id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13208v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13208v1 | LlaMaVAE: Guiding Large Language Model Generation via Continuous Latent Sentence Spaces | 2023-12-20T17:25:23 | 2023-12-20T17:25:23 | Yingji Zhang, Danilo S. Carvalho, Ian Pratt-Hartmann, André Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL | Deep generative neural networks, such as Variational AutoEncoders (VAEs),
offer an opportunity to better understand and control language models from the
perspective of sentence-level latent spaces. To combine the controllability of
VAE latent spaces with the state-of-the-art performance of recent large
language models (LLMs), we present in this work LlaMaVAE, which combines
expressive encoder and decoder models (sentenceT5 and LlaMA) with a VAE
architecture, aiming to provide better text generation control to LLMs. In
addition, to conditionally guide the VAE generation, we investigate a new
approach based on flow-based invertible neural networks (INNs) named Invertible
CVAE. Experimental results reveal that LlaMaVAE can outperform the previous
state-of-the-art VAE language model, Optimus, across various tasks, including
language modelling, semantic textual similarity and definition modelling.
Qualitative analysis on interpolation and traversal experiments also indicates
an increased degree of semantic clustering and geometric consistency, which
enables better generation control. | [
0.024215281,
0.0960905254,
-0.0292629693,
0.0476498343,
-0.0304084141,
0.00754007,
0.0157011244,
-0.0355083123,
-0.0227110162,
-0.0007116438,
0.0182160549,
-0.0632661059,
-0.0311871897,
0.0727045462,
0.0478595719,
-0.0550468117,
-0.0078582019,
-0.0292620398,
-0.0272777211,
-0.0324296877,
0.0176872518,
-0.0113381958,
0.0299379993,
0.0477422252,
-0.0128117623,
-0.0217399914,
-0.0125219533,
-0.0307916123,
-0.0063734124,
-0.0067824316,
0.0480954461,
0.034019351,
0.0558515266,
0.0181457754,
0.0000022169,
0.0018927846,
0.0082785143,
-0.0240290128,
0.017115403,
0.0233571716,
0.0744183809,
-0.026615439,
0.0044190679,
0.0044848779,
0.0013025196,
-0.042082753,
0.0439336002,
0.0062343176,
0.0698243603,
0.0619919784,
-0.0195236355,
-0.0634924993,
0.0330838934,
-0.0513597131,
0.0178032778,
-0.0532154925,
0.0225854442,
0.0336000919,
0.0065243458,
0.0066338326,
-0.043627806,
0.0613219999,
0.059090402,
-0.0303242635,
0.0117870532,
0.0373772681,
0.019085329,
-0.0474927016,
-0.0116614252,
0.075665161,
-0.0350057781,
-0.047760088,
-0.0106759351,
-0.0367330089,
-0.0487024747,
0.0160607733,
-0.0434938222,
0.0681726038,
0.0334308855,
0.013214591,
0.028607063,
0.0107239531,
0.0335407108,
-0.0026823236,
-0.0180976205,
0.0003576837,
0.0654682815,
-0.0104621928,
-0.0310002137,
0.0035822848,
-0.0653848648,
-0.038148731,
0.0201733895,
0.0332989842,
-0.0407500081,
-0.0001885167,
-0.0610463321,
-0.0595010966,
-0.0183608718,
-0.0480602384,
0.0598824136,
0.0338728987,
0.0228320975,
0.0004656518,
-0.0199364256,
0.0730657205,
-0.0559292994,
-0.0048663057,
-0.0728245974,
-0.0236565173,
0.0231556129,
-0.0299555138,
-0.0210194513,
0.0152378352,
-0.0556772798,
-0.0500630625,
-0.0239478983,
0.0502358042,
-0.0088620773,
0.0038830682,
-0.0033960491,
0.054550793,
-0.0338960215,
-0.0064371908,
0.0137993125,
-0.0021763362,
-0.0348222405,
0.0225276519,
0.0009492395,
-0.0118964193,
-0.0008264193,
0.0509627312,
0.0269836951,
-0.0017709273,
-0.01663897,
0.0285370313,
-0.0272066612,
0.0054442971,
-0.0327404216,
-0.0079490971,
-0.0038594627,
-0.0378342718,
0.0263978876,
-0.0718424618,
0.0504621752,
0.0043991054,
-0.0080064638,
-0.0651156604,
-0.0041596447,
0.0191979427,
-0.0139507689,
0.0419999138,
0.0275745969,
0.0273477957,
0.0522454232,
-0.0148630328,
0.0773921534,
0.0260641985,
0.04910722,
0.0430762991,
-0.0101838764,
0.0245642886,
0.0120226257,
0.0602581203,
0.0053262785,
-0.0266575888,
-0.0725393966,
-0.0280913152,
-0.0217139665,
0.0501304045,
0.055889722,
0.0803062916,
-0.040263731,
-0.0002256014,
0.0414736904,
0.0036998293,
0.0255585816,
0.0319467336,
0.1082002819,
0.003740045,
-0.0339856111,
-0.0093099335,
0.0245132409,
0.0419773795,
0.0352637023,
0.0189501364,
0.0221570209,
0.011171544,
-0.0247653108,
-0.0169224255,
0.006318219,
-0.0194262341,
-0.0099928956,
-0.0446078107,
0.0255003236,
0.0158240907,
-0.0546499155,
0.0336168781,
0.0281347875,
-0.0305150114,
0.0116321091,
-0.0048431773,
0.0325580239,
0.0682832226,
0.0478638597,
0.0465924554,
-0.0186776333,
0.0039134659,
-0.0207782593,
0.0638698265,
0.0132101784,
-0.0278017092,
-0.0360130742,
-0.0706390291,
-0.0231076051,
-0.0426343605,
0.0327272452,
0.0186286252,
-0.0154297389,
-0.008601361,
0.0372648053,
-0.0177952852,
-0.0197188556,
0.0438971296,
-0.0645854846,
0.0230703466,
0.0385359414,
0.0003762142,
0.0262448154,
-0.0023171492,
-0.0065865051,
0.0243436415,
0.0171940941,
-0.083219327,
-0.0279289987,
0.0139706777,
-0.0709381625,
-0.0676116943,
-0.0056460151,
-0.0382153876,
0.0183465667,
0.0120496266,
-0.0314023718,
-0.0366501063,
0.0479026362,
-0.0527277328,
-0.0027533679,
-0.0608916357,
0.0167687349,
-0.0054985974,
0.0154907322,
-0.0268757828,
0.0608465336,
-0.0304310396,
0.0238617882,
0.0356824212,
0.0726563781,
0.0058009825,
0.005533535,
-0.0224101637,
-0.0120161548,
0.0269346535,
0.0028764431,
0.035396792,
0.0411673374,
0.0168288946,
-0.0539292619,
-0.0508596599,
0.011914677,
-0.0392532013,
-0.0135367857,
0.043791689,
0.0524014048,
0.0161474701,
0.0365937129,
-0.0313144475,
0.0553868227,
0.0356769376,
0.0018470753,
0.0310678352,
-0.0201314073,
-0.0138243372,
-0.0241705012,
-0.0130388616,
0.0142486179,
0.0704142973,
0.0129306391,
-0.0084523587,
-0.0211355798,
0.0372129232,
-0.0029247659,
0.0084806923,
-0.0174053181,
-0.0327896997,
-0.0055431989,
-0.0213135015,
0.0870165452,
0.0049418509,
0.030200161,
0.0418985821,
0.054737214,
-0.0047617867,
-0.0189778656,
0.0079881772,
-0.0699448809,
-0.0158263985,
-0.0220948998,
-0.0177576598,
0.0109336674,
0.0552033633,
0.0331013128,
0.000710028,
-0.0673718378,
0.0422225036,
0.0042341817,
-0.0229355264,
0.0127317151,
-0.0176836737,
-0.0292230789,
0.0128454566,
-0.0501893386,
-0.0074315476,
0.0315507501,
-0.0289408285,
0.0125571555,
-0.0132928351,
0.0205809679,
-0.0372066535,
0.023159869,
0.0590415858,
0.0246775001,
-0.0058899736,
-0.0123332702,
-0.0249850918,
0.0434036143,
0.0017950631,
0.000885004,
0.0223932788,
-0.0369684286,
0.0106261466,
0.028082557,
-0.0269367378,
-0.0565057285,
-0.0345662795,
0.0331171006,
0.0283188224,
0.0630323142,
-0.0099276425,
-0.0167352445,
-0.0004243795,
-0.0066825124,
0.0417539515,
-0.0224776622,
0.0078158993,
-0.0457124338,
0.0762936771,
0.0886604488,
0.0032049981,
-0.0149693443,
-0.0470625497,
-0.015031701,
0.0271620881,
-0.0361889154,
0.023847647,
-0.0389619432,
0.0562104322,
0.0147961481,
0.0136365546,
-0.0109748142,
0.0144216176,
0.0269278809,
-0.0347208492,
-0.0631333739,
0.1024782062,
0.0222580824,
-0.041124247,
0.0247857422,
-0.0124862483,
0.0836289972,
0.0122703817,
0.0233771652,
-0.044340387,
-0.0026599744,
-0.0148602147,
0.0140290651,
-0.0029152934,
-0.0004956506,
-0.0213285163,
-0.0732533112,
0.041645702,
0.0081617404,
-0.0076370249,
-0.0061306194,
-0.0244111698,
-0.0275379922,
-0.0040304568,
0.0317678005,
-0.0066285999,
0.0111724641,
0.0162968934,
0.0168402381,
0.0028319671,
-0.0656483248,
-0.0221455786,
-0.0271658953,
0.0486597158,
0.0839050859,
0.0347834788,
0.0053888164,
-0.0136620663,
0.0406137705,
-0.0515319891,
-0.0208116192,
-0.0102846809,
0.0200875476,
0.0082824118,
-0.0138336541,
0.0097810496,
0.048159387,
-0.0423218533,
-0.0040532663,
-0.0024674395,
0.0502389409,
-0.0077705653,
-0.0415014476,
-0.0403753296,
-0.0238759182,
-0.012056672,
0.0503177121,
0.0573604144,
-0.039924372,
-0.0573649816,
-0.0280063823,
0.0347531214,
-0.0539744385,
-0.0247651953,
-0.0328596346,
0.0412838235,
-0.0471662804,
-0.0708549097,
-0.0369168743,
-0.0034852601,
0.0083825309,
0.002958636,
-0.0195295624,
0.042854514,
-0.0668297708,
-0.0527189225,
-0.0331133865,
-0.002261648,
0.0118325921,
-0.0103733791,
0.00019097,
0.0311916638,
-0.0477717184,
-0.0319238268,
0.0128683178,
-0.0922043547,
-0.0749483183,
-0.0033639711,
0.0288195591,
0.0050646449,
0.0669169948,
-0.0144978883,
-0.0559923239,
0.0759043843,
0.0180574972,
-0.0152966138,
0.0345805176,
-0.0339838788,
0.0133819841,
0.0075026341,
0.0372081362,
-0.0173667148,
0.0189163424,
0.0124604553,
0.0674189553,
0.0152150868,
-0.0482743792,
0.0085343672,
-0.0340356752,
-0.0436725505,
-0.0096131591,
-0.0033283944,
-0.0780211091,
-0.0193587188,
-0.0423473045,
-0.0256628077,
-0.0697143972,
0.0272560567,
0.0284172501,
0.0352032408,
-0.0330943391,
0.0072766868,
0.0298497099,
0.0231740605,
-0.0286163762,
-0.0052587185,
0.0149362432,
0.0343032517,
0.0180042647,
0.0059505608,
-0.0088669183,
0.0032320188,
-0.0378517024,
0.0220522135,
-0.0431990921,
0.0515181459,
0.0274154227,
0.0030687929,
-0.0351943187,
0.0220323503,
-0.0345933773,
-0.0073857862,
-0.089149341,
0.0353111997,
0.0447028615,
0.0043918919,
0.0634733811,
-0.0473904349,
0.000872083,
-0.0271136686,
0.0414584354,
0.0026232316,
-0.0760124773,
0.0264229495,
-0.0070953192,
-0.0070885783,
-0.0274043996,
0.067100808,
0.0291208401,
0.0312533416,
-0.0317913704,
0.0030608054,
-0.0492678396,
-0.0165765435,
0.0010831835,
0.0141628254,
0.0053186915,
0.0266456492,
-0.0032779167,
-0.0442451946,
0.0157476701,
0.0112408409,
-0.0200925358,
0.0035293498,
0.0442835912,
0.0676692054,
-0.0328509621,
-0.0119833015,
-0.0293275584,
0.0116253458,
-0.012199441,
-0.05717602,
-0.0744902268,
-7.007076275e-33,
-0.0398783386,
-0.0403270125,
0.0151861329,
-0.0459872745,
-0.0640696734,
-0.0126058618,
-0.1005575359,
-0.01293182,
0.0218048003,
0.0381535776,
0.0383493081,
-0.0051485328,
-0.0176109709,
0.0629133806,
0.023372829,
-0.0006469909,
0.0670287684,
-0.0172804091,
0.0074468437,
0.0597726256,
0.0192515738,
0.0296524521,
-0.0093772886,
-0.0402975157,
-0.0128438883,
-0.0342320427,
0.0160196964,
0.0093328757,
0.0108707398,
0.0202835966,
-0.0618422739,
0.0345908366,
0.0149871306,
0.0118750613,
-0.0270812772,
-0.0292794947,
-0.0324685685,
-0.0328059196,
-0.0221160147,
-0.0163781084,
-0.0265922695,
-0.0602608174,
0.092776686,
-0.0285987426,
0.0105096167,
0.0021378507,
0.0457288101,
-0.008108072,
-0.0015268145,
-0.0626585186,
-0.0815528855,
0.000075007,
-0.0214704052,
-0.0072571491,
0.0007470959,
-0.0096723735,
-0.0153952204,
0.0278011113,
-0.0426151417,
0.0293886755,
-0.0108009484,
0.0336819589,
0.0531166308,
0.0253346022,
0.0281680748,
0.0393143594,
-0.003322579,
-0.0476277694,
-0.0685422942,
0.0430800728,
0.0443588495,
0.0255126283,
0.0109194126,
0.0398801304,
-0.0184235629,
-0.0081892051,
-0.0495168157,
0.015879659,
-0.0402793512,
0.026887998,
0.0437189862,
0.022569444,
-0.0221967231,
-0.0459380038,
-0.034206178,
-0.0574831478,
-0.0136578074,
-0.0190699287,
0.039996855,
-0.0002963979,
-0.0173713136,
-0.0546409935,
0.0182642192,
-0.0331161767,
-0.0062107993,
0.0392127708,
-0.0546691865,
0.0445255339,
0.0065301093,
0.0543302633,
-0.056636747,
-0.0270873364,
0.005088788,
-0.0016509581,
-0.020115247,
0.0099696424,
-0.0129084885,
0.0371668041,
-0.0233224686,
-0.0138548845,
-0.0511002317,
-0.0248752907,
-0.0170546416,
0.0344305448,
0.0142026804,
0.0026630003,
-0.0269109122,
0.0584628545,
0.012192307,
0.0145249609,
-0.0120210703,
-0.0312629826,
0.0372539833,
0.062292181,
-0.0682130307,
0.0133424187,
-0.0491198152,
0.0636564568,
0.0503165126,
-0.0671648979,
-0.0060406979,
0.0167544503,
2.818e-7,
0.0576554462,
0.0059136534,
0.0279713515,
0.0347134769,
0.026442349,
0.0272889622,
0.0106763477,
0.0119421734,
-0.0137195541,
-0.0046524056,
0.0260228254,
0.0246507246,
0.0266666599,
-0.018869279,
-0.0406406187,
0.0721619725,
-0.0587234311,
-0.016189117,
-0.0220122989,
-0.056871105,
0.0551469028,
0.0731057003,
0.0013985309,
-0.0167660005,
0.0168943703,
0.017597992,
0.0809186623,
0.0177878551,
-0.0313425064,
0.0475419872,
-0.0152766146,
-0.0029139458,
0.004516542,
-0.0206404105,
-0.0052793245,
0.0277830493,
0.021561157,
0.0497654863,
0.0135329366,
-0.0386957675,
0.0017623521,
-0.0028838261,
-0.0117524052,
-0.0669978186,
0.051345896,
-0.0625348613,
-0.0301631819,
-0.0092378715,
-0.0164180528,
0.0506605618,
0.0223400686,
-0.0288458671,
-0.0106043853,
-0.0058070156,
0.0340145491,
0.0133917825,
-0.0045753065,
-0.0419602916,
0.006934179,
-0.0373278037,
-0.0729199201,
0.0178062841,
-0.0651158392,
0.0339297466,
0.0357571654,
-0.0018373709,
0.0022391852,
2.767387601e-34,
0.0146543356,
0.0029147046,
-0.0109624518,
-0.0003973761,
0.0110074757,
-0.0139973545,
0.0323983245,
0.0152649116,
-0.0181937814,
-0.0683952272,
-0.0573521219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.09446v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.09446v1 | Explainable Multimodal Sentiment Analysis on Bengali Memes | 2023-12-20T17:15:10 | 2023-12-20T17:15:10 | Kazi Toufique Elahi, Tasnuva Binte Rahman, Shakil Shahriar, Samir Sarker, Sajib Kumar Saha Joy, Faisal Muhammad Shah | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Memes have become a distinctive and effective form of communication in the
digital era, attracting online communities and cutting across cultural
barriers. Even though memes are frequently linked with humor, they have an
amazing capacity to convey a wide range of emotions, including happiness,
sarcasm, frustration, and more. Understanding and interpreting the sentiment
underlying memes has become crucial in the age of information. Previous
research has explored text-based, image-based, and multimodal approaches,
leading to the development of models like CAPSAN and PromptHate for detecting
various meme categories. However, the study of low-resource languages like
Bengali memes remains scarce, with limited availability of publicly accessible
datasets. A recent contribution includes the introduction of the MemoSen
dataset. However, the achieved accuracy is notably low, and the dataset suffers
from imbalanced distribution. In this study, we employed a multimodal approach
using ResNet50 and BanglishBERT and achieved a satisfactory result of 0.71
weighted F1-score, performed comparison with unimodal approaches, and
interpreted behaviors of the models using explainable artificial intelligence
(XAI) techniques. | [
0.0367362984,
0.0487993918,
-0.0441820212,
0.0401685238,
0.0076214229,
0.0468666703,
0.0217053946,
0.0221773274,
0.0327543393,
-0.0149347931,
0.004659032,
-0.0343474671,
0.0012639681,
0.0570038147,
0.016073497,
-0.0778889656,
0.0154699208,
0.0754129887,
0.0236327238,
-0.0140148113,
0.0450060256,
0.034458138,
-0.0558389649,
0.0374870189,
-0.0363515317,
-0.013912838,
0.0043964866,
0.0344647393,
-0.023564985,
-0.0339386351,
-0.0126109989,
0.0196281578,
0.0169037264,
-0.0200109035,
0.0000019561,
-0.0378293581,
0.0097156372,
-0.028468268,
-0.0007392064,
-0.0239919592,
0.0797322616,
-0.0211368296,
-0.0050037294,
0.0090111615,
0.0060742763,
0.0519193783,
0.1103022248,
0.0297947116,
0.0715610459,
0.0465843342,
-0.031843625,
-0.0576578826,
-0.0192746557,
0.0352881774,
0.0294025503,
0.0086015221,
-0.0160792619,
-0.0069751525,
-0.0116784154,
-0.024551807,
-0.0627821833,
0.0217979196,
-0.0066383062,
-0.0057972847,
-0.0242824256,
-0.0142339943,
0.0223809723,
-0.0469527803,
0.0294911563,
0.0517566614,
-0.0081832185,
-0.0055727516,
0.0218212325,
0.0144129079,
-0.017639678,
0.0066142711,
-0.0571697876,
0.0301665794,
-0.0025980587,
0.028947901,
0.0064469138,
0.0456931107,
0.0125737218,
0.0316970274,
0.020732129,
-0.010557076,
-0.0368858613,
0.0199373364,
-0.0242497623,
0.0106617035,
-0.03267074,
0.0256147757,
0.0158250704,
0.0099928556,
0.0122272884,
0.0431860127,
0.0082921814,
-0.0577787012,
0.0145223485,
-0.0456905067,
-0.0048258081,
0.0101026651,
-0.0387065597,
0.0405923612,
-0.0099008484,
-0.0103324614,
-0.0154160913,
0.028201865,
0.0307603627,
-0.0339305364,
-0.0493045896,
-0.0197825525,
0.0385186113,
0.0105611263,
0.0035588918,
-0.0267689172,
-0.094294861,
0.0094018457,
-0.0223274883,
-0.0419190452,
0.0281169508,
0.0023590282,
0.0026112471,
0.0126366792,
-0.0228812099,
0.0362212062,
-0.045146253,
0.0076339724,
-0.0166964959,
-0.0671743378,
0.0491380095,
0.0421706364,
0.0213534869,
-0.0357861556,
0.0036609836,
0.0924170911,
0.0159234665,
-0.0321716666,
-0.0419594012,
-0.0141992057,
-0.0334992409,
-0.0380927473,
0.0206896216,
-0.0452700667,
0.0383327529,
0.0202332288,
-0.0121844998,
0.0159204341,
-0.0016097823,
-0.0090972194,
-0.0040752515,
0.1050559953,
-0.0110775931,
0.0076082135,
0.0208243467,
0.0268800631,
-0.0017455654,
0.0270178765,
-0.0105229393,
0.0470032059,
0.07469818,
-0.0495162643,
0.0168404598,
-0.0097828722,
0.0125753013,
-0.0284567159,
-0.0201123897,
0.0058514029,
-0.0756143481,
-0.0068800803,
0.0205091443,
-0.0116585111,
0.0029992401,
0.0193335116,
0.0191168971,
0.0253907256,
0.0164262149,
0.0372860171,
0.0018643935,
-0.0038944841,
0.0064005377,
-0.0168972332,
0.0161839295,
0.0584696494,
-0.0302882828,
-0.0261683576,
0.035503298,
0.0331923813,
-0.0239536967,
-0.0426620133,
-0.0072404612,
-0.0735575184,
0.0103079285,
-0.0285779685,
0.0835681558,
-0.0113462852,
-0.0164836701,
0.0098710395,
0.0511208437,
-0.0923431739,
-0.0281797163,
-0.057431221,
0.0303295944,
0.038549725,
0.0047753872,
-0.0338610932,
0.0057059065,
0.0153893502,
0.0127402181,
0.043232616,
-0.017972026,
0.0451158285,
0.018907208,
-0.0618301183,
0.032727927,
0.0151274111,
0.009614856,
0.0271149538,
-0.0244144499,
0.0466861315,
-0.0280604791,
0.0253620893,
0.006403978,
0.0093581742,
0.0123328473,
0.0226173047,
-0.0308402497,
0.0288575124,
0.0573265217,
0.012320851,
-0.0113069769,
-0.0487905927,
-0.0012045845,
-0.0298354067,
-0.0178274009,
0.0562159568,
-0.0304563288,
-0.050029669,
0.0059765126,
-0.0902071372,
0.0033983169,
0.063081868,
-0.0103032328,
-0.0248962976,
0.0956241935,
-0.0452123359,
0.0256979931,
-0.0308983568,
-0.0228368882,
-0.0341138169,
0.0520542823,
0.025947256,
0.0359609984,
-0.0229742154,
-0.0087634986,
-0.0157056749,
-0.0136050116,
0.0522064827,
0.028499091,
-0.0217288043,
0.049073033,
0.0008760975,
0.0129493643,
-0.0293762032,
0.0021114612,
-0.0097431997,
-0.0087387571,
-0.0962161794,
-0.047373455,
0.0044775363,
-0.0022739461,
0.0301818699,
0.0108003933,
-0.0078396322,
-0.0325074755,
-0.0141221071,
0.0610889941,
0.0347456671,
0.0101402141,
0.0324243419,
-0.0258312281,
0.0379249379,
-0.0401957631,
-0.0207088105,
-0.0298485085,
0.0970983505,
0.0176791046,
-0.0253818501,
0.0371756367,
-0.0147312991,
-0.0443938598,
-0.0388066098,
-0.0153912166,
-0.0841633156,
0.0206747334,
-0.0119294394,
-0.0041240295,
0.0276971813,
0.0272726268,
0.0787262097,
-0.0408790298,
0.0058028372,
-0.0030959921,
-0.0438429452,
-0.0181042608,
0.0238826908,
0.0199527442,
-0.0711098388,
-0.0233225785,
0.0447631888,
0.0085330606,
0.0287788566,
-0.0418310836,
0.0267237034,
-0.0037965733,
-0.0211713798,
-0.0427550822,
0.0000701252,
-0.0051961588,
0.0298964102,
-0.0123246703,
-0.0410306267,
0.0522746034,
0.0006467581,
-0.0344954841,
-0.0070194118,
-0.0085274428,
-0.0371331759,
0.0879221186,
-0.0016504773,
0.031101048,
-0.0290169492,
-0.0128493486,
0.0103383483,
-0.0450164042,
0.0180776007,
-0.0164097976,
-0.0218009632,
0.0137781696,
-0.00873153,
0.0067567364,
0.0103068687,
0.0101426421,
-0.037598379,
-0.010956713,
-0.0271366704,
0.0335358866,
-0.0156380348,
0.0274887383,
0.0627958179,
0.0236156154,
-0.0968355611,
0.0040044026,
-0.013403248,
0.022552615,
0.0340067521,
0.0313464031,
-0.0013104328,
0.0311023369,
-0.0182544533,
-0.0232997593,
0.0051287622,
-0.0322470702,
-0.0384915993,
-0.0423549004,
-0.0017971614,
-0.0174215343,
0.0334998704,
0.004568507,
-0.0512561016,
0.0725139007,
-0.012666232,
0.0239249673,
0.0579719879,
0.0109274024,
-0.0411686487,
0.0149918543,
-0.0006983992,
-0.0460567623,
-0.0065680249,
-0.0021412123,
0.0049811709,
-0.0439948924,
-0.0311492216,
0.0057487912,
-0.0178225487,
-0.007369264,
-0.0092880093,
-0.0896142274,
0.0102485865,
-0.0275992807,
-0.0354185849,
-0.0284080394,
-0.0018187674,
-0.0266114194,
-0.0129018147,
-0.000169574,
-0.0272696707,
0.0177483279,
-0.0002180041,
0.0489728078,
-0.022989247,
-0.047990486,
-0.0075478945,
-0.0073450846,
0.0569379292,
0.0076227593,
0.0493212603,
-0.0295062922,
-0.0335704796,
0.0013117322,
-0.0362616368,
-0.002285559,
-0.0261654221,
0.0605234765,
0.0142577998,
-0.0356368311,
-0.0601883493,
-0.0130529497,
-0.048635859,
-0.0013431958,
-0.0397761203,
0.0391204134,
-0.0234633349,
-0.0331216119,
-0.07234402,
0.0139378095,
0.0154845407,
0.0428420231,
0.0513129123,
-0.0666368753,
-0.0160100888,
-0.031762857,
-0.0122345043,
-0.0550786592,
-0.0402754843,
-0.0246891305,
-0.0465503223,
-0.0226126313,
-0.0508999191,
-0.0321026109,
-0.0589983724,
0.065720126,
-0.0190244783,
-0.0104077784,
-0.0282470305,
0.0093551669,
-0.025310833,
0.0118341465,
0.0105678635,
0.0129904002,
-0.0171055738,
-0.0211977381,
0.0037904698,
-0.0474325828,
-0.0017686153,
-0.0298995897,
-0.0159155615,
-0.0031339768,
-0.0095075192,
0.0357791856,
0.0242100228,
-0.026862029,
0.0062447977,
-0.0821859911,
0.0363773927,
0.0673221126,
-0.0239636432,
-0.0110166036,
0.0294951014,
0.0455303602,
0.0206449162,
0.0168864243,
0.0068469057,
0.055954434,
-0.0069890749,
-0.052406732,
-0.0310429577,
-0.0140802804,
-0.0275804438,
-0.0125058852,
0.016854031,
-0.0298409332,
-0.0596319847,
-0.0318661407,
-0.0379777215,
0.0183187872,
0.0132377921,
-0.0137384254,
-0.0039259405,
0.0020833644,
0.0255252067,
-0.0349329263,
-0.0602263361,
-0.0041236468,
-0.0151855098,
0.02578412,
0.0838406608,
0.0360892303,
0.0487492681,
-0.0553424209,
0.0407890342,
0.0112821041,
0.0139104119,
-0.0097525632,
-0.0155157875,
-0.0059054745,
0.0911905169,
-0.010584089,
-0.0446842127,
0.027726341,
0.0594372377,
0.0585964769,
0.0354872122,
0.0150169907,
-0.0225021243,
0.0651058629,
-0.0454882644,
0.0610390566,
-0.0001702584,
0.0308443047,
-0.0052011819,
0.0572815835,
-0.0098548857,
-0.0201236494,
0.0198672414,
-0.0253833123,
-0.0084191244,
-0.0217677727,
0.0516197532,
-0.0793931633,
-0.0077083078,
0.0432419442,
-0.0286546946,
-0.0210048668,
0.0008556219,
0.0518690497,
0.0215864703,
0.0301282872,
0.0343225561,
-0.0390524529,
-0.0690383986,
0.0139792087,
-0.03864903,
0.0212219749,
0.0294060856,
0.0288984701,
0.0478078313,
0.034185309,
0.0711113065,
-0.0691977963,
0.0249909163,
-0.1107885689,
0.0161652807,
0.0384178236,
-5.917300441e-33,
0.0151773477,
-0.0571065657,
-0.0675438717,
-0.0170049109,
-0.0010209626,
0.0035616443,
-0.0570439138,
0.0090304986,
0.015622491,
0.021627333,
0.026331814,
0.0007583415,
-0.0052995682,
0.0134725785,
0.0315887742,
-0.0189881511,
-0.0157939848,
0.0509348027,
0.0080189537,
0.0183074977,
0.0701045394,
0.0253113862,
0.0522317477,
-0.1113507822,
0.0310216695,
-0.0116648814,
-0.0306386221,
0.0042345808,
0.0445752367,
0.0872795507,
-0.0247278176,
0.0660823509,
0.0483880192,
0.0189286917,
-0.00988294,
0.0424933061,
-0.0253765453,
0.0080567654,
0.0087477136,
0.0572636202,
-0.0498402566,
-0.0292990971,
0.057558924,
-0.0347771272,
-0.0002222349,
0.054434862,
0.0769610927,
-0.0163280386,
0.0431842878,
-0.0125846965,
-0.0195081253,
0.0347258747,
-0.0196267068,
-0.0026649807,
0.0153386071,
0.0268591978,
0.0211082771,
0.0391390771,
-0.0550449491,
0.0376214981,
-0.0459814258,
-0.0192802474,
0.0546623543,
-0.0112852566,
0.0033920722,
0.0542024113,
0.0294186156,
-0.0161748156,
0.0185973775,
0.0262177475,
0.0184300933,
0.0324040912,
0.0649733022,
0.0939946324,
0.0531074218,
-0.0526692532,
-0.0546973087,
-0.0007110886,
0.0072837742,
0.0038870175,
0.0441231281,
0.0202951673,
-0.0633636191,
0.0173674747,
0.0691469759,
-0.0302411094,
-0.0433245674,
-0.084002398,
-0.019677585,
-0.0615204647,
-0.0385201611,
-0.0019190322,
0.0421796292,
-0.0301875025,
0.005699046,
-0.0178355314,
-0.0089956988,
0.0640059933,
0.0263894051,
0.0195257179,
-0.0114415614,
-0.0182698593,
0.0037515513,
0.0236063991,
0.0333457217,
0.0309181903,
0.0455928594,
0.0278759375,
-0.031130584,
-0.0145223392,
-0.0488366671,
-0.0249159746,
-0.0390384383,
0.0513957217,
-0.0110228918,
0.007337945,
-0.0579034798,
-0.0077310954,
0.0334937572,
0.0250137486,
0.0104278969,
-0.0497976914,
-0.023579102,
-0.0059901974,
-0.0501006246,
-0.0393707082,
-0.0588618256,
-0.0322228596,
-0.0118836686,
-0.0714245811,
0.0047661145,
0.0012145295,
2.747e-7,
0.0452293418,
0.0530771129,
-0.0130905434,
-0.0312491208,
0.0682987645,
0.0497706681,
-0.009937441,
-0.0244276021,
-0.0578835718,
0.0109752677,
0.0250536669,
0.0350449011,
0.0336515494,
0.0257195346,
-0.0359271653,
-0.0082037905,
-0.0370739885,
-0.0142592303,
-0.0409492403,
0.0611995049,
0.0713647828,
0.0543147437,
0.0394915603,
-0.028096512,
-0.0239622686,
-0.0034253949,
0.0310311727,
-0.0518083014,
0.0125734508,
-0.0458875112,
0.0140066035,
0.0068875779,
-0.0034722085,
-0.0506962165,
0.0370327756,
-0.066960603,
0.0317979194,
0.006148329,
-0.0216147006,
-0.0377694853,
0.0329813734,
0.0293546021,
-0.0075835437,
-0.036188595,
0.0274996012,
0.0203720108,
-0.0754116476,
-0.0451006331,
0.0041296966,
-0.0229064766,
0.033483386,
-0.0084941173,
-0.0279196631,
0.008116018,
-0.0007680512,
-0.0660365,
-0.0246807858,
-0.0670067817,
-0.0168205891,
0.01800685,
-0.0308782179,
-0.0049574804,
-0.0217821412,
0.0115323281,
0.0639301389,
-0.035621088,
-0.0031584117,
1.864453082e-34,
0.0117999883,
-0.0126129026,
0.0130283125,
-0.047489658,
0.0355502442,
0.0113351261,
-0.0116605898,
-0.0193499327,
0.0447730683,
-0.0118719451,
-0.0115887858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13193v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13193v1 | HCDIR: End-to-end Hate Context Detection, and Intensity Reduction model for online comments | 2023-12-20T17:05:46 | 2023-12-20T17:05:46 | Neeraj Kumar Singh, Koyel Ghosh, Joy Mahapatra, Utpal Garain, Apurbalal Senapati | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Warning: This paper contains examples of the language that some people may
find offensive.
Detecting and reducing hateful, abusive, offensive comments is a critical and
challenging task on social media. Moreover, few studies aim to mitigate the
intensity of hate speech. While studies have shown that context-level semantics
are crucial for detecting hateful comments, most of this research focuses on
English due to the ample datasets available. In contrast, low-resource
languages, like Indian languages, remain under-researched because of limited
datasets. Contrary to hate speech detection, hate intensity reduction remains
unexplored in high-resource and low-resource languages. In this paper, we
propose a novel end-to-end model, HCDIR, for Hate Context Detection, and Hate
Intensity Reduction in social media posts. First, we fine-tuned several
pre-trained language models to detect hateful comments to ascertain the
best-performing hateful comments detection model. Then, we identified the
contextual hateful words. Identification of such hateful words is justified
through the state-of-the-art explainable learning model, i.e., Integrated
Gradient (IG). Lastly, the Masked Language Modeling (MLM) model has been
employed to capture domain-specific nuances to reduce hate intensity. We masked
the 50\% hateful words of the comments identified as hateful and predicted the
alternative words for these masked terms to generate convincing sentences. An
optimal replacement for the original hate comments from the feasible sentences
is preferred. Extensive experiments have been conducted on several recent
datasets using automatic metric-based evaluation (BERTScore) and thorough human
evaluation. To enhance the faithfulness in human evaluation, we arranged a
group of three human annotators with varied expertise. | [
0.0777175352,
0.0545999371,
-0.0139242588,
0.0387833677,
0.0039344965,
0.0611277223,
0.0363051295,
0.0296893883,
0.0058177281,
-0.0585903451,
-0.0136432331,
-0.0173709672,
-0.017454695,
0.0141706653,
-0.0041117705,
-0.0574144498,
0.0138025759,
0.0453492999,
0.0215407629,
-0.001338859,
0.0644802451,
0.007675048,
-0.0073447707,
0.0450973772,
-0.0687729642,
0.0072313268,
0.0415175892,
0.0199187864,
0.0019290096,
-0.0157687925,
0.0855648294,
0.0484683588,
0.0184360594,
0.0375388451,
0.0000020299,
-0.0346970819,
0.0068924986,
-0.0055221533,
-0.007130858,
-0.0289112031,
0.1090929061,
-0.0440004207,
0.0064008473,
0.0411940552,
-0.0124624018,
0.0441276729,
0.0682315007,
0.0679609179,
0.0849381238,
0.0686925799,
-0.0123920189,
-0.0683371499,
-0.0175358634,
0.0145968786,
-0.0147974333,
0.0232329238,
0.0214017536,
-0.0119740833,
-0.0890928283,
-0.0171162821,
0.0043401448,
-0.000438753,
0.0095267929,
0.0042019417,
0.0565513223,
-0.0389641225,
-0.0142512061,
-0.0297810324,
0.0258675888,
0.0553880222,
-0.0513028949,
-0.0387410857,
0.0014588225,
-0.0109130573,
-0.0364940092,
-0.0413935333,
-0.0235413481,
-0.0225711223,
0.0032830951,
0.051554013,
-0.0043091653,
0.0195310172,
0.0485584252,
0.0722624734,
0.0222348217,
0.0093559781,
-0.0228421036,
-0.0448196679,
-0.0157467145,
-0.0184718445,
-0.038007319,
-0.0085291248,
0.0126377605,
0.01639737,
-0.0198830403,
0.01930454,
-0.0516509451,
-0.0800374448,
0.0007242548,
-0.0901633874,
0.0240960307,
0.0261749774,
-0.0223752633,
0.0019227323,
0.0031027982,
0.0597697198,
-0.0023344611,
-0.0220479388,
0.0226255786,
-0.032150086,
-0.0177717377,
0.006148194,
0.0110361194,
-0.0002920635,
-0.0437920317,
0.0295802224,
-0.0431859866,
-0.0056618177,
-0.0711194202,
-0.0288554151,
-0.0001372449,
-0.010621462,
-0.0030055672,
-0.0173519906,
-0.021171594,
-0.0004995595,
-0.043993637,
0.0132384822,
-0.0435696766,
-0.0530274734,
0.0199495088,
0.0486254953,
-0.0030433098,
-0.0122666191,
0.0267072376,
0.0612266995,
0.0351129062,
-0.0304885842,
-0.0366093293,
-0.0166044328,
-0.0092795165,
-0.0332695283,
-0.0220544245,
-0.0635736138,
0.017327942,
-0.0371606871,
-0.0395293422,
-0.0690101162,
0.0162104387,
0.0241267048,
-0.0344571881,
0.0957988948,
-0.0273641236,
-0.0470318198,
0.0566737019,
0.0265217423,
0.0050574583,
0.0395636074,
0.0154856052,
0.0354041122,
0.0721580982,
-0.0156999845,
0.0220035054,
0.0407160558,
0.051844582,
0.0056212209,
-0.0283443965,
0.0202143863,
-0.0935817435,
-0.0248417798,
0.0173931848,
0.0438793786,
0.0003514176,
-0.0309765562,
0.0418443345,
0.0474322923,
-0.0624747723,
0.0201023221,
0.0463270098,
0.0533269681,
-0.0245356429,
-0.0250150319,
-0.0590568148,
-0.0088766348,
-0.0252747629,
-0.0485934354,
0.0465076268,
0.0091828397,
-0.0208166875,
-0.0738483518,
-0.0294625759,
-0.0328195691,
0.048615288,
-0.0368674397,
0.0413390473,
0.0149347791,
-0.0531279705,
0.0160224754,
0.0600536242,
-0.0507928208,
0.0113793239,
-0.0477072075,
0.0293090418,
0.0413112156,
0.0120188911,
-0.0230684467,
-0.0115406131,
-0.0602058768,
-0.0013725702,
0.0541141964,
-0.0232449435,
0.0011351181,
0.0062847487,
-0.040492598,
-0.004872153,
0.0318382196,
0.0047978624,
-0.0189539548,
0.0439290144,
-0.0043080328,
0.0251209792,
0.029090859,
-0.0403725468,
0.042861715,
0.0365286469,
-0.0360538661,
0.0007734902,
0.021490423,
0.0592740253,
0.0093727922,
-0.0162737351,
-0.0433564447,
0.0162539631,
-0.0007278074,
-0.0473579131,
0.0048838262,
-0.0277016945,
-0.0432627909,
0.0076510292,
-0.0676729754,
-0.0102972332,
0.0956098884,
-0.0179107618,
0.0170406085,
0.0330030061,
-0.0261297468,
0.01532201,
-0.0147693269,
-0.0186697897,
-0.0596645027,
0.0196119417,
-0.023972325,
0.079617016,
-0.0133398855,
0.000930136,
0.0095547494,
-0.03678919,
0.0302756894,
0.0272693075,
-0.0339369662,
-0.0482598469,
-0.0213469509,
0.0127905924,
0.0171035994,
0.0082569961,
-0.025804989,
0.0096810646,
-0.1205195263,
-0.0062821549,
-0.0337764397,
-0.0034764709,
0.0293761455,
-0.0045032087,
-0.0035725371,
0.0065983692,
-0.0084775034,
-0.0540884621,
0.0388088748,
0.0141927311,
0.0220010839,
-0.0675965175,
-0.004946568,
-0.0551413298,
-0.0124204168,
-0.0001281586,
0.0377173945,
0.0102085983,
-0.0650189519,
0.0240818206,
0.0053825434,
-0.0200017579,
0.0163179636,
-0.0149387745,
-0.0671785548,
0.0059521641,
0.0446890295,
-0.0256774034,
0.0399384499,
0.059245985,
0.1013438478,
-0.0045160162,
0.0215451587,
-0.0191276036,
-0.0004867227,
-0.0230811648,
0.0309813861,
-0.0182817448,
-0.0424715802,
0.0274554286,
0.078107141,
0.0364434049,
0.0025901394,
-0.065760076,
0.0186157543,
-0.0643845797,
-0.0269857422,
-0.0494237654,
-0.0545694344,
-0.0243704598,
0.0026034906,
-0.0319302529,
-0.0729970783,
0.059193328,
-0.0004745553,
0.0215593055,
-0.0338672772,
-0.0153475273,
-0.0147076119,
0.0180129893,
-0.0007183861,
0.0223387666,
-0.0553941615,
0.0030459268,
0.0136891864,
-0.0240369104,
0.0291247368,
-0.0168236997,
-0.0336549692,
-0.0431461483,
0.0047135907,
0.0320704617,
-0.0489333943,
-0.0662185699,
-0.0816731527,
-0.0320702754,
-0.0496023707,
0.0510697998,
-0.0267974529,
0.0144393034,
0.0107754869,
0.021018168,
-0.0018358781,
0.0106139025,
-0.0048155966,
0.0259377621,
-0.0150318965,
0.0238509923,
-0.0077020433,
0.0408406928,
0.0155129097,
-0.0208611768,
0.0340720266,
0.01019633,
-0.0052125766,
-0.0253557581,
0.0032820061,
0.001445029,
-0.0022249259,
-0.0118014039,
-0.0200057924,
0.0630497262,
0.0034456707,
0.0065190657,
0.1122675538,
0.0101465601,
-0.0171308797,
0.0008481197,
-0.0053943857,
0.011181077,
0.0082390942,
-0.0139163388,
-0.0821231231,
-0.0192251578,
-0.0181674026,
0.0412455164,
-0.0623776726,
-0.0129205268,
0.0014912623,
-0.0527768806,
0.0040061381,
-0.0261205751,
-0.0203096922,
-0.0284724887,
-0.0040972885,
0.0137339476,
-0.0060001244,
0.040221408,
-0.0356498063,
0.0182219502,
0.0014632173,
0.0366770439,
-0.067832835,
-0.0002989738,
0.0046423469,
-0.0090057086,
0.0448669977,
0.0451044589,
0.0584800802,
-0.0063432022,
-0.0292367022,
0.0557099693,
-0.0011548147,
-0.0103244493,
-0.0511885621,
0.0682360306,
-0.0075447247,
-0.0468414165,
-0.0361198001,
0.0353696868,
-0.0289696138,
-0.0031246389,
-0.0117170773,
0.0354355015,
0.0405284204,
0.0351841822,
-0.0397254229,
0.0053319638,
0.011545117,
0.0893214494,
0.0375668257,
-0.0692460984,
0.0204694942,
-0.0297304168,
-0.0030633709,
-0.0288959965,
-0.0566802584,
-0.0027103755,
-0.0470432639,
-0.0283629093,
-0.0455679856,
-0.0478022099,
0.0159092117,
0.0206883606,
0.0118313646,
-0.001065177,
-0.0015097996,
-0.024945125,
-0.0330705382,
0.0163233709,
-0.0030963144,
0.0358724855,
-0.0532140099,
-0.0253156759,
-0.0155995637,
-0.0121215843,
-0.0448497906,
0.0154793831,
-0.0305847228,
-0.0185583197,
0.0297653805,
0.0794670433,
0.0180672053,
0.0214816332,
-0.0164727066,
-0.0812285244,
0.023573732,
0.023663722,
0.0002359724,
-0.0112534082,
0.0684878081,
0.0194454752,
0.0214202534,
0.0309335943,
-0.0124023305,
0.0546912886,
0.0383613333,
-0.0646335557,
-0.0392089076,
-0.0119063603,
-0.0154548353,
-0.0132104075,
0.0631343871,
-0.0090883449,
-0.0479139388,
-0.0237254594,
-0.0198034793,
0.0021528401,
-0.0346277878,
-0.0242458601,
0.0144007569,
-0.0031232666,
-0.0024515395,
-0.0514916964,
-0.0270830858,
-0.0460817628,
-0.0222425554,
-0.0518999659,
0.0435939766,
0.0162930507,
0.0561245345,
0.0116919717,
0.0329171754,
-0.0308800377,
0.0132489409,
0.0056589697,
-0.0238340627,
0.0095713325,
0.0422245748,
0.0056481771,
0.0117972847,
0.0200652108,
-0.0034458982,
0.0415528081,
0.0097093172,
-0.0548317917,
-0.0419634432,
0.0015428516,
-0.0220223181,
0.0511460677,
0.0338876843,
-0.0034600527,
-0.0052119382,
0.027556777,
-0.0138592934,
-0.0497759767,
0.0151429372,
0.0239154752,
-0.0359804556,
0.0049599921,
0.0539210364,
-0.007486484,
0.0216028523,
0.0458714329,
-0.0250960328,
-0.0243252758,
0.0473085307,
0.0409001634,
0.076018475,
0.0389967561,
0.0546042584,
-0.0253217295,
-0.0617383868,
0.001847227,
-0.0742929056,
0.0156019377,
0.0158138126,
0.0337507501,
0.0508182161,
-0.0047801551,
0.0008427927,
-0.0332415253,
0.015275144,
0.0015150579,
-0.0597845763,
-0.0071975407,
-6.09220996e-33,
0.0006369298,
-0.0417070761,
-0.0279627182,
0.0102938982,
0.0086636357,
-0.0250391345,
0.0015943019,
0.0055757575,
-0.0053681452,
0.0465096273,
0.013993727,
0.0213903226,
0.0032745868,
0.0247680806,
-0.0393347442,
-0.0139084915,
0.0434467681,
0.010341051,
0.0029178858,
0.0141695878,
0.0550514311,
0.009551107,
0.0443103015,
-0.0806566998,
0.062156029,
-0.0390162282,
-0.0290029962,
0.0411591604,
0.0331567787,
0.080964312,
-0.0359064117,
0.0734018013,
0.0464297496,
-0.0278902184,
-0.0167084895,
0.0433472544,
-0.0431963317,
-0.0020126146,
0.0220975894,
0.0187679771,
-0.0249837544,
-0.0363635458,
0.067812331,
-0.0050811353,
-0.0482683517,
0.004575355,
0.0432055406,
-0.0057849493,
0.0167047624,
-0.053362865,
-0.0827180445,
0.0428064093,
-0.0287644733,
-0.0185212512,
0.0088092368,
0.0255025458,
0.006213225,
0.0022368014,
-0.0659200326,
-0.0042684171,
-0.0222291872,
-0.0109370071,
0.0118525987,
-0.0216498058,
0.016406266,
0.0700532272,
0.0288803969,
0.0081642251,
-0.0186726488,
0.0227784403,
0.0038038858,
0.0323326513,
0.0576181337,
0.0528760329,
0.0181127656,
-0.0819113478,
-0.0614486635,
0.0054023745,
0.0068883337,
0.0040989593,
0.0226078071,
-0.0048430413,
-0.0823707283,
-0.0187908392,
0.0054638386,
-0.0587635413,
-0.022080116,
-0.0190908909,
0.019952517,
-0.0255656261,
-0.0396710373,
-0.0009576308,
0.0089893583,
-0.0381654762,
0.0130433338,
0.0464715324,
-0.0158620495,
0.0056372578,
0.0470999554,
0.0128271561,
-0.0222305935,
0.0071108174,
-0.0197720733,
-0.009590663,
0.0386845358,
-0.0032466103,
0.0683430955,
0.0139479535,
-0.0726181641,
0.0127987331,
-0.029181974,
0.0452284142,
-0.0129179759,
0.0596384071,
-0.0084994519,
0.0470447205,
-0.0347304828,
0.0016617394,
0.0262427758,
-0.0358763188,
-0.0081630554,
0.0306359828,
-0.0378006622,
-0.0009863999,
-0.0086713247,
-0.0339420922,
0.0004425237,
0.0165972095,
0.0230263136,
-0.0810405537,
0.0070385258,
-0.0418533683,
2.645e-7,
0.0100880088,
0.0709715113,
-0.007506378,
-0.0279223956,
0.0363946036,
0.0606986247,
0.0508351512,
-0.0019638119,
-0.0279521756,
0.0226383954,
-0.0041276426,
0.0259132609,
0.0182799324,
0.0234644506,
-0.0117836371,
-0.0425285697,
-0.0634048358,
0.0002330676,
-0.0215742104,
0.0128570497,
0.0168243106,
0.0858151168,
0.067920737,
-0.0253136363,
-0.0416551754,
0.0140691409,
0.0053953892,
-0.0407855809,
0.0043071159,
-0.0226323716,
0.0437031612,
0.0106999017,
0.022365924,
-0.0151722161,
-0.0264716502,
0.0072668162,
0.0181256272,
0.06091002,
0.0022149689,
0.0030152823,
0.0317141041,
0.0123364562,
0.0034450747,
-0.0565172881,
0.0267187767,
0.0079164375,
-0.0156798791,
-0.0566637851,
-0.0161246099,
-0.0117489621,
0.0235097148,
-0.0087278923,
-0.0068095005,
-0.0106808599,
0.0322778411,
-0.0225641094,
-0.0133952778,
-0.0744495019,
-0.0051544909,
-0.0090596098,
-0.0218652003,
-0.0056466321,
-0.0378839485,
0.0108724441,
0.0596439242,
0.0203404576,
0.0499282628,
1.931125997e-34,
0.0201303065,
-0.0301578604,
-0.0039184676,
0.0043461528,
0.0525400303,
0.0454786271,
-0.0227787029,
-0.0030981132,
0.0799734518,
-0.0363849252,
0.0083448207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13179v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13179v1 | Contextual Code Switching for Machine Translation using Language Models | 2023-12-20T16:40:33 | 2023-12-20T16:40:33 | Arshad Kaji, Manan Shah | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have exerted a considerable impact on diverse
language-related tasks in recent years. Their demonstrated state-of-the-art
performance is achieved through methodologies such as zero-shot or few-shot
prompting. These models undergo training on extensive datasets that encompass
segments of the Internet and subsequently undergo fine-tuning tailored to
specific tasks. Notably, they exhibit proficiency in tasks such as translation,
summarization, question answering, and creative writing, even in the absence of
explicit training for those particular tasks. While they have shown substantial
improvement in the multilingual tasks their performance in the code switching,
especially for machine translation remains relatively uncharted. In this paper,
we present an extensive study on the code switching task specifically for the
machine translation task comparing multiple LLMs. Our results indicate that
despite the LLMs having promising results in the certain tasks, the models with
relatively lesser complexity outperform the multilingual large language models
in the machine translation task. We posit that the efficacy of multilingual
large language models in contextual code switching is constrained by their
training methodologies. In contrast, relatively smaller models, when trained
and fine-tuned on bespoke datasets, may yield superior results in comparison to
the majority of multilingual models. | [
0.0362000503,
0.0278047491,
-0.0038574282,
0.0452979133,
-0.0278705712,
0.0316616744,
0.0495675243,
-0.0189316235,
-0.0128871007,
-0.047311876,
-0.0400373265,
-0.031772811,
-0.0013758361,
0.0039047112,
0.036669571,
-0.0369936638,
0.0304955095,
-0.0570795275,
-0.0296804309,
0.020418223,
0.0037753016,
0.0061812056,
0.0073993048,
0.0477286987,
0.0381020121,
-0.0298152063,
0.0231349915,
0.0524789207,
0.0188903678,
-0.0420221649,
0.0151285157,
0.0425499305,
0.0375529379,
0.0370379239,
0.0000019451,
-0.0345161445,
-0.0243992098,
-0.0082684783,
-0.000717384,
0.011257221,
0.0362895392,
-0.0493658669,
-0.0188563112,
0.0240925569,
-0.0178888664,
-0.012009372,
0.0696037114,
-0.0044951853,
0.0655904785,
0.0946649387,
-0.0058704237,
-0.0430812724,
0.000056403,
-0.0458014496,
0.0028343396,
-0.0471362434,
0.0193398837,
0.0183455311,
-0.0195447952,
0.0250750706,
-0.0321036987,
0.0610264353,
0.0176025201,
-0.0168917123,
-0.0346515141,
0.02214697,
-0.0284877419,
-0.0038549125,
-0.0236737374,
0.0648460239,
-0.058577776,
-0.02784965,
0.0135515248,
0.006008592,
-0.0387524255,
-0.0309359394,
-0.033368513,
0.051610373,
-0.0146495774,
-0.0043754429,
0.0254488252,
0.0101401629,
0.0237589628,
0.0077339681,
-0.0486317314,
-0.0106907655,
0.0241301209,
-0.0318164006,
-0.0203145649,
0.0090380572,
-0.0053691166,
-0.0768833607,
0.0193890128,
0.0037817196,
-0.0379654244,
0.033365909,
-0.0394897163,
-0.0602130666,
0.0100867273,
-0.0311099365,
0.0345712118,
0.0568880998,
-0.0124256341,
0.0443172008,
-0.028117137,
0.0510731004,
-0.0257083923,
-0.011205324,
-0.0429696925,
-0.0052015926,
-0.0386033244,
0.0030364692,
-0.0570926443,
-0.0274946131,
-0.0174020175,
-0.0230478607,
-0.0191118661,
0.0534973927,
0.0200168565,
-0.0031324604,
0.0138973296,
-0.0537368245,
-0.0290868804,
0.0098934723,
0.0437951311,
0.0268683694,
-0.0151867112,
-0.0143276434,
0.0148978624,
-0.0609329306,
0.0013782787,
0.0121439639,
0.001839275,
-0.0486927517,
0.0061177849,
0.047705587,
-0.0329615548,
-0.0220335703,
-0.0390562266,
0.0201129988,
-0.0101820137,
-0.0396626852,
-0.0165860336,
-0.0790769085,
0.011347807,
0.0376434475,
0.0399787501,
-0.0160563309,
0.0028148284,
0.0157253109,
-0.0097942799,
0.0600960441,
0.0164949,
0.0234173369,
0.0360481329,
-0.0307903271,
-0.0233896822,
0.0821715593,
0.0414403938,
0.0036809088,
0.0580820441,
-0.0175308269,
0.0174624324,
0.0433613472,
-0.0235000029,
0.0437664762,
-0.012290718,
-0.002153001,
0.0411778204,
0.0245062113,
0.037305899,
0.0378628783,
-0.0333648697,
0.0423096716,
0.0782181621,
0.0367168933,
0.0176010672,
0.0266336519,
0.0816521645,
0.0155242635,
-0.0058215987,
0.0061270781,
-0.0362719297,
0.0479247123,
-0.0102567729,
0.0243751202,
0.028672494,
0.0243024863,
-0.0350039341,
-0.0154737132,
0.0038809476,
-0.0171225481,
0.0189680588,
0.0021434803,
0.0214373767,
0.0006782914,
-0.0436491221,
0.0033522507,
-0.0041271131,
-0.057973668,
-0.0113874059,
-0.0431377068,
0.0044033737,
0.0896795988,
0.0191776268,
0.0099146031,
-0.0272726044,
-0.0369006805,
0.0585451797,
0.0579263121,
0.0453924015,
0.0068029398,
-0.0002725057,
-0.037967097,
0.0069308262,
-0.0131479884,
-0.0102961818,
0.0210551359,
0.0390782468,
0.0369962975,
0.0022153177,
-0.0076087168,
-0.0507518277,
0.0267433375,
-0.0561465472,
0.0085992403,
-0.0041075554,
0.0109263631,
0.0064744274,
-0.0189598445,
-0.0374596454,
-0.0014765195,
0.0021151584,
-0.0460654013,
-0.0099449866,
0.0413998589,
-0.0238057021,
-0.0712403283,
0.001072544,
-0.0336574614,
0.0042941389,
-0.0123449694,
-0.027701281,
-0.0435079746,
0.0124585805,
-0.0202562511,
0.0124220904,
-0.0172552317,
0.0376699641,
-0.0167908259,
-0.0097491667,
-0.0196835808,
0.0315553695,
0.0148307765,
0.0288506262,
0.0306367446,
0.0106367394,
-0.0114815505,
-0.0244339835,
-0.0026543674,
0.025015695,
0.0069422834,
0.017800346,
0.0189484619,
0.0335704908,
-0.0199933331,
-0.0345146284,
-0.1110858992,
0.0420006104,
-0.0485404953,
0.0293411985,
0.0501942746,
0.0234672464,
-0.0277767014,
-0.0177024957,
-0.0415519476,
0.0016604927,
-0.0091360845,
0.0289669074,
0.010517505,
-0.0095866444,
0.0105151134,
-0.067157656,
-0.0101104788,
0.0155645497,
0.0326287895,
-0.0081792697,
-0.0432131998,
-0.0705417097,
0.0705050156,
-0.0022724168,
-0.0058675851,
-0.0130771212,
-0.0537697598,
0.0088359751,
-0.0184684303,
0.0623135008,
0.0762421042,
0.0078172646,
-0.0255919229,
0.0563253053,
-0.0063301334,
-0.0503722988,
0.0046388851,
0.0295764524,
-0.0706642121,
-0.0381768532,
-0.0653848276,
0.0409638584,
0.053386353,
0.0159562603,
0.0147110345,
-0.0511546098,
-0.0151651539,
-0.0242517758,
-0.0302229356,
-0.000908789,
0.0141600734,
-0.003970677,
0.0683306232,
-0.0337485112,
-0.0272387099,
0.0548909791,
-0.0309179798,
-0.0150323911,
-0.0592405125,
-0.0126326522,
-0.0564942546,
0.0221661367,
-0.0232240688,
0.0402706973,
-0.0011995706,
-0.0154121136,
-0.0289007146,
0.0107379425,
-0.0025835994,
-0.010978736,
0.0578471087,
-0.0501854159,
0.0140875587,
-0.0263260435,
-0.0576965623,
-0.0178501345,
-0.0133051835,
-0.0080716498,
-0.006966345,
0.0404286571,
-0.0180521794,
0.0150100756,
0.0113977343,
0.0321686938,
0.0923632309,
-0.0201482847,
-0.027697945,
-0.0187465027,
0.0210246779,
0.0269917343,
-0.032705117,
-0.0136519726,
-0.0461616032,
0.0372660905,
0.0023557683,
0.0224605966,
0.0065811891,
-0.026382044,
-0.0141114481,
0.0381873921,
-0.0288991984,
-0.044462461,
-0.0081475945,
0.0768463314,
-0.0531891957,
-0.0181489605,
0.1229455173,
0.033437483,
-0.0962280557,
-0.0285662189,
-0.0066342927,
-0.0101027973,
0.0473662801,
0.0354211591,
-0.0976652727,
-0.0445327312,
-0.0070027281,
0.017856935,
-0.0050294218,
0.0137444399,
-0.0138961542,
-0.0820967034,
0.0183914099,
0.0171828866,
-0.0746893734,
-0.0454937927,
-0.0137293264,
-0.0002580048,
-0.0216197968,
-0.017858196,
-0.0160136782,
-0.0310425833,
-0.0136565119,
0.0087591708,
0.024458522,
-0.0446966141,
0.0056947512,
-0.0518292934,
0.0213235673,
0.0974844545,
0.0260084141,
-0.0079449145,
0.0151826227,
0.0187326148,
-0.0279264748,
0.0141739389,
-0.010555353,
0.0376427509,
-0.0282192696,
-0.0134095103,
0.0238548461,
0.0074025649,
-0.0176093429,
0.0144268312,
0.0585172139,
0.0337811559,
0.0007556877,
-0.0053377626,
0.0223312099,
-0.0002889432,
0.0336462669,
0.0490905046,
0.0358491242,
-0.087912567,
-0.0343951508,
-0.0276609957,
-0.0140755437,
-0.0897547603,
0.0003830517,
-0.0162417032,
-0.0199647639,
-0.0293280613,
-0.1025454849,
-0.0024219996,
0.0325114429,
0.0417973623,
0.0292982552,
0.0387707166,
-0.0009308284,
0.004220183,
-0.0233136583,
-0.0164798945,
-0.0252921432,
0.0374621637,
-0.0756215081,
-0.0068722046,
0.0440661386,
-0.0518512353,
0.015303975,
0.0001791848,
-0.1196330935,
-0.0611734539,
-0.0295719504,
0.0343180597,
0.0150023969,
0.0351978578,
-0.0239594076,
-0.0548180602,
-0.0203392878,
0.0078712394,
0.0016303392,
0.0240085088,
0.0302892998,
0.0601980798,
-0.0092736157,
0.0332015641,
-0.0331392176,
0.0110288737,
0.0091770878,
0.0404218063,
-0.0617295466,
-0.0283498522,
0.0095420573,
-0.0193014108,
-0.0049582734,
-0.008537882,
-0.0236358196,
-0.0255939644,
0.0268074796,
0.0152926063,
-0.0182138663,
-0.0306263752,
-0.0309047848,
0.0391519666,
-0.0105200531,
-0.000935353,
0.043968834,
-0.010337702,
-0.0193503462,
-0.0504982807,
0.0586118288,
0.0026289728,
0.0456271879,
0.0386305638,
0.0222218204,
-0.0451592915,
0.0025254649,
0.0193893854,
0.0073208706,
-0.0311191864,
0.0769589916,
0.0098796552,
-0.0358778797,
-0.0066848281,
0.0552709736,
-0.0794730783,
-0.0350040682,
0.0343467258,
0.0041635591,
0.0894565657,
0.0150569249,
0.1021321714,
-0.0046446198,
-0.0079383487,
-0.0226401184,
0.040599931,
0.0306538455,
-0.0146259973,
-0.0030410523,
0.0097147832,
0.0087768454,
0.0144277029,
0.0935655013,
-0.0252603684,
0.0144742737,
0.0189612415,
-0.0089077689,
-0.0180925205,
0.0198960006,
0.0201411303,
0.0008563661,
-0.0016181183,
-0.0102808243,
-0.0068629808,
-0.0474255309,
0.0013706484,
-0.0180785153,
0.0158915315,
-0.0363034271,
-0.0073950337,
0.112285912,
0.0165614486,
0.0236937162,
-0.0892634988,
0.0175753012,
0.0335931107,
-0.0306980014,
-0.0666143596,
-5.905121218e-33,
-0.0114106676,
-0.0040299539,
0.0131029738,
-0.0104254717,
-0.0009828832,
0.0024330397,
-0.0666791946,
-0.0083734328,
-0.0370938741,
-0.0443228856,
-0.0250880122,
0.0114024533,
0.0132589703,
0.0107486257,
0.0348082595,
0.009443013,
0.0739942193,
0.0046799709,
-0.0294839945,
0.0279971994,
0.0390396044,
0.0091680223,
0.0307007115,
-0.0279222988,
0.0423720703,
-0.0252462421,
-0.0120240673,
0.0119693186,
0.0146390963,
0.051716473,
0.0108909914,
0.0057646199,
0.037302509,
-0.0248543229,
-0.0287895948,
0.0176462997,
-0.0596454665,
0.010181007,
0.0366003662,
0.0101821935,
0.0039730333,
-0.0851454139,
0.0208804756,
-0.0507295765,
0.009883875,
-0.0100909602,
0.0254825577,
-0.0321081094,
-0.0295793135,
-0.045263458,
-0.1044436619,
0.0170659628,
-0.0211988371,
-0.0251878928,
0.0150237186,
0.075728111,
-0.0345901698,
0.0418788157,
-0.0604353063,
0.02825463,
0.0094383191,
0.0237447079,
0.0532309972,
0.0399603322,
-0.0031480081,
0.0166748129,
0.0286196154,
0.0165017098,
0.0271888655,
-0.0129951742,
0.030589018,
0.0106043648,
0.0337875076,
0.0342609473,
0.0310910214,
-0.0115366569,
-0.0402945355,
-0.0160599034,
0.0034541963,
-0.0101836715,
0.070582673,
0.0270103365,
-0.0203290712,
-0.0158331115,
-0.0408620276,
-0.0494354181,
-0.0369941927,
-0.0313842855,
0.0367699303,
0.0257787611,
0.0036113511,
-0.0062352503,
0.070369184,
-0.0115667805,
0.0048914794,
0.0302757304,
-0.0095719714,
0.0687164515,
-0.0108193662,
0.0444095992,
-0.0626041591,
0.0003257433,
0.0289765745,
0.018438505,
0.0243779738,
0.0186512712,
0.0725345165,
0.0234776679,
-0.0569187738,
-0.0174074266,
-0.049019549,
0.0082828049,
-0.0450607166,
0.0459818393,
0.008764389,
-0.0062311925,
-0.0104508009,
0.0423207432,
-0.0114539312,
-0.0452739671,
-0.0330642425,
-0.0465021394,
-0.0266319383,
0.0463675559,
-0.0560410544,
0.0132555068,
-0.043861229,
0.0532279834,
0.0336798579,
-0.0520570725,
-0.0239751507,
0.0167540237,
2.62e-7,
0.0426871516,
0.0488650799,
-0.0269200895,
0.0384508669,
0.0307640843,
0.0135276979,
-0.0338623859,
0.0118479747,
0.0383017585,
0.055727046,
0.0151522849,
0.0396786146,
0.0695272684,
0.0212852601,
-0.0916468054,
-0.0322613157,
-0.0257097147,
0.0337724015,
-0.0569095425,
-0.0012053403,
0.0543431714,
0.0931830332,
-0.0299003311,
0.0136022596,
0.0162683334,
-0.0316916928,
0.0565105639,
-0.035572242,
-0.010901304,
-0.009082254,
-0.0469618328,
0.0359854959,
-0.0162195452,
0.0003057302,
-0.0065745921,
-0.0375293642,
0.0469095521,
0.080344677,
0.0183151793,
0.0233694408,
0.0046990081,
-0.0140664345,
-0.0197684411,
-0.0583412312,
0.0957051069,
-0.03641285,
0.0280256439,
-0.0210993644,
0.0027922122,
0.0171232708,
-0.0070955073,
-0.0687252879,
-0.0515975915,
0.0365814157,
0.016640842,
0.0101829823,
-0.0264981315,
-0.0244161934,
-0.0256292429,
0.01031119,
0.022015091,
-0.0440515839,
-0.0647648126,
-0.0088435961,
-0.0032175684,
-0.0323378704,
0.0175958723,
2.438945296e-34,
0.0430874154,
-0.0119829522,
0.0184219442,
0.011059965,
0.0238504373,
-0.0027734814,
-0.0255297441,
0.0020032369,
-0.0163367055,
-0.0540349297,
-0.0238628406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13119v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13119v2 | Graphene: Infrastructure Security Posture Analysis with AI-generated Attack Graphs | 2023-12-20T15:38:59 | 2024-05-01T01:59:20 | Xin Jin, Charalampos Katsis, Fan Sang, Jiahao Sun, Elisa Bertino, Ramana Rao Kompella, Ashish Kundu | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | The rampant occurrence of cybersecurity breaches imposes substantial
limitations on the progress of network infrastructures, leading to compromised
data, financial losses, potential harm to individuals, and disruptions in
essential services. The current security landscape demands the urgent
development of a holistic security assessment solution that encompasses
vulnerability analysis and investigates the potential exploitation of these
vulnerabilities as attack paths. In this paper, we propose Graphene, an
advanced system designed to provide a detailed analysis of the security posture
of computing infrastructures. Using user-provided information, such as device
details and software versions, Graphene performs a comprehensive security
assessment. This assessment includes identifying associated vulnerabilities and
constructing potential attack graphs that adversaries can exploit. Furthermore,
Graphene evaluates the exploitability of these attack paths and quantifies the
overall security posture through a scoring mechanism. The system takes a
holistic approach by analyzing security layers encompassing hardware, system,
network, and cryptography. Furthermore, Graphene delves into the
interconnections between these layers, exploring how vulnerabilities in one
layer can be leveraged to exploit vulnerabilities in others. In this paper, we
present the end-to-end pipeline implemented in Graphene, showcasing the
systematic approach adopted for conducting this thorough security analysis. | [
-0.0196150355,
0.0561966375,
-0.0147728464,
0.0276544429,
-0.0430958271,
-0.0803437904,
0.0404095985,
-0.0101468256,
0.0504833274,
-0.003060481,
0.0609928705,
0.0180621836,
-0.0150436237,
0.0871061236,
0.0583010912,
0.0232846998,
0.0253347084,
0.0096702008,
0.0121795116,
0.0453695208,
0.0128023047,
-0.0121951457,
0.011425335,
0.0372511186,
-0.0066586337,
-0.0078596473,
-0.0061371564,
0.0492065065,
0.0730203539,
-0.0343011469,
-0.0231161006,
-0.014797478,
-0.006292603,
-0.0327466428,
0.0000021274,
-0.0271882359,
-0.0560925044,
0.0440218076,
-0.0053143059,
0.0062459963,
-0.0066138441,
-0.0000584875,
-0.0141732013,
0.0278307479,
0.0250512753,
-0.021785751,
0.0571625382,
0.0260174312,
0.082663931,
0.0187645666,
-0.0017137793,
0.0349593759,
0.0274456851,
0.0041695293,
-0.054716181,
-0.0387643389,
-0.0081001297,
-0.0238228422,
0.0551903322,
-0.0274723135,
-0.0162950531,
-0.0415119119,
0.0089638699,
-0.0021946069,
0.0619958565,
0.032926783,
0.0126011539,
0.0226838216,
-0.0289814584,
0.0437329449,
-0.0173791125,
0.0207999889,
-0.01787192,
-0.0119293481,
-0.0232283659,
-0.0501958504,
0.042407006,
-0.0408769064,
0.0173932929,
-0.0459429361,
0.0043252241,
0.0034141399,
0.0366488025,
-0.0509505384,
0.0432200804,
0.0093565891,
-0.0006805087,
0.0226332974,
-0.0001482128,
-0.0480695292,
0.0350205563,
-0.0326048657,
0.0329778865,
-0.0109038278,
-0.0456850417,
-0.0065291869,
-0.0035189122,
-0.0233276803,
-0.0004470526,
0.0276324283,
0.0537736788,
-0.0061256154,
0.0424383804,
0.003358491,
0.0435697883,
0.0385214202,
-0.05077843,
-0.0188966114,
-0.0494924895,
0.020528378,
-0.0235431902,
-0.0281568058,
0.0312077645,
0.0320933834,
0.0497790352,
-0.06446141,
-0.0075252419,
0.0055961879,
-0.0615343936,
0.0279538371,
0.0462487005,
0.0279174037,
0.0638262779,
0.0082613388,
0.0260025859,
-0.0421016961,
-0.0545267761,
-0.0130849034,
-0.013777012,
0.023015365,
-0.023043856,
0.0101769017,
-0.0064873127,
-0.0162363313,
-0.0167070236,
0.0842732713,
0.0194652416,
-0.0327712968,
-0.0131961536,
-0.0361793824,
0.0049478868,
-0.0466223396,
0.0141944019,
0.0019724532,
0.0068605924,
0.0040978682,
0.0267266706,
-0.0036055127,
0.0019776537,
-0.0331528075,
-0.0335550345,
0.0247623622,
0.0100428574,
-0.0174205489,
0.0024780245,
0.0144492295,
-0.0175921042,
-0.0503665209,
0.0072621307,
0.0097396718,
0.0080840504,
0.0212780125,
0.0092155719,
0.0464946069,
-0.0029085753,
-0.0399789698,
0.0314658508,
-0.0135465348,
-0.0480561145,
-0.0366996266,
-0.0615243949,
0.0226902775,
0.0474272482,
-0.0603177436,
0.0204705857,
0.0175032448,
-0.0121869184,
0.0153875072,
-0.0209563691,
0.0272638444,
-0.0010954915,
-0.0316434354,
-0.0412175879,
0.0544958375,
-0.0112273097,
-0.0190662425,
0.0260385145,
0.0127862729,
0.0222683344,
0.0085433209,
-0.0279485527,
-0.0472746678,
0.0490943491,
-0.0099941092,
-0.0100160995,
-0.0032890241,
-0.0000939543,
-0.0392920934,
0.0207371321,
-0.0527164005,
-0.0524213165,
-0.0428941511,
-0.0320832171,
0.0706954449,
0.0371651575,
0.0007709984,
-0.1010848358,
0.0466308445,
-0.0624971688,
-0.0273341704,
-0.0293052718,
0.005973733,
-0.0042952891,
-0.0379258953,
0.0144332172,
-0.0103919497,
0.0464231484,
0.0230962727,
-0.0340807848,
-0.0559393652,
-0.0167675409,
-0.0558177978,
-0.0134149492,
-0.0278559476,
0.0666869283,
0.0149960276,
0.034415856,
0.0261682346,
0.013581383,
0.0004858655,
-0.0180457328,
0.0403871648,
0.0582081638,
0.0108711906,
-0.0080492785,
-0.0258963574,
0.0237262342,
0.0861217603,
0.0014920216,
-0.0667481273,
0.0350065678,
0.022462707,
-0.0303059481,
-0.0453171022,
0.1065196022,
-0.0464530997,
-0.088536799,
0.0215034802,
-0.0488765761,
-0.0062106783,
0.0045059822,
-0.002386438,
0.0151513927,
0.0408740416,
-0.0658495501,
-0.0228300411,
0.0176277142,
0.0218318608,
-0.0435695015,
-0.001855855,
-0.0631053969,
-0.0192875527,
0.0036191596,
-0.0048615043,
-0.0114667695,
0.0032169344,
0.0394960642,
-0.0813560784,
-0.0086260708,
-0.0150499549,
0.0330726057,
0.0524300523,
0.0312068649,
-0.0220618192,
-0.035120856,
0.0303711724,
0.0218159966,
-0.0344571806,
-0.0312355869,
0.0042114141,
-0.0099716838,
-0.0191247184,
-0.0029563499,
-0.0158610214,
-0.0692091882,
0.053550452,
0.0395983048,
0.0222048126,
0.0253316369,
0.0046540592,
-0.0263324063,
-0.030754596,
0.0184250567,
-0.0391949601,
0.0421679206,
-0.0082464227,
-0.0288457293,
0.0568868667,
0.0039426545,
0.0444375835,
0.0375042185,
-0.0314817019,
0.0211949144,
-0.0097048292,
0.0321377888,
0.0208126288,
-0.0181162711,
-0.0206574462,
-0.0059890826,
0.0001926468,
0.0487775356,
0.0059980769,
-0.0246443953,
-0.0104195708,
-0.0114734285,
0.0348243415,
0.0366391987,
-0.0585330166,
-0.0068792095,
-0.0140822362,
0.0238982681,
0.008478594,
0.0478948653,
-0.0144751538,
0.0131637584,
-0.0077506029,
-0.0523404479,
-0.0062522655,
0.0334364697,
0.0013938518,
0.0363723524,
0.0259008892,
0.0207369905,
-0.0293323994,
-0.0816341788,
0.0176768061,
0.0000913313,
-0.081220977,
-0.0345871784,
0.0038866743,
0.0200985707,
-0.002773141,
0.0119006587,
0.0429562554,
-0.0106487954,
-0.007494281,
-0.0252875481,
-0.0335613675,
-0.0117503023,
-0.0432804748,
0.0138226459,
-0.0148882167,
0.0116837248,
-0.0254064947,
0.0270017721,
0.0501691401,
-0.0106908036,
-0.0755327642,
-0.0589093678,
0.0673386306,
0.0154896332,
0.0633434951,
0.0672554076,
0.0396104082,
-0.108218886,
-0.0154432738,
-0.0247279052,
0.0058260104,
0.0154913776,
0.0272895228,
0.0335513167,
-0.0025714342,
0.0042919577,
0.0089090774,
-0.0315294936,
-0.0157645959,
0.0356395058,
0.0189524963,
-0.0716063976,
0.0187572502,
0.0263855811,
-0.0538538024,
0.0037905639,
-0.0221655443,
0.0603795908,
-0.0127680395,
-0.0054969704,
-0.0024270636,
-0.0439443626,
0.0458077677,
-0.0005297494,
0.0340822376,
0.0226456802,
-0.0586012155,
0.0256970227,
0.016424641,
-0.0164418574,
-0.0358869657,
0.0597743876,
-0.0087128747,
-0.0264610648,
-0.0725714266,
-0.0321906805,
0.0115238028,
0.018429555,
-0.0060970862,
0.0036632067,
0.029431887,
-0.0551573597,
0.0173811335,
0.0432685278,
0.0199992992,
0.0071957456,
-0.0046571372,
0.0399568602,
0.0526119918,
-0.02016587,
0.0179105382,
0.0429702103,
0.0313685127,
-0.0368608311,
0.0646839589,
0.050256703,
-0.0091014095,
0.0338774808,
-0.0373198129,
-0.0263998453,
0.0807794183,
-0.0081030233,
0.0285071041,
-0.0133247757,
-0.0394526422,
-0.0348425172,
0.04069243,
-0.0601416193,
-0.0174861327,
-0.0163819827,
0.0420223475,
0.0056522177,
0.0056810714,
0.0019149339,
-0.080183126,
0.0021984265,
0.0383892395,
-0.0928175449,
0.0346548036,
0.0399455279,
-0.0779138729,
-0.0436956659,
0.0346195139,
0.0411440954,
-0.0060065044,
-0.0064518359,
-0.0261598062,
-0.0170375519,
-0.0756833851,
0.0565957837,
0.0197396204,
-0.0353188142,
-0.0140498206,
0.0219668373,
0.0194215514,
-0.0684735253,
-0.0474452972,
0.0379731134,
0.1012507454,
0.0211573485,
-0.0153564988,
-0.0381591022,
0.0359802656,
-0.111692749,
-0.0260126609,
-0.0417646505,
-0.0036668577,
0.0041567106,
0.062834233,
0.0373258702,
-0.0265489686,
-0.0167475361,
-0.0012557014,
0.0499680452,
0.0309335161,
-0.0352874883,
0.0444909409,
0.0245633647,
0.0021190625,
-0.0066083809,
-0.0180280954,
0.0584936403,
-0.0029162099,
0.0149887018,
-0.0559303984,
0.0139002129,
-0.0075985766,
0.0195758957,
-0.026612334,
0.0034912936,
0.0054174312,
0.0535675138,
0.0279458892,
0.0608022548,
-0.0319124237,
0.0198915862,
-0.0204563811,
0.026973743,
0.0335080922,
-0.0318403393,
-0.0193600692,
-0.0305566974,
-0.0432311445,
-0.0747246891,
0.0293781273,
-0.0357906818,
-0.0306360126,
0.0604585893,
0.014076815,
0.0105947265,
0.0757092386,
-0.0076305969,
-0.0047826017,
0.0100427549,
-0.0575457811,
-0.0130867064,
-0.0343680233,
-0.0347614437,
0.0019600319,
-0.0067961696,
0.0199762248,
0.0386996642,
0.0078520775,
0.0132797351,
0.0302068908,
-0.0426825285,
-0.0000322804,
-0.0552372411,
-0.0519681424,
-0.0349182785,
0.0524996035,
-0.0422665738,
-0.038878493,
-0.0311112944,
-0.046863541,
0.0541373864,
0.0148990508,
0.0414115861,
-0.0023210787,
-0.0043109758,
0.0191065967,
0.0228412673,
0.0034623086,
-0.047919035,
0.0094697345,
-0.0994344801,
0.0174202714,
-0.0028034193,
-5.644385183e-33,
0.0516067669,
0.0102874413,
-0.0448355228,
0.0686589852,
0.0016204079,
0.0521369502,
-0.0479518846,
-0.016358437,
0.0230302531,
-0.0304812919,
-0.0147106033,
-0.0145030469,
0.0356221981,
0.0100119254,
0.0024256411,
0.0067767864,
0.0021954165,
0.0402409546,
-0.0594466031,
0.0723059401,
0.0355864316,
-0.005254637,
-0.0019912189,
-0.0820203498,
0.0416655652,
0.0058597773,
-0.0165587049,
-0.0230857283,
-0.0789341405,
0.0122180013,
0.0156060923,
0.0503327511,
-0.014792379,
0.0271120518,
0.0131561402,
0.0469166078,
-0.040193703,
-0.0102937697,
-0.0341726393,
-0.0205149166,
0.0166443288,
-0.0359730609,
-0.0094999997,
0.015527945,
0.0050649955,
-0.0309080556,
0.0214926228,
0.0076699839,
0.0293186866,
-0.0277071614,
0.0372333452,
-0.0028171963,
-0.0747909546,
0.0510992296,
-0.0628665984,
-0.0468387194,
-0.0317924507,
-0.0164321754,
-0.0849587619,
0.0546772629,
-0.0529202409,
-0.0170100331,
0.003452067,
-0.0078035546,
-0.0185473319,
-0.0180199426,
-0.0402239971,
-0.0554145835,
-0.0073219771,
0.0373963714,
-0.0129361469,
0.0578215383,
0.0277102962,
0.0198579449,
-0.0319509134,
-0.0424894467,
-0.0811629072,
0.0411970764,
0.0392578281,
0.0655745715,
0.0207839403,
-0.0017088878,
-0.0137875229,
-0.0147057017,
0.0145724472,
-0.079432115,
0.0062883496,
-0.0132159293,
-0.0224021524,
-0.0053954329,
-0.0935738981,
0.0370306484,
-0.0252967477,
-0.0208835211,
0.0246665925,
0.0544825271,
0.0576995239,
0.0155121712,
-0.0061003179,
-0.020167876,
0.008489592,
-0.0095334155,
-0.0248126835,
-0.0185419079,
0.0383962244,
-0.0421515554,
-0.0182743762,
0.0563156083,
0.0013697501,
-0.0065490673,
-0.0447153226,
-0.0209216513,
-0.0731118992,
0.0200180225,
-0.0171142071,
0.0399974547,
0.0067557907,
0.0162635259,
0.0088766012,
0.0582579784,
-0.0184584465,
0.0552181937,
-0.0415605009,
0.0209757611,
-0.0322579443,
-0.0086723147,
-0.0265593473,
0.0341771431,
0.0034401461,
0.0275621619,
0.0053805914,
0.0065976232,
3.204e-7,
-0.0326621793,
-0.0003578903,
0.0441592,
0.0172057319,
0.0017434313,
0.0608216599,
-0.0285751689,
0.0711237341,
0.0222921111,
-0.017461013,
0.009120238,
-0.0102187544,
-0.0036848821,
0.0281816125,
0.0516969264,
0.0042336183,
-0.0247332361,
-0.0281884894,
-0.0402691886,
0.0319410227,
0.0698515996,
-0.0213568509,
0.0728255287,
-0.0103930589,
-0.0168417878,
-0.0729403272,
-0.0324174091,
0.0393502787,
0.0199050438,
-0.034786962,
-0.027610315,
0.0391325839,
-0.0158867668,
0.0902806669,
-0.0377763622,
-0.0019209674,
-0.0537221283,
-0.0242121425,
0.0625685379,
0.0501370244,
-0.059388712,
-0.0323148072,
0.0127131818,
-0.0212896019,
0.0272983499,
0.0352088138,
-0.025746908,
0.0046533532,
-0.0134202996,
0.0171135105,
0.0157506187,
-0.0267833211,
0.0185410455,
0.0009675971,
-0.0151746646,
0.0090809744,
0.0674160421,
-0.0407170318,
-0.0236066859,
0.0229765698,
-0.0270407703,
0.0076800315,
0.0419067554,
0.068291977,
0.0450901762,
0.0281194076,
0.0129590733,
2.469537766e-34,
-0.0317980945,
-0.0173412673,
-0.0296768453,
-0.0345245339,
0.034703318,
0.000487796,
-0.0156154949,
-0.0122948345,
-0.0273321271,
0.0003999017,
-0.046221599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13103v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13103v2 | Exploring Multimodal Large Language Models for Radiology Report Error-checking | 2023-12-20T15:20:33 | 2024-03-03T21:06:33 | Jinge Wu, Yunsoo Kim, Eva C. Keller, Jamie Chow, Adam P. Levine, Nikolas Pontikos, Zina Ibrahim, Paul Taylor, Michelle C. Williams, Honghan Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | This paper proposes one of the first clinical applications of multimodal
large language models (LLMs) as an assistant for radiologists to check errors
in their reports. We created an evaluation dataset from real-world radiology
datasets (including X-rays and CT scans). A subset of original reports was
modified to contain synthetic errors by introducing three types of mistakes:
"insert", "remove", and "substitute". The evaluation contained two difficulty
levels: SIMPLE for binary error-checking and COMPLEX for identifying error
types. At the SIMPLE level, our fine-tuned model significantly enhanced
performance by 47.4% and 25.4% on MIMIC-CXR and IU X-ray data, respectively.
This performance boost is also observed in unseen modality, CT scans, as the
model performed 19.46% better than the baseline model. The model also surpassed
the domain expert's accuracy in the MIMIC-CXR dataset by 1.67%. Notably, among
the subsets (N=21) of the test set where a clinician did not achieve the
correct conclusion, the LLaVA ensemble mode correctly identified 71.4% of these
cases. However, all models performed poorly in identifying mistake types,
underscoring the difficulty of the COMPLEX level. This study marks a promising
step toward utilizing multimodal LLMs to enhance diagnostic accuracy in
radiology. The ensemble model demonstrated comparable performance to
clinicians, even capturing errors overlooked by humans. | [
0.0433705971,
0.0564433448,
0.0042381529,
0.0087663867,
-0.0102163292,
0.0437659137,
0.0318313763,
0.0710012317,
-0.0089390622,
-0.0396248475,
-0.0105015067,
-0.0884775594,
0.0204848032,
0.0121878907,
0.031014815,
-0.0618081167,
0.0369039141,
-0.0161002669,
0.0159765854,
-0.0108655244,
-0.0095605468,
-0.0101738255,
-0.0379529372,
0.0504875183,
-0.0309537258,
-0.0021733742,
0.0180915669,
0.0096539212,
0.0077939094,
-0.0223558228,
-0.0342391543,
0.0730754808,
-0.0020862157,
0.0413657017,
0.0000019747,
-0.0541374721,
-0.0200609956,
0.0330958776,
0.0018275154,
-0.0080631515,
0.0759164169,
-0.0472756289,
-0.0247594975,
-0.0061908588,
0.0064474917,
-0.0686386004,
0.046986945,
0.0425431766,
0.0552018508,
0.0740612596,
-0.0157043394,
0.0257706437,
0.0223978739,
0.0067915772,
-0.005883696,
-0.0393007733,
0.0385040641,
0.063924104,
0.0195817668,
-0.002963115,
-0.0154297771,
0.0397225097,
-0.0063661165,
-0.0228722468,
-0.0219653267,
0.029935658,
0.0193589889,
-0.0192422625,
-0.0151648,
0.034016069,
-0.0211960264,
0.0214554202,
-0.0202249717,
0.0026442839,
-0.0069628754,
0.0151236383,
-0.0244044531,
0.0212161932,
-0.0357461795,
-0.0320718214,
-0.0329075307,
-0.0377141796,
0.0077326093,
0.0233694334,
-0.0186715946,
-0.0208551381,
-0.0029949362,
-0.0239543486,
0.0140767936,
0.033290565,
-0.0249631964,
-0.0407793969,
0.0145762935,
0.0432256646,
-0.0725522637,
-0.0028964239,
-0.0331054889,
-0.0406009592,
0.0754903778,
-0.0583047271,
0.0267478116,
-0.0163727663,
-0.0578428991,
0.0729394555,
-0.0171089955,
0.0469984002,
-0.0322800092,
0.052353587,
-0.0116762239,
-0.0022647365,
-0.0103895282,
-0.0102864504,
-0.0091621494,
-0.0198876038,
0.0248660445,
-0.0152613418,
-0.0647529662,
-0.0130650494,
-0.0025835929,
0.0485102609,
0.0339552425,
0.0379797742,
-0.0378262065,
0.0110575026,
-0.0283611789,
0.035169173,
0.0375891067,
0.009938403,
-0.0231967662,
-0.0411345623,
0.0415682644,
0.0653564334,
-0.0174752027,
0.0124140866,
0.0131640583,
0.0393095575,
-0.0215230715,
-0.0112966718,
0.041260276,
-0.064172931,
-0.053804595,
-0.0487796478,
0.0142302681,
-0.0663289055,
0.0038686462,
0.0301352404,
0.0354858562,
-0.0087492205,
0.0014834972,
-0.0125305299,
-0.0241219867,
0.0601452291,
-0.0447821058,
0.0181038491,
0.0313356444,
0.0086392937,
0.0204344373,
0.0018905812,
0.0121670058,
-0.0268686637,
-0.0179948788,
-0.0212551206,
0.0428807698,
0.0013006439,
-0.063070327,
-0.027482383,
-0.0420048274,
-0.0251907613,
-0.0021467458,
0.0717571303,
0.0225094203,
0.0823430866,
-0.0197621547,
-0.0027802077,
0.0261043124,
0.0191624854,
0.0588222258,
0.0238774996,
0.0324953794,
-0.0459954925,
0.0011610209,
-0.0145126591,
-0.013874026,
0.0243152026,
-0.0090359561,
-0.0255704988,
0.0012480913,
0.0064215395,
-0.027696047,
-0.0249858815,
-0.0730737373,
0.0142490463,
-0.032467138,
-0.0148663195,
0.0645818785,
-0.04046496,
-0.0347694643,
-0.0135688642,
0.0355700143,
-0.0235210992,
-0.0303124301,
-0.0772157907,
0.0027935603,
0.0866538286,
0.0472654253,
-0.0319594592,
-0.0101952944,
-0.0011817156,
0.0309074447,
0.0131453956,
0.0607612021,
0.013448704,
-0.0149967941,
-0.0616824664,
-0.0500667654,
0.0647657141,
0.0332792364,
-0.0090037026,
-0.0010441139,
0.0198042411,
-0.042282965,
-0.0273197666,
-0.0445168875,
0.0261370298,
-0.0111585353,
-0.0171199404,
-0.0340839513,
0.0107063521,
0.0119667007,
-0.0008788909,
-0.0500075184,
-0.0184295699,
-0.0057957349,
0.0248185266,
-0.064747557,
0.0075047016,
-0.0427452438,
-0.0091162762,
0.0384941846,
-0.0555777363,
-0.0375110283,
-0.0132183172,
-0.0357103422,
0.0008104887,
-0.0347009078,
-0.0719959214,
-0.0246116035,
-0.0538654514,
0.0294207111,
0.0279578306,
0.0161771346,
-0.0124437157,
0.04448957,
-0.0200494081,
0.0215981975,
0.0159613471,
-0.0063575571,
0.0116966199,
-0.0587008074,
-0.055345159,
0.0160589162,
0.0203919001,
0.0460613668,
-0.0320071205,
0.0170164686,
-0.0069049792,
-0.0252858084,
-0.0939102173,
-0.0369575247,
0.0085216062,
-0.0254910495,
0.0280658714,
-0.0250180773,
0.0050539882,
-0.0341482423,
0.0130822882,
0.0014545671,
0.0882467404,
0.0192719027,
0.055711858,
0.0037777589,
-0.0137571935,
-0.0355233662,
-0.0114324493,
-0.0511397757,
0.0181880761,
0.0399540402,
-0.0388169251,
-0.047983747,
0.0403404571,
-0.027632026,
0.0262302812,
0.022096822,
-0.0568774268,
0.0064596492,
-0.0524711199,
-0.0537475832,
0.0664723217,
-0.0168141164,
0.020176135,
0.0355764516,
-0.0285925977,
-0.0106077166,
-0.0118643818,
0.000439209,
-0.047736723,
0.0285186786,
-0.053701058,
-0.0427405797,
0.0518585443,
0.0083374223,
0.0191198979,
-0.0126902508,
-0.0191558935,
-0.0392179266,
-0.0183110312,
-0.0102925999,
-0.0105161099,
0.0118110916,
0.0355356671,
-0.0186137054,
-0.026003398,
0.096829854,
-0.0070324675,
0.0108889751,
-0.0422907732,
-0.0178816672,
-0.0185368806,
0.0088061988,
-0.0073173242,
0.0446165577,
0.0284445807,
-0.0273743253,
-0.0122603392,
-0.0094853807,
0.0509499349,
-0.0576697811,
0.0198953971,
-0.0368604921,
0.018647451,
-0.003987832,
-0.0236728787,
-0.0219388213,
-0.0280409213,
-0.0060156551,
-0.0171652734,
0.0025342216,
-0.0217549261,
-0.0915270671,
0.0759781674,
0.0304298569,
0.027280122,
-0.0026469089,
-0.0221761465,
0.0048977914,
0.0316156782,
-0.0189758632,
0.0613694862,
-0.0121830553,
-0.0779165551,
0.0147565547,
0.0469521955,
-0.0374533795,
0.0373197794,
-0.0792632475,
0.0030116076,
-0.0154463863,
0.0397314318,
-0.0237521026,
0.0021456364,
0.0364585444,
-0.0396346264,
-0.00290955,
0.0717481375,
0.014177232,
-0.0470024832,
-0.0489171371,
0.0014824304,
-0.0386916697,
-0.0106936935,
-0.0014945542,
-0.0288665146,
-0.0271560047,
0.0198626146,
0.0149788447,
-0.0089217974,
-0.0221967474,
0.0513586476,
-0.0447263196,
0.080124028,
0.0139572993,
-0.0685120597,
-0.0644407272,
-0.025646003,
0.0135401981,
-0.0068913745,
0.0041322727,
0.0234194007,
-0.0018891644,
-0.03670476,
0.0460438505,
-0.0559275374,
-0.1058138162,
0.0066573997,
-0.0604425035,
0.001926552,
0.0571315885,
0.0136035737,
-0.050189063,
-0.0280098077,
-0.0145642785,
0.051267378,
0.0234787669,
0.0116428286,
0.0958432853,
0.0323005542,
-0.0039614029,
-0.0493727624,
0.0072690859,
-0.0194512103,
0.0268300045,
-0.053665027,
0.0791622922,
-0.0417885035,
-0.0062841438,
-0.0383361168,
0.0249020848,
0.0135291563,
0.0002383452,
-0.0017032141,
-0.0030121207,
-0.0428289212,
0.0060449042,
0.0616185144,
-0.0145745985,
-0.0070062252,
0.0528369918,
-0.0523408726,
-0.046262566,
-0.0474446453,
-0.0340696573,
0.0211896524,
0.04570847,
0.012140627,
-0.0116489017,
-0.0314182118,
0.0141085926,
-0.0385666899,
0.0376056172,
0.0219892077,
0.048881717,
-0.026444966,
0.0143565619,
0.0375548527,
0.0318642482,
0.0117562152,
0.0373511277,
-0.0464328974,
0.0014583537,
-0.008698348,
0.0487876162,
0.0261747632,
-0.0609842874,
-0.0119871907,
-0.0831208155,
0.0200623032,
0.0626804456,
-0.0021778124,
0.0300602484,
-0.011108147,
-0.0664928928,
-0.023681622,
-0.0117006702,
-0.0087192087,
-0.0117290542,
0.0013482571,
0.0033387439,
-0.0604542643,
-0.0454907343,
0.0319766365,
0.0489713363,
0.0483404435,
-0.027537493,
-0.0153469136,
-0.0093925549,
-0.006706493,
0.0070588044,
-0.0139399711,
-0.002287932,
0.0335235819,
0.0145133194,
-0.0104731377,
0.0069345604,
0.0048734732,
-0.0123155881,
-0.0263377316,
-0.0309352204,
0.0612563714,
0.0495113395,
-0.0092512444,
0.0547171086,
0.0064558587,
-0.0235982686,
-0.0277937669,
0.0379477479,
0.0112098688,
0.0335914008,
0.0682129562,
0.0123450356,
0.0291923154,
-0.0147297606,
0.0054965983,
0.0030035023,
-0.0463466905,
-0.035895966,
0.0278767161,
0.0929505453,
0.0330965705,
0.0024368549,
-0.0566503219,
0.0072284485,
-0.0422880463,
0.0581896491,
0.0059858956,
0.0229020137,
0.0589955226,
0.0066239978,
0.0348663852,
-0.0267081801,
0.076486893,
-0.0174137801,
0.0432458967,
-0.0557338111,
-0.0584026612,
-0.0454966612,
-0.001373319,
0.0381038971,
-0.0038479373,
-0.041308634,
-0.0086362539,
-0.0490186885,
-0.0580611005,
0.0124124708,
0.0205783267,
0.0056606638,
-0.0170275904,
0.0248412825,
0.0717714131,
0.0196661167,
-0.0166931711,
-0.0198678635,
0.027732579,
0.0103369839,
0.0138925482,
0.0228223074,
-5.574413882e-33,
-0.0057934388,
-0.0610775352,
0.0256946906,
-0.0662145987,
0.0264205616,
0.032915365,
-0.0309178531,
0.0265837032,
0.0339250527,
0.0324126221,
-0.0128182452,
-0.0197084285,
0.0245847516,
0.0002918668,
0.0349157676,
0.0208882131,
0.029158663,
-0.0002243932,
-0.0016998283,
-0.0332698673,
-0.0096763661,
0.0076627578,
0.0358555615,
-0.1105860472,
-0.0169667043,
0.0365129784,
-0.0332765616,
-0.0033630424,
-0.0431564674,
0.0616494007,
-0.0219139084,
0.0262115039,
0.0139850276,
-0.010424058,
-0.002468854,
0.0065694624,
-0.0472306088,
-0.0045991028,
-0.0014018104,
0.0472350605,
-0.0254763644,
0.0224285256,
0.0507830344,
-0.0306536388,
-0.0104150688,
0.0112254154,
0.0497385971,
-0.0343194455,
-0.0035774689,
0.0109740738,
-0.0294608679,
0.0642469376,
0.019203132,
-0.025524823,
-0.0000026017,
0.0243052207,
-0.0415702239,
0.0067263548,
-0.0387464128,
0.0145241665,
0.0701025426,
0.006005486,
0.0337464362,
-0.0118622426,
-0.0462671258,
0.0682733953,
0.0716353208,
-0.0375210643,
-0.0072246133,
-0.0051630554,
-0.0070973416,
0.0370115116,
0.0511488169,
0.0884833336,
0.0174111295,
-0.013879274,
-0.0563911088,
0.0363906547,
-0.0394742191,
0.0775471851,
0.0307635553,
-0.0138536301,
-0.05549822,
0.0039423676,
0.0030764665,
-0.0112867318,
-0.0344781876,
-0.0319033638,
0.0360262543,
0.0230343957,
0.008833128,
0.0474802479,
0.0497176163,
0.0075935912,
-0.0276231356,
-0.0682138428,
0.0143574709,
0.0519041382,
-0.0402435623,
-0.0083627794,
-0.0319840498,
-0.0508904755,
0.0279578846,
0.0228276812,
0.0435036421,
0.0041311113,
0.0226450711,
0.0393055901,
-0.0757537484,
0.025159074,
0.033640258,
-0.0280126669,
-0.01207068,
0.017738739,
0.0512754545,
-0.0128760673,
-0.010164639,
0.0478381701,
-0.0279762559,
-0.0072535481,
-0.0475199483,
-0.0693156719,
-0.0302446615,
-0.0168727003,
-0.0326069891,
-0.0288273618,
-0.033908911,
-0.0583991185,
0.0376859568,
-0.0166395567,
-0.009356726,
0.0262336526,
2.691e-7,
0.0536516458,
0.0711651146,
0.0080331592,
-0.0139499679,
0.0191387776,
0.0183317643,
-0.0505722649,
-0.0058556092,
0.0050566904,
-0.0027464218,
0.0302051287,
0.0054597799,
0.0215524379,
0.0580958389,
-0.0176980197,
-0.0345811807,
-0.024175236,
-0.0067111473,
-0.0237275511,
-0.0187878665,
0.0657436103,
0.0616402812,
-0.0258140303,
-0.0602783076,
0.0150358472,
-0.0480102114,
0.0552629903,
-0.0068978989,
0.0073204883,
-0.0107253361,
0.0500263721,
0.0091532227,
0.0191982817,
0.1024541408,
0.0333635919,
-0.0547273085,
0.0424867421,
0.0549005941,
-0.061491549,
0.0321805105,
0.0295182504,
0.0105746696,
-0.0066116583,
-0.0440667681,
0.0214679688,
-0.0218686108,
0.0074029127,
-0.009717457,
-0.0113366889,
-0.021163132,
0.0749325007,
-0.0588420331,
-0.0221889373,
0.0319502056,
0.0114206951,
0.0278749168,
-0.0443060659,
-0.0486108661,
0.013925666,
0.0422290079,
-0.0252413303,
-0.0575635396,
0.0535591729,
-0.0280279331,
0.0223250631,
-0.0567340255,
-0.0117321284,
2.242005222e-34,
0.050940752,
0.018253075,
0.0102036912,
-0.0036980808,
0.0254992098,
0.0019000142,
-0.0103047257,
0.0237414315,
0.0132200709,
-0.0310597587,
-0.0013952454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13096v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13096v1 | In Generative AI we Trust: Can Chatbots Effectively Verify Political Information? | 2023-12-20T15:17:03 | 2023-12-20T15:17:03 | Elizaveta Kuznetsova, Mykola Makhortykh, Victoria Vziatysheva, Martha Stolze, Ani Baghumyan, Aleksandra Urman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | This article presents a comparative analysis of the ability of two large
language model (LLM)-based chatbots, ChatGPT and Bing Chat, recently rebranded
to Microsoft Copilot, to detect veracity of political information. We use AI
auditing methodology to investigate how chatbots evaluate true, false, and
borderline statements on five topics: COVID-19, Russian aggression against
Ukraine, the Holocaust, climate change, and LGBTQ+ related debates. We compare
how the chatbots perform in high- and low-resource languages by using prompts
in English, Russian, and Ukrainian. Furthermore, we explore the ability of
chatbots to evaluate statements according to political communication concepts
of disinformation, misinformation, and conspiracy theory, using
definition-oriented prompts. We also systematically test how such evaluations
are influenced by source bias which we model by attributing specific claims to
various political and social actors. The results show high performance of
ChatGPT for the baseline veracity evaluation task, with 72 percent of the cases
evaluated correctly on average across languages without pre-training. Bing Chat
performed worse with a 67 percent accuracy. We observe significant disparities
in how chatbots evaluate prompts in high- and low-resource languages and how
they adapt their evaluations to political communication concepts with ChatGPT
providing more nuanced outputs than Bing Chat. Finally, we find that for some
veracity detection-related tasks, the performance of chatbots varied depending
on the topic of the statement or the source to which it is attributed. These
findings highlight the potential of LLM-based chatbots in tackling different
forms of false information in online environments, but also points to the
substantial variation in terms of how such potential is realized due to
specific factors, such as language of the prompt or the topic. | [
0.0685085431,
0.0431048498,
-0.0187058412,
-0.0009941616,
-0.051998809,
-0.0092086541,
0.0283929687,
-0.016545631,
0.0661772415,
-0.0206475258,
-0.0092327762,
-0.0368727557,
0.0024828606,
0.0492101163,
-0.0049589351,
-0.0193530973,
0.0371593721,
0.0137410648,
0.0848846659,
-0.0332663693,
0.0254107881,
0.0318644792,
-0.0359935313,
0.0421659797,
-0.0521028191,
-0.0085932482,
0.0148595413,
-0.0110816294,
0.0251565054,
0.0075084111,
-0.0162202585,
0.0498180278,
0.0113035217,
0.0681680217,
0.0000017225,
-0.0255044512,
-0.0093289949,
-0.013628846,
-0.0326133594,
-0.0146145476,
0.0780774504,
0.0012287145,
-0.0240756404,
0.0231141821,
-0.0492674597,
0.0084420508,
0.0452818163,
0.0286606029,
0.0588408522,
0.0979423821,
-0.0017302043,
0.0387684479,
0.0316461138,
-0.0010979609,
0.0025786906,
-0.040635787,
0.0227484759,
0.0367754065,
-0.0255787726,
0.0446090288,
0.009671025,
0.0079331594,
0.0330404453,
-0.0456328951,
-0.0466490835,
0.0161606129,
-0.0348178558,
-0.0452090092,
-0.0162254944,
0.0361102782,
0.0156646427,
-0.0255513061,
0.0317014754,
0.0040882896,
0.0158461817,
0.0206837747,
-0.0194794647,
0.0539564379,
-0.0314799175,
-0.0074833352,
0.025554793,
-0.0271385685,
0.0176691674,
0.0443373546,
0.039006874,
0.0346748605,
-0.0179222226,
-0.0046426351,
0.0041168914,
-0.0066523836,
0.0233902857,
-0.073384434,
0.0011509524,
0.0266213678,
-0.040149793,
0.0388298705,
-0.0290660709,
0.0306042191,
0.0360930637,
-0.0472495705,
-0.0431064181,
0.0413383432,
-0.0294154901,
0.0811897367,
0.0047938596,
0.0471380986,
-0.004608599,
0.0268534012,
0.0141727263,
-0.050057862,
0.0033805654,
0.013204637,
-0.0010844732,
-0.0230554454,
0.0134959221,
0.0138384849,
-0.0293989126,
-0.0049662939,
-0.0515274517,
0.0597310849,
-0.0094789313,
0.0017949626,
-0.0004824824,
-0.0158602409,
-0.0437231213,
0.0389377363,
-0.0567450859,
0.0290923715,
-0.0025375383,
-0.1002176329,
-0.0005581921,
0.0462422222,
-0.0345912389,
0.012295668,
0.0114617972,
0.036169719,
0.0131666027,
0.0149783231,
0.0222721267,
-0.0367591903,
-0.0164916255,
-0.0889586806,
0.0332676731,
-0.048845809,
0.0394154675,
-0.0066859671,
-0.0182801764,
-0.0169178676,
0.0085418504,
0.0181502942,
-0.0284374245,
0.0418934748,
0.0114143519,
0.0105552562,
0.0524302572,
0.0400845781,
-0.0481752157,
0.0578149147,
-0.0113496827,
0.0904792622,
0.0515601523,
0.0414038152,
0.0380283669,
0.00039456,
0.0109568005,
0.0206727404,
0.0078905532,
0.0001904283,
-0.0263093244,
-0.0234940965,
-0.0068429024,
0.0718377009,
-0.0360579565,
-0.0337288156,
0.0654191971,
0.0121263573,
-0.0341770761,
0.0060145692,
0.0325070769,
0.0061673461,
0.0366738737,
0.018054381,
-0.0324998088,
0.0450880788,
-0.0292747878,
-0.0591690168,
0.0179669466,
0.0374820679,
-0.010313618,
-0.0425080508,
0.001961997,
-0.0194064863,
0.0307693426,
-0.0052250857,
-0.0114856614,
-0.0146541726,
-0.0354030058,
-0.0203574058,
0.0345389545,
-0.0328710414,
-0.0258056354,
-0.0859815478,
0.0483470149,
0.0484177209,
0.0258976091,
0.0048829811,
-0.0074488204,
-0.0325742178,
0.0095102685,
0.0659210384,
0.0923363268,
-0.0221711304,
-0.0544115454,
-0.0077493275,
-0.0209707282,
-0.0246637072,
0.0215357877,
0.0367658809,
0.0541856289,
0.0366078429,
-0.0161898285,
0.0041463757,
-0.0184754133,
0.0206811447,
0.0055946577,
0.0123307696,
-0.0410959087,
0.0123960534,
0.0244551171,
0.0220349338,
-0.023647625,
0.0003153266,
0.0311085489,
0.0143674528,
-0.0640237704,
0.009868037,
-0.0239641443,
0.0341049805,
0.0217775125,
-0.022701988,
-0.0383167267,
0.0199000221,
-0.0141212773,
0.0209396407,
0.0458007455,
-0.0359835476,
-0.0168360192,
-0.04699222,
-0.0288008954,
-0.0519639775,
0.0077087078,
0.007704665,
0.0759488642,
-0.0237473212,
-0.0132383807,
0.0136900265,
0.0293688476,
0.0143235484,
0.0129948007,
-0.0011618743,
0.0153166745,
0.0212034117,
0.0102207661,
0.0555943139,
-0.0480588377,
-0.0264976192,
-0.0297792349,
-0.0923206583,
-0.0246942248,
-0.0230474975,
-0.0002965276,
0.0413979925,
-0.0355612487,
0.0138326073,
0.0176497716,
-0.0654072911,
0.0172859039,
0.0146098612,
0.030855123,
0.0214563422,
-0.0192628726,
-0.0182524472,
-0.0150501039,
0.0464578867,
-0.0244328547,
0.0022772686,
0.0625564232,
-0.0154711558,
-0.0127898585,
-0.009970339,
-0.082824856,
0.0109781865,
-0.0402972661,
-0.049917955,
0.0451389961,
0.0016159856,
0.0101185851,
0.049532935,
0.0679900125,
0.0558552183,
0.0566153862,
0.0489830077,
-0.0393387154,
-0.0325403325,
-0.0222502071,
-0.0018125527,
0.0029793177,
-0.0662643537,
-0.0143347429,
0.0254709236,
0.0266185589,
0.0326098837,
-0.0276405606,
0.0609652847,
-0.0224470738,
-0.0544921607,
0.022480024,
-0.0358673669,
-0.0089909052,
0.0436538011,
-0.0265695285,
-0.0451615192,
0.0886906385,
-0.012681921,
0.0389898606,
-0.006771598,
-0.0362214819,
-0.0013428791,
0.0346401073,
-0.0288629215,
0.0216390826,
-0.0260597002,
0.0079991855,
-0.0373994857,
-0.0500384308,
0.0560900271,
-0.0629485622,
-0.0250393953,
-0.0343711674,
-0.0069904942,
0.01798095,
-0.0072473865,
-0.0855864659,
-0.058288157,
-0.0275773276,
0.0031948583,
0.0043424615,
-0.0316990726,
-0.0545306206,
-0.0262584053,
0.0653189346,
0.0196696091,
0.0086833462,
0.0159508903,
0.0152887274,
-0.0085153412,
0.0064229486,
0.0018864544,
0.0663997233,
-0.0152372392,
-0.0018506506,
0.0533909686,
-0.0366901122,
0.0422408283,
-0.0145554766,
-0.0685300231,
-0.0211118907,
0.029819157,
0.0188407619,
-0.0193477683,
0.0141818812,
-0.0400591865,
0.0295879077,
0.0759417266,
0.0157782789,
-0.01067633,
-0.0176036619,
-0.0051631918,
-0.0356547236,
0.0102696205,
0.001363817,
-0.1121012717,
0.0253662225,
-0.0046913545,
-0.0124576306,
-0.070908621,
-0.0405416042,
-0.0344418325,
-0.0978727341,
0.0126252081,
-0.0216865428,
-0.0078494838,
-0.0524815395,
-0.0775152668,
0.0044406052,
0.0003315826,
0.0098204566,
0.0098970169,
0.0654709786,
-0.015867712,
-0.0119215334,
-0.028718615,
-0.0205892585,
0.0487820506,
-0.0218130909,
0.0821899474,
0.0420739427,
0.0603749231,
0.002196817,
-0.0230767541,
0.0368259661,
0.0395884626,
-0.0368403345,
0.0082866848,
0.0578100532,
-0.0069617089,
-0.0021294651,
-0.0116391666,
0.0133312885,
0.0514302514,
-0.0143143181,
0.0115111442,
0.0421664454,
0.0009549424,
-0.0553919785,
-0.0011212819,
0.0499982238,
0.0566538759,
0.0708921254,
0.0040413039,
0.0112293167,
-0.0183481574,
-0.0460203253,
0.0023404201,
0.0025367702,
-0.0432486832,
0.030317558,
0.0053903502,
-0.0698140636,
-0.0721426159,
-0.0418341123,
-0.0221938659,
-0.0110727791,
-0.0169017203,
-0.0335759223,
0.0116988635,
0.0122456774,
0.0075588389,
0.0022924086,
-0.0424850993,
0.0183397923,
0.0109411431,
-0.0216278192,
-0.0290881954,
-0.0403440483,
-0.0064403079,
0.0540755764,
-0.0415373668,
-0.0252989028,
0.017840052,
0.0041744602,
0.0214625616,
0.0163240004,
-0.0498055741,
0.0042586694,
0.0206066612,
0.0459023044,
-0.0553504042,
0.0082125841,
0.0244897585,
0.0161605142,
0.0256349016,
0.0096165165,
-0.0126882577,
0.0375103578,
0.0281161014,
-0.0253278222,
-0.0470751524,
-0.0310630314,
0.0360763706,
0.0269945972,
0.0114811836,
0.0062998808,
0.0129256891,
-0.0430807918,
-0.0298577491,
-0.0138856908,
-0.0275563095,
0.0236551091,
-0.0034003826,
-0.0010509843,
-0.0333230793,
0.008022151,
0.0221287552,
-0.0462047905,
0.0277361218,
-0.015591586,
-0.0105949892,
-0.003050704,
0.0585573837,
-0.0122385966,
-0.0276333969,
-0.0333213694,
0.049970936,
-0.0337682031,
0.0068289079,
-0.0016127354,
0.0174371935,
0.00150134,
-0.0479601212,
0.0504833162,
-0.0280347448,
-0.0670889989,
-0.0553748943,
0.0213789027,
0.0621795878,
0.0162308756,
0.0367885269,
0.0224107411,
-0.0349803679,
-0.0183376763,
-0.0109066656,
-0.0076080947,
0.0223841872,
-0.0333338901,
-0.0032127753,
0.0069570057,
-0.0433674268,
0.023264762,
0.02855107,
-0.0407988429,
0.0432931706,
0.0072060465,
-0.0498354323,
-0.0230884869,
-0.0529253222,
-0.0366195813,
-0.0192166306,
-0.0059752599,
0.0171116516,
-0.0663513094,
-0.0447593257,
-0.0180701725,
0.0494932123,
0.0128703071,
-0.0006048512,
-0.0050362134,
0.0848817527,
-0.0134030599,
0.0195094589,
-0.0804996043,
0.0378663242,
-0.0049648788,
-0.0013425626,
-0.0090118116,
-5.873725233e-33,
0.0078003393,
-0.0705027729,
0.0089180442,
0.005295258,
0.008492942,
0.0386733226,
-0.0278483778,
-0.0045995787,
-0.0634341836,
0.0419720262,
0.0163501482,
0.0443526208,
0.0055510118,
-0.0552826636,
-0.0485964753,
-0.0198391564,
0.0577776022,
-0.0242456812,
-0.0487141907,
0.0285769273,
0.0579085052,
-0.0365544632,
0.0255206712,
-0.0950121731,
0.0527199581,
-0.0062177302,
-0.0397558883,
-0.0037532032,
-0.0132599091,
0.0202222336,
-0.0134385722,
0.0350669511,
0.0227428619,
-0.0238484703,
0.0135312472,
0.0597963966,
-0.0241008941,
-0.0135155963,
0.0397699997,
-0.0279352665,
-0.017141955,
-0.0097856848,
-0.0092497533,
-0.0318979472,
-0.0245953668,
0.0210448708,
0.0104010906,
-0.0347931907,
0.0371207036,
-0.0051496858,
-0.0576745383,
0.0145783471,
0.0069672051,
-0.0210579149,
-0.0597792491,
0.0806754455,
0.0268033277,
0.0178314541,
-0.0526583083,
0.0623641722,
-0.0291985683,
-0.030681774,
0.0487668552,
-0.040942207,
0.0099980524,
0.0596247427,
0.0245824065,
0.0597025044,
-0.085626252,
-0.0268937778,
0.012837531,
0.027783582,
0.0701529309,
0.0870421454,
-0.0217004288,
-0.0612242445,
-0.0899915546,
0.0015370069,
0.0810052156,
0.0016807057,
0.0280920081,
-0.0363719985,
-0.0255959034,
0.0177264642,
-0.030837724,
-0.0172890872,
-0.0497374423,
-0.0231470577,
-0.0341755822,
0.0376075618,
-0.0363856666,
-0.028913334,
0.0016191886,
-0.0473362319,
0.04231859,
0.0555409528,
-0.0341278985,
-0.0260701403,
0.0098798173,
0.0371280573,
-0.0513473004,
0.0206877384,
0.0341895707,
0.0072897486,
0.005776668,
0.0125796534,
0.0314317718,
0.0169306137,
-0.019569166,
0.0119975666,
-0.0392204076,
0.0518532768,
-0.0071003977,
-0.0301046334,
0.0376325436,
0.019424513,
-0.029643802,
-0.0118622119,
0.0156759359,
0.019963704,
-0.0122398715,
-0.0005613734,
-0.0372313745,
0.0168250315,
-0.0680414736,
-0.0147346137,
-0.0483425148,
0.0295661427,
-0.0007406321,
-0.0629378632,
0.0074478686,
-0.0236012936,
2.579e-7,
-0.0115668774,
0.0313840471,
-0.0108802561,
0.0511612631,
0.0258913003,
0.0128514832,
0.0279177055,
0.015589376,
-0.0342041701,
-0.0875213966,
-0.0264000036,
0.0496969037,
0.0412649401,
0.0597211644,
-0.0303949416,
-0.0169132333,
-0.0616744272,
-0.0146692982,
-0.0499006175,
0.0387693457,
0.016808603,
0.0521359742,
0.0636003762,
-0.0056018042,
-0.0102041485,
-0.0178483464,
0.0532854721,
0.0115343491,
-0.0550329983,
0.0068623764,
0.0545365848,
0.0067441356,
0.0299338326,
0.0398420207,
0.0188578367,
-0.0083197169,
-0.004225194,
0.0544698313,
0.0366055295,
-0.0190425739,
-0.0013616635,
-0.0223407596,
0.0005298597,
-0.0645927116,
0.0699717849,
-0.0211967267,
-0.02656902,
-0.0727813914,
-0.0269830339,
0.0064902706,
0.049040392,
-0.0233214181,
-0.0395769626,
0.018712664,
-0.0185545813,
0.0198967792,
0.0357740484,
-0.0041075377,
0.0103858784,
-0.0332739502,
-0.0530528724,
-0.0843811333,
0.0107390024,
-0.0350070186,
0.0023162034,
-0.008414967,
0.0512663797,
1.927578392e-34,
0.0417571403,
-0.0030598326,
-0.0175039936,
-0.0396111868,
0.0639327168,
0.0392868482,
-0.0038647773,
-0.0163952783,
0.0234162901,
-0.0063665276,
-0.0143808285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13040v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13040v1 | Retrieval-augmented Multilingual Knowledge Editing | 2023-12-20T14:08:58 | 2023-12-20T14:08:58 | Weixuan Wang, Barry Haddow, Alexandra Birch | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge represented in Large Language Models (LLMs) is quite often
incorrect and can also become obsolete over time. Updating knowledge via
fine-tuning is computationally resource-hungry and not reliable, and so
knowledge editing (KE) has developed as an effective and economical alternative
to inject new knowledge or to fix factual errors in LLMs. Although there has
been considerable interest in this area, current KE research exclusively
focuses on the monolingual setting, typically in English. However, what happens
if the new knowledge is supplied in one language, but we would like to query
the LLM in a different language? To address the problem of multilingual
knowledge editing, we propose Retrieval-augmented Multilingual Knowledge Editor
(ReMaKE) to update new knowledge in LLMs. ReMaKE can perform model-agnostic
knowledge editing in multilingual settings. ReMaKE concatenates the new
knowledge retrieved from a multilingual knowledge base with prompts. Our
experimental results show that ReMaKE outperforms baseline knowledge editing
methods by a significant margin and is the first KE method to work in a
multilingual setting. We provide our multilingual knowledge editing dataset
(MzsRE) in 12 languages, which along with code, and additional project
information is available at https://github.com/Vicky-Wil/ReMaKE. | [
0.0541513599,
0.039652247,
-0.026556246,
0.0634311959,
-0.0402819999,
-0.0213334113,
-0.0141596645,
-0.0018467146,
-0.0008826829,
-0.0390739925,
-0.0534762591,
0.0104291067,
0.0091816252,
-0.0038816554,
0.0133179631,
-0.0335349143,
0.0594815537,
-0.0212097522,
-0.0116640441,
-0.0072810785,
-0.0016832616,
0.0135001251,
0.021314105,
0.0134181213,
0.006182583,
-0.0317165367,
-0.0093558906,
-0.0015671859,
0.0170506835,
0.0246521197,
0.0223413203,
0.0488314629,
-0.0051746182,
0.0451989509,
0.0000021172,
-0.057244923,
-0.0600493252,
0.012925785,
-0.0075201178,
0.017605802,
0.0182310231,
-0.0316305645,
-0.0279140174,
-0.0212926827,
-0.0120875286,
0.0262806434,
0.0518168174,
-0.0019680015,
0.0650241375,
0.059094917,
0.0096918792,
0.0216692127,
0.0269234274,
-0.0149296839,
0.0146269836,
-0.0122043975,
0.0389608406,
0.0409886092,
-0.0353556797,
0.0517727025,
0.0130272349,
0.0801616386,
-0.0189937707,
-0.0493938364,
-0.0041542053,
-0.0269047227,
-0.03374587,
-0.0160605367,
0.0076949238,
0.028332537,
0.0084581953,
-0.0095066167,
-0.0199108366,
0.0203054976,
0.0330784656,
0.0376548283,
-0.0343631133,
-0.016424926,
0.0176011641,
-0.0393015221,
-0.0102870828,
-0.1091902927,
0.0239007976,
0.0148145389,
-0.0095709246,
0.0633907765,
0.0405687988,
-0.0231208839,
-0.037734136,
-0.016380867,
0.0134141007,
-0.0506523848,
-0.007276597,
0.0377757661,
-0.02978939,
0.0235679261,
-0.0254505184,
-0.0259695332,
0.0348027684,
-0.0581462048,
0.0156679824,
0.035231702,
-0.0441770367,
0.0714627653,
-0.0136324596,
0.0436148271,
0.0187488087,
-0.0109908776,
-0.0209831111,
-0.0176038612,
-0.0510179363,
-0.0124900248,
-0.0354089886,
0.0059281015,
-0.0502499565,
0.0703203306,
-0.0255165379,
0.0372532159,
-0.0281973016,
0.052196864,
-0.0111990878,
-0.0230302215,
-0.0119502954,
-0.0316118337,
-0.0401394479,
0.0559041351,
0.0135003189,
-0.0208461843,
-0.0120173283,
-0.0453770906,
0.0068558468,
-0.022393113,
-0.001655402,
-0.0259133093,
0.0089260153,
0.0273538362,
-0.0395607911,
0.0056670955,
-0.0499692038,
-0.059888538,
0.0105376495,
-0.0345254317,
-0.0317223743,
-0.0784106106,
0.0655179918,
-0.0021901552,
-0.027378168,
-0.0886614025,
0.0024645035,
0.0006383889,
-0.0431098044,
0.0624940097,
-0.0538810827,
0.0361183807,
0.0620650239,
0.0182782505,
-0.0558168665,
0.0639356151,
0.0058438666,
-0.0295034982,
0.092359975,
0.0206383709,
0.0009052852,
0.0401126295,
0.0059371646,
0.0461151861,
0.0024595812,
0.030795943,
0.0142993862,
0.0164052732,
0.0016266973,
-0.0082603097,
-0.0091967983,
0.0164787006,
0.0419462845,
-0.0096071167,
0.028895583,
0.0298993718,
0.0069492469,
-0.0233104602,
0.0103110839,
-0.0255336687,
-0.0164866485,
0.0377640054,
-0.0444479361,
0.0141929481,
-0.0099335434,
0.0396443717,
0.0038090586,
-0.0286380723,
0.0019915069,
0.0052359733,
-0.0080898581,
0.0120894192,
0.0582462475,
0.0008935019,
-0.0085785063,
0.0638926476,
0.0134380814,
-0.0460186452,
0.0091856774,
-0.0094051734,
0.0002150038,
0.0745986477,
0.0628578067,
-0.0608025566,
-0.0608170964,
-0.0009481281,
-0.0317727365,
-0.0133730071,
0.0665058419,
-0.0369078666,
-0.0163354836,
-0.0228899941,
-0.0432718582,
-0.0216622259,
0.0106196431,
0.0139397457,
0.0419576652,
0.0177927613,
0.0294376649,
-0.0428102054,
-0.0313066915,
-0.0175862778,
-0.0647114366,
0.024723297,
-0.0160957985,
0.0162964184,
-0.0226139594,
0.0105998786,
-0.0184133947,
-0.0122839734,
0.0177470706,
0.0035102249,
-0.038557563,
-0.006829801,
0.0299696904,
-0.0405173227,
0.0597882606,
0.0244557932,
-0.0226901453,
-0.0094208485,
-0.0299774911,
-0.0202427972,
0.0022574684,
0.0130666262,
0.0475020967,
-0.0322989188,
0.0366935953,
-0.0296313111,
-0.0513013043,
-0.0337675996,
0.0267492216,
0.0131794959,
0.0231761634,
0.0402259156,
-0.0266937427,
0.0160925314,
-0.0192662254,
-0.0369298942,
0.0378188863,
0.0120666036,
0.0145426495,
0.030693749,
0.009602461,
-0.0266545098,
-0.0134948399,
-0.0817554444,
0.0002774387,
-0.02639273,
-0.0001923825,
0.0168756694,
0.0468213744,
-0.0124479281,
-0.0169668831,
0.0019950387,
0.0119540272,
0.0108497282,
0.0647862703,
0.0198012795,
0.0235906355,
0.0282984823,
-0.0510251969,
0.0150644798,
0.019013891,
0.0370134711,
-0.0003076306,
-0.037430767,
-0.0614860766,
0.054560937,
-0.0974150375,
0.0119750472,
0.0063477131,
-0.0157254953,
-0.0339846611,
-0.0059044682,
0.0902003273,
0.0166075472,
-0.0460017659,
-0.0058079851,
0.0690487176,
-0.047531601,
-0.0366957001,
0.0185964908,
0.0320658945,
-0.0601855032,
-0.0250047017,
-0.0134689035,
0.0243930332,
0.0135605335,
0.0009875133,
-0.0546441115,
-0.030103704,
0.0121991104,
-0.0150217526,
-0.0015376349,
-0.0667367652,
0.0169423372,
0.019548323,
0.0639226884,
-0.0425831974,
-0.020774221,
0.07317283,
-0.0079113636,
0.0096052289,
-0.0369081199,
0.0042477506,
-0.028461989,
0.0496768616,
-0.0506781563,
0.0509532467,
-0.0454269014,
0.027553495,
-0.0718383044,
0.0050876676,
0.0446167625,
-0.0427583978,
0.0649511963,
-0.0725337565,
0.0165180564,
-0.0256986432,
-0.0186218806,
-0.0061178086,
0.0380214415,
-0.0045779785,
-0.0041797096,
0.0247034896,
-0.026983954,
-0.0304040164,
-0.018741034,
0.0901989862,
0.0595895424,
0.0147013776,
-0.0244906936,
0.0021782746,
-0.0125122592,
0.015692709,
0.018702874,
-0.0146228764,
-0.0057840417,
0.0261118263,
0.0530413315,
-0.0102213798,
-0.0748552307,
0.0386209786,
-0.0247888323,
0.0282069817,
-0.0649430081,
-0.0192113053,
-0.0313792676,
0.0390146337,
-0.05385793,
-0.0124292551,
0.0799587891,
0.0398156531,
-0.042891819,
-0.0230132733,
-0.0759871081,
-0.0111412182,
0.0633490905,
0.0735381395,
-0.0957403183,
-0.0063885208,
0.0132949734,
0.0133923376,
0.0094029829,
-0.0441579558,
-0.0176182203,
-0.0892717689,
0.016061591,
0.0052755051,
-0.039294444,
-0.0538162142,
-0.0287846625,
0.013111731,
0.0141176973,
-0.0281949416,
0.0527553111,
0.0142897004,
0.0040920121,
-0.0516044348,
-0.0052023064,
-0.0301287957,
0.0081606647,
-0.0217402577,
0.0158432294,
0.0449677706,
0.0376167856,
0.0127154505,
-0.0166460648,
0.0051363814,
0.0432299301,
0.012624139,
-0.0227443241,
0.0088674352,
0.0321727395,
-0.0040460457,
0.036249809,
-0.0206224695,
-0.0038660238,
-0.0344721489,
0.0736272037,
0.1088745221,
-0.0179357883,
0.0620804019,
0.0095285922,
-0.0607186407,
-0.0020067401,
0.0520911664,
0.0037571946,
-0.0055048298,
0.0289603844,
-0.0705193728,
-0.0201353822,
-0.0090876129,
0.0016477762,
0.002661882,
-0.0623709895,
0.0315187462,
-0.0889947861,
-0.0512762293,
0.0506666563,
-0.0170486979,
0.0668980107,
0.0079927733,
0.0175822806,
-0.0159157868,
-0.0536318794,
-0.0262797941,
-0.053958986,
0.0148109412,
-0.0367267132,
-0.0125650801,
0.0167693421,
-0.0534161925,
-0.0034110579,
-0.0281527378,
-0.0173910763,
-0.0556335077,
-0.0325766876,
0.044281479,
0.0109260147,
0.0574120432,
0.0097958073,
-0.0351499282,
0.0348888338,
0.0232085008,
-0.0234161187,
0.0182394609,
0.0020659538,
0.0203028154,
-0.0389818996,
0.0501046591,
-0.1009165347,
-0.0439356863,
-0.0116932075,
0.0389478467,
-0.0271119475,
-0.0455696769,
0.0153160654,
0.05659163,
0.0139939021,
0.0360601693,
-0.0006131358,
-0.0560038537,
0.0447135717,
-0.0253201071,
-0.0495618582,
-0.0086618839,
0.0381444953,
-0.0208790135,
-0.0511005782,
0.0273250341,
0.0322270468,
0.0098755639,
0.025167454,
-0.0207468122,
-0.019431496,
0.0273556784,
0.0093378397,
0.0805424079,
0.0303266849,
-0.0074763233,
0.042149853,
-0.0102715045,
0.0060215942,
-0.0448410325,
0.018892087,
0.0138783958,
-0.0273213983,
-0.0347509645,
-0.0049043065,
-0.0373632126,
-0.0619986914,
0.0050106086,
0.0122868568,
0.0762205496,
0.0338906161,
0.07163544,
-0.0378220007,
-0.0582808182,
-0.0275603011,
0.0160663724,
0.0431455113,
-0.0219293814,
0.0061618569,
0.0020928758,
-0.0023889076,
0.0339679495,
0.0712464005,
-0.068480365,
0.0908164233,
-0.0562738664,
-0.0713770241,
-0.0267287698,
-0.0154838068,
0.0226853248,
-0.0086557753,
-0.0430961587,
-0.0382391363,
-0.0300653763,
-0.0383361951,
0.0194347557,
0.0200559832,
-0.04725454,
0.0077208853,
-0.0127282655,
0.0963213593,
0.0224143397,
0.0162757169,
-0.0387559049,
0.0255556274,
-0.0250294637,
-0.0201545935,
0.0159774441,
-5.521659532e-33,
-0.0005956865,
0.0036495926,
0.0336328484,
-0.0001116814,
-0.0105290618,
0.0021417839,
-0.0366557911,
-0.0113913361,
-0.0064302813,
0.0142050823,
-0.0199744664,
-0.005425944,
-0.0081830835,
-0.0133638335,
0.0390546136,
0.0350851156,
0.0675644726,
0.0401707105,
-0.0187441837,
0.0152767245,
0.0643580332,
0.0461406782,
0.0914497823,
-0.0251217559,
0.0899533108,
0.0307020396,
0.019610513,
0.0426567085,
-0.0289814044,
0.0479853153,
0.0008971932,
0.0677042753,
0.0061990609,
-0.0339585356,
-0.0284497086,
-0.0706527382,
-0.0242332276,
-0.0137421079,
0.0072903149,
0.0493992753,
-0.0081773344,
-0.0537033677,
0.0432290509,
-0.008702172,
-0.0093622627,
0.0099438867,
0.026222039,
-0.0472439453,
0.0045314059,
-0.0176822562,
-0.0553217344,
-0.0018141066,
-0.0006661493,
-0.0142953079,
-0.0098474249,
0.019486716,
0.0495298021,
0.0038971303,
-0.0913023651,
0.0241297465,
0.0170999356,
0.05749394,
0.0798725411,
-0.0252545364,
-0.0113082305,
0.002573862,
-0.0131396232,
0.0337617956,
0.0237333663,
0.0045726495,
0.0025742659,
0.0283353347,
0.0175994076,
0.0922610164,
-0.0194465406,
-0.0256298874,
-0.0301061403,
0.0199377611,
-0.0395313352,
0.0463666432,
-0.0261025038,
0.0531551242,
0.0211608876,
-0.0041735885,
-0.0508182831,
0.0017577595,
-0.050089933,
-0.0289368741,
0.0204447098,
0.000614421,
-0.0085333977,
-0.0074616172,
0.024095932,
-0.0178096816,
-0.0069545987,
0.0307981521,
-0.0474594645,
0.0211677756,
-0.0086912988,
0.0024135374,
-0.0064017344,
0.018503705,
0.0010183657,
-0.0119221834,
-0.0091313636,
0.0154127628,
0.0217303019,
0.0335341617,
-0.065220736,
0.0272049922,
-0.0268686842,
0.0016085812,
-0.0193307102,
-0.0325616226,
-0.0318828262,
-0.0045780852,
0.0071014254,
0.0137930196,
0.0833326057,
-0.0045733433,
-0.0371102951,
-0.0040782434,
0.0030367179,
0.0024499693,
-0.0012289592,
0.0211857781,
-0.0233692359,
0.0103531247,
0.0013830982,
0.0009708562,
-0.0089544859,
0.0096325483,
2.78e-7,
0.031085765,
0.057410378,
-0.002644971,
0.0009339218,
0.0134690711,
0.0314305611,
-0.0434266627,
-0.0051693069,
0.016664261,
0.022490887,
-0.0003826754,
0.0160249341,
0.0189321991,
0.0453416966,
-0.0739280656,
-0.026808111,
-0.0177673008,
-0.0238006953,
-0.0714042932,
-0.0206668694,
0.0381265357,
0.007387639,
0.0214793496,
-0.0034948147,
-0.0454835333,
-0.0464022309,
0.0660320818,
-0.0198618546,
-0.0417603962,
0.0375889055,
0.0766904354,
0.0300285332,
0.0228077509,
-0.0037726341,
-0.0440104157,
-0.0299369097,
0.005321403,
0.0426829718,
-0.0136871925,
0.0446836315,
0.0153467506,
0.0055189519,
-0.0128271123,
-0.0522267334,
0.049211219,
0.0146805709,
0.0472409502,
-0.0014255338,
-0.016356796,
0.0008384031,
0.0286888089,
-0.0591089278,
-0.0288257897,
0.0055508199,
0.0061409287,
0.0528078601,
-0.0426342711,
-0.0036529258,
-0.0390657559,
0.0213967841,
0.0102713332,
-0.060554456,
-0.0408760272,
-0.0597526953,
-0.0186889544,
-0.0765235648,
0.0331275314,
2.25218381e-34,
-0.0008757582,
0.0123481927,
-0.0015725159,
0.0162209887,
0.0619474053,
-0.0415507033,
-0.0304902103,
0.0025831242,
-0.0397270061,
-0.0437253192,
-0.029768832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13026v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13026v1 | FusDom: Combining In-Domain and Out-of-Domain Knowledge for Continuous Self-Supervised Learning | 2023-12-20T13:50:05 | 2023-12-20T13:50:05 | Ashish Seth, Sreyan Ghosh, S. Umesh, Dinesh Manocha | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD | Continued pre-training (CP) offers multiple advantages, like target domain
adaptation and the potential to exploit the continuous stream of unlabeled data
available online. However, continued pre-training on out-of-domain
distributions often leads to catastrophic forgetting of previously acquired
knowledge, leading to sub-optimal ASR performance. This paper presents FusDom,
a simple and novel methodology for SSL-based continued pre-training. FusDom
learns speech representations that are robust and adaptive yet not forgetful of
concepts seen in the past. Instead of solving the SSL pre-text task on the
output representations of a single model, FusDom leverages two identical
pre-trained SSL models, a teacher and a student, with a modified pre-training
head to solve the CP SSL pre-text task. This head employs a cross-attention
mechanism between the representations of both models while only the student
receives gradient updates and the teacher does not. Finally, the student is
fine-tuned for ASR. In practice, FusDom outperforms all our baselines across
settings significantly, with WER improvements in the range of 0.2 WER - 7.3 WER
in the target domain while retaining the performance in the earlier domain. | [
-0.0577930436,
0.0172414053,
0.0211980976,
-0.0207467731,
0.0198674519,
-0.0093153594,
0.0610168055,
-0.0642277598,
0.0229313057,
-0.0169364493,
-0.0808234289,
-0.0124944141,
-0.0046515567,
0.0180438571,
0.0208591167,
-0.0126083447,
0.0456585474,
-0.0484689437,
-0.0477392524,
-0.0243097562,
0.0129334806,
-0.0372079611,
-0.0476423763,
-0.0057043005,
0.0035694158,
-0.0483998545,
-0.0042616562,
-0.0244359635,
0.0252302215,
-0.0388157591,
0.0183500424,
0.0232756212,
0.0726964101,
-0.0456091687,
0.0000023295,
-0.0400321782,
-0.0316091441,
-0.0133988317,
-0.0717552975,
0.0045673517,
-0.0411160737,
0.043266844,
-0.0247215834,
0.045866143,
-0.0168395415,
-0.0112979449,
0.0169944502,
0.0411519744,
0.0487250648,
0.027156353,
0.0083963424,
-0.0296274964,
0.0099040689,
-0.0145678958,
-0.0345535204,
-0.0296104085,
-0.0293156318,
-0.0601027608,
-0.0481366254,
-0.0282692667,
0.0024624416,
0.0838492066,
0.0396257527,
-0.0155611299,
0.0203995258,
0.0240791608,
0.0030088988,
0.0084206937,
-0.0053508738,
0.0451428853,
-0.0118351709,
-0.0436790101,
0.0069265538,
-0.0191933494,
-0.0143404966,
-0.0314336158,
-0.0123765562,
0.0094137639,
0.0046452302,
-0.0074420273,
-0.0207708087,
0.0403816439,
0.0018554527,
-0.0190125071,
-0.0378401093,
0.0202231426,
-0.0251868591,
-0.0497164726,
0.0345168747,
-0.0200183149,
-0.0062663793,
-0.0033169261,
0.06328962,
0.0270549878,
-0.0219474025,
-0.0045281644,
-0.0534273423,
-0.0506600551,
-0.0286321733,
-0.0373668149,
0.0443140417,
0.0133830504,
-0.0640521049,
0.0122181801,
0.0079855239,
0.0404003188,
0.046641171,
0.0275026523,
0.0135551272,
0.066108048,
-0.049282454,
0.0141117414,
-0.0628554076,
0.0610720851,
0.000650209,
-0.0180556607,
-0.0182267874,
0.0371516757,
-0.0323111378,
-0.0117939841,
0.0257641133,
-0.0129070515,
-0.0535688661,
-0.0120005934,
0.006230541,
0.0662935227,
0.0324186459,
0.0063335765,
0.0343751647,
-0.0153860832,
-0.030980574,
0.0104603926,
0.0482917018,
-0.0066213175,
0.000543905,
0.0565406345,
0.0011926854,
-0.0198719855,
-0.0646264553,
-0.0032628418,
-0.0060432018,
-0.0633606315,
0.0169914905,
-0.0062545035,
-0.0022895474,
-0.0112627298,
-0.0117560159,
-0.0741196051,
-0.0148957223,
-0.0023121983,
0.0766854137,
0.0386025347,
-0.0010874436,
-0.0152754309,
0.0156159727,
0.0022009232,
-0.0014485641,
0.0528929047,
-0.0232864209,
-0.022676304,
-0.03276233,
-0.0452977568,
-0.0109459022,
0.0198524036,
0.0624091141,
-0.0161810778,
-0.0231402367,
-0.0035973398,
0.0401987657,
0.018271504,
0.0533261262,
-0.0147215119,
-0.0018846137,
-0.0195188466,
0.0823228955,
0.0044489703,
0.0584089831,
0.0559114031,
0.0031873109,
0.0495693497,
0.0530397408,
0.0113642849,
-0.0461137258,
0.0315894037,
-0.0124593005,
0.0188748315,
-0.0102112042,
0.0229960009,
-0.0278759357,
-0.0548630953,
0.0377898887,
-0.0354614444,
-0.0494609065,
0.0730298758,
0.0555759333,
0.043020051,
-0.0410605296,
0.0254719704,
0.0276183374,
-0.0316952839,
0.0326457918,
-0.0322836153,
-0.0172448549,
0.0267349239,
-0.0132706137,
-0.0628489554,
-0.0810623318,
-0.0400062464,
0.0211593024,
0.0069266879,
-0.0270006433,
0.0423644036,
0.0617079102,
-0.0312063769,
-0.0458374359,
0.0084364191,
-0.027400421,
0.0527571812,
-0.0272045247,
0.0500341244,
-0.0119834086,
-0.0080659846,
0.0547684208,
-0.007850932,
-0.0628357157,
-0.0402482897,
-0.0128834862,
0.0185097624,
0.0270671193,
0.0133196525,
-0.038115494,
0.0169700067,
0.0329396427,
-0.0215581898,
-0.0201498531,
0.0127075603,
-0.1242722198,
-0.0035098903,
0.0460800864,
0.0075324206,
-0.0145820882,
0.0308021642,
0.0349736884,
-0.0213820022,
0.0497047305,
0.018733114,
0.0725172684,
-0.0456871167,
0.0505159609,
0.0473437794,
0.0020339841,
0.0130191119,
0.0146272108,
0.039290037,
-0.0342760459,
-0.0164676234,
-0.0029946242,
-0.005274334,
-0.0800321102,
0.0170561057,
-0.0247827861,
-0.0423586667,
0.0354819298,
0.0005368773,
0.0046283063,
-0.0468201451,
0.0343244039,
-0.0237987973,
-0.0015542154,
-0.0232509244,
0.0069016721,
-0.0173039325,
0.0133211166,
-0.0149014182,
-0.040860042,
-0.0136246299,
-0.0294077508,
-0.0420681871,
-0.0135598918,
-0.0528976209,
0.0032164231,
0.0419162922,
0.0114437714,
0.0217338186,
0.0203361567,
-0.0126661332,
-0.0422755294,
-0.0275428761,
-0.0480229408,
0.0615018755,
0.0036288036,
0.037910711,
-0.0004077436,
0.0082694329,
-0.0266168937,
-0.0059177121,
0.044071082,
0.0415738896,
0.0204472709,
-0.0094532715,
0.0408512875,
-0.0367000401,
-0.0478340015,
0.015275117,
0.003550546,
0.0017823274,
-0.0021869831,
0.1264549643,
0.0066221361,
0.0202391222,
0.0267136674,
0.0106801167,
-0.0137824863,
-0.0367728882,
-0.0342183709,
-0.0518698357,
-0.057686571,
0.0061473083,
-0.0456626378,
0.0001445481,
0.0250941329,
-0.0059395195,
0.0213514827,
-0.0064585479,
-0.0337867774,
-0.0712107122,
-0.0300680045,
0.0394231379,
-0.0015826398,
-0.0511726961,
0.0164045561,
0.0386727341,
-0.0402842239,
-0.0174507536,
0.0234459862,
0.0138231823,
-0.0101710754,
0.032030873,
0.0099972887,
0.0018363163,
0.0201927684,
-0.0427100621,
-0.0579396449,
-0.0311309118,
-0.0249834284,
-0.0042465315,
-0.0561450049,
0.0003880529,
-0.0407539345,
-0.006552713,
0.0341340564,
0.0630646423,
-0.0100108227,
-0.0001994092,
-0.0049404134,
-0.0166442487,
0.0109884618,
0.0227291584,
-0.0197647177,
-0.0160036907,
0.0353212729,
0.0073998552,
0.0878572464,
-0.0454994589,
-0.0288824476,
-0.0088146534,
0.026111858,
-0.0217022244,
0.0127610331,
0.0466664694,
0.0403837897,
-0.0612825379,
-0.0099683674,
0.0897496343,
-0.0013590428,
-0.0217088852,
-0.032880079,
-0.0049691238,
-0.0104773343,
0.0218948275,
0.0037483738,
-0.033622656,
-0.0171912741,
0.032536637,
0.03022114,
0.0651177242,
0.0192716159,
-0.0216103271,
-0.0749167576,
0.0288104508,
0.04580044,
-0.0418737978,
0.0129759228,
-0.0408614539,
-0.0381715745,
0.0012399174,
0.0344149135,
0.0120460177,
-0.0691295192,
-0.0231320094,
0.0495881662,
-0.0559179001,
-0.0416309908,
0.0084296362,
-0.0364063755,
0.0456661656,
0.0654818714,
-0.017064156,
0.0433783829,
-0.0559883229,
0.0850134641,
-0.0296455938,
0.0041817147,
-0.0232411958,
0.0335055217,
-0.0056429296,
-0.0231620986,
0.0194839723,
0.0331595913,
-0.0323697478,
-0.0199056976,
0.0397106931,
0.0548619404,
-0.0235109255,
-0.0045817462,
0.0202146433,
0.0291587021,
0.0013660402,
0.0236091167,
0.0320278443,
-0.0310928617,
-0.0103920121,
0.022651678,
0.0528909862,
0.0172620192,
-0.0372643918,
0.0407487676,
-0.0160497241,
-0.0601296797,
0.0234294049,
-0.0337259918,
-0.001055313,
0.0646853745,
0.0058950614,
-0.0180423874,
0.0178495124,
0.0093696471,
-0.0532505661,
0.0179038197,
-0.0376524851,
0.0114389583,
-0.0666189119,
-0.0487389266,
0.035547033,
-0.0454228632,
-0.0168121178,
0.0123577695,
-0.0436126031,
-0.0310673341,
0.0610566512,
-0.0083354972,
0.0055023143,
0.0547005981,
-0.0350248031,
-0.0229642503,
0.1336328536,
0.0322995223,
-0.0560590252,
0.0318391658,
0.0762322098,
-0.0061347126,
0.0102100307,
0.0083701983,
-0.0229812302,
0.0583090372,
-0.0165814292,
0.0121057015,
0.0263416134,
0.0077118315,
0.0215085912,
-0.0035323128,
0.096097149,
0.0192244221,
0.0290644858,
-0.0355834216,
0.0427994505,
-0.0228536259,
0.0446602106,
-0.037482392,
-0.0046236208,
0.0078277774,
0.0254103262,
0.0204455517,
0.0473975874,
-0.0200534798,
-0.0070289117,
-0.0132715525,
0.0536976308,
0.0232340619,
0.0266798455,
-0.0069966889,
0.0267619509,
-0.0007667592,
0.0142365787,
0.062724404,
0.0278568529,
-0.0165708791,
0.0320717506,
0.0133184493,
0.0313836746,
0.0206104536,
0.03073195,
-0.0501734577,
-0.062104512,
-0.0548750907,
-0.0032892812,
0.0141654583,
0.0143072708,
0.0305629186,
0.0403558165,
0.0213067047,
-0.0493181422,
0.0053518908,
-0.0304552987,
0.0253501795,
0.0284724962,
-0.019359991,
0.0071042692,
0.0087789912,
0.0405532867,
-0.0331682414,
0.0302534439,
0.021355303,
0.0575527623,
-0.0634617358,
-0.0401669592,
-0.0607192479,
0.0156674162,
-0.0066514392,
-0.0110330936,
0.0269800872,
-0.0924372599,
0.0372188538,
-0.0231531933,
0.0033388096,
0.0088237813,
0.0346495584,
-0.015654631,
-0.0339840688,
0.016766686,
0.0384514332,
-0.0163489003,
0.0448138192,
-0.0185099021,
0.047215458,
-7.123816088e-33,
-0.0236415062,
0.045473069,
0.0357082486,
0.0021038321,
-0.0329849608,
0.010061495,
-0.0698170662,
0.0369329117,
0.0480027981,
-0.0117778508,
-0.0154162748,
-0.0086427201,
0.0407932848,
0.0296545494,
-0.0029992666,
-0.039799653,
0.0926683322,
-0.0096155982,
0.0175907314,
0.0079417136,
0.018868478,
0.0684714466,
0.0490514673,
-0.0899118409,
-0.0361776017,
0.0357911214,
0.0088925036,
-0.0426014252,
0.0372643396,
0.0444324054,
0.0029203084,
0.0358843394,
-0.0129556991,
-0.0375002995,
-0.0646258444,
-0.012553486,
-0.1169327945,
-0.0400106832,
-0.0430289879,
0.0114009725,
-0.0315312296,
-0.0108094374,
0.0365373604,
0.0057017375,
-0.0275293272,
-0.0616848804,
0.0498853736,
0.0219567809,
-0.0076136538,
-0.0563672259,
-0.0166402459,
0.0057426998,
-0.0074801762,
-0.0320738815,
0.0404376388,
0.0385699533,
-0.0213242285,
-0.0534502305,
-0.0375973023,
0.0354221128,
0.0050103758,
0.0255708192,
0.0346513987,
-0.0145088993,
-0.0001749313,
0.0240217671,
0.0280556437,
-0.0700055286,
0.0326354466,
-0.0521239638,
0.0636297464,
0.0008921568,
-0.0382914729,
-0.0209905952,
0.0210042428,
-0.0404702686,
-0.020571392,
-0.0255825017,
-0.0112623563,
0.0081667397,
-0.0036148471,
0.0255175363,
-0.0191168394,
-0.0033660545,
-0.0512185991,
0.0050878217,
-0.0311413575,
-0.0141396457,
0.0976359919,
0.0180804878,
0.0316329785,
0.0283232499,
0.0422823951,
-0.021894509,
0.0054965555,
-0.0095417639,
0.0125927674,
-0.032062728,
0.0261028446,
0.039282281,
-0.06137079,
0.0007260069,
0.035742268,
0.0324900933,
-0.0086948127,
0.0016381972,
0.0211282987,
0.0671365485,
-0.0651379749,
-0.031097956,
-0.0229176693,
0.026226541,
0.0601747781,
0.0017427384,
0.0487938747,
0.0014627776,
-0.0216503404,
0.0730320811,
-0.0094413124,
-0.0182041284,
-0.0331539437,
0.0325412266,
0.0310557429,
0.0416247956,
-0.0311726741,
-0.0199594889,
-0.0071441596,
-0.0401076563,
0.0259266105,
-0.0890578106,
-0.0035403646,
-0.0365259163,
3.108e-7,
-0.046313975,
0.0024463129,
0.0091583207,
-0.0205557067,
0.0203560926,
0.0108793536,
-0.0443198904,
0.0188932884,
0.0096344883,
0.049738761,
-0.0105518308,
0.0349759236,
0.0219395515,
-0.0238001533,
-0.0594149269,
-0.0208397955,
-0.034442585,
0.032804843,
-0.0172692593,
0.0096287103,
-0.0079425685,
0.0678534582,
0.0080177877,
-0.0363797769,
0.0408309996,
-0.0171943717,
0.0424167477,
0.0228895862,
0.0176436845,
-0.0735974163,
-0.0343634523,
0.0087653808,
-0.0301420651,
0.0022255678,
-0.0529245064,
0.0117884194,
-0.0140989535,
0.0028164692,
-0.0195798278,
-0.0699362084,
0.0378112122,
0.091017276,
0.0003034428,
0.0275334157,
0.0452867784,
-0.0817456022,
-0.0244129915,
0.0078767389,
-0.0636365712,
-0.0340659246,
0.003462292,
0.0379081592,
-0.0111459261,
-0.0198407583,
-0.0090142358,
0.0366149433,
-0.0279706009,
-0.0713867173,
0.004792477,
0.030397119,
-0.0416791439,
0.0082812617,
-0.0529820956,
0.0021869973,
0.0318014473,
-0.0070974166,
0.0252104215,
2.226769025e-34,
0.0276088249,
-0.0147970449,
0.0235076603,
-0.0079244431,
-0.0307934452,
-0.0430107303,
0.0371059291,
0.0205709729,
0.0223020129,
-0.0096892938,
-0.030651642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13010v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13010v3 | AgentCoder: Multi-Agent-based Code Generation with Iterative Testing and Optimisation | 2023-12-20T13:22:41 | 2024-05-24T11:47:24 | Dong Huang, Jie M. Zhang, Michael Luck, Qingwen Bu, Yuhao Qing, Heming Cui | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advancement of natural language processing (NLP) has been significantly
boosted by the development of transformer-based large language models (LLMs).
These models have revolutionized NLP tasks, particularly in code generation,
aiding developers in creating software with enhanced efficiency. Despite their
advancements, challenges in balancing code snippet generation with effective
test case generation and execution persist. To address these issues, this paper
introduces Multi-Agent Assistant Code Generation (AgentCoder), a novel solution
comprising a multi-agent framework with specialized agents: the programmer
agent, the test designer agent, and the test executor agent. During the coding
procedure, the programmer agent will focus on the code generation and
refinement based on the test executor agent's feedback. The test designer agent
will generate test cases for the generated code, and the test executor agent
will run the code with the test cases and write the feedback to the programmer.
This collaborative system ensures robust code generation, surpassing the
limitations of single-agent models and traditional methodologies. Our extensive
experiments on 9 code generation models and 12 enhancement approaches showcase
AgentCoder's superior performance over existing code generation models and
prompt engineering techniques across various benchmarks. For example,
AgentCoder (GPT-4) achieves 96.3\% and 91.8\% pass@1 in HumanEval and MBPP
datasets with an overall token overhead of 56.9K and 66.3K, while
state-of-the-art obtains only 90.2\% and 78.9\% pass@1 with an overall token
overhead of 138.2K and 206.5K. | [
0.0397541523,
0.0374680944,
-0.0527830981,
0.0358247757,
-0.0430266671,
-0.0205473658,
-0.0123083685,
-0.0025478068,
0.0250582714,
-0.0328067876,
0.0111662475,
0.0253114216,
-0.0110893119,
0.0399656668,
0.0173186436,
-0.0142284399,
0.0284885298,
-0.0206073262,
-0.0032438014,
0.0115426891,
-0.0071053244,
0.0109486952,
0.008874963,
0.0909685045,
-0.0290042646,
-0.0204603784,
-0.0317151882,
-0.0120001854,
-0.0113304453,
-0.0339564905,
0.0157405287,
0.0460639,
-0.006990205,
0.0180284083,
0.0000023603,
-0.0512349717,
-0.0144328028,
0.0105926208,
-0.000147436,
0.0061847763,
0.0269703828,
0.0048058028,
-0.0184939485,
0.0486154817,
-0.0641763657,
-0.0323630497,
0.0335020609,
-0.013735001,
0.1040263548,
0.0756423473,
0.0024692391,
-0.0062727081,
-0.0087895859,
0.0382303782,
0.0003617001,
-0.0358196348,
-0.0224024951,
0.0000134329,
0.0506844595,
0.0013164489,
-0.0154604791,
-0.0025577245,
0.0423078686,
-0.0179624408,
-0.0258980282,
0.0386934057,
-0.0266838148,
-0.0342502482,
-0.0349932835,
0.010107588,
-0.0160839669,
-0.0209532976,
0.0094325673,
-0.0033983844,
-0.0031648192,
-0.0121795414,
0.0114651993,
0.057949543,
-0.0195726585,
-0.015719071,
0.014396756,
-0.0257173348,
-0.0255504288,
-0.0024947706,
-0.0603359938,
0.0317841619,
-0.0158711206,
-0.0152881714,
-0.0502879061,
-0.0190969147,
0.0148252416,
-0.0625531673,
0.0054787258,
0.0672147423,
-0.0865175799,
-0.0011924644,
-0.043956358,
-0.0598234795,
0.0362002254,
-0.0155325998,
0.014877812,
0.0317726098,
-0.0117986007,
-0.0124801155,
-0.0459724441,
0.1009134799,
0.0245218668,
0.010181414,
-0.0144103365,
0.0252722465,
-0.0674464703,
0.0006767961,
-0.0769012496,
0.0471866094,
-0.0163412709,
0.0167031474,
-0.0039755949,
0.0685267225,
0.0020291971,
0.0602470301,
-0.0117603028,
-0.002588165,
-0.0245271027,
0.0154035958,
0.0154772839,
-0.0101508265,
-0.0291798953,
-0.0468146205,
0.0134543888,
-0.0769378543,
0.0067680832,
0.0140633909,
-0.0186614674,
0.0071008042,
0.0131452549,
0.078883484,
0.0095422659,
-0.0258191191,
-0.020196557,
-0.0439165682,
0.0452203117,
-0.0275891759,
-0.0415180065,
-0.0844268873,
-0.0156621672,
0.0237540156,
-0.0261609331,
-0.0769777,
0.0114731742,
0.0126548698,
0.0240710173,
0.0574656054,
-0.03867089,
0.0560822897,
0.0196198896,
-0.0050258064,
-0.0215895604,
0.0559503213,
0.0737318322,
0.0177762844,
0.0202208757,
-0.0193150174,
0.054949902,
0.029183479,
-0.0386563465,
0.0158143695,
0.0619768873,
0.0073942165,
0.0025193705,
0.0173362382,
-0.0083960984,
0.0527364463,
0.002602299,
0.0040640114,
0.0098548727,
0.0435699001,
0.0160757508,
0.0447653495,
0.0753861815,
0.0756310225,
-0.0302401632,
-0.0274525527,
-0.0063005229,
0.0304853432,
-0.0086603463,
-0.0075591654,
-0.0231881049,
0.0665407106,
-0.0067172763,
-0.0504218042,
0.0241443161,
-0.0296390057,
0.0419521295,
-0.0018471775,
0.0295414701,
0.0207878891,
-0.0853463113,
0.0215287656,
-0.0045342846,
-0.0946218893,
-0.0315677598,
-0.0809291899,
0.0449106805,
0.0619052574,
0.0543140545,
0.0007016877,
-0.015068966,
0.0059732753,
-0.0173832327,
0.0067036697,
0.0170155521,
-0.0007948952,
-0.0362231061,
-0.0431308188,
-0.0366669632,
-0.0050147944,
-0.0049178759,
0.0438634194,
0.0316429622,
-0.0278555714,
0.0475185812,
0.0432812721,
-0.073963888,
0.0548386984,
-0.0280171577,
0.0028199353,
0.0339764468,
-0.0039164862,
0.0338800214,
-0.0088130021,
-0.0428108983,
0.0195447449,
0.0482231304,
-0.0169586036,
-0.0366834402,
0.0088047944,
0.005317783,
-0.0576652102,
0.0137512209,
-0.0288242269,
-0.0077341618,
0.0361624658,
-0.028459264,
-0.0182191692,
0.0247112289,
-0.0521339849,
0.0090143168,
-0.0006894718,
0.0424739122,
-0.043751806,
-0.0204293896,
-0.0189544242,
0.0108175501,
0.0290996581,
-0.0123123452,
-0.0141431531,
0.0986165181,
0.0086606126,
-0.00175093,
-0.0116545381,
0.0372607186,
-0.0157848652,
0.0337429568,
0.02779104,
0.0719306692,
-0.0038749415,
-0.0496823378,
-0.1025304571,
0.036693152,
-0.0173247252,
0.0108891232,
0.0021394007,
0.0460539907,
-0.0085569331,
0.0198360458,
-0.0312281363,
0.0126003716,
0.0140832746,
0.0190423466,
-0.0048001595,
-0.0190762244,
-0.0781129897,
0.00561762,
0.021435149,
-0.0433993489,
0.0331939422,
0.0215479061,
-0.0021675581,
-0.1073293909,
0.0727750361,
0.0202161744,
0.0023852249,
0.003877287,
-0.0512334183,
0.0227194373,
-0.0305382926,
0.0304781031,
0.0556182601,
0.0115659209,
0.0228325073,
0.0122374697,
0.0010238958,
-0.0789559931,
0.0209754165,
0.0206390861,
-0.0548630022,
0.0068101725,
-0.0217498858,
0.0744353011,
0.0596398376,
-0.0009160457,
-0.0301421024,
-0.0490569174,
0.0073939748,
0.0018041442,
0.0230278037,
0.0429540314,
-0.0437421054,
-0.0186556354,
0.0343201309,
-0.0081813755,
-0.0692066774,
0.0754602328,
-0.0529830083,
-0.0137786819,
-0.0710131153,
-0.0201464724,
-0.063916415,
0.0740267113,
-0.0017937786,
0.0154340211,
-0.0136020286,
-0.0243620221,
-0.008745539,
0.0301833656,
-0.0207360089,
-0.0337579213,
0.0485105291,
-0.0484635532,
0.0159421545,
-0.0195467919,
-0.0461094156,
-0.0415867418,
0.0030103691,
-0.0170905497,
0.0070342603,
0.0387652218,
0.011775203,
-0.0004018992,
0.0254652053,
-0.0146098947,
0.0572015569,
0.0060193106,
-0.0344579332,
-0.025308311,
-0.0596943907,
-0.028854426,
-0.0254474804,
-0.0137164816,
-0.0016363631,
0.0221812893,
0.0273052678,
0.0450530462,
0.0506292805,
-0.0716501921,
-0.0162266232,
0.0188448671,
-0.028768193,
0.0164323337,
0.0537101738,
0.0533803701,
-0.0627836809,
-0.0066914181,
0.0899344236,
0.0416171774,
-0.0515527129,
0.0265148599,
-0.0105791558,
0.0307154283,
0.0541906543,
0.0594804697,
-0.0762953237,
-0.026340941,
-0.0128391311,
0.0166694801,
-0.03111309,
-0.00499793,
-0.0170647185,
-0.1228390485,
0.0368207134,
-0.01118802,
0.0090237046,
-0.0214112625,
-0.0308080707,
-0.0273072589,
0.0058862325,
0.017213285,
0.0431957208,
0.0244595837,
0.0180894434,
0.0032703045,
-0.0077667465,
-0.0016033435,
0.0330102183,
-0.046706412,
0.0349163339,
0.1119738072,
-0.0006870877,
0.0079574836,
-0.0034656625,
-0.0049344948,
0.0157363005,
0.0471873395,
-0.0305226836,
-0.0016195601,
0.0033191228,
-0.0159933306,
0.0499824509,
0.0054583731,
-0.0792751685,
0.001339158,
0.0760151967,
0.0318909176,
0.0021959243,
-0.0127500137,
-0.0326737016,
-0.0026048089,
0.0093517173,
0.0264640842,
0.0296900254,
-0.0300326981,
-0.0392111652,
-0.0550830811,
-0.0070238635,
-0.0640795976,
-0.0213094018,
-0.0051366054,
-0.0151773011,
0.0094125345,
-0.0471308865,
-0.0298567619,
0.0665743276,
0.046600882,
0.0375645086,
-0.0532633215,
0.0274586286,
-0.0024921913,
-0.0435180403,
-0.0061721071,
-0.0134191485,
0.0238601509,
-0.0296860859,
-0.0305283144,
0.0242912993,
-0.018868329,
0.0104299048,
0.0284508802,
-0.0421310998,
-0.070253484,
-0.0213346053,
0.0714878812,
0.0124928076,
0.0132521484,
-0.0282100197,
-0.0366658047,
-0.0227844026,
0.0196878295,
-0.0787625238,
0.0110575091,
-0.0176707301,
-0.0027303495,
0.0091070635,
-0.0036120866,
-0.0489030965,
0.0037887287,
-0.0212364271,
0.0335431471,
0.0100787114,
-0.0071546813,
0.050671041,
0.0502274223,
-0.034383107,
-0.0135598611,
-0.0149568878,
0.0244221091,
0.0025969383,
-0.0243848227,
-0.0278513655,
-0.0497686528,
0.051639434,
-0.0267157666,
-0.0206035245,
0.0638400242,
-0.0037766458,
-0.051037617,
0.028253125,
0.0097975861,
0.0730834231,
-0.0309066046,
0.0303052999,
0.0537075177,
-0.0134956781,
-0.0149660259,
-0.0061363629,
0.0166499056,
0.0138633931,
0.0002489253,
0.0707991794,
0.0239547994,
0.0375649855,
-0.0114730764,
0.0163599215,
-0.0274233669,
-0.050227087,
-0.0058119418,
0.0016879481,
0.003975966,
0.0707512125,
0.0079709021,
-0.0422220603,
0.0450480357,
-0.0056420644,
0.0408531837,
-0.0232411865,
-0.0519404449,
-0.0109462291,
0.0172590371,
-0.0002519718,
-0.069801122,
0.1015148386,
-0.0069143283,
0.0184575599,
-0.0199870095,
-0.0201382972,
-0.0494862162,
0.0120356772,
0.0427046567,
-0.0263741873,
0.0027913209,
-0.0231309496,
-0.020780459,
-0.0248774234,
0.0103801386,
0.023684971,
0.0383347571,
-0.0073720226,
0.0226044506,
0.0859330297,
0.0080670537,
-0.0393698663,
-0.0361799821,
-0.0129746264,
-0.0108539285,
-0.0362494066,
-0.0351476409,
-5.82779022e-33,
-0.0260033961,
-0.0494274199,
0.0325263403,
0.0289004706,
0.0170368645,
-0.0205380321,
-0.0392753668,
-0.0202714913,
0.0286563821,
-0.038309712,
0.0102963438,
0.0174986161,
0.0040525934,
-0.010339411,
0.0433499925,
0.0350348391,
0.0586920157,
0.0019706783,
-0.0585605688,
0.0258347653,
-0.0537031554,
0.0104537988,
-0.0041665002,
-0.0342952162,
-0.049049329,
-0.0075010438,
0.0251691006,
-0.0000655378,
-0.0045792256,
0.0311000329,
0.0274672415,
0.0441337414,
0.006692538,
-0.0389236882,
-0.0254352838,
0.0076630842,
-0.0006287551,
-0.0342374668,
-0.002558683,
0.0158733372,
0.0081461994,
-0.0739886314,
0.0716376528,
-0.0247361381,
-0.0500415638,
0.0522078238,
0.0227930229,
0.0159969144,
0.0144047644,
-0.0321736857,
-0.0704363808,
0.0176645536,
-0.0392270908,
-0.0289192013,
-0.0140706804,
0.0225365218,
-0.0137117086,
-0.0098470701,
-0.0039961296,
0.0304075591,
0.0273176786,
0.0268968698,
0.0365631729,
-0.0128206834,
-0.0018295617,
0.0169578195,
0.0355531201,
0.0425434373,
-0.0331069939,
0.0193744246,
0.0247388054,
0.033674363,
0.0137109449,
0.0524983332,
-0.0147060137,
-0.0398462079,
-0.0012797923,
0.051093366,
0.0313859023,
0.0078951856,
0.0562156104,
0.0257661641,
-0.036974512,
-0.0228146762,
-0.0526234545,
0.0018645797,
-0.0098280022,
-0.0618324205,
0.0461274683,
0.0120119201,
-0.0205956101,
-0.0051502516,
0.0110511882,
-0.0579627678,
0.0047367844,
-0.0150240436,
-0.0679231733,
0.0119797541,
-0.0425727032,
0.010502113,
0.0104818996,
-0.0345705077,
0.0381544307,
-0.0010639105,
0.0729515031,
0.0219439119,
-0.0008597219,
0.0191393942,
-0.0471873283,
0.000632833,
-0.046903085,
-0.0006970618,
0.0016496867,
-0.0090014646,
-0.0167982988,
0.0029452706,
-0.0021857766,
0.0060582408,
0.0281470995,
-0.0716831684,
-0.0663850233,
0.0118995775,
0.018364476,
0.0046093822,
-0.0425961986,
-0.0125485864,
-0.0682185218,
0.0544891618,
0.0229390189,
-0.03636669,
-0.0625902116,
0.0212128647,
3.122e-7,
-0.0202805884,
0.0686590001,
-0.0191901661,
0.0075660897,
0.0075361319,
0.0324241333,
0.0095612407,
0.0005746798,
0.0283578448,
0.0072305887,
-0.0486299209,
0.0103336349,
0.0068912557,
0.0288316365,
-0.0702712834,
0.0292434823,
0.0082062315,
0.01262841,
-0.0983451754,
0.0332207493,
0.0703568831,
0.0505201593,
-0.0022206854,
-0.0005675143,
0.0180712361,
-0.0377204753,
-0.0163052194,
0.0012625633,
0.0034127603,
0.0560549609,
-0.0757310763,
0.0043865354,
0.0240561701,
0.0311567262,
0.0238172133,
0.010066268,
-0.0293643214,
0.0455078594,
-0.0221163128,
0.0390506126,
0.0668772608,
-0.0177329127,
-0.0119398339,
-0.0347912982,
0.0250671897,
-0.0335935354,
-0.018963661,
0.0001531351,
-0.0103671988,
-0.0273593757,
-0.0429623388,
-0.0392832458,
0.0177630354,
0.0398802534,
-0.0117044728,
-0.0228384249,
-0.0134079279,
-0.0413016416,
-0.0026618545,
-0.0325904898,
-0.0352573544,
-0.0500564799,
-0.026348291,
0.0117136035,
0.0139345108,
-0.0288635697,
0.0362665094,
3.264207993e-34,
-0.0060718972,
-0.0210103039,
0.0179357212,
0.0575240478,
0.0880160555,
0.0048523396,
-0.0082771359,
0.0439811163,
-0.0021727749,
-0.0321892351,
-0.0437384769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12999v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12999v4 | Machine Mindset: An MBTI Exploration of Large Language Models | 2023-12-20T12:59:31 | 2024-06-02T03:57:06 | Jiaxi Cui, Liuzhenghao Lv, Jing Wen, Rongsheng Wang, Jing Tang, YongHong Tian, Li Yuan | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a novel approach for integrating Myers-Briggs Type Indicator
(MBTI) personality traits into large language models (LLMs), addressing the
challenges of personality consistency in personalized AI. Our method, "Machine
Mindset," involves a two-phase fine-tuning and Direct Preference Optimization
(DPO) to embed MBTI traits into LLMs. This approach ensures that models
internalize these traits, offering a stable and consistent personality profile.
We demonstrate the effectiveness of our models across various domains, showing
alignment between model performance and their respective MBTI traits. The paper
highlights significant contributions in the development of personality datasets
and a new training methodology for personality integration in LLMs, enhancing
the potential for personalized AI applications. We also open-sourced our model
and part of the data at \url{https://github.com/PKU-YuanGroup/Machine-Mindset}. | [
0.0360333398,
0.0539534502,
-0.0617996417,
0.0131113054,
-0.0169384088,
0.0000418588,
0.0112967435,
-0.0488510504,
0.0245748647,
0.0069648563,
-0.063063316,
0.0166736562,
-0.013528822,
0.0397621281,
0.0071489764,
-0.0414947309,
0.0572428256,
0.0040229163,
0.0036553068,
-0.0159273837,
0.0061461786,
0.0604420044,
0.0274018534,
0.0251848567,
0.0056519131,
-0.0246322714,
0.0175587162,
-0.0203180574,
0.0284950696,
0.009356698,
0.0330766961,
0.0511846691,
0.012371867,
0.0057207528,
0.000001974,
-0.0383270197,
-0.0136894695,
-0.0348636024,
0.0141431177,
-0.0093193073,
0.0728902519,
0.0510566607,
-0.0061563328,
0.0429952703,
-0.056170065,
0.0141214021,
0.0174660329,
0.0341499001,
0.0548526309,
0.0435963236,
-0.0097288862,
-0.0217720009,
0.0163867995,
-0.0010793227,
0.0172493812,
-0.0109869204,
0.0235706307,
-0.0592126288,
-0.0307366997,
0.0220232774,
0.0279530976,
0.0003738421,
-0.0032164948,
0.0287708528,
0.0117542455,
-0.0110401334,
-0.0309164431,
0.0078333439,
-0.00148445,
0.0423991047,
0.0259710029,
-0.01367936,
-0.0225678124,
-0.0158076435,
0.033473406,
-0.0114376033,
0.0079929465,
0.0164291691,
-0.0178942848,
-0.0092308531,
0.0467230417,
-0.0037041062,
-0.0186410882,
0.022512611,
-0.0460756421,
0.0556736365,
-0.0095510455,
-0.0323781893,
0.0068497676,
-0.0190437213,
0.0065892581,
-0.0418323949,
0.0057626488,
0.0021542099,
-0.0221119989,
0.0192757286,
-0.0553061143,
0.035676945,
0.0086464202,
-0.0297094248,
0.0343535878,
0.0168347545,
-0.0202829987,
-0.013587648,
0.0520279221,
0.0198823158,
0.0457493067,
0.0240454935,
-0.0249416269,
-0.0200073142,
-0.078004472,
0.0037132236,
-0.0037470683,
0.0174984932,
0.0631529093,
0.0228404067,
-0.0692903697,
0.0438642502,
-0.0329006352,
0.0063188667,
0.0153602874,
-0.0110662933,
-0.0242835488,
0.0053599603,
-0.0683001578,
0.0399377942,
-0.0489646867,
-0.0074514095,
-0.0058002896,
-0.0250979401,
0.0451731868,
-0.0109149413,
-0.0005588806,
-0.0500662252,
0.0572426021,
0.0312126093,
0.0246893261,
-0.0499140844,
-0.0340911821,
-0.0114111947,
-0.0072899694,
-0.0598638281,
0.0010331542,
-0.0240549408,
0.0425996967,
-0.0061520948,
-0.004870146,
-0.0669775233,
-0.0263024271,
0.0327806026,
-0.0175588224,
0.0548985414,
-0.0150422528,
0.0097325649,
0.0190459304,
-0.0028476431,
-0.0054033357,
0.0241799038,
0.0079173734,
0.0024170249,
0.0300674569,
-0.0500096977,
0.0209146217,
0.0531988218,
-0.0408280157,
0.0007800849,
-0.0240998473,
0.0035485243,
-0.0022988622,
0.0119661717,
0.0550218858,
0.0216875877,
-0.0010179102,
0.0013048809,
0.0896728188,
0.0449442863,
0.022195911,
0.0633137748,
0.0070008417,
0.0538662188,
0.0423561297,
-0.0158233065,
-0.0394861139,
0.0165788624,
-0.0364201218,
0.0063604792,
-0.0192122087,
0.0609784797,
-0.0161725562,
-0.0476370491,
-0.0025840488,
-0.0283223689,
0.0298021398,
0.0314590298,
0.0079357494,
-0.0334736407,
0.007359209,
0.0062472634,
0.0357932858,
-0.0417737477,
-0.0356942415,
-0.0578480363,
0.002395591,
0.1111814231,
0.0232970957,
-0.0392541103,
-0.0203899816,
-0.0078517022,
-0.0655820146,
0.027380785,
0.0668177009,
-0.0283283386,
-0.0281142984,
-0.0571824647,
0.0064302469,
0.0203480925,
-0.0096072396,
0.0305738281,
-0.0058448883,
0.0324760415,
-0.0158931594,
0.0283019114,
-0.0054995683,
-0.0024816277,
-0.0657539442,
-0.0397900715,
0.0195854902,
0.0208932832,
0.0461300649,
0.0224308018,
0.0172027312,
-0.0118382694,
-0.00974885,
0.0036332889,
0.0011426765,
0.0186677761,
0.0080737695,
0.0483851172,
0.0302301869,
0.0203695353,
-0.0398837961,
0.0439273678,
0.0146391001,
0.0029226306,
-0.0171272345,
-0.0130356671,
0.0157956071,
-0.0109981997,
0.0245030951,
-0.0532629192,
0.0484415106,
-0.0283327568,
0.0515663736,
-0.0276804902,
-0.0218882952,
0.0203697905,
-0.0584774911,
-0.0109964386,
-0.0572104156,
-0.012587552,
-0.0232809633,
0.0197976045,
0.0492339656,
0.0124880234,
0.0115938354,
-0.0367134847,
-0.055387985,
-0.0776735842,
0.0118697481,
0.0335077196,
0.0084729493,
0.0045001963,
0.0128725152,
-0.0418931358,
0.0230560414,
-0.049716901,
-0.0047694496,
0.0047736755,
0.0180921257,
0.0297429338,
-0.0204325914,
0.0020326993,
-0.0394071899,
-0.0142998509,
-0.0530031584,
-0.0062799938,
-0.0488770902,
0.060517814,
-0.0440174602,
0.0079586999,
-0.0738990679,
0.0146683501,
-0.0103930514,
-0.0437327363,
0.0210531075,
-0.0262971185,
0.0256234724,
0.1088757068,
0.0254491307,
0.0068474123,
0.0416343547,
0.0170321837,
-0.040017236,
0.0106405392,
0.0178181455,
-0.0058452627,
-0.0271767713,
-0.0715245456,
-0.0094477367,
0.0358676575,
-0.0051556109,
-0.0051835361,
-0.0470237546,
0.0843022242,
0.0437497981,
-0.0242427792,
0.0606561154,
0.0675929189,
-0.0024964365,
0.0559979379,
0.0267877225,
-0.015498301,
0.0933388472,
0.007681896,
0.0340519845,
-0.0387562923,
-0.0549307913,
-0.0332985967,
0.0163839571,
-0.0155246099,
-0.007645647,
0.0567614324,
0.0212304369,
-0.0683587044,
-0.0405672677,
0.0135111166,
-0.0422576778,
0.0175244957,
0.0085276635,
-0.0538679808,
0.0487130396,
-0.0324359089,
-0.0413562693,
-0.035099566,
-0.0679174513,
-0.0157765001,
0.0473079458,
-0.039020516,
-0.042666357,
-0.0573176816,
0.0402506441,
-0.0335150659,
-0.0322822556,
-0.0181445293,
0.0033237578,
-0.0267208815,
0.0878873467,
0.024643885,
0.0349891074,
-0.0256834477,
-0.0291909538,
-0.0208630543,
-0.0238187201,
-0.0001632957,
0.002662716,
-0.0010270602,
0.0353529491,
-0.0264616758,
-0.0053270371,
0.0307723172,
0.019621795,
-0.0024190457,
-0.0075482605,
0.1263193339,
0.044947505,
-0.0270543657,
0.0206468105,
-0.0033795186,
0.0492432751,
0.0338833109,
0.0877656266,
-0.0296176989,
-0.0305962954,
-0.0287810694,
0.0382604487,
-0.0436491147,
-0.0214370396,
-0.0290262755,
-0.0869239792,
0.012142201,
0.0298953485,
-0.0416285917,
-0.0200461224,
-0.0295205526,
-0.0103554754,
-0.0487818755,
0.0100159142,
-0.0318705291,
-0.0086164353,
-0.0089943931,
-0.0321907289,
-0.0371029265,
-0.0546611063,
0.0910603181,
-0.0233567785,
0.0442140773,
0.0258111991,
0.0289647207,
-0.0087349657,
-0.0403132215,
-0.0498033836,
0.0041012694,
0.0005240823,
-0.0014643959,
0.0553437136,
-0.0654207692,
0.0222651828,
-0.0802759379,
0.0058657127,
-0.0069116917,
0.0222100001,
0.0314019881,
0.0415971763,
0.0082651479,
-0.0261576734,
-0.0391412601,
-0.0175392516,
0.0107812854,
0.0523899533,
-0.0282175411,
-0.1185471043,
0.0080654109,
-0.0492344983,
-0.025050886,
0.0110769477,
-0.0703773126,
0.0151906749,
0.0014603424,
0.0045037642,
-0.0237431359,
-0.0845630839,
0.0004954361,
0.0023894103,
0.0027035612,
-0.0367554016,
0.0099561634,
0.0218297802,
-0.0638565645,
0.0420974046,
-0.0409797542,
0.0267822314,
-0.0515057407,
-0.0242309254,
0.0675637946,
-0.0683683008,
0.0039363392,
0.0279751476,
-0.0309336297,
-0.044548519,
-0.0037800421,
0.0451954938,
0.019980358,
0.0528636873,
0.0201263893,
-0.08972729,
0.0208300408,
-0.0042715333,
-0.020064434,
0.0157160871,
0.0225073881,
0.0432266109,
-0.0128643438,
0.032804776,
-0.0330393426,
0.0174221154,
0.0058287154,
-0.0386801772,
-0.0212325323,
-0.066602841,
0.0049054795,
0.0166073758,
-0.0316993855,
0.0049536782,
-0.0189779513,
-0.0175436009,
-0.016432263,
-0.0353778489,
-0.0358797722,
-0.0045773094,
-0.0722006261,
0.029570736,
0.0011066939,
-0.0262722634,
-0.0365072042,
-0.0332360491,
-0.0056902678,
-0.028173741,
0.0151312696,
-0.0035049585,
0.0557657704,
-0.010734695,
-0.0100103542,
-0.0140565261,
-0.0126162646,
0.0276368577,
0.0671187267,
-0.0045938678,
0.0781944767,
-0.0307750646,
0.0051730252,
-0.0161845759,
0.0671416745,
-0.0321662612,
-0.0273726005,
0.0178873781,
0.0024684526,
0.0010677236,
-0.0154730333,
0.0359970108,
-0.0257408787,
0.0049164849,
-0.0320530385,
0.0434617549,
0.0072498084,
0.0062769116,
-0.002040915,
0.0166528467,
-0.023453176,
-0.0281800255,
0.042676881,
0.0325598083,
-0.0104660029,
-0.0314166248,
-0.0295138117,
-0.0655953437,
0.0416518673,
0.0225874651,
0.0686473325,
-0.0216957889,
-0.017085854,
-0.0869404376,
-0.0844603777,
0.0826720893,
0.0090249507,
0.0024152917,
-0.030091729,
0.012136043,
0.0425175317,
-0.0385164209,
-0.0416885242,
-0.0288981739,
-0.007657289,
-0.0492472611,
-0.0200632103,
-0.0229440257,
-5.648724962e-33,
-0.0299132559,
0.0126467803,
0.0243963432,
0.0019803357,
0.0045675901,
-0.0420810729,
0.0112607963,
0.0273488667,
-0.0305873491,
-0.040409945,
-0.0473933145,
-0.0050050206,
-0.0022249448,
-0.0272217728,
0.0339088775,
0.0250233337,
0.0398599729,
-0.0083931154,
-0.0163231865,
0.0045012552,
-0.001100803,
-0.0003649817,
0.061000295,
-0.0749954879,
-0.0041980525,
-0.0210506357,
-0.0002481345,
-0.0014120444,
-0.017369926,
0.0823512971,
0.0095286928,
0.056235861,
0.0220082365,
0.0007720605,
-0.003731963,
0.0252566338,
-0.0385091677,
-0.0455924943,
-0.0140041122,
0.0239715688,
0.0360749997,
-0.0876276642,
0.0149587672,
-0.0235252958,
-0.0450283252,
-0.0340014361,
0.0649248064,
-0.0164429117,
0.0350840874,
0.0412858613,
-0.0271006916,
0.0009255175,
-0.026464181,
-0.0165257994,
0.0035898108,
-0.0042532631,
-0.0016680304,
0.0069384151,
-0.0409095809,
0.0706616491,
-0.0137782907,
-0.0186576266,
0.03231363,
0.0048718322,
-0.0052342815,
0.0262846928,
0.0921653658,
0.0606355071,
0.0466334559,
-0.0067228819,
0.0720073655,
0.0443791933,
0.0152157862,
0.0583671406,
-0.0273566041,
-0.0372319818,
0.0013328468,
0.031054277,
0.0962387547,
-0.0501173511,
0.0323060639,
0.010204467,
-0.0621984266,
-0.0316293649,
-0.0034015605,
-0.0295067709,
-0.0258596931,
-0.0100079989,
0.0066178394,
-0.0319753923,
-0.0138358073,
-0.0296151098,
0.0367205068,
-0.0437457301,
-0.0106564062,
0.0396869928,
-0.0710293129,
0.0287136249,
-0.0041638371,
-0.0026942561,
-0.0509537756,
-0.0152908592,
-0.0067874542,
-0.0121378722,
0.0417677127,
0.0519515388,
0.0244468153,
0.0234567132,
-0.0523967408,
-0.024235541,
0.0274764262,
-0.0000330092,
-0.0082675824,
0.0250387713,
0.0196067579,
0.0290119257,
0.0094690043,
0.0221595,
0.0098704277,
0.0007983355,
-0.060400065,
-0.0069758054,
0.0285434555,
-0.0054392759,
0.0188880973,
0.0102917524,
-0.0613573343,
-0.0103441551,
0.0284779407,
-0.033281289,
-0.0053641591,
-0.0035453462,
2.583e-7,
-0.0395975485,
0.0875945985,
-0.0512567312,
0.0560451187,
0.0203877091,
0.073544167,
0.0148582561,
0.0083681578,
0.0529788733,
-0.0063752439,
0.0153684784,
0.0537623093,
0.0379423015,
0.017172059,
-0.0588899702,
-0.0020356069,
0.0295569599,
0.0524549596,
-0.0611426197,
0.0412399061,
0.0528623499,
0.0711430758,
0.04467237,
-0.0028253391,
0.0028136056,
0.0247301422,
0.020505555,
-0.0013003172,
-0.0161014739,
0.0472568348,
-0.0267750956,
0.0116550308,
-0.0097954562,
0.042174235,
-0.0072477427,
0.0140079902,
-0.0122662568,
0.0779758096,
-0.0396662429,
-0.0299179032,
0.0216326118,
0.0289504007,
-0.0528257042,
-0.0188345965,
0.0422403552,
-0.024286544,
-0.0665528178,
-0.0619636141,
-0.0164961591,
-0.0358476192,
0.0147088431,
0.010336468,
-0.014168907,
0.0311928857,
0.0045414502,
-0.035578303,
-0.0185111817,
-0.039071355,
0.0439134203,
0.0208821278,
-0.0416231789,
-0.0676524714,
-0.0178810116,
0.0190117992,
0.0407761037,
-0.0497312546,
0.0437826589,
2.203468982e-34,
0.0015739395,
0.032722488,
0.0352848843,
-0.0324233994,
0.0769333392,
0.0194233153,
-0.0080452953,
0.0251240395,
0.0538300574,
-0.0743255913,
-0.0165029299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12989v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12989v1 | Benchmarking and Analyzing In-context Learning, Fine-tuning and Supervised Learning for Biomedical Knowledge Curation: a focused study on chemical entities of biological interest | 2023-12-20T12:46:44 | 2023-12-20T12:46:44 | Emily Groves, Minhong Wang, Yusuf Abdulle, Holger Kunz, Jason Hoelscher-Obermaier, Ronin Wu, Honghan Wu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, q-bio.QM | Automated knowledge curation for biomedical ontologies is key to ensure that
they remain comprehensive, high-quality and up-to-date. In the era of
foundational language models, this study compares and analyzes three NLP
paradigms for curation tasks: in-context learning (ICL), fine-tuning (FT), and
supervised learning (ML). Using the Chemical Entities of Biological Interest
(ChEBI) database as a model ontology, three curation tasks were devised. For
ICL, three prompting strategies were employed with GPT-4, GPT-3.5, BioGPT.
PubmedBERT was chosen for the FT paradigm. For ML, six embedding models were
utilized for training Random Forest and Long-Short Term Memory models. Five
setups were designed to assess ML and FT model performance across different
data availability scenarios.Datasets for curation tasks included: task 1
(620,386), task 2 (611,430), and task 3 (617,381), maintaining a 50:50 positive
versus negative ratio. For ICL models, GPT-4 achieved best accuracy scores of
0.916, 0.766 and 0.874 for tasks 1-3 respectively. In a direct comparison, ML
(trained on ~260,000 triples) outperformed ICL in accuracy across all tasks.
(accuracy differences: +.11, +.22 and +.17). Fine-tuned PubmedBERT performed
similarly to leading ML models in tasks 1 & 2 (F1 differences: -.014 and
+.002), but worse in task 3 (-.048). Simulations revealed performance declines
in both ML and FT models with smaller and higher imbalanced training data.
where ICL (particularly GPT-4) excelled in tasks 1 & 3. GPT-4 excelled in tasks
1 and 3 with less than 6,000 triples, surpassing ML/FT. ICL underperformed
ML/FT in task 2.ICL-augmented foundation models can be good assistants for
knowledge curation with correct prompting, however, not making ML and FT
paradigms obsolete. The latter two require task-specific data to beat ICL. In
such cases, ML relies on small pretrained embeddings, minimizing computational
demands. | [
0.0538647063,
0.0078173494,
0.0115613947,
-0.0435444042,
-0.0279959682,
0.0144533766,
0.0013854546,
0.0086643407,
0.0528241135,
-0.0465666018,
0.0135204569,
-0.0019419388,
-0.0236185938,
0.02277169,
-0.0006801407,
0.0024594497,
0.0415425189,
0.0275795255,
0.030589262,
-0.0043302365,
-0.0013551376,
0.017335752,
0.0277713872,
0.0165820252,
0.0314160362,
-0.0221813284,
0.0083936602,
-0.0263980962,
0.0208054632,
-0.0438567586,
0.0075310324,
0.039427489,
0.0022028829,
0.0287562814,
0.000002117,
-0.0661893338,
-0.064974688,
0.05038701,
-0.0336791873,
-0.0496923216,
0.046862863,
-0.031059403,
0.0017378585,
-0.0005116144,
-0.0189614985,
0.0259374082,
0.0477793068,
0.0700912997,
0.0049812258,
0.0248741116,
0.001011984,
-0.006746965,
0.0672511458,
0.0186057705,
0.0423848517,
-0.0005901813,
0.0590493567,
-0.0037409209,
0.0269371569,
0.0261032544,
0.0199216995,
0.0399700589,
-0.0254295804,
0.0285971612,
0.034129899,
0.0397951528,
-0.04056127,
-0.030765811,
-0.0165557675,
0.0634876788,
-0.0023462069,
-0.029865006,
-0.0122061074,
0.001551002,
-0.0191661827,
0.0305323992,
-0.0353735462,
-0.0090062004,
-0.0578030869,
0.0186245218,
-0.0064676949,
-0.0353731439,
0.0290990788,
0.0141308773,
-0.0078106839,
0.0324512571,
-0.0129532162,
-0.0529488325,
0.0341881923,
-0.002020265,
-0.0294422302,
-0.0153931435,
0.0101091471,
0.0257533081,
-0.020005079,
0.0108117936,
0.0035201099,
-0.0058770026,
0.0848274007,
-0.0251641441,
-0.0018117902,
-0.0168850329,
-0.0282923151,
0.0368646868,
0.0182128884,
-0.0189636517,
-0.0015087209,
0.0468223728,
-0.0068223919,
-0.000933597,
-0.129453972,
-0.0275580436,
-0.0141164195,
0.0642446727,
-0.0014501268,
-0.0066747926,
-0.0723283589,
-0.0213224404,
-0.027630426,
0.0018380753,
0.0352262929,
0.0263978038,
-0.0162941758,
0.0629387423,
-0.0362912118,
0.018570777,
0.0116754835,
-0.0066487896,
-0.0220003352,
-0.0398950651,
0.0109571302,
-0.0379612856,
0.0297849383,
-0.038124837,
0.0236128196,
0.0621146634,
0.0366850123,
-0.053646747,
-0.0143117374,
-0.0828939825,
-0.0179707091,
-0.0771280229,
-0.0028544301,
-0.0325980261,
0.0582855679,
0.002679171,
-0.0113001112,
-0.0626185015,
-0.0082236575,
0.0069817523,
-0.0735845491,
0.0978174731,
-0.0619914308,
-0.058731284,
0.0279088486,
0.0048149512,
-0.0260935538,
0.0433367044,
0.0007891664,
-0.0229037832,
0.020520689,
-0.0072977794,
-0.0113868276,
-0.0431773812,
0.0364471264,
-0.0599940717,
0.0206295792,
0.0057307873,
-0.0059005693,
0.082559146,
-0.0311057158,
0.0304231849,
0.0091284206,
0.0160430074,
0.0376015343,
0.0389670022,
0.0729040802,
0.0015309113,
0.004771776,
0.0076966868,
0.0182537846,
-0.0171192735,
-0.0515503287,
0.0278851837,
-0.0319032148,
0.0331236459,
0.0065657953,
0.0401055999,
0.0150731485,
-0.0113554178,
-0.0297015458,
0.0039427346,
-0.0249622837,
-0.0068199742,
0.0513485111,
-0.0336164683,
-0.0373121798,
0.0420671292,
0.0587370433,
0.0099898614,
-0.0036916963,
0.0068151737,
0.0054905484,
0.0581078902,
0.0279447287,
-0.0645873994,
-0.0526965111,
-0.0425849408,
-0.0350447036,
-0.0161262117,
-0.0011373776,
-0.0320994258,
-0.006945332,
-0.011281725,
-0.0290749762,
-0.0065288553,
0.0118532171,
-0.0347212516,
0.0012986667,
0.0374252833,
-0.0086926976,
-0.0451421477,
-0.0146451909,
0.029288318,
-0.0402002633,
-0.0236601457,
-0.0517475493,
-0.0040298821,
0.0434118137,
0.0462999195,
0.0015677318,
0.0213114545,
0.0644772574,
-0.0178986266,
-0.0219760556,
-0.035061188,
0.0148257744,
-0.0441949926,
0.0558476783,
0.0169135686,
-0.003270512,
-0.0300810691,
-0.0500435419,
-0.0260304734,
-0.0394705944,
0.0188331306,
0.0056331572,
-0.0321393944,
-0.0045993091,
0.0000328555,
-0.0087162266,
-0.052866105,
0.0499499552,
-0.0080612656,
0.0239706319,
0.0226368047,
-0.0686977208,
0.0104537914,
-0.0411484465,
0.0196009278,
0.0033289858,
0.0245802384,
0.0061641359,
0.012103335,
-0.0084940717,
-0.0671907738,
0.0273112226,
-0.0746033192,
0.001287789,
0.021433061,
0.0121807856,
-0.0138235837,
0.0005691439,
0.0281310957,
-0.0115278298,
-0.0044882172,
-0.0374052189,
-0.0383239575,
0.026507834,
0.0281010922,
0.0300208051,
0.0011844785,
-0.034665443,
-0.0007033677,
-0.0416217484,
0.0392675512,
0.0065660914,
-0.0378630757,
0.000455794,
-0.0234006811,
-0.0363162458,
0.0121326745,
0.0153879952,
0.0369769931,
0.0112596769,
0.0082047479,
-0.0038702826,
0.0315894373,
-0.0167122744,
0.042500414,
0.0520804785,
0.0337036327,
-0.0355012678,
0.0088670207,
-0.0340735279,
0.0071429778,
0.0396392941,
0.0134786265,
0.0173391178,
0.0382508971,
-0.0072492645,
-0.0101246983,
-0.0449449196,
0.0516252033,
-0.0106714461,
-0.0092033949,
-0.0481115393,
0.0353659391,
-0.0251995232,
0.0230833888,
-0.007119542,
-0.0547516793,
0.1113632619,
0.0078926161,
0.0517640524,
-0.0623305216,
0.0065983655,
0.0108917318,
-0.0126405982,
-0.002865558,
0.0266299192,
0.0492344797,
0.0008286109,
-0.020466432,
0.0247891713,
0.0173494928,
-0.0481077172,
0.0141612543,
-0.0323723666,
0.0403500982,
0.0184820928,
-0.0031694046,
0.0026412732,
0.0266565476,
-0.0311493184,
0.0478148498,
0.0296551473,
-0.0111868363,
-0.002280388,
0.0443370901,
-0.0032776063,
0.0049972264,
0.0158307534,
-0.0355677381,
0.0073712701,
-0.0104154693,
0.0451828279,
-0.0267229974,
0.0441829823,
0.0329714715,
0.0531054549,
0.0421802104,
0.0294282213,
-0.033169765,
0.0054626637,
0.0306023378,
-0.006597775,
-0.0772727355,
-0.010700305,
0.0041983877,
-0.0009974549,
-0.0446941815,
-0.0176214147,
0.1025884524,
0.0509937964,
-0.0405164883,
0.01278436,
0.0008725197,
-0.0616724566,
-0.0227441527,
0.0072108731,
-0.0964486524,
-0.0300932303,
-0.0226487629,
0.0174160376,
-0.0305610448,
-0.0826439932,
0.0091203814,
-0.0603501387,
0.0563311018,
-0.0089055011,
-0.0760695264,
-0.0356832109,
-0.0714117959,
-0.0092261489,
-0.0381743982,
0.0270745028,
0.0062722377,
-0.0205540247,
-0.0049474128,
0.0139669888,
-0.0127616255,
-0.0968829617,
0.0290068723,
-0.0340854414,
0.0258677192,
0.0361343361,
0.0440701246,
0.0214967001,
0.0279791541,
0.0325756222,
-0.0204288419,
0.0144537427,
-0.0271580089,
0.0866411999,
-0.0102841044,
0.0236589015,
-0.0567323565,
0.029701367,
-0.0222888459,
-0.0241561756,
-0.0389312319,
0.1367838383,
-0.0265642405,
-0.0089222984,
-0.0456054583,
-0.0101952692,
0.0188285988,
0.0790818781,
-0.009849227,
-0.0110594518,
-0.0400574654,
0.0164963417,
0.0345641933,
0.0058715949,
0.0165002067,
0.0486500487,
-0.079246752,
0.003149482,
-0.058931984,
-0.0550290011,
0.0896491185,
-0.015544788,
0.0085065728,
0.0791208297,
0.0347179845,
-0.0089526689,
-0.0579270981,
0.0448396578,
0.0312089678,
0.0112153813,
-0.0357182026,
-0.0571390837,
0.0747667104,
0.0000916988,
-0.018460745,
0.0138510643,
0.007748473,
-0.0676379651,
-0.0171310436,
0.0340749584,
0.0243417192,
0.0362870656,
0.0074420241,
-0.0362575948,
0.0475879572,
0.0539086722,
-0.0462555103,
-0.0526662134,
-0.0206212588,
0.0102261249,
-0.0320145972,
0.0094574941,
-0.0390946455,
0.012279788,
-0.0149989724,
0.0300983768,
0.0033763046,
-0.0347234234,
0.0786683261,
0.0288607068,
0.0568204075,
-0.0209504813,
-0.0346862227,
-0.0305294003,
0.00755713,
0.0137598822,
-0.0007691712,
-0.0213559512,
-0.0064919656,
0.0254590437,
-0.0052289716,
-0.0155065563,
0.0161421187,
-0.0232446659,
0.0036666198,
-0.0542749539,
0.0185088776,
-0.0059706671,
0.0105207944,
0.079865627,
-0.0184844881,
-0.0223092604,
-0.0112827355,
-0.0258011092,
0.0030578619,
-0.044165045,
0.032308802,
0.0144936992,
0.0557306968,
-0.0611214563,
0.0407785252,
-0.0468944237,
-0.012777729,
-0.0324492976,
0.0408807993,
0.0508997403,
-0.0284748524,
0.0352465324,
-0.0321268775,
-0.0361951217,
-0.0251986422,
0.0211647451,
-0.0036102587,
0.0161469765,
0.0567203835,
0.034593977,
-0.0341684036,
-0.0351448506,
0.0851176456,
0.026872782,
0.0618392974,
-0.0075176666,
-0.0704912841,
-0.0217989981,
0.0071365964,
-0.0022315159,
0.0123602021,
-0.0429589748,
-0.009401178,
-0.0553200878,
-0.040393617,
0.0847857967,
-0.0119620012,
-0.0462407768,
0.0078006713,
0.0426353328,
0.0406291597,
0.0305685885,
-0.0422715396,
-0.0052885083,
0.0063305269,
-0.0219497606,
-0.0451508686,
0.0094465325,
-6.29550032e-33,
0.0154889999,
-0.0397221185,
0.013546031,
0.0088158492,
0.0075017391,
-0.02070182,
-0.03044324,
-0.0354969837,
-0.0036831058,
0.0527910441,
-0.0214994885,
-0.0227087643,
0.00071324,
-0.0062884744,
0.0200667586,
-0.018781919,
0.0258013867,
0.0029540255,
0.0213200878,
0.0198435429,
0.0636848435,
0.0938255042,
0.0419487394,
-0.0504090562,
0.0124071082,
0.0479809083,
0.0404680222,
-0.0184798911,
-0.0356850997,
0.0606317334,
-0.0363245793,
0.0675058886,
0.0182662532,
-0.049346365,
-0.013633566,
-0.0266135018,
-0.1033294573,
-0.0230863839,
0.0093040727,
-0.0315120146,
0.0004582038,
-0.030647805,
0.030308133,
0.0000584982,
-0.0158309825,
-0.0179701317,
0.0434924401,
-0.0245372411,
-0.0839756578,
-0.0968869627,
-0.0673594624,
0.0091928411,
0.026849499,
0.0154875768,
0.0333396345,
-0.0177117996,
0.0157471392,
0.0557979941,
-0.0459034331,
-0.0101686716,
0.0003087272,
-0.0000781845,
0.0187740531,
-0.0008308318,
0.0042983037,
0.0488477573,
-0.0371613614,
0.010861529,
0.0289107244,
0.0098666903,
-0.0224199817,
0.0577499643,
-0.005673327,
0.019617537,
0.0368785411,
-0.0036482522,
-0.0794925764,
0.0301793106,
-0.0488195829,
0.030402476,
-0.0026991158,
0.0090393294,
0.0015498906,
-0.0303580798,
-0.0223755036,
0.0585242286,
-0.0297430232,
-0.0241271239,
0.0104425019,
-0.0156850927,
-0.0175325554,
0.0200993288,
-0.011565051,
-0.033705961,
-0.0586004034,
0.006699645,
0.0286746733,
0.0092069013,
-0.0177383777,
0.0197595842,
-0.0711051151,
-0.0116702057,
0.0100024259,
-0.0372477584,
0.0295123942,
0.0074702762,
0.0549994819,
0.0016484775,
-0.0143534625,
0.0186407696,
-0.0306321923,
0.0278054755,
-0.006134761,
0.0312632583,
0.0154547049,
0.0364931673,
0.0232938472,
0.0226779003,
0.0815300494,
-0.0026658149,
-0.0064369771,
0.0290337037,
0.0274515115,
-0.0118971067,
-0.0197829194,
-0.0073907245,
-0.0194858089,
0.0094643002,
-0.0141367791,
-0.0355612263,
-0.0078512821,
0.0052101756,
2.959e-7,
0.1024837196,
0.037915986,
0.029396167,
-0.0400736034,
-0.0100884866,
-0.0110343313,
-0.0044986377,
-0.0037391833,
-0.0138822952,
-0.0330726616,
0.0409613065,
-0.0225650463,
0.0023926513,
0.0144277699,
-0.088810645,
-0.040903639,
-0.0275544561,
-0.0373263769,
-0.0564294308,
0.017746795,
0.0200036522,
0.0381647795,
-0.0156233469,
-0.0166001376,
0.0131400218,
0.0043577286,
0.0365735143,
-0.0527666211,
0.0253783446,
0.0430645458,
0.0120213237,
0.0083608627,
-0.001107558,
0.0512024499,
-0.0233034156,
-0.0259099286,
-0.0114362091,
0.0274589658,
-0.0514974967,
-0.0138507159,
0.0426081121,
-0.0192969125,
0.0428762659,
-0.0418233834,
0.0406407937,
-0.0865843147,
-0.0497570261,
0.0139153115,
-0.0173284039,
-0.0159428995,
0.0220561605,
-0.005759446,
0.0162898581,
0.031994544,
-0.0172830559,
0.0364757702,
-0.014700342,
-0.0875179619,
-0.0064881011,
0.0850989893,
-0.014896052,
-0.0521184057,
0.0076573021,
-0.0409047417,
0.0354458243,
-0.1043651998,
-0.0102755558,
2.852778771e-34,
0.0269662682,
0.003422505,
0.0464117676,
0.037143968,
0.0218109526,
-0.0091831135,
0.0167774409,
0.0057321424,
-0.0059252456,
-0.0709970891,
0.0015387636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12918v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12918v2 | Assaying on the Robustness of Zero-Shot Machine-Generated Text Detectors | 2023-12-20T10:53:53 | 2023-12-21T02:09:52 | Yi-Fan Zhang, Zhang Zhang, Liang Wang, Tieniu Tan, Rong Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL | To combat the potential misuse of Natural Language Generation (NLG)
technology, a variety of algorithms have been developed for the detection of
AI-generated texts. Traditionally, this task is treated as a binary
classification problem. Although supervised learning has demonstrated promising
results, acquiring labeled data for detection purposes poses real-world
challenges and the risk of overfitting. In an effort to address these issues,
we delve into the realm of zero-shot machine-generated text detection. Existing
zero-shot detectors, typically designed for specific tasks or topics, often
assume uniform testing scenarios, limiting their practicality. In our research,
we explore various advanced Large Language Models (LLMs) and their specialized
variants, contributing to this field in several ways. In empirical studies, we
uncover a significant correlation between topics and detection performance.
Secondly, we delve into the influence of topic shifts on zero-shot detectors.
