id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15561v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15561v3 | README: Bridging Medical Jargon and Lay Understanding for Patient Education through Data-Centric NLP | 2023-12-24T23:01:00 | 2024-06-17T02:12:24 | Zonghai Yao, Nandyala Siddharth Kantu, Guanghao Wei, Hieu Tran, Zhangqi Duan, Sunjae Kwon, Zhichao Yang, README annotation team, Hong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advancement in healthcare has shifted focus toward patient-centric
approaches, particularly in self-care and patient education, facilitated by
access to Electronic Health Records (EHR). However, medical jargon in EHRs
poses significant challenges in patient comprehension. To address this, we
introduce a new task of automatically generating lay definitions, aiming to
simplify complex medical terms into patient-friendly lay language. We first
created the README dataset, an extensive collection of over 50,000 unique
(medical term, lay definition) pairs and 300,000 mentions, each offering
context-aware lay definitions manually annotated by domain experts. We have
also engineered a data-centric Human-AI pipeline that synergizes data
filtering, augmentation, and selection to improve data quality. We then used
README as the training data for models and leveraged a Retrieval-Augmented
Generation method to reduce hallucinations and improve the quality of model
outputs. Our extensive automatic and human evaluations demonstrate that
open-source mobile-friendly models, when fine-tuned with high-quality data, are
capable of matching or even surpassing the performance of state-of-the-art
closed-source large language models like ChatGPT. This research represents a
significant stride in closing the knowledge gap in patient education and
advancing patient-centric healthcare solutions. | [
0.0558295771,
0.0485983975,
-0.0063095661,
-0.017688388,
0.0073648524,
-0.0044680904,
-0.0313881263,
0.0109423893,
0.0292249937,
-0.0426770821,
-0.0157882217,
-0.024107663,
-0.0146277454,
0.0260103103,
0.0140025895,
-0.0623360239,
0.0317327045,
0.05540362,
0.0083510177,
0.0178723615,
-0.0127773732,
0.0221308582,
-0.0242372137,
0.063656278,
-0.0149331819,
-0.0139033282,
0.0342537612,
0.0178138781,
-0.0116732996,
-0.1040846258,
0.03886161,
0.0495640673,
-0.0189927798,
-0.0014374306,
0.0000021113,
-0.0347592235,
-0.0173940416,
0.0272438582,
-0.0444524847,
-0.0564459674,
0.0488922969,
-0.0453108996,
0.0168001503,
-0.0103492262,
-0.0467814468,
-0.0260153338,
0.0147440247,
0.0403011106,
0.0596665926,
0.0604110137,
-0.0112430621,
-0.0241851564,
-0.0099867089,
-0.010831818,
0.0552882329,
-0.0402125977,
0.0246430952,
0.0203428771,
0.0265886299,
-0.0035806138,
0.0135667659,
0.0337902233,
-0.0115656005,
0.0496841334,
0.0628596991,
0.0404046401,
-0.0306473393,
-0.0018455368,
-0.0096047204,
0.087350361,
0.0178261157,
-0.0241174642,
0.0267732609,
0.0072509027,
-0.003910739,
0.011465339,
-0.0383045077,
-0.0017409523,
-0.0333652571,
0.0093109664,
-0.0312487334,
-0.0197520964,
0.0603991188,
0.0267118588,
-0.0107108839,
-0.0237993803,
0.0145658785,
-0.0298371632,
0.0194047317,
-0.0078531578,
-0.0058825728,
-0.0435396507,
0.0438599624,
0.0310309306,
-0.0494551063,
0.0331717432,
-0.0358483419,
-0.0242683869,
0.0717453212,
-0.060097158,
-0.0009079906,
0.0097592818,
-0.0206575338,
0.0313390121,
-0.0078843422,
-0.0488655493,
0.0008526599,
0.0121579235,
-0.0193129499,
0.0197730251,
-0.0538331345,
-0.0129328985,
-0.0409952626,
0.0174904205,
-0.0310268775,
-0.0042339885,
-0.08290115,
-0.0416108966,
-0.0331657566,
0.0164904147,
0.0141132912,
0.0638456866,
-0.0450776368,
-0.0239409097,
-0.0174114816,
-0.0192916151,
-0.0193554442,
0.0094772326,
-0.0018113231,
-0.0635205954,
0.0233430378,
-0.0063940319,
-0.0004734551,
0.0067641325,
0.0046526836,
0.0457891412,
-0.0040142806,
-0.0239668973,
-0.023276411,
-0.0751070902,
-0.0246251598,
0.0102139618,
-0.0035372719,
-0.0469961539,
0.0314850546,
-0.0322289802,
0.0097995736,
-0.1079238504,
0.0468489937,
0.0563161932,
-0.0646786466,
0.083393611,
-0.0781821311,
0.0137956087,
0.0442358963,
0.0616845079,
-0.0031411266,
0.0410594866,
0.035005793,
-0.0324324258,
0.042519059,
-0.0238883123,
0.0236610565,
0.0002875885,
0.0395328552,
-0.0521328077,
0.0185341034,
0.0074998224,
-0.0391646773,
0.0863752514,
-0.0270267893,
0.0697054863,
-0.0157977808,
0.0126223527,
0.0154301496,
0.0479362309,
0.0329869576,
0.0116228554,
0.0311654694,
-0.0077503189,
-0.0040877685,
-0.0278979,
-0.0212169234,
-0.0224009957,
0.0087985396,
0.003753501,
0.0259808712,
-0.014280742,
-0.0311593283,
-0.0386666767,
-0.0277507156,
-0.0109858895,
0.0105859675,
-0.0112606669,
0.0135612441,
0.0303730406,
-0.0237604305,
0.0895075053,
0.062121328,
-0.0478511676,
-0.0016405054,
-0.0434058011,
-0.0335647538,
0.0917863175,
0.0953285843,
-0.0278737992,
-0.0746632442,
-0.0260987356,
0.0263493937,
0.0378663018,
0.0133193191,
-0.0334403738,
0.0042331317,
-0.056268461,
0.0037204921,
0.0397889204,
0.0310196057,
-0.0416787453,
0.0388075598,
0.0072301612,
0.0330561996,
-0.0387464017,
-0.0591697656,
0.0481790602,
-0.0492506474,
-0.0443743281,
0.0261264481,
0.0050636646,
0.0133605609,
0.0475608781,
0.0015009675,
0.0373457074,
0.038479466,
-0.0185316503,
0.0091611594,
0.0025753095,
-0.0215887614,
0.0243456606,
0.0094899964,
-0.0307755712,
0.0107411463,
-0.0327595957,
-0.0138639705,
-0.02982492,
-0.0406873301,
-0.0385364704,
0.0459815376,
-0.0293028615,
0.0176628828,
0.0793573558,
0.0235326607,
-0.0348391868,
0.0338467546,
-0.0207229983,
0.0135176694,
0.0169255286,
-0.0023308753,
-0.0170502383,
-0.0044012642,
0.005341439,
-0.0156817175,
-0.0235034078,
0.0198618621,
0.0140106827,
0.0361408405,
-0.0480425917,
-0.0042717769,
-0.1093483791,
-0.0157543607,
0.0146376742,
-0.0213885568,
0.0356375203,
0.0380635038,
-0.00740038,
-0.0378814079,
-0.0135833872,
0.0094586248,
0.0191027671,
0.0219894778,
0.0167278592,
0.0262142234,
-0.0205347259,
-0.0319292098,
0.0128851933,
-0.0335148424,
-0.003700993,
0.0027086907,
-0.0270153973,
0.0095444638,
-0.0454910398,
-0.046515923,
-0.0224513542,
0.0163743533,
-0.00344946,
0.0245606545,
0.0098853558,
-0.0005913918,
0.0071090641,
0.0202342048,
0.0534078926,
-0.0031679792,
-0.0323691517,
-0.025650939,
0.00835519,
-0.0293013062,
-0.0425961688,
0.0131601645,
-0.058933761,
0.0113769341,
0.077553764,
0.0067244833,
0.0137799922,
-0.0331759974,
0.007916295,
-0.0278485026,
-0.0122251967,
-0.0538380519,
0.0334094651,
-0.0507371724,
0.047006432,
-0.0089688348,
-0.0035527421,
0.0880734473,
0.0068415385,
0.0317960083,
-0.0564961135,
-0.0049610003,
-0.0269639399,
0.014277298,
-0.042978406,
0.0160502996,
0.0300703794,
-0.0345333554,
0.0008183286,
0.0151074138,
-0.0123861479,
-0.083401069,
0.0589787215,
-0.0378358327,
0.0078553408,
0.0340295359,
-0.033742547,
-0.0623086095,
-0.0170024801,
-0.0249674208,
-0.0195397735,
0.0414916947,
0.0068420097,
-0.0503511764,
-0.0115402779,
-0.0267476495,
0.0595918261,
0.0538335368,
-0.0358075276,
0.0077651301,
0.0156251863,
0.0387100838,
0.0259268023,
-0.0206224974,
-0.006154025,
0.016469961,
0.0687082335,
0.0049928618,
-0.0114117907,
0.0188977364,
-0.0179221835,
0.0033488795,
-0.0414552726,
0.0013496826,
0.0420755707,
0.0341396518,
-0.044342801,
-0.0306451414,
0.0979908928,
0.038760975,
-0.0499934927,
0.0542815737,
0.0033103388,
-0.0119569646,
-0.0144724911,
0.0181420166,
-0.0984203443,
-0.047702346,
-0.0165450722,
0.0465386584,
0.0181389619,
-0.0116033433,
0.0113549838,
-0.0180473458,
0.0117023103,
0.0119098574,
-0.0280810464,
-0.0072733993,
-0.0206175055,
0.0091882357,
0.0014670638,
0.0028988614,
-0.0178912859,
-0.0297704246,
-0.0015652176,
-0.0083936965,
-0.046302598,
-0.0791716799,
0.0464885943,
-0.0087736687,
0.045299191,
0.0969527438,
0.0471768454,
0.0220045056,
-0.0371317118,
0.0059220563,
-0.0157130361,
0.0130994702,
-0.0080558676,
0.0657348856,
-0.0153105166,
0.0154556865,
-0.0208875909,
0.0625334531,
-0.0672332942,
-0.0488942713,
0.0000210907,
0.0400475524,
-0.0140448725,
-0.0025668156,
-0.041852843,
0.0402159356,
0.0600443482,
0.0636925474,
0.0193892252,
-0.0001383557,
0.0032577999,
0.0104724271,
0.0719329864,
0.0000462391,
-0.0166385341,
0.0197400171,
-0.0585785098,
-0.0221468844,
-0.0785613731,
-0.0598137379,
0.0383878946,
0.0015831453,
0.037716601,
0.00818785,
0.0207736976,
0.0125023453,
-0.0686034337,
0.0504889078,
-0.0045479676,
0.0089014387,
-0.0588202998,
-0.0807097629,
0.0078711957,
-0.0046592834,
-0.0104607586,
0.0540137403,
-0.0054926351,
-0.0012518195,
0.0281565897,
0.0462358966,
0.0230365042,
0.0335449614,
-0.0145571306,
-0.0180819947,
0.0189500917,
0.0790728107,
-0.0834422484,
-0.021284977,
-0.0142505132,
0.0315957665,
-0.0172503199,
0.0333977304,
-0.0244727228,
0.0378644951,
-0.0156706106,
0.0561889894,
-0.0190527085,
-0.0440828986,
0.0465772524,
0.0170917157,
0.0323369503,
-0.045878455,
-0.008459948,
-0.0100864004,
-0.0012248012,
-0.0339959338,
-0.020544,
-0.0130131338,
0.0008688725,
-0.006088478,
-0.0174169522,
-0.0108611863,
0.0097487476,
-0.058444038,
-0.0231388621,
-0.049100399,
-0.0104963193,
-0.0048890947,
-0.0031398665,
0.0092130909,
-0.0261721704,
-0.0026307853,
0.0435955971,
-0.0120406616,
0.0366969109,
-0.0101327794,
0.0680565685,
-0.0132951541,
0.0347652696,
-0.0361949429,
0.0473418906,
-0.0305812247,
-0.0425760075,
-0.0505311117,
0.0255849622,
0.0353224576,
-0.008745579,
0.0292070881,
-0.0298518334,
-0.0202765372,
-0.0176138915,
0.011301212,
-0.0268969014,
0.004078296,
0.0256764181,
0.0148354983,
-0.0014265573,
-0.0448080078,
0.0921523571,
-0.024894679,
0.0573234521,
-0.004247135,
-0.0486534014,
-0.0566643104,
-0.0176681802,
0.0115035223,
0.0548715517,
-0.054290574,
0.020166276,
-0.0835474581,
-0.0422392897,
0.0277938284,
0.0003944288,
-0.0165054537,
0.0094909417,
0.0699995756,
0.0496062748,
0.0110106235,
-0.0161948595,
-0.0427433811,
0.055202838,
-0.0396752805,
-0.0102972994,
-0.0005400936,
-6.256052934e-33,
-0.014816599,
-0.0307072997,
0.0373390429,
-0.0497853234,
-0.0143896146,
0.0266286228,
-0.0401962139,
0.0092772143,
0.0044807745,
0.0470790602,
-0.0307225473,
0.0111083537,
-0.0046166847,
0.0475765318,
0.0215089489,
-0.0157141872,
0.03968459,
0.0274618585,
-0.0151550993,
0.0375935324,
0.0004911157,
0.0741469413,
0.0151965022,
-0.0831708238,
0.0429876186,
0.0109842299,
0.0142818503,
0.0042913887,
0.0214779917,
0.0417591259,
-0.0595022738,
0.0348510928,
0.0388402753,
0.0173914228,
-0.0076375776,
-0.0061528236,
-0.0675144494,
-0.0220183637,
-0.0039300742,
-0.0146154119,
-0.0608390048,
-0.0445947126,
0.0758939907,
-0.0299251657,
-0.0420652293,
0.0221835747,
0.0315565355,
-0.0294890478,
-0.0334470719,
0.0046826126,
-0.0411154777,
0.0333400257,
0.0107439915,
-0.0448192693,
-0.0226377156,
-0.0135305999,
-0.0468986072,
0.0300587043,
-0.0656184182,
0.0140291657,
0.0074783093,
0.0202736706,
0.0313310809,
-0.0383965746,
-0.0077024526,
0.0567881167,
0.0216167271,
-0.0005447389,
-0.0801587403,
-0.0073002134,
-0.0595929623,
0.0566130392,
-0.0067395181,
0.0337980874,
0.0506339967,
-0.0336896107,
-0.0254485868,
0.055032663,
-0.0608028211,
0.0580886304,
-0.0103195971,
-0.0230933633,
-0.0626026541,
-0.0052923318,
0.000491227,
0.0221122541,
-0.0146125155,
-0.0509599373,
0.038573917,
0.0044478914,
-0.0062606563,
0.0156203927,
-0.0495835468,
-0.0117023019,
0.0230545923,
-0.0485508256,
0.0555413477,
-0.0325969495,
-0.0314335749,
-0.0149533162,
-0.0307131354,
-0.0013664761,
0.0154407099,
0.0052319956,
0.036924541,
0.0225598142,
-0.0002555695,
-0.0317712873,
-0.0341605395,
-0.0057418854,
0.0105254827,
-0.0112833744,
-0.027005503,
-0.0102073168,
0.0665550828,
0.0485768355,
-0.0066543235,
0.0631174371,
0.0160636343,
0.0034997456,
-0.0362534486,
-0.0576723665,
0.0298499819,
0.0164593905,
-0.0354642607,
0.0100152446,
-0.0590236224,
0.0067459731,
0.0515819266,
-0.0539403707,
-0.0013995121,
-0.0185689703,
2.858e-7,
0.0783089772,
0.0438714437,
-0.001704729,
-0.0005050258,
0.0128298393,
-0.006956697,
0.0200944915,
-0.0162511449,
-0.0427839458,
-0.0353531018,
0.0278298073,
0.0123255784,
0.0308497585,
0.0344515331,
-0.0528650954,
-0.0390283316,
-0.06345772,
0.0250989292,
-0.0214386042,
-0.0570330173,
0.0670036152,
0.0352068879,
-0.0347154327,
-0.0325621143,
-0.0105059016,
0.0094629778,
0.0413097851,
-0.0373001918,
0.0222344566,
0.0498400033,
0.0439059399,
0.0254948791,
0.0117543191,
0.023711836,
-0.0579017177,
-0.048938863,
0.0401497297,
0.0736728311,
-0.0429703705,
0.0334588587,
0.0115333525,
-0.0045643216,
0.0176307596,
-0.0285227429,
0.033477582,
-0.0625612885,
-0.0296080094,
-0.0001468323,
-0.0541756675,
0.0164910331,
0.0225883462,
-0.0268123876,
-0.0592143238,
0.0227516964,
0.0297227204,
0.0465037636,
-0.0340432152,
-0.0832088888,
-0.0108777145,
0.02836206,
-0.0181224458,
0.0113033792,
0.0111847045,
-0.0245730225,
-0.0371134095,
-0.0414347686,
0.0176274609,
2.385638234e-34,
0.01380526,
0.0170799326,
0.022693634,
0.0294111855,
0.0334336683,
-0.0136001995,
0.0606100708,
0.0260764398,
0.0248203147,
-0.035721425,
-0.0022239713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15550v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15550v1 | Multi-level biomedical NER through multi-granularity embeddings and enhanced labeling | 2023-12-24T21:45:36 | 2023-12-24T21:45:36 | Fahime Shahrokh, Nasser Ghadiri, Rasoul Samani, Milad Moradi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, 68T07, J.3; I.2.7; I.2.1 | Biomedical Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a fundamental task of Biomedical
Natural Language Processing for extracting relevant information from biomedical
texts, such as clinical records, scientific publications, and electronic health
records. The conventional approaches for biomedical NER mainly use traditional
machine learning techniques, such as Conditional Random Fields and Support
Vector Machines or deep learning-based models like Recurrent Neural Networks
and Convolutional Neural Networks. Recently, Transformer-based models,
including BERT, have been used in the domain of biomedical NER and have
demonstrated remarkable results. However, these models are often based on
word-level embeddings, limiting their ability to capture character-level
information, which is effective in biomedical NER due to the high variability
and complexity of biomedical texts. To address these limitations, this paper
proposes a hybrid approach that integrates the strengths of multiple models. In
this paper, we proposed an approach that leverages fine-tuned BERT to provide
contextualized word embeddings, a pre-trained multi-channel CNN for
character-level information capture, and following by a BiLSTM + CRF for
sequence labelling and modelling dependencies between the words in the text. In
addition, also we propose an enhanced labelling method as part of
pre-processing to enhance the identification of the entity's beginning word and
thus improve the identification of multi-word entities, a common challenge in
biomedical NER. By integrating these models and the pre-processing method, our
proposed model effectively captures both contextual information and detailed
character-level information. We evaluated our model on the benchmark i2b2/2010
dataset, achieving an F1-score of 90.11. These results illustrate the
proficiency of our proposed model in performing biomedical Named Entity
Recognition. | [
0.026658047,
0.0535664558,
0.0492688864,
-0.0166337714,
0.0034115273,
0.0276003238,
-0.0017305812,
0.014426982,
-0.0069822641,
-0.0274522323,
-0.0171493143,
-0.0535984412,
0.0052228831,
0.0310030505,
0.0319202952,
-0.0288399607,
0.0418757237,
0.0380057618,
0.0299317241,
0.0081452578,
-0.027777262,
-0.0027281612,
-0.0066087833,
0.0416221656,
0.0031709345,
0.0088622216,
0.0223213043,
0.0044327704,
0.0668467581,
-0.0787059739,
0.015755387,
0.0403778888,
0.0056072492,
0.0181006473,
0.0000020779,
-0.0343348272,
-0.0586665869,
0.0481787212,
-0.0232591052,
-0.0253115743,
0.0008067911,
-0.0444105566,
-0.011721245,
-0.0316615589,
-0.0049784519,
-0.0304170717,
0.0278344918,
0.0911413431,
0.0016626465,
0.0464937128,
-0.0067138569,
-0.0209214259,
0.0570636541,
-0.019525703,
0.0113168117,
-0.0224806238,
0.0355096273,
-0.0332937501,
0.0168424007,
0.017869968,
-0.0172766969,
0.0359005257,
-0.0067193587,
0.0491961464,
0.0353707001,
0.0605682693,
-0.0316914208,
0.0017000426,
0.0134527218,
0.0791569203,
-0.0827381536,
0.0014985838,
0.0221826751,
-0.0097164446,
-0.0537536703,
-0.0181473177,
-0.0191908795,
-0.0072073322,
-0.0499507822,
0.0141394269,
0.000421397,
-0.0076745427,
0.0588676482,
-0.0010774533,
-0.0399586074,
-0.0056525045,
0.0147609087,
-0.0533221774,
-0.0033043274,
-0.0236411374,
0.0060510966,
-0.0131952576,
0.0546872355,
0.0374295637,
-0.009178672,
0.0279118028,
-0.0423525125,
-0.0308556296,
0.0429623015,
-0.0431883745,
-0.0111101437,
-0.0024411397,
-0.0222477298,
0.0288060736,
-0.055724889,
-0.0163882431,
-0.070048511,
0.0512798093,
0.022357069,
-0.0101300683,
-0.0321497582,
-0.0239415485,
-0.013629064,
0.0517781004,
0.0005953297,
-0.018495081,
-0.052754581,
-0.0279289763,
-0.0072187302,
0.0113695683,
0.0194691606,
0.0423450135,
-0.0390991643,
-0.0007374878,
0.0126498956,
0.0222026557,
0.0015904538,
-0.0286296047,
-0.0396226905,
-0.0459462367,
-0.0017062183,
-0.0102055799,
0.0469671004,
-0.0401473604,
0.0444542542,
0.0575884767,
0.0613396019,
-0.1059573069,
-0.0384986438,
-0.0102429558,
-0.0095708612,
-0.0205960721,
0.0244200677,
-0.0320100859,
0.0381841324,
-0.0080094831,
0.006074314,
-0.020986313,
0.0223277621,
-0.0067497701,
-0.0461766161,
0.1072849184,
-0.0502292663,
-0.0573631525,
0.0333118252,
0.0312055498,
0.0567436889,
-0.0078886189,
0.058927983,
-0.0304702874,
0.0014424435,
-0.0253764037,
0.0058792969,
0.0048168506,
0.0103810122,
-0.0835910514,
-0.0111328512,
-0.0039685462,
-0.0097260708,
0.061402604,
0.0079372087,
0.0420934372,
0.0158849601,
-0.0156116867,
0.0193639454,
0.0604833849,
0.0413315371,
0.0222748369,
0.020246001,
-0.0064578387,
-0.0052481964,
-0.0309319962,
-0.004087403,
0.0313445218,
0.0320409201,
0.0335395001,
-0.0135408845,
0.0406996645,
-0.0141306911,
0.0196017139,
0.0073353574,
-0.0196863767,
-0.0272751134,
-0.0253204759,
0.0464064702,
-0.0055226609,
-0.0788191259,
0.0835525841,
0.0546229891,
-0.027626127,
0.0144477282,
-0.018928159,
-0.0191898439,
0.022204129,
0.0503816009,
-0.0610391498,
-0.053556554,
-0.0494490713,
-0.0606200062,
0.0275635701,
-0.0151166534,
0.0064536827,
0.0406432562,
-0.047819037,
-0.0168015305,
0.0214394219,
0.0088283606,
0.0073294519,
-0.0061333603,
0.037893597,
-0.014402424,
-0.0341950543,
-0.0019278094,
0.0469404198,
-0.0627726316,
-0.037151318,
-0.0099390224,
0.0203969255,
0.0361695886,
0.0388248339,
-0.0338422284,
0.0214355141,
0.0383796133,
-0.0461414866,
-0.0473870598,
-0.0212209765,
-0.008641676,
-0.0598829873,
0.0030934631,
-0.0219285171,
-0.0087677585,
-0.0133136027,
-0.0428441875,
-0.0235742833,
-0.0447212718,
-0.0107768048,
0.0302769337,
-0.0070360769,
0.0131574487,
0.0325098522,
0.0055160071,
-0.0343238674,
0.0230463743,
-0.0465459228,
0.0171411783,
0.0294748023,
-0.0546863265,
0.0182744451,
-0.0307007004,
-0.0541656949,
0.0458604507,
-0.016693227,
-0.0263216607,
-0.0300593749,
-0.0063745836,
-0.0202204902,
-0.0280490965,
-0.0752107874,
0.0075570126,
0.0442368798,
0.0258981083,
0.0028419602,
0.0411626212,
0.0241845641,
-0.0200146325,
-0.033862073,
-0.0300515629,
-0.0236711223,
-0.015817333,
0.0442656912,
0.013028319,
-0.0098674912,
-0.0164961834,
-0.0021187833,
-0.0504193082,
0.0385673903,
0.0051043434,
-0.0667107478,
-0.0033196525,
-0.0363051221,
-0.0030564475,
0.0362739936,
-0.0093365498,
0.0051361173,
0.0105049517,
0.0243518334,
0.0130622797,
0.0815348849,
0.0262346826,
0.0494254492,
-0.0144828837,
-0.0057235695,
-0.0143829761,
0.0356995873,
-0.042589277,
0.0506082363,
0.0062926533,
-0.0406381711,
0.0147795314,
0.0884404257,
-0.0086898506,
0.0154232066,
-0.0208936743,
-0.0332196467,
-0.0094425157,
-0.011577189,
-0.0172346011,
0.0336983651,
-0.0722666159,
-0.0143824602,
0.0006005832,
-0.034302298,
0.09049768,
-0.0377336629,
0.0101917451,
-0.0420373529,
0.02949588,
-0.0235333405,
-0.0033000149,
0.0244326442,
0.0126510244,
0.0152822332,
-0.0437814407,
0.0256306287,
0.0390594453,
-0.0202503391,
-0.0645832866,
0.0247200169,
0.014835041,
0.0115548382,
-0.0139538953,
-0.0119527141,
-0.0350025184,
-0.0055487589,
-0.0224100389,
0.0407670625,
0.030103337,
-0.0350951068,
-0.050100524,
0.0510512814,
-0.0016199313,
0.0580694377,
0.0086227544,
-0.0044393339,
-0.0362014398,
0.0639877617,
0.0387628935,
-0.0057871798,
0.0217386112,
-0.004499265,
-0.0160783976,
0.0426418073,
-0.0399951898,
0.0274837818,
-0.015470393,
-0.0150260655,
0.0010537136,
-0.0513971485,
0.0217333324,
-0.0005584207,
0.0397869162,
-0.0482227616,
-0.0002104718,
0.1074810475,
0.0290296413,
-0.0284136292,
0.0111727631,
0.0219150987,
-0.0369519591,
-0.0328366794,
-0.0044953837,
-0.0654223636,
-0.0426184423,
-0.0042189895,
-0.0013673641,
0.004501773,
-0.0731984451,
0.0208882447,
-0.0500390977,
0.0137493322,
-0.0265484098,
-0.0426295586,
-0.0145371277,
-0.0623082407,
-0.0206173901,
-0.0157600064,
0.0036846802,
-0.0501749292,
-0.0099535054,
-0.0110153975,
0.0155822793,
-0.0269933622,
-0.0832510665,
0.0151073365,
-0.063611269,
0.0512077995,
0.0418785624,
0.0477546528,
-0.0426792204,
0.0103072776,
-0.0047880309,
0.001997204,
-0.0293391645,
-0.0046045231,
0.0606259741,
-0.0538301952,
-0.0346866176,
-0.0441540033,
0.0096083954,
-0.0269049779,
-0.0395134129,
-0.0586070567,
0.045882009,
-0.0187709313,
0.0007953625,
-0.0562486202,
-0.0096460283,
0.0145017141,
0.0572964512,
-0.0061440323,
-0.0457066037,
-0.013514882,
0.0488863736,
0.061866127,
-0.033677157,
0.0013475537,
0.0207470395,
-0.0583456419,
-0.024591513,
-0.0309253875,
-0.0284212213,
0.0357901305,
-0.0161001701,
0.0151648326,
0.0070625283,
0.0647518635,
-0.0035120107,
-0.0663078353,
0.054977525,
0.0315695591,
0.0282506924,
-0.0686440393,
-0.0323448218,
0.0432042331,
0.0256149881,
-0.0375452414,
0.0139813786,
-0.0079596825,
-0.0012382886,
0.0067614634,
0.0288467556,
0.0013033971,
-0.0072331605,
-0.0018730705,
-0.004264513,
0.0449613109,
0.036531467,
-0.0201366041,
-0.0279284157,
0.0065851309,
0.004206215,
-0.0272281989,
0.0170465671,
0.0004107999,
0.02904444,
-0.0032128971,
0.0469590612,
-0.009662346,
-0.0594323501,
0.0125093088,
0.0046935277,
0.0653481036,
-0.0441678464,
-0.0145015288,
-0.0523336865,
0.0371157527,
0.0325012691,
0.0487152189,
-0.0326582491,
-0.0248663854,
0.0435484014,
0.0035673843,
-0.0299082734,
0.0546545126,
-0.012658759,
-0.0126784761,
-0.0196094215,
0.066141367,
-0.0025587277,
0.0278900806,
0.022814177,
-0.0201763548,
0.0034093861,
0.0262205116,
0.0092809405,
0.002329123,
-0.0202339757,
0.0205499008,
0.0078968909,
0.0357226953,
-0.0224461053,
0.0525456928,
-0.0276200846,
0.0462965146,
-0.0254362337,
0.002752244,
0.0409877263,
-0.0094406726,
0.0352322273,
-0.0070430506,
-0.0033662622,
0.0012152269,
0.0240933821,
-0.0285568945,
0.0265621189,
0.0827746615,
0.024467634,
-0.0233854782,
-0.0366607383,
0.0572933294,
0.0387454256,
0.060333129,
0.0015803864,
-0.0391090661,
-0.0281673186,
0.0217642635,
0.0509434752,
0.0009759432,
-0.0570834167,
0.0221537389,
-0.0541457571,
0.0000815978,
0.0856615752,
-0.0284892563,
-0.0330046825,
-0.0011605872,
0.0307299104,
-0.0077834507,
0.0073237941,
-0.0247813258,
-0.0075131152,
0.0388350971,
0.0211165734,
-0.0521672107,
0.0105050309,
-6.207455059e-33,
-0.0064920373,
-0.0544507541,
-0.0127988979,
-0.0207854174,
-0.0133416075,
0.0589046516,
-0.0424399115,
-0.0212020762,
-0.0135490624,
0.0231652651,
-0.0291076656,
-0.0161126815,
0.012528874,
0.0472378694,
-0.0280550718,
-0.052581273,
0.0328571759,
0.0347550847,
0.0101712812,
-0.0127084078,
0.0119008757,
0.0996184424,
0.1094808504,
-0.0760302097,
0.0055816942,
0.0020255859,
0.032407403,
-0.0079449937,
0.0190030765,
0.0425595343,
-0.0694701895,
-0.0103850625,
0.0266786627,
-0.0391341671,
0.0107023884,
0.0263633654,
-0.1315474957,
0.0241537299,
-0.0402805246,
-0.001184486,
-0.0351563953,
-0.0257377792,
0.0349907205,
-0.0027990581,
0.0142773055,
-0.0023790279,
0.0530367754,
0.0001035977,
-0.031421911,
-0.0670022294,
-0.0777648389,
0.0699374154,
0.0229804628,
0.0213193297,
0.0287627541,
-0.0436724648,
0.0047398983,
0.0661893487,
-0.054537829,
-0.0502791703,
0.0317578204,
0.009658277,
0.0001674033,
-0.0080079287,
-0.023356149,
0.03978692,
0.0157945547,
-0.0243737791,
-0.0330971517,
-0.0104066897,
-0.0218737796,
0.0495507754,
0.0338442139,
0.0116551183,
0.038773153,
0.0046265326,
-0.0899309218,
0.0402340107,
-0.0427186117,
0.0522007234,
-0.0004463885,
-0.0194792673,
-0.0272120722,
0.0294374954,
-0.0072252578,
-0.0131467376,
-0.0142773855,
0.0132256141,
0.012579442,
-0.0097801099,
-0.040945556,
0.0588816293,
0.0199945159,
-0.0395898335,
-0.0231055897,
-0.0035408598,
0.0889510587,
0.0204571933,
-0.0404386632,
0.0187844504,
-0.0414558984,
-0.0480109453,
0.0288304351,
-0.0267570876,
0.0344736315,
-0.0085025979,
0.032024309,
-0.0052878163,
-0.0456289351,
-0.0102552716,
0.0048295907,
-0.0186519213,
-0.0189467911,
0.0884047002,
0.0276436228,
-0.0033876449,
0.0123069631,
0.0418079309,
0.0202386286,
0.0170238111,
0.0050600506,
-0.0090999128,
0.0325430408,
0.0330324583,
-0.0017813746,
-0.029576987,
-0.0206651539,
0.0552653708,
0.0206520911,
-0.0668851808,
0.0069884765,
0.0067043672,
2.873e-7,
0.1013691053,
0.028089283,
0.0529366992,
-0.0500027165,
0.0023399335,
0.0060192388,
0.0185704269,
0.0370341986,
-0.0700831786,
-0.0097661382,
0.0446414873,
-0.0080209253,
0.011351035,
0.0021509419,
-0.0713347197,
-0.0402149968,
-0.0823608637,
-0.0168419406,
-0.0123263178,
-0.0130893774,
0.0102542602,
0.0845422149,
-0.0191706698,
-0.036333587,
0.0286093615,
-0.0170411468,
0.0337581709,
-0.0245926585,
0.0404346772,
0.0629610494,
0.0009584745,
0.0337051451,
0.0011275049,
0.0294093303,
-0.0409067795,
-0.0008941475,
0.0181292407,
0.0847168192,
-0.0413904823,
-0.0066492627,
0.0342564546,
-0.0107790083,
0.015693251,
-0.0387414321,
0.0427567996,
-0.0646512806,
-0.045881629,
0.0067843525,
-0.0164607186,
0.0216667224,
0.0550462343,
-0.0131885074,
-0.0258921627,
0.0323174894,
0.0374879204,
0.001457782,
-0.0252363402,
-0.107838206,
0.0086240843,
0.0515315421,
-0.0359947495,
0.0091015771,
-0.005010196,
-0.0716448426,
0.0620477237,
-0.072431013,
0.0042003961,
2.839668336e-34,
0.0170033202,
-0.0052147978,
-0.0089691998,
0.0562156476,
-0.0024274809,
-0.009052611,
-0.0065260786,
-0.0205889642,
-0.0269673541,
-0.0468144789,
