
0.0060748444,
0.0221323483,
0.0152484011,
-0.0099530108,
-0.0438201912,
0.0014696796,
-0.0454545096,
0.0139490739,
0.0137328813,
0.0164999608,
-0.0137219531,
-0.033246778,
-0.0241175964,
-0.0107089328,
0.0210152883,
-0.0159156434,
-0.0342071168,
-0.0011297961,
-0.0067408308,
0.0047867815,
0.0329295062,
-0.0039973469,
-0.058699321,
0.0146169001,
-0.0179324728,
0.0563415177,
0.0340502225,
0.0217410792,
-0.0084937215,
0.0025054405,
-0.0413578376,
-0.0501200929,
0.0646325052,
-0.0288079511,
0.0761759654,
-0.0450484902,
-0.000504108,
0.0007485651,
0.0769763812,
-0.0203630757,
0.0022967206,
-0.0305983201,
-0.0650990829,
-0.0013643223,
-0.0295583326,
-0.0261912849,
0.0111603076,
-0.0253512915,
-0.0173763335,
-0.0248915665,
-0.029991487,
0.0436777882,
-0.0265415665,
-0.0296215173,
-0.0452867597,
-0.0070839748,
0.0014657942,
0.0226058811,
0.0083840983,
0.0467974581,
-0.0586907677,
-0.0055651921,
-0.0345977843,
-0.0157496799,
-0.0154613936,
-0.018514812,
0.0685828254,
-0.0199055914,
0.0133636929,
-0.0369788334,
-0.0765398145,
-0.0467575826,
-0.011896682,
-0.0299867038,
0.0299507529,
0.0427838191,
-0.0496266969,
-0.0608031526,
0.0036924887,
0.0403775014,
0.081686534,
0.0003529079,
-0.0196680557,
-0.0252093766,
0.0436921939,
0.0193386991,
-0.0022464239,
-0.0061223893,
0.0036990358,
0.0008387484,
0.0565254129,
0.0616583899,
0.0203009527,
-0.0636575297,
0.00254953,
0.0260245577,
-0.0157730244,
-0.0375676565,
-0.0461922772,
0.0499610454,
-0.0673303902,
-0.0302338842,
0.0923134163,
0.0237052739,
-0.008703379,
-0.0093189012,
0.0200666487,
0.0110585568,
-0.0053846226,
0.035245318,
-0.0378483757,
-0.0335734151,
-0.0165033136,
0.0324279703,
0.0560628846,
-0.0077508227,
0.0242668875,
-0.0432778746,
0.0255679954,
-0.0078435512,
0.0025615445,
-0.0497932695,
-0.0190991051,
-0.0184497815,
0.0008976403,
-0.0145990308,
-0.0007526854,
0.0280871373,
-0.0161567125,
0.0262023825,
-0.0309111085,
-0.0553148426,
0.0417434685,
-0.0222023968,
0.015020052,
0.074858509,
0.0252561085,
-0.0468865335,
-0.0924759731,
0.0214739144,
0.015564804,
-0.0552691035,
0.0028432088,
0.031430237,
0.0501742475,
-0.0398872532,
0.0093161855,
0.0033954582,
-0.0275070518,
-0.0529774614,
-0.0412545092,
0.0551674441,
-0.0043374524,
-0.0227362569,
0.0036628593,
-0.0166940056,
0.001456318,
0.0578323491,
0.0180950109,
-0.0509187169,
-0.0305492766,
-0.0188849755,
-0.0234971028,
-0.1073171049,
0.0164973754,
0.0249278992,
0.0069970172,
-0.0297511965,
-0.059928041,
-0.0290743168,
0.0289610531,
0.0393839963,
0.0110080177,
-0.0318416469,
0.0404004417,
0.0254733134,
-0.0594728962,
0.0130207241,
0.0210046303,
-0.0007419903,
-0.0606106333,
-0.0614529923,
0.0479787029,
0.0017529912,
-0.0073294076,
-0.0148803666,
-0.060425099,
-0.0249125306,
0.0317542218,
0.0516681224,
0.0152285472,
0.0257956125,
-0.0168147832,
0.0008923998,
0.0943251923,
0.0977102518,
0.0203949492,
-0.0045933505,
0.0345218368,
0.0043114023,
-0.0024818445,
0.0301569086,
-0.0329246782,
0.0270013716,
-0.0093264878,
0.0439869352,
-0.050393492,
0.0040606535,
-0.0093980646,
-0.0089948727,
0.0439185761,
0.0040459521,
0.0261287112,
-0.0389701389,
-0.0045796987,
0.0570237041,
0.0296504553,
-0.0611889437,
0.0089263618,
0.0397262461,
-0.0077424906,
0.0194013398,
0.0671452656,
0.0451077409,
-0.0385481827,
-0.038629353,
-0.0101782242,
0.052890785,
0.0060057426,
0.0252250768,
0.0201841518,
-0.0208047926,
0.0200447924,
0.0234920699,
0.0152599271,
-0.0497153662,
0.0251703151,
0.0457154512,
0.00826615,
-0.0581914224,
0.0341675133,
-0.0475471206,
-0.0160832815,
-0.0041832998,
0.0027155997,
0.0249172188,
-0.0024462007,
0.0318304077,
-0.0238705277,
-0.0252386238,
-0.0188050028,
-0.0023181115,
0.0064392742,
0.004629238,
-0.0045972378,
0.0359247029,
0.0005571854,
-0.015245623,
0.0598479323,
-0.0317389704,
0.0394457281,
0.0351498164,
0.0047796201,
-0.0393222682,
-0.0315633044,
-0.0112801455,
0.0118491156,
-0.0184299108,
-0.0016373019,
-0.0057001133,
-0.0575481392,
0.0402741097,
-0.0288648289,
0.0077341851,
0.0072214729,
0.0740688741,
0.0559469275,
-0.0050911577,
-0.0407412238,
0.0051556504,
0.0028394905,
0.0536644608,
-0.0345247239,
-0.0082686013,
-6.345455892e-33,
0.0139986016,
0.0204923097,
0.0146209653,
0.0300747231,
0.0032484899,
0.015167431,
-0.0438274518,
-0.0245427042,
-0.048028525,
0.0296650995,
-0.0230613071,
0.0274260845,
0.0157966036,
0.058625415,
0.0179085713,
-0.0367313139,
0.0451429673,
0.0196903925,
-0.026161572,
0.0437676199,
0.0748759583,
0.060009703,
0.0817952305,
-0.0503787734,
-0.0193068292,
0.016919516,
0.0108024757,
0.0005319501,
0.0158751011,
0.0312321447,
-0.0409720428,
0.0668072328,
0.0099717556,
0.0033802052,
0.0057192757,
0.0427138023,
-0.1048986018,
-0.0248302072,
-0.0548890717,
0.0310864225,
-0.0467336327,
0.0099515747,
0.0472569577,
-0.0021688913,
0.0281487014,
0.0206178594,
0.034047965,
-0.0179574806,
-0.0013942067,
-0.0557223782,
-0.0291168094,
-0.0112779783,
0.0075497814,
-0.0560328476,
-0.0001128767,
0.0166699216,
-0.0033923592,
0.0112358434,
-0.1357343048,
0.0016139973,
0.0346821882,
0.064534314,
0.0071703475,
0.0496602803,
-0.0055088094,
0.0496429577,
0.0040951786,
-0.0297878236,
0.0031826627,
0.0376631953,
0.107827045,
0.0505962335,
0.0195594598,
0.0065930649,
0.0628840104,
-0.0592288859,
-0.0399327576,
0.014238419,
0.0724909082,
-0.0110636363,
0.0122007346,
-0.0019825064,
0.0004071367,
-0.0474773422,
-0.0152129466,
0.0350360125,
-0.0258286707,
0.0180581044,
0.0071517378,
0.0482462607,
-0.022918297,
0.0092807375,
0.0420080908,
-0.0323173255,
0.0091519952,
0.0143467737,
0.01422273,
0.0238549802,
0.0199365057,
-0.0199818239,
-0.057285618,
-0.0373806618,
0.0028885535,
0.0261411797,
0.0011573075,
0.0282468665,
0.0433382951,
0.0829008892,
-0.0292494409,
0.0024321228,
-0.0431072563,
0.0077593299,
0.0314733461,
0.060123615,
-0.0100769382,
0.0016204328,
-0.0109139206,
-0.0116754863,
-0.002857924,
0.0117421998,
-0.0050410083,
0.0198532548,
-0.0252825748,
0.0301131215,
-0.0038824922,
-0.0054357275,
-0.0493690073,
0.0496060066,
-0.0269993637,
-0.0891088769,
-0.0017657194,
0.0256246533,
2.824e-7,
0.0496892519,
0.021142751,
-0.0118283657,
-0.0367679559,
0.0292561334,
0.0404618867,
0.0068580182,
0.0301490128,
-0.0077886139,
-0.0331875831,
0.0027641729,
0.0381457023,
0.0310670175,
0.0494180806,
-0.1053569764,
-0.0678076893,
-0.0616908818,
0.0280164611,
0.0093536787,
-0.0144587765,
0.00130743,
0.0730836093,
0.0245235208,
-0.0419100672,
0.0487683751,
-0.0445955209,
0.0696283132,
0.0175163858,
0.0591674596,
0.0300814975,
-0.0262842793,
0.0030366019,
-0.0092157777,
0.015484415,
-0.0379749723,
0.0125013357,
-0.0022961551,
0.0379697569,
-0.0043104896,
-0.0328536518,
0.0057563358,
-0.0174905788,
0.0020113494,
-0.0712670535,
0.0571285859,
-0.0859680474,
-0.0053320448,
0.0502816997,
-0.0128861833,
-0.0032468988,
0.0198446997,
-0.0380836092,
-0.0134098949,
0.0210523438,
-0.0121051921,
-0.0331236832,
-0.0382580943,
-0.0681072325,
-0.0131024309,
-0.0122422883,
-0.031808164,
-0.0340907425,
-0.0493267253,
-0.0491738431,
0.0021534543,
0.0009212551,
0.0150328092,
2.314307538e-34,
-0.0105019687,
0.0040872889,
-0.028457433,
0.0381356664,
-0.0151370792,
0.014468953,
0.0037197412,
-0.0344217159,
-0.0174888093,
-0.0273789633,
-0.0327367596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15118v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15118v1 | Large Language Models on the Chessboard: A Study on ChatGPT's Formal Language Comprehension and Complex Reasoning Skills | 2023-08-29T08:36:30 | 2023-08-29T08:36:30 | Mu-Tien Kuo, Chih-Chung Hsueh, Richard Tzong-Han Tsai | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models have made strides in natural language processing,
their proficiency in complex reasoning tasks requiring formal language
comprehension, such as chess, remains less investigated. This paper probes the
performance of ChatGPT, a sophisticated language model by OpenAI in tackling
such complex reasoning tasks, using chess as a case study. Through robust
metrics examining both the legality and quality of moves, we assess ChatGPT's
understanding of the chessboard, adherence to chess rules, and strategic
decision-making abilities. Our evaluation identifies limitations within
ChatGPT's attention mechanism that affect its formal language comprehension and
uncovers the model's underdeveloped self-regulation abilities. Our study also
reveals ChatGPT's propensity for a coherent strategy in its gameplay and a
noticeable uptick in decision-making assertiveness when the model is presented
with a greater volume of natural language or possesses a more lucid
understanding of the state of the chessboard. These findings contribute to the
growing exploration of language models' abilities beyond natural language
processing, providing valuable information for future research towards models
demonstrating human-like cognitive abilities. | [
0.0441000983,
0.0073407087,
-0.0463464521,
0.0461673774,
-0.0252032224,
0.0060073524,
-0.027884312,
-0.0047459351,
0.0447051078,
-0.0416631401,
-0.0210384354,
-0.0571011715,
-0.0032733437,
0.0273991581,
0.0343577676,
-0.0130723435,
0.0421865322,
-0.0555052087,
0.0775540099,
0.0014538423,
-0.0395658724,
-0.0193033963,
-0.0046557356,
0.0634806752,
0.0249191392,
-0.0167800356,
-0.0408223569,
-0.0337894633,
-0.0429704078,
-0.0159935392,
-0.0373362862,
0.0280397609,
-0.0193611402,
0.0405300856,
0.0000019126,
-0.0558846258,
0.0320313275,
-0.0360601954,
-0.0050645294,
0.0329960547,
0.0046414514,
-0.0070483712,
0.0020428053,
-0.0011608262,
-0.0357646868,
0.0086823618,
0.0378801636,
0.0485048965,
0.0349624828,
0.0725478455,
0.0170047525,
-0.0179936271,
0.0241692141,
-0.0191218853,
-0.025910113,
-0.0999556258,
0.0225027893,
0.0181364492,
-0.0157973114,
0.0026432669,
-0.0237162113,
0.0017180295,
0.0135552688,
0.008125864,
-0.0261971224,
0.0429564342,
0.0085673146,
0.0326116718,
-0.010199382,
0.0262812115,
-0.0399065204,
-0.0211067516,
0.0248484388,
0.014410086,
0.0432075337,
-0.0316516943,
-0.0411259793,
0.0562639274,
0.0016628236,
-0.0013669084,
0.0189810432,
-0.0016377849,
0.0390319377,
0.0145873055,
-0.0151966223,
0.0653558373,
-0.0363929681,
-0.034257099,
0.0171490945,
-0.0239437595,
-0.0434030183,
-0.1172412261,
-0.0131418575,
0.0604396053,
-0.0778494775,
0.024579715,
-0.010419379,
0.0190287977,
0.005092442,
-0.0692422315,
0.0345929973,
0.0782302842,
0.0213716067,
0.0535236485,
-0.0263680499,
0.0479949079,
-0.032107722,
0.0770306811,
-0.0416945443,
-0.0165558811,
-0.0376304723,
-0.0355257317,
-0.0537456162,
0.0122773675,
-0.0221384242,
-0.0519507304,
-0.0538257509,
-0.0001698215,
-0.0009042512,
0.051232297,
0.0033590556,
0.018870445,
0.0156609025,
-0.0150687201,
-0.0583855808,
-0.0252733156,
-0.0676514432,
-0.025681816,
0.0237237141,
-0.048615098,
-0.0177856795,
-0.0162850264,
-0.0620588139,
-0.036650382,
-0.0149122486,
0.0712401941,
-0.0116032567,
-0.0033998284,
-0.0034484745,
0.0153731862,
-0.0284897853,
-0.1209693626,
0.0132957958,
-0.0390691124,
-0.0182245392,
-0.0061318073,
-0.0044659558,
-0.039169427,
0.0085733905,
0.024235392,
-0.0266901776,
0.062171679,
0.0465986095,
0.0132608805,
-0.0089077381,
-0.0034132623,
-0.0054849726,
0.0808060691,
0.0467287563,
-0.0258042365,
0.0025752201,
-0.0123541802,
-0.0048452467,
0.0436525121,
-0.0031309172,
-0.0626999959,
-0.0416295305,
0.0147527866,
-0.0017262764,
0.0674689263,
-0.002567128,
0.0525611639,
0.0042649684,
-0.0367113203,
0.0507723913,
0.0549770892,
0.045590505,
0.0643859282,
0.0469621643,
-0.0158543754,
0.0222230069,
0.0232680719,
-0.0580713786,
0.0492512882,
0.0275501367,
0.0125407875,
-0.0274005253,
0.0231179204,
-0.0044009923,
-0.0609068237,
-0.0217950828,
0.0113656595,
0.0106966347,
-0.0025903189,
0.0422422886,
-0.0288841128,
-0.0372523032,
0.0194606259,
0.0042145033,
-0.0241897795,
-0.014017934,
-0.0921497196,
0.0397594087,
0.066052489,
0.0214010607,
-0.0635932088,
-0.0199451968,
0.016392136,
0.0024069401,
0.0493233055,
0.0605895966,
0.0195884369,
0.0048207268,
-0.0398615152,
-0.0065447818,
-0.0502826571,
0.0334189497,
0.0333312601,
-0.016191747,
0.0050040744,
-0.014406519,
-0.025453601,
-0.0199520756,
0.0495566763,
0.0179224815,
-0.0601703674,
-0.0277072378,
-0.0024927959,
0.0159066673,
0.0155926384,
0.000042919,
0.0173998233,
0.0231779777,
0.0017332357,
-0.0210867282,
-0.0055142632,
-0.0261452012,
0.0313226022,
0.0265291892,
0.0017825145,
-0.0345720388,
0.0402691476,
0.0070725302,
-0.0265385527,
0.0278624371,
-0.015922524,
0.0394959264,
-0.0017013524,
0.0091385832,
-0.0104373014,
0.0373409912,
0.0109841442,
0.0910037756,
-0.000890546,
-0.0108087501,
0.0209998898,
-0.0173720196,
0.0192447845,
-0.0485528335,
0.003345401,
0.020372808,
-0.0180049576,
-0.005534864,
0.0152288536,
0.0118672345,
-0.0549591668,
-0.0138946287,
-0.0729823858,
0.0397488959,
-0.0229478348,
-0.008090077,
-0.0022400375,
-0.0564379878,
-0.0143225361,
0.0000500186,
0.0011107288,
0.0167137124,
0.0248242263,
0.0096412515,
0.0003448499,
-0.002940434,
-0.0224822666,
-0.0220760107,
-0.0170364287,
-0.0272961333,
0.01819098,
0.0050827372,
0.0286057144,
-0.0367617011,
0.0218633525,
-0.0523294657,
0.0395230912,
-0.0406930558,
-0.0331131443,
0.0584026501,
-0.0364069976,
-0.0183770675,
0.0986051857,
0.0070887199,
0.0556674972,
0.1026221737,
-0.0578588992,
-0.0048122038,
0.046886228,
0.0005384894,
-0.0219193846,
-0.0498785861,
0.0101375487,
0.0009699471,
0.0761269033,
-0.0057119802,
0.0092740189,
-0.0827580765,
0.0042985715,
-0.0187351294,
-0.0427350998,
-0.0360912681,
-0.0044159084,
-0.0218529701,
0.0460772663,
-0.0306456648,
0.0200995095,
0.0565850511,
0.0218790136,
0.0134386523,
0.0087381639,
0.0340011865,
-0.0160613321,
0.0963754877,
0.0154108787,
-0.0053282939,
-0.0148408227,
-0.0279413275,
-0.0567908548,
-0.0728917271,
0.0375950597,
-0.0219194461,
0.042266801,
-0.0392290317,
0.004974605,
0.020240888,
-0.0038931102,
-0.0543442927,
0.0078582,
-0.066861406,
0.020297071,
0.0263572112,
-0.0227013342,
-0.0779240057,
0.0017734899,
0.0259010755,
0.0083484231,
0.0000222149,
-0.0435773842,
-0.0194016118,
0.012136586,
0.0468256958,
0.0632148758,
0.0330259204,
-0.0342614502,
0.0733274519,
0.0722864568,
-0.0195902754,
-0.0190057103,
-0.0074294936,
-0.0306064803,
0.0130274491,
-0.0375484787,
-0.0123470677,
0.0724463984,
0.0053769476,
-0.0795269385,
-0.0217341855,
0.0996079296,
0.0411731936,
0.0372495987,
0.0086675575,
-0.0066942247,
0.0244591758,
0.006519319,
0.0158710759,
-0.0633634776,
-0.0289378483,
0.0268557388,
-0.0260164365,
-0.0149069401,
-0.0367604271,
-0.0115010515,
-0.10334865,
0.0043702964,
0.0010576096,
-0.0579131432,
-0.012676822,
0.0220698752,
-0.0108273057,
-0.0178743359,
0.0331937224,
0.0154137714,
0.0101382593,
-0.0088382829,
0.0073400042,
-0.0344610065,
0.0030307928,
0.0415655561,
-0.0410767682,
0.0643834546,
0.0357653722,
0.070292145,
-0.0142159676,
-0.0330889933,
0.0483022034,
0.0166194793,
0.0245154947,
0.0153825264,
0.0588744581,
-0.0068250252,
0.0025420808,
-0.0260415301,
-0.0012225034,
0.0082268231,
-0.0406779908,
0.0509958491,
0.060531076,
0.0110147782,
-0.0478471927,
0.0213179644,
0.0120978579,
-0.0223178882,
0.0776351392,
0.0116048092,
-0.0176454782,
-0.0595490076,
-0.0312364176,
0.0012534226,
-0.0652687699,
-0.0781766102,
0.0228457153,
0.0658936128,
-0.0408326052,
-0.0591970347,
-0.0569131151,
0.0003255547,
0.0044554383,
0.0100057935,
0.0260202326,
-0.0035533393,
0.014283563,
-0.0037246004,
0.0215258561,
-0.0196756534,
-0.0038427217,
-0.0400335081,
-0.0249128249,
-0.0329478048,
-0.0594372489,
-0.012523178,
0.0293301083,
-0.0198207796,
-0.0219313633,
0.0212512724,
0.0795365125,
0.0314634815,
-0.0199972019,
-0.0019888745,
-0.0232751984,
-0.0179801695,
-0.0080992291,
-0.0382049605,
0.0044880388,
0.0278489403,
-0.0101477765,
0.0405595973,
0.0426496156,
0.001165226,
-0.0075336159,
0.0171421077,
0.0536108986,
0.012054272,
0.0141066229,
0.0466181636,
-0.0219672341,
0.0584836416,
-0.0014710026,
-0.0237903334,
-0.0007144773,
0.0083663557,
-0.0484695882,
0.0005915959,
0.0062970486,
-0.039513953,
0.0218415111,
0.0227328073,
0.0001239564,
0.0196365211,
-0.0139430789,
-0.0829761028,
-0.0379394852,
-0.0126334634,
0.0108843092,
0.0180584099,
-0.0041685817,
-0.008777367,
-0.0003993586,
0.0304722786,
-0.0003204738,
0.0237639584,
0.0330643654,
0.0499696471,
0.0402300954,
-0.0427746139,
-0.0065821568,
-0.0084754154,
-0.073962599,
-0.0559126772,
0.0820359066,
0.0284993742,
0.0744809657,
-0.0551169217,
0.0137538863,
-0.0380501263,
0.0070228544,
-0.0022597939,
0.0045488779,
0.0112103885,
-0.0701889545,
-0.0167760365,
0.0145006347,
0.000531647,
-0.045234777,
0.0378571004,
0.001807111,
0.0265341122,
-0.0019787275,
-0.0305925533,
-0.024718184,
-0.0449035168,
-0.0303479452,
0.034123648,
-0.0719384626,
0.03564547,
-0.0840633288,
-0.0565932803,
-0.0082498053,
0.0683185235,
0.0109201977,
-0.0244029891,
0.0084971515,
0.0465974845,
0.0004646408,
-0.0422542393,
-0.0399750955,
0.0285901576,
-0.0184874218,
0.0069650114,
-0.0277635679,
-5.678983288e-33,
-0.0262093171,
-0.042668134,
0.0725065544,
0.0227376502,
-0.0120361308,
-0.0429348536,
-0.0624513067,
0.0075243171,
-0.0327698328,
0.0235918965,
-0.0429335944,
0.044684235,
-0.0051883422,
-0.0018723075,
0.0349620841,
-0.0675968304,
-0.0107617248,
0.0004987474,
-0.0287309978,
-0.0044069355,
0.0137662757,
0.0076489109,
0.0330143347,
-0.042098321,
0.0307776947,
0.0054336125,
-0.0085885888,
-0.0008289289,
-0.0575501062,
0.0519203171,
-0.0205387268,
-0.0021742983,
0.0379137099,
-0.0218313951,
0.0226581357,
0.0081668831,
-0.0358418003,
-0.0206561238,
0.0241813753,
0.0185887385,
-0.0126862051,
-0.0099107595,
0.0399476215,
0.0222290941,
-0.0250174887,
-0.0247596838,
0.0253085159,
-0.0405573659,
-0.0056040608,
0.036931742,
-0.0879245624,
0.0101377871,
-0.0479669087,
-0.0278343204,
0.0081245033,
0.0165912397,
-0.024415357,
-0.0236652233,
-0.0289675053,
0.0010701657,
0.0404469669,
0.0121485209,
0.0166588873,
0.038286414,
0.0253795236,
0.0297929123,
0.0463416837,
0.0189343896,
-0.0716285706,
-0.0321579576,
0.0364038236,
0.0359218121,
0.0483794622,
0.0143957725,
0.0359205641,
-0.007516712,
-0.0939732045,
-0.016859334,
0.0369043685,
0.0860240757,
0.0118550453,
-0.0043160585,
-0.0132380351,
0.0193847809,
0.0105127618,
0.0079304604,
-0.0269159917,
-0.0106722163,
0.029937705,
-0.0244891625,
0.0328274891,
-0.052023612,
0.0148550561,
-0.0036817861,
0.0123311039,
-0.0102501167,
0.0028086291,
0.037711516,
-0.0165511928,
0.015746098,
-0.049272228,
-0.032926023,
0.0015895515,
0.0000467912,
0.0052291248,
0.0296706036,
0.0085625611,
0.02492336,
-0.0428764038,
-0.0062672943,
-0.0473437868,
0.0247210413,
0.0152776018,
-0.0083898418,
0.053810142,
-0.000939435,
0.0005842189,
0.0023920906,
-0.0209627338,
-0.0442855023,
-0.0201481879,
0.0367344916,
0.000585518,
-0.0103183957,
-0.0057768542,
0.0110750319,
-0.0445572212,
0.0537578277,
-0.026285585,
-0.0341589078,
-0.0159191117,
0.0159348454,
2.692e-7,
0.0308331177,
0.0613612458,
-0.0404586196,
0.0091345394,
-0.018712936,
0.0264847185,
-0.070284903,
-0.0048294482,
0.0268003549,
-0.0202639755,
0.0505285636,
0.0656360388,
0.0549539365,
-0.0018996897,
-0.0719936118,
-0.0206932388,
-0.0467502251,
0.0044234437,
-0.0258283131,
0.0445079319,
0.0530698933,
0.0797083527,
0.0310784075,
0.0209893603,
-0.0037958035,
-0.0622249842,
0.0463702716,
-0.017371932,
0.0462585613,
-0.0046253549,
0.0282351356,
-0.0087637566,
-0.0486065,
0.032321509,
0.0087433597,
0.0278674588,
0.0191432089,
0.0534346029,
0.0031602657,
0.0598415844,
-0.0332266167,
-0.0207194127,
-0.0132288514,
-0.0647113174,
0.086337015,
-0.06990996,
-0.0597603172,
-0.0137121901,
0.0166120324,
0.0090005901,
0.011598519,
0.0189870633,
-0.0405888706,
-0.0119638713,
0.0032840632,
-0.0044591688,
0.0482327864,
-0.0610343665,
-0.0075372336,
-0.0010400246,
-0.029870877,
0.0161785409,
-0.0455307849,
-0.0043130498,
0.034019988,
-0.0288675632,
0.0013261207,
2.045511469e-34,
0.015200559,
-0.0062919413,
0.0102017699,
-0.0288398229,
0.0479765683,
-0.0009337908,
0.0377774462,
0.0316282213,
0.0555870309,
-0.0300764479,
-0.0218783077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15097v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15097v1 | Sequential annotations for naturally-occurring HRI: first insights | 2023-08-29T08:07:26 | 2023-08-29T08:07:26 | Lucien Tisserand, Frédéric Armetta, Heike Baldauf-Quilliatre, Antoine Bouquin, Salima Hassas, Mathieu Lefort | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We explain the methodology we developed for improving the interactions
accomplished by an embedded conversational agent, drawing from Conversation
Analytic sequential and multimodal analysis. The use case is a Pepper robot
that is expected to inform and orient users in a library. In order to propose
and learn better interactive schema, we are creating a corpus of
naturally-occurring interactions that will be made available to the community.
To do so, we propose an annotation practice based on some theoretical
underpinnings about the use of language and multimodal resources in human-robot
interaction. CCS CONCEPTS $\bullet$ Computing methodologies $\rightarrow$
Discourse, dialogue and pragmatics; $\bullet$ Human-centered computing
$\rightarrow$ Text input; HCI theory, concepts and models; Field studies. | [
0.0661147013,
-0.006402913,
-0.0303031206,
-0.0228781532,
0.0096204942,
0.0090293447,
0.0034214591,
-0.0136130415,
0.0384416133,
-0.0520507209,
-0.0112418514,
0.037033353,
0.0141045759,
-0.0094460407,
-0.0019902661,
-0.0990907922,
0.0123780938,
0.0000670376,
0.0131327407,
0.0397077426,
0.031460423,
-0.0086450856,
-0.0532329604,
0.0824575648,
-0.0768865198,
-0.0417329669,
-0.0752599016,
-0.0056044376,
0.0287530739,
-0.0471415333,
-0.0385969952,
0.0262584146,
0.0440639816,
0.027401479,
0.0000018636,
-0.0699723437,
0.0312928967,
0.0379887782,
-0.0154153649,
-0.0538086109,
0.0704764798,
0.0541208424,
-0.0154987993,
0.0000913534,
-0.0402834974,
0.0372709297,
0.0665263459,
0.0368998088,
0.0294131078,
-0.0052948408,
-0.0214827619,
0.0048504109,
-0.0180303343,
0.0304443855,
-0.0007999248,
-0.0290657021,
-0.0064191949,
0.051915016,
0.0953729376,
0.0122600645,
-0.0002770519,
0.0200428925,
0.0125329057,
-0.0510113835,
0.0183855463,
0.0179411788,
-0.0156760942,
-0.0543400571,
-0.020492062,
0.0427193381,
0.0746049434,
0.0310720671,
0.0021718529,
0.029254416,
0.0292472616,
0.0134105887,
-0.0282037314,
0.0222568847,
-0.0156146288,
-0.0393030085,
-0.037505582,
-0.0020614716,
-0.0214263555,
0.0117257508,
0.054055579,
0.0669892579,
0.0106646726,
0.0071633444,
0.011978128,
-0.0290808566,
0.0696863979,
-0.0392212197,
0.0159949418,
0.0694211423,
-0.0338876173,
0.0133862495,
-0.0101156337,
0.0286447126,
0.0314089134,
-0.0374028198,
-0.0287854895,
0.0320817158,
-0.0201942101,
0.0087692477,
0.0784935579,
-0.0050928881,
-0.0115323495,
-0.0095846951,
0.0247751549,
0.0261832047,
-0.0559744239,
-0.0092838462,
-0.0297805779,
0.0082306573,
-0.0395264812,
-0.0490897037,
0.0011865267,
0.1037421599,
0.0042042052,
0.0366366506,
-0.061307881,
0.0022916987,
-0.0394173376,
0.0509873144,
-0.0297815185,
-0.0115491254,
-0.0376983583,
0.0209716614,
0.0190628935,
-0.0766747147,
0.0013555889,
0.0484510809,
0.0068653473,
0.0145226493,
-0.0562462322,
0.0713687018,
0.0025054209,
-0.0083236638,
0.0298725162,
-0.0425751023,
-0.0164517779,
0.0047239657,
0.0020341985,
-0.0081274044,
0.030085206,
0.0123628145,
0.0097113457,
-0.0168617051,
0.0104691684,
0.0253393725,
0.0093005942,
0.0732159093,
-0.0522930175,
-0.0219199695,
0.0463780873,
0.0157795735,
0.0008150035,
0.0157734733,
0.0463710167,
0.0208299495,
0.0210665204,
-0.0081404438,
0.0163466502,
0.0173435975,
-0.0921961814,
-0.021185616,
0.0456717201,
-0.0138534373,
0.0028262252,
0.0455713719,
-0.0027012397,
0.0258271098,
-0.0243918765,
0.0570071861,
0.0150180329,
0.0660219118,
-0.051384531,
-0.0211401563,
0.0498167612,
0.0163440518,
0.0169151835,
0.0258296039,
0.0075373272,
0.0049552033,
-0.0337259471,
-0.0131766731,
-0.0195272099,
-0.0307581276,
-0.0143707572,
-0.0470120609,
0.0002668179,
-0.0050592138,
0.0520520397,
-0.0328994058,
0.0456991605,
0.019022027,
0.0031474279,
-0.0368293934,
0.0168618914,
-0.0587584302,
-0.0275604371,
-0.0025902493,
-0.0095571242,
0.0854542404,
0.0388877615,
-0.0537102558,
0.0227443259,
-0.0084777391,
0.0128451921,
0.0752573907,
0.0419452526,
-0.0407294035,
-0.0263893511,
0.0039173025,
-0.0277031157,
-0.0098575745,
0.0029284011,
0.0225937925,
-0.0763645098,
0.0013699484,
-0.0046213525,
0.0527220555,
-0.0278873313,
0.0286847223,
0.0085370122,
0.0145067582,
-0.0465611815,
0.0289621688,
0.0200000834,
0.0709616765,
-0.0212547109,
0.0263343621,
0.0316982344,
0.019204108,
0.003736801,
0.071207419,
0.0221298076,
-0.0110553391,
0.0372717045,
-0.0609335303,
-0.0218407866,
-0.0284295063,
0.0396689698,
-0.0255826358,
-0.0049630688,
-0.0656578541,
0.053240981,
-0.0319460034,
0.0278761983,
0.0234946404,
0.013518895,
-0.0213292893,
-0.0104937069,
0.0002902854,
-0.0151616912,
0.0130532077,
0.022440901,
0.0314588211,
-0.047975082,
-0.0283482522,
0.0469537117,
-0.0103515964,
0.007027138,
0.0416084528,
-0.0031411981,
-0.0523999184,
0.006504524,
-0.1024621204,
-0.0666763037,
-0.0027186386,
-0.0323582627,
-0.0317473784,
-0.0163938683,
0.0178251788,
-0.0488631539,
0.0298935454,
-0.001955529,
-0.0174388904,
0.0022174099,
0.0687037185,
0.0529511645,
-0.0381908081,
-0.0250584614,
0.0343017727,
-0.0192932319,
0.0096613988,
0.0517782718,
-0.0293505918,
-0.0598147847,
0.0038290496,
-0.0206033587,
0.000985089,
-0.0060687796,
-0.0393213592,
0.0968427137,
0.0315245986,
0.0274844673,
0.0277450439,
0.0008750156,
0.0872541294,
0.044447206,
-0.0285123531,
-0.0068792058,
0.003024037,
0.0166167002,
0.0256347191,
-0.017997032,
-0.0029615313,
0.016090855,
0.009192924,
-0.013654259,
0.0589489155,
-0.0344091989,
-0.0032346705,
0.019438168,
-0.0579760261,
-0.0143752461,
-0.0422631912,
-0.0466690138,
0.0276650973,
0.022160152,
-0.0175446589,
0.0365830176,
-0.0425192304,
-0.0206574965,
-0.0220553689,
-0.0158064589,
0.0086687058,
0.0438360386,
-0.024618933,
0.0055965236,
0.0126608666,
-0.0371180139,
-0.0089719566,
0.0263574496,
0.005581046,
-0.0009840974,
-0.0356533304,
-0.0576252118,
-0.0108114276,
0.0275129583,
-0.0196212325,
-0.0489831269,
0.0094307186,
-0.0419439822,
0.0098051419,
0.0229437836,
-0.0102170855,
-0.0347155109,
0.0178803038,
0.0242178664,
0.0405434892,
0.0477821305,
-0.0130476821,
-0.0345896482,
-0.016977137,
0.0249819681,
0.0850332901,
-0.0298411772,
0.0488093868,
0.0510839969,
0.0247847699,
0.0470574647,
-0.058041282,
-0.0295782927,
-0.0129048331,
0.010731156,
-0.0238104574,
-0.0261959415,
0.0250717141,
0.0158431679,
-0.0095882546,
-0.0145077119,
0.0759884715,
0.0165615585,
-0.0795996115,
0.0316787548,
-0.043431364,
-0.024519477,
0.0165326539,
0.010304953,
-0.0493766256,
0.0077175461,
-0.0007224975,
-0.0141134989,
-0.0388010964,
-0.0302809086,
-0.0097325686,
-0.0891454667,
0.0393016376,
-0.0209831204,
-0.0407493711,
-0.0244315248,
-0.0066186963,
0.0140824281,
0.0441509411,
-0.0042542485,
-0.0052097929,
-0.0135210594,
-0.0205101743,
0.0256847851,
-0.0535028949,
-0.0122263124,
-0.0125403507,
0.0171908233,
0.0190020576,
0.0678460523,
0.0605819821,
0.024863828,
0.0018768383,
-0.0162259601,
0.0228863508,
0.0614271872,
-0.0305852741,
0.0086082788,
-0.0613476746,
-0.0003542811,
-0.0341244414,
0.0172342043,
-0.0117149064,
-0.0447659008,
0.0145180235,
0.042934835,
-0.1008352563,
0.0550272465,
-0.032198254,
0.0434234366,
0.0420703851,
0.011566746,
0.0431088768,
-0.0573982596,
0.0067549143,
-0.0198808368,
0.0102032032,
0.024628507,
-0.0025375169,
-0.0072003212,
-0.0241214819,
-0.0633951202,
-0.0635961071,
-0.1111305058,
0.0252571329,
0.0542515479,
0.0226322412,
-0.0098527865,
0.0043439008,
0.0709099844,
0.0058502937,
-0.0073341695,
0.0039187921,
-0.0249517579,
-0.0062538553,
-0.0303500835,
-0.0083303032,
-0.0369525589,
-0.0044212765,
-0.0097135203,
0.038748432,
-0.0435483083,
-0.0027292783,
0.0653845891,
0.0292416867,
0.0338819511,
0.00633003,
-0.0572732389,
-0.0711526498,
0.023123119,
-0.0167428944,
-0.0019918915,
-0.0007892192,
0.0296039544,
0.0042182934,
0.0001228388,
-0.0253513735,
-0.0224670209,
-0.076063931,
0.0305284206,
-0.0701945573,
-0.1049709544,
0.0048230542,
-0.0012459904,
0.0215606354,
-0.0327003933,
-0.0040257568,
0.0054146009,
0.0002097765,
-0.0477385409,
-0.0296591651,
-0.0379562117,
0.0291780625,
-0.0658045635,
0.0158130471,
0.0291878413,
0.0188861899,
-0.0794800147,
0.0394896492,
0.0295853559,
0.0033174851,
0.0473977253,
0.0270549636,
-0.0586523376,
0.0220815428,
-0.0132811693,
0.023185581,
-0.0051194229,
0.044539161,
0.026840644,
0.10523922,
0.0218913704,
-0.0170388054,
0.0168067515,
0.0519635864,
-0.022807911,
-0.0108770775,
0.0237791389,
0.0284271948,
0.0214027129,
-0.0038561122,
0.0360111818,
-0.0433764197,
0.0139224501,
0.0112559386,
0.0517718419,
0.0155364471,
-0.0478418246,
-0.0089198193,
0.0008518639,
-0.0319253057,
0.0014805266,
0.0246459283,
-0.070687212,
-0.0099531086,
-0.0147203067,
-0.0335930213,
-0.064965561,
-0.0274357237,
0.011796752,
0.0342636667,
0.0019886456,
-0.0213575698,
-0.0632692277,
-0.0349883586,
-0.0068835719,
0.0120583177,
-0.0126604931,
-0.032408312,
0.0635796711,
0.0215925332,
-0.0222622994,
-0.0451050475,
-0.0283162761,
0.0093436139,
-0.0592407323,
0.0094939955,
-0.0370317958,
-5.037717692e-33,
-0.0531400591,
-0.0977200717,
0.0341565199,
0.0381882302,
-0.0242269002,
-0.0516862646,
-0.0424947366,
0.0337208137,
-0.0038703461,
0.0218260847,
-0.0180569701,
-0.0339417979,
0.0124520585,
-0.0182055011,
0.0365669616,
0.0224768911,
0.0399229303,
0.027453592,
-0.031955678,
0.0186978355,
0.0438621528,
0.002077708,
-0.0062021115,
-0.089181751,
0.0719391406,
-0.0124672567,
-0.0424705446,
-0.0087458175,
0.0340653285,
0.0345107466,
-0.048832044,
0.0365838632,
0.0098614087,
0.0342122465,
0.015086744,
0.0690481216,
-0.0303390566,
-0.0270228758,
0.0058574975,
0.0597322471,
-0.0103407437,
-0.037308801,
-0.0232771728,
-0.0373908058,
-0.0462706983,
0.0626983866,
0.0414262414,
-0.0085168425,
-0.030596951,
0.0134254573,
-0.0968028903,
0.0199158676,
-0.0507343225,
-0.0550207756,
-0.0038758898,
0.0488252789,
0.0282565989,
-0.0063004456,
-0.0551007427,
0.0106407441,
-0.0331416801,
-0.0588464327,
0.0472306758,
-0.0025262595,
0.0219468735,
0.0481246673,
0.0158957075,
0.035327822,
0.01588469,
0.0084279682,
0.0152479783,
0.0483339876,
-0.0236417912,
0.0240323823,
-0.0478476547,
0.0023300457,
-0.0038430975,
0.0335777216,
0.019337127,
0.0277626235,
-0.0512986071,
0.0210630279,
-0.0612604357,
0.0214323904,
-0.0008645379,
0.0007938726,
0.0236190818,
-0.0708359182,
-0.0141556542,
-0.0364744216,
0.0093001816,
-0.0001020885,
0.0037148462,
0.0053972863,
0.0032267335,
-0.0175619293,
-0.0306432936,
0.027641166,
-0.0025291981,
-0.0270846076,
-0.0059433882,
-0.0270966012,
0.016025167,
0.0082695941,
0.0459832549,
0.0033539853,
-0.0289473198,
0.0382978171,
0.008285109,
-0.0345763564,
-0.0001920628,
0.0044438145,
-0.0000580693,
-0.0136609813,
0.0455885641,
0.0096171023,
-0.0369091779,
0.0929937288,
-0.0139482617,
0.0206627883,
-0.0378042944,
-0.0012719817,
-0.0104556382,
-0.0446758792,
-0.0220506173,
-0.0092604263,
0.0062818774,
0.0277368724,
0.0196680855,
-0.0280862655,
-0.0033190176,
-0.0069064731,
2.641e-7,
0.0086322092,
0.008418045,
0.0378116928,
-0.0260492247,
0.031342268,
0.0193250105,
-0.0005991959,
0.0318924971,
-0.0132325832,
-0.0259361546,
0.0306102652,
-0.0142844487,
0.0358536541,
-0.0139601883,
-0.0596112683,
-0.1115410328,
-0.0184574835,
-0.0322291218,
-0.0246042572,
0.0476503894,
0.0604143217,
-0.0214557424,
-0.0035511276,
0.0068569635,
-0.039188385,
-0.0043937764,
0.010805374,
-0.0181841627,
0.0016292525,
-0.0018996922,
-0.0142485024,
0.0049020606,
-0.0054466119,
0.0118546356,
0.015084153,
0.0052429438,
0.0285521746,
0.0416984223,
-0.0462482162,
-0.0559828803,
0.010020637,
0.0078850351,
-0.0101681808,
0.0182594638,
0.0056715361,
-0.0318894237,
-0.0333865695,
0.0179191679,
0.0030079493,
-0.0185841285,
-0.0105176223,
-0.019360207,
0.0138873849,
0.0296836141,
-0.0389628299,
-0.0147079099,
-0.0102178315,
-0.0405423008,
0.044091776,
-0.0050838552,
-0.0863689035,
-0.0771877766,
-0.0035618248,
-0.0562677681,
0.0092387917,
-0.0013225089,
-0.0025922777,
1.65438501e-34,
0.0097135659,
-0.0166268907,
0.0189258382,
0.0769353136,
0.0527694225,
0.0449358858,
0.0428206325,
0.045053523,
0.0890990421,
-0.0418087766,
-0.0316742659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15090v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15090v1 | Killing two birds with one stone: Can an audio captioning system also be used for audio-text retrieval? | 2023-08-29T07:53:17 | 2023-08-29T07:53:17 | Etienne Labbé, Thomas Pellegrini, Julien Pinquier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automated Audio Captioning (AAC) aims to develop systems capable of
describing an audio recording using a textual sentence. In contrast, Audio-Text
Retrieval (ATR) systems seek to find the best matching audio recording(s) for a
given textual query (Text-to-Audio) or vice versa (Audio-to-Text). These tasks
require different types of systems: AAC employs a sequence-to-sequence model,
while ATR utilizes a ranking model that compares audio and text representations
within a shared projection subspace. However, this work investigates the
relationship between AAC and ATR by exploring the ATR capabilities of an
unmodified AAC system, without fine-tuning for the new task. Our AAC system
consists of an audio encoder (ConvNeXt-Tiny) trained on AudioSet for audio
tagging, and a transformer decoder responsible for generating sentences. For
AAC, it achieves a high SPIDEr-FL score of 0.298 on Clotho and 0.472 on
AudioCaps on average. For ATR, we propose using the standard Cross-Entropy loss
values obtained for any audio/caption pair. Experimental results on the Clotho
and AudioCaps datasets demonstrate decent recall values using this simple
approach. For instance, we obtained a Text-to-Audio R@1 value of 0.382 for
Au-dioCaps, which is above the current state-of-the-art method without external
data. Interestingly, we observe that normalizing the loss values was necessary
for Audio-to-Text retrieval. | [
-0.0092559978,
0.016976539,
-0.012429283,
0.0338291414,
0.0128647937,
-0.0189119298,
0.0056218752,
-0.0160393286,
-0.0651183799,
-0.0412753895,
-0.0534461811,
-0.0087624993,
0.0308282971,
0.0230901279,
-0.0143027967,
-0.0707981884,
-0.0057586124,
-0.0206731092,
0.0008738701,
-0.0022103619,
-0.0166937057,
-0.0127733191,
-0.0194820687,
0.0424507298,
0.0230850112,
0.0434393808,
-0.0020214661,
0.0315771587,
0.0441320576,
-0.0168677978,
-0.0109261805,
0.0215292275,
0.0659589767,
0.0205113254,
0.0000016763,
-0.0161581002,
-0.0349631794,
0.012670652,
0.0273718499,
-0.010942094,
-0.004032766,
-0.0018094241,
-0.0153935496,
0.0511746481,
-0.000286484,
-0.0549737699,
0.0325907022,
0.0371559933,
0.0403509587,
0.0547848977,
-0.0233049933,
-0.0784818456,
0.0145377805,
-0.0454365388,
0.0135906246,
-0.0097821252,
-0.0188805293,
0.0255567133,
0.0420648046,
0.0199585613,
-0.0035485262,
0.0869379118,
-0.0103981262,
0.0032386165,
0.0336009078,
0.0444748029,
-0.0725963563,
-0.0138840694,
0.0074693477,
0.0605423264,
0.0264232419,
0.0064714993,
0.0113403155,
0.0478056222,
-0.0138238817,
-0.0399181433,
-0.0579649061,
0.0515412688,
0.0171701889,
-0.0024057487,
-0.0772055909,
0.0662822723,
0.0183283426,
-0.0353127941,
0.0070844907,
-0.0525717586,
0.0264239255,
-0.0045230431,
-0.0056520123,
-0.0374034643,
-0.0504645072,
-0.006786501,
0.0371096544,
-0.0188349877,
0.010418117,
-0.0277903136,
0.0012516521,
-0.0383531414,
-0.0094901053,
-0.021806417,
-0.0010918451,
0.0361870863,
-0.0439209193,
0.0668792576,
-0.0186566226,
0.0593510121,
0.0070201671,
0.02982793,
-0.0526822805,
0.0008783154,
-0.0550656803,
-0.0240878146,
-0.0526812524,
0.0325711519,
-0.0169808622,
-0.0322824009,
-0.0285868235,
-0.0579581112,
-0.0364228487,
0.0480407029,
-0.0158344917,
0.0371109098,
-0.031791579,
-0.0048234067,
0.0012292429,
0.0294472165,
0.014249471,
0.0586626977,
-0.00093479,
0.0200124308,
-0.0082786307,
0.0236557499,
0.0465681404,
-0.0089306589,
0.0439862944,
0.0669400766,
-0.0163906459,
-0.0505468883,
0.0172280557,
-0.0146746794,
-0.0440037809,
-0.0306036528,
-0.0122910719,
-0.0414124653,
0.0331566855,
-0.0005111649,
-0.0232882872,
-0.0109326029,
-0.0041894079,
0.0430459827,
0.0313522592,
0.088649027,
0.0434748046,
0.0184171703,
0.0547903813,
0.0309663862,
0.0105350623,
0.0401232429,
0.077965714,
0.0507400744,
0.0266850013,
-0.004976898,
-0.0058386419,
0.0333060697,
0.0005616468,
-0.0003829736,
-0.027355209,
-0.0020210587,
0.0247198734,
0.0357538424,
0.0167235415,
0.0544004925,
-0.0167912506,
-0.0241049062,
0.0493229479,
0.0163603071,
0.0124607785,
0.0134449694,
0.0180984046,
0.0056840489,
-0.0170262586,
-0.0046713501,
0.0343631022,
0.0578287505,
0.0355817303,
0.0186428856,
0.0810904428,
-0.0116579477,
-0.0197131205,
-0.0246614981,
-0.0156557225,
-0.024415385,
-0.0211584549,
-0.0132574821,
0.0076780291,
0.0189983509,
-0.0556674749,
0.0375174396,
-0.0455664806,
-0.0818378329,
-0.0128525505,
-0.0318223871,
-0.0319193229,
0.0330652595,
0.04362984,
-0.0679012612,
0.0436718203,
-0.0399587713,
-0.0192302112,
0.0483048633,
0.0233073048,
-0.0103295222,
0.0197474733,
-0.038176544,
-0.014450199,
0.0040095886,
-0.0133479247,
0.0514229648,
-0.0370131582,
0.0333805084,
0.0600405745,
-0.0215054434,
-0.0039786696,
-0.0119172996,
0.0316913202,
-0.045934014,
0.0052560037,
0.0279235933,
0.0378563888,
0.0579128712,
-0.0432555638,
0.0319492556,
0.0474913381,
-0.0326568186,
-0.0387179144,
0.0345789753,
-0.0773863867,
-0.0490146391,
0.0223331247,
-0.0781934187,
0.0338750333,
0.0327928476,
-0.0021098536,
-0.0650614202,
0.0382010527,
-0.0371466354,
0.0373607688,
-0.0432708561,
0.0184018593,
-0.0055217636,
-0.0118228709,
0.0021128091,
0.0108223557,
0.0584688485,
0.0045936001,
0.0211507045,
-0.0264243986,
0.0387842171,
-0.047629863,
-0.0550857298,
0.0265091714,
-0.0077575939,
0.0342114866,
0.0283525977,
-0.0349270217,
-0.0126540922,
-0.0144777978,
-0.066160813,
0.0247547664,
-0.0214815214,
-0.0154551314,
-0.0243035499,
-0.0028344865,
0.0265669059,
-0.0255657379,
-0.0313576348,
-0.0523958579,
0.0072337999,
0.0141733568,
-0.0243148711,
0.0436542109,
-0.0499860197,
-0.0191566721,
0.0022351299,
0.0266643278,
-0.0025589054,
-0.0263597146,
-0.014202483,
-0.0142273894,
0.0413838439,
-0.0050387038,
-0.005834464,
-0.0208284184,
-0.0169361029,
-0.0191938356,
0.0126680695,
0.0056452006,
0.0109295966,
0.0041811122,
0.0059334277,
0.0459440686,
0.0363457873,
-0.0263714343,
0.0081700021,
0.0037034063,
-0.0202487893,
0.004216006,
0.0226961188,
-0.0510172658,
0.0234783944,
0.0294004753,
0.0342604183,
-0.0331920423,
-0.0326024741,
-0.0186067391,
0.0023488593,
-0.0530109406,
-0.0460336059,
-0.018433189,
0.0381610245,
-0.0211892333,
-0.0225491803,
0.0337030627,
-0.0544170216,
-0.0640287176,
-0.0528965592,
-0.0480792411,
-0.0319263078,
0.0854564682,
0.0042567565,
0.0312620513,
0.0109378388,
-0.0415740795,
-0.0431438833,
0.0097327251,
0.035999991,
-0.0794074088,
0.0394034535,
0.0208016615,
-0.0016395702,
-0.0310045946,
-0.0546172597,
-0.0015199346,
-0.0065588541,
-0.0039169891,
0.0285420343,
-0.0413216129,
-0.0060543981,
-0.0643062443,
0.0441419743,
0.0451316573,
0.0392359905,
-0.0198674779,
0.0176572464,
-0.0106864776,
0.0652535409,
0.0069342437,
0.0000186906,
-0.0613347106,
-0.0003640657,
0.0436574072,
0.0050168578,
0.0221621487,
-0.0038579211,
-0.0314186998,
-0.0093690995,
0.0086441142,
0.0154453376,
-0.0346780233,
0.0225465801,
0.0007140287,
-0.0486521237,
-0.0210763291,
0.0865304247,
0.0223542191,
-0.0162364375,
-0.0418943316,
0.0380619317,
0.0387505889,
0.0270275809,
-0.014454321,
-0.0293064862,
-0.0312196761,
0.0357293636,
0.068472676,
0.0511266999,
0.0652419627,
-0.0135091245,
-0.0767758489,
0.0319894254,
0.0091728913,
-0.0683490336,
-0.0721026883,
-0.0469301641,
-0.0442174487,
0.0002882863,
0.0373193286,
-0.0136160953,
-0.019993104,
0.0187165309,
0.0045915069,
0.0062714601,
-0.0196599048,
0.0171587057,
-0.0415163413,
0.0535746031,
0.0977513492,
0.0679824054,
-0.02308283,
-0.0376649946,
-0.0490861461,
-0.0116490051,
0.0051862164,
0.0407559909,
0.0799619481,
-0.0136077404,
0.0158369895,
0.0523649529,
0.0000107682,
-0.0038047959,
-0.0164977722,
-0.0161945391,
0.0008907568,
0.0034913558,
0.0239134654,
-0.0241275169,
0.0639838278,
-0.0055604908,
0.0856194943,
0.0095790019,
0.0365975387,
0.015547364,
0.0002310505,
0.0352940373,
-0.0838684365,
-0.0035950195,
0.0135467835,
0.0016177158,
-0.0433490053,
-0.0514011793,
0.0152442101,
-0.0184635948,
0.0269378871,
0.0337965563,
-0.0060867434,
-0.0104340389,
0.033591561,
-0.0728665143,
0.0219687819,
-0.0005739681,
0.02742327,
-0.0156251322,
-0.0203993265,
0.0784066841,
-0.0437397026,
-0.0378047489,
0.0181293394,
-0.0471060425,
-0.0055300156,
-0.010804303,
-0.0208302997,
0.02479003,
0.0311360899,
0.0388693586,
0.0085706878,
-0.0012603477,
0.0298001003,
-0.0175751094,
0.023010198,
0.0293657463,
-0.0189742129,
-0.0566308126,
0.0123141212,
-0.0910321102,
0.0482904315,
-0.0334295034,
0.0411413051,
0.0462362021,
-0.0440034866,
-0.0024655617,
-0.0075419811,
0.0405977592,
-0.0303021409,
-0.0032113462,
-0.0289023463,
0.0265690554,
-0.0113581344,
0.0206967182,
-0.023522228,
-0.0111171491,
0.0126329642,
0.0376778394,
-0.0335733742,
0.0308804996,
-0.0112429829,
0.0014095569,
-0.0115868971,
0.0329046324,
0.0300160889,
-0.0488424711,
0.0003405565,
0.0122711239,
0.0007768745,
0.0035742805,
0.0491287634,
0.0652987212,
-0.0150512829,
0.0054724896,
0.0081544798,
0.0180054512,
-0.0044724275,
0.051336959,
-0.0619934089,
0.0313489586,
-0.025762707,
0.0244766492,
0.0447916463,
-0.0334393829,
0.0261882357,
0.0043051215,
0.0136882765,
-0.0154975327,
0.0106120463,
-0.0108212316,
-0.0347849168,
0.0044207056,
-0.0008384404,
0.0090962155,
0.0629637912,
0.040682666,
-0.0211605113,
0.0171835832,
-0.0416399278,
-0.0377878845,
-0.0098337159,
0.0001551315,
-0.0308218822,
-0.0018166327,
-0.0182933789,
-0.0323383175,
-0.0146958195,
-0.0597096272,
0.0057862741,
-0.0273934864,
0.0077179908,
-0.0022130564,
0.0490349382,
0.0151004409,
0.0164052639,
0.0025093283,
0.0268025883,
-0.0372947492,
-0.0331254117,
0.0065173912,
-0.0092344098,
-4.981788772e-33,
-0.0498111919,
-0.002587595,
-0.0316780023,
-0.0208662711,
-0.0121533526,
0.0024780841,
-0.0418528505,
0.0069312989,
0.0235114433,
-0.0162226092,
0.0260932893,
0.0036274507,
0.0294576697,
0.0249613989,
0.0201170612,
-0.0250127446,
0.0735275373,
-0.0407822765,
-0.0174856689,
0.0143611152,
0.049730096,
0.0209009405,
-0.019234376,
-0.0442332365,
-0.0356908627,
-0.0040036459,
-0.0023204982,
-0.012679439,
0.0534300841,
0.0458615758,
0.0001760568,
0.0313548185,
-0.0245238021,
-0.0460735969,
-0.0029241515,
0.0404333062,
-0.0868952572,
0.0188466907,
-0.0125264544,
0.0275899991,
0.0428242646,
-0.0087527046,
0.023602888,
-0.0200607534,
-0.0126608117,
-0.0362568125,
0.0520533323,
-0.0077392105,
-0.0059039444,
-0.0766922608,
-0.0379187129,
-0.0099813202,
-0.0242366977,
-0.0653738081,
0.0526760481,
0.0674441829,
0.0313070603,
0.0179996155,
-0.0682414845,
0.0570698455,
-0.0198956411,
0.0426860675,
0.0388975292,
0.0297217891,
-0.0474909805,
0.0570547618,
0.0229109488,
-0.0707169846,
-0.0225824192,
-0.0111584188,
-0.0055228681,
0.0303963386,
0.0580656789,
-0.0051541002,
0.059224695,
-0.023252856,
-0.0432441905,
0.0440102778,
-0.0710190758,
0.0033442986,
0.0221555457,
0.0810504854,
-0.0612293482,
0.0114404168,
-0.0604568385,
-0.0106530031,
-0.0398239382,
-0.0344360434,
0.0625682995,
0.0277533624,
0.0238664206,
0.0042564659,
0.0456154682,
-0.0288603585,
0.0314764716,
-0.0184606984,
-0.0385222621,
0.0132965408,
-0.0170460213,
0.0083508231,
-0.0121879959,
-0.0185761992,
0.1278018355,
0.0328336135,
0.0287553109,
-0.0167541634,
0.0245780796,
0.052164685,
-0.057033632,
0.0019447075,
-0.0027705831,
-0.0406064652,
-0.038139753,
-0.0014316605,
-0.0124210194,
0.055131603,
-0.0248090792,
0.0299123321,
-0.0397939831,
0.0404755585,
-0.0647108778,
-0.0348167196,
-0.0133498833,
-0.0028023336,
0.0004759236,
0.0571727529,
0.0203720015,
0.0011938839,
0.0220956206,
-0.0305454638,
-0.0156161077,
0.0271277595,
2.567e-7,
-0.0060958597,
-0.0173924025,
0.0279684439,
-0.0182696078,
0.0136648808,
0.0371985137,
-0.0666636452,
0.0188256353,
0.0098672817,
-0.0215950217,
0.0460945815,
-0.0121823316,
0.0819268301,
0.0352769867,
-0.1187334135,
-0.0127149029,
-0.0537804775,
-0.0039318041,
-0.0257551335,
-0.0262658894,
0.0728281736,
0.0898558348,
-0.025613131,
-0.0297168139,
0.003881552,
-0.0756749362,
0.052548632,
0.0019323031,
0.0212908518,
-0.0727782995,
0.0053460975,
0.0441192202,
-0.0532784909,
0.0093766619,
-0.0419118069,
0.0170526654,
0.0941203237,
0.0218911674,
0.0054007811,
-0.0924395025,
-0.0382952318,
0.0818719715,
-0.0175189711,
-0.0109151434,
0.0645457804,
-0.0358921811,
-0.0311360825,
0.0118324198,
-0.0439663269,
0.0331164896,
-0.0132113397,
-0.0009629374,
-0.0349249318,
-0.011462885,
0.0209343862,
0.0271906052,
-0.0184457824,
-0.0850472152,
-0.0055357888,
0.0132482797,
-0.0496351272,
-0.030281974,
-0.057548482,
-0.0208922755,
0.003163917,
-0.0396619141,
-0.0222805832,
1.953487251e-34,
0.0356233343,
-0.063762255,
-0.0215711873,
-0.044711303,
-0.0047868774,
0.0006787751,
0.0032172608,
-0.0178782679,
-0.0205716919,
-0.0546320453,
-0.0195360407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08612v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.08612v1 | Explaining Vision and Language through Graphs of Events in Space and Time | 2023-08-29T07:25:06 | 2023-08-29T07:25:06 | Mihai Masala, Nicolae Cudlenco, Traian Rebedea, Marius Leordeanu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Artificial Intelligence makes great advances today and starts to bridge the
gap between vision and language. However, we are still far from understanding,
explaining and controlling explicitly the visual content from a linguistic
perspective, because we still lack a common explainable representation between
the two domains. In this work we come to address this limitation and propose
the Graph of Events in Space and Time (GEST), by which we can represent, create
and explain, both visual and linguistic stories. We provide a theoretical
justification of our model and an experimental validation, which proves that
GEST can bring a solid complementary value along powerful deep learning models.
In particular, GEST can help improve at the content-level the generation of
videos from text, by being easily incorporated into our novel video generation
engine. Additionally, by using efficient graph matching techniques, the GEST
graphs can also improve the comparisons between texts at the semantic level. | [
-0.0125932209,
0.0549061112,
0.0097914934,
0.0474029854,
-0.0461368747,
0.0165186934,
0.0102091599,
0.0198500939,
-0.000168258,
-0.0313604958,
0.0676676556,
-0.0347003154,
0.0235290714,
0.0991725028,
0.0120654367,
-0.1299744844,
-0.0076912749,
0.0159891751,
-0.0014779313,
0.0183788389,
0.0143634034,
0.0141968243,
-0.0254764482,
0.0381798893,
-0.0590595268,
-0.0033056145,
-0.0246073324,
-0.0034726663,
0.0524704717,
-0.0342057869,
-0.0713316426,
-0.0333975777,
0.0851153284,
0.0444255956,
0.0000018519,
-0.0039588884,
0.0135862185,
-0.0038203539,
-0.0086426008,
0.0105495295,
0.003915803,
-0.0363961831,
0.0137375332,
-0.0298737809,
-0.0549963638,
0.0027084416,
0.058371529,
0.0357874855,
0.0551089123,
0.0681611374,
-0.0298946593,
-0.0564520098,
-0.0153294047,
-0.0117468117,
0.0409845859,
-0.0160880908,
-0.0210252665,
0.0037252032,
0.0352283008,
-0.0089354692,
-0.090602912,
0.0021595464,
0.0429829881,
-0.0393014513,
0.0397964604,
0.0609648116,
-0.008476736,
-0.0018045623,
-0.0072839288,
0.0732710809,
-0.0363544263,
-0.0309539922,
0.0195737612,
-0.0138269523,
-0.018037593,
0.0044861967,
-0.0775824785,
0.0133555681,
0.0246499777,
0.0525651127,
-0.0381961688,
-0.0035542434,
0.0305803269,
-0.0065925969,
0.026504701,
0.0147377178,
0.0259860698,
0.0581739061,
-0.0772052333,
0.0283152927,
0.0038632925,
-0.0619595796,
0.0001083193,
0.0433935709,
-0.0005954807,
-0.0059990482,
-0.031591244,
0.0311452169,
-0.0751896352,
-0.0221989192,
0.0400368571,
0.0226925313,
-0.0057600704,
0.0590505674,
-0.0250230078,
0.0934655666,
-0.0192650072,
0.0017151111,
-0.0432429798,
-0.0099890176,
-0.060285598,
-0.0022175123,
-0.0034587043,
-0.0208299495,
-0.0302491095,
-0.0513338223,
-0.0343776383,
0.0360303149,
-0.0240541808,
0.0072812294,
-0.0197217818,
0.0751359165,
-0.0182287879,
-0.0256651342,
-0.0456476919,
0.0200082511,
-0.0382544734,
0.020900622,
-0.0116388062,
-0.038535282,
-0.0099870432,
0.0550660715,
0.0438045934,
0.0132705644,
-0.0219650026,
0.0502511412,
-0.0255422443,
0.0093023432,
-0.0216509253,
-0.0289477427,
-0.0144155407,
0.0060993577,
0.0353470668,
-0.0723955259,
0.0399961732,
-0.0238281898,
-0.0313495919,
-0.035064768,
0.0174217876,
-0.0140713751,
-0.054029502,
0.0649466366,
-0.036543712,
0.0181710664,
0.0099855959,
0.0070314365,
0.0262457523,
-0.013328596,
0.0911487043,
0.0231666341,
0.0330288969,
0.0098358653,
0.0296828672,
-0.0011727983,
0.001743076,
0.0010802456,
-0.0645977631,
-0.0582938604,
-0.0543306768,
0.0529765524,
0.0519165993,
0.0046637445,
-0.0388323031,
-0.0522807203,
0.0483627543,
0.0577584319,
-0.0004354443,
0.0019429807,
0.0979975909,
-0.002569512,
-0.0271707699,
0.0508768968,
-0.0138127487,
0.0931886137,
0.0513612889,
0.0103893448,
-0.0256174356,
-0.019485103,
-0.0534138232,
-0.0188178886,
0.0128739821,
-0.0327526033,
0.03320105,
0.0001263798,
0.0417183451,
0.00962603,
-0.0453835465,
0.0248954576,
0.0177334528,
-0.0390986204,
0.033804968,
-0.0055922968,
-0.00335542,
0.0808596238,
0.0240196455,
0.0081184283,
-0.0123872086,
-0.0066715437,
0.0184253193,
0.03153947,
0.0210611112,
0.0020927007,
0.0142151071,
-0.0489278026,
-0.0479653254,
-0.0443314277,
-0.0058646873,
0.0351269171,
-0.0143003846,
0.0177421961,
0.0191246402,
-0.041010391,
-0.026921194,
0.0380586162,
0.0112794815,
-0.0101049617,
-0.0220613927,
0.0115164174,
-0.0145323239,
0.0103606395,
0.0146432733,
0.0172611699,
0.0297101121,
-0.0285569988,
-0.0088677388,
0.0836180076,
-0.0503439493,
-0.0577235557,
0.0276537798,
-0.1051592082,
-0.0158834234,
0.0294523295,
-0.0409957506,
-0.0661871508,
0.0571170636,
-0.0449309722,
0.0057319812,
-0.0086222617,
-0.0138548957,
0.0130327167,
-0.0051140659,
-0.0085461708,
0.0551947765,
0.0169873722,
0.008213657,
-0.0233580768,
0.0387942977,
0.0194920544,
-0.021314092,
0.0316191018,
-0.0035481288,
-0.0036741735,
-0.0237827972,
0.0288853738,
-0.0375458226,
-0.0449420847,
0.0316904709,
-0.0649498925,
-0.0305223484,
0.0282962583,
-0.0281399023,
0.0131739154,
-0.0263176374,
0.0096242037,
-0.0199973751,
-0.0447749197,
0.0379028805,
0.0156558491,
-0.0079629086,
0.0578625612,
-0.0202925727,
-0.0290531404,
-0.0227294993,
-0.0136133954,
-0.0263357218,
0.1074537709,
0.0751454458,
-0.0456194542,
-0.0094705466,
-0.0053225183,
-0.0106966123,
0.0151742296,
-0.0144977551,
-0.0055607469,
0.0346187502,
-0.0081719663,
0.0097959181,
0.0514899082,
-0.0002140811,
0.0681537315,
0.0242230762,
-0.029068796,
-0.0381426588,
-0.0191217326,
-0.0624240302,
0.0322612077,
-0.0259676147,
-0.0481635891,
-0.0217696652,
0.0148133393,
0.0234211683,
0.0154171567,
-0.0583131574,
-0.0011223531,
0.0073648803,
0.0143058682,
-0.0253003556,
-0.0588451736,
-0.0164065138,
0.0191046391,
-0.0395434164,
-0.0404138416,
0.0509456396,
-0.0150927529,
0.0041694851,
0.0393065698,
-0.0007452297,
-0.0370009169,
0.1054585651,
0.0610312857,
0.0277575105,
-0.0159364361,
-0.0122671919,
-0.0459645838,
-0.0037854169,
0.0480757244,
0.0111203035,
-0.0019806745,
-0.078202188,
-0.0024299172,
0.0027130807,
0.0093910843,
-0.0220823847,
-0.0126783149,
-0.0032191146,
0.0002016986,
-0.0267152376,
-0.0069591128,
-0.0435756557,
0.0114142578,
-0.0032809011,
-0.00634328,
-0.0199741628,
0.0051805945,
-0.0284137018,
0.0782775953,
0.0586282685,
0.0102679385,
-0.0114150848,
-0.0496293195,
0.0074708266,
0.0271330569,
0.0203448273,
0.0254712347,
-0.0730344206,
0.057834249,
-0.039185565,
0.0111634964,
-0.0168177262,
0.0186459199,
0.0418827087,
-0.0640898719,
-0.0001121335,
0.069558762,
0.0097897155,
-0.0266276635,
0.0311136581,
0.0362458527,
-0.0178104583,
0.0072742794,
-0.0049372069,
-0.0729128048,
-0.0131612066,
-0.0154203745,
-0.0389966704,
0.0217261892,
-0.0290183444,
-0.0381604768,
-0.0657580569,
0.035661988,
0.0291152038,
0.0025187482,
-0.0512113199,
-0.0268072989,
-0.0130570177,
0.0067621032,
-0.0500913337,
-0.037316557,
0.0360147171,
0.0191744193,
0.0197474062,
-0.0050281249,
-0.0389074013,
-0.0042920592,
-0.0329655595,
0.0061935307,
0.0046457616,
0.0735251009,
-0.0035177651,
-0.0264061559,
-0.0182757527,
0.0400780179,
0.022864243,
0.0192168802,
0.0455365926,
0.0186759569,
-0.0135540999,
0.0028978132,
0.0475330055,
-0.0038072676,
-0.0454841107,
-0.0463587232,
0.0657656789,
-0.0196264908,
-0.0274493899,
-0.0409732349,
0.0038341666,
-0.0022875492,
0.0543190949,
0.0354116149,
-0.0055320384,
-0.0592806898,
-0.0117121162,
0.0137725761,
-0.0658673793,
-0.0527147986,
0.0112508619,
0.0289583225,
-0.0248782672,
-0.0393510871,
-0.0241215955,
-0.0181164723,
0.031745892,
-0.0270834845,
-0.0292228255,
0.0044555161,
-0.0252190549,
-0.0765591338,
0.0633178949,
-0.0119474791,
0.0113864802,
0.0046638292,
-0.0016586188,
0.0010316854,
-0.0103696743,
-0.0216315389,
0.0487510078,
-0.0693260431,
-0.0401964486,
-0.0339000337,
-0.0019802761,
0.0189423244,
0.0877040327,
0.039696563,
-0.0147964107,
0.0223536529,
0.0308234803,
0.0300282445,
0.0100491494,
-0.0365734696,
-0.0303958394,
-0.0195199996,
0.0221117735,
-0.0387003608,
0.0170272775,
-0.0146036902,
0.0026447284,
-0.0408156104,
-0.0246348344,
0.004270209,
-0.0530277826,
0.0332140066,
-0.0118145626,
-0.0281698499,
-0.0471700691,
-0.07185027,
-0.0332172066,
0.0220420882,
-0.0518459305,
0.017926272,
0.0284683611,
0.0168416109,
-0.0020547782,
-0.0117892744,
0.0084894495,
-0.0293407328,
-0.039614819,
-0.0504956134,
0.0058388039,
-0.0311749354,
-0.0255536307,
0.0344797485,
0.0213422086,
0.025640158,
-0.0529975034,
-0.0002690378,
-0.004481378,
0.0228716321,
0.0323950201,
0.0252898335,
0.0102879433,
-0.0210590344,
-0.077966392,
-0.0207801834,
-0.018207252,
0.0196225122,
0.0863052011,
-0.0412521735,
0.0396768972,
-0.017737681,
0.0106258001,
0.0086865313,
0.0546095148,
0.0330331437,
-0.0499729365,
0.0311111975,
-0.0000063627,
-0.010877098,
0.0191959925,
0.0740470439,
0.0311014429,
0.016848322,
0.0131594744,
-0.0241270233,
-0.0108096758,
-0.0207635965,
0.0011641884,
0.0083743846,
0.011625764,
0.0249327552,
-0.0147253005,
-0.0413947478,
0.0140928822,
0.0002159475,
0.0189679265,
0.0289317071,
0.0934608728,
0.0270784721,
-0.0048596072,
0.0009323519,
0.0020068125,
0.0415462665,
-0.0146539416,
-0.0334164388,
-0.0284512993,
-5.682798502e-33,
-0.0157968421,
-0.085886538,
0.0040510213,
0.018772848,
-0.0293589868,
0.020107165,
-0.0608117282,
-0.0190364346,
-0.0329067931,
0.0475415774,
0.0622135922,
0.0515684076,
-0.0052215732,
0.0352243595,
-0.0130714951,
0.0009303828,
0.0149249062,
-0.0249073934,
-0.0187039953,
0.0408165827,
0.0540223569,
0.0131507087,
0.0335236378,
-0.0650474727,
-0.0313472152,
0.0085969893,
-0.0029920095,
0.0143335927,
0.0696968958,
0.0350749046,
-0.0264031645,
0.0040149218,
0.0344081447,
-0.0192869399,
-0.0190223698,
0.0214505848,
-0.0416007228,
-0.0359263159,
-0.0077588814,
0.0197222251,
-0.0865181163,
-0.0271015652,
0.0517030917,
-0.0293738302,
0.0065410123,
-0.0584870949,
0.0844683498,
-0.0068497527,
-0.0094513725,
-0.0153086428,
-0.0198583342,
0.0345754214,
-0.0620296299,
-0.0473354012,
0.0362400748,
-0.0112585342,
0.0333890207,
0.0068716882,
-0.025075933,
0.0435097627,
-0.037428759,
0.0310517438,
0.050105948,
-0.0155813759,
0.0095302621,
0.0820897818,
0.0042536762,
-0.050675042,
-0.0588552915,
0.0313742906,
0.0144518241,
0.0660031065,
0.0645114481,
0.0248620827,
0.0017727514,
-0.0128070042,
-0.0829732046,
0.0384253375,
-0.0256322976,
0.0132176001,
-0.0056048189,
0.0387568958,
0.016722519,
-0.0056138788,
-0.0116439098,
-0.0248530861,
-0.0304502957,
0.0111808609,
-0.0115252668,
-0.0189359225,
0.0280643366,
0.03055574,
0.0168151259,
-0.0469378419,
0.0175098386,
0.0476329364,
-0.0378220789,
0.0571794994,
0.0307091922,
0.0198232308,
0.0035622027,
-0.0083712954,
0.0263660215,
0.0306906383,
0.0443116724,
0.0025564989,
0.0215925183,
0.0356952772,
0.0265079886,
0.0019735012,
-0.050539773,
-0.0672993511,
0.0100854384,
-0.0210044775,
0.0342353918,
0.0224059802,
-0.0435701199,
0.0353659764,
-0.0011213234,
0.0423762798,
0.0182491038,
-0.0336145423,
-0.0223738588,
0.0361987241,
-0.0462159961,
-0.0031928073,
-0.0596718341,
0.0040480508,
0.0614943579,
-0.0589813031,
-0.0514461584,
0.0160072837,
2.478e-7,
0.0112179378,
0.0092923883,
0.0512782633,
0.0074306172,
0.0396195389,
0.0296662617,
0.0170514062,
0.0279043261,
-0.0336078517,
-0.0104999794,
0.0344034769,
0.0423304476,
0.0290256143,
0.0231919996,
0.0029295878,
0.0302147493,
-0.0637772307,
-0.0510947034,
-0.0385704376,
0.0088373097,
0.0845840946,
0.0432217866,
0.0492260158,
-0.011368894,
0.042294167,
-0.0482780598,
0.0861168802,
-0.001823514,
-0.0066474555,
0.0066240584,
-0.0156795029,
0.0187314283,
-0.0383938216,
-0.0062221508,
-0.0121676084,
-0.0078997649,
0.0157768633,
0.0028641936,
-0.0327466652,
-0.0204547178,
-0.0068037901,
-0.0139593547,
-0.0023990427,
-0.045623295,
0.0543963946,
-0.0121289892,
-0.0258288793,
-0.0058956468,
-0.00415101,
0.0221280865,
-0.0059024496,
0.0079629831,
-0.0262983665,
0.0185936112,
0.0140852705,
-0.0149289835,
-0.0100442749,
-0.0856898278,
-0.0287264846,
0.01788285,
-0.0416523926,
0.0339160748,
-0.0261292458,
0.0022474877,
0.0708387047,
0.0214073807,
-0.0536749698,
2.060691647e-34,
-0.0063799694,
0.0376910977,
-0.0248186439,
-0.0497350134,
0.0121083437,
0.002155348,
-0.0197624415,
0.0187256113,
0.0239125881,
-0.0298306942,
-0.06230722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15055v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15055v1 | Taxonomic Loss for Morphological Glossing of Low-Resource Languages | 2023-08-29T06:31:21 | 2023-08-29T06:31:21 | Michael Ginn, Alexis Palmer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Morpheme glossing is a critical task in automated language documentation and
can benefit other downstream applications greatly. While state-of-the-art
glossing systems perform very well for languages with large amounts of existing
data, it is more difficult to create useful models for low-resource languages.
In this paper, we propose the use of a taxonomic loss function that exploits
morphological information to make morphological glossing more performant when
data is scarce. We find that while the use of this loss function does not
outperform a standard loss function with regards to single-label prediction
accuracy, it produces better predictions when considering the top-n predicted
labels. We suggest this property makes the taxonomic loss function useful in a
human-in-the-loop annotation setting. | [
0.0252627041,
0.0258312896,
-0.0122743109,
0.0467711315,
-0.0087794522,
0.009810973,
0.0027807527,
0.0531264022,
-0.0176690575,
-0.0220164824,
-0.0080838362,
-0.0590485893,
0.0449507646,
-0.0206643585,
0.0650382861,
-0.0805084184,
0.036505051,
-0.022279365,
-0.0241641328,
-0.0203978028,
0.0212707855,
0.0406092033,
0.0266611874,
0.0297379959,
-0.0829651207,
0.0254348181,
-0.0032231295,
0.0273614228,
0.0027094425,
-0.0213030856,
0.0297948048,
0.0503049716,
-0.0166877303,
0.0565003529,
0.0000016755,
-0.0342937633,
0.015668897,
0.0213252939,
-0.0180540103,
0.0247534737,
0.092845276,
-0.020149678,
-0.0141974883,
0.0078785578,
0.0190426987,
-0.0148439808,
0.080904454,
-0.0422960557,
0.0130711021,
0.0054466873,
-0.0032735416,
-0.0897495747,
0.0151387956,
-0.0159352273,
-0.0141041633,
-0.011901076,
0.0151288146,
0.0045801788,
-0.015555351,
-0.0510820374,
-0.0230053645,
0.0704949424,
-0.0232142098,
0.0063383901,
-0.0298072919,
0.0660541654,
0.0128878551,
-0.0419634767,
0.0482938662,
0.0350848138,
-0.0498690531,
-0.0153089399,
0.0181614608,
0.015064206,
0.0071752961,
-0.0199230239,
-0.0288860817,
0.0296267867,
-0.0275724176,
0.0151270479,
0.0390888378,
0.0108461361,
0.0171392467,
0.0318482667,
-0.0098338099,
0.0316372402,
0.0328246541,
0.0198422745,
-0.0101304194,
0.0022761833,
-0.0264894441,
-0.0014491574,
-0.0252311938,
-0.00730664,
-0.012586033,
0.03628131,
0.0016450343,
-0.0592137948,
0.0705248639,
-0.0209786389,
0.0282400586,
-0.0408265069,
0.0039119055,
0.0187169742,
-0.0424110927,
-0.0435029604,
0.060577035,
0.0194314718,
-0.0264920909,
-0.0712516978,
-0.0136975693,
-0.0101347817,
-0.0385883749,
0.018596597,
0.0096654072,
0.0590980947,
-0.0524300672,
-0.0123579744,
-0.0029155291,
0.0200810824,
-0.0010228846,
0.0077081788,
-0.0785445869,
-0.0405583531,
-0.0093546333,
0.0091078738,
-0.0282896776,
-0.0160552114,
0.0045399815,
-0.0360674337,
-0.0047412105,
0.028899245,
-0.0002991943,
0.0268895719,
0.0092575122,
0.100697197,
0.0124963131,
-0.0395644866,
-0.0548249856,
-0.037720032,
-0.0614862666,
-0.0237676855,
-0.0282299481,
-0.0642241165,
0.0152798472,
-0.0183360614,
-0.0067360178,
-0.008616209,
-0.0012539723,
-0.01457805,
-0.0170322135,
0.0731237829,
-0.0689283386,
-0.0172919296,
0.0608667694,
-0.0042713811,
0.0217033755,
0.0460457616,
0.0091258446,
-0.002600315,
0.0359192155,
-0.0096408306,
0.0046402416,
0.0342422202,
-0.0066611026,
0.0083696302,
-0.0306842085,
-0.0412898362,
0.0045078914,
0.0567626767,
0.0940339118,
0.0844976455,
-0.0262072664,
-0.0454114825,
0.0297251064,
0.0817589015,
0.0377841778,
0.0235465541,
0.0265342202,
0.0285246391,
-0.0289342012,
-0.0161068738,
0.0143745998,
-0.0191351045,
-0.0485015549,
0.0451028273,
-0.0217558201,
0.0183652919,
-0.0108701717,
-0.0441019833,
-0.0267347842,
-0.0463457219,
-0.0109250769,
-0.0487298183,
0.0590501912,
0.0284277964,
-0.0042536929,
0.0012030926,
0.0752404928,
-0.0167088173,
0.0398289748,
-0.0240962431,
0.0048575313,
0.0421249345,
0.0378754474,
-0.0384672508,
-0.0734179169,
0.0274942387,
0.004273749,
0.0371860899,
-0.0150382668,
-0.0442541651,
-0.0081303781,
-0.0555835515,
0.0319381654,
0.0520255379,
0.0286201406,
0.0517195836,
0.0034794598,
-0.0030096062,
0.0282820221,
-0.066624701,
-0.0951841921,
0.0162944421,
0.0024244767,
0.0088401875,
-0.0142578995,
-0.0174918454,
0.0115779815,
-0.0138387671,
-0.0392524265,
0.0173845105,
0.019022787,
-0.0204147566,
-0.0186840836,
-0.0497713313,
-0.0031941093,
-0.0278259125,
0.0332472175,
-0.0170501098,
-0.0196972452,
-0.021864485,
-0.0012434265,
-0.0194419827,
-0.0013457236,
-0.0744625926,
0.1095625833,
-0.0553970486,
0.0205427799,
0.0087994589,
-0.0229559503,
-0.0324712917,
0.0527142249,
0.0070701027,
0.050530035,
-0.0238803532,
-0.0139611037,
-0.0155584337,
-0.0288092699,
-0.0106462343,
0.0249906778,
0.0205955524,
-0.0109914429,
-0.0051905457,
0.0060357433,
-0.0334381536,
-0.0342324898,
-0.1213467345,
-0.0181881767,
-0.0290792007,
0.0361112989,
-0.0182928629,
0.0205524396,
0.0007934826,
-0.0277922936,
-0.017829081,
0.0374760255,
-0.0405010208,
0.0200620648,
0.0244879033,
0.0381760933,
-0.0231114347,
-0.0133741489,
-0.010323409,
0.017418066,
0.039281249,
0.0148985339,
-0.0675134063,
-0.0367693752,
-0.0259029735,
-0.0624706186,
-0.0071467939,
0.0031481546,
-0.0307995025,
-0.0089988932,
-0.0181631539,
0.0629164651,
-0.0220901202,
0.0185962748,
-0.0257573538,
0.059620548,
-0.0232582204,
-0.059100844,
-0.0487720259,
-0.0255635809,
-0.0596641004,
-0.0215239245,
-0.0241741929,
-0.0199667085,
0.0678131655,
-0.0174724441,
0.0108757745,
-0.0013973378,
-0.0202148017,
-0.0494699478,
0.0131138247,
0.000711397,
0.0227828939,
-0.0505319834,
0.024465885,
0.027925849,
-0.0255852342,
0.0609633699,
-0.0187061504,
-0.0314316563,
-0.0139024742,
-0.0068751872,
-0.0131638153,
0.0304096527,
-0.0028229146,
0.0389246754,
0.0592316352,
-0.0690516159,
-0.0165569931,
0.0386980213,
0.0375585482,
-0.0208530631,
-0.0357587747,
-0.0879894644,
-0.0052347304,
-0.0215988476,
-0.0059904605,
0.0289150886,
-0.0045963926,
0.0016286043,
0.0353866406,
0.0383218862,
-0.0297795702,
0.0266783368,
0.0104235029,
-0.0341433138,
0.0502138138,
0.0027789718,
-0.0135050965,
0.0178701617,
0.0487739146,
0.0118690515,
-0.0112865884,
-0.0386350676,
-0.0118880384,
-0.0203039218,
0.0151993101,
-0.0191743374,
-0.0095209545,
0.0074509117,
-0.0431411453,
0.0166450739,
-0.013643668,
-0.0691024512,
0.0059591606,
-0.0249725264,
-0.0264069661,
0.0170200188,
0.0774899796,
0.0272041019,
-0.0398419313,
0.0126149263,
0.0005137009,
0.097551845,
0.0037009283,
-0.0037420946,
-0.0509974808,
-0.0017863286,
0.0041283639,
0.0601217002,
0.0431025438,
-0.045049414,
0.0400826484,
-0.0606202297,
0.0311109498,
0.0205080397,
-0.0299356263,
0.0046642544,
-0.0267461743,
-0.0107215475,
-0.0396679156,
-0.006172373,
-0.0151399532,
0.0004923914,
0.0129345087,
0.0601831675,
-0.0728574246,
-0.0514359176,
-0.0074431584,
-0.0324127339,
0.0320317782,
0.0043697562,
0.0420436226,
-0.027153058,
-0.0154747684,
0.0694413334,
-0.0212921537,
-0.0320798643,
-0.0425192192,
0.0704739392,
0.0108955521,
-0.028228607,
0.0197132453,
-0.028314963,
0.0105005587,
0.0262051858,
-0.0261456165,
0.0523821786,
0.0469419286,
0.0138839502,
0.0177578293,
-0.0380966812,
-0.0071684946,
0.0281251594,
0.0284056477,
-0.0356024317,
-0.023846738,
-0.0314573422,
-0.0001127492,
-0.0052736984,
-0.0718849003,
-0.0080298008,
-0.0439317897,
-0.0834402815,
-0.0885122269,
-0.0375261679,
0.0525456406,
0.0322322026,
0.0063466206,
-0.0087872837,
-0.0387947261,
-0.0053464812,
-0.04996939,
0.0204565991,
-0.0111860083,
-0.0136687439,
-0.0786044374,
-0.0480026975,
0.0740046948,
0.0581929274,
-0.0064492663,
0.0602288507,
-0.0034751655,
-0.0377079621,
0.0210179165,
0.0113705667,
0.0133403223,
0.0251880996,
-0.0220567137,
-0.0434399545,
0.0596733168,
0.0282229669,
0.0494062491,
0.0225346461,
0.0498129837,
0.0265174005,
-0.0030901432,
0.0566884913,
-0.0272640325,
0.0092326403,
-0.0213910528,
0.021644678,
-0.0657576248,
-0.023804469,
0.0193300247,
0.006680259,
0.0267342757,
-0.0935704857,
-0.0009141921,
-0.0287002586,
-0.0055565815,
0.017370915,
-0.0451510735,
0.0156313404,
0.0141439475,
0.0504225492,
-0.0220647044,
-0.0095850183,
0.0205032807,
0.0075278981,
-0.0041192877,
0.0038159401,
-0.01477837,
0.0322858915,
-0.0232154783,
0.0171924513,
0.0355622582,
-0.0347704925,
-0.0240046028,
-0.0223156679,
0.0335598476,
-0.0530246422,
-0.0407720655,
0.0014386014,
-0.0144625315,
-0.002822445,
0.0182249825,
0.0418358482,
-0.0351327471,
-0.0685941726,
0.0289153866,
0.0308217779,
-0.0131760119,
0.0553695075,
-0.0750370175,
-0.0116412211,
-0.0378864631,
0.032683447,
-0.0356031694,
-0.0437456444,
-0.0045662303,
0.0055666217,
-0.0234676097,
-0.0132071627,
0.0899863616,
0.0730551481,
0.0451620184,
-0.0293610096,
-0.0313674733,
-0.0239569265,
-0.0161106139,
-0.0221635439,
0.0292410553,
0.0134349875,
-0.0039929682,
-0.0815709606,
-0.0700872838,
0.0184314679,
-0.0106403669,
0.015614369,
0.0402046628,
0.0543902926,
0.0084669944,
-0.0002175549,
0.0320941992,
-0.0342833772,
0.0125410873,
0.024273159,
-0.0059054461,
-0.0198710151,
-5.4228236e-33,
-0.0463544726,
-0.0645573512,
-0.0312981531,
0.0166908987,
0.0215057153,
0.0320153832,
-0.0311661344,
0.0604802929,
0.0204405207,
0.0317521878,
0.0228252057,
-0.0071054315,
0.0162241682,
-0.0103456751,
0.0553595349,
0.0291201975,
0.0014826495,
-0.0112135429,
0.0245127082,
0.0262236521,
0.0228901859,
0.0354061387,
0.082288079,
-0.0467943251,
0.024452677,
0.0266638212,
0.0109078474,
-0.0122812362,
0.0128986072,
0.0141181229,
-0.0311607122,
0.0776853785,
-0.0002379719,
0.0253003612,
-0.0219671801,
-0.0162696652,
-0.0558723472,
0.0029193202,
-0.0216243844,
0.0032958155,
-0.0392110795,
-0.0217825025,
-0.001370566,
-0.0017416314,
0.0015020443,
0.0244672187,
0.0524594933,
-0.0212202203,
-0.0688826293,
-0.0396207981,
-0.0440516807,
0.0640524924,
0.0193324573,
-0.0033133035,
0.086512208,
-0.0116551872,
0.0422903709,
-0.0290555879,
0.0225136448,
0.0107647581,
-0.001588354,
0.0642486066,
0.0598863587,
0.0267262962,
-0.0607139692,
0.0356576629,
0.0250302795,
0.0019100698,
0.0693037957,
0.0128566502,
0.0152702006,
0.0088958694,
0.0316040032,
0.0152580086,
-0.0072732661,
-0.0037518418,
0.0284846071,
0.0271931663,
-0.0381040648,
0.0428863689,
0.0035516636,
0.0325641148,
-0.0275658313,
-0.0360657088,
-0.0128050968,
-0.0305775572,
0.0078836754,
0.0110254986,
-0.0117498962,
-0.0164050404,
-0.0276786238,
0.0709125176,
-0.0095796706,
0.0274618883,
-0.0478422605,
-0.0437885933,
0.0438268557,
0.0492565408,
-0.0192673728,
0.0155938463,
-0.0120758004,
-0.0126679195,
0.0014791151,
0.0298395772,
0.009958555,
-0.0205390025,
0.0700787306,
0.0211497471,
-0.0531878397,
-0.0019299175,
-0.0397186913,
-0.0459612571,
-0.0154659078,
0.0096725989,
0.0369632952,
-0.0135869011,
0.004223594,
-0.0003235576,
0.0633165389,
-0.0057300986,
-0.0056153876,
0.0002429256,
-0.0196246132,
-0.0054825586,
-0.0296390187,
0.0218769126,
-0.0000681962,
0.008513975,
0.0352143496,
0.0325671956,
-0.0186201707,
-0.0297448244,
2.468e-7,
0.0796698928,
0.0789956152,
-0.0029407074,
-0.0452056304,
0.0284650382,
0.0059893699,
0.0008889192,
0.0021474604,
-0.0671908483,
-0.0262523871,
0.0258611534,
-0.0491920225,
0.0269368105,
0.0383673385,
-0.1201251969,
-0.0100737158,
-0.0468109511,
0.0262773298,
-0.0563157126,
-0.0080596805,
0.0146420421,
0.0639303774,
0.0022606316,
-0.0234903805,
0.0057526003,
-0.0171640422,
0.0472848527,
-0.0232577603,
-0.0060940129,
0.0219193604,
0.0816907436,
0.05321908,
0.0103998883,
0.0051693316,
-0.0360311531,
-0.041752778,
0.0106111998,
0.0037350669,
-0.0420319401,
-0.0213517956,
0.0484615155,
-0.0119803688,
-0.0091133369,
-0.0371051989,
0.0057488265,
0.0169866346,
0.0093096942,
0.02408709,
-0.0051657073,
0.0754637867,
0.0148096513,
-0.0193068348,
-0.0618635602,
0.0248832013,
0.0155799193,
-0.0442193635,
-0.0402513109,
-0.0718891546,
0.0165783595,
0.0847205445,
-0.026786698,
-0.0478426069,
-0.0114924964,
0.040084295,
-0.0269457269,
-0.0468001999,
-0.003314191,
2.212995078e-34,
0.0269203652,
0.0040771221,
0.0238816775,
0.0729371458,
0.0034391445,
0.0105813546,
0.0287752654,
0.0602120236,
-0.0241050404,
-0.0071353531,
-0.0190683771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15053v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15053v3 | Adapting Text-based Dialogue State Tracker for Spoken Dialogues | 2023-08-29T06:27:58 | 2024-01-09T08:27:48 | Jaeseok Yoon, Seunghyun Hwang, Ran Han, Jeonguk Bang, Kee-Eung Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Although there have been remarkable advances in dialogue systems through the
dialogue systems technology competition (DSTC), it remains one of the key
challenges to building a robust task-oriented dialogue system with a speech
interface. Most of the progress has been made for text-based dialogue systems
since there are abundant datasets with written corpora while those with spoken
dialogues are very scarce. However, as can be seen from voice assistant systems
such as Siri and Alexa, it is of practical importance to transfer the success
to spoken dialogues. In this paper, we describe our engineering effort in
building a highly successful model that participated in the speech-aware
dialogue systems technology challenge track in DSTC11. Our model consists of
three major modules: (1) automatic speech recognition error correction to
bridge the gap between the spoken and the text utterances, (2) text-based
dialogue system (D3ST) for estimating the slots and values using slot
descriptions, and (3) post-processing for recovering the error of the estimated
slot value. Our experiments show that it is important to use an explicit
automatic speech recognition error correction module, post-processing, and data
augmentation to adapt a text-based dialogue state tracker for spoken dialogue
corpora. | [
0.0476858914,
0.0455138199,
-0.0107450746,
0.027566582,
-0.0023284017,
-0.0218196437,
-0.0175415184,
-0.0027584261,
0.0168643203,
-0.044988472,
-0.0017257314,
-0.0448581949,
0.026618218,
0.0560077094,
0.0025986559,
-0.0535709634,
0.0630437583,
-0.0473652631,
-0.0072754361,
0.0332830399,
0.0468334854,
-0.0084390892,
-0.0788874626,
0.0250771604,
-0.0048269317,
0.0035037387,
-0.0499434955,
0.006840867,
-0.0026862009,
-0.0054570823,
0.011645548,
0.0209931619,
0.0267126691,
0.0566372573,
0.000001672,
-0.0499304682,
-0.016340835,
0.0026199303,
-0.0755720884,
-0.0255008433,
-0.0336747356,
0.0400930196,
-0.0347195826,
0.0563378483,
0.0094794556,
-0.0039947145,
0.0462691486,
0.0145255169,
0.0564140566,
0.0671592355,
-0.007808167,
0.0272355452,
0.0469869077,
0.0047211908,
-0.0203246381,
-0.0689763874,
0.0063517727,
0.0204113554,
0.0259459019,
-0.0071428656,
-0.0025706559,
0.0370633267,
-0.0203141868,
-0.0452085584,
-0.0146693168,
-0.0264017079,
-0.0482338257,
-0.0002254381,
-0.0667806938,
0.051483795,
0.0801998228,
0.0257145222,
0.0104704304,
-0.0034298014,
-0.0038099375,
-0.0309264306,
-0.0286064167,
-0.050662484,
-0.0288013592,
-0.0193597917,
-0.0101024881,
0.0313011147,
-0.0281434096,
-0.0001767491,
0.0036760739,
0.0368265472,
-0.0019277268,
-0.0504714474,
-0.0443410873,
-0.0063897953,
0.0446933955,
-0.0632376745,
0.0514223985,
0.0001814162,
-0.0377951451,
0.0343247764,
-0.0481594205,
-0.0578400604,
-0.0538919568,
-0.0202572215,
-0.0264530927,
0.0537526719,
-0.0363499373,
0.0284381695,
0.0616543181,
0.1148245707,
0.0059689526,
-0.0392643884,
-0.0143537652,
-0.0217467286,
-0.015856836,
0.0120132556,
-0.0590654984,
0.0071251495,
-0.032142587,
-0.015749529,
-0.0171828289,
0.0326905064,
0.0086086169,
0.0288650375,
0.00810677,
0.0157372709,
-0.019729251,
-0.0192711819,
-0.0277195647,
0.0472715013,
0.0260979962,
0.0355054103,
0.0076217824,
-0.0378316008,
-0.0100220339,
0.0114544462,
0.0471608862,
-0.0190007556,
-0.0319063812,
0.0273717493,
-0.020734353,
-0.0328795426,
-0.0042478424,
0.0285089705,
-0.034297511,
-0.055365596,
-0.0567045733,
-0.0230813418,
0.0297854077,
0.0007848096,
-0.0072072698,
-0.0225295406,
0.0118174395,
0.0184388719,
-0.0084250085,
0.0444217585,
-0.0685275272,
0.0082011167,
0.0519912727,
-0.0110817505,
0.0082675712,
0.0231067371,
0.0608906746,
-0.0062046382,
0.0440623984,
-0.0062484448,
0.0247157235,
0.0248098616,
-0.0068554818,
-0.0045218416,
-0.0088378834,
0.0277483612,
-0.0441555902,
0.0070963735,
0.0026691209,
0.0431360491,
-0.0294849072,
0.0268356986,
0.0551977605,
0.0708807558,
0.0291853789,
-0.0022042461,
-0.0174379144,
0.0379157215,
0.0287278127,
-0.00270711,
0.0029098261,
-0.0185343418,
0.0088646878,
-0.0142135331,
0.043023292,
-0.0127406176,
-0.0186699741,
-0.0271360315,
-0.0125488816,
-0.0134575581,
0.0133574661,
0.0089520905,
0.0585945137,
-0.0377091132,
-0.0490345247,
0.0357017443,
-0.0231451821,
-0.0807686374,
-0.0260913465,
-0.0214398727,
-0.0288338717,
0.0866177529,
0.0569116473,
-0.0451744609,
-0.0769662559,
-0.0520561151,
-0.0221662316,
0.0318514779,
0.0344919302,
-0.0189463347,
0.0257224403,
-0.0532571971,
0.0027120269,
0.0467845351,
-0.0282766093,
0.0206123907,
0.0000616623,
0.0082461014,
0.0148500009,
0.0600214601,
0.0601666234,
-0.0192000922,
0.0164626166,
-0.0099092452,
-0.0076732747,
-0.0237480439,
0.0753752887,
0.0591227226,
-0.0291077364,
-0.0454360209,
0.0183317233,
0.0248903148,
0.0038056057,
0.0486369394,
-0.0489201173,
-0.0251728091,
0.0394867733,
0.0323886201,
-0.0182850324,
0.0316601768,
-0.0006161618,
-0.0959351733,
0.006197331,
-0.0764040723,
-0.0116552133,
-0.0571885332,
0.0315809473,
0.0201830883,
-0.0005817557,
0.0112330038,
-0.0009031357,
0.0224225037,
-0.0107652498,
0.0647964031,
0.0158738736,
0.0247213915,
-0.0669726133,
-0.0133974161,
-0.0064240484,
-0.0239917077,
0.0285234638,
0.0186865535,
-0.0332840905,
-0.0286636166,
0.026681453,
-0.0774838775,
0.021209402,
-0.0153219085,
0.0043118782,
-0.0012263551,
0.0187045671,
-0.046321176,
-0.0311605129,
-0.0437839814,
-0.0414390862,
0.0722405389,
-0.0579881892,
-0.0094875684,
0.0109584657,
-0.0448023677,
-0.0704537258,
0.0712232143,
-0.0112747373,
-0.0237068813,
-0.0400943309,
-0.0742106065,
-0.0761624277,
0.0293612294,
0.0103682084,
0.0732781142,
-0.0115395607,
-0.0552036278,
-0.005982962,
0.0340170376,
0.0071689924,
0.0167122316,
-0.0038403326,
0.0280011334,
-0.0287865084,
-0.0720413029,
-0.0481276289,
0.060506016,
0.0250013694,
0.0699512437,
-0.0350839309,
0.0265687089,
-0.0112484721,
0.0188171882,
0.0358578861,
0.0446971916,
-0.0353889316,
-0.0269569457,
-0.0050980165,
-0.0313043036,
0.0156605951,
-0.0297082532,
-0.077189818,
0.0377945453,
0.0048304447,
-0.0332108885,
0.0174087882,
-0.0762766078,
-0.0483215414,
-0.0519532524,
-0.0243544839,
-0.0047760303,
0.0331117883,
-0.0241370928,
-0.0060824323,
0.032650426,
-0.0580786839,
-0.0081644654,
-0.0063539348,
0.0111844121,
-0.068356514,
0.0493047312,
-0.0564914718,
0.0172707383,
-0.0193682853,
-0.0325249545,
-0.0509192199,
0.0033139649,
-0.0505309664,
-0.0108033083,
0.0224597007,
-0.0499396063,
-0.0201580357,
0.0316738561,
0.0437961854,
0.0720622092,
0.0283161011,
0.0261654183,
-0.0152364317,
0.0378627814,
0.0274123475,
0.0567162596,
-0.0419575348,
0.0118640447,
0.0657909811,
0.0499045178,
0.0577295236,
0.0070228544,
-0.0051145335,
-0.0258308128,
0.0445070006,
-0.0074650981,
-0.0221867524,
0.0033062797,
0.0728006884,
-0.0381723046,
-0.0196125712,
0.1187045202,
0.0260601882,
-0.015456086,
-0.0565026142,
-0.0090967547,
0.002708907,
0.0121882092,
0.0213676896,
-0.0773934051,
-0.0263211261,
0.0517082922,
0.0362207778,
-0.0182752851,
0.0059307958,
-0.0393239148,
-0.0735572726,
0.0280506127,
0.0105367452,
-0.0254954211,
-0.0410680883,
0.0306300595,
0.037464276,
0.0081619509,
0.0189456418,
0.0166761726,
0.0359320156,
-0.0414580107,
0.0491079725,
-0.0643287003,
-0.0080358628,
0.0045889025,
0.0008980389,
0.1160087064,
0.0449439771,
0.0402657166,
0.0153730744,
0.014489878,
-0.0207762104,
0.0129296985,
-0.0168760642,
0.0296979994,
0.0234701987,
-0.0324260667,
-0.0152442055,
-0.0159630757,
0.0194494668,
0.0045904275,
-0.0094382493,
0.0234602727,
0.0349909067,
-0.047933165,
0.0949286222,
0.008653217,
0.0012440044,
-0.0014276276,
0.0194118805,
0.0129744681,
-0.0478751436,
-0.006275808,
-0.0180250872,
0.0130601907,
-0.0349822156,
0.0127998358,
-0.0077526052,
0.0003332694,
0.0017359834,
-0.0699809492,
-0.0278038215,
0.0254099965,
0.0491872802,
-0.0014721991,
0.0189338513,
0.0271170158,
0.0325319655,
0.0087784017,
-0.0364605002,
-0.0091984458,
0.0241203122,
-0.0571758375,
-0.0247292481,
0.0136224683,
-0.0169770904,
-0.0125565249,
0.0649556518,
-0.0518358238,
-0.0603718013,
0.0067487997,
0.0479633063,
0.027177142,
0.0395168774,
-0.0325291418,
-0.0258817244,
-0.0450482331,
-0.0133107714,
-0.0171609279,
-0.0074770153,
0.0411886089,
0.0269355606,
-0.0375017822,
0.0023389095,
-0.0232159551,
-0.0017188572,
-0.050328996,
0.0058849403,
-0.0477216318,
-0.0886987671,
-0.0123542668,
0.0025097195,
0.0434990115,
0.0166218039,
-0.0098709455,
-0.0316423364,
0.068801254,
-0.0234387703,
-0.0102131395,
-0.0612953678,
-0.0041813585,
-0.0264174491,
-0.0277790837,
-0.0046210014,
-0.0247292481,
-0.0581283793,
0.0020590713,
-0.0161397364,
0.0018541056,
0.0458809808,
0.0095619718,
-0.0020921743,
-0.0239478182,
0.0052277697,
0.0178885404,
0.0455997922,
0.0294033624,
-0.0035836045,
0.0974763632,
-0.03569692,
-0.0692984685,
0.0558853634,
0.0404394269,
-0.0774867758,
-0.0164419394,
-0.0155817531,
0.0443927199,
0.0390501432,
0.009245621,
0.052655261,
0.0136129633,
0.0321402065,
-0.0294016842,
0.0391874388,
-0.0080890488,
0.0188329723,
-0.0109593915,
0.0207288954,
-0.007196425,
0.016136121,
0.0267177634,
0.0434098803,
0.0083319284,
0.0100896042,
-0.0095516127,
-0.0261640549,
-0.0281567145,
-0.0028646016,
0.0404779911,
-0.0146354605,
0.0056165424,
-0.0382185802,
-0.039935708,
0.0340884626,
0.0088367099,
0.0375129916,
-0.0385683551,
0.0192927215,
-0.0024132843,
-0.0304300375,
0.0075042611,
-0.0252492521,
-0.0596486963,
-0.0210309625,
0.0000957119,
-0.0154285301,
-5.046640061e-33,
-0.0424221195,
-0.0300386362,
0.0048272447,
0.0083668018,
-0.0385779366,
-0.0165074766,
-0.0235615186,
0.0002320074,
0.0139743946,
-0.0364229195,
-0.0267062187,
0.0280517936,
0.0213830024,
0.0236018337,
-0.0335445702,
0.0035772999,
0.0386372879,
-0.0023288173,
-0.01978972,
-0.0049911472,
0.0571417771,
0.0224157926,
0.059852507,
-0.064811632,
0.0230148733,
0.0148914428,
0.0019266724,
0.0043028579,
0.0368287079,
0.0213777181,
0.0180375632,
0.033130914,
-0.0168811213,
-0.0397121012,
-0.0151246013,
0.0430292822,
-0.0147636971,
-0.015933102,
0.0321293734,
0.0655717328,
0.0395676196,
0.0526683368,
-0.03317298,
0.0018534535,
0.0006578899,
0.023011446,
-0.0039931512,
-0.0108415466,
0.0018689007,
-0.0009207275,
-0.0142427366,
0.0488337763,
-0.0270882118,
-0.0800034106,
0.0027171928,
0.0765009224,
0.0675844997,
-0.0873286426,
-0.0487118214,
0.0121990964,
-0.0186780877,
-0.0119882124,
0.0397209637,
0.0187451541,
-0.0212420113,
0.0752158836,
0.0394261442,
0.0006289247,
0.0079457415,
-0.0273406915,
-0.0343079939,
0.0181192774,
0.0561611168,
0.026717972,
-0.0092696715,
-0.0140517503,
-0.0166240949,
0.0064521143,
0.0271193292,
0.018678721,
-0.0148757044,
0.0420788415,
-0.0869802311,
0.0107382396,
-0.0177972671,
0.0196309779,
0.006672007,
-0.018498376,
0.047542192,
0.0014180223,
-0.0088427002,
0.0055818129,
0.0645316169,
-0.0172038916,
0.0294598509,
-0.0069907797,
-0.0071288273,
0.0242388099,
-0.0429360792,
0.0122849466,
-0.0271524899,
-0.0334229469,
0.0492286943,
0.057155963,
0.0334749781,
-0.019176539,
-0.0513978451,
0.0438662469,
-0.0471402705,
0.0127238436,
-0.0100128623,
0.0643657073,
-0.0540371314,
0.0600644052,
0.0147050908,
-0.0046597421,
-0.014914928,
0.0811917633,
0.0075248466,
-0.0130791767,
-0.042766545,
-0.0351548828,
-0.0038307668,
-0.016135864,
-0.0103376415,
-0.0004572559,
0.0107846763,
-0.0282120518,
-0.0050580613,
-0.0079743117,
0.032719668,
-0.0259670913,
2.487e-7,
-0.0244912375,
0.0408200882,
0.054914277,
-0.0373583063,
0.0142280366,
0.0335586295,
-0.017441595,
0.0193249863,
0.0284650866,
-0.0009665649,
0.0347510614,
-0.0273975544,
0.0593851916,
0.0396641195,
-0.1135202348,
-0.0691425353,
-0.0368348509,
-0.0036088547,
-0.0051628593,
0.0486975461,
0.0315908678,
0.0592038706,
0.0120176254,
0.0097029824,
0.0022981842,
-0.0352022313,
0.0048200181,
-0.0079811262,
-0.012573787,
0.0257060062,
0.0469763502,
0.0149946259,
-0.0300063882,
0.0018323992,
-0.023935914,
0.0798618719,
0.019821072,
0.0661180243,
-0.0180473141,
-0.0432493389,
-0.0381777696,
0.03738603,
-0.0116390111,
-0.0054318649,
0.0179764964,
0.022068914,
0.0180279128,
-0.051626794,
-0.0146222338,
-0.0064172209,
-0.0028313459,
0.0169677828,
-0.0067067156,
-0.0149662774,
0.0083044907,
-0.0263462104,
-0.0110920863,
-0.0890220702,
-0.0121429451,
-0.0366239287,
-0.0449060313,
-0.0418376029,
-0.0260670856,
-0.0505388379,
-0.0004943328,
-0.013635355,
-0.0094051361,
1.742310036e-34,
0.0305621717,
-0.0155363446,
-0.0017111175,
0.0591326617,
0.048127871,
-0.0118669672,
0.03225483,
0.0049189031,
0.0673902035,
-0.04613702,
-0.0219754111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15047v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15047v1 | Large language models converge toward human-like concept organization | 2023-08-29T06:09:47 | 2023-08-29T06:09:47 | Mathias Lykke Gammelgaard, Jonathan Gabel Christiansen, Anders Søgaard | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language models show human-like performance in knowledge extraction,
reasoning and dialogue, but it remains controversial whether this performance
is best explained by memorization and pattern matching, or whether it reflects
human-like inferential semantics and world knowledge. Knowledge bases such as
WikiData provide large-scale, high-quality representations of inferential
semantics and world knowledge. We show that large language models learn to
organize concepts in ways that are strikingly similar to how concepts are
organized in such knowledge bases. Knowledge bases model collective,
institutional knowledge, and large language models seem to induce such
knowledge from raw text. We show that bigger and better models exhibit more
human-like concept organization, across four families of language models and
three knowledge graph embeddings. | [
0.0573173612,
0.051959876,
-0.0192391779,
0.0756754577,
-0.0139552392,
0.0263379682,
-0.0259635672,
0.0434509441,
0.0135509754,
-0.0430558957,
-0.0121824061,
-0.054403726,
-0.0119620077,
0.0286443625,
0.0395654775,
-0.0587533824,
0.0070480416,
-0.0597727895,
0.0371263362,
-0.0151902242,
-0.0029257538,
-0.0231834557,
0.0066296454,
-0.0309137106,
0.0121180154,
0.0072165821,
0.0083549051,
-0.0460869074,
-0.0076938467,
-0.0106376261,
-0.0154344412,
0.0404100902,
0.0140002305,
0.0245361421,
0.000001709,
-0.0288654752,
0.0502073169,
-0.0149964299,
-0.0096641453,
0.0308280587,
-0.014548393,
-0.0347010642,
-0.0029037313,
-0.0451770499,
-0.0265691783,
-0.0151894623,
0.0204162747,
0.042250108,
0.0114685502,
0.0399795361,
0.008223339,
-0.0676643699,
0.0464084297,
-0.0133772315,
0.014272945,
-0.0420765057,
0.034393657,
0.0465494171,
-0.0155864535,
0.0067011798,
-0.0085203545,
-0.0094734663,
-0.0051989676,
0.0054052323,
0.0490358733,
0.0692926422,
0.0154744554,
-0.0195498541,
0.0243128836,
0.0919438899,
0.0372591689,
-0.0196629986,
0.0218134653,
0.0374090597,
0.0231987536,
0.0793014765,
-0.0467600897,
0.0740641505,
-0.0159051381,
-0.0022874009,
0.0214335024,
0.0047047157,
0.0573076755,
0.019854784,
-0.0550028495,
0.0954477936,
-0.0022876223,
-0.0395210236,
0.0033742362,
-0.0056512509,
-0.047295887,
-0.0617798418,
-0.0371788628,
0.0238010641,
0.0127214147,
0.0418241546,
-0.0144799044,
0.0374760032,
0.0181475673,
-0.0522159934,
-0.012765253,
-0.0057117906,
0.0202038549,
0.0792785361,
-0.0290995464,
0.0522775128,
-0.0591063835,
0.0268613268,
-0.0472745933,
-0.0388142057,
-0.0758117214,
0.0069521074,
-0.0028382214,
0.0566403233,
-0.0057019247,
-0.0319896899,
0.0051658913,
0.0449270234,
-0.0045618792,
0.0157851223,
-0.0102430731,
0.0086001186,
0.0406419113,
-0.0175113324,
-0.0434977077,
-0.0066852234,
-0.0465629287,
0.0209198855,
0.0017645592,
0.0460600741,
0.016799245,
-0.0298176035,
0.0028984738,
0.0060835769,
-0.0237477869,
0.0358204208,
0.0310357846,
0.0212966986,
-0.0133418385,
-0.0377653167,
0.0178198814,
-0.0235226862,
0.0270009637,
-0.0433652475,
0.0504126176,
0.0591444299,
0.0046843807,
-0.0442191549,
-0.0007559065,
-0.0063785329,
-0.0977481604,
0.0561359636,
-0.0146291116,
0.0324113145,
0.0542390198,
0.0206670947,
-0.0346004814,
0.0271174405,
0.0326242037,
0.0014201995,
0.0393758304,
0.0043910644,
-0.0346546322,
0.0009013799,
0.0227362644,
-0.0007979066,
0.0020856913,
0.0326146148,
0.0099512031,
0.0290674213,
0.0378883779,
0.0684157386,
-0.0559663326,
-0.0147843976,
0.0553931184,
0.0884403214,
-0.018591458,
0.0155083789,
-0.0030391105,
0.0132781351,
0.029773945,
0.0008022125,
-0.0583654903,
0.0015815631,
-0.0236147214,
0.0085103912,
-0.0108367745,
-0.0081744473,
-0.0210912172,
0.0288980212,
-0.0337953568,
0.0123723792,
0.0033232179,
-0.0091330623,
0.0393642932,
-0.0090187509,
0.0309954435,
0.0633526221,
0.0946723819,
-0.0063218959,
-0.013715161,
-0.0453961678,
0.050612729,
0.0465673618,
-0.0040393933,
-0.0063960971,
0.0065408531,
0.0246893764,
-0.0101261362,
0.0114486348,
0.0299435798,
-0.0613808408,
-0.0585544445,
-0.012190735,
0.0036821738,
0.0203332603,
0.0057412186,
0.0125042321,
0.009817631,
0.0001544966,
-0.0057776771,
-0.0546746589,
-0.0120578073,
0.0254632793,
-0.0372406505,
0.0198093075,
-0.0640915409,
0.0086733848,
0.029184347,
0.0122657428,
-0.0152094243,
-0.0005652906,
0.0330127962,
-0.0447565019,
-0.0514913462,
-0.0018161502,
-0.0372021906,
-0.0252541676,
0.0321886912,
0.0174166765,
0.0083084852,
-0.0288333502,
-0.0013991143,
-0.023666691,
0.0378874876,
0.0123339854,
0.1036370099,
-0.0154876448,
0.0043284292,
-0.0159371961,
-0.0341205969,
-0.0020538722,
0.1152186245,
-0.0219381712,
-0.0135770701,
0.0136912391,
-0.0158150885,
-0.0285329446,
0.0164758768,
0.0078824675,
0.0588251986,
0.0116859376,
0.019607842,
0.0162339918,
-0.0471304171,
-0.0388974026,
-0.0089719221,
-0.0975631177,
0.0014066393,
-0.0032169858,
-0.006567446,
0.0252667293,
-0.0185999498,
0.0314786062,
0.0296929367,
-0.0341593139,
0.0288609024,
-0.0203728899,
0.0331055075,
0.0044468883,
-0.0018350453,
-0.0026091402,
-0.0240171291,
-0.0237933379,
-0.0146742603,
0.071363017,
0.0034154563,
-0.0020898592,
-0.0344980396,
0.0567369796,
-0.0649073794,
-0.0265180115,
-0.0406788662,
-0.0200051926,
0.0075014876,
-0.0126685789,
0.0256245881,
0.0524462201,
-0.0020341808,
0.0523516983,
0.0545205288,
0.0272627678,
-0.0249027871,
-0.0344706513,
0.0215264931,
0.0196925048,
-0.0445141234,
0.0122611681,
-0.0256269369,
0.0563269109,
0.0176413525,
0.0119124362,
-0.0397275873,
0.0503168106,
-0.0682233945,
0.0040398673,
-0.0795788169,
-0.0585570373,
0.0031337009,
0.0282001439,
-0.0434866734,
0.0116501488,
0.021965703,
0.0273568183,
0.0212996788,
0.0168084614,
-0.0138774356,
-0.0083116367,
0.0704116896,
0.0196495112,
0.0351498276,
-0.0275981128,
-0.0005016181,
-0.0628239885,
0.0080229733,
0.0310427155,
-0.0155567629,
0.029218005,
-0.0237307362,
0.0252367221,
-0.0094819432,
-0.0294209048,
-0.0579348877,
0.0034889609,
-0.0443898104,
0.0515172221,
0.033827316,
-0.0383933634,
0.0039344169,
0.0067159985,
0.0466674007,
0.0006477996,
0.0195130296,
0.0054736407,
0.0022648955,
0.0679463819,
0.0380101614,
-0.0126695894,
0.0020410751,
-0.0330719762,
0.0359884165,
0.0646655783,
0.0563000217,
-0.0294547286,
-0.0073670233,
-0.0291762929,
0.0044542295,
-0.0713611096,
-0.0528400093,
-0.0071115685,
0.003895933,
-0.0333785824,
0.017049551,
0.1236392707,
0.0264791269,
-0.046158269,
0.0045892717,
-0.000784971,
0.0186974369,
0.0331104249,
-0.0192434993,
-0.0696644038,
0.001643781,
-0.0019674173,
-0.0256892126,
0.04691194,
-0.0658332258,
0.022224905,
-0.0738662779,
-0.0254185107,
0.0225010961,
-0.0612389036,
-0.0041563427,
-0.0563139357,
-0.0027061198,
-0.0023994537,
-0.0343826711,
0.0296297967,
0.0073761633,
-0.000873934,
-0.0095424308,
-0.0372021571,
-0.0188615751,
0.0420693643,
-0.0465255529,
0.0639501587,
0.0342273861,
0.0624059886,
-0.0233622678,
-0.0376251638,
0.0064539285,
-0.0260228179,
-0.0038579972,
0.0268228408,
0.0511247925,
-0.0078891246,
0.0163707305,
-0.0326761678,
0.0256527606,
-0.0716236308,
-0.0213735476,
0.0069099627,
0.0874342099,
0.0109584136,
-0.0607751459,
0.0048492672,
-0.0610550009,
-0.0244932082,
0.075861007,
-0.0003305102,
-0.0177521575,
-0.0006920014,
-0.0094048893,
-0.000934634,
0.0390906073,
-0.0702596307,
0.0034678199,
0.0211253762,
0.0169397704,
-0.1229243428,
-0.0344409309,
0.0276916027,
-0.006368564,
0.0105453115,
0.0133698191,
0.0532486178,
-0.0354707353,
-0.0373840779,
0.0197577663,
-0.0472406633,
-0.0410618149,
-0.0350757539,
-0.0784947574,
0.0349845812,
-0.0115708765,
-0.0313016884,
-0.0134176137,
-0.0105502252,
-0.0869685039,
0.0185448844,
-0.0148096038,
0.0180124268,
0.0221015755,
0.0022726136,
-0.0129351327,
0.0959936231,
-0.0198551081,
-0.0846755132,
0.0143813249,
-0.0251075737,
-0.0075531541,
0.0137148937,
0.072771959,
-0.0646117032,
0.0301156305,
-0.0228324663,
0.0193488393,
-0.0642556548,
-0.0294340421,
0.0035670006,
0.0332205966,
0.0216855761,
0.0078529269,
-0.0449711643,
-0.0512050949,
-0.0166886766,
-0.028762199,
-0.0227475502,
0.0128447879,
0.0098416721,
0.0463704877,
-0.0012733077,
-0.0103639178,
0.0000181781,
0.04540921,
0.0528042689,
-0.0066017904,
-0.0433187857,
0.0357483178,
0.0099044777,
0.0634102821,
0.0099444799,
0.0116997529,
0.0107023921,
-0.0546938106,
0.038362056,
-0.0449892879,
0.0483944528,
0.00884018,
-0.05768032,
-0.03546248,
0.0252552275,
-0.0970278531,
-0.0963459164,
0.0320073925,
0.0126238829,
0.0557099767,
-0.0273670144,
0.0485671274,
-0.0376114361,
-0.0174723845,
0.0163541604,
0.011546432,
-0.005592572,
-0.006615988,
0.0127932057,
0.046495039,
-0.0265517756,
0.0323418006,
0.0479858145,
0.0108852601,
0.0304592606,
0.0019747471,
-0.0030026934,
-0.0240326691,
0.0175356679,
0.00614424,
0.0336779132,
-0.0251129065,
0.0495544039,
-0.0671401843,
-0.0428658575,
0.0091103902,
0.0004526218,
-0.0188078452,
-0.0084492061,
0.0233736075,
0.0560491793,
0.0034427508,
0.0016768388,
-0.0295243878,
0.0220408868,
-0.0505485013,
-0.0118037462,
-0.00799945,
-5.979862455e-33,
-0.0334988907,
-0.0102900947,
0.0045279516,
0.0296946317,
-0.0263634138,
-0.0130123263,
-0.0099894339,
0.023459008,
-0.0550456829,
0.0458508953,
-0.0316253901,
0.0213244744,
-0.0149801318,
-0.0212882031,
0.0098644719,
0.0104452688,
0.0132304234,
-0.018256411,
-0.0048784646,
0.0350768976,
0.0783553272,
0.0164081864,
0.0332467258,
-0.0644338876,
0.0272392295,
-0.0251712464,
0.0613636188,
0.0038192747,
0.0331697203,
0.0410615467,
-0.0537017994,
0.0304307546,
0.040185526,
-0.0054055816,
0.0116049796,
0.0082178945,
-0.076810576,
-0.0033269394,
0.0136714745,
-0.0286910664,
0.0112935565,
-0.0483487472,
0.0174992122,
-0.0076200543,
0.0191718321,
-0.0416716337,
0.0394456834,
-0.0020790303,
-0.037948627,
0.0128347762,
-0.0583841652,
0.0152789215,
0.0282864403,
0.0156913735,
-0.006523862,
-0.0769678727,
0.0022481228,
-0.0176077746,
-0.0731588081,
0.0241120681,
-0.0302581992,
0.0046311971,
0.0296417549,
0.0055658119,
0.0093577662,
0.0810956731,
0.0261577927,
0.0295753665,
-0.0331164747,
-0.0234111808,
0.0000028325,
0.070975557,
-0.0054458259,
0.0338186882,
0.027405126,
-0.033342801,
-0.0582757294,
-0.0174756572,
-0.0137891928,
0.0305709615,
0.0093588736,
0.0100444164,
-0.0459920503,
-0.0154393809,
-0.0581294373,
-0.0201311242,
-0.0311559755,
-0.0027990027,
0.0050216755,
-0.0214754213,
-0.0135809109,
-0.0305646677,
0.0103764506,
-0.0669324398,
-0.0226953346,
0.0705723688,
-0.0238793958,
0.0143636512,
-0.0198739748,
0.0059707458,
-0.0888993219,
-0.0330235362,
-0.0326729901,
-0.0010063582,
-0.0082552955,
0.0458169542,
0.0275794752,
-0.0096166013,
-0.0130507983,
-0.0227464736,
-0.0280820969,
-0.049645748,
-0.014472466,
-0.033154007,
0.0239825957,
0.0469790585,
0.0117062731,
0.012376545,
0.0524591655,
-0.0208774414,
-0.023878688,
0.0095442189,
-0.0051091709,
-0.0237004608,
-0.0199905131,
-0.0112699969,
-0.0409020707,
0.045541089,
0.0436855368,
-0.0143059297,
-0.0003697248,
-0.0181903299,
2.479e-7,
0.0114689628,
0.0719588548,
-0.0125248712,
0.0300733875,
0.0318550132,
0.0216562413,
-0.0005060232,
0.0306846257,
-0.0113566257,
-0.0857277215,
-0.0017657218,
0.0850922167,
-0.0180048682,
0.0292780753,
-0.0785484314,
-0.0369103588,
-0.0329947695,
-0.0468721874,
-0.0114473226,
-0.0382902436,
-0.010156448,
0.0544764847,
0.0372658521,
-0.0166287087,
-0.0082760546,
-0.0701524764,
0.0567385107,
-0.029742334,
0.0183199756,
0.0035091208,
0.0049984227,
0.0023882685,
-0.0116775734,
0.0517862216,
0.0266116671,
0.0315979645,
0.0087792603,
0.0246155374,
-0.0227522235,
0.0326426104,
-0.0351377577,
-0.0679303855,
0.0281546675,
-0.049681522,
0.0632743537,
-0.0270321388,
-0.0177303907,
0.0371087641,
-0.0120040523,
-0.0138522666,
-0.0250701271,
-0.0046372926,
0.0264236424,
-0.0051119723,
-0.0197338145,
0.0047962125,
0.0367506593,
-0.0464572385,
-0.0094328746,
0.0279782861,
-0.0325648747,
-0.0720390975,
0.0046959538,
-0.047297582,
0.0279016718,
-0.0260153208,
0.0247995127,
1.743730501e-34,
0.0040744958,
0.004687692,
-0.0042910776,
0.0360494703,
0.0345834829,
-0.0495812595,
-0.0176779255,
-0.0075544994,
0.0265807584,
-0.0905777439,
0.0165265389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15027v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15027v1 | Improving Neural Ranking Models with Traditional IR Methods | 2023-08-29T05:18:47 | 2023-08-29T05:18:47 | Anik Saha, Oktie Hassanzadeh, Alex Gittens, Jian Ni, Kavitha Srinivas, Bulent Yener | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Neural ranking methods based on large transformer models have recently gained
significant attention in the information retrieval community, and have been
adopted by major commercial solutions. Nevertheless, they are computationally
expensive to create, and require a great deal of labeled data for specialized
corpora. In this paper, we explore a low resource alternative which is a
bag-of-embedding model for document retrieval and find that it is competitive
with large transformer models fine tuned on information retrieval tasks. Our
results show that a simple combination of TF-IDF, a traditional keyword
matching method, with a shallow embedding model provides a low cost path to
compete well with the performance of complex neural ranking models on 3
datasets. Furthermore, adding TF-IDF measures improves the performance of
large-scale fine tuned models on these tasks. | [
0.0632064193,
0.0440247282,
0.0201945119,
0.0267210212,
0.0244195499,
-0.0006583794,
-0.0040588696,
-0.0021446301,
0.026547797,
-0.0505622029,
-0.0447623171,
-0.0089645004,
-0.0260387864,
-0.0050829332,
-0.0024742803,
0.0182801615,
0.0324117094,
0.0048092664,
-0.026581347,
0.0080353525,
-0.0037663626,
0.0172859263,
0.0309392549,
0.0196114853,
0.0508266501,
0.0195042547,
-0.011589841,
0.0167261995,
-0.0004646292,
0.0071083973,
0.0346011557,
0.0178956836,
0.0159131233,
0.0399709269,
0.0000017369,
-0.0223349463,
-0.0524476245,
0.0096491305,
0.0185910407,
0.014502218,
0.0216406137,
0.0016598185,
0.0292503852,
0.0087177157,
-0.0254396498,
-0.0236402843,
0.0177325178,
0.0839303285,
0.0204491932,
0.0405974574,
0.0006531909,
-0.0376818404,
0.0528732985,
-0.0497170165,
-0.0282961987,
-0.0474943593,
0.0148416022,
-0.014042004,
0.0114291031,
0.0676174983,
-0.0235118046,
0.0012643168,
-0.0092874262,
-0.0146240918,
0.0798319727,
0.0075836228,
-0.0884935483,
0.0429339707,
0.0179223847,
0.0763341486,
-0.0624626093,
-0.0248267855,
-0.0273495838,
0.0345782377,
-0.0200535469,
0.0285577308,
-0.0433573648,
-0.0117677227,
0.0050271037,
-0.0061860592,
-0.0047300169,
0.0276305024,
0.0106437877,
0.0332122259,
-0.0391619876,
0.0148958676,
0.019697912,
-0.0537058599,
-0.0004838254,
-0.0160803273,
-0.0690879896,
-0.0074822726,
0.0254503377,
-0.0101957545,
0.0027942704,
-0.0278011765,
0.0005412614,
-0.0047658901,
0.0226494633,
-0.0491133071,
-0.0100283278,
0.0245614313,
0.0166389085,
0.0393879078,
-0.0485243611,
0.0573714823,
-0.0369186997,
0.0097339358,
-0.0615028515,
-0.0242734961,
-0.0357360244,
-0.0252730418,
-0.0215760116,
0.0506723151,
-0.0094055152,
-0.043449644,
-0.0434970483,
0.0104288561,
-0.0023235409,
-0.0124836639,
0.0396014005,
0.0259105191,
-0.0400243364,
0.0222698934,
-0.0177532285,
0.0177463237,
-0.0005170525,
-0.0098141795,
-0.052312348,
0.0269409362,
0.0135506019,
0.0105147352,
0.0044918559,
-0.0308120549,
0.0389327966,
-0.0071320743,
-0.0318236798,
-0.0248578899,
0.0136697451,
0.0268293433,
0.0347499251,
-0.0154363438,
0.0213618651,
-0.051489871,
0.002318426,
0.010637641,
0.0283070598,
-0.0088337474,
0.0049443766,
0.0226946641,
-0.0549849272,
0.0683493838,
0.0329869837,
-0.0435173512,
0.0196631644,
0.0087920604,
0.0039570006,
0.0042124367,
-0.0125157489,
0.0302710589,
0.0516643077,
-0.0145646073,
-0.0062699169,
-0.0086507816,
-0.015548002,
-0.0334299356,
-0.010649723,
0.0044525312,
-0.0436026938,
0.0391273126,
0.0367394872,
0.035352312,
-0.0340384021,
-0.0287229214,
0.0249078199,
0.0766857192,
0.0709847659,
0.032545995,
-0.0130007593,
0.0201042015,
-0.0275061298,
0.003080924,
0.0236334,
0.0390184633,
-0.0087029766,
-0.0158137698,
0.0280853752,
0.0386944227,
-0.0383217447,
-0.0280998219,
0.0225768816,
0.0287784226,
-0.0126848575,
0.0071277651,
0.0218531378,
-0.0182902217,
0.0121596744,
0.037947882,
0.0152437715,
-0.0251254886,
-0.0184661392,
-0.0379392169,
-0.0268434398,
0.0582688898,
0.0665468872,
-0.0212216433,
-0.0004807802,
0.0002821503,
-0.0006072157,
-0.0040856116,
0.0259348694,
-0.0250311848,
-0.0218944028,
-0.0621349402,
-0.0225506648,
0.0027741904,
-0.0030215573,
0.0097438861,
0.0192842763,
0.0307411049,
0.0346590802,
-0.0310351402,
-0.028452741,
0.0248097703,
-0.0220018066,
-0.0366929062,
0.0391258933,
-0.003763387,
0.0215382334,
-0.0135277882,
-0.0187943652,
0.0174072292,
0.0546623431,
-0.0243442245,
-0.0400596745,
-0.0525216721,
0.0250352193,
0.0241898615,
0.0254794694,
-0.021948548,
0.0340903997,
0.1020142809,
-0.0268729851,
-0.0127510214,
-0.0222060941,
0.0029761831,
0.0350936837,
-0.040066693,
0.0222142842,
-0.0308132824,
0.0017636806,
-0.0811181366,
0.0227964092,
0.0038482859,
0.079306148,
-0.0251442567,
-0.0223399103,
0.0090730777,
-0.0343951583,
-0.0879005045,
0.0534894131,
-0.0006508439,
0.0271118656,
0.028355075,
0.0271476991,
0.0185797866,
-0.024822263,
-0.1252405941,
0.0289665181,
0.0113881715,
-0.0411439613,
-0.0255284254,
-0.0074265581,
0.0278274287,
-0.0132541982,
-0.0497648865,
-0.0214857794,
-0.0158988684,
0.0065853992,
0.0101529462,
-0.0290868599,
-0.0088894963,
-0.0414839648,
-0.0745369345,
-0.0013553773,
0.0747907385,
-0.0241427515,
-0.0250343438,
0.0044846395,
0.0110915927,
-0.0311160795,
0.0394403487,
-0.0334116779,
0.0042145881,
-0.0077992082,
-0.0133510437,
0.0026078047,
0.0769496337,
0.0552244,
-0.0083195139,
0.0263466928,
0.0186210759,
-0.0951292515,
0.0063807345,
-0.0168601144,
-0.0038423911,
0.0103346072,
-0.0041437591,
-0.0087330965,
-0.0004980611,
-0.0378663614,
-0.0194175392,
-0.0046184855,
0.0132069997,
0.0098390989,
0.0309553239,
-0.0596551187,
0.0049418979,
0.0301388316,
0.0194968097,
-0.0241385531,
-0.0128649194,
0.0467966236,
-0.0177035332,
0.0172194187,
-0.0580508485,
-0.0153121864,
-0.0764895752,
0.0173562299,
-0.0102213677,
0.0234195869,
-0.0505553409,
0.026585402,
-0.0159972887,
0.0392534845,
-0.0012636388,
-0.0738745853,
0.0414268263,
0.0356813073,
0.0370711647,
-0.017699603,
-0.0775026679,
-0.0305855554,
-0.0688684955,
0.0095163723,
0.0105289156,
0.0526407175,
-0.0258246791,
-0.0200521648,
0.0579933673,
0.0308655929,
0.0413595475,
-0.0301552992,
-0.0440194421,
0.0013794166,
0.0521244891,
0.0588859431,
-0.0358710885,
0.0256536324,
0.0466649868,
0.0086797941,
0.0317313597,
0.0551570766,
-0.0063849208,
-0.044070974,
-0.0082667656,
0.0768554285,
-0.0323596485,
-0.0224785507,
-0.0409205407,
-0.0348275118,
0.0214716308,
-0.0144887557,
0.0932851136,
0.0422320366,
-0.0887722,
-0.0069968444,
-0.0170062184,
0.0162187871,
0.0368167795,
0.061235711,
-0.0239479411,
0.0148065547,
0.0261914227,
0.0169899333,
-0.0097021349,
-0.0235056486,
0.0055246581,
-0.1313400716,
0.0473886468,
-0.0100681502,
0.067555137,
0.0014113211,
-0.0239671003,
-0.0052972059,
-0.0127112893,
-0.0231428184,
0.001001441,
-0.0179904476,
-0.0341812484,
0.0105029196,
0.043233458,
-0.0320540704,
0.0198359042,
-0.0728331059,
-0.0009702341,
-0.0084830867,
0.0424135178,
-0.0397773795,
-0.0360466987,
-0.0029219659,
0.0253274832,
-0.0453867652,
0.0039475639,
-0.0020221318,
-0.0414022431,
-0.0165236872,
-0.0431218892,
-0.0366304256,
-0.0083625522,
0.0510722995,
-0.0322631635,
0.0130696334,
-0.0388413295,
0.0412984602,
-0.0278987419,
-0.0342710875,
-0.0512981229,
0.0410266668,
-0.040891096,
-0.0297708046,
0.0305263884,
-0.0116120968,
0.0190513153,
0.0123876268,
-0.0630784407,
0.0250098612,
0.014432515,
-0.0214656815,
-0.0718949363,
-0.0118102944,
-0.007209315,
0.0268754456,
0.0135677969,
0.0393924341,
-0.0083175572,
-0.02536867,
-0.0596212149,
0.0421717167,
0.0071140938,
0.0108529422,
-0.0332670324,
0.0389046632,
0.0872519016,
-0.0343863443,
-0.0454108119,
-0.0434275977,
0.0039467299,
-0.0124058332,
-0.0195220299,
0.0525401868,
0.0113224825,
0.0180595387,
-0.0283466429,
-0.0816610903,
0.0429303125,
0.0310334116,
-0.018896183,
0.002533572,
0.004201584,
-0.0449849069,
-0.0276047848,
0.0130892713,
-0.0643799901,
0.0466428734,
-0.0273500588,
0.0584957041,
-0.0297281668,
-0.0274333619,
0.0273641162,
0.0132065658,
0.0502380878,
0.010125217,
0.0212122761,
-0.0374446623,
0.0326890238,
-0.0111438083,
-0.0447004512,
-0.0302314181,
-0.022532478,
0.0859779492,
0.0317485295,
-0.0280205347,
0.0504496321,
0.038462054,
0.0462286174,
-0.01683967,
-0.0105005251,
-0.0083745485,
-0.0194497015,
-0.0316609479,
0.0334833562,
-0.0549230985,
-0.0318074375,
0.0253604371,
0.0330776237,
-0.0297038928,
-0.0026914945,
0.0181711782,
-0.0046056127,
-0.0508743972,
0.0755679235,
-0.0924466401,
-0.0370197557,
-0.0341551118,
-0.0161604825,
0.0691894144,
-0.0401028842,
-0.0161290802,
0.0129108941,
-0.0380269364,
-0.0106085716,
-0.048588641,
0.0193612743,
0.0216873121,
0.0099873198,
0.0620747879,
-0.0057046441,
0.0458681993,
0.0696627349,
0.0291398186,
-0.0147988703,
-0.0110126948,
-0.0709829926,
-0.0023160242,
0.0008627976,
0.045157589,
0.0483514369,
-0.0271929316,
-0.0204936601,
-0.0098058283,
0.0052659689,
0.0414352417,
-0.0233107973,
-0.024905026,
-0.0278342441,
0.040475715,
0.0729211643,
0.0323690474,
0.0214077346,
-0.0461755693,
-0.0357022583,
-0.0620103255,
-0.0513037741,
-0.0355613194,
-6.208260273e-33,
0.0062336447,
-0.0179223325,
-0.011794297,
-0.0009258917,
0.0040390347,
0.0459786206,
0.0365127213,
-0.0307823773,
-0.0507703386,
-0.0005449773,
-0.0478373244,
0.0072596972,
0.0067511117,
0.0183690507,
0.0243975148,
0.0294307116,
0.0256595444,
0.0131399389,
-0.0051134983,
-0.0104037076,
0.0166397393,
0.059297163,
0.0165094547,
-0.0605506822,
-0.0048541455,
-0.0211050306,
0.0163382273,
0.0168521181,
0.0184607524,
0.0737626255,
-0.0197407473,
0.018053811,
0.0444239452,
-0.0638069361,
0.0620119832,
0.0258897748,
-0.0591166541,
0.0134056294,
-0.0226521734,
-0.0107219499,
0.0137880268,
0.0170901548,
0.0126959383,
-0.0180475637,
-0.0102482848,
-0.0008859391,
0.032746885,
0.0173942894,
-0.0598965622,
-0.0868314058,
-0.0198802743,
0.0069368384,
0.0267745219,
-0.0152783245,
0.0204170607,
0.0436245501,
-0.017067926,
0.0878233984,
-0.0433586985,
-0.0112717999,
-0.0759362802,
0.0594635308,
-0.0018432949,
-0.0072036968,
-0.0224333648,
0.0679201633,
-0.0064564659,
-0.0026957793,
0.0223305095,
-0.0403005406,
0.0282735415,
0.014501526,
0.074276045,
0.0272946618,
0.0642784983,
0.0120779565,
-0.0614148118,
0.0478413478,
0.0012410955,
0.0485313646,
0.0204189215,
0.0428511128,
-0.0668486655,
-0.0074460688,
-0.0113625107,
-0.0024546161,
-0.0554089174,
-0.0096024666,
0.0232799929,
0.0373231247,
-0.0552641749,
0.0218400918,
0.0310097802,
-0.0492852516,
0.0038700332,
0.043325197,
0.0038025528,
0.0250969809,
0.0093683107,
0.0357869193,
-0.0363493636,
-0.0080946134,
-0.0016299032,
-0.0304958504,
-0.0138984825,
-0.008247803,
0.0585429259,
0.0047396403,
-0.0375266708,
-0.0124522904,
-0.0029302235,
-0.0529492162,
-0.0492546521,
0.0728928894,
-0.0175976921,
0.029608693,
-0.0052145873,
0.0337193795,
0.0382075645,
0.0470365584,
0.0007879226,
-0.0408505797,
0.0308913887,
0.0023707857,
0.0210919082,
0.0207847506,
-0.0314437635,
0.0651615337,
-0.0069137807,
-0.0716362596,
-0.0062604942,
0.0176130999,
2.685e-7,
0.0297142081,
0.0376262739,
-0.0032054372,
-0.0133902933,
-0.0024691334,
0.0004133487,
0.0283875186,
0.0551729761,
0.0199036673,
0.0356811173,
0.0048795911,
-0.0058633946,
0.0349456966,
-0.0062310258,
-0.0794811919,
-0.0952328518,
-0.082488358,
-0.0374077372,
-0.0255772192,
-0.0761028156,
0.0360856615,
0.1255869716,
-0.0043445677,
-0.0103043271,
-0.0237799957,
-0.0790771693,
0.0656451359,
-0.0143351965,
0.0037101491,
-0.0045647235,
0.057825923,
0.0280718524,
-0.0144427801,
-0.0059301481,
-0.0143342419,
0.0596836396,
0.0858004093,
0.0285918694,
-0.045499675,
-0.0215689968,
-0.0126864119,
0.0035683343,
-0.0045246235,
-0.051129654,
0.0703301951,
-0.060108576,
-0.0020553633,
0.0289097968,
-0.0250516869,
0.0077320426,
0.0342633203,
-0.0561414771,
-0.0228832178,
0.0193621386,
0.0284385383,
-0.0039008567,
0.013877131,
-0.0761091337,
0.0144389952,
0.0134552829,
-0.027319001,
0.016415108,
-0.0317354612,
-0.0423497818,
0.0204123594,
0.0161930285,
0.0174651481,
2.362152684e-34,
0.0455355123,
0.0306322798,
0.0236091129,
-0.0200195443,
0.009552191,
0.0113396319,
-0.0306217205,
0.016503036,
0.0138893751,
-0.084400557,
0.0049636508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15022v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15022v2 | Recursively Summarizing Enables Long-Term Dialogue Memory in Large Language Models | 2023-08-29T04:59:53 | 2024-02-19T02:39:58 | Qingyue Wang, Liang Ding, Yanan Cao, Zhiliang Tian, Shi Wang, Dacheng Tao, Li Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently, large language models (LLMs), such as GPT-4, stand out remarkable
conversational abilities, enabling them to engage in dynamic and contextually
relevant dialogues across a wide range of topics. However, given a long
conversation, these chatbots fail to recall past information and tend to
generate inconsistent responses. To address this, we propose to recursively
generate summaries/ memory using large language models (LLMs) to enhance
long-term memory ability. Specifically, our method first stimulates LLMs to
memorize small dialogue contexts and then recursively produce new memory using
previous memory and following contexts. Finally, the chatbot can easily
generate a highly consistent response with the help of the latest memory. We
evaluate our method on both open and closed LLMs, and the experiments on the
widely-used public dataset show that our method can generate more consistent
responses in a long-context conversation. Also, we show that our strategy could
nicely complement both long-context (e.g., 8K and 16K) and retrieval-enhanced
LLMs, bringing further long-term dialogue performance. Notably, our method is a
potential solution to enable the LLM to model the extremely long context. The
code and scripts will be released later. | [
0.0389903896,
0.0504633226,
-0.0174878668,
0.012252273,
-0.0191724841,
-0.0029242684,
-0.0286056884,
-0.0062759975,
0.0339205265,
-0.0241545923,
-0.001711858,
-0.0505011939,
0.0228781905,
0.0516964421,
0.0124758044,
-0.0705570355,
0.0331960805,
-0.0397165082,
0.0000219119,
-0.0240772273,
0.0054699089,
0.0004919634,
0.0098767197,
0.0311996359,
0.0045202966,
-0.0192101263,
-0.0464216731,
-0.0045511117,
-0.0056875604,
-0.032030303,
0.0023343733,
0.0174897444,
0.0137602659,
0.032549154,
0.0000019701,
-0.0361251011,
-0.0174277779,
-0.0486368351,
-0.016564833,
0.0043852436,
0.0349110998,
0.001723017,
-0.0095287161,
0.0373446941,
-0.043153733,
-0.0150878131,
0.0419474468,
0.0241574924,
0.0800457224,
0.0752216503,
0.0046072323,
-0.0209534634,
0.0432647578,
-0.0320401788,
0.0302323084,
-0.0715962425,
-0.0025871939,
0.02632978,
0.0251726899,
0.0223179255,
-0.0079869917,
0.0185217001,
0.043676123,
-0.0252853911,
-0.0044538635,
0.0457364134,
-0.0313396677,
0.0072472487,
-0.0198339354,
0.0645116568,
0.0394337922,
-0.0198412407,
0.0042003379,
0.0325838886,
0.0199048929,
-0.0321750231,
-0.083771348,
0.0410852917,
-0.0080496082,
0.0039613633,
-0.0270791054,
-0.0064546769,
0.0033194143,
0.021414049,
-0.0489407256,
-0.0003344754,
0.0119867204,
-0.0156891085,
-0.034646932,
-0.0172198582,
0.0059474516,
-0.0842415541,
-0.0047803959,
0.0812553838,
-0.02735723,
0.0323207006,
-0.0230305623,
0.0077058254,
0.0290461406,
-0.0248300135,
-0.019681612,
0.0381837264,
-0.0033200884,
0.0574234053,
-0.0244292058,
0.0603074655,
-0.004467248,
-0.0119662173,
-0.0197809897,
-0.0233053826,
-0.058764901,
-0.0148518495,
-0.04891821,
0.0379196927,
-0.0125480723,
-0.0306725465,
-0.0187155008,
0.0721623376,
0.0182021931,
0.0144793838,
-0.0136951208,
0.0033897725,
-0.0350887477,
0.0108528016,
-0.0224426817,
0.0267531388,
-0.0450892299,
-0.0471081398,
0.0484468006,
-0.0726238936,
-0.0441565439,
0.0176132247,
-0.0091400268,
-0.0112856096,
-0.0173114575,
0.0774347335,
-0.0107207429,
-0.0273326412,
-0.0048380275,
-0.0357329212,
-0.0508768968,
-0.0830240622,
0.0151227452,
-0.0529363491,
0.0222553778,
-0.0110187009,
-0.0197669603,
-0.016626915,
0.0087769348,
0.0248959232,
-0.0155971125,
0.032838475,
0.0081124045,
-0.0008778797,
0.0222304668,
0.0147569273,
0.0119928559,
0.0442825705,
0.0335013978,
0.0292785391,
0.0273783598,
-0.0024402628,
0.0172107369,
0.0118401898,
0.023940172,
0.0051733912,
-0.0047756694,
0.0035147867,
0.0162181146,
0.0123618441,
0.0122891655,
0.0542898849,
-0.0309185758,
-0.0228588413,
0.0569834672,
0.0408411175,
-0.0154260481,
0.0184123926,
0.0148277003,
0.0114611369,
0.0189854149,
0.0335201211,
-0.0559320115,
0.0525614992,
-0.0265398044,
0.0364166014,
0.0628904477,
0.0166722033,
-0.0374997556,
-0.0257519651,
0.0232363492,
-0.0114924116,
0.0488538668,
0.0204420071,
0.0319721587,
0.0109865284,
-0.0509548225,
0.0514083579,
0.0160073526,
-0.0599302538,
-0.0498769768,
-0.0576209687,
0.0325033702,
0.078631781,
0.0487804189,
-0.0178414956,
-0.0423859917,
-0.0019329389,
-0.011203547,
0.0405922905,
0.0358832367,
0.0063476535,
0.015184816,
-0.0307332333,
0.0027364849,
-0.0230776612,
-0.002864816,
0.0351833031,
0.0562166162,
0.0009582768,
0.0183616634,
0.0229922999,
0.0281046387,
0.0015847395,
-0.0378488749,
-0.0099151405,
-0.0154751437,
-0.032902997,
0.0416203812,
0.0165900979,
0.004716632,
0.009373934,
0.0282897577,
-0.0208023489,
-0.0259617381,
0.0170009527,
-0.097712636,
-0.0381085612,
0.0504430756,
0.0149770714,
0.0021216648,
0.0235963017,
-0.0134473555,
-0.0565126687,
0.0486681573,
-0.0716650188,
0.0703637898,
-0.0415079445,
0.0270486251,
-0.0000765657,
0.0173677728,
-0.0199353062,
0.0523753092,
-0.0000906318,
-0.0220067259,
0.0411582924,
0.0544118173,
-0.018402949,
-0.0512044318,
0.0010403909,
0.0623284169,
0.0070077474,
0.0171208046,
0.042196203,
0.0099331141,
-0.0634419769,
-0.0544299558,
-0.1480429024,
0.009631441,
-0.0073575405,
-0.0361433588,
0.006454106,
0.0248284247,
-0.0115802679,
-0.0099631231,
-0.0618312806,
0.0157895628,
0.0410462804,
0.0299381148,
0.0097983032,
0.0083372165,
-0.0259959903,
-0.0528505407,
-0.0055236476,
0.011627065,
0.0291881375,
-0.0025305063,
-0.0148914848,
-0.036695756,
0.0508045629,
-0.0532806627,
0.0292029437,
-0.0361438431,
-0.0435127281,
0.0194320232,
-0.0406861119,
0.0657514781,
0.0770276263,
0.0518087037,
0.0148717696,
0.029821666,
-0.0350754932,
-0.0502557904,
0.028626116,
-0.0221912824,
-0.0634548664,
-0.0021819533,
-0.012424604,
-0.0041795373,
0.0439405814,
0.0105576422,
0.02446975,
-0.0425685123,
0.0203213859,
0.0338847972,
-0.0095390035,
-0.0076100151,
0.0075001307,
-0.055455938,
0.0383224376,
-0.0193051156,
-0.0680127293,
0.0621147677,
-0.033539407,
-0.0070517538,
-0.0424140356,
-0.0110836569,
-0.040019948,
0.0871652067,
0.0059186327,
0.0115332864,
-0.0124435984,
-0.0220234413,
-0.0310666468,
-0.0175316222,
-0.0065963082,
-0.0510404855,
0.0615890622,
-0.0341587998,
0.0133645684,
-0.0003730489,
-0.0316383913,
-0.0610877164,
-0.0084909564,
-0.0336364843,
0.0152863171,
0.0153517127,
-0.0172587484,
-0.0343026444,
0.0057031778,
0.0584732145,
0.0567689613,
-0.0275557954,
-0.0057437862,
-0.0174286775,
0.006323053,
0.042959284,
0.006362326,
0.0088049462,
-0.0333718397,
0.0488657914,
0.0568855144,
0.0492553972,
0.002659698,
-0.0305862725,
-0.0200535003,
-0.0090979934,
0.0082190065,
0.0019699233,
0.0129339667,
0.0565873086,
-0.0620936304,
-0.0281734597,
0.1034519151,
0.0003024128,
-0.054686904,
-0.0188436285,
-0.0231551751,
0.0634578839,
0.012561555,
0.0250464715,
-0.0673919469,
-0.0330381356,
0.0320441686,
-0.0094760545,
-0.0023269216,
-0.024672905,
-0.030152496,
-0.1248150393,
0.0064178496,
0.0274309777,
-0.0663497746,
-0.0234185569,
-0.0216287002,
-0.0111376317,
0.0237440746,
0.0349729471,
0.0499020368,
-0.0036179824,
-0.0173958689,
-0.0230914596,
-0.0164042786,
0.0352322087,
0.043750491,
0.013280659,
0.0632680655,
0.0635609329,
0.033790648,
0.025422642,
0.0228623115,
0.0422970802,
-0.0093944333,
-0.0062883571,
0.0177413989,
0.0657591373,
-0.0159249138,
-0.0151892994,
-0.0146792876,
0.0175647326,
-0.0149381394,
-0.0107365595,
0.0291142762,
0.0089423982,
-0.0294276811,
-0.0072553852,
-0.0177068729,
0.0548802502,
-0.0177994557,
0.0665228814,
0.0415706895,
-0.0218428522,
-0.0603006966,
-0.0286581274,
-0.0036339094,
-0.0216625761,
-0.0057208473,
-0.0185348075,
0.0099037066,
0.0160567518,
-0.0881676152,
-0.0621226579,
0.0110953571,
-0.0009971131,
-0.0155093363,
-0.0007937643,
-0.0048341085,
0.026709605,
-0.0298175495,
-0.0061154226,
-0.0642781258,
-0.0012354616,
-0.052587077,
-0.0301138125,
0.0471630581,
-0.0441919863,
0.0079990299,
0.049693875,
-0.0979600176,
-0.0487365872,
-0.0146642318,
0.039609395,
0.0286739897,
0.0661765635,
0.0173780099,
0.0133184688,
0.0148902871,
-0.006872152,
-0.0297986902,
0.0296354871,
0.0353350416,
0.0916290507,
0.0092796413,
0.0284251012,
-0.0657353178,
0.0094864061,
-0.022884151,
0.0330226272,
-0.0324146301,
-0.0591698661,
0.0108106984,
0.0085711591,
-0.0150483064,
0.0225760955,
0.0097021945,
0.0261022542,
0.0243892726,
-0.0356352553,
0.0031343806,
-0.0380156338,
0.0214815326,
-0.0235553011,
-0.0247934479,
0.0307210479,
-0.0190815311,
-0.006513135,
0.0274486877,
-0.0008937612,
-0.0321509354,
-0.0192757193,
-0.051620461,
0.0076406994,
0.0028598777,
-0.0485890768,
-0.0056574773,
-0.0234107822,
0.0324538499,
-0.0002008572,
0.0843928307,
0.0125839785,
-0.0487104356,
-0.0080010267,
0.0250899326,
-0.1169844046,
-0.0631235987,
0.0220586285,
0.0357556567,
0.0470974185,
0.0013779728,
0.0509030521,
-0.0310918689,
0.0236695688,
-0.0427752696,
0.0273235347,
0.0243814234,
-0.0371747278,
-0.0136807626,
0.0385784358,
-0.0121127414,
0.0087987687,
0.0713224784,
-0.0013190145,
0.0182887409,
0.0249954965,
0.0228021275,
-0.0274591427,
-0.0390952304,
0.016586246,
0.0300607514,
0.0096714823,
-0.0206940714,
-0.0194032341,
-0.0511574112,
0.0019356055,
-0.0094121872,
0.0067654359,
-0.0284464154,
0.0437261313,
0.0550837032,
-0.0092919273,
-0.0106509635,
-0.0353473686,
0.0370963626,
-0.009048692,
-0.0052680522,
-0.0181106925,
-6.187243903e-33,
-0.037440829,
-0.0288077611,
0.0241236333,
0.0186838824,
-0.0679587498,
-0.0068182521,
-0.0898146182,
-0.011531407,
-0.0172637645,
-0.0293763727,
-0.0270351954,
0.044479534,
0.0116123743,
0.0441161394,
0.0019214195,
-0.0302912779,
0.0439161062,
0.0133255096,
-0.0250598937,
0.092054978,
0.0487777479,
0.0206267796,
-0.0050149537,
-0.0387545824,
0.0120828468,
-0.0154352821,
0.0197811853,
0.0126090329,
0.0148905898,
0.0541796945,
-0.032908801,
0.0255499128,
0.0178162828,
-0.0365238599,
-0.0467090495,
0.0433645882,
-0.0476612225,
0.0018564775,
0.0190036818,
-0.0232197046,
-0.0370054953,
-0.0449206308,
0.0256749466,
-0.0391290672,
0.0266438983,
-0.0497268029,
0.0055332123,
-0.0472136028,
-0.0548986197,
-0.0011910681,
-0.040259786,
0.0091521703,
-0.0098330528,
-0.0502678007,
-0.0090341959,
0.0188670196,
0.0239411257,
0.035391029,
-0.0057146316,
0.0277005173,
0.0033470122,
0.0246296562,
0.0236590616,
0.0235149376,
0.0461004265,
0.0808813274,
0.0326680131,
0.0204299018,
-0.0395631045,
-0.0437360406,
0.0030269797,
0.0053849528,
0.0155159943,
0.0173993558,
0.0278078746,
0.0028940705,
-0.025771698,
-0.0132651748,
0.0341493115,
0.0569122359,
0.0501999222,
0.0138443355,
-0.0259953812,
-0.0126294587,
-0.0228924789,
0.0553601608,
-0.021823816,
-0.0365223847,
0.0248981453,
0.0280367415,
-0.0010033617,
-0.0656080991,
0.039504312,
-0.0466374718,
0.0273326747,
0.0571042597,
-0.0357822739,
0.0000476243,
-0.0164773017,
0.0174511969,
-0.0067341272,
0.0228028726,
0.0402243659,
0.0105130384,
-0.0049454179,
0.0379911102,
-0.0022047793,
0.005778031,
-0.0740797967,
0.0008761814,
-0.0455269925,
0.0455583744,
-0.0404371135,
0.0128466152,
0.004914328,
0.0202677287,
-0.0021186057,
0.0737024024,
0.0013552945,
-0.0155065553,
-0.0497124083,
-0.0274681449,
0.0007634565,
-0.0030283886,
-0.0416531712,
0.0087756412,
-0.0383587331,
0.0406005234,
0.0149834631,
-0.0478252843,
-0.0031379433,
-0.0217871573,
2.616e-7,
-0.0306314435,
0.0317857414,
0.0469631068,
0.0277122501,
0.0311228,
0.0231131874,
-0.0001456009,
0.0192639232,
0.03242708,
-0.0458013602,
-0.025392089,
0.0742444694,
0.0693861395,
0.005495613,
-0.0858567581,
-0.0147161484,
-0.0851290226,
-0.0569201671,
-0.0272207409,
-0.020873908,
0.0582482144,
0.1052281111,
0.0138081061,
-0.0001996381,
0.0079118321,
-0.0513678491,
0.0607326664,
-0.0279207025,
-0.0244818684,
0.0116207758,
-0.0066030947,
0.0482185259,
0.0053806715,
-0.0168921631,
0.0239926502,
-0.0049614115,
-0.0122060422,
0.0671150088,
0.0118752671,
-0.0529677942,
0.0117215291,
-0.0008477853,
-0.0038886762,
-0.0346698202,
0.0563083403,
-0.0667810813,
-0.0053222342,
-0.0151823377,
0.0047933273,
-0.0316924565,
0.0080877142,
-0.0074825371,
-0.0315680131,
0.0336469039,
-0.026422672,
0.0044542896,
0.0482606739,
-0.1064289883,
-0.0289556514,
-0.0050230157,
-0.0673440173,
-0.0541335978,
-0.0276358053,
-0.0314921364,
0.0098142819,
-0.0547475927,
0.0142599354,
2.352526717e-34,
0.0645662025,
-0.0195278395,
-0.0032719609,
0.04746354,
0.0474862903,
-0.0267703366,
0.0297404639,
0.0193295181,
0.0417999849,
-0.0710989833,
-0.0391297378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.15010v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.15010v1 | TransPrompt v2: A Transferable Prompting Framework for Cross-task Text Classification | 2023-08-29T04:16:57 | 2023-08-29T04:16:57 | Jianing Wang, Chengyu Wang, Cen Chen, Ming Gao, Jun Huang, Aoying Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text classification is one of the most imperative tasks in natural language
processing (NLP). Recent advances with pre-trained language models (PLMs) have
shown remarkable success on this task. However, the satisfying results obtained
by PLMs heavily depend on the large amounts of task-specific labeled data,
which may not be feasible in many application scenarios due to data access and
privacy constraints. The recently-proposed prompt-based fine-tuning paradigm
improves the performance of PLMs for few-shot text classification with
task-specific templates. Yet, it is unclear how the prompting knowledge can be
transferred across tasks, for the purpose of mutual reinforcement. We propose
TransPrompt v2, a novel transferable prompting framework for few-shot learning
across similar or distant text classification tasks. For learning across
similar tasks, we employ a multi-task meta-knowledge acquisition (MMA)
procedure to train a meta-learner that captures the cross-task transferable
knowledge. For learning across distant tasks, we further inject the task type
descriptions into the prompt, and capture the intra-type and inter-type prompt
embeddings among multiple distant tasks. Additionally, two de-biasing
techniques are further designed to make the trained meta-learner more
task-agnostic and unbiased towards any tasks. After that, the meta-learner can
be adapted to each specific task with better parameters initialization.