These investigations shed light on the adaptability and robustness of these
detection methods across diverse topics. The code is available at
\url{https://github.com/yfzhang114/robustness-detection}. | [
-0.0086455084,
0.010350829,
-0.0011598702,
0.0599442162,
-0.042204719,
0.0138747469,
0.0308252759,
0.0462209657,
-0.0241881609,
-0.0749024972,
0.0278350208,
-0.0233376063,
-0.0157105327,
0.0495103076,
0.0098821558,
0.0357129909,
0.0207722392,
-0.0185735878,
-0.0000424016,
0.0415149741,
-0.0038437096,
0.0028257349,
-0.0225866772,
0.0331563391,
-0.004792951,
0.0000511372,
-0.0182408337,
0.0143379942,
0.026635915,
-0.0568194762,
-0.0103431391,
0.0635211393,
0.0004425108,
0.1029456705,
0.0000017336,
-0.0372317173,
-0.020545952,
-0.0184029229,
-0.0180612393,
-0.0017948955,
0.0621415079,
-0.065025419,
-0.0396845862,
0.0215706844,
-0.0009541248,
-0.0100699365,
0.0286014136,
0.0522277132,
0.0210966785,
0.1163108051,
-0.0222147871,
0.0221663136,
0.0522187501,
-0.004820107,
0.0413259715,
-0.0332625248,
0.0360386856,
-0.0346371159,
0.0098235598,
0.0342937633,
0.0037359463,
-0.004667616,
-0.004127814,
-0.0208359528,
-0.0114236735,
0.0451620519,
-0.0605013631,
-0.0243185069,
-0.015767619,
0.046948906,
-0.0601498783,
-0.0381796397,
0.0455903523,
-0.0227497555,
-0.0156510808,
-0.0225685947,
-0.0156119391,
0.0720681697,
-0.0149478,
0.0289766639,
0.0300983693,
-0.0052890182,
0.0116910702,
0.0337443687,
-0.0067138765,
0.0401536301,
0.0249307156,
-0.0395877175,
-0.0331432,
0.0170046017,
-0.0136669232,
-0.0630325228,
0.0094382716,
0.0374715067,
0.0090928674,
0.0072154379,
-0.0886890665,
-0.0708002895,
0.0331002884,
-0.0302246939,
0.042676039,
0.0071120248,
-0.03821766,
0.0354717188,
-0.0588898771,
0.0501427166,
-0.0222981051,
-0.0166423935,
-0.0070797713,
0.025244249,
-0.0133918179,
-0.0087418333,
-0.0161788948,
0.0219731126,
0.0077134874,
-0.0414501205,
-0.0349049531,
0.0347431824,
0.0359755531,
0.0093023572,
-0.0680769086,
-0.0440847389,
-0.047015328,
-0.0003785223,
0.051858712,
0.0379240848,
0.0017729902,
0.0239077341,
0.0187930502,
-0.0508283488,
-0.0321135335,
0.0768146962,
0.0239058938,
-0.0072182901,
0.0035646602,
0.039079532,
-0.00608496,
-0.083437033,
-0.0585161,
-0.034393318,
-0.0522353426,
-0.0308253169,
0.0229152218,
-0.0672055408,
-0.0436826386,
-0.0047696093,
0.0038620767,
0.0127748074,
0.0202892702,
0.0317453928,
-0.0096383998,
0.0358451977,
-0.0269073248,
-0.0126894275,
0.0184689555,
0.0128761483,
0.013279764,
0.109906435,
0.0114137223,
0.0738217086,
0.0676523894,
0.005917585,
0.0380618237,
0.0438489504,
-0.0131397136,
0.0426982045,
0.0040677683,
-0.046257209,
-0.0222748835,
-0.0039823866,
0.0216654744,
0.0123804985,
-0.0191994626,
-0.0088608572,
0.0724256486,
0.0755848438,
-0.0156084094,
-0.0127890659,
0.0505975783,
0.0435882322,
-0.0290555283,
0.0132829994,
0.0136020193,
-0.0310395993,
-0.0793342069,
-0.0100331325,
-0.0013132622,
0.012837694,
-0.0176805407,
-0.0030459256,
-0.0384612307,
-0.0371188372,
-0.027270373,
-0.0580789447,
0.0858212113,
0.0203465465,
-0.0382049419,
-0.0458755083,
0.0023817129,
-0.0384292081,
0.014092356,
-0.0659188479,
0.0670138374,
0.0130796935,
0.0543484949,
-0.0049177045,
0.0176293589,
-0.0334907845,
0.0343448594,
0.0740448385,
-0.0084274067,
0.0189010203,
-0.0111155435,
-0.0304507632,
0.0100849047,
-0.0074281222,
0.0497526936,
0.0098987892,
0.0109604374,
0.0363187604,
0.0330706872,
-0.0022323548,
-0.0084228283,
0.0502805635,
-0.0053459718,
-0.0310931001,
0.0224396307,
-0.0197693054,
0.014561723,
-0.0117084682,
-0.0561675951,
0.0051078149,
0.0389927663,
-0.0546319708,
-0.0353832729,
-0.0004362832,
0.0079215756,
-0.040086925,
-0.0087149749,
-0.040681541,
0.0034655102,
-0.002850092,
-0.0273312498,
-0.0181867518,
-0.0080483444,
-0.0256873947,
-0.0397540778,
-0.0362340994,
0.0394449048,
-0.0187289938,
0.0222112965,
-0.0305629019,
0.04818004,
0.0023624413,
-0.0116322478,
0.0094306702,
-0.008355842,
0.0496255979,
-0.0435926951,
-0.0307954196,
0.0377634503,
-0.0286681466,
-0.0064673861,
0.0184408054,
0.0230414029,
-0.011404817,
-0.0122722229,
-0.0885336697,
0.0331874005,
-0.0484164506,
0.0167646501,
0.0528736003,
-0.0296894964,
-0.0218930431,
0.0097887777,
-0.0027270154,
0.0090637607,
0.0616810098,
0.0083285505,
0.0412363596,
-0.037114583,
0.0145554058,
-0.0140319802,
0.0082316063,
-0.0265418291,
0.0664471388,
0.0331913307,
-0.0291244425,
-0.0655030832,
0.0676342398,
0.0182541814,
-0.0113906218,
0.0042226142,
-0.0195821058,
0.006820708,
-0.0245259237,
0.0179524925,
0.073278673,
0.0306686498,
0.0279641617,
0.0224266555,
0.0245189182,
0.0002469383,
-0.0332298428,
0.0011044409,
-0.0030011695,
-0.0082009397,
-0.0362229459,
0.033504352,
0.0834582746,
-0.0017069187,
0.0154348258,
-0.0254247598,
0.0053130835,
-0.0425871164,
-0.0166999884,
-0.0134004541,
0.010009909,
-0.0180444606,
0.0319751203,
-0.0221516918,
-0.054406561,
0.0305603165,
-0.0496175997,
0.0072246823,
-0.0388378836,
-0.0280783232,
-0.0446052551,
0.0185717233,
0.0410416387,
0.0212872904,
0.0254202206,
0.0171914995,
-0.0010076368,
0.0302748363,
-0.0098985732,
-0.0092133479,
0.0353020579,
-0.0281513464,
0.022851631,
-0.03630694,
-0.012107824,
-0.0561454706,
-0.0527853072,
-0.0008274516,
-0.0121909454,
0.0115736974,
-0.0190157425,
-0.0324132703,
0.0320493542,
0.0048706178,
0.0624131262,
-0.0169845577,
-0.0015619677,
-0.0322817788,
0.086616911,
0.0690278038,
-0.0703710839,
-0.0029925101,
-0.0202047527,
0.0238948334,
0.0503738783,
0.0127335424,
0.0575805902,
-0.028158268,
0.0112290652,
0.0087388214,
-0.0126740402,
-0.0191124957,
0.0206721779,
0.0241144709,
-0.041181162,
-0.0237150658,
0.079923436,
0.0266382433,
-0.0482331179,
0.0010863669,
-0.0116320662,
0.0290747024,
0.0102522997,
-0.001904614,
-0.1062694639,
-0.0331054293,
0.0036894651,
0.016665129,
-0.0438371599,
-0.0266902633,
-0.0207342114,
-0.1271201968,
0.0387202092,
0.0140619613,
-0.0354164653,
-0.0254982579,
-0.0318089053,
0.0048431656,
-0.0087620886,
-0.0073236041,
-0.002974998,
-0.015519754,
-0.0088357162,
0.0137382122,
-0.0033886982,
-0.0740074515,
-0.0376900621,
-0.0448589735,
0.0374886617,
0.0685328618,
0.0105553828,
-0.0230757892,
0.0228275154,
0.0031517923,
-0.0287196133,
-0.0259746537,
0.0061269444,
0.0326507352,
-0.0399144888,
-0.0029259534,
0.0229988061,
0.0271525867,
-0.0208485983,
-0.007411879,
0.040603999,
0.0344194956,
-0.0021996098,
-0.0688004568,
-0.0237456057,
0.0042550685,
0.0173636582,
0.0878991634,
0.0316126384,
-0.0452687703,
-0.0540478081,
-0.0182772204,
0.0131366709,
-0.0570891723,
-0.0289288592,
-0.0014573255,
-0.0228047669,
-0.0515873358,
-0.0836913809,
-0.0055128126,
0.0110744387,
0.0314485766,
-0.0150634022,
-0.0017142385,
-0.0196552388,
-0.0118416464,
-0.0276535898,
-0.0062089046,
-0.0285833646,
0.0055093514,
-0.0897502452,
0.0114510506,
0.031780228,
-0.0320527703,
0.0003743885,
0.0282234047,
-0.0943973213,
-0.057155896,
-0.0079191774,
-0.0149590718,
0.0228007063,
-0.0067704143,
-0.0256246403,
-0.060054034,
0.0798519999,
0.0626557171,
-0.0079838838,
0.0377325267,
0.0030760728,
-0.0018000305,
-0.0200570524,
0.0059452215,
-0.0300134625,
0.0514243767,
-0.0062295962,
-0.0145556033,
-0.0435603447,
0.0036303194,
0.0110947546,
0.0192217994,
0.034724053,
-0.0260998178,
-0.0082630524,
-0.0062684268,
-0.0143790785,
-0.0128382044,
-0.0088481,
-0.0304458942,
0.0073232194,
0.0271421373,
-0.0141549241,
-0.011604527,
0.0506044365,
-0.0491831563,
0.0803538784,
-0.0191754159,
0.0054615601,
-0.0146898143,
0.0517049618,
0.0151329413,
-0.0140460953,
-0.003845688,
0.0368537083,
0.0034287341,
0.0264834315,
-0.0151424641,
0.0689631999,
0.0155416802,
-0.0136300651,
0.0075344145,
0.0290549714,
-0.0417489223,
0.0230506454,
-0.0359720327,
0.05363122,
0.0785458907,
-0.0006960699,
0.0574240051,
-0.0492040366,
-0.0185747463,
-0.0440776944,
0.0306818858,
0.0016335808,
-0.0331481434,
-0.014983057,
0.012850807,
-0.030652063,
0.014238094,
0.0855489299,
0.0581491217,
0.0316752754,
0.0337993987,
0.0008210909,
-0.0316391997,
0.0231893361,
0.0409814008,
-0.0101231476,
-0.0100204786,
0.0294818394,
-0.0478779227,
-0.0413904749,
0.0427357294,
-0.047498446,
0.0462854691,
0.0030241804,
-0.023780223,
0.0603893325,
-0.0219710581,
0.0438093767,
-0.0551039763,
0.0086566778,
-0.014129037,
-0.0024861088,
-0.0404387489,
-5.758222628e-33,
-0.0281921197,
-0.0684752911,
-0.024082778,
-0.0198423136,
0.0308943372,
0.0292577837,
-0.0387796909,
0.0192471016,
0.0224375986,
-0.0160879679,
0.0067555835,
-0.0022285124,
0.0031508338,
0.0255343653,
-0.0431661531,
-0.0258920696,
0.0448206365,
-0.0341475829,
-0.0549343191,
0.0207851268,
0.0364808738,
-0.0064836298,
0.0004139685,
-0.035556294,
-0.0197603777,
-0.0273044445,
-0.0330485366,
-0.0163629092,
0.0025125521,
0.0720894635,
-0.0138986679,
0.0520433336,
0.0513072833,
0.0149461748,
0.0075245695,
0.06336952,
0.0028657541,
0.011243714,
-0.0512393601,
-0.0028904781,
0.0083259512,
-0.0640712231,
0.034794528,
-0.0228425227,
-0.0177926421,
0.0251924992,
0.0306983981,
-0.030412076,
-0.0139795402,
-0.0590483695,
-0.0752150416,
0.0412055813,
-0.003559951,
-0.0132931117,
0.0156294834,
0.0516818389,
0.0262083858,
0.0547345318,
-0.0318294875,
0.0288068056,
0.0224450305,
0.0197657906,
0.0486713387,
0.0114891184,
-0.0327952839,
0.0574712753,
0.0127881858,
0.0487161018,
-0.0185338818,
-0.0136905489,
0.0275984164,
-0.0013697903,
0.061081972,
0.0631109551,
0.0666810647,
0.0008142823,
-0.0707414225,
0.0199198872,
0.0200296324,
-0.0088969581,
0.0466408208,
-0.0020729294,
-0.0436184816,
0.0045453813,
-0.0097321142,
-0.060372971,
-0.0408313684,
-0.0093907369,
0.0454157665,
0.0479597673,
-0.0427027717,
0.0027542813,
0.0567896105,
-0.0289045162,
0.0212445334,
0.0427875444,
-0.064318575,
0.0176860802,
-0.0018808708,
0.0332752131,
-0.047940705,
-0.0427021123,
0.0556529425,
-0.0016340561,
0.015372904,
-0.0152908405,
0.0493008904,
0.0176115464,
-0.0544220135,
0.0031076132,
-0.0178141296,
0.0270335805,
0.013489699,
0.0435345098,
0.0181186218,
-0.0563524105,
0.0024370253,
0.0375085436,
0.0467527471,
-0.0023762034,
-0.0156007539,
-0.0255142692,
-0.0427835397,
0.0132841123,
-0.0348854624,
0.0282539297,
0.001526398,
0.0419955701,
0.0440088101,
-0.0712401047,
0.0110800518,
-0.0305220149,
2.471e-7,
0.0102780228,
0.0671502575,
0.006092085,
-0.0185017288,
0.0281567462,
0.0418327563,
-0.0310124252,
0.0353972018,
-0.0120936902,
0.012644331,
-0.0239316244,
0.0035420863,
0.0494737737,
0.0056489483,
-0.0680611432,
0.0167855714,
-0.046033781,
0.0412941054,
-0.0980822295,
0.000839278,
0.0649515688,
0.0680451766,
-0.0223798994,
-0.0094666099,
0.0535388365,
-0.0947638527,
0.0626930445,
0.0042610196,
0.0104091596,
0.0050258478,
0.0495478064,
0.0360818952,
-0.0055954922,
0.0037545087,
-0.0061137462,
0.0042248433,
0.0085392809,
0.0647531897,
0.0239235219,
0.011988177,
0.0017062025,
-0.0175440852,
0.0063954042,
-0.0191462599,
0.0844360366,
-0.0579515137,
-0.0258017723,
-0.0456899181,
-0.0284808408,
-0.0407413766,
0.0164399464,
-0.0532192774,
-0.0253447052,
0.0019378337,
0.0158395842,
0.0051442124,
-0.0232604668,
-0.0347735137,
-0.0024735557,
-0.0118367234,
-0.0552693754,
-0.0196362305,
-0.0628093481,
0.0126307514,
0.0221760049,
-0.0701312199,
0.0167748779,
2.588497794e-34,
0.0147601878,
-0.0273701325,
-0.0375156775,
0.0160254613,
0.0206051599,
0.0081595359,
-0.0389217362,
0.0057627694,
-0.0143984817,
-0.0521618687,
0.021257285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12881v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12881v1 | Big Tech influence over AI research revisited: memetic analysis of attribution of ideas to affiliation | 2023-12-20T09:45:44 | 2023-12-20T09:45:44 | Stanisław Giziński, Paulina Kaczyńska, Hubert Ruczyński, Emilia Wiśnios, Bartosz Pieliński, Przemysław Biecek, Julian Sienkiewicz | physics.soc-ph | physics.soc-ph, cs.CL, cs.SI | There exists a growing discourse around the domination of Big Tech on the
landscape of artificial intelligence (AI) research, yet our comprehension of
this phenomenon remains cursory. This paper aims to broaden and deepen our
understanding of Big Tech's reach and power within AI research. It highlights
the dominance not merely in terms of sheer publication volume but rather in the
propagation of new ideas or \textit{memes}. Current studies often oversimplify
the concept of influence to the share of affiliations in academic papers,
typically sourced from limited databases such as arXiv or specific academic
conferences.
The main goal of this paper is to unravel the specific nuances of such
influence, determining which AI ideas are predominantly driven by Big Tech
entities. By employing network and memetic analysis on AI-oriented paper
abstracts and their citation network, we are able to grasp a deeper insight
into this phenomenon. By utilizing two databases: OpenAlex and S2ORC, we are
able to perform such analysis on a much bigger scale than previous attempts.
Our findings suggest, that while Big Tech-affiliated papers are
disproportionately more cited in some areas, the most cited papers are those
affiliated with both Big Tech and Academia. Focusing on the most contagious
memes, their attribution to specific affiliation groups (Big Tech, Academia,
mixed affiliation) seems to be equally distributed between those three groups.
This suggests that the notion of Big Tech domination over AI research is
oversimplified in the discourse.
Ultimately, this more nuanced understanding of Big Tech's and Academia's
influence could inform a more symbiotic alliance between these stakeholders
which would better serve the dual goals of societal welfare and the scientific
integrity of AI research. | [
0.0290311109,
0.023404697,
-0.0344217792,
-0.018094996,
-0.0378391445,
-0.0322101936,
0.0522402823,
-0.018050937,
0.0496940166,
-0.0162070487,
-0.0341079272,
0.0466103256,
0.0336943753,
0.0771678686,
0.000032702,
0.0239517279,
-0.00422733,
0.0475517996,
0.0212107915,
-0.0303259529,
-0.0102399178,
0.0061524124,
-0.0001354683,
0.0191951711,
0.0505225919,
-0.0285025779,
0.0572615303,
-0.0257434901,
0.0280976556,
-0.0256625935,
0.0013858844,
0.0124483379,
-0.0050687813,
0.0655396655,
0.0000018762,
-0.0276595671,
-0.0223221332,
0.01500329,
0.0273786206,
0.0458835959,
0.005219995,
0.0291491579,
-0.0038320322,
0.0015198597,
-0.0394395702,
0.025896335,
0.0325301625,
0.0054610404,
-0.0448719114,
0.0319221504,
-0.0061369846,
-0.0253887568,
0.0580049418,
0.0145323537,
-0.0156025374,
0.0183037277,
0.005125918,
-0.0080671683,
0.0114486273,
0.0366440825,
0.0047932719,
0.0336132236,
-0.003887007,
-0.0016391424,
0.0597375929,
0.0749557987,
0.0153042609,
0.004591695,
0.0171113834,
0.0352662541,
0.066300489,
-0.0179898329,
0.0882199481,
0.0001127836,
-0.0160142314,
0.0583672673,
-0.0506327786,
0.0284304321,
0.0289085917,
-0.0168199465,
0.0300949235,
0.0327513777,
0.0335801281,
0.0617633574,
-0.0458475463,
0.0474322252,
-0.0141078169,
-0.0098753814,
0.0227504,
-0.0022713533,
0.0205272306,
-0.0458758399,
0.0002411781,
-0.0052314573,
0.0374071375,
-0.0121571347,
0.012307086,
-0.0136925597,
-0.0099707982,
-0.0244685337,
-0.0403438099,
-0.0610933453,
0.0309136361,
0.0409015827,
0.0073195398,
-0.0543070547,
-0.0976210758,
0.0293237623,
0.0158634521,
0.0274003297,
-0.0580197535,
-0.0054928483,
0.0162389278,
0.023520235,
0.0480837822,
-0.0329699703,
-0.0202327017,
0.0196535699,
-0.0602316596,
-0.0276685804,
-0.0537388064,
0.0361947231,
0.0301084127,
-0.012962156,
-0.0061913119,
0.03892361,
-0.0404706411,
0.0602817163,
-0.021305725,
0.0091954498,
0.0195397008,
0.0168939941,
0.0372435451,
-0.0398726277,
0.0329984836,
0.0419984497,
0.0357890278,
-0.0342016555,
0.0128914611,
-0.0680212975,
0.0309400167,
-0.0385188237,
0.0543023348,
-0.0262535326,
-0.0051267669,
0.0576327443,
0.0141289989,
-0.0468310639,
-0.0398145244,
-0.0349122733,
-0.0522554964,
0.0047082724,
-0.0454149693,
0.00546668,
0.0571816079,
0.0270820744,
-0.0397478268,
-0.0317522883,
0.0186458211,
0.0204266328,
0.0485167839,
0.0014492694,
0.0128351701,
0.014328775,
0.0207755528,
-0.0273298789,
0.0676157102,
0.0137744648,
-0.0623633787,
0.0006397832,
-0.0119437715,
0.0402783677,
-0.0349166803,
0.0330889635,
0.0291607101,
0.0458507873,
-0.0049092537,
0.0468529612,
-0.0496890917,
-0.0134192482,
-0.0004255078,
-0.0470926762,
-0.0152977929,
0.0156816393,
-0.0322791487,
-0.0432478525,
0.0334019102,
0.0217602476,
-0.0305883456,
-0.024421677,
0.034817677,
0.0035752859,
0.0259675309,
-0.0242077019,
0.0664182082,
-0.048881948,
0.0220509823,
-0.0394984372,
-0.0143547151,
0.0627734438,
-0.003946797,
-0.0141003141,
0.0149401333,
-0.0272174031,
0.0644894093,
-0.0108840363,
0.0219145995,
0.0124245966,
-0.0013460157,
0.0061959848,
-0.0305144843,
0.0158257354,
-0.0688526481,
-0.0033581224,
0.0068020779,
-0.0172408111,
-0.0172838662,
-0.0019039034,
0.0152881136,
0.0541796461,
-0.0288432334,
0.0293222237,
-0.0375378616,
-0.0206132475,
-0.0276712086,
0.0206138678,
-0.0083786882,
-0.0106381355,
0.0537472479,
0.0347601287,
-0.031525027,
0.0146155674,
0.0559957512,
-0.0220698733,
-0.031306304,
0.0061115348,
0.0502006039,
0.1370606571,
-0.0046683559,
-0.1028618589,
0.0075797625,
0.0107527049,
0.0085824272,
-0.0173349082,
0.1142610013,
0.0146776615,
0.0304382741,
0.0577742532,
-0.0357131921,
-0.0460548848,
0.0160965417,
-0.0047830772,
0.0292666927,
-0.0128113609,
-0.0002979649,
0.034046378,
-0.0186682399,
0.0385684185,
0.0570476986,
-0.000625887,
-0.0041495608,
-0.0103975842,
0.0066390405,
0.0563332774,
-0.0964922085,
-0.0073299212,
0.0102506764,
0.0041902578,
-0.0221585091,
0.0078366036,
-0.004847853,
0.0111628808,
-0.0275321789,
0.0172187854,
0.0299322903,
0.0115555916,
-0.0066884025,
-0.0086252568,
-0.0078322431,
0.0413891375,
0.0437481366,
-0.0133609977,
-0.0317851603,
-0.0076092146,
-0.0299892016,
0.0003961395,
0.0617356449,
-0.0263372064,
-0.0229250547,
-0.0088453665,
-0.0593555495,
-0.0012775499,
-0.0510312319,
0.0400703587,
0.015079665,
0.0170529746,
-0.0294805411,
0.0690160617,
-0.0219075456,
0.0525581129,
0.0204145536,
0.0279998221,
-0.0020220967,
-0.0341906957,
-0.0233748499,
0.018670978,
-0.0005850588,
-0.0444530286,
0.0237163119,
-0.0035652819,
-0.0126185734,
0.0038389941,
0.0136524951,
0.0240331888,
-0.0250068158,
-0.0204477999,
0.0404198915,
-0.0492720455,
0.0228032246,
0.0651297793,
0.0109297996,
-0.0299907252,
-0.0044223228,
-0.0140125742,
0.0300117843,
-0.0046263998,
-0.036985755,
-0.0148651609,
0.0743076801,
-0.0041041854,
0.0155226886,
0.0355262272,
0.0037692464,
-0.0395973958,
-0.0168665964,
-0.0030191208,
-0.0160585009,
-0.0365666077,
0.0138462055,
0.0079234792,
0.0038075692,
0.0239686724,
0.0309394728,
-0.0095667895,
-0.0388650633,
-0.0022849243,
0.0826074108,
-0.0748978779,
-0.025518978,
-0.0220633764,
0.0767149851,
-0.0547694415,
0.0103980722,
-0.0291462392,
0.001369653,
0.0311172176,
0.0663406998,
-0.0303984024,
0.0658609495,
0.0192439221,
-0.0503213666,
0.019274652,
0.0182830989,
0.0126358587,
-0.0735726431,
-0.0705706701,
-0.0173469502,
-0.0457514785,
-0.0107489144,
-0.0315209292,
0.0252367388,
0.0114570847,
0.0250722766,
0.0323606431,
-0.0083199712,
-0.0271231756,
0.0180460345,
0.0178038571,
-0.0164676104,
0.0065311491,
0.0134068271,
-0.0953242034,
0.0291602165,
-0.0461428389,
-0.0114214541,
-0.0710066706,
-0.0619810559,
0.0112839993,
-0.0507202707,
0.0310774166,
-0.0240831096,
0.0027314357,
-0.0065853414,
-0.0475165136,
-0.0003927913,
-0.0317487381,
0.0018179378,
-0.0415814929,
0.0366065465,
-0.0086463345,
0.0154685033,
-0.0123063084,
-0.0005486592,
-0.0013094582,
-0.0526607595,
0.0440339372,
0.005257396,
0.0251828935,
-0.0725139603,
-0.0088463072,
0.0193796381,
0.0184156075,
-0.0060248398,
-0.0081527224,
0.0341464952,
-0.004470692,
-0.0061152657,
-0.0312114824,
0.0080356486,
-0.0223575588,
0.0219856836,
0.0207250565,
0.0673572198,
-0.0229956489,
-0.0490288138,
-0.0468205474,
-0.051183708,
-0.0291467104,
0.0386891104,
-0.0446980745,
-0.0220854543,
-0.0179871488,
0.0185657237,
0.0443457365,
0.0564841591,
-0.0560281835,
-0.0679801628,
0.0010561302,
-0.0189168174,
-0.0364698097,
-0.0356168114,
-0.0218497571,
0.0332481228,
0.0251137055,
0.0000053664,
0.0515471734,
-0.0224305876,
-0.0236133058,
0.0111946557,
-0.0065402249,
0.0058406708,
0.0068389075,
-0.0208754912,
0.0050356127,
0.0023210063,
-0.0405487306,
0.0188895706,
0.0362612456,
-0.0268329475,
-0.0237332899,
0.0056530135,
0.0290626884,
0.0312884487,
-0.0203566514,
-0.0234414637,
0.0770898834,
0.044475127,
-0.0213625263,
0.00774734,
-0.003117674,
-0.0699816048,
-0.0105342465,
-0.0324596278,
-0.036002066,
0.0112523837,
0.0289553516,
-0.0701414347,
-0.0701567829,
0.0004124148,
-0.0226464346,
-0.000690703,
0.0555880852,
-0.0386677012,
0.0458863489,
0.0273944587,
-0.0315007456,
0.0090553425,
0.0162444226,
0.0000765252,
-0.0501056015,
0.0176582038,
0.0027626185,
-0.0190500021,
0.0334366076,
0.0247142222,
0.0261322446,
-0.0508036464,
0.0308581758,
-0.0359801315,
0.1080619395,
-0.0011536704,
-0.0017457205,
-0.0079718223,
0.0358998142,
-0.0277182385,
0.0738032237,
0.0085864486,
0.0020410493,
0.0103721954,
-0.0276450943,
0.018303955,
0.0435472392,
-0.0980921313,
-0.0864020586,
0.0337752551,
-0.0167760309,
0.0049766214,
0.0225987099,
0.0155151831,
-0.0127360383,
0.0100472448,
-0.0313987806,
0.0209040102,
0.0068050278,
0.0141520081,
-0.0283850636,
0.0047624968,
-0.047058817,
0.0282807145,
0.0343786329,
-0.0167055167,
0.0075848103,
-0.0015142994,
-0.0137245459,
0.0246194024,
-0.0476775691,
-0.0226297863,
0.0445263125,
0.0041703032,
-0.0349618383,
-0.0308399517,
-0.0176975187,
0.0103956852,
-0.0107080946,
0.0117122317,
-0.0426823124,
-0.0155529371,
0.0240482762,
0.0087357713,
-0.0096786441,
0.0286899973,
0.0199984871,
-0.1120103002,
-0.0459784903,
0.0180384275,
-6.445889394e-33,
0.048998449,
-0.0419693962,
-0.0102307349,
0.0088750934,
-0.0535923503,
0.0521350056,
-0.0032905682,
0.0064335088,
-0.0497074723,
0.0103893699,
-0.0539036877,
-0.0095230844,
-0.0082197962,
-0.0239527375,
0.060552109,
0.0115214912,
-0.0104786837,
-0.0014367393,
0.0059298896,
0.0772837028,
-0.0188960414,
-0.0301205795,
-0.0130759114,
-0.0905346274,
0.0376609527,
-0.0212480295,
-0.0224786941,
-0.0170560386,
0.0364419855,
0.0298483055,
-0.0140112853,
0.0112750251,
0.0160028711,
-0.0651648715,
0.0124626504,
0.0368349962,
-0.0495155007,
0.0012594756,
0.0086985826,
-0.019907536,
0.0000823892,
-0.0317828916,
0.0648980439,
-0.0162642114,
-0.0274357423,
-0.0034321691,
0.0661792383,
-0.0158223137,
-0.0170404799,
-0.0260280333,
-0.019051984,
0.0137042888,
-0.0418110676,
0.0647431836,
-0.0201587975,
-0.0054959967,
-0.0064332071,
0.0922399238,
-0.077805236,
0.024514148,
-0.0393810496,
-0.0281998906,
0.033004038,
-0.0025947392,
0.0460405163,
0.0331080891,
0.0287446491,
0.0435548276,
0.0011935508,
-0.0495995171,
0.0052390131,
0.0698027313,
0.042924732,
0.0221972391,
0.0061660628,
-0.007742614,
-0.0926930234,
-0.0241179224,
0.0245846566,
-0.016167596,
0.0372610316,
-0.0199496001,
-0.0474811345,
-0.016777236,
0.0360894352,
-0.0807924718,
0.0058533573,
-0.0440241471,
-0.051033631,
-0.0279944781,
-0.0131334439,
0.0618808158,
0.0388173722,
-0.0669579878,
-0.0447350405,
0.0222938042,
0.0245364923,
0.0665021688,
0.0042761383,
-0.0157441515,
-0.1130105034,
-0.0439789854,
-0.0366333686,
0.0421491116,
0.0538891219,
0.036013823,
0.0185566153,
-0.0084331958,
0.007751714,
-0.0267320164,
-0.0133868791,
-0.0015997597,
-0.0131154153,
-0.0618587025,
0.0108529814,
0.0561553054,
0.037780717,
-0.0222267266,
0.0382266901,
0.1009605676,
0.0062772841,
0.0371820033,
-0.0458695628,
0.0038498214,
-0.0343107358,
-0.0282336064,
-0.0388590321,
0.049627386,
0.0012685318,
-0.0675361753,
-0.0174917262,
-0.0670334175,
2.767e-7,
0.0207436644,
0.0342360586,
-0.0117670083,
0.0209392495,
0.0323411189,
0.0199897215,
0.0271193646,
0.0218354892,
-0.021627022,
0.0017716482,
0.0273724739,
0.0233654957,
-0.0101458253,
-0.032413505,
-0.0127077252,
-0.0308499373,
-0.0763712302,
0.0259262323,
-0.0643156096,
0.031157162,
-0.0235568844,
-0.0125803081,
0.0316615477,
0.0078856861,
-0.0422985852,
-0.024109982,
0.025164118,
-0.0292030256,
0.0781917199,
0.0219532717,
-0.0245531164,
0.0108332112,
-0.0358063504,
-0.0152569283,
0.020129865,
0.0041025463,
-0.0287326425,
-0.0396283008,
0.0172257423,
0.0468371361,
0.0340140611,
-0.0630298033,
0.0309268776,
-0.0506384932,
0.044505626,
-0.0334523134,
-0.0772724301,
-0.0407509878,
-0.0483597629,
-0.0335106142,
0.0323399976,
0.0247655865,
0.0203859713,
-0.0094091995,
-0.0382025242,
-0.0256165098,
-0.0006585502,
-0.070991002,
0.042916365,
0.0154104196,
0.0055089681,
-0.0556644686,
-0.010214177,
-0.0291617755,
0.0768335611,
0.0445001498,
0.0408240557,
1.944039445e-34,
0.0364260152,
-0.062607877,
0.0140636135,
0.0392447412,
0.0355606861,
0.0103531051,
-0.0076723993,
-0.0131805092,
0.0290353615,
-0.050655771,
-0.0003649124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12853v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12853v1 | CORECODE: A Common Sense Annotated Dialogue Dataset with Benchmark Tasks for Chinese Large Language Models | 2023-12-20T09:06:18 | 2023-12-20T09:06:18 | Dan Shi, Chaobin You, Jiantao Huang, Taihao Li, Deyi Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL | As an indispensable ingredient of intelligence, commonsense reasoning is
crucial for large language models (LLMs) in real-world scenarios. In this
paper, we propose CORECODE, a dataset that contains abundant commonsense
knowledge manually annotated on dyadic dialogues, to evaluate the commonsense
reasoning and commonsense conflict detection capabilities of Chinese LLMs. We
categorize commonsense knowledge in everyday conversations into three
dimensions: entity, event, and social interaction. For easy and consistent
annotation, we standardize the form of commonsense knowledge annotation in
open-domain dialogues as "domain: slot = value". A total of 9 domains and 37
slots are defined to capture diverse commonsense knowledge. With these
pre-defined domains and slots, we collect 76,787 commonsense knowledge
annotations from 19,700 dialogues through crowdsourcing. To evaluate and
enhance the commonsense reasoning capability for LLMs on the curated dataset,
we establish a series of dialogue-level reasoning and detection tasks,
including commonsense knowledge filling, commonsense knowledge generation,
commonsense conflict phrase detection, domain identification, slot
identification, and event causal inference. A wide variety of existing
open-source Chinese LLMs are evaluated with these tasks on our dataset.
Experimental results demonstrate that these models are not competent to predict
CORECODE's plentiful reasoning content, and even ChatGPT could only achieve
0.275 and 0.084 accuracy on the domain identification and slot identification
tasks under the zero-shot setting. We release the data and codes of CORECODE at
https://github.com/danshi777/CORECODE to promote commonsense reasoning
evaluation and study of LLMs in the context of daily conversations. | [
0.0509841479,
0.0405196659,
0.0003822522,
0.0778171197,
-0.0189048536,
0.0182069391,
-0.0140736634,
-0.0086505283,
0.0462480821,
-0.0664301738,
-0.0141400555,
0.0105591509,
0.0095074316,
0.0015365173,
0.0150621235,
-0.020082416,
0.0345174409,
0.0034449645,
0.0133483177,
-0.0008549022,
0.0405818596,
0.0197444726,
-0.0124195637,
0.0554588847,
-0.0234790053,
-0.0310542211,
-0.0004606767,
0.0196429566,
0.0426382869,
-0.0134806335,
0.023558842,
0.0656783283,
0.0192194376,
0.0194294732,
0.0000019945,
-0.0536510311,
0.0058977692,
-0.031632904,
-0.0263862293,
0.0062603178,
0.0032235361,
0.0057823034,
0.0048559234,
0.0111973528,
-0.0485644266,
0.0185260251,
0.0127622625,
0.0615784563,
0.0585373677,
0.0469966121,
-0.007327606,
-0.020686958,
-0.009615628,
-0.0154838571,
0.0096620768,
-0.0923991874,
0.0333095081,
0.068002753,
-0.0108889043,
0.0037442946,
0.008729131,
0.0098595219,
0.0134626823,
-0.0447947681,
-0.0240871925,
0.0243271906,
-0.0632342845,
-0.0041387854,
-0.0106409416,
0.1068792343,
0.0656759515,
-0.0206128694,
0.0092841843,
0.0082438514,
0.0104741389,
-0.0023421524,
-0.0396645591,
0.0150513807,
0.0019103508,
0.0290325135,
0.0394112021,
-0.0127556873,
0.0094482619,
0.0483998694,
0.0086116157,
0.0437270068,
-0.0225789025,
-0.0078674639,
-0.0231187195,
0.0007324791,
-0.0501565337,
-0.0738839582,
0.0022896156,
0.0389037654,
-0.0333081558,
0.035913676,
-0.0254962668,
0.0015883595,
0.0301133972,
-0.0772565976,
-0.0230628364,
0.0244791619,
-0.0191108733,
0.0652840361,
0.0101416148,
0.0269167908,
0.007754398,
0.0422334038,
-0.0173227768,
-0.0313741378,
-0.0569499657,
-0.005429944,
-0.0367675647,
0.0227450524,
-0.047040876,
-0.0200287513,
-0.0208761599,
-0.0006820348,
-0.0067684823,
0.0190896057,
0.0278959814,
0.0033873839,
-0.0175637305,
-0.0299813803,
-0.028668981,
0.0414417982,
-0.0579877831,
0.0257024188,
0.0160265043,
-0.0539357699,
-0.0160285961,
0.0180542972,
0.0160473734,
-0.0298330635,
-0.0263192747,
0.0269764271,
-0.0130803511,
0.003551357,
-0.0489632785,
-0.0343371108,
-0.0131042246,
-0.0321851633,
-0.0172846392,
-0.05690106,
0.0206285603,
0.0117338961,
-0.0018718805,
-0.0156646948,
0.0354220048,
0.011172777,
-0.0359735936,
0.0691582635,
-0.0228253249,
0.0174599644,
0.0266692452,
0.0295768641,
0.0034468491,
0.0630113035,
0.035164997,
-0.0386282317,
0.0710515603,
0.0160538424,
-0.0180522427,
0.0051488471,
0.0181858968,
-0.0125910742,
0.0197802372,
0.0155561641,
-0.021976456,
0.0204720497,
0.0262838211,
0.0355178379,
-0.0517577529,
-0.0329877436,
0.0602650382,
0.0616556853,
-0.0583093576,
0.0182964485,
-0.0112573318,
0.0478010289,
0.011218681,
-0.001913661,
-0.0465271063,
0.0313263014,
-0.046137318,
-0.0298983473,
0.026185805,
-0.0188402925,
-0.0198803246,
-0.0295647644,
-0.0445187949,
-0.0045867893,
0.0250899531,
-0.0049704174,
0.0212938823,
0.0015300085,
-0.0222587083,
0.0851515085,
0.0282665938,
-0.0597216301,
-0.0174747203,
-0.0056228866,
0.0160008334,
0.0478685312,
0.0273725018,
-0.0016571165,
-0.0726388916,
-0.0085503682,
0.0375526734,
0.0656115785,
0.0505410917,
-0.0494839922,
-0.0068114209,
-0.0649144724,
-0.0199663453,
0.0239666477,
-0.0004865541,
-0.0177984051,
0.042117022,
-0.0136740748,
0.0133519219,
-0.0225441325,
-0.0040499852,
0.0041795191,
-0.0360643677,
0.007286218,
-0.0396615863,
-0.0047661085,
0.0393517725,
0.0227627717,
0.0020407338,
-0.0073213503,
0.010205932,
-0.0270315055,
-0.0385798328,
0.0744779408,
-0.0501614138,
-0.0770322904,
0.0648558363,
-0.0151463822,
-0.075785026,
0.0291760918,
-0.0484078489,
-0.0282057431,
0.0000875652,
0.0045301025,
0.0069853393,
-0.0789165571,
-0.0140213827,
-0.0068797604,
-0.0265488215,
-0.0025263373,
0.0890467018,
-0.0133755999,
-0.0160535965,
0.0182609018,
0.0074803098,
0.028108146,
-0.0478907712,
-0.0169398971,
-0.0065083979,
0.0044465419,
0.0034831602,
0.0189759564,
0.0264831372,
-0.0206023194,
0.0011404126,
-0.1280005425,
0.0170852132,
-0.0188110378,
-0.0015461042,
0.0244654678,
-0.0213334542,
0.0064299228,
0.0126559138,
-0.0200529769,
0.0132141989,
0.0057960311,
0.0055818101,
0.033978112,
-0.0033023458,
0.0212200489,
-0.0114018181,
0.0395194031,
-0.0357246585,
0.0013513565,
0.0165213924,
0.0201011058,
-0.0164874401,
0.0151859429,
-0.0293645561,
0.0158552863,
-0.0206665099,
-0.0734050348,
-0.0022188155,
0.01233932,
0.0015001643,
0.0526035354,
0.0125101339,
0.0501909293,
-0.0088133067,
-0.03394638,
-0.0426911786,
0.0325130112,
0.016374154,
0.0144751463,
-0.0539130494,
-0.0115912473,
-0.0272193775,
0.0649846941,
0.0030288366,
0.013450142,
-0.0752066895,
-0.0013297751,
-0.017692456,
-0.0006976009,
-0.0396276824,
-0.0005340559,
-0.0301801581,
0.0388226137,
-0.0501188673,
-0.0024410996,
0.0689026937,
-0.0263536181,
-0.0076102815,
-0.0504888147,
0.0167384781,
-0.0411863066,
0.0686275065,
-0.0576839298,
0.0110795293,
-0.0165628474,
-0.0201413538,
-0.0353778154,
0.0052459482,
0.0302216318,
-0.033540979,
0.0280810986,
-0.056862507,
0.0284960866,
-0.0348505862,
-0.0525075793,
-0.0388609059,
-0.0370898247,
-0.050791759,
0.0199002456,
0.0435566641,
-0.0100986771,
0.0146064637,
0.0220405851,
-0.0027004771,
0.0246826429,
0.0046093222,
0.0058523035,
-0.0114649562,
0.0390663072,
0.0465527177,
0.0698038861,
-0.000260999,
0.012639652,
0.0212521534,
0.0666213259,
0.007001231,
-0.0169150028,
0.0049166996,
0.0061793067,
0.0019630007,
0.0125949467,
-0.0058779959,
-0.0067466539,
0.0907136127,
-0.0391388126,
0.0022766136,
0.1271798015,
0.0331632569,
0.0075771348,
-0.0071534291,
-0.0275765918,
0.0056647598,
0.0158126988,
-0.0082763722,
-0.1081891954,
-0.0677191764,
0.0079586394,
-0.0199797619,
0.000485481,
-0.0780728385,
0.0215329733,
-0.1263381541,
0.0239456035,
-0.0101681948,
-0.0490692034,
-0.0376267694,
-0.000971997,
0.0015853151,
-0.0128093529,
0.0006599515,
-0.0013760187,
0.0323385671,
-0.0130871311,
0.0120392777,
-0.0044844123,
-0.0575543083,
0.060828086,
-0.0177267473,
0.0858593285,
0.0450365022,
0.0755926892,
0.0342314914,
-0.0417835116,
0.0065365173,
-0.0213127844,
-0.0148765855,
-0.0199201237,
0.0125678573,
-0.0198722929,
-0.0131347468,
-0.0185234789,
0.0715356767,
-0.0653417557,
-0.0338923596,
0.0287852902,
0.0473252386,
-0.0154924104,
-0.002858076,
-0.0067401333,
0.0433024801,
0.0268122759,
0.1265734285,
0.0379741117,
0.0139227975,
-0.0236218106,
-0.0252587125,
-0.0316735096,
-0.063712813,
-0.0153218256,
0.0224990863,
0.0411177836,
0.0156983156,
-0.0980809107,
-0.0231855065,
0.0425768793,
0.0111053009,
-0.0088827368,
0.0056463545,
0.0262773689,
0.0275047068,
-0.03175883,
0.0318484902,
-0.0598550588,
-0.0172681473,
-0.029143028,
0.0031125541,
0.0266030338,
-0.0128375273,
-0.0414741412,
0.0875176489,
-0.0839023143,
-0.0639725327,
-0.0520251356,
0.0139191169,
0.0149735194,
0.0430888571,
-0.0354850516,
-0.0156449676,
-0.0244863927,
0.0085922759,
-0.0380103551,
-0.003156476,
0.0346153043,
0.0349637009,
0.0163216498,
0.0694657341,
-0.0173638538,
-0.0024229588,
-0.0075986311,
0.0768461004,
-0.0580996536,
-0.0461561792,
-0.0024479001,
-0.0059145615,
0.0227981415,
0.0169145111,
0.0095086796,
-0.0472438037,
0.0202792436,
-0.0383368805,
-0.0515446067,
-0.0539476126,
0.0080128647,
-0.0022782665,
-0.0395746008,
-0.0187123939,
0.0255442895,
-0.0189870372,
0.0372007377,
0.0025520159,
-0.0045848382,
0.0177155714,
0.0245643705,
0.003886302,
-0.0329735018,
-0.0048017302,
-0.0067845206,
-0.005771169,
0.0175144039,
0.0068847109,
0.1126276925,
0.0308416244,
-0.0471406281,
0.0560748987,
-0.0250559393,
-0.0236603674,
-0.0291674044,
0.024161201,
0.0773201808,
0.0573612005,
-0.0266951583,
0.0458361916,
-0.0461274683,
-0.0048882719,
-0.0119146081,
0.0700737238,
0.0092138564,
-0.0340602286,
0.0410647877,
0.0216071941,
-0.0394743532,
0.0073557827,
0.1008847132,
-0.0269556157,
0.0216989368,
0.0211268198,
-0.0219116323,
-0.0215373598,
-0.0344747454,
0.0497253872,
0.0467422158,
-0.0028137227,
0.0408760644,
-0.0849583521,
-0.048011668,
-0.0024038313,
0.0155406464,
-0.0027278129,
0.0175200794,
-0.0002339592,
0.0659716576,
-0.0206977297,
-0.0336374231,
-0.0353978835,
0.0185982138,
-0.0842376053,
0.0064733569,
-0.0367042907,
-6.52202249e-33,
-0.0312963091,
-0.0593494214,
0.0201681014,
-0.0070435456,
-0.0074053952,
-0.0106957443,
-0.0771556795,
-0.014726718,
-0.0250030328,
0.0398427285,
0.0022421321,
0.0383587927,
0.0040022233,
0.0245017111,
-0.0032171775,
-0.03616523,
0.0309125092,
0.012535125,
-0.0018853027,
0.0233553909,
0.0620442778,
-0.0158383846,
0.0397605784,
-0.0444846153,
0.0162696764,
-0.0193037502,
0.0168558694,
0.0542227663,
-0.0033738918,
0.0441106334,
-0.007882922,
0.0256346911,
0.0268044267,
-0.024777025,
0.0058576823,
0.0219613649,
-0.0837506652,
-0.0334137678,
0.0604609214,
-0.0011138781,
-0.023066638,
-0.0188852102,
0.0116786761,
0.0109939631,
0.0043704654,
0.0017908238,
0.0440483801,
-0.0324809514,
0.0164687056,
-0.0131516308,
-0.0509007499,
0.0512252562,
-0.0400988385,
-0.0570540652,
-0.0354994722,
-0.0207791179,
0.009408162,
-0.0019174216,
-0.0653718337,
0.0148811731,
-0.0209685769,
-0.0173146389,
0.0347388349,
-0.0306739807,
0.0318741761,
0.0611262731,
-0.0517424904,
0.0212988015,
-0.0348293111,
0.0253912359,
-0.0046731327,
0.0657166913,
0.0100931516,
0.0997906104,
-0.0111659374,
-0.0028073878,
-0.0727059916,
0.0318272673,
0.0007449621,
0.0390664153,
0.0223002192,
0.0219936073,
-0.0271182582,
-0.0079044728,
-0.0105258133,
-0.0181952398,
-0.0303505454,
-0.0007018168,
0.0124081029,
-0.0100270892,
-0.0540182851,
0.0193540622,
0.0537213348,
-0.0410849676,
-0.0089949258,
0.0547322296,
0.0019282656,
-0.0128806392,
-0.0142465001,
0.0305055603,
-0.0612620227,
-0.013370215,
0.0268900711,
0.0142239761,
0.0154171512,
0.033082474,
0.0481122173,
-0.0408081189,
0.0249059945,
-0.0160984509,
-0.0259925798,
0.0038665847,
-0.0631208122,
0.01200567,
0.0357528515,
0.0320261195,
0.0051453123,
0.0271145198,
0.0184157807,
0.017523611,
-0.0292417891,
-0.0001768565,
-0.013035953,
-0.0156953428,
-0.0130892051,
0.0164255053,
-0.0236984361,
-0.0343144871,
0.0052997782,
-0.0236951392,
0.0015529996,
0.0099857813,
2.577e-7,
0.0078636808,
0.0343892016,
0.0390969291,
-0.0017724024,
0.0188229475,
0.0553986207,
-0.0110101672,
0.0266348775,
0.0001056532,
-0.0368404984,
0.016796574,
0.0570310019,
0.0799900591,
0.0300765242,
-0.0994726494,
0.0059873653,
-0.0534803718,
-0.0398917645,
-0.037177179,
0.0093848072,
0.0527438074,
0.0379301272,
0.0262411963,
0.0179505367,
0.0119865807,
-0.0553704798,
0.0336845294,
-0.0329360291,
-0.0166450944,
0.0313699879,
0.0039092312,
0.0112430137,
0.0008235474,
0.0314569399,
0.001721669,
0.0145586049,
0.0259043276,
0.0794951469,
0.0049476665,
-0.0369029306,
-0.0520418212,
-0.0435170829,
0.0120913889,
-0.0716446489,
0.0619636625,
-0.0570683107,
-0.0253753979,
-0.0281035155,
0.0190132745,
-0.0217050947,
-0.0055990531,
0.0001442978,
-0.0216300823,
0.0134285372,
0.0221196637,
-0.026799364,
0.0056087463,
-0.060881421,
-0.0216855351,
-0.0059079458,
-0.0435174368,
-0.0559129268,
-0.0257021654,
-0.0529577658,
0.0084277503,
-0.04425098,
-0.0007035637,
2.15281964e-34,
0.0035636027,
0.0010302771,
-0.0015848605,
0.0180833638,
0.0819047391,
-0.0054551028,
-0.0351643376,
0.0079420777,
0.0060924259,
-0.0327327214,
0.0126911141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12852v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12852v1 | Language Resources for Dutch Large Language Modelling | 2023-12-20T09:06:06 | 2023-12-20T09:06:06 | Bram Vanroy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the rapid expansion of types of large language models, there remains
a notable gap in models specifically designed for the Dutch language. This gap
is not only a shortage in terms of pretrained Dutch models but also in terms of
data, and benchmarks and leaderboards. This work provides a small step to
improve the situation. First, we introduce two fine-tuned variants of the Llama
2 13B model. We first fine-tuned Llama 2 using Dutch-specific web-crawled data
and subsequently refined this model further on multiple synthetic instruction
and chat datasets. These datasets as well as the model weights are made
available. In addition, we provide a leaderboard to keep track of the
performance of (Dutch) models on a number of generation tasks, and we include
results of a number of state-of-the-art models, including our own. Finally we
provide a critical conclusion on what we believe is needed to push forward
Dutch language models and the whole eco-system around the models. | [
0.0437514968,
0.0503994115,
0.0025367583,
0.0411682911,
-0.0287996568,
0.0114918342,
-0.0127472365,
-0.0363119692,
0.0290765185,
-0.0295164902,
-0.0566621646,
-0.0576387122,
-0.0037302547,
0.0084419409,
0.0568264872,
-0.0480466373,
0.0574169122,
-0.045480527,
-0.0152737368,
-0.0326850303,
0.0158647038,
0.0131192477,
0.020420894,
0.0594369695,
0.0284607578,
0.0218153931,
-0.022583345,
0.0069178115,
-0.0074227424,
0.0014599622,
0.0425987318,
0.0322714224,
0.0022764595,
0.0401975065,
0.0000020258,
-0.0549946539,
0.0116981855,
-0.0459760986,
-0.0329824947,
0.0771892071,
0.0594668388,
-0.0161146168,
-0.0479837917,
0.0361425281,
-0.0114266463,
-0.0309522059,
0.0568584912,
-0.0126322545,
0.0442390479,
0.0725479573,
0.0108721806,
-0.0499103926,
0.0396590531,
-0.064819321,
-0.0158101264,
-0.003637003,
0.0317083113,
0.026567813,
0.031861458,
0.0053753289,
-0.0623892508,
0.021410469,
0.0170257483,
-0.008446645,
-0.0060393275,
0.0037564144,
-0.0038802926,
-0.054293301,
0.0142246755,
0.0839247555,
-0.0077677784,
-0.0090808906,
0.0177596174,
0.0169683024,
0.0015632057,
-0.028689906,
-0.0532220751,
0.0420559645,
0.0383446589,
0.0279252008,
0.045557227,
-0.0331344977,
0.0105586201,
0.0373618789,
-0.0086916983,
0.0338515677,
0.019869063,
0.0042267502,
0.0173662864,
0.0218630023,
0.0016821966,
-0.054027535,
-0.0376049504,
0.0339050479,
-0.0006470823,
0.0202345494,
-0.018476598,
0.0221713334,
0.0374114364,
-0.0318866409,
0.0651888698,
0.0327548906,
-0.0437913276,
-0.0038802647,
0.0009914037,
0.0302165654,
-0.0378561877,
0.0224178322,
-0.0683338642,
-0.0211882982,
-0.0133277355,
0.0085669942,
-0.0585224107,
0.0219682269,
-0.0438152775,
-0.0119529916,
-0.0636825487,
0.0031147755,
0.0267639346,
-0.0316642262,
0.0362165086,
-0.0008550763,
-0.0587562732,
-0.0018772744,
0.0113133593,
0.052274771,
-0.0193135235,
0.0103814891,
-0.0026036233,
-0.0781291872,
0.0287484284,
0.0091912877,
-0.0181413386,
-0.0177681837,
0.0187577922,
0.0805819482,
-0.0208155029,
-0.0033128974,
-0.058106102,
-0.0192508455,
-0.0356602222,
-0.0855240598,
0.002162541,
-0.0668566301,
0.0374974199,
-0.0125827454,
0.0314254537,
-0.0107648047,
0.00924318,
-0.00345342,
-0.0144414175,
-0.0084100477,
-0.0294336993,
0.0054864888,
-0.0013079997,
-0.0077441349,
0.0079273209,
0.077039741,
0.0255442038,
-0.0176444706,
0.0215146225,
-0.0208525211,
-0.0504326783,
0.09717834,
0.0388235748,
-0.0196206011,
0.0041168495,
-0.0131972581,
0.012268696,
0.0112487357,
0.0806358904,
0.0629927218,
-0.0276319757,
-0.0223918334,
0.0522032492,
-0.0086589232,
0.017441025,
0.0254734773,
0.0603277721,
0.0228929892,
0.0414042138,
-0.0094604567,
0.0010248837,
0.0038723908,
-0.0278209988,
0.0225865394,
0.0149269272,
0.0644340068,
-0.0292377863,
-0.0262770019,
0.0329448879,
-0.0120820608,
0.0004703967,
0.0087808305,
0.0399023741,
-0.0085544912,
-0.0228585452,
0.0452503227,
0.0451233722,
-0.0338265933,
0.0153862638,
-0.0482288636,
-0.003473718,
0.0833480358,
0.0344613232,
0.0470534451,
-0.0397722051,
-0.0000902046,
0.0209947117,
0.0225928426,
0.0543013662,
-0.0535214394,
0.0115800491,
-0.0732958466,
0.006217387,
0.0071144919,
0.0090011768,
0.0418476872,
0.00517397,
-0.0132221421,
0.0159881692,
-0.0436319783,
-0.0276634973,
0.0122713717,
-0.0513805375,
0.0172066614,
-0.01720112,
-0.0176311918,
0.0398131348,
0.0367528833,
-0.0088283243,
0.0034096658,
0.0042201439,
-0.0343289003,
0.0437336788,
0.0221088231,
-0.0188904479,
-0.0640072823,
0.0341081806,
-0.0121757546,
0.0286148004,
0.0532534532,
-0.0458666496,
-0.0515772998,
0.0188204404,
-0.0831560716,
0.0148040634,
-0.0286139566,
0.01083571,
0.0074438662,
-0.0003612913,
-0.0299412571,
0.0484485328,
-0.0142690819,
0.0269701798,
0.0088771461,
0.0212448407,
-0.0039846948,
-0.0329034813,
-0.0153291505,
0.0391154774,
-0.0149413049,
0.0289328005,
0.0099694738,
0.0205412228,
-0.0206480045,
-0.0186009239,
-0.0989263281,
-0.0025444203,
-0.024308227,
0.0273380261,
0.0173295848,
-0.0006942395,
-0.0180188362,
-0.0220837649,
-0.0355550647,
0.0216109436,
0.050569322,
0.0215513948,
-0.0308274571,
-0.0062379944,
-0.0485600568,
-0.07565175,
-0.0451969244,
0.0491054915,
0.0137745729,
-0.0089691058,
-0.069551006,
-0.02958492,
0.0452751927,
-0.0758912787,
0.0083304169,
-0.0203926433,
-0.0628731102,
-0.0304457955,
-0.016318148,
0.074040778,
0.0248736273,
0.0041726385,
0.0073737195,
0.0124290623,
-0.0289806779,
-0.080351375,
-0.02688298,
-0.0540709943,
-0.0467404723,
-0.0546452701,
-0.0498767607,
0.0075444542,
0.0847010091,
0.0000534895,
-0.0152344899,
-0.0385501236,
-0.0286671557,
-0.0479456522,
0.0042760912,
-0.0167647563,
0.0144211547,
-0.0011047823,
0.0319883637,
-0.0344068483,
-0.0523914807,
0.0423085578,
-0.0228526276,
-0.0112243621,
-0.0236427207,
-0.023487173,
-0.0403193943,
0.0128137898,
0.0033282104,
0.0295388754,
-0.0002062385,
-0.0164941624,
-0.0148252146,
0.0237793438,
0.0030390101,
-0.0377384238,
0.0365070961,
-0.0467948504,
0.0303352643,
0.0032520748,
-0.0680626109,
-0.0268843491,
-0.0402385294,
-0.0346616507,
0.0047605964,
0.0251289383,
-0.0104178283,
-0.0192102529,
-0.0311993659,
0.0004738509,
0.0125544602,
-0.0186319649,
0.0152217932,
-0.029897254,
0.0380801186,
0.045403108,
-0.0283338577,
0.0188899469,
-0.0496094637,
0.0130789438,
0.0312327649,
0.0237513389,
0.0158805139,
0.0047066291,
0.0157246422,
0.0453850962,
-0.0094792536,
-0.0424997732,
0.0151196439,
0.0580084808,
-0.0325424597,
-0.0070771435,
0.0888391286,
0.0109527148,
0.0179698076,
0.0326191969,
-0.016308194,
0.069764562,
0.0247620177,
0.0377918705,
-0.0727904439,
0.0086236596,
0.0199615061,
0.0228536259,
-0.0049666585,
0.0066769696,
-0.0028344286,
-0.159003526,
0.0580843277,
0.0364715531,
-0.0406736806,
0.0023370415,
-0.0300381295,
-0.0227589812,
-0.0273383129,
0.0082541928,
0.0039092381,
-0.0108936848,
0.0049215006,
0.0568803921,
-0.0156054767,
-0.0633460581,
0.0478021316,
-0.0145739745,
0.0904207081,
0.0295766648,
0.0209318362,
0.0017156608,
-0.0054257601,
0.081321463,
-0.0543540791,
-0.0106424727,
-0.0217323359,
0.044189617,
0.022597855,
-0.0282006543,
-0.0485302731,
0.0246280003,
0.0039273351,
0.0214556176,
-0.0135167567,
0.0427061766,
-0.0072793923,
-0.0073807724,
0.0136298109,
0.0124002919,
-0.0019577912,
0.0368042253,
0.0378612205,
-0.0375048667,
-0.0042436435,
-0.0608548522,
-0.000243006,
-0.0646996945,
-0.0326999351,
0.0277806427,
-0.02476082,
0.0029037644,
-0.0691609532,
-0.0334898941,
0.0108039742,
0.0163963623,
0.0277827606,
-0.0359463431,
0.0094872573,
-0.0363571085,
-0.071831435,
0.0326244421,
-0.0475356989,
0.0240400136,
-0.0901651978,
-0.034004759,
0.0746150166,
-0.0067544691,
-0.0276347566,
-0.04960154,
-0.0878316984,
-0.10404329,
0.021268269,
0.0596029982,
0.0217479635,
0.0605455041,
0.0021252607,
-0.0626555532,
-0.0066656433,
-0.0175831243,
-0.0264590587,
0.0122544337,
0.0173305627,
0.0030025283,
4.534e-7,
0.040368963,
-0.0360691771,
0.0821194053,
0.0161010362,
0.054565005,
0.0081186397,
-0.0217149276,
-0.0003801447,
0.0358250886,
-0.0168319754,
-0.0444770567,
-0.0319864489,
-0.0524935126,
-0.0103485994,
-0.0075030201,
0.0265632216,
-0.0419198535,
-0.0175051596,
0.0483348072,
-0.012019584,
0.0092131021,
0.0158352815,
0.0180913676,
0.0299915895,
-0.0269767698,
0.0338046364,
-0.0025138033,
-0.005071565,
0.0321487784,
0.0308528338,
-0.0048830477,
0.0576174185,
0.0173192453,
0.0335793793,
-0.0141698336,
0.0492915586,
-0.0210792199,
0.0119270906,
-0.0147689776,
0.0072187237,
-0.0137646208,
-0.0258562695,
-0.0425921753,
0.0580093227,
0.0702741444,
0.0173614714,
0.0998046696,
-0.0161911249,
0.005571954,
-0.0431137905,
0.0330952592,
-0.012289335,
-0.0715130121,
0.0430177115,
0.0052422713,
-0.0226155054,
0.0213087071,
0.0670464411,
0.0413563401,
0.0629830658,
-0.0143585019,
0.0426074341,
-0.0401120447,
-0.0258781705,
0.0184244588,
-0.021234436,
-0.0102008861,
0.0022254535,
-0.0218613353,
-0.0710275322,
-0.0455501042,
0.0270604473,
-0.0105076041,
-0.019718783,
0.043002449,
0.0520607531,
0.0060006469,
0.0203364585,
-0.0545738153,
0.0129232202,
-0.0399932638,
-0.0343217328,
-0.0011910911,
-6.632654875e-33,
-0.036416322,
0.0106686382,
0.0157940406,
-0.0184327364,
-0.0414967053,
-0.022540573,
-0.0438141748,
-0.0032413995,
-0.0398921892,
0.0049179033,
0.0179790575,
-0.0193127468,
0.0274218209,
0.0291324314,
0.0132803079,
-0.0001263587,
0.0392422862,
-0.0064441734,
0.0063038571,
0.0279091708,
0.0274131447,
0.0332264118,
0.0516299382,
0.0023779396,
0.0198977794,
-0.0197482668,
-0.0098586874,
0.0008803786,
0.0059914677,
0.0644174665,
-0.0288074538,
0.0585432872,
0.011869072,
-0.0281326007,
-0.0381559096,
0.0194175337,
-0.09348239,
-0.019241767,
0.0204518996,
0.0366352163,
-0.0027575733,
-0.0443484075,
0.0120961322,
-0.0161529761,
-0.0423148125,
-0.0043962393,
0.0039310078,
-0.0242829286,
-0.0195704848,
-0.0074754143,
-0.0688490048,
0.0047050761,
-0.0194989163,
-0.0219443236,
0.0240372103,
0.0668305755,
-0.0054545244,
-0.0418716557,
-0.019923145,
0.0664929822,
0.0211217422,
0.0564801097,
0.0567338206,
-0.0017416186,
-0.0083652576,
0.0446898341,
0.0256809462,
0.0115735624,
0.0108862063,
0.0429045223,
0.0586631335,
0.0470826477,
0.0220132954,
0.0165996477,
-0.0083519826,
-0.0161564127,
-0.0863008648,
0.0192221776,
0.0325379781,
0.0036674617,
-0.0279330723,
-0.0185385477,
-0.0223912969,
-0.0327829607,
-0.0185739379,
0.001427163,
-0.0024147544,
-0.0347070992,
0.0518012866,
0.0018392145,
0.0030715996,
-0.0548016131,
0.0585921817,
-0.0498209,
-0.0492157601,
0.0066305259,
-0.0086413827,
0.0620286874,
-0.0332672447,
0.0441139303,
-0.0869851857,
-0.0585413799,
-0.0019791028,
0.0199703295,
-0.0127169946,
0.0017179482,
0.0077128806,
0.0041616294,
-0.0567168072,
0.0305290222,
-0.0487269051,
0.034478236,
0.0124331489,
0.0031648271,
0.0589754246,
-0.0266167447,
-0.0103967646,
0.0287244096,
0.0104033146,
-0.0071211918,
0.0056658024,
-0.0052814363,
0.002685776,
0.0592198633,
-0.0320607573,
0.0567124225,
-0.0308403466,
0.0087571135,
-0.0160043538,
-0.0015091756,
-0.0108006373,
-0.0087246457,
2.668e-7,
0.0439491943,
0.036519751,
0.0336221159,
0.0314682797,
0.0076107359,
-0.0181930587,
0.0090337126,
-0.0040806914,
0.0070928186,
0.0092510236,
-0.0002954009,
0.0096267574,
0.0713073462,
0.0208180137,
-0.0525287986,
0.0207303539,
-0.055986207,
0.0169743299,
-0.0636470914,
-0.0261250678,
-0.0009946276,
0.1358442903,
-0.0406968668,
-0.0333789624,
-0.0315788984,
-0.008384347,
0.0695470497,
0.007594665,
-0.0552734062,
0.0344164632,
0.0474667586,
0.0096325818,
0.003566714,
-0.0065833791,
0.0041939714,
0.0030153524,
-0.0053637563,
0.0508653596,
0.0302968826,
0.0179486386,
0.0444276519,
-0.0003759399,
-0.0398765057,
-0.0576213524,
0.0468614064,
-0.0293433089,
-0.0324898101,
0.0095365085,
-0.0074819499,
0.0184311345,
-0.0149357039,
-0.0536420457,
-0.010808425,
0.0378641002,
0.0293220747,
-0.0507390387,
-0.0120251896,
-0.0281755198,
-0.0527374111,
0.0044562812,
-0.0330018587,
-0.0621287972,
-0.0121430997,
0.0204715151,
-0.0330620222,
-0.0161366779,
0.0082286987,
1.971967308e-34,
0.0453768596,
0.0009678864,
0.034490224,
-0.0021730831,
0.0155916987,
-0.0100573953,
-0.0007359963,
0.0209545083,
-0.0330668688,
-0.0586413853,
-0.0274797473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14187v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14187v5 | WaveCoder: Widespread And Versatile Enhancement For Code Large Language Models By Instruction Tuning | 2023-12-20T09:02:29 | 2024-06-07T07:46:28 | Zhaojian Yu, Xin Zhang, Ning Shang, Yangyu Huang, Can Xu, Yishujie Zhao, Wenxiang Hu, Qiufeng Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE | Recent work demonstrates that, after instruction tuning, Code Large Language
Models (Code LLMs) can obtain impressive capabilities to address a wide range
of code-related tasks. However, current instruction tuning methods for Code
LLMs mainly focus on the traditional code generation task, resulting in poor
performance in complex multi-task scenarios. In this paper, we concentrate on
multiple code-related tasks and present WaveCoder, a series of Code LLMs
trained with Widespread And Versatile Enhanced instruction data. To enable the
models to tackle complex code-related tasks, we propose a method to stably
generate diverse, high-quality instruction data from open source code dataset
in multi-task scenarios and obtain CodeSeaXDataset, a dataset comprising 19,915
instruction instances across 4 code-related tasks, which is aimed at improving
the generalization ability of Code LLM. Our experiments demonstrate that
WaveCoder models significantly outperform other open-source models in terms of
the generalization ability across different code-related tasks. Moreover,
WaveCoder-Ultra-6.7B presents the state-of-the-art generalization abilities on
a wide range of code-related tasks. | [
0.0062487721,
0.1151884422,
-0.0020776901,
-0.0003673963,
0.012924864,
0.046795439,
0.0124220066,
0.0044826409,
-0.0244449638,
0.0163640119,
-0.0310876891,
-0.0178798363,
-0.0095040454,
0.0166137423,
0.0406615846,
0.0191569403,
0.0396214277,
-0.0443376116,
-0.058889538,
-0.0028903922,
-0.016219195,
0.0283593256,
0.0189187769,
0.0391455926,
0.0131909475,
-0.025115272,
-0.0091940146,
0.0428129248,
0.0153390905,
-0.0172842648,
0.045376569,
0.0304114111,
0.0505717918,
-0.0092653614,
0.0000019726,
0.0143411364,
-0.0074694934,
-0.027644828,
0.013957792,
0.0449808314,
0.0010293737,
-0.025960777,
-0.0229564477,
0.0280387383,
-0.0140727516,
-0.0164392199,
0.0648324564,
-0.044210095,
0.0749368593,
0.0734957084,
0.0167104788,
-0.0150480941,
-0.0050327568,
-0.0109663019,
0.0333826914,
-0.0023473154,
0.0124381259,
0.011693758,
-0.0107349055,
0.0151064862,
-0.0184778422,
0.0093507189,
0.0465311408,
0.0057468605,
0.0058919485,
0.0374205709,
-0.0280621275,
0.0002726375,
-0.0224707015,
0.0481139198,
-0.0789049566,
-0.0302626453,
0.0169897825,
0.0097566294,
-0.0470860675,
-0.0545965806,
-0.02567867,
0.0355467983,
-0.0102241701,
0.0169973914,
0.0073626381,
-0.0153153148,
0.0144661646,
0.0032999858,
-0.0068668318,
0.0466276817,
0.0179983657,
-0.0207087938,
-0.042347461,
-0.0123001058,
-0.0164415427,
-0.0390224494,
0.0106257116,
0.0753270388,
-0.0367082842,
0.010475901,
-0.0798616633,
-0.0121868309,
0.0076224227,
-0.0502841808,
0.0826805234,
0.0656839833,
-0.0351728611,
0.0021975564,
-0.0662942752,
0.0547731221,
-0.0186450351,
-0.0081834029,
-0.0302540213,
0.0062055355,
-0.0596619509,
0.019637797,
-0.0327560529,
0.0476964898,
-0.0313326195,
0.020278804,
-0.0439044163,
0.0338527858,
0.0214844178,
0.0408234186,
0.0357246362,
0.0053124726,
-0.0478430465,
0.0096761743,
0.0549816042,
-0.0094639258,
-0.0200432036,
-0.0285060219,
-0.0140405521,
-0.040801093,
-0.0139197381,
0.024707213,
-0.0043101856,
-0.033794798,
0.0381298214,
0.0185410362,
-0.0165398289,
0.0187938716,
-0.0515944473,
-0.0213051736,
0.0068109496,
-0.0358108319,
-0.0112123461,
-0.0651963204,
-0.0170123018,
-0.00665928,
0.000071157,
-0.045977179,
0.0280342065,
-0.0054693227,
0.0170861222,
0.029650975,
-0.0401886217,
-0.0132141486,
0.0057362868,
0.0330614336,
0.0172077548,
0.0294745527,
0.0355725177,
0.022401778,
-0.0181399751,
-0.049898956,
0.0221294817,
0.0390688032,
-0.0008605567,
0.0183831174,
0.0208068527,
0.0164473392,
0.0390514545,
-0.0189877488,
0.0885086209,
0.0197094884,
-0.0167428162,
0.0035640509,
0.0163756795,
-0.0029691621,
0.0077455197,
0.0563932173,
0.0885849074,
0.0158958007,
0.0009703495,
-0.0142093534,
-0.0196647625,
0.0386995599,
0.0378386416,
-0.0039237929,
-0.0110195344,
0.0479311682,
-0.038199693,
-0.0370736271,
0.008552758,
-0.0289430991,
-0.0211120062,
0.0099827247,
0.0212408379,
-0.0289322753,
-0.063662529,
0.0438005812,
0.0246989951,
-0.0651664212,
-0.0028268246,
-0.0741316974,
0.0194665119,
0.0503299013,
0.0409067236,
-0.043596521,
-0.0298777297,
-0.0020631542,
0.0206229072,
-0.026196193,
0.0034984013,
-0.0077686394,
0.0381530374,
-0.0770884752,
-0.0364116132,
-0.0394117981,
-0.0110379765,
0.0359002948,
0.0535225347,
-0.0196646452,
0.0354165137,
0.0046705827,
-0.0640663877,
0.0266713519,
0.005721678,
-0.0386066847,
0.0157523081,
-0.0148766432,
0.0172526482,
-0.030580001,
-0.0571635999,
-0.0077811177,
0.0419663563,
-0.02524825,
0.0130154705,
-0.0568091944,
-0.0876082554,
-0.0194386691,
0.0149055459,
-0.0184265114,
0.0139116207,
0.0299086925,
-0.0490748361,
-0.046495121,
0.0357702151,
-0.0341692008,
0.0251149666,
0.0156569239,
0.0333838873,
-0.0254050884,
0.0009636652,
-0.0056590587,
0.0423690937,
0.0023071221,
0.002017674,
0.0231188666,
0.0435196757,
-0.0082302699,
0.0028835773,
0.0016536487,
-0.0195565857,
-0.0287629366,
0.0489818417,
-0.001195344,
0.0481377319,
-0.0153218694,
-0.0527392179,
-0.095254004,
0.0425946862,
-0.0379962362,
0.0229246411,
0.0217492059,
0.0161598437,
0.0180891417,
-0.0219751596,
-0.0295111891,
-0.0006481577,
-0.0299013425,
-0.0164446253,
-0.0169458836,
-0.0219726767,
-0.0499105155,
-0.0326592103,
-0.0203129388,
-0.0063478458,
0.0125169018,
-0.0271631572,
0.0080231577,
-0.1038713083,
0.0614600591,
0.0144955115,
0.0276488159,
-0.0116792321,
-0.0845242962,
0.0159192942,
-0.0142700598,
0.0477487743,
0.0633929148,
-0.0124531938,
-0.004030576,
0.0446985923,
0.0072061452,
-0.0753896758,
0.0288913548,
0.0208970513,
-0.0594852716,
-0.0419479609,
-0.0177026372,
-0.0030704632,
0.0932037607,
0.0199052673,
-0.0035858662,
-0.0469024591,
-0.0120540829,
0.0178865958,
-0.0159848128,
0.0132949566,
-0.0394053645,
-0.0133847231,
-0.0071763997,
-0.0465189666,
-0.0876464918,
0.0363522433,
-0.0215073694,
-0.0068076863,
-0.0277374946,
-0.0400568657,
-0.043822892,
0.0157047976,
-0.0076609012,
0.024947172,
-0.0118604731,
-0.0441016331,
-0.024922194,
0.0175556261,
-0.0465215892,
-0.0186416414,
0.0277233087,
-0.0549847521,
0.0006525151,
-0.0043336921,
-0.0390357301,
-0.0466905087,
0.0354502723,
0.0192246865,
0.0200998392,
0.048284851,
-0.0374592356,
0.0095945252,
0.0109134866,
0.0055907695,
0.0635566413,
0.0104791718,
-0.0191663913,
-0.0425763801,
-0.0161211696,
0.0150865922,
-0.0399764478,
-0.0456556082,
-0.0208489187,
-0.0312616043,
0.0013010314,
0.0484254174,
0.0245881267,
-0.0711847469,
0.0494176932,
0.0541991815,
-0.0082697021,
-0.0195114482,
0.0579492226,
0.1029954255,
-0.0619741045,
-0.0331099741,
0.107709609,
0.0407055132,
-0.0577610321,
0.007564404,
0.0276150983,
0.0312466249,
0.0537242331,
0.027964009,
-0.0625738427,
-0.0175936297,
-0.0139477458,
0.0226421468,
0.0075262669,
0.0029231731,
-0.0148649123,
-0.0633401498,
-0.0003767,
0.0374864079,
0.003258744,
-0.0553312302,
-0.0344409645,
-0.0104028219,
0.0080779064,
0.0053883023,
0.0313557424,
-0.0139151858,
0.0178840887,
0.0420151725,
0.0119067654,
-0.0205303133,
0.0444000438,
-0.042136997,
0.0554195419,
0.1079255864,
-0.0058129975,
0.0357351787,
-0.018790856,
0.034150999,
0.0085881716,
0.0352102891,
-0.0165958572,
0.0217306819,
0.0102730282,
-0.0170662161,
0.0248474851,
0.033292558,
-0.0709868819,
0.0122369118,
0.0335883461,
0.0431895703,
-0.016144434,
-0.0174007956,
-0.0125511009,
-0.0441690013,
0.0079642534,
0.0140597951,
0.0368036218,
-0.0280878432,
-0.0297079626,
-0.0647270307,
-0.0049987151,
-0.0886957347,
0.0044376869,
0.0089162644,
0.00033158,
-0.0060095079,
-0.0225697141,
0.0112786908,
0.0082146311,
0.0396134704,
0.0261802785,
-0.0470653549,
0.0394209176,
-0.0290732887,
-0.0871890634,
-0.0052314177,
-0.033769045,
0.0053948364,
-0.0662461892,
-0.0603593923,
0.0238960199,
-0.0118879108,
-0.0024201742,
-0.0020094279,
-0.0999501273,
-0.0404131562,
-0.0263776984,
0.0834890679,
0.0119566666,
0.0433816798,
-0.0270631053,
-0.0511025079,
-0.0086984169,
-0.0146053517,
-0.0503695905,
0.0214836784,
0.0374441519,
-0.0089038629,
-0.0066036489,
0.0019517574,
-0.0584953837,
0.0386967584,
0.0582717024,
0.0031127452,
-0.0373603702,
-0.0037453275,
0.0138046676,
-0.0260204375,
-0.0183201768,
-0.0044541406,
0.0054226601,
0.0083285347,
0.029122062,
0.0333659314,
0.0120537616,
-0.0566330887,
0.0357757024,
0.0473559834,
-0.0438416228,
0.0144204525,
0.0071662744,
0.0123898778,
0.0315025225,
-0.0586957671,
0.0819724202,
-0.0088400813,
0.0373280123,
0.0892712548,
0.0060583977,
-0.0177666154,
0.0434216447,
0.0178445578,
0.0248004533,
-0.0069714366,
0.0247399341,
-0.0131452596,
0.0509514436,
-0.001552382,
0.0156142134,
-0.0317804031,
-0.0489996634,
-0.0623784661,
-0.0227010325,
0.0593916625,
0.0473558903,
0.037447542,
0.0185810644,
0.0168787558,
-0.0105566261,
0.0501105785,
-0.0197670944,
-0.0267851986,
0.0173751712,
0.030085925,
-0.0161951259,
-0.0348426253,
0.0853036717,
0.007084372,
0.0551713854,
0.0014436009,
0.0056364578,
-0.0440708958,
0.0172939375,
0.0515373498,
-0.0185637251,
-0.0138513753,
0.0213816315,
0.0388453007,
-0.0337561443,
-0.0097787175,
0.012556714,
0.0416324399,
-0.0238573141,
0.0439291187,
0.0589008071,
-0.0517451987,
-0.0297839902,
-0.0143361287,
-0.0268932804,
0.0356659107,
-0.033451464,
-0.0083267866,
-6.185128748e-33,
-0.0212519597,
0.0109189702,
0.0215343498,
-0.0393164605,
-0.0019244604,
0.0124114221,
-0.0375826359,
-0.0524033457,
-0.0047555109,
-0.0508099049,
0.0291090384,
0.0423769765,
0.0107833566,
0.0019574806,
0.0497421958,
0.0238308739,
0.0867728814,
-0.0007551764,
-0.034727592,
0.0631418824,
-0.0249507483,
0.0269504208,
0.039700456,
-0.032015007,
-0.0401008427,
0.0047720117,
0.0255319458,
-0.0186066981,
0.0370413698,
0.0524512008,
-0.0023851325,
0.045661483,
-0.0119766928,
-0.0351072475,
-0.0357226171,
-0.0117330309,
-0.048473265,
-0.0196801722,
0.0090828389,
-0.0006010227,
0.0102238897,
-0.1114428118,
0.0348652005,
0.0282997191,
-0.0376658961,
-0.0279955138,
0.0229314659,
0.0111436471,
0.0099077821,
-0.0632732883,
-0.0543944836,
0.0273945406,
-0.0195469055,
-0.0284808055,
0.0089703314,
-0.0177458078,
-0.0200821664,
0.0026447333,
-0.0452509075,
0.012889361,
0.030135477,
0.109832108,
0.0559091233,
0.0175036751,
0.0103826895,
-0.0031147245,
0.0385751911,
0.0179353487,
0.0027289863,
0.0360069796,
0.0280981623,
0.0518503711,
-0.0125144701,
-0.0174010769,
0.0403478406,
-0.0181458611,
-0.0321981758,
-0.0284101572,
0.0149205495,
0.0113195665,
0.0297840144,
0.0355575904,
-0.0191286113,
0.0013697558,
-0.0326618031,
0.0021879773,
-0.0267374944,
-0.0313991643,
0.0351203308,
0.0370029062,
-0.0303358585,
0.0013490256,
0.0393248275,
-0.0542419069,
0.0194895621,
0.0167361125,
-0.0249043629,
0.021015225,
0.0101033198,
0.0349503495,
-0.0328689888,
-0.0625320971,
0.0558571443,
-0.0267415997,
0.082927987,
0.0115775811,
0.0191027019,
0.0442681275,
-0.0571344607,
-0.0158442464,
-0.0629187897,
0.0022636272,
0.0068988232,
0.0399391316,
-0.0102830306,
0.0135120861,
0.0032541279,
0.0338778868,
-0.0423509665,
-0.038986966,
-0.0333733112,
-0.0197522026,
0.0048857848,
0.0604398623,
-0.0363969207,
-0.0016300966,
-0.0784754679,
0.0229717009,
-0.0165936351,
-0.0404535122,
-0.0626978427,
0.045753859,
2.641e-7,
-0.014100587,
0.0408318751,
0.0083205877,
0.0553113744,
0.0031545409,
-0.0005297307,
-0.0094382018,
0.016540898,
0.0182398539,
-0.029391652,
-0.0104123205,
0.0393049866,
0.0436512195,
0.0158686712,
-0.0304899588,
0.0111690527,
-0.0157806333,
0.023275204,
-0.0595647991,
-0.0052052261,
0.0220297314,
0.1016448289,
-0.0345405899,
0.0050186776,
0.060692586,
0.0265380517,
-0.0071746153,
0.0244946405,
0.0152948657,
0.0374021418,
-0.0931376368,
-0.0008824492,
-0.0381986015,
-0.0148482472,
-0.0162007324,
-0.0107484832,
-0.0082483022,
0.0899591073,
-0.0263220053,
0.0196231827,
0.0543577224,
-0.0154176885,
-0.0050847791,
-0.057126455,
0.0500479192,
-0.0189175699,
0.0336339921,
0.0152352303,
-0.0035789316,
0.0144891357,
-0.0230539516,
-0.0414172225,
0.043326389,
0.014187973,
0.0270755067,
-0.036485754,
-0.0311991535,
-0.0541721135,
-0.0350588858,
0.0170517061,
-0.0055927294,
-0.0632916689,
-0.0592129268,
0.0071726609,
0.0154258683,
-0.0458750129,
0.0230280999,
2.37872394e-34,
0.0200446062,
-0.0313457623,
0.0134241348,
0.0213931408,
0.0434941351,
-0.0356692187,
-0.070384711,
0.0288484786,
0.0087205265,
-0.043396268,
-0.0509957671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12850v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12850v3 | A Stochastic Analysis of the Linguistic Provenance of English Place Names | 2023-12-20T09:01:01 | 2024-01-02T10:01:28 | Michael Dalvean | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | In English place name analysis, meanings are often derived from the
resemblance of roots in place names to topographical features, proper names
and/or habitation terms in one of the languages that have had an influence on
English place names. The problem here is that it is sometimes difficult to
determine the base language to use to interpret the roots. The purpose of this
paper is to stochastically determine the resemblance between 18799 English
place names and 84687 place names from Ireland, Scotland, Wales, Denmark,
Norway, Sweden, France, Germany, the Netherlands and Ancient Rome. Each English
place name is ranked according to the extent to which it resembles place names
from the other countries, and this provides a basis for determining the likely
language to use to interpret the place name. A number of observations can be
made using the ranking provided. In particular, it is found that `Harlington'
is the most archetypically English place name in the English sample, and `Anna'
is the least. Furthermore, it is found that the place names in the non-English
datasets are most similar to Norwegian place names and least similar to Welsh
place names. | [
-0.0006748627,
0.0291586854,
-0.0301246084,
0.0438227542,
-0.0401773006,
0.0093057249,
0.0297095589,
-0.0214011054,
-0.0010589055,
0.0007215319,
0.022536505,
-0.0024657042,
0.0521034896,
-0.0645971745,
0.0347761512,
-0.0335019939,
0.0169184282,
-0.0305674523,
0.0029241904,
-0.0146966167,
-0.0119133051,
-0.0383890942,
0.0033191727,
0.0145099862,
0.037414901,
0.0465293713,
0.013499748,
-0.0315169506,
0.0215311237,
-0.0245284047,
-0.0291052032,
-0.0200274326,
-0.0544289015,
0.0599368289,
0.0000013487,
-0.0395458192,
0.0214162674,
-0.0284292903,
0.0271805059,
-0.0210953187,
-0.0068261754,
0.0884038731,
-0.029427018,
-0.0880681127,
0.0517096557,
-0.0031750239,
0.0849097148,
-0.057995487,
-0.0546754897,
-0.0284094624,
0.0066626393,
-0.0702375099,
-0.0615396611,
-0.0070177629,
0.065378733,
0.0177119859,
0.0363435596,
0.0679489002,
-0.0008959814,
0.0323455743,
-0.030824922,
0.0156645272,
-0.0516019166,
0.0155496662,
-0.0809482932,
0.0360334702,
-0.0419079885,
0.0369760469,
0.041502364,
0.0236013215,
0.0146019319,
-0.0327492245,
-0.0011781201,
0.0167547315,
-0.011802312,
0.0741954967,
0.010097919,
-0.0445380099,
-0.035563793,
0.0040897969,
0.0679757446,
-0.0014977573,
0.0118434625,
0.0314769074,
-0.0315146558,
0.0907522067,
0.0418837667,
-0.0027046802,
-0.0300408509,
0.0037990336,
-0.0042435676,
-0.037438184,
-0.0347642191,
0.0355793908,
-0.0041805464,
0.0074493107,
0.0202762801,
0.0565686114,
-0.0033863101,
-0.0345736556,
0.0115960296,
-0.009642479,
-0.0375925601,
0.0584121794,
-0.0262097642,
0.0431807786,
-0.0036243848,
-0.0493717417,
-0.0064578112,
0.010757898,
-0.0596432574,
0.0169092156,
-0.0153785916,
-0.0457525402,
-0.0212515295,
0.0325787738,
-0.0057163546,
-0.0226146337,
0.0042398609,
-0.013198955,
-0.0127824601,
-0.0176506303,
0.0103721246,
-0.0080988724,
-0.0477920175,
-0.0197087526,
-0.0552126616,
0.0331906565,
-0.0754291564,
-0.0040199691,
0.0390039198,
0.0331903808,
0.0226942319,
-0.0153835798,
0.0245342385,
0.0081916032,
0.0113239028,
0.0154570853,
-0.0348683335,
0.0090345843,
-0.0010106716,
-0.0168989412,
0.0231900662,
-0.0585830733,
0.0052616159,
-0.0050880052,
-0.0223563351,
-0.0495299771,
-0.0042120954,
0.0125296526,
-0.0852058381,
0.0021060391,
-0.0496359169,
0.0178111866,
0.0271928683,
-0.033428926,
-0.0147973346,
-0.0251666345,
0.0164557118,
0.0234076288,
0.0395622812,
-0.0046239286,
0.0327998772,
-0.0089170979,
0.0015776809,
-0.0142500047,
-0.0195830259,
0.0180468429,
-0.0063572577,
-0.0206836089,
0.0348022282,
0.0174103361,
0.0094732251,
-0.0177467857,
0.019017566,
0.0626624078,
0.0503779687,
0.0084319329,
0.0266478118,
0.0140936859,
-0.0423289314,
-0.0384998098,
-0.0235480443,
-0.0458185524,
0.0146988677,
0.0243269764,
-0.0212378837,
0.0190005638,
0.0450744182,
0.0107425917,
-0.0095211854,
0.0171121638,
0.0264989994,
0.0133956457,
0.0302796997,
-0.0661166459,
-0.0367151909,
0.0155553482,
-0.0249830671,
0.0401267707,
0.0348485112,
0.030184688,
0.0303936414,
0.0314955786,
-0.006786746,
0.0169851873,
0.0572609715,
0.030255165,
-0.0120005235,
-0.005644483,
-0.0483554192,
-0.0168317296,
0.0323193185,
-0.0257911198,
-0.011988109,
0.0478942208,
-0.0227433741,
0.0594375096,
-0.0171115045,
0.0660813823,
0.010744933,
-0.0375388823,
-0.0364412479,
-0.0231081396,
0.0027617698,
-0.0193586405,
-0.0373180173,
-0.0105321361,
-0.0484049246,
0.0147476047,
-0.0335297398,
0.0346347727,
-0.024051737,
-0.0340144001,
0.033941213,
0.0564212613,
0.0290159862,
0.0404689237,
0.0363700725,
-0.0486165509,
0.0467366427,
-0.0787551701,
0.0143385129,
-0.005534396,
0.0043040626,
-0.0617152788,
0.0609008074,
0.0535261296,
0.0316050202,
-0.0367977396,
0.0072725336,
-0.0536539517,
0.1029521599,
-0.0302672815,
0.0783804357,
-0.0347365402,
-0.0219053403,
0.0122426283,
-0.0464867316,
-0.0234345533,
-0.0713585913,
0.0081961798,
-0.0128983408,
0.025123775,
-0.0106862457,
0.00468974,
0.0047829081,
-0.0172543377,
-0.0258157626,
-0.0060389638,
0.0395074002,
-0.0423491634,
0.0056549078,
-0.0075861011,
0.0082807122,
0.032152418,
-0.0099321976,
-0.0337219164,
0.0504947267,
0.0217293128,
-0.0876525268,
-0.0240876544,
0.005016543,
-0.0262340903,
0.0317577496,
0.0559119508,
0.0105017293,
-0.0189891364,
-0.0636741593,
-0.000659802,
-0.0468347594,
-0.00431401,
-0.0262501873,
-0.0116605442,
0.0108204177,
0.0041575134,
0.0405070446,
-0.0639944226,
-0.0312175229,
-0.083206363,
-0.0114066079,
-0.0260245409,
0.0079449201,
-0.0230436791,
-0.048415821,
0.0571429729,
0.0050788177,
-0.0653757304,
-0.0160252955,
0.0026921784,
-0.009854842,
0.0158532895,
-0.0176322628,
0.0375161134,
-0.0402592905,
-0.0072457385,
-0.0604835451,
-0.0224291645,
-0.0093803033,
0.1284620911,
-0.035945978,
-0.045843035,
-0.0216300804,
-0.0235372465,
0.0192184187,
-0.0024088244,
-0.0047875661,
-0.0050963238,
0.0588499568,
0.024584882,
0.0318913758,
-0.009681507,
-0.0303053763,
0.022855673,
-0.0635438114,
0.0438112132,
-0.0248531979,
-0.0035858345,
0.0014679024,
-0.0060994844,
0.0528033935,
0.0029579974,
0.0197810233,
-0.0179375652,
-0.0322879925,
-0.0495933555,
0.0199556798,
-0.0243976936,
0.0673714131,
0.0848291665,
-0.0071658026,
-0.02554393,
0.0442957953,
0.0344481021,
-0.0287622903,
0.0569896735,
0.0167252906,
0.0791585371,
0.0034412257,
0.0696205273,
-0.0555533543,
-0.0375033394,
-0.039234139,
0.0291976798,
0.0513846092,
0.0271659307,
-0.0217352509,
-0.0549716018,
-0.0322138816,
0.0073286286,
0.0049187746,
0.0183576643,
-0.0197395254,
0.0243527573,
0.0293105002,
0.0250346456,
0.014074632,
-0.0272915009,
0.0124873053,
0.0605982244,
-0.0296249073,
-0.0019590422,
0.0708753243,
-0.0300927758,
-0.027430404,
-0.0102199484,
-0.0574294366,
-0.0117758373,
-0.0620617494,
-0.0087973578,
-0.0218295399,
-0.1166956425,
-0.0223048367,
-0.0221252255,
-0.0138207972,
-0.0199008863,
-0.0772234499,
0.006826384,
0.0190241784,
0.0085508907,
0.0103654899,
-0.0615402907,
-0.0055481358,
0.0075321216,
-0.0837993249,
0.0291351285,
0.0021256218,
0.0822325423,
-0.0480420478,
-0.0564975552,
-0.0362629071,
0.0102199521,
0.0240678936,
-0.0131167928,
-0.0001240607,
0.0983076841,
0.0026727216,
-0.04608595,
-0.0529747419,
0.0062960587,
-0.0326592177,
0.0200635549,
0.0085255103,
0.0222497974,
0.0340008773,
0.0004719091,
0.0681353062,
0.0552599542,
0.0265222024,
0.0082267262,
0.0293416325,
-0.0263869818,
-0.0174666438,
0.0082818381,
0.0533869751,
-0.0173092373,
0.0252803583,
-0.0244850665,
-0.0360778458,
-0.0562653169,
-0.004455273,
-0.025474932,
0.0878041014,
0.0290078875,
-0.0129693635,
0.0213882048,
-0.0357713141,
-0.0446404181,
0.0550543368,
0.029600637,
0.0003139572,
-0.0209729392,
0.0453840047,
0.1156404093,
-0.0324599631,
-0.0132807055,
-0.0264128558,
-0.0062307888,
-0.0550943799,
0.0353499465,
0.0425727852,
0.0299314409,
0.0396223292,
-0.0020293447,
0.0081495801,
-0.0030744034,
-0.0605624765,
0.047624208,
-0.038344156,
-0.0086475434,
0.0178804994,
0.0185930859,
-0.0177694615,
-0.007823131,
0.0307251234,
0.0105030583,
0.0111736506,
-0.025147019,
0.0134740211,
-0.0284686945,
0.0175522305,
0.0544480309,
-0.0463700965,
0.0075060297,
0.0255011395,
-0.0293502714,
0.0222317986,
0.0147495382,
0.0502378382,
-0.0032732175,
0.0091392901,
-0.0077643115,
-0.0358036123,
-0.0140082389,
-0.004675183,
0.0006676891,
0.0013369424,
-0.0224077776,
0.0304522403,
0.0561147779,
0.0220807269,
0.0123115461,
0.0214592703,
0.0621497445,
-0.0254347436,
0.0941987336,
-0.033503782,
-0.0453865714,
0.0059601949,
-0.0121099232,
-0.0332705826,
-0.0071108146,
-0.0123294303,
-0.0350832976,
-0.0178026911,
-0.027807897,
0.0294084158,
-0.0041194391,
0.041201584,
0.0181732848,
-0.0119504798,
0.0230388064,
-0.0137472851,
0.0069823517,
-0.0204893108,
-0.015616457,
-0.0093243802,
-0.0169501845,
0.0380554236,
-0.0534808077,
0.0225084405,
-0.0110478317,
0.0006051877,
-0.0657310709,
0.0170160197,
-0.0122459717,
-0.0347930118,
-0.0120637743,
-0.0337755531,
0.0118552875,
-0.0622334853,
-0.0578968152,
-0.0106505062,
0.0046014506,
0.0134835588,
0.0001027893,
0.017528208,
0.0262599196,
0.0336926654,
0.0426335782,
-0.0309236962,
0.0340079106,
-0.0146276196,
-0.0434031934,
-0.0518737957,
-4.715713789e-33,
0.0287988968,
-0.03745557,
0.0456272922,
-0.0292911641,
0.0105848862,
-0.0363980755,
-0.0187128019,
0.0431135073,
-0.0644866526,
0.0088738054,
0.0252192747,
-0.0382452458,
0.0035819924,
0.0011871819,
-0.0105864881,
0.0353780389,
-0.0916471183,
0.0221864115,
-0.0047308151,
-0.0358469151,
0.073889181,
-0.0272173844,
0.0519782156,
-0.0567198135,
0.0499219298,
0.0098924069,
-0.0168495718,
0.0142439129,
0.0610411167,
-0.003546156,
-0.01131,
-0.0133501021,
0.0299397986,
-0.0302875396,
0.0182468072,
-0.0384730473,
-0.0147811668,
-0.0667170882,
0.0287644323,
0.0042396095,
0.0937648192,
-0.0137381898,
0.0243990757,
0.0308462027,
-0.068405211,
0.0633778721,
0.0168310646,
0.0293853376,
-0.0825657919,
-0.0027851292,
-0.0532112382,
-0.0074544344,
0.0036483093,
0.0193089247,
0.0386869982,
-0.0036638437,
0.0340730585,
-0.0133828428,
-0.0276392419,
0.0322705023,
-0.0000767832,
0.0112439124,
0.0343642756,
0.0224136822,
0.0052999891,
0.0024136188,
0.0277691931,
0.0060946234,
-0.0097829299,
0.0518302806,
0.0356889777,
0.034384273,
0.0164679773,
0.0442775488,
0.0287078898,
0.0072007454,
0.0277893227,
0.0122104567,
0.0130104227,
-0.0357808024,
0.0030276133,
-0.0043169227,
-0.0188282412,
0.0009525944,
-0.0230644289,
-0.0299235657,
0.0156220067,
-0.0006531077,
0.0008645988,
-0.0524764508,
0.0118596628,
0.0438842103,
-0.002561505,
-0.0454392731,
-0.0992441475,
-0.0193137508,
0.0049149403,
0.016676208,
-0.0345963836,
0.0269594193,
0.0427746102,
-0.0479870066,
-0.0220336262,
0.0611708649,
0.0011719553,
0.0174243283,
-0.0714697316,
-0.002975964,
-0.0451684222,
0.0196901225,
0.0022657595,
-0.0330892503,
-0.0123311533,
-0.044972159,
0.044241447,
-0.0632519647,
0.0097857472,
-0.006884275,
0.1154780388,
-0.0237509105,
0.0748677775,
0.0014065444,
0.0540302917,
0.0268188398,
0.0043536965,
0.0217344146,
0.0028646758,
0.0041063279,
0.0334569179,
0.0314481556,
0.008631696,
0.0276601315,
2.29e-7,
0.039224714,
0.0372863337,
0.02088679,
-0.0029971339,
0.0127887521,
-0.0323701277,
0.0123608271,
-0.028151622,
-0.034537755,
0.0163210928,
0.007226509,
-0.0461304449,
0.0271942858,
0.0217223223,
-0.0298701636,
0.0138741164,
-0.0731657818,
-0.0244523976,
-0.0548290908,
-0.0195787344,
-0.0116771441,
0.062590763,
0.0152397957,
-0.0458020456,
-0.0134315332,
0.0029665832,
-0.0247636847,
-0.0734581128,
0.0056128735,
0.0211609956,
-0.0101999491,
-0.0278696436,
0.0200361349,
-0.0437185541,
0.0165116657,
0.0075735524,
0.0344722494,
-0.0843672901,
-0.0130944755,
0.0608833209,
0.0040134303,
-0.1125853509,
0.039535474,
-0.0417562351,
-0.000716636,
0.0552804098,
-0.0221485086,
0.0134945288,
-0.0295260139,
0.0719657615,
0.0537391901,
-0.002196871,
-0.002052932,
-0.0147650307,
0.0447954759,
0.0380650982,
-0.0078255869,
-0.0489739478,
0.0204411391,
0.026402466,
-0.0186440982,
0.0057102256,
0.0253790412,
-0.0000903588,
0.0164662208,
-0.0245945416,
-0.0241027363,
1.511217259e-34,
-0.0093173226,
-0.0308905672,
-0.0342663713,
0.0354062766,
0.0237657651,
0.0431214049,
0.0480577089,
0.0200208146,
0.0067443303,
0.0000160151,
-0.0001436496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12832v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12832v1 | Turning Dust into Gold: Distilling Complex Reasoning Capabilities from LLMs by Leveraging Negative Data | 2023-12-20T08:28:36 | 2023-12-20T08:28:36 | Yiwei Li, Peiwen Yuan, Shaoxiong Feng, Boyuan Pan, Bin Sun, Xinglin Wang, Heda Wang, Kan Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have performed well on various reasoning tasks,
but their inaccessibility and numerous parameters hinder wide application in
practice. One promising way is distilling the reasoning ability from LLMs to
small models by the generated chain-of-thought reasoning paths. In some cases,
however, LLMs may produce incorrect reasoning chains, especially when facing
complex mathematical problems. Previous studies only transfer knowledge from
positive samples and drop the synthesized data with wrong answers. In this
work, we illustrate the merit of negative data and propose a model
specialization framework to distill LLMs with negative samples besides positive
ones. The framework consists of three progressive steps, covering from training
to inference stages, to absorb knowledge from negative data. We conduct
extensive experiments across arithmetic reasoning tasks to demonstrate the role
of negative data in distillation from LLM. | [
-0.0110207461,
0.074571237,
-0.0223981477,
0.0485642366,
-0.0542990975,
0.0123367021,
-0.0301176216,
-0.0079595549,
-0.0448214486,
-0.023963159,
-0.0397912562,
-0.011053198,
-0.0027177564,
0.0130567681,
0.0492145903,
-0.0263702236,
0.0162108876,
-0.0685741231,
0.0007040219,
-0.0049095997,
-0.0281666145,
-0.0259050746,
-0.0260062069,
-0.0382395312,
0.0095191533,
-0.0144481212,
-0.0096332403,
-0.0162100382,
0.0252129771,
-0.0308675729,
-0.03763742,
0.0161509998,
0.0317142643,
0.0406082943,
0.0000018733,
-0.0482533202,
-0.0024286546,
0.0010486275,
-0.0805746689,
-0.0111246835,
0.0038613561,
-0.0190395266,
0.0110143777,
0.0291104764,
-0.0460015573,
0.021915853,
0.002904804,
0.0309104975,
0.0656213835,
0.0718827099,
0.0122769205,
-0.0305595808,
0.0239560716,
-0.0262936726,
0.0363769867,
-0.0200548805,
0.0178837311,
0.0500553325,
0.0578122102,
0.0063315406,
-0.029707104,
0.0347250588,
0.0644534975,
0.0375260636,
-0.0290799681,
0.035649281,
-0.0246572345,
0.0190801211,
0.0278215576,
0.0691322461,
0.0059062866,
-0.0350346602,
-0.0416438282,
-0.0249202941,
0.005704816,
-0.0124757998,
-0.0681761727,
0.0544372536,
0.0178718604,
0.0347542576,
-0.012600176,
-0.0246690456,
0.0423686281,
0.0107827252,
-0.0466936976,
0.1048318595,
-0.0033622694,
-0.0685633942,
0.0440710858,
0.0008398198,
-0.0499577299,
-0.0029918721,
0.005453622,
0.0470812693,
0.0445084386,
0.0390919521,
0.0151129346,
-0.0219056923,
-0.0110012181,
-0.0164555367,
0.0086221471,
0.0503950194,
0.0182765443,
0.0310413763,
-0.0684371591,
-0.0013628857,
-0.0205984022,
0.0451779328,
-0.0370120592,
0.0000388611,
-0.0357396901,
-0.0256065093,
-0.0183656756,
0.0667565688,
-0.0070908219,
0.028832132,
-0.0134907579,
-0.0101845525,
-0.075280048,
-0.0074641104,
0.0065122596,
-0.0095285159,
0.0338682905,
-0.0537091456,
-0.0501827076,
0.0287490692,
-0.0380163193,
0.054396905,
0.0030408748,
-0.0153605174,
-0.0200802423,
-0.0113136638,
-0.0052314461,
0.0135710593,
0.0284444522,
0.0742685124,
-0.0214147605,
0.0212773569,
-0.0694747865,
-0.0207154993,
0.0382806361,
-0.0783011839,
0.0221911389,
-0.0723017529,
-0.0040959283,
0.0393139236,
-0.0027809283,
-0.0462547466,
0.0148219811,
0.0000063932,
-0.02619485,
0.0649347007,
0.0092379879,
0.0165601168,
0.0158793125,
0.0148930764,
-0.0449931361,
0.0537004136,
0.0367230512,
-0.029134389,
-0.0068831034,
0.0133489491,
0.0390233994,
0.0126599278,
0.0583217554,
-0.0004708819,
-0.0566703975,
0.0095517049,
-0.0648881048,
0.0106758568,
0.0091180336,
0.0232847892,
-0.0459578261,
-0.0115739489,
0.033909075,
0.0407351814,
-0.0383025035,
-0.0028739809,
0.0362180956,
-0.0204149131,
0.0043285512,
-0.0122308321,
-0.0850791484,
0.0136252837,
-0.0608394258,
0.0113986041,
-0.0142605808,
-0.0357384868,
-0.0333339088,
-0.055850625,
-0.0129511254,
-0.0218714215,
0.0319354311,
0.0058473288,
0.0953480005,
-0.0243589915,
-0.0175385233,
0.0416887812,
0.0237762928,
-0.0615251698,
0.0004454963,
-0.0396420844,
0.0601944812,
0.0057652993,
0.0319225825,
-0.0502826497,
-0.0417247228,
-0.0034718416,
-0.0205939226,
0.0125734871,
0.0274910256,
-0.0001857217,
-0.0125166681,
-0.0273822583,
-0.0240043551,
0.0137401577,
0.0202169437,
-0.0138953514,
0.0155597217,
-0.0163458996,
0.0403790623,
-0.0604680553,
0.0043157684,
0.0117653729,
-0.0775203258,
-0.008205615,
-0.0178236812,
0.0067207264,
0.0213007927,
-0.0082889143,
0.0257770158,
0.0434446633,
0.0295542311,
-0.0325633176,
-0.0759391934,
-0.0106017096,
-0.0679237247,
-0.0360988788,
0.0275323391,
-0.0619993769,
0.0135188699,
0.0577131361,
-0.0508554392,
-0.0386373363,
0.086997278,
-0.0183220301,
0.0180723704,
0.0087214606,
0.0474022366,
0.0247399136,
-0.013024617,
-0.0092522269,
0.0757979378,
-0.0450944528,
0.0291201659,
-0.0046117394,
-0.0133883571,
0.0046602497,
-0.0117411809,
-0.0001186402,
-0.0404775999,
-0.010721731,
0.0065168827,
0.0118640698,
-0.0137786949,
-0.05568178,
0.016160639,
-0.0345641859,
0.0113203526,
0.0030408732,
0.050012596,
0.0359464623,
-0.0363881178,
0.0017808458,
-0.0180216767,
-0.0352950804,
0.0157056712,
0.0264922865,
-0.0021435367,
0.0215637852,
-0.0015562833,
-0.0025502071,
-0.0229360498,
-0.0179517213,
-0.0405258462,
0.0281670354,
-0.0427891836,
0.0230234601,
-0.0498153418,
0.0466419831,
-0.0420605652,
0.0396734104,
-0.0076807821,
-0.0078164609,
0.0325642042,
-0.0314421505,
0.0167161971,
0.0633276924,
-0.0610003285,
-0.0229302496,
0.0323406123,
0.0011226655,
-0.0556157939,
0.0041862912,
-0.0155446678,
0.0126277106,
-0.0159107596,
-0.0329376683,
-0.0499032997,
0.0708417147,
-0.0340508334,
-0.0230938885,
-0.0518026911,
0.0329186656,
-0.0260167904,
-0.0122968853,
0.0034411664,
0.001301469,
0.0074096732,
0.0486931205,
-0.0333178081,
-0.0444897301,
0.0530700162,
0.0029315571,
-0.0183172021,
-0.0127688739,
0.0290565155,
-0.029123405,
0.071423769,
0.0118100811,
-0.0270863045,
-0.0086356681,
0.0409361944,
-0.0784244537,
-0.0333306305,
0.0290354043,
-0.0303959232,
0.0595391802,
-0.0990102589,
0.0007077968,
-0.0147250947,
-0.053160239,
-0.0707738027,
0.0111656608,
-0.0084029157,
0.0464155041,
-0.0346017294,
-0.0050336276,
-0.0357321166,
-0.0227751024,
0.0138555942,
0.025441926,
-0.0198794454,
-0.021494206,
-0.0140341362,
0.0081077702,
0.0176294129,
0.008785381,
0.0853290036,
-0.0469260924,
0.0359609723,
0.0335568041,
0.0673555136,
0.0037467114,
0.0091626979,
0.0110763004,
0.029548645,
-0.0027632918,
-0.0329544693,
0.0424136445,
0.0302457083,
-0.0474183597,
-0.0420235209,
0.10424494,
0.0466079377,
0.0068293419,
0.0120348521,
-0.0618470646,
0.0197989829,
0.0475487076,
-0.0108371545,
-0.0565769412,
-0.0305966809,
0.0131804207,
0.0207628608,
-0.0084671164,
-0.054596629,
-0.0007101219,
-0.174572289,
0.001700602,
0.0500317886,
-0.0041932142,
-0.0393454768,
-0.0186265856,
0.0154431593,
-0.022588456,
-0.0333688781,
0.0517911538,
0.0092655122,
0.0236401204,
0.019649813,
0.0032685969,
-0.0464309342,
0.0227847546,
-0.0144437607,
0.0433461741,
0.0000115576,
0.0000664318,
-0.0176290646,
-0.0618671626,
0.0433245637,
0.0049146535,
-0.0226239543,
-0.0300564915,
0.0325096287,
0.0502725244,
0.0119344871,
-0.0044156723,
0.0656602532,
-0.0644786209,
-0.0331647731,
0.0203062166,
0.1323553175,
-0.017868802,
-0.0330964364,
-0.0038497178,
-0.0000423311,
-0.0301231164,
0.0892132372,
0.0026347023,
-0.0150855966,
-0.0171447191,
-0.0130697405,
-0.0407234468,
-0.0095441286,
-0.0078349449,
0.0116502624,
0.037839625,
0.0038625789,
-0.0569307357,
-0.0425691158,
0.0300550833,
0.0572344698,
0.0071560238,
-0.0021810185,
0.0264139604,
-0.0065906313,
-0.0336182341,
0.0084613115,
-0.0573398732,
0.0252158996,
-0.0240366198,
0.0005863286,
0.0139358575,
-0.0267222542,
-0.0241527818,
-0.0065064798,
-0.1232153624,
-0.0608284734,
-0.0078240614,
0.0670301691,
0.0359387361,
0.0382805839,
0.0116861053,
-0.0308155231,
0.0296465922,
0.0130728241,
-0.0552967824,
0.0033473519,
0.0717653632,
-0.0107546011,
0.0345235988,
0.0366338231,
-0.0078459438,
0.0384715758,
0.0640792325,
0.0522329658,
-0.0680481717,
0.0324934348,
0.0284904335,
0.0268266294,
0.0280283522,
0.0205577929,
-0.0014716065,
-0.0063026287,
0.0368157551,
-0.0344574265,
-0.0126853148,
-0.0435575098,
-0.0019728791,
0.0398309156,
0.0119048683,
-0.0012612795,
-0.047458332,
0.0065718014,
0.0502277799,
0.0120906336,
0.0096488995,
0.0510913953,
0.0422250666,
0.031039102,
-0.0371520221,
0.0158370417,
-0.011009993,
-0.0178461038,
0.0326574892,
-0.0324184261,
0.0729604512,
0.0100217424,
0.0279399399,
-0.0484711342,
-0.0199873596,
-0.0555948094,
-0.0354055837,
0.0264839511,
0.0296241418,
0.022875132,
0.0234188586,
0.0070450143,
-0.0347375534,
0.0133033283,
-0.0017711183,
0.0067303786,
-0.0112495488,
0.0065218601,
0.0392889455,
0.0385169014,
0.0156030208,
-0.0365216658,
0.0426031873,
-0.0448139831,
0.046264831,
-0.0527379513,
0.0017408839,
-0.0121110361,
-0.0441177487,
0.0030362785,
-0.0136477062,
0.0101301158,
0.0602038279,
-0.0750158653,
-0.1030271277,
-0.0369288884,
0.0285577457,
0.0061420784,
-0.0017436192,
0.0177448783,
0.0482854135,
-0.0509799607,
-0.025094904,
-0.0001821746,
0.0323682912,
-0.0065471758,
-0.0145509997,
-0.0467474461,
-5.980997542e-33,
-0.0207740869,
0.0017124703,
0.0461436734,
0.0054245568,
-0.0114315636,
-0.028860515,
-0.0102822669,
0.0282131918,
-0.0032839908,
0.0230033491,
-0.0040142955,
0.0070459065,
-0.0051523922,
0.0454200022,
-0.0029336,
-0.0271398295,
0.0233181436,
0.0185562782,
-0.019298939,
-0.0074341912,
0.0422327779,
0.0111784786,
0.0784395263,
-0.073870495,
0.0139921289,
-0.0343441963,
0.0145095345,
0.0485577621,
-0.044630114,
0.0274914633,
0.0109230895,
0.0127181066,
0.0267529357,
-0.062364012,
-0.0153948963,
-0.0306366645,
-0.0604851507,
-0.0520290993,
0.0499733388,
0.0013792217,
-0.0247495864,
0.004288658,
0.0638456121,
0.0102580274,
-0.0082332613,
0.0138820764,
-0.0004473417,
-0.0434289053,
0.0194831844,
0.0268256217,
-0.0756393895,
0.0132861361,
0.0015098023,
-0.021943802,
0.0183597021,
0.0307877362,
-0.0496024564,
-0.0057978961,
-0.0207517557,
0.0014406826,
0.0488890707,
0.0158345681,
0.0540817343,
0.02455578,
-0.0049607446,
0.0297661722,
0.0157453567,
-0.0224895887,
-0.0087976912,
-0.0370594338,
0.0223204624,
0.0357719027,
0.0573503338,
0.0152330892,
0.042695865,
0.0086487038,
-0.066335015,
-0.0097668832,
-0.0128730033,
0.0485230871,
0.007260758,
0.0036222429,
-0.0211615805,
-0.011351035,
-0.0547632016,
-0.0079933675,
-0.0217085909,
0.0022186923,
0.0344624482,
0.0016524068,
-0.029249344,
0.0195635688,
0.0218128376,
-0.0256631486,
-0.0169171579,
0.0440259315,
0.0049732435,
0.0118541829,
0.0069720196,
-0.0002855226,
-0.0819739401,
-0.0174395666,
0.0082237618,
0.004584969,
0.0111928601,
-0.0046916907,
0.0659199879,
0.0214367136,
-0.0551178604,
-0.0315959081,
-0.0637931377,
0.02388235,
0.0318531692,
0.0296611711,
0.044606667,
0.0455995798,
-0.0173490718,
0.0036292104,
0.0121048763,
-0.0433279425,
-0.0274021104,
0.0571985655,
-0.0180196092,
0.014482284,
-0.0261033252,
-0.0343647934,
-0.0123921018,
-0.0146031212,
0.0385282002,
-0.0792351291,
-0.0150517663,
0.0161662698,
2.605e-7,
0.034960404,
0.0055300035,
0.0019308659,
0.0456490479,
0.0383291952,
0.0576841645,
-0.0694616884,
-0.0472631305,
0.0469339639,
-0.0132984808,
0.0207247064,
0.0499563813,
0.0207139682,
0.0447769016,
-0.0274403524,
0.0125457495,
0.0002876236,
-0.033592917,
0.0186610091,
0.0167326927,
0.0636510625,
0.0790880397,
0.04980525,
-0.0192974526,
-0.0046936893,
-0.0209728237,
0.0464997478,
-0.0218663998,
0.0166950319,
-0.0076763905,
0.013932935,
-0.0250657797,
0.0103548318,
0.0673956051,
0.0247191247,
0.0059398771,
-0.0292730108,
0.0540060662,
-0.0126348473,
-0.00276727,
-0.0346574597,
-0.0457152091,
0.0135495178,
-0.0176568478,
0.0771303996,
-0.0765065849,
-0.0229669996,
-0.024257157,
-0.0226840712,
0.0172935855,
0.0009288703,
-0.0035315806,
0.0256507508,
-0.0076600481,
0.0205106847,
0.0019225063,
-0.0085814875,
-0.0506352857,
-0.0333571918,
0.0198885743,
-0.0260745361,
-0.0537759624,
-0.0373434201,
0.0138534186,
0.0057423799,
-0.055344414,
0.0014386172,
2.240223614e-34,
0.0378727578,
-0.0020986833,
0.007559495,
0.0167520102,
0.0109187132,
-0.0184576083,
-0.0073000784,
0.0219166745,
0.0391278602,
-0.0393697135,
0.0047163763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12815v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12815v1 | OCTOPUS: Open-vocabulary Content Tracking and Object Placement Using Semantic Understanding in Mixed Reality | 2023-12-20T07:34:20 | 2023-12-20T07:34:20 | Luke Yoffe, Aditya Sharma, Tobias Höllerer | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | One key challenge in augmented reality is the placement of virtual content in
natural locations. Existing automated techniques are only able to work with a
closed-vocabulary, fixed set of objects. In this paper, we introduce a new
open-vocabulary method for object placement. Our eight-stage pipeline leverages
recent advances in segmentation models, vision-language models, and LLMs to
place any virtual object in any AR camera frame or scene. In a preliminary user
study, we show that our method performs at least as well as human experts 57%
of the time. | [
0.016034022,
0.0127199134,
0.0367780365,
0.0266444664,
0.0060438234,
0.003418745,
0.0039634528,
0.0294107981,
0.0089444946,
-0.0910083055,
-0.001695451,
0.0058915694,
0.0200913996,
0.0122871362,
-0.0180500466,
-0.0418321565,
-0.0318902992,
-0.026118461,
-0.091168277,
0.014660947,
0.0012094723,
0.0108647496,
-0.0244866144,
0.0039667976,
-0.0002528959,
0.0000825104,
-0.0383863561,
0.0465034358,
0.0343123041,
-0.0445465073,
-0.0467265286,
-0.0150868846,
0.0534806624,
0.013796594,
0.0000019822,
-0.0529519059,
-0.0326065011,
0.0070605585,
0.0116071235,
-0.0176334046,
-0.0125832437,
0.0008030693,
0.0115653137,
-0.0071068015,
0.0229574461,
-0.0124999676,
0.0636892915,
-0.0056353947,
0.0246748794,
-0.0160124637,
0.0024652865,
-0.025231814,
0.0274310503,
0.0205743238,
0.0469262004,
0.0062010861,
0.0072027813,
0.0336472727,
0.0268869512,
0.0049468987,
0.0100679565,
0.0510102585,
-0.0263239872,
0.029322803,
0.0417996049,
0.014275915,
0.0118621411,
-0.0278109089,
-0.0094271759,
0.0205891263,
-0.0438781157,
-0.0137881013,
0.0318079703,
-0.0106997481,
-0.0428078361,
0.0417420268,
-0.0583277009,
0.0673062205,
-0.0341435187,
-0.0225039106,
-0.051123783,
0.0078896135,
-0.0064889416,
-0.001480798,
-0.028959401,
0.0359963663,
0.0347311981,
0.0075280545,
-0.042676311,
0.0039898627,
-0.0233477298,
-0.0438371785,
0.0161330756,
0.0120325964,
-0.0060754744,
0.0538986512,
-0.0262415875,
-0.0051221866,
-0.0012181952,
-0.0409855135,
0.0255255327,
0.0312372129,
-0.0450288691,
0.0900062844,
-0.035564065,
0.0576974228,
-0.0523361303,
0.0366225913,
-0.0300463457,
0.0249081552,
0.0271615423,
0.020524282,
0.0166603308,
0.0005920837,
-0.0591754913,
-0.0335388556,
-0.0000737988,
0.0257876273,
0.0002670816,
0.0033257313,
0.0213857703,
0.0353685953,
-0.0344714336,
-0.012680239,
-0.0137020024,
-0.0081476774,
0.0305213053,
0.013306207,
-0.0228286255,
-0.0309864841,
0.0218876395,
0.0448615067,
0.0644247681,
0.0267978534,
-0.0441447534,
0.0777035579,
0.0251113269,
-0.0468129739,
0.0052187811,
-0.0046479208,
-0.0079953484,
0.01062713,
0.0502451472,
-0.0120750368,
-0.0000960623,
-0.0306945685,
0.0158434007,
0.0077127619,
0.0250955131,
0.0487411506,
-0.0277081653,
0.0794763267,
-0.0738443881,
0.0244721361,
0.0346072987,
0.0119436169,
0.0740576908,
0.0145472568,
0.0256113764,
0.0465953983,
0.0308386832,
-0.0038865882,
0.0251213834,
0.0366277508,
-0.057935141,
-0.0495081767,
-0.0469867736,
-0.0002570069,
0.0012966099,
0.0830003917,
-0.0647246167,
-0.0129990419,
0.0023357098,
-0.0174678247,
0.0107217366,
0.0405313261,
-0.0099833617,
-0.0483126305,
0.0152734052,
-0.0065318458,
-0.0187513195,
-0.0571424551,
-0.0424034148,
0.066901505,
0.0068508615,
0.0131548801,
-0.0019161098,
-0.0015052011,
0.0039397748,
-0.0175679158,
-0.0479691587,
-0.0135795008,
0.0315851606,
-0.0204373449,
0.0309964474,
-0.0190902185,
-0.0575960837,
0.0331754237,
-0.0320026949,
-0.0315847844,
-0.0038045675,
-0.0174171701,
0.04612571,
0.0425701924,
0.0311178565,
-0.0399125516,
-0.0712822527,
-0.0119070644,
0.0513110608,
0.0676858798,
-0.0196757149,
-0.0058232895,
-0.0240716189,
-0.0401514955,
-0.0118863368,
-0.0091362363,
-0.0323736779,
0.0359113738,
0.0471122563,
-0.0008831471,
0.0161066316,
0.0005271489,
-0.0002117252,
0.058861196,
-0.0138693042,
-0.0405803658,
-0.0393287651,
-0.0024536343,
-0.0448006876,
0.0358823463,
0.0105684372,
-0.027051283,
0.0644572005,
0.0068545127,
0.0122087654,
-0.0093505634,
-0.0113613177,
0.0670973659,
0.0608937182,
-0.0211549476,
0.000310316,
-0.0038198789,
-0.0270876959,
-0.0040176008,
0.0102850739,
0.0196688976,
0.0358263738,
-0.0058465819,
0.0186765976,
0.0244134795,
-0.0177910347,
-0.0614533238,
0.0214390513,
-0.0568100139,
0.0351260081,
-0.0259947646,
-0.0091144312,
0.0349209309,
0.0091416165,
0.0212759972,
-0.0278635267,
-0.0172010791,
0.0444009267,
0.0258618705,
0.0160423685,
-0.0241110474,
0.0004665295,
-0.0505914725,
-0.0381424129,
-0.007397559,
-0.025588261,
0.0194104221,
-0.0137618808,
-0.0214067344,
-0.0055050878,
0.0013115183,
0.0478168614,
0.0037898491,
-0.023339184,
0.0034822335,
0.010829472,
-0.0196525976,
-0.0381191745,
0.0397770032,
-0.0042277337,
0.0049052732,
0.0535142459,
-0.0230451114,
-0.0569363758,
-0.0166508146,
-0.0441593118,
0.0009048168,
0.0242532771,
-0.0119324857,
0.0292216744,
-0.0458577685,
-0.0332436599,
0.0900077447,
-0.0442511551,
0.0301009417,
0.0446669757,
-0.0164151452,
-0.0051920502,
-0.0314452164,
0.0218758173,
-0.0037512267,
-0.0079266047,
0.0330209248,
-0.0150804361,
0.04322863,
-0.0261885822,
0.0170947034,
-0.0504575707,
-0.0067298673,
-0.0477483124,
-0.0343788676,
-0.0239089038,
0.012870254,
-0.0491049774,
0.0562699847,
-0.0352943353,
-0.0286579635,
-0.0294562895,
-0.0571282655,
-0.0152886007,
0.0083215404,
-0.0118679963,
-0.0514663309,
0.0390173346,
0.0050685913,
0.0293167941,
-0.0501158386,
0.0102016293,
-0.0013853295,
0.0121391229,
-0.0384033658,
-0.0041738967,
0.0452422537,
-0.0831512511,
-0.0051509757,
0.0087235589,
0.0140094804,
-0.0274289828,
0.0306947641,
-0.0470057912,
-0.0198729672,
-0.0452663824,
-0.0504074506,
-0.0542407669,
-0.0135876844,
-0.020429289,
0.0807258114,
0.0273928624,
-0.0200091451,
-0.0406999998,
0.0173972528,
0.0428442508,
0.0522508584,
-0.0601166524,
-0.0031780766,
-0.068188116,
0.0309850499,
0.0071344431,
-0.0372842439,
-0.0656305254,
0.0128662055,
0.0496991687,
-0.0262873583,
0.0079949992,
0.0407898575,
0.0182010252,
0.0113481935,
0.0009164569,
0.0646374524,
0.0438976102,
0.0206367821,
-0.0203727521,
-0.0225513969,
0.0272085685,
0.07584849,
0.0098213097,
-0.072264649,
-0.0342938974,
0.0021713038,
-0.0326856337,
0.0781003982,
-0.0313851759,
-0.025807973,
-0.0470310599,
0.0055443575,
-0.0065545393,
-0.0649115741,
-0.0181950647,
0.0649034828,
0.0566135943,
-0.0310154762,
-0.0686059445,
-0.0191981755,
-0.0110448711,
-0.0055903243,
0.0088726413,
0.0233946964,
0.0729561895,
-0.032527782,
-0.0384069867,
0.0179409459,
0.0364730544,
0.0407619998,
0.0161265749,
-0.0800752491,
0.0401443318,
0.0674972534,
0.0129589774,
0.0040415712,
-0.0436971374,
-0.0433860607,
0.0074362978,
0.0073443688,
0.0104558365,
-0.0280637648,
-0.0523683168,
-0.0267602541,
0.0852575675,
0.0422301069,
0.0340156816,
-0.0411147662,
-0.0012705505,
0.0198809449,
0.0102013042,
-0.0216786209,
-0.0065286974,
-0.0059648841,
-0.0447951555,
0.0424646921,
0.0650344118,
-0.0400469005,
-0.0025225219,
-0.0422209986,
-0.0488842577,
-0.0729511231,
0.0371829011,
0.0675547048,
0.088037312,
0.0488874018,
-0.0387834497,
0.0005261691,
0.0214787051,
-0.0569517836,
0.0130460793,
0.0048696967,
-0.0006281877,
-0.0547136217,
0.0370576866,
0.0215543862,
-0.0639873892,
-0.032044109,
0.0439595282,
-0.0155115221,
-0.0453844927,
0.0381068885,
0.0693432987,
0.0183360986,
0.0114071826,
0.0069959168,
-0.0318189114,
0.0048769931,
-0.0019116856,
-0.0334803388,
0.0221939776,
-0.0049832314,
0.0673464537,
0.0049129822,
-0.0123302191,
-0.0598820671,
-0.0213618521,
-0.0210524723,
-0.0374358259,
-0.052502051,
-0.0893907472,
0.0275607686,
-0.0004709147,
0.0883629993,
-0.0303536542,
0.0304555073,
-0.046407301,
0.02348461,
-0.0090355705,
0.0110211344,
-0.0592267253,
-0.0249707066,
-0.0168914031,
-0.0253411233,
0.0057207239,
0.0435589217,
0.000790813,
0.0467338301,
0.0220452007,
-0.0618701205,
-0.0190965161,
-0.0512461029,
0.0084421514,
0.0266155228,
-0.0025104848,
0.0352763906,
-0.0850288346,
0.0925934389,
0.0226381142,
0.0314296298,
-0.0014685717,
-0.041443795,
-0.0309578683,
0.054209888,
0.0174200051,
-0.0512735508,
0.0044817794,
0.1198881865,
0.0422054455,
-0.0500367433,
0.0561407059,
-0.0137262233,
-0.0008119642,
-0.0000239986,
0.0435253046,
0.0111405086,
-0.0229537729,
0.0293886568,
0.0339798108,
-0.0016734536,
-0.0256663486,
-0.0356352553,
-0.0222666916,
-0.0073789419,
-0.0186471157,
-0.0109674558,
-0.0089786071,
0.0160280373,
0.0433927365,
0.0696322992,
-0.0199075062,
0.0486536399,
-0.035068091,
-0.0253318343,
-0.0449207276,
0.0628909767,
-0.021452019,
-0.03723469,
0.0032745979,
0.0151382312,
0.0152435284,
0.0087604392,
-0.0246429984,
-0.0876684934,
-0.0365161374,
-0.031188434,
0.0657801405,
-5.408236082e-33,
-0.0612587146,
-0.0498171821,
0.0272984449,
-0.0214393474,
0.0223676357,
-0.0143523291,
-0.002583697,
0.0290830322,
0.016832361,
-0.0282443184,
-0.0041708373,
-0.0541952364,
-0.0039832285,
0.0000278794,
-0.0319640674,
0.0199263506,
-0.010979129,
0.0261810087,
0.0021802622,
-0.0627652779,
0.0208039377,
0.0469319113,
0.0145565588,
-0.0678215548,
0.0144341113,
0.0357948542,
0.0424847007,
0.0105777429,
-0.0046238871,
0.0248315185,
-0.0482344553,
-0.0194479469,
-0.0060103512,
-0.0391247682,
0.01675901,
0.0309319329,
-0.0268024001,
-0.0100067994,
0.0193420891,
0.0427347235,
-0.0575652607,
0.0245476551,
0.0044392282,
-0.0124479039,
0.0196671337,
-0.0280731339,
0.016249815,
-0.0061455783,
0.0042623333,
0.0635731295,
-0.0394969471,
0.0245728679,
0.0075610038,
-0.0564988852,
0.0534438118,
-0.005807728,
0.0719263628,
0.0313201398,
-0.0730125234,
0.0317448489,
-0.0632053241,
-0.0149000883,
0.0984235704,
0.0304474197,
-0.0235787947,
0.0984215438,
0.0213095881,
-0.0741377026,
-0.0298540648,
0.0347684883,
-0.0216896087,
0.050039269,
0.0009509815,
0.0006954273,
0.0122283492,
0.0877055004,
-0.0178722329,
0.0385239869,
-0.0860981941,
0.0356289446,
-0.024174571,
0.0336817577,
-0.0374189094,
0.0315600187,
0.0210186504,
0.036128927,
-0.0260294192,
-0.0158749651,
0.0501714312,
0.0081934882,
-0.0761808679,
0.0105529204,
0.0455125868,
-0.0337696336,
0.0009404649,
-0.0185095072,
-0.0124757783,
0.0313846283,
-0.0211468693,
0.0259331465,
-0.017911667,
-0.0250276998,
0.0529132448,
-0.0351365358,
0.0062284847,
0.0157379452,
-0.0398942009,
0.0429481678,
-0.0084276572,
0.0282052048,
-0.0014469017,
-0.0159857646,
0.0129946759,
0.0026381281,
0.0239506979,
-0.0143639455,
0.0040990449,
0.060151618,
0.015401761,
-0.0476810373,
0.0034648539,
-0.0266516991,
-0.0350826681,
-0.0155597012,
-0.0374757312,
-0.0004297399,
-0.0096052019,
-0.015733242,
0.0263416171,
-0.0307776555,
-0.032084424,
0.0158813633,
2.758e-7,
0.0190383699,
0.0189277846,
-0.0188953616,
0.0240525734,
-0.0358780809,
0.0273957979,
0.0024357412,
0.060946539,
-0.0662785098,
-0.0758934692,
-0.0042535253,
0.0296725221,
-0.0027881914,
-0.0453767702,
-0.0930486545,
-0.0345755145,
0.0744038299,
0.0167427715,
-0.0654945225,
0.0335546732,
-0.0052254628,
0.0496333502,
0.0131476903,
-0.0053739697,
0.0222667605,
-0.0063560321,
-0.0004266464,
-0.0232935157,
0.0161925405,
-0.0026135009,
0.0776192322,
0.045721706,
-0.0433640368,
-0.0358988754,
0.0089341821,
0.0105811227,
0.0936392844,
0.0246363971,
-0.0451844707,
0.0093422914,
0.0239693094,
-0.012293689,
-0.0161157567,
-0.0474010557,
0.0148443766,
0.0003750284,
0.0053020371,
-0.021033233,
-0.0224050302,
-0.0112142088,
-0.0252499226,
0.0108244969,
0.0119220838,
-0.0369453579,
-0.0125536704,
-0.0469518565,
-0.032592427,
-0.0438335463,
-0.0091055268,
-0.0112621672,
-0.017126644,
0.0276483856,
-0.0123915914,
-0.006283097,
-0.0083624562,
-0.0158990901,
-0.045967754,
1.717621555e-34,
-0.0095704617,
0.073868677,
-0.0222017895,
0.0414892361,
0.0675770044,
-0.001357786,
-0.0000567866,
0.0515561886,
-0.0111470316,
-0.0337507315,
0.0014495272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12808v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12808v1 | Enhancing Consistency in Multimodal Dialogue System Using LLM with Dialogue Scenario | 2023-12-20T07:15:04 | 2023-12-20T07:15:04 | Hiroki Onozeki, Zhiyang Qi, Kazuma Akiyama, Ryutaro Asahara, Takumasa Kaneko, Michimasa Inaba | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper describes our dialogue system submitted to Dialogue Robot
Competition 2023. The system's task is to help a user at a travel agency decide
on a plan for visiting two sightseeing spots in Kyoto City that satisfy the
user. Our dialogue system is flexible and stable and responds to user
requirements by controlling dialogue flow according to dialogue scenarios. We
also improved user satisfaction by introducing motion and speech control based
on system utterances and user situations. In the preliminary round, our system
was ranked fifth in the impression evaluation and sixth in the plan evaluation
among all 12 teams. | [
0.0555520765,
0.0105372248,
0.0064273854,
0.0483355261,
-0.0221028533,
-0.0078469133,
-0.0045358227,
-0.0066536581,
0.0237886291,
-0.0315811001,
-0.0640885532,
-0.0251843873,
0.0129522346,
0.0449153595,
0.0009352164,
-0.0959827751,
0.0458714142,
-0.0480509065,
-0.0019042683,
-0.0107527906,
0.0238056015,
-0.012460934,
-0.0914223045,
0.041208189,
-0.0343726501,
0.0087177521,
-0.0635006726,
0.0120094223,
0.0289648063,
-0.0563925728,
-0.0257798582,
-0.0129761631,
0.0528251007,
-0.0124549065,
0.000001763,
-0.0547529161,
0.0122239077,
-0.0270680767,
-0.0190355536,
-0.0778910443,
0.000330696,
0.0734743178,
0.0239893068,
0.0362848416,
-0.0062574134,
0.0521062165,
0.0332051367,
0.0700121149,
0.0852185115,
0.0642375275,
0.0021085604,
-0.0415658355,
-0.0153590972,
0.0320152193,
-0.0200547818,
-0.0754350126,
-0.028603496,
-0.0025516443,
0.0267121531,
-0.0352167301,
-0.0161871742,
-0.0191952307,
-0.0074896072,
-0.0164584368,
-0.0393326245,
0.023664074,
-0.0411736034,
-0.0375791527,
-0.04791734,
0.1069006249,
0.0743264854,
0.050052572,
0.0188131575,
-0.0008743379,
0.0056390627,
-0.0177369304,
-0.0244111884,
-0.0040644621,
-0.0252221897,
-0.0140470723,
-0.0743869767,
0.010596972,
-0.0330092423,
0.0014404863,
-0.0136291021,
0.0880245641,
0.0049949093,
-0.01996761,
-0.0099222297,
-0.0169756208,
0.0405974947,
-0.0711871386,
0.0189564712,
0.0576660894,
-0.0793840364,
0.0454444215,
-0.0064799306,
0.0784362182,
-0.0130840158,
-0.0589991361,
0.0135118384,
0.0416662693,
-0.0167161133,
0.0236343425,
0.0411735028,
0.0699590594,
-0.0128388172,
0.0319019072,
-0.008084069,
0.010036245,
0.0101024313,
0.0329006612,
-0.0621062033,
0.0163267832,
-0.0588846616,
-0.0349900946,
-0.0058102608,
0.0693247914,
0.0180656631,
0.0336126983,
-0.0134458961,
0.0017846702,
0.0003129828,
-0.005278273,
-0.0903296545,
0.0086996844,
-0.0172659811,
0.026935026,
-0.0102905584,
0.0064469026,
0.0251710042,
0.0646082833,
0.0166753139,
0.0046253996,
-0.0374236219,
0.1147010997,
-0.0137597164,
-0.0024058206,
-0.0330247544,
-0.0154132396,
-0.0158925243,
-0.0845710039,
-0.007562452,
-0.0122342492,
0.0213420875,
0.0022228467,
-0.0235864613,
0.0194688346,
0.0203092806,
0.0144225582,
0.0075930059,
0.0571768135,
0.0119070625,
0.0128420135,
0.0492071211,
0.0199592002,
-0.0098788748,
0.0233814046,
0.0689802766,
0.050380148,
0.0360151753,
0.0161003042,
0.0159943234,
0.0317620561,
-0.0564667508,
-0.0233199149,
0.0299793724,
0.0170011893,
-0.0108752344,
0.0590994656,
-0.0075965333,
0.0569560602,
-0.0359507054,
0.0225189868,
0.0361013897,
0.0163862035,
0.0032172468,
-0.0191028658,
0.0220905896,
-0.0144964848,
-0.0032732442,
0.0151688894,
0.0065280981,
0.0239861738,
-0.0101162996,
0.0038933323,
0.0329035074,
-0.0142586641,
-0.0129193924,
-0.0307866931,
-0.0016511644,
0.005759195,
0.0421878472,
-0.0088419262,
0.0262876507,
-0.0365754776,
-0.0889088586,
0.0581107177,
-0.0210253485,
-0.0394119024,
-0.0359066613,
0.0087102633,
0.0185974855,
0.0739353895,
0.0016177839,
0.011847103,
-0.0311972946,
-0.0006567183,
-0.0064999191,
0.0408458821,
0.0372155197,
-0.0230669584,
0.0409593135,
-0.0562963337,
-0.0318280235,
0.0026097104,
-0.0358512513,
0.0173707772,
-0.0249713752,
0.0344023667,
0.0097338958,
0.0192644559,
0.0732560232,
0.005845679,
0.0239477959,
0.0157881156,
-0.0381037854,
0.0208825972,
0.0532654747,
0.0309997555,
-0.0268502422,
-0.0154910702,
0.0538517684,
0.0066178003,
0.0233184937,
0.0769747496,
-0.0452463254,
-0.0538530424,
0.0463315919,
0.0035631296,
-0.0423253514,
0.0053588543,
-0.0118558565,
-0.052657526,
-0.0187504161,
-0.0538043343,
-0.0046751541,
-0.0275919233,
0.0432039797,
0.0426685214,
-0.008165461,
-0.0346299037,
-0.0111285737,
-0.0069113583,
0.0116225239,
0.0557337403,
0.0469686612,
0.0689586028,
-0.0804664195,
-0.0094011808,
0.0666965842,
0.0229355339,
0.013617374,
-0.0030191897,
0.0102463337,
-0.0447886325,
-0.0150292404,
-0.0898632705,
-0.0206049625,
0.0120097864,
-0.0227279793,
-0.0322905742,
-0.0222530607,
-0.0188800152,
-0.0453466065,
-0.0227661729,
0.0529025532,
0.040079575,
-0.0478600524,
0.0429338031,
0.0175434239,
-0.0648668259,
-0.0430468954,
0.0543842055,
0.018098617,
-0.0194317456,
0.0190395638,
-0.0352962092,
-0.0716626942,
0.0037536637,
-0.0519892946,
0.0383227803,
-0.0067235562,
-0.0438141152,
0.0563726127,
0.0116967438,
0.0146932248,
-0.0104921674,
0.009639943,
-0.0016474146,
0.0287174657,
-0.0588818491,
-0.0418139771,
0.0505732335,
0.0224460829,
0.0216711629,
-0.0425256751,
0.0115227476,
0.0084948493,
-0.0341755971,
0.0496968552,
0.07752195,
-0.0035051147,
-0.018858863,
0.0531866886,
-0.0413654372,
0.0113470769,
0.0202040393,
-0.0921993628,
0.0396835394,
-0.0052780523,
-0.0123230005,
0.0282230377,
-0.0357433036,
-0.0300182104,
-0.0030463156,
-0.0103938691,
-0.0149985133,
0.0363478996,
-0.0609392338,
0.0216600802,
-0.0111397943,
-0.0487264507,
-0.0076750056,
-0.0471875295,
-0.0109002758,
-0.0362878628,
0.0410876796,
-0.0636500567,
0.0268351901,
0.0013026776,
-0.036255829,
-0.0395380668,
0.0065763895,
-0.0197606385,
-0.0210827086,
-0.0100812791,
-0.0261655767,
-0.0079529537,
0.0316427574,
0.0088559678,
0.0227116644,
0.0302428212,
0.0008878878,
-0.0262515172,
0.0334737673,
0.0467121042,
0.1424317211,
-0.0439057164,
0.0206405409,
0.0234510861,
0.0340990089,
-0.0169719961,
-0.0231210738,
-0.0346890017,
0.0113802664,
0.048887793,
-0.0155842109,
-0.007544911,
0.0280187204,
0.0454182588,
-0.0247350279,
0.0200283434,
0.0702761412,
0.0068159266,
-0.0144217964,
-0.0221791826,
-0.0426941589,
-0.0014451443,
0.0062516523,
0.0132938968,
-0.0545563884,
-0.0187237225,
0.0044224937,
0.0076820957,
0.0088234479,
-0.0194609854,
-0.0142104682,
-0.0858904421,
0.0463201292,
-0.0056278156,
-0.0079754293,
-0.0275901388,
-0.0061776605,
0.0098924683,
0.0173964333,
0.0479345992,
0.026689576,
0.0222364925,
-0.0365981869,
0.0010382452,
-0.0337130651,
0.0124418233,
-0.0143461507,
-0.0183230527,
0.0612765178,
0.0427817218,
0.0658918247,
0.0074022855,
-0.0289208796,
-0.00307133,
0.0500999801,
0.0481364578,
-0.0352193937,
-0.00939989,
-0.0215496346,
-0.0298714153,
-0.0298536513,
-0.00709735,
0.003313429,
-0.0114928149,
0.0342635773,
0.0050802152,
-0.0879583508,
0.0398995653,
-0.0300849341,
0.0385896154,
0.0061593824,
0.0440611653,
-0.0166585967,
-0.0212253127,
-0.0341812037,
-0.0446381308,
-0.0542711355,
-0.0179424398,
0.0243018996,
0.0032667364,
-0.0327940881,
0.0445487238,
-0.0867320597,
-0.0255238563,
0.0055840481,
0.0571052022,
-0.0147722382,
-0.0021701357,
-0.0393265933,
0.0554496236,
0.0054700915,
-0.0264221989,
0.0014875948,
0.0296248067,
-0.0572438426,
0.0375983715,
0.0395246148,
-0.0168636404,
0.000393348,
0.027469933,
0.0025730752,
-0.0566995032,
-0.0510698557,
0.0404224098,
0.0143447369,
0.033699818,
0.0259295031,
-0.0054490641,
-0.0312545896,
-0.0344531313,
0.0270384811,
0.0008897677,
-0.002223274,
0.1115092635,
-0.0179714486,
-0.005431829,
-0.0634103715,
-0.0303158686,
-0.0443578884,
0.0550309569,
-0.0628843829,
-0.0946501642,
0.0039663403,
0.0466713011,
0.0060617188,
-0.0111790607,
0.0091567812,
-0.0066961274,
0.0465386957,
-0.0102525419,
-0.0171475597,
-0.0635403544,
0.0037994413,
-0.0341778882,
-0.023419844,
0.0223963019,
-0.0295830853,
-0.0531314164,
-0.0068217809,
0.0155932847,
0.0077120373,
0.0608519614,
-0.0296773054,
-0.0261757206,
-0.005994013,
-0.0122830831,
0.0290456023,
0.0021170725,
0.0122605236,
0.030657813,
0.1133389324,
-0.0049682707,
-0.0272807386,
0.0062296204,
0.0377621651,
-0.0127648143,
-0.0359208509,
0.0037621821,
0.0417123511,
0.0444720089,
0.0533631742,
-0.0019840547,
-0.0200150572,
0.0230720844,
-0.0123275779,
0.0416843034,
0.0018626512,
0.0036260884,
0.0609295256,
0.0076548732,
-0.0249594543,
0.0046216687,
0.0087779993,
0.0060564424,
-0.0030661284,
-0.0224345289,
-0.0062069716,
-0.0805387348,
-0.0257431474,
0.0091179507,
0.022174716,
0.0020965864,
-0.0226364713,
-0.0176873188,
-0.0120680118,
0.0088000949,
0.0238901544,
0.0171460342,
-0.0345784575,
0.06038706,
-4.892e-7,
0.0145372525,
-0.0121548092,
-0.0203583278,
-0.0302332286,
0.0251721069,
0.0067121061,
-0.0376292691,
-5.481183588e-33,
-0.0356691591,
-0.071722582,
0.0791008174,
-0.0015641315,
-0.0613990016,
-0.0735744685,
-0.0274454504,
0.0258288346,
-0.0176099055,
-0.0200082585,
-0.0044394815,
-0.0313421451,
0.0110485936,
-0.0052584303,
0.0049643675,
-0.0091855638,
0.0392399244,
0.0277633183,
-0.0213094708,
-0.0257013589,
0.0568244644,
0.0109931286,
0.0253977738,
-0.0856405869,
-0.0018586777,
0.0018462299,
-0.0574720129,
0.0220833942,
-0.0018977971,
0.0282796659,
0.0113388496,
0.0285840351,
-0.0037468311,
-0.0053992434,
-0.0352881663,
0.0012309289,
-0.0093592145,
-0.0375995971,
0.0359992534,
0.068027094,
-0.0041118865,
0.0072786305,
0.0183582567,
-0.0066892905,
0.0047621918,
0.038348563,
0.0027327635,
0.0000632399,
-0.0139020942,
0.0273845717,
-0.0428542085,
0.0231861174,
-0.0110048335,
-0.0581469834,
0.0059240097,
0.0622859374,
0.0034701591,
-0.0244570337,
-0.0239688829,
0.0441733226,
-0.0330656543,
-0.0517199151,
0.0528427474,
-0.016875647,
0.0012461538,
0.0538308732,
0.0024716074,
-0.0330989249,
-0.0110556995,
-0.038152799,
-0.0222283062,
0.100867413,
-0.0021942582,
0.0716488436,
-0.0677783266,
-0.0081120441,
-0.0100372843,
0.0413570739,
0.0369300246,
0.0602334589,
-0.0172393639,
0.0513161346,
-0.0039646467,
0.0046083308,
-0.0163833946,
0.0216179732,
-0.0004090602,
-0.0616782643,
0.0296503901,
0.0130456751,
0.0371606909,
-0.0196292643,
0.0614908338,
-0.0057252371,
-0.0245245639,
0.00220479,
-0.0051641134,
0.013190249,
-0.021620987,
-0.0194273032,
-0.0406828895,
-0.0505760685,
0.011476296,
-0.0040678307,
0.0231912658,
-0.0112977494,
-0.0834681243,
0.0217095204,
-0.0056895223,
-0.0070476811,
-0.0079496345,
-0.0134852976,
-0.0016130256,
0.0161969792,
0.0164225139,
-0.0435877815,
-0.0426763967,
0.065680176,
-0.0466595702,
-0.0356550366,
-0.0288509484,
-0.0529440306,
0.0254377443,
0.0193643589,
-0.0282987021,
0.0151845776,
0.0255600344,
-0.0138667831,
-0.011248677,
-0.0188146885,
-0.0074567902,
0.0132069485,
2.587e-7,
-0.0213729218,
0.0152279502,
0.000801604,
0.0438222885,
0.0076015247,
0.0426838323,
-0.0207195599,
0.0173707698,
-0.0164984614,
-0.0192146637,
0.0141611174,
-0.0101347826,
0.0240218546,
-0.0004825015,
-0.07120011,
-0.0254755672,
-0.0240217652,
-0.042956654,
-0.0333511718,
0.0473756269,
0.082179904,
0.0330854952,
-0.018847039,
0.00869139,
0.0096372552,
-0.0274843723,
0.01368412,
-0.039077688,
-0.039873153,
-0.0133358771,
0.0537646711,
-0.0276743472,
-0.0125875194,
-0.0300681666,
0.010492119,
0.0205991305,
0.0146366181,
0.076577723,
0.00051497,
-0.109848015,
0.0174806621,
0.0177545492,
-0.0009100962,
-0.0065377369,
0.0215025526,
0.0301119387,
0.0058295862,
-0.0218684934,
0.0076001943,
-0.0256161205,
0.0148216914,
-0.0167575292,
-0.0033844074,
0.0004566471,
0.009487207,
-0.0222716238,
0.003752613,
-0.0431915037,
0.03057741,
-0.0260093082,
-0.0596300326,
-0.0446044877,
-0.0102664363,
-0.0419204459,
0.0058306633,
-0.0426887423,
-0.0303941648,
1.411136084e-34,
0.0110421358,
-0.0325345397,
-0.0025165663,
0.0742952675,
0.0320483558,
0.0191259682,
0.0190340821,
0.0241154246,
0.0404528081,
-0.0224358868,
-0.0286520515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12806v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12806v1 | MedBench: A Large-Scale Chinese Benchmark for Evaluating Medical Large Language Models | 2023-12-20T07:01:49 | 2023-12-20T07:01:49 | Yan Cai, Linlin Wang, Ye Wang, Gerard de Melo, Ya Zhang, Yanfeng Wang, Liang He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The emergence of various medical large language models (LLMs) in the medical
domain has highlighted the need for unified evaluation standards, as manual
evaluation of LLMs proves to be time-consuming and labor-intensive. To address
this issue, we introduce MedBench, a comprehensive benchmark for the Chinese
medical domain, comprising 40,041 questions sourced from authentic examination
exercises and medical reports of diverse branches of medicine. In particular,
this benchmark is composed of four key components: the Chinese Medical
Licensing Examination, the Resident Standardization Training Examination, the
Doctor In-Charge Qualification Examination, and real-world clinic cases
encompassing examinations, diagnoses, and treatments. MedBench replicates the
educational progression and clinical practice experiences of doctors in
Mainland China, thereby establishing itself as a credible benchmark for
assessing the mastery of knowledge and reasoning abilities in medical language
learning models. We perform extensive experiments and conduct an in-depth
analysis from diverse perspectives, which culminate in the following findings:
(1) Chinese medical LLMs underperform on this benchmark, highlighting the need
for significant advances in clinical knowledge and diagnostic precision. (2)
Several general-domain LLMs surprisingly possess considerable medical
knowledge. These findings elucidate both the capabilities and limitations of
LLMs within the context of MedBench, with the ultimate goal of aiding the
medical research community. | [
0.0296356995,
0.0160491783,
0.0101892743,
-0.0333308056,
0.0032413981,
0.0284079295,
0.0277282689,
0.0550937206,
0.0243542623,
-0.002384084,
0.010875728,
-0.0711117834,
-0.0032030272,
-0.0041158292,
0.030518163,
-0.0487028547,
0.0127308713,
0.0107275033,
0.0184593946,
-0.0103492383,
-0.0111047169,
-0.0120672258,
-0.0288604908,
0.0362298302,
0.0518559702,
-0.0300338455,
0.0479062237,
-0.0205227248,
0.0042237062,
-0.082287699,
-0.0202057417,
0.0260981079,
-0.0122960946,
0.0287114289,
0.0000021546,
-0.0892889798,
-0.0207092669,
0.0209286176,
-0.0185307618,
0.0074207298,
0.0407986157,
-0.0232206434,
-0.03204225,
0.0098595694,
-0.0449855588,
-0.0552678928,
0.0132919569,
0.0271740425,
0.0166703928,
0.0583923236,
0.000912876,
0.0100215105,
0.0165804066,
-0.029425649,
-0.000633835,
-0.0570581146,
0.0396267846,
0.0801666304,
0.0447192788,
-0.0241546929,
-0.031467773,
0.0204434674,
0.0118872896,
0.0233159494,
-0.0291562695,
0.0404155105,
0.0034534708,
-0.0108884117,
0.0221072976,
0.0390723012,
0.0104722464,
-0.0134565402,
0.0149015402,
0.0091653299,
0.0142546464,
0.0212734137,
-0.0663693324,
0.0174532291,
-0.006323975,
-0.008637799,
0.0267799012,
-0.0358117744,
0.0328383259,
0.0202565752,
-0.0391887166,
-0.0051161642,
0.0018860069,
-0.0148679102,
0.0197297763,
-0.0209341608,
-0.0089916876,
-0.010082325,
0.0205035675,
0.0464009382,
-0.0485516004,
0.0018909816,
0.054363206,
0.0009849437,
0.0852471516,
-0.0378701575,
0.0158006996,
0.0116411261,
-0.0020225144,
0.0353693999,
-0.0343046449,
0.0531863719,
-0.01676061,
0.0395824015,
-0.0790379494,
0.034862984,
-0.0582680851,
-0.0208821408,
0.0031498726,
-0.0066213133,
0.0104052471,
0.015343898,
-0.1120050848,
-0.0593803562,
-0.0262855049,
0.0236023869,
-0.014681031,
0.0276489556,
-0.0110959718,
-0.0030333076,
-0.038640663,
0.0482290685,
0.0040919916,
0.0190654043,
-0.0253055263,
0.0059216418,
0.0325879678,
0.0182702783,
-0.0240552723,
0.030318385,
0.032465402,
0.0220126119,
-0.0135885067,
0.0237839464,
0.0139548266,
-0.0298708342,
-0.0337997377,
-0.0398745015,
0.0354012176,
-0.0847998261,
-0.0218822006,
0.0169352442,
0.0288108587,
-0.0417427607,
0.0158402082,
0.0018044824,
-0.0091574332,
0.0058452873,
-0.0418271273,
0.0024404523,
0.0048282868,
0.0581440143,
-0.0003627414,
0.0139850108,
0.0166378617,
-0.0557935908,
-0.0018472788,
-0.0478075556,
-0.0025942291,
-0.0078175282,
0.0092201009,
-0.0023343209,
0.0077351318,
0.022227522,
0.0474836789,
0.0841165408,
-0.0442665704,
0.04624274,
-0.0192023385,
0.0261761975,
0.0224939436,
0.0742497742,
0.0048422432,
-0.0135179413,
0.0005908157,
-0.0475451574,
0.0261133481,
-0.008894356,
0.0348207653,
-0.0142188706,
0.0051226537,
0.0032845524,
-0.0473181531,
0.0079006748,
-0.0280752052,
-0.0605966672,
-0.0591523238,
0.002008683,
-0.0343765207,
0.0123585677,
0.0397810787,
-0.0369044729,
0.0105408542,
0.0783391595,
0.033066377,
-0.0422930531,
-0.0050003473,
-0.0489805937,
-0.0568039306,
0.059687905,
0.0348413996,
-0.0339622274,
-0.0257019959,
-0.0073711225,
0.0350516476,
0.0353100039,
0.0467130169,
-0.0151879694,
-0.0300315879,
-0.0412090495,
0.0095140105,
0.0468769372,
0.0169764627,
-0.0433778204,
-0.0125307329,
0.0505884402,
-0.021259591,
-0.0633782893,
-0.0500437617,
0.0196467433,
-0.1256465614,
-0.023469694,
-0.0198810194,
-0.0226510782,
0.0237465259,
0.0113879666,
-0.0179431662,
0.0400323607,
0.0117795654,
-0.021899676,
-0.0310767386,
0.0218589772,
-0.0140712392,
0.0026371307,
0.0440607779,
-0.0622215644,
-0.0099051269,
-0.0176936723,
-0.0325689502,
-0.0430056639,
-0.0326051749,
-0.0132621685,
0.0340022966,
-0.0076535405,
0.0504441895,
-0.0263015479,
-0.0021032661,
-0.0205281321,
0.0079586646,
-0.0198815316,
0.0425635129,
0.0385602824,
-0.0140382657,
0.0084562087,
-0.0184915103,
-0.0580361113,
0.0132030044,
-0.009854367,
0.0357723348,
-0.0326213427,
0.0279200543,
-0.0338023864,
-0.0331812575,
-0.0957580432,
-0.017104825,
0.0148831531,
-0.0046787001,
0.0388967097,
-0.0296634808,
0.0018239728,
0.0126566691,
-0.0483440943,
-0.0134101268,
0.0212956052,
-0.0044728429,
0.0041412013,
0.0189333484,
-0.0004894114,
-0.009769612,
0.00398592,
-0.0738859251,
0.0007726369,
0.0207464378,
0.0401426665,
0.0254817791,
0.0073028188,
-0.0458339155,
-0.0310327318,
-0.0165336207,
-0.0440203138,
0.0270309839,
-0.0218817927,
-0.0285747275,
0.0522555895,
-0.0132281641,
0.0313633308,
0.0551183634,
-0.0029669923,
-0.0126213236,
-0.0059191692,
-0.0008216401,
-0.037493553,
-0.0219999105,
-0.0719696879,
-0.0406347029,
0.0741423965,
0.0131380493,
0.0022166958,
0.00654992,
-0.0133772558,
-0.0661906675,
0.0042840014,
-0.0456877351,
0.0413438044,
-0.0337026156,
0.0247435849,
0.00517675,
-0.0264591258,
0.0733773112,
0.0015103465,
0.044343181,
-0.0820738599,
-0.0125844944,
-0.0260018054,
0.0191780757,
-0.0322432816,
0.0245521571,
0.0077462699,
-0.0075884755,
-0.0209420063,
0.0305814911,
-0.0037972643,
-0.0876214132,
0.0521401875,
-0.0169057082,
0.004637883,
-0.0000111924,
-0.0130735505,
-0.024117142,
0.0304255784,
-0.0109229563,
0.0329809785,
0.0176863503,
0.0248229206,
-0.0129576009,
0.0567650832,
-0.0051507996,
0.0409545787,
0.0291422922,
0.0061191982,
0.0058221123,
-0.0385451242,
0.0023636369,
0.0067651109,
0.029371053,
-0.0596979186,
0.0770841688,
0.0848963484,
0.039776627,
0.034628991,
0.034692321,
0.0120048132,
0.0115455445,
-0.0254737101,
0.0007562527,
0.0363155268,
0.002614913,
-0.0722793713,
0.0051123719,
0.114477396,
0.0222859066,
-0.0145126851,
0.0094238948,
-0.025539156,
-0.0257272478,
0.0206425656,
0.001975561,
-0.1012081504,
0.0039090449,
-0.0202428959,
0.0340157636,
-0.0093003782,
-0.0202101618,
0.036159873,
-0.0578224882,
0.0137804998,
0.0261428859,
-0.05320701,
-0.0053318939,
-0.0361705087,
-0.0004147812,
0.0290421266,
0.0186659377,
0.010145952,
-0.0152111268,
-0.0177253745,
-0.0011845984,
-0.0849488378,
-0.0884386599,
0.0810496882,
-0.0262446143,
0.0416780971,
0.0144424718,
0.0220074914,
-0.0271211546,
-0.0076955166,
-0.0077203796,
0.0117453951,
-0.0098478859,
0.007463722,
0.0614659302,
0.0314137749,
0.0202763416,
-0.0369868502,
0.0304640457,
-0.0461586975,
0.0173341539,
0.0187732354,
0.0760602728,
-0.0212275144,
-0.0500288084,
-0.0093643693,
0.0387975499,
-0.005707094,
0.0644717216,
0.0020043894,
-0.0062041529,
0.0189867485,
0.0007891319,
0.0352498591,
0.0299971458,
-0.0256206691,
0.0770690963,
-0.0232877582,
-0.0058725444,
-0.044818081,
-0.0106269438,
0.0362768583,
0.0089226346,
0.0287998822,
0.0547443479,
0.0386021063,
-0.0089163492,
-0.0402830951,
0.0507067665,
0.0472057238,
0.0313181207,
-0.0885643885,
-0.0309693478,
0.0874604881,
0.0057648881,
-0.0157507546,
-0.0111850118,
0.0022235452,
0.0031693438,
-0.0150004383,
0.0017814005,
0.0192029718,
-0.0300016198,
-0.0046571386,
0.009742368,
0.0022319453,
-0.0023000631,
-0.0019754381,
0.0024963035,
-0.0132228881,
-0.0371584184,
-0.0082725687,
-0.0180613659,
-0.0030927986,
0.0138426153,
0.0194650684,
0.0518453829,
-0.0193229951,
0.0025654854,
0.0436757654,
0.0662660748,
0.0154492687,
-0.0052349214,
-0.0143314255,
-0.0199383162,
0.0302946121,
-0.0299483966,
-0.000305455,
-0.0105340919,
-0.0478440337,
0.0501512438,
0.0022162248,
-0.00034477,
0.0176796075,
-0.0306142587,
-0.0707437024,
-0.056326963,
0.0689742789,
-0.0182034019,
0.0040719728,
0.0515745915,
-0.0307388585,
-0.0016608732,
-0.0262652524,
-0.0070144632,
0.0254953615,
0.0139831854,
0.1052979231,
-0.0037264612,
0.0143521186,
0.030278746,
0.0037067868,
-0.0293134935,
-0.0774615034,
-0.0001024574,
0.0095429821,
0.0650193021,
-0.0051793926,
0.01670135,
-0.0276889261,
0.0135735963,
-0.0372996256,
-0.0276098978,
-0.0450281464,
-0.0034683188,
0.0455468558,
0.0227679107,
0.0103028845,
-0.0028597752,
0.0821004137,
0.0069526485,
0.0487984754,
-0.0024008635,
-0.0329524912,
-0.0204791725,
-0.0408369489,
0.0460603014,
0.0005797086,
-0.0674741492,
0.0246915109,
-0.1123315692,
-0.0606714338,
-0.0026924068,
0.0081973551,
-0.0370337591,
-0.0141193662,
0.0116709927,
0.0536896773,
0.0020601233,
-0.0045258803,
-0.0264945049,
0.0591636188,
-0.0195113216,
0.0021616654,
0.0553565398,
-5.691804993e-33,
0.0184021574,
-0.0310329776,
0.0516976267,
-0.0697507858,
0.0227043834,
0.0403322019,
-0.0231800731,
0.0009780008,
-0.0504934639,
0.0329078659,
-0.0127560673,
-0.0076199193,
0.0025703979,
0.0333050974,
0.0118276048,
-0.0110365283,
-0.0005018967,
0.028146442,
0.0000322194,
-0.0157741904,
-0.0015527981,
0.0206452217,
0.0449109115,
-0.051458478,
0.0062330565,
0.0054624337,
0.0439548381,
0.0064933589,
-0.0324977376,
0.079463914,
0.0215960015,
0.0210354887,
0.0395081677,
-0.0226427261,
0.0063436045,
-0.0631407052,
-0.0710716397,
0.0032514746,
0.012547221,
-0.0058347001,
-0.0088620856,
-0.011466722,
0.0555997118,
-0.0134591172,
-0.0234476272,
-0.0325316377,
0.0196104757,
-0.0561509989,
-0.0098231286,
-0.0401305631,
-0.0021035911,
0.0413391665,
-0.0013596137,
0.0371449329,
-0.062005952,
-0.0216455981,
-0.0452998392,
0.0301941931,
-0.0383895896,
-0.004952867,
0.0572351925,
0.0528761223,
0.0350672342,
-0.0338942446,
0.0058109565,
0.0517168418,
0.0267748814,
-0.0036248537,
0.009093794,
-0.0011737987,
-0.0034098774,
0.0310666785,
0.0501727387,
0.0272339471,
0.0077843894,
-0.0391256027,
-0.1091213599,
0.0227463655,
-0.0369350724,
0.0592724904,
0.0098428158,
-0.0154116983,
-0.0740038678,
-0.0259516239,
-0.0375842229,
0.0224539395,
-0.0205818377,
-0.029738972,
0.0364721157,
-0.004132234,
-0.002152164,
-0.0169279613,
0.0346661136,
-0.0353718437,
-0.0041618049,
-0.0370584354,
0.0188084226,
0.0229906328,
-0.0519421436,
0.0469679572,
-0.0797088817,
-0.0226209927,
-0.0135499621,
-0.0263469107,
0.0375807993,
0.0297000352,
0.0050172321,
-0.0409613363,
-0.0463120863,
-0.0083451988,
0.021726273,
-0.0689739361,
0.0368854962,
0.0181487799,
0.029921215,
0.0179439001,
0.0048572351,
0.0193389878,
0.0246466994,
-0.031196164,
-0.0553006679,
-0.061267145,
-0.0443323255,
-0.0109856287,
-0.0399177335,
0.0235465448,
-0.0360516235,
0.0631036833,
0.0787309036,
-0.043329604,
-0.0080342311,
0.0026709212,
2.84e-7,
0.0877593234,
0.0568191409,
-0.0346697792,
-0.0332954377,
0.0109891081,
-0.0070602549,
-0.0507210791,
-0.0151438341,
0.0254285652,
-0.0095023364,
0.0314569995,
0.0125640798,
0.0430923253,
0.0454484448,
-0.0588818826,
-0.0182965882,
-0.0611228161,
0.0051872074,
-0.0179450009,
0.0027601123,
-0.0025264435,
0.0423947573,
-0.0618473068,
-0.0299318191,
0.016956104,
-0.0320005417,
0.0400946513,
-0.0295497756,
0.0149435289,
0.084410131,
0.0401107743,
-0.0121337436,
0.0317549482,
0.0632963702,
-0.0134497909,
-0.007136933,
0.0307758171,
0.1164341792,
-0.0216019358,
0.0548378713,
0.0201232862,
-0.0328200459,
0.033576645,
-0.0661385059,
0.0287500359,
-0.043826513,
-0.0419969149,
-0.0096698003,
-0.0385826975,
-0.0444982238,
0.0740868673,
-0.0205586813,
-0.0253261048,
0.0465233065,
-0.0005053154,
0.0436749198,
-0.0159332454,
-0.0040435228,
-0.0441869944,
0.0191034283,
-0.0161883663,
-0.0911197215,
0.0397297703,
-0.0416274108,
-0.0260972977,
-0.0755557939,
-0.0132028572,
2.532699695e-34,
0.0121656265,
0.0037322361,
0.0276233796,
0.0162557326,
0.0311586373,
-0.0125998519,
0.0051518967,
0.010334922,
-0.0120355887,
-0.0520966575,
-0.0181290116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12783v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12783v1 | Stable Distillation: Regularizing Continued Pre-training for Low-Resource Automatic Speech Recognition | 2023-12-20T06:02:12 | 2023-12-20T06:02:12 | Ashish Seth, Sreyan Ghosh, S. Umesh, Dinesh Manocha | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD | Continued self-supervised (SSL) pre-training for adapting existing SSL models
to the target domain has shown to be extremely effective for low-resource
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR). This paper proposes Stable Distillation, a
simple and novel approach for SSL-based continued pre-training that boosts ASR
performance in the target domain where both labeled and unlabeled data are
limited. Stable Distillation employs self-distillation as regularization for
continued pre-training, alleviating the over-fitting issue, a common problem
continued pre-training faces when the source and target domains differ.
Specifically, first, we perform vanilla continued pre-training on an initial
SSL pre-trained model on the target domain ASR dataset and call it the teacher.
Next, we take the same initial pre-trained model as a student to perform
continued pre-training while enforcing its hidden representations to be close
to that of the teacher (via MSE loss). This student is then used for downstream
ASR fine-tuning on the target dataset. In practice, Stable Distillation
outperforms all our baselines by 0.8 - 7 WER when evaluated in various
experimental settings. | [
-0.0287673548,
0.0848013461,
0.0243717544,
-0.0230133235,
0.0331157446,
0.0070495903,
0.0622790083,
-0.0209081993,
-0.0144903138,
0.0117429011,
-0.0838977173,
0.0267141387,
-0.0223093368,
-0.0059079383,
-0.0023155275,
-0.0193162616,
0.0199988056,
-0.0328318961,
-0.0174071323,
-0.0291206446,
0.0262633543,
-0.0296472572,
-0.0161882862,
-0.0054611694,
0.0038472617,
-0.0009364397,
0.0010931729,
-0.0012768551,
0.0284749791,
-0.0468298271,
-0.0120264422,
0.0474744216,
0.0754867643,
-0.0546898767,
0.0000021246,
-0.0452109054,
-0.0187871903,
-0.0060663288,
-0.0792489424,
0.0134075265,
-0.0225399379,
0.0149520384,
0.0079599274,
0.0193731543,
-0.0163750499,
-0.0392458923,
0.0476114973,
0.0129861291,
0.0718256757,
0.0231484193,
0.0028999015,
-0.0740804225,
-0.004968287,
-0.0185051952,
-0.0507545099,
-0.0594636984,
-0.0237192325,
-0.0169758946,
-0.0286889095,
-0.0343381055,
-0.0111392979,
0.0373983383,
0.0171693768,
0.0088199396,
-0.0341353416,
0.0052262167,
-0.0199772157,
-0.0323436707,
0.0199639946,
0.0344909877,
-0.0088313008,
-0.0312774219,
0.000808248,
-0.0338466726,
-0.0324297324,
-0.0295086596,
-0.0152500486,
-0.0156868175,
0.0504474826,
-0.0119064553,
-0.0067114746,
0.0573093928,
0.0037201981,
-0.0073292451,
-0.0351181738,
0.0161239225,
-0.016904654,
-0.0349246189,
0.0131311007,
-0.0083103124,
-0.0280787908,
0.0148601569,
0.0492000468,
0.01099246,
0.005909889,
0.0084989695,
-0.0536199883,
-0.046122063,
-0.0270500351,
0.0081511335,
0.0028199868,
0.0421358272,
-0.0518200696,
-0.0045670313,
-0.0110415118,
0.0279363021,
0.0332656838,
0.0615644157,
-0.0042603817,
0.0559413284,
-0.0514832959,
0.0487687141,
-0.0953010842,
0.0585110746,
0.0245132949,
-0.0194010437,
-0.0269765239,
0.0086852629,
-0.0312508009,
-0.0292150229,
0.0416058935,
0.0064329538,
-0.0652813017,
-0.0160350595,
0.0342012905,
0.0552575216,
0.0055073802,
0.0188964102,
0.0282450076,
-0.0537725165,
-0.026780704,
-0.0167840943,
0.0611731522,
-0.0137151331,
0.0111035453,
0.0561471619,
0.0113521209,
-0.0368539877,
-0.0872856677,
0.0320488699,
-0.010006207,
-0.0723190159,
-0.0145317791,
-0.0152875781,
0.0215203203,
0.0009100086,
0.0410761349,
-0.0899756849,
-0.0209178925,
-0.0386016928,
0.0418819375,
0.0725848526,
-0.0444140434,
-0.0098072346,
0.0073700612,
0.0098852981,
0.0100452788,
0.065009132,
-0.0035656292,
-0.0337080099,
-0.0019424798,
-0.0370928943,
-0.0284687337,
0.0178486835,
0.0616738945,
0.0183786079,
-0.0342467092,
-0.0081942957,
-0.0220224261,
0.0067004389,
0.059313789,
-0.0025208404,
-0.0348957814,
-0.0187448468,
0.0539346151,
0.0511592776,
0.0459036864,
0.0632217824,
0.011548643,
0.0294496994,
0.0138208242,
0.0515001677,
-0.0406934991,
-0.0073414873,
0.01788426,
0.0004515025,
0.0236716643,
0.0228948407,
-0.0486919507,
-0.0464380868,
0.0426454917,
-0.0276936572,
-0.0299781784,
0.0663649663,
0.0675771609,
0.0281522628,
-0.0103645073,
0.0631511658,
0.0294633172,
-0.0466203839,
0.0377588868,
-0.0511022657,
-0.0078478409,
0.023268098,
-0.0085178027,
-0.0492384396,
-0.0534273535,
-0.039451886,
0.0256775338,
-0.0308924448,
0.0040162648,
0.0290114693,
0.0971807614,
-0.0340293124,
-0.0614191517,
0.0205871258,
-0.0010392715,
0.0480474345,
-0.0413288064,
0.0438807495,
0.0182245243,
-0.020776812,
0.0137239126,
-0.0096846968,
-0.0359268934,
-0.0468865372,
0.0254229289,
0.0265984777,
0.055941429,
0.018461043,
-0.0659101009,
-0.0060733506,
0.0238641147,
-0.0308535993,
0.0083750263,
0.0031643456,
-0.1045788378,
-0.0006253102,
0.0577477999,
0.022938773,
0.0297436025,
0.0507174209,
0.0146980006,
-0.0586054772,
0.0455346853,
0.0326103903,
0.0449163243,
-0.0477868728,
0.0462509505,
0.0359840766,
0.0287180878,
-0.0011943377,
-0.0155849634,
0.0217201486,
-0.0187374819,
-0.0122722685,
-0.016131524,
0.0108180838,
-0.0475626402,
0.009178088,
-0.0267627947,
-0.0336917676,
0.0494754389,
0.0279990304,
0.0113285948,
0.0119876657,
0.0402886905,
-0.0015484446,
-0.0223930944,
-0.0674745664,
0.0060799764,
-0.0126667107,
0.0905594081,
-0.0164217204,
-0.0530750975,
0.0177530199,
-0.0348235294,
-0.0417197272,
-0.0096537797,
-0.0342942402,
0.0485766903,
0.0218692422,
-0.0074198963,
-0.0095951846,
0.0629938841,
-0.0304915272,
-0.0500943922,
-0.0093165757,
-0.0332934335,
0.0728552863,
0.0127685918,
0.0332398862,
-0.0004866568,
-0.0162385721,
-0.0311526507,
0.0048234998,
0.0046796929,
0.0094274525,
-0.0115727549,
-0.0225888956,
0.0343923569,
0.0043842043,
-0.0517618656,
0.0127182743,
-0.0092633106,
-0.0354543291,
0.0169397965,
0.0670491606,
-0.0126201725,
0.0295417998,
-0.0130985519,
0.0127298478,
-0.010904775,
-0.0466346964,
-0.0061319727,
-0.0554847717,
-0.0344190784,
0.0227807164,
-0.008977714,
0.0176507067,
0.0362244919,
-0.0244900305,
0.0206739809,
-0.0378132612,
-0.0176482517,
-0.0460303575,
-0.0602474883,
0.0164038241,
-0.0179328714,
-0.0348394178,
0.0085409563,
-0.0215605311,
-0.0194261223,
-0.0248374194,
0.0075776991,
0.0265409648,
0.014306752,
0.0310466997,
0.0061888187,
0.0142575949,
-0.0210693553,
-0.0403711051,
-0.0460485145,
-0.0474409536,
-0.0486104116,
-0.0196810383,
0.005337052,
0.0035960965,
-0.0257642642,
0.0127944592,
-0.007320249,
0.0875708386,
0.013375042,
0.0195013471,
-0.0144013623,
0.0140075134,
0.0223629624,
0.0218967516,
-0.0011837535,
-0.0093346937,
0.0509157255,
-0.0216414239,
0.0966514871,
-0.0575643592,
-0.0479287952,
-0.0083932551,
0.0317765176,
0.0118594868,
0.0065195956,
0.030204935,
0.033763431,
-0.0409909524,
0.0041745566,
0.0818186626,
-0.0193839613,
-0.0217873212,
-0.0018292544,
-0.007960109,
0.0501824319,
0.01467463,
-0.0074352343,
-0.0359707177,
-0.0164932609,
0.0141935684,
0.0272390116,
0.0413788334,
0.0019478844,
-0.0391682573,
-0.0536732115,
0.0357635953,
0.0363943391,
-0.0038719627,
0.00943565,
-0.03003796,
-0.0166489035,
-0.0364577547,
0.0293355118,
-0.006483654,
-0.0308785774,
-0.0356042534,
0.0418877378,
-0.0692672133,
-0.0654182583,
-0.0161323044,
-0.0229844358,
0.0281435195,
0.0336112045,
-0.0388726741,
0.0245685037,
-0.033515662,
0.0852726772,
-0.0210188106,
0.007969562,
-0.0272289943,
0.0208002161,
0.0109230652,
-0.0186637118,
0.056142889,
0.005338409,
-0.0074703619,
-0.0220022351,
0.046265725,
0.0250145812,
-0.0253835618,
-0.0142258042,
0.0189813524,
0.0121228108,
0.010971535,
0.0090767965,
0.0327537693,
-0.0288337022,
-0.0218165088,
0.0463457629,
0.0522579215,
-0.0141216889,
-0.0077620014,
-0.0067281267,
-0.0235636514,
-0.0659997687,
0.0371166244,
-0.0129075283,
-0.0300189294,
0.06799604,
-0.0137376981,
-0.0035772072,
0.0092926677,
0.0579647124,
-0.0369513296,
0.0167113524,
-0.024648739,
-0.0023665426,
-0.052748654,
-0.0365516208,
0.026541898,
-0.0410139784,
-0.0108344043,
-0.0032034048,
-0.0776740909,
-0.0269845203,
0.0272553694,
0.0067438092,
0.008694537,
0.0643013194,
-0.0373250581,
-0.049936682,
0.0898476467,
0.0214235596,
-0.0748709515,
0.0194675587,
0.0733752027,
-0.0251077507,
-0.0005612083,
0.019996902,
-0.0203436669,
0.07143154,
0.0038647354,
0.0068141883,
-0.0006613701,
-0.0178150777,
0.0218934547,
0.0191902332,
0.0878339335,
-0.0042731999,
0.0495895892,
-0.03882939,
0.0413445048,
0.0193639752,
0.0443228036,
-0.0361790918,
-0.0112065952,
0.0028822257,
0.0095904777,
-0.0064621493,
0.0217478108,
-0.0310618859,
0.0069663431,
-0.035228271,
0.0474550873,
0.0130295157,
0.0196357835,
0.0171941649,
0.009152391,
-0.0028904774,
0.0521205626,
0.0682506487,
0.0142359585,
-0.0393204726,
-0.0191885307,
0.0037611283,
0.0564964972,
0.0003307548,
0.0262294021,
-0.0476248488,
-0.067254059,
-0.0413227268,
0.0285466518,
0.0082572745,
0.0012164521,
0.0494747199,
0.0469776206,
0.0060778414,
-0.0557216406,
0.0013777562,
-0.0204723738,
0.0240872987,
-0.0111998022,
-0.0096524814,
0.0051385206,
0.0623167083,
0.0542217866,
0.0125452094,
0.0346381776,
-0.0043783733,
0.0628955662,
-0.0544578247,
-0.0356475934,
-0.034985479,
0.0491156764,
0.0043391525,
0.0013866605,
0.019375449,
-0.082048364,
0.0095736105,
-0.0422734655,
0.0189910196,
0.0046735583,
0.0290117245,
-0.0236831028,
-0.0523946807,
0.0214797184,
0.0265368875,
-0.0541608818,
0.0640095249,
-0.0231851451,
0.0676867068,
-6.842040541e-33,
-0.0072464696,
0.0704180226,
0.0287799239,
0.0051370668,
-0.0110330721,
-0.0042461492,
-0.0305988267,
0.0205914266,
0.0198864788,
-0.0063050548,
-0.0465219095,
-0.0062090387,
0.0523485057,
0.0045834272,
-0.0160843898,
-0.0300862323,
0.1185221896,
-0.0075491434,
0.0170052145,
0.0114577599,
-0.0239226986,
0.0576609261,
0.0230979808,
-0.1258089393,
-0.0798100531,
0.0373186469,
-0.0092072468,
-0.059854541,
0.0602666661,
0.0128840497,
0.0081284149,
0.0268627945,
-0.0109463204,
-0.0249150861,
-0.0659751222,
-0.0080803437,
-0.1089938581,
-0.0358444825,
-0.0428766944,
0.0258283522,
-0.0310709178,
-0.008130962,
0.0255562738,
0.0000099603,
-0.041747231,
-0.0307524018,
0.0278985333,
0.0208239444,
-0.0076416279,
-0.0580026694,
0.0072188429,
0.0431460403,
-0.0007717693,
-0.028032342,
0.0460822582,
0.0281734094,
-0.0455947332,
-0.0175530352,
-0.0216005035,
0.0315563269,
0.0223279744,
0.0376396701,
0.030871788,
0.0051740441,
-0.0222712327,
0.0136055155,
0.0383891165,
-0.0340805426,
0.0637413263,
-0.0402225927,
0.0542295016,
0.0318267904,
-0.053042464,
-0.0247902777,
0.0387084,
-0.076576747,
-0.0381223187,
-0.026143169,
-0.0164478924,
0.0205641352,
-0.0140792578,
0.0240397528,
0.0082609411,
-0.0270495359,
-0.0404459052,
-0.0132707236,
-0.0282175709,
0.0031355172,
0.0565987825,
0.0423839204,
-0.0072008939,
0.0288826916,
0.0561138317,
-0.0363855138,
0.0033699397,
0.0279994849,
0.009491018,
-0.0353917778,
0.0217455458,
0.0059433817,
-0.0388858654,
-0.0290731899,
0.0185251553,
0.0205443632,
-0.0155847464,
-0.0410743766,
0.0223154202,
0.0792448595,
-0.0472990014,
-0.049319014,
-0.0030338382,
0.0116870012,
0.0489149019,
-0.00144884,
0.0573321618,
-0.0036006519,
-0.0062846523,
0.0790497959,
0.0008568137,
-0.0356731042,
0.0038330429,
0.014759074,
0.073724173,
0.0431010313,
-0.0286364686,
-0.0160125941,
0.0125258788,
-0.0572718307,
0.021102814,
-0.0762522817,
-0.0120912921,
-0.0346660092,
2.98e-7,
-0.0527857542,
-0.0103774285,
0.0016626911,
-0.0534770861,
0.0044357218,
-0.0103648035,
-0.024345221,
0.0201881509,
-0.0283851232,
0.0002312398,
0.0412705839,
0.0242189262,
0.0224991757,
0.0096252346,
-0.0288777016,
-0.0207864158,
-0.012691414,
0.0308996979,
0.0119630462,
-0.009733567,
-0.0076006311,
0.073565267,
-0.0081235049,
-0.0510426015,
0.035765633,
-0.0256102867,
0.0257644001,
0.0143264737,
0.024353236,
-0.0210285466,
-0.0158036537,
0.035750106,
-0.0039147655,
-0.0119642979,
-0.0405042134,
0.045522403,
0.0002532314,
0.0244558826,
-0.0271306485,
-0.03625324,
0.0308406148,
0.0654557273,
-0.0056728106,
0.0440757275,
0.0365028456,
-0.0613370985,
-0.0023979938,
0.0015702174,
-0.0705441758,
-0.0417087898,
0.0307654124,
0.0090555409,
0.0133520914,
0.0043739881,
0.0172822755,
0.0010443936,
-0.0576580651,
-0.0662371144,
0.0474920459,
-0.0011396667,
-0.0533046275,
0.000424333,
-0.0464440212,
-0.0065637371,
0.0517008491,
0.0212477446,
0.0230200738,
2.241535025e-34,
0.0489375032,
-0.0438716859,
0.0083944704,
0.0016064969,
-0.0320235714,
-0.0556720719,
0.0138061875,
0.0160095375,
0.0123827308,
-0.0248967949,
-0.0418921784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12773v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12773v1 | Segmenting Messy Text: Detecting Boundaries in Text Derived from Historical Newspaper Images | 2023-12-20T05:17:06 | 2023-12-20T05:17:06 | Carol Anderson, Phil Crone | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.7.5 | Text segmentation, the task of dividing a document into sections, is often a
prerequisite for performing additional natural language processing tasks.
Existing text segmentation methods have typically been developed and tested
using clean, narrative-style text with segments containing distinct topics.
Here we consider a challenging text segmentation task: dividing newspaper
marriage announcement lists into units of one announcement each. In many cases
the information is not structured into sentences, and adjacent segments are not
topically distinct from each other. In addition, the text of the announcements,
which is derived from images of historical newspapers via optical character
recognition, contains many typographical errors. As a result, these
announcements are not amenable to segmentation with existing techniques. We
present a novel deep learning-based model for segmenting such text and show
that it significantly outperforms an existing state-of-the-art method on our
task. | [
0.0293037891,
0.0836037025,
0.0457685478,
0.0445431396,
-0.0576849245,
-0.0004225784,
0.010596714,
0.0196405649,
0.0015094478,
0.003334688,
0.0330505148,
-0.0323558263,
0.0059118732,
0.0100566661,
-0.0766441599,
-0.1001149192,
0.0161579456,
-0.023918245,
0.0080641219,
0.0266463086,
0.0086159678,
0.0134382956,
0.0017238033,
-0.037854448,
-0.0409961119,
-0.0134489471,
-0.0075487499,
0.0378340371,
-0.0031533942,
-0.000278229,
-0.0118544884,
0.0249854811,
0.010986777,
0.0205080695,
0.00000186,
-0.0061980225,
-0.0499744862,
-0.0160420462,
-0.0065808529,
0.0270593297,
0.0764997378,
-0.0708172992,
-0.03795176,
-0.0331181884,
0.0241455678,
0.0211514495,
0.0075031742,
0.1212563664,
0.0174736045,
0.0947135687,
-0.0139489258,
-0.0035401934,
0.0623530336,
-0.004518861,
0.003040809,
-0.0109698605,
0.0043696337,
-0.0504336432,
-0.0333252437,
-0.0221934412,
-0.0084915962,
0.0344967842,
0.0176133234,
-0.0346067809,
-0.0250995792,
0.0209357403,
-0.0111433361,
-0.0136554856,
-0.0551948026,
0.0119373137,
-0.039008908,
0.032329075,
0.0464706905,
-0.0244785063,
-0.0402794853,
-0.0284064002,
-0.0217609685,
0.0376967825,
-0.0266629048,
0.0049954369,
-0.014734867,
0.0020162675,
0.0049083158,
0.0204807464,
-0.0277905725,
0.0724537298,
-0.0149390325,
-0.0457100011,
0.0069851922,
0.0053389687,
0.0100531727,
-0.0231603961,
0.0794363543,
0.0097213341,
0.0663666949,
0.0025070864,
-0.041622255,
-0.084853299,
-0.0146318013,
-0.0234321114,
-0.0207930747,
-0.0386794955,
-0.0381458551,
0.0449447185,
0.0110001434,
0.0192724708,
0.0199271571,
0.0146999704,
-0.0038793038,
0.0065884674,
-0.0028063331,
0.0046956823,
-0.0076550264,
-0.0097416183,
-0.0362554677,
-0.0629849359,
-0.0159973763,
-0.026356915,
0.0015848327,
0.0292033888,
0.0008195221,
0.0187395457,
-0.0065271319,
-0.0439506061,
0.0056493734,
0.0090227332,
-0.0214503668,
-0.0182971153,
0.008421327,
0.0241308808,
0.0218567215,
0.0415869951,
0.0489577353,
0.0084134275,
-0.0031078011,
-0.0083929393,
-0.0706280023,
-0.0277521461,
-0.0189858712,
-0.0342967734,
-0.0771148279,
-0.0334699526,
0.0378237329,
-0.0409291126,
0.0118674235,
-0.0510166399,
-0.0077119647,
-0.0153813753,
0.0103291292,
0.0131475199,
-0.0652750582,
0.0753378645,
-0.0210536867,
0.0132007115,
0.0628322065,
0.0294648763,
0.0782647803,
0.0407132767,
0.0585764796,
0.0648711324,
0.0765301287,
0.0544542894,
0.0185861625,
0.0642197207,
-0.0437798724,
-0.0649254546,
-0.026965199,
-0.0474170521,
-0.0410848297,
0.0306782741,
0.0133721111,
0.0505337454,
-0.0042650374,
0.0260452107,
0.0224903785,
0.0347101986,
-0.0066404617,
0.0344784521,
0.0130176153,
0.0301947761,
-0.0005101889,
0.0425552279,
-0.0302237198,
-0.0437028147,
0.0314616449,
-0.0073129549,
0.0162688512,
-0.005125524,
-0.0103725605,
-0.0291885249,
0.0080546876,
-0.0437821932,
0.0277421642,
-0.0451992117,
0.1133113354,
0.0107529275,
-0.0705113932,
0.0076041487,
-0.0239717457,
-0.0486798473,
0.0231782999,
-0.0020066136,
0.0519183688,
0.0801918954,
0.0440483056,
-0.0441016108,
0.0384961665,
0.0189228971,
0.0564524978,
0.0446357541,
0.024537148,
0.015881028,
0.0049661431,
-0.0795739815,
-0.0095593166,
0.0401526876,
0.0159692857,
-0.0273922514,
0.0117794303,
0.0446970351,
0.0242169127,
0.0085781515,
-0.0068902839,
0.0450588688,
-0.0026957849,
-0.0098872045,
-0.0258625112,
0.0275372453,
-0.0261210781,
0.0223063827,
-0.0195917692,
-0.0365368165,
0.0406126454,
-0.0143660512,
-0.0001356757,
-0.0260714702,
-0.0523681007,
-0.0025053995,
-0.040205799,
-0.0810397491,
-0.0443630479,
-0.0045015235,
-0.0519331396,
-0.0120166307,
0.0386140756,
0.0200307555,
-0.0253133662,
-0.031988956,
0.0047985669,
0.0446741097,
0.0032528385,
-0.0372335799,
0.0606674924,
0.0002467032,
-0.0340459123,
-0.0234736782,
-0.079348281,
-0.0217229091,
-0.0483884811,
0.0147472396,
-0.0401165932,
-0.0396803841,
0.0175920613,
0.0108012054,
0.0429147445,
-0.0105089648,
-0.0771967024,
-0.1241023466,
-0.0147616565,
-0.0426647067,
-0.0096156243,
0.004383917,
0.00194499,
-0.0098934369,
-0.0097673098,
0.002717704,
0.0122294975,
0.0083387783,
-0.0361748636,
0.0713037625,
-0.0199026354,
0.0094636995,
-0.0208464134,
-0.0314521007,
-0.0062504089,
0.0211145692,
0.0232473612,
-0.0546172895,
-0.0527244285,
-0.010247658,
0.0120774647,
0.0357596055,
-0.004656388,
0.0181946326,
-0.0104063209,
-0.0225676745,
0.020414317,
0.1067016274,
0.0295120347,
0.0519918837,
-0.029717166,
0.0032829857,
0.0304098316,
0.0077174101,
-0.0101216026,
0.0899425149,
0.0011411468,
-0.0353570804,
0.0274892002,
-0.0039115073,
-0.0342527665,
0.0416825265,
0.0336144902,
-0.0653360933,
-0.0266535431,
-0.0258262586,
-0.0021747949,
-0.0299193785,
0.0242361426,
0.0459123813,
-0.0323580056,
0.0139416512,
-0.0149696311,
0.0001756833,
-0.0052623255,
-0.0317034833,
-0.0236746781,
-0.031491179,
0.0456206724,
0.0245840922,
0.0293886401,
0.0114005124,
-0.0351529233,
-0.0289854649,
-0.0246378575,
-0.0382970199,
0.008630462,
0.0900150537,
-0.0553018562,
-0.00587501,
-0.0044493587,
-0.0241269376,
-0.0262289997,
-0.012631489,
0.0064575099,
-0.0142553095,
-0.0251071006,
0.0094263945,
-0.0254091099,
0.0295477845,
-0.0286497995,
0.0901218802,
0.0060335947,
0.0066196108,
-0.0385949872,
0.094891116,
0.0281654093,
-0.0194998458,
0.0051280134,
-0.0571551695,
-0.0406947918,
0.0380996503,
0.0561649464,
0.0315746255,
0.0036580993,
0.0029912847,
-0.0116029996,
-0.0338493772,
0.0001645678,
-0.0179433245,
0.0393405594,
-0.0843997747,
-0.0275709461,
0.0961499512,
0.0450513028,
-0.0138438512,
-0.0429644026,
0.002876,
-0.0452513471,
-0.0596804321,
0.0085105514,
-0.0501209758,
-0.012316525,
0.0186213776,
-0.0169623476,
0.0301985331,
-0.0049507297,
-0.0028989236,
-0.0424854532,
0.0390553474,
-0.0117252246,
0.0081087844,
-0.0396546051,
-0.0238852911,
-0.0321819969,
-0.0341483057,
0.0009466188,
-0.0062440336,
-0.0187823679,
-0.0708568096,
-0.0021976831,
-0.0811273977,
0.0046919119,
-0.0339324176,
-0.04672518,
-0.0141606228,
0.0474775359,
0.0538809486,
-0.0450714789,
-0.005539509,
0.0662517026,
-0.0115377111,
-0.0247505661,
-0.0110644819,
0.0754382536,
-0.0095800012,
0.0100770118,
0.0139471442,
0.032169994,
0.018145673,
-0.0161162503,
0.0239718091,
-0.0220799521,
0.0038147443,
-0.0491340347,
-0.0242128391,
0.0318450369,
-0.0093093533,
0.0323498882,
-0.0275922269,
-0.0493519716,
-0.0694162995,
-0.0417736694,
0.0517147928,
-0.0557125024,
0.0166312419,
0.0013080823,
-0.0209578052,
-0.0542212166,
-0.0581045598,
-0.0376961492,
0.0268843025,
0.0246838164,
0.0430198126,
-0.0269757416,
0.0125844814,
-0.0016578123,
-0.0552349463,
-0.0030840719,
-0.0402033217,
-0.0293217674,
-0.0565604791,
0.0526962206,
-0.0505067296,
-0.0093534058,
-0.0240554046,
0.0217639841,
-0.0622870624,
0.0002833159,
0.0474668257,
-0.0166378263,
0.0106614241,
0.0118527729,
-0.026981391,
-0.0458087735,
0.0374830998,
0.0171034131,
0.0500141755,
-0.0363734476,
-0.0026718837,
0.0024919016,
-0.019066168,
0.0149451531,
0.0005674921,
0.0259312075,
-0.0028324211,
-0.0457662456,
-0.0598566867,
-0.0045650611,
-0.0671505257,
-0.0173794162,
0.0606338531,
-0.0153740812,
-0.0117692128,
-0.0681950375,
0.0007741866,
-0.0040710401,
0.0127963927,
-0.0208404586,
0.0189682804,
-0.003380928,
0.028921742,
-0.0208310224,
0.0469332375,
0.0200600661,
0.0181585327,
-0.0529998355,
-0.0164344013,
0.0437960178,
0.0455907173,
-0.021436356,
0.001919944,
0.0178711973,
0.0519613773,
-0.0110803656,
0.0490818247,
-0.0082980553,
0.0258611981,
0.0193797946,
0.0113568902,
-0.0131209996,
0.0260534696,
-0.0174329802,
0.0034894957,
-0.0554216132,
0.0667471886,
0.0428374857,
-0.0367100611,
0.0369283855,
-0.0328296497,
-0.0073240525,
-0.0224473793,
0.0052350713,
0.0295979138,
-0.0030266575,
-0.0245810784,
0.0211444106,
0.003069195,
0.0158393867,
-0.0090298988,
0.0007288451,
0.0233602691,
0.0607383512,
-0.0191283617,
-0.0629809871,
0.0203706808,
0.0465828106,
-0.019183334,
-0.0090408996,
0.0015313292,
0.0015945595,
0.0370567217,
0.0676872581,
0.0282971077,
0.0380728878,
0.012466521,
0.0076629985,
0.0463468954,
-0.009345727,
0.0198551416,
-0.0071727396,
-0.035632506,
0.0120966258,
-0.0662113205,
0.0215778053,
-5.819582698e-33,
-0.0089765042,
-0.0182638727,
-0.0027967545,
-0.0099472255,
-0.0451659597,
0.0131800417,
-0.0099401837,
-0.0179602131,
0.0241959244,
0.0185574256,
-0.0072403015,
-0.0077248472,
0.0643728673,
0.0318963081,
-0.0161137171,
-0.0053006131,
0.0476684645,
-0.0254809186,
-0.0180164166,
-0.0091442801,
0.0099162161,
0.0395329073,
0.0103577124,
-0.0270810146,
0.0119898962,
0.0246116035,
-0.0505475216,
-0.0120749008,
0.0568453595,
0.0081228251,
-0.0088397805,
-0.0598627999,
0.0273138173,
0.0238170903,
0.0177701358,
0.0879276022,
-0.0914796665,
0.020467313,
-0.0412070043,
0.0340826102,
-0.0163478032,
0.0067840265,
0.0443343557,
0.0016513108,
0.0234990697,
-0.0302975122,
0.0809735134,
-0.0186873171,
0.012794693,
-0.0181505624,
-0.0431449711,
0.0262607168,
-0.0025740552,
-0.0222373065,
0.0824864209,
-0.0174426157,
0.0258536749,
0.0294834562,
-0.0666708052,
-0.0071705603,
0.0521508828,
0.0540936515,
0.0170358699,
-0.0310756117,
-0.0726035461,
0.0280653983,
0.0244281329,
-0.0215183608,
-0.0018590669,
0.0077492357,
0.0269879643,
0.0594754741,
0.0447045304,
-0.0187157094,
0.0570898205,
-0.0043223049,
-0.0660086721,
0.0126449885,
0.0363918506,
-0.015521789,
0.0198628977,
0.0154721625,
-0.0160735603,
0.0346862003,
0.0331203565,
-0.0459826663,
-0.0107239913,
0.007267457,
0.0099774795,
0.0700533539,
-0.0320155472,
0.0411158763,
0.0175971463,
-0.0028598823,
-0.0405444577,
-0.0497603379,
-0.004449469,
0.0674226135,
-0.0148040112,
-0.0215752423,
-0.0735071227,
-0.0466706902,
0.0287124068,
0.0518631451,
-0.0193321016,
-0.0065375697,
0.0499237254,
-0.0121789481,
-0.0527157672,
0.0092423838,
0.0236565229,
0.0254581813,
0.0163907632,
0.0744712278,
0.0012186624,
-0.0239184164,
0.0008088911,
0.0415536091,
0.0314293653,
-0.0140036037,
0.0188021436,
-0.0129822325,
-0.001535237,
0.0229974091,
-0.0289913993,
0.0313582085,
0.0121021783,
-0.0520560369,
0.0086959209,
-0.0091987913,
0.0037032806,
0.0175489448,
2.343e-7,
0.0164000094,
0.069528684,
0.0857261419,
-0.00335887,
0.0104288086,
0.0012254543,
-0.0022284223,
0.0127327796,
-0.0536037236,
-0.0053423168,
0.0597314425,
0.0112277688,
0.0936548486,
-0.026253324,
-0.0947540328,
0.0110654281,
-0.0204530936,
-0.0338890888,
-0.0447590202,
-0.0256169755,
0.021249054,
0.0364120454,
0.0192935597,
-0.0247080922,
0.0112572052,
-0.0264387988,
0.0060763541,
-0.0126333414,
-0.0239492077,
0.0178422779,
0.0144920647,
0.0020195618,
-0.0591954254,
0.0011966091,
-0.0015308002,
-0.0212414358,
0.0539303906,
0.0776782259,
-0.0029307522,
0.0480692126,
0.0206254143,
0.0248144399,
-0.0097090947,
-0.0099014854,
0.0509243198,
0.0027491073,
0.0491581373,
-0.0269468483,
0.0069087096,
0.0012145723,
0.0215267539,
-0.010679963,
-0.0155718885,
0.0379847847,
0.0538996495,
-0.0145374136,
-0.0313886814,
-0.0528352298,
0.02060204,
0.0198936556,
-0.0070702941,
0.0254209861,
-0.0257559605,
-0.0020334711,
-0.0459914766,
-0.0647850037,
-0.0370459594,
2.346829013e-34,
0.0429268405,
0.0105263991,
-0.0838595852,
0.0062677902,
0.0271626282,
-0.0018878571,
-0.0392269231,
-0.0282831471,
-0.0582848825,
-0.0067686788,
0.0347550735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12764v1 | Lattice Rescoring Based on Large Ensemble of Complementary Neural Language Models | 2023-12-20T04:52:24 | 2023-12-20T04:52:24 | Atsunori Ogawa, Naohiro Tawara, Marc Delcroix, Shoko Araki | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | We investigate the effectiveness of using a large ensemble of advanced neural
language models (NLMs) for lattice rescoring on automatic speech recognition
(ASR) hypotheses. Previous studies have reported the effectiveness of combining
a small number of NLMs. In contrast, in this study, we combine up to eight
NLMs, i.e., forward/backward long short-term memory/Transformer-LMs that are
trained with two different random initialization seeds. We combine these NLMs
through iterative lattice generation. Since these NLMs work complementarily
with each other, by combining them one by one at each rescoring iteration,
language scores attached to given lattice arcs can be gradually refined.
Consequently, errors of the ASR hypotheses can be gradually reduced. We also
investigate the effectiveness of carrying over contextual information (previous
rescoring results) across a lattice sequence of a long speech such as a lecture
speech. In experiments using a lecture speech corpus, by combining the eight
NLMs and using context carry-over, we obtained a 24.4% relative word error rate
reduction from the ASR 1-best baseline. For further comparison, we performed
simultaneous (i.e., non-iterative) NLM combination and 100-best rescoring using
the large ensemble of NLMs, which confirmed the advantage of lattice rescoring
with iterative NLM combination. | [
-0.0388102978,
0.0573960952,
0.0047022756,
0.0345305689,
-0.0153981848,
-0.0067725112,
0.0143046705,
-0.0165858567,
-0.050784573,
-0.0255884565,
-0.0707853884,
-0.0639245957,
0.0547148883,
-0.0649130195,
0.0162290968,
-0.020613512,
-0.0110968435,
-0.0671127066,
-0.0286353957,
-0.03714763,
-0.0209475197,
0.0168849137,
-0.0220471248,
0.0391429216,
0.0172321759,
0.0050244611,
0.0196588915,
0.0376054496,
0.0347796306,
-0.050917156,
-0.0063297339,
0.0181605984,
0.0171472877,
0.0054240637,
0.0000022424,
-0.0004284251,
-0.0282185879,
0.0020590981,
-0.053425774,
0.0082860216,
0.0218224637,
-0.0265055597,
-0.0121597862,
0.0466802269,
-0.0247129817,
-0.0345999934,
0.0414992273,
0.0124111725,
0.0058393218,
0.0325167291,
0.0134799667,
-0.0480511151,
0.036420092,
-0.0099679055,
-0.0303989779,
-0.0536428168,
0.0235684235,
0.0260535255,
0.0097001577,
0.0101457564,
-0.005867783,
0.0497813337,
-0.0112415506,
-0.0083784675,
-0.0425700583,
0.0192944221,
0.016983781,
0.0046247379,
-0.0348555781,
0.0428108945,
-0.0005800457,
-0.0433225855,
-0.0118328119,
0.0126644932,
-0.0134883653,
0.0133681847,
-0.03719493,
0.0553490072,
-0.0022604894,
0.0266749989,
0.0066670664,
0.0163320359,
0.0737773925,
0.0122294659,
-0.0208966751,
0.0359970517,
0.0247774106,
-0.0397267714,
-0.0308717098,
-0.0168021861,
0.0180728193,
0.009561344,
0.0496653058,
0.0308944378,
0.0167074073,
0.0347014591,
-0.0201059505,
-0.0378770269,
0.0052312366,
-0.0431093797,
0.0107642328,
0.0469873175,
-0.0100678252,
-0.0122317029,
-0.0604141355,
0.040083766,
0.0257252157,
0.0406037606,
-0.0345298871,
-0.0252058618,
-0.0215825811,
0.0161593892,
-0.012313759,
0.0277203638,
-0.025944924,
0.003820549,
-0.0521789715,
0.0149460109,
0.0064918697,
-0.0061046607,
0.0021962372,
-0.0145289116,
0.0023251518,
-0.0360534936,
0.0350072309,
-0.0078376709,
0.0086040515,
0.0530933328,
0.0094536869,
-0.0869495794,
-0.0293325037,
-0.0099071329,
0.0181741174,
0.0176188238,
0.0233355965,
0.0227651037,
0.0232545771,
-0.035881117,
-0.0630015433,
0.0412888788,
-0.0728946477,
-0.0290704258,
0.0129461875,
-0.0912390202,
0.0183834527,
0.0072602457,
0.0330808535,
-0.0424718447,
0.0139769213,
-0.010632487,
0.0027705107,
0.0518002138,
0.01069865,
0.0050839935,
0.0501713715,
0.0019253336,
0.0835472494,
0.0501881391,
0.0646468326,
-0.0034055624,
-0.0279146135,
-0.0179882031,
0.040825557,
0.0324341953,
0.006857947,
0.0154701676,
-0.0508659557,
-0.0282641221,
0.0496556833,
0.027463546,
0.0368102267,
0.0515947193,
-0.0442553349,
-0.0212522428,
0.0463539101,
0.0251835752,
0.0734021813,
0.0323033035,
-0.018485548,
-0.028331669,
0.0357890427,
-0.0117260125,
-0.0197195355,
0.0164822023,
-0.037360806,
0.0186572652,
0.0372954421,
0.0458689705,
-0.0291009117,
-0.0398213454,
-0.0424643978,
-0.0245763157,
-0.033742696,
0.021166496,
0.0424865037,
0.0215693191,
-0.0728133544,
0.020666929,
-0.0101451715,
-0.0581190996,
0.0071065244,
-0.0634835586,
-0.0257093497,
0.074881129,
0.0407648608,
-0.0128570711,
-0.0348514505,
-0.0321549922,
-0.0882637724,
0.0225045923,
-0.0106030591,
0.0334160253,
0.0466413759,
-0.098971352,
0.0214590039,
0.0499574617,
0.0119654294,
0.0642094091,
-0.0104931472,
-0.0032565228,
0.010393043,
-0.0292969327,
-0.0254889578,
0.0133435447,
-0.0295352265,
-0.0182336848,
0.0282491967,
-0.0063189263,
0.0393250212,
0.0247417148,
-0.0291322228,
0.0119234584,
0.0564226881,
-0.0198117793,
-0.0622830763,
-0.0114360638,
-0.1201155931,
-0.1030140892,
0.0163180754,
0.021731602,
0.0553773195,
-0.0203621909,
0.0165525209,
-0.0843925327,
0.0164187737,
-0.029927291,
0.0231536962,
-0.0627775714,
0.0889775679,
0.0201587118,
0.0306955501,
-0.0476681478,
0.0036779537,
-0.0239133649,
0.0104691861,
0.0301651303,
0.0011189213,
-0.0218537599,
-0.091652751,
-0.018942181,
0.0100583211,
-0.0292412918,
0.0666025802,
-0.0118989665,
-0.0155184437,
0.010509125,
-0.0556223728,
-0.0645141453,
-0.0146022504,
-0.0213056896,
0.004038522,
-0.0068399236,
-0.0081001548,
-0.0055181202,
-0.0038309246,
0.001644772,
-0.0381593704,
0.0033065481,
-0.0120235048,
-0.0240670275,
0.0059942137,
-0.026320722,
-0.0284030419,
-0.0163511354,
-0.0164862443,
0.0481170751,
-0.010686948,
-0.0265694726,
-0.05872868,
0.0225262959,
0.0284816511,
-0.0090089627,
-0.0046610241,
-0.037623588,
-0.0120036732,
-0.0197259597,
0.0353587009,
0.0435254872,
-0.0069755935,
-0.0303586498,
0.0314197429,
-0.0115593867,
-0.0473795198,
-0.0032338598,
0.008315484,
0.0210148375,
0.0025922079,
-0.0290575959,
-0.050573241,
0.0222196598,
0.0675972924,
0.0459854528,
-0.0193940699,
-0.0186994057,
0.0078803143,
-0.0154026207,
-0.0088464431,
-0.0493120365,
-0.0184676573,
0.0082746176,
-0.0049000485,
-0.0255190674,
0.0239598677,
-0.093033053,
-0.0142195728,
-0.0327847451,
-0.0256177951,
-0.0422097594,
-0.0107630063,
0.0200347789,
0.0082074404,
-0.0490104519,
-0.0340580083,
-0.0076122973,
-0.0273305103,
-0.0212319568,
-0.069056578,
0.0744289756,
-0.0334417708,
0.0317991674,
0.000008045,
-0.0398493223,
-0.0418618284,
0.0163391195,
-0.0042007351,
0.0314510986,
0.0087969322,
-0.0162175726,
-0.0007113133,
0.0749729946,
0.0141858477,
0.0591445044,
-0.0005247669,
0.0123530664,
0.0050724554,
0.0592473075,
-0.0245777089,
0.0233823974,
0.0185162071,
0.010113691,
0.057975471,
-0.0429410078,
0.0902981386,
0.0427183658,
-0.076849483,
-0.0112968041,
0.039136529,
0.0026655549,
0.0002854808,
-0.0047829682,
0.0057599088,
-0.0717784539,
0.0176393129,
0.099832505,
-0.0047132573,
-0.0351084098,
-0.044169534,
0.0195177849,
-0.0164911151,
-0.0027606606,
-0.0265889335,
-0.0170283318,
-0.0240657385,
0.0413711518,
0.0173768476,
0.011212321,
0.0086175362,
0.0021832846,
-0.1194996387,
0.0271680783,
0.0523250252,
-0.03084727,
-0.0219116434,
-0.0426360182,
-0.0067841844,
0.0001912444,
0.0248684082,
0.050447531,
-0.0260017216,
-0.044778429,
0.0679898337,
-0.0466851033,
-0.0292416811,
-0.0141041745,
-0.0307279453,
0.0990545526,
0.061543256,
0.0049971626,
-0.0350942798,
-0.0135243749,
0.0264975075,
-0.0473459587,
0.0342058428,
-0.0018434151,
0.0208831616,
0.0354352072,
0.0019460531,
0.0401861668,
0.025268998,
-0.0340949222,
-0.0139477579,
-0.0043517947,
0.033885479,
-0.0356435739,
0.0108671766,
0.008105292,
0.0298320148,
0.0064972849,
0.0544550978,
0.0174839571,
0.0138945375,
-0.0117239021,
0.0128903724,
0.0304039549,
-0.0649918318,
0.0275395233,
0.056950327,
0.025137255,
0.0124950232,
-0.02895022,
-0.0223754495,
-0.0044163279,
0.0464585461,
0.0502079874,
0.0191377643,
-0.0453360304,
0.0390217863,
-0.0189025868,
-0.0142463492,
-0.0379286334,
0.0253396034,
-0.0658819079,
0.0203170832,
0.0451655723,
-0.05781826,
-0.0113113234,
0.0146478349,
-0.0633148104,
-0.0300158188,
0.040708337,
0.0213040765,
0.012206235,
0.067818962,
0.0128226103,
-0.0131724179,
0.1315909177,
0.0432313494,
-0.0062328447,
0.0269253459,
0.0223849975,
0.0358312428,
-0.023379406,
0.0171802994,
-0.0311974101,
0.060708385,
0.0074556395,
0.0459685661,
-0.0134807536,
-0.1117712632,
0.0072824033,
0.0179306362,
0.018453544,
-0.0091168191,
0.0249775201,
-0.0097957663,
0.0522922985,
0.0110989641,
0.0604829825,
0.0049222023,
-0.0214435365,
0.0513747595,
-0.0238335282,
-0.0060925214,
0.0101191839,
0.0143630831,
-0.0026961034,
-0.0059429044,
0.0528596118,
-0.0211801268,
0.0388394035,
-0.0201975498,
0.0219576452,
-0.0426093712,
0.0468810834,
0.0228299424,
0.0263721943,
-0.0053748381,
0.0234449618,
-0.0260355584,
0.0230444726,
-0.048616536,
0.0446736328,
-0.0615769066,
-0.0332005322,
-0.0596377254,
0.0268671196,
0.0303450339,
0.0342383161,
0.0761235654,
-0.0128309177,
0.0361351073,
-0.0680373833,
0.0213617105,
0.0060061738,
0.0030317523,
0.0361056775,
0.0133140972,
-0.0122497277,
0.002413718,
0.0471377969,
-0.0370143279,
0.0168710127,
0.0036611638,
0.0152939716,
-0.0243779663,
-0.0195099674,
-0.0427904353,
-0.0669848025,
-0.0333481617,
-0.0283457786,
-0.0028603959,
-0.0393546112,
0.0614340156,
-0.0123164849,
0.0567330979,
-0.0656789616,
0.0123681361,
0.0149264447,
-0.0434391461,
0.0356241651,
0.0012681315,
-0.0162621234,
0.0014677721,
-0.0199880283,
-0.0295314472,
-6.66277251e-33,
-0.0508297533,
0.0031928243,
0.0409892052,
0.011926014,
-0.0050810915,
-0.0172498077,
-0.0126543837,
-0.000094339,
-0.0231727604,
-0.0454552807,
-0.02797064,
0.0242754053,
0.0414198637,
0.0175623447,
-0.0114262179,
-0.0023245243,
0.0927318335,
0.0068264618,
-0.0066224015,
0.0021226343,
0.0255339723,
0.0555429198,
0.0591652505,
-0.0682552606,
-0.0273193736,
0.0290221609,
-0.0260145087,
-0.0372643955,
-0.0004911119,
0.0266305003,
-0.001050017,
0.0311293416,
0.0205032043,
-0.0582633764,
-0.0044284901,
0.0478315018,
-0.0866803303,
0.0069509409,
0.0196399018,
0.0438209027,
0.0199926905,
-0.0475339852,
0.0520745032,
-0.0045031514,
-0.0543378405,
0.0172186382,
-0.0008454259,
-0.0630965829,
-0.0547551177,
-0.0403063409,
0.0054896786,
0.0393675342,
-0.0005107155,
-0.0473004356,
0.0376027338,
0.0007704227,
-0.0462426618,
0.0332655348,
-0.1080599651,
0.0106900912,
0.0329126492,
0.0562751107,
0.0265462399,
0.0738497004,
-0.0144463982,
0.0167978965,
0.0124100037,
-0.0475025512,
0.0049814298,
-0.061286319,
0.0314929932,
0.0263968147,
0.0277266297,
0.0118357036,
0.0295392647,
-0.0313499831,
-0.0393122844,
0.0087746317,
-0.0038300743,
0.011957977,
0.0525485724,
0.0222044773,
-0.00270113,
-0.0152167613,
-0.0930741727,
-0.0573968664,
-0.0174268503,
0.0123909255,
0.0369807184,
0.006671241,
0.0014011684,
-0.0515691824,
0.0348277614,
-0.0481248833,
-0.0050338702,
0.0074351975,
-0.0173033122,
-0.0257141776,
-0.0151044745,
0.0253871642,
-0.0341172144,
-0.0186841153,
-0.0007090368,
0.0539520979,
0.0093456535,
-0.0106686298,
0.0283185989,
0.0471150577,
-0.0689039603,
-0.0072479974,
-0.0093500521,
-0.0116450181,
-0.0062923427,
0.007853725,
0.0290985145,
0.028094342,
0.0374573916,
0.0282333847,
-0.0059623038,
0.0318268538,
0.0155455824,
-0.0266580172,
0.0079783993,
0.0380846299,
-0.0181258153,
0.0103971632,
0.0147017743,
-0.0625964627,
0.0413792059,
-0.0310654994,
0.0049582184,
0.0198119301,
2.988e-7,
-0.0030235273,
0.0304038934,
0.0323424339,
-0.0275402889,
-0.0068069748,
0.0086842906,
-0.034064237,
-0.0212671794,
0.0191597193,
0.0082360189,
0.0200922005,
0.0125730624,
0.0891536996,
0.0218420774,
-0.0842047036,
-0.0042312103,
-0.0744452551,
0.0360625088,
0.0172533691,
-0.0121460119,
-0.0191817749,
0.0893117338,
-0.0274858829,
-0.0336181149,
-0.0253088512,
-0.0492956378,
0.0574146546,
0.0039725923,
-0.0145494714,
0.0238158405,
0.0087102139,
0.0151801491,
-0.0093042813,
0.0222833194,
0.0094178831,
0.0351800099,
0.0018932677,
0.0119775655,
-0.0151918,
-0.0485161208,
0.0043993872,
0.0053062639,
0.0011396788,
0.0051145949,
0.0260050576,
-0.0123269465,
0.0117417872,
0.0173500683,
-0.023167586,
0.0110983495,
0.0583823845,
0.0093811685,
0.0288064722,
0.0155615387,
0.0136072999,
0.0246412456,
-0.0278354175,
-0.0642769858,
0.0006642672,
0.0154804317,
-0.0529763699,
-0.0287052579,
-0.0053495844,
-0.030165609,
0.024804892,
-0.0393257439,
-0.0237842854,
2.485285947e-34,
0.0298178401,
-0.0439845435,
0.0066597667,
0.0510846227,
0.008142936,
-0.043093361,
-0.0510651171,
0.0433682166,
-0.0257706232,
-0.0853192285,
-0.0271167159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12754v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12754v2 | Spectral Prompt Tuning:Unveiling Unseen Classes for Zero-Shot Semantic Segmentation | 2023-12-20T04:27:13 | 2024-06-03T03:17:01 | Wenhao Xu, Rongtao Xu, Changwei Wang, Shibiao Xu, Li Guo, Man Zhang, Xiaopeng Zhang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recently, CLIP has found practical utility in the domain of pixel-level
zero-shot segmentation tasks. The present landscape features two-stage
methodologies beset by issues such as intricate pipelines and elevated
computational costs. While current one-stage approaches alleviate these
concerns and incorporate Visual Prompt Training (VPT) to uphold CLIP's
generalization capacity, they still fall short in fully harnessing CLIP's
potential for pixel-level unseen class demarcation and precise pixel
predictions. To further stimulate CLIP's zero-shot dense prediction capability,
we propose SPT-SEG, a one-stage approach that improves CLIP's adaptability from
image to pixel. Specifically, we initially introduce Spectral Prompt Tuning
(SPT), incorporating spectral prompts into the CLIP visual encoder's shallow
layers to capture structural intricacies of images, thereby enhancing
comprehension of unseen classes. Subsequently, we introduce the Spectral Guided
Decoder (SGD), utilizing both high and low-frequency information to steer the
network's spatial focus towards more prominent classification features,
enabling precise pixel-level prediction outcomes. Through extensive experiments
on two public datasets, we demonstrate the superiority of our method over
state-of-the-art approaches, performing well across all classes and
particularly excelling in handling unseen classes. Code is available
at:https://github.com/clearxu/SPT. | [
-0.0243693348,
0.0338128544,
0.0493283793,
0.0378382541,
-0.0115920473,
-0.020774927,
0.0241506808,
-0.0350762606,
-0.0828621611,
-0.0145234484,
-0.0305939484,
0.0548898391,
-0.0155526279,
0.042661909,
-0.0344500951,
-0.05862239,
-0.0000456004,
-0.0044333516,
-0.0032076892,
0.022677239,
0.0001254732,
0.0059101195,
-0.0140129169,
0.0147394389,
-0.0427234434,
0.0012324047,
-0.0439428985,
0.027487034,
0.0384073928,
-0.063874498,
0.0172345564,
0.0213464387,
0.037154641,
0.0340332389,
0.0000022036,
-0.0105693433,
-0.0125192516,
-0.0025366191,
-0.0327015109,
-0.0147207892,
-0.0312834457,
-0.0489002503,
-0.0147457663,
-0.0680321828,
-0.0045051137,
-0.0024845791,
0.0745161697,
0.023091292,
0.0140299704,
0.0157884732,
-0.0072470126,
-0.024271518,
-0.0130514754,
-0.03741372,
0.0476931632,
0.0166554525,
0.0161638688,
-0.0624795482,
-0.0720435902,
-0.0036113784,
-0.056315694,
0.0199999698,
0.0134680923,
0.0052992953,
0.0469369106,
0.033466395,
-0.0912711695,
-0.0373909101,
0.0148546584,
0.0453664176,
-0.0277846083,
-0.0058000577,
0.0120049044,
0.0041210023,
-0.0111019434,
-0.0531056076,
-0.0383898281,
0.0161536597,
-0.0090243844,
0.0231259838,
-0.0631395727,
0.0669526383,
0.0046669026,
-0.0028158142,
-0.0021501635,
0.0050816541,
0.0220154189,
0.012770093,
0.0018516647,
0.0103196222,
-0.036266543,
-0.0035890522,
-0.0012405831,
-0.0043573566,
-0.0252761599,
-0.0178803653,
-0.03084209,
0.025864359,
-0.0158441998,
0.0478854291,
0.0493625738,
0.0278584342,
0.0035428323,
0.0545509197,
-0.0443081185,
-0.0343854576,
0.0132626388,
0.0900876895,
-0.0091024814,
-0.00077301,
-0.0517899953,
-0.0137865944,
-0.0496775247,
-0.0095000193,
0.001274117,
0.0123653738,
-0.0186668597,
-0.0527980439,
-0.0458460152,
0.0485075451,
-0.0230680592,
0.0313599594,
-0.0606298633,
-0.0099489912,
0.00077109,
0.0153466742,
-0.0323467329,
0.0037726902,
0.0276363827,
-0.051419206,
-0.0143427625,
0.0244800486,
0.0268208385,
0.0004727145,
0.0165583454,
0.0483517163,
-0.0380011573,
-0.0361166485,
-0.0171717033,
-0.0134905772,
-0.0211608261,
-0.0195175596,
0.0561120585,
-0.0156647954,
0.0014234463,
-0.0203536414,
0.0097930869,
0.007034231,
0.0064882059,
0.0125318803,
0.0118782548,
0.0483464226,
-0.031249335,
-0.0348399058,
-0.0011527101,
0.0213311985,
-0.0184674747,
0.0578643791,
0.0031509991,
0.0422741026,
0.0018929085,
0.0183065739,
0.0109956991,
0.0152869849,
0.0092542889,
-0.0001358769,
-0.0762763917,
-0.0324127115,
0.0021794636,
-0.0079883132,
0.0900380537,
-0.0583948083,
-0.0148180509,
-0.0675603375,
-0.032393571,
0.0210432578,
-0.0297635477,
-0.0121681187,
0.0635245144,
0.017534839,
-0.0365446284,
-0.0159498174,
-0.0282428116,
0.0181637388,
0.013969643,
-0.0006221453,
-0.0228816308,
0.0102319075,
-0.047431156,
-0.0248848163,
0.017005682,
0.0042405464,
-0.0124972379,
-0.0040254723,
0.0836577788,
0.0331662893,
0.0100252843,
0.0627333894,
0.0023405417,
-0.0084538367,
-0.0124556515,
-0.032697659,
0.0246637408,
0.0195312034,
0.0186872892,
-0.0408314392,
-0.0213991478,
0.0090372665,
0.0358083434,
0.0419278815,
-0.0142116202,
-0.0257883053,
0.0519660935,
-0.0600419492,
-0.0286131054,
-0.0657757223,
0.023389075,
0.0534532778,
0.0055952216,
-0.0095562432,
0.0209218357,
-0.0360738449,
0.0248527098,
0.0271646939,
0.0398664735,
-0.0457749031,
-0.0086398106,
0.005311029,
-0.0239732899,
-0.0099447556,
-0.0246709231,
-0.0407199934,
0.0233743079,
-0.0252934601,
0.0310429279,
-0.0662761554,
-0.0865971968,
-0.024776442,
0.0102113038,
-0.061806269,
-0.0103913145,
0.0215139017,
-0.0825230107,
-0.0152806463,
0.065304555,
0.0703572333,
-0.0197584219,
-0.0259274505,
-0.0280944016,
0.0022837278,
-0.0088891918,
0.0040702303,
0.0191796664,
0.0222759861,
-0.0068229036,
0.049275618,
-0.0041170376,
0.0201721881,
-0.0212639384,
0.0240401402,
-0.0141875325,
-0.0385280512,
-0.0272934325,
0.0015725986,
0.0053141885,
-0.0601060838,
0.0370871127,
-0.0388566107,
0.0042099715,
-0.0287173651,
-0.014514178,
-0.005622704,
-0.014867303,
0.0055914801,
-0.0583766326,
-0.0142737636,
0.0473105125,
-0.0331923775,
-0.0147936633,
-0.0154682714,
0.0064055272,
-0.0212206952,
-0.0051022191,
-0.0207411349,
0.0483697429,
0.0251085591,
-0.0075411764,
-0.0492422581,
0.01416915,
0.0402199179,
-0.0235523842,
-0.0001599225,
-0.0208779797,
0.0159630831,
-0.0101970118,
-0.0566245019,
-0.0346080661,
0.0507968701,
-0.0230176672,
-0.0115458546,
0.0051942728,
0.0105567519,
0.0072496948,
-0.0207847394,
-0.0204231776,
-0.0301015805,
-0.0036833482,
0.0511113256,
-0.0034155149,
0.0695260316,
0.0015158912,
0.0120597472,
-0.0318924375,
0.0178714767,
-0.0044101155,
-0.0383442678,
-0.0567918122,
0.0120574133,
0.0068829632,
-0.0067527792,
-0.0538244098,
-0.0305601303,
0.020162737,
-0.004194044,
-0.043847885,
0.032583531,
-0.0119081391,
-0.0311939809,
-0.0012298789,
0.0318583101,
0.0042177159,
0.0049985889,
-0.0397392772,
-0.0218034331,
-0.0302658826,
0.0092212232,
0.0427641794,
0.0158032384,
-0.0392327756,
-0.027032271,
-0.0587692484,
-0.0030654122,
-0.0524149053,
0.0252632722,
-0.0682281405,
0.0725080222,
-0.0496655926,
0.0142223975,
0.0110366251,
-0.0372086912,
-0.0059509864,
0.096224077,
-0.0358252786,
-0.0224541984,
-0.0236189533,
0.0426584221,
-0.0075024534,
0.0130868312,
-0.033035852,
-0.0255939011,
0.0214015432,
0.0612976104,
-0.0123786656,
0.00276309,
-0.0575242601,
0.0363432728,
0.0190469045,
-0.0117007419,
0.0200008824,
0.0353567712,
0.0599255264,
-0.0914963633,
-0.0291761104,
0.0274633728,
0.0222148243,
-0.0506740995,
-0.0316766389,
0.0040378338,
0.0572996624,
0.0538609847,
-0.0144444061,
-0.0826796517,
-0.0892191827,
0.0016399109,
-0.0012520585,
0.044506222,
0.0086442512,
-0.0378216803,
-0.0413232595,
0.0753972754,
0.0273673683,
-0.0556958765,
0.0150546553,
-0.0058861221,
0.023620002,
-0.0027444577,
-0.0525992177,
0.0010202649,
-0.0036997444,
0.0224734694,
0.026662739,
0.0059970962,
0.0014639902,
-0.007892143,
-0.0080556758,
-0.037793491,
0.0900262222,
-0.0297092069,
0.0151426001,
-0.0203774441,
0.0452571958,
-0.1062329561,
0.0118453959,
-0.0118417265,
0.1147184446,
-0.0374051556,
0.0337102488,
0.0269739088,
0.0837427527,
-0.0332291871,
-0.0142319174,
0.0354199037,
0.0193591826,
-0.0030419733,
-0.0306288879,
-0.0323294401,
-0.0162049271,
0.0135460515,
0.0280799549,
0.0255794749,
0.0169950891,
-0.0470268689,
-0.0289813876,
0.0298051536,
-0.0753397495,
0.0165253431,
0.0059689158,
0.0080766594,
-0.0839924589,
0.0620754547,
-0.004055358,
0.0686156675,
0.0009092824,
-0.0248871297,
-0.0628774092,
-0.0081255874,
0.0219150241,
-0.0659896657,
0.0327503048,
-0.031575039,
0.0080926921,
-0.0623700209,
0.0020962772,
0.0547213331,
-0.0247778334,
0.0069616884,
-0.0222470984,
-0.0796775594,
-0.0018204126,
-0.0074213976,
0.0235637221,
0.0069926335,
0.0691745505,
-0.0139149036,
-0.0117112789,
0.0993333682,
0.0636421219,
0.009211692,
0.0176077168,
0.0551626384,
0.0198608637,
-0.0311968289,
0.0099429125,
-0.0256925561,
0.0543454699,
0.0276663825,
-0.0421416126,
0.0087160459,
0.0607519038,
0.0217459518,
-0.0489958376,
0.1201173216,
-0.0140361283,
0.0565145165,
-0.0123839891,
0.0056474232,
0.0422775224,
0.0150588285,
-0.0377309881,
-0.0037128238,
-0.001354296,
0.0072452677,
0.0195021518,
0.0667257831,
0.0143004125,
0.0471714213,
-0.0426172018,
-0.0082426611,
0.0257876888,
-0.0302662235,
-0.0205224752,
0.0340141468,
0.0167423412,
0.0405754372,
0.0105912015,
0.054907877,
-0.0071950261,
0.0444742255,
0.0611375384,
0.0261178464,
-0.0328993835,
0.0480503403,
-0.0006452849,
0.0195785388,
-0.0440280922,
0.0428417251,
0.0175886061,
-0.0213786345,
-0.0145007856,
0.0166449882,
-0.0338025019,
-0.0193755813,
0.0347092859,
0.0421136767,
-0.0837350264,
0.0521988682,
-0.0055030421,
-0.0038894403,
-0.024267992,
0.0550205708,
-0.0016803684,
0.0005938117,
0.0047353962,
0.0226246305,
-0.0224007163,
0.0163635127,
0.0014789848,
0.0110248113,
0.0006042757,
0.0148871187,
-0.0208985582,
-0.0082856864,
-0.0056517674,
-0.0164971668,
-0.005314135,
0.0260600988,
0.0365693197,
-0.0139251361,
-0.0106392773,
-0.0781659707,
0.0386848338,
-0.0387202017,
0.00732869,
-0.0194531437,
0.0157479849,
-6.119521469e-33,
-0.0077941599,
0.0012226361,
0.027178539,
0.0576895066,
0.0097698858,
-0.0052533853,
-0.0173561107,
0.0243230686,
0.017783219,
0.0485500805,
-0.03919724,
-0.002529582,
0.0218961798,
0.0677176341,
0.0458480455,
-0.0731221661,
0.0765444189,
-0.0217795465,
-0.0227455851,
0.0275913049,
0.0042866636,
0.013883519,
0.0557438768,
0.0040639341,
-0.0601966828,
0.0225953665,
-0.0125836013,
0.0112669831,
0.0490322523,
-0.0047473367,
-0.003631084,
-0.0034756633,
0.0021149558,
-0.0208890978,
-0.0429492444,
-0.0228947736,
-0.1040173247,
-0.0288024079,
-0.0732554793,
0.0374561213,
-0.0921674818,
-0.0294849426,
0.0021466443,
0.0326402336,
0.0087732468,
-0.0575424656,
0.0357305966,
-0.0454775803,
-0.0077277622,
-0.0531502888,
0.013274163,
0.0374768786,
-0.0386394374,
-0.0626353398,
0.1056137234,
0.0672446564,
0.0391316749,
-0.0024710635,
-0.0946536437,
0.0364830121,
-0.0123139387,
0.0154193193,
0.0674424097,
0.0863490403,
-0.0272378325,
0.0602758601,
0.0157610793,
-0.0569817238,
0.0004127517,
-0.0041925865,
-0.0048980894,
0.0266933758,
-0.0141635574,
-0.0125700952,
0.0902909562,
0.0297603998,
-0.0186618846,
0.0293508526,
-0.0071624173,
0.0132490909,
-0.0239696167,
0.0198584776,
0.0363309011,
-0.047497686,
-0.0022135796,
-0.0687371716,
-0.0307992417,
0.0051552253,
0.0102459909,
0.0422633477,
-0.0009278544,
0.0179920793,
0.0565085858,
0.0163755286,
0.0140149789,
0.0277916081,
-0.0144019211,
0.045679383,
0.0433233008,
-0.0304637272,
-0.0620129295,
0.0148562221,
0.0685416535,
0.0057388209,
-0.0121083362,
0.0305145383,
0.0775812492,
0.027193008,
0.014642667,
0.0048200027,
-0.0374384671,
0.0230158996,
0.0213865992,
0.0241179466,
-0.0015351746,
0.0135503113,
-0.0272807218,
0.0880965739,
-0.0302190986,
0.0374172963,
0.0201481469,
0.0431707762,
0.0125223938,
0.0343510658,
-0.0295628943,
-0.0048144143,
-0.0419626608,
-0.0514035746,
0.0231363177,
-0.0580688082,
-0.0239755455,
-0.0015398852,
2.889e-7,
-0.0060429629,
-0.0315484628,
0.0263528135,
-0.0316015556,
0.007978484,
0.0683479533,
-0.0125625897,
0.0259619225,
-0.0256070215,
-0.0789202973,
-0.0065852823,
0.0596247986,
0.0311313272,
-0.002837687,
-0.0644576699,
0.0067108618,
0.0458574928,
0.0193508808,
-0.0457593687,
-0.0199855343,
0.0056521893,
0.0658104569,
-0.0268497448,
-0.0005699358,
0.0748160481,
0.0337204002,
0.0224872213,
0.0143690435,
0.0176056605,
0.0080835829,
-0.004811069,
0.0085194204,
-0.0216679871,
0.0192457624,
-0.0179663077,
-0.0236451514,
0.0055129309,
0.0289802626,
0.0018099538,
-0.0002272642,
0.00910326,
0.0644034371,
0.019213004,
0.0031722996,
0.0377146639,
-0.0638282746,
-0.0337058045,
0.02103105,
-0.0449130945,
0.0428328328,
-0.0351786315,
0.01092776,
-0.0329955034,
0.0163785648,
0.0257067047,
0.010903581,
-0.0670240968,
-0.0560281128,
-0.0057800137,
-0.0274136309,
0.004895655,
-0.0079443511,
-0.0193085913,
-0.0001868601,
0.0222334415,
0.0041403398,
-0.056934949,
2.38353061e-34,
0.0038428155,
0.0308065023,
-0.0080958297,
-0.0400639065,
0.002259139,
-0.0132110557,
-0.0085037984,
-0.0015827849,
-0.0070035891,
-0.0108563295,
-0.0394808017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12747v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12747v1 | ALMANACS: A Simulatability Benchmark for Language Model Explainability | 2023-12-20T03:44:18 | 2023-12-20T03:44:18 | Edmund Mills, Shiye Su, Stuart Russell, Scott Emmons | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML | How do we measure the efficacy of language model explainability methods?