-0.0078571355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15548v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15548v3 | YAYI-UIE: A Chat-Enhanced Instruction Tuning Framework for Universal Information Extraction | 2023-12-24T21:33:03 | 2024-04-02T09:36:35 | Xinglin Xiao, Yijie Wang, Nan Xu, Yuqi Wang, Hanxuan Yang, Minzheng Wang, Yin Luo, Lei Wang, Wenji Mao, Daniel Zeng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The difficulty of the information extraction task lies in dealing with the
task-specific label schemas and heterogeneous data structures. Recent work has
proposed methods based on large language models to uniformly model different
information extraction tasks. However, these existing methods are deficient in
their information extraction capabilities for Chinese languages other than
English. In this paper, we propose an end-to-end chat-enhanced instruction
tuning framework for universal information extraction (YAYI-UIE), which
supports both Chinese and English. Specifically, we utilize dialogue data and
information extraction data to enhance the information extraction performance
jointly. Experimental results show that our proposed framework achieves
state-of-the-art performance on Chinese datasets while also achieving
comparable performance on English datasets under both supervised settings and
zero-shot settings. | [
0.0589023456,
0.048462946,
0.024066709,
0.0594281219,
-0.0304079466,
0.0406998992,
0.0166900773,
0.0101277428,
0.0213680025,
-0.0360364877,
-0.0917176679,
-0.0323063172,
-0.0096698059,
-0.0184695926,
-0.019346416,
-0.0240985695,
0.0313424468,
0.0120351417,
0.0228455272,
0.0253898837,
0.0187554043,
-0.0284536686,
-0.0162985679,
-0.0056289006,
-0.0137406643,
-0.0207146388,
-0.0072338791,
0.0124708386,
-0.0065316777,
-0.010157275,
0.0298511181,
0.0559974164,
-0.0292273201,
-0.0224686302,
0.0000017147,
-0.0145670446,
-0.0247764066,
-0.0328522325,
-0.0629397035,
0.0105895828,
0.0462889522,
-0.0038267793,
-0.0170327518,
0.0076226862,
-0.0121020479,
-0.0313483588,
0.0404287651,
0.066486828,
0.0460416563,
0.0878745615,
-0.0110003529,
-0.0318602547,
0.0138202347,
-0.0121374512,
0.0194609091,
-0.069494687,
0.04063778,
0.0465963781,
0.005818814,
0.0209149718,
-0.0050227549,
0.0342417434,
0.0013172859,
-0.0152855879,
-0.0096101761,
0.0109933391,
-0.0457625873,
-0.0215506479,
-0.0373054631,
0.1242639646,
0.0269211419,
0.0465243869,
-0.009782427,
0.0210506953,
0.0142081166,
-0.0354745239,
-0.0559227765,
0.0024763893,
-0.0243167859,
0.0033671877,
0.0381705761,
-0.0146250781,
-0.0062545706,
-0.021303596,
-0.0062904172,
0.0290607214,
0.0007885512,
-0.0217979848,
0.0029519158,
0.0009838693,
0.0064660665,
-0.0221317522,
0.0108291367,
0.0338192731,
-0.021437142,
0.0327356271,
-0.0235231351,
-0.0133724902,
-0.0285487566,
-0.0586426072,
0.0017861555,
0.0442847423,
-0.0317483768,
0.0651769936,
0.0151470322,
0.0529718101,
0.0211047567,
0.0164647698,
-0.0393413976,
-0.0308546331,
-0.0763329864,
0.01844698,
-0.0439113937,
0.029973818,
-0.0360982642,
-0.0299463458,
-0.0142034991,
0.0333213806,
0.0035414984,
0.0082603507,
0.0296667069,
-0.0242945887,
-0.0514652729,
0.0184329171,
0.0053904955,
0.0173936971,
-0.0203496981,
-0.0100395484,
0.0016215687,
-0.0348344371,
-0.0243009981,
0.0124143269,
0.0384401977,
-0.0164490398,
-0.0026352885,
0.0911904871,
-0.0260698739,
-0.0134331081,
-0.0174169634,
0.0035671589,
0.0007149702,
-0.0463675596,
0.0033073598,
-0.0141614908,
0.0573609509,
-0.0040987856,
0.0018161326,
-0.0243630894,
0.0185428988,
-0.0184094068,
-0.0294050463,
0.0636869147,
0.0085865492,
0.0079618106,
-0.0009084538,
-0.0012458238,
-0.0036656111,
0.0848308355,
0.0248030536,
-0.0105001153,
0.1062415987,
0.0180061329,
0.00776619,
0.0502646454,
0.0053298408,
-0.0169489272,
0.0428571217,
0.0236325357,
0.0385884978,
-0.0235205367,
-0.0149467373,
0.027530523,
-0.0404837504,
-0.0222616643,
0.027886847,
-0.0095139919,
0.0092750369,
-0.0056273411,
0.0098463856,
0.0555396415,
0.0165596195,
0.0391063206,
-0.0567093082,
0.0018962855,
-0.0174270272,
0.0385966264,
0.0456547476,
-0.0106735677,
-0.0298497882,
-0.067804642,
-0.0040047248,
-0.0103690773,
0.0024731304,
0.0472161025,
0.0299028158,
-0.0040654708,
-0.0359168798,
0.0431130156,
0.0671322271,
-0.0203808341,
-0.0031505413,
0.0041804342,
0.0098901605,
0.0667577758,
0.0389838517,
-0.0510664396,
-0.0357312076,
0.0124748154,
0.0213200152,
0.0565260984,
0.0194546506,
-0.0632804558,
0.0504881442,
-0.0441138521,
-0.0392717645,
0.0262593031,
-0.0020661405,
-0.0216194633,
0.0454831347,
-0.0189610943,
0.006128897,
-0.0084540742,
-0.0560784973,
0.0264311377,
-0.048744522,
-0.0484992191,
0.0132828271,
0.0106533039,
0.0189130213,
0.0236977208,
-0.0451400615,
-0.0262320898,
0.0198464971,
-0.0051530832,
0.0069281766,
-0.0028858066,
-0.0499868952,
-0.0921573192,
0.027375007,
0.0005764702,
-0.0074779522,
-0.004229628,
-0.0727533475,
-0.0301689357,
-0.050041303,
0.0224202313,
-0.0077229152,
-0.0314510241,
0.0312676467,
0.0280924179,
0.0078908587,
-0.0398310982,
0.0331812501,
0.0305831544,
-0.0129100997,
0.0318318158,
0.0221601482,
-0.0041785752,
-0.0270963218,
-0.0060373312,
0.0407524072,
-0.0036312814,
0.0023077258,
0.0194614697,
0.0417271107,
-0.0391462818,
-0.0403799601,
-0.1187333837,
0.0454390384,
-0.0297718961,
0.0243983697,
0.0348090567,
0.0090752887,
-0.0249259435,
-0.0250870958,
-0.0619587153,
-0.0044922298,
-0.0199544467,
0.0082803993,
0.043785084,
0.0415714942,
-0.0025399877,
-0.0569001846,
0.0047263224,
0.0071842689,
-0.0014266938,
0.0107118124,
-0.0481686331,
-0.0298752431,
0.0014288215,
-0.0250915475,
0.0416548066,
-0.0181818958,
-0.031633161,
-0.0424278751,
0.0171930902,
0.021403566,
0.0680253655,
0.0079196692,
0.0301479213,
-0.0340309255,
-0.0322996266,
-0.0472885333,
0.0566783212,
-0.0408428386,
-0.0200770926,
-0.0365361497,
-0.0196802933,
0.0072249556,
0.0742457733,
0.0041559953,
0.0330866128,
-0.0204677023,
-0.0239348412,
-0.0010325485,
-0.0011751741,
-0.0242878143,
0.0526171774,
-0.0095050987,
-0.0162980855,
-0.0581813976,
0.0031023533,
0.101344198,
-0.0309932679,
-0.0330325961,
-0.0570006669,
-0.0126197794,
-0.0513413139,
0.03521543,
-0.0264328513,
-0.0080340942,
0.0376883522,
-0.0494046248,
-0.0287526492,
0.0112968702,
0.0310459677,
-0.0111298542,
0.0257941317,
-0.0302661154,
-0.0016312338,
-0.0074054087,
-0.0235273615,
-0.0423027053,
-0.0167779066,
0.0188870002,
0.036960572,
0.0395596698,
-0.0285229161,
-0.0048816605,
0.0294843912,
0.0048610964,
0.034164872,
-0.0275019761,
0.0286632925,
-0.0119459266,
0.0203973781,
0.0379327647,
-0.0188625362,
-0.0613174289,
-0.0367822535,
0.058501184,
0.0363555141,
0.0168612003,
-0.0098946691,
0.0630096942,
0.0068056439,
0.0241548382,
-0.0318548568,
-0.0080128592,
-0.0053280653,
0.0846177712,
-0.0379664265,
-0.0147691593,
0.1297399998,
0.0151569396,
-0.0150878383,
-0.019334577,
0.0224552732,
0.0141646499,
-0.0022107535,
0.0129398229,
-0.0959819779,
-0.0643181279,
-0.0292424299,
0.0147454822,
0.0205864348,
-0.0291857626,
0.0192269851,
-0.0665786713,
0.0231019612,
0.007763633,
-0.0357499011,
-0.0363150984,
-0.0404119268,
0.0438202843,
-0.0424652658,
0.0480524078,
-0.0066454811,
-0.0177699793,
-0.0165653918,
0.0107700555,
-0.0182591565,
-0.0470960587,
0.039289847,
-0.0163329951,
0.0370696783,
0.0403061658,
0.030640211,
0.0211425461,
0.0347366631,
0.0300493669,
0.0118596405,
-0.0410068892,
-0.0141667472,
0.0893647596,
-0.0469090901,
-0.0075441026,
-0.0096143493,
0.0199456867,
0.0082570482,
0.0327470824,
0.0398773178,
0.0048731202,
0.0143839605,
0.0136122676,
0.0233547296,
0.0111809084,
0.0332237296,
0.1067692712,
0.0335879363,
-0.0418468527,
-0.0190228689,
-0.0239258278,
-0.0449812189,
-0.065534927,
0.0106179845,
0.0240276214,
-0.0745250732,
-0.0417710319,
-0.099799253,
-0.0988453254,
0.0239434429,
-0.0206302647,
0.0073657329,
-0.0083589563,
0.0189545844,
0.0437461846,
-0.0115604447,
-0.0123929577,
-0.0327316411,
-0.0254811626,
-0.0692405179,
-0.0492608622,
0.0221694112,
-0.0188545566,
-0.0003821608,
0.0436701328,
-0.0545263439,
-0.0548808128,
-0.0175890215,
-0.0062299054,
0.001933435,
0.0808945745,
-0.0171100274,
0.0309636854,
0.0155995414,
-0.0002773732,
-0.0355431587,
-0.0277257003,
0.0523526445,
0.009921534,
0.010093621,
0.0387783274,
-0.0285807531,
0.0429973491,
0.0122165121,
0.0384495109,
-0.049495399,
-0.07170517,
0.0181048699,
0.0269905478,
0.0289850831,
0.0442747362,
-0.0264922604,
-0.0411030762,
0.046003107,
-0.0374468751,
-0.0589275062,
-0.0393102244,
0.0171629731,
0.02388064,
-0.0513688326,
-0.0048476108,
0.0329598933,
-0.0037742979,
0.0401766524,
-0.0298560746,
0.014105197,
-0.0214206222,
0.0216103327,
-0.0001037131,
-0.0366879106,
-0.0220310818,
0.0340390615,
0.0592415296,
0.042155087,
-0.0133527163,
0.0840888023,
0.0138390008,
-0.026999088,
0.0330254547,
0.0182669349,
-0.0501334928,
-0.0157893058,
-0.0390389822,
0.0285597201,
0.0279966611,
-0.0000181861,
0.0263441149,
-0.0280406382,
-0.0074541084,
-0.0270374659,
0.0451500602,
-0.0027589714,
-0.01566788,
0.0175785758,
0.0152426325,
-0.0295163337,
-0.0109187793,
0.0702778473,
0.0142170601,
0.0325361192,
-0.0007685425,
0.0007823866,
-0.0528857075,
-0.0117431358,
0.026539648,
0.0246213451,
-0.013692881,
0.0371040553,
0.0027912308,
-0.0226799548,
-0.0251405016,
-0.0202368777,
-0.0228953734,
0.0074816654,
0.0163601153,
0.0671039894,
0.0078935707,
-0.0400541723,
-0.0677052215,
0.0021979609,
0.0264570955,
-0.0065629259,
-0.0155898053,
-6.201750238e-33,
-0.0661156178,
0.0082090031,
0.0235784519,
0.0612037852,
-0.0112517197,
-0.0150220469,
-0.039357651,
-0.0120017212,
-0.0668907836,
0.0098206382,
-0.0203984957,
0.0022947288,
0.0361508988,
0.0504823402,
-0.0432722494,
-0.0436977595,
0.0216240883,
0.0124525335,
-0.0191357173,
0.0344735757,
0.0545912571,
0.036842972,
0.0894871131,
-0.0695308149,
0.0470835753,
-0.0180377308,
0.0498502925,
0.0373732783,
0.0727133676,
0.0532489419,
-0.0090393024,
0.0354968905,
0.0280490257,
-0.0522269607,
-0.0019850612,
0.0134038888,
-0.1326664239,
-0.005383255,
0.0048362776,
0.0283304639,
-0.0024952653,
-0.0031680085,
-0.030147586,
-0.0329679586,
0.0486295782,
-0.0379785709,
0.0435320511,
-0.0394561514,
0.008985728,
0.0008267616,
-0.0711992681,
0.0550122671,
0.0079632103,
-0.0249569062,
0.0232817568,
0.0507240668,
0.0258103982,
-0.0157068297,
-0.0381706841,
-0.0137052322,
0.0197023973,
0.0523154773,
0.0181916784,
0.0303401928,
0.0034387647,
0.038030751,
0.0192511361,
0.0198635366,
-0.0159056969,
-0.0310346335,
-0.0230774768,
0.0571882837,
-0.0257412177,
0.0218716674,
-0.011799328,
0.0165702235,
-0.0795518085,
0.0152134942,
0.0680862367,
0.0065588774,
-0.045867987,
-0.0016612199,
-0.0902545005,
0.000678698,
0.025485985,
0.0231767651,
-0.0118868649,
-0.0268047359,
0.0106146391,
0.001831799,
-0.0463180244,
0.0048492593,
0.041969724,
-0.0325007401,
-0.0190771278,
0.0379945002,
0.0140225962,
-0.002211835,
-0.0515249074,
-0.0171948783,
-0.0706335753,
-0.0697069019,
0.0120095331,
0.0102569452,
-0.0000959207,
0.0137009658,
0.0480402708,
-0.0203537252,
-0.0401314534,
-0.0143472468,
-0.0364738256,
0.0274967235,
-0.0179322381,
0.0432363562,
-0.0035514636,
0.0258169882,
-0.043300204,
0.0728233755,
0.0287681296,
0.0200542845,
-0.0298029762,
-0.0640787333,
-0.0034414444,
0.0049086693,
-0.0059914826,
0.011707318,
-0.0364873037,
-0.0317384526,
-0.0358437225,
-0.0334666558,
0.0177081097,
-0.0023794358,
2.333e-7,
0.0178709719,
0.0123814028,
0.0537883528,
0.0579582155,
0.0012910892,
0.0322381221,
-0.0026323167,
0.0007764562,
0.0195757821,
-0.0238774363,
0.0205068495,
0.0416135304,
0.0433508642,
-0.0029613208,
-0.0786410421,
-0.065946117,
-0.0119476067,
-0.0530339256,
-0.0367493369,
-0.0090173176,
0.0397593565,
0.0949905962,
-0.008514151,
0.0424284525,
-0.0465866216,
-0.0339829698,
0.0192781538,
-0.0088279219,
-0.0337765776,
0.1035700515,
0.0397224836,
0.0041667637,
-0.0170956068,
0.0383647047,
-0.018722672,
0.0229171179,
0.0185586568,
0.0798345581,
-0.0017899821,
-0.0307894368,
-0.0182019714,
-0.0178046394,
-0.0056899088,
-0.0102200387,
0.0693956912,
-0.0298133697,
-0.0003203491,
0.0078400662,
-0.0078696739,
0.020324789,
-0.023083264,
-0.0163814016,
-0.0377281532,
0.0691863298,
0.0220763907,
-0.0237407833,
-0.0107196374,
-0.0609650575,
-0.0231172424,
0.014411455,
-0.0038829495,
-0.0305235218,
0.0261267815,
-0.0417834148,
-0.0348957554,
-0.0618777126,
0.0193177834,
1.890462617e-34,
0.0008048167,
0.0072788424,
-0.0122949658,
0.0655117258,
0.0393438898,
-0.0333213359,
-0.0489162542,
-0.0015696024,
-0.0148201864,
-0.0473280512,
-0.0060591996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15523v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15523v1 | The Persuasive Power of Large Language Models | 2023-12-24T16:21:11 | 2023-12-24T16:21:11 | Simon Martin Breum, Daniel Vædele Egdal, Victor Gram Mortensen, Anders Giovanni Møller, Luca Maria Aiello | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC, physics.soc-ph | The increasing capability of Large Language Models to act as human-like
social agents raises two important questions in the area of opinion dynamics.
First, whether these agents can generate effective arguments that could be
injected into the online discourse to steer the public opinion. Second, whether
artificial agents can interact with each other to reproduce dynamics of
persuasion typical of human social systems, opening up opportunities for
studying synthetic social systems as faithful proxies for opinion dynamics in
human populations. To address these questions, we designed a synthetic
persuasion dialogue scenario on the topic of climate change, where a
'convincer' agent generates a persuasive argument for a 'skeptic' agent, who
subsequently assesses whether the argument changed its internal opinion state.
Different types of arguments were generated to incorporate different linguistic
dimensions underpinning psycho-linguistic theories of opinion change. We then
asked human judges to evaluate the persuasiveness of machine-generated
arguments. Arguments that included factual knowledge, markers of trust,
expressions of support, and conveyed status were deemed most effective
according to both humans and agents, with humans reporting a marked preference
for knowledge-based arguments. Our experimental framework lays the groundwork
for future in-silico studies of opinion dynamics, and our findings suggest that
artificial agents have the potential of playing an important role in collective
processes of opinion formation in online social media. | [
0.0643140599,
0.0682687163,
-0.011746862,
0.0073467335,
-0.0340833589,
-0.0178186595,
0.0116427466,
-0.0093210815,
0.0497121252,
-0.0348915868,
0.0162792653,
-0.0224011727,
-0.0145384846,
0.0228760894,
0.0195617583,
-0.0526441634,
-0.0029430091,
-0.0118334498,
0.0836253911,
-0.0468768179,
0.0380616449,
-0.0007825407,
0.0146075236,
0.0195389427,
0.0042583188,
0.008208436,
0.009390193,
-0.0093008978,
0.0412389487,
-0.0326410756,
-0.0032320556,
0.0511398725,
0.0267946608,
0.0470261835,
0.0000016986,
-0.02743195,
0.0266814064,
-0.0041181631,
-0.02644662,
0.0037216428,
0.0955566093,
0.0206627231,
-0.014592194,
0.0074228593,
-0.0727963522,
0.0449310318,
0.0520379022,
0.0140752746,
0.0578675307,
0.0637167022,
-0.006457943,
-0.0218408592,
0.015743766,
-0.0038385531,
-0.0439921506,
0.0275268797,
0.0430530794,
-0.0367059298,
0.0042064791,
0.0234700739,
0.018669365,
0.0037888524,
-0.0094413916,
-0.0430726856,
-0.0003132266,
0.0198501404,
-0.0199392587,
-0.0309502222,
-0.0127136568,
0.050717473,
0.0527200811,
-0.0499111861,
0.0231793039,
0.0122296,
0.0345179923,
0.0705320388,
-0.0293636397,
0.032960631,
0.0013347428,
0.0142018767,
0.0325101651,
0.0314844176,
0.0204564668,
0.0440503731,
0.0056966441,
0.0664760023,
-0.0158494245,
-0.0129812555,
0.0073042763,
0.013945098,
0.0226593949,
-0.0698994771,
-0.0143539011,
-0.0143312942,
-0.0215296317,
0.037628416,
0.0064768172,
0.02512688,
0.0246184375,
-0.1324605793,
0.017678408,
-0.0080353115,
0.0282539111,
0.0420747288,
0.0321220607,
-0.0125091178,
-0.0344186649,
0.0182299539,
0.0400274917,
0.0095360121,
-0.0691890568,
0.0034130039,
-0.0027034981,
-0.008505905,
0.0088971788,
0.0133538032,
0.0045640422,
-0.0030893886,
-0.0734333917,
-0.0019966916,
-0.0369208306,
0.0129033914,
0.0208935086,
-0.0219946485,
-0.0668929368,
0.0503839441,
-0.0520216264,
0.0301966053,
0.0124085937,
-0.0390347466,
0.0245379414,
0.0045039849,
0.0129207093,
0.0136801172,
0.0001086758,
0.0369105749,
0.0108301453,
0.0173276085,
-0.0062547671,
-0.024400793,
-0.0055686231,
-0.0534095876,
-0.0183984209,
-0.0494374074,
0.0169575531,
0.006055769,
-0.008986908,
-0.0427143574,
0.0138214147,
0.0167599823,
-0.0407337062,
0.0779515207,
-0.0420124903,
0.0010890123,
0.0414989106,
0.0100691561,
-0.0015865185,
0.0372574963,
0.0038066995,
0.0509907529,
0.0293034054,
0.0024455939,
0.0546754114,
0.005800453,
0.0050828699,
0.0120505197,
0.0089052739,
-0.0184291862,
-0.0809527487,
-0.0053808209,
-0.0417954102,
0.0664416701,
-0.01832854,
-0.0204258412,
0.0860846639,
0.021854192,
-0.0715219602,
0.0420839041,
0.014696016,
0.021283064,
-0.0003399372,
0.0142788235,
-0.0146206245,
0.0047359942,
-0.0218642838,
-0.0507475622,
0.0039874483,
0.0118699232,
-0.0311517455,
-0.0264542717,
0.0160821695,
-0.0069507202,
0.0601653084,
-0.0007471161,
0.0001047099,
-0.008029094,
0.0037414471,
-0.0161932036,
0.0326805636,
-0.0219221693,
-0.0292815473,
-0.0334436707,
0.0160560217,
0.0371014178,
-0.0065552182,
0.0228973068,
0.0149663538,
-0.0287550334,
0.0205273982,
0.0928397402,
0.0775528923,
-0.034623906,
-0.0952097923,
-0.0055778869,
0.0069774492,
0.0103548104,
0.0066677271,
0.0526344664,
-0.0087960474,
0.0196213201,
-0.0214304235,
0.0106350016,
-0.0323489755,
-0.0058565959,
0.0017267123,
0.0169989262,
-0.0495642945,
0.0079119997,
0.050656911,
0.0369969495,
-0.0219336208,
-0.00304347,
0.0421525724,
-0.0000524716,
-0.0699439272,
0.0673959032,
0.022773223,
0.0575257912,
0.0157760903,
-0.0200176351,
-0.0277012195,
-0.0138147278,
0.0302529149,
0.0092250481,
0.0762312859,
-0.0345519371,
0.0525487028,
0.0016496691,
-0.0341853611,
-0.0401955172,
0.0120431157,
-0.006989026,
0.0273268111,
0.0262433663,
-0.0524232313,
0.0096032722,
-0.0351875834,
0.0011898095,
-0.0012011825,
0.0168329794,
-0.0019994483,
0.0340033323,
0.0061887382,
0.0697141886,
-0.0833838433,
-0.0412484966,
-0.035778854,
-0.0774266571,
-0.0723356158,
-0.0098064672,
0.0145106455,
0.0045932992,
-0.041225113,
0.0336581431,
0.0368355066,
-0.0499696322,
0.0169310402,
-0.0117436629,
0.0340694748,
0.0269488767,
-0.0153691759,
-0.0212382469,
-0.0359890014,
0.0206154082,
-0.0390541293,
0.0351841301,
0.0908969417,
-0.028794786,
-0.0465578213,
-0.0067730159,
-0.0841927305,
0.0061557475,
-0.0130792102,
-0.0477241203,
0.0366686061,
0.0294621456,
0.048385337,
0.0472850092,
0.050370913,
0.0293124914,
0.0240660887,
0.0421970226,
-0.0611360967,
-0.0485977419,
-0.0319731981,
0.0419430695,
-0.06644734,
-0.0203893632,
0.0008521298,
0.012004734,
0.0100691281,
0.0148414988,
-0.0167582054,
0.0908577964,
0.004805292,
-0.0488999858,
0.0053367419,
-0.0438908674,
-0.0089696338,
0.0564361103,
-0.0320462324,
-0.0464233533,
0.055533763,
0.0147159602,
0.0262707118,
-0.0163348317,
-0.0281858314,
0.0231999028,
0.0224041566,
0.0329260752,
0.0158903748,
0.0147850811,
0.0452273861,
-0.0158545151,
-0.0737102106,
0.0316829309,
-0.0237414706,
-0.0273920167,
-0.0499787144,
0.0242965128,
0.05083647,
-0.0122218104,
-0.0090293409,
-0.0597097911,
-0.0568568818,
-0.0108052567,
0.0335640498,
-0.0434484482,
0.000055737,
-0.0113415318,
0.0490180887,
-0.0306999963,
0.0199259147,
-0.0145246023,
0.0113296118,
0.0067092231,
0.0133537631,
0.0321743712,
0.0448537469,
-0.0262199044,
0.0278937388,
0.0378747098,
0.0062111686,
-0.0317685977,
-0.0511017293,
-0.0547026731,
-0.0180906206,
0.0092865033,
0.022972811,
-0.0138119441,
0.0387142077,
-0.033502467,
0.0286893882,
0.0511129461,
0.0157843307,
-0.037125051,
-0.0110965734,
-0.0031278848,
-0.0098569691,
0.0224552043,
0.0151085397,
-0.0548488796,
0.0365238041,
-0.0064385678,
-0.0125663755,
-0.0555525385,
-0.0193162821,
-0.0013924154,
-0.0870138109,
0.0470991656,
0.0059771235,
0.0457494669,
0.0244785212,
-0.0668593869,
0.0009070057,
-0.0118230041,
-0.0460221693,
-0.0361100063,
0.0573400669,
0.0021851668,
-0.0217998587,
-0.0107837627,
0.0124314139,
0.0292563941,
-0.0308413953,
0.0796055198,
0.0706609711,
0.0946071967,
-0.030777121,
-0.092365697,
0.0433679707,
0.0413579643,
-0.0279489085,
0.0059943059,
0.0393605977,
0.012736083,
-0.0022415007,
-0.0372435451,
0.0289814901,
-0.0087521356,
-0.0019301877,
-0.0026367761,
0.0657051653,
0.0167349819,
-0.0829566792,
0.0019483439,
0.0109115047,
0.028620027,
0.0366291218,
0.0111749461,
-0.0391880237,
-0.0285506733,
-0.0680748299,
-0.0055727041,
-0.0143147586,
-0.0839554667,
-0.0452373736,
0.0106837973,
-0.0263462216,
-0.0612660907,
-0.0356690511,
-0.0265460964,
0.0135669149,
0.03259518,
-0.0221648179,
0.099077493,
0.0065458929,
0.0063957158,
0.0248698089,
-0.0400921144,
0.0333507583,
-0.0158114918,
-0.060049098,
0.0197211001,
-0.0034879779,
-0.0053666392,
-0.0113881342,
0.0266736876,
-0.0829457119,
0.0268312786,
0.0249500424,
0.0258734189,
0.0207157079,
0.0095450729,
-0.0296060108,
0.0255516078,
0.0051269876,
-0.0005377569,
0.0026372855,
0.028332375,
0.0144993737,
0.0092780758,
0.0216261782,
0.0346959233,
0.0487020016,
0.0232456308,
-0.0252188407,
-0.0881903768,
-0.0092052072,
0.0336800218,
0.0073534003,
0.0158235524,
0.0100843534,
-0.0229681693,
-0.0162161607,
-0.0602506325,
-0.0203448497,
-0.017585218,
0.0011325489,
-0.0284310393,
-0.0037304012,
0.0274921227,
-0.0034229918,
0.013301203,
-0.0537093133,
0.0289216843,
0.0200563557,
0.0295308959,
0.0071032057,
0.07419727,
0.0090516675,
-0.0042303153,
0.0243812408,
0.0415659919,
-0.020267481,
0.0253375247,
0.0066702454,
0.0179056916,
-0.000308937,
-0.0462431014,
0.0181714334,
0.0034455024,
-0.0594774,
-0.0547192171,
0.0146528967,
0.0100363493,
-0.0008078596,
0.0325857587,
0.0416346043,
-0.0200660396,
-0.0182694104,
-0.0045664543,
0.0058379318,
-0.0010451225,
-0.0151357679,
-0.0104282312,
-0.0004079675,
-0.0693677738,
0.0327360332,
0.000481411,
-0.0648222715,
0.0317187235,
0.0082523422,
-0.0390499383,
-0.0074443696,
-0.0261422638,
-0.0573831424,
-0.0247408058,
0.0093666883,
0.0140385665,
-0.0595480129,
-0.0258376841,
0.00232939,
0.0266366526,
0.0158134941,
-0.0165196918,
0.0024319771,
0.0251813475,
-0.0279877298,
0.069894366,
-0.0482817665,
0.0227536187,
-0.0312077198,
-0.0024054861,
-0.0060094539,
-5.868338163e-33,
0.0141106239,
-0.0489443503,
-0.0067357402,
0.0407714844,
-0.0079478258,
-0.0322981104,
-0.0384780765,
0.03984439,
-0.0005923001,
0.0838827267,
0.0018410573,
0.0154037606,
0.0101473657,
-0.0380880721,
0.0073264758,
-0.0021395253,
0.0462936983,
-0.0445033051,
-0.007281533,
0.0117599787,
0.037750151,
-0.0380394906,
-0.0253721997,
-0.1146917641,
0.068363741,
0.0265503787,
-0.0105933193,
-0.008483991,
-0.0290476754,
-0.0079452964,
0.0013549032,
0.0576496422,
0.0295573156,
-0.0449625142,
0.0028561165,
0.0731084421,
-0.0022387712,
-0.0065106843,
0.0232529864,
-0.0577804893,
-0.0166973677,
-0.0151700703,
-0.0086223148,
-0.0280405041,
-0.0596135296,
0.0690616742,
0.0168604907,
-0.0304955058,
0.055728063,
-0.0084418841,
-0.0633816123,
-0.002467226,
-0.0089606047,
-0.0020878497,
-0.0328301825,
0.0256216731,
-0.0056713531,
0.0364407115,
-0.0592543781,
0.0792359039,
-0.0028802468,
-0.0222377274,
0.0060904794,
-0.0236472841,
0.0273808371,
0.0633931756,
0.0616277158,
0.074129045,
-0.0640981346,
-0.0045991242,
-0.0160267539,
0.021971805,
0.0825736597,
0.1092162654,
0.0062492597,
-0.0524002276,
-0.0261997599,
-0.0145848738,
0.0619451776,
-0.0268634483,
0.0339756981,
-0.0043298104,
-0.0088299029,
-0.0124310041,
-0.0301446579,
-0.0869970918,
-0.0331475213,
-0.0332968272,
-0.025711732,
0.0204830617,
-0.011537401,
-0.0071822363,
-0.0088633746,
-0.0615232103,
-0.030176945,
0.0091508431,
0.0092769628,
0.0156471077,
0.0315914638,
-0.0295908265,
-0.0450499468,
0.0124692973,
-0.0404188223,
0.0353829153,
0.0264408179,
-0.0000721595,
-0.0114202434,
-0.0172783528,
-0.0171516351,
-0.0080928495,
-0.02369426,
0.0151063232,
0.0057993284,
-0.0339935459,
0.0012800636,
0.0352318995,
0.0078387624,
-0.0229363292,
0.01197345,
0.0275671836,
0.0008589488,
0.0350036882,
-0.0442241654,
0.0173872076,
-0.0406552218,
-0.0122140422,
-0.0581576265,
0.0263706464,
-0.0054711211,
-0.0435038283,
-0.0065072794,
-0.0585277341,
2.467e-7,
0.0023842072,
0.1031475738,
-0.0067292368,
-0.0120522156,
0.0524486005,
0.0429746993,
-0.004498018,
-0.0132362051,
0.0135294134,
-0.0897866786,
-0.0255926065,
0.0152487829,
0.0257145967,
0.0339459144,
-0.0651643202,
-0.0356488787,
-0.0243850984,
-0.0240270663,
-0.0354435258,
0.0120406942,
0.0418974124,
0.0184079502,
0.0430370718,
0.005038504,
-0.0251898523,
0.0001901187,
0.0599103011,
-0.0492514819,
-0.0165475905,
-0.0055026365,
0.0010494655,
-0.0634463802,
-0.0050127525,
0.0360171087,
0.005811871,
-0.0169955119,
-0.057402309,
0.0091611408,
0.0175177678,
-0.045089215,
-0.0000696625,
0.0020128626,
0.0137939956,
-0.0087335333,
0.0102648512,
-0.064581342,
-0.0537894182,
-0.0585300662,
-0.0367580652,
-0.012598414,
-0.0080608772,
-0.024968354,
-0.0420769751,
-0.0097535513,
-0.0075251576,
0.0157371871,
0.0342631713,
-0.0356252044,
-0.0060671689,
-0.0289410315,
-0.05305757,
-0.0834046304,
-0.0030708236,
-0.0082729617,
0.0150489984,
0.0079174256,
0.0461017266,
1.605921467e-34,
0.072997272,
0.0038102267,
0.0026221934,
-0.0165013298,
0.0521018468,
0.0364531241,
-0.0135687096,
-0.0078712944,
0.0671161562,
-0.0596064292,
-0.0042116293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15503v1 | Making Large Language Models A Better Foundation For Dense Retrieval | 2023-12-24T15:10:35 | 2023-12-24T15:10:35 | Chaofan Li, Zheng Liu, Shitao Xiao, Yingxia Shao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dense retrieval needs to learn discriminative text embeddings to represent
the semantic relationship between query and document. It may benefit from the
using of large language models (LLMs), given LLMs' strong capability on
semantic understanding. However, the LLMs are pre-trained by text generation
tasks, whose working pattern is completely different from representing texts as
embeddings. As a result, it is imperative to study how to adapt LLMs properly
so that they can be effectively initialized as the backbone encoder for dense
retrieval.
In this paper, we propose a novel approach, called LLaRA (LLM adapted for
dense RetrievAl), which works as a post-hoc adaptation of LLM for the dense
retrieval application. LLaRA consists of two pretext tasks: EBAE
(Embedding-Based Auto-Encoding) and EBAR (Embedding-Based Auto-Regression),
where the text embeddings from LLM are used to reconstruct the tokens for the
input sentence and predict the tokens for the next sentence, respectively.