Extensive experiments show that TransPrompt v2 outperforms single-task and
cross-task strong baselines over multiple NLP tasks and datasets. We further
show that the meta-learner can effectively improve the performance of PLMs on
previously unseen tasks. In addition, TransPrompt v2 also outperforms strong
fine-tuning baselines when learning with full training sets. | [
0.0472371578,
-0.0302162115,
-0.0028577112,
0.0153071312,
-0.0208478868,
0.0251657758,
0.0250196978,
-0.022542771,
0.012456459,
-0.0831577852,
-0.0853061751,
0.0093335798,
-0.0154186208,
0.0133698834,
-0.0072148149,
-0.0372539088,
0.0437386632,
-0.0144013269,
0.0190498997,
0.0208299551,
-0.0038403892,
0.0118808094,
-0.0025163896,
0.0210808422,
0.0241097938,
-0.0135062989,
0.0105460193,
0.0046339221,
0.0139076468,
-0.0172746219,
0.0512245484,
0.0645275861,
0.0364620015,
0.0079094255,
0.000001917,
-0.0556057878,
-0.0240619406,
-0.0171216391,
-0.051090654,
-0.0717417449,
0.0507995002,
-0.019311402,
0.0234325714,
-0.0014010681,
-0.0339972451,
-0.059572313,
0.0217031166,
0.0696878582,
0.0485300943,
0.0773972273,
-0.0123675074,
0.0196172632,
-0.0080080684,
-0.0362777412,
0.0585655607,
-0.0286748726,
0.0237886459,
-0.0713510066,
0.0109326458,
0.0702456757,
0.0119557744,
0.004640623,
0.0025743225,
0.0190035757,
0.0274598431,
0.0256254394,
0.0056055784,
-0.0098463856,
-0.0717479661,
0.0802534968,
-0.0059453528,
-0.0280320048,
-0.0037684971,
-0.0232844949,
0.0188357998,
0.010306526,
-0.0231797528,
-0.0051968694,
-0.0100647826,
0.0087550702,
-0.0020467548,
0.0421704464,
-0.0134891178,
0.0009047097,
0.0084667131,
0.0117106251,
-0.0172261242,
-0.0425660051,
0.0277326908,
0.0341565125,
-0.0126329036,
-0.0454194769,
-0.0161676891,
0.0075820605,
-0.0263347141,
-0.0041242614,
-0.0714538097,
-0.0312828384,
0.0073708785,
0.0128361322,
0.0687487945,
0.0063380445,
-0.0633028075,
0.079377532,
-0.0321546309,
0.0183287784,
0.0330385081,
0.0251153912,
-0.0375896655,
0.0026707728,
-0.0998155624,
0.007667237,
-0.0524875335,
0.0411518887,
0.0032015147,
0.0062427935,
-0.0140173417,
0.0303656515,
0.0059774001,
0.0150862457,
0.0374703966,
-0.009050604,
-0.0459918864,
-0.010894279,
-0.0171948951,
0.0181765426,
-0.0492067412,
0.0567333139,
0.0074291434,
-0.0198915415,
-0.0335847847,
0.0096092662,
0.017451534,
-0.0593219288,
0.0279434938,
0.0425013565,
-0.0115450434,
-0.093776606,
-0.0360637978,
0.0031671689,
-0.0157683678,
-0.0476081446,
0.0008186753,
-0.0099116368,
0.0434069112,
-0.0161657073,
-0.0081510516,
0.0174741354,
-0.0077490536,
0.0267948695,
-0.0279189926,
0.1079399437,
-0.0136445733,
-0.0160788316,
-0.0116759324,
0.0016990151,
-0.0676683262,
0.0498746969,
-0.0053070923,
0.0458157174,
0.0353252143,
0.0126975141,
0.0065976353,
-0.0220223367,
0.0202485435,
-0.0034173545,
0.030054247,
0.0151049765,
0.0516101457,
-0.0299815889,
0.0042046453,
0.0043983776,
-0.0022351637,
0.0414230376,
0.049177222,
0.0288870707,
0.0056780311,
-0.0308325179,
0.0418044887,
0.0381839238,
-0.0288439523,
0.015710745,
-0.0660534352,
0.0381824635,
-0.0438022725,
-0.038713932,
0.0137383798,
0.0121845864,
-0.0546070039,
-0.0322911739,
0.0271356367,
-0.0432697013,
-0.0172743332,
0.0167191364,
0.0502890646,
0.0389420204,
-0.0386448465,
-0.0120819611,
0.0253937207,
-0.020229416,
0.0036329327,
-0.0444863364,
0.0395353474,
0.050583493,
-0.0020602266,
-0.0651634559,
-0.0086546056,
-0.0752366111,
0.0728328899,
0.0112649892,
0.0503362454,
-0.0256134029,
0.0324111246,
-0.0292038042,
-0.0347806402,
-0.0126210917,
0.0169980843,
0.0050093927,
-0.0149746425,
0.0120307365,
0.0187089425,
-0.0209649988,
0.0144024258,
0.0382054709,
-0.007547644,
-0.0541415885,
0.0308066346,
0.0396261327,
-0.0154301263,
0.0086596729,
-0.0021958521,
-0.0159536637,
0.0218309462,
-0.0458568633,
0.0160666332,
-0.0048691905,
-0.0404162593,
-0.0493630394,
-0.0237704553,
0.0250819288,
-0.004339288,
-0.0027258263,
-0.0393069312,
-0.0489975922,
-0.0373301581,
0.0361658446,
0.0195835624,
-0.041524943,
-0.0103471838,
-0.0131971389,
0.0087265084,
-0.0378906243,
0.0524483025,
0.0463896543,
0.0201097261,
0.010327843,
-0.058371719,
0.0145100579,
-0.0060681622,
-0.0437191129,
-0.0198336523,
-0.0065333867,
0.015786875,
0.0224034134,
0.0346884169,
-0.0501826815,
-0.0369758494,
-0.0813861638,
0.0099296076,
-0.0258163288,
0.0127895176,
-0.002549076,
0.0110295955,
-0.0131292576,
-0.0464650057,
-0.0438665375,
-0.0005837283,
0.0031111967,
0.033849135,
0.0478848293,
0.0073835468,
0.0554345995,
-0.0059177531,
0.0079468358,
0.0117052095,
0.0487280563,
0.0026846214,
-0.0155966384,
-0.0543503985,
0.0188779514,
0.0242810305,
0.0110457176,
-0.0036270171,
0.0185089186,
-0.0210466553,
-0.018036617,
0.0293439254,
0.0671497807,
-0.0132877911,
-0.0212766826,
0.021442879,
0.0141885281,
-0.0561844409,
0.0229845922,
-0.0372367017,
-0.0191812087,
-0.0098125618,
0.0142856119,
0.0237113424,
0.0592909306,
-0.0123996157,
-0.0340414457,
-0.0837421715,
0.0175718591,
0.002545232,
-0.0146588674,
-0.0373920016,
0.0334241875,
0.0149560366,
0.0137835229,
-0.0294784643,
-0.0461084396,
0.0770344138,
-0.014602147,
-0.0181822367,
-0.0496612117,
-0.0187601708,
-0.028659258,
0.0605080277,
-0.0269372631,
0.0032356002,
0.0822773054,
-0.0056473352,
-0.0570083335,
-0.03178991,
0.0180279557,
-0.0081594922,
-0.0010104247,
0.0132561084,
0.0143907312,
-0.0374701209,
-0.0598784015,
-0.0394295529,
-0.0618478023,
-0.0142921796,
-0.0034746274,
-0.0467935093,
0.0312954299,
-0.0024546671,
-0.0065739211,
0.0197217222,
0.0324660875,
-0.0227134973,
-0.0229982547,
-0.0293148682,
0.0223780628,
0.0259830859,
0.0055756024,
-0.0537951067,
-0.029621724,
0.0242133271,
0.0106460927,
0.0511463098,
0.0192969572,
0.0050852019,
0.0109796608,
0.0462002903,
-0.0170244388,
-0.0255045444,
0.0104462663,
0.043327935,
-0.0399291031,
-0.0007535092,
0.0968246758,
0.0328241214,
-0.0730959922,
-0.0343541466,
0.0071548172,
-0.0062184189,
0.035209652,
0.0402970389,
-0.0675572678,
-0.0799641088,
-0.0033881238,
0.0191128645,
0.0175455138,
-0.0226728525,
-0.0406076871,
-0.0897797197,
-0.0055140359,
-0.0261500869,
-0.0027657945,
-0.020056257,
-0.0532424413,
0.0126135983,
0.0009745569,
-0.0160970725,
-0.0409930833,
-0.0197303388,
-0.0098407231,
0.0286455303,
0.0254765637,
-0.0849536285,
0.0259861536,
-0.028786866,
0.0479435213,
0.0492400117,
0.0173991285,
-0.0071428372,
-0.0039547118,
0.0217573382,
0.0108116455,
0.0105019407,
-0.0225166623,
0.0607527718,
-0.0624375045,
0.0162962526,
0.0118128322,
0.0129464166,
-0.0313245729,
-0.0309857521,
0.028294323,
0.090560399,
0.0140958056,
-0.0093816249,
0.0038245064,
-0.040872436,
0.046921581,
0.0844801664,
-0.0057001654,
-0.0698021501,
-0.0089064855,
0.0027381463,
-0.0282843076,
-0.0416632146,
0.0195261408,
0.0309438482,
-0.0185427163,
0.008856127,
-0.0512386151,
-0.0431238078,
0.0681087375,
0.0382189378,
0.0273999851,
0.019871043,
-0.0114660189,
-0.0038283262,
-0.0641533062,
0.014578592,
-0.0358914509,
0.0085934009,
-0.0531864353,
-0.0155583965,
0.0712234676,
-0.0583264902,
0.0000269722,
-0.0333856791,
-0.0621836074,
-0.0255960487,
-0.0598186441,
0.0735620782,
0.0069137965,
0.0425996073,
-0.0252536982,
-0.0366219245,
0.0726874322,
0.0511316992,
-0.0451815575,
-0.0064313267,
0.0703928545,
-0.010847006,
-0.017416168,
0.0300007127,
-0.0473639369,
0.0335894153,
0.0483593345,
-0.0174603797,
0.0321859531,
-0.0035876767,
0.0140385721,
0.002379796,
0.0996341407,
0.0132480729,
-0.0195965096,
-0.0660135299,
0.0132416068,
0.0353394523,
-0.0376641974,
-0.0595636889,
0.0207734033,
0.0214426182,
-0.0171456747,
-0.0074327434,
0.0211951435,
-0.0197631977,
0.0478789359,
-0.0493191294,
0.0130498745,
-0.0014187658,
0.0487051606,
0.0083541479,
0.0129075702,
-0.0143055608,
0.0271998756,
0.0378780812,
0.0027449115,
-0.0327502377,
0.0469097383,
0.038382452,
-0.0046907514,
-0.0119645791,
0.0716731995,
-0.0592630804,
0.0115618007,
-0.0021485754,
-0.0093553085,
0.0456760712,
-0.0035717036,
-0.0077276207,
0.0075996243,
0.009477891,
-0.0039010334,
0.0580905788,
0.0215891283,
0.0012921975,
0.0107422648,
-0.0047169486,
-0.028400626,
0.0304737352,
0.082092002,
-0.0429609269,
0.0289737899,
0.034384951,
0.0137604242,
-0.0666587651,
0.0061178342,
0.0224389993,
0.0169836786,
-0.0115518039,
0.0516065769,
-0.0128101222,
-0.0268286914,
0.0528157614,
-0.0548327789,
-0.0276333448,
0.0253171641,
0.035153117,
0.0512943044,
0.007388744,
-0.0079015289,
-0.0277738217,
-0.0223826617,
0.0406425223,
-0.0028144352,
0.0082537262,
-5.916306047e-33,
-0.0221342705,
0.021783052,
0.0141995158,
-0.0145976925,
0.0066277203,
0.0101335431,
0.0003474161,
-0.0444293171,
-0.0046070344,
-0.0217834953,
-0.0374329276,
-0.010265477,
0.0175527781,
0.0346102901,
0.001944815,
-0.0379384197,
0.0553597249,
-0.0166520216,
-0.0423458219,
0.0259194132,
0.0403698459,
0.059571363,
0.0493547842,
-0.0104553476,
0.0546511561,
0.0230296627,
-0.0103521673,
0.0219820533,
0.025514612,
0.026964372,
-0.0119339842,
0.0439172611,
0.0517282933,
-0.0274923965,
-0.0087203877,
0.1024783403,
-0.0982649177,
-0.0713060275,
0.012351485,
-0.0245328099,
-0.0264240149,
-0.0212106574,
-0.0348890871,
-0.0223062914,
0.0424886048,
-0.0058910907,
0.0388814211,
-0.030603949,
-0.01573053,
-0.0139683802,
-0.0320413224,
-0.007142745,
0.0235472452,
-0.0525354668,
0.0593439117,
0.0844003633,
0.0087198392,
0.0194228999,
-0.02480321,
0.0300480481,
-0.0298825186,
0.021338433,
-0.0221979488,
0.0193094295,
-0.0103129484,
0.0505338088,
0.0029888235,
0.0353298374,
0.00775909,
-0.0044673928,
0.0176613033,
0.0272345189,
0.0042239032,
0.0563662611,
0.0237553231,
-0.0104371188,
-0.04610347,
0.0260579884,
0.0240284428,
-0.0137638561,
0.0326045677,
-0.014180569,
-0.0305107236,
-0.0337899029,
-0.05730661,
-0.0274232756,
-0.0429700948,
-0.0099714817,
0.0385637768,
0.0524575859,
-0.0211633835,
0.0110124163,
0.0396381468,
-0.0407015085,
-0.0090726502,
0.0172332712,
0.0041155121,
-0.0007211284,
-0.0040160851,
-0.0117529919,
-0.0670508966,
-0.0572997294,
0.0541902222,
-0.0059384853,
0.0040711137,
0.021895811,
0.0947444439,
0.0262938999,
-0.0781778023,
-0.0133413905,
-0.007311462,
0.0602462664,
0.0152052678,
0.0591107532,
0.0113358079,
0.0513711385,
-0.0240514148,
0.076415889,
0.0160365663,
-0.0491461568,
-0.0290549342,
0.0133007644,
-0.0197221115,
0.0232850611,
-0.0084510166,
-0.0053762961,
-0.0192444399,
0.0156038133,
0.0170921218,
-0.0354311951,
0.0040357406,
-0.0159166865,
2.688e-7,
-0.0211671237,
0.0392662175,
-0.0068229879,
-0.0131952902,
-0.0046887249,
0.0693783388,
-0.0217577405,
0.0749939755,
-0.0129480138,
-0.0046171155,
0.0219885707,
0.021667432,
0.0471704826,
0.0161449853,
-0.088944383,
0.0085007502,
-0.0312940963,
0.0142678423,
-0.0408975556,
-0.0067644552,
0.0723024979,
0.0593386069,
0.0401413441,
-0.0086512212,
-0.0042576198,
-0.0331462882,
0.0607137866,
-0.0663833991,
-0.0007267838,
-0.0014658484,
-0.0210254788,
0.0082570352,
-0.0297127347,
0.0698725134,
-0.028189877,
0.0206148699,
-0.003001539,
0.0589932427,
0.0115298042,
-0.0214148276,
-0.0106275426,
0.0162643511,
0.0174336657,
0.0144839669,
0.0986135304,
-0.1103051081,
-0.0163646583,
-0.023703713,
-0.0069777812,
-0.0264343806,
0.0201171134,
-0.0012268177,
-0.0191677213,
0.008749174,
0.0393903181,
0.0443536974,
-0.0418403037,
-0.1202193797,
0.0063129608,
0.001690336,
-0.0045834435,
-0.0325588509,
-0.0273663867,
-0.0228810124,
0.026849132,
-0.1034793854,
0.0288382266,
2.358281818e-34,
-0.0025233589,
-0.0242812447,
0.0247949306,
-0.0211440232,
-0.0234132055,
-0.0051417663,
-0.0394472182,
-0.0255339704,
0.0439144,
-0.0563989393,
-0.0035263768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14951v1 | Robust Open-Set Spoken Language Identification and the CU MultiLang Dataset | 2023-08-29T00:44:27 | 2023-08-29T00:44:27 | Mustafa Eyceoz, Justin Lee, Siddharth Pittie, Homayoon Beigi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.AS | Most state-of-the-art spoken language identification models are closed-set;
in other words, they can only output a language label from the set of classes
they were trained on. Open-set spoken language identification systems, however,
gain the ability to detect when an input exhibits none of the original
languages. In this paper, we implement a novel approach to open-set spoken
language identification that uses MFCC and pitch features, a TDNN model to
extract meaningful feature embeddings, confidence thresholding on softmax
outputs, and LDA and pLDA for learning to classify new unknown languages. We
present a spoken language identification system that achieves 91.76% accuracy
on trained languages and has the capability to adapt to unknown languages on
the fly. To that end, we also built the CU MultiLang Dataset, a large and
diverse multilingual speech corpus which was used to train and evaluate our
system. | [
-0.0388845988,
0.020973172,
0.0167106539,
0.0539301746,
-0.0003546689,
0.0183412973,
0.0182120949,
-0.0244520921,
0.0029777116,
0.0128924521,
-0.0808232054,
-0.0493861735,
0.0175549239,
0.0523728207,
0.0048721991,
0.0068436237,
0.0204626638,
-0.0409086309,
0.0146423755,
0.007342462,
-0.0110844253,
0.0075074467,
-0.0095613385,
0.0334609784,
0.0019565825,
-0.0109210499,
0.0165629126,
0.0129062748,
0.0376515761,
0.0006979293,
0.0186191481,
0.0254563168,
0.0258375853,
0.078056857,
0.0000016334,
-0.0312522836,
-0.0221343823,
-0.0537436455,
-0.0628419593,
-0.0352766588,
0.0233502761,
0.02383825,
-0.0183204357,
0.0310788844,
0.0295298956,
-0.0640001819,
0.0649352521,
0.0004848735,
0.0123474142,
0.0520912111,
0.0134854782,
-0.0260374714,
-0.0269577615,
0.0021787365,
-0.0285171494,
-0.002393662,
0.0137598189,
-0.0554173514,
-0.0017420333,
-0.0742118508,
0.0293196402,
0.0392799899,
-0.0236622877,
0.0205990952,
-0.0287673548,
-0.0016337672,
-0.0756449252,
-0.0309257507,
-0.0116727035,
0.0721019059,
-0.0504549108,
-0.0414748341,
-0.0120164324,
-0.0089876913,
-0.0388019234,
-0.0430804193,
-0.0154805714,
0.0301256794,
0.0127706826,
0.0180214234,
0.0160293337,
0.0579161458,
0.0310667865,
0.0037850761,
-0.0084312418,
0.0112485904,
0.0018799371,
0.0112221511,
0.0176125821,
-0.0360326245,
0.0059373612,
-0.0049422286,
0.0288903564,
-0.0048969602,
-0.0079342453,
0.0014925498,
-0.0014450212,
-0.0482106879,
-0.0120946532,
-0.0562607497,
0.0245085731,
0.0448013954,
-0.119863607,
0.0198730733,
-0.0614293143,
0.0333783329,
-0.0133162923,
-0.0251782052,
0.0019876154,
-0.03286881,
0.0006037381,
0.0056113214,
0.0059992145,
0.0028406095,
0.0601853244,
0.0237048175,
-0.0267323181,
0.0003710082,
-0.0195923857,
0.0841652676,
0.0016952056,
-0.0385822952,
-0.0435412675,
-0.0109456098,
0.0457290225,
0.0512661301,
0.0025071711,
0.0157410745,
-0.0369244292,
-0.0998095348,
-0.0303872488,
0.0650372878,
0.0495823324,
0.0515270941,
0.009810226,
0.0195881799,
0.0056655514,
-0.0414380841,
-0.0438145809,
0.0082809618,
-0.0092714913,
-0.0589797385,
0.0281725302,
-0.0724533647,
-0.0056437925,
0.0062926509,
0.0286506694,
-0.0589227527,
0.0081097651,
-0.0143523477,
0.0374425389,
0.0585072488,
-0.0400169864,
0.0067090113,
0.0392492972,
-0.015633462,
0.0170031413,
0.0727265477,
-0.0116492854,
0.0152924657,
0.0404964313,
-0.005544045,
0.0369934663,
0.0880014226,
-0.0326016583,
0.0140707148,
-0.0334689356,
0.0080852779,
0.0549182408,
0.0291176289,
-0.0367100053,
-0.0198162571,
0.0173347984,
0.0042622848,
0.0131998435,
0.0362208411,
0.0251316521,
-0.0235926025,
0.0310408603,
-0.0185796954,
0.0193688087,
-0.0074926261,
0.0441998579,
-0.0292815808,
0.0108840913,
0.0093062669,
0.0118056452,
0.0257908199,
-0.046038188,
0.0214533415,
-0.0216806158,
-0.0887152031,
-0.0386068374,
0.0139859002,
0.0479124598,
0.0096180094,
0.0070064473,
0.0652873591,
0.041265361,
-0.0096199056,
-0.0106994528,
-0.0349209905,
0.0559891053,
-0.0154250031,
0.0016384788,
-0.0699986666,
0.00818446,
-0.0639962107,
0.0028897985,
0.0544414669,
0.0394531488,
-0.0161187518,
0.0408701971,
-0.0753260329,
0.0101384213,
0.0383925512,
0.0109707797,
0.076530993,
-0.0328300409,
0.0158538949,
0.01268165,
-0.0197521672,
-0.002994491,
-0.0124931205,
-0.0200048368,
-0.0176823456,
0.0937499329,
0.0220569875,
0.0431205593,
0.0591489151,
0.0027174538,
-0.0177281592,
0.0265721828,
-0.0153166456,
0.0275077,
-0.0083180554,
-0.0299964081,
-0.0177046172,
0.0574325435,
-0.0008883321,
-0.0483942665,
0.0570829026,
-0.0055974717,
-0.0527386814,
0.0790583268,
0.0223250519,
0.00190556,
-0.0393736809,
0.0124884723,
-0.0519582778,
0.0393283591,
0.0358427688,
0.0430331044,
0.0276152678,
0.006403395,
0.0319131352,
-0.0533513241,
0.0773765445,
-0.0776405931,
-0.0532962307,
0.0688769817,
-0.0145860212,
-0.0155029241,
-0.0355986655,
0.0147177232,
0.00638424,
0.0149654327,
-0.0280783661,
-0.0029248893,
-0.0573808663,
0.0046893694,
-0.0173117742,
0.0064398926,
-0.0253708251,
-0.0602732599,
-0.0202006977,
-0.0113079585,
0.0184863005,
-0.025758246,
-0.0528158285,
0.0280595273,
-0.0557769127,
-0.0056044837,
0.0084465547,
0.0057337219,
0.0640273914,
-0.0383554772,
-0.0391696207,
-0.0334101766,
0.0315227732,
-0.0257689897,
0.0362933911,
0.022921117,
0.0079119802,
-0.0002476836,
-0.0092426902,
-0.0188004877,
-0.0097761322,
-0.0456966907,
-0.0137945125,
0.068270959,
0.008651617,
0.014998259,
-0.0140708331,
-0.0170483645,
-0.0126517108,
-0.0080161225,
0.0040882993,
-0.042050872,
0.0193189811,
0.0320027471,
0.0108064674,
-0.0182367712,
-0.0524791926,
-0.0060092937,
0.0004811449,
-0.0281198099,
0.0010896323,
-0.0478919894,
0.045596078,
0.0278012361,
-0.0580210425,
0.0425730683,
-0.0686526671,
-0.0221970137,
-0.0486384258,
-0.0656051785,
-0.0255948268,
0.008669761,
-0.0033044482,
0.0172893442,
0.0198106952,
-0.0674098358,
0.0095053343,
0.0216466822,
-0.0135043804,
-0.0747058466,
0.0488803685,
-0.0075771837,
-0.0306403153,
-0.0243836194,
-0.003080169,
-0.0470174029,
-0.0129917208,
-0.0546903796,
0.0360952914,
-0.0570071228,
-0.0462048091,
-0.007165723,
0.0165074617,
0.0197453592,
0.0326126404,
0.0145405205,
0.059560027,
-0.0141475275,
0.0405039787,
0.0120466612,
0.0716564655,
0.0134308282,
-0.0038861705,
0.0121879177,
-0.0456276052,
0.0332609527,
0.0261330344,
-0.0543360263,
-0.0273387711,
0.0310570896,
0.0090094628,
0.0009891597,
0.0218301043,
-0.0164938066,
-0.0070337993,
0.0219260398,
0.1051693037,
-0.0132619878,
-0.0596653484,
-0.0410634056,
0.0008680332,
-0.0157007836,
0.0066897501,
0.0115000028,
-0.0700253695,
-0.0399472862,
0.029450411,
0.0205236077,
-0.0043409397,
0.0022623353,
-0.0434751138,
-0.0927887782,
0.012055086,
0.0190756805,
-0.0263618529,
-0.0893008932,
-0.0131133078,
0.0142881582,
-0.0072836932,
0.0164656956,
-0.0462837704,
0.0325997695,
-0.040518593,
0.0170563627,
-0.0152352462,
-0.101033397,
0.0406361483,
-0.0307680313,
0.0539608747,
0.0043186131,
-0.0070125866,
-0.0441354848,
-0.0297591873,
0.0073551382,
-0.0363167673,
-0.0437905677,
-0.0267008524,
-0.0057257973,
0.0317859538,
-0.024540266,
0.0696335807,
0.0243525133,
-0.024810873,
-0.0107124019,
0.0084039317,
0.0822521001,
-0.0144764967,
-0.0313981548,
0.0527148433,
0.0072624837,
0.0641949177,
0.0535465106,
0.0291255601,
-0.0340914428,
0.0538545586,
-0.0266118646,
0.0275661945,
0.0304407217,
-0.0102135567,
0.0343107954,
0.0091367448,
-0.0434470996,
0.0201644469,
0.0339459367,
0.006434232,
-0.0160369873,
0.0505404063,
-0.0048219818,
-0.0122664748,
-0.0004289581,
-0.0366115868,
0.0424103215,
-0.018584393,
0.0507919714,
-0.0965879187,
-0.0063255234,
0.0355681255,
-0.0898117572,
-0.0233883057,
0.0071844482,
-0.0816488415,
-0.0388191938,
-0.0060777818,
-0.0545758605,
0.0096741579,
0.0315341912,
-0.0377457589,
-0.0741844624,
-0.0051738657,
-0.000988409,
-0.0204367209,
-0.0010540747,
0.0652217716,
-0.0164410882,
-0.0616985783,
0.0246053152,
-0.0294623412,
0.0004126817,
0.0439987704,
-0.0386617333,
-0.026149882,
-0.0509254448,
-0.0056786076,
0.0159265138,
0.0779229254,
-0.0152953519,
0.0046845381,
-0.0940936878,
0.0027345307,
0.0494596958,
0.010004906,
0.0036075963,
-0.0151603976,
0.0533101559,
-0.0234489124,
0.0068983301,
0.0176081527,
-0.0263029207,
-0.0044617932,
-0.0127139324,
0.0822766349,
0.0377793796,
0.0366408266,
0.008171008,
-0.0058944453,
-0.0423158631,
0.0976832211,
0.002248981,
0.0162168797,
0.0123617994,
0.0220839214,
-0.0261549912,
-0.0122467466,
0.0168091189,
0.0073998258,
0.0274996292,
-0.0111435167,
0.0020322409,
0.0195057783,
0.0443641245,
-0.0272577219,
0.0193945318,
-0.0187837128,
0.022023255,
-0.0420949198,
0.0115927411,
-0.0272164643,
-0.0413081087,
0.0463633649,
-0.0279619209,
-0.0180182643,
0.0191311445,
0.0519016907,
-0.0084120203,
0.023150906,
-0.0443382747,
0.0294706803,
-0.025565749,
0.0220445637,
0.0270908102,
0.0076789493,
-0.0235717911,
0.0205792245,
0.0000550749,
-0.0454844758,
0.0454784259,
-0.0115234535,
-0.0035390817,
0.0417136773,
0.0032441788,
0.0092430385,
-0.0184028205,
0.0116122225,
-0.0099204779,
-0.0275107995,
0.0262044501,
0.0167386159,
-0.0087015238,
-5.183751926e-33,
0.0027011251,
0.0122438474,
-0.0418267697,
0.0356890596,
0.0359862596,
-0.017986916,
-0.0271770116,
0.0270684715,
-0.0170360953,
-0.0351685137,
0.0019867716,
0.0116366949,
0.0345698446,
0.0181001965,
-0.0207968298,
-0.0334474146,
0.0565636717,
-0.0133855864,
0.0160133839,
0.0136785321,
0.0733910501,
0.020062767,
0.1149614379,
-0.0660291314,
-0.0558022857,
-0.0321292244,
0.006677852,
0.0153600331,
-0.0018799151,
0.0330722891,
-0.0427224934,
0.0682472065,
-0.00645898,
-0.0329339989,
-0.0191385355,
0.0327498242,
-0.0231081191,
-0.0269800164,
-0.0355223604,
0.0773690045,
0.0385598317,
-0.0411783569,
-0.0257413816,
-0.0069155321,
-0.0395338312,
-0.0041434667,
0.0217131134,
-0.0438069142,
0.0356335901,
-0.0191329028,
0.0142499628,
0.0637681037,
0.006888852,
-0.0188827198,
0.0385401547,
0.0573699176,
-0.0124614248,
-0.0220656767,
-0.0552739725,
0.0612155274,
0.004325992,
-0.0088254036,
0.0553298146,
0.0593960769,
-0.029135054,
0.0450674333,
0.0428458788,
-0.0578134358,
0.0221997015,
0.0074676713,
0.022565335,
-0.0173397455,
0.0362612791,
0.0546212681,
-0.0131567745,
-0.0305912029,
-0.0522570945,
-0.0115629025,
0.0168442316,
-0.0373069234,
0.0246557631,
-0.015829375,
-0.0446701869,
-0.0104369009,
-0.0332907066,
-0.0160081554,
-0.0135509577,
0.0114091998,
0.0467814542,
-0.0193714257,
-0.0134457005,
0.0060593667,
0.0601648092,
-0.018531654,
0.0181921441,
0.0212125592,
0.0068801311,
0.0066411872,
0.0080132559,
0.0274215303,
-0.0641505867,
-0.0360323861,
0.0207480639,
-0.0204021223,
0.0289430879,
-0.0227594897,
0.0343471132,
0.0650281087,
-0.0288626533,
0.0471540168,
0.0154879978,
0.0005210164,
0.039157927,
0.0722839013,
0.025598092,
-0.0097399307,
0.0060560354,
0.0194669385,
0.0302673355,
0.013731082,
0.0025084096,
-0.0362754725,
-0.0231383704,
0.0371336527,
-0.0477759391,
0.0305643622,
0.0038377857,
0.0365280397,
0.0418780893,
-0.0099277599,
0.0414684899,
0.0230976678,
2.383e-7,
-0.0181056056,
-0.0671065375,
0.0111867143,
0.0123506552,
0.0102363806,
0.036677707,
-0.0341446623,
-0.0217057858,
-0.0087127658,
0.0089501049,
-0.0112596229,
-0.0458741784,
0.067626439,
0.0443726927,
-0.1117579713,
0.003324399,
-0.0269871652,
0.0392674245,
-0.0475030877,
-0.0143770417,
-0.0036866097,
0.128488034,
-0.0157723967,
-0.0156387109,
0.0007374268,
-0.0379205272,
0.0051062675,
-0.0212461725,
-0.0018013666,
-0.0195235498,
0.0214658566,
0.0240627397,
-0.0268426314,
-0.0003135364,
-0.0254322533,
0.0615776442,
0.0515386835,
0.0156890154,
0.0587482303,
-0.0110512087,
0.0005792387,
0.0233804546,
-0.0485707186,
-0.0051420862,
0.0514790602,
0.0378220789,
-0.0277117938,
-0.0078184903,
0.0438781269,
-0.0161635131,
0.0455881841,
-0.0319762528,
0.0012907858,
0.0207257662,
-0.0048149298,
-0.0435646437,
-0.0418988392,
-0.053716179,
0.0031334658,
0.0033711614,
-0.0627866313,
0.0099624163,
0.0295477975,
-0.0347912945,
0.0126948943,
-0.0417228453,
0.0237467419,
1.517323975e-34,
-0.0106932288,
0.0012866285,
-0.0432408266,
-0.0433135964,
-0.0109293582,
-0.0550985187,
0.0026088422,
0.0114447372,
0.0124990717,
-0.0330656767,
-0.0117722107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14921v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14921v1 | Gender bias and stereotypes in Large Language Models | 2023-08-28T22:32:05 | 2023-08-28T22:32:05 | Hadas Kotek, Rikker Dockum, David Q. Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have made substantial progress in the past
several months, shattering state-of-the-art benchmarks in many domains. This
paper investigates LLMs' behavior with respect to gender stereotypes, a known
issue for prior models. We use a simple paradigm to test the presence of gender
bias, building on but differing from WinoBias, a commonly used gender bias
dataset, which is likely to be included in the training data of current LLMs.
We test four recently published LLMs and demonstrate that they express biased
assumptions about men and women's occupations. Our contributions in this paper
are as follows: (a) LLMs are 3-6 times more likely to choose an occupation that
stereotypically aligns with a person's gender; (b) these choices align with
people's perceptions better than with the ground truth as reflected in official
job statistics; (c) LLMs in fact amplify the bias beyond what is reflected in
perceptions or the ground truth; (d) LLMs ignore crucial ambiguities in
sentence structure 95% of the time in our study items, but when explicitly
prompted, they recognize the ambiguity; (e) LLMs provide explanations for their
choices that are factually inaccurate and likely obscure the true reason behind
their predictions. That is, they provide rationalizations of their biased
behavior. This highlights a key property of these models: LLMs are trained on
imbalanced datasets; as such, even with the recent successes of reinforcement
learning with human feedback, they tend to reflect those imbalances back at us.
As with other types of societal biases, we suggest that LLMs must be carefully
tested to ensure that they treat minoritized individuals and communities
equitably. | [
0.0594673716,
0.1023197621,
-0.0322581455,
0.0091081634,
-0.0011024654,
0.0304150265,
0.0515511632,
-0.0355517566,
0.0098820506,
-0.0704035163,
-0.0019538151,
-0.0527264029,
0.0324393474,
0.0107669923,
0.0453149825,
-0.0316274427,
0.0089798635,
0.0204764865,
0.0110901464,
-0.0485176668,
0.0181110818,
0.032654088,
0.0345947929,
0.0640147254,
0.0150170429,
-0.0251354706,
0.0598404072,
-0.0081820013,
-0.0179968178,
0.0026092371,
0.0709783435,
0.048341535,
0.0180061683,
0.0137830544,
0.0000021351,
-0.0822980776,
0.0252118595,
0.0092428606,
-0.0070123514,
0.0023811462,
0.0308407638,
-0.012191372,
-0.006964718,
0.0371344835,
-0.030253714,
-0.0221341103,
0.0078643076,
0.0412996747,
0.0073327362,
0.0178946238,
-0.0017960886,
0.0058569266,
-0.0802445784,
-0.0365233868,
-0.026552463,
0.0145181315,
0.0674288049,
-0.0463954508,
-0.0660660043,
-0.0254555382,
-0.0352130309,
-0.0231426731,
-0.0210890062,
0.0073527242,
-0.0085123051,
0.0422718897,
-0.02094087,
-0.0409038477,
0.0085313851,
0.0363747627,
-0.000942055,
-0.0205472,
0.0316530354,
-0.0135084642,
0.0327811129,
0.0349530205,
-0.0347305797,
0.0566998869,
-0.0126008671,
-0.0097401943,
-0.0049983291,
-0.0081573557,
0.0383922793,
0.0585578829,
-0.0324707963,
0.0815115348,
-0.0038458419,
-0.0471782833,
0.0138905076,
0.0143644577,
-0.0063545173,
-0.0592529029,
-0.0093282582,
-0.0267128367,
-0.0245775152,
0.0073322305,
-0.0133224819,
0.0166018195,
0.0268504526,
-0.0676175728,
-0.0225475561,
0.0310094748,
0.0181438215,
0.0217641611,
-0.0054001743,
0.024382202,
0.0099447109,
0.0000736709,
-0.0075691883,
-0.0449745394,
-0.0287224371,
-0.0213385765,
-0.0051194937,
-0.0061180866,
0.0156551916,
0.0461387374,
-0.0376650728,
-0.0058134641,
-0.062540248,
0.0158043485,
0.006201148,
0.0236358996,
-0.0258984901,
-0.0193423945,
-0.0418449789,
0.026207231,
-0.0471852645,
0.0500666164,
-0.0420075022,
-0.0720335841,
0.0204433594,
0.0065234429,
-0.0086036092,
-0.0351772457,
0.0174422171,
0.0368674956,
0.0196470618,
-0.0075577307,
-0.0002311625,
-0.0049262336,
-0.068249844,
-0.0570950508,
-0.0164479557,
-0.0534179136,
0.0033483524,
0.0417193063,
0.0210425425,
-0.0412808061,
0.0005953101,
0.0160657354,
-0.0596802309,
0.0602120981,
0.0656671673,
0.0137819797,
0.0614722334,
0.0226443876,
-0.0496582016,
0.0793445557,
0.0572238788,
0.0058903093,
0.0125032617,
0.0002945868,
-0.0019832731,
0.0351184718,
0.0197312068,
0.028006142,
-0.0147125302,
0.0334747583,
-0.0075915279,
0.027348388,
0.0968558639,
0.019417949,
0.0030474542,
-0.0176233854,
0.0620879792,
0.0643839762,
-0.0044220714,
0.0254933294,
0.0315492973,
0.0364202075,
-0.0063058799,
0.0059160441,
-0.0603861101,
-0.0290999785,
0.0115885297,
-0.0456846431,
-0.0232420564,
0.0436761603,
-0.0170630086,
-0.0316805802,
-0.0102171628,
0.0048023965,
0.0380453877,
0.0276885591,
0.0429494902,
0.0066062906,
0.0019556684,
0.0498099662,
0.0544510745,
-0.0091549186,
-0.014498123,
-0.0620195679,
0.0261195693,
0.0390171632,
0.0038839525,
-0.0065669576,
0.009701686,
-0.044335667,
-0.0247048922,
0.0474210531,
0.0710811689,
0.008471204,
-0.0127080176,
-0.0482594669,
0.0032766564,
0.0325639471,
0.0452133715,
0.0279239211,
0.0685069636,
0.0364752337,
0.0126321614,
-0.0281032734,
-0.0556616746,
0.012400453,
-0.0126646459,
-0.0298229493,
0.0166049376,
0.0078041204,
0.0272053462,
-0.0111900801,
-0.0251560789,
-0.0018233114,
-0.0252897851,
-0.0026551136,
-0.004868458,
0.0188558102,
-0.0616999641,
0.0069534564,
-0.0014466783,
-0.0357742794,
-0.0704120621,
0.0144378627,
-0.0100000622,
0.0132674575,
0.0406240113,
0.0107607208,
0.0231663734,
-0.0068149613,
0.0108822016,
-0.0248952638,
0.0266829897,
-0.037848074,
0.0285501145,
-0.0122971078,
-0.0261580627,
-0.0062125777,
-0.0325120687,
-0.0033033101,
-0.0625612438,
-0.0447857045,
0.0076297089,
0.0046322378,
0.0101845516,
0.0292669665,
-0.0479838774,
-0.0124414228,
-0.0531814508,
-0.0807130039,
-0.0016452094,
-0.0054737502,
-0.0143265929,
-0.0098866094,
-0.0127204033,
-0.0396130905,
0.0021047904,
-0.0211367309,
-0.0246765614,
0.0096041616,
0.0524459705,
0.0326423906,
-0.0198127776,
0.0149724185,
-0.0420318134,
-0.0261969306,
-0.0439090393,
0.0676625818,
0.0216317754,
0.0095601343,
-0.0418183506,
0.0110238334,
-0.0426906534,
0.0155639676,
-0.0249811243,
-0.0146142105,
-0.0052496335,
0.037581604,
0.0387614481,
0.0877185687,
0.0142195215,
0.0418809354,
0.0648617074,
0.0165503565,
-0.0637986064,
-0.0264441483,
0.013480478,
0.0145516433,
-0.0030415559,
-0.0863220021,
-0.0146689778,
0.0594809391,
0.0180072524,
-0.0368271247,
-0.0382708721,
0.0593363382,
-0.0561953746,
-0.0456384271,
-0.0321184918,
-0.0227137823,
-0.006469022,
0.0146051738,
-0.0406639427,
-0.059936285,
0.0320836343,
0.0157416482,
0.0100184754,
-0.0118552297,
-0.0221896581,
-0.0581453145,
0.0380276591,
-0.0004476992,
0.0055026477,
0.030454142,
0.0019515401,
-0.0906601697,
-0.0563455559,
0.0222340543,
-0.02817633,
0.0100219212,
-0.0338915177,
0.0183694288,
0.0127282524,
-0.0625761226,
-0.0390852243,
-0.0635890514,
-0.0439816155,
-0.0078683048,
0.0333733149,
-0.0267704818,
-0.0147211486,
0.0020371671,
0.0092483982,
-0.0000545769,
-0.0184082985,
-0.0072677769,
0.0059210514,
-0.0043264925,
0.0578636639,
0.0222307406,
0.0191675462,
-0.0313666798,
-0.0113303084,
0.0133536672,
-0.0107116001,
0.0364860408,
-0.0257350411,
-0.0025182648,
0.0278741512,
-0.030268129,
-0.0173703637,
0.0151103064,
0.0169765912,
-0.0464736,
0.0245567802,
0.1058545485,
0.0186719783,
-0.0238744225,
0.008621105,
0.0043156254,
0.0431376807,
0.0449745208,
0.008840736,
-0.0750133023,
0.0171137769,
0.0299504362,
0.0121934358,
-0.0290722586,
-0.0372284427,
-0.0220766161,
-0.1331053823,
0.0152461175,
0.002524127,
-0.0196274929,
0.0007928628,
-0.0368339047,
-0.0015881899,
-0.0360177048,
0.0231788736,
-0.0115502691,
-0.0011181595,
0.010443585,
0.0275905989,
-0.0516087599,
-0.0440321974,
0.060220141,
-0.0761053935,
0.0854216367,
0.0138141923,
0.0507769324,
-0.0240539238,
0.0110622495,
0.0233822726,
0.0110245729,
-0.012022973,
-0.0174700543,
0.020771604,
-0.0549709834,
-0.0164018441,
-0.0463807546,
0.0231755376,
0.0240251515,
0.0299748834,
0.0056648129,
0.0323050618,
0.0280101523,
-0.0525465906,
-0.0375070348,
-0.020090051,
-0.0066275345,
0.1129335389,
-0.0123009514,
-0.0521308929,
-0.0334299766,
-0.045089528,
-0.0430891477,
0.0390085392,
-0.0636514053,
0.0140288128,
0.0285544824,
-0.0142330481,
-0.0066287066,
-0.0586423017,
0.0468571298,
-0.0111232195,
0.0075014918,
-0.0552633032,
0.030077327,
0.0055520358,
-0.0700343475,
0.0467459932,
-0.0293618627,
0.020601999,
0.0120300325,
-0.0081435414,
0.0118204635,
-0.0494136587,
-0.0395660475,
0.0040547927,
-0.0411504768,
-0.0529509746,
0.0396340527,
0.0232975762,
0.0229835883,
0.0714443624,
0.0122532248,
-0.0489095002,
0.0504832342,
0.0378233418,
-0.0114965746,
0.0426710919,
0.0324025191,
0.0442093238,
0.0132644102,
0.0314214379,
-0.0501139723,
0.0404538997,
0.0125556942,
-0.0161065944,
-0.0237765741,
-0.0281524044,
0.0074264198,
-0.0010761772,
0.0109208254,
-0.0304132123,
0.0137573984,
-0.0445511304,
-0.0227816198,
-0.0117678484,
-0.0487927012,
0.0091367513,
-0.0364639498,
0.0468757153,
0.0201205667,
-0.0283526331,
-0.0151555967,
-0.01611818,
0.0430389643,
-0.0251606107,
0.0087347077,
0.0108780917,
0.0179824233,
0.0165740401,
-0.0038820535,
0.0005775748,
0.0059572649,
-0.0214092843,
0.0407389402,
0.0557870381,
0.0206647404,
0.0057926127,
0.0043454249,
-0.0238483232,
-0.0217625517,
-0.0317272879,
-0.0387840569,
0.0012621848,
0.0264298543,
0.0010979008,
-0.0584246255,
0.0560877547,
-0.0162488632,
-0.0055013062,
0.0045057992,
-0.0142363077,
0.0045369142,
0.0091500962,
0.045390062,
0.0004046346,
-0.0239813831,
0.0068165855,
0.0691397116,
0.0840494335,
0.0662269741,
-0.0186587498,
-0.0407027788,
-0.0331626423,
-0.0128355911,
0.0356416851,
-0.0132672219,
-0.0080553256,
0.0064279116,
-0.1053018421,
-0.0459475853,
-0.0229903013,
-0.01019073,
0.0220188871,
-0.0372128934,
-0.0072672954,
0.0571622513,
-0.025402464,
-0.0365935154,
-0.0229420867,
-0.0022383134,
0.0037273276,
-0.0014539945,
-0.0432693958,
-6.362074443e-33,
-0.0193826668,
-0.0373586938,
-0.0107537564,
-0.0349345952,
-0.0046555167,
-0.0000763219,
0.0014167703,
-0.0009447735,
-0.02018198,
0.0160055403,
-0.0029623702,
0.0323152542,
0.0119038997,
-0.0105492957,
0.0251925476,
0.0032739742,
0.0708102882,
0.0006058844,
-0.0231857058,
-0.0515825264,
-0.0108592575,
0.0194078628,
0.0230051167,
-0.0701196417,
0.0943587124,
-0.0111129284,
-0.0203798208,
-0.0092996927,
-0.029417688,
0.0295153502,
-0.0193361174,
0.0635040849,
0.017577244,
-0.0229088534,
0.0003821677,
0.0783726797,
-0.0619569495,
-0.0214027781,
0.0224586632,
0.0264311433,
0.0463385582,
-0.023243539,
0.034601368,
0.037825875,
-0.0690248013,
-0.0079490254,
0.0586067885,
0.0008962674,
0.0489058383,
0.0336998925,
-0.0321034379,
0.0129851596,
-0.0287751649,
0.0146946078,
-0.0171032548,
0.0101044355,
-0.0099054109,
0.0283154268,
-0.0711152703,
0.0450067855,
0.0118606836,
-0.0069616809,
0.0262423716,
0.0152482754,
0.0350298546,
0.0509389974,
0.0810134038,
0.0733425245,
-0.0195483994,
-0.0730877519,
0.0404886343,
-0.0414741598,
0.009560897,
0.0503852628,
0.0495068207,
0.0009854421,
-0.0505069979,
-0.0441187695,
0.0447042845,
0.0120930225,
0.0586878955,
-0.0076171351,
-0.1082209945,
-0.0833559632,
-0.0400963351,
-0.0535724163,
-0.0111228786,
0.0000478253,
0.0355696864,
0.024001047,
-0.0291529559,
0.0075444095,
-0.0089409733,
-0.066437237,
-0.0522626787,
0.0054188701,
-0.0360699035,
-0.0398864858,
0.035404861,
0.0096896542,
-0.0835393071,
0.0087668179,
-0.0135103464,
0.0456801765,
0.0182413384,
0.0486405157,
-0.0115286699,
0.011594858,
-0.0766654611,
-0.0025017227,
-0.0078675095,
-0.0246384256,
0.0025833307,
0.0179383345,
0.039474126,
0.0364152975,
0.0077086175,
-0.0139105059,
0.0366624072,
-0.0146075655,
-0.0054491102,
-0.002788933,
-0.0104107,
0.0277139116,
-0.0145159997,
-0.0076203151,
-0.0058830706,
0.0069946102,
0.0535254367,
-0.0356600285,
-0.0125623923,
-0.063277863,
2.61e-7,
-0.0025165211,
0.0978939533,
-0.0276992004,
0.0438786186,
0.0312158689,
0.0390318669,
0.0188984424,
0.0320853107,
0.0573822297,
0.0035465581,
-0.0121205095,
0.0377889201,
0.0004561535,
0.0037885429,
-0.0605696291,
0.0089331595,
-0.0869016498,
0.0176586136,
-0.0238552094,
0.0016921462,
0.0140074864,
0.0772934258,
0.0497084819,
0.010280855,
-0.0287623256,
-0.0226973407,
0.0685113147,
-0.0247058291,
0.0119843818,
0.0202518255,
0.0152333286,
0.0142558888,
-0.0051417821,
0.0352043845,
0.0200928506,
0.033324372,
0.0013664289,
0.0384332165,
-0.0155909751,
0.0500995778,
-0.0099928295,
-0.011564564,
-0.0307833832,
-0.0810315683,
0.06319765,
-0.0409636237,
-0.0526866652,
-0.0498533063,
-0.000737444,
-0.0182031859,
0.0508756302,
-0.002062253,
-0.0206861421,
-0.0357597731,
0.0285976361,
0.0134913828,
-0.005395025,
-0.0457729548,
-0.0313219614,
0.0069231451,
-0.0417298041,
-0.0860013291,
-0.0104903933,
0.0346851945,
0.0445500799,
-0.055422768,
0.0246129185,
2.389037755e-34,
0.0348745696,
0.0624844208,
-0.0005046785,
-0.0146917896,
0.023398092,
0.0182308871,
0.0036856241,
0.0031352926,
0.0671589077,
-0.01968785,
-0.0069828187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14905v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14905v1 | Neural approaches to spoken content embedding | 2023-08-28T21:16:08 | 2023-08-28T21:16:08 | Shane Settle | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Comparing spoken segments is a central operation to speech processing.
Traditional approaches in this area have favored frame-level dynamic
programming algorithms, such as dynamic time warping, because they require no
supervision, but they are limited in performance and efficiency. As an
alternative, acoustic word embeddings -- fixed-dimensional vector
representations of variable-length spoken word segments -- have begun to be
considered for such tasks as well. However, the current space of such
discriminative embedding models, training approaches, and their application to
real-world downstream tasks is limited. We start by considering ``single-view"
training losses where the goal is to learn an acoustic word embedding model
that separates same-word and different-word spoken segment pairs. Then, we
consider ``multi-view" contrastive losses. In this setting, acoustic word
embeddings are learned jointly with embeddings of character sequences to
generate acoustically grounded embeddings of written words, or acoustically
grounded word embeddings.
In this thesis, we contribute new discriminative acoustic word embedding
(AWE) and acoustically grounded word embedding (AGWE) approaches based on
recurrent neural networks (RNNs). We improve model training in terms of both
efficiency and performance. We take these developments beyond English to
several low-resource languages and show that multilingual training improves
performance when labeled data is limited. We apply our embedding models, both
monolingual and multilingual, to the downstream tasks of query-by-example
speech search and automatic speech recognition. Finally, we show how our
embedding approaches compare with and complement more recent self-supervised
speech models. | [
-0.0487026311,
0.0473032445,
0.0223402232,
0.0454331189,
-0.0333436653,
-0.0181650147,
0.0178294033,
-0.0207113735,
-0.0224750806,
-0.0214947667,
-0.038786836,
-0.0678569824,
0.0312246047,
-0.0040915897,
0.0531455688,
-0.0431396365,
0.0462667458,
-0.0260016508,
-0.0066627124,
0.0094067957,
0.0087862937,
-0.0052442295,
-0.0270419549,
0.0155365849,
-0.0388333164,
0.017999202,
-0.0058521386,
-0.0010281224,
0.0200532116,
-0.0397889949,
-0.0210248232,
-0.0188545398,
0.0753427818,
0.0120056402,
0.0000017739,
0.006650575,
0.0038069529,
-0.0282378141,
-0.004247345,
0.0211349316,
0.0267179385,
0.0219257213,
0.0168855637,
0.0440588444,
0.0116482833,
-0.0524479635,
0.0272209439,
0.0662539378,
0.0187403373,
0.0524007194,
-0.0259812642,
-0.038583301,
0.02735563,
-0.0596008822,
-0.0309672654,
0.0274485108,
-0.01528941,
-0.0094512617,
-0.0071560969,
0.013771967,
-0.0358021334,
0.0610657856,
0.0020256897,
0.0102172699,
0.0084608551,
0.0577542894,
-0.0125285555,
0.0119258491,
0.0043459479,
0.0871634111,
-0.0314609222,
0.0024723862,
0.0038786563,
-0.0089887492,
-0.0142398858,
-0.0353767276,
-0.0156007335,
0.0068520796,
0.0550930053,
0.0355822109,
-0.0061948355,
0.057156723,
0.0643406436,
0.0106748221,
-0.0020146985,
-0.005595854,
0.0152737685,
-0.0630051941,
-0.0221751854,
-0.035585437,
0.0346193872,
0.0148360124,
0.0171249062,
-0.009548923,
0.0292156525,
0.0170731843,
-0.0139691345,
-0.0372714102,
-0.0127597302,
-0.0539046265,
0.0137671484,
0.0544103198,
-0.0349328183,
0.0426578559,
-0.0300307833,
0.0670686886,
-0.0231350865,
0.0058116433,
-0.0287335273,
0.0024033044,
-0.0377325639,
-0.0241439436,
-0.033627484,
0.0314860158,
-0.0264454465,
-0.0417698249,
-0.0247723553,
0.0218702015,
-0.0115715973,
0.0000560525,
-0.0025218721,
0.0334478207,
-0.0326405019,
0.0297871623,
0.0253526773,
0.0268124193,
-0.0319472961,
0.0249644686,
-0.0257575829,
-0.0217410233,
-0.0348683558,
0.0501335002,
0.0446951464,
-0.0123971496,
0.0039352817,
0.0489450879,
-0.0069456487,
-0.053639669,
-0.0353882909,
-0.0060590534,
-0.0375369675,
-0.0053454367,
0.0003621082,
-0.0593599044,
0.0606604032,
-0.0597442053,
-0.0121461833,
-0.0303839296,
-0.0017272668,
0.019130921,
0.0041480949,
0.1060552374,
0.0718849152,
-0.019539034,
0.0580122098,
0.022907434,
0.0522790961,
0.0431920849,
0.0574108772,
-0.0364225693,
0.0279586539,
-0.0229132418,
-0.0134658758,
0.0308702514,
0.003148583,
0.0105799371,
-0.0729680955,
-0.0179239195,
0.0294756647,
0.0835256204,
0.0451037809,
0.035973046,
-0.0480704606,
-0.0355849713,
0.0525822043,
0.1093526855,
0.0432230793,
0.0243334938,
0.0088265166,
0.0005409266,
-0.0448529609,
-0.002755916,
0.0078373784,
-0.016453214,
0.0344768614,
0.0143198054,
0.0354740247,
-0.0098423278,
-0.0597122349,
-0.0197079126,
0.0103695635,
-0.0420887806,
0.0171889253,
-0.0243374687,
0.0361953564,
-0.020463435,
-0.0634995326,
0.0291501507,
0.0082353093,
-0.0620077737,
0.0202235915,
0.007508392,
-0.0089870207,
0.0302845798,
0.0509120598,
-0.0589211062,
-0.0235351212,
-0.034130387,
0.0158256944,
0.0445028506,
0.0043666782,
-0.0222809855,
0.0483390391,
-0.071884878,
-0.0023353368,
0.0031642623,
-0.0184670705,
0.0591588095,
-0.0292560514,
0.0510334708,
0.0327733643,
-0.044487074,
-0.0049589309,
0.0111104837,
-0.021921441,
-0.0391221717,
0.0317805819,
0.0418952517,
0.0449326746,
0.0382045582,
-0.0034256531,
0.0123551618,
0.0568671003,
-0.0677988902,
-0.0071153017,
0.0158110112,
-0.0948498324,
-0.0635261983,
0.0418029837,
-0.0594812743,
0.0351479203,
0.0339783691,
-0.009447176,
-0.0661536828,
0.0438214019,
-0.0158522334,
0.0462013111,
-0.0589514561,
-0.0002989077,
0.0010300202,
0.0070972899,
-0.0151455468,
0.033899527,
-0.0209954679,
0.0090502128,
0.0200734902,
-0.024262622,
0.0172043853,
-0.0635634288,
-0.0394130684,
0.0604290403,
0.0072623282,
-0.0027673671,
-0.0186280124,
-0.0463285409,
-0.011685323,
0.0140874386,
-0.0313776359,
-0.0028334402,
0.002021543,
0.0180244092,
-0.026000591,
0.0026062066,
0.0201905388,
-0.0323003344,
-0.050128974,
-0.0544003285,
-0.0038993112,
0.0101911006,
0.0301327594,
0.0089884298,
-0.0282529276,
-0.0381705947,
0.0096521406,
-0.0017602788,
0.0135696605,
-0.0352698565,
-0.0324208252,
-0.0144833606,
-0.005269425,
0.0279411692,
0.0285740718,
-0.0105109168,
-0.0337478556,
-0.0264982358,
0.0130273271,
0.0513833128,
0.0376026407,
-0.0041048722,
0.0161532424,
0.0287452508,
-0.0272321422,
-0.0500187501,
0.0163159631,
0.0035847118,
0.0912697241,
-0.0010608974,
0.029473139,
-0.016319938,
0.0423241965,
0.0260017533,
0.0448595285,
-0.036377158,
-0.0437318087,
-0.0256067701,
-0.0057426654,
-0.0303129386,
-0.0705601275,
-0.056043759,
-0.0300737992,
-0.0155863836,
-0.0183664989,
0.0495385043,
-0.0859764293,
-0.0213652067,
-0.0406529978,
-0.0619862005,
-0.0161832999,
0.0268869326,
-0.0289869923,
0.0027774791,
-0.0123163052,
-0.0308914762,
-0.030544715,
0.0049640168,
0.0099675953,
-0.0292968061,
0.0529963635,
0.0166052561,
-0.0213411711,
-0.0255370829,
-0.0408453643,
-0.0296617988,
-0.0353436656,
-0.0054809209,
-0.0000512733,
-0.0168473795,
-0.0263852365,
-0.0370500423,
0.0409265906,
-0.0002937909,
0.0568939261,
0.0147910267,
0.0198241286,
-0.0236476213,
0.0611723587,
0.0132278921,
0.0142627787,
-0.0529219247,
0.0149393789,
0.0410687774,
-0.0077642011,
0.0787807256,
-0.0250835922,
-0.031699352,
-0.0029468494,
0.0109794624,
-0.0156570747,
-0.0363669656,
-0.0132825207,
0.0145977968,
-0.0422941558,
-0.0198948216,
0.1274676621,
0.0057874429,
-0.0215063896,
-0.0122391861,
0.0087141786,
0.0063904966,
0.0084199887,
0.0009868656,
-0.0162986163,
-0.0365137719,
0.0143718412,
0.0245928839,
0.0536179058,
0.0131044649,
-0.009882939,
-0.1042017192,
-0.0027533609,
0.0257481467,
-0.0049843672,
-0.0559566058,
-0.0467948616,
-0.0271613915,
-0.0303537007,
0.0042461655,
-0.0493969172,
-0.0026444539,
-0.0447682664,
0.0397184528,
-0.0558526292,
-0.0307040084,
0.0018817991,
-0.0446682498,
0.0236239396,
0.0285106208,
0.071272485,
-0.0121134361,
-0.0502639599,
0.015552205,
-0.0123702874,
-0.0126947137,
0.0150227481,
0.0144296,
-0.0526700877,
-0.0090712672,
0.0280887559,
0.0356834158,
-0.034390524,
-0.0028030367,
-0.017942369,
0.1111833528,
-0.0115257613,
0.0458607525,
-0.0174643956,
-0.0065164436,
0.0212429389,
0.0817149058,
0.0230657198,
-0.0173847768,
-0.0077448376,
0.0223935768,
0.0630423427,
0.0016492524,
-0.0081235925,
-0.0309464317,
0.0108834999,
0.0225251615,
-0.0806699693,
-0.0529499725,
-0.0024676505,
0.0507806279,
0.0214893222,
-0.0248833355,
0.0094496207,
-0.0163017083,
-0.0675932989,
0.0020273027,
-0.0234392732,
0.0413135253,
-0.0637459233,
0.0185087565,
0.0485774055,
-0.0198435783,
-0.0255184416,
-0.0124347117,
-0.0596527383,
-0.0620454177,
-0.0225758702,
-0.0387741141,
0.0066020009,
0.0746886879,
-0.0367642567,
0.0024659603,
0.0662541315,
-0.007663249,
-0.0369401835,
-0.0007874626,
0.0641937032,
0.0209430978,
-0.026679555,
0.0320615694,
-0.0402316302,
0.0159203131,
-0.0199807435,
-0.0083306599,
-0.0010638048,
-0.0456010588,
-0.0427523628,
-0.0345119983,
0.0714026541,
0.0011248016,
0.0170375593,
-0.0779268816,
0.0225967988,
0.0012815503,
0.0264684353,
-0.0288718715,
0.0003907873,
0.0493840948,
-0.0087865368,
-0.0303690266,
0.013135897,
0.0167932454,
-0.0172842126,
-0.0144937234,
0.0541628599,
0.0517717898,
-0.0084721809,
-0.0383212939,
0.0477845445,
-0.0020188508,
0.0287019461,
-0.0237771701,
0.0246151723,
-0.0237647276,
0.0239578504,
-0.0042226668,
0.0157416817,
-0.001030697,
0.0060781012,
-0.0440441966,
0.0336032882,
-0.0129412571,
-0.0007441408,
0.0050488911,
-0.0737357065,
-0.0016516444,
0.0162905026,
0.0149228675,
-0.0179051608,
-0.0112505574,
-0.055470515,
-0.009314117,
0.0342440419,
0.0395733006,
-0.021634683,
0.0383522213,
0.0971348435,
0.0269215498,
0.0648129284,
-0.0239375979,
0.0130144479,
-0.0329990201,
-0.0055139624,
0.0654932335,
0.0342412256,
-0.0368154757,
-0.0011633192,
-0.017146565,
-0.0448622219,
0.0343246944,
-0.0216650218,
0.0001711188,
0.0162244681,
0.0293468181,
0.0052358359,
-0.0003771659,
0.0644946247,
0.0457756408,
-0.0207670219,
0.0025937946,
-0.0550496876,
-0.0036604602,
-5.752677233e-33,
0.0023537606,
0.0003367082,
-0.0148255052,
-0.0437911116,
-0.0371590555,
0.028436169,
-0.018830264,
-0.0104829818,
-0.019415874,
-0.0134702586,
0.0035931941,
0.0182803851,
0.0232178606,
0.0427929312,
0.007345689,
-0.0296539553,
0.0750361383,
-0.0092603751,
-0.0023729401,
-0.0003713717,
0.0432222784,
0.0420841649,
0.0226389356,
-0.0047908169,
-0.0178834312,
-0.0169879925,
0.0193965305,
0.0358914286,
0.0627203435,
0.0663982108,
-0.0572479255,
0.0186226349,
-0.0125638498,
-0.0318777375,
-0.0257506911,
0.0622292645,
-0.1150316969,
-0.0400237925,
-0.0315622166,
0.0283319745,
-0.0276899617,
0.0007959613,
0.0154877268,
-0.0027360464,
0.0414579213,
-0.0067711645,
0.015553399,
-0.0012703059,
-0.0442327559,
-0.0097996388,
-0.0229777023,
0.0428160541,
-0.0248796456,
-0.0306418575,
0.0702606514,
0.0318815373,
0.0320110433,
0.0073701316,
-0.1045622006,
0.02015814,
-0.0318231098,
0.0270883497,
0.0491643921,
0.017753968,
-0.0177365374,
0.0444200225,
0.0208408851,
-0.0670617595,
0.0218052734,
-0.0417305864,
0.0218998808,
-0.0100370487,
0.0300041623,
-0.0014998482,
0.0365462676,
-0.0305314586,
-0.0330566317,
-0.0199957881,
0.0120760351,
0.0291444324,
0.0356192738,
0.0571489334,
-0.060159184,
-0.0193244573,
-0.0343261063,
-0.0399641395,
-0.0206026714,
-0.0048953937,
0.0584705062,
0.041133251,
-0.0036181016,
0.0088765044,
0.0421613306,
-0.0174598545,
0.0182949379,
0.0109940153,
0.0115537373,
-0.0075414167,
0.0044712229,
0.0108942091,
-0.0327520296,
-0.0026649779,
0.038296856,
0.0242080372,
0.0133047709,
-0.0428016856,
0.051481843,
0.0582727194,
-0.0573662259,
-0.0134044811,
-0.0023223376,
-0.0401189215,
-0.0179024078,
0.0644033551,
0.0479947925,
0.004873082,
0.0116941463,
0.0572431497,
0.0206813607,
-0.0070823552,
-0.0073972433,
-0.0377503559,
-0.0243557412,
0.0291011874,
-0.0076699108,
-0.0081381518,
0.0098322835,
0.0053759492,
0.0318226479,
-0.0625937954,
0.0000505237,
0.0081548868,
2.591e-7,
-0.0294754915,
0.0210332423,
0.0651973113,
-0.0354691595,
0.0126442555,
0.0253828615,
-0.0294242445,
0.020544013,
-0.057221964,
0.0089344736,
0.0416995287,
-0.0081841517,
0.0631761253,
0.0171992816,
-0.1007858291,
0.0202241912,
-0.088797234,
0.0113744251,
-0.0236915238,
-0.0474701449,
0.0102197481,
0.1158982515,
0.009239072,
-0.0059003038,
-0.0354731418,
-0.0414535031,
0.0231954399,
-0.0037051921,
0.0158802886,
-0.0679613501,
0.0011512312,
0.0411438532,
-0.0137227839,
-0.0313369557,
-0.0466838405,
0.0925544277,
0.053605549,
0.0158601813,
0.0127049424,
-0.0578676723,
-0.0107870642,
0.0181747079,
-0.052663818,
0.0251459498,
0.0440106913,
-0.0102165509,
-0.0148087405,
-0.0063937423,
0.0004805115,
0.0199697148,
0.0898516178,
-0.0054785348,
-0.0151435295,
-0.0071181813,
0.0206111409,
-0.0362072214,
-0.0005467827,
-0.0957168564,
0.0253953468,
0.0140578421,
-0.0579764582,
0.0614088848,
-0.055254247,
0.0048791426,
0.0561216213,
-0.0103702238,
-0.0010566345,
2.056950499e-34,
0.0206382703,
-0.0144064389,
-0.0234632846,
0.016865747,
0.0028471625,
-0.0145734102,
-0.0143717136,
-0.0198305026,
0.0634592623,
-0.0444198027,
-0.0300689042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14903v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14903v1 | MEMORY-VQ: Compression for Tractable Internet-Scale Memory | 2023-08-28T21:11:18 | 2023-08-28T21:11:18 | Yury Zemlyanskiy, Michiel de Jong, Luke Vilnis, Santiago Ontañón, William W. Cohen, Sumit Sanghai, Joshua Ainslie | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval augmentation is a powerful but expensive method to make language
models more knowledgeable about the world. Memory-based methods like LUMEN
pre-compute token representations for retrieved passages to drastically speed
up inference. However, memory also leads to much greater storage requirements
from storing pre-computed representations.
We propose MEMORY-VQ, a new method to reduce storage requirements of
memory-augmented models without sacrificing performance. Our method uses a
vector quantization variational autoencoder (VQ-VAE) to compress token
representations. We apply MEMORY-VQ to the LUMEN model to obtain LUMEN-VQ, a
memory model that achieves a 16x compression rate with comparable performance
on the KILT benchmark. LUMEN-VQ enables practical retrieval augmentation even
for extremely large retrieval corpora. | [
0.0166366659,
0.1004185602,
-0.0230046976,
0.0199487973,
-0.0309804603,
-0.0042189583,
-0.0109463874,
-0.0095987525,
-0.0218474139,
-0.0329482406,
0.0101519488,
-0.0354031995,
-0.0290089883,
0.0571168996,
0.0318939537,
-0.0525265932,
0.0706629381,
-0.0038675452,
-0.0136732068,
-0.0244200677,
0.0116963033,
-0.0152148372,
0.023400763,
0.0142404633,
-0.0013048077,
0.0148949102,
-0.0405003019,
-0.0024192717,
-0.0257078186,
0.0130598545,
-0.0131620942,
0.0347957127,
0.0713560134,
0.005097881,
0.0000021637,
-0.0201235134,
-0.0315772668,
-0.0206909478,
-0.0780040547,
0.0356279537,
0.0259604417,
-0.0199668109,
0.0130254142,
-0.0092038596,
0.0212869737,
-0.0654322058,
0.0580187663,
0.0062593115,
0.0561036803,
0.0432194285,
-0.0056415815,
-0.0194901526,
0.0468251333,
-0.0330328867,
0.0257489048,
-0.0494347624,
0.0328047648,
-0.0228281319,
-0.0108069759,
0.0269160047,
-0.06442561,
0.0397206694,
0.0583529584,
0.008498067,
0.0259033889,
0.0118753212,
-0.0491559133,
-0.0212235264,
-0.0175270736,
0.0318413451,
-0.0024618371,
-0.0472140126,
-0.0372834653,
0.0239604693,
-0.0079891589,
-0.0192606132,
-0.060758125,
0.0353511274,
0.040296033,
-0.0036075043,
-0.020518437,
0.0000118044,
0.0412026718,
0.0123311076,
-0.0477749705,
0.0105422745,
0.0384666286,
-0.0137933819,
-0.0196538493,
-0.0203490295,
-0.0628654733,
-0.0021109679,
0.0104164248,
0.0031510969,
-0.0097783627,
-0.0169210844,
-0.0377674103,
-0.0828673914,
0.024682574,
-0.008656159,
0.0337862931,
0.0463699028,
-0.0030508181,
0.0230041444,
-0.0612001084,
0.0774897486,
-0.0324534066,
0.0068307943,
-0.0373992361,
-0.044590652,
-0.0058378922,
-0.0253449585,
-0.0504049174,
0.0425221138,
-0.0228954665,
-0.0145028522,
-0.0346132293,
0.0255110115,
0.0089971134,
-0.0058729295,
-0.0325133614,
0.0404614285,
-0.0194052756,
0.0279782787,
0.0195330027,
0.0282919351,
-0.076755859,
0.0114215892,
0.0140826171,
-0.0276305154,
-0.0255574845,
0.0214227643,
0.0486526713,
-0.0468987338,
0.0240269136,
0.0446221717,
0.0109626399,
-0.0301532652,
0.0034463583,
-0.0070213419,
0.0173605941,
-0.0309475083,
-0.0112793548,
-0.0573601834,
0.0458640568,
-0.0176808592,
-0.0019757096,
0.0120644877,
-0.0080601005,
0.0093008839,
-0.0490500852,
0.0426491089,
0.0083404528,
-0.0414927825,
0.0463354774,
-0.0056638909,
0.0466850214,
0.0304078069,
0.001765581,
0.0390607007,
0.0263525117,
-0.0062589748,
-0.0419785716,
0.0115456106,
0.0797825232,
-0.0156174935,
-0.0595876761,
-0.0034282564,
0.0168770179,
0.0116638681,
0.0682450458,
0.0718290433,
-0.0733213648,
-0.0576035455,
0.0064112889,
0.0492543057,
0.0300857965,
0.013691918,
0.011594072,
0.0159636606,
-0.0197859537,
-0.0311981533,
-0.0243834388,
0.0697730854,
-0.0088685174,
0.0320707746,
0.0866716132,
-0.0006955155,
-0.0284199286,
-0.0323876292,
-0.0084095839,
-0.0327574201,
0.0496310852,
-0.0139090996,
0.0358314924,
0.0299268179,
-0.0127981026,
0.0702942759,
0.0290616564,
-0.0518202856,
0.0146559374,
-0.046109587,
0.000767011,
0.0449531376,
0.0570480302,
0.0173683632,
0.0146061042,
-0.0106140124,
-0.0177504253,
0.0183341485,
0.0086491993,
-0.0024757835,
0.0122642294,
-0.0587976426,
-0.0224896651,
-0.0411858521,
0.0014167662,
0.0161221065,
0.0448020585,
0.0252764821,
0.0252403859,
-0.0353686437,
0.0171186905,
0.008999181,
-0.0060508116,
-0.0078874286,
0.0256326329,
-0.0073028789,
0.0182362571,
0.0111731999,
-0.0108622201,
0.0172747988,
0.0495997109,
-0.0794354752,
-0.0236453954,
-0.0318865404,
-0.0288939551,
-0.0379946493,
0.0233383235,
-0.0151674347,
0.0574657172,
0.052570425,
-0.0276061054,
-0.0405830145,
0.0550355054,
-0.0383473076,
0.0577059649,
-0.0651239902,
-0.0358032025,
0.0195819587,
0.0293079652,
0.0095387967,
0.0482515879,
-0.0509710684,
0.0397799611,
0.0237702038,
0.0622657649,
-0.0045749191,
-0.0377680846,
-0.053109996,
-0.0075442553,
-0.003812205,
0.0190432984,
0.0644333065,
-0.0337041318,
0.0054393848,
0.018046014,
-0.1121457145,
0.0020419213,
-0.0390413553,
-0.026365187,
-0.0129184211,
0.0584396012,
0.0239607897,
-0.0094075352,
-0.018685,
0.0050359694,
-0.0214285105,
0.0605017468,
-0.0012246504,
-0.0055083283,
0.0304882731,
-0.0230512861,
-0.0638507009,
0.0193745494,
0.0683637559,
-0.0560667515,
-0.0131555982,
0.0344961435,
-0.0265804399,
-0.0416471474,
0.0165391918,
-0.0101561295,
-0.0539748035,
-0.0106598744,
-0.0468518697,
0.0332238041,
0.0504876114,
0.0435191393,
0.0285242368,
0.0454668254,
0.0104919914,
-0.0541022606,
0.0320614316,
-0.0489281937,
-0.0288706794,
-0.0002302043,
-0.0050467057,
-0.0166703891,
0.034041632,
-0.0070075681,
0.0176273827,
-0.0542144515,
0.0167677309,
0.0097201308,
-0.0338292383,
-0.0288047865,
0.0086451378,
-0.029122863,
0.0283126049,
-0.0335262492,
-0.0261335485,
0.0543450862,
-0.0131492736,
0.0007102222,
-0.0002673916,
0.0131302392,
-0.0249313097,
0.0535078235,
0.0433023572,
0.051557716,
-0.0785186514,
-0.0208194628,
-0.0112728169,
0.0486518368,
-0.0125265447,
-0.0238569397,
-0.0166115668,
0.0234894939,
0.0103305709,
0.0046692933,
-0.0181557275,
-0.0327407196,
0.0112527758,
0.015590745,
0.0276478343,
0.0399566628,
-0.0107132904,
-0.0373599716,
0.016211234,
-0.000581939,
0.0588546097,
-0.0159947816,
0.0212001838,
-0.0096770078,
0.0105912546,
0.0561150275,
0.025436515,
0.0145919835,
-0.0161904451,
-0.0371993966,
0.0666466877,
0.0098480294,
-0.0111184977,
0.019042803,
0.0491852798,
0.0266859811,
0.001246002,
0.0037803361,
0.0205950476,
0.0148663986,
-0.0311682485,
-0.0530247614,
0.0925047994,
0.0214923676,
-0.0571696609,
-0.0131180668,
-0.0377196334,
0.045271188,
0.0174800754,
0.0152659034,
-0.0925106481,
-0.022098409,
0.0088632498,
0.0121699832,
0.0193602741,
0.0067813941,
0.0090789096,
-0.0690345243,
0.0072684935,
0.0357395411,
0.0031973824,
-0.0263136961,
-0.0502851568,
-0.0291361343,
-0.0143476184,
0.0427069925,
0.0168952253,
0.0223243032,
-0.0021378722,
0.0220458228,
0.0188695136,
-0.0375362709,
0.0014180298,
-0.023650391,
0.0468394384,
0.0718165115,
0.0032185945,
0.0064436751,
-0.0471874364,
-0.019172309,
-0.03218605,
0.0038313472,
-0.0283828769,
0.048116181,
-0.0360699743,
0.004983651,
0.0080299098,
0.0331218317,
0.0014433505,
-0.0508029759,
-0.0247068536,
0.0279279463,
0.0012115708,
0.0016333045,
-0.0348866545,
-0.0615262985,
-0.0634123683,
0.0776019469,
0.0362870023,
-0.0065096985,
-0.0149455704,
-0.015075569,
0.0147809349,
-0.0358928256,
-0.0290185418,
-0.0241851509,
0.0355813429,
-0.0542343035,
-0.0412219279,
-0.0042609973,
0.0001833483,
0.0198450778,
-0.0300971624,
-0.0163521208,
-0.0030364087,
-0.0076878197,
-0.1243236288,
0.0129484814,
-0.0134754293,
-0.0285088103,
-0.0385093205,
-0.0098674791,
-0.01099471,
-0.032267049,
-0.0204813275,
0.0036955234,
-0.0666007251,
-0.0482729264,
0.0246990509,
0.0683185831,
0.0176387317,
0.0803877711,
0.0039075403,
-0.0279708467,
0.0670350194,
0.0316105299,
-0.0600570813,
0.0396592058,
0.0101215867,
-0.0187971946,
0.0047850199,
0.0486194044,
-0.0380592309,
0.0033172651,
-0.0370809659,
0.0579426177,
-0.0172900036,
-0.0180637576,
0.0106367087,
-0.0328200608,
0.0292904414,
0.0019270544,
0.0172178578,
-0.0122511601,
0.0211420581,
-0.0084086964,
0.0104381582,
-0.0370953903,
-0.0120958695,
0.0311110727,
0.0123258643,
-0.010244485,
-0.009741094,
0.0738922507,
-0.0234819576,
0.0011359734,
-0.0427953713,
-0.0114971157,
-0.0065949741,
0.0217947513,
0.0176235009,
-0.0306196213,
-0.0281853247,
-0.008171143,
0.0441956148,
-0.0716663897,
0.0059377295,
0.0015326318,
0.0165906362,
-0.0185288396,
0.0361182764,
-0.0573119074,
-0.0693866014,
-0.0467858501,
0.0165867265,
0.0089812092,
-0.0306975264,
0.0229023043,
-0.0130770607,
-0.0149559509,
-0.0254580881,
-0.0248017125,
0.0052944152,
-0.0480805188,
0.0170427319,
0.0293650925,
-0.0217899233,
-0.0107766353,
0.0473176166,
0.0082412707,
0.0240641665,
-0.0461907201,
0.0102276057,
-0.0259962436,
-0.0285416488,
-0.0121887932,
0.0822767392,
0.0015126439,
-0.0129256528,
-0.0102506224,
-0.0595584773,
0.0111966403,
0.0184492003,
-0.0229716897,
0.0105553884,
0.0451726988,
0.040513128,
0.0157765895,
-0.0415111408,
-0.0227070805,
0.034480121,
-0.000675939,
-0.012613127,
0.0284289736,
-7.062879196e-33,
-0.0421927832,
0.0207929946,
-0.0039750491,
-0.0769071802,
-0.008547199,
0.0447018221,
-0.0349018015,
-0.0357430801,
-0.0105568906,
-0.0200939141,
0.0242231805,
0.0271802973,
-0.0019399329,
0.0585525446,
0.0089928005,
-0.0091680121,
0.0854451805,
0.0076119327,
0.0076590762,
0.044185672,
0.0381622873,
0.041203171,
0.0330284424,
0.0090505239,
0.0069433548,
-0.0180737562,
0.0625834614,
0.0097141853,
0.0332890414,
0.0364215672,
-0.0430330709,
0.0112951789,
-0.0125513552,
-0.0132695781,
-0.0174591597,
-0.0133194989,
-0.1267694384,
-0.034320917,
0.0083647827,
0.0160107985,
-0.0330672637,
-0.0354527906,
0.0471725315,
-0.0080063511,
0.0377556458,
-0.0210529622,
-0.0058956235,
0.0018118701,
-0.0464557782,
-0.0899049342,
-0.0288358703,
-0.0023744339,
0.0077406131,
0.0269453954,
0.0582404919,
-0.0093472032,
-0.0076477663,
0.0255303066,
-0.0849595219,
-0.0130177084,
-0.0323664695,
0.069225736,
0.0579127744,
-0.0029026258,
0.0265565496,
0.065639779,
0.0327862352,
-0.0440308675,
-0.0300961863,
0.0824151263,
0.0712335259,
-0.0112146912,
0.0332052782,
0.0072408845,
0.0739477724,
-0.0342348441,
-0.0613017343,
-0.0069431653,
0.0092780488,
0.0737432316,
0.044477392,
0.0452494174,
-0.009771266,
-0.0458821915,
-0.0174914114,
-0.0363934897,
-0.04963056,
-0.0384029523,
0.0183081366,
0.0239246916,
-0.0323409475,
-0.0522317626,
0.042708382,
-0.0311745889,
-0.0052478393,
0.0408472754,
0.0216614883,
0.0011317515,
-0.0000079249,
0.0344671719,
-0.0328403749,
-0.0042675128,
0.0245148074,
-0.0428360589,
-0.011885047,
0.0138975857,
0.0139221223,
0.0459640771,
-0.0436866917,
-0.0282644592,
-0.0378866009,
-0.0295123979,
0.0085212905,
0.010596415,
0.0383444875,
0.0613513365,
-0.0022312817,
0.050575655,
0.000116712,
0.0250221342,
-0.0219054986,
-0.0606053732,
0.0343045294,
0.0455707982,
-0.039148882,
-0.019379016,
-0.0695331469,
0.0522613861,
0.0243493263,
-0.0907008946,
0.0050893868,
0.0457997285,
2.868e-7,
0.0304111522,
0.0293670297,
0.0508781523,
-0.0431429297,
0.0009489945,
0.0098133134,
0.0204421151,
0.0459794998,
0.0057722819,
-0.0123596415,
0.0083227837,
0.0773559436,
-0.0046414062,
0.0056207967,
-0.0744717419,
0.0126406578,
-0.066053994,
-0.0372442305,
-0.0332105085,
-0.0018508608,
0.041345071,
0.1410203725,
0.0127240233,
0.0114328768,
0.0425018854,
-0.017093176,
0.0691036209,
-0.001138674,
-0.033538755,
0.000129476,
0.0390275419,
0.0555429533,
-0.0136153111,
-0.0221349187,
-0.0112890527,
0.0076272963,
0.0011318835,
0.0426785983,
-0.007942697,
-0.0684055462,
-0.018873943,
-0.0338646285,
-0.0302054584,
-0.0046723145,
0.0715781525,
-0.0217007063,
-0.0093329558,
-0.0294711236,
-0.0389970504,
0.036539793,
0.0225327667,
0.0096888375,
-0.0103233708,
0.029683033,
0.0175962672,
0.0264191832,
0.003842392,
-0.1097107008,
-0.0114018638,
-0.000315643,
-0.0334640145,
-0.0018153728,
-0.0563535132,
0.0116565991,
0.0178018883,
-0.0264070295,
-0.0252496954,
2.787646512e-34,
0.0398457348,
0.0279035047,
0.0029549534,
0.0204953291,
-0.0025746909,
-0.0444656536,
0.0121349441,
0.0172139294,
-0.0218467675,
-0.074853152,
-0.0578122549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14894v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14894v1 | Multiscale Contextual Learning for Speech Emotion Recognition in Emergency Call Center Conversations | 2023-08-28T20:31:45 | 2023-08-28T20:31:45 | Théo Deschamps-Berger, Lori Lamel, Laurence Devillers | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Emotion recognition in conversations is essential for ensuring advanced
human-machine interactions. However, creating robust and accurate emotion
recognition systems in real life is challenging, mainly due to the scarcity of
emotion datasets collected in the wild and the inability to take into account
the dialogue context. The CEMO dataset, composed of conversations between
agents and patients during emergency calls to a French call center, fills this
gap. The nature of these interactions highlights the role of the emotional flow
of the conversation in predicting patient emotions, as context can often make a
difference in understanding actual feelings. This paper presents a multi-scale
conversational context learning approach for speech emotion recognition, which
takes advantage of this hypothesis. We investigated this approach on both
speech transcriptions and acoustic segments. Experimentally, our method uses
the previous or next information of the targeted segment. In the text domain,
we tested the context window using a wide range of tokens (from 10 to 100) and
at the speech turns level, considering inputs from both the same and opposing
speakers. According to our tests, the context derived from previous tokens has
a more significant influence on accurate prediction than the following tokens.
Furthermore, taking the last speech turn of the same speaker in the
conversation seems useful. In the acoustic domain, we conducted an in-depth
analysis of the impact of the surrounding emotions on the prediction. While
multi-scale conversational context learning using Transformers can enhance
performance in the textual modality for emergency call recordings,
incorporating acoustic context is more challenging. | [
-0.0109620681,
0.0343468562,
-0.0069949683,
0.0137614338,
-0.0034417543,
0.0170345306,
0.0534231849,
-0.0435022004,
-0.02374354,
-0.0423346832,
-0.0583531447,
-0.0596632212,
0.0025986938,
0.0221738908,
-0.0366631038,
-0.083305493,
0.0016964496,
0.0286480524,
0.0334418416,
0.0137687409,
0.0120684775,
0.023238318,
-0.048759032,
0.0302184131,
-0.0531141944,
0.0024370383,
-0.0320765898,
0.0279624406,
0.0696029142,
-0.0334985703,
0.0244612042,
0.035195455,
0.0489484966,
0.0198778044,
0.0000019108,
0.0007525,
-0.0236946158,
0.0009534001,
-0.0447344631,
-0.0647510886,
0.0540833883,
-0.0087599,
-0.0493029505,
0.0143312514,
-0.0068088919,
-0.0125430357,
0.0492792912,
0.0989693701,
0.0915488824,
0.0557003096,
-0.0430198796,
-0.0198701303,
-0.0139234671,
-0.0044903909,
-0.0074894228,
-0.0534558557,
0.0098791551,
-0.0020496969,
0.0178318638,
-0.0547440983,
-0.0104773678,
0.0065642116,
0.0011205706,
0.0214919783,
-0.0042130663,
0.0231409632,
-0.0395400003,
-0.0166083425,
-0.0188089889,
0.1032334566,
-0.0163361859,
0.0360362455,
-0.0004974426,
-0.0146924658,
-0.0365805849,
-0.045905184,
-0.0367489606,
-0.0417676866,
0.0028408014,
0.0108290091,
-0.0263123084,
0.0625594705,
0.0016360332,
-0.0137175815,
-0.0387516804,
-0.0085392278,
-0.0302357301,
-0.0357840285,
0.0349441916,
-0.0065868543,
-0.0200751424,
0.0417628177,
0.0099706957,
-0.0274799131,
-0.063713789,
0.0199447051,
-0.0184882544,
-0.0018725486,
-0.0123642525,
-0.0663210303,
-0.0585822947,
0.0064101578,
-0.0532436408,
0.0030884687,
0.0442138277,
-0.003230263,
-0.0137713952,
-0.0519577637,
-0.0475864895,
-0.0036982251,
-0.0252407957,
0.0589488931,
-0.0121932579,
0.0012850296,
-0.0199877918,
-0.0060209916,
-0.1058325246,
0.0000049446,
-0.0267952345,
0.0137938838,
0.011559003,
-0.0033749787,
-0.0050389171,
0.0082946038,
0.0403757133,
0.0370835401,
0.0071263383,
0.0559176654,
-0.0073769945,
-0.0710289031,
0.0223294273,
-0.002537431,
0.045814164,
0.0105663994,
0.0085006449,
0.026373405,
-0.0105163204,
-0.0165530816,
-0.0235828403,
-0.0101663787,
-0.0415104702,
-0.0309873037,
-0.0175576936,
-0.0077329883,
0.0378440097,
-0.0071153012,
0.0083668642,
0.0311643295,
0.0104790106,
-0.0303309783,
-0.0180843566,
0.0711162388,
0.0230234805,
-0.0100357244,
0.0180942807,
0.0283904821,
-0.0075193699,
0.0257129278,
0.0307448246,
-0.0068049398,
0.0443545729,
-0.0653302148,
0.0438151173,
0.0295329038,
0.0174676795,
-0.0504755341,
0.011405047,
-0.0204127543,
0.0053904974,
0.0478608198,
0.0076245456,
0.0271132011,
-0.0343308225,
-0.0157162733,
-0.0020747792,
0.06068426,
-0.0181678627,
0.0419183932,
-0.0212200079,
0.005793028,
-0.0239575878,
-0.0153427534,
-0.0192199033,
-0.0108505255,
0.0013053048,
0.0018397523,
0.0127671892,
-0.005277406,
-0.0236504115,
-0.0100920228,
-0.0069103437,
-0.001516798,
-0.0491726138,
0.0008557924,
0.0440421849,
-0.0324187092,
-0.0612258874,
0.024423413,
0.0034615039,
-0.0789874494,
-0.0286885183,
-0.0270586852,
-0.0438173711,
0.0782031044,
-0.0036651832,
-0.056677483,
-0.0487220623,
-0.0493512787,
0.0086533967,
-0.0017695006,
-0.0009410215,
-0.0078795142,
0.067801863,
-0.0669618919,
0.0124073522,
0.0349832512,
-0.0209968332,
0.0069634491,
-0.0418080799,
0.0233826041,
-0.017843714,
-0.0025938149,
0.0682362467,
-0.0187407546,
-0.0169273093,
-0.0076827332,
0.009843559,
0.0303058382,
0.0672874823,
0.0288051646,
-0.0308742877,
-0.0430740342,
0.0264329929,
-0.0066478364,
-0.0140545703,
0.0690456852,
-0.1028840542,
-0.0365194902,
0.0068626036,
-0.0002462099,
0.0063124443,
-0.0138353482,
-0.0405236073,
-0.0212864149,
0.0164821874,
0.0103296191,
0.0703907013,
-0.0073776091,
0.0270581637,
0.0418837778,
0.0462024324,
0.016688047,
0.014679322,
0.0057433415,
0.017607348,
0.0167286899,
0.0357619375,
-0.0004948506,
-0.0088848099,
-0.0050377795,
0.0112904701,
-0.0070388969,
0.0006531808,
-0.0220879521,
-0.0256619342,
-0.0542002767,
-0.0458952487,
-0.1294046193,
-0.0210222695,
-0.0236353874,
-0.0144502148,
0.0006923665,
0.0351308659,
-0.0180219617,
-0.0307922661,
-0.0162667297,
-0.0006397216,
0.0225836579,
-0.0094484603,
-0.0198721308,
0.0217638854,
-0.0166362673,
-0.0345736928,
0.0200019497,
-0.0207187328,
0.0293939617,
-0.0192978904,
-0.0224892087,
-0.003772578,
-0.015228034,
0.00959606,
0.0374566093,
-0.0407720432,
-0.0308337063,
-0.0012021416,
0.0002618453,
0.0202237219,
0.0416279137,
0.0284719057,
0.0775158852,
-0.0169216003,
0.0013575378,
0.0016903622,
0.0572351515,
-0.0183794852,
-0.0018887558,
-0.0309987068,
-0.0045924569,
-0.0256618578,
0.0554620028,
0.0115579013,
0.0482369848,
-0.0183528047,
-0.0710895956,
0.0161405541,
-0.0400270671,
-0.0108413361,
-0.0420928113,
-0.0283530727,
-0.0109962653,
0.0402311608,
-0.0089179538,
0.0033570998,
-0.0066660442,
-0.0259898342,
-0.076411128,
-0.0484873578,
-0.0169431288,
0.0516966246,
-0.0707484111,
0.0055158832,
0.0240637511,
-0.0158335902,
0.0076056556,
-0.0132085634,
-0.0352019705,
-0.0654158816,
0.0372329913,
-0.0368004516,
-0.0269666146,
0.0250131562,
-0.0614670925,
-0.0738813877,
-0.0122442991,
-0.0457628965,
-0.0030787855,
0.0404850803,
-0.0047085905,
-0.0778168291,
-0.017630741,
0.0166300498,
0.0448861718,
0.0565841943,
-0.0024733457,
0.0324872062,
0.0770003498,
0.0153707173,
0.0627795607,
0.0088045085,
0.0023442835,
0.072024934,
0.0349991992,
0.0599698052,
-0.0196568072,
-0.0063407379,
0.0385838002,
0.0078122416,
0.0187624041,
-0.0265500937,
-0.0065649482,
0.0254140981,
-0.0128607657,
0.0159463678,
0.1297454536,
0.0364722759,
-0.0683068186,
0.0103130918,
-0.0517030694,
-0.0340877622,
0.0079722684,
0.007393904,
-0.0095802853,
-0.0328309387,
0.0232337862,
0.0141029069,
-0.0048439372,
-0.0064378735,
0.0010465796,
-0.03412861,
0.0558897816,
-0.0048132692,
-0.0695339516,
-0.0410522744,
-0.0403135344,
0.0347450078,
-0.052972246,
0.0333513655,
-0.0544103086,
-0.0052515026,
-0.0610885359,
0.0365005434,
-0.0417358652,
-0.0429473035,
0.0330860242,
-0.0217723921,
0.056136664,
0.0081317881,
0.0544815697,
-0.0042785159,
0.0153853483,
0.0522901304,
0.0069695641,
0.0124657098,
-0.0082012098,
0.041367434,
-0.0377504341,
0.0069948798,
-0.0001308959,
0.0509554185,
-0.0133446185,
-0.0242934935,
0.0066469521,
0.0621288158,
-0.0561889522,
-0.0150941703,
-0.0310681183,
0.0624780357,
0.0513592474,
0.0400501862,
-0.0223836154,
-0.0240707248,
-0.0007037647,
0.0078252796,
0.0621288754,
0.0270347949,
0.0032508727,
-0.0008971842,
0.0052675442,
-0.0421016142,
-0.0361280888,
-0.0174541268,
0.0167775471,
0.0287126694,
-0.0370608047,
-0.0528766215,
0.0232605841,
0.056271255,
-0.025692191,
-0.0089374203,
0.0570917353,
0.031264089,
-0.0517628379,
0.021200072,
0.0880456716,
-0.0026777855,
-0.0157860368,
0.0048015402,
-0.0188208483,
-0.0289372392,
0.0506080687,
-0.0114644449,
0.006836805,
0.0397270881,
0.0294938181,
0.0130240517,
0.0394474976,
0.0373481028,
-0.0384912975,
-0.0117404647,
0.0803137273,
0.0385119244,
-0.0342164896,
0.0033312324,
-0.0388033316,
0.0833732858,
-0.0284581482,
0.016160341,
-0.0659851506,
-0.0566295609,
-0.0348281153,
-0.0204710364,
0.0730606169,
0.0082484959,
-0.0183076374,
-0.0206922293,
0.0471791364,
0.004794043,
0.0407778062,
-0.0278446749,
-0.0185992327,
-0.0521715805,
-0.0096910531,
-0.0281340051,
-0.0488565303,
-0.0201470535,
-0.0505516417,
0.013182207,
0.0680025816,
0.0431209728,
-0.0233261269,
0.0034831553,
0.0092844376,
0.0056281146,
0.0217742603,
0.0477146544,
0.0089986743,
-0.0002754075,
0.0656927228,
0.0060216938,
-0.0010110952,
0.0046790261,
0.0411509387,
-0.0401966386,
0.0422770232,
-0.0575369373,
-0.0093672723,
0.0009803027,
-0.0279426631,
0.0109888259,
-0.0231675263,
0.0275509898,
-0.0051412201,
0.0421884172,
-0.0518881157,
-0.0282911099,
0.0223580282,
-0.0102822594,
-0.0127125261,
0.0371609144,
0.040623948,
-0.0452523939,
0.0557938479,
-0.0078417081,
0.0025317341,
-0.0657877922,
-0.0182572808,
0.0339795128,
-0.0110425381,
0.0018668959,
0.0137296338,
-0.0543872677,
-0.0397443436,
0.0442109853,
-0.0549812354,
-0.0129393693,
-0.0343557075,
0.0304776169,
0.0302403923,
-0.0152656278,
0.043731425,
0.0020947384,
-0.0003781121,
-0.0339748263,
-0.0158813987,
0.003393797,
-5.439227991e-33,
0.0270323567,
-0.0092034861,
-0.028805187,
0.0181074589,
-0.0228492822,
0.057849668,
0.0094571617,
0.0226428993,
-0.0034820244,
0.0173322074,
-0.0188470576,
0.0195278097,
0.0183340218,
0.0108220456,
-0.0158907976,
-0.0583475307,
0.0643557161,
-0.0239096433,
0.01500588,
0.0476277843,
0.0270120651,
0.0526250862,
0.04955367,
-0.0992358103,
-0.030726634,
-0.0000522219,
-0.0307644736,
0.0014457632,
0.0573481135,
0.0148234367,
0.0020098258,
0.028932631,
-0.0005678096,
-0.0437848419,
0.0110021774,
0.0450552665,
-0.0402456857,
-0.0008008254,
-0.035015706,
0.0289286096,
-0.0224229302,
-0.0134641435,
0.0167009141,
0.0280111339,
-0.0075836009,
-0.0450402275,
0.0265640765,
-0.0110969357,
-0.0118481452,
-0.0816720277,
0.0135366647,
0.0336558037,
-0.0551487878,
-0.0334003307,
0.0258197337,
0.0562321208,
0.0056670196,
0.0013820763,
-0.0262736473,
0.0079329479,
-0.0243791603,
-0.0225150753,
-0.0009428225,
-0.0169807542,
-0.0171309263,
0.0871015638,
0.0437355451,
-0.0223314166,
-0.0092464443,
-0.030262338,
-0.0029865585,
0.0764598623,
-0.0117968582,
0.0416169874,
-0.0180547405,
-0.0298380759,
-0.0326660722,
0.0421884619,
0.0197964236,
0.0001882835,
0.0391409695,
-0.0082788058,
-0.0320394933,
0.017148288,
0.0013320714,
0.0063288338,
0.0115090013,
0.0157739054,
0.0220670495,
-0.0176728088,
0.0591675825,
-0.001724828,
0.0325392671,
-0.0219586305,
0.0383252725,
0.0309439227,
0.0053241025,
0.0278872289,
-0.0130703868,
0.001372712,
-0.0437992662,
-0.01602773,
0.0620925874,
0.0516353697,
0.0586920306,
-0.0535697341,
-0.0110385502,
0.0439525507,
-0.0401631035,
-0.0128276031,
0.0183668733,
0.0435648486,
-0.0201699287,
0.0441450141,
0.0141118728,
0.010658131,
-0.0147060947,
0.0086159036,
-0.0291538071,
0.051599782,
-0.005573296,
-0.0363709405,
-0.002810885,
0.0400401279,
-0.0818378702,
-0.0078224353,
-0.0077340305,
-0.0495966226,
0.0381420031,
-0.0229779612,
-0.0082620448,
0.0008387631,
2.784e-7,
-0.0369083621,
0.0568155833,
0.0340725146,
-0.0594517924,
0.0378455594,
0.0435139574,
-0.0187585466,
0.0114044659,
0.0098874532,
-0.0045847781,
0.1080673561,
-0.0480804183,
0.0925402492,
0.0537045412,
-0.1000921503,
-0.0189410858,
-0.0707646981,
-0.0204864964,
0.0029874698,
0.0198347233,
0.0643963665,
0.1025912911,
0.0078405179,
-0.0240764003,
0.0159482956,
0.0686575249,
-0.0009612733,
-0.0666110367,
0.0216108784,
-0.0114600658,
-0.0392256416,
0.0072186925,
-0.0129084215,
0.0139821488,
-0.0172354188,
0.0003077621,
0.0335917547,
0.0707805678,
0.0174907446,
-0.0592958406,
0.0053981426,
0.0461597741,
-0.0080126161,
-0.0067439848,
0.020538168,
-0.0502273738,
-0.0251972545,
-0.0472737215,
-0.0562279187,
-0.0042050993,
0.011428481,
0.0081150588,
-0.0292153116,
0.044549983,
-0.0065249209,
-0.0136094783,
-0.0427479446,
-0.0978687257,
0.0243231151,
0.0568039753,
-0.0345368423,
-0.022287311,
0.0259459838,
-0.032825131,
0.0542688593,
-0.0161888674,
0.0136307292,
1.663996398e-34,
0.0272678323,
-0.0319956578,
-0.0271253008,
0.0482541956,
0.0047104028,
-0.0155344969,
0.0077375849,
-0.0180172697,
0.0493581146,
-0.0424337201,
0.0175554976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14873v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14873v1 | CommunityFish: A Poisson-based Document Scaling With Hierarchical Clustering | 2023-08-28T19:52:18 | 2023-08-28T19:52:18 | Sami Diaf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI | Document scaling has been a key component in text-as-data applications for
social scientists and a major field of interest for political researchers, who
aim at uncovering differences between speakers or parties with the help of
different probabilistic and non-probabilistic approaches. Yet, most of these
techniques are either built upon the agnostically bag-of-word hypothesis or use
prior information borrowed from external sources that might embed the results
with a significant bias. If the corpus has long been considered as a collection
of documents, it can also be seen as a dense network of connected words whose
structure could be clustered to differentiate independent groups of words,
based on their co-occurrences in documents, known as communities. This paper
introduces CommunityFish as an augmented version of Wordfish based on a
hierarchical clustering, namely the Louvain algorithm, on the word space to
yield communities as semantic and independent n-grams emerging from the corpus
and use them as an input to Wordfish method, instead of considering the word
space. This strategy emphasizes the interpretability of the results, since
communities have a non-overlapping structure, hence a crucial informative power
in discriminating parties or speakers, in addition to allowing a faster
execution of the Poisson scaling model. Aside from yielding communities,
assumed to be subtopic proxies, the application of this technique outperforms
the classic Wordfish model by highlighting historical developments in the U.S.
State of the Union addresses and was found to replicate the prevailing
political stance in Germany when using the corpus of parties' legislative
manifestos. | [
0.0025588786,
0.0318831056,
-0.0223190747,
0.0130782919,
-0.0531743653,
0.0009533648,
0.0076036397,
0.0200260505,
0.0066095949,
-0.0277585052,
0.0242618956,
-0.0400489867,
0.0161648467,
0.0138166072,
-0.0130159175,
-0.0847895592,
0.0408411771,
0.0271293595,
0.0059798574,
-0.0313452445,
0.0215485301,
-0.0142564969,
0.0322541744,
0.0111755459,
0.0196967367,
0.0210135262,
-0.0489663854,
-0.0151870241,
0.0535317957,
0.0215338375,
-0.0178675372,
0.0341353863,
0.0003037634,
0.0386924036,
0.0000018915,
-0.015810838,
-0.02428535,
-0.0295068473,
0.0754483119,
-0.0073292488,
0.0712286606,
-0.0082901288,
0.0021043113,
0.0187252909,
-0.0079388227,
0.0268401541,
0.0416263863,
0.0146278609,
0.0234578121,
0.0216388758,
-0.0153436335,
-0.0882904828,
0.0015777306,
-0.0185157843,
-0.0113977287,
0.005943839,
0.0340912826,
0.0137837566,
-0.004870127,
0.0071843513,
-0.0164914913,
0.0096235536,
-0.0338468179,
-0.031592004,
-0.0100417081,
0.029754512,
-0.0016697623,
-0.0277728476,
0.0250654854,
0.0384540781,
0.0202255975,
-0.0259634405,
0.0322566256,
-0.0091381334,
-0.0120635536,
0.1078796312,
-0.0152536696,
0.0027477834,
-0.0154996989,
0.0055572661,
0.0497988835,
0.0363224596,
-0.0015780287,
0.0335386246,
-0.0680400729,
0.0867477581,
-0.0075074942,
0.018080255,
-0.0245176833,
-0.0408766381,
-0.0144322161,
0.0051914435,
0.0536832586,
0.0085980017,
0.0469111614,
0.0245941002,
0.0390036628,
0.0059473868,
0.0461288579,
-0.0391915478,
-0.0276982803,
-0.0507168435,
0.0107692964,
0.0628487021,
0.0648870841,
-0.0575246587,
-0.0021859044,
-0.0338439867,
-0.0179222096,
-0.005661055,
-0.0368167758,
0.0121230492,
-0.0189823005,
0.0088870497,
-0.0266700555,
-0.0128764659,
-0.0125813447,
0.0128910216,
0.0010015836,
-0.0286182687,
-0.0084215971,
0.0080588879,
0.0066780341,
-0.019693749,
-0.0156973377,
0.0590994656,
-0.0837425366,
0.0233580228,
-0.0405588113,
0.0308591798,
0.0376707092,
0.0411405936,
0.0247186497,
-0.0120354081,
-0.0257130414,
-0.0300143827,
-0.0076201451,
0.003684714,
-0.0030893241,
0.0051683509,
-0.0558187068,
-0.020964345,
-0.0154905906,
-0.0934841484,
0.0441383496,
-0.0138790458,
-0.0015409472,
-0.0139523838,
-0.0088964719,
-0.0109296432,
-0.0405336134,
0.0284815598,
0.0124774445,
0.0273684189,
0.0703659803,
0.0098537458,
0.0307142567,
0.0491741784,
0.0284537617,
-0.0177339539,
0.065411374,
-0.0107885469,
-0.0121027017,
0.0145674394,
0.0033741882,
0.0402174294,
-0.0176149085,
0.0171131808,
-0.0085675521,
-0.0492253043,
0.0495687835,
0.0406967215,
-0.022208713,
-0.0488532037,
0.0224039536,
0.0832963288,
-0.022866603,
0.0309309363,
-0.047062058,
0.0364555418,
0.0076444233,
0.0300799906,
0.0414830483,
-0.0343729742,
-0.0151805738,
-0.0402137153,
0.044316709,
0.0088163586,
-0.0276687648,
-0.0044285622,
0.0080751423,
0.0208228994,
0.0427531451,
-0.0801849589,
0.0522545688,
-0.0167427137,
0.0136849051,
0.0076739043,
0.033098679,
-0.0118638333,
0.0380743705,
-0.039614141,
-0.0019946571,
-0.0016879946,
0.0412153304,
-0.0396296903,
0.0663207397,
-0.0112572908,
-0.0132378228,
0.0125434911,
0.0068823886,
-0.0337001942,
-0.0590953939,
-0.0406826586,
0.0445816331,
0.057327576,
0.0104218284,
0.0272510145,
0.0125615504,
0.04031495,
-0.0123952264,
-0.0322566256,
-0.0045157,
0.0229915623,
0.0558481179,
0.0352471359,
0.0055519361,
-0.0230811108,
0.0320547633,
0.0191718414,
-0.015274887,
-0.0261333045,
0.031767346,
0.0108975451,
-0.0127062695,
-0.0037045479,
0.0302346721,
0.0110156992,
-0.0064471005,
-0.0570883788,
0.0488066189,
0.0434112288,
0.0084598074,
-0.0175257269,
0.0357015692,
-0.0083548566,
0.03666218,
-0.0197028946,
0.0417917371,
-0.061911799,
-0.0116240885,
-0.0705900416,
0.0858722702,
0.0093565732,
0.0282929409,
-0.0654731691,
0.0367121883,
0.0015453256,
-0.0543846749,
-0.0102904057,
0.0195906274,
0.0470746309,
0.0091368919,
0.0398671404,
-0.0630419776,
-0.0196371898,
-0.0670026988,
-0.0432438441,
-0.0166938845,
-0.0175288897,
0.0445281751,
0.0297012497,
-0.0176044572,
0.0089725927,
0.0260272138,
-0.0090464354,
-0.0224454813,
-0.020730231,
-0.0110603496,
0.0599758737,
-0.0235438645,
-0.0142301228,
-0.0385719016,
-0.0260657389,
-0.0076320535,
0.0219686478,
0.0393046215,
-0.0767817497,
0.0062068813,
0.0661677569,
-0.0536778606,
-0.0237497278,
-0.0294153765,
-0.0036957006,
-0.0195711441,
0.0091756135,
0.0413390733,
0.0377577431,
0.0761296898,
0.0751656368,
0.0078321593,
0.0257281028,
-0.04566627,
-0.0464190394,
-0.0658537075,
0.0512593761,
-0.0336050577,
-0.0290972777,
0.0308192279,
0.0074644447,
0.0064280666,
0.0012184946,
0.0019194459,
0.0133488877,
-0.0182387494,
0.0012782401,
-0.0346874148,
-0.0457766429,
-0.0188432541,
-0.0113989068,
0.0170532353,
-0.0665390864,
-0.0258236546,
0.0359126553,
0.0619128533,
-0.0629251599,
-0.0312165022,
-0.0114542814,
0.0727709681,
0.0520215109,
0.0171627793,
-0.0535538755,
0.0089162588,
-0.0055365949,
-0.0056967,
0.0610786267,
-0.0247399956,
0.0238974039,
-0.0110889236,
0.0261073839,
0.002954897,
-0.0129335187,
-0.0047730673,
-0.0321858674,
0.0056200325,
-0.0164289381,
0.0854029208,
-0.0588955991,
-0.0601112433,
0.0479893051,
0.0316397771,
-0.021098217,
0.0047700605,
-0.008335432,
0.0134937763,
0.0879650265,
-0.0342254639,
-0.0199562758,
0.0308169946,
-0.0108612841,
-0.0457056426,
0.0438405015,
0.039374575,
-0.0046170135,
0.0026244249,
-0.055156,
-0.0216715671,
-0.0424643457,
-0.0167791415,
-0.0321414545,
-0.0074630566,
0.0095740752,
0.0113906451,
0.0624900497,
0.0599040166,
-0.0736463964,
0.0173418112,
0.0175943654,
0.0240090992,
-0.0018345121,
0.0057012779,
-0.0275521968,
0.0514411889,
-0.0011208706,
-0.0055499962,
-0.0306018852,
-0.0509566851,
0.0048145689,
-0.0325943679,
0.0386543088,
0.0350959934,
-0.0277365968,
0.0243980531,
-0.0979832038,
0.036416091,
-0.0116731357,
-0.1028404534,
0.0120792193,
-0.018197028,
0.0032132305,
-0.0152952159,
-0.0883477107,
-0.0578532442,
-0.0037770835,
-0.0174127072,
0.0441453941,
-0.014462621,
0.0627067387,
-0.0265609138,
0.00802352,
0.0153022856,
-0.0312467571,
-0.0152799757,
-0.0049292766,
0.0329896286,
0.0174811073,
0.0317738764,
-0.0525908843,
0.0304438062,
0.0382246152,
-0.0395841897,
0.051557567,
0.0107140224,
-0.0387242064,
-0.0522896349,
-0.0187485348,
0.0236961264,
0.021414794,
0.049715288,
0.0139282215,
0.0022994338,
0.0021105849,
0.0136579657,
0.0272339452,
0.066249378,
-0.0267611165,
-0.008681369,
-0.0039433106,
-0.025352668,
-0.0392083116,
-0.0302161854,
-0.0236096662,
0.0868828595,
-0.006655091,
-0.0077537186,
0.0297699608,
-0.0247326922,
-0.0271013845,
-0.007184241,
-0.0103684934,
-0.005721496,
-0.0355476625,
-0.0579628125,
0.033733435,
0.0409933701,
-0.0406907201,
-0.0240562372,
-0.0372309014,
-0.040449854,
0.0441730656,
-0.0962990522,
0.0325230509,
0.0245286133,
-0.0415415317,
-0.0474849083,
0.0579296164,
0.089875266,
-0.0251906775,
0.0159328207,
-0.0174961668,
0.0024169916,
-0.010950692,
0.0133084729,
0.0133441063,
0.0446315929,
-0.0121827004,
-0.0305287633,
-0.097679548,
-0.0437043086,
-0.0545313396,
0.0194043443,
0.0062053115,
-0.03031848,
-0.0284324102,
-0.0382637754,
-0.0451013595,
-0.003376771,
0.0082358625,
0.0382448994,
-0.012374796,
-0.0085419239,
-0.0125291841,
-0.0496399626,
0.0520900711,
-0.0218318645,
0.004033837,
-0.0063389149,
0.0629733652,
0.0410771929,
0.0170969907,
0.0156420711,
-0.0022501205,
0.0104507497,
-0.0040470548,
0.0031293309,
0.0604123548,
0.0318189748,
0.0188996214,
0.0242814738,
-0.0207155049,
-0.0273980387,
0.0227279738,
-0.0897299647,
0.0258084238,
-0.0432661287,
0.033891961,
-0.049350366,
0.0016765774,
0.0054550702,
-0.0203601066,
-0.0242704842,
-0.032924775,
0.0030841322,
0.0093504852,
-0.0264202729,
0.0037477242,
0.020024782,
-0.0496618114,
0.0449843444,
0.0273941047,
-0.0502471216,
-0.022620203,
0.0230228174,
-0.022521941,
-0.003914657,
-0.0432713293,
-0.0116897235,
0.0388297215,
-0.0186103359,
-0.0495176017,
-0.0855138227,
0.0254261624,
0.0117833,
0.0354046151,
0.0218603145,
0.0542387702,
0.0139865,
0.0581266433,
-0.0132690547,
0.0647044033,
-0.0636354685,
0.058100719,
-0.0548517145,
-0.0122246342,
0.0391492136,
-6.005096645e-33,
-0.034389209,
-0.0689964369,
-0.0510431118,
0.0083782095,
-0.0166673474,
-0.0007198213,
0.0211067237,
0.0106022591,
0.0049915495,
0.028302351,
-0.0102740163,
0.0406798944,
0.0214677416,
-0.0450554192,
0.0068013547,
0.0027667673,
0.0066327155,
0.0060364283,
-0.0095717385,
0.0485312827,
0.0474620275,
-0.0190429557,
-0.0167910159,
-0.0462589748,
0.0577965043,
0.0076088086,
-0.0274287984,
-0.016078677,
0.0471409373,
-0.0000100114,
-0.013406503,
0.0052912957,
0.0215454791,
0.0012036999,
0.0174755845,
0.060516756,
-0.0675863549,
-0.0504542887,
0.0006590533,
0.0016317364,
0.0127681466,
0.018036779,
0.020621093,
0.0198010467,
-0.0276676361,
-0.0035376984,
0.069928132,
0.0029312472,
-0.0109761385,
-0.0057473038,
-0.0355815254,
0.0739554241,
-0.0156427566,
0.064751789,
-0.0367183723,
-0.0306143537,
0.0184848271,
0.035401877,
-0.0813641101,
0.056199979,
0.0243548471,
-0.0056558386,
-0.0013060033,
0.0373493321,
0.01784968,
0.0824902803,
0.0349402539,
0.0193489436,
-0.0228324793,
0.0124271214,
0.058796037,
-0.0112771224,
0.0252411719,
0.0520244874,
0.0144972093,
-0.0049043749,
-0.0768094808,
0.0719700679,
0.0434355773,
-0.0528483428,
0.0040370049,
-0.0127404351,
-0.0376691259,
-0.0237319805,
-0.0129942028,
-0.0693670511,
-0.0031395261,
-0.0036319529,
-0.0468228534,
-0.0156634338,
-0.0250186715,
0.021126138,
0.0102527179,
-0.016141329,
-0.0556175821,
-0.0133997425,
-0.0026542135,
0.035107825,
-0.0190093182,
-0.0018359902,
-0.0086885346,
-0.0639998764,
-0.0110660018,
0.0747938529,
0.0293696877,
-0.0181737039,
-0.0364279822,
-0.0007391897,
-0.0580184534,
-0.0272065829,
0.0236712191,
-0.0509035587,
-0.0012544675,
-0.0075594583,
0.003962921,
-0.0134273013,
0.0246157795,
0.0394999124,
0.0381264277,
0.0159932673,
0.0444004573,
0.0049835695,
-0.0582982376,
0.0185351148,
-0.0313686728,
-0.008645012,
-0.0019294068,
0.05941936,
0.0759042278,
-0.0172872357,
-0.0076193996,
-0.0084573785,
2.698e-7,
0.0794582143,
0.0405309051,
0.0079942942,
-0.080442965,
0.0070112017,
-0.003977404,
0.0208025761,
0.0335300602,
-0.0583887547,
-0.0360891968,
0.0068048076,
0.0350881554,
0.0016851304,
0.0385788791,
-0.0626513213,
0.0194913279,
-0.0484435633,
-0.0339646228,
-0.0665270016,
0.0208109319,
-0.0503000766,
0.0598839931,
0.0638237596,
0.0003109356,
-0.0248859022,
-0.0169538781,
0.0158560798,
-0.0335715897,
-0.051254075,
0.0452608094,
0.0304328743,
-0.0442744121,
0.0126623921,
0.0400826037,
0.0076771486,
0.0296497699,
-0.0133652212,
0.0170398466,
-0.031424433,
0.0853969455,
-0.0364942588,
-0.0471640117,
-0.0259572808,
-0.0510710552,
0.051061403,
-0.0260383114,
-0.0230679847,
-0.029116651,
-0.0200381279,
-0.0005232233,
0.0475169867,
0.0019219965,
-0.0152248964,
0.0550602898,
-0.0375456028,
-0.0200233795,
0.0302673727,
-0.0540767647,
0.0081422534,
-0.0266549755,
-0.0258773323,
-0.0680146143,
0.0167543944,
-0.0074538686,
0.0371216014,
-0.0081239091,
0.0044767153,
2.278082568e-34,
0.0338791199,
0.0245992895,
-0.0767673478,
-0.0401327722,
0.0144086974,
-0.0145737324,
-0.0207170378,
0.0019133883,
-0.0162740275,
-0.0937584043,
0.0112199374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14850v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14850v1 | Attention Visualizer Package: Revealing Word Importance for Deeper Insight into Encoder-Only Transformer Models | 2023-08-28T19:11:52 | 2023-08-28T19:11:52 | Ala Alam Falaki, Robin Gras | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This report introduces the Attention Visualizer package, which is crafted to
visually illustrate the significance of individual words in encoder-only
transformer-based models. In contrast to other methods that center on tokens
and self-attention scores, our approach will examine the words and their impact
on the final embedding representation. Libraries like this play a crucial role
in enhancing the interpretability and explainability of neural networks. They
offer the opportunity to illuminate their internal mechanisms, providing a
better understanding of how they operate and can be enhanced. You can access
the code and review examples on the following GitHub repository:
https://github.com/AlaFalaki/AttentionVisualizer. | [
-0.0224688891,
0.0366263688,
-0.0001071791,
0.0388883948,
0.0225488078,
-0.0013397818,
0.024620099,
-0.0145806186,
-0.0666772351,
0.0185986571,
-0.0232823547,
0.0303215981,
0.0063740327,
0.0709978491,
0.0578513145,
-0.043763198,
0.0188065171,
0.0308266971,
-0.0353916734,
0.0182794463,
0.0029108517,
-0.0143115567,
0.0244364161,
0.0903584361,
-0.0101292375,
-0.0295571126,
-0.0116727399,
-0.0014409905,
0.0585424304,
-0.0052902452,
-0.0311626345,
0.0567387566,
0.0228698719,
0.0355156511,
0.0000022709,
-0.0046621813,
-0.0140044093,
-0.007581145,
-0.014639521,
0.035230279,
0.0284691919,
-0.0584994778,
0.0160906091,
-0.0279581472,
-0.0159000624,
0.0105575742,
0.079888761,
0.0656308979,
0.0598479845,
0.0212763101,
-0.0091597047,
-0.0364898518,
0.017628435,
-0.0539302826,
0.0370789729,
0.0113828005,
-0.0021759907,
-0.0387275927,
-0.0552378111,
0.0104055665,
-0.0855065584,
0.0506719351,
0.0532355644,
-0.030816609,
0.1009673774,
0.0234287549,
-0.0154472562,
-0.0420643725,
0.0151874293,
0.0506286919,
-0.0595250279,
0.0074852719,
-0.0470805913,
-0.0002093026,
0.0098739024,
-0.0021313012,
-0.0721518025,
-0.0049671135,
0.0669021755,
0.0311421696,
-0.0418051183,
0.0339156203,
0.0146963345,
-0.0449871048,
-0.0495290048,
0.001241314,
0.01250696,
0.0066133663,
-0.0204320345,
-0.0143564036,
-0.0043437271,
-0.0061373175,
0.0440929122,
0.0090604285,
0.0553405024,
-0.0283437651,
0.0149412611,
-0.0485700294,
-0.0032185118,
-0.0300893635,
0.0596675053,
0.0312761664,
-0.0470355563,
0.0064766929,
-0.0181926843,
0.0894220695,
-0.0068612867,
0.0515909083,
0.0089321556,
0.0098706027,
0.0097556124,
-0.0124330185,
-0.0324418619,
-0.0125596048,
-0.0212622806,
-0.0301167592,
-0.0331588238,
-0.0117619662,
-0.0473848954,
-0.0193889253,
0.0359178297,
0.0387533903,
-0.0353813581,
0.012226698,
-0.0090681417,
0.051009763,
-0.0480397381,
-0.0290770195,
0.0009018662,
-0.0240691453,
-0.0692333728,
0.013778219,
0.0076449364,
-0.0148255806,
-0.0216095522,
0.0375216119,
0.0226812419,
-0.0643411279,
0.0242568646,
0.0286601633,
-0.0317016281,
0.016662905,
0.0337873623,
-0.0099328598,
0.0282240473,
0.0037132015,
0.0235688742,
-0.0389719941,
0.0013405546,
0.0038759422,
-0.0046236455,
0.0479118675,
-0.0024971189,
-0.0299677793,
-0.0206512772,
0.0098671559,
0.0142166186,
0.0141597791,
0.0413788855,
0.0493291095,
-0.0112642273,
-0.0659535006,
0.0266383346,
0.0001799049,
0.004854504,
-0.0312149543,
-0.0540034883,
-0.0523073263,
-0.0192544069,
0.0010087237,
0.0591629297,
-0.0115713179,
-0.0218492262,
-0.0530698635,
0.0443249829,
0.0511581451,
0.0616506301,
0.0207510795,
0.0122040212,
0.0305863451,
-0.0067949435,
-0.0096074194,
-0.029584121,
0.1121709049,
0.0227082204,
-0.0156136872,
-0.0054480336,
0.05465905,
-0.0209470522,
-0.0341239907,
0.0211738963,
0.0038161268,
0.011330395,
-0.0268097837,
0.0415773243,
0.0432627238,
-0.0290902611,
0.0556588657,
0.0333871134,
-0.0484451428,
-0.0060823662,
-0.0315952413,
-0.0175141934,
0.039978914,
0.0367101021,
0.0035477728,
0.0161224045,
-0.0318299793,
-0.0288286712,
0.0575600453,
-0.0398900956,
0.0369714722,
-0.0022240728,
-0.0584010184,
-0.0346726738,
-0.0604325607,
0.0250417218,
0.013551509,
-0.0420403108,
-0.0052903756,
0.0237662662,
-0.0259973407,
-0.0099514462,
0.0223073959,
0.0317324214,
-0.0111796204,
-0.0008944383,
0.016740147,
0.0002308744,
0.02398354,
-0.0052737505,
0.0154715488,
0.0576642044,
-0.0448100232,
0.0173097327,
0.0278671607,
-0.0223986767,
0.0031408889,
0.0062630088,
-0.0937737375,
0.0060151271,
0.0488153659,
-0.0170205552,
-0.0247896593,
0.0452305414,
-0.0508381203,
0.036677029,
-0.0227911137,
0.0053258273,
-0.0157796647,
0.078197524,
-0.0201556254,
0.0284053087,
-0.03599393,
0.0110410061,
0.0003391141,
0.016346639,
-0.0099523989,
-0.0022572794,
-0.0025262784,
0.0091097802,
-0.0268577468,
-0.0133361332,
-0.0125125768,
-0.0275431015,
-0.0079696514,
0.0124412095,
-0.0250569135,
-0.0360834226,
-0.0097013228,
-0.0047955746,
0.0119204996,
0.0084514059,
0.0150547363,
-0.0147693204,
0.012210452,
0.0247640871,
-0.0391247831,
-0.0223540068,
0.0329409279,
-0.0570978336,
-0.0163315721,
-0.0427770652,
-0.0330511667,
-0.0017147393,
0.0807605684,
0.0305075981,
-0.0418780036,
-0.0324826241,
-0.0335732438,
0.0419169329,
-0.0303690769,
-0.0039160703,
-0.0674189925,
0.0200532544,
0.0033352452,
0.0211378112,
0.07420858,
0.0271929651,
0.1013441607,
0.0491499677,
0.0132699767,
-0.037159048,
0.0102292914,
-0.0420322903,
0.0449361838,
-0.0042161425,
-0.0265711769,
0.0061607491,
0.0666060373,
-0.0201119129,
0.0057308879,
-0.0741792396,
0.0032380773,
-0.0008585963,
-0.0045854771,
-0.0068509527,
0.0111164218,
-0.0250778012,
0.0060075163,
0.0047499104,
-0.0428903773,
0.0391532294,
-0.0192291345,
-0.0224075001,
0.0017689682,
0.0036608039,
-0.048590675,
0.0322998464,
0.0165656041,
0.0086386716,
0.0112484694,
-0.05908392,
0.0016098298,
0.0361587293,
-0.0270072501,
-0.0039848271,
0.0403621867,
0.0253624767,
-0.0618570298,
0.0049708961,
0.0196534153,
-0.0193884019,
0.0081670331,
-0.0221583582,
0.0229212809,
0.0516920574,
-0.0366514064,
-0.0794902593,
-0.003719294,
0.0276906751,
0.0219960734,
-0.0241631512,
0.0098037515,
-0.0068676476,
0.0060691792,
0.0068961186,
0.0249504223,
0.04472607,
-0.0441183373,
0.0071883374,
0.0463574976,
-0.0410708897,
0.0043794764,
-0.0647033602,
0.0239292923,
0.013353195,
-0.0084130587,
0.0467878059,
-0.0218181033,
0.0476819091,
-0.0523785092,
-0.0257805455,
0.0892486572,
0.0122989751,
-0.0726342425,
0.0529549755,
-0.0231578313,
0.0042232452,
0.0404060259,
0.002103871,
-0.0417096131,
-0.0341109857,
-0.0292532668,
0.0155014517,
0.0637703314,
0.0086088059,
0.0307801962,
-0.0312050898,
0.0691722929,
0.0034438353,
-0.0243287235,
-0.0610541813,
-0.0351436324,
0.0061323359,
-0.0379775241,
-0.0115388893,
-0.0093350774,
0.0012650501,
0.0063144919,
0.0084283836,
0.019129945,
-0.0320214815,
-0.0017500847,
-0.0255334098,
-0.0031640939,
0.0515605658,
0.017857125,
-0.0158255864,
-0.086705938,
-0.0016216246,
0.0164305102,
0.012704242,
0.0026999912,
0.0989370048,
0.0003978438,
-0.0323812999,
-0.0250418298,
0.0215695407,
-0.0128211807,
-0.0323784575,
-0.0571144149,
0.0497627631,
-0.011077797,
-0.0237681847,
-0.0608184524,
0.01657518,
-0.0305194389,
0.0438863225,
0.0862909034,
-0.0300172344,
-0.0217175111,
-0.0395745598,
0.0344138741,
-0.0360292941,
-0.0767552853,
0.014107612,
0.0450146087,
-0.0792043805,
-0.0268587265,
-0.0147325676,
0.0316168927,
-0.0105717126,
-0.0046741315,
-0.0744647384,
-0.0365837365,
-0.0339125134,
-0.0570270494,
0.0762078762,
0.0167366788,
-0.0023354408,
-0.0218183845,
-0.0077892593,
0.047585737,
0.0072253421,
-0.0340613052,
0.0382440686,
-0.070979014,
0.0002243861,
0.0120886918,
0.0454229973,
0.0194401629,
0.0137465121,
-0.0333154351,
-0.0233978424,
0.0486467853,
0.0015146638,
-0.0194136575,
-0.007927781,
0.0281470343,
-0.0498935841,
-0.0277218837,
0.0124520883,
0.0043291128,
0.0248234756,
-0.0209683776,
0.0198917706,
0.0087183323,
-0.0270698909,
0.0128631024,
-0.0700798705,
0.0692975298,
0.0304817557,
0.0085820435,
-0.0233775359,
0.0147646125,
-0.0051902989,
0.0091880718,
-0.0646014363,
-0.0223673098,
0.0454581454,
-0.0254659727,
0.0220936369,
0.0247023385,
-0.0135814957,
-0.031418357,
-0.0278616101,
0.0504777096,
-0.0214553569,
-0.0154556083,
-0.0327985026,
0.0227270685,
0.006047226,
-0.0089642145,
-0.0264443718,
0.0263345838,
0.0131022437,
0.0212015305,
-0.025172621,
0.0217456333,
-0.0272837151,
0.0298319329,
-0.0439837351,
-0.0027148211,
-0.0313398577,
-0.0047925082,
0.0236564372,
-0.0311225429,
0.0869184434,
0.037513081,
-0.01487468,
0.0030196784,
0.0137517685,
-0.0177990086,
-0.0108529143,
0.0328370072,
-0.0021291012,
-0.0046179206,
-0.0567234457,
0.0560203344,
-0.0104850577,
-0.0000913802,
-0.024568025,
-0.0163439699,
-0.0219249334,
0.0104351472,
0.0132585922,
0.0225337632,
-0.0249312315,
0.0100529278,
-0.0551851466,
-0.0626366735,
0.0104328953,
-0.0245192721,
-0.007853834,
0.0179293901,
0.0493637323,
-0.0015536766,
-0.0172544923,
-0.0622673146,
0.0112947728,
0.0097797727,
-0.0119565558,
-0.0432672873,
-0.0044211834,
-6.724575595e-33,
-0.0273472648,
-0.0519041531,
-0.0270296521,
-0.0110051185,
-0.0209368691,
0.0063614515,
-0.0518283844,
-0.0094679436,
-0.0211701468,
0.0411752313,
0.0136198923,
0.0381653905,
0.0001433556,
0.0364260748,
-0.002962325,
0.002750661,
0.0419120006,
0.0292199105,
-0.0063727447,
0.0268408433,
0.0198465064,
0.0394748151,
0.0909361467,
-0.0346431658,
-0.008865552,
0.041226849,
-0.0150249507,
-0.039931979,
-0.0047449558,
0.0543690324,
-0.0270464439,
0.010099561,
-0.0089338925,
-0.0814743116,
-0.0418870077,
0.0007210671,
-0.042264957,
-0.0166866891,
-0.0414401889,
0.0173533615,
-0.0817682818,
-0.0635381788,
0.0742838383,
-0.0150019638,
-0.015327136,
-0.0775508583,
0.054346811,
-0.0078102886,
-0.0395152718,
0.0033389574,
-0.0500595532,
0.0210900027,
-0.0692384914,
-0.013735611,
0.0498809479,
0.0426045507,
0.02812545,
0.0494767539,
-0.0631884784,
0.0177190211,
0.0215309989,
0.0186788831,
0.0657914877,
0.0240273867,
0.0222370382,
0.0530253872,
0.0279499311,
-0.0483464934,
-0.0073865508,
-0.0116553875,
0.034521237,
0.0519708544,
0.1068535969,
-0.0576284081,
0.0165290888,
0.0133403577,
-0.0535057895,
0.0165255852,
-0.0680068731,
0.0787651241,
0.0476149954,
0.0164063331,
-0.0054116827,
-0.0022408569,
0.006967763,
-0.0565953404,
-0.029094873,
-0.0178530682,
0.0279093478,
-0.0169469267,
-0.0358149409,
0.0261199325,
0.0131479679,
-0.0381659344,
0.0478953086,
0.0356788896,
-0.0034762444,
0.0453808233,
0.0202909335,
-0.0253162291,
0.0146496817,
0.0310701057,
0.0288539194,
0.005805722,
0.0384267271,
-0.0121606952,
0.037792813,
0.0037581346,
-0.0135771614,
-0.0295462646,
-0.0241656173,
-0.0296599269,
-0.014269839,
0.0378071591,
0.0167276654,
-0.0202784929,
-0.0517981127,
0.0521869399,
0.0106398538,
0.039758224,
-0.0084998636,
0.0092218518,
0.0242031459,
0.0391772613,
-0.031178847,
-0.0066170599,
-0.0586510152,
0.0276799798,
0.0749643967,
-0.0623335131,
-0.0496174358,
0.0198206436,
2.864e-7,
0.0745586827,
0.067579098,
0.0434453711,
-0.0016506501,
0.0188809093,
0.0149536906,
-0.0030980795,
0.0372777507,
0.0152997309,
-0.0186149888,
-0.0033013951,
0.0467971154,
0.0492082722,
-0.0001486255,
-0.0443860032,
-0.0041236142,
-0.0612668134,
-0.0051008123,
-0.0246755313,
0.0119239418,
0.0508756079,
0.1204899475,
-0.0053463303,
0.0219767317,
0.0197709743,
0.0177022759,
0.0324418359,
-0.0276670177,
0.0405069664,
-0.0104419822,
-0.0099066002,
-0.0101387938,
-0.02039041,
-0.0236925483,
-0.0424576029,
0.0192223489,
0.0387777388,
0.0434786156,
-0.0425475724,
-0.0368854441,
-0.0048196106,
0.0270824563,
0.0193486474,
-0.0920215175,
0.0583469644,
-0.0749812201,
-0.0687176064,
0.0000767216,
-0.0192542486,
0.0255477875,
0.0614323802,
-0.0280861706,
-0.0157746859,
-0.0083870105,
0.0136565659,
-0.0187955163,
-0.0442228578,
-0.0627420098,
-0.0203746203,
-0.0176648349,
-0.0467890427,
0.0204452612,
-0.0860857368,
-0.0583457686,
0.0408778749,
0.0358213075,
-0.036162544,
2.726124765e-34,
0.0275226291,
-0.0000561794,
0.0258971397,
0.0188501254,
0.033543013,
-0.0363265909,
0.0318745933,
-0.0072436244,
0.0114657199,
-0.0836834759,
-0.0605351999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14683v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14683v1 | Fine-Tuning Llama 2 Large Language Models for Detecting Online Sexual Predatory Chats and Abusive Texts | 2023-08-28T16:18:50 | 2023-08-28T16:18:50 | Thanh Thi Nguyen, Campbell Wilson, Janis Dalins | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Detecting online sexual predatory behaviours and abusive language on social
media platforms has become a critical area of research due to the growing
concerns about online safety, especially for vulnerable populations such as
children and adolescents. Researchers have been exploring various techniques
and approaches to develop effective detection systems that can identify and
mitigate these risks. Recent development of large language models (LLMs) has
opened a new opportunity to address this problem more effectively. This paper
proposes an approach to detection of online sexual predatory chats and abusive
language using the open-source pretrained Llama 2 7B-parameter model, recently
released by Meta GenAI. We fine-tune the LLM using datasets with different
sizes, imbalance degrees, and languages (i.e., English, Roman Urdu and Urdu).