While many explainability methods have been developed, they are typically
evaluated on bespoke tasks, preventing an apples-to-apples comparison. To help
fill this gap, we present ALMANACS, a language model explainability benchmark.
ALMANACS scores explainability methods on simulatability, i.e., how well the
explanations improve behavior prediction on new inputs. The ALMANACS scenarios
span twelve safety-relevant topics such as ethical reasoning and advanced AI
behaviors; they have idiosyncratic premises to invoke model-specific behavior;
and they have a train-test distributional shift to encourage faithful
explanations. By using another language model to predict behavior based on the
explanations, ALMANACS is a fully automated benchmark. We use ALMANACS to
evaluate counterfactuals, rationalizations, attention, and Integrated Gradients
explanations. Our results are sobering: when averaged across all topics, no
explanation method outperforms the explanation-free control. We conclude that
despite modest successes in prior work, developing an explanation method that
aids simulatability in ALMANACS remains an open challenge. | [
0.0085130744,
0.088883318,
-0.0223836116,
0.0415317677,
-0.0099631511,
0.0219485257,
0.0276092142,
0.0074359481,
-0.0381764956,
-0.0072098467,
0.022218883,
0.0093522677,
-0.0114739416,
0.0434746854,
0.0259735864,
-0.036657311,
0.0386395976,
-0.0378771424,
0.0188952647,
0.0103705935,
0.0076629193,
0.0327347517,
-0.0006356243,
0.0694758296,
0.0340356566,
-0.0141765736,
-0.0191684552,
0.0121690137,
0.0210000724,
0.0233699679,
-0.007750669,
0.0003069299,
0.0554296263,
0.0200115945,
0.0000021267,
-0.0281906221,
-0.0166164897,
0.0325400047,
-0.0601129308,
0.0112854447,
0.0166911799,
-0.0174233187,
0.0190339256,
0.020046046,
0.008081465,
0.0529607646,
0.0640321597,
0.0465014502,
0.0415531211,
0.0836843997,
-0.0021354891,
-0.0136366161,
-0.0019226982,
-0.0109215118,
-0.0045288196,
-0.0337729342,
-0.0246080644,
0.007051345,
-0.0404389575,
-0.0002750893,
-0.0078124763,
0.0123867961,
0.0440234914,
-0.0493306555,
-0.000683779,
-0.0020279731,
0.0064415191,
-0.0353410393,
0.0168188885,
0.0390824452,
-0.0381890498,
-0.0662411824,
0.025389567,
-0.026338825,
-0.004853047,
0.0031492277,
-0.0281299297,
0.0042097885,
0.0085697211,
0.0177188199,
0.0603221171,
0.0248394068,
0.082887955,
0.0274943113,
0.0003463376,
0.0804622918,
-0.0199445989,
0.0164522361,
-0.0287709832,
-0.0389696062,
-0.0051347935,
-0.0608695112,
-0.0204167198,
0.0511945263,
-0.0572355278,
0.0353291929,
0.0101472298,
0.0095349783,
0.0229595136,
-0.0137560852,
0.0528363846,
0.0337269455,
-0.0065906704,
0.0288912393,
0.0209724754,
0.076541163,
-0.0183945205,
0.0162922442,
-0.0264832862,
-0.0022937532,
-0.0426386222,
-0.0138892094,
-0.0009756527,
-0.0371036977,
-0.0178770088,
0.0211215075,
0.0058119567,
0.0075560515,
-0.0516818166,
0.0226148982,
-0.0016123686,
0.0048127975,
-0.0468687303,
-0.0407306813,
-0.0292746946,
-0.0117217926,
-0.0746889859,
0.0000208393,
0.0400127023,
-0.0428057723,
-0.0361743942,
0.0151958037,
-0.0375854336,
-0.0177973956,
-0.0087043066,
0.0976806581,
0.0012355348,
0.0197853651,
-0.0289367568,
-0.0536394715,
-0.0071538691,
-0.0750995725,
-0.0105692735,
-0.024364261,
0.0075624418,
-0.0056316704,
-0.0238071531,
-0.0631341487,
0.0076210205,
-0.0043537156,
-0.0227798,
0.0772369578,
0.0089314003,
-0.0001035226,
-0.0116650788,
0.0267105475,
-0.0408327691,
0.0652827621,
0.0199283697,
0.0221494175,
0.0459976085,
-0.0244986434,
0.0506742969,
-0.0235635377,
0.0411653072,
0.0133808218,
-0.0241038762,
0.0085848449,
-0.0554729626,
0.0288359895,
0.0337143391,
0.0185497627,
0.0065904916,
-0.0370364487,
0.0222753324,
0.039069321,
-0.0193485133,
0.0226556435,
0.0729241222,
-0.003601287,
-0.0226354301,
0.0180682279,
-0.087454468,
0.0429419503,
-0.0305461437,
0.0085871518,
-0.0279802047,
0.0060319616,
-0.0207894444,
-0.081615001,
0.0057385708,
-0.0088764913,
0.0236514527,
0.0236359667,
0.0350707099,
0.0004731442,
-0.0329729468,
0.0205477718,
0.0349767543,
-0.0608021133,
-0.0154766776,
-0.0869409293,
0.048990272,
0.0794708356,
0.0390292592,
-0.0374717228,
-0.0319873951,
-0.0326901786,
0.0141061181,
0.0088400878,
0.0410242602,
-0.0095803505,
0.0465862602,
-0.0360484831,
-0.0124297952,
-0.049835477,
0.0414983891,
0.0053879977,
0.0192502737,
-0.0293729268,
0.0295961108,
-0.0886820704,
-0.0786949247,
0.0461617559,
-0.0570631661,
-0.0280929822,
-0.0433051847,
-0.0031019161,
0.0414918363,
0.0021472666,
0.0222015213,
0.0102419611,
0.0214290749,
-0.0118481843,
0.0015639627,
0.0510182381,
-0.0435419269,
-0.0014785515,
0.0033510108,
-0.0414376296,
-0.0118407682,
0.0621141084,
-0.0373557359,
-0.0293246862,
0.0164845679,
-0.0247410201,
0.0196104553,
-0.0278160274,
0.011048953,
-0.0424305685,
0.0018235169,
-0.0087690009,
0.045159366,
-0.0146950055,
0.0019271154,
-0.0019905264,
-0.0154656917,
0.0066529023,
-0.0070748893,
0.0003507642,
0.00785717,
-0.0326766483,
0.0099141616,
0.0244316813,
-0.0143116191,
-0.0217704456,
0.012251908,
-0.0449047312,
-0.0096017281,
-0.0387783051,
0.0063791354,
0.0174127948,
-0.0219427086,
0.0212361962,
0.0024191563,
-0.0127534941,
0.0204587765,
-0.0210657623,
0.0037415689,
0.0540288426,
-0.0103821773,
-0.0620746017,
-0.05147833,
-0.007863218,
-0.0227520503,
0.0795325786,
-0.0049467664,
0.0535666496,
-0.0519897528,
0.0054776678,
-0.0396395251,
-0.0015029648,
-0.0545763597,
-0.0566008799,
0.0165668018,
0.0279940572,
-0.0447026715,
0.0541230254,
0.0165737551,
0.072433874,
0.0399191603,
0.0576207377,
-0.0597349182,
-0.0137608172,
-0.0005064089,
-0.0275864862,
-0.027487712,
-0.0704193041,
0.0025131553,
0.0813330114,
-0.0433832817,
-0.0001463063,
-0.0704814568,
0.0320145302,
-0.0109223993,
-0.0560474172,
-0.0167535171,
-0.0488608181,
-0.0094356006,
0.0583362281,
-0.0376039818,
-0.0827412531,
0.0910140052,
-0.0273695774,
-0.0121011091,
-0.0131867509,
-0.0250505675,
-0.0056830002,
0.0826199129,
-0.003082895,
0.0357753485,
0.0567953177,
0.0010411399,
-0.0256893747,
-0.0364505947,
0.0390999056,
-0.0002392492,
0.0781253129,
-0.052321367,
-0.0175312124,
0.0261854604,
-0.0056569935,
-0.0407958217,
-0.0531787276,
-0.0132679055,
0.0143461553,
0.023762783,
-0.0498708487,
-0.0244181044,
0.0087667862,
0.0339447483,
0.0117959473,
-0.0007937197,
-0.0124042826,
-0.0039923103,
-0.0609733351,
0.0308590662,
0.0214579087,
0.0363738053,
-0.0255865529,
0.0364348032,
0.0176329166,
0.0426542312,
-0.011247701,
-0.0335704871,
0.0155191096,
-0.0266694687,
-0.029352909,
-0.0056079566,
0.0224516802,
0.0686596185,
-0.071588099,
-0.002446461,
0.093934603,
0.0147441681,
-0.0213745143,
0.039288342,
-0.0175846107,
0.0309906267,
0.0169499964,
0.0204309095,
-0.0238529351,
-0.0123121766,
0.0088500222,
0.0480069853,
-0.0109055294,
-0.0285268556,
-0.0041169906,
-0.0479107797,
0.0331206918,
-0.009955436,
-0.0599359237,
-0.03807313,
-0.0557310805,
-0.0239786394,
-0.0330991708,
0.0303116348,
0.0118430154,
0.0178340655,
-0.021209335,
0.0313694626,
-0.0345517844,
-0.0362199657,
0.0438078083,
-0.0098176887,
0.0664154887,
0.0633953214,
0.0366186202,
-0.0089119822,
-0.024357561,
-0.011593435,
0.014921207,
0.0233806036,
0.0173205398,
0.0598727614,
0.0131871905,
-0.012313474,
-0.0127205504,
0.0413692892,
-0.0283433646,
-0.0371500328,
-0.0163596906,
0.0660693794,
-0.004626852,
-0.0559026562,
-0.0083428472,
0.0011962369,
0.0197812468,
0.0972542688,
0.0564027876,
-0.0105356909,
-0.0435195416,
-0.0536982417,
-0.0260589756,
-0.0565847754,
-0.0234806184,
-0.0367742516,
0.031711515,
-0.0550136901,
-0.0251768995,
-0.0499168932,
-0.0351901278,
0.0169253219,
-0.0007206878,
-0.0239449441,
-0.0131332427,
-0.0042966395,
-0.0385019593,
0.0364522524,
-0.004174917,
0.0132727427,
-0.0093997484,
-0.0039935373,
-0.0070454534,
-0.0344969891,
-0.022378793,
-0.0009915746,
-0.0019722614,
-0.0294520967,
0.0147284642,
0.0425469093,
0.0303012431,
0.0537345111,
-0.0332305022,
-0.0253838748,
0.008678712,
0.0037904049,
-0.0093351454,
0.0052228235,
0.0848210976,
-0.0383784361,
0.0261775441,
0.0685059428,
-0.0383439325,
0.0055474229,
0.0110549331,
-0.0048121205,
-0.0468922779,
-0.0061903475,
0.0166127943,
0.0041355551,
-0.0044681467,
-0.0195288658,
-0.0266192332,
-0.021858573,
-0.0037246558,
-0.001891979,
-0.0277737137,
-0.0383998416,
0.0265087839,
0.0168309659,
-0.0280957241,
0.0258084908,
-0.0127590895,
-0.0372776799,
-0.0122150062,
-0.0032102491,
0.0413371176,
-0.003091461,
0.0587710142,
-0.0147792371,
0.0290465523,
-0.0333012715,
0.0086451937,
-0.0412844233,
0.0525806993,
-0.0102612879,
0.0793001875,
0.0290581156,
0.0205359999,
-0.0204444714,
0.0145891896,
-0.0768984631,
-0.0559002608,
0.0155676948,
-0.0003655762,
0.0212084949,
-0.0309755895,
0.0803932175,
-0.0025641809,
0.0008209592,
-0.0027318629,
0.069364056,
0.0458092354,
-0.0501595251,
-0.0038917928,
0.0158648062,
-0.0312128775,
-0.0046438761,
0.0779595003,
-0.000280414,
0.0282297134,
0.0193805955,
-0.0152183222,
-0.0024254154,
-0.0371646918,
0.0247361064,
0.0345011726,
0.0054950495,
-0.0288312621,
-0.0533695631,
-0.0872622505,
-0.0318720751,
0.0158841312,
-0.020390274,
-0.0111868531,
0.005497294,
0.0790469572,
-0.0098246662,
-0.0215756241,
-0.0443400219,
-0.0026360115,
-0.0395654403,
0.03374153,
-0.0358187445,
-6.184499124e-33,
-0.0128704356,
-0.0304781105,
-0.0124690412,
-0.0666950196,
0.0014696239,
0.0030972611,
-0.0866828039,
-0.0259035472,
-0.0746903643,
0.0605352037,
0.0106061427,
0.0459155925,
-0.000216377,
0.0048462278,
-0.0088932486,
-0.0527224019,
0.0282563847,
0.0475261025,
-0.0413910709,
0.0551061518,
0.042345129,
-0.01916622,
0.047081504,
-0.0767634138,
0.0863900855,
0.0048180311,
-0.0367387682,
0.0275446251,
-0.0448041782,
0.0790085122,
0.0046160189,
0.0394578986,
0.0125831077,
-0.0420527086,
0.0067744344,
-0.0041756495,
-0.01367551,
-0.0222163107,
0.0635872185,
-0.0157003757,
-0.0365469754,
-0.0655141771,
0.032211639,
0.0027163972,
0.0047943373,
-0.0310405362,
0.0324918814,
-0.0193025861,
0.0139080277,
0.0248554181,
-0.0615266077,
0.0045338292,
-0.0558571406,
-0.0297316592,
-0.0023851001,
0.0354184657,
0.0238993187,
-0.0001745489,
0.009285205,
-0.0197675247,
0.0323238149,
-0.0258901231,
0.0953705907,
-0.019569302,
-0.0221062042,
0.0602372177,
0.00453137,
0.0244159233,
-0.0536209717,
-0.0207887199,
-0.0110780569,
0.0640766248,
0.0786440074,
0.0201872811,
-0.0004585308,
-0.0075671254,
-0.0520145819,
0.0233996138,
-0.0052545387,
0.028368745,
0.0486229286,
0.0205788985,
-0.0875154585,
-0.0271655899,
-0.0394110866,
0.0000342226,
-0.0298882797,
-0.0370563343,
0.0224184301,
-0.0451816358,
-0.0605298541,
-0.0041153114,
-0.0084798625,
-0.0635716096,
0.0553618781,
0.0707981959,
-0.0020816047,
-0.0276495777,
0.0208069161,
0.0188347958,
-0.0201067124,
-0.0018351182,
-0.008567431,
0.0068866862,
0.0492754057,
0.0059708082,
0.0366870761,
0.0278567597,
0.0065025776,
0.0019130474,
-0.0750491396,
-0.0185160786,
-0.0307438169,
0.0047302227,
0.0097616585,
0.0185199305,
-0.0287412573,
0.0119474502,
0.0284264404,
-0.0197800584,
-0.0139598716,
0.0384891331,
-0.0291635226,
0.0281655751,
-0.0230382998,
-0.0330188833,
-0.0339196883,
0.0150963021,
0.0536704287,
-0.0359037444,
-0.0259044878,
0.0076751723,
2.669e-7,
0.0387234166,
0.0044979742,
0.0111825094,
0.0257295016,
0.0127158407,
0.056698449,
0.0113416808,
0.015620796,
-0.0193550419,
-0.0040458185,
0.0184754524,
0.0424585342,
0.0542922877,
0.0238016061,
0.0128582707,
-0.0614261739,
-0.0626336113,
-0.0365682244,
-0.0294616167,
0.0187435281,
0.0518665984,
0.0683120191,
0.0329416431,
0.0104011912,
0.0440340638,
-0.0048366757,
0.0014336127,
-0.0666068569,
0.0210891906,
0.0118892323,
0.0114826858,
0.0418828651,
0.0405741669,
0.0024789167,
-0.0197329689,
-0.0066045779,
-0.0433608219,
0.0797151402,
-0.0382293724,
-0.0265280772,
-0.0578142144,
-0.0553083979,
0.0346940905,
-0.1112476438,
0.0550829582,
0.0086849593,
-0.0170755722,
-0.022774633,
-0.0115613695,
0.0055908263,
-0.019004425,
0.0105874334,
-0.0032648623,
0.011405888,
-0.021897221,
-0.0254513025,
0.0113250129,
-0.0632184595,
-0.0701843724,
0.009788448,
0.0080347443,
-0.0077422909,
-0.0346570611,
0.0075338315,
0.0562739596,
-0.0615461171,
-0.0074934713,
2.605962839e-34,
0.0150796641,
0.017496435,
0.0133363241,
0.0154745458,
0.0654598325,
0.0215657689,
0.0158293601,
0.0091310479,
0.0606982484,
0.0127466973,
-0.0205722488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12746v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12746v1 | ChatFDA: Medical Records Risk Assessment | 2023-12-20T03:40:45 | 2023-12-20T03:40:45 | M Tran, C Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | In healthcare, the emphasis on patient safety and the minimization of medical
errors cannot be overstated. Despite concerted efforts, many healthcare
systems, especially in low-resource regions, still grapple with preventing
these errors effectively. This study explores a pioneering application aimed at
addressing this challenge by assisting caregivers in gauging potential risks
derived from medical notes. The application leverages data from openFDA,
delivering real-time, actionable insights regarding prescriptions. Preliminary
analyses conducted on the MIMIC-III \cite{mimic} dataset affirm a proof of
concept highlighting a reduction in medical errors and an amplification in
patient safety. This tool holds promise for drastically enhancing healthcare
outcomes in settings with limited resources. To bolster reproducibility and
foster further research, the codebase underpinning our methodology is
accessible on
https://github.com/autonlab/2023.hackAuton/tree/main/prescription_checker. This
is a submission for the 30th HackAuton CMU. | [
0.0268638134,
0.0503927283,
-0.032536231,
-0.0195406303,
0.0019480642,
0.0146169588,
-0.0095339529,
0.0067908131,
0.0442211479,
-0.0015963863,
0.0565548576,
-0.0328605622,
0.016299827,
0.0848691836,
0.0010431843,
-0.001055285,
0.0256969575,
0.0076114871,
0.0191314202,
0.0462916158,
-0.0020028539,
0.0018263638,
-0.0458460674,
0.0632022545,
-0.0061427141,
-0.0336280391,
0.0096218707,
0.0103830444,
0.0359053239,
-0.0755888522,
0.02856954,
-0.0021462829,
-0.0707753897,
0.0075921374,
0.0000025243,
-0.0482333787,
-0.0159777235,
0.029925596,
-0.0669637769,
-0.0492988639,
0.0665072799,
-0.0239459816,
-0.002225087,
0.0240356866,
-0.0212096572,
-0.0829442218,
0.0460540429,
0.015136322,
0.0221805796,
0.0318756811,
-0.0195303243,
0.0757560357,
0.0374383777,
0.0084827133,
0.068714425,
-0.0245216899,
0.0236245021,
0.0326174721,
0.0360740796,
-0.0428879149,
0.0409663841,
0.0185869001,
-0.020126801,
0.0045025195,
0.009783484,
0.0244618971,
-0.0404147133,
-0.042268116,
-0.0252129566,
0.0379277617,
0.0237652101,
0.0129348161,
0.0037187131,
-0.003718371,
-0.0352619141,
0.0040838905,
-0.0125908526,
-0.0078153843,
-0.0464881174,
0.0040631746,
0.0003474553,
0.0114197275,
0.033813037,
-0.0091477716,
-0.0008849784,
-0.0109733706,
-0.0276504345,
-0.0039120442,
0.0288097057,
-0.0258853268,
0.0506378189,
-0.0479401499,
0.0114787789,
-0.0035662919,
-0.0340754651,
-0.0204556677,
-0.0072790463,
-0.0268143304,
0.1300746053,
-0.0417786837,
0.0462580994,
0.0115776788,
-0.0125380429,
0.0329388231,
0.017214898,
-0.0342589058,
-0.0003972901,
0.0422143489,
-0.0190864187,
0.0457982458,
-0.0007959992,
0.0141311511,
0.0071418588,
0.0056828414,
0.0287830401,
0.0062924735,
-0.0605956689,
-0.0104527045,
-0.0360041782,
0.0539420098,
0.0378691182,
0.036774043,
-0.0029451519,
0.0702790767,
-0.0023016771,
-0.0243958104,
0.0299647469,
0.0053626182,
0.0033936081,
-0.0372266024,
0.0413084812,
0.0069141458,
0.0368669592,
0.0045421887,
0.0281860009,
0.0510209836,
0.0214209966,
-0.0374167785,
-0.0301988199,
-0.0536751337,
0.0108373752,
-0.0141296573,
0.0019998525,
-0.0276767984,
0.0285044815,
-0.0046804459,
0.0292353481,
-0.0007265128,
0.0224374123,
0.0083681587,
-0.0504414886,
0.0307515543,
-0.0693130493,
0.0036497577,
-0.01795673,
0.0391715132,
-0.0194302052,
0.0096578673,
0.0121537941,
-0.0297917966,
0.0138553949,
-0.0069957231,
0.0199041143,
0.0198526718,
0.004430532,
-0.0176220145,
0.0673213229,
0.0453817844,
0.0103643993,
0.0017152722,
-0.0703665987,
0.0243743937,
-0.0035674816,
0.0347139761,
0.035819158,
0.0004901445,
0.0488806367,
-0.0162285287,
-0.0165834203,
-0.0340597816,
-0.011881914,
-0.0889793262,
-0.0070744129,
-0.0151643315,
0.0000848026,
-0.0228930954,
-0.0456492044,
0.0030380015,
-0.010782674,
-0.0200458635,
-0.0559993275,
-0.0371447876,
-0.0414731875,
-0.0324087106,
-0.0089596966,
0.0016079947,
0.0053375959,
0.0045863325,
0.0111234011,
-0.0315388255,
-0.0704060197,
-0.049039647,
-0.0116057554,
0.1057768762,
0.0468605198,
-0.0350656994,
-0.0580299385,
-0.0348015241,
-0.0354588479,
-0.0840821043,
0.0058097378,
-0.036563836,
0.0252186693,
-0.0024780964,
-0.0052836449,
0.0573565066,
0.0407303274,
-0.0123263933,
0.0130199948,
0.0549446121,
-0.0353356078,
-0.0102519169,
-0.0313902088,
0.0230550859,
-0.036346782,
-0.0330277123,
0.0253068432,
0.024407059,
0.0411460511,
0.0210272055,
0.0279693119,
0.0123640718,
0.051476799,
0.0094300015,
0.0117972335,
0.020167822,
0.0552154668,
0.0252482723,
-0.0104172863,
-0.0266439505,
-0.0109458771,
-0.0157903098,
-0.0362989157,
0.0018015282,
-0.0294046849,
-0.050472714,
-0.0246095508,
0.00879825,
-0.008884199,
0.0625655279,
0.0254374053,
0.0071408954,
0.003382521,
-0.0164561365,
-0.0148130152,
-0.0202029347,
-0.0425995626,
0.0258204248,
0.0122878058,
0.030813396,
-0.038608484,
-0.0324829966,
0.049204573,
-0.0323298387,
0.0166989621,
-0.0052425442,
0.0255884975,
-0.0659372211,
-0.0051655159,
0.014930686,
0.0230326336,
0.019177258,
0.0339155979,
-0.0129561517,
-0.0337368511,
0.0228416622,
0.0029338086,
0.0011139624,
-0.0079513378,
0.0160289891,
0.0251387842,
-0.0045351046,
-0.0082169203,
0.0180315245,
-0.0483020209,
0.049152784,
0.0279039741,
-0.032863792,
-0.0034891097,
-0.0514043197,
-0.0256459061,
-0.0146269351,
-0.002846146,
0.0032131611,
-0.0127406586,
-0.0156974457,
-0.0070746662,
0.0176141914,
-0.0652973354,
0.0060637235,
0.0470472723,
0.0030318282,
0.00669719,
0.0125186294,
-0.0162485074,
-0.0087156445,
0.0839286894,
-0.0915957466,
-0.0180762745,
0.0123812817,
0.004907974,
0.0079728952,
0.0165269375,
0.0152344899,
-0.0123450859,
0.0347017683,
-0.0217565168,
0.0159355607,
-0.0359679498,
0.0585498102,
0.0139408763,
-0.0485279523,
0.0445224568,
-0.00409145,
0.0308403205,
-0.0428065285,
-0.0403530784,
-0.0402015112,
-0.0108095612,
-0.0068548829,
0.0251704175,
-0.0021604851,
0.0090773124,
0.043051336,
0.0050198585,
0.0213729031,
-0.0469610468,
0.031515155,
-0.0051700133,
0.0056491541,
-0.0019008187,
-0.0384013653,
-0.0247049201,
-0.0103272442,
-0.0281569771,
-0.0338800028,
-0.0184196122,
0.0124890078,
-0.0691760629,
0.0160584375,
-0.0228569359,
0.0846511647,
0.0312749743,
-0.0201199818,
0.0159394704,
-0.025145648,
0.0145422528,
-0.1043401062,
0.0336991213,
0.0094759027,
0.0246289726,
0.0809983239,
0.0340949371,
0.0243163444,
-0.0215931553,
0.0188160911,
-0.0415989012,
-0.00821508,
-0.028412234,
0.044510562,
0.0070936796,
-0.0230412446,
-0.0088092098,
0.0233997777,
0.0408498272,
-0.0169029217,
0.0455993079,
-0.0206551291,
-0.0594901927,
-0.014786412,
0.0032183372,
-0.0882856473,
-0.0113640931,
0.0057722232,
0.061328236,
-0.0478369556,
-0.0385210775,
0.0082859648,
-0.0058764913,
0.0740175173,
-0.0114433896,
-0.0408402681,
-0.0418496616,
-0.0459838025,
0.0202095937,
-0.0377026163,
-0.042808149,
-0.017005939,
-0.0155635905,
-0.0322706662,
-0.0169998743,
-0.0885124728,
-0.0392687619,
0.0298004989,
-0.0105977859,
0.0227538534,
0.0520494767,
0.0168451592,
0.0098178489,
-0.0092390422,
-0.0159057342,
-0.0220185686,
-0.0198609922,
-0.0178609733,
0.1197360978,
0.0230643023,
0.0058421055,
-0.052650962,
0.0288583674,
-0.0537757911,
-0.0221777856,
-0.0037598747,
0.0823518857,
-0.0462924019,
-0.0162442718,
-0.0624776855,
0.0215059537,
0.0478414446,
0.0114117451,
0.0103124073,
0.0156469569,
-0.0351382606,
0.0036284341,
0.0363820791,
-0.0050849775,
0.0021067248,
0.0657511726,
-0.020394776,
-0.049090147,
-0.0383738615,
-0.0316476263,
-0.0011683219,
-0.0097014094,
-0.0051526716,
-0.0447304621,
0.0011751477,
0.0017278154,
-0.0486555658,
0.0077280398,
0.0291058179,
0.0412017442,
-0.0087103508,
-0.0191482715,
0.0199851412,
0.0489627123,
-0.0143721486,
0.05348159,
-0.0440877937,
0.0171637274,
0.0637070015,
0.0667129233,
0.0365869291,
-0.0663029701,
-0.0170453377,
0.0357875898,
0.0082202982,
0.0746107101,
-0.014110852,
-0.0593672618,
-0.0222053248,
-0.0635499135,
-0.0038456342,
-0.0296792611,
-0.0055926982,
-0.0102841668,
0.0071034534,
-0.0141777284,
0.0242932476,
0.001735818,
-0.0096894149,
0.0386569463,
0.0526484959,
0.0213802885,
-0.0210293103,
-0.0149526,
0.0610097125,
-0.0004290512,
-0.0099591399,
-0.0244297106,
0.0115315793,
-0.020686321,
-0.0194250885,
-0.0209756009,
0.0009186054,
-0.0589568838,
-0.0382872559,
-0.0334803984,
0.0458032563,
0.0184182823,
0.0533534214,
0.0625502616,
-0.0219180677,
0.0156053472,
0.0193042886,
-0.0084036319,
0.0370417051,
0.0126030585,
0.0192948356,
-0.0526694097,
0.0059697581,
-0.0296509452,
0.0472949147,
-0.0488019474,
-0.0485783778,
-0.0214676429,
0.0171460994,
0.0028437884,
-0.0038044639,
0.032587599,
-0.0722379237,
0.017763041,
-0.0305753332,
0.0210576691,
0.0041805673,
0.0287441239,
0.0103409132,
0.0097152852,
-0.0178438313,
-0.0351962931,
0.0952627659,
-0.035910964,
0.039907489,
-0.0163278859,
-0.0625801459,
-0.0492170155,
-0.0244443193,
0.0434680171,
0.0031824834,
-0.0673099682,
-0.0319792069,
-0.0663025379,
-0.0516588762,
0.0401138254,
0.0079952525,
-0.0117162196,
0.0354553908,
0.000754152,
-0.0160016306,
0.0209640525,
-0.0267375596,
-0.0212434102,
0.0372506455,
-0.0644009635,
-0.0119957775,
0.039654281,
-6.769531642e-33,
0.0240341257,
-0.0375963449,
-0.027032068,
0.0112132914,
0.0316699184,
0.0330067165,
-0.0367504545,
0.0037319567,
0.0425500013,
0.0399749465,
-0.0017851655,
0.0047576553,
0.0232195556,
0.0154734459,
0.0546355247,
-0.041983638,
-0.0165942349,
0.0317727327,
-0.0060450528,
0.0283625927,
-0.0093510421,
0.0424737073,
-0.0099918656,
-0.0876025632,
0.0300884712,
0.0011369581,
-0.0043013222,
0.0101421261,
-0.0497291125,
0.0796349123,
-0.0044884849,
0.0165619869,
-0.0006241079,
-0.0052650566,
-0.0093318168,
-0.0030740539,
-0.0710271597,
-0.0169045348,
-0.0131169623,
-0.0279251933,
-0.0032245207,
-0.0165583249,
0.008058737,
-0.0111326734,
-0.0319678187,
-0.0217893738,
0.0002506113,
-0.0402280949,
-0.0174302217,
-0.0493404083,
0.0245254058,
0.0334843658,
-0.0249410607,
0.006158005,
-0.0276895333,
0.0588778853,
-0.0180974472,
-0.0184908826,
-0.0440534502,
-0.0066542821,
0.0181282386,
-0.0060748835,
0.0033816062,
-0.0294134375,
-0.0079272809,
0.0462226644,
0.0018701633,
-0.0403579064,
-0.0175185017,
-0.0134671759,
-0.0733021796,
0.0422616415,
0.0225931797,
0.0468018092,
0.0267541371,
-0.0299903993,
-0.0966098309,
0.0741422325,
-0.0998679847,
0.0493554249,
0.0195402708,
-0.0335190855,
-0.0819084421,
0.0079787513,
-0.0011237607,
0.0075998786,
-0.0279276166,
0.0014757813,
0.0102425758,
0.0197783727,
-0.0215380248,
0.0493211411,
-0.0324648879,
-0.0426146947,
0.0163168963,
-0.0235784557,
0.0649996251,
0.006707231,
-0.0149801709,
-0.0047509344,
0.0014061567,
0.0139637925,
0.0101844799,
0.0081272135,
0.0634767488,
0.02261368,
0.0796034709,
-0.0116948429,
-0.0699097812,
0.0109071555,
0.033759933,
0.0434754714,
-0.0303309746,
0.0243759677,
0.0462919809,
0.0033987407,
0.013287995,
0.0853293091,
0.0411611684,
0.0353961959,
-0.0453180186,
-0.0025062668,
-0.0327953994,
-0.0155918868,
-0.0381011888,
0.0006709314,
-0.0734381825,
0.0101570738,
0.0214150008,
-0.0591507591,
0.0396936052,
-0.0207614489,
3.35e-7,
0.0942004323,
0.0484312549,
0.0069835884,
-0.0232357271,
0.0452603213,
0.0105629526,
-0.0375493132,
0.000524295,
-0.0286410246,
0.0220088344,
0.0825848803,
-0.0467307121,
0.0574046411,
0.0823064223,
-0.0041296813,
-0.0349894203,
-0.0707352385,
-0.0438848324,
-0.0396448672,
-0.0446121953,
0.0157980584,
0.026010491,
-0.0119128609,
-0.0537374094,
0.0247295927,
-0.0109774815,
-0.0254278909,
-0.0372102223,
0.0263064336,
-0.0177838411,
0.0293679815,
0.0038494528,
0.0127062025,
0.0360690579,
-0.0479817837,
-0.0308536962,
-0.0593408458,
0.0954766348,
-0.0503957756,
0.0487498231,
0.0351154655,
-0.0614175536,
0.0577938259,
-0.0712497532,
0.0677448437,
-0.0024547598,
-0.0198718719,
0.0063326284,
-0.0023838796,
0.0132939545,
0.1000424325,
-0.021711912,
-0.027667813,
0.0318893157,
0.0062026354,
0.0420102589,
-0.0192461535,
-0.0257835332,
-0.0010251235,
0.0352977701,
0.0081341099,
-0.042864535,
0.0701105893,
-0.0111765945,
-0.0475737676,
-0.0933102593,
0.0195258819,
3.186465801e-34,
0.0148148621,
0.0218669865,
-0.0227881633,
-0.0599473976,
0.0539678782,
-0.0320904255,
0.0642184243,
-0.044426702,
0.0073285913,
-0.0236381311,
-0.03019136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12740v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12740v1 | Fine-tuning Large Language Models for Adaptive Machine Translation | 2023-12-20T03:21:48 | 2023-12-20T03:21:48 | Yasmin Moslem, Rejwanul Haque, Andy Way | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | This paper presents the outcomes of fine-tuning Mistral 7B, a general-purpose
large language model (LLM), for adaptive machine translation (MT). The
fine-tuning process involves utilising a combination of zero-shot and one-shot
translation prompts within the medical domain. The primary objective is to
enhance real-time adaptive MT capabilities of Mistral 7B, enabling it to adapt
translations to the required domain at inference time. The results,
particularly for Spanish-to-English MT, showcase the efficacy of the fine-tuned
model, demonstrating quality improvements in both zero-shot and one-shot
translation scenarios, surpassing Mistral 7B's baseline performance. Notably,
the fine-tuned Mistral outperforms ChatGPT "gpt-3.5-turbo" in zero-shot
translation while achieving comparable one-shot translation quality. Moreover,
the zero-shot translation of the fine-tuned Mistral matches NLLB 3.3B's
performance, and its one-shot translation quality surpasses that of NLLB 3.3B.
These findings emphasise the significance of fine-tuning efficient LLMs like
Mistral 7B to yield high-quality zero-shot translations comparable to
task-oriented models like NLLB 3.3B. Additionally, the adaptive gains achieved
in one-shot translation are comparable to those of commercial LLMs such as
ChatGPT. Our experiments demonstrate that, with a relatively small dataset of
20,000 segments that incorporate a mix of zero-shot and one-shot prompts,
fine-tuning significantly enhances Mistral's in-context learning ability,
especially for real-time adaptive MT. | [
0.0226569064,
-0.0170637984,
0.007039303,
0.0136402743,
-0.0133629367,
0.029136749,
0.0322627611,
0.0057416274,
-0.0053937705,
-0.023819143,
-0.0639089197,
-0.0466980301,
0.0201931093,
0.0074356236,
0.041968409,
-0.0330775529,
0.0479359925,
-0.0214164741,
-0.0113982148,
0.0086849649,
-0.0203515552,
0.013661786,
-0.0229568612,
0.0398000106,
0.0592710935,
-0.0072281547,
0.0310503598,
0.0561141595,
0.0408186242,
-0.0431582965,
-0.0149301868,
0.0374265835,
0.0369071476,
0.0347476378,
0.0000023669,
-0.0373307243,
-0.0240783971,
0.0252499692,
-0.0122951176,
-0.0205793679,
0.0734853148,
-0.0423064604,
-0.0229915604,
0.0367939919,
-0.015769707,
-0.0133909611,
0.0396945886,
-0.0077995406,
0.0360790864,
0.0689782724,
-0.0152570559,
-0.0264115706,
0.0044288314,
-0.0784570649,
-0.0058178487,
-0.0692793429,
-0.0056310957,
-0.0256154612,
-0.0190403182,
0.0188241247,
-0.0084555158,
0.0658475012,
0.0020627135,
-0.0049158721,
-0.000111066,
0.0082082124,
-0.0302493256,
-0.0357491001,
-0.0182382315,
0.0642516166,
-0.0462418422,
0.0033432806,
0.0083674276,
-0.0045892736,
-0.0217538998,
-0.0347758047,
-0.0522001758,
0.007635551,
-0.0185596403,
-0.0139444014,
0.0064718993,
0.0228600707,
0.0389707647,
-0.0155158471,
-0.0485863946,
-0.0491964631,
0.0313392207,
-0.0184222497,
0.0207402054,
-0.008898926,
-0.0360127948,
-0.0099859368,
0.0477970578,
0.0286444481,
-0.0398871899,
0.018171316,
-0.0382038131,
-0.0329627842,
0.0448210128,
-0.0678354502,
0.0495312884,
0.0613942295,
-0.0072951815,
0.060767632,
-0.0190851968,
0.0692109764,
-0.0429615974,
0.0076972125,
-0.0800760835,
-0.0038001316,
-0.0222273748,
0.0445257798,
-0.0503696799,
-0.0193320885,
-0.0671136454,
-0.0108784065,
-0.054019399,
0.030792255,
0.0436277725,
0.0138350595,
0.0627340898,
-0.0168545302,
-0.067110233,
-0.0187791158,
0.008636198,
0.0500785969,
0.0330068804,
-0.026030371,
-0.0081218733,
-0.0751467943,
-0.0135892797,
0.016404042,
-0.0058642211,
-0.0428347252,
-0.0060129897,
0.0751182213,
-0.0148390606,
-0.0366777889,
0.0100416299,
-0.0088733453,
-0.0325939059,
-0.0584346578,
-0.0040477421,
-0.0360470228,
0.0630628765,
0.0279987436,
0.0289055873,
-0.0020968043,
0.0007436299,
0.0194508638,
-0.0445946082,
0.0309635643,
-0.0067512193,
0.0134023977,
0.024229141,
0.0005201116,
-0.0149478959,
0.0627353936,
0.0285813101,
0.008879507,
-0.0203015413,
-0.0098340539,
-0.0068868143,
0.0428132154,
0.0162473265,
0.0272529926,
-0.0225651655,
0.014366529,
0.0067834533,
0.0656664297,
0.0149125401,
0.0658262447,
-0.0095787616,
0.014578294,
0.0744506866,
0.0165809337,
0.0511448681,
0.0178417936,
0.0562300533,
-0.0029459421,
-0.0052232957,
-0.0293360092,
-0.0289802384,
0.0206623692,
-0.0072493479,
-0.0071820254,
-0.0000912405,
0.0459215343,
-0.0184607785,
-0.0219892189,
-0.0387546681,
0.0081260996,
-0.0278771762,
0.0013137526,
0.0411722437,
0.0086417506,
-0.0783508569,
0.043136511,
0.0167182032,
-0.0230759159,
-0.0092773838,
-0.0627309382,
-0.0270812046,
0.074844107,
0.0776648894,
0.0026196586,
-0.0550793894,
-0.0350339562,
0.0259177536,
0.0464268848,
0.0603621081,
0.0404373147,
0.0157514773,
-0.0694738403,
-0.0229345355,
0.0499262288,
0.0111014368,
-0.0032132755,
-0.0130824177,
0.0630308539,
0.0078802705,
-0.019638177,
-0.0267435275,
0.0301240627,
-0.0575503595,
-0.024366362,
0.0205080695,
-0.0130942035,
0.0295839719,
0.0066091656,
-0.0224289987,
-0.0076745986,
0.0250019766,
-0.0368843526,
-0.0065252408,
0.0404382944,
-0.0817584842,
-0.0521313846,
-0.0082908021,
0.0244616941,
0.0181498732,
-0.0459692106,
-0.0307452064,
-0.0282078721,
-0.0635284558,
-0.0071364613,
0.0016171997,
-0.0227825362,
0.0536973812,
0.004837268,
0.0098076677,
-0.0535752475,
0.0107404646,
-0.0149433818,
-0.0243810471,
0.0284381267,
-0.0213389415,
-0.0044626063,
-0.0360272825,
-0.0348087884,
0.040686693,
0.0151678044,
0.0295190122,
0.0084437327,
0.0307117328,
-0.0079393871,
-0.0548349656,
-0.0803126767,
0.0371914357,
-0.0166426841,
0.030216353,
0.0474867783,
0.0470752195,
-0.0009065683,
-0.0022742071,
-0.0064364932,
0.0237684231,
0.0057823854,
0.0116368188,
-0.0133085167,
0.0137413088,
0.0232002791,
-0.0213429537,
0.0174881481,
-0.0006313127,
0.0136799077,
0.0017811846,
-0.0342912935,
-0.043635536,
0.0068848645,
-0.0202513263,
-0.0048015867,
-0.0055959322,
-0.0680391937,
-0.0225998014,
-0.0142402351,
0.0396423787,
0.06199532,
0.0008436088,
0.0000587275,
0.0040354831,
0.0049922531,
-0.0347094759,
0.0177943818,
-0.0129750082,
-0.083423391,
-0.0210431479,
-0.0296737105,
0.0140196802,
0.0986240506,
0.0328092612,
0.0139514403,
-0.0646460205,
-0.0050076437,
-0.0149249453,
-0.0074714036,
-0.0295408741,
0.0454238765,
-0.0062580542,
0.0152147468,
-0.0134290773,
-0.0388841592,
0.0713499561,
-0.0179901719,
-0.0002458108,
-0.0716625527,
-0.0241682529,
-0.0296556372,
-0.0232865363,
-0.015710637,
0.0202541295,
0.0002380214,
-0.0017357614,
-0.0105352812,
0.0065566842,
0.0054509463,
-0.0435327664,
0.0198970381,
-0.0483564287,
-0.0117653804,
-0.0390248895,
-0.0444743596,
-0.0112723941,
-0.0173573084,
-0.0130176218,
0.007909528,
0.0018552976,
-0.0030271641,
-0.0632164553,
0.0382038802,
0.0140428897,
0.1075587496,
-0.0282866601,
-0.0128920935,
-0.0269704666,
0.0158728622,
0.0044507957,
-0.003000061,
-0.0078338645,
-0.0538424365,
0.0643628687,
0.0258395001,
0.0009638353,
-0.0002628025,
-0.025811417,
-0.0237884317,
0.0300472006,
-0.0047442578,
-0.0342082568,
0.0053033112,
0.0632731915,
-0.0691695362,
0.0019791981,
0.1143009365,
0.0043336023,
-0.0685953945,
-0.0152739631,
-0.0298090279,
0.0131272338,
-0.0017420796,
0.0203932021,
-0.084792152,
-0.0543031245,
-0.0043835687,
0.0457452871,
0.0198151451,
0.004378391,
-0.0181555375,
-0.0481486693,
0.0264289547,
0.0355646424,
-0.0719811991,
-0.007703667,
-0.0002041896,
-0.013899589,
-0.0515235141,
0.0524076894,
0.0118469913,
-0.0033484187,
-0.0195154399,
0.0045299786,
0.0195922069,
-0.080031991,
0.0144613013,
-0.0405154079,
0.0367364697,
0.0791468769,
0.0228666961,
0.0114315981,
-0.0109060472,
0.0647464469,
-0.0268067867,
0.0319937877,
-0.0154671306,
0.0089760022,
0.019059984,
-0.0171012525,
-0.0008119838,
-0.0087327659,
-0.0138444304,
0.0182062667,
0.0187603328,
0.0652634874,
-0.0215556789,
0.0113117881,
-0.0331380442,
-0.0118640317,
-0.0041149943,
0.0494832098,
-0.0026566186,
-0.0474133417,
-0.0050029433,
0.008931688,
-0.0082969917,
-0.0245387871,
-0.017339509,
0.0161809735,
-0.0707190856,
-0.0559542887,
-0.0677478686,
-0.0180834867,
0.0243931431,
0.0335185602,
0.0165399238,
0.0421029702,
0.0175379273,
0.0002321425,
-0.0104967384,
0.0485145673,
-0.0274444614,
-0.0011035253,
-0.0771559179,
0.0001270495,
0.0520219281,
-0.0168452188,
0.0142046912,
0.0572623536,
-0.058211349,
-0.0357987843,
-0.0069506066,
0.0500511564,
0.0226354636,
0.024047412,
-0.0390119776,
-0.0441586003,
0.0293361843,
0.0281600859,
0.0107227238,
0.0167766735,
-0.0078252563,
0.0263876505,
-0.0280936137,
0.0462735705,
-0.0080541689,
-0.0124221267,
-0.0000192931,
0.0598355643,
0.0121877436,
-0.057432428,
-0.0002321063,
0.020418793,
0.0472967252,
-0.0402703919,
-0.0142397061,
0.0011612534,
0.0370760746,
-0.004231628,
0.028661225,
-0.04812105,
-0.0108504947,
0.0458109193,
-0.0455506071,
-0.0045165848,
0.0087062037,
-0.0512726195,
-0.0301063173,
-0.0777306482,
0.0161945634,
-0.0434543304,
0.0036049096,
0.0536456816,
0.0268617794,
-0.0208794978,
0.0161691122,
0.0036143332,
0.0048750285,
-0.0494210012,
0.0903005302,
-0.0217224807,
0.0199715346,
-0.0018878551,
0.0688974783,
0.0039340048,
-0.0257383808,
-0.0229639262,
0.0689613372,
0.080898717,
0.0376906022,
0.0936746076,
0.0186551288,
-0.0119207241,
-0.0460247956,
0.0364980511,
-0.0005232542,
0.0136764348,
0.0320449509,
-0.0125179477,
0.0104767252,
0.0271364674,
0.0627937019,
-0.0161769073,
0.0367690511,
0.0034528484,
-0.0197365824,
-0.0174530819,
0.0157764833,
0.0210090503,
-0.0433041528,
-0.0274578389,
-0.0044718129,
-0.046072714,
-0.0339262821,
0.0067663533,
-0.0087949848,
-0.0245328937,
-0.0439014882,
0.015504376,
0.0598840192,
-0.0376766585,
-0.0520527437,
-0.0318674967,
0.0191667899,
-0.006910237,
-0.0193607286,
0.0175654758,
-6.776972521e-33,
-0.0266983528,
0.0008881798,
0.063110657,
-0.0706280544,
-0.0380877443,
-0.0046801511,
-0.0386749916,
-0.0317746103,
-0.0214879308,
0.0152287772,
-0.0169475302,
-0.014942863,
0.0294170082,
-0.0012972251,
-0.0237876419,
-0.0010220774,
0.0587227494,
0.0098755294,
-0.0368840918,
0.0402778424,
0.0074869813,
0.0213559605,
0.075897485,
-0.0514012314,
-0.0030450048,
-0.0048702508,
-0.0132246306,
0.0250625387,
0.0005309498,
0.0283893216,
0.003841582,
0.0220619831,
0.0163699072,
-0.0459673889,
-0.0313690305,
-0.0205863509,
-0.0774719194,
0.0356679931,
0.0285651144,
0.0161138568,
-0.0072588376,
-0.0646571368,
0.0481325723,
-0.038029518,
-0.0409473851,
-0.0170932263,
-0.0034869213,
-0.0632170811,
-0.0526789501,
-0.0378707238,
-0.0452064574,
0.050360024,
0.0257806219,
-0.0432410687,
0.005929125,
0.0570138879,
-0.0534479991,
0.0533161238,
-0.0517163947,
-0.0175251719,
0.0293338392,
0.0325510614,
0.0646859705,
-0.0063261925,
-0.0227132309,
-0.0175390821,
0.0488029644,
0.0030448199,
0.0296827983,
0.0229264703,
0.0117684379,
0.007694846,
0.0613565221,
0.0433233082,
0.0263567679,
-0.010006221,
-0.0587393939,
0.0230126418,
-0.0393442549,
0.0254430398,
0.0544559434,
0.014762084,
-0.033586178,
-0.0038817807,
-0.0468275174,
-0.0262420736,
-0.0247482285,
-0.0223272685,
0.0320107713,
0.0294866953,
0.0277527366,
-0.0163966641,
0.0957159624,
-0.0050657485,
0.049134776,
-0.0198101848,
-0.0224391744,
0.0027923274,
-0.0560927317,
0.056432385,
-0.0195952691,
-0.0299512185,
0.0371633358,
0.0363038443,
0.0118650021,
0.0004372496,
0.0150943212,
0.0118347825,
-0.0353889614,
0.0046979352,
-0.0261841919,
-0.0099510299,
-0.0205972306,
0.051240176,
0.0313634239,
-0.0095209582,
0.0027229874,
0.0941701904,
0.0001674293,
-0.0467222109,
-0.0226036366,
-0.0028669613,
0.0217348207,
0.0263817236,
-0.0663454458,
0.0322554559,
-0.0069446755,
0.0132289808,
0.0130486256,
-0.0489194244,
-0.0291158035,
0.003631962,
3.045e-7,
0.0425497219,
0.0807594284,
-0.0390718132,
-0.0138710048,
0.0203118287,
0.0182942301,
-0.014951379,
0.0362401567,
0.0174926221,
0.0388018712,
0.0264492165,
0.0172103308,
0.069237709,
0.0052013383,
-0.0808986574,
-0.0424748473,
-0.0734924152,
0.0367552862,
-0.0457989648,
-0.0147816371,
0.0300159249,
0.105074428,
-0.0393535681,
-0.0112531818,
0.0266814418,
-0.0203028545,
0.0680229366,
-0.0089270631,
-0.0540371537,
0.0261562411,
0.033237651,
0.0396241546,
-0.0257892329,
-0.0214431044,
-0.0212923903,
-0.0014554908,
-0.0068342411,
0.1322184652,
-0.0330301002,
0.0086100316,
0.0580740608,
-0.0207324028,
-0.0032970421,
-0.0490020849,
0.0555361919,
-0.0756135955,
-0.0105753737,
0.0203763414,
-0.0020845833,
-0.0092445053,
0.0594235472,
-0.0481669791,
-0.0323531777,
0.0259498619,
0.0562315099,
0.0125362985,
-0.0615956225,
-0.043033462,
-0.0216896106,
0.0225090254,
-0.0258756503,
-0.0540978797,
-0.0044100233,
-0.0006582654,
0.0025072207,
-0.0534497052,
0.0121732,
2.818470178e-34,
0.0416060351,
-0.023659192,
0.000968789,
-0.0057801399,
0.0272820741,
-0.0173414424,
0.0046066702,
0.0229812674,
0.0103831347,
-0.0678296983,
-0.0298062637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12736v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12736v2 | Learning and Forgetting Unsafe Examples in Large Language Models | 2023-12-20T03:18:50 | 2024-07-03T06:13:31 | Jiachen Zhao, Zhun Deng, David Madras, James Zou, Mengye Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | As the number of large language models (LLMs) released to the public grows,
there is a pressing need to understand the safety implications associated with
these models learning from third-party custom finetuning data. We explore the
behavior of LLMs finetuned on noisy custom data containing unsafe content,
represented by datasets that contain biases, toxicity, and harmfulness, finding
that while aligned LLMs can readily learn this unsafe content, they also tend
to forget it more significantly than other examples when subsequently finetuned
on safer content. Drawing inspiration from the discrepancies in forgetting, we
introduce the "ForgetFilter" algorithm, which filters unsafe data based on how
strong the model's forgetting signal is for that data. We demonstrate that the
ForgetFilter algorithm ensures safety in customized finetuning without
compromising downstream task performance, unlike sequential safety finetuning.
ForgetFilter outperforms alternative strategies like replay and moral
self-correction in curbing LLMs' ability to assimilate unsafe content during
custom finetuning, e.g. 75% lower than not applying any safety measures and 62%
lower than using self-correction in toxicity score. | [
0.0034988944,
0.0485053137,
-0.0266651046,
0.0198065955,
-0.0130714029,
0.0320425145,
-0.0058057983,
-0.0110897813,
0.0157327894,
-0.0273082405,
-0.0362896733,
-0.0214195698,
-0.0207775757,
0.011697676,
0.0407766737,
-0.0116140768,
0.0784269646,
-0.0563731976,
0.0259509496,
-0.0211974606,
0.0208217837,
-0.004672105,
0.0315325223,
0.0257645752,
0.0280766319,
-0.0248900037,
0.0234991126,
-0.0040086405,
0.0220744498,
-0.0195196439,
0.0435997322,
0.03948915,
-0.0121202916,
0.049125839,
0.0000018845,
-0.0385896452,
-0.0245586559,
-0.0128422948,
-0.0021655043,
0.0188062657,
0.0255956221,
0.0182942357,
-0.042549219,
0.0347054154,
-0.0173014384,
0.0153056942,
0.045540642,
0.0322401449,
0.0640556142,
0.0473190509,
0.0037540791,
0.0270505641,
0.0269263051,
-0.0100067016,
-0.0085702017,
-0.0107117416,
0.0538209304,
-0.0222866945,
-0.0487802885,
-0.0079929987,
-0.0366445929,
0.0523789935,
-0.0066948952,
0.0058967904,
-0.0250585489,
0.0053722179,
-0.0438379794,
-0.0475112796,
0.0003119423,
0.0406736545,
-0.0721149519,
-0.0357628167,
0.030767113,
-0.0236266274,
0.0031931887,
-0.0281435903,
-0.03627434,
0.034363959,
-0.0097403172,
0.0187130719,
0.0115713067,
-0.0370617695,
0.0709795579,
0.0196200125,
0.034171883,
0.0442447588,
0.0160407703,
-0.0351676196,
0.0325959958,
-0.0187541693,
-0.0082156323,
-0.0292366296,
0.0151501857,
-0.0136578819,
-0.0304322783,
0.036399018,
-0.048534248,
-0.0240921583,
0.0493267775,
-0.0275404174,
0.0308610816,
0.0254810713,
-0.0303120092,
0.0396943353,
-0.0188273545,
-0.006446227,
-0.0036632759,
0.0656026602,
-0.0086477175,
0.0457789637,
0.0393646657,
-0.0063962648,
-0.0100072157,
0.0182862338,
0.0151582062,
0.0578914657,
-0.0207025204,
0.0144361956,
-0.0505926758,
0.0096523622,
0.0050924164,
-0.0029060896,
-0.055549942,
-0.0017022688,
0.0106720161,
-0.0205577184,
-0.0197877064,
0.0086780833,
0.0312433131,
-0.0669300705,
-0.022023106,
-0.0081032198,
-0.0274018124,
-0.0464311577,
0.0208514612,
0.0914402902,
0.0109065054,
-0.0318531394,
-0.0515706986,
-0.0311005861,
-0.0302020144,
-0.0538057722,
0.0129652256,
-0.0552798584,
0.001026195,
-0.0111319525,
-0.0218189359,
-0.1076767594,
0.006182929,
0.021837173,
-0.0688414201,
0.037998382,
-0.0171238966,
-0.0208294,
-0.0112985615,
0.0192970149,
-0.025764415,
0.0824992731,
0.0227068439,
0.0170443319,
0.0218388345,
-0.0023295695,
0.0082242172,
0.0445924588,
0.0436268225,
0.0458236411,
-0.0761842132,
-0.024299765,
0.0230094194,
-0.0053143245,
0.0247238614,
0.0729675144,
-0.0102627259,
-0.0331849083,
0.0671056807,
0.013790925,
-0.0005882137,
0.016841609,
0.0040833731,
-0.0026999903,
-0.0068548592,
0.0405683219,
-0.107673578,
0.0181981269,
-0.0297642816,
-0.0015163965,
0.0188530609,
0.056755852,
-0.0211160462,
-0.0159590803,
-0.0030345884,
-0.0031952218,
0.0422663055,
0.0270090159,
0.0231158175,
0.0179645624,
-0.0450807735,
0.0108339619,
0.0742423981,
-0.0254560523,
0.0190343782,
-0.0463871248,
0.0422094204,
0.068034403,
0.0554315746,
-0.0325065292,
-0.040660359,
-0.0543250218,
0.0060989251,
-0.0301548988,
0.0412731729,
0.0002198453,
0.0254093949,
-0.0563368723,
-0.0474734567,
0.0231494866,
0.0162451137,
-0.0125105521,
0.0397357829,
-0.0016056189,
0.0023494021,
-0.0025721358,
-0.0851149783,
0.0407920964,
-0.0391735062,
-0.0474152714,
-0.0291536245,
-0.0017308703,
-0.0007406189,
-0.0406030454,
-0.0175314043,
-0.0099949539,
0.0325074643,
0.0145775229,
0.0191290602,
-0.0227851924,
-0.0654644966,
-0.0045338343,
0.0448739789,
-0.0202407967,
-0.0246824287,
0.0491010845,
-0.0230820198,
-0.0229289886,
-0.0164619237,
-0.0097747101,
0.0029818034,
-0.014726446,
0.0271962136,
-0.0331375934,
0.0234240182,
-0.0321983248,
0.0449823774,
-0.0370791443,
0.0125387423,
-0.0183517169,
-0.0401099995,
-0.0242515858,
-0.037738245,
-0.0761894137,
0.001965005,
-0.0246009696,
0.0528703928,
0.0019904231,
0.0050176457,
-0.0591121949,
-0.0215741508,
-0.0107871527,
0.0041716816,
-0.0378934927,
-0.001852943,
-0.0077354065,
-0.0151012661,
-0.0320329107,
-0.0078888554,
-0.0064830813,
0.009292474,
-0.0141582061,
0.0585946925,
-0.0203313772,
-0.018380018,
-0.0078370934,
-0.029381685,
-0.0377666689,
-0.0182087049,
0.0179968309,
-0.0460448973,
-0.0319056287,
-0.0537113845,
0.0585773364,
-0.028099414,
0.0373595208,
-0.0038904983,
-0.0578752086,
0.0064374274,
0.0060523995,
0.0306370631,
0.1005340144,
-0.0104283243,
0.0234468896,
0.095762521,
-0.0022463771,
-0.0367888063,
0.0223503299,
-0.0149639584,
-0.0460341536,
-0.0059668198,
-0.0047900029,
-0.034763895,
0.0578021519,
-0.0041019684,
-0.0078051877,
-0.0307858661,
0.0274635367,
-0.0430417098,
-0.0311912559,
0.003695606,
-0.0371862762,
-0.0512144044,
0.0264096428,
-0.0173398126,
-0.0756659582,
0.0821007788,
0.0445163921,
0.0344571285,
0.0073332884,
0.0002288713,
0.0406837538,
0.0148275821,
0.0148853911,
0.0275256224,
0.0313617103,
-0.027347764,
-0.0671108887,
-0.028974399,
0.0494563431,
-0.0520182773,
0.0477007143,
-0.0391320065,
-0.0197275616,
-0.0064486181,
-0.0417101793,
-0.0583623908,
-0.034537077,
-0.0319061652,
-0.0229685809,
0.0024839703,
0.0098746354,
-0.0214803796,
-0.0100709535,
0.0213264525,
0.0000326252,
-0.0377877131,
0.0184266306,
-0.0057862122,
-0.0259818658,
0.0827795118,
-0.0389120243,
0.0593692996,
-0.0491386093,
0.0411488935,
0.0741123855,
0.0399434082,
0.0149925062,
-0.0019828593,
0.0220098272,
0.0502810217,
0.0022749424,
-0.0174074676,
0.0639308244,
0.0526615679,
-0.0610195659,
-0.023346113,
0.0361191668,
-0.0005602355,
-0.0328247435,
-0.0041198507,
0.0053304713,
0.0451897308,
0.0334114246,
-0.0020301219,
-0.044731319,
-0.0114189908,
0.0520074107,
0.0375096276,
-0.0192460921,
-0.0295488462,
0.0155347036,
-0.0616453923,
0.0366227552,
0.0440783091,
-0.0499402508,
-0.0096922247,
-0.0155405281,
0.0000638513,
-0.0336829647,
0.0691041574,
0.021865299,
-0.0254894923,
-0.0336013623,
0.0219339002,
-0.006763895,
-0.0886819288,
0.0340170227,
-0.0317613743,
0.0932314768,
0.0653372183,
-0.0112983901,
-0.0249901358,
-0.0402281843,
0.0723124892,
-0.0137532176,
0.0022233112,
-0.0019872433,
0.0684827715,
0.0084183663,
-0.0297829211,
-0.0117728608,
0.0336878523,
0.0221568756,
-0.0260386821,
-0.0211812761,
0.0754341409,
-0.0011454038,
-0.0209491961,
-0.0082864566,
-0.0011996585,
-0.0011301562,
0.0769891888,
0.0185966697,
-0.0535513423,
-0.0006834807,
-0.0448555052,
-0.0072315931,
-0.0339344814,
-0.0398381203,
0.0447433591,
-0.0112005081,
-0.0465375148,
-0.0518147349,
-0.0325857811,
0.0324312635,
0.0080582686,
0.0420385338,
0.0174589325,
0.0133169116,
0.0080015771,
-0.0244326945,
0.0332644172,
-0.0437801555,
0.0064357142,
-0.0496474579,
0.0377534293,
-0.0187428668,
0.0010802941,
-0.0138870683,
0.0295456462,
-0.0889415294,
-0.0926718265,
0.0641624928,
0.0864110962,
0.0275247395,
0.0345308818,
-0.0047544818,
-0.0673230886,
0.0357378982,
0.062491212,
-0.0512217656,
0.0068809721,
0.0542102158,
-0.0613698587,
0.0076343748,
0.0519894958,
-0.0493073352,
-0.0290639084,
0.0594917834,
0.0123988194,
-0.0146246199,
0.0222463198,
0.0243579186,
0.0118633015,
0.0564198717,
-0.0422552153,
-0.0053452752,
-0.031325262,
0.0057144933,
0.0181395933,
-0.0311432891,
-0.000510618,
0.0338385515,
0.0331362598,
-0.0137339979,
-0.0079249283,
-0.0042428649,
0.0023720607,
0.0351690166,
-0.0461344048,
0.0059787333,
-0.01238003,
0.0116767045,
0.069133684,
0.0313958004,
-0.0409294404,
0.0563407354,
-0.0156259574,
0.0299269557,
-0.0121745318,
0.020593131,
0.0158836581,
0.0266931355,
-0.0146755483,
0.0241315085,
-0.0360389948,
-0.055990018,
-0.0411539115,
-0.0050813947,
0.0280857179,
-0.0495816842,
0.0495662317,
0.0018962786,
-0.0194828622,
-0.0382808521,
-0.0203523934,
-0.000783129,
-0.0317618884,
0.0078824395,
0.0176651478,
-0.0180680379,
0.0029519082,
0.0731856152,
-0.0228376519,
0.0438370407,
0.0238281358,
0.0040115817,
-0.0250435583,
-0.0269310679,
0.0121322311,
0.0325832553,
-0.0379713811,
-0.0259951241,
-0.0581927821,
-0.0864915624,
-0.0302495882,
0.0076687504,
0.0021029527,
-0.0342597477,
0.001162388,
0.029524656,
-0.0358773582,
0.0171340834,
-0.020976292,
-0.0150165157,
0.0520992354,
-0.0184685756,
-0.0213279277,
-6.36044271e-33,
0.0125430487,
0.0207386687,
-0.0137665393,
0.0245798584,
0.0121997595,
-0.0335603841,
-0.0157043301,
0.0203226898,
-0.0278461929,
0.0056811757,
-0.0289127827,
0.0088528153,
0.0046925372,
0.0002725677,
0.0131319733,
-0.0509479791,
0.0355192311,
-0.0239833649,
-0.0378135927,
0.0344057605,
0.0181115512,
0.0403777584,
0.0585336536,
-0.0729044601,
0.0250595175,
0.0102816289,
-0.0217148513,
-0.0036670184,
-0.0524107739,
0.0492473841,
0.0088832853,
0.0331776924,
-0.002898986,
-0.0277891923,
-0.0365112834,
-0.0142677156,
-0.0588284247,
-0.016951669,
0.0091359867,
-0.0045372741,
-0.0190382805,
-0.0586463772,
0.0945658162,
-0.0136192003,
-0.0347909033,
-0.0225907657,
-0.0026361083,
-0.0377822928,
-0.0620963834,
-0.0056142118,
-0.0182685815,
0.0050355773,
0.0075990963,
-0.0449518301,
0.0309496298,
0.01102411,
0.0262251627,
0.0236862376,
-0.0411763303,
-0.010762563,
0.0239570159,
0.0336189084,
0.0684705898,
0.0128336819,
-0.0072731404,
0.0840424374,
0.018703863,
0.0352402069,
0.0496825017,
-0.0387896784,
0.0592940599,
0.0312187336,
0.025445994,
0.0306649301,
0.0406074151,
-0.0593111403,
-0.0339546353,
0.0062307296,
-0.0339871757,
0.054028362,
0.0286297277,
0.0087541891,
-0.027483793,
-0.0465358607,
-0.04559898,
0.0008455844,
-0.0406392328,
0.0089825261,
0.0360504836,
0.005925687,
-0.0275794435,
-0.0174845569,
-0.0032051685,
-0.0282490049,
0.0098100509,
0.0193550289,
-0.007040312,
-0.0187702365,
-0.0139791751,
0.0328185298,
-0.0364290252,
-0.006208898,
-0.0199578032,
-0.0445734076,
0.0237200297,
0.01863789,
0.0887821391,
0.0546984673,
-0.0859260783,
0.0131666418,
-0.0475847237,
0.0607419051,
0.0607729107,
0.0044310614,
0.0572748482,
0.0153548932,
0.0211438667,
0.0159260482,
0.0673378333,
-0.0154097695,
-0.0516420379,
0.0322468467,
-0.0374465026,
0.015481065,
-0.004833465,
-0.0157209653,
-0.0122145694,
0.0473010577,
0.0590399802,
-0.0699362084,
0.0000284904,
0.0030824866,
2.608e-7,
0.0013565128,
0.0494032539,
-0.0003445453,
-0.0000189301,
0.0058947345,
0.0543162189,
-0.0336955711,
0.0290429946,
0.0388653614,
-0.0054251202,
-0.0065556117,
0.0261886474,
0.0660870299,
0.0558502413,
-0.0455575287,
0.0257982109,
-0.078505829,
0.01769053,
-0.0307240225,
-0.0341231972,
0.0144029176,
0.0998618081,
0.0421839692,
-0.0289479513,
0.0315535702,
-0.0680570677,
0.0405278131,
-0.0509563275,
0.0099216998,
0.0022819818,
0.0220374577,
0.0787030011,
-0.0096411081,
0.0146886287,
-0.0206574015,
-0.0109264143,
-0.0287336707,
0.0651822537,
0.0069570225,
-0.0117047857,
-0.0006775714,
-0.0236972068,
-0.0060257935,
-0.0387554392,
0.073875308,
-0.0486560799,
0.0051931422,
-0.0272434447,
0.0203392524,
-0.0206935946,
0.0228752773,
-0.0259270016,
-0.0173003189,
0.0059102681,
0.0033721381,
0.0229777545,
-0.011743824,
-0.0599990934,
-0.0386903994,
0.0337100029,
-0.0033819263,
-0.085087426,
-0.0260992944,
0.0168399904,
-0.0132590057,
-0.0912881494,
0.0204415247,
2.445347148e-34,
0.0523669943,
-0.0721047372,
0.0227204319,
0.0020011656,
0.0152513515,
-0.00281098,
0.0166782644,
0.0237603765,
-0.0102694575,
-0.0079631777,
-0.025414506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12716v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12716v3 | BloomVQA: Assessing Hierarchical Multi-modal Comprehension | 2023-12-20T02:22:49 | 2024-06-10T17:39:04 | Yunye Gong, Robik Shrestha, Jared Claypoole, Michael Cogswell, Arijit Ray, Christopher Kanan, Ajay Divakaran | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | We propose a novel VQA dataset, BloomVQA, to facilitate comprehensive
evaluation of large vision-language models on comprehension tasks. Unlike
current benchmarks that often focus on fact-based memorization and simple
reasoning tasks without theoretical grounding, we collect multiple-choice
samples based on picture stories that reflect different levels of
comprehension, as laid out in Bloom's Taxonomy, a classic framework for
learning assessment widely adopted in education research. Our data maps to a
novel hierarchical graph representation which enables automatic data
augmentation and novel measures characterizing model consistency. We perform
graded evaluation and reliability analysis on recent multi-modal models. In
comparison to low-level tasks, we observe decreased performance on tasks
requiring advanced comprehension and cognitive skills with up to 38.0\% drop in
VQA accuracy. In comparison to earlier models, GPT-4V demonstrates improved
accuracy over all comprehension levels and shows a tendency of bypassing visual
inputs especially for higher-level tasks. Current models also show consistency
patterns misaligned with human comprehension in various scenarios,
demonstrating the need for improvement based on theoretically-grounded
criteria. | [
-0.0110512627,
0.0371954478,
-0.0289989728,
0.0313128233,
-0.0574338175,
0.0147964824,
0.0209811162,
-0.0458543636,
0.0170133375,
-0.0544788875,
-0.00721539,
-0.0124039697,
0.0259028897,
0.0639537349,
0.0085988436,
-0.0542564206,
0.052443102,
-0.0210531224,
-0.027674295,
0.0161001943,
-0.0317947157,
-0.0143115763,
-0.0266080126,
0.0669479221,
0.0076909172,
-0.0339003988,
-0.0194705296,
-0.0158240814,
0.0282190256,
-0.0315992162,
-0.052389659,
0.0486271344,
0.0466017164,
0.0034825208,
0.0000021023,
-0.0122831156,
-0.0110713905,
-0.0022587595,
0.0089245029,
0.0351695791,
0.0194951165,
-0.020597443,
0.0495813489,
-0.0095928553,
0.0004098152,
-0.0161172915,
0.0444805361,
0.0169403777,
0.0552202761,
-0.0059992303,
0.0070823664,
-0.0112975538,
0.0317952074,
-0.0038375289,
0.0354630984,
-0.0393827632,
0.0095271217,
0.0830394775,
0.0161388014,
0.0033660945,
-0.0842355415,
0.0460858084,
0.0382101573,
0.0021881869,
-0.0141404197,
0.0429540202,
0.0290753096,
-0.0201089717,
-0.0045485329,
0.0930475369,
0.0235998519,
-0.0106639797,
-0.0455645397,
-0.0119661363,
-0.0028239298,
0.0639890954,
-0.0852932408,
0.0157547425,
-0.0230769534,
-0.0067779087,
-0.0459793359,
-0.0258709379,
0.0214159545,
-0.0029720091,
0.0399319418,
0.0002872109,
0.0117631052,
0.0123081291,
-0.0061313114,
0.018637035,
-0.0483912453,
-0.0062558125,
-0.0107375989,
0.017302867,
-0.0263319574,
0.0309319813,
-0.0273028351,
0.0029261205,
0.0014479657,
-0.0018851254,
0.0551728234,
0.0697340816,
-0.0441182889,
0.0582575239,
-0.0203484278,
0.0872133747,
0.0012105199,
0.0517389365,
-0.0298589151,
0.0017300819,
-0.0582187027,
-0.003583164,
-0.0207479913,
0.0180445965,
-0.0248620156,
-0.0450069271,
-0.0549011901,
0.0111037018,
-0.0261150971,
0.0146230683,
0.0018067028,
0.0146014784,
-0.0207410138,
0.0329965614,
-0.0417118929,
0.0563666634,
0.0009248863,
0.0338219255,
0.0094191954,
0.001191741,
-0.015873298,
0.0021889776,
0.0020565719,
-0.0047520613,
-0.0155826658,
0.0374272317,
-0.047534246,
-0.0435338765,
-0.0344288647,
-0.0356929228,
-0.0079885675,
-0.0458998568,
0.0363996886,
-0.055932343,
0.001497471,
0.0002101905,
0.0154912574,
0.0081193168,
-0.0028606614,
0.0273745731,
-0.0128812883,
0.0596085414,
0.0130848996,
-0.0177766886,
-0.0179289877,
0.0217665602,
-0.0239896066,
0.0528279692,
0.02801116,
-0.0115672927,
0.0415676199,
-0.0152038792,
-0.0050993254,
0.0123730497,
-0.0095011815,
-0.0293204356,
-0.0329352282,
-0.0050019296,
-0.0028409846,
0.0461078584,
-0.0048687682,
0.0360906459,
-0.0378818996,
-0.0309680793,
0.057143826,
0.0411947034,
-0.0003327194,
-0.0187431183,
0.0499824509,
0.0228263848,
0.050996881,
0.0280523635,
-0.0757702515,
0.0409718081,
0.0045161843,
0.0247526001,
-0.026818309,
0.0090790344,
0.000461672,
-0.0516076647,
-0.0089050755,
0.0090827383,
0.0324564241,
0.0238781255,
0.0668990538,
-0.0099806795,
-0.0465776362,
-0.0179528557,
0.0096704112,
-0.0405969694,
0.0261697769,
-0.0376537889,
0.0393749997,
0.0515866689,
0.0526462235,
0.0054781064,
-0.0235417001,
0.0310145635,
0.009663255,
-0.0100298235,
0.0180977844,
0.0001443199,
0.0275731497,
-0.0475162677,
-0.0654021576,
-0.0207779128,
0.0014680041,
0.0014725225,
-0.0252709966,
-0.0370435715,
-0.0159389228,
-0.0995967239,
-0.0161149092,
0.023242576,
-0.01786156,
0.0260728858,
-0.0353447571,
0.0008023338,
0.006165613,
-0.0021563028,
-0.0026795531,
0.0010045483,
0.0382311456,
0.0069418475,
0.0300183073,
0.0299135111,
-0.0931151062,
-0.025258515,
0.0279642567,
-0.0716763288,
-0.0219166707,
0.0612549223,
-0.025647331,
-0.0453454591,
0.041227825,
-0.0482397787,
-0.0149867609,
-0.0361163802,
-0.0016077375,
-0.0128552373,
-0.0089189988,
-0.012113465,
0.077931121,
-0.0197465532,
0.0447149985,
-0.0010675006,
0.0437003076,
0.0261373185,
-0.0060634646,
-0.0168732479,
0.0218437295,
0.0009618034,
0.0215462409,
-0.0192678813,
0.0081616258,
-0.0759462491,
0.0387650542,
-0.1188628152,
-0.0232520085,
0.0010551929,
-0.0296128523,
0.0079178922,
-0.039186772,
-0.0046829558,
-0.014677221,
0.0123862699,
0.0717010796,
-0.0094056595,
0.0105746249,
0.0072490475,
-0.0036366391,
-0.0089826426,
-0.0176985897,
-0.0342675373,
-0.0403926186,
0.0701729208,
0.0473841131,
0.0223276019,
0.0011407147,
0.006613397,
-0.0342281796,
0.0232301597,
-0.0200270005,
-0.0048803738,
0.0507847704,
-0.0053687398,
0.0591683462,
0.0818312839,
-0.0093212714,
0.036035303,
0.0668721646,
-0.0321635082,
-0.0429599397,
0.0043156422,
0.0024895198,
-0.025010407,
-0.0099777458,
-0.0219754688,
-0.0653550103,
0.0372182317,
0.0319807529,
-0.0007950454,
-0.0500054173,
0.0177067146,
-0.0222122353,
-0.003439351,
-0.0791402981,
-0.0021483665,
-0.0026220439,
0.0328667574,
-0.0442265198,
-0.0421229675,
0.0836280659,
-0.0392926857,
0.0077833217,
0.0059177792,
0.0256388243,
-0.0034690462,
0.0881494656,
0.0214689989,
0.0180062111,
-0.0067829089,
-0.0027835744,
-0.0800541788,
0.0040335958,
0.050180614,
-0.0249803085,
0.0628606901,
-0.0844604075,
0.0031456279,
-0.0161427949,
0.0178573728,
-0.018612789,
0.0292215012,
-0.0198993478,
0.0099231768,
-0.0479499325,
-0.0143292146,
-0.0480010919,
0.0038643593,
0.0462972485,
0.0110307708,
-0.0259686466,
-0.0102918083,
-0.0169544891,
0.0263624638,
0.0424168371,
0.0500067398,
0.0081099877,
-0.0458824821,
0.0319383331,
0.0632944703,
0.0128531996,
-0.0102581643,
-0.0216452498,
0.0649688393,
-0.0083989687,
0.0332752801,
0.0154926004,
0.0151905324,
0.072417289,
-0.0669321492,
-0.012579428,
0.0529049076,
0.0060959761,
-0.0326752961,
0.0047230208,
-0.004622729,
0.0275553688,
0.0380459614,
-0.0271265935,
-0.0844803602,
-0.0390030555,
-0.018609846,
0.0385957956,
0.0179827474,
-0.0408950523,
0.0089166993,
-0.0831059217,
0.0585785285,
0.0022532188,
-0.0352078713,
-0.025650626,
-0.0281594787,
0.0087502012,
0.0031817197,
0.0108377794,
-0.0192216653,
-0.0064290185,
0.0125108305,
0.0156949181,
0.037447568,
-0.0444069989,
0.0721442848,
-0.0202867128,
0.0000817253,
-0.0109947547,
0.0012153097,
-0.0134498449,
-0.0462256558,
0.033535473,
-0.0140932733,
0.0034142036,
0.0081592556,
0.0204066839,
-0.0243636239,
-0.0206956081,
-0.0321200453,
0.0137653621,
0.0183139388,
-0.0602056943,
-0.0033045039,
0.0799474567,
0.0020637556,
-0.0349790975,
-0.0443992577,
0.028386604,
-0.054770112,
0.0672070533,
0.0544479713,
-0.0263088308,
-0.0189979989,
-0.0239208322,
0.0274914876,
-0.0439363942,
-0.0497628935,
0.0559974276,
0.0212394316,
0.0291144904,
-0.0329123326,
-0.0357231386,
0.0601793192,
0.0190398097,
-0.0123156048,
-0.0233552624,
0.0367261283,
-0.0117457863,
-0.0754448846,
0.0536384508,
0.0051331855,
0.033052668,
-0.0191380847,
0.0006364455,
-0.0111790625,
-0.0340033881,
-0.0354034789,
0.0389461778,
-0.0721571073,
-0.0110541862,
-0.0138108041,
0.0356342793,
0.0166566689,
0.0242330972,
0.039657671,
-0.0278185122,
0.0189512782,
-0.028260475,
0.0282671228,
0.0177824385,
-0.0423202403,
-0.0122586582,
-0.0171684138,
-0.0065379334,
-0.0246229228,
-0.007779019,
-0.012438315,
0.0545771196,
0.0246285181,
0.0174477473,
0.0326735675,
-0.0019295587,
0.0441467129,
0.0077437675,
-0.009904705,
-0.0483225323,
-0.0101511031,
-0.0307168867,
0.0159485992,
-0.0506108031,
-0.0018348938,
0.0393139645,
-0.0298752952,
0.0101645412,
-0.0012485987,
-0.0060470537,
0.0334064104,
-0.0229121652,
-0.0165885296,
0.0177841093,
-0.0225991383,
-0.0183192994,
0.0089986995,
-0.0401578061,
-0.0466896333,
-0.0430945605,
0.0546629578,
0.0265371129,
0.1052163765,
0.004249488,
-0.0191384032,
-0.0037039346,
0.013601196,
-0.0665496364,
-0.0304440148,
-0.0127645591,
0.0434301905,
0.0287792999,
0.0322595537,
-0.0023440986,
-0.0427780524,
0.0089031868,
-0.0387382545,
0.0342052318,
-0.0031267127,
-0.0231680702,
0.0611197166,
0.0258952882,
0.0410314649,
-0.0027178221,
0.0347600579,
0.0332593136,
0.0350570008,
-0.0263316315,
0.0057065231,
-0.0427971743,
-0.0374713987,
0.0086053247,
0.0632217973,
-0.0097749699,
0.0095187938,
-0.0798856243,
-0.083245039,
0.0026599246,
0.0569647066,
0.0163816884,
-0.0140287327,
0.0079918057,
0.0662382692,
-0.016140338,
-0.0463391803,
-0.0214566477,
0.0040721358,
-0.0227553826,
0.0133909276,
0.0091230078,
-5.968846236e-33,
-0.0400150865,
-0.0545563698,
0.0418598019,
-0.0252686292,
-0.0096434858,
0.0308634043,
-0.0464646667,
0.0298273023,
-0.0419605598,
0.0117187137,
0.0598641783,
0.0011887598,
-0.006952838,
0.0330984145,
-0.0151564134,
0.0097168703,
0.0062492886,
-0.0060604252,
-0.0468803607,
0.0283132195,
0.0437370874,
-0.0364407972,
0.0603738874,
-0.0361928158,
0.025181124,
0.0138667366,
-0.0157205965,
0.0043767565,
-0.0339179821,
0.0820056647,
-0.0380527712,
0.0435849465,
0.039128419,
0.0300792903,
-0.0207675453,
-0.0003467399,
-0.0814107955,
-0.0260908604,
0.0583470613,
0.015194024,
-0.1007297188,
0.0239340886,
0.0478581227,
-0.0050061038,
-0.0239609927,
-0.0884480998,
0.0451170877,
-0.0086455494,
-0.0224228594,
0.0238999017,
-0.0406880602,
-0.0149783371,
-0.0343858488,
-0.0268368237,
-0.0256858636,
0.0729114562,
0.0189085435,
0.0707857683,
-0.0615228862,
0.0074518416,
-0.0184294228,
-0.0057449723,
0.1079386473,
0.0318822041,
0.0298123825,
0.0798270628,
0.0357522257,
-0.0438170582,
-0.0227109548,
-0.0437655933,
0.0687071458,
0.0587208495,
0.0528753027,
0.0696273148,
-0.003424509,
0.0235186163,
-0.0800268725,
0.0459257923,
-0.0287641939,
0.073867619,
0.0036427218,
-0.0119616473,
-0.0013517996,
-0.011276437,
-0.0796000138,
-0.0308823567,
-0.039859917,
0.0030270137,
0.0660903677,
-0.0314693488,
-0.0160516091,
0.0311144311,
0.0433886163,
-0.042259369,
0.0007994458,
0.0175618622,
-0.0290609393,
0.0613816269,
0.0113413502,
0.0579192899,
-0.0250501111,
-0.0055756937,
0.0456283018,
-0.0030433505,
0.0055643469,
-0.0170793477,
0.007230571,
0.0243681073,
-0.014790521,
0.0005973926,
-0.0446113348,
-0.0499637648,
-0.0085408818,
-0.0049391133,
0.0616567507,
0.0187249891,
-0.0449563339,
0.024051683,
-0.020451365,
0.0087667713,
-0.0212704297,
-0.029396927,
-0.0281813033,
0.0384044535,
0.0013695563,
-0.011884449,
-0.0476020165,
-0.0497739837,
0.0171250273,
-0.0457874127,
0.0147514874,
0.0612009093,
2.693e-7,
0.0362882353,
0.0332318731,
0.0021355958,
-0.0043699699,
0.0039684866,
0.0490944944,
-0.0397878736,
-0.0015871607,
0.0340448096,
-0.0556508414,
-0.0143129649,
0.0415116362,
0.0289768446,
-0.0044213664,
-0.0107286181,
0.0163739752,
-0.0107827131,
-0.0155020459,
-0.0468202084,
0.0258725658,
0.1050226167,
0.0393276587,
-0.0220318083,
-0.0126102641,
0.0314153247,
-0.047194127,
0.0858003572,
-0.0328828432,
-0.047378663,
-0.0537181422,
-0.0303811338,
0.0107083386,
0.0236664228,
0.0317044035,
-0.0136771305,
-0.0106695527,
0.0374970846,
0.0145036373,
0.0082042282,
-0.0142714772,
-0.0427330621,
0.0041544475,
-0.0025002358,
-0.0747250393,
0.0690212548,
-0.0497571416,
-0.0232204907,
0.0046220454,
-0.0474713184,
0.004685692,
0.0335903801,
0.0077354894,
-0.026473891,
0.0010544999,
-0.0078497669,
-0.0137681877,
-0.0005081246,
-0.0213528462,
0.0143398922,
-0.0164442174,
-0.0354486182,
-0.0476309918,
-0.0419407375,
-0.0557694659,
0.028527135,
-0.0331172012,
-0.0502986275,
2.136357209e-34,
0.0039266185,
-0.0156477951,
0.0471675508,
-0.0255176965,
0.0004228208,
-0.0395129733,
0.0003175883,
0.0091477875,
-0.0101946164,
-0.0757846534,
-0.0203536227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12713v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12713v2 | Response Enhanced Semi-supervised Dialogue Query Generation | 2023-12-20T02:19:54 | 2024-02-16T02:19:39 | Jianheng Huang, Ante Wang, Linfeng Gao, Linfeng Song, Jinsong Su | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Leveraging vast and continually updated knowledge from the Internet has been
considered an important ability for a dialogue system. Therefore, the dialogue
query generation task is proposed for generating search queries from dialogue
histories, which will be submitted to a search engine for retrieving relevant
websites on the Internet. In this regard, previous efforts were devoted to
collecting conversations with annotated queries and training a query producer
(QP) via standard supervised learning. However, these studies still face the
challenges of data scarcity and domain adaptation. To address these issues, in
this paper, we propose a semi-supervised learning framework -- SemiDQG, to
improve model performance with unlabeled conversations. Based on the
observation that the search query is typically related to the topic of dialogue
response, we train a response-augmented query producer (RA) to provide rich and
effective training signals for QP. We first apply a similarity-based query
selection strategy to select high-quality RA-generated pseudo queries, which
are used to construct pseudo instances for training QP and RA. Then, we adopt
the REINFORCE algorithm to further enhance QP, with RA-provided rewards as
fine-grained training signals. Experimental results and in-depth analysis of
three benchmarks show the effectiveness of our framework in cross-domain and
low-resource scenarios. Particularly, SemiDQG significantly surpasses ChatGPT
and competitive baselines. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/DeepLearnXMU/SemiDQG}. | [
0.0666669607,
0.0544530563,
0.0113548236,
0.0214592293,
-0.0101864552,
0.0147722727,
0.0012405035,
-0.0035407385,
0.0171702057,
-0.058980234,
-0.057879135,
-0.0333088189,
-0.0716907904,
0.0414858833,
0.0154170776,
-0.0456761904,
0.0345733538,
0.0019291275,
0.004793263,
0.0240954999,
0.0109403785,
0.0191586297,
-0.0348968059,
0.0322142616,
-0.0216946341,
-0.0053396006,
-0.0551364906,
0.0331898406,
-0.0078531969,
-0.0307689253,
0.0419512317,
0.0332604349,
0.0286598187,
0.0506478138,
0.0000016468,
-0.0505174883,
-0.0271430518,
-0.0404757373,
-0.0222751964,
-0.0201109741,
0.0313756727,
0.040544223,
0.0241514836,
0.0306159612,
-0.0431129336,
0.0023048455,
0.0387016349,
0.0959030166,
0.0746493489,
0.0956956595,
-0.0129932091,
-0.0014020394,
-0.0038126779,
-0.0324798673,
0.043269895,
-0.0724677816,
-0.0036619222,
0.0176229104,
0.0382106192,
0.0296638738,
0.0096248118,
0.0134371193,
0.0047616516,
-0.0835567117,
0.0208067801,
0.0183542743,
-0.0529457182,
0.0013736349,
0.0012040496,
0.1110724807,
0.0372614227,
-0.0012880532,
0.0169977155,
0.0086531499,
0.0241204221,
-0.0091252849,
-0.0572414771,
-0.0284607653,
0.0094419234,
0.0118969092,
-0.024854213,
0.0334053822,
-0.0033086487,
0.0004439111,
-0.009855181,
0.0294114817,
0.0059023164,
-0.0512681045,
-0.0253319647,
0.0058147609,
0.025408769,
-0.0453399904,
0.0014421428,
0.024102699,
-0.072676897,
0.0152804935,
-0.024071699,
0.0128727118,
0.0064056129,
-0.0325555839,
-0.0080041373,
0.0217366442,
0.0062801084,
0.0629819408,
-0.0148105947,
0.0196470488,
-0.0203168821,
0.0278835651,
-0.070684582,
-0.0231233183,
-0.0814424679,
-0.0255636275,
-0.0460206568,
0.0540429503,
-0.0368648171,
-0.0237611923,
-0.0320051312,
0.0434909239,
0.0290286988,
-0.0233268198,
0.0140817091,
0.0569402836,
-0.0663790703,
0.0293988455,
-0.0385026522,
0.0028133378,
-0.024714686,
0.006193622,
0.0483074747,
-0.0594101325,
-0.0195141714,
0.0190234315,
0.0277413987,
-0.0432921126,
-0.0283297859,
0.0518223159,
-0.031870354,
-0.0440044142,
-0.0251222383,
-0.030011639,
0.0040511526,
-0.033011049,
0.003410785,
-0.0030095996,
0.0536121763,
-0.0388170294,
-0.0260755625,
0.0188753717,
0.0199608505,
0.0414465554,
0.0194060523,
0.0327153206,
-0.0029652549,
-0.0038533155,
0.0252464321,
0.0125974277,
0.0220267046,
0.1004421636,
0.020692138,
0.0244973749,
0.0435792468,
0.0189131461,
0.0081952186,
-0.0459323488,
0.0504803434,
0.0123981591,
0.0027584056,
0.0335487761,
0.003942545,
0.0360160358,
0.0067975488,
0.0408068113,
-0.0373951904,
-0.0217384137,
0.0216766987,
0.0166109707,
0.002740432,
0.0049945009,
0.0212046802,
0.0515549369,
-0.0189855322,
0.0183147863,
-0.0222228486,
0.0370614193,
0.0157098435,
-0.0146039519,
0.067185469,
-0.0247071572,
-0.0588677861,
-0.0327367596,
0.0439256877,
0.0225993507,
0.0035939801,
0.0452901833,
0.0245143585,
0.0415003821,
-0.0487050042,
0.0081437239,
-0.0018994731,
-0.0469629355,
0.0077084266,
-0.0405131616,
0.0318709016,
0.0385510884,
0.0548963472,
-0.0325102992,
-0.0264546983,
-0.0410047695,
0.0154689196,
0.049458541,
0.0480598249,
-0.0302692316,
0.042281501,
-0.0308593623,
-0.0459109768,
-0.0256510433,
-0.0038302897,
0.0240252651,
0.0179466829,
0.0059251655,
0.0437869988,
-0.0458323956,
0.0080402819,
0.0070651574,
-0.0069797072,
-0.0406156071,
0.0495739505,
-0.0050022989,
0.0188068971,
0.0410906225,
-0.0257852152,
0.0072570099,
0.0224805307,
-0.0157322232,
-0.0751975402,
-0.0074980925,
-0.0555031933,
-0.0587734133,
0.0131414765,
0.0003781567,
0.0181539636,
-0.0078619067,
-0.0212760363,
-0.0619044565,
0.010060899,
-0.04732427,
0.068437323,
-0.0634509102,
-0.0252806693,
0.0386727378,
0.0127046872,
-0.0660188645,
0.0347043611,
0.031988807,
-0.0095397048,
0.0184159484,
0.0080696493,
0.0085705733,
-0.064823918,
-0.008268659,
0.0156272613,
-0.0436712354,
0.0165621508,
0.0416220278,
0.0241390765,
-0.0734902695,
0.0102159465,
-0.0940762088,
0.0231860299,
-0.0101400539,
-0.0091193896,
-0.0039870897,
0.0572465472,
-0.0073249899,
-0.0236197151,
-0.0574967265,
-0.0409484841,
0.0435654633,
0.0178356953,
0.041328568,
0.0517855659,
0.0138661293,
-0.0482204668,
0.0032130466,
0.0281184185,
0.0437372327,
0.0076127085,
0.0100109987,
-0.0069526918,
0.0185352564,
-0.0590254739,
0.014499899,
-0.0073534823,
-0.0273199826,
-0.0025537903,
-0.0265275612,
-0.0155210756,
0.0281299874,
0.0618709587,
-0.0011323934,
-0.0288474243,
-0.0057059545,
-0.0908762068,
0.0479421206,
-0.050672017,
-0.0306072757,
-0.0053844792,
0.0135931829,
0.0420667157,
0.0171631556,
0.0075857686,
0.0117997825,
-0.0537846796,
0.0154629583,
0.0422462374,
-0.0354119949,
-0.0398764685,
0.0385607667,
0.0088778427,
0.0298299212,
-0.0110991988,
-0.041349519,
0.0931470022,
0.0314080305,
-0.0180663969,
-0.0597367473,
-0.0273355823,
-0.0297822487,
0.0431232229,
-0.0253159981,
0.0326532945,
0.0033508225,
-0.0432070605,
-0.0301889163,
-0.0115140919,
0.028218966,
-0.0212511588,
0.023985615,
0.0016287249,
0.0384715199,
0.0028894499,
-0.0565486699,
-0.0880794004,
-0.0224056952,
-0.0008659246,
-0.0171531625,
0.0067050289,
-0.0157688316,
-0.0140457982,
0.004818798,
-0.0003779881,
0.0147361942,
-0.0162649695,
-0.0273359232,
-0.0033552356,
0.0523556732,
0.0589679629,
0.0185867101,
-0.0355404876,
-0.0103278607,
0.0488755815,
0.0344339646,
0.0529883057,
-0.0402067751,
0.0171424244,
-0.0304696914,
0.0132074747,
-0.0285595339,
0.0236277282,
-0.0085830111,
0.0377256051,
0.0045331703,
-0.0260371678,
0.1031788364,
0.0392799005,
-0.0275024418,
-0.0167311486,
-0.0147430738,
0.0426745936,
0.0221647043,
0.0520358495,
-0.0727166981,
-0.0206805822,
-0.025564272,
0.0347173661,
-0.0086538345,
-0.0262448266,
-0.0105618425,
-0.1158392131,
0.0197605807,
-0.0346536934,
-0.0156560987,
-0.0102721024,
-0.0420020744,
-0.0022864803,
-0.0142454756,
-0.0302733574,
0.0189604554,
-0.0172088388,
-0.0067634922,
0.0248196591,
0.0302467626,
-0.0520123504,
-0.0190051682,
-0.0022606722,
0.0128371604,
0.0678980276,
0.0506260879,
0.0502524376,
0.0255987644,
0.0151033057,
-0.0286457129,
0.0032561182,
-0.0285207294,
0.0863299593,
-0.0317144804,
-0.0109206233,
-0.0267375968,
0.0108598443,
-0.03056949,
-0.0061543398,
0.0110105174,
0.0222530141,
-0.0531943776,
0.0204499364,
-0.0396673717,
0.0066479268,
0.0162006728,
0.0818105415,
0.0237379633,
-0.006094337,
-0.0639047548,
-0.0114810793,
-0.00362492,
-0.076801464,
0.0172947757,
-0.0337553136,
-0.0015187038,
0.0290344264,
-0.078583248,
-0.0430502668,
-0.0049804254,
0.0337001123,
-0.0268943124,
-0.007963392,
-0.0059411782,
0.027522957,
-0.0292703938,
-0.0107696578,
-0.0402425602,
-0.0143607697,
-0.0371664762,
-0.0301571582,
0.072498396,
-0.0498192012,
-0.0056227725,
-0.0190155208,
-0.0437072851,
-0.057492841,
-0.0586375147,
0.0277959276,
0.0141329002,
0.0581138097,
-0.0118711218,
0.0081082154,
0.0123266997,
0.0761767477,
-0.0301321559,
-0.0505918413,
0.0296946801,
0.0331365913,
-0.0063268975,
0.0445414893,
-0.0660573319,
0.0025790844,
-0.0166852623,
0.0571788773,
-0.0245919544,
-0.065422006,
0.0454668626,
-0.0191626474,
0.0384665877,
0.0177453626,
0.0183410048,
-0.0275153387,
0.0341074988,
-0.0132282255,
-0.0201185253,
-0.072319828,
0.0383406505,
-0.0034753948,
-0.0327592716,
0.0079110619,
0.0007348093,
-0.0776061714,
0.0805346221,
-0.0455771834,
-0.0246302672,
-0.0081861494,
-0.0299425609,
0.0116363363,
-0.004233825,
0.0023500889,
0.0293041784,
0.0615663044,
0.0365311913,
-0.0041881306,
0.0462484062,
0.029057242,
-0.0004381198,
0.0256937202,
0.0039453516,
-0.1001280546,
-0.0437455289,
-0.0510059334,
0.0074478383,
0.0429430567,
-0.0113526052,
0.0030805382,
-0.004747855,
0.0135534033,
-0.020272769,
0.0468161739,
0.0011197119,
-0.0166807845,
0.0178792458,
0.0290778168,
-0.0212006532,
0.0365272611,
0.0626923591,
-0.0190194603,
0.0400368348,
0.0141655048,
-0.0209934488,
-0.0647335127,
-0.0493949242,
0.0327972099,
0.0371907726,
-0.0052449643,
0.0286145769,
0.0116488831,
-0.0407154188,
-0.009781654,
-0.0265834723,
-0.0145968366,
0.0014194198,
0.1000238135,
0.0604865402,
-0.0084993541,
0.0030281683,
-0.0636851341,
0.0095137935,
-0.0182544719,
-0.0301720947,
-0.0070754392,
-5.734844616e-33,
-0.011448415,
-0.0044483938,
0.0174279083,
0.0047547682,
-0.0431011654,
-0.0265460126,
-0.0423394889,
-0.0017837773,
-0.0158803947,
-0.0112849977,
-0.0061660516,
0.0212381855,
0.0134219667,
0.0567890033,
-0.025559349,
-0.0619064607,
0.0684330091,
-0.0110881897,
-0.0006013701,
0.0798735693,
0.032587111,
0.0439523757,
0.008632632,
-0.0706443042,
-0.003134279,
-0.0127885677,
0.00560079,
0.0450185165,
0.0417574793,
0.0747318715,
-0.033030685,
0.0334852859,
0.0323091261,
-0.0283850934,
0.013626351,
0.0150745697,
-0.0491249748,
-0.0204072352,
-0.0296787396,
-0.0312324315,
-0.0233328436,
-0.0064195208,
-0.0109716374,
-0.0204738341,
0.0347689465,
0.0161441769,
0.023190232,
-0.0046056104,
-0.0366769768,
-0.0493486449,
-0.0406790711,
0.0088709593,
-0.036453981,
-0.0608109385,
-0.0254493784,
0.1243768409,
0.0314136669,
0.0183478855,
0.0172315277,
0.0359647758,
-0.0176743884,
0.0342717953,
0.0259572603,
0.0281740092,
-0.0094381301,
0.0548520498,
0.0390833281,
0.016444331,
-0.0057717287,
-0.0011574966,
-0.0281090792,
0.016708361,
-0.0060701813,
0.0598892383,
0.0083689084,
-0.0056228819,
-0.0558509156,
0.0449735597,
0.0274463259,
0.0010897063,
0.0008207567,
0.0181213338,
-0.0216986816,
-0.0064320923,
-0.0152274193,
0.0222055372,
-0.0304163955,
-0.0133242086,
0.0526366122,
0.0491539612,
-0.0203230102,
-0.0031261123,
0.0379384272,
-0.0468098484,
-0.0370731279,
0.0458409302,
-0.0213919077,
-0.0383348837,
0.008137621,
-0.0218975432,
-0.0257749427,
-0.0344143212,
0.049153503,
0.0065096985,
-0.0399935022,
0.0028407599,
-0.0024170778,
-0.0069901794,
-0.0374250226,
-0.0082311351,
-0.0100556388,
0.0476424992,
-0.0726138949,
0.0338092893,
-0.022518687,
0.0071762167,
-0.0293634143,
0.0945889428,
0.0025836031,
-0.0006829076,
-0.0293138139,
-0.0605295114,
0.0171316043,
-0.0029695865,
-0.0158327203,
0.0224659666,
-0.0219308529,
0.0101743108,
-0.0141136199,
-0.0705641359,
-0.0165454745,
0.0155601231,
2.456e-7,
-0.014047686,
0.0159045886,
0.0349070467,
0.0398941971,
0.0064922366,
0.0500728749,
0.0178100318,
0.0484633334,
0.0340657905,
-0.0114482772,
0.0081982967,
0.0189753473,
0.033806935,
0.002456292,
-0.0995731354,
-0.0308947824,
-0.0738883987,
-0.0572499745,
-0.0479984991,
-0.027928954,
0.0828119218,
0.0747977197,
-0.0060622999,
-0.0056517962,
0.0097498484,
-0.0244324207,
0.0576572306,
0.0108872969,
-0.0484161898,
0.0401303805,
0.0344179422,
0.0334829651,
0.0030627716,
-0.0050713131,
-0.0206177961,
0.032836441,
0.026075162,
0.0300629362,
0.018508736,
-0.0589659363,
0.0026126634,
0.0063344184,
0.0352265388,
-0.0099983523,
0.0616727211,
-0.0398389883,
0.0173268262,
-0.0007829901,
-0.0129134599,
-0.0030951388,
0.0352124274,
-0.0394877009,
-0.0495540947,
0.006327542,
0.0206567813,
0.0169124566,
0.0106995041,
-0.0716412961,
0.0241907816,
-0.00632466,
-0.06697274,
-0.0261757318,
-0.0400809832,
0.0183558278,
-0.0032988826,
0.0096811438,
0.0059390655,
1.95205898e-34,
0.0499486811,
0.005913049,
-0.016899921,
0.0156009588,
0.0017850415,
0.0079860836,
0.000538661,
-0.0409046635,
0.0490492545,
-0.0528768301,
-0.0194778331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12683v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12683v1 | Turning English-centric LLMs Into Polyglots: How Much Multilinguality Is Needed? | 2023-12-20T00:49:52 | 2023-12-20T00:49:52 | Tannon Kew, Florian Schottmann, Rico Sennrich | cs.CL | cs.CL | The vast majority of today's large language models are English-centric,
having been pretrained predominantly on English text. Yet, in order to meet
user expectations, models need to be able to respond appropriately in multiple
languages once deployed in downstream applications. Given limited exposure to
other languages during pretraining, cross-lingual transfer is important for
achieving decent performance in non-English settings. In this work, we
investigate just how much multilinguality is required during finetuning to
elicit strong cross-lingual generalisation across a range of tasks and target
languages. We find that, compared to English-only finetuning, multilingual
instruction tuning with as few as three languages significantly improves a
model's cross-lingual transfer abilities on generative tasks that assume
input/output language agreement, while being of less importance for highly
structured tasks. Our code and data is available at
https://github.com/ZurichNLP/multilingual-instruction-tuning. | [
-0.0091324272,
0.0313885584,
-0.0020127266,
0.0588924624,
-0.0218215045,
0.0425333567,
0.0270832125,
-0.0377764739,
-0.0318231806,
-0.018662028,
-0.0765126273,
-0.0313671678,
-0.0354180634,
-0.0185254347,
0.0521133766,
-0.0399564169,
0.0515731536,
-0.048545491,
-0.0582685359,
-0.0283330362,
0.0174432788,
0.0354697779,
-0.0003650158,
0.0088872192,
0.0056694248,
-0.0066154068,
0.0064590587,
0.0207461528,
0.0368198007,
0.0268918443,
0.0096873203,
0.0171109121,
0.000074018,
0.0062351665,
0.0000018438,
-0.0340004601,
0.0055291411,
-0.0106881699,
0.0245615263,
0.0233912561,
0.0193165522,
-0.0361980088,
-0.0277553461,
-0.0016652039,
-0.0195410792,
0.0194687247,
0.068987079,
0.0067536063,
0.0394399762,
0.0878875405,
-0.0020255798,
-0.023224365,
0.0159932282,
-0.0389396772,
0.0281937588,
-0.0537256338,
-0.0135586178,
-0.0066655772,
-0.0083345957,
-0.0229364987,
-0.028135879,
0.0546713509,
0.0392451584,
0.009984321,
-0.048322659,
0.0038294136,
-0.0210060216,
-0.0043672584,
-0.0260948054,
0.0630374178,
-0.0564377941,
0.0056886137,
-0.0104702096,
-0.021342475,
0.0076065981,
-0.0357180014,
-0.0439670235,
0.0438227952,
0.010818325,
0.0128338737,
0.0321715996,
-0.058841113,
0.0446768068,
-0.001657158,
-0.0251510236,
0.0755450502,
0.0382404774,
0.0048075425,
0.0269377679,
0.0366165712,
0.0050936169,
-0.0246939249,
-0.0185667388,
0.0124358283,
-0.0213507004,
0.0137678599,
-0.0431182273,
0.002935936,
0.00464783,
-0.0217551831,
0.0623361208,
0.0456647389,
-0.0382130481,
0.0408318937,
-0.0191204343,
0.0375830717,
-0.0151250493,
0.0429008752,
-0.0531576276,
-0.0355779901,
-0.0141314082,
0.0270534623,
-0.0235239863,
-0.0060655461,
-0.0298771616,
0.029957125,
-0.0572020262,
0.0229826327,
-0.001329686,
0.0088138618,
0.0288724657,
-0.0457184277,
-0.0775222108,
-0.0203951038,
0.017030187,
0.0524531677,
-0.0392401926,
0.0271483548,
0.0251559708,
-0.0936074853,
-0.0133642955,
0.029559752,
-0.0329312347,
-0.0694760978,
0.0205156151,
0.0747678503,
-0.0373488292,
0.0008815228,
-0.0678830594,
0.0058447514,
-0.0081492942,
-0.0797166526,
0.0318741687,
-0.0781949684,
0.0355672613,
-0.0027862317,
0.0284591783,
-0.0411115289,
-0.0161680821,
-0.0279921889,
0.0045824996,
0.0519800596,
-0.0170951802,
-0.0010036046,
0.0066990857,
-0.0137146786,
-0.0019420243,
0.1224614531,
0.0212231539,
0.0208102204,
0.0299377237,
-0.0173538923,
-0.0046217917,
0.0969717726,
0.0070759938,
0.0252467319,
-0.0024161492,
-0.0146790231,
0.0129607664,
-0.0021242297,
0.0683922544,
0.0142239276,
-0.0222086441,
0.004144547,
0.0269416049,
0.0258962121,
0.0278913379,
0.0310645085,
0.0972758904,
-0.0329543874,
-0.0088146776,
0.025920853,
-0.0584204756,
0.0336669944,
-0.0165366996,
0.0250165313,
-0.0013795961,
0.085567221,
-0.0420694239,
-0.016927598,
0.0116358437,
-0.011814408,
0.0019968867,
-0.000876199,
0.049446933,
0.0211453661,
-0.0178379733,
0.0575702228,
0.0617268309,
-0.0529630855,
0.0255177338,
-0.0290628616,
-0.0205377489,
0.050352525,
-0.0072156154,
0.0074121929,
-0.0583578236,
-0.0121405888,
0.03726013,
0.0306238569,
0.0873227492,
-0.0125165321,
0.0767566338,
-0.0532906279,
-0.0160580128,
-0.0235129241,
0.0000941208,
0.0733574182,
-0.0138453478,
0.0189741589,
0.003975518,
-0.0293885469,
-0.0309141576,
0.0198467579,
-0.0938481018,
-0.0244987626,
0.0127540063,
0.0045080674,
0.0123260478,
0.0088454029,
-0.0206315368,
-0.0151159018,
-0.0000216493,
-0.0488509908,
0.0281005483,
0.0149547579,
-0.0190983359,
-0.0405530185,
0.0365544781,
-0.0197086819,
-0.0278111845,
-0.0116043445,
-0.068240881,
-0.0366951376,
0.016978465,
-0.0038311912,
-0.0032239563,
-0.0490394942,
0.0071624694,
-0.0006819288,
0.0095068291,
-0.0386637151,
-0.0046470324,
-0.0079458598,
0.0110730911,
-0.0015754924,
-0.0133113014,
0.0180506986,
-0.0411683843,
-0.0114805913,
0.0402170904,
0.0135448957,
0.0286669433,
0.0120220007,
0.0642543137,
-0.0409101844,
-0.0431999117,
-0.0634976551,
0.0145114856,
-0.0480173752,
0.0579344705,
0.0259840712,
0.0237526167,
-0.0242303479,
-0.0182795972,
-0.0463670082,
0.006069262,
0.015502804,
0.0475658551,
0.0031562701,
-0.0008597533,
0.00480694,
-0.033039175,
-0.0167079493,
0.0373539291,
0.0120707797,
-0.031549003,
-0.0032283594,
-0.059697248,
0.0209802575,
-0.0497151539,
0.0135129243,
-0.0199552141,
-0.0392443091,
-0.0038493946,
-0.0063100681,
0.0486077778,
0.0495476313,
-0.0492181256,
-0.0069682882,
0.0386337191,
-0.0234397594,
-0.0525844283,
0.041844938,
0.0000049421,
-0.0639536083,
-0.0834114775,
-0.0360220633,
-0.0005637465,
0.0871160477,
-0.0378894061,
-0.0286330562,
-0.0596945025,
-0.0169592686,
0.001645953,
-0.045581609,
-0.0047933017,
0.0498935506,
0.0037762185,
0.0486749634,
-0.01151287,
-0.0561618619,
0.0543349199,
-0.0257705394,
-0.0184676368,
-0.0430073775,
-0.0262832753,
-0.0170697812,
0.0126721822,
-0.0118645374,
0.0417734794,
-0.0253456645,
-0.0224263426,
-0.0759171098,
-0.0039356458,
0.0258495081,
-0.0037512502,
0.0693323836,
-0.0503056869,
-0.0130063044,
-0.0389501452,
-0.0453868732,
0.0029133153,
0.0257247761,
-0.0151911043,
0.0217904355,
0.020669302,
-0.0211706758,
-0.0321367495,
-0.0335107185,
0.0435631387,
0.0184045695,
-0.0184473004,
0.0089679454,
-0.0294187609,
-0.0177854188,
0.0407313369,
0.0358508378,
0.0112279318,
-0.0781544894,
-0.0201156754,
0.0091417609,
0.0052422695,
-0.0220716242,
-0.0058030928,
0.0309785139,
0.0549669005,
-0.0338359959,
-0.0434475169,
0.016475901,
0.1050733253,
-0.0365886316,
-0.0179199446,
0.063883096,
-0.0214622617,
-0.0337028392,
-0.0010044128,
-0.0245123152,
0.0470958836,
0.0399712771,
0.063709043,
-0.0766462684,
-0.0223547593,
-0.0034150765,
0.0023358108,
0.0344909728,
0.0133781256,
-0.0274275262,
-0.0977606028,
0.0288239997,
0.023437161,
-0.0735865012,
-0.033076413,
-0.0056736981,
-0.0212453622,
-0.0246487986,
0.0475409329,
-0.0245969165,
-0.0188424718,
0.0030249446,
0.0219306108,
0.0123868892,
-0.0562149547,
-0.0031854997,
-0.0525357053,
0.055598408,
0.0734475777,
-0.0024036609,
-0.0018714721,
-0.0380965956,
0.0785723031,
0.0146629689,
-0.0028773013,
0.0023141943,
0.0215096697,
0.0207133871,
-0.0243166108,
0.0642122775,
-0.004106408,
-0.0336491615,
0.0070139235,
0.0298296139,
0.0779476613,
0.0055416306,
-0.0135133713,
0.0091271037,
-0.008060242,
0.0024290022,
0.0285635926,
0.04122122,
-0.0403698049,
-0.046541851,
-0.0750589818,
-0.0246323738,
-0.0883153379,
-0.0365954377,
0.0273786187,
-0.0491124652,
-0.0294954404,
-0.0330137797,
-0.0601356663,
0.0226811096,
0.0364143103,
0.0179824531,
-0.0256378744,
-0.0145636825,
-0.0149655333,
0.0009370818,
0.0329878144,
-0.0323815569,
0.0276532229,
-0.065192312,
-0.0225107111,
0.041535899,
-0.019722946,
0.0068555595,
-0.0093558598,
-0.0637004673,
-0.0766975135,
-0.0214722082,
0.0720647871,
0.0107133901,
0.0613613427,
-0.0008305308,
-0.0569723509,
0.0038374511,
0.0311928634,
0.0041169696,
0.0301286913,
0.0683220923,
0.0276495311,
-0.0102459677,
0.0600266233,
-0.0549866259,
0.0257757846,
0.0649856776,
0.041222021,
-0.0072431522,
-0.0392130874,
-0.0131580746,
0.0272454433,
-0.0052134022,
-0.0314203724,
-0.0019361788,
-0.0320285857,
0.0183457844,
-0.0040504117,
-0.0066653551,
-0.0599972494,
-0.0254511293,
0.0206561014,
-0.0269616917,
0.0227695964,
0.0322925188,
0.0307143759,
0.0334064737,
-0.0495611317,
0.0069077793,
0.0157031715,
0.0121952053,
0.0366822183,
0.0441274457,
-0.0004946432,
0.0234272201,
0.0046388116,
0.0451165326,
-0.018301744,
0.0229688473,
0.0016695731,
0.0300136805,
-0.0118962582,
0.007467323,
-0.0331432931,
-0.049529355,
-0.0227458254,
0.0093471464,
0.0786671415,
-0.0090693058,
0.1092849597,
-0.0007256542,
-0.0227220487,
-0.0274755042,
0.0408966169,
-0.0137385158,
-0.0028479579,
0.0204345845,
-0.0033558307,
-0.0105813965,
-0.0284437556,
0.0721863881,
-0.0074290242,
0.0414179713,
-0.0074608987,
0.0406552106,
-0.0175469741,
-0.0552277304,
0.0218032543,
-0.0204730462,
0.0018178457,
0.0193463042,
-0.0093640378,
-0.0726079941,
-0.0184456613,
0.0271215811,
-0.003564853,
0.0008492322,
0.0325222723,
0.0833589211,
-0.0235035308,
-0.0034404781,
-0.0345271453,
-0.0120288581,
0.0444420055,
-0.0301340558,
0.0080343569,
-5.904531267e-33,
-0.0454956666,
0.0306152292,
0.0370090604,
-0.001549625,
-0.0285432823,
-0.0375111848,
-0.0187392198,
0.0097291674,
-0.0169316176,
0.0211428031,
-0.0064778188,
-0.0165329836,
0.0140444087,
0.0340454839,
0.029382918,
0.0094909631,
0.0356082879,
-0.0050696097,
-0.0136829074,
0.0438212194,
0.015793208,
0.0442255624,
0.1059918553,
-0.024965765,
0.0057247169,
0.0259751361,
-0.0148565266,
0.0076683578,
-0.017542297,
0.0350822471,
0.0081075011,
0.0184898302,
0.007023125,
-0.0376083814,
-0.0626440942,
-0.0462705344,
-0.0483638942,
-0.0451413058,
0.0209807605,
0.0115948608,
-0.0378683731,
-0.0681700632,
0.0511969402,
-0.0196111836,
-0.0350787342,
-0.0344105475,
0.02184196,
-0.0326731652,
-0.0113652283,
-0.0539175197,
-0.076186426,
0.0140571063,
0.0001596973,
0.0132992137,
0.0355704054,
0.0271734037,
-0.0017659037,
0.015264241,
-0.0172448661,
0.0243406445,
0.0054871528,
0.0531944744,
0.1125285625,
0.0056374315,
-0.0166177582,
0.0093405759,
0.016742466,
0.0086173639,
0.0363959968,
0.0134239513,
0.03253318,
0.0393216573,
0.0149083845,
0.0621389076,
0.0182583313,
0.0093512191,
-0.0652823672,
0.0417255424,
0.0073275156,
0.0139069837,
-0.0094492771,
0.0137776742,
0.0218254551,
-0.0335038751,
-0.0296378266,
0.0014301254,
-0.0083589936,
-0.0404231176,
0.0247393437,
-0.0301009044,
0.0084586255,
-0.0099569466,
0.0601020604,
-0.0360481218,
-0.0280777588,
0.0003191243,
-0.0231999736,
0.0054862355,
-0.0000859861,
0.0512977317,
-0.0564055666,
-0.0523020513,
-0.0257900991,
-0.014088287,
0.0282666013,
0.0048933038,
0.0620433055,
0.0342006646,
-0.0715341344,
0.0170112923,
-0.0478501543,
0.0418391712,
0.0367322788,
0.0766584948,
0.0066541573,
-0.0220319554,
-0.0108503429,
0.0622748435,
0.0158564802,
-0.0468756743,
-0.0068299356,
-0.0232084803,
0.0079504047,
0.0501109213,
-0.0469769351,
0.0084342482,
-0.0423936769,
-0.0042781797,
0.0318133608,
-0.0391789749,
-0.0277385321,
0.0144065395,
2.559e-7,
0.0467695594,
0.0030719484,
0.0110165803,
0.0162754003,
-0.0007256755,
0.0184262116,
-0.052884914,
0.0296116173,
0.0094949994,
-0.007882067,
-0.0098880148,
0.0441346839,
0.0764432773,
0.0423913151,
-0.0508646034,
0.0315996893,
-0.0240457412,
0.0536928736,
-0.0326864198,
0.0092919646,
-0.0171009861,
0.0724448189,
-0.0121477675,
-0.0127534037,
0.0230610501,
-0.0156756416,
0.0509099476,
-0.0589482635,
-0.0213034637,
0.0543136112,
0.0189854745,
0.0046089222,
-0.0082154088,
-0.0091800326,
-0.0308149494,
0.0078239245,
0.0009022719,
0.0782343745,
0.0113006486,
-0.0200120565,
0.0332362503,
-0.0162227601,
-0.0022430443,
-0.0206719618,
0.0483675189,
-0.0301644094,
-0.0111934533,
-0.0208640303,
0.0150140785,
0.0044019455,
0.0472977273,
-0.0666503981,
-0.0129375039,
0.0183767099,
0.0633097813,
-0.0044483063,
-0.0645571202,
-0.0358683318,
-0.0056879059,
0.0286611114,
-0.02654179,
-0.0652736202,
-0.0234979037,
0.0249225628,
-0.0112123061,
-0.0462761745,
0.0024109602,
2.133427656e-34,
0.0376808606,
-0.0194882751,
0.0272185504,
0.0363259129,
0.0126966117,
-0.032945767,
-0.0467505381,
0.0005612763,
-0.0198344495,
-0.04972592,
-0.0212990884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12682v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12682v1 | Mini-GPTs: Efficient Large Language Models through Contextual Pruning | 2023-12-20T00:48:13 | 2023-12-20T00:48:13 | Tim Valicenti, Justice Vidal, Ritik Patnaik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | In AI research, the optimization of Large Language Models (LLMs) remains a
significant challenge, crucial for advancing the field's practical applications
and sustainability. Building upon the foundational work of Professor Song Han's
lab at MIT, this paper introduces a novel approach in developing Mini-GPTs via
contextual pruning. Our methodology strategically prunes the computational
architecture of traditional LLMs, like Phi-1.5, focusing on retaining core
functionalities while drastically reducing model sizes. We employ the technique
across diverse and complex datasets, including US law, Medical Q&A, Skyrim
dialogue, English-Taiwanese translation, and Economics articles. The results
underscore the efficiency and effectiveness of contextual pruning, not merely
as a theoretical concept but as a practical tool in developing domain-specific,
resource-efficient LLMs. Contextual pruning is a promising method for building
domain-specific LLMs, and this research is a building block towards future
development with more hardware compute, refined fine-tuning, and quantization. | [
0.0232350715,
0.0778655112,
-0.0269980561,
0.082505025,
-0.0518292636,
0.0057752109,
0.0215291269,
0.041852653,
-0.0157258976,
-0.0159394033,
-0.0652769804,
-0.0302939788,
0.0237849914,
0.0118051013,
-0.0155776655,
-0.0369140543,
0.0380550176,
-0.0203753896,
0.0202461313,
-0.0338307805,
0.013348761,
0.0093894815,
0.0360639952,
0.0279970337,
0.0334272087,
-0.0259228665,
0.0040929131,
0.0089132283,
0.011622861,
0.0154390717,
-0.0012070804,
0.0483535677,
0.0136572598,
0.0439790264,
0.0000020385,
-0.0203035828,
-0.0025628095,
0.0181730669,
-0.016764449,
0.0362146758,
0.0725406781,
-0.0363865122,
-0.0134945968,
0.0086622257,
-0.0415363163,
-0.0246921536,
0.0280194692,
0.0256840549,
0.0609866381,
0.1035660878,
-0.0108286776,
-0.0512146167,
0.0231794771,
-0.0623712204,
-0.0034915905,
-0.0806048587,
0.0189727563,
-0.0158980861,
-0.0029742492,
0.0018172569,
-0.0344113,
0.0384970009,
0.0282700732,
0.0126909725,
-0.0597773939,
0.022191789,
-0.0571620576,
0.0210549198,
0.0001166446,
0.0634598136,
-0.0019657821,
-0.0239221882,
0.0174427126,
-0.0005410151,
-0.0247766282,
-0.0379119329,
-0.0504666343,
0.0186926574,
-0.0104186358,
0.0202846024,
0.0306069124,
-0.0204965938,
0.0400330722,
0.0200554952,
-0.0382856354,
0.0573550686,
0.0170122087,
-0.0238268431,
-0.0151845552,
-0.0137310997,
-0.0394073613,
-0.04130169,
0.0000636484,
0.0114862239,
-0.0325922631,
0.0201265793,
-0.0354423448,
-0.006052562,
0.0004962433,
-0.0175993703,
0.0010155698,
0.0326720513,
0.0663312972,
0.0738030076,
0.0271117371,
0.0505078547,
0.0050236173,
-0.0280959196,
-0.0536066517,
-0.0281761549,
-0.0269477312,
-0.001456026,
-0.0485242121,
0.0385791622,
-0.0553840585,
-0.0205491353,
-0.0396023951,
-0.0016220669,
-0.0177336335,
-0.0032749071,
0.0290188938,
-0.0080242846,
-0.0284845792,
-0.0331315435,
0.0165570453,
0.0006606377,
-0.0344545692,
0.0061326958,
-0.0230219048,
-0.0462206751,
-0.0056069619,
0.0360726751,
0.0016638307,
-0.0516838431,
-0.0005740818,
0.0602331795,
0.0253300499,
-0.0499545224,
-0.028432861,
-0.021733297,
-0.0315657854,
-0.0850971043,
-0.0465939976,
-0.0577400103,
0.0328878239,
-0.0557451732,
0.009936668,
-0.0713700578,
-0.0130988704,
0.0280618407,
-0.0398256741,
0.0709394962,
0.0306882765,
0.0209940821,
0.0086725047,
0.0121470112,
0.0322580561,
0.0875650272,
0.0629611835,
0.0137483589,
0.0188609399,
-0.0115758311,
-0.0415630825,
0.0497315489,
0.0465160683,
0.0297684651,
-0.028022645,
0.0065516485,
-0.0417397171,
0.0172355175,
0.0121169453,
0.0867308006,
-0.0286321603,
-0.0153023656,
0.0564289838,
0.06859418,
0.0069166268,
0.0532573573,
0.0357074887,
0.0170933492,
-0.0062583769,
-0.006520418,
-0.0399102084,
-0.0129641974,
-0.0182860363,
-0.0156567059,
-0.0007371238,
0.0220805388,
-0.0339774117,
-0.0363371037,
-0.0114949048,
-0.0064330432,
-0.0233404692,
0.0380995348,
0.0272184815,
-0.0027555861,
-0.0309007633,
0.059040878,
-0.0023394064,
-0.0561420098,
-0.0188639387,
-0.0584289506,
-0.0052807983,
0.0422191098,
0.0562343448,
-0.0341326259,
-0.0259331558,
0.0088823857,
0.0186159965,
0.0330926441,
0.0430841707,
-0.0155146718,
0.0129559282,
-0.045577798,
-0.0092329569,
0.006165571,
0.0153321782,
-0.021421453,
0.0685453489,
0.0291511584,
0.0271397326,
-0.0443233997,
-0.0049711475,
0.0164216738,
-0.0545078479,
-0.0277124848,
0.0401756428,
0.0002745661,
0.0630362928,
-0.0047649611,
-0.0069037667,
-0.0053069112,
0.0363789499,
-0.0481632911,
0.0109278681,
-0.003548037,
-0.0182029027,
-0.0472385809,
0.0479271188,
-0.0112325298,
0.0351872295,
0.0326369442,
-0.0872813314,
-0.0436444134,
-0.0011801448,
-0.0389111899,
0.0313116238,
-0.0472999215,
0.0189833064,
-0.0249828026,
0.0315022394,
-0.0296946876,
0.0524982139,
-0.0344201103,
-0.0077923369,
0.0414102674,
0.005171827,
0.0067539993,
-0.0659965277,
-0.0186497103,
-0.0025691346,
-0.0035631766,
0.0259261504,
0.0460887849,
0.0232884716,
-0.0115593662,
-0.0235860907,
-0.0972157121,
0.0411513597,
-0.0297868643,
0.0282342881,
0.0218485091,
0.0453293249,
0.0014631939,
0.0258323979,
-0.0099246968,
0.0061999578,
0.0115909921,
0.0148233538,
0.006814932,
-0.0014485711,
-0.0236844141,
-0.0308216047,
-0.0199953094,
0.0041837441,
0.0332868621,
-0.0411435589,
-0.0107039893,
-0.0253150109,
0.0792591274,
0.0072771795,
0.008332924,
-0.0206819456,
-0.0107887937,
-0.0346880518,
0.0012327064,
0.043900568,
0.0701720566,
-0.0016473368,
0.0641327128,
0.0264077801,
-0.0036895364,
-0.0399143621,
0.0315767527,
-0.0037334848,
-0.0298800301,
-0.0266244933,
-0.0437919609,
0.0325712524,
0.0416338742,
-0.0103585916,
-0.0047964812,
-0.0692429319,
0.0488357767,
-0.0165537931,
-0.0465549938,
-0.016106775,
0.0221123546,
-0.0227804873,
0.0086546168,
-0.0243340842,
-0.0390033051,
0.0425635315,
-0.0212174971,
0.0337184668,
-0.0390452445,
-0.0259395614,
-0.0624398626,
0.0670676976,
-0.0001054306,
0.0154529111,
-0.0120674009,
0.0007441893,
-0.0461100824,
-0.0016839219,
0.0020750742,
-0.0135038625,
0.0694082826,
-0.0513454527,
0.0492580608,
-0.0140541447,
-0.0673676655,
-0.0024454903,
-0.0161479563,
-0.0251063202,
0.0159061756,
0.0127571756,
-0.0351335742,
-0.0314822905,
0.0364558809,
-0.0017481793,
0.0428086668,
0.0093155084,
0.0048930747,
-0.0057491823,
0.0611277334,
0.0728375316,
-0.0129745118,
0.0119844917,
-0.0199979264,
0.0581669062,
0.0420920625,
0.0365899503,
0.0262079109,
-0.0152076297,
-0.0327508114,
0.0242679305,
-0.0324094668,
-0.0227124225,
0.0117622335,
0.0158985835,
-0.0593960993,
-0.0313762091,
0.122652635,
0.0226186179,
-0.0690449104,
0.0130645558,
0.0345728286,
0.0524448156,
-0.0032174459,
0.023113234,
-0.0929062739,
-0.0341026485,
0.0119685903,
0.0088846106,
0.0117400307,
-0.0283097979,
-0.0450707562,
-0.0983127281,
0.0503493845,
0.011885819,
-0.0368301086,
-0.0039847642,
-0.00496687,
0.0044406219,
-0.0505537055,
0.011459047,
-0.0002836705,
-0.0255693235,
-0.0043007471,
-0.0241697151,
-0.0254687089,
-0.0613824166,
0.0410753228,
0.0124066407,
0.0344018452,
0.0437485985,
0.0564531945,
-0.0037897858,
-0.0044302111,
0.0403182246,
-0.0179145895,
-0.0244167242,
-0.0317207985,
0.0195033178,
0.0011206092,
0.021550471,
0.0280064438,
0.0442523807,
-0.0430429466,
-0.0125276158,
0.0352032185,
0.0757557303,
-0.0316398889,
-0.0353488512,
-0.0066247769,
-0.0217074379,
-0.0115850391,
0.1014749482,
0.0292554833,
-0.0249589793,
-0.0484752245,
0.0010016826,
-0.0362553,
-0.0616655387,
-0.044074215,
-0.0346798301,
0.0120705757,
-0.0241537634,
-0.0387171805,
-0.0162380803,
0.0140973125,
0.0072433585,
-0.0228874628,
0.0288556255,
0.0087925373,
0.0150049422,
-0.0528355576,
-0.0077689523,
-0.0783855319,
0.0105754742,
-0.0487978756,
0.0410297327,
0.0341736563,
0.0021866553,
-0.0247296169,
0.02801379,
-0.1164824367,
-0.0647723377,
-0.0297499038,
0.0430176146,
0.0228155963,
0.0434330329,
-0.0223538466,
-0.0388643742,
0.0398044065,
0.0635839924,
-0.001087558,
0.0353635103,
0.0116113788,
-0.0199317988,
-0.0032776403,
0.0844092369,
-0.012475702,
0.0386200212,
0.0101233013,
0.0461157933,
-0.0250491668,
-0.0005187381,
0.0050902246,
0.0466955192,
-0.00092354,
-0.0204804726,
-0.0264576562,
-0.0122741135,
0.0193292759,
-0.0293161385,
-0.0012508576,
-0.0516737327,
0.0120754754,
0.0279165711,
-0.0040536998,
-0.0510174334,
0.0237308629,
0.0206360295,
-0.0231126305,
-0.058892034,
0.033648219,
0.0086858701,
-0.0061992696,
0.0625126436,
-0.0124646537,
0.0027505369,
0.017621642,
-0.0067471955,
0.027590448,
-0.0266800486,
0.0133767715,
0.0313313715,
0.0120159984,
-0.0258826874,
0.044867117,
-0.0511136763,
-0.0800250545,
-0.0096065402,
0.0256044399,
0.0437924564,
0.0127554052,
0.025088938,
-0.014814565,
-0.0273191836,
-0.0469117165,
0.0307544786,
0.0527765453,
-0.030398231,
0.0164705254,
0.0313475318,
-0.0263326485,
0.0197675172,
0.0983925313,
0.0106002465,
0.0391332358,
0.0373902656,
-0.0230902955,
-0.0479982756,
-0.0680347532,
-0.0452682041,
0.0121273277,
-0.0257366169,
0.0028580797,
-0.0664846599,
-0.0682164505,
-0.0033140464,
-0.0141642774,
-0.0024837146,
-0.0147283282,
0.033992365,
0.054109104,
-0.0015461644,
0.0105840685,
-0.0209986791,
-0.0012407345,
-0.0565794595,
-0.0679479837,
-0.0071022734,
-6.174908559e-33,
-0.0136655187,
-0.0224194583,
0.043691393,
0.0040215654,
-0.0301409736,
0.0284083821,
-0.0517633334,
-0.0352472737,
-0.0286365766,
-0.0000383663,
-0.0231251623,
0.0422697589,
0.0018596402,
0.0305979438,
-0.0304504409,
-0.0015208067,
0.0466750748,
-0.0070028971,
-0.020177573,
0.0570839606,
-0.011472187,
0.0153386462,
0.0254681315,
-0.0345065631,
-0.0100180637,
0.0315534063,
-0.0180489719,
0.037718609,
-0.0142528219,
0.0532398298,
-0.0445611812,
0.0563760549,
0.0296539236,
-0.0254185628,
0.0075010364,
0.0383724719,
-0.0764893591,
-0.0064683445,
0.042132467,
-0.0130957961,
-0.0032875061,
-0.0474639758,
0.0356194116,
0.0059563164,
-0.0153512526,
-0.0248770174,
0.001310096,
-0.02409699,
-0.0223357081,
-0.0239100121,
-0.0753731057,
0.0444812812,
0.0060042851,
0.009328438,
0.0397120751,
0.0238093995,
-0.0198624544,
0.0794595852,
-0.0264772605,
-0.0015094616,
0.0174357202,
0.0472961552,
0.0504830517,
-0.0215823073,
0.0102662025,
0.0255920608,
0.0045618387,
0.0177822802,
-0.0246020593,
-0.0120248217,
0.0292652603,
0.0435910486,
0.0320945494,
0.0591401532,
0.0086439615,
-0.0285486672,
-0.091996111,
-0.0076795765,
0.0293679498,
0.0335118435,
0.0120991254,
0.0251193643,
-0.0160999559,
-0.005158477,
-0.0268137753,
-0.0092318542,
-0.0214443579,
-0.0023201129,
0.0191160403,
0.0176198464,
-0.0458531715,
-0.0219373852,
0.0371533297,
-0.0835282803,
0.0037134099,
0.0496301912,
0.0061556776,
-0.0063279117,
0.0269261841,
0.0594039671,
-0.0616326258,
-0.0114750378,
-0.0145343421,
0.0005221352,
0.0223312024,
-0.0244983099,
0.0306168329,
0.0258092415,
-0.051499825,
-0.0225996003,
-0.0257494319,
0.0123888487,
-0.0225330424,
0.0465878099,
0.0082647456,
0.0399317183,
0.0315439142,
0.0408807322,
0.0494130515,
-0.0338852964,
-0.0311697163,
0.005205546,
0.0099969115,
0.0018932743,
-0.0162343793,
-0.0122672953,
0.0003260648,
0.0292460416,
0.0551517904,
-0.0516618118,
-0.0395031609,
0.009620552,
2.719e-7,
0.0481865555,
0.0235903487,
-0.0028671315,
0.0286302771,
0.0252527967,
0.026088899,
0.0106152827,
0.0087519987,
-0.0250434577,
0.0089292154,
0.0484635457,
0.0457861498,
0.0812976509,
-0.0023587027,
-0.1070120484,
0.0374327265,
-0.0564444922,
-0.0288172774,
-0.0420451276,
-0.0040248106,
-0.0167981666,
0.0998686254,
0.0174343996,
-0.029569637,
-0.0179782324,
-0.0332958065,
0.0531168804,
-0.0514441095,
-0.0058043068,
0.0394183323,
-0.0152333332,
-0.0008483758,
-0.0110097202,
-0.0282624774,
-0.0045142933,
0.0206484627,
-0.0207306203,
0.1197464764,
-0.0047936868,
0.0123190852,
-0.0032174464,
-0.0343833491,
-0.0084514748,
-0.0494405441,
0.0850957558,
-0.0284458064,
-0.0215303916,
-0.046777226,
0.006241167,
-0.0298830159,
0.0073833768,
-0.0163040105,
-0.0135726612,
0.0170533098,
0.0228193793,
-0.0244024061,
0.0014219815,
-0.0694939047,
0.0013057103,
0.0146279568,
-0.0584760122,
-0.0143431118,
-0.0392890498,
0.0148127396,
0.0168908872,
-0.0663769022,
0.014698361,
2.782937187e-34,
0.0573789366,
-0.0187669415,
-0.0072874567,
0.0443536192,
0.0365191028,
0.0109133339,
-0.0319287218,
0.0016433173,
-0.0058458168,
-0.0937884003,
-0.0190457627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12681v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12681v1 | Imitation of Life: A Search Engine for Biologically Inspired Design | 2023-12-20T00:45:27 | 2023-12-20T00:45:27 | Hen Emuna, Nadav Borenstein, Xin Qian, Hyeonsu Kang, Joel Chan, Aniket Kittur, Dafna Shahaf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Biologically Inspired Design (BID), or Biomimicry, is a problem-solving
methodology that applies analogies from nature to solve engineering challenges.
For example, Speedo engineers designed swimsuits based on shark skin. Finding
relevant biological solutions for real-world problems poses significant
challenges, both due to the limited biological knowledge engineers and
designers typically possess and to the limited BID resources. Existing BID
datasets are hand-curated and small, and scaling them up requires costly human
annotations.
In this paper, we introduce BARcode (Biological Analogy Retriever), a search
engine for automatically mining bio-inspirations from the web at scale. Using
advances in natural language understanding and data programming, BARcode
identifies potential inspirations for engineering challenges. Our experiments
demonstrate that BARcode can retrieve inspirations that are valuable to
engineers and designers tackling real-world problems, as well as recover famous
historical BID examples. We release data and code; we view BARcode as a step
towards addressing the challenges that have historically hindered the practical
application of BID to engineering innovation. | [
0.054195825,
0.0595321096,
-0.0441341288,
0.0090753715,
-0.0057689887,
-0.0218198393,
-0.0077528218,
0.0354227833,
-0.0290564559,
-0.0004774902,
-0.0239499323,
0.0582484715,
-0.0218072161,
0.0799116865,
0.0285701677,
0.0224026442,
-0.0347923264,
0.047238607,
0.0044628181,
0.0050252969,
0.0030241334,
0.0213232283,
-0.0009377188,
0.0502400249,
0.0637006536,
0.0176174864,
-0.0068990798,
0.0229694284,
0.0319309533,
-0.0653814301,
0.0129363956,
0.0062036864,
0.0283501986,
0.0162720531,
0.0000019241,
-0.0233285762,
-0.0128864413,
-0.0176637098,
0.0252800435,
0.0131833544,
0.0672320127,
0.0316767432,
-0.0054416345,
-0.0195125043,
-0.014444246,
-0.0129917981,
0.0600079596,
0.0209594946,
-0.001417096,
-0.0072269887,
-0.0198962539,
-0.0773072913,
0.0217015333,
0.0330041125,
0.0476919338,
0.0691965371,
-0.0092722969,
-0.007664036,
0.1211501658,
0.0001220511,
0.0296310354,
0.0378820598,
-0.0217317902,
0.0151653783,
0.0528218225,
0.0185708199,
0.0084969532,
-0.0340307467,
0.0112035414,
0.0662584901,
-0.0307425335,
-0.0215327926,
0.0368658043,
-0.0260492079,
-0.0154352095,
0.0445541851,
-0.0336968973,
-0.0248467419,
-0.009902712,
0.0068903216,
-0.0388637632,
-0.0164557043,
-0.0118168863,
-0.0270334296,
0.0235287454,
0.0137305809,
0.0075878701,
-0.0054258569,
-0.0374809355,
-0.0587420501,
0.0453726277,
0.0019311738,
0.0353401043,
-0.0059290226,
0.0325586349,
-0.0203865301,
0.0253209118,
0.0056298152,
0.0605888888,
-0.018853154,
0.0927215219,
0.0068779099,
-0.0077269729,
0.0352719277,
-0.0389574282,
-0.0038402141,
-0.0530760251,
0.0136832213,
-0.0367599949,
0.0111974264,
-0.1050087959,
-0.0143738165,
-0.0082909549,
0.0111953514,
-0.0180229656,
-0.0014039086,
0.0068434011,
0.001791072,
-0.0432990566,
-0.0129393553,
-0.0233277567,
0.0570542738,
0.050746087,
0.0067284545,
-0.0398640372,
-0.0733377561,
-0.001956339,
0.0433432087,
-0.0303952675,
-0.0346166939,
0.0237315949,
-0.0180079527,
0.0250453111,
-0.01464424,
0.0112708928,
0.0967850834,
0.003689728,
-0.0005963595,
-0.0344527364,
-0.0545445308,
0.0664904267,
0.0527354926,
0.0260454714,
-0.0440875776,
0.0234489068,
-0.0302025359,
-0.0010388538,
-0.0186746754,
0.0143205225,
0.0061241542,
-0.0272792224,
0.07884904,
-0.0523232482,
0.0363909043,
-0.0332703702,
-0.0065825046,
0.0035476254,
-0.0080278888,
0.0128942402,
0.0055193799,
0.021795718,
-0.0176994205,
-0.0079286722,
-0.0104621043,
-0.0224114861,
-0.0368507914,
0.047443185,
0.0105085475,
0.0321398936,
0.0605521686,
0.0004229753,
-0.0394651592,
-0.0129523845,
0.0282651354,
0.0366493762,
0.067274116,
0.0228615589,
0.0825442895,
0.0056661316,
0.0328743197,
-0.0166479219,
-0.0811632648,
0.0142169623,
0.0285772812,
-0.015041898,
-0.0000995578,
-0.018158542,
0.0482956544,
-0.0210095402,
-0.0024763583,
0.0193132274,
0.0283881947,
-0.0087206801,
-0.0091057364,
-0.0030417982,
0.0288776532,
0.0095642041,
-0.0587485135,
-0.012032195,
-0.0424309373,
-0.0158598516,
-0.0013796675,
0.0038269823,
0.0912891626,
0.0379819572,
-0.047174152,
0.0224072002,
0.036765568,
-0.0231277011,
0.0092394743,
0.0091207381,
-0.0321766101,
-0.0399192125,
0.0102492105,
-0.0262303464,
-0.0179115143,
-0.0122054527,
-0.0062587373,
-0.0301443338,
0.0373116881,
-0.0091158152,
0.0226573423,
-0.0664150342,
0.0311214887,
-0.0516398586,
0.0232431497,
0.0300960075,
-0.0151360091,
-0.0028467253,
0.0212512389,
0.0051442422,
0.0246634986,
0.0599860847,
-0.0960681885,
-0.0717400685,
0.0532001257,
0.0451703742,
0.0526854135,
0.0168842804,
-0.1268466264,
0.0136558348,
0.0423791632,
0.0068087457,
-0.009626653,
0.0158092808,
-0.0284406152,
0.0790803283,
0.0330885984,
0.0146385897,
-0.0222223513,
-0.0225715395,
-0.0173958857,
0.0234725345,
0.0566562004,
0.0063614757,
-0.0233917255,
-0.0352062322,
0.0067623793,
-0.032665953,
0.0238551125,
0.0100913784,
0.0013349286,
0.020036364,
0.0329625569,
0.0027715971,
-0.0546807013,
0.049457211,
-0.0223746542,
-0.0143591594,
0.0582494549,
0.002870101,
-0.0011573213,
-0.0396579728,
0.0110295452,
-0.0176555347,
-0.0097820796,
0.0120391808,
-0.0477471687,
-0.0221455861,
0.060984455,
0.0067637726,
-0.0524842069,
-0.0485796556,
-0.0176914316,
-0.0478465259,
0.0715052858,
0.0877395645,
0.0267060678,
-0.057365533,
0.0363835841,
-0.0215376541,
-0.0195713583,
0.0229018573,
-0.0186462179,
0.014809466,
-0.0122927641,
0.0005853801,
0.0177810676,
0.0457243323,
-0.0385351256,
0.0009898295,
0.0046391618,
-0.0560457967,
-0.0118054673,
-0.019821845,
0.0541657731,
0.0406057239,
-0.0328638554,
0.0516781993,
-0.0185387954,
-0.0453110486,
-0.004121324,
0.0107760616,
0.0908188969,
0.0688150227,
-0.0032779258,
-0.0228504259,
0.0178923812,
0.0338008404,
0.1028022543,
-0.0138592841,
0.0084023569,
0.0550106466,
0.0461375639,
0.0372265168,
0.0204401389,
0.0110112149,
-0.0021012432,
0.0607592203,
-0.0009977298,
0.0201020576,
0.0563564561,
0.0287521128,
0.0424293838,
0.0395433158,
0.0302747581,
-0.0444862992,
-0.0123620545,
-0.0276843887,
-0.0087213796,
0.0079467306,
-0.1166039482,
-0.0550952926,
0.026507115,
-0.0468026251,
0.0116014183,
0.0256217029,
-0.047958117,
-0.0552530363,
-0.0035784219,
0.0266337525,
-0.0053871796,
0.0198099706,
-0.0125479279,
0.0021844716,
0.0257205479,
0.0299029108,
-0.0019732015,
0.0239024721,
0.0626550019,
-0.0078517776,
0.0155334659,
-0.0287389904,
-0.025092667,
-0.0565958209,
0.0527687483,
-0.0040567606,
-0.0196289327,
0.008489415,
-0.0114319986,
-0.0035559011,
-0.008864766,
-0.024340611,
0.0052269818,
0.0489943065,
-0.0168648958,
0.0307406168,
-0.0122732334,
-0.0165629126,
0.0390858278,
0.0125167388,
-0.0567477755,
-0.0206618849,
-0.0513174869,
0.0191626269,
-0.0347516462,
-0.0356255695,
0.0085663944,
-0.0890641212,
0.0318339393,
-0.003096652,
-0.0496919341,
-0.0551340245,
-0.0603566393,
-0.008547633,
-0.0372254066,
-0.091071941,
0.0284798127,
-0.0290930942,
0.0179890562,
-0.0113993809,
-0.0253061615,
-0.0387947299,
0.0524033718,
0.0172560941,
-0.014052392,
0.0555182882,
0.0707162544,
0.0202019587,
-0.0609196723,
0.0281157214,
-0.0310681071,
0.0056315237,
-0.0282712672,
0.0021812897,
0.0370223448,
-0.0094858687,
-0.0204814225,
0.0270130634,
-0.0863394886,
0.0113909105,
0.055107791,
0.062823154,
0.0118975602,
0.0299899746,
-0.1040018201,
-0.0893763974,
-0.0257083755,
0.0122983232,
0.0476380028,
-0.0521396212,
-0.0402561352,
-0.0390162617,
-0.0070081409,
-0.0567119159,
-0.0821878761,
-0.0275212135,
-0.0634196252,
0.0012916008,
-0.0541917309,
0.0409411415,
0.0015149978,
0.0103541575,
0.0298457295,
-0.0744007751,
0.0206358302,
-0.0006512361,
-0.0861753076,
-0.0152344238,
-0.0217582583,
0.0096247522,
0.013117251,
-0.0320244767,
0.0696122944,
-0.0624577366,
-0.0221141744,
0.0281590652,
0.0110684941,
-0.0326607414,
-0.036943309,
0.0432671271,
0.0221970305,
-0.0425624289,
0.0107323257,
-0.0266546365,
0.0164388157,
0.0785319656,
0.0104882978,
-0.0565850735,
-0.0197787452,
0.0191485416,
0.0062888847,
-0.0146349976,
-0.0163525473,
0.0253413413,
-0.011525915,
0.022379823,
0.0157464501,
0.0175201166,
0.0678623542,
0.0520355925,
0.0146489525,
0.0116197122,
-0.0139417946,
-0.0046943673,
0.0106183458,
0.058828868,
-0.0231718142,
-0.0363639891,
0.0021350188,
-0.0287100505,
0.0107208882,
0.0012432581,
-0.0144993616,
0.000572788,
0.0739813223,
-0.0499184653,
0.0542939119,
0.0556578115,
0.0775700733,
-0.0298579782,
-0.0407865308,
0.0084984004,
0.0502951369,
-0.0484587103,
0.0683665574,
-0.0190774277,
-0.0360919647,
0.0224566665,
0.0121301822,
-0.0080530774,
0.0736910775,
-0.0406256504,
-0.0583116598,
-0.039961379,
-0.0098792259,
0.0083501395,
0.0066683465,
-0.0172920711,
0.0069653979,
-0.0142278653,
-0.0016568748,
0.0319995359,
-0.0548388287,
-0.0208523106,
0.0052900338,
0.0510183759,
-0.0076996256,
-0.0718731284,
0.0393590741,
-0.0183699038,
0.0146269687,
-0.0249841027,
-0.0174561162,
-0.0046899458,
0.0162741169,
0.0510424376,
0.0162489526,
0.0029499934,
-0.0682911798,
-0.0458210222,
-0.0028863961,
0.044102557,
0.0364920013,
0.016871402,
0.0613392405,
0.0453963652,
0.0249124877,
-0.0058751577,
-0.0537386388,
0.0296360943,
0.0055779,
-0.0743684471,
-0.013139206,
-0.0424729809,
-5.829222854e-33,
0.0208320301,
-0.0379321761,
0.0016230209,
0.0277001411,
-0.0153936138,
-0.0125594167,
-0.0444969609,
-0.0173155926,
-0.0125018191,
0.0087031228,
-0.0178678278,
-0.0531484596,
-0.0283010677,
-0.0329082422,
0.0801661983,
-0.0194560681,
0.029996153,
0.0252790935,
-0.0396561101,
0.019967027,
0.007881443,
-0.0002938815,
-0.0196880791,
-0.0493157953,
-0.0327086933,
0.0033753121,
0.0149140013,
-0.0267260149,
0.0067022345,
0.0389472842,
-0.0176252145,
0.03065053,
-0.0083582923,
0.0002159269,
-0.0204326417,
-0.0512417741,
-0.0601182729,
0.0011163506,
-0.0223036204,
-0.03401177,
0.0277173501,
-0.01558269,
0.0602555871,
-0.0020097117,
-0.0385801494,
0.0198660344,
0.0628691092,
-0.0639240295,
0.0113701597,
-0.0181279182,
-0.0582642481,
-0.0133491317,
-0.0120310159,
0.0069910465,
0.0561764687,
0.0134161301,
0.0040571284,
0.0593335293,
0.0016749512,
0.092609562,
-0.0179347005,
-0.0281159598,
0.0192283746,
0.0040173433,
0.0432062224,
0.0455129407,
0.03968326,
0.0062594055,
0.0109656481,
0.0067450372,
0.0090895537,
0.0763617903,
0.0401507616,
0.0221146327,
0.0643794164,
0.0008826528,
-0.0039492757,
0.0244402867,
-0.0210690387,
-0.0116092591,
0.0013405343,
0.0471175537,
0.0387541018,
-0.0066060335,
0.0418250784,
-0.0299643464,
-0.0336198173,
0.0138237569,
-0.0161456577,
-0.0039007806,
-0.0252573062,
0.0380834155,
-0.0256299581,
-0.0300094392,
0.0168252904,
-0.0340061747,
-0.0031185856,
-0.0131433681,
-0.0194033757,
-0.05485994,
-0.0445553288,
-0.0303121842,
-0.0384365916,
0.0411237329,
0.0230429806,
-0.0381957516,
-0.0144494316,
-0.0048639807,
-0.0206027143,
-0.0143647529,
-0.0222528111,
-0.0513647757,
-0.0156190768,
-0.0838404596,
0.0010447296,
0.0066575739,
0.0050516529,
-0.0368952677,
0.0171232373,
0.0165814068,
-0.056490086,
0.0231820364,
-0.0578415059,
0.0037115836,
-0.0297487136,
-0.0392614715,
-0.0397369303,
0.034222465,
-0.0359850787,
-0.074310869,
-0.031808503,
0.0296218731,
2.719e-7,
-0.0102145029,
0.0090860827,
0.0092941262,
0.0064449711,
-0.0055878162,
0.0226290617,
-0.0032339876,
-0.0007676813,
-0.0259980038,
-0.0443929546,
0.0134235527,
0.0217361674,
-0.0082543893,
-0.0218094382,
-0.0667429641,
-0.0207924712,
-0.0253931377,
-0.0336191356,
-0.0462690182,
-0.0001417218,
0.0382540785,
0.001049476,
0.022628732,
-0.017254103,
0.0039570383,
-0.0020283449,
-0.0128954686,
-0.0457352959,
0.0799317658,
-0.0116527621,
-0.0370418318,
0.0214950852,
-0.0325983576,
-0.0107319411,
0.0072789839,
-0.0199302267,
0.0302882679,
-0.0452787355,
0.0308667403,
0.041530434,
0.029264383,
0.0133335246,
-0.0110996291,
-0.0212212354,
-0.0225437712,
-0.0286543947,
0.0180249233,
-0.0319931693,
-0.0231418405,
0.02576207,
-0.0221035369,
-0.0018309178,
0.0127214184,
-0.0140009196,
-0.0276772492,
-0.0087911133,
-0.0027758242,
-0.044466462,
0.0175851062,
0.0041644257,
-0.0473969728,
0.0018979462,
-0.0389973707,
0.0446390398,
0.0343202613,
-0.0201540031,
0.0080608213,
1.94031873e-34,
0.0191412158,
0.0069818646,
-0.0073897182,
0.0766063631,
0.0239103045,
0.0281817373,
-0.0015292583,
-0.0104691014,
0.0014050022,
-0.0244859774,
-0.0252179634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12660v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12660v1 | Is post-editing really faster than human translation? | 2023-12-19T23:21:19 | 2023-12-19T23:21:19 | Silvia Terribile | cs.CL | cs.CL | Time efficiency is paramount for the localisation industry, which demands
ever-faster turnaround times. However, translation speed is largely
underresearched, and there is a lack of clarity about how language service
providers (LSPs) can evaluate the performance of their post-editing (PE) and
human translation (HT) services. This study constitutes the first large-scale
investigation of translation and revision speed in HT and in the PE of neural
machine translation, based on real-world data from an LSP. It uses an
exploratory data analysis approach to investigate data for 90 million words
translated by 879 linguists across 11 language pairs, over 2.5 years. The
results of this research indicate that (a) PE is usually but not always faster
than HT; (b) average speed values may be misleading; (c) translation speed is
highly variable; and (d) edit distance cannot be used as a proxy for
post-editing productivity, because it does not correlate strongly with speed. | [
0.0720167756,
0.0039352463,
-0.038582731,
0.0078861797,
-0.0367789865,
-0.009396906,
0.0289221331,
-0.0211439002,
-0.0471405312,
-0.0220676996,
-0.0317231938,
-0.0499533191,
0.0568431728,
-0.0107921101,
0.0164556652,
-0.010374899,
0.0455378704,
0.0351006463,
0.0139616439,
-0.0013401259,
-0.0124070831,
0.0052119354,
0.0295673311,
0.0475284085,
-0.0041271616,
-0.003604217,
-0.00805353,
0.0106871529,
0.0224174466,
0.0153710973,
0.0022902412,
0.0337426364,
-0.0226832386,
0.1264237016,
0.0000020725,
-0.0411965139,
0.0015049406,
0.0284918323,
-0.0292371511,
0.0739981905,
0.0455513895,
-0.0462766141,
-0.0604068972,
0.0272564348,
-0.0261737816,
-0.0049109766,
0.045500543,
-0.0272035208,
0.0330393352,
0.0927474424,
-0.0296727046,
-0.0346326903,
-0.0075097717,
-0.0391541757,
-0.0177885499,
-0.0412412882,
-0.0309911054,
-0.029192375,
-0.0646692067,
0.0062025199,
-0.0016121916,
0.0718135834,
0.0344085954,
-0.0467703976,
-0.0572289452,
-0.0065645082,
-0.0345660076,
-0.017807344,
-0.0014358592,
0.0365329087,
-0.010026467,
0.0334672518,
-0.0428910367,
0.0082369354,
0.000868203,
-0.0142768221,
-0.0052380916,
0.0198882241,
0.008350255,
-0.0248173773,
-0.0093560191,
-0.0111718383,
0.0196646843,
-0.0312139615,
0.0109066172,
0.0182872843,
0.0254268032,
-0.0395598672,
-0.0083309859,
0.0192930121,
0.0284865238,
-0.0438014306,
0.0485476106,
0.0004999306,
-0.0105964104,
0.0005593192,
-0.0051528648,
-0.0496605746,
0.0091511859,
-0.1032734141,
0.0147725893,
0.0478253067,
-0.02525088,
0.0351386741,
-0.0340626128,
0.0424360372,
-0.0107993912,
-0.0108371256,
-0.037470296,
0.0149644492,
-0.0321131684,
0.0044809799,
-0.0372422114,
-0.0056231725,
-0.053915821,
0.013284185,
-0.0490860678,
0.006762329,
0.0241350159,
0.0273126476,
0.0177180469,
0.0022433137,
-0.0464506187,
0.0017723978,
-0.0337338932,
0.0400701277,
-0.0110363793,
-0.0119609842,
-0.0458826572,
-0.0143944221,
0.0299393758,
-0.01544593,
-0.0090115331,
-0.0356095545,
-0.0035055056,
0.0416409448,
-0.0298313014,
0.0088311657,
-0.0106581636,
-0.0288658421,
0.0142902089,
-0.0546114556,
-0.038000524,
-0.0517778583,
0.0627644137,
0.0324469842,
-0.0416703261,
-0.0614327788,
-0.0340588279,
0.0023227793,
-0.0215558223,
0.0302137453,
-0.0494852029,
0.0425496735,
0.060718786,
-0.0075400495,
0.009700303,
0.0224019904,
0.054069858,
0.010741163,
0.0665978789,
-0.0177749433,
-0.0107221557,
0.1014953256,
-0.0263053775,
0.0211883523,
-0.0223871283,
0.0040772073,
0.0222188272,
0.0511062928,
0.0547351725,
0.0234608185,
-0.0070374408,
0.0093467394,
0.0703630149,
0.0416523144,
0.0100644203,
0.0329272188,
0.0492638201,
0.0013846854,
-0.0011971777,
-0.0474917442,
-0.016405249,
0.0097828601,
0.0186263751,
0.0046040486,
0.0138155483,
0.018065799,
-0.012090777,
-0.0244229212,
-0.0083408915,
0.0164358094,
0.0419956036,
-0.017168548,
0.0147320982,
-0.0389962792,
-0.0505914539,
0.0447136462,
-0.0372058898,
-0.0378798954,
0.0008469123,
-0.016582666,
-0.0765618905,
0.0947446376,
0.0438984483,
0.0362977199,
-0.014747126,
-0.0265941713,
0.0003377685,
0.0769537464,
0.0728638917,
-0.0057227272,
0.0117808925,
-0.0046282513,
-0.0146814305,
-0.0284026694,
-0.0033009977,
0.0341075063,
0.0417483896,
0.0527493246,
0.0289352499,
-0.0016352591,
-0.087200284,
0.0075077037,
-0.0028399655,
-0.0008285003,
-0.0123395743,
0.0239272378,
-0.0212278757,
0.0293995906,
-0.0387365445,
-0.0248204488,
-0.0090586329,
-0.0146605503,
0.018925054,
0.0621310957,
0.0487436838,
0.010586462,
0.038062159,
-0.0114199743,
-0.0334871598,
0.0100969309,
-0.0298898704,
-0.0245713647,
-0.0144254128,
-0.0229388271,
0.0031852091,
-0.0043264171,
0.0481332839,
-0.0328751765,
-0.0161996465,
-0.0320984535,
-0.0090563986,
0.0006824525,
0.0406436846,
-0.0009724844,
0.005760273,
0.0585941263,
-0.0236893166,
-0.0438460447,
0.0444907844,
0.0025564558,
-0.0078117247,
0.0296121575,
0.0141721535,
-0.0174117237,
0.0076023615,
-0.0832714811,
-0.0303788669,
-0.0170768239,
0.012035517,
0.0545783751,
0.0041817571,
-0.0047613839,
-0.0088756206,
-0.0055236672,
0.0205203313,
-0.0050981618,
0.0424947478,
0.0260681324,
0.0079389038,
-0.0038163634,
-0.0500265248,
0.0059883799,
0.0346749239,
-0.0216747019,
0.0595309362,
-0.0611478686,
-0.066473037,
0.0165743064,
-0.0450398363,
-0.0011701963,
0.0231503285,
-0.1152281314,
-0.018637117,
0.0065886006,
0.0367670655,
0.0074355542,
-0.023908725,
-0.0435486808,
0.0250304863,
0.000153913,
-0.0385236256,
-0.0114432285,
-0.010443137,
-0.0132159898,
-0.0371574648,
-0.0534781553,
0.0260064434,
0.0406972617,
0.0115504302,
-0.0146887777,
-0.0320418328,
-0.0074775144,
-0.0446285866,
-0.0225118529,
-0.042011831,
0.0226217452,
-0.0313452072,
0.1025721133,
-0.0213113613,
-0.0465959162,
0.0225856155,
0.0132248783,
0.0093301078,
-0.0255461652,
-0.0137955239,
0.0012412173,
0.0468532592,
-0.0218947921,
0.0251967162,
-0.0787263587,
-0.0353045762,
-0.0491960198,
0.0463109612,
0.0184695031,
-0.0090952665,
0.0223441012,
-0.0435063653,
-0.0119669633,
-0.0381369404,
0.008586715,
0.0142006055,
-0.0093562789,
-0.0126231425,
-0.0070323325,
0.0561005734,
-0.058555983,
-0.0117603866,
0.0001266726,
0.0192836374,
0.1145389378,
-0.0130454218,
-0.0016055924,
0.0027755648,
-0.0211350992,
-0.0189223103,
0.0111033497,
0.0054437257,
-0.0387708768,
0.0295642987,
0.0079280101,
0.0060598366,
-0.0064086085,
-0.0176346637,
-0.0452715307,
0.007054498,
-0.0423936881,
-0.0424601324,
0.0118944319,
0.0305828452,
-0.0353169367,
-0.0042172452,
0.1015924215,
0.0362208001,
-0.0517056659,
-0.0031180147,
-0.0488379225,
-0.0506576933,
0.0544625036,
0.0398285985,
-0.0262658093,
0.0256595053,
0.0185385179,
0.0115815187,
0.0020654416,
-0.016206624,
-0.0407918431,
-0.0748813972,
0.0437671766,
-0.0213650577,
-0.0807021186,
0.0034469299,
0.0125748189,
-0.0393826514,
0.0066944435,
0.0029223438,
-0.0062170103,
0.0429350771,
0.0110663399,
-0.0123016005,
-0.0293141212,
-0.020528432,
0.0131896716,
-0.0516325347,
0.0018668094,
0.0497144535,
0.048625052,
-0.0291390363,
-0.0261636451,
0.0435693227,
0.086498715,
-0.00060314,
-0.0100862915,
0.0500628874,
0.0374197848,
0.0035399268,
0.0323917121,
-0.04481126,
-0.0061374125,
0.0425709672,
0.047175061,
0.0453000516,
-0.0165750794,
0.0487843752,
0.034946356,
-0.0027313947,
-0.00907363,
0.0352478735,
0.0079105515,
-0.0715785027,
0.0183537602,
0.0021749109,
-0.005488358,
-0.0445507057,
-0.0280872416,
-0.002546808,
-0.0829473957,
-0.0015816387,
-0.1027485952,
-0.076358512,
0.0122032221,
0.0260575954,
0.0800932869,
0.0228338744,
0.0119916983,
-0.0174782593,
-0.0271618348,
0.0010007805,
0.0304838717,
0.0215925314,
-0.0622148179,
0.0155007886,
-0.0123386914,
0.0028523586,
-0.0200382099,
-0.03299224,
-0.0436036997,
-0.0405231863,
0.0316505581,
0.0225560293,
0.023401238,
0.0032591538,
0.0070976252,
-0.0712984279,
-0.0436326601,
0.024114361,
-0.0412653349,
0.0159165319,
-0.008242677,
0.0278639235,
-0.0321715623,
0.016597677,
-0.0120595209,
-0.012169092,
0.0132845156,
-0.000787808,
0.0206170268,
-0.071078077,
-0.0223578848,
0.045266632,
0.0332519412,
-0.0229399018,
-0.003073826,
-0.0482969768,
0.0076557091,
-0.0403489023,
0.0128438361,
-0.0265800338,
-0.0635958612,
0.0344860442,
0.0095263161,
-0.0175347142,
0.0582066476,
-0.0227461159,
-0.0550520159,
-0.028981626,
-0.0268552732,
-0.0442781225,
0.0467766859,
0.0185081977,
0.056648992,
0.011520084,
0.0265025236,
-0.0007200136,
0.0074430141,
-0.0283380598,
0.046276655,
-0.0044206595,
0.0379397422,
-0.0095475679,
0.0340828039,
-0.0290743876,
-0.0708239004,
0.0033465684,
-0.0060911975,
0.0701044723,
-0.0139294676,
0.0752211958,
-0.0099196155,
-0.0245044008,
-0.015715519,
0.0439105853,
0.0254726205,
-0.0055293906,
-0.0104042254,
-0.0342404284,
-0.0059713684,
0.049069684,
0.0478912704,
-0.047412917,
0.0337967984,
-0.0284979101,
-0.0275213271,
-0.0022222165,
-0.0143185174,
-0.0381449014,
-0.031115124,
-0.0291837957,
-0.0472919643,
-0.0518049635,
-0.036871966,
-0.0156521108,
0.023833666,
0.0033682892,
-0.0165677015,
0.0043949727,
0.066068083,
-0.0126227802,
-0.0003200406,
-0.0621200167,
0.0142520424,
-0.0234857872,
-0.0206432939,
-0.0300375726,
-5.751703409e-33,
0.0221817698,
-0.0308091529,
0.0517442748,
0.0238661189,
-0.0466601178,
0.025109943,
-0.0348399952,
-0.0079587884,
0.024337979,
-0.0010758992,
-0.0509793051,
0.0211312138,
0.0222927444,
-0.0228362586,
0.0580034368,
0.0509324707,
0.0542989336,
-0.0260443781,
-0.0209310018,
-0.0307147503,
0.0224374384,
0.011670392,
0.0920095518,
-0.0223036483,
0.0815380737,
0.0172524676,
0.0076635145,
0.0161269903,
0.0326546021,
0.0018540242,
0.028323032,
0.0005498219,
0.0078898389,
-0.0550116859,
-0.0100557664,
-0.0472901762,
-0.0206155423,
0.011268531,
0.0058082151,
0.070977889,
-0.0071833474,
-0.0220293291,
0.0513085462,
-0.0359520577,
-0.0587880053,
0.0198302306,
0.0026832449,
-0.011923085,
-0.0079077845,
0.0031015116,
-0.0908442438,
0.01015581,
-0.0134330317,
0.0123297321,
0.0359990522,
0.0406648479,
-0.0301520061,
-0.0477627665,
-0.1775466949,
-0.0332218409,
0.0088199917,
0.0345624164,
0.0379909128,
-0.0237177853,
-0.0195533633,
-0.0132217035,
0.071950309,
0.0373440199,
0.0461539403,
0.0533460416,
0.0664876699,
-0.0299272537,
0.067856431,
0.029894352,
0.053579852,
-0.0500377826,
-0.0482643545,
0.0466015898,
-0.0210581589,
0.014380211,
-0.0074976194,
-0.0138363447,
0.0126461349,
-0.0133559611,
-0.0430626199,
0.0004533821,
-0.0018816738,
-0.0522607751,
0.00366267,
-0.006523299,
0.0409137197,
-0.0402585827,
0.0676325113,
-0.0254749302,
0.0565545708,
-0.0105397766,
-0.0541941039,
0.0513435416,
0.0259698573,
-0.0008933211,
-0.0308997557,
0.0434545055,
-0.0400307439,
0.074395135,
0.0274988785,
-0.0304930471,
0.037098635,
0.0194075201,
-0.0298456624,
0.0332316905,
-0.0097320108,
0.0316258259,
-0.008516036,
-0.000368647,
0.0006069269,
-0.0416867174,
-0.0069421637,
0.0018529036,
0.0569120683,
0.010268392,
-0.0140440771,
0.0092351194,
0.0674851909,
0.0072791218,
-0.0499437153,
0.0455586128,
-0.0354999416,
0.0472913608,
0.0356480032,
-0.0231501125,
-0.0277512018,
-0.0209774151,
2.723e-7,
0.062428534,
0.0665946826,
0.009904258,
0.0364074297,
0.0349591672,
-0.0103206541,
-0.0138119599,
-0.0059724511,
0.0019097095,
0.0881921127,
0.0219419822,
-0.0091053443,
0.0499391034,
0.0470060892,
-0.0368807055,
-0.0312337931,
-0.0644786358,
0.0405704863,
-0.0564558543,
0.0121946298,
-0.0235770103,
-0.0015253756,
-0.0037219319,
-0.0251943152,
-0.0243164096,
0.0100053027,
0.0590976477,
-0.0170126576,
-0.0040116771,
-0.0023850806,
0.0435004197,
0.0833213776,
-0.0005397797,
-0.0185010508,
-0.042402532,
0.0036767721,
0.0137740867,
0.0430420451,
-0.0249128304,
0.0324936062,
0.0197655968,
-0.0432192795,
-0.023998484,
-0.044009883,
0.0401389524,
-0.0448986143,
-0.0344986618,
0.0224797055,
0.0243232735,
0.0125551065,
0.0452278405,
-0.04972798,
0.0156702697,
0.0337751508,
0.0271845236,
-0.0365079381,
-0.0143337809,
-0.0241283923,
-0.0195206385,
0.0310043115,
0.0307652112,
-0.0183885749,
-0.032405965,
-0.0017400968,
-0.0094498759,
0.0218024217,
0.0252839774,
1.704333073e-34,
0.0214943364,
-0.0057493318,
0.0536258407,
-0.0051376126,
0.0309928134,
-0.0075778035,
-0.0126628978,
-0.0354571044,
-0.035676647,
-0.0052611744,
-0.0546475835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12655v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12655v2 | Can Transformers Learn Sequential Function Classes In Context? | 2023-12-19T22:57:13 | 2023-12-21T04:29:24 | Ryan Campbell, Emma Guo, Evan Hu, Reya Vir, Ethan Hsiao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In-context learning (ICL) has revolutionized the capabilities of transformer
models in NLP. In our project, we extend the understanding of the mechanisms
underpinning ICL by exploring whether transformers can learn from sequential,
non-textual function class data distributions. We introduce a novel sliding
window sequential function class and employ toy-sized transformers with a GPT-2
architecture to conduct our experiments. Our analysis indicates that these
models can indeed leverage ICL when trained on non-textual sequential function
classes. Additionally, our experiments with randomized y-label sequences
highlights that transformers retain some ICL capabilities even when the label
associations are obfuscated. We provide evidence that transformers can reason
with and understand sequentiality encoded within function classes, as reflected
by the effective learning of our proposed tasks. Our results also show that the
performance deteriorated with increasing randomness in the labels, though not
to the extent one might expect, implying a potential robustness of learned
sequentiality against label noise. Future research may want to look into how
previous explanations of transformers, such as induction heads and task
vectors, relate to sequentiality in ICL in these toy examples. Our
investigation lays the groundwork for further research into how transformers
process and perceive sequential data. | [
0.0129610989,
0.084122777,
-0.0182623733,
0.0233080182,
-0.0020042709,
0.0202185363,
0.0106669161,
-0.0166383423,
-0.0330129452,
-0.0570393503,
-0.0218015667,
-0.0349208191,
0.0099061504,
-0.0002894756,
-0.0007674778,
-0.0746682659,
0.0452814959,
-0.0112930117,
-0.015972618,
0.0271566007,
-0.0341367275,
-0.0308101494,
-0.0460862219,
0.0638651401,
-0.0007211324,
-0.0586155467,
-0.018930044,
-0.0445211418,
0.0089929774,
-0.0379868932,
0.0366780721,
0.0753130764,
0.0174799487,
0.0373570882,
0.0000016716,
-0.0224329308,
-0.0227661226,
-0.0017279247,
-0.0204200968,
-0.0296457279,
-0.0156072853,
-0.0278690364,
-0.0350419618,
-0.0081895813,
-0.0625357702,
-0.0396798737,
0.0676471889,
0.0582026765,
0.0574171953,
0.0595708564,
-0.0147797205,
-0.0526393093,
0.0132221598,
-0.0454227403,
0.0268329848,
-0.0430003889,
-0.006311052,
-0.0695863366,
-0.0131453946,
0.0185803697,
-0.0303057916,
0.0109334225,
0.0428318605,
0.0318054371,
-0.0330460034,
0.0520492233,
0.002544313,
-0.0477790907,
-0.027341621,
0.0229661092,
-0.0349291563,
-0.0245967936,
-0.005342138,
0.0259083435,
0.0202117339,
-0.0157612134,
-0.0515681617,
0.0441096872,
-0.0080320705,
0.01004327,
0.0302425493,
0.0476930365,
-0.0053983014,
-0.0278283786,
-0.0173184983,
0.0692334697,
-0.0039668246,
-0.0281662438,
0.0087265475,
-0.0092518991,
-0.0278628431,
-0.0379841663,
-0.0130264033,
0.0445589572,
-0.0195020176,
0.0417246893,
-0.0203951001,
-0.0247545484,
0.0204674266,
-0.0197967626,
-0.0409713201,
0.0296620224,
-0.0164423846,
0.0067352592,
0.0011046169,
0.0640972406,
-0.0295787007,
0.0511294492,
-0.0032883631,
0.0378540158,
-0.058517687,
-0.0273404084,
-0.0428151302,
0.0270681903,
-0.0029844735,
0.0186841674,
-0.0326786414,
0.0560699403,
0.005241985,
0.0163626764,
0.0038758039,
-0.0010234948,
-0.0695876628,
0.017022742,
-0.0469538085,
0.0324363261,
-0.0078678178,
-0.0020021463,
-0.011387025,
-0.010311014,
-0.0343872495,
-0.0260024536,
-0.0047575403,
-0.0336933099,
-0.0235252772,
0.1107414812,
-0.0345197953,
-0.0465987287,
-0.0376648381,
-0.0195303857,
0.0202453267,
-0.0376611128,
0.0234729797,
-0.037704099,
-0.035235703,
0.0519927479,
0.0181379505,
-0.0019578568,
0.0174429864,
0.0489774831,
-0.0169679187,
0.0912951306,
0.0104157608,
-0.0289593562,
-0.0281689111,
0.0275776312,
0.006986965,
0.04892442,
-0.016362818,
-0.0301415026,
0.0206882209,
-0.0242136475,
0.0128416102,
-0.0038347838,
0.0029090196,
-0.011695764,
0.0037156225,
-0.0129959201,
0.0223707967,
-0.0092811882,
0.0161214396,
0.0223868694,
-0.0307707191,
-0.0390725248,
0.023664318,
0.0148292948,
0.0212336965,
0.0274400897,
0.0334707573,
0.006376652,
-0.0028318574,
0.0731364116,
-0.0865239426,
0.0065297098,
-0.0022043164,
0.0013272237,
-0.0452858098,
0.0034464183,
-0.0208887886,
-0.0577487461,
-0.0041444846,
-0.0167799182,
0.0026836067,
-0.0404033177,
0.0235975906,
0.0901132897,
-0.0455862358,
0.072323896,
-0.0048019951,
-0.0263170339,
-0.0400677174,
-0.0403836407,
-0.0199192464,
0.025668459,
0.0290302485,
-0.0603684857,
-0.0446828492,
-0.0168918185,
-0.0077976719,
0.0105428835,
0.0075101922,
-0.034025982,
0.0123926299,
-0.0152359325,
-0.0234909039,
0.0120725874,
0.0190702062,
-0.0049130023,
-0.0057851751,
-0.0326147079,
0.0033216574,
-0.0230308846,
0.0118541401,
0.0509294756,
-0.0123775098,
-0.0592841767,
0.0016596727,
0.0253975857,
0.0279930569,
-0.0359209292,
0.0033355898,
0.0113238227,
0.0476109535,
-0.0126875155,
0.0086165713,
0.0438223965,
-0.0784796327,
-0.0388197117,
0.0028808597,
-0.0035125089,
-0.019428812,
0.0482122749,
-0.0450959392,
-0.0301126074,
-0.0080641629,
-0.030330861,
0.067350097,
-0.0182666387,
0.021106204,
0.0346501805,
0.0154934507,
-0.0572834723,
0.0801824629,
-0.0107228542,
0.0455582961,
0.0133263189,
0.0163867902,
0.0118467053,
-0.0025612577,
-0.0046901591,
0.0408672988,
-0.0441440605,
-0.0076483577,
0.0161025804,
-0.0220171865,
-0.0466282703,
-0.0242431499,
-0.0342625268,
0.0096206088,
-0.0388894677,
0.0174132884,
0.0291094948,
-0.0058387094,
0.0372894108,
-0.0393613763,
-0.0272743199,
-0.0146035748,
-0.0126206791,
0.033888828,
0.0510815755,
0.0220020432,
-0.0457675196,
0.0053095385,
-0.0277514681,
-0.0606639981,
0.0760640353,
-0.0207238458,
-0.0092552621,
-0.0564687476,
-0.0159151424,
0.0196428057,
0.051345367,
-0.0472702794,
-0.0151187303,
0.0399447866,
-0.0056801052,
0.0774530992,
0.0174446888,
0.0435401239,
0.0600667819,
0.0132006081,
0.0071684569,
-0.0164226796,
0.027727766,
-0.0529326014,
-0.0141901448,
-0.074436374,
0.0245614573,
-0.0056444379,
0.118561469,
-0.0362153351,
0.0004536255,
-0.0414574556,
-0.0045071002,
-0.0051720594,
0.0083274236,
-0.0130053656,
-0.012427574,
-0.0233542379,
0.0343662277,
0.0023052136,
-0.0221926682,
0.0597273633,
0.0143038547,
-0.0231016316,
-0.0523684658,
0.0145228393,
-0.0267362539,
0.0889193639,
0.0591982901,
-0.0286709145,
0.0397476405,
-0.0534272157,
-0.071133256,
0.035420049,
-0.0037409372,
-0.0341998264,
0.0540517718,
-0.0361781344,
-0.0085192202,
-0.0221548099,
-0.0501843542,
-0.0972546563,
-0.0593003407,
0.0023298713,
0.0175394882,
-0.0059627257,
-0.0000789579,
-0.0704099089,
0.0107455077,
-0.0008601841,
0.0689631104,
0.0030079777,
-0.0234995633,
-0.0245567262,
0.0361871943,
0.0254515335,
0.0275202692,
0.0378722548,
-0.0131943142,
0.0362020247,
0.0292780213,
0.054326281,
-0.0106115518,
-0.0121781994,
0.0123423701,
0.0374817252,
-0.0678720251,
-0.054900337,
0.041883871,
-0.0041469424,
-0.0579226762,
-0.04268796,
0.0794030353,
0.0366731025,
-0.0727514327,
0.0281766932,
0.0204044413,
0.0312321223,
0.0547719151,
0.0142053785,
-0.0770520717,
-0.0281330198,
0.0112246471,
0.004245467,
-0.0276124682,
-0.0177487824,
-0.0176638961,
-0.0875679776,
0.0065221926,
-0.0255538076,
-0.0565810725,
-0.0068158386,
-0.0471159033,
0.0090334993,
-0.0082465,
0.0162195023,
0.0143000195,
-0.0459333062,
-0.002768544,
0.0333578177,
-0.0168349147,
-0.0451914407,
-0.003913004,
0.0310734175,
0.0058467584,
0.0494460315,
-0.0167075228,
-0.0072423825,
-0.0599066466,
0.0361943804,
-0.0517715774,
-0.0029021115,
0.0053804615,
0.0789834037,
-0.0087299105,
-0.0201905072,
0.0084068086,
0.0147886872,
-0.0319294147,
-0.0371980816,
-0.0413517728,
0.0694608539,
-0.0417398959,
-0.0209698901,
-0.0162401833,
-0.0128020346,
0.0129785445,
0.0418886021,
-0.000780599,
-0.0334197208,
-0.0435115509,
-0.0376994051,
0.0511945374,
-0.0253961943,
-0.0620374419,
0.0319523662,
0.0306565892,
-0.0758163333,
-0.0543964095,
-0.0480567478,
-0.020919947,
0.0103269517,
0.0057327393,
-0.0050110444,
0.0002076412,
0.006546563,
-0.0702545047,
-0.0124111976,
0.0330961049,
0.0166642107,
-0.0863800421,
-0.0137268957,
0.0418375805,
-0.003981533,
-0.0606624521,
0.0257532373,
-0.0909923762,
-0.0243752953,
0.0610517338,
0.0450521596,
0.018168997,
0.0412803255,
-0.0064089498,
-0.0194483399,
0.0230397992,
0.0780530274,
-0.0073637567,
-0.028791815,
0.0719175339,
-0.01251755,
-0.0004557317,
0.0187920053,
-0.0178504232,
0.0330858678,
-0.010585336,
0.0463039018,
-0.0426061042,
0.0171719156,
0.0739406869,
-0.0455823801,
0.0775794685,
0.0022210826,
-0.0026574631,
0.009491303,
0.0392883793,
0.0211070962,
-0.0248701237,
0.0022770166,
-0.0077610193,
0.0064485492,
0.0303236376,
-0.0077090291,
0.0108126393,
-0.0041607935,
0.0281554144,
0.0157094561,
0.0077637727,
0.0223377775,
0.0030619272,
-0.0137482658,
0.0253196619,
0.0100369165,
0.0060873278,
0.0478876904,
0.0572188683,
-0.0103588039,
0.0561085343,
0.0578122959,
0.038963601,
-0.0133131882,
0.0118121495,
-0.1055192277,
0.0324256234,
-0.0126239145,
-0.0286606662,
0.0336963534,
-0.0504181124,
0.0254542585,
-0.0361623839,
0.0239680652,
0.0041064727,
-0.0012937755,
0.0245785676,
-0.0109962914,
0.0423543714,
0.04217932,
0.0104728071,
-0.0114632156,
0.1031787768,
0.0119040664,
0.0234907288,
0.0056485333,
0.0153809339,
-0.0413343608,
-0.0294599291,
0.0066060247,
-0.0016421091,
0.018059155,
0.0037686564,
-0.0312896296,
-0.0398759209,
0.0554007366,
-0.0432009585,
0.0518664829,
-0.0593966246,
0.0383303277,
0.0645636618,
0.0049750633,
-0.0326678902,
-0.0323470421,
-0.0046404647,
0.0588975511,
-0.0147358505,
-0.0547970533,
-5.517771217e-33,
-0.0259721149,
-0.0643888563,
0.0213580132,
0.0466754325,
0.0307599306,
0.0131359743,
-0.0212817024,
0.0100626554,
0.0032286895,
0.0186666623,
-0.013530978,
0.0156220393,
0.0171913467,
0.0092746094,
0.0298567228,
-0.0432646945,
0.0502406396,
0.0055445391,
-0.0148575539,
0.0052986867,
0.0271083098,
0.0304598026,
0.067023702,
-0.0591845103,
-0.0009141974,
-0.0055694478,
0.0084464336,
-0.0006244826,
-0.0168363862,
0.0633526593,
-0.0129038477,
0.0287657045,
0.0462338291,
-0.0773296729,
-0.0155063197,
0.0308328774,
-0.1105346978,
-0.0237593036,
-0.017271148,
0.0573043711,
-0.0291169677,
-0.0237475019,
0.051269073,
-0.0230154358,
-0.0065863128,
-0.0212982502,
0.0483245589,
-0.0084341187,
-0.0275769085,
-0.0400638692,
-0.0727899,
0.0066252686,
-0.0009384783,
-0.02887889,
0.0405535698,
0.0531629361,
-0.0047365655,
0.0120868199,
-0.0414239839,
-0.0012213757,
-0.031551443,
0.0573693886,
-0.0108966036,
0.0427069962,
-0.0128019899,
0.0373588502,
0.0009774874,
0.0223486125,
-0.0176090337,
-0.0047205365,
0.0228030756,
0.0316337906,
0.0146618392,
-0.018198235,
0.0767939687,
0.001257875,
-0.0086241849,
0.005957074,
-0.016632909,
0.0229488574,
-0.0081932181,
-0.0056561963,
0.0172115304,
-0.0003028577,
-0.042796731,
-0.0064945095,
-0.0120000374,
0.0119609898,
0.0029620253,
0.0205052942,
0.0209313929,
0.0526108183,
0.0264904182,
-0.0188369229,
-0.0226669442,
0.0187794305,
-0.019618107,
0.0195026658,
-0.012233167,
0.0080542797,
-0.0550912134,
-0.0429592505,
0.0272875726,
0.0101421112,
0.0223512407,
-0.0071257264,
0.083264865,
0.0106891198,
-0.0558987446,
-0.0269372445,
-0.0192890335,
0.0403223224,
-0.0066485992,
0.0121832117,
0.0658149347,
0.0196460299,
-0.018908482,
0.0353095755,
0.0096332189,
-0.0087314853,
-0.0370237641,
0.0664406195,
-0.0422319695,
0.0164802298,
-0.0100253224,
-0.0642417148,
-0.016860025,
0.0415733419,
-0.0159978028,
-0.078822054,
-0.0031001961,
0.0186243877,
2.5e-7,
0.0386917666,
0.0224543512,
0.0383441374,
0.0371162854,
0.041361168,
0.0038594448,
-0.0138716577,
0.0124559598,
0.0123738516,
-0.0095606977,
0.0197482724,
-0.0264877174,
0.0333839618,
0.0345605128,
-0.0591460988,
-0.0425928347,
-0.0371830724,
0.0356260873,
-0.0234937668,
0.0342209004,
0.0539575592,
0.1167675853,
-0.0004587768,
0.0103203282,
0.0072071147,
0.0142577151,
0.0622759424,
0.0228838064,
0.0433016941,
0.0111372126,
-0.0333043598,
0.0061491714,
0.0000432276,
0.0474509746,
-0.0109372698,
0.009858056,
-0.0101398267,
0.0340639539,
0.0088049257,
-0.0681036785,
0.0119274594,
0.0191722549,
0.0127569344,
0.00045166,
0.0500765033,
-0.079826273,
-0.021229215,
0.0534816422,
-0.0450690091,
0.0073553822,
-0.012060795,
0.0394961797,
-0.0354177617,
0.0265807733,
0.0058346977,
0.0178339779,
-0.0084620407,
-0.0867939889,
-0.0356451087,
0.0244627912,
-0.0383515544,
0.0045809844,
-0.0448857434,
-0.0428644903,
0.0162515976,
-0.0013045341,
-0.0364608839,
2.373619953e-34,
0.0312450267,
-0.0202839039,
0.0301424321,
0.0284806006,
0.0085456418,
-0.0348428413,
0.0438153744,
0.0356690101,
0.035212215,
-0.0615122057,
-0.0072214575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12634v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12634v1 | MotionScript: Natural Language Descriptions for Expressive 3D Human Motions | 2023-12-19T22:33:17 | 2023-12-19T22:33:17 | Payam Jome Yazdian, Eric Liu, Li Cheng, Angelica Lim | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO | This paper proposes MotionScript, a motion-to-text conversion algorithm and
natural language representation for human body motions. MotionScript aims to
describe movements in greater detail and with more accuracy than previous
natural language approaches. Many motion datasets describe relatively objective
and simple actions with little variation on the way they are expressed (e.g.
sitting, walking, dribbling a ball). But for expressive actions that contain a
diversity of movements in the class (e.g. being sad, dancing), or for actions
outside the domain of standard motion capture datasets (e.g. stylistic walking,
sign-language), more specific and granular natural language descriptions are
needed. Our proposed MotionScript descriptions differ from existing natural
language representations in that it provides direct descriptions in natural
language instead of simple action labels or high-level human captions. To the
best of our knowledge, this is the first attempt at translating 3D motions to
natural language descriptions without requiring training data. Our experiments
show that when MotionScript representations are used in a text-to-motion neural
task, body movements are more accurately reconstructed, and large language
models can be used to generate unseen complex motions. | [
-0.0039004055,
0.0613507293,
0.0207355786,
0.0401883759,
-0.006174339,
0.022781739,
-0.0103302766,
0.014188854,
-0.0130395414,
-0.0813902766,
-0.0368766822,
-0.0300902929,
0.0530460551,
0.03953363,
0.0386429094,
-0.1052188054,
0.0130670033,
-0.0208604578,
-0.0053868238,
0.0187301971,
0.0266742092,
0.040366821,
-0.0319064818,
0.0367388427,
-0.0313587449,
0.023744395,
-0.0218612459,
-0.0063722786,
0.0271808933,
-0.0251269005,
-0.0297344737,
0.0203086808,
0.1054004356,
-0.0408978797,
0.000001856,
-0.0116895568,
0.0719670206,
-0.0027950106,
0.0370720141,
-0.0183547977,
0.0447835438,
-0.0436861813,
0.0145764835,
0.0175255388,
-0.0122133037,
0.0011664375,
0.0279802941,
0.0409373827,
0.0644599944,
0.0671150237,
-0.0308713131,
-0.0356218666,
-0.0149124507,
0.0099976556,
0.0557119958,
0.0214898102,
0.007736457,
0.0037741796,
0.0675741881,
0.0349587575,
-0.0473261252,
0.0010128982,
-0.0068028704,
0.0152643677,
-0.0001236168,
0.0517530255,
0.0071444972,
-0.0034768968,
-0.0168392677,
0.0613083132,
0.0087911766,
0.0181394145,
0.0180769861,
0.0126340128,
0.0398247913,
-0.0176969934,
-0.019150842,
0.0589430444,
0.0275287069,
-0.0023540992,
-0.0541562364,
0.0622204244,
0.0023863041,
-0.0129278135,
0.0206745081,
-0.0281377602,
0.0051085157,
0.0479795635,
-0.0081830807,
-0.0416284204,
0.0602332205,
-0.0684323162,
0.0574599579,
0.0171686076,
0.0380489565,
-0.0240820795,
-0.0837742612,
0.0121921515,
-0.0281675868,
-0.0444853418,
0.02839607,
0.0581835769,
0.0470768362,
0.0227561295,
-0.0023933153,
0.0697862953,
-0.0290555973,
0.0161925629,
-0.0214886721,
0.016116228,
-0.0107081737,
-0.0059483629,
-0.036179103,
-0.00953604,
-0.0615184978,
-0.0512872674,
-0.0156063745,
0.0214514956,
-0.0121833654,
-0.0482738316,
-0.025801342,
0.0799732432,
-0.0142721236,
-0.0183728337,
-0.0092380326,
-0.0016577282,
-0.0053387145,
0.0433917567,
0.0054905689,
-0.0290881507,
-0.0259240214,
0.0464067385,
0.0101517532,
0.0235368628,
0.0164928362,
0.0661979616,
-0.0336518325,
-0.0330961682,
0.0401731171,
0.0063849799,
-0.0151526304,
-0.0182258021,
0.0222323481,
-0.0627425313,
0.0228486564,
-0.0247431714,
-0.0114943339,
-0.057820484,
0.007412558,
0.0106098913,
-0.0029330414,
0.0529638343,
-0.0004391975,
0.022737937,
0.0222917926,
-0.0110944957,
0.0258829258,
-0.0128767323,
0.0759341866,
0.0033354857,
-0.0445119292,
0.0063579278,
0.031499926,
0.0497055277,
-0.0484472699,
-0.0306561217,
-0.0303341337,
-0.0483633243,
0.0213762894,
0.0968408957,
0.0464631356,
0.0484361611,
-0.040850956,
-0.017451888,
0.021759307,
0.0624590442,
-0.035869576,
0.0023354848,
0.0698469058,
0.0247495119,
0.0058918442,
-0.0567332469,
-0.0460219868,
0.0679557472,
0.0314015225,
-0.0491277128,
-0.0429719128,
0.0156980623,
-0.0469268784,
-0.0273536313,
-0.0088091977,
-0.015325875,
0.0698041394,
-0.0113082593,
0.031902831,
0.0177588984,
-0.0341892317,
0.0178880524,
-0.0161173344,
-0.052649796,
0.0131472927,
0.003652157,
-0.0395427532,
0.0438994467,
-0.0397679508,
-0.0102580357,
-0.0060971226,
-0.015611588,
0.0231166761,
0.0385564901,
0.0027743513,
0.016656803,
0.0337122977,
-0.0443540663,
-0.0244584866,
-0.0051906444,
0.0369281359,
0.0094094221,
-0.0303190555,
0.0185380429,
0.0002787937,
0.0022207913,
-0.0559114441,
0.0518193543,
-0.0542950332,
-0.0270619225,
0.0263508353,
-0.0153448526,
0.0150840869,
0.0206220821,
-0.0144534968,
0.0121229077,
0.001210048,
-0.0290416442,
-0.0166744273,
0.050048463,
-0.0318134353,
-0.0118755549,
0.0088788047,
-0.0254017673,
-0.0198582858,
0.0066076075,
-0.0072615007,
-0.0723454058,
0.0277777389,
-0.0672831982,
-0.0367504731,
0.0179071687,
-0.0045004166,
0.0575643107,
-0.0302747637,
-0.0092346091,
0.0123421289,
0.0052039935,
-0.0268238038,
0.0389278717,
-0.0335512683,
-0.0038540149,
-0.0241424739,
-0.0331681855,
0.0227020029,
-0.0370728783,
0.0475543961,
0.0392174311,
0.0316356644,
-0.0060274205,
0.0129530001,
-0.0261235703,
0.0117643038,
0.0143927829,
0.0176893938,
0.0044051642,
0.0007307364,
-0.0023044588,
-0.007133455,
-0.0704967529,
0.0356092453,
0.001916194,
-0.0456199348,
0.014871846,
-0.0073383041,
-0.034445636,
-0.0358857326,
0.0235239025,
-0.0063483007,
0.0410374552,
0.055503767,
-0.0362034552,
-0.0192374494,
0.0064852792,
-0.0080207093,
0.0361785777,
-0.0175781865,
-0.0281125475,
0.0455754399,
-0.0236138497,
-0.0141097689,
0.0121337967,
-0.0297074169,
0.0257277768,
0.0420221351,
0.009995997,
-0.0432822853,
-0.0041204682,
-0.0105067929,
0.0399119556,
-0.0598117113,
-0.0558487363,
0.0635617971,
0.0318064988,
0.0486405939,
0.0294761397,
-0.0645371228,
-0.0475719832,
-0.0008169196,
-0.0033539676,
-0.0059629986,
0.0235256664,
-0.0565428212,
-0.030644564,
-0.0080466261,
-0.029384546,
-0.0053095683,
-0.0125939753,
-0.0463871881,
0.0163961239,
0.0148664135,
-0.0123249367,
0.0765351355,
0.0090068774,
0.0400217921,
-0.0119606238,
-0.0285790414,
-0.0120987957,
-0.018280562,
0.0384784415,
0.0003189123,
-0.0204316583,
-0.0737864524,
0.0192973036,
-0.0177279972,
0.0247981101,
0.014186387,
-0.0255276281,
-0.0286655314,
0.0086787911,
-0.0316420496,
-0.0622511432,
-0.0200164504,
-0.0461243615,
0.0042429301,
0.0482804924,
-0.0192778595,
-0.0038847199,
-0.0326679312,
-0.0163746551,
0.0151479701,
0.0530317277,
-0.0831201673,
0.0088332482,
0.0103550758,
0.060086824,
-0.0361599699,
0.0264223088,
-0.0943819508,
0.0088937636,
0.0107399039,
-0.0057402062,
-0.0180858281,
0.0724666268,
0.0455571562,
-0.0281030014,
-0.0067232596,
0.0647532344,
0.0115949055,
0.00722053,
0.0187781174,
0.0377290547,
0.0093426602,
0.00119789,
-0.0297429804,
-0.0526106283,
-0.0541737862,
-0.0108521497,
0.0121911773,
0.0640095547,
-0.0085774427,
-0.0046947277,
-0.0633482039,
0.0369388908,
0.0347280577,
-0.0583179034,
-0.0879780352,
-0.0060311132,
0.0135042127,
0.0044971467,
-0.0178512651,
-0.023357654,
0.0101613495,
0.0186256189,
0.0041749356,
-0.0464681499,
-0.0875867084,
0.0137342941,
-0.0137903849,
0.0235772002,
-0.0019681207,
0.052128084,
-0.040548034,
-0.0301567037,
0.0034347069,
0.0103015816,
0.0251806173,
0.0136793843,
0.0249894988,
0.0279534888,
-0.0255644135,
-0.0108056059,
0.0809319764,
-0.0723261088,
-0.033225324,
-0.039679043,
0.0510146096,
-0.0812831074,
-0.0150026558,
-0.0452408865,
-0.0217607934,
0.0169237722,
0.0555394143,
-0.0017285126,
-0.0418734141,
-0.0286725685,
-0.0327555351,
-0.0022336689,
0.0060939286,
-0.073091127,
0.0009225793,
-0.0161205214,
-0.026653707,
-0.0689431205,
0.0151397325,
0.0762355477,
0.0497239381,
-0.0157044269,
-0.0141341323,
0.0249239728,
-0.0175721534,
-0.0631415099,
0.0471547917,
-0.0187366605,
0.0317871384,
0.0304369517,
-0.0135214776,
0.0251815375,
0.0501643904,
0.0188167915,
-0.0093002981,
-0.0475102141,
-0.0524106845,
-0.0412369445,
0.0574961193,
0.0131368013,
0.0242402647,
-0.000886297,
-0.0241364781,
0.0013255337,
0.0290571861,
-0.0056251315,
0.0229621679,
0.0028110207,
-0.0050925277,
-0.040854495,
-0.0048031281,
-0.0236570146,
-0.0107809575,
-0.0518747084,
0.0066919657,
-0.0408323631,
-0.0445045456,
0.0055647967,
-0.0172386635,
0.037783511,
-0.0183336474,
0.0092486823,
-0.026844332,
-0.0804187506,
-0.0303487703,
-0.0018332672,
-0.101672776,
-0.012596556,
0.0708202273,
0.0183257014,
0.0079233889,
-0.0097671822,
-0.0117215384,
-0.0274349693,
-0.0035499744,
0.0011845439,
0.0569232479,
0.0003728266,
-0.0247111227,
0.0201006532,
-0.0094699692,
0.0331645831,
-0.0743582919,
-0.0099136289,
-0.0008310451,
0.0127704479,
0.035388466,
0.0092298994,
0.0001301644,
-0.0086305803,
-0.0081574973,
-0.0333908722,
-0.0370581634,
-0.011160952,
0.0125191379,
0.0049206982,
0.0443315618,
-0.0401605964,
0.0185136385,
0.0193878394,
0.0936970264,
-0.0084001962,
-0.0441804975,
0.0662702918,
-0.0216408037,
-0.0168768018,
-0.049054116,
0.0221917666,
-0.0123603633,
0.0216102879,
0.0123529481,
-0.046528969,
-0.0237876493,
-0.0198710915,
0.017137628,
-0.0200796518,
-0.0024028602,
0.0062576882,
-0.0119708665,
-0.0385564379,
0.0022633187,
0.0002851388,
0.0065840166,
-0.0287157856,
0.097890459,
-0.0367912613,
-0.0192649513,
0.0254160166,
0.0053506778,
-0.0072233104,
-0.0218920931,
-0.0412446521,
-0.0888982415,
-4.956353279e-33,
-0.0199804809,
-0.0583438687,
0.0302863475,
-0.0216106437,
-0.0603361018,
-0.0118053127,
-0.0746999905,
0.013422396,
0.0430532172,
0.0578870662,
0.0400808193,
0.0173813011,
-0.0033206057,
0.0240041614,
0.0377819985,
-0.0055238847,
0.0037745333,
-0.0697683841,
-0.0262285247,
0.0222038012,
0.0550877415,
-0.0232635662,
0.0863212794,
-0.0784219429,
0.0051055918,
0.0147864698,
-0.0730199814,
0.0020913989,
0.0375163257,
-0.0068522757,
-0.0398006588,
0.0008090248,
0.024590699,
0.0125100883,
-0.0145888338,
0.0473450385,
-0.0275576692,
-0.0436358638,
-0.0238788389,
0.0429430529,
-0.0693092868,
0.0182300229,
0.0390058234,
-0.0188598242,
-0.0385211445,
0.00647109,
0.0462882407,
-0.0285940636,
0.0152883315,
-0.0259392671,
-0.0243766997,
0.0086679459,
-0.0445100181,
-0.067110166,
-0.0046124142,
0.0457620285,
-0.046755325,
-0.0644238591,
0.0093383305,
-0.0175441056,
-0.0483563915,
0.0105733648,
0.0170751363,
0.0103899306,
0.036101561,
0.0492115058,
-0.0086999759,
-0.0259548221,
-0.0270271003,
0.045577161,
0.0754175484,
0.0736583173,
0.0394638106,
0.0802175775,
0.03533848,
0.0278491713,
0.0053114933,
0.0703578666,
-0.0617691651,
0.0679159611,
-0.0490086824,
0.0197544862,
-0.0220858622,
-0.0164040253,
-0.0296298135,
-0.0084267538,
0.0301053058,
0.0150895277,
0.0122701768,
0.0022933122,
0.0334121548,
-0.0207432136,
0.0527282134,
0.0108981589,
-0.0090301987,
0.0291449446,
-0.0279654488,
0.0530274659,
0.0138106616,
-0.0348528661,
0.010883891,
-0.0605357513,
0.0451766849,
0.0168366116,
0.0785514712,
0.0228149034,
-0.0322995186,
0.0678072274,
-0.0236374307,
-0.0224368051,
-0.0096679227,
0.0061974199,
-0.001178412,
0.032731913,
0.0480416529,
-0.0277593862,
-0.0446727574,
0.0517834537,
-0.0536861047,
-0.0061834082,
-0.0002199996,
0.0178781897,
-0.0214210395,
0.0180031434,
-0.050439164,
0.0299009364,
-0.014843463,
0.0021791232,
0.0347659104,
-0.0426087007,
-0.0001556293,
0.0436122119,
2.464e-7,
0.0079062711,
0.0133944657,
0.0419447944,
0.0480151661,
0.023892235,
0.0536296368,
-0.0051497249,
0.0661026537,
0.0127108712,
-0.0105264625,
0.0295369364,
0.0186374262,
0.0170179158,
-0.0229116641,
-0.0424567349,
0.0334808864,
-0.0109592425,
0.0227528866,
-0.0287175309,
-0.0102536399,
0.0815402344,
0.0347514376,
0.0162092913,
0.0276607778,
0.0158818774,
-0.0386768728,
0.0610375293,
-0.0689696446,
0.0247659385,
-0.0243490748,
0.0546461381,
-0.0097938813,
-0.0348499641,
-0.0324180573,
-0.0331257805,
0.004429156,
0.0445564464,
0.0721085593,
-0.0634681359,
0.0238423441,
-0.0008976781,
-0.0218153764,
-0.0255967248,
0.0327190422,
0.0401333012,
-0.0636894181,
-0.0061853924,
-0.0424678773,
-0.0119352713,
0.0032338856,
0.0311869737,
-0.009046969,
0.0009064235,
-0.0004468274,
0.0346396379,
-0.0315707326,
0.0053059841,
-0.0694284439,
-0.0211705118,
-0.0284318142,
-0.0737692565,
0.0766599253,
-0.0024025284,
0.0062790415,
0.0029551659,
-0.0098941345,
-0.0191330984,
1.814397112e-34,
-0.0257470962,
0.0046933251,
0.0240304563,
-0.0119759636,
0.0188283511,
0.0126621146,
0.0393414423,
0.0484245867,
0.0284950696,
-0.0532277152,
-0.0385564156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12624v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12624v1 | Building a Llama2-finetuned LLM for Odia Language Utilizing Domain Knowledge Instruction Set | 2023-12-19T22:01:01 | 2023-12-19T22:01:01 | Guneet Singh Kohli, Shantipriya Parida, Sambit Sekhar, Samirit Saha, Nipun B Nair, Parul Agarwal, Sonal Khosla, Kusumlata Patiyal, Debasish Dhal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Building LLMs for languages other than English is in great demand due to the
unavailability and performance of multilingual LLMs, such as understanding the
local context. The problem is critical for low-resource languages due to the
need for instruction sets. In a multilingual country like India, there is a
need for LLMs supporting Indic languages to provide generative AI and LLM-based
technologies and services to its citizens.