LLaRA turns out to be simple, lightweight, and highly effective. It is applied
to adapt LLaMA-2-7B (base) on the Wikipedia corpus, where it substantially
improves the model's fine-tuned performances on a variety of dense retrieval
benchmarks, like MSMARCO and BEIR. Our model and code will be made publicly
available at BGE repository. | [
0.0502188653,
0.0331007168,
0.0126402294,
0.0435830541,
-0.0017557632,
0.0135460692,
-0.0104897302,
0.0260878131,
0.0309637487,
-0.0674625561,
-0.0111748539,
-0.0303710718,
-0.0346196331,
0.0621076897,
0.0418819748,
-0.0183907226,
0.0344753265,
-0.0037274081,
0.0045616357,
-0.0128306635,
0.0186443701,
0.0242055152,
0.0214271806,
0.0116159692,
-0.0022856602,
0.0013374198,
-0.0053198957,
0.0151413279,
-0.0304902811,
-0.0082069207,
0.0350561887,
0.0289515015,
0.0688703507,
0.0088061281,
0.0000016468,
-0.0504030995,
-0.0260981619,
-0.0133234002,
-0.0314825289,
0.0556149967,
0.0066985404,
-0.008225929,
0.0512484498,
0.0122961337,
0.0001102351,
-0.0171124302,
0.0242149998,
0.0344495177,
0.0370788537,
0.0646789819,
-0.0062183463,
-0.043659348,
0.0702727586,
-0.0248316377,
0.0159176458,
-0.0161732975,
0.0469624288,
-0.0208783168,
-0.0141450781,
0.0470160991,
0.0064461534,
0.0265594888,
-0.0170918573,
-0.0178423803,
0.0755769834,
0.0273258556,
-0.0374126844,
-0.0321406126,
0.0140775638,
0.0634967759,
-0.0137712341,
-0.0396340974,
0.0197782833,
0.0420765206,
-0.0290527176,
-0.0026276931,
-0.0544590689,
0.0150919864,
0.0239670705,
0.0078775641,
-0.000583372,
-0.0139635634,
0.0326676816,
0.0456202291,
-0.0585459098,
0.0281421803,
0.038467966,
-0.0248984396,
-0.004072105,
0.0164786819,
-0.0531433001,
-0.0173748769,
0.0343234465,
0.0553211868,
-0.0131997019,
-0.0047082519,
-0.0117490152,
-0.0227583013,
0.0360066593,
-0.0373213813,
-0.0209783092,
0.0401160121,
-0.0125431651,
0.0471634306,
-0.0570226274,
0.068880856,
-0.019379925,
0.003545261,
-0.0551758073,
-0.0180839691,
0.0084688365,
-0.0349330716,
-0.0531839132,
0.0554876179,
-0.0378277823,
-0.0362158418,
-0.0212351289,
0.0521450378,
0.0460688956,
-0.0026533501,
0.0159169249,
0.0092321141,
-0.0403070748,
-0.008891576,
-0.0199501459,
0.0148674482,
-0.0194417164,
0.0106888171,
0.0073753567,
-0.0087285377,
-0.0312786736,
0.0382708944,
0.0378277227,
-0.0242068004,
0.003123557,
0.0120095024,
-0.0205218643,
-0.0418583415,
-0.0240828488,
-0.0174851045,
0.0137004415,
-0.0252849516,
0.0130359912,
-0.0564678609,
0.0277763586,
0.0169647187,
-0.0016696503,
-0.0564878918,
0.0106888711,
0.0387117378,
-0.0245344117,
0.0472078025,
-0.0177466907,
0.0057004583,
0.0455117226,
0.0225607939,
0.0352696739,
0.0651651919,
0.0123479944,
0.0670654997,
0.0643786117,
0.0191939734,
-0.0305076614,
0.0190911889,
0.0396185443,
0.0203719363,
-0.0312641114,
0.0465788245,
-0.0035090076,
0.0513943657,
0.0465722829,
0.0660241023,
-0.0587343387,
0.0001010023,
0.0174302701,
0.052704908,
0.0223467723,
0.0104656024,
0.0542421415,
-0.0022240288,
-0.0074652424,
-0.0230849851,
-0.0049900385,
0.0137611646,
-0.0228469297,
-0.0120214233,
0.0609602705,
0.0214995705,
-0.066686146,
-0.009985528,
-0.0092733428,
-0.0143927019,
-0.0609477535,
-0.0016849322,
0.0380563587,
-0.0140591795,
-0.0331962965,
0.064686358,
0.0045130309,
-0.0462986119,
0.036865849,
-0.0555626042,
0.0453594327,
0.0391853042,
0.0661413446,
-0.0396160372,
-0.0130734704,
0.0060954294,
0.0058703129,
0.0053794445,
0.0187305827,
-0.059394557,
-0.0141373482,
-0.0726889893,
-0.0429744273,
-0.0281479191,
0.0141622378,
0.0013003998,
0.0126130693,
0.0252396353,
0.0740514696,
-0.0678630993,
0.0178765804,
0.0485573821,
-0.0359543934,
-0.0360138081,
0.0032294681,
0.016489666,
-0.0152901448,
0.0024423422,
-0.0020066865,
0.0207088497,
0.052164495,
-0.0498930663,
-0.0238231365,
-0.0377034433,
-0.0435271747,
-0.0502424799,
0.0282110739,
0.0304446779,
0.0402676649,
0.0235503931,
-0.0197583269,
-0.0340976156,
-0.0062690335,
-0.0139773265,
0.0300755724,
-0.0611662529,
0.0206241552,
-0.006410657,
0.0332761593,
-0.055891823,
0.063763082,
-0.006670557,
0.0271551888,
0.0064810975,
-0.0160883591,
0.0354058295,
-0.0271505043,
-0.0744376853,
0.0077341669,
0.021251224,
0.0321224034,
0.0161459986,
0.0050891102,
-0.0375653841,
-0.0194445215,
-0.0888935179,
0.0219653975,
-0.041489061,
-0.0066869473,
0.0029662936,
0.0239188764,
-0.0030237357,
-0.0141879106,
-0.0362141468,
-0.0038540154,
0.0174340103,
0.0328629576,
0.0084952656,
0.0207054801,
0.0077746883,
-0.0292782448,
-0.0380019844,
0.0120197348,
0.0672151744,
-0.0358719751,
-0.0118898507,
-0.0367976129,
0.0368180573,
-0.032059893,
-0.0121676885,
-0.0172167365,
-0.0024411664,
-0.0077837696,
-0.0637195855,
0.0618223958,
0.0684230551,
0.0136729386,
0.0409451649,
0.0327433683,
-0.003378704,
-0.080866158,
0.0017817927,
-0.0344848335,
0.0087519102,
-0.0164153799,
-0.0072461516,
0.0138867637,
0.0182860103,
-0.0130188391,
-0.009603098,
-0.033411555,
-0.009017312,
0.014015262,
-0.0091390302,
-0.0671014339,
-0.0221785326,
0.0193709042,
0.0363123752,
-0.0149508426,
-0.035344243,
0.0538118407,
-0.0384031758,
-0.0022259015,
0.0064713634,
0.0042328886,
-0.074605234,
0.0338607468,
-0.0157154985,
0.0157089606,
-0.0282052401,
-0.0287969541,
-0.0276650395,
0.0263239127,
-0.0084294854,
-0.0585417934,
0.0464450642,
-0.0099125523,
0.0226785578,
-0.0146529004,
-0.040366061,
-0.0448070951,
-0.0404531769,
-0.0262303371,
0.0306114107,
-0.018895641,
-0.0062661595,
-0.0453453474,
0.0364346392,
0.0106316954,
0.0158224367,
-0.0294558872,
0.0092391316,
-0.0118424445,
0.0515349656,
0.0681708828,
0.0080641424,
-0.0124537591,
-0.0054676984,
0.0380670764,
0.0299215056,
-0.0038084942,
-0.0430973954,
-0.0301049519,
0.0129397102,
0.0504909046,
-0.0341850407,
-0.0207220055,
-0.0257845875,
0.024089843,
0.0049258019,
-0.052114971,
0.1103017852,
0.0312464666,
-0.0764818043,
-0.0314114578,
-0.0309883989,
0.0732106492,
0.0322176404,
0.0454747081,
-0.0243069716,
-0.0044641299,
0.0155902347,
0.0372674614,
0.0348079652,
-0.0039700489,
0.0075898492,
-0.1002819613,
0.0206432622,
0.0030992609,
0.0396602117,
-0.0493885018,
-0.0576363094,
-0.0018499179,
0.0103431977,
0.017911464,
0.0321277492,
-0.0112551562,
0.0105414717,
0.020813223,
0.0122353695,
-0.0335090347,
-0.0258839224,
-0.024390256,
0.0209533684,
0.03799228,
0.0305665694,
0.0311781466,
0.0035875509,
0.0054389765,
-0.0504291579,
-0.0306751095,
-0.0241163317,
0.056629695,
-0.0289391708,
-0.0006695454,
0.0008975467,
0.0019015466,
-0.0257680919,
-0.0130265076,
-0.0176607594,
0.0599253401,
-0.0242258236,
0.0217282586,
-0.0541371778,
-0.0358073264,
-0.0127290096,
0.0530802384,
0.0314810947,
0.0104782386,
-0.0309611131,
-0.0212307107,
0.001561833,
-0.0163585693,
-0.0507478006,
-0.0246923342,
-0.0058005545,
0.0339201577,
-0.0763537809,
-0.0260020327,
0.0203292724,
0.044554241,
-0.0123479161,
0.0305347946,
-0.0430906303,
-0.0471372269,
-0.0514640622,
0.0345558152,
-0.0451578647,
0.0023839062,
-0.0517290644,
0.0228689928,
0.0665391237,
-0.0377270877,
-0.0131543605,
-0.0512796119,
-0.0237554871,
-0.0443189889,
-0.0226500835,
0.0330481492,
0.0100542651,
0.0372578651,
-0.0228132028,
-0.0916387364,
0.1120856702,
0.0392449312,
-0.0539900549,
0.0120527884,
-0.0195635501,
0.007596252,
-0.0375553034,
0.0419973433,
-0.0777706355,
0.0144434208,
-0.0140027357,
0.0701859519,
0.0153824966,
-0.0655271336,
0.0215624124,
0.0321353264,
0.0529669672,
-0.004650746,
0.0471939035,
-0.0574955307,
0.0105042756,
-0.0236096624,
-0.0167914592,
-0.0252279993,
0.0424976237,
0.0315537043,
-0.0189769566,
-0.0247235578,
0.0280432981,
0.0065939156,
0.0590760224,
-0.0283678826,
-0.0013512543,
-0.0117321229,
0.0179397073,
0.0229436439,
0.0090890639,
-0.0413594246,
-0.010433686,
-0.0131145502,
0.0353190824,
-0.0608274341,
0.0032976,
-0.0026675139,
-0.0100361146,
-0.0398203731,
0.029700717,
-0.0672104359,
-0.03374945,
-0.0281557199,
0.0090818191,
0.0647090748,
-0.0392441303,
0.0186940208,
0.0110311536,
-0.0254561715,
-0.0253785215,
-0.0003615444,
-0.000524585,
-0.0045177881,
0.0534754805,
0.0245792102,
-0.0236199889,
0.0288530905,
0.0588578023,
0.049918063,
0.0373658128,
0.001156269,
-0.0306679532,
-0.0279730689,
-0.0331384577,
0.0668717772,
0.0152287912,
-0.0583966672,
-0.0176492464,
0.0107487459,
-0.0583019331,
0.0723632574,
-0.0424027927,
-0.0586568266,
0.0044363351,
0.0466313958,
0.0887986869,
0.0221117716,
0.0113225747,
-0.0460431688,
0.0399414487,
-0.0430599637,
-0.0260085985,
0.0098771444,
-6.139231938e-33,
-0.0203603767,
-0.0020727071,
0.0248786584,
-0.0259797927,
-0.0358533487,
0.0085691428,
-0.0180618279,
-0.025812462,
-0.0238950662,
-0.0061920742,
-0.0474887304,
0.0157279838,
0.0010849906,
0.0033910475,
-0.0213737395,
-0.0015252887,
0.0444913097,
-0.01504994,
-0.0119287977,
0.040402133,
0.0238047335,
0.0560632162,
-0.0079808012,
-0.0300653055,
-0.0089820027,
-0.0250467733,
0.0144261243,
0.0298485886,
0.0180027653,
0.0580303818,
-0.0536160842,
0.0518854186,
0.0251025259,
0.0349231213,
-0.0098782899,
0.0272875093,
-0.0813572928,
-0.0099628763,
-0.0217052903,
-0.0071000275,
-0.0144137321,
-0.0340610482,
0.0230838768,
-0.0360960551,
0.0246261414,
0.0065328022,
0.0292865783,
-0.0090307761,
-0.0643442199,
-0.0288786106,
-0.0334728062,
0.0185688511,
0.0086930161,
0.0033765524,
0.0412779935,
0.0287134405,
0.035907127,
0.0471307337,
-0.0282722823,
0.0175535865,
-0.0689990968,
0.0638565719,
-0.000619123,
0.0248192828,
-0.0085373186,
0.0583464578,
-0.0400594994,
-0.0475163274,
-0.0379720032,
0.0131018674,
0.0254539978,
0.0444336981,
0.0107861692,
0.0541200303,
-0.0031250359,
-0.0396916121,
-0.0902607739,
0.0491478071,
-0.0111954836,
0.0580966547,
0.0350060239,
0.0240404624,
-0.0315580741,
-0.0209694579,
-0.0429321267,
0.0093861558,
-0.052093219,
-0.0187615175,
0.0387345701,
0.058305718,
-0.0328763053,
-0.0212361813,
0.0517007671,
-0.04175945,
0.0104480404,
0.0551758297,
-0.0206183828,
0.0076259039,
-0.0063925027,
0.0575049259,
-0.0347355157,
-0.0623226054,
0.0303160977,
-0.0339603648,
-0.0436839834,
0.0118358377,
0.0211978313,
0.0267452747,
-0.0378522947,
0.0046040909,
-0.0195439197,
-0.0609603859,
-0.017851904,
0.0379233249,
-0.011825908,
0.0215586796,
0.0137504293,
0.0360596292,
0.0318868347,
0.0108860834,
-0.0160641428,
-0.0590297244,
0.0297142267,
0.0336083882,
-0.0417695418,
0.0110756131,
-0.0472018383,
0.0336084217,
0.0009297364,
-0.0585456118,
0.0049026441,
0.0172728579,
2.442e-7,
0.0528997406,
0.0257286355,
0.0238096062,
0.0038208051,
-0.0131257279,
-0.0033378405,
-0.0031344353,
0.0473650247,
0.031512741,
-0.0239647552,
0.0328860357,
0.0319351703,
0.0161558911,
-0.0159895513,
-0.0916577056,
0.0086070867,
-0.0356989503,
-0.0192805361,
-0.0678483993,
-0.0693519488,
0.0572405495,
0.0897107869,
-0.0196589753,
-0.0083376113,
-0.0308408514,
-0.0589842871,
0.0866688266,
0.0119486712,
-0.0197900888,
0.0392398275,
0.0536066405,
0.0610591322,
0.0041911532,
-0.0253276974,
-0.0106615657,
0.0664309859,
0.042459812,
0.08203765,
-0.0078765731,
-0.0379010923,
0.0158704426,
-0.0280504748,
0.0243403111,
-0.0402949862,
0.0779701173,
-0.008972575,
0.0096403155,
0.011830139,
-0.0421689712,
-0.0117548406,
0.0220394377,
-0.0414993279,
-0.0170268249,
0.0126640117,
0.0396846235,
0.0072256573,
-0.0109954113,
-0.1182580665,
-0.0017845227,
-0.0356078744,
-0.0719267726,
-0.0050469292,
-0.0491907932,
0.0143336654,
0.0041303337,
-0.019088449,
0.0208519399,
2.262076559e-34,
0.0460139364,
-0.0026499336,
-0.0124681825,
0.0366671719,
0.0341964848,
-0.0406110175,
-0.0031765907,
0.0216587968,
0.016435571,
-0.1334953755,
-0.0074919416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15478v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15478v1 | A Group Fairness Lens for Large Language Models | 2023-12-24T13:25:15 | 2023-12-24T13:25:15 | Guanqun Bi, Lei Shen, Yuqiang Xie, Yanan Cao, Tiangang Zhu, Xiaodong He | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid advancement of large language models has revolutionized various
applications but also raised crucial concerns about their potential to
perpetuate biases and unfairness when deployed in social media contexts.
Evaluating LLMs' potential biases and fairness has become crucial, as existing
methods rely on limited prompts focusing on just a few groups, lacking a
comprehensive categorical perspective. In this paper, we propose evaluating LLM
biases from a group fairness lens using a novel hierarchical schema
characterizing diverse social groups. Specifically, we construct a dataset,
GFair, encapsulating target-attribute combinations across multiple dimensions.
In addition, we introduce statement organization, a new open-ended text
generation task, to uncover complex biases in LLMs. Extensive evaluations of
popular LLMs reveal inherent safety concerns. To mitigate the biases of LLM
from a group fairness perspective, we pioneer a novel chain-of-thought method
GF-Think to mitigate biases of LLMs from a group fairness perspective.
Experimental results demonstrate its efficacy in mitigating bias in LLMs to
achieve fairness. | [
0.0562309176,
0.1072620973,
-0.030059943,
0.0533999465,
-0.0193679892,
0.0192773622,
0.0381453335,
-0.0148556503,
-0.0019030113,
-0.0800664425,
-0.012548713,
-0.0475265533,
0.0220944639,
-0.0057726745,
0.0446376652,
-0.038465146,
0.0275489055,
0.0170250367,
0.041582156,
-0.0500685275,
0.0547043346,
0.0446574911,
0.0109917093,
0.0552570522,
-0.028725015,
0.0059495838,
0.0497839414,
0.020387888,
0.0477764271,
0.0052450895,
0.0337786376,
0.1071900651,
-0.0188992731,
0.0454078428,
0.0000020222,
-0.0553826466,
-0.0286437161,
-0.0057982206,
0.0401581861,
-0.0143339587,
0.0626508668,
-0.0071012354,
0.0044921963,
0.0487529077,
-0.0292465575,
0.0205083899,
0.0512436442,
-0.0061580846,
0.0472523794,
0.0347427875,
-0.0097781336,
-0.0136030195,
-0.0440119654,
-0.0161271561,
0.0180354472,
-0.0071713557,
0.0093328496,
-0.0495887138,
-0.0291743446,
-0.018147178,
0.023664955,
0.0218084045,
0.0017666004,
-0.0033813303,
0.040810179,
-0.0285253134,
-0.0377590358,
-0.040720392,
-0.0130640203,
0.0637270436,
0.0167957135,
0.0007879356,
-0.0088047739,
-0.0230216831,
0.0392085649,
0.021095017,
-0.0373907536,
0.0732671097,
-0.0145036373,
0.0145238033,
-0.0016342535,
0.051138591,
0.0010281622,
0.0483474061,
0.0014109346,
0.0765152499,
0.0088682333,
-0.009847871,
-0.0285555385,
0.0603264868,
-0.0416971371,
-0.046137929,
0.0098221432,
0.0010074134,
-0.0469177403,
0.0201594047,
-0.0412257798,
-0.027430784,
0.0719819739,
-0.0357582308,
0.0576452911,
0.0200373605,
0.0200461242,
-0.0223339852,
0.0412462652,
0.0148634501,
0.0011205509,
0.0060815169,
-0.0109507106,
-0.0152326329,
-0.0152075794,
-0.0124103297,
0.016261775,
0.0170578472,
-0.0391177684,
0.040793255,
-0.0656659156,
0.0022071647,
-0.0524985306,
-0.0349408649,
0.0137207685,
0.0251069963,
0.0046172314,
0.0142279696,
-0.0098258844,
-0.0003905565,
-0.0322857499,
0.0050269505,
-0.002223962,
-0.0556076057,
0.0258630197,
0.0026828966,
-0.0088376505,
-0.0242804233,
-0.0510358997,
0.0394451134,
0.0065553263,
-0.0162618123,
-0.039878238,
-0.0576638505,
-0.0269156639,
-0.0504416078,
-0.0240046512,
-0.0722603798,
0.0353405029,
0.0411688946,
-0.0098594669,
-0.0350802392,
-0.0083288783,
0.0610451102,
-0.0416287556,
0.029923046,
0.0131415604,
0.0190222897,
0.0445238762,
0.0434304066,
0.0002006172,
0.0985822007,
0.024886921,
0.0118978275,
0.0519609116,
0.0150630027,
-0.0027826815,
0.0461742692,
0.0205633305,
0.0153330956,
-0.039684657,
-0.0032157637,
-0.0659453124,
0.0100550996,
0.0186514743,
0.0802765638,
0.0215806235,
-0.0056261662,
0.0780796036,
0.0540290996,
0.0001773784,
0.020570023,
-0.00176444,
0.031551145,
-0.0535407104,
0.005694746,
-0.0386873521,
0.0188177992,
-0.0472969338,
-0.0286286771,
0.0306270849,
0.0730678663,
-0.0179302096,
-0.0171911754,
-0.0336624011,
0.0245511904,
0.0569080748,
0.0055244141,
-0.0288018789,
0.011047747,
0.0068120528,
0.0522611625,
0.0687842444,
-0.082254298,
0.0050011305,
-0.0486373156,
0.0253443681,
0.0454875603,
0.052633971,
-0.0150118424,
0.0204622392,
-0.0085493149,
0.0134617155,
0.0700881407,
0.0405341163,
-0.0215861946,
-0.0380206332,
-0.0411924124,
-0.0292722117,
0.0432438813,
0.012324255,
-0.0070332396,
0.0440048911,
0.0195272807,
0.010050104,
-0.0105711175,
-0.0419641882,
0.0279190075,
0.0449756868,
0.0195390806,
-0.0115580587,
0.0250972454,
0.0072351913,
0.0321636088,
-0.0054687047,
-0.002858852,
-0.0418039002,
-0.0199950971,
-0.0394958705,
-0.0069514415,
-0.0636316985,
-0.0286012478,
0.0089559788,
-0.0492839217,
-0.025226118,
0.0392550603,
-0.0273753311,
0.0185853411,
0.0677418113,
-0.0058030519,
-0.0063906265,
-0.0305249505,
0.0079905344,
-0.0334475711,
0.0064611649,
-0.0735375881,
0.0512846708,
-0.0171394683,
-0.0107964976,
0.0112791294,
-0.0550135039,
0.002122141,
-0.0292780623,
-0.008191891,
0.0361766629,
-0.0067738099,
0.0361321643,
0.0455614813,
0.018588433,
-0.0223708879,
-0.0152218323,
-0.070541136,
-0.0108387824,
-0.0299327336,
0.0064848959,
0.0140099172,
0.0363026001,
-0.0148499217,
0.0095783984,
-0.0623958856,
-0.0026005346,
0.0310146753,
0.0342798531,
0.0304450151,
-0.0574003793,
-0.0147833787,
-0.0287036374,
-0.0337355547,
-0.0388724282,
0.0685897171,
0.0462732501,
-0.0217034724,
-0.0287855156,
-0.0320194289,
-0.0777046382,
-0.0177202262,
0.0327277146,
-0.0055575874,
0.0268670674,
0.0484949313,
0.0430313684,
0.0171356276,
0.0676637068,
0.0272256471,
0.0360583365,
0.0103727132,
-0.0242789984,
-0.0377162918,
-0.0070879878,
-0.0071656555,
0.0247924402,
-0.0729813427,
0.0143209845,
0.0710827187,
0.0509756766,
-0.0388206318,
-0.0754057616,
0.0483795181,
-0.0905395746,
-0.058366444,
-0.0496956222,
-0.0528587811,
-0.0165211316,
0.0243814271,
-0.0415313654,
-0.0588799827,
0.0570599735,
0.0030603516,
0.0287686158,
-0.0290395487,
-0.0050510219,
-0.064436093,
0.0524579473,
-0.0083293682,
0.0506112352,
0.0244635586,
-0.0207998212,
-0.0567313917,
-0.006175647,
0.047001496,
-0.0337746479,
0.0512308218,
-0.0359394327,
0.0091221817,
-0.0190608371,
-0.0305105466,
-0.0353812389,
-0.0775099173,
0.0101215858,
0.0042619486,
0.0208716448,
-0.0331617445,
-0.0100234253,
0.012440349,
-0.0025564833,
-0.0129944291,
-0.0452389903,
-0.0050453418,
0.0077039879,
0.0124511346,
0.0353185385,
-0.0432978161,
0.043584846,
-0.0583827496,
-0.0013931778,
0.0645074844,
0.0303239245,
0.0058142915,
0.0247959848,
-0.009874559,
0.0379716717,
-0.0200417172,
0.0054676645,
0.0048811352,
0.0788142607,
-0.0017280049,
0.0310554598,
0.1018339768,
0.0302211121,
-0.0676401779,
0.0357183777,
-0.0018136856,
0.0553171635,
0.0084835347,
-0.0040845727,
-0.1150914952,
-0.0086437874,
-0.0083544254,
0.0374454744,
-0.0501179174,
-0.057013277,
-0.0065571684,
-0.1024691388,
0.0400736444,
0.0132292202,
-0.0273307767,
-0.0047944244,
0.0200392045,
0.0267879032,
-0.0017407179,
0.0386020169,
-0.0074234162,
0.0003782006,
-0.0016727286,
0.0097908219,
-0.0331951044,
-0.0195637941,
0.0159782376,
-0.0688716173,
0.0459671691,
0.0217927266,
0.018484395,
0.0287811179,
-0.0257237665,
0.0383558348,
-0.0281694774,
-0.010009707,
-0.021951139,
0.0339096077,
-0.022839481,
0.0006942042,
-0.0404260047,
0.0277971644,
-0.0138701396,
-0.0087497942,
0.0020917915,
0.0206477642,
0.0115547348,
-0.0353566743,
-0.061834842,
0.0119762048,
0.0217241719,
0.0686793849,
0.0488520861,
-0.0445124656,
0.0097562047,
-0.0633834526,
-0.0164958779,
-0.0360586196,
-0.0779782459,
0.0416519493,
0.0149469776,
-0.0237106606,
-0.0666741058,
-0.0460837148,
0.0104044825,
-0.0039314018,
-0.0059825545,
-0.0393299498,
-0.0018599249,
-0.0188199393,
-0.053164795,
-0.00021019,
-0.0352824815,
0.0413309522,
-0.0006210214,
-0.0245127603,
-0.0358111747,
-0.0016978919,
-0.0092126457,
0.0381220356,
-0.0698307976,
-0.076061368,
0.0139632784,
-0.0059531438,
0.0229027867,
0.0089022815,
0.0078819776,
-0.0914192572,
0.0507835373,
0.034086559,
-0.0139335813,
0.0558436997,
-0.0175646115,
-0.0122901602,
0.0111012673,
0.0507370122,
-0.0229698233,
0.0358299576,
0.0183783155,
0.0233761873,
-0.0049008369,
-0.0460006632,
-0.0121314628,
0.0096869227,
-0.0115546975,
-0.05424935,
-0.0172078256,
-0.0594810024,
-0.0435233228,
-0.0475900471,
-0.0426764563,
-0.0339886434,
-0.024227852,
-0.0101140384,
0.0063165422,
-0.0329630673,
-0.0592702441,
-0.0430970564,
0.0358751789,
-0.0639910847,
0.0802251399,
-0.0490604155,
0.0343209766,
0.0214915965,
0.0074142851,
-0.0121888323,
0.0049319868,
-0.0328411311,
0.0263557993,
0.0165117793,
0.0340754688,
0.015412692,
0.0104791326,
-0.0376069881,
0.0426900722,
-0.005473678,
-0.0166405272,
-0.00455026,
-0.014153542,
0.0098008588,
0.0058481772,
0.0690594614,
0.0128732892,
0.0038954848,
0.0148161631,
0.0240861438,
-0.0259309169,
-0.0302944351,
0.0164196845,
-0.000934212,
-0.0146598406,
-0.0205195136,
0.0715223551,
0.0411062166,
0.0056640999,
-0.0297282226,
-0.0367049314,
-0.0202878378,
-0.0332557298,
0.0228987373,
-0.0010529865,
-0.0092973299,
-0.0238409583,
-0.1067633852,
-0.0593627244,
-0.0286011752,
-0.0021874541,
0.0349625163,
0.0032367192,
0.0203275383,
0.0586664528,
-0.0078105116,
-0.0323665142,
-0.0343124904,
-0.0397782512,
-0.0302565861,
-0.0346445031,
0.0050787809,
-6.846838762e-33,
-0.0173390564,
-0.0695587695,
-0.014251451,
-0.0197937228,
-0.0242973473,
0.010696698,
-0.0308806486,
0.0153158121,
0.0208843369,
0.0034468553,
0.0029921925,
0.0009917634,
0.0119277127,
0.0414093919,
0.0292083509,
-0.0097631784,
0.0346134603,
-0.0094667422,
-0.0357408561,
0.0240888298,
-0.0007074579,
-0.0023996208,
0.0219881628,
-0.0409877785,
0.0682173669,
-0.0219936203,
-0.0222000498,
0.0312016476,
-0.0009875624,
0.03921571,
0.0010962373,
0.089136824,
0.0535329059,
-0.0125876898,
-0.0249964818,
0.0639478862,
-0.0201353673,
-0.0234634299,
0.0160017032,
-0.0118731363,
-0.0040867394,
-0.0122233257,
0.028646579,
0.0061612935,
-0.0401498303,
-0.0381755903,
0.0526713841,
0.0061941673,
0.0546902753,
0.0097498968,
-0.0814309344,
0.0349975266,
-0.0216062553,
0.0302162357,
-0.0060057063,
0.0022217743,
0.0137833543,
0.038085416,
-0.0097507099,
0.0531143844,
-0.0222479794,
-0.0014806073,
0.0676703379,
0.0407556593,
-0.0185578689,
0.0567625985,
0.0112304809,
0.064638935,
-0.0577388145,
-0.0148701845,
0.0110359779,
0.0018994812,
0.0366298743,
0.0884483233,
0.0085788779,
-0.0167070329,
-0.0421111546,
0.0178440455,
0.0180519987,
-0.0294872131,
0.0307675581,
-0.0066021606,
-0.0717393532,
-0.0513191447,
-0.0001441364,
-0.0285534412,
-0.0358914696,
-0.0100635318,
0.0257023387,
-0.0060382411,
-0.0546631999,
0.0106285661,
0.0385386236,
-0.0112325875,
-0.0401876494,
0.0329170525,
-0.0012792501,
-0.0016587073,
-0.0126098581,
0.0036782841,
-0.0799070001,
0.0053175245,
0.0170842409,
0.0317487232,
-0.0011550892,
0.0221476201,
0.0092971241,
0.022365503,
-0.0540764742,
0.0118703358,
-0.0142480796,
0.0428263694,
-0.0317027234,
-0.0213764701,
0.0124909468,
-0.0093882661,
-0.0088530658,
0.0285239257,
0.0512108989,
-0.026932992,
-0.0275861789,
0.0319242403,
-0.0276613627,
0.0194138493,
-0.0351219773,
-0.0094503481,
0.0010050893,
-0.0243269634,
0.0958752558,
-0.0360883847,
-0.0176977143,
-0.0792062134,
2.701e-7,
0.0410006642,
0.0451695323,
-0.0043703145,
0.0541274063,
0.0053869518,
0.0349786766,
0.0700129718,
0.0435334593,
0.0191271547,
0.016918093,
0.01013273,
0.064391464,
0.0314101651,
0.0483542942,
-0.0324946232,
0.0278075226,
-0.0836220235,
0.0233823396,
-0.0352992527,
-0.0139549151,
0.017634118,
0.0218978971,
0.0227143224,
-0.0327721834,
-0.0474568978,
-0.0165375564,
0.026695149,
-0.0096334936,
-0.0191364102,
0.0227616895,
0.0448372811,
-0.0275068562,
0.0363759287,
0.0304549709,
0.0049215192,
-0.0094927736,
0.0026167375,
-0.0205095448,
0.0031956499,
0.0024166349,
0.0059480104,
-0.0205004979,
0.0012800809,
-0.0819998309,
0.0237655416,
0.0010052469,
-0.0289753992,
-0.0355903469,
0.026483953,
-0.0217418429,
0.0293445624,
-0.0298359599,
-0.0186192766,
0.0238363631,
0.0179493856,
0.0218487214,
-0.0103169363,
-0.0640240386,
-0.0477736108,
-0.0339047015,
-0.0270174071,
-0.0522940978,
-0.003076761,
0.0309552494,
-0.0294756219,
-0.0220467262,
0.0244872123,
2.650940192e-34,
0.00230435,
0.0036985301,
0.0120000057,
-0.0120037692,
0.043931365,
0.0215355698,
-0.0392420217,
-0.0194704197,
0.024629293,
-0.0228662994,
-0.0292169787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15472v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15472v1 | Towards Consistent Language Models Using Declarative Constraints | 2023-12-24T12:53:07 | 2023-12-24T12:53:07 | Jasmin Mousavi, Arash Termehchy | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL | Large language models have shown unprecedented abilities in generating
linguistically coherent and syntactically correct natural language output.
However, they often return incorrect and inconsistent answers to input
questions. Due to the complexity and uninterpretability of the internally
learned representations, it is challenging to modify language models such that
they provide correct and consistent results. The data management community has
developed various methods and tools for providing consistent answers over
inconsistent datasets. In these methods, users specify the desired properties
of data in a domain in the form of high-level declarative constraints. This
approach has provided usable and scalable methods to delivering consistent
information from inconsistent datasets. We aim to build upon this success and
leverage these methods to modify language models such that they deliver
consistent and accurate results. We investigate the challenges of using these
ideas to obtain consistent and relevant answers from language models and report
some preliminary empirical studies. | [
0.0758193433,
0.120487459,
-0.0297782477,
0.0287624486,
-0.0477185659,
-0.0152704231,
-0.0102586141,
-0.0190517642,
-0.0117568849,
-0.0535286553,
0.0034045046,
-0.0408876948,
0.0134619456,
0.0256819855,
-0.0108231558,
-0.0570915379,
0.0568624251,
-0.0177353229,
-0.0001474051,
-0.024082562,
0.0336289257,
0.0004721919,
0.0285815615,
0.0001590538,
-0.0303023346,
-0.0239759218,
0.0086660758,
0.0009357826,
-0.0275090728,
0.0098368572,
0.0241225548,
0.0396550186,
0.0064483047,
0.043412067,
0.0000022123,
-0.0571255907,
-0.025343325,
-0.0089745792,
-0.027659392,
0.0033116406,
0.0074118148,
-0.0438781567,
0.0088994093,
-0.0037220859,
-0.0465552285,
-0.028195966,
0.0548225828,
0.002402395,
0.1031603292,
0.0443616286,
-0.0061860457,
-0.0330960974,
-0.0125990901,
-0.0149182295,
-0.0033836686,
-0.009346881,
0.0538720489,
0.0636504069,
0.0330486596,
0.0010307441,
0.0091938386,
0.029071575,
0.0283816364,
-0.0142014418,
-0.0059811622,
-0.0023401983,
-0.0491968058,
-0.0435176194,
-0.0044803242,
0.0457186289,
0.0492595956,
-0.0539150238,
0.0072657196,
-0.0239244848,
-0.0162680726,
0.0301146414,
-0.0325924344,
0.0344604217,
-0.0040050671,
0.013723637,
-0.0067106439,
0.0153152319,
0.0342702046,
0.0154763069,
-0.0587576143,
0.064073205,
0.0162477326,
-0.0343803391,
-0.0561971962,
-0.0121704508,
-0.051134266,
-0.0808398575,
0.0327812284,
0.0422242396,
-0.066336073,
0.0264965072,
-0.0787332132,
-0.0391413011,
0.0507198125,
-0.0681813583,
0.0343146659,
0.0272549931,
-0.0182356797,
0.0444111004,
0.0313988216,
0.0851763859,
-0.0143175432,
0.0015157792,
-0.024453165,
-0.0321507789,
-0.0388255753,
-0.027354518,
-0.0430857167,
0.0156581458,
-0.0013945927,
0.0028385257,
-0.0143356202,
0.0413997211,
-0.0493313931,
0.053572569,
-0.0103448182,
-0.0231604129,
-0.0378835015,
-0.025020957,
-0.0569328927,
0.0356645621,
-0.0394059196,
0.0246110503,
-0.0140927276,
-0.0655632243,
0.019732058,
-0.0032865864,
-0.0171699338,
-0.0139231458,
0.0022801177,
0.0690697804,
0.0338818021,
0.0467341058,
-0.0297901519,
-0.0419031382,
-0.0281557366,
-0.0600578375,
-0.0514350012,
-0.0873735622,
0.0374850146,
0.0359308645,
-0.00980468,
-0.1015413404,
-0.0065599959,
0.0148818977,
-0.0254075695,
0.0974182636,
-0.0525609963,
0.027577661,
0.0377747305,
0.0089537343,
0.0191162173,
0.0532116741,
0.0124987951,
-0.0190927722,
0.0516863614,
-0.0212919954,
0.0286123436,
0.0410460643,
0.0091604209,
0.0000414502,
-0.0647782236,
0.0646237209,
0.0101913074,
0.033949364,
-0.0211736597,
0.1077482477,
0.0006590101,
-0.0177458748,
0.0644967034,
0.0026179017,
0.0151278432,
0.0085236337,
0.0133557962,
0.0018763457,
0.0075269509,
0.0147896893,
-0.0499274246,
-0.0200409163,
0.0151442084,
0.01050473,
-0.0013507756,
0.0254941024,
0.0032448571,
-0.0744382516,
-0.0391788073,
0.0359914303,
0.0078042997,
0.0250530429,
0.0497858785,
-0.0020653545,
0.0295973681,
0.0779704899,
0.0348855108,
-0.013412429,
0.0096593462,
0.0041382411,
0.0221371371,
0.0563524477,
0.0433019735,
-0.038020432,
-0.0462442748,
0.0045702918,
0.0473459326,
0.0542590767,
0.0727878511,
-0.0322006866,
-0.0333809629,
-0.025790073,
-0.0249224808,
0.0459254012,
0.0239839721,
-0.0094235428,
0.0145126078,
-0.0003074995,
0.0117944852,
-0.0446014106,
-0.0421049632,
0.0392794944,
-0.0168604478,
-0.0166467149,
-0.0228732638,
-0.0002404745,
0.0160908289,
0.0189897269,
-0.0081111714,
0.0338333882,
0.034559194,
0.0064501716,
-0.0182213709,
-0.0138691328,
-0.0411209427,
0.0396904685,
0.0845350623,
-0.0353129357,
-0.0353171863,
0.0242989156,
-0.0281001851,
-0.0386522263,
0.0194966942,
-0.0519555472,
0.023992179,
-0.0257707536,
0.0207145084,
-0.0123782717,
-0.0216146614,
-0.0415121317,
0.052471187,
0.0163151193,
0.0156389773,
0.0208941493,
-0.0362452753,
0.0453968123,
-0.0430301987,
0.01658074,
0.0341479108,
0.0036050233,
0.0505847372,
0.0538621172,
0.002910546,
-0.0219001584,
-0.0031110914,
-0.0286481772,
-0.0214506555,
-0.0046434002,
0.0086476654,
0.0406845137,
0.019801449,
-0.004910843,
-0.0070398953,
-0.025482893,
-0.0245955791,
0.0412520356,
0.0196258556,
0.0348388143,
0.0313985609,
-0.0313620456,
-0.0371274129,
-0.023496436,
-0.0339352824,
0.0186807048,
-0.0132481018,
-0.0337182619,
-0.0788506716,
-0.0286234561,
-0.0769262463,
0.0465544611,
-0.0095851794,
0.0155477645,
0.0269403998,
-0.009789749,
0.0065212729,
-0.0157882143,
-0.0396069624,
0.0210104119,
0.0760712549,
-0.0198479109,
-0.0712031648,
-0.0176591501,
-0.0070469645,
0.0066864844,
0.0014507396,
-0.0323052853,
-0.0054850318,
0.0409689583,
0.0162247103,
-0.0125782005,
-0.0432901271,
0.0646556243,
-0.0426898077,
-0.0062704971,
-0.0557777844,
-0.0440628715,
-0.0131515702,
0.0658751503,
-0.0171776805,
-0.0527684614,
0.0814907774,
-0.0399026312,
0.0292175915,
-0.0376160294,
-0.016764719,
-0.0369304791,
0.0481768809,
0.0037303499,
0.0240345467,
0.037057966,
-0.000336853,
-0.0576975271,
-0.0040113069,
0.048320055,
-0.0463451371,
0.0894499198,
-0.0733292401,
0.0401962735,
0.0077718445,
-0.0506630205,
-0.0589844435,
-0.0413798653,
-0.0199408811,
0.0287517793,
0.0033232586,
-0.0083492128,
-0.0427135937,
0.0007158404,
0.0033364124,
0.0259890649,
0.0043616639,
-0.0201112647,
-0.0507439338,
-0.0119388737,
0.0584140271,
0.0349791013,
0.0197254792,
0.0100529836,
-0.0180119239,
0.0295644216,
-0.0039594471,
-0.0019484743,
-0.0063917143,
0.0212789215,
0.0319254994,
-0.0442131497,
0.0049446444,
0.0186218563,
0.036111746,
-0.053311374,
-0.0279224869,
0.1064897552,
0.0457819216,
-0.0189224165,
0.0180277675,
-0.0359742306,
0.0165262111,
0.0434493758,
0.0524200052,
-0.0970710516,
-0.0234172996,
0.0051574172,
0.0430745706,
0.0102360239,
-0.0141665926,
-0.039510943,
-0.0877803937,
0.0065085324,
0.0268126987,
-0.0373010859,
-0.0456206612,
-0.0384461954,
0.0040210378,
-0.0175203197,
0.0466524698,
0.0286865029,
-0.0205409061,
-0.0017796628,
0.0074405456,
-0.0013881595,
-0.0416058339,
0.0120288273,
-0.041840598,
0.0617434196,
0.0653664172,
0.0036097905,
0.0080228234,
-0.0120189385,
0.0511335433,
0.001681157,
-0.0361525863,
-0.0256106257,
-0.0273365229,
0.0136256674,
-0.0178812146,
-0.0274664406,
0.0162267555,
-0.0381124914,
-0.0097270776,
-0.0060436879,
0.0853855759,
-0.0098880054,
0.0057133511,
-0.0247978028,
-0.0317718275,
0.0156508107,
0.1019046679,
0.0302822497,
-0.0033114993,
-0.0276740175,
-0.0524646193,
-0.0140961446,
0.0091115385,
-0.0101589151,
0.04264367,
-0.0058727022,
0.0173768438,
-0.0556159578,
-0.0553591475,
0.0335031413,
0.0019373525,
0.0380102918,
-0.0141929612,
0.0362450108,
-0.0286712013,
-0.0356365219,
0.006305329,
-0.0534147024,
0.0234229155,
-0.041838605,
-0.0065549258,
-0.0122762611,
-0.0133082839,
-0.0020156796,
0.0540233739,
-0.0358787663,
-0.0753303394,
0.0237395931,
0.0310122222,
0.0369548947,
0.0377207249,
-0.021514995,
-0.0592206344,
-0.033913333,
0.0381675176,
-0.0409365594,
-0.017048832,
-0.0200539976,
-0.0031420398,
0.001701992,
0.0286084916,
-0.0580526702,
0.0191872083,
0.0012728657,
0.0616981126,
-0.0505494662,
-0.0327712446,
0.0787928924,
0.035867136,
-0.0117278202,
0.0170854572,
-0.0195511021,
-0.0031339424,
-0.0033852833,
-0.0473488681,
-0.0624627806,
-0.0293911453,
0.0143292462,
0.0104471175,
0.0047687669,
-0.0045586061,
0.0130217168,
-0.0376146957,
0.0316811614,
-0.051914759,
-0.0076855314,
0.0268445015,
-0.010951071,
0.0330127701,
-0.0144501077,
0.0014772316,
0.0394714065,
-0.0126505746,
0.0595878437,
-0.0251924638,
0.0199986938,
0.0333829001,
0.0142228529,
-0.045038186,
-0.0182872638,
-0.0418763347,
-0.0648023412,
-0.013960476,
-0.0076236846,
0.0225570165,
0.0188928302,
0.0461434573,
-0.0379181467,
-0.0212398469,
-0.0395053104,
-0.000301774,
0.0739393756,
-0.0156855658,
0.0258404631,
0.0303012766,
-0.0256236885,
-0.0048839562,
0.0662679002,
0.0172236562,
0.0458202288,
-0.0421001054,
-0.030448731,
-0.0355743319,
-0.013289813,
-0.0063033463,
0.0175436456,
-0.0523891784,
-0.0510407425,
-0.0607006066,
-0.0781779811,
-0.002865847,
0.0585746951,
0.0066807708,
-0.0086474642,
-0.011488881,
0.053522978,
0.0342735723,
-0.0264482573,
-0.0195403881,
0.0235396121,
-0.0321293958,
-0.0103076473,
-0.0515643954,
-6.483669048e-33,
-0.0234848373,
-0.0229511224,
0.0202163476,
-0.0597622953,
0.0056181927,
-0.0049383626,
-0.0327000804,
-0.0111910012,
-0.0123173771,
0.0040431553,
-0.0098473392,
0.0181378573,
0.0205906704,
0.0084616086,
0.0226639621,
-0.0168101713,
0.0331361666,
0.0113947652,
-0.0299571678,
-0.0101312995,
0.0665073618,
-0.0120699191,
0.0435409769,
-0.061139144,
0.0581279062,
-0.0168459415,
-0.0210281927,
0.0727376938,
-0.0106466142,
0.0626514629,
-0.0128432242,
0.0538308546,
0.0161467735,
-0.0553819016,
-0.0531178676,
0.0027645305,
-0.0784280971,
-0.03332486,
0.0363968089,
0.0149607053,
-0.0041095675,
-0.0077191517,
0.0830289647,
-0.0428295396,
-0.009717443,
0.0284615736,
0.0200605989,
-0.0132758236,
-0.0064087342,
-0.004559001,
-0.0671238154,
0.0294171162,
0.0095565021,
0.0183074884,
0.0094181029,
0.01924772,
0.0051529994,
0.0166246276,
-0.0487574488,
0.0300538167,
0.052666273,
0.0355362929,
0.0630276427,
0.0153130554,
-0.0076456056,
0.0439524353,
-0.0122782439,
-0.0264883768,
-0.0265880078,
-0.0082755638,
-0.0052925507,
0.048648078,
0.0273013804,
0.060212899,
0.0207026135,
0.0005319623,
-0.0497013107,
0.0304437689,
-0.0163237844,
0.0302751865,
-0.0170050748,
0.0155811636,
-0.0582731441,
-0.044425346,
-0.0318520777,
0.0100273285,
-0.047575146,
-0.0062101269,
0.0395532064,
-0.0132913794,
-0.0348687768,
0.0417834781,
0.005181496,
-0.0702098534,
-0.0887122378,
0.0068372139,
-0.0024059813,
-0.0037415996,
0.0213737004,
0.0370759889,
-0.0380819477,
0.003095747,
0.0074442145,
0.0155864432,
0.0124823898,
0.0390391015,
0.0108598396,
0.0150453066,
-0.0321421474,
0.0201188102,
-0.0292417016,
-0.0017569473,
-0.0400344878,
-0.0153942304,
0.0558179058,
0.0115409875,
0.0015390768,
0.006339408,
0.0318453871,
-0.0268222336,
-0.0247093681,
0.0327462852,
0.0036102813,
0.0271156207,
-0.0125466138,
-0.0084756594,
-0.0491052754,
0.0045802812,
0.0522775464,
0.0003639297,
0.00690541,
-0.0098205293,
2.795e-7,
0.0655860975,
0.0546243303,
0.0354518555,
0.0456772409,
0.0181629322,
0.0129222125,
-0.0274678692,
0.0038174863,
-0.0207245238,
-0.0391942486,
0.0111807715,
0.0056977691,
0.0369030684,
0.0464913398,
-0.0231116712,
0.0105196405,
-0.0512283035,
0.0052337502,
-0.0542814694,
0.0295662116,
0.0716088563,
0.0698646307,
0.0162880514,
-0.0040233866,
-0.0334384777,
-0.0443548858,
0.0327086784,
-0.0260578506,
0.0314461142,
0.0373179615,
0.0404548533,
-0.0007518681,
0.0353780426,
0.0044865389,
-0.0144897392,
-0.0005709738,
-0.0106100021,
0.0726661161,
-0.0076339296,
0.0359217972,
-0.061292477,
-0.0435175151,
-0.0014584089,
-0.073111847,
0.0533520095,
-0.0435675159,
-0.0118498895,
-0.0090778675,
-0.0236127302,
-0.0108350106,
-0.0072977412,
0.019093249,
-0.0334415697,
0.0203486122,
0.0307229329,
0.0384736918,
-0.0384382419,
-0.0397088118,
-0.0320413746,
0.0075400881,
-0.0377852805,
-0.0204973612,
-0.0147459237,
0.0118329069,
0.0222241823,
-0.0671294555,
0.016315937,
2.684030358e-34,
0.033897087,
0.0265835728,
0.0084426794,
-0.0210762154,
0.0367730781,
-0.0142761599,
-0.002989603,
0.0455949903,
0.0152517837,
-0.0697337016,
-0.0152987149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.17262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.17262v1 | Multimodal Classification of Teaching Activities from University Lecture Recordings | 2023-12-24T08:33:30 | 2023-12-24T08:33:30 | Oscar Sapena, Eva Onaindia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T05 (Primary), 97P80 (Secondary), I.2.6; I.2.7; I.5.4 | The way of understanding online higher education has greatly changed due to
the worldwide pandemic situation. Teaching is undertaken remotely, and the
faculty incorporate lecture audio recordings as part of the teaching material.