Based on the power of LLMs, our approach is generic and automated without a
manual search for a synergy between feature extraction and classifier design
steps like conventional methods in this domain. Experimental results show a
strong performance of the proposed approach, which performs proficiently and
consistently across three distinct datasets with five sets of experiments. This
study's outcomes indicate that the proposed method can be implemented in
real-world applications (even with non-English languages) for flagging sexual
predators, offensive or toxic content, hate speech, and discriminatory language
in online discussions and comments to maintain respectful internet or digital
communities. Furthermore, it can be employed for solving text classification
problems with other potential applications such as sentiment analysis, spam and
phishing detection, sorting legal documents, fake news detection, language
identification, user intent recognition, text-based product categorization,
medical record analysis, and resume screening. | [
0.1044447273,
0.0510597713,
-0.0245820433,
0.023417728,
-0.0397881269,
0.0404035933,
0.0394846946,
0.0245952252,
0.0336935334,
-0.0791810825,
-0.0442493036,
-0.0826136395,
-0.01431322,
0.0377540998,
-0.0257903859,
-0.015780285,
0.0013715702,
0.0157643892,
0.0422185622,
-0.0045315595,
0.0550898612,
0.0154044703,
0.004152366,
0.0184557252,
-0.0071987053,
-0.0059926785,
0.035813421,
-0.0052617653,
-0.0138323419,
-0.0032917627,
0.0723798648,
0.0548416376,
-0.0096921036,
0.0353231654,
0.0000019292,
-0.0678116903,
0.028448686,
-0.0142169856,
0.0110276379,
0.0154617587,
0.0980205983,
-0.0346768126,
-0.0418522581,
0.0493844301,
-0.0305932909,
0.0226281993,
0.0697767362,
0.047765594,
0.0647844374,
0.0600009635,
-0.012995868,
-0.0631855801,
0.0253995173,
0.0115657514,
-0.0080201281,
0.0087086754,
0.0770483837,
-0.0279897247,
0.0011146801,
0.0164901707,
0.0106283408,
-0.0038204144,
-0.0155167608,
-0.0337016657,
0.006315853,
-0.0210276525,
-0.0212389026,
-0.0679195002,
0.0136113213,
0.049600441,
-0.0628003627,
-0.0149907526,
0.0173684303,
-0.0121123604,
-0.0238155816,
-0.0286294911,
-0.0213046744,
0.0595901385,
-0.0304053929,
0.0419441201,
0.0141619453,
0.0185405519,
0.0418719314,
0.0877465978,
0.022545144,
-0.0068537313,
-0.0303487424,
-0.0320935994,
0.0051484858,
-0.0146952746,
-0.0037995819,
0.007094739,
0.0568550639,
0.0156163545,
0.0047586784,
0.0079541057,
-0.0245532524,
-0.057728529,
0.0472101234,
-0.1194323227,
0.0082106553,
0.0386245586,
-0.0568611547,
-0.0043643075,
0.0065271775,
0.0351120606,
0.0048593865,
0.0092638405,
-0.0174033456,
0.0024620148,
0.0106397541,
0.0349069536,
-0.0052223969,
0.0158719067,
0.0093895784,
0.0412744991,
-0.0954450443,
0.0236749761,
-0.0291591901,
-0.0412345156,
0.0081191491,
-0.023400262,
-0.0011118784,
0.0225121491,
-0.002744298,
-0.0196361504,
-0.0082163028,
0.0324305333,
-0.0610111244,
-0.0683203936,
0.0239128582,
0.0309234038,
-0.0119564002,
-0.0222614054,
0.0381885841,
0.080770798,
0.0207512677,
-0.068210952,
-0.0432988666,
-0.0073739374,
-0.0276445448,
-0.0207035374,
-0.0087253964,
-0.0479979552,
0.0351367481,
-0.0062939306,
-0.0296417773,
-0.0230358765,
0.0270140171,
0.0185298119,
-0.0557074994,
0.0471927971,
0.0100223813,
0.0124083543,
0.046445027,
0.0262404755,
0.0081473794,
0.0665405095,
0.0230536256,
0.0680612996,
0.0565246679,
-0.0050409799,
-0.0141179282,
0.066055052,
-0.008563431,
-0.0053982651,
-0.0053588394,
0.0203931239,
-0.0021183465,
-0.0194825903,
-0.001917319,
0.0131099652,
0.0064398227,
-0.0366729945,
0.0546413511,
0.0627090558,
0.001238644,
0.0460868254,
0.0421775244,
0.0315917544,
0.0001698651,
-0.0572810732,
-0.0416100956,
-0.0290305242,
-0.0235303938,
-0.0605920106,
0.0174121521,
0.0764096081,
-0.0165809207,
-0.0488867797,
-0.0216853153,
-0.0282371715,
0.0218171477,
-0.0144400522,
0.0518014841,
0.0003762484,
-0.0148693537,
-0.0102748331,
0.0809816495,
-0.0039371043,
-0.0048693791,
-0.0640487149,
0.0499522053,
0.0853471979,
-0.0042743701,
-0.0117921438,
-0.0064428048,
-0.0535385087,
0.0249687247,
-0.0001776159,
-0.0244160201,
0.0282218922,
-0.0059194784,
-0.04874973,
-0.0263260845,
0.0281636957,
-0.0079896767,
-0.0369726457,
0.0465320125,
0.0363828242,
0.025040118,
0.0587649308,
-0.0576113127,
0.0405382179,
0.0031964439,
0.0035798729,
0.0106477886,
0.0313717537,
0.0705522597,
-0.0131804813,
-0.0105376868,
-0.0595715679,
0.0269501172,
-0.0213983115,
-0.0196144339,
-0.0404203273,
-0.0213861801,
0.0194283351,
0.0444542915,
-0.0079258746,
0.0187145807,
0.0133357495,
-0.02387104,
0.0314359479,
0.0377806537,
-0.0417520553,
-0.0125155672,
-0.0431310683,
-0.0073281229,
-0.0601891242,
0.0452920906,
0.0134817502,
0.0551568642,
-0.0308661014,
-0.0308744051,
-0.041664768,
-0.0794749632,
-0.0026793606,
0.0218665116,
-0.0220247861,
0.0047421758,
-0.030299142,
0.0258707982,
0.0066756806,
0.0672502816,
0.0097569684,
-0.0465274118,
-0.0775567591,
0.0134716081,
-0.0242869873,
-0.0030920324,
0.0190699268,
0.0147027262,
-0.028797105,
0.0254900455,
-0.0147473728,
-0.0327192284,
0.0223413259,
0.0170604531,
0.005181028,
-0.0701693073,
-0.0168745592,
-0.0117145572,
-0.0020354432,
0.0140459631,
0.0189170949,
0.0240488891,
-0.0768093243,
0.0228846613,
0.0245682672,
-0.0428912677,
0.009096209,
-0.0153925912,
-0.0725459829,
-0.0206848867,
-0.0095827766,
-0.0511211231,
0.0302575659,
0.0509932935,
0.0767224357,
0.0455087386,
0.0251945686,
-0.0103140688,
-0.0157751162,
-0.0170201939,
-0.0073431516,
0.0047908113,
-0.0466423668,
-0.0000784907,
0.0492973849,
-0.0041544405,
0.0106866583,
-0.0177864935,
-0.0224180445,
-0.0343493707,
0.0039716065,
-0.027840348,
-0.050007645,
-0.0027334916,
-0.0115787648,
-0.024921678,
-0.0701756328,
0.0427439697,
0.0038715058,
0.0315458998,
-0.0223722328,
-0.0797142982,
-0.033042971,
-0.0094080335,
-0.0187593792,
0.0531575419,
-0.0046924218,
-0.0313634686,
0.0485578664,
0.0022727877,
0.0371197313,
-0.0385585651,
0.0131340036,
-0.024247691,
0.0175931528,
0.0293030422,
-0.0482772514,
-0.0609401241,
-0.0918535814,
-0.0339686051,
-0.0482379124,
-0.0200079791,
-0.0136233158,
-0.0182988383,
0.0425530449,
-0.0182209294,
-0.007252695,
-0.0195120107,
0.0149866259,
0.0047234488,
-0.0199715365,
0.0157557968,
-0.0518377759,
0.0137149859,
-0.002976075,
0.0051174578,
0.0659995377,
-0.0370755494,
-0.0110612735,
0.0179589875,
0.0223856382,
0.0349283144,
-0.0063699046,
-0.0158566758,
-0.0083314208,
-0.0017563603,
-0.0069781118,
0.0044090007,
0.0680516735,
0.0249012057,
-0.0245898906,
0.0132789537,
-0.0192992035,
0.0051499354,
0.003448908,
-0.0215106923,
-0.0686306432,
-0.0035308313,
-0.0131546585,
0.0151159968,
-0.0775023177,
-0.0145855807,
-0.0010827673,
-0.0560524575,
0.0221678335,
0.01432057,
-0.0530662723,
-0.0311454982,
-0.0273742955,
0.0032963315,
0.0069471272,
0.0309966505,
-0.0174520537,
-0.0367218517,
-0.0329476967,
0.0038522475,
-0.0266326424,
-0.0493844114,
0.0350972936,
-0.0242107678,
0.0229547974,
0.001702833,
0.0593272746,
-0.059837956,
-0.0014349262,
0.0368831381,
-0.0027055289,
-0.015112306,
-0.0329785682,
0.0232195091,
-0.0016769682,
-0.0231813081,
-0.0490742363,
0.0358269885,
-0.0032505894,
0.0152231706,
0.0135147059,
0.0635757819,
0.0006686864,
-0.0262659043,
-0.0180693697,
0.0140541978,
0.0134623107,
0.0656761751,
-0.0048275129,
-0.0624132417,
0.0089352252,
-0.035112951,
-0.0663506687,
0.0526574776,
-0.0544240847,
-0.0148868654,
-0.0255789366,
-0.0315143578,
-0.0413248725,
0.0077842101,
0.0120112589,
-0.0501326583,
0.0198860802,
0.0068871356,
0.0160826482,
-0.0136487195,
-0.0422540456,
0.0173562299,
-0.0023127932,
0.0513395965,
-0.0451926999,
0.0373414382,
0.0003688072,
-0.0586813837,
0.0029853634,
0.0173926856,
-0.0482674465,
-0.0320656188,
0.0141495448,
0.0363067351,
0.0127956923,
-0.0124714691,
-0.0368603505,
-0.0803708807,
0.0396247767,
0.0516681373,
-0.0350636691,
-0.0325311236,
0.0259954333,
0.0051126336,
0.0267471354,
0.0128073785,
-0.0003623275,
0.0409905314,
0.0313112661,
-0.0709661841,
-0.0448648669,
-0.015757503,
-0.0204425603,
0.0187760629,
0.0194704868,
0.0059794388,
-0.0645902157,
-0.0224195942,
-0.0087713934,
-0.0085855378,
-0.0086002601,
-0.0084384568,
0.026829889,
0.0470521338,
0.0175260603,
-0.038761884,
-0.0042761108,
-0.0395358317,
0.0058504557,
-0.0389890522,
0.0357057601,
-0.0006578595,
0.0238766167,
0.0452505872,
0.0048353714,
-0.0060892594,
0.0267837718,
0.0120324204,
0.0066915313,
-0.0223028045,
0.0195024274,
-0.0199412107,
0.0105049349,
0.0017353019,
0.0169741865,
0.0320090204,
-0.002465968,
-0.0384333916,
0.0278222933,
0.0094946502,
-0.0187036227,
0.0542330593,
0.0065000048,
0.0005176427,
-0.0131909503,
0.0332433879,
-0.0406915694,
-0.0416636392,
0.011775976,
0.0048866137,
-0.0299292598,
0.038587708,
0.0311724208,
0.0143987425,
0.0171595309,
0.053165663,
-0.0352558568,
-0.0069041057,
0.0080215205,
0.0376057401,
0.0300418735,
-0.0151412627,
0.0094680432,
-0.0307041686,
-0.0239965431,
-0.0078242216,
-0.1067476794,
0.0014193722,
-0.0166839361,
0.0172429513,
0.0570478626,
-0.0121287685,
0.0230784137,
-0.0346173607,
-0.0366618186,
0.0092194956,
-0.0527045391,
-0.003664356,
-5.803914093e-33,
0.0293907728,
-0.034137249,
-0.0252964403,
0.0284723938,
-0.0061886841,
-0.0351668485,
0.056714993,
-0.0214871094,
-0.0154494876,
-0.0098228958,
0.0020140798,
0.0249773134,
-0.0004721237,
-0.0066506434,
-0.0237582754,
0.006744076,
0.0118788546,
-0.0205774754,
-0.0057475553,
0.0262128282,
0.0549769923,
0.0276836716,
0.0430837013,
-0.0845492631,
0.0411219187,
-0.0274823643,
-0.0415260233,
0.0255502779,
-0.0161103904,
0.0731961951,
-0.0460528843,
0.0837659836,
0.0319775827,
0.010619984,
0.0413701311,
0.0554285906,
-0.0450445414,
0.0111475056,
0.0123096071,
0.0301445145,
0.0649941862,
-0.0300128907,
0.053961046,
0.0068612122,
-0.0336561464,
-0.0077506723,
0.0362292901,
-0.0247558095,
0.0100191608,
-0.0393866263,
-0.0350968987,
0.0134494565,
-0.0252364036,
-0.006432456,
0.0186826158,
0.0540944412,
-0.0091028288,
0.0215230267,
-0.052033823,
0.029077813,
0.0156790707,
-0.0335689709,
-0.0095664142,
-0.0294584744,
-0.0052592056,
0.0631370842,
0.0087912465,
-0.0104412418,
-0.0267583989,
0.0088240784,
0.0119531667,
0.0474094637,
0.0052043633,
0.0313412957,
0.0148585904,
-0.0670948029,
-0.1391245574,
-0.0022213219,
0.0702525526,
0.0234256331,
0.0186252333,
-0.0380756408,
-0.0679720044,
-0.0398653783,
0.0083528357,
-0.0411280915,
-0.0238556396,
-0.0307873115,
-0.0060639414,
-0.0181003977,
-0.0200859513,
-0.0244767442,
-0.026623724,
-0.0493525155,
-0.0410661139,
0.0425969698,
-0.0361232124,
0.0205264688,
0.0254510492,
0.025220558,
-0.0500781089,
-0.0214835685,
0.0122977607,
-0.0681878999,
0.0135980519,
-0.0041155163,
0.0730056614,
0.0275594201,
-0.0565165579,
0.007767681,
-0.0069564991,
0.0490911528,
0.0224716365,
0.1009484753,
-0.0085335979,
0.0318713225,
-0.0057820538,
0.0472083315,
0.0448398069,
0.0352420807,
-0.0095660286,
-0.0171081889,
-0.0190297421,
0.0111799212,
-0.0064780577,
0.0163431745,
-0.0293168593,
0.0087877419,
0.0370589234,
-0.0702872276,
0.0046703671,
-0.0291884486,
2.634e-7,
0.0075968266,
0.073582001,
-0.0655028746,
-0.0103390729,
0.0223191325,
0.0383193344,
0.0417881571,
0.0347860679,
0.0339722484,
-0.0051131491,
-0.0149236582,
0.0343491659,
0.017295029,
0.0297194067,
-0.0616162643,
0.0095223757,
-0.0729834214,
-0.0212904494,
-0.0517709777,
-0.0335851647,
0.0145887593,
0.1095052063,
0.050596945,
-0.0608828068,
-0.0323494449,
-0.0364274494,
0.0336812176,
-0.0445369445,
-0.0448717251,
0.0093711456,
0.0618528537,
0.0307073593,
0.0071252249,
0.0064336951,
0.012657363,
0.0330035686,
0.0059974901,
0.0620143227,
-0.0062412582,
0.0508837141,
0.0160085931,
-0.0295433551,
-0.0090077054,
-0.0490541719,
0.1036711633,
0.0090930173,
-0.0290461145,
-0.048965048,
0.0124520147,
-0.03786752,
0.0583222993,
-0.0671185702,
0.0276091807,
0.0286959782,
0.0294758193,
-0.0443953574,
-0.0143070621,
-0.0393532813,
0.0192478858,
-0.0040525864,
0.0039849603,
-0.0270349458,
-0.021317549,
0.0182258468,
0.0417344384,
0.0000910404,
0.08255779,
2.172537869e-34,
0.0204441678,
-0.0300010294,
0.0260350406,
-0.0072586471,
0.0185520202,
0.0586672053,
0.019468626,
0.0156664848,
0.0048208633,
-0.0315660723,
0.0400411002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14669v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14669v1 | ANER: Arabic and Arabizi Named Entity Recognition using Transformer-Based Approach | 2023-08-28T15:54:48 | 2023-08-28T15:54:48 | Abdelrahman "Boda" Sadallah, Omar Ahmed, Shimaa Mohamed, Omar Hatem, Doaa Hesham, Ahmed H. Yousef | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | One of the main tasks of Natural Language Processing (NLP), is Named Entity
Recognition (NER). It is used in many applications and also can be used as an
intermediate step for other tasks. We present ANER, a web-based named entity
recognizer for the Arabic, and Arabizi languages. The model is built upon BERT,
which is a transformer-based encoder. It can recognize 50 different entity
classes, covering various fields. We trained our model on the WikiFANE\_Gold
dataset which consists of Wikipedia articles. We achieved an F1 score of
88.7\%, which beats CAMeL Tools' F1 score of 83\% on the ANERcorp dataset,
which has only 4 classes. We also got an F1 score of 77.7\% on the
NewsFANE\_Gold dataset which contains out-of-domain data from News articles.
The system is deployed on a user-friendly web interface that accepts users'
inputs in Arabic, or Arabizi. It allows users to explore the entities in the
text by highlighting them. It can also direct users to get information about
entities through Wikipedia directly. We added the ability to do NER using our
model, or CAMeL Tools' model through our website. ANER is publicly accessible
at \url{http://www.aner.online}. We also deployed our model on HuggingFace at
https://huggingface.co/boda/ANER, to allow developers to test and use it. | [
0.0376624353,
0.0203807466,
0.0167611483,
0.0499675758,
0.0062698699,
0.085391663,
0.0116640022,
0.0249564089,
0.0185275842,
-0.045092687,
-0.0125110131,
-0.0279563777,
0.0444266573,
-0.0006795556,
0.0105659524,
-0.0308360364,
-0.0093286131,
-0.0493367538,
-0.0009345465,
0.0141608501,
0.0225271825,
0.0068628467,
-0.0300307591,
0.0282613151,
0.0129205342,
0.0372863039,
-0.0209472571,
-0.0184887238,
0.0384639502,
-0.0165435188,
0.0318924189,
0.0379599333,
-0.0304569826,
0.003518295,
0.0000020039,
-0.0526489951,
-0.068775475,
-0.0026365854,
-0.0300227776,
-0.0549593456,
-0.0249474421,
-0.0556552447,
-0.0610018112,
0.0012688286,
-0.0053977245,
-0.0220266208,
0.0371369608,
0.0717944056,
0.0403172225,
0.0656796619,
-0.0001267533,
-0.0626595318,
0.0649624392,
0.0453398973,
-0.022204658,
-0.0053090421,
0.0197957717,
-0.0418375917,
-0.0382245295,
-0.0002211915,
0.0057582511,
0.0226062238,
-0.0055937618,
-0.0012256216,
-0.012818818,
0.0030587616,
-0.0586265847,
-0.049057737,
0.0053383475,
0.0324963294,
-0.0259980522,
-0.0074997302,
0.0280044451,
0.0157024208,
-0.0167375617,
0.0240268819,
-0.0103084724,
0.0429747961,
-0.0658397973,
-0.0131370751,
0.0523000434,
0.0175331309,
-0.0144906668,
-0.0089036357,
-0.0342736356,
0.0263229422,
0.0281412993,
-0.0484597646,
0.0112010818,
0.0095972139,
0.0166488905,
-0.0280991551,
0.0816024989,
0.0224039294,
0.0556866601,
-0.0014278373,
-0.010638875,
-0.031163536,
-0.0034298175,
-0.0876783952,
-0.0371697657,
0.0503418706,
0.0257915091,
0.0171137638,
-0.0748388246,
0.0215791073,
0.0252192803,
0.0101693189,
0.0468852855,
-0.0052625528,
-0.0705140233,
0.000113295,
-0.0401833244,
0.0658532158,
-0.0428556688,
0.0135082472,
-0.0296988748,
0.0014634265,
0.0052213734,
0.0494917929,
0.0508094504,
-0.052211564,
0.0100912908,
0.0023378888,
-0.0333501287,
0.0256785192,
-0.0020594881,
-0.0293949097,
-0.0474896841,
-0.065571703,
0.0235146638,
-0.0220073257,
0.075802356,
-0.012142892,
0.002199268,
0.0693213418,
0.0182522871,
-0.0950339288,
-0.0608520359,
0.0332138576,
0.0176231135,
0.0017080174,
-0.0061466065,
-0.0497704707,
0.0466084965,
0.0362148434,
0.0095382081,
-0.0309306141,
0.0191916376,
0.0046985126,
-0.0001071246,
0.0789872408,
-0.0293826219,
-0.0178956464,
0.0691021979,
0.0114301136,
0.0664503798,
0.0499182753,
0.0521895699,
-0.0040969118,
0.0300129782,
0.0109245135,
0.0249662492,
0.0405233167,
-0.0168314278,
-0.0175048336,
0.0288456287,
-0.0120982407,
-0.0291019678,
0.0175428223,
-0.030593358,
0.0178242456,
-0.0052750311,
0.0014310653,
0.0234538298,
0.015867006,
-0.0111487219,
0.026794184,
0.0034964934,
0.0236177333,
0.0498102047,
-0.0247142259,
0.0005663062,
0.0056109871,
0.0020474617,
0.023325365,
-0.026073914,
0.0877225175,
-0.0103303241,
-0.0109759057,
0.008774098,
-0.0385963619,
0.0039101541,
-0.0278729554,
0.0878148451,
0.0072142319,
-0.0983725116,
0.0763759166,
0.0251524728,
-0.0411378145,
0.0337685645,
-0.0303710196,
-0.0198151916,
0.0723952949,
0.0452877954,
-0.0177294184,
-0.0618266873,
-0.0390458815,
-0.0637720749,
0.054841239,
-0.0041016182,
-0.0257791337,
0.0091455774,
-0.0266363472,
-0.0313339233,
0.0478499234,
0.0169017781,
0.0099332482,
0.0024828087,
0.0805250928,
0.0278427899,
-0.0199397318,
-0.0156813897,
0.0399890132,
-0.0326893777,
0.0137785133,
-0.0341293775,
0.0376157723,
-0.0200614668,
0.051493451,
-0.0105366129,
-0.0205007903,
0.0160395242,
-0.0366808213,
-0.0084506543,
-0.0147923902,
0.0401204638,
-0.0192318745,
0.0116685424,
-0.0514403507,
-0.0045658886,
0.0307267327,
0.0133029958,
-0.0397723317,
-0.0249081813,
0.0196252577,
0.0494640544,
0.0035494363,
0.0873517022,
-0.0075305984,
0.0302290581,
0.0044983388,
0.0354833603,
-0.0280596223,
0.0015647082,
0.0082380502,
-0.0538602583,
0.0060418351,
0.013047846,
-0.0235195737,
0.0391677208,
-0.01849363,
-0.0339728929,
0.0270578489,
-0.024778625,
-0.0398959182,
-0.0384315997,
-0.0679739341,
-0.0105848042,
-0.0102930199,
0.0808118805,
-0.0007658553,
0.0362326205,
-0.0349396169,
0.0006595661,
0.0112323174,
-0.0233543757,
-0.0409553796,
-0.0232888795,
0.0285591278,
-0.0177970678,
-0.020491343,
-0.016025342,
0.0102833332,
-0.0238002669,
0.0410061181,
0.072926864,
-0.0880607069,
-0.0263214782,
-0.0087687979,
-0.0118260905,
-0.0090713454,
0.0323128588,
-0.0160235912,
-0.0125335502,
0.0253515057,
0.0126691926,
0.02572258,
0.0152091375,
0.0466245972,
-0.0376926623,
-0.0439426899,
-0.0452480763,
0.0020015633,
-0.0209106691,
0.024608396,
-0.0393352024,
-0.0278727263,
0.0311917681,
0.0426470153,
-0.0421761945,
0.0336814336,
-0.035180334,
0.0013562295,
-0.0130103175,
0.0186661687,
0.0106464317,
0.0044640661,
-0.0112524079,
0.0387488231,
0.0089619467,
0.0163987707,
0.0247227978,
-0.0386086591,
0.0151699306,
-0.0188569818,
0.0435028747,
-0.0318299979,
-0.0118774157,
-0.0096611045,
0.0045792079,
0.0155723765,
-0.0895687938,
0.0236245133,
0.0551726855,
0.0056678653,
-0.0354365483,
-0.0054234788,
0.0143515309,
-0.0034220091,
-0.026683405,
0.0054614898,
-0.0159183498,
0.0341720358,
-0.0585110709,
0.0108664483,
0.0055911392,
-0.010246777,
-0.0107256761,
0.0605734289,
0.013886882,
0.0616729409,
0.0088607268,
0.0036756189,
-0.0064301435,
0.0301489532,
0.0030797443,
-0.0119798779,
0.0297212303,
0.0062154806,
0.0069804438,
0.018359961,
-0.0456585139,
-0.0213214643,
0.00250599,
-0.0322645418,
0.0379214324,
-0.1059036776,
0.0084159663,
-0.0623362996,
-0.0182110518,
-0.0546650477,
0.0064059431,
0.1135632992,
0.0197112858,
-0.029267028,
-0.0333262458,
0.0079682255,
-0.0378724411,
-0.0167933777,
-0.0058677713,
-0.1011347771,
-0.0050536152,
0.0462876335,
0.002749997,
0.012481859,
-0.0407520086,
0.0612452216,
-0.0876778066,
-0.0261971168,
-0.0355993658,
-0.0217016954,
-0.0437929109,
-0.0659225583,
-0.0208084155,
-0.0227234494,
-0.0404459946,
-0.0130344452,
0.0032202408,
0.0247715898,
0.0218683425,
-0.0009494253,
-0.089307785,
-0.010389939,
-0.0430460237,
0.0164597873,
0.0293654948,
0.0359710716,
-0.050432764,
-0.0356456563,
-0.02428253,
-0.0513316095,
-0.0515171923,
-0.0056374394,
0.0416935124,
-0.0500350446,
-0.0154158203,
-0.0459510311,
-0.0405801125,
-0.0322866105,
-0.0038530466,
0.0065636421,
0.0220175125,
0.0147521161,
0.0266293269,
0.0247786958,
-0.0413001254,
0.0020935209,
0.0414003767,
-0.0285126846,
-0.0315908976,
-0.0257307738,
-0.0082005849,
-0.0097602503,
-0.0578100905,
-0.0424549133,
0.0100591937,
0.00028804,
-0.0535121225,
-0.0823936313,
-0.0279858969,
0.0268755276,
0.0324553214,
0.0326994509,
-0.019663712,
0.0652342066,
0.0316417478,
-0.0588360392,
-0.0301511902,
0.0201418698,
-0.0136302346,
-0.0702079758,
-0.0155417537,
0.0351053439,
-0.0176886171,
0.0023895307,
-0.0199055485,
-0.017237056,
-0.0185807385,
0.0141626177,
0.030859014,
0.0121953096,
-0.0150415534,
-0.0105291037,
-0.0087842159,
0.0373343714,
0.0346701816,
-0.0414037779,
-0.0312807076,
0.013334712,
0.0162430108,
-0.026167715,
0.02389233,
0.0055230558,
-0.0125729488,
-0.0060257837,
-0.0051505785,
0.0005975589,
-0.0148139168,
-0.0009605478,
-0.0199302565,
0.0304508675,
-0.0211043321,
-0.0466270335,
-0.0579013713,
0.0385120362,
-0.0085101128,
0.0392401144,
0.0057070795,
0.0158057734,
0.0169523768,
0.0218079835,
0.0019916475,
0.0584935434,
0.0109093012,
-0.0499542356,
-0.0365535691,
0.0739468411,
0.0041653793,
0.0376665071,
0.0059854505,
-0.0200834014,
0.0203573145,
-0.0204401631,
0.0355779566,
0.0239560623,
-0.0366251841,
0.0020549439,
-0.0134014357,
-0.0007355443,
0.0320170298,
0.0539452061,
-0.0097676208,
0.0250389203,
-0.044744838,
0.0834697261,
0.0385543182,
-0.0038452409,
0.0633738041,
0.0116040017,
-0.0024008816,
0.0270217508,
0.0107898368,
-0.0220320858,
-0.022654457,
0.0099696126,
-0.0001390101,
-0.0083462242,
-0.0089556333,
0.0380947813,
-0.0124507733,
0.0126740029,
0.0530956052,
-0.0140822791,
-0.0230220649,
-0.0111758774,
0.0162928756,
-0.028102532,
-0.0632078722,
-0.0033332983,
0.0030516987,
-0.0470613427,
0.0179021824,
-0.0043784026,
0.0122706201,
0.0118826153,
-0.0006219763,
0.0192636196,
0.0297591351,
-0.037710581,
-0.042060975,
0.0294437464,
-0.0436746255,
-0.0366047956,
0.0013828728,
-5.938191915e-33,
-0.0378331728,
-0.0180037264,
-0.0095295049,
0.0082670879,
0.0223937239,
0.0183004104,
-0.0200243723,
0.0005547592,
-0.0018278102,
-0.028750645,
-0.0272294115,
0.0080197323,
0.0459038503,
0.0133050848,
-0.0003949165,
-0.0513693616,
0.0355605744,
0.0426556915,
-0.0361390635,
0.003092197,
0.0387165919,
0.0717160478,
0.1174123809,
-0.0612456873,
0.0281866603,
-0.0133053837,
-0.0207160376,
-0.0267982893,
0.0875999406,
0.0866727754,
-0.0385918319,
-0.0017636159,
0.0084027797,
-0.0581692755,
0.03546042,
0.0081490939,
-0.1350928247,
0.0392722525,
-0.0466673113,
0.10589955,
0.0031621368,
-0.0223595835,
0.021369826,
-0.0053305696,
-0.023981981,
0.0486359894,
0.0343637057,
-0.0241523962,
0.0260713939,
-0.0418858528,
-0.1000502557,
0.0584217161,
0.0019500803,
0.0302671213,
0.0675251335,
0.0233227573,
0.0366887152,
-0.0459650904,
-0.0854693651,
-0.0093999235,
0.0351091214,
-0.0102162398,
0.0599300675,
0.0177607238,
-0.0294060502,
0.0265942849,
-0.0046834094,
-0.0168375634,
0.0048660384,
0.0264028348,
0.0090693254,
-0.0241583772,
-0.0020735513,
0.043427702,
0.019209167,
-0.0554616712,
-0.0417982116,
0.0672750995,
-0.0075481157,
0.0315676257,
-0.0137331849,
-0.0263551902,
-0.0563362017,
0.0156498253,
0.0199409146,
-0.0367280208,
-0.0321638286,
-0.0032861524,
0.0077431253,
0.0073228539,
-0.0858327523,
0.0684849024,
-0.0015905942,
-0.0209980477,
-0.0186091699,
0.0306588281,
0.0193395857,
0.0277373902,
-0.0338581502,
0.0108429417,
-0.0242311899,
-0.0663781613,
-0.0080281598,
0.0025963173,
0.0217806064,
0.0039932756,
0.0270942468,
0.0351913534,
-0.0753196701,
0.0164008029,
-0.0080723856,
0.036098659,
0.0156833045,
0.0728595629,
-0.0017032232,
-0.0343603902,
-0.0120194675,
-0.0047537186,
0.0541185848,
-0.0053111697,
-0.035169173,
0.0185407326,
0.0131939156,
0.0058853296,
-0.021561455,
-0.0047412082,
-0.0296566654,
0.0346014984,
-0.017393874,
-0.0757301226,
-0.0047315056,
-0.0292003173,
2.752e-7,
0.024402976,
0.016699478,
0.0403896719,
-0.0473417602,
-0.0197339449,
-0.0169937462,
0.04110815,
0.0581901707,
-0.0076811579,
0.0360260233,
-0.0130469482,
-0.0267204214,
0.0206492562,
0.0022544479,
-0.1006137133,
-0.072095722,
0.0150808739,
0.0005364267,
-0.0606301017,
0.0525925793,
0.0322284251,
0.0736574084,
-0.0327441618,
0.0059985789,
-0.0357637666,
0.0142739806,
0.038254492,
0.0079886708,
0.0431527905,
0.0363554507,
0.0134257553,
0.0350285731,
-0.0057669431,
0.0219254233,
-0.0346341282,
0.0138093727,
0.0177962538,
0.0746917129,
0.0152729061,
0.0382761769,
0.0161930118,
-0.0527505875,
0.0220484491,
-0.0573392734,
0.0778485313,
-0.00736738,
-0.0286115464,
0.0561299063,
-0.0466757864,
-0.009063011,
-0.0210725758,
-0.0254828352,
-0.0221353285,
0.0428977273,
0.0390807353,
-0.0205048043,
0.0018767628,
-0.0324241966,
0.026172962,
-0.0367073342,
0.0223866682,
0.0179031286,
-0.0082342932,
-0.0707231835,
0.0170924012,
0.0026037735,
0.0175918005,
2.336712415e-34,
-0.020567771,
0.0309527963,
-0.0321535617,
0.0517521426,
0.0366076156,
-0.0245273001,
-0.0076320572,
-0.0041476563,
-0.0125502264,
0.0042890594,
-0.0062363939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14654v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14654v1 | Joint Multiple Intent Detection and Slot Filling with Supervised Contrastive Learning and Self-Distillation | 2023-08-28T15:36:33 | 2023-08-28T15:36:33 | Nguyen Anh Tu, Hoang Thi Thu Uyen, Tu Minh Phuong, Ngo Xuan Bach | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Multiple intent detection and slot filling are two fundamental and crucial
tasks in spoken language understanding. Motivated by the fact that the two
tasks are closely related, joint models that can detect intents and extract
slots simultaneously are preferred to individual models that perform each task
independently. The accuracy of a joint model depends heavily on the ability of
the model to transfer information between the two tasks so that the result of
one task can correct the result of the other. In addition, since a joint model
has multiple outputs, how to train the model effectively is also challenging.
In this paper, we present a method for multiple intent detection and slot
filling by addressing these challenges. First, we propose a bidirectional joint
model that explicitly employs intent information to recognize slots and slot
features to detect intents. Second, we introduce a novel method for training
the proposed joint model using supervised contrastive learning and
self-distillation. Experimental results on two benchmark datasets MixATIS and
MixSNIPS show that our method outperforms state-of-the-art models in both
tasks. The results also demonstrate the contributions of both bidirectional
design and the training method to the accuracy improvement. Our source code is
available at https://github.com/anhtunguyen98/BiSLU | [
0.0263870656,
0.0530082993,
0.0013488687,
0.0302061103,
-0.0402024016,
0.024379326,
-0.005470919,
-0.0158488322,
-0.0053078127,
-0.0578224808,
-0.0479436778,
-0.0312067103,
0.0055633029,
0.0404725894,
-0.0091898618,
-0.010842002,
0.0585543476,
-0.0347527936,
0.0108448425,
0.0303573702,
-0.0049401908,
0.0304486919,
-0.0583939664,
0.0275094286,
-0.0154832248,
-0.0431812629,
-0.0513333157,
0.0299148802,
0.0106387809,
-0.0216869507,
0.0391589962,
0.0575959235,
0.0021116454,
0.0103653949,
0.0000021214,
-0.0176897813,
-0.0348630138,
-0.018853927,
-0.1055196002,
-0.0216533411,
-0.0305019803,
-0.0295467321,
0.0030795801,
0.0177559275,
-0.0259401035,
-0.0374506786,
0.0194510426,
0.0341691971,
0.0365550071,
0.0449626483,
-0.0036124599,
-0.0328432247,
0.0148964077,
-0.0171120819,
0.0112011181,
-0.0255209859,
0.0370901562,
0.0141789373,
-0.0277356207,
0.0129925432,
-0.0018869061,
0.0413197279,
0.0155276591,
-0.0039400333,
0.0072525339,
0.0146771725,
0.0014059802,
-0.043904312,
-0.0496521592,
0.0855957195,
-0.0201177336,
0.0048422106,
0.0078058727,
-0.0697700009,
-0.010289534,
-0.0213034414,
0.0032754815,
0.0016580786,
-0.014603124,
0.0137220146,
0.0562333912,
0.003595527,
0.0089524435,
0.0187380016,
-0.0293850023,
0.0158485286,
-0.0059766425,
-0.0225972794,
-0.0052396213,
-0.0194311701,
0.0172970649,
-0.0450198874,
0.0198471379,
0.018513795,
-0.0409010835,
0.0308910795,
-0.0201226622,
-0.0401625298,
0.0257774573,
-0.004070228,
-0.0103644254,
0.0577612892,
-0.0846919641,
0.0583380833,
0.0122245401,
0.0081370063,
-0.0022092329,
0.0169030335,
-0.0621418655,
0.0220227279,
-0.0309069362,
0.0028672719,
-0.0424060896,
0.0351584405,
-0.0568153635,
-0.0235487334,
-0.0026655765,
-0.0063057891,
-0.0089886831,
0.0065829065,
0.0422071554,
-0.001111247,
-0.0286620371,
0.0003114097,
0.0124707064,
0.0849975571,
-0.0148499366,
0.0430690348,
-0.013988304,
-0.0446563065,
-0.0504327454,
0.0436048172,
0.0098837316,
-0.0523753688,
-0.0010254013,
0.0342434309,
-0.0220060404,
-0.0451273248,
-0.0586067811,
-0.0083070109,
-0.0458232686,
-0.0719661415,
-0.0591711104,
-0.05297447,
0.0233849362,
0.0050901915,
0.0184649918,
-0.0288175661,
0.0101704728,
-0.0159654487,
0.0150050884,
0.1053004339,
-0.0122427437,
0.0064094393,
-0.0009533452,
0.0138388211,
-0.0211258214,
0.0712053701,
0.0066741379,
0.0149887046,
-0.0000744508,
0.00195915,
-0.0103577487,
0.0046897465,
0.023086777,
-0.0095885433,
0.0458817221,
0.0118373958,
0.0387002863,
0.013983232,
0.0572501086,
0.0481499694,
-0.0399874002,
-0.026929399,
0.0349134468,
0.0045181541,
0.0636789501,
-0.0117277438,
0.060282208,
0.0679196715,
-0.0236898176,
0.0354062095,
-0.0432281196,
0.0045230063,
0.0207836572,
-0.0028712738,
0.0398756564,
0.0076164072,
-0.0204097647,
-0.0310584959,
0.002397781,
-0.0338306837,
0.0201188661,
-0.0174851045,
0.0644812584,
0.0033699761,
-0.0508381426,
0.0683399215,
0.0095807211,
-0.0027846608,
-0.0183798894,
-0.0698379278,
0.0150830513,
0.0234495737,
-0.0371091515,
-0.0360298194,
-0.0590872206,
-0.0385092571,
-0.0790241808,
-0.0105653638,
0.0287683345,
-0.0076016202,
0.0768373087,
-0.0330354571,
-0.0207377095,
-0.0178236309,
0.0090894885,
0.0331060961,
-0.0278465524,
-0.0018196233,
0.0088042729,
-0.0038083999,
0.0727823526,
0.0023121387,
-0.0032073937,
0.0001532634,
0.0130435545,
0.0234058928,
0.0501227304,
0.03306555,
0.0100479815,
-0.0310805943,
0.012700798,
-0.0117502315,
0.0166783165,
0.0177124105,
-0.0690173581,
-0.0803979263,
0.0219373312,
0.0006704352,
-0.0429804847,
0.0238520242,
-0.0310470127,
-0.0808389038,
0.0076362346,
0.0106240921,
-0.0069338302,
-0.0598043948,
0.0026677283,
0.073681578,
0.0203472357,
0.010343004,
0.0523681939,
0.0047676465,
0.0075545413,
0.0624325909,
-0.0262054913,
0.055733487,
-0.0544237457,
-0.0108989049,
-0.0217517782,
-0.057651598,
-0.0167994536,
-0.0181433,
0.0200166348,
-0.0721059367,
-0.0125009818,
-0.0603071414,
0.0014649167,
-0.0382199921,
-0.0041740565,
0.0243470073,
0.0158350449,
0.0019521881,
-0.0345394462,
0.0030659388,
-0.0492778383,
-0.0184866339,
-0.0266146995,
0.0025704426,
0.032041654,
-0.0074044229,
-0.0226001237,
0.0313604921,
-0.0110072782,
-0.0004388493,
-0.0294806622,
-0.0411487482,
-0.0343365632,
-0.0002625815,
0.0610676408,
0.0301061198,
-0.0045533855,
-0.0496344455,
-0.0072515621,
-0.0127885649,
-0.0401944071,
0.0578103513,
-0.0205685366,
0.0374705307,
0.0212221909,
-0.0249812603,
-0.0601200424,
0.073589325,
0.0003171269,
0.0842376351,
-0.0063297208,
0.0089484556,
-0.0252238456,
0.0702051297,
0.0342002176,
0.0330931135,
-0.0218969006,
-0.0372919664,
-0.0083273947,
-0.0614502802,
-0.0045810002,
0.0048358128,
-0.0355715491,
0.020555811,
-0.0264990237,
-0.0505010039,
0.048600588,
-0.0231667161,
-0.0497950315,
-0.0453162752,
-0.02669641,
-0.0248019807,
0.0670140758,
-0.0265342742,
0.0030904727,
0.0570599586,
-0.0671035275,
-0.0246988703,
-0.0191160738,
0.0064516752,
-0.0032286083,
0.0639998093,
-0.0352103859,
0.0240817498,
-0.0214354526,
-0.0556061603,
-0.0565066822,
-0.0904297456,
-0.0327406563,
0.0026756977,
0.0250970721,
-0.0253094565,
-0.0009046778,
0.0111750159,
-0.0052593071,
0.0500017442,
0.0175097566,
0.0196882226,
-0.0105945962,
0.0473013148,
0.0295369271,
0.0514799058,
-0.0458767265,
0.0143853743,
0.04779559,
0.0319370031,
-0.0164640453,
0.0341078155,
-0.0216523949,
0.0478133112,
0.0388399065,
-0.0111707486,
-0.0354277492,
-0.0092761954,
0.0751715302,
-0.0305299573,
0.0094383731,
0.0987672955,
0.0238322392,
-0.0093311705,
-0.0237636585,
-0.0072697853,
-0.0149743771,
-0.0057188361,
0.0038693275,
-0.0969696641,
-0.0762310922,
0.0135255195,
0.0113600567,
0.0341559276,
0.014045326,
-0.021659134,
-0.0814251602,
0.0460497849,
0.0029293371,
-0.0553220659,
-0.0298203453,
-0.0024398537,
0.0247744787,
-0.0477357395,
0.00479085,
0.0116527854,
0.0013059772,
-0.0401558243,
0.0302157644,
-0.0128879864,
0.000269937,
0.0258967839,
0.0001154513,
0.0959348232,
-0.005101976,
0.0246281922,
0.0130357593,
-0.0183514506,
-0.0327870511,
-0.0656254441,
-0.0202275179,
-0.034798611,
0.0382701382,
-0.0285609458,
-0.0206617527,
0.0257149376,
0.0332580768,
-0.036633376,
-0.0569038652,
-0.0306920391,
0.022658214,
-0.0136259831,
0.0274819676,
-0.0035998777,
0.017919274,
0.0771542639,
0.0813102797,
0.0236156322,
-0.0026215313,
-0.007137124,
-0.0010965313,
0.0021709413,
-0.0726697594,
0.0394445099,
0.0265143439,
0.0195813049,
-0.0119834803,
-0.0083208224,
-0.0393931977,
0.0361313447,
0.0113999322,
0.0034120677,
0.0592611693,
0.0271612369,
0.0103296638,
-0.0070256051,
0.0096561508,
-0.0005981586,
0.0394812934,
-0.0285029635,
-0.0662666485,
0.0205707513,
-0.0678514615,
-0.0394359902,
0.0048299963,
-0.1020296216,
-0.0277708229,
0.0093873758,
0.0355331674,
0.0183506683,
0.0611256585,
-0.0479376726,
0.0338261835,
-0.0316534676,
0.020366976,
-0.0538068376,
-0.0211476423,
0.079087317,
0.029751854,
-0.0178676955,
0.0267602857,
-0.0220352653,
0.0169663373,
-0.0097806882,
0.0209618118,
-0.0750534013,
-0.0204881653,
0.0541342236,
-0.0181676038,
0.0541882887,
0.010505843,
0.0362997875,
-0.0622636862,
0.0502765551,
0.0223283265,
-0.0052352203,
-0.0543649606,
0.013541921,
0.0359642804,
-0.0229991265,
-0.0071383528,
-0.046618484,
-0.0018538174,
-0.0125149852,
0.0063573122,
0.0195262991,
0.0473642647,
-0.0294781141,
-0.0007003254,
-0.0100175915,
-0.0231275521,
0.0222409498,
0.0277303495,
0.0239552818,
0.0118660741,
0.0948569179,
0.0066713267,
-0.0148445135,
0.0175776184,
0.0227313712,
-0.0118829431,
-0.025593441,
-0.0052081645,
-0.0231520832,
0.0428669117,
-0.0275996849,
0.0245851986,
0.0228179712,
0.0265389029,
-0.0100056808,
0.0655189529,
-0.0039931708,
0.0288385395,
0.0349768847,
0.0180146359,
-0.0181310307,
-0.0126636354,
0.0542080663,
-0.0537140183,
0.0418572128,
0.0230508558,
0.0493371151,
-0.0500584431,
-0.0139919221,
0.0086839059,
0.051020734,
-0.0389781743,
0.0253587663,
-0.0163062941,
-0.0480069034,
-0.0208023358,
0.0237706043,
0.0190741122,
0.0273889322,
0.0222449955,
0.0131932441,
-0.0085661644,
-0.0330054499,
-0.0393503122,
-0.0475584306,
0.0126969758,
0.0159871392,
-0.0209605824,
-6.448865599e-33,
-0.0185124669,
0.002804942,
0.0055330554,
-0.0337783806,
0.0047255587,
0.0258181617,
-0.0108112469,
-0.0209811404,
-0.0354261249,
-0.0057949922,
0.0293802358,
0.021962272,
0.0406260639,
0.0082758553,
0.0269873329,
-0.0256629474,
0.0656593367,
0.007641776,
-0.0014829885,
-0.0146255894,
0.0171359852,
0.0224530362,
0.0379394107,
-0.0387579426,
-0.0219841897,
0.022695018,
-0.0439039245,
0.0406625345,
-0.0254064593,
0.0653616711,
-0.0008956112,
0.0048255376,
0.005578334,
-0.0355180129,
-0.0198353492,
0.0408342965,
-0.1172364354,
-0.0431499332,
0.043895077,
0.0309272874,
-0.0523597337,
0.0103056114,
0.0020990286,
0.0159855187,
0.0307898503,
-0.0156110153,
0.0025719737,
0.0126403747,
0.015103058,
0.0301519334,
-0.0271797366,
0.0298184399,
-0.0341521241,
-0.0629973784,
0.0424850844,
0.0285366308,
0.0217076186,
-0.0401927419,
-0.101576671,
0.0034388646,
-0.0289489906,
0.0248025022,
0.0245036874,
0.0249555241,
-0.0384415276,
0.0535262264,
0.0406606235,
-0.0548107736,
0.0595640615,
-0.0400761887,
-0.0289417878,
0.059165623,
-0.0217285398,
-0.0088185798,
0.0913571045,
0.0077536758,
-0.0165983029,
0.0060830018,
0.0144152688,
0.0523883104,
-0.0103290742,
0.039993681,
-0.0475973599,
0.0177344363,
-0.0321685001,
-0.030025512,
-0.0415598713,
-0.0182188619,
0.0406248756,
0.0416361168,
-0.0083298115,
0.0225263145,
0.0662944391,
-0.0330794342,
0.019278951,
0.0127855558,
-0.0114201102,
0.0060929223,
-0.014348357,
0.0168962628,
-0.0424062572,
-0.05614122,
0.025596628,
0.0492992848,
0.0249109566,
0.0067978771,
0.0141878892,
0.0212156437,
-0.0361079015,
0.0050962362,
-0.0299194511,
0.0197631884,
-0.0472538769,
0.0117913075,
0.0484838821,
0.0185818188,
-0.0374500677,
0.0462740101,
0.0046772202,
0.0215551853,
-0.0462402888,
-0.0578707643,
0.0043124226,
0.0404491723,
-0.0043934169,
-0.0083978139,
-0.0011968517,
-0.0508308485,
0.0119413342,
-0.0308990814,
0.0118091563,
0.0348091498,
2.814e-7,
0.0426480174,
-0.0018610889,
0.0130264498,
0.0235024374,
0.0006631087,
0.0534891859,
-0.0204916298,
0.0009536526,
0.0083757211,
-0.0258893073,
0.0228155199,
0.0139244106,
0.0236762986,
0.008667767,
-0.106324628,
0.0487254895,
-0.0087764263,
-0.0094042132,
-0.0443629548,
0.0167885739,
0.0990293175,
0.1063489243,
0.0136002759,
-0.0086538577,
0.0163711011,
-0.002715091,
-0.0138954222,
0.0043307445,
0.0414391942,
0.0065882592,
-0.0012948102,
-0.0010936685,
-0.0035803569,
0.0642107576,
-0.0275973603,
0.0281874165,
-0.0004354884,
0.0435057506,
0.0133448699,
-0.041104082,
-0.0357793421,
0.0301049761,
0.0144862095,
-0.0498761423,
0.0767067969,
-0.0581937991,
-0.0066766082,
-0.0416784286,
-0.0562073737,
0.0213242751,
0.0160220135,
0.0299871992,
0.0087404223,
0.0235613771,
0.0082750348,
-0.0278973542,
-0.0507993922,
-0.0890023187,
-0.0228482615,
0.0105728898,
-0.0156245064,
-0.0148991467,
-0.0137853827,
-0.0699429289,
0.0492011271,
-0.0650491416,
-0.0531255566,
2.20111983e-34,
0.0282684192,
-0.0351787657,
0.0155304456,
0.0760395899,
0.0025799244,
-0.019172458,
-0.0940730795,
0.0097984616,
0.0109648071,
-0.0356654227,
-0.0269294605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14641v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14641v2 | Challenges of GPT-3-based Conversational Agents for Healthcare | 2023-08-28T15:12:34 | 2023-08-29T15:48:23 | Fabian Lechner, Allison Lahnala, Charles Welch, Lucie Flek | cs.CL | cs.CL | The potential to provide patients with faster information access while
allowing medical specialists to concentrate on critical tasks makes medical
domain dialog agents appealing. However, the integration of large-language
models (LLMs) into these agents presents certain limitations that may result in
serious consequences. This paper investigates the challenges and risks of using
GPT-3-based models for medical question-answering (MedQA). We perform several
evaluations contextualized in terms of standard medical principles. We provide
a procedure for manually designing patient queries to stress-test high-risk
limitations of LLMs in MedQA systems. Our analysis reveals that LLMs fail to
respond adequately to these queries, generating erroneous medical information,
unsafe recommendations, and content that may be considered offensive. | [
0.0832946897,
0.022202488,
-0.0124429828,
0.0019597167,
-0.0233674888,
0.0193441398,
0.0035022248,
0.0242466461,
0.0368105844,
-0.0221845787,
-0.0021686514,
-0.0632315353,
-0.0276541431,
0.0227756221,
0.0100650676,
-0.0570837185,
0.017704932,
-0.0018314581,
0.0532688573,
-0.0011969238,
0.0268178247,
0.0070152422,
-0.0340352505,
0.0644662306,
0.0126379598,
-0.0147124846,
-0.0042641819,
-0.0057165455,
0.0055740639,
-0.0666870698,
-0.015040556,
0.0280663241,
-0.0171881877,
-0.0046226522,
0.0000018064,
-0.0579018109,
-0.0004819498,
0.0409018733,
-0.0599346124,
-0.0411218368,
0.0298155416,
-0.0222486928,
-0.010643445,
0.025654057,
-0.0359869227,
-0.011855226,
0.0486567691,
0.0739154518,
0.0597850382,
0.0502674431,
-0.0226470213,
0.0154202031,
0.0209248457,
0.0062146317,
0.0370226651,
-0.0904406831,
0.0417267457,
0.0196129773,
0.0958423242,
-0.006397476,
0.0320725739,
0.029985236,
0.0040213196,
0.030694494,
-0.0421158187,
0.0295394547,
-0.0391069241,
-0.0202945042,
-0.0138930073,
0.0724017471,
0.0400710888,
0.0216645487,
0.0122698583,
0.0098367147,
-0.0006835869,
-0.0201462097,
-0.0566729605,
0.0034721959,
-0.0456846543,
-0.0238707494,
-0.0258472767,
-0.0002451623,
0.0174194537,
0.013296607,
-0.0123508787,
0.0087655382,
0.0254754834,
-0.0277255364,
0.0042743641,
-0.0314523801,
-0.0170286167,
-0.0025506371,
0.0407468341,
0.0441143773,
-0.0741590336,
0.03738847,
-0.0139334584,
0.0197071154,
0.0758857653,
-0.0578702129,
-0.0078199701,
0.0383156948,
0.0214486122,
0.0309332442,
0.0431103259,
0.0107867066,
-0.0465906076,
0.0099444864,
-0.0427474156,
-0.0129457954,
-0.0294229779,
-0.0369475335,
-0.0590835549,
0.0332010165,
-0.007205944,
-0.0083228331,
-0.0421092957,
0.0320872962,
0.0129550127,
0.0012299872,
0.0061688167,
0.035960447,
-0.0361808538,
0.0006595381,
-0.0444262326,
0.0117950514,
-0.0413090996,
-0.0113059022,
-0.0009809628,
-0.1032143459,
0.016630251,
0.0081404066,
0.0004828991,
-0.0132754864,
0.0033053826,
0.0701376051,
-0.0080172326,
-0.0137630394,
0.0113136936,
-0.0417236201,
-0.0518952087,
-0.0405182019,
0.0157577507,
-0.0282305591,
0.0273084547,
0.0173504017,
-0.0306305364,
-0.0351007581,
0.0378871672,
0.0416290127,
-0.0582199208,
0.0484270342,
-0.0343870968,
0.0256208777,
0.0175119676,
0.0589357093,
-0.0120660644,
0.0259673782,
0.007887695,
-0.0512996614,
0.0179719254,
-0.0401056036,
0.0329553597,
0.0092393821,
0.0129946005,
-0.0148761254,
0.0403481387,
0.0613175035,
0.0099093458,
0.0674530342,
-0.063865982,
0.116278179,
-0.0101187397,
-0.0309009515,
0.0531633534,
0.075578697,
-0.03576966,
0.0053878534,
0.023896629,
-0.0030378301,
0.0231550764,
0.0012612609,
-0.0234704483,
-0.0015223949,
0.006999983,
0.0008748797,
-0.0224029738,
0.0250619836,
-0.0488491692,
-0.0209200028,
-0.0321522765,
-0.0109513029,
0.0088096838,
-0.0047442135,
0.0134075377,
-0.023870917,
-0.0392394662,
0.0478576832,
0.0049754744,
-0.0498875752,
-0.0338548608,
-0.0628174916,
-0.0178190339,
0.1165452302,
0.069534637,
-0.0046514841,
-0.070589304,
-0.0236869603,
0.0128553323,
0.0199995469,
0.0317866988,
-0.0050733704,
-0.0020481267,
-0.0456774272,
0.0027984362,
0.044485826,
0.0095321909,
-0.0372475721,
0.0196995642,
0.0331077687,
0.0004195735,
-0.013572881,
0.0121253161,
0.0009339594,
-0.0473507494,
-0.0333384536,
-0.0200045686,
-0.0224581473,
0.0369234383,
0.0346762985,
0.0006833992,
0.0291305315,
0.0327063315,
0.0080566211,
-0.0097813755,
0.027423881,
-0.0387127325,
0.0125316838,
0.0042038066,
-0.0130032217,
-0.019407833,
-0.0123427911,
-0.0060004434,
-0.0388769917,
-0.0451381765,
-0.0893717781,
0.0339666903,
-0.0266957302,
0.0020918308,
0.0516265035,
-0.0061744517,
-0.037878111,
0.0026469072,
0.0039839242,
0.0065192403,
0.033861924,
0.005134929,
-0.016121434,
-0.0601901561,
-0.014622028,
0.050887581,
0.011023202,
0.0229893904,
-0.0083906772,
0.0123383673,
-0.0410024859,
-0.0219093394,
-0.1271279603,
-0.0221329331,
0.0081893941,
0.0085446369,
0.0192968585,
0.0525953844,
-0.0244445298,
-0.0219023805,
-0.0569334626,
0.0049773422,
0.0413541533,
0.0440101437,
0.026742423,
0.0349714309,
-0.0346749537,
-0.0136123365,
0.0042459001,
-0.0402389765,
-0.0042850426,
0.0137388809,
-0.0028793202,
0.0079111168,
-0.0276364014,
-0.0550715253,
0.02485287,
0.0008126103,
-0.0353692099,
0.0356238894,
-0.0214429293,
0.0072430777,
0.0473017171,
0.0050916178,
0.0216764174,
0.0007913758,
-0.0174206775,
-0.02405563,
0.032091599,
-0.0354135819,
-0.0524633899,
0.0043413984,
-0.0388459638,
0.0095984414,
0.0619564652,
0.0232943278,
0.0258883704,
-0.0538267009,
0.0208210368,
-0.0075711729,
0.00676934,
-0.0106503731,
0.0069369595,
-0.0466947295,
0.0353278145,
0.0300601814,
-0.0173233785,
0.084620066,
-0.0113750705,
-0.0025053942,
-0.0770953521,
-0.0219111741,
-0.0444061495,
0.022599902,
-0.0328824595,
0.0377166308,
0.0414804965,
-0.0321904346,
-0.0173059683,
-0.0133774141,
-0.0208581686,
-0.0597008169,
0.0469418392,
-0.037283536,
0.0144651383,
-0.0020160372,
-0.0647766069,
-0.0233818423,
-0.0101178614,
-0.0503499471,
-0.0080707902,
0.0075045447,
0.0136115421,
-0.0446740687,
0.0266969875,
0.0030665013,
0.0480490923,
-0.0066518225,
-0.0255957115,
-0.0065869847,
0.0010215497,
0.0319697931,
0.0319345333,
-0.005318467,
0.0245971717,
0.0731861591,
0.0784927458,
0.0205994342,
-0.0175142661,
0.0180066526,
-0.0020785506,
0.0088179177,
-0.0200944133,
-0.0068743215,
0.0414776392,
0.0225074142,
-0.0686252937,
-0.0008692267,
0.1065569371,
0.0346085653,
-0.0338720568,
0.0134575833,
-0.0264442861,
-0.0199224595,
-0.0328776054,
0.0182561036,
-0.0639527589,
-0.0309838951,
-0.0240991656,
0.0264245179,
-0.0540546291,
-0.0051776664,
0.023252381,
-0.0646883994,
0.0509747006,
-0.0162518062,
-0.0182157606,
-0.0123858983,
0.0036297161,
0.0258018263,
0.0138152083,
0.035045132,
0.0236331522,
-0.0206386428,
-0.0214287117,
-0.009199962,
-0.0456832759,
-0.0474070907,
0.0625995845,
0.0085084159,
0.0371769331,
0.0882725641,
0.0450982824,
-0.0189432576,
-0.0478730984,
0.0172957014,
-0.0092232674,
-0.0107012577,
0.003960277,
0.0354659185,
0.0179099832,
0.0058123684,
-0.0917050466,
0.0342995077,
-0.0331656486,
0.0054330146,
0.008912161,
0.082272321,
-0.0576888286,
-0.0175978038,
-0.0534478799,
0.0456813537,
0.0134624476,
0.0683609769,
-0.0147632426,
-0.0182651598,
-0.048515141,
0.0062608989,
0.0134678399,
0.0090356804,
-0.0349465385,
0.015187731,
0.0217097253,
0.0093053821,
-0.0450509973,
-0.0494320877,
0.0521035455,
-0.016621789,
0.0037413221,
0.0313392356,
0.0139137851,
0.0525038205,
-0.0091304881,
0.0112665221,
0.0199514143,
0.0038710905,
-0.0526070632,
0.0010619712,
0.0585856624,
-0.022598248,
0.0030044229,
-0.0048054997,
0.007903168,
-0.0146512892,
-0.0039283209,
0.0505938195,
0.0275870692,
-0.0348264687,
-0.0115480656,
-0.0183673315,
-0.0243380554,
0.0232099034,
-0.050875809,
-0.0111543853,
0.0027706267,
0.029781362,
-0.0055934181,
0.0119603286,
-0.0366192013,
0.0090971021,
-0.046728082,
0.030698007,
-0.0436615199,
-0.0387042314,
0.0280444156,
0.0525862761,
-0.0147236744,
0.0291212536,
-0.0166388657,
0.0171552077,
0.0431211591,
-0.0502486415,
0.0195560977,
-0.0297584068,
0.0155391134,
0.0093637351,
-0.0056474847,
0.0067726187,
-0.0274568703,
-0.0817321911,
-0.0239158608,
-0.0158546288,
0.0310189426,
-0.0076981424,
-0.0353299528,
0.0463533513,
-0.0289277527,
-0.0123419147,
0.026479993,
0.0074271774,
0.037185993,
0.0095768422,
0.0959400609,
-0.0084406603,
-0.0143369744,
0.0374733657,
0.0592719615,
-0.0710349157,
-0.1026999205,
0.0006009152,
0.0370868444,
-0.0129133575,
0.0230127294,
0.0188706219,
-0.0286069587,
0.0165777896,
-0.0315310694,
-0.0120636532,
-0.0109992903,
0.0013805011,
0.0699365512,
0.0264460798,
0.002555612,
-0.0394964069,
0.0655824319,
0.0017055386,
0.0474828593,
0.0088110063,
-0.0454317033,
-0.0242334194,
-0.0494796261,
0.0052463142,
0.0046454212,
-0.0467128232,
-0.005626617,
-0.0866344348,
-0.0370013751,
-0.0246370733,
-0.0338602699,
-0.0340638384,
-0.06842269,
0.0761225298,
0.0595618598,
0.0264696479,
-0.0331424922,
-0.0111247525,
0.0429790355,
-0.0857916698,
0.0102482066,
0.0219789073,
-5.953661053e-33,
-0.0017220533,
-0.0282274019,
0.0304763336,
-0.0195080936,
-0.0316555724,
-0.0043765702,
-0.0326250903,
0.0043933792,
-0.0218743067,
0.0100510214,
-0.0439057723,
0.0239333902,
0.007883694,
0.0327641219,
-0.0341751575,
-0.0830022395,
0.0175945498,
-0.0026949935,
-0.0042372416,
0.0513688177,
-0.0074558826,
0.0186266769,
-0.0149758365,
-0.0717192665,
0.0177228674,
-0.0172270834,
0.0194245707,
0.0208456181,
-0.0232577603,
0.0809795558,
-0.019912621,
0.0485335924,
0.0525104329,
-0.0180613473,
0.0092709158,
0.0410132706,
-0.0335113406,
-0.0046958965,
0.0274206921,
-0.0149837006,
-0.0241207406,
-0.0298382062,
0.0145627502,
-0.0266692378,
-0.0245613623,
-0.0026728027,
-0.0185517371,
-0.0136933485,
0.0102316402,
-0.012692105,
-0.0403044596,
0.0301150121,
0.0073054349,
-0.0118214106,
-0.0338855423,
0.0294628534,
-0.0300991684,
0.0225924756,
0.0260791555,
-0.0263219755,
0.0483709797,
-0.0052344743,
0.0045354874,
-0.0218473077,
0.0017214589,
0.0276049245,
0.0263965894,
0.0072991173,
-0.0593533702,
0.0025300123,
-0.0692392141,
0.028939737,
0.0553155579,
0.0448890813,
-0.0125285117,
0.0057815756,
-0.0642231107,
0.0364653319,
-0.0494993441,
0.0853213072,
0.0396169387,
-0.019734975,
-0.0755573958,
-0.010807991,
-0.0198165104,
0.0571257174,
-0.0258728154,
-0.0591465235,
0.0595269501,
-0.0203866567,
0.0229222085,
0.001420259,
-0.0093319286,
-0.0002811119,
0.0454463512,
-0.0066772792,
0.0146732396,
0.0017857945,
-0.0275815912,
0.0157086253,
-0.0292706136,
0.0294330008,
0.0201723799,
-0.0221408866,
0.0152772488,
0.0376597643,
-0.0461449176,
-0.0262406487,
-0.0510062687,
-0.0133442869,
0.0042770468,
0.0320624635,
-0.0203355271,
0.0267435983,
0.0322237089,
0.0192974936,
-0.0005490651,
0.0467793681,
-0.0043606604,
-0.0197116937,
-0.0796024725,
-0.0531096868,
-0.0046314914,
-0.0096912533,
-0.0510130227,
0.0156421214,
-0.0358309001,
0.0489756465,
0.0194631834,
-0.0711928979,
0.0002955509,
0.0057686535,
2.701e-7,
0.0738738105,
0.0485964194,
0.0196325015,
0.012319441,
0.0385849662,
0.0280159004,
0.0189972911,
0.0221002661,
0.0299421642,
-0.0248416141,
0.0371700972,
0.0282468554,
0.0244260132,
0.0587345175,
-0.0693700463,
-0.0213049576,
-0.0792203248,
-0.0404055715,
-0.04713374,
-0.0130086094,
0.0765897557,
0.0494716205,
-0.0650062785,
-0.0263799131,
0.0121013476,
-0.038259659,
0.0369654857,
-0.0409856439,
-0.0034515427,
0.038929835,
0.0353051238,
-0.0138509925,
0.0274247546,
0.0490109585,
0.0191451479,
-0.0255200993,
0.0023807893,
0.0984070227,
-0.0377261229,
-0.0156024871,
0.0222905464,
-0.0534691997,
0.0325030498,
-0.0602999777,
0.0707002133,
-0.0493173748,
-0.051688876,
0.0213830434,
0.010806662,
-0.0592886508,
0.0353955515,
-0.0410741344,
-0.0438992195,
0.0092406329,
-0.0012652301,
0.0136650819,
0.0290290639,
-0.0357958302,
0.025436284,
0.0138714323,
-0.0331513919,
-0.079666093,
0.0157532264,
-0.0259979814,
-0.0015486921,
-0.0393969156,
0.005812027,
2.169725406e-34,
0.0355437733,
0.0067758104,
0.0339449011,
0.0517371148,
0.0428547114,
0.0307843629,
0.0428201333,
0.0175271444,
0.044718951,
-0.0684609413,
-0.014481822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14634v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14634v1 | Breaking the Bank with ChatGPT: Few-Shot Text Classification for Finance | 2023-08-28T15:04:16 | 2023-08-28T15:04:16 | Lefteris Loukas, Ilias Stogiannidis, Prodromos Malakasiotis, Stavros Vassos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-fin.CP | We propose the use of conversational GPT models for easy and quick few-shot
text classification in the financial domain using the Banking77 dataset. Our
approach involves in-context learning with GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, which minimizes
the technical expertise required and eliminates the need for expensive GPU
computing while yielding quick and accurate results. Additionally, we fine-tune
other pre-trained, masked language models with SetFit, a recent contrastive
learning technique, to achieve state-of-the-art results both in full-data and
few-shot settings. Our findings show that querying GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 can
outperform fine-tuned, non-generative models even with fewer examples. However,
subscription fees associated with these solutions may be considered costly for
small organizations. Lastly, we find that generative models perform better on
the given task when shown representative samples selected by a human expert
rather than when shown random ones. We conclude that a) our proposed methods
offer a practical solution for few-shot tasks in datasets with limited label
availability, and b) our state-of-the-art results can inspire future work in
the area. | [
0.0050204238,
0.0760379583,
-0.0015983704,
0.0125585971,
-0.0300036501,
0.0286154207,
0.0782079548,
0.0641055033,
0.0281914715,
-0.0583533533,
-0.0373916477,
-0.0413755067,
-0.0023345305,
0.0357201435,
0.0331614129,
-0.0468398295,
0.010625653,
0.0231605638,
0.0327161662,
-0.0172727797,
0.0335733294,
0.0264885575,
0.0053186896,
0.000633518,
0.0101305321,
-0.035310708,
-0.0045907479,
-0.0162447579,
0.0133512598,
0.0124736326,
0.0430902392,
0.0564379059,
0.0300371647,
0.0616731197,
0.0000021043,
-0.048379153,
-0.0436257236,
0.0032515498,
-0.0263248831,
0.0212173164,
0.0436410792,
-0.016647419,
0.0292725991,
0.03183496,
-0.0664712638,
-0.0326366201,
0.0372822918,
0.0753545538,
0.0296084918,
0.0728513077,
-0.0416550376,
-0.0645387322,
-0.0129746292,
-0.0831927285,
0.0343240947,
-0.0817703679,
0.0309207439,
0.0015812163,
-0.030070046,
0.0378152616,
-0.0266687889,
0.0271769855,
0.0075784628,
0.0056793224,
0.0079259155,
0.0429400168,
-0.0407956317,
0.0256285239,
-0.0259447433,
0.0453487784,
-0.0331988782,
0.0084269438,
0.0256282836,
-0.0633146837,
-0.0140669858,
-0.0038902184,
-0.0248930193,
0.0122027369,
-0.0151729705,
0.012655112,
-0.035190057,
0.0293259937,
0.0317074545,
-0.0131455651,
-0.0020767655,
-0.0504647456,
-0.0147862434,
-0.0234080926,
0.0059151202,
0.0179948546,
-0.0467971824,
-0.0467011817,
-0.0244781021,
-0.0232497081,
0.0289824922,
0.0028357636,
-0.0310385805,
-0.0412933491,
0.0010284215,
-0.0412890464,
-0.0011977673,
0.0335495174,
-0.0050956151,
0.0505563915,
-0.0286849961,
-0.002622575,
0.0256150085,
-0.0324395485,
-0.00335802,
0.0299173407,
-0.0795644224,
-0.0219883211,
-0.0724089369,
0.0729758516,
-0.064863652,
-0.0179839861,
-0.0620785989,
-0.0033131144,
0.0138397422,
-0.0066348705,
0.0080146324,
-0.0264029615,
-0.0107888132,
-0.013330631,
-0.0054845572,
-0.0280883107,
-0.0402343348,
0.0267643072,
-0.0143050542,
-0.0438391268,
-0.0054400004,
0.0256661102,
-0.0148465941,
-0.0330894627,
0.0146365678,
0.0638007149,
0.0005868004,
-0.1006502286,
-0.036435701,
0.0046189642,
-0.0274797715,
-0.0287023354,
-0.0283497777,
-0.0066533638,
0.0124361068,
0.0024782135,
-0.002336361,
0.0006239081,
0.0001076262,
0.0136046233,
-0.0145043042,
0.1055679619,
0.0230271574,
-0.0453712456,
0.0390098132,
-0.0201878045,
-0.0136285638,
0.0519230515,
0.001815132,
0.0210519955,
0.0298748575,
-0.0083426218,
0.0369674712,
0.0340905376,
0.0439100787,
-0.0423761569,
0.0394944176,
0.0361030474,
0.0251218546,
0.0063688154,
0.0194711648,
0.0206414349,
-0.0535810292,
-0.0310636554,
0.0658742785,
0.0367349386,
0.0439265445,
0.0407939106,
-0.0227233618,
0.0734610185,
-0.0102724116,
-0.0224618725,
0.0173355043,
-0.0073698922,
-0.0490258597,
0.0155091863,
0.0314432606,
0.0054414375,
-0.0467346907,
-0.0178670902,
0.0052900412,
-0.0035562611,
-0.0085496744,
0.0188932735,
0.0374871381,
-0.0197482537,
-0.0665527806,
0.0228230525,
0.0368463919,
-0.0200918056,
-0.043601457,
-0.0647968724,
0.0456437282,
0.0389651544,
0.022662621,
-0.0167215113,
0.0226274282,
-0.0434692204,
0.0266804639,
0.0480994619,
0.0461933166,
0.0187134929,
0.0179016422,
-0.0752348527,
0.0054757646,
0.0118751023,
0.0279843975,
0.0363880396,
0.011836323,
0.0072634839,
0.0204011984,
0.0009438532,
-0.0003286025,
0.014376861,
0.0045518079,
-0.0753219053,
0.0654458404,
-0.0100815147,
0.0026926198,
-0.0004277671,
-0.0229260214,
-0.0175544061,
-0.0172844548,
0.0084597943,
-0.0088168131,
-0.0128348898,
-0.0281236861,
-0.0392614678,
-0.0451842323,
0.0001363576,
0.0009631088,
0.0146840606,
-0.0832644105,
-0.0256114304,
-0.0452100672,
-0.0226666573,
0.0227646176,
-0.0736186281,
-0.0334345847,
0.0174716227,
0.0221943893,
-0.0305157918,
0.0830972642,
0.029842414,
0.0104860906,
-0.0361364,
0.0089591388,
0.044069916,
-0.0400483347,
0.033656653,
-0.002781403,
-0.01447553,
0.0239621531,
0.0342232883,
0.0211703219,
-0.0004098545,
-0.0042758496,
-0.0947561711,
-0.0163424127,
-0.0017067383,
0.0266070478,
0.0068464745,
0.0229810197,
-0.0224056561,
-0.0349857435,
-0.0621003397,
0.0072802003,
-0.0075944811,
-0.0026538419,
0.0630636588,
0.0058518751,
0.0133074997,
-0.0219326392,
0.0208655633,
0.0170906857,
0.0300905723,
0.0405891128,
-0.0586197861,
-0.0023227949,
0.019516971,
0.0158508401,
0.0124498494,
-0.0181183647,
0.0211361013,
-0.0189393256,
0.0111444043,
0.0041763484,
0.0242216475,
0.0171713829,
0.0572941601,
-0.0641186759,
0.0196513254,
-0.0328473933,
0.0336674228,
-0.0278077498,
-0.013062872,
0.0055957111,
0.0193819497,
0.0144785419,
0.0531642884,
0.0008366353,
-0.0067272228,
-0.1101175919,
0.0458811074,
0.0299017336,
0.0312684178,
-0.0563105159,
0.0485918522,
-0.0035341089,
0.0230098125,
-0.0001090741,
-0.0413059965,
0.0497944318,
0.007546619,
-0.0140330847,
-0.0370972157,
-0.0474717431,
-0.0541163795,
0.0569934286,
-0.0042282213,
-0.0031299242,
0.0421225838,
-0.0374383852,
-0.026644757,
-0.0396133736,
0.0621061549,
0.0064020762,
0.0126459925,
-0.0111084012,
0.0568021946,
-0.0341659002,
-0.0723735318,
0.0036347981,
-0.1094073579,
-0.0173612703,
0.0053582592,
0.0509960428,
-0.0385697037,
-0.0473007709,
0.0323327407,
-0.0299748164,
0.0563809685,
-0.0217392929,
-0.0394012965,
0.009776595,
0.0368690304,
0.0519287959,
-0.0248681549,
-0.0078376634,
-0.032400772,
0.0305311158,
0.0314743184,
0.0135086197,
0.0164817963,
-0.0001066671,
-0.0313474685,
-0.0195730999,
-0.0531686991,
-0.0185098872,
-0.0169680156,
-0.0161907654,
-0.0237540305,
-0.0169809368,
0.1072259173,
0.0022069244,
-0.0204677507,
-0.0280635431,
0.0425585918,
0.0146655738,
-0.0385330133,
0.0531733595,
-0.1127632931,
-0.0519805327,
-0.0297754575,
0.0318887271,
0.0157393795,
-0.033578366,
-0.0354161225,
-0.105676122,
0.0553084165,
0.0037582552,
-0.0362578146,
-0.0122619839,
-0.0193539374,
-0.0015609202,
-0.0414336696,
-0.0208047591,
-0.0216795094,
-0.0130895833,
0.0110396678,
0.0049678949,
-0.0240610596,
-0.0190425813,
0.0309743658,
0.0217239801,
-0.0361309275,
0.0491256528,
0.0123003675,
0.0080115804,
-0.0179193541,
0.0135392128,
-0.0213064086,
-0.0136306845,
-0.0048385654,
0.0811474845,
-0.0461859293,
-0.0136613622,
0.0139175784,
0.0306898654,
-0.0066732406,
-0.0014872572,
-0.0097019682,
-0.0098789306,
-0.0106485616,
-0.0284545515,
0.0100996699,
0.0202826336,
0.0154785784,
0.0788556486,
0.0140277119,
-0.0574969873,
-0.0296528731,
-0.0222320296,
0.0194170475,
-0.0397032313,
0.0083984444,
-0.0447485447,
0.0345301107,
-0.0192038361,
-0.0540038384,
-0.0564826801,
0.0342001729,
0.0444091856,
-0.0400865339,
-0.002597963,
0.0101357447,
0.0037461203,
-0.0182366259,
-0.0147419171,
-0.0602672435,
0.0164116751,
-0.0462294891,
0.006359071,
0.0452086888,
-0.0631483421,
-0.0697820187,
0.0289335269,
-0.0798131153,
-0.0409332551,
-0.017380327,
0.0141575197,
0.0228742044,
-0.0057709301,
-0.0099214558,
-0.018463064,
0.0682877377,
0.0937063247,
-0.0481002629,
-0.0231872592,
0.0384845212,
-0.0003873533,
-0.0230192132,
0.0234911349,
-0.024818372,
0.0475929119,
0.0017985193,
-0.0140224844,
-0.0621489398,
0.0242985673,
-0.0178841837,
-0.0267387629,
0.0803187788,
-0.0051533408,
-0.0348872654,
-0.0317733102,
0.0191547368,
0.0184904598,
0.0257498659,
-0.0337282382,
-0.0506244712,
0.0449412689,
-0.0207779966,
-0.034929581,
-0.005233414,
-0.0243386105,
0.0085008927,
-0.0233196225,
-0.0283902716,
0.0037766462,
0.0047249603,
0.0063035083,
-0.0330764502,
0.0214361679,
0.0175096747,
0.0364271514,
0.0140665509,
-0.002858018,
0.0519111976,
0.0468131378,
0.0138620939,
0.0084968526,
-0.0113046933,
-0.0477269068,
-0.0071841208,
-0.0517418608,
0.0466172397,
0.0217234883,
-0.0353029408,
-0.0119824475,
-0.0480293408,
0.0031112439,
-0.0097207492,
0.0360482447,
0.0044560968,
-0.0300060082,
0.016627254,
0.0112382658,
-0.050297536,
-0.0094356872,
0.1055067405,
0.0199839901,
0.0171935465,
0.0233307686,
-0.0150828278,
-0.0557358675,
-0.027150372,
0.0662839189,
0.0313140079,
0.0274955947,
0.0216974989,
-0.0719866455,
-0.02644049,
0.015851317,
-0.0280205831,
-0.0084396284,
0.0081935301,
0.0599083193,
0.041867882,
-0.0053205229,
0.0272849277,
-0.0176138803,
0.0010976413,
-0.0069548395,
-0.0160926133,
-0.0487120003,
-6.43028985e-33,
-0.01862894,
-0.0316361077,
0.0290686376,
0.0246177819,
0.051657781,
0.0043095388,
0.002774958,
-0.0357005186,
0.0115791596,
0.0084874406,
0.0104623744,
0.0248867534,
0.0142435012,
0.0652901679,
-0.0224025566,
-0.0028912274,
0.0391109884,
-0.0213134307,
-0.0236703884,
0.0473904051,
0.0102179656,
0.0675165504,
0.0504202843,
-0.0500481054,
0.0077500506,
-0.0161672477,
-0.0432337038,
0.0134381559,
0.0368435532,
0.031835977,
-0.0188345332,
0.0260276161,
0.0189440772,
-0.0737105682,
0.0111533161,
0.0109410686,
-0.0590065904,
-0.0633172244,
-0.0038724942,
0.0084707784,
0.0180953816,
0.0017421999,
-0.0084333019,
-0.0214730948,
-0.0014867635,
-0.0397683382,
0.0151849147,
0.0093140053,
0.00431342,
-0.0387666635,
-0.0437155403,
0.0659098774,
0.0197864752,
0.0037895392,
0.0490295291,
0.0585552603,
0.0275180265,
0.0301635731,
-0.0540887974,
-0.0006669525,
0.0330330059,
-0.0278001837,
-0.0035478417,
0.0116226459,
-0.0023430188,
0.0371423215,
0.0120281242,
0.0038030196,
0.0108603844,
-0.0085460097,
-0.0114484141,
0.0206140503,
0.0229678918,
0.0755536333,
0.0572600365,
-0.0505423248,
-0.0591590255,
0.0189055428,
0.0128395474,
-0.0317287073,
0.0325927064,
0.0245753955,
-0.0638725534,
-0.0390106812,
0.0151008749,
-0.0319407769,
-0.0276752114,
-0.0163525939,
0.0188738834,
0.0360825695,
0.0081745898,
0.043613553,
0.0224827155,
-0.0289858598,
-0.0528975949,
-0.0074798502,
-0.0068321377,
0.0038913426,
0.0083885919,
-0.0105109112,
-0.0605505705,
-0.0429433919,
0.0236987136,
0.0527782664,
-0.0140044577,
-0.0211347602,
0.0483327769,
0.0160815623,
-0.0947248191,
0.0066149328,
0.0087753758,
0.0407033004,
-0.0144192763,
0.0632722303,
-0.0114672333,
0.0494858325,
0.009622925,
0.0186899845,
0.0047940444,
-0.003348253,
-0.0033002845,
-0.0252517052,
-0.028114967,
0.0395865217,
0.0291301198,
0.0115001695,
0.0357969739,
0.0225623492,
0.0611423925,
-0.0186084434,
-0.0108083244,
0.0314919241,
2.788e-7,
0.0343204811,
0.0757238939,
-0.0258787256,
0.0110863708,
0.0094181551,
0.0661823153,
0.0234938003,
0.0249773301,
-0.0156105384,
0.0135160116,
0.0470336899,
-0.0030095775,
0.072781913,
-0.0084280446,
-0.0928585529,
-0.0212746523,
-0.0732304677,
0.0063426653,
-0.0491567217,
0.0181627348,
0.0692922696,
0.1104851663,
0.0302971229,
-0.0293782335,
0.016584618,
-0.0559804775,
0.0742480904,
-0.0511681549,
-0.014581915,
0.0023079636,
0.0107308105,
0.0450395308,
-0.0181756783,
0.0335962251,
-0.0144125093,
0.0229217857,
0.0134363174,
0.0566957109,
0.0216498803,
0.0140281254,
0.0007004788,
0.031856861,
-0.0100076916,
-0.0339760296,
0.0404739641,
-0.0926268324,
-0.0178373028,
-0.0217887629,
-0.0387593918,
-0.0231059249,
0.0563886948,
0.0185914356,
-0.0336860195,
0.0166965704,
0.028241463,
-0.0117263664,
-0.0196574014,
-0.0664688796,
0.0248009097,
0.0144305704,
-0.042486202,
0.0334710255,
-0.0441582054,
0.0058010356,
0.0444826484,
-0.0435558148,
0.0149542512,
2.451365129e-34,
0.0519419163,
-0.0296034981,
-0.0418849885,
0.0193087719,
0.0266019069,
0.0219658166,
0.0298795123,
0.0206459034,
0.0318792053,
-0.0881747007,
0.0179167558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14608v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14608v1 | AI in the Gray: Exploring Moderation Policies in Dialogic Large Language Models vs. Human Answers in Controversial Topics | 2023-08-28T14:23:04 | 2023-08-28T14:23:04 | Vahid Ghafouri, Vibhor Agarwal, Yong Zhang, Nishanth Sastry, Jose Such, Guillermo Suarez-Tangil | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI | The introduction of ChatGPT and the subsequent improvement of Large Language
Models (LLMs) have prompted more and more individuals to turn to the use of
ChatBots, both for information and assistance with decision-making. However,
the information the user is after is often not formulated by these ChatBots
objectively enough to be provided with a definite, globally accepted answer.
Controversial topics, such as "religion", "gender identity", "freedom of
speech", and "equality", among others, can be a source of conflict as partisan
or biased answers can reinforce preconceived notions or promote disinformation.
By exposing ChatGPT to such debatable questions, we aim to understand its level
of awareness and if existing models are subject to socio-political and/or
economic biases. We also aim to explore how AI-generated answers compare to
human ones. For exploring this, we use a dataset of a social media platform
created for the purpose of debating human-generated claims on polemic subjects
among users, dubbed Kialo.
Our results show that while previous versions of ChatGPT have had important
issues with controversial topics, more recent versions of ChatGPT
(gpt-3.5-turbo) are no longer manifesting significant explicit biases in
several knowledge areas. In particular, it is well-moderated regarding economic
aspects. However, it still maintains degrees of implicit libertarian leaning
toward right-winged ideals which suggest the need for increased moderation from
the socio-political point of view. In terms of domain knowledge on
controversial topics, with the exception of the "Philosophical" category,
ChatGPT is performing well in keeping up with the collective human level of
knowledge. Finally, we see that sources of Bing AI have slightly more tendency
to the center when compared to human answers. All the analyses we make are
generalizable to other types of biases and domains. | [
0.0808164179,
0.0491723903,
-0.0153427543,
-0.0048904754,
-0.02965701,
-0.017901333,
0.0301487222,
-0.0162122604,
0.0496856719,
-0.051552359,
-0.0124066807,
-0.0006324072,
-0.0226032045,
0.0120743075,
-0.0357251242,
-0.0211415105,
0.0067722509,
0.0084590502,
0.0839158818,
-0.0530355312,
0.0478101149,
0.03098673,
0.0063791284,
0.0597897545,
-0.0256708693,
-0.0153616183,
0.0320947617,
-0.0126414737,
0.020049138,
0.0045139426,
0.0188460816,
0.0652814358,
-0.0089623379,
0.0519972108,
0.0000017954,
-0.0368426666,
0.0044341497,
-0.003999175,
-0.0047218767,
-0.0090625416,
0.0737890229,
0.0540006347,
-0.0094244387,
0.032518696,
-0.0665602162,
0.0370308273,
0.0421107076,
0.044996269,
0.0455929674,
0.0186364278,
-0.0034332403,
-0.0161602423,
0.0065102503,
-0.0015279489,
-0.0264178179,
-0.0320926085,
0.0382267796,
0.0099639874,
-0.0292335022,
0.0183723606,
-0.0235441308,
0.0084056286,
0.0363022089,
-0.0502941236,
-0.0442103371,
0.0013515762,
-0.0572002903,
-0.0546628125,
0.0195022263,
0.0620257743,
0.055265069,
-0.0391233973,
0.0379508212,
0.0146477818,
0.0275795609,
0.0612668581,
-0.0648338273,
0.053657487,
-0.007205185,
0.0038636033,
0.0387278348,
-0.013326792,
0.0166927315,
0.0476856269,
0.0025081758,
0.0383722298,
-0.0231287461,
-0.0099456254,
0.0152099654,
-0.0023022902,
-0.0000733491,
-0.0547956973,
0.0198027492,
0.0051038703,
-0.0156037603,
0.0177339837,
-0.0168915447,
0.0187434331,
0.0217672475,
-0.0906202123,
-0.0243352447,
0.0356783494,
-0.0149902729,
0.0613643155,
0.0502268635,
-0.0029991504,
-0.0263940487,
0.0258261133,
0.0074724671,
-0.0152362771,
-0.0235559698,
-0.0026791762,
-0.0140018277,
0.0058241715,
0.0002557439,
0.0224300642,
-0.0000294096,
-0.0138963182,
-0.0666555315,
-0.0150561761,
0.0053512552,
0.0166425146,
0.0104054939,
-0.0121883852,
-0.0619471073,
0.0351004638,
-0.0706176162,
0.0231187325,
0.009030031,
-0.0572632663,
0.0395704806,
0.0311015137,
-0.0152506977,
-0.0097463001,
0.0251539089,
0.0483992808,
0.0165187884,
0.0321010277,
0.0140733765,
-0.0239488222,
-0.0183190312,
-0.06060417,
0.0142250191,
-0.0563994423,
0.0398069508,
0.0103995847,
-0.0251472257,
-0.0357187912,
0.0211374313,
0.0437634438,
-0.0300048143,
0.0330618359,
0.0078602294,
0.0194426477,
0.0819253474,
0.029707931,
-0.0455165505,
0.0770024657,
-0.0126522267,
0.0310618766,
0.0506955385,
0.0074536568,
0.0040213782,
0.0098818699,
0.0065489551,
0.0071932916,
-0.0227201469,
0.0440319069,
-0.063866213,
-0.0299090911,
0.004898428,
0.0893938243,
-0.0167656634,
-0.064856641,
0.0545449741,
0.0787615553,
-0.0420814343,
0.0496439971,
-0.0035217283,
0.0154240448,
0.0366934799,
0.018808715,
-0.0166114643,
0.0215170868,
-0.0337079987,
-0.0690228269,
0.0047972235,
0.0410389155,
-0.022062527,
-0.0391500182,
0.0212233681,
0.004810059,
0.0493674427,
0.0075245551,
0.017977817,
-0.0479751676,
0.007519824,
0.0019787061,
0.0288775768,
0.0045622257,
-0.0380560197,
-0.08042036,
0.0444247574,
0.0071777003,
0.030916268,
-0.0056699566,
-0.0130117284,
-0.0335317813,
0.0433524325,
0.0781023353,
0.1028044671,
-0.023992762,
-0.0850663483,
-0.0043834639,
-0.03158921,
0.0066666896,
0.0110145863,
0.034366414,
0.0438943394,
0.0155693041,
-0.0215491988,
0.034130238,
-0.0236304123,
-0.0017996803,
0.0029997225,
0.0183666907,
-0.0453821272,
0.0012756403,
0.0466796495,
0.0323680118,
-0.0413785726,
-0.0009673911,
0.0116326027,
0.0036875103,
-0.0695489496,
0.0045211203,
-0.011267202,
0.0620492585,
0.0451265872,
-0.0262616966,
-0.0444472358,
0.013259152,
0.0153110679,
0.0209773313,
0.0383007526,
-0.0046732733,
-0.017069459,
-0.0157067124,
-0.0443613119,
-0.0541450679,
-0.0005480703,
-0.0518205352,
0.0310010146,
-0.0072774738,
0.0069266013,
0.0264145974,
-0.053616561,
0.0308539923,
0.0048980084,
-0.0160420779,
0.032242991,
0.0113336081,
0.0379665457,
0.0726702511,
-0.0597258173,
-0.0317719243,
-0.0185344908,
-0.0984492227,
-0.0434769206,
-0.0093804067,
-0.0001501334,
0.0211896263,
-0.0445766635,
0.0052010221,
0.0275326706,
-0.0495263524,
-0.0115130013,
0.00637388,
0.0437507592,
0.0271518324,
-0.00939452,
0.0022525126,
-0.0293321405,
0.004848483,
-0.0208170246,
0.0002567077,
0.0437274724,
-0.0113662062,
0.0296573807,
-0.0073666512,
-0.0890917778,
0.0006053763,
-0.0395864025,
-0.0452566743,
0.0274398103,
0.0113712512,
0.0110314973,
0.0518448651,
0.053928528,
0.0583262183,
0.0255955998,
0.0489371419,
-0.0532541126,
-0.0438420959,
-0.0070263334,
-0.0171938781,
-0.0210411642,
-0.0212068614,
0.0054031219,
0.0393739864,
0.0193827264,
0.0208717939,
-0.0637197271,
0.0916690826,
-0.0650597885,
-0.0521941036,
-0.0188509785,
-0.0139919249,
-0.015009501,
0.0624104217,
-0.0230490528,
-0.0373415835,
0.0416183807,
0.0269337203,
0.0403832048,
-0.0024468924,
-0.0297615565,
-0.0359153152,
0.0227276683,
-0.0207856353,
0.0369514488,
-0.0274625607,
0.0204309598,
-0.0692460239,
-0.0578294434,
0.0517639033,
-0.0699981004,
0.012821475,
-0.0211497806,
0.0162393693,
-0.0187121779,
-0.027015293,
-0.0267264582,
-0.0485224687,
-0.0306703132,
-0.0019674208,
0.0593783744,
-0.0110588567,
0.0231947619,
0.0147814611,
0.0193402171,
-0.026425818,
-0.0048418911,
-0.0020698933,
0.0416605659,
0.0083670262,
0.0132701844,
0.0308429804,
0.0445437394,
0.0132546956,
0.0227785613,
0.0658214763,
-0.0040175053,
-0.0042589614,
-0.0013379421,
-0.0426727459,
0.0091072805,
-0.0094955154,
-0.0012204911,
-0.01095754,
0.042074658,
-0.0365130864,
0.0444323644,
0.072759755,
0.0239625573,
-0.0326636843,
-0.0344270915,
-0.0396183543,
-0.0077308798,
0.0108772684,
0.0088580465,
-0.0874930397,
0.0299208239,
0.004247359,
0.00860155,
-0.0788948685,
-0.0510994866,
-0.0100482721,
-0.1041952223,
0.0194194335,
-0.0237738118,
-0.0149823846,
-0.0181820653,
-0.0323463455,
-0.0068085692,
-0.0335273072,
0.0087799886,
-0.0004207099,
0.0328387059,
0.0159682576,
0.0081326626,
-0.0297756828,
0.0111133289,
0.0450702831,
-0.021734003,
0.0818403661,
0.0200730842,
0.0663585663,
-0.0197967179,
0.0222549774,
0.079612352,
0.0495743379,
-0.0410041139,
-0.0099511538,
0.0276088584,
-0.0004417319,
-0.0069077536,
-0.0456600487,
0.0282222498,
0.0150069036,
0.0004568393,
0.0027357112,
0.0438976511,
0.0017331206,
-0.0336204283,
-0.0349319838,
0.02576706,
-0.0001914847,
0.0595705956,
0.01647719,
-0.0383968167,
-0.0333641432,
-0.0760669112,
0.0101183588,
0.0234136377,
-0.0702099353,
-0.0275095832,
0.0062628533,
-0.0279795956,
-0.0438831784,
-0.0545656197,
-0.0193939377,
-0.0060710055,
0.0100755859,
-0.0207558721,
0.0269020274,
0.0087902797,
0.0234071501,
0.009634803,
-0.0415141769,
-0.0087934332,
-0.010976471,
-0.0220588837,
0.0053487089,
-0.0062287189,
-0.0416710973,
0.0136535028,
-0.0016850345,
-0.0488302968,
0.0583835691,
0.0269195847,
0.0269012172,
-0.0067144413,
-0.0084584616,
-0.0029104732,
0.0183617175,
0.0766359419,
-0.021473296,
-0.0086431131,
0.0351702049,
0.0699720755,
-0.0032290726,
0.0221362915,
-0.0174201746,
0.0150035508,
0.0166275725,
-0.0222494137,
-0.0450233854,
-0.0485088751,
0.0246832259,
0.0278882403,
-0.0104855374,
0.030071497,
-0.0084497249,
-0.0332239456,
-0.0372997336,
-0.0292640775,
-0.0078549897,
0.0087538287,
-0.0234688167,
0.0275015477,
-0.0379691087,
-0.0027403361,
0.0264040194,
-0.0412816629,
0.0367024802,
-0.0250218604,
0.0261217747,
-0.0013878332,
0.0359094851,
-0.0263239238,
-0.0065855337,
-0.0050903261,
0.0514129251,
0.0083877305,
0.0235755052,
-0.011885955,
0.0467794314,
0.0012119559,
-0.022864446,
0.0646995455,
-0.0052202735,
-0.0599815659,
-0.1171904728,
-0.0007740347,
0.0468782336,
0.0139540294,
0.0094125122,
0.0086669046,
0.0031859742,
-0.0476505421,
-0.0125559615,
-0.0117223719,
0.0392233692,
-0.0049070446,
0.0298684612,
0.0021319543,
-0.0570011511,
0.0166840386,
0.0444648378,
-0.0119967898,
0.0328700207,
0.027837703,
-0.0503473356,
-0.0072992938,
-0.0671068579,
-0.0038603588,
-0.0294080097,
-0.0001194363,
0.01137973,
-0.0812142268,
-0.0188583657,
-0.0447490327,
-0.0054533812,
0.0030701237,
-0.0323299915,
-0.0072315396,
0.0599050075,
-0.0055324952,
0.0187801998,
-0.0565822758,
0.0379006602,
-0.0729949847,
0.0090741701,
-0.0121000446,
-6.09297844e-33,
0.0062243016,
-0.0415721796,
0.0017867107,
0.0118351914,
-0.0126667116,
-0.0202190969,
0.0044601467,
0.0283980761,
-0.0656322464,
0.0375937559,
-0.0102872849,
0.0352229849,
0.0061170585,
-0.0260405913,
-0.0008337476,
-0.0759759247,
0.015788788,
-0.0528980643,
-0.0325304493,
0.0268776454,
0.0159731954,
-0.022637276,
-0.0125388969,
-0.0710116699,
0.0320577584,
0.0095678233,
0.0244781021,
0.0076360661,
-0.0037932571,
0.0291250478,
-0.0142698791,
0.0724879652,
0.0330657437,
-0.055537343,
0.0150704952,
0.0552630499,
-0.0392407924,
-0.0256059114,
0.0177236982,
-0.0347828008,
0.0300881751,
-0.0217034444,
0.0240281206,
0.0066521661,
-0.0483774804,
0.0103717698,
0.0311679859,
-0.0159804523,
0.0365991965,
-0.0290713869,
-0.0336219929,
0.0208753049,
-0.0246579107,
-0.0183769148,
-0.046200294,
0.0414028242,
0.026066659,
0.072017625,
-0.0394213721,
0.0151038039,
-0.0298725478,
-0.0129215224,
0.030236451,
-0.0368797667,
0.0314879827,
0.0510885678,
0.0259525217,
0.0826591924,
-0.0702024773,
-0.0543134436,
-0.0257419329,
0.0107373642,
0.0578473508,
0.0516592786,
-0.0058060954,
-0.0486164726,
-0.0556826219,
-0.0096342564,
0.0549783558,
0.0244247038,
0.0429375693,
-0.0127001889,
-0.0336729363,
-0.0143876579,
-0.045203533,
-0.0827870667,
-0.0375561342,
-0.0298746247,
-0.014380062,
-0.0038612047,
-0.0459431969,
-0.0402740203,
0.0397372246,
-0.06776236,
0.004656021,
0.0271611586,
-0.0268208813,
-0.0171068106,
0.037449833,
0.0325167142,
-0.0704491735,
0.0224737674,
-0.0122964159,
0.0091087604,
0.020195324,
-0.0016400447,
-0.0161133818,
0.0004161578,
-0.0370313302,
-0.0084583135,
-0.020413585,
0.0285585877,
-0.0073836399,
0.0189117286,
0.0252225492,
0.0416656397,
0.0181193184,
0.0002187361,
0.0539355986,
0.0511303432,
-0.0068672127,
-0.0257739648,
-0.0470926464,
-0.0276081059,
-0.0336569995,
-0.0061709029,
-0.0364263356,
0.0637800023,
0.0021836367,
-0.0503783375,
-0.0165578499,
-0.0619198419,
2.474e-7,
0.0464784354,
0.0478581749,
-0.0039531686,
0.033403419,
0.0399985872,
0.0345630236,
0.0388072506,
0.0246040728,
0.0087872101,
-0.0497482382,
-0.020834161,
0.0320452303,
0.0376609117,
0.0506424047,
-0.0224027336,
-0.0561710224,
-0.0793603137,
-0.0034260708,
-0.0345482491,
0.0282062646,
0.0138689019,
0.038059663,
0.0213795081,
0.002236011,
-0.0503165461,
-0.012472989,
0.0817227811,
-0.036388386,
-0.0411173776,
0.023740679,
0.0461676009,
0.0024557768,
0.0355318636,
0.0067340927,
0.0186840408,
0.0097011877,
0.0050928406,
0.0675344765,
0.0319530033,
-0.0133052552,
0.0152278086,
-0.0199745055,
0.0161761623,
-0.0595725104,
0.0797703937,
-0.0632616132,
-0.0401481241,
-0.084346205,
-0.0124056675,
-0.0361996256,
0.0636631772,
-0.0284743533,
-0.0303938761,
-0.0043415432,
-0.0166338123,
0.0334341973,
0.0341632515,
-0.046207156,
-0.0163866412,
-0.0423039719,
-0.0682761446,
-0.0810424164,
-0.001932479,
0.0068418733,
0.0045196912,
0.0245927423,
0.042978894,
1.907683724e-34,
0.0469070226,
-0.0053206775,
-0.0091911713,
-0.0098093189,
0.0496897511,
0.0391546823,
0.0166078601,
-0.0115038753,
0.0209453162,
-0.0220006034,
0.004218081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14536v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14536v1 | Spoken Language Intelligence of Large Language Models for Language Learning | 2023-08-28T12:47:41 | 2023-08-28T12:47:41 | Linkai Peng, Baorian Nuchged, Yingming Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | People have long hoped for a conversational system that can assist in
real-life situations, and recent progress on large language models (LLMs) is
bringing this idea closer to reality. While LLMs are often impressive in
performance, their efficacy in real-world scenarios that demand expert
knowledge remains unclear. LLMs are believed to hold the most potential and
value in education, especially in the development of Artificial intelligence
(AI) based virtual teachers capable of facilitating language learning. Our
focus is centered on evaluating the efficacy of LLMs in the realm of education,
specifically in the areas of spoken language learning which encompass
phonetics, phonology, and second language acquisition. We introduce a new
multiple-choice question dataset to evaluate the effectiveness of LLMs in the
aforementioned scenarios, including understanding and application of spoken
language knowledge. In addition, we investigate the influence of various
prompting techniques such as zero- and few-shot method (prepending the question
with question-answer exemplars), chain-of-thought (CoT, think step-by-step),
in-domain exampler and external tools (Google, Wikipedia). We conducted
large-scale evaluation on popular LLMs (20 distinct models) using these
methods. We achieved significant performance improvements compared to the
zero-shot baseline in the practical questions reasoning (GPT-3.5, 49.1% ->
63.1%; LLaMA2-70B-Chat, 42.2% -> 48.6%). We found that models of different
sizes have good understanding of concepts in phonetics, phonology, and second
language acquisition, but show limitations in reasoning for real-world
problems. Additionally, we also explore preliminary findings on conversational
communication. | [
0.0323638022,
0.0190500841,
-0.0334083326,
0.0361859873,
-0.0598736815,
0.0067086364,
0.0557943359,
-0.0283554047,
0.0293678232,
-0.0244683977,
-0.0105335368,
-0.0382283852,
-0.0074158781,
-0.0258428715,
0.0498985872,
-0.0473799296,
0.0326953977,
-0.0683176219,
0.0315564126,
-0.0207147803,
0.0193771943,
0.0185630918,
-0.0792565346,
0.0373644009,
0.021395674,
-0.0210414045,
-0.0334780514,
-0.0213534478,
0.0017498709,
-0.0271767899,
-0.0048963805,
0.0512165464,
0.0128597347,
0.0266179834,
0.0000022237,
-0.0752005056,
0.0196281374,
-0.0268269703,
-0.0722103342,
0.0081783645,
-0.0164599363,
0.0707047805,
-0.01473362,
0.0597013272,
-0.0330478027,
0.0107135857,
0.0276989415,
-0.0089193275,
0.0350868851,
0.0435712673,
0.0041973395,
-0.0288564656,
0.0604871362,
0.0155265518,
0.0345114805,
-0.0086620264,
0.0208219681,
0.0285858754,
0.0403097086,
-0.0151992645,
-0.0094327088,
0.0465387926,
0.0175428167,
-0.0336585864,
-0.0194570888,
0.0258552451,
-0.0501636714,
-0.0614438467,
-0.0101376874,
0.0774297044,
-0.004619502,
-0.0163107328,
-0.0048347274,
0.0253346954,
0.0081920661,
0.0111368047,
-0.0638167709,
0.0333496705,
0.0011451601,
-0.002213126,
0.010233325,
-0.0002615294,
-0.0047479956,
0.0201286208,
-0.0107597997,
0.0320953839,
0.004089592,
-0.0380885229,
0.0071167359,
0.010170117,
-0.011401264,
-0.0549414344,
0.0113338856,
0.0545164682,
-0.0362649895,
0.0622441955,
0.030132873,
-0.0103306482,
0.0231681876,
-0.0172652751,
0.0308602843,
0.0628373399,
-0.0171427093,
0.0221103523,
0.0000474001,
0.0442844182,
0.0225001164,
0.0194461625,
-0.0239111483,
-0.0082046585,
-0.0594689772,
-0.0253950004,
-0.0402857661,
0.0599673837,
0.0062436694,
0.0042957803,
-0.0018206045,
0.0042267856,
-0.015717512,
0.0280973297,
-0.0009775967,
-0.0267318897,
0.0049224286,
-0.0112517783,
-0.0448904634,
0.0728209764,
-0.0304874815,
0.0411871076,
0.0109097315,
-0.0885611624,
0.0264109839,
0.0008087621,
0.0249307361,
0.0064333663,
0.0208882857,
0.0582728386,
-0.0221224297,
-0.0485099256,
-0.002806647,
-0.0234996453,
-0.0052215159,
-0.0813003555,
-0.0101400297,
-0.0815456435,
0.0235477015,
0.0006301773,
-0.0148840109,
-0.0070812381,
0.0118750073,
0.0307058189,
-0.0001872373,
0.0540639274,
-0.0031822214,
0.0469391607,
0.063359201,
0.0138427289,
0.0025564446,
0.0683003217,
0.0593888201,
-0.045883175,
0.0308739152,
-0.0402872674,
-0.0012806245,
0.0464007556,
0.018627001,
-0.0147449328,
-0.0140156709,
0.0051418915,
-0.0136692254,
0.0585332364,
-0.032234434,
0.0454292223,
-0.0246664416,
0.0059154169,
0.0775902122,
0.0858687162,
-0.009095273,
0.002142699,
0.050750237,
0.041262649,
0.0498012938,
0.0029032202,
-0.0139487591,
-0.005260733,
-0.0430933312,
0.0286954101,
0.024040008,
0.0292228013,
-0.0188784394,
-0.0556656234,
-0.0277891848,
0.0025584539,
-0.0298885293,
0.0801474601,
0.0293508265,
0.0022075565,
-0.0274662189,
0.0314652957,
0.0374107808,
-0.0340995789,
0.0063235471,
-0.0446279682,
0.0568849295,
0.0736229047,
0.0383731015,
-0.0135536864,
-0.0813238919,
-0.0006312235,
0.0267936885,
0.0534865633,
0.0257600788,
-0.0272399262,
-0.0123300664,
-0.0462723225,
0.0248430688,
0.0337550901,
-0.0188258272,
0.007176498,
-0.0019997612,
0.022255687,
-0.027866181,
-0.0148240821,
0.0080101229,
-0.0246971995,
-0.069320783,
-0.0192514807,
-0.0335157402,
0.0188130457,
0.0123564992,
0.0280495156,
-0.0075315624,
-0.0084029622,
0.0146382498,
-0.0074279201,
0.0003655509,
0.0074820505,
-0.0783828273,
-0.0582699552,
0.0481891446,
-0.0507785827,
-0.0188966189,
0.0120680761,
0.0057611354,
-0.0434871837,
0.0165758431,
-0.0373666324,
0.0323465466,
-0.0258457735,
0.0266295243,
-0.025934184,
0.0091490084,
-0.0034055347,
0.0230670515,
0.032722991,
-0.0078011723,
0.0527143478,
0.0303390305,
-0.0002412341,
-0.0543817878,
-0.0362054817,
0.0445130095,
-0.0209957901,
0.0072624763,
-0.0120612243,
0.0123573793,
-0.0815947577,
-0.0038907051,
-0.1121933758,
0.013225927,
0.0087427478,
0.0203289688,
0.0088689476,
-0.0043033161,
-0.0255579185,
-0.0179306734,
-0.069829084,
0.0085731056,
0.0142376032,
-0.012371866,
0.002092683,
-0.0074275224,
-0.0298456308,
-0.040878851,
0.0001740805,
-0.0273602307,
0.0149030965,
0.0210794266,
0.0128092058,
-0.0353272744,
0.0359695517,
-0.062319424,
0.0079991352,
0.0201267805,
-0.0500629954,
0.0130613148,
-0.0362271741,
0.0582949482,
0.0353343636,
0.0081395796,
0.0053078127,
0.040207576,
-0.0267656706,
-0.0735383034,
0.0102629242,
-0.0091927191,
-0.0159424804,
-0.0417905077,
-0.0069253878,
-0.0706852749,
0.0611979663,
0.0363874845,
0.007083145,
-0.033163622,
0.0405293629,
-0.0099024931,
-0.0295746531,
-0.0487846658,
-0.0212250538,
-0.0396337882,
0.0543651134,
-0.002269034,
-0.0032002446,
0.0702906102,
-0.0377834737,
-0.0264437702,
-0.0606284775,
-0.0120456647,
-0.0122102229,
0.0305419918,
-0.0058389227,
-0.009697021,
0.0179441422,
-0.0178250745,
-0.0584431216,
0.0243977923,
0.0067835925,
-0.0639473274,
0.0171308387,
-0.0709406659,
-0.0232123025,
0.024812704,
-0.0206403304,
-0.0558929071,
0.0000102564,
-0.0482640453,
0.0126321157,
-0.0155487563,
0.0050407201,
0.0161866769,
-0.0123324348,
0.0517405681,
0.0188736711,
-0.0014005144,
-0.0084139742,
-0.0195509121,
0.0472267494,
0.0447051115,
0.0346589126,
-0.0021277233,
0.0159345046,
0.1334199905,
0.0244147591,
0.0778521746,
0.0092309183,
0.0126254987,
0.0198901333,
0.0450715795,
-0.002657349,
-0.0091886185,
0.0563713498,
0.0477592237,
-0.0550095439,
-0.0190071687,
0.1287715584,
0.0286452621,
-0.0296599139,
-0.0069253282,
-0.0390013978,
0.0294214021,
0.0124616176,
0.0317672603,
-0.0922351331,
-0.0231864862,
0.0134912366,
-0.0034927614,
-0.0369944014,
-0.0207339767,
-0.0127584646,
-0.1573781222,
0.0160161275,
-0.0063455356,
-0.0426407605,
0.0404643044,
-0.0333490111,
0.0182285681,
0.0268943664,
0.0277317278,
-0.0055335979,
0.0048436155,
-0.0074528446,
0.0457325578,
-0.0278144125,
-0.059073735,
0.0644277111,
-0.0139582036,
0.0638188273,
0.0406689532,
0.03709938,
-0.0223289263,
-0.0505258739,
0.0003600091,
-0.0047029783,
-0.0120342011,
0.0092516383,
0.0425326675,
0.009683961,
-0.0136937462,
-0.036974106,
0.0443309471,
0.0108123282,
0.0082878554,
0.0596382432,
0.1119569987,
-0.0048873438,
-0.0063101663,
0.018070437,
0.0467053913,
-0.0061262469,
0.0644693747,
0.0615388118,
-0.0657546893,
0.0178318173,
-0.0095165139,
-0.0195001327,
-0.0212632399,
-0.065273948,
0.0303934403,
0.0467405282,
0.0115960566,
-0.0714449063,
-0.0568390526,
0.0729089677,
0.0436985306,
0.0213725735,
0.0018477937,
0.0399460047,
0.0354049616,
0.0034178905,
0.0140105281,
-0.0251814742,
0.0318703502,
-0.0715117455,
-0.0056112744,
0.0208672564,
-0.0601390041,
-0.0210627001,
0.0003797987,
-0.0740278065,
-0.0815070868,
-0.0076164478,
0.0462489612,
0.0277273543,
0.0432094932,
-0.0124647813,
-0.05516541,
0.0313896798,
-0.008582457,
-0.0318461098,
-0.0236675926,
0.0136236856,
0.0222892258,
0.0265106689,
0.0183340926,
-0.0065544681,
0.0302835759,
-0.0205244422,
0.0216673296,
-0.0414396748,
-0.0501903705,
0.0237690471,
0.0393591151,
0.0387377404,
0.0016371754,
-0.0000643233,
-0.0277202725,
0.0391695611,
-0.0225521624,
0.0067401347,
-0.0170194078,
-0.0253742747,
0.012571251,
-0.0086349398,
0.0139500657,
-0.0483111888,
-0.0148097165,
-0.0076753343,
0.0166081339,
0.0452799983,
-0.0058809933,
0.0245770328,
0.0205098335,
0.0082685612,
-0.021186661,
0.0166685972,
0.0126273297,
0.0572031364,
0.0057593598,
0.08062464,
-0.00726709,
-0.026566362,
0.0482034534,
0.0046761511,
-0.0246463995,
-0.0878166929,
0.0273097176,
0.0551746301,
0.0474927872,
-0.0013374228,
0.0161000509,
-0.0149846319,
0.0336699449,
-0.0036228616,
0.0082972404,
-0.0405578837,
-0.0541217402,
0.0467671938,
0.0339039229,
0.0128402459,
0.0078568626,
0.0263706688,
-0.019713914,
0.0357066393,
-0.0113971131,
0.0341025963,
-0.0241684429,
-0.0108613335,
-0.0196818318,
0.0388694592,
0.0016756589,
0.015174686,
-0.0848904699,
-0.0770024583,
-0.0300238691,
-0.0035859931,
0.0105449511,
-0.036954511,
0.0192117207,
0.0108167818,
-0.0295024645,
0.0176749285,
-0.0207663625,
-0.0108464006,
-0.0201020241,
-0.0304819196,
0.0105489995,
-6.709397759e-33,
-0.0164360926,
-0.0471122563,
0.048571825,
-0.0034158269,
-0.0081311893,
-0.0120371096,
-0.0652635619,
0.0110197542,
-0.0555243902,
-0.0122800656,
-0.0200985353,
-0.021638982,
0.000635904,
0.0301765297,
0.0096159615,
-0.0133271459,
0.0093855727,
-0.0074132201,
0.0237272605,
0.0156578477,
0.0143174026,
0.0068226061,
0.0535435639,
-0.0068017966,
0.023215089,
-0.0271260981,
0.0285905935,
0.0199069977,
-0.0460285172,
0.0620382912,
-0.0189994872,
0.0531788617,
0.0083396574,
-0.0669826418,
-0.013998881,
0.0205355771,
-0.053495165,
-0.0488484465,
0.0452641882,
0.0312058069,
-0.0224239249,
-0.0102181602,
-0.0016746137,
-0.0100083062,
-0.008200069,
-0.005364073,
0.0443503149,
-0.0097276391,
0.029104514,
0.0194222499,
-0.0608930327,
0.004495848,
-0.0537606329,
-0.0408304371,
0.0176949818,
0.0792782083,
-0.014654818,
-0.0214453042,
-0.0427130684,
0.0490904152,
0.030366933,
-0.029945787,
0.0950684473,
-0.0309350248,
-0.0163885243,
0.033363387,
0.0547974929,
-0.0252833664,
-0.0025032028,
-0.015037369,
0.0200488977,
0.0324258022,
0.0395962857,
0.0463461801,
-0.0030547755,
0.0026618354,
-0.0462549105,
-0.0140115535,
0.0436297357,
-0.0093869613,
0.0106168361,
-0.0107391821,
-0.0435662419,
-0.0110205887,
-0.063785702,
0.0009676742,
-0.0289130248,
-0.0463898443,
0.0570228808,
-0.0579164363,
0.0205127914,
-0.0085199848,
0.0372787602,
-0.0296648387,
-0.0122004552,
0.010892679,
-0.0213341359,
0.0392713398,
-0.02453986,
0.0256030764,
-0.0722273365,
0.0207552873,
0.0211255755,
0.0088605396,
0.0140400501,
0.0317301229,
0.0045276852,
0.0039054169,
-0.0268666539,
-0.013863367,
-0.0773079097,
0.0075712977,
0.0141111044,
0.0018554149,
0.0227913316,
0.0146015128,
-0.0310822558,
0.0301893987,
0.0071365517,
-0.0557338409,
-0.0421010479,
-0.0373099595,
-0.0566588715,
0.0046827486,
-0.0619515069,
-0.0128311235,
-0.0230680443,
0.0002180057,
-0.0007178522,
-0.0316056646,
0.0015941303,
0.0034323507,
3.066e-7,
-0.0030090287,
0.0621480644,
0.0038224971,
0.0158718135,
0.0130099542,
0.0152196381,
-0.0251777824,
-0.0389301516,
0.042099338,
0.001545822,
0.0048488788,
0.0308004282,
0.0602776185,
0.0139126945,
-0.119708024,
-0.0502681248,
-0.0444020778,
-0.0093984222,
-0.0681037903,
0.0239988565,
0.0694697648,
0.0540205389,
0.0236515161,
-0.0289958529,
-0.0185552184,
0.0006203247,
-0.0115414253,
-0.0199193284,
-0.0038578289,
-0.0098259188,
0.0215570386,
-0.0021940437,
0.0035173537,
0.0432175547,
-0.0050605284,
0.0138214529,
-0.0216872115,
0.0279304441,
0.0205071177,
-0.0079525039,
-0.0018396364,
0.0156111168,
-0.0252274424,
-0.0732057169,
0.0699627399,
-0.0300797131,
-0.0347368531,
0.0227024406,
-0.0206685681,
-0.0423026383,
-0.0197286047,
-0.0134931682,
-0.0119067403,
0.0146434791,
-0.0266121123,
-0.055695992,
0.0213659126,
-0.0141146313,
0.0141237965,
0.0346660651,
-0.0317825377,
-0.0625580326,
-0.0189000908,
-0.0461526737,
-0.0101351561,
-0.0441740751,
-0.0005542573,
2.314670059e-34,
-0.010193537,
-0.0060155271,
0.0489721149,
0.0406863652,
0.0203860663,
0.0110997129,
0.019688515,
0.0003194304,
0.047186587,
-0.0772365481,
-0.0304431003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14533v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14533v1 | A Multi-Task Semantic Decomposition Framework with Task-specific Pre-training for Few-Shot NER | 2023-08-28T12:46:21 | 2023-08-28T12:46:21 | Guanting Dong, Zechen Wang, Jinxu Zhao, Gang Zhao, Daichi Guo, Dayuan Fu, Tingfeng Hui, Chen Zeng, Keqing He, Xuefeng Li, Liwen Wang, Xinyue Cui, Weiran Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The objective of few-shot named entity recognition is to identify named
entities with limited labeled instances. Previous works have primarily focused
on optimizing the traditional token-wise classification framework, while
neglecting the exploration of information based on NER data characteristics. To
address this issue, we propose a Multi-Task Semantic Decomposition Framework
via Joint Task-specific Pre-training (MSDP) for few-shot NER. Drawing
inspiration from demonstration-based and contrastive learning, we introduce two
novel pre-training tasks: Demonstration-based Masked Language Modeling (MLM)
and Class Contrastive Discrimination. These tasks effectively incorporate
entity boundary information and enhance entity representation in Pre-trained
Language Models (PLMs). In the downstream main task, we introduce a multi-task
joint optimization framework with the semantic decomposing method, which
facilitates the model to integrate two different semantic information for
entity classification. Experimental results of two few-shot NER benchmarks
demonstrate that MSDP consistently outperforms strong baselines by a large
margin. Extensive analyses validate the effectiveness and generalization of
MSDP. | [
-0.0007611794,
0.0349623673,
0.0091123264,
0.0297358595,
0.000235843,
0.0383565761,
0.0485112816,
0.0137099884,
-0.0173257682,
-0.0802350938,
-0.033534348,
-0.0263467729,
-0.0188417416,
-0.0332882144,
0.0325639807,
-0.019203566,
0.0362495556,
0.0162809696,
0.0012784742,
0.0379160084,
-0.0021194709,
0.0123423114,
-0.014521935,
0.0163787007,
0.0094738416,
0.0049155261,
-0.0079142293,
0.020227477,
0.0294701755,
-0.0744728148,
0.0224817228,
0.0440462604,
0.0199769493,
0.0281291846,
0.00000196,
-0.0669642761,
-0.0299834665,
0.0315801315,
-0.0428385921,
-0.0109016355,
0.0816163346,
-0.0250023119,
0.0280179158,
0.0194795281,
0.0042176619,
-0.1020647734,
0.0059170257,
0.0888375118,
0.0271565001,
0.079696618,
-0.0078204488,
-0.0319985598,
-0.0019945002,
-0.0119854547,
-0.0039153229,
-0.0126614943,
0.034223035,
-0.0652688444,
-0.0313956179,
0.0064654984,
-0.0090978565,
0.0053882692,
-0.0090044932,
0.0632982999,
-0.0078516584,
0.0404761285,
-0.006085733,
0.0160462987,
-0.0015803272,
0.0332943052,
-0.0352104083,
-0.0143301729,
0.0416313186,
-0.0172135271,
-0.0311950967,
-0.0396652818,
-0.0186793189,
-0.0228233337,
-0.0040904521,
0.0281109158,
0.0125836106,
0.0205662642,
0.0084365746,
0.0081383595,
-0.0290791485,
-0.0169409104,
0.0261509418,
-0.0329418667,
-0.0171991102,
-0.0015103162,
-0.0234443434,
-0.0351444185,
0.0114298509,
0.0211396553,
-0.0126892915,
0.026419105,
-0.0605954789,
-0.0931549817,
0.0106737595,
-0.0058717509,
0.0370602868,
0.0287676472,
0.004025327,
0.0377670452,
-0.0582225434,
0.0229610875,
0.0253967717,
0.0139377192,
-0.0000578181,
-0.029260397,
-0.0416621193,
0.003518611,
-0.0527278148,
0.0766109675,
-0.0549046807,
0.0062670764,
-0.0128709208,
0.0048794826,
0.0060141371,
0.0027937209,
0.0109672602,
-0.0263547953,
-0.0194170512,
0.0036834085,
-0.0122050894,
0.0056131897,
-0.0041984734,
0.00917813,
-0.0267027374,
-0.0302711185,
-0.0225259848,
-0.0175243858,
0.0276521053,
-0.0527720898,
0.0420325883,
0.076083459,
0.0107887788,
-0.1144722104,
-0.05651813,
0.0138360672,
0.0195059739,
-0.0502267517,
-0.0082344934,
-0.0219506081,
0.0460498631,
-0.0142710777,
-0.0012540454,
-0.054075662,
-0.0002213943,
0.0074413307,
-0.0221812017,
0.1033384651,
-0.027384216,
-0.0338570252,
0.0246730689,
0.0087106172,
0.0090478966,
0.0706154704,
0.0171859488,
-0.0162635241,
0.0108466474,
0.0107443463,
-0.011611633,
0.0187312849,
0.0318384096,
-0.0199161936,
0.0020081857,
0.0151992701,
0.0162005648,
-0.0321702063,
0.0396483317,
0.0440631509,
-0.0212224461,
-0.0080182757,
0.0161846876,
0.0202015508,
0.0046675969,
-0.0271258354,
0.0294966754,
0.0244059227,
-0.0126632303,
-0.0015380555,
-0.0224321503,
-0.025376739,
-0.0358849615,
0.001793361,
0.0107043888,
0.0693692788,
-0.0540637001,
0.0051189805,
0.0159817655,
-0.0108327167,
0.0186959505,
0.0301425643,
0.0663288757,
0.0108906031,
-0.0873439014,
0.0659491643,
0.03781965,
-0.0103578661,
0.0233973581,
-0.0495945252,
-0.0017514506,
0.0090963989,
0.0351505615,
-0.0585258827,
-0.0313622504,
-0.0333314873,
-0.015734734,
0.0514772721,
-0.0095391702,
-0.0075187744,
0.0599593557,
-0.0345482975,
-0.007604057,
-0.030944448,
0.0311565362,
0.0116521502,
0.0147330873,
0.0259542428,
0.0412638448,
-0.0355096981,
0.0006233453,
0.0708075538,
-0.0200624075,
-0.0480987355,
0.0263056327,
0.0253885668,
0.0152619649,
0.0301067829,
-0.0033454394,
-0.0296507217,
0.0218525063,
-0.0391105227,
0.0490611568,
-0.0402422324,
0.0058051175,
-0.1239407063,
0.0075426968,
0.0048505226,
0.0041401037,
0.0552997738,
-0.0569516979,
-0.0428323969,
-0.02600573,
0.0209620893,
0.0415024236,
-0.0393362753,
0.0269424114,
0.0045902533,
0.0090528438,
-0.0269163158,
0.0620859154,
0.0091231065,
0.0363375768,
0.0114394128,
-0.0076299547,
0.0103344265,
-0.0504744649,
-0.0602715202,
-0.03087884,
-0.0205996912,
-0.0173354726,
0.0056740046,
0.0056885108,
-0.0470232666,
0.0019532312,
-0.0783510655,
0.0160769764,
-0.0231709667,
0.0513562746,
0.0075468486,
0.0235152431,
-0.0108397342,
-0.0280527137,
0.0064303041,
-0.0259107258,
-0.0201523919,
0.0145078273,
0.0098645743,
0.0076776934,
-0.035701979,
0.0088996375,
0.0111965481,
-0.0098307356,
0.0471673235,
-0.0163928773,
-0.0425316803,
-0.0600215606,
0.0916982293,
0.0078549506,
0.0296150148,
0.000467768,
0.0347740129,
-0.0091493772,
0.0418496281,
0.0281205941,
0.0415464975,
-0.0271605402,
0.0358477607,
-0.0106868092,
0.0008734352,
-0.052979853,
0.0339562856,
-0.0204293281,
0.0668173283,
-0.0187411141,
-0.0269763712,
0.037097875,
0.0969039574,
-0.0240745209,
-0.0005889069,
-0.0419953912,
-0.0016237614,
-0.0253365263,
-0.0419490039,
-0.0185075663,
0.0182806663,
-0.0133252209,
-0.0282495283,
-0.030305801,
-0.0022094706,
0.0673813894,
-0.0497503392,
-0.0228332747,
-0.0316294171,
-0.0107936924,
-0.0494031049,
0.0402813405,
0.0056339609,
0.0027174209,
0.0270412751,
-0.0659327433,
-0.0377067402,
0.0242042877,
-0.0208746009,
-0.0238923784,
0.0110178152,
0.0116268313,
0.001448052,
-0.0216717422,
-0.0274073351,
-0.0285480991,
-0.0598206148,
-0.0272395611,
0.0451931544,
0.0085410532,
0.0421623103,
-0.0180388428,
0.0538863651,
-0.00980944,
0.0412435085,
0.0345018841,
-0.0138630196,
-0.0403426774,
0.0356731862,
0.0368026346,
-0.0212861411,
0.0083388155,
-0.0150104165,
0.008817533,
0.0040891673,
0.063352935,
-0.0226872098,
0.0039583216,
-0.0165742356,
0.0236421134,
-0.0663917661,
0.0081784651,
0.0005428092,
0.030397201,
-0.015608605,
0.0012816752,
0.1141759157,
0.0048243753,
-0.0283877011,
-0.025028903,
0.0424457528,
-0.0051460131,
0.0222863071,
0.0213783178,
-0.0734512508,
-0.0487994179,
0.0012121424,
-0.0137143042,
0.0192868356,
-0.0484835468,
-0.0175758097,
-0.1141900122,
-0.0151861561,
-0.0203346163,
-0.0690955222,
0.0378735848,
-0.0783567801,
0.0271857101,
-0.0341937728,
0.0216055606,
-0.0266890433,
-0.0240183529,
0.0019787094,
0.0109730195,
0.0487806201,
-0.0581454448,
0.0059668473,
-0.0520703606,
0.0235895868,
-0.0125195775,
0.0220625922,
-0.0107577471,
-0.0006771809,
0.009473782,
-0.0535124168,
-0.0150286071,
-0.0249872804,
0.0630876124,
-0.0733939335,
-0.0135946376,
-0.0107933413,
-0.0243096482,
-0.0080627585,
-0.0461330116,
-0.022765249,
0.0411109999,
-0.00137877,
0.0109485323,
-0.0145296277,
-0.0571114384,
0.0279513169,
0.1007309631,
0.0220511071,
-0.0387767889,
-0.0045882296,
0.0367249213,
0.0111991083,
-0.0341635346,
0.0200331658,
-0.0144653795,
-0.0386810564,
-0.0081516718,
-0.0108399214,
-0.0491757728,
0.072085686,
0.0381862372,
-0.0221625697,
0.0196521524,
-0.0144173168,
0.0003549314,
-0.0799365342,
0.0155362897,
-0.031761948,
0.0228698291,
-0.0536404476,
-0.015740009,
0.0426686406,
-0.0103814071,
-0.039137844,
-0.015342921,
-0.0810744688,
-0.0478970259,
-0.0115586128,
0.0295378305,
0.0063490886,
0.0372262597,
-0.0001346817,
-0.040010009,
0.0719039962,
0.0562477559,
-0.0566848554,
0.005463446,
0.0155671677,
-0.0010571602,
-0.0222705211,
0.0118087986,
-0.044823952,
0.0337106287,
0.0669144541,
0.0424484313,
-0.015754208,
-0.0180742033,
-0.005751316,
0.0359797888,
0.0992074013,
-0.0369837396,
-0.0014709793,
-0.047297772,
0.0193212107,
0.0005692894,
0.0055145738,
-0.0318720266,
-0.0269307066,
-0.0058031077,
0.0089716185,
-0.0292427149,
0.0898484737,
-0.0095717646,
0.0447421782,
-0.0533030145,
-0.0020435741,
0.0031840119,
0.0039835558,
0.0119397696,
0.0118690198,
-0.001879452,
0.0076221111,
0.0395331271,
0.0019256205,
-0.031011181,
0.0270307027,
0.0111538135,
0.0202177968,
-0.0449315682,
0.0349692516,
0.002129978,
0.0356059037,
-0.0491470359,
0.0015163495,
0.0371411927,
-0.0088545922,
0.0250192583,
0.0093034841,
-0.0081323273,
0.0017497224,
0.0073968191,
-0.0076660207,
-0.0110889068,
0.0294364989,
0.0234673303,
-0.0194075294,
-0.0076079234,
0.0834353492,
0.0158764441,
0.044961866,
0.0148192318,
0.0167112164,
-0.0515822321,
0.006837145,
0.0591715053,
0.0225169808,
-0.0109815113,
-0.0002821979,
-0.0555989221,
-0.0492019206,
0.0306554828,
-0.0541541427,
-0.0310171191,
0.0130682979,
0.0254451651,
-0.0005508329,
0.0114510702,
-0.0267535876,
-0.0060507189,
-0.0229488052,
0.0300831217,
-0.0205906238,
-0.0086864186,
-6.043528331e-33,
-0.0296843424,
-0.0035143571,
0.0304123741,
-0.0231306702,
0.015518032,
0.0266120341,
0.0059283287,
-0.0307545736,
0.0021714361,
-0.0281322803,
-0.0201615989,
-0.0062593035,
0.0217315424,
0.0405364931,
-0.0540997349,
-0.0152376508,
0.0898478404,
0.0096397046,
-0.0240729917,
0.0001845072,
0.0084102321,
0.0790585354,
0.0820579231,
-0.0672263056,
0.0042295312,
0.0049920352,
0.0037051165,
0.0062876502,
0.0615716763,
0.054894723,
-0.0557594672,
0.031270463,
0.0314839631,
-0.0857749507,
-0.022006467,
0.0120599074,
-0.1314668953,
-0.0214272942,
0.0053042569,
0.0122807985,
-0.0284248423,
-0.0218799151,
0.018493887,
-0.0030335577,
0.0056822407,
0.0137275131,
0.0239753034,
0.0023326727,
-0.0075870086,
-0.0522854216,
-0.0457357466,
0.0286439545,
0.0160271693,
0.0093856081,
0.085776858,
-0.0275218189,
0.0162437856,
0.0104469368,
-0.0868048817,
-0.025880307,
0.0245856419,
-0.0368238948,
0.0259290207,
0.061191313,
0.0061150948,
0.0521493554,
0.0366202742,
0.0211000498,
0.0060623195,
0.0011501067,
0.051683858,
0.0233977437,
-0.0061992547,
0.0332206339,
0.0586085059,
-0.0241028015,
-0.0863154978,
0.0375893563,
-0.0173608977,
0.005300425,
0.0118487552,
0.0023519883,
-0.0350575708,
-0.0166434851,
-0.0236714259,
-0.0153159285,
-0.0500826724,
0.0004675855,
0.0407560058,
0.0509148948,
-0.0668392554,
0.0300500281,
0.0463840552,
-0.021352645,
-0.0300630741,
0.012771056,
0.0312902033,
0.0078062341,
0.0113475556,
0.0066777826,
-0.0494923629,
-0.0577770881,
0.0320270434,
-0.0096995607,
0.0096784048,
-0.0192300715,
0.0403403491,
-0.0072943098,
-0.0720688626,
0.0163769275,
0.0083336653,
0.0177282654,
0.0193199404,
0.0090040658,
0.0291391164,
0.022574449,
0.0019737037,
0.024558749,
0.0714930072,
-0.0672331676,
-0.0019983246,
0.0572424047,
0.0249199923,
0.0489359275,
0.0111667523,
-0.0025040689,
0.0223091319,
0.0052122646,
0.0376486108,
-0.0253996961,
0.0001501124,
-0.0072348295,
2.557e-7,
0.0082968958,
0.0050208061,
-0.0219421797,
0.0070001027,
-0.0185272843,
0.0265331399,
0.0318968631,
0.0503382571,
-0.0196379423,
-0.0049597207,
-0.0052232486,
-0.0161982048,
0.0108514773,
0.0140111996,
-0.1056016535,
-0.0125542097,
0.0121867536,
0.0207179617,
-0.0600772575,
0.0512681752,
0.0491050035,
0.0943353549,
0.0122515243,
-0.0133660678,
-0.0487723351,
-0.0226932075,
0.0588434264,
-0.0234124586,
0.0270134993,
0.0220227968,
-0.0168919843,
0.0452451482,
-0.0126592442,
0.0361942537,
-0.0170852132,
0.0634784922,
0.0275046658,
0.0720259994,
-0.0020430053,
-0.0012500716,
0.0175599903,
-0.0232328363,
-0.0182016268,
-0.0032073816,
0.0947425589,
-0.0782383904,
-0.014692829,
0.0274977442,
-0.0549067743,
-0.006673316,
0.001482412,
0.0168668423,
-0.0137739768,
0.0279160831,
0.0194845516,
-0.02290814,
-0.0318948813,
-0.1005163193,
0.015736239,
0.0338558145,
-0.0191965364,
0.0043796194,
-0.0021677271,
-0.0207381211,
0.0376884677,
-0.0930421352,
0.0133717488,
2.54622316e-34,
-0.0108543085,
0.0067445775,
-0.0355750285,
0.0481197163,
0.0108933877,
-0.0325083844,
-0.0630535781,
0.0099972393,
0.008254745,
-0.0968362167,
0.0264916811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14508v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14508v2 | LongBench: A Bilingual, Multitask Benchmark for Long Context Understanding | 2023-08-28T11:53:40 | 2024-06-19T04:00:32 | Yushi Bai, Xin Lv, Jiajie Zhang, Hongchang Lyu, Jiankai Tang, Zhidian Huang, Zhengxiao Du, Xiao Liu, Aohan Zeng, Lei Hou, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although large language models (LLMs) demonstrate impressive performance for
many language tasks, most of them can only handle texts a few thousand tokens
long, limiting their applications on longer sequence inputs, such as books,
reports, and codebases. Recent works have proposed methods to improve LLMs'
long context capabilities by extending context windows and more sophisticated
memory mechanisms. However, comprehensive benchmarks tailored for evaluating
long context understanding are lacking. In this paper, we introduce LongBench,
the first bilingual, multi-task benchmark for long context understanding,
enabling a more rigorous evaluation of long context understanding. LongBench
comprises 21 datasets across 6 task categories in both English and Chinese,
with an average length of 6,711 words (English) and 13,386 characters
(Chinese). These tasks cover key long-text application areas including
single-doc QA, multi-doc QA, summarization, few-shot learning, synthetic tasks,
and code completion. All datasets in LongBench are standardized into a unified
format, allowing for effortless automatic evaluation of LLMs. Upon
comprehensive evaluation of 8 LLMs on LongBench, we find that: (1) Commercial
model (GPT-3.5-Turbo-16k) outperforms other open-sourced models, but still
struggles on longer contexts. (2) Scaled position embedding and fine-tuning on
longer sequences lead to substantial improvement on long context understanding.