This paper presents our approach of i) generating a large Odia instruction
set, including domain knowledge data suitable for LLM fine-tuning, and ii)
building a Llama2-finetuned model tailored for enhanced performance in the Odia
domain. The proposed work will help researchers build an instruction set and
LLM, particularly for Indic languages. We will release the model and
instruction set for the public for research and noncommercial purposes. | [
0.0247799326,
0.0121086147,
-0.0447115935,
0.062694557,
-0.043296542,
0.0247764662,
-0.0121152811,
-0.005815519,
0.0169569962,
-0.0204982813,
-0.0598293766,
-0.0253697503,
-0.0059060841,
0.0126052238,
0.0260366332,
-0.038511239,
0.0234241243,
-0.0368180647,
-0.0410990976,
-0.013310519,
0.0145230321,
0.013927036,
-0.0337045006,
0.0014392557,
-0.0063579693,
-0.0045122756,
-0.0114578791,
0.0048339525,
-0.0031313016,
-0.0237958916,
-0.0054703914,
-0.0058316458,
0.0233485568,
-0.0194699001,
0.0000020374,
-0.0851376057,
-0.0232846458,
-0.0202941801,
-0.0255674515,
-0.0000692128,
0.0332311131,
0.0284780283,
-0.024023002,
0.0148896975,
-0.0425201468,
0.0544353165,
0.0353639759,
-0.0048306561,
0.0246041901,
0.0930352062,
0.0116098411,
-0.0410047024,
0.0418740362,
0.0056953491,
-0.0079890182,
-0.0247873645,
0.0063409307,
0.002385295,
0.0651278496,
-0.0187192764,
-0.0014716232,
-0.0014999268,
0.0115316678,
0.0004070106,
-0.0256791916,
-0.0044647176,
-0.0031972968,
-0.0033194998,
-0.0084885526,
0.0301601775,
0.0408269465,
-0.00928888,
0.009371167,
0.0085717859,
-0.0169963576,
-0.0277618188,
-0.0428665318,
0.0476601124,
-0.0029726224,
0.0570600294,
0.0703457221,
-0.027066581,
-0.0181362014,
0.0048621236,
0.0029066203,
0.106077455,
0.007300687,
-0.0075448961,
-0.0387105122,
-0.0064447387,
-0.0003668408,
-0.0203803852,
-0.0019661291,
0.087567538,
-0.008594878,
0.0556723103,
-0.0158467442,
0.0073937271,
0.0434830971,
-0.0261486657,
0.0523133427,
0.0346759558,
-0.0255774297,
0.0010750192,
-0.0041777925,
0.0411653221,
0.0114984484,
0.0209100861,
-0.0336681753,
-0.0287756808,
-0.0127989454,
0.0061083948,
-0.0206257366,
0.0558529161,
-0.0351619013,
0.0643088073,
-0.0577031448,
0.0441973321,
-0.0204131305,
0.0304210335,
0.0056795678,
-0.0576737821,
-0.0275009219,
-0.0389252156,
-0.033797171,
-0.023563616,
-0.0417933352,
0.0515454151,
-0.0308424402,
-0.091709055,
0.0262352899,
0.032987196,
-0.0332673602,
0.0041469671,
0.0042308168,
0.0859260112,
0.0008499093,
-0.0408581644,
-0.089863874,
-0.0141268373,
0.0421399921,
-0.0748879164,
0.011813798,
-0.0880656987,
0.0391190499,
0.0216832049,
-0.0069862413,
-0.0843875632,
0.0022064645,
0.0069070715,
0.0450203754,
0.0353691056,
-0.0563638173,
0.0107017523,
0.0266875084,
0.0183614455,
0.0422694981,
0.0731397569,
0.040329989,
0.011459996,
0.0327878147,
-0.0031562608,
-0.0191680621,
0.0697437897,
-0.0043413178,
0.0068072835,
-0.0019237159,
0.0423254818,
-0.028015377,
0.0181594882,
0.0186748859,
0.0185497757,
0.0144309774,
0.0803018808,
-0.0041383575,
0.0459859036,
0.0523118265,
0.0323881395,
0.0485326275,
-0.0072671375,
0.0239283517,
0.0009828702,
-0.0276508834,
0.0281612985,
-0.0028037974,
0.017152058,
-0.0271903183,
0.0360071771,
-0.0144489333,
-0.0421138331,
0.0045664054,
-0.0389950052,
-0.0602368824,
-0.0134388143,
0.0366714969,
0.0061993902,
-0.0323485248,
0.0363399833,
0.0562166534,
-0.0403337963,
0.0014027514,
-0.0666702241,
0.0375056826,
0.0480121188,
0.0089157801,
-0.054647658,
-0.0582292825,
0.0283078365,
0.0189049989,
0.0534912534,
0.0091333203,
-0.0500766635,
-0.0542411543,
-0.0530871339,
-0.0118751498,
-0.005751756,
0.0060693678,
0.0452067442,
0.0113428431,
0.0151720317,
-0.0139247216,
-0.0471499115,
0.0111526111,
0.0316267461,
-0.0597559251,
-0.032928016,
-0.0207110737,
0.0267205667,
0.0467783362,
0.027487468,
0.0089596538,
-0.0241202414,
0.0412529148,
-0.0206224732,
0.0125841592,
-0.0046983934,
-0.0064271712,
0.0233677439,
0.0466541499,
-0.0402583554,
0.0088586789,
-0.0379644372,
-0.0366864242,
-0.0372277424,
-0.0049249968,
0.0024369368,
0.0267709531,
-0.0416382626,
0.0244000591,
-0.0075663817,
-0.013801788,
-0.0271949917,
0.0483594798,
-0.0146051813,
-0.0061459895,
0.030335227,
0.0127599025,
0.0520754568,
-0.0166672934,
0.0140645439,
-0.0112875421,
-0.00247841,
0.0334054232,
-0.046277415,
0.067806825,
-0.0465833433,
-0.0412663296,
-0.0517029949,
0.0024991177,
-0.0148700038,
0.0460716523,
-0.0063547473,
0.0217823833,
-0.0276189391,
0.0043257168,
-0.02301009,
0.0231582131,
0.0161469877,
-0.0195608884,
0.0089005018,
0.0163489357,
-0.0539902523,
-0.0297834389,
0.0278068557,
0.0138302855,
-0.0205190573,
0.0001457942,
-0.0343012549,
-0.088359274,
0.0397906825,
-0.0273101814,
0.0192176197,
-0.0212807301,
-0.0413248874,
0.0036737607,
-0.0121605452,
0.0220313612,
0.0135375811,
-0.0568645261,
0.0199222025,
0.0375131443,
-0.0138879884,
-0.0623310655,
-0.0042342152,
0.0068848329,
-0.0197877791,
-0.0172295813,
-0.0320619009,
-0.0077573364,
0.0296545327,
-0.018535953,
0.015606124,
0.0001125775,
-0.022795612,
-0.0320439264,
0.0204956569,
0.0127649307,
0.0377547666,
-0.0549005121,
0.0687576979,
0.0023554822,
-0.0616874844,
0.0439070202,
-0.0282961763,
0.0212731734,
-0.044432383,
-0.0225743353,
-0.0674262866,
0.0079167057,
-0.0435937196,
0.0179344453,
-0.0238506943,
-0.0214672051,
-0.0381830558,
0.0428303443,
-0.0022004999,
-0.0305945948,
0.0521970429,
-0.0778804347,
0.013404808,
-0.0294727981,
-0.0146500068,
-0.0451317579,
0.0770714805,
0.0037845953,
0.0194648467,
0.0292517561,
0.0112625929,
0.0276780333,
0.0103373034,
-0.0037745584,
-0.0182952434,
0.0049581882,
0.0113041112,
-0.0150781013,
-0.0166103877,
0.0176884513,
0.0502370223,
-0.0252577756,
0.0108277826,
0.0026854025,
-0.0366928875,
0.0296974219,
-0.0583232827,
0.000496849,
0.018836908,
0.0671448112,
-0.0455413274,
-0.024962632,
0.0494046248,
0.0531161688,
-0.0083761606,
-0.0254525989,
0.0746910945,
0.0412949622,
-0.0203200951,
-0.0022308948,
-0.0743268132,
-0.0281970892,
0.0316757895,
0.0642713904,
-0.0992484242,
0.000241802,
-0.0007902114,
0.030760495,
-0.0012899067,
-0.0137645826,
-0.0289143324,
-0.1262519062,
0.0532057323,
-0.0157905631,
0.0079445131,
-0.0420440994,
-0.0149308313,
0.0001634481,
0.0353943221,
0.0043122,
0.0377428047,
-0.0493683368,
-0.02564626,
0.0293884017,
-0.0063449512,
-0.0546982288,
-0.0119336825,
-0.0222041104,
0.0748269558,
0.0879084989,
0.0134343179,
-0.0013291476,
-0.0204117838,
0.0129206944,
-0.0426503792,
0.0260471236,
-0.0358709097,
0.0002731471,
0.0215755533,
-0.0315749906,
0.0010454212,
0.0536830612,
-0.0255113002,
0.0081201382,
0.0324459635,
0.0682045594,
-0.0423518904,
0.0295478944,
-0.0111368224,
-0.046571292,
0.0110865617,
0.0154325096,
0.0250699911,
-0.011846072,
0.004596632,
-0.0549359694,
-0.0485053547,
-0.0447850525,
0.0014840619,
0.0236365218,
-0.0637914836,
0.0058523081,
-0.0361061506,
-0.027576549,
0.0642303079,
0.0188247561,
0.0640479773,
0.0222444404,
0.0059837382,
-0.0116501106,
-0.0466049314,
-0.0309809558,
-0.0529764779,
0.0368642919,
-0.0783412457,
-0.0411641896,
0.0529094376,
-0.0430428088,
-0.0039949655,
0.000310909,
-0.0173247717,
-0.0543720908,
0.0304428004,
0.08215826,
0.0228370242,
0.0025719081,
-0.014859749,
-0.053016644,
0.026101293,
0.0339241475,
-0.0101188682,
0.0251565408,
0.0156291313,
0.0415753089,
0.0010009141,
0.0349111259,
-0.0784890205,
0.0368917473,
0.0172109026,
0.006207516,
-0.0434640348,
-0.0316584222,
0.0085564153,
0.0505680554,
-0.0122253243,
-0.0441930816,
-0.0384693705,
-0.0326081254,
0.0437048301,
-0.0079837916,
-0.0023039603,
-0.015439176,
-0.0062170662,
-0.0092416145,
-0.0221914239,
0.0073923874,
-0.0116017992,
-0.0310474671,
0.0148768034,
-0.0151673481,
0.1094337329,
0.0233604312,
0.0618707612,
-0.0010125884,
0.01906069,
0.0001227131,
0.0052569807,
-0.0109591568,
0.0495867059,
-0.004263768,
0.0634607747,
-0.0241658315,
0.0452841818,
-0.0072391378,
0.0360528156,
0.1025327519,
-0.0249185544,
-0.0116894795,
0.0762484893,
0.0812263936,
0.0239364225,
0.0336140804,
-0.0421075113,
0.0241892952,
-0.0043500443,
0.0328107141,
-0.0239328612,
-0.0270379353,
0.0583808012,
0.0154466666,
0.0011811785,
-0.018237371,
0.0638407618,
-0.0270106923,
0.0358001962,
-0.0106984768,
0.036905624,
-0.0520736873,
-0.0346983373,
0.030014582,
-0.0190216377,
0.009546536,
-0.0239253342,
-0.0613800958,
-0.0538761392,
-0.016479088,
0.0001763994,
-0.0269003175,
-0.0265855491,
0.0419109873,
0.0222864263,
0.0440906212,
0.0152147124,
-0.0262340568,
-0.0197329596,
-0.0617922023,
-0.0344458818,
0.0320699215,
-5.929446604e-33,
-0.0717579499,
-0.0319434144,
0.0591475032,
0.0454772599,
0.0203701779,
-0.0337261595,
-0.0069047669,
-0.0173933171,
-0.0163600501,
-0.0271961018,
-0.0213105641,
-0.01706204,
0.0212567914,
-0.0253340248,
0.0026187929,
0.0260900315,
0.0068041701,
-0.016418783,
0.0034451408,
0.00421341,
0.029044196,
0.0178916622,
0.0670271069,
-0.063374728,
0.0127891824,
-0.0472559147,
-0.0126508782,
0.0223450251,
-0.0237850677,
0.0504383259,
-0.0161932018,
0.0469770916,
0.0260335058,
-0.0120969899,
-0.0098824697,
-0.0234094802,
-0.0656496063,
-0.0644026399,
0.0538190007,
0.0409223773,
0.0352063067,
-0.0818088278,
0.0513397567,
0.0090097245,
-0.0531012863,
0.0524727218,
0.0248973537,
-0.0218715128,
0.0110399602,
-0.0376737043,
-0.0878563151,
0.0253361128,
0.0212978683,
-0.02562562,
0.0049261134,
-0.0506212898,
0.0032021545,
-0.0506927148,
-0.0252437741,
0.0180706698,
0.0429746248,
0.0319058336,
0.0824208558,
-0.0311966948,
-0.018157674,
-0.0074649821,
-0.0002364228,
-0.0195990242,
0.0493629836,
0.0283660032,
0.0013312791,
0.0818806142,
-0.0181371756,
0.0373376757,
-0.017358657,
-0.0274943002,
-0.0391366519,
0.0623311885,
0.0232916251,
0.0467290096,
-0.0084482878,
-0.0246606302,
-0.0253605619,
-0.0037555099,
0.0184950195,
0.0091167493,
-0.0153595414,
-0.0378392003,
0.050444752,
-0.0462623239,
-0.0027271421,
-0.013284239,
-0.003189353,
-0.0208341125,
-0.0097277807,
-0.0234224889,
-0.0214213096,
0.0273955949,
0.0009249639,
0.0114181796,
-0.0490682833,
-0.0827877373,
-0.0366499573,
0.0023577434,
0.0282593556,
0.0113092065,
0.0171703026,
0.0285152365,
-0.0567608252,
0.0405323617,
-0.0295979679,
0.0544542111,
0.0305320118,
0.014561072,
-0.0081239073,
-0.0187557675,
-0.0100542083,
0.0049799439,
0.0187440999,
-0.0637024865,
-0.0016246805,
-0.0101683326,
0.0014032802,
0.0238295756,
-0.0627722964,
0.0218662806,
-0.0415737405,
0.0252598356,
0.0012550893,
-0.0087642753,
-0.0051220111,
0.0269951783,
2.791e-7,
0.0323848352,
0.0591444746,
0.0250131618,
0.0631690621,
-0.0158563089,
-0.0027566266,
-0.0353622958,
-0.0161888655,
-0.0107438723,
0.0384255461,
-0.0053913142,
0.0211022906,
0.0275319461,
0.0192649066,
-0.0797825903,
0.0317575745,
0.0659826919,
0.0203543548,
-0.0664143339,
0.0112181017,
0.0145065542,
0.0519725792,
-0.0022257543,
-0.022984568,
-0.0284622293,
-0.0251474455,
0.0213127751,
-0.0109613808,
0.0190436672,
0.0568887591,
0.0154974647,
0.0223040562,
-0.036481265,
-0.0261113327,
0.0006376903,
0.0014709131,
-0.040079318,
0.0912320465,
0.0072099473,
-0.0045115328,
0.0707078874,
-0.0426327996,
-0.0074685086,
-0.0292625893,
0.0430516079,
0.024393741,
-0.0151050454,
0.0113243405,
0.0107255392,
-0.0136839775,
-0.0677868351,
-0.0437769219,
0.0348352604,
-0.0057186298,
-0.0054848073,
-0.0867615417,
-0.039777644,
-0.02610486,
-0.001595614,
0.01674385,
0.0000370311,
-0.069867745,
-0.032128416,
0.0176541228,
-0.0121961897,
-0.0644767061,
0.0202082507,
2.456637175e-34,
0.004580365,
-0.0373049341,
0.0279788971,
0.0895580873,
0.0022798639,
0.0068229344,
-0.029551113,
0.0423025824,
0.0094043454,
-0.0497567244,
0.0067453641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14185v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14185v2 | Auto311: A Confidence-guided Automated System for Non-emergency Calls | 2023-12-19T20:52:04 | 2024-01-30T17:02:20 | Zirong Chen, Xutong Sun, Yuanhe Li, Meiyi Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Emergency and non-emergency response systems are essential services provided
by local governments and critical to protecting lives, the environment, and
property. The effective handling of (non-)emergency calls is critical for
public safety and well-being. By reducing the burden through non-emergency
callers, residents in critical need of assistance through 911 will receive a
fast and effective response. Collaborating with the Department of Emergency
Communications (DEC) in Nashville, we analyzed 11,796 non-emergency call
recordings and developed Auto311, the first automated system to handle 311
non-emergency calls, which (1) effectively and dynamically predicts ongoing
non-emergency incident types to generate tailored case reports during the call;
(2) itemizes essential information from dialogue contexts to complete the
generated reports; and (3) strategically structures system-caller dialogues
with optimized confidence. We used real-world data to evaluate the system's
effectiveness and deployability. The experimental results indicate that the
system effectively predicts incident type with an average F-1 score of 92.54%.
Moreover, the system successfully itemizes critical information from relevant
contexts to complete reports, evincing a 0.93 average consistency score
compared to the ground truth. Additionally, emulations demonstrate that the
system effectively decreases conversation turns as the utterance size gets more
extensive and categorizes the ongoing call with 94.49% mean accuracy. | [
0.0343792364,
0.0230380036,
-0.02317743,
-0.0182546731,
-0.0303919949,
-0.0045118486,
-0.0028084167,
-0.0355271623,
-0.0659597218,
-0.0824132636,
0.0355213359,
-0.0072518708,
0.004233887,
0.0590137653,
-0.0354403481,
-0.0659581944,
0.0021175325,
0.0091346148,
0.067544654,
0.0560103357,
0.038424924,
0.0209834203,
-0.0374617018,
0.0509727523,
-0.0412294753,
0.0240169168,
-0.0535140261,
-0.0000529137,
0.0431954451,
-0.031920556,
0.0048459838,
0.0259786937,
0.0271319393,
0.0214478951,
0.000001946,
-0.0580578744,
0.0060307318,
-0.0116353408,
-0.0762259066,
-0.0495955087,
-0.0309793036,
-0.008390449,
-0.0210042987,
0.0382188298,
-0.0020964502,
-0.0203324128,
0.0231664814,
0.0333153941,
0.0558427721,
0.0060290159,
-0.0230665077,
0.0116490945,
0.0100254016,
0.0241093095,
-0.0418514982,
-0.0252725501,
0.0075909044,
-0.010555041,
0.0266082827,
-0.0573224425,
0.0734146833,
-0.0057242885,
-0.0025189004,
-0.0125381947,
-0.0037388429,
0.02570167,
-0.0910156667,
-0.0191930328,
-0.008239083,
0.063513808,
0.000885047,
-0.01150396,
0.0141834849,
0.0021812196,
0.0057119015,
-0.0245110989,
-0.0476009548,
-0.054320734,
-0.0371879861,
-0.031361144,
-0.0311367381,
0.0788166448,
-0.0313304067,
-0.0068235705,
0.009284405,
-0.00532678,
-0.0103297774,
-0.0121911662,
-0.0031643184,
-0.0084290411,
0.0205451325,
-0.0616910532,
0.0577588752,
0.0186452847,
-0.0778249502,
0.0086480221,
0.0149713485,
-0.0040423875,
0.0463772416,
-0.0615561567,
0.0021485032,
0.0250219293,
-0.031091461,
-0.0071267318,
0.0348542854,
-0.0196369532,
0.0690528229,
-0.0568614379,
-0.0310957357,
0.0031706674,
-0.0471606068,
0.0268931352,
-0.0535775758,
0.0411025845,
-0.013916106,
0.0216020513,
-0.0351162143,
0.0348836929,
0.0173181724,
0.0107680643,
-0.0282633789,
0.0111314114,
-0.040029034,
0.0000183892,
0.0012254731,
-0.0161231495,
-0.0394774228,
0.0514360256,
0.0062117958,
-0.0451163501,
0.0288705435,
-0.0098116165,
0.044806689,
0.0328964852,
-0.042286396,
0.0308142286,
-0.0245380569,
0.0077939704,
-0.0816673785,
-0.0270553175,
0.0001580744,
-0.0399489999,
-0.0498849601,
-0.034707956,
0.0148206269,
0.0427143946,
-0.0247238204,
0.0797087848,
0.0328542031,
-0.0108196735,
-0.0256085303,
0.0296472721,
-0.01978397,
0.0560798198,
0.077971369,
0.0045365696,
0.0352710523,
0.0299316533,
0.0116051156,
0.0063224752,
0.0653893724,
-0.0456041023,
0.0397710241,
-0.0096518351,
-0.0196064953,
0.0026925607,
0.0128742941,
0.0584607311,
-0.0312016737,
0.0097456882,
0.0281644389,
0.014295131,
0.011753696,
-0.016910091,
0.0391852446,
0.0611451194,
-0.008196461,
0.0172376707,
0.0268740747,
0.0676544234,
-0.0282089338,
-0.0173021182,
0.0042941319,
-0.0212645829,
-0.0608966313,
0.0070864572,
0.0329630338,
0.0015738904,
-0.0394907407,
-0.0067413924,
-0.0127468593,
-0.0105775641,
-0.0407880731,
0.0150180319,
-0.000899514,
-0.0349456035,
-0.0340061635,
0.0355845578,
-0.0341891125,
0.0199337769,
-0.0351800583,
-0.0612203851,
0.0114871608,
0.1110910326,
0.0072922502,
-0.0136487922,
-0.0359446071,
-0.065781042,
0.0267467592,
0.0064155008,
0.0057468726,
-0.0093068583,
0.0347771496,
-0.0334781893,
-0.0213691071,
0.0622899644,
0.0326144248,
0.0330141336,
-0.0149977608,
0.026395414,
0.0131144123,
0.0269467086,
-0.0339759178,
-0.0076187933,
0.0428351872,
-0.0423131064,
-0.0087282266,
-0.0163054168,
0.0430718549,
-0.000434551,
-0.0023899609,
0.0110727409,
0.0076121483,
0.0004215466,
-0.049064137,
0.0314824246,
-0.0547310486,
0.0336443707,
0.0081017278,
0.0074151931,
0.0012333692,
-0.002381763,
-0.0191924386,
-0.0303670671,
0.0009573555,
-0.0987959206,
0.0093476223,
-0.015727045,
0.0322047397,
0.06914334,
-0.0205091294,
-0.0019435852,
0.0157865435,
0.0168483667,
-0.0152403675,
-0.0204432271,
0.0218481291,
0.0334208496,
-0.0392660275,
0.0296792854,
0.0017588815,
-0.0348758847,
0.0203732308,
-0.0264198352,
-0.0357131585,
-0.0183731206,
0.0228976365,
-0.0885815397,
-0.0043307394,
-0.0464478806,
-0.0151368901,
0.0098283077,
0.0279689115,
-0.0214079935,
-0.0527191535,
0.0050045229,
-0.0420435965,
0.0607215315,
0.0044755824,
-0.0242719892,
0.0400022678,
-0.0497858897,
-0.0415024534,
0.0093123214,
-0.0094156628,
0.0102791861,
0.0081319902,
-0.0785521567,
-0.0516557544,
0.0051738932,
-0.0009364095,
-0.0036664093,
-0.0137698036,
-0.04646888,
-0.0095490385,
0.0189511664,
0.0171748716,
-0.0114740012,
0.0575368926,
-0.0113928271,
-0.011244271,
-0.0164691657,
-0.0325116143,
-0.000826648,
-0.0393037908,
-0.0445386954,
0.0110484613,
-0.0524917431,
-0.0050973305,
0.0377217382,
0.0211475622,
0.0420421883,
0.0132483654,
-0.0547908284,
0.0107735805,
-0.0316316523,
-0.0523599349,
-0.0646194071,
-0.0099453246,
0.0549842976,
-0.0012694268,
-0.0228932276,
0.0348570682,
0.0188374445,
0.0221967492,
-0.0476875603,
-0.044823397,
-0.0364786871,
0.0619746856,
-0.0230348855,
0.0151871555,
0.0480373427,
-0.0339765213,
0.0458964109,
-0.0430844724,
0.0166248605,
-0.0529305711,
0.0437440537,
-0.0599504448,
-0.0187931657,
0.0272839088,
-0.0825279504,
-0.0709843189,
-0.0212878399,
-0.0450798534,
0.0034870047,
-0.0066600339,
-0.0016377224,
-0.0460925996,
0.0402929857,
0.0158630665,
0.0678742006,
0.0138635794,
-0.0002534248,
0.0215630271,
0.0336718,
0.0248384532,
0.0581914037,
-0.0268949941,
0.0542298816,
0.0752388164,
0.0251795053,
0.0508154146,
0.0295617506,
-0.0053296983,
0.0016308813,
-0.0022480877,
-0.0247932263,
-0.0422195382,
0.0391124114,
0.0015038108,
0.0021861896,
0.0199953131,
0.0643009469,
0.0350113548,
-0.014325873,
-0.0008671239,
-0.0934045315,
-0.0224977229,
0.0345787331,
0.0206716377,
0.0121939527,
0.0002508941,
0.0242370833,
0.0414582491,
-0.0508318059,
-0.0335225649,
0.0217059497,
-0.0878843516,
0.083850272,
-0.0006600746,
-0.0044704555,
-0.0251194928,
-0.0449713841,
0.0449540429,
0.0079129674,
0.0137792807,
-0.0202013236,
-0.0151712168,
-0.0481087863,
0.0086092455,
-0.1120699868,
-0.0528569594,
0.0196816437,
-0.0187832229,
0.0382993966,
0.0593440309,
0.0383694768,
-0.0132328309,
0.026546482,
0.0012424994,
0.0264733676,
0.0231072176,
0.0157310981,
0.0334253684,
0.0109008765,
0.035866864,
-0.0438928902,
0.0623785369,
0.0157571081,
-0.0236100219,
0.0685335547,
0.066010721,
-0.0771505311,
0.014853186,
-0.0425641015,
0.0635699853,
0.0697574094,
0.0266690645,
0.0356395096,
0.0035728519,
0.0332009941,
-0.0031215604,
0.0168834068,
-0.0260968264,
0.0042747566,
0.0284733288,
-0.0151438816,
-0.0906964913,
-0.0059535,
-0.0388232246,
0.0334380977,
-0.003233619,
-0.0116063124,
-0.0400604643,
0.0199968833,
0.0254301131,
-0.0229382534,
-0.0284873247,
0.0500322655,
0.0367156938,
-0.0317291208,
0.0196611751,
0.0288104936,
0.0348213986,
-0.0216975473,
0.0425000302,
0.0193567667,
-0.0038964627,
0.0628282726,
0.0142114256,
0.0261408053,
0.0084008332,
-0.0100891031,
0.0047994289,
-0.0274430737,
0.0396109186,
-0.0595338419,
-0.0513272956,
0.0146199791,
0.0238701236,
0.0074374191,
0.0058918982,
-0.0293463208,
0.0876842886,
-0.0402313173,
0.0150580397,
-0.1103106365,
-0.0305979606,
0.0087176757,
0.0063140667,
0.041437041,
-0.0066866176,
-0.0338833705,
-0.0061993189,
0.0450528301,
-0.0070957723,
0.0042122784,
-0.0008829115,
0.0746852979,
-0.0143216569,
0.0067573665,
0.0039126817,
0.0011557149,
-0.0760567188,
-0.0067199515,
0.0002460209,
0.0110669974,
0.0482971147,
0.0372142605,
0.0172847547,
-0.0410068147,
-0.0294899959,
0.0395803452,
0.0369145796,
0.0485201925,
0.0248703137,
0.0617563687,
-0.011507011,
0.0351522602,
0.0100519909,
0.0086145783,
-0.0341237932,
-0.0546285138,
-0.0518513136,
0.0280241612,
0.013851787,
0.0055662584,
-0.0249008983,
-0.012460866,
0.0105016697,
-0.0155593818,
0.0482383557,
0.0158429556,
0.0152602829,
-0.0072519649,
0.0367022082,
-0.0321779437,
0.0128432279,
0.018784862,
-0.0047476823,
0.0105840545,
-0.0111539504,
-0.0692946538,
-0.0488690846,
-0.0139586199,
0.0117637822,
0.0685253218,
-0.0091508981,
-0.0487758629,
-0.0968120471,
0.0033891131,
0.0206879433,
-0.010439313,
-0.0038140405,
-0.0272648707,
0.0534456894,
0.0143501777,
0.0126809655,
0.0241777021,
-0.0206079744,
0.0190717876,
-0.0235534124,
0.0164627787,
-0.0081430925,
-5.680338045e-33,
-0.0159994252,
-0.0582568236,
-0.0103619322,
-0.0056935935,
0.0203701872,
-0.0095612491,
0.0190429185,
0.0257189479,
0.0461490527,
-0.0026106862,
-0.0073487191,
0.0081835007,
0.0171674658,
-0.0302220322,
0.0206617955,
0.0028674135,
0.0516411774,
-0.012501047,
0.0079531167,
0.0216812249,
0.0262710527,
0.0280826446,
0.0093113231,
-0.1413443536,
-0.0215836279,
0.0100317793,
0.0083692493,
-0.0037788984,
0.032089211,
0.0218653679,
-0.0037281443,
0.0392084159,
0.0156245111,
-0.0401569046,
-0.0006493353,
0.0878772661,
-0.0412034094,
-0.0328251347,
0.0119258463,
-0.0189229399,
0.0161581002,
0.0243806262,
-0.0223665554,
0.0199972838,
0.0098244334,
-0.0006900573,
0.0320939645,
-0.0377409756,
-0.0207149927,
-0.0324863046,
-0.0661274642,
0.0243621543,
-0.0376059413,
-0.0370179079,
-0.0453935117,
0.0593826734,
-0.0191876516,
-0.0190297719,
-0.020421315,
-0.0273219235,
-0.0074125417,
-0.0377933942,
-0.0016238651,
-0.0003575486,
-0.0740313232,
0.0278900918,
-0.0107097412,
-0.0442454182,
-0.0600099452,
-0.026250517,
-0.0325907953,
0.0946763828,
0.0186917968,
0.055678986,
0.0082198279,
-0.0275302883,
-0.0645435676,
0.0390939862,
0.0329122841,
0.0127778416,
0.0307232812,
-0.0101511776,
-0.1048770472,
0.0096011655,
0.000734191,
-0.0109353894,
-0.0110551994,
0.0044885715,
0.0343203098,
0.0225250758,
0.0174485389,
0.0303280186,
0.0223844126,
0.0259234011,
0.0345880575,
-0.0322179198,
0.0016536138,
0.0056309262,
-0.0130274128,
0.017408153,
-0.0744426027,
0.0200545844,
0.0291725416,
0.0526025742,
0.0301667955,
-0.016317429,
0.0258967392,
0.0139579112,
-0.0275603533,
0.0086332252,
0.0251481794,
0.0471168272,
-0.0317648761,
0.0147487223,
0.0273864474,
-0.0015680889,
-0.0136438655,
-0.0020364099,
-0.0397734828,
-0.0266077574,
-0.0014473023,
-0.0564055108,
-0.0337706171,
0.0382117145,
-0.0091637978,
-0.0114600761,
-0.001562602,
-0.0681690276,
0.0210443158,
0.0322760902,
0.0196879096,
-0.0192319602,
2.636e-7,
-0.019268902,
0.0187010169,
0.0210921243,
0.0094077289,
0.0164698195,
0.0332750119,
0.0349283144,
0.0047158515,
0.0468152538,
-0.0281229857,
0.0611749589,
-0.0311298296,
0.046750892,
0.0921657458,
-0.0848741084,
-0.0867923424,
-0.0633533522,
-0.0179682765,
-0.0708708838,
0.0122141922,
0.0785335153,
0.0791146755,
0.0102920355,
-0.0182814021,
0.0296023879,
-0.0019313592,
-0.0340791047,
-0.0377231501,
-0.0244368948,
-0.0028748773,
0.0526658297,
0.0456406735,
-0.0208561607,
0.0746512115,
-0.0347792879,
-0.0112266578,
-0.0001154973,
0.0612170883,
-0.0221501235,
-0.0503914319,
-0.0327251405,
-0.0439740345,
0.0170536768,
-0.0232086442,
-0.0000480992,
-0.0366173871,
0.0075107384,
0.0462382957,
-0.0491722636,
0.0044155307,
-0.0290940925,
0.0034564317,
-0.0237727556,
0.0367889591,
-0.0010151007,
0.0035011678,
0.0000682152,
-0.0404709615,
0.0426154733,
0.0567552112,
-0.009301723,
-0.0565061942,
0.0143012209,
-0.033726003,
0.0155823827,
-0.0170126688,
0.0175763182,
2.158793079e-34,
0.014019127,
0.0447098948,
-0.0077396231,
-0.0160903875,
0.0447237268,
0.0023333731,
0.0178121924,
-0.0074121547,
0.0351709612,
-0.0221238639,
-0.0105047915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.05399v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.05399v1 | Automated Assessment of Students' Code Comprehension using LLMs | 2023-12-19T20:39:12 | 2023-12-19T20:39:12 | Priti Oli, Rabin Banjade, Jeevan Chapagain, Vasile Rus | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | Assessing student's answers and in particular natural language answers is a
crucial challenge in the field of education. Advances in machine learning,
including transformer-based models such as Large Language Models(LLMs), have
led to significant progress in various natural language tasks. Nevertheless,
amidst the growing trend of evaluating LLMs across diverse tasks, evaluating
LLMs in the realm of automated answer assesment has not received much
attention. To address this gap, we explore the potential of using LLMs for
automated assessment of student's short and open-ended answer. Particularly, we
use LLMs to compare students' explanations with expert explanations in the
context of line-by-line explanations of computer programs.
For comparison purposes, we assess both Large Language Models (LLMs) and
encoder-based Semantic Textual Similarity (STS) models in the context of
assessing the correctness of students' explanation of computer code. Our
findings indicate that LLMs, when prompted in few-shot and chain-of-thought
setting perform comparable to fine-tuned encoder-based models in evaluating
students' short answers in programming domain. | [
0.020898873,
-0.0109450249,
-0.042359598,
0.0544632412,
-0.0217564348,
0.0220280383,
0.0029928819,
-0.024865685,
-0.0283870455,
-0.0518602729,
0.0208550766,
0.0149417063,
0.0151899178,
0.006072036,
0.0206626952,
-0.0216158871,
0.0001414541,
-0.0490168482,
-0.0313337855,
0.0215484574,
0.0111746239,
0.0234045275,
-0.0013794281,
0.0575867891,
0.0702793598,
-0.0252168775,
-0.0197477881,
-0.0334822796,
0.0064367359,
-0.0217638854,
-0.0229189228,
0.0102096992,
0.0292129237,
-0.0068365103,
0.0000019519,
-0.0581228398,
0.0055211489,
0.0124373874,
-0.0184651092,
0.0666585043,
-0.0057205404,
0.023900684,
0.0487089679,
0.0250622481,
-0.0269991606,
-0.0092562409,
0.0499353819,
-0.0291594528,
0.0772891194,
0.0480615459,
0.0267100874,
-0.0420444049,
0.0324445255,
0.029565936,
0.0421514437,
-0.0184727758,
0.0237226598,
0.0543688722,
0.0000060082,
0.0321707875,
-0.034948241,
0.0023785057,
0.0337362029,
-0.0109776249,
0.0297218133,
0.0161913857,
-0.0042898604,
0.0115358308,
0.0167245511,
0.0448856279,
-0.0267374665,
-0.0441306047,
-0.0015343195,
-0.0049651288,
-0.0194045287,
0.0386914201,
-0.0670022592,
0.0366326645,
-0.0247374009,
0.0068387375,
0.0005648759,
-0.0178055074,
-0.0144359581,
0.0102507696,
-0.0308544524,
0.0504064411,
0.0012268876,
-0.0385476798,
-0.0338419676,
0.0021530404,
-0.0022555913,
-0.0382993482,
0.0077274176,
0.1018320024,
-0.0036940936,
0.0152670732,
0.0140994769,
-0.0207060017,
0.0098367007,
-0.0200064629,
0.0147147123,
0.0295593049,
0.0039401413,
0.0235482361,
-0.0582737736,
0.1098148301,
0.0171344243,
0.0243299194,
-0.0513781458,
-0.0174106192,
-0.0755161196,
-0.0250173528,
-0.0232277196,
0.0618324317,
0.0083713559,
0.0178540275,
-0.0284528229,
0.0215473231,
-0.0028476818,
0.031672176,
-0.0318300091,
-0.0077327248,
0.0123095214,
0.0157900788,
-0.0385850519,
0.0316150561,
-0.0317990966,
-0.0209241696,
-0.0126954541,
-0.0233096033,
-0.0229888465,
0.041832637,
0.0091170119,
-0.0063451706,
0.0189341269,
0.0471758135,
0.0071653361,
0.0291148853,
-0.0161141194,
-0.0263309944,
-0.006486732,
-0.0093473559,
-0.008814102,
-0.1029911041,
-0.0163310245,
0.0527981594,
0.0077424929,
-0.0208377596,
0.0110117616,
0.0462029278,
0.0076745693,
0.0375009701,
-0.0033921872,
0.0168275982,
0.0366361812,
0.0055009462,
-0.0046457048,
-0.0157683808,
0.0367450081,
0.0003548767,
0.0261370912,
-0.0846514702,
0.0529722385,
0.0064340187,
-0.0193676576,
-0.0279480293,
-0.0017014185,
0.0524324141,
0.035993509,
0.0382106118,
-0.0007404833,
0.0598094165,
0.0173805188,
0.0034429701,
-0.0132140517,
0.065582782,
0.0046061967,
0.0435786769,
0.0755976364,
0.0507503301,
0.0179147236,
0.0247064661,
-0.0289112907,
0.0457087867,
-0.0210424811,
0.023914868,
0.0271028914,
0.0111417202,
0.0138077987,
-0.0835975111,
-0.018724747,
0.007499611,
-0.0049470668,
0.014094891,
0.0548545904,
-0.0063545452,
-0.0327301063,
0.0314848945,
0.0168735161,
-0.0398991369,
0.0255985726,
-0.076462239,
0.0355575942,
0.0552829355,
0.0362936668,
-0.0224950165,
0.0141027691,
-0.0292307939,
-0.0022356545,
-0.0177279916,
0.0160244908,
-0.0113380067,
-0.0136791831,
-0.0489647798,
-0.0048708948,
-0.0435616747,
-0.0303261261,
-0.0099751102,
-0.0083812857,
-0.0016968678,
0.0476382561,
-0.0315409638,
-0.0578709431,
0.0309887808,
-0.0030173315,
-0.0426848866,
-0.0229846686,
-0.0015970597,
-0.0015441601,
-0.0093896594,
-0.023612339,
0.0356693082,
0.0045983861,
-0.0211465415,
-0.0398152284,
-0.0695536435,
-0.0618168041,
-0.0398132429,
0.031887304,
-0.0960822701,
-0.005611816,
0.0494839065,
-0.0350455642,
-0.0339589566,
0.0335526355,
-0.0818498731,
-0.0044665812,
0.0025766992,
0.0185965095,
-0.0368683711,
-0.0271026436,
-0.0270457026,
0.0306596216,
0.0530670285,
0.0814660192,
0.0146283852,
0.0140816355,
0.0166748147,
0.011448333,
-0.0256392434,
-0.0179190524,
-0.0292040631,
0.0055510914,
0.0324954353,
0.0160465315,
-0.0453682132,
-0.0121811908,
-0.0634896159,
-0.0121324174,
-0.0037901744,
0.0210779812,
0.025937764,
-0.0239553694,
0.0111243296,
-0.0002103981,
-0.0498552099,
-0.0073135919,
-0.0206128284,
-0.009358556,
0.0393706709,
-0.0132697448,
-0.0679977015,
-0.039468389,
-0.0241761822,
-0.0639239848,
0.0773069039,
0.0405047536,
-0.0075231679,
-0.0572074354,
0.0618620068,
-0.0198667739,
-0.0405272134,
-0.0110137807,
-0.0362492539,
0.0169490539,
-0.0110604614,
0.0211282428,
0.0711016208,
0.0332537927,
0.0221561119,
0.0633544549,
0.001486815,
-0.0615836866,
-0.0104682269,
0.0136025595,
-0.0690811574,
-0.0142382495,
-0.0531125292,
0.0224493723,
0.0627027377,
0.0392857268,
-0.0115084527,
-0.0130890086,
0.0140849827,
-0.0107883448,
0.0288114436,
-0.0480142944,
-0.0570635088,
-0.0008958166,
0.0369994603,
-0.0029752192,
-0.0650979131,
0.1179714948,
-0.0665637776,
-0.0183124579,
-0.0202654488,
-0.018222006,
-0.0707269162,
0.0526893884,
0.0027027428,
0.0168960243,
-0.0113725439,
-0.0009884062,
-0.0234253909,
0.0097301649,
0.0214378908,
-0.0426716283,
0.0461800098,
-0.0478518307,
-0.0304683726,
0.0062766522,
0.0155819682,
-0.0338331759,
-0.0039137532,
-0.0268674009,
0.0093400795,
0.0199904796,
-0.0096474243,
0.002085953,
0.0082238354,
0.0317993201,
-0.0249172375,
0.0132276053,
-0.0468925647,
-0.0103675956,
0.0131124472,
0.0112217553,
-0.0190724805,
-0.0009405371,
-0.0164072271,
0.0607615337,
0.0157993212,
0.0109091634,
0.0476323292,
-0.043296285,
-0.0156246675,
0.0121565806,
-0.0557164736,
0.0008603883,
0.0671677589,
0.0489650667,
-0.0629855543,
-0.0170159768,
0.1106143892,
0.0373174585,
-0.0214254577,
-0.0023453399,
-0.0399764515,
-0.0083307521,
0.0494622886,
0.0218809005,
-0.0708514005,
-0.0410320349,
-0.0424784087,
0.0212747399,
0.002337873,
-0.0101380181,
0.0036009247,
-0.1075578481,
0.0025898879,
0.0110161938,
-0.0381629281,
-0.0606739148,
-0.0755188763,
-0.0170557275,
0.0085747186,
-0.019428594,
-0.0041599819,
-0.0264222398,
0.0227544177,
0.0337844938,
-0.0221730415,
0.0220486559,
0.0593174323,
-0.0085078953,
0.0214786213,
0.0380220637,
0.0025155125,
-0.0344462991,
-0.0324980877,
0.0078855539,
-0.0401532538,
0.0295690428,
0.0004102324,
0.0315889791,
-0.0059332703,
0.0101165436,
-0.0108807702,
0.0324816294,
-0.0404985398,
-0.0074730362,
0.0732522905,
0.0706464872,
-0.0185147487,
-0.0450632796,
-0.0301047172,
0.0201157331,
-0.0320826024,
0.0885583535,
0.0857510492,
-0.0304692164,
-0.0134667829,
-0.0704613775,
-0.0211780686,
-0.0001133603,
-0.0586846843,
-0.0095687713,
0.0434668809,
0.0502905697,
-0.0071440581,
-0.0134255337,
0.0651055276,
-0.0120423678,
0.002468114,
0.0058723162,
0.0304184277,
-0.0018176206,
-0.0599243939,
0.0020084914,
-0.0302775614,
0.0290091857,
-0.0292510334,
0.0079075592,
0.0236292351,
-0.0132629452,
-0.0423067808,
-0.0082521643,
-0.0967954248,
-0.0193276145,
-0.0490151644,
0.0260212049,
0.0175128952,
0.0026048715,
0.0046454929,
-0.0333888382,
0.0043264595,
-0.0069437879,
-0.0156710986,
0.0195524544,
-0.0167031009,
0.0188273098,
0.0203129146,
-0.0202824343,
-0.0434502847,
-0.0118478704,
-0.0042424472,
-0.0005157942,
0.0004066636,
-0.0612579621,
0.0377873853,
0.0615272112,
0.025302574,
0.0438629054,
-0.0224622302,
0.0345769338,
0.0247716401,
0.010094895,
-0.0092854947,
-0.0207506772,
-0.0131386239,
0.0225552171,
-0.0145876501,
0.028833339,
-0.0039145141,
-0.0330947973,
0.0060725282,
-0.0102985408,
0.0853709951,
0.0160671771,
0.0113605764,
0.0301142,
-0.0040379162,
-0.0366970599,
-0.0409500487,
0.0184890591,
0.0520450808,
0.0119981728,
0.0834630057,
0.0086678807,
0.050280109,
0.0087301712,
0.00363762,
-0.0565885641,
-0.079668887,
-0.007648088,
0.0081120869,
-0.003156516,
0.0212674942,
0.0105538173,
0.0221003443,
0.0393936895,
-0.0217368193,
0.0596753135,
-0.026302712,
-0.0364177264,
0.0618165098,
0.0378886871,
0.0205513276,
0.0056709549,
0.0626844689,
-0.0196116194,
-0.0027869171,
0.0157109052,
-0.0412284806,
-0.0169204492,
0.0078778137,
-0.0012251848,
0.0076278914,
0.0390592851,
-0.0183013119,
-0.028066935,
-0.0623294227,
-0.0026834533,
0.0295931268,
0.0416792706,
-0.0317592211,
0.0301258825,
0.0810191333,
-0.0161924362,
-0.0231283195,
-0.0113303447,
0.0277150907,
-0.0055341246,
-0.0518470444,
-0.0715258271,
-5.616869799e-33,
-0.0252900794,
-0.0604839288,
0.0048251147,
0.0303924363,
0.016660694,
-0.0143950349,
-0.0547745265,
-0.0061056055,
-0.0369227417,
-0.017883094,
0.0399348773,
0.0173905455,
-0.0245638732,
0.0102230739,
0.0260413568,
-0.0324728154,
0.018167004,
0.0230429806,
-0.0288977884,
0.0418648422,
-0.0082590049,
-0.0311255381,
0.0286439322,
-0.0189724639,
0.0295547415,
-0.0388821065,
0.022671923,
-0.0071140477,
-0.0120663485,
0.0686509386,
-0.006816084,
0.0757668614,
0.0268995669,
-0.0549491346,
-0.0054319832,
0.0303404462,
-0.034942437,
-0.0474808216,
0.0353540368,
-0.029687183,
-0.0030135666,
-0.0403387323,
0.0694669858,
0.0166003257,
-0.0245606098,
-0.0234390143,
0.0883927345,
0.0124387098,
0.0162692145,
-0.0304963738,
-0.0410688557,
0.0002485889,
-0.1078776941,
-0.0371273719,
-0.0147535764,
0.0706197172,
-0.0276276208,
0.0665838346,
0.0105572613,
0.0167543255,
0.0382668227,
0.0410028622,
0.0564128831,
-0.0164935309,
-0.0096657556,
0.0161691271,
0.0215424076,
-0.0288558844,
-0.046698153,
-0.0033713689,
0.0122475596,
0.0058379858,
0.096605733,
0.030155506,
0.0486383773,
0.0461682566,
-0.0729073286,
0.0452357829,
-0.0151014486,
0.0562049225,
0.0057175052,
-0.008294425,
-0.0502192751,
-0.0237877984,
-0.0788952559,
0.0016173746,
-0.0389668308,
-0.0325385258,
0.0448057391,
-0.0649577454,
-0.0127395084,
-0.0121262632,
0.0169041641,
-0.0752671063,
0.0191866066,
0.0030945032,
-0.0288825184,
0.0431599952,
-0.0119789373,
0.0310667884,
-0.0313676931,
0.0189378224,
0.0366259515,
0.000798091,
0.0713008642,
-0.0044353292,
0.0096562337,
-0.013400442,
-0.0481091514,
-0.0241129957,
-0.0504495874,
-0.0767740235,
-0.0372122526,
-0.0229870807,
-0.001009452,
0.0551917478,
-0.0162502509,
0.037810307,
-0.0411111824,
-0.0467582978,
-0.0250400826,
-0.0353744887,
-0.0049836454,
-0.0009605826,
-0.0379444622,
-0.0145165129,
-0.0387306213,
0.0081476523,
0.0009777825,
-0.0341294818,
-0.0191493742,
0.0296773948,
2.602e-7,
0.036619328,
0.0449605957,
0.0199704897,
0.0230937302,
-0.0173120741,
0.0176012106,
0.0137728248,
-0.0081210425,
0.0601374358,
-0.027754169,
-0.0086497376,
0.0423662998,
0.0327352472,
0.0063829147,
-0.0398856103,
0.0076860241,
-0.0595002025,
-0.0129500134,
-0.0442941189,
0.0589719303,
0.1549969316,
0.0358137824,
-0.0159135684,
0.0225749165,
-0.0201837793,
-0.042012658,
0.0108604888,
-0.019341886,
0.0235029235,
0.0236815456,
-0.0321310386,
-0.015513693,
0.0294477344,
0.0375562496,
0.0221601333,
-0.0112979691,
0.0137082459,
0.0365784355,
0.010411337,
0.031727884,
-0.0006370693,
-0.013479989,
0.0149659021,
-0.0918056294,
0.0533177443,
-0.0668992475,
0.0010018711,
0.016668262,
-0.0370651148,
-0.0177286379,
-0.0006102629,
-0.0073904265,
0.0249728709,
0.021266399,
-0.0019054462,
-0.0282889083,
-0.0009914387,
-0.0320939757,
-0.0259445496,
0.0098707303,
-0.0110994121,
-0.0157716423,
-0.0500319898,
-0.0399784222,
0.0385862179,
-0.0275611263,
0.0207507499,
2.12705565e-34,
0.0135420756,
-0.0297044702,
0.0371488407,
-0.0006902748,
0.0503278635,
0.0147799933,
-0.0205209609,
0.0267686564,
0.0169988032,
-0.0815419406,
-0.0093915565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12588v1 | An Empirical study of Unsupervised Neural Machine Translation: analyzing NMT output, model's behavior and sentences' contribution | 2023-12-19T20:35:08 | 2023-12-19T20:35:08 | Isidora Chara Tourni, Derry Wijaya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Unsupervised Neural Machine Translation (UNMT) focuses on improving NMT
results under the assumption there is no human translated parallel data, yet
little work has been done so far in highlighting its advantages compared to
supervised methods and analyzing its output in aspects other than translation
accuracy. We focus on three very diverse languages, French, Gujarati, and
Kazakh, and train bilingual NMT models, to and from English, with various
levels of supervision, in high- and low- resource setups, measure quality of
the NMT output and compare the generated sequences' word order and semantic
similarity to source and reference sentences. We also use Layer-wise Relevance
Propagation to evaluate the source and target sentences' contribution to the
result, expanding the findings of previous works to the UNMT paradigm. | [
0.031829834,
0.0707359165,
-0.0236426182,
0.0476591289,
-0.0601496547,
0.0051880805,
0.0047675213,
-0.0302123614,
-0.0387202278,
-0.0084826341,
-0.0141842486,
-0.0299138278,
0.0231112204,
-0.0559509993,
0.0425370112,
-0.0191759244,
0.0349206626,
-0.0079716379,
-0.0319989659,
0.0045820512,
0.0042100088,
0.0279645659,
-0.0002869933,
0.0322894044,
-0.040660467,
0.0026929537,
-0.0043052509,
0.0326576047,
0.0367777273,
-0.0001081349,
-0.0296673812,
0.0377826951,
-0.0204373077,
0.0715739504,
0.0000017664,
-0.0412947647,
-0.0395501889,
0.0065692845,
0.0809679106,
0.0170434695,
0.0474167839,
-0.0364483781,
-0.0475161299,
0.0407397002,
-0.0196918976,
-0.0111795831,
0.0653907806,
0.0192643404,
0.0539276972,
0.0842473134,
-0.0121491747,
-0.0160366334,
-0.0070398645,
-0.0420678072,
-0.0173146371,
-0.0215810314,
-0.0150070908,
0.0017511714,
-0.0591123104,
0.013264996,
-0.0050439183,
0.0603465214,
0.014367708,
-0.0459328666,
-0.0283018425,
-0.0066800499,
-0.0440088101,
-0.0271959007,
0.041968178,
0.0613226406,
-0.0695011392,
-0.0128975809,
-0.0046493891,
0.0020030846,
-0.0151303168,
0.0093210191,
-0.043508023,
0.0491879173,
0.0004879305,
0.0276360344,
0.0088471109,
0.0357740372,
0.0367657244,
-0.0289421882,
-0.0047827177,
0.0218013693,
0.0406479202,
-0.0201322995,
-0.0065574236,
0.0054988423,
0.0080822352,
-0.0151621392,
0.0391529165,
-0.0014317514,
-0.0077660056,
0.0210655537,
0.0042600147,
-0.0535326116,
0.0192032196,
-0.1054359153,
0.0287956614,
0.0975614116,
-0.016418457,
0.0081702005,
-0.0489542298,
0.0366660804,
-0.0510640331,
0.0020108509,
-0.0932207331,
-0.0071470053,
-0.0592652112,
0.0014904705,
-0.0056581548,
-0.0158752184,
-0.066776894,
0.0326594934,
-0.0503668562,
0.0104186889,
0.0201395489,
-0.0179217178,
0.0397066586,
-0.0108084437,
-0.0503613874,
0.0080714468,
-0.0022034878,
0.0615369789,
-0.0172656309,
-0.0409314036,
-0.0230189916,
-0.0610171035,
-0.0167839713,
0.0315683745,
-0.0243317354,
-0.0200715177,
-0.013436785,
0.1098329127,
-0.0470289886,
-0.0472274125,
-0.0342650302,
-0.0071528805,
-0.0076578404,
-0.0524137653,
0.0295405127,
-0.0438572168,
0.0540554486,
-0.0039089224,
0.0042028702,
-0.0047870083,
-0.0107345646,
0.012164725,
-0.0097572822,
0.0537245944,
0.0042722011,
0.0071988027,
0.0487473197,
0.0185419712,
0.0699829832,
0.0472468995,
0.0250289459,
0.0142669221,
-0.0013062559,
-0.0237206183,
-0.0283416025,
0.0292382538,
0.0302014053,
0.0028376288,
-0.0541893356,
0.0533819757,
-0.0139969196,
0.0543768145,
0.0436849445,
0.0509429276,
-0.0279875547,
0.0354933366,
0.058333002,
0.0195902381,
0.0185011234,
0.0872118026,
0.0516793467,
0.0286901779,
-0.0086656893,
0.0409361385,
-0.0416599996,
0.0564183928,
0.0188242942,
0.0121731991,
0.0559347421,
0.0569917038,
-0.0300351828,
-0.0392071158,
0.0205415655,
-0.0192389954,
0.0304712988,
-0.0542050861,
0.019953208,
0.0258832313,
-0.023949055,
0.0219676532,
0.0105706304,
-0.0532589965,
0.0166896656,
-0.0277482141,
-0.0442455932,
0.0599918626,
0.01758161,
0.0029592637,
-0.0284151826,
0.0247783847,
-0.0509062782,
0.0477169566,
0.0108606899,
0.011714695,
0.011529386,
-0.0340006128,
-0.0100037297,
-0.0300385524,
-0.006961585,
0.0610221513,
-0.0243008696,
0.0486642346,
0.0524036773,
-0.0558397062,
-0.0294267721,
0.029505929,
-0.0118296798,
-0.0248434301,
0.0372281112,
0.0165526289,
0.019081207,
0.0255789645,
-0.0010355855,
0.0234722812,
0.0163506251,
-0.0118832458,
-0.0517555438,
0.0238000862,
-0.0674697757,
-0.0614238307,
0.0023732281,
-0.0756346285,
0.0048463801,
0.0214458983,
-0.0363119356,
-0.0706259236,
0.0335061178,
-0.0489095747,
-0.0181096103,
-0.0746194273,
0.0125388857,
0.0309471302,
0.0052755075,
-0.0151947876,
0.0646329969,
-0.0112382509,
0.0030197364,
0.0390502065,
-0.0296986885,
0.0493730791,
0.0181294847,
-0.0017914731,
0.0615420453,
0.0215742681,
0.0441026874,
0.0588491596,
0.0378099903,
-0.004368925,
-0.0271551516,
-0.0621458367,
-0.0035661601,
-0.0260242447,
0.0543172881,
0.0532314479,
0.0773406476,
0.0083961794,
-0.0267476626,
-0.0285520013,
-0.0039369711,
0.0273905769,
0.0061890134,
0.0402300619,
0.0068285088,
0.0226705875,
-0.0497275665,
-0.0378766842,
0.0245646648,
0.0153001156,
-0.0191297475,
-0.0013091363,
-0.0727292672,
-0.0339444391,
-0.060319405,
-0.00038538,
-0.0078295674,
-0.0745776445,
0.0273628216,
-0.0246155728,
0.0407280549,
0.0123786246,
0.0053808158,
0.0021428589,
0.0611918569,
0.0155272139,
-0.0372982249,
0.0102607301,
-0.0442967713,
-0.0133792218,
-0.0265500825,
-0.0229868367,
-0.0140777025,
0.0457388908,
0.0049717817,
-0.0257649086,
-0.0678480789,
-0.0088373525,
0.0040848982,
-0.0246591922,
-0.0175764449,
0.0481041335,
0.0129744969,
0.0360494778,
0.0105319032,
-0.0340790376,
0.0440099426,
-0.0647783279,
0.0057744579,
-0.0562796928,
-0.0081626866,
-0.0623075292,
0.0405760556,
-0.0017652019,
-0.0010026038,
-0.0505322814,
-0.0447984934,
-0.0477122627,
0.0065449364,
0.0059806001,
0.0053182859,
0.0354349092,
-0.0393657684,
-0.0131625384,
-0.0275670756,
0.0276542213,
-0.0122020748,
-0.0396919735,
0.0252085552,
-0.017755013,
0.0400246866,
0.0005519089,
-0.0257631075,
0.0194450319,
0.02460167,
0.0638038367,
-0.0071790852,
0.0054371585,
-0.0248996317,
0.0151535915,
0.0043107658,
-0.0132840341,
0.022849137,
-0.0133972205,
0.0184485298,
0.0118746776,
-0.0186346434,
-0.0125475433,
-0.0411622301,
-0.0399590656,
-0.0090966225,
-0.0156935789,
-0.0303847082,
-0.0079829432,
0.0229104348,
-0.0392486379,
-0.0199407078,
0.0783274174,
-0.0033867164,
0.0090854084,
0.0153559325,
-0.014497106,
0.0041464805,
0.0096886586,
0.0275319833,
-0.0215917751,
0.0042748875,
-0.0040115463,
0.0318447314,
0.0290601961,
0.0404002182,
-0.0281373169,
-0.076756008,
-0.0043934584,
0.0249425005,
-0.0743780285,
-0.003392902,
-0.0053308709,
-0.0296387076,
-0.0545185432,
0.0184756611,
-0.0145679507,
0.0108259879,
0.0171271283,
-0.0010137039,
0.046060767,
-0.0732738674,
-0.0326345451,
-0.0282940473,
-0.0001221404,
0.0829874277,
0.0128780054,
-0.0047529172,
0.0048372857,
0.0361227244,
-0.0442925505,
0.0372369625,
-0.0022549254,
-0.0042603542,
-0.0047835992,
-0.0054479633,
-0.0026317292,
-0.0282739569,
-0.0230843686,
0.05865255,
0.0379998758,
0.0539785847,
-0.0286393259,
-0.0265246313,
-0.0209145192,
-0.0111068096,
0.0038358062,
0.031186359,
0.0224164668,
-0.0207410902,
-0.0024973033,
0.0220851991,
0.0024805781,
-0.0370645933,
-0.0306131076,
-0.0016605257,
-0.0243151356,
-0.0222534835,
-0.0950259343,
-0.0938835666,
-0.0306960717,
0.0177507661,
0.0061162282,
0.0396029167,
0.0285359174,
-0.0098387925,
0.0108218398,
0.0331796557,
-0.0093027661,
-0.0297957398,
-0.0314076617,
0.0123602916,
0.0135681788,
-0.0597533695,
0.001879365,
-0.0211628173,
-0.0989463478,
-0.0657479316,
-0.0563382544,
0.0779650807,
0.0173376184,
0.0684745461,
-0.0088904947,
-0.0245605558,
0.0066943141,
0.0496846512,
-0.0345652252,
-0.0214652698,
-0.0094831437,
-0.0341825001,
-0.0359723233,
0.0400609709,
-0.0008481573,
0.0455104187,
-0.0024357315,
0.0607151762,
0.0198594108,
-0.0456535108,
0.0327358432,
-0.0262403246,
0.0680813342,
-0.0292018689,
0.0218496993,
-0.026299715,
0.0219370015,
-0.0261215139,
0.0076026875,
-0.038004145,
-0.0263661742,
0.0347515605,
0.0419206023,
-0.0007378448,
-0.0496075563,
-0.0200424846,
-0.0053077918,
0.0123150321,
-0.0364517272,
-0.0279444084,
0.0393186845,
-0.0247227848,
0.0414057299,
0.0034228533,
0.0286132824,
-0.0090075908,
0.0020158766,
-0.0697073638,
0.0318142511,
0.0182748176,
0.0338929966,
0.0485843569,
0.0495476723,
-0.040058028,
0.0003590992,
-0.0035263777,
0.0341622122,
0.0887370259,
-0.0256252941,
0.1144712791,
-0.0142181842,
0.0087944148,
-0.0186737608,
0.0543632098,
0.0193153359,
0.0168313198,
-0.0330714248,
-0.0116984993,
-0.017141493,
0.0106553119,
0.0485235415,
0.0097260252,
-0.0377124064,
0.0167815387,
-0.0157898739,
-0.0265975948,
-0.0114003802,
-0.0157184023,
0.0033781009,
-0.0427386314,
-0.0122596892,
0.0053633349,
-0.0168394409,
-0.0146331396,
0.0286914427,
-0.0108241625,
-0.0275192987,
0.0460765064,
0.0690545589,
-0.0242824554,
-0.0127133112,
-0.0374735445,
0.0063280649,
-0.0271873325,
-0.0248690639,
-0.0136216246,
-5.6984087e-33,
-0.0201715548,
-0.0051282789,
0.0003938955,
-0.0239237677,
-0.0003347855,
-0.0259165503,
-0.0343472883,
-0.0326194279,
0.0073359348,
0.0000156989,
-0.0091203814,
0.0307945441,
0.0218679439,
-0.0012033852,
0.0402243398,
0.0101134703,
0.0728483647,
0.0217137169,
-0.0148897897,
0.0411519855,
0.0317108333,
0.0297955424,
0.100343287,
-0.070750609,
0.0294747148,
-0.0684384853,
-0.0015645811,
0.003549587,
-0.0292764697,
0.0300389472,
-0.0012601243,
0.0261892304,
0.0164153781,
-0.0431968495,
-0.0344379805,
-0.0554562397,
-0.0807427615,
-0.015264052,
0.0170029253,
0.0204299595,
-0.0752360672,
-0.0188646205,
0.0550767928,
-0.0550661907,
-0.0150119802,
0.007960652,
0.0260025766,
-0.0062145903,
-0.0142503427,
0.0260735545,
-0.0592898466,
0.0135044456,
-0.0237063486,
0.0291101467,
0.0147418827,
0.0840873048,
0.0002953339,
-0.0342358239,
-0.0754189938,
0.0028757213,
-0.0447341315,
0.0766931325,
0.0624761842,
-0.0010740677,
-0.0239050295,
-0.0161643177,
0.0716636181,
-0.017944606,
0.0553135201,
-0.0127318688,
-0.003567199,
-0.010946936,
0.0599232502,
0.0401828885,
0.0305327103,
-0.0100922789,
-0.0605254583,
0.0406914912,
-0.0519287102,
-0.0004679956,
0.0048109861,
0.0011327534,
-0.0155375553,
-0.0123751154,
0.0118751302,
-0.04376949,
-0.0039584981,
-0.0589987598,
0.0316978991,
0.0046455245,
-0.0075592771,
-0.0176664013,
0.0546406396,
0.0088082748,
0.0507278629,
-0.0249685701,
-0.0422594361,
-0.012054746,
-0.0092172883,
0.0604308248,
-0.0338343643,
-0.0298836641,
-0.0039132475,
0.0140686342,
0.0155545827,
-0.0076719173,
0.048466254,
0.0221264008,
-0.0283130053,
0.0154035725,
-0.016819723,
0.0200079009,
-0.0664852187,
-0.0118753873,
0.0006796917,
-0.0280443728,
-0.0068368856,
0.0399718061,
0.0504003689,
0.0118328864,
0.0066090352,
0.0041890228,
0.0437397473,
0.0135548534,
-0.0287704654,
0.0517100357,
-0.0510567166,
0.006881075,
0.0241602883,
-0.0534332432,
-0.0195887815,
0.0412879214,
2.64e-7,
0.0362749435,
0.023408087,
0.0191327408,
0.0039320216,
0.0190013759,
0.0038716847,
-0.0714854151,
0.0278211012,
-0.0014877236,
0.0647756606,
0.0505604483,
-0.0140259815,
0.0488357022,
0.021024717,
-0.0809237286,
-0.0139179435,
-0.0806859955,
0.0324572809,
-0.0554439574,
0.0242053587,
0.0247132182,
0.0833978727,
-0.0248777643,
0.0185713004,
-0.0379244424,
-0.0391065553,
0.0738056675,
0.0176538769,
-0.0254639536,
-0.0202542227,
0.0466057099,
0.027382357,
-0.0476385392,
-0.0057503842,
-0.0184293352,
-0.0036520474,
0.0679479092,
0.0691422671,
0.0031370774,
-0.0022787487,
0.0551020615,
-0.0111031812,
0.0118045956,
-0.0459901653,
0.0258413609,
-0.0160809942,
-0.0164319053,
0.0339031704,
-0.0292346813,
0.0042616301,
0.0574842133,
-0.0224600881,
-0.0094676865,
0.0037016375,
0.0402094908,
-0.0063034492,
-0.0321877114,
-0.0227032229,
-0.0392588526,
-0.024440838,
-0.0101685813,
-0.0332140476,
-0.0168892555,
0.0335799456,
0.03676451,
0.0239595734,
-0.0360729247,
1.845845718e-34,
0.0231198631,
0.008166424,
0.019298628,
-0.096048139,
0.0305114873,
-0.0152032487,
-0.0503416099,
0.0104778856,
-0.0083573097,
-0.0283566937,
-0.0628769621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.17254v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.17254v1 | Faithful Model Evaluation for Model-Based Metrics | 2023-12-19T19:41:33 | 2023-12-19T19:41:33 | Palash Goyal, Qian Hu, Rahul Gupta | cs.CL | cs.CL | Statistical significance testing is used in natural language processing (NLP)
to determine whether the results of a study or experiment are likely to be due
to chance or if they reflect a genuine relationship. A key step in significance
testing is the estimation of confidence interval which is a function of sample
variance. Sample variance calculation is straightforward when evaluating
against ground truth. However, in many cases, a metric model is often used for
evaluation. For example, to compare toxicity of two large language models, a
toxicity classifier is used for evaluation. Existing works usually do not
consider the variance change due to metric model errors, which can lead to
wrong conclusions. In this work, we establish the mathematical foundation of
significance testing for model-based metrics. With experiments on public
benchmark datasets and a production system, we show that considering metric
model errors to calculate sample variances for model-based metrics changes the
conclusions in certain experiments. | [
0.0294176377,
0.0641098768,
-0.0185537618,
-0.0071295863,
-0.0430456251,
0.025689207,
-0.0003610924,
0.0147612737,
0.0235953797,
-0.0605375506,
-0.0067331973,
0.0224377085,
0.0373295993,
0.0364189483,
-0.0029729581,
-0.0080343559,
0.040795505,
0.0132389208,
0.0168853067,
0.0095107621,
-0.0154384449,
-0.0130840782,
0.0156453028,
0.0442083962,
-0.011441295,
-0.0122475009,
0.0770374238,
-0.0052551818,
0.0118056256,
-0.0586576983,
-0.0052306852,
0.0311976429,
-0.0088300034,
0.0688168705,
0.0000015585,
-0.0725372732,
-0.0136202984,
0.0473870784,
-0.0140090464,
-0.0148958778,
0.0604979433,
0.0026333001,
0.0029354722,
0.0248302389,
-0.0069358852,
-0.0137244388,
0.0694716871,
0.0107409488,
0.0106734289,
0.0424057394,
-0.0201766212,
-0.0117775137,
0.0457355864,
-0.0036994009,
-0.0349844173,
-0.0018005359,
0.0605850928,
0.0541483648,
-0.0393872149,
-0.0248748157,
-0.0071445657,
0.0411082916,
0.0100778555,
0.012930545,
0.0084949397,
0.0291792769,
0.0165203195,
-0.0309374463,
0.0230556745,
0.0173764806,
-0.0158874877,
-0.0132734235,
-0.0055897245,
-0.0019254339,
0.0178916026,
0.032532867,
-0.0236382987,
-0.0210613068,
0.0077917986,
0.0103669688,
-0.0169893615,
0.0274996981,
0.0419462137,
0.0106721111,
0.0273017939,
0.0395531282,
0.0154113052,
-0.0421880931,
0.0140013983,
0.0108506689,
-0.0496424027,
-0.0336277075,
0.0062093288,
-0.0259404387,
-0.0207878333,
0.0022372371,
0.0102249477,
-0.0484868102,
0.0524798892,
-0.1027830243,
0.0459635928,
-0.0202904511,
-0.0212727226,
0.0322437026,
-0.0265407711,
0.0461685136,
0.0259604063,
0.0205872972,
-0.0103723472,
0.0442300849,
-0.0621343814,
0.0108178994,
0.0049617048,
-0.0226371307,
0.0177386254,
-0.0066705053,
-0.0672366545,
0.0449801162,
-0.0338310599,
0.0052344431,
0.031993784,
-0.0021172424,
-0.0065773772,
0.0398792103,
-0.0442818627,
-0.0415232293,
-0.0058594928,
0.0360471494,
-0.0499177612,
-0.0561019555,
0.0032709108,
0.0201321524,
-0.0216101818,
-0.0328920186,
0.0374524035,
0.1077484116,
0.0526152216,
-0.0278236419,
0.0054680128,
-0.0029719514,
-0.0541933626,
-0.0426227935,
-0.0720478892,
-0.0453461185,
-0.0108392499,
-0.0010992417,
0.0347074643,
-0.0514575988,
-0.0094661443,
-0.0257890448,
-0.0287486929,
0.0558272451,
0.0102137346,
0.0131162684,
-0.0073526525,
-0.0189565532,
-0.0352124237,
0.0666751638,
0.0766800717,
-0.0213942975,
0.0744953379,
-0.0082927532,
-0.0173090622,
-0.0059385509,
-0.0058204751,
0.0120715462,
-0.0404412784,
0.0150143849,
-0.004702955,
-0.0256343223,
-0.0192477796,
0.0407687873,
-0.0330653898,
0.0269898959,
0.0489783026,
0.0415383652,
0.0370276384,
-0.0176505111,
0.0464212,
-0.0334738679,
-0.030628616,
-0.0096403444,
-0.040871501,
-0.0436233692,
-0.0512479469,
0.0021332451,
0.0442659929,
0.0100818621,
0.0193268154,
-0.0791647583,
-0.0320746489,
0.0019493023,
0.0151243489,
-0.0362979211,
0.079513371,
-0.0221154951,
0.009812423,
0.0181530192,
0.028942788,
-0.0104103498,
0.011601679,
-0.0376166254,
0.013692623,
-0.0011555391,
0.0312165618,
-0.0449743271,
0.0285259485,
-0.0137399752,
-0.0524070822,
-0.0517612435,
0.0429038666,
-0.0191402677,
0.0114189275,
0.0389987603,
-0.0000273958,
0.0103854211,
0.0604977533,
-0.0329886042,
0.0001860439,
0.058116246,
0.002843301,
-0.0965390131,
-0.0809740722,
0.0596821867,
0.0162869468,
-0.0232419036,
0.0125706224,
-0.0157556981,
0.0457581915,
-0.003655347,
-0.0676424205,
0.015485107,
0.0096885227,
0.0128874509,
-0.0355025381,
-0.0151040154,
0.0681772754,
-0.0066362624,
0.0364891365,
-0.0481995307,
-0.0062913364,
0.0491892323,
-0.0201723929,
-0.0081586009,
0.0148776574,
-0.0573441125,
0.018170448,
-0.0227958299,
0.0085283741,
-0.0650527701,
0.0374108069,
-0.0655024573,
0.050701499,
0.0086286068,
0.0563676693,
-0.0665486231,
-0.0358965658,
0.0308708344,
-0.0016533842,
-0.026026791,
-0.0018645599,
-0.0136978542,
0.0137448413,
0.0447232388,
-0.017439615,
-0.029150689,
-0.0191578567,
-0.0566568524,
-0.0026093856,
-0.0147152375,
0.0214163084,
0.0104053402,
0.0000467489,
-0.0201981664,
0.0175484736,
0.0277540982,
-0.0750067383,
0.0359959565,
0.0382348187,
0.0197174363,
-0.03860493,
-0.0168646052,
-0.0482099578,
-0.033728864,
-0.0361463204,
0.0940476507,
0.0141276829,
0.0060016247,
-0.0317181088,
0.0349158123,
-0.0389121771,
-0.0163968671,
0.0390423983,
-0.0336839147,
0.0417802222,
0.0544869043,
0.0353043862,
0.0795548409,
0.0196439624,
0.0296516195,
0.0626428202,
0.0135641694,
-0.0432454199,
-0.0273594912,
-0.0585769191,
-0.0203060154,
-0.0236714017,
-0.0810863301,
0.0152670965,
0.0135606974,
0.0116670923,
-0.0422756486,
-0.0277509596,
0.0801140219,
-0.0317304656,
-0.024276197,
-0.0171936415,
-0.0178343058,
-0.002164413,
0.0527715646,
-0.0028281934,
-0.0789518505,
0.0388417989,
-0.0149349393,
0.0257445965,
-0.0477960035,
-0.0025426627,
0.0231971666,
0.0136331487,
0.0108998483,
0.0095677441,
0.0120897843,
0.0143516408,
0.03325551,
-0.0251204558,
0.0646508932,
-0.0407627858,
-0.0058233137,
-0.052719295,
0.0209076237,
0.0363601632,
0.0184757113,
-0.0362209752,
0.0211752653,
-0.031573575,
0.0052383761,
-0.0043959366,
-0.0135864094,
-0.0132981231,
0.0473489501,
0.0294416714,
-0.0263184141,
-0.0096350731,
-0.035260886,
-0.0099378778,
0.0074749943,
0.0311531946,
-0.066078566,
0.078245841,
-0.0117038293,
0.0489156023,
0.0463676639,
-0.0029207459,
0.0742032826,
-0.048126664,
0.0038965738,
-0.0194820967,
-0.0114106182,
0.009282276,
0.0284578092,
0.0215331428,
0.0111741759,
-0.0188454762,
0.0809984505,
0.0223107319,
0.0297248885,
0.0449023992,
-0.0092930691,
0.0299626924,
0.0290022623,
-0.0257694609,
-0.0093328897,
0.012954874,
0.0364342965,
0.0214377642,
-0.079847239,
-0.0331000537,
0.004295391,
-0.0474588238,
0.0184202101,
-0.0094570667,
-0.0327295214,
-0.0165726971,
-0.1157313287,
0.0485101268,
-0.0871757716,
0.0058278078,
-0.0280220099,
0.0076270401,
-0.0125003848,
0.0181612745,
-0.0347288437,
-0.1253078282,
0.0255902559,
-0.0461394526,
0.056936644,
0.0416051783,
0.0228261072,
-0.025518056,
0.0002474372,
0.0056203092,
0.0323681906,
-0.0197783206,
-0.0139546646,
0.0671491548,
0.0127893565,
-0.004186572,
-0.0317349769,
0.0018107945,
-0.0245049372,
0.0032356929,
-0.0491921119,
0.055731114,
0.0153490631,
-0.0458591245,
-0.0199678726,
-0.0100958133,
0.0163298156,
0.0834394768,
0.0240082517,
-0.0142071415,
-0.024980614,
-0.0002805597,
-0.015590216,
0.0090539167,
-0.0330480225,
-0.0042473022,
-0.0491293371,
-0.0867757499,
-0.0562941357,
0.0033345527,
-0.0097980462,
0.0277777929,
-0.0155596342,
-0.0190878268,
0.0038136553,
0.0044767433,
-0.0246920381,
0.043932911,
0.0245581996,
0.0326716006,
-0.0396530181,
0.028717421,
0.0161579344,
0.0317605808,
-0.0724226758,
0.0163848195,
-0.094361037,
-0.0669598877,
0.005181462,
0.0349452682,
0.0259479322,
-0.0086864401,
-0.0379836261,
-0.0394930132,
0.0237649996,
0.009433181,
-0.0375094526,
-0.0139766773,
0.0423102826,
-0.0646071285,
0.0213297643,
0.0007096836,
-0.0545353666,
0.0279427953,
0.0503935181,
0.0178031214,
-0.0458918735,
-0.026563121,
0.0208729804,
0.0381306447,
0.0704073012,
0.0032089292,
-0.0253522377,
-0.003304888,
-0.0315623842,
-0.0206094813,
-0.0332787596,
-0.0062422757,
0.010454759,
0.0212569255,
0.0480399504,
-0.0751844123,
-0.0085652471,
-0.0643524081,
0.0146920932,
-0.0198033508,
0.0049134046,
0.0372245908,
0.0307451915,
0.0517251454,
0.004484063,
-0.0255368464,
-0.0414256491,
0.0036844516,
0.0156662259,
0.0106318677,
-0.0402877219,
-0.0058699618,
0.0288943909,
0.0010810719,
0.0268513691,
-0.0585030317,
-0.0134480959,
-0.0327320173,
-0.031768322,
0.0043889219,
-0.0123051787,
0.0453730747,
-0.0404612757,
0.0009517144,
-0.0627575815,
-0.0001425445,
0.0087907435,
0.0055058319,
-0.0066297748,
0.0128345145,
-0.0257544145,
0.0360881425,
0.0660031363,
0.0006012009,
0.0271010716,
-0.0736735016,
-0.0760144442,
-0.0167687293,
-0.0102955615,
0.0088544572,
0.0000941522,
-0.0205377862,
0.0035832052,
-0.0466370173,
-0.0961799473,
0.0387357324,
0.0215697028,
0.0715898201,
0.0382534191,
-0.0446853749,
0.0600783601,
0.0197248627,
0.0094358325,
-0.0458590649,
-0.0392842144,
0.0370120592,
-0.0031529525,
-0.0427744836,
-5.626921011e-33,
0.0184355751,
-0.036916025,
-0.0665565804,
-0.0232847854,
-0.0025471558,
-0.0185703468,
0.0198819041,
-0.005252555,
-0.0254437923,
0.0193307828,
0.0225401036,
0.0211021993,
0.0019986932,
-0.0204275306,
0.0185148437,
-0.0200942382,
0.0027952595,
0.0105580455,
-0.0184681658,
-0.0226309467,
0.0433502235,
0.0125120338,
0.0587570183,
-0.0813682079,
0.0740191415,
0.0738039538,
-0.0221797023,
0.0148625979,
-0.0171057079,
0.0680356845,
0.0091359643,
0.0815415382,
0.0182115566,
-0.0068124374,
-0.0100233546,
-0.0214283857,
-0.0120464657,
-0.011497098,
0.0289543271,
-0.00147364,
-0.0021619808,
0.0339799486,
0.0491378643,
0.0151128834,
-0.0711341426,
-0.0238312185,
0.0521786697,
-0.0652696714,
-0.0087192301,
-0.0209845901,
-0.0321450196,
0.0202696826,
-0.0373036787,
0.0097565223,
-0.0006809819,
0.0199306272,
0.0026458856,
0.0244172961,
0.0153208124,
0.0042967536,
0.0238750521,
-0.0019067435,
0.0260854252,
0.0129488492,
0.0335482471,
0.062514551,
0.0160870682,
-0.0047193342,
0.0190015789,
-0.0153632239,
0.0484540351,
-0.0060415789,
0.0386401527,
0.0518922284,
0.0194770042,
-0.005805965,
-0.085963279,
0.014933425,
-0.0141849387,
0.039803192,
0.0289036967,
-0.009939407,
-0.062815994,
-0.0138971936,
-0.0437284,
-0.0581275076,
-0.0450658277,
-0.0110938698,
0.0104562128,
-0.0178480484,
-0.020305248,
-0.0190346595,
-0.0097798621,
-0.0369604044,
-0.0190382879,
-0.0222709533,
0.0117894709,
0.0115611199,
0.0080128377,
0.0050639561,
0.0120830778,
0.0046734931,
0.0028000076,
0.0521525629,
0.052011054,
-0.0417859405,
0.0421840549,
-0.0021018619,
-0.0551537685,
0.0256579742,
0.0033709812,
-0.012096581,
0.0466879793,
-0.006031774,
0.0119138937,
0.0024038472,
-0.0091948705,
0.0506119356,
0.0394647829,
0.0030257173,
-0.0239229612,
0.0162513144,
-0.0274634641,
0.0134965423,
-0.0101022879,
-0.0492585674,
-0.0262122937,
0.0296748895,
0.0501454547,
-0.023015894,
-0.0026247906,
-0.0567465946,
2.56e-7,
0.0700985789,
0.0442806222,
-0.020100113,
0.0298639219,
0.0116636967,
0.0140729658,
-0.0321346782,
0.0415635146,
0.017947197,
-0.0200495683,
0.0216712207,
-0.0375208743,
0.0261659939,
0.0195823964,
0.0277576167,
0.0069689434,
-0.1058842018,
0.0213143807,
-0.0234900545,
0.0254632067,
0.0470014848,
0.0579053462,
0.0496360883,
0.0076113311,
-0.0111980177,
-0.0284365565,
0.0140320119,
-0.04285229,
0.0215377416,
0.0557297468,
0.0784781724,
0.0001636825,
0.0516261943,
0.0504941903,
-0.0252508093,
-0.03023782,
0.0224196315,
-0.0076615508,
-0.0221798383,
0.0346099362,
-0.0136923073,
-0.0395741053,
0.0243087485,
-0.0487555154,
0.0601699464,
-0.011155244,
-0.017493343,
-0.0658315569,
-0.0276627354,
-0.0104476167,
0.0826137885,
-0.0162804071,
-0.0391799994,
0.0142319063,
-0.0070306566,
0.0523357913,
-0.0056119789,
-0.0298716519,
0.0015380004,
-0.0175033808,
-0.023056021,
-0.0960981324,
0.0271669645,
0.0005315434,
0.0244106036,
-0.0266446099,
-0.0014176067,
2.365529475e-34,
0.0511382818,
0.0145742642,
0.0199190434,
-0.0130956359,
0.0500788167,
0.0116845872,
0.0291357189,
-0.0294853915,
-0.0075297458,
-0.0878540128,
-0.001146702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12436v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12436v2 | A Challenger to GPT-4V? Early Explorations of Gemini in Visual Expertise | 2023-12-19T18:59:22 | 2023-12-20T12:40:47 | Chaoyou Fu, Renrui Zhang, Zihan Wang, Yubo Huang, Zhengye Zhang, Longtian Qiu, Gaoxiang Ye, Yunhang Shen, Mengdan Zhang, Peixian Chen, Sirui Zhao, Shaohui Lin, Deqiang Jiang, Di Yin, Peng Gao, Ke Li, Hongsheng Li, Xing Sun | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM | The surge of interest towards Multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs),
e.g., GPT-4V(ision) from OpenAI, has marked a significant trend in both
academia and industry. They endow Large Language Models (LLMs) with powerful
capabilities in visual understanding, enabling them to tackle diverse
multi-modal tasks. Very recently, Google released Gemini, its newest and most
capable MLLM built from the ground up for multi-modality. In light of the
superior reasoning capabilities, can Gemini challenge GPT-4V's leading position
in multi-modal learning? In this paper, we present a preliminary exploration of
Gemini Pro's visual understanding proficiency, which comprehensively covers
four domains: fundamental perception, advanced cognition, challenging vision
tasks, and various expert capacities. We compare Gemini Pro with the
state-of-the-art GPT-4V to evaluate its upper limits, along with the latest
open-sourced MLLM, Sphinx, which reveals the gap between manual efforts and
black-box systems. The qualitative samples indicate that, while GPT-4V and
Gemini showcase different answering styles and preferences, they can exhibit
comparable visual reasoning capabilities, and Sphinx still trails behind them
concerning domain generalizability. Specifically, GPT-4V tends to elaborate
detailed explanations and intermediate steps, and Gemini prefers to output a
direct and concise answer. The quantitative evaluation on the popular MME
benchmark also demonstrates the potential of Gemini to be a strong challenger
to GPT-4V. Our early investigation of Gemini also observes some common issues
of MLLMs, indicating that there still remains a considerable distance towards
artificial general intelligence. Our project for tracking the progress of MLLM
is released at
https://github.com/BradyFU/Awesome-Multimodal-Large-Language-Models. | [
0.0352392904,
0.0606118292,
-0.0136350635,
0.038884975,
-0.0404976457,
0.0074167699,
0.0102635669,
-0.0103257615,
-0.0311603993,
-0.05935077,
-0.0355586335,
-0.0143655231,
-0.0263216812,
0.0917039961,
0.001291659,
-0.080408968,
0.0318580531,
-0.0518730208,
0.0217276718,
-0.0226040296,
-0.0019887814,
0.0244343374,
-0.0347466096,
0.0515826792,
-0.0033891785,
-0.0379670747,
-0.0375547893,
-0.0127395419,
0.0188101418,
0.0092957132,
-0.0411516167,
0.0322239213,
0.0547992326,
0.0426594317,
0.0000019584,
-0.0547776073,
0.0072254371,
0.0144203948,
0.0123750456,
-0.0027058809,
0.0049954937,
-0.0252632201,
0.0350636542,
0.0138805844,
-0.0606253333,
-0.0349657126,
0.0398860909,
0.0483350903,
0.0658575594,
0.0549629144,
-0.008953549,
-0.0037774136,
0.0486838408,
-0.0074024601,
-0.0230300352,
-0.0791734904,
0.0040624239,
0.0211425461,
0.0134086013,
0.0018718152,
-0.0307051502,
0.0376245454,
0.0568166077,
-0.0024225398,
-0.0511499085,
0.0593696311,
-0.0200317502,
-0.0366451815,
-0.0380609408,
0.0495034121,
0.030648699,
-0.0031211453,
-0.031607464,
0.0113242324,
-0.0002767018,
0.0176935103,
-0.0525653884,
0.0459841974,
-0.0101567013,
-0.0024585398,
-0.0337573774,
-0.0370490402,
0.0017114179,
0.0089764921,
-0.0368718468,
0.0431232825,
0.01847996,
0.0190385599,
-0.0001601333,
0.012682545,
-0.0501599088,
-0.0372016095,
-0.0499957949,
0.070648998,
-0.024330819,
-0.0092930496,
-0.0288061574,
0.0039110971,
-0.0110759633,
0.0259710848,
0.0107983872,
0.0425113551,
-0.0582095906,
0.0518555082,
-0.010707519,
0.0633554012,
-0.0227315407,
0.0610591024,
-0.0229285751,
-0.0578475408,
-0.0678392798,
-0.0239740275,
-0.0388983861,
-0.0040731127,
-0.0369030535,
-0.0452315845,
-0.0044648037,
0.0244791098,
-0.024764657,
0.0029520264,
-0.0040852386,
0.0372298509,
-0.010691585,
-0.0379154347,
-0.0562899411,
0.0583399907,
-0.0405397825,
0.0226560887,
0.0090718735,
-0.0675078705,
0.0227363203,
0.0385833234,
-0.0060480684,
-0.0228385888,
0.0096704587,
0.0897000656,
-0.034374658,
-0.0178744495,
-0.0242611375,
-0.0213189237,
-0.0071170246,
-0.0981594473,
0.0313028321,
-0.0515696257,
-0.0048670946,
0.0259741731,
0.0007741166,
-0.0085288072,
-0.006883835,
0.0003605944,
-0.0108109517,
0.0631789789,
-0.0178011451,
-0.0033077267,
0.0350742415,
0.0256927386,
-0.0394867919,
0.0742968321,
0.0187067986,
0.0142685007,
0.0201858375,
-0.0071363631,
0.0366749726,
0.0175006762,
-0.0290911701,
0.0004623604,
-0.0347679816,
0.0291413777,
-0.010267674,
0.0321355313,
0.0266865678,
0.0492471159,
-0.009407429,
-0.0307360943,
0.081178613,
0.0171463415,
-0.0008693006,
0.0289427843,
0.0549683087,
0.0041550421,
0.0252412874,
0.0170237981,
-0.0593131296,
0.0594440773,
-0.0337024555,
0.0059409989,
-0.0373256989,
0.0310405698,
-0.0193071533,
-0.034477137,
-0.0039552776,
0.0159050357,
-0.0202973336,
0.0284446888,
0.0823654905,
-0.0333983488,
-0.0082737226,
-0.0130991554,
0.0133478614,
-0.0145017924,
-0.0186568499,
-0.0921628326,
0.0201979373,
0.0345444158,
0.0191235337,
-0.0140857473,
-0.0308723077,
-0.0157974474,
-0.0031906127,
0.0381283127,
0.0500029027,
0.0058328812,
0.0122329658,
-0.0438702404,
-0.0158703588,
-0.0589997061,
-0.0021125008,
0.0305106323,
-0.0067715258,
0.0130936541,
-0.014816341,
-0.017426718,
0.0375655666,
0.0210581943,
0.0418426394,
0.0100493431,
-0.0353076681,
0.0191843491,
0.0164997689,
0.0005032867,
-0.0075439699,
-0.0010040948,
0.0248407237,
-0.0121082999,
-0.002539586,
0.0104883602,
-0.0112738023,
-0.003708204,
0.0485532098,
-0.0953432322,
-0.0304554999,
0.0746525452,
-0.0345022269,
-0.0463751815,
0.0193020068,
-0.00748506,
0.0236756615,
-0.0491046607,
-0.0323057696,
0.009737161,
0.0051401304,
-0.0112233944,
0.0748358294,
0.0055129225,
-0.0084979497,
0.0292584598,
0.0184020139,
0.0267715864,
-0.0338707492,
-0.0248738229,
0.0289098043,
0.0020907698,
0.0152420262,
-0.014027602,
0.0008438742,
-0.0500701107,
-0.0082004378,
-0.1166033298,
-0.0156872347,
-0.0339860767,
-0.0246765353,
0.0197399035,
-0.0082732281,
-0.0079223085,
-0.0194412991,
-0.0196867473,
0.0219766237,
0.024888128,
-0.0019760462,
0.033883363,
0.0269974582,
-0.0143365972,
0.0100175627,
-0.0064761066,
-0.0361946821,
0.0248944126,
0.0313965008,
0.0074461857,
-0.0167425964,
-0.0115240468,
-0.0324316025,
0.0450379662,
-0.0341809355,
-0.0098923566,
0.0543372259,
-0.0508855991,
0.0132332295,
0.0865924656,
0.0190514512,
0.0529378951,
0.0378249884,
-0.0049027232,
-0.0172372237,
0.0460418202,
-0.0042287768,
-0.0557878241,
-0.0486013778,
0.0092545096,
-0.0315546021,
0.0240891483,
-0.0342907794,
-0.0154885696,
-0.0656788275,
0.0328302644,
0.0156952646,
-0.048628293,
-0.0398320444,
0.0391223133,
0.0063343607,
0.0406130515,
-0.0174325425,
-0.0706935301,
0.0631781295,
-0.0201517213,
-0.0119954776,
-0.0031998658,
-0.0193532649,
-0.0451431125,
0.0977668464,
0.0004544932,
0.0370711125,
0.0030695158,
-0.0204879511,
-0.0808669776,
0.0088901287,
0.0090403184,
0.0087305671,
0.080366008,
-0.0893051922,
0.0061928625,
-0.0350808054,
-0.0321714282,
-0.0121703977,
0.000235956,
-0.066229105,
0.0408042632,
-0.0018875507,
-0.0381793417,
-0.0519151017,
0.0102251088,
0.0087074386,
0.0004685881,
-0.0141128255,
-0.0075040995,
-0.0308971927,
0.0337092653,
0.0770478621,
0.0944789499,
0.0032848779,
-0.0394983105,
-0.0175126344,
0.0619359873,
0.023643503,
-0.0063017481,
-0.0398234688,
0.0272743925,
0.0281760376,
-0.0050631096,
-0.0258101486,
0.0277969092,
0.040917702,
-0.0638841167,
0.0031013794,
0.0838075951,
0.0013994001,
-0.0486402735,
-0.0273480583,
0.0054692794,
0.0356326289,
0.0296046957,
0.0322571099,
-0.0861730948,
-0.0470234007,
-0.0125631187,
-0.0036057662,
0.0080197183,
0.0012685745,
-0.013038056,
-0.0859593824,
0.070539698,
-0.0443247221,
-0.0399953797,
0.0060249744,
0.0062923841,
-0.0201495066,
-0.0099922912,
-0.0036952065,
-0.0016643256,
-0.0038936236,
-0.018854389,
0.0237714518,
0.0178426839,
-0.0228918754,
0.0350488536,
-0.0302543025,
-0.0072468789,
0.0113411816,
0.0195273906,
-0.0367845446,
-0.0656843334,
-0.0184680633,
0.0051768497,
0.0293270797,
0.007782633,
0.0466662683,
-0.0254075155,
-0.0232312735,
-0.0182213336,
0.0350364707,
-0.0063881367,
-0.0044391863,
-0.0026627642,
0.051649224,
-0.0245129373,
-0.01418343,
-0.0448278151,
-0.007149566,
-0.0485916846,
0.0583931506,
-0.004181311,
-0.0105577167,
-0.0855801776,
-0.0285372511,
0.0005273369,
-0.0152074816,
-0.0250070784,
0.0269770008,
0.05592959,
-0.0187487043,
-0.0279039107,
-0.0335059762,
0.0581074394,
0.0748558193,
-0.0256418567,
-0.0148357227,
-0.0436263718,
0.0454989634,
-0.0347781219,
0.0575667843,
0.0042258585,
0.0170752276,
-0.0774233639,
-0.0126434928,
0.0172466282,
-0.0614539646,
-0.0305348877,
0.0285050906,
-0.0608227886,
-0.0383263789,
-0.0196980089,
0.0488459729,
0.0346381254,
0.0183837023,
0.0008131992,
-0.0427996553,
0.0152128451,
0.0020841644,
0.0103350524,
0.0107207913,
0.0117829526,
-0.016219411,
-0.0064893924,
0.0240361877,
-0.0250554234,
-0.0059542381,
0.0005490662,
0.0198182147,
0.0099173971,
0.0104472945,
0.0233779103,
0.0177692063,
0.041783642,
-0.0100305565,
0.012399137,
-0.0206724051,
0.010784219,
0.0081699826,
0.0004667934,
-0.0527661182,
0.0064677196,
0.0197331794,
0.0156028094,
0.0192140918,
0.014727571,
0.0218127575,
-0.0137561439,
-0.0384386703,
-0.0017089926,
0.0605311096,
-0.0117381634,
0.0086804135,
-0.0028339061,
-0.025164675,
-0.0158621538,
0.0124721816,
0.0577904098,
0.0118453139,
0.115123935,
0.0362324156,
-0.0317977853,
0.0008817044,
0.0232569892,
-0.094469294,
-0.1119749695,
0.0097237062,
0.0902016163,
0.0820225477,
0.031307824,
0.0214642771,
-0.0389684252,
-0.0151133155,
-0.0206681807,
0.0229879804,
0.0328892842,
-0.027709268,
0.0580970645,
0.0310164168,
-0.0041587162,
-0.0066519296,
0.0805824623,
0.020574091,
0.0363227241,
-0.0090951743,
-0.0082660448,
-0.0259838514,
-0.0433881395,
0.0360434875,
0.0277690832,
0.0101962676,
0.0168954115,
-0.0621335804,
-0.0579000637,
-0.0051353672,
0.0289235897,
-0.0132284379,
-0.0165855512,
0.0313352831,
0.058127936,
0.0120846499,
-0.0762134343,
-0.0306744017,
-0.0061865542,
-0.0062680305,
0.0359447338,
0.0078032296,
-6.168663745e-33,
-0.0227937829,
-0.0234519485,
0.0599639341,
-0.0057240915,
0.0045407433,
0.0012779582,
-0.0103916759,
0.0063552582,
-0.0567780547,
0.0437558591,
0.0032358454,
-0.0081259245,
0.0001845483,
0.0303198956,
0.0165940486,
-0.0270656031,
0.0043829782,
0.0100062443,
-0.0202353261,
0.0151414406,
0.0336254351,
0.0055313203,
0.0426765345,
-0.0267273318,
-0.010421467,
0.0025364747,
-0.0192765296,
0.0309864916,
-0.0779728666,
0.0865603015,
-0.0191448238,
0.0253444351,
0.0343007892,
0.0127584022,
0.0054482068,
0.0069188476,
-0.0519078337,
-0.0134376744,
0.0054491553,
0.021376146,
-0.0938904881,
0.0135816094,
0.0272040684,
0.0000222572,
0.0024866983,
-0.0380540453,
0.0651130453,
-0.0054023103,
0.0045981789,
-0.010711316,
-0.0458341688,
0.0071007949,
-0.0119448463,
-0.0101125883,
-0.0002450668,
0.0282093044,
-0.0043872646,
0.0285553038,
-0.003156495,
0.0164387301,
-0.0066865776,
-0.0172831584,
0.1007914394,
0.0186342932,
0.0115200765,
0.0450256392,
0.0425179526,
-0.0553582199,
-0.0126943002,
-0.0478660055,
0.0234183781,
0.1033634692,
0.0320915878,
0.0316088311,
-0.021384906,
0.0353958048,
-0.0628788471,
0.0075254724,
-0.010431054,
0.0690982491,
-0.0031990188,
0.0029393856,
-0.0186029859,
0.0132623455,
-0.0205474347,
0.0018065826,
-0.0421220437,
-0.0056348955,
0.0560715683,
-0.0006164152,
-0.0062519116,
0.0314834192,
0.0523157828,
-0.0647751242,
-0.002042318,
-0.0164662562,
-0.0408868231,
0.0562426634,
0.0095580416,
0.0582031645,
-0.0309473258,
-0.0057845088,
0.0116471313,
-0.0179373492,
-0.0053803027,
-0.0007854689,
0.0231162608,
0.0287377611,
-0.0289581697,
0.0046981531,
-0.0641210228,
0.0015567491,
-0.0029281967,
-0.0028866795,
0.0505108945,
-0.0146319531,
-0.0231821761,
0.0098837782,
-0.0141087426,
0.0141646853,
-0.0371119864,
-0.0423841327,
0.0056107626,
-0.0110119386,
-0.0183358137,
-0.0099493265,
-0.0308314431,
-0.0683422834,
0.0059326864,
-0.0539180003,
-0.0140668284,
0.0576203652,
2.607e-7,
0.048176311,
0.0316671133,
0.0115406923,
0.0051383958,
0.0296598133,
0.0446521267,
-0.0330955945,
0.0205702614,
0.0112582641,
0.0120384563,
-0.0156947467,
0.0528954826,
0.0206091162,
0.0426516309,
-0.0199024919,
0.0266713835,
-0.0052439915,
-0.0411931463,
-0.0673363283,
0.0377996974,
0.076018624,
0.0441665128,
-0.0232311059,
-0.0110574011,
0.0585711598,
-0.0725202933,
0.0832601786,
-0.0263821632,
0.0009679004,
0.0118297571,
0.032196369,
0.0322809331,
-0.0086419629,
0.0378688201,
0.0244733877,
-0.0090341065,
0.0374721475,
0.0696461797,
-0.0138392262,
-0.0430387817,
-0.0082556326,
-0.0000913976,
0.0199270733,
-0.0682778135,
0.0922240615,
-0.0292018596,
-0.03828777,
-0.0309279021,
-0.0343036875,
-0.0430535935,
-0.0055474504,
-0.0062129013,
-0.0116209248,
0.0114139579,
-0.0042544804,
-0.0447952487,
-0.028329663,
-0.0845154151,
0.0176507849,
-0.0071898103,
-0.0573079474,
-0.0279394127,
-0.0487426259,
-0.0195247382,
0.0783382058,
-0.0119511988,
-0.0466071256,
2.140829597e-34,
0.0241781902,
-0.0184745044,
0.0095813666,
0.0336713344,
0.0125368927,
0.0117004644,
-0.0199733321,
-0.019137362,
0.0005348389,
-0.0727772862,
-0.0159937851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12430v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12430v3 | Efficient Title Reranker for Fast and Improved Knowledge-Intense NLP | 2023-12-19T18:56:52 | 2024-02-25T21:51:21 | Ziyi Chen, Jize Jiang, Daqian Zuo, Heyi Tao, Jun Yang, Yuxiang Wei | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In recent RAG approaches, rerankers play a pivotal role in refining retrieval
accuracy with the ability of revealing logical relations for each pair of query
and text. However, existing rerankers are required to repeatedly encode the
query and a large number of long retrieved text. This results in high
computational costs and limits the number of retrieved text, hindering
accuracy. As a remedy of the problem, we introduce the Efficient Title Reranker
via Broadcasting Query Encoder, a novel technique for title reranking that
achieves a 20x-40x speedup over the vanilla passage reranker. Furthermore, we
introduce Sigmoid Trick, a novel loss function customized for title reranking.
Combining both techniques, we empirically validated their effectiveness,
achieving state-of-the-art results on all four datasets we experimented with
from the KILT knowledge benchmark. | [
0.0338747799,
0.0587377958,
0.0012743731,
0.0391852334,
0.0119186863,
0.008657054,
-0.0345773175,
0.0156849865,
0.0262662023,
-0.0360074937,
0.0109473681,
0.0341349393,
-0.0314350314,
0.0218458418,
-0.0150440969,
-0.047234796,
0.0286533386,
0.0216099098,
0.0248591155,
-0.0135393525,
0.0062999967,
0.0105056912,
-0.0079491585,
0.0001512023,
-0.0022163228,
0.0134969093,
-0.0154337771,
0.0168502089,
0.0198959634,
-0.0457033552,
0.037374042,
0.0330614597,
0.025573099,
0.0106868055,
0.0000019784,
-0.0421462096,
-0.0453536436,
-0.0085168444,
-0.0047675464,
0.0115515487,
0.0288351551,
-0.0297279377,
0.0423375778,
0.0278696641,
-0.0314302407,
0.0062860362,
0.0227715317,
0.0503278896,
0.0470140874,
0.0761738941,
-0.0074996687,
-0.0503655188,
0.016048789,
-0.0480216034,
0.0208867285,
-0.0735522211,
0.0133177824,
-0.0007171223,
-0.0212433953,
0.0317204073,
-0.0114053544,
0.0360305943,
0.0240633506,
-0.0048754141,
0.0348847061,
0.0155103393,
-0.0760374591,
0.0257829987,
-0.0086144917,
0.0719644651,
-0.0559917316,
-0.0117864665,
0.0111156357,
0.039539203,
0.0026513562,
0.0054960232,
-0.0244033001,
-0.0128744254,
0.0169440955,
0.0101808542,
-0.0049380241,
0.0685240999,
0.0162783116,
0.0103221927,
-0.0388615169,
0.0717993379,
0.0140993828,
-0.0286480449,
0.0120642819,
0.033279635,
0.0124888206,
-0.0225308016,
0.0244170092,
-0.0043613659,
-0.0171558373,
0.0233627297,
-0.012139665,
-0.0066631953,
-0.0099939927,
-0.0640403479,
-0.0647579879,
-0.0122045437,
0.037543539,
0.0522565432,
-0.039284192,
0.0402213521,
0.0574378297,
0.0287102386,
-0.0362379812,
-0.0201665703,
-0.0388947688,
-0.0504756644,
-0.0239525996,
0.0479865968,
-0.0420528911,
-0.0206689406,
-0.0335506126,
-0.0224436559,
-0.0111131566,
-0.0032576066,
-0.0401886962,
0.0363583751,
-0.021440886,
-0.014839327,
-0.0503693148,
0.0434737988,
-0.0151284719,
-0.0373709202,
0.0118942177,
-0.0056318115,
-0.018538015,
-0.02866848,
-0.0047896402,
0.0148838181,
0.0125990473,
0.0035675985,
-0.0690312311,
-0.0195270926,
0.0204230398,
-0.0589387566,
-0.0234122388,
0.0020682586,
-0.0044828956,
-0.0488546714,
0.0789178684,
0.009779349,
0.0012852225,
-0.0079737594,
0.032446593,
0.0307498351,
-0.0446155518,
0.0468237996,
0.0275101848,
-0.024147369,
0.0047932067,
0.0545819961,
0.0391820855,
0.0431406759,
-0.0132715302,
0.0478833877,
0.0659305304,
0.0295337792,
-0.002263166,
-0.0106594861,
0.0241183173,
-0.0178481396,
0.0255920794,
0.0225690696,
-0.0088037858,
0.0313232541,
0.0536764339,
0.0093157217,
-0.027345188,
-0.0372049622,
0.03820749,
-0.0021583906,
0.0360676646,
-0.0091017112,
-0.0605488196,
0.0414697453,
-0.0047290944,
0.0062492127,
-0.0009305811,
0.0087642604,
0.001440928,
0.0029035555,
0.0486244708,
0.0261098053,
-0.0148772364,
-0.0603609793,
0.0052886801,
0.0132873124,
-0.0074842377,
0.0365307964,
0.0108335167,
0.0281294603,
0.0263814423,
0.0619177632,
0.04005263,
-0.0263825059,
0.0216689184,
-0.0077339793,
-0.0392310172,
0.0592557602,
0.0637395382,
-0.0700525865,
-0.017213542,
0.0287079681,
0.0164083838,
-0.0065713492,
0.0277420823,
-0.0259206444,
0.0367628112,
-0.0393754356,
-0.0087024514,
0.0038922869,
0.0390746184,
0.0167152863,
0.0196681116,
0.0234467201,
0.0260176193,
-0.0562945791,
-0.0406776853,
0.0108954888,
0.0457886159,
-0.027972281,
0.0490454249,
-0.0172696505,
-0.0163180195,
0.0184524413,
-0.0127942897,
0.0120934676,
0.0414325595,
-0.0529806688,
-0.0794004053,
0.0027185222,
-0.0436317995,
-0.0878274217,
0.0001955528,
-0.0796306506,
-0.003699345,
0.080921784,
-0.0609858781,
-0.0293426737,
-0.0374103375,
-0.0205462202,
0.0118916538,
-0.0229551941,
0.0109543437,
0.0146481292,
-0.0293356925,
-0.089350611,
0.0769053474,
-0.008525759,
0.0258462392,
-0.0074124676,
-0.0645373464,
-0.019134827,
-0.0214548148,
-0.0452771559,
0.0466993079,
-0.0210897326,
0.0007019193,
0.0350800566,
-0.027303135,
-0.0471597426,
-0.0272314511,
-0.076193735,
0.0218221303,
-0.003332224,
-0.018751502,
0.021001149,
0.0199176967,
0.0082216989,
-0.0233243462,
-0.0655604601,
-0.0815609023,
-0.0239693597,
0.0110320309,
0.0232614502,
-0.0102300243,
0.0347648747,
0.0057002758,
-0.055663541,
-0.0071520535,
0.070957154,
-0.0043375515,
0.0180562232,
-0.0184168424,
-0.0162583087,
-0.0514227785,
0.0059309318,
-0.0311309192,
0.011974684,
-0.0193069205,
0.0085767005,
0.0130825909,
0.0271228757,
0.0534546115,
0.0400164202,
0.037138775,
0.0103341946,
-0.0409489833,
0.0122922305,
-0.043832507,
-0.0170537606,
0.0121224178,
-0.0180888548,
0.0314254016,
-0.0077623283,
0.0044707409,
-0.01499137,
-0.0275820363,
-0.0003801419,
-0.0341747254,
-0.0199534688,
-0.0968849212,
0.0238691904,
0.0190869477,
0.0074267015,
-0.0312046632,
-0.0042072046,
0.0416607745,
0.0003147286,
0.0000216336,
-0.0765033737,
0.0101522021,
-0.0416052043,
0.0682273507,
-0.0115483999,
0.0487843007,
-0.0382474251,
-0.0535415635,
-0.0036894791,
0.0381659754,
0.0097222179,
-0.0718970373,
0.0081583569,
-0.0089729335,
-0.0028876164,
-0.0017929489,
-0.0818680823,
-0.0103480248,
-0.011831088,
0.0464288108,
-0.0100348834,
0.0225153696,
0.0149883069,
-0.0434129722,
0.0026508886,
0.0333451368,
0.0180946868,
-0.032061398,
-0.0181384385,
0.01988375,
0.0789129138,
0.0661601722,
0.0096860807,
-0.0197882019,
0.0054066516,
0.0225363784,
0.0862481818,
0.0449955277,
-0.0040896926,
0.0368152671,
-0.0164995231,
0.0288645681,
-0.0719287917,
-0.0044108965,
-0.0183578227,
0.030994039,
-0.0626864135,
0.0125232274,
0.1082805917,
0.0613389313,
-0.0403506421,
-0.0016244228,
0.0123287216,
0.0354626589,
0.0320888236,
0.0413511954,
-0.0924627855,
-0.0231496375,
0.0079497425,
0.0286501944,
0.0090069603,
-0.0506768748,
0.016300302,
-0.1026421413,
0.024462834,
-0.0019930946,
-0.0198049694,
-0.0096138939,
-0.0615388118,
-0.0194756463,
-0.0206211451,
-0.0383507125,
0.0509058796,
-0.0148052555,
0.0223479215,
0.0127866296,
-0.0226336624,
-0.008327161,
0.0337395482,
-0.0461959615,
-0.001871658,
0.0011205048,
0.0415456928,
-0.022852527,
0.0045231907,
-0.054994259,
-0.0189101584,
-0.0043409164,
-0.0068266373,
0.0792368874,
-0.0556582734,
0.00935008,
-0.0349141434,
0.0115869408,
0.0085755587,
0.0294185728,
-0.0020268001,
0.0141421035,
-0.0000382252,
-0.0026383321,
-0.0327966586,
-0.0271853656,
-0.0304270498,
0.0692330673,
-0.0287324935,
0.0234665181,
-0.0575155132,
-0.0408197716,
0.0582933836,
0.0057952683,
-0.0325753726,
0.0150001766,
0.005593535,
-0.0028447574,
-0.0831319243,
-0.0346425101,
0.0063226959,
0.0338999629,
-0.0046017622,
0.0262563378,
0.0160064679,
-0.0317287222,
-0.125325352,
-0.0292571671,
-0.0264145471,
-0.0314731263,
0.0103768725,
0.0157119837,
0.0434396006,
0.0003623867,
-0.0489386469,
-0.0094051668,
0.0014698132,
-0.0502854623,
-0.0258629899,
-0.0035024551,
0.0168986563,
0.0420055166,
-0.0286948811,
-0.0409760214,
0.0508489944,
0.0562703833,
-0.0320529677,
0.0062241144,
0.0131531814,
-0.0037149678,
-0.0094241267,
0.0343428105,
-0.0534074791,
0.0130971903,
-0.0574640222,
0.0557770506,
-0.0047780881,
0.0554651991,
0.0232182499,
0.0271737017,
0.0322592258,
0.0100478316,
-0.0349094458,
-0.0377303101,
0.0558573902,
-0.057568796,
-0.0337800235,
-0.0167637598,
0.0620110035,
0.0323144235,
0.0385210998,
-0.0040803198,
-0.0200919881,
0.0417319946,
-0.0005463909,
-0.0493469089,
-0.0350975469,
0.027022332,
-0.0562099181,
0.0055010519,
0.0119346241,
-0.0356784165,
0.0261146873,
0.0332920738,
0.0518670641,
-0.0364995375,
-0.0437811986,
0.0619963706,
-0.0068314997,
-0.0395055339,
0.0454887934,
-0.093475163,
-0.0243813917,
-0.0270860922,
-0.0060087028,
0.0531416759,
-0.0235344376,
0.0211485904,
0.0129184891,
-0.0205847472,
0.0108416723,
-0.0163113829,
0.0105609763,
-0.0665645301,
-0.005676833,
0.0440713391,
-0.0195756536,
0.0412496701,
0.0987615362,
0.0186069757,
0.0284128767,
0.0125722308,
-0.0707602352,
-0.0157798287,
-0.0262012072,
0.0418731198,
0.0807783231,
0.0092568425,
-0.016650755,
-5.609e-7,
-0.017627988,
0.0162341222,
-0.0379345901,
0.0418574922,
-0.0223304462,
0.0460303053,
0.0608087592,
0.0259122476,
-0.0436959192,
-0.0533097796,
-0.0404343121,
-0.0564139262,
-0.0449372604,
0.0156366825,
-6.404523748e-33,
0.0045146709,
-0.0174620524,
-0.024952488,
-0.0083301673,
-0.0376290753,
0.0376714058,
-0.0075239302,
-0.0078402637,
-0.0138239907,
0.0370846502,
-0.0118921772,
0.0185871702,
0.0113368044,
0.044111155,
0.0152197964,
-0.0210569352,
0.0177472737,
0.0146903293,
-0.0289127361,
0.0143739991,
0.0460688807,
0.0511359535,
0.0074390648,
-0.0207853131,
-0.002149614,
-0.0062704245,
-0.0087062847,
0.0156174526,
0.0207869802,
0.0130490297,
0.0148925139,
0.0393899046,
0.055231899,
-0.0786244571,
0.0258127544,
-0.0037942845,
-0.0915960521,
-0.0312157106,
-0.0397208631,
-0.0051106093,
-0.0185375605,
0.0364072397,
0.0659667477,
0.0154709732,
0.0229520798,
-0.0623366237,
0.0219019428,
-0.0138724847,
-0.0455247462,
-0.0705344677,
0.0036862835,
0.0156192472,
-0.0247813575,
-0.0105484137,
0.0223829206,
-0.0019890047,
0.0230254587,
-0.000174976,
-0.0436419472,
0.0060995189,
-0.0168417376,
0.0938829929,
0.0107263811,
-0.0190882348,
-0.031087935,
0.0697852224,
0.0318909138,
-0.0197333172,
0.0079766242,
0.0548738874,
0.0109837679,
0.0357558243,
0.0554143637,
-0.0165036805,
0.0660565197,
-0.0096042808,
-0.0642727315,
0.0500485636,
0.0397305265,
-0.0103766015,
-0.0163524989,
0.0388729535,
-0.0582264476,
-0.0395800136,
-0.0439647026,
0.0407515578,
-0.0250424314,
-0.0115846451,
0.0405626781,
0.0308205858,
-0.0034271767,
0.0298667587,
-0.0246047135,
-0.0408826247,
-0.0187869929,
0.0242393594,
0.0273174196,
0.0086581791,
-0.0233146492,
0.0164406635,
-0.0248471722,
0.0431783386,
0.0261843167,
0.0022674976,
-0.0101107545,
-0.0307926908,
0.0399150141,
-0.0089860214,
-0.0505027957,
-0.0030947926,
0.0140033606,
-0.0062984955,
-0.0283990782,
0.0218586121,
-0.0106729865,
0.0157331936,
-0.0029899213,
0.0271457601,
0.0428804494,
0.0421713069,
-0.0570422001,
-0.003847095,
0.0389961042,
-0.0163235292,
0.0020249446,
0.0199478846,
0.0117963217,
-0.0318160392,
-0.0109741045,
-0.0480467044,
-0.0478251316,
-0.0181574617,
2.791e-7,
0.033478938,
0.0678406581,
0.0195842981,
0.0542039983,
0.0069776722,
-0.0016340872,
0.037337441,
0.0767168626,
0.01891426,
0.0122717302,
0.0172828548,
0.0102039045,
0.0279881172,
0.0190688372,
-0.1204494312,
-0.0540122762,
-0.056749709,
-0.0627708882,
-0.0393213071,
-0.0336692184,
0.0829034671,
0.0394664332,
0.0101770842,
0.0076435125,
0.0161661804,
-0.0254743136,
0.0318533145,
0.0312176589,
0.0263134539,
0.0125019588,
0.0791330263,
0.0336552449,
-0.0178701673,
0.0143054044,
-0.03390323,
0.0195985977,
0.0461958051,
0.0537390448,
-0.0247154608,
-0.0449683256,
0.0075442651,
0.024155343,
-0.0057429401,
-0.0832736492,
0.0755935982,
-0.0263137165,
-0.019625714,
0.0348768607,
-0.0554803424,
-0.0107968934,
0.0168639664,
0.0189866349,
-0.0236443747,
0.0217919126,
0.0107355323,
0.0402773879,
-0.0050041247,
-0.0955637544,
-0.0352520645,
0.006476427,
-0.0203101709,
0.0096143447,
-0.0173105951,
0.0071694129,
-0.0370816216,
-0.0778187662,
-0.0172343422,
2.723519392e-34,
0.0307773985,
0.009823354,
-0.0079847537,
0.006553723,
0.0316538103,
-0.0092921806,
-0.0212616753,
-0.006980848,
-0.0190200079,
-0.0626666471,
-0.0073326458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12364v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12364v1 | SpokesBiz -- an Open Corpus of Conversational Polish | 2023-12-19T17:48:26 | 2023-12-19T17:48:26 | Piotr Pęzik, Sylwia Karasińska, Anna Cichosz, Łukasz Jałowiecki, Konrad Kaczyński, Małgorzata Krawentek, Karolina Walkusz, Paweł Wilk, Mariusz Kleć, Krzysztof Szklanny, Szymon Marszałkowski | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper announces the early release of SpokesBiz, a freely available
corpus of conversational Polish developed within the CLARIN-BIZ project and
comprising over 650 hours of recordings. The transcribed recordings have been
diarized and manually annotated for punctuation and casing. We outline the
general structure and content of the corpus, showcasing selected applications
in linguistic research, evaluation and improvement of automatic speech
recognition (ASR) systems | [
-0.02368805,
-0.0031774738,
0.0035402442,
0.0367707685,
-0.02811273,
0.0084134741,
0.0025821393,
-0.0120652979,
0.0001963012,
0.0195776839,
-0.0251585804,
0.0562500991,
0.0518075228,
0.0035701825,
0.0296297409,
-0.0575823188,
0.045898512,
-0.0613442808,
0.0001728028,
0.0046206922,
0.0402900428,
0.0047036735,
-0.0670803115,
0.0459977947,
0.0241837204,
-0.0066595003,
-0.0189397633,
0.0227623377,
-0.0106832199,
0.0032821889,
-0.0135614332,
-0.0017821336,
-0.0149689466,
0.0366167091,
0.0000013775,
-0.0275445711,
0.0096098501,
-0.021288123,
-0.0572215244,
-0.0096792523,
-0.0068116132,
-0.0257773139,
-0.0071501913,
0.0226495676,
0.0002691547,
-0.0431781188,
0.0423862934,
-0.0017252443,
0.003909471,
0.0294515863,
-0.0061675846,
-0.0232854579,
0.0310843047,
0.0243509617,
-0.0868929848,
-0.013601575,
0.0117396554,
-0.0410301909,
0.0074868761,
-0.0196294542,
0.0368304253,
0.0490196198,
-0.0394713134,
-0.0528638959,
-0.0036840928,
-0.008281596,
-0.0682628751,
-0.0566636957,
-0.0582759082,
0.0163319241,
0.0310480744,
-0.0282282103,
0.0125941038,
-0.0130034229,
0.0118555846,
-0.0241171047,
-0.054709781,
-0.017622672,
-0.0274736471,
-0.0081205899,
-0.0006257214,
0.0821624473,
-0.0060502221,
-0.0116583183,
0.0288993176,
0.0658264607,
0.0201564487,
-0.0011058066,
0.0691912323,
-0.0291398931,
0.0763820261,
0.003456726,
0.0703490376,
-0.0140977167,
-0.0225569699,
0.0049913037,
-0.0070707505,
0.0033974489,
0.0208197124,
-0.0435521267,
-0.0197874568,
0.030938955,
-0.038409669,
0.0329246372,
0.0022967381,
0.0160567276,
0.0227257237,
-0.0264877994,
-0.0468526594,
-0.0125816176,
-0.0504793972,
0.0056762062,
-0.0858337805,
-0.0068166358,
-0.0481340326,
-0.0206787363,
-0.0303531028,
0.0393953137,
0.0378767103,
0.0220170487,
0.0171429813,
-0.0284200162,
0.0027988432,
0.0304821022,
0.0271630306,
0.0628665835,
-0.0455376282,
0.0294461343,
-0.0322843008,
-0.0615809634,
0.0107869403,
0.0352344625,
0.0409676693,
-0.0207106154,
0.0002018367,
0.0333049111,
0.0269879047,
-0.0310056098,
0.0120328553,
-0.0127261654,
-0.0511968993,
-0.0357793458,
-0.0262535531,
-0.0324702002,
0.0397654213,
0.0083885659,
-0.0144591173,
-0.0176366046,
-0.0146355163,
-0.0190328173,
-0.0047866264,
0.0514867119,
-0.0384499505,
-0.0028541943,
0.0248020589,
-0.0415849015,
0.0282854233,
0.0140336864,
0.0322867855,
-0.0212638881,
0.0488587692,
-0.0368511602,
-0.0004860432,
0.0637899861,
-0.034968283,
-0.0054755351,
-0.0104708485,
0.0442858413,
-0.0196791217,
-0.007340509,
0.0503086373,
0.0601563416,
-0.0266386885,
-0.0098688928,
0.0353950188,
0.0829212368,
0.0269457251,
-0.0002754293,
0.0221429896,
-0.0108009074,
0.0297075305,
0.0268827453,
0.0324600935,
-0.0625561774,
0.0119480845,
0.0248141419,
0.0094511034,
0.0050573256,
-0.0045775822,
0.0195418186,
0.0024650241,
-0.0050843335,
0.0363298059,
-0.000352999,
0.0232539363,
-0.0218490493,
-0.0465074778,
0.0666334033,
0.0302311145,
-0.0276474804,
-0.0275471248,
-0.0441546924,
-0.0161357466,
0.0580435358,
0.0270464569,
-0.0369264595,
-0.0270126536,
-0.0356617086,
-0.0319410972,
0.0347496681,
0.001414296,
-0.0364335887,
0.0334461741,
-0.0276814196,
0.0281725787,
0.0287815332,
0.013580732,
0.0475059003,
-0.0572438091,
0.0036488916,
0.0049052848,
-0.0032368151,
-0.0110883014,
-0.0251866654,
0.0456685908,
0.002545085,
-0.0090160444,
-0.0061607989,
0.0249720942,
0.0841079727,
-0.0150504289,
0.0221801382,
0.0561711825,
-0.0151485801,
0.0922332257,
0.0960595012,
-0.0264911186,
-0.0344924703,
0.0378442295,
-0.047468029,
-0.0188115034,
-0.0304951239,
0.0293301176,
-0.0647462979,
0.0624295324,
-0.0545642078,
0.0126656489,
-0.0223895777,
0.0553443097,
0.0154698417,
0.0701878592,
0.0270583518,
-0.0276277587,
0.0330419354,
-0.0143391546,
0.0177338459,
-0.0378331468,
0.0441164114,
-0.0883918256,
0.029045729,
0.0651025698,
-0.0326493867,
-0.038122043,
0.0129827429,
-0.0110357106,
-0.0349732004,
0.034158051,
-0.1002624035,
0.0117993858,
-0.0041478528,
0.0240975078,
-0.0502001569,
0.0418040045,
-0.0061023533,
-0.0222286638,
-0.0103267515,
-0.0415195376,
0.0173582584,
-0.0047411746,
-0.0172822885,
0.0363619253,
-0.0415933244,
-0.0457661301,
0.0124223381,
0.0080324253,
-0.0345073827,
0.0033536761,
-0.0614542738,
-0.0656151101,
0.0314328335,
0.0089529306,
0.015349458,
-0.0041742292,
-0.0468219817,
0.0034433135,
0.0218580272,
0.0414079055,
0.0157632828,
-0.0657110736,
-0.0113306148,
-0.0182388611,
-0.0435930714,
-0.0225340128,
0.0001655819,
0.0027058735,
0.0671018511,
-0.0252528414,
0.0299077481,
0.0168889891,
0.0235585216,
0.0045018643,
0.0439419076,
-0.0213515665,
-0.0047009732,
-0.0215174463,
0.0090087494,
-0.0166349709,
-0.0504183583,
-0.0453797095,
0.0370121524,
0.0375689045,
0.019874787,
0.0233813245,
-0.0783432871,
-0.04278896,
-0.062122032,
-0.0957218707,
-0.0033240446,
0.0398442671,
-0.0075714756,
-0.0074668122,
-0.0112284226,
-0.1140875295,
0.0118763912,
-0.0225860588,
0.0409855619,
-0.0038428449,
-0.0133549031,
-0.0594823062,
0.0108248005,
0.0017841172,
-0.0451438949,
0.0123345433,
-0.0479705557,
-0.0416214168,
0.0124310143,
0.0311545841,
-0.0209031347,
0.0461704358,
0.0519208945,
-0.0235717092,
0.0642977357,
-0.0043037673,
0.0423138216,
-0.0241746772,
0.048952356,
0.0067420192,
0.0165344886,
0.0047701793,
-0.0005725026,
0.0008735585,
-0.0129621793,
0.0404216498,
0.0011272427,
-0.0106873857,
-0.0357026346,
0.0213407818,
-0.0029608584,
-0.0226757508,
-0.0489370301,
0.0151967192,
-0.0113699781,
-0.0098502776,
0.0716369227,
-0.0195533521,
-0.0130839888,
-0.0121586472,
-0.0078334818,
-0.0036100619,
-0.0294247791,
0.0248384401,
-0.073192887,
-0.0068268208,
0.0482166335,
0.0536081418,
-0.0359227695,
0.0009109356,
0.0019586731,
-0.0941636488,
0.0055409335,
0.01443596,
-0.0259574521,
-0.0270680469,
-0.0378884636,
-0.0286369268,
-0.0107345358,
-0.0005761284,
0.0240685903,
-0.0184832588,
-0.0287206899,
0.0367997736,
-0.0675861463,
-0.0557654984,
-0.00444549,
0.0103444057,
0.0841945559,
0.0108497441,
0.0465161987,
-0.0229829531,
-0.0047897869,
0.006429174,
-0.0323327892,
-0.0131404633,
-0.0257520676,
0.0009976025,
0.0473723523,
-0.0083061885,
-0.0194332823,
0.0532482825,
0.0272569321,
0.0059306468,
0.0473913141,
0.0207228903,
-0.0299611334,
0.0112679498,
0.0474395379,
0.026931718,
0.0573953427,
0.0269604642,
0.0509215929,
0.0304929279,
-0.0198952667,
0.0036688349,
0.0075926511,
-0.0390986055,
-0.0046203965,
0.0023453636,
0.0050054989,
-0.0389523692,
-0.0684607029,
-0.0430826433,
0.0535117872,
0.0078395084,
0.0157328565,
-0.0156896189,
-0.0276394337,
0.0642157644,
-0.0265484545,
0.0171323027,
0.033967495,
0.0013831907,
-0.0951864421,
-0.0155832795,
0.0383352414,
-0.0198495891,
-0.0179098863,
0.0168516915,
-0.0426181033,
-0.0704572871,
0.0483559966,
0.0285915118,
0.0279939864,
0.0485461168,
-0.0269376263,
-0.0354532413,
-0.0118727377,
0.0019219366,
-0.0806353241,
-0.0113882609,
0.0603609011,
0.035781689,
-0.0076157204,
0.0208129361,
-0.0074524651,
0.0054807956,
-0.0691632405,
-0.0408009551,
-0.0331222229,
-0.1036302373,
-0.0235837046,
0.0125251515,
0.0788796544,
-0.0180934034,
-0.0512631908,
-0.0205046963,
0.0424739756,
-0.0107974317,
0.0171667058,
-0.0002719121,
0.0118324226,
-0.0020048225,
0.0201186314,
-0.042619057,
-0.0070972578,
-0.0843006223,
-0.0242612623,
0.0033784423,
0.036728289,
0.0756511763,
-0.0178350862,
0.0402233601,
-0.0014258667,
-0.0438757874,
0.0708222762,
0.0482325703,
0.0335513279,
-0.0028731173,
-0.0315177701,
-0.0122165214,
-0.0482960455,
0.0166852959,
0.0084388545,
-0.0308898762,
0.0164587945,
0.0405673496,
0.0619579963,
0.0406189077,
0.011851077,
0.0989540964,
0.0059227301,
0.0020634879,
-0.0126391007,
0.0330773331,
-0.0192472097,
0.024443794,
-0.023884844,
0.0028686919,
-0.0526867621,
0.0082613425,
-0.0098628206,
-0.0277426504,
0.0054072496,
0.0187475253,
0.0252772328,
-0.0575469397,
-0.0272163395,
-0.0610635579,
-0.0235226266,
-0.0409444198,
-0.0110260425,
-0.0265706666,
-0.0247148983,
0.0114604784,
0.0536413193,
0.0012251167,
-0.0179820769,
-0.0014312565,
-0.0459696092,
0.0002658472,
0.0528500974,
-0.0015658786,
0.0209295899,
0.0181667563,
-0.0184200313,
-0.0137453331,
-5.295954699e-33,
-0.0323021077,
-0.0196943004,
-0.0019097956,
0.0641779155,
-0.0341875441,
-0.0288936626,
-0.0160591584,
0.0120859472,
0.018822005,
-0.0174081251,
-0.0327030867,
-0.0127265137,
0.0476904698,
-0.0218718182,
0.0294744223,
-0.0084751341,
0.0658479407,
0.0191906262,
0.0147416051,
0.0114765065,
0.0483283699,
0.0455419049,
0.0483784154,
-0.0625912622,
0.0004491388,
-0.0283652227,
-0.0138312196,
0.007584678,
0.0734885558,
0.0384640619,
0.0120935068,
0.0371628925,
-0.0247131921,
0.0288056415,
0.0016455895,
0.0499499328,
-0.0626093224,
-0.0092334719,
0.0561573282,
0.1259445995,
0.0260352511,
-0.0025164345,
0.0213067327,
0.0054199407,
-0.025528146,
0.0726013929,
-0.0024894888,
-0.042198848,
-0.0036039141,
0.025507303,
-0.050520733,
0.0141243665,
-0.04756568,
-0.0288314559,
0.0748592168,
0.0862143189,
0.0062971199,
-0.0461267866,
-0.0418147519,
0.0588308722,
0.0295898579,
0.0255350173,
0.0225077923,
-0.0057372241,
-0.0266563818,
0.0063075265,
0.0923445448,
-0.1131853387,
0.0638689324,
0.0165084954,
0.0259809531,
0.008737321,
0.0103583587,
0.047927551,
-0.0056150788,
-0.0001760109,
-0.0294028744,
-0.0668410212,
0.1158031151,
0.0035025105,
-0.0547358654,
0.0236886702,
-0.0257085171,
-0.0193328988,
0.0074913865,
0.0025039259,
0.0078831119,
-0.0028025939,
0.0354495049,
-0.0429302044,
0.0144667197,
0.0224803761,
0.0606606156,
0.0236941297,
-0.0336784124,
-0.0207620878,
0.0028677718,
-0.0113138305,
-0.0509550832,
0.0431958139,
-0.0409060866,
-0.0277993791,
0.0087744836,
0.0200058967,
0.0683477223,
0.009362218,
-0.0087245656,
0.0383568928,
-0.0357440338,
0.015253515,
0.0175026804,
0.0299510229,
-0.0361252166,
0.0601818673,
0.0284661893,
0.0067244763,
0.0020471825,
0.0464660786,
0.0142378267,
0.0172484349,
-0.0269636773,
-0.0442869663,
0.0377798453,
0.0091237845,
-0.0483932272,
0.0330377892,
0.0500520766,
0.0189521499,
-0.0027436672,
0.0295686834,
0.0190881062,
-0.0053561148,
2.339e-7,
-0.0064937659,
0.0444002263,
0.0077347606,
-0.0166580714,
0.0071110171,
-0.0231652856,
-0.0437790342,
-0.03028192,
0.0026576433,
0.0453035943,
0.0038425939,
-0.0849403143,
0.0706142709,
0.0231578648,
-0.1281889975,
-0.0320352577,
-0.0450231545,
-0.0200199485,
-0.0549343899,
0.0161726959,
0.0116274338,
0.0678429529,
0.0045055575,
0.0060784277,
-0.0380238742,
-0.0322648585,
-0.0083249686,
0.001450628,
-0.0190227982,
-0.0171044823,
0.0344006009,
0.0210815668,
-0.0528411269,
0.0019224769,
-0.0034985736,
0.056034103,
0.0044396529,
0.0177485887,
-0.0008728647,
-0.0518351048,
0.0159058347,
-0.0187789369,
-0.0537854061,
0.0031347631,
0.0191174075,
-0.0309142228,
-0.0012534474,
0.0054228967,
-0.011175869,
-0.0172032472,
0.0100180227,
-0.0107747279,
0.006016043,
-0.0082104895,
-0.0029033236,
-0.0391682237,
-0.0160245374,
-0.0346675701,
0.0185439028,
-0.0204135478,
-0.0243361443,
-0.0247911625,
0.0162710156,
-0.0333766155,
-0.0069790632,
-0.0290833674,
-0.0108420895,
1.358388759e-34,
0.0133479564,
0.0104880147,
0.0122540025,
0.0286831744,
-0.0178682841,
-0.0456441231,
0.0051184124,
0.0477914587,
0.035582073,
-0.0216455776,
-0.0352312103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14184v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14184v1 | Large Language Models in Medical Term Classification and Unexpected Misalignment Between Response and Reasoning | 2023-12-19T17:36:48 | 2023-12-19T17:36:48 | Xiaodan Zhang, Sandeep Vemulapalli, Nabasmita Talukdar, Sumyeong Ahn, Jiankun Wang, Han Meng, Sardar Mehtab Bin Murtaza, Aakash Ajay Dave, Dmitry Leshchiner, Dimitri F. Joseph, Martin Witteveen-Lane, Dave Chesla, Jiayu Zhou, Bin Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This study assesses the ability of state-of-the-art large language models
(LLMs) including GPT-3.5, GPT-4, Falcon, and LLaMA 2 to identify patients with
mild cognitive impairment (MCI) from discharge summaries and examines instances
where the models' responses were misaligned with their reasoning. Utilizing the
MIMIC-IV v2.2 database, we focused on a cohort aged 65 and older, verifying MCI
diagnoses against ICD codes and expert evaluations. The data was partitioned
into training, validation, and testing sets in a 7:2:1 ratio for model
fine-tuning and evaluation, with an additional metastatic cancer dataset from
MIMIC III used to further assess reasoning consistency. GPT-4 demonstrated
superior interpretative capabilities, particularly in response to complex
prompts, yet displayed notable response-reasoning inconsistencies. In contrast,
open-source models like Falcon and LLaMA 2 achieved high accuracy but lacked
explanatory reasoning, underscoring the necessity for further research to
optimize both performance and interpretability. The study emphasizes the
significance of prompt engineering and the need for further exploration into
the unexpected reasoning-response misalignment observed in GPT-4. The results
underscore the promise of incorporating LLMs into healthcare diagnostics,
contingent upon methodological advancements to ensure accuracy and clinical
coherence of AI-generated outputs, thereby improving the trustworthiness of
LLMs for medical decision-making. | [
0.0290339012,
0.044595588,
0.0009884416,
-0.0062036524,
-0.0158226974,
0.0414115526,
0.0420948938,
0.0302778445,
0.0343733244,
-0.0190178026,
-0.0040218271,
-0.0506289974,
0.0210184678,
0.0516134389,
-0.0027954057,
-0.0160115436,
0.0468919612,
-0.0044381595,
0.0636390448,
-0.0091376603,
-0.0326498374,
0.0126128588,
-0.0198647585,
0.0558087304,
0.0119406851,
-0.0327506214,
0.0532991104,
-0.0448569581,
-0.0162081067,
-0.056479726,
-0.0217298698,
0.0365983918,
-0.0093140407,
0.0263286326,
0.0000020257,
-0.1058071107,
-0.0130338855,
0.0246356577,
-0.0486398004,
-0.0293372497,
-0.0064978423,
0.0063641011,
0.0353013314,
0.034538459,
-0.0115443161,
-0.0091986777,
0.0239038803,
0.0585732982,
0.0315423012,
0.0504726619,
-0.0105889188,
-0.0269125234,
0.0460450724,
-0.019149214,
0.0153506231,
-0.0282609537,
0.0508683622,
0.0099626267,
0.0021350291,
-0.0472983643,
0.0363046899,
0.0339721553,
-0.0126804169,
0.0370270051,
-0.0196831338,
0.0536669977,
-0.0018496084,
-0.0260329451,
0.0106805163,
0.0165541675,
0.0108229136,
0.0186691433,
-0.004511531,
-0.012118808,
0.0036849815,
0.0336054787,
-0.0495110378,
0.0172503032,
-0.0179256033,
0.0047778608,
0.0077219903,
-0.0164717194,
0.0221091192,
-0.0175408423,
-0.0642933995,
0.0430558994,
0.0003870252,
-0.0324776322,
0.0280910432,
-0.0077255624,
-0.0664351881,
-0.0341379084,
0.0256481804,
0.0326972865,
-0.0670218766,
0.0155291101,
0.0096748713,
0.0047546886,
0.0889541581,
-0.0303925592,
0.0263473969,
0.0225368757,
-0.0295562204,
0.024052022,
-0.0299053304,
0.0562372729,
-0.0260505155,
0.0442362279,
-0.0387739874,
-0.0010804711,
-0.0531706661,
-0.0321207382,
-0.022931736,
0.0338871963,
0.0149526801,
-0.0022756427,
-0.1186328083,
-0.0056165913,
-0.0244841296,
0.0040941457,
0.0373708569,
0.0391027145,
0.0048966524,
0.0277251676,
-0.0465047844,
0.0026087845,
-0.0102569237,
0.0280538201,
-0.0040697833,
-0.0466035567,
0.0185683444,
0.0261644106,
-0.0343368985,
-0.0531869978,
0.0167323872,
0.0429737829,
0.0009518333,
-0.0325777531,
-0.0167990867,
-0.0450056642,
-0.0621855631,
-0.0397930741,
0.0213798061,
-0.0347221382,
0.0204931349,
0.0476795807,
0.0133409435,
-0.059312664,
-0.0038232314,
-0.0147178182,
-0.0557568632,
0.0598600283,
-0.0522347055,
0.0160763729,
0.021984024,
0.0056227832,
-0.0254079383,
0.003194923,
0.0198248979,
-0.0375103019,
0.0009881431,
-0.0346290618,
0.0164006334,
0.0179552697,
-0.0036369583,
-0.0241474397,
-0.0338821188,
0.0384172387,
-0.0282648876,
0.0616031326,
0.00483337,
0.0515810177,
0.0458215959,
-0.0096548432,
0.0414716899,
0.0685275197,
0.0129617238,
0.0240658764,
0.0120971175,
-0.0225320272,
0.0062391367,
-0.0165573396,
-0.0311207455,
-0.0156210177,
-0.0096947448,
-0.0076531409,
-0.0027057983,
0.011668019,
-0.0150506971,
-0.0359069556,
-0.0410827287,
-0.0179468486,
-0.0108971791,
0.0226095431,
0.0309553221,
-0.0612205565,
-0.0087343259,
0.0183671955,
0.0279832631,
-0.0000533934,
-0.0527188405,
-0.0927397758,
-0.0042117517,
0.0677639544,
-0.0005915564,
-0.0214938838,
-0.0333890803,
-0.0164556429,
0.0031619642,
-0.0036876025,
0.0079702009,
0.0023553262,
-0.0241963938,
-0.0291232429,
-0.0056938599,
0.0364723317,
0.0156420451,
-0.0389962606,
-0.0284753032,
0.0027914278,
-0.0175174754,
-0.0313953236,
-0.0200564265,
0.0558759719,
-0.0217060335,
-0.0325653851,
-0.0210672002,
0.005093371,
0.0565555766,
-0.0053323936,
-0.0026367207,
0.0274591185,
-0.0045897588,
-0.0021773097,
-0.0295716301,
0.0063170646,
-0.0512094311,
-0.0094791809,
0.0268874615,
0.0658848956,
-0.0214046873,
-0.0145124029,
-0.012647775,
-0.0229373686,
-0.0254664831,
-0.0419588238,
-0.0085272649,
-0.0223440416,
0.0338337794,
-0.0028642484,
0.0066216481,
-0.0486347936,
0.067403309,
-0.0389745496,
-0.0033828737,
-0.0051748767,
-0.0341391265,
0.0354108661,
-0.026714487,
-0.0393001437,
0.0344353057,
-0.0084603895,
0.0085164076,
-0.0346205644,
-0.0047505712,
-0.0126718879,
-0.0062245307,
-0.1094269902,
-0.0145043004,
0.0137978755,
-0.0015420773,
0.0022188651,
-0.0139023289,
-0.0168003123,
0.008434739,
-0.0122261113,
-0.0076180901,
0.0540918298,
0.0601553433,
0.014012184,
0.0400353149,
-0.0273944177,
-0.0001450581,
-0.0064751832,
-0.0615111664,
0.0596405379,
0.0249257833,
-0.0092987707,
-0.0169110671,
-0.004251997,
-0.0357778072,
0.0081046922,
-0.0076743406,
0.019568488,
0.0300337449,
-0.0236168597,
-0.0236036871,
0.0375350937,
9.942e-7,
0.0654447153,
0.043330051,
0.0129216313,
-0.0342069492,
0.0012358306,
-0.0124276532,
-0.0605870336,
-0.0162330568,
-0.0437114574,
0.0018433442,
0.0603446662,
0.0476506501,
0.0154412398,
-0.0480560474,
0.0125839533,
-0.022640679,
0.0169980377,
-0.0382613018,
-0.0052293837,
-0.0561657175,
0.0424165726,
0.0018513873,
-0.0530470684,
0.089678064,
-0.0176031962,
0.0413374826,
-0.0856890753,
-0.0247664545,
-0.0332629271,
0.0288985074,
-0.0106304148,
0.0183653291,
0.0146958409,
-0.0075597065,
-0.0285101775,
-0.0331902988,
-0.0391430147,
-0.0446379893,
0.1160018146,
-0.0404295474,
0.043636743,
0.0215784125,
-0.0084058549,
-0.0384169407,
-0.0050017573,
-0.0237324797,
0.0376711302,
0.0024531139,
-0.0066951332,
-0.0788766146,
0.0095197251,
0.0020252839,
0.0332270227,
-0.0119301938,
-0.0217302851,
0.0062122038,
-0.0051075122,
0.0193094369,
0.0320621319,
0.0162464306,
-0.0335641652,
0.0248956997,
0.0340058506,
-0.0132019483,
0.0195783097,
-0.0228418633,
0.0013063251,
0.0099903923,
-0.0551536195,
-0.0188319553,
0.0419523641,
0.0489913151,
-0.0277584773,
-0.0128098037,
0.1494252235,
0.0448628217,
-0.0842668638,
0.0061946148,
-0.0294902772,
-0.0102105858,
0.0085808774,
-0.0173660479,
-0.022810014,
-0.0326636769,
-0.0162983406,
0.065140225,
-0.045201581,
-0.0256695561,
0.0036424375,
-0.0283483639,
0.0543025173,
-0.0167165063,
-0.0472141691,
-0.0203478318,
-0.0215048846,
0.0025177277,
0.0131999347,
0.0210105162,
-0.0120351408,
-0.0109758768,
0.0020738905,
0.0153761506,
-0.0537328534,
-0.0726267695,
0.0653867126,
-0.0055442974,
0.0678574964,
0.0495614037,
0.0190952122,
-0.0450322703,
-0.0266269688,
0.0303577315,
-0.0401947498,
0.0270737354,
-0.0028409166,
0.041443456,
0.0389515944,
0.0199239515,
-0.0432836376,
-0.0069661867,
-0.027082324,
-0.0349819288,
0.0091837998,
0.0997186527,
-0.1000668406,
-0.0411601774,
-0.0289302282,
0.0082394946,
0.0063059013,
0.0570937544,
0.0022860917,
-0.0179981459,
-0.0263615623,
0.0289061293,
0.0183532629,
0.0600691251,
0.0054540983,
0.0287004467,
-0.0121879075,
-0.0126074953,
-0.0336341336,
-0.0370596834,
0.0561022237,
-0.0183432195,
0.0179460607,
0.0366986804,
0.0071590431,
0.0171337184,
-0.0413492136,
0.0893342346,
0.045051951,
0.0174421631,
-0.066979602,
-0.0154938241,
0.0083284443,
-0.0398316421,
-0.0408011563,
-0.0176844485,
0.0099869985,
0.0151710939,
0.0323906019,
0.01683826,
0.0301952921,
-0.0275240559,
0.0074751996,
-0.0535970144,
0.0317520052,
0.0277401935,
0.0191913433,
-0.0056870338,
-0.01933752,
0.0242577139,
-0.0128244348,
0.0116283391,
-0.0304140244,
0.029963728,
-0.0013852572,
0.0067225979,
-0.0174968783,
0.0089604463,
0.0416204929,
0.0498739965,
0.0405262299,
-0.0149876289,
-0.0253005736,
-0.0084120072,
-0.0045768907,
0.0066548171,
0.009134314,
0.0089882147,
-0.0276072416,
0.0369083174,
-0.0027883067,
-0.0131260063,
-0.0397338793,
-0.0607118383,
-0.0456453711,
-0.0624154173,
0.0451656319,
-0.028229896,
0.0124506997,
0.0229353439,
-0.0189501122,
-0.0082695149,
-0.005212781,
-0.0167625677,
0.0072591393,
0.0245213099,
0.0965007171,
0.0008660696,
0.0085801585,
-0.0268375501,
0.0249498468,
-0.0344100557,
-0.0902221724,
0.0082559483,
0.0397151411,
0.015577605,
-0.0108056357,
0.0082837995,
-0.0276576076,
0.0307979081,
-0.0368654989,
-0.0159768742,
0.0200261083,
0.01964093,
0.0605300888,
0.0188602731,
-0.0316731334,
-0.0380273201,
0.0810758844,
-0.0067023681,
0.0279287845,
-0.0389423519,
-0.062253505,
-0.0252230857,
-0.0613212548,
0.0046251309,
-0.0031297302,
-0.080971092,
-0.0122133931,
-0.0712203085,
-0.0161540154,
0.0423023067,
-0.0251938757,
-0.0056366907,
-0.0059137223,
0.0294246301,
0.06910301,
-0.0198208299,
-0.058286123,
-0.0247032829,
0.0176008437,
-0.0333509892,
-0.0042892946,
-0.0180326607,
-5.729524035e-33,
0.0097045414,
-0.0321002491,
0.0242921989,
-0.0363085344,
0.0032095492,
0.0021137495,
-0.0348649621,
0.004407079,
-0.005420716,
0.0261199735,
-0.0102305887,
-0.0027621815,
0.013077708,
0.0257917438,
0.0253859088,
-0.0477517545,
0.0211412199,
0.0118466411,
-0.0110501759,
0.0133799464,
0.0014897255,
0.0202313513,
0.0239135548,
-0.1236124113,
0.0588546246,
0.0269891229,
0.0234100744,
0.0359814391,
-0.0622586571,
0.0576559678,
-0.0226249266,
0.060471192,
0.0503729247,
0.0192636587,
0.0164972562,
-0.0007518395,
-0.0055032987,
-0.0147641646,
0.0540628321,
-0.0234590191,
0.0044548786,
-0.0210174192,
0.0694376454,
0.0049056434,
-0.0411768965,
0.0113087846,
0.039479591,
-0.0444587581,
0.0176460426,
-0.0221226588,
-0.0310663935,
0.0207295734,
0.0078464393,
0.0340897329,
-0.0385280252,
-0.0120936194,
-0.0443342589,
0.0681111142,
-0.0185395628,
-0.0205850936,
0.0253259782,
-0.0103925755,
0.039748989,
-0.0054486631,
-0.0247552581,
0.0819909573,
0.0506729633,
0.0003180452,
-0.0543077327,
-0.0268811975,
-0.0271860808,
0.0428455248,
0.0653599352,
-0.0206782185,
0.0194349028,
-0.0268430393,
-0.0769414902,
0.0029215992,
-0.0424155593,
0.0567135885,
0.0840790793,
-0.0476375483,
-0.0806815475,
-0.0077531538,
-0.0376902707,
0.0300638806,
-0.0495206118,
-0.0163646694,
0.0321766511,
-0.0398620963,
0.0359345004,
0.0138299102,
0.0247527901,
-0.0040077898,
0.0001178,
-0.0522527732,
0.0377633534,
0.0138876541,
-0.0092741484,
0.0258731134,
-0.009085428,
-0.037031047,
0.0074248575,
-0.044948142,
0.0503381528,
0.024456393,
0.0356593207,
-0.0417272076,
-0.0375383794,
0.0001140566,
-0.0006507372,
-0.0086482512,
-0.0185942259,
0.0080826934,
0.0241035912,
0.0387854241,
0.0007537364,
0.0323882513,
0.0083857486,
-0.028320998,
-0.0309997015,
-0.0308394898,
-0.0185261872,
0.004654408,
-0.0224012937,
0.0221395716,
-0.0017211242,
0.0541442148,
0.0116454326,
-0.0511872135,
-0.0014278145,
0.0144993048,
2.839e-7,
0.1172024682,
0.0797437578,
-0.0382299013,
-0.0170468744,
0.0117662838,
0.0124448836,
-0.0251064319,
-0.0083186878,
0.0324309506,
0.0250125248,
0.0362035558,
0.0276522711,
0.024320554,
0.0423785858,
-0.0186981782,
-0.0152136181,
-0.066289261,
-0.0210975148,
-0.0676738396,
0.0598479994,
0.0911469609,
0.0491368212,
-0.0377942286,
-0.0493027307,
0.031065667,
-0.0360007994,
0.0108877961,
-0.0398452617,
0.0177840889,
0.033396896,
0.0467761345,
-0.0338007733,
0.0724970475,
0.1019258276,
0.0034742977,
0.0025957508,
0.0041361935,
0.0727842525,
-0.0713082775,
0.0109755686,
-0.0016087305,
0.0015551029,
0.048156254,
-0.0621733554,
0.0567765012,
-0.0353610814,
-0.0610936135,
-0.0231896192,
-0.0251078773,
-0.0292928834,
0.0753636584,
-0.0236707423,
0.0081133777,
0.0201426763,
0.0069501325,
0.0006662169,
-0.0098062661,
-0.0524540357,
-0.0005383618,
0.0599805601,
-0.0726350844,
-0.0462610982,
0.0193323288,
0.0014618149,
0.047261592,
-0.0540476851,
0.0094732689,
2.817905848e-34,
0.0195667017,
0.033785291,
0.0162737872,
0.0049582445,
0.01602754,
0.0005249606,
0.0537776761,
0.0435491912,
-0.0271665677,
-0.0757497475,
-0.000755821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12343v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12343v3 | LatestEval: Addressing Data Contamination in Language Model Evaluation through Dynamic and Time-Sensitive Test Construction | 2023-12-19T17:16:43 | 2024-03-01T15:17:21 | Yucheng Li, Frank Guerin, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Data contamination in evaluation is getting increasingly prevalent with the
emergence of language models pre-trained on super large, automatically crawled
corpora. This problem leads to significant challenges in the accurate
assessment of model capabilities and generalisations. In this paper, we propose
LatestEval, an automatic method that leverages the most recent texts to create
uncontaminated reading comprehension evaluations. LatestEval avoids data
contamination by only using texts published within a recent time window,
ensuring no overlap with the training corpora of pre-trained language models.
We develop the LatestEval automated pipeline to 1) gather the latest texts; 2)
identify key information, and 3) construct questions targeting the information
while removing the existing answers from the context. This encourages models to
infer the answers themselves based on the remaining context, rather than just
copy-paste. Our experiments demonstrate that language models exhibit negligible
memorisation behaviours on LatestEval as opposed to previous benchmarks,
suggesting a significantly reduced risk of data contamination and leading to a
more robust evaluation. Data and code are publicly available at:
https://github.com/liyucheng09/LatestEval. | [
0.0340351239,
0.06173224,
-0.0104092285,
0.023584038,
-0.0568584614,
0.0297455508,
0.0043217451,
-0.0320554823,
0.0276311859,
-0.0574665479,
-0.0213231612,
-0.0264611859,
0.0076825009,
0.0333766192,
0.0147172771,
-0.0178653095,
0.0553434752,
-0.0227653217,
-0.015739711,
0.002431754,
-0.020466499,
0.0092656063,
0.0055045509,
-0.0008782908,
0.0553333797,
-0.037927866,
-0.0252377521,
-0.0153942779,
0.0162499119,
-0.0242699552,
0.0330546722,
0.0612701699,
0.0016435422,
0.0471390113,
0.0000021358,
-0.0314714015,
-0.0411909074,
-0.0081353262,
-0.0220052302,
0.0442887433,
0.0591019168,
0.0025296805,
0.0117806541,
0.0052693202,
-0.0189214926,
-0.0245804843,
-0.0047484101,
0.0064385142,
0.0757420659,
0.0700215027,
0.0065486352,
0.0161138736,
0.0358527824,
0.0037270838,
0.0221639052,
-0.08419732,
0.0338167325,
0.0470343642,
0.0386418365,
0.0124284504,
-0.0328566208,
0.0651610792,
0.0338587016,
-0.0008039635,
0.0039059359,
0.0250495858,
-0.0000627894,
-0.0092251813,
-0.0155264856,
0.0824384019,
0.0198205803,
-0.054870449,
-0.0305995159,
-0.0029786858,
-0.0332613289,
0.0320051052,
-0.023066856,
0.0029068901,
-0.0158839915,
0.0051812069,
0.027633477,
-0.0134254834,
0.0528668016,
0.0347053781,
-0.0241002571,
0.075700596,
0.0382053405,
-0.0254508294,
0.0090230126,
0.0175835565,
0.0094906939,
-0.0473720133,
0.023942085,
0.0531296469,
-0.0077782804,
0.0275537167,
-0.0376210846,
-0.0525914058,
0.0382520072,
-0.0164563861,
0.0115440069,
0.0412419736,
-0.0339721553,
0.0662364513,
-0.0141064934,
0.0612779483,
0.0014027386,
0.0086588925,
-0.0691670999,
0.0000716873,
-0.0041045547,
-0.0159522705,
-0.0250576362,
0.0155038247,
-0.0320761614,
-0.0196187161,
-0.0013969316,
0.0427418835,
0.0167999808,
-0.007663528,
-0.036722783,
0.0038972807,
-0.0310301669,
0.0081949523,
-0.0047504054,
-0.009132022,
-0.047757376,
-0.0025192637,
-0.0094664861,
-0.0481200293,
-0.0193891283,
-0.0061968323,
-0.0082814964,
-0.0394436643,
0.0010293609,
0.0490924083,
-0.0263403319,
-0.0502553768,
-0.0328287445,
-0.0126265287,
-0.0066982554,
-0.060070727,
-0.0167920385,
-0.0337636657,
0.0282590333,
0.0148662953,
0.0152093461,
-0.0143231936,
-0.0210244041,
0.0542984605,
-0.0389237516,
0.0503188893,
0.00632917,
0.005703242,
0.0132642752,
0.0077768331,
0.0103551783,
0.0908335894,
0.014381839,
-0.0080274418,
0.062533848,
0.0059830979,
-0.0158181116,
0.0397917815,
0.0246197786,
0.0123840375,
0.0023143576,
0.0315979458,
-0.0193490051,
0.0053623444,
-0.0017346565,
0.0494710915,
-0.0179244317,
-0.0384586416,
0.0528044589,
0.0252497084,
0.0068379757,
0.0036298174,
0.0432890207,
0.0165316146,
0.0334473401,
0.043384593,
-0.0467596203,
-0.0370576233,
-0.0557403266,
0.0224966817,
-0.0064225825,
0.0304640308,
-0.0177986622,
-0.034916915,
-0.0193366017,
0.0134013994,
0.0294447187,
0.0407128185,
0.0644731075,
0.0363416597,
-0.057655368,
0.0247359518,
0.0174696557,
-0.0387946628,
0.0292532183,
-0.0070068799,
0.0660876408,
0.062807709,
0.0846616253,
-0.0208826344,
-0.0549810827,
0.017443357,
0.0242838636,
-0.0012186553,
0.0332666188,
-0.0415965058,
0.040831022,
-0.0405189171,
-0.0191858299,
-0.0067699421,
0.0100955572,
0.0051834579,
0.0425654836,
0.0168096665,
0.0326468274,
-0.0851285756,
-0.0474500135,
0.0551348627,
-0.0726810545,
-0.0333009139,
-0.0292657297,
0.005533874,
-0.0108452523,
0.0102295317,
0.0069415472,
-0.0054202615,
0.0474075563,
-0.0140979094,
0.0036251303,
0.0036147234,
-0.068972379,
-0.0248946659,
0.0250946078,
-0.0180934127,
-0.0104544116,
0.0646587312,
-0.0305025503,
-0.0278940611,
-0.0177449249,
-0.0053977952,
0.0037121647,
-0.04356727,
0.0101475203,
-0.0249708034,
0.0064447341,
-0.0652756244,
0.0617362708,
-0.0027485162,
0.0256074686,
0.0338857584,
0.0298265275,
0.0054802247,
-0.0136724049,
-0.0582536831,
0.0057697087,
-0.0056709899,
-0.0002238649,
0.026663037,
0.0306465942,
-0.0906711891,
-0.0093825059,
-0.0859449953,
0.0060556415,
-0.0202219225,
0.0061899824,
0.0486645252,
-0.0012514455,
-0.0127757788,
-0.0017468799,
-0.0038567327,
-0.0212385021,
0.0098413974,
0.0144299716,
0.0219078567,
-0.0001063135,
0.0252700113,
-0.0416632108,
-0.027438134,
-0.0296001825,
0.0686126798,
0.0337411948,
0.0044125738,
-0.0565335117,
0.0063926918,
-0.0251096617,
0.0068171774,
0.0030984699,
-0.0126512572,
-0.0067035817,
-0.0237748902,
0.016263647,
0.0762919411,
0.0045728106,
0.0060460619,
0.0569302179,
-0.0167943537,
-0.0535186864,
0.0170499384,
-0.0115572726,
-0.0230107401,
-0.0318292603,
-0.0278366879,
-0.0113288099,
0.0526750237,
-0.0006709537,
-0.0311215296,
-0.0314112604,
0.0338403806,
-0.0721867532,
-0.0268760901,
-0.0515445247,
-0.0036469451,
-0.0238141119,
0.0369866267,
-0.0484494343,
-0.0437029004,
0.0768345296,
-0.0326656587,
-0.0103230681,
-0.0663673729,
0.0287937615,
-0.0293017793,
0.0671090335,
0.0227283798,
0.0144794816,
-0.0162279103,
-0.0247323513,
-0.0558118224,
-0.0055429814,
0.0193820391,
-0.0407834984,
0.0535993502,
-0.052147612,
0.0130124381,
0.0072446223,
-0.009685331,
-0.0706551149,
-0.0343757607,
-0.0146969575,
-0.014591408,
-0.0275438633,
0.0022628633,
-0.0404448472,
0.0078349803,
0.0009259488,
0.0464654863,
-0.0306196921,
-0.0186314806,
-0.0079553621,
0.0663641244,
0.0579619482,
-0.0022893054,
0.0127061419,
-0.0266479123,
0.0318817869,
0.0641767979,
0.0254235771,
-0.0003999153,
-0.0195909757,
0.022825215,
0.0359505899,
-0.0347911902,
0.0430294387,
-0.0162654426,
0.0412370302,
-0.0766159743,
-0.040289171,
0.1143418998,
0.0459188744,
-0.0302217454,
-0.0058771218,
0.0048091705,
0.0294767264,
0.0069912514,
0.0087693036,
-0.1001691222,
-0.0256518871,
0.0180822778,
0.0467727259,
0.0066014952,
-0.0439276658,
-0.0245743133,
-0.0970624536,
-0.0118311057,
0.0029460983,
-0.0382261463,
0.0094192317,
-0.0412248373,
0.0121532818,
-0.0327412114,
0.0420644917,
0.0386847593,
-0.0006929711,
0.0287506543,
-0.0220822673,
-0.0026675805,
-0.0503082499,
0.0542185865,
0.0107789878,
0.0143598616,
0.0345866494,
0.0270389281,
0.0020047829,
0.0104653807,
0.0422227234,
-0.0627162158,
-0.0109488433,
-0.011366629,
0.0730368868,
-0.0165071283,
0.0039146133,
0.0040103854,
0.0331130624,
-0.0321481302,
-0.0085636126,
0.022689661,
0.0489271879,
0.0124214021,
-0.0332509801,
-0.0314369537,
0.0062441006,
0.011923301,
0.1068930626,
0.0245025493,
-0.0376472697,
-0.0279860087,
-0.0115876291,
0.0094715124,
-0.0704844892,
-0.0218336433,
0.0431333818,
0.0048757629,
-0.0203081761,
-0.0824401751,
-0.1015786976,
0.0157449674,
0.0040570474,
0.0486296415,
0.021296829,
-0.0061570499,
-0.018139502,
-0.0513038523,
0.036366079,
-0.0332134254,
0.0118763214,
-0.0527859181,
-0.0016396501,
0.008179877,
-0.0052756779,
-0.0298064314,
0.0809459463,
-0.1252704561,
-0.0532975309,
0.0276836902,
0.0200676676,
0.0237311479,
0.0512458496,
-0.047384724,
-0.013016344,
0.0676849782,
-0.0428178199,
-0.0512678325,
0.0282822009,
0.0176979676,
-0.0296676718,
-0.008327039,
0.0333846509,
-0.0381625928,
0.0085612917,
0.009350854,
0.0407436043,
-0.0016111513,
-0.0042859078,
0.0303000323,
0.0210095365,
0.0284572113,
-0.0136255156,
-0.0136335548,
-0.025289271,
0.0178128779,
-0.0097998651,
-0.0264031235,
-0.0291281007,
0.0295332149,
0.0258105528,
-0.0378090851,
-0.02041745,
0.0305032227,
-0.0083114197,
0.0716899484,
-0.0448048003,
0.0070251366,
0.0295700859,
0.0235235002,
0.0135267237,
0.0002840811,
-0.0391000547,
0.0029264959,
-0.0402265638,
0.0415407866,
0.0045069847,
0.0463254601,
0.022252094,
-0.0192726776,
-0.0048688501,
0.0233163778,
-0.1002485752,
-0.0085261231,
-0.0308207534,
0.0071301372,
0.0137751764,
-0.0324940458,
0.0491659567,
-0.0226991158,
-0.0182570964,
-0.0476473793,
0.0045283497,
0.0248429533,
-0.0248057656,
0.0020110982,
0.0180638526,
0.0104264831,
0.0315065943,
0.0756682828,
0.0100684203,
0.0458350517,
0.028475685,
-0.0112882638,
-0.0457119904,
-0.0194367245,
-0.013586117,
0.02522997,
-0.0237524379,
-0.0113683799,
-0.0527898036,
-0.0834133998,
0.0131627945,
0.0113641173,
-0.003404466,
0.0040360149,
0.003929201,
0.0802563876,
-0.0068696192,
0.0158078987,
-0.0547519028,
0.059291482,
0.0052199359,
-0.0284963939,
-0.025138285,
-6.793477931e-33,
-0.0045542517,
-0.0272311363,
0.0050842855,
-0.0461971834,
-0.0184593499,
0.0532823056,
-0.0477454104,
-0.0219123196,
-0.0337805152,
-0.0081320796,
-0.0221281257,
0.0267261043,
0.009558524,
0.0323435143,
-0.0339216404,
-0.0236412678,
0.0343726538,
-0.0002856033,
-0.0451403521,
0.0338294208,
0.0328483544,
0.049684085,
0.0438501425,
-0.0321069509,
0.0459524132,
-0.043906495,
-0.0152278747,
-0.0029967274,
0.0098431483,
0.039674554,
-0.0453634784,
0.0307458118,
0.0359440558,
-0.0193392597,
-0.0040717246,
0.0179494489,
-0.1235779375,
-0.0455693528,
0.0217659194,
0.0143290302,
-0.0628097579,
-0.0027506405,
0.0176739432,
-0.0257065948,
0.0314199477,
-0.0316880234,
0.0320143513,
-0.0231743529,
-0.0504335761,
0.0101935416,
-0.0629616678,
0.03583524,
-0.0280574393,
-0.0097356401,
0.0100209247,
0.0723184273,
0.030722443,
0.0541517772,
-0.0598695129,
0.0020813765,
0.0411638133,
0.0071241586,
0.0462835133,
0.0245544743,
0.0117566483,
0.0542412885,
-0.024705844,
-0.0050125513,
0.0093546864,
-0.0044838339,
0.0491873696,
-0.0129982466,
-0.0054775462,
0.0392004624,
0.0308981184,
-0.0051825745,
-0.0480119064,
0.0468101613,
0.0259363856,
0.0265612248,
0.0199972726,
-0.0347862467,
-0.0406727642,
-0.0015212168,
-0.0714374706,
-0.0025357569,
-0.0539562255,
-0.0154028255,
0.0500434935,
0.0004453794,
-0.0575466044,
-0.0208976418,
0.0157400537,
-0.0408807807,
-0.0143200206,
0.0529412962,
-0.0286946036,
-0.0023875316,
-0.0088256635,
0.076274626,
-0.0074456418,
0.0085504428,
-0.0016573514,
0.0040434613,
0.0081294579,
-0.0051287948,
0.0131219635,
0.0293176118,
-0.0443553813,
0.0004711846,
-0.0315973163,
0.0147956973,
0.0000981488,
0.0311789718,
0.0430531576,
0.0321549065,
-0.0144154252,
0.0589282811,
0.0535730757,
0.0450578257,
-0.0424585789,
0.0017513862,
0.0078265714,
0.0184304602,
-0.0274024867,
-0.036929138,
0.0002900884,
0.0175630357,
0.0096298745,
-0.0638182834,
0.034218125,
0.0444343388,
2.754e-7,
0.0619737282,
0.0321955867,
0.0190897249,
0.0238894615,
-0.0011991711,
0.0060394895,
-0.028153643,
0.0148855494,
0.0201725308,
0.0092569645,
0.0045629884,
0.0202216487,
0.0457725041,
0.0352724902,
-0.0960774422,
-0.0298350565,
-0.0348646902,
0.0102228718,
-0.0384733863,
0.005827181,
0.020400418,
0.0960314572,
0.0201976672,
-0.0358809568,
-0.0037454353,
-0.0951441601,
0.0330323167,
-0.030229127,
-0.0389878675,
0.0473523699,
0.0548723303,
0.0274567436,
0.0288094431,
0.0095128277,
-0.0325405337,
0.009513434,
-0.0035281712,
0.0151214208,
0.0225943066,
-0.0499671213,
-0.0340745337,
-0.0396197848,
0.0096542556,
-0.0914617181,
0.1074251011,
-0.0258550905,
-0.0120619573,
-0.0232918747,
-0.0319265574,
-0.0076283538,
0.0322744437,
-0.0108779389,
-0.0328235067,
0.039671503,
0.0105265742,
-0.0168467592,
0.0028654814,
-0.0806413889,
-0.0172233954,
-0.0003899439,
-0.0285192374,
-0.0502909794,
-0.0257550292,
-0.0565753952,
-0.0068776282,
-0.0887917951,
0.0350626037,
2.567580423e-34,
0.0408726484,
-0.0261418223,
-0.0088593634,
0.0075597889,
0.0220969804,
-0.0221487824,
0.0181430802,
-0.0113804881,
0.006473477,
-0.0994449556,
-0.0059140613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12334v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12334v1 | PowMix: A Versatile Regularizer for Multimodal Sentiment Analysis | 2023-12-19T17:01:58 | 2023-12-19T17:01:58 | Efthymios Georgiou, Yannis Avrithis, Alexandros Potamianos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multimodal sentiment analysis (MSA) leverages heterogeneous data sources to
interpret the complex nature of human sentiments. Despite significant progress
in multimodal architecture design, the field lacks comprehensive regularization
methods. This paper introduces PowMix, a versatile embedding space regularizer
that builds upon the strengths of unimodal mixing-based regularization
approaches and introduces novel algorithmic components that are specifically
tailored to multimodal tasks. PowMix is integrated before the fusion stage of
multimodal architectures and facilitates intra-modal mixing, such as mixing
text with text, to act as a regularizer. PowMix consists of five components: 1)
a varying number of generated mixed examples, 2) mixing factor reweighting, 3)
anisotropic mixing, 4) dynamic mixing, and 5) cross-modal label mixing.
Extensive experimentation across benchmark MSA datasets and a broad spectrum of
diverse architectural designs demonstrate the efficacy of PowMix, as evidenced
by consistent performance improvements over baselines and existing mixing
methods. An in-depth ablation study highlights the critical contribution of
each PowMix component and how they synergistically enhance performance.
Furthermore, algorithmic analysis demonstrates how PowMix behaves in different
scenarios, particularly comparing early versus late fusion architectures.
Notably, PowMix enhances overall performance without sacrificing model
robustness or magnifying text dominance. It also retains its strong performance
in situations of limited data. Our findings position PowMix as a promising
versatile regularization strategy for MSA. Code will be made available. | [
0.0127385641,
0.0923490152,
0.0114582833,
0.0427312739,
0.0096087698,
-0.009443569,
-0.0114637325,
-0.0115627469,
-0.0150072081,
-0.0517650507,
-0.0507564247,
-0.0486775935,
0.0022733931,
0.0420189872,
0.055481717,
-0.0676693395,
0.0123952627,
0.0416086763,
0.0007453689,
-0.0077456986,
0.0691573545,
-0.0191684607,
-0.0128348796,
0.0441420563,
-0.0626866668,
-0.0023081545,
-0.023754511,
0.0392145663,
0.0377175324,
-0.0329907872,
-0.002081851,
0.019556202,
0.027708672,
0.028787626,
0.0000022924,
-0.0014345078,
0.0215332005,
0.0065027568,
0.062779285,
-0.0235268604,
0.080761455,
-0.0359711125,
0.0215149689,
-0.0264019072,
-0.0268401597,
-0.0567400157,
0.0841810629,
0.0724826679,
0.0711438134,
0.0347273275,
-0.0549794808,
-0.008637324,
0.0065869624,
0.0064237397,
0.0063626557,
-0.0084747402,
0.0070503713,
-0.0414256528,
0.0240472872,
-0.0056818607,
-0.042685315,
0.0131657906,
-0.019723298,
0.0072272364,
0.0401720293,
-0.004665033,
0.0061790356,
-0.0464436598,
-0.0517422333,
0.1012173444,
-0.0093171317,
0.0320278034,
-0.0189073645,
-0.0004740141,
-0.0158855896,
-0.0127127329,
-0.0316399708,
-0.0212001503,
0.0000182548,
0.0107537275,
-0.0680801496,
0.0241407473,
0.0246321727,
-0.0090756482,
-0.0080502229,
0.0130530121,
0.0178738981,
-0.0144724054,
0.0132728592,
0.034596175,
0.0028217668,
-0.0086089419,
0.0001362859,
-0.0079536028,
0.0145277223,
-0.0107824579,
-0.0356238447,
-0.0459146686,
-0.0024335855,
-0.0369065553,
0.0211900584,
0.0303648375,
-0.0718084723,
0.0445988476,
0.0027591176,
-0.0396477841,
-0.0253998283,
0.0311830733,
-0.0309515353,
-0.0000534066,
-0.0505499728,
-0.0072773988,
0.0349864028,
0.019090645,
-0.0173883177,
-0.0619279742,
-0.0455448665,
0.0077773747,
-0.0512834974,
-0.0054343976,
-0.0115756858,
0.0433682799,
0.0190077815,
0.015261204,
-0.0100666517,
0.064125143,
-0.0400461331,
0.0372123197,
-0.0037434984,
-0.0170762036,
0.009882818,
0.0392124243,
0.0090333782,
-0.0253327284,
-0.0023419575,
0.0819581449,
-0.0259258728,
-0.0236775503,
-0.0065763439,
-0.0311629623,
-0.0390112102,
-0.0453456491,
0.0312850438,
-0.0197780412,
0.0735070035,
-0.0164545048,
0.0197288301,
-0.0143451924,
-0.0100739738,
-0.0184133947,
-0.0258681588,
0.0845308229,
-0.0550756268,
-0.0419472679,
-0.0183579288,
0.0158339627,
-0.0029296291,
0.0697346255,
-0.0106267883,
0.0469581187,
0.0383704379,
0.0120655242,
-0.0190860517,
-0.0088969171,
-0.0119541604,
-0.0062826811,
-0.0408369228,
-0.0436316617,
-0.0329485871,
-0.000162688,
0.0405795202,
0.0638273954,
-0.023170732,
-0.0075713242,
0.0364320315,
0.0099054938,
-0.0178879555,
0.0127323186,
0.003939949,
-0.0156012615,
0.011009533,
0.0167468619,
-0.0100365644,
0.0374240912,
-0.0166901536,
-0.0412495546,
0.0980603248,
0.0837799907,
-0.0292559229,
-0.028378455,
-0.0095129618,
-0.0468228534,
0.0258099623,
-0.0188593678,
0.0186722856,
-0.0252484959,
-0.0431190357,
-0.0171479527,
0.0408410802,
-0.0595378168,
0.0034013675,
0.014196841,
0.0146461381,
0.0751121417,
0.0089287087,
-0.0552427284,
0.0198274404,
0.0003307844,
-0.0256531797,
0.0025447989,
0.0161356758,
-0.0024763623,
0.0763866901,
-0.0622820966,
-0.0699184537,
-0.0031626823,
0.015130789,
0.0326871537,
-0.0511511564,
0.0059552747,
-0.0221203119,
0.0018734969,
0.0699531063,
-0.0004179695,
0.0636522919,
-0.006880376,
0.009542481,
0.023999704,
0.010819844,
0.0354346931,
-0.0145477215,
-0.0109115932,
0.0207391437,
-0.0450263247,
-0.0631085783,
0.0277988985,
-0.0484468862,
-0.0507092066,
0.0397892334,
-0.0509541743,
0.0161520354,
0.0104634408,
-0.0484269857,
-0.0264934506,
0.0461503714,
-0.0260908604,
0.0246424563,
-0.0148414867,
-0.034942504,
0.0135885943,
0.0285759475,
-0.0132034039,
0.0223833863,
-0.0252091512,
-0.0246176329,
-0.0057500014,
-0.0459996201,
0.0419101454,
0.0477382801,
-0.065957047,
0.0167966485,
-0.0094891535,
0.0324376449,
0.0086818058,
-0.0351535752,
-0.0191808473,
-0.0069660069,
-0.117937617,
-0.0315973237,
0.0152793806,
-0.0290336888,
-0.0256601647,
0.0384670347,
0.0263614859,
-0.0065387837,
-0.0121981949,
0.0112967947,
-0.0019731289,
0.0480519459,
0.018671209,
0.0478118919,
0.0350009799,
-0.0374208838,
-0.0221547466,
-0.0166556947,
0.0402847789,
-0.0273528937,
-0.00954895,
-0.0191097669,
-0.0387214981,
-0.0785534605,
0.0313658081,
-0.0125062307,
-0.0349574611,
0.0026588663,
-0.0289316811,
0.0456109084,
-0.0108193718,
-0.0122927995,
0.0079552624,
0.037874639,
-0.0093450937,
0.0036697302,
0.0258091539,
0.004754635,
0.0396831408,
-0.006760492,
0.0261558108,
-0.0294815637,
0.0542272143,
0.0121117234,
-0.0056522978,
-0.0484000668,
0.0261556674,
0.0029113742,
-0.0575882159,
-0.0190006029,
-0.0028062749,
0.0045315456,
0.012210492,
-0.0133654336,
-0.0394716039,
0.0671365932,
0.0068073547,
-0.0053511006,
-0.010705322,
-0.0059432713,
-0.026880756,
0.0220530555,
-0.0243854001,
0.0331979096,
-0.0338323861,
0.0448626317,
-0.0203102678,
-0.019650979,
-0.000510814,
0.0027678215,
0.0382155403,
0.0258297976,
-0.0111927027,
0.0114696072,
-0.0474087596,
0.0030918485,
-0.0673597455,
-0.0533794537,
-0.0466040745,
0.0445874594,
-0.0149738425,
-0.0104198996,
-0.0203571394,
0.0194844287,
-0.0371458344,
0.0082521681,
-0.0201209374,
0.0155787142,
0.058216624,
0.018394297,
0.0130623095,
0.0000549794,
-0.0234840363,
-0.0048670359,
0.046645388,
0.0281325001,
-0.0542573705,
-0.058798831,
0.0007368028,
0.0245618857,
0.080184713,
-0.0260070041,
-0.0263824742,
0.0683106631,
-0.0256436076,
0.0898330137,
0.0450827181,
0.0237040389,
-0.0894661918,
0.0132086705,
0.005556385,
0.0669039786,
0.034843009,
-0.0112528782,
-0.0568467081,
-0.0716823712,
-0.0146304574,
-0.0086227022,
0.0168945491,
-0.005599075,
0.0015832245,
-0.0643369853,
0.0153153632,
-0.0065612695,
-0.0025306414,
-0.0052646599,
-0.0386331975,
0.0149047468,
-0.0158760119,
-0.0196598768,
-0.0352901258,
0.0114967516,
-0.0111247124,
-0.0122941099,
-0.0164632574,
-0.0598922446,
-0.0112670995,
-0.019648727,
-0.0067057423,
0.012802342,
0.0525790416,
-0.0122927837,
-0.0735027567,
0.0314350687,
0.0368868448,
0.002775742,
-0.0312033836,
0.0889407843,
-0.0223534051,
-0.0265958793,
-0.0232061241,
-0.007195164,
-0.0140505079,
-0.00924592,
-0.04956818,
0.0690496489,
-0.0019205933,
0.008865878,
-0.0623293929,
0.0266772136,
0.0316847712,
0.0138424421,
-0.0202597976,
-0.0795253217,
-0.0270209983,
-0.0246791579,
0.0104541685,
-0.0361348055,
-0.0003818311,
-0.0163515825,
0.0008611674,
-0.0181693621,
-0.0513017699,
-0.0201630909,
-0.0122888442,
0.0383851901,
-0.0207943171,
0.0141186835,
-0.0545301326,
0.0172932595,
-0.0339456163,
0.0330750309,
0.0235481784,
0.0372227877,
0.0127488952,
0.0183964055,
0.0163015686,
0.0140006905,
0.0051719914,
0.0373712182,
-0.064182058,
-0.0573071726,
-0.0545562655,
0.0645116195,
0.0013437079,
-0.0130554391,
0.0477845632,
-0.036958959,
0.0328404643,
0.0377257913,
-0.0058439546,
0.0153773939,
0.0716288462,
0.005434542,
-0.0017797581,
0.0085861906,
-0.0431568846,
0.0080284663,
-0.018556077,
-0.0094095776,
0.0103959981,
-0.0181586128,
-0.0139070991,
-0.0317420773,
0.0348160863,
-0.0339945778,
-0.0082678553,
-0.027087843,
-0.015801765,
-0.0044952952,
-0.0090272492,
-0.0705102012,
-0.0070596207,
0.0243294574,
0.0028092104,
-0.0327177756,
-0.0002262696,
0.00613529,
0.0609511696,
-0.0166571029,
0.0744301304,
0.0523471721,
-0.029897267,
-0.0112993252,
0.0424944274,
0.0243407059,
0.0184395891,
-0.0157346837,
-0.0308402013,
-0.0198516306,
0.0284642372,
0.0042040041,
-0.0176015534,
-0.0236237999,
0.0590568073,
-0.0235616397,
0.0580177791,
-0.0167576224,
-0.0234322194,
0.0345195308,
0.0034886801,
0.0500858538,
0.0272984393,
-0.0172597319,
-0.0069227964,
0.0202817153,
-0.0457429625,
-0.0254098698,
0.0553325117,
-0.0043886318,
-0.01621796,
0.0183187816,
0.0665638,
-0.0584752373,
0.0309539549,
-0.0042437627,
0.0191461369,
-0.0590905845,
0.0187517051,
0.1111359075,
0.0908105001,
-0.0017909638,
0.0087299086,
-0.0325345397,
-0.0555257648,
0.0591454133,
-0.041764684,
-0.0215173475,
0.0208204333,
0.0334472731,
0.0217443183,
0.0119032683,
0.0275880825,
-0.0104114534,
-0.0422996506,
0.0174077805,
-0.0175747648,
0.044184804,
-6.876478118e-33,
0.0077538118,
0.0071460069,
-0.0380933434,
-0.0488290414,
-0.0335098282,
0.0239699855,
-0.0052983686,
0.0368720032,
0.0257123373,
0.0292622782,
0.0203173831,
-0.0268676206,
-0.0152215753,
0.0348248444,
0.0238442719,
0.0204726383,
0.0312300418,
0.0116352094,
0.0278875269,
-0.0016061864,
0.0213765744,
0.0364566334,
0.020600386,
-0.1196644232,
0.0333586559,
0.0464869328,
-0.0512652919,
-0.0257175826,
0.044209566,
0.0476989225,
-0.0494872406,
0.0780268088,
0.0209610276,
0.0296687745,
-0.0239200704,
0.0410727039,
-0.0051573343,
-0.0132935857,
0.0166388955,
0.0018384515,
-0.0780399367,
-0.0236072671,
0.0176039208,
-0.0129602021,
-0.0073480192,
-0.0317783915,
0.0399353504,
0.000187916,
0.0153648667,
-0.0180474967,
-0.0448606983,
0.0140574174,
-0.0198858194,
-0.0057313801,
0.0279895011,
0.0537145063,
0.0394471809,
0.0360201299,
-0.036882177,
0.0388166867,
-0.0751663521,
-0.0181655996,
0.0174690261,
0.0251756478,
0.0100066131,
0.0829873309,
0.0418035202,
-0.0055392995,
-0.0094073489,
0.030190751,
0.0183280557,
0.0303677879,
0.0309706423,
0.0997018144,
0.0367769711,
-0.0127663147,
-0.0069408589,
0.0303676147,
0.0190107748,
-0.0250944495,
0.0183727965,
0.0837689936,
0.0021411919,
-0.0068056122,
0.008929926,
-0.0505903438,
-0.0296483021,
-0.0333196446,
0.0023341246,
0.0322576351,
-0.0144670513,
0.0250979196,
0.0386664718,
-0.0454052016,
-0.0106820744,
0.0306661222,
-0.034035515,
0.0500902459,
0.0290793329,
-0.0214465819,
-0.0241262186,
-0.0121532381,
0.0481444821,
-0.0103448164,
0.0183359347,
-0.0312419459,
0.0061537316,
0.0565344915,
-0.0760614872,
-0.024306694,
0.0022606354,
0.0090098213,
-0.0029790204,
0.0411233492,
0.0134081542,
0.0099827386,
-0.0401674137,
0.034444429,
-0.0009985456,
0.0619126856,
-0.0296643991,
-0.0660650432,
0.0015341947,
-0.0048814621,
-0.0071503608,
-0.0244728941,
-0.0085371388,
-0.1028465703,
0.028004447,
-0.0969844386,
-0.0192758162,
-0.0075586028,
3e-7,
0.0133731682,
0.0484126061,
0.0072286315,
-0.059973266,
0.0135414042,
0.0489196517,
-0.0126471035,
0.0253846124,
-0.0295024049,
-0.0549638867,
0.0096333073,
0.043482706,
0.0278301872,
0.0303280707,
-0.0309104323,
0.0090603894,
-0.0046365359,
-0.0104209529,
-0.0398572087,
0.0417598039,
0.0819148123,
0.1161451265,
0.0048165452,
-0.0488991886,
0.0056322147,
-0.009537464,
0.0760607645,
-0.0021979262,
-0.0234612338,
-0.0292164441,
0.0229651462,
-0.0180142038,
0.0036382487,
-0.0359654687,
-0.0027024401,
-0.0208839234,
0.0434719399,
0.0447923951,
-0.0373963378,
-0.0847471431,
0.0080876891,
0.0377941169,
-0.0354849473,
0.0122213028,
0.0378194004,
0.0032758561,
-0.0465049148,
-0.0731689781,
-0.0180161707,
0.0252544787,
0.0616349764,
-0.0111892335,
-0.0366035365,
0.0175424851,
0.0266992599,
-0.0032286029,
-0.0573039427,
-0.0933419392,
-0.004484823,
0.0235652551,
-0.0534885079,
-0.0127280625,
-0.0074350489,
-0.0070972145,
0.0583946221,
-0.043639604,
-0.0238132775,
2.695097454e-34,
0.0639219657,
-0.0619066544,
0.0238014665,
-0.0222037863,
0.0238458924,
-0.036205247,
-0.0268510692,
-0.0233252849,
0.0303690862,
-0.0621769093,
0.0076243924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12321v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12321v2 | Bypassing the Safety Training of Open-Source LLMs with Priming Attacks | 2023-12-19T16:47:12 | 2024-05-17T05:27:25 | Jason Vega, Isha Chaudhary, Changming Xu, Gagandeep Singh | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | With the recent surge in popularity of LLMs has come an ever-increasing need
for LLM safety training. In this paper, we investigate the fragility of SOTA
open-source LLMs under simple, optimization-free attacks we refer to as
$\textit{priming attacks}$, which are easy to execute and effectively bypass
alignment from safety training. Our proposed attack improves the Attack Success
Rate on Harmful Behaviors, as measured by Llama Guard, by up to $3.3\times$
compared to baselines. Source code and data are available at
https://github.com/uiuc-focal-lab/llm-priming-attacks. | [
-0.039862562,
0.0134406704,
-0.0060834954,
0.0369651541,
0.0048487135,
-0.0176835172,
0.0107993912,
0.022479644,
-0.0225524697,
0.0030640443,
-0.0258259922,
0.04592577,
-0.0067214179,
-0.0231431704,
0.0559246875,
0.0177016277,
0.0875421315,
-0.036279887,
-0.0528595373,
-0.0116532268,
0.0005974503,
-0.0635175854,
-0.0425140522,
-0.0189857874,
0.001364412,
-0.0261325669,
-0.050201539,
0.0382376313,
0.0583599284,
-0.0880202278,
0.0202548318,
-0.0256208312,
0.0279440023,
0.0343913361,
0.0000019137,
-0.0152272815,
-0.0329250246,
0.0300700739,
-0.0036725677,
0.0325102322,
-0.0290306769,
-0.029673893,
-0.0368344113,
0.0390298069,
-0.0180012193,
0.026892459,
-0.0103469081,
0.0357969217,
0.0617135428,
0.1019717306,
0.0387091488,
-0.0134349307,
0.031614773,
-0.032201536,
0.015998045,
-0.0651244372,
-0.0063034398,
-0.0207461882,
-0.025743261,
0.0166899525,
-0.0157693867,
-0.0452035852,
0.0004803143,
0.0052908463,
0.0015114637,
0.0414948463,
-0.0317842737,
0.011974806,
-0.0451929122,
0.0217367597,
-0.0440544821,
-0.011304196,
0.0265807863,
-0.0010869799,
0.00946128,
-0.0295007937,
0.0149808852,
0.0264578573,
0.0055738371,
0.025766341,
0.0039032269,
0.0085143577,
0.0212512966,
-0.0171712115,
0.0465771854,
0.0763529986,
0.0217537712,
-0.0504940003,
0.0430239998,
-0.0190559924,
0.0450494587,
-0.0134156263,
-0.0477174334,
0.0416955985,
0.0067995912,
-0.0020385217,
-0.0598483495,
-0.0129476124,
0.0383530967,
-0.0194244068,
0.0294498559,
0.0233805571,
-0.0090646083,
-0.0185908992,
-0.045407664,
0.0035947554,
-0.0365431458,
0.1030264422,
-0.0023722774,
0.0982777923,
0.0071315086,
0.046635624,
0.0432374626,
0.0078013339,
0.0051556854,
0.0580365472,
-0.0611606054,
0.0310931504,
-0.0176128279,
0.0391184092,
-0.0543460026,
-0.0048901234,
-0.0037968312,
0.0220508147,
-0.0110256998,
-0.0843654647,
0.0009874289,
-0.0142127881,
-0.0108441217,
-0.0485472903,
-0.051886674,
0.0398573317,
-0.0819516107,
-0.0208796524,
0.0192944501,
0.0890222639,
0.0063990047,
-0.0441958383,
-0.0790164918,
-0.0537094027,
0.0035574394,
-0.0151654519,
0.0488675572,
-0.0609053969,
-0.018000206,
-0.0552490763,
-0.0128480075,
-0.0201054886,
0.0205680896,
-0.0057024932,
-0.0097786887,
0.063746132,
0.00270572,
0.0059930533,
0.0065677743,
0.0443513654,
-0.0187396761,
0.0426436849,
-0.0046178061,
0.0153360348,
0.0387493111,
-0.0008542115,
0.0352176614,
0.0448732153,
0.0125253377,
0.0210553873,
0.030983923,
-0.002102403,
0.0326998793,
0.0189937819,
0.0206828751,
0.004629483,
-0.0173896253,
-0.0169757567,
0.0545239225,
0.0629831925,
-0.0378852822,
0.0194344129,
-0.0396188386,
-0.0329976268,
0.0281056948,
-0.0209899489,
-0.0613466538,
0.027798662,
-0.0815433711,
-0.002706469,
-0.0265248735,
0.0572162382,
-0.0413153283,
-0.0114965709,
-0.0244455319,
-0.0470726416,
-0.0686600879,
-0.0109633524,
0.0093199825,
-0.0044230833,
-0.0294261109,
0.0735679567,
0.0355165042,
-0.0716754049,
-0.0430065244,
-0.0663922206,
0.004616647,
-0.0313592106,
0.0156556033,
-0.038436994,
-0.049655918,
-0.0122016808,
-0.0454188436,
0.013831174,
-0.0140406312,
0.0421981998,
0.0295889061,
-0.0157867223,
-0.0057596751,
-0.0286792871,
0.005989626,
0.0235984586,
0.0272361003,
-0.0008719813,
-0.0113608995,
0.0009839676,
-0.0320093445,
0.0587377958,
-0.0080070347,
-0.077813141,
-0.0176857598,
0.0231151655,
0.0539135002,
0.0261369366,
-0.0368504636,
-0.0040808665,
0.0606529228,
-0.0007108263,
0.0443615392,
-0.025744481,
0.0083591323,
0.0127004003,
0.0529124774,
-0.0522113368,
0.0044135642,
0.0139842024,
-0.0689398125,
-0.0021852506,
-0.0110492324,
0.0097886631,
-0.0260861907,
0.0041626696,
0.0248144437,
0.0229125693,
0.0063449373,
-0.0201832317,
0.0428906754,
0.0050326549,
-0.0191065166,
-0.0090329004,
0.006186638,
0.0324761495,
-0.05706238,
-0.0465179794,
-0.0087700095,
-0.0389038809,
0.0098784193,
-0.0422069542,
0.0618501827,
-0.0152268568,
-0.0030885856,
-0.0120548429,
0.0205730721,
-0.0252255928,
0.0412120596,
0.0163342059,
-0.0631910935,
-0.0494790748,
-0.0021916784,
0.0104508717,
0.0096840104,
-0.0150424689,
-0.038974788,
0.0145050064,
-0.0236611292,
-0.0622050352,
0.0083724651,
0.0196178705,
0.0001758957,
-0.0005075965,
-0.0404244736,
-0.0085304175,
-0.041901622,
0.0514256395,
-0.0077028396,
0.025447011,
-0.0251258984,
-0.0370450504,
0.0468528084,
0.0475584157,
-0.0251376275,
0.0813093111,
0.0087925065,
0.0077982531,
0.0862219408,
0.0630928054,
-0.0519199222,
0.0102221342,
0.0310654249,
-0.0898326263,
-0.0316035561,
-0.0067830011,
0.0086131841,
0.0568973161,
-0.0254151803,
-0.0000363516,
0.0066832937,
-0.0304781292,
0.0330308303,
-0.0335439257,
0.0064671836,
-0.0026810723,
-0.0783797577,
0.0002509138,
0.0186209362,
-0.083686173,
0.0271787755,
-0.0328990854,
0.005246175,
0.0076446231,
-0.0377574153,
-0.004172151,
-0.0001820293,
-0.0358181521,
0.0012046151,
0.0224306565,
0.0032543729,
-0.0039678221,
-0.0345392935,
0.0237674993,
-0.0304703582,
0.02086116,
-0.0143646393,
-0.0043311892,
-0.0467523336,
-0.0378390886,
-0.051725544,
-0.0155529771,
-0.0087326886,
-0.0411321744,
-0.0416170768,
-0.0149865039,
0.0379333533,
-0.0652991757,
0.0449376218,
-0.0427035429,
-0.020118678,
-0.0148783587,
-0.0385210626,
-0.0252774358,
0.0011588406,
-0.0563866459,
0.0295438562,
-0.0510567874,
0.0018691345,
0.0738935471,
0.0677256286,
-0.0333195329,
-0.0611794926,
-0.0102253985,
0.0313605182,
-0.0274668243,
0.0092487168,
0.0526231453,
0.0523596555,
0.0304553285,
-0.0055436185,
0.007764752,
0.0099176774,
-0.0250872541,
0.0315927118,
-0.0069396324,
0.0348702669,
0.0112856142,
0.0382792018,
-0.061531052,
-0.004233242,
0.0349141061,
0.1278804243,
-0.0068663592,
-0.0096006133,
0.0003925208,
-0.0755531415,
0.0187936854,
0.0308924969,
-0.0207990035,
-0.0355620235,
0.0242581014,
-0.0157310758,
-0.0090306578,
0.0517604426,
0.0418982878,
-0.0082114292,
0.0017615573,
0.0376661457,
0.0013441473,
0.0072787749,
0.0010846331,
-0.0414270312,
0.0510880053,
0.0460216478,
-0.0468685366,
-0.0248998571,
-0.05227229,
0.0502158888,
-0.0106935864,
0.0236100219,
0.0053032716,
0.0190630034,
-0.0065513197,
0.0030843047,
-0.0032337762,
0.0565160289,
0.0058949115,
-0.0354032964,
0.0588382818,
0.0075362772,
-0.0388260894,
0.0166527051,
-0.0207554027,
-0.0133200651,
0.0050511328,
0.0219310746,
-0.0076848837,
0.0292678978,
-0.0134734856,
-0.0517437197,
-0.0048340936,
-0.0061065299,
-0.0488915518,
0.0074275578,
-0.03489656,
0.0074836565,
-0.0158005469,
-0.002335747,
-0.062574245,
0.0540701374,
0.0074224509,
-0.0677234828,
-0.0122523438,
0.0277283862,
-0.0290983766,
0.0057197763,
-0.038874492,
0.0486720614,
-0.0512052625,
0.0313974321,
0.0142973186,
-0.0004163396,
0.0030819413,
-0.0131947128,
-0.0408634469,
-0.072799176,
-0.0008801066,
0.0834630802,
0.0331273638,
0.0016179604,
0.0044862567,
0.0179807749,
0.0985994413,
0.0585483015,
-0.0130604161,
0.0641860217,
0.0697280392,
-0.0069394414,
0.0141641656,
0.0031853081,
-0.0008975998,
-0.017953882,
0.0614957921,
-0.0055660587,
-0.0524932072,
-0.0313481018,
-0.0141340969,
0.0572006144,
0.0561764166,
-0.0357541591,
0.0505839512,
0.0333703309,
0.0535234287,
0.0057601426,
0.0347198807,
0.01224849,
-0.0169659685,
0.0157212932,
-0.0277577769,
0.0366163962,
0.0146351391,
0.0176971257,
0.0307599735,
-0.0013107442,
0.0609472878,
-0.0041320189,
-0.0084030908,
0.0163315944,
0.0102721602,
0.0053881733,
0.0398280732,
-0.0065667965,
0.0198206287,
0.0312511325,
0.0381996408,
-0.0099834139,
0.0389683247,
-0.0271208175,
0.0228984803,
-0.0307527967,
-0.0475096107,
0.0370856635,
0.0365851074,
0.0470056571,
0.0358088538,
-0.0030377535,
-0.0159526579,
0.0128206322,
0.0026345341,
0.0197106618,
-0.0575080924,
0.0005024761,
0.0473306179,
-0.0051858337,
0.0147068091,
-0.0092904475,
0.0759197399,
-0.0084384531,
0.0726910979,
0.0020005694,
0.012885863,
-0.0351182632,
-0.0293502249,
0.0642726794,
-0.0006263196,
-0.0164302792,
-0.1062049717,
-0.0554466397,
-0.0362938493,
0.0200064965,
0.0181553941,
0.0135809425,
0.0203319862,
0.010954137,
-0.0216075908,
0.0104918918,
0.0065590371,
-0.0119875064,
-0.0358437262,
0.0542237461,
-0.0393504761,
0.0264192373,
-5.534510624e-33,
0.00593678,
-0.0174252242,
-0.0129534025,
0.0444939919,
-0.0344562009,
-0.022654267,
-0.0094922585,
0.0074313032,
0.0061054258,
-0.0486036837,
-0.0320582315,
-0.0052259262,
0.0236183424,
-0.0319342427,
-0.0255435165,
-0.0675380901,
-0.0471516736,
-0.042131491,
-0.0267553851,
-0.0282110553,
-0.009392363,
0.0337107666,
0.0225224178,
-0.0380708352,
0.0341220051,
-0.0154727651,
-0.0455944464,
-0.0046405233,
-0.0961738229,
0.0196120795,
0.0018962589,
0.0036994182,
-0.0210020244,
0.0072164722,
0.0198144037,
0.0091491556,
0.0020936625,
-0.0107735023,
-0.0151031259,
-0.0206702705,
-0.0028673704,
-0.066922769,
0.0319531187,
-0.0007159231,
-0.061374519,
-0.0090421,
-0.0221832041,
-0.0037144804,
-0.0144631276,
-0.04244316,
0.0251267254,
0.010330312,
-0.0067615691,
-0.009300191,
0.0029072615,
-0.0833185539,
0.0030699405,
-0.0353173204,
-0.0427041985,
0.0312405322,
0.0320485383,
-0.0101199076,
0.0386873148,
-0.002481343,
0.0082868924,
0.0453153066,
-0.0257025715,
-0.0196857732,
0.0226475727,
-0.0175664499,
0.0017823088,
0.0612395629,
0.0273471251,
0.0297793858,
0.0410943218,
-0.0122576468,
-0.0885097459,
0.0434122048,
0.048118595,
0.0344202854,
-0.0276651978,
0.0349720977,
-0.0536122024,
0.0132896649,
0.0286476295,
-0.0074122064,
0.0186916851,
-0.0053723175,
0.0035663194,
0.0313112773,
-0.0207213797,
-0.0418565273,
-0.0178127829,
0.0113060446,
0.0721014291,
-0.0203661807,
0.0349391215,
-0.0206278656,
-0.0201370772,
-0.0493959226,
-0.0336481519,
-0.0516984425,
-0.031529326,
-0.0907059237,
0.0626070872,
-0.0160811078,
0.0316887051,
0.0401198752,
-0.0626655966,
0.0256110728,
-0.0157558396,
0.0430254266,
0.064307332,
-0.0214415062,
0.03356307,
-0.0455913022,
0.008070942,
0.0056294892,
0.0339174345,
-0.0089707142,
-0.0336865559,
0.0417607836,
-0.0004456172,
0.0399198532,
0.0135869095,
0.0554882549,
0.0377791338,
0.0665056035,
-0.0152707091,
-0.0640229955,
-0.0013979573,
-0.0305728186,
2.633e-7,
-0.0299265441,
-0.0054436438,
0.0397527739,
0.0605946705,
0.0034081787,
0.0700095147,
-0.0503811687,
0.0929318368,
-0.0168151166,
-0.0634235069,
0.0002345059,
0.0107790343,
0.0386683606,
0.0029447793,
0.0184607934,
0.0021608383,
-0.0143620996,
0.01725653,
-0.0365085192,
-0.0477819517,
0.0314235352,
0.0206834711,
0.019525703,
-0.0223932341,
0.0159218572,
-0.0424448736,
0.019371856,
0.0131313782,
0.0001166819,
-0.0185288768,
0.066825971,
0.025844112,
-0.046786651,
0.0300535951,
-0.0294916034,
-0.0326306112,
-0.0704175085,
0.0406920202,
0.0213535037,
-0.0366818272,
-0.0089656785,
-0.0327392668,
-0.0286388919,
0.0166762173,
0.0738118291,
0.0493493155,
0.0145076057,
0.027546376,
-0.050402116,
-0.0249154568,
0.0289577171,
-0.0242508613,
0.0635517985,
0.005186615,
-0.0099311229,
0.006514098,
-0.0218469389,
-0.0345221162,
-0.0134159653,
0.0062958896,
0.0132656731,
-0.0953525379,
0.0227370933,
0.0779870525,
-0.0158579648,
-0.0156421922,
-0.0610925294,
2.473425622e-34,
-0.0511304624,
-0.0470962226,
0.0205748342,
0.0233437419,
-0.0053048753,
-0.0070486283,
0.0160011202,
-0.0211999621,
0.0063724904,
-0.0043019829,
-0.0070003606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12299v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12299v1 | Instruct-SCTG: Guiding Sequential Controlled Text Generation through Instructions | 2023-12-19T16:20:49 | 2023-12-19T16:20:49 | Yinhong Liu, Yixuan Su, Ehsan Shareghi, Nigel Collier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction-tuned large language models have shown remarkable performance in
aligning generated text with user intentions across various tasks. However,
maintaining human-like discourse structure in the generated text remains a
challenging research question. In this paper, we propose Instruct-SCTG, a
flexible and effective sequential framework that harnesses instruction-tuned
language models to generate structurally coherent text in both fine-tuned and
zero-shot setups. Our framework generates articles in a section-by-section
manner, aligned with the desired human structure using natural language
instructions. Furthermore, we introduce a new automatic metric that measures
discourse divergence in a fuzzy manner. Extensive experiments on three datasets
from representative domains of news and recipes demonstrate the
state-of-the-art performance of our framework in imposing discourse structure
during text generation, as verified by both automatic and human evaluation. Our
code will be available on Github. | [
0.0230763927,
0.0494987033,
0.0070677609,
-0.0127241472,
-0.0301425066,
-0.0026460316,
-0.0075616254,
0.0208660904,
-0.0094171371,
-0.0386574492,
0.005359882,
-0.0192805808,
0.0202989765,
0.0209536441,
0.0017918603,
-0.05069758,
0.0109486999,
-0.0171835572,
0.0280327499,
0.0131477211,
0.0271612611,
0.0296813585,
-0.0046826052,
0.0248712674,
0.0019962979,
-0.0243401844,
-0.0131475981,
0.0236575007,
0.0296581741,
-0.0346260741,
0.0389774255,
0.0509157814,
-0.0053770081,
0.017488746,
0.0000018583,
-0.008038356,
0.0125735421,
-0.0095275957,
0.0383422263,
0.0316366479,
0.0327646397,
-0.0147430319,
-0.0165358502,
0.0139968768,
-0.0450226255,
0.0437089093,
0.0297220685,
0.0604627617,
0.0904081464,
0.0868096575,
-0.015891552,
-0.0623105019,
-0.0163353179,
0.0029414636,
-0.01141789,
-0.0003492731,
-0.0274759308,
0.0106017431,
0.0146187153,
0.0474586859,
0.0238463804,
0.0179484524,
0.018749347,
-0.0202364158,
0.0139434515,
0.0516132377,
-0.0073577114,
-0.0311194453,
-0.0067474884,
0.0643383935,
0.0092303576,
-0.0371294804,
0.0370763242,
-0.0243279543,
-0.0180008803,
-0.0223204996,
-0.0369268209,
0.0367267653,
-0.0329916924,
0.0211374853,
0.0456910096,
0.0004172479,
-0.0116950748,
0.0287545919,
0.0152851669,
0.0382023454,
0.0165291801,
-0.0154588725,
-0.0341254771,
0.0194994435,
-0.0215082504,
-0.1061302796,
0.0300354175,
0.0420250818,
-0.0756984279,
-0.002332207,
-0.0829459056,
-0.0421296731,
0.0288236197,
-0.0434809215,
0.0430816002,
0.0252720565,
0.019667251,
0.0089655956,
-0.0142659415,
0.0681564435,
-0.0127828065,
-0.0436291248,
-0.0446939655,
0.0510939881,
-0.0452879667,
-0.0266340263,
-0.0230395962,
0.0116046518,
-0.0679834634,
-0.0633685887,
-0.0580511093,
0.0210474133,
0.0236262064,
0.0031974954,
0.0386893153,
0.0305890702,
-0.0458272286,
0.0016718466,
0.0009794887,
0.0065894919,
-0.0509066582,
-0.0022305145,
0.0398920178,
0.0338218734,
-0.012909322,
0.0310521144,
0.0079806373,
0.0278143641,
-0.0311552975,
0.0155107249,
-0.0731145144,
-0.0134911053,
-0.0189431757,
-0.0561614446,
-0.0123357065,
-0.0569498204,
-0.0249339268,
-0.0695625246,
-0.0002551132,
0.0036974056,
-0.010863306,
-0.0425644033,
0.0294757299,
0.0520622022,
-0.034427803,
-0.0021112845,
-0.0242330842,
0.0136242835,
0.0541575551,
0.0159207396,
0.0508585349,
0.058090426,
0.0496642888,
0.0272090621,
0.0325297378,
0.0176439844,
0.0143276462,
0.0156908315,
0.0113335215,
0.0032290816,
-0.0136988005,
0.0056218938,
-0.0711857453,
0.0532075763,
0.0172172654,
0.0759343058,
-0.0144034885,
0.0451748222,
0.0895208791,
0.0424030125,
0.0028463958,
0.0231927149,
0.0704718977,
0.0468079224,
-0.0138015579,
0.0670748129,
0.0161493737,
0.0310731065,
-0.0282434896,
0.0375748537,
0.0579867885,
0.0156432278,
-0.0137289539,
-0.0359762311,
0.0171287805,
-0.0046586618,
0.0436876528,
-0.0673575252,
0.0068344125,
0.0382292457,
-0.0729569942,
-0.0131379701,
0.0203450378,
-0.0685171783,
0.0182509776,
0.0035834571,
0.0570479743,
0.0692213699,
0.0533430502,
0.0204012822,
-0.0118929921,
0.003800153,
0.0678030252,
0.0782429725,
0.0058233645,
-0.0080884229,
-0.0181565266,
-0.0381099135,
-0.0140385367,
-0.0248458646,
0.0156788975,
-0.010367522,
0.0382445268,
0.0016588516,
0.0463127866,
0.0158984493,
-0.0697430596,
0.0478458218,
-0.0469075888,
-0.0023597004,
0.0178905167,
-0.0111307167,
-0.0003115142,
0.00686091,
-0.04065229,
0.0124794682,
0.0112979393,
-0.0175986998,
-0.0155431787,
-0.0046226387,
-0.0173345022,
-0.0163917616,
-0.0200712476,
-0.0612995178,
0.0159738343,
-0.0581256561,
-0.0153355664,
-0.0520358719,
0.0036473027,
-0.0486239344,
-0.0205133203,
-0.0237399507,
0.0232809354,
0.0207929667,
-0.0246801265,
-0.0491304696,
0.0605704263,
0.000423098,
0.0081549864,
0.0409446843,
-0.0346245877,
-0.013601413,
-0.0086044362,
0.033768408,
-0.0038701447,
0.0007345854,
0.0044358759,
0.0693099797,
0.0565985925,
-0.0284808744,
-0.0640089437,
-0.1082897931,
0.0200125109,
-0.0354939289,
-0.0015516891,
0.0507090501,
0.0027774852,
-0.0174610056,
0.0110871438,
-0.0310555678,
-0.0098945163,
0.0243931916,
0.0051537924,
0.0565605313,
-0.0004991474,
0.0155991949,
-0.0317993388,
0.0095798029,
0.0129192546,
0.0127054695,
0.0596859828,
0.0380899757,
-0.0922392234,
0.0153902713,
-0.043365173,
-0.040878322,
0.0088892635,
-0.0662504882,
0.0247706324,
0.0360163376,
0.071924001,
0.0632184595,
0.0608938932,
0.0522694178,
0.0142763928,
-0.0160555895,
-0.003429638,
-0.0153267942,
-0.0427317582,
0.0405297093,
-0.0133185964,
-0.0369503088,
0.0430291742,
0.0528282449,
0.0333331339,
0.0297406483,
-0.0552405976,
0.0371921994,
-0.0358821452,
-0.017152762,
0.0271154735,
-0.0271240994,
-0.0169194769,
0.0415044986,
-0.0170188081,
-0.0194921102,
0.0584550612,
-0.0340129808,
0.0248214658,
-0.0514328107,
-0.0102156857,
-0.027375726,
0.0219279379,
0.0214623846,
0.0380973853,
0.0346090943,
-0.0075134798,
-0.0610071234,
0.0176476482,
0.0402535461,
-0.0264736041,
0.0352709405,
-0.0785539225,
-0.0160825588,
-0.0099500744,
-0.034585014,
-0.0297361035,
-0.0666353181,
0.0201071911,
-0.0103374012,
0.0646722019,
-0.0354570337,
-0.0225026421,
0.0060369549,
0.0313419886,
0.0515723191,
-0.0387287885,
-0.005917083,
-0.0391669981,
0.0582339913,
0.0712703019,
-0.0224373844,
-0.0089282589,
-0.0653190091,
0.0170815326,
0.0332689956,
-0.0257790703,
0.0045645386,
-0.0125272907,
-0.0148723908,
-0.0023676076,
-0.0368021615,
-0.0399865247,
0.0353186652,
0.084965013,
-0.0360606909,
-0.0325296894,
0.1322589368,
0.030655589,
-0.0214657653,
0.0138877491,
0.0329497755,
0.0543328188,
-0.0095754657,
0.0142632267,
-0.069412522,
-0.0186941884,
0.0055167312,
0.0303362124,
-0.0189108923,
-0.0246929266,
-0.0197771117,
-0.0560936332,
0.016395038,
0.0262434781,
-0.0279707126,
-0.0327254757,
-0.0192460828,
-0.0000063402,
0.0207132213,
-0.0117446939,
0.0153049091,
-0.0454357937,
0.0238633342,
0.0012555678,
-0.0249785744,
-0.034723781,
-0.0530774668,
-0.0287441127,
0.0450352132,
0.0640332177,
0.0373364724,
0.0159485526,
0.0206298213,
0.0014405369,
-0.0300801937,
-0.0024566234,
-0.0288743377,
0.0236904528,
-0.0054526008,
0.0025153575,
-0.037108887,
0.0529113933,
0.0143134808,
-0.010689131,
0.0228582416,
-0.0085016256,
-0.0201407243,
-0.0485005416,
-0.0254591573,
0.0247158241,
0.0445220247,
0.0568347871,
0.0484429263,
-0.0707485974,
-0.060053315,
-0.0373008735,
-0.0035596373,
-0.0592919998,
-0.0032151204,
-0.0170349739,
-0.0437871031,
-0.0125665376,
-0.1058260426,
-0.0363089107,
-0.0086760465,
0.0140978694,
0.0492957346,
-0.0238855239,
0.0457133166,
-0.0244890526,
-0.0283910614,
-0.0405463614,
0.019113468,
-0.0026226891,
-0.0881934986,
-0.0238526501,
0.0309249442,
-0.0279906504,
-0.0150506152,
0.0259913336,
-0.0539674535,
-0.0683397353,
-0.0039128354,
0.0254291669,
0.0147994692,
0.0454672314,
0.014203757,
-0.0590850674,
0.0629698038,
0.0589434281,
-0.0445539765,
0.0419746898,
0.0035009482,
0.0327594578,
0.0021932926,
0.0240136199,
-0.0191444326,
0.0237876605,
-0.0402602367,
0.0657435581,
-0.0291953553,
-0.0268719029,
0.01365167,
-0.028262144,
0.0048939791,
-0.0597527325,
0.0240043234,
-0.0499568991,
-0.0113954125,
-0.0597440153,
-0.0333381034,
-0.0503737219,
0.0124266986,
0.0139224688,
-0.0007802175,
-0.0240611341,
0.0204417743,
-0.0316583924,
0.0576008633,
-0.0565876253,
-0.0110350205,
-0.0344576798,
0.0329776406,
0.0138665391,
-0.0139107313,
-0.0348600261,
0.0248359721,
-0.0455932617,
0.0297823641,
-0.0182308648,
0.0906979367,
0.0386257805,
0.0052991635,
0.000406906,
0.0452442653,
-0.0458823033,
0.0490000956,
-0.034586072,
0.0088912183,
0.046573393,
-0.0296512917,
0.1119521186,
-0.0274013821,
0.0057588872,
-0.0203552842,
0.0878860056,
-0.0064660632,
-0.013154095,
-0.0304165725,
0.0162842181,
-0.0107200285,
0.0008745914,
0.0952177644,
0.0101718288,
-0.0486892238,
0.0516790189,
-0.0077295369,
-0.039714586,
-0.0246981885,
0.0032317347,
0.0148584293,
0.0131867053,
0.0010954466,
-0.0249460693,
0.0095483186,
0.018709993,
0.0167274941,
0.0130041307,
-0.0146400146,
0.0545818545,
0.0460881367,
-0.0266858954,
0.0034851739,
-0.0659369528,
-0.0154931489,
-0.0425751209,
-0.0382760279,
-0.0415132903,
-6.094472787e-33,
-0.0668664649,
-0.075433284,
0.0061823595,
0.0313917026,
-0.0373332724,
-0.0057381843,
-0.0769726858,
0.0157711264,
0.0740619302,
0.0467976257,
0.0053688264,
-0.0037963192,
-0.0031246592,
0.0414068103,
0.0110509107,
0.0023020166,
0.0557555631,
-0.0179765038,
-0.0544567779,
0.060524039,
0.0258351583,
-0.0028812955,
-0.0114981467,
-0.0065914979,
0.0025937571,
-0.0345391333,
-0.0135841044,
-0.0298638418,
0.0498442873,
0.0308113862,
-0.0024413553,
0.0068985452,
0.0140400184,
0.0215421971,
-0.0175059419,
0.0452793986,
-0.0087127509,
-0.0213407204,
0.0002467782,
-0.0256208405,
-0.0494463816,
-0.045664154,
0.0170086306,
-0.036162857,
-0.0086904736,
0.0084855743,
0.0573986173,
-0.0113054831,
-0.0095234653,
-0.0513084345,
-0.0736413673,
0.0205406863,
-0.0512612574,
-0.0417632833,
-0.0043827025,
0.0377119333,
0.010919665,
-0.0115688341,
-0.0338975415,
0.0371930636,
-0.0086963782,
0.0484393388,
0.0266235173,
0.0032689697,
-0.0126970271,
0.053631071,
-0.0144207925,
0.0073450962,
-0.0570591837,
0.0396332145,
-0.0155062713,
0.022879377,
0.0267677307,
0.0055514108,
0.0185654182,
-0.0125377271,
-0.0481395051,
0.0307062548,
-0.0097727133,
-0.0016598478,
0.0295908544,
-0.0132624907,
-0.0024881396,
0.0000589021,
-0.0141267674,
-0.0325604081,
0.0005499625,
-0.0207947753,
-0.0000807379,
0.031440407,
-0.0483016819,
-0.0422283597,
0.0209186133,
0.0143029504,
0.0016761391,
0.0183146913,
-0.070259586,
0.0180155579,
-0.0033420385,
0.0166283157,
-0.0533866659,
-0.0284054428,
0.0380489863,
0.0370187014,
0.0167956464,
-0.0036894379,
-0.002590653,
0.0152381612,
-0.0466121063,
0.0145884044,
-0.0053669894,
0.0297737867,
-0.0181230102,
-0.0101020755,
0.0178413074,
-0.004041038,
-0.0108005106,
0.0432580449,
0.020202674,
-0.0188329946,
-0.0348525792,
-0.0162091628,
0.024958631,
0.0172845628,
-0.0286691766,
0.0336732455,
-0.0359735154,
0.0126611823,
-0.0062879827,
-0.0666547716,
-0.022191491,
0.0229608882,
2.516e-7,
-0.0082347216,
0.0770432428,
0.0319599472,
0.0427555963,
0.0104117151,
0.0064360336,
0.0135319056,
0.0351045504,
-0.0050238068,
-0.013011381,
0.0248971283,
0.0052047889,
0.0347416438,
0.0214986894,
-0.0712383091,
0.0147829019,
-0.1014749929,
-0.0006603433,
-0.0679013431,
-0.0157233104,
0.0708560348,
-0.0201135632,
-0.0104943262,
0.0227836948,
0.0088943588,
0.0034128467,
0.0637585595,
0.0285969526,
0.0165146291,
0.0439947769,
0.0179036018,
0.0008488304,
-0.0247433763,
-0.0265979599,
-0.0312465746,
-0.0096354233,
0.0070747402,
0.0671768934,
0.0189405791,
-0.0162899625,
0.0224955566,
-0.0026672247,
0.0232563652,
-0.0504642762,
0.0417674035,
-0.0735567659,
-0.0040717693,
-0.0162567701,
-0.0530473068,
-0.0122236237,
0.0126270261,
-0.0399111733,
-0.0376872048,
0.0251513664,
0.0218558274,
0.019105386,
-0.0074450038,
-0.0267381612,
-0.0470557027,
0.0040747686,
-0.039753072,
-0.0025311725,
-0.0370363928,
0.0237182584,
-0.0267116278,
-0.0476705953,
-0.004681279,
2.48832639e-34,
0.0508047044,
-0.0323561393,
-0.0028065024,
0.0086168135,
0.0169299226,
0.0138632404,
-0.046408549,
0.0076836497,
0.0191699564,
-0.0731922239,
-0.0112485439
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.02972v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.02972v2 | REE-HDSC: Recognizing Extracted Entities for the Historical Database Suriname Curacao | 2023-12-19T16:12:35 | 2024-04-05T09:32:57 | Erik Tjong Kim Sang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We describe the project REE-HDSC and outline our efforts to improve the
quality of named entities extracted automatically from texts generated by
hand-written text recognition (HTR) software. We describe a six-step processing
pipeline and test it by processing 19th and 20th century death certificates
from the civil registry of Curacao. We find that the pipeline extracts dates
with high precision but that the precision of person name extraction is low.