This new online teaching-learning setting has largely impacted university
classes. While online teaching technology that enriches virtual classrooms has
been abundant over the past two years, the same has not occurred in supporting
students during online learning. {To overcome this limitation, our aim is to
work toward enabling students to easily access the piece of the lesson
recording in which the teacher explains a theoretical concept, solves an
exercise, or comments on organizational issues of the course. To that end, we
present a multimodal classification algorithm that identifies the type of
activity that is being carried out at any time of the lesson by using a
transformer-based language model that exploits features from the audio file and
from the automated lecture transcription. The experimental results will show
that some academic activities are more easily identifiable with the audio
signal while resorting to the text transcription is needed to identify others.
All in all, our contribution aims to recognize the academic activities of a
teacher during a lesson. | [
0.018016737,
-0.00801442,
-0.0242599472,
0.0289913062,
0.0013999488,
0.0071532815,
0.0457296409,
0.0012149104,
-0.0560557358,
-0.1380206645,
-0.0073880181,
-0.0106314737,
0.0105921477,
-0.0198258664,
0.0343398526,
-0.1173568293,
-0.0157902557,
-0.0400491953,
-0.0499119163,
0.0385945067,
-0.0009948926,
0.0022035281,
-0.0871553645,
0.0185073819,
-0.0383799896,
0.0078777289,
-0.0379326083,
-0.0331134163,
0.0122955022,
0.0311648622,
-0.0211141054,
0.0443620533,
0.0206761993,
-0.0144183794,
0.0000019093,
-0.0155361183,
-0.0191134345,
-0.0351327248,
0.0403367653,
-0.038409058,
0.0537085272,
0.0298645534,
-0.0080047371,
0.0074698883,
-0.022801714,
-0.0025305373,
0.0410508215,
0.026710853,
0.0262145624,
0.0348720588,
-0.0163648147,
-0.0395749137,
0.0089525776,
0.0669074804,
0.0430566706,
0.016041832,
-0.0091026947,
0.0150163723,
0.0254490227,
0.0355877876,
-0.0501034819,
0.0288562272,
-0.0451140031,
-0.0194927454,
0.0076911463,
0.0164539125,
-0.044263456,
-0.0420430563,
-0.0086489292,
0.0310121253,
0.0196259189,
0.0301643461,
0.0390140191,
0.041229222,
0.0068901214,
0.0721746162,
-0.043677602,
0.0455149747,
-0.0408060253,
-0.0223220866,
-0.0392383263,
0.0588251576,
-0.0219588019,
0.0216280706,
0.0456450395,
-0.063763611,
0.0112416577,
-0.0016280168,
-0.0150851691,
-0.00489954,
0.0022497908,
0.0266361032,
0.0350416228,
0.0397540741,
0.0214776266,
-0.0099610845,
-0.0138252266,
-0.0489496887,
-0.0247282516,
-0.012860328,
-0.006807284,
0.0271241851,
-0.0304498598,
0.0434971787,
0.0126337605,
0.0390243977,
-0.0081738709,
-0.0160668902,
-0.0194019154,
0.0343656465,
-0.0669106469,
0.0230471212,
-0.0085767265,
0.0106932335,
0.022904275,
-0.0525232106,
-0.0387825333,
0.0154087394,
-0.0248478465,
0.0227261856,
-0.0138709219,
-0.0157672372,
-0.0004706375,
0.0336637907,
0.0441373698,
0.0566930398,
0.0215630233,
0.062560074,
-0.0582793243,
-0.0341844298,
0.075774312,
0.0427738018,
0.0329800248,
0.0101756863,
0.0020532345,
0.0385760516,
-0.0295233876,
-0.0478979871,
-0.0112917982,
-0.0337173045,
-0.0301368497,
0.012078396,
0.043185398,
-0.0519424565,
-0.0112611884,
-0.0249936935,
0.0052427044,
0.0320933796,
0.0097264117,
-0.0161414985,
0.0328595005,
0.0707340091,
0.0264046174,
0.0370693654,
0.1099630743,
0.0362356007,
-0.0131676923,
0.0002778455,
0.0242299978,
-0.0318858586,
0.0758193433,
-0.0414182171,
0.0416420735,
0.0783049166,
-0.0667535737,
-0.0360552892,
0.0084657222,
-0.0657508448,
0.0380927771,
0.0071992595,
-0.0311235096,
0.0150030693,
-0.0080382535,
0.0124605484,
0.0506057143,
0.050823044,
-0.0157485548,
-0.0317384824,
-0.0001765273,
0.0005750487,
0.0019214868,
0.0588322282,
0.0434240513,
-0.0006434271,
-0.0224406663,
-0.0380175374,
0.0357153825,
0.0008128551,
-0.0224966239,
-0.0452015623,
-0.0476259217,
-0.0574695989,
0.0140516646,
-0.0157150459,
0.0571074411,
-0.0189447198,
-0.0233104955,
0.0331108272,
-0.006179044,
-0.045125965,
0.0167795941,
-0.0505686775,
0.0069548953,
0.039082095,
0.0224985071,
-0.0530690216,
-0.0030581993,
-0.0388818644,
0.0395133719,
0.0052116192,
0.0339253023,
-0.0201769061,
-0.0013099152,
-0.0542109646,
-0.0209665969,
0.0091221603,
0.0149278939,
-0.0145046506,
-0.0248665866,
0.0109971557,
0.0150842164,
-0.0021970489,
0.0248852912,
0.0245583244,
0.0004783925,
-0.0407159962,
-0.024285648,
0.0628224462,
0.0253357198,
0.043746125,
0.0125980219,
-0.0029843876,
0.0304322913,
-0.0345514268,
0.0468923301,
0.0359372646,
-0.0053802454,
0.0085379416,
0.0513911024,
-0.0671109259,
0.0154977627,
0.0289445743,
0.0083076237,
-0.0464087985,
0.0395599045,
-0.0293362644,
0.0183919966,
-0.0190219805,
0.0322229899,
0.0073508346,
0.0023067587,
0.0031332751,
-0.0154032465,
0.0302651841,
0.0490792543,
-0.0105291568,
-0.0197560843,
0.024548281,
-0.0464893542,
-0.0224702228,
0.0282128546,
-0.0543682389,
0.0186688993,
-0.0043331864,
-0.0181357805,
-0.0279024951,
-0.0290212128,
-0.0619896688,
-0.0378293656,
-0.009071202,
-0.0012699821,
-0.0110165235,
-0.0153827872,
0.0122690471,
-0.0199402794,
-0.0056144195,
-0.0151541093,
-0.0131784603,
-0.0070407521,
-0.0308225453,
-0.0234470274,
-0.0180157516,
-0.0036310845,
-0.0130021572,
0.0024424561,
0.0187629592,
0.0546853654,
-0.024138093,
-0.0241470523,
-0.0273019932,
0.039308548,
0.0057824608,
0.0015109774,
-0.0041421372,
0.0129978275,
-0.0282173306,
0.0321967676,
0.0589078888,
0.0178982988,
0.0411552228,
0.0323354155,
-0.0143631548,
-0.0182716772,
-0.0101889065,
0.0004147378,
0.0112055466,
-0.0394288525,
-0.0195134599,
-0.0399621874,
-0.0227755923,
0.037580654,
0.0325825475,
0.0084103681,
-0.0377707183,
-0.0335372798,
0.0370357037,
-0.0496725291,
-0.0232579764,
-0.0340600535,
-0.0223205648,
0.0375464968,
0.0116436109,
-0.0053908825,
-0.0309816226,
-0.011878714,
-0.0306984466,
-0.0488857739,
-0.0035902248,
0.0571508221,
-0.0229779333,
0.0241145063,
-0.0006937021,
-0.0507412665,
-0.0353527106,
0.007701566,
0.0710170642,
-0.0700378194,
-0.0202572476,
-0.0367968529,
-0.0140039874,
-0.0055484152,
0.0296249446,
-0.00750652,
0.0170534905,
-0.006061452,
0.0043953429,
-0.0423510596,
0.0135102607,
-0.0375506394,
0.0474069268,
0.0109492829,
0.0101492889,
0.0134973433,
0.0076930444,
0.0218959823,
0.097134389,
-0.0022769254,
0.0444332846,
-0.1292272508,
-0.0106603233,
0.0062283049,
0.0102733811,
0.0228505917,
-0.0212303624,
-0.0272229109,
-0.0072191944,
0.0498779528,
0.0000880369,
-0.0684095845,
0.0389534831,
0.021277329,
-0.0231882595,
0.0176797491,
0.1011509895,
0.0130566116,
-0.0733310431,
-0.0221779235,
0.0368354581,
-0.0752894208,
-0.0051756161,
0.0105586778,
-0.0481524691,
-0.0217240136,
-0.0092167649,
0.0245251078,
0.0196940005,
0.0267417412,
0.0210440475,
-0.027277099,
0.0266844444,
0.0178852901,
-0.0478685349,
-0.0171578228,
-0.0746598542,
0.0291422233,
-0.0420512818,
-0.005603597,
-0.056285616,
-0.0162062254,
-0.0096243788,
0.0623928122,
-0.0255021825,
-0.0516059026,
0.0043829218,
0.0132027138,
0.0083572865,
0.0195806716,
0.0432750992,
-0.023519801,
-0.1088974252,
0.0150736701,
0.0034624971,
0.0260120388,
-0.0210558269,
0.0553611889,
-0.0226400755,
0.0280974451,
0.0473729521,
0.0420981571,
0.0142630646,
-0.0257885661,
0.0171786565,
0.0807215795,
-0.0393298604,
0.0247976948,
-0.0480993837,
0.0236164127,
0.0511392169,
0.0276438762,
-0.0234679412,
-0.042536661,
0.0157395974,
0.0104200784,
0.0546677187,
0.0120763909,
-0.0309466328,
-0.0110929273,
-0.0125091467,
-0.03783511,
-0.0288524181,
0.0003690217,
0.0236163978,
0.0247061029,
-0.0091157127,
0.01911458,
0.0481179506,
0.0784923881,
-0.0891949236,
0.0138907954,
0.0403367318,
0.0472603254,
-0.0505641364,
-0.0741197541,
0.040686354,
-0.0386455618,
0.0122866044,
-0.0168749914,
-0.0409932099,
-0.0314365588,
-0.0030224361,
-0.0113977641,
0.0207504556,
0.0024841798,
0.0235207435,
0.0012976824,
-0.0267833229,
-0.0054840711,
-0.0270086117,
0.0040316335,
0.059918534,
-0.0188919138,
-0.0444910638,
-0.0263664424,
-0.0294598155,
0.0150169563,
-0.0234255362,
-0.0288247615,
-0.0833084881,
-0.0672608316,
-0.0291487537,
-0.0478133932,
0.0722068325,
-0.0156972203,
-0.0433767177,
-0.0270962566,
-0.0143168485,
0.0402931869,
-0.0053362767,
-0.0099325571,
0.0183410365,
0.0170015953,
0.0419023596,
0.0042497036,
0.0499113984,
-0.0115509648,
-0.0399170145,
-0.0262217708,
0.045373518,
0.0425218754,
-0.0560431778,
-0.0402847901,
0.031957373,
0.0019996769,
0.0362823419,
0.0685127228,
-0.001017611,
0.0161763597,
0.0907889009,
-0.0033992496,
-0.0043961126,
0.0188738871,
0.0169675238,
0.0073103844,
0.0766356513,
-0.0345971584,
0.0241808444,
0.0236915089,
-0.0315592661,
0.0081567075,
0.0167086311,
-0.0052551306,
-0.0291856974,
0.097864978,
-0.0351981372,
-0.0368979685,
0.0282588303,
-0.0022071982,
0.0322979018,
0.0331346169,
0.0389158688,
-0.0640394911,
-0.0135391615,
0.0152359838,
-0.0094198845,
-0.0445255265,
0.0170572046,
0.0519398004,
0.036544811,
0.0018335816,
0.0162228402,
-0.0045534042,
-0.0216551758,
-0.0136172948,
-0.0325027108,
0.0050738016,
-0.0083340826,
0.0385471806,
0.0164604001,
-0.0214633904,
0.0333296545,
-0.0482591502,
-0.0206334218,
-0.0159471296,
0.0255691651,
-0.0160929151,
-4.962910333e-33,
-0.0370464884,
-0.0909656957,
-0.0079974877,
0.0880824924,
-0.015515021,
0.0104055181,
0.0016012643,
0.0503522083,
-0.0248389225,
-0.029047396,
0.0677338764,
-0.0164576303,
0.0192594677,
0.0212089904,
0.0288279504,
0.0249602124,
0.0394909494,
-0.0412350111,
0.0190556068,
0.0209120903,
0.0426767133,
0.0067090746,
0.0478200838,
-0.1045974493,
-0.0123180589,
-0.0095811179,
-0.0440029763,
-0.031632524,
0.0141112488,
0.0506566949,
-0.0580283925,
0.0470567048,
-0.0038387449,
-0.0370112285,
0.0101755857,
0.0576848798,
-0.0222287439,
-0.0142620709,
-0.0376381837,
0.0923994631,
0.0017694696,
-0.024330616,
0.0248704143,
0.0056573157,
-0.032263495,
-0.0351491719,
0.0891361758,
-0.0285533126,
-0.0138186654,
-0.045194786,
-0.0520228669,
0.0332996808,
-0.0422490612,
-0.0710629895,
0.04242808,
0.0306557491,
0.0242571887,
-0.0769407973,
-0.0559415556,
0.0981991738,
0.0010749542,
0.0141689423,
0.0662281513,
0.0096472185,
-0.0379653275,
0.0289579704,
0.0151506392,
-0.0336305499,
0.0196407866,
-0.0317148119,
0.0292815063,
0.0514857732,
0.0152703756,
0.0092125228,
0.0149020646,
-0.0047229482,
0.0088057704,
0.057536386,
0.0342926569,
-0.0084966384,
-0.0175528526,
0.0228100438,
-0.0094472691,
0.0047151353,
-0.0038163669,
-0.0104271229,
0.0028146973,
-0.0114434455,
-0.003318388,
0.0008020629,
0.0089922883,
-0.0106560858,
0.0399140604,
-0.018814154,
-0.0061239316,
0.0094184801,
-0.0112589588,
0.0513641275,
-0.0326797217,
-0.0463945679,
-0.0025750543,
-0.0727608651,
0.0638341308,
-0.0114616565,
0.029095104,
-0.0171961449,
-0.0254544858,
0.0693784878,
0.0012276262,
-0.0343003571,
0.0255717058,
-0.0528175123,
0.022220483,
0.0266403798,
0.0282672215,
-0.0045226743,
-0.0473395623,
0.0588050187,
0.0013148111,
-0.0039273258,
-0.0249997489,
-0.0663861409,
0.0021118841,
-0.0133206891,
-0.0607491173,
0.0013430549,
-0.0414108187,
-0.0080935033,
0.0056646271,
-0.0229035895,
0.0107159931,
-0.003605712,
2.605e-7,
0.0288681779,
0.0332188755,
-0.0270501748,
-0.0758332312,
0.0361701846,
0.0272075795,
-0.0276245996,
-0.0000185206,
0.0132145472,
-0.0011121023,
0.0391036905,
-0.027644841,
0.0781762227,
0.0456005484,
-0.0407659374,
-0.0697704703,
-0.0100849234,
-0.0029238721,
-0.053604003,
0.0825706199,
0.0903905109,
0.0794393271,
0.0242799427,
-0.0145688374,
-0.0344788879,
-0.0302472375,
0.0157566313,
-0.0027241446,
-0.0006762584,
-0.041677285,
0.0357434079,
-0.0086304042,
-0.0253159441,
-0.0051873252,
-0.044157207,
-0.021421317,
0.0688841119,
0.0311205909,
-0.0303133074,
-0.0270574838,
-0.0049171201,
0.0488622971,
-0.0420221835,
0.0276241265,
0.0309353266,
-0.0054807509,
-0.0036906889,
0.0224598348,
-0.0341078117,
-0.0102493539,
-0.0077646179,
0.0022407779,
0.0075286049,
0.0096667279,
-0.0079400167,
-0.0191001184,
-0.0453633107,
-0.0567979924,
0.0110096689,
-0.0175544079,
-0.0679238662,
-0.0163304135,
0.0451058336,
-0.070609197,
0.0364492349,
0.0068263472,
-0.028974548,
1.799703777e-34,
-0.0143387737,
0.0308603868,
-0.0166615564,
0.0166773722,
-0.0476774499,
0.0207368545,
0.0053480756,
0.0337931067,
0.0107737863,
-0.0352765732,
-0.0400033072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15407v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15407v2 | A Comprehensive Analysis of the Effectiveness of Large Language Models as Automatic Dialogue Evaluators | 2023-12-24T04:50:57 | 2024-01-20T06:26:33 | Chen Zhang, Luis Fernando D'Haro, Yiming Chen, Malu Zhang, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic evaluation is an integral aspect of dialogue system research. The
traditional reference-based NLG metrics are generally found to be unsuitable
for dialogue assessment. Consequently, recent studies have suggested various
unique, reference-free neural metrics that better align with human evaluations.
Notably among them, large language models (LLMs), particularly the
instruction-tuned variants like ChatGPT, are shown to be promising substitutes
for human judges. Yet, existing works on utilizing LLMs for automatic dialogue
evaluation are limited in their scope in terms of the number of meta-evaluation
datasets, mode of evaluation, coverage of LLMs, etc. Hence, it remains
inconclusive how effective these LLMs are. To this end, we conduct a
comprehensive study on the application of LLMs for automatic dialogue
evaluation. Specifically, we analyze the multi-dimensional evaluation
capability of 30 recently emerged LLMs at both turn and dialogue levels, using
a comprehensive set of 12 meta-evaluation datasets. Additionally, we probe the
robustness of the LLMs in handling various adversarial perturbations at both
turn and dialogue levels. Finally, we explore how model-level and
dimension-level ensembles impact the evaluation performance. All resources are
available at https://github.com/e0397123/comp-analysis. | [
0.0514421947,
0.0464137457,
-0.0042672935,
0.0472543165,
-0.0195474438,
0.0115221143,
0.0115460632,
-0.0103760809,
-0.0021378989,
-0.0600173585,
-0.1088327169,
-0.054567568,
0.0402547754,
0.0330525823,
0.0335686691,
-0.0390562266,
0.0287385359,
-0.0246166345,
0.016765682,
0.0129643409,
-0.0081690755,
-0.0150138848,
-0.0217903778,
0.0715512261,
0.0333985165,
-0.0264172684,
-0.0182040296,
0.0092607774,
0.0205113385,
-0.0112339249,
-0.0030336978,
0.0610019341,
-0.0055645541,
0.0772102699,
0.0000017058,
0.0123514766,
0.0478671901,
-0.012565366,
-0.0398920663,
0.0460713729,
0.0204240959,
0.0246123523,
-0.022559287,
0.0158820506,
-0.0480085351,
-0.0430366881,
0.0239805225,
0.0300144386,
0.0811015218,
0.0932332724,
0.0158163775,
-0.03732365,
0.0045858622,
-0.0596959181,
-0.0270153247,
-0.0676909611,
-0.0036705728,
0.015064138,
-0.0259374436,
0.0166381821,
0.0003817844,
0.031109646,
0.0266657919,
-0.0625068024,
-0.0050826063,
0.0170595627,
-0.0587102175,
0.022372568,
-0.0400611162,
0.1073223501,
0.01351065,
0.0128335906,
-0.0106572686,
0.0018331477,
0.0142158382,
-0.0478033796,
-0.0410636514,
-0.0156565178,
0.031434264,
-0.0152368443,
-0.0490859076,
0.0207897536,
0.0190102085,
0.0176589377,
0.0154951634,
0.0478669219,
0.0130246086,
-0.0325680561,
-0.0064613302,
-0.008615463,
-0.0213281438,
-0.0376424156,
-0.0022035665,
0.011181633,
-0.0631619766,
0.0130409291,
-0.0272380784,
0.0143944286,
0.0142604206,
-0.0415393226,
0.0605928116,
0.0105291856,
-0.0004705188,
0.066925019,
0.0136528332,
0.0921489,
-0.0116071198,
0.0364347324,
-0.036180377,
0.0136216925,
-0.0614807718,
0.01061776,
-0.0233190004,
-0.0047807633,
-0.0561372899,
-0.0307401791,
-0.0412500016,
0.0148191517,
-0.008079119,
0.0160429757,
0.0282900464,
0.0296153072,
-0.0026855581,
0.0096803438,
-0.0246162135,
0.0220095664,
-0.0104659125,
-0.0076385415,
0.0155228507,
-0.0744225904,
-0.0370854139,
0.0470546037,
-0.0315694027,
-0.0259027537,
0.0074220006,
0.1025400162,
0.0153774507,
-0.0497558266,
0.0344537944,
0.0158733595,
-0.086857453,
-0.0849080533,
-0.017291123,
-0.0067191487,
0.0449578427,
-0.0368187465,
-0.0125712985,
-0.004916504,
-0.011180616,
0.0242643077,
-0.0039559919,
0.0335566401,
0.0508336946,
0.0153109934,
0.0066821137,
0.0062159835,
-0.0257470813,
0.0425746366,
0.0542544648,
0.0254434515,
0.0183473211,
-0.0185815021,
0.0244864468,
0.0446412861,
0.0193462577,
0.0028797965,
0.0073193549,
0.0285382234,
-0.0066389753,
0.036431767,
0.0009844927,
0.0814613476,
-0.0571549423,
-0.041296456,
0.0705313832,
0.0186778121,
0.0037145016,
0.0250981078,
0.0754987746,
0.0202617813,
0.0441172756,
0.0084131164,
-0.0537507385,
0.0205227956,
-0.0205872282,
-0.0267949365,
0.0681002811,
0.008059632,
-0.0425784811,
-0.0691932365,
0.0082577681,
0.0341101624,
0.007031031,
0.0011045565,
0.0150860613,
0.00310486,
-0.043218933,
0.008151439,
-0.008277067,
-0.032606706,
-0.0238876063,
-0.0563215949,
-0.0037627406,
0.0538446642,
0.0786962435,
-0.0027620886,
-0.0170130488,
-0.0268692411,
-0.0081882998,
0.0405324996,
0.0584361739,
-0.0253529139,
0.0604944378,
-0.0511320047,
0.0058825058,
-0.0425507352,
0.0056702672,
0.0562093556,
-0.0015524392,
-0.0312425364,
0.0007262285,
-0.0252037384,
-0.022761954,
0.0099789193,
0.008913178,
-0.0400012769,
0.0251097903,
-0.0001599023,
0.0490803719,
0.0194708779,
-0.0361030139,
0.0118696308,
0.0318523906,
-0.0098091466,
-0.0132385194,
0.0124098565,
-0.0650054142,
-0.0837330371,
0.0343813449,
-0.010390345,
-0.0220535155,
0.008254176,
-0.0579748787,
-0.0521106645,
0.027704617,
-0.0571603253,
0.0089391619,
-0.0420226529,
0.0368771963,
0.0034248335,
0.0377732553,
-0.0427855961,
0.024636453,
-0.0086146686,
0.0134904142,
0.0492240712,
0.0218550898,
0.0390582718,
-0.0465780236,
-0.0474893972,
0.0414773263,
-0.0087609813,
0.0290268548,
-0.0005727112,
0.0195800755,
-0.0487475917,
-0.0621113479,
-0.0982832238,
0.0058187763,
-0.0350478254,
0.0097913519,
0.0461558215,
-0.0274505019,
0.0021014654,
-0.0053635272,
-0.0342022479,
-0.0347122923,
0.047728911,
0.0115008578,
0.0204933602,
0.0310460627,
-0.0226211268,
-0.0362442061,
-0.0027967724,
0.0177941509,
0.0813659057,
-0.0204034727,
0.0329483598,
-0.0236196443,
0.000329847,
-0.0250315703,
0.0107352249,
-0.030057095,
-0.0885387883,
0.0198716726,
0.0345114768,
-0.0061646416,
0.0767623112,
0.0119600054,
0.0239580292,
0.0328667462,
-0.0253916197,
-0.0246446002,
0.0163914002,
-0.0021828858,
-0.0062223114,
-0.0272112489,
0.0046623247,
0.0067267767,
0.0270435158,
0.0265706293,
0.041143015,
-0.055022981,
0.0199778806,
0.0128610693,
-0.0672335029,
-0.0082438635,
-0.0071671093,
-0.0409069881,
0.0057549602,
-0.0356013142,
-0.0413264222,
0.0868707448,
-0.0662715435,
-0.0564552769,
-0.0376112349,
-0.0250484962,
-0.0420269892,
0.049144499,
-0.0139924455,
-0.0035848732,
-0.0366409086,
-0.0250787511,
-0.0288838055,
-0.0399487205,
0.0141302124,
-0.0373766199,
0.0284932964,
-0.0153655764,
-0.0097302264,
0.0059761712,
-0.0311385207,
-0.0522597991,
-0.0421438217,
-0.0138154002,
0.0071759783,
0.0243197475,
-0.0232656244,
-0.0414229967,
0.0270601735,
0.0004501808,
0.0120114777,
-0.0351854563,
0.0196618903,
-0.0065903394,
0.0447508171,
0.0400399566,
0.0141571602,
-0.0059392685,
-0.0048333551,
0.0862046629,
0.0261092577,
-0.0159829352,
0.0270476267,
-0.0468827225,
-0.0170093216,
-0.0026400129,
0.0192759465,
-0.0004009871,
0.0032143726,
0.0426389575,
-0.0296209995,
-0.0116081089,
0.1091558635,
0.0026066413,
-0.0392325148,
-0.0129627325,
0.0086694844,
0.0257850643,
0.0000887107,
0.000996024,
-0.0358354747,
-0.031122392,
0.0005285625,
0.0196945928,
-0.0002635385,
0.0020180838,
-0.0195897762,
-0.0973133221,
0.0170794483,
0.0015296409,
-0.0578056611,
-0.0422912389,
0.0028478934,
0.0131689264,
-0.0640059114,
0.061418131,
0.0034998746,
0.005014881,
-0.0000409195,
0.0188111737,
-0.0018124765,
-0.0473592915,
0.0443443917,
0.0061283177,
0.0730706677,
0.0936908796,
0.066196382,
0.0305208676,
-0.011079886,
0.0358099043,
-0.0275916643,
0.0009187735,
0.0109424349,
0.0885301307,
-0.0277297944,
-0.0006297275,
-0.0072839237,
-0.0008907415,
-0.0023668876,
-0.0127283866,
0.0070405789,
-0.0162847042,
-0.0445740223,
-0.0040414962,
0.0001369396,
0.0500023775,
0.0116443587,
0.094857417,
0.0605612062,
-0.047341302,
-0.0181569215,
-0.0053484999,
-0.0370046906,
-0.0574123114,
-0.0186221246,
0.023522459,
0.0484856255,
0.0075500165,
-0.0691775605,
-0.0492726043,
-0.0011229636,
-0.0018024524,
-0.0149300536,
-0.0091954209,
-0.0481291972,
0.0235119164,
0.0245678928,
0.0191636048,
-0.0274926387,
0.0181600675,
-0.0718481243,
0.0035208631,
0.0590292215,
-0.0237641186,
-0.0169452224,
0.0497869328,
-0.0829345584,
-0.0626050532,
-0.0080507686,
0.0611824431,
0.0168882236,
0.0254727881,
-0.035343647,
-0.0273244306,
0.0306444522,
0.0067042285,
-0.0148807792,
0.0228303708,
0.0655277371,
0.0303674173,
-0.0307623763,
0.0347571224,
-0.0191028137,
0.0271339007,
0.0403153785,
0.024464203,
-0.020722691,
-0.0829990655,
-0.0027251323,
-0.0024000462,
0.060651388,
0.0072006327,
-0.0207547862,
0.016104402,
0.0164758004,
-0.0139897661,
-0.0186833106,
-0.0701702386,
-0.0057974188,
0.010674011,
-0.0107484479,
-0.0238714013,
-0.0161138512,
-0.0330244042,
0.0205637347,
-0.0289196149,
0.015977677,
0.0273841992,
-0.0164035689,
-0.0155964298,
0.0062702517,
-0.0286359936,
0.0119031454,
-0.008739558,
0.0022368114,
0.0287493132,
0.0709244087,
0.0298931189,
-0.0346068479,
0.0271010492,
0.0832291767,
-0.1038805991,
0.0083364174,
-0.0260424782,
0.0331568792,
0.042884957,
0.0294220299,
0.053324271,
-0.0016134077,
0.0089632096,
-0.033896111,
0.0471261963,
0.0056129298,
-0.0200011861,
0.0442239717,
0.0191045068,
-0.0165849105,
0.0312687792,
0.0548567884,
0.0006494227,
0.0255792812,
0.0262286346,
0.0045845862,
-0.0487100407,
-0.0511158556,
-0.0425943993,
-0.0153881265,
0.0024899635,
0.0070148315,
-0.036514122,
-0.0470622703,
-0.0115163932,
0.0353107527,
0.0205331855,
0.0012347031,
0.0196523499,
0.0310484823,
-0.0179686956,
0.0152324392,
-0.0345392339,
0.0000965807,
-0.0091427565,
-0.0157791637,
-0.054996673,
-5.42794949e-33,
-0.0510400981,
-0.0276488643,
0.0059273033,
-0.0190935228,
-0.0485314652,
-0.0160089228,
-0.0501632467,
0.0055756522,
-0.0339710042,
0.004635002,
-0.015374247,
0.0275579616,
0.0092565073,
0.0273339767,
-0.0251553506,
-0.0565007292,
0.052280657,
-0.0067655258,
-0.0448200479,
0.0369545855,
0.0004158518,
-0.0028502156,
0.0281277485,
-0.0634282306,
0.0246686209,
0.0053795064,
-0.0406477265,
0.0066674347,
-0.0290277284,
0.0744321123,
-0.0118853273,
0.0324323662,
0.0142367315,
-0.0251821894,
-0.0109450668,
0.0057427431,
-0.0290315915,
0.0084934253,
0.0292787589,
0.0109385857,
0.0055383444,
-0.0079527954,
-0.0022695311,
-0.0280174632,
-0.0201037154,
-0.0022367067,
-0.0008024284,
-0.0263913237,
-0.0143516818,
0.0105738239,
-0.0058678263,
0.0336824693,
-0.0331125855,
-0.0690780133,
-0.0036703623,
0.0518796854,
0.0042081601,
0.0015246776,
-0.0222516228,
0.0205841884,
-0.0014730939,
0.0208369661,
0.0397491641,
0.0342428237,
0.0063690231,
0.0647680312,
0.0179152358,
0.0203185845,
-0.0052657416,
-0.0614416786,
-0.0023372851,
0.0236208215,
0.0622004457,
0.0576164573,
-0.0089236228,
0.0144189904,
-0.0364018381,
0.0125476466,
0.018115025,
0.0383025445,
0.0135056004,
0.0039987704,
-0.0129053723,
-0.0011015452,
-0.0447654314,
-0.0519365147,
-0.0328793861,
-0.0307339933,
0.0421316288,
-0.0048686862,
-0.0119687635,
-0.0426765569,
0.0387961045,
-0.0479675755,
0.0129278544,
0.0661887005,
-0.0281666592,
0.0125661651,
-0.0061463988,
0.0084788008,
-0.0141393831,
-0.0099517042,
0.060709931,
0.0421342961,
0.0172118377,
-0.0240894854,
0.0308958609,
0.0270571597,
-0.028833665,
0.0101375217,
-0.0162100252,
0.0423142016,
-0.040733505,
0.0368397161,
0.0090668369,
-0.0124218892,
-0.0432139337,
0.0532492734,
-0.0390159525,
0.0140498336,
-0.0183977503,
-0.0291989371,
0.0512366891,
0.0067749401,
-0.0576717891,
0.0238876361,
0.0084998766,
-0.0522305965,
0.0171799213,
-0.0165129043,
-0.0070664864,
-0.0135715753,
2.353e-7,
-0.0114280926,
0.0365255252,
0.0260498207,
0.0072251661,
0.0338691771,
0.0347514562,
-0.0283905305,
-0.0069967289,
0.0193778891,
0.0035471395,
0.0270526316,
0.0185129717,
0.0985612273,
-0.0104821958,
-0.0785994604,
-0.0030823201,
-0.1144666672,
-0.0330696069,
0.0029379032,
-0.0170858558,
0.0298501384,
0.1070966348,
0.0067469371,
0.0374560617,
-0.0203733686,
-0.0431998782,
0.0487181172,
-0.0253991503,
-0.0228554178,
0.0219670199,
0.0607375801,
-0.0067576859,
-0.0013723079,
0.0096070943,
0.0069899336,
0.0407039486,
0.0308112595,
0.0925424248,
0.0102195293,
-0.0497602895,
-0.0178067386,
-0.0086595835,
0.0116720982,
-0.0332692862,
0.0536676683,
-0.043450322,
-0.0242105145,
-0.0418320484,
-0.0216348432,
-0.011399461,
0.0766664296,
-0.0300863534,
-0.007541466,
0.0237340517,
0.0171115603,
-0.03265284,
0.0079251565,
-0.0820999593,
-0.0262459498,
-0.0147150364,
-0.0531865172,
-0.0561862476,
-0.0097779781,
-0.0258681607,
0.0180404764,
-0.0496691838,
-0.0075693899,
1.729843826e-34,
0.0543020479,
-0.0244523436,
0.0304243248,
-0.0112199271,
0.0434533432,
0.0135253752,
0.0235955101,
-0.041667223,
0.035779871,
-0.0956526026,
-0.0014442938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15398v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15398v1 | Fairness-Aware Structured Pruning in Transformers | 2023-12-24T03:57:52 | 2023-12-24T03:57:52 | Abdelrahman Zayed, Goncalo Mordido, Samira Shabanian, Ioana Baldini, Sarath Chandar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | The increasing size of large language models (LLMs) has introduced challenges
in their training and inference. Removing model components is perceived as a
solution to tackle the large model sizes, however, existing pruning methods
solely focus on performance, without considering an essential aspect for the
responsible use of LLMs: model fairness. It is crucial to address the fairness
of LLMs towards diverse groups, such as women, Black people, LGBTQ+, Jewish
communities, among others, as they are being deployed and available to a wide
audience. In this work, first, we investigate how attention heads impact
fairness and performance in pre-trained transformer-based language models. We
then propose a novel method to prune the attention heads that negatively impact
fairness while retaining the heads critical for performance, i.e. language
modeling capabilities. Our approach is practical in terms of time and
resources, as it does not require fine-tuning the final pruned, and fairer,
model. Our findings demonstrate a reduction in gender bias by 19%, 19.5%,
39.5%, 34.7%, 23%, and 8% for DistilGPT-2, GPT-2, GPT-Neo of two different
sizes, GPT-J, and Llama 2 models, respectively, in comparison to the biased
model, with only a slight decrease in performance. | [
0.0257250462,
0.082629092,
-0.0241471324,
0.0366830081,
0.005224728,
0.0273243133,
0.0229109321,
-0.0159453489,
-0.047004547,
-0.0438935906,
-0.0402472019,
-0.0504728034,
0.0141500141,
-0.0378689952,
0.0066203075,
-0.0500039868,
0.0196087901,
0.0115793813,
0.0098179448,
-0.0302635171,
0.017264897,
0.03955625,
0.036022,
0.0774117783,
0.0064673983,
-0.0077247429,
0.0358271599,
0.0105430344,
0.0096121551,
0.0369349271,
0.039160572,
0.079288058,