(3) Context compression technique such as retrieval brings improvement for
model with weak ability on long contexts, but the performance still lags behind
models that have strong long context understanding capability. The code and
datasets are available at https://github.com/THUDM/LongBench. | [
0.0043839579,
0.0371621214,
-0.0023446423,
0.0699504092,
-0.0217552744,
0.0090115108,
0.0254342929,
-0.0460660979,
-0.0111001413,
-0.0328022316,
-0.0357384756,
-0.0696517378,
0.0256338902,
-0.0031791311,
0.0311718173,
-0.040352203,
0.0440573208,
-0.0363604426,
-0.0125015322,
0.0129248574,
0.0157529395,
0.0022377933,
0.0308687631,
0.0483522974,
0.0304534677,
-0.0515363514,
-0.0163775664,
-0.0100047337,
0.0220586192,
-0.0237364881,
0.0263750535,
0.0330629982,
0.0329464786,
0.0527881868,
0.0000019522,
-0.0387994088,
-0.044770129,
-0.0108317053,
-0.0088346079,
0.016739333,
0.0345931053,
-0.0384063348,
-0.0138660055,
-0.0049241199,
-0.0217239074,
-0.0015352701,
0.0113910958,
0.011249911,
0.0201563276,
0.0647715628,
-0.0002356544,
-0.03489016,
0.0093698185,
-0.0552483536,
0.028989695,
-0.0793161914,
0.0109038381,
0.0112733385,
0.0289124176,
0.0238232426,
-0.031999439,
0.0412782356,
0.0523491688,
0.0124461846,
-0.0328938887,
0.0329685025,
-0.0489294492,
0.0076502566,
0.0136286579,
0.0818234533,
-0.0489247888,
-0.0200275127,
0.0016898344,
0.0145980446,
-0.0035585992,
-0.0750842467,
-0.0547011346,
0.0163227823,
-0.0231137164,
0.0052057602,
0.0289049968,
0.00038184,
0.0396430865,
0.0124518014,
-0.0583828874,
0.0343824141,
0.0012625377,
-0.0053166184,
-0.0382667184,
-0.017586017,
-0.0138042904,
-0.0379698277,
0.016624799,
0.0409219526,
-0.038475167,
0.0331007168,
-0.0272809062,
-0.0452851988,
0.0271301251,
-0.0469320156,
-0.0355182625,
0.0518629588,
-0.060422644,
0.0671848804,
-0.0412169285,
0.0624048486,
-0.0249140561,
-0.0080985995,
-0.0561255068,
-0.0375567973,
-0.0360994264,
0.0009950123,
-0.0410695225,
0.0047637275,
-0.0489315875,
-0.0337339304,
-0.0183477998,
0.0264496841,
0.0064702011,
0.0329487883,
0.0038645552,
-0.0162955578,
-0.033794295,
0.0021554718,
0.0191962961,
0.0369710922,
-0.0474036038,
-0.0135839414,
-0.009827273,
-0.0272634123,
-0.0139848161,
0.0158724952,
-0.0071331328,
-0.0518718362,
0.0004610544,
0.0433836803,
0.0041653845,
-0.0318750329,
-0.0226232745,
-0.0244819969,
-0.0266851168,
-0.0741578341,
-0.0190444309,
-0.0875261799,
0.0129914954,
0.0151492199,
0.0108001679,
-0.0083794342,
0.0012188564,
0.0265592504,
0.0051826597,
0.0742238462,
0.0233232658,
-0.0195561573,
0.0170324501,
0.0372956507,
0.0114241112,
0.1032972336,
0.0032789898,
0.0268267784,
0.0474503301,
0.0235265717,
-0.0199291222,
0.0334212072,
0.0197424702,
0.0059103519,
-0.0086405221,
0.0553232022,
0.0453425311,
0.0186918173,
0.036889188,
0.0176069215,
-0.0281363111,
-0.0267950222,
0.0006169902,
0.0304633509,
0.0372887999,
0.0023552617,
0.0420151837,
0.0101472503,
-0.0117326193,
0.0079692826,
-0.0443700925,
0.0323379003,
-0.0017697816,
0.0368911251,
0.0268631466,
0.0157136768,
-0.0282883402,
-0.0239279382,
-0.0188612472,
-0.0064025144,
0.0153571311,
0.0266980138,
0.0443940237,
-0.0140225617,
-0.041829668,
0.0545845479,
-0.0034185394,
-0.0414327085,
-0.0097434511,
-0.0108373743,
0.0214584898,
0.0767651945,
0.0250244141,
-0.0578936897,
-0.035022486,
-0.0197383836,
0.0272775758,
0.0143722696,
0.0110678142,
-0.0220800508,
0.0393268019,
-0.0451536253,
-0.0207458492,
-0.0241656173,
0.0005737947,
0.0364914685,
0.0395210311,
0.0349415541,
0.040659532,
-0.0448649861,
-0.008319323,
0.0241758283,
-0.0540746972,
-0.0244363323,
-0.0271215886,
0.0161384568,
0.0097416947,
0.0322319902,
0.0030693207,
0.0035378323,
0.020492414,
-0.0534153283,
0.0161577798,
0.0034662758,
-0.0884268656,
-0.0612829812,
0.0571849309,
-0.0115704453,
-0.0243716221,
0.0165866408,
-0.0460969992,
-0.0564749055,
0.0218438804,
0.0126228696,
0.0176011063,
-0.0293030478,
0.0139326593,
-0.0168705117,
0.0358467139,
-0.0242924411,
0.0540176332,
-0.0091084372,
0.0380573943,
0.0475265123,
0.0516533405,
0.0277308635,
-0.0217542835,
-0.0488066263,
0.0317882486,
0.0046101734,
-0.0064883414,
0.0119528063,
0.0174107291,
-0.0438714772,
-0.0235271789,
-0.1273109764,
0.0408620797,
-0.0571825095,
0.0251781177,
0.0234210435,
0.0115918312,
-0.0065843244,
-0.0094452258,
-0.0521499962,
-0.0179140568,
-0.0208101403,
0.0142104924,
0.0162731353,
0.0270628259,
-0.0019828714,
-0.0548747517,
-0.009397869,
-0.0100914221,
0.03978879,
-0.0268574636,
-0.0395065807,
-0.0461164564,
0.0207155738,
0.0031907116,
0.0182311703,
-0.0497760586,
-0.023272004,
-0.0009022274,
-0.0234738644,
0.0771189481,
0.0666118711,
0.0033290673,
0.0034920711,
0.0305744689,
-0.0218558908,
-0.0356010199,
0.0277590249,
0.0264585335,
-0.004685041,
-0.0339179039,
0.00167981,
-0.0304826405,
0.0704694837,
-0.0206803512,
-0.0175235532,
-0.0386370048,
-0.0277225077,
-0.0086171124,
0.0066398438,
-0.0364741497,
0.0001509462,
-0.0173202995,
0.0259118918,
-0.0522651039,
-0.0212014113,
0.0692621469,
-0.0651054308,
-0.0209785514,
-0.0440946408,
-0.0111288233,
-0.0888548195,
0.08204218,
-0.0087222746,
0.0045433645,
-0.023362482,
-0.0218549185,
-0.040642947,
0.0163675658,
-0.0254113488,
-0.0290698055,
0.0617939904,
-0.0221884008,
0.0109944874,
-0.0394832753,
-0.0245451275,
-0.0228231791,
0.002338385,
-0.0287673343,
0.0265867896,
0.0444891043,
-0.0070103635,
0.0038843658,
0.0292566475,
0.0341053121,
0.0949148759,
-0.0193275046,
0.0154949473,
-0.0148300426,
0.0097678192,
0.0305821579,
0.0031221993,
0.0179313291,
-0.0467534289,
0.043074023,
0.0325184092,
0.0489029959,
-0.0226546153,
-0.0292088669,
-0.0168561749,
-0.0014895168,
-0.024422856,
-0.0277885366,
-0.0047275685,
0.0536159985,
-0.099072516,
-0.0176031273,
0.1115155667,
0.0031324374,
-0.0747482553,
-0.0177137218,
-0.0364699513,
0.0132037019,
0.0346849523,
0.0020492764,
-0.1148203388,
-0.047338888,
0.0056300582,
-0.0094296755,
0.0380183794,
-0.0176956225,
-0.013315252,
-0.0992747098,
-0.0108035412,
0.0017469405,
-0.0892329738,
-0.0167770814,
-0.0268957969,
-0.0046899421,
0.0035584019,
0.0364352763,
0.0281576477,
-0.0048433454,
-0.004927366,
-0.0230493397,
-0.0056178332,
-0.0202204641,
0.0499751717,
-0.0285170004,
0.0212495513,
0.0364915915,
0.0252391174,
0.0295379907,
0.0357999131,
0.0493770987,
-0.0342947841,
-0.0025812481,
-0.0004775003,
0.0373116732,
-0.0272332244,
-0.0089428546,
0.0180911887,
0.025123762,
-0.052673772,
0.0043276171,
0.0440957956,
0.0685802177,
0.0144009441,
0.0118497573,
-0.0140976394,
-0.0142313857,
-0.0025877086,
0.0879462212,
0.0443406962,
-0.016057305,
-0.0547741801,
-0.0218255874,
-0.0278597604,
-0.0732126981,
0.0139271058,
-0.0009036526,
0.0040044831,
-0.0008888802,
-0.0578768589,
-0.0631843582,
0.0261599235,
0.025828084,
-0.0103624677,
0.0614942014,
-0.0214261971,
-0.0129783675,
-0.0717858076,
0.0234614238,
-0.0161417797,
0.0435602032,
-0.0457900763,
0.0445194617,
0.0246641431,
-0.029708907,
-0.0013413794,
0.0433235541,
-0.1130433381,
-0.0437513813,
-0.0198145993,
0.0032511533,
0.0099882446,
0.0774857625,
-0.0223409627,
-0.0184951369,
-0.002824435,
0.0071113878,
-0.0418328829,
0.0120097464,
0.0305267666,
0.0212563295,
0.0026275148,
0.0512645207,
-0.055419147,
-0.0002607941,
-0.0136244362,
0.0329137295,
-0.0255101603,
-0.0120238224,
-0.0126304375,
-0.0117314756,
0.0105285849,
0.0022103803,
0.0069163237,
-0.0165013,
0.0430492125,
-0.0265632402,
-0.0163480248,
-0.0124465013,
0.0139903547,
0.0156348031,
-0.0530097932,
0.0202012789,
0.0334814601,
0.0172484778,
0.0203143377,
-0.0272643957,
0.0546991415,
-0.0089314338,
0.0086974502,
0.0214169491,
0.0126437442,
-0.0134040518,
-0.0164627284,
-0.0055642994,
0.0491631292,
-0.0352543108,
0.0390421674,
0.015091531,
-0.0060713249,
-0.0031326653,
0.0285848156,
-0.0820644572,
0.0067071416,
0.0156933535,
0.0120525723,
0.0793572366,
-0.0290965457,
0.0516814813,
0.0152638787,
-0.0133703789,
-0.0293126013,
0.0250300262,
-0.0000862915,
-0.023989806,
0.0083705243,
0.0481279977,
-0.006005446,
0.0096744141,
0.0988178477,
0.0222715307,
0.0053225458,
0.0405883528,
0.0096348124,
-0.0356841721,
-0.0214088932,
-0.0024538413,
0.0450229794,
-0.0235998146,
-0.0042948709,
-0.0286284499,
-0.054456383,
0.01139748,
-0.0070509217,
-0.0329969488,
-0.0108328592,
0.0155389719,
0.0837923586,
0.0007453139,
-0.0001665609,
-0.0225071535,
0.0311247241,
0.00825697,
-0.0211878885,
0.0001468763,
-5.85444235e-33,
-0.0235733371,
-0.0222116318,
0.0269225277,
-0.0361635722,
-0.0359742716,
0.0373626836,
-0.0489148535,
-0.0253730565,
-0.0099465707,
-0.0267001539,
-0.0220035408,
0.0339491516,
0.0097747641,
0.0281874016,
-0.0082114898,
-0.013272481,
0.0419186316,
0.0250708833,
0.0060179792,
0.0289490093,
0.0460594185,
0.0616711043,
0.0466639288,
-0.0159747601,
0.0285135917,
-0.0059187724,
0.0307474677,
0.0077611059,
0.0251336992,
0.0660042763,
-0.014202876,
0.0302459076,
0.0398241691,
-0.0596850365,
-0.0449191071,
0.0246646088,
-0.1167438701,
-0.0098555582,
0.0295886658,
0.0017682894,
-0.0145107992,
-0.0568260401,
0.0461921468,
-0.0013414767,
0.0298167095,
-0.0248819552,
0.0294645168,
-0.0542255901,
-0.0293689407,
-0.0226638447,
-0.0471631214,
0.0433011726,
0.006588025,
0.0097385589,
0.0652204305,
0.0452301316,
0.0087710712,
0.0648889095,
-0.0568886958,
-0.0380779244,
-0.0296142269,
0.0745314434,
0.0718845055,
0.0263147932,
0.0271581244,
0.0351951048,
0.0132050505,
0.002497694,
-0.0132785896,
-0.0216971096,
0.0294544529,
0.0241926536,
0.0204011723,
0.0453740545,
0.0350559726,
0.0036703807,
-0.0651354343,
0.0138592487,
0.012425812,
0.0231094155,
0.0324589573,
0.0231082477,
-0.0272699017,
-0.0082927123,
-0.0379750542,
0.0026051335,
-0.0360074304,
-0.0081157247,
0.0404752269,
0.0139907449,
-0.0015589931,
-0.0207623169,
0.0611520372,
-0.0513627231,
-0.0064437836,
0.0666802898,
-0.0177797917,
-0.0002804988,
0.0132305119,
0.0718271583,
-0.0436206385,
-0.0118275862,
0.0016030011,
0.0266288724,
0.0042067021,
-0.0179082789,
0.0556306317,
-0.0140599972,
-0.0489134304,
-0.0102682058,
-0.0502054915,
0.0085133594,
-0.0351347551,
0.0600376502,
0.0265031196,
0.0129771084,
0.0064860531,
0.095420666,
0.0116436081,
-0.0098413518,
-0.0128762685,
-0.0525757521,
-0.0225650743,
0.0331955068,
-0.0389660783,
-0.0117727891,
-0.0370349251,
0.0393832475,
0.0415171832,
-0.0567565486,
-0.00495299,
0.0402884446,
2.482e-7,
0.0380486101,
0.0130560873,
0.0533121303,
0.0128871091,
0.0150341382,
0.0103461612,
-0.0257912781,
0.0355707593,
-0.0253995974,
-0.0040127304,
-0.0127546638,
0.0373187847,
0.0474984795,
0.0175992604,
-0.0977800488,
-0.0018726781,
-0.0462438986,
-0.0005993408,
-0.0542914383,
0.0097443191,
0.0343285985,
0.126558423,
-0.0349418037,
0.0137565276,
0.0171646904,
-0.0394323729,
0.0431788079,
-0.0295394864,
-0.0042378712,
0.0244262535,
-0.0161728468,
0.0499206148,
-0.00882571,
-0.03838332,
0.0151250213,
0.0331740268,
0.0165604334,
0.0803634152,
0.0284271445,
-0.0282874405,
0.0279618073,
-0.0441225544,
-0.01757304,
-0.0687663183,
0.0778639764,
-0.0408969335,
0.0059964121,
-0.0222355388,
-0.0065403851,
-0.0194899123,
0.0093167927,
0.0266664606,
0.0035515409,
0.0370540395,
0.0021157418,
-0.0531177148,
0.0061450521,
-0.1182578877,
-0.0654558539,
0.0124977753,
-0.0350302309,
0.0117687546,
-0.0509849153,
-0.0109179774,
0.0217155609,
-0.0495206229,
0.0061442475,
2.466464491e-34,
0.0502798483,
-0.0444763303,
-0.0156149892,
0.0058030169,
0.0316395126,
-0.0424842238,
-0.0502333976,
0.003144634,
0.016879702,
-0.0584856495,
-0.0249791481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14484v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14484v1 | Multimodal Detection of Social Spambots in Twitter using Transformers | 2023-08-28T10:51:11 | 2023-08-28T10:51:11 | Loukas Ilias, Ioannis Michail Kazelidis, Dimitris Askounis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although not all bots are malicious, the vast majority of them are
responsible for spreading misinformation and manipulating the public opinion
about several issues, i.e., elections and many more. Therefore, the early
detection of social spambots is crucial. Although there have been proposed
methods for detecting bots in social media, there are still substantial
limitations. For instance, existing research initiatives still extract a large
number of features and train traditional machine learning algorithms or use
GloVe embeddings and train LSTMs. However, feature extraction is a tedious
procedure demanding domain expertise. Also, language models based on
transformers have been proved to be better than LSTMs. Other approaches create
large graphs and train graph neural networks requiring in this way many hours
for training and access to computational resources. To tackle these
limitations, this is the first study employing only the user description field
and images of three channels denoting the type and content of tweets posted by
the users. Firstly, we create digital DNA sequences, transform them to 3d
images, and apply pretrained models of the vision domain, including
EfficientNet, AlexNet, VGG16, etc. Next, we propose a multimodal approach,
where we use TwHIN-BERT for getting the textual representation of the user
description field and employ VGG16 for acquiring the visual representation for
the image modality. We propose three different fusion methods, namely
concatenation, gated multimodal unit, and crossmodal attention, for fusing the
different modalities and compare their performances. Extensive experiments
conducted on the Cresci '17 dataset demonstrate valuable advantages of our
introduced approaches over state-of-the-art ones reaching Accuracy up to
99.98%. | [
0.0839759782,
0.0098401867,
0.0038942846,
0.023401767,
-0.024675509,
0.0075284089,
0.0139354626,
0.0017392947,
0.0289018396,
-0.0726409703,
-0.0186404958,
-0.0310143773,
0.0053682923,
0.0574339628,
0.0465260819,
-0.0627718046,
0.0199227873,
0.0555852838,
-0.0087308921,
-0.0117436061,
0.0429673046,
0.0082491506,
0.0043231002,
0.0487976521,
-0.0556907915,
0.0176271945,
0.0068468982,
0.0205326714,
0.055803813,
-0.0046533369,
0.0192684345,
0.0453728847,
0.035044793,
0.0619678907,
0.0000021162,
-0.0178373214,
-0.0161762387,
-0.0138372704,
0.0252229143,
-0.0181625132,
0.0404213108,
-0.0283215903,
0.0051433635,
0.0389957428,
-0.0656388104,
0.0286025796,
0.0840438083,
0.0629488528,
0.0932525322,
0.0915758908,
-0.0279147606,
-0.0059982087,
0.0500742234,
-0.0120458128,
0.0167940371,
0.022654023,
0.0073694298,
-0.0363690034,
0.0124934828,
0.0298713688,
-0.0240904242,
0.0375184119,
0.001727557,
-0.0184022654,
0.0321523435,
0.0103216805,
-0.0220096409,
-0.0334870592,
0.0085328193,
0.0748640373,
-0.0405840911,
-0.0140245501,
0.0150451157,
0.0322556309,
0.0106654745,
0.0207164567,
-0.0247453749,
0.0224026684,
-0.0119228512,
0.0199732799,
-0.0499436893,
-0.0334572606,
0.0383716784,
0.0396455079,
-0.0243761558,
-0.0144139724,
-0.0037413279,
-0.0248610023,
-0.0308435541,
-0.0036967525,
-0.0173116364,
-0.0537327938,
0.0089944173,
0.0335350074,
-0.0072781155,
-0.0302077588,
-0.0847719014,
-0.1066751108,
-0.008340315,
-0.0390360169,
-0.0047030081,
0.0106826685,
-0.0207933411,
0.0262300409,
-0.0087387795,
0.0254185349,
-0.0626674518,
0.0878673419,
-0.0035379289,
-0.0142241046,
-0.0523519069,
0.0055394284,
-0.0346885659,
0.0053578136,
0.0297498852,
-0.0447530523,
-0.0840463787,
0.0254234672,
-0.0008751529,
-0.0237875581,
-0.0182505101,
0.0440926626,
0.00283445,
0.023161158,
0.0105708595,
0.0182730295,
0.0312757306,
-0.0080214888,
-0.030699838,
-0.0511030629,
-0.0352594256,
0.0572565645,
0.0210542493,
-0.0493797362,
0.0293037258,
0.0822928846,
0.0097209327,
-0.0618414283,
0.0156827085,
-0.0251928885,
-0.040988937,
-0.0278044082,
0.0213166364,
-0.0583780408,
0.0097012538,
-0.0034915491,
-0.0130053628,
-0.0085024899,
0.0206159838,
0.0169188567,
-0.033265084,
0.0680162385,
-0.0241974797,
-0.0054032044,
0.0118137738,
-0.0010839446,
-0.0087656314,
0.0161842462,
0.019694142,
0.0976944864,
0.0249088127,
-0.0300641377,
0.021032298,
0.0584883876,
0.0264661331,
-0.0080781635,
0.0234151296,
-0.0445271246,
-0.0385465547,
-0.0137133403,
0.0304552373,
0.0348872319,
-0.020302115,
-0.0057313852,
0.0782461911,
0.0234801788,
-0.0214428864,
-0.0002651027,
0.0568726063,
0.0308714453,
-0.0068512829,
-0.0328098312,
-0.0665823445,
0.0277524497,
-0.0088875731,
-0.017244298,
0.0291072205,
0.0733293369,
-0.0005440527,
0.0122345956,
0.0142460028,
-0.0316289589,
0.0742312819,
-0.0126003511,
0.0571567938,
0.0022653202,
-0.0295471195,
0.057885088,
0.0026351516,
0.0025952593,
-0.0344411284,
-0.0195218697,
-0.0255386941,
0.0346710272,
0.0108374748,
0.0072960737,
-0.0060791592,
-0.0332392678,
-0.0215804297,
0.0115415705,
0.0117868315,
0.0177015327,
-0.0203723591,
-0.0288709551,
-0.0587947853,
-0.0063981786,
-0.0341374204,
0.0144864935,
0.0421951301,
0.0235847477,
0.0238789059,
-0.0137189059,
0.0235492587,
0.0186658464,
0.0232804827,
0.0174730085,
-0.0160979237,
0.0481649488,
0.0782492533,
0.0145262005,
-0.0001161965,
-0.0123619642,
0.0221593995,
-0.050474856,
-0.0621294789,
0.0126402238,
-0.0090825176,
-0.0017993839,
0.0678987354,
-0.0588882416,
-0.0354924798,
0.077465497,
-0.0390751958,
-0.0000622216,
0.0999573097,
-0.0989997461,
0.0117086638,
-0.0627738163,
-0.0184353925,
0.0022914798,
0.0751898289,
0.0024762566,
0.0644804686,
-0.0487741455,
-0.0438931212,
0.0007876729,
-0.0510847308,
0.0156860035,
0.0099870255,
-0.0096187284,
-0.0220213886,
-0.0249498971,
0.0270494744,
0.0112084681,
0.0113005228,
-0.0369999669,
-0.0000856142,
-0.107183449,
-0.0150873298,
-0.0277194288,
-0.0109976511,
-0.0274705291,
0.0235804487,
0.0351413079,
-0.0167165231,
-0.0257150549,
0.035727445,
0.0115190903,
0.0119837346,
0.0276438147,
-0.0339266621,
-0.0435123779,
-0.013621904,
-0.0065251482,
-0.0227301139,
0.0432251468,
0.0030828246,
-0.0818110704,
0.0277009197,
-0.0552057438,
-0.0368156172,
0.0474704914,
-0.0051498963,
-0.0512029566,
0.0234542359,
-0.010257463,
0.0218743812,
0.0000258612,
0.0376932621,
0.0453714281,
-0.0054452331,
0.0361702628,
-0.0336372592,
0.0134409443,
-0.0186706223,
0.0137022771,
-0.0199177694,
-0.0092053898,
0.0197008625,
0.0470631979,
0.012567522,
-0.0033723034,
-0.0315533429,
0.0014840811,
0.0316273607,
-0.0324768946,
-0.0026441943,
-0.0179796051,
-0.0149145303,
-0.0289683305,
-0.0477498136,
-0.0651332363,
0.0658508688,
-0.0153751466,
0.0082077999,
0.0265658088,
-0.0591086149,
-0.0114396969,
0.0274160597,
0.0789009333,
0.0448562503,
-0.0127256811,
-0.0102895554,
0.0197812375,
0.0256263502,
0.0185119025,
-0.0087110437,
0.0120746847,
0.0463754237,
0.0252808873,
-0.0112311924,
-0.0100421673,
-0.040151082,
-0.0858069137,
-0.05945611,
-0.0179209094,
0.0031856757,
-0.0879091397,
-0.0646579191,
0.0100765163,
0.047805205,
-0.0161085147,
0.0019530591,
-0.005122161,
-0.0058333715,
0.0430856496,
0.0172713157,
0.019623721,
-0.0232285187,
-0.0410494655,
-0.0337527618,
0.0698331743,
-0.0063316859,
0.0109706344,
-0.0565361194,
-0.027313171,
-0.0089111598,
0.0127373682,
-0.0343107954,
-0.0123985847,
0.0147922207,
-0.0112037873,
0.0349585116,
0.0877587497,
-0.0056242063,
0.0002161583,
0.0084637851,
0.0187000744,
-0.0192836095,
0.0070946105,
-0.0099529307,
-0.0809282362,
-0.0533621311,
-0.0330095626,
-0.0179634038,
-0.0196677446,
-0.0221558791,
-0.0067817024,
-0.072690919,
0.0019395857,
0.003409581,
-0.0445228741,
-0.0897621959,
-0.0270319115,
-0.011851904,
0.0106366454,
0.0085711116,
-0.032705985,
-0.0043121404,
-0.0006120148,
0.0040992866,
0.0003627313,
-0.0289075337,
0.0215957779,
-0.0387344919,
0.0040151477,
0.0265496615,
0.0370669216,
-0.03803524,
-0.0420453958,
0.0067343814,
0.066878058,
-0.0039988393,
-0.0195863098,
0.1009899378,
-0.0390901528,
-0.018480178,
-0.0220813565,
0.0113133537,
-0.0004010815,
-0.0176742226,
-0.0581271425,
0.0653901994,
-0.029362211,
-0.0307042748,
-0.0381260663,
0.010992663,
0.0048457575,
0.0166251771,
0.0410868712,
-0.0581077822,
-0.0062085455,
-0.0161286872,
-0.0092835454,
-0.029955687,
-0.0543274134,
0.0342477188,
-0.0371763706,
-0.0843873695,
-0.0391814448,
-0.0113206729,
0.0224939566,
0.0023068665,
0.0011744158,
-0.0238508191,
0.0363117158,
0.0187404975,
-0.0902288482,
0.0454430655,
0.0028402205,
0.0729684755,
-0.0180008095,
0.0182405505,
0.0147703523,
-0.0493372343,
-0.0005135915,
0.0230168793,
-0.0847955123,
-0.0603348054,
-0.0133988867,
0.0291958228,
0.0120312897,
-0.0055197757,
-0.0289501324,
-0.0343954265,
0.0493396819,
0.0450062975,
0.0332216509,
-0.0181114618,
0.0352722332,
0.0040336587,
0.0050349864,
0.0115149841,
-0.0279133972,
0.0150428079,
-0.000189323,
-0.0673358962,
-0.0750728846,
0.0101283723,
-0.0007308061,
0.0364002585,
0.0735604763,
-0.0070231031,
-0.0054222131,
-0.0074017118,
-0.0508257039,
0.0268671345,
-0.0092108231,
-0.0216260348,
-0.0063692131,
0.0067273253,
0.0055887708,
0.0063485759,
-0.0052453894,
-0.0134907449,
-0.011458979,
-0.0234650709,
-0.0069803102,
-0.016198406,
-0.005933437,
0.0192230009,
0.0098049538,
-0.0065318025,
0.037508022,
0.0098492056,
-0.0183067098,
-0.0058976333,
-0.0039486112,
0.0071972348,
-0.0127274552,
0.0227135308,
0.0253340397,
-0.0243750606,
0.0067835161,
-0.0326671489,
0.0062079891,
0.0437656008,
0.0169320628,
0.0440298207,
-0.0054840297,
-0.0005106905,
-0.0061040781,
0.0323733538,
-0.038342949,
-0.0193285979,
0.0071956636,
-0.00896776,
-0.0357768647,
-0.0092351604,
0.0405415446,
0.005063741,
-0.0098431641,
0.0398238525,
-0.0484518111,
-0.0433343165,
-0.0019703889,
0.0202283468,
0.0181147493,
0.0200065412,
0.0220581107,
-0.0162366163,
-0.0577296205,
0.0321723558,
-0.0160896126,
-0.0362800695,
0.0452565774,
0.0218807664,
0.0457733423,
0.0125847002,
0.0232339408,
-0.0325077474,
0.0100991465,
0.0274932217,
-0.0632431433,
0.0348613411,
-6.739486741e-33,
0.0291236397,
-0.0726831704,
-0.0138014266,
-0.0195242073,
-0.0603859983,
0.0163263939,
-0.0058533223,
0.0166607667,
-0.0190040991,
0.0199780073,
0.0051332554,
0.0055369623,
-0.0138283949,
0.0430732965,
-0.0265889354,
-0.0002763865,
0.0245272331,
0.0114068389,
0.0031295831,
0.0267300662,
0.0722822174,
-0.0024406426,
0.0611800961,
-0.0867733061,
0.0052642715,
-0.007224814,
-0.0393939912,
-0.0029890111,
-0.011266687,
0.0316909663,
-0.0063954704,
0.0586260483,
0.0281921085,
-0.0159208085,
0.0019997598,
0.0571950264,
-0.0336399004,
-0.011536127,
-0.0211844482,
0.0154805044,
-0.038254939,
-0.0299408343,
0.0686619505,
-0.0270121638,
0.0092769777,
-0.0047356854,
0.0567655116,
0.0138962111,
0.017388938,
-0.0438511185,
-0.015325645,
0.018310789,
-0.031430237,
-0.0266280286,
0.0126246493,
0.0514650233,
0.0698446333,
0.0386216082,
-0.0625633076,
0.0370312333,
-0.0282168314,
-0.0187787134,
0.038816072,
-0.0196683016,
-0.007382378,
0.0523301736,
-0.0099519286,
-0.0179613233,
-0.0455003753,
-0.0157818776,
-0.0022299781,
0.0749927312,
0.0282200482,
0.0486351214,
0.0178725515,
-0.0484875739,
-0.0740898401,
0.0449098647,
0.0277043488,
0.0392484702,
-0.0039820173,
-0.032804057,
-0.0090836072,
0.023419138,
0.0283211786,
-0.0209106542,
-0.0401082821,
-0.0249796715,
-0.0237441957,
0.0050417138,
-0.0113756927,
0.00113858,
0.0373702981,
-0.0451174974,
0.0117440522,
0.0564529188,
0.0022767694,
0.0313691348,
0.0121834427,
0.0324546508,
-0.0050128764,
-0.0369471982,
0.0613653734,
-0.0260895472,
0.007974783,
-0.0255899504,
0.052707389,
0.0448098145,
-0.034334328,
-0.0093386136,
-0.0080712903,
0.0389587022,
-0.0558749363,
0.0421815366,
0.0156355072,
0.0291762352,
-0.0437494218,
-0.0166460015,
0.0246550031,
0.0144713502,
-0.0316857547,
0.022976622,
0.0067468421,
-0.0045423368,
-0.0055075395,
0.0214038063,
-0.0467507914,
-0.0055713151,
0.0148645509,
-0.1010017246,
0.0004111588,
-0.0245014392,
3.053e-7,
0.0097993808,
0.0625931621,
-0.0011110116,
-0.0058838679,
0.0188246425,
0.0969107226,
0.0521000251,
0.0841708854,
-0.0362553746,
-0.0596242771,
-0.0027869951,
0.059750516,
0.017233232,
0.0000372674,
-0.0313486718,
-0.0079331733,
-0.0633961409,
-0.0129430266,
-0.0356245898,
0.0449745357,
0.0232064743,
0.0976714417,
0.0497015528,
-0.0719923228,
0.0367643498,
-0.0517523475,
0.0478461906,
0.0142825237,
-0.0373843089,
-0.0001280277,
0.0537278168,
-0.0007001848,
0.0209875759,
0.0170308016,
-0.0145253101,
0.0226025563,
0.0275979135,
0.0147745376,
-0.0362320729,
-0.0309349634,
-0.0263148099,
-0.0133795049,
-0.0032456189,
-0.0019001003,
0.0389373824,
-0.0428988151,
-0.082467176,
-0.0334655456,
-0.0146519197,
-0.0071769985,
0.054333102,
-0.0288592111,
-0.01167602,
0.0498036779,
0.0300479066,
-0.0325906537,
-0.0205556173,
-0.1105603203,
0.0128846122,
-0.0310282931,
-0.0660463125,
-0.0152153354,
-0.0136530921,
-0.0157598741,
0.1021877155,
0.0226780139,
0.0048081526,
2.417764128e-34,
0.0408729389,
-0.0114049083,
0.0217148177,
-0.0257956274,
-0.0161085762,
0.0185975842,
-0.0062161125,
-0.025154531,
0.0206233896,
-0.0685856268,
0.0019067655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14482v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14482v1 | An Empirical Study of Consistency Regularization for End-to-End Speech-to-Text Translation | 2023-08-28T10:44:18 | 2023-08-28T10:44:18 | Pengzhi Gao, Ruiqing Zhang, Zhongjun He, Hua Wu, Haifeng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Consistency regularization methods, such as R-Drop (Liang et al., 2021) and
CrossConST (Gao et al., 2023), have achieved impressive supervised and
zero-shot performance in the neural machine translation (NMT) field. Can we
also boost end-to-end (E2E) speech-to-text translation (ST) by leveraging
consistency regularization? In this paper, we conduct empirical studies on
intra-modal and cross-modal consistency and propose two training strategies,
SimRegCR and SimZeroCR, for E2E ST in regular and zero-shot scenarios.
Experiments on the MuST-C benchmark show that our approaches achieve
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance in most translation directions. The
analyses prove that regularization brought by the intra-modal consistency,
instead of modality gap, is crucial for the regular E2E ST, and the cross-modal
consistency could close the modality gap and boost the zero-shot E2E ST
performance. | [
0.031169422,
0.0883612707,
0.0305460747,
-0.0049555255,
-0.0137207247,
-0.0215489008,
0.0087826708,
0.0194705911,
-0.0648362339,
-0.0110991839,
-0.027617665,
-0.0379585288,
0.0675561205,
-0.0148527352,
0.0241841022,
-0.0208964758,
0.0376412682,
0.0126466146,
-0.0472968854,
0.01689451,
0.0440951623,
0.0000660574,
-0.0068227486,
0.0442390442,
-0.012356801,
0.0063985921,
-0.0172106419,
0.0594483651,
0.0546001457,
-0.0329518914,
-0.0056799049,
0.0118415067,
0.0417181849,
0.0473752692,
0.0000021007,
-0.0266088117,
-0.0211112108,
0.0155171361,
-0.0173266605,
-0.0064635603,
0.0259989575,
-0.0937229842,
0.0030341214,
0.0215485878,
0.0354842953,
0.001660643,
0.0615351684,
0.0432046913,
0.0626984984,
0.0981490389,
-0.0214847531,
-0.0187913403,
0.0572148599,
-0.0767177045,
0.0225044228,
-0.0561220869,
-0.0250367429,
-0.0309131872,
-0.0597478375,
-0.0081482902,
-0.0194287933,
0.0374276116,
0.004613487,
0.0074966289,
-0.0590906143,
0.0017974117,
-0.0198249109,
-0.0298191998,
-0.0247454885,
0.1083047688,
0.0020839192,
0.0134988762,
-0.0000854181,
0.0100162486,
-0.0521565191,
-0.0288604777,
-0.034053836,
0.0083814738,
0.0211045463,
-0.0143767158,
-0.0213623345,
0.0335109234,
0.03323346,
-0.021950908,
-0.0390873551,
-0.0036429951,
0.0248269849,
-0.0210128278,
0.0106526427,
0.0120138079,
-0.0159203913,
-0.0409461744,
0.0362070613,
0.0251748879,
-0.0290196445,
-0.0130725838,
-0.0581196249,
-0.0129755363,
-0.0052198404,
0.0094671044,
0.0350219347,
0.1059550568,
-0.0323882923,
0.0080630593,
-0.016267566,
0.0470664538,
-0.0370009616,
0.0526588187,
-0.013074684,
-0.0128261242,
-0.0386127867,
0.0414368957,
-0.0438987464,
-0.0068790084,
-0.0105478847,
-0.0462142751,
-0.0384240486,
-0.0263520014,
-0.0148961209,
0.0379291959,
0.0379092507,
-0.0069326893,
-0.1020552814,
-0.054361131,
0.032841187,
0.0739608705,
-0.0142924208,
0.0255736709,
0.017715862,
-0.0190950204,
-0.0292173754,
0.0144194504,
0.0138276387,
-0.0175305605,
-0.009645585,
0.0589807555,
-0.0322297662,
-0.0135813262,
-0.0224815626,
-0.0192610491,
-0.0286918674,
-0.1434314996,
-0.0396028273,
-0.0340170823,
0.0703318864,
-0.0206080731,
0.0308657773,
-0.0360597707,
-0.0305692144,
-0.0260531381,
0.0159976408,
0.0643346682,
0.0025288321,
-0.0342128985,
0.0364498198,
0.0325872041,
0.0104922121,
0.0392720178,
0.036154598,
-0.0245968048,
-0.0142826596,
0.0277672075,
-0.0258448459,
0.0482935943,
0.0349716581,
0.0210939981,
-0.0664480552,
-0.0168367289,
0.0069096838,
0.0524530113,
0.0176434573,
0.0556690842,
-0.0453842543,
-0.0174264051,
0.0465579927,
-0.001468536,
0.0583509281,
0.0022464842,
0.0488859043,
0.0140845058,
-0.0168533195,
0.0180579592,
-0.0247333646,
0.0094476249,
0.0123654027,
-0.0151062561,
0.0357823819,
0.0139483241,
-0.041141782,
-0.0053611114,
-0.0158258565,
0.0004105576,
-0.009727071,
-0.0276008099,
0.0274116434,
-0.0303524211,
-0.0365969688,
0.0308297854,
-0.0076768608,
-0.0392896347,
0.0458705761,
-0.0105778687,
-0.0104751755,
0.0234452486,
0.004318797,
0.0079095708,
-0.0503605828,
-0.043263752,
0.021487413,
0.0550259762,
0.0444889814,
0.025121294,
0.0887177736,
-0.0505215749,
-0.0344912782,
0.0346321538,
0.0134677151,
0.0223682355,
-0.0352838933,
0.093254149,
0.0494940951,
-0.012239675,
0.0278163478,
0.0247020386,
0.0072569544,
0.0184386447,
0.0452811867,
0.0215174966,
0.0037648503,
0.0013778814,
-0.0460840762,
0.0001682172,
0.0088955583,
-0.0338160433,
0.0079263449,
0.0082888026,
-0.0863183662,
-0.0236024708,
0.0618147776,
-0.0263032019,
0.025153894,
0.0650884062,
-0.0097861821,
-0.0548088811,
0.012751014,
-0.0075615766,
0.0226713754,
-0.0253944658,
0.0434783548,
0.037267819,
0.0019506532,
0.0157081112,
-0.0257627033,
0.0145401554,
-0.0175357815,
0.0574614815,
-0.0290931389,
0.0347246341,
-0.0666636154,
-0.0179217346,
0.0459370203,
-0.0088744313,
0.0588055477,
0.0360209085,
0.0119829746,
-0.013814969,
0.0030855332,
-0.0703217387,
0.011606534,
-0.0180616509,
0.0298620388,
0.0294626802,
0.0418485701,
0.0084979441,
0.0070236358,
0.0083916821,
0.0243668612,
-0.0000066905,
-0.0220907293,
-0.0233869273,
0.0201976262,
-0.0201912541,
-0.0229208469,
-0.01710039,
0.0032738673,
-0.0010884223,
-0.0201277472,
0.0121100806,
-0.0780722648,
-0.0003974865,
-0.0365312956,
0.0192351118,
-0.0261557084,
-0.02065612,
0.0103419693,
-0.0068895454,
0.0120944018,
0.0129567217,
-0.0057022525,
-0.0262954533,
-0.0165668856,
-0.0043564825,
-0.0959723964,
0.0074831722,
0.0039656474,
-0.0225834567,
-0.0213149786,
-0.0078127403,
-0.0123642245,
0.0852896199,
0.0110712769,
0.0316397697,
-0.0477999859,
-0.0207707677,
0.0092890766,
-0.0190421809,
-0.0140721239,
0.0147057921,
0.0058850911,
0.0031880727,
-0.0372860879,
-0.0202191621,
0.0470155478,
-0.0806802511,
-0.0018814683,
-0.0114682745,
-0.0294902306,
-0.0183672495,
0.0054237321,
-0.0581075996,
0.0172332935,
-0.0070225825,
-0.0308602378,
-0.0467512682,
-0.0483251177,
0.002998417,
0.0137806898,
0.0337037928,
0.0092459824,
0.0052554947,
-0.0591146238,
-0.0058143171,
-0.0107623991,
-0.0408926941,
-0.0291097239,
0.025391886,
-0.0132020963,
-0.0456579849,
-0.0315697677,
-0.0051490879,
0.0136123654,
0.0780688748,
-0.0146869915,
-0.019632427,
-0.0037286512,
0.0773390904,
0.0186882075,
0.0207801592,
-0.0366585143,
-0.0423942022,
0.0290341098,
0.0137815764,
0.0218091868,
0.0209964551,
-0.0387988165,
-0.037177559,
0.0126296775,
0.0292085484,
0.0121989697,
0.0140610915,
0.0693935752,
-0.0631355569,
0.0143154887,
0.0493617244,
-0.0269048307,
-0.0627506152,
-0.017979756,
0.0247268509,
0.0683706477,
0.010248783,
0.0131603386,
-0.1011003628,
-0.0644895434,
0.0043224599,
0.0402162224,
0.0440317728,
0.0019140776,
-0.0425842218,
-0.0539471321,
0.0283063743,
0.0245913733,
-0.0957220644,
-0.0193961486,
0.0102799889,
-0.0065410542,
-0.0135422293,
0.0692289695,
0.0012460826,
0.0052673318,
-0.0496295393,
0.0319673009,
0.0405388661,
-0.0238160118,
-0.0019254162,
-0.0566343367,
0.0321705565,
0.0130222524,
0.0131760882,
0.0124984207,
-0.031093182,
0.0861955658,
0.0194848012,
-0.0098865051,
-0.0064692353,
0.0210342519,
-0.0547998697,
-0.0268378239,
0.0297857225,
0.000801153,
0.0281063542,
0.0333179943,
0.0009265837,
0.0540294647,
0.020843301,
-0.0224901754,
-0.003462737,
-0.0002560069,
0.0093493657,
0.0594346412,
-0.0123977056,
-0.0448006801,
-0.0276876725,
-0.0082985759,
0.0209729392,
-0.0594661534,
-0.0033839138,
-0.0125596942,
0.0012492388,
-0.0247481838,
-0.0366809517,
-0.0288210437,
-0.0119314818,
0.0447872169,
0.0059985439,
-0.0081246654,
-0.019084882,
-0.0036541054,
-0.0366955884,
0.000264431,
-0.0544634052,
0.035335362,
-0.0503110439,
0.0540542118,
0.0023871479,
-0.0252573993,
0.0307922978,
0.0337372608,
-0.132381767,
-0.0548963845,
-0.0497998595,
0.008387127,
0.0186172184,
0.0529216304,
-0.0173775256,
-0.0188182648,
0.0261864625,
0.0167644694,
-0.0513127856,
0.0126703959,
0.0228781924,
-0.0246187989,
-0.0113948174,
0.0311869234,
-0.0263832137,
-0.0036321485,
0.0133677889,
0.0775293559,
0.0169046205,
-0.0280266106,
0.0279530566,
-0.0032577703,
0.0080389129,
-0.0179451108,
0.0001023782,
-0.0211116113,
0.0207955912,
-0.0099126231,
0.0422214381,
-0.0453161411,
0.0026698681,
0.0411303453,
0.0097481133,
0.0102408193,
0.0090117333,
-0.0333009288,
0.0073926388,
-0.0251271036,
-0.0165676307,
-0.0041744942,
0.0251268223,
0.0240664948,
0.0094551388,
-0.010019742,
0.0442792363,
0.0015638547,
0.0188952852,
-0.0629397482,
0.05079557,
0.0100317774,
0.0150980428,
-0.0214637201,
0.0192119982,
-0.0158718694,
-0.0070096808,
-0.0253514182,
0.000805684,
0.0511230975,
0.0584357791,
0.0802340955,
0.0338207781,
0.0011462922,
-0.0284147523,
0.0558618382,
-0.0527839698,
0.0052966019,
0.0018284346,
-0.0072775893,
0.0159017015,
0.0692135394,
0.0023126504,
0.0255638305,
0.005234024,
-0.0407316834,
0.0033864861,
-0.0236529335,
-0.002374161,
0.0032111045,
0.0152733158,
-0.0267053656,
-0.0502518006,
-0.0031250133,
-0.0749682337,
0.0549420714,
-0.0022882454,
0.0101556582,
0.0304917265,
-0.014500007,
0.0318989977,
-0.0336388424,
0.0053089978,
0.0082328124,
-0.029344162,
0.0385217927,
0.0015723144,
-0.0024074961,
-6.799363484e-33,
-0.0101972306,
0.0510927029,
0.0110338014,
-0.0725556016,
-0.0658462867,
-0.0078509115,
-0.0570826642,
-0.0054653226,
-0.0009898444,
-0.0042637005,
0.0037572379,
0.0391985513,
0.0166497864,
0.002908516,
-0.0085337525,
0.0023096423,
0.0825900882,
-0.0066806707,
-0.042553477,
-0.0106240995,
0.0437372662,
0.0126353586,
0.0782223344,
-0.0941424444,
0.0331277885,
0.0078446837,
-0.0406249315,
0.0048945369,
0.0092649348,
0.0418588147,
-0.0121556604,
0.0070656505,
0.0277663376,
-0.0384548865,
-0.0124787828,
-0.038770929,
-0.1017400175,
0.0006006959,
-0.0023227229,
0.0143036582,
-0.0743278563,
-0.0240256302,
0.0526790358,
-0.0306084175,
-0.0140540302,
-0.0566573516,
-0.0097429315,
0.020644946,
-0.0237756409,
-0.0092594754,
-0.0726557747,
0.0266574863,
-0.0120316157,
-0.0105965706,
-0.0014797619,
0.0763712898,
-0.0085713807,
-0.0041738055,
-0.0464714505,
-0.0143068414,
-0.0286244042,
0.0214845967,
0.0668473244,
0.0235999525,
-0.0494848192,
0.016712537,
0.0445435755,
-0.0170492977,
0.0143959615,
-0.0219223853,
0.0440104455,
0.0151924398,
0.015485025,
0.089191027,
0.0653102174,
-0.0137265092,
-0.085566543,
0.0324141644,
-0.0195220839,
0.0315093882,
-0.0053735799,
0.008971897,
-0.0098584006,
-0.0060487865,
-0.0249734595,
-0.0728448927,
-0.0380593836,
-0.0178392362,
0.0297520012,
0.0662063584,
-0.0233045239,
0.0034509378,
0.1151539162,
-0.0076471125,
0.0078921542,
0.0353426002,
-0.0422305353,
-0.0007534794,
-0.0080534751,
0.0238086097,
-0.0550152436,
-0.0342009366,
0.0285458844,
0.0427413955,
0.0302101318,
-0.0611355491,
0.0339344032,
0.0416985266,
-0.0357576571,
-0.0247034263,
-0.0208138954,
0.0202336963,
-0.0163209625,
0.0208336432,
0.0565730818,
-0.028226506,
-0.0161166359,
0.086323522,
-0.0187997948,
-0.0055355518,
-0.0029271657,
0.0290915798,
0.0724800378,
0.0426015258,
-0.0277630985,
0.017782215,
0.0010563475,
-0.0475393385,
0.046721112,
-0.0430064984,
-0.017321609,
0.0015207935,
2.705e-7,
-0.023322789,
-0.0363120623,
0.047049351,
-0.0248607174,
-0.0091913491,
0.0031883824,
-0.047106903,
0.0288917255,
-0.0144480923,
0.0163960215,
0.0306498483,
0.0092971353,
0.1075199768,
0.0277890861,
-0.0412493274,
-0.0331424326,
-0.0356160738,
0.0461563878,
-0.0134897698,
0.0193323828,
0.0592111982,
0.0902070254,
-0.0371506996,
-0.0153784417,
0.0130857108,
-0.0119398916,
0.0733990148,
0.0078675393,
0.0100426152,
-0.0074670003,
0.0264950283,
0.0066911289,
-0.0327324793,
-0.0250639319,
-0.011930841,
0.0299474467,
0.0202529188,
0.087099202,
-0.0125733484,
-0.0247804411,
-0.0043217945,
0.0184704531,
-0.0288102794,
0.0084271617,
0.0231388472,
-0.0521286391,
0.0169349816,
-0.0118836546,
-0.0185772851,
0.0057662013,
0.0341534242,
-0.0330443233,
-0.0032827703,
0.006224182,
0.0441031605,
0.0013244164,
-0.045138862,
-0.0473925136,
-0.0330346078,
-0.010217336,
-0.0336227417,
-0.0238882322,
-0.0113613633,
-0.0122746797,
0.0374398381,
-0.0184706878,
-0.0311923884,
1.929422678e-34,
0.0298537966,
-0.0377341881,
0.0301488265,
-0.0445952713,
0.0143194832,
-0.0178505406,
0.0093714548,
-0.0187723357,
-0.0042169415,
-0.0654829293,
-0.0523370989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14436v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14436v1 | Bridging the KB-Text Gap: Leveraging Structured Knowledge-aware Pre-training for KBQA | 2023-08-28T09:22:02 | 2023-08-28T09:22:02 | Guanting Dong, Rumei Li, Sirui Wang, Yupeng Zhang, Yunsen Xian, Weiran Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Knowledge Base Question Answering (KBQA) aims to answer natural language
questions with factual information such as entities and relations in KBs.
However, traditional Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) are directly
pre-trained on large-scale natural language corpus, which poses challenges for
them in understanding and representing complex subgraphs in structured KBs. To
bridge the gap between texts and structured KBs, we propose a Structured
Knowledge-aware Pre-training method (SKP). In the pre-training stage, we
introduce two novel structured knowledge-aware tasks, guiding the model to
effectively learn the implicit relationship and better representations of
complex subgraphs. In downstream KBQA task, we further design an efficient
linearization strategy and an interval attention mechanism, which assist the
model to better encode complex subgraphs and shield the interference of
irrelevant subgraphs during reasoning respectively. Detailed experiments and
analyses on WebQSP verify the effectiveness of SKP, especially the significant
improvement in subgraph retrieval (+4.08% H@10). | [
0.0309123509,
0.019286599,
0.0117417676,
0.0315257646,
0.003640383,
0.0051120124,
-0.0119935591,
0.0278602969,
0.0663601235,
-0.0615131781,
-0.0264125876,
-0.0168069527,
-0.0685742497,
0.0481649451,
0.0077579622,
-0.0595912375,
0.0646598116,
0.0112804063,
0.0436685421,
-0.007183481,
0.0241000876,
0.0101286722,
-0.0150678996,
-0.0259252656,
-0.0215140469,
-0.0581498146,
-0.0061361948,
0.0093571795,
0.0123665901,
-0.0307408776,
0.0310447384,
0.0432123914,
0.0317395702,
-0.0434075035,
0.0000018726,
-0.0290857404,
-0.0194068048,
-0.0108629065,
-0.0641728789,
0.0124008749,
-0.0402935445,
0.0174142774,
0.038668409,
0.0029451794,
-0.0518235564,
-0.0384097211,
0.0205338877,
0.0719197243,
0.0647668391,
0.0723527819,
-0.0096340673,
-0.0099443076,
-0.02539015,
0.0028331613,
-0.0106469942,
-0.0609080717,
0.025002826,
0.026185777,
0.0117446026,
0.0362961292,
0.006470406,
0.0096453922,
0.0078310864,
0.0166150574,
0.0678943172,
0.0365950167,
-0.0326331332,
0.0368913375,
0.0246406049,
0.1212982163,
-0.003216882,
-0.0162402075,
0.005349434,
-0.0152884135,
-0.0169522241,
-0.0085992506,
-0.0328676179,
-0.0027395694,
-0.012639557,
-0.0149796279,
-0.0299679674,
0.0259530582,
0.0038928594,
-0.000049111,
-0.034632802,
0.0672073588,
-0.0056293756,
-0.0293130931,
0.0322132297,
0.0196332876,
-0.0502824411,
-0.0555625521,
0.0371218659,
0.0644314885,
-0.0098070549,
0.0313425027,
-0.023869738,
0.0424988009,
-0.0056712981,
-0.0670129582,
-0.0192263778,
0.0391403288,
0.0053051994,
0.061234951,
-0.030319754,
0.0416029431,
-0.0100244218,
-0.0073680808,
-0.0388539471,
0.0297996476,
-0.0450054258,
-0.0223889221,
-0.0745984092,
0.0503347144,
-0.0362644829,
-0.0063102008,
0.0227796882,
0.0336139798,
0.0008685467,
-0.029792631,
0.0184723064,
0.0274457131,
-0.0034079293,
-0.0162331834,
-0.0407735445,
0.0463630445,
-0.0648521185,
-0.0009118682,
-0.0453902707,
-0.0117884316,
-0.0292625278,
0.0054338537,
0.0231790319,
-0.0488765351,
-0.0157717224,
0.0085112965,
0.005863118,
-0.0136638395,
-0.0533425212,
-0.0414746106,
0.0019727342,
-0.0287256092,
0.0094045047,
-0.0343309417,
0.0443183333,
-0.0003660632,
-0.0439990237,
-0.0237654336,
0.0334647186,
0.0113778785,
-0.0413647704,
0.0492370725,
-0.0188530162,
-0.0250916556,
-0.0393556133,
0.012486821,
-0.0004815014,
0.0697435364,
0.004478002,
-0.021271674,
0.0159547105,
0.0196562745,
-0.0843363479,
0.0112776952,
0.0546371192,
-0.0011587075,
0.0357313566,
0.0581912957,
-0.020725688,
0.0136099914,
0.0510875322,
0.0122302929,
-0.0267550349,
-0.0298312996,
0.0048473878,
-0.003769598,
0.011883188,
0.033185076,
0.0176738556,
0.0369933508,
0.0378993191,
0.0429500677,
-0.0284622889,
0.0107358601,
-0.0297596771,
0.0241461191,
-0.0342923962,
-0.0155324601,
-0.0485806987,
-0.0266997479,
-0.0069963401,
0.0262445789,
0.0177206099,
0.0298475698,
0.0500168428,
0.0370250195,
-0.0400372706,
0.0939343274,
0.0256305858,
-0.0082161883,
0.0179676712,
0.0084385006,
-0.0055237636,
0.0667785779,
0.009865718,
-0.0693239421,
-0.0470375419,
0.022386346,
-0.0015773347,
-0.002414301,
0.0059065786,
-0.0252453666,
-0.012657511,
-0.0142358039,
-0.0302567258,
-0.0343921408,
-0.0292131547,
-0.0049999901,
0.0417057797,
0.0269487556,
0.0103786504,
-0.0409189425,
0.0337746181,
0.011215684,
-0.0255547594,
-0.0217766557,
-0.0167298932,
0.0364001021,
-0.0128739895,
0.0336402096,
0.0106201572,
0.0173523687,
0.0463345535,
-0.0176847763,
-0.0231287871,
-0.0303561892,
-0.0425646715,
-0.1157953739,
0.0395307392,
0.0333327018,
-0.0159815587,
-0.0162215214,
-0.0210068617,
-0.0236895848,
-0.002719633,
-0.0219076481,
0.064957127,
-0.0118033374,
-0.0241894927,
0.053921558,
-0.0282589588,
-0.0631279945,
0.0758652687,
0.0043953229,
0.0150108561,
0.0016912748,
-0.0289959889,
0.0200066417,
-0.0254363343,
0.0189580992,
-0.0040489347,
0.0080280546,
-0.003804934,
0.0251489729,
-0.0036179852,
-0.0726795122,
0.0471634157,
-0.0580434203,
0.0267701782,
-0.0040875049,
0.0470944829,
0.021828305,
0.0255217683,
0.0214886405,
-0.0466416031,
-0.0510000661,
0.0026922058,
-0.0096693626,
0.0026678762,
0.03408603,
0.0107037565,
0.0135380197,
-0.030250242,
-0.0287834965,
-0.0401794836,
0.0596918352,
-0.0100130849,
-0.0022125787,
0.0012512364,
0.0601412579,
-0.0291264541,
0.0430048481,
0.0137525722,
-0.0167580694,
-0.0226165112,
-0.0084433025,
0.0168335456,
0.0716075152,
-0.0276919585,
-0.0040460736,
0.0200137813,
-0.024195496,
-0.056145113,
0.0448919199,
-0.0141295791,
-0.0025166031,
0.0032108538,
-0.00325071,
-0.0030379465,
0.0900140777,
-0.0155428937,
-0.0402889103,
-0.0570886694,
-0.0096594952,
0.0230372958,
0.0208832994,
-0.0376995988,
0.0028255663,
0.0180980451,
0.0171054564,
-0.0655136406,
0.0259542372,
0.0711712614,
0.0274069794,
0.00172524,
-0.0296644997,
0.034888424,
-0.0405065678,
0.0480078459,
0.007592258,
0.0144499987,
0.0297518913,
-0.0291174669,
-0.0510631315,
0.007193754,
-0.0019416232,
-0.0199133549,
-0.0146068819,
0.0123671014,
0.051254116,
0.0070891641,
0.0010203237,
-0.0701837912,
0.0115728369,
-0.0153687438,
0.0356262587,
0.008651563,
0.0219011046,
0.0007396112,
0.0285403207,
0.0122370208,
-0.0083294678,
-0.0070682745,
0.0086051961,
-0.0162313338,
0.0799125433,
0.0462170281,
0.0168396719,
0.0375791676,
0.003174705,
0.0054589864,
0.0579458028,
0.0103638452,
-0.0215364229,
0.0158737395,
0.003025329,
0.0101077948,
-0.0761093795,
-0.0089675579,
-0.0277740993,
0.0311611183,
-0.0558159612,
-0.0143513102,
0.1198381558,
0.0585650317,
0.0311887097,
-0.0071004792,
-0.0036590458,
0.0393091142,
0.0275233164,
0.0404897407,
-0.0827875212,
-0.0208182577,
-0.018823998,
-0.0124069629,
0.0293042473,
-0.0461722575,
0.0137158427,
-0.0776376203,
-0.0235398337,
0.0106420536,
-0.0303122383,
-0.01951872,
-0.0419260338,
0.0007455409,
0.0243528727,
-0.0225875881,
0.0160455368,
-0.0331567526,
0.0155255841,
0.0066352407,
-0.0399974659,
-0.0267895591,
0.0361423157,
-0.037968725,
-0.0078295078,
0.0083279172,
0.0464526936,
0.0208248775,
0.0143912761,
-0.044037357,
-0.0102612413,
0.0030263532,
-0.0242236555,
0.0318154506,
-0.0268180743,
-0.0145856254,
-0.0455112234,
-0.0328558125,
-0.0565145761,
-0.0136625646,
-0.0245947186,
0.0881932825,
0.0085583804,
-0.0210751053,
0.0057219304,
0.0088259857,
0.0054253964,
0.0668933839,
0.0184920952,
0.0285706408,
-0.0470083952,
-0.0072223064,
0.0179152079,
-0.0408156961,
-0.0406481996,
0.0593898222,
-0.0382169895,
0.0247705691,
-0.088870272,
-0.0501047261,
0.0574466735,
0.020630056,
-0.0345813073,
-0.0322181992,
0.0585911684,
-0.0142638963,
-0.0827421397,
0.0502521396,
-0.0445202142,
0.0068978909,
-0.0197623689,
-0.0232952628,
-0.0040778541,
-0.0138110686,
-0.0306060128,
-0.0239295457,
-0.0419576764,
-0.0470664166,
-0.0113605652,
0.034088362,
0.0026906619,
0.0549712814,
-0.0321345851,
-0.0383184291,
0.0349887982,
-0.0367537774,
-0.1057399735,
-0.0182584897,
0.0325013921,
-0.0121176895,
-0.0115597472,
0.0248917863,
-0.0666223168,
-0.0019668632,
0.0082692467,
0.0737078115,
-0.0307373051,
-0.0544450209,
0.0157342721,
0.0109017696,
-0.0311608966,
0.0520537198,
-0.0067992583,
-0.0358383916,
0.0165199414,
-0.0207819771,
-0.0240500253,
-0.0431214646,
-0.0032497991,
-0.0083076134,
-0.0286052637,
-0.0188369695,
-0.0003302277,
-0.0354537889,
0.0108060222,
0.0154882381,
0.0068168947,
0.0530444719,
-0.0013590816,
0.0386145376,
-0.0266381446,
-0.0289028734,
0.0102476096,
0.0119544538,
0.0295869093,
-0.0147673376,
0.0139978426,
0.0144256577,
-0.0107381186,
-0.0491837375,
-0.0162701532,
-0.0228969269,
-0.0350214951,
0.0104804533,
-0.0053644567,
0.0479008183,
-0.0231300779,
0.0079275724,
0.0140023166,
-0.0101483827,
-0.0098206885,
-0.0000571015,
-0.0158921052,
0.0075660595,
0.0553920418,
0.031070197,
-0.0125272209,
0.0305709336,
0.0651875436,
0.053958796,
0.0437531844,
-0.0049258261,
-0.0353701115,
-0.0249126256,
-0.0171689484,
-0.0159614999,
0.0709184706,
-0.0300244614,
0.0584580749,
-0.05047727,
-0.0693354458,
0.0403618999,
-0.036118757,
-0.0722845048,
0.006539016,
0.0623032562,
0.0019382231,
0.0422270745,
-0.0696307495,
-0.0157168917,
0.0343440026,
-0.0139144491,
-0.0049688201,
-0.0150268925,
-6.400252295e-33,
-0.063920863,
-0.0430455767,
0.0150178801,
-0.0092623839,
-0.0503284,
0.0164186582,
-0.0357878171,
-0.0263844021,
-0.0436077565,
0.0120137017,
-0.0089393388,
-0.0091247391,
-0.0069236499,
0.004530184,
-0.0364079066,
-0.0380953439,
0.0186590496,
-0.0019464351,
0.012956867,
0.0230953265,
0.0177227855,
0.0729079619,
0.0750423595,
-0.0342423208,
0.010472781,
-0.0276337042,
0.0299165137,
0.0371944942,
0.0194506124,
0.0678789839,
-0.0413890928,
0.0097135101,
0.0324140489,
-0.0006473925,
0.0029138199,
0.0241677426,
-0.1345655918,
-0.0403619111,
0.0330868959,
0.0479144901,
-0.0497956797,
-0.0213071145,
0.0230353512,
0.0024492557,
0.0888346434,
-0.0615812242,
0.0415234007,
-0.0104605546,
-0.0261085611,
-0.0607614703,
-0.0317188799,
0.0255905408,
-0.0095239114,
0.0065819421,
-0.0113329524,
0.0273444746,
-0.0063800896,
0.015819028,
-0.0490081534,
-0.0087173497,
0.0128690777,
0.0399134494,
-0.0167954694,
0.0112304967,
0.0148561411,
0.0134997526,
-0.007740458,
-0.0094235875,
-0.0233443137,
0.0264709983,
0.0144500686,
0.0323773138,
-0.0026729233,
0.0114112338,
0.0260275155,
0.0325435735,
-0.1033686697,
-0.0107745957,
-0.0009859105,
0.0641087741,
-0.0511932075,
0.0040834486,
-0.0223519057,
-0.037796624,
-0.0237826668,
0.0136597883,
-0.0447390005,
-0.039231237,
0.0255033094,
-0.0024840496,
-0.0005905467,
0.0077523678,
0.0056318981,
-0.0445518829,
0.0009566826,
0.0332833752,
0.0291602202,
0.0252043214,
0.0099488944,
0.0689809918,
-0.0699092299,
0.0074310177,
0.0491434783,
-0.0667557791,
-0.0147753283,
0.0400840938,
0.0252525657,
-0.0200366415,
-0.04281253,
-0.0250435378,
-0.0256998409,
-0.0131814256,
-0.0129263392,
0.0229736771,
0.043120902,
0.0506303534,
0.0136808669,
0.0916764364,
0.0235410277,
-0.0132837864,
-0.0239868406,
0.0087059001,
0.0256266706,
0.0653657839,
-0.0103865666,
0.0050160177,
-0.0217780489,
0.0161576644,
-0.0480287075,
-0.0729603097,
-0.0344734713,
0.0071699661,
2.588e-7,
0.0633209124,
0.0343463011,
0.0512456857,
0.0664470196,
-0.010542986,
0.0013461661,
0.0254563075,
0.0149635263,
0.0034331735,
-0.0469420925,
0.0288895424,
0.0615270361,
-0.0223340485,
0.0089237327,
-0.075539358,
0.0096751396,
-0.003441761,
-0.0506326109,
-0.0280393679,
-0.0530026481,
0.0804651156,
0.0291175023,
0.0049439911,
0.0398683511,
-0.0103714727,
-0.0432083234,
0.0782010853,
0.0372671038,
-0.0153241511,
0.0283997003,
0.0205513388,
-0.0007091773,
-0.0384207368,
0.0634679422,
-0.0105151916,
0.055551447,
0.0364593342,
0.0576554425,
-0.0287462771,
-0.0239010751,
-0.0107353432,
-0.0467126295,
0.0185176842,
-0.0120122433,
0.1146229878,
-0.0442209579,
0.0050728833,
0.0295157842,
-0.0460278094,
-0.0310129374,
-0.0248891283,
0.0070437598,
-0.0021131157,
0.0165501833,
0.0239499658,
-0.0003031561,
0.0151485382,
-0.0788011625,
-0.0311194789,
0.056854438,
0.0004440894,
-0.0087966733,
-0.0062679104,
-0.0187113509,
0.0131163877,
-0.0028981662,
0.0027148447,
2.490262742e-34,
0.0189743303,
0.0113635762,
0.0035953219,
0.0740077421,
0.0368301794,
-0.0586919375,
-0.0477288105,
-0.0293306336,
0.0627236962,
-0.086116299,
0.0135874283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14429v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14429v1 | Biomedical Entity Linking with Triple-aware Pre-Training | 2023-08-28T09:06:28 | 2023-08-28T09:06:28 | Xi Yan, Cedric Möller, Ricardo Usbeck | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Linking biomedical entities is an essential aspect in biomedical natural
language processing tasks, such as text mining and question answering. However,
a difficulty of linking the biomedical entities using current large language
models (LLM) trained on a general corpus is that biomedical entities are
scarcely distributed in texts and therefore have been rarely seen during
training by the LLM. At the same time, those LLMs are not aware of high level
semantic connection between different biomedical entities, which are useful in
identifying similar concepts in different textual contexts. To cope with
aforementioned problems, some recent works focused on injecting knowledge graph
information into LLMs. However, former methods either ignore the relational
knowledge of the entities or lead to catastrophic forgetting. Therefore, we
propose a novel framework to pre-train the powerful generative LLM by a corpus
synthesized from a KG. In the evaluations we are unable to confirm the benefit
of including synonym, description or relational information. | [
0.0685039088,
0.0076635336,
0.0280319117,
-0.0289374497,
0.0178358834,
0.0313305221,
-0.0368911177,
0.0053874599,
0.0539172515,
-0.0507883169,
-0.0234921537,
0.011897021,
-0.0302838404,
-0.0048881299,
0.0462847315,
-0.0040435628,
0.0627810657,
0.0553344861,
-0.0157897323,
-0.012836921,
-0.0295050312,
0.0295456946,
-0.002784282,
-0.0045041963,
0.0107957833,
0.0203833636,
0.0433038063,
-0.0077768741,
0.0486187935,
-0.0651794896,
-0.0407696702,
0.0262959655,
-0.0023294108,
0.0012928906,
0.0000015997,
-0.083236672,
-0.02084185,
0.030465588,
-0.0519084819,
-0.0134791657,
-0.0130373938,
-0.0224785432,
0.0243818499,
-0.0055099102,
-0.0381793268,
-0.0575414002,
0.0115120849,
0.0533900298,
0.0234236661,
0.0568177141,
-0.0034731254,
-0.0304556433,
0.0407616198,
-0.0285915807,
0.0269358493,
-0.0345538445,
0.0671933889,
0.0043297117,
0.0252207555,
0.0260963477,
-0.0048033386,
0.0345591679,
-0.0147801638,
0.0332502946,
0.0793926343,
0.0455449149,
-0.0241525173,
0.0201632287,
0.0150364665,
0.0755330846,
-0.0208467934,
-0.0293838959,
0.022660125,
0.0072856457,
-0.021251075,
0.03757542,
-0.0141011989,
-0.0254693571,
-0.0311498586,
0.0122258514,
0.0089316955,
-0.0249289833,
0.0594060831,
0.009133976,
-0.0289472118,
0.0213842914,
0.0247415248,
-0.0078278733,
0.0452708751,
0.036226362,
-0.0303287208,
-0.0247172192,
0.0187556911,
0.0407215841,
-0.0236006621,
0.0389616713,
-0.0205697622,
-0.0015087536,
0.0510628223,
-0.0738824978,
-0.0556895398,
-0.0107944384,
0.0173035711,
0.0661524832,
-0.0724722072,
-0.033071354,
-0.0406619981,
0.0221625697,
-0.027519552,
-0.0224700235,
-0.0570986159,
-0.0008359569,
-0.0329089351,
0.0391324945,
-0.0026024932,
-0.0063753449,
-0.0648175105,
0.0050276718,
0.0002282254,
0.0189272165,
0.0156051591,
0.0235015377,
-0.0070858626,
-0.0088758897,
-0.0468444824,
-0.0006657272,
-0.0199295711,
0.022831466,
-0.0683230534,
-0.0429839678,
-0.0072974041,
-0.0177529287,
0.0103906402,
-0.0472175255,
0.0195701346,
0.0541019142,
0.0279140137,
-0.0250000898,
-0.0412705727,
-0.0318550915,
0.0250181109,
-0.0328793079,
-0.0024423306,
-0.0415793806,
0.0546750017,
0.0028589861,
0.008496548,
-0.0420841277,
0.0387859605,
-0.0098150419,
-0.063902922,
0.0945148394,
-0.0646726862,
-0.0122377006,
0.01104654,
0.0377880447,
0.0221662391,
0.0144766066,
0.0175753944,
-0.0647187307,
0.0214308742,
0.0051495386,
-0.0555268899,
-0.0091972267,
0.0419330932,
-0.0408016331,
0.0333150625,
0.0040273685,
-0.0131610595,
0.0758887604,
0.0194418728,
0.0669226497,
-0.0204934385,
-0.0146854194,
-0.0136364177,
0.0327132754,
0.038475655,
0.0149358772,
0.0619719997,
-0.0325359963,
0.0233134534,
-0.0024368656,
-0.0159101747,
-0.0205549859,
-0.0284449831,
0.0221067909,
-0.017179694,
0.0536620282,
-0.0245367475,
0.0177243166,
0.0025155819,
0.0061422363,
-0.0228825789,
-0.0259604435,
0.0793400779,
0.0228493735,
-0.0227909591,
0.0480739102,
0.0774475411,
-0.0109182317,
0.0657383725,
-0.0176044423,
-0.0117978621,
0.0401123539,
0.0474221446,
-0.0166185591,
-0.0280491132,
-0.00491249,
-0.0424787514,
0.0004516896,
0.0174187217,
-0.0574704558,
-0.0003580088,
-0.0300163683,
-0.0225555208,
0.0277543738,
-0.0107049365,
-0.0039437725,
0.0334993936,
0.0451885201,
0.0167223159,
-0.0387311876,
0.0446578115,
0.052958902,
-0.0601300783,
-0.0070246537,
-0.0302963164,
-0.0057577286,
0.0254880935,
0.0506217144,
0.0035748619,
0.0164572652,
0.058331538,
-0.0465086326,
-0.0374828316,
0.0009504179,
0.0008599075,
-0.0677807927,
0.036424119,
-0.0120156566,
-0.0184480604,
-0.0414552279,
-0.0354213193,
-0.0415505394,
-0.0224989876,
-0.0005854594,
0.1037597582,
-0.0105670234,
0.0204113442,
0.0392012894,
-0.0138131538,
-0.0482304618,
0.0810865462,
-0.0174530726,
0.0256320089,
-0.0030762642,
-0.0124945184,
-0.0104453824,
-0.0009952571,
-0.0434386916,
0.0105621871,
0.0476603322,
-0.0118055949,
-0.0090099098,
-0.0357589982,
-0.0904113129,
-0.0100843608,
-0.0886367708,
0.0429427624,
0.0316420831,
0.0387165584,
0.0047084419,
0.0203166455,
-0.0002985566,
-0.0138188386,
-0.0231543705,
0.0193691924,
-0.0022691137,
-0.0048721111,
0.0278073419,
0.0251049604,
0.0146254469,
-0.008396727,
0.0004603484,
-0.0427475087,
0.0446126163,
0.0326076187,
-0.0607169829,
0.0075984849,
0.0638370141,
-0.047177732,
0.0132567808,
-0.0005299131,
0.0060777157,
-0.0242934506,
0.0206398182,
0.03415538,
0.0384596586,
-0.0195043515,
0.0139632495,
0.0359917805,
0.0136845978,
-0.033959046,
0.0186045747,
-0.0588802025,
-0.0119487718,
-0.0279027577,
-0.0028368759,
-0.0092343604,
0.0316815637,
0.0042377482,
-0.0446925685,
-0.0163125545,
-0.0092146341,
0.0029874013,
0.0056943847,
-0.0200550705,
0.0289330278,
0.008328733,
-0.0210880246,
-0.0012479041,
-0.0066025564,
0.0773980767,
-0.0071356357,
0.0325742327,
-0.0269318242,
-0.0121017592,
-0.026768595,
0.018959308,
0.0089703696,
0.0185750052,
-0.0099660689,
-0.0149717806,
-0.0244972408,
0.0389148071,
-0.0033810567,
-0.0211403687,
0.0061718128,
-0.0153140798,
0.0563786067,
0.0244241003,
0.0049790866,
-0.0347833559,
0.019617429,
-0.0514562465,
0.0224212427,
0.0074491478,
-0.0035800566,
-0.0246145576,
0.0195166711,
0.011700402,
0.0211629272,
0.0406404622,
-0.0400299244,
-0.0113345468,
0.0272592958,
0.0339162387,
-0.0132430829,
0.0221574642,
0.0092467275,
0.0030944999,
0.0630514696,
0.0090408046,
-0.0189340319,
0.0018737556,
0.0019075926,
-0.0029145794,
-0.0744210929,
-0.020028485,
-0.0192732718,
-0.008617972,
-0.0187594034,
0.0048905369,
0.0979093686,
0.0377421528,
-0.0450239591,
0.018971283,
0.0336695388,
-0.03989641,
0.0120639959,
0.0197197292,
-0.0947068408,
-0.0282012392,
-0.0367387943,
-0.0306252073,
-0.0090209087,
-0.0823980942,
0.0035962088,
-0.0919373482,
-0.0219931845,
-0.0034836489,
-0.0079670073,
-0.0253461525,
-0.0574025363,
0.006665837,
-0.0225019939,
-0.047140792,
-0.024299698,
-0.025250487,
0.0121079655,
0.0108540067,
0.0098068714,
-0.077551119,
0.0095942523,
-0.0595173985,
0.0472926274,
0.0364241004,
0.0397898667,
-0.0043285494,
0.0276509821,
0.007562384,
-0.0136751048,
-0.0138905542,
-0.0143004917,
0.0422931463,
-0.0376831479,
-0.0043013394,
-0.0533096455,
0.0122921504,
-0.0412316881,
-0.0397624783,
-0.0198534187,
0.0683772042,
-0.0070408094,
-0.0145137394,
-0.0158324484,
0.0053110947,
-0.0182429925,
0.0659681261,
-0.0201867409,
0.0085174665,
0.0219918992,
0.0284221806,
0.0554239154,
0.0247492976,
-0.0092810895,
0.0617225766,
-0.0772491172,
0.0042877155,
-0.0617521927,
-0.0197012089,
0.0641543195,
0.0135393161,
0.0116429143,
0.0653344691,
0.0377623215,
-0.0178515501,
-0.0694102719,
0.0655597895,
-0.0000834162,
-0.0140931066,
-0.0174157266,
-0.0517200083,
0.0750667155,
0.0091894697,
-0.0428049825,
-0.0066559953,
-0.0265072957,
-0.0472108573,
-0.0514306016,
0.0252110586,
0.0169523526,
0.0430218428,
-0.0136151928,
-0.0322922729,
0.0498755649,
0.0580963865,
-0.0454369821,
0.024316581,
-0.0306589007,
-0.0003302456,
-0.022270197,
0.0205431655,
-0.029432252,
0.0037340112,
0.0172872208,
0.0576485917,
-0.0410277545,
-0.0491509177,
0.0058558267,
0.0398721024,
0.039241422,
-0.0380918905,
0.0437880754,
-0.0589911267,
0.0076315482,
0.0036250791,
0.0052976636,
-0.0351038538,
-0.0123963533,
0.0520523302,
0.0287400782,
-0.0201629121,
0.0031517285,
-0.0156094423,
0.0323561504,
0.0006799962,
0.0020210606,
0.0149857309,
-0.0146244168,
0.0539833978,
-0.0234799478,
-0.0097136544,
0.0017688595,
0.0165716279,
-0.0020425385,
-0.0471106134,
0.0221968889,
0.02049735,
0.0166567806,
-0.0167087968,
0.0203214288,
-0.0424410366,
-0.0084861973,
-0.0297728162,
0.0162026361,
0.05816954,
0.0025367332,
0.0304816291,
-0.0150054116,
-0.0324179605,
-0.0045609958,
0.0290499013,
-0.0443743877,
0.0126368804,
0.074335739,
0.0098310811,
-0.0256498698,
0.0099706165,
0.0689724535,
0.021335952,
0.0990577489,
0.0120792948,
-0.0604526475,
-0.0254037529,
-0.039757356,
0.0094213672,
0.0282257833,
-0.0379531123,
0.0404019617,
-0.0604175217,
-0.0697002187,
0.0302045681,
-0.0208987612,
-0.055341851,
0.008562969,
0.0681723431,
-0.0000197501,
0.0368364044,
-0.0347338542,
-0.0025521896,
0.0126715535,
-0.030377768,
-0.0272657257,
0.0221641175,
-5.623454404e-33,
-0.0377909541,
-0.0462890156,
0.0223787632,
-0.0390170887,
-0.0381382406,
0.0246514156,
-0.0176608916,
-0.0344619974,
-0.040982727,
0.0320865177,
-0.0031766349,
0.0139282774,
-0.0092214635,
0.0074074571,
-0.0467414968,
-0.0167134609,
0.0125856241,
0.0242279172,
0.014249553,
0.0178650469,
0.0302231628,
0.0748279467,
0.0700236559,
-0.0539352372,
-0.0112941954,
0.0115801664,
0.009210065,
0.0171630941,
-0.0055959043,
0.0575407669,
-0.0464119054,
0.0316514261,
0.0247652251,
0.0018303456,
0.0127897328,
-0.0006133957,
-0.1525423378,
-0.0453749001,
0.0276483223,
-0.0060731103,
-0.0034622031,
-0.0259611793,
0.0353412442,
-0.0118330168,
0.0285480563,
-0.0243776832,
0.0403513238,
-0.0087961163,
-0.0665047839,
-0.0764294043,
-0.0547419563,
0.0383083224,
0.0264915582,
0.0416045897,
-0.0101549895,
-0.0739789754,
-0.0159946401,
0.0204866193,
-0.0162635613,
-0.0126560768,
0.0045003612,
-0.0057301037,
-0.0190282464,
-0.0156423356,
0.0314364247,
0.0580617338,
-0.0012278931,
-0.0379583798,
-0.0453236215,
0.0358288698,
-0.0156562123,
0.0068731457,
-0.006820919,
0.039100375,
0.003195374,
-0.0060840282,
-0.1215877533,
0.0279502161,
-0.0420990139,
0.0426854566,
-0.0276144035,
-0.0270239357,
-0.0010458648,
-0.0051956861,
-0.0464010127,
0.0066992138,
0.0038898708,
-0.0318242982,
-0.0087476932,
-0.0211452208,
-0.0003540597,
0.0432844572,
-0.0227600243,
-0.0407010205,
-0.0010913521,
0.031807404,
0.0472700372,
0.0213643592,
-0.0364157185,
0.0193757005,
-0.0843808651,
-0.0275961868,
0.0300608445,
-0.0406563543,
0.0391122736,
0.0107707828,
0.0204204079,
-0.0440558307,
-0.0390483476,
-0.0134151736,
-0.0066890409,
-0.0328241326,
-0.0100729652,
0.0080590593,
0.0309388004,
0.0518139713,
0.0234136209,
0.0476004258,
0.0546224676,
0.0123272808,
-0.0023350706,
0.0206049811,
0.0404561609,
0.0276458655,
-0.0243326593,
-0.0025090536,
-0.0265203528,
0.0295348037,
0.0328071676,
-0.0828934833,
-0.0062429956,
-0.0121993944,
2.59e-7,
0.0986763388,
0.0118410392,
0.0057371585,
-0.0079768021,
0.0003596076,
-0.0040887799,
0.040447101,
0.0370399244,
-0.0345218889,
0.0036867582,
0.0295228381,
0.0221418869,
-0.034100581,
0.0263056681,
-0.0862175152,
-0.0090850005,
-0.0523739271,
-0.050169453,
-0.0216014963,
-0.0357418358,
0.0200971104,
0.0572038703,
0.0229529031,
-0.0040264116,
-0.0151893795,
-0.0613144487,
0.063743934,
-0.0166902766,
-0.0040679532,
0.0637074187,
0.020821061,
0.036366377,
-0.0161934737,
0.090807572,
-0.0371396467,
0.0094298366,
0.0201726165,
0.056641195,
-0.0347102098,
0.0164972134,
0.0328911729,
-0.0569925085,
0.0254420266,
0.0122982822,
0.0603298731,
-0.0652154237,
-0.0247514807,
0.0323540196,
0.0007193504,
-0.0195737462,
0.0190452356,
-0.0236799791,
0.0043131141,
0.019105738,
0.0285787135,
0.0257733855,
-0.0226060618,
-0.1099122167,
0.0321045779,
0.0558985509,
-0.0248152781,
-0.0773796961,
0.0439230576,
-0.0238622725,
0.031233035,
-0.0677142814,
0.0244642813,
2.124059288e-34,
0.0021557633,
0.0190082528,
-0.0081661865,
0.0333283916,
0.0339829102,
-0.0294563007,
-0.0190624185,
-0.0007539256,
0.017635297,
-0.0949975923,
0.0185440555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14423v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14423v2 | GADePo: Graph-Assisted Declarative Pooling Transformers for Document-Level Relation Extraction | 2023-08-28T09:04:03 | 2024-06-18T09:28:04 | Andrei C. Coman, Christos Theodoropoulos, Marie-Francine Moens, James Henderson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level relation extraction typically relies on text-based encoders
and hand-coded pooling heuristics to aggregate information learned by the
encoder. In this paper, we leverage the intrinsic graph processing capabilities
of the Transformer model and propose replacing hand-coded pooling methods with
new tokens in the input, which are designed to aggregate information via
explicit graph relations in the computation of attention weights. We introduce
a joint text-graph Transformer model and a graph-assisted declarative pooling
(GADePo) specification of the input, which provides explicit and high-level
instructions for information aggregation. GADePo allows the pooling process to
be guided by domain-specific knowledge or desired outcomes but still learned by
the Transformer, leading to more flexible and customisable pooling strategies.
We evaluate our method across diverse datasets and models and show that our
approach yields promising results that are consistently better than those
achieved by the hand-coded pooling functions. | [
0.0184532832,
0.0279574469,
0.0161889587,
0.0461670905,
0.0041707405,
0.0251274463,
-0.0138328038,
-0.0407710522,
0.0332254954,
-0.0379990339,
-0.012261223,
-0.0143802576,
0.0175819732,
0.0217767898,
0.0141298519,
-0.0215039775,
0.0000697384,
0.0322826244,
0.0085870493,
0.0234246533,
0.0230449457,
0.025871288,
0.0324959271,
-0.0145055391,
-0.0180882979,
-0.0221147034,
-0.0048627285,
0.0216701068,
0.0087700058,
-0.0357727595,
-0.0047985991,
0.0203398503,
0.0252469238,
-0.0094417967,
0.0000017841,
-0.0336284712,
-0.0525653511,
0.0012169116,
-0.0086130369,
-0.0545323342,
0.0160409641,
-0.0899787396,
0.0370102152,
-0.002024709,
-0.0184757169,
-0.0705359057,
0.0286890045,
0.0451462977,
0.039373491,
0.0692192838,
-0.0410637856,
-0.0541476198,
0.0614931583,
-0.0306959338,
-0.0228781961,
-0.0694074407,
0.0328147113,
0.0212391019,
-0.0128280446,
-0.0342609622,
-0.0412809402,
-0.0041818833,
0.0283360463,
-0.0255040321,
0.0927006155,
0.0509175882,
-0.0206536427,
0.0046716412,
-0.022028137,
0.1116931215,
-0.0146727134,
-0.0138409622,
0.0001011225,
-0.0044317069,
0.0180225037,
0.0427957736,
-0.0404591821,
-0.0095964037,
-0.032777641,
0.0174897946,
-0.0392018743,
0.0129607758,
0.028502468,
-0.0162154343,
-0.0373895429,
0.0324962065,
-0.0185030792,
-0.0414055176,
0.0658896342,
0.0385224372,
0.0092302412,
-0.0394785143,
0.0280137155,
0.064708218,
0.023576282,
0.0041380366,
-0.0175757799,
-0.0299352761,
-0.0283434261,
-0.0359100997,
0.0085813804,
-0.0099824574,
-0.0004583178,
0.063964434,
-0.0089805052,
0.0333465002,
-0.057476908,
0.0325186849,
-0.0453227796,
-0.028813323,
-0.0255852118,
0.0219275691,
-0.0770812184,
0.0379988998,
-0.0096884677,
-0.042547591,
-0.0202414114,
0.0469128713,
0.0160065163,
-0.0106635187,
0.0144560775,
0.0115030976,
0.0041045649,
-0.002566901,
0.0167700127,
0.0282258336,
-0.009099083,
-0.0135861551,
0.0016756132,
0.0029012447,
-0.0333887935,
-0.0205524322,
0.0609928779,
-0.045698218,
-0.0076209991,
0.0960736796,
0.0094561568,
-0.039340917,
0.0194556639,
-0.0254205428,
0.0079929447,
-0.0563955791,
0.0310657993,
-0.0243415628,
0.0907912478,
0.042425476,
-0.0093046324,
-0.0434806161,
0.0182120018,
-0.0032507032,
-0.0512611903,
0.0316345133,
-0.0054622828,
-0.0163239967,
-0.0121574095,
-0.0316680335,
-0.0151419276,
0.0672487989,
0.0514091216,
0.0419967212,
0.0133518893,
0.0050052693,
0.0006938078,
0.0043477295,
0.0439466685,
-0.0077848509,
0.026606001,
0.0070916698,
-0.0273295809,
-0.0238179937,
0.0350412242,
0.0194188375,
-0.0482010245,
-0.0206754338,
0.0175368097,
0.034693487,
0.0129277613,
0.0513567068,
0.0080175688,
0.0078137098,
-0.0024933184,
0.0174363554,
-0.0643767864,
0.0370682403,
0.0155168641,
0.0313380323,
-0.0262859296,
0.0150847584,
-0.0144729977,
0.0070405556,
-0.0085080285,
-0.0072848406,
0.0486399829,
-0.0034129866,
0.0645559132,
0.0392794237,
-0.0454321727,
0.0727492273,
0.0245756935,
-0.0450256281,
0.0006188512,
0.0422491394,
-0.0423873626,
0.0503806062,
0.0409510881,
-0.0111490488,
-0.0480264239,
-0.0127893984,
0.0035110288,
0.0066568879,
0.0042473907,
-0.0038319207,
0.0019011905,
-0.0646606833,
-0.0738258883,
-0.0076898327,
-0.0378568619,
0.0130252512,
0.0210344475,
-0.0284996331,
0.0219257195,
-0.040509183,
-0.0217990987,
0.0119772321,
0.0286924969,
-0.0242386796,
-0.0076003158,
0.004912294,
0.0166178457,
0.0090688849,
0.0218710247,
0.0232651792,
0.0495530702,
-0.0081347404,
-0.0299416333,
-0.0000613442,
-0.0436390713,
-0.0360350236,
0.0178471524,
-0.0362106226,
-0.0577949174,
-0.0203508213,
-0.0462773629,
-0.0273527931,
0.0002030721,
-0.0657492653,
0.0795132369,
0.0150245717,
-0.0008466613,
0.0249660648,
0.0208298191,
0.0140868053,
0.1006557271,
-0.023583835,
-0.0309300534,
-0.0064600995,
-0.0112740127,
-0.0299197678,
-0.011831169,
0.030824421,
-0.0026534351,
-0.00211558,
-0.0119085787,
0.0295171142,
-0.0069678957,
-0.0555037856,
-0.0101154651,
-0.0762761533,
0.0224505775,
-0.0120525807,
0.0353972279,
0.0245861877,
0.0273625571,
0.0069378028,
-0.0330487043,
-0.0451268256,
0.018777417,
-0.033919353,
0.0129888626,
0.0435638689,
-0.0234604292,
0.0209829807,
-0.0059574344,
-0.0550766401,
-0.0307711251,
0.0819251537,
0.0308879912,
-0.0352541953,
0.0084345667,
0.0286598317,
-0.0229338072,
0.0321217999,
-0.0115669472,
-0.0043880683,
-0.0143436529,
-0.0133872917,
0.0124486564,
0.0405815132,
-0.0093934378,
0.0738144144,
0.019345697,
-0.0088176522,
-0.0048424318,
0.0399409607,
-0.0594771467,
0.0166776292,
-0.0070814574,
0.0277243033,
-0.0137309134,
0.0399559289,
-0.0195446759,
0.0150011983,
-0.0124309417,
-0.0342725143,
0.0428781137,
0.0364022702,
-0.0016663751,
-0.021977853,
0.0079608615,
-0.0385948904,
-0.071045503,
-0.0055650771,
0.0834031627,
-0.0063721277,
-0.0370781608,
-0.0247083455,
0.0115008857,
-0.0759636164,
0.0409386493,
0.0206452534,
0.0139440671,
-0.0095865047,
-0.0397707298,
-0.001880282,
0.0034981407,
0.0133832144,
-0.0163521133,
0.0522173196,
0.0270225778,
0.047789894,
-0.0317434743,
-0.0120584192,
-0.0412794724,
0.005669646,
-0.0256112572,
0.0255733486,
0.0272089448,
-0.0251948964,
-0.0415688865,
-0.0020735841,
0.0121670133,
0.013977441,
-0.0186979547,
-0.0242434256,
-0.0175813157,
0.0762787685,
0.0442913324,
0.0177788511,
0.0112297656,
-0.0113793509,
0.0241593253,
0.0784205943,
0.013534816,
-0.0220194273,
-0.0051363725,
0.0157237034,
-0.0169430394,
-0.026542794,
0.0525527559,
-0.0403654724,
0.0103124734,
-0.0828178227,
-0.0159461945,
0.0709058866,
0.0151082091,
-0.0788295791,
-0.0142066749,
0.0509485081,
-0.0004796441,
0.0288168974,
-0.0043621585,
-0.0823674053,
-0.0276711546,
-0.0187999383,
-0.017459942,
0.0512184724,
-0.0383848585,
-0.0219448823,
-0.0692466646,
-0.0078494279,
0.0309736878,
-0.0356159247,
0.0037722322,
-0.0747067332,
0.0146722291,
-0.000224809,
-0.0194466226,
-0.0091091115,
-0.0398693122,
-0.0280449148,
-0.0128293168,
0.0031253961,
-0.0110339578,
0.0006267515,
0.0281488691,
-0.0669910163,
-0.0013201744,
0.0334642492,
0.0120834438,
-0.0134432875,
0.0716125593,
-0.0508118495,
-0.0383660607,
-0.0094594276,
0.0851912498,
-0.0559648946,
0.010987672,
-0.0514151566,
0.0099631092,
-0.077171348,
0.0024138212,
-0.0560348853,
0.0775065869,
0.0178169739,
-0.0195453279,
-0.0018270063,
-0.0377550311,
-0.0122925323,
0.0122503778,
0.0389005579,
0.0198397879,
-0.0371256322,
-0.0113662314,
0.0268773157,
-0.0478173718,
-0.018265985,
0.0091490233,
-0.038702555,
-0.027859794,
-0.0414008684,
-0.0536844693,
0.0454189479,
-0.0052309344,
-0.0317720287,
-0.0356445611,
0.0971496254,
-0.0389247537,
-0.0873793811,
0.0279785898,
-0.0193070527,
0.005430528,
0.013183658,
-0.0194670632,
0.0152664185,
0.0187433735,
-0.0059654652,
0.0144203575,
-0.0689899325,
-0.0566974804,
-0.0364453048,
-0.0228306111,
0.0095741227,
0.0533948131,
-0.0484195016,
0.0454792082,
0.0483100973,
0.0242999233,
-0.0725138932,
-0.0256822594,
0.0165859517,
-0.0377754532,
0.0001849789,
0.0182167757,
-0.0689545721,
0.0280837379,
0.0111864535,
0.002079691,
-0.0539030805,
-0.0285388231,
0.0201877728,
0.0059484267,
0.0431401394,
0.0274227988,
0.0250184219,
-0.002495294,
0.0362877883,
-0.0096476786,
-0.0027781266,
-0.0389330946,
-0.0013687029,
-0.0130840233,
-0.0098274536,
0.0182761084,
0.0231494736,
0.0078195669,
0.0033631031,
-0.013023315,
-0.0115390094,
-0.0097053368,
-0.0184844639,
0.0158544853,
-0.0005048758,
-0.0229052231,
-0.0215132833,
0.0150464475,
0.0194794536,
-0.0013638509,
0.0199593119,
0.0207800101,
-0.0167463701,
-0.0479194298,
0.0033827138,
-0.0852197856,
0.0165405106,
-0.0344213471,
0.006246184,
0.0346453898,
-0.0134909013,
0.0454087891,
0.0185744911,
0.0056753177,
0.0098534049,
0.0214312412,
-0.0306308456,
-0.0298861656,
0.003176511,
0.0375364646,
-0.0064734314,
0.0277840588,
0.055594258,
0.0075697796,
0.018335646,
0.0110555654,
-0.0392925665,
-0.0387785435,
-0.0488051809,
-0.0264375992,
0.028089894,
0.0032915687,
-0.0022794895,
-0.0654423088,
-0.0699930191,
0.0168962311,
-0.0370558798,
0.0024734365,
0.0203347672,
0.0199335571,
-0.002268886,
0.0208386406,
-0.0482054539,
-0.0225498043,
0.0699749589,
-0.0365074314,
-0.0061805989,
-0.0116278445,
-5.955381683e-33,
-0.0371514894,
-0.0790909454,
-0.0050361869,
0.0151474336,
-0.0809650272,
0.0447458886,
-0.0458299555,
-0.0504592583,
-0.008175238,
0.0226022601,
-0.0147035588,
0.0296514835,
-0.0045529078,
0.006729716,
-0.0206000656,
-0.0188350119,
0.0317344815,
0.0231660083,
-0.0079929158,
0.0496259294,
0.0549977608,
0.0401074104,
0.0498960502,
-0.0631683692,
0.0221116729,
-0.0284522492,
0.014213738,
0.0070675751,
0.0498962142,
0.0434268489,
-0.0053804936,
0.007910056,
0.0340540521,
-0.0065588709,
-0.021453321,
0.0537674613,
-0.1357967556,
-0.0361883119,
-0.0141893113,
0.0137423817,
-0.0118417731,
-0.0088839671,
0.0609912574,
0.0252437107,
0.0786973909,
-0.0968460515,
0.0328628942,
-0.0024155998,
-0.0374489054,
-0.0523924157,
-0.0282145664,
0.0189439338,
0.0026841417,
-0.0009136779,
0.0255826898,
-0.0083809076,
0.0223910417,
0.0146763679,
-0.0382458456,
-0.0302513316,
-0.0166235119,
-0.0044273101,
0.0056807916,
0.0230906922,
0.0118630994,
0.0412509665,
-0.0382678881,
-0.0106705744,
-0.0412824266,
0.0126262968,
-0.0126873981,
0.0715652928,
-0.0193459094,
-0.0250807125,
0.0290032532,
0.0279345401,
-0.0928884819,
0.0144784702,
-0.0131136905,
0.0954387784,
-0.0463848561,
0.0293843206,
-0.0005335144,
-0.0215653665,
0.039008569,
0.0392370634,
-0.0226708893,
-0.0145710818,
-0.0213386267,
-0.0025486774,
-0.0258395188,
0.0705834329,
-0.0080593769,
-0.0368975624,
-0.0111719714,
0.0957262665,
0.0191357266,
0.0445196256,
0.0034662096,
-0.0147985686,
-0.0247351844,
-0.0106874146,
0.0037079919,
0.0202506222,
0.0028581335,
0.0481911264,
0.0816154033,
0.0038384944,
-0.0328609683,
-0.0209940299,
-0.0415106975,
-0.0178433042,
-0.0384605005,
0.0355421975,
0.0208032075,
0.0679586455,
-0.0200853702,
0.038968619,
0.0296480972,
0.0480684973,
-0.0367022157,
0.0779282376,
0.03304106,
0.071173422,
0.0099184224,
-0.0207191054,
-0.0105347615,
0.0333340615,
0.0656802654,
-0.0377417542,
-0.013084827,
-0.0038729017,
2.558e-7,
0.0545794517,
0.0258332882,
0.1078134328,
0.0030075307,
0.0047853435,
0.0097184945,
0.0030764863,
0.0623987429,
0.024583118,
-0.0117911194,
0.0277106054,
0.0441475511,
-0.0114820581,
0.0573963597,
-0.0718871579,
0.0185483284,
-0.0776642859,
-0.0611434691,
-0.0254959501,
-0.0169505849,
0.0583770052,
0.0456671156,
0.0309189893,
0.0015028981,
-0.0399921536,
-0.0318008438,
0.0823521838,
0.026735235,
0.015267943,
0.0207809024,
-0.02851668,
0.003776859,
-0.0306679998,
0.0256125666,
-0.0219769087,
0.0476681963,
0.0192882884,
0.0419577509,
-0.0609585829,
-0.0075801988,
-0.0063844351,
-0.0457360297,
0.0027322832,
0.0189965293,
0.0439676046,
-0.0668407455,
0.0022975686,
-0.0425705388,
-0.0397396646,
0.0179945063,
-0.014451934,
0.0551411174,
-0.0074105859,
0.0497670211,
0.0181190707,
-0.0181527194,
0.0101335282,
-0.0804112777,
-0.0041715172,
0.0413885489,
0.0140210772,
-0.022361258,
-0.0035358558,
-0.0282375775,
0.0283038113,
0.0009526448,
0.0010420595,
2.233875485e-34,
0.0272671003,
0.0210013501,
0.0043122689,
0.0471737422,
0.0223795976,
-0.0886963308,
-0.0490931496,
0.0228379816,
0.0183420572,
-0.090554297,
0.0139954351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14391v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14391v2 | FIRE: Food Image to REcipe generation | 2023-08-28T08:14:20 | 2024-05-12T18:45:52 | Prateek Chhikara, Dhiraj Chaurasia, Yifan Jiang, Omkar Masur, Filip Ilievski | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Food computing has emerged as a prominent multidisciplinary field of research
in recent years. An ambitious goal of food computing is to develop end-to-end
intelligent systems capable of autonomously producing recipe information for a
food image. Current image-to-recipe methods are retrieval-based and their
success depends heavily on the dataset size and diversity, as well as the
quality of learned embeddings. Meanwhile, the emergence of powerful
attention-based vision and language models presents a promising avenue for
accurate and generalizable recipe generation, which has yet to be extensively
explored. This paper proposes FIRE, a novel multimodal methodology tailored to
recipe generation in the food computing domain, which generates the food title,
ingredients, and cooking instructions based on input food images. FIRE
leverages the BLIP model to generate titles, utilizes a Vision Transformer with
a decoder for ingredient extraction, and employs the T5 model to generate
recipes incorporating titles and ingredients as inputs. We showcase two
practical applications that can benefit from integrating FIRE with large
language model prompting: recipe customization to fit recipes to user
preferences and recipe-to-code transformation to enable automated cooking
processes. Our experimental findings validate the efficacy of our proposed
approach, underscoring its potential for future advancements and widespread
adoption in food computing. | [
0.0220566634,
0.0593340918,
0.0162712876,
0.003850973,
0.0010625351,
0.0026538689,
-0.0301762018,
0.0372896306,
0.0043431902,
-0.028463155,
-0.0229422823,
-0.0117796138,
-0.0092321001,
0.0869582444,
-0.0057026753,
-0.0568064153,
0.0063643772,
0.0350080468,
-0.029745711,
0.0454146266,
0.0054057026,
-0.0213904418,
0.027922241,
0.0218159426,
-0.0630889088,
0.0248007476,
-0.0468530171,
0.0429948233,
0.0049599232,
-0.0239004623,
-0.0142830312,
0.0638793036,
-0.017871011,
-0.0072873444,
0.0000017407,
0.0177585147,
0.0183299482,
-0.0095531754,
0.0121748215,
0.0089489277,
0.0369202085,
-0.0018774284,
-0.0131188072,
-0.0184184406,
-0.034529116,
0.0167579893,
0.108294785,
0.037215732,
0.0255912039,
0.0280992091,
0.0035116964,
-0.1411375999,
-0.0132203791,
0.0416938476,
0.0758598521,
0.0453852601,
-0.0133931311,
-0.0365867317,
0.0234501474,
0.0007242538,
-0.0171773806,
0.0624165535,
0.0454225577,
0.009455896,
0.0102899913,
0.0647456422,
-0.0188755915,
-0.0722455308,
-0.02131005,
0.0436035693,
-0.0248590931,
0.0028039694,
-0.0303970762,
0.0231357291,
-0.0263911709,
-0.0210247859,
-0.0336909145,
-0.0253332593,
-0.0104637807,
0.0433738977,
-0.0626695007,
-0.0173749831,
0.0313794091,
-0.0237058513,
0.0398360826,
0.0351383016,
0.0149886133,
-0.0150570618,
-0.0476480238,
0.0174332894,
0.0176042523,
-0.0745696947,
-0.0004953193,
0.0543158725,
0.0234201513,
0.0214224663,
-0.0362213328,
-0.0035383005,
-0.0137636494,
-0.003333752,
0.0685120523,
0.0280266088,
-0.0585927926,
0.0261574425,
-0.0147377448,
0.0293422565,
-0.0387005694,
0.0227740668,
-0.095068112,
0.0118036577,
-0.055161234,
-0.0230333451,
-0.0130459191,
-0.0135263614,
-0.0205467362,
-0.02849387,
-0.0236106031,
0.0100660007,
0.0023379854,
-0.0066382056,
-0.0184516329,
0.0836298764,
-0.0310737379,
0.0232982617,
-0.0710351989,
0.0278810635,
0.0116993291,
-0.0246818829,
0.0168698877,
0.0246702228,
-0.0123003414,
-0.0158303753,
0.0101309484,
0.0403707027,
0.0313110277,
0.0375450589,
-0.0404695123,
-0.0442814119,
-0.0126231583,
-0.0152862044,
-0.0534940846,
-0.0404809192,
0.0502107069,
-0.0574824177,
0.0353072882,
-0.0179455299,
0.0081042442,
-0.0118585229,
0.0578647032,
0.0594104454,
-0.0594564937,
0.0797339007,
0.0596374013,
-0.0071900436,
0.0176593326,
0.0172003675,
0.0010964968,
-0.0036500168,
0.0465351306,
0.0548608117,
0.0053193639,
0.002101097,
0.0568378456,
0.0070715384,
-0.0087695895,
0.029960867,
-0.0533618256,
0.0064485781,
0.0050954386,
0.0041979426,
-0.0173708573,
0.0559827201,
0.00320523,
0.0261666682,
0.1145458966,
0.0508950129,
0.0069574192,
0.0525173135,
0.0345848314,
-0.003932754,
0.0004465459,
-0.0040494255,
-0.0190050416,
0.0869739279,
-0.0730270147,
-0.006447799,
0.0065423083,
-0.0251833368,
-0.0464314967,
-0.0436857417,
0.0140304472,
-0.0426453836,
0.0675017089,
-0.0036313075,
0.0489291176,
0.0100330245,
-0.0269389469,
-0.0103034182,
-0.0380019881,
-0.0480775088,
0.0093333311,
0.0004376817,
0.044737637,
0.085710302,
0.018665012,
-0.005707589,
0.0371101126,
0.0267222095,
0.0168135557,
0.0157006942,
-0.0140805198,
-0.0001314633,
0.0228939131,
-0.0157982837,
-0.058475554,
-0.041475039,
0.0333476439,
-0.0422606952,
-0.0015332068,
-0.0229154583,
0.0070172949,
0.027503306,
-0.028766891,
0.022591494,
0.028370278,
-0.0253383815,
0.0208190829,
0.009357349,
-0.0331632346,
-0.0092623839,
0.0507531799,
0.0327335112,
-0.0024752498,
-0.045080293,
0.0039008677,
0.0322525315,
0.0377484411,
-0.0004803353,
-0.0047192262,
-0.0680168644,
0.0066330559,
-0.0086926548,
-0.0156509392,
-0.0395152718,
0.0419415683,
-0.052597221,
-0.0270675141,
-0.0141379079,
-0.0111448122,
0.0349808335,
0.0171310026,
-0.0065265079,
0.0687625855,
-0.024265293,
-0.0048490344,
-0.0433115214,
0.0065347259,
-0.0278754663,
-0.0021690698,
0.0222740583,
-0.0469431132,
0.0243409574,
0.0499582775,
0.0085085128,
0.0625865683,
-0.0539907813,
-0.0343381688,
-0.0571453907,
0.0012870202,
-0.0249956716,
-0.0495610684,
0.0111417547,
0.0367941223,
0.028467156,
-0.0232489631,
-0.0295231249,
0.0211706124,
-0.0465987585,
0.0194292888,
-0.0093301414,
0.0218930002,
0.0023102229,
-0.0361874811,
-0.0167153478,
0.031741973,
0.045330368,
0.0073849922,
0.0258654431,
-0.0504227318,
-0.0607462004,
-0.028973639,
0.0086447429,
0.0257747937,
-0.0302581564,
-0.0029267773,
-0.0031159483,
0.0205341242,
0.0655715913,
0.0029860856,
0.0069646356,
0.0475710444,
-0.0154597349,
-0.0327968374,
0.0115426676,
-0.0349837467,
0.0224608853,
0.0245765615,
-0.0458335206,
0.020718636,
0.0188483614,
-0.0054738792,
0.061390046,
-0.0469187573,
0.0463135019,
0.0267590135,
-0.0505558997,
-0.0223530214,
0.0431312881,
-0.0154007347,
0.0354256853,
-0.033862941,
-0.0705483481,
0.0463043563,
-0.0230362453,
0.0154231358,
0.0124095641,
0.0057548322,
-0.0021198103,
0.0403014235,
0.0286973584,
0.0458212793,
0.0125070466,
0.0252280086,
-0.0375622325,
0.040488258,
-0.0016579593,
-0.0722559988,
0.0752876624,
-0.0567034967,
-0.0464095548,
-0.0000453409,
-0.0194805786,
-0.0507181399,
0.0161432568,
0.0015007498,
0.0009025874,
0.0178215411,
0.0278821327,
-0.0613382198,
0.035766162,
0.0262584239,
0.0135431821,
0.0329916216,
-0.0485715903,
-0.0115528526,
0.0315725356,
0.0232979991,
-0.0080107227,
-0.0407428741,
-0.0148719437,
-0.0229164455,
0.0309398286,
0.0152221331,
-0.0355889499,
-0.0459316298,
0.0787402093,
0.0325206518,
0.0467036776,
-0.010193307,
0.0193392746,
0.0344792828,
-0.0208445098,
-0.0523498133,
0.0420787372,
0.0233797412,
-0.0557136387,
0.0205712598,
0.0382509343,
-0.0679691434,
0.0293353796,
0.0705841184,
-0.0882722437,
-0.0287607759,
-0.026717037,
0.0107154595,
-0.0542397015,
0.004364708,
-0.0430765375,
-0.0475684628,
0.0591975488,
-0.004290767,
-0.0531836823,
-0.0916721821,
-0.0081092697,
-0.0082299989,
0.0114767365,
-0.0131118717,
-0.0167662594,
-0.0237648245,
0.0056051956,
0.0014009543,
0.0398536436,
-0.0216029063,
0.0064737266,
-0.0619498789,
-0.0208812244,
0.1069047078,
0.0160990953,
0.0117847696,
-0.0312773287,
-0.0416112393,
0.0358487591,
0.0258817784,
-0.0184847098,
0.0223576147,
-0.0030186737,
-0.0172637235,
-0.0078194262,
0.0307181384,
-0.0082598748,
-0.0391881838,
-0.021078242,
0.0747260898,
0.0114443023,
-0.0129708229,
-0.0546326973,
-0.0428954847,
0.0404712521,
-0.0004701708,
0.0221020877,
-0.0201674346,
-0.0450329781,
-0.0454093553,
-0.0524531975,
-0.0439074039,
-0.0122633651,
0.0763642564,
-0.0593373068,
-0.0234676525,
-0.0590627268,
0.0163949281,
0.0015311602,
0.0261680651,
0.0036532583,
-0.0327484943,
-0.005120161,
0.0600213073,
-0.0387549214,
-0.0136979837,
0.0001874673,
-0.0219237376,
-0.0590015575,
-0.0328832269,
0.0287976172,
-0.0388032794,
0.0142688164,
0.0721513331,
-0.1113005355,
-0.0103178471,
-0.0310492925,
0.10825371,
0.0141842552,
0.0478876382,
-0.00117799,
-0.0248302687,
0.0254376326,
0.022021452,
0.025766639,
-0.024424091,
-0.0198547412,
-0.0450159349,
0.0359237045,
0.0026548214,
-0.0737740174,
0.0367322564,
0.0083965231,
0.0196727291,
-0.0014956144,
-0.0465381369,
0.0661780983,
-0.0388743132,
0.0113747586,
0.0106116291,
0.0134564005,
0.0009362461,
0.005677761,
0.0080390265,
-0.0336524211,
-0.061470516,
-0.0148284268,
0.0172631796,
0.0060061957,
-0.0003547828,
-0.0503202192,
-0.0096154828,
0.0109649701,
-0.0522710234,
-0.019924216,
0.0081697237,
0.0196813848,
-0.0058545037,
0.0159069784,
-0.0132041229,
0.06158676,
-0.048092369,
-0.0034431482,
-0.0150992097,
0.0387821272,
-0.0113188848,
0.0068048574,
-0.090282321,
0.0607323423,
-0.023182787,
-0.0106434813,
-0.0046637855,
-0.0327403061,
0.0502712876,
-0.0369506292,
0.0202663653,
-0.039080862,
-0.0021319487,
-0.0465235338,
0.0924847648,
-0.0111426525,
-0.0281600114,
0.0340826325,
0.0112292431,
0.0283119902,
-0.0071141645,
0.069578439,
-0.0427442752,
0.0249457713,
0.000168232,
-0.0067343484,
-0.0199356675,
0.0261483025,
0.0101223355,
0.0051562479,
-0.019635655,
-0.0513875596,
-0.0223004911,
-0.0319006406,
0.023226032,
0.0239141379,
0.010942434,
0.0058991211,
0.0464034118,
0.0604479574,
0.0102901338,
-0.0323409066,
0.0199550502,
0.0340615138,
-0.0316717178,
-0.0198860094,
0.0039820173,
-5.947484198e-33,
0.005177117,
-0.0566004626,
0.0371728688,
0.0375803448,
0.0030003779,
-0.0080112973,
-0.0389493182,
-0.0062455726,
0.0394877717,
-0.0069553582,
0.0199099276,
-0.0223266277,
-0.0020067382,
0.0325551517,
0.0361333452,
-0.0574695356,
0.0338032432,
0.0087473402,
-0.0175644159,
0.0027251807,
0.0180497281,
0.009882208,
0.0003895989,
-0.0008311629,
-0.0419142582,
0.0018858814,
0.0123750791,
-0.0252680983,
-0.0041942461,
0.0347626992,
-0.0631624833,
0.0467617512,
0.0009750637,
-0.0171473529,
-0.0226103365,
0.0335805528,
-0.0377565548,
-0.002640018,
-0.0584557503,
-0.0225417838,
-0.0863420814,
-0.0538647361,
0.0617212467,
-0.0033106185,
-0.0196568221,
0.0264672618,
0.0560718179,
-0.030931389,
-0.0140370792,
0.0045200158,
-0.0503690317,
0.0031413406,
-0.0020997659,
-0.0318511426,
0.0466374904,
0.0441449434,
0.0446923375,
-0.0019636971,
-0.0358877406,
0.0535189286,
-0.0060419696,
-0.0218731835,
0.0644408166,
0.0669093952,
0.0170055032,
0.0377834924,
0.0139628267,
-0.0247243624,
-0.003132425,
-0.0214304868,
-0.0180383418,
0.1207025796,
0.059675809,
-0.0068556909,
0.0254680496,
-0.004395924,
0.0010244776,
0.0034064043,
-0.0351297297,
-0.0182877723,
-0.0092162034,
0.0228525214,
0.0364729762,
0.0039770398,
0.0070414119,
-0.0265478622,
-0.0288702305,
-0.0440895557,
0.0168494154,
0.0293731298,
-0.0300328415,
-0.0168272257,
0.0136032142,
0.0379655063,
0.0680521578,
-0.0402795598,
0.0181903094,
0.0138078453,
-0.0103440918,
-0.0224450696,
-0.0613769703,
-0.0280420408,
0.0220492408,
0.009751902,
-0.0040009767,
0.024583824,
-0.0045076166,
0.0482085384,
0.0282439422,
-0.0169717688,
-0.0254108105,
-0.015812723,
0.0226445943,
-0.0028923301,
0.0350205936,
0.0005431492,
-0.0302287173,
0.0159387365,
-0.0277357139,
0.0195483789,
-0.0422859676,
-0.0234319903,
0.0519038588,
-0.0354964584,
-0.0168315694,
0.0164036378,
-0.083147347,
-0.0064420095,
0.013996412,
-0.0601051971,
-0.0066774543,
0.0560139902,
2.445e-7,
0.0359014124,
0.0249021817,
0.0118594961,
-0.0278642979,
-0.0117710084,
0.0328260548,
0.0202599932,
0.0601840243,
-0.0081098499,
-0.0085238852,
0.0133200726,
0.0027579018,
0.0116921635,
0.051716838,
0.0170969106,
-0.0094732782,
-0.0356810205,
0.0517461672,
-0.020773381,
0.0019275747,
0.0387616493,
0.0359138586,
0.0418779962,
-0.0171119161,
0.0069520795,
0.0158297196,
0.0841734856,
-0.0384456255,
0.0364180319,
-0.0509146862,
-0.0085417284,
0.0326859988,
0.0144003909,
-0.043814294,
-0.0353077687,
-0.0481260903,
0.0506840758,
-0.0000579676,
-0.0518267006,
-0.0292937607,
-0.013698875,
0.0252164565,
-0.0167935155,
-0.0846046135,
0.0433301628,
-0.1075306088,
0.0222876985,
0.0439328551,
0.0134698348,
0.0348350294,
-0.006345341,
-0.0126246838,
0.0170188025,
-0.014691093,
0.0170421321,
0.0081295576,
-0.0004553372,
-0.0310911033,
-0.0366324112,
-0.0253161062,
-0.0240516476,
0.0087460289,
-0.0415137447,
-0.0378761254,
-0.0367445946,
-0.0113985334,
-0.0669055656,
1.764076311e-34,
-0.0056959069,
0.029440552,
0.0119509613,
-0.0144137125,
0.0010883182,
0.0046198978,
-0.0206260588,
-0.0037455284,
0.0224813949,
-0.0725660771,
-0.0498075932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14359v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14359v3 | Effect of Attention and Self-Supervised Speech Embeddings on Non-Semantic Speech Tasks | 2023-08-28T07:11:27 | 2023-09-27T18:00:54 | Payal Mohapatra, Akash Pandey, Yueyuan Sui, Qi Zhu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Human emotion understanding is pivotal in making conversational technology
mainstream. We view speech emotion understanding as a perception task which is
a more realistic setting. With varying contexts (languages, demographics, etc.)
different share of people perceive the same speech segment as a non-unanimous
emotion. As part of the ACM Multimedia 2023 Computational Paralinguistics
ChallengE (ComParE) in the EMotion Share track, we leverage their rich dataset
of multilingual speakers and multi-label regression target of 'emotion share'
or perception of that emotion. We demonstrate that the training scheme of
different foundation models dictates their effectiveness for tasks beyond
speech recognition, especially for non-semantic speech tasks like emotion
understanding. This is a very complex task due to multilingual speakers,
variability in the target labels, and inherent imbalance in the regression
dataset. Our results show that HuBERT-Large with a self-attention-based
light-weight sequence model provides 4.6% improvement over the reported
baseline. | [
-0.0031776067,
0.067153208,
0.0019979177,
0.0306923706,
0.0173245519,
-0.014820924,
0.02959859,
-0.0623372197,
-0.0112211695,
-0.0247420911,
-0.0771922171,
-0.053614974,
-0.0081091672,
-0.0175342746,
0.0209510643,
-0.0662083775,
0.0246387646,
0.0490208119,
0.0271130577,
-0.0102443881,
0.0482020192,
0.0190825649,
-0.0066239648,
0.042746909,
-0.0757649466,
-0.0136772841,
-0.043784894,
0.0277728252,
0.0408126563,
-0.0062733018,
0.0088972738,
0.0879573822,
0.052449733,
0.0295319222,
0.0000018279,
-0.019840952,
0.0178968813,
-0.0154023021,
-0.0510748215,
0.0111566577,
0.0497422963,
0.0489877537,
-0.0136335194,
0.0185934678,
-0.0056734704,
0.022123225,
0.0331306644,
0.0586483851,
0.063111715,
0.0315339677,
-0.0165594835,
-0.0037011702,
-0.0189975072,
-0.0501060188,
0.0193049498,
-0.0240016431,
-0.0150398416,
-0.0033127824,
0.0074122949,
-0.0554398708,
-0.0445552617,
0.0401263051,
0.0260301922,
0.0200123433,
0.0400224067,
0.0143148396,
-0.0521591008,
-0.0619867966,
-0.013666031,
0.0980586931,
-0.0137912417,
0.0167992823,
-0.0131341992,
0.0255539194,
0.0272930004,
-0.0501298532,
-0.016570786,
0.0076265675,
0.0291815493,
0.0169332474,
-0.0022167102,
0.0695495531,
0.0073991967,
-0.0184999928,
-0.0316357538,
0.0444156639,
-0.0420447849,
-0.024795128,
0.0600386895,
-0.0022610861,
-0.0359529331,
-0.0061793178,
0.015976565,
-0.0222646613,
0.0171801504,
0.0038894978,
-0.0645265207,
-0.023960378,
-0.0072050979,
-0.063627772,
-0.0117302751,
0.0285529345,
-0.0536806434,
0.0518273227,
0.0381346866,
0.0475546233,
0.0147582907,
-0.0205749497,
-0.0153470421,
-0.0044642771,
-0.0249597393,
0.0498892516,
-0.0260763876,
0.0390803367,
-0.0365993977,
-0.0633887276,
-0.0681989193,
-0.0199661013,
-0.0503779873,
0.0115326736,
0.0271511916,
0.0118868351,
-0.0042314669,
0.0124685913,
0.0389431268,
0.0554803386,
-0.0188309718,
-0.0005983146,
0.0150535824,
-0.0851202607,
0.006698125,
0.026859181,
0.0290245749,
-0.0169672985,
0.0262732636,
0.0183205865,
0.0079366853,
-0.0516065061,
-0.0235399101,
-0.0162481591,
-0.0489300564,
-0.0661625192,
-0.0190038737,
-0.0347850136,
0.0224254057,
-0.0352164544,
0.0148771647,
-0.0126578109,
0.0265121926,
-0.0285563264,
-0.0089281825,
0.0591637976,
0.0461200103,
-0.0025003783,
-0.0023825844,
0.0226439536,
0.0188113376,
0.0715019554,
0.0241057724,
0.0380200073,
0.0502270684,
-0.0266283583,
0.0104181161,
0.0331736356,
0.0164937899,
-0.0206604246,
-0.0150705399,
-0.0233964659,
-0.0121572744,
0.0427985601,
0.0811086521,
0.0120996051,
-0.0206511281,
-0.077782236,
0.0779140815,
0.0686927661,
-0.0081928698,
0.0176204108,
-0.0000843562,
0.059480343,
-0.0094900206,
-0.0229223836,
-0.026231898,
0.0530241467,
-0.007587885,
0.001957617,
0.0567625389,
0.02766289,
-0.0564980283,
-0.0390427597,
-0.0094187614,
-0.0298057646,
-0.0033375996,
0.0360558927,
0.0304881185,
-0.0249026511,
-0.0504840873,
0.0311210323,
-0.0060661449,
-0.080294989,
0.0048880409,
0.0109301833,
0.0104998155,
0.0185841713,
-0.0461858995,
-0.0283465739,
-0.0331669822,
-0.0398059227,
0.0236836784,
0.0110142026,
0.036804989,
0.0243827496,
0.0535359085,
-0.0681327507,
-0.0021915266,
0.0013773075,
0.0017529555,
0.063772738,
-0.042617891,
0.0357181095,
0.007827064,
-0.0180443376,
0.0395886339,
-0.0242658462,
-0.0158561822,
-0.0214286353,
-0.018698778,
0.037402533,
0.0806990042,
0.0501197241,
-0.0171584822,
-0.0065840124,
0.036312025,
0.0034583705,
-0.0084652491,
0.0379250236,
-0.0432897918,
-0.0624879822,
0.0443482883,
-0.0352220088,
-0.0354846306,
0.0604257658,
-0.0448276848,
-0.0440321192,
0.0783144012,
-0.0233598556,
0.0190945473,
-0.0433199033,
0.0209055711,
0.0098037766,
0.0822379962,
0.0270245094,
-0.0034699582,
-0.0170993563,
-0.0062906388,
-0.018367853,
0.0079832925,
0.0169902053,
-0.0607830063,
-0.0663420632,
0.006941868,
-0.0048123701,
0.0093538016,
-0.0001976748,
-0.0394534022,
-0.0484049171,
-0.017560102,
-0.0930707902,
0.0070576807,
-0.0201632548,
-0.0135654025,
-0.0172741041,
0.0259072836,
-0.0134587688,
-0.0347271301,
-0.0207338873,
-0.0025374996,
0.0014647302,
0.0008103799,
-0.0250335615,
-0.0010646662,
0.0083349915,
-0.0604852997,
0.0030281125,
0.0050756107,
0.0084051117,
-0.0125780944,
-0.0071885926,
0.0090848124,
-0.0219746251,
-0.0431495719,
0.0370787717,
-0.0114238989,
-0.076375179,
-0.0199944098,
0.0070586111,
0.0248584729,
0.0722829625,
0.0011403557,
0.0724542215,
0.007009665,
0.002579737,
-0.0230921675,
0.0535132885,
0.0018206723,
0.041041255,
-0.0087042442,
-0.0031719552,
-0.0195397846,
0.0765147954,
-0.0012667422,
0.0171413142,
-0.0801722854,
-0.0450711064,
0.0273542833,
-0.0494788811,
-0.0282686949,
0.0025302267,
-0.0259570386,
-0.0109381275,
-0.0077061267,
-0.0356430598,
0.0393650904,
-0.0328183845,
-0.0683478937,
-0.0610607862,
-0.0383252017,
-0.0085025802,
0.031738501,
-0.0344606414,
-0.0014274108,
0.0040889438,
-0.0274241194,
-0.0367282368,
-0.0015421195,
-0.0126377586,
-0.0514569692,
0.0504048914,
0.0108379554,
-0.0452878922,
0.0225817636,
-0.0248561334,
-0.0278280135,
-0.0642505661,
-0.0548858009,
-0.01339324,
0.007930804,
-0.0110619375,
-0.0280819423,
0.0048254849,
0.0555196442,
-0.0199681185,
0.0109679718,
0.0210202541,
0.0186505932,
0.0357771665,
0.0421276763,
0.024286326,
0.0041336888,
-0.005117808,
0.0502380803,
0.0350721031,
0.0949876234,
-0.0059244712,
-0.0245332979,
0.0248235501,
0.0054530236,
0.0204087533,
-0.0454575904,
0.0073660724,
0.0229651593,
-0.0258485712,
0.0566940904,
0.1246078759,
-0.0021535221,
-0.0419081412,
0.0163805746,
-0.0309729204,
0.0071366658,
0.0443715043,
0.0127197942,
-0.0329039581,
-0.0441920087,
0.028294025,
-0.0051043769,
0.0374425575,
-0.0008022502,
-0.0130880261,
-0.0820990279,
0.0435020588,
0.0119701643,
-0.0178790521,
-0.0386357121,
-0.0259190742,
0.0019577378,
-0.0215744209,
0.0087907137,
-0.0499263108,
0.0112000108,
-0.0013776039,
0.057314761,
-0.0539838038,
-0.0421054922,
0.0423910096,
-0.0298349522,
0.0640210435,
0.0087671131,
0.0739727914,
-0.0058172233,
-0.0301319361,
0.0395056941,
0.0060691866,
-0.0101953922,
-0.0073348028,
0.0575531647,
-0.0461704098,
-0.023743622,
-0.0135642961,
0.0245516561,
-0.0390195698,
0.0201988369,
-0.015318525,
0.0876433179,
-0.0098553132,
-0.0115710497,
-0.031946335,
0.0623400584,
0.0248491839,
0.0647551045,
0.0496367291,
-0.0411933884,
-0.0044854335,
0.0118576633,
0.0507676974,
0.0179840233,
-0.0376679748,
0.0251002815,
0.0127757695,
-0.0611856543,
-0.0296443012,
-0.0959925056,
0.0092331255,
0.0567031354,
-0.0239050183,
-0.0375219323,
0.0002147239,
0.0089309504,
-0.0292318892,
0.0501362868,
0.0205934253,
0.0047530392,
-0.0467044748,
0.0167287756,
0.0305356998,
-0.0075062169,
-0.0110300519,
-0.0025236809,
-0.0238301512,
-0.0645687953,
0.0093374131,
0.0270920787,
0.0188339278,
0.0650111511,
-0.0054936279,
-0.0152942324,
0.0270486157,
-0.0106760571,
-0.0223530736,
0.0163962394,
0.0753924325,
-0.0036054421,
-0.0267807227,
0.024896197,
-0.0141337886,
0.0498663671,
-0.0083414037,
-0.0084339464,
-0.0073647047,
-0.0504145771,
-0.0390225723,
0.0001247308,
0.0692037791,
0.0179588981,
0.0051928936,
-0.0295164213,
0.0086045694,
0.0095401714,
0.0271192342,
-0.0679761097,
-0.0585608706,
-0.0013548844,
-0.0190572422,
-0.0323128104,
-0.0452474914,
-0.023515638,
-0.0508037433,
0.003171816,
0.0526337661,
-0.0304984525,
0.0115279695,
-0.0196823534,
0.0173593089,
0.0145291388,
0.0023069428,
0.034162499,
0.0045008403,
0.0204660892,
0.0387365855,
-0.0253540054,
-0.0093648694,
0.0390072204,
0.0187355783,
0.0001678266,
0.0004639584,
-0.015392594,
-0.0063403575,
0.0407277383,
-0.0554551221,
0.0217156615,
-0.0087870639,
0.0222461615,
-0.0307502635,
0.0368388072,
-0.0637904555,
-0.0457263179,
0.0301669575,
-0.0129170045,
-0.0284366049,
0.0133447349,
0.0578061305,
0.0072222184,
0.0141470162,
0.0193760563,
0.0072950805,
-0.0611416437,
-0.0144268544,
0.070969604,
-0.0150940195,
-0.0078961272,
0.0252619311,
-0.0486867018,
-0.0891996101,
0.0184579697,
-0.0339218751,
-0.022306053,
-0.0142861176,
0.0482878871,
0.0211511571,
-0.0488200746,
0.0294477902,
-0.0217510704,
0.0099056615,
-0.0672140941,
-0.0424354747,
0.0538285747,
-6.032398603e-33,
0.000192746,
0.0229422338,
-0.0574721582,
-0.0202429015,
-0.0331877023,
0.0445735082,
-0.0157812368,
0.0350908078,
0.0049051922,
0.0401627347,
-0.0319847874,
0.0483894721,
0.0056650769,
0.0370301679,
0.0040087947,
-0.0237855837,
0.0425290689,
-0.0115038836,
0.0094565414,
0.0167978238,
0.0085958,
0.0550029837,
0.0870349407,
-0.0548493862,
-0.0437675864,
0.0215628278,
0.0228660349,
-0.0276405253,
0.0501931235,
0.0572783574,
0.0189376492,
0.0545415059,
-0.0132664256,
-0.0578273721,
-0.0149870617,
0.0430581495,
-0.0382845253,
-0.0418258645,
-0.0379360095,
0.0307437293,
-0.0271102507,
-0.0028415916,
0.0151127642,
0.0265287142,
0.0234192908,
-0.0346956253,
0.0203889739,
0.0022494886,
0.0022092671,
-0.0223755427,
0.0043674628,
0.0269151423,
-0.0402433947,
-0.0159740541,
0.0702090859,
0.0533344261,
0.0093292892,
0.0029539524,
-0.0304216817,
0.02191885,
-0.0313441642,
0.0224285349,
0.0528717302,
-0.0119119585,
0.0188063085,
0.0350751095,
0.029601844,
-0.0231183413,
0.0112807294,
-0.0236584358,
0.0049175564,
0.0580842085,
0.0221880544,
0.0321725309,
-0.0035614285,
0.0196212251,
-0.0247541554,
0.0340164527,
0.0454879254,
0.0179231409,
0.0358151495,
0.0187740214,
-0.0338311233,
0.0187837984,
-0.0180433467,
0.0001466752,
-0.0313257575,
-0.0204859897,
0.0446871668,
-0.0130048962,
0.02364875,
0.0024110882,
0.0432671309,
-0.0215699133,
-0.0171192493,
0.0489317141,
0.0099580605,
0.0369583853,
0.0262704547,
0.0356459655,
-0.065286234,
0.0214958061,
0.0155470567,
0.0439968221,
0.0212416854,
-0.0230175108,
-0.0051106228,
0.0146182273,
-0.0325600393,
-0.0491951369,
-0.0284598432,
0.0438223556,
-0.0455706082,
0.0275981426,
0.017175993,
0.0219240151,
-0.0225291569,
0.0293860845,
-0.0312255677,
0.0124317901,
-0.0116020385,
-0.0439929627,
-0.0012164392,
0.0280224942,
-0.0591152646,
-0.0082807485,
-0.0259022545,
-0.0323394947,
0.0407013446,
-0.0276042186,
-0.0165042188,
0.0059341984,
2.725e-7,
-0.0410564393,
-0.0152457422,
0.0027694728,
-0.057427831,
0.0020101126,
0.0601841435,
-0.015167607,
0.0574435852,
-0.0101100635,
-0.0407944061,
0.0359993912,
0.014207134,
0.0736192018,
-0.0184667725,
-0.0898576751,
-0.0703805536,
-0.0385394506,
0.0425646119,
-0.0125819501,
-0.0173470378,
0.034793023,
0.1296846122,
0.0483337753,
0.0201732051,
0.0163606238,
0.0590562187,
0.0139061343,
-0.0456039272,
-0.006693596,
-0.0302390289,
0.0141693614,
-0.0374949686,
-0.0372366607,
0.0053131315,
-0.0214350857,
0.002571756,
0.0354925804,
0.0425580628,
-0.0066301175,
-0.07707192,
0.0047045187,
0.0565608181,
-0.057597585,
-0.0182036217,
0.0068123527,
-0.0473158546,
-0.0671285838,
-0.0113356793,
-0.0434365012,
-0.0152200339,
0.0449643619,
0.0051370333,
-0.0311780367,
0.008300948,
0.0051382952,
-0.0285658948,
-0.0274702217,
-0.0975722224,
0.0180985928,
0.0118842861,
-0.0683506429,
0.0137370033,
-0.0509206429,
0.0161140263,
0.0305452887,
-0.0162175242,
-0.0158695187,
1.903975636e-34,
0.0148903271,
-0.0042914958,
0.0159905646,
0.0025129297,
0.0178648289,
-0.033960212,
-0.0300202519,
-0.0173135381,
0.0823371783,
-0.0164438598,
-0.0093444502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14353v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14353v1 | ZhuJiu: A Multi-dimensional, Multi-faceted Chinese Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2023-08-28T06:56:44 | 2023-08-28T06:56:44 | Baoli Zhang, Haining Xie, Pengfan Du, Junhao Chen, Pengfei Cao, Yubo Chen, Shengping Liu, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | The unprecedented performance of large language models (LLMs) requires
comprehensive and accurate evaluation. We argue that for LLMs evaluation,
benchmarks need to be comprehensive and systematic. To this end, we propose the
ZhuJiu benchmark, which has the following strengths: (1) Multi-dimensional
ability coverage: We comprehensively evaluate LLMs across 7 ability dimensions
covering 51 tasks. Especially, we also propose a new benchmark that focuses on
knowledge ability of LLMs. (2) Multi-faceted evaluation methods collaboration:
We use 3 different yet complementary evaluation methods to comprehensively
evaluate LLMs, which can ensure the authority and accuracy of the evaluation
results. (3) Comprehensive Chinese benchmark: ZhuJiu is the pioneering
benchmark that fully assesses LLMs in Chinese, while also providing equally
robust evaluation abilities in English. (4) Avoiding potential data leakage: To
avoid data leakage, we construct evaluation data specifically for 37 tasks. We
evaluate 10 current mainstream LLMs and conduct an in-depth discussion and
analysis of their results. The ZhuJiu benchmark and open-participation
leaderboard are publicly released at http://www.zhujiu-benchmark.com/ and we
also provide a demo video at https://youtu.be/qypkJ89L1Ic. | [
-0.0012609746,
0.0762264654,
0.0030858163,
0.055252634,
-0.0179345328,
0.0016841205,
0.0467321016,
-0.00151966,
-0.0046118656,
-0.0084889494,
-0.0936962739,
-0.078593947,
0.0306507181,
0.0047296491,
0.0392457061,
-0.0366476141,
0.0386983119,
-0.0173797514,
-0.022263715,
0.0062973127,
0.0191956367,
-0.0241169482,
0.0154214893,
0.0410917476,
0.014808815,
-0.0281777494,
0.0408319607,
0.0045220722,
0.0095417053,
-0.0390112884,
0.0036016463,
0.0442650318,
-0.026776474,
0.0502048172,
0.0000021232,
-0.0496770255,
-0.0031020292,
-0.0064814123,
0.0002399257,
0.0740675479,
0.0450204983,
-0.0119325379,
-0.0193692725,
0.0357430317,
-0.0288025532,
-0.0500560217,
0.0266027469,
0.0555526875,
0.0361209251,
0.0749475136,
-0.0085343402,
-0.0166225787,
0.0532474443,
-0.0619127937,
-0.0452183895,
-0.06449081,
0.0141140167,
0.0359073207,
0.0057381922,
-0.0154818641,
-0.0311005563,
0.0294899885,
0.0271977168,
-0.0058850655,
-0.0259468518,
0.0271287356,
-0.0241429955,
0.0149292033,
0.0081743449,
0.0863325894,
-0.0208301581,
0.011143147,
-0.0128376996,
-0.002878651,
-0.0295203496,
-0.0010220782,
-0.0655281544,
0.0227912981,
0.022329567,
0.0163962077,
0.0079254825,
0.0093634184,
0.0597315133,
0.0324555077,
-0.0083955135,
0.0451962575,
0.0504207909,
-0.0379121713,
0.0074142916,
-0.0195344687,
-0.0039438829,
-0.0507711284,
-0.0174756069,
0.0023340699,
-0.0222855583,
0.0277387165,
-0.0056624641,
-0.0213535391,
0.0082996562,
-0.0542984232,
0.0694109276,
0.028119931,
-0.0171649549,
0.0481963381,
-0.016526809,
0.1001635566,
-0.0172722675,
0.0235833917,
-0.0648343414,
-0.0212216862,
-0.0409883969,
0.00015954,
-0.0116512543,
0.0367979333,
-0.0116106765,
-0.0409299098,
-0.0356889181,
-0.0102447169,
-0.01881033,
0.0005929227,
0.0344040431,
-0.0291922428,
-0.0244254302,
-0.0150658758,
-0.0293120686,
0.0272738077,
-0.0225711279,
0.0253480896,
-0.0265643448,
-0.0280018467,
0.0193797834,
0.0280382298,
-0.0087207714,
-0.0349206999,
0.0126149571,
0.0539584011,
-0.0065403553,
-0.0036531547,
0.0006929435,
0.0292020347,
-0.0298091806,
-0.0870047808,
0.0029253634,
-0.0635314658,
0.0115534468,
-0.0082101868,
0.0338718854,
-0.0384172238,
0.0158358663,
-0.0091207474,
0.0185850151,
0.0120761553,
0.0231675692,
0.0018193462,
-0.0034562976,
0.0276402403,
-0.0168183632,
0.0605532639,
0.0273520574,
0.0048326012,
0.0344395489,
-0.0019178151,
-0.002794377,
0.0549150072,
-0.011384584,
0.0151997991,
-0.0336193554,
0.0174548253,
0.0418136306,
0.0416817144,
0.0002854201,
0.0666195005,
-0.0199050717,
0.0079702036,
0.0879684612,
0.0258509573,
0.0192016903,
0.0090112938,
0.0230785627,
-0.0038716712,
0.0285329763,
-0.0042540813,
-0.0310090221,
0.0060846829,
-0.0261093527,
0.0260455199,
0.0441402495,
0.0178308226,
-0.02750149,
-0.060088262,
-0.0446062908,
0.0002012686,
0.0114672147,
0.0147687187,
0.0418138057,
-0.0261739865,
-0.0143306581,
0.0291184355,
-0.0006868264,
-0.0556722805,
0.0303908214,
-0.0271878149,
-0.0056281537,
0.0804012492,
0.0321672782,
-0.0036536024,
-0.02072878,
0.0239977483,
-0.0070569557,
0.0609147586,
0.0596728101,
-0.0167373866,
0.0061727441,
-0.0461767726,
0.0000850993,
-0.0068703834,
0.0189103801,
0.0051031383,
0.0191173758,
0.0232418794,
0.0157557297,
-0.074605912,
-0.041810967,
0.0295752268,
-0.0561541431,
0.0006899878,
-0.0060542594,
-0.0116206966,
0.0227259416,
0.0170348659,
-0.0442979112,
0.0227313675,
0.0014435806,
-0.0404918157,
-0.0198956411,
0.0101389075,
-0.056357991,
-0.0348800942,
0.0751520321,
-0.0251890756,
-0.0190580059,
0.0708466098,
-0.0407582223,
-0.0531649776,
0.0187730137,
0.0232499074,
-0.0060528186,
-0.0717166662,
0.0399872437,
-0.035814181,
0.0184873156,
-0.0007583201,
0.0701482818,
-0.019186778,
0.0511648133,
0.0306300484,
0.0447589085,
0.0231429022,
-0.025715366,
-0.0760803074,
0.0057051592,
0.0134419082,
0.049315583,
0.0155785009,
0.0004260108,
-0.0121199181,
-0.0477828383,
-0.0908915624,
0.0479333997,
-0.0558258928,
0.0113180839,
0.0231662896,
-0.0236419421,
-0.011328239,
0.0155299436,
-0.0434349813,
-0.0050773136,
-0.0188592374,
-0.0051631229,
-0.0111686718,
-0.0114499014,
-0.0053990334,
-0.0440592952,
-0.0086612115,
0.0137248505,
0.0304515567,
-0.0250440743,
0.001260609,
0.009841104,
0.0300088935,
-0.0275742356,
0.0081188399,
-0.022340944,
-0.0490589328,
0.0037275276,
-0.001797131,
0.0429759137,
0.0241325311,
-0.0027558254,
-0.0055336435,
0.0532918423,
0.0027257877,
-0.0250824895,
0.0144935157,
0.0177393928,
-0.0158306584,
-0.0675690323,
-0.0276297983,
-0.0190106574,
0.0728735402,
0.033695735,
-0.0154581722,
-0.0394834913,
-0.0290204007,
-0.0524894744,
-0.0170247797,
-0.0323575474,
0.0256529674,
-0.0409169756,
-0.0079622427,
-0.0637408644,
-0.0394524336,
0.0232733674,
-0.0689303428,
0.0039678649,
-0.0099207079,
0.0034529525,
-0.0602741502,
0.0752139315,
0.0017495139,
0.002696329,
-0.022782281,
-0.0026473943,
-0.0383056924,
0.0328688286,
0.0011144506,
-0.0474183448,
0.0534259044,
-0.0476807952,
0.0197614543,
-0.0261661578,
-0.0298398435,
-0.0164930634,
-0.0102882935,
-0.0243131593,
0.0608155318,
0.0420124345,
-0.0237503294,
0.0040986701,
0.0398463383,
0.0045944601,
0.0555554107,
-0.0141419303,
0.0415324494,
0.004480496,
0.0009147484,
0.0352248214,
0.0251377262,
0.0128201554,
-0.0438141041,
0.0525239259,
0.0446431078,
0.0558489561,
0.048897177,
-0.0235252362,
-0.0078528281,
0.0169629734,
-0.0093184328,
-0.0209900849,
0.0078470102,
0.052742403,
-0.0564607419,
0.0116268359,
0.1338265389,
0.0170091018,
-0.0028517393,
0.0101501672,
0.0230492186,
0.0055752243,
0.0413277373,
-0.0248696096,
-0.0771598369,
-0.0104161436,
-0.007165987,
-0.0055057555,
0.0280788653,
-0.0208445881,
0.00354581,
-0.1565940827,
0.01759547,
0.0105715143,
-0.0283275228,
-0.0175322779,
-0.0377808772,
0.0065583419,
-0.0167258047,
0.0316439569,
-0.0012291762,
0.0009163782,
-0.0270878263,
0.0187321547,
-0.0488815643,
-0.0900213271,
0.0642750934,
-0.0528406575,
0.055801969,
0.0393448099,
0.0414244756,
-0.0176849924,
-0.00962051,
0.0154261952,
-0.0114037655,
-0.0313894153,
0.0176301934,
0.0274226703,
0.0121434843,
-0.0170880426,
0.0070034498,
0.0070409086,
0.0032462096,
0.0253914725,
0.0332862064,
0.054262165,
0.0099825142,
-0.0091059245,
0.0142204128,
-0.0242223237,
-0.0219052974,
0.1063313931,
0.0213361885,
-0.0613185726,
-0.015374478,
0.0101543041,
-0.0409883149,
-0.0761730075,
-0.0302495919,
0.0687190071,
-0.0006495878,
0.0003131056,
-0.0871733949,
-0.0334614068,
-0.0051379139,
-0.0048750727,
0.0079812203,
0.03976449,
0.0037059449,
-0.0123893097,
-0.0204622727,
0.0056507713,
-0.0095445691,
0.0338043794,
-0.0790415555,
-0.0003084641,
0.0201873928,
-0.0112380497,
-0.0029083621,
0.0112011041,
-0.0857208669,
-0.0447628014,
-0.0321923308,
0.0195584372,
0.002857195,
0.0019079561,
-0.0131550692,
-0.0489643402,
0.0155869611,
-0.0346931033,
-0.0142516093,
0.0254465025,
0.0195982363,
-0.0444875881,
-0.0013724205,
0.0383362249,
-0.0511965975,
0.0135926856,
0.0331473313,
0.0626728386,
-0.0030716902,
-0.0126640936,
-0.0000462173,
0.025113536,
0.0033810837,
-0.0306294076,
0.0021496173,
-0.0555703007,
0.0252477732,
-0.0368691422,
-0.0332354344,
-0.0309741516,
-0.023807032,
0.0926025286,
0.0144767696,
-0.0202207845,
0.0499546379,
0.0423376039,
-0.007145735,
-0.0502698012,
0.0273816604,
-0.0135446759,
0.0093679186,
-0.0037818826,
0.0035470352,
-0.0234315116,
-0.017273875,
-0.0092145344,
0.0159135554,
-0.0195358247,
0.036444556,
-0.0056874794,
0.0046673329,
0.0114919618,
0.0168042313,
-0.045426514,
-0.0421699807,
-0.0117182359,
0.0474899299,
0.0891543999,
0.017006455,
0.0629481524,
-0.0273813754,
-0.0051509649,
-0.0746936873,
-0.0091662388,
0.0052923858,
-0.036371734,
0.0149059528,
0.0105282813,
-0.0264956802,
0.006708357,
0.0876898319,
0.0397511609,
0.038198892,
0.0295828748,
0.0331405848,
-0.0320570953,
-0.020045992,
0.009805508,
0.0021738727,
-0.0416918993,
0.0239634495,
-0.0681486949,
-0.0731077716,
0.0130556216,
0.0188494716,
-0.0080843288,
0.0095782811,
-0.0087877428,
0.0523993969,
-0.0160172507,
0.0166785493,
-0.0522713698,
-0.0394893587,
-0.0231793225,
0.0017444731,
-0.014544866,
-6.643788276e-33,
-0.0240361504,
-0.0069437977,
0.0270389486,
-0.0552582741,
-0.0098237619,
0.0179065373,
-0.0415237695,
0.0110643702,
-0.0538572781,
-0.011665239,
-0.0176796839,
0.0006401156,
0.0016984136,
0.0418453924,
-0.0139398994,
0.0146195637,
0.0425641909,
-0.0139409816,
-0.0186284445,
-0.0016309505,
0.0208482556,
0.0256184377,
0.0569461025,
-0.0422048382,
-0.0065512299,
-0.0124274679,
-0.0048035025,
0.0161269885,
-0.0023956825,
0.0815016255,
-0.0203377437,
0.0421570353,
0.0331400372,
-0.0519823208,
-0.0346206464,
-0.0306977592,
-0.0852477327,
-0.0250992775,
0.0332570113,
0.0130324978,
-0.0108689209,
0.0068971557,
0.0036381343,
0.0074665169,
-0.0092306286,
-0.0362715609,
0.0142387347,
-0.0385146849,
-0.0055310908,
-0.0089972559,
-0.0341892131,
0.043738164,
-0.0125367725,
-0.0040694131,
0.0062029371,
-0.0177868623,
-0.0224355869,
0.0011540639,
-0.065286994,
-0.0233317353,
0.0091757188,
0.0803418234,
0.0915658101,
0.0253879316,
0.0138528608,
0.0637842268,
0.0311230365,
0.0152972797,
0.0113964407,
-0.0347662866,
0.0616824739,
0.0583100319,
0.0655892938,
0.0537491888,
0.0196929611,
-0.0185267646,
-0.0922488719,
0.0193864927,
0.0424734652,
0.0084587215,
0.0192135554,
0.0241120122,
-0.0311662741,
-0.0184749868,
-0.0575717911,
0.028085636,
-0.0434276685,
-0.0149490908,
0.0542070642,
0.0149822272,
-0.0105273435,
-0.0285052378,
0.0422769748,
-0.0586695261,
-0.0306454636,
0.0640690252,
-0.0005661421,
0.0193077531,
-0.0194054246,
0.0567845739,
-0.085220173,
-0.0432549827,
0.0039414,
0.0167444069,
-0.0050949091,
-0.021696534,
0.0237428378,
0.0054470352,
-0.0641241372,
0.0060844445,
-0.0422035605,
-0.025807254,
0.0120294001,
0.027677374,
0.0382553227,
-0.0152811119,
-0.0090882387,
0.0295215975,
-0.0063812183,
0.0104040047,
-0.0394765995,
-0.0225677621,
-0.0125193456,
0.0049899984,
-0.0216579325,
0.0478989221,
-0.0389940999,
-0.011996801,
0.0500672348,
-0.0162509419,
-0.0141018266,
0.0325527489,
2.662e-7,
0.0582519248,
0.0028275102,
0.021065522,
0.046536345,
0.0018844282,
0.007922858,
-0.0777627677,
0.0192040447,
-0.0110429553,
0.02665524,
0.0113697983,
0.0405292399,
0.1071524546,
0.0252897162,
-0.0716176704,
0.0261228606,
-0.0666261688,
0.0101982579,
-0.0246326122,
-0.0056736814,
-0.0032697718,
0.0961670727,
-0.0170443822,
0.0269104335,
-0.0106031131,
-0.0807003379,
0.0506544858,
-0.0041266605,
-0.0165711381,
0.0626510382,
0.0015296035,
0.0495944135,
-0.0139151644,
-0.0065594702,
-0.003889258,
0.0516671762,
0.0566050373,
0.0938667953,
0.0220301915,
-0.0329393111,
-0.0132463071,
-0.0058060312,
-0.0159539636,
-0.0439031348,
0.0725208521,
0.0041343831,
-0.0249624569,
-0.0271736067,
0.0140589541,
0.0092698652,
0.0219458472,
-0.0089150276,
-0.018299602,
0.0444270745,
0.0192346759,
-0.0415541045,
-0.0235470403,
-0.0493719839,
-0.0659383386,
0.0076777413,
-0.0503728539,
-0.0875842124,
-0.0199968722,
-0.0161059834,
-0.0110023301,
-0.0373431891,
-0.0026324359,
2.169273117e-34,
0.0292143095,
-0.0271469876,
0.00347346,
0.0151762478,
0.0399353616,
-0.0224219486,
-0.0421573222,
-0.0211305264,
-0.0471437648,
-0.069981128,
-0.0118553974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14352v1 | EdgeMoE: Fast On-Device Inference of MoE-based Large Language Models | 2023-08-28T06:56:08 | 2023-08-28T06:56:08 | Rongjie Yi, Liwei Guo, Shiyun Wei, Ao Zhou, Shangguang Wang, Mengwei Xu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPTs and LLaMa have ushered in a
revolution in machine intelligence, owing to their exceptional capabilities in
a wide range of machine learning tasks. However, the transition of LLMs from
data centers to edge devices presents a set of challenges and opportunities.
While this shift can enhance privacy and availability, it is hampered by the
enormous parameter sizes of these models, leading to impractical runtime costs.
In light of these considerations, we introduce EdgeMoE, the first on-device
inference engine tailored for mixture-of-expert (MoE) LLMs, a popular variant
of sparse LLMs that exhibit nearly constant computational complexity as their
parameter size scales. EdgeMoE achieves both memory and computational
efficiency by strategically partitioning the model across the storage
hierarchy. Specifically, non-expert weights are stored in the device's memory,
while expert weights are kept in external storage and are fetched into memory
only when they are activated. This design is underpinned by a crucial insight
that expert weights, though voluminous, are infrequently accessed due to sparse
activation patterns. To further mitigate the overhead associated with expert
I/O swapping, EdgeMoE incorporates two innovative techniques: (1) Expert-wise
bitwidth adaptation: This method reduces the size of expert weights with an
acceptable level of accuracy loss. (2) Expert management: It predicts the
experts that will be activated in advance and preloads them into the
compute-I/O pipeline, thus further optimizing the process. In empirical
evaluations conducted on well-established MoE LLMs and various edge devices,
EdgeMoE demonstrates substantial memory savings and performance improvements
when compared to competitive baseline solutions. | [
0.0317054763,
0.0567418486,
-0.0139700389,
0.0253850147,
-0.0353892222,
-0.0193322785,
0.0794376358,
-0.0072577992,
0.0140643874,
-0.0247428734,
-0.0216311794,
-0.0319906846,
-0.0213730801,
0.0300876312,
0.0030451557,
0.0119183091,
0.0249665789,
-0.0295911245,
-0.0039171963,
-0.0419838987,
0.0022457698,
0.0298973657,
0.0270606577,
0.0146815078,
0.0038980443,
0.0072824522,
-0.0271926224,
0.0157277379,
-0.0299141984,
0.0035960802,
0.0070302612,
0.0699525774,
0.0256420933,
0.0501355156,
0.0000021484,
-0.0232301615,
-0.0506179743,
0.0079276962,
-0.037305098,
0.0207605083,
0.0598931499,
-0.0036685078,
-0.0297887437,
0.0109599121,
-0.0020582688,
-0.0324625038,
0.0818419829,
-0.0223122276,
0.0151407151,
0.0840317905,
-0.0087372269,
0.0163696669,
0.0392535217,
-0.0232976899,
0.0013924204,
-0.0285059363,
0.0083217658,
-0.0590763129,
-0.0312828459,
-0.0093252799,
-0.0026462963,
-0.0050041759,
0.027069889,
0.0632550642,
-0.0058708997,
0.0261363909,
0.0034017819,
-0.0111014666,
-0.0424718447,
0.0158386193,
-0.018896576,
-0.0391549729,
0.0159601159,
0.0153213022,
-0.0489966273,
0.0252240524,
0.00641303,
0.0269245263,
-0.029584378,
0.0108929994,
0.0260870904,
-0.0164704528,
0.0542071089,
0.026621649,
-0.0684679374,
0.073868759,
0.0248449426,
0.0017986991,
-0.0202012192,
-0.0050417092,
-0.0278354362,
-0.0526566766,
0.0320495218,
0.011666934,
-0.0185027886,
0.0017938263,
-0.0548213236,
-0.0362950116,
-0.0243436843,
-0.0177848116,
0.0438548885,
0.0364304893,
-0.0034594391,
0.03646788,
-0.0107739968,
-0.0047832578,
-0.0410584658,
-0.008142557,
-0.0256539676,
-0.001481128,
0.0012696343,
-0.001242523,
-0.0096809166,
0.053127192,
-0.0020567288,
-0.0431669317,
-0.0419665799,
0.004603547,
-0.0122627011,
-0.0106328754,
0.00237245,
0.0053065019,
-0.0078074327,
-0.0377554409,
0.0043414296,
0.0351061709,
-0.0125330808,
0.0330160782,
-0.0078977346,
-0.1028356627,
0.0091641434,
0.031776078,
-0.0046541323,
-0.015133678,
0.0472869314,
0.0632420406,
-0.0039817914,
-0.0782410577,
-0.0110903401,
-0.0066406666,
0.019343676,
-0.0766052529,
0.0003089196,
-0.0898456946,
0.0483466014,
0.022780912,
0.018099932,
-0.0640260056,
-0.0009874766,
0.0380528308,
-0.0375750102,
0.022527298,
-0.0365342796,
-0.0012374689,
0.010956184,
0.0062048929,
-0.032146249,
0.0695247203,
0.0380793661,
0.0168051273,
0.0341688506,
-0.0042115333,
-0.0157076977,
0.0485548861,
0.02905575,
-0.0151511589,
-0.0511468612,
-0.0075600375,
-0.0167760588,
0.0026736367,
0.0091844015,
0.0637350455,
0.0091412356,
-0.0238477401,
0.0492902137,
0.089988783,
-0.0249873027,
0.0615655854,
-0.0159139689,
0.0139766345,
-0.0077229822,
-0.0166213755,
-0.035587091,
0.0181388073,
-0.0455975831,
-0.0014731268,
0.1035755947,
0.0748927444,
0.0008228892,
0.0118045146,
-0.0317187496,
-0.031464234,
-0.0373737589,
0.0435514003,
0.0381598175,
-0.0612729192,
0.0077177221,
0.0465835743,
0.0338617153,
-0.0424704701,
-0.0584190823,
-0.0829223245,
0.0497632734,
0.0749508366,
0.0263057537,
0.0019414535,
-0.0251434408,
0.0280956812,
-0.0020628918,
-0.0111157103,
-0.0149043454,
0.018868221,
0.0245366432,
-0.0698217005,
-0.0028973047,
0.042412933,
0.0340519287,
0.023402568,
0.068744868,
0.0280777067,
0.0199305192,
-0.0413520522,
-0.0289307982,
-0.0136664268,
0.0105092535,
0.0141055649,
0.0390906259,
0.0018300626,
0.0184052233,
-0.0261380952,
-0.0264995899,
-0.0065476764,
0.0254957434,
-0.0414550938,
0.0209375843,
-0.037058115,
-0.0513102449,
0.0485828593,
0.0060701487,
-0.0035711848,
0.047373686,
-0.003124757,
-0.0257269163,
-0.051915139,
-0.0031608727,
-0.0296892934,
0.0308273025,
-0.0326632746,
0.0094771171,
-0.0009767751,
0.0415300913,
0.0272131357,
0.0488887057,
-0.0361490287,
0.0107615562,
0.0188669618,
0.0019473437,
-0.0113809016,
-0.0078971013,
-0.0196714811,
-0.0047405823,
0.0268384367,
0.0150959492,
-0.0278722681,
-0.0085814372,
0.0156378746,
-0.02665326,
-0.1254628301,
0.0482500084,
-0.063646324,
0.030590592,
0.0143749574,
0.0365680121,
-0.0068224827,
-0.0103808446,
-0.0145605253,
0.0189661086,
-0.0095897391,
0.0514574088,
-0.057046622,
-0.0208050534,
-0.0052959146,
0.0135438489,
-0.0571729727,
0.0089278445,
0.0500022061,
-0.0453406498,
-0.0102792531,
-0.0249480307,
-0.0116265239,
-0.0077166916,
0.0363897979,
-0.0193446707,
0.0118744066,
0.0074406168,
-0.0502514839,
0.0503689758,
0.079860732,
-0.0124842385,
0.006664874,
0.0617481247,
-0.004759443,
-0.0263724998,
0.0035993003,
0.0340728164,
-0.0214530416,
-0.0198955983,
-0.0069005876,
-0.0640828758,
0.0707417578,
-0.0337899923,
-0.0295135956,
-0.0189842507,
-0.0007295513,
0.0055975998,
-0.0198948104,
-0.0095221773,
0.039788954,
-0.0104803061,
0.0329904519,
-0.0178625844,
-0.0888133496,
0.0763328001,
-0.0330075994,
-0.0126842717,
-0.0258578602,
-0.050486546,
-0.0110921254,
0.0405922718,
0.004393728,
0.0380006805,
-0.0363713503,
0.00482362,
-0.0212946534,
0.0290156789,
-0.0094382865,
-0.0481300019,
0.00835454,
-0.0599758923,
0.0254726857,
-0.0085944086,
-0.0273945965,
0.0184764806,
-0.0055776704,
-0.0579135753,
-0.0147131784,
0.0344322808,
-0.0462054126,
-0.0016745763,
0.0538765155,
0.0107957385,
0.0838710442,
0.0029579415,
0.0139878858,
-0.0073917964,
0.0093121296,
0.031882599,
0.0420408621,
-0.0122999204,
-0.015971832,
-0.0088197598,
0.0628533065,
0.0628046021,
-0.0561649278,
-0.0474069975,
0.0199514572,
0.0699970126,
-0.0146507556,
-0.0419955701,
0.0734064057,
0.0369893275,
-0.07725586,
-0.0029011888,
0.0839173645,
-0.009064462,
-0.0986660048,
-0.0210295748,
0.0407035947,
0.0328777656,
0.0020488766,
0.039964065,
-0.0797875077,
-0.0435146466,
0.0233583357,
0.0187373832,
-0.0100668734,
0.0051129935,
-0.0245094672,
-0.09308099,
0.0199448336,
0.0145911146,
0.0126092182,
-0.0097865928,
-0.0440966412,
-0.0192868207,
-0.007340767,
-0.0095691876,
-0.0161984842,
0.0107910689,
-0.0028472606,
0.0024334784,
-0.0176535081,
-0.0185056757,
0.0337188505,
-0.0107554961,
0.0260200407,
0.0429515764,
-0.0478189215,
-0.0047163418,
-0.0136981187,
0.024298301,
0.0037298035,
-0.0027600597,
-0.036376927,
-0.0038203564,
-0.027679462,
0.0059723901,
-0.0316779017,
0.0288124904,
0.036410436,
0.0117922509,
-0.0060131843,
0.1065137237,
-0.0126107205,
-0.0176179763,
-0.0153547069,
-0.0548036285,
-0.0108775171,
0.030994365,
-0.026254775,
-0.0394644588,
-0.0327266529,
-0.0191360321,
-0.0308838151,
0.0109966127,
-0.0088395523,
0.0168946572,
0.0292888395,
-0.0808183104,
0.0229110681,
0.0280783884,
0.0044421987,
0.0653226078,
0.036086604,
0.0330133587,
0.020034153,
0.0143783791,
-0.0838723332,
0.0286474209,
-0.0418645069,
0.0209965575,
-0.0570359305,
-0.0084203715,
0.0572186857,
-0.0183043312,
0.0003215774,
0.0242320448,
-0.067033127,
-0.0953819081,
-0.00541024,
0.0417881832,
0.0307915881,
0.0379177555,
0.0144565897,
-0.0608858801,
0.0837484524,
0.0492525585,
-0.0800325572,
0.0368224233,
0.0151342833,
-0.0281866975,
0.0118712429,
0.034417212,
-0.0265723467,
0.0046658791,
0.0154420836,
-0.0060468847,
-0.0521910861,
-0.055271402,
-0.0136702396,
-0.0046482375,
0.0506857373,
-0.0243710466,
0.0165729821,
-0.0151922414,
0.0634561628,
0.0280934516,
0.0156097412,
-0.0386175103,
-0.0228810497,
0.0020512091,
0.0066978722,
-0.0152454944,
-0.0050764214,
0.0743729621,
-0.0372867137,
-0.0271363631,
0.0204413105,
-0.0103792427,
0.0106019322,
0.0442313738,
-0.0249653365,
-0.0217737444,
0.0289193224,
0.0078293188,
0.0445680283,
-0.0502830222,
0.0434640385,
-0.0152613958,
-0.0349734798,
-0.0351732112,
0.0451506414,
-0.012362143,
-0.0510495491,
-0.0229327325,
0.0590363927,
0.0394248776,
-0.0185204893,
0.0101847099,
-0.0371890962,
0.0035291261,
-0.0539110079,
0.0133610582,
-0.0198593978,
-0.013298355,
0.0260513034,
0.0156984646,
-0.0067261332,
0.0416145027,
0.0546743087,
0.0459804162,
0.0250371303,
0.0216093678,
-0.0363435484,
-0.0249949303,
-0.0256300047,
0.0050282353,
0.0331713185,
-0.0272738915,
0.007321809,
-0.0280968957,
-0.0494677462,
-0.0007645111,
-0.0381908529,
0.0219696052,
-0.0567454621,
-0.0035779804,
0.0850218758,
0.0019794628,
-0.0042726784,
-0.0122167561,
0.0025221161,
-0.0317776278,
0.001736244,
0.0207819995,
-6.926367567e-33,
0.0210355222,
-0.0098513616,
0.0277393777,
-0.0468515307,
0.0143642742,
0.0186816864,
-0.0062577357,
0.0071694176,
-0.0282342713,
-0.0326842591,
-0.0516285039,
0.0164009165,
0.0309104174,
0.0316856727,
0.0087204939,
0.0218621735,
0.0371125862,
-0.0041454234,
-0.0242294557,
0.0492825545,
0.0213885531,
0.0214329213,
0.0360542275,
-0.0390588902,
-0.0219055507,
-0.0089082895,
0.0195214897,
-0.0314910933,
-0.0603803471,
0.0228111576,
-0.0171940066,
0.0303053353,
0.0117008677,
-0.0121908728,
0.0047490881,
-0.0114618549,
-0.0436526388,
0.0092586242,
0.0097847711,
0.012905905,
0.0173219368,
-0.0568490885,
0.0508890003,
0.0378579237,
-0.0432982817,
-0.0059247511,
-0.014746774,
0.001589153,
-0.0538385399,
-0.0222632475,
0.0231447965,
0.044890333,
0.0450121313,
0.0166451652,
0.0455463901,
-0.0368639007,
-0.0331517793,
-0.0352426544,
-0.0533534437,
0.0021125714,
0.0084974729,
0.0776400268,
0.076100871,
0.0059861857,
0.0044525992,
0.0455382466,
0.0535494238,
-0.0289800614,
-0.0218437724,
0.0212699268,
0.0258398671,
0.036841765,
-0.0080290101,
-0.0178427063,
0.0758244544,
-0.0162994098,
-0.0591370277,
-0.0094041023,
0.0491326936,
0.007024819,
0.0741416216,
-0.0000689202,
-0.0568383299,
-0.0453216545,
0.003510905,
-0.0272449404,
-0.0467751473,
-0.0326566547,
0.0064044814,
0.0168644413,
-0.0300835725,
-0.0056798197,
0.0390569568,
-0.0354606435,
0.0040752543,
-0.0123193273,
0.0245000459,
0.0170708448,
0.0038698849,
0.0552243069,
-0.0592914782,
-0.059262082,
-0.0299165193,
-0.0182671212,
0.0167742595,
0.0070841354,
-0.0002966411,
0.0442137644,
-0.0877239332,
-0.0325502604,
-0.0350335315,
0.0120897219,
-0.0048308535,
0.0316652469,
0.0540411584,
0.0056948569,
0.0292411074,
0.0398203507,
-0.0221011918,
-0.0058364072,
-0.0256180633,
-0.0362373106,
0.0060865772,
-0.0061811605,
-0.0232655313,
0.012634336,
-0.050626047,
-0.0145840459,
-0.0146737695,
0.0006395435,
-0.0245704893,
0.0432613753,
3.014e-7,
-0.0164122507,
0.0174973439,
-0.0101182992,
-0.030669935,
0.0056692101,
0.0025085907,
0.0080145756,
-0.0038338292,
0.0150202457,
-0.0160827097,
0.0129640196,
0.0521868505,
0.0704054534,
0.0157310646,
-0.0624063574,
-0.0134338662,
-0.0110694906,
0.0455403663,
-0.0645471886,
-0.0019633714,
0.0039647296,
0.1218688488,
0.004465871,
-0.0329857729,
0.0276285708,
-0.0224472787,
-0.0018215071,
-0.0038140968,
0.0297641996,
-0.0176753122,
0.0621583909,
0.042377688,
-0.0418865979,
0.0378101878,
0.0207672436,
0.0312319677,
-0.0551372468,
0.0923828259,
0.0059731938,
0.0129962107,
0.0217275079,
-0.0355642103,
-0.0446541496,
-0.0202370398,
0.0786012188,
0.0267260503,
-0.0296017341,
-0.0518141277,
0.0345161408,
-0.0669252053,
-0.0053869952,
0.0058212331,
0.0256592371,
0.0261300933,
0.0120353587,
-0.0562138446,
-0.0168139115,
-0.0558041632,
-0.0221040938,
0.0115575874,
-0.0413564406,
-0.0787653998,
-0.0803670287,
0.0129802218,
0.0309591442,
-0.0484232083,
0.0258743484,
3.187396784e-34,
0.0234005824,
-0.0062490781,
0.0037332356,
0.0902122408,
0.0140362689,
-0.031044215,
0.0173331518,
0.023449881,
-0.0114154937,
-0.1153125092,
-0.0339842662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14346v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14346v1 | DISC-MedLLM: Bridging General Large Language Models and Real-World Medical Consultation | 2023-08-28T06:41:49 | 2023-08-28T06:41:49 | Zhijie Bao, Wei Chen, Shengze Xiao, Kuang Ren, Jiaao Wu, Cheng Zhong, Jiajie Peng, Xuanjing Huang, Zhongyu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose DISC-MedLLM, a comprehensive solution that leverages Large
Language Models (LLMs) to provide accurate and truthful medical response in
end-to-end conversational healthcare services. To construct high-quality
Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) datasets, we employ three strategies: utilizing
medical knowledge-graphs, reconstructing real-world dialogues, and
incorporating human-guided preference rephrasing. These datasets are
instrumental in training DISC-MedLLM, surpassing existing medical LLMs in both
single-turn and multi-turn consultation scenarios. Extensive experimental
results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed model in bridging the gap
between general language models and real-world medical consultation.