Next we show how name precision extraction can be improved by retraining HTR
models with names, post-processing and by identifying and removing incorrect
names. | [
0.0615653992,
0.0362703875,
0.0191983022,
0.0316753834,
-0.0134857502,
0.024642814,
-0.0162787419,
0.0200048368,
0.028608067,
0.008109252,
-0.0045762453,
-0.0279259812,
0.0540626012,
-0.0486276783,
-0.029279964,
-0.0829050839,
0.0403439142,
0.0051759044,
-0.0012984774,
0.0230257772,
-0.0309675764,
-0.0037118865,
-0.0001805068,
-0.0174395274,
0.0005902197,
0.0512133949,
-0.0152259553,
0.0074122958,
0.0154645229,
-0.0295648314,
-0.0203764718,
0.0547046624,
-0.0135112032,
0.0799066722,
0.0000017274,
-0.0568403751,
-0.04601999,
-0.0088471724,
-0.0615345389,
0.0001796648,
0.0485084355,
-0.0224736687,
-0.0513427369,
-0.0212436207,
-0.0191483833,
-0.0340375714,
0.0401818417,
0.0014648493,
-0.0094240494,
0.088348262,
0.00026775,
-0.0306663141,
0.052926939,
-0.0112013407,
-0.0084824022,
-0.0059492094,
0.0446461067,
0.0125152823,
0.0182386562,
0.0140187833,
0.0489910394,
0.0368432663,
-0.0329670906,
-0.0080375345,
0.0224570408,
0.0066556218,
-0.0336846113,
-0.0077975485,
0.0253951252,
0.0490544029,
-0.0182870701,
-0.0031624478,
0.0563827455,
0.0177695155,
-0.0479155518,
-0.0288255438,
0.0036555161,
0.0108534703,
-0.0614287779,
-0.0239316877,
0.0222668238,
0.006955571,
0.0136039369,
0.0069294143,
0.0098701566,
0.007067665,
-0.0137628671,
-0.0430188961,
0.0429682359,
-0.0000983831,
0.0376302116,
-0.0264212899,
0.0629538372,
0.0114070019,
0.0541724376,
0.0090549737,
-0.0206811167,
-0.0564407595,
0.0087303342,
-0.0766494125,
-0.0111373235,
0.0240449775,
-0.0373435616,
0.0364536121,
-0.0676770508,
0.0307375677,
-0.0101262117,
0.0138072306,
0.0467330217,
-0.0226583127,
-0.0279776044,
-0.0053180265,
-0.0460763499,
0.013725902,
-0.0180632956,
0.027590597,
-0.0637913495,
-0.0259420741,
0.0129329506,
0.0252740774,
0.0162270684,
-0.0116726402,
-0.0328365229,
-0.0187324416,
-0.0440303273,
0.0058861626,
0.0132002952,
-0.0179537255,
-0.026630234,
-0.0404049195,
0.0262093581,
0.0003952474,
0.0532688834,
-0.0399241261,
0.0463627838,
0.0115898326,
-0.0433923304,
-0.0447551198,
-0.0826073214,
-0.0472440533,
-0.0179882813,
-0.0313057452,
-0.0068370863,
-0.0131211523,
0.0277246535,
-0.0277000535,
-0.0244182684,
-0.0496757552,
0.0201475825,
-0.0190967042,
-0.0389772132,
0.0713106543,
-0.0430642031,
-0.0096149603,
0.1160079539,
-0.0066555054,
0.0049395231,
-0.0217845105,
0.0328965113,
0.0196151156,
0.0387192965,
0.0166934468,
0.0370863453,
0.0527308248,
-0.0027721827,
-0.0550914519,
-0.0278562754,
0.0158602353,
-0.0100478334,
0.03695108,
0.0606340617,
0.042237103,
0.0089580975,
-0.0128459623,
0.001810646,
0.0126604885,
-0.0307605732,
0.0415219665,
0.0529983453,
-0.0202407781,
0.0370850638,
-0.012442858,
-0.0158464219,
-0.0145425862,
0.0170069356,
0.0402716286,
-0.059716206,
0.0067791063,
0.0133533617,
0.0052857646,
0.0146594672,
-0.0046781907,
-0.0618158951,
-0.0203431062,
0.0817885026,
-0.0226497296,
-0.0470109731,
-0.0143548306,
-0.0092829363,
-0.0714152455,
0.0160191841,
-0.0194600839,
0.0211433657,
0.0552234128,
0.0577476062,
-0.0309908986,
0.0106640607,
0.000941209,
-0.0339207202,
0.0232402012,
-0.0380448252,
-0.0376659408,
0.0359638594,
-0.0423976816,
-0.0221342538,
0.1236042455,
-0.0296692122,
0.0266707372,
0.0354349688,
0.0331500061,
0.056636434,
0.0330133624,
-0.0350461155,
0.0424873717,
-0.0103685837,
-0.0527998097,
0.0026384108,
0.0408653356,
0.011998794,
0.0237082392,
-0.0109131355,
-0.0424117595,
-0.0027797273,
0.000693934,
0.0263863225,
-0.0060257474,
-0.0380295664,
-0.0253409632,
0.0066820406,
-0.0295856744,
-0.0117397979,
0.027744079,
0.0241287146,
-0.0451039523,
-0.0389077067,
0.0431156978,
-0.0225285478,
-0.0519333109,
0.0760279745,
0.0207754243,
-0.0061899428,
-0.0551513769,
0.0797399879,
0.0170240179,
-0.0164022837,
-0.0058706393,
-0.0581739619,
0.0030989512,
-0.0852140635,
-0.0333804525,
-0.0008619618,
0.0053454144,
0.0045212321,
-0.0113248527,
-0.008712179,
-0.0530015752,
-0.0272416417,
-0.088453792,
-0.0207197536,
-0.0095496569,
0.0181585178,
0.0021231363,
0.0376734175,
-0.0187504459,
-0.031083608,
0.0150377965,
-0.0430351682,
-0.0022001413,
-0.0151281646,
0.0556790084,
0.0125739807,
0.0095002865,
-0.0065060914,
-0.0237233769,
-0.0041651167,
0.0203231834,
0.0294415243,
-0.0909150019,
-0.0282215346,
0.0472898111,
-0.0121323783,
0.0253684558,
-0.0105078304,
0.0134459417,
-0.0375083126,
0.0160456114,
-0.0132322237,
0.0762492493,
-0.0075285886,
-0.0175456088,
-0.0095411511,
0.0162670761,
0.008303036,
0.0167956781,
-0.0463303588,
0.0854456276,
0.0304638967,
-0.0155549608,
0.009802389,
-0.0044013015,
-0.0007160709,
0.0441223979,
0.0157387126,
-0.0430400111,
-0.0006347193,
-0.0057361778,
-0.0138312811,
-0.039446719,
-0.0267008804,
0.0087136747,
-0.0367088802,
-0.0044426108,
0.0326340348,
-0.0447110385,
-0.0161420163,
0.0047090543,
0.006343022,
-0.0303703193,
0.024787752,
0.0233329218,
0.0145239541,
0.0026658329,
-0.0958971903,
-0.022349054,
-0.0154965539,
0.0408364013,
-0.0365966186,
-0.0011027084,
-0.032837972,
0.0279194321,
-0.0535904057,
-0.0386397652,
-0.0251753684,
-0.0209649298,
-0.0288820397,
0.0073628752,
-0.0124060838,
0.0139724417,
0.0010643132,
0.0373717286,
0.0224792268,
0.0619104207,
0.0064239427,
-0.0003372544,
-0.0398200564,
0.1007591933,
-0.0340899676,
-0.019807294,
0.0247543342,
-0.0236691572,
0.0004883361,
-0.0253752675,
0.0040612617,
-0.0153059233,
0.021599872,
0.0020549484,
-0.0122275855,
-0.0542608052,
-0.0160454735,
-0.0376381017,
0.004453789,
-0.0469218902,
0.0065484871,
0.0662429705,
-0.0053066649,
-0.0306656118,
-0.0352479182,
0.0031048111,
-0.0100213299,
-0.0169101749,
0.0019640389,
-0.0539966747,
0.0179285519,
0.0275490452,
0.0308207944,
-0.0627200082,
-0.0580307096,
-0.0043951189,
-0.0789870992,
0.0456073061,
0.022582395,
-0.0787191764,
0.0234123524,
0.0098204678,
-0.0097729443,
-0.0278144684,
0.0057719485,
0.0488615558,
-0.0181817189,
-0.0098696565,
0.0441182479,
-0.0524318404,
-0.0347422063,
-0.0104517527,
-0.0260023009,
-0.0163008142,
0.0517920628,
0.0221831761,
0.0045920936,
-0.0149338217,
-0.003081731,
-0.0609549843,
-0.0109480666,
-0.0482395999,
0.0775778517,
-0.0160913225,
-0.0135399224,
-0.0457516797,
0.0142959086,
0.0409857146,
0.0315805599,
0.0254963282,
0.0250974577,
-0.0398709364,
0.0266168788,
0.0293401759,
-0.0343309902,
0.0064796032,
0.0033295008,
-0.0007505048,
0.0254248492,
-0.0352298245,
0.0196475275,
0.0179275833,
-0.0080175055,
0.004712488,
0.0254804101,
-0.088790305,
-0.049831491,
-0.0507150665,
-0.0407290831,
0.0260979347,
0.0343505517,
0.0051983884,
-0.0200192016,
0.0560073555,
0.0628006756,
-0.0595434532,
0.0068197348,
-0.0594836138,
-0.0157862958,
-0.0997711122,
0.0133741917,
-0.0056611169,
-0.0002928813,
-0.0039979424,
-0.054689955,
-0.0487410054,
-0.0159413889,
0.0454765595,
-0.0307503287,
0.0342000015,
0.0223181006,
-0.0176785346,
-0.0613959357,
0.0216772854,
0.0268895309,
-0.0261822212,
-0.0357958823,
-0.0125336424,
-0.0061730715,
-0.049042359,
0.0011204804,
0.0224210676,
0.0007995089,
0.0338618942,
-0.0350672901,
-0.0349350534,
-0.0240035225,
-0.0340703763,
0.051394064,
0.0624041706,
-0.0069999495,
0.0108291572,
-0.0281926654,
0.0265508723,
0.0112336585,
0.0163980741,
0.0330916792,
0.0071292887,
-0.0169637166,
0.0266865138,
-0.018331388,
0.0216966141,
-0.0041137068,
-0.021771308,
-0.0455655716,
-0.010505829,
-0.0029172916,
0.1005088389,
0.0079839323,
-0.0120703569,
0.0154299242,
0.0730931833,
0.0680350959,
0.0699858889,
-0.012955402,
0.0046097534,
-0.034877412,
0.0036983446,
0.0145638911,
-0.0176925566,
-0.0364777036,
0.0552129,
-0.0849445686,
0.0613770559,
0.0668573603,
-0.0120164556,
0.0065256376,
-0.0167538151,
0.0047674747,
-0.0071049752,
-0.0097495355,
0.0166828968,
0.0188870691,
-0.0257454943,
-0.0153467692,
-0.0486902967,
0.056714382,
0.0165887475,
0.018867258,
0.0046176007,
0.064538233,
-0.049149204,
-0.0277671237,
-0.0506852083,
0.0400792211,
-0.0457331911,
-0.0531287156,
-0.0600244626,
-0.0490819924,
-0.0042925114,
0.086502336,
0.0096793529,
-0.0145392735,
0.0170415435,
-0.0078061307,
-0.0111667262,
-0.0212696977,
-0.0183630362,
-0.0341719389,
0.0222508386,
0.0013821694,
-0.0085619064,
0.0236491729,
-5.525004916e-33,
-0.0308889188,
-0.0060214349,
0.0113526462,
-0.018263042,
-0.0256627239,
-0.01392774,
-0.0309234038,
0.0168453902,
0.0131660262,
-0.0185809862,
-0.0370705426,
-0.0203874186,
0.0708123967,
0.005726622,
0.0065835556,
0.0038989829,
0.0281491708,
0.0205530114,
-0.0451274477,
0.0100079607,
0.0611417182,
0.0574089773,
0.0570039451,
-0.0381457917,
0.0231805649,
0.0144588444,
-0.0085985288,
0.0130255092,
0.058434125,
0.0234457869,
-0.0246490799,
-0.0296111871,
-0.0007226518,
-0.0022472674,
0.0167522021,
0.0277278852,
-0.1503950804,
0.0428265259,
-0.0277863741,
0.0707093179,
0.0192099307,
-0.0276151504,
0.06050428,
-0.0132367974,
-0.0322748534,
0.0245229285,
0.0154425008,
-0.0501215048,
-0.0299450271,
-0.0765076354,
-0.0123606957,
0.0711752176,
0.0487923622,
0.0564903766,
0.0671754777,
-0.0206375383,
0.025998326,
0.005470315,
-0.0748051256,
-0.0305770375,
0.0411590338,
0.0137941763,
0.0116503164,
0.0197337009,
-0.0365432464,
-0.0097617526,
0.0360159501,
-0.0224045869,
0.0256584678,
0.0320788845,
0.039425116,
0.029259963,
0.0074722827,
0.0848757252,
0.0584131479,
-0.0502584502,
-0.0704150051,
0.0557186194,
-0.0188730489,
0.0058766087,
-0.0097082676,
-0.036092177,
-0.0456300154,
0.0329398289,
0.010938962,
0.019880211,
-0.0150651038,
-0.004726504,
0.0051779817,
0.0122583797,
0.0127337128,
0.051350344,
0.007279939,
0.0082282731,
-0.0263041425,
-0.0413070321,
0.0178709682,
0.0437798053,
-0.0072881537,
-0.0342635885,
-0.0063763023,
-0.0374398008,
-0.007515355,
0.0693387538,
-0.0313125737,
-0.02107176,
0.0311737675,
-0.0224985369,
-0.0749780536,
0.0299344566,
0.0223523956,
0.0476758257,
0.0193602312,
0.0615473725,
-0.0181063078,
-0.0366414413,
0.0435193367,
-0.0121932337,
0.0260761734,
-0.0000141193,
0.0166177452,
0.0544599667,
0.0451573059,
0.0116986679,
-0.0143767139,
0.0180772413,
0.0295368079,
0.0142683843,
-0.0027841474,
-0.0042827218,
0.0413339734,
-0.0069904341,
2.45e-7,
0.0121587561,
0.0126006855,
0.092986159,
-0.0478137657,
-0.0242969859,
-0.0033419458,
0.0126427431,
0.0202725492,
-0.0557491221,
0.0072205435,
0.0673244148,
-0.0539095812,
0.1035707369,
0.0427369028,
-0.097295329,
-0.051027149,
-0.0224088598,
-0.0281573236,
-0.0751842111,
0.0451934636,
0.0021984789,
0.0622858331,
-0.0018132718,
-0.047050938,
-0.0356953219,
-0.0003511782,
0.0342912264,
0.0220946986,
0.008104071,
0.023305567,
0.0524351224,
0.029875448,
-0.005797727,
0.037534114,
0.0038058741,
0.0141380168,
0.0170674771,
0.0716564655,
-0.0211899392,
0.0496900752,
0.0129833743,
-0.0126396008,
0.0079360362,
-0.0277108978,
0.0418341681,
0.0230206028,
0.0106275324,
0.0019365746,
-0.0308536626,
-0.0117803896,
0.0064667556,
0.0049173539,
-0.0040813684,
0.0210231375,
0.0377462767,
-0.0199606493,
-0.0223125909,
-0.0683867112,
0.0574297458,
0.048770003,
0.0236613322,
-0.0357485712,
0.0278686993,
0.0127316965,
0.0248144139,
-0.0324088521,
0.0401226543,
2.15131744e-34,
-0.0408573896,
0.022268381,
-0.0508372337,
-0.0088475859,
0.0088569466,
-0.0055891862,
0.0043369378,
-0.0081651583,
-0.0331119262,
-0.0175875425,
0.0184721667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12269v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12269v2 | Automated speech audiometry: Can it work using open-source pre-trained Kaldi-NL automatic speech recognition? | 2023-12-19T15:51:49 | 2024-01-11T15:37:46 | Gloria Araiza-Illan, Luke Meyer, Khiet P. Truong, Deniz Baskent | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | A practical speech audiometry tool is the digits-in-noise (DIN) test for
hearing screening of populations of varying ages and hearing status. The test
is usually conducted by a human supervisor (e.g., clinician), who scores the
responses spoken by the listener, or online, where a software scores the
responses entered by the listener. The test has 24 digit-triplets presented in
an adaptive staircase procedure, resulting in a speech reception threshold
(SRT). We propose an alternative automated DIN test setup that can evaluate
spoken responses whilst conducted without a human supervisor, using the
open-source automatic speech recognition toolkit, Kaldi-NL. Thirty
self-reported normal-hearing Dutch adults (19-64 years) completed one
DIN+Kaldi-NL test. Their spoken responses were recorded, and used for
evaluating the transcript of decoded responses by Kaldi-NL. Study 1 evaluated
the Kaldi-NL performance through its word error rate (WER), percentage of
summed decoding errors regarding only digits found in the transcript compared
to the total number of digits present in the spoken responses. Average WER
across participants was 5.0% (range 0 - 48%, SD = 8.8%), with average decoding
errors in three triplets per participant. Study 2 analysed the effect that
triplets with decoding errors from Kaldi-NL had on the DIN test output (SRT),
using bootstrapping simulations. Previous research indicated 0.70 dB as the
typical within-subject SRT variability for normal-hearing adults. Study 2
showed that up to four triplets with decoding errors produce SRT variations
within this range, suggesting that our proposed setup could be feasible for
clinical applications. | [
-0.0486531742,
0.0144252693,
0.0037867273,
0.0064078695,
-0.0089138011,
-0.0211285669,
0.0611955673,
-0.0017525095,
-0.0001633919,
0.0541690812,
-0.0296524279,
0.005303998,
0.0754402876,
0.0036592309,
-0.0178687982,
0.0185830314,
-0.0024956302,
-0.0590121821,
0.0494185165,
-0.0375941768,
-0.0085842721,
-0.0199988931,
-0.0900845602,
0.0371198729,
0.0223514065,
0.0534115955,
0.0476654954,
-0.0294391531,
-0.0028110105,
-0.0602330156,
0.0156451724,
-0.0053277849,
-0.005309694,
0.0347904973,
0.0000021782,
-0.0467751585,
0.061613109,
0.0292299483,
-0.0583617128,
0.0044780434,
0.0189470388,
0.0168118104,
-0.0184391849,
-0.005994393,
0.0073070107,
-0.0253637973,
0.0215671863,
-0.0096712345,
0.0003072749,
0.0037360187,
-0.009682795,
-0.0174288154,
0.030017199,
-0.014230541,
-0.0070180995,
-0.0187422559,
-0.0061985203,
0.01580167,
-0.0047826604,
-0.0487830825,
0.0467090309,
0.0150941862,
-0.0166176148,
0.0312417839,
-0.0021120757,
-0.0032251929,
-0.03517906,
-0.0711097866,
-0.0441106595,
0.0465576574,
0.0631821901,
0.0286483839,
-0.006258111,
-0.0003364507,
-0.01670756,
-0.0452388339,
-0.0257594939,
-0.0132155111,
-0.0155699681,
-0.0329563841,
-0.0346291885,
0.0237351786,
-0.0068713175,
-0.0714928359,
0.0081100427,
-0.02048935,
0.01639436,
-0.0301100742,
0.0484016873,
-0.0365458168,
0.0301576164,
0.0143728172,
0.0430367216,
0.0176779665,
-0.0433311425,
-0.0446418524,
0.0163202081,
-0.0643490925,
0.0401990414,
-0.0201323908,
0.0120495614,
0.0243518185,
-0.0913418084,
-0.0084236804,
-0.0468425304,
0.0328995176,
0.0344677716,
-0.0253557637,
-0.0353906415,
0.0398412682,
0.0595788956,
0.0114684748,
-0.0008986171,
-0.0044096704,
-0.0458843373,
0.0338020436,
-0.0782202929,
-0.0221550465,
-0.0107269697,
0.0079525197,
0.0407050438,
0.0162089132,
-0.0258618053,
-0.0018182092,
0.0072624907,
0.0518783033,
-0.0174264014,
0.0355922952,
-0.0505387262,
-0.0924402252,
0.0171706602,
-0.0060046115,
0.0589467734,
0.0019527543,
0.0472635478,
0.0667939931,
-0.00206466,
0.0070134117,
-0.0014643418,
0.03233549,
-0.0098412884,
0.0080011087,
0.0109629976,
-0.0555557199,
0.0382225439,
0.0235338714,
0.0063506262,
-0.0222337432,
-0.015528,
-0.0113079259,
0.0159468558,
0.0112834815,
-0.0295644067,
0.0076533668,
0.0207951553,
-0.0198129471,
0.0381122828,
-0.0030769578,
0.0019280151,
-0.1060664356,
-0.0074903117,
-0.0797094628,
-0.0183187015,
0.0418513231,
0.0148072205,
0.0028409234,
-0.0056281365,
0.0260173269,
-0.0611404441,
0.0512549803,
0.0438517481,
-0.0035585512,
-0.0225457959,
-0.0504338667,
0.0340415649,
0.0847765207,
0.0664528012,
0.009008212,
-0.0380563028,
-0.0373055525,
0.0252455715,
-0.0201049112,
0.0118720261,
-0.028517127,
-0.0277439468,
0.0271344334,
0.0295891985,
0.0294840652,
0.0120907901,
-0.0071753147,
-0.0017552386,
-0.0260194261,
-0.0032656891,
0.0329798236,
0.0293358248,
-0.0452865623,
-0.0300860833,
0.0126140621,
0.0023797236,
-0.0308188088,
-0.0062916768,
-0.0732622221,
0.0170470867,
0.0148341553,
-0.017730156,
-0.0279594865,
0.029867487,
-0.0054653049,
-0.0559279211,
-0.0150318472,
0.0024012837,
0.0276005641,
0.0669065267,
-0.0440952815,
-0.024367217,
0.0500075072,
-0.0024234196,
0.0414427705,
-0.010224185,
0.063052319,
0.0022812374,
-0.0552662574,
0.0332002863,
-0.0231102798,
-0.0378897004,
-0.0455957167,
0.0116422903,
-0.0262732543,
0.053359054,
0.0562165082,
-0.0404337049,
0.0070182788,
-0.0190723911,
0.0192221291,
0.047551915,
-0.0096389307,
-0.0143714324,
-0.0056801941,
0.0524521433,
-0.0096738907,
-0.0028028667,
0.0223918203,
0.0387838781,
-0.0470004082,
-0.0035537432,
-0.034357436,
-0.0050094533,
-0.0512788631,
-0.0299540013,
0.0214388222,
-0.002549547,
0.002542529,
-0.0257284008,
0.0045478991,
-0.0080308765,
-0.0436289795,
-0.0300210584,
0.0039988239,
-0.0220266301,
-0.0261010975,
0.0003055019,
-0.0248220246,
0.053782925,
0.001516271,
0.0264503658,
-0.0146069238,
0.0065063583,
-0.065784663,
-0.0293774959,
-0.0041816076,
0.0099302484,
-0.0069482476,
0.005256386,
0.022077674,
-0.0672406033,
0.0075004166,
0.0280749276,
0.0298561044,
-0.0047078053,
-0.0605849959,
-0.0205101892,
-0.0008323113,
0.0106964633,
-0.0157334749,
-0.0014290317,
0.0033177021,
0.0389483944,
-0.0518643409,
-0.0466526635,
0.0136808045,
0.0111455265,
-0.0006760813,
0.0241379719,
0.0118877999,
0.0292363707,
0.0064797495,
0.009086011,
-0.004544016,
-0.0536431521,
-0.0172867049,
0.0051389877,
-0.0062059965,
0.0167877767,
-0.0098132314,
0.0374215841,
0.0154842446,
-0.002473864,
0.0007104856,
-0.0134145375,
-0.0049221907,
0.050753545,
0.0203018989,
-0.0359463319,
-0.0075091501,
-0.024981644,
-0.0082399342,
-0.0521529801,
-0.0209648907,
-0.0161664765,
0.0558791459,
0.0353020765,
-0.0201728195,
0.0071819867,
-0.0542300195,
-0.0361133218,
-0.0787751898,
-0.0516394787,
0.0023010524,
-0.0153620616,
-0.0343708806,
-0.0125097744,
0.0113184834,
-0.0612560399,
0.0293229911,
-0.019659847,
0.0326757692,
-0.0548598357,
0.0391509645,
-0.0136879347,
0.02456191,
-0.0128367925,
-0.0139611494,
-0.0181991905,
0.018370267,
-0.033394184,
0.0100333448,
-0.0573415048,
-0.0196960773,
-0.0108248452,
0.0143187074,
0.0222373828,
0.1093336865,
0.0361661129,
0.0073095467,
-0.0071145063,
0.0549227335,
-0.0413832404,
0.0174330585,
0.0155022126,
-0.0002907244,
-0.0151329162,
0.0071991584,
0.0171019863,
0.0637038723,
-0.0280128755,
-0.002897603,
0.0344470777,
0.002326363,
0.0231536478,
0.047072392,
0.0452875532,
0.0012668303,
0.029287817,
0.0713932291,
0.0035842087,
-0.0664988756,
-0.0215508919,
-0.018162163,
-0.035032358,
-0.0093794418,
-0.0361391343,
-0.0309498105,
0.0055211559,
0.0473757572,
0.0991623998,
0.0189084075,
0.0432803221,
-0.0092702536,
-0.016009016,
0.0565298088,
0.0436300561,
-0.0471100733,
-0.0327817686,
-0.0161899626,
0.0319040902,
-0.0168881007,
0.1055096313,
0.0053715538,
-0.0003729255,
-0.0176642928,
-0.0017795572,
-0.1151368022,
-0.0856855512,
0.0601012707,
0.000453534,
0.099582307,
0.0499156564,
-0.0407474153,
-0.0300546475,
-0.0106520345,
0.0347743742,
-0.0578905344,
-0.004918695,
-0.0105411895,
0.0387979709,
0.0802472085,
-0.0014206828,
-0.0222052932,
0.0446666218,
-0.0556236841,
-0.0109197609,
0.0214223154,
0.0066293655,
-0.0219311286,
0.0028709853,
0.0126908263,
0.0764622614,
0.0117540928,
0.018454928,
0.0194026735,
-0.0009654486,
0.0035633934,
0.0160167143,
0.0694796667,
0.0098590162,
-0.0189238954,
0.0425779559,
0.0204143431,
-0.0710278377,
-0.0005105395,
0.0095699755,
0.0142092779,
0.0451668426,
0.0473259948,
-0.0354015678,
0.0501318201,
0.0590461381,
0.0019086422,
0.0368264765,
0.0303130094,
0.0474651977,
-0.0334561169,
0.0200148076,
0.0301781967,
-0.0214099921,
-0.0234402008,
-0.0087465011,
0.0052312766,
0.017384015,
0.06960392,
-0.0074770874,
0.0250053685,
0.0274469387,
-0.0490112379,
-0.0317827649,
0.0599255711,
-0.0273514204,
-0.0431426279,
0.0626489967,
0.0070864973,
-0.0020380511,
-0.0181573182,
-0.009147739,
-0.018736599,
0.0370844826,
-0.0467331633,
-0.0193187222,
-0.0208022632,
-0.0392443761,
0.0151432436,
0.0572314858,
0.0356535017,
0.0055209743,
0.0324919187,
-0.0096321842,
0.0560798049,
0.0157260932,
0.0654459298,
-0.0076861326,
-0.0605023913,
0.0114342291,
0.0147878276,
-0.0412111767,
-0.0045155301,
-0.0422623754,
-0.0311042573,
-0.0260228552,
0.083965674,
0.0646037757,
0.0616200641,
0.0064488254,
-0.0515714027,
-0.0212184321,
0.0283784252,
-0.0356554799,
0.0486099385,
0.0070398548,
0.0462544411,
-0.0540154949,
-0.0319809131,
0.0315879025,
0.003111335,
-0.0010347931,
-0.0250700433,
-0.0043827305,
-0.0146904979,
-0.0241303481,
0.0520705171,
0.0158011205,
-0.0258122329,
0.0411689952,
-0.0298237372,
-0.0538787469,
-0.0430602133,
0.0803321674,
-0.0231248811,
-0.0012536533,
-0.0110835209,
-0.0290272012,
0.0245912559,
0.0157880113,
-0.0221050177,
-0.031928461,
-0.0346142463,
-0.0315844305,
-0.0774916857,
-0.074939996,
0.0357383788,
-0.072378166,
0.0131599577,
0.0224823933,
-0.0179406963,
-0.0390533879,
0.0153930513,
0.0359297805,
-0.0127985738,
-0.0478232689,
0.0011572556,
-0.0377400555,
-0.0117402244,
0.0526588783,
-0.0092765056,
-0.0097727068,
-0.0015023977,
0.0051461309,
-6.238107543e-33,
0.0029295436,
-0.0225054864,
0.0218561273,
-0.0356515944,
-0.0345215797,
0.0076769483,
-0.0129898507,
0.0310182013,
0.0023052688,
0.0043000304,
0.0183867645,
-0.0394039787,
0.0484081805,
0.0135407308,
0.0163639821,
0.0038433308,
0.0630388483,
-0.0152972406,
0.0021616521,
-0.0623092353,
-0.0061297109,
0.0106510064,
0.0503430925,
-0.0350923203,
0.0211599022,
0.0695501566,
0.0150245205,
-0.0573872626,
0.018599283,
0.0001445808,
0.0270948596,
0.0365909971,
-0.0105855204,
0.0072338064,
0.030194087,
0.0077904854,
-0.128777504,
-0.0024045869,
0.0113232918,
0.0799894407,
0.0263358671,
0.047958672,
0.0410642512,
-0.0276791845,
-0.0397557877,
-0.0300979838,
-0.0017927531,
-0.0422171578,
-0.0122797647,
-0.0074133496,
0.0370837227,
0.0360091142,
-0.0155235017,
-0.0020233772,
0.0145103661,
0.0312075932,
-0.0578892082,
-0.0433830731,
-0.0494896546,
0.0433379598,
0.0179545712,
-0.0346180387,
-0.0461957864,
-0.0291721672,
-0.0422031209,
0.0079974374,
0.1029809117,
-0.0747797564,
-0.0036804883,
-0.0774645731,
-0.0032496823,
-0.0216813292,
0.038966354,
0.0179289952,
0.0385790132,
-0.0177613702,
-0.032160081,
-0.0162005369,
0.0051983492,
-0.0208959598,
0.0238617547,
0.0304457601,
-0.0619951785,
0.00687843,
-0.0097568743,
0.0009431738,
-0.0480116531,
0.0059641213,
0.0405702442,
-0.0264649112,
0.026817346,
-0.0292155761,
0.0345909633,
-0.0179215912,
0.0971807167,
-0.0550339893,
0.0536260419,
-0.0015793062,
-0.0338731632,
-0.0125841377,
0.0329959989,
0.0203101169,
0.0562193729,
0.0373356044,
0.0341413729,
-0.0330383331,
-0.0372815877,
0.0069005354,
-0.0739572719,
0.0150889745,
0.0170231387,
0.0021022875,
0.0128588667,
0.0153320767,
0.022427069,
-0.0021471218,
0.0095349438,
-0.0060570911,
-0.024977766,
-0.0002668958,
-0.0194268748,
0.0021316912,
-0.0141871274,
0.0140808607,
-0.0233652182,
0.0008259414,
0.0011052227,
-0.039882455,
-0.0091079911,
0.0381277092,
0.0126523646,
-0.0176887289,
3.011e-7,
-0.0411056653,
0.0299252383,
0.0196461845,
-0.0284427665,
0.0194148999,
-0.0175302196,
-0.0435680412,
-0.0103512611,
0.0011259138,
0.0498281829,
0.034454111,
-0.0615731403,
0.0431360602,
0.071194157,
-0.0364674889,
-0.0504053794,
-0.0186890867,
0.039612554,
-0.0243084654,
0.049548924,
0.0024199963,
0.0128900995,
-0.058299765,
-0.0782405809,
0.0285978112,
-0.0609811395,
-0.0070501287,
0.0063221697,
0.0130688194,
-0.0144544309,
0.0653920025,
-0.0429499447,
0.0784004629,
0.0976530761,
-0.0389662795,
-0.000778772,
-0.0162841734,
0.0487782769,
-0.0289381016,
-0.0490886569,
0.0277754124,
0.0882984251,
0.0167156272,
-0.0164153855,
0.0517781004,
0.0209234729,
-0.020776527,
-0.0046307771,
-0.0452929921,
-0.0631734952,
0.0690093637,
-0.0416172035,
0.0349241011,
-0.0181062799,
0.0186855812,
0.0216739103,
-0.0396213159,
0.0187957995,
0.0144325318,
0.0513091311,
-0.0480761193,
-0.0841066763,
0.0008613803,
-0.0358766653,
-0.0227075834,
-0.0317450948,
0.0135895293,
2.426944233e-34,
0.0414889865,
-0.0086153559,
0.042521663,
-0.0514774658,
0.0058777309,
-0.0311862584,
0.0682208687,
0.0131625067,
0.0220541432,
0.0178859849,
-0.023522744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12253v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12253v1 | Geo-located Aspect Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) for Crowdsourced Evaluation of Urban Environments | 2023-12-19T15:37:27 | 2023-12-19T15:37:27 | Demircan Tas, Rohit Priyadarshi Sanatani | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis methods are rapidly being adopted by the field of Urban
Design and Planning, for the crowdsourced evaluation of urban environments.
However, most models used within this domain are able to identify positive or
negative sentiment associated with a textual appraisal as a whole, without
inferring information about specific urban aspects contained within it, or the
sentiment associated with them. While Aspect Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) is
becoming increasingly popular, most existing ABSA models are trained on
non-urban themes such as restaurants, electronics, consumer goods and the like.
This body of research develops an ABSA model capable of extracting urban
aspects contained within geo-located textual urban appraisals, along with
corresponding aspect sentiment classification. We annotate a dataset of 2500
crowdsourced reviews of public parks, and train a Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers (BERT) model with Local Context Focus (LCF)
on this data. Our model achieves significant improvement in prediction accuracy
on urban reviews, for both Aspect Term Extraction (ATE) and Aspect Sentiment
Classification (ASC) tasks. For demonstrative analysis, positive and negative
urban aspects across Boston are spatially visualized. We hope that this model
is useful for designers and planners for fine-grained urban sentiment
evaluation. | [
0.0041718213,
0.0681229085,
0.0160034187,
0.0770307034,
-0.0091259899,
0.0127756605,
0.0101276673,
-0.0372813009,
-0.0510000847,
-0.0415062383,
-0.0784093216,
0.0239959806,
-0.0074109244,
0.0270999186,
-0.0179243796,
-0.0303153321,
-0.0151450327,
0.0454577655,
-0.0106468964,
0.0121319238,
0.0276896954,
0.0314796418,
0.0040615723,
0.0295850746,
-0.0026944838,
0.0202600993,
0.001422696,
0.0210957453,
0.0527501889,
-0.0554683544,
0.0189699326,
0.0039835009,
0.0035539565,
-0.0342194401,
0.0000020136,
0.0403609984,
-0.0200000163,
0.0110410033,
0.1025262475,
-0.0270707384,
0.0533169545,
-0.0218907017,
0.0192363821,
-0.010492851,
-0.0126926508,
-0.0595273711,
0.0199250225,
0.0649451613,
0.0494574308,
0.0080458764,
-0.0199821889,
-0.0515247956,
-0.0337287895,
-0.0057784081,
-0.0276558809,
0.0136901671,
-0.0097064283,
-0.0748599023,
-0.0344200656,
0.0643883497,
-0.0079666581,
-0.0405421257,
0.0032711406,
0.0258293375,
0.0456875116,
0.0134520773,
-0.0113088973,
0.032846,
-0.0029774099,
0.0527637117,
0.0328803845,
-0.0191458389,
-0.0111198835,
-0.0199564546,
-0.0158155449,
0.0255056415,
-0.0214266945,
-0.0229295641,
0.0179897528,
0.0572189838,
-0.0514655784,
0.0277799778,
0.0071347752,
0.0094885333,
0.0384076498,
0.0565473288,
-0.0208966006,
-0.0590811707,
-0.0631239936,
0.0882359147,
0.0214109942,
-0.0158110075,
0.0171747301,
-0.0199215077,
0.0205245297,
0.0020103392,
0.0440833122,
0.0454536602,
-0.0080135157,
-0.0639837086,
0.0053164805,
-0.0337006785,
-0.0505881533,
0.0566564016,
0.0291284118,
-0.0253486689,
0.0142818913,
0.0440428667,
-0.0331051089,
0.0227197967,
-0.0463933088,
0.050359536,
-0.0036960738,
0.038554661,
-0.059551511,
0.0150163537,
-0.0153182605,
-0.0268683564,
-0.0351574235,
-0.0089100525,
-0.0055411314,
0.0567711703,
0.0327526219,
0.0013145452,
-0.0008039067,
0.047258012,
-0.0230384283,
0.0113758072,
-0.0577229075,
0.0439494587,
0.0237370376,
0.0303452555,
0.0519215129,
-0.0136115411,
-0.0547340438,
0.0200856589,
0.0698647127,
-0.0266908854,
-0.0483645648,
0.0092401821,
-0.0129913017,
-0.0074047018,
0.0143855028,
-0.0308114942,
-0.0287652817,
0.0055862903,
-0.008180486,
-0.0028726328,
-0.0196293909,
0.0061105457,
0.0012223005,
0.0477412678,
-0.0385212228,
-0.0057930942,
0.0223945621,
-0.0347408094,
0.0788453519,
0.0549502037,
-0.0071791112,
0.1027517989,
0.0245181527,
-0.0025281697,
0.0235654172,
-0.0240086708,
0.0358891599,
0.0062554143,
0.0079507222,
0.0182459261,
-0.0670812204,
-0.0374508128,
-0.0301492848,
0.0285933707,
0.0050739502,
0.0014007365,
0.0548083559,
-0.001479304,
-0.0374334008,
0.0284506679,
0.0153614916,
0.0569016822,
-0.0464311726,
-0.0429111086,
-0.020044921,
0.0105095869,
-0.0290295389,
-0.0143880602,
0.0076061143,
-0.0231893919,
-0.0188387744,
-0.0341813117,
-0.0032264981,
-0.0059936163,
0.022466775,
0.0021405646,
0.0662091076,
-0.0093972208,
-0.0354729481,
0.0048324601,
0.0161027852,
-0.0288344547,
0.010168259,
-0.0062733134,
0.0489374623,
0.0488061495,
-0.0382358395,
0.0030122893,
0.0432720967,
-0.0315282643,
-0.0553260893,
0.0154780494,
0.0504032969,
-0.0141185867,
-0.0240864158,
-0.0165327694,
-0.045218423,
-0.009822933,
0.040318694,
-0.0198876429,
0.0057850233,
0.0406694897,
0.0225149635,
-0.0436791591,
-0.0047477065,
-0.0349696837,
0.0819855109,
-0.0381243303,
-0.011253994,
0.023616489,
0.0058787921,
0.0269230697,
-0.0300367754,
0.002876736,
0.0343969166,
-0.0161018465,
-0.0731176436,
0.0464559868,
-0.0319913141,
-0.0385498106,
-0.0141384769,
-0.0175209641,
-0.0166984275,
0.0324476771,
-0.0426210165,
0.0213875994,
-0.0080415411,
-0.0319984592,
0.0262787398,
-0.0041167391,
0.0117609454,
0.0031176303,
-0.0247222688,
-0.0134250233,
0.0454581194,
-0.0540942252,
0.0115944184,
-0.032928627,
-0.0023392097,
0.0429428816,
0.0508832447,
-0.0536306687,
-0.0578942895,
0.0253089219,
0.0369491279,
0.0132716214,
0.0321347564,
-0.0142858159,
0.0112255551,
-0.1267758757,
-0.0275375023,
-0.016742548,
0.0390112028,
0.0244170502,
-0.0526546426,
0.0117138913,
-0.0024121422,
-0.0475893579,
-0.006814491,
-0.0643663928,
0.0211588424,
0.0240995232,
-0.0242382139,
0.0531540215,
-0.0120560182,
-0.0046146428,
-0.0192350056,
0.0436395667,
0.0254966225,
-0.0115175983,
0.0065612276,
0.0116829174,
0.0079898583,
-0.0098282751,
0.0303298738,
-0.0302326679,
0.0105581125,
0.0168638304,
-0.0140963653,
-0.0080478499,
0.0106980978,
0.0366862379,
-0.0158080552,
-0.0110752676,
-0.0450372919,
0.0017306048,
-0.0599316284,
0.0207447801,
-0.0027361449,
-0.0313170515,
0.0301890392,
0.0443155803,
-0.0182071067,
-0.0000505701,
-0.043457441,
0.0140533419,
-0.045022808,
-0.0042711329,
-0.0070386752,
0.013367082,
0.0134156216,
0.0382312201,
-0.024001196,
-0.0156689864,
0.05093823,
0.0007358338,
0.0181988869,
-0.0240134187,
0.0610356815,
-0.064985007,
0.0539550073,
-0.0118197352,
0.0070358231,
-0.0043169097,
0.0171925537,
0.047342591,
-0.0431016795,
-0.0464210808,
-0.0182133727,
0.036867734,
-0.0045150113,
-0.013957357,
0.0173178744,
-0.0818218216,
0.0235191062,
-0.0434460528,
-0.0513100252,
-0.0150718736,
0.0258837491,
-0.0342667177,
0.0407787561,
0.037095312,
-0.0353386365,
0.0146076391,
-0.0072655114,
-0.0216181204,
0.0069827656,
0.0342862941,
0.0430894569,
0.0441503674,
-0.0136240805,
0.0067140101,
-0.0914452299,
0.0298825204,
-0.0543659925,
0.0030043237,
-0.0328940526,
0.0099170133,
0.0467813686,
0.0160299372,
0.0006808929,
-0.0387856215,
0.0647932813,
-0.0125026144,
-0.0218458567,
0.0663928166,
0.0264833663,
-0.0730046481,
-0.0080547491,
-0.0231844932,
0.0026238277,
0.0160657577,
-0.0019266541,
-0.0366740003,
-0.0315547846,
-0.0440002345,
0.0282215942,
0.0218756981,
-0.005452577,
0.0333598517,
-0.1258132309,
0.0308464803,
-0.0374842361,
-0.0720121562,
-0.0544516966,
-0.0525025167,
-0.0063494365,
-0.0400239043,
-0.0244297646,
-0.0692901611,
0.0087407362,
0.0077226083,
0.023463985,
-0.0378150344,
-0.0140313311,
0.0055572246,
-0.0039936919,
0.0548964664,
0.0395523682,
0.0522434488,
-0.0138778398,
-0.0616767853,
-0.0087091085,
-0.0047044326,
0.044661738,
-0.0417110473,
0.0558100641,
-0.06369064,
-0.0287893321,
0.0226376299,
-0.0244048703,
-0.086798124,
0.0175662227,
0.0290164836,
0.0292919502,
-0.0182816237,
0.004045099,
-0.0525171384,
0.0509560406,
0.0353707746,
0.0014303405,
0.0275781415,
-0.0435926914,
-0.0081611499,
-0.0402232744,
-0.0304421633,
-0.0740563199,
-0.0450811498,
-0.0317508206,
-0.0067140004,
-0.0503520705,
-0.0560964607,
-0.0451398268,
-0.0266079269,
0.0094170943,
-0.0130060045,
-0.0469384342,
0.0288006905,
-0.0308751427,
-0.0496377274,
0.0506116636,
0.0052884142,
-0.0018305681,
0.0280667339,
-0.00450854,
0.0809838846,
-0.0220193379,
-0.0357328728,
0.0008350638,
-0.0520107709,
-0.0082023917,
0.0067488477,
0.0771632642,
-0.0044469009,
-0.0074188183,
-0.0142713869,
0.0062195281,
0.0228504706,
0.0126447435,
-0.0247469395,
-0.0309083592,
0.0462103076,
0.0848605335,
0.0333093144,
-0.016488703,
-0.0203352068,
0.0737078935,
0.0388720445,
-0.0244205128,
-0.0512906723,
0.0090137683,
0.0161059797,
0.0070950338,
0.1017453894,
0.0183521137,
-0.0232280251,
-0.0349094234,
-0.0044050016,
0.0068925829,
0.0134141967,
-0.0323082916,
0.0051792325,
-0.0029937539,
0.0012774348,
-0.076773338,
0.0647255257,
0.008460694,
0.0246889181,
-0.0585632175,
0.0388209,
0.0402705818,
-0.0006269235,
-0.0353321619,
0.0500772633,
-0.0215480141,
-0.0100678131,
0.0000530825,
-0.0199312568,
-0.0009719009,
0.0213040039,
0.0214043465,
0.0489459522,
-0.0139014535,
0.0487330668,
0.0185023751,
0.011862278,
-0.0518212244,
0.0197204314,
-0.0012086835,
-0.0081062345,
0.0385368913,
0.0032752862,
0.0236035679,
0.0020839358,
0.0198591109,
-0.0220224019,
-0.0220700968,
0.025601564,
-0.0027602557,
-0.021341987,
-0.004045588,
0.0277135614,
-0.0757392049,
0.0136572272,
0.0175315831,
-0.0243297201,
-0.0199340917,
0.0479416586,
0.0069373855,
0.0095851216,
0.0264564939,
0.0022539902,
-0.0614544563,
-0.0343212038,
0.0445316695,
0.0011130696,
0.0238952637,
0.0082006473,
0.0468550809,
0.0188704226,
-0.0008894649,
0.0126789492,
-0.0462224707,
-0.0070485235,
-0.0186705887,
-0.0020129092,
-0.0178635977,
-6.477210441e-33,
-0.0129639618,
-0.0795918331,
-0.0097043552,
-0.0095001906,
-0.0248066057,
0.0072708777,
-0.0167718884,
0.0169452578,
0.015955478,
0.0170807205,
0.0346743725,
0.0212122165,
0.0037474339,
0.0445825048,
0.0435760431,
-0.0459219702,
0.0652904361,
0.0024968064,
0.0336990729,
0.0369880684,
0.0370422192,
-0.0170744397,
0.0440748557,
-0.1266525388,
0.0139976572,
-0.0337816142,
-0.0569341928,
-0.0052350424,
0.0160861649,
0.0216375105,
-0.0347260907,
0.0664312914,
0.0335705504,
-0.0261584222,
-0.0265806299,
0.0100701647,
-0.014645203,
0.0211320724,
-0.0154047403,
-0.0127507206,
-0.0305869915,
-0.0256312471,
0.0164812636,
0.0600943752,
-0.0020790095,
0.0263843238,
0.0372656099,
-0.0074183187,
-0.0202817526,
-0.0756486654,
-0.0533687212,
0.0359549113,
-0.0137368003,
-0.0167827308,
0.03490033,
-0.0024074379,
0.0341936536,
0.0759519562,
-0.0200242568,
0.0021048619,
0.0029490807,
-0.0061761322,
-0.0224094894,
-0.0244587976,
0.0062132119,
0.0637783483,
-0.0101205865,
0.0159550477,
-0.0281973202,
-0.0067075039,
0.0409886651,
0.0480893441,
-0.0090957358,
0.0532483421,
0.0141137848,
-0.0249760095,
-0.0004746461,
0.02488539,
-0.0341531523,
-0.0363680087,
0.0403012075,
0.0122524509,
-0.0533998795,
-0.0115956524,
0.0266871769,
-0.0776049718,
-0.0404698476,
-0.0095121469,
-0.0039015494,
0.0268742479,
-0.033102572,
0.0641541108,
-0.0115336999,
-0.0449782908,
-0.0183159709,
0.0293734409,
-0.043121431,
0.0448099673,
-0.0306410994,
0.0300358515,
-0.0612269416,
-0.0236230623,
-0.0561154187,
0.0557340384,
0.0107634757,
0.0110128149,
0.053245388,
0.0382065699,
-0.0608770512,
-0.0159232952,
0.0083123529,
-0.0245499443,
-0.0241001584,
0.0344095528,
-0.0020078388,
0.0017831945,
-0.0086806491,
0.084644869,
-0.0133554349,
0.0682759807,
0.0158781204,
-0.0168601349,
-0.0054186601,
0.0239908583,
0.0260234121,
-0.0349151269,
0.0445231572,
-0.0222836006,
-0.0159248784,
-0.0467703342,
-0.0281902887,
-0.0121678784,
2.673e-7,
0.0238844268,
0.0704241097,
-0.0057472377,
-0.0334294997,
0.0057239374,
0.0600350313,
0.0162480604,
0.0449132137,
-0.0030313665,
0.0207079668,
0.0338393115,
0.0327163972,
0.0179082956,
0.058546029,
-0.1030000597,
0.1210848466,
-0.0609091409,
0.0124613522,
-0.0181907564,
0.0433115624,
0.0924760699,
0.0750928819,
0.0261756293,
-0.001543766,
-0.0023071945,
0.0696519613,
0.007861156,
-0.0619953685,
-0.0360945426,
-0.0107031912,
-0.032242652,
-0.0129644666,
0.0109562268,
-0.0690244883,
-0.0367673896,
-0.0088813975,
0.0416058488,
0.0307246372,
0.0010856335,
-0.0876618177,
0.0422669016,
-0.0271033384,
0.0037388371,
-0.0137053309,
0.0375569277,
-0.0562216938,
-0.015184246,
-0.0580648407,
-0.0334677622,
0.0338490307,
0.0489133149,
0.01550496,
-0.0225095078,
-0.0008070599,
0.0056602038,
-0.0357033759,
-0.0438463986,
-0.0684967488,
0.0471140407,
0.0278976411,
-0.0133640198,
-0.0268270392,
-0.0028037627,
0.0098784566,
-0.0175198056,
-0.0185658596,
-0.0140915271,
1.592253131e-34,
0.0451813452,
-0.0075003803,
-0.0289451741,
0.0122975837,
0.0171285067,
-0.0114488462,
-0.0499584451,
-0.0379038043,
-0.010505287,
0.0098011503,
0.0333516821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12241v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12241v1 | GeomVerse: A Systematic Evaluation of Large Models for Geometric Reasoning | 2023-12-19T15:25:39 | 2023-12-19T15:25:39 | Mehran Kazemi, Hamidreza Alvari, Ankit Anand, Jialin Wu, Xi Chen, Radu Soricut | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large language models have shown impressive results for multi-hop
mathematical reasoning when the input question is only textual. Many
mathematical reasoning problems, however, contain both text and image. With the
ever-increasing adoption of vision language models (VLMs), understanding their
reasoning abilities for such problems is crucial. In this paper, we evaluate
the reasoning capabilities of VLMs along various axes through the lens of
geometry problems. We procedurally create a synthetic dataset of geometry
questions with controllable difficulty levels along multiple axes, thus
enabling a systematic evaluation. The empirical results obtained using our
benchmark for state-of-the-art VLMs indicate that these models are not as
capable in subjects like geometry (and, by generalization, other topics
requiring similar reasoning) as suggested by previous benchmarks. This is made
especially clear by the construction of our benchmark at various depth levels,
since solving higher-depth problems requires long chains of reasoning rather
than additional memorized knowledge. We release the dataset for further
research in this area. | [
-0.0154238166,
0.0621706173,
-0.0172897708,
0.0811175853,
-0.0796569511,
0.0465088077,
0.0444800965,
-0.0121308025,
0.0147700747,
-0.0328607075,
0.0168475956,
-0.0093763294,
0.020351639,
0.0231271647,
0.0217406135,
-0.0849987715,
-0.0318507589,
-0.0969298407,
-0.0114075495,
-0.0060948064,
-0.0312969163,
-0.0155965528,
-0.0248987116,
-0.009088912,
-0.029781837,
-0.0463483296,
-0.0035900124,
-0.0224002637,
0.0121924002,
-0.0284076203,
-0.0588874444,
-0.0034467343,
0.0391710252,
0.0130253443,
0.0000020461,
-0.0186701529,
-0.0016516875,
0.038620811,
0.0020926336,
0.0006592443,
-0.0426706001,
-0.0487593189,
0.0005491534,
-0.0131398709,
-0.0347959399,
0.0117284711,
0.029679805,
0.030790275,
0.0501020849,
0.039985761,
-0.0078474814,
-0.0580278784,
0.0204980038,
-0.0077023469,
0.0466693975,
-0.0477167778,
0.0226973426,
0.0362839475,
0.0175826792,
0.0281211827,
-0.0573644675,
0.0592824146,
0.050211139,
0.0150731001,
-0.0303302836,
0.0194697585,
-0.0233896729,
0.0308759101,
-0.0049285199,
0.0681860447,
-0.0222990215,
0.0068650981,
0.0000074572,
0.00515565,
-0.0141992839,
0.0285432618,
-0.0797234476,
0.0524629243,
-0.0198303573,
-0.0146140074,
-0.0418490022,
-0.026406005,
-0.0047347252,
-0.017297117,
-0.0556580946,
0.0586310662,
0.0220503844,
0.0016540902,
-0.0219323393,
0.0086467369,
-0.0510405861,
-0.0563698336,
-0.0179085564,
0.0464664064,
0.0142792305,
0.0243890863,
0.0050573251,
-0.000011555,
-0.0271887984,
-0.0427860469,
0.0865033716,
0.0248330757,
0.0143541079,
0.0857563987,
-0.0685685799,
0.0916549638,
-0.012575726,
0.0598371662,
-0.0133142397,
-0.0015115069,
-0.0022753335,
0.0072782626,
-0.0303976294,
0.0208617691,
0.000529327,
-0.0080811512,
-0.0012717652,
0.0176005047,
-0.0204949994,
0.050963331,
-0.005312792,
-0.0075221029,
0.005131878,
-0.0768987983,
-0.0280824248,
-0.0017371053,
-0.0184911191,
0.0199574456,
-0.0250959024,
-0.0009440627,
0.0204153974,
0.0102784075,
0.0231539663,
-0.0177966915,
0.0130422767,
0.0681647882,
0.0187052358,
-0.0214580167,
-0.0315956883,
-0.0293667801,
0.0159021784,
-0.0748511404,
0.0279248264,
-0.0862846076,
0.0218901485,
0.0050723217,
-0.0334826298,
-0.0057673263,
-0.0003618332,
0.0388771072,
-0.0185702816,
0.088451229,
0.0515238307,
-0.0008074262,
0.0318092257,
0.0145973284,
0.0045155203,
0.066753082,
0.0445629396,
0.0473071896,
0.01666403,
0.0136443032,
0.0070209224,
0.0303168092,
0.0055851284,
0.0081539368,
-0.0779505745,
0.0316314064,
0.0276017543,
0.0525929742,
-0.0466615036,
0.0770087242,
-0.0287784319,
-0.0513411053,
0.0199587103,
0.0691001639,
-0.0002721531,
-0.0192228518,
0.0651639774,
-0.0222193841,
0.0175403878,
-0.0066370685,
-0.0762566701,
0.0317358784,
-0.0197306909,
0.0060059349,
-0.0289023314,
0.0055290312,
-0.0226397812,
-0.0724810511,
-0.0354405753,
-0.0013145806,
-0.0182794407,
0.0351052172,
0.0833167285,
0.0057683974,
-0.0011431964,
-0.0193756111,
-0.0033104585,
-0.0169968717,
-0.0295414422,
0.006389596,
0.0239466596,
-0.0056314701,
0.0558870248,
-0.018970903,
-0.0172083378,
-0.0054603149,
0.0693942383,
0.0108390385,
0.0432438962,
0.0039889594,
-0.0112684909,
-0.0241727978,
-0.0255275145,
-0.0014310617,
0.0073467009,
0.0103631057,
0.02983905,
-0.0145618105,
0.0031474954,
-0.0411697775,
0.0142030222,
0.0241117217,
-0.0473209247,
-0.0258167628,
-0.0519461781,
0.0136628412,
-0.0386066325,
-0.0446177311,
0.0051913722,
0.011211928,
0.0132839773,
-0.0495898388,
0.0133414883,
-0.0123090241,
-0.0482923165,
-0.0299117249,
0.0376310349,
-0.0935375467,
-0.0435178354,
0.0015791589,
-0.0645399839,
0.0020596324,
0.0443716347,
-0.0080109518,
0.0089978445,
-0.0018146052,
0.0036537121,
0.0161215998,
-0.0405620486,
-0.032781437,
0.0519965813,
-0.0125202099,
0.0340132453,
0.0022334659,
0.0021444557,
0.0274491832,
-0.0002412748,
0.0052242866,
0.0098627713,
-0.0088334447,
0.0257089119,
-0.0518651567,
0.0051992284,
-0.0160754435,
-0.0257926118,
-0.0392303877,
-0.0144965248,
-0.0033732322,
0.0052613611,
-0.0011866216,
-0.0580034554,
-0.0041483948,
-0.0224044006,
-0.0381790437,
0.0317476131,
-0.0096325101,
0.0211063214,
0.0303228926,
-0.0045518242,
-0.0031430344,
0.0095227938,
-0.0351798348,
-0.0333845131,
0.0779121369,
0.0663948655,
0.0517986082,
-0.0174717978,
0.028568048,
-0.0473579988,
0.0255848952,
-0.0326596312,
0.0188090093,
0.0172183085,
-0.0598224737,
0.0422931276,
0.0904808789,
-0.0249398015,
-0.0023469022,
0.0238600951,
-0.0291540921,
-0.0271005053,
0.0026820907,
-0.0224537402,
-0.0032922837,
-0.029646324,
-0.0289575905,
-0.0269030165,
0.0490297228,
-0.036200311,
-0.0172788147,
-0.0315952823,
0.0703282729,
-0.0157770794,
0.0167240463,
-0.058028575,
0.0074244807,
0.0411765017,
0.0581236333,
-0.0264013112,
-0.0472903326,
0.0305228662,
-0.0284275003,
-0.002837325,
-0.0080913696,
0.0500680096,
-0.0776043534,
0.0990615785,
0.0401540287,
0.008553626,
-0.0132231219,
0.009242326,
-0.0398778357,
-0.0035322239,
0.0327397995,
0.006417817,
0.0533611327,
-0.081471391,
0.012610333,
-0.0244835131,
-0.0461574979,
-0.0235377122,
0.0455606766,
-0.0418917835,
-0.0005394571,
-0.0393592231,
-0.0378782786,
-0.0096423589,
0.0407671109,
0.0142372428,
0.0033937553,
-0.0332817882,
-0.0152696948,
-0.0174349416,
0.0229465179,
0.0420320779,
0.0365579091,
-0.0038916131,
-0.047106795,
0.0059936456,
0.0540247597,
0.0099680079,
-0.0041436465,
-0.0271523744,
0.0461472496,
0.0101106213,
0.0207322147,
-0.0148310764,
0.0153026357,
0.0326949395,
-0.0722497478,
-0.0300802775,
0.0751991272,
0.0474016443,
-0.0109485006,
-0.0367653593,
-0.0370451845,
0.0035339447,
0.0452387966,
0.0033707721,
-0.0405548178,
-0.0141559616,
0.0163835809,
-0.0369012617,
0.0479051732,
-0.0277088322,
-0.0051645418,
-0.0975036323,
0.0604663491,
0.0011781028,
-0.0312371999,
-0.0440412201,
-0.0013503539,
-0.0119576715,
0.0187931322,
-0.0666676462,
-0.0314552188,
-0.000856618,
0.0043731197,
-0.0034974029,
-0.0120751411,
0.011767867,
0.0369132832,
-0.033792004,
-0.0312836282,
-0.0067619178,
0.0309630446,
0.0061615761,
-0.1246469617,
0.0459632128,
0.0367200337,
-0.0122871082,
0.0042335647,
0.0310940873,
0.0172944013,
-0.0200293493,
0.0151874656,
0.0246922541,
-0.0514486916,
-0.0282052327,
0.0135999052,
0.085612826,
-0.0025668193,
-0.0112436442,
-0.0265395641,
0.0034714644,
-0.0592125654,
0.0340715051,
0.0076620197,
-0.007743896,
-0.0821255222,
-0.0464680046,
-0.0184565037,
-0.0599603504,
-0.0407925136,
0.0187465958,
0.0802828968,
0.0116457855,
-0.0533693917,
0.0128253447,
0.0473617241,
0.077801466,
-0.0077764587,
-0.0666510761,
0.0298214499,
-0.0130339749,
-0.0278189201,
0.0426646657,
-0.0372309573,
0.0544754006,
-0.0430463478,
0.0452043526,
-0.0052957516,
-0.0386984535,
-0.0276512634,
-0.0003610077,
-0.1037296355,
-0.0160936192,
-0.0122073144,
0.0574583635,
0.0128826331,
0.0367506333,
-0.0029932524,
0.0022213736,
-0.0008317549,
-0.0092074675,
0.0019178261,
0.0373411588,
0.0119674969,
0.0131381936,
-0.0001145353,
0.0080179153,
0.0395230651,
0.0121105192,
0.0389010198,
-0.0148498742,
-0.0155859515,
-0.0064458433,
-0.0092812506,
0.0198812522,
0.0169362091,
0.062997736,
0.0255448744,
-0.0062958212,
0.0259079244,
-0.0530782305,
-0.0066518388,
-0.0464203842,
0.0108374162,
0.0073398668,
-0.0092902509,
0.0044711614,
-0.0308491513,
0.0139655685,
0.0254077706,
-0.0115253702,
0.0129132969,
0.0119590377,
-0.0055862116,
0.0493031219,
0.005874923,
0.0166235361,
-0.0034336643,
-0.0468172766,
0.0656652674,
0.0013807578,
0.0437767133,
0.0283711627,
-0.0083696358,
-0.0503781885,
-0.0172738601,
-0.0665874183,
-0.1099999249,
0.0063606543,
0.0424248762,
0.0548534989,
0.0260673724,
-0.050417617,
-0.0473325178,
-0.0063351365,
0.0011232413,
0.0180396996,
0.0487797335,
-0.0264695436,
0.07591708,
0.0431270637,
0.0153997447,
-0.0413690582,
0.0273020808,
0.0052769189,
0.0112398099,
0.0286750533,
0.0120174102,
-0.0205687396,
-0.0274438895,
0.0193535816,
0.0133744609,
0.0128397066,
0.0500187203,
-0.0708333254,
-0.0903866887,
0.0083720041,
0.0473313704,
-0.0075618275,
0.0442588218,
0.0274860542,
0.067632921,
-0.0037344976,
-0.0035982868,
0.0140099488,
0.0289393105,
-0.0453516282,
-0.0234782342,
0.0043045012,
-5.273766508e-33,
0.0108203869,
-0.0335177183,
0.0842876583,
0.0041146707,
0.0164564569,
0.0064137601,
-0.0121825896,
0.0181008782,
-0.014260551,
-0.0020488498,
0.0228335578,
-0.0009458831,
-0.0197246782,
0.0509887412,
-0.0178992432,
0.0097965477,
-0.0047573959,
0.0055395886,
-0.0267634783,
-0.009057953,
0.0022923206,
-0.017599389,
-0.0023717606,
-0.0395655707,
-0.005427917,
0.0181017052,
0.0198332723,
0.0272326488,
-0.0530224256,
0.0666135177,
-0.022283338,
-0.0114320153,
0.0373543687,
0.007946494,
-0.0248988625,
0.0247631855,
-0.0655543655,
-0.0277812928,
-0.0093491357,
0.0296485685,
-0.09071289,
0.0001144112,
0.0050613754,
-0.0080480799,
0.0034542959,
-0.085987024,
0.0444085486,
-0.0328277349,
-0.0315874629,
0.0190407,
-0.0078242663,
0.0274648592,
-0.0196531136,
-0.0417834111,
0.0370641649,
0.0063666152,
0.0049722209,
0.0540987328,
-0.0034242386,
0.0146580171,
0.0199736115,
-0.001588764,
0.045820564,
0.0039722635,
0.0084001841,
0.045707088,
0.0167052057,
-0.0465722866,
-0.0394233689,
-0.0013641204,
0.0280706901,
0.0683762133,
0.0594441332,
0.0193331465,
0.0232777596,
0.0323716216,
-0.0578279309,
0.0037418692,
-0.0777749345,
0.0520062968,
0.017447859,
-0.001676901,
-0.0292701684,
-0.0140292412,
-0.0500928164,
0.0099176615,
-0.0465017743,
0.0315622836,
0.0335075371,
0.0031604108,
0.0252230018,
0.0365059115,
0.0183700975,
-0.0570764728,
-0.0230424888,
0.0310034938,
0.0185650699,
0.0301493611,
0.0032251461,
0.0636223406,
-0.0368396416,
0.0084547373,
-0.0035956723,
0.0136802802,
0.0011522385,
-0.0128963459,
0.0328911692,
0.013102226,
-0.0482053347,
-0.0196740497,
-0.0715474561,
-0.0337120257,
0.0257097706,
0.0572031587,
0.0374584869,
0.0350863039,
-0.0189777911,
0.0632865727,
-0.0401841365,
-0.0457629375,
-0.0192163419,
0.0179955754,
-0.0500970259,
0.0158981793,
-0.0147749763,
-0.0120689739,
-0.0367797725,
-0.0214961804,
0.0454892479,
-0.0557618812,
0.0078378515,
0.0324019045,
2.574e-7,
0.0273890272,
0.0478420146,
0.0301450305,
0.0128247328,
0.0377621986,
0.0380644053,
-0.0300688017,
-0.0216369815,
0.0053830133,
0.0266959928,
-0.009053926,
0.0740203261,
0.0239015259,
0.0261509847,
-0.0383245125,
0.0925280452,
0.0157472584,
-0.04286699,
-0.0748312399,
0.001068003,
0.093246229,
0.0291231535,
-0.0211240742,
-0.0023654276,
0.0207502749,
-0.0579594746,
0.0416583903,
-0.0254467241,
-0.0030225604,
-0.0114769628,
-0.0151404096,
0.0011735967,
-0.0021495237,
0.0093650557,
0.014866964,
-0.013169935,
0.0140674533,
0.0512862653,
0.0159665588,
0.0140144611,
-0.013889553,
-0.0392826758,
-0.0352533534,
-0.0562207215,
0.0714394227,
-0.0610197745,
-0.0436204672,
0.000240793,
0.0278774798,
0.0028147108,
0.0260892976,
0.0094269738,
0.0033499422,
-0.017621357,
0.0455827229,
-0.0374405421,
0.0169546716,
-0.0964324921,
0.0098032067,
0.0172999371,
-0.0203756522,
-0.0218539983,
-0.0628104731,
0.0057119746,
0.0343715474,
0.0008990664,
-0.0588088259,
2.311777929e-34,
0.0217555482,
-0.0080563901,
0.0029494192,
-0.0111967865,
0.0270724948,
-0.0355936773,
0.0048921583,
0.0060158069,
-0.0042565973,
-0.0753056929,
0.0092367167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14183v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14183v2 | On Early Detection of Hallucinations in Factual Question Answering | 2023-12-19T14:35:04 | 2023-12-27T20:26:49 | Ben Snyder, Marius Moisescu, Muhammad Bilal Zafar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While large language models (LLMs) have taken great strides towards helping
humans with a plethora of tasks like search and summarization, hallucinations
remain a major impediment towards gaining user trust. The fluency and coherence
of model generations even when hallucinating makes it difficult to detect
whether or not a model is hallucinating. In this work, we explore if the
artifacts associated with the model generations can provide hints that the
generation will contain hallucinations. Specifically, we probe LLMs at 1) the
inputs via Integrated Gradients based token attribution, 2) the outputs via the
Softmax probabilities, and 3) the internal state via self-attention and
fully-connected layer activations for signs of hallucinations on open-ended
question answering tasks. Our results show that the distributions of these
artifacts differ between hallucinated and non-hallucinated generations.
Building on this insight, we train binary classifiers that use these artifacts
as input features to classify model generations into hallucinations and
non-hallucinations. These hallucination classifiers achieve up to 0.80 AUROC.
We further show that tokens preceding a hallucination can predict the
subsequent hallucination before it occurs. | [
0.0252633765,
0.0257709399,
-0.0056677917,
0.0367694348,
-0.0029162136,
0.0066696922,
-0.0271608327,
0.0057363263,
-0.0100566279,
-0.0398982018,
-0.0199947376,
-0.0712762326,
-0.004309345,
-0.0135393161,
0.0210816152,
-0.0299433824,
0.0553276874,
-0.0460287221,
0.007294795,
-0.0196002834,
-0.0027201315,
0.0047616893,
0.0056649013,
0.0647607744,
-0.0350148194,
-0.0470794253,
0.0153901298,
0.0092386762,
-0.000928837,
0.006093137,
0.0299570784,
0.0802897885,
-0.0209791753,
0.0697703958,
0.000001918,
-0.0431105047,
0.0321283825,
-0.0435459465,
-0.042024646,
0.0059835245,
-0.0243050624,
0.0460715704,
0.0253210049,
0.0067905379,
-0.0438783206,
0.0250448007,
0.0304073635,
0.0991542786,
0.0630373955,
0.0490879118,
0.0104318894,
-0.0169971213,
0.0360641927,
0.0262142215,
0.0550988801,
0.0060564699,
0.023304835,
-0.0208605733,
-0.0271601826,
-0.0404937267,
-0.011654187,
0.0295271222,
0.0415021069,
-0.0102199093,
0.0273608677,
0.0358363055,
-0.0620198511,
-0.0202444028,
-0.0219875239,
0.0715887025,
-0.0485979468,
-0.0448273681,
0.0021183852,
0.0152924405,
0.0303265378,
-0.0013343901,
-0.02892223,
0.0036422159,
-0.0132062547,
0.0098425038,
0.0266590528,
-0.003376157,
0.041504439,
0.0289368387,
-0.0160590913,
0.0956656188,
-0.0059014205,
-0.0399981737,
0.0264698789,
0.0124833491,
-0.0087900842,
-0.0618226491,
0.0240020063,
0.0418245681,
-0.0375606753,
0.0036333106,
-0.0522591136,
0.0207385495,
0.03082202,
-0.045519527,
-0.011724025,
-0.0229479373,
-0.0866946205,
0.0674425736,
-0.0539102964,
0.0262239426,
-0.0088732466,
0.0634115189,
-0.0059374995,
0.0076912767,
-0.009553534,
-0.0353601165,
-0.0566071011,
0.0234417561,
0.0336528122,
-0.0429792739,
-0.0115987407,
0.0035123294,
-0.0311947018,
-0.0177209973,
-0.020667199,
0.0553846955,
0.0211720932,
-0.0166962333,
-0.0272473637,
0.0203851573,
-0.0501286276,
0.0004155465,
0.0213314686,
-0.086373426,
-0.0489229113,
0.032121513,
-0.0061568911,
0.0092801219,
0.0026006014,
-0.0000092863,
0.0167608894,
-0.0051416671,
-0.0361728296,
-0.0526737683,
-0.0252083372,
-0.0532682613,
0.0006714751,
-0.0507037006,
-0.0109925251,
-0.0282978844,
-0.0082998211,
-0.0180035625,
0.0245211106,
0.0167020578,
-0.0246320292,
0.0660820231,
-0.0313381292,
-0.0049005267,
0.0315802582,
0.0280328579,
-0.0184390098,
0.0567800812,
0.0048514502,
0.0336506963,
0.0258216839,
-0.0210642088,
0.0824812353,
-0.0047959089,
0.0148437992,
0.0101414565,
0.0083813537,
0.0010564859,
-0.0049379268,
0.0163692739,
0.031899374,
0.0413829871,
-0.0164637845,
-0.0474452712,
0.0727088824,
0.0444880873,
-0.0248049777,
-0.0009019219,
0.0191090517,
-0.0145563297,
0.0079526175,
0.037797384,
-0.0694316253,
0.0411908403,
-0.0174957607,
-0.0008264502,
0.0393881425,
-0.0243794117,
-0.0083257165,
-0.0462230369,
-0.0174983852,
0.0113416333,
-0.0129796397,
0.0094725471,
0.0005646987,
0.0242244732,
-0.0563671328,
0.041721344,
-0.0022328887,
-0.0300180912,
0.0316571705,
-0.0761710405,
0.0459938906,
0.0710664839,
0.0229915362,
-0.0183930174,
0.0121891499,
-0.0437505953,
0.0444886982,
0.0546907671,
0.0115050515,
0.0023025505,
0.0231936723,
-0.0320912562,
0.014816626,
-0.0008419824,
0.0344761536,
-0.0083977906,
-0.0158443917,
0.0140390806,
0.0002675824,
-0.0336482301,
-0.0165813547,
0.048455406,
0.0196601823,
-0.0335488655,
0.004146806,
-0.0098695625,
0.007206175,
-0.0002545763,
0.0108896066,
0.0321499147,
0.0107920226,
-0.0373643413,
-0.0711042061,
0.0017580538,
-0.0575487651,
0.0083028991,
0.0357992165,
-0.0141223734,
0.0052071842,
0.0021702268,
-0.0018279471,
-0.0372955091,
0.0134682255,
-0.0605210625,
0.0227539018,
-0.0493045077,
0.0287965462,
0.0100297341,
0.0756550208,
-0.0100513985,
0.0771622956,
-0.0325569771,
0.0200232789,
-0.0078385593,
-0.0346102417,
-0.0010965659,
0.0010732785,
-0.0152774183,
-0.0253011864,
-0.0190619193,
0.0289648734,
-0.0065045389,
-0.0549005009,
-0.0734009296,
-0.0205618963,
-0.0686070919,
-0.0114518618,
-0.0441870429,
0.0045687216,
0.0209602844,
-0.0493523888,
-0.0075327675,
-0.0247997288,
-0.0451466292,
0.0150913298,
-0.0043029999,
0.0389380939,
0.0153577486,
-0.0037404078,
-0.0242670942,
-0.030521227,
0.0143672116,
-0.0194819476,
0.0387265384,
-0.0149525087,
-0.0326144882,
-0.0955050811,
-0.0225896817,
-0.0250724927,
0.0111192754,
0.0123073375,
-0.0340022705,
0.0130456463,
0.0271034446,
0.0359884724,
0.1140910387,
0.0490366854,
0.0509937331,
0.0389924198,
-0.0219675135,
-0.0373736247,
0.0085473582,
-0.002888809,
0.0060980641,
-0.0171813462,
-0.028100295,
0.0379319489,
0.0596899353,
0.0239029285,
-0.0027942981,
-0.0492393151,
0.0123158395,
-0.0601356551,
-0.0554314479,
0.0152156418,
-0.0335431807,
-0.0276211016,
0.0445615947,
-0.0124917012,
-0.053447485,
0.0924583375,
-0.0349009223,
0.0021233039,
-0.0060335891,
-0.033732295,
-0.0063471766,
0.0269254576,
0.0052971952,
-0.0015548937,
0.0120891985,
-0.0343309678,
-0.0347767472,
0.0013851895,
-0.0396752246,
-0.0354547054,
0.033703994,
-0.006450613,
-0.0049447385,
0.0345002525,
-0.0197766162,
-0.0573964678,
-0.0579854362,
-0.0129488967,
-0.0122982739,
-0.042872522,
-0.0088912584,
-0.0237890445,
-0.0068257754,
-0.0102405287,
0.002006459,
-0.0676652119,
-0.0165136103,
0.0114114527,
0.025316285,
0.1014420763,
0.0239386,
0.0485362932,
-0.0342660025,
0.0222011227,
0.0717247203,
0.0398841463,
0.0575099327,
-0.0176769644,
-0.0411278568,
0.0335946009,
-0.032357078,
-0.0311715845,
0.025194183,
0.0459277108,
-0.0672870353,
-0.0045155603,
0.0955042168,
0.0183761101,
-0.0585660227,
0.0089967269,
-0.0487373658,
0.0305351,
0.0017092436,
-0.0221188832,
-0.07734216,
-0.0418546572,
-0.0255216546,
0.011122155,
-0.0198776312,
-0.0149762314,
0.0086287642,
-0.0603269413,
0.0204927064,
-0.014435146,
-0.025261946,
-0.0022200316,
-0.002310812,
0.0085626598,
0.0364157781,
0.0403850228,
-0.0160822757,
0.0098184394,
-0.0235368293,
0.0259112045,
-0.0342449658,
0.0186146293,
0.0324802175,
-0.0230325498,
0.0623578988,
0.0838189349,
0.038301602,
-0.0100546144,
-0.0845436156,
0.0467721708,
-0.0258814674,
0.009464833,
-0.0000150214,
0.0575330667,
0.0003903493,
0.0093488479,
-0.0112094749,
0.0527951829,
-0.053845726,
0.0038042564,
0.011708417,
0.0745902658,
-0.040956609,
-0.0949706137,
-0.0288134813,
0.0410701111,
0.0170546044,
0.0715252459,
0.0464758947,
-0.0489555039,
-0.0786472484,
-0.0221142601,
0.0407633781,
-0.0311433561,
-0.0294412933,
0.0534102432,
0.0847759917,
-0.0303201452,
-0.0807425529,
-0.0385656804,
-0.008255817,
0.0074972319,
-0.0119061749,
0.0409252159,
-0.0497360975,
0.0071194205,
-0.022419801,
0.057174325,
-0.0366650969,
0.0231709983,
-0.0729296878,
0.0207445342,
0.0181548651,
-0.010339479,
-0.0023232982,
0.038410306,
-0.0868980885,
-0.0508518144,
0.0554334372,
0.039930746,
0.0212767143,
0.0181534849,
-0.0327777229,
-0.0746227577,
0.0824782327,
0.0226188339,
0.0042661368,
0.0060633318,
0.0150632141,
-0.0129458783,
-0.0099262372,
0.0455206297,
-0.0166480243,
-0.0080831023,
-0.0023913691,
-0.0013083926,
-0.0171189662,
-0.0184107386,
0.0165240578,
-0.0252259783,
0.033896666,
-0.0052944184,
0.0220391005,
0.0048876991,
0.0116651664,
0.0299936738,
-0.0018376283,
-0.0010871023,
-0.0107049132,
0.0383985005,
-0.0383289345,
0.0151044577,
-0.0419958383,
-0.0151505116,
0.0029982424,
-0.0275791548,
-0.0199904982,
0.0199170373,
0.0002415131,
0.0296121687,
-0.0248381179,
-0.0353298672,
0.0059234956,
0.0051583597,
0.0503057241,
0.0347662121,
0.0512530133,
0.0003622892,
-0.0204052981,
-0.0071445475,
0.0122361472,
-0.0600105003,
-0.0838320553,
-0.021741461,
0.007852328,
0.0346274227,
0.0054238294,
0.0568271317,
-0.0027538622,
0.0119455727,
-0.0115246708,
0.0026878824,
0.0368906595,
-0.0541454256,
0.0250077415,
0.0258381851,
-0.0278693903,
-0.0086122947,
0.0792152956,
-0.0396107845,
0.0304113217,
0.0044636754,
-0.0240759496,
-0.0143000931,
-0.0371081457,
-0.0476428568,
0.0178483836,
-0.0094191628,
0.0244006068,
-0.0338238291,
-0.0361842699,
-0.0047202557,
-0.0056571411,
0.0113192862,
-0.0103808939,
0.0172046535,
0.0615363233,
0.0041122613,
-0.0416764393,
-0.0309607554,
0.0067661367,
0.0412105359,
0.0004082799,
-0.0128080407,
-6.7584122e-33,
0.024525471,
-0.0382383019,
-0.016176844,
-0.0230137035,
-0.0090860426,
-0.0016849925,
-0.0109482566,
0.0231559072,
-0.0321769491,
0.0206457842,
-0.0223548319,
0.0520910434,
0.0196907073,
0.0258119144,
0.0117450031,
-0.0578178316,
0.03679258,
0.0063741398,
-0.0252378806,
0.0228664689,
0.0334492549,
0.0077564227,
0.0788487867,
-0.0309341308,
0.0610232577,
-0.0197536293,
-0.0311963186,
0.0390992537,
-0.0172154158,
0.0398486927,
-0.0324771181,
0.066723749,
0.0286380202,
-0.048077751,
0.0009207202,
0.0250065085,
-0.0385222547,
-0.0299120154,
0.0098207016,
0.0302166883,
-0.0784889758,
-0.0540801063,
0.0568447374,
0.0026544279,
0.0209201928,
-0.0321657024,
0.0444999263,
-0.0017055316,
0.0033407146,
-0.0170233343,
-0.0470617376,
0.0022652177,
0.0095621692,
-0.024875531,
-0.0256327521,
0.0336979143,
-0.0233779754,
-0.0246710088,
-0.0749741122,
0.0153574999,
-0.0152061395,
0.0425508358,
0.0575799979,
0.0041518249,
-0.0075764451,
0.0733400658,
0.065721646,
0.0182613786,
-0.0604322553,
-0.0193864554,
0.0190698914,
0.0195383094,
0.0630837306,
-0.0262028761,
0.0830203891,
0.0099609792,
-0.0143448226,
-0.016970966,
-0.0095437411,
0.0277255289,
0.0686091557,
-0.0243731234,
-0.0399612747,
-0.0187584348,
-0.0352863073,
0.024069665,
-0.0373200253,
-0.0351856239,
0.0161660407,
0.0117697958,
-0.016952958,
-0.0141005553,
0.0309343599,
-0.0367851816,
-0.0024032588,
0.0218122285,
-0.0104146022,
-0.0079396525,
0.0250348616,
0.0082645584,
0.0192635357,
0.0398344286,
0.0206047799,
-0.0236148052,
0.0445341803,
0.0312997773,
0.0317533538,
-0.0097762197,
-0.0761734024,
0.0057626334,
-0.0068740197,
0.0252212584,
-0.0021201381,
0.0231302325,
0.0453744493,
0.0027242494,
-0.0283931978,
-0.0064075175,
-0.0036097218,
0.0438237488,
-0.0296296794,
0.0419413075,
-0.0350927599,
0.0093211075,
-0.0357361548,
-0.0207793321,
-0.0450236425,
-0.0159216058,
-0.0047805067,
-0.1029186621,
-0.0089027127,
0.0170620289,
2.711e-7,
-0.003337634,
0.0443245061,
0.0073477416,
0.0139754741,
0.028341325,
0.0320781954,
0.055532299,
0.0079332702,
0.0347684324,
-0.0631332025,
-0.0275861733,
0.0259751435,
0.0518601872,
0.0668953955,
-0.1079982072,
-0.0350829065,
-0.0554576255,
0.0273932852,
-0.0489096679,
-0.0565709993,
0.0237472672,
0.0721038058,
0.0176293999,
-0.0343346409,
-0.000173251,
-0.0630609542,
0.0281023439,
0.0191459209,
0.0319695286,
0.0250769481,
0.0683127791,
-0.017886769,
0.0243759807,
0.0601937361,
-0.0126452846,
-0.0219329931,
-0.0120627517,
0.003776331,
-0.0259804688,
-0.0820722431,
-0.0234827921,
0.001734398,
0.0480810963,
-0.064951241,
0.0484300517,
-0.0111937821,
-0.0069284523,
-0.0380413309,
-0.0040124636,
-0.0401797332,
0.0671386197,
-0.0269130282,
-0.002749474,
0.0347998403,
0.0006142174,
0.0188165195,
0.0194656458,
-0.0686885715,
-0.025054818,
-0.0160669051,
-0.0167559795,
0.0005908087,
-0.0193734635,
0.0271199029,
0.0087651433,
-0.0731711984,
0.0154626602,
2.412778838e-34,
0.0238283947,
-0.0067039183,
0.0550189316,
0.0632431656,
0.0231956691,
0.0193353686,
0.0312564038,
-0.0135150859,
0.0317300223,
-0.0406400412,
-0.0148422178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12148v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12148v1 | Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning Methods for Pretrained Language Models: A Critical Review and Assessment | 2023-12-19T13:31:24 | 2023-12-19T13:31:24 | Lingling Xu, Haoran Xie, Si-Zhao Joe Qin, Xiaohui Tao, Fu Lee Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the continuous growth in the number of parameters of transformer-based
pretrained language models (PLMs), particularly the emergence of large language
models (LLMs) with billions of parameters, many natural language processing
(NLP) tasks have demonstrated remarkable success. However, the enormous size
and computational demands of these models pose significant challenges for
adapting them to specific downstream tasks, especially in environments with
limited computational resources. Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) offers
an effective solution by reducing the number of fine-tuning parameters and
memory usage while achieving comparable performance to full fine-tuning. The
demands for fine-tuning PLMs, especially LLMs, have led to a surge in the
development of PEFT methods, as depicted in Fig. 1. In this paper, we present a
comprehensive and systematic review of PEFT methods for PLMs. We summarize
these PEFT methods, discuss their applications, and outline future directions.
Furthermore, we conduct experiments using several representative PEFT methods
to better understand their effectiveness in parameter efficiency and memory
efficiency. By offering insights into the latest advancements and practical
applications, this survey serves as an invaluable resource for researchers and
practitioners seeking to navigate the challenges and opportunities presented by
PEFT in the context of PLMs. | [
0.0591566972,
0.0421082862,
-0.002862995,
0.0350734219,
-0.0077784467,
0.0174369477,
-0.0131478412,
-0.0077018188,
-0.0507099107,
-0.0630989671,
-0.0674409568,
-0.0384416804,
0.0246486999,
-0.0114961695,
0.0151401041,
-0.0367694609,
0.046880383,
-0.022617586,
-0.0088806693,
0.0175219439,
-0.0027641612,
0.0116782151,
-0.0069366512,
0.0416167602,
0.0244707633,
0.0175592657,
-0.0039575389,
0.0215383936,
0.0280462503,
0.0218989272,
0.0225727409,
0.0808910429,
-0.0058415164,
0.0154042616,
0.0000019876,
-0.0247032344,
-0.0407127328,
-0.005595068,
-0.0067177946,
0.0433604941,
0.0699536204,
-0.0019359312,
0.0011664656,
0.0375446379,
-0.0249905214,
-0.0598207749,
0.0651624948,
0.0450435951,
0.0412992164,
0.0817611665,
-0.0127504151,
-0.0311153941,
0.0067953244,
-0.0189147405,
-0.0496289358,
-0.0156682692,
0.029850537,
-0.0718083307,
-0.0168192405,
-0.00843783,
-0.0396581329,
0.0169556867,
-0.0137298591,
0.0359070674,
-0.0287798811,
-0.0076083196,
-0.0457471311,
-0.0506246313,
-0.0217937846,
0.0609295927,
-0.0881779864,
-0.0286647733,
0.0053238878,
-0.0261805821,
-0.0500770882,
0.0108151101,
-0.0028738058,
0.0129498979,
0.0195905212,
0.0216941517,
0.0222683102,
-0.011766539,
0.0100242887,
0.0321087465,
-0.0606280342,
0.0340470858,
0.0391577631,
0.0003436557,
-0.0011541931,
-0.0212025158,
-0.0393701121,
-0.0055358605,
0.0090747168,
0.0190774929,
-0.0148104792,
0.0045893653,
-0.059133593,
-0.0492905378,
0.0172516257,
0.0062082629,
0.0754139423,
0.0442358665,
0.0108718602,
0.0274909604,
-0.0316114388,
0.0032370363,
-0.0233443473,
0.0484655984,
-0.0498302393,
-0.0182813685,
-0.0277833156,
0.0150623135,
-0.0941051915,
-0.0072891396,
-0.0212319642,
-0.0235466789,
-0.0243002288,
0.0090648709,
0.0417411625,
-0.0415722989,
0.036488533,
-0.0042574797,
-0.0303533282,
-0.0214200877,
0.0143058887,
0.0697463155,
-0.0134842293,
0.0080066342,
-0.0487586074,
-0.0633720309,
-0.015600713,
0.0259635635,
0.0363990031,
-0.040924862,
0.0277490746,
0.0239026733,
0.0101758018,
-0.083831124,
-0.0437999256,
0.0183638725,
-0.0097545693,
-0.0711757541,
-0.0031187255,
-0.0449387878,
0.0296487473,
0.0018659038,
0.0441413298,
-0.029851215,
0.004712082,
0.0036641699,
-0.0544966646,
0.0741461217,
-0.0172397308,
0.0332532451,
0.0043034991,
-0.0098504601,
0.0231833607,
0.0686777532,
0.0478122421,
0.0288706422,
0.0285442397,
-0.0435777754,
0.0002194027,
0.050752975,
-0.0172809381,
0.0074452255,
0.0058308053,
-0.0201752447,
0.0176388528,
-0.0066386983,
0.0095315157,
0.0390192568,
-0.0247130673,
0.0086401347,
0.0542094335,
0.0284425598,
0.0646744445,
0.0432806015,
0.0441447161,
0.0044122012,
0.0524896085,
-0.034680374,
-0.0298042987,
-0.0044187861,
-0.049160365,
0.0014904262,
0.0038402637,
0.0740323514,
-0.0405685715,
-0.0126983197,
0.0019021851,
-0.023888275,
0.0020453653,
-0.0072244583,
0.0586211495,
0.0159095749,
-0.0633401498,
0.09732043,
0.035801053,
-0.0266263429,
-0.0114546362,
-0.0374132916,
-0.0356393643,
0.0581013374,
0.032557454,
-0.03972755,
-0.0345853344,
0.0184312854,
0.0404452682,
0.0176358484,
0.0465660803,
0.0385194384,
0.0185669437,
-0.0628824756,
-0.0215036552,
0.0130617833,
0.0071514868,
-0.0013235813,
0.0456625,
-0.0034247041,
0.0389422849,
-0.0251444522,
-0.0380227938,
0.0416058563,
-0.0064246105,
-0.0105841374,
0.0178577695,
0.0085659977,
0.0158954393,
-0.0064029121,
-0.0044253333,
0.0091855563,
0.0408308096,
-0.0038038495,
0.036567416,
-0.016788872,
-0.0231570192,
0.001788919,
0.0167641938,
-0.0187978745,
0.0425968654,
0.0476184189,
-0.0412214436,
-0.0467126258,
-0.0151529843,
-0.0292967558,
0.0572808385,
-0.033984486,
0.0550417826,
-0.0498644486,
0.0423359796,
-0.0276502669,
-0.0174073279,
0.0141129773,
0.0173454285,
0.016791068,
0.0254713707,
0.0146029349,
-0.0191583391,
-0.055672273,
-0.0047548157,
0.0024144726,
0.0144770732,
0.002386685,
0.0249917116,
-0.0345470943,
-0.0467605777,
-0.0897929892,
0.0359315686,
-0.0429630466,
-0.0008793197,
0.0122716995,
0.0228267629,
-0.0213032644,
-0.0009646263,
0.0169397667,
0.0253898129,
-0.0048558344,
0.024582183,
0.0088063702,
-0.0226368494,
-0.0403411239,
-0.033274807,
-0.0252239406,
0.0089541133,
0.0460944325,
-0.0153886136,
-0.0231507216,
-0.0669718087,
0.0242642816,
0.0078019314,
0.0399675854,
0.0078615686,
-0.0699825212,
-0.0228999406,
-0.0219737589,
0.0578350648,
0.0391740091,
0.0034826212,
0.0210376345,
0.0309074614,
-0.0044618687,
-0.0128097897,
-0.0032860849,
-0.0702956989,
-0.0606712624,
-0.0275639445,
0.0126317618,
0.003116376,
0.0893587843,
-0.0444078669,
-0.0018654622,
-0.0591444224,
0.0249782316,
-0.0318139978,
0.0066930735,
0.0375751741,
0.0173351876,
-0.0173426047,
0.0060074939,
0.0024241009,
-0.0550297014,
0.0496222787,
-0.079606995,
-0.003530954,
-0.0500560701,
-0.0007018447,
-0.0244789049,
0.0125421956,
0.0315614194,
0.0174622815,
0.0205588657,
-0.0093116025,
-0.0329567306,
0.0341216698,
0.0066670366,
-0.0310546029,
0.0449050888,
0.0002369708,
0.007177168,
-0.0329721831,
-0.007770522,
-0.0283742938,
-0.0752720237,
-0.0190683119,
0.0175505392,
0.0387920253,
-0.031197479,
-0.0322681032,
0.0384073555,
-0.0116000632,
0.0261949319,
-0.0172948185,
-0.0028294045,
-0.0405050293,
0.0118366377,
0.055085931,
0.0210035034,
0.0570492186,
-0.0068394658,
-0.0096340682,
0.0122101614,
0.0200693998,
0.0025758082,
-0.0340818875,
0.0008932882,
0.0431684144,
-0.0503578819,
0.005418133,
0.0053031989,
0.03893397,
-0.0535322018,
-0.0003827099,
0.1353371441,
0.0438881703,
-0.0400222093,
0.0147764152,
0.0622144639,
0.0077205678,
0.0086865136,
0.0281176623,
-0.0530128852,
-0.0411713645,
-0.0054271268,
0.0380207896,
-0.0060724034,
-0.0109168692,
-0.0130501427,
-0.0972328857,
0.0083098598,
0.028424317,
0.0240858849,
-0.0319810212,
-0.0317683816,
0.0057764556,
-0.0225534905,
0.0044160588,
0.0065941811,
-0.0272713229,
-0.0200997684,
0.0119125396,
-0.0092416508,
-0.0653176755,
0.0201243442,
-0.0495634414,
0.0149492882,
-0.0106582213,
-0.0236958172,
-0.0012770565,
-0.0297966041,
0.0158239827,
-0.0486388542,
0.0095320139,
-0.0448826067,
-0.0015764859,
-0.0159743968,
-0.0342871584,
0.0257250201,
0.0097324764,
-0.0427170172,
-0.017862767,
-0.0567826405,
0.0450825989,
-0.0365115814,
0.0018286996,
0.0288480856,
0.0065457923,
-0.0144412694,
0.0592388026,
0.0285024699,
-0.0445569642,
-0.0115451738,
0.0172039866,
-0.0192271098,
-0.0256545544,
-0.0262631439,
-0.0087464154,
0.0064947135,
-0.0172940996,
-0.0276680887,
0.022017898,
0.0526236184,
0.0261476673,
0.0017029066,
-0.0064232629,
0.0451822951,
0.0014103627,
-0.0427255929,
0.0609653071,
-0.0366455205,
0.0024696372,
-0.0852911547,
-0.0346530378,
0.0687749609,
-0.0018635641,
-0.005781963,
0.0226400513,
-0.1077706739,
-0.0577312745,
0.0413591713,
0.0614092983,
0.0123063922,
0.0161946639,
-0.0269285068,
-0.0657318458,
0.0185208078,
0.009054522,
-0.0353324525,
0.0271391924,
0.0268425085,
-0.0197620858,
-0.0241229907,
0.0194690377,
-0.0079131797,
0.0130719747,
0.0356585905,
0.0440190695,
0.0042760447,
-0.106575422,
-0.0012343366,
0.0069416873,
0.0943672061,
-0.0268677324,
-0.0125363981,
-0.0280815922,
0.0400065556,
-0.0017732187,
0.0011872901,
-0.035062857,
-0.0290795118,
0.0166545343,
0.010666565,
-0.0423108675,
-0.0030379118,
-0.0103307338,
0.0200960469,
-0.0018508648,
0.0543297641,
-0.0093653221,
-0.0359139852,
0.0270313211,
0.0040332866,
-0.0081584416,
0.0579637177,
0.0228812061,
0.0051647043,
-0.0395299047,
0.0665849373,
0.000817269,
0.0217722971,
-0.1053276211,
0.058074262,
-0.0092746848,
-0.072448276,
-0.0477631465,
0.0225278363,
0.0488407984,
-0.0257790312,
0.0460794978,
-0.0235652775,
-0.0275609028,
-0.0134272259,
0.0352392867,
0.0033834344,
0.0416561626,
0.0148205934,
0.0096279169,
-0.0337539203,
0.0162130427,
0.0475688167,
0.0192993134,
0.0380795076,
0.0245625246,
-0.0155166807,
-0.0091884062,
-0.002373833,
-0.0364234969,
-0.0183945671,
-0.0296355858,
0.0017618068,
-0.0333674885,
-0.0288665704,
0.0198759902,
-0.0276583545,
-0.0164509881,
-0.0117728794,
0.0446813591,
0.0378809981,
-0.0230836812,
0.004230991,
-0.0203710571,
-0.0393304862,
0.0312957056,
-0.0071097049,
0.0065706503,
-6.613126241e-33,
-0.0338461436,
0.0118406508,
-0.0034488419,
0.0248301942,
-0.0270208959,
-0.0173624791,
-0.0062035862,
0.0126260547,
-0.0133855948,
-0.0281035509,
-0.0167798083,
-0.0158659425,
0.0311825648,
0.0192427728,
-0.0368059911,
-0.0133785913,
0.0636648461,
-0.0078657884,
-0.0168679375,
0.0058870628,
0.0010517504,
0.0368644372,
0.0653146431,
-0.0079064118,
-0.0529101714,
0.0196551755,
-0.0183061119,
0.0364504419,
-0.0069592819,
0.0533262417,
-0.0192073807,
0.0353830829,
0.0130252782,
-0.0420883968,
-0.0277849827,
0.0320314132,
-0.080072768,
0.0004803075,
0.0292305611,
0.0183394738,
0.0091812853,
-0.0093375556,
0.0566109903,
-0.0004240698,
-0.0095506702,
0.0066636871,
0.0031408579,
-0.0281310156,
-0.0015030124,
-0.0435767211,
-0.074864395,
0.0233625062,
0.0146971969,
-0.0186578352,
0.0502538942,
0.0010583971,
-0.0288682822,
0.051495906,
-0.050293196,
-0.0216242317,
0.0973915458,
0.0723386183,
0.0378812477,
0.0198607706,
0.0107186586,
-0.0026429561,
-0.008717116,
0.0023229576,
0.0040067942,
0.0155735221,
0.0904200822,
0.0392237864,
0.0348966457,
-0.003994809,
0.0073747267,
-0.0222515985,
-0.0473530032,
-0.0074164048,
-0.0182335693,
0.0551598892,
0.0217342339,
-0.0070067211,
0.0098616751,
-0.0131955435,
-0.0684601888,
-0.0015577442,
-0.0366028994,
-0.002689908,
0.016879024,
0.0366238952,
-0.0560384244,
0.0182677265,
0.057780616,
-0.058620166,
0.0274021272,
-0.0073535861,
0.0010179179,
0.0357351527,
-0.0356223918,
0.0232140534,
-0.0602332391,
-0.08642634,
0.032007385,
-0.0192050915,
-0.0000455475,
-0.0382897817,
0.0125281299,
0.0581717752,
-0.0635517389,
0.0150135942,
-0.0076642768,
0.0037636161,
0.0027706602,
0.0597433783,
0.0267979335,
0.0085266922,
-0.0070716026,
0.0281932391,
0.0159300677,
-0.0277536772,
-0.0177390184,
-0.0063118231,
0.0605539568,
0.0424035005,
-0.0015680748,
0.0196809471,
-0.0302168764,
-0.0122274375,
0.0399134532,
-0.0541490652,
-0.0126567082,
0.0258818381,
2.721e-7,
0.0779948831,
0.0769209638,
0.0139117409,
-0.0389605835,
0.0077535012,
0.002694316,
0.0081801694,
-0.0159607418,
0.0116193574,
0.023560185,
0.0393560641,
0.0243680403,
0.0559516847,
0.0041495254,
-0.0776735321,
-0.0093599409,
-0.0526413471,
0.0449907184,
-0.0552827045,
-0.0326320305,
0.0212944318,
0.1145411059,
-0.0015320354,
-0.0103657842,
0.0010263865,
-0.0044178846,
0.0627721325,
-0.0419985652,
-0.007364111,
0.0524649248,
0.0192164332,
0.0392304286,
-0.0044570272,
-0.0000275878,
-0.0292490032,
0.0534924641,
-0.0108192489,
0.0794992894,
-0.0138658406,
-0.0218692999,
0.0242553223,
-0.0102935014,
-0.0102901096,
-0.0658274516,
0.0722646564,
-0.104015924,
0.0049978425,
-0.02089254,
0.0113720084,
-0.0036061553,
0.0187338293,
-0.0543329865,
-0.0268050153,
0.0528469011,
0.0451037847,
0.0014570026,
-0.0508425161,
-0.0983073488,
-0.003188485,
0.0297986828,
-0.0192255098,
-0.0274446793,
-0.0378085673,
-0.0791258812,
0.0621698238,
-0.0376070738,
0.0032816913,
2.772152945e-34,
0.0396640003,
-0.0330090635,
0.0352140702,
-0.0173505303,
0.0159048885,
0.0198776051,
0.0080611231,
0.0227434039,
-0.0336366259,
-0.1270918846,
-0.0183880571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12141v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12141v3 | Neuron-Level Knowledge Attribution in Large Language Models | 2023-12-19T13:23:18 | 2024-06-09T20:03:02 | Zeping Yu, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Identifying important neurons for final predictions is essential for
understanding the mechanisms of large language models. Due to computational
constraints, current attribution techniques struggle to operate at neuron
level. In this paper, we propose a static method for pinpointing significant
neurons for different outputs. Compared to seven other methods, our approach
demonstrates superior performance across three metrics. Additionally, since
most static methods typically only identify "value neurons" directly
contributing to the final prediction, we introduce a static method for
identifying "query neurons" which activate these "value neurons". Finally, we
apply our methods to analyze the localization of six distinct types of
knowledge across both attention and feed-forward network (FFN) layers. Our
method and analysis are helpful for understanding the mechanisms of knowledge
storage and set the stage for future research in knowledge editing. We will
release our data and code on github. | [
0.0464236289,
0.0369272605,
-0.0249026734,
0.0569636635,
-0.0122035583,
-0.0200501736,
0.0211102553,
-0.0431026816,
-0.0560653992,
-0.0101276049,
-0.0583784655,
-0.0252793636,
0.0285489578,
0.0275641605,
0.0784140229,
0.0129441256,
0.0513032302,
0.0108617553,
-0.0028021564,
0.0060371691,
0.0006812238,
0.0015340133,
0.0398012437,
0.0615594834,
-0.0136343678,
-0.0351987965,
0.0032560972,
-0.0061169798,
0.011472092,
0.0452027805,
0.0089163743,
0.0509659052,
-0.0236183163,
0.0652302355,
0.0000021171,
0.0082865646,
0.0114362193,
-0.0109928735,
-0.0393159166,
0.0551401675,
0.018874567,
0.0133269979,
-0.0165612027,
-0.0214665961,
0.001661967,
0.0116299596,
0.0606774762,
0.0196696855,
0.0347671174,
0.0618735552,
0.0077290856,
-0.0153499721,
0.0245514084,
-0.0442187563,
0.0364252888,
-0.0221625902,
0.034812469,
-0.0096069733,
-0.0739373937,
-0.0037021833,
-0.015322431,
0.0814808458,
0.0383200943,
-0.0344492942,
0.045449324,
0.0407175384,
-0.0171199311,
-0.0002468383,
0.0051551214,
0.0312073138,
-0.0205326714,
-0.0400196239,
-0.0091686696,
0.006585625,
0.0238622222,
-0.0102186082,
-0.0564927012,
-0.0048472555,
0.0360739604,
-0.0008356023,
0.0293153804,
-0.0280394219,
0.0543460101,
0.0118536195,
0.0039445027,
0.0325595438,
0.0118316952,
0.0073022917,
-0.0453006029,
0.0007588278,
-0.034025494,
-0.0755462274,
0.0413679183,
0.0288982168,
0.0300933924,
0.0114349537,
-0.0219042972,
-0.0135838287,
-0.0088106776,
-0.0757108778,
0.0711016729,
0.0368240401,
0.0075827902,
0.0309169013,
-0.0511110984,
0.037218973,
-0.0206161141,
0.0523314252,
-0.0001854498,
0.0099882195,
-0.0485155806,
-0.0563851595,
-0.0242420454,
0.0108707873,
-0.0159838479,
-0.0371375754,
-0.0276069511,
0.0023665419,
-0.0206506941,
-0.0359870046,
-0.0135756815,
0.0498990864,
-0.0246676262,
0.0233473834,
-0.0012725316,
0.0572504178,
-0.0352725014,
0.0207707565,
0.0000907429,
-0.0174198505,
-0.0488279276,
0.0257843677,
0.0029725498,
-0.0585174263,
0.0064671021,
0.018659031,
-0.0093393158,
-0.0211608205,
-0.0652527362,
-0.0365840085,
-0.0227215402,
-0.041375272,
0.0224600062,
-0.0547788925,
0.0171145685,
-0.0050847386,
-0.0310114753,
-0.0496398509,
-0.0015474609,
0.0250292663,
-0.0333548076,
0.0357534848,
0.0234993994,
0.0253782198,
0.0236299764,
-0.0099713374,
-0.0312379617,
0.005046749,
0.0459151752,
0.0710069388,
0.0110001154,
0.0092950845,
-0.0042953398,
0.0336823799,
0.0929957554,
-0.0272565149,
-0.0634492412,
-0.0289000906,
0.0063532428,
0.0071685351,
0.0355961844,
0.0274779499,
-0.0280106179,
-0.005398537,
0.1023714021,
0.0385247543,
0.0124492412,
0.0326310955,
0.0274435803,
-0.0506781936,
0.0117213363,
-0.0540578812,
-0.0678229555,
0.0912317559,
-0.0099175181,
-0.0229295865,
0.0165487584,
0.0034464288,
-0.0224115551,
-0.0130186547,
0.0244960748,
0.0524460264,
-0.021441251,
0.0028083578,
0.024605833,
0.0237066448,
-0.0214129537,
0.0426435173,
-0.0098574208,
-0.0012126054,
0.0274220277,
-0.0591081269,
0.0147910723,
0.0234808773,
0.0301527698,
-0.0154198352,
-0.0373006724,
-0.006504613,
0.0041099684,
0.0307401773,
0.020682713,
-0.0092893876,
0.0104084332,
-0.0037659518,
-0.0075567868,
-0.0550317876,
0.0344244465,
0.0136814732,
0.0171203315,
-0.0172677785,
0.0137979584,
-0.0637876242,
-0.0616500229,
0.0151543356,
0.0057042036,
0.0075924769,
-0.0029370782,
0.0155149288,
0.0055427575,
-0.0118586579,
-0.0142384535,
0.0552425943,
-0.0176793318,
-0.0363320671,
0.017204361,
0.0172125567,
-0.0286585297,
-0.0555539131,
0.0636911616,
-0.0050574387,
-0.0192231331,
0.0294847656,
-0.0144001627,
-0.0330811962,
0.0541705862,
-0.0622194372,
0.0415792391,
-0.0542975664,
-0.0110937068,
0.0051991283,
-0.0100651523,
-0.0027944408,
0.0635683015,
-0.0207845159,
-0.0005242802,
-0.0105049675,
0.0023309044,
0.0092956088,
-0.0198571458,
-0.0373460576,
-0.0484216735,
-0.0248725805,
-0.0013749158,
-0.0168929286,
-0.0243060235,
-0.0089499252,
-0.0172506869,
-0.0450267382,
0.0066873645,
-0.0154008903,
0.0043224525,
0.0400590263,
-0.0048799175,
0.0291701443,
0.0125631513,
-0.0376211107,
0.0269730557,
-0.0184264891,
0.0315626375,
0.0286465753,
0.0162740424,
-0.0023225981,
-0.063758038,
-0.0279758126,
-0.0334898755,
0.0730758384,
-0.004608741,
-0.0283652078,
-0.0131794997,
0.0270130672,
-0.0466498174,
-0.0145202503,
-0.0196968541,
-0.055439394,
0.0015645684,
-0.0226005595,
-0.0223302841,
0.0856675357,
-0.0255250707,
0.0191506837,
0.0450267754,
-0.0177569296,
-0.0487572365,
-0.0031598713,
-0.0424621888,
0.0385887027,
-0.0118829254,
-0.0103638405,
-0.0119186845,
0.0911445543,
0.0423299409,
-0.0419848338,
-0.0411954448,
0.0433327928,
-0.0132819144,
-0.0304706264,
-0.0438189805,
0.0140413465,
-0.019286925,
0.0338544771,
-0.0741100609,
-0.0584589429,
0.0665356219,
-0.0164111387,
0.0190042872,
0.0131436894,
-0.0051206029,
0.0020281198,
0.0542419925,
0.0013508708,
0.0452146903,
-0.0248827152,
-0.0317421332,
-0.0614125878,
0.00210547,
0.014471692,
-0.0078950953,
0.0321506746,
0.0031174035,
-0.0117853153,
0.0228097886,
0.0130663346,
0.0010355142,
0.0043864432,
-0.0110118063,
0.0536101311,
0.0419855826,
-0.0289706495,
-0.0233918913,
-0.0121190269,
0.0523570925,
0.0749099553,
-0.0479084477,
0.004731331,
-0.0234999973,
-0.0062695611,
0.0209456719,
-0.0015994355,
0.0464230776,
-0.0423480384,
-0.0370065719,
0.0467727929,
0.0316850692,
0.0314534716,
-0.0349904299,
-0.002183377,
-0.0078172144,
-0.0474305414,
-0.0041554482,
-0.0241720546,
0.0627478808,
-0.0641279221,
-0.0288602095,
0.1025751233,
0.0310685467,
-0.0827045664,
0.0094575491,
-0.0096667986,
-0.0195129663,
0.0443611294,
0.0481580868,
-0.0423570089,
-0.0195839051,
0.0119317845,
0.0166298896,
0.038354855,
-0.0207882356,
0.0148635451,
-0.0989099741,
0.0245052986,
0.0030630985,
-0.0477455072,
-0.05307943,
0.0189680867,
0.0118458467,
0.0055315406,
-0.0302044936,
0.0041052932,
0.0384529009,
0.0027133033,
-0.0089403372,
0.0445185117,
0.0142726693,
0.0459316745,
-0.0426184796,
0.0667705163,
0.0740646273,
0.0497283749,
0.0104561187,
-0.0159133226,
0.0156621784,
0.0042527374,
0.0106672412,
-0.0026740283,
0.0630301014,
-0.0207743086,
0.0035107678,
-0.0217540916,
0.0167479813,
-0.0334272943,
-0.0206439756,
-0.0322270654,
0.0676942393,
-0.0211148523,
-0.0283322167,
0.0066469177,
0.0129064703,
-0.0108367465,
0.086861603,
0.0826293379,
-0.0236941185,
-0.0254328754,
-0.0285945944,
0.0123910466,
-0.0509205237,
-0.0405868851,
0.0089322198,
0.0426563732,
-0.0440969244,
-0.0548720844,
-0.0100594368,
0.0381429866,
0.0047071208,
0.0351103507,
-0.0374745242,
0.0205291305,
-0.0572194234,
-0.0338182189,
0.0295743365,
-0.0186273921,
0.0217040982,
-0.0559578091,
-0.0199558996,
0.0142326886,
-0.0554609485,
-0.044594191,
0.0158041697,
-0.0653943568,
-0.0433189198,
-0.0171222482,
0.0606385842,
0.0123441741,
0.01219666,
-0.0173935201,
-0.0316848233,
0.0491616689,
0.0131547004,
-0.0214638058,
0.0244416036,
0.0009162794,
-0.0207304489,
-0.0081792008,
0.0449114814,
-0.016367659,
0.005363869,
0.0667136386,
0.0530966707,
-0.0086796153,
-0.0033836176,
0.0019713689,
-0.0163039975,
0.0322468951,
0.0309208389,
-0.002779427,
-0.0630499721,
-0.0023161045,
0.0323693231,
-0.017284397,
-0.0636341274,
-0.0105304411,
0.0474560745,
0.0345763713,
-0.0072917794,
-0.0334839411,
0.0791128352,
0.0170896184,
-0.0123959314,
-0.0525027141,
-0.00102416,
-0.0039265174,
0.0004433545,
0.0457254238,
-0.0080172764,
0.0446878113,
-0.0188056286,
0.0465495847,
-0.0117034819,
0.0234316215,
0.0384645127,
-0.0032051785,
-0.0583861955,
0.0255518463,
-0.0886296704,
-0.0442136936,
-0.0198221114,
-0.0147081148,
0.0410839394,
-0.0227682274,
0.0610277168,
-0.0246729217,
-0.0225671288,
-0.0119589409,
0.033579357,
-0.0031116563,
-0.0371982604,
-0.0036514888,
-0.005890768,
0.0210790168,
-0.0582606122,
0.0606063455,
0.0078049726,
0.077256687,
-0.0360553525,
-0.0694459677,
0.0045075356,
-0.033456672,
-0.0087232338,
-0.0161908977,
-0.0422113054,
0.0153485248,
-0.0534479879,
-0.104304485,
0.0101702129,
0.0259336662,
-0.0252505988,
-0.005936387,
0.0054921708,
0.0387090147,
0.0369667187,
-0.0262275264,
-0.0157377385,
-0.0017747312,
-0.0182293281,
-0.0172728393,
-0.0150971813,
-6.6111639e-33,
-0.043530751,
-0.0228197239,
-0.012379677,
0.0265350901,
-0.026542956,
0.0095773106,
-0.0768976361,
-0.0191533342,
-0.003978238,
0.0542762354,
-0.0121300127,
0.0423432849,
-0.0077219955,
0.0088270428,
0.0205524601,
-0.0127930781,
0.0292756036,
-0.0175442509,
-0.0085608605,
0.0434128977,
0.0420012325,
0.0327076912,
0.0957049727,
-0.012905946,
0.0375701562,
0.0447900295,
0.0130677652,
0.0539207868,
-0.0772317573,
0.0255205315,
-0.0103521394,
0.0129570775,
0.012931183,
-0.0743608326,
-0.0300644021,
-0.0349515416,
-0.0456834622,
-0.050051365,
0.0246699434,
0.0081804246,
-0.0171680097,
-0.0628808811,
0.0697585866,
-0.0057171239,
0.0146855796,
-0.0475925691,
0.0281668361,
0.0044291252,
-0.0238606669,
-0.0365952253,
-0.0715986937,
-0.0167789888,
-0.0014270172,
-0.028114032,
0.0181084108,
-0.0399946086,
-0.0021995488,
-0.0496451519,
-0.111827299,
-0.0065534902,
0.0005539278,
0.0653391406,
0.045126386,
0.0326910131,
0.03697199,
0.066109851,
0.0292760916,
0.0238866825,
-0.050953526,
0.0164070837,
0.0261509251,
0.0366402715,
0.0570198521,
0.0013749535,
0.034963131,
-0.0097913425,
-0.0359469205,
-0.0276918765,
-0.0088746194,
0.0487590283,
0.0425604209,
-0.0214015059,
0.0361390077,
-0.0278202593,
-0.0461033881,
-0.0465120859,
-0.0446043871,
-0.0090058958,
0.031039102,
-0.0071213446,
-0.0281938817,
-0.0081237229,
0.0311397538,
-0.0569448322,
0.0249927416,
0.061570324,
0.0055728275,
0.0518713407,
0.0219823495,
-0.0049859867,
-0.0896019042,
0.0349026956,
-0.0228194371,
-0.0021989818,
0.0145895965,
0.0492700189,
0.0474017039,
0.0382551886,
0.0083076563,
0.0038743245,
-0.053058017,
-0.0066703688,
-0.0021126359,
0.0524399206,
0.0176186822,
-0.0039346269,
-0.0022912782,
-0.0260122009,
0.0410018079,
0.0645988211,
0.0032534236,
0.042292133,
0.0165233184,
0.0230819341,
-0.0574808791,
-0.0163486637,
-0.0777599737,
0.0156580601,
0.0247549098,
-0.0364407562,
-0.0142164547,
-0.0003068085,
2.932e-7,
0.0730884597,
0.0316123553,
0.017954994,
0.0697581768,
0.0465175286,
0.0245678462,
0.0164847188,
-0.0025582754,
0.0405688472,
-0.0298161153,
0.0105360718,
0.0465948246,
0.0384635292,
0.0267594978,
-0.0677248836,
-0.0049451613,
-0.0599820092,
0.0308686998,
0.0014393195,
-0.0451084748,
-0.0423106551,
0.0690484568,
0.0284867678,
-0.0291569047,
0.0145152891,
-0.0498482995,
0.0630912334,
0.0012630607,
0.0247625522,
0.0254556015,
0.033924073,
-0.0107585732,
-0.0217518732,
-0.0027326921,
-0.002989914,
0.0129015259,
-0.010971738,
0.0470821895,
-0.0301576164,
-0.0316864252,
-0.0438309573,
-0.0179589763,
0.0135275964,
-0.0682009012,
0.0097830463,
-0.0677992478,
-0.0144319236,
0.0136985695,
0.040257711,
-0.0145455673,
0.009982991,
-0.0262166839,
0.0246911589,
-0.0018224627,
-0.0098313643,
0.0034500579,
-0.0144897215,
-0.0711032674,
-0.0673441738,
-0.0262334943,
-0.036226023,
-0.0352683328,
-0.0719446316,
-0.0524372607,
0.0184102226,
-0.0522620752,
-0.0142800994,
2.630749929e-34,
-0.0113117751,
0.0183913428,
0.0202683415,
0.0238154754,
0.0445020311,
0.0090733785,
0.0097877514,
-0.0496859178,
0.010784314,
-0.0722486302,
-0.066841647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12108v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12108v2 | Knowledge Graph Error Detection with Contrastive Confidence Adaption | 2023-12-19T12:32:27 | 2024-01-16T10:03:57 | Xiangyu Liu, Yang Liu, Wei Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge graphs (KGs) often contain various errors. Previous works on
detecting errors in KGs mainly rely on triplet embedding from graph structure.
We conduct an empirical study and find that these works struggle to
discriminate noise from semantically-similar correct triplets. In this paper,
we propose a KG error detection model CCA to integrate both textual and graph
structural information from triplet reconstruction for better distinguishing
semantics. We design interactive contrastive learning to capture the
differences between textual and structural patterns. Furthermore, we construct
realistic datasets with semantically-similar noise and adversarial noise.
Experimental results demonstrate that CCA outperforms state-of-the-art
baselines, especially in detecting semantically-similar noise and adversarial
noise. | [
0.0361194313,
0.0390879475,
-0.0007437273,
0.0716292784,
-0.0112404199,
0.0185324457,
-0.0519536547,
0.004202114,
0.0585112646,
-0.0340074971,
0.0075550498,
-0.0017018924,
0.009784407,
0.0167725496,
0.0455105491,
-0.0314461626,
0.0422162078,
0.0027024511,
0.0239039175,
-0.0045676916,
-0.01467722,
-0.0047075064,
0.0061327019,
-0.0426630452,
-0.0070707966,
-0.0092769107,
-0.0094552143,
0.0192211345,
0.0227760021,
-0.0696386695,
0.0190072786,
0.0282205697,
0.0097880894,
0.0368151851,
0.0000017793,
-0.0256298278,
-0.0035675785,
0.0107472371,
-0.0236102287,
0.0138900112,
0.0008280974,
-0.0349436291,
0.011925444,
0.010393627,
-0.0146405343,
-0.0277932007,
0.0172508191,
0.0607113056,
0.03079932,
0.0627969131,
-0.0145007791,
-0.0022782872,
0.04161283,
-0.0173700918,
0.0055396454,
-0.0133942943,
0.0588502027,
0.0450256206,
-0.04752139,
0.0233596526,
-0.0322453901,
0.0235402212,
-0.008210334,
-0.0044924631,
0.0079665398,
0.0182234347,
-0.000319925,
0.0370573029,
-0.0135526732,
0.1006564572,
0.0020533251,
0.0069248006,
-0.0108018052,
-0.0344802737,
0.029453095,
0.0104712956,
0.0015719937,
-0.0418391675,
-0.0508160219,
0.0093241734,
-0.0175461285,
-0.0504480489,
0.0560770594,
-0.0374430455,
-0.0148929134,
0.0116654597,
0.0038707668,
-0.0443925858,
0.0105154775,
0.0451701172,
-0.0309049822,
-0.0150766848,
-0.0055107102,
-0.0043105977,
-0.0370347723,
0.0138609475,
-0.0649556369,
-0.0632259771,
-0.0066060736,
0.0051349932,
0.0100762155,
-0.0376688838,
-0.0458244532,
0.052595228,
-0.0543549992,
0.0552152358,
0.008235191,
0.0445952751,
0.0172997583,
-0.0014113806,
-0.010786619,
0.0243513193,
-0.0008063759,
0.039127782,
-0.0293618888,
0.0158809051,
-0.0328625105,
0.0446286686,
-0.0399466343,
0.0886137933,
0.0135461958,
-0.0070796572,
0.0099670403,
-0.0139836725,
-0.0092295446,
0.0249668509,
0.0314766169,
0.0276156068,
-0.0261158142,
-0.0425843447,
-0.0105056753,
0.0298469979,
0.0249476675,
0.007643763,
-0.001708865,
0.0831464007,
0.0060433052,
-0.0279215239,
-0.0574182346,
-0.0165496692,
-0.0201761276,
0.0159808453,
0.0115212342,
-0.0335617624,
0.0110382568,
-0.0189172383,
0.009170427,
-0.0425182059,
0.0046246927,
-0.0379224271,
-0.0841155425,
0.1018272415,
-0.0893444419,
-0.0287038069,
-0.039201472,
-0.0002136379,
-0.0628266633,
0.0090125343,
0.0460163653,
-0.0370930471,
0.0455306917,
0.0195908137,
-0.0264442824,
-0.021042075,
0.0660280585,
0.015126761,
-0.0022370846,
-0.0044111568,
-0.0334205776,
0.0212579239,
0.0337176695,
0.0722087845,
-0.0377413258,
-0.0323099904,
0.0354309045,
-0.0143633736,
0.0113183986,
-0.0028200459,
0.0196797084,
-0.0058210813,
-0.0131312739,
0.0499388911,
-0.0626002774,
-0.0316962861,
-0.0614450276,
0.0028275624,
0.0430248827,
-0.0258826353,
-0.0070960694,
-0.0205629524,
-0.0161501821,
-0.0040460262,
0.0171839166,
-0.0368328765,
0.0655735955,
0.010096075,
-0.0559668876,
-0.0484377034,
0.0361116789,
-0.011315031,
-0.0040978426,
-0.0222123843,
0.0327007137,
0.0688689351,
0.0453684293,
-0.0263662785,
0.0009764628,
0.0208663959,
-0.0426830687,
0.0021314302,
0.0367122628,
-0.0312776789,
-0.0039420505,
-0.0398663729,
-0.054092057,
-0.0190792754,
-0.002575415,
0.0379833542,
0.0245594252,
0.0151955392,
0.0002477173,
-0.0694737732,
0.0044695232,
0.0081516393,
-0.0086224498,
0.0164429937,
0.0052240561,
-0.0048061409,
0.0333267003,
0.0133969132,
-0.0190758072,
-0.0047142808,
0.0047553401,
0.0063512949,
-0.0314626805,
0.0002105254,
0.0171023626,
-0.1017209068,
0.0725896135,
-0.040709652,
-0.0556269661,
-0.0099489354,
-0.0798253119,
-0.0436464399,
0.0619946457,
-0.0209950972,
0.0323885418,
0.016355725,
-0.0289258547,
0.0224151146,
0.0012668124,
0.0120028788,
0.0716338158,
-0.0189544149,
0.0001046007,
0.0169498287,
0.0007589695,
0.0185585395,
-0.0000043474,
-0.0220560413,
-0.008217168,
0.0004009792,
0.0397205725,
0.0176625475,
-0.0032633615,
-0.0454229936,
0.0050334628,
-0.0275019314,
-0.0217577871,
0.0095462967,
0.0236499328,
0.0221436769,
-0.0103309611,
0.0064512957,
-0.0512781069,
-0.0409010909,
0.0785392001,
-0.0064113312,
0.0238565728,
0.0503786057,
-0.0166303609,
0.0164208449,
-0.0333195515,
-0.0071698618,
-0.0217338391,
0.0456497781,
0.0298791323,
-0.03062029,
-0.0513508543,
0.0850979388,
-0.0280573145,
0.0581163988,
-0.0261620637,
0.0033005869,
0.0105473492,
-0.0035468871,
0.005621701,
0.0380693786,
-0.0565435626,
0.0426238924,
0.0434890576,
-0.0407115035,
-0.0252061132,
0.0062326002,
-0.0286714677,
0.011790459,
-0.0455811247,
-0.0080942921,
-0.0312069152,
0.0213750042,
0.0460235588,
-0.0323362797,
-0.0510244481,
-0.012675399,
0.0132758422,
0.0079064509,
-0.0048898864,
-0.014037054,
0.035378214,
0.0196795631,
-0.0473217852,
0.0344489627,
0.0899438933,
-0.0080593703,
0.0543157347,
0.0281417277,
-0.005205899,
0.0075925002,
0.0203769598,
0.0232208613,
0.0111521324,
0.0004617845,
-0.0414888449,
-0.0552767329,
-0.0585493334,
0.0831158385,
-0.0289289076,
0.0276124775,
-0.0411942415,
0.0245526414,
0.0326843932,
-0.0146765215,
-0.0419636257,
0.01456712,
-0.0256601218,
0.0088125151,
0.0279633291,
-0.0561429523,
-0.0284486264,
-0.0400176235,
0.0046177791,
0.0432719737,
0.0207289848,
-0.0409385003,
-0.0375026613,
0.0570767187,
-0.0079994248,
0.0002704984,
0.0423034318,
-0.03412975,
0.0127420053,
0.0842027143,
-0.0078809364,
0.0103856726,
-0.0336810015,
-0.0032419749,
-0.0201132447,
0.0120821744,
-0.0400298201,
-0.023608461,
0.0363519676,
-0.036741659,
0.0025401325,
0.0713543594,
-0.0191059522,
-0.0451689549,
-0.019720193,
0.0006957811,
-0.0042634499,
0.0182918869,
-0.018163342,
-0.1076627374,
-0.0273662265,
0.0071481406,
0.0573428795,
0.0199205633,
-0.0497409478,
0.0082081733,
-0.0986749902,
0.0143145341,
0.0133640189,
-0.0362653024,
-0.0891842321,
-0.0576274917,
0.0505638756,
-0.022333812,
0.0001886949,
-0.0147687905,
0.0055672084,
0.0105449576,
0.0160665624,
-0.0019678737,
-0.0784779489,
-0.0265519191,
-0.0135187851,
0.0544611439,
-0.0132320188,
0.0025799577,
0.0112681454,
-0.0142160486,
-0.0064143222,
-0.0067930119,
-0.0374726392,
-0.0064232461,
0.0753623545,
0.0140096098,
-0.0058646817,
-0.0343193598,
-0.0186731908,
-0.0701353624,
-0.0132120866,
0.001921594,
0.0786855519,
0.0073957471,
-0.0237059016,
-0.0063741226,
-0.0064724497,
0.0241884645,
0.014882138,
0.0344066992,
0.0455370434,
-0.012848217,
-0.0387579873,
0.0295260027,
-0.0532914102,
0.0205047242,
0.068012245,
-0.0238460377,
0.0272576865,
-0.0557152182,
-0.04882605,
-0.0064780074,
-0.0069811204,
0.0012562672,
-0.0419054814,
0.0291504711,
-0.0310898926,
-0.0781247318,
-0.0343553722,
-0.0261217337,
0.0121887978,
0.0074374718,
0.0309721883,
-0.0004866068,
0.0097225569,
-0.0341300704,
-0.0193159766,
-0.0486276448,
-0.0748443827,
-0.0167165678,
0.0156098148,
0.005511608,
0.0671595261,
-0.0459742695,
0.0206720214,
0.0396904163,
0.055493921,
0.0114839254,
0.0200890861,
0.0263118129,
-0.0434918851,
-0.0021108144,
0.0271120239,
-0.0714890137,
-0.0305972379,
0.0061990591,
0.0154989958,
-0.0591043644,
-0.0407501571,
0.0136126317,
0.0629949793,
0.0286435634,
0.0446424857,
0.0327788144,
-0.0612574629,
0.0028305906,
-0.0237549283,
-0.0215533618,
-0.0390742905,
-0.0096286284,
-0.0007172461,
-0.0371390581,
-0.0015451449,
-0.0251946431,
0.0024067746,
0.028325798,
-0.0271793995,
-0.0373802483,
0.0514993519,
0.028097216,
0.0409696922,
-0.0133476323,
-0.0168445595,
0.0363350026,
0.0482860096,
0.0263296235,
-0.0008504022,
0.0029920789,
0.0285210237,
-0.0304291938,
0.0063452637,
-0.042039156,
-0.0486521199,
-0.005736107,
-0.0273447763,
-0.0034415943,
0.0639675483,
0.0236727707,
0.0759573057,
-0.0396251567,
-0.0084985811,
-0.0134305805,
0.0268295463,
-0.0173768755,
-0.0029317534,
0.0589082055,
0.0113545097,
0.0181834623,
0.0219907183,
0.0833121315,
-0.00557571,
0.0794709921,
-0.0110704741,
-0.0861031339,
-0.0336031765,
-0.0039693508,
0.0385209247,
0.0218802188,
0.015130287,
0.0168716181,
-0.0182315838,
-0.0938536748,
0.0213639606,
0.0428907983,
0.0091354093,
0.0366155393,
-0.017836662,
0.0356457531,
0.0664210096,
-0.0134454137,
-0.0152255073,
0.0246122535,
-0.0256622285,
-0.0387168899,
0.0055561843,
-5.843296827e-33,
-0.0398622528,
-0.0801262707,
-0.021712888,
-0.0243699923,
-0.0310788043,
0.0111104641,
-0.0462317728,
-0.002046756,
-0.0248941872,
0.070900172,
0.0179221537,
0.0585252903,
-0.008450035,
0.0119021134,
-0.0014135151,
-0.028193254,
0.0456912443,
-0.0045813089,
0.0235131625,
0.0130271241,
0.059109427,
-0.0126490695,
0.0772898346,
-0.121611461,
0.0510233678,
0.022684196,
-0.0003503175,
0.0193358269,
0.0038759951,
0.0231816731,
0.0038876215,
0.0748401806,
0.0079015782,
0.0540813692,
-0.007229215,
-0.0791315138,
-0.0814586878,
-0.0774298161,
0.0059467498,
0.0317122601,
-0.057834547,
-0.0015619562,
0.0459954888,
-0.0255336035,
0.0494946688,
-0.0734876245,
0.042307239,
-0.0187074374,
-0.0361328796,
-0.0138921188,
-0.0142593887,
0.0508165136,
-0.0151265571,
0.0323543549,
-0.0012057879,
0.0046791043,
0.0565178581,
-0.0233750027,
-0.1053293571,
0.0082930392,
-0.0051225284,
-0.0216274802,
-0.0111658117,
-0.0008067523,
-0.0347268917,
0.0381431952,
-0.0173298325,
-0.0038748647,
0.0058904444,
-0.0122254873,
-0.0287724193,
0.0302355196,
0.0423084721,
0.0840125382,
-0.0054850942,
-0.0115320776,
-0.0941523165,
-0.0268350262,
-0.0272583924,
0.0159338117,
-0.0304772723,
0.0112337749,
-0.0515915379,
-0.0229428001,
-0.0094803553,
-0.0623307526,
-0.0267528351,
-0.0240801219,
-0.0083538601,
-0.0106890714,
0.013178831,
-0.0005714428,
-0.0482836738,
-0.0421000309,
-0.0003440767,
0.0386365764,
-0.0212129112,
0.0030237585,
-0.0243773665,
0.0243856404,
-0.0173154883,
-0.0445013978,
0.0095075713,
-0.0049734316,
0.0161031783,
0.0484836623,
0.0460980907,
0.0126810418,
-0.0665933415,
0.0051411274,
-0.0081179375,
-0.0141101899,
0.0038689906,
-0.0277214274,
0.0389482826,
0.0049528102,
0.0104173636,
0.0131825479,
0.0415212549,
0.0337651931,
0.0086322436,
0.0320172533,
-0.0165062193,
0.0232197754,
-0.0042826054,
-0.0355365276,
-0.0335222296,
-0.0216113161,
0.0214811638,
-0.043687772,
0.010430132,
-0.0141478311,
2.689e-7,
0.0259241778,
0.0217797793,
0.0278488453,
0.0482740514,
0.0434365608,
0.0437761135,
-0.0073297704,
0.0196306836,
-0.0237883087,
-0.0136340857,
0.0341715962,
0.0134009477,
0.0004037953,
0.0803038403,
0.0049895793,
0.0027249111,
-0.0443177521,
-0.0472665243,
0.0051931092,
0.0260424428,
0.1029511616,
0.0304043945,
0.0596367456,
0.0002221114,
0.0060041747,
-0.0612990595,
0.0567194261,
0.0271064285,
0.0135742147,
-0.0007519458,
0.062143933,
0.0154177621,
0.0048714075,
0.0923387334,
-0.0051344414,
-0.0205540843,
0.0058203475,
-0.0133611253,
0.0089968722,
0.0213753227,
-0.01500923,
0.0182762798,
0.0306824073,
-0.0204248521,
0.0394127704,
-0.0378344692,
-0.0188073386,
0.0163216218,
-0.0390773192,
-0.0457935706,
0.0287159421,
0.0282074977,
-0.0279288217,
-0.0279547367,
0.0118729742,
0.0579000376,
-0.0144842276,
-0.0444102474,
0.0715576336,
0.0162360556,
-0.0029392564,
-0.0600012243,
0.0500362031,
-0.0269115344,
0.044211708,
-0.0138395298,
0.0438983962,
2.077226169e-34,
0.0729610771,
-0.0095677022,
0.0000371902,
-0.0397166274,
0.0195551198,
-0.0230458323,
0.0124003636,
-0.0395245478,
0.0507698543,
-0.0800653994,
-0.0002441716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12037v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12037v2 | Founder-GPT: Self-play to evaluate the Founder-Idea fit | 2023-12-19T10:46:13 | 2023-12-20T17:42:18 | Sichao Xiong, Yigit Ihlamur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE | This research introduces an innovative evaluation method for the
"founder-idea" fit in early-stage startups, utilizing advanced large language
model techniques to assess founders' profiles against their startup ideas to
enhance decision-making. Embeddings, self-play, tree-of-thought, and
critique-based refinement techniques show early promising results that each
idea's success patterns are unique and they should be evaluated based on the
context of the founder's background. | [
0.0557144657,
0.0535077229,
-0.0307365172,
0.0282806233,
-0.026239723,
-0.0450765714,
-0.0430659465,
-0.013065761,
-0.0111368876,
-0.0476286784,
0.0058570593,
-0.0007513369,
0.0001311453,
0.1050924584,
-0.0033465002,
0.0391977169,
-0.0212492514,
0.0381229855,
0.0473895408,
0.0046710935,
0.0189520773,
0.02779199,
0.0091308113,
0.0296301227,
0.0447649471,
-0.0226393212,
0.0186141543,
0.0126581341,
0.0119344704,
-0.0915552527,
-0.0400096849,
0.0387550183,
0.0156548582,
0.0380064137,
0.0000018827,
-0.0924089998,
-0.0494444817,
-0.0260664448,
0.0486005433,
0.0170715302,
0.0237268396,
0.0682344362,
-0.0136490893,
0.0308027212,
-0.0419934988,
-0.0132947108,
-0.0180587154,
0.0587816276,
0.0375841931,
0.0163365193,
-0.0163169987,
-0.0865700617,
0.0008416823,
-0.0230361186,
0.0039108428,
0.0132463425,
0.010023538,
0.035973262,
-0.0117774187,
-0.0232243706,
-0.0351883546,
-0.0148102017,
-0.0309971664,
-0.0143724838,
0.054335054,
0.0141880112,
0.0159354173,
-0.018959146,
-0.0233096275,
0.0178461038,
0.0441803224,
0.0177499726,
-0.0075021861,
-0.0213984847,
0.0375426225,
-0.0046660476,
0.0021724084,
0.0087202275,
0.0064173052,
0.0465067253,
0.0405881628,
0.0256374571,
-0.0049610501,
-0.0222105067,
0.0017044491,
0.0672141835,
-0.0180789456,
-0.0030554424,
-0.0128580043,
-0.0018615595,
0.0223120973,
-0.025125891,
0.0149208065,
-0.0229053218,
0.0280797407,
-0.0102760429,
0.007497503,
0.0777390599,
-0.0098552229,
-0.0129581606,
-0.002892518,
0.0401388668,
0.0652324483,
0.0527357049,
-0.0558251701,
0.0502987616,
0.0039382293,
-0.0768110752,
-0.0288968235,
0.0312123708,
-0.0732830688,
0.0073015499,
-0.0740761757,
0.0424611606,
0.0345768034,
-0.0472075045,
-0.0858159363,
0.048726771,
0.0228455402,
0.0039716228,
-0.0104972711,
0.002592959,
0.070742473,
-0.0070663495,
-0.0468115509,
-0.0103192963,
-0.0038260194,
-0.0098958751,
-0.0268912241,
-0.0132457661,
0.0224387236,
0.0129720187,
-0.0043751108,
0.0137617961,
-0.0016979204,
-0.0301654804,
0.036231976,
-0.0431585833,
-0.0271827187,
-0.0204797853,
0.0047789854,
-0.0351794586,
-0.048445411,
-0.0535336547,
-0.0577047989,
-0.0027496419,
0.0012573856,
-0.046370022,
0.014734949,
-0.01235341,
-0.0062654279,
0.0021013294,
-0.0103665972,
0.0152133498,
0.0006586783,
0.012056523,
0.035131596,
0.0422774404,
0.0305587947,
-0.0168804172,
0.0171254501,
-0.0256778877,
-0.0113182859,
0.0411443971,
-0.0191379581,
-0.0297949258,
-0.0016811459,
0.0347969532,
-0.0447610766,
0.0560619943,
-0.0208224524,
-0.0196150169,
-0.0230751969,
0.105929777,
0.0472523272,
0.0838107318,
0.0719985142,
0.0464307554,
0.0462946892,
0.021632487,
-0.0224859249,
-0.0668806732,
0.0668782741,
-0.0480115637,
-0.0083814776,
-0.003779867,
0.0225545652,
0.0362212211,
0.013449735,
-0.0032625203,
0.0087049957,
0.0281855501,
-0.0234654546,
-0.038263876,
-0.0010432733,
-0.0191060007,
-0.028940089,
-0.0231457446,
-0.0475392528,
-0.0115173552,
-0.0213608537,
-0.0003683593,
0.0133372983,
0.0440420546,
0.0584330074,
-0.0206638295,
0.0103792921,
-0.0276393369,
-0.083690539,
-0.0247072503,
0.0624903888,
0.0290539358,
-0.0869311243,
-0.0007820905,
-0.0077983611,
0.0140377665,
0.0145733422,
-0.0251034237,
-0.0316752978,
0.0471286438,
-0.0019149679,
0.0238365494,
0.0522204526,
0.0106415236,
-0.0369375981,
-0.0050359755,
-0.0288374927,
-0.0266850144,
0.0265141539,
0.0693497732,
-0.0051546195,
0.0289491881,
0.017991716,
0.0046959566,
-0.0428827554,
0.0384212583,
-0.0052243066,
0.0000865039,
0.0111893872,
-0.0283683985,
-0.0119542209,
-0.0340899006,
0.0359792411,
-0.0087696584,
0.0459606014,
-0.0156131508,
0.031393867,
-0.0074106497,
-0.0127390185,
-0.0428595021,
0.0159561802,
-0.0107772341,
0.0374624655,
0.0044076405,
0.0624504723,
-0.0348198712,
-0.0246817619,
0.0243152324,
-0.0059447545,
-0.0556551665,
0.0152592538,
-0.0098804431,
0.0320571475,
0.0426923372,
0.0000035899,
-0.049898725,
-0.0196677186,
-0.1198604479,
-0.0052273353,
0.0195863005,
-0.0056466991,
0.0291919541,
0.0174000598,
-0.0191460233,
0.0369346365,
-0.0023897556,
0.0304938089,
0.0536487289,
-0.005875919,
0.0338191912,
-0.0017028189,
-0.077881813,
0.0077030277,
0.0180243962,
-0.0512008108,
0.0273714475,
0.0636278689,
-0.0145288045,
-0.060958501,
0.0044955481,
-0.0325846486,
-0.0302804895,
-0.0036839491,
-0.0067865602,
0.0228046291,
-0.0315666497,
0.0435295701,
-0.0211834852,
0.0022418988,
0.0625258461,
-0.0022242314,
-0.0766804889,
0.0139119718,
-0.0038297896,
0.0127478018,
0.0529823378,
-0.0014397262,
-0.0016856947,
-0.0051505365,
0.0488468036,
-0.0067029055,
-0.0055706068,
-0.0575217158,
0.085192807,
-0.0370879993,
0.0419291183,
-0.0318350829,
-0.0426368304,
-0.0152878659,
0.113262929,
0.0238146093,
-0.0066132033,
0.0537282079,
-0.0169358328,
-0.0012183504,
0.0068339859,
-0.0329744741,
-0.0874021053,
0.0425206982,
-0.0367554575,
-0.004228136,
0.0035904774,
-0.0095092291,
-0.0271867402,
-0.0343983583,
0.0523316152,
-0.0411666967,
0.032539051,
0.0030695011,
-0.0107579473,
0.0224701632,
0.017944254,
-0.0379703827,
-0.0742714629,
-0.0164418686,
0.0193764959,
0.0617405809,
0.018691361,
-0.080813244,
0.0226879474,
-0.0089392439,
0.0163836721,
0.0120883565,
-0.0258507002,
0.0038450859,
0.0174168851,
0.0113160443,
-0.0218299273,
0.0598046333,
0.0336856768,
0.0628174394,
-0.0454768613,
-0.0206261147,
-0.0088617504,
-0.0254448913,
-0.0048818192,
-0.0178405233,
-0.0075133964,
-0.0199753884,
0.0235833526,
0.0116396127,
0.0056894417,
-0.0231852513,
0.0797800422,
0.0231377929,
0.0271453001,
0.0234792773,
-0.0000713486,
0.0046491344,
0.0669225082,
0.0339712352,
-0.0399358682,
0.0280056018,
-0.0590081625,
0.0006221829,
0.0055864481,
-0.0503940023,
-0.0489779115,
-0.102931343,
0.0429036431,
0.0011800491,
-0.0387034267,
-0.0313899405,
0.003284232,
-0.0226737857,
-0.0316735394,
-0.0587036051,
0.0030125084,
-0.0516060628,
0.0084033441,
-0.0275019482,
-0.0892605335,
-0.0293120276,
0.0533511117,
-0.0330663584,
-0.0104720267,
0.0484343916,
0.0115632499,
-0.0076526408,
0.0555682071,
-0.0413458198,
-0.0374944471,
-0.0204072371,
0.0313610658,
-0.0088073052,
-0.0192446373,
0.0184809361,
0.0114542339,
0.0124368034,
-0.0707702041,
0.0216701422,
0.0297460258,
0.078785345,
0.0069514778,
0.0048424783,
0.0171198882,
0.0175968166,
0.0022676,
0.0483103171,
-0.0069091031,
-0.0710214749,
0.027152352,
-0.008776186,
0.0092947856,
0.030356098,
-0.0924523175,
-0.0297460575,
0.0466088131,
0.0419584699,
-0.0750484467,
-0.0572798327,
-0.0100194653,
0.0197189264,
0.0097428011,
0.058690697,
-0.0478478596,
0.0188248791,
0.0001962816,
0.0031573363,
0.010504107,
-0.0161475986,
-0.050851658,
0.0516467728,
0.0061394316,
-0.0510749929,
-0.0357756354,
0.0110802613,
-0.0354737788,
-0.0088498695,
0.0092210965,
-0.0291785356,
0.0303144734,
-0.0195629895,
-0.0353864767,
0.0088396575,
0.0571671128,
-0.0375565588,
-0.0003910984,
0.0090137403,
0.0217607636,
0.0358829424,
0.0018151432,
0.0088971807,
-0.014732657,
0.0098754801,
0.023987975,
0.036064215,
0.0331303589,
-0.0310460348,
0.033947859,
0.0293025207,
0.0565042198,
-0.026487574,
0.0075283665,
-0.0242217071,
-0.0316328146,
-0.0225950014,
-0.0445728414,
-0.0688049197,
0.0037659996,
0.0476021729,
-0.0162497666,
0.008159453,
-0.0132500045,
-0.0538525805,
-0.0098900441,
-0.0365754813,
0.0385914445,
0.030746216,
0.0159820002,
0.0089362953,
-0.0257174037,
0.0011014072,
-0.0069151446,
-0.0266234316,
-0.021568425,
-0.0192546919,
0.0459997244,
0.0143153416,
0.0058702496,
-0.0154961366,
0.0078020557,
-0.0166875441,
-0.0612739511,
-0.0068971799,
-0.0272724405,
0.009277517,
0.0023106134,
0.0435199589,
-0.0472090133,
0.0257229675,
-0.0066797449,
0.0513596311,
-0.024850022,
-0.0460292287,
0.0124768913,
0.0422416888,
-0.015946079,
0.0056006801,
0.0303485543,
0.0500764772,
-0.0077980133,
-0.0440133587,
-0.0320455134,
-0.0466703698,
-0.0023804912,
0.0070165293,
0.0188102406,
-0.0197472107,
0.0282393582,
-0.1196927205,
0.0126631912,
-0.0211032853,
-0.0055085127,
0.0024462885,
0.045777943,
-0.0031252042,
0.063221857,
-0.0269722305,
-0.0098517509,
-0.0574208796,
-0.0429740362,
-0.0772423595,
-0.0407334901,
-0.0219460707,
-5.668955954e-33,
0.0059951884,
-0.0358764455,
0.0708832517,
-0.0250668507,
-0.0017343396,
0.0160436183,
-0.0096992599,
0.0555538759,
0.0087850094,
-0.0082887057,
-0.0109842634,
-0.0067878449,
-0.0136141097,
-0.0186231751,
0.0195706021,
0.0414911173,
0.0326501653,
-0.0213055685,
-0.0445416309,
0.0026464062,
-0.0433429331,
0.0176428426,
0.0145695917,
-0.019649405,
-0.0007740075,
0.0001981201,
-0.0444089547,
-0.0005491154,
0.0128474375,
0.0116712442,
-0.0236348715,
-0.0113829188,
0.0239872616,
-0.0847844481,
-0.0054076314,
-0.0483210906,
0.0270446893,
0.0011706495,
0.0114511764,
-0.0154660931,
0.0024734274,
0.0813236386,
0.0018300454,
-0.0182859059,
0.0001888762,
-0.0041899458,
0.0245339479,
-0.0137702702,
0.0275333244,
0.0322167836,
-0.0545392297,
0.0256831963,
-0.0342619605,
0.0362411067,
0.0581493899,
-0.0272726361,
-0.0100512374,
0.0177603401,
0.0195991471,
0.008495356,
-0.0129351513,
0.0098708021,
-0.0004949162,
-0.0070803477,
0.0001998857,
0.0598054342,
-0.0078171641,
0.0624060705,
-0.0229288805,
-0.0122839361,
-0.0147584621,
0.0665898621,
0.0276655778,
0.0321757086,
-0.0047626477,
0.0585775524,
-0.0545359254,
-0.0151957506,
0.0321478508,
-0.049281083,
0.0369391069,
0.0175977778,
-0.0174536556,
-0.0236146711,
0.0025274125,
-0.0686070621,
-0.0163837317,
-0.0024955657,
-0.0054993117,
-0.0152256051,
-0.0165442973,
0.041308336,
0.0471362062,
-0.0557057373,
-0.0494282916,
0.0246561095,
-0.0409398638,
0.0192127395,
-0.0165053234,
0.0096706143,
-0.050801795,
-0.0127348239,
0.0172043834,
0.0348338224,
0.0307780486,
-0.0059037646,
-0.0182557609,
-0.033388,
-0.0404654033,
-0.0351904891,
0.0080078868,
-0.0054050605,
-0.0046800929,
-0.0602574572,
0.0096241711,
0.0400198177,
0.024283208,
0.0519091673,
0.1050058454,
-0.0353447013,
-0.0066244286,
-0.0013912946,
-0.0165209081,
0.0002672076,
-0.0091761984,
-0.0078115445,
0.0272354744,
0.0430832505,
0.0806279331,
-0.0191495381,
-0.0245187227,
0.0062338337,
2.83e-7,
0.0455078892,
0.0786248744,
-0.0352912024,
-0.0565047525,
0.0521515608,
0.0330955796,
0.013668525,
-0.0157443229,
0.010038103,
-0.0205887258,
0.0496588387,
0.0233468078,
-0.0170536377,
0.0152890002,
-0.0465987884,
-0.0460771807,
-0.0780050457,
0.0311667528,
-0.0588592328,
0.0006665599,
0.0801649541,
0.0210448839,
0.0707828477,
0.0189839248,
-0.0306894667,
-0.020025719,
0.0311013889,
-0.0328947194,
0.0194052812,
0.0496694744,
-0.0417615771,
-0.0286463406,
-0.0588071235,
0.0200412516,
0.0239983089,
0.0675919205,
0.0286181737,
-0.0352525897,
0.0291131157,
0.1009811386,
0.0140642487,
-0.0023865206,
-0.0277985781,
-0.0629480258,
0.0102746449,
-0.0606825836,
-0.062432535,
0.0123847835,
-0.0306498595,
-0.0465304665,
0.0607498288,
0.0108343307,
0.0246249624,
0.008710173,
-0.0124799553,
-0.0155815976,
0.0069289361,
-0.0385820381,
0.0102211302,
0.0060642269,
-0.0599805042,
-0.0108450055,
-0.0075641326,
-0.0046325708,
0.0684821978,
0.0217823945,
0.0955882445,
2.441313963e-34,
-0.0144379027,
-0.0269932523,
-0.0058380878,
-0.0197192524,
0.0690487325,
-0.0130701791,
0.0052374615,
0.0232738275,
0.0042903372,
-0.0505617186,
-0.0314257778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12021v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12021v3 | Synergistic Anchored Contrastive Pre-training for Few-Shot Relation Extraction | 2023-12-19T10:16:24 | 2024-03-11T14:42:28 | Da Luo, Yanglei Gan, Rui Hou, Run Lin, Qiao Liu, Yuxiang Cai, Wannian Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Few-shot Relation Extraction (FSRE) aims to extract relational facts from a
sparse set of labeled corpora. Recent studies have shown promising results in
FSRE by employing Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) within the framework of
supervised contrastive learning, which considers both instances and label
facts. However, how to effectively harness massive instance-label pairs to
encompass the learned representation with semantic richness in this learning
paradigm is not fully explored. To address this gap, we introduce a novel
synergistic anchored contrastive pre-training framework. This framework is
motivated by the insight that the diverse viewpoints conveyed through
instance-label pairs capture incomplete yet complementary intrinsic textual
semantics. Specifically, our framework involves a symmetrical contrastive
objective that encompasses both sentence-anchored and label-anchored
contrastive losses. By combining these two losses, the model establishes a
robust and uniform representation space. This space effectively captures the
reciprocal alignment of feature distributions among instances and relational
facts, simultaneously enhancing the maximization of mutual information across
diverse perspectives within the same relation. Experimental results demonstrate
that our framework achieves significant performance enhancements compared to
baseline models in downstream FSRE tasks. Furthermore, our approach exhibits
superior adaptability to handle the challenges of domain shift and zero-shot
relation extraction. Our code is available online at
https://github.com/AONE-NLP/FSRE-SaCon. | [
0.0170590095,
0.0637488067,
0.026396865,
0.0763978735,
-0.0237335656,
0.0217527952,
0.0084369751,
-0.0161674898,
-0.0252410527,
-0.0773949549,
-0.0594750345,
-0.0512071364,
-0.0316222534,
0.0058016009,
-0.0059435028,
-0.0568488017,
0.0274537764,
0.0406385995,
0.0011060103,
0.0267207827,
0.0116067342,
0.0189694241,
-0.0169462953,
-0.0276289005,
-0.0229423791,
-0.0241440292,
0.0359942839,
0.0010744054,
0.0435949601,
-0.0591169521,
0.0226114262,
0.0414226688,
0.0115467357,
-0.0175590161,
0.0000019778,
-0.063322559,
-0.0153264962,
0.0001495658,
-0.024614187,
-0.0016743864,
0.0395169593,
-0.0263590142,
0.0302704163,
-0.0190024413,
-0.05185619,
-0.116284214,
0.0257521011,
0.0777933523,
0.007753382,
0.0699944496,
-0.0377903618,
-0.0689940453,
0.0043070763,
-0.0373014249,
0.0028342602,
-0.0323084965,
0.0243162252,
-0.0359950922,
-0.0327149145,
0.0284495819,
-0.0135531463,
0.0146728652,
0.0229102988,
0.0149818761,
0.0240833592,
0.0740698799,
-0.0467298813,
-0.0141067365,
-0.0121213077,
0.0960735008,
0.0302608423,
0.018474631,
-0.0084569277,
-0.01267666,
-0.0229154304,
-0.0184046663,
-0.0012425174,
0.0039531933,
-0.0030494537,
0.0390551612,
0.0109342001,
0.0527281836,
0.0197838359,
0.0074477959,
-0.0233173519,
-0.0254637878,
0.0117644882,
-0.0168639161,
0.0140745463,
0.0490293019,
-0.0344228707,
-0.0136464378,
-0.0142614376,
0.0136961024,
0.019083729,
0.0353470594,
-0.0394702815,
-0.0219250768,
-0.0115387077,
-0.0325293243,
0.0264177565,
0.0152909057,
-0.0675375015,
0.0743496269,
-0.0324108414,
-0.007160855,
-0.0034578503,
-0.0242910217,
-0.0078579513,
-0.0150152221,
-0.0378631651,
0.0099501191,
-0.0172420666,
0.0692189708,
-0.0384761877,
-0.0010938663,
-0.0100566354,
0.0028794685,
0.0083394153,
0.0091477828,
-0.0083510801,
0.0185036622,
-0.0174442846,
-0.0194174778,
-0.0106095467,
0.0455075204,
-0.0322361402,
0.0166070852,
-0.0187868439,
-0.0303282719,
-0.0371804163,
0.0106843524,
0.032338988,
-0.0563468039,
0.0138372099,
0.0790236294,
0.0087892944,
-0.0878112242,
-0.037584763,
0.0099194329,
-0.0130341882,
-0.0564742535,
-0.0103428625,
-0.0295061525,
0.0636290237,
0.0180935096,
-0.0210454036,
-0.0511258654,
0.0299521927,
-0.0067128646,
-0.0614604242,
0.0813323259,
-0.0160293225,
-0.038670931,
-0.030539006,
0.013571213,
0.0208340511,
0.0834966525,
0.0136373835,
-0.0178870931,
0.0320729353,
0.0255375002,
-0.0210314915,
0.0013535753,
0.0230844896,
-0.0158891473,
-0.0303330123,
0.0183904376,
0.0298628919,
-0.014744129,
0.0433764234,
0.0286685079,
-0.0350463986,
-0.0214625616,
0.0313146897,
0.0104296543,
0.0030564973,
0.0322952308,
0.0575629398,
-0.0010186752,
-0.0063467105,
0.0237105414,
-0.0655842423,
0.0203179419,
-0.0080883373,
0.0153643861,
0.0079646558,
0.0407516137,
-0.0337450728,
0.0073654489,
0.015682511,
-0.03555803,
-0.0381476507,
0.0101367114,
0.0800209716,
0.0372028723,
-0.0470257178,
0.0754089057,
0.0752499029,
-0.0034075265,
-0.019527575,
0.0404058844,
-0.0356909782,
0.0115547925,
0.0096909413,
-0.0621406287,
-0.0614672005,
0.0009045027,
0.0066259666,
0.0490997173,
0.027656354,
0.0045375684,
0.0894493535,
-0.0274270158,
-0.0481174812,
-0.0312779583,
0.0068732104,
0.0066541787,
0.024999667,
0.0201062821,
0.0285362769,
0.0047365217,
0.017788969,
0.034630619,
-0.0317814536,
-0.047541175,
0.0290939156,
0.0185651481,
0.012787303,
0.019549096,
-0.0335946977,
-0.0211341828,
0.030894706,
-0.0394495688,
0.0408404805,
0.0060464186,
-0.0780689716,
-0.101715669,
0.0295848139,
-0.0027561917,
-0.0204168335,
-0.0171199646,
-0.0592413396,
-0.0093391873,
-0.0137960427,
0.0540104657,
0.0485399067,
-0.0149098374,
-0.0102328602,
0.0415308736,
0.0145737762,
-0.0120650986,
0.0849906877,
0.0187565964,
-0.0067660469,
-0.0135108661,
-0.029207116,
0.0033103069,
0.0046604956,
-0.0041200165,
-0.0358466767,
-0.007488816,
-0.0181264747,
0.015185195,
0.0219823513,
-0.0460847281,
0.0075165387,
-0.0376822352,
0.0243342072,
0.0054116342,
0.0371078476,
0.0315733664,
0.008602581,
-0.0093816267,
-0.018504506,
0.0002255027,
0.0097995652,
-0.0370678268,
0.0016613824,
0.0587192625,
0.0449422151,
0.0124714412,
-0.0469817854,
0.0101988353,
-0.0113668125,
0.0605526865,
-0.0045226724,
0.0103537571,
-0.0022741063,
0.0905745327,
-0.0063232239,
0.0370569602,
0.0027605824,
-0.0039749094,
-0.0354101099,
-0.0156902969,
-0.0102967927,
0.0211568121,
-0.0213807374,
0.0526089706,
0.0186035298,
-0.0140338643,
-0.015190836,
0.028196061,
-0.0417372733,
0.0414836966,
-0.0057152971,
0.0237432662,
-0.0222942587,
0.0691478178,
-0.0168722626,
0.0146664763,
-0.0133230472,
0.0030879579,
0.0206885803,
-0.0112377116,
-0.0103454767,
0.0416902862,
0.0113303363,
-0.0065738978,
-0.0732004717,
0.0168399103,
0.0790869519,
-0.0214693379,
-0.0145253232,
-0.0245155878,
-0.0011625658,
-0.0428047851,
0.0693490505,
0.0100973658,
-0.0091569778,
0.0384969674,
-0.0051160757,
-0.0488220118,
-0.0429280438,
0.0030696294,
0.0213135798,
0.0195973963,
-0.0235843435,
0.005105319,
-0.0196152478,
-0.0420530215,
-0.038082391,
-0.0876074657,
-0.0182595719,
0.0071083857,
-0.0298270546,
0.0223335251,
-0.0067211962,
0.0004934247,
0.0250852611,
0.030597752,
0.0061830706,
-0.0192876048,
-0.0183841251,
0.0809161738,
0.0608031191,
-0.0361128338,
-0.0028384617,
0.0120449346,
0.0391958617,
0.0641117394,
0.0060824798,
-0.0013344138,
-0.005779712,
0.0024169181,
-0.0032322998,
-0.0113630956,
-0.0110704852,
-0.0216573644,
0.0412834994,
-0.0426653214,
-0.0406742916,
0.1062763557,
0.0150886355,
-0.0358148627,
-0.0132939154,
0.0370203517,
0.0028955704,
0.0308591984,
0.0141041456,
-0.0719742477,
-0.0465667173,
-0.0427859277,
-0.0282487981,
0.0221950356,
-0.0389469825,
-0.0206687041,
-0.1160711199,
-0.0201143213,
-0.0101729464,
-0.0407443009,
0.0009449754,
-0.0271311719,
0.0229492411,
-0.0257087033,
-0.0022307215,
-0.0199571569,
-0.0368482992,
0.0083179306,
-0.0135588143,
0.0433844887,
-0.0476642661,
0.0275535826,
-0.0472752973,
0.0176275987,
0.0261777267,
0.010867523,
-0.0074694082,
0.0384646021,
0.0038282371,
-0.061508093,
-0.0200439394,
-0.0223945659,
0.0840338171,
-0.0626728907,
-0.0253270082,
0.0042402348,
-0.006433513,
-0.0531314202,
-0.0332481712,
-0.0028421059,
0.0365633778,
0.0156730097,
0.0018218333,
0.0006696269,
-0.0061967555,
0.0037798779,
0.0715733543,
0.0245404672,
-0.0123183196,
-0.0048182989,
0.015188776,
-0.0048644179,
-0.0654248521,
-0.0136205703,
-0.0066532288,
-0.0214514434,
0.0107645094,
-0.044713527,
-0.0773372799,
0.0321602374,
0.0253971461,
-0.033087492,
-0.0180910211,
-0.01767179,
0.0015472432,
-0.0532202534,
0.0203868244,
-0.0201551784,
-0.0317638703,
-0.0089481706,
-0.0016915512,
0.0631726533,
-0.0368621871,
-0.0249420218,
-0.0402216278,
-0.035273809,
-0.0368162878,
-0.0198170878,
0.0495041385,
0.0013978365,
0.0588894896,
-0.0084629385,
0.0124910297,
0.0458840281,
0.1011960655,
-0.0541986525,
-0.0118169449,
0.0345897041,
-0.0334719904,
0.0148752956,
0.0247356556,
-0.0346815623,
0.0514153168,
0.0520597994,
0.0350125507,
-0.0227694791,
-0.0312604308,
0.0224280246,
-0.0474156104,
0.1233310252,
-0.0125289224,
0.0082849469,
-0.0219693296,
0.016556127,
-0.0588004775,
-0.0082600275,
-0.0483450741,
0.0035447418,
-0.0063729906,
0.0132092088,
-0.0253966507,
0.0165934227,
-0.0167352241,
0.0589564964,
0.0019891961,
-0.018333748,
0.0395327583,
-0.0146412477,
0.0049386267,
0.0102966307,
-0.0145568112,
0.0098651592,
0.0135676777,
0.0100410655,
-0.0459871106,
0.0420514941,
0.0221414194,
-0.016340185,
-0.0126849459,
0.0126916636,
-0.0166594256,
0.0561404079,
-0.0404089615,
-0.006685365,
0.0714828968,
-0.0749956593,
0.0199062526,
-0.0148706287,
0.0043973569,
-0.0064443517,
0.0329945125,
-0.0232167412,
0.0079119354,
0.0041603483,
0.0329429135,
-0.0232458506,
0.0450647213,
0.086825788,
-0.021673033,
0.0564795658,
0.0479309596,
0.0145031475,
-0.0279697925,
0.0053049475,
0.0169256143,
0.0195654351,
-0.0122950589,
0.0340461135,
-0.0474805012,
-0.0554479957,
0.0190857667,
-0.0494060032,
-0.0389332063,
0.0296285488,
0.0377092697,
0.0176661443,
0.0248631351,
-0.0135935321,
-0.0051102247,
0.0091165313,
0.0119045405,
-0.0062878607,
-0.0137699647,
-6.911464503e-33,
-0.0518398173,
-0.0167718697,
0.0128861964,
-0.0122524416,
-0.0133629981,
0.0341489129,
-0.0426556878,
-0.0217038114,
-0.0385716707,
0.0337863714,
0.0062263925,
0.0037382627,
0.005638639,
0.0460396931,
-0.0205497444,
-0.0162590519,
0.0186086204,
0.0104950294,
0.021487711,
0.002828459,
0.0215585604,
0.0625706688,
0.0900032967,
-0.0808198303,
-0.0242261812,
0.0112888655,
0.0386726968,
0.0429438762,
0.076386407,
0.0307550337,
-0.0442196131,
0.0272207949,
0.0320779607,
-0.0515042022,
0.0181486718,
-0.0125350105,
-0.1164677069,
-0.046171695,
0.0049466477,
-0.0264860373,
-0.0017406687,
-0.0082446029,
0.0093255732,
-0.0013221002,
0.0601408333,
-0.0665686205,
0.024418721,
-0.0249330532,
0.0063309358,
-0.0470635742,
-0.073638998,
0.0200646129,
0.0290474277,
-0.0159452837,
0.0287974514,
0.0060962755,
0.0250636078,
0.0437087007,
-0.0447699353,
-0.0421935469,
-0.023627175,
0.0262351297,
0.0040577031,
0.0115969134,
-0.0101129496,
0.0627832785,
0.0050135041,
-0.0063322186,
-0.014038302,
-0.0004029655,
-0.0083115315,
0.0334054381,
-0.0301841293,
0.0663843155,
0.0407979675,
0.0161435101,
-0.1000106856,
-0.003748883,
-0.017237518,
0.0340119042,
-0.0323259309,
0.0118349092,
-0.0171586741,
-0.0152855301,
0.0181723014,
-0.0275325216,
-0.0274270587,
-0.0314913839,
-0.0019750034,
0.0066543412,
-0.0164228305,
0.0591071807,
0.0235762987,
-0.0349317305,
-0.027758617,
0.0112077864,
-0.0093762856,
0.0199386477,
-0.0053658867,
-0.0005404179,
-0.0668689683,
-0.0385825001,
0.0074712387,
0.0066854423,
0.0081732776,
0.0219797213,
0.0767105892,
-0.0245400891,
-0.0537173562,
-0.0229721833,
-0.0242819991,
-0.0195894241,
0.0055181226,
0.0080223139,
0.0026480732,
0.0767485574,
-0.0201531015,
0.0980103314,
0.0522069447,
-0.0232466832,
-0.0154477721,
0.0105516585,
0.0082308454,
0.047390677,
0.0127741583,
-0.0053421929,
-0.0091894073,
-0.005375518,
0.0126245217,
-0.0395648554,
-0.0207512323,
-0.0202283654,
2.711e-7,
0.0520447567,
0.0123272818,
0.0240549892,
-0.0019118576,
-0.0006829237,
0.0566607155,
0.0049597528,
0.0517136194,
-0.0171726309,
-0.0322702788,
0.0201089773,
0.0241489951,
0.006375581,
0.0357534997,
-0.0546619035,
0.0119830444,
-0.0417989381,
-0.0749279037,
-0.0394630879,
0.0038308923,
0.0918667316,
0.0966481194,
0.0436342098,
0.0127428323,
-0.0293083433,
-0.036474064,
0.0641957521,
-0.0256586727,
-0.0088688377,
0.0034548829,
-0.0428450666,
0.0080933478,
-0.0387574024,
0.01568795,
-0.0287530888,
0.0411931723,
-0.0155598987,
0.0443886891,
-0.0213423204,
-0.0358634964,
0.0035013454,
0.0182999671,
-0.0089777242,
0.004438417,
0.0863965675,
-0.1082644686,
-0.0270405654,
0.0095241657,
-0.0631054193,
0.0154831512,
-0.0247819982,
0.0278277136,
-0.0190070085,
0.0216963403,
0.0193841215,
0.002943082,
-0.0805269927,
-0.0926873907,
-0.0096792681,
0.073497124,
0.0206410978,
0.015741935,
0.0122597516,
-0.0447085276,
0.03407754,
-0.0399982072,
0.0164667778,
2.56450072e-34,
-0.002734825,
-0.0051053911,
-0.012239702,
0.0450557731,
0.0140063781,
-0.0253577586,
-0.0833373368,
-0.0183671359,
0.0211729594,
-0.0450869538,
0.036839515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12009v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12009v2 | Active Preference Inference using Language Models and Probabilistic Reasoning | 2023-12-19T09:58:54 | 2024-06-26T15:00:52 | Wasu Top Piriyakulkij, Volodymyr Kuleshov, Kevin Ellis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Actively inferring user preferences, for example by asking good questions, is
important for any human-facing decision-making system. Active inference allows
such systems to adapt and personalize themselves to nuanced individual
preferences. To enable this ability for instruction-tuned large language models
(LLMs), one may prompt them to ask users questions to infer their preferences,
transforming the language models into more robust, interactive systems.
However, out of the box, these models are not efficient at extracting
preferences: the questions they generate are not informative, requiring a high
number of user interactions and impeding the usability of the downstream
system. In this work, we introduce an inference-time algorithm that helps LLMs
quickly infer preferences by using more informative questions. Our algorithm
uses a probabilistic model whose conditional distributions are defined by
prompting an LLM, and returns questions that optimize expected entropy and
expected model change. Results in a simplified interactive web shopping setting
with real product items show that an LLM equipped with our entropy reduction
algorithm outperforms baselines with the same underlying LLM on task
performance while using fewer user interactions. | [
0.0702558383,
0.0420373417,
-0.0129439542,
0.0201689526,
-0.0237691514,
0.0043255016,
-0.0009671198,
-0.0016479212,
0.0261571016,
-0.0340838321,
-0.0039182166,
-0.020975871,
-0.0108712167,
0.006201698,
0.0023121228,
-0.087770544,
0.0043969271,
-0.0617751703,
0.0039750636,
-0.0323840752,
0.015146099,
-0.0020277672,
-0.0226133727,
0.0113955876,
0.0537631661,
0.0019694064,
-0.0453325622,
0.0173256043,
-0.0075683743,
-0.0003770256,
-0.000161022,
0.0559053905,
-0.0114791431,
-0.0608637333,
0.0000023118,
-0.0627916902,
-0.0150001822,
-0.0427329727,
-0.0428036153,
0.0051536723,
0.0296043381,
0.0967348814,
0.0400524363,
0.0176636279,
-0.0424172096,
-0.006143013,
0.0487388931,
0.0107403882,
0.0171900019,
-0.0103688417,
-0.0167154204,
-0.0055982438,
-0.0209144726,
-0.0154912593,
0.0810467377,
-0.0586071014,
0.0193763953,
-0.0522378497,
0.0182389971,
0.0093503017,
0.047414884,
-0.0005268872,
0.0175263938,
0.0220533982,
0.0240354445,
0.037371356,
0.0307145827,
-0.0095548481,
-0.0068728714,
0.0563903041,
0.018361792,
0.0265273824,
0.0087915882,
-0.0305930786,
0.0194524713,
0.047544729,
-0.0168438237,
-0.0137159042,
-0.0471525192,
-0.0052008121,
0.0151417051,
0.0048925956,
0.0209994614,
0.022898715,
-0.0291710999,
0.0824434236,
0.0009316855,
-0.0241535772,
0.0258355923,
0.0128706936,
-0.0457120389,
-0.0689939484,
-0.0015649803,
0.0187485572,
-0.044406306,
0.0155046964,
0.0156982299,
0.044769045,
-0.0305164549,
-0.0508792698,
0.0112336697,
0.0321128555,
-0.0023161652,
0.0515963435,
0.0467531718,
0.0050424216,
0.0154523076,
-0.0534250885,
-0.0567711592,
0.0233641639,
0.0005941914,
0.0162231978,
-0.0116112735,
0.0231105462,
-0.0366453975,
-0.0031914148,
-0.0217672866,
0.0620190427,
0.0248579755,
0.0247157924,
0.0305844508,
0.0375406481,
-0.036482051,
0.0048682303,
-0.1103021353,
0.0030586631,
-0.0562576056,
0.0220001284,
0.0088941688,
-0.0216347314,
0.0363052711,
0.0232296158,
0.0058427029,
-0.0357212722,
-0.0046706968,
0.0701540858,
0.0074327202,
-0.013135761,
-0.0603335276,
-0.0447323136,
0.002833996,
-0.0336891785,
-0.0108751077,
-0.0491069481,
0.0130669279,
0.0438540541,
-0.0031192382,
-0.0427421778,
0.009860157,
0.0006620444,
-0.0227116589,
0.0932561681,
0.0222196169,
-0.0163727328,
0.020146817,
-0.0029005024,
0.0011830968,
0.0463351868,
-0.0022289797,
0.0974961594,
0.0441984199,
0.0022696059,
0.0199496597,
0.0281926654,
-0.0407825634,
-0.0160357486,
-0.016746236,
0.0298287775,
-0.0327518135,
-0.0236393958,
0.0024726207,
0.0686845407,
-0.0130750621,
0.0008702931,
0.1093101278,
0.0214633588,
-0.0404181145,
-0.0158202462,
0.027510222,
0.0210422184,
-0.0068485318,
0.0076848259,
-0.0061743688,
0.0269960314,
-0.0288538914,
-0.0078876866,
0.0345566794,
-0.0224697739,
-0.0355602093,
-0.057598196,
-0.0022496146,
-0.0313527547,
0.0240091532,
0.0995266661,
0.0526092537,
-0.0173910465,
-0.01679915,
0.0050237221,
0.055971276,
-0.0113422852,
-0.0055130119,
-0.0568839461,
0.0693611503,
0.1337948143,
0.0480280258,
-0.0312203318,
0.0208622199,
-0.0124009848,
-0.0314157791,
0.0075783092,
0.0708651394,
-0.0278027169,
0.0107020494,
-0.0294020027,
-0.0354997031,
0.0320972838,
0.0013027039,
0.0341946036,
0.0017123127,
-0.0322035588,
-0.0066276733,
-0.0229195151,
0.0344224945,
-0.0078649204,
-0.0149402497,
-0.0423044227,
0.0579189546,
0.0234300606,
0.0509896167,
-0.0208612494,
0.016661996,
-0.0025443693,
-0.0145115592,
-0.0177744478,
-0.025078753,
0.0331895277,
0.0107310088,
-0.0152047882,
-0.0000101898,
0.0251506995,
-0.0078372993,
-0.0238958281,
-0.0072769639,
0.0148941092,
-0.0310995784,
-0.0236586947,
0.0449452922,
-0.0094753709,
-0.0009147421,
0.005578612,
-0.0307380166,
-0.0761718675,
0.0702961311,
-0.0110249026,
-0.0123607628,
0.0074189473,
-0.0371482857,
-0.0378387198,
-0.0561086424,
0.0027258692,
-0.0067471876,
0.0305181071,
-0.0039161188,
0.0348586664,
-0.0006972277,
-0.0132824397,
-0.0041432572,
-0.0717453361,
0.0018287363,
0.0234139599,
0.0089602647,
-0.0081507396,
0.0583433136,
-0.0051214802,
0.0062921299,
-0.0247741081,
0.0369098075,
-0.0530539155,
0.0268936623,
0.0280860867,
0.0326404274,
0.0098393494,
-0.0654934645,
-0.0036226178,
0.0011009093,
0.0146871042,
0.0182215497,
0.0317909718,
-0.0522643812,
0.0314512663,
-0.0241701789,
0.001654567,
-0.0175183918,
0.0135637838,
-0.0105689596,
-0.0695178732,
0.0628165901,
0.0991905034,
0.0377266705,
0.0136955874,
0.0390836112,
-0.0225068685,
-0.0632610694,
0.0180378556,
-0.0606794395,
-0.0192865431,
-0.0374225862,
-0.0587946624,
0.0057728896,
0.053849265,
-0.0057433574,
0.0092140902,
-0.0330422819,
0.025780566,
-0.0003422729,
-0.0033992489,
-0.0560123026,
0.0379157364,
0.0064268974,
0.0970401168,
0.0052645705,
-0.0403214619,
0.0866048262,
-0.0052662422,
0.0126230763,
-0.0440821312,
-0.0162919834,
0.0081390925,
0.0113172038,
0.0218676068,
0.0156562086,
0.0185928512,
0.0099799698,
-0.0701696053,
-0.0312675498,
0.0394256711,
-0.0416803434,
0.0123559693,
-0.0548023507,
-0.0028929783,
0.0065615806,
-0.0933445096,
-0.0636424795,
-0.0759370923,
-0.0136754382,
-0.0425323956,
0.0517442338,
-0.0248623099,
-0.0217058901,
0.0239877589,
0.029364489,
0.0152901653,
-0.0101303803,
-0.0628504381,
0.0062814821,
0.0204129051,
0.0813624337,
-0.0171278641,
-0.0250406675,
-0.0575816631,
0.0077368841,
0.0463435315,
0.0164176282,
-0.0081144217,
-0.0150759146,
-0.0200953074,
0.0492974371,
-0.0320137814,
0.0207705926,
0.062195424,
0.009691556,
0.0104740923,
-0.0005281861,
0.1267048717,
0.0272309445,
-0.0811351165,
-0.0030594971,
-0.0013723832,
0.0219924022,
0.0001475094,
0.0575181358,
-0.0587544739,
-0.0468150191,
0.0108747287,
0.0743449852,
-0.0052832379,
-0.0301010292,
0.0128395678,
-0.09095148,
-0.01732325,
-0.0446837917,
0.0141574899,
0.0229548123,
-0.0438030064,
0.01857608,
-0.0278842188,
0.0059461361,
0.0125774601,
0.0073726941,
0.0220103692,
0.0171761122,
-0.0138219735,
-0.00872669,
0.0160925463,
-0.0081229331,
0.0038618036,
0.0698898137,
-0.0095756901,
0.0050896276,
-0.0208148677,
0.0120625524,
-0.0368618406,
-0.0203447212,
-0.0343373977,
0.0279872604,
-0.013678316,
0.0221760832,
-0.0342283547,
0.0257399622,
-0.0017707957,
0.0264234021,
0.0448876135,
0.0271021333,
-0.0109957336,
-0.017432021,
-0.015879387,
-0.019054519,
0.0464334451,
0.0648526922,
0.0119810132,
-0.1002546847,
-0.0041648084,
-0.0890819654,
-0.0419146903,
0.0065765651,
-0.0258654822,
-0.0298557151,
0.0108338734,
-0.0641545951,
-0.0642264634,
-0.0130973691,
0.0067487676,
0.031906236,
0.0122667626,
-0.015213876,
0.0353904627,
0.0302602258,
-0.0157393198,
0.0197881907,
-0.0048337705,
0.0148606859,
-0.037552122,
-0.0275701806,
0.0446646325,
-0.0570287928,
-0.0217643008,
0.0018925259,
-0.0219337251,
-0.0538629554,
-0.021851005,
0.0908488035,
0.0299754478,
0.0077998564,
-0.0454738103,
-0.0338739455,
-0.0315433107,
0.0281840079,
-0.0101686576,
-0.0255787484,
0.012513564,
0.0631162077,
0.0259252116,
0.0191906299,
-0.0523875281,
0.0108787259,
0.025749661,
-0.0007747558,
-0.0355041176,
-0.1090684459,
0.0286782496,
0.0181203596,
0.0448924378,
0.0073880167,
-0.0039067557,
0.0109269405,
0.0213203002,
0.0229446851,
-0.0435591973,
-0.0290978476,
0.0009986872,
0.0196179524,
0.0298178829,
-0.0001820419,
0.0062896619,
0.0069143451,
0.0201015603,
-0.0240326747,
-0.0165140741,
0.0299557038,
0.02988692,
0.0346484929,
-0.0257136766,
-0.00453158,
0.0015592107,
0.0265546702,
0.0772865266,
0.0106597757,
0.0770067573,
0.0082947593,
-0.0171681866,
-0.0370845646,
0.0102981701,
0.0058346777,
-0.0852606148,
0.0088265939,
0.021914918,
-0.0068471231,
-0.0070247264,
-0.0106379464,
-0.0417775922,
0.0043651429,
-0.0208155531,
0.0157799125,
0.0366623588,
0.0041329423,
0.036645405,
0.045604948,
-0.0290309843,
-0.0259125195,
0.0555099621,
-0.0139737129,
0.002945889,
-0.0189052671,
-0.0609500743,
-0.0403379835,
-0.0051135528,
-0.0180516224,
0.0316788033,
-0.0461142473,
0.0180855468,
-0.0277294423,
-0.0554020219,
-0.0783035457,
-0.0030286624,
0.0050750589,
-0.0215276554,
0.0759163126,
0.0767460763,
0.0106563196,
-0.0215723924,
-0.0406843089,
0.0516668148,
-0.0526080206,
-0.0048788739,
-0.0242401268,
-7.020986781e-33,
0.0113558425,
-0.0081299972,
-0.0083544627,
0.0112546086,
0.0290416759,
-0.0528846346,
-0.031190699,
0.0371356905,
0.0175026022,
-0.0145169599,
-0.0073281024,
-0.0226258039,
0.0051498585,
-0.0018046593,
-0.0029120387,
-0.0395890735,
0.0303835496,
0.0326380022,
-0.0444775261,
0.0305466522,
0.0488558486,
0.0026479873,
-0.0148337344,
-0.0309054777,
0.0215502456,
-0.0044654789,
0.0105045736,
0.0331738442,
0.0136163449,
0.0289159454,
-0.0132538751,
0.0297634881,
-0.0085797533,
-0.0410534553,
0.0158373639,
0.0386624709,
-0.0478666984,
-0.0054440936,
0.0390896201,
0.0048583313,
-0.0289602745,
0.0059323045,
-0.0088745039,
0.0214235671,
0.0100724511,
0.0329713821,
0.0433075503,
-0.0279063303,
-0.0043394039,
-0.0491499975,
-0.0030983044,
-0.0046575712,
-0.0252727978,
0.0038246065,
-0.0020147592,
0.0752155408,
-0.0153993145,
0.0142273707,
0.0232047085,
0.0372458659,
0.0183735825,
0.0256623887,
0.0214621555,
0.0006800432,
-0.001241618,
0.0127603691,
0.0152172884,
-0.0095730312,
-0.009751061,
0.0353284143,
-0.0368106663,
0.0178695023,
0.0058299499,
0.0277690552,
0.0324149542,
-0.0030384702,
-0.041068878,
0.071763441,
0.1020697951,
-0.0174914394,
0.0480462722,
0.0141732786,
-0.0540994108,
-0.0384598747,
-0.0193410907,
0.0279790852,
-0.0407693908,
-0.0524737611,
0.0310449582,
0.0133391814,
-0.0546692535,
-0.0399005376,
0.0097493157,
-0.0065490645,
-0.0535269007,
-0.0057914588,
-0.0130696418,
-0.012912631,
-0.0084853219,
-0.0141464602,
-0.0308308583,
-0.0177239925,
-0.0195804685,
-0.0292374212,
-0.0385450795,
0.0445519201,
-0.0318004079,
-0.0047291256,
-0.0308896266,
-0.027777886,
-0.016815627,
0.004020927,
-0.0234162137,
0.0514145792,
0.049890887,
0.014219949,
-0.0055119991,
0.0289236661,
-0.0187302046,
-0.0333070941,
-0.0719986409,
-0.0232029725,
0.0066313939,
-0.010570595,
-0.0159483887,
-0.0350417979,
-0.025516063,
0.00770699,
-0.0154282134,
-0.0522918738,
-0.0156175178,
0.0038377799,
3.031e-7,
0.0127908094,
0.0459655002,
-0.0742707476,
0.0354198515,
0.0024053717,
0.0573311523,
0.0407184958,
-0.0241650362,
0.0634774342,
-0.0210592244,
0.0249797404,
0.0329961218,
0.0404728502,
0.0269790199,
-0.120526582,
-0.0804084986,
0.0198063757,
0.0345205106,
-0.0249518827,
0.0051008291,
0.0386460274,
0.065096274,
0.039660424,
0.0066964603,
0.0366086587,
-0.0292555671,
0.007192194,
-0.0763310865,
0.0185879953,
-0.0012956989,
0.0177297462,
-0.0037419137,
-0.0070321611,
0.0007194873,
-0.0018130365,
-0.0331548415,
-0.0305535439,
0.0631066188,
0.0312006194,
-0.03376811,
-0.0047557834,
-0.0233542584,
0.0332082734,
-0.0590814278,
0.0897556767,
-0.0380561836,
-0.019547699,
0.0269644968,
-0.0004776194,
-0.0502074733,
-0.0188391842,
-0.0082041686,
-0.0345300436,
-0.0186845902,
0.0030595972,
-0.0125142951,
-0.0186587889,
-0.0497693829,
-0.002582009,
-0.0102494508,
-0.048817955,
-0.0869180709,
-0.0283086505,
0.0407198332,
-0.0216977969,
-0.0232697725,
0.0356109887,
2.881091425e-34,
0.0353176072,
0.0604090467,
-0.0085539985,
0.0383225121,
0.0499217398,
0.0209625456,
0.0088134501,
-0.0023746053,
0.0777157396,
-0.0938557982,
-0.0170032177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12006v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12006v1 | Can ChatGPT be Your Personal Medical Assistant? | 2023-12-19T09:54:27 | 2023-12-19T09:54:27 | Md. Rafiul Biswas, Ashhadul Islam, Zubair Shah, Wajdi Zaghouani, Samir Brahim Belhaouari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | The advanced large language model (LLM) ChatGPT has shown its potential in
different domains and remains unbeaten due to its characteristics compared to
other LLMs. This study aims to evaluate the potential of using a fine-tuned
ChatGPT model as a personal medical assistant in the Arabic language. To do so,
this study uses publicly available online questions and answering datasets in
Arabic language. There are almost 430K questions and answers for 20
disease-specific categories. GPT-3.5-turbo model was fine-tuned with a portion
of this dataset. The performance of this fine-tuned model was evaluated through
automated and human evaluation. The automated evaluations include perplexity,
coherence, similarity, and token count. Native Arabic speakers with medical
knowledge evaluated the generated text by calculating relevance, accuracy,
precision, logic, and originality. The overall result shows that ChatGPT has a
bright future in medical assistance. | [
0.0768581033,
0.0235223938,
-0.0140872728,
-0.0097269369,
-0.0598510467,
0.0271256007,
-0.0090486659,
0.031577982,
0.0172487032,
-0.0471937694,
-0.0001715288,
-0.0660683885,
-0.0140703311,
0.0284725558,
0.0211735349,
-0.0403807461,
0.0293167233,
0.0010811829,
0.0474742316,
-0.0110199796,
0.0447707623,
0.0203750003,
-0.0386958048,
0.0620153546,
0.0166801494,
-0.0231742393,
0.025848873,
-0.0284908302,
0.0090976618,
-0.0213916246,
-0.0020933086,
0.0562890247,
-0.0216397475,
0.0037299332,
0.0000018891,
-0.0602751188,
-0.0303774141,
0.0143362777,
-0.0303507578,
-0.0184062365,
0.0507487953,
0.005699174,
-0.0169373751,
0.0461356565,
-0.0612733774,
0.0071818409,
0.0289969724,
0.0383141451,
0.0793342888,
0.0659409389,
-0.0140173184,
-0.0150260655,
0.0364982001,
-0.0071037621,
0.0363445878,
-0.0588161498,
0.0236032158,
0.0241045523,
0.0447469428,
0.0083465753,
0.0157585237,
0.033514224,
-0.0274359025,
0.0048710778,
0.0048861359,
0.0100805908,
-0.0816404819,
-0.0088416524,
0.0215165988,
0.0377820656,
0.0120404214,
-0.0031245039,
0.0015768529,
0.0205878578,
-0.0064388877,
0.0162321758,
-0.0508685634,
-0.0020103012,
-0.0409337021,
-0.0039474396,
0.0574441999,
-0.012264112,
-0.0118005229,
0.0002679421,
-0.0177285206,
0.0013436602,
0.0166105889,
-0.0404462032,
0.000711129,
-0.0070025879,
-0.0359097198,
-0.0419547856,
0.05400398,
0.038277965,
-0.0367967226,
0.0058576656,
-0.0156496447,
-0.022287149,
0.0725603327,
-0.0957771838,
0.0028494722,
0.0561167039,
0.0076999795,
0.0423752405,
-0.0135378558,
0.0269197859,
-0.0068939948,
0.0258593671,
-0.0707680508,
-0.0017228955,
-0.1006891876,
-0.0161527321,
-0.0461036488,
0.0569647811,
-0.026509542,
-0.0016226268,
-0.1044721305,
0.0060840952,
0.0302783232,
-0.016096076,
0.0247887317,
0.0066420143,
-0.0131014418,
-0.0042899125,
-0.0353387147,
0.0003861804,
-0.0423599668,
0.0059351213,
-0.0250897426,
-0.1024177596,
0.047295928,
0.0098093804,
0.0353222415,
-0.0006453406,
0.0224677622,
0.0628059432,
-0.0144380359,
-0.0418631881,
-0.0053531844,
-0.0261754133,
-0.0286446549,
-0.0222167484,
-0.0222893134,
-0.0591424778,
0.0387684777,
0.0347464383,
0.0025873103,
0.0180017706,
0.0156260226,
0.0522259176,
-0.0391009562,
0.0351922587,
-0.0181579441,
0.0539592728,
0.0624000616,
0.0209235456,
0.0314785577,
0.0304908771,
0.0064867563,
-0.0422470085,
0.0191964135,
-0.0169544555,
0.0056703868,
0.0008181384,
0.0132969171,
-0.0157769322,
0.0157538503,
0.0413102619,
-0.0041936454,
0.0609521866,
-0.0751155242,
0.0860056505,
-0.0094568515,
0.0102624604,
0.0422720648,
0.0577533357,
0.0213251654,
0.0740792528,
-0.0131709343,
0.0134364152,
0.0454628989,
-0.0128243202,
0.0230608005,
0.0065156096,
-0.0078550577,
0.0101415878,
0.0324145854,
0.0485938862,
-0.0340209529,
-0.021507021,
-0.0415406004,
-0.0068132053,
-0.0180587955,
-0.0156788938,
0.0374458544,
-0.0208816603,
-0.0230539814,
0.0338102914,
0.0258723423,
-0.0235432386,
0.0047920286,
-0.0790811032,
-0.019403927,
0.0649262816,
0.0403951779,
-0.0198996719,
-0.0554749556,
-0.0251723398,
0.0174893495,
0.0184525941,
-0.0014074167,
0.0049603367,
-0.0288248714,
-0.0429657549,
-0.0079353107,
0.0568330288,
-0.0046371161,
-0.0324288793,
0.016787596,
0.0843951851,
-0.0116277179,
-0.0213159062,
0.0219330378,
0.0083549637,
-0.0306871329,
-0.0010504206,
-0.0049783518,
-0.0219057202,
0.0406610742,
0.0634505898,
-0.0057316897,
0.0505674481,
0.008459908,
-0.0565893054,
-0.0638073012,
0.0058707311,
-0.0523881651,
0.0009421716,
0.0364263281,
-0.0483755283,
0.01010192,
-0.0038134542,
-0.0100041591,
-0.0558720455,
-0.0059843608,
-0.0664348453,
0.0513412654,
-0.0342862383,
0.0258029252,
0.021596767,
-0.005400836,
-0.0406001545,
0.0477874167,
-0.0016991247,
0.0175707024,
-0.0029637443,
-0.0363217518,
0.0216336716,
-0.0302999131,
-0.0082029356,
0.0151393497,
-0.0099133793,
0.0351031907,
0.0267963596,
0.024633823,
-0.0483218059,
-0.0472661182,
-0.1139895022,
-0.0100755356,
0.0088884719,
0.0318607427,
0.030584475,
0.0299402457,
-0.0123098278,
-0.0126062026,
-0.0927275643,
-0.0035016416,
0.0350036807,
0.0299841631,
0.044382222,
0.0205797106,
0.0155000621,
-0.0455446057,
-0.0142830955,
-0.0190728568,
0.0026842535,
0.0510751829,
-0.0095220441,
0.0140867839,
-0.0476385504,
-0.0606114529,
-0.0140877934,
0.0257913899,
-0.0465830229,
0.0154448729,
-0.0417997912,
0.0116018075,
-0.0006751218,
0.0285806246,
-0.015081971,
-0.0230731349,
0.0074104592,
-0.015836034,
0.0078160306,
-0.041240979,
-0.0565598011,
0.0094180461,
-0.0461072661,
-0.0237457771,
0.034557201,
0.0375787728,
-0.0000681773,
-0.0751783922,
0.0228091758,
-0.0498116277,
0.0496759601,
-0.0669812709,
0.0286399312,
0.0014130422,
0.0660559908,
0.0219382737,
-0.0166356172,
0.0745614693,
0.0035817139,
0.0208892785,
-0.0807002112,
-0.0363084152,
-0.0525477044,
-0.0000986185,
-0.040551234,
0.0479797721,
-0.0213981196,
-0.0297776312,
-0.0150158731,
-0.0030918419,
0.0244486742,
-0.0590342321,
0.0191885121,
-0.0123177813,
0.0184334498,
0.0019708604,
-0.0456135944,
-0.0298832711,
-0.0385107659,
-0.0450843982,
-0.0209966544,
0.0483680144,
0.0138572529,
-0.0524663888,
0.0366817266,
0.0131819174,
0.038091369,
0.0002507505,
-0.0196241047,
0.002578347,
0.021793507,
0.05069023,
0.0021854215,
-0.0094874222,
0.0182189532,
0.0410529487,
0.0834065974,
-0.0147596495,
-0.0056988834,
0.0063555669,
0.0068791364,
0.0197132733,
-0.0397679731,
-0.0210558716,
-0.0190212931,
-0.015093456,
-0.0214506965,
0.0039273188,
0.1259157658,
0.0416808054,
-0.0369241163,
-0.0010411305,
-0.0453281105,
-0.0388847031,
-0.0305652004,
0.0183492601,
-0.0961169302,
-0.0112623721,
-0.0266833548,
0.0107635548,
-0.0109114703,
-0.0127329128,
0.0493808128,
-0.0544473529,
0.0184839349,
-0.0175594855,
-0.0476687662,
-0.0259796251,
-0.0270121973,
-0.0059120371,
0.0096781896,
-0.008884985,
-0.00111272,
-0.0216312613,
0.0229126085,
0.017764736,
-0.0332283601,
-0.054551132,
0.0391317643,
-0.0088191144,
0.0323300362,
0.0828482956,
0.0352196209,
-0.0132866651,
-0.0206227098,
-0.0038934622,
-0.0079004467,
0.0054837787,
-0.0069092065,
0.0403121486,
0.0028780862,
0.0066853077,
-0.0873786211,
0.002247975,
-0.0676905438,
0.0238403901,
0.0285175033,
0.0666159913,
-0.0264784098,
0.0190350302,
-0.0381597616,
0.0237324778,
-0.0003594996,
0.0639676303,
-0.0208276305,
-0.0139344214,
-0.0193530805,
0.0209744796,
0.0196839552,
0.019153161,
-0.0391665995,
0.0201300103,
0.0079822997,
-0.0251249522,
-0.0910041034,
-0.0118422611,
0.018368369,
-0.0155870523,
0.0004390454,
0.0672830343,
0.0277142059,
0.0374505222,
-0.0333676711,
-0.0026854174,
0.0128488308,
-0.001394558,
-0.077001147,
-0.0266531706,
0.0596845858,
-0.0483167954,
-0.0122048836,
-0.0178493634,
-0.0374319479,
-0.0081754811,
0.0091034835,
0.0005186356,
0.0247353446,
-0.0169970971,
-0.0236452855,
-0.0245807692,
0.015240767,
0.0270439964,
-0.0482141562,
0.0083667673,
-0.0165802632,
0.0153267905,
-0.0009063254,
0.0400539748,
-0.0056801974,
0.0180276316,
-0.0188961551,
0.0165790226,
0.0028838573,
-0.0463120341,
0.0346590281,
0.0439441316,
0.0129433051,
0.0051462706,
-0.0331006907,
-0.0051807431,
0.0166824088,
-0.0258323681,
0.0283201672,
-0.0425183028,
-0.0177339762,
0.0269886591,
-0.0234612264,
-0.0133734355,
-0.0246379524,
-0.0703806132,
-0.0401804931,
-0.046229206,
0.0380158983,
-0.0405643135,
0.0053593447,
0.0303841662,
-0.0063400543,
-0.0003166481,
-0.050571952,
0.0118260197,
0.0167415198,
-0.0353245661,
0.0677739307,
-0.0124069611,
-0.0054304521,
0.048184365,
0.0738899857,
-0.0335594937,
-0.0696710572,
-0.0102718184,
0.0704608783,
0.0560433902,
0.0019384259,
0.0369209275,
-0.0130669763,
-0.0040910849,
-0.0282599665,
0.0371684283,
-0.0086902184,
0.0122033292,
0.0342040062,
-0.0071748942,
-0.0035338101,
-0.009148919,
0.1020763889,
-0.0214740727,
-0.0077831149,
0.0319089964,
-0.0662610605,
-0.0273744985,
-0.0037327264,
-0.0175730363,
0.0210941117,
-0.0400948189,
0.0355636701,
-0.0554551147,
-0.0517282709,
-0.0279311221,
-0.0194671806,
-0.0233167186,
-0.0083918413,
0.0670443922,
0.0730755478,
0.0010492889,
-0.0370591283,
-0.0643401369,
0.0615517721,
-0.062059138,
-0.0102885701,
0.0329200141,
-6.645228257e-33,
0.016662119,
-0.0151439412,
0.0320263915,
-0.0053278194,
0.0101312585,
0.006244164,
-0.0125401728,
0.0152918501,
-0.0258038305,
0.0240743663,
-0.0340731144,
0.0205767713,
0.0206088703,
0.0292967577,
0.0066242414,
-0.0420026407,
0.0054380973,
-0.0110765109,
0.0111574521,
0.0597176626,
-0.0163653716,
0.047635328,
0.0512129329,
-0.0794737488,
0.0098897563,
-0.0399332456,
0.0045375838,
0.0207833629,
0.0065468797,
0.0915942788,
-0.0281697474,
0.0406683125,
0.0568557009,
-0.0074775945,
0.0224816538,
0.0021769521,
-0.0513409004,
-0.0375733413,
0.0180278216,
-0.0270519871,
-0.0255308393,
-0.0196340904,
0.009163579,
-0.0174386706,
-0.0333975255,
0.0194303654,
0.0169702992,
-0.017827291,
0.0032703464,
-0.003226921,
-0.0417667106,
0.0435024835,
0.016963752,
-0.0011813189,
-0.0357876755,
0.0481104217,
-0.0335601643,
0.0275943149,
0.0048737461,
0.0074741314,
0.036107935,
0.0188556183,
0.01671689,
-0.0459641032,
-0.0389510132,
0.0186399333,
0.0187436026,
-0.0256295782,
-0.0061364626,
0.0193637162,
-0.0472197905,
-0.0017965925,
0.0583909266,
0.0556494147,
0.0060076998,
-0.0068032984,
-0.0877722278,
0.038418673,
-0.0443176068,
0.0589656271,
0.0321301371,
-0.0119487224,
-0.0673409998,
0.0112454332,
0.0033470728,
0.0530444682,
-0.0460459143,
-0.0463489667,
0.0232043769,
-0.0121178748,
-0.0049346695,
0.0014517748,
-0.012492869,
-0.0000968354,
0.0499998704,
-0.0389829502,
0.0041319118,
0.0047445958,
-0.0186680537,
0.028548846,
-0.0551960766,
0.0045839725,
-0.0141502777,
-0.0133320242,
0.0082813483,
0.0183234755,
-0.0104189534,
-0.0166959986,
-0.0629879162,
0.0073216869,
0.0140016219,
0.0160984918,
-0.0104848891,
0.0032470117,
0.010205864,
0.0171336662,
0.0060410569,
0.0810076445,
0.0205151383,
0.0009968906,
-0.0556992702,
-0.0778366327,
0.0191873424,
-0.026913289,
-0.0206839461,
0.0257714614,
-0.0552073419,
0.0338425674,
0.0075828559,
-0.0584090836,
-0.0057910099,
-0.0264725443,
2.766e-7,
0.0829107091,
0.0635424331,
-0.0007550356,
-0.0045611756,
0.025282938,
0.0064637018,
0.020470364,
0.0117237633,
0.0202755984,
0.0513251238,
0.0294701848,
0.0014241266,
0.0295217261,
0.0370130502,
-0.0624312088,
-0.0204930678,
-0.0861563608,
-0.0188620612,
-0.0287122335,
0.0094763478,
0.0958371833,
0.1042119637,
-0.0596444122,
-0.0240204986,
-0.0095099946,
-0.0521108173,
0.0572293513,
-0.0270702522,
-0.034604691,
0.0365932137,
0.0399997681,
0.0160390381,
0.0295813978,
0.0412186719,
-0.0309751388,
-0.03797682,
0.040418148,
0.0957228616,
-0.0283444244,
0.0017115017,
0.0355322249,
-0.0077122012,
0.0211686455,
-0.0743926018,
0.0745539218,
-0.0258339345,
-0.0379226133,
0.0093382457,
-0.0029163107,
-0.0479141399,
0.0652962923,
-0.0247070324,
-0.0512203909,
0.0229473133,
0.0256049093,
0.0259585362,
-0.0178814773,
-0.0280224048,
0.0095203174,
-0.0096064368,
-0.0408372097,
-0.046807684,
0.0097809806,
-0.0215946324,
-0.0024589899,
-0.0132932151,
0.019766219,
2.291068107e-34,
0.0214553159,
0.0283270348,
0.027156895,
0.0053436561,
0.0339874439,
0.0228851084,
0.0187428761,
0.0268222634,
0.0222646035,
-0.0608340539,
-0.0169204231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11997v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11997v1 | Coreference Graph Guidance for Mind-Map Generation | 2023-12-19T09:39:27 | 2023-12-19T09:39:27 | Zhuowei Zhang, Mengting Hu, Yinhao Bai, Zhen Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mind-map generation aims to process a document into a hierarchical structure
to show its central idea and branches. Such a manner is more conducive to
understanding the logic and semantics of the document than plain text.
Recently, a state-of-the-art method encodes the sentences of a document
sequentially and converts them to a relation graph via sequence-to-graph.
Though this method is efficient to generate mind-maps in parallel, its
mechanism focuses more on sequential features while hardly capturing structural
information. Moreover, it's difficult to model long-range semantic relations.