-0.0274570994,
0.0529358201,
0.000002035,
-0.0367275402,
-0.0016973064,
0.0132226124,
-0.0240186416,
0.040193174,
0.030260168,
-0.0283940509,
-0.0328689441,
0.0465088338,
-0.003675774,
-0.0051018763,
0.0413729809,
0.0415234827,
0.0442842841,
0.0340754278,
-0.0119801294,
-0.0125296153,
-0.0364817865,
-0.052747149,
-0.0235498995,
-0.0026506982,
0.022111807,
-0.0591182224,
-0.053662464,
-0.0321944319,
-0.0386543833,
0.0322192535,
0.0456198044,
0.0288622193,
-0.0111301215,
0.0304312259,
-0.0672995895,
-0.0424845032,
-0.0034454099,
0.0437542908,
-0.0376791619,
-0.0073353397,
0.0189837608,
-0.0194314476,
0.0008431214,
-0.0217903275,
-0.037032716,
0.0470069014,
-0.0031563852,
0.016776938,
-0.0192805827,
-0.0184118412,
0.0273971893,
0.0033872908,
-0.0337182917,
0.0836160481,
0.033172138,
-0.0321762264,
-0.0072635091,
0.0288877282,
-0.0105484417,
-0.0447403714,
0.0134044848,
-0.0249341801,
0.0190303214,
0.0060812235,
-0.0167743769,
-0.0261403769,
0.0212034341,
-0.0151110198,
0.0265604705,
0.0742063075,
-0.0052667628,
0.0022730927,
0.022571452,
0.0439998507,
0.0051288805,
0.0369819067,
-0.0263791606,
-0.0143542569,
0.0461140312,
-0.0093656471,
-0.0253787134,
-0.0290157031,
-0.0504678525,
0.0600492544,
-0.0267334748,
-0.0096094385,
-0.0167523026,
-0.0472157933,
0.0740280896,
-0.0018719396,
-0.0669788346,
0.006184041,
0.0171550419,
0.0412177444,
-0.0382453538,
-0.0048873713,
-0.0315501317,
-0.1048250347,
-0.0192879532,
0.0180758629,
-0.0169472154,
-0.0537683368,
-0.0140079157,
0.0397169143,
0.0074055018,
-0.0632879958,
-0.0163458828,
0.0119348979,
-0.022122493,
-0.0757757053,
0.0052689575,
-0.0479296558,
0.0051379371,
0.0202288609,
0.0105533283,
-0.0309370738,
-0.0333527997,
0.0162219591,
-0.0249445532,
0.0251273476,
0.0577724911,
0.0195420366,
0.0475616753,
0.0196097977,
-0.0043403739,
0.099872902,
0.039089635,
-0.0024121637,
0.0188990831,
-0.0446313061,
-0.0226641353,
0.0457090586,
0.0410696156,
0.0290761981,
-0.0155407451,
-0.0122862095,
-0.0198367797,
-0.0039292863,
0.0802207217,
0.0526143536,
-0.0043161609,
-0.0634327009,
0.057923086,
0.0522840843,
0.0425517559,
0.0569347963,
0.0305803865,
0.012653294,
-0.019092707,
0.0273888633,
-0.1028724313,
0.0112198517,
0.0011448374,
-0.0175567176,
-0.0119146025,
0.0657961518,
-0.0392717272,
-0.0173226371,
-0.0071862014,
0.002998865,
0.0167041793,
0.0151850535,
0.0290167686,
0.0153945647,
-0.025296675,
0.1124434546,
0.0512620695,
-0.0554393083,
0.0133870123,
-0.0768272206,
-0.024376899,
-0.0039295587,
0.0043683625,
-0.0110599305,
-0.0134030804,
0.0027287283,
-0.0137005793,
0.0457714982,
0.0364237837,
0.037346255,
0.0218246691,
-0.0602543838,
-0.0156048769,
0.0345315337,
0.0309322458,
0.0020731031,
0.0505263656,
0.0301542617,
0.0356631987,
-0.0311775468,
-0.0222285744,
0.0386404544,
-0.0276373364,
-0.0112614995,
0.0047657201,
-0.00531425,
0.0131689049,
-0.0105487751,
-0.029612625,
-0.0197457559,
-0.0001090395,
-0.0124132382,
0.0054714307,
0.0112546645,
-0.0683413818,
0.0110317525,
0.0308648348,
-0.0487307534,
-0.0113532646,
0.1096242592,
-0.0154994605,
0.002863083,
0.051479131,
-0.0230415557,
0.0195212662,
-0.0296709053,
0.0296492614,
-0.0128371967,
0.0571866669,
-0.0251365863,
0.0201344695,
-0.0406375714,
-0.0119492821,
0.0332248062,
-0.0770976841,
-0.0049721524,
-0.048379302,
-0.050461065,
0.0187247004,
-0.0270288028,
0.0001923285,
0.0088651525,
0.0044530355,
-0.005879323,
-0.0110141952,
-0.054842189,
0.0078181876,
-0.0458315425,
0.0033666538,
-0.0139941834,
0.0542861335,
-0.0293733906,
-0.0146408333,
0.0126804374,
-0.043633204,
0.0307947546,
0.0133601455,
-0.0172261838,
-0.0392809175,
-0.0165601317,
-0.0298060197,
-0.07089407,
-0.0058735325,
0.0525865331,
0.0009487702,
-0.0079938658,
-0.0402549617,
0.0092500271,
-0.0150403352,
0.0301624537,
-0.0148620466,
-0.0613361932,
0.0050655641,
0.0358487926,
0.0517590642,
0.0803275928,
0.031995371,
0.0297395475,
0.0603456646,
0.0074528954,
-0.0353223719,
0.0154052181,
-0.009284541,
-0.0038136106,
-0.0122542614,
-0.0583795197,
-0.0150328539,
0.0952551365,
0.0301966406,
-0.0255451202,
-0.0891905278,
-0.0128423767,
-0.0594876446,
-0.0471925773,
0.0221332479,
-0.0108450865,
-0.0431211889,
0.0090849232,
-0.0506954528,
-0.0568773933,
0.0473723412,
-0.0167317223,
-0.0279494617,
-0.036399249,
0.0088009378,
-0.0452010483,
0.017864896,
0.0006539346,
0.0260614641,
-0.0105395056,
-0.0263490677,
-0.0710707903,
-0.0090616504,
0.0252391417,
-0.0346426144,
0.075080961,
-0.0044004079,
0.0008694475,
-0.0323763192,
-0.0469425134,
-0.05184545,
-0.0265326928,
-0.0234455206,
0.0118568353,
0.0428226627,
-0.0355489478,
-0.0433630347,
0.0203285068,
0.0041495725,
0.0612745322,
0.0054293568,
0.0212007519,
-0.0003061683,
-0.0409955196,
0.032412529,
0.0203422047,
0.0567626767,
-0.049759943,
0.0041671181,
0.0540644713,
0.0223927144,
0.0289416574,
0.0131078372,
-0.0014954036,
0.0564113669,
-0.0379780009,
-0.0199620798,
0.0008277805,
0.0754385889,
-0.039629668,
0.0225609113,
0.0968595445,
-0.0001600237,
-0.0734820813,
0.0250263624,
-0.0127956979,
0.0515795611,
0.0137073742,
0.018042732,
-0.0914931819,
-0.0131770456,
0.0353648625,
0.0338424332,
-0.004276691,
-0.0219641477,
-0.0032540301,
-0.097816579,
0.022660356,
-0.0024905843,
-0.0459921621,
-0.0212668646,
-0.0059778066,
0.0221450124,
-0.0392510183,
0.0521737747,
0.0083511071,
-0.0200046729,
-0.0061562546,
0.0151759563,
-0.0342667811,
-0.0238284357,
0.0227779746,
-0.0459937826,
0.0186985042,
0.0409196392,
0.0026845345,
0.0013885206,
-0.0451873019,
0.0270312689,
-0.0370210558,
-0.0151123758,
-0.0140577843,
0.0258222017,
-0.0160860326,
-0.0229086615,
-0.0350401476,
0.017583441,
0.0006223776,
0.0152469017,
-0.0224988852,
0.0487496331,
0.0143520115,
-0.054552976,
-0.0469133779,
0.0138776824,
-0.0250834543,
0.0946385637,
0.0493578203,
-0.0274734199,
-0.0284128804,
-0.0430895984,
0.0183120966,
-0.0124150664,
-0.0649655163,
0.041858159,
0.0432622135,
-0.0825637504,
-0.0046338704,
-0.0221506562,
0.0042392882,
-0.0036007853,
-0.0030068406,
-0.0642127022,
-0.0014071667,
0.0144091332,
-0.0503657162,
0.0481908806,
-0.0264825616,
0.0277472492,
-0.045098789,
0.0048771119,
-0.0267903898,
-0.0136223184,
-0.0251315534,
0.0099259419,
-0.0972934216,
-0.0463925824,
0.0629282147,
0.0526817888,
0.0281325281,
0.0320429429,
0.0040173195,
-0.0647276863,
-0.021756649,
0.0270555541,
-0.026887726,
0.0674968958,
0.0498917326,
-0.0595423393,
0.0008580169,
0.051899787,
-0.0278377254,
0.0562832206,
0.0260206796,
0.0304217394,
0.0001875916,
-0.0371001251,
-0.0156801958,
0.0100698601,
0.0238165986,
-0.0198193062,
-0.0070624696,
-0.0424634963,
0.0199137013,
-0.0019574224,
0.0087920362,
-0.0401921086,
-0.0104113901,
0.0010642967,
0.0494384579,
-0.0216415916,
0.0068385117,
-0.0169650521,
-0.002760764,
-0.0489454158,
0.0649927408,
-0.0183420684,
0.0063797226,
0.0198328737,
0.0129052997,
-0.0104728201,
-0.0045729363,
0.0041278922,
0.0248245429,
0.0104739293,
0.0266778432,
0.0237817764,
0.0206518583,
-0.0450012237,
0.0173352566,
-0.0310510565,
-0.0353426971,
-0.0159374066,
0.0031193614,
0.0169572141,
-0.0150110051,
0.0505555645,
0.0196882673,
-0.0042039077,
-0.0153530259,
0.0070545594,
0.015641151,
0.0174600631,
0.031928923,
0.0026894778,
0.015463572,
-0.0366838053,
0.0506135486,
0.0176069234,
0.0490709133,
-0.036768008,
-0.0052759303,
-0.0146960961,
-0.0616888851,
-0.0234828331,
-0.0263915174,
-0.0136791468,
-0.0116881318,
-0.0977564752,
-0.0742855892,
-0.0148044145,
-0.0149508137,
0.0239752326,
-0.0317700841,
0.0247632749,
0.0336994641,
-0.0153739462,
-0.0618824773,
0.0034103396,
-0.0404458679,
0.0019591204,
-0.0219292063,
0.02022787,
-6.748048748e-33,
-0.0162373614,
-0.0045702094,
-0.0052440139,
-0.026551323,
-0.0544765554,
0.0155536337,
-0.0211041793,
-0.0153767504,
-0.0210359246,
-0.0104131643,
-0.0319574401,
0.039834898,
0.012711728,
0.0187797509,
-0.0146560511,
-0.0014724873,
0.0703735948,
0.0156037314,
-0.0441578105,
0.0157679077,
-0.0383307002,
0.0371859483,
0.0835399777,
0.0120540354,
-0.0009843763,
-0.008591542,
0.012553527,
0.0054463246,
-0.0374932811,
0.0492036454,
-0.0204536375,
0.0672585666,
0.0372094177,
-0.062293414,
0.0042830077,
0.0453188717,
-0.0761129484,
-0.0167789217,
0.0204197839,
0.0366982743,
0.0034036355,
-0.0094292862,
0.0517812259,
0.0374711156,
-0.0346162058,
-0.0644107237,
0.0467141382,
0.0123992683,
0.0135074779,
0.0369050987,
-0.0309312139,
0.0456660055,
-0.0277917888,
0.0013008352,
0.009660325,
0.0259743873,
0.0029996892,
0.0463293232,
-0.0485283099,
-0.0039070826,
0.0269859992,
0.0335107371,
0.0498859286,
0.0363486186,
0.0038419235,
0.031071756,
0.033531826,
0.0258765258,
-0.0290712826,
-0.0862022266,
0.0755718723,
-0.0264641512,
0.0199829079,
0.0273547154,
0.0346611328,
-0.0154914707,
-0.0486659631,
-0.014832437,
0.0053510084,
0.0563482344,
0.0199578945,
0.0050496175,
-0.0589364544,
-0.0316074491,
-0.0088052452,
-0.0749566332,
-0.0167808551,
-0.0150767248,
0.025418723,
0.0175946839,
-0.0609103553,
0.0316576026,
0.0402756818,
-0.0358941779,
-0.0043203421,
0.0275034383,
-0.0123180123,
-0.0236840937,
0.0146606211,
0.0212885607,
-0.0624116808,
0.0280233026,
0.009306917,
0.0070483303,
0.0089390818,
0.005387716,
-0.0125561338,
0.0390909687,
-0.0620285086,
0.0155101391,
-0.0258436482,
0.0525326729,
-0.0001430027,
0.0628012195,
0.0182371959,
0.0343516916,
0.0063927276,
0.0154983252,
0.0371381752,
-0.0180145409,
-0.0649531782,
0.0469836965,
0.0367017463,
0.0443078913,
-0.041037038,
-0.0251464266,
0.0123210335,
0.0302274823,
0.0609916188,
-0.0587153137,
-0.0339269303,
-0.0115850428,
2.609e-7,
0.0362765677,
-0.0089789843,
0.0173086561,
0.0118013099,
0.0078148395,
0.0133793075,
0.0317700841,
0.0330050625,
0.0574110039,
0.0507699661,
-0.0248689353,
0.0524234548,
0.049929332,
0.0112601649,
-0.0854342207,
-0.0092309341,
-0.1068608314,
0.0207747035,
-0.0202521645,
-0.0089218952,
-0.0387012474,
0.1081501395,
0.0335158706,
-0.0194005314,
-0.0220616907,
0.0249950178,
0.0075401468,
-0.0279306564,
0.0338531584,
0.0187360849,
0.0293743853,
-0.0134668155,
0.011979918,
0.0001369505,
0.0103867119,
0.027664816,
-0.0108414972,
0.0599478483,
-0.0158233084,
0.0144279199,
0.0084645236,
0.0232025273,
-0.0295778122,
-0.0752664357,
0.0517017283,
-0.0169138201,
-0.0259262323,
-0.0367085822,
-0.0171544906,
-0.0086696912,
0.0141998781,
-0.0066898307,
-0.030776808,
0.0291398801,
0.0226774774,
-0.0259220358,
-0.0086896922,
-0.0887677222,
-0.0233220086,
-0.0345746092,
-0.0440074764,
-0.0538419187,
-0.0202294867,
-0.0363913961,
0.0022912086,
0.0054478007,
0.0121816257,
2.384071291e-34,
0.0141178193,
0.0144677665,
0.0236980021,
0.0208908133,
0.0033809524,
-0.0221633241,
0.0280442722,
-0.0157989897,
0.0153429946,
-0.0237847902,
-0.0369130783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15395v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15395v1 | Prompt Valuation Based on Shapley Values | 2023-12-24T03:37:11 | 2023-12-24T03:37:11 | Hanxi Liu, Xiaokai Mao, Haocheng Xia, Jian Lou, Jinfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) excel on new tasks without additional training,
simply by providing natural language prompts that demonstrate how the task
should be performed. Prompt ensemble methods comprehensively harness the
knowledge of LLMs while mitigating individual biases and errors and further
enhancing performance. However, more prompts do not necessarily lead to better
results, and not all prompts are beneficial. A small number of high-quality
prompts often outperform many low-quality prompts. Currently, there is a lack
of a suitable method for evaluating the impact of prompts on the results. In
this paper, we utilize the Shapley value to fairly quantify the contributions
of prompts, helping to identify beneficial or detrimental prompts, and
potentially guiding prompt valuation in data markets. Through extensive
experiments employing various ensemble methods and utility functions on diverse
tasks, we validate the effectiveness of using the Shapley value method for
prompts as it effectively distinguishes and quantifies the contributions of
each prompt. | [
0.026471246,
0.0770094469,
0.0045289868,
-0.0062521519,
-0.0679889768,
0.0034538074,
0.0707565397,
-0.0319524892,
-0.0121947275,
-0.0301719103,
-0.0014858636,
-0.0559632741,
0.0144399973,
0.0687962323,
-0.0155810928,
-0.06707827,
0.0400171354,
-0.0306826644,
0.0548836701,
-0.0094906921,
-0.0045912424,
-0.0325092375,
-0.0130778132,
0.0692570135,
0.0313918851,
-0.0241096858,
-0.0106259678,
-0.0198103637,
0.0022364454,
-0.0441009402,
-0.0280279927,
0.0822750404,
-0.0268777087,
0.0080027878,
0.0000020287,
-0.095396392,
-0.0434859954,
0.0271390472,
-0.0727003068,
0.0244651083,
0.0650415421,
0.0457759537,
0.0149667468,
0.0096868966,
-0.0322384723,
0.025604168,
0.0583271198,
0.033474654,
0.0123809427,
0.0410719663,
-0.0001666056,
0.0285465531,
-0.0196078643,
-0.0301321764,
0.0324275382,
-0.078117691,
0.0155097432,
-0.0241873283,
-0.0046138368,
0.0224722996,
0.0106539326,
0.0512564667,
0.0032383993,
-0.0233282484,
0.0331720673,
0.0293290876,
-0.0216279291,
0.0163275637,
-0.0792087466,
0.0390990898,
0.0383403376,
0.0550990961,
-0.0035427343,
-0.0554566719,
0.0410401598,
0.0079617603,
-0.0644927397,
0.0324539393,
0.0219526663,
0.0117062116,
-0.0122891488,
0.0556585267,
0.0277953111,
0.0314170755,
-0.009646317,
0.0878871605,
-0.0312419031,
-0.0299328733,
0.052411776,
0.002981947,
-0.0494111925,
-0.0461103134,
-0.0075474838,
0.0187742021,
-0.0628135055,
0.0063459226,
0.0231418367,
-0.0102672847,
0.015029042,
-0.0218008831,
0.051212851,
0.0063464306,
-0.0112700528,
0.064078629,
-0.0250596795,
0.0212442428,
0.0267607737,
-0.0600619465,
0.0083420528,
0.0540385395,
-0.0252738725,
-0.0217006225,
-0.0224940889,
0.0479047298,
-0.0233111549,
-0.0111723756,
-0.029964881,
0.0080139386,
-0.0245740041,
0.0439586565,
0.030416837,
0.0172133781,
-0.0199787784,
-0.0076917596,
-0.066355288,
-0.0193945877,
-0.0400853641,
0.0334048606,
0.0219622962,
-0.0769975558,
0.0145412926,
0.0115760975,
0.0021597545,
-0.0251901038,
0.022003185,
0.0564092025,
0.0323636271,
-0.0314277634,
0.001711336,
-0.0500940271,
-0.0353957079,
-0.026613092,
-0.0539121516,
-0.0518588088,
-0.012140763,
0.0149790933,
0.0061555011,
0.0028213996,
-0.0145062339,
-0.002758519,
-0.0351998918,
0.0789667666,
0.0125667779,
0.0036658656,
-0.0448560119,
-0.033015348,
-0.0550973415,
0.0682888478,
0.0107016694,
0.0458088294,
0.0423554219,
0.0048885997,
-0.0127710998,
0.0124362381,
-0.0235412754,
0.0000477583,
-0.0351404436,
0.0404925682,
0.0285432935,
-0.0059131361,
-0.0022038673,
0.0262375902,
-0.0022945548,
0.0186390653,
0.0714231208,
0.0584176891,
0.0119475955,
-0.0497710519,
0.0156994388,
0.0390833877,
-0.0072801127,
-0.0327919126,
-0.0095783705,
0.0103751542,
-0.0361998267,
0.0061649042,
0.030663697,
0.0020993834,
-0.0211916752,
-0.0542210527,
0.0145045649,
0.0009560568,
-0.0071576331,
0.0459020473,
0.0159158669,
-0.050173156,
-0.0236254409,
0.0038254261,
-0.0080699194,
-0.0357992053,
-0.0076826154,
-0.0396675542,
0.0431035832,
0.0820662901,
0.0271307472,
-0.0316817313,
0.0381301865,
-0.0318052694,
-0.0315202996,
0.0244792029,
0.0568654314,
-0.0269660093,
-0.0082827546,
-0.0252569541,
-0.0609114319,
-0.0043010558,
0.0214030147,
0.018343119,
-0.0151716582,
-0.015668489,
-0.0198255312,
-0.0007629687,
-0.055322051,
0.0176455844,
0.007238654,
-0.0380535424,
0.0054163374,
0.0076415539,
0.0319136791,
0.0293085519,
-0.0110217454,
0.02768852,
0.000134559,
0.0133260777,
-0.0335223489,
-0.0018873669,
-0.0495614335,
0.0107689053,
0.0008720297,
0.0118088517,
-0.0027280457,
-0.0292605609,
-0.0288128443,
-0.0160510689,
-0.0366197713,
-0.0179647617,
-0.0209715702,
-0.0480175056,
0.0252905469,
-0.0137464944,
-0.0090749608,
-0.048715122,
0.0531147234,
-0.0183677021,
0.0397942141,
0.0088531766,
-0.0115062268,
0.0405712016,
-0.0718884841,
-0.0185920801,
0.0227521602,
-0.0134412777,
0.0511219576,
0.0431050807,
-0.0182576105,
-0.0076992386,
-0.0158593208,
-0.0580347106,
-0.0091850236,
-0.0092421956,
0.0119669465,
0.0228014328,
0.0005756013,
-0.0033445621,
-0.0139781861,
-0.0491883233,
-0.0399076901,
0.0272808187,
0.0375859104,
0.0270659383,
0.0208464433,
-0.0067835716,
-0.0113659333,
-0.0092090052,
0.0006553686,
0.0473940931,
0.0647319555,
0.0007661686,
-0.0472998247,
0.0073336163,
0.011547571,
-0.0239337347,
-0.0115426769,
0.0327784829,
0.0040223226,
-0.000257429,
0.0304421373,
0.0335613079,
0.021810852,
0.0029699828,
0.0290100779,
-0.0059594153,
-0.0876630768,
-0.026620999,
-0.0228819959,
0.0221472159,
-0.0304714665,
-0.0275521409,
0.0554341674,
0.0330527686,
-0.0021806459,
-0.0115937106,
-0.0613874272,
0.0497761704,
0.0005381948,
-0.0405763984,
-0.0747162402,
0.0124478703,
0.0020581193,
0.0791975856,
0.0132092899,
-0.0687556267,
0.0545066893,
-0.0296475831,
0.0153588243,
-0.0224646311,
-0.0077442992,
-0.0452144928,
0.0314229131,
-0.0473264009,
0.0100464206,
0.0197954196,
-0.0433701463,
-0.0399577431,
-0.0005112594,
0.0493223667,
-0.0456950404,
0.0343759581,
-0.0292375386,
0.0380623378,
0.0035375296,
-0.0152796414,
-0.0361114442,
-0.0911877677,
-0.018948311,
0.0377303436,
0.0490796641,
-0.0150282802,
-0.0064202896,
0.0194591004,
0.0368906707,
0.0120190019,
-0.0103243887,
-0.0145732444,
-0.0021339811,
-0.0359390415,
0.0274554957,
0.0450136736,
0.0336944573,
-0.0409452617,
0.0552785806,
-0.0066658235,
0.0375688747,
0.0435181111,
-0.0323240981,
0.0320040658,
0.0362791233,
-0.0620946549,
0.0233268701,
0.0645684451,
0.0041609029,
-0.0250189081,
0.0271223821,
0.0933705866,
0.0191812404,
-0.0519463979,
0.0019795436,
-0.0178038832,
0.0195703506,
0.0069596269,
0.0015955936,
-0.0960383341,
0.0067947819,
-0.0182633568,
0.0483024716,
-0.0257705171,
-0.0749868006,
-0.0107873091,
-0.1370945722,
0.053242147,
-0.0228455476,
0.0058691027,
0.0096002407,
-0.0512811951,
0.0022654189,
-0.0484538749,
0.0273383334,
0.0192586984,
-0.0322386995,
0.0204252936,
0.0139547223,
-0.0203088094,
-0.0609297119,
0.0299148895,
-0.0565932766,
0.0449472256,
0.1121392995,
-0.0022202837,
-0.0322113782,
-0.0162424482,
-0.0558653176,
0.0218130872,
-0.0165160764,
0.0155593669,
0.0754982829,
0.0002414014,
0.0058642803,
-0.0078070248,
0.0071507078,
0.0031666604,
0.012851635,
0.0248754229,
0.033086244,
-0.0159292892,
-0.0207246915,
0.0335666016,
-0.0041391333,
0.031525366,
0.0911442861,
0.0285862107,
-0.0706052929,
-0.0403341316,
-0.0348059833,
-0.0552102327,
-0.0414603204,
-0.0083529577,
0.0321265236,
-0.0032720387,
-0.0119135603,
-0.0681114197,
-0.0471180342,
0.0218826719,
0.0570645072,
-0.0038829222,
0.0339820422,
-0.0072187469,
0.0213396307,
-0.0161704868,
0.0408502743,
-0.0151419379,
0.0329405516,
-0.0733308643,
0.034842927,
-0.0015762788,
-0.0447830893,
-0.0399530344,
-0.0315264091,
-0.0233300142,
-0.0578647219,
0.013156089,
0.0402438417,
0.038928736,
-0.020405218,
-0.0243565757,
-0.0539768711,
0.0413753167,
0.0806488991,
0.0125770597,
-0.0264470931,
0.0287719071,
0.0421782248,
-0.0134027917,
0.019764889,
-0.0258906037,
0.0290971361,
-0.0102147777,
0.0626894161,
0.0220585,
-0.0217778124,
0.0134939868,
0.0383042693,
0.0327906422,
-0.0294332989,
-0.0136003755,
-0.0201976709,
-0.0093299132,
0.0129983742,
-0.0337645374,
-0.0305192489,
0.0142692616,
0.0438858569,
-0.0152284876,
0.0071814512,
0.0561053343,
-0.000897515,
0.0125691229,
-0.0621596724,
0.0136134811,
0.0065654083,
0.0027582748,
0.052142255,
-0.0185532495,
-0.0102075813,
0.0035038283,
0.0234377813,
0.0181319397,
0.0494793318,
0.0515620708,
0.0072910679,
0.0013717371,
0.0205123685,
0.0386400037,
-0.0499275886,
-0.1009813324,
0.0049923509,
0.0110831875,
-0.0271559022,
0.0087821642,
-0.0048348019,
-0.0486635752,
0.00409739,
-0.0201366525,
0.0102569489,
0.0352146812,
-0.0356361344,
0.0443132482,
0.0234718267,
-0.0589481331,
-0.0062569655,
0.0558710098,
-0.0380322635,
0.0278644487,
-0.0763235167,
-0.0254386086,
-0.0518882126,
-0.0254207347,
0.0035544077,
-0.0119132278,
-0.048438631,
0.0131355086,
-0.0768984482,
-0.0173235927,
-0.0352436379,
0.0100828856,
0.0279368926,
-0.0211843383,
-0.0064553129,
0.0496686287,
-0.0243358295,
0.0331174508,
-0.0336581096,
-0.000581196,
-0.0520118177,
0.0034984874,
-0.0762964264,
-6.176074503e-33,
0.0033257362,
-0.0557547957,
0.0070818067,
-0.0089461962,
0.0257083066,
0.0050081504,
-0.010550905,
0.0244427193,
0.0006315974,
-0.0103225326,
-0.0041256985,
-0.0171147119,
0.0245676395,
0.0193075836,
0.0447022356,
-0.0315182246,
0.0254191365,
-0.0042859614,
-0.0776859522,
-0.0031962043,
0.0206111651,
-0.0038649419,
0.0431506634,
-0.0060466076,
0.0954510421,
0.0106480159,
-0.0504639484,
0.0192986503,
0.0034923088,
0.040739961,
0.0001189894,
0.0172942653,
0.0215892699,
-0.0635920018,
-0.0350235403,
0.0364399403,
-0.0012353961,
-0.0032544846,
0.0227510035,
-0.010278591,
0.0000649453,
-0.0079495916,
0.0011585648,
0.0086082779,
-0.0539033115,
0.0262897778,
0.0269317124,
-0.035768602,
-0.0231327768,
-0.0057010017,
-0.009552815,
0.0291233938,
-0.0069071627,
0.0338575207,
0.0472438224,
0.0816491172,
-0.0134604489,
0.0469958074,
-0.0155292964,
0.0346122459,
0.0422016606,
0.0239277687,
0.0411576554,
0.0246006865,
0.0227576755,
0.0526833981,
0.0041135685,
0.0105026402,
0.0012816272,
-0.0382380933,
0.0194709655,
0.0465007238,
0.0374219753,
0.0304627027,
0.0458724014,
0.0393789262,
-0.0397303626,
0.0399990492,
0.0642521307,
-0.0298751574,
0.058684919,
-0.0026855734,
-0.0471303575,
-0.0466650575,
-0.0539230928,
-0.0456200317,
-0.0145317549,
-0.040935725,
0.0416311249,
0.0072333831,
-0.0320841931,
0.0332910977,
0.0496706776,
-0.0108339433,
-0.0824328884,
-0.0375832915,
0.01320678,
0.056058459,
0.0191961266,
0.0136783021,
-0.0657472387,
0.0124201374,
0.0128277373,
-0.0122492472,
0.0147219207,
0.004978532,
0.0101614576,
0.0263796262,
-0.0683162287,
0.0009029968,
-0.0096370764,
0.0276205782,
0.0040463111,
0.0233108941,
0.0269793551,
-0.0322838053,
-0.017842181,
0.0325064175,
-0.0278768484,
-0.0313699022,
-0.0273965094,
-0.0072331545,
-0.0327380896,
-0.0148709975,
0.0073730475,
0.0012639896,
-0.0180450361,
-0.0023740504,
0.0488498248,
0.0195490178,
-0.0088616693,
0.0099120662,
2.739e-7,
0.052085869,
0.0466978066,
-0.0030654613,
0.0382216796,
-0.0299827773,
0.0660621077,
-0.0346131846,
-0.0038463201,
0.0241829734,
-0.0425218232,
0.0147164864,
-0.0084111225,
0.0567122735,
0.0272104219,
-0.0660394654,
-0.0650296062,
-0.0756247044,
0.0077371816,
-0.0709872097,
-0.0239529181,
0.0417198874,
0.0211814977,
-0.0058488189,
0.0162864514,
0.0177938007,
-0.0146345412,
0.0227834433,
-0.0814232752,
0.0064532529,
0.0371175557,
0.0423274934,
-0.0476755425,
0.0037030741,
0.023526812,
0.0075970022,
0.0345791467,
0.0148849608,
0.0753624439,
0.0393569171,
0.0056815459,
-0.0293651689,
-0.0634305105,
0.0302666817,
-0.0593016781,
0.0418209247,
-0.0464210995,
-0.0358094797,
-0.0612445176,
-0.0384306163,
-0.0167446155,
0.0468936898,
0.0082014985,
0.0333230682,
0.0062512024,
-0.0242619868,
-0.0040298603,
0.0070505575,
-0.0278144237,
-0.0152276326,
0.003388626,
-0.027619848,
-0.0537593402,
-0.0189563539,
0.0304174777,
0.0021717949,
-0.0909116492,
0.020676909,
2.63896691e-34,
0.0636320114,
-0.0054673501,
0.0246502142,
0.0257782191,
0.0495298095,
0.0314307362,
-0.0024791842,
0.0129848607,
0.0484553277,
-0.0831728205,
-0.0171094332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15321v1 | Greedy Grammar Induction with Indirect Negative Evidence | 2023-12-23T18:43:56 | 2023-12-23T18:43:56 | Joseph Potashnik | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper offers a fresh look at the pumping lemma constant as an upper
bound for the finite structural information of a Context Free Grammar. An
objective function based on indirect negative evidence considers the
occurrences, and non-occurrences, of a finite number of trees, encountered
after a sufficiently long non-adversial input presentation. This objective
function has optimal substructure in the hypotheses space, giving rise to a
greedy search learner. With this learner, a range of classes of Context Free
Languages is shown to be learnable (identifiable in the limit) on an otherwise
intractable hypotheses space. | [
0.0054836087,
0.0158870351,
-0.0061243898,
0.0489670038,
-0.0501231626,
0.0185774956,
-0.0978942066,
0.0352125801,
-0.0520119704,
-0.0188974608,
-0.0033267776,
-0.0729600564,
-0.0079122391,
-0.0444697514,
0.0628158674,
-0.0109321177,
0.0441462211,
-0.018118754,
0.0077119651,
0.015706826,
-0.0117612313,
-0.0477054194,
0.0011202894,
-0.0285672229,
-0.0388978198,
0.0364854075,
-0.0384174883,
-0.034483593,
-0.0254635885,
-0.0200655162,
-0.0502286628,
-0.0134429792,
-0.0068635517,
0.070912376,
0.0000017512,
-0.0391367823,
-0.0291470569,
-0.00507583,
-0.1071579829,
-0.0234930236,
0.0129463738,
-0.0362221859,
-0.0111690611,
-0.0090327347,
-0.0335500203,
0.0500362813,
0.0464098454,
0.0091810878,
0.0560056306,
0.0741346776,
0.0165162385,
-0.0610291734,
0.0040089278,
-0.0089791864,
0.0738415942,
0.0269166939,
0.0167639405,
-0.0774914697,
0.0415276848,
-0.050716307,
-0.0056050452,
-0.0027196424,
0.0046636956,
-0.0025506211,
-0.0233279206,
0.0228353776,
-0.044382032,
-0.0127313221,
0.0043786061,
0.0086801052,
-0.0176521204,
-0.0300234277,
0.0022149896,
-0.0256911535,
-0.0168262944,
-0.0371721089,
-0.023856543,
0.0623969436,
-0.0241248347,
0.0383260734,
0.1033752486,
-0.0239160899,
0.0372074433,
-0.0392096713,
-0.0078073842,
0.0533305854,
-0.0055568423,
-0.0557405539,
0.035230305,
0.0174233969,
-0.0239623431,
-0.0009862458,
-0.0577882454,
0.0070091793,
-0.0345874652,
0.0486026518,
0.0221549328,
0.0371450447,
-0.0132209836,
-0.0244046189,
-0.0192340147,
0.0061957836,
0.0447960682,
0.040879339,
-0.0192006566,
-0.0401662588,
-0.0552917533,
-0.0071525997,
-0.0095963478,
0.0121654114,
-0.0144476052,
-0.0186194479,
-0.0501809828,
0.0541290045,
0.0039459746,
0.0307488162,
-0.0186083056,
0.0167700127,
-0.0130256107,
0.0311728679,
-0.013414423,
-0.0646740571,
-0.0403229333,
0.0165279955,
0.0075549101,
-0.0252281204,
0.0081166904,
-0.0022246861,
0.0057200557,
-0.0401660241,
-0.0194528569,
0.048512511,
0.0261084922,
0.0387667865,
-0.0060563004,
0.0640594512,
-0.0032252285,
-0.0185621288,
-0.0589460842,
-0.0046368302,
0.023597531,
-0.0005187829,
0.0117383497,
-0.0068655848,
-0.0620216653,
-0.0175225381,
0.0056032878,
-0.0131998714,
-0.0104926815,
-0.013295114,
0.0252670366,
0.0338977128,
-0.010426322,
-0.002255338,
0.0110911652,
-0.0199284721,
-0.0204831008,
0.0869396701,
-0.0070820265,
0.0038895458,
0.0288338419,
-0.0062515233,
0.0435118712,
0.055562187,
-0.0162840635,
0.0174207203,
0.0411342159,
-0.011620854,
-0.0099498453,
0.011688604,
-0.059833061,
0.0362946987,
-0.0374538004,
-0.0552575625,
-0.0488947518,
-0.000808639,
0.0315724313,
-0.0306603275,
0.0802017376,
-0.0165414289,
-0.0043523344,
0.0342525579,
-0.014758097,
-0.0510506481,
-0.0888839141,
0.0306991488,
-0.0661284551,
-0.0637096614,
0.0091491519,
-0.0308326744,
-0.0214603934,
-0.0486996844,
-0.0251017418,
-0.0456803702,
0.0967262015,
0.0339543596,
-0.0633139163,
-0.0225833785,
0.0281355437,
-0.0307478867,
0.020618828,
-0.0045522642,
0.0789554864,
-0.055812709,
0.0123233013,
-0.0565352105,
0.0058651883,
-0.0012479312,
-0.0123792524,
0.0386120118,
-0.0007933784,
-0.0237845127,
0.0575564057,
-0.0048910584,
0.017339278,
0.062751621,