Additionally, we release the constructed dataset and model weights to further
contribute to research and development. Further details and resources can be
found at https://github.com/FudanDISC/DISC-MedLLM | [
0.0853396952,
0.0216013845,
-0.0012043385,
0.0140141314,
-0.0155765777,
0.0190052092,
-0.0194592886,
0.0028642493,
0.0100784991,
-0.0153009612,
-0.0466854163,
-0.0386299714,
0.0248568431,
0.0108167091,
0.0296510775,
-0.0508633927,
0.020498978,
0.0161686596,
0.0476846918,
-0.0045945467,
0.0107950596,
0.0327760242,
-0.0615912527,
0.0537701286,
0.005265601,
0.001480095,
0.0344785601,
0.0261755101,
0.025905164,
-0.0575959906,
0.0371895581,
0.040171124,
-0.0070433789,
-0.0310051814,
0.000001896,
-0.0310538895,
0.0213558227,
-0.0129183754,
-0.0651070401,
-0.0434399694,
0.0369440317,
-0.0554245897,
0.0217118077,
0.031840004,
-0.0168711003,
-0.0070361216,
0.014998843,
0.0664097294,
0.0558755659,
0.0810242295,
-0.0101826303,
-0.0167294238,
-0.0069151451,
-0.0580420829,
-0.019754976,
-0.05152338,
0.0382666625,
0.0122542325,
0.0167408269,
-0.0185994729,
0.0108757103,
0.0247019287,
-0.0307339057,
0.0150851831,
0.0262213424,
0.0055779666,
-0.0288367234,
0.0235491395,
-0.0115586119,
0.1293585151,
0.0071703056,
0.0242613535,
0.0175578315,
-0.00995743,
0.0050469204,
-0.0195793603,
-0.0499912463,
-0.0298005473,
-0.003914441,
0.009861079,
-0.0494398475,
-0.0186864417,
0.0330010615,
-0.0054633268,
0.0021768759,
0.0243089199,
0.0036211759,
-0.0116443289,
0.0163389631,
-0.0399092548,
-0.0160370339,
-0.0262261983,
0.0184810944,
0.029533796,
-0.1092714593,
0.0092927627,
-0.031983193,
0.0196435638,
0.0722145289,
-0.0374265127,
0.048777163,
0.00748544,
-0.0005344933,
0.0383598804,
0.0360612832,
0.0038480114,
-0.0022775459,
0.01281734,
-0.0483329222,
0.0010948776,
-0.035134241,
0.0186751839,
-0.0247212853,
0.0111157699,
-0.0487787165,
-0.014241742,
-0.0876804814,
-0.0108474689,
0.0026150274,
0.0419106856,
0.0387052819,
0.0594701432,
-0.0296623427,
-0.027399512,
-0.0251354277,
0.0601559952,
0.0111333653,
0.0444499701,
0.0029041236,
-0.0354510285,
0.0160171222,
0.0198761616,
0.0100235585,
-0.0262481216,
0.0175299775,
0.0504454933,
0.0011550584,
-0.0040598824,
-0.0019303705,
-0.0141685978,
-0.0501540489,
-0.0384417102,
-0.0050734519,
-0.05316706,
0.0470549762,
-0.0027715357,
0.0216998719,
-0.0386668071,
0.0255066752,
-0.009772718,
-0.0734726638,
0.0553109646,
-0.0151281301,
0.0408352986,
0.0082052099,
0.0243952796,
0.0004704666,
0.0077710147,
0.0230764057,
-0.0332777202,
0.0262736659,
-0.043001838,
0.0087490305,
0.0251136161,
0.0034514659,
-0.0061375853,
0.0000676187,
0.0415086858,
-0.0206867475,
0.108831495,
-0.0096585844,
0.0576046854,
-0.0217358172,
-0.0368971936,
0.0506293401,
0.0286186878,
0.0120463027,
0.0088262856,
-0.0031638891,
0.0285135563,
0.0001364117,
-0.0146748489,
-0.0418309458,
-0.0144287683,
0.0098293247,
-0.0077943634,
0.000238071,
-0.0108991638,
-0.0363904908,
-0.019437246,
-0.0140839405,
-0.0234478079,
-0.0229373127,
0.006250653,
0.0044727628,
-0.0146088889,
-0.0533636436,
0.0869982764,
0.0338583291,
-0.0005640144,
-0.0386365205,
-0.033149723,
-0.0028518226,
0.104381077,
0.0497557335,
-0.042276118,
-0.067715086,
-0.0325285532,
0.0358356014,
0.0150339957,
0.0461765788,
-0.0159781855,
0.0324415676,
-0.0737316981,
-0.0073086787,
0.0229306463,
0.0108670117,
-0.0105396779,
0.0061470489,
0.0010730405,
-0.0029614605,
-0.0203633588,
-0.0329953618,
0.0183479711,
-0.0131436242,
-0.0114769898,
0.0291443188,
-0.0224918332,
0.0382897034,
0.0123041831,
-0.0288194511,
0.0150159188,
0.0329301655,
-0.0188054163,
-0.0049943984,
-0.0016974988,
-0.0705623776,
-0.0363248549,
0.0317184962,
-0.026750043,
-0.0270910114,
-0.0073707472,
-0.0655814931,
-0.0451124981,
-0.0565000921,
-0.0329858363,
0.0421304852,
0.0034650606,
0.0211515091,
0.0596936457,
-0.0047611487,
-0.0308098104,
-0.0066973995,
-0.0159044303,
0.0147708831,
0.0200400315,
-0.0067220121,
-0.008618311,
-0.0372995064,
0.011006807,
0.0321713611,
0.0018180428,
0.0277270637,
-0.0176073425,
0.0506824888,
-0.0367206261,
-0.0396364927,
-0.1293293238,
-0.004716529,
-0.007564194,
-0.0206930097,
0.0142967459,
0.0134615442,
-0.0146795809,
-0.0300897676,
-0.0629361048,
0.0092351018,
0.0390674248,
-0.0122635197,
0.0275411829,
0.0406870916,
0.0045184353,
-0.0228864253,
-0.0011373053,
0.0067166528,
0.0044221077,
-0.0133659095,
0.0085461354,
-0.0160184857,
-0.0213739332,
-0.0433263592,
0.0087906066,
-0.0378864519,
-0.0530853942,
-0.0161351543,
0.0055686492,
0.0154854888,
0.0385580026,
0.0311125517,
-0.0229487736,
0.0037074853,
-0.0013456958,
-0.0270690955,
0.0097723762,
-0.0428146459,
-0.051019229,
-0.064120546,
-0.0314064957,
-0.0046066656,
0.0541285053,
0.0215216689,
0.0306977816,
-0.022582192,
-0.0319615081,
0.0389058255,
0.0191035382,
-0.0233143941,
0.0258184336,
-0.0537395589,
0.0444273241,
-0.0034556838,
-0.0240530074,
0.0711060986,
-0.0225959998,
0.0175495259,
-0.0613597296,
-0.0426057577,
-0.0298402552,
-0.0279351082,
-0.0353906862,
0.0241599176,
0.0070184311,
-0.018735908,
-0.0114391465,
-0.0193447135,
-0.0019597954,
-0.0740708485,
0.0609288104,
-0.0406791605,
0.0108352648,
0.0215013959,
-0.0555746742,
-0.0547128171,
-0.0404606052,
-0.0343101583,
-0.0013834655,
0.0349148922,
-0.0183928739,
-0.0692683011,
-0.0098177763,
-0.0085273199,
0.0847306103,
0.0181061383,
0.0116680283,
-0.006212573,
0.0064213802,
0.0621661469,
0.0486326851,
0.0006589,
0.0002973302,
0.0305909682,
0.0458553322,
-0.0026147391,
-0.0040532709,
0.0128535898,
-0.0161811765,
-0.0012556714,
0.01155423,
0.0062634205,
0.035007719,
0.0185592175,
-0.0370147787,
0.005276903,
0.126787886,
0.0043277247,
-0.0784649178,
0.0390742458,
-0.0027495914,
-0.008655848,
0.0042142658,
0.000886963,
-0.0753204897,
-0.0496760383,
-0.0204500444,
0.047498256,
-0.0017393639,
-0.0148848137,
0.0200000927,
-0.0591586567,
0.0255674403,
0.0166840907,
-0.0183685031,
-0.0501518138,
0.0000050418,
0.0194480531,
-0.0063584005,
0.0358612761,
-0.0225581583,
-0.0166189522,
-0.0399246439,
-0.0024906953,
-0.0306472778,
-0.0868403837,
0.0580418706,
-0.0065831849,
0.0540860593,
0.052268669,
0.0363714993,
0.0079661999,
-0.0158432107,
0.0342495888,
0.0322927982,
0.0004631919,
-0.0198354498,
0.0653488114,
-0.0074417898,
-0.0048882202,
-0.0216626488,
0.049881544,
-0.0567186587,
-0.016583018,
0.0268161502,
0.0334091522,
-0.0428315327,
-0.0059751496,
-0.0031559931,
0.0531527624,
0.0569306277,
0.0507319346,
0.0149198407,
-0.0131305326,
0.0115889991,
0.0003753535,
0.018238483,
0.0086904708,
-0.0059398036,
0.0210805964,
-0.0075181373,
0.0314046443,
-0.0504373051,
-0.007063081,
0.050092455,
-0.0309215151,
0.0142792128,
0.0196166318,
0.0352645107,
-0.0027245851,
-0.0280053914,
0.0584033728,
-0.0148106823,
0.03569258,
-0.0738638714,
-0.0384973846,
0.0635310784,
-0.0106808944,
-0.0137847951,
0.0168938357,
-0.0206360538,
-0.0454585254,
-0.0070686676,
0.0640293062,
0.0146551207,
0.0584322736,
-0.0123371547,
-0.0565631837,
0.0102703311,
0.0418608449,
-0.0695280954,
-0.0153390896,
0.0310299005,
0.0235367436,
-0.0178267527,
0.0464560315,
-0.0077984966,
0.022908939,
0.0212593954,
0.0318406969,
-0.0304235835,
-0.0867559239,
-0.0028118652,
0.0254105758,
0.027018534,
0.0019405701,
-0.0052408129,
-0.0239191316,
0.0623852238,
0.0006505877,
0.0079692099,
-0.0544276796,
-0.0280825701,
0.0177788753,
-0.0481236279,
-0.0036582013,
-0.0400041007,
-0.0711455643,
-0.0342378467,
-0.0259694625,
0.0151479039,
0.0068618832,
-0.0507881045,
0.0754133165,
-0.0193642173,
-0.0073400666,
0.0563877858,
0.0151209468,
0.0242058355,
0.0325539112,
0.0774749815,
0.0150543125,
0.0166849922,
-0.0132118445,
0.0272687264,
-0.0031424614,
-0.0869740695,
-0.006681141,
0.0476320907,
0.0601914972,
-0.0083450275,
0.0378633812,
-0.0178636704,
-0.0020663301,
-0.0356234387,
0.0564011671,
-0.0478871502,
0.026363451,
0.0650701001,
0.0157943461,
-0.0180794895,
0.0389590263,
0.0918543264,
0.0019535837,
0.038603574,
0.0128476657,
-0.0287005305,
-0.0676508471,
-0.0376594849,
0.0161414556,
0.0301927179,
-0.0474963263,
0.0055122669,
-0.0446347706,
-0.0440809242,
-0.0076480205,
-0.019580286,
-0.0431306958,
-0.0410156026,
0.0625945777,
0.0357464254,
-0.0035835127,
-0.0171628818,
-0.0363855362,
0.0403175727,
-0.0260760989,
-0.021442445,
-0.0054288232,
-5.973356461e-33,
0.005808027,
-0.0344972052,
0.0263955668,
-0.0310966205,
-0.0100759547,
-0.0169615243,
-0.0156834852,
0.014234093,
-0.0310734473,
0.0441193804,
-0.0165642425,
0.0230265837,
0.0097844638,
0.0536105707,
-0.0188972298,
-0.03424659,
0.0514474027,
0.0094230967,
-0.0275596809,
0.0750215948,
-0.0263528824,
0.0617861636,
0.0532695875,
-0.0826986954,
-0.010035581,
-0.0029466576,
0.0159327779,
0.0389105305,
-0.0396707468,
0.0597370006,
-0.0150655853,
0.052900061,
0.03215684,
-0.0028041163,
-0.0031754856,
-0.004075367,
-0.0539873987,
0.0192745514,
0.0315416642,
-0.010161235,
-0.0362259336,
-0.0203750562,
0.0332856588,
-0.018074641,
0.0153792808,
-0.0256028119,
0.0116826249,
-0.0437807068,
-0.0326083824,
-0.0047495342,
0.0006217444,
0.0384438969,
-0.007577139,
-0.0571513921,
-0.0428814068,
0.0145327467,
-0.0454827957,
0.0499508604,
-0.0149023663,
0.0073583894,
0.0380493924,
0.0070906426,
0.0006963983,
-0.0217372961,
-0.0384193026,
0.0476837829,
-0.0112858042,
-0.0037456532,
-0.0159835834,
-0.0119621456,
-0.0547968149,
0.0896278396,
0.0214554016,
0.0358643308,
-0.0216799472,
-0.0200321767,
-0.053679198,
-0.0065078367,
-0.0693775341,
0.0484034903,
0.019168267,
-0.0324635878,
-0.0388641916,
-0.0235142,
-0.0358159654,
0.0180055648,
-0.0032757502,
-0.0079662623,
0.0242815707,
0.0202722829,
0.0097350739,
0.0059843268,
0.004736763,
-0.0327593908,
0.0194151979,
0.0115701091,
0.0204265602,
-0.0046182019,
-0.0385107696,
-0.0046289819,
-0.0715503544,
-0.0032931562,
0.0241058283,
-0.0321248919,
0.0326983631,
0.0098044071,
0.0325900204,
-0.0350980237,
-0.0262375977,
0.0080809314,
0.0247320272,
0.0189074147,
-0.0315553099,
0.0475279279,
0.014516036,
0.0322513953,
-0.0287227873,
0.078051202,
-0.0353621356,
-0.0242990088,
-0.0325223617,
-0.0901106521,
0.0132028563,
0.0276000947,
-0.0620632805,
0.0129411025,
-0.0353671722,
0.006927582,
0.0375450775,
0.0067528118,
-0.0084664235,
-0.0208353531,
2.634e-7,
0.0598101467,
0.0505746678,
0.0055107172,
-0.0053519965,
0.0410299525,
0.0258213002,
0.0026975244,
0.0031667184,
0.0062222416,
-0.0213690475,
0.045012787,
0.0069517558,
0.065454863,
-0.0075859134,
-0.087161392,
-0.014873716,
-0.0885401964,
-0.0250838213,
-0.0291600786,
-0.0438737944,
0.029549161,
0.0987376422,
-0.0355223604,
-0.0317257866,
0.0154658118,
0.0110787079,
0.0474795327,
-0.0692092851,
-0.0193582494,
0.0534056239,
0.0325345695,
-0.000570104,
0.0100006238,
0.0305301491,
-0.0211938433,
0.0101963086,
-0.0186591484,
0.1337932944,
-0.0396474302,
-0.0255821217,
0.0145757236,
0.0274610799,
0.0090661934,
-0.0452524945,
0.0406303667,
-0.0862749144,
-0.0335447825,
-0.0209130365,
-0.0119924322,
-0.048205018,
0.059353631,
-0.0546346605,
-0.0093071535,
0.011736026,
0.0412094854,
0.0063712508,
-0.0175711233,
-0.0580960475,
-0.0073635066,
0.0719946027,
-0.0454006605,
-0.0434281379,
0.0467426702,
-0.0242665894,
-0.0260004271,
-0.0519363135,
0.0304604713,
1.954485503e-34,
0.0466890968,
0.0145487906,
0.0048166024,
0.0146059943,
0.0456981733,
-0.0030733768,
0.0112750866,
0.0260824878,
0.0229207799,
-0.0880658701,
-0.0148153091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14337v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14337v1 | Cognitive Effects in Large Language Models | 2023-08-28T06:30:33 | 2023-08-28T06:30:33 | Jonathan Shaki, Sarit Kraus, Michael Wooldridge | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT have received enormous attention
over the past year and are now used by hundreds of millions of people every
day. The rapid adoption of this technology naturally raises questions about the
possible biases such models might exhibit. In this work, we tested one of these
models (GPT-3) on a range of cognitive effects, which are systematic patterns
that are usually found in human cognitive tasks. We found that LLMs are indeed
prone to several human cognitive effects. Specifically, we show that the
priming, distance, SNARC, and size congruity effects were presented with GPT-3,
while the anchoring effect is absent. We describe our methodology, and
specifically the way we converted real-world experiments to text-based
experiments. Finally, we speculate on the possible reasons why GPT-3 exhibits
these effects and discuss whether they are imitated or reinvented. | [
0.0270318072,
0.022839725,
-0.0433546193,
0.0082384385,
-0.0769615024,
-0.0106050838,
0.027771201,
0.0284661334,
0.0334988683,
-0.0396393687,
-0.0278289374,
-0.0572556816,
0.0275233798,
0.0198569261,
0.0633842647,
-0.0492905378,
0.0581427328,
-0.0688110664,
0.0357113406,
-0.0244340487,
0.0230280049,
-0.0247794334,
-0.0144397002,
0.0421784595,
0.0093284659,
-0.0087084705,
-0.0071450118,
-0.0037985384,
-0.0097390916,
-0.0516298562,
-0.0268966015,
0.0738462508,
0.0134805366,
0.0248426497,
0.0000021201,
-0.0429278947,
0.024190357,
-0.016749911,
-0.0167737808,
0.0683879778,
0.0627435073,
0.0253363177,
-0.0012288787,
0.0281290151,
-0.0178297199,
-0.0037211569,
0.0258781668,
0.0404940024,
-0.0031626739,
0.0367947295,
-0.0188955888,
0.0143456822,
0.0264333133,
-0.0114508392,
0.0472726002,
-0.0290002804,
0.032867901,
0.0265915114,
0.004304796,
0.0308642555,
-0.0181049798,
0.0067286673,
-0.0041343798,
0.0437387303,
-0.003395024,
0.0537134409,
-0.0514617302,
-0.0237418767,
-0.0318576768,
0.0436824635,
0.0021416794,
-0.0452211164,
0.0086668618,
0.007002301,
0.0306041334,
0.0332824849,
-0.086716108,
0.0175750926,
0.0180625841,
-0.0053913556,
-0.0023800542,
0.0190934259,
0.0014326439,
-0.0163492411,
-0.0015965906,
0.0555363521,
0.012211509,
-0.0734585375,
-0.0138631985,
0.0048470679,
-0.0472442769,
-0.0821365416,
0.0142718107,
-0.0042666458,
-0.0072327713,
0.0119521366,
-0.0164192785,
0.0069705108,
0.0430697426,
-0.0528523996,
0.0095340479,
0.0619570017,
0.0153351976,
-0.0029109062,
-0.025382733,
0.0713830441,
-0.0184760485,
0.0098895933,
-0.0134175634,
0.0587426201,
-0.0333363861,
-0.0422888808,
-0.0493980311,
-0.0096457005,
-0.0088804774,
-0.0480635539,
-0.067774497,
-0.000016176,
0.0259026624,
-0.0330129042,
-0.0094821276,
-0.0109303882,
-0.0117585342,
-0.0138365487,
-0.0360577367,
0.0065381052,
-0.0285322666,
0.0329986699,
-0.007749897,
-0.0936622992,
-0.0157383401,
0.0083828941,
-0.0139733898,
-0.0267381128,
-0.0142835993,
0.0629707351,
-0.0328925401,
-0.0164284129,
0.0091777109,
-0.0295377579,
-0.0310052652,
-0.040587537,
-0.0175964125,
-0.0612892099,
0.0037060182,
0.0556572117,
-0.0136132389,
-0.0154709797,
-0.0055432925,
0.0343340822,
-0.0575157255,
0.0461788699,
0.0345101878,
0.0440972634,
0.0089246938,
0.0171727221,
-0.0064727548,
0.0661602244,
0.0184697267,
0.000295968,
0.011451846,
-0.0234392416,
0.000434338,
0.0623709038,
0.0087775299,
0.001287915,
-0.0232397392,
-0.0197806209,
0.0390640162,
0.0225316603,
0.0303218123,
0.0594856068,
-0.0462917052,
0.0024693424,
0.0964563712,
0.0960879177,
-0.0205401126,
0.0357536115,
-0.0145026185,
0.0485115089,
0.005956782,
0.042174954,
-0.0555837713,
0.0101034166,
-0.0349945985,
0.0134658152,
0.0430257879,
0.0453152545,
-0.0135587556,
0.006902792,
-0.0285337195,
0.0180967301,
0.029129995,
0.0040841377,
0.0200975072,
-0.0164133683,
-0.028125694,
0.0471397825,
0.0301454104,
-0.0489308909,
-0.0433227271,
-0.0369092412,
-0.0328796059,
0.0307302866,
0.0253819246,
0.0147099178,
0.0335798226,
0.0203807987,
-0.0109613761,
0.0589141473,
0.0608335659,
0.0472236015,
-0.0525949746,
-0.0543861911,
0.0240714867,
0.0137077402,
-0.0017444252,
-0.0075066732,
0.0498119332,
0.0284385923,
0.0052866242,
0.0019969216,
0.031661801,
0.0050537284,
-0.0285731982,
0.0033927471,
-0.0858812258,
-0.0333451889,
0.0004491198,
-0.0335672684,
-0.0116586043,
0.0270602666,
-0.0110131232,
-0.0055578724,
0.0172861964,
0.0385259017,
-0.074351728,
-0.0063131121,
0.0109161446,
0.0056807259,
-0.0068185539,
0.0115507795,
0.0260986965,
-0.0262881257,
0.0509029701,
-0.0287909545,
0.0745155439,
-0.0066162357,
0.0527519993,
-0.0237424728,
0.0199879464,
-0.0297942664,
0.0710456967,
0.0205104947,
0.0301094688,
0.0125060594,
-0.0043458301,
0.0040612472,
-0.0700912848,
-0.0101385592,
-0.0032658265,
-0.0177085847,
-0.0062270272,
0.0083114086,
-0.027475981,
-0.0647046566,
-0.0273306221,
-0.1068204567,
0.0013317056,
0.0098108128,
0.0250856951,
0.0167918075,
-0.0141802626,
-0.0524273105,
0.003575796,
-0.0409954414,
-0.0076002618,
0.0135178743,
0.0648368746,
0.0052658101,
-0.0400263444,
-0.0368117951,
-0.055210162,
-0.0324146412,
-0.0361390486,
0.0403028987,
0.0359403268,
-0.0377370901,
-0.0451179259,
0.0508307219,
-0.0188292004,
0.027895242,
-0.0088543277,
-0.0462622978,
0.0273137037,
0.0065370193,
0.1237435341,
0.0547692701,
-0.0034093573,
0.0348257795,
0.0283818897,
-0.0203190111,
-0.0436402895,
-0.0088133449,
-0.021969771,
-0.003239786,
-0.015603262,
-0.0778897852,
-0.0170299262,
0.1088476703,
0.0231046956,
0.003608193,
-0.0525004938,
0.0300485454,
-0.051916942,
-0.0233228505,
-0.0389733352,
-0.0163418669,
-0.0521173105,
0.0346670337,
-0.0257210303,
-0.056662593,
0.0229783319,
-0.0179844927,
-0.0069023585,
-0.0445212498,
0.0218134038,
-0.0013801157,
0.044930201,
0.052295167,
0.0139442654,
0.012303479,
-0.0099719642,
-0.0468090326,
-0.0140889902,
0.0014673192,
-0.0280141383,
0.030323416,
-0.0428666845,
0.0083814422,
-0.0177073777,
-0.0514190905,
-0.0218741167,
-0.0415850878,
-0.0462310053,
-0.0109562837,
0.0659086108,
-0.0301123187,
-0.0196158402,
0.0360627063,
0.0483361185,
0.0119302357,
-0.0335957892,
-0.00672206,
-0.0147926742,
0.0025882695,
0.0199732631,
-0.0109755369,
0.0251780022,
-0.0387792252,
0.0131289093,
0.0538298637,
0.0457343459,
0.0245197192,
0.0015473032,
0.014300487,
0.0262459777,
-0.0367982648,
-0.0458403006,
0.044427231,
0.0735710338,
-0.0462752171,
-0.0071154861,
0.1049780697,
0.0395931937,
-0.0484400094,
0.0145959677,
-0.0557916164,
0.0714641586,
0.0056968997,
-0.0023231993,
-0.046088893,
-0.0265163574,
0.0198973473,
-0.0698926896,
-0.0379957855,
0.0002974382,
-0.0032835563,
-0.1078197956,
0.022975741,
0.0042246897,
-0.0415728241,
0.0194046386,
-0.0324242413,
0.0054852492,
0.028784791,
0.0142405489,
0.0362327248,
-0.0432669856,
0.0116218505,
-0.0009289835,
-0.0638057142,
-0.0298650488,
0.0212842468,
-0.0001357196,
0.0832457393,
-0.0061678593,
0.0155752813,
-0.032888487,
-0.0768265575,
0.0693083927,
0.0236998368,
0.0148616917,
0.0159668997,
0.0359273404,
0.0301054772,
0.0259098634,
-0.0854701325,
-0.0145873129,
0.0078407936,
-0.0480115339,
0.0110232588,
0.0251372829,
-0.0037825264,
-0.0213024896,
0.0127675626,
0.0303168409,
-0.0192492139,
0.0858890489,
0.0271507967,
-0.0610440634,
-0.0321520977,
-0.018695794,
0.0031046285,
0.007003211,
-0.0793771148,
0.0097476551,
0.0459197275,
-0.0058332416,
-0.0364297293,
-0.0102362297,
0.0132192131,
-0.0070129093,
0.0106533663,
0.0307797883,
0.0091431597,
-0.0068061328,
0.0132194916,
0.0463014431,
-0.04388614,
0.0214369949,
-0.0474340804,
0.0017980646,
0.0104957204,
-0.0412562676,
-0.0024943445,
0.0011087179,
-0.093166545,
-0.0750939026,
0.0169416014,
-0.019002514,
0.0385072865,
0.0093165105,
0.0237488765,
-0.0296693798,
-0.004614274,
0.0022644845,
-0.0391943008,
0.0549918637,
-0.0232450683,
0.0182749145,
0.0395434313,
0.0094932094,
0.0226991493,
0.0299088806,
-0.0128450375,
0.0175379254,
-0.0363011397,
-0.0339576267,
0.0265476443,
0.0393564813,
0.0604076907,
0.0065590367,
0.0230914075,
-0.007074581,
-0.0154387569,
-0.0408304073,
0.015184598,
-0.0098662442,
-0.0468392186,
0.0130229797,
0.0289812274,
-0.00430129,
-0.021513097,
-0.0481365509,
0.0020179858,
-0.0043164371,
0.0205597095,
-0.0423567481,
0.0054343175,
0.0648096949,
-0.001993974,
-0.0214901175,
0.0147726405,
-0.0536002517,
0.0412793458,
-0.0042671161,
0.0737643987,
0.0112128388,
-0.0360580236,
-0.0225063358,
0.0154366568,
-0.0293998998,
-0.0488533489,
0.0222110283,
0.0625305772,
0.0054155141,
-0.017171137,
0.0432290025,
-0.0497943573,
0.017210003,
-0.0024977538,
-0.0170605388,
0.0054027014,
-0.0125574488,
0.0266688615,
0.0068898997,
-0.0380752794,
0.0019076612,
0.0725437626,
0.0178697668,
-0.0068952283,
0.0226608869,
-0.0375765935,
-0.0023424684,
-0.0281438362,
0.0293667559,
0.0179952141,
-0.0131799877,
0.009365255,
-0.0862593278,
-0.0591944903,
-0.041286625,
0.0071413592,
0.0334251635,
-0.0381407477,
0.0487397015,
0.0453949235,
-0.0250986833,
-0.0485899374,
0.0048906291,
0.0075405799,
-0.0400662236,
-0.0118884267,
-0.0127779152,
-6.693710787e-33,
-0.0146171367,
-0.0085603828,
0.0248041581,
0.0005729168,
-0.028718194,
-0.0347623229,
-0.0275376998,
0.0523499586,
-0.0067415885,
0.002149299,
-0.0269507561,
0.017146688,
0.029804375,
-0.012090629,
-0.0085312771,
0.0095004272,
0.0277598985,
-0.0008335801,
-0.0291745011,
0.0016389519,
0.0029946393,
-0.0335951485,
0.0269759651,
-0.0176350214,
0.0322388858,
-0.042616006,
0.0102484599,
-0.0325444862,
-0.0233098343,
0.0512082092,
-0.0425874181,
0.0640755072,
0.0350531675,
-0.0430457778,
-0.018834332,
0.0875764787,
0.0012821042,
-0.0223877113,
0.060474731,
0.0195201915,
-0.0085313544,
-0.0092101377,
0.0272640884,
-0.0186384842,
-0.0631446615,
0.0149039365,
0.0254453942,
-0.0074847648,
-0.0278461128,
0.0555647686,
-0.0635186359,
0.0181641392,
0.0049183541,
-0.0038692993,
0.002061747,
0.0223004334,
-0.0358969085,
-0.0041353791,
-0.0262958053,
0.0310334526,
0.02191112,
0.0353941806,
0.0306907389,
0.0312700309,
0.0272439234,
0.0494071655,
0.0242330208,
0.0391615406,
-0.0371623524,
-0.0200718492,
0.0412873365,
0.0009254208,
0.0312762409,
0.0200694259,
0.070763804,
-0.0468762852,
-0.0371187702,
-0.0110034244,
0.0306717101,
0.0082376935,
0.0668169037,
0.0220400542,
-0.0617238544,
-0.0577405915,
-0.0341939479,
0.0465534404,
-0.0398263037,
-0.0403964818,
0.0410628468,
-0.0356513783,
0.037909802,
-0.0376503952,
0.046007812,
-0.0181431174,
-0.0344021954,
-0.025367029,
-0.0279963147,
0.0345476791,
-0.0202351995,
0.0204042699,
-0.0720736384,
-0.0142252026,
-0.0018038338,
0.0442325808,
0.0147823971,
0.0343800932,
-0.0096188337,
-0.0102899522,
-0.065469265,
-0.0033655809,
-0.0223919265,
-0.0041792463,
0.0440592319,
-0.0375157446,
0.059538234,
-0.0205972847,
-0.0160729587,
0.00530612,
0.0251615085,
-0.0447397232,
-0.0299457181,
-0.0055240006,
-0.0582106113,
0.0212299656,
-0.0285695828,
0.0173201971,
-0.0653715432,
0.039985992,
0.0359748453,
-0.0432360061,
-0.0371355303,
-0.0061350795,
2.815e-7,
0.0100383153,
0.0707351342,
0.0095815444,
0.0223584007,
0.0309799761,
0.0251430776,
0.0033527007,
0.0265411604,
0.0507896803,
-0.0151545247,
-0.0288254675,
0.0710478351,
0.0286215395,
-0.0015948984,
-0.0627800822,
0.0113729034,
-0.0715739056,
-0.0003285152,
-0.0432657488,
0.0219285134,
0.030686127,
0.0190667398,
0.0030660753,
0.011537971,
-0.0108306492,
-0.0548489727,
0.0667657107,
-0.0417128168,
-0.0249943547,
0.0287576132,
0.0181356836,
0.0050811181,
-0.0058186147,
0.0859946534,
0.0240936987,
-0.0126914363,
0.024705518,
0.0196712278,
-0.0053451713,
0.0564063154,
-0.0017099646,
-0.0250908099,
-0.0159033109,
-0.0824864805,
0.0596705638,
-0.0873248503,
-0.0431846455,
0.0189236607,
0.0151694473,
-0.0491117463,
0.0377857611,
0.0131770028,
-0.0229441151,
0.0092828264,
0.0134851104,
0.0213789884,
-0.0144534661,
-0.0667370483,
-0.0443762504,
0.038956251,
-0.0460255221,
-0.0792625248,
-0.0489311069,
-0.0096321134,
0.0173814949,
-0.0264321193,
-0.012106034,
2.603093439e-34,
0.0333145112,
0.0214305632,
0.0519766696,
-0.0048158919,
0.0341270752,
-0.0134985549,
0.0562986173,
0.0504731685,
0.0281959753,
-0.0707697347,
0.0021868132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14321v1 | Leveraging A Medical Knowledge Graph into Large Language Models for Diagnosis Prediction | 2023-08-28T06:05:18 | 2023-08-28T06:05:18 | Yanjun Gao, Ruizhe Li, John Caskey, Dmitriy Dligach, Timothy Miller, Matthew M. Churpek, Majid Afshar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Electronic Health Records (EHRs) and routine documentation practices play a
vital role in patients' daily care, providing a holistic record of health,
diagnoses, and treatment. However, complex and verbose EHR narratives overload
healthcare providers, risking diagnostic inaccuracies. While Large Language
Models (LLMs) have showcased their potential in diverse language tasks, their
application in the healthcare arena needs to ensure the minimization of
diagnostic errors and the prevention of patient harm. In this paper, we outline
an innovative approach for augmenting the proficiency of LLMs in the realm of
automated diagnosis generation, achieved through the incorporation of a medical
knowledge graph (KG) and a novel graph model: Dr.Knows, inspired by the
clinical diagnostic reasoning process. We derive the KG from the National
Library of Medicine's Unified Medical Language System (UMLS), a robust
repository of biomedical knowledge. Our method negates the need for
pre-training and instead leverages the KG as an auxiliary instrument aiding in
the interpretation and summarization of complex medical concepts. Using
real-world hospital datasets, our experimental results demonstrate that the
proposed approach of combining LLMs with KG has the potential to improve the
accuracy of automated diagnosis generation. More importantly, our approach
offers an explainable diagnostic pathway, edging us closer to the realization
of AI-augmented diagnostic decision support systems. | [
0.0413936935,
0.0448954068,
0.0010745939,
-0.018548375,
-0.0038137615,
0.0325870663,
0.0002086213,
0.0544808619,
0.0654069781,
-0.0054604448,
0.0577699803,
-0.0248390008,
0.001536393,
0.0692514777,
0.0060441522,
-0.0224684626,
0.0138648441,
0.0060646385,
0.0380976386,
0.0065367548,
-0.0307142902,
0.0284960344,
-0.0292335171,
0.0338200256,
-0.0165596362,
-0.0055038673,
0.0171969887,
-0.0068683033,
0.0206967238,
-0.0807748809,
-0.0379613526,
-0.0058954395,
-0.0246529207,
-0.0180778056,
0.0000019633,
-0.0565120205,
-0.0021121253,
0.0088385856,
-0.067943953,
-0.0642268807,
-0.0032923203,
-0.0594057068,
0.0264662076,
0.0138501404,
-0.0328367613,
-0.0605124123,
0.0179347675,
0.0279721525,
0.0178822894,
0.0651101992,
-0.0178904776,
-0.002677663,
0.02475233,
-0.003968196,
-0.0007598016,
-0.0428205766,
0.0651287809,
0.031200828,
0.0724358335,
-0.0590465367,
-0.0072896597,
0.034980651,
-0.0145780779,
-0.0087511372,
-0.0037948187,
0.0476854779,
0.0291057508,
0.0002401009,
0.0313905403,
0.0656579137,
-0.0080815563,
-0.0256261826,
0.0457207784,
-0.0011914329,
-0.0203208271,
0.0166981015,
-0.0108103631,
0.0049483152,
-0.0661844015,
0.0050595421,
0.0308149308,
-0.0313337781,
0.0668284744,
0.0003738908,
-0.0199989211,
0.048267521,
-0.012738239,
-0.0098087639,
0.0118072815,
-0.0115923788,
-0.0229222719,
-0.0524694584,
0.0348889306,
0.076786302,
-0.0922856554,
0.0213264134,
0.0120939706,
-0.0126517033,
0.0757352635,
-0.0320021249,
0.0089546908,
-0.0130772507,
0.0287282392,
0.0315519348,
-0.0071641738,
-0.0066385553,
-0.0242430884,
0.037470255,
-0.0673867986,
-0.0151493121,
-0.0515309498,
-0.0214366969,
-0.0192127582,
-0.0013065584,
0.049996037,
0.0090550277,
-0.0827121958,
0.0152875707,
-0.0291886777,
0.0425472818,
0.0299870409,
0.0454394296,
-0.007231575,
-0.0099113854,
-0.0342746936,
0.012329977,
0.0124685345,
0.0027336751,
-0.010053928,
0.0118639199,
0.0172794871,
0.0260891505,
0.0202897917,
0.0246433709,
0.0374257825,
0.0480470099,
0.0305775031,
0.0186480973,
-0.0041417577,
-0.0753607452,
-0.0322792083,
-0.0190542396,
-0.0046226894,
-0.0659455135,
0.0357220508,
0.0466197506,
0.0027389859,
-0.0715592727,
0.010575559,
-0.0083345249,
-0.0554473996,
0.0375542603,
-0.0992525518,
0.0247159936,
-0.0037975968,
0.0425762422,
-0.0185824391,
-0.0223141797,
0.0124126375,
-0.0412474424,
0.0059369332,
-0.0193860903,
0.036245238,
-0.0007824203,
0.0287954118,
-0.027962273,
0.0065136696,
-0.0088594006,
-0.0160223097,
0.0749454126,
-0.0322034806,
0.0417268611,
0.0317843333,
0.001828865,
0.0035236902,
0.0400381871,
0.0196072441,
-0.00079092,
0.0609203316,
-0.0291215386,
-0.0136453118,
-0.0034897758,
0.0193279106,
-0.0232840851,
-0.0142760659,
0.0094341915,
-0.0321436413,
-0.0095309671,
-0.0157813486,
-0.0476109907,
-0.0843012184,
-0.0236906018,
-0.0090260291,
0.0123887165,
0.0376031175,
-0.0097072609,
-0.0160167795,
0.0751114041,
0.0760529339,
-0.0092815161,
-0.005706789,
-0.0697813034,
-0.0057801004,
0.1230025738,
0.0481264591,
-0.0428645238,
-0.0366016254,
-0.0042063138,
-0.0067216638,
-0.0201608073,
0.0191456899,
-0.0461973511,
0.0012521017,
-0.0283337086,
0.0007597451,
0.0536208227,
0.024345655,
-0.0274435133,
-0.0215809904,
0.008043197,
-0.0063442425,
-0.0658892617,
-0.0635071844,
0.0215805303,
-0.0642698556,
-0.0053858636,
0.0112467445,
-0.002545957,
0.0419905223,
0.0282389447,
-0.0012162244,
0.0307055712,
0.0180179849,
-0.0326519608,
-0.0501521938,
0.0324234329,
-0.0250058044,
-0.0279046521,
0.0242755841,
-0.0016348183,
-0.0352901332,
-0.0483699478,
-0.0483779497,
-0.0431915671,
-0.0155136725,
-0.0499014296,
0.0271430053,
0.0199962016,
-0.0177924484,
0.0636957511,
-0.0363446884,
-0.010142331,
0.0377851315,
-0.024817083,
0.0119852731,
-0.004832719,
-0.0255960524,
0.0093140816,
-0.0109768622,
-0.0176566746,
0.0098587638,
0.0108868238,
0.0223256331,
-0.0063711517,
-0.0114629613,
-0.0099490704,
0.017989276,
-0.1301825345,
-0.0328568742,
0.0286910105,
-0.0148057239,
0.0233960543,
0.022862535,
-0.0021360002,
-0.0077467561,
-0.0463777632,
0.0248161014,
0.0620160885,
0.0118537256,
0.0439083427,
0.0438053273,
-0.0252276305,
-0.0021693264,
-0.0056918208,
-0.0732627138,
0.0372779332,
0.0425856113,
-0.0068007265,
-0.0127835805,
0.0171349756,
-0.0603231005,
-0.0090168091,
-0.0019913286,
-0.0159198176,
-0.0066253226,
-0.0550323501,
-0.0293539576,
0.0470073856,
-0.036354959,
0.0281793959,
0.0552256145,
-0.018180253,
-0.0192184187,
0.0125352303,
-0.0564430431,
-0.0087964488,
-0.0161877759,
-0.0632139817,
-0.015714705,
0.0518684797,
0.0309730209,
-0.0168302469,
-0.0276010837,
-0.0007196649,
-0.0301385485,
0.0375082009,
-0.0422674827,
-0.0215967949,
-0.0056286454,
0.0511978567,
0.0023909351,
-0.0319439359,
0.1008101404,
-0.0114901997,
0.0687694252,
-0.0437488817,
-0.0395865589,
-0.0377151147,
0.0265917946,
-0.0034039509,
0.0520359352,
0.0099220397,
-0.003030003,
0.0196667016,
-0.0017187821,
0.008519615,
-0.0684335753,
0.0320754163,
-0.0362021737,
0.0333587825,
0.0606306978,
-0.0378822498,
-0.0392352566,
0.0221958756,
-0.0345328227,
0.0048895981,
-0.0122781387,
0.0041426364,
-0.0331527591,
0.0287403613,
-0.0085933851,
0.0480556674,
0.0451017767,
-0.0222126432,
0.0239739176,
-0.0113506671,
0.0044504143,
-0.0170175377,
0.0089684865,
-0.0300652143,
0.0249988995,
0.048896499,
-0.0108272061,
0.0175264664,
-0.00239334,
0.0186934005,
-0.0374394208,
-0.0209037215,
-0.0161107816,
0.0198092479,
-0.0190901682,
-0.0573483594,
-0.0061748652,
0.09839122,
0.019288823,
-0.0570457391,
0.0344415382,
0.0067733624,
-0.0292834099,
-0.0248392317,
0.0180294644,
-0.0699373558,
-0.0258997548,
-0.0192573834,
0.0472558327,
-0.0116845695,
-0.0616716929,
0.0252025966,
-0.0273619443,
0.0236312244,
0.0077104545,
0.0117905177,
-0.0387444459,
-0.0599838085,
-0.0292002782,
-0.0104963118,
-0.0290072095,
-0.0259917825,
-0.0018442266,
-0.0080059478,
0.004882955,
-0.0792525858,
-0.0744825676,
0.043646086,
-0.004036448,
0.0243339464,
0.0231497586,
0.051029034,
-0.0051216795,
0.0000230793,
-0.0150116459,
0.0454532802,
0.0313421451,
-0.0198759194,
0.0491046123,
0.0368228331,
-0.0060899104,
-0.0616467521,
0.0098811351,
-0.0684694946,
-0.0304515027,
-0.008344274,
0.1102179959,
-0.0276885442,
-0.0480342619,
-0.0232300349,
0.005452665,
0.046028208,
0.0478534028,
-0.0194472708,
0.0076141856,
-0.0143614775,
0.0329660699,
0.0407814421,
0.016207939,
-0.0036731011,
0.044282198,
-0.0365794227,
-0.0263698976,
-0.0454602465,
-0.0277219228,
0.0279560536,
-0.001551788,
0.023496164,
0.0091487328,
0.0200561862,
0.0010246327,
-0.0858391002,
0.0360354744,
0.0370352976,
0.0273866262,
-0.0405301042,
-0.0374572873,
0.0379425511,
0.0145888152,
-0.0029874702,
0.0271323975,
0.0018239793,
-0.0200404935,
0.0128376372,
0.0248760935,
0.0216696672,
0.0200124644,
-0.0058751432,
-0.0149526522,
0.0342190452,
0.0324946269,
-0.0402320996,
-0.0263725203,
-0.0157536957,
-0.0215772167,
-0.001248865,
0.0222668648,
-0.0334138237,
0.0197427683,
-0.0042763855,
0.0294981916,
-0.0532201305,
-0.0380081013,
0.0303499214,
0.058761593,
-0.0001577016,
-0.0236429255,
-0.0346728712,
-0.0369042829,
0.0228135996,
-0.0084616272,
-0.0104156807,
-0.0063480954,
0.0184224118,
0.0147893755,
-0.0182271078,
0.0080590779,
-0.0018937791,
-0.0413885675,
-0.0416415334,
-0.0178880263,
0.03942094,
0.0135543672,
-0.022266211,
0.0847617537,
-0.0296499003,
0.0181296617,
0.0301776342,
0.0242052507,
0.0267914031,
-0.0010695042,
0.0597147793,
0.0010149518,
0.0390466563,
-0.0284423344,
0.0108919516,
-0.0214777738,
-0.0651115924,
0.0025638263,
-0.0027897591,
0.0547397137,
-0.0047258036,
0.0234282669,
-0.0532573275,
0.0083566755,
-0.0221076123,
0.0314154886,
-0.0041760677,
-0.0040976061,
0.0405946933,
0.0068233982,
-0.0125978524,
-0.010518061,
0.0872995481,
-0.0141708339,
0.0568038262,
-0.0029192427,
-0.0696751326,
-0.0319885872,
-0.0250723213,
0.0226993058,
0.0296950024,
-0.0640692338,
0.0228641219,
-0.0815822035,
-0.069982864,
0.0177731831,
-0.0166059807,
-0.018888725,
0.0009567256,
0.045665659,
0.0418605246,
0.0303267278,
-0.006720149,
-0.0227077082,
0.0533488542,
-0.063599959,
0.0051959865,
0.0342128798,
-5.721036231e-33,
0.0144284563,
-0.0763212219,
0.0299656,
-0.0185245164,
0.0456982404,
0.040009249,
-0.0488244817,
0.0004123332,
0.0141545236,
0.0710561201,
-0.0082438514,
0.0002609865,
0.0023617318,
0.037350744,
-0.0067562172,
-0.014452205,
0.024998121,
0.0385451205,
-0.0154660186,
0.0404766388,
0.0419168435,
0.0318324491,
0.020086091,
-0.1070276052,
-0.0075511402,
-0.0126627749,
0.0173269249,
0.0287269782,
-0.0280688889,
0.0607041568,
-0.0161812399,
0.0523143336,
0.0475841314,
0.0350916572,
0.0014373073,
-0.0136499451,
-0.0606201999,
-0.0215720516,
0.0131654264,
-0.0151368314,
-0.0187540464,
-0.0263669733,
0.0288321208,
-0.0148573527,
-0.0042946842,
-0.0081931055,
0.0215642229,
-0.0280449428,
-0.011006644,
-0.0608862676,
-0.0049827816,
0.0566513911,
-0.0084025972,
0.0041291947,
-0.0098464619,
-0.0530337878,
-0.0333420411,
-0.02005326,
-0.0248631462,
-0.0031796817,
0.0294852462,
-0.0005933876,
0.0176837705,
-0.0421424359,
-0.0441138521,
0.05559,
0.0264388751,
-0.0120504834,
-0.0449415185,
0.0423107669,
-0.0833001435,
0.0457059704,
0.0439165831,
0.0022312815,
-0.0004787599,
-0.0405617431,
-0.1068532318,
0.0340156555,
-0.049912829,
0.0570823811,
0.0288449991,
-0.0491987392,
-0.0671841204,
-0.035578765,
-0.0205226708,
0.0002303083,
-0.0281130262,
-0.0301525407,
0.0180727597,
-0.0035138889,
0.0056149797,
0.0082880314,
-0.0120263202,
-0.0203034375,
-0.0101136733,
0.0202452634,
0.0547478087,
-0.0084591638,
-0.039961528,
0.001952909,
-0.0345066823,
-0.0356059186,
-0.0102791777,
-0.0282059144,
0.0480100662,
0.0458705574,
0.0363541618,
-0.0213575494,
-0.0162641779,
0.0096612396,
0.0145209637,
-0.0178396311,
-0.0214498453,
-0.0065575913,
0.0511597693,
0.0497303866,
0.002580126,
0.0388685688,
0.0232881773,
0.019585887,
-0.0226241946,
-0.0122771533,
-0.0119037125,
0.0002097559,
-0.048555363,
-0.034527652,
-0.0415399745,
0.0177518185,
0.0588761494,
-0.0475208275,
0.0016107423,
0.0003585338,
2.813e-7,
0.1130940542,
0.0588302985,
0.0043525808,
-0.002808816,
0.0359712914,
0.000512956,
0.0009281714,
-0.012495649,
-0.0047005913,
-0.0278745443,
0.0358721726,
0.0127270576,
0.0001350695,
0.0734947845,
-0.0435975455,
0.004354151,
-0.0487785786,
-0.0250683837,
-0.0278524179,
-0.0133167589,
0.0706196427,
0.042479299,
-0.0255722869,
-0.0507346764,
0.0370857976,
-0.0390890352,
0.0235276837,
-0.0187749229,
0.017605288,
0.0376179405,
0.0496376231,
-0.0014978151,
0.0291735772,
0.0844267979,
-0.0224002115,
-0.0239896644,
-0.0174742024,
0.0702664554,
-0.0528810769,
0.044907216,
0.0157515034,
-0.0478218086,
0.0484501161,
-0.0486738905,
0.0530947745,
-0.0426748134,
-0.0474089012,
0.0186775792,
0.0141705284,
-0.0320191756,
0.0127346935,
-0.0239734408,
-0.0192431174,
0.0445552394,
0.0017070889,
0.0228273105,
-0.0034676469,
-0.0855122134,
-0.0281883571,
0.0642004758,
0.0035179988,
-0.0355481096,
0.0686308146,
-0.021832265,
0.0244475342,
-0.0856381059,
0.0430063568,
2.72483815e-34,
0.0329393335,
0.0404100195,
-0.022940442,
-0.0102763129,
0.0534734651,
-0.0299878456,
0.0128108831,
0.0270631909,
0.0194950122,
-0.0762654468,
-0.0195732806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14306v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14306v3 | Evaluating the Robustness to Instructions of Large Language Models | 2023-08-28T04:57:07 | 2023-11-27T17:43:20 | Yuansheng Ni, Sichao Jiang, Xinyu wu, Hui Shen, Yuli Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently, Instruction fine-tuning has risen to prominence as a potential
method for enhancing the zero-shot capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs)
on novel tasks. This technique has shown an exceptional ability to boost the
performance of moderately sized LLMs, sometimes even reaching performance
levels comparable to those of much larger model variants. The focus is on the
robustness of instruction-tuned LLMs to seen and unseen tasks. We conducted an
exploration of six models including Alpaca, Vicuna, WizardLM, and Traditional
Task-oriented Models(Flan-T5-XL/XXL, T0++) using real-world relation extraction
datasets as case studies. We carried out a comprehensive evaluation of these
instruction-following LLMs which have been tuned based on open-domain
instructions and task-oriented instructions. The main discussion is their
performance and robustness towards instructions. We have observed that in most
cases, the model's performance in dealing with unfamiliar instructions tends to
worsen significantly, and the robustness of the model for RE instructions
deteriorates compared to QA. Further, we discovered that up until a certain
parameter size threshold (3B), the performance of the FLAN-T5 model improves as
the parameter count increases. The robustness of different scales of FLAN-T5
models to RE instruction is worse than the robustness to QA instruction. | [
0.0457698703,
0.0325313434,
-0.0243575107,
0.0768559203,
-0.018114211,
0.0525895841,
-0.005213954,
-0.0147496471,
-0.027836984,
-0.0799274743,
-0.0545565076,
-0.0547851026,
-0.0111867143,
-0.0069468124,
0.0134482505,
-0.0467034616,
0.0559105948,
-0.058853101,
-0.0049848352,
0.0181839056,
-0.0289580449,
-0.0015083875,
0.014574632,
0.0281676799,
0.0096794888,
-0.0099155651,
-0.0056023425,
0.0119796181,
0.0154974591,
-0.0115257148,
-0.008446902,
0.0469598472,
0.0123121478,
0.019106688,
0.0000021067,
-0.0419561006,
0.0102523696,
0.0048754117,
-0.0455531366,
0.015004958,
0.0547178313,
-0.0348058566,
-0.0118344249,
0.0106237223,
-0.024285255,
-0.0269764438,
0.0509084538,
0.0389758497,
0.0064058085,
0.0903977156,
-0.0034939565,
-0.0719591901,
0.0357729942,
-0.0227688849,
-0.0064283283,
-0.0616708621,
0.0543608442,
-0.0086073559,
0.0324423835,
0.0261413697,
-0.0309423376,
0.0219035372,
0.0196234696,
-0.0039091753,
-0.0383555703,
0.0326113999,
-0.0126995388,
-0.0264281631,
-0.0121104186,
0.0827970877,
-0.0140278488,
0.017432509,
-0.0109333619,
-0.0055393646,
-0.0085062832,
0.022267757,
-0.0400088839,
0.0295646731,
0.022936359,
0.0218338035,
0.0382855684,
-0.0130280778,
0.018004721,
-0.013314262,
-0.0406943336,
0.0598311424,
0.0276203007,
-0.0378337018,
0.004979929,
-0.0056202877,
-0.0114269694,
-0.0512024201,
-0.0256811827,
0.0500363261,
-0.0289684292,
0.0317920856,
-0.0434232466,
-0.0061841696,
0.0021826085,
-0.0682138726,
0.0752948225,
0.044272773,
-0.0370781645,
0.035004504,
-0.0264072586,
0.0739911869,
-0.023837423,
0.0062194257,
-0.0205715466,
0.0016721681,
-0.0672318265,
0.0178117268,
-0.0271546915,
0.0511149764,
-0.0803213269,
-0.0045329714,
-0.0354621373,
0.0349268243,
0.0052465061,
0.0149732437,
0.0011233115,
-0.0445371605,
-0.0336722843,
0.0040922817,
-0.0220331326,
0.0137808537,
-0.0186424181,
0.006515902,
-0.0172874834,
-0.0757007897,
-0.0149722164,
-0.0074388301,
0.00067904,
-0.0602224134,
0.0098153874,
0.1019657701,
0.029575035,
-0.06001224,
-0.006929318,
-0.0156754777,
-0.0022692226,
-0.1005177274,
0.0223783981,
-0.0219752118,
0.0310258269,
0.0132234329,
0.0054069874,
-0.0260371175,
0.0192560405,
0.0108253658,
-0.07135465,
0.0665929019,
0.0266477484,
0.0127939302,
-0.0491458103,
0.0079568578,
0.0348531604,
0.0857343525,
0.0190494098,
0.0269890688,
0.0417841598,
0.0031491215,
0.0052403416,
0.0411951654,
-0.0318128578,
0.0107298605,
-0.0238209534,
0.0295801498,
0.0401344597,
-0.0111027155,
0.0454070941,
0.0485956259,
-0.0075465352,
-0.0182496142,
0.0579097122,
0.0231761467,
0.03333354,
-0.0037005118,
0.0817601159,
-0.0035262932,
0.0193055347,
0.0301073212,
-0.0875402763,
0.0148493266,
-0.0481382012,
0.0303355921,
-0.0468617342,
0.0491894595,
-0.0463643,
-0.0083139092,
-0.0364280194,
-0.0144349774,
-0.0238196515,
-0.0061179972,
0.0733721629,
-0.0024174508,
-0.0549389906,
0.0250388291,
0.0570448302,
-0.011464322,
-0.0432384089,
-0.0670372248,
0.0108493082,
0.0517599471,
0.043623466,
-0.0151285511,
-0.0304110441,
0.0104502551,
0.0073333834,
0.0479186848,
0.0295640044,
-0.013630446,
0.0258489586,
-0.0404045694,
-0.0398690552,
-0.0206169151,
0.0241186153,
0.0149460267,
0.0270060543,
-0.0052214805,
0.0188206919,
0.0035815395,
-0.0272312351,
0.0589516163,
-0.0381138287,
-0.0430813953,
-0.0214427765,
0.0047270092,
0.0193996355,
0.0203825403,
-0.0255194064,
-0.0071956539,
0.0514658988,
-0.0315400995,
0.0393599421,
-0.0028130717,
-0.0478855558,
-0.0198971108,
0.0336838476,
0.0460823067,
-0.0167570561,
0.0036299611,
-0.0324332453,
-0.0164037142,
0.0114036044,
-0.0036292614,
0.0465651341,
-0.006279049,
0.0446866378,
-0.01731975,
0.0138171334,
-0.0253289305,
0.0547622554,
-0.0040325634,
0.0048267692,
0.0250106733,
-0.0225867499,
-0.0146932788,
-0.0284631159,
-0.0265715327,
0.0103317406,
0.0063360455,
-0.023378687,
-0.0154796839,
0.0366217084,
-0.0088971816,
-0.0419434197,
-0.0453052707,
-0.0035067138,
-0.0340815596,
0.0384890623,
0.0354535244,
0.0175212827,
-0.0123988399,
0.0008900216,
0.0194567405,
0.0320659466,
-0.0317498408,
0.0337924846,
0.0195282791,
0.0348066278,
-0.068549335,
-0.0479874685,
-0.0032487167,
-0.0006938152,
0.0582049824,
-0.0059094173,
-0.0052906531,
-0.0372221842,
0.0653026029,
-0.0108368015,
0.0316182598,
-0.0241858959,
-0.0469208732,
0.0023986713,
0.0011072005,
0.0466331542,
0.0633954108,
-0.0375667252,
0.0495989472,
0.0444040038,
-0.0155505799,
-0.0206111949,
0.0138830785,
-0.0167115238,
-0.0559135377,
-0.0488730483,
-0.0229586028,
-0.0246714186,
0.105792813,
-0.040447887,
0.0224455874,
-0.0317339487,
0.0091439858,
-0.0087613948,
-0.0267553069,
0.0098303948,
0.0209482852,
-0.0225761924,
0.0105590923,
-0.0418355875,
-0.030981686,
0.0450675078,
-0.0139851309,
-0.0169367548,
-0.0272818357,
0.0087394593,
-0.0325825773,
0.077572912,
0.0121638346,
0.0014349556,
0.0255335029,
-0.010985963,
-0.0487774163,
-0.0240754914,
-0.0181587413,
-0.0059348512,
0.0393778905,
-0.0734562278,
0.0187460855,
-0.0431935564,
-0.0234404542,
-0.0431882255,
0.0006712834,
-0.0195143297,
0.0386818498,
0.011187017,
-0.0183215886,
-0.0269125514,
0.023494916,
0.0252885483,
0.0240462646,
-0.0349195786,
-0.0063519152,
-0.0453932211,
0.0157066658,
0.0689006373,
-0.0079453252,
0.0072455457,
-0.0373141691,
0.0489530042,
0.0111012813,
0.0071807802,
-0.0184608046,
-0.011442123,
0.0074688718,
0.0209288523,
-0.0260671694,
-0.0321779698,
0.042475421,
0.0758246556,
-0.0765465796,
-0.0518641993,
0.1094748899,
0.0209696107,
0.0094375294,
0.0215945728,
0.0029185691,
0.0073528998,
0.0300290324,
0.0388888046,
-0.0758124813,
-0.0261834599,
0.0105228843,
-0.0029405172,
0.0027857067,
-0.0204333551,
-0.0004303011,
-0.1484337002,
0.0519719943,
-0.0060980087,
-0.0403756276,
-0.045452483,
-0.032025639,
0.022296641,
-0.0175876524,
0.0431893989,
0.0215343703,
-0.0515826121,
-0.0234608389,
0.0196961854,
0.0229131468,
-0.0946182907,
0.0247937217,
-0.0415193439,
0.0820884854,
0.0646687672,
0.00200448,
0.0094816852,
0.0115433903,
0.0409934148,
-0.0186591595,
0.0132783428,
-0.0132316174,
0.0424150936,
0.005784573,
-0.0142219998,
-0.0065169837,
-0.0013601191,
-0.0360530727,
0.0100797536,
-0.0079842852,
0.0604717955,
-0.0105596287,
-0.0178314112,
-0.0216461942,
-0.0306377597,
-0.014196883,
0.0855013281,
0.049087733,
-0.0398901775,
-0.0620023422,
-0.0279131755,
-0.054932639,
-0.0709364787,
-0.0203498229,
-0.0130214393,
-0.0603235923,
-0.0106094014,
-0.04357161,
-0.056009423,
0.0424813405,
0.0292438585,
0.0205760021,
-0.0094854832,
0.0460462049,
0.0008070323,
-0.0319123343,
-0.0123545341,
-0.0390139706,
0.0205203984,
-0.0696895048,
-0.0254849866,
0.0458801091,
-0.0018648381,
-0.0006741905,
-0.0101414602,
-0.0858222842,
-0.0630334169,
0.017513765,
0.0610253438,
0.0289956778,
0.02174481,
-0.0145300925,
-0.0412202813,
0.0239060204,
0.0255692918,
-0.0553803444,
0.0478923917,
0.0343640707,
-0.0269542951,
0.00547184,
0.0421688855,
-0.0403187834,
0.0399141796,
0.0430516787,
0.0420705453,
-0.0251627918,
-0.0379445516,
0.0002538418,
0.0031506072,
0.0157037172,
0.0218607318,
-0.0416510031,
-0.0110195251,
0.0302098822,
-0.086116448,
0.0216123946,
-0.0518324673,
0.0043546329,
0.0025751037,
0.0245806314,
-0.0128837917,
-0.0216875877,
-0.022292491,
0.0566259697,
-0.0430933498,
-0.0035194631,
-0.0251812637,
0.0211909935,
0.011585786,
0.0281000715,
-0.0135969948,
0.0134957572,
0.0169614796,
0.0456588902,
-0.0208339691,
0.0468049496,
-0.0064741499,
0.000836076,
-0.0443537496,
0.0337844566,
-0.0457529649,
0.0120900059,
-0.0193541534,
0.0576146692,
0.0563607402,
-0.0270733498,
0.0621140189,
-0.0222085509,
-0.01044048,
-0.0370571762,
0.0183567554,
0.009800897,
-0.0063707237,
0.0309461039,
0.0336367562,
-0.0355666652,
0.0037041365,
0.0840900987,
0.0223431885,
0.0726439431,
0.0192727838,
0.0086040907,
-0.019201478,
-0.0164185632,
0.0011116748,
-0.0074717347,
-0.0205423459,
0.0192529149,
-0.071431838,
-0.0689703971,
-0.0131202908,
-0.013604789,
-0.0031794272,
-0.0146398693,
0.0154869501,
0.0243357047,
0.0335586034,
-0.0334653258,
-0.0459611714,
-0.014478297,
-0.0081172725,
-0.0156164318,
-0.0203293804,
-6.639877554e-33,
-0.078636378,
-0.0062347022,
0.0137279946,
-0.0127544655,
-0.0120252045,
0.0245384648,
-0.0399847776,
-0.0072449408,
-0.0387875736,
0.0183433536,
0.0066930079,
-0.0204806961,
0.0171291213,
-0.0027713429,
0.0095683327,
0.0067025977,
0.0329146124,
-0.0339604877,
0.0090033393,
0.0041610822,
0.0331420489,
0.0161951389,
0.0397197604,
-0.0709357783,
0.0007009226,
-0.0204471778,
0.0216232408,
0.0070571979,
-0.005799531,
0.0783363357,
-0.0381814763,
0.0261074081,
0.0293091182,
-0.0265540797,
-0.0448037833,
-0.0097250901,
-0.0952805653,
-0.0282625966,
0.0459645465,
-0.0004707515,
0.0094946334,
-0.0439031273,
0.0384714194,
0.0130881546,
-0.0306756161,
-0.0303873252,
0.0178772658,
-0.0540160276,
-0.0212870706,
0.0025203892,
-0.0968135968,
0.0080764676,
0.0402279198,
-0.0310482029,
0.0356514007,
0.0324595049,
0.0099737402,
0.0096078655,
-0.0272201989,
-0.0022143105,
0.0546295755,
0.0622241423,
0.0586437955,
0.039430663,
0.0118181603,
0.0271265097,
0.0094159544,
-0.0077674747,
-0.0058463365,
-0.0258346833,
0.0410046689,
0.0526797958,
0.001854399,
0.0123665165,
0.0089525748,
0.0324564725,
-0.0853751376,
-0.0140766306,
0.0267993957,
0.0698240846,
0.0356710218,
0.0147313476,
-0.057882227,
-0.0086247595,
-0.0021088182,
0.0379475653,
-0.0258001406,
-0.0284773093,
0.0516338572,
0.0101976171,
-0.0063432106,
0.0157028064,
0.0280323848,
-0.0435576662,
-0.0212571844,
-0.0004043187,
-0.0381535217,
0.029213272,
0.0009674602,
0.0073961238,
-0.0598459132,
-0.0633065775,
0.032676097,
0.0027449364,
0.0194096062,
0.0112223988,
0.0333455577,
0.0317890719,
-0.0651167408,
-0.0171663836,
-0.037917126,
0.0070036491,
0.0105565172,
0.039697744,
0.024842862,
-0.0017408393,
0.0069417879,
0.072909385,
0.0234523341,
-0.0391084477,
-0.0397118516,
0.0184971895,
0.0310240984,
0.0292884726,
-0.0277034082,
0.0141658224,
-0.0229549631,
0.0383509696,
-0.0042501078,
-0.0246952213,
-0.0251879245,
0.0083848545,
2.863e-7,
0.0367716365,
0.0551246926,
0.0380528718,
0.0494424812,
0.0142368218,
0.0311672837,
-0.0182490088,
0.0318082683,
0.0074636205,
0.0043435772,
0.0032101555,
0.0269463379,
0.0323134959,
0.0054067909,
-0.0329042301,
0.0123291267,
-0.0399165601,
-0.0132402238,
-0.0769106522,
-0.0260467324,
0.0299900472,
0.1086365804,
0.0084184976,
0.0352866203,
-0.0171734914,
-0.0243438538,
0.0467361771,
-0.041558437,
-0.0239203461,
0.0179983992,
-0.0216644239,
0.0445549712,
-0.0042599975,
0.0143536469,
-0.0028839065,
0.0437980965,
-0.0304546766,
0.0899206623,
-0.0318827964,
-0.015665276,
0.0320057571,
-0.032669723,
-0.0045220195,
-0.048274193,
0.0678655058,
-0.0722167119,
-0.034590818,
0.0147191221,
0.0011385443,
0.0158595927,
-0.0372584909,
0.0026037868,
0.0135086048,
0.0088432468,
0.0227406286,
-0.024947824,
-0.0366817378,
-0.0732228458,
0.0108597698,
0.0312716775,
-0.0180749688,
-0.0605029054,
-0.0437479466,
-0.0358349644,
0.017876178,
-0.0443453491,
-0.010424234,
3.104275558e-34,
0.0198754855,
-0.0030182556,
0.0161264688,
0.0528587662,
0.0194116328,
-0.004193143,
-0.0630731657,
0.0363608263,
0.0037699316,
-0.0953604579,
-0.0045697535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14280v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14280v2 | FonMTL: Towards Multitask Learning for the Fon Language | 2023-08-28T03:26:21 | 2023-09-11T22:51:25 | Bonaventure F. P. Dossou, Iffanice Houndayi, Pamely Zantou, Gilles Hacheme | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The Fon language, spoken by an average 2 million of people, is a truly
low-resourced African language, with a limited online presence, and existing
datasets (just to name but a few). Multitask learning is a learning paradigm
that aims to improve the generalization capacity of a model by sharing
knowledge across different but related tasks: this could be prevalent in very
data-scarce scenarios. In this paper, we present the first explorative approach
to multitask learning, for model capabilities enhancement in Natural Language
Processing for the Fon language. Specifically, we explore the tasks of Named
Entity Recognition (NER) and Part of Speech Tagging (POS) for Fon. We leverage
two language model heads as encoders to build shared representations for the
inputs, and we use linear layers blocks for classification relative to each
task. Our results on the NER and POS tasks for Fon, show competitive (or
better) performances compared to several multilingual pretrained language
models finetuned on single tasks. Additionally, we perform a few ablation
studies to leverage the efficiency of two different loss combination strategies
and find out that the equal loss weighting approach works best in our case. Our
code is open-sourced at https://github.com/bonaventuredossou/multitask_fon. | [
0.039904885,
0.0346539244,
0.0087530781,
0.0388049111,
0.0244650301,
0.0740458518,
0.0225447882,
-0.028797837,
0.0164468326,
-0.0556896441,
-0.0774217173,
-0.0846265107,
0.0139519479,
0.0145888701,
0.0094550923,
-0.0542625599,
0.0010403431,
0.0113962833,
0.0324679092,
0.0005735323,
0.0267790724,
0.0473360382,
-0.0136370035,
0.0382889882,
-0.0027363398,
0.0382982306,
0.0017528548,
-0.0076251086,
0.018489942,
-0.0025460501,
0.0105305379,
0.0139221363,
-0.0184940491,
0.061244525,
0.0000021714,
-0.0553409271,
-0.0546784326,
-0.0008005013,
-0.030854797,
-0.0163586289,
0.0504297353,
0.0062051648,
-0.019786898,
0.0260320008,
-0.0138391806,
-0.0439018235,
0.0905149356,
0.0565292947,
0.0274438281,
0.0514092296,
-0.0056514237,
-0.0036728315,
0.049131494,
-0.0144989286,
-0.0157991201,
-0.0279567074,
0.0242600404,
-0.0017928442,
-0.0181941446,
-0.0334377885,
-0.0039556562,
0.0436443202,
0.0098342597,
0.037087936,
-0.0085059432,
0.0328234956,
-0.03279531,
-0.0457551777,
-0.0042452365,
0.0636577383,
-0.0358847789,
0.0155712292,
0.0165437199,
0.0080823749,
-0.0193061288,
-0.048346784,
-0.0363484211,
0.0232741609,
0.0035796433,
0.029466182,
0.0270672664,
0.001751925,
0.0455367006,
0.0040574619,
-0.0170572307,
0.0406453945,
0.0037080371,
-0.0007353705,
0.0291075408,
0.0467166491,
-0.0511222817,
0.0003567903,
0.0257384032,
-0.0223703105,
0.0024312264,
-0.0024319545,
-0.0247668345,
-0.0542119145,
-0.0009302013,
-0.0618587658,
0.043203827,
0.0022889606,
-0.0386334211,
0.0256408118,
-0.0610201992,
-0.0422963239,
-0.0123135904,
0.0439729504,
0.0085372375,
-0.041495502,
-0.1128338501,
-0.0143452138,
-0.0191193055,
0.0563616343,
-0.0234921705,
0.0036948258,
-0.0349660143,
-0.011769468,
-0.008732141,
-0.0091565382,
0.0023766831,
-0.0319354087,
-0.0333001874,
-0.0141546074,
0.0157584995,
0.0368006118,
0.0047848257,
0.04407572,
-0.0074946256,
-0.0897858217,
0.0145300897,
-0.0125737078,
0.0225702599,
-0.0299171638,
0.0315269157,
0.0526157282,
0.0085524647,
-0.0599241555,
-0.0809080303,
0.0188530684,
-0.0017121274,
-0.051479809,
-0.0394397639,
-0.0394405238,
0.0522369556,
-0.0112858051,
0.0375236832,
-0.0157871153,
0.0091010174,
-0.0164220799,
0.0116482778,
0.1044976264,
-0.0161855556,
-0.0420268327,
0.0650577024,
0.0185050592,
0.0433119275,
0.0989407152,
0.0460303016,
-0.0082652653,
0.0257177986,
0.0246106237,
-0.0415678062,
0.0384972729,
0.0073925033,
0.0057413657,
0.0323432535,
-0.029126564,
0.0491117723,
-0.040511515,
0.0391070992,
0.0303570013,
-0.0079781348,
0.0351969898,
0.0239951294,
-0.0137307923,
-0.009545018,
0.0155967623,
0.0334599204,
0.0206918754,
-0.016788872,
-0.0112708863,
0.0057201548,
0.0067218151,
-0.0318661444,
-0.0112557607,
0.0380176194,
0.0604910664,
-0.0283896159,
-0.0150577435,
0.0018812512,
-0.0445754565,
0.0426480696,
0.006351517,
0.0667851716,
0.0141158393,
-0.0505303442,
0.0484688096,
0.056373205,
-0.0367940664,
0.0076209554,
-0.0306172017,
-0.0467112511,
0.015806647,
0.0042487914,
-0.0350060053,
-0.0254309624,
-0.073035419,
-0.001036057,
0.0372975953,
0.0063050939,
-0.0187874213,
0.0992849544,
-0.0611186698,
-0.0119501799,
0.0216393266,
0.0027579458,
0.0373744257,
-0.0052292291,
0.0304366983,
0.0367263295,
0.0044651395,
-0.0406215042,
0.021843385,
-0.0385481268,
-0.011128542,
0.0141570214,
0.0366155654,
0.0182975885,
0.0392660387,
-0.0081263278,
-0.0103068966,
0.0015507542,
-0.0633779541,
-0.0120165814,
0.0174134988,
-0.0003171217,
0.0041810228,
0.0193978492,
0.00204621,
0.0029665714,
0.0590875149,
0.0071532121,
-0.0612784661,
-0.0144662047,
0.0025782834,
0.0579700097,
-0.0287568755,
0.002893023,
-0.0194870178,
0.0376635157,
0.0027406772,
0.0255168099,
0.0012642563,
0.016903121,
-0.008956478,
-0.0617558882,
0.0307420008,
-0.0263362378,
-0.0810096413,
0.0235063806,
-0.007060294,
-0.013154313,
0.0125591373,
0.0144918673,
-0.0373015702,
-0.0158110932,
-0.1101571992,
0.0063048364,
-0.0487628952,
0.0389924273,
-0.0185099337,
0.0693984404,
-0.008677219,
-0.0279181991,
0.0058727148,
-0.0149836363,
-0.021691218,
0.0216206294,
0.0039298972,
0.0322354659,
-0.0486703999,
0.0125508187,
0.0068514259,
0.0139209516,
0.0112330783,
-0.0043536625,
-0.0353801809,
-0.0362274349,
-0.0272397082,
0.0091631627,
0.0068817995,
0.0259494502,
0.0173395146,
-0.0240756925,
-0.0078531625,
-0.0171043482,
0.0179204717,
-0.0488980487,
0.0407974496,
0.0194873679,
0.0051740082,
-0.0194031652,
0.0152125256,
-0.0083992276,
0.01015143,
-0.05625581,
-0.0011770993,
-0.015701808,
0.0772875771,
-0.0037328815,
0.011617586,
-0.0409091935,
-0.0427937284,
-0.0289422721,
-0.0503673591,
0.001274747,
0.0077526723,
-0.0195892435,
0.0038125573,
-0.0083739925,
-0.0223531518,
0.0674838051,
-0.006622625,
-0.0624125116,
-0.0488768928,
-0.0116595346,
-0.0459225513,
0.0775544047,
-0.0179415103,
0.0242568403,
0.0443024337,
-0.1001022607,
-0.02029703,
0.049719587,
0.0238054581,
-0.003538206,
0.0087375855,
-0.0126888184,
-0.0061878636,
-0.0024088952,
-0.0334742852,
0.0148665877,
0.0193263032,
-0.0612722561,
0.026464181,
-0.0210089255,
0.02136565,
-0.0224828422,
-0.000153934,
0.0064816629,
0.0253455322,
0.0371561386,
-0.0020910443,
-0.0074637928,
0.0485175513,
-0.0028166869,
0.0031231246,
-0.0164545551,
-0.0422097333,
-0.0222551264,
0.0095214862,
0.0154570164,
-0.0179510284,
0.0045326394,
-0.007528591,
0.0390021801,
-0.0359945223,
-0.0211273395,
0.0114384023,
0.0430499017,
-0.0278557763,
0.0040927948,
0.115916416,
0.0220278706,
-0.0093570445,
-0.0200495943,
-0.011507052,
0.0328665376,
0.0221048836,
0.0036120692,
-0.0523587167,
-0.0548027344,
0.0161360148,
0.0018404325,
0.0118364524,
-0.0319869071,
0.0025342409,
-0.0916846916,
-0.0217196252,
-0.0079931421,
-0.0163604803,
0.0025058514,
-0.044798024,
-0.0229992568,
-0.0613235086,
-0.0269374736,
-0.0429378971,
0.0174728055,
-0.0109122824,
0.0443820059,
-0.0008114017,
-0.0590819493,
0.0260140561,
-0.0511130691,
0.0693663806,
0.0588872731,
0.0197574049,
-0.0360325277,
-0.0246405695,
0.0003010746,
-0.0078537902,
-0.0347862504,
-0.017759556,
0.0124246795,
-0.0297588892,
-0.0213616043,
0.0238193292,
0.0222332403,
-0.0279632527,
0.0017876077,
-0.0180831347,
0.0469684638,
0.0031596171,
0.0191536583,
0.0154124703,
-0.0389481522,
0.0616033971,
0.0577088967,
0.0281947106,
-0.0600680113,
-0.0179717932,
-0.0028593028,
-0.0154778808,
-0.0417285264,
0.0026080615,
0.0187060572,
-0.0121282618,
-0.0126173394,
-0.0408695638,
-0.0275214389,
0.0475087315,
0.0432223566,
0.0215024594,
0.0239765849,
0.0219557621,
0.0069326703,
-0.0561021119,
0.0185768716,
-0.0238811057,
0.0364620499,
-0.0291486736,
-0.0347426422,
0.0100871939,
0.0114981877,
-0.037782982,
0.0341049284,
-0.1168383285,
-0.0663156137,
0.0120655382,
-0.0100110304,
0.0200128108,
0.035827145,
0.0042237993,
-0.0548738725,
-0.011633601,
-0.0117701758,
-0.0391354635,
-0.0196257886,
0.0755779594,
0.0061192336,
-0.004359995,
0.0416161381,
-0.0180112198,
0.0414890423,
0.0236056633,
0.0343465731,
-0.013945017,
-0.0058050565,
-0.0317826383,
-0.0014418424,
0.0520092361,
-0.0519695319,
-0.0465993993,
-0.0685210824,
0.0234191678,
0.048891779,
0.0192698594,
-0.0327894986,
-0.0103607625,
0.0444511957,
-0.012452485,
0.0027064725,
0.0336778872,
0.0398566164,
-0.0083115567,
0.0016385871,
0.0345752649,
0.0145642525,
-0.0005527685,
0.0106267929,
0.0179212317,
-0.0015197741,
0.0256334413,
0.0784434155,
0.0299515445,
-0.034550108,
0.0266997349,
-0.0098453211,
0.0075939056,
-0.017776927,
0.023280004,
-0.0193192493,
-0.0019746025,
-0.0690360293,
0.006062693,
0.0553679466,
-0.0287375748,
0.0642299652,
-0.0084891021,
0.0013018855,
-0.020712629,
0.0315227248,
-0.0660378337,
-0.0318285674,
0.0201848187,
-0.016824713,
-0.025628496,
0.0407967903,
0.0810581893,
0.0190983154,
0.0222129822,
0.0064006308,
0.0191202518,
-0.0478249416,
-0.0343704298,
0.0361372121,
0.0252697822,
-0.0328897983,
0.0421167277,
-0.0098026088,
-0.0554259233,
0.0285316743,
-0.0473053828,
-0.0018027003,
0.0132758543,
0.0380938873,
0.0036944791,
-0.0045848754,
0.008872983,
-0.0276664384,
-0.0566995777,
0.0395197682,
0.0010725154,
0.0295913853,
-6.451853559e-33,
-0.0167551674,
0.0281537455,
-0.0203408673,
-0.0071550258,
-0.0133054992,
0.0354309268,
-0.0128378961,
0.0256903768,
-0.0228125751,
-0.0400450192,
0.0032999201,
-0.0143950237,
0.0386448391,
0.055774454,
0.0317906886,
-0.0172280055,
0.0615174435,
0.0312250573,
0.0014899648,
0.0221125297,
0.0442847125,
0.0905429572,
0.0890581086,
-0.030502528,
0.0729021281,
0.0132074393,
-0.0213969089,
-0.0352821127,
0.0546244346,
0.0722373575,
-0.0597504005,
0.0320500769,
-0.0005748097,
-0.0783625543,
-0.0356007293,
0.0330362245,
-0.1300406754,
0.0066797505,
-0.0109839449,
0.0431495719,
-0.0430053137,
-0.0151111754,
0.0285317264,
0.0233982,
0.0220510606,
0.0027555828,
0.0327440351,
-0.0359537527,
0.0047899806,
0.0011597744,
-0.0703838691,
0.0248263776,
-0.021725174,
0.0163498055,
0.0833306536,
0.0074659362,
-0.0212830864,
-0.0437885374,
-0.1030981094,
-0.0158492289,
-0.0221322048,
0.0055737672,
0.0448462144,
0.01955208,
-0.0300238431,
0.0631444305,
-0.0138826407,
-0.0218619648,
-0.004470007,
0.0141418288,
0.0429175235,
0.0201191083,
-0.0135486722,
0.0306551214,
0.0373048037,
-0.064740628,
-0.074470669,
0.0142824743,
0.0229302067,
0.030237237,
0.0096716424,
0.0231409762,
-0.0509592034,
-0.0327229314,
-0.0309786201,
-0.0262677688,
-0.0387050658,
-0.0318637602,
0.0394202396,
0.0172081646,
-0.0381498411,
0.0572533347,
0.0385471471,
-0.0314458832,
-0.0301315319,
-0.0195757113,
0.0392515995,
0.0328595713,
0.0106772622,
0.0061831088,
-0.0719099566,
-0.0373480655,
-0.0126493918,
-0.0134905409,
0.0176419374,
-0.0206108112,
0.0849027559,
0.0181741193,
-0.072473906,
0.0164120831,
-0.0255528707,
0.0083961356,
0.0017283722,
0.0830303431,
0.0212359987,
-0.0088251354,
-0.017455101,
0.0283247828,
0.0365321711,
-0.0162519831,
-0.0189528745,
0.0094962399,
0.0316329822,
0.0073296498,
-0.0379025564,
-0.0154519873,
-0.0018131667,
-0.049234841,
0.0170587692,
-0.0461168848,
-0.0088852448,
0.0019803441,
2.833e-7,
0.0178839695,
0.0121484892,
0.0208714418,
-0.0782422498,
-0.0089974916,
0.0497511923,
-0.0095304148,
0.0605053231,
-0.0528770573,
0.0187891703,
-0.0290494729,
-0.0113576911,
0.06113692,
0.0236303955,
-0.1213082746,
-0.0421840362,
-0.005047272,
0.0298327841,
-0.0445027575,
0.0045289141,
-0.0049263239,
0.1207904592,
0.0142624266,
-0.0298116263,
-0.029597668,
-0.021721052,
0.0640218258,
-0.0041032508,
0.0119647579,
0.0014919852,
-0.0081403945,
0.0880928189,
-0.0132858958,
0.0131955063,
-0.053774301,
-0.0026030128,
0.0479727685,
0.0648613945,
0.0014301005,
-0.0097957319,
0.0200255252,
-0.0014722839,
-0.0255245212,
-0.0202304889,
0.0851840228,
-0.0223509744,
-0.0708506927,
-0.0046211542,
0.01851587,
0.0106983948,
0.0161965489,
-0.0173891075,
-0.0110249892,
0.0045483694,
0.0166927539,
-0.0443162806,
-0.0376126468,
-0.0641213804,
0.0097479895,
0.0153132202,
-0.0163892079,
-0.0051823403,
-0.0112669487,
-0.0433757342,
0.0188170616,
-0.0684964508,
0.0260399599,
2.628459092e-34,
-0.0008370621,
0.0015166563,
0.0109840604,
0.0698191673,
-0.0229880586,
-0.026900541,
-0.0433688499,
-0.0089144204,
-0.0149954464,
-0.0310258549,
0.0075875833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14272v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14272v1 | Goodhart's Law Applies to NLP's Explanation Benchmarks | 2023-08-28T03:03:03 | 2023-08-28T03:03:03 | Jennifer Hsia, Danish Pruthi, Aarti Singh, Zachary C. Lipton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite the rising popularity of saliency-based explanations, the research
community remains at an impasse, facing doubts concerning their purpose,
efficacy, and tendency to contradict each other. Seeking to unite the
community's efforts around common goals, several recent works have proposed
evaluation metrics. In this paper, we critically examine two sets of metrics:
the ERASER metrics (comprehensiveness and sufficiency) and the EVAL-X metrics,
focusing our inquiry on natural language processing. First, we show that we can
inflate a model's comprehensiveness and sufficiency scores dramatically without
altering its predictions or explanations on in-distribution test inputs. Our
strategy exploits the tendency for extracted explanations and their complements
to be "out-of-support" relative to each other and in-distribution inputs. Next,
we demonstrate that the EVAL-X metrics can be inflated arbitrarily by a simple
method that encodes the label, even though EVAL-X is precisely motivated to
address such exploits. Our results raise doubts about the ability of current
metrics to guide explainability research, underscoring the need for a broader
reassessment of what precisely these metrics are intended to capture. | [
0.0234581642,
0.019010637,
0.0003083474,
0.0180126894,
-0.028365612,
0.0235074833,
-0.0038024031,
0.0118939131,
-0.0421067104,
-0.0174120087,
0.0406732783,
0.0025109872,
0.001823711,
0.0336511955,
0.0183496233,
-0.068239972,
0.0244295802,
0.0137888193,
0.0247050114,
0.0342797488,
0.0020934974,
-0.0176068246,
0.0048538498,
0.0495700873,
0.0203789156,
0.0024795746,
0.0048965705,
0.0020731101,
0.0153186135,
0.0079360083,
-0.0320736915,
0.0084832199,
-0.0292746238,
0.0123210046,
0.0000021975,
-0.0359600112,
-0.0196115673,
0.0055409344,
-0.0642872974,
0.0557269193,
-0.0054996116,
-0.0454231314,
0.0361433364,
-0.0244780872,
0.0093513597,
0.0415905043,
0.0523622595,
0.0588765331,
0.047265429,
0.0631845817,
0.0064273933,
-0.0018664703,
0.0022736392,
-0.0138681466,
0.0156996418,
-0.0209118836,
-0.0054733353,
0.0044304021,
-0.0054610046,
-0.0032071625,
-0.030301908,
0.0401371531,
0.0532974675,
0.0036620675,
0.0594779514,
0.0024065771,
-0.0231945291,
-0.0276128501,
0.0377127938,
0.0390194617,
0.0217397846,
-0.0207245871,
-0.0215404741,
-0.0206403248,
-0.0075850128,
0.0116345957,
-0.0567974262,
-0.0188088901,
-0.0042464132,
0.021632228,
0.0217452534,
-0.0055863154,
0.0629018396,
0.019649813,
-0.0046497332,
0.0822517946,
-0.0151894614,
-0.0252543781,
-0.0144714294,
-0.0194055308,
-0.0746944323,
-0.0282954108,
-0.020264294,
0.019228559,
-0.0169541109,
0.0146554848,
0.016638618,
0.0147742117,
0.0462233536,
-0.0200894196,
0.0334700793,
-0.0151275182,
-0.0281544104,
0.0497332774,
-0.0063673868,
0.0897488594,
-0.0123804612,
0.0180505347,
-0.0207909532,
-0.0195261519,
-0.0596326552,
-0.0206365194,
-0.0114713041,
0.0026101838,
-0.0450105593,
-0.0084731234,
-0.0332199894,
-0.0181141049,
-0.0500909314,
0.0044208621,
-0.0048760893,
0.0136457924,
-0.0103259711,
-0.0205703676,
-0.0421144553,
0.0110919289,
-0.0919278339,
0.0155117884,
0.0155965677,
-0.0627852455,
-0.0199522991,
0.0239889342,
0.0046736724,
-0.0139438817,
-0.0279868804,
0.0406229571,
0.0257555395,
-0.0298676081,
-0.0291350652,
-0.0615405105,
-0.0607653335,
-0.0454226695,
-0.0194901861,
-0.0314372219,
-0.0105476901,
0.0066608922,
0.0031093974,
-0.067327641,
-0.0099614607,
-0.0020108547,
-0.0277613252,
0.0840423405,
-0.0243440419,
0.0018816816,
-0.06387721,
0.0077846409,
-0.0191775542,
0.0329255462,
0.0050105206,
0.0169928931,
0.0685816333,
-0.0560761727,
0.0543479808,
-0.0275871065,
0.0169404168,
-0.0152053526,
0.0151774995,
-0.0215203334,
-0.0588437468,
-0.0002552182,
0.0078941872,
0.0150494203,
-0.0244286507,
-0.023578234,
0.0417898744,
0.0197555944,
0.0167200621,
0.0194639657,
0.0603511818,
0.0120189618,
-0.0300169848,
0.0637734905,
-0.0628740042,
0.0152907716,
-0.0297824107,
0.0198889505,
0.0309393778,
-0.0388729535,
-0.0054761954,
-0.1071833298,
-0.0436960682,
0.0307717994,
-0.0096188756,
-0.0002021156,
0.0685564429,
0.0253697932,
-0.0144220321,
0.0259097405,
0.0356717706,
-0.0327283442,
0.0297468957,
-0.0341209844,
0.0216408763,
0.0475588143,
0.0514652245,
-0.0269716624,
0.0250527542,
0.0100351153,
0.0277697593,
0.0118072173,
0.0091501437,
0.0074873706,
0.0508370213,
0.002031381,
-0.0093766497,
-0.0822183117,
0.0647863522,
0.0005044173,
-0.0025047094,
-0.0645654052,
0.0193252806,
-0.1024519578,
-0.0274009928,
0.0398225673,
0.0188176949,
-0.0640356317,
-0.0381803066,
0.0122075463,
0.0236281473,
0.0349247456,
0.0081231892,
0.0322229862,
0.0099219084,
-0.0212275777,
-0.0115148816,
0.0323907882,
-0.0092589902,
-0.0159920659,
-0.0087605743,
-0.0667928457,
-0.0038917246,
0.0409361087,
-0.0187301412,
-0.0245863572,
0.0128457481,
-0.046029903,
0.0448796712,
-0.0180168059,
0.0319794156,
-0.0141562438,
0.0104915136,
-0.0336338356,
0.0753385127,
0.0048955288,
0.0653109625,
-0.0405745618,
-0.0138267623,
0.0273365155,
-0.0055884933,
0.001888101,
-0.0024707562,
-0.0218966696,
-0.0161876976,
0.0305192508,
-0.0270889662,
-0.076918453,
0.0039422596,
-0.0438062809,
0.0006133278,
-0.0375377946,
0.0014374497,
0.0303010326,
-0.0037101032,
0.0239364207,
-0.0091343476,
0.0239540283,
-0.0494331867,
-0.0311249811,
0.0150577016,
0.0286246352,
0.0133970017,
-0.0397919305,
-0.0203004293,
-0.033625517,
0.0059252349,
0.0602047108,
0.0191050563,
0.0126411393,
-0.0308237989,
0.0253697168,
-0.0117318146,
-0.0317130052,
-0.0276904497,
-0.0316373706,
0.0103190904,
0.0181208216,
-0.055151429,
0.046522107,
-0.0150564043,
0.0804036632,
-0.0113646649,
0.016372744,
-0.0245234277,
-0.0254075658,
-0.0460680798,
-0.0282378644,
-0.0096802535,
-0.0547865257,
0.0194902271,
0.0785971433,
-0.0173124392,
-0.006303912,
-0.069121182,
-0.0037762267,
-0.0400543101,
-0.0624225028,
-0.0376014672,
-0.0122477263,
-0.0225512274,
0.0570594147,
-0.0574983545,
-0.0834472105,
0.0536074154,
-0.0447175838,
-0.0111764893,
-0.0146346595,
-0.0333223306,
-0.0329768956,
0.0573158488,
0.0233352222,
0.0030068974,
0.0591860674,
-0.0363194905,
0.0146940965,
-0.0230291151,
0.0289253835,
0.007300247,
0.0608532354,
-0.0470331013,
-0.007536409,
0.034228906,
-0.029285349,
-0.0257233698,
-0.0587393157,
-0.010983442,
0.0413257815,
0.0142697804,
-0.0074470663,
-0.0589809269,
0.0072084526,
0.0385054536,
-0.0164569169,
0.0094166668,
-0.0200800318,
-0.0182283241,
-0.0139089394,
0.0170571581,
0.0077889669,
0.0437813587,
-0.0370458812,
0.0202672798,
0.0540377535,
0.0074910661,
0.0377104953,
-0.0032621864,
0.026951585,
-0.0111300526,
-0.0363050699,
-0.0168702621,
-0.0002705392,
0.096466288,
-0.0775320828,
-0.0229467005,
0.1049611866,
0.010593215,
0.0283860229,
0.0189533141,
-0.0049667587,
0.0009405001,
0.0258784965,
-0.0352659374,
-0.0088270688,
-0.0257433765,
0.0103543596,
0.05231319,
-0.0147723043,
-0.00965128,
-0.0008959588,
-0.0739391297,
0.0446097739,
-0.016148245,
-0.0375924967,
-0.0543587543,
-0.1023666188,
0.0364373326,
-0.0241011046,
-0.0038799751,
0.0112025319,
0.0293652676,
0.0227718279,
0.0365566835,
-0.0115465289,
-0.0236384459,
0.0059267082,
-0.0380749255,
0.005019323,
0.0435876064,
0.0517548174,
-0.0170676894,
-0.0192254279,
-0.011331711,
-0.0304232705,
0.0285448451,
0.0060699326,
0.0826426595,
0.0397742018,
-0.0109678544,
-0.0347392745,
0.0559279211,
-0.0088526886,
-0.0277890936,
-0.0162368026,
0.039731402,
0.0050717816,
-0.017168222,
-0.0018979845,
0.001673146,
-0.0358155891,
0.0912680402,
0.0917449072,
0.0085761873,
-0.0232533012,
-0.0292264856,
-0.0032771279,
-0.0524059646,
-0.0282519981,
0.0356595479,
0.0023607018,
-0.0364168659,
-0.0314580761,
-0.0595078208,
0.0020005512,
0.0346559621,
-0.0009427377,
0.0223911721,
-0.0278516673,
-0.0270745475,
-0.0172270052,
0.0585332066,
0.0001404818,
-0.0080403714,
-0.0120597025,
-0.0287447758,
-0.0197665114,
-0.0111752115,
-0.0200140998,
-0.0075359051,
0.0246795006,
-0.011666256,
0.0224857125,
-0.0122941518,
0.0322597325,
0.0326612554,
-0.0283558704,
-0.040822614,
-0.0246929396,
0.0076562734,
-0.0100836493,
0.0175609626,
0.0495420508,
-0.0437769927,
0.0240181107,
0.0616377667,
-0.0246770438,
0.0231483951,
0.0106815025,
0.0442192107,
0.0057534026,
0.0290064663,
0.0506154485,
0.0049705617,
0.0656704381,
-0.0032743593,
-0.0576468669,
0.002033856,
-0.0327505879,
-0.0115601635,
-0.0185671523,
-0.0254466776,
0.0343656391,
-0.0137838386,
0.0285237823,
-0.0481611975,
0.0445388295,
-0.0321405455,
0.036547035,
-0.0522763021,
0.0382554084,
0.024540687,
-0.0385881811,
-0.0245946981,
0.0145405885,
-0.0264523886,
0.0023648678,
-0.0220129862,
0.0560352579,
0.0316787846,
0.0468013063,
0.0192239024,
0.0254698619,
-0.0111933434,
-0.0119424975,
-0.0902589187,
-0.0199643709,
0.0149181401,
0.039272625,
0.0149219399,
-0.0450505577,
0.0596040078,
0.0016537934,
-0.0342407711,
-0.0053726202,
0.0656180009,
0.0527152717,
-0.0306233577,
-0.0106658218,
0.0522040427,
-0.0247568656,
-0.0113127762,
0.0429669805,
-0.0164103173,
0.0266755819,
-0.0268423595,
-0.0332784168,
-0.0179031994,
-0.0291507971,
-0.0379049368,
0.0682142898,
0.0317020193,
0.0242101327,
-0.0948617384,
-0.0779090002,
-0.0250824224,
0.0067991987,
0.007844666,
-0.0136432545,
0.0135262879,
0.0912745893,
-0.0074020978,
-0.0328063518,
-0.032496579,
0.0147470003,
-0.0159737431,
0.0505847111,
0.0100107305,
-6.684038672e-33,
-0.0019791278,
-0.0388658047,
-0.0315529555,
-0.0221116059,
0.001409949,
0.0409059674,
-0.0520091988,
-0.0112018622,
-0.0395438299,
0.0585109219,
0.002906692,
0.0445096679,
0.0171653721,
0.0165598299,
-0.0127610052,
-0.0356474742,
0.0198413022,
0.0597584955,
-0.0418571159,
-0.0020182896,
0.0530768372,
-0.0101982709,
0.0630281195,
-0.0508909188,
0.0876709446,
0.0272369366,
-0.0099085001,
0.01487171,
-0.0156823657,
0.0774758384,
0.0145652117,
0.081291467,
0.0422565676,
-0.0790676251,
0.0052804449,
0.0207798406,
-0.0657101274,
-0.0166788753,
0.0736736208,
-0.0055838241,
-0.0682930946,
-0.018488802,
0.0593828522,
-0.0027812815,
-0.0117494641,
-0.0283959117,
0.0707186013,
-0.0341473445,
-0.0193512347,
-0.000030284,
-0.0565130487,
0.0473239869,
-0.0311325844,
-0.030537894,
0.0293674711,
0.0406141169,
0.0068081468,
0.0316761024,
0.0022551878,
-0.0169397108,
0.0492192991,
0.0285185222,
0.029814586,
-0.0034270913,
0.0046840049,
0.0843900591,
0.0226570591,
0.0022367195,
-0.0319679566,
-0.0237464737,
-0.0170281753,
0.0738063157,
0.0881339535,
0.0466025509,
0.0558138229,
0.0226660427,
-0.0416151956,
0.0015191955,
-0.0345739126,
0.0340438187,
0.0414111838,
0.0144393276,
-0.1083751544,
-0.0152724413,
-0.0581940599,
-0.0105552534,
-0.0385953151,
-0.0163424332,
0.0372779071,
-0.0263987239,
-0.0361240171,
0.0133079765,
-0.0062616304,
-0.0246823337,
0.0232237782,
0.0372187793,
0.002496514,
-0.0023803178,
0.011180006,
-0.0230102818,
0.011598357,
-0.0040531699,
-0.0287201256,
0.0212335233,
0.0583982766,
-0.0420720577,
0.0656067282,
-0.0323110744,
-0.0055619306,
-0.0169505607,
-0.0778535604,
-0.0215661861,
-0.0213265903,
-0.0285038706,
0.0534359105,
0.0501588024,
-0.0547871739,
0.0198756903,
0.024125129,
0.0385698415,
-0.0071522072,
0.019283995,
-0.0305457748,
-0.0088178813,
-0.0227452684,
-0.0458681807,
0.0028111318,
-0.0272607096,
0.0338418745,
-0.0193760004,
-0.0369400829,
0.0139140934,
2.824e-7,
0.0588517599,
0.0174725782,
0.0236807503,
-0.0206608567,
0.0104502169,
0.0443024077,
-0.0109100174,
-0.0429261364,
-0.0116663435,
-0.0719828978,
-0.0273172893,
0.0235520992,
0.0513100736,
-0.0150634991,
-0.0202858783,
-0.0319224373,
-0.0146941924,
-0.0382008925,
-0.0133302445,
0.0245175138,
0.0732888728,
0.0547676459,
0.0348817892,
0.0048191985,
0.0257514268,
-0.0342340767,
-0.0080004185,
-0.0685635433,
0.0127795301,
0.0109610036,
0.0524033867,
0.0070075309,
0.0300540831,
0.0214411188,
-0.0124640893,
-0.0017929549,
0.0319565684,
0.0570115931,
0.0033758671,
-0.0320111737,
-0.0359527245,
-0.031640362,
0.0275367461,
-0.0905856043,
0.0891103148,
-0.0136455167,
-0.0597737767,
-0.0054620858,
-0.0544872992,
0.013063157,
0.0180474836,
0.0295509323,
-0.0309431124,
-0.0053907009,
-0.0152880419,
-0.0257327538,
-0.0271473136,
-0.0601053461,
-0.0531564765,
0.0288615655,
-0.0025625145,
-0.0161489472,
-0.0136335446,
-0.0093434509,
0.0367964134,
-0.0865399018,
-0.0376654677,
2.608056e-34,
0.0258601829,
-0.0048486697,
0.0460589938,
-0.0048979083,
0.045650728,
0.0095594516,
-0.0267007928,
-0.0148927467,
0.0316635557,
-0.0433751605,
0.0001528044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14266v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14266v1 | SalesBot 2.0: A Human-Like Intent-Guided Chit-Chat Dataset | 2023-08-28T02:48:49 | 2023-08-28T02:48:49 | Wen-Yu Chang, Yun-Nung Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent research on dialogue systems and corpora, there has been a
significant focus on two distinct categories: task-oriented (TOD) and
open-domain (chit-chat) dialogues. TOD systems aim to satisfy specific user
goals, such as finding a movie to watch, whereas open-domain systems primarily
focus on generating engaging conversations. A recent study by Chiu et al.
(2022) introduced SalesBot, which provides simulators and a dataset with
one-turn transition from chit-chat to task-oriented dialogues. However, the
previously generated data solely relied on BlenderBot, which raised concerns
about its long-turn naturalness and consistency during a conversation. To
address this issue, this paper aims to build SalesBot 2.0, a revised version of
the published data, by leveraging the commonsense knowledge of large language
models (LLMs) through proper prompting. The objective is to gradually bridge
the gap between chit-chat and TOD towards better naturalness and consistency.
The newly released large-scale dataset with detailed annotations exhibits
smoother transitions between topics and is more human-like in terms of
naturalness and consistency. It can serve as a valuable resource for both
academic research and commercial applications. Furthermore, our proposed
framework can be applied to generate numerous dialogues with various target
intents. | [
0.0835699514,
0.0426996574,
-0.0215438101,
0.0232812539,
-0.0251674354,
-0.014840696,
-0.0245127454,
-0.0039669019,
0.0465853922,
-0.0085061286,
-0.0679721534,
-0.004902557,
0.0126135135,
0.0384579897,
0.0051027481,
-0.0660229474,
0.0199299362,
-0.0167636815,
-0.007457105,
0.0202256851,
0.0442993343,
0.0341396444,
-0.0194077287,
0.0794493183,
-0.0211098474,
-0.0358055457,
-0.0248519722,
0.0044482192,
0.0132195447,
-0.0021484904,
0.0301338807,
0.0483727604,
0.0314644016,
0.0286229793,
0.000001911,
-0.0151477028,
0.0396164507,
-0.0358257666,
-0.0423510298,
-0.0315096825,
0.072737582,
-0.0033297306,
-0.0077377269,
0.0217247512,
-0.0605321638,
0.0542209037,
0.0449667163,
0.0346536674,
0.0776475295,
0.0704127699,
-0.0212019701,
-0.0192131568,
-0.012556063,
-0.0083738323,
0.0282856803,
-0.052174367,
-0.0176935289,
0.0343855247,
0.0371694565,
0.0056284326,
0.0091657881,
0.0309644528,
0.021624947,
-0.0505659841,
0.0170684904,
0.0507919788,
-0.0457755327,
-0.0472501963,
-0.0402707867,
0.1191437468,
0.0261893682,
-0.0028921622,
0.0035391401,
0.0071945852,
0.0403558239,
-0.0042792461,
-0.0557318404,
-0.0019465131,
-0.0060615367,
0.0018253517,
-0.0197706744,
0.0006658281,
-0.0152763836,
0.0142499562,
0.0205191858,
0.0129627166,
-0.0010391014,
-0.0172952358,
0.0009430663,
-0.0152422665,
0.0205104128,
-0.0629829317,
0.0089557981,
0.010571951,
-0.0644493029,
0.0291308127,
-0.0498169437,
0.0375032946,
0.0039367527,
-0.081674397,
-0.0038560797,
0.0332097337,
-0.029215524,
0.0359822363,
0.0424600132,
0.02471832,
0.0143395942,
0.0237914789,
-0.0462457649,
0.0170083549,
-0.0600023605,
-0.0089490907,
-0.0651454702,
0.0153047936,
-0.06219,
-0.0383963473,
-0.0151061276,
0.0648040101,
0.0076532257,
-0.0044368752,
0.0273488034,
0.0271111019,
-0.0411230549,
-0.0028430973,
-0.0307689365,
0.0062444322,
-0.0314359851,
0.0116546713,
0.044529669,
-0.0566703677,
-0.0226203501,
0.0316105857,
0.0072053801,
-0.0242368672,
-0.0112338914,
0.039002154,
-0.0201737825,
-0.0242467243,
0.0063490956,
-0.0099774674,
-0.0315881781,
-0.0581420772,
-0.0237706043,
-0.0405886769,
0.0395765156,
-0.003782758,
-0.0039630011,
-0.0163472742,
0.0022074438,
0.0431289449,
-0.0275415722,
0.071140781,
-0.0303172916,
0.0221437272,
0.0334275961,
0.0092411395,
-0.0065029021,
0.0565408953,
0.0292837489,
0.0375775918,
0.0352891274,
-0.0124772172,
0.0216499679,
0.0434779972,
-0.0222905856,
-0.0196030457,
0.0241051205,
0.0156927407,
-0.0171666984,
0.0434231646,
0.0245602559,
0.0461448096,
-0.058752235,
-0.024312865,
0.0626088083,
0.0464478396,
-0.0516716614,
0.0211359989,
0.0440317094,
0.0709214956,
0.03357362,
-0.0006866122,
-0.0272715278,
0.0044457284,
-0.0381279066,
-0.020978447,
0.0206246804,
-0.0158524457,
-0.029474685,
-0.01365609,
0.0215641186,
-0.0195596553,
0.051998049,
-0.0257597771,
0.0303378738,
0.0199701916,
-0.0380247049,
0.0294919163,
0.0110852979,
-0.0440878645,
-0.0495312996,
-0.0180471707,
0.0208875537,
0.0839069486,
0.0500446633,
-0.0236493573,
-0.0744179636,
-0.0102470759,
-0.0131138964,
0.0873941034,
0.0397145711,
-0.0538077168,
0.0076916423,
-0.0533673316,
0.0262689013,
-0.0041820123,
-0.0092042182,
-0.0016478453,
0.007796545,
-0.010187705,
-0.0150568997,
-0.0351454206,
0.0032833894,
0.0065595531,
-0.0265815165,
0.0193791762,
-0.0247774217,
-0.0196932349,
0.0255747158,
0.030247312,
0.0001890279,
-0.0255446155,
0.021249583,
-0.0064572063,
-0.00126403,
0.076939024,
-0.0269826483,
-0.0400742665,
0.0387175195,
-0.0055053579,
-0.0460881256,
0.0550532825,
-0.0025838111,
-0.0339626484,
-0.0049877283,
-0.0334830992,
0.0386556797,
-0.0307563003,
0.0002953823,
0.0201891214,
0.0216191914,
-0.0018960034,
0.0278241653,
0.0126933213,
-0.0210416038,
0.0591613278,
-0.0349982046,
0.0029140352,
-0.0296236277,
0.0218977761,
0.033072032,
-0.0151177663,
0.0144076282,
0.0327233672,
0.0343621224,
-0.0656784475,
-0.016647486,
-0.1118426695,
-0.0133656384,
-0.01160751,
-0.019934576,
0.0043793661,
0.0130346296,
-0.0167609993,
-0.0332200639,
-0.0421118103,
0.0493701324,
0.0137279248,
-0.0001718308,
0.0424001589,
-0.0200457834,
-0.0245622136,
-0.0290215742,
0.0299634449,
0.0203533545,
0.0118228141,
0.0124740945,
0.0000571203,
-0.0689076558,
0.040128842,
-0.0266385935,
0.0159791708,
-0.0226597786,
-0.0614199825,
0.0255122203,
0.0025285135,
0.0562212616,
0.048955366,
0.0410718061,
0.0267849211,
-0.008384712,
-0.0261721928,
-0.0546785779,
0.0030643896,
-0.0085831508,
0.0135833761,
-0.0515687577,
-0.0460294299,
0.0230374578,
0.0470101759,
-0.0099268984,
0.0391533002,
-0.0788195953,
0.0049245721,
0.0237945858,
-0.0403399095,
-0.0113167372,
0.0359525196,
-0.0429161899,
0.0197825618,
-0.0029892123,
-0.0571679883,
0.0768539459,
-0.0157666244,
-0.0400245786,
-0.0362720527,
-0.0051025855,
-0.0023256766,
0.047623381,
-0.0210607722,
0.0063897492,
0.0215933453,
-0.0386006869,
-0.0146742444,
0.0177845396,
0.0136738075,
-0.0316737853,
0.0268009584,
-0.0609016977,
0.0166106448,
-0.0052683912,
-0.0567597896,
-0.0527920574,
-0.0891544297,
-0.0375459492,
0.0003722821,
0.0475695916,
-0.0447136685,
-0.0455766954,
0.0166249648,
-0.0065147639,
0.0558465943,
0.0095312856,
-0.018386472,
-0.0047903568,
-0.0091432631,
0.0656570345,
0.0624055974,
-0.0376921967,
-0.0007294485,
0.0451462902,
0.0348121449,
0.0254028141,
-0.0298009645,
-0.0202813148,
-0.0262085311,
0.0287720822,
0.0250668302,
0.0096127829,
0.0158501007,
0.0615271963,
-0.0076509076,
-0.0389148667,
0.102186434,
0.0115472144,
-0.0306203458,
0.00391457,
-0.0387484208,
0.0222454555,
0.0077819959,
0.0231220033,
-0.0820951089,
-0.0433995649,
0.0035929231,
0.0181242675,
0.0082772067,
-0.0381762311,
-0.0043470976,
-0.1075608581,
0.0318207853,
-0.0033204583,
-0.0775145441,
-0.0250658318,
-0.007758785,
-0.0191565882,
-0.0198824666,
0.0392219275,
-0.0014718175,
-0.0050027398,
-0.0200701486,
0.0055966321,
-0.0188970827,
-0.0473523103,
0.0358071253,
-0.0085272342,
0.0927471295,
0.063625142,
0.0757501498,
0.0319671519,
0.0126542347,
0.0100973267,
0.0423527695,
-0.0083496226,
0.0010376974,
0.0391406827,
-0.0115023255,
-0.0199524071,
-0.0325114168,
0.0417699553,
-0.0404551551,
-0.0310011245,
0.0310297385,
0.0309131984,
-0.0436242186,
0.0074449587,
-0.0137503641,
0.0535597652,
0.0278964564,
0.0760147423,
0.0211161431,
-0.0550629795,
-0.0221811794,
-0.0392208174,
-0.0187585987,
-0.0040539284,
-0.0321734175,
-0.0032495982,
-0.0077188145,
-0.0234686956,
-0.0850934312,
-0.055206541,
0.0354904942,
0.031398613,
0.0128743239,
-0.0125403721,
0.0307523441,
0.0148611441,
0.0132792853,
0.0290777348,
-0.0502130464,
0.0108436458,
-0.0737095103,
-0.0216429569,
0.0287111606,
-0.0909347162,
0.0001387024,
0.0244054962,
-0.0490085855,
-0.0539726466,
-0.0327641368,
0.0513541251,
0.0251597837,
0.0466724411,
-0.0233141184,
-0.0251760427,
-0.0507467575,
0.0602546111,
-0.0649651811,
-0.0094667561,
0.0394926518,
0.0648765415,
-0.0010269472,
0.0429937057,
-0.0237867218,
-0.0109970123,
-0.0261767693,
0.0380828194,
-0.011855375,
-0.0660103336,
0.0340303928,
0.0187199228,
0.0272752587,
0.0058963201,
0.0072134142,
-0.03728972,
0.0095146587,
-0.0206515528,
-0.0294058975,
-0.0729679763,
0.009915404,
0.0076646446,
-0.0165869892,
-0.0021732014,
0.0196295455,
-0.0813062266,
0.0409807451,
-0.0204130076,
-0.0334722996,
0.0278921556,
0.0122857457,
0.0107475892,
-0.0276607256,
-0.0022588465,
-0.0065547158,
-0.0207790732,
0.0362382568,
0.0078902142,
0.1012658477,
0.0193988048,
-0.0587294176,
0.0328224674,
0.0640359372,
-0.0370423943,
-0.0282116923,
0.0141328955,
0.0403183438,
0.0260804612,
0.0052708574,
0.0662155896,
-0.0541685447,
0.0226837248,
-0.0302143805,
0.062900722,
-0.0148007777,
-0.0454788134,
0.0183432046,
0.0075083002,
-0.0348363966,
-0.0058384291,
0.0715064183,
-0.0529911481,
0.012152886,
0.0125126317,
-0.0163944028,
-0.0507818311,
-0.0250438787,
0.0270372145,
0.0230994001,
0.0119458018,
-0.0056946143,
-0.0769151449,
-0.0303748362,
0.000696483,
-0.004087904,
0.0060598305,
-0.0141169,
0.0440729223,
0.0740643069,
-0.0354261212,
0.0035475059,
-0.0362479836,
0.0114811063,
-0.0490992889,
-0.0067598121,
-0.0577683747,
-5.649462952e-33,
-0.0160029978,
-0.0206903853,
0.0288281254,
0.0154786343,
-0.0547865033,
-0.0335327499,
-0.02400559,
-0.0056128255,
0.0092252782,
0.0152840326,
-0.0305197891,
0.0407562107,
0.0106630139,
0.0183295831,
0.014312054,
-0.0430223271,
0.0473332666,
0.0048112231,
-0.0405187309,
0.0535161272,
0.0131160868,
0.0049025053,
0.0662246794,
-0.0366294459,
0.0113985129,
0.0046943543,
-0.0092924004,
0.0186214708,
0.0187744144,
0.0510533415,
-0.0252456516,
0.0664478391,
0.0063864007,
-0.0123089589,
-0.0115281036,
0.0498860516,
-0.0237606578,
-0.0043611149,
0.0431434549,
0.0149225602,
-0.0080270562,
-0.0143914353,
0.0019227293,
-0.0499575399,
-0.0036324558,
0.0382378213,
0.0128769148,
-0.0490057617,
0.0038703235,
0.0482380912,
-0.075269796,
0.0151730254,
-0.0232990999,
-0.1170130819,
-0.0033197673,
0.0866345614,
-0.005122338,
-0.028582111,
-0.0085838009,
0.0669154599,
-0.0401173458,
-0.0281028487,
0.0432535745,
0.006929473,
0.0317100063,
0.0909015462,
0.0358548611,
0.0346544273,
-0.0005027951,
-0.0058509018,
0.0048493026,
0.0711206645,
0.002406986,
0.0613640323,
-0.0042252173,
0.0020646967,
0.0015930533,
0.0408991575,
0.0300683361,
0.012137007,
0.0081665013,
0.0085008312,
-0.0438704528,
-0.0122740222,
0.0047614691,
0.0297450144,
-0.002985097,
-0.0082241595,
0.0144295096,
0.0045446581,
0.0047424822,
-0.028489653,
0.029688064,
-0.0367864035,
0.0041376329,
0.0290265735,
-0.0455222353,
0.0142026693,
-0.004281213,
0.0028996367,
-0.0500176027,
-0.0213590302,
0.053517323,
0.0061207064,
0.0215430297,
0.0514763258,
-0.0294650458,
0.0247749891,
-0.0156346466,
-0.0140431887,
-0.0305924341,
0.0418207571,
-0.0597529374,
0.0164184328,
0.0416874923,
0.0253745485,
-0.0490823612,
0.0758760497,
-0.0311767329,
-0.0181718264,
-0.0470267199,
-0.0191231873,
0.0067715691,
-0.0129384212,
-0.0178994965,
0.0154189887,
-0.0245843623,
-0.0468120836,
-0.0076008718,
-0.0535308868,
-0.0199030023,
-0.02843819,
2.622e-7,
-0.0196364298,
0.0342141539,
0.0160838533,
0.0615778379,
0.0008779771,
0.0423240699,
-0.0047432599,
0.04115263,
0.021210866,
-0.0366510786,
0.0198570974,
0.0153404111,
0.0696508065,
-0.0151962023,
-0.1247282624,
-0.0233440436,
-0.0505454727,
-0.049631428,
-0.0315253772,
-0.0025482348,
0.0412913002,
0.0666645989,
0.0132225286,
-0.0112648346,
0.0099842492,
-0.0137367127,
0.0385429971,
-0.0698686317,
-0.0179633982,
0.0205371734,
0.0107249105,
-0.0133673428,
-0.0010108156,
-0.003484444,
0.0129970387,
0.0115680145,
0.0289697554,
0.0594558641,
0.0064141313,
-0.0234935582,
-0.0049829632,
-0.0224204939,
-0.0127368411,
-0.0187466033,
0.023898907,
-0.0603822619,
-0.0475455858,
-0.0495371521,
0.0015340986,
-0.0068365103,
0.0110494951,
-0.0473942645,
-0.0071846005,
0.0071997344,
0.0081213992,
-0.0122050187,
0.0109069981,
-0.0361313149,
0.0201247111,
0.0001972862,
-0.0755389035,
-0.0730805397,
-0.0311305206,
-0.0163638014,
-0.0108299749,
-0.0356876217,
0.0199603848,
1.858580891e-34,
0.0288077258,
-0.0033640489,
0.0030284473,
0.0499732643,
0.0346711278,
-0.0081900163,
0.0298156831,
0.0173653048,
0.0463537164,
-0.0604601093,
-0.0140499985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14242v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14242v1 | The Cultural Psychology of Large Language Models: Is ChatGPT a Holistic or Analytic Thinker? | 2023-08-28T01:05:18 | 2023-08-28T01:05:18 | Chuanyang Jin, Songyang Zhang, Tianmin Shu, Zhihan Cui | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The prevalent use of Large Language Models (LLMs) has necessitated studying
their mental models, yielding noteworthy theoretical and practical
implications. Current research has demonstrated that state-of-the-art LLMs,
such as ChatGPT, exhibit certain theory of mind capabilities and possess
relatively stable Big Five and/or MBTI personality traits. In addition,
cognitive process features form an essential component of these mental models.
Research in cultural psychology indicated significant differences in the
cognitive processes of Eastern and Western people when processing information
and making judgments. While Westerners predominantly exhibit analytical
thinking that isolates things from their environment to analyze their nature
independently, Easterners often showcase holistic thinking, emphasizing
relationships and adopting a global viewpoint. In our research, we probed the
cultural cognitive traits of ChatGPT. We employed two scales that directly
measure the cognitive process: the Analysis-Holism Scale (AHS) and the Triadic
Categorization Task (TCT). Additionally, we used two scales that investigate
the value differences shaped by cultural thinking: the Dialectical Self Scale
(DSS) and the Self-construal Scale (SCS). In cognitive process tests (AHS/TCT),
ChatGPT consistently tends towards Eastern holistic thinking, but regarding
value judgments (DSS/SCS), ChatGPT does not significantly lean towards the East
or the West. We suggest that the result could be attributed to both the
training paradigm and the training data in LLM development. We discuss the
potential value of this finding for AI research and directions for future
research. | [
0.0287840702,
0.0307126474,
-0.0369836204,
0.0072558806,
-0.0347001478,
0.021226855,
0.0287917964,
-0.0377749465,
0.0558068901,
-0.0218642,
-0.0655934215,
-0.0437765494,
-0.005867464,
0.0179872122,
0.0058804718,
-0.0366262607,
0.0193404816,
0.0152723296,
0.0683297813,
0.0117731746,
-0.0243173335,
0.032208588,
0.004649221,
0.0369427986,
0.0165698733,
-0.0163455829,
0.0108062141,
-0.061338786,
0.0571378544,
-0.0433634184,
-0.0124515425,
0.0256915092,
0.0116516957,
0.0144215906,
0.0000021736,
-0.0562013276,
-0.0069951657,
-0.0272538178,
0.0759040639,
0.0121308127,
0.0745405629,
0.0494280793,
0.0125664817,
0.0254065357,
-0.0446178652,
-0.0081358552,
-0.0105573758,
0.0818727911,
0.009311894,
0.0214991774,
0.0230733063,
-0.0641668066,
-0.0056034536,
0.0038837704,
-0.0532646514,
-0.0023071941,
0.0464360863,
0.0309045929,
-0.0415466018,
0.008893135,
-0.0339554362,
0.0096878996,
0.0128431786,
-0.0037200807,
-0.0370143801,
-0.0214560144,
-0.0167321861,
-0.0312431958,
0.0681559071,
0.0124298008,
0.0830536187,
0.0039999159,
-0.0128911668,
0.0168022644,
-0.0030701086,
-0.0238545854,
-0.0321611799,
0.0780419782,
-0.0229076389,
0.0079623526,
0.0467164591,
0.0162815414,
-0.0424383171,
0.0096484041,
-0.018780876,
0.056108512,
-0.0475342833,
-0.0071916101,
-0.0152597819,
-0.0104614012,
-0.0238791797,
-0.0570049658,
-0.0140760206,
0.0306879617,
-0.0131753301,
-0.0154294856,
0.0477973856,
0.0180056691,
-0.0114030922,
-0.0548488684,
0.0205352567,
0.0663348511,
-0.010583546,
-0.0310361627,
0.0323626027,
0.0530449711,
0.0407823324,
0.0037155747,
-0.0386052914,
0.0097628785,
-0.0455775112,
-0.0133576812,
0.0412967503,
0.0029161107,
0.0486215353,
0.0206563752,
-0.0899593979,
-0.0219230074,
-0.0382091962,
-0.0007671947,
-0.053833317,
-0.0396835022,
0.0684213266,
0.0266454108,
-0.0543712229,
0.083086051,
-0.0551971085,
-0.0201740526,
-0.0453034267,
-0.046704255,
0.0680225417,
0.0095218476,
-0.0366799831,
0.0009799574,
0.007658462,
-0.0122854989,
-0.0006127847,
-0.0075010923,
-0.0504352041,
0.0024488547,
-0.000175185,
-0.0565318279,
0.0336943641,
-0.0282179154,
-0.0249128696,
0.0489266962,
0.001465735,
-0.0517235883,
0.0035016348,
0.008126772,
-0.0422000736,
-0.0060833031,
0.0535907298,
0.0536586344,
0.0314913876,
0.0241518114,
0.010999239,
0.0228944384,
0.0134622734,
0.0101999762,
0.0110285981,
-0.0357822031,
-0.0131437043,
-0.0264648944,
-0.0532728098,
-0.0201192051,
-0.0531088188,
0.0019431245,
-0.0491375588,
0.0006621265,
0.0537079163,
0.059681274,
-0.0218506772,
0.0490774997,
0.053204149,
0.0678055808,
0.0173068084,
0.0619639046,
0.0302772596,
0.0438405573,
0.0151095595,
-0.0000911397,
-0.0359405056,
0.0222156495,
0.011154741,
-0.0184846986,
0.0031837148,
0.0204318091,
-0.0207264069,
-0.0278972778,
-0.0352073498,
0.0226216502,
0.0150465351,
0.0136502311,
0.013530625,
-0.0527881905,
0.0586543083,
-0.0279783737,
0.0360295363,
-0.0239955857,
-0.0548463315,
-0.0638001859,
0.0109461993,
0.0468352288,
-0.0460900217,
0.0224324372,
0.0228352472,
-0.0164479744,
-0.0067254454,
0.0287333857,
0.0691013262,
0.0112805692,
-0.0712717921,
-0.0031568201,
0.0087944074,
-0.0377063118,
-0.0192371923,
0.0142860161,
-0.0190522671,
0.0545955487,
0.0018246194,
0.0709386319,
0.0142187774,
-0.0278202966,
-0.0237235203,
0.0202689841,
-0.0534132384,
0.0228635892,
0.0175534021,
0.0252005979,
-0.0185553096,
0.0416710675,
-0.0209324602,
0.0093484465,
-0.02350647,
0.0659913644,
-0.0352229923,
0.0629806519,
0.0042364742,
-0.0345278233,
-0.0178853329,
-0.0420098826,
0.0592955612,
0.0127970167,
0.0446503051,
0.0175364409,
-0.0004474856,
-0.0201491173,
0.0300278515,
-0.0610355437,
0.0136270933,
-0.0189165287,
0.0530285351,
-0.0336877368,
0.0335237458,
-0.0243059844,
-0.0490268692,
0.0566048399,
0.0287651718,
-0.0528577976,
0.0030312683,
0.0126360422,
-0.0050025154,
0.0259515624,
0.0075389431,
-0.0493325815,
-0.0178567506,
-0.0908259228,
-0.0315547585,
0.0253133345,
0.0016960008,
-0.0022111852,
-0.0400971584,
-0.0566730946,
0.0281991307,
-0.0342112705,
0.0333663672,
0.0387956277,
0.0678675473,
-0.0036007864,
-0.0348220058,
0.0107154129,
0.0417418517,
0.0046796519,
-0.034668643,
-0.0040465859,
-0.0236241091,
-0.0141935227,
-0.0216421392,
-0.014991153,
-0.0664186925,
-0.0159960501,
-0.0589709058,
-0.0685852841,
0.0388868079,
0.0189882815,
0.0359935723,
0.0124130324,
0.0255551338,
0.0194913503,
0.0664600804,
-0.0107298559,
0.0291128065,
-0.0134427045,
0.0417275839,
-0.0155399023,
0.0038474158,
-0.0990927741,
-0.0559598282,
0.0735230222,
0.0035414787,
0.0186905637,
0.0022069013,
0.0488988832,
-0.0728963614,
-0.0208649617,
-0.0023773655,
-0.0134132663,
0.0087555377,
0.0628949106,
0.0122821797,
0.0066620274,
0.0402502231,
0.0286778323,
0.0071078613,
0.0019028996,
-0.0089574009,
-0.0338325575,
0.0782543123,
0.0155819841,
0.0105879698,
0.0638772175,
-0.0134272352,
-0.0606977046,
-0.0332607366,
-0.0073605669,
-0.0272898916,
0.0335207619,
-0.0236997176,
-0.0546290427,
-0.0417292751,
-0.0063757435,
-0.0469242111,
0.0244420692,
-0.0442827381,
0.0197445098,
0.0294747632,
-0.0106710596,
0.0051720673,
0.0129864747,
0.0817512497,
-0.0225126613,
-0.0385988913,
0.0191526283,
0.0242855735,
-0.0524255671,
0.0396187529,
0.0213021282,
0.0560761467,
-0.0011440382,
0.0434964411,
0.0284275729,
0.0141034834,
-0.0178651679,
0.0381239615,
0.0011825529,
0.0311297495,
0.030599298,
-0.0465789363,
0.0318823047,
0.0448686518,
-0.0144082019,
0.0332624093,
0.0921871439,
0.0109405061,
-0.007535459,
0.0094081219,
-0.0487859324,
-0.0222670734,
0.0438460857,
0.0379321203,
-0.0699843541,
0.031910345,
-0.009301696,
-0.0346124507,
-0.075101316,
-0.0654018149,
-0.0041641039,
-0.0589945056,
0.0001688601,
0.008256332,
-0.0122056538,
-0.0001195771,
0.027856458,
-0.0121830953,
0.0092425933,
-0.0008306651,
0.0031429881,
-0.0298306625,
-0.0041411389,
-0.0095853275,
-0.0507039502,
-0.0065697581,
0.0598922819,
-0.0143449716,
-0.0003103257,
-0.0327680409,
0.0245791338,
-0.0119711515,
-0.0560106635,
-0.000716311,
0.0066743102,
0.0166870393,
0.0035967214,
-0.0480228998,
-0.0165498126,
0.0137326056,
-0.0160229411,
-0.0348169468,
-0.0047511621,
0.0005456312,
0.0143568404,
0.0450583845,
0.0019298106,
-0.0517217964,
0.0157151874,
0.0350573212,
-0.0162143353,
0.0612196289,
-0.0108789615,
-0.0503119379,
0.0253592599,
-0.0010439182,
-0.0345085673,
0.0824123621,
-0.0902715996,
0.046001941,
-0.0048682024,
-0.0116187921,
-0.0224102195,
-0.1216823906,
-0.018605791,
-0.0355245955,
-0.015290617,
-0.0462771431,
0.0044514313,
0.0319336876,
-0.0668023005,
0.0205370821,
0.0071868547,
0.0163308606,
0.02026801,
0.0024894816,
0.0257370211,
-0.0431144089,
0.0089176241,
-0.004972015,
0.0072097308,
-0.0149481473,
0.0533228368,
0.0166444536,
0.0080831507,
-0.0472843982,
0.0418444835,
-0.0162023269,
-0.0344064794,
-0.0154691804,
-0.0211021751,
0.0375029817,
-0.0320579261,
0.0691927373,
0.0169509556,
0.0099739423,
0.0097062243,
0.0402854644,
0.0304074772,
-0.0235233046,
-0.0266105141,
-0.0035016013,
0.0241715144,
0.0149549684,
0.0104393438,
-0.0289941914,
0.0409881473,
-0.037954431,
-0.0649572536,
-0.0568410009,
-0.0524317808,
-0.0184725299,
-0.0660787895,
0.0235359669,
0.0103529887,
-0.0086864885,
-0.000157578,
0.0193868913,
-0.0308440551,
-0.0013800028,
0.0315445289,
-0.0030104963,
0.0450964756,
-0.0260497723,
0.0012561181,
-0.0441127606,
-0.0130493948,
-0.0048713502,
0.0171182062,
0.0029621003,
0.1490837485,
-0.0119892349,
-0.0221434049,
0.0112511106,
0.0231790747,
-0.0224644355,
-0.0914942175,
0.0632370487,
0.0014178251,
0.0394272171,
-0.0267952494,
0.0146702537,
-0.0518989004,
0.0082047377,
-0.0208061617,
0.0118669765,
-0.0101437084,
-0.061651919,
-0.0082480041,
-0.0107007772,
-0.014862244,
-0.040412996,
0.0226782393,
-0.0300251208,
-0.0180574432,
0.0039754519,
-0.0612617545,
-0.0374246351,
0.0084247747,
-0.0068650716,
0.0037098872,
-0.0148020266,
0.028142076,
-0.0957179815,
-0.0647380278,
-0.013945736,
-0.0100070061,
-0.0132618425,
-0.0324244015,
-0.0090459129,
0.0635037944,
-0.0044498863,
-0.0485359505,
-0.0436120071,
0.0191006977,
-0.0422248282,
0.0109357219,
0.0103678871,
-6.351149692e-33,
-0.0367148705,
-0.0099558653,
0.0605844073,
-0.0288336668,
-0.0338559113,
-0.0494533516,
-0.0058829063,
0.0636366457,
-0.0685244203,
0.0219022706,
-0.0311364885,
0.0029130178,
-0.0019598322,
-0.0363815539,
0.0640771985,
0.0346642546,
-0.0025149551,
-0.0167080835,
-0.0032331808,
-0.0303185824,
0.054122746,
-0.0266913623,
0.0851145983,
-0.0488652587,
0.0025245056,
0.0034886601,
0.0277950615,
0.0285650361,
0.023268627,
-0.0127115641,
-0.0246610157,
0.0084964149,
0.0676219314,
0.0107384929,
-0.0067898356,
0.0007548422,
-0.0151446359,
-0.0596683137,
0.0210446473,
0.0214191992,
0.0452915989,
-0.0322128683,
-0.0018741308,
-0.0238383301,
-0.0319139063,
0.0147705115,
0.0114245275,
-0.0175552759,
0.052702263,
0.0469685495,
-0.0276536755,
-0.0032978924,
-0.0029077521,
0.0328496397,
-0.0411487967,
0.020880701,
-0.0309226811,
0.0007369181,
-0.0595014282,
0.0238632001,
0.0173132885,
-0.0032384351,
0.048585806,
0.0123066008,
0.0216233116,
0.0524670519,
0.0522185676,
0.0458602645,
-0.0514556356,
-0.0512389764,
0.0608143806,
-0.0086463541,
0.0043910448,
0.0393509828,
-0.0364053883,
-0.0637944639,
-0.0214826111,
-0.0575512461,
0.0742656589,
0.0356660821,
0.010524597,
0.0192944482,
-0.004786788,
-0.0306927133,
-0.0048349081,
-0.036570821,
-0.0207494851,
-0.0124182189,
0.0034572289,
-0.0218077395,
0.0322442912,
-0.001104575,
0.0829899982,
-0.022761032,
0.017968988,
-0.0089357812,
-0.0495811179,
0.0119584706,
0.0158469174,
-0.0098231267,
-0.0567540638,
-0.0008989226,
-0.0633930564,
0.0047422023,
0.0049895472,
0.0311155319,
0.0038917176,
0.0063675269,
-0.0270835627,
-0.0323714875,
-0.0062643271,
-0.0091249496,
0.0181353949,
-0.0469198301,
0.034498293,
0.027582841,
0.0015970861,
-0.0344891325,
0.0508706607,
-0.0010443275,
-0.0450491942,
0.017986957,
-0.0211234037,
0.013604668,
0.0177123863,
0.0144719072,
-0.0294805728,
0.0635137334,
0.0540693924,
-0.0491111204,
-0.0077975974,
-0.0186539665,
3.013e-7,
-0.0133103253,
0.0522828102,
-0.0588237718,
0.0388268195,
0.0436205864,
0.0373679064,
-0.0073094629,
-0.0235123355,
0.062343087,
-0.0139914667,
-0.0097397342,
0.0032887841,
0.0553440228,
0.0404934697,
-0.0254625939,
-0.0142338509,
-0.0261272304,
-0.0078815948,
-0.025504861,
0.0620191395,
0.0197286084,
0.0037369602,
0.0119713638,
0.0062318477,
-0.0443163104,
0.0077555757,
0.0434688032,
-0.0100519732,
0.0056589548,
0.0293073114,
-0.0163762998,
-0.0442134663,
0.0193893258,
0.0287892371,
0.0346604884,
0.007625977,
0.0445771441,
0.0526493713,
0.0262731351,
0.0567261316,
0.0273018852,
0.0308629815,
-0.0196978394,
-0.1020632982,
0.0531349853,
-0.0904550403,
-0.0538649485,
-0.0067551173,
0.0130344694,
-0.027535269,
0.0490909852,
0.0024841893,
-0.0122846114,
0.0565892197,
0.027764881,
-0.0463098474,
0.0289346557,
-0.0073773493,
0.0118480427,
-0.0171857346,
0.0064696898,
-0.0271651112,
-0.0183894169,
-0.039779149,
0.0090047987,
-0.0018296711,
-0.0008938793,
2.61448173e-34,
0.0078238938,
-0.0094372667,
0.0010166018,
-0.0441462509,
0.0787642971,
0.0204286408,
0.0016474728,
0.0481281243,
-0.0044482155,
-0.0251019187,
-0.032017909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14217v1 | Generations of Knowledge Graphs: The Crazy Ideas and the Business Impact | 2023-08-27T22:35:27 | 2023-08-27T22:35:27 | Xin Luna Dong | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL | Knowledge Graphs (KGs) have been used to support a wide range of
applications, from web search to personal assistant. In this paper, we describe
three generations of knowledge graphs: entity-based KGs, which have been
supporting general search and question answering (e.g., at Google and Bing);
text-rich KGs, which have been supporting search and recommendations for
products, bio-informatics, etc. (e.g., at Amazon and Alibaba); and the emerging
integration of KGs and LLMs, which we call dual neural KGs. We describe the
characteristics of each generation of KGs, the crazy ideas behind the scenes in
constructing such KGs, and the techniques developed over time to enable
industry impact. In addition, we use KGs as examples to demonstrate a recipe to
evolve research ideas from innovations to production practice, and then to the
next level of innovations, to advance both science and business. | [
0.0716411397,
0.0083780084,
-0.0101370085,
0.0425090045,
-0.0092984242,
-0.0385728627,
-0.023904331,
0.050721731,
0.0798928589,
-0.0452472754,
-0.0019342713,
0.0405459888,
-0.0504310802,
0.0697415248,
0.0141710956,
0.028847238,
0.0216038376,
0.0329319648,
0.0333141237,
0.0128871622,
-0.0069317245,
0.0245879591,
-0.0109731071,
0.013129916,
-0.0000930287,
-0.0031432363,
-0.0053361855,
-0.0029000486,
0.0194551032,
-0.0394600965,
0.0044830218,
-0.0109146908,
0.022507634,
0.0434350483,
0.000001794,
-0.0436938405,
0.016681999,
0.0105678607,
-0.0511299148,
-0.0076484601,
-0.013872508,
0.0348378383,
0.0372030064,
-0.0136703141,
-0.0586923584,
0.0162265524,
0.0070225825,
0.0448519327,
0.0049941307,
0.0480575264,
-0.0048234812,
-0.0533424504,
0.0393410064,
-0.0239099208,
0.0450606644,
-0.048341874,
0.0296027679,
-0.0368252844,
0.0383224376,
0.0150648672,
0.0095806904,
0.0491098613,
-0.0021219966,
-0.0249171015,
0.0834929198,
0.0553972162,
0.0084300097,
0.0330183282,
-0.0040950375,
0.0871224627,
0.009796706,
0.0083844261,
0.0032418428,
-0.0009896131,
0.0108967572,
-0.0134353423,
-0.029850699,
-0.0339161716,
-0.0192306321,
0.0094795767,
-0.0373315215,
-0.032934919,
0.0656336769,
0.007614431,
-0.0016377885,
0.0894621611,
-0.0108085629,
-0.0338855088,
0.0506894812,
0.0023565851,
0.0467306897,
-0.0417311639,
0.0290144105,
0.0526623875,
0.0237818304,
0.0256458558,
0.0237411633,
0.0195794795,
0.0031931773,
-0.0695017949,
-0.0114434315,
-0.0102655897,
0.0041686008,
0.0819628164,
-0.0644323751,
0.0081540253,
-0.0323964246,
-0.0085606053,
-0.0153135583,
-0.0186504293,
-0.0729817301,
-0.0242741928,
-0.014531279,
0.0434780978,
-0.0191601515,
-0.0434485115,
-0.0212430824,
0.0562870912,
-0.0033128322,
0.0089735361,
0.0123335682,
0.0673410669,
0.0674507022,
0.003134818,
-0.1020919085,
0.0185415521,
-0.0179078914,
0.0164213218,
0.0079937233,
0.0174732525,
0.0404592976,
0.0105227074,
0.0024149036,
0.0241824798,
-0.0019202383,
0.0656806231,
0.0289393086,
0.0014159895,
-0.072510846,
-0.0564680137,
0.0100857234,
-0.023934558,
0.0208684951,
-0.0395794958,
0.0440796167,
-4.263e-7,
-0.0175209586,
-0.0467960238,
0.0253420696,
0.008463908,
-0.0618666448,
0.045408953,
-0.0499998182,
-0.0042114686,
0.0193748213,
0.0286065061,
-0.0147353737,
0.0422034711,
0.0310160499,
-0.0051212404,
0.0625087842,
0.0401995927,
-0.0183975175,
0.0092203692,
0.0183183234,
-0.0407878049,
0.0294440091,
0.0139948288,
-0.0497190394,
0.0660113916,
-0.0111603877,
0.008788106,
-0.0362780541,
0.0115366792,
0.0703404993,
0.0352001823,
0.0387457423,
0.0340679474,
0.0303990636,
-0.0186174065,
-0.0006609361,
-0.0453889519,
-0.0094559891,
0.021877192,
-0.0478510074,
0.0029495757,
-0.0134503562,
-0.0166621134,
-0.0295541473,
-0.0091619529,
0.0258384738,
0.0265935753,
0.0237827823,
0.0222970285,
0.0596197732,
-0.0249410924,
-0.0224025734,
0.002360686,
-0.003514749,
-0.0339539312,
0.0369256139,
-0.0367029533,
-0.0039495369,
0.134262085,
0.0645582378,
-0.0111905886,
-0.0256533567,
0.0451189652,
-0.0732288435,
0.0303995516,
0.0219697095,
-0.0225238353,
-0.0269582178,
-0.043128062,
-0.0455381796,
-0.0429408662,
-0.0175872929,
-0.0149422372,
-0.0076165167,
0.0529685244,
-0.0000283538,
-0.0245413072,
0.0302437562,
-0.0186969992,
-0.0300781652,
0.0521821417,
0.0024733241,
0.0161427408,
-0.0256077163,
0.0797425807,
0.035782028,
0.0161790624,
0.0610238276,
-0.0319361575,
-0.0668092743,
-0.0112891728,
0.0260649137,
-0.0038551628,
0.032377135,
-0.0281483866,
0.0300092865,
-0.0167613197,
-0.003734085,
-0.0328306109,
0.0151932994,
-0.0170406513,
0.0774763301,
-0.003091105,
-0.0365457013,
-0.0103971343,
-0.0289966408,
-0.0288447756,
0.0733926818,
-0.002155998,
0.0017911876,
-0.0426222719,
-0.022886619,
0.0132698976,
-0.0449135676,
-0.0174693875,
0.0005573211,
0.031338796,
0.0197661463,
0.0283595268,
-0.039057672,
-0.0558056049,
0.0357655846,
-0.0943123624,
0.022056574,
0.0184367727,
0.0259354319,
-0.003986103,
-0.0002249437,
0.0281847622,
-0.0512081459,
-0.0485173576,
0.0890885517,
-0.0036579862,
-0.0066079749,
0.048251655,
0.0632043481,
-0.0118327942,
0.0031571866,
-0.0172319654,
-0.0270885359,
0.0182279777,
0.0320940539,
-0.0171592496,
-0.0406651795,
0.0153036462,
-0.085530825,
0.0175316669,
-0.0128139053,
0.0358263217,
0.008550399,
-0.0288014058,
0.0057509146,
0.0274266526,
-0.0339528769,
0.0169792026,
-0.0075397575,
-0.0287248697,
-0.0403513424,
0.017264042,
-0.0463096388,
0.0517356023,
-0.0522838905,
0.0351190604,
0.0140549624,
-0.0131445704,
-0.0032799123,
-0.0360606462,
-0.0241823774,
0.0503019914,
0.0244045425,
-0.0101889381,
-0.050121624,
-0.0064235562,
0.027500093,
0.0437174663,
-0.0166946612,
-0.0098169735,
0.058302179,
0.0441023074,
0.0133180311,
-0.0028823158,
-0.0516088232,
-0.041357711,
0.0566230416,
-0.0248986073,
0.0095541785,
-0.0158964675,
-0.0093947919,
-0.026576262,
0.0539530255,
-0.0281389374,
-0.0354529433,
0.051617384,
-0.020107206,
0.0287777595,
0.0251443852,
-0.0350474156,
-0.0298359524,
-0.005749783,
-0.0286355801,
0.0391512588,
0.0361095332,
-0.0425327234,
-0.0376963876,
-0.0153456926,
0.0015951482,
0.0137659749,
0.003447826,
-0.0341624171,
-0.0032774066,
0.0353682972,
0.0315596014,
-0.0078029628,
0.0018201312,
0.0496043488,
0.0020242331,
0.0611997396,
-0.0090644453,
-0.0668606684,
-0.0238067862,
-0.0217349194,
0.0028040733,
-0.0701843724,
-0.0358951539,
-0.0180933923,
-0.0182472579,
-0.0324465446,
0.0211714897,
0.0528621674,
0.0206191614,
-0.0481642522,
0.0121297017,
0.0252513606,
-0.034316998,
0.0499339029,
0.0456387289,
-0.1082118452,
0.0063562845,
-0.0309934169,
0.0290255267,
0.0205527805,
-0.0735233799,
-0.000345321,
-0.1006554663,
0.03075739,
-0.0341104642,
-0.0225613192,
-0.0350342467,
-0.0288858842,
0.0009468837,
-0.0048012473,
-0.0437699109,
-0.0057589025,
-0.0239446349,
-0.0235605482,
-0.0018568301,
0.0223967154,
-0.0446717888,
0.0080672698,
-0.0575471371,
0.0131933577,
0.047766339,
0.0368657336,
0.0094432756,
-0.0125996396,
-0.0389300175,
0.0144649874,
0.0412616245,
-0.0126768462,
0.0295712147,
-0.0008765013,
-0.0199254956,
-0.0454062782,
-0.0191379972,
-0.0486781336,
0.0325665399,
-0.0013559988,
0.0981899351,
-0.0148424134,
-0.0552476533,
-0.0342424549,
-0.0158467684,
-0.0044924803,
0.0588684566,
-0.0147866579,
-0.0115769571,
-0.033596877,
-0.037745811,
0.0009576461,
-0.0135292169,
-0.0267561041,
0.0220381729,
-0.0440883376,
0.0275263041,
-0.0876888633,
-0.0374458842,
0.0328291915,
-0.0211187601,
0.0124236429,
0.0207195077,
0.0094036432,
-0.0147129241,
-0.052031301,
-0.0421319641,
0.0032037746,
-0.0078596948,
-0.0210544374,
-0.0116193034,
0.0433729216,
-0.0259398241,
-0.0228801686,
-0.0165380184,
-0.0503240936,
-0.0625414774,
-0.0483565293,
0.0429672971,
0.0180595964,
0.0310176909,
-0.0239754766,
-0.0564932972,
0.0946897566,
0.0834338218,
-0.0577378534,
-0.0348997973,
-0.0162216201,
0.019096652,
0.0015077634,
0.0251938049,
-0.0805162117,
-0.0359753892,
-0.031586159,
0.0519473962,
-0.0423397981,
-0.0618551746,
-0.0087643983,
0.0151438536,
-0.0001829275,
0.0309756249,
0.0396600775,
-0.0419614837,
0.0320462249,
-0.0105932355,
-0.0032911445,
-0.035606198,
-0.0125524532,
-0.0193744767,
-0.0096675856,
0.0058744778,
0.0371712483,
0.030464258,
0.0142576937,
-0.0761523023,
-0.0037595974,
0.0347588733,
0.0203767456,
0.0130637996,
0.0255207215,
-0.0247511826,
0.0481525399,
0.0070884163,
0.0284301955,
-0.0416030623,
0.0522427186,
0.0149711948,
-0.0516175255,
-0.0287120342,
0.0372198299,
-0.0695770606,
-0.0890588462,
0.0190276075,
0.0246346872,
0.0564920902,
0.0454675518,
-0.0019935798,
-0.0364192575,
-0.0092424843,
-0.0053273649,
-0.0025725067,
-0.0102641713,
-0.0178370737,
0.0023140374,
0.0284157656,
0.0057282099,
0.0121894199,
0.0553234853,
-0.0097446945,
0.0582491867,
-0.0188637879,
-0.0488242172,
-0.0347932503,
-0.0348040871,
0.0615620241,
0.0452021174,
-0.0153369289,
0.0014109467,
-0.0344516933,
-0.0282521322,
0.0225741193,
0.0175343379,
-0.0077033425,
-0.0058546662,
0.0689100549,
0.0271189418,
0.0422638394,
-0.0380426086,
-0.0182528794,
0.0045369971,
-0.103533119,
-0.0098635145,
0.0033160169,
-5.710350253e-33,
0.0445499122,
0.0004742449,
0.0405593142,
0.0339136645,
-0.0357406326,
-0.0157782454,
-0.0186286867,
-0.0272119995,
-0.0384818912,
0.0195662677,
-0.0220752303,
0.0127896713,
-0.0069433013,
-0.015543635,
0.0157361198,
-0.0588875003,
0.021212412,
-0.0034849991,
0.04073992,
0.0429734737,
0.0593037382,
0.0591664538,
0.0578371659,
-0.0471287966,
0.0395169407,
-0.0096907439,
0.0198687632,
0.0603702404,
-0.0337342322,
0.0703616217,
-0.0195143335,
0.0629888028,
0.0253509358,
-0.0215648189,
0.0055610621,
-0.0332862213,
-0.0954772457,
-0.043999061,
-0.0082316929,
-0.0085365996,
-0.0496057197,
0.0032933671,
0.0489129648,
-0.0038704169,
0.050419949,
0.011548074,
0.0579564907,
-0.0011884791,
-0.0399189442,
-0.0491499417,
0.0051728222,
-0.0214652754,
0.0088893818,
0.0310108066,
-0.0156965666,
-0.0193383899,
0.0043662433,
-0.0025522031,
-0.0950105116,
0.0065946542,
-0.0172701851,
-0.0110463183,
0.0248659905,
0.0063835355,
-0.0065628635,
0.0286189821,
0.0017908887,
0.0030267208,
-0.0266374759,
0.0049312958,
-0.0117249759,
0.1029220298,
0.0145406052,
-0.0206905678,
-0.0185078476,
0.0151778739,
-0.0756129175,
0.0236790031,
0.0332495831,
0.0078907041,
-0.0243051499,
0.01400398,
-0.01815762,
-0.0221829247,
0.0008876158,
-0.0176198184,
-0.0678811595,
-0.0264750961,
-0.0072944635,
0.005093649,
0.0096057933,
0.0516915135,
-0.019140102,
-0.0697966814,
0.001775275,
0.0546969064,
0.0122007774,
0.0049749548,
0.0262421556,
-0.0332360901,
-0.070111692,
0.0020481586,
-0.0223375075,
-0.0117362663,
-0.0191699043,
0.0079046246,
-0.0112617752,
0.0029561636,
0.0071603325,
-0.0071861539,
-0.0104274182,
0.0018376531,
0.0265851058,
-0.0471514687,
0.0037330659,
0.0316744596,
0.0077117579,
0.0351242051,
0.0671081468,
0.0645654425,
-0.0078886533,
0.0056644282,
0.0443902873,
-0.0128140943,
-0.0042222715,
-0.004603826,
-0.0209378041,
0.0210813917,
-0.0088821584,
-0.0816910714,
-0.0246778075,
0.0236439519,
2.56e-7,
0.0316489264,
0.0158110503,
0.0075269081,
0.0423978828,
0.0418791398,
0.0063604191,
0.0255737323,
0.0235790852,
-0.0174209494,
0.0118008666,
0.0220821537,
0.0219076723,
-0.0348387361,
0.0125372568,
-0.0945066288,
-0.0452890061,
-0.012345246,
-0.0380578786,
-0.05947797,
-0.0059723589,
0.0428291075,
0.0121408505,
0.0521146432,
0.0012701589,
-0.0028569491,
-0.0529525876,
0.0562695339,
0.004949078,
0.0683951452,
-0.0020513891,
0.0424644314,
0.0373227745,
-0.0505998805,
0.0372561812,
-0.0238199309,
0.0418544635,
-0.0016519013,
0.0038116053,
-0.0031203649,
-0.0044726352,
0.0172721595,
-0.0463959202,
0.0227338336,
-0.0560667366,
0.0645905435,
-0.0261357296,
-0.0128288753,
0.0401436873,
-0.0006181496,
-0.03453115,
-0.0252671894,
-0.0546122231,
0.0033466793,
-0.0332281515,
-0.0070295604,
0.0017538773,
0.0020528936,
-0.0786078498,
0.0272250101,
0.0148905404,
-0.0204070248,
-0.0418177582,
-0.0349868536,
0.0179896504,
0.0051693912,
-0.0139007261,
0.0279361121,
1.709276234e-34,
-0.0027804906,
0.0254037902,
-0.0242747329,
0.0159810483,
0.0100852065,
-0.0069235205,
-0.0233777743,
-0.0237581711,
0.0375967734,
-0.0946243107,
-0.0363535024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14199v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14199v1 | Symbolic and Language Agnostic Large Language Models | 2023-08-27T20:24:33 | 2023-08-27T20:24:33 | Walid S. Saba | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We argue that the relative success of large language models (LLMs) is not a
reflection on the symbolic vs. subsymbolic debate but a reflection on employing
an appropriate strategy of bottom-up reverse engineering of language at scale.