In this work, we propose a coreference-guided mind-map generation network
(CMGN) to incorporate external structure knowledge. Specifically, we construct
a coreference graph based on the coreference semantic relationship to introduce
the graph structure information. Then we employ a coreference graph encoder to
mine the potential governing relations between sentences. In order to exclude
noise and better utilize the information of the coreference graph, we adopt a
graph enhancement module in a contrastive learning manner. Experimental results
demonstrate that our model outperforms all the existing methods. The case study
further proves that our model can more accurately and concisely reveal the
structure and semantics of a document. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/Cyno2232/CMGN. | [
0.0372146145,
0.0128924185,
-0.0151511654,
0.0447687842,
-0.0332419388,
0.0107718511,
-0.0619953983,
-0.0420988873,
0.075784564,
-0.0245612767,
-0.0089161778,
0.0408383049,
0.0075939237,
0.0077085444,
0.0154694114,
-0.0711525902,
0.0119296154,
-0.0009655051,
0.0204548892,
0.0372054316,
-0.0130461175,
0.0387775861,
0.0003874545,
0.0142750703,
-0.0222513974,
-0.0101752626,
-0.0571391657,
0.0062808036,
0.0664388761,
-0.0715034679,
-0.0175538845,
-0.0076941154,
-0.0000163441,
-0.0055535203,
0.0000020777,
-0.0342699885,
-0.0490574613,
-0.0013650028,
0.0418683775,
-0.038926404,
0.0203963891,
-0.0347825922,
0.0132621014,
0.0077810376,
-0.0398697518,
-0.0070112622,
0.0374777094,
0.082766138,
0.0687292293,
0.0569887534,
-0.0437276587,
-0.0441090874,
0.0407061949,
-0.0091308961,
-0.0107837906,
-0.0498460382,
-0.0159030687,
0.0278206542,
-0.0056072897,
0.0103590954,
-0.0341679193,
-0.0110300118,
0.0359962694,
-0.0145408055,
0.0674670711,
0.0378819443,
-0.0166027844,
-0.0121410601,
0.0030300987,
0.1227662787,
0.0036362868,
0.0378954411,
0.0362542607,
-0.0206703655,
-0.01393402,
0.0028532741,
-0.0230148342,
0.0083394079,
-0.0427377261,
0.038137529,
0.0532937609,
0.0261564348,
-0.010190025,
-0.0139040928,
-0.0338532776,
0.0597552247,
-0.0192263145,
0.0072480729,
0.0730793849,
0.0114556635,
-0.0602496825,
-0.0391650647,
0.0204910599,
0.0330775641,
-0.0050660083,
0.0140202902,
-0.0496408753,
-0.0259450246,
0.0017872917,
-0.0429069027,
0.0665060356,
0.0068042409,
-0.02029486,
0.0284279175,
-0.0462685153,
0.0288215391,
-0.0355572402,
0.0424257144,
-0.0591243245,
-0.0247697327,
-0.0502499603,
0.0395268425,
-0.0619438626,
0.0748229623,
-0.0175621621,
-0.0714717135,
-0.0641989708,
0.016153736,
0.0172806028,
0.0199492387,
0.0126989,
0.023292698,
-0.0261659883,
-0.0017716424,
-0.0144843934,
-0.0072741937,
-0.0396392196,
-0.0037938359,
-0.0214921162,
0.0427188501,
0.002845967,
0.0317673832,
0.0408980325,
-0.0066135437,
-0.0176442042,
0.1053302884,
0.0100373542,
-0.0097920801,
-0.0515891202,
-0.0786022469,
0.0036269573,
-0.0234558266,
0.0610306002,
-0.0496658012,
-0.0307935365,
0.0006832183,
-0.0212235563,
-0.0110126613,
0.0551328398,
-0.000511782,
-0.065986976,
0.048776079,
-0.0578962006,
-0.0293206424,
-0.0191507228,
0.0070987968,
-0.0267204549,
0.0274800453,
0.0494184531,
0.0272345953,
0.0349761099,
0.0154995862,
-0.0362519957,
0.0000975283,
0.0584303588,
-0.029935332,
0.0166212022,
-0.0020140305,
-0.0307817552,
0.0016860381,
0.0173881333,
0.0496714078,
-0.0177980661,
-0.0041187918,
-0.0054362724,
0.0506387167,
-0.0195622314,
0.005465412,
-0.0005853874,
0.0256200917,
-0.0375223719,
0.0575955845,
-0.0429700613,
0.0479319505,
0.0194494389,
0.0199873243,
0.029902434,
0.0009027472,
0.0166040137,
-0.019074494,
-0.0036415847,
-0.0037585089,
0.0425039567,
-0.0616440512,
0.0402798653,
0.0607652664,
-0.0545007996,
0.0465351939,
0.0226031896,
-0.0460875146,
-0.0012697828,
0.0284853168,
-0.0238475576,
0.0309412982,
0.0465206839,
0.0024956348,
-0.0393619873,
-0.0052863914,
-0.0105968369,
0.0461836271,
0.0062804567,
-0.0338403322,
0.016434934,
-0.0871491358,
-0.0418640599,
-0.0183781348,
-0.0218427274,
0.0061022411,
0.0083091715,
-0.0068965168,
0.0526295751,
-0.0414762124,
0.004409011,
0.0174731277,
0.0011061606,
0.0117528047,
0.0198417474,
0.0285249054,
0.0185669679,
0.03825178,
0.0096216463,
0.0200345516,
0.0431089476,
-0.0554943345,
0.0065370137,
0.0367305204,
-0.0654773563,
-0.0530882478,
0.0321821123,
-0.0856067687,
-0.0058666547,
-0.0134047717,
-0.0613694899,
-0.0713366196,
0.0233903807,
-0.0588416234,
0.0636893064,
0.0133512551,
-0.0270397384,
0.0436846763,
-0.0127448365,
0.0001030378,
0.069740735,
-0.0276267789,
-0.0025796304,
0.0331719629,
-0.0106607536,
0.0192755535,
0.0082227122,
0.0644479319,
0.0094126351,
-0.0045455573,
-0.0267889239,
0.0183166247,
0.0305780638,
-0.0741971359,
-0.0235051978,
-0.0833838508,
-0.0108335074,
0.025096545,
0.0112131657,
0.0615792833,
-0.0071485983,
0.0197257288,
-0.0446643159,
-0.0497939475,
0.0702620223,
0.0163476262,
-0.0297009759,
0.0334541239,
-0.0098729078,
-0.0375559181,
-0.0103589725,
-0.0146633191,
-0.0325858071,
0.0172369368,
0.0274977926,
-0.0367743447,
-0.0113391867,
0.0657443479,
0.0100679155,
0.0148487482,
-0.0146957198,
-0.0260929391,
0.0123988204,
-0.0177873354,
-0.0015989682,
0.0300924946,
-0.0150841568,
0.0382705703,
0.0274969134,
-0.0782754868,
0.0053317654,
0.0200152397,
-0.013683279,
0.0502359271,
-0.0263761654,
-0.0121674472,
-0.0075998418,
0.0405755378,
0.0423754342,
0.0118782399,
-0.0457118116,
0.0219297819,
0.0047647287,
-0.0011672616,
0.0025940882,
0.0016985128,
0.0260076802,
0.0374371707,
-0.0333118215,
-0.00034345,
0.05493211,
-0.0122521613,
0.0243490413,
-0.0285577159,
0.0225143377,
-0.0704677552,
0.0914767757,
0.0251047295,
0.0340543762,
0.0603561699,
-0.056765113,
-0.0666995347,
-0.020804612,
0.0090118414,
0.0134147024,
-0.0298860148,
-0.0504811667,
-0.0041101044,
-0.0128291789,
-0.0013317575,
-0.0353067704,
0.0734524056,
-0.0256107431,
0.0317696482,
0.039551463,
-0.013629931,
0.007904687,
-0.0261155777,
-0.0077995723,
0.0335438699,
-0.0330321565,
-0.0084623611,
-0.0309479907,
0.0935183316,
0.0623338595,
-0.0131261079,
0.0269200336,
-0.0271308273,
0.014351421,
0.0536655784,
-0.0425592773,
-0.0026747754,
-0.0027490801,
0.0236412305,
-0.0301655382,
-0.0105750049,
-0.0122056454,
-0.0054590898,
0.0246594939,
-0.0417394415,
-0.0344729945,
0.0888395309,
0.0475262664,
-0.0697065517,
0.0006369812,
0.0064888289,
0.0013895525,
0.014513148,
-0.0124096116,
-0.0393497124,
-0.0287565719,
-0.0032884968,
0.0067485836,
0.0065778205,
-0.0689319074,
-0.0026139258,
-0.068109937,
0.0356283709,
0.0174632762,
-0.0563616268,
-0.020389447,
-0.0278994069,
-0.0003046382,
0.0199744999,
-0.0660866201,
-0.0372396559,
0.0000018214,
0.0001970998,
-0.0259163678,
-0.0124798138,
0.0061769476,
-0.0048372243,
-0.0288604721,
-0.0042894683,
0.0518667027,
0.0571757481,
0.0432974733,
0.0021446373,
0.0299635995,
0.0082025453,
0.0007549145,
-0.0199532919,
0.0630791262,
0.014024605,
0.0061692554,
-0.0160525497,
0.0646089762,
-0.0682138503,
0.0017990409,
0.0154747656,
0.0521046855,
-0.0252954736,
0.0119689349,
-0.0585505329,
0.0261802822,
0.0023212859,
0.0395166129,
0.0331201293,
-0.0144061595,
-0.0172913894,
-0.0336920582,
0.0591684394,
-0.1044574752,
-0.0174805634,
0.0025465775,
-0.0114997011,
0.0598650053,
-0.0568734184,
-0.0389908068,
-0.0066461461,
-0.0082978057,
0.007883545,
-0.0312515981,
0.0782908946,
-0.0327903666,
-0.0708318129,
-0.0284961164,
-0.0095646875,
0.0099485777,
-0.0258554239,
-0.0148600591,
0.0487993471,
0.0252932962,
-0.0036840001,
0.0792416334,
-0.0419529043,
-0.0382783599,
-0.0335352495,
0.0273847748,
0.0041156081,
0.0460102484,
-0.0000244986,
0.0292256698,
0.0152678443,
0.0221342016,
-0.0724024326,
-0.0082984436,
0.0169431791,
0.0315535665,
-0.0151952188,
0.0260907132,
-0.0292057227,
0.0443692952,
0.0149314664,
0.0490120277,
0.0116954008,
-0.0536387265,
0.0129213184,
0.0112519758,
0.03045002,
-0.0117531521,
0.0464198291,
-0.0391049087,
0.0252881423,
-0.0523129217,
-0.0270725321,
-0.0418990552,
0.0203903969,
0.0122420061,
-0.005431219,
0.0155784367,
-0.0458841473,
0.0091786375,
0.0121650109,
0.0509468801,
-0.0228754338,
0.0184548981,
-0.0026412499,
0.0133738965,
-0.0077892658,
-0.0152365761,
-0.0059793475,
-0.0112146651,
0.0338730849,
-0.0229303408,
0.0654161349,
0.014597632,
-0.0460486673,
-0.0182943139,
0.013558412,
-0.0575739294,
-0.0159986634,
-0.0451841429,
-0.0124942688,
0.0554063134,
0.0013530279,
0.0463870689,
-0.0448826961,
0.0131054735,
0.0168785974,
0.0798862875,
-0.0257327594,
-0.0475289114,
0.0006200275,
0.0063499925,
0.019843841,
0.0013614284,
0.0553371832,
-0.002252562,
0.0006293462,
0.0155179277,
-0.0430049002,
-0.0728140548,
0.0084186317,
-0.0146443387,
0.0437708944,
0.0069866725,
0.0667743087,
-0.043125838,
-0.0372852236,
0.0809938833,
-0.006724555,
0.0347382575,
0.0296050087,
0.0568269268,
-0.0073178238,
0.0171090681,
-0.0489343517,
-0.0149132898,
0.0407019891,
-0.0698286146,
-0.073267445,
-0.0402164012,
-6.137541063e-33,
-0.0743585452,
-0.0956736505,
0.0035497299,
0.0082350401,
-0.0316768512,
0.0037609574,
-0.0820842609,
4.604e-7,
0.007718917,
0.0146000544,
-0.0012092448,
-0.0058513056,
-0.0086200768,
0.0405097418,
-0.0065010907,
0.025075607,
0.0414167084,
-0.0004288777,
-0.0049005556,
0.0615539923,
0.0672902241,
0.0089894664,
0.0539433248,
-0.0976541042,
-0.0282971971,
0.0241105575,
0.010425617,
0.0110288095,
0.0351470187,
0.0251690969,
-0.0174211636,
0.0079982961,
0.0116876932,
0.0082922317,
-0.0111957425,
-0.0065385005,
-0.0811032057,
-0.0627713501,
-0.0267852377,
0.0077786082,
-0.02980645,
-0.0682991669,
0.0175234135,
-0.0052967789,
0.0520575903,
-0.0707618743,
0.0690926611,
-0.0110395262,
-0.0123055708,
0.0096078776,
-0.0601346605,
0.0239261389,
-0.0172299836,
-0.0072299493,
-0.0026575071,
0.037565589,
0.0139517216,
-0.0001713064,
-0.0521920212,
0.018241182,
0.0198223721,
0.0104053663,
0.0064790589,
0.0145689901,
0.0210118257,
0.0610921346,
-0.018238375,
-0.0139823807,
-0.0218740813,
0.0579675734,
0.0081030661,
0.0777356699,
0.0037306834,
0.029269537,
-0.0170992911,
0.0170096811,
-0.0666064098,
0.0109962691,
-0.0174631178,
0.0346154682,
0.0048785927,
0.0041893669,
0.0078175021,
-0.0309502501,
0.0007449772,
-0.082009539,
-0.0060108635,
-0.0132282628,
0.0010387358,
-0.0106259976,
-0.0131222755,
-0.0193463061,
0.0146027617,
-0.0430476367,
0.0170592964,
0.0391406715,
-0.0309830774,
0.0443369746,
-0.0135249151,
-0.0022627292,
-0.0747400597,
-0.0364146978,
0.0029258598,
-0.005194122,
0.034383636,
0.0101637784,
0.0374339893,
-0.0175757278,
-0.032899756,
0.0010725131,
-0.0207216814,
0.0186723769,
-0.0261873454,
-0.0167889223,
0.0088481177,
0.0042620744,
-0.0259304736,
0.0511036031,
0.0133109363,
0.0498722792,
-0.0121794706,
-0.0097438106,
0.0186279565,
0.0560419522,
-0.0045114281,
-0.0028001107,
-0.0077087972,
-0.0021066393,
0.0383397602,
-0.0509719886,
-0.0196110401,
0.0162801575,
2.822e-7,
0.0034644029,
0.0313035659,
0.0657560676,
0.0027281865,
0.0125120142,
0.0461180285,
-0.0050594099,
0.0193169825,
-0.0035079031,
-0.0725501403,
0.008688109,
0.0161880124,
0.0074269138,
0.0646892563,
-0.0794156715,
0.0403013043,
-0.0343523547,
-0.0391416363,
-0.0319413655,
0.0409921147,
0.0743212178,
0.0226972494,
0.012625711,
-0.001605498,
-0.0113935266,
0.0338591971,
0.0326965302,
0.0090587623,
0.008620223,
-0.0293793231,
-0.0313388817,
0.0018130681,
-0.066645965,
0.0047639278,
-0.0009119104,
0.0211864915,
0.0124347657,
0.0079116514,
0.0149832461,
-0.0164225642,
0.0165956076,
-0.0012359917,
0.0229345523,
-0.0195996594,
0.0244746692,
-0.0991760865,
-0.0494508818,
-0.046243906,
-0.0327708721,
0.0264693052,
0.0034067794,
0.0068428242,
0.0110588996,
0.0173634104,
0.0221085809,
-0.0193072595,
0.0201639235,
-0.0527539216,
0.0127964085,
0.0046994686,
0.0260182302,
-0.0141098369,
-0.0178438146,
0.008193437,
-0.042301178,
-0.0271725021,
0.0014508697,
2.429328972e-34,
0.0083409278,
-0.0369582511,
-0.0124207465,
-0.0234408509,
0.0553393066,
-0.0724586695,
-0.0363832079,
0.0161449332,
0.0061569978,
-0.0962604061,
-0.034437906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11985v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11985v3 | Climate Change from Large Language Models | 2023-12-19T09:26:46 | 2024-07-01T10:40:19 | Hongyin Zhu, Prayag Tiwari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Climate change poses grave challenges, demanding widespread understanding and
low-carbon lifestyle awareness. Large language models (LLMs) offer a powerful
tool to address this crisis, yet comprehensive evaluations of their
climate-crisis knowledge are lacking. This paper proposes an automated
evaluation framework to assess climate-crisis knowledge within LLMs. We adopt a
hybrid approach for data acquisition, combining data synthesis and manual
collection, to compile a diverse set of questions encompassing various aspects
of climate change. Utilizing prompt engineering based on the compiled
questions, we evaluate the model's knowledge by analyzing its generated
answers. Furthermore, we introduce a comprehensive set of metrics to assess
climate-crisis knowledge, encompassing indicators from 10 distinct
perspectives. These metrics provide a multifaceted evaluation, enabling a
nuanced understanding of the LLMs' climate crisis comprehension. The
experimental results demonstrate the efficacy of our proposed method. In our
evaluation utilizing diverse high-performing LLMs, we discovered that while
LLMs possess considerable climate-related knowledge, there are shortcomings in
terms of timeliness, indicating a need for continuous updating and refinement
of their climate-related content. | [
0.0148907052,
0.086339958,
-0.0131381061,
0.0342927091,
-0.0290665422,
0.0159656107,
-0.0010688429,
0.0003172234,
0.0278264135,
-0.0534287915,
0.0280742273,
0.0168817379,
-0.0317887142,
0.0463366657,
0.0090728384,
-0.0730352998,
0.0390383638,
-0.0436823703,
0.0186427552,
-0.025869647,
0.0197316483,
-0.0084788213,
-0.0122270435,
0.0092110792,
0.0167092308,
-0.0207821,
-0.0173993539,
-0.0004113919,
0.050129883,
-0.043651145,
0.0108394232,
0.0605923869,
0.0372630432,
-0.0039899764,
0.0000021995,
-0.0512913689,
-0.0386416726,
-0.0171306282,
-0.0213332139,
0.0062250635,
0.0803491324,
0.004086413,
0.0179375447,
-0.0047694347,
-0.0558533967,
0.006738727,
0.0563361607,
-0.0219800733,
0.0934355631,
0.0037884687,
0.0072180005,
-0.0007543543,
0.0085174656,
0.0292217582,
-0.0146958465,
0.0377640538,
0.0477522984,
0.0583899654,
0.0217813123,
0.0243160613,
0.0033617672,
0.0790212825,
0.0028998249,
-0.0336477049,
-0.0006025198,
0.0177908447,
-0.0147150019,
-0.0243757702,
-0.011125451,
0.0657614097,
0.0491267443,
0.0114197433,
-0.0021131693,
-0.015899092,
0.030367827,
0.0306803081,
-0.0534983985,
-0.00356686,
0.0278943703,
-0.0187522117,
-0.0187362544,
-0.0040851138,
-0.0105634937,
0.0410449803,
-0.0024215558,
0.096385166,
-0.0133507662,
-0.0230780672,
-0.0377876535,
-0.0168360956,
0.0019764618,
-0.0594554842,
-0.0275747832,
0.0485927314,
-0.018835023,
0.0303071737,
0.0290358625,
-0.0137713291,
0.0235406626,
-0.0649038106,
0.0343059897,
0.0173267853,
0.0282545798,
0.0215027537,
0.0665821731,
0.0426348858,
0.030638542,
-0.0001391431,
-0.0295788851,
0.0054510268,
-0.0845784545,
-0.0339241438,
-0.0046637747,
-0.0029933811,
-0.0051774345,
0.036652986,
0.0106450273,
0.0019848265,
-0.021330582,
0.0095361853,
-0.0013678703,
0.0053007291,
0.0011364145,
-0.0327626131,
-0.0452457406,
0.0521109477,
-0.0501056612,
0.0292015094,
0.0200698338,
-0.0458608791,
0.025646491,
0.0038483718,
0.0266573839,
0.03532435,
-0.0151649183,
0.0670756623,
0.0169355329,
0.023465123,
-0.020598013,
-0.0476993285,
-0.0088497112,
-0.0277086962,
-0.0261195395,
-0.0894874856,
-0.0027258308,
0.0083461301,
-0.0042447317,
-0.0254862607,
0.0032797724,
-0.0209403131,
-0.0082921004,
0.050951045,
-0.0567326136,
0.0115968594,
0.0714517683,
0.0177454427,
-0.0029001266,
0.091057688,
0.0427737795,
0.0263757221,
0.0152104422,
-0.015959261,
0.0061713918,
0.0040048691,
-0.0017074237,
0.0489913672,
-0.0356581733,
0.0399887301,
-0.0221645944,
-0.0038283383,
-0.0112096881,
0.0288920794,
0.0152178816,
0.0338143744,
0.0643012896,
0.0104775578,
-0.0216118041,
0.0239983611,
0.0244706143,
0.035263937,
0.0044828933,
0.00960082,
0.0211942047,
0.0355824232,
-0.0397132225,
-0.0110224644,
0.0106066139,
0.0277798306,
0.003473636,
-0.0604308806,
-0.025427971,
0.0313989967,
-0.0062080091,
0.0274895541,
-0.0020133038,
-0.0102445614,
0.0032655844,
0.0357769653,
-0.0152330454,
-0.0373855047,
0.0197328907,
-0.0192612857,
0.0269565973,
0.0458317809,
-0.0132490415,
-0.008423591,
-0.0677852109,
-0.0161819998,
0.0082917931,
0.0050186347,
0.0715081245,
-0.0249276925,
-0.0613736957,
-0.0026811811,
-0.0438108705,
-0.0001293106,
0.0030605805,
-0.0076584057,
-0.0004715883,
0.0012666337,
0.0060519204,
-0.0290421005,
-0.0495443307,
0.013466008,
-0.0416516177,
-0.0145072564,
-0.054491844,
0.0037845068,
0.0378467292,
0.0097265691,
-0.0048796944,
0.0470009558,
0.025452245,
-0.0302135665,
-0.0882759318,
0.0489624925,
-0.0150460936,
0.0226827655,
0.0478170328,
-0.0376595333,
-0.0296935905,
0.0228638686,
-0.0337376818,
-0.0182205644,
0.0255677477,
-0.004589655,
0.0005288687,
-0.0124711897,
-0.0176437777,
-0.0145577053,
0.0041733701,
-0.0268194638,
0.0780016184,
-0.0099030882,
0.0254479852,
0.0209054314,
0.0005707676,
0.0113499276,
-0.0310090668,
0.0049844258,
-0.0213435292,
-0.0193664953,
0.0048711458,
0.043477945,
-0.0143262791,
-0.0968332216,
-0.003916244,
-0.0602626391,
-0.0223053675,
-0.00250361,
0.038844984,
0.0521363989,
-0.0369047821,
-0.0168582555,
0.0376887172,
-0.0095088752,
0.0091594877,
-0.0050716703,
0.0251889676,
0.0426567644,
0.0138523225,
0.0219764747,
-0.0408642665,
0.0230563972,
-0.0424186736,
0.0541763641,
0.0650626868,
-0.0090115666,
-0.0325207226,
0.0197004825,
-0.0491595417,
-0.0309210327,
0.0255382061,
-0.0361818187,
-0.0102592241,
-0.0314234272,
0.0405613631,
-0.0137501946,
0.0434431359,
0.017189838,
0.0326799974,
-0.0511734635,
-0.0610669404,
-0.0095193116,
0.0065367264,
-0.0226028133,
0.004870615,
-0.0580571666,
0.0156436395,
0.0289850123,
-0.0070860977,
0.0013561102,
0.0187653266,
0.0860020742,
-0.0838834047,
-0.0279912464,
-0.0872632638,
-0.0304309763,
-0.0164546799,
0.0887412503,
0.0022120983,
-0.0570650771,
0.0495768897,
-0.0260271281,
0.0276780594,
-0.0700292438,
-0.0143306283,
0.0038964385,
0.0642273352,
-0.0306252148,
0.0377027877,
0.0314796232,
0.017316509,
-0.0726178661,
-0.0572408885,
0.0112101231,
-0.0129219713,
0.0083573125,
-0.1061940193,
0.013571931,
0.0044247252,
-0.0039510881,
-0.0231610537,
-0.02052393,
-0.0431413911,
0.0167026222,
0.0295628496,
-0.0390548632,
-0.0395334177,
0.0158270169,
0.0640016645,
-0.0252220482,
0.00929958,
-0.0251578335,
0.0119334869,
0.0273019951,
0.0555002317,
0.0476773009,
0.0197788179,
-0.0206009299,
0.0594014078,
0.0416043699,
0.0169521049,
0.0156686157,
-0.0159019027,
0.0106348498,
0.0226487629,
-0.0123130037,
0.0298989881,
0.0189515278,
0.0351229347,
-0.0573311821,
-0.0013355968,
0.0976478755,
0.0185469985,
-0.0038012497,
-0.0094438111,
-0.0515985675,
0.0091058388,
0.0190194231,
0.0177504122,
-0.0727118179,
0.0197388325,
0.0094757183,
-0.0160683505,
-0.0389474817,
-0.0419485085,
-0.0206031818,
-0.079781428,
0.0539187752,
0.0021598618,
-0.0505672507,
0.0088485721,
-0.047523655,
-0.0015140477,
0.0372160226,
-0.0391746387,
-0.0087284371,
-0.007798539,
-0.0147411274,
0.0238788687,
-0.0768800825,
-0.033400286,
0.0428347029,
0.02895144,
0.0432505943,
0.0642974824,
0.0471327826,
-0.0206723753,
-0.0295494683,
0.0465166233,
-0.0189408083,
-0.0103576547,
-0.0087726321,
-0.0329598375,
0.0514183044,
-0.0092714783,
-0.0130792428,
0.0231183935,
-0.0107441526,
-0.0169681758,
0.0528971255,
0.1102900133,
-0.0090275202,
-0.0010101225,
-0.0146196084,
0.0255892593,
0.0330278128,
0.0429749414,
0.0393956676,
-0.0046846922,
-0.0008405821,
-0.0711054578,
-0.0324565768,
-0.0257913657,
-0.0362505652,
0.0130795613,
-0.0206064098,
-0.0217128713,
-0.0510528833,
-0.0217227899,
0.0719215274,
-0.0005781571,
0.0052049197,
-0.0240839254,
0.077364929,
0.0227977503,
-0.0307850856,
0.0315722786,
-0.0412605479,
0.0290475935,
-0.0417363606,
-0.0410896316,
0.0272074137,
0.0469033867,
-0.0363021456,
0.0344521403,
-0.0740731731,
-0.064162083,
0.0184675604,
0.0207404885,
0.0268298816,
-0.0505082794,
0.0181216244,
-0.0180277601,
0.0378789455,
0.0652974248,
-0.0068646856,
-0.0137837995,
-0.0056468938,
0.0243124161,
-0.0025497568,
0.019501945,
-0.0151574342,
0.0301738977,
-0.031490963,
0.0504937433,
-0.0641217828,
-0.0384339839,
0.020018436,
0.0262491014,
0.014549898,
0.0025496336,
-0.0507621765,
-0.0202511828,
-0.0263185091,
-0.0015338496,
-0.0528347939,
-0.0169218667,
0.0414517112,
-0.0119121354,
0.0033341616,
0.0027159099,
0.0481954105,
-0.0377707444,
0.0120966667,
-0.0313640535,
0.0648540333,
0.019156646,
0.0419099927,
0.0165516119,
-0.0057648961,
-0.0152452309,
-0.0537376069,
-0.0149546852,
-0.0146963466,
0.0282395147,
0.0131935822,
0.0057095755,
0.0220409147,
-0.0157689862,
0.0179559644,
-0.0287395678,
-0.0833465606,
-0.0330813155,
0.0485450141,
0.0160793755,
0.0560051054,
-0.0188928936,
-0.0281964187,
-0.044103574,
-0.0173574165,
-0.0017718851,
0.014724846,
-0.0425323956,
0.0791103691,
0.0263818521,
-0.037318971,
-0.0341769457,
0.049683895,
-0.0514785089,
0.0577654243,
0.0141921518,
-0.0189296119,
-0.0399576798,
-0.0281644836,
-0.0374874212,
-0.0491089225,
0.0059007625,
0.0199655555,
-0.0841770545,
-0.0607514791,
0.034537904,
0.0322092287,
-0.0119783599,
0.018468976,
0.0247026049,
0.0199751556,
-0.0146047594,
-0.0185269974,
-0.025754571,
0.0607713573,
-0.0629210994,
-0.0108092194,
0.0286448635,
-6.829283489e-33,
-0.0296637639,
-0.070246689,
0.0162720941,
-0.0098191686,
-0.0048095048,
0.0215697996,
-0.0306502972,
0.0355910212,
-0.0403628983,
0.0503510609,
0.021864634,
-0.017462587,
0.0083627189,
-0.0260900389,
0.0357460603,
-0.0210945848,
0.029476352,
-0.021626357,
-0.0179602988,
-0.0051296274,
0.053388793,
0.0092121838,
0.0375030637,
-0.0780966803,
0.0576310679,
-0.0274473187,
-0.0317391567,
0.0079396097,
-0.0010659698,
0.0228546485,
-0.0100370916,
0.0731595084,
0.027922146,
-0.0620825589,
-0.0470794253,
0.062500827,
-0.0427958854,
-0.0448951535,
0.0363631956,
-0.0597479157,
-0.0130147161,
-0.0272479653,
0.0077758362,
0.0363103449,
-0.0118240602,
0.0061089783,
0.0529527813,
-0.0480291769,
0.01552008,
-0.0222863387,
-0.0379085988,
0.0360070094,
-0.0357482471,
0.0336080305,
-0.0472682901,
0.0797011107,
0.0155708157,
0.053275723,
-0.0511918664,
0.0545239486,
0.0669030398,
0.0255730953,
0.0684596971,
-0.0034316515,
0.0221044961,
0.0629951134,
-0.0651664138,
0.0035656304,
-0.0606553294,
-0.0136033287,
0.0073285699,
0.0109262438,
0.036063984,
0.095525749,
0.0138455303,
-0.0050978623,
-0.041706834,
0.0396608934,
-0.0046465653,
0.0567576773,
0.0027940616,
-0.0272095706,
0.0380307175,
-0.0102850078,
-0.0940966085,
0.0342267379,
-0.0444948673,
-0.0003024086,
0.0274114218,
-0.0328445397,
-0.050828252,
-0.02615254,
0.0205607023,
-0.0265803374,
-0.0382289998,
0.0083518764,
0.0055227159,
0.0206657555,
0.0396791138,
0.0538522229,
-0.0587861203,
0.0262214635,
-0.0233425759,
0.0468218885,
0.0212713461,
0.0069695371,
-0.0090207066,
0.0218386035,
-0.0384467058,
-0.0178548153,
-0.039870251,
-0.010657547,
-0.012574587,
-0.0381625518,
-0.0287719686,
0.008043861,
0.0058319145,
0.0062804222,
0.0132702403,
-0.0034233334,
0.0168857556,
0.0193643458,
-0.0495598353,
0.0147408294,
-0.0268709008,
-0.0214823391,
-0.0415332504,
-0.0039509027,
0.0329549871,
-0.0203808434,
0.0020206622,
0.0065042176,
2.792e-7,
0.0759763122,
0.0283775683,
-0.0195031501,
-0.0039812136,
0.0047957762,
0.0238962024,
-0.0109035848,
-0.0143704675,
0.0109724775,
-0.0150171574,
-0.0154620893,
-0.0099383229,
0.0349851362,
0.0566140078,
-0.0649143681,
-0.0303736161,
-0.0537466817,
-0.0049308613,
-0.0740100741,
-0.0025892502,
0.0786575824,
0.019721387,
-0.0002012091,
0.0133204646,
-0.0300226379,
0.0034219001,
0.0438813642,
-0.0634682328,
-0.0116161462,
0.0234786365,
0.0454840735,
-0.0249976832,
0.0361994207,
0.0216293093,
-0.0245292708,
-0.0652788132,
-0.0211931095,
0.0422081314,
0.0447685458,
-0.0421943292,
0.0067985342,
-0.0235472098,
0.0213737171,
-0.0734953955,
0.0383551009,
-0.0756335184,
-0.0129070077,
-0.0321251005,
-0.0463550426,
0.0104032531,
-0.0042825425,
-0.0507930592,
-0.0201975051,
0.0281549264,
-0.0151834087,
-0.0048039351,
0.0004199526,
-0.0034319398,
-0.0173612069,
-0.0255984031,
-0.0296561569,
-0.0872104615,
-0.0388045982,
-0.0427613035,
0.0091342125,
-0.0221275501,
0.0554998294,
2.093115088e-34,
0.0180137474,
0.0222111791,
-0.0275641177,
-0.0369760692,
0.0425014012,
0.0169232525,
0.0041546295,
0.0248620417,
-0.0054971408,
-0.0789787844,
-0.0051636877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11983v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11983v1 | Fluctuation-based Adaptive Structured Pruning for Large Language Models | 2023-12-19T09:23:48 | 2023-12-19T09:23:48 | Yongqi An, Xu Zhao, Tao Yu, Ming Tang, Jinqiao Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Network Pruning is a promising way to address the huge computing resource
demands of the deployment and inference of Large Language Models (LLMs).
Retraining-free is important for LLMs' pruning methods. However, almost all of
the existing retraining-free pruning approaches for LLMs focus on unstructured
pruning, which requires specific hardware support for acceleration. In this
paper, we propose a novel retraining-free structured pruning framework for
LLMs, named FLAP (FLuctuation-based Adaptive Structured Pruning). It is
hardware-friendly by effectively reducing storage and enhancing inference
speed. For effective structured pruning of LLMs, we highlight three critical
elements that demand the utmost attention: formulating structured importance
metrics, adaptively searching the global compressed model, and implementing
compensation mechanisms to mitigate performance loss. First, FLAP determines
whether the output feature map is easily recoverable when a column of weight is
removed, based on the fluctuation pruning metric. Then it standardizes the
importance scores to adaptively determine the global compressed model
structure. At last, FLAP adds additional bias terms to recover the output
feature maps using the baseline values. We thoroughly evaluate our approach on
a variety of language benchmarks. Without any retraining, our method
significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art methods, including LLM-Pruner
and the extension of Wanda in structured pruning. The code is released at
https://github.com/CASIA-IVA-Lab/FLAP. | [
-0.0189398564,
0.0781411976,
-0.0167966485,
0.0516014881,
-0.0471190028,
0.0116428621,
-0.0012044415,
0.0176989846,
-0.0116685759,
0.0068801348,
-0.0029804793,
-0.0514654368,
0.007804791,
0.0165154263,
-0.0078284368,
-0.0236580893,
0.0391563177,
-0.0329426341,
0.0260469764,
-0.0083793383,
-0.0019370381,
0.015598136,
0.0254036784,
0.0281008873,
0.0312664621,
-0.0092114704,
-0.0149394693,
0.0180715062,
0.0085172262,
0.0250919368,
-0.0014523896,
0.0609503537,
0.0013978884,
0.0223207977,
0.00000223,
-0.0101999873,
-0.0053367694,
0.0205158629,
-0.0274956711,
0.0630387962,
0.0771812499,
0.0090993885,
-0.0433427654,
0.0042401836,
0.0121860942,
-0.0453616716,
0.049534779,
-0.0125780562,
0.0360576399,
0.0814994797,
0.0148566086,
-0.0457053259,
-0.0196218994,
-0.0290333033,
-0.0364995524,
-0.0421847887,
0.0041948105,
-0.0271996185,
-0.0373284966,
-0.017741207,
-0.0033901406,
0.0079226717,
0.0281618387,
0.0198889375,
-0.0457265228,
0.0281328019,
-0.056155242,
0.0128141586,
0.025143886,
0.02860092,
-0.055891972,
-0.0505477153,
0.0397084802,
-0.0238333493,
-0.0116730621,
-0.0310211331,
-0.0286737736,
0.0131103341,
-0.0014196845,
0.0290159155,
0.0217885785,
-0.0504802726,
0.0541546233,
0.0124770189,
-0.0342357047,
0.0342703983,
0.0312399492,
0.0348820612,
-0.041483175,
-0.0425563008,
-0.0099491384,
-0.059953101,
0.0080792392,
0.008896701,
-0.000796792,
-0.0104513019,
-0.0590949208,
-0.0345067233,
-0.003961191,
-0.0702332333,
-0.018525159,
0.0420347527,
0.0219149794,
0.032918755,
-0.0111163799,
0.0446171016,
0.0152642885,
-0.0278026145,
-0.0388236791,
0.0054696696,
0.0000303312,
-0.0050483197,
-0.0095934402,
0.0433039665,
-0.0189181976,
0.0040912526,
-0.0498608835,
-0.020337224,
-0.0154230101,
-0.0223314799,
0.0208868124,
0.0022888388,
-0.0277100615,
-0.0027204757,
0.0238671806,
0.0433471911,
-0.0108496742,
-0.0119438525,
-0.0197045654,
-0.0518010594,
-0.0164549053,
0.0301890951,
-0.0224851966,
-0.0124977827,
0.0361609571,
0.050366696,
0.006862456,
-0.0615074709,
-0.0445118397,
0.002462558,
-0.0044939485,
-0.0785569474,
0.0170114301,
-0.095121406,
0.0041397223,
-0.0277662501,
0.0010609579,
-0.0651027113,
-0.015583138,
0.0182273798,
-0.0543285608,
0.0198468789,
-0.0135242529,
0.0224305633,
0.0044526872,
-0.0243188795,
0.0368917249,
0.0847104564,
0.0458491743,
0.0222241394,
0.0175677054,
-0.0302054435,
-0.0378584862,
0.0434549935,
0.0270250142,
-0.0139791518,
-0.0697726905,
-0.0124559328,
-0.0368070565,
-0.0205834396,
0.0705115795,
0.0630241036,
-0.0492366105,
-0.0460009165,
0.0282180551,
0.019251911,
0.0224180389,
0.0693719238,
0.0118065234,
0.0120580597,
0.0038180863,
0.01699006,
-0.0659087524,
-0.0011373095,
-0.0287010148,
0.010469635,
-0.0027557272,
0.0756539926,
-0.0410808027,
-0.0085999705,
-0.0202491321,
-0.0112542696,
0.0196485333,
0.043857649,
0.058249712,
-0.0062448517,
-0.0177542567,
0.0653002635,
0.0410920195,
-0.056639269,
-0.0152968168,
-0.0531479977,
-0.0276495088,
0.0711121038,
0.0305800047,
-0.0111553641,
-0.0170579311,
0.0546207763,
0.0207658131,
-0.0424664393,
0.0226887483,
-0.00303677,
0.0352069587,
-0.0478478,
0.0105940169,
0.012104596,
0.0406492688,
0.0096215922,
0.0244737528,
0.0120468335,
0.0143063664,
-0.0450147353,
-0.0500056259,
0.0170684345,
-0.0063199881,
0.007282625,
0.0320302211,
-0.0240867678,
0.024355324,
0.0008479692,
-0.0528448448,
0.0071160956,
0.0747972205,
-0.0278591532,
0.0543410741,
-0.0359132029,
-0.0232402645,
-0.0534976162,
0.0642602667,
0.0351984389,
0.0156660005,
0.0396388955,
-0.0757861957,
-0.0263827406,
0.0437121242,
-0.0304515287,
0.0339980721,
-0.0401810557,
0.0359023027,
-0.0135394307,
0.061091397,
0.006069384,
0.0478409342,
-0.0374932364,
0.0000809374,
0.0202620029,
-0.0251127332,
-0.0130656129,
-0.0407792591,
-0.034934245,
0.0223091524,
-0.0076370575,
-0.0094748875,
-0.0201504473,
0.0195115786,
0.0294866115,
-0.0048992243,
-0.0674763471,
0.0312822871,
-0.05246206,
0.0645686537,
0.0209789202,
0.0460668653,
0.0093244798,
-0.0299412943,
0.0330450349,
0.0217316672,
0.0110018635,
0.0326558538,
-0.0241268352,
-0.030475257,
-0.0675004497,
-0.0179585367,
-0.0579825565,
0.0353860185,
0.0635017306,
-0.0491192341,
-0.0720292032,
-0.0379442014,
0.0413047224,
-0.0318939015,
0.0441915803,
-0.0339350179,
-0.0403916687,
-0.0301813632,
0.0083153667,
0.0043386035,
0.0687378049,
-0.0204697624,
0.0198004991,
0.0644705966,
-0.0152596431,
-0.0108608864,
0.0136998408,
-0.0128662456,
0.0125501929,
-0.0279602464,
-0.038648624,
-0.0350853056,
0.0655577257,
-0.0187278911,
-0.0198658705,
-0.0400697291,
-0.0448222682,
0.0019554647,
-0.0309462473,
-0.0257752184,
0.0013863108,
-0.0350825302,
-0.001703019,
-0.0031192845,
-0.0721852258,
0.0350002311,
-0.0476858206,
0.0060084416,
-0.0209130011,
-0.0426548868,
-0.0135976868,
0.0617179945,
0.0313577652,
0.0068082982,
-0.0175355133,
0.0010995741,
-0.0342013389,
0.0058830511,
0.0090933917,
-0.0318445638,
0.0034269753,
-0.0550476313,
0.0381395556,
-0.012007664,
-0.0148643125,
0.0227595698,
-0.0250694733,
-0.0434822477,
0.0357309729,
0.0443594567,
-0.0366210416,
0.0022588568,
0.0469734073,
0.0022061192,
0.0602662675,
0.0194509625,
0.0485750996,
0.0085353572,
0.012741657,
0.0724034458,
0.0134562012,
0.0519162342,
-0.0127788754,
-0.0058461642,
0.0543225482,
0.0393098556,
0.0069478368,
-0.0559064187,
-0.0038388597,
0.0120648658,
-0.0220861938,
-0.0365878269,
0.0307109766,
0.048163157,
-0.0726218373,
-0.0129217654,
0.0643312559,
0.0164993331,
-0.0475960821,
0.0307607297,
0.033548709,
0.0976547673,
0.0124817695,
0.0564076826,
-0.0379921384,
-0.0341250114,
0.0459399708,
-0.0108751478,
0.0194249339,
-0.0260926764,
-0.002381919,
-0.0858503655,
0.0363146029,
0.0108176339,
-0.0390271805,
0.0270921662,
-0.045413956,
0.0184693225,
-0.0286554527,
-0.003356111,
0.0192215256,
-0.0157535747,
0.0067120213,
-0.0004983478,
-0.0479922146,
-0.0608969182,
-0.0043576076,
-0.0029272095,
0.0529514514,
0.0399470665,
0.0002410342,
-0.0010026002,
-0.0123842359,
0.0821488798,
0.0233570226,
-0.0139313694,
-0.0408022255,
0.0496975109,
0.0268690959,
-0.0063346219,
-0.0023049081,
0.0005244876,
-0.0133536421,
-0.0095127728,
-0.0258850157,
0.0815791488,
-0.0063410774,
-0.0329601988,
-0.0091507798,
-0.0325753167,
-0.020333508,
0.0485003181,
0.0284441728,
-0.0038909882,
-0.0656847209,
-0.029100446,
-0.0374299176,
-0.0123433806,
-0.0255999919,
0.0077849184,
0.0067722574,
-0.0771944374,
0.0018437868,
0.0309951212,
0.0350789092,
0.0026954575,
-0.0515087172,
0.0024981739,
-0.0131641179,
0.0208072513,
-0.072576575,
0.0066241859,
-0.0197790023,
0.0370112248,
-0.0273721442,
0.0116670839,
-0.0068161637,
0.0212171637,
-0.0374974683,
0.0167728812,
-0.1289448589,
-0.0668367222,
0.0019917882,
0.0575394109,
0.0219513439,
0.0473438799,
-0.0103789018,
-0.0555808283,
0.0112947924,
0.0443864092,
-0.0505379736,
0.0762000754,
0.0147391139,
-0.0888918266,
-0.0100263227,
0.069118917,
-0.0269685462,
0.0015699075,
0.0096072741,
0.0352115557,
0.0236695912,
-0.0138853844,
-0.041755069,
0.0204676706,
0.0058409674,
0.0039182603,
-0.0325800553,
-0.0138594555,
0.0432524718,
0.0149952313,
-0.0165276937,
-0.0444799773,
0.03433799,
-0.0109639587,
0.0232877899,
-0.0139729129,
0.0172613002,
0.0415734462,
-0.0156707931,
-0.0001732306,
-0.0206817407,
0.0236065574,
0.0076162056,
0.063146174,
-0.0233135056,
-0.0035855637,
0.0129297879,
0.0043130382,
0.0114491694,
-0.0500173829,
-0.0412436314,
0.0093017193,
0.0018484225,
-0.0883349925,
0.014798318,
-0.0220438708,
-0.0712943673,
-0.0680471361,
0.0314263552,
0.0505697019,
0.0057039866,
0.0693890899,
0.0056468314,
-0.014120792,
-0.0669096783,
0.0105588045,
0.0368642434,
-0.0073128748,
0.0148634389,
0.0086728428,
-0.0387975276,
0.0132495444,
0.0891603231,
0.0404088981,
0.0420735665,
0.0112130623,
-0.0256763138,
-0.0254288483,
-0.0622243062,
-0.0626239851,
0.0226666871,
-0.0289239995,
-0.0122726578,
-0.0441150032,
-0.08633928,
0.0081794215,
0.00689054,
0.0044104001,
-0.0193178356,
0.0435804948,
0.0458352938,
0.0110729467,
0.0070915739,
-0.0111212442,
-0.0303031895,
-0.0168213919,
-0.0329036452,
-0.0025745744,
-6.714762421e-33,
-0.0075342804,
-0.0014983702,
0.0099955443,
-0.0261945911,
-0.0407257043,
0.0018490432,
-0.0418224595,
0.0013288199,
-0.0167826191,
0.0129973795,
-0.0156820584,
0.034442544,
0.0152346343,
0.0053106388,
-0.0360000841,
-0.0063846293,
0.0632695183,
0.0097779911,
-0.020027969,
0.0504861474,
0.0207676031,
0.0374562629,
0.102864489,
-0.020222161,
-0.0642886311,
0.0099228397,
0.0149063803,
-0.0012240103,
-0.0175764188,
0.0238715615,
-0.023306407,
0.033313442,
0.0129958764,
-0.0082839979,
-0.0192234516,
-0.0349413268,
-0.0535232686,
-0.0152428998,
0.0344105996,
0.0076923058,
-0.0012690225,
-0.0157394893,
0.036252901,
0.040081162,
-0.0051664761,
-0.019631749,
0.0075458027,
-0.0291652214,
-0.0370339043,
0.0172638167,
0.0038526384,
0.0576328039,
0.0113154007,
0.0076661273,
0.0132323308,
-0.0020904876,
-0.0323818326,
0.0318416879,
-0.0331308097,
-0.0075046238,
0.0374434814,
0.104158327,
0.0778793916,
0.0254172944,
0.0272016563,
0.0603868775,
0.0395034961,
0.0241499823,
-0.0041530309,
0.0363188758,
0.0544466749,
0.0161819719,
0.0077052303,
0.0501379296,
0.0642974228,
-0.0034743408,
-0.1045214832,
-0.0219451394,
0.0337589271,
0.0720424876,
0.0179118738,
0.0373485647,
0.0084738517,
-0.0455723703,
-0.0126316948,
-0.0244513601,
-0.0285403561,
-0.0237870533,
0.0135069303,
0.0253976677,
-0.0631184503,
0.0220075697,
0.0283697322,
-0.0439596884,
-0.0216806065,
0.035957925,
-0.0206892621,
-0.0046806363,
0.0353044644,
0.0347483344,
-0.030195158,
-0.0226355065,
-0.0125227021,
-0.0467626341,
0.0293906331,
-0.035731554,
0.0089764791,
0.0560112596,
-0.0356270485,
0.0033432103,
-0.0283635501,
-0.0022525284,
-0.011115348,
0.0986790285,
0.0350854211,
0.0103658205,
0.0242421031,
0.0421822965,
0.0342199132,
0.0006573144,
-0.0263532568,
0.0191322379,
0.0429702215,
0.0367920883,
-0.0250831731,
0.0012205786,
-0.0370332859,
0.0216684677,
0.0219780784,
-0.0752947628,
-0.034733858,
0.0684611201,
2.954e-7,
0.021294713,
-0.0170115959,
-0.0051082065,
-0.0033134269,
0.0195911322,
-0.0023560838,
-0.0158991385,
-0.0286692046,
0.0266528651,
-0.0050306153,
-0.0046391557,
0.0312984474,
0.0658043325,
0.0107442075,
-0.0888575315,
0.0424853787,
-0.0664465204,
-0.0102808466,
-0.0310875885,
-0.0678736418,
-0.0608540624,
0.1045005396,
0.0155065842,
-0.0211294293,
-0.0010007455,
0.0001450915,
-0.004090168,
-0.0107771838,
0.0111836707,
-0.0110122859,
-0.0233260356,
-0.0041984706,
-0.0243756659,
-0.0101330839,
-0.0092302179,
0.0118622286,
-0.0177994091,
0.0946603939,
-0.0018548219,
0.0217115022,
0.032167118,
-0.0132151134,
-0.0270133205,
-0.0247084759,
0.0765629858,
0.0051395735,
-0.0111971246,
-0.0463907085,
-0.0059547098,
-0.0174570922,
-0.0095245205,
0.0058171474,
0.0037241029,
0.0389293432,
0.0296283141,
-0.0257890932,
-0.0396237969,
-0.0521511026,
-0.0291644707,
-0.0036243275,
-0.0716626048,
-0.0454619937,
-0.048169747,
0.0007876777,
0.0313366093,
-0.0360627398,
0.0121266665,
3.112079279e-34,
0.0419425443,
-0.000783234,
-0.0271984115,
0.0633975267,
0.0243783072,
-0.0183042027,
0.0035324676,
0.018072281,
-0.0473124944,
-0.0634832829,
-0.0421420373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11970v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11970v1 | Large Language Models Empowered Agent-based Modeling and Simulation: A Survey and Perspectives | 2023-12-19T09:06:45 | 2023-12-19T09:06:45 | Chen Gao, Xiaochong Lan, Nian Li, Yuan Yuan, Jingtao Ding, Zhilun Zhou, Fengli Xu, Yong Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.MA | Agent-based modeling and simulation has evolved as a powerful tool for
modeling complex systems, offering insights into emergent behaviors and
interactions among diverse agents. Integrating large language models into
agent-based modeling and simulation presents a promising avenue for enhancing
simulation capabilities. This paper surveys the landscape of utilizing large
language models in agent-based modeling and simulation, examining their
challenges and promising future directions. In this survey, since this is an
interdisciplinary field, we first introduce the background of agent-based
modeling and simulation and large language model-empowered agents. We then
discuss the motivation for applying large language models to agent-based
simulation and systematically analyze the challenges in environment perception,
human alignment, action generation, and evaluation. Most importantly, we
provide a comprehensive overview of the recent works of large language
model-empowered agent-based modeling and simulation in multiple scenarios,
which can be divided into four domains: cyber, physical, social, and hybrid,
covering simulation of both real-world and virtual environments. Finally, since
this area is new and quickly evolving, we discuss the open problems and
promising future directions. | [
0.0035819635,
0.0048901276,
-0.0437437221,
0.015706148,
-0.0466037393,
-0.0385359228,
0.0367666073,
-0.00070754,
0.0446350016,
-0.0163416006,
-0.0051081227,
-0.0405858494,
-0.0367754549,
0.0093171587,
0.0250284877,
-0.0231657624,
0.0355768166,
-0.0741061121,
-0.0301117655,
-0.0072079697,
-0.0078409733,
-0.0352928415,
0.0039742277,
0.0246187598,
0.0041220686,
-0.0004354101,
-0.0550736301,
0.0006475999,
0.0290248338,
-0.0073799375,
-0.0270863399,
0.0210772362,
0.0987885818,
0.0622231252,
0.0000020818,
-0.0460436344,
-0.0060306177,
0.0046473797,
-0.0111574605,
0.0151401404,
0.0823490173,
-0.0234793928,
-0.0414231867,
-0.0095743099,
-0.0550858639,
-0.0124441963,
0.0526321717,
-0.0224518888,
0.0245467089,
0.0242889784,
-0.0102494098,
0.0137702655,
-0.01951476,
0.0294880252,
-0.0636975765,
-0.0094434498,
0.0503839664,
0.0196012668,
0.0797073767,
-0.0014638342,
-0.0197872259,
-0.0215832945,
0.0225028787,
-0.0205451138,
0.0020581675,
0.0617458113,
-0.0226668492,
-0.0072964309,
-0.0435677581,
0.0044002342,
0.012061269,
-0.0329822525,
0.0319367014,
0.0020966416,
-0.0322366171,
0.023253167,
-0.011679085,
0.0183544103,
0.0311226193,
-0.0093061356,
-0.0147208143,
0.039191395,
0.0123668825,
0.0214483589,
-0.026739778,
0.0537101999,
0.0282903761,
-0.0039969897,
-0.0748252571,
-0.043458961,
0.0289445147,
-0.0530309081,
-0.0053991619,
0.0375633799,
-0.0655690953,
-0.0094827348,
-0.0416323356,
0.0210286938,
0.0207623001,
-0.0653972551,
0.0452660099,
-0.0119507611,
0.0486379601,
0.039862968,
0.0372966714,
0.0613971725,
-0.0375512876,
-0.0030748297,
0.0023024019,
0.0031674956,
-0.025339419,
-0.0027455234,
-0.0224737059,
-0.0176468622,
-0.0189650282,
-0.0429995768,
0.0180923957,
0.0461915396,
-0.0396474861,
0.0235468857,
-0.0610462055,
-0.018038271,
-0.0102986619,
-0.012177052,
-0.0234032813,
-0.0212310273,
-0.0233087111,
0.0251834095,
0.0030008799,
-0.0705391318,
0.0278529972,
-0.0050878213,
-0.0267247539,
-0.0278873071,
-0.0247242544,
0.0728949085,
0.0116693815,
-0.010215926,
0.0332803875,
-0.0114067523,
0.0381511636,
-0.033339005,
-0.0348815843,
-0.0722596943,
0.0274610128,
-0.0410197116,
-0.0110540697,
-0.0312290117,
0.0019176393,
-0.0190680288,
0.008632862,
0.0697471723,
-0.0463619381,
0.0495803058,
0.0113483872,
-0.0168716535,
0.0257734433,
0.0846367627,
0.0437262543,
0.0012081887,
0.0231761057,
0.0121195177,
0.0493636876,
0.0764712095,
-0.0144865327,
0.0581705421,
0.0146829253,
-0.0150007391,
0.0639023557,
0.0615651868,
-0.0239624251,
0.0147062056,
-0.0267527364,
-0.0041841092,
0.090331018,
0.0249478109,
-0.0247657746,
-0.01123273,
0.0316716582,
0.0628107786,
-0.0121140676,
-0.0319062062,
-0.0255899373,
0.0251011718,
-0.0033104855,
0.0086400863,
-0.0431672186,
0.0819280595,
-0.0150426542,
0.0019475005,
0.016184397,
-0.0003773508,
0.0412869044,
-0.0196146909,
0.0387606546,
-0.0107750185,
-0.0133415926,
-0.0146863796,
0.0243291017,
-0.033860404,
0.0014769126,
-0.0760604665,
-0.0275434442,
0.0744379163,
0.0617614128,
-0.0189489685,
-0.0248796456,
0.0063210763,
0.0012727777,
0.0657884404,
0.0110981446,
0.0146939931,
-0.0449410044,
-0.0291887578,
-0.0174150839,
0.0391032621,
0.0112138186,
0.0392616466,
-0.0089963563,
-0.0055865999,
-0.0342990719,
0.0233715437,
-0.0370363258,
0.0198210943,
-0.0477713384,
0.0027428535,
-0.0548067465,
0.0068289014,
0.0578596517,
0.0076067671,
-0.0403350778,
-0.007265782,
0.0055820444,
-0.0078547979,
-0.0350473262,
0.0339351036,
0.0235890392,
0.0614921525,
0.0339333415,
0.011696985,
0.0543012321,
0.0300138593,
-0.0038823097,
-0.0090670809,
0.0150849866,
-0.0017178515,
0.0547236092,
0.0099006137,
0.0190990791,
-0.0546617992,
0.0260395575,
-0.0060732355,
0.0236644484,
0.0328208767,
-0.0388853848,
0.0219082907,
0.046928741,
0.0070231985,
-0.0189789124,
-0.0081997924,
-0.0026580878,
0.0175022483,
0.0311086513,
0.0540890284,
-0.0009851509,
-0.0070448034,
-0.0046596355,
-0.0757495463,
-0.0079137394,
-0.0023650951,
-0.022875309,
0.0176764317,
-0.0185168404,
-0.0331931561,
0.0561128296,
0.0013807099,
0.0548302159,
-0.0112879304,
-0.0021131351,
-0.0005837925,
-0.0299096163,
-0.0871964768,
-0.0336987376,
0.0129150907,
-0.0093506211,
0.0519250184,
0.0289257579,
-0.0100752404,
-0.0456937701,
0.0162544716,
-0.0406700373,
0.0386219621,
-0.0162765533,
-0.0727077499,
0.0279977433,
-0.0298424587,
0.0196629819,
0.016632257,
-0.0102286637,
0.0493302532,
0.057142593,
-0.0317143463,
-0.055507578,
0.0070923143,
-0.0433118977,
-0.0103876442,
-0.0722681135,
-0.0242257342,
-0.0024336013,
0.0710615367,
-0.0306019951,
-0.0084205801,
-0.0173085537,
0.0185615625,
-0.060982246,
-0.0445455387,
0.033071693,
-0.0118304361,
-0.0310355388,
0.056952849,
-0.0352808684,
-0.0047319918,
0.0672710985,
-0.0170897078,
0.0181385893,
-0.021572968,
-0.0042502466,
-0.0065354272,
0.0531851128,
0.0303508583,
0.0105967522,
0.0016937495,
0.0538793243,
-0.0263246074,
-0.0471020192,
0.0027046406,
0.0029070945,
-0.0104326885,
-0.0537194982,
0.0197641645,
0.0117906956,
-0.0244150683,
-0.0046924814,
0.0002017,
-0.0286260135,
0.0481371842,
-0.0147536686,
-0.0303356312,
-0.0320479311,
0.0291866716,
0.0487115644,
0.017670773,
-0.0014883652,
-0.000642349,
-0.0577355176,
-0.0165235531,
0.0613903031,
0.0349023789,
0.0089172302,
-0.0382548496,
0.0490306243,
0.0281012729,
0.0271272268,
-0.028845476,
-0.0456202291,
-0.0125322537,
0.0120339068,
-0.0014889551,
0.0431896374,
0.0427203812,
0.0176146403,
-0.0473945364,
0.006354976,
0.0791105777,
0.0146359252,
-0.0001539343,
0.0278127752,
-0.0684145764,
0.0314092264,
0.0061720884,
0.0363505632,
-0.0215657018,
0.0299736522,
-0.0085145738,
-0.0335184149,
-0.0239224434,
-0.0227968544,
0.0414184257,
-0.093670018,
0.0721251965,
0.0213864334,
-0.0596751906,
-0.0242755972,
-0.0470384508,
0.0330671109,
0.0062088128,
0.0146373687,
-0.0028883312,
0.0554510616,
-0.0534608029,
-0.007002933,
-0.0448583066,
-0.0342960246,
0.0037051106,
-0.0822541416,
0.1044855416,
0.0563091673,
0.0381631181,
-0.0221384261,
-0.0223360732,
-0.0443596505,
0.0255165268,
0.0212189369,
0.0185254384,
-0.0430106409,
0.0407590345,
-0.0000499431,
-0.0082360739,
-0.0010980858,
-0.0180292018,
-0.0370797142,
0.0280567892,
0.0745311379,
-0.0184199568,
-0.0378891937,
-0.0497906953,
0.0015718907,
0.0638663247,
0.0194453653,
-0.0021192213,
-0.0731254891,
-0.0502406284,
-0.0128003955,
-0.0502903424,
0.0202200506,
-0.075792931,
-0.0144532016,
-0.0115575837,
-0.0693593919,
-0.0127070788,
-0.0607837327,
0.0259870216,
0.0085427342,
0.0271667764,
-0.0100737996,
0.0749892369,
-0.0369909965,
0.0206453316,
-0.0467164181,
-0.0491189584,
0.053933233,
0.0278791916,
-0.0017649138,
0.0624329485,
-0.0526870787,
0.0092306258,
0.0074613858,
-0.0204122849,
-0.071486339,
0.070101805,
0.0511011444,
0.0195117295,
0.028732663,
-0.0177273881,
-0.0190690719,
0.0557590537,
-0.0242432952,
-0.0480887853,
0.048473116,
-0.0212766528,
-0.005893935,
0.0138317151,
0.0327762403,
-0.0162061471,
0.0422479212,
0.0017728307,
0.0450073145,
-0.0744716153,
-0.0308207572,
0.0073432126,
-0.0170312468,
-0.0151850265,
0.0132007711,
-0.0214612558,
-0.004040889,
-0.0161277261,
-0.0578014217,
-0.0111927278,
-0.0169076938,
-0.0341800898,
-0.0344623514,
0.031918034,
0.0622780807,
0.0239457991,
0.0065431586,
0.0001556675,
0.0369894542,
-0.0019106227,
-0.0049598194,
0.0174608435,
0.0306401476,
0.030637553,
0.0196710937,
0.0323268473,
-0.0272548757,
0.013641417,
0.0375970751,
0.0167268552,
0.0336510055,
-0.0508037619,
-0.0529232621,
0.0056379852,
-0.0143081965,
-0.0490160473,
0.0296914019,
0.0722389817,
0.0494193695,
0.0470351949,
0.0579451174,
-0.0917562619,
0.0050490657,
-0.0168560203,
-0.0181412939,
0.0086958865,
-0.0701435357,
0.0265022144,
0.0337076187,
-0.0239474662,
0.0178669933,
0.0265821647,
0.0152740385,
0.0436462462,
-0.0273769051,
-0.0105384355,
-0.0162857249,
-0.0147192059,
-0.0055402867,
0.0021828427,
-0.0184439793,
0.0022912582,
-0.0922353938,
-0.0264927763,
0.0080935294,
0.0728434697,
-0.013713371,
-0.0504202954,
0.0377274901,
0.0216214359,
-0.023444457,
0.0019783492,
-0.038658835,
-0.0350426808,
-0.0325391777,
-0.0068040555,
0.0156491343,
-5.903451649e-33,
-0.0110793309,
-0.0148770511,
0.0795564577,
-0.0082882941,
-0.0451446585,
-0.0413263701,
-0.0425506644,
-0.0179445744,
0.0162421167,
0.0363097154,
0.0110262604,
0.0031613421,
0.0141050331,
-0.0043630055,
0.000916779,
0.018293187,
0.0208966509,
-0.0376125276,
-0.0245671105,
-0.0123698991,
-0.0103563005,
-0.0334668681,
-0.0499534942,
-0.0698177665,
0.0148522118,
-0.0261959564,
-0.0381912105,
-0.0064412286,
-0.0360954516,
0.0380849615,
-0.038492918,
0.0305712949,
-0.0031005249,
-0.0239674244,
0.0006869273,
0.0162230842,
-0.007491644,
0.0150771104,
-0.0220682807,
0.016439138,
-0.0230027307,
-0.0348547548,
-0.0206775945,
0.0121414019,
-0.0788570046,
0.042934332,
0.0352421179,
-0.0362807736,
-0.0025429742,
0.012492151,
-0.1094206199,
0.0177578274,
-0.0012629072,
-0.0118177691,
0.010394942,
-0.0350134112,
-0.0275445245,
-0.0332209878,
-0.0484630093,
0.041360043,
0.03614939,
-0.0234916378,
0.0520169809,
0.0637704805,
0.0491056219,
0.0591287762,
0.0267061647,
0.0223798547,
-0.0336824208,
-0.0136415241,
0.0277747381,
0.0192020144,
0.0057429904,
0.1126472279,
-0.0818843469,
-0.0043191798,
-0.0093123587,
0.0055051753,
0.0296618734,
0.0213353708,
0.0729792565,
0.0298122782,
-0.0323086865,
-0.0155393677,
-0.0126336543,
0.0228823014,
-0.004272887,
-0.0388479941,
0.0001838242,
-0.0287707467,
-0.0149042988,
-0.0204046108,
0.0257644616,
-0.0336532667,
-0.0533899032,
-0.0248367861,
0.0130288554,
0.0258678533,
0.0063795117,
0.0039459215,
-0.0199493002,
-0.0484295078,
-0.0358061008,
0.0076741762,
-0.0133539196,
0.024010079,
-0.0641356632,
0.0479896478,
-0.0006648244,
0.0067093084,
-0.0037612023,
-0.008842608,
0.0808611587,
-0.0221094228,
0.0291778073,
-0.0364729874,
0.0225898921,
0.0141847944,
0.0270502903,
-0.0834965184,
0.0580667257,
0.0561780371,
-0.0390154719,
0.0178066194,
-0.0227908343,
0.0279470626,
-0.1143109724,
0.0393407792,
0.0320751742,
-0.0306830909,
-0.023564091,
-0.0227889493,
2.801e-7,
-0.0431571901,
0.065463841,
0.0287858378,
0.0010668333,
0.0400130562,
0.0592084788,
0.0021268874,
0.0489459932,
-0.0268711615,
-0.0171220545,
0.0307118669,
0.0690557659,
0.0254669972,
-0.0243026745,
-0.0696850792,
0.0353392363,
-0.0117558911,
-0.0052475883,
-0.0792008266,
-0.0504567996,
0.0146977929,
0.0464697555,
0.023744477,
0.0149580352,
0.0146217784,
-0.0178715568,
0.0047659855,
-0.0614092276,
-0.0165959876,
0.0398809314,
-0.0705487654,
-0.0233840868,
-0.0407185555,
0.0105466386,
0.0162425768,
0.0411476269,
-0.006997874,
0.0375422463,
-0.0213412885,
0.0340274796,
0.0107350321,
-0.0504826531,
-0.0244381633,
-0.0487877019,
0.0244988147,
-0.0673293471,
-0.0107917916,
-0.0069594854,
-0.0345212966,
-0.0006268276,
-0.0333186984,
-0.046895925,
-0.0376103893,
0.0011483999,
-0.0208746195,
0.0177363195,
0.0086394269,
-0.0152837066,
0.0180172808,
-0.0292640477,
-0.0412904695,
-0.0505294539,
0.0007690233,
0.0184240267,
0.0331136174,
-0.0229137521,
0.0247073006,
2.394369035e-34,
0.0327920578,
0.0288865957,
-0.0051871478,
0.0220397655,
0.0139641576,
-0.0038928834,
-0.0027694844,
0.0443219654,
0.054417491,
-0.0413951352,
-0.0095367637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11947v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11947v1 | Emotion Rendering for Conversational Speech Synthesis with Heterogeneous Graph-Based Context Modeling | 2023-12-19T08:47:50 | 2023-12-19T08:47:50 | Rui Liu, Yifan Hu, Yi Ren, Xiang Yin, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Conversational Speech Synthesis (CSS) aims to accurately express an utterance
with the appropriate prosody and emotional inflection within a conversational
setting. While recognising the significance of CSS task, the prior studies have
not thoroughly investigated the emotional expressiveness problems due to the
scarcity of emotional conversational datasets and the difficulty of stateful
emotion modeling. In this paper, we propose a novel emotional CSS model, termed
ECSS, that includes two main components: 1) to enhance emotion understanding,
we introduce a heterogeneous graph-based emotional context modeling mechanism,
which takes the multi-source dialogue history as input to model the dialogue
context and learn the emotion cues from the context; 2) to achieve emotion
rendering, we employ a contrastive learning-based emotion renderer module to
infer the accurate emotion style for the target utterance. To address the issue
of data scarcity, we meticulously create emotional labels in terms of category
and intensity, and annotate additional emotional information on the existing
conversational dataset (DailyTalk). Both objective and subjective evaluations
suggest that our model outperforms the baseline models in understanding and
rendering emotions. These evaluations also underscore the importance of
comprehensive emotional annotations. Code and audio samples can be found at:
https://github.com/walker-hyf/ECSS. | [
-0.004336881,
0.0277413595,
0.0012486129,
0.0052071521,
0.0035609151,
-0.0149799138,
0.0396114662,
-0.0399483778,
0.0317423195,
-0.0082549239,
-0.0514919683,
-0.0247661732,
-0.0103747901,
0.0518792942,
0.0077339467,
-0.1099653468,
0.0018262584,
0.0098170731,
0.037871372,
-0.0298446752,
0.0275470335,
0.0424510241,
-0.0240341648,
0.020098757,
-0.0695181116,
-0.0227831453,
-0.0494488738,
0.0446780995,
0.035164237,
-0.0197433904,
0.0147998044,
0.0197732095,
0.0482444912,
-0.0143021448,
0.0000019997,
-0.013060105,
-0.0097289328,
-0.0134390285,
-0.0088126268,
-0.0218123756,
0.0943135098,
0.0225409791,
-0.0203600265,
0.012047274,
-0.0276585575,
-0.021474747,
0.055087436,
0.0391914956,
0.109607242,
0.0900690779,
-0.0374158993,
-0.0260528009,
-0.0093698306,
-0.0137154609,
-0.001909581,
-0.0057877079,
-0.006770995,
0.0255559422,
0.0440493338,
-0.0855405331,
-0.056927979,
0.0180541519,
-0.006675892,
-0.0211156886,
0.0349715464,
-0.0222137328,
-0.0136762289,
-0.0349474251,
-0.0159911346,
0.1034883484,
0.0065083615,
0.0265801847,
0.0171451587,
0.0093909679,
0.0099793449,
-0.0385871045,
-0.0207817964,
0.0083950572,
-0.0111377966,
0.0107521657,
-0.0109897703,
0.0490834303,
-0.011488176,
-0.0097831693,
0.0120891817,
-0.0008193479,
-0.0285094064,
-0.0126397172,
0.0051225019,
-0.0262545608,
-0.0111723375,
-0.0162224453,
0.0331858434,
-0.0104633654,
-0.0259546377,
0.0250966214,
-0.0482470877,
-0.0083352616,
-0.0634851381,
0.0022087104,
-0.0185805522,
0.0241066739,
-0.0131928073,
-0.0070479508,
0.0441444926,
0.0300343223,
0.0113662677,
-0.0517856628,
-0.0354584306,
-0.0189545341,
-0.022392394,
0.0292583629,
-0.0360974446,
0.0186933819,
-0.0575162396,
-0.0531358123,
-0.0843962058,
0.0256688446,
-0.078129366,
0.0246883798,
0.028900722,
0.0336642824,
-0.0064935302,
-0.0005407919,
0.0348998271,
0.0153791644,
-0.0040501212,
0.0371894352,
0.0394608751,
-0.0646516383,
0.0215476435,
0.0088890456,
0.0495091043,
0.0181936864,
0.0133608151,
0.0424815118,
0.0041859481,
0.0023180284,
-0.0239087008,
-0.0263815541,
-0.0362332948,
-0.0271217879,
-0.0031982374,
-0.0245110467,
0.0383845866,
-0.0244425293,
0.0101001924,
-0.0176465679,
-0.0025045616,
-0.0527157411,
-0.0063471845,
0.0151193887,
-0.0367216021,
0.0118059209,
0.0029292968,
0.0081040645,
-0.0044963802,
0.0287598465,
0.0479490981,
0.0275091995,
0.0218473133,
-0.032681141,
0.0535962954,
0.0232448392,
0.0090624085,
-0.0066137821,
-0.0282016899,
-0.048969239,
-0.0374803767,
0.0357813276,
0.0772232637,
0.0366404392,
-0.0426410921,
-0.0019854093,
0.0528595522,
0.0004870642,
0.0276918001,
0.038133733,
-0.0023906487,
0.0750581995,
0.0250613149,
-0.0007028847,
-0.0002576639,
0.0425375178,
-0.0156651139,
0.0354085192,
0.0223077424,
-0.0028734631,
-0.033830788,
-0.0291710179,
0.0074333586,
-0.0321564078,
0.0181909222,
0.0200231988,
0.0130727272,
0.01343532,
-0.0672441944,
0.0060451007,
0.013209465,
-0.0881330669,
-0.0155814663,
-0.0049554091,
-0.0072862483,
0.0943201631,
-0.0021771155,
-0.010571178,
-0.0126989372,
-0.0302642155,
-0.0247479677,
0.0164985396,
0.0026453179,
-0.0272724833,
0.0788043663,
-0.0786212832,
0.027411662,
-0.0186884794,
-0.0158198755,
0.0185379647,
-0.0648921058,
0.0103115095,
0.0017819352,
-0.0345218256,
0.0480436347,
-0.0379616581,
-0.0148284724,
0.0127985226,
0.0055005066,
0.0069565875,
0.0042152382,
0.0360330567,
-0.0269558001,
-0.0216641575,
-0.0011337536,
-0.0077837226,
0.0130975675,
0.0490939394,
-0.0607853271,
-0.0825891197,
0.0248428304,
-0.0433672741,
-0.0057979459,
-0.0132884691,
-0.056073267,
-0.0831312612,
0.0798313767,
-0.0265471507,
0.049188707,
0.0071286941,
0.0136854658,
0.0077407435,
0.0490534678,
0.0509981178,
-0.004348923,
0.0092282277,
-0.017550569,
0.0162793491,
0.0554894619,
-0.0275874417,
-0.0615722276,
0.0063288724,
-0.000876835,
-0.0062629743,
0.0225282945,
-0.0235528182,
-0.0261659455,
-0.0793296993,
-0.044176396,
-0.0869112983,
0.0014883218,
0.0231144279,
-0.0419445299,
0.0098749716,
0.0161446668,
-0.031708207,
-0.0069407597,
-0.0483139306,
0.0066956016,
0.0173500869,
-0.0217687823,
-0.0230366774,
-0.0047517684,
-0.0182219427,
-0.072896339,
0.0195199922,
0.0054794378,
0.0317896008,
-0.0377697237,
-0.0196438823,
0.0053924592,
0.0413297005,
-0.0221917331,
0.0560646839,
-0.0183662847,
-0.0463927202,
-0.0016134386,
0.010202704,
0.0401597768,
0.0382982679,
0.0169210508,
0.057727132,
0.000765411,
-0.0501462929,
-0.0303714722,
0.045919057,
-0.0096181249,
0.0600122996,
-0.0272649191,
-0.039898023,
-0.0071260054,
0.0174231492,
0.0369768143,
0.0464537069,
-0.0501136892,
0.0022057104,
0.0481070727,
-0.0369448103,
0.0422852188,
-0.0415787324,
-0.0233420935,
-0.0207734425,
-0.000427343,
-0.0273369402,
0.0175979454,
0.0207162406,
-0.0573561788,
-0.0216860268,
-0.0273517966,
-0.0031714998,
0.041963201,
-0.0642830357,
-0.0007905949,
-0.0010097719,
0.0060981107,
-0.0213360153,
-0.0491679646,
-0.0041901781,
-0.0740137547,
0.0074150017,
-0.0075112944,
-0.0497509688,
0.0380934253,
-0.0171496794,
-0.0155519741,
-0.000677056,
-0.0478881449,
0.0155462017,
0.047320541,
-0.0216190629,
0.0268186778,
-0.0106889363,
0.0175389238,
-0.0099700093,
-0.0070944238,
0.0113848476,
0.0168385617,
0.0476562008,
0.0588154607,
0.0023447378,
0.0046235463,
-0.0094614672,
0.0816022754,
0.0298861377,
0.0805016533,
0.000801964,
-0.0207986366,
0.0445241816,
-0.0020293647,
0.0636099577,
-0.0171445888,
-0.018614471,
0.0383231714,
-0.0034035591,
0.0367456488,
0.1165786684,
-0.0167478099,
-0.0241716262,
0.0301482826,
-0.0156438053,
0.0224292371,
0.0181517433,
0.0050869407,
-0.0564380139,
-0.0130414953,
0.0428849421,
0.0412916355,
-0.0006839603,
-0.0227013249,
-0.0181688927,
-0.0788929686,
0.0430175476,
0.027935341,
-0.007281227,
-0.0192311667,
-0.0118343141,
0.0081759309,
-0.0033216213,
-0.0078956289,
-0.0355014801,
0.0127949147,
-0.0055522928,
0.0602751076,
-0.0469965525,
-0.0292889681,
0.0100645535,
-0.0225679185,
0.0932272673,
-0.0243775807,
0.0926756933,
0.0008501948,
0.0003532926,
0.0141435275,
0.0045888522,
-0.0137287676,
0.0065602744,
0.0303330477,
0.0059590279,
-0.0172419641,
-0.027610654,
0.0471642502,
-0.0035953317,
-0.0114871934,
-0.0110813081,
0.0179899056,
-0.0490919277,
-0.0126945125,
-0.0168326553,
0.0383806936,
0.0521970242,
0.0288721994,
0.0355876833,
-0.0539509244,
-0.0059174895,
-0.0304809194,
0.0591436997,
-0.0411191694,
-0.0056839688,
0.0137240794,
-0.0117075983,
-0.0150115173,
-0.0513437428,
-0.0309180636,
-0.0100802099,
0.033255484,
-0.045240961,
-0.0684323162,
0.0042852429,
-0.0068758582,
-0.0200695302,
-0.0040378529,
0.0199173726,
0.0197898392,
0.0048628752,
-0.0230998471,
0.0184012055,
-0.0397567898,
0.0009091068,
0.0399390869,
0.0194869917,
-0.064790301,
0.0308563001,
0.0234606974,
0.0189243685,
0.0606961995,
0.0220838878,
-0.0258976016,
0.0378981493,
0.0265939273,
0.0231475178,
0.0022558412,
0.094920367,
0.0561698899,
-0.0142950565,
0.0068139094,
-0.0594472177,
0.0637455061,
-0.0027656935,
0.0271833111,
0.008210687,
-0.0752335712,
-0.0310068205,
0.0014680399,
0.0154149709,
0.0208265707,
-0.0007822517,
-0.0364189669,
-0.0253099725,
-0.0431845039,
0.0106997006,
-0.0824027732,
-0.0291248355,
-0.0199190993,
0.0301175863,
-0.0134729408,
-0.0459011532,
-0.0059480197,
-0.0093051549,
0.0036187174,
0.0299719218,
0.0353340246,
-0.0309343021,
0.0045567071,
0.0236556809,
-0.0081630778,
0.0171143562,
0.0113258893,
-0.0089246072,
-0.0045072548,
0.0151808923,
0.0023246191,
-0.0571530946,
0.0084022991,
0.0251439083,
-0.0269359201,
0.0515605025,
-0.0284430422,
-0.0048698494,
0.0224771015,
-0.0040290831,
0.0748839527,
-0.0237979498,
0.0408922061,
-0.0247387085,
0.0411141366,
0.0026724932,
-0.0662773997,
0.0188987199,
-0.008937154,
-0.029783817,
0.0186459031,
0.0317534022,
-0.038228929,
0.073034659,
-0.0222688541,
0.0117228571,
-0.0460331254,
-0.0080515416,
0.0156570226,
-0.0176771954,
0.0336443223,
-0.009074606,
-0.0646095201,
-0.076356262,
0.0587237701,
-0.0235963408,
-0.0000359665,
-0.0501092449,
0.0433404185,
0.0107314996,
-0.0375593603,
0.0395927131,
-0.013445192,
0.0276421979,
-0.0526121482,
-0.0218798071,
0.0098432591,
-5.305358654e-33,
-0.0051607676,
0.0070828805,
-0.0488068722,
-0.0045855721,
-0.0728451684,
0.0326156728,
-0.0714232624,
0.0063020359,
-0.0273925513,
0.0565524101,
-0.0258843005,
0.0223973431,
0.0062494939,
0.0379695185,
-0.044188261,
0.005724276,
0.050812196,
0.0182815567,
0.0046744337,
0.0526174828,
0.0166007522,
0.0410950594,
0.043311812,
-0.1063048914,
-0.0108236177,
-0.0194495451,
-0.0396411493,
-0.0115314918,
0.1131455153,
0.0431914404,
0.0156212114,
0.0886900723,
-0.0153455948,
-0.0045663882,
-0.0176747926,
0.0039989469,
-0.0034277041,
-0.0093488162,
0.0000409456,
-0.002370212,
-0.0288367234,
-0.0128020281,
-0.0152947502,
0.0332328193,
-0.0183268115,
-0.0383327045,
0.0146111241,
-0.0282652322,
-0.0121516054,
-0.0998124257,
0.0019835201,
0.0257293824,
-0.0466172658,
-0.0552809574,
0.0231143981,
0.0852398798,
0.007031532,
-0.0334566385,
-0.0134425322,
0.0453183688,
-0.0365285054,
-0.0182425976,
0.0351129323,
0.0239136852,
0.026329102,
0.068584621,
0.0510478877,
0.0119496062,
0.0078278817,
0.0181384385,
0.0150999222,
0.070220992,
0.0006963462,
0.0383841023,
-0.0620540231,
-0.0349669941,
0.0285332259,
0.0185700152,
0.0555029884,
-0.0203068331,
-0.0012788837,
0.059580192,
-0.0072661163,
-0.0109259943,
-0.0220690984,
-0.0406136289,
0.0076213642,
0.0017270015,
-0.000558293,
-0.0229064897,
-0.0029719155,
-0.0140673285,
0.0069969236,
-0.0228970256,
0.0044338116,
0.0660901442,
-0.0781503916,
0.0556663051,
-0.0024614509,
-0.0087342747,
0.0199937169,
-0.0407977886,
0.0782837421,
0.0360532105,
0.0575037412,
0.0030914219,
-0.0378207043,
0.05906149,
-0.0291917156,
-0.0106867561,
-0.026063446,
0.0623055063,
-0.0282074492,
-0.0426398702,
-0.0112522775,
0.0147041334,
-0.0366254449,
0.0055353222,
0.0154524706,
0.0921835676,
0.0331697091,
-0.0140563576,
-0.0085696587,
0.0501663275,
-0.0808159262,
0.0156003963,
-0.0003846893,
-0.0499992073,
0.0399937406,
-0.0304169524,
-0.0292498246,
-0.0121953003,
2.754e-7,
-0.0624455139,
0.0056573958,
0.0417920388,
-0.0396552309,
0.0442546606,
0.0662444159,
-0.0044568428,
0.0209691934,
0.0496955812,
-0.052677121,
0.0370919928,
-0.0050539034,
0.077799134,
-0.0030483534,
-0.0687127933,
0.0050369217,
-0.048153162,
-0.0089138709,
-0.0056188246,
0.0543433577,
0.0544612221,
0.0610754229,
0.0420259647,
-0.0055943131,
0.0251909364,
0.0453121997,
0.0006463018,
-0.0396697633,
-0.0050327629,
-0.0065548536,
-0.032523796,
-0.0347744524,
-0.0020643144,
-0.0240552295,
-0.013735299,
-0.0057939063,
0.0172076467,
0.0479334034,
0.014457169,
-0.0726017281,
0.0444457345,
0.0313685387,
-0.0438986346,
0.0052696685,
0.0265042745,
-0.010155932,
-0.0302513633,
-0.0673339516,
-0.0464911275,
0.0015130461,
-0.0231397077,
-0.0346244946,
-0.054565195,
0.0108916927,
-0.011386768,
-0.0251628831,
-0.0181141272,
-0.0449045375,
-0.0166356172,
0.0147162722,
-0.0538082607,
-0.0512149334,
0.0040110424,
0.0482613854,
0.0326157473,
0.0079654949,
0.0074315015,
2.070569703e-34,
0.0320801884,
-0.0121882455,
-0.005807878,
0.0151368324,
0.0247066692,
-0.0005940789,
-0.0246905591,
-0.0014328471,
0.0593436845,
-0.0646127462,
-0.0220771991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11945v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11945v2 | Multi-Granularity Information Interaction Framework for Incomplete Utterance Rewriting | 2023-12-19T08:43:02 | 2024-01-08T12:45:29 | Haowei Du, Dinghao Zhang, Chen Li, Yang Li, Dongyan Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent approaches in Incomplete Utterance Rewriting (IUR) fail to capture the
source of important words, which is crucial to edit the incomplete utterance,
and introduce words from irrelevant utterances. We propose a novel and
effective multi-task information interaction framework including context
selection, edit matrix construction, and relevance merging to capture the
multi-granularity of semantic information. Benefiting from fetching the
relevant utterance and figuring out the important words, our approach
outperforms existing state-of-the-art models on two benchmark datasets
Restoration-200K and CANAND in this field. Code will be provided on
\url{https://github.com/yanmenxue/QR}. | [
0.0150786974,
0.0551765487,
0.0143204806,
0.0102294032,
-0.0361608192,
-0.0276838243,
-0.0586623587,
0.0292047914,
-0.0893611014,
-0.0564882755,
-0.0246813148,
-0.0173037276,
0.0578797609,
-0.0073093954,
0.0348770022,
-0.075740464,
0.0340466574,
0.0163051076,
-0.0090164468,
0.0140505405,
0.0165530164,
-0.000779922,
-0.011196889,
0.038596198,
-0.0294311959,
0.0436560661,
-0.0151140112,
0.0788171664,
0.016765913,
0.0446520671,
-0.0186263844,
0.0366854109,
0.0131092779,
0.027421236,
0.0000020759,
-0.0478235222,
-0.0746521875,
0.003724514,
-0.0210161302,
0.0000273898,
0.0185442921,
-0.0032285175,
-0.0262299944,
-0.0012439587,
-0.0173409451,
0.0088016689,
0.0963049158,
0.074514918,
0.0621479973,
0.0764390752,
-0.039445363,
0.0013505439,
0.0120462291,
-0.0261572581,
0.051637914,
-0.0307694152,
0.0540535077,
0.0259355437,
-0.0270616151,
-0.0141060688,
-0.0402539894,
0.0683543459,
-0.0359311216,
-0.0518430322,
-0.0022319143,
-0.0264971685,
-0.0021633229,
-0.0175004005,
-0.0087485714,
0.0436527841,
-0.0062916088,
0.0293079745,
0.0158904344,
0.0115611367,
0.0044062361,
-0.0316947252,
-0.0295121204,
-0.0463679396,
0.0148358271,
0.020360034,
-0.0533366017,
-0.0308661722,
-0.0050411294,
0.0065144184,
-0.0127869863,
0.018024018,
0.0454109162,
-0.0139090912,
-0.0568474196,
-0.0175603349,
0.015201536,
-0.0104994159,
0.0185761433,
0.0072802952,
-0.0513487309,
0.0041169664,
-0.0683850944,
-0.0223877914,
0.0057024825,
0.0392725244,
0.0083525144,
0.048050981,
-0.0146094868,
0.0270247366,
0.014963978,
0.0327573419,
0.0090785865,
-0.017495051,
-0.0370514244,
-0.0313589126,
-0.0317350514,
0.0093885027,
-0.0282425899,
0.0746381953,
-0.088597998,
0.0028266406,
-0.0659758598,
0.003103795,
-0.0129383337,
-0.0214311741,
-0.0153528834,
0.0092479764,
-0.0514288433,
-0.0340589918,
0.0223789029,
0.0225348826,
0.045735199,
0.0647865683,
0.0026341132,
-0.0301237702,
-0.0375988893,
-0.0021236364,
0.0475354418,
-0.0649884641,
-0.0193509199,
0.0053296178,
-0.0678969026,
-0.0362570845,
-0.0368886888,
-0.0472762063,
-0.0365912318,
-0.0294232816,
-0.0630357414,
-0.0418328531,
0.0523660779,
-0.0604026131,
-0.0199362971,
-0.0634126365,
-0.0055916081,
0.0008730114,
-0.0155311832,
0.0892321095,
-0.0152768278,
0.0287564322,
0.0274505299,
0.0266051404,
0.0207270496,
0.0117254714,
0.0156285726,
0.0042091222,
0.03570747,
0.0009014754,
0.0314440504,
0.0123403892,
-0.0021091911,
0.0025965853,
-0.0212160312,
-0.0162722021,
-0.0105598206,
0.024342183,
0.0773617625,
0.0622009374,
-0.0539537445,
0.0025772573,
0.0794726163,
0.0110739274,
0.0044693211,
0.0116450135,
0.0362147763,
0.0630302876,
-0.0292140748,
0.0502107665,
-0.0087365052,
0.0187883638,
-0.0131621985,
0.039378915,
0.0719120726,
-0.0017133752,
-0.0125980675,
-0.0301013887,
0.0423749387,
0.000017844,
0.0291718468,
-0.010267647,
0.0321493596,
0.0426876992,
-0.0840033367,
0.0053819739,
0.0084069856,
-0.0731200501,
0.0107680392,
-0.0501133204,
-0.0154101448,
0.0561382733,
0.0752222836,
-0.0668137074,
-0.0098386882,
-0.0141645372,
-0.0305183772,
0.0036968091,
-0.0098286709,
-0.0041229492,
0.0470185578,
-0.0733005852,
-0.014166818,
0.0033168218,
0.0239474513,
0.013392929,
0.009618043,
-0.0256959535,
0.0301369354,
0.0141881881,
0.0213057641,
0.0063917628,
0.0424846411,
0.0103873005,
0.0318569094,
0.010274577,
0.0085322997,
0.0332005993,
-0.0464628935,
-0.0096374685,
0.0358874202,
0.0051410627,
-0.0259952303,
-0.0095480559,
-0.0387248509,
-0.0695916116,
0.0269863065,
0.0113682337,
-0.0070136962,
0.016074216,
-0.0159484278,
-0.0955927372,
-0.0073411255,
-0.0144546172,
0.0408460684,
-0.0523775108,
0.0427687764,
0.0364328623,
0.0334159583,
-0.0612036586,
0.0038100479,
-0.0046872981,
-0.0031765192,
0.0472418405,
-0.0171996504,
-0.036215581,
-0.095581159,
-0.0234112572,
-0.0092469715,
-0.042506326,
0.0339362472,
-0.0011103641,
-0.0156258382,
-0.0255634636,
-0.0562654138,
-0.082654722,
-0.0054447409,
-0.0115397386,
0.0037187829,
0.0382679068,
0.0667457953,
0.0062966398,
-0.008810726,
0.027617069,
-0.0140112322,
0.0039106105,
0.0138248224,
0.0152235245,
0.0109707955,
-0.0167080034,
-0.0538640358,
0.0126870349,
0.0394093655,
0.0068146074,
-0.0300866365,
-0.0838981122,
-0.0286343656,
0.0305538569,
-0.0278264713,
-0.0026429319,
-0.021663513,
0.0053248908,
-0.038168326,
0.0156375896,
0.0720993802,
-0.0029680692,
-0.0127802733,
0.0200866368,
-0.0301288851,
-0.0649825484,
-0.0185291227,
0.0193369854,
-0.0053841816,
0.0018535551,
-0.0140396515,
-0.0282057039,
0.0046095382,
0.0168780591,
0.0549464487,
0.0281329323,
-0.0067435806,
-0.034550149,
0.0195375271,
-0.0307982098,
-0.0512814634,
-0.0462598987,
-0.0452791192,
0.009652189,
-0.0598483831,
-0.0288973078,
0.041959282,
-0.0357287489,
-0.0172506422,
-0.0255459007,
-0.0320967883,
-0.0024640223,
0.0536687486,
-0.043499928,
0.0241593625,
0.0074898447,
-0.0639717504,
-0.0797808096,
-0.033231616,
-0.0114132073,
-0.0342957303,
0.0839648396,
-0.0569826514,
0.0206877906,
-0.0051404932,
-0.0218366422,
0.0170205273,
-0.0311289243,
0.0303371977,
-0.0020933098,
0.0430505015,
-0.0551324822,
-0.0320455395,
0.0001446888,
0.0585283898,
0.0541253276,
0.0053420025,
0.0039565838,
-0.0242135897,
0.0768615007,
0.0239954926,
0.0552236326,
-0.0257475451,
-0.0112100476,
0.0322278552,
0.040298719,
0.0568975918,
-0.0404044464,
0.0271669235,
-0.0001924386,
0.0184067562,
0.0020172484,
-0.0116569307,
0.012559575,
0.0662746951,
-0.0286926795,
0.0237126816,
0.0649082661,
-0.0157708265,
-0.0166774374,
-0.0169673488,
0.0046104514,
0.0052746837,
0.0138073489,
0.0035003428,
-0.0891722888,
-0.0407308042,
0.0621636063,
0.0146428188,
0.0235622972,
-0.0121809356,
-0.0153546641,
-0.04151823,
0.0850083902,
0.0072189472,
-0.0462322831,
-0.0424223542,
-0.0247636717,
0.0385006629,
-0.0177557226,
0.0153719373,
0.0402915552,
-0.0029074105,
-0.0140706422,
-0.0135246851,
0.0257020537,
-0.0511535965,
-0.0165070817,
-0.0008698896,
0.0720608979,
0.0336392932,
0.05496829,
0.0113827474,
0.043984931,
0.0332681276,
-0.0126132211,
-0.0216126423,
-0.0093414672,
0.0889527127,
0.0162584875,
0.010266521,
-0.0068764579,
0.0338640474,
0.0059914584,
-0.0564388447,
-0.0093253227,
0.0145387258,
-0.0240147896,
0.043514315,
0.033389885,
-0.0247472748,
0.0502327122,
0.0651275069,
0.0328861475,
-0.0021905701,
-0.0085264007,
0.0043982551,
-0.0125964154,
-0.0625821799,
0.0143268155,
-0.021352008,
-0.0273251105,
-0.0225495975,
-0.0765797943,
-0.0267219245,
0.0481953248,
0.0343990438,
0.0098126754,
0.0492881313,
0.006650825,
-0.0059069139,
-0.0382591635,
-0.0261267163,
-0.0428299457,
0.0441828854,
-0.0241545681,
-0.007591777,
-0.0033576412,
-0.0695349276,
-0.0030310673,
0.0118916575,
-0.0231897607,
-0.0432402082,
0.0139136715,
0.0058903019,
0.0320431963,
0.0413263254,
0.0007616033,
-0.0240816623,
0.0172556303,
0.0138014052,
-0.035165377,
0.0671725124,
0.0299140923,
-0.0040140962,
-0.0327565633,
0.0415857956,
-0.0434961095,
0.0022561438,
0.0040505831,
0.0697521716,
-0.0172611568,
-0.0848888755,
0.0264121983,
0.0297869407,
0.0006269741,
0.0130465506,
0.0206086598,
-0.067921564,
0.0281984322,
-0.0001050783,
-0.0001892574,
-0.0674291551,
0.0185873359,
0.0287220012,
0.0109868664,
0.0120301349,
-0.0039190059,
-0.0292287041,
0.0151968282,
-0.0501684323,
-0.0468499623,
-0.0371397436,
-0.0159628764,
0.0472199731,
0.0298919473,
0.023080118,
0.0628102645,
-0.0024574541,
0.0119739668,
0.0043593226,
0.0171134695,
-0.0003272566,
-0.0142255556,
-0.0417979769,
0.0445204265,
-0.0444101989,
0.0301810317,
-0.0458139367,
0.0144859105,
0.0448037796,
0.0187421758,
0.0858571306,
0.0040263636,
-0.0188995358,
-0.0297993366,
0.052927129,
0.0126865376,
0.0031792799,
0.0117587401,
0.0000783096,
-0.0233060159,
0.0716930702,
0.0802017376,
-0.0634134337,
0.0492342748,
-0.0171016995,
-0.0086441552,
-0.0382889472,
-0.0863719955,
-0.0047513726,
0.0461980626,
-0.0390574858,
-0.0401172526,
-0.0145289702,
-0.0326620676,
-0.0045360457,
-0.013050708,
-0.0274410583,
-0.0089473333,
0.009231898,
0.0150530189,
0.0024063948,
0.0333617814,
-0.0179355871,
-0.0474572331,
0.0226798989,
-0.0350209922,
-0.0123807937,
-6.07648809e-33,
-0.0444754921,
0.0145984795,
0.0185485389,
0.0115585132,
-0.0542029068,
0.0465646796,
-0.0371501409,
0.0129372021,
0.0040277094,
0.0018630427,
-0.0092502106,
0.0152004818,
0.0232908446,
0.0350606255,
-0.0345039666,
0.0441535562,
0.06860286,
0.0302731488,
0.0005549301,
0.011569404,
0.0335512199,
0.0453475937,
0.055165682,
-0.0497215129,
0.005032382,
0.0338112414,
-0.0660953224,
0.0336864479,
0.0191921275,
0.0224396363,
-0.0096409498,
0.029620843,
0.0165792201,
-0.0452021472,
-0.0650287271,
0.0219095889,
-0.0794093236,
0.0343002826,
0.0444389395,
-0.0041722441,
-0.0320850611,
-0.0201695561,
0.0322721638,
-0.0122455964,
0.0156879686,
0.0063323756,
0.0086179012,
-0.0250470955,
-0.0145668248,
-0.004584115,
-0.0527120903,
0.0393940285,
-0.0016558756,
-0.0604836941,
0.0229276605,
-0.010528069,
0.0110618453,
-0.0357240662,
-0.0714919716,
0.007002742,
-0.0186228361,
0.0607739538,
-0.0099811824,
0.0395508856,
-0.0203847792,
0.0493087135,
0.027871158,
-0.0162030887,
0.0203326605,
-0.0553925708,
-0.0421396419,
0.0593082644,
-0.0108760558,
0.0490992218,
-0.0175382737,
-0.0083677741,
-0.020939311,
0.0220083613,
-0.0423593037,
0.0286478493,
0.0030887132,
0.0835145414,
0.0057527721,
-0.0002025047,
-0.0363019332,
0.055208277,
-0.0387826264,
-0.0006252326,
0.0324302986,
0.0419181511,
-0.0090622995,
0.0349525996,
0.0554027259,
-0.0018476074,
0.0227177218,
-0.0110058188,
-0.0602110662,
0.0426094495,
-0.0190547276,
-0.0402970016,
0.0073041879,
-0.0056146216,
0.0788552687,
0.0294854604,
-0.0221389569,
-0.0175097659,
0.0134648215,
0.058850877,
-0.0525140427,
0.0002061766,
-0.0173269659,
0.0197017994,
-0.0220282432,
-0.0292745903,
-0.0018408915,
0.035180293,
-0.0053998507,
0.0113964733,
0.0307499245,
0.0321237668,
0.0158973187,
-0.039694313,
0.0126488982,
-0.0049837101,
-0.0230462737,
0.0305902213,
0.0242822394,
-0.0520165637,
0.0324217826,
-0.003178928,
-0.0226046108,
0.0096549857,
2.919e-7,
0.0313326679,
-0.003451908,
0.0580477044,
-0.0432358347,
-0.0038126297,
0.0175727252,
0.0016616975,
0.002705086,
-0.0075632571,
0.0111187305,
0.0651771575,
-0.0078985235,
0.0663427562,
-0.0346348844,
-0.0819610953,
0.0145767154,
-0.0423943549,
-0.0444847532,
-0.0368997194,
-0.0102140903,
0.0229448639,
0.0642417893,
0.0035390158,
-0.0249481164,
-0.0101848776,
-0.0339744538,
0.0286358297,
-0.0321052894,
-0.020918699,
0.03758201,
0.0390648283,
0.009666237,
0.0213709939,
0.0153288702,
-0.0195682496,
0.0035606464,
0.0471628048,
0.0509549044,
-0.0339764841,
-0.0122490954,
-0.0060477084,
0.0098817395,
-0.0110398633,
-0.0190940555,
0.0368114449,
-0.0185384545,
0.009727234,
0.0257211085,
-0.0491091684,
0.0505831093,
0.0033993081,
-0.0088563813,
-0.0115132509,
-0.0019105175,
0.0115251867,
0.0708473846,
-0.0639401972,
-0.0430035964,
-0.0187838562,
0.0257903691,
-0.0412481464,
-0.0284355804,
-0.0167153981,
-0.0747190714,
0.0133721279,
-0.1078232229,
-0.0129975006,
2.746340972e-34,
0.0187990572,
0.0116055934,
0.0272982474,
0.0491099916,
0.0237976126,
-0.0145117259,
-0.0456181876,
0.0227705892,
-0.0375986174,
-0.0850655064,
-0.0479329452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11922v1 | Relation-Aware Question Answering for Heterogeneous Knowledge Graphs | 2023-12-19T08:01:48 | 2023-12-19T08:01:48 | Haowei Du, Quzhe Huang, Chen Li, Chen Zhang, Yang Li, Dongyan Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Multi-hop Knowledge Base Question Answering(KBQA) aims to find the answer
entity in a knowledge graph (KG), which requires multiple steps of reasoning.
Existing retrieval-based approaches solve this task by concentrating on the
specific relation at different hops and predicting the intermediate entity
within the reasoning path. During the reasoning process of these methods, the
representation of relations are fixed but the initial relation representation
may not be optimal. We claim they fail to utilize information from head-tail
entities and the semantic connection between relations to enhance the current
relation representation, which undermines the ability to capture information of
relations in KGs. To address this issue, we construct a \textbf{dual relation
graph} where each node denotes a relation in the original KG (\textbf{primal
entity graph}) and edges are constructed between relations sharing same head or
tail entities. Then we iteratively do primal entity graph reasoning, dual
relation graph information propagation, and interaction between these two
graphs. In this way, the interaction between entity and relation is enhanced,
and we derive better entity and relation representations. Experiments on two
public datasets, WebQSP and CWQ, show that our approach achieves a significant
performance gain over the prior state-of-the-art. Our code is available on
\url{https://github.com/yanmenxue/RAH-KBQA}. | [
0.0417230725,
-0.0064647696,
0.0005837718,
0.0713432282,
-0.0245957319,
0.0009185941,
-0.034521576,
-0.0006963634,
0.0605307892,
-0.0435381271,
-0.0221255813,
-0.0054148519,
-0.0476770476,
-0.0033873157,
-0.005476499,
-0.0069053676,
0.0309192203,
0.0112656057,
0.0235059038,
-0.0189279448,
-0.0018597133,
0.0641189665,
-0.0340243727,
0.0091048023,
-0.0454540551,
-0.0337123945,
0.0062467172,
0.0228611529,
0.0377163999,
-0.0083203344,
0.0219842643,
0.0168258473,
0.0229373649,
-0.0179533977,
0.0000019893,
-0.0320331268,
-0.0251110028,
0.0190218985,
-0.0415932015,
-0.0347872227,
-0.0774035081,
-0.0159151535,
0.0471319593,
0.0049084481,
-0.0503868945,
-0.0088551389,
-0.0016297367,
0.0657719523,
0.0281267874,
0.0405489057,
-0.0120532829,
-0.0594206676,
-0.0113678025,
0.0237494651,
0.0325889625,
-0.0458441488,
0.0367814489,
0.0226649437,
0.0031770419,
0.014125783,
-0.0288495664,
0.0089658257,
0.0223950725,
0.0296609979,
0.0371222422,
0.0329272188,
-0.0073957583,
0.034111049,
0.0020825025,
0.1146667153,
0.0474370196,
-0.0027992607,
0.0183132272,
0.0337472409,
-0.0171253663,
0.0154587487,
-0.0193403624,
-0.0236790758,
-0.0471663624,
-0.0276703276,
-0.0396710001,
-0.0167664941,
0.0325496048,
0.0135728801,
-0.0292457025,
0.0902324617,
0.0040468648,
-0.0095684836,
0.014255547,
0.0269203652,
-0.0238459855,
0.0001893725,
0.0289443843,
0.0558343381,
-0.0445233472,
0.0456051752,
0.0082054073,
0.0040827114,
0.0035038544,
-0.0449385606,
-0.0376801118,
0.050580062,
0.022767175,
0.0734768212,
-0.0500138514,
-0.0013441809,
-0.0321635902,
-0.0020379673,
-0.0198960379,
-0.0512493588,
-0.0622048229,
-0.0315246433,
-0.0609734282,
0.0652318373,
-0.0339473039,
-0.025853822,
-0.0291602798,
0.023114875,
-0.0189705472,
-0.0349554121,
0.0391492359,
0.0572050959,
0.0080711804,
0.0044833948,
-0.0356957652,
0.0679929256,
-0.0896880254,
0.0109242871,
-0.019409012,
-0.0019629907,
-0.0070903306,
-0.0101549393,
0.0382890888,
-0.0409704261,
-0.0026521767,
0.090621464,
0.0277133826,
0.0166474245,
-0.0259450711,
-0.0767965391,
0.0103486888,
-0.0366066024,
0.0070898547,
-0.049962502,
0.0703077763,
0.0374829061,
-0.0257797111,
-0.0142243356,
0.0289983246,
-0.0006963394,
-0.0645380691,
0.0508964919,
-0.02357045,
-0.0195814557,
0.0069182087,
0.0348928832,
-0.0239254124,
0.0737498328,
0.0203602761,
-0.030805653,
0.0334030911,
0.0303322412,
-0.0631750375,
-0.0016899944,
0.0708663985,
0.0106478557,
0.0540955923,
0.0476171151,
-0.0239568762,
0.0193518661,
0.0309289154,
0.0361324064,
-0.0246488377,
-0.0408825055,
-0.0231880452,
0.0124490475,
-0.0053263325,
0.0217722505,
0.0293374434,
0.012627217,
-0.0109819649,
0.0096689761,
-0.0381587744,
0.0329052471,
-0.0395346805,
-0.0046622893,
-0.0244687404,
0.0320793949,
-0.0256753024,
0.0136636412,
0.0168704279,
0.0263068508,
-0.0086108539,
0.0454284623,
0.0473598503,
-0.0013238568,
-0.0460747071,
0.0888886154,
0.0273029972,
0.0087181581,
0.0060974699,
0.0113621065,
-0.0061175427,
0.0621425658,
0.0320948213,
-0.0201516002,
-0.0344475247,
0.0170428455,
-0.021626126,
-0.0309416,
0.0061246525,
-0.0311907865,
0.0245855544,
-0.0237591472,
-0.044998318,
0.0135282101,
-0.0253206491,
0.0032958006,
0.0394377932,
0.0270290878,
0.0227606054,
-0.0551581457,
0.063636668,
-0.0090953652,
0.0107728671,
0.0439788885,
0.0173532888,
0.0329869129,
-0.013882597,
0.0616949461,
0.0283472966,
0.0334841572,
0.0322382636,
-0.0196867418,
-0.056289997,
-0.016783366,
-0.0281940717,
-0.0827042237,
0.0537283905,
-0.0325615406,
-0.01707015,
-0.0217130668,
-0.0250849761,
-0.0389703624,
0.0240689032,
-0.018537771,
0.0502774902,
0.0013691332,
-0.0567310229,
0.0574977845,
-0.0351228975,
-0.0415726975,
0.0804467425,
0.0036215484,
0.0183853079,
-0.0016089866,
-0.0301365778,
0.0162176453,
-0.0136154033,
0.0135688186,
-0.0195390172,
0.0058949152,
-0.0034011879,
0.0038418025,
-0.0424676649,
-0.0738457739,
0.0420816056,
-0.0801762789,
0.0115242749,
0.0074849911,
0.0282847136,
0.0230117943,
0.0215435531,
0.0183975305,
-0.0263926685,
-0.0323375128,
0.0322137773,
-0.010270494,
0.0123364842,
0.0287091341,
0.0224682279,
-0.0075233178,
0.0030095584,
-0.0436480679,
-0.0443521217,
0.0642115325,
-0.0095636947,
-0.0144895921,
-0.0063568763,
-0.015727086,
-0.0865430012,
0.0181170814,
0.0019529862,
0.0053004501,
-0.0022450688,
-0.0142026786,
0.0374322049,
0.0034982534,
-0.0224853493,
0.0057430258,
0.005788432,
-0.0053953468,
-0.0504444838,
0.029242631,
-0.0235237237,
0.0562507249,
-0.0140267834,
-0.0159447994,
-0.0317787081,
0.0100960368,
0.0215928201,
-0.0352791548,
-0.0403719023,
0.0173557866,
0.0330526493,
0.0143059613,
-0.057443779,
0.0115091158,
0.0460647233,
-0.0091743916,
-0.0294875689,
0.0435522757,
0.0932071656,
0.0395896211,
0.0173039772,
-0.0005946194,
0.0190498922,
-0.0449790172,
0.0771836266,
-0.0394222699,
0.0337578245,
-0.0179700106,
-0.0247795954,
-0.0499021038,
-0.0074393321,
0.0344426595,
-0.0205121469,
0.0121984873,
0.0018181704,
0.0462222174,
-0.0045410013,
-0.0151448008,
-0.0174534731,
0.0266498625,
-0.0270984974,
0.0300852694,
-0.00946288,
0.0015614028,
0.0310973022,
0.0068563288,
0.0248581246,
-0.0437091291,
-0.0063539241,
-0.002838745,
-0.0065399045,
0.0638759658,
0.0630420968,
0.0104718478,
0.0366825797,
0.0305963363,
0.0136911562,
0.060676977,
0.0287254862,
-0.043080572,
0.0189395677,
-0.0151091265,
-0.0007332675,
-0.0459059589,
-0.0021862066,
-0.0277171191,
0.046605669,
-0.0536918864,
0.0104422364,
0.0686957613,
0.0287972167,
0.0076916264,
0.0003134116,
0.0108985649,
0.036323756,
0.0262013786,
0.0401742123,
-0.1286188513,
-0.0344575569,
-0.017868422,
0.0046641221,
0.0264141895,
-0.0805048719,
0.0157643929,
-0.0574356057,
-0.0126793506,
-0.0150237838,
-0.0473930947,
-0.0654672384,
-0.039243497,
0.0087860869,
0.0036098266,
-0.0396133028,
0.0082978904,
-0.0181227457,
0.0102612758,
-0.0120158754,
0.0356670693,
0.00673314,
0.0414972082,
-0.0320857316,
-0.0172560867,
0.0065658991,
0.0164374914,
0.0301451534,
-0.0006608104,
-0.0189084839,
-0.0436856188,
-0.0089253075,
-0.0393487476,
0.0133392923,
-0.0268159304,
-0.0145997163,
-0.0622551478,
0.0104643479,
-0.0784329623,
0.0080672363,
0.005377267,
0.0914478749,
-0.0089092236,
-0.0274834093,
-0.0193929784,
-0.0210535713,
0.0173717644,
0.0714425817,
0.0061625638,
0.025817655,
-0.0671179742,
-0.02313428,
0.0138322553,
-0.037891008,
-0.0185940955,
0.0275625065,
-0.0171192121,
0.0360794514,
-0.0593810678,
-0.0576485731,
0.0580064319,
0.0383684151,
-0.0305148512,
0.0091499463,
0.0219541155,
0.0132486708,
-0.0705285668,
0.0077041481,
-0.0354934521,
0.0329789333,
0.0005168898,
0.0032671085,
0.0077647804,
-0.005317111,
-0.0334444866,
-0.0252733547,
-0.0335639268,
-0.032226827,
-0.0592561029,
0.0133775612,
0.0072477143,
0.0396681875,
-0.0174679216,
0.0050895307,
0.0170748066,
0.0076449467,
-0.0684106499,
-0.0244910885,
0.0162204672,
0.0014806901,
-0.0196933076,
0.057970129,
-0.0804510787,
-0.0203138329,
-0.0070830709,
0.115488261,
-0.0383344665,
-0.0236271769,
0.0196435135,
0.0111292237,
-0.019190697,
0.0431899205,
0.0142318783,
-0.0248185396,
0.0238900203,
-0.0243226662,
-0.0337449759,
-0.0257132836,
0.0217936896,
-0.0347751826,
-0.050873559,
0.0068090521,
-0.0203266907,
0.0238410197,
0.0255612675,
-0.0198302381,
-0.0295231733,
0.0492067374,
-0.0336891562,
0.0516618006,
-0.0255992152,
-0.021741882,
0.0141054587,
0.0306345243,
0.0189061202,
-0.0119686816,
0.0348952971,
0.037811745,
-0.046571698,
-0.0490679853,
-0.0295122284,
-0.0677725449,
-0.0237536356,
0.0073442911,
0.0108626131,
0.0619747788,
0.0323740877,
0.0119064366,
0.0056461869,
-0.0282814484,
0.0084431348,
0.0349569507,
0.0173172671,
-0.012862578,
0.0604445077,
0.0382039994,
0.0053003193,
0.0182007682,
0.069871515,
-0.0253603905,
0.0519393533,
-0.0083012693,
-0.0475640073,
-0.0213629212,
-0.0598631576,
-0.0121570956,
0.0162509866,
-0.0201431941,
0.0239497554,
-0.0420382544,
-0.0762128234,
-0.0135016907,
-0.033012446,
-0.0553781316,
-0.0136237163,
0.0328031853,
0.0144498907,
0.0703477785,
-0.0715966299,
-0.009762018,
0.0201395974,
-0.0787281021,
-0.0063946387,
0.0139981583,
-6.040821388e-33,
-0.0214439575,
-0.0427999869,
0.0271205176,
-0.0487260111,
-0.0383113176,
0.0179553609,
-0.0293892398,
-0.0233245492,
-0.0620697178,
0.024702942,
0.0015184473,
0.0175998937,
-0.0104895923,
0.0238920059,
-0.0178101901,
-0.0349214189,
-0.0065493062,
0.0231126118,
0.0160261206,
0.0101733869,
0.0328788869,
0.0530057885,
0.05506365,
-0.020401964,
0.0140812183,
-0.0253820326,
0.0151186204,
0.0458410904,
-0.0141099961,
0.0525024198,
-0.0077359653,
0.0380090922,
0.0259297956,
-0.0072681876,
0.0212896671,
-0.0030016704,
-0.1571060866,
-0.036062628,
0.0062746881,
0.0065632858,
-0.0582359657,
-0.0030367442,
0.0361305326,
0.0155631956,
0.0887173638,
-0.0590218343,
0.0306492951,
-0.0022608782,
-0.0227607079,
-0.0581019036,
-0.0131866205,
0.0098131672,
-0.0079417033,
0.0080856485,
-0.042420622,
0.0552102365,
0.0253765322,
-0.0247391388,
-0.080295153,
-0.0149402972,
-0.0402279757,
-0.0152646117,
-0.0054872963,
0.0164220519,
0.0097289495,
0.0248338785,
0.0020249067,
-0.0354095288,
-0.044323381,
-0.0031321726,
-0.0366235375,
0.0240573734,
-0.0158846639,
0.0126469107,
-0.0007528582,
0.006543552,
-0.1213832274,
0.0025770909,
0.0271867309,
0.0402013958,
-0.0189007111,
-0.0040115267,
-0.0330037586,
-0.0394297019,
-0.0164372921,
0.0394465849,
-0.031301111,
-0.0369500592,
0.0039288425,
-0.0177492946,
-0.0268810727,
0.0356313027,
-0.0037273664,
-0.0641135871,
-0.0177070685,
0.0883339196,
0.0017820355,
0.0014490465,
0.0277976952,
0.0466149338,
-0.020000143,
0.0183882862,
0.0204633549,
-0.0500886105,
-0.0102382591,
0.0469150729,
0.023489004,
-0.0266083274,
-0.0220080558,
-0.0047377362,
-0.0420130529,
-0.0145379268,
-0.0410861857,
-0.0278521646,
0.0160826016,
0.0626499578,
0.0113780107,
0.0421269797,
0.0323603414,
0.0563223399,
0.0120943002,
0.061372485,
0.0032115986,
0.0371175967,
0.0014301654,
-0.0073838886,
-0.0104343155,
0.0148604587,
-0.0378889777,
-0.0565376021,
-0.0302061029,
0.0260702763,
2.669e-7,
0.0463405512,
-0.0187258013,
0.0448749214,
0.0666108951,
0.0009341928,
0.0106821163,
0.0442382023,
0.0389928408,
0.0067969314,
-0.0691670105,
0.0050324639,
0.0621817335,
-0.0340151824,
0.0363188572,
-0.0593222603,
-0.0528686009,
-0.0170285478,
-0.0535827801,
-0.0540343001,
0.0124908695,
0.0742702484,
0.0193619877,
0.0211561918,
0.0085900677,
-0.0285943057,
0.0213901605,
0.057272613,
0.0250736065,
0.0301793776,
-0.0017428114,
-0.0082791196,
-0.0229287054,
0.0099907722,
0.0369887687,
-0.0118403919,
0.0351343118,
0.0068131182,
0.0399144515,
-0.0242045075,
-0.0376559906,
-0.0123909181,
-0.0517468117,
0.0434181914,
-0.0053576133,
0.0878483802,
-0.0249216948,
-0.0162923578,
0.0343416706,
-0.0390038863,
-0.0109649068,
-0.0340139493,
0.0048226304,
0.0043013883,
0.0121523794,
0.0231032055,
-0.0202556532,
0.0106446594,
-0.0932699889,
0.0144975996,
0.0457543693,
-0.0002882103,
-0.004322031,
0.0296928976,
-0.0351533704,
0.024736898,
-0.0268030688,
0.000850516,
2.13848894e-34,
-0.0023407617,
0.0178277213,
0.0151517168,
0.0360878073,
0.0526212044,
-0.0574999563,
-0.0407705866,
-0.0318603255,
0.0470452532,
-0.0782344863,
-0.0153002786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11920v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11920v1 | External Knowledge Augmented Polyphone Disambiguation Using Large Language Model | 2023-12-19T08:00:10 | 2023-12-19T08:00:10 | Chen Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | One of the key issues in Mandarin Chinese text-to-speech (TTS) systems is
polyphone disambiguation when doing grapheme-to-phoneme (G2P) conversion. In
this paper, we introduce a novel method to solve the problem as a generation
task. Following the trending research of large language models (LLM) and prompt
learning, the proposed method consists of three modules. Retrieval module
incorporates external knowledge which is a multi-level semantic dictionary of
Chinese polyphonic characters to format the sentence into a prompt. Generation
module adopts the decoder-only Transformer architecture to induce the target
text. Postprocess module corrects the generated text into a valid result if
needed. Experimental results show that our method outperforms the existing
methods on a public dataset called CPP. We also empirically study the impacts
of different templates of the prompt, different sizes of training data, and
whether to incorporate external knowledge. | [
0.0332180671,
-0.0038770805,
-0.0016229664,
0.0019819774,
-0.0046335938,
-0.0243175644,
0.0170982257,
-0.0057256673,
0.0184252746,
-0.0351798199,
-0.03105551,
-0.0162229296,
0.0194160696,
-0.0033218639,
0.0070143384,
-0.0638093129,
0.058755476,
-0.0485266708,
-0.0290389974,
-0.0197423119,
-0.0009516745,
0.0338527635,
0.0076977415,
0.0126453079,
-0.0405371971,
-0.0123904841,
0.0076040137,
0.0552990139,
-0.0083401063,
0.0017322387,
-0.0440170616,
0.0039304416,
0.0105857709,
0.0783425868,
0.0000017304,
-0.0958852172,
-0.0904273763,
0.0116263414,
-0.0552724563,
-0.000092031,
0.0218100734,
0.0203670543,
-0.0245883372,
0.0522459745,
0.0202422012,
-0.0128926532,
0.059901733,
0.0422551222,
0.0465732031,
0.0337411202,
-0.0169298947,
-0.063077569,
0.033807911,
0.0182880238,
-0.0217982773,
-0.0186027456,
0.015021788,
0.0091549959,
0.0011368986,
-0.0216990337,
-0.0206327606,
0.0409238487,
-0.0171624403,
0.0026920997,
-0.0069172313,
0.0000591491,
-0.0096658096,
-0.037336234,
-0.0313895382,
0.0594956987,
0.0049667014,
-0.0257724877,
0.0125294058,
0.0105640143,
0.0014223822,
0.0295648687,
0.0038540622,
0.0101716164,
-0.0414950959,
0.0055942317,
0.003290168,
0.0015570135,
0.0266913194,
-0.0315481275,
-0.0539824516,
-0.0007298819,
0.044781968,
-0.042908147,
0.0293628685,
0.0001410493,
-0.008692205,
0.0076468382,
0.0431435183,
0.0070169126,
-0.0355773494,
0.0401288643,
0.016476199,
-0.0190287046,
-0.0140878186,
-0.0186761674,
-0.0047629513,
0.0196976624,
-0.0177624077,
0.0039546769,
-0.0463996567,
0.0196304359,
-0.0144844735,
-0.0124963149,
-0.0552669838,
-0.0442048758,
-0.065947406,
-0.0134958439,
-0.1012306437,
0.049019102,
-0.0031111368,
-0.0174115729,
-0.0286472049,
-0.0030597767,
-0.0009048324,
0.024292564,
0.0455000922,
-0.0182565395,
-0.0500733182,
-0.0023792353,
-0.0160311684,
0.0794041678,
0.0067016664,
-0.0035306632,
-0.0649765581,
-0.0622118488,
0.0234098453,
-0.0009068682,
0.025365619,
-0.0089925416,
-0.0037146606,
0.0484221205,
-0.0317239277,
-0.02872191,
-0.0309579782,
-0.0230886824,
-0.0337097086,
-0.0066960966,
-0.0451627634,
-0.08626993,
0.0027808901,
-0.0137858577,
0.023341259,
-0.0310825445,
0.0357971713,
0.0081176795,
0.0025269156,
0.0576136783,
-0.0399513356,
0.0410154127,
0.0616515391,
-0.015106705,
0.0226621926,
0.0472388417,
0.0639689267,
-0.0002097451,
0.0650471747,
0.0002503317,
-0.0059068929,
0.0862396657,
-0.0125932079,
-0.0268653128,
0.0039851703,
-0.0209214278,
0.0323330089,
0.0087757884,
0.0016217941,
0.115810886,
-0.0118892342,
0.0309678782,
0.0314993113,
0.0000992171,
0.0373917297,
-0.0250159614,
0.0419708118,
0.0310087036,
-0.0050585964,
0.021910565,
0.0229308158,
-0.0585893691,
-0.0244879164,
0.0421873964,
0.0221026894,
0.0259814002,
-0.0173691716,
-0.0172597859,
-0.0013927437,
-0.0522074625,
0.0074490821,
0.0292427856,
0.0700194985,
0.0451292098,
-0.0490811728,
0.0853650421,
0.0183464717,
-0.0359692052,
0.0295869261,
-0.045496285,
0.0095309289,
0.0791468173,
0.0046027768,
-0.0113379313,
-0.0176769197,
-0.0375158414,
-0.0541306809,
0.0634046718,
-0.0094640665,
-0.0580260828,
-0.0178970397,
-0.074759081,
0.0057179709,
0.0852541924,
-0.0145332208,
0.0094987312,
0.0219728034,
-0.0121287275,
0.0447585993,
-0.0317640416,
-0.0121462746,
0.0078535238,
-0.058210846,
-0.036874067,
0.0018007503,
0.0203942843,
-0.0106310463,
0.0586975813,
-0.0537282266,
0.0128425462,
0.0034118765,
-0.0338814817,
0.0222594906,
0.0100135691,
-0.0419847555,
-0.0618056022,
0.0376068391,
-0.0133115491,
-0.0197320711,
-0.0061850348,
-0.002682569,
-0.1085462421,
-0.0510340333,
-0.0294514559,
0.0657393187,
-0.052002348,
0.0468010642,
0.0070275832,
0.0165793747,
-0.0355022326,
0.0131008914,
0.0490666181,
-0.0000148124,
0.0330299996,
0.0614108592,
0.0256750304,
-0.0678074062,
-0.0565518886,
0.041087579,
0.0080551524,
0.0176024865,
0.041617617,
0.0105923377,
-0.0345526189,
-0.044999674,
-0.0876689926,
0.0187056754,
-0.0151506392,
-0.0101032332,
0.01952013,
0.058368437,
-0.0028560958,
-0.0319473632,
-0.0040432522,
-0.0265738498,
0.0242919587,
-0.0101204254,
-0.0112927807,
-0.0167277288,
-0.0383493155,
-0.0047101681,
0.0069699939,
0.0059158648,
0.0326006897,
0.0043484345,
-0.0697616637,
-0.0459827483,
0.062017601,
-0.017004557,
0.0161001757,
0.0319742374,
-0.0014590311,
0.010101079,
-0.0064275335,
0.1008746326,
-0.0124993417,
0.0059907571,
-0.0226214752,
0.015953768,
-0.0224584192,
-0.0582688004,
-0.0009962679,
-0.0233699679,
-0.0715584978,
-0.0350793675,
-0.0332718045,
-0.013875844,
0.0496742241,
0.0427269787,
-0.0034441082,
-0.0327540152,
-0.0665243119,
-0.0438482538,
-0.016142251,
-0.0148057695,
-0.0046526711,
-0.0681827366,
0.0020383352,
-0.0274910592,
-0.0252950378,
0.0417202227,
-0.0638647452,
-0.0106063923,
-0.0624663755,
-0.0129096303,
-0.0275852513,
0.0576410741,
-0.0135036707,
0.033415474,
0.0145381093,
-0.0663451254,
-0.0621013194,
0.0126953181,
0.0084562879,
-0.0633667707,
0.0370519161,
-0.0311416853,
0.0275301058,
-0.0012805368,
0.0001151221,
-0.0486716814,
-0.0050133518,
-0.0127974721,
0.0565904528,
0.0419056416,
0.0080240751,
0.0556587279,
0.0368435271,
0.0357216597,
0.0239811912,
0.0392527245,
0.0014241226,
-0.0066268868,
0.0606783666,
0.0395833887,
0.0227325782,
-0.0092076361,
-0.0520012081,
0.0693348944,
-0.0036798895,
0.0169788729,
-0.0050676037,
-0.0076009119,
-0.0316523984,
0.0261888634,
-0.0208429061,
-0.0491046682,
0.0337939598,
0.045355875,
-0.0180295892,
-0.0025780876,
0.134791255,
0.0260263663,
-0.035488084,
-0.0231999904,
0.0355161391,
-0.0074703842,
-0.0019055597,
0.0043093795,
-0.0892394856,
-0.019044932,
0.0321797766,
0.0184435956,
-0.0010456383,
0.0070911516,
-0.0105162431,
-0.1572049856,
0.034118671,
0.0071410765,
0.0008746016,
-0.0090107759,
-0.0330759659,
-0.0052623111,
0.0300204307,
0.0054959031,
-0.0077264127,
-0.0218321849,
-0.0124992821,
0.0217194837,
-0.0406838544,
-0.0434806906,
-0.0205534138,
-0.0490449741,
0.0611516833,
0.0680202618,
0.0157295894,
-0.0147014828,
0.0322162993,
0.0064080739,
-0.0059495913,
-0.0140454406,
0.0010703072,
0.0039077345,
0.0255412031,
-0.0069343355,
-0.0131286085,
0.0011478219,
-0.0186135732,
0.0010388624,
0.0102313757,
0.056340117,
0.0069327145,
0.0243330207,
0.0328519791,
0.0257801376,
0.0123145198,
0.0753771439,
-0.0208334643,
-0.0356891453,
-0.0126043726,
-0.0197248217,
0.0066427211,
-0.0311472137,
-0.0147839747,
0.0631294027,
-0.0635826364,
-0.0053717555,
-0.0719076991,
0.0215402097,
0.0226905663,
0.0443532728,
0.0166718457,
0.0616268665,
0.0251190327,
0.0482582524,
-0.0270590261,
-0.0274621155,
-0.030509755,
0.0335507467,
-0.0722769573,
-0.0520315766,
0.0348653682,
-0.063603282,
0.0187138598,
0.0472299606,
-0.0244825687,
-0.0355246551,
0.0206092838,
-0.0157448351,
0.0219652057,
0.0582523681,
-0.0390069634,
0.0270316564,
0.0593952239,
0.0487191789,
-0.0202082321,
-0.0054167905,
0.0014943799,
0.0325848758,
-0.0352636538,
0.0034417708,
-0.0573286489,
0.015374952,
-0.005579765,
0.0441435874,
-0.0277903918,
-0.0704185739,
0.0219743587,
0.0937236622,
0.0049578534,
-0.050586272,
0.0326173268,
-0.0470159575,
0.006476644,
0.0043838643,
-0.0052288845,
-0.0068714293,
0.0237306356,
0.0562897325,
0.0027426803,
0.0216837581,
0.0129698347,
0.0266401749,
0.0138857514,
0.0218621884,
-0.0017015277,
0.0155105144,
0.0099530714,
0.0184436552,
-0.0120316632,
-0.0092249699,
0.0432478413,
0.0463584326,
0.0140481871,
0.000119818,
0.0241216309,
-0.0109955203,
0.0222442187,
-0.022419706,
-0.0008743753,
-0.0365207568,
-0.0083971154,
-0.028556712,
0.0133235594,
0.087673977,
-0.0004253022,
0.0434062742,
0.000575405,
0.0120191379,
-0.0259703733,
0.0339107141,
-0.0002511332,
0.0015952636,
0.0053837071,
-0.0034795308,
-0.0168093406,
-0.0042615966,
0.067649439,
0.0145721287,
0.0272949804,
-0.0132984566,
-0.0074920026,
-0.0349565558,
-0.0395804979,
-0.0456032902,
0.0097180652,
-0.0276912749,
-0.0076391236,
-0.0493534058,
-0.0720998719,
0.014298521,
-0.0197342504,
0.0130548552,
0.0032050745,
0.0458495915,
0.0033967691,
0.007206243,
0.0262192171,
-0.0358400308,
-0.0006972955,
0.0248315688,
-0.0111285755,
0.0034431349,
-5.592843429e-33,
-0.0529915728,
-0.0170580205,
-0.0026015686,
-0.0027371477,
-0.0506363437,
-0.0105849607,
-0.0116163529,
-0.0296808369,
-0.0199244712,
-0.0276736319,
-0.0177368391,
-0.0078316955,
0.0298346113,
0.0388478637,
-0.0356841013,
0.0156179648,
0.1135976836,
-0.0211759526,
0.0150524508,
0.0121668717,
0.1060513705,
0.0742185786,
0.013705058,
-0.0177968424,
-0.0038311835,
-0.0192566067,
0.0195550546,
0.0188271143,
0.0238803886,
0.0820155442,
0.0100508491,
0.0852757767,
0.0065585836,
-0.045913443,
-0.0253716912,
0.0405046716,
-0.1230326444,
-0.0010093689,
0.0180273019,
0.0483764894,
0.0160119068,
-0.0126590487,
0.0112362048,
-0.0408477448,
-0.0000486902,
0.0245747138,
0.0288311653,
-0.0571465604,
-0.010480104,
-0.0535398871,
-0.0150382482,
0.0153927403,
0.0066449521,
0.0003069021,
0.0284244996,
-0.0014659127,
-0.0352177583,
0.0021900563,
-0.0347367935,
0.0241423324,
0.03150554,
0.0300203599,
0.0188819021,
0.0871755555,
0.0159509499,
-0.0049390625,
0.036789801,
-0.0425967798,
-0.0198064484,
-0.02093843,
0.0190891661,
0.0298564937,
-0.0299252719,
0.0520930663,
0.0035253407,
-0.0621438026,
-0.0373240337,
0.0115097873,
0.0320111811,
-0.0207850877,
0.0214432869,
-0.0123913297,
-0.0044160853,
-0.0469014682,
-0.0663674027,
0.0117005035,
0.004311577,
-0.0232423339,
0.02786671,
0.0062967739,
-0.0126904109,
0.0027793858,
0.0742221922,
-0.0419488773,
-0.0031467318,
0.0072204694,
0.0073414799,
0.0276144929,
-0.0326105952,
0.0151943164,
-0.0519782156,
-0.0571454279,
0.0397546701,
-0.0003559985,
-0.0112501625,
0.0094206994,
-0.0473909564,
0.0207915083,
-0.0704893321,
0.0515016578,
-0.0207336694,
-0.0044352622,
-0.0121872695,
0.0141153866,
0.0125888074,
-0.0018334251,
-0.001392536,
0.0152742565,
0.0102078952,
0.0214266535,
0.0100224894,
-0.0127160596,
-0.0086201988,
0.0341122299,
-0.0362654738,
0.0363981389,
-0.0072017964,
0.0248165559,
0.037199378,
-0.0094671305,
-0.0104679838,
0.0021267249,
2.6e-7,
0.0298086125,
0.0098397024,
0.0371878967,
0.0288906954,
0.0165465977,
-0.0349493437,
-0.0001635951,
0.0046018437,
-0.0001059319,
-0.0017709519,
0.0137825729,
-0.0153428419,
0.0549705029,
0.0414816812,
-0.1169232577,
0.0210766252,
-0.0254488885,
0.0258877762,
-0.0440886803,
0.0591464639,
0.0703904256,
0.086425446,
-0.0335917585,
-0.0202622432,
-0.03427222,
-0.021201862,
0.0529865064,
-0.0181619879,
-0.0149350939,
0.012768005,
0.0635218769,
-0.0002485855,
-0.0130631337,
0.0409575142,
-0.0138911866,
0.0284076389,
0.0439330228,
0.0346999131,
0.0407196842,
-0.0193226393,
-0.0029941595,
-0.0018488145,
-0.0207685269,
-0.015114977,
0.0472521335,
-0.000061184,
0.0079081682,
-0.0031280036,
-0.0234945882,
-0.014393365,
-0.0394234248,
-0.0500069819,
-0.0218020938,
0.0169006363,
0.01886818,
0.0148347402,
-0.0223283954,
-0.0235993117,
-0.011637616,
0.0154776871,
-0.0305113047,
-0.0868636742,
0.0204445068,
-0.0605888888,
-0.0226453319,
-0.0212128796,
0.0423666164,
2.463024334e-34,
0.0296328496,
-0.0350737274,
0.0019898512,
-0.003646974,
0.0165189281,
-0.0533017628,
0.0096914656,
0.0338529125,
-0.0201761201,
-0.0823436305,
-0.0331894159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.10900v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.10900v1 | Towards building a monitoring platform for a challenge-oriented smart specialisation with RIS3-MCAT | 2023-12-19T07:58:39 | 2023-12-19T07:58:39 | Enric Fuster, Tatiana Fernández, Hermes Carretero, Nicolau Duran-Silva, Roger Guixé, Josep Pujol, Bernardo Rondelli, Guillem Rull, Marta Cortijo, Montserrat Romagosa | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC | In the new research and innovation (R&I) paradigm, aimed at a transformation
towards more sustainable, inclusive and fair pathways to address societal and
environmental challenges, and at generating new patterns of specialisation and
new trajectories for socioeconomic development, it is essential to provide
monitoring systems and tools to map and understand the contribution of R&I
policies and projects. To address this transformation, we present the RIS3-MCAT
platform, the result of a line of work aimed at exploring the potential of open
data, semantic analysis, and data visualisation, for monitoring
challenge-oriented smart specialisation in Catalonia. RIS3-MCAT is an
interactive platform that facilitates access to R&I project data in formats
that allow for sophisticated analyses of a large volume of texts, enabling the
detailed study of thematic specialisations and challenges beyond classical
classification systems. Its conceptualisation, development framework and use
are presented in this paper. | [
-0.0350244492,
0.0174144097,
-0.0423905328,
0.0014829608,
0.0010205606,
-0.0242948886,
-0.0023438088,
0.0016232552,
-0.0230603684,
0.0060875532,
0.0452472642,
0.1521452367,
-0.0140486863,
0.0694301352,
-0.0074187936,
-0.0230997968,
0.0415220559,
0.0037597439,
-0.001403586,
0.034665633,
0.0092383586,
0.0061796228,
-0.0004175862,
0.0455933958,
0.0180312563,
0.0293218009,
-0.0178951304,
0.0016659017,
0.0277248938,
-0.0982385501,
-0.0000583213,
0.025801478,
0.0244056191,
0.065226756,
0.0000021745,
-0.0425816178,
-0.0700105727,
0.027214516,
0.0118842507,
-0.0258437619,
0.0284087565,
-0.0117159141,
0.0152132008,
0.0008727635,
-0.0263668261,
-0.0419422276,
-0.0044719563,
-0.0545459501,
0.0062149726,
-0.082442157,
0.0048350561,
-0.0293037817,
-0.0050593065,
-0.0455203876,
-0.0337577686,
0.0546472967,
-0.0078507531,
-0.0447888598,
0.0609502755,
0.0452696308,
-0.0050114389,
0.0420746915,
-0.0119625116,
-0.0084272232,
0.028796114,
0.0217954163,
0.0099136028,
0.0049858247,
0.013306343,
0.0152315572,
0.03676337,
0.0403502211,
0.0095880544,
-0.0116550708,
-0.0073313378,
0.023049349,
-0.04139442,
0.0124827363,
-0.0205935594,
0.0046489774,
0.0052661346,
0.0322367065,
-0.0044062817,
0.0307127833,
-0.0368087701,
0.0869180858,
-0.0412650518,
-0.0063638263,
0.0134501234,
0.0145113328,
0.0656920001,
0.0051064631,
-0.0193448737,
0.0054845023,
-0.0197980851,
-0.008007545,
0.0695759058,
-0.027179094,
0.0382102653,
0.0198245272,
-0.0399930179,
0.0167440977,
-0.0079365084,
0.0418413058,
0.0778099298,
-0.0000768689,
-0.034623988,
0.0556988046,
0.0035484526,
-0.0423882678,
-0.048488427,
-0.0116759287,
-0.0185929574,
-0.0170291997,
-0.0400350392,
0.0526820123,
0.04280762,
-0.002703533,
-0.0423021801,
0.0393288024,
-0.0397074744,
0.0378010273,
0.0092725856,
0.0089555578,
-0.073309131,
0.004368023,
-0.0389951281,
0.0355437919,
-0.0311142318,
0.0232511405,
0.055260472,
-0.0048543811,
0.011482277,
0.0096863844,
0.012388126,
0.029304428,
0.0410740785,
0.0043613655,
-0.0286016092,
-0.0554206334,
0.0438345373,
-0.0200281274,
0.0616605282,
-0.0107732769,
0.0064526089,
0.0098893708,
0.0105198808,
-0.0266733188,
-0.0222279932,
0.0219043698,
-0.0305149294,
-0.0247344766,
-0.1283252686,
-0.0276643876,
0.0093661388,
0.0332399718,
0.0067390935,
0.021038048,
0.0059905988,
0.0161330476,
0.0234657712,
0.0105904909,
-0.0104224365,
-0.0033691716,
0.0024829831,
0.013951323,
-0.0139044309,
0.0666888207,
-0.0687590167,
0.0044005625,
-0.0100809364,
-0.0383591466,
-0.0005280048,
0.0614875369,
0.025833251,
0.0228868853,
0.0587840825,
-0.00402669,
-0.0118822102,
0.025828002,
-0.0118071074,
-0.0804522708,
0.0359642841,
-0.024383761,
0.0496297218,
0.0168316737,
-0.0279046353,
-0.010956075,
0.0051679136,
-0.0268710647,
0.0277636647,
0.071694158,
-0.0123361489,
0.0075831651,
0.0637900531,
-0.0237611067,
0.0677491352,
-0.0401188396,
0.0038369489,
0.0173687115,
0.015436748,
-0.0715746954,
0.0832061544,
0.0243515447,
0.0282091238,
-0.0812612772,
-0.0013764019,
-0.0263190735,
-0.0438843891,
0.0377178825,
-0.0276989527,
-0.01796671,
-0.0423828922,
0.0278917197,
-0.0446757041,
-0.0263499767,
-0.0048483745,
0.0198515859,
-0.0504321791,
0.0415272191,
-0.0282700434,
-0.0598099418,
0.0371537507,
0.0104676289,
0.036002811,
0.0408519208,
-0.0089213336,
0.0086035216,
-0.0493344441,
0.0912600681,
0.0263474826,
0.0138497632,
0.0433378555,
-0.0259642322,
0.0256577265,
0.0164340809,
0.0595590957,
0.1068973318,
-0.0134986108,
-0.0843366012,
0.0023248924,
0.0178001691,
0.0028562082,
0.0015220969,
0.0288426727,
0.0211386029,
0.026694173,
0.0095370542,
-0.0210639797,
-0.0314873494,
0.0286460891,
-0.0198898595,
0.0220163353,
-0.0170685183,
0.0319021977,
0.0419501141,
-0.0587812923,
0.0124336118,
-0.0201981571,
0.0330889151,
0.0017545569,
-0.0161877759,
0.0247716848,
0.0015673651,
0.0022339413,
-0.01648755,
0.0497745462,
-0.0380157493,
0.0222652815,
-0.0013284804,
0.0233893488,
0.013336841,
-0.0095515987,
-0.0343142785,
0.0184599236,
0.0402374752,
-0.0149441957,
0.0171353351,
-0.0432903245,
0.0009150692,
0.0408048779,
0.0463128723,
-0.0015090285,
0.0230041649,
-0.0101305051,
0.0547652692,
0.0574216135,
0.010834734,
-0.0370690823,
-0.0623469055,
-0.0172457248,
-0.0040965965,
0.0092695281,
0.0121119125,
0.0322129056,
0.0380360484,
0.0296335388,
-0.0609118268,
-0.0347068235,
0.0714680552,
0.0146848494,
-0.0692798421,
-0.0045862482,
0.0225154385,
0.0059853834,
0.0548339672,
-0.0152458847,
0.0093682753,
0.0359513201,
-0.0221630894,
-0.0026379805,
0.0093284631,
0.0159185249,
0.0559672639,
-0.0247629676,
0.0085893301,
-0.0209172126,
0.0373519212,
0.0051394263,
0.0662052482,
-0.0003749736,
-0.0225092936,
-0.0507907979,
-0.0096655618,
0.0270433147,
-0.0665733889,
-0.0780300349,
-0.0449182205,
0.0599928088,
-0.0355233848,
-0.0211402457,
-0.0072879279,
0.0147570986,
0.0066537377,
-0.0520666353,
-0.0290256385,
-0.0090051219,
0.0085252915,
-0.0556926206,
-0.0319173411,
-0.0247224867,
0.0017810267,
-0.0082712118,
0.026451055,
-0.0162395537,
0.0349365994,
0.0791872293,
0.0131253395,
-0.0017019003,
0.0333260372,
0.0558370538,
0.0583906025,
0.0589372776,
-0.0440859534,
-0.0145713584,
0.0087258108,
-0.0470887199,
0.0206499361,
0.0180925708,
0.0082851313,
-0.0379501283,
0.0007999694,
-0.0223029573,
-0.0194998644,
-0.0396309868,
0.0034941055,
-0.0225351956,
-0.0237513706,
0.0167441405,
-0.0256113354,
-0.0238847118,
-0.0396829993,
-0.0292212088,
0.0066904859,
-0.0015909519,
-0.0606745109,
0.0120747583,
-0.0052260123,
-0.0436521135,
0.0458655208,
0.0090021873,
-0.0668309703,
0.0378003083,
0.0103048095,
0.050147485,
-0.0446114615,
-0.0280356966,
-0.0512647107,
0.0207335856,
0.0723714679,
-0.0514669046,
-0.1242823452,
-0.0283347722,
0.0196785536,
0.0416825898,
-0.0058432566,
-0.0534669235,
-0.0369497202,
0.0213226136,
0.0032777241,
0.0082070744,
-0.0821532831,
-0.0182978287,
-0.0341845304,
-0.0380124152,
0.0048636901,
0.0486678034,
0.0154406065,
-0.0224446673,
0.0388708711,
-0.0275480524,
-0.0146240322,
0.0115478728,
-0.0313316844,
-0.0264446344,
0.0144026512,
-0.0036694279,
-0.0423356667,
-0.0116721541,
0.0133981695,
-0.0090444479,
0.0580725037,
0.0918836743,
-0.0158583894,
0.0386053585,
-0.0743911266,
-0.0300982594,
0.0217377003,
-0.0400951132,
-0.0093128793,
-0.0003750699,
0.0318484083,
-0.0409393311,
-0.0055880323,
-0.0084696645,
-0.0034861802,
0.0478586331,
-0.0307840519,
-0.0428925641,
0.0529599153,
-0.0318310447,
0.0642598271,
0.0036160867,
-0.04178074,
-0.0349776782,
0.0748947859,
-0.0571923405,
-0.0567710623,
0.0289335866,
-0.0264289025,
0.0242026001,
-0.0251827352,
-0.0671712384,
-0.0004007355,
0.0278341677,
-0.0308917034,
-0.011183762,
-0.0468542688,
-0.0016959598,
0.0110056447,
0.0087060444,
0.0280937087,
-0.0431231931,
0.0301541016,
-0.0150047019,
0.0756241828,
0.0514561459,
-0.0514436662,
-0.0338791795,
-0.031196326,
0.0035057049,
-0.0450950302,
-0.0598336235,
0.0230428632,
-0.0183457043,
-0.0082206372,
0.0171435177,
-0.0052225348,
0.0088702263,
-0.0207736064,
-0.0628116578,
0.1209700331,
-0.00035941,
-0.0257732235,
-0.0416979715,
-0.0205896832,
0.0302752256,
0.0013102909,
-0.0035359783,
-0.0187606458,
-0.0107252095,
-0.0339464173,
-0.0266278759,
0.0350718759,
-0.0086556338,
-0.0182151869,
-0.0980002508,
0.05442366,
-0.0133850519,
0.0457635075,
-0.0231200587,
0.0199800916,
-0.0016851084,
-0.0078105386,
-0.051845815,
0.0215034951,
0.0129952645,
-0.0025373928,
0.0022462909,
-0.0102594476,
0.0511908792,
0.0683003291,
0.037763793,
-0.0835054219,
0.0163030326,
0.0180240944,
0.0256691631,
0.0571973696,
-0.0342376307,
0.0031710465,
-0.0132181859,
-0.0054046186,
-0.009286847,
-0.014784974,
-0.0213676449,
0.0042463248,
-0.0114774043,
-0.0417424291,
-0.0443074778,
0.0394545197,
0.0186435953,
-0.0414081253,
-0.0148332175,
0.0074629402,
-0.000139688,
0.0108311521,
0.0891370475,
0.0273806304,
-0.0423744284,
-0.0176816247,
-0.0923788697,
-0.009019251,
0.0570404604,
0.0226924345,
-0.0256381743,
0.0075349072,
-0.0062273634,
0.0051020877,
0.0031105066,
-0.0678821579,
-0.0077606756,
-0.019615503,
-0.0856186599,
-0.0255322587,
0.0220722016,
-6.087863202e-33,
-0.0128133772,
-0.0710275993,
0.040347334,
-0.035943076,
-0.0261912625,
0.0138822263,
0.0332321301,
-0.0247892477,
0.0043582199,
0.011057185,
0.0041878172,
0.0028062169,
-0.0053677787,
0.0077618444,
0.0371233597,
0.0074267252,
0.0170254111,
0.0231671222,
0.0017813345,
-0.0087708347,
-0.0043288921,
-0.0417663008,
0.0467595309,
-0.1139428169,
0.0550111756,
0.0065367152,
-0.0248953737,
0.0088682184,
0.0322213173,
0.0475051291,
0.017406771,
0.0581829697,
0.033676412,
-0.0783082992,
-0.0305207558,
0.0130533762,
-0.0439653546,
-0.0430428572,
-0.0109631652,
-0.0009452319,
-0.0241558924,
-0.0085211797,
0.0325081795,
0.0430844948,
0.0117177023,
0.0076986868,
0.0361897089,
-0.0109389974,
0.0007777861,
-0.0217776559,
-0.019839704,
0.0191290081,
-0.0499437749,
0.0538472757,
0.0123325838,
-0.0076658363,
0.0385949053,
0.0469468944,
-0.0550173894,
0.0255185012,
-0.0170096215,
-0.0466798656,
0.0371817276,
0.0067973956,
-0.0102106724,
-0.0029964938,
-0.0269670263,
-0.0178702362,
0.0700670406,
0.0199320242,
0.0351840332,
0.0624780022,
0.0408579856,
0.0171262808,
-0.0327643007,
-0.0070965956,
-0.0630129203,
0.0069755502,
0.0052566919,
-0.0142954458,
-0.0181827657,
0.0026582617,
-0.0135664539,
-0.0033150592,
-0.0288312174,
-0.039847903,
-0.0274382178,
0.0244760402,
0.0371902473,
-0.020158574,
-0.0084530022,
0.0931596681,
-0.0105073443,
-0.0305830911,
0.0280436538,
-0.0188913587,
-0.0229316317,
-0.0055071935,
-0.0158833768,
0.0304070693,
-0.0539254248,
-0.030061353,
-0.0177214015,
0.0604557134,
0.0222131815,
0.0213326309,
-0.0562922694,
-0.0048758988,
-0.0405314304,
0.0384638086,
0.0118323239,
0.0369953364,
-0.0209866669,
-0.0212497879,
0.0104177427,
-0.0297257584,
0.0366464853,
0.0334587358,
0.0409256928,
0.0286077596,
0.0179713555,
-0.0212368295,
-0.0193365403,
-0.0065033371,
0.0250250269,
-0.0020479474,
-0.0285624433,
-0.0168498028,
0.0031535476,
0.0089633297,
-0.0013812206,
-0.0165250767,
2.86e-7,
0.0300556999,
0.0424080454,
-0.0151635995,
0.0358978771,
0.0245581195,
-0.0084435502,
0.0453449562,
0.0433450416,
-0.0741968006,
0.0347366929,
0.0203054864,
-0.0292312689,
-0.0076575731,
0.0639887974,
-0.025356207,
-0.0500142127,
-0.0226546433,
0.0168820508,
-0.1232912168,
0.0224089269,
0.0532427765,
-0.0133211417,
0.0164955165,
0.0352863036,
0.0084031653,
-0.053492412,
-0.0117268944,
0.0007107315,
0.0499569625,
0.0117729232,
0.0100150239,
0.0679943115,
-0.0106919799,
-0.0156596638,
0.0124586374,
-0.0230804775,
-0.0597326346,
-0.0159335881,
0.0138010578,
0.0256410204,
0.016660016,
-0.0874385983,
0.0275373198,
-0.0509004481,
0.022284314,
-0.0067305006,
0.0063623525,
0.0116717648,
0.0213124957,
-0.0182555616,
0.0093989233,
-0.0360986963,
-0.0175741091,
-0.0131758144,
-0.017393861,
0.0029877133,
0.0018575614,
-0.0372054875,
0.0574410446,
-0.0078934291,
-0.0291054547,
-0.0673123375,
-0.0330803916,
0.0225353837,
0.0125044845,
-0.0261975825,
0.0447903685,
2.448376801e-34,
-0.0269013774,
0.0084366528,
-0.0355474539,
-0.0518871918,
0.0397279039,
0.0078032627,
-0.02905236,
-0.0275406688,
-0.004886704,
-0.0136850113,
0.0022407891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11895v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11895v1 | Analyzing Public Reactions, Perceptions, and Attitudes during the MPox Outbreak: Findings from Topic Modeling of Tweets | 2023-12-19T06:39:38 | 2023-12-19T06:39:38 | Nirmalya Thakur, Yuvraj Nihal Duggal, Zihui Liu | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | The recent outbreak of the MPox virus has resulted in a tremendous increase
in the usage of Twitter. Prior works in this area of research have primarily
focused on the sentiment analysis and content analysis of these Tweets, and the
few works that have focused on topic modeling have multiple limitations. This
paper aims to address this research gap and makes two scientific contributions
to this field. First, it presents the results of performing Topic Modeling on
601,432 Tweets about the 2022 Mpox outbreak that were posted on Twitter between
7 May 2022 and 3 March 2023. The results indicate that the conversations on
Twitter related to Mpox during this time range may be broadly categorized into
four distinct themes - Views and Perspectives about Mpox, Updates on Cases and
Investigations about Mpox, Mpox and the LGBTQIA+ Community, and Mpox and
COVID-19. Second, the paper presents the findings from the analysis of these
Tweets. The results show that the theme that was most popular on Twitter (in
terms of the number of Tweets posted) during this time range was Views and
Perspectives about Mpox. This was followed by the theme of Mpox and the
LGBTQIA+ Community, which was followed by the themes of Mpox and COVID-19 and
Updates on Cases and Investigations about Mpox, respectively. Finally, a
comparison with related studies in this area of research is also presented to
highlight the novelty and significance of this research work. | [
0.0478630513,
0.0471311696,
-0.0070505282,
-0.0525964685,
-0.0124622071,
0.0041081444,
-0.0185846444,
0.0046893684,
-0.0019280614,
-0.0231775232,
0.0579210259,
0.0208002701,
-0.0529255494,
0.0524713024,
-0.0092643015,
-0.0445832461,
-0.0113614667,
0.0560856983,
0.0342443138,
0.0275563952,
0.0578125268,
0.0136172976,
0.0098988162,
0.0341951922,
0.0228042565,
0.0007141933,
0.0317906179,
0.0048071975,
0.046465233,
-0.073130928,
0.0147471586,
0.0048350543,
0.0398296267,
-0.0095042353,
0.0000021057,
-0.0189526398,
-0.0367787182,
-0.0071080732,
0.0582208037,
-0.026359126,
0.0946497321,
-0.0378364176,
0.0031450915,
0.0641744733,
-0.0485667251,
0.0120099615,
0.0659509823,
0.023565067,
0.0412393324,
0.0414543264,
-0.0329605341,
0.0389458798,
0.0003512783,
0.0057239439,
0.0107961316,
0.0117999967,
0.043107599,
-0.0269666295,
0.0384374782,
0.0169842783,
0.0448579304,
0.0546961017,
-0.0611793883,
0.0083997007,
-0.0065275356,
0.0181569662,
0.0301832706,
-0.0672187731,
0.0130214756,
0.0120424554,
0.0670459867,
-0.0143725025,
0.0651216432,
-0.0025873051,
-0.0294386894,
0.0236735232,
-0.0432039164,
-0.000074035,
-0.0157557018,
0.0384908542,
0.0022788357,
0.0098066172,
0.0343530104,
0.0422088802,
0.0136951813,
0.0642780513,
-0.0211491138,
-0.0434574969,
-0.0515041091,
-0.0294223987,
0.0021150967,
-0.0282518007,
0.0542454422,
-0.005054648,
0.0259450171,
0.040943291,
0.0494102016,
-0.0656273663,
0.0342582799,
-0.1344998777,
-0.067631118,
-0.0004036359,
0.0511433892,
-0.0233552307,
0.0959083363,
-0.0672252476,
-0.0444546752,
-0.0013027621,
0.0606409609,
0.025769081,
-0.0724073052,
0.0485798344,
-0.0140180113,
-0.0137598617,
0.0353794768,
0.0441226885,
0.0068865451,
0.008913476,
-0.036674656,
-0.0399369486,
-0.0645558238,
-0.0127865495,
-0.0225004647,
0.0131132957,
0.0304204319,
0.0808441415,
-0.0418987498,
0.0329906382,
-0.025312921,
0.017570382,
0.0391445756,
-0.0043781381,
0.0490923785,
0.004450033,
-0.0239217691,
0.0248224754,
0.0060109221,
-0.0108212698,
0.0140399123,
-0.0105978511,
-0.0244799145,
0.0185445305,
-0.0136895366,
-0.0368377194,
-0.0019483948,
0.0569252558,
-0.0111806309,
0.0224037059,
0.0186229292,
0.0287082735,
-0.0760672539,
-0.0208484065,
-0.0299959369,
0.0177168529,
0.0567812659,
0.0558139086,
0.0451376736,
0.0149118137,
0.0250810366,
0.0575476661,
0.0169748515,
0.0058786338,
-0.0224039238,
-0.0086524934,
0.019791441,
0.0133182844,
0.017226385,
0.0218124818,
-0.0304705426,
0.0008266537,
-0.0807897598,
0.0432243086,
0.0176556744,
0.0570188537,
-0.0093568815,
0.0250093173,
-0.0576934889,
-0.011638673,
-0.0333867781,
0.0869839042,
-0.0389346033,
-0.0462487228,
0.0345460773,
-0.026803555,
0.0389967225,
-0.0086778728,
0.0276149679,
0.0288652927,
-0.0239410754,
-0.0238221101,
-0.0414755866,
0.0196312424,
0.0344508626,
-0.0541497543,
0.0015608831,
-0.0604420677,
-0.0024465849,
0.0141109573,
0.0356806517,
-0.0353291184,
0.0183063131,
-0.0422901921,
0.0047661946,
0.0498176217,
-0.0004500549,
0.0028034726,
-0.0270152129,
-0.0616571158,
-0.0147372941,
-0.0154787125,
-0.0217694137,
0.0183303822,
-0.0803317279,
0.0009073473,
0.0000734225,
0.0210018214,
0.0284768827,
-0.0217700507,
-0.0145992637,
0.0391874686,
-0.0136170089,
0.0165469665,
0.0137424851,
-0.0090009347,
0.0233431589,
0.0269791298,
-0.0376687981,
0.0174398962,
0.0603985228,
0.0609023347,
0.023324294,
0.001771939,
0.0547914095,
-0.008456355,
-0.0587259531,
0.0459490493,
0.0262741297,
0.0786284804,
0.0038772852,
-0.0637471303,
-0.0038456526,
0.0334942304,
-0.0192835238,
0.0309243072,
0.0897372365,
0.0202385839,
0.0021139053,
-0.0203486942,
-0.0228224713,
-0.0470850766,
-0.0199938696,
0.0238647722,
0.0027736684,
-0.0525072403,
-0.0215471555,
0.0040559703,
-0.0838682204,
0.010919746,
-0.023615377,
0.016714612,
-0.0184084978,
-0.0049095121,
0.0343356729,
0.0164574385,
-0.0464884304,
-0.0212173257,
-0.007278224,
-0.088988997,
-0.0141795278,
-0.0268614069,
-0.0080655869,
0.0626977831,
0.0287520476,
-0.0215702001,
0.0089891488,
-0.0035879908,
-0.026244089,
0.0190458447,
0.0225000847,
0.0174540039,
-0.0098382011,
0.0475826189,
-0.0286785848,
-0.0132187949,
-0.0887446925,
0.0039661103,
0.036641743,
-0.102291517,
0.0504545569,
-0.0062697884,
-0.0757022575,
-0.023241261,
-0.0211978182,
-0.0234258138,
0.028170269,
-0.0361946262,
0.0369114988,
-0.047768265,
0.0480169393,
0.0782593265,
0.0526153408,
0.0618006922,
0.0150057683,
0.0006126083,
-0.0369767621,
-0.0145131806,
0.0099871531,
-0.0587839931,
0.0371828377,
0.0217684433,
0.0090565663,
0.0273203459,
-0.0332063548,
0.0195344985,
-0.0681807473,
0.0032359886,
-0.0316826403,
-0.007167005,
-0.0092231501,
-0.0089583909,
-0.0073359055,
-0.0183500573,
-0.0174121354,
0.044160679,
0.0550447144,
-0.0809056312,
-0.0469019301,
-0.01585491,
-0.0143593643,
-0.011759419,
0.0323965624,
-0.0107343132,
0.0174304843,
0.0473383442,
-0.0853406116,
-0.0394444987,
-0.0209169406,
-0.0162805244,
-0.0093876617,
0.0032014449,
0.0101025375,
-0.0080060605,
0.0213563424,
-0.0828726962,
-0.0722650588,
-0.0183328837,
0.017905781,
0.0080672614,
0.0111683365,
0.0427687429,
0.0136097837,
-0.0350693054,
0.0291462149,
-0.0152185746,
0.0324295312,
0.0135867707,
0.0019145157,
-0.0408362038,
-0.0236702189,
0.0202107932,
0.003402805,
0.0268591512,
0.019009795,
-0.0322599784,
-0.0176638309,
0.0018601302,
-0.0131815895,
-0.0032489512,
-0.0041532423,
-0.0020428242,
0.050012514,
-0.0057179788,
0.0354953073,
0.0585141256,
0.0311707705,
0.0127063002,
-0.0067624985,
-0.0285138208,
-0.0323952287,
-0.0253381096,
0.0268411506,
-0.0528024584,
0.0392612182,
-0.0279902853,
-0.0165917352,
-0.0507739671,
-0.0204112157,
-0.0266930982,
0.0319086649,
0.020526249,
0.0123791005,
0.0474669971,
-0.0170368887,
-0.055032704,
0.0438964218,
0.0005620319,
-0.0048455661,
-0.0485838763,
-0.0053967154,
0.0057678996,
0.0086292606,
-0.0519411266,
-0.0226631388,
0.0011484517,
0.0050732954,
0.0079067973,
0.0131418323,
0.0615287647,
-0.0403873622,
0.0131924376,
-0.0107162716,
0.0521368943,
-0.0184295457,
-0.0060574152,
0.0284021497,
-0.0144883785,
0.0177202057,
-0.0506406315,
0.0252930187,
-0.0341281816,
-0.0337030031,
-0.0183503032,
0.0801658109,
-0.0192488525,
-0.0899730921,
-0.054314319,
0.0625064075,
0.011307586,
0.0320854262,
0.0125145288,
0.003167181,
0.022060154,
-0.0215583742,
0.0476114899,
0.0388215557,
0.0108283535,
-0.0722416341,
-0.01193152,
-0.081884332,
-0.0087251365,
-0.0198084787,
-0.009326986,
-0.0046477453,
-0.0247042272,
-0.0263428297,
0.0532078259,
-0.0310289524,
-0.0282050893,
-0.0063557778,
0.0263555553,
0.0222249236,
-0.0008097672,
-0.0293546468,
0.0252131782,
0.0491659157,
-0.0023069785,
-0.0163882431,
-0.0564976782,
-0.0430066995,
0.018252071,
-0.0315886065,
0.0222636331,
-0.0138766868,
0.0215667728,
-0.0057173613,
0.0207555536,
0.0571982935,
-0.0337435082,
-0.0256643519,
0.0054418957,
0.0465821214,
0.0161039606,
0.0075973547,
0.0237455219,
0.0087722801,
-0.0194903836,
-0.0119416872,
-0.0966356397,
0.0241832342,
-0.0162513815,
-0.0168005843,
0.0445516258,
0.0213103592,
-0.0566148609,
-0.0469817221,
-0.0541191362,
0.0045259441,
-0.0085812723,
-0.0014349604,
-0.0181969441,
-0.0250579827,
0.0100724213,
-0.0780357867,
-0.0103971045,
-0.0678273737,
-0.0068541067,
-0.0387626812,
0.0519114994,
0.0043498022,
0.0246108938,
0.0146704186,
-0.0147848874,
0.0137339011,
0.0063207438,
-0.0168515854,
-0.0402825624,
-0.001837405,
-0.0001617764,
-0.0358567722,
-0.020065682,
0.0415347405,
0.0199074019,
-0.0329664536,
-0.0507787727,
-0.0292599574,
0.0297797713,
-0.0141461706,
0.016303109,
0.0225194208,
-0.0201787539,
-0.0282766931,
-0.0230679009,
0.0511643216,
-0.0425827391,
-0.0022520465,
0.0326270871,
-0.02183857,
-0.034758091,
-0.0045130108,
-0.0201433264,
-0.0019072387,
0.0078623369,
0.0444778912,
-0.0340324678,
-0.0170609187,
0.0298632924,
0.0097698681,
0.038990967,
0.0025844465,
0.0612645708,
-0.0459453538,
-0.0159126893,
0.063463062,
-0.0689056739,
-0.0129363313,
-0.0328430533,
-0.0025537054,
0.0412676893,
0.0092007164,
0.0149211856,
-0.0233058408,
0.0332889929,
-0.0120299058,
-0.0260250755,
-0.0071347882,
-6.387407816e-33,
0.0191990118,
-0.0304345228,
-0.0228443332,
0.0061061443,
-0.0284703672,
0.0057867114,
-0.00783756,
0.0032390011,
0.0052131568,
0.0224490967,
-0.0050713001,
0.0373175442,
0.005943452,
-0.0092554679,
0.0028337785,
0.0016464838,
0.0642126426,
-0.0167728756,
-0.0038846557,
0.0388691649,
0.028902771,
0.0360187776,
-0.0424538106,
-0.0952345803,
0.048934076,
-0.0124150682,
-0.0032164736,
-0.0148722967,
0.0614766777,
-0.009013054,
-0.0104318438,
0.0349901058,
0.0591477938,
0.0120002329,
0.0223590229,
0.093817614,
-0.0080147944,
-0.0386289805,
0.0097853383,
-0.0723808333,
0.0045864573,
-0.0461645015,
0.0415761434,
0.0266943108,
-0.0239774268,
0.0173855387,
0.0377877504,
0.0061832545,
0.0467191786,
-0.0133805294,
-0.0167161692,
0.0196349416,
-0.0279703029,
0.0491434932,
-0.0050173467,
0.0113630434,
-0.0073321778,
0.1080085933,
-0.0009946878,
0.0273127444,
0.0249994993,
0.0000401626,
0.0325453319,
-0.0313577689,
0.0159295686,
0.0198130459,
-0.0155951604,
0.014929858,
-0.035665486,
0.0314706713,
-0.0405461378,
0.0112679452,
-0.0128258504,
0.0469651818,
-0.0336636901,
-0.0405512638,
-0.0535229482,
0.0291007999,
0.0241393931,
0.014864753,
0.0144591061,
-0.0152948452,
-0.0113419238,
-0.0116213132,
-0.0130115598,
-0.0595099851,
-0.0244631208,
-0.0166772846,
-0.0420438498,
-0.0090656718,
-0.016005991,
0.0025441076,
0.0003733455,
-0.0002760256,
-0.044841148,
0.0019775901,
-0.0184133518,
0.0095451288,
0.0242103264,
0.0476190336,
-0.0894047171,
0.0321024843,
-0.0316267274,
0.0363686644,
0.0145673165,
-0.0089388015,
-0.0444228314,
0.0159384198,
-0.0445780158,
-0.0156566426,
0.0087565472,
0.0045948545,
-0.0344703123,
0.0001708928,
-0.0325052328,
0.0383252315,
0.0333635621,
0.0196287092,
0.0718553588,
0.0350781493,
0.0418408401,
-0.0589616075,
-0.0847562477,
0.0147149842,
-0.0068446603,
0.0090814643,
-0.0270943753,
0.0500209294,
0.0396225192,
-0.0599734709,
-0.0036214227,
-0.0613309294,
2.865e-7,
0.0861312076,
0.042378854,
-0.0258345306,
-0.0221343767,
0.0377349146,
0.0443405919,
-0.027717771,
0.0167401396,
-0.0039595976,
-0.0314203575,
0.009051024,
0.0234164745,
-0.046458181,
0.0043903198,
-0.0098191071,
0.0253212582,
-0.0879010931,
0.0294816997,
-0.0541982241,
0.0524098538,
0.0137007525,
0.0419881828,
0.0057317759,
0.0196320135,
-0.0606248565,
0.037056949,
0.0574371889,
-0.0699814558,
-0.0580180958,
0.0305781029,
0.0080612814,
-0.0051785926,
0.0020060292,
-0.0215960126,
-0.0101284478,
-0.0232392885,
0.0022089276,
0.0277956538,
0.0147697423,
0.0152363749,
0.0239380822,
-0.0507790931,
0.0270685293,
-0.0358423032,
0.022402171,
-0.052921772,
-0.0643816441,
-0.0415171273,
-0.0163092595,
0.0240853671,
0.0332544446,
-0.0039070058,
-0.079795666,
0.0024585482,
-0.040736936,
0.008151981,
-0.0048373463,
-0.0458248667,
0.0261366852,
-0.068940185,
-0.0215996355,
-0.0736011341,
-0.0113957794,
0.0094887232,
0.0231064465,
0.0185083784,
0.0817441642,
1.823612804e-34,
0.0456201993,
-0.0239645969,
-0.0822585374,
-0.0592428483,
-0.0076357918,
-0.0028508091,
-0.0324292146,
0.0034078064,
0.0086554727,
0.0018407584,
0.0310224183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11890v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11890v1 | Difficulty-Focused Contrastive Learning for Knowledge Tracing with a Large Language Model-Based Difficulty Prediction | 2023-12-19T06:26:25 | 2023-12-19T06:26:25 | Unggi Lee, Sungjun Yoon, Joon Seo Yun, Kyoungsoo Park, YoungHoon Jung, Damji Stratton, Hyeoncheol Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | This paper presents novel techniques for enhancing the performance of
knowledge tracing (KT) models by focusing on the crucial factor of question and
concept difficulty level. Despite the acknowledged significance of difficulty,
previous KT research has yet to exploit its potential for model optimization
and has struggled to predict difficulty from unseen data. To address these
problems, we propose a difficulty-centered contrastive learning method for KT
models and a Large Language Model (LLM)-based framework for difficulty
prediction. These innovative methods seek to improve the performance of KT
models and provide accurate difficulty estimates for unseen data. Our ablation
study demonstrates the efficacy of these techniques by demonstrating enhanced
KT model performance. Nonetheless, the complex relationship between language
and difficulty merits further investigation. | [
0.0465741456,
-0.005200108,
-0.0498271734,
0.0331490785,
-0.0342926048,
0.0166865084,
-0.0057931761,
-0.0223943293,
0.0023005046,
0.0148061421,
0.0259033069,
-0.0322219208,
-0.0212741327,
-0.0150015317,
0.0120722828,
-0.076865606,
-0.0034673868,
0.0098058041,
0.0022802043,
-0.0070680543,
-0.0125098983,
-0.0205429234,
-0.0111210821,
-0.0050832611,
0.0483075865,
-0.0278959759,
-0.0096577778,
-0.0044680387,
-0.0033895036,
-0.0187663492,
0.0364643857,
0.0547992289,
0.0235276278,
-0.000935984,
0.0000023709,
-0.0659996942,
-0.0392531082,
-0.0115167843,
-0.0525126755,
0.0184603576,
0.0052261031,
0.0327289551,
0.0312281512,
0.0376717187,
-0.0185363442,
0.0115773994,
0.0080884537,
0.0183795746,
0.0259678047,
0.015249541,
0.0107436478,
-0.010974763,
0.004222346,
0.0146147367,
0.0591545589,
-0.031485118,
0.008221942,
0.0180882085,
-0.0268339869,
0.022429442,
-0.0467318557,
0.0433185808,
0.0274635721,
0.0372871086,
-0.0109922839,
-0.012933271,
0.0334539972,
0.0261439886,
0.0452035218,
0.0420740917,
0.022320414,
0.0269735884,
-0.0532916002,
-0.007258208,
0.0304155312,
0.068911247,
-0.0300787538,
-0.029142065,
-0.0389839634,
-0.0265574157,
0.0534060821,
0.0031443897,
-0.0036638326,
-0.0008933934,
-0.0078859553,
-0.0448883846,
-0.0037975281,
-0.0443276502,
-0.0056309169,
0.0142412819,
-0.0057970965,
0.0061032041,
0.0128799463,
0.0237994269,
-0.0371572971,
0.0322218128,
0.0307428949,
-0.0487148017,
0.0115775587,
-0.0086970469,
0.0353361219,
0.0387544967,
-0.0557831153,
0.0520073809,
-0.0465859324,
0.0326035284,
0.0344856642,
-0.0373074338,
-0.0231993664,
0.0012472322,
-0.0465798788,
0.0111891311,
-0.0179792754,
0.0181092583,
0.0119487187,
0.0560943224,
-0.0246182512,
-0.0003826052,
-0.0199706033,
0.0028807202,
-0.0153916692,
-0.0574466884,
-0.0252833981,
-0.0094837323,
-0.0564032122,
0.0018424421,
-0.0521825701,
0.0071166945,
-0.0278243572,
0.02091516,
0.0212549046,
-0.0170921572,
0.0226877797,
-0.0223271493,
0.0295139086,
0.0089802593,
-0.0118693374,
-0.0399505496,
-0.0629617274,
-0.0094235903,
0.0237562135,
-0.0238820165,
0.0022611218,
-0.0515843369,
0.0113176154,
0.0296010785,
0.0047922102,
-0.0287669729,
-0.017789783,
0.0066406159,
-0.0226027053,
0.0744310766,
0.0130125294,
-0.0203414802,
0.0238614399,
0.0350733399,
-0.0456556343,
0.0283248518,
-0.024285458,
-0.0361946672,
0.0196931921,
-0.0457363427,
0.0285323523,
-0.0167355444,
0.0187777039,
0.0014429177,
0.0153082367,
0.0161162484,
0.0042007556,
0.0091982633,
0.009135738,
0.0381483175,
-0.0080303997,
0.0046300804,
0.0149477758,
-0.0008558296,
0.0604761429,
0.0426039845,
0.0298846029,
0.0401824526,
0.004317848,
0.0541054755,
-0.0078283669,
0.0163696557,
-0.0229817182,
0.0087666558,
0.0443928614,
0.0263812114,
-0.0400252864,
-0.0888636783,
0.0117165968,
0.0221638139,
0.0460156351,
0.0337408371,
0.0875014365,
-0.0224424526,
-0.0367158577,
0.0122819776,
0.0421719477,
0.0180521086,
-0.0099751642,
-0.0317792669,
0.0235602204,
0.0317944959,
0.0278794672,
-0.0677398592,
-0.0430297032,
-0.007410747,
0.0181505848,
0.0061153723,
0.0205480009,
-0.0068223919,
0.0009073114,
-0.0470536165,
-0.0458481014,
0.0135271493,
0.0225873012,
-0.0191775579,
0.0339830071,
-0.0003039974,
0.0078809327,
-0.0514850095,
-0.0304719824,
0.0065306663,
-0.0587703958,
-0.0536725186,
-0.0179479104,
0.0130157564,
0.008098607,
0.0233789794,
0.0332259946,
-0.0083359675,
0.0070272679,
-0.0485231057,
-0.0127457697,
-0.0062460653,
-0.0221718494,
-0.049873542,
0.038033735,
-0.0299537852,
-0.0087175695,
0.0292098466,
-0.0385637879,
-0.0641362965,
0.0418961309,
-0.0404970162,
0.0586752445,
0.0370353796,
0.0039983154,
-0.020573331,
-0.0570400171,
-0.015254003,
0.086218752,
-0.0132453172,
0.1160754338,
0.0025711297,
-0.039140217,
-0.006440639,
0.0131271398,
-0.023825299,
-0.0769117177,
-0.0262345131,
0.0191868059,
0.037043646,
-0.0095304986,
-0.0752392262,
0.0200404618,
-0.0241897274,
0.0122021353,
0.0140717812,
0.0229768772,
-0.0005123988,
-0.0255909357,
0.0048457105,
-0.0216047429,
-0.0461050048,
0.0123479627,
-0.0384825617,
-0.0032806711,
-0.0179324057,
0.0852035135,
-0.0434924215,
-0.0386256874,
-0.0113399411,
0.0076459339,
-0.0098714465,
0.0027542484,
0.0250232369,
-0.0558506809,
0.1020628586,
0.0014783305,
-0.0103102336,
-0.031920176,
-0.0231455881,
0.0070935651,
0.0013881855,
0.0520695113,
0.0306154098,
-0.025670208,
0.0275395531,
0.031861987,
-0.0284876805,
-0.0366864428,
0.0405081548,
-0.0273554642,
-0.0387782827,
0.0020347908,
-0.1000220031,
-0.0452970676,
0.0938492492,
-0.0034862587,
-0.0329785384,
-0.0348343998,
0.0125185186,
-0.0532317758,
0.0553064644,
-0.0073592872,
0.0523687005,
0.0171267409,
0.0101278517,
-0.0253377855,
-0.0203704722,
0.0976168886,
0.0246243663,
0.0164923817,
-0.0317122601,
0.0022905048,
0.00090204,
0.0319089442,
0.004944629,
0.0116409678,
0.009939759,
-0.0070288219,
-0.0594874471,
-0.002919106,
0.0712824166,
-0.0438731015,
0.0435425751,
-0.0559177659,
-0.0459809192,
0.0263407398,
-0.019701682,
-0.0197334941,
0.0186214969,
0.0310105216,
-0.0101189269,
0.0529657155,
-0.0103425737,
-0.0100491056,
-0.0191481747,
0.0405898504,
0.0165600628,
0.0342023745,
-0.0548446849,
-0.0060113114,
0.026313575,
0.0000708381,
-0.026277896,
0.0303775314,
-0.0539500378,
0.0676707476,
0.0231324732,
0.0534154214,
-0.0240124967,
0.0580125116,
-0.0159754138,
0.0132241677,
-0.035034202,
-0.0309487693,
0.0375903808,
0.0022380794,
-0.0615086406,
-0.0220611952,
0.1114544421,
0.0537232719,
-0.0564309694,
-0.0234373193,
-0.0585150421,
-0.0039833579,
0.0519625098,
0.0274549555,
-0.0402220525,
-0.0010072644,
0.0052549927,
0.0914150029,
-0.0334376171,
-0.0346269496,
0.0196730588,
-0.0676103383,
0.0125667518,
-0.0032891226,
-0.0206854064,
-0.0612188093,
-0.0918438733,
-0.0112306476,
-0.006842046,
0.0026639523,
0.0011771579,
0.0075212512,
0.0003378583,
0.0488972552,
-0.0479148775,
-0.0714029521,
0.0316634476,
-0.018935591,
0.0811158866,
-0.0144182481,
0.003204705,
-0.0284033902,
0.0219997931,
-0.0057354784,
-0.0374577641,
-0.0114458855,
-0.0279112849,
0.0567596741,
0.0359792151,
0.0007814797,
-0.0500834957,
0.0126015525,
-0.0267140437,
0.0212376472,
0.0234719794,
0.0785111263,
0.0323458239,
0.0022220742,
0.0182296373,
-0.0384144522,
0.0099888528,
0.0930104852,
0.0418987907,
-0.0604604483,
0.0525201112,
-0.0444569625,
0.0111186327,
-0.0145043293,
-0.0413422175,
0.0421568677,
-0.0391260348,
0.056563694,
-0.0207727812,
-0.0280716009,
0.0462019108,
0.0378926843,
-0.0151730236,
0.0682288408,
-0.0134760421,
-0.0269465167,
-0.061083585,
0.0275031403,
-0.0130225252,
-0.0107127037,
-0.0827075765,
-0.0478803292,
0.0194572974,
-0.0176431555,
-0.0104945656,
0.0183459651,
-0.0323479436,
-0.0264878888,
-0.0002971959,
0.0618302599,
0.020561425,
0.0474242643,
0.0125908311,
-0.0224805772,
0.0058451057,
-0.0442213155,
0.0018864567,
-0.0127807809,
-0.0014032075,
-0.0066679735,
-0.0249183532,
0.0028279319,
-0.0225364231,
-0.0267812721,
0.0297314189,
0.0579980239,
-0.0657349378,
-0.0064567281,
0.0472696833,
-0.0027421017,
0.0576484427,
0.0195651818,
-0.0541714691,
-0.0304326173,
0.0097061396,
-0.005995987,
-0.0177619047,
-0.0326225832,
-0.0281385295,
0.0335479863,
-0.0181057528,
-0.0041099056,
-0.0245203655,
-0.0182648636,
-0.0146431187,
-0.0641122982,
0.0523412861,
0.0004892992,
0.0319399163,
0.0516272597,
-0.0103200208,
-0.0151820146,
-0.0044161142,
0.0047808592,
0.0637347326,
0.0200456865,
0.0865660906,
0.0037625949,
0.0214116294,
0.014736142,
-0.0559209138,
0.020014137,
-0.075136289,
-0.0362612531,
-0.0420593843,
0.0381539576,
-0.0377483889,
0.0277706552,
-0.030864818,
0.0165933259,
-0.0062454878,
0.0050616688,
0.0006144259,
-0.0212105606,
0.0454692021,
0.0523838103,
0.0479525626,
0.0432625264,
0.1075377092,
0.0259165,
0.0658032298,
-0.0185568668,
-0.0492086522,
-0.0313400663,
0.0443226099,
0.0615744479,
0.0356102586,
-0.0088176513,
0.0435234606,
-0.0621568561,
-0.0849219114,
0.0159303136,
-0.0229066052,
-0.0019831285,
-0.0192355104,
0.0396760441,
0.0560200252,
-0.0228645671,
-0.0367430001,
-0.0389204025,
0.0299401917,
-0.0517617837,
-0.0368864723,
0.02718894,
-6.953558956e-33,
-0.0227381214,
-0.0338208415,
0.0183017887,
-0.0381783433,
0.0538637564,
0.0417802669,
-0.0302066375,
0.027775798,
-0.0402370244,
-0.000407195,
0.0199993365,
0.0028951475,
-0.0086111696,
-0.0000899176,
0.0127672469,
0.0248028282,
0.045597285,
0.0249905139,
0.0207781643,
0.0071357014,
0.0219430849,
0.0167705137,
0.0233687814,
-0.0902542323,
0.0364959352,
-0.0196383055,
0.031286452,
0.0321489684,
0.0143010328,
0.0366539806,
-0.0248284154,
0.0366958864,
0.0179147907,
-0.09474428,
-0.0061925319,
-0.0774425194,
-0.0701118484,
-0.0444170162,
0.0149402358,
0.0054461262,
-0.0095757572,
-0.0306376629,
0.0008765329,
0.0028342656,
0.0188941471,
-0.0457670987,
0.0492430292,
-0.0153239565,
-0.0166723598,
0.0088945413,
-0.0357205383,
0.0103576519,
-0.0612376556,
-0.0433489308,
0.0112720793,
0.0574716926,
0.0156829227,
-0.046533443,
-0.1007978022,
-0.0082427328,
0.0042740707,
0.0316078179,
0.0154390577,
0.0192361344,
-0.0156470891,
-0.0073935948,
-0.0082216477,
0.0210177787,
0.0316652879,
-0.0128979152,
0.0282214414,
0.0105182361,
0.0476333387,
0.0354109183,
0.0418693088,
0.0098238392,
-0.0600610673,
0.0402549915,
-0.017721286,
0.0116539886,
0.0224198326,
0.01072283,
-0.0906319171,
-0.043983683,
-0.0503928103,
0.0004144409,
-0.0165961608,
-0.021579558,
0.0337682925,
0.0207168981,
-0.0319644436,
-0.0863367915,
0.0182188805,
0.0007019537,
0.0058212802,
0.0029253354,
-0.0108555006,
0.0695277378,
-0.0451547056,
0.0146360174,
-0.0801646113,
-0.019947296,
-0.0286825057,
-0.0753801093,
0.0126975011,
0.0336515009,
0.0331000909,
0.0000459293,
-0.0557628907,
-0.0181795619,
-0.0032573752,
-0.0181875154,
0.0161116645,
-0.0014718862,
0.0238912683,
0.0131636979,
0.001055709,
0.0281234328,
0.0556442812,
-0.0158421639,
-0.0244466439,
-0.0159458686,
-0.0552062318,
-0.013783589,
0.0016438292,
-0.0270828214,
-0.0039002793,
0.0129463421,
-0.0032140859,
-0.020593971,
-0.0236531515,
-0.0189094543,
2.921e-7,
0.0386891589,
0.0567313917,
-0.0249512829,
0.0542674027,
-0.0260008983,
0.0421527214,
0.0246693399,
-0.0630182326,
0.0419032872,
-0.0172211695,
0.028707929,
0.033459682,
0.0231566131,
0.0240999963,
-0.0746030286,
-0.043960087,
0.0618018173,
0.0037054082,
-0.0277558956,
0.01604365,
0.0723075047,
0.0428312346,
0.0242588669,
0.0185801908,
-0.0178133193,
-0.0466981158,
0.0320378095,
-0.0507744588,
0.0091995532,
0.0049494524,
0.0449028797,
0.0421386845,
-0.0042261826,
0.0602466501,
-0.029692363,
-0.0080924127,
-0.0164130237,
0.0107390406,
0.0254920237,
-0.0075494018,
0.0344070978,
0.0163318757,
0.0152087267,
-0.0629510283,
0.0287381485,
-0.0176331736,
-0.0214723293,
0.0712460652,
-0.0190547239,
-0.0184084009,
0.0217955429,
0.007521098,
-0.0184198339,
-0.0350105166,
-0.0039235172,
-0.0111135431,
-0.0059969197,
-0.0494662225,
0.0047355094,
0.0816046,
-0.0009604088,
-0.0467317626,
-0.0542848893,
-0.0299376715,
0.0029287469,
-0.060670916,
0.0321235545,
2.768611998e-34,
0.0243395586,
0.0222204849,
0.0477770045,
0.0274761543,
0.0483986773,
-0.015716644,
-0.0630711839,
0.0233475063,
0.0386193879,
-0.0815641731,
0.0066996901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11882v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11882v2 | ConsistentEE: A Consistent and Hardness-Guided Early Exiting Method for Accelerating Language Models Inference | 2023-12-19T06:16:13 | 2024-04-07T17:16:42 | Ziqian Zeng, Yihuai Hong, Hongliang Dai, Huiping Zhuang, Cen Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Early Exiting is one of the most popular methods to achieve efficient
inference. Current early exiting methods adopt the (weighted) sum of the cross
entropy loss of all internal classifiers during training, imposing all these
classifiers to predict all instances correctly. However, during inference, as
long as one internal classifier predicts an instance correctly, it can
accelerate without losing accuracy. Thus, there is a notable gap between
training and inference. We propose ConsistentEE, an early exiting method that
is consistent in training and inference. ConsistentEE formulates the early
exiting process as a reinforcement learning problem. A policy network is added
to decide whether an instance should exit or continue. The training objective
of ConsistentEE only require each instance to be predicted correctly by one
internal classifier. Additionally, we introduce the concept Memorize Layer to
measure the hardness of an instance. We incorporate memorized layer into reward
function design, which allows "easy" instances to focus more on acceleration
while "hard" instances to focus more on accuracy. Experimental results show
that our method outperforms other baselines on various natural language
understanding and generation tasks. | [
0.0501248576,
0.0908572823,
0.0197737366,
-0.0030556929,
-0.0302799027,
0.0152102448,
-0.0063229022,
-0.0402937345,
-0.0042892005,
-0.0122329174,
0.0071386439,
-0.0131944083,
-0.0042498023,
-0.0035162373,
0.0020878783,
-0.051977668,
0.0448056832,
-0.0158875436,
0.0149352197,
-0.022801904,
0.0122327199,
0.0245364569,
-0.0090644071,
0.0601409525,
0.0115558561,
0.0053027552,
-0.0234318376,
-0.0056208791,
0.0291971844,
-0.0351212658,
0.0304273739,
0.0424736477,
0.0335642546,
0.0389413126,
0.0000022923,
-0.0668092892,
-0.0367386416,
-0.0030516314,
-0.0260336604,
0.0066119651,
0.0152152302,
-0.0386461392,
0.0104572857,
0.0210414045,
-0.0152362129,
-0.012247582,
0.0827923566,
0.022931559,
0.0631825849,
0.0564261973,
0.0249859188,
-0.0400337093,
0.0021661934,
-0.0566120073,
0.0101354392,
-0.0673784912,
0.0111973304,
-0.0254283492,
-0.0046325675,
-0.0640824661,
-0.013467296,
0.0371762887,
0.0661651492,
0.0199222751,
-0.0217335615,
0.0802421123,
0.0051301857,
-0.0188279934,
-0.0383782201,
0.0327267721,
-0.0153256701,
-0.024375407,
0.0201620329,
-0.0289809518,
-0.0174412765,
-0.03583318,
-0.0256677847,
0.0309938435,
0.0004372871,
0.0368632115,
0.0507074036,
0.0343459696,
0.0200537723,
0.049953457,
-0.0331526548,
0.0200183261,
0.0227942914,
0.001961061,
0.0245199781,
0.034281861,
-0.0487602688,
-0.0393347852,
-0.0053982148,
0.038829118,
-0.0587771162,
0.0411555208,
-0.0894616097,
-0.0005300747,
-0.0143064046,
-0.0399741717,
0.056751851,
0.0762474388,
0.0382457599,
0.0416317545,
-0.0418564044,
0.0410649031,
-0.0085974019,
-0.0079526864,
-0.0261994414,
0.0085511496,
-0.0318174325,
0.0007319418,
-0.0570627712,
0.0419491157,
0.0337319709,
-0.052954033,
-0.0922702998,
0.0090559795,
-0.026203217,
0.0236965399,
0.0140632829,
0.0361666344,
-0.0624469891,
0.0191330016,
-0.0219391584,
0.0160535574,
-0.0740897581,
-0.0034917882,
0.0537940487,
-0.0317784324,
-0.0230766442,
0.0292052291,
0.0402458087,
-0.0094770426,
0.0194083378,
0.0630334541,
-0.0287884418,
-0.0091026966,
-0.0751087517,
-0.0456814393,
-0.0142357657,
-0.1023035124,
-0.0172175989,
-0.0709186047,
0.0437302031,
-0.0038063251,
-0.017134998,
-0.029205896,
0.0133652147,
-0.0015896871,
-0.0185206831,
0.0371167473,
-0.0031463762,
-0.0047573121,
0.0381172337,
0.018544687,
-0.0051105926,
0.0658759922,
0.0027594131,
0.029196661,
0.0178994257,
0.0093179056,
-0.0096569899,
0.0742120594,
0.0477517396,
-0.0170905739,
-0.0485519618,
-0.0255201384,
-0.0383645147,
0.0302807912,
0.0421054736,
0.0442381762,
-0.0461186022,
0.0199544691,
0.041392345,
-0.0085192528,
0.0113494163,
0.0025986652,
0.069745928,
0.0086108139,
-0.0173676144,
0.0323464125,
-0.0451723374,
0.0294579845,
0.0238427818,
0.0263509806,
0.0628390908,
0.0066679604,
-0.0376265794,
-0.0567664467,
0.0078237839,
-0.0049374397,
0.007189523,
0.0070566591,
0.0569840781,
0.0269073192,
-0.0472345054,
0.0549267791,
0.0411258079,
-0.0253554434,
-0.0077110007,
-0.038394019,
0.0526990667,
0.0649985895,
0.0314263776,
0.0089674769,
-0.0482877567,
0.0176554918,
-0.0188058764,
0.0452492647,
0.0374506414,
-0.0090838484,
0.0208651349,
-0.0745030269,
-0.0414006412,
0.0203098804,
0.0194242485,
0.037218228,
0.0650763884,
0.0158704724,
0.0351926684,
0.0066144788,
-0.035674043,
0.0477612391,
-0.0352492705,
-0.0204931386,
0.0241520926,
0.0114741651,
0.0360414013,
-0.0253519956,
-0.0032662277,
-0.0138226803,
0.0085480977,
-0.0325353444,
-0.0110710552,
0.035230007,
-0.072586149,
-0.0558001399,
0.0092919366,
-0.0082530575,
-0.0074888128,
0.0131031349,
-0.0327500403,
-0.039052844,
0.0205416363,
-0.0579716824,
0.0547580235,
-0.0452083796,
0.0215853509,
0.0073483395,
0.0060013263,
-0.0178606845,
0.0916566551,
-0.0361121669,
0.0288179684,
0.0462432988,
-0.0221157186,
-0.0219523162,
-0.0479143895,
-0.0096824197,
-0.0089333383,
-0.0015724159,
0.0072898036,
0.0669643134,
0.0269826986,
-0.0458435677,
-0.0215293225,
-0.035047736,
0.0119837578,
-0.0105485618,
0.0154379811,
0.0256953277,
0.0117372693,
-0.0032789072,
-0.0209621284,
-0.0109853968,
0.0285317134,
0.0108795408,
-0.0082850046,
-0.0063792397,
0.0380887836,
-0.0361949205,
-0.0427884348,
-0.0108529124,
0.0144961933,
0.0471248329,
-0.0061421376,
0.0187630877,
-0.0364022553,
-0.0006965996,
-0.0525651239,
0.0217275247,
0.0002164371,
-0.0294773318,
0.013268915,
-0.0238491073,
0.0243490078,
0.0358245671,
0.0277890917,
0.0574775375,
0.0333326906,
-0.0186866019,
-0.0674194247,
0.0246224962,
-0.0446222536,
0.0063852905,
0.010978071,
-0.0240767132,
-0.0082143126,
0.0948373303,
0.0367354415,
0.010574203,
-0.055898305,
0.0213582236,
-0.0203864835,
-0.0402984582,
-0.0090491548,
0.0071453187,
-0.0055565196,
-0.0085295606,
-0.0343158096,
-0.0306618866,
0.1044308767,
-0.0213408545,
0.0112512875,
-0.0230282899,
-0.0104500316,
-0.000076693,
0.0530419946,
0.0205351524,
0.0358409397,
0.0068264552,
-0.009672896,
-0.0433972105,
-0.0140290651,
0.0242920145,
0.0032878225,
0.0215914734,
-0.0608923957,
0.0009349543,
0.0033313935,
-0.0234591439,
-0.0730097517,
-0.0110336738,
-0.0037383626,
0.0027998812,
-0.0155754797,
-0.0225624051,
-0.0425216034,
-0.0000663167,
0.0009124539,
0.0544409715,
-0.0329063274,
-0.0088453246,
-0.0258264709,
0.0307835005,
0.0772762895,
0.0104749594,
-0.0047610239,
-0.0774289072,
0.028498916,
0.0461707152,
0.0300569311,
0.0452893041,
-0.0716340914,
-0.0034138598,
0.0397280119,
-0.0575979799,
-0.0256399196,
0.0466064699,
0.0228484236,
-0.0958406851,
-0.0344242975,
0.1423332691,
0.0154383956,
-0.016166294,
0.0210337359,
0.0213938039,
0.0850885287,
0.018103065,
0.0296620652,
-0.058373332,
-0.0287113693,
-0.0028799498,
0.0461362898,
-0.0194576494,
-0.0243814774,
-0.0062996126,
-0.1206604987,
0.0310144909,
-0.0010255742,
-0.0649766773,
0.0263573583,
0.0073382007,
-0.0083606392,
-0.0097373566,
0.0018673453,
0.0226287208,
0.0302191209,
0.0121324863,
0.0382863358,
0.0130717205,
-0.0140845729,
-0.0186564773,
-0.0581265278,
0.0355455615,
0.0628396496,
0.0090473387,
0.0059614414,
-0.0092490232,
0.0368617065,
-0.0310245976,
-0.0067898142,
-0.0253549404,
0.0148593793,
0.0072418107,
-0.0224156789,
-0.0076704621,
0.0500688441,
0.0131846843,
0.0130142858,
0.003806781,
0.039854452,
-0.0071113855,
-0.0481969193,
-0.0148872789,
0.0227646604,
0.001656272,
0.0710051507,
0.0049674516,
-0.0693257675,
-0.0421435311,
-0.0162192993,
-0.0035872224,
-0.067734994,
-0.0080644786,
0.0060082399,
-0.0189897828,
-0.041026447,
-0.0615234524,
-0.0296843816,
-0.0080069015,
0.0750255585,
-0.0149022453,
-0.0243146326,
-0.0334053077,
0.0171146728,
-0.0396690369,
-0.0161198992,
-0.0106917294,
-0.0022799787,
-0.0313028954,
-0.0117623815,
-0.0029623762,
-0.0176227987,
-0.0188292824,
0.0486140177,
-0.0191790145,
-0.0654178038,
-0.0137344832,
0.0650204718,
0.0236313902,
0.0705851242,
-0.0269980598,
-0.0672385618,
0.0655105338,
0.0072880671,
-0.0208603833,
0.0333198979,
-0.004731243,
-0.013066832,
0.0054349704,
0.0237358268,
-0.0239873286,
0.0267175641,
0.0162781328,
0.0632735342,
-0.0132143367,
-0.0307555478,
0.039032612,
-0.0230155457,
-0.0197041687,
-0.0603464246,
-0.007995584,
-0.0347121507,
-0.00691619,
0.0083906511,
-0.0521281175,
-0.0432103835,
0.0322786383,
0.0342781357,
0.0197046436,
-0.020170927,
-0.0105265239,
0.0505564399,
0.005888951,
-0.0455119349,
-0.0336920843,
0.0296598822,
0.0350730754,
0.0065882681,
-0.0138607118,
-0.0321225375,
-0.0086759077,
-0.0062750229,
0.0240389947,
-0.0626547113,
0.0635166243,
0.0474380739,
0.0104733044,
-0.0063439328,
-0.0137261525,
-0.0303433686,
-0.0045399433,
-0.0671485662,
0.0403065383,
0.0408988521,
-0.0010636002,
0.0531686544,
-0.0335652642,
-0.0076034339,
-0.0130731687,
0.0201989878,
-0.0131054763,
-0.0627680868,
0.0085083144,
0.0246416498,
0.0057621677,
-0.0239344407,
0.0534728952,
0.0118339239,
0.0633181781,
-0.0078018233,
0.0072673103,
-0.0634661615,
-0.0320653357,
0.0047165835,
0.022936387,
-0.0166092645,
0.0164384004,
0.0211883131,
-0.0462398492,
-0.0422960222,
0.0510647222,
0.0165413413,
0.0145101519,
0.0675335228,
0.0475817733,
-0.0514427908,
-0.0516317897,
-0.0263889916,
0.0142187448,
-0.0087836906,
-0.0204112194,
-0.0315971486,
-7.133344205e-33,
-0.0434841178,
-0.0070797126,
0.0586534925,
-0.032961268,
-0.0452834852,
0.0164781455,
-0.0604662709,
0.003420817,
0.0104582123,
0.0098927543,
0.0257566888,
0.0018534535,
0.0117538925,
0.0262144115,
0.0192349199,
0.0208563823,
0.0515392944,
0.0064171683,
-0.0471372679,
0.0222206712,
0.0238728598,
0.0334893651,
0.0497708172,
-0.03672098,
-0.0099643553,
0.0294568334,
-0.0676005781,
0.0192476884,
-0.0059029651,
0.0473620258,
-0.0198980626,
0.0018734055,
0.0055858702,
-0.0847256407,
-0.0087502813,
-0.0239331536,
-0.0818876103,
-0.0365240797,
0.0026517068,
0.0179335754,
-0.0624579787,
-0.0320354067,
0.059662953,
-0.0282654781,
0.0116605386,
0.0157856531,
0.036343202,
-0.0110098813,
-0.0139390454,
-0.0361520275,
-0.0696566924,
0.020687731,
0.0032372943,
-0.0339670889,
-0.0268619899,
0.0213340577,
-0.0208524764,
-0.0058716312,
-0.0296756439,
-0.0118715251,
0.0095378719,
0.0455973335,
0.0442430004,
0.043777816,
-0.0085815154,
0.0478862748,
0.0175542179,
-0.0627829581,
-0.003136324,
-0.003845331,
0.0599822886,
0.0559197329,
-0.0005879677,
0.0116896778,
0.0648636594,
-0.0066419248,
-0.0690839067,
0.0605264865,
0.0245008748,
0.0537022874,
0.0486062169,
-0.0069787144,
-0.0435802452,
-0.029389197,
-0.0575183146,
-0.0078603141,
-0.0332945883,
-0.0280187987,
0.031652268,
0.0678600296,
-0.0416122936,
-0.0397158265,
0.0226526018,
-0.0421923399,
-0.000552026,
0.0244511254,
-0.0506523289,
-0.0091358032,
-0.0067991968,
0.0218074303,
-0.0778315738,
-0.0355909355,
-0.0284034703,
-0.0153171606,
0.0034082714,
0.0121609261,
0.0206640679,
0.0401460007,
-0.0628425702,
0.0226122364,
-0.0536254793,
0.0353856944,
-0.026846664,
-0.0038591616,
0.0484319255,
-0.0049313172,
-0.0214570407,
0.0237386599,
0.0265424661,
0.0059937635,
-0.0248639286,
0.012470305,
0.0460287482,
0.0352200866,
-0.0363235697,
0.0086750817,
-0.0096143708,
-0.0184481703,
-0.0073656365,
-0.0634499267,
-0.0212253947,
0.0289937779,
2.981e-7,
-0.0109107895,
0.0033302011,
0.039568413,
0.0424350314,
0.0112438863,
0.0211518388,
0.0096486537,
0.0122328661,
-0.0372907035,
0.004961025,
0.0511245094,
0.0283113755,
0.0319685601,
0.0081987344,
-0.0675197616,
0.0112792812,
-0.0916826501,
0.0224647056,
-0.0404880755,
-0.0296750888,
0.0016246,
0.0726593435,
0.0302226748,
-0.0025978645,
0.026183283,
-0.0188072231,
0.0780250356,
0.0188262649,
0.0168031976,
0.013047724,
0.0306710117,
0.0342837349,
-0.0080207661,
-0.0188998859,
-0.0037920573,
0.0321392715,
-0.0121720824,
0.0412625447,
0.0066519324,
-0.0290489588,
0.0168599803,
0.0111172339,
0.0198296439,
-0.0420468263,
0.0613198355,
-0.0746488571,
-0.0182908699,
-0.0469051041,
0.01647228,
-0.0163884107,
-0.0201792233,
-0.0114698214,
-0.0192253608,
0.0256589726,
0.0346435048,
-0.0148115922,
-0.0414882973,
-0.0684036836,
-0.0376934968,
0.010549319,
-0.0368927568,
-0.0106019536,
-0.0612137243,
0.0004095063,
-0.0046480275,
-0.0929149091,
-0.0191026609,
2.757463857e-34,
0.0229515769,
-0.021636337,
-0.0071039819,
0.0162732583,
0.0342358388,
0.0188733377,
-0.0031462428,
0.0072966865,
0.0347438902,
-0.0363256745,
-0.0560766421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11881v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11881v1 | Punctuation restoration Model and Spacing Model for Korean Ancient Document | 2023-12-19T06:15:52 | 2023-12-19T06:15:52 | Taehong Jang, Joonmo Ahn, Sojung Lucia Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In Korean ancient documents, there is no spacing or punctuation, and they are
written in classical Chinese characters. This makes it challenging for modern
individuals and translation models to accurately interpret and translate them.
While China has models predicting punctuation and spacing, applying them
directly to Korean texts is problematic due to data differences. Therefore, we
developed the first models which predict punctuation and spacing for Korean
historical texts and evaluated their performance. Our punctuation restoration
model achieved an F1 score of 0.84, and Spacing model achieved a score of 0.96.