0.0270815492,
0.0150139686,
-0.0509357154,
-0.0323964991,
-0.0093500139,
0.0100499345,
-0.0267510638,
0.044737082,
0.000718092,
-0.0074488642,
-0.0018177404,
0.0285729896,
0.0771164149,
0.012570817,
-0.0016704858,
0.0199969672,
0.0530149713,
-0.0330182761,
-0.0303796344,
0.0217528045,
-0.0522946045,
-0.064131394,
-0.0018917327,
-0.0488955565,
0.0037957774,
-0.0354524702,
0.0181981269,
-0.0427380688,
0.0528293513,
-0.0983079299,
0.125118494,
-0.0036178397,
0.0519000627,
-0.0007149008,
-0.0401976258,
-0.0072971559,
0.0970876515,
0.0172183011,
0.0208103918,
0.017861275,
-0.0239701495,
0.0421306975,
-0.0670102537,
-0.0052573816,
-0.0138696134,
-0.0177736077,
-0.0449817888,
0.0411776751,
-0.0030144167,
-0.0544490218,
-0.0086505413,
0.0012233036,
-0.0120860366,
-0.0115789315,
0.0568112805,
-0.0034738071,
0.0060800342,
0.0167415906,
-0.0296564233,
-0.0151030775,
0.0326719992,
0.0095521128,
0.0009273323,
0.0155318221,
0.0405621976,
-0.0686176866,
-0.0188147835,
-0.0070664273,
-0.0211648177,
0.0525927432,
0.0271677151,
-0.0549663417,
-0.0185014158,
0.0439462177,
0.0251339544,
0.0410818011,
-0.0183729529,
-0.0102517614,
0.0492225587,
-0.0633081868,
-0.0699827448,
0.0516992584,
-0.0106306113,
0.0103676887,
-0.0284153,
0.0235012285,
0.0085715242,
-0.0274430308,
-0.0525387563,
-0.0126935244,
-0.0364316925,
0.0085926559,
0.0479417369,
0.1341879964,
-0.0358820818,
-0.0055824574,
-0.0435176529,
0.0051186848,
-0.0281931236,
-0.0070765857,
0.0054040002,
-0.039715834,
-0.0342415385,
0.0193721987,
-0.0007531759,
-0.0588218123,
0.0536942743,
-0.0469761416,
-0.0461749397,
0.013892822,
-0.0079770572,
-0.0253073685,
0.0238732882,
0.0719649494,
0.0281444192,
0.0963998511,
-0.0153675433,
-0.0109942565,
0.0406123921,
0.0944881663,
0.0332200713,
-0.0529025607,
-0.0082976623,
0.026917588,
0.0096749282,
-0.0559616536,
-0.0470470488,
-0.0664850399,
0.0191355087,
-0.0251557287,
0.0372743644,
-0.0143169332,
-0.0119523779,
-0.0043259053,
-0.0232731607,
0.0166793857,
0.037902277,
-0.0127657028,
-0.0195271485,
0.0118725179,
-0.0364547633,
0.0453270636,
-0.0054000542,
-0.0199050885,
0.0146211358,
0.0052238898,
0.0232611727,
0.0334882028,
0.0172965024,
0.0475560538,
0.0242752321,
0.0037894612,
-0.0892956257,
0.0181468669,
-0.013737943,
0.0052389479,
-0.0085738031,
0.0514344238,
0.0254410282,
-0.0295242984,
0.0494668931,
-0.0064901076,
0.0267580897,
0.0297045037,
-0.0170693379,
-0.0616968311,
-0.0181680173,
-0.0054057008,
0.0529186502,
-0.0833275691,
-0.0344755575,
0.0035537591,
-0.1124898046,
-0.011529455,
0.0372365005,
-0.0406291746,
0.0354421027,
-0.0210561287,
-0.0072195679,
-0.0490446277,
-0.0867110938,
0.0378732197,
-0.0171825998,
0.0040504839,
0.0459353477,
-0.0101694502,
-0.0717533156,
-0.0878467187,
-0.0188887585,
0.050948415,
0.0315385796,
-0.0029591895,
-0.0243464429,
0.0103203906,
0.0034285632,
-0.0588630661,
0.0108074546,
-0.0427437611,
0.0004173213,
0.031055728,
-0.0168655161,
-0.0138237812,
0.0404493995,
-0.0222217776,
0.0267002005,
0.0357105099,
0.1024655104,
0.0031494242,
-0.0183652937,
0.0374744609,
-0.0243916046,
-0.001763117,
0.0299855638,
0.0213208571,
0.0131275197,
0.0475549512,
-0.0561593883,
0.0192145985,
0.051233232,
-0.0098568471,
0.0530128032,
-0.0254789814,
-0.0058982475,
-0.0602267534,
-0.0137776909,
0.0014510464,
0.0894240662,
0.0096134758,
0.0213098172,
0.0090529472,
-0.0181042776,
-0.0179534778,
-0.0200297851,
-0.0142010786,
-0.0105508547,
-0.0658147857,
-0.0262515973,
0.0444398336,
-0.0197128598,
-0.0091152145,
-0.044967439,
0.0439310819,
-0.0539821908,
0.0075595337,
0.037194252,
0.0221880786,
0.01088815,
0.0120877167,
-0.0160113983,
-0.0187705569,
0.0363618992,
-0.0628567934,
0.0157568734,
0.0792191029,
-0.0562027879,
0.0182885081,
0.0219462235,
-0.0046506496,
-0.0004867991,
0.0240931604,
-0.0022371828,
-0.0526026003,
0.0615760349,
0.0942942575,
0.0826419368,
0.0172399357,
-0.0080011608,
-0.0186119266,
0.0168036502,
-0.0108188381,
-0.018862389,
-0.0149752451,
-0.0276922043,
0.0118160052,
-0.0287256762,
0.0189201888,
0.0008409791,
-0.0197338667,
-0.0099777058,
0.0310937446,
-0.0031327044,
0.0477024466,
0.0659771264,
0.0249545313,
-0.0007281975,
0.0035151606,
0.0401340649,
-0.008838186,
0.0005869141,
0.0356737599,
-0.0228694584,
0.0222579036,
0.0466585793,
0.0186615139,
-0.0186069533,
-0.0125906067,
-0.0481252968,
0.0461927652,
0.0037044398,
0.0042566783,
0.046962928,
0.0001586989,
0.0402967595,
-0.0449582897,
0.0317218713,
0.0155792041,
0.0198353436,
-0.0216439366,
-0.0798271075,
0.015209401,
0.0270672217,
-0.0389286429,
0.012196782,
0.0617512241,
0.0041435468,
0.0373034291,
-0.0453585349,
0.0298101641,
-0.0639180616,
0.0312330984,
0.0180817079,
0.0258469619,
0.0230042581,
0.038742315,
-0.0334164537,
-0.0509284772,
-0.055776,
-0.005173516,
0.029154012,
0.0253307503,
0.0298121311,
0.0182572044,
0.0006518735,
-0.0254132114,
-0.0246135872,
0.0261931252,
-0.0143060135,
0.0141460979,
0.0082386993,
-5.30796421e-33,
-0.0322341844,
-0.0153823141,
-0.0367777087,
0.0166841242,
0.0143873617,
0.0178264845,
-0.0076274332,
0.0337819234,
0.0248469133,
-0.0076972074,
-0.0119911311,
-0.0099998917,
0.0055388338,
0.006811785,
-0.0293092635,
0.0032738603,
0.01485621,
0.0033930084,
-0.0298751444,
-0.0126972673,
0.0107253408,
-0.0114050731,
0.034952268,
-0.0485443026,
0.0134326983,
-0.0355626605,
-0.0202291775,
0.0796771944,
-0.0091070021,
0.0473421142,
0.0449810624,
0.0166714638,
-0.0001212197,
-0.0113713536,
-0.0035683103,
-0.0536501855,
-0.0285969153,
-0.0405225828,
0.0217866227,
0.0311297998,
-0.0401984453,
-0.00826611,
0.0356638059,
-0.0559548959,
-0.0017639608,
0.0794788003,
-0.0244933628,
-0.0163671914,
-0.0057278401,
0.0056477049,
-0.0364374518,
0.0489454903,
-0.0148038492,
0.0239984076,
0.0285684224,
0.0186680183,
-0.0199306682,
-0.0338536724,
0.0231409594,
0.0547451079,
0.0132844485,
0.0237789657,
0.0216011889,
0.0055441279,
0.0111504141,
-0.0056822812,
0.070746772,
-0.0317550972,
0.0431808643,
-0.0281001963,
-0.0154690603,
-0.0001024866,
0.0241700523,
0.0806723461,
0.0225717574,
0.0231308714,
-0.0377233066,
0.0018834408,
0.0571938977,
-0.0001826237,
-0.0340914167,
0.0103307562,
-0.0555274524,
-0.0374330282,
-0.0373486802,
0.0037775678,
0.0184163041,
0.0179970041,
0.0169644523,
0.0182970762,
-0.0082720742,
0.0045934641,
0.006724338,
0.0047472236,
0.0269778334,
0.042592328,
-0.0008421965,
0.0275041945,
-0.023425227,
-0.0088860169,
-0.0250291526,
-0.0437199362,
-0.0067948448,
-0.0402136594,
0.0306204055,
-0.0029323823,
0.0009643116,
0.0690640509,
-0.0030622557,
-0.0225780029,
-0.0115360795,
-0.0251373779,
-0.0023153923,
-0.0538676046,
0.0795798525,
0.0098442296,
-0.0061130784,
-0.0047303233,
0.0493072718,
0.0132988859,
-0.0311652869,
0.0103469938,
-0.0243580546,
0.0402756445,
-0.0269005243,
-0.02947901,
0.0181822199,
0.0327664725,
0.0585759431,
-0.0744672865,
0.0192348324,
-0.0193805769,
2.545e-7,
-0.0231896453,
0.0029565415,
0.0027917349,
-0.033213798,
0.0404715873,
0.0373801515,
-0.0258481484,
-0.0377877988,
-0.0654284731,
0.002699933,
0.012641401,
-0.0562180243,
-0.0073131658,
-0.0298613813,
-0.0609553009,
0.0099096885,
-0.0017919834,
-0.047908809,
0.0107112797,
0.039860405,
0.0333862901,
0.0909580961,
0.0030443794,
-0.0160919204,
-0.0115043558,
-0.0426011011,
0.0101602906,
-0.0240875017,
0.0156461839,
-0.0126274433,
0.0291256886,
-0.018234415,
-0.0159650538,
0.014178535,
-0.0056087784,
0.0305615272,
-0.047002323,
-0.0542286374,
0.0004797685,
0.0310208388,
0.0586049296,
0.0003704172,
-0.0196429286,
0.0235268027,
0.0165293682,
-0.0250890981,
-0.0380815677,
0.0305001102,
-0.0122431191,
0.0023265705,
-0.086405009,
0.0316727683,
-0.0047847978,
-0.0151111213,
0.0082763378,
-0.0167962406,
-0.0184417162,
0.0044672997,
0.0340472348,
-0.0212927479,
-0.0081326766,
-0.0163752176,
0.0083869705,
0.062766552,
-0.000062926,
-0.0336036198,
-0.0084373327,
2.099764437e-34,
0.0150950868,
-0.0507142767,
0.0531845391,
0.022669455,
0.0010753562,
0.0155174723,
-0.01740757,
0.0275173932,
0.0621374771,
-0.0314118601,
0.015905885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15316v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15316v2 | Paralinguistics-Enhanced Large Language Modeling of Spoken Dialogue | 2023-12-23T18:14:56 | 2024-01-17T17:07:37 | Guan-Ting Lin, Prashanth Gurunath Shivakumar, Ankur Gandhe, Chao-Han Huck Yang, Yile Gu, Shalini Ghosh, Andreas Stolcke, Hung-yi Lee, Ivan Bulyko | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated superior abilities in tasks
such as chatting, reasoning, and question-answering. However, standard LLMs may
ignore crucial paralinguistic information, such as sentiment, emotion, and
speaking style, which are essential for achieving natural, human-like spoken
conversation, especially when such information is conveyed by acoustic cues. We
therefore propose Paralinguistics-enhanced Generative Pretrained Transformer
(ParalinGPT), an LLM that utilizes text and speech modalities to better model
the linguistic content and paralinguistic attributes of spoken dialogue. The
model takes the conversational context of text, speech embeddings, and
paralinguistic attributes as input prompts within a serialized multitasking
multimodal framework. Specifically, our framework serializes tasks in the order
of current paralinguistic attribute prediction, response paralinguistic
attribute prediction, and response text generation with autoregressive
conditioning. We utilize the Switchboard-1 corpus, including its sentiment
labels as the paralinguistic attribute, as our spoken dialogue dataset.
Experimental results indicate the proposed serialized multitasking method
outperforms typical sequence classification techniques on current and response
sentiment classification. Furthermore, leveraging conversational context and
speech embeddings significantly improves both response text generation and
sentiment prediction. Our proposed framework achieves relative improvements of
6.7%, 12.0%, and 3.5% in current sentiment accuracy, response sentiment
accuracy, and response text BLEU score, respectively. | [
0.0233668648,
0.0892768204,
-0.012631801,
-0.0003703042,
-0.017630348,
0.0099890428,
0.0145494388,
-0.0262450296,
-0.014818796,
-0.0887278169,
-0.0682781637,
-0.0597030893,
-0.0003508017,
0.0169169176,
0.0215085559,
-0.0566747747,
0.0271034911,
-0.0206758939,
0.0290000737,
0.0037537774,
0.0156693496,
0.0337051526,
-0.019014027,
0.0420253091,
-0.0332143269,
-0.0005605139,
-0.0308042858,
0.02245255,
-0.0066809952,
-0.0075522456,
0.0557108708,
0.0673531443,
0.0354082994,
0.0178159196,
0.0000019093,
-0.0143245878,
0.0296272188,
-0.0288761724,
0.0234232992,
-0.0175657179,
0.0853668079,
0.0252504703,
0.0067032003,
0.0523047969,
-0.0460038036,
-0.0586149432,
0.0542376786,
0.0638082772,
0.0716169178,
0.0723985881,
-0.0246607885,
-0.0302001201,
0.0274500195,
-0.0247983206,
0.0081392424,
0.0007005905,
-0.0149053279,
-0.0024111015,
0.0039868057,
0.0274381973,
-0.0058180559,
0.0340249948,
0.0018147851,
-0.0310807358,
-0.0086693987,
0.0179941375,
0.0134407943,
-0.0457729883,
-0.0099762902,
0.1005164012,
-0.0028531603,
-0.0336085297,
-0.0053372537,
0.0149865681,
-0.0094465306,
-0.0362844244,
-0.0455384068,
0.0315850861,
0.0282071028,
0.0107327783,
-0.0023409107,
0.0453949086,
-0.0030687277,
0.0058859847,
-0.0125862816,
0.0051559061,
0.0002094692,
-0.0179837961,
-0.0185505673,
0.0067110048,
-0.0087212175,
-0.0505124144,
-0.011076862,
0.0026851043,
-0.0744786933,
0.0043924968,
-0.061453063,
-0.0379436724,
-0.0069959671,
-0.0308763832,
0.0224576574,
0.0178329851,
-0.0362398773,
0.0166846849,
-0.0048075039,
0.0298051909,
-0.0155222612,
-0.0231136512,
-0.0319151469,
-0.0233667288,
-0.0569625907,
-0.0098428,
-0.0257216785,
0.0308040977,
-0.0456423201,
-0.0412978195,
-0.0409954078,
0.0251468588,
-0.0107260533,
-0.0040698675,
0.0294636711,
0.0431230105,
-0.0327625908,
0.0008195662,
-0.0034845136,
0.0356887914,
-0.0156267677,
0.0477696918,
0.0076465262,
-0.0419567674,
0.009929602,
0.0573916659,
0.0266162623,
-0.0299054086,
0.01569934,
0.039710179,
-0.0282701589,
-0.0283076111,
-0.0130216312,
-0.0348506682,
-0.0586938635,
-0.0812755078,
0.0127902208,
-0.0318673365,
0.0571043268,
-0.0056105657,
-0.0248934906,
0.0174773578,
0.0077298605,
0.0217540897,
-0.0222570021,
0.0580823682,
0.0287043359,
0.0063328571,
0.0271086711,
0.0051183533,
0.0037126809,
0.0504659303,
0.0285033397,
0.0391880162,
0.0210418124,
-0.0339400657,
0.0005675095,
0.0213408135,
0.0086738421,
-0.0133018084,
-0.0240758378,
0.0194456819,
0.0162520707,
0.0154343424,
0.045689892,
0.0481929146,
-0.0363574736,
-0.0226874277,
0.0798433498,
0.0316471495,
-0.0143030109,
0.0511404797,
0.0335972011,
0.0596688837,
-0.0296796616,
-0.0118203731,
-0.0276388377,
0.0315383188,
-0.0228350405,
0.0038450134,
0.0463037193,
0.0272290576,
-0.0291023757,
-0.0434008613,
0.0238473434,
-0.0453353487,
0.0241685957,
0.0263897069,
0.0024383247,
0.0218090974,
-0.0832782015,
0.0490666032,
0.0079108281,
-0.0658530369,
-0.0224616267,
-0.0286808051,
0.0074955183,
0.0729875043,
0.0192935094,
0.000540826,
-0.0479741246,
-0.0768764466,
0.0363060087,
0.0391553752,
0.0225746166,
-0.0173040386,
0.0481005386,
-0.0692825094,
0.0209120177,
-0.0103784846,
-0.0105811022,
0.0322814584,
-0.0110003855,
0.0083379867,
0.0217712019,
0.0214123651,
0.0223369971,
-0.0110353911,
-0.0250975061,
-0.0302700102,
0.0590697043,
0.0000064831,
0.0486800075,
0.031148456,
-0.0347036794,
0.0026114867,
0.0165484566,
-0.0323921777,
-0.0237421151,
0.0668407604,
-0.0804428086,
-0.0703690127,
0.0218136963,
0.0251359828,
-0.0057370597,
0.0435773991,
-0.0173750482,
-0.0591333434,
0.0136882402,
-0.0428052992,
0.0482268855,
-0.064599216,
0.0000069582,
0.0155514451,
0.0567994192,
-0.0114451796,
-0.0059668017,
0.0238583218,
-0.0109682549,
0.0048054629,
0.0270031132,
0.021613365,
-0.025567865,
-0.0448145829,
0.0250933487,
0.0069815805,
0.0152853131,
0.0220227018,
0.0131686609,
-0.0090989778,
-0.0541494042,
-0.1504987329,
0.0099236397,
-0.0022021674,
-0.0086860033,
0.0188474637,
0.0094906269,
-0.0015181941,
-0.0206854176,
-0.0650115535,
0.0019236444,
0.059563648,
0.0094266199,
0.0304741915,
-0.0122423684,
-0.0017436245,
-0.0433236957,
0.0264806747,
-0.0027879919,
0.0478541963,
-0.0141106304,
0.0401450247,
-0.0112785418,
0.0162285641,
-0.0120982556,
0.0455024764,
0.0042464994,
-0.0663777739,
-0.0162177663,
-0.0330321975,
0.0333663039,
0.0394156687,
0.053566359,
0.0206812918,
0.0117268544,
-0.0270298179,
-0.0458617583,
0.0350381769,
-0.0340712778,
-0.0084807202,
-0.0203478243,
-0.0111812279,
-0.0150727555,
0.0668911263,
0.0279979818,
0.0119203171,
-0.0637622997,
-0.0090531912,
0.0356470346,
-0.0350517333,
0.0067392536,
0.0005716259,
-0.0344135426,
0.0185504574,
0.0083509767,
-0.0228437148,
0.0466708429,
-0.0514270812,
-0.0471399911,
-0.0706678033,
-0.0226266645,
-0.0074739167,
0.0587244183,
-0.0094968891,
0.0186795052,
0.0158786122,
-0.0158890821,
-0.0411727987,
-0.0077592204,
-0.0008845087,
-0.0430184677,
0.0204636473,
-0.0131621379,
-0.0191867817,
0.0081495969,
-0.056254074,
-0.0422846079,
-0.0499391854,
-0.0205348358,
-0.0095126191,
0.0013713371,
-0.0244519319,
-0.0154687092,
0.0095052216,
-0.01010428,
-0.0145928636,
-0.0160043687,
0.0032526259,
-0.0072999601,
0.0710023046,
0.0726283267,
0.0452398062,
-0.0250057504,
-0.0005260929,
0.0298515018,
0.0229809806,
0.0293053221,
0.027741449,
-0.0366343409,
-0.0274737589,
0.0298001859,
0.0319945924,
-0.0352142714,
-0.0058374493,
0.0135609815,
-0.0181353949,
-0.0100311153,
0.148359701,
0.0159571953,
-0.0346685722,
-0.0145952832,
0.0054693478,
0.0443978943,
0.0149942646,
0.0473246314,
-0.0404556692,
-0.0532668494,
-0.0197023153,
-0.002002185,
0.001750866,
-0.0152641293,
-0.0065576304,
-0.11193344,
0.0314833857,
-0.0003703252,
-0.0440924205,
-0.0264275558,
-0.005228437,
-0.0357861444,
-0.0058286847,
0.0287972484,
-0.0404308923,
0.002599597,
-0.0020652788,
0.0150108412,
-0.0269331969,
-0.0336901061,
0.040923968,
-0.0035636919,
0.0498187356,
0.0277109072,
0.065111883,
-0.0058509968,
-0.0145776067,
0.0256582443,
0.026675798,
-0.0145793939,
0.006087767,
0.043879278,
-0.0342131108,
-0.0201081131,
-0.0309414715,
0.0181742534,
-0.0102454536,
-0.0095104417,
0.0081250761,
0.0274100564,
-0.0331896916,
-0.0100105787,
-0.0245395601,
0.0605576895,
0.0465799496,
0.0504613854,
0.0165406354,
-0.0753630549,
-0.0352565572,
-0.0073870891,
0.0298319142,
-0.0483664386,
-0.0049867379,
-0.0183658134,
0.0260455441,
0.0007212108,
-0.095547244,
-0.0469636098,
-0.0070036026,
0.0374898911,
-0.0245203506,
-0.0194812715,
-0.0025457279,
-0.0040532099,
-0.0606705323,
-0.0057514571,
0.0247048251,
0.0181482472,
-0.0499547236,
-0.0218259599,
0.1001287326,
-0.0626167208,
-0.0158613436,
0.0043950686,
-0.0859354287,
-0.0619312748,
-0.0286162179,
0.0736450031,
0.0094604278,
0.0620249175,
0.0056723375,
-0.0285805427,
0.0414406247,
0.0359105356,
-0.0667468905,
0.0099382559,
0.062910147,
0.0622404218,
-0.0107368091,
0.0288112424,
-0.0146315061,
0.0306468215,
-0.0254909471,
0.0073781973,
-0.0159910545,
-0.0563685931,
-0.0262397416,
0.0050993492,
0.0456254259,
0.0087229209,
0.0009660388,
-0.0205364507,
0.0192249678,
-0.0029140941,
0.0087822732,
-0.0727546886,
0.0028964151,
0.0237204898,
-0.0092030801,
-0.0195904989,
-0.0008761856,
-0.0281972475,
0.0410637781,
0.0150859421,
0.0240384024,
-0.0025287832,
-0.00314127,
0.0213884152,
0.0220706519,
-0.0312801078,
-0.0002677167,
0.0351834781,
0.028687479,
-0.016180627,
0.0740637183,
-0.0056662778,
-0.0289066285,
0.0008537847,
0.0455704145,
-0.0454510264,
-0.0117621683,
-0.0190489832,
0.0292105377,
0.0293504037,
-0.003780866,
0.0696548373,
-0.0360149331,
0.017637236,
-0.0225434005,
0.1011383981,
-0.0322704129,
-0.0337623321,
0.03617144,
-0.0078546712,
-0.0396331996,
0.0217165984,
0.0653343946,
0.0130930878,
0.0227610674,
0.02695751,
0.0121773658,
-0.0689519122,
-0.0423047394,
0.0532320179,
0.0182166956,
0.0057763299,
0.0149247311,
-0.0211176444,
-0.0552493818,
0.02640648,
-0.033325173,
-0.0157722775,
-0.0347721539,
0.0300921984,
0.0547574461,
-0.0014852533,
0.0339112543,
-0.0435614623,
-0.0014369093,
0.002668699,
-0.0241736751,
-0.019133132,
-6.040877591e-33,
-0.0184628833,
-0.0156801529,
0.0014519118,
0.0137885315,
-0.034654513,
-0.0226687249,
-0.0211671386,
0.0060310485,
0.0037097153,
-0.0044694492,
-0.0097507574,
-0.0045023113,
-0.0086999517,
0.0701993555,
0.0153202489,
-0.0063897558,
0.0653158277,
-0.0168383513,
0.0053920029,
0.0523151122,
0.030119447,
0.0484747887,
0.0399944298,
-0.0921233073,
-0.028245531,
-0.0168048032,
-0.0140232947,
0.0075386562,
0.0272976644,
0.0441153683,
-0.0286559276,
0.0612946078,
0.0069815288,
-0.0326965563,
-0.0139946481,
0.0825024471,
-0.0453318246,
-0.0012774081,
-0.0046045394,
0.0206817891,
-0.0143616088,
-0.0163506083,
-0.0142282536,
-0.0087812776,
0.0183976386,
-0.0140682999,
0.0192581732,
-0.0039801267,
0.0147010935,
-0.0386732444,
-0.0485340096,
-0.0037755498,
-0.0139197903,
-0.0450964086,
0.0059250831,
0.0798939466,
0.0170218777,
0.0236868076,
-0.0303163938,
0.0209383443,
-0.0239374954,
-0.0098821996,
0.017548902,
0.0162576996,
0.0117989164,
0.0603324287,
0.0183362514,
0.0090412172,
-0.0141632827,
0.0462697521,
-0.0041887271,
0.0457982048,
-0.0304905828,
0.083467856,
-0.0007555402,
-0.0295829773,
-0.0260326322,
0.0109905265,
0.0586413555,
0.0107239848,
0.0467358753,
-0.0036598071,
-0.0030285388,
-0.0200239439,
-0.0263438597,
0.0074255392,
-0.0166673921,
-0.0245293677,
0.0430780165,
0.0272755995,
-0.0083580716,
-0.0353359208,
0.0543732233,
-0.0553525463,
-0.0171609167,
0.0355044231,
-0.0619041808,
0.0096920561,
-0.0268924441,
0.0161937401,
-0.0324516743,
-0.0295958277,
0.0588831306,
0.0045428802,
-0.0011067132,
0.0268805102,
-0.0006495991,
0.0357502624,
-0.0641517788,
0.003661145,
-0.0214652009,
0.0548624247,
-0.0376681089,
0.0363131724,
0.0095547885,
0.031789694,
-0.0215191431,
0.0720887557,
-0.0314112417,
0.0074496237,
-0.0244259667,
-0.0559351556,
0.0307632592,
0.0133539308,
-0.0358501449,
0.0066928412,
-0.003124685,
-0.0581049509,
0.0046401154,
-0.0437943749,
-0.0059167142,
0.0003054774,
2.746e-7,
0.000309515,
0.0686110035,
0.0063288449,
0.0164564904,
0.0107013592,
0.0737046003,
0.0113112777,
0.0372075886,
0.0233053081,
0.0044218912,
0.0096355556,
-0.0021634588,
0.0805759728,
0.0270429309,
-0.1114315689,
-0.061542213,
-0.0759397671,
0.0082768779,
-0.0106310137,
-0.023191208,
0.113574855,
0.1029325426,
-0.0050011924,
-0.0222765524,
0.0299273096,
-0.0113341501,
0.0651243255,
-0.0338624828,
-0.0289816037,
-0.0129646054,
-0.0132709304,
-0.0091289878,
-0.0066675791,
-0.0043945611,
-0.0231934432,
0.015869081,
-0.0002303296,
0.0843532011,
0.0130959349,
-0.0931293219,
-0.0043371334,
0.0264972858,
-0.0138506684,
-0.0515814908,
0.0578614734,
-0.0669863522,
-0.0284510069,
-0.0435342193,
-0.0414442345,
0.0010881573,
0.0134467287,
-0.0416616015,
-0.0205040872,
0.0124184247,
0.025227746,
-0.017193798,
-0.0070459545,
-0.1007720232,
-0.0046486682,
-0.0022308857,
-0.0747894123,
-0.0152242882,
-0.0252875704,
-0.0035620106,
0.0500332601,
-0.01925366,
0.0036369152,
2.430104752e-34,
0.0448127463,
-0.0159546919,
0.0255253203,
0.0088596521,
0.0264366828,
0.0022486446,
0.0046453732,
-0.0140352286,
0.0611158349,
-0.0707255602,
-0.0241870061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15304v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15304v2 | Exploring the Capabilities of ChatGPT in Ancient Chinese Translation and Person Name Recognition | 2023-12-23T17:30:28 | 2024-02-23T05:24:26 | Shijing Si, Siqing Zhou, Le Tang, Xiaoqing Cheng, Yugui Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | ChatGPT's proficiency in handling modern standard languages suggests
potential for its use in understanding ancient Chinese. This paper explores
ChatGPT's capabilities on ancient Chinese via two tasks: translating ancient
Chinese to modern Chinese and recognizing ancient Chinese names. A comparison
of ChatGPT's output with human translations serves to evaluate its
comprehension of ancient Chinese. The findings indicate that: (1.)the
proficiency of ancient Chinese by ChatGPT is yet to reach a satisfactory level;
(2.) ChatGPT performs the best on ancient-to-modern translation when feeding
with three context sentences. To help reproduce our work, we display the python
code snippets used in this study. | [
0.0598522648,
-0.0008765153,
-0.0095008407,
0.05616685,
-0.0399758965,
0.0221190583,
0.034005858,
0.069613263,
0.0442922153,
-0.0182167944,
-0.029968489,
-0.0567458495,
0.0764043331,
-0.0483160354,
0.0076040351,
-0.0851553828,
0.0547186658,
0.0362692922,
-0.0056225089,
0.0263051372,
-0.0176972337,
-0.0183128733,
0.0134650972,
0.0350721367,
0.0014551656,
-0.0090084495,
0.0001529946,
0.0291441549,
0.0339047052,
-0.0311567169,
-0.0514072329,
0.0034563262,
0.0021710948,
0.0894266888,
0.0000017496,
-0.050523717,
-0.0365597904,
-0.0093755154,
-0.014904757,
-0.0011408117,
0.0638977662,
0.0079686493,
-0.0271799155,
-0.0018472187,
-0.0172749367,
-0.0228096303,
0.0891319662,
0.0679564402,
-0.0000216264,
0.0716282725,
-0.0101144807,
-0.0299115963,
0.02957578,
-0.0035751653,
0.0360287316,
-0.0650703087,
-0.0022552521,
0.0446185693,
-0.0143525572,
0.0310913865,
-0.0100202169,
0.0462290309,
-0.0387147479,
0.0244982652,
-0.0588437244,
0.0459124781,
-0.0588577427,
0.016772287,
-0.0120532466,
0.0243834611,
-0.0014490375,
-0.0179398991,
-0.0293671768,
0.0406766087,
-0.0173268039,
-0.0243592337,
-0.0403917469,
-0.0179373752,
-0.061655961,
-0.0265651941,
0.0110318195,
-0.0298957583,
0.0227206126,
-0.000524105,
-0.0341223851,
-0.0148922224,
0.0319742113,
-0.0481640473,
-0.0207510777,
0.0060608629,
-0.0076275235,
-0.0010816522,
0.0368018076,
0.0298663042,
-0.0256166477,
0.0197080784,
0.0385943353,
0.0134628043,
-0.0469356216,
-0.0415984541,
-0.0522758812,
0.1013797075,
-0.0236338265,
0.016460469,
-0.0432265103,
0.0711205751,
0.0174625665,
0.0220976491,
-0.0543335043,
0.0035571519,
-0.0774400681,
-0.0048346967,
-0.1001374945,
-0.0081694033,
-0.0075534591,
-0.0037291101,
-0.0354286022,
-0.0177525058,
0.0454478674,
-0.0103349201,
-0.0161109399,
-0.0410326831,
-0.0404031016,
0.0138570722,
-0.0228948295,
0.0305826981,
0.0192934256,
-0.0282965712,
-0.0129013183,
-0.04182861,
-0.0214811768,
0.0147788683,
0.0161820464,
-0.0490420237,
0.0027961796,
0.0924452543,
-0.0395802967,
-0.051942993,
-0.0188430846,
0.0173116606,
-0.0270279702,
-0.0479320809,
0.0012823687,
-0.0151345376,
0.0087332902,
0.013268522,
0.0629988685,
0.0006578976,
0.0091642858,
0.0147037162,
-0.0119703421,
0.0690233409,
0.0373257846,
0.0073644863,
0.0232141316,
0.0028427693,
-0.0369418599,
-0.0060308613,
0.0575086884,
0.0062658577,
0.0271914583,
0.0059103551,
-0.0192403626,
-0.0025752827,
-0.024601467,
-0.0227360185,
0.0036478264,
-0.0422894359,
0.0466799513,
0.0315828659,
-0.0425862111,
0.0594064966,
-0.0218903534,
-0.0007442629,
0.0216651391,
0.0546246432,
0.0179453213,
0.0676950216,
0.0292446669,
-0.0013337545,
0.0313591547,
0.0416318737,
-0.0401470773,
0.0026487901,
-0.0151187042,
0.0118337246,
-0.0469127223,
0.0271409433,
0.0187248662,
-0.0096538709,
-0.017489912,
0.0038422728,
0.0343430042,
-0.0438076928,
0.0313053206,
-0.014068312,
-0.0560468584,
-0.013891995,
0.026383847,
-0.0322415978,
-0.0021260548,
-0.0409767181,
-0.0218063127,
0.0915783793,
0.0788209811,
0.0081317546,
0.0176311433,
0.011327114,
-0.0084478101,
0.0432443805,
0.0456567779,
0.0245069843,
0.0051590609,
-0.0561072156,
-0.0248019584,
0.0776677728,
-0.0153058302,
0.0349345841,
0.0528305843,
0.0573683456,
0.0582954623,
0.0038682441,
-0.030553231,
0.0436535366,
-0.0499925651,
-0.0242060293,
-0.0282899551,
0.0053191585,
-0.0088354526,
0.0489320494,
-0.0375306271,
0.0164037365,
-0.0251334254,
-0.0074411258,
-0.0086734304,
0.0474178046,
-0.0606918186,
-0.0800011978,
0.0205952115,
-0.0306353308,
-0.0138963209,
-0.0254312512,
-0.0048134904,
-0.0675559491,
-0.0251745339,
-0.0044443393,
0.0486127473,
-0.0256448742,
0.0524922498,
0.012847825,
0.0278333183,
-0.038239602,
0.0856687352,
0.060445711,
0.017760383,
0.0173465982,
0.006425899,
0.0276545286,
-0.067840673,
-0.0770315006,
-0.0111762527,
0.04115941,
0.012570885,
0.0220465045,
0.0504044741,
-0.0070936196,
-0.0539792217,
-0.079814136,
0.0266919136,
-0.0383614115,
0.0165411588,
0.0098834559,
0.0251171961,
-0.0096143382,
-0.0117795048,
-0.0053780689,
0.0493802354,
-0.0593066327,
-0.0140432091,
0.0068011135,
-0.0185817145,
-0.0096576847,
-0.0033147773,
0.0206640158,
-0.0034762074,
0.0052644731,
0.0564872436,
-0.0950529873,
-0.0198863186,
-0.0235008281,
-0.0290866289,
-0.009470406,
-0.02286705,
-0.0386838391,
-0.0001617455,
-0.0099121341,
0.0390155166,
-0.0054865009,
-0.0045103822,
0.0072208317,
-0.0232587717,
-0.0234793313,
0.0160309821,
0.0035364237,
-0.0260620657,
-0.0605499074,
-0.0031050895,
-0.0251874216,
-0.0433974601,
0.0298849549,
0.0154376943,
0.0295133665,
-0.0736050606,
-0.0396259464,
-0.0345148705,
0.0340693183,
-0.0240958538,
0.0574752651,
-0.0291382931,
-0.0167308208,
-0.0343091153,
0.0044082608,
0.0547920279,
-0.0365074314,
-0.0199186318,
-0.0587417111,
0.0169161912,
-0.0407937095,
0.09735585,
0.0038081466,
0.0315730982,
0.0088414345,
-0.0958108976,
-0.0362342186,
0.0678458661,
0.0513172373,