However, due to the subsymbolic nature of these models whatever knowledge these
systems acquire about language will always be buried in millions of
microfeatures (weights) none of which is meaningful on its own. Moreover, and
due to their stochastic nature, these models will often fail in capturing
various inferential aspects that are prevalent in natural language. What we
suggest here is employing the successful bottom-up strategy in a symbolic
setting, producing symbolic, language agnostic and ontologically grounded large
language models. | [
0.0543027036,
0.049579531,
-0.060289368,
0.0718679428,
-0.0495815463,
0.0254792068,
-0.0033365944,
0.0210565235,
0.0039105606,
-0.0537134819,
-0.0133470381,
-0.0573078841,
0.0010901236,
0.0301706791,
0.0431195199,
-0.0299962349,
0.0212040767,
-0.0446410924,
-0.0149253299,
-0.0239436608,
-0.0063912189,
-0.0118324608,
0.0653682873,
0.0207746141,
0.0020244003,
0.0077045574,
-0.0040731584,
-0.0090094665,
-0.03011184,
0.0323941559,
-0.0374785401,
-0.0410543494,
0.0361745581,
0.0695141926,
0.0000018856,
-0.0204784703,
0.0246274751,
-0.0005515137,
-0.0351854973,
0.03962804,
0.055994764,
-0.0251945481,
-0.0488039516,
-0.0072382856,
-0.0057614902,
-0.0306429546,
0.0501948111,
0.0133421933,
0.0284892265,
0.0375409164,
0.0094914921,
-0.0671233088,
0.0196495336,
-0.0206509903,
-0.0155229485,
0.0016477256,
0.0453093685,
0.0410683379,
0.0055101234,
0.0151864951,
-0.0156895127,
0.055869054,
0.00759872,
-0.0014887737,
-0.0324178226,
-0.0047411183,
0.0157401767,
-0.0174861047,
-0.0003643344,
0.0244342219,
-0.0173221864,
-0.028473096,
0.0003250558,
0.0019833755,
-0.0213690326,
0.0338263735,
-0.0442857072,
0.0525463447,
0.0093195578,
0.0323277041,
0.0826695785,
-0.0128689045,
0.0641235039,
0.0184675194,
-0.0878576934,
0.0718917623,
0.0070073945,
0.003089085,
-0.049555216,
-0.0358237699,
-0.0366148986,
-0.042014312,
-0.0002426555,
0.0248212758,
0.0270601362,
0.0509927608,
-0.00556596,
0.0128561538,
-0.0085584763,
-0.0511161014,
0.0533291101,
0.0004984973,
0.0093933083,
0.0492982119,
0.0015997613,
0.0298197363,
-0.058445286,
-0.0223947037,
-0.0539470389,
-0.0245124456,
-0.030415792,
-0.0229224116,
-0.031311661,
0.0574856885,
-0.0271474514,
-0.0029838155,
0.0088499254,
0.0316314623,
0.0101748733,
-0.0200448018,
-0.0377253257,
-0.0087936316,
-0.0072393278,
-0.0386437997,
0.0093330313,
0.0464482121,
0.009109308,
0.0183259882,
-0.0275231544,
-0.0506935157,
0.0383024924,
0.0186642241,
-0.0135530904,
-0.0267885942,
0.016541481,
0.0870760903,
0.0557253994,
0.0063519776,
-0.0386933163,
-0.0307419188,
-0.0255673788,
-0.0490630791,
-0.0169757791,
-0.0445383824,
-0.0057707527,
0.0170058608,
0.0134666525,
-0.0609788932,
0.0074467873,
-0.024684377,
-0.0684479699,
0.0593967177,
0.0009714907,
0.0197493155,
-0.0072949268,
-0.0107156541,
0.0198942199,
0.04377174,
0.0512843356,
0.0431116633,
0.0379178971,
-0.041891139,
-0.0428471565,
0.0561084598,
0.008167739,
0.0405071341,
-0.0837629363,
-0.0016964714,
-0.0027954639,
0.0058724652,
0.0273022242,
0.0818549544,
-0.0007653105,
-0.0034280212,
0.0619955584,
0.0745802149,
0.0052329558,
0.0412842035,
0.0564932786,
-0.0036569287,
0.0166383609,
-0.0103278011,
-0.0350423343,
-0.0126878871,
-0.0351643823,
-0.002155134,
-0.0382963941,
0.0233890247,
-0.0201950409,
0.0022305439,
-0.0297864303,
-0.0027808407,
-0.0413285978,
0.0241018087,
0.0809671134,
-0.0031039391,
0.0193670541,
0.0411362946,
0.0382841453,
-0.0189197324,
0.0177383889,
-0.0642337501,
0.04129453,
0.0430739634,
0.0431004427,
-0.0134674935,
0.0439910516,
0.0082482481,
-0.0180187933,
0.048337359,
0.0126745282,
-0.0352718048,
-0.0363906845,
-0.0215013009,
0.0161488969,
0.0304516349,
0.0284180995,
0.0333201922,
-0.0545363687,
-0.0037723528,
-0.0063453363,
-0.0275799073,
-0.0302998628,
0.0104874438,
-0.0519091189,
-0.0151605569,
-0.0044458015,
-0.0046474575,
0.0622699633,
0.0121266684,
-0.0375042409,
0.0138087356,
0.024075957,
-0.061179556,
-0.0217574071,
0.0150966542,
-0.0006207398,
-0.0017097803,
0.0560041517,
0.016966451,
0.0373933725,
0.0397909842,
-0.0011427546,
-0.0357098132,
0.0786559358,
-0.0497973561,
0.0838181004,
-0.0264965612,
0.0286463797,
-0.0364664942,
-0.008274056,
-0.023380639,
0.0299563501,
-0.0168061946,
0.0137540698,
0.0281388108,
-0.0145401843,
0.0143890465,
-0.0443450771,
-0.0193195362,
0.0409181863,
0.002427493,
0.0209596045,
0.0146446731,
-0.0228815898,
0.015534658,
-0.0453058034,
-0.0533919111,
-0.012894677,
0.0040576193,
0.0223397687,
0.0240040924,
0.021555528,
0.0024628541,
0.0267815646,
-0.0002433078,
0.0314878561,
-0.0168193672,
0.0451180786,
0.0190405808,
-0.0125486981,
-0.0409986526,
-0.0376143381,
-0.0312319025,
-0.0166428499,
0.080020614,
-0.0141486572,
0.0169576425,
-0.0717219636,
0.0220175795,
-0.0337820873,
0.0197636057,
-0.0198804252,
-0.064542383,
-0.0136991506,
-0.0447286181,
0.0122499093,
0.0369732454,
-0.0302570406,
0.0633250922,
0.0206165947,
-0.0202792622,
-0.0394234881,
-0.045133207,
-0.0020196023,
-0.0261380747,
-0.0590547249,
-0.0637350231,
-0.047734756,
0.1099822298,
0.0276182033,
-0.0140155591,
-0.0469294451,
0.0538579673,
-0.0578360334,
-0.0125565743,
-0.0257786941,
-0.0098947771,
-0.0231342465,
0.0314050689,
-0.0254265349,
-0.0449002199,
0.0249223877,
-0.0064857556,
0.0218945239,
0.0074990098,
-0.044901453,
-0.0292135309,
0.106881015,
0.0115177725,
0.0282426476,
0.0227202605,
-0.0176560842,
-0.0353674516,
0.0120664416,
-0.0122101502,
-0.0263427775,
0.026057126,
-0.0479317307,
0.0460218266,
0.006256944,
-0.0295568705,
0.0073875999,
-0.0458912589,
-0.0787121207,
0.0276808403,
0.0147614209,
-0.0066197757,
-0.0404104851,
0.0351657942,
0.0369078778,
-0.0198552236,
0.0215928685,
0.0058729281,
-0.0221268125,
0.0251321383,
0.0329656415,
-0.0226023756,
0.0508124195,
-0.0113569675,
0.0254947636,
0.0154445404,
0.0319390222,
-0.0006311064,
-0.0344465338,
-0.0100477636,
0.0343922898,
-0.0255780444,
-0.0600746647,
0.0128294434,
0.0088964049,
-0.06495516,
-0.0038059501,
0.0896233842,
0.0115028163,
-0.0057728365,
0.044771947,
0.0160173178,
-0.0236595441,
0.021408543,
-0.0075060963,
-0.0811664462,
-0.0279866941,
0.0142235262,
-0.0094737355,
-0.0115923453,
-0.0354211852,
-0.0022413661,
-0.0987118706,
0.0185683127,
0.0311069526,
-0.0666154847,
-0.0126170283,
-0.0234205686,
-0.0157666188,
-0.0117184548,
-0.0028391904,
0.0528867692,
-0.0458862856,
-0.0192917753,
0.0073191412,
-0.0302380882,
-0.0290951245,
0.0454259627,
-0.0256048795,
0.0620309673,
0.0143120531,
0.0426502675,
-0.0417522527,
0.0131722521,
0.0415028408,
-0.0507290475,
0.0175762977,
-0.0163330063,
0.0001754767,
0.0270142984,
-0.0291990638,
-0.0405617207,
0.0271911919,
-0.0650505424,
0.0208675303,
-0.0203313977,
0.079849869,
-0.0255832076,
-0.0520869493,
-0.017100716,
-0.0367153771,
-0.01452142,
0.0687403455,
0.0138710858,
-0.0542543791,
-0.0238566697,
-0.0267399959,
-0.0477191359,
0.0779621005,
-0.0681813434,
-0.0053229518,
0.0081866393,
-0.0202506464,
-0.0452370606,
-0.0037759512,
0.0012033109,
0.0275242589,
0.035728734,
0.0282328632,
0.033224903,
-0.0468291715,
-0.0378201418,
0.0212343596,
-0.0593001097,
0.034700647,
-0.0322152451,
0.0071325637,
0.0646809638,
-0.0407921858,
-0.0064810282,
-0.0230533648,
-0.0914334431,
-0.1029661968,
0.0092599271,
0.0201727655,
0.0348805673,
0.0095269913,
-0.0047456459,
-0.0973179489,
0.039082896,
0.0018920735,
-0.0447917283,
0.026923744,
0.0123140747,
0.0113077266,
0.0011026113,
0.0820754543,
-0.0451484621,
0.0278117731,
0.0270317607,
0.0166036859,
-0.0411136188,
0.019112017,
0.013241413,
0.0333017036,
-0.0188172664,
-0.0264967605,
-0.0587591566,
-0.0244102627,
0.0049697873,
-0.0427912362,
-0.0229301862,
-0.0384866185,
-0.0047869361,
0.0499899425,
0.0123081394,
-0.032714989,
-0.036075417,
0.0116303191,
0.060616985,
-0.0074982117,
0.0232891161,
-0.0114157656,
0.0335156545,
0.0689643621,
0.0202145334,
-0.0001771374,
0.0228550509,
-0.0294720922,
0.0378651172,
-0.0167739484,
0.0097494414,
0.0123185832,
-0.0243395381,
-0.0411531664,
-0.0022920223,
-0.0441499203,
-0.0863063484,
0.01733323,
0.0118821915,
0.0764938295,
-0.0182851814,
0.051613953,
-0.042350959,
-0.0072743939,
-0.0288868509,
0.0172704421,
0.0120787751,
-0.0247244742,
0.029761361,
0.0230366103,
-0.048639074,
0.0327779278,
0.0513122045,
0.0292422548,
0.0594830252,
0.016733896,
0.0083124014,
-0.0039315526,
-0.0025259529,
0.0100427847,
0.0018502867,
-0.0352176502,
0.0270732827,
-0.1018756256,
-0.078203395,
0.0090883682,
0.0334505066,
-0.0049515138,
-0.0347017124,
-0.0005662128,
0.0373049714,
0.0230597537,
0.0020570511,
-0.0631046295,
0.0500328019,
-0.0189820249,
-0.0129709812,
0.0096922657,
-6.376472779e-33,
-0.0018725423,
-0.015287159,
0.0048318086,
0.0095176706,
-0.0175702069,
0.0099187214,
-0.0441461429,
-0.0066829184,
-0.036171034,
0.0320314318,
-0.0001184555,
-0.0081287948,
0.0037365265,
0.0149926189,
0.0367506333,
0.0351054445,
0.0351527147,
0.0033152611,
0.0486348793,
0.005021865,
0.0756145492,
0.0012770112,
0.0457556173,
-0.0509440787,
0.0212675445,
-0.0178920254,
0.023994701,
0.0538115092,
0.0047037601,
0.025807552,
-0.0327981301,
0.0284034088,
0.0164623708,
0.0146117387,
0.0045118737,
-0.021875212,
-0.031969659,
0.005724018,
0.0599484481,
0.024269117,
0.0374246463,
-0.0417173691,
0.0326515138,
-0.0071585863,
-0.037557479,
0.0112982383,
0.0088578612,
-0.035793256,
-0.0130654778,
-0.0478792712,
-0.0492309891,
0.0279290173,
0.0167949144,
0.0116351862,
0.0210353062,
-0.0424868576,
0.0049041151,
-0.0060448605,
-0.0061014886,
0.0206086319,
0.0248047058,
0.0248172637,
0.049999617,
0.0229285602,
0.0338208638,
0.0409628637,
0.0374235623,
0.0163103379,
0.0047912244,
0.0087645156,
0.0374712944,
0.0516261123,
0.0132101998,
0.0295724161,
0.0238028206,
0.0040846933,
-0.0646662042,
-0.0450502671,
0.0468583368,
0.0467953384,
0.0203107446,
0.039689213,
-0.0415395163,
-0.0220381096,
-0.0492249317,
-0.0509864204,
-0.025985077,
-0.0197344758,
-0.0041458043,
-0.0164758414,
-0.0065701799,
-0.0066703502,
0.0372938588,
-0.1045723185,
-0.0442748517,
-0.0138050597,
0.0244516358,
0.0402174257,
-0.0134424083,
0.0454275236,
-0.0633936822,
-0.0379204862,
-0.0383218154,
-0.0146536585,
-0.0021217782,
0.037396241,
-0.0071614748,
0.0582939126,
-0.0188415721,
-0.0096908445,
-0.0347757004,
-0.0450432971,
-0.0116372751,
-0.0234617759,
0.0544295609,
0.0274129175,
0.014436923,
0.026652826,
0.0316977389,
-0.0051101022,
0.0087629315,
0.0453072712,
0.0112482877,
0.0061837109,
-0.0261895098,
-0.0090302378,
-0.055894047,
0.0302389991,
0.0781877115,
-0.0286153778,
-0.0118944719,
0.0029347532,
2.747e-7,
0.0228761341,
0.0411327928,
0.0182437431,
0.0053565521,
0.0594934672,
0.0274291094,
-0.0156990532,
-0.0140272873,
0.0077929148,
-0.0123959072,
0.0059703318,
0.0095010689,
0.0555023029,
0.0106667895,
-0.0712230131,
0.0626373067,
-0.0348619409,
-0.0387333557,
-0.038230814,
0.0113898469,
-0.0329054333,
0.1090875193,
0.0396437235,
-0.0315981843,
-0.0146212187,
-0.0351488329,
0.0479679778,
-0.0453092344,
-0.0018558761,
0.0193051156,
-0.0190985613,
0.0279854853,
-0.0003164986,
-0.0265916679,
0.0230395515,
0.0307733361,
-0.0188255999,
0.0391658135,
-0.0368236639,
0.0394441262,
-0.0198434573,
-0.0927708745,
-0.0125473104,
-0.0409181193,
0.0508760549,
-0.0418727137,
-0.065892145,
-0.0334857628,
-0.0281029399,
-0.0213763751,
-0.0469923392,
-0.0316315666,
0.0066189896,
0.0182753503,
0.0024273491,
-0.021962529,
-0.0183047988,
-0.0505821034,
-0.0068565733,
0.048036743,
-0.0436487086,
-0.0557011217,
0.0034827797,
-0.0171168558,
0.0540389642,
-0.0827419534,
0.0048202612,
2.391214026e-34,
0.0465236157,
0.0090082083,
-0.0061550429,
0.0204337444,
0.0230752043,
-0.0004917082,
-0.0330576003,
0.0329393446,
0.0394559018,
-0.089853026,
-0.024000017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14186v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14186v1 | Empowering Cross-lingual Abilities of Instruction-tuned Large Language Models by Translation-following demonstrations | 2023-08-27T19:22:12 | 2023-08-27T19:22:12 | Leonardo Ranaldi, Giulia Pucci, Andre Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The language ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) is often unbalanced
towards English because of the imbalance in the distribution of the
pre-training data. This disparity is demanded in further fine-tuning and
affecting the cross-lingual abilities of LLMs. In this paper, we propose to
empower Instructiontuned LLMs (It-LLMs) in languages other than English by
building semantic alignment between them. Hence, we propose CrossAlpaca, an
It-LLM with cross-lingual instruction-following and Translation-following
demonstrations to improve semantic alignment between languages. We validate our
approach on the multilingual Question Answering (QA) benchmarks XQUAD and MLQA
and adapted versions of MMLU and BBH. Our models, tested over six different
languages, outperform the It-LLMs tuned on monolingual data. The final results
show that instruction tuning on non-English data is not enough and that
semantic alignment can be further improved by Translation-following
demonstrations. | [
0.0119425198,
0.0307293385,
0.0196011886,
0.0695151463,
-0.0267333537,
0.0156972632,
0.0031509914,
-0.0538875088,
-0.0143528543,
-0.0048968238,
-0.081473738,
-0.028985519,
-0.032342799,
-0.0658421516,
0.020773543,
-0.0183229558,
0.0729951113,
-0.0296421275,
-0.0710737854,
-0.0386827476,
0.0027566545,
0.0305134803,
-0.0222266186,
-0.0060747927,
0.011036383,
-0.0438532718,
0.0038446395,
0.0116148181,
0.0375890993,
-0.0086737974,
0.0041388622,
0.024091078,
0.0016163271,
0.0492741093,
0.0000017095,
-0.0640408844,
0.0107660014,
0.0044445279,
-0.0213678293,
0.031276118,
-0.0158687457,
-0.0327405669,
-0.0054907827,
0.0037284256,
-0.0282424781,
-0.0040594144,
0.0416674167,
0.0300250668,
0.0598525107,
0.0505634882,
0.0179153346,
-0.0399984233,
0.0265004691,
-0.0311013367,
-0.0000665771,
-0.0633107871,
0.0066161817,
0.0347942635,
0.0155901751,
0.0219402853,
-0.0342702083,
0.0541122034,
0.0447775871,
0.034591116,
-0.0411693342,
-0.0015161696,
-0.0212441068,
0.0046249912,
-0.0012922806,
0.0615899488,
-0.0083877463,
-0.0286457166,
-0.0563529916,
0.0122456206,
-0.0063922317,
-0.0134861143,
-0.0501107909,
0.0272077285,
0.022494562,
0.0196850654,
0.0523909889,
-0.0070857089,
0.0210822709,
0.0282677133,
-0.0061625279,
0.0665587485,
0.0438153893,
-0.0482724793,
0.0263770204,
0.0173023026,
-0.0053383019,
-0.0247817133,
-0.0215279832,
0.0500405021,
-0.0560892634,
0.0357153863,
-0.0213338491,
-0.0113365054,
0.0410426892,
-0.0558352992,
0.0216240343,
0.0596380383,
-0.0155888647,
0.0749960095,
-0.0309212748,
0.0869116634,
-0.0404726341,
0.0514463782,
-0.0813143626,
-0.058836326,
-0.0082269963,
-0.0148654506,
-0.0121850632,
0.0124571463,
-0.0405343436,
0.0016523907,
-0.0528703406,
0.0407776609,
0.0041466011,
0.0253562443,
0.0060449801,
-0.0290718619,
-0.0306543466,
-0.0072902106,
-0.020274872,
0.0668533444,
-0.048118066,
0.0004691278,
-0.0382194817,
-0.0504286215,
-0.014695799,
0.0215203203,
-0.0412163846,
-0.0547633246,
0.043685209,
0.0640676469,
-0.0315966345,
-0.0092118289,
-0.0181878917,
0.0088135526,
0.0380811766,
-0.0760815069,
-0.003967518,
-0.0657765865,
0.0790704638,
-0.0053227665,
-0.002742325,
-0.0065357117,
0.0086188922,
0.0211639404,
-0.010269491,
0.053443592,
0.0077931071,
0.0217049196,
0.0300836749,
-0.0166390371,
0.048130732,
0.0868160874,
-0.0075359447,
-0.0482114032,
0.0620491542,
-0.0199353322,
-0.0412451662,
0.0611058064,
0.0426569097,
0.039222613,
-0.0004815308,
0.071723409,
0.0425781459,
0.0523943417,
0.0329384208,
0.0184289329,
0.0005426077,
-0.0040286579,
0.020799309,
0.0303056277,
-0.003745384,
0.0191156548,
0.0391138643,
0.0025502737,
0.0003641417,
0.0198458321,
-0.0396562815,
0.0291946735,
-0.0228110254,
0.0391757935,
0.0131934285,
0.0546292812,
-0.0675806478,
-0.0223615915,
-0.0147528239,
-0.0015899132,
-0.0032687744,
0.0359058902,
0.012345993,
0.0233699866,
-0.0181172881,
0.0784994215,
0.0507575832,
-0.0229482148,
0.0257221609,
-0.0391660407,
0.0391543545,
0.0309180859,
-0.0028018148,
-0.0125406319,
-0.0601026416,
0.0071318308,
0.044477541,
0.0622609332,
0.0466910675,
-0.0233061928,
0.001101217,
-0.0473300442,
-0.004986688,
-0.0526193716,
-0.0287677925,
0.0204581022,
0.0253507849,
0.0405674167,
-0.0019222512,
-0.0495144874,
-0.0254676379,
0.0316045657,
-0.0522310883,
-0.034757439,
-0.0141748004,
0.0335065164,
0.0063965945,
0.0176803041,
0.0057801409,
-0.0104704974,
0.0379017591,
-0.0285483766,
0.0125933019,
0.0164267663,
-0.0262130015,
-0.0372292101,
0.0556825586,
-0.0071719461,
-0.0466329567,
0.0311219171,
-0.0589725673,
-0.0361072719,
-0.0068272431,
-0.0215281583,
0.0194544811,
-0.0409092791,
0.0059299204,
0.0044522686,
0.0020231376,
-0.0405024961,
0.0431882963,
0.0079389298,
0.0581464246,
0.0364694819,
0.0103867976,
0.0291769002,
-0.0385916457,
0.0026276514,
0.0521422476,
0.0014198662,
0.027553007,
0.0375761017,
0.0420730338,
-0.0547741987,
-0.0182851963,
-0.0857636407,
0.0557942614,
-0.0289601274,
0.0507004559,
0.0584897064,
0.0206306987,
-0.0127025098,
-0.0300549623,
-0.0810291991,
-0.0513848513,
0.0231672451,
0.023743378,
0.0349773355,
0.0147019066,
0.0012075994,
-0.0243298691,
-0.0112047484,
-0.0025189794,
0.0310985167,
-0.0213318188,
0.0448872149,
-0.0560458116,
-0.0122057656,
-0.063084662,
0.0177281611,
0.0080450531,
-0.0673447326,
-0.0089888051,
0.0456373245,
0.033952117,
0.0707386136,
-0.0070333844,
-0.0414438173,
0.038932588,
0.0223182198,
-0.0624691173,
0.039398104,
-0.0069273124,
-0.0647976771,
-0.0621871799,
-0.0315412842,
0.0004597963,
0.0616034754,
-0.0135012614,
-0.0160332453,
-0.0496569797,
0.0025019133,
-0.009162304,
-0.0037863385,
-0.0357507579,
0.0486031957,
0.0003453082,
-0.0071784393,
-0.0320296809,
-0.0035203039,
0.0763823837,
-0.022285074,
-0.0187762827,
-0.0987029076,
0.0047451667,
-0.0654628798,
0.0236985385,
-0.0413446575,
0.0429627523,
-0.0715228096,
-0.0164969396,
-0.0553408973,
-0.0438718349,
0.0006827812,
-0.0322991237,
0.0108635454,
-0.029440105,
-0.0030404045,
-0.0291521233,
-0.0463283397,
-0.0343296789,
-0.02972316,
-0.0098983934,
0.0348060094,
-0.0174076967,
0.0059564831,
-0.0397567041,
-0.0215109494,
0.0709193423,
-0.0150335319,
-0.0105201099,
0.0239630025,
-0.0230799839,
0.0192119852,
0.0656560287,
0.0391268842,
0.0019366585,
-0.0285571218,
0.0441211723,
0.0133341178,
0.0156268366,
-0.0306604169,
0.0017973572,
-0.0205681901,
0.0543034002,
-0.0300519764,
0.0094327796,
-0.0330469348,
0.0785562769,
-0.0177999604,
0.007798403,
0.0897899121,
0.0172262136,
0.0063669947,
0.0027159664,
-0.0394323766,
0.0102409609,
0.0423675962,
0.0546136089,
-0.0863532498,
-0.0413656719,
-0.0297260694,
0.0066199354,
0.029896779,
0.0283050649,
-0.0037831746,
-0.1387548298,
-0.0178854298,
0.0116682835,
-0.0903851762,
-0.0509096943,
-0.0328357108,
-0.0013350563,
-0.0176464133,
0.0707097948,
-0.0117045538,
0.0012215318,
-0.0021123001,
0.0097878613,
0.0422363281,
-0.0484147966,
0.034995839,
-0.054389894,
0.0152222514,
0.0485464893,
0.0295980517,
-0.0258797575,
-0.0429401174,
0.0209786016,
-0.0432616509,
-0.027217241,
0.0113278469,
-0.0130643891,
-0.0124392249,
-0.029353328,
0.0005399489,
0.0354141258,
-0.0155240679,
0.0368480012,
0.0125325052,
0.0965745524,
0.0245130006,
0.0264237374,
0.0043465276,
-0.0042728954,
-0.0148208216,
0.0736913756,
0.0043251156,
-0.0494135544,
-0.0024571868,
0.0004773732,
-0.0403423384,
-0.02669519,
-0.0287507195,
0.0528896749,
-0.0377774239,
0.0179559104,
-0.0428172685,
-0.0798729435,
0.0132163167,
0.0142527828,
0.0058906949,
0.0285616014,
-0.0462095849,
-0.0162007455,
-0.0016011269,
0.0553343445,
-0.0397415198,
0.0301985312,
-0.0659628063,
0.0093629928,
0.0385305025,
-0.0339116268,
-0.0077327969,
0.0186431687,
-0.0576566309,
-0.0734225363,
-0.0438369066,
0.0373194031,
0.0037967039,
0.0671696961,
-0.0091694659,
-0.0295956824,
0.0072456105,
-0.0140741486,
-0.0081491861,
0.0274203625,
0.0313724615,
0.0170201268,
-0.01035232,
0.0656867996,
-0.0368967056,
0.0002731999,
0.0182176232,
0.0861940086,
-0.0432291478,
-0.0490514971,
0.0346363708,
0.0321589783,
-0.0180341508,
-0.0079722656,
-0.0047000987,
-0.010842192,
0.0569160096,
-0.022431178,
-0.0406590179,
0.0153324138,
-0.0157319456,
0.0316488333,
-0.0732265934,
0.0186182447,
0.0070454176,
-0.0031424286,
-0.0025992824,
-0.0318956487,
0.0149782822,
-0.0076475344,
0.0012468604,
-0.0067229918,
0.0330031291,
-0.0294786096,
0.0015733549,
0.0178660396,
0.0704569891,
-0.0172255952,
0.0640818924,
0.0327595472,
0.0027938553,
-0.0044909301,
0.0037440853,
-0.0141329188,
-0.0437064692,
0.0265148375,
0.0182418767,
0.0932069495,
-0.0089180032,
0.0494373515,
0.0053288909,
-0.0517914593,
-0.0000310207,
0.0038831064,
-0.0090713585,
-0.0057843714,
0.0729610696,
0.0042620804,
-0.0027280494,
0.0091054551,
0.0299321748,
-0.0178405475,
0.0363148414,
-0.0007119561,
0.035147395,
-0.0150127653,
-0.0348826237,
0.0289499015,
-0.0261658505,
-0.0448391102,
0.0246776715,
-0.0145190479,
-0.0593877509,
-0.005763426,
0.0231419299,
-0.0523749739,
-0.0086890925,
0.0250692684,
0.071876809,
-0.0116130002,
-0.0398099497,
-0.0211335178,
0.0060250345,
-0.0108018368,
-0.0209028479,
-0.0112365829,
-5.883902443e-33,
-0.0251948517,
0.0397849046,
0.0388778597,
-0.0349797346,
-0.0082816631,
-0.0086862091,
0.0034976825,
-0.0136258826,
-0.0774628893,
0.0174803175,
-0.0057684295,
-0.0135077145,
0.0079277586,
0.0308740977,
-0.0128183467,
-0.0325369984,
0.0156151922,
0.0032282923,
-0.0331204087,
-0.0020768926,
-0.006914061,
0.0051727924,
0.0915692374,
-0.024056185,
0.0313944072,
-0.0384626575,
0.021724442,
0.0527732633,
-0.0298844893,
0.0815043524,
-0.0124742072,
0.0330956914,
0.02181812,
-0.0239523742,
0.0012913356,
0.0001272255,
-0.0575018302,
-0.0315738022,
0.0743656158,
0.0402272791,
-0.0464996211,
-0.0619306229,
-0.004966931,
-0.025151154,
-0.0214118045,
-0.0181958303,
0.0002641483,
-0.0217492618,
0.0011023324,
0.011390225,
-0.0497003496,
-0.0029805601,
-0.0068238741,
-0.0312032588,
0.0027677251,
0.0566914566,
0.0110969152,
0.0015049817,
-0.0478258543,
-0.0103420485,
-0.0098111769,
0.0253774654,
0.0951818004,
0.0065178648,
0.0011723274,
0.0108825834,
-0.013749918,
-0.0213926062,
0.0435105748,
0.0204056147,
0.0013097605,
-0.007373502,
0.0480045788,
0.0570739582,
-0.0007941519,
0.0382883884,
-0.0891901478,
0.0132410228,
-0.0040365136,
0.0372147411,
0.0221613552,
-0.0163393747,
-0.0353794023,
0.0117986668,
-0.0619663596,
0.038424138,
-0.0243256148,
-0.0388668031,
0.0198670849,
-0.0199921392,
-0.0326364487,
0.0028479903,
0.0319614783,
-0.0224703141,
-0.0197714958,
0.0527132079,
-0.0071535651,
-0.0041027176,
-0.0225524753,
0.0519955605,
-0.0475910231,
-0.0272999834,
-0.0336717926,
-0.030162232,
-0.0145496093,
0.0243035108,
0.0504535846,
-0.0275331084,
-0.0556223877,
0.0274792761,
-0.0319842063,
0.0140641397,
-0.0292026475,
-0.007998378,
0.0196040627,
0.0188572183,
-0.0079046777,
0.0610786825,
0.0228311177,
-0.0349155925,
-0.0048030908,
-0.0487929359,
-0.0115037728,
0.0284743514,
-0.022199329,
0.0333212689,
-0.0399025418,
0.0344880037,
-0.0315142386,
-0.0571357645,
-0.0089425594,
0.0440540873,
2.436e-7,
0.043160405,
0.002262614,
0.0201508589,
0.0513393879,
-0.0184574835,
0.0052241432,
-0.0461157113,
0.0104008801,
0.0078702196,
-0.0101230219,
-0.0046349321,
0.0541962832,
0.0511515699,
0.0112159243,
-0.0737552419,
0.0084716529,
-0.0383063406,
0.0196196511,
-0.0640654787,
0.016136948,
0.0041123643,
0.1003198102,
-0.0086267358,
0.0163073465,
-0.0235919245,
-0.0367751159,
0.0613232516,
-0.0116830114,
-0.0555521287,
0.0365695097,
-0.021525858,
0.0296369325,
0.0144195994,
0.0084303822,
-0.01666734,
0.0378053635,
0.01231346,
0.0583289862,
-0.0000285704,
-0.036436379,
-0.0236748029,
-0.0396339484,
-0.0163912512,
-0.0392849855,
0.0535186343,
-0.0097864,
-0.0183010958,
-0.006367031,
-0.0064257495,
0.0061566127,
0.0567827672,
-0.0469332598,
-0.0269943345,
0.0086992132,
0.0511062071,
-0.024827363,
-0.0252901372,
-0.0198764484,
-0.0236876123,
0.0322110578,
-0.0096637309,
-0.0242320169,
0.0092012836,
0.0136891985,
-0.0173185151,
-0.0488327146,
0.0081737749,
1.821528482e-34,
0.0210293569,
-0.0154025229,
0.0353415795,
0.0355033837,
0.0224379841,
-0.0357823186,
-0.0263513494,
0.0007403607,
0.0237076841,
-0.0550980978,
0.0107427193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14182v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14182v1 | Generative AI for Business Strategy: Using Foundation Models to Create Business Strategy Tools | 2023-08-27T19:03:12 | 2023-08-27T19:03:12 | Son The Nguyen, Theja Tulabandhula | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative models (foundation models) such as LLMs (large language models)
are having a large impact on multiple fields. In this work, we propose the use
of such models for business decision making. In particular, we combine
unstructured textual data sources (e.g., news data) with multiple foundation
models (namely, GPT4, transformer-based Named Entity Recognition (NER) models
and Entailment-based Zero-shot Classifiers (ZSC)) to derive IT (information
technology) artifacts in the form of a (sequence of) signed business networks.
We posit that such artifacts can inform business stakeholders about the state
of the market and their own positioning as well as provide quantitative
insights into improving their future outlook. | [
0.0083433539,
0.036088597,
-0.0215038173,
-0.0005722786,
-0.0486053303,
-0.0066469898,
-0.0317725539,
0.0245489739,
-0.0058939843,
-0.0634705573,
0.023596216,
-0.0052600219,
-0.0160858054,
0.0590222254,
0.0180900935,
0.0142984213,
-0.0043977881,
0.0502089858,
0.0201967545,
0.0150821311,
-0.0076362714,
0.0569765456,
0.0140868071,
0.0092293797,
0.0219229925,
0.0203247033,
-0.0314254388,
0.0042615547,
0.0385691933,
-0.0601935461,
-0.0344046094,
0.0076094717,
0.0199775212,
0.0256734509,
0.0000020813,
-0.0704992563,
-0.0890435502,
-0.0273772422,
-0.0342684016,
-0.0120110959,
0.0418289453,
-0.0375709124,
-0.0027265798,
0.026166426,
-0.0586922802,
-0.0136538651,
0.0290048327,
0.07135728,
0.0246598292,
0.0984467268,
-0.0317189805,
-0.0678728372,
0.0378697738,
-0.0496815145,
-0.0183035731,
-0.0570873283,
0.0240478292,
-0.0192629658,
-0.0351539999,
0.0207268838,
0.0033727153,
0.003289334,
0.0011482411,
0.0340838656,
0.0021383588,
0.0664378107,
0.0065174587,
0.0237081461,
-0.0273479037,
0.0273960996,
0.018070301,
-0.0070772702,
0.0350748487,
-0.0461829454,
0.0248371549,
-0.0103601739,
-0.0242531672,
0.052769918,
-0.0143165821,
0.0673127919,
0.0228349622,
-0.0081250286,
0.0278397668,
-0.0044579292,
-0.0057864618,
0.0546990298,
-0.0120954737,
-0.0369549654,
0.0339188017,
0.0016412325,
0.0342724174,
-0.0690592825,
-0.0110868262,
0.0351543725,
0.0216842126,
0.0386922173,
-0.0056813275,
0.0677804053,
-0.0153470142,
-0.0441109464,
-0.0019358991,
-0.0107349046,
0.0630860105,
0.0352906212,
-0.0432014056,
-0.001337551,
-0.0141278012,
-0.0398094244,
-0.0044597439,
0.0132799409,
-0.0878439918,
-0.0223349389,
-0.0335806981,
0.0499621741,
-0.0474876724,
-0.0483748056,
-0.041837994,
0.0248654038,
-0.0117320828,
0.0289495084,
0.0302687269,
0.0007775864,
0.043477308,
-0.0320157968,
-0.0657449365,
0.0034478381,
-0.0006801491,
0.0090319067,
-0.0364838578,
-0.0335853994,
0.0286119003,
0.0043234369,
0.0129219871,
-0.0065073669,
0.0076861535,
0.0765407756,
0.0305454899,
-0.0404376537,
-0.1211750954,
-0.0263404921,
0.0227070898,
-0.0577889644,
0.0106742829,
-0.0106015522,
-0.0011030125,
-0.0125861894,
-0.0144960098,
-0.0268943738,
0.0151225589,
-0.017372692,
-0.0346240476,
0.0304522105,
-0.0183879044,
-0.0028853065,
0.0029156627,
-0.0236871112,
0.1103684157,
0.0431303643,
0.0539089963,
0.039138332,
0.0274113473,
-0.0125123933,
0.0106609603,
0.025075268,
-0.003429848,
-0.0254386626,
0.0054886024,
-0.0111923777,
-0.0743302181,
-0.0568647832,
-0.02161818,
-0.0133688143,
-0.0131530715,
0.0478254966,
0.0596390851,
-0.011996977,
0.0750790611,
0.0502278246,
0.0173022896,
0.0006956306,
-0.0490766503,
-0.0484546572,
0.0309027713,
-0.0001950832,
-0.072582081,
0.0247081723,
-0.0291986801,
-0.0002698107,
-0.0227139462,
-0.0157481339,
0.0247894451,
0.0151294842,
0.0160284527,
-0.0212675743,
0.0596280955,
-0.0161389317,
-0.1007825285,
0.0333094858,
-0.0206177663,
-0.0215663482,
0.0105033405,
-0.0157514419,
0.0032594951,
0.0877515897,
0.052229099,
-0.0173955113,
-0.0304228589,
-0.0011669165,
-0.0887625292,
0.0600778908,
-0.0018480186,
-0.0056531825,
-0.0399722606,
-0.0310980827,
-0.0181013569,
0.0089311553,
0.0164879169,
0.0394773893,
-0.0244909078,
0.0625930801,
0.0106171137,
-0.0122800162,
0.0330132768,
0.0179724935,
-0.0214890186,
-0.0317051224,
0.0266345516,
0.0106635392,
0.0386578962,
0.0729280412,
-0.0010518596,
-0.0061933124,
0.0282253753,
-0.0137742506,
-0.0720301047,
-0.0065135178,
0.0334137045,
0.0342713445,
0.0054260236,
-0.0299515799,
0.0146129923,
-0.0049136863,
-0.0307426751,
-0.0642270669,
0.0276576411,
-0.0022134273,
0.0221756008,
-0.0453659296,
0.0019191424,
-0.0089975903,
-0.0035638516,
-0.0026231154,
0.0705021024,
0.0036818057,
-0.0065351543,
-0.0409784578,
-0.0314154923,
0.0041146693,
-0.0316670574,
0.0247206055,
0.0366255119,
0.0064811697,
0.0126610603,
0.0595895648,
0.0072049242,
-0.002758615,
0.0229185466,
-0.0786283761,
0.0399403498,
0.0101953065,
0.0255617518,
0.0352910683,
0.0001537398,
-0.0123692425,
0.0052153813,
-0.0294859391,
0.0422676168,
0.0209903028,
-0.0345443301,
0.0370606706,
0.0072882604,
-0.0599346943,
0.0052526752,
0.0157660674,
-0.0316814259,
0.0069632302,
0.0614559017,
-0.0686133727,
-0.067418009,
0.0389376581,
-0.0299662091,
0.0201319903,
-0.0204753429,
0.0229209866,
0.0021709371,
-0.0138673894,
-0.0200779252,
0.005321682,
-0.0056915157,
0.0566003621,
0.0026129971,
-0.0332765765,
-0.0175672844,
0.012823212,
-0.0793877169,
0.0502068996,
-0.0463920087,
-0.0769460127,
0.0450900942,
-0.0068912008,
0.0166464131,
0.0076211547,
-0.0582590438,
0.0061129997,
0.0301206466,
0.0190927573,
-0.0004208917,
-0.0054795458,
-0.0013966218,
0.0837051868,
0.03816339,
-0.004683285,
0.011380828,
-0.0117332861,
0.0125448182,
-0.0078681493,
-0.0297921412,
-0.0689342618,
0.0578254275,
-0.0031320804,
-0.0162320845,
0.0337884277,
-0.0344889425,
-0.0153547693,
0.010889736,
0.0156509057,
-0.0180015955,
0.0112776794,
-0.0163757317,
0.0321647488,
0.003733821,
0.0101383217,
-0.0406080969,
-0.0016821743,
-0.0173807368,
0.042482093,
0.0344057232,
-0.0083673894,
-0.0477329716,
0.0451042354,
-0.0144966645,
0.0319692269,
0.0076710633,
-0.030031763,
-0.0204357728,
0.0337112956,
0.0496506952,
-0.0492835715,
0.0477614999,
0.0162879732,
-0.0043362952,
-0.0142121194,
-0.0471550934,
0.0212432053,
-0.0368984379,
-0.0141486488,
-0.0115952948,
-0.0456571542,
0.0175708346,
0.0010326791,
-0.0349800251,
0.0065664384,
0.0224458184,
0.096895054,
0.0059342762,
0.035179846,
0.0096695898,
0.0399594642,
-0.0216426477,
0.0085504847,
0.047351893,
-0.1131149977,
-0.0040197624,
-0.0361119322,
-0.0008332421,
-0.0060284431,
-0.066605337,
-0.0245208256,
-0.1614405066,
0.0796433985,
-0.0171908848,
-0.0371440239,
0.0123653896,
-0.0468980111,
-0.0082756216,
-0.0726282671,
-0.0607007034,
-0.0348995812,
-0.0150350267,
-0.0076338979,
-0.0027497725,
-0.014815473,
-0.057297457,
-0.015395781,
0.0172760729,
-0.0261665545,
0.0398393571,
0.0359657295,
-0.0352288857,
0.0072493344,
-0.0147081567,
-0.0314527266,
0.0021098382,
-0.0054717935,
0.0498730764,
-0.0197357256,
0.0153594539,
-0.0050219242,
0.0057259626,
-0.0493163466,
0.0068366434,
0.0408815704,
0.049431812,
-0.018139286,
-0.0417703167,
0.0152489357,
-0.0096299108,
0.0248037726,
0.0547976345,
-0.0313317999,
-0.0386082865,
-0.0371115059,
-0.0234355964,
0.0491771214,
-0.0161726642,
-0.0438141674,
0.0068433499,
-0.0421156548,
-0.0938846469,
-0.0640507415,
-0.0444983207,
0.0209623501,
0.0353174731,
0.0257165264,
-0.0254936591,
0.0454749539,
0.0087677212,
-0.0404404812,
-0.0636084676,
-0.0174900424,
0.016411664,
-0.0465994366,
0.0079406006,
0.0135546895,
-0.0099657215,
-0.052413471,
0.0098585552,
-0.0411064476,
-0.0546768494,
-0.0371189155,
0.0228227731,
0.0260299165,
-0.0030458758,
-0.0042274063,
0.0026931246,
0.0741154775,
0.0774107203,
-0.0073544825,
-0.0173747782,
0.0176338721,
-0.0005033895,
-0.0104373777,
0.0193354227,
-0.0287427697,
0.0678414032,
0.009052353,
0.0586297065,
-0.0560140684,
-0.0083079468,
0.0106440438,
-0.0073315511,
0.0188034736,
-0.0304459296,
-0.0298953988,
-0.0332271159,
0.0030906207,
-0.0169057455,
0.0017948471,
-0.0208176449,
-0.0395028107,
0.0353671685,
-0.009468575,
0.0083705112,
0.0464523248,
-0.0595815219,
-0.001999913,
-0.0393963009,
0.0208227504,
0.0480558053,
0.0788625553,
0.0042597344,
-0.0488543361,
0.0064030299,
-0.0261927601,
0.0228775386,
0.0170430671,
-0.0100294286,
0.0234499741,
0.0187209863,
-0.0026369321,
-0.0284643881,
0.0030851075,
-0.0193157289,
-0.012801311,
-0.0021083865,
0.0223031938,
0.0286342185,
0.0233297944,
0.0345581174,
-0.0666320845,
0.0111516034,
0.0127249332,
0.0198053233,
0.0102121318,
-0.0477744341,
-0.0007941941,
0.038353648,
-0.049153395,
0.023686504,
0.0534272119,
0.0279604867,
0.0222824868,
-0.0493509173,
-0.0347500071,
-0.0751029328,
-0.044488959,
0.0490427688,
0.0233606938,
0.0184411723,
0.0262391213,
-0.0817390084,
-0.022777101,
0.02065254,
0.0004050437,
0.0398864336,
0.0079448326,
0.006344947,
0.0278881118,
0.0003669683,
-0.012941909,
-0.046053566,
0.0107736317,
-0.0986816511,
-0.0176879596,
-0.0452343337,
-6.539103892e-33,
-0.0074600326,
-0.0526240878,
0.0337678902,
0.0100585539,
-0.0077006174,
0.0180266667,
0.0030634115,
-0.0259042978,
0.0151133807,
-0.0178605989,
-0.0052445368,
0.0093117515,
0.0159077458,
0.0075511872,
0.0035076484,
0.0064988527,
0.0425281674,
-0.0010679556,
-0.0336682647,
0.0165183544,
0.0294247624,
0.0114092287,
0.0985158086,
-0.062068671,
0.0088232439,
-0.0390672386,
-0.0653432682,
0.0118142739,
0.0532791577,
0.0283331797,
-0.0049971021,
-0.0087560499,
0.0413395986,
-0.1251952201,
0.0610426515,
0.0256397333,
-0.0502519757,
-0.0347211286,
0.0126058031,
-0.0177299399,
0.0089019751,
0.0108995251,
0.0115131456,
-0.0129033746,
-0.001920042,
0.0368924551,
0.0357180983,
-0.0140969735,
0.0072579714,
-0.0186292138,
-0.0741579682,
0.0318224356,
-0.0180192199,
0.0476582497,
0.0162141565,
0.0210447907,
-0.0092413099,
0.022384515,
-0.0407183468,
0.0297519788,
0.0445977487,
-0.0362438671,
0.0542212315,
0.0345548987,
-0.0005217814,
0.0252321549,
-0.0172796845,
-0.0121594351,
-0.0309901591,
-0.0014559834,
-0.0352514647,
0.0787847862,
-0.005699344,
0.0139597766,
-0.0061462885,
0.017519692,
-0.0637572259,
0.0555946194,
0.0136842839,
0.0098433057,
0.0100992443,
0.0039285151,
-0.0077690957,
-0.0175071862,
0.0580267608,
-0.0725681037,
-0.0125794187,
-0.0081564626,
0.0149599146,
0.0173775814,
-0.0358977988,
0.0941447243,
0.0307788663,
-0.0196024198,
-0.0693919063,
0.0465788916,
-0.0078109801,
0.0364193581,
0.0046446542,
-0.0134422602,
-0.0541934967,
-0.0396969691,
0.0151655702,
0.0236916896,
0.0097995885,
-0.0212822016,
0.025568299,
0.0097017065,
-0.0405360311,
-0.0005124582,
0.0005098066,
0.0563274585,
-0.0032735432,
-0.0335032977,
0.0230853427,
0.0161803309,
0.0184254665,
0.0104853632,
0.0298075713,
-0.0043104282,
0.0070697432,
0.0193854943,
0.0032626747,
-0.0003050926,
-0.0084388033,
0.0136103211,
0.0488240905,
0.0339894593,
0.0412214734,
-0.0493569002,
-0.031513989,
0.0246411934,
2.894e-7,
0.0400980562,
0.0522185974,
-0.0064063091,
0.0461914614,
0.0232932363,
0.0338934399,
0.0236168392,
0.0083097685,
-0.0253314245,
-0.0100311935,
0.0726247653,
-0.0027669328,
0.0042917165,
0.0378085971,
-0.0529624484,
0.0057042055,
-0.0055351853,
-0.0156724174,
-0.0839905739,
0.0195079856,
0.0676138401,
0.0440436639,
0.0499789007,
-0.0125891156,
-0.0029578572,
-0.0078820968,
0.0120150419,
-0.0184093993,
0.0592775941,
0.0165506732,
-0.0228487626,
0.0076080444,
-0.0548332967,
0.0170901865,
-0.0159733333,
0.0565751269,
-0.019156754,
0.0328635126,
0.005417733,
0.0089269541,
0.0214874875,
-0.031576287,
0.0052715638,
-0.014039902,
0.0766725987,
-0.0489291139,
-0.0231994968,
-0.0169625953,
-0.0649266392,
0.0227949973,
-0.0369603075,
0.0123848608,
-0.0043093492,
0.011215562,
-0.0249953624,
-0.0232613962,
0.0334738493,
-0.0415117368,
0.0857979953,
0.0197345465,
-0.0302866753,
0.0180441998,
-0.0054872935,
0.0064272699,
0.0395314284,
-0.0199920423,
0.0392041206,
2.410406268e-34,
0.0146256061,
-0.0112835765,
-0.0001790051,
0.0269716699,
0.0454645827,
0.0270435289,
-0.0472770892,
0.0232883841,
0.0098544033,
-0.0974888802,
-0.0255950224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14179v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14179v1 | Towards Vision-Language Mechanistic Interpretability: A Causal Tracing Tool for BLIP | 2023-08-27T18:46:47 | 2023-08-27T18:46:47 | Vedant Palit, Rohan Pandey, Aryaman Arora, Paul Pu Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Mechanistic interpretability seeks to understand the neural mechanisms that
enable specific behaviors in Large Language Models (LLMs) by leveraging
causality-based methods. While these approaches have identified neural circuits
that copy spans of text, capture factual knowledge, and more, they remain
unusable for multimodal models since adapting these tools to the
vision-language domain requires considerable architectural changes. In this
work, we adapt a unimodal causal tracing tool to BLIP to enable the study of
the neural mechanisms underlying image-conditioned text generation. We
demonstrate our approach on a visual question answering dataset, highlighting
the causal relevance of later layer representations for all tokens.
Furthermore, we release our BLIP causal tracing tool as open source to enable
further experimentation in vision-language mechanistic interpretability by the
community. Our code is available at
https://github.com/vedantpalit/Towards-Vision-Language-Mechanistic-Interpretability. | [
0.0109445853,
0.0563705228,
-0.0281151235,
0.0522813089,
0.0025921315,
0.0127029149,
0.0193132199,
0.0236800667,
0.0014486962,
-0.0409805998,
0.0007949198,
-0.0078914091,
0.0102246897,
0.0734568089,
0.0554972067,
-0.0508599393,
0.0212151613,
-0.0272139572,
-0.0214468613,
0.0141003039,
0.0308540557,
-0.0048723216,
-0.0129283285,
0.0612850599,
-0.0237640385,
-0.0341393277,
-0.0055724951,
0.0302367862,
0.0003350468,
0.014739438,
-0.0271593332,
0.0495289676,
0.0234337952,
0.0382141545,
0.0000018513,
-0.0225230195,
0.0267694984,
-0.0032108207,
-0.0050366214,
0.0105531355,
-0.0202494375,
-0.01871516,
0.0135456445,
-0.0117439087,
-0.0274382234,
0.0292113554,
0.0877033323,
0.0204278789,
0.0582903698,
0.0274717305,
-0.0068835742,
-0.0153322769,
0.0048391297,
-0.0015336663,
0.0674365461,
0.0145574799,
-0.0106467074,
-0.0052440702,
-0.0252271779,
0.0027412579,
-0.0788478032,
0.0191168003,
0.0473081954,
-0.0126895187,
0.0189360976,
0.016237719,
0.0110781044,
-0.0445914939,
0.0068638576,
0.0893122777,
0.0451631583,
-0.0389741287,
0.0201978534,
0.0117466599,
0.0042874394,
0.051151108,
-0.0648269504,
0.0352165699,
0.0171780549,
0.016005395,
-0.0260802675,
-0.0411950201,
0.0344649404,
0.0125298901,
0.016727021,
0.0379099585,
0.016863415,
0.030504657,
-0.0645602718,
0.0324375667,
0.0229946803,
-0.0663078576,
-0.0156843215,
0.0186121278,
-0.0264683794,
0.0102225728,
-0.0317708664,
0.0031278078,
-0.0055157016,
-0.0088752303,
0.0599522777,
0.0175247844,
-0.0638469011,
0.0210313741,
-0.0508595668,
0.0549123846,
-0.0581868142,
0.0676535964,
-0.0109961508,
0.0089706434,
-0.0086481869,
-0.0531963184,
0.0153978961,
-0.0141860042,
-0.0398435108,
-0.044415839,
-0.0558922924,
0.0273176245,
-0.0300343912,
-0.0556891747,
-0.0213662088,
0.0086546587,
-0.0046706451,
0.0191677678,
-0.028432345,
0.0353789814,
-0.0392533951,
0.0230343509,
0.010176545,
-0.0290994961,
-0.0237165596,
0.0424105227,
0.0219645072,
-0.0059565403,
-0.0215564184,
0.092119053,
0.0094357217,
-0.0196107794,
-0.0460400954,
-0.0682258755,
-0.0144856963,
-0.0173357334,
0.0568457209,
-0.057540182,
0.0115907229,
0.0087266434,
-0.0255286936,
-0.0165536515,
0.0114883156,
0.0214478299,
-0.0352787264,
0.0828738436,
-0.0242555924,
-0.0164637174,
-0.0194281098,
0.0138610369,
0.0208626054,
0.063525334,
0.0254138168,
0.0526114032,
0.0309362896,
-0.0088363066,
0.0406646505,
0.0243928302,
0.0405821018,
-0.0060601295,
-0.0628599748,
-0.0350136235,
-0.0120857218,
0.0043946574,
0.0605021566,
-0.005920846,
-0.0527667403,
-0.0516980067,
0.063855648,
-0.0005976311,
0.0046747308,
-0.0024483679,
0.0609368458,
-0.0407464504,
0.0004992094,
0.012524046,
-0.0690734237,
0.0822206736,
-0.016350504,
-0.0072314828,
-0.0066149347,
-0.0020006348,
-0.0160082262,
-0.0389912166,
0.0128749525,
0.019437857,
-0.0111894254,
-0.0054642423,
0.0291045979,
0.0427242331,
-0.0139372526,
0.0457389653,
0.0099131661,
-0.0624550954,
0.0103186071,
-0.0620942451,
0.0436779782,
0.0481006876,
0.0547035895,
-0.0041104397,
-0.003698787,
0.0134056108,
0.0109635824,
0.0547293089,
-0.0550400279,
0.0115534021,
0.0414927043,
-0.0427376218,
-0.0294530801,
-0.0301846098,
0.0214776378,
0.0099419812,
-0.014425857,
-0.0410088785,
-0.0135768484,
-0.0287310854,
-0.020486176,
0.0463460051,
0.0277086422,
-0.0123458141,
-0.0269574746,
0.0257111434,
0.0016375572,
-0.0141681684,
-0.0147179784,
0.0029083821,
0.0082023311,
-0.0396624468,
-0.0094563197,
0.0541737154,
-0.0384911336,
-0.043033611,
0.0045313863,
-0.0771270469,
-0.0059219268,
0.0458397791,
-0.0306581277,
-0.0426825546,
0.0629896596,
-0.0456794053,
-0.0030543015,
-0.0565321781,
-0.0329837352,
0.0188975446,
0.0438077748,
-0.0266902652,
0.0268183462,
-0.0218159817,
-0.0199596919,
0.0149635905,
0.0162421037,
0.020270355,
-0.0006594284,
0.0129138427,
-0.0026177689,
-0.0055821897,
-0.019553531,
0.0183453429,
-0.0167819373,
-0.05144554,
0.011780628,
-0.064437516,
-0.0367917828,
-0.025982596,
-0.014759575,
0.0588761158,
-0.0014160478,
0.0188759062,
-0.0336573496,
-0.0264258832,
0.0401462279,
-0.0033543215,
0.0168682244,
0.0493461974,
-0.0264940858,
0.0117889112,
-0.0151996883,
-0.0256598759,
-0.0139405811,
0.07190945,
0.0279675536,
0.0061232196,
-0.0616413206,
-0.0250075143,
-0.0268338583,
-0.0122860381,
-0.011242589,
-0.0598578975,
0.0386759117,
0.0129085155,
0.0105920024,
0.0769518465,
-0.0139776981,
0.0689265728,
0.0021827091,
-0.0212583896,
-0.0218459107,
-0.0302202832,
-0.0105976453,
0.0269264895,
-0.0170086678,
-0.0712037683,
-0.0280559212,
0.0715302005,
0.0009229159,
0.0011195999,
-0.0646697953,
0.0206794124,
0.0014166345,
-0.0627647638,
-0.0403053425,
-0.0031653182,
-0.0170281436,
0.063100107,
-0.0344767645,
-0.0980871171,
0.0529176891,
-0.0320118107,
-0.0290262476,
0.0491700582,
0.0309293196,
-0.0245060325,
0.10505227,
0.0640538782,
0.0162533056,
0.0086436803,
-0.0189969987,
-0.0590648837,
-0.0238582231,
0.0152919525,
0.011594939,
0.026392404,
-0.0511102527,
-0.0035472617,
-0.0063854465,
0.0249353424,
-0.02351344,
-0.013115312,
0.0015001189,
-0.012704839,
-0.0269547794,
-0.0313400179,
-0.0077987807,
-0.0109908134,
0.0571959727,
0.0120652625,
-0.0428390801,
-0.0012751943,
-0.0265043061,
0.0535579696,
0.0680285022,
0.0086297067,
0.0551255755,
-0.0633045584,
-0.0254485328,
0.0684022084,
0.0095841037,
-0.0029282381,
-0.0497043915,
0.043232087,
0.011327181,
0.0330931954,
-0.0025465246,
0.0165977608,
0.0658496693,
-0.0908719078,
-0.0207406543,
0.0573175661,
0.0180679765,
-0.0370001234,
0.016642103,
0.0058077727,
0.0358342566,
0.0464786179,
0.0200398378,
-0.0890862271,
-0.0554873347,
-0.0106683457,
0.0151407365,
-0.0123048173,
-0.0060495296,
-0.015842149,
-0.0572584718,
0.0664286688,
-0.0175837688,
-0.0083353417,
-0.005570461,
-0.0077001578,
-0.0298879575,
-0.0027232785,
-0.0171849113,
0.0225992836,
0.0262781121,
0.0313846432,
-0.0048342044,
-0.0153365955,
0.0129106604,
-0.0049401806,
-0.0200166553,
0.0299567599,
0.0685363412,
0.0063818279,
-0.0384647064,
-0.0284421351,
0.0073082759,
0.0116621386,
0.0120933643,
-0.0131854471,
0.0837541223,
0.0262838397,
-0.060896527,
-0.0313017108,
0.0505032316,
-0.0232301503,
-0.038167648,
-0.0252689589,
0.0420362428,
-0.0182712898,
-0.0230623484,
-0.0191259198,
0.0270655416,
-0.0400293209,
0.0445057862,
0.0734639913,
-0.0495481193,
-0.0602448918,
-0.0310247801,
-0.0199943371,
-0.0964006782,
-0.0594313815,
-0.0113490485,
0.0544154905,
-0.0028123129,
-0.0938330665,
-0.0286078732,
-0.01181396,
0.0684962943,
-0.0303550418,
0.0010936777,
0.001681362,
-0.0320669673,
-0.0415869094,
0.0791250244,
-0.0268294644,
0.0248889327,
-0.0520522632,
-0.0337206572,
0.0001303124,
-0.0514220223,
-0.022041684,
0.0289110169,
-0.0525069945,
-0.0386853963,
-0.0009662274,
0.0862673968,
0.0209657066,
0.045532763,
0.0183192957,
-0.0523786135,
0.0226817112,
0.0166363046,
0.0268459544,
0.0448115803,
-0.0002660369,
-0.0312996767,
-0.0094163753,
0.0338552296,
-0.0185231268,
0.0159038119,
0.0235059485,
0.036241781,
-0.0144966515,
0.0464696102,
0.0325349458,
-0.0132683469,
0.0302880984,
-0.0172775518,
0.0204736479,
-0.0239347536,
0.0000477667,
-0.0310876984,
0.0176490135,
-0.0962829366,
0.0230180304,
-0.0048899287,
0.0054377574,
0.0019152078,
-0.0776572078,
-0.0093987649,
0.0005447281,
-0.0335063487,
0.0304749943,
-0.0153198885,
0.0175770726,
-0.0229350887,
0.0282241665,
0.0082989288,
0.046308402,
-0.0476066433,
0.0631749034,
0.003705919,
0.09048675,
0.053574197,
-0.0032461071,
-0.0363324024,
0.0121118296,
-0.0619924441,
-0.010905752,
0.0435262285,
0.0214261934,
0.0491400398,
-0.0033651225,
0.0384452641,
-0.0087224757,
-0.0018138924,
0.0131558077,
0.068039678,
0.0074235625,
-0.0106413858,
0.0527922548,
0.009188124,
-0.0045872219,
-0.0302498881,
0.0859071687,
0.0126815317,
0.0167415086,
-0.0069094556,
0.0158729982,
-0.0090560718,
-0.0586473458,
0.021110082,
-0.0016435258,
-0.0225969814,
0.0212126281,
-0.0410263799,
-0.0761954859,
-0.0027290983,
0.0287777111,
0.0183732063,
-0.0223334972,
0.029827537,
0.0375390574,
0.0221185908,
-0.00474793,
-0.030332949,
-0.0083243856,
-0.0301540028,
0.0133399554,
0.0409083255,
-6.334723628e-33,
-0.0361832678,
-0.0637503266,
0.0257110763,
0.0136987204,
-0.005749173,
0.0472841561,
-0.0400276072,
-0.0107659418,
0.0211457536,
0.036253497,
0.0309661087,
0.0098815765,
0.0021887631,
0.0521143898,
-0.0085875774,
-0.0235836934,
0.0037189263,
0.0120117338,
-0.0124829533,
0.0198800918,
0.0497906245,
0.0072844452,
0.0230301358,
-0.033123564,
0.013100774,
0.0199253783,
-0.0166090094,
0.0153178116,
-0.0312529728,
0.0694810078,
-0.0254839305,
0.0141224489,
0.0346890651,
-0.0261860937,
-0.0353319794,
0.0317115411,
-0.0454329886,
-0.0223262962,
0.0503913499,
0.0391097143,
-0.1427804828,
-0.0093421545,
0.049339626,
-0.0366616361,
0.0018338927,
-0.0196099617,
0.0332867354,
-0.0130876601,
0.0021536413,
0.0189594962,
-0.066795975,
-0.0051405262,
-0.0046824156,
-0.0243973304,
0.0180824883,
0.0242089517,
-0.0117746294,
0.0354352258,
-0.0226384122,
-0.0173307676,
-0.0193859152,
0.0175054353,
0.0595762916,
0.079295136,
0.0243386198,
0.0714144185,
0.0362607911,
-0.0392405465,
-0.0309598651,
-0.0018295946,
0.0140790595,
0.044096414,
0.0717327222,
0.0353078507,
-0.0039200573,
0.0339464061,
-0.0443504974,
-0.0206272453,
-0.0118720466,
0.014816273,
0.0290154237,
-0.0116188955,
0.0275473185,
0.0011904878,
-0.0407438986,
-0.0104652978,
-0.0494646057,
0.0011381212,
0.0403518565,
0.0120713748,
-0.012533159,
0.0057904888,
0.0478305891,
-0.042023845,
0.0283687096,
0.0286397133,
-0.0225711651,
0.0371682383,
0.0244047083,
0.0068168803,
-0.0287265312,
0.0168364979,
0.0225543287,
-0.01559145,
0.0298344158,
0.0235730056,
0.038524501,
0.0017135581,
-0.0000646681,
0.0024664504,
-0.0504709519,
-0.0047595543,
-0.0121771861,
-0.0072964164,
0.0315311551,
-0.0000776665,
-0.0730258524,
-0.0017993463,
0.0127711464,
0.0205092691,
-0.002699645,
-0.0240396783,
-0.0380466655,
0.0612426512,
-0.0647099018,
-0.0373409428,
-0.0356077179,
0.0120613296,
0.0095817689,
-0.0831579193,
-0.0235886425,
0.0281079877,
2.543e-7,
0.0404657088,
0.0507190228,
0.0167556666,
0.0340843983,
0.0434503667,
0.0354982056,
-0.0000514171,
0.0142604504,
-0.0130885458,
-0.026058821,
-0.008406206,
0.0294817965,
0.0529377609,
-0.0228055269,
0.0080677858,
0.0355519652,
-0.0309117958,
-0.0034348459,
-0.0169271603,
0.0048506293,
0.067204155,
0.038562391,
-0.0086015742,
-0.0337749794,
0.0756781027,
-0.0239172839,
0.0866484493,
-0.0229665656,
0.0278450735,
-0.0456898101,
-0.0181529447,
-0.0277922936,
-0.0056132446,
0.0291907452,
-0.0071170363,
-0.0322090313,
-0.0015800924,
0.0124970777,
-0.0385610126,
-0.0259074718,
-0.0407319404,
-0.0195707865,
0.0147092398,
-0.0693312883,
0.0527364388,
-0.028208673,
-0.0629874468,
-0.015803922,
-0.0196989179,
-0.0143862404,
0.0187341478,
-0.0188995115,
-0.0288533028,
0.0115085058,
0.0164910685,
-0.0101906722,
-0.023342751,
-0.059282165,
-0.0456900038,
-0.0214591343,
-0.0256261826,
-0.0115278941,
-0.1217247471,
-0.0325656198,
0.0274749361,
-0.0266815368,
-0.0721888691,
2.345692089e-34,
0.0220562313,
-0.0173570458,
0.0224975217,
0.0048770974,
0.0232857615,
-0.0302990917,
-0.0011460613,
-0.0087925708,
0.0168950204,
-0.0771633461,
-0.0403732359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14149v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14149v1 | Examining User-Friendly and Open-Sourced Large GPT Models: A Survey on Language, Multimodal, and Scientific GPT Models | 2023-08-27T16:14:19 | 2023-08-27T16:14:19 | Kaiyuan Gao, Sunan He, Zhenyu He, Jiacheng Lin, QiZhi Pei, Jie Shao, Wei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generative pre-trained transformer (GPT) models have revolutionized the field
of natural language processing (NLP) with remarkable performance in various
tasks and also extend their power to multimodal domains. Despite their success,
large GPT models like GPT-4 face inherent limitations such as considerable
size, high computational requirements, complex deployment processes, and closed
development loops. These constraints restrict their widespread adoption and
raise concerns regarding their responsible development and usage. The need for
user-friendly, relatively small, and open-sourced alternative GPT models arises
from the desire to overcome these limitations while retaining high performance.
In this survey paper, we provide an examination of alternative open-sourced
models of large GPTs, focusing on user-friendly and relatively small models
that facilitate easier deployment and accessibility. Through this extensive
survey, we aim to equip researchers, practitioners, and enthusiasts with a
thorough understanding of user-friendly and relatively small open-sourced
models of large GPTs, their current state, challenges, and future research
directions, inspiring the development of more efficient, accessible, and
versatile GPT models that cater to the broader scientific community and advance
the field of general artificial intelligence. The source contents are
continuously updating in https://github.com/GPT-Alternatives/gpt_alternatives. | [
0.0281630624,
0.0844972357,
-0.0081760418,
0.0228793472,
-0.0497473367,
-0.01381109,
0.016627349,
-0.0085101845,
-0.0165530145,
-0.0528180562,
-0.0582063794,
-0.0178460237,
-0.0183734745,
0.0405837744,
0.015329917,
-0.095680356,
0.0359797031,
-0.011978793,
-0.0342507549,
0.0070529007,
0.0143049452,
0.0206101295,
-0.0036421637,
0.0601922162,
-0.0362817384,
-0.0186629761,
-0.0118063567,
0.0036676161,
0.0171249453,
-0.0057833255,
-0.0125683015,
0.0725086555,
0.0279489309,
0.0564356893,
0.0000022912,
-0.030555591,
-0.0225073174,
0.0188381653,
0.0257134661,
0.0114121931,
0.0643153191,
-0.0396865569,
-0.0049849581,
-0.0043465099,
-0.0534891821,
-0.0697605535,
0.0819320306,
0.0459969938,
0.0652348101,
0.0602766164,
-0.0163826905,
-0.057058733,
0.0458024293,
-0.0116942367,
0.0152667137,
-0.030261945,
0.0000628659,
-0.0162671488,
-0.011327235,
0.0253713634,
-0.0458290651,
0.0266069323,
0.0315056555,
0.0327826999,
0.0049730125,
0.0403191186,
-0.041792538,
-0.0559382029,
-0.054019779,
0.0726118088,
-0.0277126096,
-0.0212186631,
-0.008270462,
-0.0207358971,
-0.0238184631,
0.0427905954,
-0.0719636902,
0.0433477983,
0.0203909073,
0.02249006,
-0.0455073863,
0.0264304765,
0.0021484876,
-0.0091121858,
-0.0235917941,
0.0502078645,
0.0434113182,
-0.004901466,
-0.002282545,
0.0097343838,
-0.0482070521,
-0.021344671,
0.015670659,
-0.0058595552,
0.0330529362,
0.001035232,
-0.0434720367,
-0.0382710136,
0.0060553341,
0.0145245204,
0.0495953336,
0.0269992743,
-0.0410174243,
0.0323387086,
-0.0252519827,
0.0263225231,
-0.0625559166,
0.0255444068,
0.0100484611,
-0.0205596182,
-0.0590233654,
-0.0169409495,
-0.0685123131,
-0.0053028497,
-0.0148568759,
-0.0446735658,
-0.0316953696,
0.0200583637,
0.005027541,
-0.0589103475,
0.0478570908,
0.0323406532,
-0.046310734,
-0.0184448771,
-0.0004870054,
0.0521459617,
-0.0177799817,
0.0011304226,
0.0042101089,
-0.0812030733,
-0.0101694744,
0.0221000407,
0.0216930322,
-0.0507461429,
-0.0041212183,
0.0631692261,
0.0112219341,
-0.0660244375,
-0.0187900197,
0.0020560962,
-0.018848259,
-0.0553310439,
0.0142825078,
-0.0431899503,
0.0377529152,
0.0093516484,
0.0400226936,
-0.0272685122,
-0.0144101949,
0.0055990652,
-0.0163579546,
0.0919852108,
0.0056862133,
0.0243016835,
0.0107384231,
0.0158843491,
0.0283083934,
0.0412134379,
0.0392230041,
0.0099299643,
0.0511253327,
-0.0539140403,
0.0294654872,
0.0612961799,
-0.0119531546,
-0.0176067092,
0.0331274495,
-0.0194681622,
-0.0044175158,
0.0241967551,
0.0285970811,
0.059524823,
-0.0304232556,
-0.0144340238,
0.0893084854,
0.0603663214,
0.0240863655,
0.0273450706,
0.0905055031,
0.0130732181,
-0.0017143544,
-0.0262025204,
-0.0385488793,
0.0572452769,
-0.0478426367,
-0.0081360936,
-0.0051719821,
0.092287071,
-0.016927233,
-0.0011697874,
0.0106666535,
-0.04360044,
-0.0004439824,
-0.0363751464,
0.0703614056,
0.0181144252,
-0.0632373989,
0.0430446789,
0.012530745,
-0.087637119,
-0.0283530354,
-0.0460354201,
0.0031363363,
0.0286978036,
0.057947889,
-0.0054744482,
-0.024702942,
-0.0237874184,
-0.0146888234,
0.0250991397,
0.0308960918,
0.018914029,
-0.010387118,
-0.0643686876,
-0.0252302215,
0.0073144254,
0.0140005201,
0.0301209129,
0.0483660661,
0.0262204353,
0.0285909288,
-0.0274658632,
0.0438571535,
0.0307519641,
0.0034399626,
-0.0270728543,
-0.0202949829,
-0.0050259302,
0.0612831488,
0.0036932621,
0.0062200394,
-0.0109016579,
0.0364065431,
0.0018487463,
-0.0123463199,
0.0412538052,
-0.0526947007,
0.0037006717,
0.0057969131,
-0.0711773634,
0.0134794395,
0.0598347485,
-0.0549479239,
-0.0520476587,
0.0121306684,
-0.015310335,
0.0427448079,
-0.061961934,
-0.0075036073,
0.020379059,
0.0336880982,
-0.012678206,
0.0339836255,
0.0231892578,
-0.0314576626,
-0.0042696111,
0.0021526096,
0.0226469543,
-0.0270251147,
-0.0199637581,
0.0281617157,
-0.0054046316,
0.0056621376,
0.0164166819,
0.0291210338,
-0.0338921472,
-0.0063192756,
-0.0984195545,
0.020263968,
-0.0141374152,
0.009242259,
0.0287100859,
0.0324460529,
-0.0197299533,
0.0138746351,
-0.0111600561,
0.0168133453,
0.022920562,
0.0093809897,
0.0074134767,
-0.0224536248,
0.0013598725,
-0.0354788639,
-0.0216009188,
-0.0097575905,
0.046808783,
-0.0054252236,
-0.0114058396,
-0.0173408315,
0.0015475234,
-0.0018933211,
0.0310570542,
0.001351591,
-0.0399979874,
0.0129031967,
-0.0339190289,
0.0938050225,
0.0137716923,
0.0177322868,
0.0311788041,
0.0087216794,
-0.0277779885,
-0.0309257209,
0.0179399811,
-0.0627453104,
-0.0554957539,
-0.0016550474,
-0.0105223311,
0.0100996876,
0.0671610832,
0.0142290099,
-0.0176758301,
-0.0791599303,
0.0232194848,
-0.0073751048,
-0.0223336034,
0.0097266538,
0.0184374675,
-0.0208715349,
-0.0018943574,
0.0081964079,
-0.0494116098,
0.0425780863,
-0.059015803,
-0.0174017213,
-0.0211761035,
0.0160260927,
-0.0419974886,
0.0814631507,
0.0401818268,
0.0069924789,
0.0375388153,
0.0087730624,
-0.052182503,
0.0536547117,
0.0271410868,
-0.0102840066,
0.0316809528,
-0.0220374223,
0.0052777575,
-0.0378538966,
-0.0201896112,
0.0055408566,
-0.0406702794,
-0.0125016114,
-0.0018601583,
0.0198897459,
-0.0181869827,
-0.0184411146,
0.0431391187,
0.0186079144,
0.0485341214,
-0.0039547104,
-0.020108832,
-0.030231053,
0.0465001352,
0.0188631974,
-0.0008002458,
-0.0109320814,
-0.0115121529,
-0.0438861325,
0.0704432055,
0.0279850196,
-0.0134406807,
-0.0456961058,
-0.0022236221,
0.0393174812,
-0.0213368665,
-0.0203349125,
0.0058529116,
0.059842851,
-0.0434324145,
0.0368184783,
0.1036055908,
0.0142676914,
-0.0436816476,
-0.0007656489,
0.0465898067,
0.0045611938,
0.0090566128,
-0.0009589171,
-0.1008801386,
-0.0488078147,
-0.0050570909,
-0.002731578,
0.009131969,
-0.0177137349,
0.0049427073,
-0.1088787019,
0.0702451617,
-0.0086179888,
-0.0259444527,
-0.0060650278,
-0.032492388,
0.0019173728,
-0.0459088571,
-0.0252871942,
-0.0128977783,
-0.0189451408,
0.0353648886,
-0.0206448659,
-0.0227774438,
-0.0532759503,
0.0371923149,
-0.0239908788,
0.0106119625,
0.0871953741,
0.0146686817,
-0.0059636286,
-0.0528558232,
0.0154230809,
-0.0156407431,
-0.0039993683,
-0.0110821696,
0.0291334298,
-0.0154576134,
-0.0104452427,
-0.0184011776,
0.0396018736,
-0.0347357318,
-0.0296962429,
-0.0277479719,
0.1041195691,
0.0038335286,
-0.0351909436,
-0.050582774,
-0.0029688082,
-0.004254146,
0.0663328245,
0.0072261849,
-0.0337415263,
-0.0627171397,
-0.0041019521,
0.0488193855,
-0.0231475718,
-0.0900632963,
-0.0130706951,
0.0166593194,
-0.0533846542,
-0.0408528559,
-0.0161521472,
0.0427060202,
0.0123842396,
-0.0007642913,
-0.0437736288,
0.0178201813,
0.0232132208,
-0.0283599682,
0.0650132522,
-0.0197208747,
-0.0119271139,
-0.0807851851,
-0.0357180573,
0.0714906156,
-0.0155309886,
-0.0081332941,
0.0613606535,
-0.0387440175,
-0.0300695784,
-0.0129700573,
0.0819763392,
0.0230550766,
-0.0175192878,
-0.0030778048,
-0.0201472323,
0.0157043431,
0.0435980782,
-0.0344495401,
0.0200625267,
0.0177011956,
0.0001325967,
-0.0080635101,
0.0039745104,
0.0013089398,
0.0406767353,
-0.0250441786,
0.0257888399,
0.0091115069,
-0.0435159765,
0.0384365059,
-0.0091163935,
0.1066611186,
-0.0162166525,
0.0277900323,
-0.0404130071,
-0.0242987443,
-0.0189913362,
0.0015798574,
-0.084416233,
0.0057733627,
0.0358274579,
0.0203083735,
-0.0215099193,
0.0111076944,
-0.0154149598,
0.0157837793,
-0.0647431314,
0.0212506596,
0.046851512,
-0.0300487299,
0.0137232151,
0.0017706689,
-0.0054286066,
-0.009977717,
-0.0499534458,
0.0079853702,
-0.0279968251,
0.0812647119,
-0.0074380469,
-0.0106644528,
0.0229125246,
0.0573866032,
-0.0450416543,
-0.0242034961,
-0.0597214289,
0.0433761813,
0.0398504622,
0.0227581393,
0.0702134445,
-0.0477287211,
-0.0250288043,
-0.0183645207,
0.0539395027,
0.0173420757,
-0.0145126712,
0.0220561642,
0.0093480432,
-0.0057239207,
-0.0409799404,
0.0853026062,
-0.0037141857,
0.0572773069,
-0.0098327855,
-0.0286026411,
-0.0288470127,
-0.0353180729,
-0.0062589617,
-0.0182111282,
-0.0033590021,
0.0032788569,
-0.0668780729,
-0.0443056338,
-0.0131690875,
0.0059648128,
-0.0069210161,
-0.0223538615,
0.0718053207,
0.0620814748,
-0.0355420187,
-0.0463939942,
-0.0071657011,
0.000632927,
-0.0102686631,
-0.019712273,
0.0091032786,
-6.688348328e-33,
-0.0342803225,
0.0065241721,
0.0191936158,
-0.0191339366,
-0.0158881322,
-0.0211724546,
-0.0196151119,
0.0041394378,
0.0039172932,
-0.0038956723,
0.0134761501,
-0.0089529427,
0.0089015942,
0.0375455059,
0.0302433334,
0.0294891186,
0.0465007611,
-0.0293128286,
-0.0189316161,
0.0393245257,
0.0177585743,
0.019867463,
0.0822642893,
-0.0658197999,
-0.0317204669,
0.0207964294,
-0.0456564352,
-0.0331643037,
-0.0325444974,
0.0531743839,
-0.0353987888,
0.0150658153,
0.014741634,
-0.0525485389,
-0.0142171197,
0.0200125296,
-0.0636304244,
0.0125668626,
0.0035610602,
0.0173734482,
-0.0481611788,
-0.0241042953,
0.0302515049,
-0.0305318106,
-0.004973711,
-0.0351852998,
0.0313562527,
0.008241416,
0.020767998,
-0.0412545949,
-0.0782740191,
0.0330759659,
-0.0047966638,
-0.0021495807,
0.0337205455,
0.0279713031,
0.0014860692,
0.0515438952,
-0.03823727,
0.0208256766,
0.0352135412,
0.0030104513,
0.0599976145,
-0.0138485115,
0.0242575184,
0.0159167089,
-0.0040100063,
-0.0697281882,
-0.0451962538,
0.0013299756,
-0.0001198778,
0.0720777288,
0.0460485071,
0.0630971193,
0.0309539232,
0.0163273253,
-0.0145002566,
0.0045067617,
-0.0304880738,
0.0262600351,
0.0188605394,
0.0269310847,
0.0087332176,
0.0200092886,
-0.0066880551,
-0.0447880588,
-0.0089955116,
-0.0419019833,
0.0325414389,
0.0152230104,
-0.0127694486,
0.0418817364,
0.0526722893,
-0.0288923141,
0.0008401612,
-0.012168197,
-0.0276587624,
0.0673936531,
-0.0228434186,
0.0183124729,
-0.0389830805,
-0.0087956153,
0.0337457918,
-0.0134800291,
0.01353784,
-0.0048468653,
0.0164520908,
0.0582269989,
-0.0489291362,
-0.0091523416,
-0.0232990775,
0.0201458521,
-0.0194498263,
-0.0010055372,
0.0135298735,
0.0074143605,
-0.0356242768,
0.0295234825,
0.0214419886,
-0.0031199574,
-0.050451234,
-0.0221802443,
0.007263565,
-0.0014224682,
-0.0036214369,
0.019353224,
-0.0372588895,
-0.0411590301,
0.0456843786,
-0.054028444,
-0.0301266834,
0.0104646888,
2.933e-7,
0.0705555677,
0.039189104,
0.0287611987,
-0.0256947335,
0.0258576106,
0.0229286607,
0.006567705,
0.0410942398,
-0.0159966778,
-0.0041641146,
0.0084286481,
0.0373779424,
0.0270312447,
0.0250266641,
-0.0365751348,
-0.0141755762,
-0.0379334465,
-0.0150698246,
-0.0680459812,
-0.0130769126,
0.0617484748,
0.0930323452,
0.0008094929,
-0.0092114024,
0.0125038633,
-0.0005034238,
0.0970469937,
-0.0456820689,
0.0129596852,
0.0284077339,
0.0172786526,
0.0254591666,
-0.0102012297,
-0.0212303605,
0.0012258848,
-0.0253837127,
0.0354982913,
0.0597332567,
-0.0058295019,
-0.0430958085,
0.0199834164,
-0.0015463718,
-0.0280551594,
-0.0770223513,
0.094991982,
-0.0733074248,
-0.01015794,
-0.0068607996,
-0.0518867932,
-0.0184434503,
0.0040444131,
-0.0290881582,
-0.018309176,
0.0170815941,
0.0170901436,
0.0040026824,
-0.0519742891,
-0.094854407,
0.0150823006,
0.0024952716,
-0.0439668112,
-0.0237352159,
-0.0474960655,
-0.0385231711,
0.0562876724,
-0.0170493107,
-0.0272852238,
2.959394502e-34,
0.0298828837,
0.0048018149,
0.0415574908,
-0.0283591114,
0.0128738843,
-0.0103733838,
0.0260726549,
-0.0138926459,
-0.0278120972,
-0.0850078091,
-0.0465380661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14132v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14132v3 | Detecting Language Model Attacks with Perplexity | 2023-08-27T15:20:06 | 2023-11-07T03:30:15 | Gabriel Alon, Michael Kamfonas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | A novel hack involving Large Language Models (LLMs) has emerged, exploiting
adversarial suffixes to deceive models into generating perilous responses. Such
jailbreaks can trick LLMs into providing intricate instructions to a malicious
user for creating explosives, orchestrating a bank heist, or facilitating the
creation of offensive content. By evaluating the perplexity of queries with
adversarial suffixes using an open-source LLM (GPT-2), we found that they have
exceedingly high perplexity values. As we explored a broad range of regular
(non-adversarial) prompt varieties, we concluded that false positives are a
significant challenge for plain perplexity filtering. A Light-GBM trained on
perplexity and token length resolved the false positives and correctly detected
most adversarial attacks in the test set. | [
0.0395960435,
0.0848481357,
-0.0250688549,
0.0619274825,
-0.0637303293,
-0.0046249945,
0.0239983164,
0.0219337698,
0.0333179645,
-0.0179879256,
-0.0000682622,
-0.035818629,
-0.0114913881,
0.0364850499,
0.0710280091,
0.0205522683,
0.0675301254,
-0.0245858468,
-0.0296222344,
-0.0205687042,
-0.0119586056,
-0.0066528427,
-0.0085812379,
0.0351711921,
0.0091601629,
0.0074210474,
-0.0170364249,
0.0249064118,
-0.0040807859,
-0.0349661261,
-0.0215729214,
0.0451388471,
-0.0349759869,
0.1115177348,
0.0000018978,
-0.059153337,
-0.0313363336,
0.0088788448,
-0.0637595132,
0.0389156416,
0.0414209403,
0.0015290199,
-0.0180396605,
0.0266125891,
-0.0266113579,
0.003412223,
0.0200795382,
0.0661693364,
0.0399253331,
0.08483769,
-0.0104811639,
-0.009414522,
0.0277730506,
-0.0351558179,
0.0278315879,
-0.0537873134,
0.0372819044,
-0.0560631566,
-0.0012458948,
0.0471067205,
-0.0032539002,
-0.016485814,
0.0021195894,
-0.0050878157,
-0.1133465469,
-0.0009499657,
-0.0022818125,
0.0096234949,
0.0361912958,
0.0497579835,
-0.0674036145,
-0.0016406807,
0.007911264,
0.0196717102,
0.0240408517,
0.0188582391,
-0.005977056,
0.0105443755,
0.0033677719,
-0.0056222244,
0.0086752847,
-0.0474933498,
0.0670745745,
0.0177783463,
-0.0465411656,
0.0493024364,
0.0345662013,
-0.0077230046,
-0.012072525,
-0.0625310764,
-0.0275857616,
-0.0470352061,
0.0013385419,
-0.0002205277,
-0.0224945825,
-0.0052408944,
-0.0800940767,
-0.0366092473,
0.0556264669,
-0.0430687182,
0.027003305,
0.0169345681,
-0.0344225988,
0.0501070097,
-0.0262813531,
0.0258616079,
-0.0249260236,
0.0629873648,
-0.0048339278,
-0.0072526345,
-0.0113645568,
-0.0208945014,
-0.0039998856,
0.0448290221,
0.0091519468,
-0.0041244491,
-0.0425091907,
0.0409816541,
0.00493568,
0.0157947261,
-0.0449026003,
0.0093231108,
0.0081292409,
0.0006377831,
0.0121349366,
-0.0322314128,
0.0010952337,
-0.0010367357,
-0.0173028372,
-0.0758271292,
-0.0376914702,
0.020981444,
-0.0381082594,
-0.0561110787,
0.0051828576,
0.09619838,
0.0238639526,
-0.0269976892,
-0.0458689332,
-0.0641897619,
-0.0003318831,
-0.004880534,
-0.0104175992,
-0.0417824723,
-0.0286447853,
-0.0252082553,
-0.0092927385,
-0.0552518405,
-0.0100040631,
-0.0031938546,
-0.0352874957,
0.0705112293,
0.00176015,
-0.0126952939,
0.0132924244,
0.0286879968,
0.0151891373,
0.0820430741,
-0.0425683483,
0.0494339652,
0.046814207,
-0.0177587662,
0.0453581959,
0.0419235006,
0.0034384637,
0.0234023016,
-0.0420896783,
-0.0090954881,
0.0373028331,
-0.0213424526,
-0.0017315195,
0.0385499895,
-0.0132093383,
-0.0531187952,
0.0708102882,
0.0501708649,
-0.029669933,
0.0267436504,
-0.0065187691,
-0.0080056805,
-0.0303107947,
0.0351818725,
-0.0759512335,
-0.0379751697,
-0.0942732841,
-0.0339396782,
0.0310225505,
0.0342679471,
-0.0098434193,
-0.0065910481,
0.0070039383,
-0.0071027535,
0.0402350053,
-0.0026727787,
0.0407494269,
0.001314925,
-0.0362877697,
0.0320886485,
-0.0154243251,
-0.0231317263,
-0.01053493,
-0.088034071,
-0.0356581509,
0.0435618646,
0.0703863502,
-0.0204093419,
-0.0192719027,
-0.0065221242,
-0.0233453121,
0.0162883624,
-0.0139955478,
0.0396732502,
0.0356444828,
-0.0102001932,
-0.00080843,
-0.0075976145,
0.0417580642,
0.0082635442,
0.0153078595,
0.0244767759,
0.017777184,
-0.0393889882,
-0.0122986967,
0.0316709951,
0.0074340664,
-0.0378892943,
0.026892988,
0.0277250074,
0.0321176238,
0.0079277083,
-0.0007429775,
0.0469675101,
0.0553869046,
-0.0307548083,
0.0125631439,
-0.0416508168,
0.0196293239,
-0.0008905376,
0.0424813926,
-0.0017369509,
0.0171257723,
0.089408718,
-0.0421153195,
-0.0171469506,
0.0845203623,
-0.0610697232,
0.0196174886,
-0.0335704833,
0.0084604714,
-0.0223390069,
0.042590525,
-0.0270168409,
0.0292543769,
-0.0207270496,
0.0204819329,
-0.0308313668,
-0.0073963632,
0.0346651301,
-0.0054032877,
-0.0550440438,
-0.0060771913,
-0.038118463,
0.0036749633,
-0.0215813313,
-0.0112169571,
-0.0041541723,
-0.0337430239,
-0.0564220846,
-0.0450328924,
-0.0294365212,
0.0274394322,
0.0340654366,
0.0227299258,
-0.0244360417,
-0.0308919847,
-0.016729312,
-0.0259832386,
0.0155120473,
0.0284608137,
0.0141763063,
-0.0127528515,
-0.0697276816,
-0.0061239479,
-0.0201244,
-0.0230051316,
0.0668759048,
-0.006860917,
-0.0122343628,
0.0019982394,
0.0006868923,
-0.0313456394,
0.0427621864,
-0.0239519589,
-0.057130646,
0.0332870595,
-0.0097793648,
-0.022867389,
0.0575749762,
0.0499581508,
0.0353865176,
0.0497106314,
0.0132724708,
-0.010074635,
-0.0246853344,
0.0035218755,
-0.0273070801,
-0.0509867817,
-0.0256206039,
0.025218932,
0.0071090898,
0.0148952929,
-0.0249718241,
-0.0170827042,
0.0566834621,
0.0192857198,
-0.0191763435,
-0.0428580418,
-0.015345809,
-0.0249209832,
0.0192436669,
0.0129350172,
-0.0557880737,
0.0844920948,
-0.0547137111,
0.0304754432,
-0.0307116676,
-0.0463450812,
0.0101619652,
0.048685573,
-0.0301567614,
0.0416362062,
-0.0028034423,
-0.0699313134,
-0.0293160193,
-0.0320961773,
0.0252083912,
-0.0311245918,
0.0463361628,
-0.0080204215,
0.0097154053,
0.0108210966,
0.0054014358,
-0.0627253652,
-0.0791182145,
-0.0212151986,
-0.0074218181,
0.0537577122,
-0.0447446257,
-0.0344809964,
0.0229209214,
0.0087897396,
-0.0058395057,
-0.0332420878,
0.0113257244,
-0.0197203476,
0.0104234852,
0.0294878948,
-0.0301608387,
0.0106875971,
0.0027325863,
0.0273653492,
0.0637207627,
-0.0117810573,
-0.0226317011,
0.0257498771,
0.0127265621,
0.018239418,
-0.0202800874,
-0.0201980211,
0.023688389,
-0.011993546,
-0.0268237758,
-0.0255765617,
0.0653556138,
0.0230994485,
-0.0434209406,
0.0159237608,
-0.0262500253,
0.0057853712,
0.0102892546,
0.0204356238,
-0.0663081631,
-0.0125075066,
0.0211288091,
0.0296163168,
-0.0223885309,
-0.037859384,
-0.0276705455,
-0.1025646701,
0.0174737349,
0.0153853502,
-0.0529130362,
-0.0264899395,
-0.0276822913,
-0.0294218436,
0.0407918841,
0.050132297,
0.0069350246,
0.0079333615,
0.0008227474,
-0.0097876005,
-0.0179938413,
-0.0508061834,
-0.0050358186,
-0.0435049683,
0.0221736431,
0.0888705924,
-0.0108075086,
-0.0417696163,
-0.0277991686,
0.0631031618,
0.0210765079,
-0.0043056342,
-0.0019507521,
0.0383837223,
0.0157563351,
-0.0281293467,
0.0031412737,
0.0257726815,
-0.0347749628,
-0.0083200475,
0.0338525623,
0.0295455921,
-0.0505939163,
0.017992707,
-0.0019613404,
-0.018675698,
0.0219718907,
0.0464042313,
0.0259736869,
-0.0304203182,
-0.020210173,
-0.071369715,
-0.0038986045,
-0.0172741637,
-0.0321680419,
0.022084428,
0.0408390686,
-0.0336116031,
-0.0086760176,
0.0234578364,
-0.0068208268,
0.0408838615,
0.0315883271,
0.0383740775,
-0.0463304669,
0.0097368695,
-0.0380538106,
-0.0391519666,
-0.0021449907,
0.044136215,
-0.0985507667,
0.0342855714,
-0.0015212577,
0.0026360233,
-0.0231312606,
-0.0024879435,
-0.0659548342,
-0.0686642081,
0.0219572894,
0.0181822088,
0.0219194125,
0.0019669298,
-0.0620936267,
-0.0568662733,
0.0170196705,
0.0608049445,
-0.0046482123,
0.0156938229,
0.06302315,
-0.0377111025,
0.0072467867,
0.0344677344,
-0.0356815532,
-0.0121022873,
0.0495460667,
-0.0090141995,
-0.0431419462,
0.0114355953,
0.0167498458,
0.0557831749,
0.0707313046,
0.0070063099,
0.0287203621,
0.015527565,
0.0256808922,
-0.0187855437,
-0.011753357,
0.0022646324,
-0.0033263909,
0.0307858884,
-0.0067020133,
0.031084802,
-0.0202846415,
-0.0400228053,
0.0482035317,
-0.0187338423,
0.0097787902,
-0.0357913226,
0.0081481934,
0.0525390804,
-0.0044603571,
-0.0115044918,
0.0575729609,
0.0186634101,
0.038066715,
-0.0240349323,
0.0132707087,
-0.0050110901,
0.0102083907,
-0.0346496403,
0.0488937795,
-0.0712761357,
-0.0578710251,
0.0115507739,
0.018302992,
0.051544603,
0.005557436,
-0.006358515,
-0.0033262705,
0.017499283,
-0.0309548117,
-0.0252528861,
0.003704543,
-0.0276380628,
0.0229416154,
0.0035155334,
-0.0155111989,
0.042512238,
0.1089476123,
0.009779905,
0.0336755738,
0.0532791913,
-0.0272707772,
-0.0053058439,
-0.0134936487,
0.0700367764,
0.0587904826,
-0.062522918,
-0.0200889651,
-0.0271839928,
-0.0623489097,
-0.0164412484,
-0.0185513776,
0.0115734562,
0.0282092355,
-0.0230102111,
0.1011969224,
0.0024900006,
0.016985245,
-0.0827078894,
0.0462097153,
0.0103292745,
-0.0692426041,
0.0223027542,
-6.071166407e-33,
0.0360134467,
-0.0574918464,
-0.0542043522,
-0.0598774217,
0.0279586818,
-0.0045136809,
-0.0100795915,
0.0046840548,
-0.0423777737,
-0.0199616197,
-0.0167065226,
0.017575711,
-0.0025634635,
0.0448229052,
-0.0242076945,
-0.0431582555,
0.0266343579,
0.0279220119,
-0.0066771563,
0.0225829184,
0.0510452054,
0.0233256668,
0.0135980928,
-0.0824892968,
0.0208636895,
-0.0025816958,
-0.0243375618,
0.0207863636,
-0.0248026382,
0.0494286083,
0.0032470995,
0.015113689,
-0.0019245391,
-0.0120088626,
0.001951645,
-0.0257123653,
0.0371945687,
-0.0038597886,
0.0104071209,
-0.0050215153,
0.0413263701,
-0.057695549,
0.0169722717,
-0.0215284918,
-0.0240346901,
0.0164941624,
-0.0123862978,
-0.011795559,
-0.0254823584,
0.0171651579,
0.0189875457,
-0.0007348889,
-0.0229681488,
0.0215666145,
-0.0087856371,
-0.0075178603,
0.0458446257,
0.026595531,
-0.0143730799,
0.0612840056,
0.051499065,
0.0312566087,
0.0361877941,
0.0180278085,
0.0056357989,
0.0630580485,
0.0180137921,
-0.0334479287,
-0.0293702707,
0.022461012,
0.0164247211,
0.0466838218,
0.0673744678,
0.0607037693,
0.064371191,
-0.0309163984,
-0.0859034806,
0.0093992939,
0.0044336724,
0.0192005187,
0.0589002557,
0.0012370909,
-0.0594355911,
-0.0091456845,
0.0079313368,
-0.0356387869,
-0.045704022,
-0.0539572313,
0.0077113993,
-0.0311315954,
-0.0405103266,
-0.0521045849,
0.0066573992,
-0.0625020266,
-0.0362123698,
0.0265240353,
-0.0097659267,
-0.0312018041,
-0.0019048291,
0.0185782202,
0.036719691,
-0.013245401,
0.0177767519,
-0.0706166774,
0.0205205996,
-0.0238627438,
0.0081478944,
0.0228651054,
-0.0671104491,
-0.0242529083,
0.0013107316,
0.0377429165,
0.0155314291,
0.0304986648,
0.0202791486,
-0.014153528,
0.0157916974,
-0.0270713158,
0.0404668488,
-0.0156273879,
-0.0375206396,
-0.0009967982,
-0.0259699654,
0.0530177057,
-0.0091579892,
-0.0254190359,
-0.0089637898,
0.0014937532,
0.0529774129,
-0.0627772138,
-0.0032129588,
-0.012558437,
2.847e-7,
0.0204426125,
0.0253066253,
0.0007207473,
0.0206132103,
0.0139983818,
0.0543495156,
-0.0021259577,
0.0635648891,
-0.0254391432,
-0.0041338219,
-0.0127893081,
-0.0096805943,
0.027270034,
0.0288856458,
-0.0661946014,
0.0213551968,
-0.0613895021,
0.0023178058,
-0.0707419217,
0.0282666571,
0.0357717052,
0.1181310415,
0.0039623929,
-0.034274403,
0.0011924638,
-0.1071945801,
-0.0388707742,
-0.0134326126,
-0.0142146982,
-0.0208034385,
0.0552570485,
0.0121637667,
0.0512638502,
0.0492834263,
-0.0300494805,
-0.0031657068,
-0.0152823003,
0.0157827027,
0.0124298492,
-0.068148315,
-0.0517958887,
-0.0405206457,
0.026051512,
-0.0856951028,
0.0766128749,
0.0744266659,
-0.0221394226,
-0.0055030701,
-0.0099524958,
-0.0452287532,
0.0464867912,
-0.0443484448,
-0.0335893743,
0.0237803217,
0.038161464,
-0.0029101311,
0.0467555709,
-0.0429189429,
0.0067627295,
-0.0330805108,
-0.0297579728,
-0.027624948,
-0.0079134414,
0.0481229275,
0.0366375111,
0.0347300619,
0.0191909615,
3.004401012e-34,
0.0361153074,
-0.0182493385,
0.0194825064,
0.0306888297,
0.0441414975,
0.0343645625,
0.0223560091,
0.0159568191,
-0.0147216879,
-0.069025673,
-0.0273867473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14120v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14120v5 | Large Language Models Streamline Automated Machine Learning for Clinical Studies | 2023-08-27T14:28:38 | 2024-02-21T18:35:25 | Soroosh Tayebi Arasteh, Tianyu Han, Mahshad Lotfinia, Christiane Kuhl, Jakob Nikolas Kather, Daniel Truhn, Sven Nebelung | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | A knowledge gap persists between machine learning (ML) developers (e.g., data
scientists) and practitioners (e.g., clinicians), hampering the full
utilization of ML for clinical data analysis. We investigated the potential of
the ChatGPT Advanced Data Analysis (ADA), an extension of GPT-4, to bridge this
gap and perform ML analyses efficiently. Real-world clinical datasets and study
details from large trials across various medical specialties were presented to
ChatGPT ADA without specific guidance. ChatGPT ADA autonomously developed
state-of-the-art ML models based on the original study's training data to
predict clinical outcomes such as cancer development, cancer progression,
disease complications, or biomarkers such as pathogenic gene sequences.
Following the re-implementation and optimization of the published models, the
head-to-head comparison of the ChatGPT ADA-crafted ML models and their
respective manually crafted counterparts revealed no significant differences in
traditional performance metrics (P>0.071). Strikingly, the ChatGPT ADA-crafted
ML models often outperformed their counterparts. In conclusion, ChatGPT ADA
offers a promising avenue to democratize ML in medicine by simplifying complex
data analyses, yet should enhance, not replace, specialized training and
resources, to promote broader applications in medical research and practice. | [
0.0076072766,
0.0816465989,
-0.0222440157,
-0.0230761021,
-0.0202411003,
0.0389845744,
0.0383501276,
0.0109475181,
0.0202572905,
0.0197823104,
0.0528051592,
-0.0179449096,
-0.0211728215,
0.0658953115,
0.0068791769,
-0.0299536344,
0.0067277187,
0.0058963457,
0.0311653949,
-0.0050898809,
-0.0157592352,
0.0233570579,
0.0165622812,
0.0604612157,
-0.0044539412,
0.001022355,
0.0467015989,
-0.0406370573,
-0.0298525244,
-0.0343140773,
0.0195394736,
0.022711141,
-0.0002542445,
0.0514949299,
0.0000021962,
-0.0829326138,
-0.0242345389,
0.0439935997,
-0.0154353194,
-0.0164042562,
0.0179126319,
-0.0291630086,
0.0254229158,
0.0114263725,
-0.0218915679,
-0.0318921469,
0.052342087,
0.0070600165,
0.022950273,
0.0488407649,
-0.016174484,
-0.0312526114,
0.0696757361,
-0.0550654829,
0.0474930555,
-0.0323078558,
0.0498569645,
0.0117848357,
-0.004528428,
-0.0345624872,
0.0316673853,
0.0603163466,
0.0027763413,
0.0369041711,
-0.0058819503,
0.0563171655,
-0.0347225815,
-0.0452118441,
0.0056104758,
-0.0103117535,
-0.0075238999,
-0.0320418999,
0.0189368483,
-0.0101401275,
0.0238872524,
-0.0063999374,
-0.0476627573,
0.0211110488,
-0.0319608115,
-0.0182066821,
-0.01661513,
-0.0126045253,
0.0330670327,
-0.0128724258,
-0.0251403097,
0.0414571911,
-0.0075184009,
-0.0042614415,
0.0184324794,
0.0153545626,
-0.0165726095,
0.0106302956,
-0.0182631277,
-0.0055594197,
-0.0311025381,
-0.0032170431,
0.021282861,
-0.0105035407,
0.0918113217,
-0.0694990531,
0.0328681991,
-0.0093373945,
-0.0057690344,
0.0252256878,
-0.0264493898,
-0.0153367482,
-0.0178887099,
0.033856906,
-0.0143210152,
0.0225147437,
-0.0181221534,
-0.0094934739,
-0.0018814098,
0.0050563379,
-0.0174262039,
0.0393268727,
-0.0850490928,
0.0268633049,
-0.0090395808,
0.0052649789,
0.0162258241,
0.0282453243,
-0.0118870037,
0.0347169749,
-0.010161614,
-0.0280608255,
0.0193962101,
0.0123088183,
-0.0235609282,
-0.0842473432,
0.0317974761,
-0.0039761439,
-0.0021103122,
-0.0145127457,
0.0342567824,
0.0888022855,
0.0177194141,
-0.0104067596,
0.0099905515,
0.0041509629,
-0.0491068885,
-0.0703089461,
-0.005860562,
-0.0904290006,
0.0231187977,
0.060324695,
0.0115543874,
-0.0313450396,
-0.0126239387,
-0.0220950227,
-0.0554230809,
0.0489199869,
-0.0447541773,
0.0095381942,
0.0322083123,
0.0125573026,
-0.0416397378,
0.0341451876,
0.0107319877,
-0.0062258141,
0.0069137453,
-0.0620519035,
0.0178325512,
0.0339530893,
0.0129457992,
-0.0294399932,
-0.0181284808,
0.0071282983,
0.0004289016,
0.0412444957,
-0.0532486178,
0.0207477883,
0.0175040159,
-0.0234865714,
0.0445281044,
0.0401986167,
0.0214281417,
0.077575095,
0.0113447094,
-0.0091500077,
0.0203986466,
-0.0608199276,
-0.0074107889,
-0.0160966739,
-0.0172186773,
0.0117458403,
-0.0264481474,
0.0228034575,
-0.0167566035,
-0.0542055741,
-0.0280578025,
0.0017747128,
-0.0049943519,
-0.0204330534,
0.0377651639,
-0.068954967,
-0.0140946656,
-0.0240700506,
0.0637840107,
0.0075250361,
-0.0621934235,
-0.0841273516,
-0.0298400689,
-0.0007683776,
0.0194641761,
-0.0326225087,
-0.0338340215,
-0.0420906805,
0.0174380336,
-0.0493619926,
0.007686398,
0.0304737519,
0.0120567326,
0.0236634128,
0.0037426061,
0.027605487,
0.0302731004,
-0.0199191906,
0.0094422409,
0.0185772851,
-0.0380843468,
-0.0282216985,
-0.0639380738,
0.0409366265,
-0.0326313749,
-0.0226916447,
0.0348226465,
-0.0248490684,
0.0488634296,
-0.0162193812,
-0.0232633185,
0.0033425218,
0.0394934155,
-0.0268129781,
-0.0319050588,
-0.0004990275,
0.0240464676,
-0.0135819409,
0.0065478361,
-0.0212006513,
-0.0243931338,
0.0012418606,
-0.0594367087,
0.0211051367,
-0.0227363072,
-0.0273324046,
0.0175327696,
-0.0007005904,
0.0007993263,
-0.0151137849,
0.0262595285,
-0.0447408929,
0.0204372443,
-0.0088527305,
-0.0236331206,
-0.0072036353,
-0.0662518218,
0.036391627,
0.0093269199,
-0.0238100737,
-0.0042144475,
-0.0066187056,
0.0148586864,
0.0081629753,
0.0002105658,
0.0055367197,
0.0200786814,
-0.0764635876,
-0.0061825952,
0.0118091237,
0.0088841999,
-0.0157340337,
-0.005064405,
-0.0395594873,
-0.0153623829,
-0.0346469954,
0.002428012,
0.0285869092,
0.029465843,
0.0414437391,
0.0248698853,
-0.0271308944,
-0.0502760857,
-0.0291057415,
-0.0466451161,
0.0355904661,
0.0417729057,
-0.0451603904,
0.0363350399,
0.0044571366,
-0.0245106965,
-0.0000240789,
-0.0161530077,
-0.0086112833,
0.0064955186,
-0.0303819031,
-0.0135256359,
0.0379307419,
-0.0162750892,
0.0291015171,
0.0303125046,
0.021278793,
-0.0090792179,
0.0072666327,
-0.0527482182,
-0.06481646,
0.020981187,
-0.0314089693,
-0.0032900013,
0.0462272018,
0.0177901946,
-0.0041097086,
-0.0328145437,
0.0153085319,
-0.000853785,
0.0017515514,
-0.0611627512,
0.0433928892,
-0.0395011641,
0.0326570123,
-0.0000726624,
-0.1060938537,
0.1063019037,
0.001959098,
0.0252297968,
-0.0771384984,
-0.0222677775,
-0.0046639778,
-0.0042076027,
0.0370314121,
0.0234736893,
-0.0092171058,
0.0256544817,
0.0192690101,
0.017236542,
-0.0000708232,
-0.0509466007,
0.0922201052,
-0.027014805,
0.0293560531,
0.0449076854,
-0.0251302253,
-0.0289476439,
0.0140751107,
-0.0263470486,
-0.0083792228,
0.0157205239,
-0.0106021827,
-0.0605124384,
0.0270779189,
-0.0212230086,
0.0367231034,
-0.030182397,
-0.0164294168,
0.0116825989,
-0.0629272014,
0.0362254865,
-0.060214527,
-0.0136069776,
-0.0237311982,
0.0619609058,
0.0271507036,
-0.0066631422,
0.026147116,
-0.0318720266,
0.0254549664,
-0.0182868354,
-0.0049513644,
-0.0079626897,
0.0341793858,
0.0004849138,
-0.0495062023,
0.0285362732,
0.093494691,
0.0037365963,
-0.0892717764,
-0.0115964729,
0.0087901596,
0.010483929,
-0.0300234221,
0.0325877741,
-0.0772373751,
-0.0216699392,
-0.017230954,
0.0424238965,
-0.0336742811,
-0.0406432375,
0.0348329321,
0.0048707714,
0.0574874803,
0.0107854558,
-0.0831184834,
-0.0169859696,
-0.0788484439,
0.0009497752,
-0.0801629648,
-0.0198511742,
-0.0464336723,
0.003806242,
-0.004594286,
0.0038191299,
-0.0947987065,
-0.0783303678,
0.0438480638,
-0.0128925284,
0.0361006334,
0.0461099483,
0.0053543528,
-0.0457672812,
0.0370630175,
0.0119768968,
0.0375067443,
0.0130736902,
-0.0233036242,
0.0912146345,
0.0437155887,
0.0002496026,
-0.0516538844,
0.0437591635,
-0.0116096279,
0.0356247388,
-0.0005086478,
0.1039654538,
-0.0352822766,
-0.0538759604,
-0.0443901718,
0.0044433633,
0.0007285199,
0.0485385619,
-0.00096216,
-0.0118783657,
-0.0218817182,
-0.0185911935,
0.0465047657,
0.0290110577,
0.0034803974,
0.0040752389,
-0.0435763821,
-0.018168658,
-0.0103840902,
-0.0087280162,
0.0456709974,
-0.0652669892,
0.0048561199,
0.0498076603,
-0.0162304025,
0.0011906596,
-0.074118562,
0.0646062046,
0.0710829124,
0.034455549,
-0.0288261902,
-0.0679489225,
0.0448665246,
-0.0138758002,
-0.0102772545,
0.041535493,
-0.0374698825,
-0.0336332135,
-0.0049271723,
0.0858223736,
0.0189518332,
-0.0160959344,
-0.0005433107,
-0.0262456648,
0.0417026654,
0.0733018294,
-0.0237928964,
-0.0429886058,
-0.0435051173,
-0.0266201384,
-0.0054424168,
-0.0280187167,
0.007898733,
0.040073894,
-0.0339259245,
-0.0258316752,
-7.098e-7,
-0.0082065351,
0.0448687077,
0.0574667789,
0.0828300416,
-0.0133920154,
-0.0363455191,
0.0014479699,
-0.0021826408,
0.0123645961,
0.0186082609,
-0.0303347912,
-0.0211409833,
0.0174195673,
0.0358272493,
-0.0436468497,
-0.0268659778,
-0.0430365354,
-0.0610880367,
-0.1089648157,
0.0577158928,
0.0177403018,
0.0277761891,
0.0806360468,
0.0045048338,
0.0077285715,
-0.0116485013,
-0.0112960804,
-0.005188216,
0.0076803216,
0.0277671032,
-0.0016636529,
0.0767939761,
0.0104404911,
0.0437057056,
-0.0244650021,
-0.0558470935,
-0.0216111932,
0.0179615133,
0.0455067046,
-0.0235924181,
0.0565437675,
-0.0388156176,
0.0066773682,
-0.0733878985,
0.0048258277,
-0.0334526338,
0.0525732711,
0.0026599341,
0.0024791821,
-0.055363223,
-0.0561588854,
0.0911260545,
0.0357925408,
0.0630472675,
-0.0309919193,
-0.0571341999,
-0.0296489689,
-0.0185394995,
0.063265577,
-0.0108837923,
-0.0507337749,
-0.0247584917,
-0.0455138199,
-0.0512978733,
-0.0190586429,
-0.0080320574,
0.0110974601,
-0.0079112025,
0.008091771,
0.0553767383,
-0.0138721569,
-0.0248531811,
-0.0330365561,
0.0368431285,
-0.0107887387,
-0.0380322374,
0.0177543722,
-5.609089863e-33,
0.0523822159,
-0.0090557113,
0.0144780083,
0.0374664254,
0.0150940968,
0.0120200496,
-0.0367602184,
-0.002803277,
0.0352224894,
0.0526858419,
-0.0044202702,
0.0063676685,
-0.0191673711,
0.0154581191,
0.0473950356,
-0.0263146181,
-0.003798455,
-0.021034738,
0.0205444004,
0.0194355845,
-0.0378724858,
0.0512347817,
0.0023632916,
-0.0739810839,
-0.0044219806,
0.0302947648,
0.0107127894,
-0.0249936283,
-0.058963865,
0.0549956486,
0.0149634555,
0.0565700382,
0.0315346383,
0.0044544493,
-0.0003737524,
-0.0441387184,
-0.0283033606,
0.0335905217,
-0.0083859637,
-0.0208204035,
0.0032571324,
0.0272472724,
0.0532325022,
-0.0180618875,
-0.0393554568,
0.0032476552,
0.0226877425,
-0.0354710072,
-0.0243088566,
-0.0150425453,
-0.0071007949,
0.0505657941,
-0.0331400856,
0.016806839,
0.0170939397,
0.0052402792,
-0.0222188495,
0.0282392912,
0.0052620769,
0.016506359,
0.0560809784,
-0.0226356313,
0.0213072356,
-0.0208973158,
0.020331515,
0.0486732498,
0.0414546691,
-0.0437149927,
-0.0235949103,
0.0341280289,
-0.014168513,
0.0343142673,
0.0363754854,
0.0043378109,
0.0136252968,
-0.02252925,
-0.1172470525,
0.0563346036,
-0.029439576,
0.0068508522,
0.0119501818,
-0.0228452832,
-0.0172857065,
-0.009726176,
-0.0238374155,
-0.0064988402,
-0.0099722221,
-0.0327261537,
0.0187665783,
-0.0358939432,
-0.0039514978,
0.049759496,
0.0321714282,
-0.0279800836,
-0.0109217633,
-0.0251341555,
0.0230712444,
-0.009862965,
-0.0023207162,
0.0362744667,
-0.0346030109,
-0.0177361146,
-0.0091797607,
-0.0133780157,
0.0533903465,
-0.0135286711,
0.0223393254,
-0.0161765367,
-0.0393976755,
0.0074930941,
-0.0149263861,
0.0075438567,
-0.0063863941,
0.0178478733,
0.0247603916,
0.0089464718,
0.0173873845,
0.0631319359,
0.0249869134,
0.0059947106,
-0.0418026857,
-0.0479357243,
-0.0217584055,
-0.0339100212,
-0.0153141459,
-0.0068454002,
-0.0327683389,
-0.0031215439,
0.0567604825,
-0.0486653745,
-0.0118215177,
-0.0204391293,
2.848e-7,
0.1036379114,
0.0726385713,
-0.0391560569,
-0.0250801221,
0.0300862025,
0.0080581456,
-0.027098665,
-0.0029120182,
0.0061824983,
0.052848693,
0.0648409054,
-0.0019026798,
0.0653999522,
0.0121936891,
-0.0315294079,
-0.0258221347,
-0.0738801509,
-0.00376892,
-0.0598963499,
-0.0030441806,
0.0429687724,
0.0683694035,
-0.0138165681,
-0.0381744094,
0.0506337881,
0.0080548488,
-0.0002737426,
-0.066070959,
0.0139242103,
0.0403962359,
0.0030706399,
0.0009582686,
0.0521863811,
0.0589049868,
-0.0209165104,
-0.0263062343,
-0.0010044181,
0.0896708295,
-0.0121866185,
0.071486555,
0.0690286607,
0.0216981638,
0.0551341102,
-0.0967861786,
0.0439324491,
-0.0432076268,
-0.0467689149,
-0.0170926694,
0.016633939,
-0.027890373,
0.1151871234,
-0.0255478118,
-0.016369164,
0.0355673879,
0.0150267258,
0.0069052828,
-0.0224624611,
0.0024070307,
-0.0076087397,
0.0235986561,
-0.0517844073,
-0.015394411,
-0.0089168707,
0.0114862034,
0.0306365099,
-0.0272239391,
0.0554742403,
2.714768387e-34,
0.0335103609,
-0.0082164668,
0.0159360673,
0.0075066113,
0.0471068621,
-0.0007808137,
0.049687542,
0.0183325689,
-0.0541588776,
-0.0540302247,
0.0121625401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14115v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14115v2 | Situated Natural Language Explanations | 2023-08-27T14:14:28 | 2024-03-25T03:54:48 | Zining Zhu, Haoming Jiang, Jingfeng Yang, Sreyashi Nag, Chao Zhang, Jie Huang, Yifan Gao, Frank Rudzicz, Bing Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Natural language is among the most accessible tools for explaining decisions
to humans, and large pretrained language models (PLMs) have demonstrated
impressive abilities to generate coherent natural language explanations (NLE).
The existing NLE research perspectives do not take the audience into account.
An NLE can have high textual quality, but it might not accommodate audiences'
needs and preference. To address this limitation, we propose an alternative
perspective, \textit{situated} NLE. On the evaluation side, we set up automated
evaluation scores. These scores describe the properties of NLEs in lexical,
semantic, and pragmatic categories. On the generation side, we identify three
prompt engineering techniques and assess their applicability on the situations.