It has the advantage of enabling inference on low-performance GPUs with less
VRAM while maintaining quite high accuracy. | [
0.057773117,
0.0619249195,
-0.0241720825,
0.0134557663,
-0.0313338265,
-0.0048857713,
0.0194451194,
0.0429467596,
0.0099107902,
-0.0207716562,
0.0221031606,
-0.0309289768,
0.0743327737,
-0.0400731489,
0.0038480237,
-0.1140576601,
0.0443861075,
-0.0052952524,
0.0231413003,
0.0345403068,
0.0152137242,
-0.0292794108,
0.0075551667,
0.0262585711,
-0.017196212,
-0.0776521415,
-0.0343895517,
0.0468551405,
0.0289066974,
-0.0059672622,
0.007481799,
0.0398662947,
-0.03981952,
0.0606790632,
0.0000017205,
-0.0162492879,
-0.0200473629,
-0.0125586623,
0.0328000747,
0.0525140613,
0.0246501677,
-0.0538783558,
-0.0548385568,
-0.0113184014,
-0.00722935,
0.0028481286,
0.0625441,
0.0527519695,
0.0168190654,
0.0744052306,
-0.0253263004,
-0.0545233786,
0.0162049551,
-0.0041376324,
-0.0375206582,
0.0210564509,
0.0117933657,
0.0066072694,
-0.0645676032,
-0.0067305788,
-0.0252560563,
0.031975057,
-0.0290483404,
-0.0164239034,
-0.0287125483,
-0.0252366457,
-0.0577245988,
0.0057178619,
-0.0134812733,
-0.024298666,
-0.0256774463,
-0.0264588688,
0.0198346972,
0.0146989515,
-0.0053320527,
-0.0379160605,
-0.0382706858,
-0.0134787755,
-0.0397604555,
0.0076061883,
0.013766204,
-0.0252374224,
0.0185193904,
-0.0081446366,
-0.0043775174,
0.0043028849,
0.026920246,
-0.0527681299,
-0.0405543633,
0.0117628081,
-0.0432571657,
-0.0065537272,
0.0497406051,
-0.01694474,
0.0035936793,
0.0089985253,
-0.0543858856,
-0.0581169873,
0.0214504413,
-0.020743195,
-0.003644261,
0.0511372425,
0.0103538074,
-0.0113813197,
-0.045417767,
0.0315550826,
0.0196414758,
-0.0060001812,
-0.0122400029,
0.0222240929,
-0.0062952875,
-0.0157640949,
-0.0320627503,
-0.0019806258,
-0.0124735972,
-0.0419085063,
-0.067113623,
-0.0439241529,
0.0225870516,
-0.014655265,
0.0477231629,
-0.0149947563,
-0.0353860855,
-0.0047889487,
-0.001514647,
-0.0043046712,
-0.0069089932,
0.0255033877,
0.0233881697,
-0.0316453204,
0.0009256996,
0.0238380786,
0.0263422467,
-0.0288872719,
-0.0124103613,
0.0098303156,
-0.0361502357,
0.0028956796,
-0.0357447006,
0.0101492824,
-0.0390366688,
-0.0318662859,
-0.0254250057,
-0.0469142497,
-0.0243276171,
0.016934162,
0.0161443781,
-0.0030290792,
0.0143781016,
0.0199926235,
-0.0377062298,
0.066150561,
-0.0119891092,
0.0083003007,
0.0216291733,
-0.0502627641,
0.0337388553,
-0.008966337,
0.082215704,
0.0202943217,
0.0751132593,
0.0397526585,
-0.0234029517,
0.0310080796,
-0.0408957899,
-0.0171386749,
-0.06632597,
-0.0278321113,
-0.0077158324,
0.0379966311,
-0.0160569847,
0.0685737804,
-0.008708681,
0.0029453153,
0.0443562791,
0.0401777104,
0.0203189943,
0.064627558,
0.0163393505,
-0.0195146352,
0.0555870123,
0.0127591286,
0.0101983249,
-0.04084545,
0.0129126944,
0.0739067718,
0.0456427187,
0.0367033295,
0.0405526757,
-0.0386886075,
-0.0182920061,
-0.0384027399,
0.0420371965,
-0.0452197269,
0.0538346283,
0.011860732,
-0.0833255053,
0.0247619879,
-0.0077271103,
-0.0473095998,
-0.0674460828,
-0.0051111709,
0.0121923788,
0.1256397367,
0.0686848611,
-0.0078200167,
0.0251700375,
0.0098793209,
-0.0177037213,
0.040853139,
0.0138815744,
0.0040505398,
0.0324852765,
-0.0621450804,
0.0330468453,
0.0666164979,
0.0396884866,
-0.0008782336,
0.018446099,
0.0202654414,
0.0315466374,
-0.0010228886,
-0.0389430262,
0.0550675765,
-0.0072375266,
0.0255724322,
-0.0345282294,
0.0057033147,
0.0038588417,
0.0302033927,
-0.0216983929,
0.022477394,
0.0298207495,
-0.0724871457,
0.031771332,
0.0191567708,
-0.0487782136,
-0.0445334949,
0.0359521881,
-0.0131272878,
0.0494117364,
0.0384145081,
0.0052152975,
-0.0445378385,
-0.0371249542,
0.0030874284,
0.032912869,
-0.0434065089,
0.0606477298,
-0.0276208892,
0.0108127305,
-0.0475917011,
0.0368429609,
-0.004406244,
0.0188850854,
0.018378729,
-0.0063050822,
0.0342881195,
-0.0044774744,
-0.023259528,
-0.0101579372,
-0.0001853686,
0.0094233332,
0.0087492159,
-0.0119582592,
-0.0302755423,
-0.0416265838,
-0.1047474667,
0.0330070108,
-0.0456806459,
0.022229014,
-0.0068754726,
0.0082087163,
-0.0297936872,
-0.0335333608,
0.0370259285,
0.0240027718,
-0.0029850085,
-0.0044857007,
0.0739065409,
-0.0287026856,
0.0123427678,
-0.0469346568,
-0.0176976323,
-0.0026083048,
0.0410766676,
0.0252323654,
-0.0794510692,
-0.0446777306,
0.0525432229,
0.0278570279,
0.0028519663,
0.0235678349,
-0.0798168108,
0.0159150921,
-0.0191712361,
0.0417506099,
0.0908739567,
0.0014246876,
-0.0222013704,
-0.049312517,
-0.0323039889,
0.0293392017,
-0.0115688071,
0.007448039,
0.0189898778,
-0.035924077,
0.0066057337,
-0.0264398605,
0.0712831244,
-0.0130272033,
0.0225625969,
-0.0418124646,
-0.0229557659,
0.000002128,
0.0130626643,
0.0477197468,
-0.0032966174,
-0.0478803515,
0.0118327141,
-0.0183417853,
-0.0322162844,
0.0203705188,
0.0067576142,
0.0216753278,
-0.0479783379,
0.0492470153,
-0.045349028,
0.0425722674,
0.0342724398,
-0.003852759,
0.0150921009,
-0.0704786032,
-0.0317536034,
0.0716475323,
0.0213978067,
-0.0457545146,
0.0018468446,
-0.0011776556,
0.0011603647,
-0.0253393762,
0.0057515712,
0.0026814211,
-0.0121355532,
-0.0137721281,
-0.0045268787,
0.0226244796,
-0.0315076485,
-0.0543085262,
0.040073473,
-0.035044115,
0.0487228185,
-0.0201775376,
0.0201024767,
-0.0206091031,
0.0333566219,
-0.0098597454,
-0.016941864,
-0.0398416445,
-0.0744839013,
0.0196910035,
0.0390269011,
-0.019446658,
0.0105179483,
-0.0258176457,
-0.0354318172,
0.021023998,
-0.0258382838,
-0.0594035052,
-0.0100339307,
0.0481744595,
-0.0794164315,
0.046014756,
0.1039185971,
0.0120243616,
-0.0232732575,
-0.0103084184,
-0.0117659485,
0.0265411474,
0.0088042188,
-0.0339222103,
-0.0737318322,
-0.0272870194,
0.0361195505,
-0.0073508262,
0.0108619528,
-0.0142568629,
0.0392076895,
-0.0718029067,
0.0162990205,
0.0222456753,
-0.0558611453,
-0.0384536125,
-0.0159218498,
-0.0024963035,
-0.0080811633,
-0.0285247359,
0.0107547911,
-0.0115516027,
0.0349831879,
0.0259939097,
-0.0639591664,
-0.0169728883,
-0.0460349768,
-0.0472803824,
0.0028697967,
0.0484423861,
0.08204633,
0.0124003747,
-0.0200642496,
-0.0228548944,
-0.0143697346,
0.0302850697,
-0.0204432383,
0.1007389873,
0.0219840202,
-0.0103522092,
-0.0156778079,
-0.0000480815,
-0.0338912942,
-0.0356922001,
0.0381608605,
-0.0467350222,
0.0166971702,
0.0091340598,
0.0078272978,
-0.0275441539,
0.0082667284,
0.0183336847,
-0.0072800322,
-0.0389955007,
-0.0942646265,
-0.0719607696,
0.0641215816,
-0.0839392468,
-0.0004581596,
0.0065201242,
-0.0575190596,
-0.0432897322,
-0.0716703311,
-0.0291418266,
-0.0225192811,
0.0464916639,
0.0254822541,
0.0189070422,
-0.0368962549,
0.0470840149,
-0.0465399325,
-0.0494602285,
0.0043254048,
0.0238302127,
-0.0461692065,
0.0241583847,
-0.0540098511,
-0.0001181108,
0.0026954229,
-0.0087875323,
-0.0724730119,
-0.0481369309,
0.0280483216,
0.0327485166,
0.0184775498,
0.0353375487,
0.0131965615,
0.0109498361,
-0.0190929919,
0.0517057516,
-0.0271768253,
-0.0047437963,
0.0085351402,
-0.0318445154,
-0.027961079,
0.0215875693,
0.042174425,
-0.0094445311,
-0.0138072055,
0.077368468,
-0.0399661288,
-0.0503102094,
0.0196430441,
0.0046461159,
0.0423811823,
-0.0403472111,
-0.0366560556,
-0.020044269,
0.0324147828,
-0.0371259712,
-0.0009360975,
-0.0170087237,
0.0023028916,
0.0225834511,
0.0041536065,
-0.0176772922,
-0.0509512424,
0.0140545741,
0.0031659938,
-0.0438761525,
-0.003429523,
0.0335539244,
0.0573695637,
0.0006978227,
0.0099464441,
0.0066515729,
0.0034320955,
-0.0036244048,
0.0269337483,
0.027304884,
0.018041838,
-0.0188290421,
-0.0030167045,
-0.017374495,
0.0007478935,
-0.0228909757,
-0.0013849742,
-0.033075247,
0.0122600319,
0.0770697296,
-0.0140795326,
0.0920756832,
-0.0416298024,
-0.031650424,
-0.0225986131,
0.0304303207,
0.043707028,
0.0256839488,
-0.0852691755,
-0.0058639138,
-0.0243737828,
-0.0146570373,
0.0468740426,
-0.0048749326,
-0.000908817,
0.0102237659,
-0.0882971734,
-0.0331115052,
0.0068838531,
0.025904404,
0.005705724,
0.0021100934,
-0.0182752889,
-0.0219214782,
-0.0283664465,
0.0087093636,
0.025737267,
0.0218931548,
-0.0171434414,
-0.0308044422,
0.0545152538,
-0.0267956946,
-0.0141873024,
-0.0831769705,
0.0229653027,
0.0168360379,
0.005842343,
-0.0344499871,
-4.9930996e-33,
0.0005633391,
0.0353162177,
-0.0222102441,
0.022333866,
-0.039304059,
-0.0327593237,
-0.0375014171,
0.0167488083,
0.0273803733,
0.0161481909,
-0.0154104279,
-0.0075940457,
0.0334896594,
0.0175697915,
0.0410503559,
0.0331710838,
0.0802200064,
-0.0071955929,
0.0128314951,
-0.0183392186,
0.0365049653,
0.069386147,
0.0663395375,
-0.0237890966,
0.0223689992,
-0.0420095995,
-0.0015560291,
-0.0101806251,
0.0408230051,
0.0621633194,
0.032277111,
0.0144894114,
0.0215517897,
0.016441796,
-0.0231887624,
0.0170758273,
-0.0772635713,
0.0286425725,
0.0060729925,
0.090074271,
-0.0348423086,
-0.0349347442,
0.0057267672,
-0.0197450798,
0.030327756,
-0.0241080001,
0.0307319667,
-0.0783080459,
-0.0360831022,
-0.0256348345,
-0.0622546449,
0.049472183,
-0.0168646723,
0.0192138273,
0.0469279662,
0.0223940481,
-0.0124496371,
0.0264151581,
-0.0382553488,
-0.0183762871,
0.0370873027,
0.0624142736,
0.0199790094,
0.027251184,
0.0033950531,
0.0281904284,
0.0204397459,
0.0246153735,
0.0200176649,
0.0311782435,
0.0210877582,
0.016566515,
0.0023559984,
0.0437128916,
0.0714982748,
-0.0422072411,
-0.0573664233,
-0.0160071254,
-0.0038835995,
0.0270626377,
0.0267630909,
0.0537636355,
-0.0483524613,
0.0075498912,
0.0073520583,
-0.0225635022,
0.0159144998,
-0.0367385596,
0.0093587516,
0.0117112389,
-0.0203446522,
0.01861839,
0.0226868112,
-0.0551329926,
0.0000562815,
-0.0110262325,
-0.0172100291,
0.0385838114,
-0.0443879589,
0.0023464232,
-0.021335138,
-0.0411557369,
-0.0127325663,
-0.009732022,
0.0024704619,
-0.0225061327,
0.0228047855,
-0.0015013455,
-0.080529213,
0.0145103736,
0.0335542373,
-0.0290299449,
0.0134731559,
0.0608408786,
0.0004933985,
0.0148703083,
0.0252687801,
0.0134265684,
0.0436653048,
0.0104815308,
-0.0124837803,
-0.0512736551,
0.0132363103,
-0.0331124403,
-0.0031633205,
-0.037305709,
-0.0131628048,
0.0358804092,
-0.0186478104,
-0.0503158644,
-0.0152794058,
0.0063864444,
2.289e-7,
0.0561674349,
0.0555444956,
0.0538532622,
-0.0176564716,
0.0093638254,
-0.0000873713,
-0.015798809,
0.0166213978,
0.0275249835,
0.0223936792,
0.0505249463,
-0.0311906002,
0.1008569151,
-0.0173044819,
-0.1201291531,
0.035866376,
-0.0487490334,
-0.0282263253,
-0.0480001345,
0.0268834662,
0.0088517666,
0.0574254803,
-0.021482978,
-0.0060729384,
-0.0013114404,
-0.0117532937,
0.0309320707,
-0.005345426,
-0.026876606,
0.0467828885,
0.1064975485,
-0.0306157563,
-0.005503431,
0.0288619548,
-0.0105753271,
0.0038331735,
0.0693629831,
0.0646573529,
-0.0115305511,
0.0742526725,
0.0230414253,
-0.0146307759,
-0.0129757049,
-0.0627536252,
0.0223988444,
0.0778777525,
0.0240880325,
-0.0348023698,
-0.0384545289,
0.024234239,
0.0421044044,
0.0006091441,
-0.0139008584,
0.0307112522,
0.0259213913,
0.0240847506,
-0.0035769925,
0.0099861501,
-0.077457279,
-0.0058400971,
-0.0132831661,
-0.0108069368,
-0.005555484,
-0.020306142,
-0.0200267192,
-0.0469602197,
-0.0052503515,
2.246975589e-34,
0.0389819853,
-0.0451838635,
-0.0036591408,
0.0618609637,
0.0040831775,
-0.0546844937,
0.0224423092,
0.0524112359,
-0.0045146262,
-0.0522188991,
0.0149307624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11875v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11875v3 | Sparse is Enough in Fine-tuning Pre-trained Large Language Models | 2023-12-19T06:06:30 | 2024-06-08T03:29:17 | Weixi Song, Zuchao Li, Lefei Zhang, Hai Zhao, Bo Du | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | With the prevalence of pre-training-fine-tuning paradigm, how to efficiently
adapt the pre-trained model to the downstream tasks has been an intriguing
issue. Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods have been proposed for
low-cost adaptation. Although PEFT has demonstrated effectiveness and been
widely applied, the underlying principles are still unclear. In this paper, we
adopt the PAC-Bayesian generalization error bound, viewing pre-training as a
shift of prior distribution which leads to a tighter bound for generalization
error. We validate this shift from the perspectives of oscillations in the loss
landscape and the quasi-sparsity in gradient distribution. Based on this, we
propose a gradient-based sparse fine-tuning algorithm, named Sparse Increment
Fine-Tuning (SIFT), and validate its effectiveness on a range of tasks
including the GLUE Benchmark and Instruction-tuning. The code is accessible at
https://github.com/song-wx/SIFT/. | [
0.0072505735,
0.0908357576,
0.0124856057,
0.0191822164,
0.0257446133,
0.0273474678,
-0.011657564,
-0.0159566347,
-0.0761122406,
-0.0268796459,
-0.0751148984,
-0.0544899441,
0.0259158276,
-0.001669945,
0.0594300777,
-0.0378308147,
0.0442874879,
-0.0323434919,
-0.003601121,
-0.0092796916,
0.0024880494,
0.0220006853,
-0.009003317,
0.027867794,
0.0102609219,
0.0209707636,
0.0072040074,
0.0388577841,
0.0307169165,
0.0190133043,
0.0267649852,
0.0728285909,
0.0234175101,
0.0262247343,
0.0000020169,
-0.0374031477,
-0.0016781935,
0.0008276296,
-0.0117475996,
0.0539389588,
0.0211796481,
0.0065839197,
-0.0435017757,
0.0133521343,
-0.0071816789,
-0.0631889999,
0.0827534422,
0.0055664005,
0.0599687248,
0.1110182628,
-0.0147914197,
-0.0377766006,
0.0166844875,
-0.0595785156,
-0.0046801018,
-0.0835595578,
0.0224989224,
-0.0127283409,
-0.0257509965,
-0.0325427428,
-0.0324615873,
0.0156207802,
-0.0043099932,
0.0371506922,
-0.0095281936,
0.0168671198,
-0.0305712689,
-0.001335995,
0.0025677418,
0.0492139906,
-0.0971068367,
-0.0286554694,
-0.0060429345,
-0.0182685368,
-0.0196822546,
-0.0141514447,
-0.0312931724,
-0.0101606334,
0.0389761291,
0.0251762439,
0.0290519595,
-0.046186354,
0.0630924553,
0.0224464163,
-0.0615938231,
0.030643899,
0.0300270077,
-0.0046402225,
0.0024943075,
-0.0055419304,
-0.0521228984,
-0.0091644125,
-0.0238573663,
0.033676248,
-0.0457025506,
0.0032107087,
-0.1062148884,
-0.030561287,
-0.019962525,
-0.0067086741,
0.0959804207,
0.0410103723,
-0.0051273913,
0.0542423427,
-0.0148267765,
0.0048455233,
-0.0152848968,
0.040289253,
-0.0372353047,
0.0326554514,
-0.0060469978,
0.0155066978,
-0.0524965748,
0.0185576063,
-0.0155143868,
-0.0154047972,
-0.0068359063,
-0.0077337166,
0.016778158,
-0.0160232261,
0.0139227519,
-0.0392342135,
-0.0456449725,
-0.0224525686,
0.0353969149,
0.0401705205,
-0.0487578027,
0.0178773198,
0.0060948944,
-0.0540993437,
-0.0274464227,
0.0133968005,
0.0199436694,
-0.0367512219,
0.0340851061,
0.018678328,
-0.0321855173,
-0.0328316279,
-0.059132047,
0.0293006245,
-0.006796944,
-0.0587531924,
-0.010191327,
-0.0565890782,
-0.0032765053,
-0.0230875257,
0.0346540138,
-0.0605567656,
-0.0186088476,
-0.0141969947,
-0.0589643084,
0.0413628332,
-0.0503870919,
0.0176849458,
0.0139698051,
0.0029918144,
0.0339655206,
0.0866102353,
0.0204185173,
0.0118411733,
0.0084575983,
-0.0187449697,
-0.0444430746,
0.0374240503,
0.0388908125,
0.0256080348,
-0.0239681993,
-0.0099220248,
0.0228281077,
-0.0022113805,
0.0370465331,
0.0228557214,
-0.0441977121,
-0.019224599,
0.0374142528,
0.0422123149,
0.0165768676,
0.0182287507,
0.0193481129,
-0.0110606002,
0.0211241674,
0.002702012,
-0.0629361793,
-0.0046884743,
-0.0343359634,
0.0073002526,
0.0307099689,
0.0360364318,
-0.0532316715,
-0.025588559,
0.013404225,
-0.0028021017,
-0.0140843289,
0.0017792204,
0.0603071973,
0.0207737256,
-0.0391678624,
0.0206517484,
0.0520384759,
-0.0257454682,
0.0111210877,
-0.0702466965,
-0.0023930387,
0.0148921646,
0.0225315001,
-0.0438461043,
-0.0699773729,
0.0143119022,
0.026286874,
-0.0205315538,
0.0393156745,
0.0110926582,
0.0315459445,
-0.0613727383,
-0.0038690222,
-0.010978492,
0.0262748804,
0.0203821938,
0.0101585798,
0.0228342358,
0.0441716984,
0.0002253971,
-0.0259566996,
0.0300536938,
-0.009764079,
-0.031702593,
0.0151668061,
0.0145029975,
0.0285153147,
-0.0005678532,
-0.0428054854,
0.0050357208,
0.0208635889,
-0.0044979784,
0.0450343788,
-0.0338935405,
-0.0279577971,
0.0184298214,
0.0357132554,
0.0083358679,
0.0347482488,
0.0182921309,
-0.0547784977,
-0.061737746,
0.0366611518,
-0.0059321667,
0.0459403247,
-0.0222354364,
0.0389976427,
-0.0435200594,
0.0517179631,
-0.023989113,
-0.0035692325,
0.007290788,
-0.020324342,
-0.0054826234,
0.0547666028,
-0.0117811402,
-0.0142541667,
-0.0687613264,
0.0011477581,
-0.0144272121,
0.0297443327,
0.004315895,
0.017657809,
-0.0179078691,
-0.0108811269,
-0.0654353872,
0.0455002785,
-0.0648879483,
0.033280652,
0.0301261656,
0.03025412,
-0.0197574515,
-0.0259626973,
0.0054742983,
0.016672451,
-0.0168992132,
0.0079477811,
-0.0106746359,
0.01875454,
-0.0217223577,
-0.0513330512,
-0.0449865349,
0.0409131795,
0.0294926986,
-0.0242805127,
-0.0111146756,
-0.0677413791,
0.0505607873,
-0.0073663532,
0.02645123,
-0.0064156544,
-0.0598780289,
-0.0125812953,
-0.0565015152,
0.0420309976,
0.0829122663,
-0.007347587,
0.0383308418,
0.0292535424,
-0.0081920456,
0.0037549133,
0.0028035257,
-0.0199650116,
-0.0738981664,
-0.0649937764,
0.005792188,
-0.0026058988,
0.0890823528,
-0.0565794222,
-0.0143822813,
-0.068320483,
-0.0026208593,
-0.0138390688,
-0.0130235562,
-0.0125832893,
0.0523312762,
-0.0077007371,
0.0109066907,
-0.0118380999,
-0.0618148632,
0.0374302827,
-0.030358091,
0.0060592759,
-0.0306216571,
-0.0236634724,
-0.0211439021,
0.0235995241,
0.0244868174,
0.0114193512,
-0.0006822133,
-0.022480594,
-0.0713010356,
0.001873207,
-0.0046645436,
0.0057293735,
0.0448825173,
-0.0424127206,
0.0205749087,
-0.0243095197,
-0.0018048543,
0.0100824898,
-0.0233999472,
-0.0185074825,
0.0251061078,
0.049708914,
-0.0580247082,
-0.0328510031,
0.0026954522,
-0.0295925941,
0.0617455281,
-0.0098774163,
0.0049884734,
-0.0300276559,
-0.0005870918,
0.0641450807,
0.0265859943,
0.0070505003,
-0.0213897135,
-0.064457044,
-0.010658903,
0.0487763844,
-0.0072131953,
-0.0478373878,
0.0109177073,
0.0421299674,
-0.0015217183,
-0.0246393345,
0.0253093522,
0.0631822273,
-0.0571489669,
-0.0125114415,
0.1023182794,
0.0110753691,
-0.0625819862,
0.0166145805,
0.0472208224,
0.0772371963,
0.0258650798,
0.0313825235,
-0.0507659391,
-0.0472924449,
0.0004197282,
0.0272045266,
0.0308762174,
0.0072549302,
-0.0058003725,
-0.0910889059,
-0.0044039963,
0.0482085384,
-0.0495083183,
-0.0090611195,
-0.0359736346,
0.0230909977,
-0.0420977809,
0.0201396476,
0.0051590996,
-0.0166378785,
-0.0027122076,
0.029693136,
0.008211175,
-0.115131408,
-0.0048421239,
-0.0353684127,
0.0576676354,
0.0426639244,
-0.0214802399,
-0.0038998355,
-0.0016501896,
0.0674845874,
-0.0077281888,
0.0000277306,
-0.0227297377,
0.0257302206,
-0.004116592,
-0.0232483316,
0.0478148125,
0.0335116573,
-0.0271155853,
0.0264927093,
0.0029678678,
0.0545885749,
0.0128069278,
-0.0084662056,
0.0251056012,
-0.0349231884,
-0.0057206904,
0.0073580882,
0.0255480185,
-0.0488934293,
-0.0152868824,
-0.0132893231,
0.0077535212,
-0.0097664716,
-0.013870623,
-0.0003364685,
-0.0232838001,
-0.0297098551,
-0.0317551941,
0.0176429059,
0.0316546112,
0.0694051459,
-0.0131961154,
-0.0184226949,
0.0228849184,
0.00808019,
-0.0413208343,
0.0402816013,
-0.0363138281,
0.0151686547,
-0.0821375251,
-0.0433246158,
0.0237304009,
0.007047792,
-0.0157065708,
-0.0182875022,
-0.1083223447,
-0.0835196748,
0.010427271,
0.0669378489,
0.0120868906,
0.0317424685,
-0.0222934522,
-0.0939520448,
0.0191122759,
0.0252252277,
-0.0075469925,
0.0385089144,
0.0500268899,
-0.0835356489,
-0.017052399,
0.034996938,
-0.0334645323,
0.0376312584,
0.0408151969,
0.0209365934,
0.00496038,
-0.0266648643,
-0.0176615249,
0.0022807769,
0.0329019316,
-0.0151926111,
0.0212107301,
-0.0314920396,
0.0305819698,
0.0386080593,
0.0119682122,
-0.033014603,
-0.0281643383,
0.025634395,
-0.0035852275,
-0.0076612118,
-0.0075432751,
0.0212198086,
0.0356218182,
-0.0383441374,
0.0195993707,
0.0252476241,
0.0294989254,
0.0769418776,
0.0021018558,
-0.0052791098,
0.0309618283,
0.0146174226,
0.0178777762,
-0.0306456331,
0.018306287,
0.0217701104,
0.0156559832,
-0.0581640825,
0.018672986,
-0.0351962447,
-0.0855832398,
-0.0550949052,
0.0379618593,
0.0804619566,
-0.0316159055,
0.0578769073,
0.0011354689,
-0.0182235446,
-0.0282852687,
0.0177615806,
-0.0068541518,
0.0120135564,
-0.0134219639,
0.0170686692,
-0.0057406877,
0.0254467092,
0.0699260309,
0.0250554141,
0.036453031,
0.0072820503,
0.0222186316,
-0.0108610382,
-0.033786729,
-0.000562288,
0.0388432667,
-0.0192827433,
0.0296896119,
0.0288699307,
-0.0817790404,
-0.0550235324,
-0.0244614892,
0.0303627327,
0.0148645304,
0.035612341,
0.0373514891,
-0.0286537502,
0.0320723467,
-0.0031029428,
-0.036302004,
0.0015547217,
0.0051400806,
0.0179537367,
-6.901455903e-33,
-0.0355232507,
0.0389823839,
-0.0154950414,
0.0270457286,
-0.0116650276,
-0.0233019348,
-0.0167520922,
0.0086046029,
-0.0291040894,
0.0063393423,
-0.0164101962,
0.0053548785,
0.0246292911,
0.0529421791,
-0.0456626303,
0.0090378476,
0.0815055817,
-0.0041850293,
-0.0042150025,
0.0320121609,
0.00030304,
0.0340497419,
0.0753995478,
-0.0114785163,
-0.0333234966,
0.0153223658,
-0.0265156012,
0.0209729765,
0.0104025854,
0.0262388755,
0.0150143867,
0.0257050265,
-0.0081545766,
0.0075834361,
-0.0434211008,
-0.007348055,
-0.0733801052,
-0.0265636332,
0.0283787828,
0.0115254875,
-0.0055947131,
-0.0089510269,
0.0174186286,
-0.0058186194,
-0.0061566066,
-0.0306029115,
0.0147334235,
-0.0386032313,
-0.0315823331,
-0.0242770351,
-0.0626199469,
0.040226683,
-0.0019859134,
-0.0041975793,
0.0328066461,
-0.0321117528,
-0.0226064194,
-0.0187685322,
-0.0130994897,
0.0038498358,
0.0556266122,
0.0878074095,
0.0565998293,
0.0635225773,
-0.0125773447,
-0.0069242697,
0.0103159044,
0.0280492567,
0.0208245963,
0.0170723591,
0.0844863951,
0.0186567158,
-0.0006797756,
-0.0180809312,
0.0689004138,
-0.0235001445,
-0.0678112358,
-0.0275437348,
0.0099231396,
0.0447208807,
0.0395849757,
0.0544241332,
0.0136675928,
-0.0124500301,
-0.061734695,
0.0175815672,
-0.0406278707,
-0.0143932169,
0.012648955,
0.0256767534,
-0.0365372896,
0.0279825721,
0.028096864,
-0.0351883247,
0.0347479358,
0.0057221493,
-0.0200009514,
0.0054676929,
-0.0314822346,
0.0168107226,
-0.0633410066,
-0.0867481604,
0.0228725187,
-0.013591771,
0.016868975,
-0.0179616362,
0.0409674384,
0.0427441746,
-0.0502856486,
-0.0195208453,
-0.0057244464,
0.0039398316,
0.0253716297,
0.0788347051,
0.025456598,
-0.0199862234,
0.0110359685,
0.0717167333,
0.0061708572,
-0.0030623374,
-0.0015803557,
-0.0065208799,
0.0245160665,
0.0197094977,
-0.0301238783,
0.030846104,
-0.0406649224,
-0.0253193211,
0.0209388547,
-0.0713102594,
-0.0389594063,
0.0053681191,
2.756e-7,
0.0224614292,
0.0291505568,
-0.0193263758,
0.0136603015,
0.0106514283,
-0.0019727959,
-0.0143396324,
-0.0077930056,
-0.0074134502,
0.0136839068,
0.0385494158,
0.0311464164,
0.0484268889,
0.0047972016,
-0.0532699786,
-0.0074923728,
-0.0688673705,
0.0622808374,
-0.0358811952,
-0.028727917,
-0.0171543136,
0.1055990383,
0.0088121695,
-0.0232979506,
0.0286650266,
-0.0147945685,
0.0412551425,
-0.0200284515,
0.0202616733,
0.0523699038,
-0.0145202139,
0.0415887684,
-0.0301603246,
-0.0016724078,
-0.024728274,
0.0424440689,
-0.0030254377,
0.0667662919,
-0.0346622542,
0.0172058176,
0.0219535977,
0.0087214923,
0.0029528087,
-0.0513518006,
0.0606626086,
-0.0802068263,
-0.0121909641,
-0.0545779169,
-0.0093708346,
-0.0221882388,
0.0182486828,
-0.0549592227,
-0.0061647529,
0.0043141949,
0.0536106192,
-0.0073453006,
-0.0461073183,
-0.1004337072,
0.022189578,
0.1002917737,
-0.007027355,
-0.041706752,
-0.053377375,
-0.0551552325,
0.0383132063,
-0.0270818081,
0.0238343403,
2.514660678e-34,
0.0760128498,
-0.0353824794,
0.024325002,
-0.0023389934,
0.0358189754,
-0.0060501299,
-0.0343898945,
0.0214697663,
0.0113235554,
-0.0900242925,
-0.0246913079
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11870v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11870v1 | A Revisit of Fake News Dataset with Augmented Fact-checking by ChatGPT | 2023-12-19T05:46:11 | 2023-12-19T05:46:11 | Zizhong Li, Haopeng Zhang, Jiawei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The proliferation of fake news has emerged as a critical issue in recent
years, requiring significant efforts to detect it. However, the existing fake
news detection datasets are sourced from human journalists, which are likely to
have inherent bias limitations due to the highly subjective nature of this
task. In this paper, we revisit the existing fake news dataset verified by
human journalists with augmented fact-checking by large language models
(ChatGPT), and we name the augmented fake news dataset ChatGPT-FC. We
quantitatively analyze the distinctions and resemblances between human
journalists and LLM in assessing news subject credibility, news creator
credibility, time-sensitive, and political framing. Our findings highlight
LLM's potential to serve as a preliminary screening method, offering a
promising avenue to mitigate the inherent biases of human journalists and
enhance fake news detection. | [
0.0641049892,
0.0309512075,
0.0020532599,
0.0339061059,
-0.0523826592,
0.0066579077,
0.022216253,
-0.0003190745,
0.027184777,
-0.0287332051,
-0.0162529685,
-0.0363767929,
0.0026348513,
0.0421297513,
0.0243041944,
-0.00318019,
0.0688680559,
0.0415669344,
0.0691308677,
-0.0137113146,
0.0334705226,
0.0461358465,
-0.0246233046,
0.0243532006,
-0.0221843608,
-0.0050778687,
0.0243406817,
0.0109382551,
0.0452793688,
-0.0089048371,
-0.0254850201,
0.0498346016,
0.0256818868,
0.0864391923,
0.0000013806,
0.0034085952,
-0.0063798097,
0.003195401,
-0.0474603139,
-0.0016721685,
0.0594717003,
-0.0578741245,
-0.0351474695,
0.0375661477,
-0.0467360057,
-0.0590698272,
0.0089427866,
0.0361856297,
0.1057148427,
0.1342234164,
-0.0120889815,
0.0330246985,
0.0156953316,
-0.0101852044,
0.0102585442,
-0.0385951623,
0.0518363975,
0.0409262292,
-0.0429549143,
0.0699271336,
0.043867249,
-0.0210111961,
0.0331483632,
-0.0241380259,
-0.0692958534,
0.0092262272,
-0.0647348762,
-0.0139634628,
0.007486437,
-0.0016930951,
0.001369358,
-0.0722453594,
0.0030959249,
0.0062373737,
0.0003613234,
0.0450812057,
0.0101174917,
0.0338234603,
-0.044643376,
-0.0013466179,
0.0271307901,
-0.0272824112,
0.0281039625,
0.0720600635,
0.0413242802,
0.0380561911,
-0.0027642453,
-0.0132084657,
0.0094138142,
-0.0010051308,
0.0125314733,
-0.0642746538,
-0.0062107877,
-0.0106574558,
-0.0108237267,
0.0018208758,
-0.0551774167,
0.0233968887,
0.0280124471,
-0.0973519534,
-0.04964488,
0.0121913534,
-0.0073973858,
0.0656974092,
-0.0161550138,
0.0003553547,
-0.0226346236,
0.01470342,
0.0056721992,
-0.0116758468,
0.0032515891,
0.0322792269,
0.0147493361,
-0.0200336911,
-0.0126915183,
0.0143924076,
-0.0521366708,
0.0098508867,
-0.0097260652,
0.0256643407,
-0.0067813192,
-0.0039384398,
-0.0125261266,
-0.027997857,
-0.0464715473,
0.037040703,
-0.0117698153,
0.0354050472,
-0.0143979369,
-0.050151702,
-0.0093026375,
0.0436016172,
-0.0151099712,
0.0036115337,
-0.0036286626,
-0.0191198923,
-0.004843886,
0.0134987878,
-0.0410490744,
-0.0145897195,
-0.0015933537,
-0.0597026609,
0.0078335693,
-0.0746914595,
0.0002638273,
-0.0213122107,
-0.0020193518,
-0.005607341,
-0.019123368,
0.0433738679,
-0.0131427078,
0.0484672338,
0.0115680965,
0.0256732684,
0.0632575378,
0.0261155404,
-0.0205438826,
0.0961643159,
0.0065534692,
0.0778629929,
0.0456710607,
0.031116128,
0.0122494586,
0.0196499415,
0.0324900635,
0.0729736313,
0.0003347371,
-0.004141429,
-0.0153478542,
-0.0039755129,
0.0300420243,
0.0116640031,
-0.0263098013,
-0.0426728092,
0.0778971389,
-0.0296191704,
0.0017492952,
-0.0023650988,
0.0656020939,
0.0089628939,
0.0354539305,
0.0192023218,
-0.0317673758,
0.0084457481,
-0.0543468483,
-0.024017781,
-0.0190703683,
0.0646199137,
-0.0106705632,
-0.0012611309,
-0.0095325895,
0.0251316465,
0.0147611341,
-0.015030846,
-0.0310879461,
-0.011426406,
-0.0461142212,
0.0153044853,
0.0315825939,
-0.0134029184,
0.0019305787,
-0.0728253946,
0.0244204737,
-0.0082386145,
0.023646934,
0.0423052497,
0.0158725921,
-0.0284971949,
0.0321847349,
0.0367007107,
0.0405878015,
-0.0312938429,
-0.0675577447,
0.0189299379,
-0.0100561669,
-0.0064880517,
0.0375240892,
0.0113814827,
0.0616049729,
0.0467621647,
-0.006676909,
-0.0237687919,
-0.0492621846,
0.0118259992,
-0.0207975209,
0.0077258125,
-0.0208453052,
0.0119134858,
0.0040286421,
0.0175309498,
-0.0022429391,
-0.0282335579,
0.0553493723,
0.0201229192,
-0.0129098091,
-0.0260726027,
0.0014236162,
-0.0369923003,
-0.0089352373,
-0.0239184294,
-0.0448611118,
0.0456473082,
-0.0032130622,
0.0144589143,
-0.0023589684,
0.0004676706,
0.0154756997,
-0.0513327345,
-0.0210911129,
-0.0265109092,
0.0077097467,
0.0225401334,
0.0900004581,
-0.0401245877,
0.0039115259,
0.0039942432,
0.0203076303,
-0.0141819827,
-0.0086073121,
0.0070537115,
0.0188969299,
0.0111422222,
0.0255425386,
0.0181601569,
-0.0126707852,
-0.0173156094,
-0.0396964848,
-0.0664304867,
-0.0093731936,
-0.0287373234,
-0.0069716349,
0.0590493605,
-0.0245887879,
-0.0076759076,
0.0351354927,
-0.0518624,
-0.0459574722,
0.0011176076,
0.0191629436,
-0.0145942383,
-0.0289735105,
0.0088629164,
0.0021474732,
0.0310431924,
-0.0214808974,
0.0340357274,
0.0174741484,
-0.0397357456,
-0.0317606404,
0.0027746393,
-0.0508335233,
-0.0169875938,
-0.0363963097,
-0.0251530427,
0.0111173047,
0.0218692385,
0.0009564405,
0.0583958589,
0.0417957529,
0.0625251755,
0.0166293401,
0.0483297557,
0.0019713899,
-0.0326421596,
-0.0398318581,
0.0241010729,
-0.0209570061,
-0.0823777765,
0.0140598714,
0.0056740069,
0.0170993786,
0.0186522249,
-0.0046652905,
0.0758258253,
-0.0101449387,
-0.0068437541,
0.0589662082,
-0.0290654842,
-0.0211665351,
0.0306977611,
-0.0415279828,
-0.0240104571,
0.0740891993,
-0.0321899652,
0.0646849945,
-0.013674112,
-0.0305873156,
-0.0287467036,
0.0014936184,
-0.0229393765,
0.0211012475,
-0.0242482666,
0.0186545197,
-0.0088056466,
-0.0156346262,
0.0747488514,
-0.0349277556,
-0.0066722301,
-0.0288460515,
0.0376993306,
0.0330325551,
-0.0110661983,
-0.0428369902,
-0.1112628952,
-0.0118970778,
-0.0312519968,
-0.0172728803,
-0.0416122675,
-0.0858590975,
-0.0025921187,
0.042775549,
0.0356813595,
-0.0246104542,
0.021032935,
0.0267981701,
0.0415460877,
0.0159786958,
0.0215108693,
0.0608286671,
0.0085657313,
-0.0062478818,
0.0513769537,
-0.0047480981,
0.0272119306,
0.0004641006,
-0.0295475461,
0.0024664137,
0.0151833789,
0.0037754348,
-0.0303580556,
0.0121183544,
-0.0308775734,
0.0290884804,
0.0851036757,
0.0160561725,
-0.0379571915,
-0.0134389866,
0.0493895262,
-0.0239513405,
0.0372144431,
-0.0287876297,
-0.0847467184,
0.0107411891,
0.0040228195,
-0.0221915524,
-0.0720302686,
-0.027956225,
-0.0521292873,
-0.0867508128,
0.0252282526,
-0.0094175488,
-0.0214404725,
-0.0145338913,
-0.1007343009,
0.0022425409,
-0.0101287263,
0.015149829,
0.0070765773,
0.0462202057,
-0.0256878473,
-0.0121245272,
0.0109559083,
-0.073514387,
0.0271761511,
-0.0041810255,
0.0586199313,
0.031490162,
0.0610199459,
-0.0194663573,
-0.0431322046,
0.0040066447,
0.0366465971,
-0.0675014183,
-0.0087999282,
0.042493917,
-0.0614488348,
-0.0091074798,
-0.028452307,
0.0594445094,
0.0402732454,
0.002206641,
-0.0187869221,
0.0316914096,
0.0165183879,
-0.0509890728,
-0.0143551808,
0.0217744559,
0.0367621444,
0.0726487041,
0.0147440899,
-0.0056562815,
0.0299059842,
-0.0034012184,
-0.0321239531,
0.016872324,
-0.0839604959,
0.0564900711,
-0.0262601748,
-0.0520168208,
-0.0502662919,
-0.0091077434,
-0.0270557571,
0.0184658784,
-0.034747906,
0.0004663051,
0.0408338904,
-0.0151133155,
-0.0144720152,
0.0186165217,
-0.0030527792,
0.036148794,
-0.0126567269,
0.0166706517,
0.0067654275,
-0.0149835581,
-0.0071200486,
0.0478399694,
-0.09156207,
-0.0373973288,
0.0165124666,
-0.0365490839,
0.0238184407,
0.0372201279,
-0.0165437795,
-0.0132212555,
0.0096565345,
0.0374179222,
-0.0646966174,
0.0384279303,
0.0048088362,
0.0022864353,
0.0397143885,
0.0096825212,
-0.0117389243,
0.0357743241,
0.0188858118,
-0.0365582518,
-0.0438901521,
-0.0066805226,
0.0486656986,
0.0102188494,
0.0411229543,
-0.001846126,
0.0340533964,
-0.0333519466,
-0.0549153388,
-0.039589569,
-0.0321882181,
0.0055576107,
0.0174902938,
0.0245894361,
-0.0175767597,
-0.0269452743,
-0.0031866315,
-0.0425062403,
0.0181883071,
-0.0304447729,
-0.0211639199,
-0.0272251293,
0.0277141314,
-0.0072089937,
-0.024109453,
-0.0466756076,
0.021561332,
-0.0341502093,
0.0000756094,
-0.0074621602,
0.0076951603,
0.0350304209,
-0.0236257315,
0.0413663313,
-0.0290940981,
-0.0687269419,
0.0033133675,
-0.0370449163,
0.0496143289,
0.0130802821,
-0.007703023,
0.0358996913,
-0.003188181,
-0.0290720575,
-0.0080654249,
-0.0330390744,
0.0112041971,
-0.0286049526,
0.0138394684,
0.0158076826,
-0.0493363664,
0.0532875024,
0.0558331646,
0.0192733668,
0.0269454382,
0.0278276112,
-0.0762928203,
-0.0129621504,
-0.0225226842,
-0.0237915143,
0.0000960918,
0.006259142,
-0.0288545489,
-0.09529154,
-0.0537997447,
-0.0026028948,
0.0352900699,
0.0323371328,
0.0153256962,
-0.0635717437,
0.0926682204,
0.0021903447,
0.0228568725,
-0.0428087339,
0.0101735024,
-0.0079591032,
-0.043972861,
0.0104899574,
-5.786844446e-33,
0.0284028761,
-0.0682144463,
-0.0210496616,
-0.0099430075,
-0.0020251267,
0.0627942011,
0.0019991174,
-0.0102532199,
-0.0640576705,
0.0365620479,
0.0208745692,
0.0622651987,
0.0048106308,
-0.0199389812,
-0.0768828839,
0.0081801778,
0.0431773253,
-0.015801983,
-0.0509124361,
0.0105161397,
0.0271230452,
-0.053047657,
0.0247348715,
-0.0464708321,
0.0795924067,
-0.0292288717,
-0.0625598207,
0.0096514756,
-0.0222566947,
0.0529292077,
0.0031168128,
0.0344097242,
0.0472780652,
-0.0431415029,
0.0084166275,
0.0262199789,
-0.0435365103,
-0.0013708139,
0.0439335071,
-0.0206257105,
-0.0164851677,
0.0160869639,
0.0128656495,
-0.010030414,
-0.0322395265,
0.0113632213,
-0.0032025832,
-0.0238263495,
-0.009901478,
0.0108509269,
-0.0053414637,
0.0213436391,
0.0213197134,
0.010945973,
-0.0580942407,
0.044168435,
0.0138713652,
0.0123882517,
-0.0911875218,
0.0316286199,
-0.0439256914,
0.0118030645,
0.0125055276,
-0.0449472517,
-0.0361590721,
0.0539429262,
0.0257123969,
0.0593553782,
-0.054869324,
-0.0023128958,
0.0132499523,
0.0063264277,
0.0399134047,
0.1272016168,
0.01939971,
-0.0707801655,
-0.082201764,
0.0298969783,
0.0601828247,
-0.005464918,
0.0106614903,
-0.0346436538,
-0.0229740515,
0.0034334201,
-0.034072686,
-0.0176590104,
-0.0447029583,
-0.01583446,
-0.0143477637,
0.0370473489,
-0.014647143,
0.025508957,
0.0122381262,
-0.0246636309,
0.0244586021,
0.0251642298,
-0.0746100172,
-0.0099577596,
-0.0059555704,
0.0621109679,
-0.0615235828,
0.0330942161,
0.0233773738,
0.0317302346,
0.0013998313,
-0.0384397171,
0.0547988303,
0.0068818606,
-0.0505535193,
0.0149188768,
-0.0271868631,
0.0391295813,
0.0037813121,
-0.0106112575,
0.0496318936,
-0.01044631,
-0.0184949115,
-0.0054282527,
-0.0076367813,
-0.0078311879,
-0.0100220358,
-0.0077334489,
-0.0251738112,
0.0345887169,
-0.0094220508,
-0.0073148403,
-0.0211686119,
0.0207436476,
0.0179599579,
-0.068877019,
0.0066938382,
-0.006689216,
2.345e-7,
-0.0288041942,
0.0414824001,
-0.01977502,
0.0419512801,
0.0109944884,
0.0355563052,
0.0291219149,
0.0121890763,
-0.0283239651,
-0.0993225127,
-0.0294281002,
0.0299166441,
0.0326143503,
0.0452792048,
-0.0405295938,
0.0347870812,
-0.0774812326,
-0.0038208051,
-0.0513302386,
-0.0174451973,
0.0170225557,
0.0516726263,
0.0447253324,
-0.0188741367,
-0.0054412442,
-0.0261544492,
0.0738485157,
0.0457064435,
-0.0813551992,
0.0203925036,
0.0674806237,
-0.0022310652,
0.0156036988,
0.0250392649,
-0.0264018867,
0.0065590809,
-0.0038936466,
0.034500476,
0.0278554484,
0.0080570364,
-0.0030692483,
-0.0464810058,
0.0057215812,
-0.0489512719,
0.0809957907,
-0.0136286635,
-0.037907403,
-0.0870992839,
-0.028564563,
0.0039900667,
0.0471345372,
-0.0224419199,
-0.014052364,
0.0354958326,
-0.0076521956,
0.0137910796,
0.0035264995,
-0.010778618,
-0.0141489161,
-0.015803583,
-0.0641521066,
-0.051647447,
0.0042362073,
-0.0130643211,
0.0477226749,
-0.0470277332,
0.058489535,
1.830123481e-34,
0.0405303054,
-0.0016990799,
-0.0094782198,
-0.0385254398,
0.0593782999,
0.046665106,
-0.0161712114,
-0.0352869295,
0.0117842332,
-0.0097743096,
-0.0009325213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11852v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11852v1 | Predicting Human Translation Difficulty with Neural Machine Translation | 2023-12-19T04:42:56 | 2023-12-19T04:42:56 | Zheng Wei Lim, Ekaterina Vylomova, Charles Kemp, Trevor Cohn | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human translators linger on some words and phrases more than others, and
predicting this variation is a step towards explaining the underlying cognitive
processes. Using data from the CRITT Translation Process Research Database, we
evaluate the extent to which surprisal and attentional features derived from a
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) model account for reading and production times
of human translators. We find that surprisal and attention are complementary
predictors of translation difficulty, and that surprisal derived from a NMT
model is the single most successful predictor of production duration. Our
analyses draw on data from hundreds of translators operating across 13 language
pairs, and represent the most comprehensive investigation of human translation
difficulty to date. | [
0.026455285,
-0.0025994151,
-0.042249877,
-0.0026924235,
-0.0210571587,
0.0316715278,
0.040480841,
-0.0163051691,
-0.0249806214,
0.0128894933,
0.0197489727,
-0.0671233237,
0.0540000461,
-0.0513298139,
0.033708822,
-0.0305594914,
0.0236347131,
0.0142718721,
0.0107923122,
0.0300793052,
-0.0154337622,
0.0167338252,
-0.0012738528,
0.0523037538,
0.0114707006,
-0.0233040042,
-0.0152297746,
0.0398212783,
0.0358950011,
-0.0202730317,
0.0032208285,
0.0645947456,
-0.0110334773,
0.0561327487,
0.0000019869,
-0.0091483165,
0.008607273,
-0.0067795734,
0.0000253263,
0.0137070222,
0.0499636978,
-0.0516198389,
-0.0143955722,
0.0555106923,
-0.0188975539,
0.0066252179,
0.0447489545,
0.0071718786,
0.030421352,
0.0310067534,
-0.0175977498,
0.0235310458,
0.0057303151,
-0.0475068912,
0.0186688788,
-0.0685135201,
-0.0326077715,
-0.0446984917,
-0.0331543535,
-0.0191811062,
-0.0199363735,
0.0840082392,
0.0278767031,
0.01433957,
-0.0300974771,
-0.0030163217,
-0.0190127287,
-0.0312157944,
-0.004041472,
0.0590609759,
-0.0246456116,
0.0249704719,
-0.0362948813,
0.0077815857,
0.0182121824,
0.0217765048,
-0.0271138307,
0.0197596364,
-0.0319320187,
-0.0168600921,
0.0253451187,
0.0167898852,
0.004401233,
-0.0237430893,
0.0046688737,
-0.0235210359,
0.0059916764,
-0.0552364737,
0.0224564672,
0.0075364532,
-0.0011021188,
-0.001679554,
0.0561403558,
-0.0115507059,
-0.026607817,
0.0272339843,
-0.0129584065,
-0.0963778198,
0.0016406876,
-0.0819417611,
0.0240193624,
0.0821977779,
-0.0201168358,
0.0176410098,
-0.0293514263,
0.0887271911,
-0.0154396566,
0.0069274059,
-0.061404977,
-0.0078188311,
-0.0444383174,
0.0140451994,
-0.0304527525,
-0.0500602499,
-0.03377413,
0.0015933526,
-0.0550329909,
0.0046079368,
0.0163739137,
-0.0194435604,
0.02920953,
0.0063316463,
-0.0415136293,
0.0192553401,
-0.0246869326,
0.0517380424,
-0.0174482204,
-0.0283157323,
-0.0229041167,
-0.0387636386,
-0.0075235474,
0.0171974227,
-0.0292020105,
-0.0358826593,
-0.034873791,
0.0702798739,
-0.0331623368,
-0.0385275446,
-0.0512465574,
-0.0178217925,
-0.0061114281,
-0.0617159493,
0.0224653967,
-0.0148163754,
0.0674812421,
0.0100814039,
-0.0046127238,
-0.0568966419,
-0.0392315648,
0.0283847116,
0.0080928402,
0.0667327419,
0.0342362113,
0.0346981324,
0.013202006,
-0.0058139893,
-0.0230725836,
0.0240356531,
0.0258178506,
0.0285724513,
-0.0075644245,
-0.0327505097,
-0.0201825891,
0.0403592996,
0.0002375213,
0.0069810008,
-0.0430826433,
-0.007845114,
-0.0125393271,
0.015299038,
0.05845825,
0.0369468741,
0.0051108096,
0.0230064113,
0.0730064735,
0.0681489632,
0.0286104809,
0.0589881055,
0.0738291442,
0.0549834892,
-0.0164736211,
0.0043631573,
-0.0387983061,
0.0380565897,
-0.0005519076,
-0.0097523686,
0.0112935835,
0.0479165018,
-0.0336922593,
-0.0386681296,
0.0147434436,
0.0021285252,
0.0658949837,
-0.0045897691,
0.0066374564,
-0.0486799255,
-0.074756436,
0.0611646958,
-0.0233251154,
-0.0395983756,
-0.0240105912,
0.0241617281,
-0.0667706281,
0.0930720866,
-0.0084202159,
0.0344791971,
-0.0039928202,
-0.0172178671,
-0.0030797971,
0.0715239942,
0.0259623751,
0.0370445326,
0.0179294385,
-0.0293807648,
0.0123410216,
0.0294674654,
0.0310846772,
0.0054389434,
-0.0136738373,
0.0636058673,
0.0452884547,
-0.0130987223,
-0.0869118571,
0.0156604405,
-0.0500972681,
-0.0564319789,
-0.0270314515,
0.0233657993,
0.0062584104,
0.0246943366,
0.0230817609,
0.0030047146,
-0.007124335,
-0.0303818136,
-0.0055352184,
0.0799807087,
-0.0312410239,
-0.0193135161,
-0.0015338548,
-0.0207570605,
-0.0434304513,
-0.0035855505,
-0.0068724114,
-0.0603099912,
0.0269948691,
-0.068361491,
0.0001600549,
0.0115860105,
0.0615958907,
-0.0194140207,
0.011838831,
-0.0443823859,
0.0321096033,
-0.0304814819,
0.038747251,
0.011751188,
-0.0668510199,
0.0243884884,
-0.0337445103,
-0.0049117268,
0.0060058669,
-0.0145880263,
0.0239788294,
0.0113713257,
-0.0012211931,
-0.0531010032,
-0.0362639651,
-0.0565969795,
-0.0088602584,
0.006408561,
0.0328163169,
0.0271472633,
0.0255691223,
-0.0048224684,
0.022000486,
-0.0206010062,
0.0024054227,
-0.0146325435,
0.006446579,
-0.0036843373,
0.0117478371,
0.0068778307,
-0.0370919928,
-0.0293247327,
-0.0063046957,
-0.0004222815,
0.0358979851,
-0.0491197258,
-0.0768730044,
0.0172472987,
0.0114949457,
-0.0181403123,
0.0059690573,
-0.0918547809,
0.0106972121,
0.0046092365,
0.0526801869,
0.0644493029,
-0.0113211032,
-0.003761919,
0.0216642991,
-0.0333118737,
-0.0276564527,
0.0266169626,
-0.0171398018,
-0.0177329294,
-0.0268801507,
-0.1024026051,
-0.0169128682,
0.0580817275,
0.0103256078,
0.0059243068,
-0.0772940218,
0.0084614288,
-0.0298831277,
-0.0112229828,
0.0060438262,
0.0672513545,
-0.0150880218,
0.080665186,
-0.00683469,
-0.031943392,
0.0548724756,
-0.0096198069,
0.0000645625,
-0.0499899313,
0.0039664721,
-0.0189542677,
0.0336684287,
-0.028490223,
0.0044887625,
-0.0166548584,
-0.037229728,
-0.0456192605,
0.0177774299,
0.0052753771,
-0.0089706657,
0.034477137,
-0.0411336496,
-0.0353187211,
-0.0135811446,
0.0060676294,
-0.0103306063,
-0.0052828775,
-0.0085403016,
-0.0128137525,
0.0205392931,
-0.0229502153,
-0.0450138934,
-0.015604551,
0.0156278778,
0.0418382548,
-0.0431119725,
-0.0314165987,
-0.0119513525,
0.0027209104,
-0.0199936051,
0.0061756084,
0.0048081749,
-0.0638005733,
0.02678941,
0.0045566312,
0.0024708137,
0.0207718313,
-0.0167726446,
-0.0402728133,
0.013799862,
-0.0213016048,
-0.0300968736,
0.0047738221,
0.02911078,
-0.0587301366,
0.0158877391,
0.1146548018,
0.0386005044,
-0.0500080101,
0.0134266606,
-0.0587344058,
0.0091287093,
0.0112383021,
0.0372861065,
0.0052546747,
-0.0140390182,
-0.0045459857,
0.0734188631,
0.0082323663,
-0.0197335072,
-0.0432197526,
-0.0394084789,
0.0181982704,
0.0101888664,
-0.0648032799,
-0.0257987082,
0.0176234897,
-0.0484418869,
-0.0181098357,
0.0626287535,
-0.0004284668,
0.0229107123,
0.0112316227,
0.0038596762,
0.0115790265,
-0.0477156527,
0.0238695089,
-0.0240077525,
-0.0024436815,
0.0270552933,
0.0445958897,
0.0144251892,
-0.0438857041,
0.0327246562,
0.0043348819,
0.0341276899,
-0.0139296968,
0.0520766005,
0.0288504958,
-0.0179359335,
-0.030391518,
-0.0276671946,
-0.0400883518,
0.0682793781,
0.015323313,
0.0590756647,
0.0121937171,
0.0162627418,
0.0139491893,
-0.0120803118,
0.0167730246,
0.0444423892,
0.0295164417,
-0.08547315,
-0.0328201987,
0.0128712012,
-0.0027079061,
-0.0788491517,
-0.022718545,
0.0300479662,
-0.027742343,
-0.0468349308,
-0.0766084939,
-0.0990965068,
-0.0030494265,
0.0247987993,
0.0370665565,
0.0299506504,
0.0421069153,
0.0093779154,
-0.0394481868,
0.0708887726,
0.0329477526,
0.0071026189,
-0.0644450188,
0.0071075857,
-0.0042825923,
-0.0166074969,
0.0163984373,
0.0131673543,
-0.065786615,
-0.0370410755,
-0.0272431839,
-0.0106722023,
0.0286755171,
-0.0044831312,
-0.0132470941,
-0.0446549989,
-0.0366129205,
-0.0107127847,
-0.0240295734,
0.0129239298,
0.0208810959,
0.0348795652,
-0.0157481693,
0.0317982957,
0.0107861888,
-0.0075247698,
-0.0192795619,
0.0371302739,
0.0016908152,
-0.0473707579,
0.0117864022,
0.00409027,
0.0294200536,
-0.0214989372,
0.0163514819,
-0.0346755609,
-0.0284900498,
-0.000269544,
0.0338193066,
-0.0605779439,
-0.0443852358,
0.047973983,
-0.0302322321,
0.0030746378,
-0.0040877387,
-0.027589241,
-0.0628831014,
-0.0320249759,
0.0082979035,
-0.0686887875,
0.0504940525,
-0.0152351297,
0.0391821302,
-0.0120679829,
0.0131025063,
-0.0302324276,
0.0343350172,
0.0054372223,
0.0922895148,
-0.0095096417,
0.0560912602,
0.0133205187,
0.0249649063,
0.0382255465,
-0.0684464946,
0.0256544314,
-0.0103184385,
0.0555052906,
-0.0252057221,
0.0871620104,
-0.0012430687,
0.0192855019,
-0.0140040265,
0.0457892679,
0.0104107214,
0.019174071,
0.0137376487,
-0.0227841102,
0.0261014197,
-0.0144435223,
0.0744508356,
0.0157486517,
-0.0215493124,
-0.0020007414,
-0.0503926091,
-0.0372520052,
-0.0053688274,
-0.0051042261,
-0.0230465848,
-0.0092970617,
0.0150537305,
-0.0561738573,
-0.0494586229,
0.0147085655,
-0.006013616,
-0.004275219,
-0.0279400013,
0.0122071858,
0.0700673461,
-0.070032239,
-0.022417983,
-0.054183986,
-0.0008088024,
-0.0316805169,
-0.0351939574,
-0.0417338423,
-5.807785143e-33,
-0.0130651426,
-0.0542417392,
0.0270895585,
-0.0062183393,
-0.0268439408,
-0.0029639257,
-0.0472556762,
0.0115940329,
-0.0000142928,
-0.0186468717,
-0.0077651958,
0.0273699537,
0.0183585063,
-0.0072831865,
0.0499393269,
0.0142716598,
0.036925815,
0.0122199282,
0.0010899602,
0.0156353749,
0.02955015,
0.0070086233,
0.0636348799,
-0.062869437,
0.0638222769,
-0.0122668184,
0.0208211709,
0.002633201,
0.068323411,
0.0116975652,
0.0082366867,
0.023493018,
0.0185744762,
-0.0409428626,
-0.0222255047,
0.0016693792,
-0.0647560507,
-0.0153212342,
0.0257537682,
0.0387746505,
-0.0515862294,
-0.0650472268,
0.0432011299,
-0.0487839356,
0.010079721,
-0.0074194334,
0.0297926236,
-0.0284695122,
-0.0217304025,
0.0106133427,
-0.0822482929,
0.0239248443,
-0.0345160477,
-0.0127698276,
0.0383809879,
0.1168565303,
-0.0417713523,
0.0018341315,
-0.1026870236,
-0.0267359149,
-0.0176108591,
0.0261731874,
0.0478896163,
0.0009702805,
-0.0251814649,
-0.0372769162,
0.0520418137,
0.0106201284,
0.0368211642,
0.0151243852,
0.0520423017,
-0.0306227822,
0.0790524259,
0.0128217386,
0.0583520941,
-0.0217852965,
-0.0232260544,
0.0310081523,
0.0170224681,
0.0172946863,
0.0504906885,
0.0060253781,
-0.0398115218,
-0.0268069953,
-0.036864765,
-0.0200285278,
-0.0131355394,
-0.0450913794,
0.027897181,
0.0285803713,
0.023151191,
-0.0590629764,
0.0949815959,
0.0041142302,
0.0934665799,
-0.0087274322,
-0.0420696475,
0.0320732892,
-0.0034164928,
0.0192207918,
-0.0469091199,
0.0041100159,
-0.0398537442,
0.0367176421,
0.049373731,
0.0006744321,
0.0239970982,
0.0109229386,
0.0014077132,
-0.0023902217,
-0.0200406387,
0.0299074724,
-0.0377314091,
0.025937302,
0.02540268,
-0.0257913657,
-0.0184827242,
0.0277752429,
0.0289567057,
-0.0068361918,
-0.0162069481,
0.0178602878,
0.0266366266,
-0.0017944644,
-0.0508047901,
0.0119210305,
-0.0329676904,
0.0748839602,
0.0286051575,
-0.0511419065,
-0.0252558235,
0.0022248812,
2.705e-7,
0.0332672112,
0.0698761716,
-0.0159958173,
0.0363583751,
0.0382817164,
-0.0012101312,
0.0145151597,
0.0082737748,
-0.0156387705,
0.0237255748,
0.0370501056,
0.0103503847,
0.084406361,
0.0151102645,
-0.0568480231,
-0.0872608349,
-0.0340295173,
0.0768517256,
-0.0290861763,
0.0230381154,
0.0583264753,
0.0417017341,
-0.0254975203,
0.0019446581,
-0.0057107685,
-0.0329084694,
0.0622678585,
0.0105217574,
0.0145288119,
-0.0123821553,
0.06569729,
0.06141885,
-0.0457722321,
0.0282075275,
-0.0197886135,
-0.0277485307,
0.0242447536,
0.0549831726,
-0.0166375935,
-0.0329708196,
0.0405749977,
-0.0287763756,
-0.0271342862,
-0.0515279435,
0.0133400578,
-0.0756116733,
-0.069030121,
0.0803033933,
0.0174963195,
0.0421711579,
0.0433257632,
0.0088725612,
0.0004058686,
0.0176448841,
0.030776754,
-0.0584422834,
-0.0149036031,
-0.0350015536,
-0.020724047,
0.0379869938,
0.0100173317,
-0.0198889822,
-0.053729441,
-0.0181805957,
0.0160664003,
-0.0070224274,
-0.0011812435,
1.875207708e-34,
0.0438709222,
0.0055537042,
0.0567735359,
-0.0149898957,
0.0340533219,
-0.0029633099,
-0.0516025349,
0.0031242748,
0.0053295833,
-0.0454650186,
-0.0416084416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11828v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11828v1 | TESS: A Multi-intent Parser for Conversational Multi-Agent Systems with Decentralized Natural Language Understanding Models | 2023-12-19T03:39:23 | 2023-12-19T03:39:23 | Burak Aksar, Yara Rizk, Tathagata Chakraborti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MA | Chatbots have become one of the main pathways for the delivery of business
automation tools. Multi-agent systems offer a framework for designing chatbots
at scale, making it easier to support complex conversations that span across
multiple domains as well as enabling developers to maintain and expand their
capabilities incrementally over time. However, multi-agent systems complicate
the natural language understanding (NLU) of user intents, especially when they
rely on decentralized NLU models: some utterances (termed single intent) may
invoke a single agent while others (termed multi-intent) may explicitly invoke
multiple agents. Without correctly parsing multi-intent inputs, decentralized
NLU approaches will not achieve high prediction accuracy. In this paper, we
propose an efficient parsing and orchestration pipeline algorithm to service
multi-intent utterances from the user in the context of a multi-agent system.
Our proposed approach achieved comparable performance to competitive deep
learning models on three different datasets while being up to 48 times faster. | [
0.0577091537,
0.0390707068,
-0.0230869148,
0.0257348139,
-0.0307620969,
-0.0078810295,
0.0554985777,
-0.0418154262,
0.0484632067,
-0.0394299813,
-0.0007232313,
-0.0081631914,
-0.0157226231,
0.0486999117,
-0.0327163748,
-0.0481651537,
0.0232612304,
-0.025666846,
0.016728593,
0.008260713,
0.0069778026,
0.0542185046,
-0.007060919,
0.0819145367,
-0.0219551418,
-0.0680181012,
-0.0334239081,
0.0140228989,
-0.0306564253,
0.0037658755,
-0.0052895108,
0.0025438152,
0.0285915863,
0.0394842736,
0.0000021955,
-0.054187268,
-0.0533081815,
-0.007619008,
-0.060770072,
-0.045250494,
0.0389639251,
-0.0128123416,
-0.0054156459,
0.0409831032,
-0.0403161161,
0.0421306714,
0.0306402892,
0.0291781649,
0.061010316,
0.0343908109,
-0.0211803708,
0.0134060783,
-0.0132629918,
0.0306153595,
-0.0341845863,
-0.0873368606,
0.0027214938,
0.0006160896,
0.013621253,
-0.0007770873,
0.0248260964,
0.0237191543,
0.0217886232,
0.0157058276,
-0.0298332684,
0.0080075022,
-0.0094892876,
-0.0456655025,
-0.0639547333,
0.0814531446,
-0.0293203983,
0.0410925038,
0.012221097,
-0.0166619476,
0.0006517624,
-0.0331885517,
-0.0211507138,
0.015124416,
-0.0396580622,
-0.0287564714,
-0.0137728332,
0.0103531089,
-0.0096653085,
0.0124297319,
-0.050571654,
0.0837061852,
-0.0294898096,
0.0078339232,
-0.0061514201,
0.0059844041,
0.0339495055,
-0.0719093233,
0.042001877,
0.0385434106,
-0.0924501792,
0.0178663693,
-0.0215431713,
-0.0168623533,
-0.0178469755,
-0.0456419177,
-0.0572483353,
0.0376964398,
-0.0306908656,
0.0534842201,
0.0106140785,
0.0269776322,
-0.0029720641,
0.0118987635,
-0.0407672338,
-0.0457045883,
-0.0724811554,
-0.0099009676,
-0.0632479116,
0.0504610538,
-0.078776814,
-0.0348876938,
-0.0085428953,
0.0751513615,
-0.0146183651,
-0.0011616782,
0.0146514401,
0.0593604967,
-0.0318509452,
0.0088920165,
-0.0262991954,
0.0580744445,
-0.0633654669,
0.0267711412,
0.0154274637,
-0.1140735671,
-0.0204492416,
0.0343618467,
0.0210728291,
0.0000979081,
-0.0182246454,
0.0603279173,
-0.0011947248,
-0.0177906882,
0.0104701752,
-0.0750173852,
0.0198534057,
-0.0676606148,
-0.0355917588,
-0.0475906283,
0.0456348807,
-0.0024700337,
0.010674173,
-0.0403529927,
0.0045417449,
0.0054583657,
-0.0121674035,
0.0491832718,
-0.0019149596,
0.0097645558,
0.0258745961,
0.0082976427,
-0.0394667462,
0.0869425386,
0.0288699158,
0.0520717055,
0.0388310105,
0.0035856841,
-0.0051765814,
0.0299443286,
-0.0409092642,
-0.047442168,
0.071977675,
0.01571366,
-0.0452832095,
0.0571402386,
0.0298621636,
0.0275442116,
-0.0195887834,
-0.0152372243,
0.0191590972,
0.0619215034,
-0.0320556536,
-0.0075228843,
0.0679769516,
0.0902923793,
-0.0220861342,
-0.0277228337,
-0.0475468896,
0.0204450469,
0.0190066732,
-0.0261574015,
-0.0173853897,
0.0418190733,
-0.0240473654,
-0.0206753891,
0.0152048292,
-0.0253692083,
0.0222830847,
-0.0000414103,
0.0374390595,
-0.0096627148,
-0.0542972833,
0.0564502999,
-0.0281614792,
-0.0037623772,
-0.0327623636,
-0.0435464159,
-0.0264805388,
0.089254275,
0.049019929,
-0.0069586313,
-0.0532305092,
-0.0457163975,
-0.0032914644,
0.0371347181,
-0.0025346335,
-0.0224127229,
0.0460526533,
-0.037892662,
-0.0192555431,
0.0140656447,
-0.0050362749,
0.0161685981,
-0.0111755831,
-0.020815365,
-0.0208877213,
0.0027734602,
0.0054901522,
0.0271651503,
0.0039489227,
-0.0053756796,
0.0089477142,
0.0386788175,
0.0627296865,
0.0606989488,
0.0166565608,
-0.0326148644,
0.0048751528,
-0.0114441263,
-0.0604957975,
0.0541375801,
-0.0076705907,
-0.0599626787,
0.0253937207,
0.0141243888,
-0.0444514863,
0.0515543818,
-0.027467642,
-0.0375642478,
0.0168275181,
-0.0293523539,
0.0137157245,
0.0023872431,
-0.0160456579,
0.0225480739,
0.0241758209,
-0.0150054712,
0.0245269109,
-0.0083563281,
-0.0297227353,
0.0001614851,
0.0288813002,
0.0314432718,
-0.0234501194,
0.0027987522,
0.0139502734,
-0.0248913132,
0.0032610027,
0.0032583536,
0.0046104346,
-0.0230712295,
0.0169045422,
-0.1012850776,
0.0012009871,
-0.0235965922,
-0.0222727023,
0.0056082113,
0.0518794917,
0.0322354883,
-0.0501924418,
-0.0099553028,
0.0489889272,
-0.0019519033,
0.0184470825,
0.0337008908,
-0.0004899074,
-0.075567469,
-0.0034376774,
0.0286615025,
-0.0387579352,
0.0359489098,
0.0025120459,
-0.0320449509,
-0.038861949,
-0.021731982,
-0.0441489853,
0.0307176467,
0.0074367067,
-0.0313813202,
0.028261669,
-0.0162157658,
-0.0344524458,
0.0609632879,
-0.0270455815,
0.0353177413,
0.0015024882,
-0.0159831122,
-0.068301037,
0.0420349501,
0.0067067179,
0.0110264095,
-0.040025156,
-0.0166754462,
0.0128973313,
0.0674865395,
0.0335137993,
0.0015579261,
-0.0414930955,
-0.0234541856,
0.0125037003,
-0.0451344214,
-0.0226560906,
0.0024929098,
-0.0318165421,
0.0379920118,
0.0202168878,
-0.0243585166,
0.0832585841,
-0.0031579421,
-0.0453457013,
-0.0642825961,
-0.0498832799,
-0.0357117429,
0.0728086606,
-0.0401253179,
0.039350085,
0.0140239354,
-0.0570703186,
-0.0456505343,
0.0120174978,
0.0078812931,
-0.0115466444,
0.0163514335,
-0.0459345765,
0.015607968,
-0.006152065,
-0.0625684485,
-0.0351475179,
-0.035908509,
-0.069211252,
0.0264898129,
0.0133482581,
-0.0076534403,
-0.0728515238,
0.0019378309,
-0.0353923365,
0.0398862176,
0.0025748548,
-0.0094317449,
-0.0535294935,
-0.0254028607,
0.0407174751,
0.0376688913,
-0.0202108677,
0.0081567932,
0.0567822009,
0.0319396369,
0.0397713073,
-0.0318977199,
-0.0458360389,
-0.0148123084,
0.027197428,
-0.0157890227,
0.0291790292,
0.0248405002,
0.0617877208,
-0.0583910495,
-0.0030925593,
0.1031696573,
0.0262499768,
-0.0177976005,
0.0110745318,
-0.024428552,
0.0154389571,
0.0213024095,
0.0213076677,
-0.0781716853,
-0.079130888,
0.0052028908,
-0.0117305126,
0.0123818172,
-0.0493212752,
-0.008156199,
-0.0567057095,
0.0150988335,
-0.034816023,
-0.0622334816,
0.0054692244,
-0.0049484335,
-0.0047928677,
-0.0376098976,
0.019845726,
0.0030651966,
0.039039176,
-0.0291516576,
0.008148876,
-0.0482268669,
0.0053879311,
0.0554657876,
-0.0520479754,
0.0690915361,
0.03731253,
0.0135398759,
0.0212812796,
0.0193740539,
0.0038774358,
0.0540646128,
0.0284581631,
-0.0069507267,
0.0176614355,
-0.0242194682,
-0.0022316517,
0.0075771585,
0.0269839372,
-0.0726593509,
0.0062200772,
0.0030333898,
0.0551139675,
-0.0317515582,
0.0274719037,
-0.0226953812,
0.0210600737,
0.0660395324,
0.0809197724,
-0.0123806596,
-0.048735477,
-0.066103965,
-0.0447170436,
-0.0298477858,
-0.028309077,
0.0066398215,
0.0131777087,
-0.0081179086,
-0.0395066477,
-0.045014549,
-0.0617843494,
0.0481043756,
0.0137719223,
-0.0066155423,
0.0146128545,
0.0694126189,
0.0494672991,
0.0070097903,
0.0108723678,
-0.0174280014,
0.0381460898,
0.0093593644,
0.0000530139,
0.0298550613,
-0.0368159078,
-0.0352498926,
0.045179598,
-0.0960916877,
-0.0142999925,
0.018970795,
0.0171071384,
0.020417748,
0.0282988884,
-0.0345696285,
-0.0158981625,
-0.0140273599,
0.0028025825,
-0.0639424026,
-0.0348624587,
0.0309233665,
0.0699383691,
0.0056949868,
0.0535182022,
-0.0641217306,
0.0106577147,
-0.0580577403,
0.0190632027,
-0.0558844097,
-0.0540031455,
0.0166800711,
0.0037865529,
0.0032187516,
0.0339448303,
-0.0049710232,
-0.0110442061,
0.0344825648,
0.0152923455,
-0.0084125232,
-0.0439999141,
0.0293912385,
-0.0108132111,
-0.0365507603,
0.0439351387,
0.0087059112,
-0.0042856745,
0.0037507233,
0.0183688514,
-0.0069474448,
0.0158137307,
0.0018476699,
0.0075480156,
-0.0103544537,
-0.0005138462,
0.0385709666,
-0.0081790881,
0.03013332,
0.0068230545,
0.0469804332,
0.0135360388,
0.0082777394,
-0.0185636021,
0.0267996993,
-0.0797940195,
-0.0801267922,
0.0370708779,
0.0056823525,
0.0027804757,
0.0396751054,
0.0361620374,
-0.0149002504,
0.0334642604,
0.004486457,
0.0480667911,
-0.007152617,
-0.0360071063,
0.017197175,
-0.0019057113,
-0.0237207618,
-0.0301515516,
0.0657645762,
-0.0477565043,
0.0467040353,
-0.0230836067,
-0.0363370404,
-0.088156797,
-0.0412874855,
-0.0099005019,
0.0715717301,
-0.0094586853,
-0.0068357564,
-0.0250439197,
0.0069282218,
-0.0171700139,
-0.0123823965,
-0.013773351,
-0.027419718,
0.0521351323,
0.0780555159,
0.0222938806,
-0.0445866063,
-0.0390185378,
-0.0226822197,
-0.0307785068,
-0.014505744,
-0.021902645,
-6.229863655e-33,
0.0002817303,
-0.0136871357,
0.0471747629,
-0.0057072169,
-0.010700088,
-0.0030351735,
-0.0309618022,
-0.0123858545,
-0.0443469509,
-0.0059249825,
-0.0030038161,
0.0501561202,
0.0384209491,
0.0159958638,
0.0332196653,
-0.0248931907,
0.0618271232,
-0.0123645794,
0.0065884264,
0.0209871735,
0.0741685331,
0.0412263796,
0.0117150489,
-0.0465230979,
0.0035618884,
0.0329554006,
-0.0151548022,
0.044931706,
0.0069139139,
0.0262414869,
-0.0183103532,
0.0194616616,
0.0098971967,
-0.0475883819,
-0.0098834671,
0.0202733371,
-0.0300025418,
-0.0201063342,
0.022191124,
0.0595445782,
-0.0770765245,
0.0003561435,
0.03667178,
-0.0084763095,
0.0456596874,
0.0292187538,
0.0349403359,
0.0204432495,
0.0064631421,
0.0155544588,
-0.055043105,
0.0160937645,
-0.0349911153,
-0.0218290649,
0.0334704109,
0.0485574417,
0.0142157841,
-0.0013842513,
-0.0439337268,
-0.0007690269,
-0.0656215474,
-0.0296134967,
0.0360153802,
0.0054142587,
-0.0104225548,
0.0479880422,
0.0563902408,
-0.0177899171,
-0.0333965681,
-0.0014506503,
-0.0090090474,
0.0799558908,
-0.0146537339,
0.0308953021,
-0.0207405258,
-0.0055877659,
-0.0405626409,
0.0194678437,
0.0886667818,
0.0408761278,
0.0138952229,
0.0257769655,
-0.0429499298,
0.0093535557,
0.0037078585,
-0.0075088628,
-0.0128899217,
-0.0185702797,
0.0295385979,
0.0030014992,
-0.007514351,
0.0083165811,
0.0561590195,
-0.0587778352,
0.0205792505,
0.0273675919,
-0.0149874659,
-0.0025102203,
0.012933813,
0.0263181068,
-0.0288357697,
-0.0126850633,
0.0062206918,
0.0165255778,
0.0480455942,
0.0221885554,
-0.0011542707,
0.0089551462,
-0.0243351664,
-0.0117397998,
-0.0710291639,
0.0159162208,
-0.0632065088,
0.040749345,
0.0556595735,
-0.0071336231,
-0.0339094028,
0.0455989204,
-0.0098569067,
-0.0085389065,
-0.0183017626,
0.004674118,
0.0068060895,
-0.0186021924,
-0.0475677848,
-0.0273031536,
-0.0322049633,
-0.0536347628,
0.0252205264,
-0.0459795594,
-0.0094529856,
-0.0022242328,
2.889e-7,
-0.0070482609,
0.020933345,
0.0175962541,
0.0494680032,
0.0302731581,
0.0692823455,
0.0301358383,
0.050498087,
-0.042499125,
-0.0272250082,
-0.0126606934,
0.0231744554,
0.0266158301,
0.0313371532,
-0.107268624,
-0.0506983101,
0.0051380163,
-0.0022521031,
-0.0622715354,
0.0170559399,
0.0699489713,
0.079942137,
0.0133502409,
-0.0206253845,
0.0271749161,
-0.0190650728,
-0.0185991116,
0.0108461184,
0.0367877111,
0.0370930582,
-0.0204248745,
0.0150891021,
0.0092593394,
0.028074963,
0.0315958783,
0.0355002321,
-0.006486617,
0.0714345649,
-0.0156850647,
-0.0132871829,
-0.0104146441,
-0.0477479175,
0.0083658425,
-0.0301445499,
0.0445903391,
-0.0215576272,
-0.0275304057,
-0.0297922213,
0.0226741657,
0.0021524141,
-0.0304328613,
0.0207470823,
0.0070849345,
0.0157982837,
-0.0138451429,
-0.047300458,
-0.0023097931,
-0.0753133595,
0.0103612477,
-0.0116167627,
-0.0609993823,
-0.0276269149,
-0.0276847128,
0.0029499447,
0.064217329,
-0.0530929826,
-0.0173945371,
2.383348775e-34,
0.0190915875,
0.0259860791,
0.0029408433,
0.0975803211,
0.0326841623,
-0.0111510763,
-0.0171836335,
0.0071662897,
0.0240089074,
-0.0447971374,
-0.0121636586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11819v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11819v2 | An Adaptive Placement and Parallelism Framework for Accelerating RLHF Training | 2023-12-19T03:24:55 | 2024-01-25T02:46:06 | Youshao Xiao, Weichang Wu, Zhenglei Zhou, Fagui Mao, Shangchun Zhao, Lin Ju, Lei Liang, Xiaolu Zhang, Jun Zhou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recently, ChatGPT or InstructGPT like large language models (LLM) has made a
significant impact in the AI world. Many works have attempted to reproduce the
complex InstructGPT's training pipeline, namely Reinforcement Learning with
Human Feedback (RLHF). However, the mainstream distributed RLHF training
methods typically adopt a fixed model placement strategy, referred to as the
Flattening strategy. This strategy treats all four interdependent models
involved in RLHF as a single entity, distributing them across all devices and
applying parallelism techniques designed for a single model, regardless of the
different workloads inherent to each model. As a result, this strategy
exacerbates the generation bottlenecks in the RLHF training and degrades the
overall training efficiency. To address these issues, we propose an adaptive
model placement framework that offers two flexible model placement strategies.
The Interleaving strategy helps reduce memory redundancy and communication
costs of RLHF training by placing models without dependencies on exclusive
devices with careful orchestration. On the other hand, the Separation strategy
improves the throughput of model training by separating the training and
inference runtime of the RLHF pipeline with additional shadow models.
Furthermore, our framework provides a simple user interface and allows for the
agile allocation of models across devices in a fine-grained manner for various
training scenarios, involving models of varying sizes and devices of different
scales. Extensive experiments have demonstrated that our Interleaving and
Separation strategies can achieve notable improvements up to 11X, compared to
the current SOTA approaches. The results highlight the effectiveness and
adaptability of our approaches in accelerating the training of distributed
RLHF. | [
0.0562864132,
0.0374744125,
-0.0112605607,
0.0133566651,
-0.0386913866,
0.0216528792,
0.04106142,
-0.010565944,
0.0011647684,
-0.0464353152,
-0.0802804679,
-0.0337998196,
-0.0110335639,
-0.034507975,
-0.0059438082,
-0.0582085066,
0.0596753992,
-0.0244959649,
-0.0320041515,
-0.0100758923,
-0.0056319302,
0.005484255,
-0.0208140314,
0.0241130572,
0.000657757,
-0.0148485359,
-0.0414621234,
0.0345374905,
0.036071606,
-0.0189009011,
0.0124183167,
0.0504094325,
0.0476810373,
0.0521167554,
0.0000022427,
0.0061882795,
-0.0077419635,
0.0090392819,
-0.0133668361,
0.0204346925,
0.0673276484,
0.0229476672,
-0.0256287977,
0.0532766655,
-0.0095913233,
-0.0270443559,
0.0345729552,
0.0154645005,
0.0427403636,
0.0757859498,
0.0092724115,
0.0186564233,
0.0090761958,
-0.0467326716,
-0.0182356611,
-0.0172074158,
0.0062657329,
0.0187644456,
0.0118505051,
-0.0006328403,
-0.0067526679,
0.0264616627,
0.0686157569,
0.0371450037,
0.0080189817,
0.0416061953,
-0.0176231042,
-0.0249870792,
-0.0668779239,
0.0229019932,
-0.0340323374,
-0.0335109979,
0.020625921,
-0.0025560642,
-0.0306204297,
0.0109507702,
-0.0101880776,
0.0350038335,
-0.0194412544,
-0.0084636528,
0.0002414776,
-0.039851632,
0.0312005188,
0.000768013,
-0.0004397425,
0.0300730728,
0.0124259638,
-0.0262698457,
-0.0192470774,
0.019041175,
-0.0233952347,
-0.021453755,
0.0040987749,
0.0154364407,
-0.0647787899,
0.0304813795,
-0.0482354462,
-0.0017155901,
-0.0009738742,
-0.0657584816,
0.0707567409,
0.0376960039,
-0.0046073236,
0.0246966891,
-0.0204071384,
0.0224309694,
-0.0508015342,
0.0141882207,
-0.051451955,
0.0556147657,
-0.0387300998,
-0.0305848438,
-0.046742212,
0.0275580585,
-0.0598518513,
-0.0564250499,
-0.0404211767,
0.0246780142,
-0.0319524966,
-0.0214191768,
0.021161437,
0.0152149629,
-0.0464034043,
0.0106679825,
0.0223303605,
0.0543315895,
-0.0451942943,
0.014768322,
0.0051881187,
-0.0642383918,
0.001603759,
0.0018869098,
-0.0221464019,
0.0078176782,
0.0174394697,
0.0564198568,
-0.0035377326,
-0.0189482048,
-0.040077813,
0.018642962,
0.0427592956,
-0.0747955665,
0.0008563099,
-0.0334094688,
0.036479082,
-0.0138416104,
0.0240045208,
0.0308588333,
-0.0003182139,
0.0331626721,
0.0081930635,
0.0788952783,
0.0239119753,
0.0053889332,
0.059956003,
-0.0013402717,
-0.0189251937,
0.0833626464,
0.0539373942,
0.0360603184,
-0.0086210417,
-0.0328289084,
-0.0160798579,
0.0345055163,
0.016848838,
-0.0015543333,
-0.0275410973,
-0.0134344688,
-0.0113711739,
0.0245492924,
0.029562274,
0.0493407026,
-0.0413963087,
0.0395918563,
0.0514347069,
0.0598552935,
-0.0056200526,
0.0028638972,
0.0198762137,
0.0386760421,
-0.0152412914,
-0.0065359771,
-0.1029025093,
0.030214658,
0.0198149048,
0.0033642473,
0.0194050204,
0.0296722911,
-0.0120386807,
-0.0145833539,
-0.0196271669,
-0.0062498944,
-0.0104426704,
0.0271380581,
0.0378793702,
-0.0112868808,
-0.0601577461,
0.0433311649,
0.083091408,
-0.0516016036,
-0.0325510018,
-0.0571263917,
0.0305457693,
0.0682251379,
0.0008008403,
-0.030274529,
-0.0429074727,
0.017574193,
0.006192551,
0.0311289802,
0.055260364,
0.0002798811,
-0.0062954873,
-0.0380251184,
-0.0271183923,
0.0185311083,
-0.0041471431,
0.0585513636,
0.0744437128,
-0.0051839463,
-0.031434074,
0.0473913886,
-0.0510891378,
0.0156508572,
-0.0226291437,
-0.0038164102,
-0.0059458278,
0.0081960345,
0.0521210618,
-0.0376572534,
-0.0381485671,
-0.0066140573,
0.0380278528,
-0.0167383831,
-0.0172972567,
-0.0010988654,
-0.0701014921,
-0.0008190072,
0.012020763,
0.0459877588,
0.0336539224,
0.0284589715,
-0.0238377377,
-0.0099577419,
0.0240449198,
-0.0227614287,
0.0703225061,
0.0007005539,
0.0459491536,
0.0096975854,
-0.0199901517,
-0.0203752685,
0.0605525449,
-0.0075299917,
-0.0222242363,
-0.0210835263,
0.023064008,
-0.0088078063,
-0.0240042489,
0.0320645235,
0.0003389973,
-0.016295163,
0.0170984529,
0.0066937534,
0.021610301,
-0.0224328227,
-0.0241281688,
-0.0917730555,
0.008461738,
-0.0356165431,
0.0354387015,
0.014311648,
0.0176786948,
0.0019303861,
-0.0482805409,
0.000012265,
0.0021870115,
0.0112213055,
0.0395363495,
-0.031164661,
0.0107534109,
-0.0386205427,
-0.0179832503,
-0.0255164709,
0.0090305069,
0.0107004056,
-0.0126619637,
0.003943596,
-0.0749259889,
-0.004030325,
0.0065392125,
0.0502844229,
-0.0034059191,
-0.0352615379,
0.0300201513,
-0.0052073002,
0.035868533,
0.1144489571,
-0.0189450588,
0.0635556355,
0.0413964987,
0.0289426856,
-0.0642222092,
0.0543034561,
-0.0009766108,
-0.0515590832,
-0.0382195152,
-0.000889805,
-0.0342944376,
0.0682250336,
-0.0283022467,
0.0333753563,
-0.0669791773,
-0.0371329188,
-0.0401029289,
-0.0821921304,
-0.0224611182,
-0.0078993887,
-0.0397757404,
-0.0142376954,
-0.0452524647,
-0.0712924004,
0.0279814377,
-0.0178668946,
-0.0000293167,
-0.0595878772,
-0.0506682768,
-0.0250223298,
0.0477978848,
0.0284877699,
0.0319317318,
-0.0375623591,
-0.0194175765,
-0.047468055,
-0.0046760575,
0.0146625768,
-0.0084948717,
-0.0239924863,
-0.031718757,
-0.0051967925,
-0.0329503678,
-0.0864426047,
-0.0278928839,
-0.0054495353,
-0.0113170622,
-0.0379396714,
-0.0001254529,
-0.0624164417,
-0.0296754986,
0.034171816,
0.0242113378,
0.0678239092,
-0.0210318808,
-0.002341989,
-0.021987671,
0.0185011085,
0.0564466715,
-0.0205465592,
-0.0061275684,
-0.038893912,
0.0193657819,
0.0539438874,
0.0592740327,
-0.0152348122,
-0.0415599309,
0.0092910519,
0.0497304723,
-0.03217002,
-0.0166640002,
0.0249088928,
0.0623804815,
-0.0640676469,
-0.0483824275,
0.0825758129,
0.0210347008,
-0.074185811,
0.0204091799,
0.0096953064,
0.0959698036,
0.0209433194,
0.0503831469,
-0.0535515063,
-0.0088744275,
0.0139455032,
0.0080094589,
0.0198993217,
0.027824007,
-0.014282437,
-0.1142392009,
0.0397147574,
0.0176257081,
-0.0621510893,
-0.0193295814,
-0.041349642,
-0.0198166184,
-0.0054072062,
0.0251845457,
0.0041293409,
-0.0196973421,
-0.0010527673,
0.0338168591,
-0.0131020667,
0.0074563818,
-0.0128863128,
-0.0451181121,
0.0144059304,
0.0589869991,
-0.034822084,
0.0170648228,
-0.0059920819,
0.0129171861,
0.0478522703,
0.0204746425,
-0.0293169692,
0.0209691394,
-0.0287232324,
-0.0056434404,
-0.02483055,
0.0110348687,
-0.029956514,
-0.022824496,
0.0143087953,
0.0913321674,
0.0058793696,
0.0074026296,
-0.0111690275,
0.0011146397,
0.0127025768,
0.0468699597,
-0.0026198202,
-0.0644760132,
-0.0390109345,
0.004616987,
-0.0164139904,
-0.02486182,
0.0124625592,
0.0091900537,
-0.0269717705,
-0.0230243541,
-0.0288179256,
0.0041369158,
-0.0076109217,
0.0518147536,
0.0283800829,
-0.0219549164,
0.0488202684,
0.0323016755,
-0.0327054262,
0.0170022286,
-0.0195933022,
-0.0033657793,
-0.0372977704,
-0.0273549426,
0.0455671139,
-0.0345133878,
0.0087267468,
0.0059155528,
-0.0842255652,
-0.0632493123,
0.0078920415,
0.030308485,
0.0235160943,
0.0905729011,
0.0147204828,
-0.0193604175,
0.0438676588,
-0.0008788282,
-0.0877007023,
0.0602835938,
0.0071959235,
-0.0074515962,
0.0048305001,
0.0207549017,
-0.0495896935,
0.0203901771,
0.0135828601,
0.0235713888,
-0.0304594822,
-0.0008210702,
0.0062538469,
-0.0081752995,
0.0182022918,
-0.0101799509,
-0.0130423158,
-0.0266666152,
0.0461455658,
-0.0181155354,
-0.0049835099,
-0.043838989,
0.0161782224,
0.0166711845,
0.0160827041,
-0.0035235349,
-0.029084757,
0.1217136458,
-0.009599736,
-0.0187896416,
-0.0256392453,
0.0008057762,
0.004701687,
0.0058839973,
0.0607054457,
0.00788425,
0.0112717329,
-0.0197924078,
0.0369532481,
-0.0294167586,
0.065807946,
0.0167106818,
-0.035302382,
-0.0426327959,
0.0424215533,
-0.0635231286,
-0.0616746433,
-0.0171146821,
0.0413344763,
0.0780681521,
0.0307004713,
0.0594944954,
-0.0386821292,
-0.0293914601,
0.0125589631,
0.0062776902,
-0.032821849,
-0.003404808,
-0.0066197203,
0.04937521,
-0.0115283355,
-0.0068672448,
0.0138777532,
0.0329911374,
0.0454291515,
-0.0040132008,
-0.0222470611,
-0.0388510227,
-0.0355906226,
0.0339615829,
0.0156722888,
-0.016295338,
0.0065528215,
-0.0092162676,
-0.0602023304,
-0.0266537089,
0.0295569804,
-0.0157376397,
-0.0548230484,
0.0492647476,
0.0404332541,
-0.0030647067,
-0.0524250343,
-0.0170050133,
-0.0170195941,
-0.0270835329,
-0.0083038146,
0.0155269271,
-6.827031683e-33,
-0.0250145886,
0.0161998719,
0.042458795,
-0.0291579161,
-0.0618975647,
0.02148127,
0.0047190851,
-0.0082709473,
0.0006945228,
0.0165530853,
-0.00858807,
0.0220105499,
0.0321297795,
0.0116551146,
0.0058043264,
0.0123305889,
0.0424268954,
-0.0311855804,
-0.0534554236,
0.0478219762,
0.0055690161,
0.0428269096,
0.0393903293,
-0.0412501805,
-0.0465167351,
-0.000825557,
0.0042336495,
0.0180655196,
-0.0954018533,
0.0308060162,
-0.0199666265,
0.0193777587,
-0.0206356291,
-0.0554702431,
0.0122587038,
0.0427121185,
-0.0868670866,
-0.0018402598,
-0.0111365942,
0.0400993526,
-0.0856095329,
-0.0120199947,
0.0428867042,
0.0147078428,
-0.0292299502,
-0.0107487459,
-0.0134987151,
0.0114455689,
-0.0516667254,
0.0493915007,
-0.0462607034,
0.0014178318,
0.0318034105,
-0.0127134612,
0.0115739247,
0.012379366,
-0.0223712679,
-0.0126055526,
-0.0551489405,
-0.0030794628,
-0.0123345032,
0.0222012512,
0.0672951788,
0.0638010725,
0.0224581622,
0.063090995,
0.0613204315,
-0.0110245775,
0.0076689343,
-0.0131118624,
0.0038634588,
0.0484644286,
0.0037187748,
-0.0055232514,
0.0305873696,
0.0121880528,
-0.0600938387,
-0.0457618609,
0.0415475108,
0.0325791426,
0.0478474796,
0.0200831704,
-0.0740381107,
-0.0249910317,
-0.0189111661,
-0.0151698738,
-0.0101607302,
-0.0510182939,
0.0544768237,
0.0493148863,
-0.0182806402,
-0.0072487127,
0.026916232,
-0.0267833099,
0.0222558044,
0.0357428193,
0.0185051002,
0.0441674776,
-0.0176690426,
0.0334215648,
-0.0811975598,
-0.0358105041,
-0.0342677645,
0.0161937531,
-0.0060134251,
-0.0035126219,
0.0401214249,
0.0317721441,
-0.071356371,
0.0284834094,
-0.0177570488,
0.0519625507,
0.0086579537,
0.0556795821,
0.0605408102,
-0.0049604769,
0.0108613828,
0.0679113716,
0.0072626569,
-0.0468208194,
-0.0195613131,
-0.0040087304,
-0.020710038,
-0.0074460767,
0.0127302315,
0.0278363973,
-0.0948949382,
0.0300637614,
0.0246401485,
-0.0735481158,
-0.0322346203,
0.0062722475,
3.116e-7,
-0.0425550677,
0.0072451988,
0.0319083184,
0.0106874118,
0.0205931477,
0.0141745079,
0.0147718629,
0.0203416087,
0.0143222548,
0.0450657979,
0.0109002069,
0.0828111991,
0.0451809689,
-0.0072417976,
-0.0660224408,
-0.04671783,
-0.1269093156,
0.0355357975,
-0.0214389954,
-0.0101102181,
-0.0136096822,
0.0781986564,
0.0313071385,
-0.0208421666,
0.0087236753,
0.0083229495,
0.0226883311,
-0.0099358438,
-0.0213942789,
0.013151357,
-0.0405287929,
0.020309614,
-0.0395259969,
-0.0008246654,
0.0139412927,
-0.0170407929,
-0.0501902625,
0.0558904409,
-0.016636597,
-0.0235079788,
-0.0006226846,
0.0340008177,
-0.0261834357,
-0.0354629867,
0.0340204462,
-0.0547705479,
-0.0153196407,
-0.051283367,
0.0205570087,
-0.0361407734,
-0.0048624077,
0.0041397763,
0.0174913611,
-0.0010010726,
0.0054060542,
-0.0080202976,
-0.037836697,
-0.0653553382,
-0.0118630975,
0.0317766443,
-0.0380760729,
-0.0545711331,
-0.0627741814,
0.0188484192,
-0.0072802035,
-0.0606639236,
-0.0177093856,
3.053659276e-34,
0.0166799705,
-0.0249178018,
0.0485270657,
0.0764908269,
0.0247599334,
0.000709521,
-0.011233679,
-0.0012779038,
0.0399115495,
-0.066984944,
-0.0135932686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12466v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12466v1 | Users Approach on Providing Feedback for Smart Home Devices | 2023-12-19T03:18:12 | 2023-12-19T03:18:12 | Santhosh Pogaku | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | Smart Home technology has accomplished extraordinary interest in making
individuals' lives more straightforward and more relaxing as of late.
Technology as of late brought about delivering numerous savvy and refined
frameworks which advanced clever living innovation. In this paper, we will be
investigating the behavioural intention of user's approach on providing
feedback for smart home devices. We will be conducting an online survey for
sample of three to five students selected by simple random sampling to study
the user's motto for giving feedback on smart home devices and their
expectations. We have observed that most users are ready to share their
feedback on smart home devices actively to improvise the service and quality of
the product to fulfill the user needs and make their lives easier. | [
0.0329926535,
-0.0826835334,
-0.0266414918,
-0.0578772947,
-0.0442774147,
-0.023058841,
0.042720791,
-0.0317144915,
0.0259320159,
-0.0520386174,
0.017085189,
0.0300810859,
0.0058135162,
0.0155339753,
-0.0200491939,
0.0218319725,
-0.0006410106,
0.0416344963,
0.0225053597,
0.0508385561,
0.023744788,
-0.0169148892,
0.0088382931,
0.007736559,
-0.0104415473,
0.0012968893,
0.0218939595,
-0.0098175788,
0.036373537,
-0.0307961926,
0.0700407475,
0.0253297109,
-0.0284252241,
0.0329212397,
0.0000018025,
-0.0581838004,
0.0118925255,
0.007425738,
-0.0428888835,
-0.0154251968,
0.0508010425,
0.0483968668,
0.0011802674,
0.0320170186,
-0.0324994624,
0.0198096409,
0.0462216474,
0.0828872472,
-0.0099581536,
0.0044059567,
-0.0264120959,
-0.0116656031,
-0.0144988829,
0.0109618427,
0.0439874902,
0.0613304526,
-0.0098846806,
-0.0196951665,
0.0336061157,
0.0162069909,
-0.0004089831,
-0.0059841345,
-0.0145570906,
0.0030124327,
0.0301594604,
0.0119561274,
0.0377561003,
-0.024915535,
-0.0370454751,
0.0037841231,
0.0545703955,
0.0232801698,
0.0028198361,
-0.0053143175,
-0.0183575358,
0.0340365656,
-0.0450028256,
-0.0274102315,
-0.0059180828,
0.0246191174,
-0.0480657853,
0.0149156861,
0.0088643618,
-0.0361014903,
0.0715923011,
0.0394039154,
-0.0357379168,
0.0166482255,
-0.0454161242,
0.0181876179,
0.0811805576,
-0.0093424907,
-0.0163329113,
-0.0367455594,
-0.01947245,
-0.0284616575,
0.0302638579,
-0.0086029172,
0.0022601478,
-0.0149658471,
0.0425183773,
0.0215022359,
0.0364874117,
0.0289104804,
0.0660982057,
-0.0238421485,
-0.0244792067,
0.0010169117,
-0.0680014342,
0.062711902,
-0.0477047153,
-0.0106040388,
0.0188728012,
0.0407098904,
-0.009074335,
-0.062666595,
-0.0166705996,
-0.005354329,
0.0232208967,
0.0135627016,
-0.0095081571,
0.0456801169,
-0.0028793605,
-0.014490623,
-0.019732669,
0.0325756632,
-0.0660087094,
0.0172129255,
-0.0279683527,
-0.0064738281,
0.0395820476,
0.0180579349,
0.0078700585,
0.0065207342,
-0.0242661927,
-0.0399722569,
0.0254265424,
-0.0172693003,
0.0130523564,
-0.0232241862,
0.0216962993,
-0.011171544,
-0.0031984029,
0.0117770899,
-0.0249479581,
0.019680215,
-0.0105814524,
0.0322270058,
-0.0287422929,
-0.0061813714,
-0.0011495688,
-0.0221147481,
-0.0476192124,
0.0343964323,
0.0273357909,
0.0314596593,
0.0122013921,
-0.0411268026,
0.0154193193,
-0.0050282953,
0.0169747844,
0.0019074406,
0.0195973553,
0.022571519,
-0.0423766002,
-0.0016278358,
0.0623490289,
0.035750214,
-0.0612836927,
-0.026968848,
-0.0654487386,
0.0126945348,
0.0105512626,
0.1013652906,
0.0807862207,
0.0128510259,
0.0127271106,
-0.013861455,
-0.0731267706,
0.0140167791,
0.0157722682,
-0.0595950708,
0.0256995242,
0.0340392739,
-0.0132355858,
0.0139316684,
-0.0111814737,
-0.0611984022,
-0.01674469,
-0.0106042633,
-0.0666289106,
-0.0689914823,
0.0508940592,
0.0817730576,
-0.0206482615,
0.0210400801,
0.0095142853,
0.0002075982,
-0.0336400047,
-0.0425288677,
-0.0113393087,
-0.0730815604,
0.1436695457,
0.0859769136,
-0.0119059952,
0.0269186329,
0.0103034778,
-0.0428874306,
-0.0353073515,
-0.04834342,
0.0544786602,
-0.0051633581,
-0.0473300628,
0.0429281816,
-0.0365769714,
-0.032284271,
0.0140994741,
0.023904888,
-0.0829744786,
0.0194986779,
0.0231646039,
0.0235048812,
0.0040520825,
-0.0202537272,
0.0581923947,
0.0069956877,
-0.0171642173,
0.0076103499,
-0.0076030307,
0.0310473368,
0.0306597836,
0.0067966976,
0.0385248698,
-0.0123330541,
0.0094919996,
0.0334335268,
0.0141411778,
0.0465020612,
0.0025901285,
-0.0263626482,
-0.0023240549,
0.0434894264,
0.0050278604,
0.0066562337,
-0.0118138343,
-0.0207688883,
0.0098230178,
-0.0206024013,
-0.0224427916,
-0.0260036662,
-0.0784298405,
0.0154233677,
0.013268101,
0.0180704854,
0.0038733853,
-0.0127817513,
-0.0124657946,
0.0203567874,
0.0038993573,
-0.0041288831,
-0.0147921294,
0.0213034526,
0.0248034578,
-0.0174476542,
0.0267535727,
-0.0503337532,
0.0525545515,
-0.0801275149,
-0.0393517278,
-0.0322124362,
-0.0048093302,
0.0228478946,
0.0242708232,
0.0401881821,
-0.0226025935,
-0.0061747623,
0.0093889013,
0.0038481846,
-0.0201560427,
0.0209407546,
0.0474412367,
-0.0128593696,
0.0233209822,
0.0114164278,
-0.0013614611,
-0.0313016921,
0.0796612054,
0.0362635218,
-0.037097495,
-0.0642817318,
0.0139987618,
-0.0707757324,
0.0209934469,
-0.0132024586,
0.0198109485,
0.0046790964,
0.025999343,
0.0020498259,
0.0378439091,
0.0212852992,
0.0142856287,
-0.0216282532,
-0.0167305935,
0.0037410038,
-0.0143019203,
0.0014295259,
-0.0362764038,
0.0283252839,
0.0638651475,
-0.0316485055,
0.0181486961,
0.0170004461,
0.0079010045,
0.057297416,
-0.0187161434,
-0.0098485332,
0.0301199425,
0.0051646959,
-0.0225488953,
0.0766723901,
0.053667549,
-0.0354652479,
0.0227507669,
0.0141641442,
0.0004609863,
-0.0401850715,
-0.0155668966,
-0.0269545875,
0.0222026799,
-0.0866206661,
0.0426714942,
0.0205521286,
-0.015656,
0.0232678335,
-0.075154379,
0.0208833739,
-0.0095821694,
-0.0093218014,
-0.0221114047,
-0.0356032178,
-0.023113152,
-0.041205734,
0.0364195406,
-0.0409807712,
-0.021538917,
-0.0277517457,
-0.0350691751,
0.0081575615,
0.0155106494,
-0.0069103623,
0.0088150166,
0.011187491,
0.0458884723,
-0.0313952379,
0.0512526669,
-0.0387335457,
0.0122893192,
0.0068418388,
-0.0638447702,
0.0027009528,
-0.0671655536,
0.0089719836,
0.0614238568,
0.0360716544,
-0.02970149,
0.0056169783,
0.0264994726,
0.0234720502,
0.004585159,
0.0090187825,
0.0343605056,
0.0249398276,
0.0463498011,
0.0408192575,
-0.0066706515,
0.0132963918,
-0.0015053133,
-0.0299063008,
-0.0248636752,
-0.0019183827,
0.0107821198,
-0.0577818528,
0.01401556,
0.0013012147,
0.057159882,
-0.0413051806,
0.0031433206,
-0.0088529456,
-0.0210711323,
-0.0148493573,
0.0009866945,
0.0141129196,
-0.0578176603,
0.0331357718,
-0.0250949841,
0.0147819454,
0.0638043657,
-0.0140255997,
-0.0268738847,
-0.0047722384,
0.0085641276,
-0.0741518959,
-0.0473726094,
0.0738789067,
-0.0365909673,
0.0566483289,
0.1061327681,
-0.0126849692,
0.0233097989,
-0.0286972225,
-0.0662923232,
0.0037085086,
-0.0092198616,
-0.0285999384,
-0.0554833561,
-0.0054273824,
0.0193571337,
0.0015661638,
0.066073209,
-0.0287337136,
0.0410464443,
0.0191749036,
-0.0089434544,
0.0112209842,
-0.0376325585,
-0.0619648285,
-0.0161209796,
0.0892564133,
0.0272858813,
-0.039216239,
-0.0522316433,
0.0191630069,
0.0189394392,
-0.056717921,
0.0884997398,
-0.0443303436,
0.0022946352,
0.0211118907,
-0.0045537571,
-0.032037247,
-0.0141343977,
0.0074208882,
0.0336424857,
0.0441537239,
-0.0177055784,
-0.020083243,
0.0602352135,
0.0172166135,
-0.0352687463,
0.0560134351,
0.0002947119,
-0.0262839105,
0.0099767298,
0.0489054993,
-0.0351102389,
0.0208602063,
-0.0164185204,
0.0324235037,
0.0208197422,
0.0244332366,
0.079742983,
0.026481431,
-0.01414546,
-0.0029233706,
0.0183728933,
-0.0362451449,
0.0047390689,
-0.0022678797,
0.0018878261,
0.0392547362,
0.0392702036,
-0.0164318215,
-0.0053235427,
0.0001821992,
-0.0306215174,
-0.0014476901,
0.0144384112,
0.0090285242,
-0.036705967,
0.0310814362,
0.0339211449,
0.0369606391,
-0.007885919,
0.0197159871,
0.0255982578,
-0.0140388124,
0.0227434319,
-0.0190454386,
-0.0248056334,
0.0002810311,
-0.0462754443,
-0.041301392,
-0.008547321,
0.0267486144,
-0.0319368877,
-0.0169512089,
-0.0443534926,
0.0605289266,
-0.0427823439,
0.0310424026,
0.0300017521,
-0.0062988726,
-0.0138045531,
0.014275644,
0.0251215473,
-0.0015027121,
0.0051657413,
-0.0017961635,
-0.0185856931,
-0.0180678871,
-0.0218523424,
0.059009131,
0.046561867,
-0.0672445968,
0.0221809242,
0.0527390353,
-0.071917288,
0.0092984512,
0.0071988557,
-0.032328859,
0.0192667488,
-0.0354704261,
0.0341548361,
-0.0314671099,
0.0381539874,
0.0077572856,
0.0283574238,
-0.0307369754,
-0.0246909354,
-0.0002466943,
-0.0476487689,
-0.0242764726,
-0.0696870536,
-0.0176326819,
-0.0496763289,
0.0240118429,
-0.0083018886,
-0.0190658439,
-0.0183025971,
-0.0667368844,
0.0039771409,
0.0069572972,
0.0209581144,
-0.0227797031,
0.0641236305,
0.003205908,
0.0458351932,
0.0533310138,
-0.0482584983,
-0.053000737,
0.0086399503,
-0.0419254042,
-0.1064058691,
0.035199929,
-0.0217694249,
-5.683030662e-33,
0.0403152071,
-0.0479707085,
-0.0149718849,
0.0150185432,
-0.0017422708,
-0.0537193231,
0.0164231136,
0.0559286997,
0.0237116553,
-0.0389602929,
-0.0345502198,
-0.0183281638,
0.0193725135,
0.0119684851,
0.0575190894,
-0.0521681793,
0.1044441685,
-0.0207525995,
0.0050321915,
0.0205779802,
0.0122297322,
-0.0071864226,
-0.008794928,
-0.0556248873,
0.051287137,
-0.0457447916,
-0.0351106673,
-0.0313180275,
-0.0361893959,
-0.0152795808,
0.0291055404,
-0.0064854319,
0.0213090628,
0.0519316234,
0.0076061203,
0.0533739105,
-0.0187562834,
0.0121277682,
-0.0043842341,
0.0073692836,
-0.0349715911,
-0.0222590473,
0.0021211538,
-0.002113539,
-0.0891105011,
0.0590723343,
0.0271378327,
0.0156186679,
0.0073891515,
0.0167616736,
-0.0394667238,
-0.0550097898,
0.0011197174,
0.0213149786,
-0.0450191535,
0.0359957963,
-0.0023292417,
-0.0651685447,
-0.0936897919,
0.043822173,
-0.011366657,
-0.0029942764,
0.0346076116,
-0.0302930456,
0.0215320457,
0.0092111807,
0.000232589,
-0.0218984839,
0.0134654632,
0.0149271777,
-0.0276259053,
0.0452860259,
-0.0188488513,
0.0557305068,
-0.0050271084,
-0.0533371978,
0.0254329368,
-0.008317099,
0.0533367395,
0.0157393459,
0.0273298007,
0.0148028499,
-0.0182079989,
0.003504812,
0.0271012355,
0.0298820324,
-0.0185621046,
-0.0714337751,
0.0267562289,
0.0383301862,
-0.052052673,
-0.050626155,
-0.0258307289,
0.0083405217,
-0.0000295852,
-0.0771086067,
0.0180493463,
0.001710203,
-0.0086408611,
-0.0308113638,
-0.0071676066,
-0.0103098825,
-0.0513798781,
0.08798296,
-0.03435608,
0.0015662429,
-0.0188398995,
0.0757002085,
-0.0199296903,
-0.0068175429,
0.074326694,
-0.0099318605,
-0.0460608751,
-0.0125649534,
-0.0108473469,
0.0222701486,
0.0188354496,
0.0670479909,
-0.0842002779,
-0.0362397619,
-0.0524580367,
0.0020229169,
0.0201791208,
-0.0336458907,
-0.0119021712,
-0.0158563405,
-0.084126167,
0.0201673806,
0.0458410643,
0.0420420393,
-0.0279949829,
-0.0317241699,
2.808e-7,
-0.0607452169,
0.0216313731,
-0.0735885799,
-0.0206568241,
-0.0196762681,
0.0524020642,
-0.0000189548,
0.0375615992,
0.0535418615,
0.0270729866,
0.0383767746,
-0.0940406621,
0.0029994787,
0.0044900356,
-0.0716115683,
-0.0403683297,
-0.014643657,
0.056657251,
0.0190209281,
0.0603391789,
0.0808352455,
-0.0595788322,
0.0012139005,
0.0115831383,
0.0059926561,
-0.0027256196,
-0.0028902639,
-0.0656328648,
0.03776972,
-0.0337886773,
0.0137436828,
0.0055088224,
0.0093601085,
-0.0542863756,
-0.0096002016,
-0.0475768186,
-0.0614148863,
0.0537037961,
0.0077371495,
-0.090904206,
-0.0056281649,
-0.0233008787,
0.0142607829,
-0.039073009,
-0.0091523314,
-0.0211604983,
-0.0531808063,
0.0150787346,
0.0647710636,
-0.0365015753,
0.0226484481,
-0.0451747999,
0.0220220555,
-0.0171950627,
-0.0082596783,
0.0025137966,
-0.0402904861,
-0.004022555,
0.0818821117,
-0.0327726714,
-0.0041063023,
-0.0821043625,
0.0163857266,
0.0062262118,
-0.0280095581,
0.0202206075,
-0.0085364962,
1.595708786e-34,
-0.0540666915,
0.0150005082,
0.019186439,
0.0140200816,
0.0066463249,
0.0423858389,
0.0836348906,
-0.0096643278,
0.0312658362,
-0.0028710214,
-0.0401563421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11805v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11805v4 | Gemini: A Family of Highly Capable Multimodal Models | 2023-12-19T02:39:27 | 2024-06-17T22:05:29 | Gemini Team, Rohan Anil, Sebastian Borgeaud, Jean-Baptiste Alayrac, Jiahui Yu, Radu Soricut, Johan Schalkwyk, Andrew M. Dai, Anja Hauth, Katie Millican, David Silver, Melvin Johnson, Ioannis Antonoglou, Julian Schrittwieser, Amelia Glaese, Jilin Chen, Emily Pitler, Timothy Lillicrap, Angeliki Lazaridou, Orhan Firat, James Molloy, Michael Isard, Paul R. Barham, Tom Hennigan, Benjamin Lee, Fabio Viola, Malcolm Reynolds, Yuanzhong Xu, Ryan Doherty, Eli Collins, Clemens Meyer, Eliza Rutherford, Erica Moreira, Kareem Ayoub, Megha Goel, Jack Krawczyk, Cosmo Du, Ed Chi, Heng-Tze Cheng, Eric Ni, Purvi Shah, Patrick Kane, Betty Chan, Manaal Faruqui, Aliaksei Severyn, Hanzhao Lin, YaGuang Li, Yong Cheng, Abe Ittycheriah, Mahdis Mahdieh, Mia Chen, Pei Sun, Dustin Tran, Sumit Bagri, Balaji Lakshminarayanan, Jeremiah Liu, Andras Orban, Fabian Güra, Hao Zhou, Xinying Song, Aurelien Boffy, Harish Ganapathy, Steven Zheng, HyunJeong Choe, Ágoston Weisz, Tao Zhu, Yifeng Lu, Siddharth Gopal, Jarrod Kahn, Maciej Kula, Jeff Pitman, Rushin Shah, Emanuel Taropa, Majd Al Merey, Martin Baeuml, Zhifeng Chen, Laurent El Shafey, Yujing Zhang, Olcan Sercinoglu, George Tucker, Enrique Piqueras, Maxim Krikun, Iain Barr, Nikolay Savinov, Ivo Danihelka, Becca Roelofs, Anaïs White, Anders Andreassen, Tamara von Glehn, Lakshman Yagati, Mehran Kazemi, Lucas Gonzalez, Misha Khalman, Jakub Sygnowski, Alexandre Frechette, Charlotte Smith, Laura Culp, Lev Proleev, Yi Luan, Xi Chen, James Lottes, Nathan Schucher, Federico Lebron, Alban Rrustemi, Natalie Clay, Phil Crone, Tomas Kocisky, Jeffrey Zhao, Bartek Perz, Dian Yu, Heidi Howard, Adam Bloniarz, Jack W. Rae, Han Lu, Laurent Sifre, Marcello Maggioni, Fred Alcober, Dan Garrette, Megan Barnes, Shantanu Thakoor, Jacob Austin, Gabriel Barth-Maron, William Wong, Rishabh Joshi, Rahma Chaabouni, Deeni Fatiha, Arun Ahuja, Gaurav Singh Tomar, Evan Senter, Martin Chadwick, Ilya Kornakov, Nithya Attaluri, Iñaki Iturrate, Ruibo Liu, Yunxuan Li, Sarah Cogan, Jeremy Chen, Chao Jia, Chenjie Gu, Qiao Zhang, Jordan Grimstad, Ale Jakse Hartman, Xavier Garcia, Thanumalayan Sankaranarayana Pillai, Jacob Devlin, Michael Laskin, Diego de Las Casas, Dasha Valter, Connie Tao, Lorenzo Blanco, Adrià Puigdomènech Badia, David Reitter, Mianna Chen, Jenny Brennan, Clara Rivera, Sergey Brin, Shariq Iqbal, Gabriela Surita, Jane Labanowski, Abhi Rao, Stephanie Winkler, Emilio Parisotto, Yiming Gu, Kate Olszewska, Ravi Addanki, Antoine Miech, Annie Louis, Denis Teplyashin, Geoff Brown, Elliot Catt, Jan Balaguer, Jackie Xiang, Pidong Wang, Zoe Ashwood, Anton Briukhov, Albert Webson, Sanjay Ganapathy, Smit Sanghavi, Ajay Kannan, Ming-Wei Chang, Axel Stjerngren, Josip Djolonga, Yuting Sun, Ankur Bapna, Matthew Aitchison, Pedram Pejman, Henryk Michalewski, Tianhe Yu, Cindy Wang, Juliette Love, Junwhan Ahn, Dawn Bloxwich, Kehang Han, Peter Humphreys, Thibault Sellam, James Bradbury, Varun Godbole, Sina Samangooei, Bogdan Damoc, Alex Kaskasoli, Sébastien M. R. Arnold, Vijay Vasudevan, Shubham Agrawal, Jason Riesa, Dmitry Lepikhin, Richard Tanburn, Srivatsan Srinivasan, Hyeontaek Lim, Sarah Hodkinson, Pranav Shyam, Johan Ferret, Steven Hand, Ankush Garg, Tom Le Paine, Jian Li, Yujia Li, Minh Giang, Alexander Neitz, Zaheer Abbas, Sarah York, Machel Reid, Elizabeth Cole, Aakanksha Chowdhery, Dipanjan Das, Dominika Rogozińska, Vitaliy Nikolaev, Pablo Sprechmann, Zachary Nado, Lukas Zilka, Flavien Prost, Luheng He, Marianne Monteiro, Gaurav Mishra, Chris Welty, Josh Newlan, Dawei Jia, Miltiadis Allamanis, Clara Huiyi Hu, Raoul de Liedekerke, Justin Gilmer, Carl Saroufim, Shruti Rijhwani, Shaobo Hou, Disha Shrivastava, Anirudh Baddepudi, Alex Goldin, Adnan Ozturel, Albin Cassirer, Yunhan Xu, Daniel Sohn, Devendra Sachan, Reinald Kim Amplayo, Craig Swanson, Dessie Petrova, Shashi Narayan, Arthur Guez, Siddhartha Brahma, Jessica Landon, Miteyan Patel, Ruizhe Zhao, Kevin Villela, Luyu Wang, Wenhao Jia, Matthew Rahtz, Mai Giménez, Legg Yeung, James Keeling, Petko Georgiev, Diana Mincu, Boxi Wu, Salem Haykal, Rachel Saputro, Kiran Vodrahalli, James Qin, Zeynep Cankara, Abhanshu Sharma, Nick Fernando, Will Hawkins, Behnam Neyshabur, Solomon Kim, Adrian Hutter, Priyanka Agrawal, Alex Castro-Ros, George van den Driessche, Tao Wang, Fan Yang, Shuo-yiin Chang, Paul Komarek, Ross McIlroy, Mario Lučić, Guodong Zhang, Wael Farhan, Michael Sharman, Paul Natsev, Paul Michel, Yamini Bansal, Siyuan Qiao, Kris Cao, Siamak Shakeri, Christina Butterfield, Justin Chung, Paul Kishan Rubenstein, Shivani Agrawal, Arthur Mensch, Kedar Soparkar, Karel Lenc, Timothy Chung, Aedan Pope, Loren Maggiore, Jackie Kay, Priya Jhakra, Shibo Wang, Joshua Maynez, Mary Phuong, Taylor Tobin, Andrea Tacchetti, Maja Trebacz, Kevin Robinson, Yash Katariya, Sebastian Riedel, Paige Bailey, Kefan Xiao, Nimesh Ghelani, Lora Aroyo, Ambrose Slone, Neil Houlsby, Xuehan Xiong, Zhen Yang, Elena Gribovskaya, Jonas Adler, Mateo Wirth, Lisa Lee, Music Li, Thais Kagohara, Jay Pavagadhi, Sophie Bridgers, Anna Bortsova, Sanjay Ghemawat, Zafarali Ahmed, Tianqi Liu, Richard Powell, Vijay Bolina, Mariko Iinuma, Polina Zablotskaia, James Besley, Da-Woon Chung, Timothy Dozat, Ramona Comanescu, Xiance Si, Jeremy Greer, Guolong Su, Martin Polacek, Raphaël Lopez Kaufman, Simon Tokumine, Hexiang Hu, Elena Buchatskaya, Yingjie Miao, Mohamed Elhawaty, Aditya Siddhant, Nenad Tomasev, Jinwei Xing, Christina Greer, Helen Miller, Shereen Ashraf, Aurko Roy, Zizhao Zhang, Ada Ma, Angelos Filos, Milos Besta, Rory Blevins, Ted Klimenko, Chih-Kuan Yeh, Soravit Changpinyo, Jiaqi Mu, Oscar Chang, Mantas Pajarskas, Carrie Muir, Vered Cohen, Charline Le Lan, Krishna Haridasan, Amit Marathe, Steven Hansen, Sholto Douglas, Rajkumar Samuel, Mingqiu Wang, Sophia Austin, Chang Lan, Jiepu Jiang, Justin Chiu, Jaime Alonso Lorenzo, Lars Lowe Sjösund, Sébastien Cevey, Zach Gleicher, Thi Avrahami, Anudhyan Boral, Hansa Srinivasan, Vittorio Selo, Rhys May, Konstantinos Aisopos, Léonard Hussenot, Livio Baldini Soares, Kate Baumli, Michael B. Chang, Adrià Recasens, Ben Caine, Alexander Pritzel, Filip Pavetic, Fabio Pardo, Anita Gergely, Justin Frye, Vinay Ramasesh, Dan Horgan, Kartikeya Badola, Nora Kassner, Subhrajit Roy, Ethan Dyer, Víctor Campos Campos, Alex Tomala, Yunhao Tang, Dalia El Badawy, Elspeth White, Basil Mustafa, Oran Lang, Abhishek Jindal, Sharad Vikram, Zhitao Gong, Sergi Caelles, Ross Hemsley, Gregory Thornton, Fangxiaoyu Feng, Wojciech Stokowiec, Ce Zheng, Phoebe Thacker, Çağlar Ünlü, Zhishuai Zhang, Mohammad Saleh, James Svensson, Max Bileschi, Piyush Patil, Ankesh Anand, Roman Ring, Katerina Tsihlas, Arpi Vezer, Marco Selvi, Toby Shevlane, Mikel Rodriguez, Tom Kwiatkowski, Samira Daruki, Keran Rong, Allan Dafoe, Nicholas FitzGerald, Keren Gu-Lemberg, Mina Khan, Lisa Anne Hendricks, Marie Pellat, Vladimir Feinberg, James Cobon-Kerr, Tara Sainath, Maribeth Rauh, Sayed Hadi Hashemi, Richard Ives, Yana Hasson, Eric Noland, Yuan Cao, Nathan Byrd, Le Hou, Qingze Wang, Thibault Sottiaux, Michela Paganini, Jean-Baptiste Lespiau, Alexandre Moufarek, Samer Hassan, Kaushik Shivakumar, Joost van Amersfoort, Amol Mandhane, Pratik Joshi, Anirudh Goyal, Matthew Tung, Andrew Brock, Hannah Sheahan, Vedant Misra, Cheng Li, Nemanja Rakićević, Mostafa Dehghani, Fangyu Liu, Sid Mittal, Junhyuk Oh, Seb Noury, Eren Sezener, Fantine Huot, Matthew Lamm, Nicola De Cao, Charlie Chen, Sidharth Mudgal, Romina Stella, Kevin Brooks, Gautam Vasudevan, Chenxi Liu, Mainak Chain, Nivedita Melinkeri, Aaron Cohen, Venus Wang, Kristie Seymore, Sergey Zubkov, Rahul Goel, Summer Yue, Sai Krishnakumaran, Brian Albert, Nate Hurley, Motoki Sano, Anhad Mohananey, Jonah Joughin, Egor Filonov, Tomasz Kępa, Yomna Eldawy, Jiawern Lim, Rahul Rishi, Shirin Badiezadegan, Taylor Bos, Jerry Chang, Sanil Jain, Sri Gayatri Sundara Padmanabhan, Subha Puttagunta, Kalpesh Krishna, Leslie Baker, Norbert Kalb, Vamsi Bedapudi, Adam Kurzrok, Shuntong Lei, Anthony Yu, Oren Litvin, Xiang Zhou, Zhichun Wu, Sam Sobell, Andrea Siciliano, Alan Papir, Robby Neale, Jonas Bragagnolo, Tej Toor, Tina Chen, Valentin Anklin, Feiran Wang, Richie Feng, Milad Gholami, Kevin Ling, Lijuan Liu, Jules Walter, Hamid Moghaddam, Arun Kishore, Jakub Adamek, Tyler Mercado, Jonathan Mallinson, Siddhinita Wandekar, Stephen Cagle, Eran Ofek, Guillermo Garrido, Clemens Lombriser, Maksim Mukha, Botu Sun, Hafeezul Rahman Mohammad, Josip Matak, Yadi Qian, Vikas Peswani, Pawel Janus, Quan Yuan, Leif Schelin, Oana David, Ankur Garg, Yifan He, Oleksii Duzhyi, Anton Älgmyr, Timothée Lottaz, Qi Li, Vikas Yadav, Luyao Xu, Alex Chinien, Rakesh Shivanna, Aleksandr Chuklin, Josie Li, Carrie Spadine, Travis Wolfe, Kareem Mohamed, Subhabrata Das, Zihang Dai, Kyle He, Daniel von Dincklage, Shyam Upadhyay, Akanksha Maurya, Luyan Chi, Sebastian Krause, Khalid Salama, Pam G Rabinovitch, Pavan Kumar Reddy M, Aarush Selvan, Mikhail Dektiarev, Golnaz Ghiasi, Erdem Guven, Himanshu Gupta, Boyi Liu, Deepak Sharma, Idan Heimlich Shtacher, Shachi Paul, Oscar Akerlund, François-Xavier Aubet, Terry Huang, Chen Zhu, Eric Zhu, Elico Teixeira, Matthew Fritze, Francesco Bertolini, Liana-Eleonora Marinescu, Martin Bölle, Dominik Paulus, Khyatti Gupta, Tejasi Latkar, Max Chang, Jason Sanders, Roopa Wilson, Xuewei Wu, Yi-Xuan Tan, Lam Nguyen Thiet, Tulsee Doshi, Sid Lall, Swaroop Mishra, Wanming Chen, Thang Luong, Seth Benjamin, Jasmine Lee, Ewa Andrejczuk, Dominik Rabiej, Vipul Ranjan, Krzysztof Styrc, Pengcheng Yin, Jon Simon, Malcolm Rose Harriott, Mudit Bansal, Alexei Robsky, Geoff Bacon, David Greene, Daniil Mirylenka, Chen Zhou, Obaid Sarvana, Abhimanyu Goyal, Samuel Andermatt, Patrick Siegler, Ben Horn, Assaf Israel, Francesco Pongetti, Chih-Wei "Louis" Chen, Marco Selvatici, Pedro Silva, Kathie Wang, Jackson Tolins, Kelvin Guu, Roey Yogev, Xiaochen Cai, Alessandro Agostini, Maulik Shah, Hung Nguyen, Noah Ó Donnaile, Sébastien Pereira, Linda Friso, Adam Stambler, Adam Kurzrok, Chenkai Kuang, Yan Romanikhin, Mark Geller, ZJ Yan, Kane Jang, Cheng-Chun Lee, Wojciech Fica, Eric Malmi, Qijun Tan, Dan Banica, Daniel Balle, Ryan Pham, Yanping Huang, Diana Avram, Hongzhi Shi, Jasjot Singh, Chris Hidey, Niharika Ahuja, Pranab Saxena, Dan Dooley, Srividya Pranavi Potharaju, Eileen O'Neill, Anand Gokulchandran, Ryan Foley, Kai Zhao, Mike Dusenberry, Yuan Liu, Pulkit Mehta, Ragha Kotikalapudi, Chalence Safranek-Shrader, Andrew Goodman, Joshua Kessinger, Eran Globen, Prateek Kolhar, Chris Gorgolewski, Ali Ibrahim, Yang Song, Ali Eichenbaum, Thomas Brovelli, Sahitya Potluri, Preethi Lahoti, Cip Baetu, Ali Ghorbani, Charles Chen, Andy Crawford, Shalini Pal, Mukund Sridhar, Petru Gurita, Asier Mujika, Igor Petrovski, Pierre-Louis Cedoz, Chenmei Li, Shiyuan Chen, Niccolò Dal Santo, Siddharth Goyal, Jitesh Punjabi, Karthik Kappaganthu, Chester Kwak, Pallavi LV, Sarmishta Velury, Himadri Choudhury, Jamie Hall, Premal Shah, Ricardo Figueira, Matt Thomas, Minjie Lu, Ting Zhou, Chintu Kumar, Thomas Jurdi, Sharat Chikkerur, Yenai Ma, Adams Yu, Soo Kwak, Victor Ähdel, Sujeevan Rajayogam, Travis Choma, Fei Liu, Aditya Barua, Colin Ji, Ji Ho Park, Vincent Hellendoorn, Alex Bailey, Taylan Bilal, Huanjie Zhou, Mehrdad Khatir, Charles Sutton, Wojciech Rzadkowski, Fiona Macintosh, Konstantin Shagin, Paul Medina, Chen Liang, Jinjing Zhou, Pararth Shah, Yingying Bi, Attila Dankovics, Shipra Banga, Sabine Lehmann, Marissa Bredesen, Zifan Lin, John Eric Hoffmann, Jonathan Lai, Raynald Chung, Kai Yang, Nihal Balani, Arthur Bražinskas, Andrei Sozanschi, Matthew Hayes, Héctor Fernández Alcalde, Peter Makarov, Will Chen, Antonio Stella, Liselotte Snijders, Michael Mandl, Ante Kärrman, Paweł Nowak, Xinyi Wu, Alex Dyck, Krishnan Vaidyanathan, Raghavender R, Jessica Mallet, Mitch Rudominer, Eric Johnston, Sushil Mittal, Akhil Udathu, Janara Christensen, Vishal Verma, Zach Irving, Andreas Santucci, Gamaleldin Elsayed, Elnaz Davoodi, Marin Georgiev, Ian Tenney, Nan Hua, Geoffrey Cideron, Edouard Leurent, Mahmoud Alnahlawi, Ionut Georgescu, Nan Wei, Ivy Zheng, Dylan Scandinaro, Heinrich Jiang, Jasper Snoek, Mukund Sundararajan, Xuezhi Wang, Zack Ontiveros, Itay Karo, Jeremy Cole, Vinu Rajashekhar, Lara Tumeh, Eyal Ben-David, Rishub Jain, Jonathan Uesato, Romina Datta, Oskar Bunyan, Shimu Wu, John Zhang, Piotr Stanczyk, Ye Zhang, David Steiner, Subhajit Naskar, Michael Azzam, Matthew Johnson, Adam Paszke, Chung-Cheng Chiu, Jaume Sanchez Elias, Afroz Mohiuddin, Faizan Muhammad, Jin Miao, Andrew Lee, Nino Vieillard, Jane Park, Jiageng Zhang, Jeff Stanway, Drew Garmon, Abhijit Karmarkar, Zhe Dong, Jong Lee, Aviral Kumar, Luowei Zhou, Jonathan Evens, William Isaac, Geoffrey Irving, Edward Loper, Michael Fink, Isha Arkatkar, Nanxin Chen, Izhak Shafran, Ivan Petrychenko, Zhe Chen, Johnson Jia, Anselm Levskaya, Zhenkai Zhu, Peter Grabowski, Yu Mao, Alberto Magni, Kaisheng Yao, Javier Snaider, Norman Casagrande, Evan Palmer, Paul Suganthan, Alfonso Castaño, Irene Giannoumis, Wooyeol Kim, Mikołaj Rybiński, Ashwin Sreevatsa, Jennifer Prendki, David Soergel, Adrian Goedeckemeyer, Willi Gierke, Mohsen Jafari, Meenu Gaba, Jeremy Wiesner, Diana Gage Wright, Yawen Wei, Harsha Vashisht, Yana Kulizhskaya, Jay Hoover, Maigo Le, Lu Li, Chimezie Iwuanyanwu, Lu Liu, Kevin Ramirez, Andrey Khorlin, Albert Cui, Tian LIN, Marcus Wu, Ricardo Aguilar, Keith Pallo, Abhishek Chakladar, Ginger Perng, Elena Allica Abellan, Mingyang Zhang, Ishita Dasgupta, Nate Kushman, Ivo Penchev, Alena Repina, Xihui Wu, Tom van der Weide, Priya Ponnapalli, Caroline Kaplan, Jiri Simsa, Shuangfeng Li, Olivier Dousse, Fan Yang, Jeff Piper, Nathan Ie, Rama Pasumarthi, Nathan Lintz, Anitha Vijayakumar, Daniel Andor, Pedro Valenzuela, Minnie Lui, Cosmin Paduraru, Daiyi Peng, Katherine Lee, Shuyuan Zhang, Somer Greene, Duc Dung Nguyen, Paula Kurylowicz, Cassidy Hardin, Lucas Dixon, Lili Janzer, Kiam Choo, Ziqiang Feng, Biao Zhang, Achintya Singhal, Dayou Du, Dan McKinnon, Natasha Antropova, Tolga Bolukbasi, Orgad Keller, David Reid, Daniel Finchelstein, Maria Abi Raad, Remi Crocker, Peter Hawkins, Robert Dadashi, Colin Gaffney, Ken Franko, Anna Bulanova, Rémi Leblond, Shirley Chung, Harry Askham, Luis C. Cobo, Kelvin Xu, Felix Fischer, Jun Xu, Christina Sorokin, Chris Alberti, Chu-Cheng Lin, Colin Evans, Alek Dimitriev, Hannah Forbes, Dylan Banarse, Zora Tung, Mark Omernick, Colton Bishop, Rachel Sterneck, Rohan Jain, Jiawei Xia, Ehsan Amid, Francesco Piccinno, Xingyu Wang, Praseem Banzal, Daniel J. Mankowitz, Alex Polozov, Victoria Krakovna, Sasha Brown, MohammadHossein Bateni, Dennis Duan, Vlad Firoiu, Meghana Thotakuri, Tom Natan, Matthieu Geist, Ser tan Girgin, Hui Li, Jiayu Ye, Ofir Roval, Reiko Tojo, Michael Kwong, James Lee-Thorp, Christopher Yew, Danila Sinopalnikov, Sabela Ramos, John Mellor, Abhishek Sharma, Kathy Wu, David Miller, Nicolas Sonnerat, Denis Vnukov, Rory Greig, Jennifer Beattie, Emily Caveness, Libin Bai, Julian Eisenschlos, Alex Korchemniy, Tomy Tsai, Mimi Jasarevic, Weize Kong, Phuong Dao, Zeyu Zheng, Frederick Liu, Fan Yang, Rui Zhu, Tian Huey Teh, Jason Sanmiya, Evgeny Gladchenko, Nejc Trdin, Daniel Toyama, Evan Rosen, Sasan Tavakkol, Linting Xue, Chen Elkind, Oliver Woodman, John Carpenter, George Papamakarios, Rupert Kemp, Sushant Kafle, Tanya Grunina, Rishika Sinha, Alice Talbert, Diane Wu, Denese Owusu-Afriyie, Cosmo Du, Chloe Thornton, Jordi Pont-Tuset, Pradyumna Narayana, Jing Li, Saaber Fatehi, John Wieting, Omar Ajmeri, Benigno Uria, Yeongil Ko, Laura Knight, Amélie Héliou, Ning Niu, Shane Gu, Chenxi Pang, Yeqing Li, Nir Levine, Ariel Stolovich, Rebeca Santamaria-Fernandez, Sonam Goenka, Wenny Yustalim, Robin Strudel, Ali Elqursh, Charlie Deck, Hyo Lee, Zonglin Li, Kyle Levin, Raphael Hoffmann, Dan Holtmann-Rice, Olivier Bachem, Sho Arora, Christy Koh, Soheil Hassas Yeganeh, Siim Põder, Mukarram Tariq, Yanhua Sun, Lucian Ionita, Mojtaba Seyedhosseini, Pouya Tafti, Zhiyu Liu, Anmol Gulati, Jasmine Liu, Xinyu Ye, Bart Chrzaszcz, Lily Wang, Nikhil Sethi, Tianrun Li, Ben Brown, Shreya Singh, Wei Fan, Aaron Parisi, Joe Stanton, Vinod Koverkathu, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Yunjie Li, TJ Lu, Abe Ittycheriah, Prakash Shroff, Mani Varadarajan, Sanaz Bahargam, Rob Willoughby, David Gaddy, Guillaume Desjardins, Marco Cornero, Brona Robenek, Bhavishya Mittal, Ben Albrecht, Ashish Shenoy, Fedor Moiseev, Henrik Jacobsson, Alireza Ghaffarkhah, Morgane Rivière, Alanna Walton, Clément Crepy, Alicia Parrish, Zongwei Zhou, Clement Farabet, Carey Radebaugh, Praveen Srinivasan, Claudia van der Salm, Andreas Fidjeland, Salvatore Scellato, Eri Latorre-Chimoto, Hanna Klimczak-Plucińska, David Bridson, Dario de Cesare, Tom Hudson, Piermaria Mendolicchio, Lexi Walker, Alex Morris, Matthew Mauger, Alexey Guseynov, Alison Reid, Seth Odoom, Lucia Loher, Victor Cotruta, Madhavi Yenugula, Dominik Grewe, Anastasia Petrushkina, Tom Duerig, Antonio Sanchez, Steve Yadlowsky, Amy Shen, Amir Globerson, Lynette Webb, Sahil Dua, Dong Li, Surya Bhupatiraju, Dan Hurt, Haroon Qureshi, Ananth Agarwal, Tomer Shani, Matan Eyal, Anuj Khare, Shreyas Rammohan Belle, Lei Wang, Chetan Tekur, Mihir Sanjay Kale, Jinliang Wei, Ruoxin Sang, Brennan Saeta, Tyler Liechty, Yi Sun, Yao Zhao, Stephan Lee, Pandu Nayak, Doug Fritz, Manish Reddy Vuyyuru, John Aslanides, Nidhi Vyas, Martin Wicke, Xiao Ma, Evgenii Eltyshev, Nina Martin, Hardie Cate, James Manyika, Keyvan Amiri, Yelin Kim, Xi Xiong, Kai Kang, Florian Luisier, Nilesh Tripuraneni, David Madras, Mandy Guo, Austin Waters, Oliver Wang, Joshua Ainslie, Jason Baldridge, Han Zhang, Garima Pruthi, Jakob Bauer, Feng Yang, Riham Mansour, Jason Gelman, Yang Xu, George Polovets, Ji Liu, Honglong Cai, Warren Chen, XiangHai Sheng, Emily Xue, Sherjil Ozair, Christof Angermueller, Xiaowei Li, Anoop Sinha, Weiren Wang, Julia Wiesinger, Emmanouil Koukoumidis, Yuan Tian, Anand Iyer, Madhu Gurumurthy, Mark Goldenson, Parashar Shah, MK Blake, Hongkun Yu, Anthony Urbanowicz, Jennimaria Palomaki, Chrisantha Fernando, Ken Durden, Harsh Mehta, Nikola Momchev, Elahe Rahimtoroghi, Maria Georgaki, Amit Raul, Sebastian Ruder, Morgan Redshaw, Jinhyuk Lee, Denny Zhou, Komal Jalan, Dinghua Li, Blake Hechtman, Parker Schuh, Milad Nasr, Kieran Milan, Vladimir Mikulik, Juliana Franco, Tim Green, Nam Nguyen, Joe Kelley, Aroma Mahendru, Andrea Hu, Joshua Howland, Ben Vargas, Jeffrey Hui, Kshitij Bansal, Vikram Rao, Rakesh Ghiya, Emma Wang, Ke Ye, Jean Michel Sarr, Melanie Moranski Preston, Madeleine Elish, Steve Li, Aakash Kaku, Jigar Gupta, Ice Pasupat, Da-Cheng Juan, Milan Someswar, Tejvi M., Xinyun Chen, Aida Amini, Alex Fabrikant, Eric Chu, Xuanyi Dong, Amruta Muthal, Senaka Buthpitiya, Sarthak Jauhari, Nan Hua, Urvashi Khandelwal, Ayal Hitron, Jie Ren, Larissa Rinaldi, Shahar Drath, Avigail Dabush, Nan-Jiang Jiang, Harshal Godhia, Uli Sachs, Anthony Chen, Yicheng Fan, Hagai Taitelbaum, Hila Noga, Zhuyun Dai, James Wang, Chen Liang, Jenny Hamer, Chun-Sung Ferng, Chenel Elkind, Aviel Atias, Paulina Lee, Vít Listík, Mathias Carlen, Jan van de Kerkhof, Marcin Pikus, Krunoslav Zaher, Paul Müller, Sasha Zykova, Richard Stefanec, Vitaly Gatsko, Christoph Hirnschall, Ashwin Sethi, Xingyu Federico Xu, Chetan Ahuja, Beth Tsai, Anca Stefanoiu, Bo Feng, Keshav Dhandhania, Manish Katyal, Akshay Gupta, Atharva Parulekar, Divya Pitta, Jing Zhao, Vivaan Bhatia, Yashodha Bhavnani, Omar Alhadlaq, Xiaolin Li, Peter Danenberg, Dennis Tu, Alex Pine, Vera Filippova, Abhipso Ghosh, Ben Limonchik, Bhargava Urala, Chaitanya Krishna Lanka, Derik Clive, Yi Sun, Edward Li, Hao Wu, Kevin Hongtongsak, Ianna Li, Kalind Thakkar, Kuanysh Omarov, Kushal Majmundar, Michael Alverson, Michael Kucharski, Mohak Patel, Mudit Jain, Maksim Zabelin, Paolo Pelagatti, Rohan Kohli, Saurabh Kumar, Joseph Kim, Swetha Sankar, Vineet Shah, Lakshmi Ramachandruni, Xiangkai Zeng, Ben Bariach, Laura Weidinger, Tu Vu, Alek Andreev, Antoine He, Kevin Hui, Sheleem Kashem, Amar Subramanya, Sissie Hsiao, Demis Hassabis, Koray Kavukcuoglu, Adam Sadovsky, Quoc Le, Trevor Strohman, Yonghui Wu, Slav Petrov, Jeffrey Dean, Oriol Vinyals | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | This report introduces a new family of multimodal models, Gemini, that
exhibit remarkable capabilities across image, audio, video, and text
understanding. The Gemini family consists of Ultra, Pro, and Nano sizes,
suitable for applications ranging from complex reasoning tasks to on-device
memory-constrained use-cases. Evaluation on a broad range of benchmarks shows
that our most-capable Gemini Ultra model advances the state of the art in 30 of
32 of these benchmarks - notably being the first model to achieve human-expert
performance on the well-studied exam benchmark MMLU, and improving the state of
the art in every one of the 20 multimodal benchmarks we examined. We believe
that the new capabilities of the Gemini family in cross-modal reasoning and
language understanding will enable a wide variety of use cases. We discuss our
approach toward post-training and deploying Gemini models responsibly to users
through services including Gemini, Gemini Advanced, Google AI Studio, and Cloud
Vertex AI. | [
0.017651761,
0.0448169,
-0.0096327346,
0.0585157499,
-0.0290552694,
-0.0034579879,
0.053372439,
-0.0375049226,
-0.0428416245,
-0.0747924745,
-0.0358634144,
-0.0424018167,
-0.0381105542,
0.0890138596,
0.0182515681,
-0.0813780352,
0.0654263124,
-0.0450202785,
-0.0040639765,
-0.0085909255,
0.0188211612,
0.0080172904,
-0.0608405396,
0.0447614416,
-0.0473527275,
-0.0419152416,
-0.0617430024,
0.0111100683,
0.0032871228,
-0.0203156807,
-0.0229568239,
0.0415198319,
0.0493843369,
0.0414362364,
0.0000020867,
-0.0105749117,
0.0069564907,
-0.0102261137,
-0.0329007618,
-0.0358503088,
0.0683860034,
-0.0075950716,
0.0023186479,
-0.0056579122,
-0.0322888568,
-0.016444819,
0.0444487743,
0.0098457783,
0.087834768,
0.0545378402,
-0.0093349414,
-0.0262637194,
0.0291766431,
0.0028410463,
-0.0040602353,
-0.0584190413,
-0.0223657861,
0.013938739,
0.0360965617,
0.0059273997,
-0.0247435868,
0.0216523465,
0.0581921861,
0.0281005241,
-0.0364592075,
0.0282262359,
-0.0193101689,
-0.0484371334,
-0.0437753871,
0.0743108913,
0.0141666736,
0.0057684756,
-0.0104186116,
0.0331802517,
0.0003708286,
-0.0028407006,
-0.0344130993,
0.0081483563,
-0.0256805196,
-0.0301812701,
-0.0572603047,
-0.0157739464,
0.0357402414,
0.0170040112,
-0.0126680089,
0.0255346186,
0.0103334077,
0.029483635,
-0.004105981,
-0.0308944713,
-0.0444064066,
-0.0241717473,
-0.0067567485,
0.0399197266,
-0.047672309,
-0.0095740445,
-0.0626234561,
-0.0292879343,
-0.0240211692,
0.0002976476,
0.0535029843,
0.0157235861,
-0.0469197594,
0.0822987035,
-0.0060980534,
0.039454747,
-0.0247114748,
0.0443143435,
-0.005495213,
-0.0334325507,
-0.0622525737,
-0.0140789337,
-0.01330481,
0.0043368451,
-0.0447797477,
-0.0816991031,
-0.0057734149,
0.0097979624,
-0.019345928,
0.0149572408,
-0.0059579862,
0.0453928635,
-0.013811483,
-0.0333272703,
-0.0263523366,
0.0420464203,
-0.041124545,
0.0440955758,
0.0312293544,
-0.0811952129,
0.0141280228,
0.0194721799,
-0.0054452023,
-0.0203164965,
0.0194164757,
0.1073701829,
-0.0440017134,
-0.0357586965,
-0.0120489784,
-0.0472537354,
0.0055810227,
-0.093642652,
0.0402218029,
-0.0225704517,
0.0518299006,
-0.005475027,
0.0017383686,
-0.025263099,
0.0034137839,
-0.0011686371,
-0.0038215031,
0.0923322141,
-0.0149126481,
0.0072897431,
0.0221043304,
0.0176993962,
-0.0481730178,
0.0515416451,
0.0209696367,
0.0320383981,
0.0215137377,
-0.0059585143,
-0.0091213733,
0.0258416571,
-0.0232817307,
-0.0421327241,
-0.0431546643,
-0.0066171619,
0.0024488308,
0.0684759691,
0.0211452171,
0.0345514454,
-0.0227763131,
-0.0721934512,
0.0769598857,
0.0183121916,
-0.0077208066,
0.0200606845,
0.0277569685,
-0.0261352956,
0.0061946176,
-0.0343089029,
-0.0877425373,
0.0810394734,
-0.0046610613,
-0.0017904704,
0.0211852901,
0.0168125983,
-0.0277988967,
-0.0280217212,
-0.017017426,
0.0103184516,
-0.0274818037,
0.039124161,
0.0421014279,
-0.0231034849,
-0.0229383912,
-0.0029935879,
-0.0026647002,
-0.0135016469,
-0.0296814237,
-0.0646641403,
0.0162606221,
0.0574129224,
0.0153273484,
-0.0051377066,
-0.0449008085,
0.0128205139,
0.0111041507,
0.0342822187,
0.0431438908,
-0.0031136454,
0.0538106225,
-0.0526303537,
-0.0293373615,
-0.0520573184,
-0.004879639,
0.0489362553,
-0.0010863907,
-0.0125517417,
-0.0042908094,
-0.0277959127,
0.0715872198,
0.0211982764,
0.034146402,
0.0133562079,
-0.0263868384,
-0.0004158619,
0.025925735,
-0.0062616654,
-0.008910724,
-0.0171020571,
0.0135626579,
-0.0179621223,
0.0255266484,
0.0169437565,
-0.0404369384,
-0.0055117458,
0.0270901788,
-0.0628250986,
0.0093304282,
0.0697810054,
-0.0450800732,
-0.0350278616,
0.035265211,
0.0020235491,
0.007683598,
-0.0639025867,
-0.0201353598,
0.0380787477,
0.0085128266,
0.027957499,
0.0432432853,
-0.0357577913,
-0.0108370818,
0.0052721123,
0.0118127586,
0.0267157182,
-0.0418179035,
-0.0222779997,
0.0152408741,
-0.0231578462,
0.0056244675,
-0.0337271951,
-0.0294717606,
-0.0433475412,
-0.0107937176,
-0.104137361,
0.0022892891,
-0.0306621883,
-0.0248863753,
-0.0144919716,
0.0019418328,
0.0035996747,
-0.0553945974,
-0.000081133,
0.0247162562,
0.0240588635,
0.0198998749,
-0.0201952774,
0.0134796621,
0.0373897031,
-0.0134430602,
-0.0140466541,
-0.0168266837,
0.0569924414,
-0.0013673991,
0.0215740446,
-0.0042371284,
-0.0187079571,
-0.040833205,
0.0563609712,
-0.0212579332,
-0.0112482607,
0.0395238996,
-0.0399356484,
0.02515609,
0.1010035947,
0.0036870542,
0.0278120209,
0.0265396498,
-0.0011142335,
-0.0367347859,
0.0452015698,
0.0345006771,
0.0058071143,
-0.0310181696,
0.0191316344,
-0.0504276082,
0.0554085672,
-0.0082168719,
0.0041354904,
-0.0350923315,
0.0366787352,
0.0184581392,
-0.0818701014,
-0.0334108286,
0.0375175066,
0.0135851018,
0.0075031724,
-0.0503783748,
-0.0183607861,
0.0536548756,
-0.0456960015,
-0.0063282554,
0.0181752685,
-0.0073505198,
-0.002628688,
0.0809071809,
0.0209491607,
0.0459305979,
-0.0345485769,
0.0049933596,
-0.0341681913,
0.0161936134,
0.019668445,
-0.0038165369,
0.013658613,
-0.0468749218,
-0.0002437545,
-0.0050863852,
-0.0417441912,
-0.0177235194,
-0.0016291214,
-0.0631476864,
0.0183745138,
-0.0150584802,
-0.0045720525,
-0.053436745,
0.0151080051,
0.0130955577,
0.0211542901,
-0.0106169051,
-0.0128252078,
-0.0313234441,
0.0441703908,
0.0358110629,
0.0687538236,
-0.0194039624,
-0.0447413959,
0.0046146619,
0.0606943332,
0.0346531346,
-0.0286960322,
-0.0865115076,
0.0520536117,
0.0011838562,
0.0238035358,
-0.0446177758,
0.0438595638,
0.0392158516,
-0.0782938376,
0.0236994326,
0.0608312339,
-0.0012813339,
-0.0315788276,
-0.0127725098,
-0.000504258,
0.0116243847,
0.0441160575,
-0.0102473469,
-0.0735720992,
-0.0984690711,
0.0166537613,
-0.0278974511,
0.044843182,
-0.0004930453,
0.0027112141,
-0.0509977676,
0.0383580998,
-0.0260899924,
-0.0230599884,
-0.0024299268,
0.0055864067,
0.0040424881,
-0.0090599786,
-0.0054770038,
0.0090487264,
0.000345813,
-0.0037699251,
0.0227361545,
0.0315786488,
-0.022954246,
0.0546217933,
-0.0315630808,
-0.00559557,
0.0405351594,
-0.006193833,
0.0024714428,
-0.0838397741,
0.0043390226,
0.0307295397,
0.0526958816,
0.0074896952,
0.0539944433,
-0.0336166285,
-0.0254328754,
-0.0099801766,
0.0285704341,
0.0054696496,
-0.0320075862,
-0.0215102769,
0.0666940138,
-0.0160513725,
-0.0006478242,
-0.0577187762,
0.0090559339,
-0.0255653337,
0.0435373224,
-0.014324774,
-0.0142863002,
-0.0840171203,
0.0023792041,
0.0019118643,
-0.0368161164,
-0.0069211693,
0.0292633995,
0.0504575819,
-0.0223173276,
-0.0060911076,
-0.0284110885,
0.0117911063,
0.0687572956,
-0.0076108072,
-0.0288569909,
-0.0356181189,
0.0611928068,
-0.0498210788,
0.0641825721,
0.0002256625,
0.0177145135,
-0.0536768995,
0.0349083282,
0.024535602,
-0.0454747193,
-0.0168036986,
0.0637618452,
-0.0575917587,
-0.0335632972,
-0.014616536,
0.0720886663,
0.0285086613,
0.0342418477,
0.0084261028,
-0.0435753576,
-0.0164270774,
-0.0257730447,
-0.0275322944,
0.013281526,
0.0474711731,
-0.0240582991,
-0.017584255,
0.0321696438,
-0.0333325006,
0.0116588455,
-0.0154155549,
0.0058152783,
-0.0264092628,
0.0059042564,
0.0134801343,
-0.0170976836,
0.0342134237,
0.0115991998,
0.0331453532,
-0.0163937155,
0.0273087658,
0.0267801676,
0.0126868933,
-0.0374982916,
0.0281148478,
0.0071891425,
0.0088038249,
0.0147152059,
-0.0125019802,
0.0524412356,
0.0068062111,
-0.0167625286,
0.013384046,
0.050738547,
0.0062420182,
-0.0163054392,
-0.000314363,
-0.0070900414,
0.0312766135,
-0.0140210446,
0.0471194647,
-0.028543422,
0.1048442572,
0.0091107404,
-0.0399936847,
-0.0387575813,
0.0488881953,
-0.0566488728,
-0.0526993051,
-0.0075415997,
0.0574602187,
0.0453761145,
0.0434311926,
-0.0351024792,
-0.0106112445,
-0.0145540498,
-0.0074945698,
0.0565773062,
0.0313178673,
-0.042507764,
0.0479374267,
0.0299630463,
0.0319987126,
-0.0192576144,
0.039586734,
-0.000954037,
0.0483766124,
0.0006885863,
0.0164409932,
-0.0434143469,
-0.0343840159,
0.0287420601,
0.0428537726,
0.0128182685,
0.0186881218,
-0.0376631096,
-0.0667922571,
-0.0096549019,
0.0586380288,
0.0015465255,
-0.0014081477,
0.0242025387,
0.0719344392,
0.0140751535,
-0.073493585,
-0.0058911168,
-0.0018475496,
-0.0138644846,
0.0361167602,
0.0224800445,
-6.337688813e-33,
-0.0122348042,
0.0204269197,
0.0494571701,
-0.0444348641,
-0.0065717516,
-0.0057176803,
-0.0228952225,
0.0089156842,
-0.0409945436,
0.0000527537,
0.0043160254,
0.0124017671,
0.0084970007,
0.0249430183,
0.0109493071,
-0.0051020379,
0.0292508099,
-0.0100956531,
-0.0121294502,
0.0012653801,
0.0443768427,
0.0224884041,
0.0334902592,
-0.0288386345,
-0.0191751849,
0.0336703137,
-0.0344404764,
0.0249527991,
-0.0752437189,
0.0669881925,
-0.0453749076,
-0.0132039282,
0.0213514902,
-0.013492072,
-0.0040645692,
0.0056578722,
-0.0713898391,
0.0031130742,
-0.002452519,
0.0276259314,
-0.0974967852,
-0.0293080695,
0.0246746801,
-0.0102621093,
-0.0016123503,
-0.0442026518,
0.0283335056,
-0.0107122799,
-0.0044752979,
-0.0036495444,
-0.0250591524,
0.0112853143,
-0.0144442981,
-0.0353528932,
0.0420592129,
0.0473661162,
-0.0120967384,
-0.0067589334,
-0.0355649702,
0.0086487718,
-0.0334661081,
-0.007781249,
0.1046470553,
0.009487642,
-0.0208640583,
0.0518376045,
0.0363527834,
-0.0644565225,
-0.0191907045,
-0.0219468493,
0.0253092628,
0.1243825257,
0.0155134909,
0.0629665628,
0.0180718713,
0.0120829958,
-0.0205158088,
0.0134765282,
0.0073751733,
0.0688106641,
0.014450036,
0.0073444662,
-0.0207669605,
0.0370606631,
-0.0366351232,
-0.0407570489,
-0.0500060134,
-0.0374720357,
0.0650240183,
0.0032806317,
0.0069723991,
0.013043548,
0.0725983083,
-0.0503454059,
0.0279249605,
-0.0034541341,
0.007838509,
0.0494741499,
-0.0032388582,
0.0463190861,
-0.001608633,
-0.0177250877,
0.033586707,
-0.0132629452,
0.0266907476,
-0.0264062006,
0.0090132887,
0.0486653298,
-0.0223701391,
-0.0302015021,
-0.0388935059,
0.0300733484,
0.0065932325,
0.0165041424,
0.0468216017,
0.0016532652,
-0.0384668,
0.0060659368,
-0.0495508946,
0.0128465444,
-0.0486724302,
-0.0410686843,
-0.0052183494,
0.0196048301,
-0.0285448059,
0.0113194594,
-0.0702151135,
-0.0911012292,
-0.010219967,
-0.0701151714,
-0.0053520477,
0.0796322301,
2.771e-7,
0.0064372891,
0.0110213142,
-0.0107787345,
-0.0170979369,
0.0158700738,
0.0542928912,
-0.0179470368,
0.0363190062,
-0.000829774,
-0.0356110856,
-0.009863277,
0.07717105,
0.0290253796,
0.0353305042,
-0.0130651146,
0.0169661641,
-0.001748409,
-0.0121546304,
-0.0540281683,
0.0231484417,
0.0485705137,
0.0716687292,
-0.0169982612,
-0.0166595671,
0.039707616,
-0.0287528876,
0.0604617633,
-0.007230619,
-0.0060112188,
-0.0195884388,
0.03363619,
0.005978168,
-0.023392491,
0.0283365455,
0.01280843,
-0.0178676285,
0.037507195,
0.0607871935,
-0.0236750115,
-0.0641533732,
-0.0235160477,
0.0206361767,
-0.0180784091,
-0.0326598547,
0.0954146981,
-0.0095194951,
-0.0276949592,
-0.0479660854,
-0.0280948356,
-0.0021483069,
-0.0293981396,
0.0005592923,
-0.0080287568,
0.0024584944,
0.0039517796,
-0.0505706929,
-0.0240358077,
-0.0819211155,
-0.0093981195,
0.0341994762,
-0.0725426599,
0.0029526094,
-0.0446819067,
-0.0258190576,
0.086357221,
-0.0469951108,
-0.070267342,
1.991947728e-34,
0.0115467189,
-0.0039763972,
0.0171921793,
0.0154542532,
0.0145438798,
-0.0076256143,
-0.0131207192,
-0.026052013,
0.0015388996,
-0.0607711785,
-0.0172728673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11803v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11803v2 | NLP for Maternal Healthcare: Perspectives and Guiding Principles in the Age of LLMs | 2023-12-19T02:35:13 | 2024-01-23T19:37:20 | Maria Antoniak, Aakanksha Naik, Carla S. Alvarado, Lucy Lu Wang, Irene Y. Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Ethical frameworks for the use of natural language processing (NLP) are
urgently needed to shape how large language models (LLMs) and similar tools are
used for healthcare applications. Healthcare faces existing challenges
including the balance of power in clinician-patient relationships, systemic
health disparities, historical injustices, and economic constraints. Drawing
directly from the voices of those most affected, and focusing on a case study
of a specific healthcare setting, we propose a set of guiding principles for
the use of NLP in maternal healthcare. We led an interactive session centered
on an LLM-based chatbot demonstration during a full-day workshop with 39
participants, and additionally surveyed 30 healthcare workers and 30 birthing
people about their values, needs, and perceptions of NLP tools in the context
of maternal health. We conducted quantitative and qualitative analyses of the
survey results and interactive discussions to consolidate our findings into a
set of guiding principles. We propose nine principles for ethical use of NLP
for maternal healthcare, grouped into three themes: (i) recognizing contextual
significance (ii) holistic measurements, and (iii) who/what is valued. For each
principle, we describe its underlying rationale and provide practical advice.
This set of principles can provide a methodological pattern for other
researchers and serve as a resource to practitioners working on maternal health
and other healthcare fields to emphasize the importance of technical nuance,
historical context, and inclusive design when developing NLP technologies for
clinical use. | [
0.0726938397,
0.1044935882,
-0.0236418061,
-0.0248526428,
-0.0523924828,
0.0216849409,
0.0137789492,
0.004517016,
0.0292897616,
-0.0383752324,
0.0437756181,
-0.0333620794,
0.0290175863,
0.0264808722,
-0.0299911089,
-0.0519234352,
-0.0310634766,
0.074212566,
0.0455832966,
0.0279994067,
0.0232031662,
0.0514505208,
-0.0273511093,
0.0842430517,
-0.036821086,
0.0078426255,
0.0216330849,
0.0016126067,
-0.0031421587,
-0.0741452128,
0.0008356249,
0.0338002518,
-0.0117035601,
0.0186816063,
0.0000020026,
-0.0462735333,
-0.0162366945,
0.0502754524,
-0.0549831316,
-0.0829173848,
0.1081587225,
-0.0663105249,
-0.0318035893,
0.0095058233,
-0.0352847129,
0.0280095562,
0.0870525315,
0.0399941653,
0.0084520206,
0.0277308952,
-0.0126996888,
0.0113654379,
0.0078363447,
0.0342938304,
-0.0037977872,
-0.0231537931,
0.0126253478,
0.0062054484,
0.0572899207,
-0.0201383997,
0.007633986,
0.0812610686,
-0.0154561736,
-0.0109823439,
-0.015760975,
0.0045830379,
0.0013563266,
-0.0872984752,
-0.0007737022,
0.0506996959,
0.0486138687,
0.0143305054,
0.0273856986,
0.0041940399,
-0.0372418053,
-0.003438459,
-0.0475980714,
0.0406521372,
-0.0284520201,
0.0120188678,
-0.02336834,
-0.0015221373,
0.0209902059,
0.0305855181,
0.0563323945,
-0.0182326846,
-0.0016751464,
-0.0136720072,
-0.0000297559,
0.0114345364,
0.0045313421,
0.0045230561,
0.044519078,
0.014552651,
-0.033060953,
0.0595239885,
-0.0042239367,
-0.0118740089,
0.0932397842,
-0.0764361098,
-0.0027830945,
0.001612012,
0.0274318568,
-0.0031268781,
0.0642118901,
-0.0267158486,
0.0221179724,
0.0185161661,
-0.044165656,
0.039683681,
-0.0343253314,
-0.0365500301,
0.0146975033,
-0.0040797312,
-0.0407496504,
0.036906559,
-0.0553308725,
-0.022457635,
-0.026716873,
-0.0005312188,
-0.0314177871,
0.0443140939,
0.0112072825,
0.0337121561,
-0.0312573388,
-0.0289582144,
0.0137167266,
0.0182834696,
-0.0241577569,
-0.0766089186,
0.0425800905,
-0.021747034,
-0.0193705391,
0.0447593443,
0.0104983216,
0.0920987874,
0.0271516703,
-0.0343815349,
-0.0022041376,
-0.0100981947,
-0.0320986211,
-0.0312200207,
0.0215227157,
-0.0208765343,
0.0180630144,
0.0247436631,
-0.0119213052,
-0.0733562931,
0.0374278761,
0.0491628386,
-0.0509842746,
0.052397158,
-0.0258546546,
0.007794416,
0.0243664198,
0.0535157025,
0.039630603,
0.0427841134,
0.0527196564,
-0.0524778739,
0.0447679982,
-0.0222687293,
-0.035945572,
-0.0084939729,
-0.0078506367,
-0.0474383868,
-0.0118515799,
0.0302410889,
-0.0119738933,
0.0472846925,
-0.0492503457,
0.0523811243,
0.010348619,
0.003381988,
0.0359822884,
0.1380306929,
-0.0177370664,
0.0108224461,
0.0261402875,
-0.0094220098,
-0.0188691895,
-0.0492520891,
-0.0011269242,
-0.0291753672,
0.0074578021,
-0.0535567813,
-0.0276043601,
0.0004246855,
0.0002346927,
-0.0593922138,
-0.0786499977,
-0.0352911316,
0.0337357484,
-0.0033161936,
-0.0207206775,
-0.0005396446,
0.0051425849,
0.0376807377,
0.0474365428,
-0.0694402754,
-0.0294855982,
-0.0635854751,
-0.0125975609,
0.096044749,
0.028940063,
-0.0251826905,
-0.0091351271,
-0.0409053415,
-0.0270107444,
0.041843012,
-0.0076597868,
0.0082652569,
-0.0115568768,
-0.0060143401,
-0.0172090195,
0.0502642505,
0.0028820205,
-0.0330211222,
-0.0043577668,
0.0368233137,
-0.0058661532,
0.0290720705,
-0.0472948998,
0.0596905351,
-0.0346659534,
-0.0334328525,
-0.0215578713,
-0.0117759323,
0.0389979258,
0.0509535857,
0.0229178872,
0.0338996165,
0.0198523793,
0.0071427687,
-0.0092721181,
0.0378636606,
-0.0223572031,
0.0049279057,
-0.0131302327,
-0.0586200245,
-0.0066986075,
0.0060748635,
0.0087060789,
0.0132812504,
-0.0162218343,
-0.0646845773,
0.0352496915,
-0.0235427804,
-0.008735843,
-0.018923007,
0.0105937822,
-0.0559587106,
-0.0281545259,
-0.0478206538,
0.0151080051,
-0.0021708407,
-0.0436530747,
-0.0484526865,
0.0039700083,
-0.0001421488,
0.0473215505,
0.0212422423,
0.0339308716,
0.0042214822,
0.0622321181,
-0.0431482829,
-0.0182268936,
-0.0911272168,
-0.0378472582,
0.0289032049,
-0.028274348,
-0.0064973738,
0.0131173655,
0.0121008996,
-0.0226194542,
-0.0142434156,
-0.0179406404,
0.0097530568,
0.0148326075,
0.0056217746,
-0.0166366566,
-0.0058684316,
-0.0066144047,
0.0028691534,
-0.0253912602,
0.0319078751,
0.0654696152,
-0.0091169961,
0.0168608837,
-0.0476742126,
-0.0405653417,
-0.0253333692,
0.0136940833,
-0.0006865772,
0.0442727692,
0.035585884,
-0.0434862748,
0.0242123809,
-0.0053418172,
0.0643880814,
-0.0150146792,
0.0206968095,
-0.0090360977,
-0.0295023005,
-0.005222803,
0.0241177659,
0.0269464944,
-0.0471487045,
0.0116956308,
0.0661879033,
0.0116125736,
-0.0182613377,
-0.0162476972,
0.0281994529,
-0.050746534,
-0.0122476947,
-0.0221787021,
-0.0380860381,
-0.0451396778,
0.0188773293,
0.0402750038,
-0.0399138369,
0.0632305518,
0.0076463739,
0.0139724864,
-0.0648287907,
-0.0572559908,
-0.0487398468,
0.0208417308,
-0.0399790816,
0.0390476063,
0.0379714184,
-0.0417297259,
0.0220533032,
-0.0086800754,
-0.0051882723,
-0.085382618,
0.0240499247,
-0.0364585891,
0.0329430886,
0.0046050558,
-0.0643883869,
-0.0519122817,
-0.0325887054,
-0.0402408242,
0.0055671874,
0.0334966518,
0.0444859788,
-0.0467907004,
0.0285492931,
-0.0111111859,
0.0320559777,
0.0781332105,
-0.0107786171,
0.0119233271,
-0.0519222021,
-0.0449389294,
0.0037125167,
0.0497746766,
0.0399817936,
0.0151522188,
0.0618017688,
-0.0262097083,
0.0313311554,
0.0321232043,
0.027130736,
0.0220978614,
-0.0121341739,
-0.0065637482,
0.0084313303,
0.0261736494,
-0.0447844602,
0.0232162625,
0.0536234826,
0.0074649467,
-0.04632698,
0.0395045392,
-0.038220901,
-0.0711622387,
-0.0166905485,
-0.0145949507,
-0.0711381137,
-0.0052063917,
-0.0100777382,
0.0341655836,
-0.0802798569,
-0.041058898,
-0.0127807017,
-0.0171657205,
-0.0099654282,
-0.004728124,
-0.027296355,
-0.0031511702,
-0.0348506458,
-0.0018393877,
0.0037395358,
0.055562444,
-0.009787783,
-0.0297212712,
-0.0372356772,
-0.0153042758,
-0.0699249879,
-0.0670233145,
0.045137167,
-0.0010376169,
0.0508619621,
0.0717335492,
0.0804089531,
0.0074764895,
0.0036753768,
-0.0106178652,
0.0377751701,
-0.019027885,
-0.003632779,
0.0107677504,
-0.002182401,
0.0042437338,
-0.0875101313,
0.0257502478,
-0.0181135759,
-0.0187372956,
-0.0144267576,
0.024425555,
-0.0386638083,
-0.025954714,
-0.0595199279,
0.0541606173,
0.0503154248,
0.0330353118,
0.0003125955,
-0.0244442057,
-0.0099878879,
-0.0001503097,
0.0392128639,
0.0775712952,
-0.0675527975,
0.0121453293,
-0.0243642032,
-0.0192364659,
-0.0606909022,
-0.0079716025,
-0.0065549263,
-0.0018334447,
0.0319350213,
-0.0024114044,
0.0805475712,
0.0270787943,
-0.0471588857,
0.0332504213,
0.0259894058,
-0.0035699802,
-0.0129452357,
-0.0384868756,
0.0174027607,
-0.003432245,
0.0202770866,
0.0098325629,
0.0355162062,
0.0095515735,
0.0160201583,
0.014461996,
0.0146107329,
0.0093416627,
0.0037212542,
0.0058979434,
-0.0186371226,
0.0836980417,
-0.0420888737,
-0.0116431424,
0.0000535492,
0.0619689152,
-0.0016112975,
-0.0033909371,
-0.0009888638,
0.0084125428,
-0.0116885323,
0.0246881302,
-0.0083635189,
-0.0086238524,
0.0177049506,
0.0346689895,
-0.0114417039,
-0.0376512632,
-0.0152860852,
0.0019579935,
-0.0307698492,
-0.0281367507,
-0.0142948087,
-0.0404603854,
0.0075276839,
-0.0095889159,
0.0014258176,
-0.0294055156,
-0.0014819325,
-0.1059089974,
-0.0271798838,
-0.0252588186,
0.0887680948,
-0.0014846867,
0.0214330293,
-0.0176921729,
-0.0070094587,
-0.0046381862,
0.0211873911,
-0.0314405113,
0.0399394706,
0.006573657,
0.0454074852,
-0.009962935,
-0.0070848628,
0.0059536067,
0.0470949337,
-0.0109713282,
-0.0680988953,
-0.0456094556,
0.0187056772,
-0.0051826406,
0.0029598477,
0.0031623014,
-0.0204417165,
0.0076110628,
0.0090636853,
-0.0290463213,
-0.0220907535,
-0.0116917295,
0.0276425779,
-0.0111533552,
-0.0333363675,
-0.0456603654,
0.023120638,
-0.0133771356,
0.0397333987,
-0.0028657529,
-0.0211014077,
-0.0186672118,
-0.0544083565,
0.0590156727,
-0.0427106358,
-0.044217214,
0.014468261,
-0.0745899901,
-0.0234978497,
-0.0008298185,
-0.0561345853,
-0.0053410577,
-0.0160350911,
0.051754225,
0.0238504689,
0.0211232342,
-0.026053872,
-0.0339036584,
0.0398997925,
-0.0380703211,
0.0002886718,
0.0534008853,
-5.380934859e-33,
0.0142672574,
-0.0599908419,
0.0254385546,
-0.0227674339,
-0.0240115058,
0.0090584075,
0.0035866243,
0.0293835513,
0.0065048393,
0.0224870685,
-0.0249705538,
-0.0142280553,
-0.002999997,
0.0469765551,
0.0037608659,
-0.0234121569,
0.0180051718,
0.0019507993,
0.0050855442,
0.0155284461,
-0.0355474316,
0.0333222859,
0.0468742587,
-0.0917546451,
0.0776263326,
0.0167682339,
-0.0014386172,
0.0227183942,
0.0310344901,
0.030356504,
-0.0262608714,
0.0277011655,
0.0273531079,
-0.0088669788,
-0.0198513027,
0.0740175694,
-0.0230510309,
-0.0120036025,
0.0296704024,
-0.0033518495,
-0.0552051216,
-0.0332328938,
0.0762041435,
-0.0128639201,
-0.0543558635,
0.0221712887,
0.022944808,
-0.0510388575,
0.042192433,
-0.0083802929,
-0.0343282372,
0.0092648147,
-0.0484679975,
-0.0122430203,
-0.0035500014,
-0.0099325581,
-0.0721427947,
-0.0008442174,
-0.0250374451,
-0.0218105949,
0.0047027427,
-0.0421620011,
0.0255062841,
-0.0494199283,
0.0489092097,
0.0601358376,
-0.0001229131,
0.0060107638,
-0.0445990115,
0.0045460328,
-0.0164957512,
0.0448675714,
0.0500894673,
0.0235092863,
-0.0161935128,
-0.0417018719,
-0.0435330421,
-0.005235489,
-0.0396202542,
0.0447206944,
0.0404136144,
-0.0128472475,
-0.074096635,
0.0090190396,
-0.0426981002,
-0.0357648507,
0.0057059336,
-0.0288333818,
0.0133200027,
-0.0033223513,
-0.0084074317,
-0.00700081,
-0.0335377455,
-0.0533638299,
-0.0013683668,
-0.0439614989,
0.0698607415,
-0.0431354791,
-0.0065877265,
-0.0265249461,
-0.0238654856,
0.009130572,
0.0082298368,
-0.0017926006,
0.0718166977,
-0.0130835781,
-0.0187026057,
-0.0203497838,
-0.0179486424,
-0.0303924121,
0.0282300785,
0.0313250162,
0.0464185774,
-0.0255648084,
0.0367962793,
0.0093795741,
-0.0092008421,
0.0597291999,
0.0254446231,
0.020276513,
-0.0090829665,
0.0072918255,
-0.0173610989,
0.001593826,
-0.0893157944,
-0.0220637433,
-0.0256330539,
0.0681931898,
0.0593257621,
-0.0383106135,
0.0003952807,
-0.0165958405,
2.637e-7,
0.0675869435,
0.0722794905,
0.0054395595,
-0.0303317457,
0.0227167364,
0.002369632,
0.0332193747,
0.028310826,
-0.0225190558,
-0.018749781,
0.0127008567,
0.0001502719,
0.0396490209,
0.0350668915,
-0.0578327999,
-0.0150605896,
-0.067324087,
-0.0130860144,
-0.0181083605,
0.0225936044,
0.0330763124,
0.052928973,
-0.038908951,
-0.0424910486,
-0.0145457452,
0.0272195637,
0.0152544137,
-0.0646377057,
0.0282168742,
0.0136012938,
-0.006612014,
-0.0087422756,
0.03771827,
0.0008816111,
0.0077532185,
-0.0381068438,
0.0403824449,
0.1173040494,
-0.0532368496,
-0.0158417579,
0.0092778644,
-0.0199744254,
0.0143639529,
-0.0235940255,
0.0402010679,
-0.0216039121,
-0.0525880121,
-0.027899785,
0.0351279564,
-0.0756028816,
0.0857789144,
-0.0195612293,
-0.0326026268,
0.0571195967,
0.0109882653,
0.0010899079,
-0.0017847526,
-0.0291350707,
-0.0070151025,
0.0194389131,
-0.0076591419,
-0.0424689651,
0.0512963533,
-0.0047678738,
-0.0232366137,
-0.0203526244,
0.0385335721,
2.106282691e-34,
-0.0063988976,
-0.0126638589,
0.0255628992,
0.0500639379,
0.0254120622,
0.0550415069,
0.0202888511,
0.007673922,
0.0272912569,
-0.010141097,
0.0179349948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11795v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11795v1 | MELO: Enhancing Model Editing with Neuron-Indexed Dynamic LoRA | 2023-12-19T02:11:01 | 2023-12-19T02:11:01 | Lang Yu, Qin Chen, Jie Zhou, Liang He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown great success in various Natural
Language Processing (NLP) tasks, whist they still need updates after deployment
to fix errors or keep pace with the changing knowledge in the world.
Researchers formulate such problem as Model Editing and have developed various
editors focusing on different axes of editing properties. However, current
editors can hardly support all properties and rely on heavy computational
resources. In this paper, we propose a plug-in Model Editing method based on
neuron-indexed dynamic LoRA (MELO), which alters the behavior of language
models by dynamically activating certain LoRA blocks according to the index
built in an inner vector database. Our method satisfies various editing
properties with high efficiency and can be easily integrated into multiple LLM
backbones. Experimental results show that our proposed MELO achieves
state-of-the-art editing performance on three sequential editing tasks
(document classification, question answering and hallucination correction),
while requires the least trainable parameters and computational cost. | [
0.0510126203,
0.0292157736,
-0.0199603327,
0.0287360121,
-0.0312014036,
0.012563712,
0.0113023976,
-0.0154909538,
0.0024231938,
-0.0617419854,
-0.0652995035,
-0.0182635393,
-0.0007411048,
0.0501222946,
0.0290681757,
-0.0592894703,
0.0754364803,
-0.014938687,
-0.0075499462,
0.0160473995,
-0.0204954185,
-0.0060645067,
-0.0049073575,
0.0243745651,
0.0502332263,
-0.0263263863,
-0.0516256355,
-0.0022866628,
0.001295318,
-0.0030328797,
-0.0030574519,
0.0673764497,
0.003868564,
0.0577895716,
0.0000021364,
-0.0297611803,
-0.03722753,
0.0188235976,
-0.0204246975,
0.000737361,
0.0532891303,
0.0023659167,
-0.0448944941,
0.0027040849,
-0.0205289721,
-0.0298662987,
0.0509554893,
0.032489948,
0.0743669271,
0.0741741583,
-0.0022551506,
-0.0151581168,
0.0574085042,
-0.0178296715,
-0.0210939217,
-0.0024805793,
0.0267972033,
0.0107338661,
-0.0382009782,
-0.0180663839,
-0.0260830242,
0.0431848466,
0.0278994311,
-0.0464699529,
0.0264531933,
0.0104077728,
-0.0410288312,
-0.0190593619,
-0.0280426722,
0.0328917913,
-0.0724274963,
-0.0136628486,
-0.018366864,
-0.016785698,
-0.0015589856,
-0.0291560516,
-0.040658243,
-0.0117384475,
0.0225992054,
0.0092233652,
0.0344169848,
-0.0897133872,
0.0344771296,
0.0316692144,
-0.005813736,
0.0539131723,
0.0622182898,
-0.016803883,
-0.040190164,
-0.0421982482,
-0.0149292909,
-0.0693670511,
0.0168504547,
0.0448052287,
0.0028419623,
0.0065894923,
-0.0566341169,
-0.0229977872,
0.0286138617,
-0.0708145052,
0.0805511549,
0.0385218114,
0.0102770552,
0.0379416831,
-0.0379225165,
0.0113876816,
-0.0161189195,
0.0413060486,
0.0158830434,
0.0046465867,
-0.0559559353,
-0.0333195105,
-0.0421465747,
0.049243819,
-0.0606311522,
-0.020651225,
-0.0364656001,
0.0463369638,
0.0131691927,
-0.0031352628,
-0.0258645229,
-0.0018653806,
0.0000336801,
-0.0186244193,
-0.0299949553,
0.0106205931,
0.0234744195,
0.0202765986,
-0.0194759481,
-0.0479167923,
-0.0021481437,
0.0015987947,
0.0189030971,
-0.0432316028,
0.0195823703,
0.0488012955,
0.0060002361,
-0.0502922609,
-0.0683057979,
-0.0187844131,
0.0325232074,
-0.0441168509,
-0.0053878673,
-0.0417094231,
0.0090438547,
-0.0400998071,
-0.032956548,
-0.0716627538,
-0.0004960531,
0.0249737352,
-0.0057724947,
0.0436592512,
-0.0615949854,
-0.0145620825,
0.0647259653,
0.0004511671,
0.0013921164,
0.0242141802,
0.0580741614,
0.0000966173,
0.033552397,
0.0121095041,
0.0185919181,
0.0461571328,
-0.0015279202,
0.0048311432,
-0.0793507174,
-0.0081537068,
0.0038485746,
0.0123655545,
0.0185810942,
0.0264826789,
-0.0558506325,
0.0056933677,
0.1001871973,
0.0340381935,
0.0627046153,
0.0573441163,
0.0102306651,
-0.0565677695,
0.0322352238,
-0.0501794778,
-0.0416935943,
0.0619256981,
-0.0451178886,
0.0097361188,
0.0033685945,
0.035014946,
-0.0034378823,
-0.0400956944,
-0.0099180005,
0.0401716717,
0.0161721651,
-0.0187596083,
0.0086914888,
0.0183260106,
-0.0181169454,
0.0639550164,
0.0005285141,
-0.0178602338,
-0.0277272779,
-0.0763189197,
-0.0014259701,
0.0792471841,
0.0770482421,
-0.0508115068,
-0.0796146616,
-0.0399118997,
-0.0192618072,
0.0715050325,
0.0370791554,
-0.0090942709,
0.0103847338,
-0.0466332473,
-0.0026368173,
-0.0277579408,
0.0253899097,
-0.0025846725,
0.0278259329,
0.0109764514,
-0.0083244937,
0.0131736966,
-0.0503265671,
0.0344033502,
-0.0346879847,
-0.0205330234,
0.0058006532,
-0.0080653513,
0.0113714291,
-0.019535508,
-0.0279431678,
-0.0109495074,
0.0048214658,
-0.0173283648,
-0.0354478508,
-0.0112082716,
-0.0016187455,
-0.0242525991,
0.0754461437,
0.0485866703,
-0.0090553937,
0.0121621862,
-0.0469253324,
-0.0168589521,
0.0031579719,
-0.0581914335,
0.0205817148,
-0.0674948096,
0.0339336097,
-0.0015634495,
0.0197239928,
-0.0315279923,
0.0308004245,
-0.0298108235,
-0.0106073925,
0.0382759124,
0.0203916002,
-0.0087094586,
-0.0471141003,
-0.0264339242,
0.0367459059,
0.0260769241,
-0.0077237845,
-0.0239217989,
-0.0124640185,
-0.0374369398,
-0.0558670349,
-0.039421428,
0.0029091558,
-0.0102112908,
0.0198101681,
0.0438924097,
0.0378852934,
-0.0200113486,
-0.0098389983,
-0.0155132841,
-0.0025371313,
-0.005324922,
0.0392673388,
0.0340496451,
0.0162210073,
-0.0443255231,
-0.0666162372,
-0.0318825543,
-0.0057504484,
0.0534323566,
-0.010047527,
-0.0600247793,
-0.0527799316,
0.0061892257,
-0.055821754,
0.0249450728,
0.0258716233,
-0.0419083536,
-0.0129476087,
-0.0056166234,
0.0073941713,
0.0689493939,
0.0007480906,
-0.003377276,
0.0875562504,
-0.0029581564,
-0.0159387328,
0.0131538184,
-0.0053432509,
0.0417737029,
-0.0320219621,
0.0156173781,
-0.0139430808,
0.0667455792,
0.0135043981,
-0.021096684,
0.0027432672,
0.030919401,
0.0070228204,
-0.0235318933,
0.0030982126,
-0.0256598704,
-0.013572352,
0.0240098443,
-0.0632255375,
-0.0488600805,
0.0590350293,
-0.0089587457,
-0.0018074862,
-0.0522009172,
-0.0279013366,
-0.0556671619,
0.0325255878,
0.010357338,
0.0301861968,
-0.05489989,
-0.0249329042,
-0.0473671891,
-0.0301998146,
-0.0050645755,
-0.0412398502,
0.0336908698,
-0.0543046966,
0.0055134171,
-0.0141682923,
-0.0172728449,
-0.016936969,
0.0011595542,
-0.0142055061,
0.0482189655,
0.0159724522,
-0.02153299,
-0.0050044577,
0.0079351729,
0.0225163698,
0.093616724,
-0.0311794225,
-0.0088055404,
-0.0393264294,
0.0235685334,
0.0715346038,
0.0485720374,
0.0164599996,
0.0180754513,
0.0401447415,
0.0346158855,
0.0083215013,
-0.0393657461,
-0.0626133978,
0.0511977673,
-0.0014434517,
-0.0867463425,
-0.0026936887,
-0.0242670439,
0.0066038012,
-0.0803087354,
-0.0030336056,
0.1057566106,
0.0540753938,
-0.0742318109,
-0.0092045125,
-0.0570702255,
-0.0011793826,
0.0586835891,
0.064869225,
-0.056349013,
-0.0293048043,
0.0268159565,
0.0022218907,
-0.0304308292,
-0.0168045182,
-0.0294562485,
-0.0885500535,
0.0393637791,
0.0150459073,
0.016960308,
-0.0072851176,
-0.0185438506,
0.0031408865,
0.0148425614,
-0.0043684882,
0.0386598259,
0.008367423,
-0.0057962844,
-0.0289219897,
-0.0051367129,
-0.0104237301,
-0.0148592163,
-0.0185052212,
0.051456511,
0.0784831867,
0.0168729387,
0.0158152599,
-0.004545406,
0.0640511811,
0.0468772016,
0.0232469924,
-0.0251185074,
0.0538365729,
0.0071262675,
0.0020149043,
-0.0209073983,
0.0318973698,
0.0386726484,
-0.0347369462,
-0.0514337793,
0.0921228603,
-0.0251760706,
0.0434207544,
-0.0156903137,
-0.0351211689,
-0.0052028457,
0.0050179046,
0.0588572957,
-0.0305937957,
-0.0190831218,
-0.0353702977,
-0.0472680815,
0.0000111046,
-0.0344993547,
-0.0118862446,
0.0037009872,
0.0091746878,
-0.0278074481,
-0.0317625813,
0.0353174843,
0.0150037548,
0.0371104442,
0.0285739098,
0.0137627777,
-0.0351090729,
-0.0564300455,
-0.0036435393,
-0.0309059303,
0.0003975607,
-0.0667540804,
-0.0086528286,
0.0598258264,
-0.0254712813,
-0.0239276402,
0.0064600883,
-0.0295719244,
-0.0662919357,
0.0196015704,
0.0689692795,
0.0223989394,
0.025803443,
0.0045341584,
-0.0783860907,
0.0435124747,
0.03491522,
-0.0274954084,
0.053757526,
-0.0180925485,
0.0021015566,
-0.0074256943,
0.0302805211,
-0.0372195765,
0.0047486457,
0.035513036,
0.0445816889,
0.0001592313,
-0.0374514721,
0.0136848651,
0.0258431043,
-0.0156034566,
0.0437743254,
-0.0017561408,
-0.056764964,
0.0755154118,
0.0066632731,
0.0011388203,
-0.0159812141,
0.0229418837,
0.0108426223,
-0.0429628044,
-0.0422026552,
0.0290726759,
-0.010620893,
-0.0184121225,
0.011858141,
-0.015258682,
0.0021755716,
0.0240989551,
0.0177266169,
0.0109304991,
-0.0359047614,
0.0142551353,
-0.0035196336,
0.0312474724,
-0.030458821,
0.0257314742,
-0.0097639244,
-0.0313034616,
-0.1024092138,
0.0645651296,
-0.0623344742,
-0.0629307926,
-0.0393222421,
0.0128794359,
0.0563279055,
0.0332231596,
0.0506494641,
-0.0061960784,
-0.0369188935,
0.0141358664,
0.0026037199,
0.0437053479,
-0.0439621098,
0.0249857195,
0.0027468917,
0.0056215217,
-0.0071599199,
0.0370229557,
0.0214419533,
0.101737909,
-0.0176599342,
-0.005434569,
-0.040807277,
-0.0076646125,
-0.0004176554,
-0.014585563,
-0.0367962755,
-0.0206143949,
-0.0362554789,
-0.0455797091,
0.0597412102,
0.0109248692,
-0.0174188968,
-0.0236159395,
-0.0133509599,
0.0028025026,
0.0230530575,
-0.0149829006,
-0.0230843481,
-0.0076856548,
0.0289290044,
-0.0243942533,
-0.018667426,
-6.118897355e-33,
-0.0269112773,
-0.0065854425,
0.0567366928,
-0.0159764849,
-0.0107347006,
-0.0332000218,
-0.0334315263,
-0.0107402159,
0.0264202021,
-0.0203818157,
-0.0385125279,
0.0399895273,
0.0014943294,
0.0082907565,
0.0222905874,
0.0133619476,
0.061020188,
0.0059983763,
-0.0052544805,
-0.003632697,
0.0104720406,
0.0548903234,
0.0675539449,
-0.0226176083,
-0.0092858383,
0.0617070049,
0.0081780879,
0.0108221006,
-0.0584743619,
0.0563191846,
-0.0326680019,
-0.0064461171,
0.0137002571,
-0.0479284078,
-0.0256081913,
-0.0335633904,
-0.0313177034,
-0.0114870556,
-0.0088841664,
0.0402240269,
0.0043540583,
-0.0690215826,
0.051664222,
0.0316784941,
0.0031779471,
0.0053133736,
0.0101055056,
-0.0546215847,
-0.0207483992,
0.0152691128,
-0.0754603222,
0.0290451627,
0.0189313535,
-0.000782727,
0.0295267813,
-0.0258626416,
-0.0080945585,
-0.0125966286,
-0.1168416515,
-0.015109228,
0.0252993722,
0.0569874346,
0.0324087702,
0.0025501549,
0.0083981249,
0.0559499897,
0.0656862035,
-0.018742336,
0.004910429,
0.0259427261,
0.0159823541,
0.0467902534,
0.0403009839,
0.0149002327,
0.0451089777,
0.0133419139,
-0.0588318221,
-0.0146217039,
-0.0333314352,
0.0677303001,
0.0132357841,
0.0346722193,
0.0188836809,
0.0192871951,
-0.0354966111,
-0.0328738093,
-0.0717931166,
-0.0237046555,
0.0285666734,
0.0141766062,
-0.0213775225,
-0.0165119264,
0.011638768,
0.0058265924,
0.0047740415,
0.0318945386,
-0.0113179656,
0.0633276403,
0.0084901843,
-0.0081694014,
-0.0050863498,
-0.0178179741,
-0.0093536684,
-0.009416461,
0.0120960921,
-0.0214906037,
0.0196070187,
0.0648506209,
-0.0908638164,
0.0333038121,
-0.0236494932,
0.0228404552,
0.0468906313,
0.051312007,
-0.0032822429,
-0.039374847,
0.0018579351,
0.0203900672,
0.0296440516,
0.0133903157,
-0.0036424473,
-0.0011190622,
0.0255505722,
0.0473447368,
-0.0162813757,
0.0144565087,
-0.0423889421,
0.035535235,
-0.0030691109,
-0.0635225326,
0.0109556206,
0.0351137593,
2.923e-7,
0.0164020769,
0.0576053262,
0.0229150224,
0.0043300209,
0.0419485681,
0.0054654279,
-0.0020885374,
0.0044461638,
0.0302861854,
0.018439142,
-0.0079155704,
0.0140046934,
0.025836587,
0.0231380556,
-0.0533687845,
-0.0079399785,
-0.0305566452,
0.0637326986,
-0.0491884835,
-0.0476012863,
0.0042202943,
0.0865028054,
0.0107820099,
-0.0159558188,
-0.0048487764,
-0.0486077555,
0.0584275313,
0.0409083255,
0.0135118449,
0.0197533071,
0.0460516848,
0.0416935086,
-0.0123070488,
-0.0233728662,
-0.0099600116,
0.0325934105,
-0.0379090942,
0.060084369,
-0.0522839539,
-0.0102801183,
0.0267882142,
-0.0201892033,
-0.0208583102,
-0.0008647272,
0.0550344326,
-0.0235206075,
-0.0191323198,
-0.0283027031,
-0.0003003391,
-0.0186959319,
0.0444958322,
-0.0802336857,
-0.001283742,
0.0238561779,
0.0002793013,
-0.0116519472,
-0.0253307018,
-0.0547710247,
-0.02452535,
-0.0262354426,
-0.0193106327,
-0.011621316,
-0.0757740512,
0.0046719857,
0.0423329063,
-0.0551342256,
0.0056022005,
2.867143909e-34,
0.0270469096,
0.0169935767,
0.015821686,
0.0842874423,
0.0457015708,
0.0013395963,
0.0234701205,
0.0005959657,
-0.0123333074,
-0.1184032336,
-0.0452320054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11792v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11792v1 | COOPER: Coordinating Specialized Agents towards a Complex Dialogue Goal | 2023-12-19T02:07:42 | 2023-12-19T02:07:42 | Yi Cheng, Wenge Liu, Jian Wang, Chak Tou Leong, Yi Ouyang, Wenjie Li, Xian Wu, Yefeng Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, there has been a growing interest in exploring dialogues
with more complex goals, such as negotiation, persuasion, and emotional
support, which go beyond traditional service-focused dialogue systems. Apart
from the requirement for much more sophisticated strategic reasoning and
communication skills, a significant challenge of these tasks lies in the
difficulty of objectively measuring the achievement of their goals in a
quantifiable way, making it difficult for existing research to directly
optimize the dialogue procedure towards them. In our work, we emphasize the
multifaceted nature of complex dialogue goals and argue that it is more
feasible to accomplish them by comprehensively considering and jointly
promoting their different aspects. To this end, we propose a novel dialogue
framework, Cooper, which coordinates multiple specialized agents, each
dedicated to a specific dialogue goal aspect separately, to approach the
complex objective. Through this divide-and-conquer manner, we make complex
dialogue goals more approachable and elicit greater intelligence via the
collaboration of individual agents. Experiments on persuasion and emotional
support dialogues demonstrate the superiority of our method over a set of
competitive baselines. | [
0.0881866366,
0.0511727594,
-0.0315508321,
0.0074589076,
-0.039400667,
-0.006574532,
0.0437363051,
-0.0358348079,
-0.0000237881,
-0.0123181287,
-0.0168876965,
-0.0217451546,
-0.0041651614,
0.0334085375,
-0.0020558171,
-0.0877724439,
0.0284400564,
-0.0004229636,
0.1195346415,
-0.0177060533,
0.0348834097,
-0.0014387141,
-0.04730184,
0.0387198552,
-0.0612417795,
-0.0011184984,
-0.0428852886,
0.0091905249,
0.0342874713,
-0.0112849642,
0.0158573091,
0.0310309604,
0.0273728352,
0.0073568425,
0.000001998,
-0.053464748,
-0.0148904277,
-0.039414417,
-0.0427804217,
-0.059055075,
0.0632400215,
0.0114994738,
-0.0051886998,
0.0315447114,
-0.049304273,
0.0300689377,
0.0164723061,
0.0699948967,
0.0695686042,
0.0755341426,
-0.0025442892,
0.0109478552,
-0.0197625738,
-0.0259914119,
-0.0779534504,
-0.0644534752,
-0.0215069503,
0.0026278286,
-0.0081468699,
0.0020614429,
0.0302948877,
-0.0032914183,
0.0002938422,
-0.0602407753,
-0.0263370778,
0.0052536693,
-0.055384893,
-0.0410965793,
-0.0371815115,
0.047601819,
0.037321195,
0.0507682078,
-0.011493627,
0.0118744718,
0.0533158183,
0.0026024885,
-0.0503123067,
0.0098006446,
-0.000625816,
-0.0163934808,
-0.0083159655,
0.0244903918,
-0.0178558901,
0.0015299456,
-0.0356436744,
0.0435191579,
-0.0357205011,
-0.0043412359,
0.0333217233,
0.0060179876,
0.0063909185,
-0.0839441121,
-0.0162876695,
0.0332265571,
-0.1333418041,
0.0274426583,
0.0102571277,
0.0332226232,
-0.0051311119,
-0.0262029395,
0.040381223,
0.0305914022,
0.0351673216,
0.0286281332,
0.0313820615,
0.0240123048,
0.0059821038,
0.0203225948,
-0.0014128411,
0.0030175101,
-0.0355433449,
-0.018438708,
-0.0553132631,
0.0409805141,
-0.0496357381,
-0.0505671166,
-0.0143736834,
0.032905329,
-0.0701149553,
0.0489330851,
-0.0436763316,
0.046170149,
-0.0233216695,
0.0099763935,
-0.0369821899,
0.0373287722,
-0.0580893643,
0.0253463052,
0.0548004508,
-0.018533824,
-0.0070611835,
0.0322043337,
0.0074014333,
0.0094337519,
-0.0020547118,
0.0568929873,
-0.0507569499,
0.0047387886,
0.0259690378,
-0.03484473,
0.0091056209,
-0.0655726343,
-0.0208526738,
-0.0120242136,
0.0488469154,
-0.0214216672,
-0.0211394392,
-0.0339691862,
0.0328888185,
-0.0288903192,
0.0096950103,
0.0520758592,
0.0154066421,
0.0055707153,
0.0454514809,
0.0486104861,
-0.0519294776,
0.0425827019,
0.0268479306,
0.0396077968,
0.053737402,
0.0256816242,
0.0470962711,
0.0105233463,
-0.0104225939,
0.0110660866,
0.0692006126,
0.0051122201,
-0.0443068147,
0.0547238216,
-0.0248482507,
0.0403725877,
-0.0360531136,
-0.0290391501,
0.0762965456,
0.06881845,
0.0033524749,
-0.0025801591,
-0.0202445649,
0.0483498387,
0.0049286494,
-0.0126742991,
-0.021765843,
0.044707641,
0.0090898052,
-0.0222741552,
0.0133356536,
-0.012622186,
-0.0367305949,
-0.0566388257,
0.0231095254,
0.014415347,
0.0558332764,
0.063546963,
-0.0030983777,
-0.0187518019,
-0.0383954644,
-0.0219024811,
-0.0198961105,
-0.037445657,
-0.0268650614,
-0.0463472344,
-0.0045565912,
0.0426530801,
0.0437549651,
-0.0073274896,
-0.0644108579,
-0.0226276089,
0.0008045172,
0.0557806343,
0.0861070231,
-0.0322063267,
0.0141214812,
-0.0406249166,
-0.0356293581,
-0.0220437031,
-0.0089415824,
0.0310772248,
-0.0036352836,
-0.0128418282,
-0.0329023562,
0.0646173954,
0.032169953,
-0.0135880737,
0.0431735888,
0.029571142,
-0.0188618433,
0.020750178,
0.0567408428,
0.0330039635,
-0.0329752266,
-0.0009753363,
0.0122174555,
0.0098383967,
-0.0396602489,
0.0543611608,
-0.018976165,
0.0039868662,
0.0240106937,
-0.005216429,
-0.015428436,
0.0021590393,
0.0056991749,
-0.0206670109,
0.0775505081,
-0.041710306,
0.00483377,
-0.0004339788,
0.0259154104,
-0.0000228528,
-0.0120256674,
0.0053266459,
0.0129154595,
0.0368095972,
-0.0513340011,
0.0229007844,
-0.0242917892,
0.0133279739,
-0.06235715,
0.0455801189,
0.0279689282,
0.0270604324,
-0.0056307721,
0.047930833,
-0.0110102827,
-0.0514681414,
-0.0557079688,
-0.128592819,
-0.0252674613,
-0.0119111054,
-0.0087175556,
-0.0238309018,
-0.0053376029,
0.0112367067,
0.0188314859,
-0.0569920689,
0.0259389132,
0.0453981832,
-0.0119070476,
0.0350808948,
0.032566946,
-0.0431899875,
-0.032920938,
0.0330133736,
-0.0113926539,
-0.0074830195,
0.0207100287,
-0.0144721121,
-0.0171703678,
-0.0321070291,
-0.0784387738,
0.0306895301,
-0.03278023,
-0.0515473187,
0.0705177486,
0.008611409,
-0.0020734221,
0.0751181245,
0.0607452393,
0.0588802397,
-0.0279490873,
-0.0413434878,
-0.0687248334,
0.0535232872,
-0.0228345376,
0.0336212516,
-0.0870694593,
-0.0044404878,
0.0273381639,
0.0057620215,
0.0021754208,
0.0279443096,
-0.0205071401,
0.0411482304,
0.0522572249,
-0.0424484611,
0.0032190583,
-0.0361244641,
-0.0061147432,
0.0643519536,
-0.02572947,
-0.0052363798,
0.0627410784,
0.0154245058,
-0.0269669127,
-0.0283096656,
-0.0148219699,
-0.0379665121,
0.0768743828,
-0.0781605765,
0.0020642949,
-0.0104418285,
-0.0166130215,
-0.0331896693,
-0.0571513176,
0.0281829406,
-0.0500565469,
0.0448816977,
-0.0666778535,
-0.0116670588,
0.0298649203,
-0.0357980207,
-0.0411234014,
-0.0082952483,
-0.0284905136,
0.0214617793,
0.0403661616,
-0.0412279405,
-0.0719162747,
-0.0251771752,
0.0360370874,
0.0067548333,
0.0292831771,
-0.0171065703,
-0.0087928269,
-0.0369625762,
0.0163301155,
0.0863754749,
0.0365417078,
-0.0489883646,
0.0769157708,
0.0567717776,
0.0103137493,
-0.0321340561,
0.0047582574,
-0.0258766282,
0.0048600249,
0.007072214,
0.0240093544,
-0.0235639438,
0.0466513559,
-0.0195647776,
0.0247800741,
0.0668455288,
0.0374247357,
-0.0137324408,
-0.0041337074,
-0.0459394045,
0.0111828716,
0.0028042819,
-0.0012391387,
-0.030995151,
0.0067055733,
0.0111862738,
0.0108722579,
-0.0397778675,
-0.0347419269,
-0.0308256857,
-0.0593765974,
0.0456359796,
0.0052860188,
0.027004648,
0.0298831705,
0.0156016573,
0.0375022218,
0.0103595369,
0.000315505,
-0.0159079935,
0.0701038986,
-0.0394287556,
-0.0243777782,
0.0103213442,
0.0219694264,
-0.0013434514,
-0.0370982736,
0.0602252558,
0.0645935982,
0.0631711558,
0.0260937531,
0.0043558734,
0.0331082009,
0.0716341361,
0.0082645947,
0.005693404,
0.0264774505,
-0.0239984002,
0.0085058855,
-0.0041300491,
0.0245239269,
-0.0046628774,
-0.0126014119,
0.046022553,
-0.0178439207,
-0.0575590692,
-0.0204155315,
0.0075940075,
0.0506588817,
0.029882472,
0.0574309938,
-0.0005844913,
-0.0414454751,
-0.0176335406,
-0.0195163433,
-0.0299251322,
-0.0298870839,
-0.0295994263,
-0.0147744585,
0.0257887989,
0.0311168544,
-0.037766099,
-0.0883489475,
0.047179509,
0.037246339,
-0.0138223693,
-0.0327064097,
-0.0028708528,
0.0285155643,
0.0377053805,
-0.0021017892,
-0.0017276744,
0.0171361566,
-0.0405274592,
-0.0305460449,
-0.039959155,
-0.0522565991,
0.0123484349,
-0.0086322669,
0.0087413872,
-0.0355136245,
-0.0303071495,
0.0464258529,
0.0263140965,
0.0104492391,
0.0147268744,
-0.0143925492,
-0.0054521253,
-0.0080120685,
-0.00688875,
-0.0050097685,
0.048251573,
0.0430656299,
-0.0156768765,
0.0303311832,
-0.0021599866,
0.0387880206,
0.0068560713,
0.0291256346,
-0.0380285867,
-0.0524469055,
0.0157594997,
-0.0171011481,
-0.0285545047,
0.0229137763,
-0.033506643,
-0.0090907933,
0.0144207021,
-0.0339339823,
-0.0406311676,
-0.0417026468,
-0.0286668483,
-0.0488043725,
-0.0077495063,
0.0438969731,
-0.0003583333,
-0.0199254509,
-0.0189976655,
0.0080878399,
0.0031688297,
-0.013525391,
-0.0076305801,
-0.0217528753,
0.0041202116,
0.0135146864,
0.0389474854,
-0.0124992244,
0.0404754318,
0.0240427442,
0.076061219,
0.03046293,
-0.0667691454,
-0.0005849065,
0.0187434535,
-0.0662401617,
-0.0858694613,
0.0658165812,
0.0466229133,
0.0127222147,
0.0683192238,
0.0008802243,
-0.0604084693,
0.0114888065,
0.0098126186,
0.0002270457,
0.0301023684,
-0.0317778364,
0.0172343981,
0.0262685306,
-0.0122323921,
-0.0099479724,
-0.029443102,
-0.1004129946,
-0.0023418625,
-0.0420582965,
-0.0146815712,
-0.0615412332,
-0.051272545,
-0.0030470944,
0.0229780078,
0.0140564842,
0.0133318696,
-0.0561923869,
0.0184202734,
0.0175637137,
0.021134926,
-0.0060238456,
-0.0257098787,
0.0142417736,
0.0390471444,
-0.0327663422,
-0.0126280691,
-0.0306325275,
-0.0132358558,
-0.0416892618,
-0.0087637426,
-0.0056134402,
-5.516924494e-33,
-0.0063547981,
-0.0346065871,
0.0294911209,
0.0121409986,
-0.0319051147,
-0.0222005304,
-0.0332382396,
0.0295533817,
-0.0303955842,
0.0445468612,
-0.0209093727,
0.0271928385,
0.0056452453,
-0.050531216,
-0.0200305786,
0.0193207785,
0.0336070098,
-0.0015174377,
-0.0457980819,
0.0146760466,
0.00412498,
-0.0261183269,
-0.0233989246,
-0.1100858226,
0.0326869301,
0.038378004,
-0.0254070573,
0.0516576059,
0.0011700243,
0.0302477572,
0.0396015607,
0.0211701058,
0.0037618971,
-0.0436524339,
0.0135170491,
0.0505078211,
-0.0088772057,
-0.0185424816,
0.0183617435,
-0.0258990135,
-0.0511302538,
-0.0128948595,
-0.0466695651,
0.0038694371,
-0.0104529541,
-0.03133028,
-0.019451458,
0.0092073446,
0.0305743441,
0.0240825191,
-0.0503751785,
-0.0046808645,
-0.040067926,
-0.039097745,
0.003232206,
0.0307889637,
0.0105644036,
-0.0305702761,
-0.008973862,
0.0449999794,
-0.0320493467,
-0.0226620641,
-0.0063461997,
0.0016408348,
-0.0118757216,
0.0624010339,
0.0425273664,
0.0480546951,
-0.0211165268,
-0.0444089994,
-0.0349941365,
0.0585557818,
0.0612463467,
0.0641722083,
-0.05967943,
-0.0096914442,
-0.0143685639,
0.0190017894,
0.0675686374,
0.022256108,
-0.000793274,
0.0275337603,
-0.0223097503,
0.0000206387,
-0.0334019475,
0.0124206534,
-0.0197300781,
-0.0470615216,
0.0213097967,
0.0549777299,
-0.0037547892,
0.0124080023,
0.0100149112,
-0.0184023678,
0.0085782744,
0.027360186,
0.0008334019,
0.050424207,
-0.0272591487,
-0.0490248539,
-0.0166897736,
-0.00488345,
0.0281302612,
0.0104599437,
0.019066155,
0.0068372646,
-0.0001571855,
-0.0190424491,
-0.0004120723,
-0.0050274371,
-0.0177775435,
0.0858182609,
-0.0283805188,
-0.0258889105,
-0.0164676383,
0.0154840145,
-0.0173589308,
0.0147361411,
-0.0131012257,
-0.0350668468,
-0.0445993766,
0.0275748651,
-0.0063327937,
0.0059490521,
-0.0436298437,
0.0162456464,
-0.0208949167,
-0.0356282331,
-0.0300884265,
0.0044575701,
-0.0219201669,
-0.0306931008,
2.654e-7,
-0.0648164898,
0.0302757062,
0.0217204057,
0.0521607511,
0.0094116433,
0.0431275964,
-0.0070419172,
0.0180272851,
0.0209386945,
-0.0470529534,
0.0346885808,
0.0524299555,
0.057799641,
0.0210104231,
-0.0724357367,
-0.0656536445,
0.0095350966,
-0.045543883,
-0.0200975295,
0.0064127608,
0.0906284451,
0.0096752988,
0.0285151172,
0.0104979808,
0.0054254974,
-0.0070606251,
0.0327086225,
-0.0536789037,
-0.0066664401,
0.047010757,
-0.015341687,
-0.065506056,
-0.0047941483,
0.0313142054,
0.0271951128,
0.0386472456,
-0.0609130785,
0.0551437475,
-0.01528004,
-0.0894179791,
-0.0148797091,
0.0287954081,
0.0100936424,
0.0083482312,
-0.0154895475,
-0.0614361316,
-0.0272897575,
-0.0222405568,
0.00277581,
-0.0191107057,
-0.0083453022,
-0.0136513077,
-0.0285074823,
0.008496739,
0.0063673076,
0.0311145056,
0.0478647053,
-0.0549953245,
0.025188053,
0.0037232535,
-0.0412964448,
-0.071746178,
-0.0025832884,
0.012474617,
-0.0470581986,
-0.0051509235,
-0.0124378679,
1.777336438e-34,
0.0264956299,
0.0034922969,
0.0088749826,
0.0588049404,
0.0739715323,
0.0159545187,
-0.0447168909,
-0.0299370997,
0.0706987604,
-0.0376023389,
-0.0075145541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11785v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11785v1 | Zero-Shot Fact-Checking with Semantic Triples and Knowledge Graphs | 2023-12-19T01:48:31 | 2023-12-19T01:48:31 | Zhangdie Yuan, Andreas Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite progress in automated fact-checking, most systems require a
significant amount of labeled training data, which is expensive. In this paper,
we propose a novel zero-shot method, which instead of operating directly on the
claim and evidence sentences, decomposes them into semantic triples augmented
using external knowledge graphs, and uses large language models trained for
natural language inference. This allows it to generalize to adversarial
datasets and domains that supervised models require specific training data for.
Our empirical results show that our approach outperforms previous zero-shot
approaches on FEVER, FEVER-Symmetric, FEVER 2.0, and Climate-FEVER, while being
comparable or better than supervised models on the adversarial and the
out-of-domain datasets. | [
0.0100356909,
0.0351233333,
0.0421184003,
0.0411527418,
-0.0423796028,
0.0057214685,
0.0011591575,
-0.0115034943,
0.0444234274,
-0.0779975355,
-0.0036679998,
0.0271758158,
0.0143270446,
0.0130065549,
0.028345475,
-0.015491588,
0.0525430962,
0.0172803625,
0.0608576871,
0.0004403178,
0.0005957585,
0.0229367055,
-0.0287401918,
-0.0039482322,
-0.0163425822,
-0.001351199,
0.0104030147,
-0.0125204856,
0.0399652943,
-0.0517396219,
-0.0045696078,
-0.0038952588,
0.0311698448,
0.0819463432,
0.0000016014,
-0.0360783488,
0.0080757113,
0.0273262318,
-0.0242857225,
0.0155638652,
0.01488782,
-0.0423193425,
0.0234393347,
0.0181105863,
-0.0346427709,
-0.0788954571,
0.0358401649,
0.0642775819,
0.0604951195,
0.1035267338,
-0.0146172429,
-0.0141406739,
0.0094573349,
-0.002292037,
0.0044781379,
-0.0187130868,
0.0781685486,
0.0080142487,
-0.0113252718,
-0.0105273351,
0.0074281674,
0.0357590131,
0.0004641459,
0.0214486942,
-0.0540782064,
0.0585525893,
-0.0437941924,
0.0115205972,
0.0000349957,
0.0546027683,
-0.0262952559,
-0.0358810872,
-0.0114226043,
-0.0036450897,
0.0068249796,
0.0006152093,
-0.0081001557,
-0.0012747775,
-0.0329838283,
0.0075983913,
0.0153245907,
-0.0191220548,
0.0753635988,
0.0240927823,
-0.0132731171,
0.0987319201,
-0.0139013492,
-0.0383604914,
0.0119566889,
-0.0262123365,
-0.0067905337,
-0.0485320985,
-0.0070861648,
0.0027863863,
0.0029176557,
0.0129267257,
-0.0491270199,
-0.0192740448,
0.0336572081,
-0.0534998067,
-0.0161953177,
-0.0210691784,
0.0064921868,
0.0688197613,
-0.0262446571,
-0.0366840139,
0.0028078011,
0.0250437297,
0.0198122561,
-0.0479236469,
-0.0216439292,
0.0243285038,
-0.0108568855,
0.0141857024,
0.0156113878,
0.0369516388,
-0.0659556612,
-0.027608078,
-0.0119530596,
0.0333501101,
-0.0020540378,
0.0129168769,
-0.0064516398,
-0.0174745433,
-0.0127992639,
0.0372464471,
-0.0210619997,
0.0319091007,
-0.0068046269,
-0.0353099145,
-0.0182051286,
0.0060998704,
0.024537513,
0.0004563952,
0.0317281112,
0.0406898521,
0.0396743715,
-0.0042931796,
-0.0388492793,
-0.0357141495,
-0.0400676392,
-0.0525943786,
0.0014077122,
-0.0609326586,
-0.0010321853,
-0.0055214497,
-0.0081488146,
-0.0245437436,
-0.0129075274,
-0.0001314477,
-0.0702542216,
0.0794250518,
-0.034830261,
-0.024080459,
0.0047702948,
0.0039484152,
0.0078956671,
0.0525500663,
0.0195439178,
0.0170300324,
0.0392158516,
0.0517136641,
0.0093168374,
0.0069526657,
0.0870225877,
0.039632462,
0.015511415,
-0.0016568635,
-0.0030359263,
0.0154398615,
-0.0241620503,
0.0184624903,
-0.02778681,
-0.0529387183,
0.0413403586,
-0.019616317,
-0.0352037437,
-0.0660261139,
0.0623570532,
-0.023319291,
0.0119514372,
0.0061399951,
-0.0448542275,
-0.0004563104,
-0.0473627113,
-0.0087035894,
0.0148984622,
0.0218356978,
-0.0207324326,
-0.0417584702,
-0.0396106876,
-0.0047875941,
-0.0196546149,
-0.0106326733,
0.0261352584,
0.011476527,
-0.032625515,
-0.0111923879,
0.0666081682,
-0.0263041798,
-0.0359214358,
-0.0451083258,
-0.0071833865,
0.0298139248,
0.0361458883,
-0.0106805088,
-0.0078339819,
-0.013007178,
0.014837251,
0.0049016881,
0.0393373519,
-0.0120796347,
0.0295691192,
-0.0210343078,
-0.001076433,
-0.0574633703,
0.0529563017,
0.0086347694,
0.0403791294,
0.0261379518,
0.0046279687,
-0.0248291139,
0.0141600948,
0.0180954505,
-0.0395029113,
-0.0228669886,
0.0146067804,
0.0174208954,
0.0272608362,
-0.0021716831,
-0.0125219282,
0.0129743898,
0.0332819298,
-0.0331175402,
-0.0482917503,
0.0241407286,
0.0373963527,
-0.0708606914,
0.0203584339,
-0.0183631536,
-0.0482817963,
0.0127983689,
-0.0571529306,
0.017034838,
0.0083710216,
0.0082677528,
0.0308718551,
-0.0036883273,
-0.0308832098,
0.0133017423,
0.0085607702,
0.0212735403,
0.0544964671,
-0.0272940211,
-0.0032863645,
-0.0360654294,
-0.0496362783,
0.0095607918,
-0.0160798263,
-0.0084108599,
-0.0055741523,
0.0203250907,
0.0006430656,
-0.0182548389,
-0.0559895709,
-0.0057436214,
0.0398669876,
-0.0769927502,
0.0249543563,
0.0123471506,
0.0135482587,
0.0143660028,
0.00056491,
0.0050925245,
0.0136249578,
-0.0291225016,
-0.0001533884,
0.0122282654,
0.0039144028,
0.037424475,
-0.0267032776,
0.0029355593,
-0.0054684333,
0.0039993469,
-0.0428851955,
0.0619820356,
0.032809332,
-0.0201746188,
0.0455909781,
-0.001397464,
-0.0695763528,
0.0487597696,
-0.0171663407,
-0.0140919732,
-0.0031490703,
-0.0004364592,
-0.0435791165,
0.0673609599,
-0.0268695634,
0.0022712993,
0.061191421,
0.0163884163,
-0.0002855714,
0.0044577206,
-0.0360619314,
0.015914632,
0.0161744915,
-0.0030518426,
0.0046091746,
0.0465496294,
0.0594557114,
-0.0238281991,
-0.003143745,
0.0618559755,
-0.012597125,
-0.0280093215,
-0.002128042,
0.012886283,
0.0104587572,
0.0101625295,
-0.0420391038,
-0.0309000686,
0.0957603604,
-0.017118711,
0.0586006157,
-0.0357458405,
-0.0246774703,
-0.0101144817,
0.0130602149,
-0.0212500729,
0.0280701686,
0.0113506671,
0.0491819419,
0.0039829132,
-0.0735973343,
0.0637331605,
-0.0099048959,
0.0004738276,
-0.0150009971,
0.0367373005,
0.0388266221,
-0.0407989323,
-0.0364398435,
-0.0453449376,
-0.0597253069,
0.0135984989,
-0.0579311959,
-0.0197106283,
-0.093372725,
-0.0142259616,
0.0414180793,
0.0371095613,
0.0162932705,
-0.011784506,
0.0187801905,
0.0057358486,
0.0162006877,
-0.0226327553,
0.0122449556,
-0.0063542211,
-0.0173656009,
0.0713226572,
-0.018075591,
0.0575265884,
-0.0305158366,
-0.0253433213,
-0.0513146631,
-0.0179948695,
0.0308423713,
-0.0268114489,
-0.0191573594,
-0.0586628243,
0.0317467228,
0.078153424,
-0.0005297666,
0.0278328396,
0.0121038957,
0.0162890945,
-0.0328797437,
0.0075428383,
-0.012295994,
-0.1258211881,
-0.0411742032,
-0.0200035032,
-0.0171958171,
-0.0328079611,
-0.0485812947,
-0.0232393406,
-0.0920436904,
0.0099780411,
-0.0006661129,
-0.0157094579,
-0.0536706857,
-0.0735737085,
0.0350569822,
-0.0109342989,
-0.0551852174,
-0.031099828,
0.0303266924,
-0.0032810462,
-0.0345018543,
0.0248162802,
-0.0517308488,
0.0659411773,
-0.0389212146,
0.0142323095,
0.0198571943,
0.0393273942,
-0.0021425488,
-0.0233514998,
-0.0025712901,
0.023544021,
-0.0525101796,
0.0013748128,
0.0652734935,
-0.0341409221,
0.0061092786,
-0.0302018169,
0.0262528062,
-0.0021888565,
-0.0060649654,
0.0274075493,
0.0708162934,
0.0138601921,
-0.065847531,
-0.0232925341,
0.0178392548,
0.0284559205,
0.083555989,
0.0041453517,
0.0317203812,
-0.0053545441,
-0.0345344059,
-0.0439942628,
-0.0467826203,
-0.0487065725,
0.0771225691,
-0.0436956361,
-0.0917666778,
-0.0463710837,
0.0060680355,
0.045261018,
0.03230194,
-0.0454122834,
-0.0185450558,
0.0250206385,
0.0196926836,
-0.0596935749,
-0.0101194428,
-0.0140694212,
0.0459329635,
0.0294257291,
0.0103528788,
0.0373228975,
0.0227709282,
-0.0049925107,
0.0423442088,
-0.0219722316,
-0.0706633404,
-0.0191836059,
0.013776591,
0.0149344094,
0.0578665845,
-0.0286078509,
0.0241433512,
0.043850489,
0.1031264663,
-0.0383892134,
0.0260446463,
0.0220835563,
-0.0278028958,
0.045542527,
0.0305806734,
-0.0299040675,
0.0243520886,
0.0128343496,
-0.0007549151,
-0.0471868068,
0.0087811556,
0.0374896675,
0.0417501666,
0.0643761382,
0.0007112179,
-0.0356420465,
-0.0224656556,
-0.0189279746,
-0.0344636627,
-0.0294528641,
-0.0006102271,
0.0338020995,
-0.0133061148,
-0.0061582155,
-0.0334455743,
0.0045349319,
-0.0375658423,
0.0129706515,
-0.022251403,
-0.0183442868,
0.0389418416,
0.0298853889,
0.0352817997,
-0.0545088984,
-0.0302228928,
0.0367969573,
-0.017101625,
-0.0290092751,
-0.019623002,
-0.0137238707,
0.0502960533,
0.0205915738,
-0.0332623199,
-0.0284102652,
-0.0542615987,
0.0244314,
-0.0190062728,
0.0157451164,
0.0410972051,
0.0189727973,
0.0167089645,
-0.0110633317,
-0.0434247218,
0.0053257425,
0.0265783425,
-0.0336948447,
-0.0014680973,
0.0375583321,
0.0142541202,
-0.0423750766,
0.0159539655,
0.040163476,
0.0418115929,
0.1143364981,
0.046485465,
-0.0660318658,
-0.028967699,
-0.0453424118,
-0.0207364094,
0.007595202,
0.0122498982,
0.0063662394,
-0.0965420157,
-0.0780533403,
-0.007206385,
0.0331565849,
-0.0113781141,
0.04399167,
0.0089956224,
0.0584908724,
0.0510957018,
-0.0245335735,
-0.0169958752,
0.0561373532,
-0.0262514167,
-0.0725937411,
0.0150291119,
-5.968477792e-33,
0.0123304566,
-0.0495796427,
0.0076899785,
-0.0045419247,
-0.0021371555,
0.0462200493,
-0.0044445521,
-0.0285311826,
-0.0636654124,
0.0696432739,
0.0441247001,
0.0258675776,
-0.0072074174,
-0.0200951416,
-0.0365057327,
-0.0271802731,
0.0493101515,
-0.0199327171,
-0.0363633633,
-0.0022141999,
0.0920412615,
-0.0115651097,
0.0808782578,
-0.0770227835,
0.0175177604,
-0.0105832582,
-0.0205413345,
0.0333322808,
-0.0256799404,
0.0386346467,
0.0284984838,
0.0379874557,
0.030064797,
-0.0081115523,
0.0334238112,
-0.0350218825,
-0.0925870985,
-0.0085456381,
0.0372512266,
-0.0464353636,
-0.0443216078,
-0.0015538761,
0.0425367616,
0.0182476155,
0.0366121233,
-0.031147344,
0.0090811253,
-0.0228275787,
-0.006420787,
-0.0735961795,
-0.0412279405,
0.0523306951,
0.0118499054,
-0.0084022768,
-0.0205236748,
-0.0029218537,
0.0164239481,
0.0304620769,
-0.0554873496,
0.0227118488,
-0.0066732997,
-0.0053114984,
0.0071253763,
-0.0269939695,
-0.016226273,
0.0548703894,
-0.0239054281,
0.0079495329,
-0.0733243898,
0.039405819,
0.0202200674,
0.053360112,
0.0158152655,
0.1069713756,
0.045644708,
-0.0283416752,
-0.1173709333,
0.0107582193,
0.019127883,
0.009954486,
-0.0335458741,
-0.0406694748,
-0.0276642628,
-0.0078705698,
-0.0242792983,
-0.0001939733,
-0.0399562828,
0.0207277499,
-0.0039285007,
0.0031863663,
-0.0031856475,
0.022975998,
-0.0210529193,
-0.0231337436,
0.0107911574,
0.0677820891,
0.0123568103,
-0.0139070991,
-0.0170491729,
0.0263478439,
-0.052093409,
0.0148202367,
-0.0106175346,
0.044426959,
0.0200648326,
0.0074065295,
0.0649251416,
-0.0081071472,
-0.0360628255,
-0.0089861406,
-0.0252800733,
0.013940868,
0.000733826,
0.0041473564,
0.0125780711,
0.0291880947,
0.0111246603,
-0.001881512,
0.0034849942,
-0.0049472898,
0.0193470437,
0.0370591208,
0.0090399813,
0.0249431841,
-0.0276437905,
-0.0297912415,
-0.0250159614,
-0.0363861844,
0.021566283,
-0.1008038595,
0.0124726817,
0.0038711121,
2.529e-7,
0.0513894372,
0.0399366841,
-0.0292696282,
0.0270884,
0.0064116768,
0.0666066855,
0.0057843048,
0.0187454689,
-0.0159679092,
-0.0690759718,
-0.0452954881,
0.0332602039,
-0.0013346546,
0.0645739138,
-0.0841754079,
0.0146056293,
-0.0399799123,
-0.0454182886,
-0.0355938487,
-0.0314401649,
0.0254497882,
0.0614840724,
0.0814242363,
0.0007476834,
0.0218704287,
-0.0320855603,
0.0433523953,
0.0657504052,
-0.0461222492,
0.0182775464,
0.0606424399,
0.0001272652,
0.0151792327,
0.0608524457,
-0.0349087454,
-0.0045807585,
-0.0106376568,
0.0459914505,
0.0044881492,
0.0077309101,
-0.0028241591,
-0.0554874539,
-0.0126527203,
-0.0138482638,
0.0744458437,
-0.0452327877,
-0.045628842,
-0.0435744636,
-0.0021293082,
0.0446228348,
0.025565682,
-0.0028387876,
0.0026723472,
0.0149405589,
-0.022899596,
0.0039883568,
-0.0081450213,
-0.0234017652,
-0.0204644036,
-0.0199191421,
-0.017236555,
-0.06400989,
0.0702540427,
-0.0230329279,
0.0621247552,
-0.0836337209,
0.0307729933,
2.134904141e-34,
0.034035407,
-0.009489472,
-0.0354111306,
-0.0702173039,
0.043558564,
-0.008094674,
0.0205275938,
-0.0376170054,
0.0190987606,
-0.0210153293,
-0.0002390354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11779v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11779v3 | Tokenization Matters: Navigating Data-Scarce Tokenization for Gender Inclusive Language Technologies | 2023-12-19T01:28:46 | 2024-04-06T09:32:53 | Anaelia Ovalle, Ninareh Mehrabi, Palash Goyal, Jwala Dhamala, Kai-Wei Chang, Richard Zemel, Aram Galstyan, Yuval Pinter, Rahul Gupta | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Gender-inclusive NLP research has documented the harmful limitations of
gender binary-centric large language models (LLM), such as the inability to
correctly use gender-diverse English neopronouns (e.g., xe, zir, fae). While
data scarcity is a known culprit, the precise mechanisms through which scarcity
affects this behavior remain underexplored. We discover LLM misgendering is
significantly influenced by Byte-Pair Encoding (BPE) tokenization, the
tokenizer powering many popular LLMs. Unlike binary pronouns, BPE overfragments
neopronouns, a direct consequence of data scarcity during tokenizer training.
This disparate tokenization mirrors tokenizer limitations observed in
multilingual and low-resource NLP, unlocking new misgendering mitigation
strategies. We propose two techniques: (1) pronoun tokenization parity, a
method to enforce consistent tokenization across gendered pronouns, and (2)
utilizing pre-existing LLM pronoun knowledge to improve neopronoun proficiency.