-0.0397256017,
-0.0034676536,
0.0008601151,
0.037371859,
-0.0554814227,
0.0270094424,
-0.0194789805,
0.0144681623,
-0.0263112485,
0.0242022574,
0.0370830409,
-0.0268122926,
0.003455841,
0.0775866285,
-0.0046661193,
0.0040440308,
-0.0207166318,
0.0178772043,
-0.0218288247,
0.0293674376,
-0.056879539,
0.0462856069,
-0.022347495,
0.0015881343,
0.0509459935,
0.0074642724,
-0.0040997127,
-0.0365647897,
0.0085190265,
-0.0244012084,
-0.008919239,
-0.0202189889,
-0.0577635281,
-0.0312880054,
0.0092921555,
-0.0616124868,
0.0369696096,
0.085639149,
0.0130030522,
-0.0317260586,
-0.0200676899,
-0.0076593105,
-0.0203340389,
-0.0089714546,
-0.0136977639,
-0.0885879919,
-0.0185241252,
0.0106298728,
0.0101097906,
0.0249763038,
-0.0241091829,
-0.0238300394,
-0.0764994249,
0.0326314718,
0.0308192335,
-0.0836307779,
-0.0226116553,
0.001869905,
-0.0225298665,
-0.0261842925,
0.0291964374,
0.0438870937,
-0.0144434143,
-0.0181798488,
-0.0004957843,
0.0186962821,
0.0013509557,
0.0304687228,
-0.0393349379,
0.0182652269,
0.0589819476,
0.0815120041,
0.0023121801,
0.0241952892,
0.0420569777,
0.0101347631,
0.0301143266,
-0.0189775601,
0.0671201721,
0.0083472384,
-0.0093572019,
-0.0004619388,
-0.0388854705,
0.0190382637,
-0.0109304646,
0.0655415207,
-0.0229277872,
-0.0178801212,
-0.0123482915,
0.0808152258,
0.0194313284,
-0.0170175433,
0.0743526891,
-0.0015924626,
0.0252455566,
-0.0516218245,
-0.003739377,
0.0139565505,
-0.0032922532,
-0.0376127772,
0.0280392375,
-0.065796867,
-0.0584454872,
-0.1093187556,
-0.0466432385,
-0.0053043934,
0.0259354282,
0.034296453,
0.0267612077,
-0.0006874166,
0.0809325948,
-0.0318463892,
0.0029775684,
-0.032440234,
0.0135760279,
-0.055096779,
-0.0266330671,
0.0333326682,
-0.0547674783,
0.0217802189,
0.0241990536,
-0.0451727509,
-0.0286547877,
-0.0003570804,
-0.0438385196,
0.0188328139,
0.0099957716,
-0.0380606465,
0.0256660227,
-0.013784443,
0.010118356,
0.0164815262,
-0.0188146215,
0.0008047591,
0.0180030111,
-0.0232436042,
0.0067287986,
0.0288085267,
-0.0041502067,
-0.0201403536,
0.0341018364,
-0.0017416715,
-0.0142655484,
0.0571511164,
0.0482512005,
0.0222865902,
-0.0273613725,
0.0014616362,
-0.0135401133,
0.0111924475,
-0.0243742745,
0.0060602464,
-0.0187958386,
-0.0496169589,
0.0182103552,
-0.0144977979,
0.0094342623,
-0.0293617882,
-0.0116970092,
-0.0077488967,
-0.0141189983,
-0.0110892337,
-0.0262549203,
0.0378841124,
-0.0004978993,
0.0102613205,
-0.0072822729,
0.0147647625,
0.00993241,
0.0442084707,
-0.0274450947,
0.053376954,
0.0069822059,
0.00735371,
0.0310109314,
-0.0045755613,
-0.057421267,
-0.0539906658,
-0.0154817672,
0.0688302964,
0.0682016909,
0.0296788365,
0.0687811077,
-0.0601441376,
-0.0138172396,
-0.0140220104,
0.0408851206,
0.0332670808,
0.0070383092,
-0.0598821715,
-0.0200454276,
-0.0024134757,
-0.019013416,
0.0582814962,
-0.0425881818,
0.0189644545,
0.0401314758,
-0.0473458953,
-0.0055337222,
-0.0240468979,
-0.0011967816,
-0.0292945597,
-0.0086839041,
-0.0001854301,
-0.038910348,
-0.0462417789,
-0.0489901789,
0.0344082788,
0.0022997605,
0.0134178437,
-0.0172461439,
0.0250294432,
-0.0197264235,
-0.0031708281,
-0.0375622697,
0.0238535628,
-0.0055712657,
-0.0081097139,
-0.0266197417,
-5.49943975e-33,
-0.0570527129,
-0.0073022502,
0.0660247877,
0.0341660306,
-0.0266546682,
-0.0284173507,
-0.0605053082,
0.0510893464,
-0.0277481321,
-0.004118246,
-0.0218790453,
-0.0163028929,
0.0287973583,
-0.0183723159,
-0.0358544141,
-0.0266298801,
0.0178384669,
0.0288984124,
-0.0145696783,
0.0434897915,
0.0969804749,
0.0368705317,
0.108483389,
-0.0615015924,
0.016896233,
-0.0168607365,
0.0012003739,
-0.0036431018,
0.0012881518,
0.0255646072,
-0.0052293497,
-0.0217956863,
0.0360767059,
0.0194190852,
-0.0063833003,
-0.0137849394,
-0.1137327626,
0.0003671646,
-0.0209673289,
0.0753591061,
0.0425812602,
0.0206567552,
-0.0082674408,
-0.0524762608,
0.0249818619,
0.013194616,
0.0314051732,
-0.052826114,
-0.0377101824,
0.0121288346,
-0.0585844815,
0.0581064932,
-0.0002014734,
-0.0059345956,
0.010978261,
0.0163508058,
-0.0266141184,
-0.0024464307,
-0.0031088674,
-0.0077785407,
0.0224885195,
0.0320755541,
-0.0214725733,
0.0493176877,
-0.0137712434,
-0.01497442,
0.0465895794,
-0.0168194622,
0.0207799561,
-0.0056479583,
0.0187895428,
-0.0146228047,
-0.0043306556,
0.0392584763,
0.0107840346,
-0.0616798997,
-0.0053010965,
-0.0031894653,
0.0734741688,
0.0071513974,
0.0095891375,
0.0198757276,
-0.0441048294,
-0.0151404692,
0.0069339685,
0.0060176863,
-0.0099336784,
-0.0516627878,
0.0126437452,
-0.0037299846,
-0.0059619509,
-0.0194749869,
0.0517617427,
-0.0444993712,
-0.0060165096,
-0.036979489,
-0.0318804048,
-0.0061654733,
-0.0454972424,
0.0011047273,
-0.0153597165,
-0.0918070152,
0.0360529907,
0.0089874351,
-0.0182383209,
-0.0395137705,
0.02799985,
0.0100689866,
-0.0287882406,
0.003760773,
-0.0227169897,
-0.0380290486,
0.0039485898,
0.000858831,
0.0051313234,
-0.0016850365,
0.0262586772,
-0.0171683785,
0.0852588564,
-0.013279805,
-0.0511838384,
0.0048559336,
-0.0014012539,
-0.0467597991,
-0.0230070222,
0.0457320884,
0.0024072947,
0.005737619,
0.0417268649,
-0.0347569585,
-0.0089158881,
0.0084170206,
2.64e-7,
0.0614161082,
-0.0086229183,
0.049602665,
0.0447022803,
-0.0372647271,
-0.0145477941,
-0.0323587805,
0.0336066484,
0.0022060736,
0.0213006064,
0.0758478567,
0.0016537516,
0.0693567172,
0.0076066488,
-0.0567473248,
-0.0142289149,
-0.0410886668,
-0.0312013943,
-0.038786415,
0.0763834342,
0.0764589012,
0.0886957124,
-0.0304451827,
0.008413922,
-0.0165184997,
-0.0441680141,
0.0524956025,
-0.0047854441,
-0.0023912524,
0.0553395934,
0.0361775681,
0.0272082575,
-0.0237327684,
0.0377687179,
-0.0196595527,
0.0092145372,
0.0671960935,
0.035695143,
-0.0156296659,
0.0254804008,
0.0105165299,
-0.0075000855,
0.0135067217,
-0.0351877138,
0.0287009552,
0.026606936,
0.0231046584,
0.0036114133,
0.0084289201,
0.01658158,
-0.0099448012,
0.0142456722,
-0.0402388833,
0.0428151116,
0.0350207202,
0.0142822759,
-0.0116014434,
-0.0567405336,
-0.0088368794,
-0.0106119839,
-0.0167813804,
-0.0757810995,
0.0170694906,
-0.0548625253,
-0.0007326833,
-0.0092186211,
-0.0355523825,
1.914868588e-34,
-0.01675882,
-0.0384719744,
-0.0157964714,
0.0221620388,
0.0207534283,
-0.0097838603,
0.0615477711,
0.0098642642,
-0.030216502,
-0.0078999698,
-0.0328358784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15291v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15291v2 | Reverse Multi-Choice Dialogue Commonsense Inference with Graph-of-Thought | 2023-12-23T16:18:47 | 2023-12-27T03:30:26 | Li Zheng, Hao Fei, Fei Li, Bobo Li, Lizi Liao, Donghong Ji, Chong Teng | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the proliferation of dialogic data across the Internet, the Dialogue
Commonsense Multi-choice Question Answering (DC-MCQ) task has emerged as a
response to the challenge of comprehending user queries and intentions.
Although prevailing methodologies exhibit effectiveness in addressing
single-choice questions, they encounter difficulties in handling multi-choice
queries due to the heightened intricacy and informational density. In this
paper, inspired by the human cognitive process of progressively excluding
options, we propose a three-step Reverse Exclusion Graph-of-Thought (ReX-GoT)
framework, including Option Exclusion, Error Analysis, and Combine Information.
Specifically, our ReX-GoT mimics human reasoning by gradually excluding
irrelevant options and learning the reasons for option errors to choose the
optimal path of the GoT and ultimately infer the correct answer. By
progressively integrating intricate clues, our method effectively reduces the
difficulty of multi-choice reasoning and provides a novel solution for DC-MCQ.
Extensive experiments on the CICERO and CICERO$_{v2}$ datasets validate the
significant improvement of our approach on DC-MCQ task. On zero-shot setting,
our model outperform the best baseline by 17.67% in terms of F1 score for the
multi-choice task. Most strikingly, our GPT3.5-based ReX-GoT framework achieves
a remarkable 39.44% increase in F1 score. | [
0.0603644811,
0.0524401851,
0.0048967274,
0.0193689279,
-0.0399305671,
0.0177091192,
-0.0336814597,
-0.0026816525,
0.0759307519,
-0.041510582,
0.0057619871,
-0.0024579135,
-0.014412526,
-0.0202995688,
-0.0062539447,
-0.0210520066,
0.0509360954,
-0.0137101356,
-0.0058722314,
-0.0382226519,
-0.0160424765,
0.0287372638,
-0.0210845359,
0.0082781473,
0.0081126112,
-0.0242931023,
-0.0286350418,
-0.0029245452,
0.0271683801,
-0.0178683121,
-0.0064390372,
0.0439086445,
0.0073314374,
0.0297964383,
0.0000019667,
-0.0476561487,
-0.0157919917,
-0.0286938511,
-0.0265292283,
-0.0291253682,
-0.0106040994,
0.080235891,
0.0514946766,
0.0240477789,
-0.0201260112,
0.0321752764,
0.0169439204,
0.0303717684,
0.0442533083,
0.0424940661,
0.0143844113,
-0.0358145759,
-0.0191090237,
0.0097929901,
0.0065884618,
-0.0527372397,
0.01857014,
0.0157571789,
0.0291400906,
-0.0190757681,
-0.0384448506,
0.0258491542,
0.014775564,
0.0405037738,
-0.0553622991,
0.0452853665,
-0.0160312578,
-0.0165370237,
-0.0179434922,
0.1226640642,
0.0501342602,
-0.0235815421,
-0.0061334269,
0.002354458,
0.021932574,
0.0305418819,
-0.0457501896,
-0.0091651343,
-0.0210224837,
0.0000134795,
-0.0016268028,
-0.0238926318,
-0.0027924725,
0.0504713953,
-0.0094772382,
0.0651889443,
0.0050704074,
-0.0243089404,
0.0325487033,
0.0322790779,
-0.05059053,
-0.0398463458,
0.0031674872,
0.0418783203,
-0.0780091733,
0.009934389,
-0.0106793707,
-0.0352892354,
0.0102347294,
0.0000589601,
0.0309891962,
0.030065326,
-0.0089457743,
0.0424213,
0.0097833509,
0.0141840605,
-0.0275657084,
0.0388604254,
-0.0354141742,
-0.0220096409,
-0.0312692709,
0.0007017897,
-0.045489829,
0.0792405829,
-0.038115114,
-0.0063866526,
-0.0057131182,
0.0230555162,
0.0036251189,
-0.0128156738,
0.0200386718,
0.0569448695,
-0.0081265802,
-0.0069325077,
-0.0717624351,
0.0666206926,
-0.0603439696,
0.0450831167,
0.0490878671,
0.0032745795,
-0.0241929274,
0.0140687972,
0.0514686666,
-0.0347366855,
0.023220161,
0.0310245994,
-0.0103815785,
0.0010206428,
0.0035206217,
-0.0382500924,
0.0062247701,
-0.0382112823,
0.0037312079,
-0.0559886284,
0.0229619928,
0.015351492,
-0.0176539477,
0.0098417001,
0.0106780455,
0.0423726104,
-0.0240792334,
0.0673672631,
-0.0315961987,
-0.0158819035,
0.025915768,
0.000956045,
-0.0380215049,
0.0518574938,
-0.0046592196,
-0.0166207384,
0.0418403707,
0.0273441579,
0.0109639708,
-0.0013905492,
0.0426288173,
0.0001692798,
0.0240036547,
0.041611746,
-0.0625610724,
0.0248409137,
0.0282513779,
0.0215937905,
-0.0480233952,
-0.0446467735,
0.0304566156,
0.0661447272,
-0.0575879216,
-0.0091273282,
0.0100601446,
0.0263367835,
0.0085151037,
0.062375892,
-0.0339928754,
0.0260309018,
-0.03689171,
0.005703303,
-0.0030229816,
0.0059655108,
-0.0233990885,
0.0106713772,
0.0259616915,
-0.002605736,
0.0660959035,
0.0364908166,
0.0354091637,
-0.0203873105,
-0.0469364002,
0.0364572071,
0.0288352463,
-0.0440879129,
-0.0351087265,
-0.0400891751,
0.0119775347,
0.0138953039,
0.0676404908,
0.00452339,
-0.0839395598,
-0.0023500801,
-0.0067947274,
0.022491686,
0.0351458043,
-0.0100896535,
0.0162389278,
-0.0387881957,
-0.0050456058,
0.052931048,
-0.0233421233,
0.0014074077,
0.0098235346,
-0.018570805,
-0.0122619681,
-0.0170011446,
0.0455913916,
-0.0237059761,
0.0147895869,
0.0134100169,
-0.0003689802,
0.006099063,
0.0695606843,
-0.0004635972,
0.0203975849,
0.0028822769,
-0.0039118612,
0.0276325382,
-0.0449648872,
0.010528964,
-0.0312952138,
-0.0991040692,
0.043679703,
-0.0381709263,
-0.0597743765,
0.0565007254,
-0.041694466,
-0.045697771,
0.0254158396,
-0.0461148955,
0.0380334295,
-0.0373627096,
-0.056581486,
0.0448542535,
-0.0427536368,
-0.0116368895,
0.106160976,
-0.0333874077,
0.0203564595,
0.0224738363,
-0.0396803617,
0.0169468503,
-0.0570796058,
0.0056304755,
-0.0234873798,
-0.0182411354,
0.0008994205,
0.0095179761,
0.0379768163,
-0.0819882601,
0.0388450548,
-0.1086526364,
0.0066920314,
0.017708905,
0.0200240277,
-0.0042677796,
0.0323503911,
0.001654151,
-0.0431352146,
-0.0574163571,
0.0402964801,
0.0064872825,
0.0104886359,
0.0293471441,
-0.030306939,
-0.0016629044,
0.0016363205,
-0.003228531,
-0.0351791382,
0.0146046095,
-0.0333487764,
0.0225070361,
0.0300404318,
0.0139325354,
-0.0744812265,
0.0430254042,
-0.0127776768,
-0.0376216806,
0.0175561365,
-0.0094038425,
-0.0063429889,
0.0429748334,
-0.0050049415,
-0.0352107547,
0.0048233615,
-0.0258408356,
-0.0487531833,
0.0405673906,
-0.0397023745,
0.0009303392,
0.0126410797,
0.010457607,
-0.034837503,
0.0231868308,
0.0244556051,
0.0038635889,
-0.0507605448,
-0.0127539104,
0.017018728,
-0.0074579036,
-0.0497835316,
0.0258558095,
-0.0183202624,
0.0400851779,
-0.0235341415,
0.0179205723,
0.1223179549,
0.0219563674,
0.0140019897,
-0.0838724822,
0.0182346702,
-0.0110822609,
0.0045108427,
-0.0162327215,
0.0111524789,
0.026157964,
-0.0212868787,
-0.065756157,
-0.0507467277,
0.0478045046,
-0.0314603113,
0.0402919725,
-0.0485726781,
0.0182071906,
-0.0018130246,
-0.0371860713,
-0.0140486835,
-0.0826398283,
-0.0095500145,
0.0136894202,
-0.0058574467,
-0.0128480466,
-0.0284773987,
-0.0262894668,
0.0098009119,
0.0089538908,
-0.0013673708,
-0.0025827351,
-0.0213010367,
0.0723882169,
0.0712131783,
0.060313724,
0.009904121,
0.0330495499,
0.0067130122,
0.060273923,
0.0466021337,
-0.0220561288,
0.0347053185,
0.0106077092,
0.0206095353,
-0.0020738733,
-0.0119434427,
0.001708107,
0.1067099124,
0.0025078892,
-0.0327137411,
0.0784686953,
0.0406515971,
-0.0205307752,
-0.0275359508,
-0.0040393667,
0.0528145246,
0.0036525512,
0.0072541418,
-0.0806429237,
-0.0640041232,
0.0077788951,
0.0375002138,
-0.0232332833,
-0.0768015087,
0.0376580358,
-0.1235500947,
-0.0038901307,
-0.0233223476,
-0.0473683551,
0.0091416268,
-0.0638400614,
0.0107700704,
0.0046630101,
-0.0454245433,
0.0059937951,
0.0171571542,
0.0081914673,
0.0263118092,
-0.0002196522,
-0.0015624773,
0.0458156727,
-0.0054650703,
-0.0018516498,
0.0158744343,
0.0465755016,
0.0177555736,
-0.0300189368,
0.0043007387,
-0.0680734143,
-0.0171272866,
-0.0452809408,
0.009048203,
0.010219031,
-0.0095633511,
-0.0782019049,
0.0685979202,
-0.0359092653,
-0.0434582196,
0.0068880278,
0.0988333076,
-0.0298662204,
0.0048588216,
-0.0130153699,
0.0262319185,
0.0031701,
0.0706977993,
0.0386277661,
-0.0064669233,
-0.0487286896,
-0.0482090265,
-0.0190971605,
-0.0426196866,
0.0107829925,
0.0032973541,
0.0248150062,
0.0205685142,
-0.0397061221,
-0.0539693683,
0.0253805686,
0.0191765353,
-0.0565775782,
-0.0088156508,
0.0113130994,
0.0332675613,
-0.0057651075,
0.0070596999,
-0.0395221226,
0.0010088397,
-0.0021646477,
0.0312471539,
0.0173444785,
0.0041282596,
-0.0345640481,
0.0787532553,
-0.0546566173,
-0.0420600325,
-0.048147209,
0.0451252647,
0.0169229489,
0.0140785556,
-0.0321160853,
-0.000411467,
0.034030851,
0.0242145304,
-0.0072652949,
-0.0062999036,
0.0307537969,
0.0447536744,
0.0075361626,
0.0485770553,
-0.0273205489,
-0.0337620899,
-0.0114078419,
0.0623807684,
-0.0479295067,
-0.0300064776,
0.0239757169,
0.0189653169,
0.0050801695,
-0.0050229309,
0.0452229604,
-0.0321597271,
0.0009078495,
-0.0284521449,
-0.0325446688,
-0.0085640345,
0.0092262579,
0.0156519152,
-0.0645557269,
-0.0111801615,
-0.0339535028,
-0.0418542922,
0.0376834683,
-0.0220568888,
-0.0106660323,
0.1158753708,
0.0051305005,
0.0112460116,
-0.0501186512,
-0.0371680893,
-0.03198535,
0.0282812975,
0.037562713,
-0.0081530521,
0.1170132384,
0.0400637649,
-0.0548216142,
-0.0181622077,
-0.0232001524,
-0.0769959986,
-0.0169144515,
-0.0011397547,
0.0360143892,
0.0151870642,
0.0369061716,
0.018733304,
0.0211984515,
-0.0142380074,
0.0034647326,
0.0522282794,
0.0058845715,
-0.0033689965,
0.0748105571,
0.0211499054,
-0.0033643988,
0.0013225607,
0.0626011789,
-0.0256285686,
0.0075325542,
-0.0053931386,
-0.0456447452,
-0.0269637071,
-0.0436612964,
-0.0437470637,
0.0736750513,
0.0095729781,
0.0433207452,
-0.0738624111,
-0.0658733919,
-0.0148298498,
-0.0026852912,
0.0225327667,
-0.0063251005,
0.0453179888,
0.0339522734,
0.0389661305,
-0.0901659653,
-0.0160637852,
0.0477506034,
-0.0681439415,
-0.0246498156,
-0.0345382281,
-6.56800636e-33,
-0.0222568363,
-0.043672964,
0.022896139,
-0.0021716659,
-0.0079494687,
-0.0331815854,
-0.0451874435,
-0.0183508229,
-0.0532664359,
0.017077757,
-0.0107332896,
0.0100681046,
0.0003861499,
0.0547245294,
-0.0140934214,
-0.0284198429,
-0.0033384508,
-0.0127237514,
-0.0214544851,
-0.0026210924,
0.0736065283,
-0.0050497814,
0.0471029393,
-0.0055106184,
0.0151362065,
-0.0140846986,
0.0079733264,
0.0387413427,
-0.036812067,
0.0666068047,
-0.0078304466,
0.0525339581,
0.0198306385,
-0.0077141132,
0.0285096895,
0.0310106557,
-0.0874260366,
-0.0799263343,
0.0503331013,
-0.0202232506,
-0.0232783519,
0.0059464052,
0.0024907268,
0.0021843035,
0.0345835239,
-0.0322449952,
0.0155013306,
0.0042317091,
-0.0242174882,
0.0017374714,
0.0118652657,
0.0130925765,
-0.0254961401,
-0.0503782965,
-0.0573134124,
0.0708467215,
-0.010486397,
-0.0053745755,
-0.0646261349,
0.0011478195,
-0.0122407563,
-0.036069259,
0.0244609099,
-0.0159934554,
0.0062085707,
0.0373303965,
-0.0284177419,
-0.0693758503,
-0.0403623804,
-0.0232720394,
-0.0168059561,
0.0417687446,
0.0258991048,
0.0560268313,
-0.0008907296,
0.0057525765,
-0.1073528454,
0.0266417805,
0.005306344,
0.0542884246,
-0.0042948574,
0.0012127325,
-0.0259582102,
-0.029081393,
-0.0379301533,
-0.0389812253,
-0.0319192372,
0.0044900533,
0.0236190632,
-0.021348007,
-0.0154214026,
0.0053881668,
0.0402157605,
-0.0381378569,
-0.0097298473,
0.0413876772,
-0.0219725668,
0.0117961718,
0.0187060051,
0.0393268541,
-0.0335208662,
0.0173948724,
0.0265426412,
0.0230526775,
-0.0270363223,
0.0180550944,
0.037231911,
-0.0113835558,
-0.0115307113,
-0.0188766867,
-0.047070466,
-0.0039790096,
-0.0512444228,
-0.0129300384,
0.0483789407,
0.0162659194,
0.0056489985,
0.039459493,
0.0142688965,
0.0242787264,
-0.0176839828,
-0.0035026625,
0.0210039467,
0.0095175225,
-0.0111747421,
0.0091341799,
0.0035545325,
-0.0436414368,
-0.0175587237,
-0.0319861211,
-0.0133876093,
0.0479934216,
2.658e-7,
0.0185272153,
0.0031574983,
0.0293834154,
0.0382162146,
0.0137846293,
0.0783854797,
0.0174495261,
0.0151570262,
0.0435729921,
-0.0356485918,
0.0324796587,
0.0468369052,
0.0294127911,
0.0544200279,
-0.0533955432,
-0.0234394278,
-0.0567338392,
-0.0601322949,
-0.0239974409,
-0.031131465,
0.0675319433,
0.0389711857,
0.0392424203,
-0.032315962,
-0.0248334948,
0.0026217939,
0.0218982436,
0.0044668098,
-0.0380068272,
-0.0307023544,
0.0250515249,
-0.0291787162,
0.0276184883,
0.0478052497,
0.0075405738,
-0.0071123079,
0.0178395957,
0.0215830971,
-0.02616092,
-0.0848761797,
-0.0027197211,
-0.0446871892,
0.0420449823,
-0.0587453619,
0.0863418058,
-0.0388081074,
-0.0115434118,
-0.0082361801,
-0.0413001962,
-0.0025203167,
0.0168339368,
-0.0164208021,
-0.0074722483,
-0.0137075894,
-0.0000785871,
0.0165908709,
-0.001615377,
-0.0589542724,
0.0258197989,
0.0393396877,
-0.0162156075,
-0.0487977825,
0.0080399578,
-0.0241821297,
0.0367482007,
-0.053948883,
-0.005853028,
2.173741373e-34,
0.0155795515,
-0.0035717816,
0.0042650644,
0.0224571675,
0.0399430208,
0.0001785265,
0.0039183525,
-0.0207638666,
0.0560050718,
-0.0788720846,
-0.014327799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15272v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15272v1 | Detecting anxiety from short clips of free-form speech | 2023-12-23T14:44:17 | 2023-12-23T14:44:17 | Prabhat Agarwal, Akshat Jindal, Shreya Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Barriers to accessing mental health assessments including cost and stigma
continues to be an impediment in mental health diagnosis and treatment. Machine
learning approaches based on speech samples could help in this direction. In
this work, we develop machine learning solutions to diagnose anxiety disorders
from audio journals of patients. We work on a novel anxiety dataset (provided
through collaboration with Kintsugi Mindful Wellness Inc.) and experiment with
several models of varying complexity utilizing audio, text and a combination of
multiple modalities. We show that the multi-modal and audio embeddings based
approaches achieve good performance in the task achieving an AUC ROC score of
0.68-0.69. | [
-0.0184213165,
0.0514306724,
-0.0109061981,
-0.0103211487,
0.0108298734,
0.0287377201,
0.0402003266,
0.011316197,
0.0010789357,
-0.0302821267,
-0.0179972816,
-0.019790696,
-0.0179264471,
0.0147318831,
-0.0191219375,
-0.0497360379,
0.0093455277,
0.0462567918,
0.0667581186,
0.0071552624,
0.0080861226,
0.0143423053,
-0.0550382696,
0.0499958955,
-0.0332624577,
-0.023306692,
0.0068128668,
0.0000775335,
0.03815341,
-0.0887920037,
-0.033236295,
0.017344242,
0.0175282061,
0.036848478,
0.000001897,
-0.0074032578,
-0.0002312219,
0.0062017376,
-0.0052870512,
-0.0550990254,
0.0320092253,
-0.0293793473,
0.0259724818,
0.0318920389,
-0.013153364,
-0.0549777821,
0.0268605892,
0.0812443867,
0.0631324947,
0.0651479512,
-0.0459473021,
-0.009896813,
0.0249711014,
-0.009030031,
0.0027600783,
-0.0365603268,
0.0375643037,
-0.0402751267,
0.0176938009,
-0.0325216129,
-0.0188004784,
0.0292142872,
-0.0383492336,
0.0523218587,
0.0210845526,
-0.0034287805,
-0.0134503152,
-0.0347522832,
-0.0169819798,
0.0861171558,
0.0081407418,
0.0383093171,
0.0054537174,
0.014249038,
0.0206734017,
0.0395328179,
-0.0272436254,
-0.0060092495,
0.0099392422,
0.0293503162,
0.0153245786,
0.025226824,
0.0158939939,
-0.0420527011,
0.0183862299,
0.0289199781,
-0.0296515338,
-0.0344581529,
0.043259535,
-0.0366965309,
-0.0184934661,
-0.029291695,
0.0141987102,
0.0088957017,
-0.0292852502,
0.0014015568,
-0.0293464288,
-0.0609104708,
-0.0129775451,
0.0255309362,
-0.0233329087,
0.0014324845,
-0.0579664409,
0.0067091454,
0.0265128464,
-0.0230893828,
0.0330901779,
0.0100897625,
0.0071966327,
0.0197167043,
-0.0460982844,
0.0484176651,
-0.0157713369,
-0.0023563129,
0.0128779234,
-0.0548935644,
-0.0801264197,
-0.028611565,
-0.0384503603,
0.0324532874,
0.0012693007,
-0.0014681056,
0.0656246394,
0.0577115491,
0.0661939979,
-0.0156478453,
-0.0004847719,
0.0446294472,
-0.0087540308,
-0.0280178096,
0.0243468601,
-0.0052677672,
0.0193379167,
-0.0159200057,
0.0184572879,
0.0232315864,
0.0644655749,
-0.0207686275,
-0.0235788208,
-0.0137423109,
-0.0442296676,
-0.0178153124,
0.004534414,
-0.0188554041,
0.0188894253,
-0.0309953094,
0.0355404355,
-0.0385129452,
-0.0045140078,
-0.0266645849,
-0.0257931612,
0.0774259791,
-0.0006853927,
0.0136111742,
0.0188508108,
0.0316700153,
0.0251527429,
0.0341902561,
0.0697440282,
-0.0490994453,
0.0633019879,
-0.059118174,
0.0307223741,
-0.0058372575,
0.0088739963,
-0.0636741892,
0.0298230872,
-0.055136729,
-0.0316704661,
0.0392081477,
-0.035625454,
0.0291861165,
0.0204282533,
-0.0263232999,
0.0123568662,
0.0866967291,
0.0320203789,
-0.0245506298,
-0.0025756655,
0.0407312401,
-0.0257197898,
-0.0270916224,
0.022198813,
-0.0210810062,
-0.0227312073,
-0.0348418914,
0.0317360274,
-0.0289918222,
-0.0338233933,
-0.0320411772,
-0.0699071735,
-0.028269086,
-0.0434476137,
0.0233254302,
-0.0062744999,
-0.0353381038,
-0.0161989592,
-0.005560752,
0.0003468679,
-0.0181948636,
-0.0462178327,
-0.0117919352,
0.0239435527,
0.0075818365,
-0.0045928815,
-0.0778291374,
0.044261381,
-0.0441215523,
0.0010681758,
-0.0191880222,
0.0173826069,
-0.0040570069,
0.0291797072,
-0.0452665165,
0.0176844727,
0.0295248665,
0.0382174812,
-0.0193668678,
-0.0578650013,
0.0511598736,
-0.0328331552,
-0.0199560225,
0.0360092632,
0.0436973013,
-0.0060915523,
-0.0635925904,
0.0222074483,
0.0268178396,
0.0704154596,
0.026474908,
-0.0291427448,
-0.0106254257,
0.0089117484,
-0.0279962737,
-0.0326512642,
0.0259403884,
-0.0328151211,
-0.0088517461,
0.0120694321,
0.0042576077,
0.0388029926,
0.054154247,
-0.0515353791,
-0.0285322201,
0.0103585543,
-0.0276642591,
0.0353304818,
-0.0019905812,
-0.01102133,
0.0109747741,
0.0617898516,
-0.0146264117,
-0.0030180647,
-0.0062980205,
0.0261968505,
-0.0065117204,
-0.0434898734,
0.0006681954,
0.0125544239,
-0.0681565702,
-0.038634792,
-0.0201433897,
0.0045454972,
-0.0571901612,
-0.0550319403,
-0.0104027139,
0.0011326283,
-0.1100052372,
0.0066304286,
0.0020541043,
-0.0405995585,
-0.0046883514,
-0.0275264699,
-0.0044130259,
-0.0203365348,
-0.0329254568,
0.0178915225,
0.0564153269,
0.0534466878,
-0.0020396584,
0.0025772247,
-0.009695203,
-0.0376179144,
-0.0010631124,
-0.050670512,
0.0270070378,
-0.0041361125,
-0.0021379213,
-0.0349262208,
0.0305988267,
-0.0119615728,
0.015736701,
0.0163659398,
0.0043848096,
-0.0286058523,
0.004005821,
0.0100009413,
0.0445188284,
-0.002448743,
0.0613074191,
0.0393512025,
0.0194251258,
-0.0022048368,
0.0176254045,
0.017307071,
0.0203661975,
-0.0345031433,
-0.0164796617,
-0.0219003744,
0.0526766255,
0.0525959283,
0.007549901,
-0.0050910474,
0.002601716,
0.0050281677,
0.0071545276,
-0.029162094,
-0.0344199315,
0.0006847784,
0.0360555686,
0.0198819339,
-0.0238074064,
0.0418059081,
-0.0101996148,
-0.0313633122,
-0.0480261222,
-0.0659268573,
-0.0125612216,
0.0183182023,
-0.0225005224,
0.0197470095,
0.0350339524,
0.0102529814,
0.0207745582,
-0.0463654399,
-0.0261744298,
-0.0616568811,
-0.019535657,
-0.0027387955,
-0.0436394364,
0.0221794564,
-0.0410372615,
-0.071637325,
-0.0382672176,
-0.0324790962,
-0.0067591653,
-0.0278258473,
0.0122265806,
-0.0673193261,
0.0167892873,
0.0159454178,
0.027758481,
0.009038643,
-0.0283186231,
0.0383414701,
0.0855933577,
0.0654883757,
-0.0063153733,
0.0083467579,
-0.0147647187,
0.0414417423,
0.0272863358,
0.0228520259,
0.0707801804,
0.0000793328,
0.019851042,
-0.0217786357,
0.0130526852,
-0.0067248368,
0.0299238563,
-0.0194365587,
-0.0010618703,
0.0052418299,
0.1304032356,
0.0410613455,
-0.0492340736,
0.0203462001,
-0.014804801,
-0.0268766005,
0.0102940397,
-0.0017277519,
-0.0495038144,
-0.0166148432,
0.0139470296,
0.0620871969,
0.0018713622,
0.0037223634,
0.0248826873,
-0.0406064577,
0.055559136,
-0.0263733082,
-0.012552307,
-0.0020229495,
-0.0399970748,
0.026440395,
-0.0278250668,
-0.0076364931,
-0.0886126608,
-0.0132004954,
-0.0102860192,
0.0128356405,
-0.1168741211,
-0.0655124187,
0.0544434115,
0.0025568872,
0.0628404841,
-0.0099828597,
0.0788447112,
-0.0140548497,
-0.063441284,
-0.0178235341,
0.0312395561,
-0.0245616976,
0.0002575558,
0.0910882428,
-0.0148776267,
0.0056566438,
0.0135797933,
0.0615897924,
-0.0538601205,
0.006453468,
0.0156198926,
0.0991213322,
-0.0157516189,
-0.0098243477,
-0.0512592457,
0.0482725762,
0.0386993922,
0.0574132018,
0.0140404422,
-0.0460137948,
0.0046351934,
0.0236272756,
0.0414665863,
0.0065536532,
-0.0186242107,
0.0365499631,
0.0121447286,
-0.0739175603,
-0.0425065793,
-0.0522388555,
0.0158799365,
-0.0025389816,
0.0219958443,
-0.056576822,
0.0002296326,
0.0331032351,
-0.0955080613,
0.0357816145,
0.0625668243,
0.0190382805,
-0.0144073479,
0.0172053762,
0.0614025295,
0.0180193763,
-0.0329436064,
0.0028399096,
-0.0331788398,
-0.0108024934,
0.0369675979,
-0.0243948139,
0.010972078,
0.0033167957,
0.0016273068,
0.0195194148,
0.0379335992,
-0.0200742744,
-0.0707713589,
0.0166162197,
0.061098095,
-0.0133398268,
-0.0168898478,
0.0457212254,
-0.011976962,
0.0583533235,
0.0041272147,
-0.0444040857,
-0.020436693,
-0.0108438637,
-0.015025923,
0.0082089324,