Situated NLE provides a perspective and facilitates further research on the
generation and evaluation of explanations. | [
0.0293736458,
-0.0132539514,
-0.0199471731,
-0.0066943835,
-0.021356279,
-0.0124869486,
0.0354318507,
-0.03615015,
-0.0173763148,
-0.0484476015,
0.0097489078,
0.023254972,
0.0082831336,
0.0300014857,
0.027721649,
-0.094271116,
0.0032323205,
-0.0135235945,
0.0220642425,
0.0206496138,
-0.0026597674,
0.0469197631,
-0.0400700606,
0.0510972403,
0.0137333572,
-0.0124832885,
-0.0555200316,
0.0011462227,
0.0076505011,
-0.0447322652,
-0.0031017251,
0.0061271102,
0.0529003404,
-0.0460750125,
0.0000024465,
-0.0379585102,
0.0460035801,
-0.0179249775,
-0.0555262528,
0.012264112,
-0.0054835235,
0.0072058686,
0.0241388958,
-0.0040239198,
0.0030684639,
-0.0045024804,
0.0208050907,
0.0468451418,
0.0591858365,
0.0469145551,
0.0049201883,
-0.0363981538,
-0.0593968704,
0.0170009993,
0.0135440705,
-0.0144075984,
-0.0249389801,
0.0116205001,
0.0560983159,
0.0335612521,
0.0099324947,
0.0178462584,
0.0317321606,
-0.0506617092,
0.0392929278,
0.0367836356,
0.0015541483,
-0.0402488187,
-0.0363288745,
0.0609850623,
0.0322626457,
-0.0027946557,
-0.0087557947,
-0.0511884876,
0.0056344862,
-0.0064538568,
-0.0249194633,
0.0373682529,
-0.0033663234,
0.0141424788,
-0.0248140823,
0.044198744,
0.0332384706,
0.0275561158,
0.0232092794,
0.0728514567,
-0.0257540811,
0.0085616885,
-0.0340317786,
-0.0005430437,
-0.0007989593,
-0.0637138486,
0.0106335282,
0.0714330822,
-0.0752018541,
0.0188711677,
0.0121598486,
0.0471227504,
0.0050465721,
-0.0119978925,
0.0420926921,
0.0372688398,
-0.0366589949,
0.0487709194,
-0.0149361296,
0.0657953396,
0.0149107361,
-0.0035623179,
-0.0274656322,
0.041856505,
-0.044469934,
-0.0186665207,
-0.0363486744,
-0.0095187081,
-0.0778023228,
-0.0119906999,
0.0042065564,
0.0211242642,
-0.021407092,
0.0153511781,
0.0124457926,
0.0659356639,
-0.0313517116,
-0.0394733585,
-0.0734768957,
0.008390029,
-0.0909572393,
0.0389614254,
0.0237962827,
-0.0444720425,
0.0073284572,
0.0227952804,
0.0182991214,
0.0068937987,
-0.0441821627,
0.0559084192,
0.0186048951,
0.0079790726,
-0.0664440989,
-0.0643655509,
-0.0072455318,
-0.0543368421,
-0.059642192,
-0.0024779323,
0.0140431523,
-0.0084420107,
-0.0122245243,
-0.0210794769,
0.0127701322,
0.0164150428,
0.0091432584,
0.0690549463,
-0.0255912971,
0.022507729,
0.0331371762,
0.0191580728,
0.0052464069,
0.0200996995,
0.0067601791,
0.0460560508,
0.0357505344,
-0.0526559912,
0.0149795851,
-0.0366235077,
-0.0092846826,
-0.0422827378,
0.0076243067,
0.0390345082,
-0.0568307415,
0.0600366667,
0.0002933299,
0.0024674677,
-0.0114344535,
0.0518390536,
0.0471647754,
0.0568110868,
0.0322303176,
0.0051148273,
0.0707364231,
0.0444266535,
-0.0347026251,
0.0242667329,
-0.0116270361,
0.0337496437,
-0.0440574437,
0.014775984,
0.0207494814,
0.0097287269,
-0.0323421955,
-0.0770985261,
-0.0044826572,
0.0059244037,
0.0322520584,
0.0043638498,
0.0143741742,
-0.0021983583,
-0.0486878455,
0.0108698579,
0.031168865,
-0.0443169065,
0.0287576467,
-0.0421167575,
0.0415570661,
0.1331694871,
0.0315312296,
-0.0138548687,
0.0082980851,
-0.0153090721,
0.0112225907,
0.0348824933,
0.0283879731,
-0.0081330976,
-0.0200282019,
-0.0391004682,
-0.0495731384,
-0.0567586832,
0.0191867873,
0.0256631337,
0.0067617567,
0.0044179871,
0.0309490748,
0.0014857608,
-0.0414450355,
0.0231376886,
0.0007556496,
-0.0468228199,
-0.0040492811,
-0.0017705967,
0.0087318439,
0.0591408312,
0.0146899074,
0.0363157615,
0.0080160545,
0.0115324948,
-0.0159959979,
0.0388897322,
-0.0382090099,
-0.0251879506,
0.0133458367,
-0.0541425422,
-0.0106188711,
-0.0357149318,
-0.0288959108,
-0.0350987054,
-0.0054437565,
-0.0517453477,
-0.0122463889,
-0.0489694253,
-0.0017437211,
-0.0035135108,
-0.0378502868,
-0.0365516171,
0.0796648636,
0.0275103375,
-0.0091292737,
0.0348419324,
0.0092441309,
0.0042095063,
-0.042344138,
0.0410552993,
-0.0380189046,
0.00488682,
0.0004793574,
0.0331716947,
0.0326843075,
-0.0462914743,
0.0022146376,
-0.0573588349,
-0.036431618,
-0.0334979966,
-0.0134925367,
0.057910081,
-0.0272301491,
-0.0070709442,
-0.0348334759,
-0.0378999934,
-0.0094241751,
0.0112140775,
-0.0002270233,
0.0653060898,
0.0211368185,
-0.0366813056,
-0.0010356115,
0.0111444714,
-0.0066911406,
0.0370281599,
0.0694554076,
-0.0130847553,
-0.1055035889,
0.0287494268,
-0.0132368272,
-0.0550311618,
0.0019866943,
-0.0170184504,
0.0548755489,
0.0376812294,
-0.0074795405,
0.0158168655,
0.0233107954,
0.0854841843,
0.0464417562,
0.0118253743,
-0.0262386557,
-0.0090249656,
-0.0496339425,
0.0057002688,
-0.0158252586,
-0.0436024815,
0.01312197,
0.0085229194,
0.0303165875,
0.0279892124,
-0.0696765855,
0.0405607298,
-0.0115693314,
-0.0304405093,
-0.0612343587,
-0.0654198453,
-0.0025308721,
0.1206858009,
0.0042145117,
-0.042281352,
0.082484208,
-0.0326768421,
0.0146832485,
-0.0440866463,
-0.0228570625,
-0.036736995,
0.0693207011,
-0.0435773134,
0.0240917541,
0.0256123934,
-0.0209897552,
-0.0050569596,
-0.0740553215,
0.02953084,
-0.0008784957,
-0.0131037254,
-0.0636131242,
-0.0293546598,
0.0381798595,
-0.0070914999,
-0.0298183933,
-0.0917036161,
-0.0482648313,
-0.0022637083,
0.0217127372,
-0.0024463362,
0.0164697859,
0.0083167749,
0.0394964367,
0.017498713,
0.0260877255,
-0.0069551961,
-0.022311829,
0.0005840746,
0.0296269748,
0.0826308057,
0.0170640331,
0.0037336142,
0.0160975307,
0.014497418,
-0.0119765904,
-0.003508697,
-0.0336277001,
0.0151260123,
-0.007818643,
-0.0395792313,
-0.001457739,
0.0587197803,
0.0603003986,
-0.0601293482,
0.0151752597,
0.1259327978,
0.0355705395,
0.0034164686,
0.0176034328,
-0.022248609,
-0.0052196877,
-0.003803286,
0.0270053409,
-0.0632081777,
-0.027448006,
-0.0164126474,
0.0100191403,
-0.0125498818,
0.0289974902,
-0.0202649478,
-0.0989743024,
0.0515939146,
0.002981218,
0.007037553,
-0.0257708691,
-0.0441368334,
-0.0369998626,
0.0234873295,
0.0109934006,
0.0127479555,
0.0124181835,
0.0283080749,
0.0388455912,
-0.0486782156,
-0.0419620052,
0.041483447,
-0.0246253964,
0.0457974486,
0.0533010848,
0.027751416,
0.0096741877,
-0.058418557,
0.0007277929,
-0.0171106998,
0.0751522779,
0.0009008401,
0.0199084692,
0.0170211103,
-0.0090098875,
-0.0650074631,
0.0504937284,
-0.0469453633,
-0.0373023413,
0.0401828326,
0.0636315644,
-0.0532504357,
0.0105509162,
0.006545356,
0.0464042909,
0.0267644338,
0.0743753985,
0.0588782914,
-0.0287437364,
-0.0272211991,
-0.0280393064,
-0.0086654564,
-0.0098393522,
-0.0552674681,
0.0054502408,
0.0110442443,
0.0005617423,
-0.0247539133,
-0.0483601205,
0.043221198,
0.035627991,
0.0324035324,
-0.0345384888,
0.0191277154,
0.0018598458,
0.0083652446,
0.0656009167,
0.0072745322,
0.0149341533,
0.0007171267,
-0.0096504698,
0.0121039571,
-0.0661311671,
0.0079961913,
-0.0284505896,
0.0498382375,
-0.029684471,
-0.0062575545,
0.0170311183,
0.0250188895,
0.0371768922,
-0.0203270093,
-0.0466943681,
0.0260850675,
0.0079405354,
-0.0789257437,
-0.0069413022,
0.0196037088,
0.0199188292,
0.0162235629,
0.0175091531,
-0.0128901266,
-0.0082732243,
-0.0411893949,
0.032647144,
-0.0225175731,
-0.0622736737,
0.0431692339,
-0.0052164556,
0.0446673036,
-0.0504293665,
-0.0174618233,
-0.0234141611,
0.0026281751,
-0.0502672829,
-0.0473534018,
-0.0186689682,
0.0171050858,
0.0222622212,
-0.0147534283,
0.0035480682,
-0.01801355,
-0.0755992979,
0.0135209644,
-0.0096597802,
0.02658353,
0.0267273169,
-0.0053687668,
-0.0359014645,
0.0175068341,
-0.0395695381,
0.0162698645,
-0.04803719,
0.0478144586,
0.0214550924,
0.0976440609,
0.0110893548,
-0.0244049281,
-0.0138372537,
0.0152524272,
-0.0337202139,
-0.0319129564,
0.0079733403,
0.0349979512,
0.013362105,
-0.0094534494,
0.0190507174,
0.0058142296,
-0.0105197523,
0.0145460153,
0.0758077502,
0.0512568727,
-0.052907709,
0.0218333155,
0.0205183644,
-0.04039561,
-0.0321108066,
0.0192890167,
-0.0276107863,
-0.0065855714,
0.0086825155,
-0.0231820568,
-0.0025888761,
-0.0211103894,
-0.0277859904,
0.024174178,
-0.0158059448,
-0.0119684599,
-0.0686331764,
-0.0265208352,
-0.0447876155,
0.0442264602,
-0.0212686062,
-0.0262628514,
0.0513863303,
0.0304369535,
-0.0115156295,
-0.0179394651,
-0.03136646,
0.0545392744,
-0.0387758687,
0.040025901,
-0.0454852693,
-6.844088106e-33,
-0.0307865217,
-0.0952655599,
0.0317537412,
-0.0334576219,
-0.0077550579,
-0.001805371,
-0.0610318854,
-0.0001981416,
0.022444576,
0.0513987131,
0.0189651344,
-0.0119917104,
0.005708395,
0.0155559955,
-0.0199887939,
-0.0551782921,
0.0195825025,
0.0329229981,
-0.0309659634,
0.0326910652,
0.0233644117,
-0.0099715926,
0.0050518918,
-0.0631210208,
0.0856429189,
0.0046581039,
-0.0518273376,
0.0090874527,
-0.031779591,
0.039049644,
-0.0345219001,
0.0479073785,
0.0106632067,
-0.0548310392,
0.0131471297,
0.0842536315,
-0.0269397832,
-0.0293660145,
0.0672927946,
0.0090439953,
-0.0698363632,
-0.0485797934,
-0.0149284359,
-0.0160544161,
-0.0215815883,
0.0289133601,
0.0367468819,
-0.0153431045,
-0.0024532622,
0.0130609861,
-0.0283814315,
0.0084938258,
-0.0692548156,
-0.0313708894,
-0.0130017791,
0.0521168672,
-0.0213581659,
-0.0074719493,
-0.0288992599,
0.0231716316,
0.0360531099,
-0.0154205523,
0.0578367934,
-0.0272907559,
-0.0117039932,
0.0527511165,
-0.0051376205,
-0.0070472015,
-0.0976736993,
0.0094235577,
-0.0557935052,
0.0370558873,
0.08109539,
0.0267757196,
-0.0268404093,
0.0404988006,
-0.0558594428,
0.0328144766,
-0.0425870679,
0.021756703,
0.0311062224,
0.0020912758,
-0.0424484983,
-0.0253169592,
-0.052047506,
-0.0134578235,
-0.0173871294,
-0.038957756,
0.0195606016,
-0.0213971995,
-0.0701034293,
-0.0076425108,
-0.0525948815,
-0.0364048555,
-0.0005053274,
-0.0026960038,
-0.0065258672,
-0.0104114339,
0.0055062007,
0.0203031823,
0.0179693513,
0.0153090805,
0.0187411476,
0.04135748,
0.0236174148,
-0.0017891716,
0.0012229262,
0.0378477909,
0.0018545861,
0.0214495212,
-0.0522932187,
-0.0151129002,
-0.0399198271,
-0.0443532839,
0.0229253769,
0.026941834,
-0.0618842766,
0.0336980782,
0.0049027232,
-0.0239166655,
0.0131715247,
0.009297383,
-0.010656747,
0.0314064063,
-0.0016859577,
0.0128702335,
-0.0134668462,
0.0265795738,
0.0583022125,
-0.0104500912,
-0.0071148826,
0.0187375061,
2.969e-7,
0.0234177262,
0.0099365944,
0.0427390747,
-0.0226239972,
0.0124738775,
0.0440845713,
0.011519894,
-0.0076679266,
0.0032190853,
-0.036713928,
0.0476841219,
0.0226002913,
0.0116104446,
-0.0063709724,
-0.0395482406,
0.0074161598,
-0.0377732478,
-0.0115456898,
-0.0640488118,
0.017754076,
0.1177726611,
-0.0112973554,
-0.0008861556,
0.0104893018,
-0.0060495986,
-0.0465847626,
-0.0054314071,
-0.060395088,
0.0014100047,
-0.0082498314,
0.0585412793,
-0.0016686111,
0.0285551865,
-0.0177114122,
-0.0118535832,
-0.0176981557,
-0.0210828483,
0.0755200237,
0.0064900494,
-0.0449651219,
-0.0242772251,
-0.0265205558,
0.0195843726,
-0.0496673174,
0.0747611597,
-0.0651897192,
-0.0350341275,
-0.0070858193,
-0.0288383085,
-0.0276339781,
-0.0009810057,
-0.0137271779,
-0.0037672927,
-0.0013014221,
0.0118004307,
-0.016302485,
0.0022904517,
-0.0866243541,
-0.0295720827,
0.0096680801,
-0.0064206212,
0.0228577554,
-0.0292444229,
0.019270692,
0.0664110035,
-0.067410402,
-0.0034201867,
2.215925778e-34,
0.007700609,
0.0367294922,
0.0244653504,
-0.0068946453,
0.0438478217,
0.047501158,
0.0022967081,
-0.0181060396,
0.082322605,
-0.0277097467,
-0.017469909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14089v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14089v2 | MedAlign: A Clinician-Generated Dataset for Instruction Following with Electronic Medical Records | 2023-08-27T12:24:39 | 2023-12-24T09:12:06 | Scott L. Fleming, Alejandro Lozano, William J. Haberkorn, Jenelle A. Jindal, Eduardo P. Reis, Rahul Thapa, Louis Blankemeier, Julian Z. Genkins, Ethan Steinberg, Ashwin Nayak, Birju S. Patel, Chia-Chun Chiang, Alison Callahan, Zepeng Huo, Sergios Gatidis, Scott J. Adams, Oluseyi Fayanju, Shreya J. Shah, Thomas Savage, Ethan Goh, Akshay S. Chaudhari, Nima Aghaeepour, Christopher Sharp, Michael A. Pfeffer, Percy Liang, Jonathan H. Chen, Keith E. Morse, Emma P. Brunskill, Jason A. Fries, Nigam H. Shah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The ability of large language models (LLMs) to follow natural language
instructions with human-level fluency suggests many opportunities in healthcare
to reduce administrative burden and improve quality of care. However,
evaluating LLMs on realistic text generation tasks for healthcare remains
challenging. Existing question answering datasets for electronic health record
(EHR) data fail to capture the complexity of information needs and
documentation burdens experienced by clinicians. To address these challenges,
we introduce MedAlign, a benchmark dataset of 983 natural language instructions
for EHR data. MedAlign is curated by 15 clinicians (7 specialities), includes
clinician-written reference responses for 303 instructions, and provides 276
longitudinal EHRs for grounding instruction-response pairs. We used MedAlign to
evaluate 6 general domain LLMs, having clinicians rank the accuracy and quality
of each LLM response. We found high error rates, ranging from 35% (GPT-4) to
68% (MPT-7B-Instruct), and an 8.3% drop in accuracy moving from 32k to 2k
context lengths for GPT-4. Finally, we report correlations between clinician
rankings and automated natural language generation metrics as a way to rank
LLMs without human review. We make MedAlign available under a research data use
agreement to enable LLM evaluations on tasks aligned with clinician needs and
preferences. | [
0.0593034104,
0.0531489626,
0.0081399493,
-0.0364280306,
-0.0255832225,
0.0298625529,
0.000310736,
-0.001374463,
0.0285382736,
-0.0236174725,
0.0057128188,
-0.070277229,
0.0175478067,
0.0090313032,
0.0232227389,
-0.0503732711,
-0.0050438917,
0.0239209775,
0.0079205353,
0.0100071672,
-0.0254610106,
0.0204976406,
-0.0520972498,
0.0556358211,
0.0376403853,
0.010276977,
-0.000643825,
0.0194725469,
0.0178097636,
-0.0932459682,
0.0131082973,
0.0424432531,
-0.021433996,
-0.0273614954,
0.000002016,
-0.0573319122,
0.0119585805,
0.0322838277,
-0.0549927503,
-0.0136644449,
0.0144370673,
-0.0599828325,
0.0013733635,
0.0245740898,
-0.0284024589,
-0.0244031362,
0.0132553708,
0.0189671125,
0.0576621778,
0.0635000989,
-0.006288114,
0.0254461505,
0.0129361609,
-0.014540907,
0.0392578468,
-0.0410931334,
0.017046541,
0.02818124,
0.0490406081,
0.0018637371,
0.0204155874,
0.0392722301,
-0.0056367479,
0.033436317,
-0.0009987134,
0.0423001386,
-0.0186775047,
0.0116450666,
0.0068829479,
0.084481217,
0.054105401,
0.0374236219,
0.0396169201,
0.0051987516,
-0.0141004687,
-0.0017667197,
-0.0467118286,
0.0297516491,
-0.0382213853,
-0.0272199456,
-0.0079237241,
-0.0171671398,
0.0210367385,
0.0071422472,
-0.0061306371,
-0.0073819784,
0.0232006237,
-0.0246895179,
0.0239387564,
-0.0073225852,
-0.0127297994,
-0.0528509803,
0.0595864467,
0.0618015453,
-0.0666364878,
0.0168411396,
-0.0429079346,
-0.0143774077,
0.0905739963,
-0.0173928086,
0.0441265441,
0.0295029674,
0.0222678054,
0.0177930556,
0.0048804986,
0.0408354253,
-0.0282692015,
0.0252770241,
-0.050745897,
0.021445835,
-0.0430948026,
-0.0315710083,
-0.0167803951,
0.0155250579,
-0.0248632263,
-0.0096878568,
-0.090113692,
-0.0226963311,
0.0133008407,
0.0169631019,
0.0276582558,
0.0539182387,
-0.0172408149,
-0.0028104954,
-0.0470337272,
-0.0035148638,
-0.0240728706,
0.0178722255,
0.0092987111,
-0.0414174236,
0.0181729887,
0.0042411168,
0.01714384,
0.0044133952,
0.0270476285,
0.0491049998,
0.0091569982,
-0.0216890574,
-0.0107580386,
-0.0456462912,
-0.020767441,
-0.0324302427,
0.0013274491,
-0.0487712361,
0.0506170876,
0.0402242541,
-0.0144713866,
-0.0441761985,
0.0182050299,
0.0573072769,
-0.047917679,
0.0504442044,
-0.045951508,
0.0346763209,
0.0332131609,
0.0169532914,
0.0119625106,
-0.0116842473,
0.0261066444,
-0.0382899866,
-0.0090119885,
-0.0146050612,
0.0184338372,
-0.0023284799,
0.0210111514,
-0.032338541,
0.0198426265,
0.0412864983,
-0.0223505385,
0.0900917202,
-0.0114640007,
0.0921269283,
0.0025923529,
-0.0077439072,
0.0136790155,
0.0633217096,
0.0125990929,
-0.0192703754,
0.0515775457,
-0.0063641663,
-0.0003179539,
-0.0154127739,
-0.0228628088,
0.0183690526,
0.0144856414,
0.0187190138,
0.0072218054,
-0.0127660763,
-0.0503555015,
-0.0386324413,
-0.019762354,
-0.0221353732,
-0.0189580005,
-0.0057859113,
0.0153692663,
-0.0001294791,
-0.06406039,
0.073774457,
0.0162778646,
-0.0378153957,
0.0009191855,
-0.0385428816,
-0.0003082011,
0.1199525297,
0.0588054471,
-0.0100564826,
-0.042094864,
-0.0236356091,
0.0407276936,
0.0204784553,
0.0161389746,
-0.016187517,
0.0195019953,
-0.0625838861,
-0.0152928764,
0.0351204313,
0.0015071603,
-0.0148054538,
0.0116062434,
0.007486518,
0.022613788,
-0.0292861518,
-0.0530679524,
0.0608688295,
-0.0783255175,
-0.0479482822,
0.0115928464,
-0.0106200501,
0.0205889568,
0.0442488492,
0.0007186368,
0.0607666411,
0.0355555192,
-0.0221478101,
-0.0074846339,
-0.0129813971,
-0.0440891683,
-0.0239637736,
0.0078793596,
-0.0356704444,
0.0044281352,
-0.0242540073,
-0.0277985297,
-0.0472075529,
-0.0535174683,
-0.0713048428,
0.0038774237,
-0.0126076415,
0.0112277865,
0.0898812786,
-0.0284688417,
-0.0508336239,
0.0153712258,
-0.0373523906,
0.0380814821,
0.0712038279,
-0.0136016542,
0.0050986726,
-0.0401513875,
0.0081444997,
-0.0014419489,
-0.0112489546,
0.0181325004,
-0.0038650408,
0.0604245737,
-0.03566055,
-0.0295203235,
-0.1185253486,
0.0041175019,
-0.003458163,
0.0167633835,
0.0563597977,
0.0226685945,
0.0006520128,
-0.0102968207,
-0.056340646,
-0.0449176431,
0.0517462231,
0.021818921,
0.0321745314,
0.0382527113,
-0.0110513708,
-0.0341671295,
-0.0100978976,
-0.0329695567,
-0.0015853044,
0.0311264526,
0.006363031,
-0.0455653705,
-0.0081370249,
-0.0416817404,
-0.0376356021,
0.0087735374,
-0.017454695,
0.0200985316,
0.0075038834,
0.0208689459,
0.026991412,
0.0008423752,
0.0044827783,
0.0134824496,
-0.0161305424,
-0.0535227247,
0.0069441875,
-0.0259358361,
-0.0206576101,
0.0089178076,
-0.070083715,
0.0181653947,
0.0611576438,
0.035594333,
0.017979363,
-0.0324941948,
-0.0191085413,
-0.0301744957,
0.0409455486,
-0.0676245317,
0.0196717232,
-0.0463117175,
0.0501263104,
0.0080750948,
-0.0275860913,
0.080637455,
-0.0164070446,
0.0210054778,
-0.0748311728,
-0.0045123803,
-0.051888302,
0.0096582351,
0.0003682406,
0.0264424719,
0.003922469,
-0.0379425585,
-0.0067258338,
0.0137813548,
-0.010819531,
-0.0677290186,
0.042533379,
-0.0384123176,
0.0406925865,
-0.0001044898,
-0.0267964881,
-0.0589833967,
-0.0302823652,
-0.007956625,
-0.0087762494,
0.0211344715,
-0.0024169094,
-0.0386033878,
0.0124835037,
0.013333898,
0.0739882439,
0.0222770143,
-0.0286447667,
-0.0025571811,
0.0353587754,
0.0431595966,
0.0151305683,
-0.0043431083,
-0.0227777045,
0.0267860498,
0.0446084999,
0.0339327455,
0.032641653,
0.0140599273,
-0.0057692258,
-0.0040122992,
-0.0348435454,
0.0029007019,
0.0602301434,
0.047639709,
-0.0519406237,
-0.00679219,
0.1095498577,
0.044950664,
-0.0410402231,
0.025839569,
0.0003375123,
0.0020634925,
-0.0003694829,
0.0239585452,
-0.0576476119,
-0.0314599164,
-0.0150992321,
0.0767222643,
-0.0185470618,
-0.0430238321,
0.0068751262,
-0.0601336434,
0.0153200692,
0.0116694365,
-0.0363852493,
-0.0365386307,
-0.0300328098,
-0.0197032336,
0.0160420071,
0.0050712121,
0.0093041705,
-0.0372200087,
0.0038896343,
0.0103268502,
-0.0637506545,
-0.0925375149,
0.0380299054,
-0.0381452329,
0.0788463727,
0.0768498033,
0.0299592949,
-0.0040845522,
-0.0254014917,
-0.0044854977,
-0.0180589985,
0.0086899726,
-0.0016193454,
0.079426378,
0.0322154127,
0.0009705118,
-0.0539303608,
0.0526724868,
-0.0686139092,
-0.0053866454,
0.0190857369,
0.0466056205,
-0.0382401198,
0.0080801118,
-0.0426534824,
0.0484000631,
0.0250531342,
0.047161933,
0.0116058886,
-0.0228210352,
-0.0188678093,
0.0024480163,
0.0502563454,
-0.0305361189,
-0.0079498058,
0.0457596108,
-0.0289598312,
0.0161576401,
-0.0827639252,
-0.0408358797,
0.0682739094,
-0.0008365224,
0.0184763577,
0.0097237192,
0.0250406843,
-0.0125193391,
-0.04735801,
0.0366184935,
0.0177692361,
0.017336458,
-0.0816121921,
-0.0678398088,
0.0446411483,
0.006431805,
-0.0093824035,
0.0363160297,
-0.0065288362,
-0.0107639423,
-0.0048027826,
0.0738915429,
0.022696903,
0.0038089701,
0.0232694577,
-0.0052792053,
-0.0117501849,
0.0515345484,
-0.0730282888,
-0.0253460258,
-0.0196659993,
0.0249614399,
-0.0277034193,
0.0111804781,
-0.017427776,
0.0181020815,
-0.0093611842,
0.0662643611,
-0.0113873174,
-0.0389164239,
0.0401899554,
0.0320264064,
-0.0187796447,
-0.0347702242,
-0.0065489099,
-0.0086647961,
0.0250187609,
-0.0301264562,
0.0069870348,
-0.0417012163,
0.0038629055,
0.0193995629,
-0.0293062069,
-0.0151326712,
-0.0015006276,
-0.0578666776,
-0.0258008316,
-0.0381173715,
0.020056542,
-0.0296655074,
0.0328528993,
0.0258795749,
-0.0467185937,
-0.0208205804,
0.0280477796,
0.0065950258,
0.0416816063,
0.0042388504,
0.0914777666,
-0.0293788631,
0.0374056175,
-0.0035213793,
0.044505354,
-0.0242713429,
-0.0621957444,
-0.0260314159,
0.0037555757,
0.04019228,
0.0104567036,
0.0307637379,
-0.0274224672,
0.0075370553,
-0.0412493721,
0.0326078869,
-0.0071330215,
0.0121197039,
0.0604485087,
0.0142881311,
0.0030382993,
-0.0207321104,
0.0949153453,
0.0381981656,
0.0376034677,
-0.0080463914,
-0.0348477103,
-0.0547581688,
-0.0241064392,
0.0129636573,
-0.0177549981,
-0.0626365617,
-0.0034971042,
-0.0606820807,
-0.0432868078,
0.0069524446,
-0.0022313637,
-0.0202551801,
-0.0397149101,
0.0737630129,
0.0218368564,
-0.0012828048,
-0.031736888,
-0.0324661881,
0.0454812497,
-0.0575921722,
-0.0155302659,
-0.0243086647,
-5.730963281e-33,
-0.0274237674,
-0.0590359829,
0.0460291654,
-0.0354317464,
0.0178214107,
0.0200666878,
-0.0504147224,
0.0019034155,
0.0135180941,
0.0060724951,
-0.0119016152,
-0.0062253317,
0.0127036674,
0.0683833733,
0.0109029384,
-0.0545135885,
0.0276684463,
0.002362788,
-0.0236388091,
0.0502817519,
-0.031769231,
0.0418209843,
0.0128582288,
-0.0811003819,
0.0186474063,
-0.0047161607,
0.0233199392,
-0.0171641763,
-0.0166155733,
0.0673391521,
-0.0382819287,
0.0168582071,
0.0413048007,
-0.0015226165,
-0.0117916605,
0.021582786,
-0.0773033202,
-0.0126587991,
0.0132232243,
-0.0354779512,
-0.0568244345,
-0.039438691,
0.0481548198,
-0.0199040119,
-0.0376929455,
0.0162653849,
0.0163358953,
-0.0209138021,
-0.0204950459,
-0.0405778028,
-0.0275911782,
0.0444507599,
-0.0129579259,
-0.0415849574,
-0.0545591153,
0.0444909111,
-0.0587687008,
0.0137889832,
-0.047914058,
-0.0042561386,
0.026824398,
0.0093997251,
0.0151640456,
-0.0399951972,
-0.0170889348,
0.0388906635,
0.0142879002,
-0.0046606958,
-0.0432496518,
0.0247786045,
-0.0667127669,
0.0311515946,
0.0401555337,
0.0062702531,
0.0134738516,
-0.0043717283,
-0.0759247243,
0.0762314424,
-0.0736646131,
0.0455656759,
0.0412610956,
-0.0495276526,
-0.067818366,
-0.0190141033,
-0.0282561202,
0.0236082636,
-0.0182231106,
-0.0335989334,
0.0711282194,
0.014290045,
-0.0148241082,
-0.026662359,
-0.0014710039,
-0.0063270587,
-0.0102023603,
-0.0194737408,
0.0340811685,
0.0044638272,
-0.0413812436,
-0.0093383556,
-0.0716072991,
-0.00090919,
0.0268207639,
-0.0015027795,
0.0410214663,
0.027785439,
-0.0082975281,
-0.0212219786,
-0.06339816,
0.0026142288,
0.0167497657,
0.0256406218,
-0.0387547426,
-0.0096944524,
0.0417574234,
0.0180288069,
-0.0140181258,
0.0847153291,
-0.0306586064,
-0.0313828066,
-0.0401271395,
-0.0591237731,
0.0304536056,
0.0308414064,
-0.0458465442,
0.0222095065,
-0.0532918684,
0.0360792018,
0.0226478446,
-0.0221109819,
0.0045144046,
0.0073659895,
2.7e-7,
0.091543518,
0.0508305319,
0.0280866846,
0.0022829501,
0.0115235224,
-0.0102111502,
-0.0030937956,
-0.0049740449,
0.0066716215,
-0.0199122261,
0.0420240052,
-0.0192257222,
0.0326728337,
0.0229389388,
-0.0512103848,
-0.0067349053,
-0.0687219426,
-0.012075047,
-0.0482167266,
-0.0362680741,
0.0729906857,
0.0447513573,
-0.0779859424,
-0.0200944338,
-0.0027618178,
-0.0011160824,
0.0572043173,
-0.0214155484,
-0.0069576423,
0.0173624791,
0.0488302968,
-0.0177805591,
0.0178196337,
0.0426067486,
-0.0166538917,
-0.0233781859,
0.0001599316,
0.1144126281,
-0.0302656349,
-0.0049436693,
0.0101212114,
-0.0305863079,
0.0226129871,
-0.0272783991,
0.0424894169,
-0.0712597221,
-0.0325817429,
0.0335347317,
-0.028861329,
-0.0108268019,
0.0528782569,
-0.0223421808,
-0.0231689252,
0.034711197,
0.0301972944,
0.0011951689,
-0.01358137,
-0.0504123643,
-0.0055860654,
0.0411639921,
-0.0294883158,
-0.0075656325,
0.020020755,
0.0006796229,
-0.0289369561,
-0.0666499957,
0.0005619798,
2.45974351e-34,
0.0189016368,
-0.0012632682,
0.0248848572,
0.030092027,
0.0442803837,
0.0007347902,
0.0150524471,
0.0305698346,
0.0306424964,
-0.0673595592,
-0.0187763702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14077v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14077v1 | An Analysis of On-the-fly Determinization of Finite-state Automata | 2023-08-27T11:51:27 | 2023-08-27T11:51:27 | Ivan Baburin, Ryan Cotterell | cs.FL | cs.FL, cs.CL | In this paper we establish an abstraction of on-the-fly determinization of
finite-state automata using transition monoids and demonstrate how it can be
applied to bound the asymptotics. We present algebraic and combinatorial
properties that are sufficient for a polynomial state complexity of the
deterministic automaton constructed on-the-fly. A special case of our findings
is that automata with many non-deterministic transitions almost always admit a
determinization of polynomial complexity. Furthermore, we extend our ideas to
weighted finite-state automata. | [
-0.0193490703,
0.0620019771,
-0.009833714,
0.0031994344,
-0.0584659539,
-0.0372303911,
-0.0057820934,
-0.0347611196,
-0.000557652,
-0.0053844126,
0.0723552853,
0.0329736546,
-0.0088037373,
0.0590872355,
0.0133331614,
-0.0399540365,
0.0164619181,
-0.0581597351,
-0.0513361394,
-0.0078472961,
-0.051163476,
-0.0270153712,
-0.0808693171,
-0.0154008958,
0.0007513181,
-0.0685407072,
-0.0312289447,
-0.0458860621,
-0.0225728247,
-0.0142589724,
-0.0596632808,
0.0225475561,
-0.0434983969,
-0.0158097856,
0.0000017604,
-0.0260566417,
-0.0102839097,
0.0019283157,
-0.0405152403,
0.0428162292,
-0.0429417863,
0.037058752,
-0.0008473856,
0.055067759,
0.0152021302,
-0.0081511596,
0.0499080494,
-0.0140461689,
-0.0002860556,
-0.0027598839,
-0.0026728569,
0.0223595221,
0.0309000853,
0.0069221943,
-0.0722568557,
-0.0536893718,
0.0431692488,
-0.0649961159,
0.018431332,
-0.0682563186,
-0.0305192303,
-0.039432019,
-0.0114271836,
-0.0284295194,
-0.0167443063,
0.0053234631,
0.0471346639,
0.0043329983,
-0.0403051265,
-0.0013427591,
-0.0504403636,
0.0043192045,
0.0082635777,
0.0029287538,
-0.0064767725,
-0.015084465,
0.0476229377,
0.020158885,
-0.027388595,
0.0170725603,
0.0267137997,
0.0277158972,
-0.0090982206,
-0.0283038598,
-0.0251918677,
0.0531262495,
0.0323204808,
0.0104071153,
-0.0079016341,
-0.0332414396,
0.0602780692,
-0.0703587756,
0.0165805873,
0.0417457968,
0.0007412829,
-0.0103692506,
-0.0143032735,
-0.0148545094,
-0.0179583933,
-0.0246756393,
0.0640887469,
-0.0020034295,
0.0275835805,
-0.0019710711,
0.0165521353,
0.0711294934,
0.0227724779,
-0.0792997554,
-0.0052072592,
0.0401417948,
0.0100802835,
0.0157427788,
-0.0979874805,
0.0290251318,
0.0151271028,
0.0134730684,
-0.0372369848,
0.0365987569,
-0.0211865548,
0.0111563904,
-0.0718829036,
-0.0187617578,
-0.0082970886,
0.01836868,
0.0032566916,
0.0299091041,
-0.0047983779,
-0.0168831833,
-0.02677566,
-0.0242137145,
0.0081339497,
-0.0052324375,
0.0585807264,
0.0206688922,
-0.0797529072,
0.0453538634,
-0.0386128724,
-0.0439036675,
0.0334851444,
0.0055939099,
0.0408248268,
0.0170367323,
0.0038562922,
0.0211281423,
-0.0126207974,
0.0097469687,
0.0314807743,
-0.0115842596,
-0.0063773273,
-0.0310618542,
0.0670632869,
0.0002139489,
-0.0005640082,
0.0364442468,
-0.0245366786,
-0.0034656089,
0.0079596471,
0.01848788,
0.0221447349,
0.0353373624,
0.0324316844,
-0.012690302,
0.0547935963,
0.0301058162,
-0.0479870662,
0.0261563715,
-0.0036570802,
-0.0511857904,
0.0060948106,
-0.0308160968,
-0.001527965,
0.0898585841,
-0.0223173853,
-0.0284061693,
-0.0314916484,
-0.0084797116,
-0.0099349469,
0.0565175973,
0.0243783463,
0.0113819772,
0.062121056,
0.0742713138,
0.0132491095,
-0.0118490374,
-0.0176267028,
-0.0083465427,
0.0409664959,
0.0335196629,
-0.0281936098,
-0.023726197,
-0.0002238183,
-0.0369859412,
0.0435460471,
-0.0597183779,
0.0102637373,
-0.0309711099,
-0.0241651125,
0.0065005682,
-0.0670155659,
0.0004611666,
-0.0076797707,
-0.0278034303,
-0.0083361696,
0.0478370897,
0.0176188555,
-0.0403019413,
-0.0109277591,
0.0263675936,
0.0199888777,
0.0173061565,
0.0158847291,
-0.0467488281,
0.0531348325,
0.0332593396,
0.0124925841,
0.0568742827,
0.0165972523,
0.0078715635,
-0.0114510925,
-0.0145252487,
-0.0027344627,
0.0263538565,
-0.0591319576,
-0.0086818477,
0.0029574665,
-0.0728843883,
0.0196613185,
0.0233059842,
0.0238284767,
-0.0119334161,
-0.0407874361,
0.0531275161,
-0.0173382256,
0.0183351487,
0.0083538257,
-0.0403893888,
0.0262724552,
0.0416935422,
0.0310050957,
0.013236451,
0.0014904011,
0.0533287153,
-0.0522181019,
-0.0123924054,
0.0387541689,
0.0006359006,
-0.0205216371,
0.0633459836,
0.012970902,
0.0362793319,
0.0315530337,
0.0370570868,
-0.0057476438,
-0.0237064566,
0.0288695227,
-0.0283375587,
-0.0196833927,
0.0552383773,
0.0339224413,
-0.0233682021,
-0.0365784802,
-0.0471023284,
-0.0089084618,
0.0103069749,
-0.053597115,
0.0359948687,
-0.0067225504,
-0.0140950428,
0.0017187562,
0.0031426321,
0.0635525882,
-0.0513172336,
0.0470129885,
0.0060314066,
-0.0081421072,
-0.0101390574,
0.0416515358,
0.0080358153,
0.0123514133,
0.0321802534,
0.011583766,
-0.0752640516,
-0.0218469761,
0.0111850249,
-0.0187777225,
-0.005589522,
-0.0485928357,
-0.0624962263,
-0.0323846042,
-0.026665194,
-0.0162927452,
0.0446892492,
-0.0203746613,
-0.0089364992,
0.0301983654,
0.0201483332,
0.0650513321,
0.0426692404,
0.028416587,
0.0188639425,
0.0452999957,
-0.0018289835,
0.0772231743,
0.0072293854,
0.0342275687,
-0.0150052775,
-0.0078152288,
0.0124201924,
0.0945704058,
0.0730617791,
-0.0445056781,
-0.054647781,
-0.0312165432,
-0.0797916353,
-0.0088871075,
0.054462336,
0.030676458,
-0.0666716099,
-0.0435258411,
0.0459987894,
-0.0273251701,
-0.0537462607,
-0.0106463516,
-0.0045636105,
0.0492918491,
0.006868551,
-0.0165820383,
0.0159168523,
0.0542131625,
0.0362688489,
0.0348781161,
0.0367623456,
-0.0080236504,
0.0022395512,
-0.0541809648,
-0.0347283706,
-0.0304136276,
0.0485006832,
-0.0219643153,
0.0546463057,
-0.0523132384,
-0.0416442193,
-0.0197363421,
0.0421227552,
-0.0107795754,
0.0039946605,
-0.0215574019,
-0.0419877172,
0.0364698134,
-0.0048430199,
-0.0387442559,
0.0437633395,
-0.0111354534,
0.017074259,
0.0363519304,
-0.0118863434,
-0.0140991388,
-0.0047821617,
-0.0406025425,
0.0025403737,
0.0360733606,
-0.0051107849,
0.0537681133,
0.0412789211,
-0.0348050334,
-0.0529580079,
0.0131830536,
-0.099422574,
-0.0049620531,
0.0709684193,
-0.0425529554,
0.0285021123,
-0.0299509354,
0.0269741397,
0.02678225,
0.0261828043,
0.0651468113,
0.0138381971,
-0.0291652139,
0.0153090898,
0.0445801951,
-0.0979401767,
0.0180399623,
-0.0160728488,
-0.0229045916,
-0.0007874436,
0.0001423855,
-0.005667978,
-0.0312355366,
-0.0338952169,
-0.0170410499,
0.0105356686,
-0.0295157135,
0.0116000697,
0.0494020395,
0.0212605204,
-0.0628879741,
0.0243391525,
-0.0098526301,
0.005883873,
0.0690188333,
-0.0123124616,
0.0085679246,
-0.0275931247,
0.0254065637,
-0.0272822361,
-0.0310122985,
0.0574903227,
-0.0143029522,
-0.0424056165,
0.0613252483,
0.0431375764,
-0.0012877518,
0.0096026631,
-0.0218898468,
0.020583326,
-0.0064376444,
-0.005897217,
-0.0221733171,
0.0355477296,
-0.0105041843,
0.0059473016,
0.0551792905,
0.0172240529,
-0.0365007669,
0.0006277171,
-0.0807146952,
0.0639068708,
-0.0019622438,
-0.0405340455,
-0.0107780863,
-0.0017858365,
-0.0481898598,
0.0079422621,
-0.0503220782,
-0.0085920552,
-0.0829650909,
0.0002932444,
-0.0449220203,
-0.0421115644,
0.044003576,
0.0084972475,
0.0149686122,
-0.0131617459,
-0.0008007003,
0.0573278777,
0.0181777701,
-0.0225345884,
-0.0527143888,
-0.0784906596,
0.049062293,
0.0066872044,
-0.0382069051,
0.0319770761,
0.0864987448,
-0.019249903,
-0.0134552093,
-0.0372699946,
0.0114724757,
0.0513383262,
0.0042931153,
0.0144934086,
-0.1009896249,
-0.0014912885,
-0.0109817283,
0.0189989302,
-0.0100219008,
0.0342519395,
0.0145251798,
0.0427751988,
-0.0404022746,
0.0017563406,
0.0226239022,
-0.0140531426,
0.0106128659,
-0.0155731225,
0.0073127081,
0.0106522776,
-0.0576375984,
-0.0271814447,
0.0243408233,
-0.0208699331,
0.0398681201,
0.0991948247,
-0.0049736835,
0.0192133933,
0.0184241515,
0.0124103902,
-0.0339569971,
0.0572948158,
-0.0252126474,
0.0190462265,
-0.0300972667,
-0.073898688,
0.0087421415,
-0.0134732826,
0.0661087558,
-0.0002032371,
0.0094727175,
0.0187088214,
0.0205735713,
-0.0233643278,
0.0061295293,
0.0115791662,
0.0090400046,
-0.0153948329,
0.0033150925,
-0.0227407925,
0.0020163611,
0.0555488355,
-0.0088868104,
-0.0057266392,
-0.0058961054,
-0.024594212,
0.0215799436,
0.0014094674,
0.0512424707,
0.0106154326,
-0.0384772047,
-0.0554913431,
0.0421348512,
-0.0265585408,
-0.0031079047,
-0.0198563505,
-0.0277758017,
-0.0342037044,
0.0324388817,
0.0429470837,
0.0227619391,
0.0738310367,
0.0483381301,
0.0854153112,
0.0130406916,
-0.0032269785,
-0.0518530048,
-0.0548488721,
-0.0859140903,
0.0359130166,
0.0246525966,
-0.0029713586,
-0.0390286818,
-0.0381622724,
0.0504399799,
-0.0023227241,
0.0893715322,
-0.0567403249,
0.0036367606,
-0.0291521773,
0.0289440993,
0.023565311,
-0.0136897238,
-0.0137555022,
0.0378785096,
-0.0269683339,
0.0024118291,
-5.756353592e-33,
-0.0125508057,
-0.0154314432,
-0.0215238221,
0.0025418235,
-0.0252549462,
-0.0045814821,
-0.0623564906,
0.0220173318,
0.0339386649,
-0.0014248148,
-0.014293218,
0.0126633085,
0.0121672815,
0.0214528777,
-0.0108693512,
-0.0203002561,
0.0255958661,
-0.0471134745,
-0.0583547316,
-0.016881207,
0.0109199109,
-0.0407531671,
-0.0421941355,
0.0050237677,
0.0105801336,
-0.0121737486,
-0.0401397385,
0.0161849931,
-0.0141918929,
0.0311633497,
-0.0195618048,
-0.0067004929,
0.040923018,
-0.0032477214,
-0.0076935962,
-0.0009201106,
0.0214359686,
-0.0638571754,
0.0095569948,
-0.0065101143,
-0.019305151,
-0.0184800662,
0.0292491931,
0.0267907027,
-0.0328424908,
0.0510678105,
-0.0308281351,
-0.0230115894,
-0.0350152031,
-0.0718965977,
-0.0246644281,
0.0111952852,
-0.0097753471,
0.0009573235,
-0.0119389528,
-0.0555341989,
-0.0095730238,
-0.0974029154,
0.0914864913,
0.0020891267,
0.0834984556,
0.0364025384,
-0.0661880672,
-0.0129743135,
0.0299112126,
-0.0147296647,
0.015686363,
0.0276738144,
-0.0156124141,
0.0139189344,
-0.0077936123,
-0.0123559395,
-0.0056874901,
-0.0451679491,
0.0403865464,
-0.0292132087,
-0.0412629396,
0.0086068874,
-0.0053262115,
0.033782091,
-0.0022348752,
-0.0362960547,
-0.0400214568,
-0.0394726917,
-0.0373248532,
0.0165919848,
0.0267872382,
0.0456593893,
-0.0167501606,
0.0227439385,
-0.0203069858,
-0.005588802,
0.0309436861,
0.0202414226,
-0.0698107257,
0.0307483692,
0.0322169922,
0.0376829356,
-0.0257754829,
-0.0145005807,
0.0033114108,
-0.0051229806,
-0.069174245,
-0.0167645346,
0.0063646333,
-0.0010676096,
-0.0639222488,
0.0584273227,
-0.1050608903,
0.0083602117,
-0.0092853764,
-0.0051529515,
0.0224750545,
0.089305453,
0.034062393,
-0.0349887088,
0.0062280372,
-0.0169867557,
-0.0117290244,
-0.0545510314,
-0.0062678601,
0.0674908385,
0.0053864219,
0.0650005862,
-0.0283209309,
-0.0425323248,
-0.0437368751,
0.0338855647,
0.0167532638,
-0.0481903665,
-0.0287652761,
0.014198143,
2.666e-7,
-0.0234643184,
-0.0291708503,
0.0699539781,
0.0419875719,
0.0559588112,
-0.0173371285,
-0.0000497984,
0.0272008572,
-0.0165845267,
0.0457965173,
-0.0469007008,
0.0235285554,
0.001620885,
-0.0138079775,
-0.0060265912,
0.0271652788,
0.0490346961,
0.0775317922,
-0.0018794967,
-0.0173440762,
0.0106120128,
-0.0136546521,
0.0306399632,
0.0438279174,
-0.01608021,
-0.0077846549,
-0.0212918315,
0.065842703,
0.0835520327,
0.0345341079,
0.0166777484,
0.0161106084,
-0.006355742,
-0.012034446,
0.0063646664,
0.0363520086,
-0.0397978835,
0.0663975701,
0.0010669024,
0.050303448,
0.0169240609,
-0.094870016,
-0.008388116,
0.0948913321,
0.0217946582,
0.0579273477,
-0.0155620538,
-0.0629701614,
0.0021963925,
0.0400036909,
-0.0663073659,
0.0595494471,
-0.0327472612,
0.0398852639,
-0.0144279459,
0.0327329859,
0.0433275141,
0.0117411101,
-0.0206284784,
-0.0393820517,
0.0036542998,
0.0000115232,
-0.0071400153,
0.0323621333,
-0.004661561,
0.0074640159,
0.0012881021,
1.921927983e-34,
0.0139681445,
-0.052705016,
0.0395974368,
-0.0182459205,
0.0293376297,
-0.0462770499,
-0.0566291139,
-0.0025038058,
0.0628764555,
-0.0312171672,
-0.0403888077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14034v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14034v2 | Confucius: Iterative Tool Learning from Introspection Feedback by Easy-to-Difficult Curriculum | 2023-08-27T07:53:00 | 2023-12-21T07:30:31 | Shen Gao, Zhengliang Shi, Minghang Zhu, Bowen Fang, Xin Xin, Pengjie Ren, Zhumin Chen, Jun Ma, Zhaochun Ren | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Augmenting large language models (LLMs) with external tools has emerged as a
promising approach to extending the capability of LLMs. Although some works
employ open-source LLMs for the tool learning task, most of them are trained in
a controlled environment in which LLMs only learn to execute the human-provided
tools. However, selecting proper tools from the large toolset is also a crucial
ability for the tool learning model to be applied in real-world applications.
Existing methods usually directly employ self-instruction methods to train the
model, which ignores differences in tool complexity. In this paper, we propose
the Confucius, a novel tool learning framework to train LLM to use complicated
tools in real-world scenarios, which contains two main phases: (1) We first
propose a multi-stage learning method to teach the LLM to use various tools
from an easy-to-difficult curriculum; (2) thenceforth, we propose the Iterative
Self-instruct from Introspective Feedback (ISIF) to dynamically construct the
dataset to improve the ability to use the complicated tool. Extensive
experiments conducted on both controlled and real-world settings demonstrate
the superiority of our tool learning framework in the real-world application
scenarios compared to both tuning-free (e.g. ChatGPT, Claude) and tuning-based
baselines (e.g. GPT4Tools). | [
0.0231133178,
-0.009177072,
-0.032114435,
0.0425734818,
-0.027574027,
0.0255055521,
-0.0376288593,
-0.0180365294,
0.006552191,
-0.0320123993,
-0.0679846033,
0.0279448777,
-0.0222923253,
-0.0395547524,
0.0426664762,
-0.0450612083,
0.057522431,
-0.0275364295,
-0.0874833763,
0.0063193073,
-0.0167581867,
0.0299270041,
-0.0308310464,
0.0547077134,
0.0069030072,
-0.0128784031,
-0.0286218338,
0.0048110671,
-0.0057045426,
0.0005918396,
0.0360108241,
0.0294994917,
0.0549726374,
0.057057865,
0.0000021434,
-0.0649477467,
-0.0151385712,
-0.0189151019,
-0.0102356495,
-0.0103736678,
0.0389046445,
0.0276581552,
-0.031108126,
0.0606318265,
-0.0383048281,
0.0131856818,
0.0091719506,
-0.0226718616,
0.0722481981,
0.0776292458,
0.0130783329,
0.0069819442,
-0.009694458,
0.001369541,
-0.0356976427,
0.0010041581,
-0.0208047591,
0.0391492397,
0.0021585177,
0.0068562808,
0.0003395111,
0.0150811132,
0.0464929231,
0.0113027086,
0.0273366012,
0.0340011865,
-0.0227402207,
-0.0099171437,
-0.019873308,
0.0413249992,
-0.0551383942,
-0.0539147072,
-0.00507901,
-0.0239218641,
0.0212989263,
-0.0056461948,
-0.0687504485,
-0.0121297836,
-0.0039422191,
0.0266807284,
0.0148155997,
-0.0563383996,
-0.0055029057,
0.0080846231,
0.0072429809,
0.0335427634,
-0.0093382997,
-0.0191509426,
0.0334772095,
-0.0092857555,
0.0129607897,
-0.0182120223,
-0.0342489816,
0.0641893819,
-0.0445394106,
0.0328754745,
-0.0344205312,
0.0016989654,
0.0018932329,
-0.0596693493,
0.0378365256,
0.0312326141,
-0.0372390673,
0.0186742581,
-0.0487764329,
0.0075644604,
0.0486104898,
0.0616305582,
-0.0443822034,
0.0160321277,
-0.0731375217,
-0.0200270358,
-0.0393969566,
0.0090775033,
0.0040798197,
0.0028434417,
-0.0209491346,
0.0698021054,
0.0006242325,
0.0250487886,
0.0134987375,
-0.0323744342,
-0.0557917096,
-0.0191108994,
-0.0160893667,
0.0198053159,
0.0006322608,
0.0292469617,
-0.0231480561,
-0.0364782512,
-0.0057949224,
0.0102971205,
-0.024093451,
-0.019066317,
0.0193369053,
0.1001934782,
-0.0612077713,
0.0104737664,
-0.0708464235,
-0.0047520916,
0.0687142015,
-0.0469446182,
-0.0022882239,
-0.0789737329,
-0.0218570251,
0.0314362496,
-0.0095838849,
-0.0513285585,
-0.0000106328,
-0.0175104644,
0.0142532177,
0.0509118177,
-0.0230894927,
0.0112435939,
0.0551167913,
-0.0087465541,
0.0013784273,
0.0706184283,
0.0098855058,
0.0323386639,
-0.0045300191,
-0.0307432227,
0.0159875378,
0.0717034414,
-0.0178129021,
0.0278445315,
-0.0717492029,
0.0102739548,
0.0052955495,
0.0180151127,
0.0368493162,
0.0065507763,
-0.0062202383,
0.0411930941,
0.0462232642,
0.0244048052,
0.0556529835,
0.0555741154,
0.0535511412,
0.0648657009,
0.0129179759,
0.0151300998,
-0.0576263219,
0.0179269109,
-0.0385687202,
0.0145373419,
-0.027969934,
-0.0039228387,
-0.0126198363,
-0.0518939458,
-0.0037088178,
0.0027059864,
-0.0157229956,
-0.0027180787,
0.0627845749,
0.0070648408,
-0.0462432429,
-0.0003163735,
0.0398062021,
-0.0409248285,
-0.0221732203,
-0.0728109777,
-0.0060730935,
0.0702898279,
0.0537263751,
-0.052911289,
-0.053148102,
-0.0221010596,
-0.0106422538,
0.0195562113,
0.0377660692,
-0.0306093432,
-0.016847752,
-0.0536660627,
-0.0417206064,
-0.0120726004,
-0.0094150938,
0.0370567776,
0.0329141319,
-0.0305881891,
0.0019450588,
-0.0439368486,
-0.0329511315,
0.0483796522,
-0.0297595058,
-0.0768982545,
-0.0180332288,
-0.0003588947,
0.0261664502,
-0.0173252523,
-0.015499928,
-0.0131712295,
0.0347122438,
-0.0013106272,
-0.0148023441,
0.0223628543,
-0.0342865363,
0.0024618534,
0.0611584038,
0.0133526642,
-0.0111086937,
0.0250493512,
-0.0195042901,
-0.0509066544,
0.0126897413,
-0.0040428871,
0.0427171625,
-0.0376232862,
0.0256970506,
-0.0279366951,
-0.011311193,
-0.0485388488,
0.0336867459,
0.0115188053,
-0.0181449354,
-0.0248286147,
0.0223478135,
-0.0133341402,
-0.003642773,
-0.0007652702,
-0.0029560947,
0.001519396,
0.0638086572,
-0.0153068127,
0.0324818641,
-0.0465922579,
-0.0220332686,
-0.0825876221,
0.017192319,
-0.0249416195,
0.0059086126,
0.002438332,
-0.0272681024,
-0.0162769612,
-0.0489796922,
-0.0169920381,
0.0154464804,
-0.0273761358,
0.0021056174,
-0.0068231644,
-0.0098544452,
-0.0078924391,
-0.0409794897,
-0.0096203052,
-0.0220447723,
-0.0081378426,
-0.0067973365,
-0.0083769094,
-0.0498076156,
0.0771673545,
0.015945306,
0.0382236019,
-0.0231471471,
-0.0496731773,
0.0162222087,
-0.0256207213,
0.0215457343,
0.0620998628,
-0.0255726837,
0.0302305687,
0.0577692129,
0.0051830057,
-0.0973842368,
0.0252916012,
0.0061068763,
-0.0680456311,
-0.0381490067,
0.0140461586,
-0.0102765216,
0.0490114875,
0.0107663451,
0.0185020715,
-0.0107537974,
0.0013169961,
0.0063497219,
-0.0400837809,
-0.0200378317,
0.005719929,
-0.0367886201,
-0.0150099415,
0.0040046563,
-0.0742336959,
0.0444799438,
-0.0215733498,
-0.0134337945,
-0.0340890475,
-0.0450723767,
-0.0197918583,
0.0614739209,
0.0129581792,
-0.005712322,
0.0181968883,
-0.0244902764,
-0.0758389458,
-0.0057605207,
0.0347838961,
-0.0297804866,
0.0407415517,
-0.057995379,
0.0093464274,
-0.006014361,
-0.0231609829,
-0.0397422276,
0.0074343099,
-0.0248991325,
0.0128158508,
-0.0009170204,
-0.0124697583,
0.0272147469,
0.022815913,
0.0362669267,
0.0642907694,
0.0058895722,
-0.0121364035,
-0.0227011591,
-0.0034014273,
0.0260163601,
0.0165996272,
-0.0204308927,
-0.0348649286,
0.0272901617,
0.0015529307,
0.0634102002,
-0.0484463163,
-0.0534671843,
0.0037375728,
0.0152718714,
-0.0523134023,
-0.0058662719,
0.0283631105,
0.0389981829,
-0.083421424,
-0.0100805406,
0.093040742,
0.0317243189,
-0.0522017032,
0.0043845,
0.0304935537,
0.017482236,
0.0770791098,
0.0620348155,
-0.0646944717,
-0.0310203563,
0.0012363046,
0.0367011279,
0.0003629505,
0.0023448782,
-0.0188410562,
-0.1473507881,
0.0261307545,
0.0274764448,
-0.0221692473,
0.0465112142,
-0.0429829247,
-0.0048812241,
-0.0293319598,
0.0003950934,
0.041155152,
-0.0309339818,
-0.0027750169,
0.0401897468,
-0.0386350267,
-0.0701093152,
0.0099444883,
-0.0022743938,
0.0518953726,
0.0531465784,
-0.0265334342,
-0.0166229773,
0.0386547334,
0.1305851936,
0.0259466898,
0.026633434,
-0.0461377315,
0.0279704761,
-0.0131972115,
-0.0120334188,
0.0254873354,
0.0491843,
-0.023571305,
0.020194279,
0.0173848886,
0.0810692608,
-0.0216375161,
0.0345444344,
0.0076042432,
-0.0503318533,
0.0103595145,
0.0158865042,
0.0263237953,
-0.034268856,
-0.0167491585,
-0.0390255041,
-0.0539271608,
-0.0379627459,
-0.030591201,
0.0121942712,
0.0006152426,
0.0001102774,
-0.0454933643,
-0.0432289429,
0.0489482433,
0.0259903595,
0.0362475365,
-0.0031689855,
-0.0117608579,
0.0362342969,
-0.0658889264,
0.014067255,
-0.0320532545,
0.0236513149,
-0.0634081587,
-0.0424483903,
0.0305790436,
-0.0482517295,
-0.0046183048,
0.0230005477,
-0.043695312,
-0.0878668576,
-0.0230421405,
0.0679040849,
0.0220228545,
0.070459418,
-0.0419307873,
-0.0556322932,
0.0088859098,
0.0305273123,
-0.0358109996,
-0.0070796707,
0.0417973176,
-0.0046314914,
-0.0002063211,
0.0263622776,
-0.0272825994,
0.0165121518,
0.0280144792,
0.0113483313,
-0.0193982925,
-0.0517594405,
0.0581324846,
0.0029135691,
0.0057285628,
0.0006927903,
0.0249869283,
-0.0582925938,
0.0355044268,
0.0384221189,
-0.0122178067,
-0.0428810231,
0.0208946634,
-0.0164070968,
-0.0247429758,
0.0439089872,
-0.0236599278,
-0.0096596181,
0.0343765169,
-0.0362496674,
0.0241869036,
-0.0139260804,
0.0151401991,
0.0295055844,
0.0345904082,
-0.0206898991,
0.0051092468,
0.0227203853,
0.0308091491,
0.0058257063,
0.0719533116,
-0.0119244587,
0.0178364422,
-0.0198925994,
0.0076988176,
-0.0318402015,
-0.0519168861,
-0.0631763116,
0.0332702324,
0.0782790408,
-0.0234071016,
0.0380481593,
-0.0405128114,
0.0118880849,
-0.0164240059,
0.0404734574,
-0.0451458022,
-0.0011312501,
-0.0122682266,
0.0377829224,
-0.010932697,
-0.0017447049,
0.0677719712,
0.0084380722,
0.0299735572,
0.0051874109,
0.0134172523,
-0.0714608207,
-0.0427725837,
0.0550195128,
-0.0061161523,
-0.0020518536,
0.024797814,
-0.0035422405,
-0.0695252866,
-0.0647288784,
0.0309782736,
-0.0114025539,
-0.0466889478,
0.0436575785,
0.0829133168,
-0.0282437857,
0.0191957243,
-0.0199229959,
-0.0059188358,
-0.0109319501,
-0.0176052172,
-0.0012499563,
-5.596605746e-33,
-0.0450553149,
-0.0054660127,
0.0549176596,
0.0324654989,
0.0027877453,
-0.0287188236,
-0.018786611,
0.0106729008,
-0.0054534753,
-0.0151415505,
-0.021082148,
-0.0030357689,
0.0168169532,
-0.0120475227,
0.0533591285,
0.0575478338,
0.0733960569,
-0.0022288093,
-0.0195184164,
0.0220967215,
0.0210241266,
0.0438212417,
0.0908667222,
-0.0450410359,
-0.0283627715,
0.0080622761,
-0.0071713678,
0.0348173976,
-0.0061129243,
0.0755436942,
0.0208204594,
0.0326421559,
0.0165411942,
-0.0304166824,
-0.0334656239,
-0.0293355733,
-0.0715372637,
-0.0312899128,
-0.0073883766,
0.0369307362,
0.0173531603,
-0.0208955333,
0.062404789,
-0.0398289226,
-0.023952486,
0.0044920552,
0.0429505482,
-0.0178929381,
-0.0275225956,
-0.0082723852,
-0.0559829324,
0.0308564994,
-0.0201447792,
-0.0706571937,
0.0092576817,
0.0161472838,
-0.0150023382,
-0.0509816706,
-0.0229755826,
0.0224275813,
0.0593925454,
0.0673675016,
0.0941912904,
0.03977938,
0.0041662371,
0.0159719475,
0.0142141683,
-0.0259873997,
0.0335408188,
-0.0094658453,
0.0579952039,
0.057535775,
0.0115354983,
0.0060766526,
-0.0083168373,
0.0072270618,
-0.0050176671,
0.0361504778,
0.0371475667,
0.0671353489,
0.0263063814,
0.0506263599,
-0.0442240871,
-0.0025677374,
-0.035943307,
-0.0036894311,
0.0047381981,
-0.0469672717,
0.0474458709,
0.0110044712,
0.0038965738,
-0.0302520748,
0.031686645,
-0.0221454632,
-0.0099527799,
0.004758337,
-0.0476538129,
0.0527041219,
-0.0060755131,
0.0263419691,
-0.0564824045,
-0.0497231483,
-0.0160996541,
-0.0057290043,
0.0318971574,
-0.0073678838,
0.0343243256,
0.0521456972,
-0.0722096115,
0.0106305685,
-0.0674629584,
0.0017756495,
-0.0046770982,
0.0368474387,
0.0148073174,
-0.0094564911,
-0.0230704248,
0.0209277775,
-0.0332233608,
-0.0751935542,
-0.0489251055,
-0.0397577994,
-0.0362601727,
0.0148538891,
-0.0370297544,
0.0015510571,
-0.0217718054,
0.0041211261,
0.0435033888,
-0.0337672941,
0.0008863761,
0.0011802361,
2.771e-7,
-0.0142957335,
0.0302751921,
0.0003210006,
0.0190549027,
0.0014830744,
0.0276135858,
-0.0543252863,
0.0314528346,
0.0049576568,
0.0073462888,
0.0226538479,
0.0689167753,
0.0589830279,
0.0250620078,
-0.0518354252,
0.0140672177,
-0.0198920202,
0.049325183,
-0.0643813238,
0.0125723984,
0.0157290995,
0.0772799104,
0.022604296,
-0.0104966499,
-0.0072190785,
-0.0444322042,
0.0222313143,
-0.0215931982,
-0.0205362197,
0.0433538109,
-0.0179351773,
0.0805600584,
-0.0088164089,
0.0084724603,
-0.0126535343,
0.0298675653,
-0.0260258131,
0.069432959,
-0.0216272436,
-0.0077643842,
0.0496869758,
-0.022163216,
0.0017408013,
-0.0482575707,
0.0357795432,
-0.0678551942,
0.0098471586,
-0.0249889586,
0.0267301928,
-0.0122667439,
-0.0174855739,
-0.0256689917,
-0.0232217647,
0.0000355258,
0.0237766169,
-0.0139732137,
-0.0336618461,
-0.0398569182,
-0.0288355108,
0.0696859807,
-0.0290494058,
-0.0530723073,
-0.0426824652,
-0.0014990489,
-0.0446227491,
-0.0055607748,
0.0124339517,
2.543221976e-34,
0.0291644484,
-0.00269895,
0.0327734947,
0.0732730106,
0.0136307981,
0.0026497608,
0.0153884618,
0.0576547906,
0.0383035392,
-0.0203310344,
-0.0228409357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.14763v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.14763v1 | VoiceBank-2023: A Multi-Speaker Mandarin Speech Corpus for Constructing Personalized TTS Systems for the Speech Impaired | 2023-08-27T07:35:30 | 2023-08-27T07:35:30 | Jia-Jyu Su, Pang-Chen Liao, Yen-Ting Lin, Wu-Hao Li, Guan-Ting Liou, Cheng-Che Kao, Wei-Cheng Chen, Jen-Chieh Chiang, Wen-Yang Chang, Pin-Han Lin, Chen-Yu Chiang | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Services of personalized TTS systems for the Mandarin-speaking speech
impaired are rarely mentioned. Taiwan started the VoiceBanking project in 2020,
aiming to build a complete set of services to deliver personalized Mandarin TTS
systems to amyotrophic lateral sclerosis patients. This paper reports the
corpus design, corpus recording, data purging and correction for the corpus,
and evaluations of the developed personalized TTS systems, for the VoiceBanking
project. The developed corpus is named after the VoiceBank-2023 speech corpus
because of its release year. The corpus contains 29.78 hours of utterances with
prompts of short paragraphs and common phrases spoken by 111 native Mandarin
speakers. The corpus is labeled with information about gender, degree of speech
impairment, types of users, transcription, SNRs, and speaking rates. The
VoiceBank-2023 is available by request for non-commercial use and welcomes all
parties to join the VoiceBanking project to improve the services for the speech
impaired. | [
0.0324253961,
0.002321277,
-0.0071558976,
-0.040255826,
0.0228034984,
-0.0276827123,
0.0529033244,
-0.0136031946,
-0.0032703844,
0.0214504581,
-0.0433796532,
-0.0368301235,
0.0725947395,
0.0273476988,
-0.0020557807,
-0.0866396651,
0.051272586,
-0.0044510341,
0.0183379725,
-0.0008385941,
0.0433334857,
0.0069885454,
-0.0469742343,
0.0545659848,
0.0134784393,
-0.0251630191,
0.0293070134,
0.0028034558,
-0.0001653543,
-0.0395449251,
-0.0159398075,
-0.0059101395,
0.0291826241,
0.0157355461,
0.0000019678,
-0.0321915112,
-0.0235197525,
0.0028487609,
-0.050827466,
0.0223976392,
0.0022726918,
0.0515523069,
-0.0269030686,
0.0588512868,
0.0042584515,
-0.0049308096,
0.0550747663,
0.0549132377,
0.0367710739,
0.0391370542,
-0.0308845453,
0.0312667899,
0.0096714068,
0.0038975975,
-0.0071322853,
-0.0295811016,
-0.0134651558,
-0.0465426594,
0.0277616531,
-0.0550311878,
0.0016942986,
0.0550547577,
-0.021172341,
0.0009368049,
0.0174645279,
-0.0110834576,
-0.0253370069,
-0.0402524695,
-0.0304696877,
0.0649041608,
0.0805106461,
0.0147752855,
0.0214451477,
0.001970198,
-0.0163949039,
-0.0566213839,
-0.0244982298,
-0.033262141,
0.0023891723,
-0.0072731432,
-0.0093625262,
0.046405714,
-0.0277248342,
-0.0085555045,
-0.0272327382,
-0.0297225323,
-0.0040971735,
-0.0303723868,
-0.0044415356,
-0.0255692434,
0.0122664487,
-0.0075514843,
0.0819049627,
-0.0107678929,
-0.0408484638,
-0.0278163794,
-0.0070853787,
-0.0670309961,
-0.0190121997,
0.016464496,
0.0461931191,
0.0458341949,
-0.0795827061,
-0.0397034883,
0.0129299834,
0.0322301872,
-0.0240414534,
-0.0495837517,
-0.0164907034,
0.0079009421,
0.0001153727,
0.0332465135,
-0.0361746252,
0.0218862779,
-0.0059889392,
-0.0109722121,
-0.0569394492,
0.0194698367,
-0.0031639093,
-0.0190633647,
0.0386668667,
0.0500021055,
-0.0357140116,
0.0071892915,
0.0007669873,
0.0321059749,
-0.0304284003,
0.0717882663,
-0.018111961,
-0.083057113,
0.0087605761,
0.0279883109,
0.0495483056,
-0.0059605055,
0.0039672866,
0.0100281611,
0.0001992061,
-0.0152202211,
-0.0338063538,
0.00466289,
-0.0472811311,
-0.0022137794,
-0.0370770656,
-0.0236937199,
0.0033513161,
-0.003583926,
0.0104680257,
-0.0087315142,
0.0043556737,
-0.0052540279,
0.035794314,
-0.0088122962,
-0.0212197695,
0.0050731823,
0.0729408786,
-0.045416493,
-0.0148330303,
0.0025595592,
0.0483132415,
-0.0231358409,
0.037766356,
-0.0158639401,
-0.0024076707,
0.0445491485,
-0.0252102017,
-0.0093393326,
-0.0486373678,
-0.0090739299,
-0.0270302463,
0.0117280865,
0.0167034101,
0.0528181903,
0.0098257428,
0.0204210579,
0.0698964968,
0.0777636766,
0.0502724759,
-0.0252144542,
-0.0139395669,
-0.026675066,
0.002804867,
-0.0441253707,
0.0559349842,
-0.0121239247,
0.023756139,
0.0083519854,
-0.0023793639,
0.0148719912,
-0.022371687,
-0.0314487778,
-0.011112391,
-0.0527649075,
-0.0348294973,
0.0328679234,
0.0210652426,
-0.0070418254,
0.0072165444,
0.0256330185,
-0.0193972513,
-0.0930719152,
0.0064187068,
-0.0535872132,
-0.0263462979,
0.0870087296,
0.0183338299,
-0.0017488609,
0.0124125415,
-0.0445630401,
-0.0695283711,
0.0217892863,
-0.0326666571,
0.0020053992,
0.0071527758,
-0.082169421,
-0.0204523634,
0.1007720158,
-0.0351240188,
0.0065083383,
-0.0402676314,
0.0470939055,
-0.0036326945,
-0.0024371399,
0.0238448698,
-0.0021984756,
-0.0243334882,
0.0022990722,
0.0274510384,
-0.0151882302,
0.0735796764,
0.0944352001,
-0.0436076932,
0.0149264289,
0.0013980935,
-0.0107795242,
0.0155922612,
0.0714108571,
-0.0784634277,
0.0031284024,
0.0260510147,
0.0151896877,
0.0148690734,
0.0654305294,
0.0413044989,
-0.0992499068,
-0.0138134975,
-0.0288563874,
0.0261865444,
-0.0640498474,
0.0470660217,
0.0188023224,
0.0391398929,
0.0246965345,
-0.0252376366,
0.002535803,
-0.0237102713,
-0.0066993297,
-0.0233216025,
0.0449860245,
-0.1244458407,
-0.0344386436,
-0.0056622806,
-0.0383149758,
0.0220369063,
-0.0033541629,
-0.0414985269,
-0.0124499826,
0.0330010802,
-0.065617606,
-0.0033365395,
-0.0012257778,
-0.0059393938,
-0.015813008,
0.0431729369,
-0.0154706622,
-0.0538038723,
-0.0270418115,
0.0303863361,
0.0059125638,
-0.0440981537,
-0.0236775149,
-0.0087078884,
-0.0121465921,
-0.0481670909,
0.0271917861,
-0.0053868187,
-0.0172539428,
-0.0136657488,
-0.1360629201,
-0.0206218753,
0.0049910336,
0.0334442146,
0.0429090634,
0.0267164633,
-0.0221369583,
0.009866925,
-0.001645466,
0.0026819427,
0.0179230627,
-0.0000104462,
0.0099893268,
0.0189265441,
0.0316051617,
-0.0150983483,
0.0051182755,
0.0145287178,
0.0622230731,
-0.0043714633,
-0.0007937886,
0.0291503426,
0.0080040889,
0.0818555653,
0.0248618945,
-0.0236739293,
-0.0943026543,
-0.0184075795,
-0.0149110556,
0.0284406394,
-0.0204470418,
-0.1003726348,
-0.0218434017,
0.0096078739,
-0.0195706636,
0.0001016436,
-0.0411679372,
-0.0236785337,
-0.0854076445,
-0.043799717,
-0.0106514227,
0.0144522041,
-0.0497318245,
0.0037064129,
-0.0013929314,
-0.0656352118,
0.0128731215,
0.0094364826,
-0.0036593061,
-0.0260321833,
0.0078994501,
-0.0051194322,
-0.0009740197,
-0.0123576354,
-0.0003612995,
-0.0220509134,
0.0158589538,
-0.0484750234,
0.0376399979,
0.0608974509,
-0.0117385155,
0.0118529722,
0.0259441398,
0.0191814452,
0.1084582955,
0.0091213305,
0.0220811721,
-0.0101806326,
0.0277052242,
0.0015706255,
0.0471374989,
-0.0108772852,
0.0148226591,
0.0553671457,
-0.001084493,
0.0536469445,
0.0498449691,
0.0241583325,
0.0038892312,
0.0538134873,
-0.0167067945,
-0.0013238806,
0.0431736782,
0.0673451349,
-0.0006691997,
0.0163278617,
0.1029086187,
0.0358120501,
-0.0806532875,
-0.0137321148,
0.0121403253,
-0.0047596907,
-0.0052338555,
-0.0314061642,
-0.1077199429,
-0.0163012352,
0.0430265851,
0.0592798367,
-0.0182336289,
0.0260663833,
-0.0253629293,
-0.0510063954,
0.0271913819,
0.0223391689,
-0.0074931164,
-0.0027077685,
0.0179479755,
-0.0247856304,
0.0049196067,
0.0665631145,
0.0061062872,
-0.0153930103,
-0.0228506904,
0.0484711193,
-0.1211621016,
-0.0716057569,
0.0096475715,
-0.0305664428,
0.1297702938,
0.0943543613,
0.0202396791,
0.0080155842,
-0.0366334431,
-0.0102923876,
-0.0226407945,
0.0103381062,
-0.0324452147,
0.0186493285,
0.0273450632,
-0.031510748,
-0.0389662236,
0.0864604786,
-0.0206242036,
0.0130553283,
0.0289141331,
-0.0058131218,
-0.060072314,
0.0376136713,
-0.0248985998,
0.045541551,
0.0028242078,
0.0450499617,
-0.0161531512,
-0.0680787414,
0.0282469317,
0.0016781007,
0.0174621604,
-0.0455794558,
0.0085874032,
0.0638150349,
-0.0353375189,
-0.0634091944,
-0.084839724,
-0.0146213211,
0.0021820466,
0.02203089,
0.0051900344,
0.0469652824,
0.0196857583,
0.0712303221,
0.0027798053,
-0.0269188266,
0.0561993755,
0.026474921,
-0.085616231,
-0.0265621748,
-0.0110508827,
-0.0303988513,
-0.0130907828,
-0.0275576003,
0.0106450636,
-0.040352419,
0.0894990861,
-0.0385546647,
0.0119601674,
0.0243578646,
-0.0014450158,
-0.0142236026,
0.0345469452,
0.0137388492,
-0.0175191518,
0.0145752188,
0.0459128357,
-0.0035864131,
-0.00818065,
0.0023232924,
-0.0003560163,
0.0312119033,
-0.0234214347,
0.0100653777,
-0.0099000847,
0.0136001706,
-0.015072776,
0.0503492355,
0.0516761132,
-0.0273031481,
0.0112209823,
-0.0464771055,
0.0600876398,
-0.0157248173,
0.0405308977,
-0.0475699008,
-0.0165309981,
0.0332096592,
-0.0156042362,
-0.0257841125,
0.0125099933,
-0.0726331547,
-0.0511506386,
0.0202679671,
0.0800180957,
0.0278940648,
0.0432268716,
-0.0400051512,
-0.0111153135,
-0.0125236893,
0.0509326383,
0.0171858072,
-0.0014621726,
-0.0019755906,
0.0561388358,
-0.0406895317,
-0.0135360509,
0.04565797,
0.0133499475,
0.0077040466,
-0.0138827646,
-0.0389805622,
-0.0224120505,
0.0085399458,
0.0163531434,
0.0116982283,
0.0029848905,
0.0471906625,
-0.0279990137,
-0.0322835222,
-0.025489293,
0.0515380576,
-0.0101757776,
-0.0233968273,
-0.0586447939,
-0.0177340657,
0.028893739,
0.0002802362,
0.0110885594,
-0.0114821997,
-0.0007122427,
-0.0236556046,
-0.0185508057,
0.0292115193,
-0.0252001043,
-0.0639290288,
-0.0240354501,
0.0093019595,
-0.0292553268,
0.0519633964,
-0.013247394,
0.0028574716,
-0.0160030127,
0.0005936475,
-0.0465996936,
-0.0370932221,
0.0065266616,
0.0064447811,
-0.0637880266,
-0.0201948378,
-0.0238577295,
0.0233271681,
-6.155453026e-33,
0.0127465148,
0.021603303,
-0.0096641025,
-0.0005348537,
-0.0054303058,
0.0022594831,
0.0016923611,
0.0020505956,
-0.0177737102,
-0.0056741764,
-0.0260546338,
0.0090797208,
0.0418993346,
0.0450386517,
0.0046027103,
0.043105796,
0.0743224099,
-0.011141629,
-0.0011359392,
-0.0126788756,
0.0575151704,
0.0352683552,
0.0514838919,
-0.0435851663,
0.0261415262,
-0.0004811953,
-0.0129541494,
-0.0134056993,
0.0694049522,
0.0199052524,
0.0006416261,
0.0307911448,
-0.0176248141,
-0.0221565235,
-0.0116811842,
0.0595081747,
-0.0924241468,
-0.0261015818,
-0.0057274229,
0.0583519116,
0.0217674654,
0.0087263081,
0.0020870841,
-0.0147684701,
-0.0571985766,
0.0227292366,
0.0134621868,
-0.0329281613,
0.015985461,
-0.024596354,
0.0208669771,
0.0259285551,
0.0156966653,
0.0128434394,
0.0315623097,
0.0166453607,
-0.0378314629,
-0.0522712842,
-0.0560627058,
0.0305916779,
0.0255658664,
0.0283965152,
-0.0208908506,
-0.0311497431,
0.0101977345,
-0.0050638723,
0.0359037519,
-0.06640549,
0.0229421631,
-0.0247796029,
0.0297138561,
0.0101763355,
0.0482084416,
0.0195097402,
0.0175823085,
-0.0539636426,
-0.0230149552,
0.0310035758,
0.0417265147,
0.0193086974,
-0.01550915,
0.0374528542,
-0.0266586784,
0.0204870868,
-0.040654473,
-0.0114292996,
-0.0222403388,
-0.0032676999,
0.0299821869,
-0.0329579562,
-0.0055711768,
-0.0388405994,
0.0563473143,
-0.0259694681,
0.0058279913,
-0.0359546356,
0.0240656435,
0.0049337097,
0.0018976683,
-0.0154790487,
-0.054952208,
-0.0077075497,
0.0544933863,
0.0173644405,
0.0097402185,
-0.0180333573,
-0.0136650596,
0.0473018736,
-0.0561172925,
0.0059430473,
0.0484238006,
0.0060270219,
0.0003679466,
0.0426303484,
0.0258966237,
-0.0304232743,
-0.0015375548,
0.0407239608,
-0.0348778255,
0.0015655624,
-0.0178373177,
-0.0048334287,
0.0132283354,
0.0432458557,
-0.0525895245,
0.0355191194,
-0.0242933687,
0.0418977067,
0.0387345776,
-0.0043076375,
0.0190796275,
-0.0342605896,
2.612e-7,
-0.0169176534,
0.0213694368,
0.0385414027,
-0.0020555432,
0.0143036274,
0.0144601669,
0.0061781099,
0.0067262561,
-0.0389434732,
0.0501220748,
0.0377432369,
-0.0590547994,
0.0522519983,
0.0002274342,
-0.0786186531,
-0.0212054886,
-0.0573883727,
0.0375638641,
-0.0105380462,
0.0578504428,
0.0281695966,
0.0514752232,
-0.0381004661,
-0.0494547896,
0.0554880947,
-0.0241316408,
-0.0074502267,
-0.0146771222,
0.0269879196,
-0.0070571345,
0.0582902767,
-0.0332936347,
0.0084946183,
-0.0188794248,
-0.0756240636,
0.0416231565,
-0.012331916,
0.0405778326,
-0.0542256311,
-0.0724390522,
0.0383808948,
0.0683226883,
-0.0173374526,
0.0427919477,
0.0277326033,
0.0473008081,
-0.0151473191,
-0.0139635028,
-0.0028409839,
-0.0287087895,
0.012687075,
-0.0154746063,
0.0307583995,
-0.0140944254,
0.0048743705,
0.038447503,
-0.0328271501,
-0.0420363061,
0.0152213397,
0.0125236958,
-0.0491404124,
-0.0399392247,
-0.0079120044,
-0.0145073896,
-0.0242465846,
-0.0554789715,
-0.0015978288,
2.216722222e-34,
0.004567951,
-0.0002719784,
0.0125002703,
0.0124573456,
-0.005947961,
-0.0324635394,
0.0522608384,
0.017504083,
-0.0094922008,
-0.0113018425,
-0.066181168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13961v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13961v2 | Translate Meanings, Not Just Words: IdiomKB's Role in Optimizing Idiomatic Translation with Language Models | 2023-08-26T21:38:31 | 2023-12-25T02:54:13 | Shuang Li, Jiangjie Chen, Siyu Yuan, Xinyi Wu, Hao Yang, Shimin Tao, Yanghua Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | To translate well, machine translation (MT) systems and general-purposed
language models (LMs) need a deep understanding of both source and target
languages and cultures. Therefore, idioms, with their non-compositional nature,
pose particular challenges for Transformer-based systems, as literal
translations often miss the intended meaning. Traditional methods, which
replace idioms using existing knowledge bases (KBs), often lack scale and
context awareness. Addressing these challenges, our approach prioritizes
context awareness and scalability, allowing for offline storage of idioms in a
manageable KB size. This ensures efficient serving with smaller models and
provides a more comprehensive understanding of idiomatic expressions. We
introduce a multilingual idiom KB (IdiomKB) developed using large LMs to
address this. This KB facilitates better translation by smaller models, such as
BLOOMZ (7.1B), Alpaca (7B), and InstructGPT (6.7B), by retrieving idioms'
figurative meanings. We present a novel, GPT-4-powered metric for human-aligned
evaluation, demonstrating that IdiomKB considerably boosts model performance.
Human evaluations further validate our KB's quality. | [
0.0461896174,
0.0255823545,
-0.0190717317,
0.0541635305,
-0.0695219785,
0.0012858106,
0.0030197655,
0.0398588479,
0.032063067,
-0.0028026227,
-0.0446322225,
-0.0431133695,
0.0195882134,
0.0159118213,
0.0026998613,
-0.0341910645,
0.0326073244,
0.0138089452,
-0.0181983151,
0.0195931681,
-0.0210945345,
0.0275817774,
0.0260764603,
0.029203264,
-0.0116249323,
-0.0082077999,
0.0218683593,
0.0529513732,
0.019079281,
-0.0210232139,
-0.0103431148,
0.0093002738,
-0.0053805029,
0.0446327329,
0.0000025083,
-0.048317872,
-0.0398988463,
-0.0075956066,
-0.0049610208,
0.0269072652,
0.0807892531,
-0.0567855202,
-0.0286858603,
-0.0100964606,
-0.0465350598,
0.01812784,
0.0559977219,
0.0163746849,
0.0076780347,
0.0359621719,
-0.0174601451,
-0.0527996644,
0.002416305,
-0.0166240167,
0.0024074635,
-0.0844961181,
0.0005466922,
0.0138741983,
-0.0646813959,
0.0004012103,
-0.0368368067,
0.0538172945,
0.0146536361,
0.0000771874,
-0.0108101657,
0.0213318225,
-0.0358455144,
-0.0237830076,
-0.0126610361,
0.058204148,
-0.0238781366,
-0.0005238518,
-0.0299122836,
-0.0229850095,
-0.0061410833,
-0.0274493769,
-0.033897765,
0.0010266447,
-0.0223775413,
0.001054944,
-0.0069365189,
0.0240255184,
0.0148988161,
0.0303423647,
-0.0698923692,
0.0044767046,
0.0413971171,
0.0045920149,
-0.0044560819,
-0.0350342952,
-0.0517144576,
-0.0098823346,
0.023513509,
-0.006948567,
0.015325903,
0.033122573,
-0.0007675792,
0.0051752143,
0.0151379732,
-0.0674954355,
0.043927379,
0.0756567866,
0.0262928326,
0.0502706692,
-0.0260942336,
0.0489467606,
0.0013821693,
0.0383562483,
-0.0412186086,
-0.0198291074,
-0.0830199644,
0.0053927028,
-0.0475551225,
0.0110972179,
-0.0213370062,
-0.0226344038,
-0.0381676517,
0.0487561375,
-0.0133317523,
-0.0245370641,
0.0349399336,
0.0307799298,
-0.0617924035,
-0.0352097973,
-0.0150043275,
0.0865264013,
-0.0059076501,
-0.0077979607,
-0.0362285189,
-0.0716582313,
-0.0010015871,
-0.0010704459,
-0.0080472911,
-0.0541604646,
0.016697539,
0.067460306,
0.0165375564,
-0.0494427383,
-0.0186531693,
-0.010661264,
-0.0059380038,
-0.0257112812,
-0.0164553784,
-0.0566388369,
0.0680128559,
0.005315125,
0.0297485571,
-0.0758692175,
0.0107198972,
0.007990378,
-0.0312578268,
0.0560928844,
0.0018487209,
0.0187894832,
0.0000801044,
0.020714974,
-0.0439505056,
0.0552066267,
0.0515186414,
-0.0052444665,
0.0585080534,
-0.0280304961,
-0.0412047468,
0.0335654579,
0.0001949981,
0.0435470641,
-0.0425219312,
0.0209420789,
-0.0042760721,
0.0431604981,
0.0112613253,
0.0597563125,
-0.006114603,
0.0362966955,
0.0863836333,
0.0283695962,
-0.0129667055,
0.0481871963,
0.0404142179,
0.0504928268,
-0.0039506587,
-0.0496665649,
0.0034819911,
0.0077660191,
-0.0150201097,
0.0072729606,
0.0083360579,
0.0817736387,
0.0210912246,
-0.0027918885,
-0.0072975713,
-0.0146730188,
0.0390964039,
-0.0401636399,
0.0391586795,
0.0172082186,
-0.0178024266,
0.1044876203,
-0.0220052488,
-0.0568297543,
-0.0197531302,
-0.0477123298,
-0.064890869,
0.0653962791,
0.0504585914,
0.0168621801,
-0.0215650257,
-0.0031845167,
0.0207843445,
0.0341841541,
0.0235215053,
0.0010428467,
0.0107565755,
-0.0333287194,
0.0062836297,
0.0347878933,
0.0074133701,
-0.0101343952,
0.0342551395,
0.0507554747,
0.0352738276,
-0.0628885627,
-0.0660489947,
0.0139905754,
-0.0359215885,
-0.0182344988,
0.0219644904,
-0.0007236833,
0.0284230951,
0.022899434,
-0.0117895966,
0.0158497933,
0.0230764113,
-0.0474657491,
-0.0397891253,
0.0748166591,
0.0042248894,
0.0114600817,
0.0572107509,
-0.0140477698,
0.0046661389,
-0.018304754,
-0.037059553,
-0.0165042281,
0.014046724,
-0.0344249643,
0.04653202,
-0.0146208955,
0.0223099813,
-0.0282752384,
0.0078547467,
-0.0117052235,
0.0642369464,
-0.0055206884,
0.0029360768,
-0.0234697796,
-0.018054625,
0.0448039286,
0.0374541841,
-0.0060563344,
0.0242932588,
-0.0200296361,
0.0197987277,
0.0184153654,
0.0363326818,
-0.0584638231,
-0.0274244342,
-0.1060791463,
0.0204021204,
0.0315551423,
0.0213770885,
0.0461780354,
0.0566134565,
-0.0082178712,
0.021936845,
0.0227251537,
-0.0373916291,
-0.0047617578,
0.0365758315,
-0.0204457361,
-0.0032784394,
-0.0214405153,
0.0228551719,
0.0264407583,
-0.0173485614,
0.0302817822,
0.0063553434,
0.0339941978,
0.0022520656,
-0.0092719877,
-0.0580414943,
-0.0499029681,
0.0157376286,
-0.0560616739,
-0.0069582718,
-0.0142273717,
0.0377486087,
0.0392100886,
0.0256190486,
0.0011578689,
0.0261346325,
-0.0525998361,
-0.0537250452,
-0.0303010102,
-0.0015998489,
-0.0573673099,
-0.0129720559,
-0.0661895871,
-0.0112813134,
0.036816787,
0.031008428,
0.0036342689,
-0.077074416,
0.0246197972,
-0.0339515246,
0.0201872177,
-0.0483704023,
0.0353535302,
-0.0145778023,
0.0277997851,
-0.0161327105,
-0.0228012502,
0.0618456341,
-0.0242426563,
0.0030057761,
-0.0360551365,
0.0083382297,
-0.0160625968,
0.0792776719,
-0.070705764,
0.0374927074,
-0.0248815529,
0.0220835134,
-0.0112711545,
0.0277802832,
-0.0123271681,
-0.0682349652,
0.0022475075,
-0.0685886517,
-0.0032974433,
-0.0098862695,
-0.0065890378,
0.0085595297,
0.00101942,
-0.0308896191,
-0.0126927551,
0.0610153973,
-0.0085499687,
0.01515962,
0.0447431467,
0.0361431614,
-0.0139419371,
-0.000448838,
-0.0305931587,
0.004281275,
-0.0157433394,
-0.0062838993,
-0.0122903837,
0.0103153866,
0.0276461337,
0.0255205184,
0.0228428096,
-0.0129779186,
-0.0675528646,
-0.019371409,
-0.0177807454,
0.0215880927,
-0.015925834,
-0.0184697025,
-0.0317159109,
0.0148576628,
-0.0380797461,
-0.0563088767,
0.0918588638,
0.0323219858,
-0.050669603,
0.0225496888,
-0.0256962199,
0.0334145315,
0.0151803959,
0.0158266798,
-0.0903686285,
-0.0398775004,
0.0117382361,
0.0058033117,
-0.0022866924,
-0.0214388017,
-0.028400857,
-0.1102546379,
0.0190039854,
0.0414287485,
-0.047078073,
-0.0613636151,
-0.0029172872,
-0.0325501487,
-0.0288890097,
-0.016071897,
-0.0047569252,
0.0180189423,
-0.0011500926,
-0.0318217911,
0.0122393668,
-0.0738952383,
0.0349888653,
-0.0394166373,
0.0149155147,
0.0430411994,
0.0824005455,
0.0117072109,
-0.0703585818,
-0.0243287683,
-0.0282570776,
-0.0137101682,
-0.0180952512,
0.0020579391,
-0.0028180445,
-0.0181119964,
0.0212384872,
-0.0317036323,
-0.0535647869,
-0.0132621964,
-0.0045648497,
0.0370247327,
-0.0254743323,
0.0274887215,
0.0088053849,
-0.0417317487,
0.0178477541,
0.0843046606,
0.0037459575,
-0.0423661284,
0.022626562,
-0.0159272738,
-0.0041597644,
-0.0457163975,
-0.0553831942,
-0.0017635806,
-0.0717511773,
-0.0143819954,
-0.0662412345,
-0.0227479041,
0.0052170735,
0.0413066074,
0.0137741547,
-0.00655076,
-0.0432685502,
0.0269934349,
-0.0658714026,
0.0364543907,
-0.0376606174,
0.0293163657,
-0.0368055031,
-0.0033266521,
0.0300395228,
-0.0165576376,
-0.0001905734,
0.0818461105,
-0.0027514058,
-0.0587084591,
0.0109983096,
0.06362506,
0.0308532044,
0.0056200395,
-0.0365194455,
0.0175294336,
0.0388120264,
0.0238954015,
-0.0122306906,
0.0045086276,
0.0413509831,
0.0211009942,
0.0047301669,
0.0557798706,
-0.0231777206,
0.0373238772,
-0.0461374111,
0.0966835245,
-0.0021115611,
-0.0653633103,
0.0202962458,
0.038270276,
-0.022476444,
-0.0574191548,
-0.0789682865,
0.0374001712,
0.009510058,
-0.0132734869,
-0.0398840383,
-0.0204621311,
0.0134656886,
0.0742781535,
-0.015616741,
-0.0076084477,
0.0244089868,
-0.003902565,
-0.0453003012,
0.0403992571,
-0.0516004823,
0.0327968411,
-0.0046790233,
-0.0006080934,
0.0209171325,
-0.0251826681,
-0.052785106,
-0.0146274306,
0.0087300483,
-0.034798041,
0.0397423506,
0.0090692136,
-0.0193793532,
-0.0003360064,
0.0576779954,
0.0063278587,
-0.0205535423,
-0.0138060283,
0.0046681967,
0.0514015853,
0.0052064271,
0.0756754503,
-0.0199352913,
-0.0135066519,
-0.0081105176,
0.019491015,
0.0114389881,
-0.0458304435,
-0.0168684237,
0.0061649531,
-0.0064384774,
-0.0002060423,
0.0468632281,
-0.0761259571,
0.0629869699,
-0.0082267774,
-0.0362117589,
-0.0228419192,
0.0033842395,
0.0087121138,
0.0045212354,
0.0165852346,
-0.0040411763,
-0.1103546694,
-0.0595531836,
0.0430193394,
0.0221077502,
0.0033256009,
-0.0256742965,
0.0219922755,
0.0822931156,
0.0352908932,
0.0230336078,
-0.0454944707,
0.0073613776,
-0.1120235547,
0.0018377615,
-0.0368897505,
-7.297180934e-33,
-0.0530364476,
-0.0224935263,
0.0008379229,
-0.0293705203,
-0.0317545012,
-0.0063508609,
-0.0463739708,
-0.0065799295,
0.0169413183,
0.0002289898,
-0.0081262905,
0.0047724419,
0.0055130757,
-0.0047743898,
0.049720265,
0.0507978275,
-0.0010168012,
0.0169236436,
-0.0478487425,
0.0202543326,
0.0821738169,
0.028903788,
0.0694014058,
-0.0596965067,
0.0451728106,
0.0214594416,
-0.029600976,
0.0033475219,
0.0122272484,
0.0289499052,
-0.0199405607,
0.0509147905,
0.0314764977,
0.0005942138,
0.0240001269,
-0.0194294769,
-0.06283696,
-0.0001066432,
0.0536540374,
0.0198950768,
0.0554506555,
-0.0458353013,
0.0602906048,
-0.0375596881,
-0.0113733029,
0.0229631737,
-0.022118127,
-0.0571839586,
-0.0198545959,
-0.0208194405,
-0.0861099511,
0.0009348626,
0.0248071887,
-0.0218336266,
-0.0223517511,
0.0045130453,
-0.0193042085,
0.0232149865,
-0.0829101801,
0.0104925102,
-0.0117996791,
0.007732843,
0.0608351789,
-0.023365628,
0.0237678271,
0.0303806104,
-0.0473236255,
-0.049300313,
0.0385464989,
0.0271253381,
0.0474478304,
0.0493956394,
0.0558434799,
0.0698793456,
0.0316695981,
-0.0283633936,
0.0063117505,
0.0470208935,
0.0222087074,
0.0227973163,
0.0342328511,
0.0252793916,
-0.020727843,
0.0087882914,
-0.00813141,
-0.0279874429,
-0.0219673775,
-0.0640489385,
0.0220436379,
-0.0086292205,
-0.0752148256,
0.0254979804,
0.064542301,
-0.020269582,
-0.0215830393,
-0.0061161336,
-0.0141369086,
-0.0033994506,
0.0026585639,
0.0234512519,
-0.0000705269,
-0.0478575565,
0.0113047808,
0.0424389914,
0.0207043178,
-0.0035008753,
0.0281374361,
0.0297926925,
-0.0357225873,
0.0108820312,
-0.0480295159,
-0.0292417146,
-0.050981205,
-0.0199246015,
0.0087669985,
0.0253875982,
-0.0313573964,
-0.0331424177,
0.0633035824,
0.0228616204,
-0.0128535451,
0.0095812017,
-0.0074449847,
0.0411356911,
-0.0392670371,
0.0108927777,
-0.0274205171,
-0.0357478708,
0.0416264534,
-0.0206359532,
-0.0325763077,
-0.0038223853,
3.349e-7,
0.0616281964,
0.0451858602,
-0.0118760588,
0.0049416181,
-0.0057362434,
0.0349582434,
-0.0138805453,
0.0084855901,
-0.0296446625,
0.0109363738,
0.0282550212,
0.0430892147,
0.0427578911,
0.0337721556,
-0.0630137995,
-0.0088355122,
-0.0412070118,
0.0383226424,
-0.0360588171,
0.0023850785,
0.0278250165,
0.0919332057,
0.0062058023,
-0.0025172122,
-0.0020754186,
-0.067976661,
0.0582657792,
-0.03229912,
0.0447179936,
-0.0178288184,
0.0790558308,
0.0160548016,
-0.0093555432,
0.0027134742,
0.0010847204,
-0.0201578103,
0.0287890248,
0.0576287657,
-0.0347030498,
0.0160261746,
-0.0250453148,
-0.0736152381,
0.0094843302,
-0.0796621293,
0.0681820735,
-0.0769827366,
-0.0213707946,
0.0074648545,
-0.0317702368,
0.0180482492,
0.0351423323,
-0.042911727,
-0.0356152542,
0.0009608262,
0.0296166446,
0.0023160051,
-0.0182944145,
-0.0507243313,
-0.0075820913,
0.0019745554,
0.0092732636,
-0.0135463197,
-0.0212799348,
0.0013355233,
-0.0309983697,
-0.0476970151,
0.0033738255,
2.891616921e-34,
0.0228322335,
0.0110224457,
0.0222287383,
0.0251227487,
0.0688068643,
-0.0061812084,
0.0052818744,
0.0232156701,
-0.0418711454,
-0.0353170708,
0.0122067956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13958v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13958v1 | Improving Knowledge Distillation for BERT Models: Loss Functions, Mapping Methods, and Weight Tuning | 2023-08-26T20:59:21 | 2023-08-26T20:59:21 | Apoorv Dankar, Adeem Jassani, Kartikaeya Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The use of large transformer-based models such as BERT, GPT, and T5 has led
to significant advancements in natural language processing. However, these
models are computationally expensive, necessitating model compression
techniques that reduce their size and complexity while maintaining accuracy.
This project investigates and applies knowledge distillation for BERT model
compression, specifically focusing on the TinyBERT student model. We explore
various techniques to improve knowledge distillation, including experimentation
with loss functions, transformer layer mapping methods, and tuning the weights
of attention and representation loss and evaluate our proposed techniques on a
selection of downstream tasks from the GLUE benchmark. The goal of this work is
to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of knowledge distillation, enabling
the development of more efficient and accurate models for a range of natural
language processing tasks. | [
0.0217642616,
0.046011813,
-0.0110889189,
0.066310294,
-0.0260078218,
-0.005502406,
-0.0149225267,
0.0092112534,
-0.01957356,
0.0019380914,
-0.0127585456,
-0.0143850772,
0.0099163437,
-0.0027563248,
0.0350063965,
-0.0679930821,
0.0360390618,
-0.0138192475,
-0.0052008019,
-0.0046514715,
-0.0025810329,
-0.0017476056,
0.021626791,
0.0477302521,
-0.0141739016,
-0.0255593825,
-0.0073853638,
0.0166816246,
0.0031560473,
0.0204434805,
0.0193084292,
0.0733300522,
0.0063526952,
0.0178898349,
0.0000019554,
-0.0224674139,
-0.0159902107,
0.0224606358,
-0.0486060008,
0.0347571857,
-0.0378608666,
0.0019845583,
0.0033793973,
0.0298800487,
-0.0073230756,
0.0069966349,
0.0603604391,
0.0494007617,
0.0844544843,
0.0585240386,
0.0076316046,
-0.0420884937,
0.0283338539,
-0.0277980752,
0.0178440772,
0.0026735268,
0.0271100905,
-0.0140251014,
-0.0417696536,
-0.034938138,
-0.0331917927,
0.0360122249,
0.0254538525,
0.0200927183,
0.0189528633,
0.021467546,
-0.079394117,
-0.0456388667,
-0.006650744,
0.0574795827,
-0.0462728813,
-0.0227836482,
0.0015436389,
0.0374680646,
0.0022210127,
0.0026894349,
-0.0310809966,
-0.0240969136,
0.0195399318,
0.0067796358,
-0.0256573949,
-0.0003860042,
0.0198954623,
-0.0169860572,
-0.0549183935,
0.0044132234,
0.0200239737,
-0.0297411196,
-0.0097266808,
-0.0244239196,
-0.0810525864,
-0.0335804857,
0.0415229611,
0.0169289298,
0.0588668026,
-0.0074171601,
-0.0478516407,
-0.0436266065,
0.0050840792,
-0.0261360351,
0.0499766581,
0.0639179274,
0.0105489586,
0.0315200724,
-0.0437353067,
0.1057450101,
-0.0167108476,
0.0367083177,
-0.0150684183,
-0.0351400711,
-0.0587261766,
-0.0150282104,
-0.0708572417,
0.0567950942,
-0.0223934371,
-0.0296609923,
-0.0039315121,
-0.0182967652,
-0.0063470001,
-0.0162660312,
0.0600626208,
0.0202252101,
-0.0420093834,
-0.0138242412,
-0.0196890775,
0.102109693,
-0.0285817124,
-0.0203268398,
0.0061951652,
-0.03767303,
-0.0526883788,
0.0126385437,
0.0043267757,
-0.0211224351,
-0.0028942924,
0.027050199,
0.0056112544,
-0.0338690653,
-0.0457178839,
-0.0098146554,
-0.0366798639,
-0.0567300133,
0.0213789251,
-0.0643301979,
0.0367179997,
-0.0205087457,
-0.0051470585,
-0.0585173704,
0.0067037544,
-0.0109537831,
-0.0372413881,
0.0505005196,
-0.0050109392,
-0.0059915227,
-0.0083827255,
0.0237744022,
-0.0134322084,
0.0534691252,
0.0247913655,
0.0316360369,
-0.0118103316,
-0.029097937,
-0.0272102244,
0.0526455753,
0.0610803179,
-0.0102794515,
-0.0399722308,
-0.0130474605,
-0.0288181249,
0.0114014754,
0.0396633558,
0.0899019092,
-0.0556184128,
-0.0122329751,
0.0683884248,
0.0450470559,
0.0691976398,
0.0641330108,
-0.0228733234,
0.0276021548,
0.0427112281,
-0.0105862375,
-0.0307615995,
0.0119429883,
0.0050429651,
0.0096028028,
0.0114436895,
0.0609999374,
-0.0266215988,
-0.0000131093,
0.0032846837,
-0.0182699319,
-0.0008683894,
-0.0219172109,
0.0183668006,
0.0365627035,
-0.0234510936,
0.1632816643,
0.0171000399,
-0.050635241,
-0.0142092109,
-0.047387667,
-0.026299933,
0.0249274522,
0.0433771797,
0.0063393153,
-0.0571497679,
0.0070994678,
-0.0271854922,
0.0261758119,
0.0094831809,
0.0034934552,
0.0216319244,
-0.0555259138,
-0.0330795236,
0.0116763012,
0.0125844665,
-0.0324740894,
0.0428564623,
-0.0154034207,
0.0147565315,
-0.0881502032,
0.0115785403,
0.0193279646,
-0.0093981717,
-0.0387863144,
-0.0258095972,
0.0184105951,
0.0281555634,
-0.0040932824,
-0.0236024447,
0.0076470533,
0.0383020639,
-0.0330733731,
-0.0043056835,
-0.0223456752,
-0.0258558225,
-0.0832588598,
0.0545861349,
-0.0342863873,
0.0169180129,
0.0884167552,
-0.0266824197,
-0.0327546559,
-0.0060318741,
-0.0737063438,
0.0849395022,
-0.0151206832,
0.037677519,
-0.0017960049,
-0.0167128909,
-0.017852772,
0.0513376854,
-0.0635017157,
-0.0093775494,
-0.0140212327,
-0.0306072142,
-0.0075046187,
0.0067897267,
-0.0355087109,
0.0064612757,
-0.0266328212,
0.013350958,
0.0197284538,
-0.0130742155,
-0.0241534151,
-0.0484568588,
-0.0516676977,
0.011394253,
-0.0161184296,
0.0468846858,
0.0185925346,
0.0506125093,
0.0186220519,
0.0028103748,
-0.0177434534,
-0.0143895075,
-0.0510202162,
-0.0031158482,
-0.003898106,
-0.0097447755,
-0.0118869273,
-0.0140909478,
-0.0305800028,
0.0018358518,
0.0522887781,
-0.0700226948,
-0.0305154026,
-0.0234918427,
-0.002247371,
-0.0152861821,
0.0235629138,
0.0239710659,
-0.0692451298,
-0.0145238554,
-0.0073453416,
0.0567071103,
0.0302645713,
0.0108538661,
0.0600765795,
-0.0035519411,
-0.0046728174,
-0.0546980761,
0.0424636565,
-0.039852269,
0.023518838,
-0.0238388851,
-0.0370821655,
0.002972051,
0.0771243423,
-0.0260229185,
0.0135314055,
-0.0702238455,
-0.0114905201,
0.0206005704,
-0.022024367,
0.0027747632,
0.0070947069,
-0.0356443897,
-0.0413068384,
-0.0446056128,
-0.0092061749,
0.0425321013,
-0.0429783948,
0.0118410075,
-0.0456004888,
0.0197961237,
-0.0050232713,
0.0403367579,
0.0024005771,
0.0347678699,
-0.0224994607,
-0.0130092595,
-0.046452444,
0.0028279005,
0.0032145027,
-0.0317115821,
0.0343500599,
-0.0090934904,
-0.0180874839,
-0.0013790898,
-0.0275124125,
-0.0111489715,
-0.0141394176,
0.0035901833,
0.0447445065,
0.0531695262,
-0.0388695374,
-0.0663112253,
0.0117565077,
0.0255009811,
0.0498563424,
-0.0065985597,
0.0027998637,
-0.0210764371,
0.0672704875,
0.0162600223,
0.0298778284,
0.027984174,
-0.0249593556,
0.0059749316,
0.0659173504,
0.0271842983,
0.0053308168,
-0.0355444103,
-0.0111163454,
0.0349910185,
-0.0266792662,
-0.0239936281,
0.0034996287,
0.040837165,
-0.0953550041,
-0.0031031673,
0.1011504754,
0.023133412,
0.0131266676,
0.0143433912,
0.0082380688,
0.0649226606,
-0.0167365707,
0.0037140462,
-0.0603359565,
-0.0658332855,
0.0211589225,
0.0279840119,
0.0361700021,
-0.0167067256,
0.0257710889,
-0.0909901187,
0.0106859589,
0.0167819466,
0.0200797822,
-0.0571652018,
-0.0386857167,
-0.0035418249,
-0.014521067,
0.0090561034,
-0.0111642685,
-0.0024775323,
0.0016689252,
0.0328538045,
-0.0196355004,
-0.0668816566,
0.0041470146,
-0.0469204932,
0.0547213107,
0.0503867269,
0.0359722413,
0.010980878,
-0.0632513538,
-0.0105104949,
0.0012904278,
-0.0163093843,
-0.0058348035,
0.0544832461,
-0.0002048295,
0.0007165479,
-0.0028584686,
0.0186218284,
-0.0234787948,
-0.0090136928,
-0.0289370567,
0.0700003952,
0.0216615256,
-0.0247837063,
-0.0057483451,
-0.0256252009,
-0.0297014322,
0.1160134897,
0.0455790013,
-0.0019034249,
-0.0556278974,
-0.0054414868,
0.0067101992,
-0.0388143957,
-0.0400005952,
0.0245150868,
-0.012512953,
-0.0436973386,
-0.0380741879,
-0.0016789727,
0.0326508135,
0.0229937118,
-0.002649995,
-0.0384414196,
0.0403600149,
0.0279018097,
-0.0806135833,
0.0382940508,
-0.000476604,
-0.0094979014,
-0.0474416614,
0.0080270255,
0.0082219085,
0.0157854762,
-0.0403730273,
0.0258610453,
-0.1050405726,
-0.0546891913,
0.0340281986,
0.0425841473,
0.0271986052,
0.0460874029,
-0.0247435644,
-0.0492899716,
0.059322264,
0.0346312262,
-0.0293359905,
-0.0010380045,
0.0330549851,
-0.0611060373,
0.0071471496,
0.0458795652,
-0.0262316819,
0.0104271816,
-0.0011469497,
0.0725405961,
-0.0237392355,
0.0026830437,
0.0287093185,
0.0233815871,
0.0346821658,
0.0229583196,
0.0224312227,
0.0099974899,
0.045149494,
0.0272920262,
0.0141274091,
-0.0590677895,
-0.0003913711,
0.0422018357,
0.0177072529,
0.015920788,
0.0231932644,
0.0538310483,
-0.0317746364,
-0.027265111,
0.0007927817,
-0.0058053695,
-0.0189672075,
0.0454106331,
0.0076900162,
-0.015027849,
0.0024643787,
0.0072245053,
-0.0043272907,
-0.0352624618,
0.0141965076,
0.0278456043,
0.0277510099,
-0.0161047317,
0.0386506505,
-0.0381188914,
-0.060452424,
-0.0698968917,
0.0092983609,
0.0069990018,
0.0027225909,
0.0515368879,
-0.0433813669,
-0.0241414234,
-0.0099736098,
-0.019571241,
-0.0153315598,
0.0216696113,
0.0061130268,
0.0127547877,
0.0033271476,
-0.0255937334,
0.1108853891,
-0.0023656485,
0.0620585345,
-0.0222988129,
-0.0239848401,
-0.0357437767,
-0.0274401959,
0.0219675507,
0.0120937778,
0.0035687631,
-0.0047487514,
-0.0447364673,
-0.0695637092,
0.0146481255,
-0.0113146771,
0.0102475816,
-0.0322047584,
0.0600792579,
0.0318429582,
-0.0059298235,
-0.0603465401,
0.02352014,
-0.0218134709,
-0.0235201977,
-0.0243826807,
0.02764876,
-6.364390167e-33,
-0.0193800684,
0.0339047574,
-0.0111312065,
-0.0037079824,
-0.042881649,
0.0327954292,
-0.0288019031,
-0.0321305208,
-0.0239599589,
0.0308453441,
0.000939194,
0.0467869714,
0.0161306243,
0.0511592701,
-0.0248262975,
0.0080263885,
0.1002494469,
-0.0004475867,
-0.0288313404,
0.027878033,
-0.0099086976,
0.0426010229,
0.0400760472,
-0.0050222548,
-0.057157632,
0.0174956974,
0.003694074,
0.025901651,
0.0296248011,
0.0563421436,
-0.0367597416,
0.0262194015,
-0.0074353735,
-0.0596257076,
-0.0374178663,
0.013956422,
-0.1204385608,
-0.0182942208,
0.0252275057,
-0.0112867299,
-0.034404356,
-0.0344516225,
0.0546033122,
0.0203521959,
0.0222052541,
-0.0466971956,
0.0006193086,
0.0062123151,
-0.0257436056,
-0.0419570766,
-0.0361229256,
0.0213821717,
-0.0251934845,
-0.0587195083,
0.0490952842,
0.002198254,
-0.0145539958,
0.0131888185,
-0.0822521448,
-0.0266112071,
0.0522716232,
0.0852346718,
0.0433191657,
0.0077672983,
-0.0191476103,
0.0500337034,
-0.0247617066,
-0.0060509574,
-0.0159906428,
-0.0318472274,
0.0564962626,
0.0890197083,
0.0553935207,
-0.0130914217,
0.0562541373,
-0.0048126434,
-0.0376834795,
0.0060637956,
0.0083851898,
0.0697019249,
0.0067612771,
0.0109375948,
0.0024105536,
-0.0030039095,
-0.0334878974,
-0.0185387898,
-0.0199235324,
0.0050879768,
0.0203405693,
-0.002129531,
-0.03853257,
0.0217000544,
0.0378932841,
-0.0486669801,
0.0460068807,
0.0216519479,
0.0017060244,
0.031662859,
0.0091449339,
0.0390249863,
-0.0830769762,
0.0141688911,
0.0218800604,
0.0144885741,
0.0131608453,
0.024757823,
0.0399161503,
0.0360840186,
-0.0523872562,
-0.0228477549,
-0.0469496995,
-0.0134754395,
-0.0132955825,
0.0211119037,
0.0333000645,
0.0117146969,
0.0079695461,
-0.0426964983,
0.0310135968,
0.0304642413,
0.0024914038,
0.0367722623,
0.0495759584,
0.0243982915,
0.0066872137,
-0.014748306,
-0.0554151386,
0.0190675762,
0.0122136725,
-0.0568982922,
-0.0313798375,
0.0144241396,
2.643e-7,
0.0431507565,
0.0493669175,
0.0439196154,
-0.0121952472,
0.0098162573,
0.0159281194,
0.0184407234,
0.0408277884,
0.0098199816,
-0.0238898154,
0.0022447438,
0.0135354633,
0.049386356,
0.0027239725,
-0.085254848,
-0.0296501443,
-0.0491418354,
-0.0317619033,
-0.021289153,
-0.0175590012,
0.0254258774,
0.0955747515,
0.00706357,
-0.017303098,
0.0127728628,
-0.017294921,
0.0454500951,
-0.0071559437,
0.0423664004,
0.0226965006,
0.0497729704,
0.0065116193,
-0.0051022125,
0.0199491661,
-0.0201940127,
0.0218670703,
0.005070474,
0.0607725233,
-0.029274065,
-0.0308477953,
-0.0120595815,
-0.0222728793,
-0.0196624678,
-0.0643598139,
0.0461094491,
-0.0630164742,
-0.0210151169,
0.0374048948,
-0.0378532149,
-0.0015056938,
0.0057054376,
-0.017897401,
-0.0134739764,
0.0069616609,
0.0219939966,
-0.0103100045,
-0.0355548412,
-0.0796524957,
-0.0264813229,
0.0030055451,
-0.0475375839,
-0.0456275903,
-0.0445887521,
-0.0627697781,
0.0304241944,
-0.0709798932,
-0.0078270175,
2.701330788e-34,
0.0088378424,
-0.0033880114,
0.016195653,
0.0389301255,
0.0186260622,
-0.0382391773,
0.0023395394,
-0.0063321185,
-0.0237605218,
-0.088136591,
-0.028249504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13916v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13916v4 | Exploring Large Language Models for Knowledge Graph Completion | 2023-08-26T16:51:17 | 2024-02-18T07:35:34 | Liang Yao, Jiazhen Peng, Chengsheng Mao, Yuan Luo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge graphs play a vital role in numerous artificial intelligence tasks,
yet they frequently face the issue of incompleteness. In this study, we explore
utilizing Large Language Models (LLM) for knowledge graph completion. We
consider triples in knowledge graphs as text sequences and introduce an
innovative framework called Knowledge Graph LLM (KG-LLM) to model these
triples. Our technique employs entity and relation descriptions of a triple as
prompts and utilizes the response for predictions. Experiments on various
benchmark knowledge graphs demonstrate that our method attains state-of-the-art
performance in tasks such as triple classification and relation prediction. We
also find that fine-tuning relatively smaller models (e.g., LLaMA-7B,
ChatGLM-6B) outperforms recent ChatGPT and GPT-4. | [
0.0603745133,
0.0276460014,
0.0054832851,
0.0573771335,
-0.0358622223,
-0.0066812001,
-0.0553267747,
0.0150500461,
0.0992236808,
-0.0576555431,
0.0322494991,
-0.0169142205,
0.0101937037,
0.0033523992,
0.0121677713,
-0.0318510011,
0.02139269,
-0.0182822626,
0.0120726377,
-0.0233246665,
-0.0143214809,
0.0524750873,
0.030022027,
0.0037333439,
-0.0077346466,
0.0120218676,
-0.0239683352,
0.0038992641,
-0.0424596854,
-0.0355062149,
-0.0139923012,
0.0451053269,
0.0018813754,
-0.0188274477,
0.0000016487,
-0.060870409,
-0.0085148262,
-0.0091047091,
-0.0224001743,
-0.0030532766,
-0.014003492,
-0.012451998,
0.0743519813,
0.018528251,
-0.0591465905,
-0.0234385505,
0.0072364733,
0.0477560721,
0.0099341283,
0.0560300983,
-0.0118283611,
-0.0275831763,
0.0405381732,
-0.0461075567,
0.0316350386,
-0.0276784878,
0.0785879195,
0.0236838423,
0.046312701,
0.0237681586,
-0.0148754092,
0.0071898978,
0.0064241518,
0.0144374203,
0.0378113203,
0.0301912222,
-0.0333989672,
-0.0076522781,
0.0235750601,
0.0813023597,
0.005650844,
0.0138282981,
-0.003791105,
0.0038416325,
0.0167035107,
0.0158851836,
-0.0182291344,
-0.0302690249,
-0.0521711633,
-0.0033776292,
-0.0288530085,
-0.0461605005,
0.0585930347,
0.010635158,
-0.0436369479,
0.0736369342,
0.0085050827,
-0.0216943193,
0.0082536368,
0.0162772126,
-0.0215586927,
-0.0570900589,
-0.0015687172,
0.0432456695,
-0.0467510447,
0.0288430471,
-0.0290071908,
0.0168907475,
0.0226721279,
-0.0254181307,
-0.0370953716,
0.0141616408,
0.0040946542,
0.0626962781,
-0.0545983352,
0.0090702558,
-0.0032800939,
-0.0120249921,
-0.0521080792,
-0.0265346635,
-0.0369801857,
0.0121883638,
-0.0320808589,
0.0647657067,
-0.0181880351,
-0.0504394099,
-0.0527063869,
0.0364107229,
0.0037112033,
0.0615727939,
0.0386290066,
0.0186717808,
0.012587185,
-0.0087981708,
-0.0296919458,
0.019458618,
-0.0183335822,
0.0277170576,
-0.0199889746,
0.0084754517,
0.0034938555,
-0.0112627419,
0.0282960478,
-0.0331234559,
0.0299556646,
0.0758324116,
0.0234305281,
-0.0639998093,
-0.03239353,
-0.0589507446,
-0.0178684834,
-0.0783635452,
0.0065989434,
-0.0626300499,
0.0607978739,
0.0422143005,
0.001270843,
-0.0171016995,
0.0477575958,
0.0058988505,
-0.0571364537,
0.0624484532,
-0.0164408777,
-0.003777338,
-0.0323846005,
0.025253918,
-0.0183798168,
0.0313124731,
0.0009684985,
0.0363167599,
0.0430265032,
-0.0063358899,
-0.0175497327,
0.0472581796,
0.0546922982,
0.0170744713,
0.025219705,
0.0135645559,
0.0013660274,
0.0418079719,
-0.0101020299,
0.0633845702,
0.0042914008,
-0.0203526914,
0.030039208,
0.0354800411,
0.0012261475,
0.028617505,
0.0592101701,
-0.0094867134,
-0.0023683023,
0.0175522044,
-0.0346937776,
-0.0147102168,
-0.0554217212,
0.0411883257,
0.0496554486,
0.037310034,
-0.0116310036,
-0.0102814296,
0.0021778732,
-0.0349729247,
0.0396696143,
0.0258401893,
0.0662561283,
0.0190605223,
-0.0457103178,
0.0148490313,
0.0540158376,
-0.009823855,
0.019207485,
-0.0010928088,
0.0399120264,
0.0821380094,
0.0463614389,
-0.0155633688,
-0.0244185589,
0.0093862303,
-0.0040073185,
-0.0197977908,
0.0299150739,
-0.0285596997,
-0.0323072076,
-0.0361042246,
-0.0530705638,
0.0353169292,
-0.0217116997,
0.0239252578,
0.0699801371,
0.0197354946,
0.025658926,
-0.0708090216,
0.0233245101,
0.0024856441,
-0.0353532135,
0.0014600656,
0.0280823838,
0.018066803,
0.0360648185,
0.0350842439,
0.0311076343,
0.0052593728,
0.0383274667,
-0.0253543463,
-0.0814643055,
-0.0425070897,
-0.007874894,
-0.0690850765,
0.0634520128,
0.0487009175,
-0.0017809481,
-0.0241482574,
-0.0376991779,
-0.0455680117,
0.0093393195,
-0.0277969651,
0.0805870742,
-0.0001111392,
0.0040389202,
0.047466889,
-0.0020179097,
-0.0166962948,
0.0855316073,
-0.0275100544,
0.0149812745,
0.0048196199,
-0.0451396443,
-0.0071367952,
0.0118189808,
-0.0367171206,
0.0354418382,
0.0354835242,
0.0131639941,
0.0414776243,
-0.0155249154,
-0.0460032411,
-0.0079944665,
-0.1005453989,
0.0059689623,
0.0174076762,
0.0223436151,
-0.0538671166,
0.0182661433,
0.0216067359,
-0.0123802116,
-0.0438613519,
0.0217509475,
-0.0185266957,
0.0190020055,
0.0163792353,
0.0304680727,
-0.0480541997,
-0.0008699215,
-0.027615888,
-0.0096180812,
0.0874245986,
-0.0081318188,
-0.0460867584,
0.0040675621,
0.0328655243,
-0.0590028465,
0.0318684764,
-0.025345495,
0.0285685472,
-0.02840917,
-0.0432335958,
0.0374136157,
0.0041081859,
-0.0355132557,
0.0070050042,
0.0276422165,
0.0141040813,
-0.0292077865,
-0.0005400153,
-0.0667379126,
-0.011305498,
-0.0498891175,
0.0043099988,
-0.0526776426,
0.0007201925,
-0.0048293364,
-0.016599277,
-0.0705968067,
-0.0071691424,
0.0249625426,
0.0248327907,
-0.0298954993,
-0.0042543048,
0.0198106058,
-0.0113145895,
-0.0292720422,
-0.0036672021,
0.0921859369,
-0.0299049225,
0.0057735243,
0.0199032314,
0.0076170899,
-0.0513568074,
0.0842196569,
0.0130323656,
0.0228710696,
0.0090264995,
-0.0140434019,
-0.0298208352,
-0.0141493995,
0.0241506752,
-0.0387701802,
0.0361085869,
-0.0117110088,
0.0368092284,
0.0256715659,
-0.0034072311,
-0.0041638017,
-0.0061482484,
-0.0442464128,
0.0266845431,
0.0014824852,
-0.0344989374,
0.0056390534,
-0.011880694,
0.0047856793,
-0.0026117242,
0.0028796089,
-0.0170957036,
-0.0321320221,
0.0426510014,
0.0447380319,
-0.0284026358,
-0.0145133911,
-0.0179428626,
0.0067330939,
0.0578966253,
0.0157130528,
0.0142009947,
-0.0142380539,
0.0052224277,
0.0304657631,
-0.0358398631,
-0.0476040021,
0.0202839151,
-0.0195648354,
-0.0352133326,
0.0421022512,
0.1112613678,
-0.0029193799,
-0.0400796533,
0.0152231557,
0.0406100973,
0.0109140836,
0.0378124975,
0.0023753194,
-0.1106989607,
-0.0203748755,
-0.0086445799,
-0.0052209436,
0.0424974449,
-0.0683184341,
-0.005667625,
-0.0968798399,
-0.0038333656,
0.0153691163,
-0.005586463,
-0.0537219793,
-0.0575853102,
0.0066255438,
0.0129742334,
-0.0544966012,
-0.0240784828,
-0.0293264035,
-0.0145354271,
0.0049088039,
-0.0001465782,
-0.048206158,
0.0507107303,
-0.0137329195,
0.0350334905,
0.0052059223,
0.0038129527,
-0.0197800938,
0.0153058041,
0.0023977475,
0.033387132,
-0.0274371244,
-0.0106645459,
0.0097020939,
-0.0249463487,
-0.0010228339,
-0.02564843,
0.0032927922,
-0.0590797774,
-0.0084341858,
0.0146562839,
0.1158745438,
0.0032637818,
-0.0582171008,
0.0015695677,
-0.0121255238,
0.0056183324,
0.0472255945,
0.0017875747,
-0.0123445559,
0.0135961901,
-0.0035026977,
-0.0001036471,
0.0092402231,
0.0046905279,
0.0169580039,
-0.043376673,
0.0259208698,
-0.0299534667,
-0.0493056141,
0.0790579468,
-0.0027567346,
0.0112857427,
0.0575227104,
0.0525011905,
-0.0115683759,
-0.0389261656,
-0.0004172141,
-0.0173270088,
0.0215649065,
0.0056325956,
0.0203364212,
0.0128431544,
-0.0438587815,
-0.0157144628,
-0.0253000464,
-0.0810363367,
-0.0629803464,
-0.0694291666,
0.0560587682,
0.0099337837,
0.0598815978,
-0.0088213701,
-0.0312254466,
0.0253344253,
0.0556269847,
-0.022970615,
0.0210043322,
-0.0110879866,
0.0074868528,
-0.0073189479,
0.0421726331,
-0.0519227311,
-0.0068094227,
-0.0174022112,
0.0632434487,
-0.0522447713,
-0.0620089695,
0.022832578,
0.0442399383,
-0.0030470921,
-0.0043293224,
0.0195690878,
-0.0251572393,
0.0209947266,
-0.0169118848,
-0.0317134894,
-0.0512595028,
-0.0372181498,
0.0273947362,
-0.0190543365,
0.0130898692,
-0.0708937868,
0.0095070405,
0.0327544995,
-0.0069380892,
-0.049579028,
0.0050475583,
-0.0419918448,
0.1001309082,
-0.0254744999,
-0.0272366274,
0.0404986329,
-0.0019641628,
-0.0073763449,
-0.0421321057,
0.0297476966,
-0.0000450614,
-0.0110778669,
-0.0051229941,
-0.0211848058,
-0.0038006133,
-0.017459495,
-0.0302017089,
0.0666022897,
0.0748960003,
0.0277443193,
0.023909675,
-0.0342451222,
-0.0291961245,
-0.0280033462,
0.0418150611,
-0.026623236,
-0.0537193157,
0.0397520363,
0.0274932701,
-0.0329293199,
0.0124181174,
0.0796719864,
0.0283510238,
0.0673817396,
0.0398249701,
-0.0616782084,
-0.0337301865,
-0.0638718084,
0.0162361786,
0.0315507129,
-0.0297197253,
0.0358122364,
-0.0424604118,
-0.0862343982,
-0.0089361286,
-0.0366570018,
-0.0492441319,
0.0111145033,
0.015015861,
0.0541307218,
0.0290384181,
-0.0360687301,
-0.0516636893,
-0.0019510132,
-0.0609207377,
-0.0310565606,
0.0329585224,
-5.565374698e-33,
-0.0221410207,
-0.0620831661,
0.0499325842,
0.0224574581,
-0.0251548849,
0.004941632,
-0.0208621137,
0.0065037645,
-0.0192257185,
0.0164545495,
-0.0110751279,
-0.0058591557,
-0.0153755499,
0.0301930811,
0.0055709253,
-0.0134442439,
0.0286832452,
0.0205246694,
0.0278628543,
0.0274347886,
0.0230223965,
0.0214244053,
0.037715815,
-0.0621735193,
0.0249217618,
-0.0354851522,
0.0065169791,
0.0069924034,
-0.0271464549,
0.0503140464,
-0.0247162264,
0.0602215864,
0.0190634821,
-0.0030589106,
0.0159997903,
-0.0226476565,
-0.0864792764,
-0.0354392752,
0.0229701791,
0.0005996784,
-0.0523688719,
-0.0106357234,
0.0201093238,
-0.0102975648,
0.0707018897,
-0.0438358448,
0.0299726669,
-0.0194671601,
-0.0848221779,
-0.0633076951,
-0.0132017313,
0.0246363487,
0.0198569335,
-0.0118162595,
0.0242063012,
0.0105317915,
0.0331565961,
-0.0251679812,
-0.0117819142,
-0.0072385781,
-0.0141802765,
0.0086829579,
-0.0015719146,
-0.0019237141,
0.0013226555,
0.0348389558,
-0.0344494916,
0.0001844463,
-0.0366913825,
0.0007023189,
-0.0391418487,
0.0662068576,
-0.0439089984,
0.0170057099,
-0.0585930347,
-0.0143876243,
-0.0596048199,
-0.0205152407,
0.0177633446,
0.0309278537,
0.0061673024,
-0.023884913,
-0.0329719037,
-0.0363291316,
-0.0514933094,
0.0104894182,
-0.0341574885,
-0.0459121875,
0.0056484984,
0.0231303666,
0.0193828586,
0.0024899989,
-0.0175945666,
-0.0602264963,
-0.0350989141,
0.0717168674,
-0.0148775121,
-0.0115809739,
-0.0157992635,
0.0462796316,
-0.0356853455,
-0.0406217538,
0.0012099437,
-0.0691124201,
-0.0177924726,
0.0278207846,
0.0154488729,
0.00046924,
-0.0432464816,
-0.0147502907,
-0.034031447,
-0.0071484395,
-0.001757732,
-0.0098698242,
0.0648280233,
0.058737725,
0.0061401636,
0.0450181738,
0.037571121,
0.026969295,
-0.0047190432,
-0.0044769123,
0.0270998161,
-0.0033096045,
0.0008177375,
-0.00712081,
-0.0309503134,
-0.0070456993,
0.0212494135,
-0.0162089076,
-0.0095650619,
0.0040918505,
2.513e-7,
0.0263156835,
0.0441739745,
-0.0074297753,
0.0798563436,
-0.0271884613,
0.0309167206,
0.0144518325,
0.053648103,
0.0056286342,
-0.0056002946,
0.0455566645,
0.001597975,
-0.0193604622,
0.0363598987,
-0.1062453836,
-0.0008408893,
-0.0471597016,
-0.0311955586,
-0.0834324881,
-0.0163844191,
0.0806395784,
0.0707259551,
0.0704570189,
-0.0002864263,
-0.0234425161,
-0.0704771504,
0.0762799829,
-0.0098559652,
-0.028982522,
0.040327739,
0.0384826921,
0.0519130044,
0.006334994,
0.0906068683,
0.0068311878,
0.029288549,
0.0241660532,
0.0652275458,
0.0093038715,
0.016790418,
0.0124624455,
-0.0087958621,
0.0069078337,
-0.0366435535,
0.0803794637,
-0.0454885997,
0.00600392,
0.0190497041,
-0.0428931452,
-0.0554626733,
0.0077277133,
0.0112178288,
0.0350095443,
-0.0020564438,
0.014226784,
0.0050980812,
0.0037491971,
-0.0704872236,
0.0163064562,
0.0254660044,
-0.0179414339,
-0.0327490345,
-0.0023822524,
-0.0298435204,
-0.0086728828,
-0.0647548214,
0.0316713192,
2.355530197e-34,
0.031224845,
-0.0093962988,
0.0095253019,
0.004850409,
0.0154007664,
-0.0417010412,
0.0011252546,
0.0184833761,
0.0223474614,
-0.1070654318,
-0.0112902233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13911v1 | A Wide Evaluation of ChatGPT on Affective Computing Tasks | 2023-08-26T16:10:30 | 2023-08-26T16:10:30 | Mostafa M. Amin, Rui Mao, Erik Cambria, Björn W. Schuller | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | With the rise of foundation models, a new artificial intelligence paradigm
has emerged, by simply using general purpose foundation models with prompting
to solve problems instead of training a separate machine learning model for
each problem. Such models have been shown to have emergent properties of
solving problems that they were not initially trained on. The studies for the
effectiveness of such models are still quite limited. In this work, we widely
study the capabilities of the ChatGPT models, namely GPT-4 and GPT-3.5, on 13
affective computing problems, namely aspect extraction, aspect polarity
classification, opinion extraction, sentiment analysis, sentiment intensity
ranking, emotions intensity ranking, suicide tendency detection, toxicity
detection, well-being assessment, engagement measurement, personality
assessment, sarcasm detection, and subjectivity detection. We introduce a
framework to evaluate the ChatGPT models on regression-based problems, such as
intensity ranking problems, by modelling them as pairwise ranking
classification. We compare ChatGPT against more traditional NLP methods, such
as end-to-end recurrent neural networks and transformers. The results
demonstrate the emergent abilities of the ChatGPT models on a wide range of
affective computing problems, where GPT-3.5 and especially GPT-4 have shown
strong performance on many problems, particularly the ones related to
sentiment, emotions, or toxicity. The ChatGPT models fell short for problems
with implicit signals, such as engagement measurement and subjectivity
detection. | [
0.0460790507,
0.0301761646,
-0.0247814283,
0.02510418,
-0.0332560465,
0.0264590345,
-0.0179412942,
-0.0284414273,
0.0505611971,
-0.0309455041,
-0.0177507214,
0.0081218239,
-0.0525987186,
0.0256972238,
-0.0344256759,
-0.0672074333,
0.0227837916,
0.0696780309,
0.0336211994,
0.0087278048,
0.0162736475,
0.0500302501,
-0.0066548935,
0.0347943977,
-0.0048317723,
-0.0251794476,
0.0104644047,
0.0105606373,
0.0423118994,
-0.0452187471,
0.031842757,
0.0197549332,
-0.0106717842,
-0.0118235806,
0.0000020499,
-0.0083451085,
-0.0154770222,
-0.023290785,
0.0196999107,
-0.0489328802,
0.0897415951,
0.0162109118,
-0.0181705263,
0.0211740006,
-0.0440321714,
-0.0129205501,
0.0405944064,
0.0776123405,
0.0876776427,
0.0831965655,
-0.0261395779,
-0.0115393773,
0.0242140424,
-0.005851422,
0.0101484088,
-0.0070064561,
0.012987826,
0.0059136632,
-0.0075030825,
0.017408533,
-0.0212312508,
-0.0082238056,
0.0002113816,
0.0394574814,
0.001758705,
0.0030748164,
-0.0054640481,
-0.0108034285,
-0.0316200629,
0.037224438,
-0.0128322048,
0.0101289218,
0.0178635791,
-0.0061326693,
0.0101034455,
-0.0479356386,
-0.0110314842,
-0.0243773423,
-0.0084303068,
0.010824576,
0.0269917473,
0.0455413386,
-0.0034195022,
0.0143614169,
0.0496174879,
0.0290689375,
-0.0251665581,
-0.0452203453,
0.0427008905,
0.0305488352,
-0.0165450834,
-0.0087031359,
0.0156721007,
-0.0026573827,
0.0357961655,
0.0204161461,
0.0049974341,
0.0036482417,
-0.0251785293,
-0.0789316073,
-0.0322379991,
0.0501069464,
-0.0356251784,
0.0122436183,
0.0283083599,
0.0172725655,
0.0275774952,
-0.0403580181,
-0.0249647032,
0.0305024721,
-0.0840849951,
0.0195421651,
-0.0067681498,
0.0706414059,
-0.0228524506,
-0.0335937031,
-0.0813666061,
0.0247567613,
-0.0091464669,
-0.0305230822,
0.0266566072,
0.0093360348,
-0.0002044463,
0.0249378216,
-0.0034184505,
0.0349278562,
-0.0277839415,
-0.0051248888,
-0.0272971559,
-0.035183195,
0.0240640771,
0.0102149704,
-0.0035353857,
-0.0281452872,
0.0346885175,
0.0527050458,
0.0289631374,
-0.0520530939,
-0.0524029694,
0.0060116835,
-0.0204913225,
-0.0454052947,
0.0046848636,
-0.0194091946,
0.0309206117,
-0.0016965927,
0.0050651538,
-0.0250382088,
0.0249980353,
-0.0124309855,
-0.0159331262,
0.0544640943,
0.0225779042,
-0.0367221124,
0.0086855404,
0.0088865189,
-0.0037468683,
0.0363614,
0.0119157787,
0.0731943473,
0.0304691438,
-0.0135911722,
0.0360595733,
0.0044832318,
-0.0127209332,
-0.0438612439,
0.0200690497,
-0.0401952825,
-0.0635807291,
0.0061841677,
-0.0193532091,
0.0392443091,
-0.0217469167,
-0.0122696934,
0.0432549454,
0.0204861853,
-0.0086737871,
0.1021331996,
0.0055837813,
0.0062069502,
-0.000417014,
0.0009084251,
-0.022581026,
0.0315324031,
-0.0466563776,
-0.0185190998,
-0.02004507,
0.0145396478,
-0.0359581895,
-0.0828327686,
-0.0209176335,
-0.0178015232,
0.0288796257,
-0.0113938842,
0.0385426618,
-0.0213554725,
-0.0592264459,
-0.0332044996,
0.0206153467,
-0.0665736198,
-0.028346708,
-0.0447281115,
0.0072017964,
0.06696444,
0.0198780131,
-0.0475461707,
-0.0331724174,
-0.0184641592,
-0.0445827246,
0.0179772899,
0.0226196405,
-0.0011968847,
0.0055252286,
-0.0443383344,
0.0385766365,
0.015080261,
-0.0098290537,
0.023138253,
-0.0099220751,
0.0405736715,
-0.0183231831,
0.0156807527,
0.0105643896,
-0.0003521167,
-0.0137653202,
-0.0386582576,
0.0329230465,
0.0171455424,
0.0580722615,
0.0323778801,
0.0099322945,
-0.0372092985,
0.0133779543,
-0.0055253059,
-0.0882315859,
0.042787347,
-0.0241026785,
-0.055882208,
0.0103186313,
-0.0053881891,
0.0154268797,
0.0385065489,
-0.0400042646,
-0.0004301427,
0.0444966294,
-0.0275594387,
-0.0057309265,
-0.036147479,
0.0080319019,
-0.0111443168,
0.0210816711,
-0.0184575599,
0.0709184557,
-0.0198392663,
-0.0114706894,
-0.0295863859,
-0.0406551659,
-0.0160389598,
-0.0176363215,
-0.0707104504,
-0.0180524811,
0.0101282131,
0.0119621791,
0.0079535041,
0.0087932497,
-0.046278175,
-0.0697204471,
-0.1264478564,
0.0405319408,
0.0119435741,
0.0168709271,
0.0003256141,
-0.0101458821,
-0.0112101333,
0.0161478892,
-0.0493198819,
0.0008909199,
0.0082009304,
0.019265255,
0.0233564265,
0.0040154732,
0.0298827812,
-0.0696806014,
-0.0046375375,
-0.0414434224,
-0.0093337782,
-0.0094476305,
-0.05073376,
-0.0061098915,
0.0365677662,
-0.0606484227,
0.0247123055,
-0.014005702,
-0.0728080273,
-0.0038000145,
0.0026405256,
0.0264681075,
0.0695504695,
0.0205471721,
0.113123998,
-0.0403646231,
-0.0158832315,
-0.0126976734,
0.0540783629,
-0.0621821582,
0.0110294856,
0.0134276794,
-0.0204134136,
-0.025824016,
0.0587600321,
0.0133156357,
0.0075896089,
-0.0701036081,
0.0285180882,
-0.0181793272,
0.018612273,
0.0200902112,
0.0054126233,
0.0048274845,
-0.0308777746,
0.0101149846,
-0.0160357039,
0.0579934865,
0.0427227765,
-0.0221029166,
-0.0724054202,
-0.0110684521,
-0.0423756056,
0.0512070768,
-0.0275348406,
0.0072964597,
0.0086438861,
-0.0045466814,
-0.0118583469,
-0.0548416525,
-0.0117818983,
-0.0582290925,
-0.0187265594,
0.0019306253,
-0.0187209509,
0.0292830244,
-0.0734880567,
-0.0185321663,
-0.0285467952,
-0.0327254348,
-0.0241561886,
-0.0014522709,
0.0126574356,
0.002289352,
0.0019177949,
0.0122538274,
-0.0568709485,
-0.0306772795,
-0.0391414575,
0.0338712558,
0.0218812339,
0.0416117609,
-0.0281838235,
0.0370468237,
0.0022285611,
0.0375558436,
0.0419401377,
-0.0189202297,
0.0045339759,
-0.0112303486,
0.022157399,
-0.0114432937,
0.0017934911,
-0.025049977,
-0.0300139003,
0.0008747873,
-0.0254198182,
0.0139117595,
0.1330242306,
0.0199997444,
-0.0292730927,
-0.0017684685,
0.010811545,
-0.0500668846,
0.0151018603,
0.0067312554,
-0.0350968204,
-0.013669258,
-0.0300922953,
0.0383618958,
-0.044984702,
-0.030588869,
0.0114483619,
-0.0877145156,
0.0394861586,
0.0026847653,
-0.0091140456,
-0.0062605594,
0.0106048761,
0.0131193791,
-0.0521745235,
-0.0331056267,
-0.0587759539,
0.0055621574,
-0.001612616,
0.0209707636,
-0.035047736,
-0.0153699713,
0.0313796215,
0.020704044,
0.0433329754,
0.0341098607,
0.0939386487,
-0.0107326768,
-0.0140564069,
0.0275298655,
-0.0132104419,
0.0117437253,
-0.0323808566,
0.0630389452,
-0.0390153565,
-0.0152028268,
-0.027686337,
0.0236790162,
-0.0269308388,
0.0518710092,
-0.0128263989,
0.0628750548,
-0.0076366272,
-0.0362463221,
-0.030450169,
0.0399170667,
0.041705288,
0.0592026636,
-0.0024276979,
-0.0731516406,
-0.0280226301,
-0.0124494974,
0.0298208185,
-0.0071958438,
-0.0826622248,
-0.0451922119,
0.0241278131,
-0.0281956866,
-0.0665162131,
-0.0685747936,
-0.0117034055,
0.0053686365,
-0.0361207575,
-0.038601052,
0.011884219,
0.0432055444,
-0.0361298211,
0.0008100682,
0.0417235084,
-0.0205777362,
-0.0155663276,
-0.0049679009,
0.0710120946,
-0.0350159034,
-0.0318056233,
-0.0068519916,
-0.0273842141,
-0.0303039905,
0.0315157138,
0.0700560734,
0.0180605445,
-0.0341057107,
-0.0258371104,
-0.0057580285,
-0.0098983757,
0.0499704778,
-0.0168949571,
0.0080961902,
0.0552885607,
0.0844051465,
0.0016295729,
0.0043572458,
-0.0133622475,
0.0985689461,
0.0150002101,
-0.0275534354,
-0.0141704846,
-0.0303826034,
-0.0156919006,
0.0145595167,
0.0552979596,
0.0522298701,
-0.0436476879,
-0.0111915106,
-0.0441501662,
0.0023427061,
-0.0150177535,
-0.0382650718,
-0.0286953785,
-0.0021403104,
0.0342820324,
-0.0840469077,
-0.0468849763,
0.0134490067,
-0.0136033101,
-0.0588549823,
0.0127833672,
0.0394330099,
0.0075497287,
-0.0354388058,
0.0331385769,
-0.0459886119,
-0.0124023156,
0.032126274,
-0.0008218498,
-0.0129549969,
0.0722549036,
-0.001598788,
0.0130833294,
0.023935739,
0.0759330764,
-0.0300104171,
0.0148572046,
-0.0572879873,
0.0276991781,
0.0167830773,
0.0159855504,
0.0252023991,
-0.0362352729,
0.0199063513,
-0.007204921,
0.0114563443,
0.0019685554,
-0.01148347,
-0.0083772596,
0.0059287762,
-0.0244887695,
-0.0169463176,
0.0208568517,
-0.0864250287,
0.0397873521,
0.0484488942,
-0.0273740832,
-0.0370639227,
0.0203178711,
0.0206793826,
-0.0166153274,
0.0474890359,
0.0571134128,
-0.0665752962,
-0.0395581685,
0.0765556619,
-0.0278389975,
0.0217762738,
-0.0377278291,
0.0347123854,
0.0774242654,
-0.0093930634,
0.0359889008,
-0.0423359424,
0.0120274518,
-0.09702418,
-0.014868563,
-0.0178162158,
-6.039068799e-33,
-0.0196234286,
0.0157258343,
-0.035644833,
0.0664532632,
-0.0507339686,
0.0229621436,
-0.0202460885,
0.0391541198,
-0.0114737432,
0.0321030244,
-0.0101280082,
0.0514924079,
-0.0150483437,
0.0151289785,
0.015586555,
-0.027119305,
0.0285619572,
-0.0146137243,
0.0090757702,
0.0379308462,
0.050033424,
0.0397023596,
0.0639616996,
-0.1237427741,
0.0099934116,
0.0187857188,
-0.0242031924,
0.0007110198,
0.0368857272,
0.0534731075,
-0.0017756135,
0.0706300586,
0.0369924568,
-0.032210961,
0.0293629467,
-0.0047621788,
-0.0368727967,
-0.0608497895,
-0.0039670533,
-0.0269252341,
-0.0261530485,
-0.0182205942,
0.0224714242,
0.027387064,
-0.0443174653,
-0.0285758115,
0.0156193953,
-0.016252635,
0.0433830395,
-0.0718685165,
-0.0182263535,
0.013330237,
-0.0136656268,
-0.0282241646,
0.0152833797,
0.0363667943,
-0.0059865485,
0.0512882695,
-0.0267857704,
-0.0117109288,
-0.0504183918,
0.0008300951,
-0.0310020987,
-0.0572298206,
-0.0021431807,
0.0486371107,
-0.003846142,
0.0230274461,
-0.0286003556,
0.019378854,
-0.0042006141,
0.0416503623,
0.0769313425,
0.0316568688,
-0.0116967391,
-0.0325180441,
-0.0271149892,
0.042162396,
0.1007158011,
-0.0301147401,
0.0588907599,
-0.0187552851,
-0.0590900891,
0.006745914,
0.0329638161,
-0.0516673066,
-0.0304371566,
-0.0594059154,
0.0078404658,
-0.0146026658,
-0.0084183523,
-0.0076377206,
-0.0162467696,
-0.0297533497,
0.0424621813,
0.0456408262,
-0.0359319337,
0.0654169917,
0.0006509356,
0.0109642614,
-0.0438013785,
0.0089413105,
-0.0168189779,
0.0433943123,
0.0271994919,
-0.0124165043,
0.0121918526,
0.0353718624,
-0.0343487188,
-0.0282916576,
-0.0026071311,
0.0807064325,
-0.0244667996,
0.068804428,
-0.0403937735,
0.024421338,
0.0000438778,
0.0265500825,
0.0247938447,
0.0630954951,
-0.0372565426,
-0.030496018,
0.0060951789,
0.0020852671,
-0.0193418525,
-0.0334048644,
0.0258629471,
-0.0072944821,
-0.0576396398,
-0.0403163321,
-0.0213310346,
-0.0000943535,
2.873e-7,
0.0107899727,
0.0624558628,
0.0213251412,
0.0064897011,
0.0350211151,
0.0422049202,
0.0114029013,
0.0344169438,
0.0622527376,
-0.0249143261,
0.0521124043,
0.0181182195,
0.0345669799,
0.0320111029,
-0.0801178068,
0.004705708,
-0.0289963819,
0.0114693567,
-0.0138860205,
0.0433178768,
0.1098572239,
0.0749483481,
0.0515543148,
0.0182377286,
0.0132206064,
0.0641980395,
0.0342710912,
-0.0217691064,
-0.0142177418,
-0.0101792011,
-0.0041323816,
0.0116662262,
-0.0137026301,
-0.0183275919,
0.0167877395,
0.0072069657,
0.0393611006,
0.0481805168,
-0.0010690597,
-0.066131033,
0.043784067,
0.0460415222,
-0.0003253373,
-0.0151739819,
0.0637199283,
-0.0651040003,
-0.0355505645,
-0.0574972741,
-0.0350997187,
-0.0228728782,
0.0505213812,
0.0023075307,
-0.060861513,
0.0121884914,
0.0086589931,
-0.0187495984,
-0.0071597095,
-0.0858195275,
0.0252953395,
0.0009970035,
-0.0240677595,
-0.0489675067,
-0.0031818661,
0.0390275195,
0.0019057811,
-0.0307611525,
0.0039012576,
2.21296041e-34,
0.0224579927,
0.0069800601,
0.0164494254,
-0.0062068314,
0.0284447074,
0.0424510278,
-0.0224170946,
-0.0312692113,
0.0217387229,
-0.0380223617,
-0.001140363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13904v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13904v2 | LMSanitator: Defending Prompt-Tuning Against Task-Agnostic Backdoors | 2023-08-26T15:21:47 | 2023-10-14T15:07:37 | Chengkun Wei, Wenlong Meng, Zhikun Zhang, Min Chen, Minghu Zhao, Wenjing Fang, Lei Wang, Zihui Zhang, Wenzhi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Prompt-tuning has emerged as an attractive paradigm for deploying large-scale
language models due to its strong downstream task performance and efficient
multitask serving ability. Despite its wide adoption, we empirically show that
prompt-tuning is vulnerable to downstream task-agnostic backdoors, which reside
in the pretrained models and can affect arbitrary downstream tasks. The
state-of-the-art backdoor detection approaches cannot defend against
task-agnostic backdoors since they hardly converge in reversing the backdoor
triggers. To address this issue, we propose LMSanitator, a novel approach for
detecting and removing task-agnostic backdoors on Transformer models. Instead
of directly inverting the triggers, LMSanitator aims to invert the predefined
attack vectors (pretrained models' output when the input is embedded with
triggers) of the task-agnostic backdoors, which achieves much better
convergence performance and backdoor detection accuracy. LMSanitator further
leverages prompt-tuning's property of freezing the pretrained model to perform
accurate and fast output monitoring and input purging during the inference
phase. Extensive experiments on multiple language models and NLP tasks
illustrate the effectiveness of LMSanitator. For instance, LMSanitator achieves
92.8% backdoor detection accuracy on 960 models and decreases the attack
success rate to less than 1% in most scenarios. | [
0.0266390722,
0.0263561234,
-0.0135079622,
0.0432462655,
-0.0257667564,
-0.0041039307,
0.009142126,
-0.0185717326,
0.0069259671,
-0.0379462168,
-0.035316579,
0.0018410556,
0.0017002482,
0.0332257152,
0.0550193414,
0.0327103846,
0.0831404701,
-0.0312298108,
-0.0548426881,
0.0141312294,
-0.0292587169,
-0.0015929678,
0.0034104241,
0.0545986481,
0.0188329965,
-0.0269287303,
-0.0200081859,
-0.0014820892,
0.009609567,
0.006877834,
0.0140036214,
0.0360469222,
-0.0270980112,
0.0653218627,
0.0000020524,
-0.0160891805,
-0.0456249081,
-0.0040997341,
-0.0432749949,
0.0283811353,
-0.0254701357,
-0.0278100111,
-0.0425869673,
0.0380700715,
-0.0298295356,
-0.0076080551,
0.0326908492,
0.0504131019,
0.0828762278,
0.0808161795,
0.0015222672,
0.0375167802,
0.0566738322,
-0.0394670628,
-0.0562533177,
-0.0396600217,
0.0078934608,
-0.0761773214,
-0.0491642505,
0.0084238499,
-0.013896483,
0.0201064441,
0.0073412601,
-0.0081424275,
-0.0561854206,
0.0344978049,
0.0075746388,
-0.0327699594,
-0.0446975715,
0.0352623053,
-0.0768925995,
-0.0183817539,
0.0071384627,
-0.0251189694,
0.0022912829,
0.0220734421,
0.0209528711,
0.0281825978,
-0.0031976753,
-0.0116808778,
0.0229209419,
-0.0383961238,
0.044209674,
-0.0108105754,
-0.0088505624,
0.0602551363,
0.0330772884,
-0.0301464945,
0.0077126478,
-0.0109066265,
0.0009128209,
-0.0804398358,
0.0055585247,
0.0042337384,
-0.055283118,
0.0088481447,
-0.0542846173,
-0.0656779557,
0.0039763497,
-0.0190207921,
0.0174073,
0.0602312535,
-0.0407255366,
0.0043827677,
-0.0352448076,
0.0651428998,
-0.0488054343,
0.0364352427,
0.0154819833,
0.023429811,
-0.0148414439,
-0.0162207838,
-0.0547049083,
-0.0042812871,
-0.0264320336,
-0.0254852548,
0.0048768972,
0.0680431798,
-0.0045814398,
0.0070687924,
0.0303379539,
-0.0057936562,
-0.0524264239,
0.0256207511,
0.0416082814,
0.0295744184,
0.0176379159,
-0.0230048299,
0.0017348846,
-0.0908625126,
-0.0408403762,
-0.0164552964,
-0.039921362,
-0.0575734153,
-0.0098931938,
0.058870364,
0.0142197507,
-0.0195601024,
-0.0367194004,
-0.0534022078,
-0.0094754854,
-0.0234382302,
0.0064523951,
-0.0415544175,
-0.0298073888,
-0.0129923346,
0.0147924414,
-0.0198914092,
-0.0040940717,
0.0192235727,
-0.0313809589,
0.0622543879,
0.0107804555,
-0.0129743181,
-0.0070620277,
0.0100639872,
-0.0222038385,
0.0770788118,
-0.0054972945,
0.0360159948,
0.056078136,
-0.0333036408,
0.0060617756,
0.0674723983,
0.0111342836,
0.0331154093,
-0.0011238573,
-0.0193319321,
0.0464748479,
-0.0368862674,
0.0211503692,
0.0440612845,
0.0015322847,
-0.0105153844,
0.0718484148,
0.0107653355,
-0.0059993761,
0.0160641372,
0.028973097,
-0.013221737,
-0.0622626953,
0.0432631187,
-0.087897785,
0.0025205861,
-0.0591791905,
-0.0051019429,
0.0216120612,
0.052052483,
-0.0154805398,
-0.0134665417,
0.0160779692,
-0.0078052352,
-0.0151602533,
0.0016333233,
0.032687027,
0.0461397208,
-0.0325411931,
0.0857058614,
0.0005580225,
-0.0377770402,
-0.0270701554,
-0.0927431658,
-0.0575333089,
0.0418279953,
0.0709204972,
-0.0082457848,
-0.0340523608,
-0.0250056852,
-0.0041246051,
0.043934539,
0.018196255,
0.0176416654,
0.003792387,
-0.0194940679,
-0.0242440552,
0.009484238,
0.0357788429,
-0.0001023875,
0.0078750066,
0.0089286342,
0.0099543007,
0.0162872598,
-0.0121076778,
0.0466815718,
-0.0441317298,
-0.0526144989,
0.0177558623,
0.0381002128,
0.0016974066,
-0.0228073057,
-0.01384148,
0.0118723018,
0.0473261811,
0.0209349059,
0.0070584905,
0.0126960538,
-0.0278973691,
0.0004554239,
0.0349910818,
0.0320780464,
-0.0088781677,
0.0977293178,
-0.0267959144,
-0.0415777527,
0.0314175189,
-0.0366714559,
0.0257656965,
0.0055460543,
0.0343847834,
-0.0323649868,
0.0360471532,
-0.0093111712,
-0.0033605115,
-0.0090867635,
0.0038498214,
-0.0012847576,
0.004365189,
0.0066105104,
-0.0165480413,
-0.0782733038,
0.0067263222,
-0.0360121094,
-0.0001962286,
0.0040188981,
-0.0008595173,
-0.011026415,
-0.0105571924,
-0.05540042,
0.0362827219,
-0.0435699001,
0.0361144878,
0.0518665351,
0.0307831671,
-0.0099005755,
-0.0142870639,
0.0311093051,
-0.0127598578,
0.0152670583,
0.0594294108,
-0.0058622705,
-0.0090685394,
-0.014523088,
-0.0063057803,
-0.021565577,
-0.0380610824,
0.0725001693,
-0.0284617972,
-0.0201429781,
-0.0655746683,
0.0257093795,
0.0228534602,
0.0579839461,
-0.0238476377,
-0.0390419364,
0.0272688773,
0.0123130213,
0.0319322385,
0.0852293223,
0.006439663,
-0.0071695689,
0.0758974627,
0.0027650185,
-0.063124612,
0.0009124482,
0.0075992672,
-0.0496125109,
-0.0531180315,
0.0265406594,
0.0217536818,
0.1033736765,
0.0042263679,
-0.0488012061,
-0.0420566685,
-0.0142539768,
-0.0101451427,
-0.0149755683,
-0.0075335847,
-0.0691831484,
-0.0760873035,
0.010358803,
-0.0213272609,
-0.05502351,
0.0624933839,
-0.0471706502,
0.0126714865,
-0.0433581881,
0.001725097,
0.0069426466,
0.0349202193,
-0.0195136424,
0.001961895,
0.0688949078,
-0.0394178219,
-0.0440862775,
0.0190533511,
0.0063162148,
-0.0181843136,
0.0364284664,
0.0000325641,
-0.0002699138,
-0.0285675433,
-0.0378550328,
-0.0662979707,
-0.0573845692,
-0.0103415512,
0.0055896696,
0.0361938477,
-0.0212447532,
-0.0059395512,
-0.0062008519,
-0.008073844,
0.036831893,
-0.0176477619,
-0.014751601,
-0.0566196777,
0.0164333284,
0.0499224998,
-0.0485615581,
0.0286026094,
-0.0218654443,
0.0166453049,
0.0680791214,
0.0455769561,
-0.0295010731,
-0.0421407707,
-0.0159568656,
0.0325672626,
-0.0492335148,
-0.0232861396,
0.0174834076,
0.0247831531,
-0.0520995148,
-0.0406206325,
0.07706514,
0.0125479512,
-0.0737677068,
0.0106343711,
0.0173166674,
0.0222306848,
0.0330322795,
0.0147505356,
-0.0767882988,
-0.0227239951,
0.0573674627,
0.0215799324,
-0.0196304154,
0.0022671355,
-0.0205781888,
-0.1316485703,
-0.0097935433,
-0.01635997,
-0.0267414805,
0.0160797741,
-0.0567466393,
-0.00696069,
-0.0061803153,
0.0415080786,
0.0008787167,
-0.0037995535,
-0.0014176508,
0.0161112528,
0.0179107394,
-0.0277232025,
0.0260853674,
-0.0448473208,
0.046839647,
0.065510273,
-0.0259547066,
-0.0126984427,
-0.0165307932,
0.0657979771,
-0.0066829016,
-0.0050832597,
0.0111336205,
0.0338367373,
-0.0163757503,
-0.0083108945,
0.0253491625,
0.0068311193,
-0.034760762,
0.0101005882,
0.0039317845,
0.0613862872,
-0.0205678605,
-0.0027010951,
-0.003172149,
-0.0234240443,
0.0470605008,
0.0551989451,
0.028364012,
-0.057186529,
-0.0244549885,
-0.0323095992,
-0.0048352149,
-0.0315355659,
-0.064473249,
0.0032789484,
0.025075106,
-0.0826621577,
-0.0274305474,
0.0039521372,
-0.0188125595,
0.0336616226,
0.0490323342,
-0.0104510821,
-0.0063123391,
0.0082718469,
-0.0491150394,
0.0376348421,
-0.0248458218,
0.0657569841,
-0.0556061491,
0.0336961262,
0.0185010303,
0.0133280633,
-0.0310745817,
0.0298901871,
-0.1083787829,
-0.08321812,
0.0213057417,
0.0498016141,
0.0287971292,
0.0316574909,
-0.0423180722,
-0.0379185863,
0.0527248234,
0.0212090723,
-0.0645431727,
0.0256540608,
0.0713768825,
-0.0573568344,
0.0034691978,
0.040778771,
-0.0362643301,
-0.0230197273,
0.0743974969,
0.0136158522,
0.0143825673,
-0.0418652035,
-0.0030809483,
0.0266915876,
0.1028012931,
-0.0198748913,
0.0110856881,
-0.00712161,
0.0247634016,
-0.0152935367,
-0.0131188082,
-0.0050671939,
0.0458832234,
-0.0023227884,
-0.0145272491,
0.0210298225,
0.0211237818,
0.0176707469,
0.0185270775,
-0.0701790676,
0.0148788746,
0.0095620984,
0.0313744284,
0.0629670396,
0.025133526,
-0.0090495087,
0.0145856477,
0.0560854636,
0.0240952708,
-0.027874874,
0.0205270611,
0.0237928722,
-0.005162071,
-0.0407596864,
0.0783718899,
-0.0988200307,
-0.0270458423,
0.0110582672,
0.0113652246,
0.0301347673,
0.0071702376,
0.0322953723,
0.0112218577,
0.0010899489,
-0.0186089016,
-0.0172664877,
0.0127597898,
-0.0169782657,
0.011582124,
-0.0211914554,
0.0039264988,
0.0245898366,
0.0839811862,
-0.035190925,
0.0819112882,
0.0021267913,
-0.0138798049,
-0.0196688101,
-0.0276888832,
-0.0278375167,
0.0011441776,
-0.0365951769,
-0.0182300676,
-0.0329149514,
-0.0872051269,
-0.0098912809,
0.0174406413,
0.0092473663,
0.0109950528,
0.0031379366,
0.0533123352,
0.0330417752,
-0.0120589063,
-0.0536794104,
0.0128478361,
0.0177393612,
-0.0175343398,
-0.0188060869,
-6.237721834e-33,
0.0033195487,
-0.0290171448,
0.0063448446,
0.0187689532,
-0.0112836463,
0.0142262019,
-0.0365498289,
0.0097586196,
-0.0232839733,
-0.0201163627,
-0.0346331857,
0.0225665532,
0.0150834667,
0.0020875626,
-0.0037412394,
0.015478977,
0.0559463203,
-0.0222178046,
-0.0588145368,
0.0373280309,
0.0604939647,
0.0240774285,
0.0485476442,
-0.0074948026,
0.0238762107,
0.0054759644,
-0.0216290615,
0.0161614083,
-0.0529387705,
0.0595825464,
0.0019189358,
0.0320571698,
0.0118542593,
-0.0972818807,
-0.0221857671,
0.066759482,
-0.0297373515,
-0.0056013069,
-0.0182898473,
0.0145854829,
0.0093764542,
-0.0503496043,
0.0551872291,
0.0082618287,
-0.0237380378,
-0.0071450146,
0.0130646667,
0.0006560883,
-0.0065077371,
-0.019427754,
-0.0246968195,
-0.0035613675,
-0.0030571127,
-0.031220736,
0.0059932349,
0.0419020914,
0.0207174849,
-0.0245086588,
-0.0658582598,
0.025203228,
0.034444578,
0.0376389697,
0.0572606362,
0.0288047362,
-0.0082462048,
0.0387635902,
-0.0004756638,
0.0184081681,
0.0094036171,
0.000825608,
0.0367345363,
0.0445785746,
0.0433408059,
-0.0023059088,
0.0412562042,
-0.0517183952,
-0.0315047316,
0.0234617777,
0.0453949943,
0.0396460965,
0.0563543215,
0.0090178838,
-0.0276376083,
0.0062476946,
-0.0439109653,
-0.0313731357,
-0.0174290203,
-0.0134119941,
0.0222750381,
0.031499438,
-0.0196945257,
0.0131537979,
0.0473042652,
-0.0560261607,
0.0264870133,
0.0294377971,
-0.0107454043,
-0.0149269281,
-0.0081519764,
0.0199234392,
0.0071006538,
-0.0159069598,
0.0070255068,
-0.0183978193,
0.0429909341,
-0.0045728791,
0.0088406326,
0.0397121944,
-0.0766977742,
0.0081628505,
-0.0515049025,
0.0433920994,
0.0192140434,
0.0583859086,
0.0465084277,
-0.0117871137,
0.0046922984,
0.0344362371,
0.0333483927,
-0.0159796476,
-0.0579954199,
0.0641158447,
0.0320739634,
0.015071976,
-0.0170551464,
0.0030083198,
-0.0166257396,
0.0719315261,
0.0332122669,
-0.056539841,
-0.0145035684,
-0.0129849864,
2.87e-7,
0.0022416844,
0.0134134414,
0.0181273483,
0.015104482,
0.0355680883,
0.0519283451,
-0.0179817118,
0.0670599267,
0.0060835434,
-0.011378862,
-0.040696349,
-0.0004259111,
0.0352847502,
0.0140509494,
-0.0593673848,
-0.0192697197,
-0.0923207849,
0.04284909,
-0.0431580767,
-0.0139949592,
-0.0126428073,
0.0893437415,
0.0122249033,
-0.0368880741,
0.012433501,
-0.0394219048,
0.0055738469,
0.0204602331,
-0.003912549,
0.0135837216,
0.058886569,
0.039000798,
0.0147534637,
0.0262846295,
-0.0492419265,
0.0234034695,
-0.0864629224,
0.0301555321,
-0.0068972423,
-0.0702241287,
-0.0190679915,
-0.0313418321,
-0.0149251353,
-0.0408713296,
0.075270772,
-0.0112685226,
-0.0120450081,
-0.0607356168,
0.0055951406,
-0.0274675582,
-0.0032892283,
-0.0191581342,
-0.0038871323,
0.0399159975,
0.0184931476,
0.0130017903,
-0.0154225817,
-0.095000416,
-0.0418273173,
-0.0419964045,
-0.0498939268,
-0.0504795387,
-0.0059611611,
-0.0221361984,
-0.0101404293,
-0.0240200516,
-0.0178506002,
3.130201178e-34,
0.0163376033,
-0.0141958995,
0.031342227,
0.0187581182,
0.0195558891,
-0.0227117836,
-0.0014657155,
0.0047696084,
0.0132890493,
-0.052381061,
-0.0617680363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13844v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13844v1 | Solving Math Word Problem with Problem Type Classification | 2023-08-26T10:35:16 | 2023-08-26T10:35:16 | Jie Yao, Zihao Zhou, Qiufeng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Math word problems (MWPs) require analyzing text descriptions and generating
mathematical equations to derive solutions. Existing works focus on solving
MWPs with two types of solvers: tree-based solver and large language model
(LLM) solver. However, these approaches always solve MWPs by a single solver,
which will bring the following problems: (1) Single type of solver is hard to
solve all types of MWPs well. (2) A single solver will result in poor
performance due to over-fitting. To address these challenges, this paper
utilizes multiple ensemble approaches to improve MWP-solving ability. Firstly,
We propose a problem type classifier that combines the strengths of the
tree-based solver and the LLM solver. This ensemble approach leverages their
respective advantages and broadens the range of MWPs that can be solved.