Our proposed methods outperform finetuning with standard BPE, improving
neopronoun accuracy from 14.1% to 58.4%. Our paper is the first to link LLM
misgendering to tokenization and deficient neopronoun grammar, indicating that
LLMs unable to correctly treat neopronouns as pronouns are more prone to
misgender. | [
0.0374959074,
0.0775194913,
-0.0182699542,
0.0150875971,
0.0088206874,
-0.0025080582,
0.0308689978,
-0.0340036415,
-0.0570354797,
-0.0651683286,
0.0022193501,
-0.0541727357,
0.01807319,
0.0032045406,
0.0522354953,
-0.012793323,
0.0376317911,
0.0134882666,
0.0115594445,
-0.0381086655,
0.0191220343,
0.0319149382,
0.018102441,
0.0696426332,
-0.0469494052,
-0.0277110152,
0.0159885287,
0.018919142,
-0.0557971708,
0.0084787961,
0.0403289199,
0.052271571,
-0.021709023,
-0.0015758625,
0.0000020562,
-0.0814277679,
-0.0102629634,
0.029262336,
-0.0190280825,
0.028249247,
0.0429907516,
-0.0152691463,
-0.0352218077,
0.0375569202,
-0.0115031796,
-0.0300459154,
0.0512222797,
0.0448717922,
0.0408341922,
0.0308692232,
-0.0064329747,
0.0448510312,
0.0013975736,
-0.0054905931,
-0.0496943444,
0.0195416883,
-0.0084852772,
-0.0594800152,
-0.0202431232,
0.0042749434,
-0.0379934274,
0.0194302201,
0.0105279693,
0.0069353674,
0.0061330865,
0.0256383736,
-0.0253277551,
-0.052324906,
-0.0159458071,
0.0210528839,
0.015995685,
-0.0003871045,
0.0227722749,
0.0192926228,
-0.0040425146,
-0.0230495483,
-0.0197249465,
0.0386673585,
0.0079604853,
0.0252080541,
-0.0085971467,
-0.0758543238,
0.0469092615,
0.0349088162,
-0.0340414271,
0.1153594851,
0.0167499073,
-0.050443206,
0.0106158061,
0.0179711953,
-0.0143018235,
-0.0466874205,
0.0167079214,
-0.0358000174,
-0.0373590961,
0.0088330703,
-0.0265853796,
-0.0324257016,
0.0279557928,
-0.0181042738,
0.0035854906,
0.0276928917,
-0.0159194563,
-0.0135261239,
-0.0424891748,
0.020177668,
0.0345417969,
0.0110643441,
-0.0089232884,
-0.0584578849,
-0.0164887402,
-0.0434348993,
-0.0476861671,
0.0306436718,
-0.0217825882,
0.0245345868,
-0.0206958707,
-0.0148925986,
-0.029410556,
0.0148138646,
0.0159153622,
0.0297522303,
-0.0142837716,
0.0098549938,
0.0068743262,
0.0466967896,
-0.0575997308,
0.025161935,
-0.0181821715,
-0.1021410897,
0.0071617472,
-0.0052755605,
-0.0162904635,
-0.0365816019,
-0.0061471225,
0.0267767217,
-0.006953707,
-0.0390769243,
-0.0201619025,
-0.0152316866,
-0.0485705249,
-0.0300842207,
-0.0305805523,
-0.0891670659,
-0.0119603714,
0.0360319614,
0.0200845748,
-0.0442634113,
0.0169582143,
0.0035205761,
-0.0247231741,
0.0708444118,
-0.0105834687,
0.0137317581,
0.0197896641,
-0.0188712217,
-0.0004745779,
0.0936749429,
0.0781648904,
-0.0597463697,
0.0368846133,
-0.0065706717,
-0.0265887287,
0.0587137192,
0.0190618709,
0.0082960948,
-0.0050793085,
-0.0093918936,
0.0275828391,
0.038136363,
0.1191578805,
0.0464407019,
0.0176169723,
-0.0142957028,
0.0473047718,
0.0705921352,
-0.0011570095,
0.0413672179,
0.0180127285,
0.0085339118,
-0.0236543622,
-0.0001093147,
-0.0709462613,
-0.0145471944,
0.0263961945,
-0.0252130944,
0.0287365243,
0.0549918786,
-0.0099969702,
-0.0264283232,
-0.0223740842,
-0.0079358872,
0.0242067818,
-0.0089173224,
0.0043712221,
0.0413590558,
0.0290019158,
0.1061161086,
0.0540471934,
-0.0746583194,
0.0247528926,
-0.0241499841,
-0.0129383728,
0.0389881954,
0.0151762413,
-0.0105615361,
-0.0183348563,
-0.0502650365,
-0.003631121,
0.019764863,
0.0532690361,
0.0233652629,
0.0329514928,
-0.0398839302,
0.0005335193,
0.0053155469,
0.0163634792,
-0.0049443515,
0.0541590899,
0.0526052006,
0.0052252519,
-0.0387932584,
-0.0452164114,
0.023450477,
-0.0024249337,
-0.0276397225,
0.062029995,
0.0083981464,
0.005476193,
0.0396717824,
-0.0214595515,
0.0077371243,
-0.0092256395,
-0.0193753596,
-0.0358226039,
0.0219908748,
-0.0310514942,
-0.0018028765,
0.0543979593,
-0.023583794,
-0.0511533283,
0.0301313046,
-0.0125843044,
-0.0354192406,
0.0577405542,
-0.0298442971,
0.0393808074,
-0.0338892564,
0.0212194454,
0.0110852886,
0.0330959335,
-0.0159781873,
-0.0102206767,
-0.0352999531,
-0.005938435,
-0.0359063111,
0.0030223611,
-0.0016791705,
-0.0562928393,
-0.0615720302,
0.0434591137,
-0.0167348273,
0.0375516787,
0.0326831713,
-0.0170732532,
-0.0204540901,
-0.0384646282,
-0.0651636422,
-0.0090412302,
-0.0085781906,
0.020964412,
-0.0329239592,
0.0311084054,
-0.0290258266,
0.0134373149,
-0.00571104,
-0.0239349809,
0.0042739422,
0.0443201177,
0.0457469374,
-0.0126971854,
0.0151451128,
-0.0209538639,
-0.0038183208,
-0.050751891,
0.0241532382,
-0.0173417497,
0.005495606,
-0.0255465377,
0.0021704771,
-0.0044022673,
-0.0012868487,
0.0145029044,
-0.0244722087,
0.0296965186,
-0.0043527479,
0.0727449805,
0.0559063181,
-0.0072887926,
0.0330577753,
0.0261774156,
-0.014374895,
-0.0647805035,
0.0228281263,
0.0355090611,
-0.049149856,
-0.0207511745,
-0.0511165,
0.0192619655,
0.0336325131,
-0.0112451855,
-0.0356684439,
-0.0310507007,
0.0444340259,
-0.0754818916,
-0.0421519317,
0.0114886062,
-0.0042134859,
-0.0063410043,
-0.0054447455,
-0.0307486486,
-0.0069794888,
0.0497113094,
-0.0260842759,
-0.0421408787,
-0.0230907276,
-0.0026052655,
-0.0346404538,
0.0300215147,
-0.0599299371,
0.0329136103,
0.0324427299,
-0.0669392347,
-0.0547647513,
-0.0378316045,
0.0148239527,
-0.0180063173,
0.0512347408,
-0.0249274261,
0.0241138116,
0.0067081787,
-0.0820482969,
-0.0079743061,
-0.0122458963,
-0.0282365549,
0.007830061,
0.0216377228,
-0.0396973714,
0.0176620111,
0.0258928798,
-0.0077744927,
-0.0023726663,
-0.0286481138,
-0.004894454,
-0.0254491735,
0.0049629044,
0.0171613656,
0.0247756187,
0.0373192541,
-0.0173757263,
-0.0133031933,
0.0549977273,
0.0215770192,
0.0111747561,
-0.0114335306,
0.021677278,
0.0427691862,
-0.0580479167,
-0.0329938717,
-0.0167239252,
0.0817014277,
-0.0760046244,
0.0012726926,
0.1113849208,
0.0218947716,
-0.0294342004,
0.0213112216,
-0.0230869353,
0.0449068397,
0.0188535079,
0.0055351155,
-0.0825695992,
-0.0202762522,
0.0357465968,
0.0147778243,
-0.0228782073,
-0.0483665392,
-0.0215293523,
-0.1646025777,
-0.0018299801,
0.0079566129,
-0.0417397767,
-0.0268539023,
-0.0298984591,
0.0012513048,
-0.0169054698,
0.0772121027,
0.0120016644,
-0.0224628579,
0.0223300681,
0.0169966314,
-0.0396510288,
-0.0086982269,
0.0080156438,
-0.1124999523,
0.0788098946,
0.0583204553,
0.0436493084,
-0.0233784113,
0.0285140593,
0.0332623459,
-0.0112797655,
-0.0002889513,
-0.0345738493,
-0.018029483,
-0.0314726159,
-0.0204235949,
-0.0246570911,
0.0372283906,
0.0391504504,
-0.0051086792,
-0.0073812506,
0.0299492981,
0.0392248929,
-0.020327881,
-0.0199318752,
-0.0151169756,
0.0109617505,
0.0786103308,
0.037010245,
-0.0528714582,
-0.0672521964,
-0.0693797395,
0.0158605408,
0.0067844852,
-0.0099216662,
-0.0083497586,
0.0482891239,
-0.0363013484,
-0.0393307656,
-0.0744296983,
0.0508300997,
-0.0160428546,
0.0067260852,
-0.0376158245,
-0.0019474353,
-0.0091926586,
-0.0341213159,
0.0427153036,
-0.0323350318,
0.0427839421,
-0.0558881164,
-0.0043089064,
-0.006366197,
0.0168474298,
0.0072858767,
0.0260401759,
0.006232636,
-0.0525999591,
0.00733581,
0.0674219877,
0.0171842761,
0.0432971269,
-0.0166067351,
-0.0970423818,
0.028400667,
0.1000150293,
-0.0265325215,
0.0214686338,
0.0607935004,
0.0378104784,
0.0163504612,
0.0552731864,
-0.0213478077,
-0.0281674489,
-0.0167712308,
0.0486770272,
-0.0093257576,
-0.0189239383,
0.0304323565,
0.0238095932,
-0.0081722951,
-0.0607233793,
0.0456757545,
-0.0322652049,
-0.0071073566,
-0.018275125,
-0.02614302,
-0.0148548977,
-0.0043810452,
0.0149531215,
0.0414669029,
0.0015165564,
-0.0274394155,
0.0030989319,
0.0392174497,
0.0068905414,
0.0114782257,
-0.0035844597,
0.0266164187,
0.010487563,
0.0200151261,
0.0166132972,
-0.0073976046,
0.0094606271,
0.0227872059,
-0.0177569184,
-0.0163720567,
0.0044624666,
0.0065753614,
-0.0290813688,
0.0014647248,
-0.0090100477,
-0.023197338,
0.0108639346,
-0.0131729329,
0.0261179376,
-0.0116107119,
0.0779396221,
-0.0243477244,
-0.0211871266,
-0.0162176322,
-0.0143892746,
-0.0070211836,
-0.0051637636,
0.0215722118,
-0.0051375502,
-0.0236104503,
-0.0433237106,
0.0484620221,
0.0450615957,
0.0461133979,
-0.0165599287,
-0.0039703934,
-0.0218611602,
-0.0225574728,
-0.0119535867,
-0.0311513077,
-0.0263121929,
0.0139393201,
-0.0862448066,
-0.0549362488,
0.0088303424,
-0.0289977677,
0.0051189675,
-0.0193516687,
-0.0096473368,
0.0486044921,
-0.0119313831,
-0.0725604668,
-0.0455518961,
-0.0095222099,
0.0636828169,
-0.0183440372,
-0.0178852379,
-6.728331299e-33,
-0.0364452191,
-0.0060767881,
-0.0138517646,
-0.0223081447,
-0.0255000014,
0.0022980534,
-0.0153586436,
-0.0069349646,
0.012234088,
0.013619341,
-0.0303624067,
0.0255438816,
0.019977821,
0.0336693525,
0.0372458696,
-0.0011135405,
0.0805192739,
0.0333637707,
-0.0369675867,
-0.0351236463,
0.0137530481,
0.0429182984,
0.0303032286,
-0.0322123319,
0.0614042208,
0.0136492383,
-0.0364518426,
0.0239585787,
-0.0118381446,
0.0260154586,
0.0194662567,
0.0712261349,
-0.0040029678,
-0.0222337358,
0.0027982686,
0.0775644034,
-0.1154375523,
-0.0160577446,
0.0312492792,
0.0350509398,
0.0528740138,
-0.0567461252,
0.0593370199,
0.0040755142,
-0.057534121,
-0.0037748797,
0.0306900535,
0.0293348487,
0.0435292311,
0.0083489139,
-0.0449135415,
0.0028286381,
-0.0245490652,
0.0167135317,
0.0120260278,
0.0023758509,
-0.0210209955,
-0.0288676023,
-0.0945219174,
0.019866867,
0.0050733057,
0.0222192518,
0.0480933301,
0.022985125,
0.0204572883,
0.022716416,
0.0622600839,
0.0052770474,
-0.013476857,
-0.0004424821,
0.0574524663,
-0.0257833637,
0.00545415,
0.0279331803,
0.008666629,
-0.0239590593,
-0.023682896,
-0.0431881025,
0.0265769251,
0.0296818037,
-0.0015266793,
-0.0111240214,
-0.0577424765,
-0.0821993649,
-0.0476549901,
-0.0652019754,
-0.0195389949,
-0.0271207914,
0.0221318994,
-0.0284636486,
-0.0544191636,
0.0455334708,
-0.0257751681,
-0.0509394296,
-0.094492197,
-0.0108961491,
0.0201295018,
0.0046122731,
0.0167750213,
0.0398097411,
-0.0528143756,
0.0005900486,
-0.0038116658,
-0.0174220912,
0.0273575224,
0.0354182348,
0.0229969602,
0.0156832226,
-0.104168497,
-0.0140394038,
-0.0368627049,
0.0382479727,
-0.0177573431,
0.0070896163,
0.0353858024,
0.0357288718,
-0.0020930313,
0.0000716119,
0.0593639612,
0.0389009789,
-0.0574982502,
-0.0135116782,
-0.0305451453,
0.0104595525,
0.0094546601,
0.00806263,
-0.0314976163,
0.0179386158,
0.0590828098,
-0.0464566164,
-0.0244543348,
-0.0390059464,
2.772e-7,
0.0182510633,
0.0684133917,
0.0361810997,
-0.0119704874,
-0.0013137914,
0.0411926061,
0.0118022766,
0.0372218825,
0.034711767,
0.0134224007,
-0.0603841729,
0.048231788,
0.0254722442,
0.0364751741,
-0.0794094875,
0.0292837992,
-0.0479168557,
0.0285058524,
-0.0578661151,
0.0229973961,
-0.0205153767,
0.0845168903,
0.0523293167,
-0.0109772459,
-0.0263765454,
-0.052022852,
0.0131772505,
0.0055224872,
0.0081145139,
0.0318104699,
0.0209610667,
0.0001865425,
0.0513729006,
0.0082685975,
0.0066238893,
0.0073340558,
-0.0017689491,
0.0264748968,
0.0015742123,
0.0113383131,
-0.0195840206,
-0.028096322,
-0.0385268703,
-0.0393961444,
0.0620893613,
-0.012120747,
-0.027362464,
-0.0319840983,
-0.0126063237,
0.0085641639,
0.0205034632,
-0.0466875806,
-0.0325600952,
0.0466431826,
0.0221562833,
-0.0018949831,
0.0042924583,
-0.0610597283,
-0.045685038,
0.007393857,
0.0100873122,
-0.0587250292,
0.0090942755,
0.0484541468,
0.0093948422,
-0.0586121492,
0.0229080301,
2.59768364e-34,
0.0193600114,
0.0212168694,
0.0398388542,
0.0373309962,
0.0335524455,
0.0064419406,
0.0350202993,
0.0230638292,
0.0296787154,
0.0271945558,
0.0016843913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14180v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14180v1 | Dynamic Topic Language Model on Heterogeneous Children's Mental Health Clinical Notes | 2023-12-19T00:36:53 | 2023-12-19T00:36:53 | Hanwen Ye, Tatiana Moreno, Adrianne Alpern, Louis Ehwerhemuepha, Annie Qu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.AP, stat.ML | Mental health diseases affect children's lives and well-beings which have
received increased attention since the COVID-19 pandemic. Analyzing psychiatric
clinical notes with topic models is critical to evaluate children's mental
status over time. However, few topic models are built for longitudinal
settings, and they fail to keep consistent topics and capture temporal
trajectories for each document. To address these challenges, we develop a
longitudinal topic model with time-invariant topics and individualized temporal
dependencies on the evolving document metadata. Our model preserves the
semantic meaning of discovered topics over time and incorporates heterogeneity
among documents. In particular, when documents can be categorized, we propose
an unsupervised topics learning approach to maximize topic heterogeneity across
different document groups. We also present an efficient variational
optimization procedure adapted for the multistage longitudinal setting. In this
case study, we apply our method to the psychiatric clinical notes from a large
tertiary pediatric hospital in Southern California and achieve a 38% increase
in the overall coherence of extracted topics. Our real data analysis reveals
that children tend to express more negative emotions during state shutdowns and
more positive when schools reopen. Furthermore, it suggests that sexual and
gender minority (SGM) children display more pronounced reactions to major
COVID-19 events and a greater sensitivity to vaccine-related news than non-SGM
children. This study examines the progression of children's mental health
during the pandemic and offers clinicians valuable insights to recognize the
disparities in children's mental health related to their sexual and gender
identities. | [
0.0167560782,
0.0949509442,
-0.0196858421,
-0.0240468234,
-0.0141907251,
0.0091459146,
-0.0167472512,
-0.0352364928,
-0.0166149177,
-0.0438183509,
0.0364102796,
-0.0417021699,
-0.0243653059,
0.0094078435,
-0.0477168486,
-0.0879524723,
0.0242314078,
0.0177381262,
0.0517792702,
0.0045530773,
-0.0169048961,
-0.0041571688,
-0.0193220284,
0.0095577464,
0.0026928512,
-0.036098063,
-0.0078061423,
0.0227734316,
0.0345615856,
-0.0649973527,
0.0215001833,
0.0181131512,
0.0216521285,
-0.0373232402,
0.0000023303,
-0.0201352928,
-0.0569660813,
-0.0234784838,
0.0390359499,
-0.0445785262,
0.070205465,
-0.0825681388,
-0.0107607134,
0.0066713174,
-0.0335498974,
-0.0492865816,
0.028157508,
0.0606016107,
0.046774406,
0.0295595545,
-0.0356016532,
0.0050220904,
0.0092894863,
-0.0131354807,
0.0605431348,
-0.0250296984,
0.0422715172,
0.0179126896,
0.0362431854,
-0.0567042865,
0.0079951547,
0.0195716489,
-0.050614804,
-0.0162835307,
0.0300239753,
0.0288010482,
0.0151699781,
0.0005834759,
0.0139861247,
0.0594888553,
0.0337150358,
0.0430501141,
0.0876968503,
-0.0165801533,
-0.0371030606,
0.0344717987,
-0.057749752,
0.0005113631,
-0.0183758289,
0.0170834418,
0.0463524796,
-0.0064035011,
0.0334340073,
0.0109525677,
0.0166213252,
0.0602968633,
0.0007984428,
-0.0334867984,
-0.0546224974,
-0.0389687903,
-0.0019891781,
-0.0526633337,
0.0336142108,
0.0143752266,
-0.0068653948,
0.0435086563,
0.0055442555,
-0.0967882499,
0.0119770318,
-0.043193996,
-0.050604105,
0.0011501426,
0.0061896467,
0.0143564595,
0.1155785546,
-0.0245038122,
-0.0245345067,
-0.0122397626,
-0.0143725201,
0.002064304,
-0.0585826375,
0.0376443043,
0.0091052335,
0.0190573819,
0.0451931171,
0.0346544199,
0.0006609354,
0.020829536,
-0.0159415752,
-0.0213868413,
-0.0477006994,
0.0009948135,
-0.0492389388,
-0.0170423537,
0.0353951007,
0.0362883359,
-0.0366152413,
0.0087580094,
-0.0178758055,
0.0417981111,
0.0260895621,
0.0002513226,
0.0324419066,
0.0063988846,
-0.0273312442,
-0.009081047,
0.0291021131,
0.0192998759,
-0.0521038547,
-0.0100508006,
-0.0144657921,
0.0019849064,
0.0218249802,
-0.0580187179,
0.0038653659,
0.0276513658,
0.0035185011,
-0.0092796078,
0.0016490984,
-0.0138975158,
-0.0653982759,
0.0108879069,
0.0007782476,
-0.016817091,
0.0765329152,
0.0347147435,
0.0473249331,
0.0752340928,
0.0141181415,
0.0022730078,
0.0295956898,
0.0040827896,
-0.0386542156,
-0.0341040939,
0.0123185925,
0.0305233747,
0.0239770822,
-0.0016375532,
0.0060533001,
0.0357458815,
-0.0247248877,
0.0079917125,
-0.0001771441,
-0.0170771573,
0.0054164515,
0.097882919,
-0.0311928932,
0.0084562106,
-0.0336083621,
0.0476254411,
-0.0243842453,
-0.020869093,
0.0131027186,
0.0049080816,
0.028921796,
-0.0227537546,
-0.0280723274,
0.0050393557,
-0.039951358,
-0.0329133645,
-0.0566939898,
-0.0377919264,
0.0111443736,
-0.0314442068,
0.0349811651,
-0.0239380375,
0.0243378803,
0.0581009574,
0.0416351855,
0.0091669131,
0.0060990755,
-0.0135097168,
0.0275867376,
0.0720269233,
0.0184512362,
-0.0587088205,
-0.0731518716,
-0.0650668219,
0.0589630939,
-0.0045945244,
-0.0222252589,
0.0074454136,
-0.0011852838,
-0.0063692848,
-0.0026713437,
0.0246396754,
0.0509434603,
0.011058229,
-0.0302836988,
0.0258300956,
-0.0253653787,
-0.026315989,
0.0463516638,
0.0447285213,
-0.0323822871,
0.005471637,
0.0555355251,
-0.0298140198,
0.078551203,
-0.0026222037,
0.0173800271,
0.0232409034,
0.0261660032,
-0.0363512114,
-0.055353459,
0.0185384117,
-0.0298081599,
0.0171893332,
0.0029161186,
-0.0421317443,
0.0060851951,
-0.0237553492,
-0.0449145176,
-0.0048373309,
0.1029151231,
-0.0130047956,
0.0038248322,
0.0198237039,
0.0001038649,
-0.0100329574,
-0.0143822618,
-0.0221475139,
0.0341780409,
-0.0559833273,
-0.0035880646,
0.0158328172,
-0.0366218947,
-0.0376138315,
-0.0361061655,
0.0164998882,
0.0261424985,
0.0022981344,
0.0093528321,
0.0064753969,
-0.0391771682,
-0.0001434934,
-0.034880612,
-0.1182415634,
0.023490632,
-0.0259534717,
-0.0066729258,
0.0448419265,
-0.0032416943,
-0.012405117,
0.0160647593,
0.0132231442,
-0.0072920816,
-0.0039949003,
0.0355765484,
0.0156485327,
0.0062760762,
0.039241273,
-0.09005294,
-0.0312045328,
-0.066524595,
0.02661472,
-0.0072427597,
-0.0194574092,
0.0021477398,
-0.0543694831,
-0.0715886503,
-0.0149048865,
-0.0304481015,
0.026152147,
0.0103118364,
-0.0242715888,
0.1041078418,
0.0312891416,
0.0340106599,
0.0793505833,
0.0547128133,
-0.0137922764,
-0.0184958205,
0.0169470776,
-0.0273865815,
0.0322186761,
-0.0011777335,
-0.0692144781,
0.0366350524,
0.0579353161,
0.0286849272,
0.0208066422,
-0.0129432296,
-0.0078099659,
-0.0602554865,
0.0290246531,
-0.0456700623,
0.0059037604,
-0.0103878863,
-0.0037676869,
-0.0279570799,
-0.0407765433,
0.0300743952,
0.0730922595,
0.0292591192,
-0.0791873708,
-0.0161123537,
-0.0551936664,
0.0163398329,
-0.0306204502,
-0.0088398689,
0.0161315687,
0.0033674662,
-0.0120131159,
-0.0313222781,
0.007558166,
-0.0289367549,
0.0370676555,
-0.0437963791,
0.0351428948,
0.0304145142,
-0.0093871197,
-0.0354989916,
-0.0597812012,
0.0101388646,
-0.0127602946,
-0.0202153083,
0.0160066765,
-0.0598850511,
-0.0118948063,
0.010864296,
0.0440969244,
0.0006991812,
-0.0332902037,
0.0115609849,
0.0341416225,
0.0627097562,
-0.0957562178,
-0.0215231683,
-0.0436447598,
-0.0033358785,
0.0395765975,
0.0578177162,
0.0064182165,
0.006883061,
0.03294475,
-0.0221699551,
-0.0071321628,
-0.0300968885,
0.0146759208,
0.0084327227,
-0.0377859399,
0.0128428461,
0.0772924945,
0.0204555858,
-0.0325119011,
0.0108921649,
-0.0481847599,
-0.0116770566,
-0.0180661269,
-0.0002540958,
0.0009877761,
0.0223681387,
-0.0190672502,
0.0440688841,
0.0106730368,
-0.0542522483,
-0.0020865607,
0.0323238559,
-0.0056320112,
-0.0066684275,
0.0260251202,
0.0182899777,
-0.0741077513,
0.0289042369,
-0.0071520451,
-0.019715922,
-0.0351021364,
-0.0138811627,
-0.0087620988,
-0.0021499584,
-0.0664703846,
-0.0495018065,
0.0217723269,
0.0144518539,
0.0541138239,
-0.0013872054,
0.0556250624,
-0.0113901431,
-0.0322412811,
-0.0128725106,
0.0275008846,
-0.059565112,
-0.018129155,
0.0064472244,
-0.0087268353,
0.0343688428,
-0.0298495498,
0.0505576544,
-0.0474054329,
-0.0133370468,
0.01720093,
0.0890512541,
-0.0137521885,
-0.0365139246,
-0.0601502918,
0.0346558318,
0.0499954373,
0.0304459147,
0.0004639912,
-0.0385858528,
0.0470195338,
-0.0009150548,
0.0575125813,
0.0269145872,
0.0166024957,
-0.0423772708,
-0.0203332864,
-0.0617304742,
-0.0460841842,
-0.0028319971,
-0.0168547612,
-0.0437031277,
-0.0358764939,
-0.0397823006,
0.0702576563,
-0.0460714214,
-0.0859771073,
0.0522396415,
0.0271874145,
-0.0244367234,
-0.0228216648,
-0.068871133,
0.0257589631,
0.0430430286,
-0.0126158167,
0.0105018355,
-0.117754966,
-0.0350692235,
0.0425395221,
-0.0399130061,
0.0106518259,
0.0124465572,
0.0019961719,
0.0119634951,
0.0270128306,
0.0095642665,
-0.018613318,
-0.0386100896,
0.0075570531,
0.0104180807,
0.0033528307,
0.0262956433,
-0.0163222011,
0.0372854695,
-0.0063893395,
0.0041873907,
-0.0687563568,
0.0103374971,
-0.0497851297,
-0.0309310444,
0.0330443308,
0.0172131211,
-0.079188332,
-0.0507966131,
-0.0495817438,
0.0068959808,
0.0216691028,
0.0052196453,
-0.0242541078,
-0.0098598599,
-0.0057901959,
-0.057104703,
0.0180303529,
-0.0314887241,
-0.0016972951,
-0.0303854197,
0.0520695597,
-0.0453753807,
0.0279668868,
-0.0019537595,
0.007145104,
0.0109800613,
0.047646407,
-0.0287193637,
0.0068339733,
-0.0115747098,
0.0152811287,
-0.0011633738,
0.0248359907,
0.0056922664,
-0.0173990745,
-0.0477507561,
-0.0465544574,
-0.03589103,
-0.022293428,
0.0318391696,
0.0245581418,
0.0563987754,
-0.0282342564,
0.0025241463,
-0.0399947688,
0.0308624357,
0.0066834632,
-0.0066760741,
0.0488753356,
0.0123549188,
-0.0080727851,
0.0330727845,
0.0414560474,
0.015280636,
0.0533736534,
0.021378519,
0.008462877,
-0.0228060819,
0.0392768197,
0.0266554933,
0.0469637625,
-0.0417607389,
0.0398110338,
-0.0485269241,
0.0144371446,
0.0869458914,
-0.0767314583,
-0.0255746655,
-0.0188752413,
0.0218170285,
0.0591830499,
-0.0085748695,
0.0115484316,
-0.0270331409,
0.0528369509,
-0.0234356746,
-0.06495215,
-0.0531608574,
-6.654955473e-33,
0.0034353719,
-0.0343791023,
-0.0300254282,
-0.0041376976,
0.0187451765,
0.0454548411,
-0.0473460741,
0.017048819,
0.0131841144,
-0.0130602932,
0.0269604102,
0.0546656661,
0.011094328,
0.0137421638,
0.0328876749,
-0.0228939913,
0.0517819747,
-0.0158998482,
0.0070899576,
0.0324044861,
0.0119101396,
0.0492780469,
0.0401820205,
-0.1015557125,
0.0454098545,
-0.0192634817,
0.0268651247,
-0.0054718875,
0.0788955986,
0.0151117789,
-0.0343805887,
0.0465103388,
0.0350481756,
-0.0183905102,
0.0053910078,
-0.0070721568,
-0.0525435209,
-0.04038845,
0.0053738486,
-0.0472197346,
-0.0202587098,
-0.0319231562,
0.0047377846,
0.043810159,
0.0163610522,
-0.0423635505,
0.0631169751,
0.0099797174,
-0.00154228,
-0.0465906411,
-0.0216956101,
0.0511698686,
-0.0460570343,
0.0366033651,
-0.0082887942,
-0.0168339368,
-0.006449332,
0.0721270218,
-0.0303929392,
0.019761052,
-0.0106657473,
0.022211099,
-0.0054970933,
-0.0394958742,
0.0279091075,
0.0530152917,
0.0016452058,
0.0430736654,
-0.0244594831,
0.0047404072,
0.03040969,
-0.01133247,
0.0038328664,
-0.0081766397,
0.043322254,
0.0124379378,
-0.0638760328,
0.0234109946,
-0.0088957129,
0.0339837819,
0.0220768899,
0.0432441086,
0.0114071192,
0.0039463439,
-0.0102864858,
-0.0068061976,
0.0021287564,
-0.0045712474,
-0.0281825867,
0.011917877,
-0.0627391487,
-0.0016172738,
-0.0049164002,
0.039568428,
-0.0504865274,
0.0340286233,
0.0396162979,
-0.0116764428,
0.0170647912,
0.0333303809,
-0.0785714313,
-0.012899722,
0.0156301577,
-0.0004830244,
0.0331262648,
0.0281871781,
-0.0212316941,
-0.0133175952,
-0.0453047864,
-0.0283815376,
0.0308725648,
0.0023446025,
-0.0260991622,
0.0542934388,
-0.002137769,
0.0092140818,
0.0143238055,
0.0684196427,
0.0653609633,
0.065446265,
-0.0137044899,
-0.0527802296,
-0.0474917479,
0.022804169,
0.0080439663,
-0.0113626868,
-0.009266519,
0.0095082754,
0.0494040772,
-0.0385268182,
-0.0035055296,
-0.0563007966,
3.052e-7,
0.0583264455,
0.094317548,
0.0012499719,
-0.0230010897,
0.0559418388,
0.0060732686,
-0.042766504,
0.0000326691,
0.0372483321,
-0.0327446014,
0.0127183767,
0.0339454599,
0.0193665568,
0.0729292482,
-0.0253318716,
0.0111416411,
-0.0447903946,
0.0392765813,
-0.0440580733,
-0.0072623119,
0.0338107832,
0.0599322692,
0.0322699659,
-0.0027389857,
-0.0241953768,
0.0409945212,
0.0600391366,
-0.0421770215,
-0.0298694838,
0.0530758426,
0.0358973369,
0.0255052261,
0.0068701031,
-0.041629184,
-0.0306279287,
0.0008227272,
-0.0282321759,
0.0469853729,
-0.0102756321,
0.0063744751,
0.0004909547,
-0.0025747609,
-0.0424938276,
-0.0013369048,
0.0451118797,
-0.0639359951,
-0.0300431289,
-0.0347042941,
-0.0401870906,
0.0476193503,
0.0488146283,
-0.0125142746,
-0.0679302216,
0.0537716672,
-0.0134873223,
0.0001944454,
0.0052494472,
-0.0532224029,
-0.0184069443,
0.0248523001,
-0.0661183298,
-0.0059459019,
-0.0036541242,
0.0054222574,
-0.0059780972,
-0.0327594951,
0.0626098216,
2.645975795e-34,
0.0513296947,
0.0230296031,
-0.0664881691,
-0.0317145884,
-0.0182158519,
-0.0120335035,
-0.0565615557,
0.0077428007,
-0.0221637432,
-0.0159677174,
0.0088244006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11720v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11720v2 | Assessing Logical Reasoning Capabilities of Encoder-Only Transformer Models | 2023-12-18T21:42:34 | 2024-07-01T13:49:45 | Paulo Pirozelli, Marcos M. José, Paulo de Tarso P. Filho, Anarosa A. F. Brandão, Fabio G. Cozman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Logical reasoning is central to complex human activities, such as thinking,
debating, and planning; it is also a central component of many AI systems as
well. In this paper, we investigate the extent to which encoder-only
transformer language models (LMs) can reason according to logical rules. We ask
whether those LMs can deduce theorems in propositional calculus and first-order
logic; if their relative success in these problems reflects general logical
capabilities; and which layers contribute the most to the task. First, we show
for several encoder-only LMs that they can be trained, to a reasonable degree,
to determine logical validity on various datasets. Next, by cross-probing
fine-tuned models on these datasets, we show that LMs have difficulty in
transferring their putative logical reasoning ability, which suggests that they
may have learned dataset-specific features, instead of a general capability.
Finally, we conduct a layerwise probing experiment, which shows that the
hypothesis classification task is mostly solved through higher layers. | [
0.0137790749,
0.0729778782,
-0.026613215,
0.0449949503,
-0.0065151933,
0.0463594161,
0.0275920574,
-0.0175760668,
-0.0001146155,
-0.0064923484,
-0.0214923378,
0.0220516119,
0.0071172798,
0.052111391,
0.0094825113,
-0.0071739666,
0.0078422111,
-0.0289803855,
0.0140441377,
-0.0009269798,
-0.0370927304,
-0.0114236632,
0.0000083995,
0.0232463516,
-0.0004860211,
0.020995168,
-0.0217997245,
-0.0294362921,
0.0344630443,
0.0229041092,
-0.0175135266,
0.0104023134,
0.0284477156,
0.0053955768,
0.0000018231,
-0.0392707475,
-0.0093136216,
-0.0334147513,
-0.058745373,
-0.067946285,
-0.0150058893,
-0.0674850792,
-0.0065731816,
0.0200543664,
-0.0409891345,
-0.0233559776,
0.0393380113,
0.0419785604,
0.0497251041,
0.0739988387,
-0.0172102898,
-0.0567737631,
0.0362639241,
-0.0174490176,
0.0083588446,
-0.0081531461,
0.0139988102,
0.0077541806,
-0.0393465646,
-0.0562030859,
-0.0136182094,
0.0242028087,
0.0882662013,
0.0100404359,
-0.0560667701,
0.0490269996,
-0.0282976497,
-0.0546761416,
0.0202560518,
0.02769191,
-0.0398755036,
-0.0515315868,
-0.0272736568,
0.0107989777,
-0.0162110198,
0.0157606732,
-0.0173225496,
0.0704460293,
-0.0078636128,
0.0222987123,
0.0506242029,
-0.0044733076,
0.0237732772,
0.0052964347,
-0.0904373527,
0.1375165284,
-0.0258129202,
-0.0361358002,
0.0203273855,
0.0215658918,
-0.0207019318,
-0.0567191355,
-0.0110141989,
0.0545672216,
0.0130873388,
0.0280627701,
-0.008349915,
0.0283308215,
-0.0312574469,
-0.0299062058,
0.0050276318,
0.0433935374,
0.0134455953,
0.0288718641,
-0.0522263423,
0.0812642053,
0.0005955471,
0.1119894832,
0.0046031391,
-0.0507909805,
-0.0402090922,
-0.032053858,
-0.0165490657,
0.0337909646,
-0.0068630865,
0.0091461977,
-0.0265150629,
0.0216154251,
0.0080939298,
0.0443678759,
-0.0203903522,
-0.0188459102,
-0.0004794222,
-0.0488895401,
-0.0671685711,
0.0298779551,
-0.0069015203,
0.0342102312,
0.0246616397,
-0.0801340342,
-0.0294208005,
-0.0001207342,
0.0130447177,
-0.0095641622,
0.0557675771,
0.0408461764,
-0.0167862773,
-0.0195161533,
-0.0262670908,
-0.0263767522,
0.0267978087,
-0.0633795708,
0.0559141599,
-0.041673746,
0.0173725393,
0.0235269722,
0.0142810494,
-0.050266277,
-0.0177969262,
0.0294104163,
0.00354837,
0.0923885927,
0.0204646457,
0.0123438602,
0.0283158012,
-0.01462657,
-0.0337918699,
0.0514196269,
0.0520676076,
0.0272442829,
-0.0213955678,
-0.0196499396,
0.0255406983,
0.0162270274,
0.0083318055,
-0.0357562937,
-0.0554944985,
0.0135735283,
-0.0479911044,
0.0022197345,
-0.0159629453,
0.0416889936,
-0.0340784304,
-0.0099917753,
0.039198257,
0.0426514074,
0.0236382168,
0.0029929082,
0.0403694622,
-0.0181823261,
-0.0050242599,
0.0114529328,
-0.0628763363,
0.0440664925,
-0.0061509125,
-0.0139011852,
-0.0525354296,
0.0121122124,
-0.0309550352,
-0.0686452165,
-0.00545158,
-0.0205135476,
0.0293727592,
0.0145035116,
0.0534653999,
0.0454102419,
-0.0092700711,
0.0602034852,
-0.0100403372,
-0.0757293403,
-0.003362196,
-0.0712820813,
0.0328473821,
0.0001037616,
0.0241024848,
0.0147572542,
-0.0397742502,
0.0016865921,
0.0256832875,
0.0475725308,
0.0363054723,
-0.0073605208,
0.0151915811,
-0.067229487,
-0.018107364,
-0.0154287368,
0.0106745111,
0.0119004063,
-0.038763389,
-0.0211819727,
0.0045676939,
-0.0238229837,
0.0342437029,
0.0221947897,
-0.0255960096,
0.0088370116,
-0.0022866915,
0.0308077261,
0.016600104,
-0.034854915,
-0.0142033743,
0.0054970533,
0.0235297214,
-0.0511914194,
-0.063429065,
0.0336707272,
-0.028127851,
-0.0374584049,
-0.0098522482,
-0.0844077915,
-0.0147017632,
0.0395680778,
-0.0384778343,
-0.0283765662,
-0.000284121,
-0.0284854416,
0.0022485114,
-0.030053759,
0.0205504093,
-0.0298058484,
-0.0044797966,
0.0249517187,
0.0839357227,
-0.0107943267,
0.0147409085,
0.0143200988,
0.0026709044,
0.0200110674,
-0.0398358069,
0.0032320286,
0.0113118757,
-0.0244619809,
0.0048591476,
-0.0004071622,
0.0021978354,
0.0036120096,
-0.0493931957,
-0.0501850471,
-0.0012322145,
-0.0271413904,
0.0098831076,
-0.0009820611,
-0.0130730569,
0.0058328141,
-0.0119236559,
-0.0303198565,
0.0026418141,
0.0284499452,
0.0123562496,
0.0286543239,
-0.0335337743,
-0.0198089089,
0.0192812514,
-0.0163326021,
-0.0177810825,
0.0305044502,
-0.0003910952,
0.0282257125,
-0.0033749091,
-0.0135134403,
-0.0284337141,
0.0007473791,
-0.0317504853,
-0.0421256311,
0.0394808687,
0.0000281297,
-0.0261562914,
0.1145932674,
0.0154045736,
0.0240346026,
0.0432531834,
0.0165827572,
-0.0169083942,
0.0314003192,
-0.0244730376,
-0.0022865527,
-0.0724205673,
0.0007193752,
-0.0049759289,
0.0627158582,
-0.0214353893,
0.0322195701,
-0.0722791702,
0.0479464084,
0.0075791264,
-0.0162753202,
0.0100759529,
0.0012080503,
0.0159541238,
0.0861570984,
-0.025753906,
-0.0026194612,
0.0732318684,
-0.0033565504,
-0.0319566317,
-0.0244563874,
-0.0124051496,
-0.0505356751,
0.0433119647,
0.0254401639,
-0.0228877887,
0.019492358,
-0.0185440835,
-0.0309163835,
0.0074311714,
0.0043518241,
-0.0188719165,
0.0458143018,
-0.0321779139,
-0.012685461,
-0.0151303597,
-0.0570096076,
-0.056507431,
0.0300876964,
-0.0674518794,
0.0290358625,
-0.0354469977,
-0.0157884397,
-0.0537642799,
0.0088189701,
0.0027562829,
0.0402194448,
0.0167443529,
-0.0168773513,
-0.0414670072,
-0.013254337,
0.0268788692,
0.0574533455,
-0.0052921083,
-0.0385169797,
0.0395871662,
0.0091382312,
-0.0356532633,
0.0081714643,
-0.0297098923,
0.0627284274,
0.0100778891,
0.0425929166,
0.0056101969,
0.0195998419,
0.0268563293,
-0.0299239792,
-0.0361973681,
0.1292257905,
0.0124230366,
0.0023668215,
-0.0076981932,
-0.0088050319,
-0.0082395757,
0.0249088854,
0.0066220071,
-0.0616522543,
-0.0453456044,
0.0195720103,
-0.021642277,
-0.032436911,
-0.0103559596,
0.0054218909,
-0.1135351658,
0.0395554565,
-0.0242151376,
0.0091068484,
-0.0472372323,
-0.0357622989,
-0.0040843701,
-0.0556204021,
0.0064488775,
-0.0204131175,
0.0227881186,
-0.0250866208,
0.006774202,
-0.0093841366,
-0.0480608605,
0.0275916457,
-0.0062925601,
-0.0092253182,
0.0433673412,
0.0214577708,
-0.031362325,
-0.0955317765,
-0.0050263354,
0.0205189884,
0.005588857,
0.0087692123,
0.0285567846,
-0.0038763101,
-0.0045719729,
0.0279197134,
0.0310918316,
-0.0608718693,
-0.0164404996,
0.01202578,
0.069303982,
-0.0653869659,
-0.0734529421,
0.0139473127,
-0.0024725639,
-0.0516723692,
0.0496655591,
0.0247873794,
-0.0087678879,
-0.0491294526,
-0.065224953,
-0.0244183764,
-0.0461505204,
-0.0252548773,
0.0367774107,
0.0718679503,
-0.0476387106,
-0.0233984403,
-0.024273295,
0.0148310307,
0.0250933189,
-0.0174563956,
-0.0615789816,
0.0636443347,
0.0005215333,
-0.0393942185,
-0.0030167638,
-0.0320794471,
-0.0067558992,
-0.0233595632,
0.044892136,
0.0180842429,
-0.0326917283,
-0.038854938,
-0.0152721973,
-0.0530908369,
-0.0417726897,
-0.0118337302,
0.0334594995,
0.0286250785,
0.0094954614,
-0.0199257843,
-0.0352217928,
0.0617685206,
0.0113009429,
-0.0068028034,
0.0053359182,
0.0544473641,
-0.0581031181,
0.0049048043,
0.0350678861,
-0.0084805014,
0.0489195846,
0.0338240899,
0.0066306707,
-0.0487434939,
-0.027245855,
0.0481060967,
-0.0096602272,
0.0485072173,
0.0686827078,
-0.0263724215,
-0.0240636617,
0.0500834398,
0.0005552727,
0.0085620033,
-0.0435045622,
-0.0186360367,
0.0121906325,
0.0410543047,
0.0133768972,
-0.0158593562,
-0.0128109818,
0.0099773342,
0.0146352416,
0.0218102802,
0.0281053353,
0.0345775075,
-0.0049818731,
-0.0282343104,
-0.0092548262,
-0.0207284149,
0.0088223564,
0.0481487177,
0.0147487577,
0.0704289675,
0.0476061627,
0.0389383249,
-0.020812707,
-0.0030974522,
-0.0898355544,
-0.0857883096,
0.0296557955,
-0.0203913078,
0.0508690402,
0.0128138848,
-0.0103221564,
-0.0364088602,
0.0180588458,
-0.0004189962,
0.045507282,
0.0298444629,
-0.0428040512,
0.0585454516,
0.0093096942,
-0.0149460752,
-0.0322625898,
0.0203077774,
-0.0121980254,
0.0536458865,
-0.0246596318,
0.01089535,
-0.0378797874,
-0.0309060793,
-0.0251618735,
-0.0303714406,
0.0052691316,
0.0253807101,
-0.0139358761,
-0.0811162442,
0.0365957208,
0.0217073746,
0.0470273718,
-0.0252224412,
0.0041339695,
0.065037556,
0.0002519691,
-0.0407508165,
0.0047554024,
-0.0315462388,
-0.0269677751,
0.0119556468,
-0.0299038999,
-5.835412199e-33,
-0.0045780549,
-0.0067780917,
0.0432349145,
-0.0048038242,
0.0333345346,
-0.0075174775,
-0.0427711792,
-0.0308428369,
-0.0511980802,
0.0179166533,
-0.0075806044,
0.0452542491,
0.0117225498,
0.0390316397,
0.004266121,
-0.0332153738,
0.031219298,
0.0196974352,
-0.0562910177,
-0.0168222226,
0.029854944,
-0.0248633455,
0.0393108204,
0.0053793201,
-0.0263164341,
0.0107150162,
-0.0086490521,
0.0382324494,
-0.0769752935,
0.0640414357,
0.001509767,
-0.0001313591,
0.0335841142,
-0.0559041202,
0.0029120999,
0.0396796949,
-0.0530344546,
-0.021450039,
-0.02447428,
0.0331284702,
-0.0203561652,
-0.0375137329,
0.0688400716,
0.0244304873,
-0.0072616418,
-0.0476269908,
0.0243153442,
-0.0305916928,
0.0515963025,
-0.0166687313,
-0.0192115624,
0.0095729176,
-0.0149381952,
-0.0515205897,
0.0263052266,
0.041946508,
-0.0273120832,
0.0021716347,
-0.0592434332,
0.0326747075,
-0.0030388529,
-0.020207921,
0.0786546618,
-0.0143746762,
-0.0224124175,
0.0444024354,
0.0059584207,
-0.0083717769,
-0.0417894647,
0.0303852782,
0.0319814086,
0.0773935169,
0.0522546768,
-0.009623657,
0.0501518287,
0.0040361444,
-0.0713093281,
-0.0074609187,
-0.0172384549,
0.0651911795,
0.0436318778,
-0.0249786228,
-0.0083942506,
0.0063278722,
-0.0524352714,
0.0238717832,
-0.0251390152,
-0.0112678912,
0.0121146403,
0.0106643904,
0.0102578374,
-0.0143744238,
0.0504325144,
-0.0595058836,
0.0672880933,
0.0339446403,
0.0041994266,
0.0058155917,
0.004438336,
0.0232102964,
-0.0351296142,
-0.0340437926,
0.0402138568,
0.0088480935,
0.0345803015,
0.0266028438,
0.0421812274,
0.0474992916,
-0.0150068393,
-0.0379079953,
-0.0318398103,
-0.0029026128,
-0.0378701948,
0.0890352577,
0.0216680504,
0.0592676438,
-0.0136175659,
-0.0095684389,
-0.0777421147,
-0.0284438245,
-0.0578848831,
0.0514261536,
0.0074064396,
0.0389040709,
-0.0258453898,
-0.0449269712,
-0.0641181767,
-0.0184164699,
-0.0110514378,
-0.0362638198,
0.0057660914,
0.0453353301,
2.666e-7,
-0.0034052122,
0.0152400369,
0.0290613994,
0.0631055087,
0.0264982693,
0.0418296866,
-0.0172285624,
0.0096403323,
0.0434087552,
-0.0407035947,
0.0013481089,
0.0522001423,
0.0606570952,
0.0324013308,
-0.0652245879,
-0.0136020174,
-0.0196474511,
-0.023298461,
-0.0059211263,
0.0350074545,
0.1022630781,
0.0867922902,
0.0174214225,
-0.0256135017,
0.0123959053,
-0.0201599356,
0.035962902,
0.0022426911,
0.0236372594,
0.0103889769,
0.0167795103,
0.0204027779,
0.0102589065,
0.0876954347,
0.0054599033,
0.0220284462,
-0.0230465885,
0.061678689,
-0.0061646835,
-0.0415343903,
-0.042223677,
0.0013008087,
-0.0186300743,
-0.0422082655,
0.0852974579,
-0.0917668119,
-0.0588122159,
0.0394533314,
-0.0054708738,
-0.0067259213,
-0.0111574437,
0.0059094639,
0.0039835684,
-0.0172208436,
0.0366134942,
-0.0011617261,
0.0181013662,
-0.0631354675,
0.013749741,
0.002455241,
-0.0417935997,
-0.0262234397,
-0.0180493761,
-0.0254723411,
0.0612792373,
-0.0107596628,
-0.0015009397,
2.075682415e-34,
0.0039168014,
-0.0028253053,
0.0011462152,
-0.0018367752,
0.0741785318,
-0.02115307,
-0.0059621716,
0.0137195205,
0.0044428585,
-0.0814888626,
-0.0049165464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.12464v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.12464v2 | Towards Better Serialization of Tabular Data for Few-shot Classification with Large Language Models | 2023-12-18T21:11:17 | 2023-12-21T02:43:26 | Sukriti Jaitly, Tanay Shah, Ashish Shugani, Razik Singh Grewal | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We present a study on the integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) in
tabular data classification, emphasizing an efficient framework. Building upon
existing work done in TabLLM (arXiv:2210.10723), we introduce three novel
serialization techniques, including the standout LaTeX serialization method.
This method significantly boosts the performance of LLMs in processing
domain-specific datasets, Our method stands out for its memory efficiency and
ability to fully utilize complex data structures. Through extensive
experimentation, including various serialization approaches like feature
combination and importance, we demonstrate our work's superiority in accuracy
and efficiency over traditional models. | [
-0.0363462418,
0.0752052665,
0.0139997937,
0.0128348898,
-0.0382992551,
0.0472091287,
0.0690191463,
0.012784902,
-0.0304408893,
-0.1082205176,
-0.0215772763,
-0.0635418445,
-0.0026432192,
0.0226881001,
0.0078566056,
0.000504458,
0.0216892175,
-0.0112320455,
-0.0183123983,
-0.0174158756,
-0.0345684774,
0.0003521193,
0.0430860408,
0.0036397879,
0.0631381422,
-0.0054465807,
-0.0252296664,
-0.0108365593,
-0.0220578574,
-0.0180785414,
-0.0309457444,
0.0753015727,
0.0545542389,
0.0534890182,
0.0000019591,
-0.0431944691,
-0.0392476395,
0.0118877757,
-0.0148631344,
0.0227784682,
0.0641648546,
-0.0319349691,
0.003253639,
-0.0125494925,
0.0101445466,
-0.0863821059,
0.0305054467,
0.0248934496,
0.0527547188,
0.0327212438,
-0.01499194,
-0.0702785924,
0.0375748798,
-0.0073880223,
0.0332419947,
-0.0000642983,
0.054811772,
-0.0065741064,
-0.0283249263,
0.0282285847,
-0.0052958522,
0.0151954032,
-0.0198279954,
-0.0117199346,
0.0328511074,
0.018047519,
-0.0303282905,
0.019320827,
0.0394908972,
0.0167986676,
-0.0061705154,
-0.0414498337,
0.0051818504,
-0.0039050963,
0.0043316423,
-0.0023967016,
-0.0619136915,
0.0240532495,
0.0096734716,
-0.0004394607,
0.0295135099,
-0.0091921641,
0.0021263247,
0.0029858907,
-0.0191637743,
-0.0217314586,
0.0009294375,
-0.0015100311,
-0.0124514904,
0.004940832,
0.0057380036,
-0.0457275845,
-0.0113151185,
0.0143700559,
0.0143280346,
-0.0139310192,
-0.0486028269,
-0.0808652639,
0.036207445,
-0.0577710941,
0.0881356895,
0.0084615452,
0.0057096169,
0.0498067439,
-0.0388739295,
0.0467836931,
0.0077483365,
-0.0194545221,
-0.0133518577,
-0.0197132099,
-0.0860676616,
0.0011765343,
-0.0213011894,
0.074192293,
0.0433731303,
0.0153814638,
-0.047292728,
0.0277786795,
-0.0223460682,
0.0286141895,
-0.0268768054,
-0.0259097256,
0.0233365372,
0.0089614224,
0.002206132,
0.0146478405,
0.009701944,
-0.0010281857,
-0.0345488377,
-0.0275077652,
-0.0053649545,
0.0148911746,
0.04547159,
-0.0465987511,
0.0227687452,
0.0322178453,
-0.0090798512,
-0.0772249848,
-0.0217153728,
-0.0128509952,
-0.0119767562,
-0.0297152344,
0.000634155,
-0.0957797617,
0.0583444387,
0.0305666942,
0.006842643,
-0.038732484,
-0.0169685297,
0.0197413824,
-0.0151833631,
0.0798754394,
0.0098481104,
0.0090429587,
0.0498946384,
-0.0477657281,
0.0034356492,
0.0637061894,
0.0091458261,
0.0359660424,
-0.0142183248,
-0.0731157735,
0.0046768342,
0.0207756739,
-0.0161717646,
-0.0289173368,
-0.0809112787,
0.0336333029,
0.0692494884,
0.0000050904,
0.0275834221,
-0.0210548975,
-0.0183961093,
0.0176341496,
0.0587832667,
0.0796135888,
-0.0046219681,
0.0155865736,
-0.0009443083,
0.0266981274,
0.0127809336,
-0.0515037552,
0.0146366498,
0.0124446657,
-0.0027732125,
-0.0005031611,
0.0282078441,
0.0564093664,
-0.0337900221,
-0.0212078597,
-0.0156979077,
-0.0162899327,
-0.0063902158,
0.004260398,
0.0861017704,
-0.0245597977,
0.0226713978,
0.0496635735,
0.0434965342,
-0.0034974145,
-0.0431243032,
-0.0457380079,
0.0092634195,
0.0310290307,
0.0109528312,
-0.0175216049,
-0.0257078428,
-0.0262671728,
0.035436362,
-0.0230742153,
0.0240026601,
-0.0116559798,
-0.0086927628,
-0.0153666576,
-0.0260139294,
0.0463612564,
0.0291070156,
0.0107312398,
-0.0057907379,
0.0204811916,
0.0126967346,
-0.0179493316,
-0.0326730013,
0.0008051611,
0.0150911119,
-0.0447962768,
0.0403039008,
0.002725044,
0.0388152041,
0.0191443451,
-0.0194890331,
-0.0195238851,
0.0680474192,
-0.046335157,
-0.0121913981,
-0.0533459373,
0.0190610774,
-0.0215524156,
0.0220565591,
0.0769544169,
-0.0112215783,
0.0053895162,
-0.0621464103,
-0.0223612618,
-0.0226625334,
-0.0337385572,
-0.0035058698,
-0.0428435132,
0.0477048941,
-0.0389645584,
0.0339947753,
-0.0539377555,
0.0565537028,
-0.0067726336,
0.0078822114,
-0.0014019661,
-0.0815849453,
0.0073331902,
-0.0033020445,
-0.0248066168,
0.0390649214,
-0.0237251893,
0.0447884686,
-0.0039445716,
0.0013232633,
0.0218649227,
-0.0131351594,
-0.0682848915,
0.0356119573,
-0.0011268465,
0.018956013,
-0.0001690047,
-0.0114117954,
0.0128248818,
-0.0014320322,
-0.0450848229,
0.010315448,
0.0147842215,
0.0268152542,
0.0476941504,
-0.0337727107,
-0.0457634404,
0.0095521128,
-0.0307423994,
-0.0167426933,
0.0817877501,
-0.0526360236,
-0.0522176288,
-0.0410028733,
0.0149495462,
-0.0215107538,
-0.0125560863,
0.0310150441,
-0.0166722145,
-0.0371981598,
-0.0543129072,
-0.0333588719,
0.0408897102,
-0.0195497386,
0.0408025272,
0.0851741657,
0.0069990708,
-0.0367374569,
-0.0106515829,
-0.0323277861,
-0.002974859,
-0.0131938243,
-0.0526043177,
-0.0066592298,
0.0411470458,
-0.0233813301,
0.0034775368,
-0.0211638287,
0.0179404728,
0.0163221452,
0.0035800831,
-0.0674892217,
0.0429672375,
0.0030363477,
0.0045313048,
0.0202151369,
-0.0436917059,
0.0259087086,
-0.0521436296,
0.0104268407,
-0.0116387084,
-0.0422944576,
-0.0606883578,
0.0750593692,
0.0238276478,
0.0182767343,
0.0203987435,
-0.0068406742,
-0.0083473837,
-0.0016799183,
0.0028920292,
-0.0494714603,
0.0572370701,
0.001172852,
0.0143818054,
-0.0435918681,
-0.0232795198,
0.0169588719,
-0.0546762086,
-0.0293965302,
0.0135568082,
-0.0106037753,
-0.0064195269,
-0.0458548032,
0.0234770644,
0.0229272917,
0.0335368849,
-0.0177316293,
-0.008065938,
-0.0086268205,
0.0486892238,
0.0232421532,
-0.0139459912,
-0.0356843993,
-0.0117809707,
0.013019301,
0.0631471798,
-0.026844319,
0.0464319438,
-0.0235718936,
-0.0056479955,
0.0652517229,
-0.0104175378,
-0.0271438509,
-0.0089651588,
-0.0051284577,
-0.0628036112,
0.0054924856,
0.1208193898,
0.0250484552,
-0.0502703041,
-0.0418069959,
-0.0003282034,
0.0399985388,
-0.0011137505,
0.0503678061,
-0.0295866709,
-0.0291213486,
0.0064577213,
0.0068470524,
0.0100317961,
0.0014173996,
-0.0056590829,
-0.1069566384,
0.059957806,
0.023112284,
-0.0410461463,
-0.0645852834,
-0.043629881,
-0.0160342399,
-0.0125974435,
-0.0232317206,
0.0024866813,
-0.0313591287,
-0.0044891317,
0.0259436332,
-0.0520333871,
-0.0560571961,
0.0181444827,
-0.0047198404,
0.0356819741,
0.0355587415,
0.0183630884,
-0.0419497341,
0.0038578934,
-0.0269048214,
0.0523820221,
-0.044648096,
-0.0302204583,
0.0463579036,
0.003977864,
-0.0061256443,
0.0159072485,
-0.0058640586,
-0.0108023174,
-0.0205838885,
-0.0175293386,
0.081196256,
-0.0484523363,
-0.004165024,
-0.0011804455,
-0.0593921989,
-0.0356613398,
0.0714339018,
0.020187309,
-0.056094896,
0.0030805175,
-0.0161450468,
-0.0733912736,
0.0202548262,
0.0016224413,
0.0170365367,
-0.0351462327,
-0.0543036871,
-0.0531353019,
-0.0054853093,
0.059247084,
0.0100605143,
-0.0365788899,
0.0430078618,
-0.0192911178,
-0.0347620584,
-0.0746335387,
-0.0007458027,
-0.0284162387,
-0.0074556023,
-0.0538895689,
-0.0116759799,
0.0507971123,
-0.0467212349,
-0.0352304541,
-0.0398989953,
-0.100648433,
-0.0316616409,
0.0018196974,
0.0431479514,
0.012807765,
-0.0051918388,
0.0369709358,
-0.0677292198,
0.0282366276,
0.0641132444,
0.0102226567,
0.0100163603,
0.005907259,
-0.0377347022,
-0.0213829912,
0.0076323487,
-0.0500921905,
0.0107044633,
-0.0104438439,
-0.0281965602,
-0.0267754328,
0.0170246102,
0.0021590707,
0.0164792407,
0.0659831837,
0.0054477099,
-0.0476399809,
0.0204022154,
0.0449911878,
-0.0125363935,
-0.0389470644,
-0.0349683426,
-0.0200201813,
0.0160804875,
-0.0222943518,
-0.0356901586,
0.0106479609,
0.0501904935,
0.0491117053,
-0.020892188,
-0.0081409598,
-0.0200215764,
-0.0273774136,
0.0405186564,
-0.0014957699,
-0.0543988645,
-0.0213561002,
0.0090736672,
0.0140835783,
-0.0455954,
0.0256705191,
-0.0064493516,
0.024598429,
-0.0378068648,
0.0461297445,
-0.0300210323,
-0.042206347,
-0.0347846821,
-0.0061050719,
0.0267576519,
-0.0042631682,
0.0130614033,
-0.0030185613,
-0.0303799938,
-0.0404066481,
0.0403771102,
0.0331609026,
-0.0028141909,
0.0318662934,
0.0162304807,
-0.0395719893,
-0.0260038152,
0.0812038556,
0.0457292311,
-0.0219639,
0.020859668,
-0.0343567953,
-0.0285954494,
0.0395259634,
0.0470685363,
0.0193645712,
-0.0133788399,
-0.0507728532,
-0.0420871451,
-0.0352248363,
0.0632484332,
-0.0429051816,
-0.0310684107,
0.0226564873,
0.0066479314,
0.0430694222,
0.0173871033,
0.0021097779,
-0.0626238957,
0.0067970599,
-0.01191324,
-0.0224099066,
0.0129005462,
-5.664370424e-33,
-0.0204423144,
-0.0204770342,
-0.0213392861,
-0.0260118097,
0.0353197381,
-0.0184759647,
0.0042976653,
-0.0166585725,
0.0462552123,
-0.0196566675,
0.0099139111,
-0.0235551279,
0.0228813943,
0.0323065557,
0.0493490286,
-0.0100922333,
0.0470888242,
0.0014782889,
0.025978988,
0.0224634428,
0.0254934877,
0.0431050062,
0.0367769003,
-0.0496840514,
-0.0123197576,
0.0023153631,
0.0242786277,
-0.0116091827,
0.0447418392,
0.0436602533,
-0.0360962376,
0.0189286489,
0.0137830395,
-0.0581109039,
-0.011914636,
0.0188073143,
-0.0568298362,
0.0013782578,
-0.0253077447,
0.0363991074,
0.0497276634,
-0.0320536382,
-0.0155775966,
-0.009109119,
0.0281988103,
-0.0584912747,
0.024377482,
-0.0304717459,
-0.057166893,
-0.0354169235,
-0.0219000448,
0.0285288896,
0.0333473347,
0.0228080302,
0.0886771381,
0.0136439903,
0.0214825161,
0.0609585159,
-0.0379508696,
-0.0008297408,
0.014527618,
0.0129172821,
0.0476441719,
0.0100375107,
0.0343684442,
0.0512660593,
0.0530161373,
0.0121910162,
-0.0052249851,
0.0201860964,
-0.0059592403,
0.0165378619,
-0.0042036995,
0.0399063379,
0.0714182928,
0.0190993939,
-0.0553982556,
0.0392405316,
-0.0065405495,
-0.0104288859,
0.0341005176,
0.018397307,
-0.0324293077,
-0.0330474526,
-0.028671965,
-0.0089366827,
-0.032936696,
-0.0170796774,
0.0008631906,
-0.0123219592,
-0.0112466421,
-0.0139087401,
0.0619042963,
0.0036741924,
-0.0733701363,
0.0302412584,
-0.0131205339,
0.0562193654,
0.0071770996,
-0.0335383452,
0.0143186236,
-0.0320543535,
-0.0101346718,
-0.0505671017,
0.0388236865,
0.0233809613,
0.0690573454,
0.0388307124,
-0.0711006448,
0.0009595054,
-0.0142954383,
-0.0399334915,
-0.00043845,
0.0587425493,
0.0195419155,
0.0292299222,
0.0248796269,
0.0914922431,
0.0423803404,
-0.0183373075,
0.0190840978,
-0.0258616861,
-0.0167450532,
0.0031300825,
0.0297913086,
0.0345171429,
-0.0199365038,
0.0260450095,
0.0751423389,
0.0019742127,
0.0169711616,
-0.013044063,
2.605e-7,
0.0614262037,
0.0857863277,
-0.0511795357,
0.022616474,
0.0154664516,
0.0656495094,
-0.011540344,
0.0382576548,
0.0048746574,
0.0313932039,
0.0208383594,
0.01456815,
0.0848571807,
0.0528785586,
-0.0843701288,
0.0026372522,
-0.0586551912,
-0.0047857142,
-0.0505402982,
0.0128216241,
0.0663067997,
0.1288788319,
-0.0038404171,
-0.0329888128,
0.0246639419,
-0.0403328463,
0.0595057569,
-0.0476384833,
0.0167822149,
-0.0012347858,
0.0016436658,
-0.013346687,
-0.0063478947,
0.0219968315,
-0.0102614202,
-0.0000098796,
-0.0223475397,
0.0742136464,
-0.0302063078,
0.0389066152,
0.0128980139,
-0.0388608091,
-0.0068420535,
-0.0369982719,
0.0926440954,
-0.0608836114,
-0.0422155149,
-0.013072622,
-0.001070298,
-0.0147323878,
0.0350983776,
-0.0086368555,
0.0206042994,
0.0229566321,
-0.0011172895,
-0.0516522638,
-0.0052446742,
-0.076755777,
-0.0327506475,
0.0442915447,
-0.0105969338,
-0.0052835192,
-0.0126123056,
-0.0350011773,
0.0593184344,
-0.0568451583,
0.0123752644,
2.96510093e-34,
0.0323568843,
0.0094607715,
-0.0037151023,
0.0643124878,
-0.0128495041,
-0.0081292531,
0.0207599998,
0.0360227078,
0.0034475161,
-0.1003658324,
0.0412348323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11703v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11703v1 | Shaping Political Discourse using multi-source News Summarization | 2023-12-18T21:03:46 | 2023-12-18T21:03:46 | Charles Rajan, Nishit Asnani, Shreya Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.IR, cs.LG | Multi-document summarization is the process of automatically generating a
concise summary of multiple documents related to the same topic. This summary
can help users quickly understand the key information from a large collection
of documents. Multi-document summarization systems are more complex than
single-document summarization systems due to the need to identify and combine
information from multiple sources. In this paper, we have developed a machine
learning model that generates a concise summary of a topic from multiple news
documents. The model is designed to be unbiased by sampling its input equally
from all the different aspects of the topic, even if the majority of the news
sources lean one way. | [
0.0198395196,
0.0117771681,
0.0346146561,
-0.0257999692,
-0.0105460128,
0.0060810787,
-0.0407053418,
-0.0441965126,
-0.0213504806,
-0.0602176636,
0.0564453825,
0.0080495449,
-0.0006475432,
0.0078322068,
-0.0409395844,
-0.0975996926,
0.0336675532,
0.0069618253,
0.0418627076,
-0.0232086312,
0.0104314974,
0.0266196448,
-0.0019868587,
0.0258101709,
-0.0385724381,
0.0109135555,
-0.0393871106,
-0.0101009598,
0.0380330794,
0.0179281253,
-0.0255636442,
0.0139762759,
0.0041383957,
-0.0099893808,
0.0000016778,
-0.0094252396,
-0.0419497974,
-0.0322102457,
0.0482087061,
-0.0101744877,
0.0715062097,
-0.0727574006,
0.0184485465,
0.0164839532,
-0.0195584316,
0.0333525203,
0.0246059429,
0.0654713884,
0.0922382027,
0.0385269113,
-0.0092390329,
-0.0296216123,
-0.0076468093,
-0.0080476757,
-0.0205558781,
-0.0549814031,
0.0174570642,
0.0238380972,
-0.0398906209,
0.0011013014,
0.0021557685,
0.0102130314,
0.0016378722,
0.0084371595,
-0.0194964111,
0.0060883784,
-0.0294997543,
-0.0271344893,
-0.0050637973,
0.0638093576,
-0.0032469756,
-0.0148785496,
0.0554574132,
-0.0123417927,
0.0309829824,
0.0498898178,
-0.0816281065,
0.0606606565,
-0.0288965814,
0.0484856628,
0.0080675064,
0.0074117584,
-0.0118910931,
0.0484795347,
-0.0137101607,
0.0251854341,
-0.013497036,
-0.0033142008,
-0.0139572481,
0.0102354866,
0.0315212943,
-0.0389757007,
0.0114055388,
0.0083742617,
-0.0111797675,
0.0108659221,
-0.0469522253,
-0.0636628494,
0.0316344202,
-0.0853487253,
-0.0420888327,
-0.0323156156,
0.0063841012,
0.0980058536,
0.0437809825,
-0.0803081244,
-0.0026751913,
-0.0178121533,
-0.0213426519,
-0.044556696,
-0.0272523332,
0.0292323269,
0.0101128742,
0.0603009611,
-0.038056232,
-0.0262684654,
-0.0343728997,
0.0103188353,
-0.0189364348,
0.0094523244,
0.0000532889,
0.0322352126,
-0.0013593422,
-0.0206357762,
-0.0120266797,
0.0565927513,
-0.0491944216,
0.0099487351,
0.0009208138,
0.0283252373,
0.0071435058,
0.0164020509,
0.0241030846,
0.0493387133,
-0.0083256373,
0.0451106131,
-0.0173276085,
0.0168893188,
-0.0340837426,
-0.0270156711,
-0.0237026382,
-0.0266147461,
0.0260869116,
-0.0854239017,
0.0327972025,
-0.0001440713,
-0.0058696903,
-0.0184150673,
0.0000512297,
0.0186245888,
-0.0773643181,
0.0184708126,
-0.0037791042,
0.0094281351,
0.0922058225,
0.0028888478,
0.0191729236,
0.1155899987,
0.0262245312,
0.0551664606,
0.0689347461,
0.0207925551,
-0.0092207743,
-0.0108707808,
0.0168256164,
0.0252625924,
0.0330089405,
-0.0434238464,
-0.0505035147,
-0.0442790724,
0.0195807423,
0.0461283736,
-0.0036493023,
0.0418798327,
0.0399203226,
0.0288531594,
-0.0310113523,
0.0181918107,
0.016007483,
0.0596672744,
0.0402576961,
0.0454624742,
0.0254349709,
0.0367301628,
-0.020787634,
0.0351628698,
0.085618861,
0.0505509526,
-0.0378308035,
-0.0302550644,
0.0159373488,
-0.0288077258,
0.0131638646,
0.0086646909,
0.0422168747,
-0.014848846,
-0.0363789611,
0.0440715514,
0.0287149772,
-0.0518638045,
0.0348569937,
0.0008829166,
0.0247411504,
-0.0059307707,
-0.0138354376,
-0.0244545192,
0.0157620739,
-0.0534308739,
0.0484332517,
0.0137261292,
0.06378223,
-0.0330479443,
-0.0283805691,
-0.016263919,
-0.0473747365,
-0.0084941611,
0.0303432271,
0.0464544706,
-0.0244668387,
-0.0162632521,
0.023187913,
0.0179312956,
-0.020911023,
0.0271119308,
0.0030256682,
0.0029396708,
0.0039680544,
-0.0118390145,
0.0235832352,
0.0613386668,
-0.0062670861,
-0.0077084973,
0.0417860821,
0.0222289357,
-0.0365178138,
-0.0097068362,
-0.0118195638,
0.0364371389,
0.0205371957,
-0.0962954536,
-0.0053542238,
0.0160173289,
-0.0434634425,
-0.0491315536,
0.0404710472,
-0.0328276828,
-0.0417195186,
-0.001029073,
-0.0178438313,
-0.0112303216,
-0.0320478976,
-0.0297319237,
0.094462581,
0.0144403391,
-0.0034739894,
0.0450040363,
-0.0757643506,
0.0067625586,
-0.0188255422,
0.0121956784,
-0.0126220556,
-0.0104402052,
0.0338624194,
0.0534149036,
-0.049401395,
-0.011070271,
-0.0410575606,
-0.0780277327,
-0.0147205945,
-0.0203867629,
-0.0207540747,
0.0658471063,
0.0161141083,
0.0047632311,
-0.0057877372,
-0.0121891955,
-0.0562289804,
0.0019148407,
0.0040751039,
0.0022205117,
0.0183997564,
0.0525592454,
-0.0139025263,
0.005975022,
-0.0269622002,
0.0678311959,
0.0325485691,
-0.0328626931,
-0.0106232837,
-0.0102874171,
-0.022498155,
-0.0275893789,
-0.0190610625,
0.0387923606,
-0.0276773348,
0.0222453307,
0.0191266462,
0.0507744886,
0.0618691333,
0.0362295434,
0.0339528099,
0.0218778048,
-0.0509677865,
-0.0141744558,
-0.0341529213,
0.0618430339,
-0.0035404549,
-0.0348786153,
0.0508628748,
0.022161657,
0.045442462,
0.023637373,
-0.0064216862,
0.0698562935,
-0.0110693276,
-0.0018604528,
-0.0547343567,
-0.0446865559,
0.0036778951,
0.0282973964,
-0.0093256216,
-0.0050465488,
0.0352402255,
0.011777279,
0.0745960698,
-0.0347402468,
0.0028395636,
-0.0399964191,
0.0155587094,
-0.0381439701,
0.0319526009,
-0.0333139524,
0.0088197067,
-0.0305277556,
-0.04304168,
0.0809360445,
-0.0336229429,
0.087979652,
-0.0410291366,
-0.0012515623,
-0.0158032328,
-0.0071571041,
-0.025222104,
-0.0419415757,
-0.0019134717,
0.0313388854,
0.0409883596,
0.0096935108,
-0.0638102591,
0.0138819581,
0.0680950135,
0.0083500901,
-0.0206941646,
-0.0051161088,
0.0060619521,
0.0538913757,
0.0481458418,
-0.0490611456,
-0.0028901771,
-0.0331647396,
-0.0115200244,
0.0237209499,
0.0205000397,
0.0287388656,
0.0003195671,
-0.0392493121,
-0.023168264,
-0.0721054971,
0.0188081078,
-0.0338221043,
0.0238104258,
0.0085850237,
0.0574330315,
0.0792564973,
0.0288957432,
-0.0411768816,
-0.0152364708,
-0.0049860063,
-0.0446666442,
0.0046270774,
0.0229513831,
-0.0583300516,
0.0373454019,
-0.0088631706,
0.0171776172,
0.0119942278,
-0.0191408824,
-0.0024254031,
-0.0629530251,
-0.0067870086,
0.0131875835,
-0.0488624163,
-0.0445442311,
-0.0602165945,
0.007964354,
-0.0599906407,
-0.0427677557,
0.0099255554,
-0.023062136,
0.0027844573,
0.0192388613,
-0.0789116099,
-0.0296848863,
-0.0430422164,
-0.0186355263,
-0.0072283051,
0.0286147036,
0.0535498224,
-0.0256863032,
0.0456658751,
0.0189277269,
-0.0261604972,
-0.0329519659,
0.0113713406,
0.0681225359,
-0.0336714052,
0.0069504292,
0.0018977305,
0.0604504235,
0.0583359525,
-0.0111016855,
0.0241860505,
0.0112118768,
-0.0034402106,
-0.0092156241,
-0.0224142242,
0.0245819408,
0.0265181959,
0.065052256,
0.0373974293,
-0.0092704035,
0.0019824116,
-0.0460439399,
-0.0004041219,
-0.0686210319,
0.0027535502,
-0.0105957948,
-0.075753212,
-0.0381448232,
-0.0498489738,
-0.0359315574,
-0.0035486005,
-0.0053972122,
-0.0036122256,
0.0154055087,
0.0544187948,
0.0229047369,
0.0014731323,
-0.0150529006,
0.0083255954,
-0.0326234363,
0.0134477559,
-0.0612415746,
0.0282120239,
-0.004808093,
-0.0529404245,
0.0369980671,
-0.0250173528,
-0.0354277305,
-0.0050677252,
0.0159255955,
0.0228330605,
0.0420447774,
0.0062241079,
0.0136962878,
0.0472158454,
0.0447006561,
-0.0072452198,
-0.0217457134,
0.0109606795,
0.0312540941,
-0.0026969325,
-0.0008873336,
-0.0616033487,
0.0493544973,
-0.0357574821,
-0.0295023806,
-0.064128831,
-0.0345069878,
-0.0061980505,
-0.0032484799,
0.0261273663,
-0.0182366334,
-0.041036658,
-0.0415207297,
-0.0456561819,
-0.0221611355,
-0.0289310478,
-0.0048217406,
0.044748567,
0.0032086177,
-0.0492891409,
-0.0106750689,
0.0656252131,
-0.0026075402,
0.0280912705,
-0.0313254111,
-0.0034457352,
-0.0371019989,
0.0124832541,
-0.0506490506,
-0.0279861502,
-0.0478780046,
0.0104976567,
-0.0281885695,
-0.0158736818,
-0.0087940879,
-0.0300322417,
0.0131271137,
0.0126066757,
0.0379832983,
-0.010089986,
-0.0933805928,
0.0062849075,
-0.0750413984,
0.0459231995,
0.0524239726,
-0.0169077273,
0.05930987,
0.0182551313,
-0.0163492709,
-0.013974282,
0.0333283134,
0.018385781,
0.0097743049,
0.0024532117,
0.0199200045,
-0.0209421087,
0.0252676345,
0.0813302994,
-0.0383324847,
0.010710313,
0.0270463675,
-0.053713996,
-0.0478279553,
-0.0240282789,
-0.0021551598,
0.0289054289,
-0.0288375374,
-0.0524863042,
-0.0298032593,
0.0107320808,
0.0599014238,
0.0219042003,
0.0378642529,
0.0170079302,
0.0061042979,
0.0756797791,
-0.0019462808,
0.044012852,
-0.0705221295,
0.0110314116,
-0.0459930971,
-0.0186465606,
0.0285643153,
-5.532384449e-33,
-0.0502169766,
-0.023684606,
-0.0221816506,
0.0205503143,
0.003049013,
0.0062508341,
-0.0311246794,
0.002834308,
-0.0235086158,
0.0046390854,
0.0097594904,
0.0130797429,
0.0335649736,
0.0178883839,
0.0143276164,
0.0323563442,
0.0277408268,
-0.008916989,
-0.019428486,
0.0391554087,
0.0351485834,
-0.0006137516,
0.0212276168,
-0.057528723,
0.0143230949,
-0.0111452285,
-0.0364657491,
-0.0662462562,
0.0642925203,
0.0271230731,
0.0066923145,
-0.0076810312,
0.0401677042,
-0.0382255614,
-0.0438379832,
0.0621579662,
-0.0579993427,
-0.0252072681,
0.0367428809,
-0.0518568493,
-0.0232880544,
-0.0246855244,
0.0469665304,
-0.0019978816,
0.0256174318,
-0.0269384049,
0.0945407897,
-0.0444558188,
-0.0394030102,
-0.0887714997,
-0.0012394452,
0.0395421274,
-0.0405307524,
0.002745697,
-0.0186272878,
0.0614535585,
0.049351152,
0.0142140519,
-0.038412448,
0.0505067036,
0.0050358782,
0.0252446719,
0.0491465367,
-0.0379589573,
-0.0075847232,
0.0704598948,
-0.0198017508,
-0.0177492872,
-0.0610032752,
-0.0366113745,
-0.0133484993,
0.0166203082,
0.0056245108,
0.0612611361,
0.0056075435,
-0.0235362295,
-0.0864108577,
0.0810274035,
0.0417383611,
0.0042881635,
0.0163133144,
-0.0291193333,
0.0332557634,
-0.0012289549,
-0.0334341936,
-0.0493257828,
0.0019734153,
-0.0254869759,
-0.0485048294,
0.0448996536,
-0.0519657694,
0.0528359413,
0.0130438302,
-0.0573892109,
0.016834639,
0.0652426109,
-0.0309883617,
0.0244544316,
-0.0064144628,
-0.0239210967,
-0.0407109037,
-0.0055369027,
0.0035712186,
0.0255150497,
-0.0111053474,
0.0013899691,
0.0384873375,
-0.0316140689,
-0.0409049131,
0.0143388798,
0.0296067949,
-0.0019614948,
-0.0387182757,
0.0261751786,
0.010637166,
0.0119030513,
0.01706996,
-0.0150209675,
-0.0062490683,
0.0128729017,
0.0229478572,
-0.047965318,
-0.0188302565,
0.0222986974,
-0.0175027642,
-0.0082352469,
-0.0161923971,
0.0217293035,
0.05201203,
-0.0006242517,
-0.0139041534,
0.0020845537,
2.28e-7,
0.0543338545,
0.0401083976,
0.0196629446,
0.0086087119,
-0.0222627856,
0.0237983,
-0.0058880108,
0.0619836561,
-0.0334858671,
-0.0628016591,
0.0045414227,
0.0224947259,
0.0027299612,
0.0512791276,
-0.1049437076,
-0.0407126509,
-0.0586059466,
-0.0170949977,
-0.0414985605,
-0.0007179386,
-0.0050179935,
0.0221771579,
0.0205638874,
-0.013543536,
-0.0274347924,
0.0083914604,
0.0488763973,
-0.0073169195,
-0.074306041,
0.0282908622,
0.0790274888,
-0.0188773256,
0.0019071775,
0.0165740643,
-0.0173164513,
-0.0168454144,
0.0231398176,
0.0536459237,
0.0301531889,
0.0015345106,
0.0149951167,
-0.015295295,
0.0246667471,
0.0213257316,
0.0675920323,
-0.0678514242,
-0.0075560873,
-0.0886241794,
-0.0653416812,
0.0356002972,
0.0300729629,
0.0163077638,
-0.0076630437,
0.0528499894,
-0.0338009447,
0.001663344,
0.0256764125,
-0.023497561,
-0.0211823396,
0.0172479507,
-0.0146985995,
-0.0373381265,
0.0293400455,
-0.0414458551,
0.0466974489,
-0.0591217987,
0.0273968708,
1.541420576e-34,
0.0838808343,
-0.0062152199,
-0.0513954572,
-0.0288269054,
0.010531256,
-0.0268130377,
-0.0485800579,
-0.0120090675,
-0.0306989141,
-0.0373370275,
-0.0040277722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11701v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11701v1 | Opportunities and Challenges of Applying Large Language Models in Building Energy Efficiency and Decarbonization Studies: An Exploratory Overview | 2023-12-18T20:58:58 | 2023-12-18T20:58:58 | Liang Zhang, Zhelun Chen | eess.SY | eess.SY, cs.CL, cs.SY | In recent years, the rapid advancement and impressive capabilities of Large
Language Models (LLMs) have been evident across various domains. This paper
explores the application, implications, and potential of LLMs in building
energy efficiency and decarbonization studies. The wide-ranging capabilities of
LLMs are examined in the context of the building energy field, including
intelligent control systems, code generation, data infrastructure, knowledge
extraction, and education. Despite the promising potential of LLMs, challenges
including complex and expensive computation, data privacy, security and
copyright, complexity in fine-tuned LLMs, and self-consistency are discussed.
The paper concludes with a call for future research focused on the enhancement
of LLMs for domain-specific tasks, multi-modal LLMs, and collaborative research
between AI and energy experts. | [
-0.0297005158,
0.1260054857,
-0.0132133383,
0.0727998763,
-0.0332635641,
-0.0150516201,
0.0377587341,
-0.007680872,
0.0161673408,
-0.0359902307,
-0.0338000171,
0.0324303992,
-0.0085197873,
0.0226256996,
0.0432283804,
0.0389723964,
0.0217934828,
-0.0390520021,
0.0226244386,
-0.0083416561,
-0.0307468921,
-0.0217708088,
0.044765234,
0.0245762169,
-0.0379048251,
-0.0204873979,
-0.033078514,
-0.0120891873,
-0.0029382701,
-0.0060445606,
0.0071771247,
0.0528704785,
0.0344461687,
0.0698276237,
0.0000021589,
-0.0229181275,
-0.0908671096,
0.0392465517,
0.0210868474,
-0.0123713827,
0.0686600953,
-0.002574096,
-0.0097512612,
-0.0189753212,
-0.0263309311,
-0.0082770651,
0.0792411044,
-0.0200116225,
0.0145239038,
0.0264945906,
0.0031149676,
-0.0443901122,
-0.0024480699,
-0.0287849847,
-0.038858667,
0.0250654612,
0.0482042804,
0.052108027,
-0.0027951456,
-0.0119319633,
-0.011606737,
0.0358464904,
-0.0090526463,
-0.013076161,
-0.0110417595,
-0.0203641132,
-0.0128846811,
0.0403467901,
-0.030364668,
0.0184129272,
0.0233562645,
-0.0098354071,
0.0450588502,
-0.0096638044,
-0.0398626551,
0.0079841828,
-0.0377582051,
0.0176422521,
0.0223677326,
0.0026466649,
-0.0203890726,
-0.0040849326,
0.0382257439,
0.0184674263,
-0.0232938584,
0.1143287346,
-0.0112223597,
-0.0129695591,
-0.0169138219,
0.0271610767,
0.0234095529,
-0.0460092761,
0.001213421,
0.0178784188,
0.027867876,
0.0335538909,
-0.0122268582,
0.0292113591,
0.0263452455,
-0.0405008793,
0.0188445784,
-0.0063083516,
0.0546886548,
0.0138221681,
0.0196570382,
0.074201189,
-0.0472358502,
-0.0123015698,
-0.038540028,
-0.0092916191,
-0.0336470194,
-0.0123742716,
-0.039669022,
0.0437037237,
-0.0520105585,
0.011733206,
-0.0232624784,
0.0334836282,
-0.0541354157,
0.0614902228,
-0.0208352711,
-0.0196327884,
0.0445277989,
-0.043091204,
0.0192881823,
-0.0170175415,
0.0196660962,
0.0071067987,
-0.0338649414,
-0.0679357722,
0.0360724591,
0.0014406996,
-0.0346426442,
0.010192154,
-0.0264569484,
0.0538547672,
0.0274717696,
0.0078274272,
0.004062057,
-0.0914794952,
0.0495521799,
-0.0408567451,
0.0121811805,
-0.0765260309,
-0.033899013,
-0.0379914343,
0.0052843248,
-0.0593287423,
-0.0233785957,
-0.0318327397,
-0.0192705858,
0.0559922718,
-0.0970998481,
0.0246974118,
0.0450867675,
0.0053842287,
-0.0014899744,
0.0567301102,
0.0513208918,
0.0139489947,
0.0151434634,
-0.016048912,
0.0359116867,
0.0186591372,
0.0233021397,
-0.0043550311,
-0.0329143777,
0.0043374877,
0.0235435069,
-0.0418733992,
-0.0495144241,
0.0417541564,
0.0430045873,
-0.0002807656,
0.0679812506,
0.0238110386,
0.0012625685,
0.0169378743,
-0.0150370914,
0.0743523389,
0.0091348793,
-0.0276244059,
-0.0158587098,
-0.0172464661,
-0.0465412624,
-0.0112448828,
-0.0162837692,
0.0314526744,
0.0185921118,
-0.0522929169,
-0.0050110593,
-0.0503203087,
-0.0005162746,
0.0459573306,
0.0530701652,
-0.0105803199,
-0.0069724661,
0.0375995226,
0.0213251114,
-0.0052129184,
-0.0217494313,
-0.0823095068,
-0.0284999292,
0.063337639,
0.0184594281,
-0.0077936323,
0.0427577458,
-0.0173825771,
-0.0175401662,
-0.0208366942,
0.0294475071,
-0.011641548,
0.0359222591,
-0.00296997,
-0.0368465036,
-0.0423325449,
0.0226753075,
0.0061058342,
-0.0603755191,
-0.0217502639,
-0.008313478,
0.0070094471,
-0.0285735168,
0.0176073443,
-0.0106868213,
-0.0023105368,
-0.0483343787,
0.0291287955,
0.0152445696,
0.0129447328,
-0.0286860485,
-0.0029153228,
0.0479782596,
-0.027155092,
-0.0707088113,
-0.0191590488,
-0.049799379,
0.0766983479,
0.0419131406,
0.0372135155,
0.0505993068,
0.0169195179,
-0.0400167108,
-0.0232561603,
0.0236190818,
-0.0515897498,
0.0727113709,
-0.0356778502,
0.0285489652,
-0.0639530495,
-0.0198785774,
-0.032607574,
0.0600392744,
-0.0086591346,
0.0127084106,
-0.0051073176,
0.0114738699,
0.0194707029,
-0.0002186731,
-0.017685296,
-0.0017668668,
-0.0292335488,
0.0243420806,
0.0198120233,
0.0112479441,
0.0387491994,
0.0578722507,
-0.058145266,
-0.0180633962,
0.0045824186,
0.0464882143,
0.0080835633,
-0.0424357168,
-0.0130569283,
0.0136031993,
0.0000540512,
0.0266205668,
-0.0344139524,
-0.0210821237,
0.0109225707,
-0.0097851893,
-0.1024899781,
-0.0257847384,
-0.0333052203,
0.0106257945,
0.0628712028,
0.0256054122,
0.0053963871,
-0.0377946571,
0.0628704503,
0.0429364704,
0.0118817464,
-0.0006193297,
-0.0449151061,
-0.0274144579,
-0.0055415519,
0.0311371293,
-0.0099117858,
-0.0023279048,
-0.0075063398,
0.0526500084,
-0.0532951728,
-0.0646871552,
0.0027456847,
0.0045554456,
-0.0082714511,
-0.0284017902,
-0.005647792,
0.0588321649,
0.0400025845,
-0.0153602399,
0.0068811681,
0.0409144647,
0.0531819053,
-0.0160891544,
-0.0461441278,
-0.0182591882,
-0.0020934476,
0.0249857381,
0.0858641341,
0.0318144895,
-0.078112103,
0.071368061,
-0.0839504451,
0.0120955212,
-0.0088726291,
-0.032953918,
-0.0392169915,
0.0265285838,
0.0037637486,
0.0469661243,
-0.0002209038,
0.0059608715,
-0.0015270244,
-0.0476358645,
0.0008469262,
0.0037446637,
0.0467336699,
-0.0466733724,
-0.0042590681,
0.0018315059,
-0.0835208148,
0.0042377985,
0.0253868327,
-0.0416706502,
-0.0125137102,
0.015214189,
-0.0325517282,
-0.0129842293,
0.0159601457,
0.0311430376,
0.0206567384,
0.0093735689,
-0.0023545963,
-0.0034132896,
-0.0057804859,
-0.0111495154,
-0.0083917445,
-0.0046822405,
-0.000372254,
0.0005756677,
0.0450399518,
-0.025249226,
0.0290024001,
-0.0526204854,
0.0122118527,
0.0281434283,
0.0275821239,
-0.0087665413,
0.0201145466,
0.0040568006,
-0.0693530068,
0.0265490133,
0.0367302001,
-0.0269820932,
-0.004514744,
0.0151424212,
-0.0356088802,
-0.0061072679,
-0.0316950418,
-0.0105018625,
-0.0945846066,
0.0010730455,
0.0493735783,
0.0711692274,
-0.0337482728,
-0.0147652067,
-0.0307889991,
-0.0311350673,
0.0396087617,
-0.004402081,
0.0046216561,
-0.0473351292,
-0.0154002905,
0.0230927058,
-0.0161586311,
-0.0686656758,
-0.0246617757,
0.0022274046,
-0.025499355,
0.0215353221,
-0.0616256334,
-0.0371827893,
-0.0356670655,
-0.0366839543,
0.0534427688,
0.089896962,
0.0395877101,
0.0151369032,
0.0009830815,
-0.0019123885,
0.001335892,
-0.0020829644,
-0.0523159206,
-0.0750624612,
0.0811771899,
0.0136961751,
0.0182501338,
0.0341940969,
-0.0236660279,
-0.0208063759,
0.0569717176,
0.0706881583,
-0.0602588058,
-0.0197263658,
-0.0291763172,
-0.0095166704,
0.0757757202,
0.0361582488,
-0.0205027852,
0.0046837637,
-0.0805330053,
-0.0523876511,
-0.0315142013,
-0.0140149361,
0.0046265433,
-0.0239507537,
-0.0441853553,
-0.0337143019,
0.0032710286,
0.024255313,
-0.0311725475,
0.000614427,
0.0019860996,
-0.016127374,
0.094103165,
0.0110080224,
-0.0421844125,
-0.0440972596,
-0.0613277368,
0.0270103198,
-0.0486853719,
-0.0307942238,
0.0747667998,
-0.0110774906,
0.0124054048,
-0.0069592185,
-0.0743907541,
-0.0577144027,
0.0437399782,
0.0847919881,
0.0183368344,
0.0170852318,
0.033199802,
0.0116223935,
0.0104389247,
0.0095637878,
-0.0407548398,
0.0148184747,
0.0146002015,
0.0279472265,
0.01366603,
0.0237028301,
-0.0325713232,
0.0468649492,
0.0083584012,
0.0136014661,
-0.0449573025,
0.0120161651,
0.0210486129,
0.0678274855,
-0.0504833497,
0.0089653023,
0.0097019523,
0.0179591291,
-0.0044416194,
-0.0178679563,
-0.0054868408,
-0.0732587203,
-0.0192451943,
0.0001631041,
0.0203364622,
0.0265408885,
0.0749180764,
0.0505096912,
-0.0083903726,
-0.0001687626,
0.0462542288,
-0.0023662045,
0.0720921755,
0.0437557399,
0.0177391022,
0.0212913398,
0.0380547568,
0.0079982998,
-0.003956276,
-0.0090532973,
-0.0114345821,
0.0337448046,
-0.0076444759,
-0.0660469681,
0.0352004431,
0.022836104,
-0.0664013922,
0.0196961723,
-0.0011236782,
0.0203322843,
0.1127612889,
-0.0149752358,
-0.0766077265,
0.0196473338,
-0.0184517335,
0.0332531855,
0.0054595848,
-0.0102393795,
0.0047866921,
0.030945655,
-0.0661945343,
-0.0187076237,
0.0595814809,
0.0510833114,
0.0178761445,
-0.0505172089,
-0.0572475828,
-0.0467937998,
-0.0023199501,
-0.0102697853,
-0.0261103939,
-0.0245301537,
-0.057726603,
-0.0661596656,
0.002973126,
0.0034839592,
0.0194337182,
0.0394037068,
-0.0098664379,
0.0503378399,
0.0549211502,
0.0137072196,
-0.0517019965,
-0.0221904293,
-0.0223364085,
-0.0116531318,
0.0010219483,
0.0207437277,
-6.371737741e-33,
0.0103657385,
-0.0914769471,
0.0144289462,
0.0296855811,
-0.0044354619,
-0.0017295101,
0.0144112715,
-0.0376196131,
-0.0135435555,
-0.0314128436,
-0.0024144128,
0.0013402934,
0.0131266108,
0.0036650309,
0.0486261472,
0.0224402361,
0.0432905443,
-0.0188006684,
-0.005685993,
-0.0033865597,
0.0579682626,
0.0155862998,
0.0053133378,
-0.0782505646,
0.019769704,
-0.0142429294,
-0.0201188885,
0.0045582,
-0.0091431653,
-0.0148669649,
-0.0183680709,
0.0491473339,
0.0198116526,
-0.0087355617,
-0.035383556,
0.0594286472,
-0.0438206941,
0.0078154439,
-0.0117664225,
0.0231302418,
0.0535472445,
-0.0703388676,
0.0485800244,
0.0186800994,
-0.0602209829,
0.0172199439,
-0.0016254216,
-0.0209925026,
0.0318375751,
-0.0064484961,
-0.0597362779,
-0.0059941034,
-0.0125932842,
0.0508838072,
0.0335805267,
-0.0074391561,
0.0091659212,
0.0436476544,
-0.0637026206,
0.0326207094,
0.0773814768,
0.0035087799,
0.0729217231,
0.0230210144,
-0.000604571,
0.0156096453,
0.0191365667,
-0.0075755012,
-0.0323737301,
-0.0136639969,
0.0384140126,
0.0777908191,
-0.0048897355,
0.0295742434,
0.0041728425,
-0.0055575361,
-0.0607934557,
-0.0238558482,
0.0118333912,
0.0338747799,
0.0126591083,
0.0048362333,
0.0434587263,
-0.0320938975,
-0.00853692,
0.0422416255,
-0.0110485666,
-0.0051678782,
-0.0121409353,
-0.0046972302,
-0.0273114722,
-0.0056373221,
0.0032701669,
-0.0505223051,
-0.0208280385,
0.0641990975,
0.0126409335,
-0.0162206311,
0.0124016507,
0.0509057492,
-0.0692912638,
-0.035517361,
-0.027654523,
0.0230004564,
0.0256777722,
-0.0007968086,
-0.0453062803,
0.0673735589,
0.013913596,
0.0198549535,
0.0041793068,
-0.0435114764,
0.0258286111,
-0.0317243449,
0.0301558841,
-0.0251457933,
0.033722233,
0.0344003253,
-0.0377320088,
0.0003501328,
-0.0017142799,
0.0327773578,
-0.0445659161,
0.0305274241,
0.0192942489,
-0.0282600746,
-0.0901315138,
-0.0441844836,
0.0434182659,
-0.0092850691,
-0.0344231799,
0.0176931936,
3.016e-7,
-0.0193679258,
0.0354318433,
0.0007139252,
0.0061160424,
-0.0267361142,
0.0499884151,
-0.037829373,
-0.0093894061,
-0.0446633026,
0.0211859122,
-0.0027041268,
-0.0460933745,
0.0733390525,
0.0065556779,
-0.0285593886,
-0.012426246,
-0.0283692367,
0.0129197212,
-0.0804719254,
-0.0543571189,
0.0348516963,
0.0200314149,
0.0247397572,
0.0006013972,
0.0063421,
-0.0338607803,
-0.0020009717,
-0.0550292954,
0.0032190285,
0.0279054102,
0.0068443706,
0.0243233424,
0.0233426038,
-0.064650178,
-0.0029510551,
0.0255465936,
-0.0262140892,
0.0686281174,
0.0495296493,
0.004290266,
0.0299135502,
-0.0649492666,
-0.0253979061,
-0.0010287347,
0.0138616227,
-0.0163882524,
-0.0243333951,
0.0141972294,
-0.016899135,
-0.0482180417,
-0.0537240915,
-0.0202981979,
0.0197275318,
-0.0142204501,
-0.0228647459,
-0.0307396855,
0.0053282771,
0.0222049039,
0.0633425117,
-0.0395494998,
-0.0491608717,
-0.0194881372,
-0.0359108038,
0.0021746901,
0.0121599529,
0.0231156405,
0.0444786772,
2.587711683e-34,
-0.0254467651,
-0.0708621144,
-0.0328332968,
0.0344532207,
0.0094193425,
0.0331191495,
-0.045107998,
0.021705091,
-0.0355673544,
-0.063337788,
0.0134083135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11681v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11681v3 | Designing LLM Chains by Adapting Techniques from Crowdsourcing Workflows | 2023-12-18T20:01:58 | 2024-05-06T18:18:46 | Madeleine Grunde-McLaughlin, Michelle S. Lam, Ranjay Krishna, Daniel S. Weld, Jeffrey Heer | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | LLM chains enable complex tasks by decomposing work into a sequence of
subtasks. Similarly, the more established techniques of crowdsourcing workflows
decompose complex tasks into smaller tasks for human crowdworkers. Chains
address LLM errors analogously to the way crowdsourcing workflows address human
error. To characterize opportunities for LLM chaining, we survey 107 papers
across the crowdsourcing and chaining literature to construct a design space
for chain development. The design space covers a designer's objectives and the
tactics used to build workflows. We then surface strategies that mediate how
workflows use tactics to achieve objectives. To explore how techniques from
crowdsourcing may apply to chaining, we adapt crowdsourcing workflows to
implement LLM chains across three case studies: creating a taxonomy, shortening
text, and writing a short story. From the design space and our case studies, we
identify takeaways for effective chain design and raise implications for future
research and development. | [
0.0521586873,
0.0566195957,
-0.0234594848,
0.0026772642,
-0.0638154447,
-0.0218306947,
0.0168194175,
0.0389785245,
-0.0123693896,
-0.0055535813,
-0.0105004888,
0.0403917246,
0.0054115541,
0.0092787314,
-0.005179829,
-0.0452728942,
-0.035391435,
-0.0323313847,
-0.0479386523,
0.0051434995,
0.0102435723,
-0.0133402515,
-0.0117547493,
0.0325506814,
-0.0046317545,
0.025299903,
-0.0540804155,
0.053129144,
0.0226243772,
-0.035304036,
-0.0030198833,
0.0523345321,
-0.0317290276,
0.0066735824,
0.0000020914,
-0.0552540347,
0.0274563637,
0.0281493738,
-0.0643890351,
-0.0048295548,
-0.0113687003,
0.0132798944,
-0.0060413675,
0.0095718456,
0.0334750488,
-0.002501026,
0.0477864705,
0.0240929853,
0.0312239174,
-0.0291302651,
0.0143902674,
0.0375889689,
0.0083394852,
0.0062387311,
0.0324247368,
-0.007260473,
0.0142954299,
-0.0230637994,
0.0873755589,
-0.0008116651,
0.0539390557,
0.009559975,
-0.0032271491,
0.0103397351,
0.0540607646,
-0.0113909934,
0.0042011268,
-0.0630880743,
-0.0271735154,
0.0428552218,
0.0502611846,
-0.011424535,
0.0321631879,
-0.0216304772,
0.02125418,
0.0262067895,
-0.0349415988,
0.0396784134,
-0.0361021161,
-0.0216201246,
-0.0698883086,
0.0364998616,
0.0062424871,
-0.014851341,
0.0433976427,
0.0089119272,
-0.0371046104,
-0.0080192741,
-0.0270593967,
0.0403275527,
0.0648775697,
-0.0399704948,
0.0467755981,
0.009231939,
-0.014026762,
-0.0222033039,
0.0497518517,
-0.0088493833,
0.0485415198,
-0.0014294737,
0.0161648076,
-0.0472403876,
0.0069188136,
0.0211527739,
0.0179182421,
-0.0396986343,
-0.0328014791,
0.0025852555,
-0.0325483754,
0.0035677522,
-0.0495240912,
0.0319409594,
-0.0147542171,
0.0282727554,
-0.0366959684,
0.0522121228,
-0.0024367149,
0.0166082662,
-0.0214534272,
0.0560616851,
0.0500920787,
0.0467498116,
-0.0080266763,
-0.0365078971,
-0.0406015106,
-0.0614013113,
-0.0319303721,
0.0487700514,
0.0132900774,
0.0052313842,
0.0165746436,
-0.0072971135,
0.0320525393,
0.0021692263,
0.0326646939,
0.0589529388,
0.0458523594,
0.0376477838,
-0.0899197757,
-0.0824184343,
0.0593673848,
0.0089246314,
-0.021940751,
-0.088054359,
0.0122188032,
0.0128614148,
-0.0050356402,
0.0357318297,
-0.0158701632,
-0.0102433451,
-0.0506897345,
0.0240954682,
-0.0423310585,
0.0332175344,
0.0319060981,
0.0562742054,
0.0096228039,
0.0226839539,
0.0512144193,
0.0540653318,
0.0830255896,
0.0057820249,
0.0823378488,
0.0433522463,
-0.0663015768,
0.0121481596,
0.0756496191,
0.0363998786,
-0.0500787161,
0.020492563,
0.009333902,
0.0035800908,
-0.0158816352,
0.1021296158,
0.0469964035,
0.0423320979,
0.0006539754,
-0.0211772826,
-0.027927177,
0.0366422385,
-0.0042295987,
-0.025917599,
0.0127412332,
0.0596895255,
-0.005256535,
-0.0116680069,
-0.0349939466,
0.0409305803,
-0.0517677888,
-0.0230295081,
-0.0309188943,
-0.008306833,
-0.014645665,
0.011030009,
0.0018623058,
0.0514531918,
-0.022621436,
0.0081500225,
-0.0455443338,
-0.0802004114,
-0.0241481084,
-0.0368910171,
-0.0124556059,
0.0640268698,
0.0304804649,
-0.0133100748,
0.0167120192,
-0.0119850403,
0.0207721423,
0.0036473805,
-0.0186405443,
-0.0141210975,
-0.0654558912,
-0.0096758818,
-0.0404112004,
0.047337316,
-0.0267769489,
-0.0182701387,
0.0140202278,
-0.0270264242,
-0.0310652629,
-0.0276054684,
-0.0448177978,
0.0133315697,
-0.0138100134,
-0.0141210947,
0.0011032986,
0.0263196193,
0.034712825,
0.0322327763,
0.0312530734,
-0.0069049709,
0.049990546,
-0.0036898048,
-0.0706382468,
0.0080774557,
0.0473397225,
0.077578783,
-0.0646794885,
-0.0608044527,
0.0112786237,
-0.0000424491,
-0.0475809537,
0.0054881535,
-0.0195606314,
0.0250521451,
-0.0348382667,
0.0263385866,
0.0057734917,
0.0121004125,
-0.0628874078,
-0.0261344966,
0.012127216,
-0.0119430143,
0.01229442,
-0.0713156536,
-0.0061619803,
0.0062076785,
0.0102910548,
0.0415059663,
0.0338952206,
0.0280122757,
0.0491015315,
0.0255375039,
0.0288586933,
-0.0492257513,
-0.0429434963,
-0.0205281656,
-0.001011449,
0.0082447138,
0.0591547936,
-0.017176643,
-0.0051375856,
-0.009992132,
-0.0122239776,
-0.0015652531,
0.0285056327,
0.020672733,
-0.0078428304,
0.0195896551,
0.0447305851,
-0.0201156102,
0.0169501491,
0.0151838558,
0.0263605285,
0.0166086704,
0.0264787618,
-0.0604817569,
-0.1123344302,
0.0024891307,
0.0012415716,
-0.0259353183,
0.0352685489,
0.0053922981,
0.0070560854,
0.0508495905,
0.0174065605,
-0.0284113884,
-0.033232972,
0.0296906028,
0.0366111435,
-0.0389114581,
0.0245396942,
-0.0076566744,
0.0299434029,
-0.0613694973,
0.015580453,
-0.027967168,
0.020817114,
0.0062902914,
-0.0275948551,
0.005264217,
0.0077829333,
-0.0210622139,
0.0204650313,
-0.0047840988,
-0.013868263,
-0.0872018933,
-0.04249781,
0.0897074789,
-0.0208849479,
-0.0375047065,
0.0244476385,
-0.0055911583,
0.013882895,
0.0177561305,
-0.0441752821,
-0.0648274571,
0.0739530921,
0.0029012577,
-0.0029772222,
0.0047186082,
0.0207979344,
-0.0394446701,
0.0662986562,
0.0161016174,
-0.0385429487,
0.0057497518,
-0.048065722,
-0.0656462684,
-0.0295175705,
-0.0614817776,
-0.0158110596,
0.034022186,
-0.0446666256,
-0.0161945168,
0.0382951945,
-0.0051318607,
0.0170873646,
-0.0180223603,
0.0507173352,
0.007681448,
0.0493753888,
-0.0322138853,
-0.0125355581,
0.0343289673,
-0.0450824834,
-0.0095855119,
0.0041303579,
0.0044883629,
-0.0527321361,
0.0593089648,
0.0619351454,
-0.0327510014,
0.0179862473,
-0.0423034728,
0.0812188089,
-0.0267809685,
-0.0237333886,
0.0026146825,
0.0337249599,
-0.0070564579,
0.0053342166,
0.0011050224,
0.0239629894,
-0.0639233515,
0.0317046307,
-0.0077438299,
0.0419192091,
0.0315136015,
0.0440106653,
-0.0748027116,
0.0148854023,
0.0062044361,
0.0385998264,
-0.0566786267,
-0.0350811034,
-0.0081979232,
-0.0548234396,
0.0876690298,
-0.0124530392,
0.0098082442,
0.0608422905,
-0.0755412057,
0.0234090518,
0.0203739721,
-0.040453285,
0.0176416785,
-0.0294542052,
-0.0158294067,
0.0257258639,
-0.0314665437,
-0.005096321,
-0.0042903186,
-0.0366042107,
0.029158704,
0.0428891666,
0.0021591387,
-0.0301805828,
-0.0584352575,
0.0651396438,
0.0054022931,
0.0214475431,
-0.0012671967,
0.0342924781,
0.0155611048,
-0.0032368216,
-0.0238934234,
-0.0072449283,
-0.0975810289,
-0.0300954375,
0.0546398498,
0.0587478392,
0.0231837947,
-0.0233160127,
0.0044781812,
-0.0483015329,
0.0176163744,
0.0170725267,
-0.0032800313,
-0.0633333176,
-0.0106933834,
-0.0321466215,
-0.0124992728,
-0.0249497034,
-0.0458086282,
-0.0182579402,
-0.0062572281,
0.0080406945,
-0.0389184095,
-0.024351038,
0.0048613674,
0.0300258361,
0.0110836495,
-0.0085352128,
0.003491261,
0.0286251344,
-0.0081734778,
-0.0122513026,
-0.0047962693,
0.0056133904,
-0.0686376467,
0.0234278012,
-0.0644667894,
-0.0164883342,
0.0057158214,
0.0609024838,
-0.1252931803,
0.0153065585,
0.001026142,
0.0601341762,
0.0366734304,
-0.0371300913,
0.0145633146,
-0.0629317239,
-0.0505891219,
0.0944853649,
0.0032757556,
0.0273547806,
-0.0260685198,
0.0149598373,
-0.0158975814,
-0.0573016517,
-0.0639405996,
-0.0116643701,
0.0382700302,
-0.0114222625,
-0.0376870185,
-0.0418037921,
-0.0130927451,
0.04533213,
0.0049171816,
-0.0358947292,
-0.0362859629,
0.0195520055,
0.0477961861,
0.059692204,
-0.0299998261,
-0.0352598727,
0.0098246159,
-0.0673872307,
-0.0417716987,
0.052526243,
0.0618258603,
-0.0016313482,
0.0199730322,
-0.0285671391,
0.0439767316,
0.0107715661,
0.0587550402,
0.0304567441,
0.015419065,
-0.0026221031,
-0.0120890075,
0.0116652707,
0.0332444608,
0.0355763286,
-0.023686748,
-0.0005768682,
0.0290812105,
0.0006336437,
0.0647971705,
-0.0314494632,
-0.0780059844,
0.0010226355,
-0.0007241882,
0.0145275807,
0.0303073227,
0.0129117118,
-0.0256441161,
-0.010815002,
-0.0241865665,
-0.000861309,
-0.0449465103,
0.0153281353,
-0.0586409271,
0.0237210207,
-0.0262721181,
-0.0244511571,
0.027293954,
-0.0123758037,
-0.0291193686,
-0.0438007191,
-0.042277474,
-0.0348267369,
-0.0321391225,
-0.0260803327,
-0.0252119135,
-0.0090063876,
-0.070511654,
-0.0844771639,
-0.0129914582,
-0.0138574271,
0.0007586438,
0.0394648723,
-0.0128021827,
0.038159892,
0.0015174734,
-0.0072296984,
-0.0094402134,
-0.0031293274,
-0.034167245,
0.0014142218,
-0.0259519108,
0.0281059742,
-6.021419486e-33,
0.0272485204,
-0.1125634983,
0.0466326289,
0.0480889976,
0.0367577858,
0.0001560542,
-0.0039593312,
0.047381267,
0.0516162217,
0.0254773702,
-0.0122105433,
-0.0567062125,
0.0150006721,
-0.0475688502,
0.0668426007,
0.0268701836,
0.0431375802,
0.0106206257,
-0.0238065999,
-0.0021091616,
-0.0219131075,
0.0031197281,
-0.0029597313,
-0.0510826185,
0.0428431444,
-0.0433305651,
-0.0341425426,
0.0458505526,
0.0009600362,
0.0258753039,
0.015790578,
0.034852244,
0.0091078188,
-0.0043602693,
0.0060906135,
0.0056075444,
-0.0722392946,
0.0258025676,
0.0032052838,
-0.0302097406,
-0.061089728,
-0.0131979603,
0.0397043079,
0.0424657278,
-0.0416853204,
0.0285146125,
0.0195864812,
0.0021774101,
0.0016450268,
0.0110149588,
-0.0052419771,
-0.0147689609,
0.03202378,
-0.001654266,
0.0053971829,
-0.002014898,
0.0051431162,
0.0140643679,
-0.0971835703,
0.0054966691,
-0.0347142629,
-0.0357229486,
0.0349327661,
-0.0118795363,
-0.0187987685,
0.0127080958,
-0.0487661622,
0.0688522831,
-0.0285428651,
-0.0064683869,
-0.0486390442,
0.0902095214,
0.0725579858,
0.0435870886,
0.0133784516,
-0.0071479394,
0.0073901801,
0.0552585833,
-0.0594973154,
0.02052854,
-0.0248033702,
-0.0068703573,
-0.0114614889,
-0.0009478375,
0.0195188224,
-0.0255786236,
-0.0226045083,
0.0331819355,
-0.0267978348,
0.011165984,
0.0142092565,
-0.0085307555,
-0.0153927179,
0.0322749577,
-0.0524968617,
-0.0296662152,
0.0526580326,
0.0480375178,
0.0147371357,
-0.033512868,
-0.0332239233,
0.0021253298,
-0.0543164499,
0.0600470528,
0.0404358767,
0.0060736844,
0.0308524873,
-0.0111959185,
-0.0601534136,
0.0338881239,
-0.0247220993,
0.0477071963,
0.0048898938,
-0.085040316,
-0.0214939974,
-0.0126816649,
0.0264012665,
0.0005729729,
-0.0108714737,
-0.0665368885,
0.009190416,
0.0872588754,
-0.0770187378,
-0.0142896809,
0.0203360021,
0.0054501579,
-0.0042908345,
0.0315381289,
0.0739082322,
0.0147359166,
-0.0336849019,
-0.0088691609,
2.807e-7,
0.0024718978,
0.0007188844,
0.0080817984,
0.0389694646,
0.0285215136,
0.0257437192,
-0.0194831807,
0.0022570342,
-0.0276463944,
-0.0493742004,
0.0300367158,
0.0003970695,
0.0513397232,
0.0245817136,
-0.105317533,
-0.0776636451,
0.002785272,
0.0649696589,
-0.0060681277,
-0.0175277591,
0.0159730092,
-0.0712899715,
0.039914012,
-0.026465686,
-0.0289091654,
0.0170847494,
-0.0067754122,
-0.0498210303,
0.0533287413,
0.034630578,
-0.000796855,
-0.0447410718,
0.0132297678,
0.0118499007,
-0.0236587413,
-0.087903142,
0.0025753668,
0.0172143038,
0.011220905,
0.0092298128,
-0.0187944565,
-0.0461317413,
0.0143430633,
-0.0115268463,
-0.0263097603,
0.017685581,
0.0026988734,
0.0195423737,
0.0079528345,
-0.0230012592,
-0.00410194,
0.0186925866,
0.0348998047,
0.0235546622,
0.0025679958,
0.0016406768,
-0.0234357957,
-0.0170272812,
0.027132133,
0.0034000138,
-0.002974184,
-0.0536774658,
0.0033134134,
0.0406935997,
-0.0310528874,
0.0116092926,
-0.0221755002,
2.233241131e-34,
-0.0229950193,
-0.0184055213,
0.0184218064,
0.0506014563,
0.0112295123,
0.0011373861,
-0.045581691,
0.0000863795,
0.0134342229,
0.01681168,
-0.0057333983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11671v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11671v2 | Evaluating Language-Model Agents on Realistic Autonomous Tasks | 2023-12-18T19:27:09 | 2024-01-04T18:46:39 | Megan Kinniment, Lucas Jun Koba Sato, Haoxing Du, Brian Goodrich, Max Hasin, Lawrence Chan, Luke Harold Miles, Tao R. Lin, Hjalmar Wijk, Joel Burget, Aaron Ho, Elizabeth Barnes, Paul Christiano | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this report, we explore the ability of language model agents to acquire
resources, create copies of themselves, and adapt to novel challenges they
encounter in the wild. We refer to this cluster of capabilities as "autonomous
replication and adaptation" or ARA. We believe that systems capable of ARA
could have wide-reaching and hard-to-anticipate consequences, and that
measuring and forecasting ARA may be useful for informing measures around
security, monitoring, and alignment. Additionally, once a system is capable of
ARA, placing bounds on a system's capabilities may become significantly more
difficult.
We construct four simple example agents that combine language models with
tools that allow them to take actions in the world. We then evaluate these
agents on 12 tasks relevant to ARA. We find that these language model agents
can only complete the easiest tasks from this list, although they make some
progress on the more challenging tasks. Unfortunately, these evaluations are
not adequate to rule out the possibility that near-future agents will be
capable of ARA. In particular, we do not think that these evaluations provide
good assurance that the ``next generation'' of language models (e.g. 100x
effective compute scaleup on existing models) will not yield agents capable of
ARA, unless intermediate evaluations are performed during pretraining.
Relatedly, we expect that fine-tuning of the existing models could produce
substantially more competent agents, even if the fine-tuning is not directly
targeted at ARA. | [
0.0516135395,
0.0593443364,
-0.0366325751,
0.0126835937,
-0.0570713542,
0.0059020384,
0.0436003581,
-0.0183319487,
0.0142080169,
-0.0119923167,
-0.0041612117,
-0.0196474865,
-0.0316674672,
0.0418279208,
0.019687634,
-0.0258274451,
0.0580179021,
-0.0402450785,
0.0126856705,
-0.0300204046,
-0.0377439633,
-0.0373570956,
0.0299967043,
0.0038208512,
0.0081205266,
0.004294828,
-0.0428212956,
-0.019989958,
0.0304398108,
0.0142974118,
-0.031630069,
0.0121311629,
0.0279160943,
0.0528284349,
0.0000022718,
-0.0686853975,
-0.0187871773,
0.0045146835,
-0.0443913415,
0.0018955504,
0.0703569949,
-0.0014319574,
-0.0304304045,
0.008832884,
-0.0646110773,
0.0001591064,
0.054742001,
-0.0319276042,
0.0363029055,
0.0605224073,
0.0086403005,
0.0172881596,
-0.0002111776,
-0.0013688524,
-0.0429875292,
-0.055252187,
0.0013948041,
0.0276786741,
0.0380957834,
0.0333236605,
-0.001479878,
0.0264095347,
0.0282854959,
0.001550682,
-0.0288003627,
0.0486344546,
-0.0326329693,
-0.034264043,
-0.0061086002,
0.0166881476,
-0.0184158999,
-0.0329835787,
0.0177246667,
0.0161652602,
0.001398886,
0.0214484558,
-0.0121145714,
0.0459018201,
0.0482915454,
-0.0072663575,
0.0165727325,
-0.0068863076,
0.0378733613,
0.0130698262,
-0.02862937,
0.0797762498,
0.0071858889,
-0.0033303152,
-0.0516952835,
-0.0288386717,
0.0441588834,
-0.0673333257,
-0.019559253,
0.0578060597,
-0.01955764,
0.0186878983,
-0.0726651177,
-0.0149410842,
-0.0059982012,
-0.0391187035,
0.0352644213,
0.0356185064,
-0.0107780779,
0.0409700796,
-0.0334378742,
0.0693680495,
-0.0284253992,
0.0399073809,
-0.0146428021,
-0.0090963626,
-0.0577083752,
0.0067727538,
-0.0085263094,
0.0400485992,
0.014660893,
-0.0247898214,
-0.0084983194,
0.0669779629,
-0.0144143868,
0.0519856103,
-0.0636343062,
-0.0384530611,
-0.0097485743,
-0.0335708782,
-0.0331020765,
-0.0237568077,
-0.0386620201,
-0.0004972076,
0.0109332083,
-0.0600273684,
-0.0016094557,
-0.01494026,
-0.0072520659,
-0.0075677428,
0.0345628187,
0.128687039,
0.0244316943,
0.0001065447,
-0.0158968177,
-0.0038342203,
0.0161589626,
-0.0520089716,
-0.0548051521,
-0.0569132566,
0.0236552972,
0.0170866959,
-0.006789444,
-0.0452184789,
-0.0060114558,
-0.050286755,
-0.0263177119,
0.0654486939,
-0.0091010826,
0.0397310071,
-0.0038286471,
-0.0061752913,
0.0229624603,
0.0526198409,
0.0420803316,
0.0422155149,
0.045020707,
0.0223219432,
0.046096731,
0.0408377126,
-0.046703428,
0.0543736517,
0.0090296101,
0.0099395299,
0.038381841,
-0.0170740169,
-0.0095949704,
0.0323507227,
0.0168903302,
0.0006992239,
0.0821089968,
0.0570775531,
-0.0457622483,
0.0311155226,
0.0358447321,
-0.0014256826,
-0.016604634,
-0.0327435248,
-0.0636846572,
0.0302759837,
-0.0170367733,
0.0165528376,
-0.0376327075,
0.0451573096,
-0.0317120664,
-0.0341423452,
-0.0136972247,
-0.0219954308,
0.0058649248,
0.0041502919,
0.0477923118,
0.0275037382,
0.0104452483,
0.0031568806,
-0.0024274581,
-0.0509993136,
0.0061469409,
-0.1190951839,
-0.0043071327,
0.0697181597,
0.0720604584,
-0.0216222052,
-0.0210953988,
0.0339621976,
-0.01463266,
0.0377696194,
0.0386117622,
-0.0022143279,
-0.0200726241,
-0.0160449427,
-0.0314952247,
0.0051309029,
0.0090417191,
0.0503168292,
-0.027578488,
0.0339911208,
-0.0055330032,
-0.0185596962,
-0.0749010518,
0.0122794416,
-0.0282022245,
-0.0121652214,
-0.0169114228,
0.0206506271,
0.0216899309,
0.0002896324,
-0.0402520411,
0.0153133851,
0.0233578421,
-0.0053135445,
-0.0382054411,
0.0424930118,
0.0228407234,
0.0707225725,
0.0433707796,
0.0016949427,
0.0598595142,
0.0424343646,
-0.0045310785,
-0.0555617735,
0.0964618996,
-0.0273883399,
0.0211148728,
-0.0072578308,
0.0728458315,
-0.0749194026,
0.0117289973,
-0.0052442565,
0.0494939722,
0.0038600035,
-0.0311365705,
-0.0161348637,
0.0497970581,
0.0424674526,
-0.0056436057,
-0.042013187,
0.0012062797,
-0.0089444481,
0.0386354551,
0.0663519874,
0.0060219583,
-0.0079888608,
-0.0328067914,
-0.0295793116,
-0.0070939246,
-0.0169108566,
0.0306593049,
0.0555805229,
0.0150193749,
-0.0114497058,
-0.0268218312,
-0.0175152645,
0.0505389087,
-0.0016782143,
0.0280484557,
0.0109876199,
-0.0074598854,
-0.0703342631,
-0.0410596579,
0.0004707126,
-0.0036798378,
0.020087013,
0.0020465581,
0.0334308483,
-0.0770449713,
0.0036589194,
-0.0499081984,
0.0322485343,
-0.0133874388,
-0.0739541501,
0.0379905365,
-0.0424601808,
0.0004542214,
0.0687581897,
-0.0092867259,
0.0188534092,
0.0949130654,
0.0157899465,
-0.0397977196,
-0.0038978641,
-0.0172092579,
-0.0580558963,
-0.0538755208,
-0.0107128276,
-0.0104837213,
0.0627127141,
-0.0066436846,
-0.0089373812,
-0.0398935415,
0.0085883019,
-0.0242175572,
-0.0654039904,
-0.0004557677,
-0.0113772992,
-0.0034624909,
0.0670581162,
-0.0319884494,
-0.0563491397,
0.0548694097,
-0.0132253924,
0.0007734602,
-0.0185127892,
-0.0521248393,
-0.0161600038,
0.0920851454,
0.0436416268,
0.0335785784,
-0.0133594098,
-0.005839597,
-0.0490059741,
-0.0038227383,
0.026908692,
-0.027249448,
0.0045477115,
-0.0565313958,
0.0215720776,
0.012331007,
-0.0485421494,
-0.0492760353,
0.026919011,
-0.0133047597,
0.0164713115,
-0.0304718073,
-0.0449341238,
-0.0495564751,
0.0125297746,
0.0905433893,
0.0570414439,
0.0015526499,
-0.014410465,
-0.035717506,
-0.0451138504,
0.0131618986,
0.0141720744,
0.0008631349,
-0.013895114,
0.0537460074,
-0.0063535944,
0.0758850425,
-0.0183136184,
-0.0194960088,
0.0125550292,
0.0185014755,
-0.0288800765,
-0.0089703789,
0.036235407,
0.0205505751,
-0.0435622297,
-0.0536784679,
0.0829857737,
0.0114655755,
-0.003296653,
0.0247970782,
-0.0555989482,
-0.0313174687,
0.0477658734,
0.0405938067,
-0.0488119386,
0.0228448734,
0.0147148659,
0.0099285655,
-0.0321979709,
-0.0247958601,
0.0021979967,
-0.0867371485,
0.019151276,
0.0118811307,
-0.0726837069,
-0.0206883326,
-0.0394830219,
0.0129396645,
-0.0151828956,
0.0222673975,
0.0129348319,
0.0195364524,
-0.0176712573,
-0.0033441435,
-0.0108013703,
-0.0337924212,
0.0054448699,
-0.0600233823,
0.0572671108,
0.0878511295,
0.0081595108,
-0.0147949373,
-0.0124333268,
-0.0081418902,
0.0097687785,
0.0440284908,
0.0448195301,
-0.0022852896,
0.0467947386,
-0.0473129079,
0.0050454801,
-0.0057416344,
-0.0259043928,
-0.0196523238,
0.0127736554,
0.0496689305,
-0.0243206322,
-0.0354252085,
-0.0144624179,
-0.0588658713,
0.0126754316,
0.0361827388,
-0.0020883272,
-0.0621584244,
-0.0433958508,
-0.013850796,
-0.023458086,
-0.0610997416,
-0.0458355583,
0.037806455,
-0.008691987,
-0.0560994036,
-0.0536026843,
-0.0647770688,
-0.0147768445,
0.0211205613,
0.0541112833,
-0.0394667611,
0.0643194392,
0.0150402803,
-0.0258509889,
-0.0703573376,
-0.0449763425,
0.0109283002,
-0.043563135,
-0.0189938154,
0.0135150012,
-0.0262256227,
-0.0111355092,
-0.0248420164,
-0.0375660695,
-0.063949734,
0.0665207729,
0.0679727942,
0.0338338427,
-0.0240076389,
-0.0339645036,
-0.0269279294,
0.0638324991,
0.008202035,
-0.0431813151,
0.0148812514,
0.0166401453,
-0.0383736305,
-0.0066727116,
0.0405219048,
-0.0496029072,
0.0429698788,
0.024865048,
-0.0089110397,
-0.0516278259,
-0.0271175988,
0.0201808009,
0.0402917713,
-0.0390657075,
-0.0082408432,
0.0098303305,
0.0252195615,
0.0020808415,
-0.0077480804,
-0.0120773343,
-0.0157974288,
-0.0228999201,
-0.000804104,
0.0364892893,
0.0499282479,
0.0271648765,
0.0136628253,
-0.021961432,
0.0211984236,
-0.0113009065,
-0.0263195504,
0.0890595764,
0.0312973671,
0.0172416214,
-0.0126665942,
0.0418879427,
-0.0116626481,
0.0415789373,
0.0022982003,
0.0202103425,
-0.0053471928,
-0.0131727802,
-0.0445617512,
0.0495576784,
-0.0943539441,
-0.0876075849,
0.0387531295,
0.0366379358,
0.0618528649,
0.0185126662,
0.0479102097,
-0.0538790636,
0.0241425037,
-0.0275989771,
-0.0244165808,
0.0119258249,
-0.0478243083,
-0.0367730185,
0.0217032172,
-0.0081931083,
0.0125705712,
0.0385913141,
-0.0263170302,
0.0663811266,
-0.0379289128,
0.0040368349,
-0.0370316543,
-0.0289275162,
-0.0498623736,
-0.0187341999,
-0.0260165893,
-0.0132541452,
-0.0378464274,
-0.0455753841,
-0.0314860605,
0.059450902,
0.0155373281,
-0.018264167,
-0.0040784548,
0.0453675129,
-0.0026672708,
0.0124132093,
-0.0557784736,
-0.0088855959,
-0.0065516322,
0.018585939,
0.0384721458,
-6.344396477e-33,
0.0111532146,
0.0098506128,
0.0192218963,
-0.0163418707,
0.0142636988,
-0.0106862998,
-0.0686152056,
0.0168003123,
-0.0365952998,
-0.0042729429,
-0.0073661171,
0.0027245283,
0.02625948,
-0.0142833227,
0.0285942554,
0.0382295437,
0.0218008962,
0.0031582867,
-0.0373525992,
0.015690675,
0.0650378838,
-0.0262748953,
0.0281643495,
-0.0459245108,
0.0250928905,
-0.0160667133,
-0.0333158039,
-0.0026373714,
-0.0093401466,
0.0419987701,
-0.0085034175,
0.0126594398,
0.0181954633,
-0.0534962192,
-0.0328592137,
-0.0333384462,
-0.0339309685,
-0.0237578303,
-0.0131838834,
0.0161254182,
-0.016667312,
-0.0220027026,
0.0064149303,
-0.0009167655,
-0.0584183857,
0.0434979945,
0.0263051633,
-0.0362049453,
0.003812945,
0.0488792062,
-0.0666419566,
-0.0060766623,
-0.0019549096,
0.0242848899,
0.0159197655,
-0.0064111715,
-0.0227493849,
-0.033757966,
-0.0619645379,
0.0719110891,
-0.0013888434,
0.0228981804,
0.0740647763,
0.029033307,
-0.0115617486,
0.0538290739,
0.0037935148,
-0.0046185669,
0.0129049271,
0.0089333579,
0.0261100754,
0.0512550846,
0.0381325409,
0.0631466657,
-0.0369806923,
-0.0205412246,
-0.0057130177,
0.0193537213,
0.069593735,
0.0272909366,
0.046719335,
0.0040599089,
-0.0569573119,
-0.0027329852,
-0.0111825895,
-0.0057691722,
-0.0412942357,
-0.0667159557,
0.0252896901,
0.0041475156,
-0.0249167997,
-0.022585297,
0.0112588387,
-0.0473647937,
-0.0193595551,
0.0067729121,
-0.0225940533,
0.0179350469,
-0.0065417169,
0.0239448212,
-0.0194556937,
-0.0669701472,
-0.0358850248,
0.0345215648,
0.0204396006,
0.013340435,
-0.0176105183,
0.0769588351,
-0.0634842068,
0.0198955927,
-0.024202656,
0.0218678713,
0.0313238502,
-0.0133594526,
0.0009765365,
-0.0083780391,
0.0115264226,
0.0103495223,
0.015452466,
-0.0785356015,
-0.0138830114,
0.0763837546,
-0.0040317699,
0.0327338055,
-0.0494669601,
0.00748782,
-0.1027715355,
0.0836005732,
0.0101808142,
-0.030813016,
-0.0196024776,
0.0033384839,
3.088e-7,
-0.0078729512,
0.0126442267,
0.0173462201,
-0.0045140767,
0.0146908173,
0.0774384663,
-0.0399566218,
0.0720179155,
-0.0524546877,
-0.0139627028,
-0.0008861725,
0.0373187736,
0.0249773562,
0.0178853478,
-0.0223356485,
0.0103728641,
-0.0505724847,
0.0217406563,
-0.0580476038,
-0.0068303808,
0.0019789699,
0.064993754,
0.0464283451,
-0.0094120046,
-0.0049494929,
-0.0884911567,
-0.0122510176,
-0.0022261648,
-0.0013350425,
0.0127258841,
-0.0337620117,
0.0869424045,
-0.0289514754,
0.011816089,
-0.0044617299,
0.0314824022,
-0.048009187,
0.0474416502,
-0.0147035429,
0.0142748281,
-0.0023352308,
-0.0208874401,
-0.0147886435,
-0.0542638153,
0.0503175221,
0.008139207,
-0.030728301,
0.0195107423,
0.0087206541,
0.0295271631,
-0.0310272258,
-0.0096890507,
-0.0174970943,
0.0211922955,
0.0072415927,
0.0105894534,
-0.0042580236,
-0.0831660777,
0.012645063,
-0.00690303,
-0.0176896732,
-0.0429583117,
-0.0384982079,
0.0282808822,
0.0278895199,
-0.0304009318,
0.025074631,
2.420759342e-34,
-0.0062197912,
0.0241294038,
0.0158190578,
-0.0005007805,
-0.0199257955,
0.0200817082,
-0.0385565087,
0.0220007859,
0.0264970511,
-0.0176144335,
-0.0382011794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11462v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11462v4 | Cascade Speculative Drafting for Even Faster LLM Inference | 2023-12-18T18:59:46 | 2024-02-27T05:42:31 | Ziyi Chen, Xiaocong Yang, Jiacheng Lin, Chenkai Sun, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang, Jie Huang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Introduced to enhance the efficiency of large language model (LLM) inference,
speculative decoding operates by having a smaller model generate a draft. A
larger target model then reviews this draft to align with its output, and any
acceptance by the target model results in a reduction of the number of the
target model runs, ultimately improving efficiency. However, the drafting
process in speculative decoding includes slow autoregressive generation and
allocates equal time to generating tokens, irrespective of their importance.
These inefficiencies collectively contribute to the suboptimal performance of
speculative decoding. To further improve LLM inference, we introduce Cascade
Speculative Drafting (CS Drafting), a speculative execution algorithm that
incorporates two types of cascades. The Vertical Cascade eliminates
autoregressive generation from neural models, while the Horizontal Cascade
optimizes time allocation in drafting for improved efficiency. Combining both
cascades, CS Drafting achieves up to an 81 percent additional speedup over
speculative decoding in our experiments, while maintaining the same output
distribution as the target model. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/lfsszd/CS-Drafting. | [
0.0160407722,
0.0778452531,
-0.0092889071,
0.0335532464,
-0.0386854708,
0.0206526611,
0.0011522039,
0.0171672199,
-0.0378294289,
-0.0167429857,
-0.0104835974,
-0.0795385987,
0.0059390836,
0.0272109751,
0.0216979962,
0.0077380058,
0.0164796486,
-0.0737944469,
-0.0084277,
-0.0082301926,
-0.0319809839,
0.0347534865,
0.0069218329,
0.0425263084,
0.0112597682,
-0.0163402166,
-0.0293529946,
0.0230033509,
-0.0210299846,
-0.0241893809,
-0.0328690261,
0.0554078966,
0.0022331434,
0.040893089,
0.000002082,
-0.0239996035,
0.0016611621,
0.0162500069,
-0.0399594791,
0.0197123624,
0.0441112742,
-0.033554282,
-0.0194967426,
0.0078060441,
-0.0127362935,
-0.0276399944,
0.0329875164,
0.0240977574,
-0.0172011554,
0.0725398138,
0.0133065758,
-0.0493910909,
0.0251964778,
-0.0237314068,
-0.0123207131,
-0.0536742322,
0.0155322328,
-0.0169338007,
-0.0377418809,
-0.0093768435,
0.0013003271,
0.0283932332,
0.0525175482,
-0.0128802788,
-0.0266488623,
0.0372392684,
0.0228318609,
-0.0349061266,
0.0071355929,
0.0494914353,
-0.0169801712,
-0.0503796749,
-0.004741611,
-0.0157186463,
0.0066796709,
-0.0327381752,
-0.0305473898,
0.0645765588,
-0.036273282,
0.0297996942,
0.0815637559,
0.001820697,
0.0582128614,
0.0056486074,
-0.0218953062,
0.0738293231,
0.0300053153,
-0.0085926214,
-0.0287756454,
0.0273833703,
0.0022315565,
-0.0675333738,
0.008893122,
0.0092185158,
-0.0236716084,
0.0116588874,
-0.0440151393,
-0.0439873673,
-0.0013963303,
-0.0278698448,
0.050109148,
0.0584017597,
0.0051614796,
0.0078702606,
-0.0654546693,
-0.0255713519,
-0.0392275974,
0.0157166291,
-0.0524724722,
0.0038958346,
0.0194490589,
-0.0123826023,
-0.0337400585,
0.0422344133,
-0.0327648185,
-0.005803436,
-0.0424853601,
0.0200541262,
0.0139212813,
0.0091171544,
0.0408352837,
-0.0014678948,
-0.029092364,
-0.0120371357,
0.0115834596,
-0.0013771462,
-0.0200377144,
0.0180232376,
-0.0050800866,
-0.0584292896,
-0.0307825208,
0.0237457603,
-0.020131506,
-0.0228504594,
-0.0148803322,
0.1142134443,
0.0016962786,
0.0080138296,
-0.0613748468,
-0.0442292579,
0.0189517662,
-0.0666226745,
0.0242430121,
-0.0842681155,
0.0306747928,
0.0139376512,
-0.0178104993,
-0.0437969379,
-0.0086461399,
0.0108727589,
-0.0156755429,
0.0475509092,
-0.0291125551,
-0.0121097453,
0.0021927394,
0.0077874777,
-0.0264679808,
0.1149497479,
0.0295332167,
0.063210912,
-0.0097637381,
0.0115201343,
-0.0108836358,
0.0795494616,
0.0369872302,
-0.0094869863,
-0.0376734175,
-0.0357079431,
-0.0009583393,
0.0250760056,
0.0809626505,
0.0324488655,
-0.062121544,
-0.0063461214,
0.028391175,
0.0526391603,
0.0408551246,
0.0314584523,
0.0928673521,
0.0094761392,
0.0085105272,
0.02224553,
-0.0512086749,
0.0411661677,
-0.04247633,
0.0311971847,
-0.0001004841,
0.0467127487,
-0.0109380223,
-0.0236222427,
-0.013662667,
0.0067469175,
-0.0268052593,
0.0070370534,
0.0506721996,
0.0313084424,
-0.0577968843,
0.0673896298,
0.0290761851,
-0.0184762776,
-0.0155168436,
-0.0579370297,
0.0299215764,
0.0698296875,
0.0220220182,
0.0234560687,
-0.009209591,
0.0179909803,
-0.0332794935,
0.0520867594,
0.0138620604,
-0.0113978116,
0.0237138271,
-0.0402035564,
-0.0022730283,
0.0139954826,
0.0373870768,
0.0413475558,
0.0460096709,
-0.0124769611,
0.0128485607,
-0.0410509109,
-0.0194055084,
0.0341917649,
-0.0180984288,
-0.0148447901,
0.0099459514,
-0.0023124961,
0.0228817109,
-0.0075941538,
-0.0170934834,
0.0289112292,
0.0250053331,
-0.049471505,
-0.0368147902,
0.0217463281,
-0.0523574166,
-0.0624945648,
0.0258458182,
0.0128639685,
-0.0421076044,
-0.0183824226,
-0.0490984656,
-0.0206603166,
0.0260076802,
-0.0099918852,
0.0551938266,
-0.0448774099,
0.028138198,
0.0226797946,
-0.002060334,
-0.0009546178,
0.0576324873,
-0.0386499912,
-0.008847272,
0.0237959344,
0.0253127683,
-0.019382257,
-0.0189531203,
-0.0026316983,
0.010844456,
-0.023559643,
-0.0233234037,
-0.0376717634,
0.0170517359,
-0.0130636785,
-0.0146236932,
-0.0657631159,
-0.0138461329,
-0.0334646031,
0.0188182443,
0.012385116,
0.0078671072,
-0.0106423311,
-0.0139763495,
0.0108835623,
-0.0004286886,
-0.017103957,
0.0208077412,
0.006749386,
-0.0120389387,
-0.0275612082,
-0.0106670549,
-0.0358392671,
-0.0115698259,
0.0693798289,
-0.017753901,
-0.0388064496,
-0.0967751369,
0.0562525727,
0.022521887,
0.0082724141,
-0.0102775814,
-0.0216508955,
0.0169406813,
-0.0448894277,
0.0124602308,
0.046964027,
-0.0178784002,
-0.0070808972,
0.042506963,
0.0243970379,
-0.0474220812,
-0.0124995597,
0.0165024213,
0.0055100014,
-0.0580351613,
-0.0598156378,
-0.0279005338,
0.0780265257,
0.0147642363,
-0.0105731227,
-0.0462224707,
-0.0083189532,
0.0103209699,
-0.0545373671,
-0.011868393,
-0.0215171222,
-0.0104671214,
0.0472315997,
-0.021846801,
-0.0580349676,
0.0747975558,
-0.0631905943,
0.0006154788,
0.0139472159,
0.0231645349,
-0.0459471494,
0.0675249621,
0.0000921986,
0.0020786584,
-0.0098278644,
-0.053169053,
-0.0194539577,
0.0350070074,
0.0061556636,
-0.0066077434,
0.0634401739,
-0.0536611378,
0.0126632871,
-0.0363769121,
-0.0261522923,
-0.0368937179,
-0.0245960131,
-0.0555473082,
0.0045574708,
0.0347641446,
-0.0324803665,
0.0199961234,
0.0084551452,
-0.0543738231,
0.0434408672,
-0.0280634556,
0.0170345344,
-0.0062358258,
0.011859281,
0.0383720286,
-0.0403735228,
0.0237919558,
-0.0506558418,
0.0628694743,
0.0807889551,
0.0293670334,
0.0517796874,
-0.0571433529,
0.0111421067,
0.0310207102,
0.0009102135,
-0.0003845065,
0.044084765,
0.0482505113,
-0.0681571513,
0.0160521865,
0.1090829,
0.0008877671,
-0.0654620752,
-0.0009423349,
-0.0077219228,
0.0630970597,
-0.0013128171,
0.0337871425,
-0.092619203,
-0.0332217626,
0.0584201068,
0.0056353635,
0.004006309,
-0.0278433859,
-0.0145405503,
-0.1122612134,
0.0578267351,
0.0058850758,
-0.0200424325,
0.0267317258,
-0.0276830494,
-0.0268189237,
0.023380192,
0.0116869798,
0.0561850891,
-0.0151325678,
-0.0035163832,
0.0068204054,
-0.0190527756,
-0.0095815351,
0.0057140864,
-0.0306480471,
0.0468224771,
0.0426821709,
0.0032251757,
0.0149206333,
0.0061048795,
0.0431029759,
-0.0061069564,
0.0104805855,
-0.0461737625,
0.0357034877,
-0.0002522004,
0.0198025424,
0.0043081944,
0.0268687345,
-0.0244772099,
-0.0082671316,
-0.0126823829,
0.0291918665,
-0.0202519763,
-0.0659305826,
-0.0127470493,
0.0202570073,
-0.0041597839,
0.0721117929,
0.0674495548,
-0.0305589996,
-0.054955557,
-0.0446851775,
-0.0550688207,
-0.110195972,
-0.018576948,
0.0035773607,
0.0489094369,
-0.0138551891,
-0.0324186757,
0.0018982654,
0.0408286788,
0.0425376818,
-0.0037497005,
0.0458340384,
-0.006975661,
-0.0424967036,
-0.0532765053,
0.022241855,
-0.0175608899,
0.0098329382,
-0.0317309797,
0.0035007107,
0.0334230661,
-0.0249285288,
-0.0106128873,
0.0351925716,
-0.1407329291,
-0.066089727,
-0.0120969713,
0.0347857177,
0.0190725364,
0.0484306328,
-0.0248906948,
-0.0267504826,
0.0447689444,
0.0328923203,
-0.0084861675,
0.0144072166,
0.0190919414,
-0.014131235,
0.0058417171,
0.0468436591,
-0.0112167085,
0.0079402523,
0.0315063521,
0.0313646384,
-0.0018046632,
0.0136356466,
0.0060173981,
0.0197870061,
0.0051764012,
-0.052297987,
-0.0082576536,
-0.0088477097,
0.0463874266,
-0.0182793327,
-0.0160726905,
-0.0344055146,
0.0363104157,
0.0116919372,
-0.0202218015,
-0.0066628153,
-0.0021025881,
0.0456013083,
0.0368531644,
0.0072421241,
0.0038687212,
-0.0085746516,
0.0290185381,
0.0536251366,
-0.0125811659,
-0.0253593531,
0.0222162902,
-0.0196168534,
0.0316418596,
-0.0409734547,
-0.0051266099,
0.0266286116,
0.0253593717,
-0.0475021563,
0.0175526217,
-0.0517287627,
-0.0768165812,
-0.0363301896,
0.0197170507,
0.0582089275,
0.0156493001,
0.0500383414,
-0.0298452005,
-0.0016113627,
0.0032452508,
0.0228178389,
-0.0226019397,
-0.0349497609,
0.0508680828,
0.0027626914,
-0.0275082029,
-0.0119519569,
0.0615607649,
0.0368237533,
0.0443868563,
0.0145518519,
0.0202717297,
-0.0089748865,
-0.0621447302,
-0.0285038427,
0.0126125207,
-0.0320789479,
-0.0168198086,
-0.0240174495,
-0.0824334174,
0.0142748868,
0.0137568275,
-0.0040994408,
0.0223265979,
0.014199255,
0.0507322736,
0.012695007,
-0.0564716943,
-0.0245156251,
-0.000690283,
0.0654726401,
-0.0546278283,
-0.0384451076,
-6.405502347e-33,
-0.0295039024,
-0.0419139527,
0.0330110788,
-0.015792707,
-0.0308265053,
-0.0163075943,
-0.0381443314,
-0.0179184061,
0.0052322648,
-0.0020720535,
-0.0290759858,
0.0377014987,
0.0240316223,
0.0263828244,
0.0218905117,
0.0008388574,
0.0671263635,
-0.0186012723,
-0.0056407596,
-0.0074420604,
-0.004256696,
0.0531572029,
0.045582816,
0.0015717424,
0.0029596991,
-0.0104071768,
-0.0174211338,
-0.004921617,
-0.0576688237,
0.0353018828,
-0.0110909501,
0.0053331801,
0.0258118901,
0.0003171753,
-0.0309056994,
-0.0026199194,
-0.0962561518,
-0.0130933244,
0.0510661937,
0.0189262293,
-0.0174054094,
-0.0317136534,
0.0277777053,
0.0242677853,
-0.0232549179,
-0.0388931707,
-0.0064030928,
-0.0079396442,
-0.0302829538,
-0.0337614343,
-0.0592311509,
0.0204891432,
0.0353069156,
0.0336973816,
0.0491144396,
0.024458142,
-0.0109639689,
0.019481875,
-0.0772949979,
0.0023635684,
-0.0440137945,
0.0578998812,
0.0607848577,
0.0075424439,
0.0018292371,
0.0344017595,
0.0272784121,
-0.0043355087,
-0.0881123617,
-0.0261821058,
0.0326137953,
0.02893655,
0.0129032712,
0.0139201544,
0.0733163729,
-0.0025119965,
-0.0520732626,
-0.0008922333,
0.0135789765,
0.0468320809,
0.0465497486,
0.0187204424,
0.0017702559,
-0.0392367803,
-0.0599449091,
-0.0418476984,
-0.0453934968,
-0.0217562523,
0.0133890277,
0.0149419671,
-0.002355047,
-0.0482653119,
0.0459561683,
-0.0450310111,
-0.0132711222,
0.0251577031,
0.0015450349,
0.0304105487,
-0.0123471832,
0.0417735837,
0.0001743356,
-0.0141133452,
0.0088813845,
-0.0132472161,
0.0188837424,
0.0042758244,
0.0348696411,
0.0014356326,
-0.0476877242,
-0.0100392196,
-0.0513947122,
0.0340372212,
0.0394217856,
0.0200337507,
0.0535234138,
0.0073390254,
0.0053354055,
0.0188753009,
0.0040926812,
0.0543894507,
-0.0317810439,
0.0290282406,
-0.0008788306,
0.0582593605,
-0.0193914622,
0.007260473,
-0.0432706438,
0.0131125376,
0.0336643904,
-0.0711939931,
-0.0272568613,
0.0761943087,
2.722e-7,
0.0491669402,
0.008439648,
0.0455827713,
0.0629475266,
0.0181718301,
0.0061942078,
-0.0038354583,
-0.0060429093,
0.0444170423,
0.0107510863,
0.007815565,
0.0305326283,
0.0766541362,
0.0324588269,
-0.1057533249,
-0.0102521488,
-0.0479163378,
0.0104917921,
-0.0417930149,
-0.030157892,
-0.0115104131,
0.0904842839,
-0.0185584296,
-0.0428279825,
0.0355546251,
-0.0096537489,
0.0299216118,
-0.0023295279,
0.0069345529,
0.0154128661,
-0.0069735432,
-0.0183244199,
0.020811107,
0.0145878028,
-0.0060133268,
-0.0227173418,
-0.0385697372,
0.0354406834,
0.0053431401,
0.0024472829,
-0.0000256216,
-0.0257399939,
0.0002528864,
-0.0383542888,
0.0511605814,
-0.0445131399,
-0.0147652077,
-0.0546644628,
0.0152977165,
-0.0231232569,
-0.0220625866,
-0.0122633008,
0.0490915291,
0.0514117815,
0.0427687876,
-0.0219080765,
-0.0211731829,
-0.0822602585,
-0.0531912558,
-0.016428683,
-0.0765650719,
-0.0427687466,
-0.0297542904,
0.0048839152,
0.0251931213,
-0.0770538151,
-0.0212101489,
2.980403249e-34,
0.0540262014,
0.0029372112,
0.0111319441,
0.1020469293,
0.0270696264,
-0.0097703254,
0.0267938729,
0.0276961513,
-0.0213337652,
-0.0874506384,
-0.0479881093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11444v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11444v2 | An In-depth Look at Gemini's Language Abilities | 2023-12-18T18:47:42 | 2023-12-24T12:25:10 | Syeda Nahida Akter, Zichun Yu, Aashiq Muhamed, Tianyue Ou, Alex Bäuerle, Ángel Alexander Cabrera, Krish Dholakia, Chenyan Xiong, Graham Neubig | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The recently released Google Gemini class of models are the first to
comprehensively report results that rival the OpenAI GPT series across a wide
variety of tasks. In this paper, we do an in-depth exploration of Gemini's
language abilities, making two contributions. First, we provide a third-party,
objective comparison of the abilities of the OpenAI GPT and Google Gemini
models with reproducible code and fully transparent results. Second, we take a
closer look at the results, identifying areas where one of the two model
classes excels. We perform this analysis over 10 datasets testing a variety of
language abilities, including reasoning, answering knowledge-based questions,
solving math problems, translating between languages, generating code, and
acting as instruction-following agents. From this analysis, we find that Gemini
Pro achieves accuracy that is close but slightly inferior to the corresponding
GPT 3.5 Turbo on all tasks that we benchmarked. We further provide explanations
for some of this under-performance, including failures in mathematical
reasoning with many digits, sensitivity to multiple-choice answer ordering,
aggressive content filtering, and others. We also identify areas where Gemini
demonstrates comparably high performance, including generation into non-English
languages, and handling longer and more complex reasoning chains. Code and data
for reproduction can be found at https://github.com/neulab/gemini-benchmark | [
-0.0134538095,
0.0931628123,
-0.0052779927,
0.0388535224,
-0.0358884074,
0.0085649164,
0.0156495832,
-0.0120571377,
-0.0470329858,
-0.0231919661,
-0.0363467634,
-0.0315912962,
-0.009850747,
0.0907462314,
-0.0072267386,
-0.0617702827,
0.0594085939,
-0.0578979142,
0.0227040853,
-0.0123925172,
-0.0430847257,
-0.0109441821,
-0.0405024774,
0.0697257444,
0.0006864109,
-0.0345111787,
-0.0143218869,
-0.0423072726,
0.0159563646,
-0.0031633859,
-0.0109994104,
0.0520012416,
0.0070669656,
0.0790032521,
0.0000019645,
-0.031693615,
0.0456155054,
0.0164988637,
-0.0179329682,
-0.0104921879,
0.049595125,
0.0088631855,
-0.0060814004,
0.0405937955,
-0.0685628355,
-0.0349352583,
0.0440881364,
0.0215787534,
0.0628353059,
0.089460291,
-0.0052935635,
0.0183617063,
0.0415855087,
-0.0338796303,
0.0023953472,
-0.0432916693,
0.0005958061,
-0.0203700252,
0.035137549,
0.0189103242,
0.0113288332,
0.0149839986,
0.0790950283,
0.0042353324,
-0.0604234152,
0.0415653586,
-0.0801136717,
0.0019499867,
-0.0173021983,
0.0450688154,
0.0100742634,
-0.0138023701,
-0.0388353281,
0.0238714665,
0.0025322884,
-0.0466506705,
-0.028240202,
0.0255831182,
0.0362954065,
0.0140902251,
0.022024516,
-0.0010429121,
0.024002593,
-0.0030426581,
-0.0535614677,
0.114186734,
0.0341139995,
-0.0111382371,
-0.004664395,
0.0158289913,
-0.0481013171,
-0.0573751852,
-0.016775189,
0.0381002426,
-0.0258798376,
0.0078247786,
-0.0597769879,
0.00142916,
-0.0070067663,
-0.0159853138,
-0.0043308497,
0.0817033798,
-0.0149618844,
0.023253236,
-0.0259924531,
0.087265268,
-0.0074345577,
0.0786286071,
-0.0247379094,
-0.0217381008,
-0.0451091006,
-0.0008319409,
-0.0341373421,
0.0135802552,
-0.0302418713,
-0.0399560668,
-0.0558682159,
0.0208764952,
-0.0137678729,
0.036850132,
0.0376339778,
0.0145199858,
-0.0250759963,
-0.0043946519,
-0.0419490524,
0.0302354731,
-0.0654865354,
-0.0003140337,
0.0573478751,
-0.075381957,
0.0015138864,
0.0223243367,
-0.0407637246,
-0.0318130255,
0.012794029,
0.0768956468,
-0.0250915103,
-0.0310693514,
-0.038778346,
0.0100129293,
0.0125291925,
-0.0979333967,
0.0194454435,
-0.0573339686,
0.0139245419,
0.0167195834,
-0.0329645686,
-0.0439628772,
0.0115269087,
0.0478313603,
0.0047227922,
0.0257593803,
-0.0106258495,
-0.0199919008,
0.0177204516,
0.0236608665,
-0.0477422848,
0.0576260537,
0.0328378193,
0.0044968664,
0.0025807302,
-0.0088399509,
-0.016405439,
0.0394669771,
-0.0002355825,
-0.0168408342,
-0.0188929643,
0.0297254454,
0.0022001292,
0.0525920987,
0.0263904482,
0.0463289432,
-0.0226782914,
-0.0321951434,
0.0548730418,
0.0324265324,
-0.0269833691,
0.0498329997,
0.0463250168,
-0.0211028326,
0.0247709751,
0.0012774002,
-0.0918292329,
0.038775336,
0.0149473036,
0.0279846136,
-0.0261130538,
0.0377211608,
-0.0358590782,
-0.0504138991,
-0.0024593368,
-0.0147968614,
-0.0118197836,
0.0296904072,
0.0467441678,
-0.018029552,
-0.0375181399,
-0.0101409629,
0.0060016941,
-0.043239776,
-0.0284509547,
-0.0803554282,
0.0168059282,
0.0406233966,
0.0221211016,
-0.010010968,
-0.0499780551,
0.0177375842,
-0.0366123617,
0.0521077402,
0.0494517311,
0.0035040705,
-0.0153877353,
-0.0600437932,
0.0064222342,
-0.0537246652,
-0.0008703159,
0.0430108942,
0.0475086384,
0.0413623117,
0.0010227263,
0.0176509302,
0.0132347643,
0.0245783143,
-0.0029025828,
-0.0306014698,
0.0040321066,
-0.0054538711,
0.0381281674,
-0.0299212411,
0.0040296372,
0.0144454762,
0.0090467744,
-0.0166835375,
-0.0082484903,
0.0025096294,
-0.0519943535,
-0.0269890595,
0.0390815437,
-0.0296388194,
-0.0425473079,
0.0789941102,
-0.0228185598,
-0.0678118393,
0.0417041034,
0.009873976,
0.005953955,
-0.0470176712,
0.0066839522,
0.0127248457,
0.0050566169,
0.0190090593,
0.0952798575,
-0.0069997641,
0.0086537171,
0.0483813509,
0.050846193,
0.0341557637,
-0.0381845161,
-0.0209240858,
0.0330241881,
-0.0033958573,
0.0007164691,
-0.0089882119,
0.010438744,
-0.0331339873,
-0.0168013852,
-0.0781112537,
0.0250310283,
-0.0218916293,
0.0186027903,
0.0137316035,
-0.0001372472,
-0.0073503158,
-0.0173761416,
-0.0537589043,
0.0188262928,
0.0151695665,
0.0046595461,
0.0039122696,
0.0073806029,
-0.004572738,
-0.0167731065,
-0.0189616438,
-0.0369304717,
0.0263538584,
-0.0295869932,
0.0516511612,
-0.0239743628,
0.0315099955,
-0.0513321832,
0.0345496163,
0.0030073398,
-0.012720176,
0.0530386455,
-0.039910879,
0.0429987386,
0.0756632388,
-0.0063238582,
0.0130254989,
0.0385636315,
-0.0172660705,
-0.027876962,
0.0581546687,
0.0042319181,
-0.0064924927,
-0.0140624698,
-0.0086000739,
-0.0182357673,
0.0585248321,
-0.0247952752,
-0.015271158,
-0.0779003948,
0.021736417,
-0.0172051731,
-0.0154559547,
-0.0254949089,
0.0525776111,
-0.0109304618,
-0.0039557833,
-0.0373805389,
-0.0342667289,
0.0689500719,
-0.0371542312,
-0.0053792382,
-0.0501630418,
-0.0132647483,
-0.0274077542,
0.0374842584,
0.0108488398,
0.0256393012,
-0.0280728526,
-0.0231863353,
-0.0432982035,
0.013895262,
-0.0078483289,
-0.0098499646,
0.060628809,
-0.0503893979,
-0.0116160959,
-0.0033756339,
-0.0639150366,
-0.0536154993,
0.0378560312,
-0.0345013179,
0.0648423657,
0.039171692,
-0.0761303231,
-0.0492496975,
-0.0285829902,
0.0024945789,
0.0537092052,
-0.0338213742,
-0.0186739713,
-0.0203875564,
0.0006948967,
0.0519538932,
0.0470491163,
0.0332835615,
-0.0115064168,
0.0066890945,
0.0540601499,
0.058143165,
-0.0159655195,
-0.0470865145,
0.0235218406,
0.0163040999,
-0.0482689627,
-0.0152804265,
0.05365742,
0.0219515543,
-0.0724692866,
-0.0539051704,
0.0930112451,
0.0318712182,
-0.0240583569,
-0.0172001012,
-0.0318711326,
0.0378109999,
0.0283687431,
0.0213097297,
-0.0596862808,
-0.0348009989,
0.0079223132,
-0.0048223296,
-0.0011033466,
0.0051745698,
-0.0007646566,
-0.095156461,
0.0412368923,
-0.0107491873,
-0.0566099659,
0.0103345085,
-0.0177407451,
-0.0382205918,
-0.0103860199,
0.0277661048,
0.0022478264,
0.024521552,
-0.0088582346,
-0.0060134116,
0.0183271151,
-0.0478802025,
0.0479536727,
-0.0056353672,
0.0125582805,
0.0614541993,
0.0209270287,
-0.0104048755,
-0.0797622502,
-0.027870696,
-0.0180003624,
0.0062573156,
0.0238338392,
0.0275931321,
0.0215811264,
-0.0221969634,
-0.0232397337,
0.0466687791,
-0.0544924773,
-0.0153905265,
0.0331828333,
0.06935931,
-0.0284679979,
-0.0315146595,
-0.0107429586,
-0.0018547552,
-0.0167342853,
0.0503879637,
0.0034620708,
-0.0166695714,
-0.0863195583,
-0.0343339592,
-0.0267205443,
-0.0653349385,
-0.006358088,
0.0359649435,
0.071775116,
-0.0426277481,
-0.0467111506,
-0.0486183763,
0.035785608,
0.0439227298,
-0.0160822421,
-0.0177968629,
-0.021124566,
0.0156771056,
-0.0030939316,
0.0197505746,
-0.012140397,
0.0250308495,
-0.0827327743,
0.0086627258,
-0.014278709,
-0.0185271259,
-0.0268430877,
0.0448491052,
-0.0797359943,
-0.0425201319,
0.0170826223,
0.0729890913,
0.0281869397,
0.0019970536,
-0.0199804828,
-0.0141082313,
-0.0098977434,
-0.0178671423,
0.0091719273,
0.0000106485,
0.0149640189,
-0.0290919207,
0.0060435301,
0.0258463491,
-0.0164580476,
0.0132924421,
-0.0049658646,
0.0351474248,
-0.0450044349,
0.0458535478,
0.033619754,
0.0237992126,
0.007376594,
0.0035230804,
0.0042856261,
-0.001140226,
0.0252023581,
-0.0248102322,
0.0138046136,
-0.0241871569,
-0.0135677885,
0.0502992906,
0.0226593576,
0.0131358551,
-0.0107604731,
0.0136921154,
-0.0271390714,
-0.0006681603,
0.006466514,
0.0296095796,
0.0865299925,
0.0254741739,
-0.0118380878,
-0.0409894437,
-0.0146079799,
-0.0021704948,
0.0621501133,
-0.0225210171,
0.0895449966,
0.0163898598,
-0.0055048009,
0.0126864752,
0.0255647469,
-0.0998986438,
-0.0535368957,
0.0081495009,
0.0556838885,
0.0598653071,
0.0359660015,
0.0011507517,
-0.0710898638,
-0.0181630217,
-0.0108250128,
0.0102109071,
0.025272293,
-0.0448439419,
0.0051442678,
0.0146156764,
0.0113505023,
-0.0465536341,
0.0842808858,
-0.0040958677,
0.0190733634,
0.0239727497,
0.018290801,
-0.0241691973,
-0.0427310206,
-0.0302449819,
0.0198817831,
-0.0094856722,
0.0003197694,
-0.0267976578,
-0.0720199496,
-0.0048695896,
0.0487473495,
0.026093781,
-0.0140783563,
0.0312364493,
0.0376667194,
-0.0274462812,
-0.0601346605,
-0.0111194076,
-0.0013374444,
-0.0281592179,
-0.0006202876,
-0.0213109311,
-5.737579845e-33,
-0.0371441729,
0.0092518311,
0.0685701892,
0.0093127498,
0.0079330094,
-0.0199991073,
-0.0428451113,
0.0067137759,
-0.0462737046,
0.0061147078,
-0.0064491495,
0.0215123314,
0.0091659492,
0.0456061661,
0.001614842,
-0.0152187571,
0.0166598484,
-0.0148385549,
-0.0371007957,
0.0419049077,
0.0635068193,
0.0065724961,
0.0476362407,
-0.0018476207,
0.0071225557,
-0.0185490511,
-0.0071467571,
0.0202987231,
-0.0880467072,
0.0731266662,
-0.0196586605,
0.0454064198,
0.0030754332,
-0.0168050453,
0.0019241694,
-0.0148944976,
-0.0554414354,
-0.0561818033,
-0.0184784196,
0.0210418291,
-0.0460021123,
-0.0464233272,
0.0097136674,
-0.0012309403,
-0.0345364586,
-0.0327242687,
0.0103033064,
-0.0146427955,
-0.0081209801,
-0.0012446017,
-0.057117451,
-0.0032809032,
-0.0006606893,
-0.0090946173,
-0.0107612545,
0.045980081,
-0.0438244715,
-0.0200232137,
-0.0337780118,
0.0011143263,
0.0082654906,
0.0346599296,
0.0579245836,
0.0039892257,
0.0000973869,
0.0301543847,
0.0347247235,
-0.0244998466,
-0.0177587196,
-0.0209124647,
0.0480794832,
0.073352702,
0.0792936236,
0.0199909899,
0.0427041277,
-0.0053965924,
-0.0570789501,
0.0363612734,
0.0246363319,
0.0239838473,
-0.0087252827,
-0.0219173189,
-0.0461481921,
0.0175186135,
-0.0071308697,
-0.0074725864,
-0.0593409687,
-0.0593738481,
0.080130361,
-0.0168446973,
0.0207866207,
-0.0101466225,
0.0382418893,
-0.0340789407,
0.0261451676,
0.0105777504,
-0.0320213847,
0.0382403918,
-0.0099958098,
0.0722003132,
-0.0491319522,
-0.0196624864,
0.0257495102,
0.0004770602,
0.0121715711,
0.0120274732,
0.0282220244,
0.0408627167,
-0.0432021171,
-0.0057483991,
-0.039452929,
0.0437767431,
0.0263726693,
-0.0071581253,
0.0208231695,
-0.015621976,
0.0135756377,
0.0066277361,
-0.0469916798,
-0.0031892355,
-0.0489754826,
-0.0268007871,
0.0310030635,
0.0078568403,
-0.0112647796,
0.0047360351,
-0.0526394807,
-0.0120288003,
-0.0185486302,
-0.0676098242,
-0.0154165262,
0.0672005787,
2.508e-7,
0.0372658819,
0.0141715799,
0.0153994458,
0.0493998826,
-0.0108959442,
0.0164826997,
-0.0535510369,
0.0089849764,
0.035121005,
0.0531799607,
0.0006251624,
0.0284886714,
0.0371194482,
0.0604503714,
-0.0755693614,
0.032456629,
-0.0293579008,
-0.0202905219,
-0.0584661067,
0.0158219114,
0.0408164151,
0.0830367208,
-0.0163738802,
-0.0044141319,
0.0516770929,
-0.043500524,
0.0724231377,
-0.0080525633,
-0.0077709039,
0.0176360309,
-0.0181085709,
0.0290452503,
-0.0145433713,
0.033223398,
-0.022027418,
0.0053229867,
0.0334977359,
0.0722705498,
0.0007746825,
-0.0474259779,
-0.0124639431,
-0.0031172014,
0.0164889563,
-0.0507905334,
0.064552173,
-0.043777559,
-0.0293409787,
0.0137233417,
-0.0084076617,
-0.023592446,
0.022929145,
-0.0238796715,
0.0078625875,
-0.0073330607,
0.0164277814,
-0.0261630416,
-0.0004463564,
-0.051627323,
-0.0009257564,
0.0306639485,
-0.0499907359,
-0.0350747667,
-0.0901660845,
-0.0062828111,
0.0508512706,
0.0162742548,
-0.0172164626,
2.401985641e-34,
0.0055140699,
-0.0221958105,
0.0136852525,
0.0342601538,
0.0244708564,
0.0120844841,
0.0474109352,
-0.0105702858,
0.0169069674,
-0.0597134791,
-0.0387157723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11441v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11441v2 | Social Learning: Towards Collaborative Learning with Large Language Models | 2023-12-18T18:44:10 | 2024-02-08T15:52:29 | Amirkeivan Mohtashami, Florian Hartmann, Sian Gooding, Lukas Zilka, Matt Sharifi, Blaise Aguera y Arcas | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We introduce the framework of "social learning" in the context of large
language models (LLMs), whereby models share knowledge with each other in a
privacy-aware manner using natural language. We present and evaluate two
approaches for knowledge transfer between LLMs. In the first scenario, we allow
the model to generate abstract prompts aiming to teach the task. In our second
approach, models transfer knowledge by generating synthetic examples. We
evaluate these methods across diverse datasets and quantify memorization as a
proxy for privacy loss. These techniques inspired by social learning yield
promising results with low memorization of the original data. In particular, we
show that performance using these methods is comparable to results with the use
of original labels and prompts. Our work demonstrates the viability of social
learning for LLMs, establishes baseline approaches and highlights several
unexplored areas for future work. | [
0.0311676096,
0.074176982,
-0.0388447791,
0.0703516826,
-0.0628081709,
-0.0191791654,
0.0538157523,
-0.0284862313,
0.056464836,
-0.0084402533,
-0.0522675142,
-0.0264784731,
-0.0176726598,
0.0142983506,
0.0237413812,
-0.0355439708,
0.0072348695,
-0.0542453602,
0.0055444045,
-0.0374503955,
-0.028837366,
0.0031087967,
0.0187622029,
0.0207783077,
0.0103861233,
-0.0052847862,
-0.014523251,
-0.0343626775,
0.0171511229,
-0.0139860297,
0.0001325173,
0.0538328849,
0.0382274501,
0.0593378209,
0.0000020063,
-0.0669536442,
-0.0468389317,
0.0183127467,
-0.0266393665,
0.0189606659,
0.0238019638,
0.0135320136,
0.0300961621,
0.0132872043,
-0.0650788546,
-0.000002174,
0.0401734635,
0.0046130875,
0.0561749339,
0.066378668,
0.0143508418,
-0.0152719775,
-0.0048599932,
-0.0395411178,
0.0203326847,
-0.0699004605,
0.0356475152,
0.0040066801,
0.0077638687,
0.0232936256,
-0.0057062539,
0.0479514338,
0.0234107506,
-0.011459372,
0.0290405918,
0.0274610166,
0.0179664716,
-0.0087200534,
-0.027170714,
0.0711689964,
0.0385604091,
-0.0238539502,
0.0318971835,
0.0114697786,
0.0530210622,
0.0704333708,
-0.0452337153,
0.0378363132,
-0.0129747884,
0.0089081796,
0.0040394864,
-0.0038208573,
0.0352689251,
-0.0079038236,
0.0526713431,
0.0237752683,
-0.0074602547,
0.0009064744,
-0.021624025,
-0.016108308,
-0.0040496695,
-0.0442805141,
0.0535503067,
0.0228141621,
0.0186310634,
0.0370722152,
-0.0538653359,
-0.02182585,
0.0147872036,
-0.0402342789,
0.0348737575,
-0.0367189944,
0.0430329405,
0.0643722638,
-0.0200497601,
0.0186960194,
0.0268709883,
0.0332969837,
0.0016341963,
0.0006867452,
-0.0728653148,
0.0036610328,
-0.0418528207,
0.0627982691,
-0.0035988721,
0.0159828756,
-0.0032479716,
0.0174278822,
-0.0540619493,
0.0511735082,
-0.0034562179,
-0.0030976401,
0.0004770081,
-0.0304177962,
-0.0120202815,
-0.0230288133,
-0.0114599299,
0.0022101251,
0.0054965634,
-0.0385387018,
0.0139932483,
-0.0596358813,
-0.0005170579,
0.0028328057,
-0.0256303158,
0.0711043775,
-0.0133511992,
-0.0267708264,
-0.0029557077,
-0.0546898097,
0.0295599997,
-0.0513337888,
-0.024526678,
-0.0575671606,
0.0457696803,
-0.0052030175,
0.0006845072,
-0.0689588487,
0.0149469525,
0.0231981128,
-0.0288171116,
0.0858288407,
0.0165685434,
0.0057178531,
0.0301241223,
0.0624859892,
-0.0188351069,
0.0398296304,
0.0215747654,
-0.0178581644,
0.0377338082,
-0.0271465778,
0.0364851877,
0.0111569837,
0.0533414818,
0.0151274092,
0.0040797945,
-0.0033738348,
0.0642610788,
-0.0230304264,
-0.0288513731,
0.0662984625,
-0.0066466881,
-0.0440433547,
0.0837252364,
0.0583705492,
-0.0334204398,
0.0443833098,
-0.0130476579,
0.0557749718,
0.0015784564,
0.0018160719,
-0.0512219295,
0.0095531875,
-0.0687340125,
-0.0405986831,
-0.0099742133,
-0.0005353158,
-0.0017970846,
-0.0139792198,
0.027156841,
-0.0508210212,
0.0367864743,
0.0532209873,
0.0253078509,
0.0289806873,
-0.0002740849,
0.0340614319,
0.0354934931,
-0.0471458547,
0.0337116569,
-0.0222188924,
0.0617020987,
0.0592216589,
0.03951836,
-0.0458957069,
0.0161622111,
-0.0300371628,
-0.0040363041,
-0.0206321981,
0.0653354973,
-0.0332584865,
0.0170287397,
-0.037080843,
-0.0403531753,
0.0158277471,
0.0122602126,
0.0178706665,
0.0259218048,
-0.0195969548,
0.0155908661,
-0.0155379595,
-0.0303108394,
0.0035363683,
-0.0639765039,
-0.0461455174,
-0.0022954301,
0.0185576547,
0.0183754954,
0.0290991105,
0.021959424,
-0.0046597715,
0.0240239836,
-0.0009970999,
-0.0165735595,
-0.0077097756,
-0.0425139479,
-0.0168076698,
-0.0104590897,
-0.0278790724,
0.01030662,
0.0464827456,
-0.0127621712,
-0.0127184168,
0.0137454551,
-0.0160937533,
0.0576407015,
0.0001410185,
0.0180258099,
-0.0065875622,
-0.0171955228,
-0.026550889,
0.0317706652,
-0.0121956477,
-0.0257973671,
-0.0190122537,
-0.0270942952,
-0.0276577119,
-0.044117257,
0.009935041,
-0.0007899993,
0.0077818236,
0.0119512407,
0.0262609683,
-0.0150134517,
-0.0367665328,
-0.0240246616,
-0.0420671515,
0.0035538676,
-0.0133367879,
0.0115943188,
0.0031723527,
-0.0039415397,
0.0056353617,
-0.0381690264,
-0.0754231662,
0.0089887856,
-0.0470138006,
0.019329669,
-0.001355518,
0.0278704464,
-0.0410815738,
-0.0078138961,
-0.0162773579,
0.0033947739,
0.0353949741,
0.0216424093,
-0.031214593,
-0.0587813221,
0.0429961309,
-0.031318035,
0.0407183282,
-0.0059933709,
0.0052297264,
-0.0192565359,
-0.004662354,
0.015804816,
0.0517291091,
-0.0054216236,
0.030029377,
0.0630466193,
-0.0071208626,
-0.0490211844,
-0.0053587733,
-0.0501404554,
-0.0293500666,
-0.0487938635,
-0.0344534852,
0.0032478722,
0.0110571394,
0.0129283648,
-0.0405356735,
-0.033910118,
0.0341333486,
-0.015791595,
-0.0512685515,
-0.0466111153,
-0.0236520804,
0.0169907939,
-0.0033586461,
0.0052792504,
-0.0496086851,
0.0876705199,
-0.0087584285,
0.018315969,
-0.0222774036,
-0.0199844446,
-0.0261817984,
0.0883929059,
0.0086052911,
0.0464470387,
0.025306195,
-0.0353364274,
-0.0170332957,
0.007237941,
0.0709123462,
-0.0459428616,
0.0021984694,
-0.0510755591,
-0.0264331065,
0.019791428,
-0.0321668014,
-0.0371885635,
-0.0612954535,
-0.0338673368,
0.0163516086,
-0.0355411731,
-0.0356190354,
0.0196314305,
-0.0391084515,
0.0210685898,
-0.0120916516,
0.0324681923,
0.0037114981,
-0.0326050632,
0.0052217548,
0.001715465,
-0.0291299801,
-0.0292758904,
-0.0545398183,
0.0227772444,
0.0698508918,
0.0828447863,
-0.0146903731,
0.0341098271,
-0.0281785782,
0.0221410189,
0.0047954288,
-0.0182198193,
0.0446539745,
0.0507498942,
-0.0708990172,
-0.002780576,
0.0884271264,
0.0184511244,
-0.0351298787,
-0.0175255239,
0.0098604262,
0.0238748696,
0.0140131563,
0.0202254355,
-0.059645623,
-0.0046345768,
0.0113530429,
0.034646228,
-0.0067247129,
-0.0767244175,
-0.0165646896,
-0.142494455,
-0.016049603,
0.0204081237,
-0.0343612954,
0.0069310348,
-0.0537764356,
-0.0054259212,
0.0048047658,
-0.0279780347,
-0.0420061611,
-0.0176205356,
-0.0206857231,
0.0077242632,
0.0022034775,
-0.0316856131,
0.0178554747,
-0.050981164,
0.107888028,
0.0440167673,
0.0155040072,
-0.0122293243,
-0.0643639863,
0.0047596563,
0.0546176769,
-0.0066112713,
0.0093959663,
0.0528543815,
0.0038657151,
-0.0028484492,
0.02321155,
0.0929304436,
-0.0110879829,
-0.0191281885,
0.031073777,
0.0700567141,
0.0087398514,
-0.0505064055,
0.035015434,
0.0017406512,
0.0350144655,
0.0994379073,
0.0138373049,
-0.019214442,
0.0362566151,
-0.0153397899,
0.0123839639,
0.0066628424,
-0.010256581,
0.0179842226,
-0.0164509397,
-0.0459495634,
-0.0730433166,
0.0147801917,
0.0539150722,
0.0096347136,
0.0692424253,
0.017639488,
0.0686808154,
-0.0019106595,
-0.0191095434,
0.0184360333,
-0.0993151367,
0.0160866417,
-0.0467147566,
-0.0492973849,
0.0031236995,
-0.0270825066,
-0.0153374346,
-0.0106297797,
-0.0811881423,
-0.091464363,
0.0039108004,
0.0431078672,
0.0138981454,
0.0691759139,
-0.0188512299,
-0.0813358426,
0.0561312921,
0.0457908809,
-0.035944026,
0.0087665161,
0.0355233327,
-0.0093389144,
0.0053337174,
0.0490276068,
-0.0157075636,
-0.0526784658,
0.0448977277,
-0.0211818758,
-0.0498352088,
-0.038985312,
0.0060397182,
0.0050326772,
0.0409777164,
0.0221488606,
0.0146404384,
-0.0419062227,
0.0181237888,
-0.0154161183,
-0.0151932314,
-0.0444599427,
-0.0152065977,
0.0467830598,
-0.0069239126,
0.0457102582,
-0.0134425992,
0.0426984392,
0.0304066502,
-0.0402247719,
0.0265559703,
0.0329691283,
0.0189986154,
0.0479821973,
0.0149789685,
-0.0156058092,
0.0331841446,
0.0200636256,
0.0338530391,
0.0014997822,
0.0592024401,
0.0078327022,
-0.0215701405,
0.0228508599,
0.0134733049,
-0.0606068857,
-0.0877505168,
-0.018479079,
0.0633024871,
-0.0082495091,
0.008167834,
-0.0028410633,
-0.0739783868,
0.0055897967,
-0.0260182861,
0.0253304169,
-0.0281415749,
-0.0720536932,
0.0291404147,
0.00969317,
0.0005673442,
0.0599522628,
0.0868453607,
0.0123595661,
0.0388115235,
-0.0206636637,
-0.0067270226,
-0.0467981249,
-0.0151282838,
0.0578560233,
0.0274784248,
-0.0293129273,
0.0142160244,
-0.0345556177,
-0.0744950548,
-0.0242609642,
-0.0123185357,
-0.0032493176,
-0.0113562234,
0.0546652153,
0.0305481013,
-0.0440873131,
-0.0103084845,
-0.0658298135,
0.0273195803,
0.0309580266,
-0.0228125323,
-0.0171334427,
-5.737165116e-33,
-0.0050279833,
-0.0371067785,
0.0022865769,
0.0532236584,
0.0327567421,
0.0107828649,
-0.0381238237,
0.0125807626,
0.0138416383,
0.0090753175,
-0.0153024364,
-0.0022939595,
-0.001574551,
0.0330865271,
-0.0091726417,
-0.0432132706,
0.0586348362,
-0.0179078095,
0.0156676341,
0.0522419736,
0.0381259732,
0.0276091248,
0.025467746,
-0.0885470659,
0.0565201901,
-0.0018801205,
-0.0150967948,
0.021000769,
-0.0387883894,
0.0235240087,
-0.0208749231,
0.002843929,
-0.0154911568,
-0.0109958807,
-0.0235506427,
0.041410666,
-0.0564673282,
-0.0090122875,
0.0009830595,
-0.0164277311,
-0.0192742851,
-0.0617745742,
0.0210732985,
-0.0433998592,
0.00381881,
0.0080973478,
0.0265311692,
-0.0128668966,
-0.023299763,
-0.0183364321,
-0.0037775701,
-0.0126841832,
-0.0348534249,
-0.0387891084,
0.0532347448,
-0.0044824984,
0.0088849552,
-0.0323931538,
-0.0191985294,
0.0445341803,
0.0301363487,
-0.0089058317,
0.0506413579,
0.0010613077,
0.0379813388,
0.0537852012,
0.0367910303,
0.0221085194,
0.0062130215,
-0.0177118629,
-0.0031028173,
0.0492468253,
0.0364926271,
0.0486109219,
-0.0411329716,
-0.0025474867,
-0.0102988388,
0.0063220118,
-0.0127327843,
-0.0313295461,
0.0311670415,
0.0043743961,
-0.0525633283,
-0.0147628495,
-0.0790527686,
0.0048524109,
-0.0259617288,
0.0338835604,
0.0022834172,
0.0241429694,
-0.0701578334,
-0.0186438914,
0.0033181016,
-0.0619838461,
-0.059619911,
0.0067289011,
0.0665826723,
-0.0040945895,
-0.0077917739,
-0.0206069928,
-0.0647008643,
-0.0155648822,
-0.0022822602,
-0.0332487747,
0.0109462794,
0.0192244072,
0.0500080101,
0.0362970941,
-0.0590004399,
-0.020691758,
-0.0536712483,
0.0150564052,
0.0488153808,
-0.0118347229,
0.043380782,
0.0043049166,
-0.0206687972,
0.0292132013,
0.0290543083,
-0.0054826024,
-0.0139266271,
0.0275028516,
-0.0426311158,
-0.0287016109,
-0.0183774531,
-0.0380866192,
-0.0182920601,
-0.0004521662,
0.1006142497,
0.0089314124,
0.014725849,
-0.0331538059,
2.613e-7,
-0.0363704041,
0.0177398473,
-0.0131192757,
-0.0161533915,
0.0091091646,
0.0746943504,
-0.0116171734,
0.0820337534,
0.0232069138,
-0.0121764578,
-0.0216958243,
0.0367411003,
0.0396066308,
0.0293161776,
-0.0899381712,
-0.0262547135,
-0.0145597272,
-0.0014432857,
-0.0448115803,
-0.0028624025,
0.0083559612,
0.0476694219,
0.0819681212,
-0.0047337757,
-0.0016449071,
-0.0445918068,
0.0539039746,
-0.0848968253,
-0.0382220037,
-0.0001532737,
0.0328324437,
0.0361848064,
-0.0016469356,
0.019813979,
-0.0317751355,
-0.01950844,
-0.0429058298,
0.0677598342,
0.0571366362,
-0.002600475,
-0.0024678539,
-0.0379781835,
-0.0325120538,
-0.0208265856,
0.0424018614,
-0.0464652516,
-0.0480123572,
0.0237334147,
0.0492066108,
-0.0842127725,
0.0007314407,
-0.0053381571,
-0.0072071399,
-0.0000917921,
-0.0062225079,
-0.0079996418,
0.0019588389,
-0.0382387713,
-0.0040901611,
-0.055496797,
-0.0225778706,
-0.0545404255,
-0.0047813361,
-0.007819091,
-0.0533406511,
-0.020584669,
0.0712298974,
1.966167437e-34,
-0.0126745207,
-0.0085849902,
-0.0112940297,
0.0099807344,
0.0296137873,
-0.0153811509,
-0.0243211277,
0.010804683,
0.0460999832,
-0.0574157611,
0.0003930583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11420v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11420v1 | Tuning LayerNorm in Attention: Towards Efficient Multi-Modal LLM Finetuning | 2023-12-18T18:21:43 | 2023-12-18T18:21:43 | Bingchen Zhao, Haoqin Tu, Chen Wei, Jieru Mei, Cihang Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | This paper introduces an efficient strategy to transform Large Language
Models (LLMs) into Multi-Modal Large Language Models (MLLMs). By
conceptualizing this transformation as a domain adaptation process, i.e.,
transitioning from text understanding to embracing multiple modalities, we
intriguingly note that, within each attention block, tuning LayerNorm suffices
to yield strong performance. Moreover, when benchmarked against other tuning
approaches like full parameter finetuning or LoRA, its benefits on efficiency
are substantial. For example, when compared to LoRA on a 13B model scale,
performance can be enhanced by an average of over 20% across five multi-modal
tasks, and meanwhile, results in a significant reduction of trainable
parameters by 41.9% and a decrease in GPU memory usage by 17.6%. On top of this
LayerNorm strategy, we showcase that selectively tuning only with
conversational data can improve efficiency further. Beyond these empirical
outcomes, we provide a comprehensive analysis to explore the role of LayerNorm
in adapting LLMs to the multi-modal domain and improving the expressive power
of the model. | [
0.0155257005,
0.0532788113,
-0.011105991,
0.060827814,
-0.0167517625,
0.0142607279,
0.0239007827,
-0.0335396379,
-0.0441677086,
-0.0707071126,
-0.0557759292,
-0.0520690531,
0.0002399473,
0.0315682366,
0.0303576421,
-0.0292842742,
0.0462503396,
-0.062685594,
-0.0052895197,
0.0181682203,
0.0051024589,
0.0174425747,
0.014861498,
0.0421452522,
0.0370796323,
-0.030122621,
-0.0333647951,
0.0129492627,
0.0117059452,
-0.0037944515,
0.0063203112,
0.037825577,
0.0434413366,
0.0208934322,
0.0000020449,
-0.0363159999,
-0.0017445149,
-0.0147320246,
0.0111834006,
0.0300135687,
0.0653336495,
-0.0192836132,
0.0206316318,
0.0150830848,
-0.0138795059,
-0.0033644768,
0.0365238301,
0.0658207983,
0.043254666,
0.0973728597,
-0.0101966672,
-0.0368126817,
0.0152439708,
-0.0478303842,
-0.035550952,
-0.0782908946,
0.0209879111,
-0.0055682766,
-0.0082331561,
0.0042581274,
-0.0306886137,
0.0520385392,
0.0064758584,
-0.0097698709,
-0.0089979796,
0.0306931604,
0.0311439782,
-0.0302140024,
-0.0092952391,
0.088539362,
-0.0471576005,
0.0073796706,
0.0151703516,
-0.0009522513,
0.0050413222,
-0.0227477457,
-0.0418147221,
0.0170744974,
0.0117627662,
0.0113506513,
-0.00380632,
-0.0457998291,
0.0522036776,
0.020608481,
-0.038193807,
0.0270624496,
0.0125515144,
0.0017988917,
-0.012551208,
-0.0204096902,
-0.0153941344,
-0.0564175844,
0.0036658896,
0.0409160964,
-0.0329655558,
0.0086288247,
-0.0713857934,
0.0139305042,
0.011828891,
-0.0195077397,
0.0636123493,
0.0301951729,
-0.0308468416,
0.0695074797,
-0.0172229186,
0.0010837566,
-0.0339523442,
0.0156535916,
-0.0369024724,
-0.0071288729,
-0.0069428207,
0.0184292365,
-0.0254830755,
-0.0011508917,
-0.0753280222,
-0.037615709,
0.0065189642,
0.0407444648,
0.0257836282,
-0.0295794718,
-0.0086457161,
-0.0103522465,
-0.0389700197,
-0.0519167185,
0.0130965784,
0.0629877895,
-0.0205724798,
0.0448109843,
0.0171367899,
-0.0598593354,
-0.0233603399,
0.0381504595,
0.0247908998,
-0.02934522,
-0.0072071878,
0.0680101737,
-0.0448309034,
-0.018667385,
-0.0456759557,
-0.0165034961,
-0.0149457045,
-0.0760430172,
0.0081611518,
-0.0210326593,
0.0275577381,
-0.0010217262,
-0.0030700096,
-0.025107557,
-0.0098501425,
0.0104642315,
-0.026399482,
0.039334096,
0.0252710562,
0.015765518,
0.0227620732,
0.0139279822,
0.0018543722,
0.0902053863,
0.0427354202,
0.008751112,
-0.0039442168,
-0.0334824845,
-0.010241352,
0.0286039133,
0.009571651,
0.0157574043,
-0.01560059,
0.0203297008,
-0.0060422304,
0.0302467179,
0.0780224577,
0.0271502901,
-0.0390905328,
-0.0178529918,
0.0743509829,
-0.0070966957,
0.0577957332,
0.0404234268,
0.0073988237,
0.0147160273,
-0.0097498326,
-0.0010064172,
-0.0846888125,
0.0593966916,
-0.0292019695,
0.0084477542,
0.0382300839,
0.0534553602,
-0.0211564582,
-0.0162094552,
-0.0032443902,
0.0055339662,
0.0102931522,
0.0278100558,
0.0275784303,
-0.0056339181,
-0.04545426,
0.0616938584,
0.0532916263,
-0.0199673343,
-0.0095283473,
-0.0519000255,
0.019502135,
0.0122782104,
-0.0167969093,
-0.01693899,
-0.0478291512,
-0.0248850007,
0.0581214875,
0.0537340827,
0.0267441738,
0.0111314496,
0.0629558414,
-0.0833378434,
0.0017295243,
-0.0491939262,
0.0073709302,
0.0417670496,
-0.0165576227,
0.0033677449,
0.0088551929,
-0.0327228978,
-0.0056057242,
0.0281195771,
-0.0075589498,
-0.0147882337,
-0.0132523198,
-0.0013449175,
0.0319829062,
-0.0071248924,
-0.0022683418,
-0.0076465523,
0.0111384243,
-0.0389424935,
0.0010585459,
0.0115422187,
-0.0499768332,
-0.0030632224,
0.0363346674,
-0.0016472762,
0.0024890578,
0.0204769559,
-0.044847291,
-0.0474739783,
0.0447415337,
-0.0246505439,
0.0308069512,
-0.0210203752,
0.0232124887,
-0.0013822684,
0.0537775233,
-0.0481624454,
0.0214616898,
0.0003510935,
-0.0209711418,
0.04810296,
0.0316965319,
-0.0021637352,
-0.0123700481,
-0.0123129236,
0.0278880931,
-0.0001378641,
0.0200310741,
-0.0186002422,
0.0228463188,
-0.048002556,
-0.0418387651,
-0.10185159,
0.0076998109,
-0.0343257822,
0.0234381501,
0.0352877565,
0.034403313,
-0.0104201604,
-0.0174968094,
-0.02157012,
0.0319726318,
-0.0157549232,
0.0114531592,
0.0083390772,
0.0140007408,
-0.0365641378,
-0.0359493792,
0.0018835779,
0.0251443572,
0.0470284298,
-0.0154502774,
-0.017416453,
-0.0648467392,
-0.0024754824,
-0.0058048652,
0.0325639062,
-0.0306178425,
-0.0358690955,
-0.0248676017,
-0.0209394433,
0.0444351472,
0.0937038735,
0.016687585,
0.0174913108,
0.0572661348,
-0.016377639,
-0.052280847,
0.0558129027,
0.0062880185,
-0.0307748374,
-0.070946537,
0.0019045617,
0.0197854303,
0.0968708321,
-0.0393384546,
0.0195492655,
-0.0265172254,
0.0093931733,
0.0224971306,
-0.0500517115,
0.0019129338,
0.0334896147,
-0.0327472985,
0.0332604237,
-0.0230306275,
-0.0415914431,
0.0421490557,
-0.0412763022,
-0.0421646237,
-0.0448050946,
-0.0214249473,
-0.0384958163,
0.0527459271,
-0.0135726547,
0.0327376612,
0.0046243132,
-0.0397066548,
-0.0431027003,
0.0099924067,
0.0025835847,
0.0023454039,
0.1020284817,
-0.0346839502,
0.0194724724,
-0.0428503789,
-0.0333116502,
-0.0008760071,
-0.0370230451,
-0.0495896116,
-0.0028585887,
-0.0130989188,
-0.0182732809,
-0.0652374923,
0.0116874324,
0.0176511556,
0.0443323776,
-0.0238991734,
0.01256127,
-0.0214817524,
0.0299270414,
0.0469473712,
0.0845042989,
0.0025351769,
-0.0189386159,
0.0272300895,
0.0430858918,
-0.0077527235,
0.0170748942,
-0.0305006318,
-0.0049483371,
0.041498255,
-0.0028683613,
-0.0159138516,
0.0223822109,
0.0805337727,
-0.07656499,
-0.0011532748,
0.096942395,
-0.0265383124,
-0.0565219112,
-0.0108919889,
-0.0093741352,
0.033414036,
0.0048735519,
0.0406021737,
-0.0596417002,
-0.0722118393,
0.0114225382,
0.0072611622,
0.0288930479,
-0.0036844476,
-0.0121557973,
-0.0714795515,
0.0177035257,
-0.0078510679,
-0.0452080891,
-0.0239629056,
-0.0266796276,
0.0147198364,
0.0064968327,
0.0418141596,
0.0116599528,
-0.0165813658,
-0.0303141344,
0.0161549058,
0.0374991037,
-0.0558649711,
0.0304196328,
-0.0199357904,
0.0668389201,
0.0308838375,
0.0279547404,
0.0024857938,
-0.0388996974,
0.0783658922,
0.0066529289,
0.0077379914,
-0.0167628359,
0.0066699195,
-0.0274606589,
-0.0120590143,
0.0069306414,
0.0261631981,
-0.0341140255,
-0.0124533735,
0.0022183172,
0.0413857773,
0.0011226046,
-0.0265472345,
-0.0094995201,
-0.0012795577,
-0.0061768019,
0.0736885071,
0.0566238351,
-0.0413069502,
-0.0344224423,
-0.0259908158,
-0.0398348495,
-0.0382929035,
-0.0132553661,
0.0061859107,
0.0047727572,
0.0108542331,
-0.0111169629,
-0.02563232,
0.0152379414,
0.0272174627,
-0.0021083779,
-0.0197375845,
0.0106051471,
0.0123255653,
-0.0238529518,
0.0697520301,
-0.0413128547,
0.0123527469,
-0.0745792091,
0.0024466361,
0.0567545369,
-0.0288757496,
-0.0044633392,
0.0167789683,
-0.1166621521,
-0.0715330914,
-0.0088530527,
-0.0001004554,
0.0181661993,
0.0543260984,
-0.0098385895,
-0.0973245874,
-0.0018955054,
0.0081726052,
-0.042247586,
0.0541977882,
0.0403060503,
0.0026373188,
-0.0094248159,
0.0745261833,
-0.0316656716,
0.011152626,
0.0364476256,
0.0444594324,
0.0033055348,
-0.0560491979,
-0.0229252353,
-0.0029143833,
0.017838303,
0.0089373766,
-0.0206152871,
-0.0316545404,
0.0208862033,
0.009201115,
0.0018604837,
-0.0682109669,
-0.0195359737,
0.0076961992,
-0.012755149,
0.0080753211,
0.0230974536,
0.0300528463,
-0.0038842591,
-0.0423885547,
0.0563178547,
0.0183414984,
-0.0266992208,
0.0290447082,
0.0020276355,
-0.0394557752,
0.0220906809,
0.0051378063,
0.0287706051,
-0.0302171968,
0.0606158972,
-0.0013427995,
-0.0308031514,
-0.0457023755,
0.0375082903,
-0.0634044334,
-0.0552469455,
-0.0233312249,
0.0066583492,
0.0474394187,
0.0124435863,
0.0958521441,
0.0150754545,
-0.0198775977,
-0.0194800533,
0.0433969572,
-0.0083220638,
-0.0057477709,
0.0503094979,
0.0232412703,
-0.0314216651,
0.0145931654,
0.0647199079,
0.0050505367,
0.0285898093,
0.0229584035,
0.0270291585,
-0.0261090565,
-0.028767474,
0.0152558936,
0.0559676327,
-0.0236399267,
0.0116890343,
-0.0079268999,
-0.0402649008,
0.010423705,
-0.0269023459,
-0.0025331529,
-0.0454785377,
0.0164291337,
0.067140013,
0.0068715853,
-0.0268567409,
-0.0331827886,
0.0140135335,
0.0256348271,
0.0101540592,
-0.0179034881,
-6.7230188e-33,
-0.0279814806,
0.0013806279,
0.0216702335,
-0.0301392805,
-0.0449753888,
0.0035916544,
-0.0469899401,
0.0142167155,
-0.0363406278,
-0.0073042298,
0.0020219458,
0.0096460497,
0.0142824939,
0.0451381244,
-0.0088900086,
-0.0256962888,
0.0580835864,
0.0024933324,
-0.0299465377,
0.0283313766,
-0.0051800692,
0.0280320067,
0.0473592207,
-0.037246529,
-0.0140019776,
0.0141704716,
-0.0322852843,
0.0222764537,
-0.0091229603,
0.0558190905,
-0.0251016766,
0.0189747661,
0.0332302786,
-0.0330481976,
-0.0282744449,
0.0360228457,
-0.0627097413,
-0.0027123829,
0.0566565469,
0.0107804267,
-0.0291034989,
-0.0459030867,
0.063929297,
0.0313222371,
0.0404210351,
-0.0557763092,
0.001145522,
-0.0129658747,
-0.0484852754,
-0.0019767915,
-0.0716399401,
0.0264622401,
-0.0088658547,
-0.0220601093,
0.0271188468,
0.0235074647,
-0.0121473251,
0.0378117338,
-0.0462149121,
-0.007416327,
0.0129761156,
0.0431034751,
0.0802932978,
0.0697441772,
-0.0175296832,
0.0386328436,
0.0323712006,
0.0137457317,
-0.0113758175,
-0.0172063317,
0.0398052633,
0.0596201234,
-0.0199635252,
0.0535323285,
-0.0216387678,
0.014926468,
-0.0726049691,
-0.0267595407,
0.0082040075,
0.0449511856,
0.0352357924,
0.0373281986,
0.0228815638,
-0.0219811033,
-0.0503284447,
-0.0071320739,
-0.0526063032,
0.0091760699,
0.04211393,
0.0242183004,
-0.0234209727,
-0.0134864189,
0.0708472431,
-0.0235319994,
-0.008200502,
-0.0038224843,
-0.0006667309,
0.0270525478,
0.0060454751,
0.0282064639,
-0.0307568889,
-0.0268338807,
0.0040996168,
-0.0171427056,
0.0121360784,
-0.0031276406,
0.0228621569,
0.0190073401,
-0.0661128312,
-0.0274792835,
-0.041342482,
-0.0015470814,
0.0054164105,
0.1001750827,
0.0239890944,
-0.0220408645,
-0.0255331825,
0.0662293956,
-0.0102139255,
0.0141619183,
-0.0344091207,
-0.0349944942,
0.0163487513,
0.0193808898,
-0.0458337851,
-0.0128821479,
-0.0378010347,
-0.0380499139,
0.0475347266,
-0.0552391,
-0.0382717997,
0.0168409366,
2.745e-7,
0.014795132,
0.0302422177,
-0.0270319302,
-0.0184531622,
0.0217918064,
0.0466251299,
-0.0023097408,
0.0234141778,
0.0409640074,
-0.0040756078,
-0.0246711336,
0.0320473053,
0.0402736142,
0.000747801,
-0.0753253251,
-0.0272349715,
-0.0323266983,
0.0173530448,
-0.0207151547,
-0.0224159807,
0.0056740642,
0.1234755069,
-0.0156253148,
-0.0098742098,
0.0308230966,
-0.059105169,
0.0564626642,
-0.0534347221,
-0.0255853683,
0.0297915339,
0.0392932259,
0.016932847,
-0.0116096111,
-0.0103339264,
0.0165633298,
0.0342448093,
-0.0161190927,
0.1244837642,
0.0065090638,
-0.0134951873,
0.0031577735,
-0.0112873763,
-0.002052993,
-0.0641355142,
0.0538202822,
-0.0705311596,
-0.0520923622,
-0.0673342124,
0.0161509011,
-0.0296552703,
-0.006542325,
-0.0128336148,
-0.0158910546,
0.0222380366,
0.0141820339,
-0.039208591,
-0.0287185032,
-0.0959193334,
-0.0505062118,
-0.0130941626,
-0.0626748204,
-0.0338818207,
-0.0632071272,
-0.0412393548,
0.0650455952,
-0.0805583745,
0.0069836271,
2.419236251e-34,
0.0399843045,
-0.0168452468,
0.0060611926,
0.0277867746,
0.0232540481,
-0.0009643629,
-0.0062281433,
-0.0055627846,
-0.0018591589,
-0.1489417851,
-0.0089078769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11399v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11399v1 | News Signals: An NLP Library for Text and Time Series | 2023-12-18T18:02:41 | 2023-12-18T18:02:41 | Chris Hokamp, Demian Gholipour Ghalandari, Parsa Ghaffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present an open-source Python library for building and using datasets
where inputs are clusters of textual data, and outputs are sequences of real
values representing one or more time series signals. The news-signals library
supports diverse data science and NLP problem settings related to the
prediction of time series behaviour using textual data feeds. For example, in
the news domain, inputs are document clusters corresponding to daily news
articles about a particular entity, and targets are explicitly associated
real-valued time series: the volume of news about a particular person or
company, or the number of pageviews of specific Wikimedia pages. Despite many
industry and research use cases for this class of problem settings, to the best
of our knowledge, News Signals is the only open-source library designed
specifically to facilitate data science and research settings with natural
language inputs and time series targets. In addition to the core codebase for
building and interacting with datasets, we also conduct a suite of experiments
using several popular Machine Learning libraries, which are used to establish
baselines for time series anomaly prediction using textual inputs. | [
-0.0030347877,
0.0817637369,
-0.0399461873,
-0.0027825655,
-0.0505194627,
0.025716247,
0.0176464375,
0.0258699358,
0.037381433,
-0.0183797479,
0.0847098902,
0.0189070199,
-0.0188557748,
0.0909661427,
-0.00830983,
-0.0510203689,
0.0596475936,
-0.0194882005,
0.0620420463,
0.0311102942,
0.0209606849,
0.0315951407,
0.0039428454,
0.0168604646,
-0.0331457257,
0.0095564891,
-0.0307058636,
-0.0198345222,
0.0439973846,
-0.0681951419,
-0.0098825982,
0.0098585263,
0.0331476852,
0.0600254163,
0.0000018948,
-0.0156239094,
-0.02770284,
-0.0425139405,
0.0023822195,
-0.0140945716,
0.053049922,
-0.0760453939,
0.0476277322,
0.0097841034,
-0.0849845931,
-0.0009646916,
0.0283602718,
0.0284761991,
0.0398197323,
0.0818913281,
-0.0205835458,
0.0367427729,
0.0034838715,
-0.0061539658,
0.0302950628,
-0.0032633445,
0.0303000696,
-0.0107398685,
0.0139683774,
-0.0067627574,
0.01240048,
-0.0005954053,
-0.0058296365,
0.0174736008,
0.0131386379,
0.042352695,
-0.0275436621,
-0.0181533378,
-0.042648837,
0.0203987993,
0.0053834147,
-0.0473856293,
0.0388609916,
-0.017627662,
-0.0241203755,
0.0395803079,
-0.0322272554,
-0.0180809665,
0.029126443,
0.0279568639,
0.0367688462,
0.0253121797,
-0.0092816642,
0.0318700187,
0.0019452898,
0.0562015437,
-0.0038886366,
-0.0331348777,
-0.035233628,
0.0159466378,
0.0207593273,
-0.0496184267,
-0.0051550418,
0.021185562,
-0.0139259305,
-0.0090455404,
-0.0116360513,
-0.0416931435,
0.0024766459,
-0.0547715165,
-0.025536973,
0.0014048539,
0.015329957,
0.0261653308,
0.0503649078,
-0.01136423,
0.0216609109,
-0.04772003,
0.00742184,
0.0148755293,
-0.0700323284,
-0.0029955301,
0.0243636835,
-0.0319081545,
0.0076733748,
-0.0057869027,
-0.0174336098,
0.0152434707,
0.0077408026,
0.0167725179,
-0.0265596621,
0.0221077148,
-0.0200619381,
0.020455746,
-0.0019818931,
0.0075651468,
-0.0449692309,
0.0449240543,
-0.0232201647,
-0.0203441717,
-0.0180178937,
0.0083652316,
0.0249954462,
0.0040456085,
0.0124638965,
0.02380668,
0.0549840555,
0.0042427555,
-0.0859113857,
-0.0468865931,
-0.0142712668,
0.000678231,
-0.0624264851,
-0.032953959,
-0.0144774895,
0.0181138087,
0.0128489556,
0.0165724177,
-0.0254773218,
0.01134203,
-0.0189970937,
0.0327508263,
-0.0182257835,
0.0038850594,
0.0088186981,
-0.0243690554,
0.0352388509,
0.0657958686,
0.0265636574,
0.0009753851,
0.065850161,
-0.0447250269,
0.0086749531,
-0.0102324635,
0.0155424047,
-0.0255996082,
-0.0374489352,
0.0160324927,
-0.0422221571,
-0.0057143983,
-0.0163979828,
-0.021731073,
0.0168815926,
-0.0176055077,
0.0202686507,
0.0486936159,
-0.009237159,
-0.0013646006,
0.0229539536,
-0.0102633573,
-0.0217508562,
-0.0438656881,
0.0141103175,
0.0299730003,
-0.0488034375,
0.0295132864,
-0.0510345995,
0.0369042307,
-0.0332354307,
-0.0348571278,
-0.0352919288,
0.0021840921,
0.0475530215,
-0.0467417315,
0.0383396558,
-0.0198744554,
0.0054631103,
-0.0202354323,
0.0255003925,
0.0181645919,
0.0169332586,
0.0156786591,
0.0306791347,
0.0753953457,
0.0330235735,
-0.0354984179,
0.0290484726,
-0.0359454565,
0.0165484902,
-0.0064041833,
-0.0044335783,
-0.0115436055,
-0.0261325985,
-0.0396386944,
-0.006926273,
0.0300730485,
0.013569287,
-0.0174717978,
0.0015515821,
0.077735737,
-0.0013694083,
-0.036355678,
-0.0501780584,
0.0305284597,
-0.02297014,
-0.0621912815,
0.002873044,
-0.0121167665,
0.0221331846,
0.0117304884,
0.0024113776,
0.003159147,
0.0433574542,
-0.0162237417,
-0.0373251885,
0.0443574339,
0.0118160564,
0.0060890471,
-0.0010895196,
-0.0228485595,
-0.0015046198,
0.043706689,
-0.0463976152,
-0.050235115,
0.0586294569,
-0.0157280918,
0.0495914407,
-0.0467289276,
-0.0620384626,
0.0107987178,
0.0310093891,
0.0056485152,
0.0343477875,
0.006028234,
0.0196845029,
-0.0078105922,
-0.0081640407,
-0.0126538817,
0.0061406,
-0.0089752693,
-0.0213423707,
-0.0048890803,
0.0230991784,
0.0428432189,
-0.0264979582,
-0.0307486895,
0.033085797,
-0.018994011,
-0.0224827565,
-0.0091049466,
0.0135546615,
0.009376769,
-0.0085175857,
-0.0226797257,
-0.0339122228,
0.0152140623,
-0.0183909964,
0.0048833173,
0.0228830092,
0.0719012171,
-0.0038393915,
-0.0133465463,
-0.0065542702,
0.0015489159,
-0.0577658527,
0.069382295,
0.0533690453,
-0.0440062806,
-0.0014372393,
-0.027267646,
-0.0150795747,
-0.0133575257,
-0.0098198177,
-0.002875309,
-0.0139596574,
-0.027417073,
0.0105917063,
0.0290258881,
0.0354431346,
0.0430035144,
-0.0128285522,
-0.0493002161,
-0.0376361199,
0.0102661252,
-0.0546378456,
0.0799033195,
-0.0196278598,
0.0045930864,
0.0155482795,
0.0423550606,
0.0221745577,
-0.0090787141,
-0.0370922089,
0.0297052544,
-0.0396104865,
-0.000837653,
-0.0294610895,
-0.0096199429,
-0.0225183144,
0.05937282,
0.0221859198,
-0.0535625629,
0.063279815,
0.0254581776,
0.0096023381,
-0.0248118155,
-0.0636306778,
-0.0689581856,
0.0287886802,
-0.0169214439,
-0.0040574716,
0.014576653,
-0.0348639786,
0.0206961632,
0.0060227048,
0.002370517,
0.0010819221,
-0.0094592674,
-0.0089605134,
0.0177841671,
0.0373034701,
0.0169237927,
-0.0348188058,
-0.0233495366,
-0.0328410193,
-0.0418225974,
-0.0196072869,
-0.0506159328,
-0.0580856875,
0.0229278598,
-0.0323372819,
-0.0140440259,
0.0072406847,
-0.036999166,
0.0649934933,
0.0365619063,
0.0353895947,
-0.0391562693,
-0.0079151178,
-0.0056709321,
0.0004540002,
0.0125793256,
0.0127650397,
0.0431529544,
-0.0577955246,
0.0439941399,
-0.0194163043,
-0.0551966503,
0.0164397769,
0.0170594454,
-0.0204906184,
-0.0344816782,
-0.0206795167,
0.114783898,
0.0571815521,
-0.0181936622,
0.0132654039,
0.0233705733,
0.0364550315,
0.0129550621,
0.0012753188,
-0.0548476055,
-0.0054548546,
-0.0218367819,
0.0453548841,
-0.0273922756,
-0.0687631294,
0.0008617107,
-0.0545036644,
0.02724161,
0.0127540799,
-0.0197083969,
-0.0177275185,
-0.1373552382,
-0.0072486131,
-0.0868407339,
-0.0016908668,
-0.0429431126,
-0.0021426072,
0.0438442826,
0.0505862236,
-0.1133282781,
-0.07246764,
0.0091942279,
0.0326109305,
0.0281719211,
0.0219838582,
0.0548668653,
-0.0319396779,
-0.0009187211,
-0.0776732489,
0.0069518615,
0.0270176753,
-0.0463259071,
0.0668793544,
-0.0058838013,
-0.0130948862,
-0.0558777675,
0.0836689398,
-0.0741623491,
-0.0105797509,
0.0168208219,
0.0781022906,
-0.0145344622,
-0.0436608382,
-0.0600387417,
-0.0049445708,
0.0632966757,
0.0664423779,
-0.0154654644,
-0.0369999968,
-0.0177194122,
0.0018095346,
0.000750633,
-0.0297173969,
-0.0439197272,
-0.0180345569,
0.0182524808,
-0.0532858483,
-0.0616287254,
-0.0558514856,
0.0065837665,
0.0158196222,
0.006298996,
0.0139646409,
0.0016644313,
-0.0414399505,
-0.0540752597,
-0.0113876639,
0.0400865376,
0.0384018272,
0.0151380803,
-0.0041510942,
0.0235161129,
0.0260821078,
-0.0397034287,
0.0449030995,
-0.1249918714,
-0.0661747977,
0.0451359525,
-0.0347898789,
0.0214983076,
0.018457951,
0.0130889462,
0.0363589004,
0.0679755881,
0.0924750194,
-0.029165592,
-0.017296331,
0.0031992875,
-0.0105364705,
0.0349928662,
0.0013486041,
0.0054831733,
0.04477394,
-0.0467186496,
-0.0334560275,
-0.0811905116,
0.0018171712,
-0.0158419237,
-0.0088283988,
0.0428852774,
0.0141535383,
-0.0472339578,
-0.023871351,
-0.0510267764,
-0.0096247466,
-0.0121944984,
-0.0004735489,
0.007554817,
0.010776544,
-0.0054859337,
-0.0532154292,
0.0637151897,
0.0204837024,
-0.0271350946,
-0.0741244778,
0.0566095971,
0.0410805382,
0.0660896525,
-0.0158705804,
0.0179753639,
0.0220376216,
-0.0007718325,
-0.0368003584,
0.0273130406,
0.0114163477,
-0.0065465635,
-0.0048669386,
0.0526081957,
0.0206540506,
-0.0195529927,
-0.1020954177,
0.0161616933,
0.0113521153,
-0.0175411161,
-0.0323500335,
-0.0700130388,
0.0276564974,
-0.0537448116,
0.0301115662,
0.0119967116,
0.0529614687,
0.0048539089,
0.033372011,
-0.0068278001,
-0.0017969467,
-0.0797055662,
0.0236724876,
0.072912015,
-0.0428616926,
0.0570456386,
0.054407537,
-0.0396921933,
-0.0271532927,
0.0333652422,
0.0318249017,
-0.0042446433,
0.0051622605,
-0.0183441006,
-0.0517148599,
-0.0047722645,
0.0478494354,
-0.0264372118,
0.0321918875,
0.0204102956,
0.0043259743,
0.058549352,
0.0075930757,
0.0687521547,
-0.0120742284,
-0.0150577556,
-0.0435565338,
-0.0607740693,
-0.066064477,
-6.015894663e-33,
0.0103905834,
-0.051194869,
-0.0256217606,
-0.0051022531,
0.0299537331,
0.065563336,
0.0053904145,
-0.0243577231,
0.0120660421,
0.0060564443,
0.0058018388,
0.0246918537,
0.00430563,
-0.0174075309,
0.0632403269,
-0.0125277964,
0.0157413166,
-0.004353717,
0.0359613337,
0.0238968544,
0.1119493395,
0.0419032946,
0.0635348111,
-0.0277510677,
0.0303246677,
-0.0073584183,
-0.0194547195,
-0.035353452,
0.0685629845,
0.0251080636,
-0.0101842014,
0.0543015637,
0.017023107,
-0.045228146,
-0.0482107103,
0.0413896032,
-0.0148382047,
-0.0803341195,
-0.0213209055,
-0.0055111074,
0.007993998,
0.0132729141,
0.0147837484,
-0.0131490463,
-0.0220056381,
0.0367059223,
0.0530490801,
-0.0162821673,
-0.0048937974,
0.0042508421,
-0.0099338526,
0.0432619937,
-0.0833084136,
0.0461002775,
0.0159554165,
0.0363301635,
0.0256192349,
0.0331265032,
-0.0539603159,
0.0537046157,
-0.0021608202,
0.0015357523,
0.0082770865,
-0.0282959454,
0.0170907788,
0.0527492538,
0.0059996978,
-0.0251804106,
0.0067457561,
0.0902422816,
0.0242667366,
0.0483454578,
0.0281270295,
0.0587072782,
0.0492982268,
-0.0680015609,
-0.0468500443,
0.0580855459,
0.0411767922,
-0.015941944,
-0.0006651257,
0.00708189,
-0.055893749,
-0.0099709881,
0.0155809522,
-0.0131359315,
0.0003175608,
-0.019873172,
-0.0050326376,
0.02330417,
-0.0148327937,
0.0367545485,
-0.0055700862,
-0.0280845314,
-0.0276288185,
0.0217788629,
-0.0225931592,
-0.0132291224,
0.0128815006,
-0.0104780719,
-0.0446040034,
-0.0283950493,
0.0271468908,
0.0188109614,
0.0307487808,
-0.0725668669,
0.0102689127,
0.0640437827,
-0.05662328,
-0.0247946624,
0.0203077812,
0.0184472669,
-0.0117660807,
-0.006958337,
0.0301096495,
-0.029947428,
-0.0190123897,
0.0398175865,
0.0008612825,
0.0248296913,
0.0014923337,
-0.0184563529,
-0.0281573944,
-0.0147313531,
-0.0105624022,
-0.0540024675,
-0.0146800019,
-0.0348138623,
0.0463349819,
-0.0258346312,
-0.0050993268,
0.0136803919,
2.718e-7,
0.0360773727,
0.0865275413,
0.043932762,
0.0801880732,
0.0109568853,
0.0106624784,
-0.0137696369,
0.0438023657,
-0.0292252302,
-0.000895373,
0.04244164,
-0.0182275064,
0.0199100673,
0.0587478727,
-0.0480146967,
-0.0285836924,
-0.0936044306,
0.0038993096,
-0.1104717255,
-0.0102198124,
0.0486412533,
0.0689030215,
0.0673008785,
-0.0005416839,
0.0377444588,
-0.0458306111,
-0.0001176071,
-0.0195537563,
-0.0115458444,
0.0004459531,
0.0316338018,
0.0214015041,
0.0154518271,
0.0062823645,
-0.0566568561,
-0.006247872,
-0.0523629524,
-0.0321342461,
-0.0114557352,
-0.0071049682,
0.0005088152,
0.005803572,
-0.0056231748,
-0.0416175947,
0.0600866154,
0.0310213957,
-0.0445751958,
-0.0600436255,
-0.0554948598,
0.0342444479,
0.0323022045,
0.0369816758,
0.0058229016,
0.0393392332,
-0.0104417577,
0.0196319297,
0.0150744803,
-0.0198108852,
-0.0010652692,
-0.0127392411,
-0.0118124438,
0.0023507157,
-0.0380335413,
0.0015712824,
0.0124626476,
-0.028648369,
-0.0007623832,
2.625687038e-34,
0.0281833243,
0.0185111612,
-0.040800266,
0.0187551472,
0.0104763936,
-0.0070577399,
-0.0287849158,
-0.0048279194,
0.0290540885,
-0.0495563149,
-0.0096001197
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.