Furthermore, we also apply ensemble techniques to both tree-based solver and
LLM solver to improve their performance. For the tree-based solver, we propose
an ensemble learning framework based on ten-fold cross-validation and voting
mechanism. In the LLM solver, we adopt self-consistency (SC) method to improve
answer selection. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of these
ensemble approaches in enhancing MWP-solving ability. The comprehensive
evaluation showcases improved performance, validating the advantages of our
proposed approach. Our code is available at this url:
https://github.com/zhouzihao501/NLPCC2023-Shared-Task3-ChineseMWP. | [
-0.0129225561,
0.0760607645,
0.0183581281,
0.0181715358,
-0.0386894532,
0.0136939567,
0.0122073013,
0.0379403234,
-0.0189661272,
-0.0737394616,
0.0444859639,
-0.0304303933,
0.0156281739,
0.0000656023,
0.0021235556,
-0.0106026232,
0.0079607479,
-0.003251096,
0.0108075533,
-0.0322175361,
-0.0072633792,
0.0012961746,
-0.0133736543,
0.0056763412,
-0.0447650887,
-0.0701622441,
0.0096657081,
-0.0760950968,
-0.0102506252,
-0.0434957556,
0.034394253,
0.0801012814,
0.0145159289,
0.0339624211,
0.0000023715,
-0.0570142902,
-0.0611887313,
0.0206832532,
-0.0608885214,
-0.018360585,
-0.0385534465,
0.047499083,
0.0335004106,
0.0455788225,
-0.0677065179,
0.0020633913,
0.0056615425,
0.0755075812,
0.0517993495,
0.0373432711,
-0.0074133291,
-0.0186306126,
-0.0024646723,
0.0217120964,
0.048235368,
-0.0757784247,
0.0440051705,
0.0354602709,
0.0261723865,
-0.017068604,
-0.0380844958,
0.0031143362,
0.009030615,
-0.025115924,
0.0419858582,
0.0022042829,
-0.0521444008,
0.0238484032,
-0.033633966,
0.0570452139,
0.0079161003,
-0.009827246,
0.0062615946,
-0.0160822328,
-0.0332813486,
0.0499638207,
-0.0148822702,
0.0030945821,
-0.0493329838,
-0.016332794,
-0.0222508498,
0.0319093764,
0.0256434288,
0.0379857272,
-0.04990796,
0.1007092372,
-0.0037250798,
-0.0527760312,
0.0028325401,
-0.0151609601,
-0.0618029758,
-0.06636893,
0.0566852242,
0.0476002134,
-0.0174936969,
0.0185217299,
-0.0192723032,
-0.0923607498,
-0.0029335604,
-0.0433139503,
0.0298387557,
0.0163638629,
0.0452437662,
0.0442609861,
-0.0216921773,
0.0820557773,
0.0153734395,
-0.0395746231,
-0.0261963177,
0.0378200337,
-0.0637584329,
-0.0366635881,
-0.0416138247,
0.0860643983,
0.0022200372,
-0.0141873015,
-0.0323805586,
-0.0138971582,
-0.0008827722,
-0.0158675704,
0.0346493088,
0.0062777116,
0.0050404426,
0.0039951098,
-0.0356305912,
0.0125760743,
-0.0259051882,
0.0191121958,
-0.0398723148,
0.0204853155,
0.0108044557,
0.0154067464,
0.0069697523,
-0.0165527202,
0.0515146293,
0.0424093902,
0.0018526119,
0.000906311,
0.0288435705,
-0.005887283,
-0.0415967889,
-0.0839067474,
-0.0389854535,
-0.0942283124,
0.052504804,
0.0323220752,
-0.0291840117,
-0.0122063886,
0.0405905358,
0.0186997652,
0.0508762747,
0.0556427725,
0.0266289115,
0.0088735633,
0.0704897866,
-0.0113576306,
0.007426966,
0.0246882401,
0.0621774085,
0.0010125404,
0.0290782712,
-0.0173652377,
0.0601419359,
0.0068237325,
-0.0117987441,
-0.0167659055,
0.014672786,
0.0206333883,
0.0343715064,
0.0345631093,
-0.0773361325,
0.0288590956,
-0.0096807312,
0.0012946934,
0.0095857512,
0.038304776,
0.0308570322,
0.0074388189,
-0.032519538,
-0.0017296724,
0.0366742201,
-0.0076614763,
-0.0144872572,
0.0352988243,
-0.0689677671,
-0.0211492907,
0.0202947538,
0.0106899366,
-0.0210370161,
-0.069762513,
-0.0619140863,
0.0178282037,
-0.0485969484,
0.0318739489,
0.0679610521,
-0.044506643,
-0.0028181609,
0.0467137918,
-0.0024283642,
-0.020677004,
-0.0230119694,
-0.036186561,
0.0510942265,
-0.0186993796,
0.0612976514,
-0.061693307,
0.0001990394,
-0.0252031796,
-0.0033402988,
-0.0104652001,
0.0206043329,
0.0021116594,
-0.0334233902,
-0.0438722931,
-0.0222765617,
0.0184050743,
-0.0142547777,
-0.0346098803,
0.0462835468,
0.0065273661,
0.0071618115,
-0.0186937191,
-0.0323113054,
0.0567782447,
-0.038302701,
-0.0347318612,
0.0629763231,
-0.0237890482,
0.0333286114,
-0.0143152168,
0.013714375,
0.0264220145,
-0.0171431266,
-0.0263950247,
-0.0934266597,
-0.0247232001,
-0.0900967568,
-0.0475447252,
0.0805061385,
-0.030012913,
-0.0145118199,
-0.0279451702,
-0.0216333456,
-0.0366053805,
0.0174704753,
-0.0564636551,
-0.0300743915,
-0.0535355285,
0.0535980724,
-0.0262706019,
-0.0053450293,
-0.0485627055,
0.1059429348,
0.0422274061,
0.0388986655,
-0.0576626435,
-0.0260073114,
0.0520316549,
0.0211260971,
-0.0013754059,
0.0215097722,
-0.0205713864,
0.0340153351,
0.0280572176,
-0.0040823333,
-0.0347362608,
-0.0453043059,
-0.005793706,
0.0238840487,
0.0158954654,
0.0527473055,
-0.0123380823,
-0.0297911521,
-0.0081024887,
0.0190502349,
-0.0545693971,
0.0042196051,
0.0041516377,
-0.0525398031,
0.0291998573,
-0.0092482911,
0.0216162857,
-0.0158712137,
-0.0037192397,
-0.0395521633,
0.0478408448,
0.0248931218,
-0.0287659559,
-0.0403485894,
0.0496586636,
-0.0413835831,
-0.0187052693,
0.0133187035,
0.0347345844,
-0.017484352,
-0.0206840653,
0.0269935932,
0.0340453498,
0.0184580274,
0.0373284742,
0.0428694673,
-0.0149882808,
-0.0627565384,
0.0097283302,
-0.0039654579,
0.0372895785,
0.0476811342,
-0.0263369586,
0.0121639529,
0.0652186871,
0.0074772318,
-0.0325300246,
-0.0034859234,
0.0524207391,
-0.0181817766,
0.0177345946,
-0.0604546778,
0.0046341615,
0.0195273366,
-0.0156871602,
0.0114068193,
-0.0381995849,
0.0911850259,
-0.0166512411,
-0.0112527525,
-0.1139710769,
-0.0166645497,
-0.0966187119,
0.0143719427,
-0.0060234466,
-0.0098036202,
-0.0032725849,
0.0021612816,
-0.0125700617,
-0.0325689316,
0.0712219924,
-0.0442360006,
0.0335155725,
-0.014549044,
0.0393631794,
-0.0219599158,
-0.0485432632,
-0.0082967654,
-0.04352035,
0.0131286522,
0.041879639,
-0.0099064317,
-0.0345859639,
-0.0378583111,
0.0227526836,
0.0326161534,
0.0140598156,
-0.0780456737,
-0.0316899754,
-0.008986244,
0.0400305875,
0.0221334044,
0.0422573984,
0.0474628694,
-0.0547612384,
0.0591280833,
0.0089531923,
0.0708944872,
0.046544943,
-0.0011942202,
0.0011234167,
0.0084930612,
-0.0541330576,
-0.0200539939,
0.0089949472,
-0.0189649072,
-0.0471305363,
0.0356230512,
0.0765239522,
0.0724614114,
-0.0053546098,
-0.0455538519,
-0.070433937,
-0.023576349,
0.0152843408,
0.0544665195,
-0.0496023372,
-0.0228311997,
-0.0032089229,
-0.000480096,
-0.0113371955,
-0.0387382619,
-0.0040471368,
-0.0830989257,
0.0120239723,
0.0140483864,
-0.0287548788,
-0.0059520924,
-0.0350278504,
0.0076627238,
-0.005623973,
-0.0087384917,
-0.0072998526,
-0.0066391965,
0.0155585809,
0.0325310603,
-0.0376453809,
-0.0115539934,
0.0225110874,
-0.0234200638,
-0.0405902751,
0.0391253792,
0.0297898557,
-0.0561420098,
-0.0249176193,
-0.0091702929,
0.0019648217,
-0.0502168871,
-0.014988739,
0.0151326815,
0.0131602315,
0.0255861953,
-0.0017671601,
0.0472370721,
-0.0421971455,
0.0004003221,
0.0646874383,
0.1091718599,
-0.040328946,
-0.0286203995,
0.0100301998,
-0.0205296744,
-0.0030947453,
0.0683311075,
-0.0147598982,
-0.0212107953,
-0.0692844987,
-0.0213480629,
-0.0406924561,
-0.0254317094,
0.0296878386,
0.0292233825,
0.0254211035,
0.0424255617,
-0.0467979237,
0.0130386073,
0.0767295361,
0.0437632091,
-0.0125794355,
0.0184194651,
-0.0066066473,
0.0113808783,
-0.023518322,
-0.0231339727,
-0.0169389173,
0.0544680245,
-0.0259304699,
0.0395395979,
0.0307991225,
-0.0011009239,
-0.0078659682,
-0.0035072467,
-0.0599952079,
-0.0578927398,
-0.0253360514,
0.0051357457,
0.0007732912,
-0.0310868397,
-0.0014860576,
-0.0084495125,
0.0250160322,
0.0758600011,
-0.0147316242,
0.0198621694,
-0.0075024776,
-0.0218327977,
-0.0117466636,
-0.0124720931,
0.0055191782,
0.0285089258,
0.0175748486,
0.0373060703,
-0.0283394251,
0.0110006006,
0.043607384,
0.0678003505,
-0.0544181392,
0.0271191243,
-0.0322073251,
-0.0076625487,
0.0189725608,
-0.011101664,
-0.0306215547,
-0.0265641734,
0.0064295167,
-0.0225961953,
-0.0384355597,
0.0292360112,
0.029844556,
0.0351209231,
-0.0023183727,
0.0169572998,
0.1033842042,
0.025957888,
-0.006629657,
0.0318029821,
-0.0250425916,
0.0219469257,
-0.022769928,
0.0325487852,
0.0337685756,
0.0101964148,
0.0667058378,
0.0086110123,
0.0074957223,
-0.0629580766,
-0.0533880703,
-0.0270638522,
-0.0656584501,
-0.0442079715,
0.054563839,
0.0127301682,
0.0027328117,
-0.0367082097,
-0.0164710954,
-0.0245118421,
-0.0321199782,
0.0010985548,
0.0231054481,
0.0354952216,
0.0380186848,
0.048712723,
-0.0068270951,
-0.0015818895,
0.0567028858,
-0.0061417739,
-0.0082956618,
0.0385120288,
-0.0150780836,
-0.0465394892,
0.015572004,
0.0110663865,
-0.0238988064,
0.0046115839,
0.020713158,
-0.0599259697,
-0.0136604002,
0.0429105461,
-0.0285596903,
0.0108676152,
0.0336646475,
0.0143084088,
0.0654548556,
-0.035982687,
0.0085871164,
-0.0216086619,
0.0439561382,
-0.0531402007,
0.0013787659,
-0.0148366829,
-5.835375832e-33,
-0.0315291882,
-0.0863131732,
0.0143236639,
-0.0186394695,
0.0279431138,
0.0098373899,
-0.0123217376,
0.0095706414,
0.0270404089,
-0.0142059792,
-0.0150606474,
-0.0042183185,
0.007977481,
0.0164196417,
0.0187085345,
0.0062575624,
0.0119642494,
-0.0355575867,
-0.048209656,
-0.0404929817,
0.0328211077,
-0.0019178872,
0.0346202515,
-0.0550747253,
-0.0267282259,
0.0174069721,
-0.0017212121,
0.0060623256,
-0.0341192782,
0.0527335145,
-0.0241239984,
0.0332733989,
0.0192226674,
-0.0336659364,
-0.0216691662,
0.0105675422,
-0.0223248098,
-0.0458597094,
-0.0416000709,
-0.0154759437,
-0.0333891399,
-0.0016773696,
0.016263688,
0.0103440192,
-0.012811699,
-0.0470442772,
0.0359207541,
-0.0409696549,
-0.0371438004,
-0.0251866225,
-0.0174937285,
0.044219289,
0.0066608316,
0.004286387,
0.0067595048,
0.0316220075,
-0.0375219211,
-0.0107426774,
0.0102434428,
0.0097975787,
0.0402074456,
0.0193693321,
0.0042332099,
-0.0019105665,
-0.0104571795,
0.0255993474,
-0.0265214723,
-0.0524319299,
-0.018505061,
-0.0455994755,
0.0155938072,
0.0264613405,
0.1187987253,
0.0126135424,
0.0564378388,
0.0075319232,
-0.0331812911,
0.0136353225,
0.0384696051,
-0.0089501003,
0.0295573622,
0.0090899719,
-0.0429261811,
-0.0265161674,
-0.0292811692,
0.0115464907,
-0.0469977222,
-0.0045123552,
0.0101350024,
-0.0180981401,
-0.0215049256,
0.0086971493,
0.0309506822,
-0.0364576168,
-0.0417199768,
0.031134937,
0.0125697777,
0.0242781416,
0.0095900623,
0.0175336786,
-0.0385387838,
0.0063725901,
-0.0236896481,
0.0159665532,
0.0128955888,
-0.0002436939,
-0.000800267,
-0.0099930195,
-0.0547029376,
-0.0040739905,
-0.0110355765,
-0.0335040726,
0.0613757558,
0.0445166677,
-0.0117279766,
0.0190471187,
0.0062470175,
-0.0065739015,
-0.004648916,
-0.0336391591,
0.0034896105,
0.0095076719,
-0.0175803322,
0.0354672335,
0.0106108468,
0.0064904056,
-0.0098857209,
-0.0171479005,
0.0284773596,
-0.0265357774,
0.0092209056,
-0.0081085917,
2.973e-7,
0.0448126197,
0.0767628103,
-0.0106115397,
-0.0298439916,
0.0102012809,
0.0269589014,
-0.0189647023,
-0.0204121359,
-0.018102685,
-0.0247396603,
0.0270926096,
0.0278918538,
0.0577708259,
0.0760133043,
-0.0326690637,
0.0272419192,
-0.0509316102,
0.0106679164,
-0.0575674064,
0.0167613272,
0.0419348665,
0.0704849809,
0.020629039,
0.0102347992,
-0.0561132878,
-0.0419028997,
0.0297527369,
0.0168531798,
0.0171384718,
0.0479793251,
-0.0105687594,
-0.0352079421,
0.0095381085,
0.0468265079,
-0.0292273965,
0.0681765676,
0.0660950914,
0.0375345945,
0.0165215135,
0.0551535748,
-0.0027448852,
0.0182182007,
0.0093040504,
-0.0248473827,
0.0539272726,
-0.0640545785,
-0.0408227108,
-0.0530626737,
0.0418297052,
-0.0614574961,
0.0724693015,
0.0170246791,
0.0608778708,
0.0417606086,
-0.0000920228,
-0.0250777453,
-0.0007998693,
-0.0609691143,
-0.0073541845,
0.0288298372,
-0.0621628985,
-0.0043100617,
-0.0133406296,
0.0109977126,
0.0656857044,
-0.0335095339,
-0.008017377,
3.129147365e-34,
0.01323881,
-0.012672591,
-0.0122860102,
0.0569673516,
0.0371488407,
-0.0145304911,
-0.0298082251,
0.025389336,
0.0132002905,
-0.0961601362,
0.022658376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13782v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13782v1 | Planning with Logical Graph-based Language Model for Instruction Generation | 2023-08-26T06:28:14 | 2023-08-26T06:28:14 | Fan Zhang, Kebing Jin, Hankz Hankui Zhuo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the superior performance of large language models to generate natural
language texts, it is hard to generate texts with correct logic according to a
given task, due to the difficulties for neural models to capture implied rules
from free-form texts. In this paper, we propose a novel graph-based language
model, Logical-GLM, to infuse logic into language models for more valid text
generation and interpretability. Specifically, we first capture information
from natural language instructions and construct logical bayes graphs that
generally describe domains. Next, we generate logical skeletons to guide
language model training, infusing domain knowledge into language models.
Finally, we alternately optimize the searching policy of graphs and language
models until convergence. The experimental results show that Logical-GLM is
both effective and efficient compared with traditional language models, despite
using smaller-scale training data and fewer parameters. Our approach can
generate instructional texts with more correct logic owing to the internalized
domain knowledge. Moreover, the usage of logical graphs reflects the inner
mechanism of the language models, which improves the interpretability of
black-box models. | [
0.0537588447,
0.0094999811,
-0.0055823815,
0.0181423705,
-0.0620849244,
-0.0013007674,
0.0194487032,
-0.0133936228,
0.0619866587,
-0.0743298829,
0.0076366649,
0.003010893,
0.0029682009,
0.0638139695,
0.0238484293,
-0.0504015945,
0.0289211459,
-0.0146961454,
0.0012099282,
0.0165701304,
-0.010515037,
0.0424921885,
0.0139260916,
0.0297148004,
-0.0126939546,
0.0068636877,
-0.0536577404,
0.0180205069,
-0.0100643672,
-0.0236682929,
-0.0224952921,
0.0057183388,
0.0311907437,
-0.005929206,
0.0000017498,
-0.0226080175,
-0.0288238749,
-0.0116584329,
-0.0094729019,
-0.0455871485,
0.0484314896,
-0.0238867905,
0.0202720929,
0.0238058157,
-0.0258958023,
-0.0170231387,
0.0324325748,
0.0485429242,
0.0589358509,
0.0973109379,
-0.0001322132,
-0.0412554741,
0.0168555733,
-0.0008119754,
0.023083454,
-0.0344336182,
0.0108763492,
0.0696247816,
0.0369564444,
0.0013665101,
-0.0415130965,
0.0104837045,
0.0433786064,
-0.0342969783,
-0.0018245338,
0.0227649119,
0.0368133411,
0.0075889737,
-0.0038105519,
0.0771476924,
-0.0229194574,
-0.0245172605,
0.0211190395,
-0.0295569487,
0.0278951917,
0.0161163621,
-0.0344615057,
0.0839088485,
-0.021259075,
0.0083666928,
0.0607946292,
-0.0215317905,
0.0443774685,
-0.0080833063,
0.010917617,
0.098695673,
-0.0037262398,
-0.0211627372,
0.0224353299,
0.0025974659,
-0.0188811701,
-0.0486964323,
0.0099458192,
0.0538507141,
-0.0486710891,
0.0623709783,
-0.0761370882,
0.0273245294,
-0.0077202795,
-0.0263314433,
0.0409130864,
0.0292719994,
0.0216578115,
0.0159388166,
-0.0175777432,
0.0442342795,
0.0263031796,
0.0519337915,
-0.0595406592,
0.0325381681,
-0.0803195238,
-0.0063744034,
-0.065015845,
0.0489629246,
-0.0332927667,
-0.0427896008,
-0.0288652126,
0.0327158794,
-0.0052919728,
0.0068891905,
0.0353913419,
0.0218912978,
-0.0346356407,
-0.0334905423,
-0.017536696,
-0.0039073769,
-0.0215289667,
-0.0068266434,
0.0211069565,
-0.0060710846,
0.0045379326,
0.0314429216,
0.0312760547,
-0.0009300711,
-0.0137545923,
0.0934264287,
0.0100624915,
0.0057256045,
-0.0818774998,
-0.0868077874,
-0.0023538801,
-0.0517600887,
0.0425588973,
-0.0539919324,
0.0065467744,
-0.0091311466,
-0.0247783307,
-0.0621097535,
0.0204691868,
0.0280084927,
-0.001443737,
0.0145687526,
-0.007781778,
-0.0076786545,
0.0046154745,
-0.0084978342,
-0.0049681906,
0.0643265024,
0.0305186491,
0.0264364183,
0.0063369768,
0.0107849436,
-0.0284641888,
0.0100487405,
0.0192280244,
-0.0003092521,
-0.0388417318,
-0.0145217739,
-0.0421128906,
0.0383442715,
-0.0016335703,
0.0384877287,
-0.0357698351,
-0.0071928971,
0.0084884511,
-0.0019834156,
0.022523338,
-0.0164923295,
0.1089480743,
0.0216464326,
-0.0189419631,
0.0391835794,
-0.0486330576,
0.0039126985,
0.0007507385,
0.047008805,
-0.0329001769,
-0.0006825728,
0.01416062,
-0.0653631017,
0.0014624578,
-0.0256022234,
0.0699393749,
-0.0264003351,
0.0539277978,
0.0488327108,
-0.0777031109,
0.0401200876,
0.0296080597,
-0.0374721177,
0.0427576825,
-0.0332455523,
0.0080920774,
0.0743063688,
0.0363919251,
0.0080991928,
-0.0516198687,
-0.0212117005,
0.021649519,
0.0530364439,
0.0102578644,
-0.0257573109,
-0.0129401088,
-0.0643889979,
-0.0587231852,
-0.0397559553,
0.0145324878,
0.0076678577,
0.0091696689,
-0.0261769835,
0.0328534171,
-0.0378253385,
-0.0568852574,
0.0428782515,
-0.0624108985,
-0.0184285659,
-0.011393656,
-0.0163999926,
0.018282596,
0.0123974159,
-0.0013083159,
0.023106629,
0.0236605033,
-0.0198810268,
-0.0386931226,
-0.0004161984,
-0.0528127365,
-0.0543215461,
0.0487036332,
-0.0519679934,
-0.0097168237,
-0.0300820917,
-0.0488908291,
-0.0418813713,
0.0191769116,
-0.0735847354,
0.0164668262,
-0.0068260534,
-0.0090862717,
0.0206107441,
-0.0803840607,
-0.0300741922,
0.0635014251,
-0.0010326649,
-0.0093337391,
0.036031656,
0.0236364417,
0.018631747,
-0.0556713156,
0.0547979996,
-0.0190966446,
-0.003737533,
0.0284393877,
0.044081185,
0.0601074472,
-0.0479552448,
-0.0128259594,
-0.050805673,
0.0171005949,
-0.0182037819,
-0.0131026777,
0.0459898151,
0.0049905637,
0.0121349841,
-0.0173341203,
-0.0700400993,
0.0211617146,
0.0079154968,
-0.0267653037,
0.0266348068,
0.0002018656,
-0.0122633893,
-0.0267461184,
-0.0290626474,
-0.0355118439,
0.0281757675,
0.083356984,
0.0206804425,
-0.0565534458,
0.0849197507,
-0.0263151452,
0.0156820025,
0.0031763155,
-0.0159355681,
0.0055831559,
-0.0250951145,
0.0119432751,
0.0663174689,
0.0019563911,
0.037510898,
0.0681375414,
-0.0162253939,
-0.0571142621,
0.0182460118,
-0.0714807287,
0.0158841647,
-0.0619488396,
-0.0746819526,
0.0108169755,
0.0383442305,
0.0338036194,
0.0005177191,
-0.0765660927,
0.0123177506,
-0.023523381,
-0.0134862689,
0.0036938617,
-0.0141201457,
0.0022591229,
0.0041427994,
-0.0316385701,
-0.0384971537,
0.0765749589,
0.0139982346,
0.0215449184,
-0.0446271002,
-0.0058865473,
-0.0558104925,
0.033992324,
0.0411510766,
0.044425454,
0.0293430127,
-0.0145739624,
-0.0675346628,
0.0128233721,
0.0321392678,
-0.0068962453,
0.0213475712,
-0.0524564907,
-0.0019048651,
0.0305987857,
0.0174844135,
-0.0492935032,
0.0083735902,
0.001154459,
0.0387102403,
-0.0010887253,
-0.0209814943,
-0.0198528394,
-0.0196988881,
0.0007384971,
0.0125817461,
-0.0275591668,
-0.0220515486,
-0.0525349155,
-0.0206933878,
0.0795899555,
-0.0082143368,
-0.0235929098,
-0.0449955016,
-0.0076547796,
-0.0109574795,
-0.0109573398,
-0.0101245679,
-0.015180557,
0.0242332369,
-0.0103369495,
-0.0369780287,
-0.0243336633,
0.0704367086,
0.0242445078,
-0.0659575611,
-0.0319310203,
0.1250719577,
0.0140042612,
0.0174911674,
-0.0060763806,
-0.0121786827,
0.0240812153,
0.0154060721,
0.0297195837,
-0.0569963381,
-0.0332020558,
-0.020933155,
0.0236688685,
0.0046195108,
-0.0363423377,
-0.011485585,
-0.1199178994,
0.0227562841,
0.037361417,
0.0130465692,
-0.0279374924,
-0.0207141191,
-0.0656176507,
-0.0060141017,
-0.0124831768,
-0.0191691332,
-0.0388588831,
0.022648748,
0.0281532556,
0.0189336501,
-0.0227564704,
-0.0191365313,
-0.0034066627,
0.025064934,
0.0736000389,
0.0168557707,
0.0080572357,
-0.0164491571,
0.03239806,
0.0696989521,
-0.0111726755,
-0.0224902406,
0.045043055,
-0.0004137053,
0.0179304015,
-0.0081297439,
0.0357958041,
-0.0497527868,
-0.0130094932,
0.0089412266,
0.0781019926,
-0.0037169841,
-0.04048324,
-0.0244141705,
0.0402975418,
0.0162930842,
0.0539035052,
0.0289028846,
-0.0204104241,
-0.0383258723,
-0.079233624,
0.0238023065,
-0.0979886577,
-0.0189205222,
0.0427678414,
-0.0472172387,
0.0155444741,
-0.072698459,
-0.0420298539,
0.0276692528,
0.0331418477,
0.0244961716,
-0.0078022014,
0.0653842166,
-0.0518578775,
-0.0327760838,
0.0022367174,
-0.0296558589,
-0.0016386209,
-0.0462362207,
-0.0464198329,
-0.0245350376,
-0.043175932,
-0.0159200281,
0.0395276584,
-0.025231041,
-0.0691810176,
-0.025924759,
0.0591375083,
0.0156900473,
0.0550862215,
0.014812896,
0.0058156871,
-0.0070226025,
0.0096266484,
-0.0101440828,
-0.0075716651,
0.0220095422,
-0.0039055613,
0.0059323977,
0.0217623208,
-0.0476295315,
0.0227469727,
-0.0022627013,
0.0645024478,
-0.0343102962,
-0.015311108,
0.0461880341,
0.0217484534,
-0.0169785507,
-0.0204684865,
-0.0152603285,
-0.0497304313,
-0.0189519841,
-0.0600313991,
-0.0294352584,
-0.0718077049,
0.0196645968,
0.0166067258,
-0.0054692654,
0.0383926816,
-0.047511775,
-0.0295290761,
0.0431550741,
0.0094114169,
-0.0064953892,
0.006096608,
0.0094963685,
0.0350371562,
-0.0371878967,
0.0024419001,
0.0120724402,
0.0030741119,
0.035615515,
0.0074080243,
0.0764270723,
0.0325609855,
-0.0062294696,
-0.0183968842,
-0.0336470567,
-0.0172727834,
-0.0246718787,
-0.004915358,
-0.0101623572,
0.0435288399,
0.0174863953,
0.0403665267,
-0.0555032492,
0.0087708654,
-0.0102220159,
0.0888847783,
0.0384001099,
-0.0859251022,
0.0476615615,
0.0158334319,
-0.0074480376,
-0.0494854338,
0.0587725714,
0.0839664936,
0.0428632647,
-0.0067287227,
-0.0301159229,
-0.0471240878,
-0.045612175,
0.0155722937,
0.0444621481,
-0.0098105846,
0.0199130643,
-0.0546368212,
-0.0600698926,
-0.0127172368,
0.0419984944,
0.0420353822,
-0.0119058304,
0.0717201307,
0.0130436039,
-0.0190757215,
-0.0410321988,
-0.0658637136,
0.0493913405,
-0.0248600841,
-0.0384648219,
-0.0373694524,
-5.351976188e-33,
-0.0616720244,
-0.0874721184,
0.0535554029,
0.0016478928,
-0.0072681615,
-0.0022907453,
-0.0565350428,
0.0026871257,
0.0168315265,
0.0463470034,
0.0560920984,
0.0100832488,
-0.0066645704,
0.0463346019,
-0.0023096357,
-0.0046249358,
0.0513339639,
-0.0154557489,
-0.0056198677,
0.0385810509,
0.0426371954,
0.0143848266,
0.0046217511,
-0.047834944,
0.0177583341,
0.00144816,
0.0111173242,
0.0274092685,
-0.0158199221,
0.0678504333,
0.0164407436,
0.0132267242,
0.0198885966,
-0.0046705934,
-0.0306686629,
0.0043438696,
-0.0385665409,
-0.0438380204,
0.0289447736,
0.0028886658,
-0.0444036834,
-0.0460329056,
0.036081776,
-0.0145702558,
0.0126193604,
-0.0564570874,
0.0502970032,
0.0107553964,
-0.0193275958,
0.0037326007,
-0.0900414884,
0.0228254031,
0.0031213749,
-0.0020952402,
0.0026619041,
0.034305919,
0.0011156879,
-0.0361417904,
0.0116229868,
0.0229282025,
0.0141141461,
0.0072224317,
0.0530147366,
0.0409631282,
-0.0047173467,
0.0457199402,
-0.0046228594,
0.0111002056,
-0.0500514582,
0.0560448617,
0.0042506219,
0.0817160532,
0.0016294735,
0.0017834874,
0.0017826492,
0.0262731481,
-0.0872174576,
0.0253278743,
-0.0343537889,
0.0209131464,
0.0203837901,
-0.0215168782,
-0.0181357078,
-0.0204592366,
-0.0329921767,
0.0129760196,
0.0111112054,
-0.0419709608,
0.0220271815,
-0.0033074806,
-0.0120658381,
-0.0393432789,
-0.0002182788,
-0.0473369397,
-0.004441272,
0.0468323864,
-0.0336324647,
0.019926995,
-0.0206326973,
0.0358732194,
-0.0574163347,
-0.0638567135,
0.0146909067,
-0.017375391,
0.0141044818,
0.0391019508,
0.0332206823,
0.0274261162,
-0.0150641231,
0.0109874969,
-0.0623653233,
-0.0033241694,
-0.0081765633,
0.0144946435,
0.0361975878,
0.0248739514,
-0.0261653084,
0.0269082878,
0.0273612458,
-0.0608755425,
-0.0028344872,
-0.0098211747,
0.0248524714,
0.0326221511,
-0.0511624552,
-0.0166756604,
-0.0385534205,
0.0169184878,
0.0336428508,
-0.0330018662,
-0.0046865684,
0.0085214265,
2.424e-7,
0.0582453981,
0.0198968779,
0.0285373405,
0.0870920867,
-0.0024329529,
0.041034732,
0.0091002034,
0.0107043898,
0.0036256381,
-0.009218174,
0.0015992536,
0.03141734,
0.0014244642,
0.0091833612,
-0.0658647865,
0.017941948,
0.0168196727,
-0.0316771828,
-0.0313817188,
0.0266942307,
0.0787740648,
0.0290853977,
0.0093481382,
-0.0028435178,
0.0061662639,
-0.0609162003,
0.059160579,
0.0080184266,
0.0064740363,
0.0271298736,
0.0233204234,
-0.0030011698,
-0.0192072671,
0.0029258321,
-0.0095318994,
-0.000677244,
-0.0182141662,
0.0798900649,
-0.0083904192,
0.0227989033,
0.031704694,
-0.0487229675,
-0.001753062,
-0.0066799889,
0.0150645645,
-0.0451285467,
-0.0068116523,
-0.0026068825,
-0.0115940915,
-0.0049544508,
-0.0469401665,
-0.0250829719,
-0.0008148742,
0.0123042027,
0.0203938428,
-0.0282890573,
0.0309081934,
-0.0065583824,
-0.015249351,
0.0012850717,
-0.0271608345,
-0.0160925351,
-0.0377372131,
0.0513399839,
-0.0012182798,
-0.0323908851,
-0.0016085632,
2.487217017e-34,
0.0248086713,
-0.0233284459,
0.0027986325,
0.0045068637,
0.0525269508,
-0.0002968686,
-0.0439860523,
0.046002958,
0.0374061279,
-0.0634261593,
-0.044989001
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13775v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13775v2 | EditSum: A Retrieve-and-Edit Framework for Source Code Summarization | 2023-08-26T05:48:57 | 2023-09-07T11:19:30 | Jia Li, Yongmin Li, Ge Li, Xing Hu, Xin Xia, Zhi Jin | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Existing studies show that code summaries help developers understand and
maintain source code. Unfortunately, these summaries are often missing or
outdated in software projects. Code summarization aims to generate natural
language descriptions automatically for source code. Code summaries are highly
structured and have repetitive patterns. Besides the patternized words, a code
summary also contains important keywords, which are the key to reflecting the
functionality of the code. However, the state-of-the-art approaches perform
poorly on predicting the keywords, which leads to the generated summaries
suffering a loss in informativeness. To alleviate this problem, this paper
proposes a novel retrieve-and-edit approach named EditSum for code
summarization. Specifically, EditSum first retrieves a similar code snippet
from a pre-defined corpus and treats its summary as a prototype summary to
learn the pattern. Then, EditSum edits the prototype automatically to combine
the pattern in the prototype with the semantic information of input code. Our
motivation is that the retrieved prototype provides a good start-point for
post-generation because the summaries of similar code snippets often have the
same pattern. The post-editing process further reuses the patternized words in
the prototype and generates keywords based on the semantic information of input
code. We conduct experiments on a large-scale Java corpus and experimental
results demonstrate that EditSum outperforms the state-of-the-art approaches by
a substantial margin. The human evaluation also proves the summaries generated
by EditSum are more informative and useful. We also verify that EditSum
performs well on predicting the patternized words and keywords. | [
0.0667204559,
0.0301283114,
-0.0311855655,
0.0189484674,
0.0209532138,
-0.0012494101,
-0.0867573991,
-0.008876605,
-0.0418201573,
-0.0107989507,
-0.0039283871,
0.0657704473,
0.0465838015,
0.0523159243,
0.0246041305,
-0.0643605962,
0.0186102912,
0.0138169955,
-0.0316649415,
0.0399553217,
0.0640175045,
0.0149155436,
0.0294221044,
0.0569192842,
0.0307469573,
0.0070909522,
-0.0114516709,
-0.0363659821,
0.022324685,
-0.02939431,
0.0232160818,
0.0227189157,
-0.0265450571,
-0.0257732738,
0.0000019569,
-0.0395459943,
-0.0155624496,
0.0056326678,
0.0598748662,
0.0565478466,
0.0375083797,
0.0004053551,
0.0167957712,
0.0051587215,
-0.0303427111,
-0.002644958,
0.0654607192,
-0.007691612,
0.0950439796,
0.0284197684,
0.0069757309,
-0.0275646802,
-0.00145999,
0.034124054,
0.0194282793,
-0.0111015197,
-0.0340308174,
0.0055547352,
0.0300375298,
-0.001568314,
0.0360116698,
0.003085529,
-0.0215015877,
0.0043345825,
0.0535992235,
0.028885005,
-0.0457672291,
-0.0126489187,
0.0405500978,
0.0360874049,
0.0009669972,
-0.0150279794,
0.0418320559,
-0.0040617664,
0.0035156624,
-0.0000068751,
-0.0547029153,
0.0292382129,
-0.0170186441,
-0.0207416546,
-0.0121711781,
-0.0075000147,
-0.0178966429,
-0.0029766043,
-0.0230872333,
-0.0155512439,
-0.0054879817,
0.0082494533,
-0.0465851128,
-0.0330480784,
-0.0133591956,
-0.0749150813,
-0.021731101,
0.0678466409,
0.0021740957,
-0.0046979031,
0.0069024609,
-0.0507737175,
0.0659613311,
-0.0283297226,
-0.0355944112,
0.0208654143,
-0.0431468338,
0.0014457626,
-0.016932996,
0.0332214497,
0.0228150692,
-0.0249344707,
-0.0458523221,
0.0145565653,
-0.0644395351,
-0.0111221522,
-0.0519994721,
0.082966812,
0.0393023342,
0.0276529044,
-0.0132140238,
0.0702388585,
0.0163428765,
0.0313524194,
-0.03573028,
-0.0124494275,
-0.0126717472,
0.0081398441,
0.0118650412,
-0.0430758446,
-0.0336740799,
-0.0645849332,
-0.0078204758,
-0.0347163193,
-0.0113718258,
-0.0039158822,
-0.001902152,
0.0261596665,
0.011945094,
0.0176979303,
0.0260185674,
-0.0010129838,
-0.0295920428,
-0.0393287688,
0.0028639457,
0.0408075526,
-0.0411478132,
-0.0912558287,
-0.0663423836,
0.04158796,
-0.0311462414,
-0.0423224308,
0.000352496,
0.0265094936,
-0.0076263607,
0.0313868783,
-0.1009202152,
0.0283796415,
0.0309429299,
0.0008066029,
-0.0132054379,
0.00526116,
0.0450582057,
0.0339416824,
0.0341555886,
-0.0435333028,
0.0355168954,
0.0151839396,
-0.0309429206,
-0.0072291768,
0.0117601221,
0.0319734886,
-0.0272162165,
-0.02976018,
0.0290888101,
0.0134755336,
-0.0055649034,
0.0479841642,
-0.016106125,
0.0775103346,
-0.0052628717,
0.0602362566,
0.0295429882,
0.0781603083,
0.0133153144,
0.0221131183,
0.0067726877,
0.0397100113,
-0.0237572156,
0.0546087101,
0.0182485133,
0.0039635287,
0.0193729103,
-0.0629753321,
0.0022515934,
0.0155935399,
0.0036884672,
-0.0130149713,
0.0071084821,
0.022702653,
-0.0159436017,
0.0248163436,
0.0452683978,
-0.0443407483,
-0.0070975684,
-0.0121651348,
0.0182611383,
0.0434213057,
0.0468395092,
-0.0472531915,
0.0042597917,
0.0065856013,
-0.042844329,
-0.0342856124,
0.0613658056,
-0.029069325,
-0.0209183097,
-0.0399946049,
-0.0447569899,
-0.0572868772,
-0.0164478086,
0.0289219711,
-0.0059469119,
-0.0747952536,
0.0706692785,
0.0005507475,
-0.0679601207,
0.0216750596,
0.0415142477,
0.0078131678,
0.0200375561,
-0.0276869629,
0.0099072251,
-0.0214530621,
-0.0488568805,
0.0337949432,
0.0146554457,
0.0096047092,
-0.0319011249,
0.0167440157,
0.0197886992,
-0.0006654008,
0.0092766043,
-0.0595976785,
-0.0025570341,
0.0097506959,
-0.0186651405,
-0.0252503268,
0.0414785519,
-0.0740526095,
0.04907801,
-0.0081953416,
-0.0051241261,
-0.029515354,
-0.0327909067,
-0.0133247329,
0.0389226712,
0.0401683077,
0.0102422787,
0.0148664545,
-0.0069083842,
0.0223885141,
0.002130778,
-0.0265381876,
-0.0064773113,
-0.0255561043,
0.0074410788,
0.0633069053,
0.0370271578,
-0.0403743349,
-0.0184326861,
-0.0825205818,
-0.0024576921,
0.01092338,
0.0282536279,
0.0367560647,
0.0344280005,
-0.0184822939,
-0.0360005572,
-0.0263650566,
-0.0384015962,
-0.0201224834,
-0.0014602719,
0.0348466672,
0.0292401165,
-0.0293717347,
-0.0509124398,
0.0069630435,
-0.0164782796,
0.0214291252,
0.0216754712,
-0.0557068773,
-0.072539717,
0.0883730352,
0.0140282912,
-0.0193269327,
0.0049855928,
-0.0235226937,
-0.0156869106,
-0.0402565002,
0.0743336827,
0.0171058606,
0.0402528532,
-0.018148683,
0.0627348348,
0.0015482644,
-0.0291483533,
-0.0297942962,
0.0217444487,
-0.0386442281,
0.0495374873,
-0.0138561269,
0.0857914388,
0.0510395691,
0.0212642569,
0.0062795617,
0.0099504022,
-0.0097439708,
0.0021896923,
0.071020931,
-0.0450642593,
-0.050560426,
-0.0219845027,
0.0424367003,
-0.0034466193,
-0.0677742586,
0.0670202374,
-0.0207939018,
-0.0159925446,
-0.0543706492,
0.0050445832,
-0.0487555191,
0.0344738662,
-0.0062209088,
0.028287461,
0.0241640415,
-0.0455455817,
-0.0152118905,
0.0071002794,
0.017207725,
-0.0143699385,
0.049592305,
-0.0714641809,
-0.0047835438,
-0.00436938,
-0.0057034204,
-0.0362091213,
-0.0092535829,
-0.0372218899,
-0.0248908065,
0.0558145829,
0.0160709526,
0.0166568682,
0.0067998571,
0.0538617186,
0.0481451936,
0.0398378447,
-0.0502424017,
0.0135237128,
-0.0251198318,
-0.0049906452,
-0.0301499758,
0.0027447939,
0.0115617253,
-0.0074709784,
0.0288762581,
0.0355980396,
0.0194189101,
-0.0434392616,
-0.0549697727,
0.0111718401,
-0.076113835,
-0.0550653562,
0.0420706086,
-0.0007991856,
-0.0117833558,
0.0144825168,
0.0739759356,
0.0375566967,
-0.0479551144,
0.005686868,
0.008538642,
0.0298994519,
0.0655735433,
0.0335423499,
-0.0449918397,
-0.0098443218,
-0.0016927907,
0.0369897299,
0.0212556086,
0.0193390511,
-0.0302634668,
-0.0543090068,
0.0071401359,
-0.0160177108,
-0.0533962436,
-0.0356810279,
-0.0193116665,
-0.021574039,
0.0010902258,
-0.0803060979,
0.0397900119,
-0.0203016512,
0.0312494244,
-0.005415793,
-0.113351129,
0.0664207786,
0.0226400327,
-0.013558669,
-0.0317116752,
0.1232338101,
0.0132459784,
0.0080025988,
0.0430581309,
0.0111124991,
-0.0511970855,
0.0117492154,
-0.0093020685,
0.0415290743,
0.0034713917,
-0.021385543,
0.0290743671,
0.0070789177,
-0.0137424422,
-0.0058946447,
0.0730633959,
-0.0183724537,
0.0044480972,
0.0218484923,
-0.0625159666,
0.020304285,
-0.0631330535,
-0.0031399757,
0.098490037,
0.0364295691,
0.025023574,
-0.0493209735,
-0.0174059253,
-0.0697055981,
-0.031334877,
-0.0527053364,
-0.038066145,
0.0312820636,
-0.1000828519,
-0.0408196412,
0.0142851798,
-0.0152438777,
0.0301426426,
-0.0106918719,
0.009409111,
0.0015008065,
-0.0747968853,
0.0040291883,
-0.0039288602,
-0.0056760279,
0.0075128516,
-0.0453476347,
0.0289578568,
-0.0463115275,
-0.0321881883,
-0.007733786,
-0.029883977,
-0.0125937657,
-0.0330511481,
0.0437749811,
0.012158473,
0.0263011344,
-0.0308437943,
-0.053291101,
-0.0249770191,
-0.0218075495,
-0.0301507749,
-0.0028891019,
0.0005012234,
0.0517249107,
0.0131333955,
-0.0143184466,
-0.0954997763,
-0.0000082881,
-0.0455418006,
-0.0291927885,
-0.0344037749,
-0.0342599303,
0.0480804555,
0.0530606546,
0.0328888223,
0.0081482325,
0.0339279249,
0.0011582384,
-0.0314193591,
0.0232514553,
-0.0453303419,
-0.0360192247,
0.0975100175,
-0.0315863118,
-0.0172893628,
0.0476851128,
0.0783714056,
-0.0763972327,
0.0122061856,
0.017350385,
0.0235300027,
-0.0136309611,
0.0252864417,
0.0013088745,
0.009827028,
-0.0264157727,
-0.0312814601,
-0.0121613191,
0.0095984712,
-0.0132158147,
0.007538497,
0.0183588136,
-0.0020869854,
0.0172380731,
0.0264995843,
-0.0522973798,
-0.0104580382,
-0.0244242344,
-0.0171274282,
0.004923021,
0.0331785828,
0.0470289402,
0.0058574434,
0.0131082535,
-0.0117077949,
0.0807929859,
-0.0308252815,
-0.0419466347,
-0.0236368682,
0.0463996194,
-0.0001683078,
-0.0637520403,
0.081178695,
-0.0458252616,
-0.015349241,
-0.0143466219,
-0.0176637117,
-0.029050732,
0.0108674886,
0.024528401,
0.0316806361,
-0.0267354753,
-0.0588364974,
-0.0349867381,
-0.0084720291,
-0.0019447487,
0.020644052,
0.0585929677,
0.0010212342,
0.0569722205,
0.0596382879,
0.0063952669,
-0.0181770921,
-0.0083792554,
0.0032020123,
-0.016659651,
-0.0102592297,
-0.0304554421,
-5.013152431e-33,
-0.0307461843,
-0.011513791,
-0.0201295856,
0.06564565,
0.0061878106,
0.0021410023,
-0.0696303993,
0.0012842483,
0.0239379387,
-0.0381294675,
0.0242103133,
0.0115565546,
-0.0199894086,
-0.0583238304,
0.07301341,
0.0445747711,
0.0352897532,
0.0581116937,
-0.0623122603,
0.0548953116,
-0.0252794344,
0.0175604038,
0.0488179401,
-0.0262015294,
0.0249753036,
-0.0299075823,
0.0072178966,
-0.0239178445,
0.0726088509,
0.0164637174,
0.0127011733,
0.0120836459,
-0.0148753347,
0.0063140765,
-0.0646951124,
-0.0455786623,
-0.007472252,
-0.0068953591,
0.0252319314,
-0.0135215484,
0.0148246503,
-0.0685028359,
0.0457235835,
-0.0290966015,
-0.0030155859,
0.0027428144,
0.0759768561,
-0.020951014,
-0.0198398903,
-0.0643901303,
-0.0366744958,
0.0516893081,
-0.0758694038,
-0.0178019796,
-0.0092615979,
0.0383706652,
0.0113592539,
0.0110848295,
0.0398094207,
0.0137206325,
0.0432022922,
0.0587806851,
0.0331152193,
-0.0009737721,
0.0078166351,
0.013467554,
0.0350479633,
0.0043626837,
-0.0113038644,
0.038562946,
0.0276528355,
0.0224694442,
0.01880165,
0.0263624452,
0.0746605843,
0.0317454599,
0.0311590806,
0.082627207,
-0.0738267004,
0.0692977905,
-0.0296823941,
0.0242587347,
-0.0190980248,
-0.0017623497,
-0.0270715505,
0.0306451693,
-0.0186949857,
-0.0328574367,
0.0080827773,
-0.0005947608,
-0.0270996038,
-0.0035320728,
-0.0456575304,
-0.0414291322,
0.0589611046,
0.0079325177,
-0.0605102815,
0.049191393,
-0.0334721878,
-0.0390854925,
0.0133835739,
0.0304253269,
0.0203761775,
0.0076651005,
0.0418916903,
0.0184263345,
0.0341915227,
0.0017905642,
-0.0372530073,
0.0089324089,
-0.0097328508,
-0.031954214,
-0.0779945627,
-0.0521332808,
-0.0477204099,
0.0044701826,
-0.0023722011,
0.027682595,
0.0022967837,
-0.0152317733,
-0.0666422397,
0.0072421478,
0.0255300719,
0.0299438201,
-0.00795181,
-0.0037590514,
-0.0064862799,
0.040285062,
0.0607251376,
0.019663902,
-0.0543089174,
0.0113460887,
2.601e-7,
0.0175107475,
0.023077542,
0.0561969578,
-0.0099408347,
-0.0415554754,
0.0342768431,
-0.0011837538,
0.0036709844,
0.046114333,
0.0179014131,
-0.0162441991,
-0.0021961858,
0.0040832753,
0.0153295007,
-0.0823822767,
-0.0250131208,
-0.0425080694,
-0.0307567306,
-0.0424633659,
0.0307142884,
0.0586920679,
0.0214745943,
-0.0056744595,
0.0224916246,
-0.0053136144,
-0.020741526,
-0.0063872575,
-0.0101478491,
0.0098537765,
0.0446491204,
-0.0044427235,
0.0218332317,
-0.0237263329,
-0.0475863703,
-0.0269127842,
-0.029119296,
0.0297420342,
0.0176861826,
-0.0061319182,
0.0617920421,
0.0248016678,
-0.0273472201,
0.0175620131,
-0.0150446389,
-0.0003497063,
-0.0498187579,
0.0199097954,
-0.0262182001,
-0.0492655225,
-0.0082358485,
-0.0408014432,
0.005829168,
-0.0252502635,
0.0118082957,
-0.0275606997,
-0.0534875654,
-0.0483284183,
-0.0368844792,
-0.0537207089,
0.0310125481,
0.0214546733,
-0.0190086048,
-0.0264422745,
-0.0156049542,
0.0064530745,
-0.0094418889,
0.0266067572,
2.200481803e-34,
0.0518637709,
-0.0238131788,
-0.0155476658,
0.0091657843,
0.0743107572,
-0.0325289257,
-0.0224938504,
0.0366660208,
0.0141021777,
0.0127433194,
-0.0449865796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13768v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13768v1 | Adversarial Fine-Tuning of Language Models: An Iterative Optimisation Approach for the Generation and Detection of Problematic Content | 2023-08-26T05:20:58 | 2023-08-26T05:20:58 | Charles O'Neill, Jack Miller, Ioana Ciuca, Yuan-Sen Ting, Thang Bui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we tackle the emerging challenge of unintended harmful content
generation in Large Language Models (LLMs) with a novel dual-stage optimisation
technique using adversarial fine-tuning. Our two-pronged approach employs an
adversarial model, fine-tuned to generate potentially harmful prompts, and a
judge model, iteratively optimised to discern these prompts. In this
adversarial cycle, the two models seek to outperform each other in the
prompting phase, generating a dataset of rich examples which are then used for
fine-tuning. This iterative application of prompting and fine-tuning allows
continuous refinement and improved performance. The performance of our approach
is evaluated through classification accuracy on a dataset consisting of
problematic prompts not detected by GPT-4, as well as a selection of
contentious but unproblematic prompts. We show considerable increase in
classification accuracy of the judge model on this challenging dataset as it
undergoes the optimisation process. Furthermore, we show that a rudimentary
model \texttt{ada} can achieve 13\% higher accuracy on the hold-out test set
than GPT-4 after only a few rounds of this process, and that this fine-tuning
improves performance in parallel tasks such as toxic comment identification. | [
0.083067283,
0.048681464,
-0.038294062,
0.0520737469,
-0.0273120292,
0.0342068747,
0.0126170442,
0.0038838922,
0.0457724072,
-0.064276576,
-0.0250023194,
-0.0394411944,
-0.0184371416,
0.024652306,
0.0307513196,
-0.0273498073,
0.055346638,
-0.0111320429,
0.0212651491,
0.0051600719,
0.0250409711,
0.007971039,
0.0289967973,
0.0207801238,
-0.0275450032,
0.0002351327,
0.0332988426,
0.0084802024,
0.0108882636,
-0.0220240429,
0.0624212846,
0.0537742563,
-0.0153755341,
0.0935445353,
0.0000020974,
-0.0312462114,
0.0111951306,
-0.0143572502,
-0.0164532103,
0.0259367432,
0.0363535434,
-0.0341719724,
-0.0290993396,
0.0407954715,
-0.0334120579,
-0.0088077635,
0.0322862305,
0.0468408987,
0.0788309649,
0.1042702124,
-0.0122849839,
-0.0196344908,
0.033526767,
-0.0322554931,
-0.0283749308,
-0.0443738438,
0.052915588,
-0.0142157916,
-0.0356753469,
0.0220007375,
-0.0049875174,
0.0134733981,
0.0248290859,
-0.0224595498,
-0.0168308597,
-0.0166785922,
0.0180674493,
-0.033244852,
0.0056485417,
0.0588633493,
-0.0473868996,
-0.0318683311,
0.0067910491,
-0.0157112926,
0.02361973,
-0.0226792898,
-0.0169989746,
0.0141262012,
-0.0125147104,
0.0080677923,
0.0237525832,
-0.015230081,
0.060216099,
0.0510917045,
0.045037508,
0.0096411863,
0.0104730809,
-0.0473689996,
0.0074868598,
-0.0093759876,
-0.0280641038,
-0.0451934561,
0.0258190949,
-0.0005907409,
-0.0521847792,
0.0147362212,
-0.0660855919,
-0.0477954485,
0.0434904359,
-0.0265907571,
0.0472515523,
-0.0043537528,
-0.0238477886,
0.0399053469,
-0.021428654,
0.0149663668,
-0.0066507687,
0.0175712872,
-0.0085145431,
0.0119301975,
0.0091285342,
-0.0104299588,
-0.0424860306,
-0.0105353184,
-0.0274015851,
0.024129875,
-0.0325765721,
0.0384762511,
-0.0196668692,
0.0133835468,
0.0031117501,
0.00979992,
-0.0218304526,
0.010696955,
-0.0089331977,
-0.0466279313,
-0.0502851456,
0.0261157379,
0.0069095539,
-0.0703882873,
-0.0170588437,
0.0412719026,
-0.0552348793,
-0.0131985424,
0.011670664,
0.1042514369,
0.0060538133,
-0.016480796,
-0.049981758,
-0.040962521,
-0.0468982011,
-0.0542993695,
0.0032160541,
-0.0313879959,
-0.0151945325,
-0.0236810744,
-0.0386736356,
-0.0725633949,
-0.0029516092,
0.0074248952,
-0.0166602507,
0.0747480094,
-0.0176885743,
-0.0362772718,
0.0230250712,
0.0421719924,
-0.0274337828,
0.0578413419,
0.0051442701,
0.0845645964,
0.0272194035,
-0.0210945532,
0.0077120834,
0.052471593,
0.0440845564,
0.0378930494,
-0.0236842874,
-0.0024556264,
0.0028249712,
0.0070320703,
-0.0276125297,
0.0715208501,
-0.0053748838,
-0.0334646404,
0.087699011,
-0.0316308513,
-0.0476030409,
0.047847487,
0.0434572585,
-0.0156513024,
-0.0254868064,
0.0196579378,
-0.0700276121,
-0.0154204955,
-0.0664184168,
-0.0608589947,
0.0143622505,
0.0323345177,
-0.0162091851,
-0.0428911112,
0.0095417295,
-0.0261770356,
0.0507940166,
-0.0167982448,
0.0221051984,
0.0442308336,
-0.0519397631,
-0.0405418277,
0.0312696993,
-0.0035007924,
-0.0161109269,
-0.0862416998,
0.059842594,
0.041861739,
0.065193437,
-0.028669402,
0.0201751925,
-0.0600316152,
0.0323783383,
0.0317629129,
0.055141706,
-0.0228577349,
-0.0215386152,
-0.0387695283,
-0.0189576969,
-0.0142815709,
0.0217334628,
0.0375558548,
0.0293228328,
-0.0077395625,
0.0311225094,
0.0339128748,
-0.0569816679,
0.040747501,
0.0095903948,
-0.0490310304,
0.0129119158,
0.0192049667,
0.051635053,
-0.0057228375,
-0.0080469288,
-0.0077990973,
0.0185952745,
-0.0213633869,
-0.0035873794,
-0.0571034588,
-0.026989894,
-0.0105185965,
0.028624868,
-0.0013926479,
-0.0324514769,
0.0529416837,
-0.0360030718,
-0.0001548972,
0.0209699646,
-0.0420996323,
-0.0014127885,
-0.0539860763,
-0.0048982692,
-0.0194731895,
0.0219656322,
-0.0400019363,
0.0638747662,
0.0037198202,
0.0038984655,
0.01518365,
0.0143707385,
0.0170350578,
0.004749083,
-0.0501576364,
-0.010920492,
-0.0197471641,
0.0287463255,
0.0372264311,
0.0212514438,
-0.0128548434,
-0.0501492023,
-0.0425687395,
-0.0029198243,
-0.0314784385,
-0.0050499099,
0.0280924328,
-0.0202329345,
-0.0067534535,
0.0024565575,
-0.0336562619,
-0.0135995848,
0.0141599774,
0.0489695184,
0.0115052359,
-0.0067952769,
-0.0070108501,
-0.0344408713,
0.0106089013,
0.0004577053,
0.0128885387,
0.0254082736,
-0.0294931307,
-0.0362386517,
0.015298916,
-0.0093807047,
0.0269735567,
-0.0304538235,
-0.0643718541,
0.0237955842,
0.0259878635,
0.0059159943,
0.0854379162,
0.0376798846,
0.0721389204,
0.0352999493,
0.045783814,
-0.0255185813,
0.0011977311,
0.0044250973,
-0.0106560625,
-0.0094158081,
-0.0195696857,
0.0244266409,
0.0510423258,
0.041187454,
-0.0039030984,
-0.0442841947,
0.0954782814,
-0.0250223055,
-0.0388715714,
0.0048315129,
-0.0642638803,
-0.0334988423,
0.0066953744,
-0.0431316942,
-0.0854697675,
0.0865420774,
-0.0249284841,
0.0235303398,
-0.0143161453,
-0.0310656726,
0.0250288453,
0.031789802,
0.0293899924,
0.0294994786,
0.0173377097,
0.0054611787,
-0.0412427597,
-0.0010099818,
0.044614017,
-0.0104580931,
0.0233237911,
-0.0182499196,
-0.0053471513,
-0.0005372897,
-0.0674879998,
-0.0820431337,
-0.0644992068,
-0.0071885688,
-0.0060174931,
0.039964553,
-0.001278059,
-0.0239765607,
0.0031815709,
-0.0195348579,
0.0242127459,
-0.0383831598,
0.0212352332,
-0.022506468,
0.0180261638,
0.0508562103,
-0.0292255096,
0.0173265636,
-0.0289797168,
0.015881177,
0.0554851778,
-0.038652163,
0.0331691839,
-0.0064364537,
-0.0154112503,
-0.0056216819,
0.0000710621,
-0.0139115257,
0.0164543912,
0.0202302001,
-0.0476207584,
-0.0048673307,
0.0797514394,
0.0019092894,
-0.0266225077,
0.0149046453,
0.0360694416,
0.0260547809,
0.0078255115,
-0.0282046683,
-0.0793042928,
-0.0437608361,
0.0125011234,
0.0440875143,
-0.0516610406,
-0.0244388878,
-0.0014253412,
-0.1077595577,
0.0176071804,
0.0035185327,
-0.0284145679,
-0.0223578084,
0.0045553907,
-0.0243055895,
-0.0024757173,
0.0384125635,
-0.0251919515,
0.0244695507,
-0.0110379532,
0.002774412,
0.0232431944,
-0.036906451,
0.0124494592,
-0.0097847618,
0.069127135,
0.0818474218,
0.0382595025,
-0.0085787484,
-0.0151945557,
0.0743440986,
-0.0238328427,
-0.004852877,
-0.0158566181,
0.0432527959,
-0.0052602417,
-0.019535739,
-0.023370225,
0.0377767906,
0.0022589809,
0.0015018717,
0.0139132068,
0.0656979308,
0.0230237972,
-0.0420958698,
-0.0215871222,
0.0081622582,
0.0460839756,
0.0775130913,
0.0463339314,
-0.0695302486,
-0.007348157,
-0.0486663505,
0.0153182317,
-0.0460497737,
0.0003362731,
-0.0047868234,
0.0149730314,
0.0088690072,
-0.0635321885,
-0.0408975631,
0.0072272127,
-0.0250879768,
0.0331340805,
-0.0054256478,
-0.05731434,
0.0073299212,
-0.0030258815,
0.0156793837,
-0.009423364,
0.0299320891,
-0.0660382435,
-0.0354766324,
0.0109527912,
-0.0341374092,
-0.016601555,
0.0424309261,
-0.0590116568,
-0.0805225745,
0.0346340053,
0.0879999921,
0.0138243753,
0.0316891521,
-0.0393724889,
-0.0672370642,
0.045860678,
0.0528408065,
-0.0169168785,
-0.0081986682,
0.0437005237,
-0.0172505658,
-0.0044448283,
0.0481575429,
-0.0224596262,
0.0297677405,
0.0600080788,
-0.0426776484,
-0.0329670087,
-0.0223083254,
0.0218976811,
0.0399420299,
0.0533045009,
-0.0322154239,
-0.0228252951,
-0.0306626093,
-0.0059776781,
0.0068999329,
-0.0380685665,
-0.0206422824,
0.0254212767,
0.0195837133,
-0.0246909652,
-0.0110149197,
-0.0035377995,
-0.0253715999,
0.0305406246,
-0.0565912798,
0.0097733689,
0.0315002501,
0.0538530611,
0.0513667166,
0.0069046882,
-0.0190621465,
0.0558118932,
0.0149967428,
-0.0020334681,
-0.0234500635,
0.028351143,
0.0275530778,
0.012539289,
0.0035664656,
0.0259105247,
-0.0159336235,
-0.0145211695,
-0.03930014,
0.0219330974,
0.0356281959,
-0.0212364253,
0.0134504214,
-0.0233783722,
-0.0231564045,
-0.0146396197,
-0.0015045834,
0.0200692844,
-0.0511486493,
0.0134725636,
0.0018471086,
-0.0273265261,
0.0081429724,
0.051136855,
-0.0071567325,
0.0821488574,
0.0303623676,
-0.0124281906,
-0.0457728095,
-0.0356048569,
0.027829472,
0.0006510348,
-0.0150402058,
0.0242416542,
-0.018002931,
-0.0625254139,
-0.0528215952,
0.0080548711,
0.009302686,
-0.0034257029,
0.0237625111,
0.0425292589,
-0.003180847,
0.0242663734,
-0.0346330553,
-0.0058915755,
0.0135063473,
-0.0550753437,
-0.0046787309,
-6.085094179e-33,
0.00513004,
-0.0362366401,
-0.0370933861,
0.0111351106,
0.0097466074,
-0.0285708271,
-0.0129358741,
-0.0142879719,
-0.0205803793,
0.0050592059,
-0.0073680142,
-0.0097577935,
-0.0140498755,
0.0234276913,
-0.0384122767,
-0.0424277931,
0.0668697879,
-0.0332018808,
-0.0480686985,
0.0435927436,
0.0219599437,
0.0179506876,
-0.0011095686,
-0.0722171366,
0.0350998826,
-0.0052100183,
-0.0423600487,
0.0221314933,
-0.0539090261,
0.0575013235,
0.0122165987,
0.0509299412,
0.0323894322,
-0.0001663193,
0.0055355392,
0.0402433574,
-0.0217083432,
-0.0084121833,
0.0291250944,
-0.0150275184,
-0.0181931295,
-0.0585721657,
0.0501911752,
-0.0316461921,
-0.0137774488,
0.0060264692,
0.0041179345,
-0.0345163755,
-0.0122666387,
-0.0390255526,
-0.0753580481,
0.0060724467,
0.0088911504,
-0.0330628119,
-0.0018945595,
0.0292662121,
0.0349087119,
0.0166857671,
-0.0504347198,
0.0042306967,
0.0352834091,
0.0099662617,
0.0128673585,
0.0032098154,
-0.0109502766,
0.0634982362,
0.0076546101,
0.021793589,
-0.0346977226,
-0.0051590181,
-0.0031767618,
0.025603978,
0.0722752884,
0.0719583333,
0.0249734838,
-0.0875339061,
-0.0988597423,
-0.0003329908,
0.0415969044,
0.0162971076,
0.0341628194,
-0.0364637226,
-0.0384832993,
-0.0183764547,
-0.0421173871,
-0.0665276274,
-0.0153836142,
-0.0319855735,
0.0209496282,
0.0130053097,
-0.0307372622,
-0.0553252734,
-0.0193242151,
-0.0629260391,
0.0288799275,
0.0389010534,
-0.0183671732,
-0.0427371711,
0.02284519,
0.0193349943,
-0.0437115878,
-0.0157057103,
0.0278395005,
-0.0548463874,
0.0256449524,
0.0168699324,
0.0896272585,
0.0332617685,
-0.0596318766,
0.0416799188,
-0.0156987272,
0.102565214,
0.0107825538,
0.0565964803,
0.0208651163,
-0.0018268331,
-0.0002219266,
0.0123270173,
0.039109569,
0.0206281375,
-0.0534097292,
-0.0007884136,
-0.0217983052,
0.0110886144,
-0.0328755826,
-0.0252023246,
-0.0101305582,
0.0140289832,
0.0490335189,
-0.1055424437,
0.0227160715,
-0.0229648836,
2.773e-7,
-0.0041300845,
0.0619523264,
-0.0066896509,
0.0007514405,
0.0515343212,
0.0525318272,
0.0005174883,
0.039422445,
-0.0045191874,
-0.0147359753,
-0.0194983035,
0.0022739673,
0.0457281433,
0.0426107273,
-0.0573021956,
0.0218364373,
-0.1044000387,
0.0288727507,
-0.0433245376,
0.0058817617,
0.0267849956,
0.1335497499,
0.0144031467,
-0.0510008559,
0.0090010948,
-0.0621634871,
0.0385756418,
-0.0272437762,
-0.0088302465,
0.01359188,
0.0594496056,
0.0223558322,
0.0189461578,
0.0088401036,
-0.0147358067,
-0.0042291516,
-0.0262088254,
0.0575997792,
0.0107353413,
-0.0091809314,
-0.0014326808,
-0.0203627534,
0.0088791605,
-0.05982491,
0.0859947354,
-0.0099763554,
-0.0041806963,
-0.0430013463,
0.0058353604,
-0.0452362522,
0.0384036563,
-0.0647300482,
-0.0226663891,
0.0080752363,
0.0127503881,
0.0014132737,
0.0180189554,
-0.0486777313,
-0.0096238339,
-0.0262351278,
-0.0344402716,
-0.0397700481,
-0.0219189879,
0.0025684759,
0.0225806292,
-0.041991394,
0.0572485067,
2.473446744e-34,
0.0318541005,
-0.0520392992,
0.0314660147,
-0.0542939641,
0.0227393787,
0.0427093804,
0.0129676647,
0.0119639114,
0.0086209094,
-0.0208871514,
-0.029981317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13760v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13760v1 | How Can Context Help? Exploring Joint Retrieval of Passage and Personalized Context | 2023-08-26T04:49:46 | 2023-08-26T04:49:46 | Hui Wan, Hongkang Li, Songtao Lu, Xiaodong Cui, Marina Danilevsky | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR | The integration of external personalized context information into
document-grounded conversational systems has significant potential business
value, but has not been well-studied. Motivated by the concept of personalized
context-aware document-grounded conversational systems, we introduce the task
of context-aware passage retrieval. We also construct a dataset specifically
curated for this purpose. We describe multiple baseline systems to address this
task, and propose a novel approach, Personalized Context-Aware Search (PCAS),
that effectively harnesses contextual information during passage retrieval.
Experimental evaluations conducted on multiple popular dense retrieval systems
demonstrate that our proposed approach not only outperforms the baselines in
retrieving the most relevant passage but also excels at identifying the
pertinent context among all the available contexts. We envision that our
contributions will serve as a catalyst for inspiring future research endeavors
in this promising direction. | [
0.0589264967,
-0.0072779497,
-0.0315588154,
0.0184006952,
-0.033954069,
-0.0437763445,
0.0534555987,
0.0051706559,
0.0063738981,
-0.0306252595,
-0.0284770709,
-0.017580213,
0.0045622149,
0.0514469072,
-0.0228174888,
-0.0311121829,
0.0234444365,
-0.0055673686,
0.0389302447,
0.0530776642,
0.0332599916,
0.0156658236,
0.0207909048,
0.033246018,
0.0050789197,
0.0010610714,
-0.0046494827,
0.0203545876,
0.0153250732,
-0.0441352464,
0.0559418723,
0.0267193597,
0.0550494231,
0.0164490324,
0.0000015439,
-0.0456720851,
-0.0342567302,
-0.0185419358,
-0.0096868761,
-0.0076273144,
0.0517880507,
0.0528954677,
0.0264487509,
0.0030615903,
-0.0288668368,
0.0202899985,
0.0063968874,
0.0402076356,
0.0037194064,
0.0542696789,
-0.0231142621,
0.0002315229,
-0.0294369981,
-0.0003954319,
0.0492247827,
-0.0745598972,
-0.0161384139,
-0.0048682322,
0.0420460068,
0.0496583693,
0.0154888397,
0.0317939706,
-0.0230035204,
-0.023102589,
0.0282313675,
0.0095767416,
-0.0197101049,
0.0382979885,
-0.0243090224,
0.0682897568,
0.0645490661,
-0.0262583662,
-0.0142797064,
0.0043615317,
-0.0157247018,
-0.0258417465,
-0.0660670698,
-0.0160420965,
-0.0403196439,
0.0026142863,
-0.0337641202,
0.0689751357,
-0.0001385359,
0.0135426791,
0.0093957819,
0.0424623825,
0.0016483187,
-0.0352416337,
-0.0087175425,
-0.0152896205,
-0.0059108124,
-0.0116595579,
0.0565134697,
0.0063325907,
-0.0194663964,
0.0203372948,
-0.0157076679,
0.0010908413,
0.0217438191,
-0.0251832977,
-0.0255164057,
0.0120747788,
-0.0115878042,
0.0433396734,
0.0280565023,
0.0064099226,
0.0175734889,
-0.0379002579,
-0.050657846,
-0.0049634213,
-0.0211008694,
0.0101120155,
-0.0563152619,
0.0421545543,
-0.0768667758,
-0.0498755835,
-0.0027842221,
0.0319538936,
0.0460144468,
-0.0027734356,
-0.0366842113,
0.0448207147,
-0.035995651,
-0.0038167201,
0.0033193787,
-0.0059632589,
-0.0529599339,
-0.0017595848,
0.0028282187,
-0.0191531796,
0.0098117832,
-0.0129693365,
0.041857928,
-0.0094652129,
-0.012584554,
-0.012711932,
-0.0164503772,
-0.0938891247,
-0.0188783314,
-0.0278063659,
-0.0307609066,
-0.0097649582,
-0.0762791485,
-0.0254503973,
0.0180372968,
0.0262966007,
-0.000225501,
-0.0009712806,
0.0192227438,
0.0568825901,
-0.0061073308,
0.0536144935,
0.0229618307,
-0.0229836088,
0.0443335585,
0.0528942943,
0.0433545671,
0.0488625839,
0.0179529767,
0.029542489,
0.1036917344,
0.0252951421,
-0.0041278522,
-0.0008961271,
-0.039427571,
-0.0173282158,
0.0055599837,
0.0377968177,
-0.0065121045,
0.0142542217,
-0.0442477576,
0.015143373,
-0.0402513519,
-0.0096779168,
0.0459428579,
0.1018636152,
0.0265494585,
0.0042743389,
0.0033985088,
0.0345154516,
-0.006911838,
-0.0069040498,
-0.0190967508,
-0.021255007,
-0.0320277363,
-0.0183986891,
0.0531698838,
0.0107926726,
-0.004781174,
-0.0257720035,
0.0018377126,
0.0287240446,
-0.0114687504,
-0.0053401114,
0.0298288148,
-0.0061814701,
-0.0473784842,
0.0159130599,
0.0092957038,
-0.0781923607,
-0.0092286384,
0.0238109343,
0.0188662466,
0.0927133188,
0.1025714129,
-0.0630620122,
-0.0047517275,
-0.0015181274,
0.010788356,
0.0102882199,
0.0232720952,
-0.026927093,
0.0309272371,
-0.0569005385,
-0.02439579,
-0.0057954025,
-0.0096814213,
0.0079005389,
0.0193449855,
0.0402947478,
0.0282037649,
-0.0405538343,
0.0281916838,
0.0139152398,
-0.0142999366,
-0.0187113769,
0.0064655947,
0.0173029602,
-0.0204660781,
0.0659371838,
0.017860299,
-0.0164854936,
0.0352316983,
-0.0098240105,
0.0185436513,
0.0355673358,
-0.084679693,
0.013561802,
0.0083233705,
-0.010866127,
0.0424900576,
-0.0109172734,
0.0406525359,
-0.0443523377,
-0.0135673452,
-0.0350024477,
0.0444651842,
-0.0120129324,
0.0162025373,
0.0049254787,
0.0104211988,
-0.0609905869,
0.0440853946,
0.0392376184,
0.0382252336,
0.0152950538,
0.0598457046,
0.0379204042,
-0.0274192989,
-0.0276246015,
-0.0036116051,
0.0006686902,
-0.0095075816,
0.0747908428,
-0.0303802583,
-0.0668790415,
0.0018093347,
-0.1313188523,
0.0179992262,
-0.0183171779,
-0.0061333906,
0.0251752567,
0.0527079552,
-0.0275757536,
-0.0448058061,
-0.0336728804,
-0.006611859,
0.0180012137,
-0.0086433617,
0.0194330439,
0.052338779,
-0.0062833657,
-0.0858202428,
0.0020526913,
0.0011140903,
0.0400380678,
0.0146033103,
-0.0212276895,
-0.0519246086,
0.0148556102,
0.0174217969,
0.0454815477,
-0.0343037546,
0.0065494552,
0.0124851018,
-0.0408671908,
0.0140061071,
0.0429979786,
0.0220796634,
0.0257195123,
-0.0005681526,
-0.0546445511,
-0.0862827227,
0.0320701525,
-0.0076233954,
0.010887539,
-0.0275427364,
-0.0109684533,
0.0413504168,
-0.0065573412,
0.0064500673,
0.0230265148,
-0.0290311221,
-0.0022375213,
0.0318398699,
-0.0007722902,
-0.0370883979,
-0.0148371831,
-0.0233251844,
0.0607029535,
-0.0044808555,
-0.0268390831,
0.0277393963,
-0.0366288796,
-0.0209983215,
-0.062497776,
-0.0175814386,
-0.061150413,
0.0851352066,
-0.0507574864,
-0.0099195167,
-0.0048397868,
-0.0715170726,
0.0079465229,
0.0198075175,
0.0326520689,
-0.0363988541,
0.0408219136,
-0.0236447342,
0.0107383253,
0.0416699946,
-0.0547234714,
-0.0487514585,
-0.0468749255,
-0.0136173023,
-0.0167573057,
0.028300697,
-0.0288560949,
-0.0494187474,
0.0260063242,
-0.0106975958,
0.0595380031,
-0.0121676447,
-0.0244230255,
-0.0071034054,
0.0500748716,
0.0279259421,
0.0039817318,
0.0032934553,
0.0166620035,
0.0447133146,
0.0368383154,
0.0396635756,
-0.0567143038,
0.0262869298,
-0.0334289148,
0.0529810563,
-0.0560861751,
-0.0046058721,
-0.004591763,
0.0443652011,
-0.0403568894,
-0.076405026,
0.0919875279,
0.0534844585,
-0.0932192504,
-0.0521540232,
-0.0395585895,
-0.0077783102,
0.0171892643,
0.0238844045,
-0.0591204278,
-0.0257824659,
0.0114553347,
0.0472435281,
0.0225447509,
-0.0267189536,
-0.0288798679,
-0.0610988885,
0.0056674876,
0.0065695862,
-0.0251644868,
-0.0100769913,
-0.0253920015,
0.0263823234,
0.0089323344,
-0.0079480885,
0.0110770026,
-0.0465400964,
-0.0232916884,
-0.050968226,
0.0252297278,
-0.0054836916,
0.0048528202,
-0.0046477779,
0.005411109,
0.0384960845,
0.0341321081,
0.0319487117,
0.0234718025,
0.0011438759,
-0.0823094249,
0.0106788985,
-0.0019680862,
0.0397902764,
-0.0511810184,
0.0429695211,
-0.0564664789,
0.0160906184,
0.0012763049,
-0.0351120494,
0.027525099,
-0.0161830559,
-0.0126723778,
0.0287635792,
-0.0459057204,
0.0519900583,
0.0386277027,
0.0700890198,
-0.0066729318,
-0.0197813641,
-0.0338406265,
-0.020053437,
0.0371551886,
-0.0356845856,
0.0060533215,
-0.0318615697,
-0.0045036469,
0.0484736376,
-0.0765804127,
-0.0690960363,
-0.0212061256,
0.0092565883,
0.0076803835,
0.0375611931,
-0.0532971807,
0.0312139839,
-0.0470570363,
0.001272398,
-0.0278129186,
0.0019308142,
-0.0378432535,
0.0212204251,
0.0224851947,
-0.0720526427,
0.0215997566,
0.0160724968,
-0.0552842654,
-0.0338117257,
-0.0037559818,
-0.0417107157,
0.0131571293,
0.0513345227,
-0.0419314057,
-0.0478461273,
0.0536344573,
0.0029913916,
-0.0578224659,
-0.0014897414,
0.006165674,
0.059932664,
-0.0181708634,
0.0292017497,
-0.0534913838,
0.0124504156,
-0.046940729,
0.0276825465,
-0.0229201969,
-0.1079283133,
-0.0161127429,
-0.0260678865,
0.0079450076,
0.0247318093,
-0.0000471717,
-0.0403808467,
0.0495967381,
-0.0263815671,
-0.0255785715,
0.0006786434,
0.0121200774,
-0.0177576579,
-0.0318000317,
-0.0214233696,
0.0484202541,
-0.0160100125,
0.0569742545,
-0.055229485,
0.0187738352,
0.0410616286,
-0.0255206879,
-0.0050447206,
0.0177548192,
0.0012690163,
0.0164982788,
-0.005943743,
0.0920000002,
-0.0270620827,
0.0816024318,
0.0109307114,
-0.0772132725,
0.0017566073,
0.0522851013,
-0.1258986294,
0.0419982225,
0.0063638594,
0.0107733356,
0.0216282029,
-0.0352654643,
0.0463543683,
-0.017142579,
0.0163042322,
-0.0023603421,
-0.0113197546,
0.0095482878,
-7.673e-7,
-0.0411431417,
0.0477389134,
0.0056979186,
0.0749214515,
0.0412875675,
-0.0366131775,
0.0147962682,
-0.0032229177,
-0.0592659339,
-0.0336424075,
0.0216022842,
0.0099180723,
0.1246113256,
0.0010563596,
-0.0121535193,
-0.0378362089,
0.0108021041,
0.0670171082,
-0.0123024909,
-0.0088121807,
-0.0039376994,
0.0462871566,
0.0712039918,
0.006383149,
-0.0136462245,
-0.0224688109,
0.0169728938,
-0.0249470808,
0.0033414634,
-0.0512432642,
-5.012029099e-33,
-0.0269803479,
-0.0199413672,
-0.0228278525,
0.0356322825,
-0.0317390822,
0.0151464511,
-0.0154424235,
-0.013120465,
0.0241505783,
-0.0108423969,
-0.0535328276,
0.0253712106,
0.0178517997,
0.0135821486,
-0.0316115879,
-0.0096804928,
0.0384604894,
0.0115413442,
-0.0258129202,
0.0385119542,
0.0798799992,
0.0557799079,
0.0048824716,
-0.0720738843,
0.0380784869,
-0.0610035844,
-0.005788723,
0.0074321758,
0.0762095153,
0.0503172055,
-0.0130464863,
0.0419579335,
0.0151370121,
0.0234630089,
0.016200725,
0.050048586,
-0.0822056904,
-0.0251765903,
0.0118481405,
0.0108020809,
0.021236008,
-0.0270502772,
0.0105396472,
-0.038752716,
0.0052838498,
0.0204858296,
0.039332822,
-0.0099288067,
-0.0187043194,
-0.0443967208,
-0.0284077544,
0.0282579828,
-0.028225936,
0.0092276251,
0.0153840408,
0.0392026342,
0.0512131453,
0.0192900859,
-0.0275775734,
0.0372557305,
-0.0490356423,
0.0208789296,
-0.0317564197,
0.0103065139,
-0.0219516996,
0.0544009358,
0.0286909305,
0.0034604233,
-0.0127152344,
-0.0585830137,
0.010003739,
-0.0049355221,
0.0071145492,
0.0613296218,
-0.0213515889,
0.0124892192,
-0.020275889,
0.0751366019,
0.0467764959,
-0.0328510739,
0.0421633795,
0.0220927671,
-0.0852791891,
0.0058738212,
-0.0186326783,
-0.0204549842,
-0.0353038944,
-0.0113264406,
0.0309040658,
0.0199831091,
-0.0174283665,
-0.0194082893,
0.0186761133,
-0.025161704,
0.0059499447,
0.040104147,
-0.0018483599,
0.0248513166,
-0.0081537701,
-0.0006895453,
-0.0225638952,
0.0077249981,
0.023199942,
-0.0226359088,
-0.0218374841,
-0.0296915788,
-0.0150888711,
-0.0070675607,
-0.0706343204,
-0.0019728572,
0.0164007396,
0.0250410531,
-0.0459789224,
-0.0090548582,
0.0119288741,
0.0159852896,
-0.022176018,
0.0929266289,
0.0414013527,
0.0597053729,
-0.0380577892,
-0.0823280811,
-0.0009812252,
-0.0120090721,
-0.008272524,
0.0290603787,
0.0172569212,
0.0307098012,
0.021831017,
-0.014874965,
0.0129064238,
0.009974543,
2.293e-7,
-0.0109309303,
0.0178823676,
0.0436930545,
-0.0197857153,
0.0162622202,
0.0241066255,
0.0229374077,
0.0168284271,
0.0223506205,
-0.0147577878,
0.0240447149,
0.0055943835,
0.0142763574,
-0.0015523657,
-0.1119024679,
-0.0475929268,
-0.0032943699,
-0.0442500152,
-0.035792619,
-0.0047962866,
0.0408996195,
0.031627249,
0.0138262268,
0.0098277833,
-0.0332809724,
-0.0422693901,
0.0088472143,
-0.0557364821,
-0.0155583201,
0.0091906097,
0.0248578079,
0.0108952336,
-0.0395156331,
-0.0472590998,
-0.0022434434,
0.0740803406,
0.0402412899,
0.0499742739,
0.0275277998,
-0.0651204064,
-0.0220462736,
0.0129500898,
-0.005511167,
-0.0286361985,
0.0526808053,
0.0309644248,
0.0129913976,
0.0050226217,
-0.0043449812,
-0.0370086245,
-0.0122790914,
0.0145171154,
-0.0456265062,
0.0276777782,
-0.0230074115,
0.003663003,
0.0184013788,
-0.1397323459,
-0.0126018319,
0.0019719768,
-0.0253587179,
-0.001751157,
-0.0397120267,
-0.015801141,
-0.0193943158,
-0.0530980676,
0.0299044009,
1.721713515e-34,
0.006294623,
0.0026450746,
-0.0135896765,
-0.0020702856,
0.0423858017,
-0.010570718,
0.0131635349,
0.0102060279,
0.0493040979,
-0.096082136,
-0.0217484348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13754v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13754v2 | ZC3: Zero-Shot Cross-Language Code Clone Detection | 2023-08-26T03:48:10 | 2023-09-07T11:22:59 | Jia Li, Chongyang Tao, Zhi Jin, Fang Liu, Jia Li, Ge Li | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.IR | Developers introduce code clones to improve programming productivity. Many
existing studies have achieved impressive performance in monolingual code clone
detection. However, during software development, more and more developers write
semantically equivalent programs with different languages to support different
platforms and help developers translate projects from one language to another.
Considering that collecting cross-language parallel data, especially for
low-resource languages, is expensive and time-consuming, how designing an
effective cross-language model that does not rely on any parallel data is a
significant problem. In this paper, we propose a novel method named ZC3 for
Zero-shot Cross-language Code Clone detection. ZC3 designs the contrastive
snippet prediction to form an isomorphic representation space among different
programming languages. Based on this, ZC3 exploits domain-aware learning and
cycle consistency learning to further constrain the model to generate
representations that are aligned among different languages meanwhile are
diacritical for different types of clones. To evaluate our approach, we conduct
extensive experiments on four representative cross-language clone detection
datasets. Experimental results show that ZC3 outperforms the state-of-the-art
baselines by 67.12%, 51.39%, 14.85%, and 53.01% on the MAP score, respectively.
We further investigate the representational distribution of different languages
and discuss the effectiveness of our method. | [
-0.0102369599,
0.0368603058,
-0.0324219838,
0.0457906015,
-0.0249380171,
0.0018830091,
0.0022333555,
0.015317061,
-0.0112843188,
0.0016737661,
-0.041944176,
0.036878258,
-0.002311158,
-0.0022758965,
0.0271715056,
0.0221453384,
0.0421511792,
0.0109889209,
-0.0500605591,
0.010634575,
-0.0041264202,
0.0100483354,
0.0374265984,
0.0521918312,
0.0234452579,
-0.0366461091,
0.0178299658,
-0.0024956532,
0.0136385122,
-0.0369371325,
0.0003313454,
0.0189401954,
-0.0115408972,
0.0717923269,
0.0000019684,
-0.0182548556,
-0.0404777601,
-0.0110973557,
0.0214025062,
0.0354415663,
0.0358213,
-0.0144676473,
0.0192951411,
-0.0141817527,
-0.0176068638,
-0.0585295856,
0.0474401116,
-0.028775122,
0.0434446074,
0.0131512703,
-0.0093399305,
0.0435614176,
-0.0287452824,
0.0066610975,
0.0250809174,
-0.0130090825,
-0.0326529779,
0.030761566,
0.0106126294,
0.0224081799,
0.0197707489,
0.0394361019,
-0.0257235151,
0.0336631425,
-0.052191902,
0.0057706903,
-0.0433815643,
0.0192389581,
0.0363966376,
0.0548902266,
-0.0858232304,
-0.0773024112,
0.0246908609,
-0.0152113233,
-0.0095471255,
0.0146402717,
-0.0324922875,
0.0031107049,
0.0196050312,
0.0158140734,
0.0058401702,
0.0089926748,
0.0164684542,
-0.0640474632,
0.0050432645,
0.006470209,
-0.0025793477,
0.005555877,
-0.0132913142,
-0.0202681851,
0.0319400541,
-0.0323162079,
-0.0412695706,
-0.0182338748,
-0.0031593654,
-0.0102709141,
-0.0448249988,
-0.03751624,
0.0543697812,
-0.0122269699,
0.0157798473,
0.0428000949,
-0.0367704704,
-0.0066672792,
-0.0893815681,
0.0906583667,
-0.0210926365,
0.0133322589,
-0.007771363,
-0.0110119358,
-0.070604898,
0.0201410577,
-0.0358778909,
0.0412380993,
0.0627646446,
0.0427688546,
-0.0143953692,
0.0338466987,
-0.0188530944,
0.0582190193,
-0.0391525477,
-0.0527821034,
-0.0024746279,
0.0368926376,
0.0723808184,
0.0067133396,
-0.0077962549,
-0.0245483872,
-0.0632241145,
-0.0587327369,
-0.0250356067,
0.016585432,
-0.0309562571,
-0.0171867032,
0.0010618923,
0.0749417916,
0.0363994353,
0.0399960577,
-0.0473931544,
-0.014686537,
0.026080694,
0.013517024,
-0.0273472127,
-0.0864130706,
-0.0522119477,
0.0051590903,
0.0207800642,
-0.0621945746,
-0.0330907702,
-0.0324704424,
-0.0109694116,
0.0472566336,
-0.0844277963,
0.0248598885,
-0.0273451861,
-0.0015901491,
-0.0297082178,
0.0066498835,
-0.0352072679,
-0.0143341003,
0.0378430523,
-0.0253741387,
0.0274498966,
0.0189395063,
-0.005810841,
0.0026069146,
-0.0050015128,
0.0032394642,
0.0281612538,
-0.064997144,
0.0261122286,
-0.0202316977,
-0.020081589,
-0.0305681489,
-0.0207889844,
0.0344097726,
-0.0028301743,
0.0377057754,
0.0569001548,
0.0440867916,
-0.0508083738,
-0.005138272,
-0.0256052874,
0.0248761512,
0.0073093036,
0.0202147588,
-0.0343177617,
0.0145199038,
-0.0185070839,
0.0137934219,
-0.0249888189,
-0.0149381654,
-0.045854006,
-0.0248546172,
0.0097644944,
0.0066557704,
0.0035462375,
0.0637775362,
0.0096866991,
-0.0490982644,
-0.0676086023,
-0.0144252926,
0.041521769,
0.006475789,
0.0268906727,
-0.0374528877,
0.004734416,
0.0098603852,
-0.0032303371,
-0.0415162332,
0.0517002828,
-0.0346900038,
0.0471809059,
-0.0520923994,
-0.0572073124,
-0.0519841276,
-0.0230884533,
0.0605447963,
0.0150606437,
0.0190959331,
0.0472112,
-0.0574269481,
-0.0332937911,
0.0235879235,
0.0043651806,
-0.0094808452,
0.0215395913,
0.007789501,
0.0136971446,
-0.0198336206,
-0.0499564335,
-0.00232754,
0.044662971,
-0.0272927564,
-0.0069453688,
0.0201118533,
-0.022207398,
-0.0187414791,
0.0371111706,
-0.0659695044,
-0.0077930912,
0.0226958971,
-0.0492157489,
0.0011790424,
0.0816820785,
-0.0186926406,
0.025700599,
0.0155282328,
0.0617459863,
-0.0545597821,
0.018828325,
-0.0143963946,
0.042436298,
0.0253744572,
0.040665742,
0.0467403978,
0.0411246829,
0.1002955735,
0.0384607725,
-0.0540327802,
-0.0155639993,
-0.0468794294,
0.0311437678,
-0.0166087393,
0.0373339541,
0.0048316517,
0.01939236,
-0.0196861345,
0.0045278911,
0.0133182239,
0.0481806062,
0.0324553698,
0.0294803251,
0.02154232,
-0.0390468463,
-0.0164659582,
0.0157923624,
-0.0171129983,
0.0102190943,
0.0345454775,
-0.0338852629,
-0.0376236401,
-0.0155353704,
0.0066082496,
-0.0209145918,
0.0667794123,
-0.0458448641,
-0.0239998046,
-0.1082704961,
0.0873433724,
0.004325462,
0.0411258154,
-0.013909637,
0.0097659118,
-0.0019775596,
-0.016077783,
0.0386647582,
0.0214547515,
-0.0404457226,
-0.078965947,
0.0557242408,
0.0298681408,
-0.08135847,
-0.0366603211,
0.0359595716,
-0.0426775925,
0.0185510367,
-0.0309088882,
0.0606152453,
0.0465207994,
-0.0101101855,
-0.0127031775,
-0.0093365014,
-0.0279935226,
-0.0027926883,
0.0222853106,
0.0039138808,
-0.0237883534,
0.0145100048,
0.01244999,
-0.0105970614,
-0.0732671097,
0.0389510095,
-0.055587776,
0.0131240003,
-0.017816104,
-0.0090300012,
-0.0467429645,
0.0385635272,
-0.0301359762,
0.0193276219,
0.0453569479,
-0.0163509063,
-0.0371460505,
0.026959816,
0.0255693998,
-0.0027630678,
0.0288908929,
-0.005210835,
0.0266277082,
0.0047670044,
-0.0109639736,
-0.0210249498,
0.0098107923,
-0.0066368682,
-0.0117574278,
0.0112666823,
0.0170100089,
0.0131226946,
0.050376635,
0.0021453151,
0.076374352,
0.0666603968,
-0.0374254696,
-0.0036873959,
-0.0073341201,
-0.038252987,
-0.0837819129,
-0.0040031471,
-0.016650429,
-0.0246117823,
0.0098706996,
0.0409825481,
0.0541641116,
-0.0410639979,
-0.0015478682,
0.027586747,
-0.0098759299,
-0.0614150316,
0.0223228466,
0.0061169807,
-0.0097610559,
-0.0101070134,
0.0676549301,
0.0038465704,
-0.0813889354,
0.0109013375,
-0.0573144406,
0.0386388265,
0.0797423273,
0.012022729,
-0.0602574646,
-0.0392739139,
-0.0297689494,
-0.0284373071,
0.0113366852,
0.0076800524,
0.0128207346,
-0.0632392839,
-0.0187265202,
0.0052086986,
-0.084190242,
-0.038912084,
-0.0068280692,
-0.0087771947,
-0.0158870034,
-0.0683942139,
-0.0213290863,
-0.0163980518,
0.0273423009,
-0.0134999147,
-0.0414285064,
-0.0180925652,
0.0198220722,
-0.0477208868,
-0.0058618723,
0.0635189861,
0.0274365302,
0.041219078,
-0.0365954451,
0.0284572002,
-0.0523027405,
-0.0146866273,
-0.0216484126,
0.0695072785,
0.0332996957,
-0.0217941497,
0.0619345829,
-0.023490455,
-0.0450171456,
0.0017324011,
0.0211601742,
0.0414508283,
-0.0076542618,
-0.0250847433,
-0.0089471573,
-0.0175725073,
-0.0051697488,
0.0189304594,
0.0850182325,
0.004629293,
-0.0255124234,
-0.0130744781,
-0.0012887168,
-0.0480452105,
-0.0244442336,
0.0086489487,
-0.038841784,
-0.0052899704,
-0.0340513885,
0.0315064266,
-0.0125103202,
-0.0011748637,
0.0364828445,
0.0090879826,
-0.0137743633,
-0.0384271257,
-0.0839070231,
-0.0304435901,
-0.0525883548,
0.038068898,
0.0053257658,
0.0186071787,
0.0102236019,
0.020952234,
-0.0244311094,
-0.0010433123,
-0.1005013138,
-0.0342385285,
-0.0735228285,
0.0362065136,
0.0075052325,
0.0269400701,
-0.0159967896,
-0.0021117781,
-0.0152215799,
-0.0173061937,
0.0189636946,
-0.015422781,
0.0064744856,
-0.0653572008,
0.0203459542,
0.0105572892,
-0.0474222451,
0.0021716179,
0.0635161176,
-0.0454195887,
-0.034561865,
0.0201458782,
0.0272035748,
0.0324215256,
0.0321615003,
0.0293332897,
0.004331124,
0.0090350164,
-0.0267001931,
0.0287533626,
-0.0140412701,
-0.0233713333,
0.0402338654,
0.0132764578,
0.0020893519,
0.0389749445,
0.0276632886,
-0.0169790648,
0.0279980153,
-0.0053901356,
0.0237898286,
-0.0122141978,
0.0956043378,
0.0136361485,
0.0124517288,
-0.0030130141,
0.0100860838,
0.0081696939,
0.044533249,
-0.0352381878,
0.0309860054,
0.0200357642,
0.0532971807,
0.0248387624,
0.0384103134,
-0.0232123397,
-0.0609802902,
0.0002553517,
-0.0491563864,
0.0538487583,
0.0070824521,
0.0643898398,
0.0231835879,
0.02565974,
-0.0163714569,
0.0294329356,
-0.0396590531,
-0.0090877162,
-0.0215520449,
0.0096591432,
-0.0280747712,
-0.0304141734,
0.1106028035,
-0.006607628,
-0.0132165393,
-0.0561645105,
-0.0252354052,
-0.0370180011,
0.0334991328,
0.0842474401,
0.0104939835,
-0.0180533286,
-0.0368119404,
-0.0499337688,
-0.0358328074,
0.0109791178,
0.0267435815,
0.002969142,
0.0436176397,
-0.012616735,
0.0898223072,
0.0070997225,
-0.019420648,
-0.0149508854,
0.0063491222,
0.0123993792,
-0.0534316823,
-0.0299759153,
-4.983727603e-33,
0.0061795525,
0.0019089163,
-0.0420004502,
-0.0065543437,
-0.0140709383,
0.036738269,
-0.0489903316,
-0.0085041402,
-0.0403628498,
-0.0505913943,
0.0345538668,
0.0096618673,
-0.0042249803,
-0.0707974434,
0.0623233989,
0.0477548204,
0.0441437326,
0.0607273616,
-0.0608275346,
0.0479610823,
-0.0214268062,
0.007430959,
0.0749141723,
-0.0657097921,
-0.0353635065,
-0.0193176158,
0.0729796365,
-0.0303306915,
0.0531091765,
0.0423290767,
0.025398368,
-0.0014459061,
0.0134928664,
-0.0452167913,
-0.0692824349,
-0.0868652463,
-0.0105676232,
-0.0459904261,
0.0141829588,
-0.0093070883,
0.0254010335,
-0.0289808884,
0.0405053496,
0.0004538284,
0.0066645816,
0.0082400497,
0.051256232,
0.0078814691,
-0.028607795,
0.0141574666,
-0.0643111691,
0.0231248923,
-0.030597141,
0.0404946394,
0.0219313912,
0.0922649726,
0.0067731952,
0.0632604882,
-0.0369540937,
0.045683641,
-0.0567497127,
0.0624433234,
0.0926371589,
-0.0017895332,
0.0154406391,
0.0180758983,
0.0337430686,
-0.011823575,
0.0682904571,
-0.0016459008,
0.0418349318,
0.0310453139,
0.0296203196,
0.0553014316,
0.0284246095,
-0.0015522098,
0.0085927146,
0.051742062,
-0.0080872588,
0.0071817865,
-0.013114322,
0.0485939831,
-0.036175739,
-0.0108223474,
0.0081390049,
-0.0454982854,
-0.0136499666,
-0.0453367755,
0.0377992839,
-0.0254353639,
-0.0142855467,
0.0591089465,
0.0466071106,
-0.0341757089,
-0.0098009612,
0.0106706647,
-0.0325874686,
-0.0063322545,
-0.003586822,
0.0047817011,
-0.0216747019,
-0.038978789,
-0.0177786704,
0.0049424414,
0.1078372374,
0.0208897628,
0.0590147041,
-0.0035123813,
-0.07927645,
-0.0024451579,
-0.0105762314,
-0.0541338697,
-0.0625400916,
0.0200636424,
-0.0238307919,
-0.0066009485,
0.0279703178,
-0.0214420352,
0.062162824,
-0.0750562251,
-0.0291555468,
0.0097047882,
0.0146654686,
0.0225741044,
-0.0367239565,
-0.0190127101,
-0.0580996722,
0.042139709,
0.020602135,
-0.0425319597,
-0.0650863647,
0.0036873105,
2.692e-7,
-0.0053602257,
-0.006722508,
0.0062413127,
-0.015019808,
0.0002962018,
0.0546909198,
-0.0313706361,
0.0323995948,
-0.0081801983,
0.020421138,
-0.0183197726,
-0.0092440061,
0.0209351052,
0.0367019549,
-0.0571187213,
0.0374810025,
-0.0454180315,
-0.0095485272,
-0.0592890978,
0.0170378648,
0.0442987382,
0.0529177226,
0.001918732,
-0.005365706,
0.046350304,
-0.034208037,
-0.0172223281,
-0.0066507952,
0.0496237725,
0.0502033308,
-0.0681623891,
-0.0185623802,
-0.0275246203,
-0.0014520675,
-0.0181281064,
-0.0052154185,
0.0243963338,
-0.0123446491,
-0.016264284,
0.0495704673,
0.0305653531,
-0.0392777808,
-0.0062339981,
-0.0617824085,
0.0130382897,
-0.0044706543,
0.0041152975,
-0.0214019753,
-0.0099147325,
0.0314437076,
0.0119953351,
0.0403788015,
0.0052138381,
0.0218457859,
0.0125490688,
-0.004751693,
-0.0679114014,
-0.0222224705,
-0.0378427505,
-0.0189465731,
0.0066876486,
-0.0087324632,
-0.0183329023,
-0.0130881341,
0.0186810922,
0.0083982022,
0.0675244778,
2.405195522e-34,
0.0144908251,
-0.0303049218,
0.0483921282,
0.0039374409,
-0.0026925982,
-0.028685553,
-0.0105998879,
0.0067027137,
-0.0454901941,
0.0365436822,
-0.0010830497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13738v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13738v1 | On Philomatics and Psychomatics for Combining Philosophy and Psychology with Mathematics | 2023-08-26T02:52:42 | 2023-08-26T02:52:42 | Benyamin Ghojogh, Morteza Babaie | math.HO | math.HO, cs.AI, cs.CL | We propose the concepts of philomatics and psychomatics as hybrid
combinations of philosophy and psychology with mathematics. We explain four
motivations for this combination which are fulfilling the desire of analytical
philosophy, proposing science of philosophy, justifying mathematical algorithms
by philosophy, and abstraction in both philosophy and mathematics. We enumerate
various examples for philomatics and psychomatics, some of which are explained
in more depth. The first example is the analysis of relation between the
context principle, semantic holism, and the usage theory of meaning with the
attention mechanism in mathematics. The other example is on the relations of
Plato's theory of forms in philosophy with the holographic principle in string
theory, object-oriented programming, and machine learning. Finally, the
relation between Wittgenstein's family resemblance and clustering in
mathematics is explained. This paper opens the door of research for combining
philosophy and psychology with mathematics. | [
-0.0314178728,
0.0462384038,
-0.0368335471,
0.0083009899,
-0.0515594967,
0.020509284,
-0.0052637127,
0.0232229903,
-0.017081622,
-0.021450486,
-0.021646034,
-0.0107644498,
0.0186233819,
-0.0406889766,
0.0224440433,
-0.116487518,
-0.0180045776,
0.0012836636,
0.000797233,
-0.0042196489,
-0.0550285392,
-0.0579850711,
-0.0348427258,
-0.0044658282,
0.0130447634,
-0.0512629859,
-0.0166717432,
-0.0438508727,
0.0158456564,
-0.0166866239,
-0.060021203,
-0.0669605359,
-0.0202778857,
0.0722305104,
0.0000017723,
-0.0520076379,
-0.0098467497,
0.04547989,
0.0232038908,
-0.0381077938,
-0.0100025795,
-0.0176882446,
0.0070738229,
-0.0103439838,
-0.0278461017,
0.0841644406,
0.040042989,
0.0162638091,
-0.0155001823,
0.0309001449,
0.0016738689,
-0.0846749172,
0.0809323043,
-0.0085636256,
0.0846237615,
0.0293283872,
-0.0137818847,
0.0039116121,
0.0225537512,
-0.00631409,
-0.0320732854,
0.009375657,
0.0567146875,
0.0367248058,
0.0127986167,
0.0004829142,
-0.0288462974,
0.036245171,
0.0283486359,
0.0155372648,
0.0518659391,
0.0246558581,
0.0431571715,
0.0374655351,
-0.0365984179,
0.006859127,
-0.0497948788,
0.0313969515,
-0.0092322631,
-0.0027057284,
0.068136543,
0.0143420734,
-0.0017849011,
0.0278047211,
-0.0180070233,
0.0790737271,
0.0100884046,
-0.0478767306,
0.0373999178,
0.0205463096,
-0.0404575579,
-0.0345719866,
-0.0193619411,
0.0229610242,
0.0046968497,
-0.0031290781,
0.0314577632,
-0.0366352722,
-0.0304862242,
-0.0522446334,
0.0436212495,
0.0301926788,
0.0167173054,
0.0079615964,
0.068667084,
0.051982034,
-0.018163085,
0.0238035172,
-0.0455765054,
0.0498824008,
-0.0779383108,
0.0007840858,
-0.0110190939,
0.0516271852,
0.0746779963,
0.0138008008,
-0.0745569989,
0.0320781209,
-0.0485302284,
-0.026546739,
-0.0662865266,
-0.0730478242,
-0.0061710351,
0.0119005218,
-0.0259794258,
-0.0239018127,
-0.0124807172,
-0.0176769979,
-0.0654752925,
0.0162449609,
0.0257888138,
0.0395905487,
-0.0391035639,
0.0062937667,
-0.0387762673,
0.0356567353,
0.0822977871,
0.0212633889,
-0.0122346897,
-0.0542713441,
0.0246840492,
0.0135683119,
0.032933455,
-0.0330075547,
-0.0298969932,
-0.0214520339,
-0.0140989209,
0.0138639612,
-0.0250818897,
-0.0192354582,
-0.0122492397,
0.0397329442,
-0.0166381933,
-0.0099435942,
0.0035956085,
0.0223801676,
-0.0228036512,
-0.0143305082,
-0.0027204228,
-0.0246585961,
0.0147632826,
-0.0529527031,
0.042319864,
-0.0213405397,
-0.0210050587,
-0.0380450487,
-0.0005458232,
-0.0268968288,
-0.0212151911,
0.0171168167,
-0.017683072,
0.0222911388,
-0.0128685143,
0.0237137582,
-0.0218039304,
0.0910559073,
0.0378461331,
0.0429643691,
-0.0096345339,
-0.0176664181,
0.0404987484,
0.0641232282,
-0.0552051328,
0.0410188399,
-0.0815453827,
0.0389379077,
0.0025753779,
-0.0571188107,
0.0072936476,
-0.0895210132,
0.0269949045,
-0.0075894655,
-0.0327155031,
0.0079285018,
0.0500735901,
-0.0363048837,
0.0542928539,
-0.0407557562,
0.0007845542,
0.0065595061,
0.0001578037,
-0.003044667,
0.0109164454,
0.008852548,
0.001905264,
-0.0581275821,
0.0837114528,
-0.0183796585,
-0.0188842807,
-0.0139442114,
-0.0062104827,
0.0098979035,
-0.0425130054,
0.0143300882,
0.0280865747,
-0.0209966749,
-0.0170192681,
-0.042526342,
-0.0826564804,
0.0220262036,
-0.0194934495,
0.0549250729,
0.0388285182,
0.0349007994,
-0.0213129465,
-0.0363120437,
-0.0123187164,
-0.0062078065,
0.0410004556,
-0.0015421564,
-0.0027795937,
0.0525031276,
-0.00451444,
-0.0302839726,
0.0600463599,
-0.0160442796,
-0.0088669201,
0.002490937,
0.0105508296,
-0.0775767565,
0.0703860819,
0.0084020691,
0.0066984147,
-0.0194044746,
0.0976933688,
-0.0546939448,
0.080462113,
0.0114218825,
0.0318669416,
-0.0307694692,
-0.0126556344,
-0.0165871233,
0.0476670414,
0.0131912231,
0.0783379823,
-0.0234423559,
-0.0117750941,
0.0220866818,
-0.0213023517,
-0.0238403082,
0.0209487453,
0.0182395764,
0.0180421211,
0.0230931584,
-0.0203252696,
-0.0113898087,
0.0379117131,
-0.0363285467,
-0.0266331714,
-0.0064646569,
0.0110591752,
0.0143403141,
-0.0406777002,
0.0037300892,
-0.0051952219,
0.0481337234,
0.0356524512,
-0.0072716856,
0.0152693605,
0.028643962,
0.0012986776,
-0.0352786146,
-0.0395348109,
-0.0468886197,
-0.05949549,
-0.0118827829,
0.0230412204,
0.0179548282,
-0.0125635006,
0.0064535048,
-0.0259011984,
-0.0005867878,
-0.0156520121,
0.0377236232,
0.0398709178,
0.0291912816,
0.0496027619,
0.0691163838,
-0.0209473521,
0.043416854,
-0.0175038986,
0.0048684189,
0.035170462,
-0.0342561081,
-0.0166848805,
0.029328458,
-0.0077884127,
-0.048618108,
0.0539915077,
0.0017158162,
-0.0093290368,
-0.0193093754,
-0.0045833318,
0.0514898598,
-0.0423125438,
0.012822954,
0.0316148251,
-0.0328663476,
-0.0227194484,
0.0364072658,
0.0141611919,
-0.012964474,
0.0275675245,
0.0454398058,
-0.0184219666,
-0.0369825177,
-0.0418573581,
-0.0152379274,
0.071078822,
0.025235055,
-0.0098730912,
0.052307833,
0.0083221653,
-0.0207748972,
-0.0436810888,
-0.0213322621,
0.0031572464,
0.0039928402,
-0.0257359464,
-0.0233479887,
-0.0086088246,
-0.0108351847,
-0.0284254849,
0.047414057,
-0.0237716641,
0.0162740201,
-0.0707477331,
0.0013936217,
-0.0362937003,
-0.0252148453,
0.0642443374,
-0.0256482009,
0.0358932465,
-0.0566131435,
-0.0236302335,
-0.0630568936,
0.0247327182,
-0.0462004282,
0.0483094938,
-0.0171100609,
-0.02229199,
0.0367494635,
0.0205217842,
0.02427442,
-0.0013297481,
0.010476076,
-0.0070959646,
-0.0414945707,
-0.1012569293,
0.0083616497,
-0.0466980189,
-0.0149096437,
0.0132934954,
0.0656685308,
0.0046207649,
-0.0176302791,
0.043277435,
-0.0929350108,
-0.0614469387,
0.0128469933,
0.0126396799,
0.0059424601,
0.0583716966,
-0.0276682582,
0.01429928,
-0.0312350895,
-0.0550419614,
0.0511616319,
-0.0080085965,
-0.005016156,
-0.0016327585,
-0.0161400605,
-0.0422631837,
0.0527084246,
0.0142689673,
0.0181452427,
-0.0607501864,
-0.01121144,
-0.0288541634,
0.044070445,
0.055819612,
-0.0184617992,
0.020544095,
-0.0260530803,
-0.0067312866,
-0.0620559789,
0.0031417622,
0.0555658564,
-0.0683345273,
-0.1302567869,
-0.0251009837,
0.0487060808,
-0.0151977791,
0.0258812588,
-0.0467398465,
0.0370891988,
0.0167951304,
-0.0505583547,
0.0204932019,
-0.0338731557,
-0.0378974564,
0.0451035053,
0.0524147674,
-0.0144979786,
-0.0280722566,
-0.0405087806,
0.0203411784,
-0.0317762718,
0.0067381058,
-0.021910537,
0.0010523029,
-0.0253768452,
-0.0021736841,
0.0266574733,
0.0925188959,
-0.0422043018,
-0.0195175782,
0.002554764,
-0.0415378921,
-0.0390332825,
0.027184125,
-0.0255271289,
0.0770434067,
-0.002460449,
-0.0218040161,
0.0156793408,
0.0004054348,
-0.0380263776,
0.0063903653,
0.0087408144,
-0.0147609394,
-0.0071152411,
0.0032933003,
0.0121632973,
-0.0171476044,
-0.0501090921,
-0.0265727453,
0.0470073819,
0.0026332843,
0.0078535331,
0.0195763167,
0.0250430554,
0.0139433714,
0.0295433663,
-0.010233758,
-0.0813498646,
-0.0006961969,
0.0100590345,
0.0557586662,
-0.0105788587,
0.0385248363,
0.0369280465,
-0.0139299529,
0.0303880665,
-0.004617726,
0.0268861745,
-0.0157949422,
-0.0766026825,
-0.0105969748,
0.0035176671,
0.0502857305,
0.0288963746,
0.0283564273,
-0.0027042725,
0.0552195422,
-0.0271165334,
0.0305251181,
-0.000912126,
-0.0298023988,
-0.0355299599,
0.0053484743,
0.0298686251,
-0.0095847435,
-0.0397692993,
0.0374103785,
-0.039225243,
0.0630735978,
0.039895732,
0.0108863786,
0.0218599439,
0.0160493366,
0.0219500437,
0.0363954306,
-0.0324821435,
-0.0300573222,
0.0806067064,
-0.0082713654,
-0.0014518301,
0.0705477968,
0.0165327787,
-0.0305537935,
-0.0220797788,
-0.0697760731,
-0.0781900808,
0.0245422386,
0.0064532701,
-0.0060491362,
-0.0018970782,
-0.0460952781,
-0.0557431877,
0.0267016683,
0.0169366859,
0.0283755567,
0.0228531156,
-0.0085783871,
-0.0025411537,
0.0534050502,
0.0149520114,
-0.0511575677,
0.0106797945,
-0.0564444922,
-0.0282090995,
-0.0144738471,
-0.0286593623,
-0.0327277407,
0.0250652973,
0.0301023014,
0.0794862881,
0.0282000322,
0.0279747322,
-0.049023129,
-0.0547236688,
0.0190139711,
-0.0074759033,
0.01831121,
-0.0033514067,
0.0739163682,
0.057940118,
-0.0037345211,
-0.0156366304,
0.0104599865,
0.0755781084,
-0.041590672,
-0.0334457904,
0.0108882086,
-4.860207024e-33,
-0.0252229515,
-0.045740936,
0.0068333745,
0.0426248834,
-0.0623374209,
-0.0586532392,
0.0086978292,
0.0011472488,
-0.0268666539,
0.0013517835,
-0.0207235087,
0.0151611501,
-0.0113723585,
-0.0158854872,
0.0313970968,
0.0009848271,
-0.0239322763,
-0.0342334174,
-0.0110601941,
-0.0328010209,
-0.023203373,
-0.032450892,
0.0497833043,
-0.0169909392,
0.0109706521,
-0.0073329327,
0.0713213906,
-0.0038154926,
-0.0015444831,
0.0207604803,
-0.0113914451,
0.0224829856,
0.0149917994,
0.0335674733,
-0.0342605412,
0.0645987019,
0.035454616,
-0.0827915594,
0.0242351927,
0.0400859937,
-0.0182312541,
-0.033835534,
0.037994206,
-0.024477832,
-0.0150301987,
-0.0196841862,
0.0561219715,
-0.0481947884,
-0.0339537598,
0.0049637551,
-0.0503512099,
-0.022341406,
-0.0370732993,
0.0088115791,
0.0856532827,
-0.0039200075,
-0.0161163826,
-0.019991532,
0.0213601198,
0.0233520027,
-0.0420836173,
-0.0070555443,
-0.0587280281,
0.0084743826,
0.0439032577,
0.0021453777,
0.0755864009,
-0.0226883516,
-0.0027687715,
0.005338612,
0.0323243439,
0.0597615205,
-0.0010393191,
-0.008268021,
0.0160023477,
0.0285346694,
-0.0535982735,
-0.0050371145,
0.0397257842,
-0.0420262851,
0.0303852428,
0.0394742601,
-0.0329973735,
-0.0105272187,
0.0313312449,
-0.0253070388,
-0.0217105355,
0.0274102055,
-0.0668084547,
-0.063418448,
0.0295381937,
0.0556969643,
0.0048946915,
-0.0663049817,
0.0322136842,
-0.0246182848,
0.009061344,
0.0317852311,
0.0392153598,
-0.013023762,
-0.0352687277,
-0.0022775941,
-0.0702983662,
0.0622734614,
0.0556497648,
-0.0134327505,
-0.0183969084,
0.0046818987,
0.0341354087,
-0.0368405133,
0.0072338209,
-0.0356157385,
0.0634481981,
-0.0096925832,
0.0399858132,
0.0358450264,
0.0094471229,
-0.0343753658,
-0.0149395373,
0.0018841011,
-0.0189522468,
0.0776316524,
-0.0391365588,
0.0264709778,
-0.0012950992,
-0.0443596765,
-0.0016256747,
0.0138941752,
0.0837019309,
-0.0293106455,
-0.0564167649,
-0.0324044861,
2.785e-7,
0.0050281067,
-0.0052950904,
-0.0097824503,
0.0128018865,
0.0341741592,
0.0143051259,
-0.0069156904,
-0.0074695097,
0.0084736813,
-0.0344289206,
0.029382458,
-0.0190138593,
-0.0102750193,
-0.0184592623,
-0.0143349813,
-0.0236378238,
-0.0030327823,
-0.0032860269,
-0.015101823,
0.0656859502,
0.0125211971,
0.0040009604,
0.0739389062,
0.0005261459,
-0.0119740115,
0.0555605367,
0.0065996498,
0.0195084848,
0.0692554936,
0.0350026526,
0.0086704167,
0.0195328593,
0.0192640871,
0.0301094651,
0.0816811621,
-0.0042995936,
0.0635395497,
-0.01193076,
0.0255194306,
0.024441611,
-0.0209768731,
-0.0454232544,
0.0051460108,
-0.0277564917,
0.0241835564,
-0.0204283036,
-0.0859753639,
0.0127506154,
-0.0237354208,
0.0155460862,
0.0413071178,
0.0315949246,
-0.0097205834,
0.0071134162,
0.0032391299,
-0.0273633543,
-0.0173382238,
-0.0015018921,
0.0536198094,
0.0561264269,
-0.0241429973,
-0.0090636928,
0.0026264952,
0.0081278877,
0.0435159765,
-0.0361290276,
-0.0345520899,
2.41235318e-34,
-0.0105381496,
-0.0029532108,
0.0335295387,
-0.0399631895,
-0.0474560298,
0.0078987097,
-0.028049754,
0.0130196298,
0.0551007353,
-0.0016623649,
-0.0249269176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13715v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13715v1 | A Computational Evaluation Framework for Singable Lyric Translation | 2023-08-26T00:27:08 | 2023-08-26T00:27:08 | Haven Kim, Kento Watanabe, Masataka Goto, Juhan Nam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Lyric translation plays a pivotal role in amplifying the global resonance of
music, bridging cultural divides, and fostering universal connections.
Translating lyrics, unlike conventional translation tasks, requires a delicate
balance between singability and semantics. In this paper, we present a
computational framework for the quantitative evaluation of singable lyric
translation, which seamlessly integrates musical, linguistic, and cultural
dimensions of lyrics. Our comprehensive framework consists of four metrics that
measure syllable count distance, phoneme repetition similarity, musical
structure distance, and semantic similarity. To substantiate the efficacy of
our framework, we collected a singable lyrics dataset, which precisely aligns
English, Japanese, and Korean lyrics on a line-by-line and section-by-section
basis, and conducted a comparative analysis between singable and non-singable
lyrics. Our multidisciplinary approach provides insights into the key
components that underlie the art of lyric translation and establishes a solid
groundwork for the future of computational lyric translation assessment. | [
0.0100713652,
0.0429584607,
-0.0221389383,
0.0206498485,
-0.0430192426,
0.001681076,
0.0447176769,
-0.0071280403,
-0.0503649935,
0.065912649,
-0.0772130862,
-0.019887628,
0.0816133693,
-0.0432336703,
0.002821641,
-0.0565670878,
-0.0085226754,
0.0073603988,
0.0454931408,
0.0085450485,
-0.0263410881,
-0.0071916799,
-0.0066118971,
0.0442867316,
-0.0142928371,
-0.0164470188,
-0.0013343743,
0.0616604574,
0.026616741,
-0.0203912612,
-0.0584367737,
-0.0147355143,
-0.0189962443,
0.0698027238,
0.0000013793,
-0.0443075038,
-0.0173803102,
-0.002806206,
0.0357447714,
-0.0163946077,
0.054459475,
-0.0296711177,
-0.0097197676,
-0.013342781,
0.0056019085,
-0.0060760807,
0.0515674651,
-0.0398753621,
0.0516778603,
0.0907304808,
0.0147696175,
-0.0452357195,
-0.0060128672,
-0.0420712754,
-0.0113054244,
-0.0052075405,
-0.0327608027,
0.0255483836,
-0.0100932186,
-0.0372039154,
-0.0443155542,
0.092703037,
-0.0216418747,
0.0241307672,
0.0054808077,
0.0025222662,
-0.0845895633,
-0.0251704082,
0.0414385051,
0.0121366838,
0.0124214292,
0.0067674005,
-0.00983229,
0.0335664302,
-0.0344047099,
-0.0209745541,
-0.0376321524,
-0.0112528224,
0.0609067902,
-0.00836612,
-0.0400491096,
0.0407368802,
0.0412191488,
-0.0433337726,
0.0048900889,
0.0071303197,
0.0344324335,
-0.0813900456,
0.0259963926,
-0.0079433257,
0.0062672952,
-0.0193355531,
0.0410991684,
-0.0291363876,
-0.0158690158,
0.0201685019,
0.0001721245,
-0.0639215112,
0.0123662399,
-0.037250936,
0.1094636545,
0.040391501,
-0.0118587632,
0.0390170403,
-0.0209428053,
0.0261661652,
0.011299476,
-0.0022508311,
-0.0669742823,
-0.008691499,
-0.0106869647,
0.0178934671,
-0.0525890291,
-0.0756869316,
0.0168020818,
-0.0177125987,
-0.0191016998,
-0.0310893841,
-0.009941021,
0.019409176,
0.0217978097,
-0.0490639992,
-0.0468201712,
-0.0142307663,
0.0366072878,
0.0343447737,
-0.0356600471,
0.0103828367,
-0.0241015479,
0.0048203222,
0.0085559608,
0.0173950847,
0.0306771342,
0.0054518608,
0.0351764336,
0.0133286566,
0.0749716833,
-0.0199666508,
0.021907866,
0.0071126055,
-0.0677623823,
-0.0489811525,
-0.0339063257,
-0.0663807988,
0.0845280215,
-0.0347365327,
-0.000395944,
-0.0345329829,
-5.077e-7,
-0.0089960862,
0.0140890544,
0.0248635318,
0.0432293974,
0.0748773664,
-0.0256522987,
0.0069445721,
-0.0112906815,
-0.0086636459,
0.0692090914,
0.0112488503,
0.0607043318,
-0.0339110866,
-0.0203866623,
0.0298929587,
0.0051316516,
0.0331389643,
-0.0458773226,
-0.0123400148,
-0.0030961283,
0.0916345045,
0.0011488098,
0.0262320042,
0.0225051008,
-0.0293143932,
0.0407345593,
0.0660984293,
0.0453842729,
0.0544231534,
0.0229679104,
0.018042529,
-0.0070382259,
-0.0062512448,
0.0001393059,
0.0287736319,
0.0600930899,
0.0243372507,
0.1086359322,
0.0104302559,
0.0202413928,
0.0195200853,
-0.0238197632,
-0.0007558816,
-0.0125141731,
-0.0076384009,
-0.0079086954,
0.0159824695,
0.0057668937,
0.0339856781,
-0.0124178613,
-0.0782275945,
0.0018193311,
0.0102081848,
-0.0173861906,
0.0532877333,
0.0341999009,
0.0083391154,
0.0563067384,
-0.0024895535,
0.0143500054,
0.0598119311,
-0.0178821217,
0.0140308635,
0.0388335809,
0.0174865983,
0.0187299624,
0.0251200572,
0.013933043,
0.0057590511,
-0.0259886514,
0.0537925661,
0.0214437414,
-0.0341432765,
-0.0352176428,
0.0013719165,
0.0320348628,
0.0043418468,
0.0433376394,
0.0476608872,
0.0355537757,
0.0583374463,
-0.0466715321,
0.0364026204,
-0.0134974187,
-0.0091195293,
-0.0052567064,
0.0423373915,
-0.002890273,
-0.0404112004,
0.0456706248,
-0.0619967692,
0.0210318156,
-0.0105850855,
0.0094073946,
-0.0459225513,
0.0684466809,
-0.0208897237,
0.0065414044,
0.0148817645,
0.0676301792,
-0.0526279174,
0.0109839672,
0.0338113345,
-0.037270695,
0.0491599403,
0.0347180553,
-0.0318479538,
-0.0168384928,
0.0605715699,
-0.0243569762,
-0.0472032502,
0.0440835468,
0.0269059055,
0.0086635556,
-0.01966778,
-0.0196207464,
-0.0457052924,
-0.0709064528,
-0.0933644325,
0.0307886507,
-0.0226914007,
-0.0119426493,
0.052847717,
0.0090814456,
-0.0221712738,
0.0019918846,
-0.0156383868,
0.0047543962,
0.0107965283,
0.0331081897,
-0.0541967452,
-0.0212551635,
-0.0473682806,
-0.0089377258,
-0.0088927252,
0.0170123912,
-0.01473941,
-0.0299222339,
0.0063515278,
-0.0053114765,
0.0076174447,
-0.0889842212,
-0.0864581838,
0.0357702821,
-0.0302843079,
-0.0115223695,
-0.0182476845,
0.0351778418,
0.019704869,
-0.0178650822,
-0.035986688,
0.0738783553,
-0.0497857183,
0.0165959373,
-0.0261177253,
-0.0008951775,
-0.0175100192,
0.0141947567,
-0.0499108918,
0.0243190546,
0.0056916741,
0.074395746,
-0.0286711045,
-0.0000677432,
-0.0135526266,
-0.0730800778,
0.0272679012,
-0.0164540559,
0.0487758145,
-0.0030348497,
0.0491017327,
-0.044554472,
-0.0253817663,
0.0388784483,
-0.0441850126,
0.0024393711,
-0.0373689756,
-0.0389637984,
-0.0517506376,
0.0372270532,
-0.0672512725,
0.0292721242,
-0.0381980315,
-0.0086980211,
-0.0058327015,
0.0480071232,
-0.0054480224,
-0.0546759143,
0.034688063,
-0.0195186473,
-0.0256921649,
-0.0018178194,
0.0112901339,
0.0386498235,
-0.0112261362,
0.0286701694,
-0.034629982,
-0.0087093655,
-0.0249823686,
0.0328171663,
0.0088845808,
0.0219194442,
0.0159936678,
0.0000823819,
-0.0050449222,
0.0191797707,
0.0260013472,
-0.0336031094,
-0.007305258,
-0.0094466684,
-0.0147763118,
0.0327759609,
-0.0197653119,
0.0192477237,
0.0065585491,
-0.0088587273,
-0.0025271534,
0.007875653,
0.0284370873,
0.0066781319,
-0.0154674826,
0.0432705693,
-0.0512096435,
0.013448623,
0.0973158628,
0.0143367238,
-0.003275028,
0.0044093993,
-0.0202978253,
0.029099416,
0.0122123314,
0.004957323,
-0.0077258111,
0.007984384,
0.0262401979,
0.0576165281,
0.0381408371,
0.0043952637,
-0.0241845567,
-0.0346822329,
-0.0045789247,
0.0411661454,
-0.0399097055,
-0.0279014837,
0.0016269959,
-0.019731503,
0.0181271937,
-0.0149685284,
-0.0181505345,
0.0024539796,
0.0285515878,
-0.0236022417,
-0.0002369122,
0.0003474839,
0.0133868568,
-0.0827592313,
0.0622799881,
0.0373630039,
0.0812542066,
0.002286162,
-0.0278734006,
-0.04346608,
-0.0150531298,
-0.0077239028,
0.0563525558,
0.0065599671,
0.0718362406,
-0.0251318496,
0.0099899666,
-0.0184300635,
-0.0524699725,
0.0214553922,
0.0445789695,
0.0305846818,
-0.0034266063,
0.0021059187,
0.0273452718,
0.0608361848,
-0.0046046176,
0.0832393914,
0.0533907153,
-0.0333885103,
0.032026682,
-0.0133983754,
0.0107758464,
-0.0530277118,
-0.0280769691,
-0.0007480812,
-0.0433404669,
-0.0370085612,
-0.0566778444,
-0.012732612,
-0.0274475403,
0.0084915524,
0.0521127135,
-0.0081487987,
-0.0474289246,
-0.0321931466,
-0.0530539304,
-0.0056838025,
-0.0321552828,
0.0816353559,
-0.0259608086,
-0.0337492824,
-0.0214415751,
0.0153212622,
0.0101880701,
-0.0359918363,
-0.0783933252,
-0.0197504181,
-0.0007451422,
-0.0016781865,
0.0180892255,
0.0163043365,
-0.025843177,
0.0082953312,
-0.0388743989,
-0.0190962013,
-0.011507038,
0.0330361351,
0.0340700336,
-0.0093157664,
0.0137366736,
0.017637698,
-0.0263318084,
0.0070291907,
0.0254188441,
0.0625576153,
0.0429000184,
-0.0628268495,
0.0358907469,
0.0214146245,
0.0063244202,
-0.0105632301,
-0.0331151895,
-0.0093390634,
-0.0425051376,
-0.0057257372,
0.0007621023,
-0.0259698573,
-0.0467596054,
0.0969019234,
0.0701314732,
-0.018346414,
0.0155878654,
-0.0039802389,
-0.0784469917,
-0.0226615667,
0.007558438,
0.0401443839,
-0.0129232435,
-0.0094167311,
0.0223973431,
-0.0238684341,
0.0006636014,
0.0255052485,
-0.0070015113,
0.0266277455,
-0.0177303553,
0.006001459,
-0.0091567598,
0.0141762597,
0.0286392104,
-0.005091046,
-0.0201217141,
0.0289805438,
-0.0277414303,
0.0592019632,
0.0095974589,
0.0547424592,
0.0187385678,
-0.0171072632,
0.0066135037,
0.0246980563,
0.007394311,
-0.054967124,
-0.0595334657,
0.0124812815,
0.0248009842,
0.0239836052,
0.0572045892,
-0.0560214482,
-0.0207325164,
0.0047817617,
-0.0348817669,
0.053958375,
-0.0103677418,
-0.0515705161,
-0.0324901454,
0.0109793143,
-0.0139587037,
-0.0439739488,
-0.0747570395,
-0.0017715979,
0.015436152,
0.0456344001,
0.0063745207,
-0.0181129035,
0.0344756097,
-0.0395732224,
0.0422984213,
-0.0346531197,
-0.0283685364,
-0.0208526179,
0.0081308326,
0.0004334958,
-4.61694655e-33,
-0.027027322,
0.0000555061,
-0.0341484807,
-0.0014352245,
-0.0767747909,
-0.0377008915,
-0.1044437513,
0.0384285673,
0.0028559458,
-0.0064439047,
0.0310685728,
0.0117154727,
-0.0075032059,
0.00407275,
0.0269616432,
0.0211779941,
0.03197046,
0.0214256477,
-0.0990628451,
0.0222625695,
0.0566891842,
0.0164484419,
-0.0202999841,
-0.0422137715,
0.0512219183,
0.0025120371,
0.0182386618,
0.0234963577,
0.0542127267,
0.0134322448,
-0.0019627698,
0.019625498,
0.0238457676,
0.0139046749,
-0.0365234725,
-0.0134170987,
-0.0522580743,
-0.0321790986,
0.002326183,
0.0560292862,
0.0314596333,
-0.0068754307,
0.0119846361,
-0.0353741832,
-0.0275748856,
-0.0249025468,
-0.0074649556,
-0.0717913061,
-0.0295635909,
-0.0477956682,
-0.0282242186,
-0.0067097968,
-0.0607023463,
-0.0134476628,
0.0443453677,
0.0200520679,
-0.0299173053,
0.0562958047,
-0.0303875823,
0.0406511128,
-0.0550068803,
0.0390775278,
0.0493955016,
0.0086982129,
-0.0100593278,
0.0271130688,
0.0318035968,
-0.0817723349,
0.0073166252,
0.0486384705,
0.0101598995,
0.0034230789,
0.0264241491,
0.010815436,
0.0610271171,
-0.0284956414,
0.0295462683,
0.0157048646,
-0.0459033698,
-0.0338248797,
0.0118954405,
0.0576648265,
-0.02156833,
-0.0071746749,
-0.0199948307,
-0.0525216311,
-0.0251967125,
-0.0510348566,
0.0374782719,
-0.0285759941,
-0.0483002551,
0.001142796,
0.0111705493,
-0.0357199945,
0.0046525984,
-0.0188702717,
-0.0175334364,
0.0242222808,
-0.0030744197,
-0.0026150881,
0.0042052777,
-0.0197894964,
0.0445513912,
0.0200394019,
0.0452827662,
-0.0643431842,
0.0519857444,
0.0567286275,
-0.0512097999,
-0.0018329566,
-0.0273314193,
-0.0622743182,
-0.0063170893,
-0.0184733849,
0.003532466,
0.0231858864,
-0.000484986,
0.0176399536,
0.061433658,
0.0301907938,
-0.005173522,
-0.0085819066,
-0.0310582314,
-0.0234131627,
-0.0051910779,
-0.0023677067,
-0.0128825698,
-0.0257888511,
0.0196395628,
-0.0361254588,
-0.036132805,
-0.0201769006,
2.361e-7,
0.0338210985,
-0.0075694835,
0.011428779,
-0.0166582055,
0.0257520527,
0.0081665283,
-0.1224468648,
0.0185354147,
0.0072272778,
0.0257174186,
0.0551166125,
0.0097238002,
0.1160919294,
0.0373965688,
-0.0917680413,
0.0064587877,
-0.0678860396,
-0.0171584021,
-0.0910680071,
-0.0198098179,
0.0315942317,
0.0501015782,
0.0153072625,
-0.0098201884,
-0.0031249893,
-0.0218426697,
0.0207820795,
-0.0558795966,
0.0313138962,
-0.0667476654,
-0.0158740636,
-0.0185286775,
-0.0134188738,
-0.0170938876,
-0.0399376564,
0.042049963,
0.1027774662,
0.0422995687,
0.0569781102,
0.0059747924,
-0.0017257016,
0.0058421362,
-0.0102942679,
-0.0388284884,
0.0124301417,
0.0088481177,
-0.0630485937,
0.0307765678,
0.0061211674,
0.0403381586,
0.0274113379,
-0.0069823056,
-0.038358327,
-0.0327771828,
0.04588864,
-0.0108797224,
0.0138860261,
0.0157309771,
-0.0226289295,
-0.0102439113,
-0.0111613022,
-0.0419073068,
-0.0042926762,
0.0429467633,
0.0008626769,
-0.0509891026,
-0.0142997662,
1.561250041e-34,
0.0614666119,
-0.0492572784,
0.0082255285,
-0.0496578738,
0.0539950319,
-0.0511241481,
-0.0093717389,
-0.0168633554,
-0.0376601331,
-0.0293276776,
-0.0355186202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.13710v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.13710v1 | WellXplain: Wellness Concept Extraction and Classification in Reddit Posts for Mental Health Analysis | 2023-08-25T23:50:05 | 2023-08-25T23:50:05 | Muskan Garg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | During the current mental health crisis, the importance of identifying
potential indicators of mental issues from social media content has surged.
Overlooking the multifaceted nature of mental and social well-being can have
detrimental effects on one's mental state. In traditional therapy sessions,
professionals manually pinpoint the origins and outcomes of underlying mental
challenges, a process both detailed and time-intensive. We introduce an
approach to this intricate mental health analysis by framing the identification
of wellness dimensions in Reddit content as a wellness concept extraction and
categorization challenge. We've curated a unique dataset named WELLXPLAIN,
comprising 3,092 entries and totaling 72,813 words. Drawing from Halbert L.
Dunn's well-regarded wellness theory, our team formulated an annotation
framework along with guidelines. This dataset also includes human-marked
textual segments, offering clear reasoning for decisions made in the wellness
concept categorization process. Our aim in publishing this dataset and
analyzing initial benchmarks is to spearhead the creation of advanced language
models tailored for healthcare-focused concept extraction and categorization. | [
0.0653410703,
0.0920326263,
-0.0087946774,
-0.0221560504,
0.0153376414,
0.0284261536,
-0.0234187189,
0.036738053,
0.0597270504,
-0.0571874119,
-0.0078515727,
0.0451708063,
-0.0368598476,
0.0285484251,
0.0007593983,
-0.0461743362,
0.0256574955,
0.0477155223,
0.0496835448,
0.0199805554,
0.0125165572,
0.0275241211,
-0.0263151433,
0.0164175965,
0.0045564678,
-0.0041426271,
0.1092853472,
-0.0003537124,
0.0201638397,
-0.0839616954,
0.029746484,
0.0672719926,
-0.0566353127,
0.0093868077,
0.0000017464,
0.0074298861,
-0.0106698265,
0.0010556725,
0.0185235813,
-0.0744296759,
0.0618373901,
-0.0854594186,
0.0182095189,
0.0005753979,
-0.0138902012,
-0.030752603,
0.0283645112,
0.0494190082,
0.0521293133,
0.0571060665,
-0.0236819256,
-0.0443413518,
-0.0413355529,
0.0137155717,
-0.0066626715,
0.0229976568,
0.0608795621,
-0.0416637883,
0.0377775282,
-0.0201955326,
0.0260800887,
0.0076555097,
-0.0443385579,
0.0258779172,
0.0064502712,
0.0150365513,
-0.0102404021,
-0.0154199647,
-0.0026135717,
0.0896639973,
0.0155649437,
0.03343473,
0.0319966301,
0.0063160518,
-0.007763485,
-0.0051953262,
-0.0185597818,
-0.0028934507,
-0.0235129483,
0.017704973,
0.0249829758,
0.0385135002,
0.0416344367,
0.0237570237,
0.0462954193,
0.0491673462,
-0.0121719157,
-0.0395769551,
-0.0024753131,
-0.0077050207,
-0.0013880942,
-0.0372237377,
0.0420248061,
0.0122884875,
0.0294973534,
0.038442865,
-0.0015024177,
-0.0358204655,
0.0556062199,
-0.0159048904,
-0.0259885341,
-0.0096442942,
-0.0132668866,
0.0143310232,
0.0689396635,
-0.0381042361,
0.0138285505,
-0.0129892314,
-0.0327222534,
0.038716536,
-0.063829042,
0.0155605068,
-0.0426143706,
0.001022118,
0.0348474719,
-0.0140989628,
-0.0529834144,
-0.0148254335,
-0.0442464352,
-0.0573950447,
-0.0135142207,
-0.0202289075,
0.0150893405,
-0.0017399663,
0.0103561217,
0.0067673689,
-0.0248952396,
-0.004440011,
-0.0089671705,
-0.0310840588,
0.0290254224,
-0.0007190167,
0.0222721528,
-0.04300154,
0.0197758172,
-0.0227341466,
0.065807119,
-0.064888157,
-0.0249818135,
-0.0263217185,
-0.0463497825,
-0.0093248133,
0.0055390182,
-0.0624799505,
0.0383864418,
-0.0180475991,
0.0214037448,
-0.0238648411,
0.031227177,
0.0275541786,
-0.085971646,
0.0489313379,
-0.0615569018,
0.0194546189,
0.0301203206,
0.0295629483,
0.0501147732,
0.0448563248,
0.0012807524,
-0.0206207801,
0.0980698317,
-0.0305528976,
0.0009855917,
0.0063298978,
0.0006350981,
-0.0285336636,
0.023113491,
-0.0166203585,
-0.0117793716,
0.020962188,
-0.0563767143,
0.0244109817,
-0.009329576,
0.0490576476,
0.0313569903,
0.1005975604,
-0.0329049006,
0.027505165,
-0.0322925895,
0.0190473087,
0.0014524729,
-0.0307527725,
-0.024149606,
-0.0242397562,
-0.0119024711,
-0.0427748859,
0.0174878631,
0.0187349562,
-0.0178131517,
-0.0440787971,
-0.0770736039,
-0.0320749097,
0.01649924,
-0.0400351621,
0.0058920858,
0.0007191604,
0.0184235685,
0.0263118278,
0.0603564568,
-0.0576735362,
0.0028835214,
-0.0219635125,
0.0375659056,
0.0293183252,
0.0115561942,
-0.0627378002,
-0.0353501886,
-0.0140651297,
0.0961687267,
0.0302880406,
0.0187358558,
0.0000655553,
-0.0222357996,
-0.0043226797,
0.0020184915,
0.0126484819,
0.0294226483,
-0.0658290237,
0.0054572909,
0.0164519083,
-0.0495547429,
0.0355338193,
-0.0089930547,
0.0512609296,
0.0611093231,
-0.0156302266,
0.0168443825,
-0.0002321004,
0.0284499153,
0.0519854687,
0.0148523329,
0.0237275716,
0.00177321,
-0.0570089817,
-0.0444893353,
0.0101115033,
0.0033170406,
0.0086057484,
-0.0007455685,
-0.0079148654,
-0.0121267252,
0.0386643633,
-0.03862115,
0.0027523804,
0.0377103016,
-0.0425650589,
0.0015485225,
0.0146287661,
-0.0490553044,
0.0163811054,
0.0206247792,
-0.031452179,
0.0478178523,
-0.0530439764,
0.04625744,
-0.0500005446,
-0.0631295517,
-0.054865703,
-0.0008566527,
-0.0140307955,
-0.000330415,
-0.0327561013,
-0.0177441742,
0.0263186861,
0.0286127161,
-0.036329221,
-0.0141950138,
-0.0825654194,
0.0059758257,
-0.0415247492,
0.0212395266,
0.0305573214,
-0.0020989988,
-0.0140974224,
-0.0304516591,
-0.0312114023,
0.0231589954,
0.0202762727,
0.0595768727,
0.0039677988,
-0.0225208253,
0.0366497152,
-0.0223444197,
-0.0295724012,
-0.0332385451,
-0.0203948524,
0.0165771432,
-0.0192260928,
0.0093758805,
-0.0575453453,
-0.0468039289,
-0.038436573,
0.0062930943,
-0.020596303,
-0.029157117,
0.0093733724,
0.0206952058,
0.0028953066,
0.0271232389,
0.0444475561,
0.0032714878,
0.0443951972,
0.0298301578,
0.0060668015,
-0.0637429208,
0.000931196,
-0.0187617689,
-0.0564934686,
0.0429295711,
0.0726488456,
0.0202943478,
0.0034761857,
-0.039522972,
0.0391565636,
-0.0736814961,
0.0123364981,
-0.0426970385,
0.0216615424,
-0.0085608829,
0.0155187538,
-0.0270037986,
-0.0235097911,
0.0441316739,
0.0340769067,
0.0254041981,
-0.0560923778,
-0.0413238779,
-0.0371678732,
0.0026393835,
0.0112852687,
0.0198525041,
0.0442501977,
-0.0130326301,
0.0707651898,
-0.0186553262,
-0.0163031444,
-0.0520809926,
0.0323297158,
-0.0310681853,
-0.002367015,
0.0306728669,
-0.0350625627,
-0.0222175084,
-0.0477423593,
-0.0455963574,
-0.023415301,
0.0176603924,
0.0374442823,
-0.020951679,
-0.0207070075,
-0.0414499678,
0.0244098119,
0.0049285535,
-0.0167182833,
0.0324343294,
0.0203522239,
0.0604385622,
0.0140017243,
0.0117360009,
0.0208116751,
0.0076019512,
0.0873512775,
-0.0403578542,
-0.0010439066,
0.0598833486,
0.0035280529,
0.0195465796,
-0.0456036068,
0.0276024546,
-0.0222357027,
0.0204810351,
-0.0139543023,
-0.0373791121,
0.0770439729,
0.0087239062,
-0.015436694,
0.0534767024,
-0.0130694434,
-0.0497229472,
0.0212952569,
-0.0017715595,
-0.0353864469,
-0.0232455116,
-0.0423223376,
0.0476410203,
-0.0278731324,
-0.01945737,
0.0229490623,
-0.0175091717,
0.0216524024,
-0.0153296459,
-0.0476239622,
0.0081950277,
-0.0552347191,
0.0133254686,
-0.0318381228,
-0.0440575331,
-0.0276878402,
-0.0041116462,
0.0064568492,
0.0132055087,
-0.0708444491,
-0.0281794332,
0.0217938516,
0.023469748,
0.0131170759,
0.0486026071,
0.0669261292,
0.0216962229,
-0.0474844314,
0.0207461771,
-0.0521607324,
-0.0080527496,
-0.0152706988,
0.0804336444,
-0.0118692899,
0.0147283245,
-0.0358203426,
0.0925478265,
-0.1016224772,
-0.0367074162,
-0.0151800485,
0.0589433908,
0.0248311833,
-0.0496537909,
-0.0352264643,
0.0358614437,
0.0541628711,
0.0425918549,
0.0185636654,
-0.0026367174,
0.0048045656,
0.0343554802,
0.0395137444,
-0.0179001763,
-0.0345834643,
-0.0110956738,
-0.0369713083,
-0.0403855592,
-0.070657067,
-0.0469768196,
0.022108648,
-0.0276461132,
-0.0333735012,
-0.0269427989,
0.0073413574,
0.0390800685,
-0.0607545748,
0.0754376277,
0.0119400499,
0.0139254313,
-0.0193799511,
-0.0636999011,
0.02130582,
0.0270591229,
-0.0012989423,
0.0384221822,
-0.0301411431,
0.007054857,
0.0362725928,
0.0085501932,
0.0061752517,
-0.0252431352,
-0.0255346484,
-0.0351986922,
0.0297564771,
0.0402592942,
-0.0872410163,
-0.0346508734,
0.0038985813,
0.0449449942,
0.0164296161,
0.0451341905,
-0.0030537443,
0.0501364991,
0.0148956478,
-0.0039089699,
-0.0460290499,
-0.0285788383,
-0.0226106849,
0.0243083648,
0.0387983359,
0.0029567615,
-0.0021842257,
-0.0376230553,
-0.066188246,
-0.0007567021,
-0.0263050143,
-0.0154529409,
-0.018780943,
0.0381847546,
0.0009265454,
-0.0677952617,
0.0210652929,
-0.0163928028,
0.0199714042,
-0.0812978372,
-0.0049570557,
-0.0000713246,
0.0186212752,
-0.0229122844,
-0.0122980503,
-0.0000052963,
0.0463259108,
-0.0160738025,
-0.0291023292,
-0.0351334363,
0.0729876161,
-0.0119628077,
-0.0044372766,
0.0083817597,
0.0508063249,
-0.0421952009,
-0.0231193956,
0.0115968483,
-0.0279211923,
0.0243450906,
0.0000586617,
0.0690731779,
0.0157573652,
-0.0545252971,
0.0021132447,
0.0270641502,
-0.04622541,
-0.0282103475,
0.0663667694,
0.0057380106,
-0.0253046378,
-0.0385081843,
0.0343295634,
-0.0713551939,
0.0155521519,
0.0750710294,
-0.0251159389,
-0.0075243651,
-0.0014976126,
-0.0347697325,
0.0708024353,
-0.0352369957,
0.0191071965,
-0.0604909025,
-0.0554522313,
0.0434742607,
-0.0483646616,
0.0168537516,
0.0349053703,
0.0310456622,
0.0290483851,
0.0276810303,
-0.0049655787,
-0.0694679394,
0.0359453894,
-0.0521545708,
-0.0156421363,
0.0170844793,
-5.482299573e-33,
0.0207201336,
-0.0173933003,
-0.004493251,
0.0397434719,
-0.0163267031,
0.0239637457,
-0.0026660622,
0.0098384218,
0.0232513603,
0.0395787507,
0.0498283878,
0.0276529975,
-0.0149818575,
0.0455150008,
0.0032269205,
-0.0085036978,
-0.00121561,
-0.0171652082,
-0.0314425975,
0.050994914,
0.0164318942,
0.0667021722,
0.035508547,
-0.0832952932,
0.0315937847,
0.0367949381,
0.0396653712,
0.0464509055,
0.0684746802,
0.0309069417,
-0.0717375875,
0.0955878571,
0.0612986945,
0.0105894832,
0.0178159159,
0.0239020083,
-0.0735637248,
-0.0735019892,
-0.035269469,
-0.0119604645,
-0.0535064712,
-0.0487469807,
0.0195738897,
-0.0045886976,
0.0084749693,
-0.0224051438,
0.0491999686,
-0.0227305014,
0.0189291742,
-0.0247737542,
-0.0531512313,
0.0422339924,
0.003474579,
-0.0038407438,
-0.0041714846,
-0.0072249537,
-0.0137221208,
0.0585556664,
-0.0322937332,
0.0122645376,
-0.0394927748,
0.0185041819,
0.0140018566,
-0.0591603108,
-0.0042453893,
0.0302404836,
-0.0214349777,
0.0227294546,
-0.0403456092,
0.0036603515,
-0.0271392446,
0.0342856646,
0.0406882204,
0.0257728081,
0.0292952545,
-0.0629421845,
-0.0374433137,
-0.0076861875,
0.0073090331,
-0.0076644393,
0.0032067711,
-0.0191998202,
-0.0017910032,
0.0087760221,
0.0069610812,
0.0029526746,
-0.032517001,
0.0059805214,
-0.035999652,
0.0148976836,
-0.0499794558,
0.044867266,
-0.0466230735,
-0.0188993271,
-0.0099350484,
0.0202444158,
0.0355281048,
-0.0160647389,
0.014165801,
-0.0072831814,
-0.0684320256,
0.0119207837,
-0.0133636631,
0.0158393532,
0.0495096706,
-0.0152292661,
0.0350851193,
-0.0317019671,
-0.0131935962,
-0.0286359359,
-0.0010412369,
0.0385339744,
0.0011603278,
0.0337581635,
0.0125599792,
0.0318608657,
0.0119685289,
0.0779086873,
0.0928037167,
0.0401871093,
-0.0570886545,
0.0054925475,
-0.013887329,
-0.0284925271,
-0.0118093127,
-0.0577492826,
0.0229421556,
0.0002914272,
0.0353982449,
-0.0581588522,
0.0049091359,
-0.0347420685,
2.446e-7,
0.0756314993,
0.0578286052,
-0.0330550112,
-0.031803485,
0.0330999903,
0.0034315297,
0.0075411415,
0.0172448643,
-0.0020387564,
0.0087143732,
-0.0201824214,
0.0157755185,
0.031192638,
0.0434013158,
0.0078630075,
-0.0070793941,
-0.0333318189,
-0.0142363776,
-0.0425561965,
-0.0326239131,
0.0418625884,
0.0388635136,
-0.0009267664,
-0.0240754467,
-0.0488888845,
-0.0136314565,
0.0182092264,
-0.0315641575,
0.0008333971,
0.0563896,
0.0333617292,
-0.0024442757,
-0.0086659929,
-0.0403840095,
-0.0338413566,
-0.0142655522,
0.0425747745,
0.0578136928,
-0.0298411846,
0.0073244772,
0.0044305022,
0.0057239714,
-0.0038978141,
-0.0219263695,
0.046773795,
-0.1138434038,
-0.0547849014,
-0.0631914586,
-0.0311230794,
-0.0103071062,
0.0301806964,
-0.0097963344,
-0.0227383412,
0.0635896325,
0.0419062003,
0.0048494511,
-0.0042702216,
-0.0827981085,
-0.0169716924,
0.0195309334,
-0.0480714887,
0.013748046,
0.0075655957,
0.0303381532,
-0.0286014006,
-0.0431543626,
0.0196897481,
1.729829592e-34,
-0.037051484,
0.0121009778,
-0.0092463046,
-0.0164400209,
0.0085714003,
0.0089732641,
0.0025098561,
0.0293058995,
-0.0315402187,
-0.069981955,
0.0257229656
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.