0.0363562442,
0.0199270248,
-0.0304525569,
-0.0271276589,
-0.015225078,
0.0100891981,
0.0161268301,
-0.0270697754,
-0.040018294,
0.0285371207,
-0.0239932723,
-0.0538681783,
-0.0286138188,
-0.0091356533,
-0.0323427171,
-0.0553323664,
0.0709738582,
0.0078918384,
-0.0003711699,
-0.0215589385,
0.0202765726,
0.0207589213,
0.0151645867,
-0.0065518902,
0.0069785439,
0.0261145979,
0.0668042302,
-0.0197753571,
0.0347298644,
0.0322514661,
0.0446778163,
-0.041417256,
-0.0386984982,
-0.0118752029,
-0.0511112213,
0.0282668155,
-0.0498610623,
0.0458181202,
0.0148706893,
0.0152500197,
-0.0243717283,
0.0098474752,
-0.0793186948,
-0.0195966717,
0.042877879,
0.0066429479,
-0.008059442,
0.0296848882,
0.0567569658,
-0.0359882042,
0.0267316326,
-0.002867521,
-0.0477838926,
-0.0645908788,
0.0224909764,
0.0360053554,
0.0717329308,
-0.0019167071,
0.0119880429,
-0.0325014107,
-0.0592147335,
0.0414061807,
-0.068625994,
0.0145875579,
0.0176776461,
0.0084709385,
0.0206786226,
-0.0025273189,
0.0171566028,
-0.0306558628,
-0.0095660342,
-0.0435189754,
-0.0569760092,
-0.0017195698,
-5.005626329e-33,
-0.0000307333,
0.0159485806,
-0.0305401385,
-0.003076629,
0.0181572158,
0.0460180677,
-0.0042255074,
0.0263668839,
0.0064268368,
-0.0010546505,
0.0074177319,
0.0407518111,
0.0061411466,
0.0585479736,
0.0267976914,
0.0001416659,
0.0477812253,
-0.0494790934,
0.0070920032,
-0.0177058261,
0.0100348685,
0.0612912551,
0.0342700928,
-0.1239258274,
-0.0214800891,
0.035824284,
-0.0135585237,
-0.0407391861,
0.0290182997,
0.0349050052,
-0.0384062342,
0.0463935025,
0.0305845309,
0.004942839,
0.0212998223,
0.048530627,
-0.0482170023,
0.0001530294,
-0.0520344041,
0.0222236793,
-0.0479332507,
0.0102750296,
0.0199108589,
-0.0111262063,
0.0225383919,
-0.0414642096,
0.0671225786,
-0.048759263,
0.0289894864,
-0.0375121832,
-0.0100365803,
-0.0014025557,
-0.0387912989,
-0.0397714265,
0.0537491292,
0.0578925945,
-0.0065275119,
0.0005323698,
-0.0390759893,
0.0074044024,
-0.035572499,
0.0023054942,
-0.002917676,
-0.0346298888,
-0.0461842492,
0.053876508,
0.0372560024,
-0.0918804109,
0.0082701435,
0.0241877846,
-0.0135828387,
0.0587863699,
0.0305541158,
-0.0301871151,
0.0109626632,
-0.0089812707,
-0.0389644206,
0.0171617083,
-0.0174588338,
-0.0192191973,
0.0533909723,
-0.0059475857,
-0.0233251974,
0.0148581108,
-0.0237029009,
0.0000925544,
-0.0202129781,
0.0004407604,
0.0469323918,
0.0103651453,
0.0023155108,
-0.0005572079,
0.0008386401,
-0.04685276,
-0.0170510411,
0.0114325928,
-0.0039409823,
0.0392430909,
0.009278588,
-0.0299773104,
0.0001727386,
0.0229815822,
0.0705016181,
0.0247965716,
0.0860737413,
-0.0376157835,
0.0318040773,
0.0120041938,
-0.0828805789,
-0.0305866022,
0.0570459701,
0.0207671411,
0.002468653,
0.1217449307,
-0.016762333,
0.0182279944,
-0.0323131755,
0.0325419754,
-0.0343010426,
0.0069807153,
-0.0527740419,
-0.0505671948,
-0.0214919467,
0.0057732514,
-0.0369245559,
-0.0467963107,
-0.0128514143,
-0.0159042086,
0.0575692579,
-0.0418604761,
0.0317446999,
-0.0439873785,
2.69e-7,
0.0010118799,
0.0242559928,
-0.0098694582,
-0.0422828421,
0.03968063,
0.0133172404,
0.0019581686,
0.0461865515,
-0.0159246214,
-0.0206477065,
0.0320879258,
0.0083137145,
0.0493927039,
0.0645115897,
-0.029609777,
-0.0552916378,
-0.0530724153,
0.0308613423,
-0.0514404997,
0.0002513398,
0.0891091377,
0.117744647,
0.033652205,
-0.0330784842,
0.0213047192,
0.0146053648,
0.0052065072,
-0.0091764862,
0.021365745,
-0.0157281104,
0.0006414508,
0.0234990846,
0.0043584253,
0.0106173428,
-0.0158095732,
0.0056613516,
0.0010137556,
0.0272718687,
-0.0332623869,
-0.038164638,
-0.0093149785,
0.0838647559,
-0.0361571945,
0.0184816252,
0.0526411049,
-0.0341472812,
-0.0551175214,
-0.0523955077,
-0.0250706673,
-0.0236634146,
0.0819942951,
0.0069253873,
0.0170414671,
0.0202581733,
0.0177582987,
-0.0049176444,
0.0115337875,
-0.0872648731,
-0.0008906947,
0.0560998283,
-0.0552871898,
0.031498678,
0.024772374,
-0.049258966,
-0.0029463987,
-0.0830900222,
-0.0105501721,
2.264838052e-34,
0.0004339765,
0.0327839963,
-0.0019198653,
0.0027833856,
-0.0001114987,
-0.0226962157,
-0.0376988649,
-0.0292476136,
-0.0146055259,
-0.0798573121,
-0.0137600796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15228v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15228v2 | Adversarial Data Poisoning for Fake News Detection: How to Make a Model Misclassify a Target News without Modifying It | 2023-12-23T11:37:09 | 2024-01-04T16:20:42 | Federico Siciliano, Luca Maiano, Lorenzo Papa, Federica Baccini, Irene Amerini, Fabrizio Silvestri | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | Fake news detection models are critical to countering disinformation but can
be manipulated through adversarial attacks. In this position paper, we analyze
how an attacker can compromise the performance of an online learning detector
on specific news content without being able to manipulate the original target
news. In some contexts, such as social networks, where the attacker cannot
exert complete control over all the information, this scenario can indeed be
quite plausible. Therefore, we show how an attacker could potentially introduce
poisoning data into the training data to manipulate the behavior of an online
learning method. Our initial findings reveal varying susceptibility of logistic
regression models based on complexity and attack type. | [
0.037988387,
0.0614047721,
-0.0163083822,
0.0390404835,
-0.0165584311,
0.0155744953,
0.0070665167,
-0.0214588866,
0.0296005756,
-0.0240362361,
0.0157336984,
0.0087274071,
0.0270182192,
0.0527098738,
0.0501149483,
-0.0032241326,
0.0690012872,
0.0381231233,
-0.018590387,
-0.0300051924,
0.0184875969,
-0.0139948027,
0.0048702485,
-0.0142929796,
-0.01977483,
-0.0329900682,
-0.0064066802,
0.0102016032,
0.0159931239,
0.0111345975,
-0.013855339,
0.0185423698,
-0.0106900129,
0.0775665417,
0.0000016186,
-0.0014135709,
-0.0319306403,
0.0153435329,
-0.0328111574,
0.017182054,
0.0069117756,
-0.0920612067,
0.0021367697,
0.056867253,
-0.0370202772,
-0.0234120041,
0.0148845697,
0.0708117932,
0.0559352748,
0.1416029632,
-0.0144901965,
0.0173681285,
0.0565234795,
-0.0208085887,
0.00242575,
0.0031799311,
0.0141645884,
-0.007133184,
-0.0694917515,
0.0109996106,
0.007815998,
0.0218008496,
0.0171266831,
0.0267361775,
-0.0275197607,
-0.0040774448,
0.0030002703,
-0.0180382505,
0.0070204157,
-0.013213777,
-0.0980769545,
-0.0241387822,
0.0287442524,
0.0042172046,
0.0511584505,
0.0210397784,
0.0209852159,
0.0053745694,
-0.0279184598,
0.0020235698,
0.0020345734,
-0.0561393127,
0.0522300117,
0.023487417,
0.0200814437,
0.0276086498,
-0.0172321741,
0.0158114918,
0.0041616103,
0.0050999424,
0.0062865065,
-0.0043555261,
0.0258023702,
-0.0190493111,
-0.0071201161,
-0.0020169069,
-0.1042938232,
-0.0065085497,
-0.0062207575,
-0.1014812738,
0.0300495941,
-0.0251390524,
0.0450610369,
0.0295834299,
0.017691059,
-0.0325730368,
-0.0233560726,
0.0428392179,
0.0003095943,
0.0273696613,
-0.0054066796,
0.0011967521,
0.0162559506,
0.0202589557,
0.0056766211,
-0.0017930374,
-0.0344434083,
0.0367965065,
-0.0290359668,
0.0396664292,
-0.045154199,
0.0192101989,
-0.0332839601,
0.0329424366,
0.0143852364,
-0.0063124551,
0.0316490941,
0.0115065426,
-0.0256524328,
-0.0477290824,
-0.0158410966,
0.0057248883,
-0.0361012742,
0.0220762827,
-0.0285526626,
0.04495278,
0.0043998947,
-0.0143037736,
-0.0527215265,
-0.096840404,
-0.0211904272,
0.0028613878,
0.017258605,
-0.0234716833,
-0.033254426,
-0.0251428466,
-0.0119313309,
-0.0571062341,
-0.0194820706,
-0.0098251356,
-0.0469309762,
0.0710057095,
0.029715918,
-0.007565984,
0.0285491645,
0.0149128679,
-0.0355519466,
0.0904720724,
0.0028508578,
0.0955717117,
0.0671639666,
0.0095992228,
0.0357545726,
0.0198715646,
0.0748952702,
0.0225142837,
0.0180834997,
-0.0118846288,
-0.0124897473,
-0.0189140961,
-0.0190067794,
-0.0117623983,
0.0007449658,
-0.0514407977,
0.1089258194,
-0.0686216205,
0.0094335051,
0.0435172617,
0.0023534265,
0.0170512088,
-0.008672623,
0.011091359,
-0.0418084972,
-0.0092294645,
-0.0982643291,
-0.0503882691,
-0.0350933,
0.0306747835,
-0.0138909705,
-0.0357848927,
0.0209631305,
-0.0119394809,
0.0203616545,
0.0029784711,
-0.0169896837,
0.0204051957,
-0.0076457681,
-0.0138635524,
0.0044124001,
0.0208472423,
0.0245120395,
-0.0364935584,
-0.0253346767,
0.0064724479,
0.053576488,
0.0008269704,
0.0243240278,
-0.0592645667,
0.0140871955,
0.0029830318,
0.0493015535,
-0.0247885101,
-0.0315351337,
0.0262159575,
0.0096489619,
-0.0128032248,
0.0125864828,
-0.0038168295,
0.037929412,
0.0314713046,
-0.0245420057,
0.0209264737,
-0.036612384,
0.0047346568,
-0.0062286663,
-0.0398953073,
-0.0136076165,
0.0431992672,
0.0378518589,
0.0071692173,
0.000080234,
-0.0007726331,
0.049836766,
0.0301040728,
-0.0429335535,
-0.0516636819,
0.0405479409,
-0.005375558,
-0.0128891803,
-0.0470911562,
-0.0034079039,
0.0931978449,
-0.0332878605,
0.0642618313,
0.0437422879,
-0.0262532495,
0.0043923617,
0.0097185746,
-0.0351275019,
-0.0044773156,
0.0387446135,
0.0260361154,
0.0367437787,
-0.0607167818,
-0.0097576752,
-0.0339720771,
-0.0037954033,
0.0015860213,
-0.0133379381,
-0.0165673569,
-0.0125865471,
-0.0345105305,
0.0228783917,
-0.0028733141,
-0.0940904394,
0.009799799,
-0.0047639799,
0.0062420717,
-0.0387341119,
-0.0341939256,
-0.0101556284,
0.0227157287,
-0.0077772359,
0.0000760729,
-0.0153605221,
-0.0199513268,
-0.0076672016,
-0.0145255644,
0.0404781513,
-0.0264052562,
-0.03084304,
0.0402272642,
0.0276073646,
0.0096313274,
-0.0176355112,
0.0637844056,
0.0159064773,
-0.0509137623,
-0.0199258141,
-0.0296728183,
-0.0027692833,
0.0305111185,
-0.0320132077,
-0.0253986754,
0.0159897432,
0.0443416573,
-0.0393638648,
0.1053265706,
0.0412312225,
0.1157811955,
0.0322024822,
0.0649898723,
0.0243074857,
-0.0328084566,
-0.0199368149,
0.023754742,
-0.0498365499,
-0.0194962956,
0.0136386184,
0.0141540691,
0.0569190569,
-0.0328878053,
-0.0027782507,
0.0822436586,
-0.0156413801,
-0.0612199455,
0.0082968585,
-0.0093679102,
0.0069731628,
-0.045643907,
-0.0327519923,
-0.0504780784,
0.0524695218,
0.0088394424,
0.0556554236,
-0.0353407227,
-0.051342845,
0.0449574739,
-0.013813165,
0.0061661005,
0.0005818274,
0.0198731013,
0.02119755,
-0.0181482658,
-0.0044527142,
0.0762133747,
-0.0430191495,
-0.0172745083,
0.0048449603,
0.0097812796,
0.0143110976,
-0.0099103898,
-0.0430010967,
-0.0774542987,
0.0103829317,
-0.0113235386,
0.0073848069,
-0.0467298068,
-0.0516080186,
-0.0609108061,
0.0044494485,
0.0118487831,
-0.0322065428,
0.002716623,
0.0028152722,
0.02898621,
0.0307832547,
-0.0566854253,
0.0118522393,
-0.02530347,
0.007805041,
0.0620549433,
-0.0222221632,
0.0185727179,
-0.0436851121,
-0.0237268172,
-0.011771882,
0.017919993,
0.0140874758,
-0.001627755,
-0.0056142695,
-0.0047859824,
0.0087500447,
0.0213883538,
-0.0062353085,
0.0083435038,
0.0221698005,
0.0537029393,
-0.0098178573,
0.0145835159,
-0.0223437585,
-0.0548629947,
0.0153328087,
0.0127944667,
0.0497791432,
-0.0334813707,
-0.0217104964,
-0.0211586617,
-0.056967821,
0.0052066958,
0.0051154997,
-0.0056208349,
-0.0347692482,
-0.0585316457,
-0.0510711148,
-0.0384561457,
0.0141216274,
-0.0353903994,
0.0279295892,
0.0083502214,
-0.0183010325,
0.0119035225,
-0.0444609299,
-0.0420426913,
-0.022701662,
0.0264708921,
0.0434993915,
0.0205839798,
-0.0125168469,
0.0045894068,
0.0211404413,
0.0497847684,
-0.0230271723,
0.0069044204,
0.121829167,
-0.0243705027,
-0.0191388428,
-0.0263790768,
0.070477061,
0.0199171323,
0.013333289,
-0.0008482701,
0.0211143717,
0.0063141584,
-0.0549789928,
-0.03230327,
-0.0031343561,
0.0612605214,
0.0359500386,
0.0057169073,
-0.0445310883,
0.0011867211,
-0.0644154251,
0.0101961149,
0.0109887924,
-0.0486502461,
0.0456806459,
-0.0076886318,
-0.0710169226,
-0.0565785319,
-0.0098890616,
-0.0245724116,
0.0328571238,
-0.0085301455,
0.0065870988,
0.0205957219,
0.0109142037,
-0.0313636921,
-0.0039268443,
0.0120327929,
0.0575843938,
-0.0003514602,
-0.0101220375,
0.0139464447,
-0.0030892766,
-0.0193630103,
0.0113711981,
-0.07965298,
-0.0700848252,
0.0324386768,
0.0056993729,
0.0222152248,
0.0675959513,
-0.0367286727,
-0.0432283208,
0.0608513877,
0.0366559364,
0.0236439966,
0.0294371601,
0.0706657395,
-0.0154679818,
0.0312936418,
0.0290117059,
-0.0067782286,
0.0171836037,
0.0546272062,
-0.0721556768,
-0.0722464025,
0.0689080358,
-0.0053752121,
0.0005507787,
0.0680654272,
0.0247244071,
-0.0338420793,
0.0231972579,
-0.0092716496,
0.0098115122,
-0.0291125607,
0.0008276772,
0.0106750121,
0.0545492247,
0.0274840575,
0.0017979247,
0.0141929202,
-0.0004192766,
0.004622248,
-0.0642528608,
-0.043027468,
-0.0038113629,
0.0512788072,
0.0264220238,
0.0190405659,
-0.0336160026,
0.0365867354,
0.0181557033,
0.0288585071,
-0.0075134099,
-0.016836185,
0.0156330708,
-0.0023519765,
0.01399804,
-0.0226428118,
-0.0601437166,
-0.0093814833,
-0.0448149741,
0.0337170064,
0.0005095104,
-0.0183981042,
-0.0434911735,
-0.0029629979,
-0.0188972559,
-0.0049735182,
-0.0494289733,
-0.0237019639,
-0.0326815732,
0.0124258297,
-0.0108648734,
-0.0117736701,
0.0682995096,
0.0630023405,
0.0369991735,
0.0616557002,
-0.0205390509,
-0.0647686571,
-0.0278376639,
0.0019602191,
0.0471527167,
0.0256328434,
-0.0190868303,
-0.0212086327,
-0.0239722226,
-0.0668920502,
0.0118535273,
0.0026883685,
0.0573667325,
0.0105535602,
-0.0571211874,
0.0467092246,
-0.003000427,
0.0800711513,
-0.0616434962,
0.031246772,
0.0108406655,
-0.0718950629,
0.0377240926,
-5.5985207e-33,
0.0532187372,
-0.0286558773,
-0.0742411986,
-0.0043556034,
0.0440052487,
0.0429761298,
0.0290389918,
-0.0353628285,
-0.0382948071,
-0.008975138,
0.0091344928,
0.0388851948,
-0.0303930808,
0.0448012725,
-0.0739142001,
-0.0667089596,
0.0369523093,
-0.0342499316,
-0.0474533699,
-0.001316125,
0.0704621673,
-0.0125914067,
-0.0033293245,
-0.0683555454,
0.0308699757,
-0.0036620982,
-0.0504267775,
0.0098577049,
-0.0498203784,
0.0658371076,
0.0185235497,
0.0196535531,
0.028548589,
-0.0178361032,
-0.0059175296,
0.0492729917,
-0.0010011105,
-0.0213421695,
-0.0107198441,
0.0112463208,
-0.0049742758,
0.0063384469,
0.0469539575,
-0.0065548583,
0.0059764707,
-0.0085988417,
-0.0141115719,
-0.0150915571,
-0.0263860151,
-0.0173775814,
-0.0318732858,
-0.0120439474,
-0.0208891947,
0.0117861414,
0.0057165157,
0.0279333908,
0.0553959459,
-0.0058348342,
-0.0714221075,
0.0176824071,
0.0053160684,
0.0075161457,
0.0165671185,
-0.029824011,
-0.0437731668,
0.056791909,
0.0354675725,
0.0275167096,
-0.0120721161,
0.0216323137,
0.0033366843,
0.0130393645,
0.0763081983,
0.0751608759,
0.0440958589,
-0.0844369233,
-0.0816237777,
-0.0201714281,
0.0475459136,
-0.0598278642,
0.0136373024,
-0.0127442991,
-0.04954198,
0.0094847493,
-0.0422456078,
-0.0874134228,
-0.0419280864,
-0.0146685718,
-0.0045301965,
0.057852637,
-0.0543042943,
0.0372267365,
-0.0106774652,
-0.0706425309,
0.0040993565,
0.0457084924,
0.0142560052,
0.0053342693,
-0.0002140397,
0.014237754,
-0.0153113455,
-0.0048308293,
0.0147890756,
-0.0412004478,
0.0268084109,
-0.0154867424,
0.0734287351,
0.040591348,
-0.0108989114,
-0.0072777248,
-0.015611059,
0.0387545079,
0.0128745129,
0.0141702807,
0.0429360829,
-0.0245929025,
-0.0102675986,
-0.0150576597,
-0.0076026558,
0.0447210483,
-0.0092241215,
-0.0032873154,
-0.0646009147,
-0.0072812415,
0.0020765364,
-0.0282299258,
0.0022157156,
-0.0047070584,
0.0356094465,
-0.0944207534,
0.0140525987,
-0.0356129967,
2.667e-7,
-0.0284293126,
0.0349793099,
-0.0197451841,
-0.007034041,
0.0553754419,
0.0482959077,
0.0066610314,
0.0731808692,
-0.0237002317,
-0.073412329,
-0.0515820272,
-0.0124496166,
0.0235585552,
0.0174007304,
-0.047147274,
0.0109264012,
-0.0204654597,
0.0204356275,
-0.0389473066,
0.0091727627,
-0.0194145516,
0.0710537881,
0.0471186712,
-0.0136388708,
0.003062896,
-0.0193965342,
0.0061652437,
0.0180092808,
-0.0139427315,
-0.036733523,
0.0852822512,
0.0097966297,
0.0095583173,
0.0082080169,
-0.0655679703,
-0.0267640278,
-0.0314136967,
0.0082371701,
0.0123615135,
0.0080570318,
-0.0488302484,
-0.0730373114,
0.0361263528,
-0.0089043537,
0.0678788722,
-0.0276185255,
-0.0193178505,
-0.0727019608,
-0.03384142,
-0.0178469196,
0.0422121398,
-0.0060983333,
0.0019410583,
0.0158253051,
-0.0234441254,
0.0400589816,
0.041503232,
-0.0075322785,
0.0129525848,
0.0054143281,
-0.0218416788,
-0.0303332098,
0.0094888741,
0.0198082384,
0.0746952891,
0.0123936906,
-0.0087127853,
2.147921134e-34,
0.0346157588,
-0.0202850103,
0.0251796637,
-0.0460490994,
0.0271512214,
-0.0188185237,
-0.0056918096,
-0.0218187235,
0.0273691565,
-0.0150022842,
-0.0191163886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15197v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15197v1 | TransFace: Unit-Based Audio-Visual Speech Synthesizer for Talking Head Translation | 2023-12-23T08:45:57 | 2023-12-23T08:45:57 | Xize Cheng, Rongjie Huang, Linjun Li, Tao Jin, Zehan Wang, Aoxiong Yin, Minglei Li, Xinyu Duan, changpeng yang, Zhou Zhao | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.CV, eess.AS | Direct speech-to-speech translation achieves high-quality results through the
introduction of discrete units obtained from self-supervised learning. This
approach circumvents delays and cascading errors associated with model
cascading. However, talking head translation, converting audio-visual speech
(i.e., talking head video) from one language into another, still confronts
several challenges compared to audio speech: (1) Existing methods invariably
rely on cascading, synthesizing via both audio and text, resulting in delays
and cascading errors. (2) Talking head translation has a limited set of
reference frames. If the generated translation exceeds the length of the
original speech, the video sequence needs to be supplemented by repeating
frames, leading to jarring video transitions. In this work, we propose a model
for talking head translation, \textbf{TransFace}, which can directly translate
audio-visual speech into audio-visual speech in other languages. It consists of
a speech-to-unit translation model to convert audio speech into discrete units
and a unit-based audio-visual speech synthesizer, Unit2Lip, to re-synthesize
synchronized audio-visual speech from discrete units in parallel. Furthermore,
we introduce a Bounded Duration Predictor, ensuring isometric talking head
translation and preventing duplicate reference frames. Experiments demonstrate
that our proposed Unit2Lip model significantly improves synchronization (1.601
and 0.982 on LSE-C for the original and generated audio speech, respectively)
and boosts inference speed by a factor of 4.35 on LRS2. Additionally, TransFace
achieves impressive BLEU scores of 61.93 and 47.55 for Es-En and Fr-En on
LRS3-T and 100% isochronous translations. | [
-0.0178593546,
0.0054714675,
0.006280899,
0.0060006436,
-0.000412901,
-0.0193549562,
0.066260457,
-0.0105926106,
-0.0367592834,
0.0151182031,
-0.020860754,
-0.0248954687,
0.0545181856,
0.0143764475,
0.0466967709,
-0.1058297679,
-0.0009644359,
-0.0465392284,
-0.0355642326,
-0.01548634,
0.0181993917,
0.0275646877,
-0.0688375905,
0.0001563958,
-0.0414331332,
0.002924782,
-0.0133046582,
0.0277456362,
0.0480647609,
0.0172636081,
-0.0720635876,
-0.0072628269,
0.0417169444,
0.019960884,
0.0000017313,
-0.0200065132,
-0.0147881135,
0.0402099714,
-0.0225944016,
-0.0055797086,
0.0130371368,
-0.0562415719,
-0.0293212514,
0.0478152409,
-0.0206558742,
-0.0098341433,
0.0605781265,
0.0151617397,
0.0308074541,
0.0346064568,
-0.0363407247,
-0.0489328206,
-0.027783351,
-0.0495811887,
-0.0216072444,
-0.0069397343,
-0.0401253588,
0.0010797726,
-0.0271865483,
0.0066561289,
-0.0674226508,
0.0636751279,
0.0051255394,
-0.0206905399,
0.0196794961,
-0.0082749305,
-0.0383745693,
-0.0644876063,
-0.0067829909,
0.0743478313,
0.0045086187,
0.0346693471,
0.0331927426,
0.0311570894,
-0.000773062,
-0.0019428711,
-0.0144585995,
0.0244107153,
0.0077285501,
-0.0026491315,
-0.0311164483,
0.0502516441,
0.0226690341,
-0.0906745493,
-0.0136491908,
-0.0414170437,
0.027766183,
0.0141080311,
0.0076273307,
-0.0140599748,
-0.0010697306,
-0.0006160093,
0.0529638678,
0.0010432204,
-0.0020722861,
0.0041645318,
-0.0373476595,
-0.0192581974,
-0.0363824069,
-0.0573356934,
0.00604046,
0.0362585224,
-0.0407656804,
0.0220227167,
0.0119208945,
0.0639422908,
-0.024588652,
-0.0249623433,
-0.031558495,
-0.0175764933,
0.0105767893,
0.0181909055,
-0.0559097044,
-0.0463185608,
-0.0472173542,
-0.0248276666,
-0.025044648,
0.0046644444,
-0.0248921644,
0.0413032286,
0.0255438462,
-0.0101211276,
-0.0338726453,
-0.0326416269,
-0.0066062002,
0.0636859164,
0.0037690056,
0.021826202,
-0.0215711482,
-0.0663014874,
-0.0366018116,
0.0065337955,
0.0097531369,
-0.0031329605,
-0.0136241224,
0.0958399698,
-0.0299201328,
0.0166721735,
0.0309168268,
0.0267012697,
-0.0507882275,
-0.0204977095,
-0.0048594996,
-0.0724726766,
0.0024273649,
-0.0078614447,
0.0106728636,
0.0059289006,
0.0131113054,
-0.0150916651,
0.020330701,
0.0482771546,
-0.0077825654,
0.0487369634,
0.0557261072,
0.0231809597,
0.0115052955,
0.0608254299,
0.0602997579,
-0.0392329693,
-0.0077318512,
-0.0203204714,
-0.0281629059,
0.0859520957,
0.0194390453,
0.0304000769,
-0.073075287,
-0.0391467363,
0.0468761139,
0.0486659892,
0.0266494006,
0.0559449866,
-0.0079459306,
-0.030239081,
0.0577831492,
-0.0103281848,
0.0114179458,
0.0072453301,
0.0705904439,
-0.008314603,
-0.0023746074,
0.0088539338,
0.0158611983,
0.0308109336,
0.0258953832,
0.0077818413,
0.0070191873,
0.0245828237,
-0.055722639,
-0.0124692889,
0.0162426457,
-0.016111888,
-0.0049153594,
-0.0189053826,
0.0278012399,
0.0411312319,
-0.0370825939,
0.030709127,
-0.0446774475,
-0.0519975387,
0.0427572131,
0.0171859786,
-0.0363635533,
0.0697543249,
0.0073919906,
0.0282850787,
-0.0170435943,
-0.0181373376,
0.0025481374,
0.0913095102,
0.0277038869,
-0.0292378645,
0.0790905505,
-0.0545497574,
0.0116376206,
0.0501542836,
-0.0198804736,
-0.0034334573,
-0.0265084393,
0.0705373138,
0.0125135677,
-0.0098089827,
0.0424429737,
0.0044468404,
-0.0680916607,
0.026303228,
-0.0093367072,
0.0334819332,
0.0044195838,
0.0117086675,
-0.0249111801,
-0.0067230961,
-0.0156199494,
-0.0371066928,
0.0275704656,
0.0707679987,
-0.034627948,
-0.0397200696,
0.0414438993,
-0.0551471263,
-0.0183868818,
0.0103848958,
0.0122608123,
-0.0858040377,
0.0230631754,
-0.0206330474,
0.0060242671,
-0.0089752553,
0.0414708965,
0.0273613557,
0.0182136316,
-0.0013189141,
-0.0476678237,
0.0050954679,
-0.0367122106,
0.0334672332,
0.0025604374,
0.0153774209,
-0.0492764898,
-0.0065864436,
0.0438348427,
0.0178024415,
-0.0119505962,
0.0001308909,
-0.0297511108,
-0.0457671024,
-0.0285212155,
-0.096355103,
-0.0093738316,
0.0178992674,
-0.0186571088,
-0.0271080285,
0.0199847389,
0.0135360723,
-0.0411489159,
-0.0616963245,
-0.013289283,
0.0124360127,
-0.0557024144,
-0.0456436388,
0.0037469747,
-0.0284154378,
-0.0208626427,
0.0094236983,
0.0339806676,
-0.0105815604,
-0.0183777809,
-0.0402034894,
-0.0149916289,
0.0147671606,
-0.0083992807,
0.0556610711,
-0.0096638966,
0.0011516332,
-0.0189673714,
0.0321126319,
0.076463677,
0.0273127723,
0.0204411913,
-0.0215996932,
-0.0003594562,
-0.0651339963,
-0.0216844883,
0.0151058454,
0.0156274382,
0.0306431856,
-0.0493602082,
0.0114379842,
-0.0446317308,
-0.0060683209,
0.0586846881,
0.0519494116,
-0.0807625577,
-0.0113951676,
0.0319443345,
-0.0535898842,
-0.0007317291,
0.0292370487,
0.0060810489,
0.0109363031,
-0.0313826837,
-0.0529999584,
-0.0009235915,
-0.0788322166,
-0.0652316287,
0.0283355732,
0.0062500234,
-0.0103626018,
0.0386364609,
0.0062408308,
0.011010509,
-0.0575492308,
0.0122417985,
-0.0631360188,
0.039774809,
0.013026271,
-0.0549376905,
0.0136558497,
-0.0599491149,
-0.0366119742,
-0.0314544737,
-0.0025026854,
-0.0142006576,
0.0337738208,
-0.0328809954,
-0.0202524345,
-0.0360420868,
-0.03862679,
-0.0283966716,
0.0301575419,
0.0223337971,
0.0415229164,
-0.003675991,
0.0312062781,
-0.015000144,
0.0111426972,
0.0459953807,
0.0400114991,
-0.0366094857,
-0.0488103554,
0.0841326639,
-0.0004276445,
0.0527205691,
0.0051341541,
-0.0918993354,
-0.0041302042,
0.0260882173,
0.0505946614,
-0.0541394688,
0.0003201493,
0.0190961026,
-0.0203479044,
0.0144658079,
0.0754530206,
-0.0375055298,
0.0059811333,
-0.023942098,
-0.0032373576,
0.0284641683,
0.0087745078,
-0.0051587978,
-0.026308788,
-0.0224153567,
0.0445538424,
-0.0072910236,
0.071409449,
0.0628077537,
-0.0474312752,
-0.0582875647,
0.063952826,
0.0743579492,
-0.0427779667,
-0.0283380859,
0.0006322585,
-0.0132423835,
-0.0265083034,
0.0205662176,
0.00760965,
-0.0240630005,
0.0103838127,
0.0397672914,
-0.0247128438,
0.0112197092,
-0.0146939857,
-0.0165873393,
0.0680964738,
0.0665836111,
0.03745839,
0.0008566263,
-0.0314903222,
-0.0044068345,
-0.0043541817,
-0.0032602474,
0.0020928141,
0.0348466225,
0.0055262116,
-0.0391526334,
0.0345953554,
0.0348014422,
0.0255365018,
0.0266934037,
0.0456462465,
0.0282960553,
-0.0216238797,
0.0284782052,
-0.0041196677,
0.0644899979,
-0.0216589328,
0.0135269593,
-0.0213180259,
-0.0666999146,
0.023075249,
0.0481472015,
0.002231448,
-0.0415643118,
-0.0404085219,
0.0107564768,
0.017565148,
-0.0266123638,
-0.0557987094,
0.0316250026,
0.0020492529,
0.0639143139,
0.0271625854,
0.0276265908,
0.0291079562,
0.0264198743,
-0.0438750759,
-0.0082441363,
-0.0101050995,
0.0443481281,
-0.0547029711,
0.0048724813,
-0.0184068419,
-0.0376928672,
0.0265560392,
0.0875013098,
-0.0500955842,
-0.0582890026,
-0.0125054242,
0.0201433748,
0.0167509336,
0.0818275139,
0.0086647719,
0.0163797811,
0.0141346436,
-0.0279588904,
0.0308975801,
0.0580810197,
0.0277196243,
-0.0125060184,
-0.0271571651,
0.0166627001,
-0.0105681075,
0.0233192258,
-0.052958671,
0.0219475441,
-0.0193131585,
-0.061602775,
-0.0071354611,
-0.0080467192,
0.0611224957,
-0.011238778,
0.1021598801,
-0.0429368392,
0.0175471213,
-0.0290568657,
0.0504445769,
-0.0859048665,
-0.0087251449,
0.0551094487,
0.042893827,
0.0313616656,
-0.0071057058,
0.0039438461,
-0.0551176108,
0.041567374,
-0.003561124,
-0.0630215108,
-0.0060403068,
-0.0087719606,
0.0280396938,
0.0475319698,
0.0344603285,
0.0045933351,
0.0072442964,
0.0064757257,
0.0432672873,
0.0153566189,
0.0079485094,
0.0282533541,
0.0118008154,
0.013226375,
-0.0297686923,
0.0028892048,
-0.0069318078,
0.0046462952,
-0.0038806666,
0.0995846465,
-0.0086210771,
0.034789566,
-0.0345451832,
0.0699290857,
-0.0464862585,
-0.0169352386,
0.025746746,
-0.0419011451,
-0.0161272939,
0.028306121,
0.0143464133,
-0.0125411488,
-0.0249523725,
-0.0253253914,
0.0399310924,
-0.0137569001,
-0.0491494313,
-0.0370307602,
-0.0863261819,
-0.0140505647,
-0.0178302936,
-0.0112675447,
-0.0475088917,
-0.0139722619,
0.0066054198,
0.0110020982,
-0.0325814858,
0.0563792512,
-0.014804705,
-0.0344027616,
0.0339843407,
-0.0095309298,
-0.0394768976,
-0.0055907443,
-0.0237430558,
0.0089794118,
-4.745110332e-33,
-0.0701976046,
-0.0146455308,
0.0574675538,
-0.003746721,
-0.0684827417,
-0.021224184,
-0.0323308222,
0.0392659307,
-0.0012496945,
0.007713865,
0.02377652,
0.0056647374,
0.0107378904,
0.0240730662,
0.007818698,
0.0465836152,
0.0572185479,
-0.0139105786,
-0.0005581629,
0.0113964435,
0.042524498,
0.0261506476,
0.0157943461,
-0.0449849144,
-0.0679208562,
0.0159923416,
-0.0171180051,
-0.0049066255,
-0.011603619,
-0.0084853247,
0.044439815,
-0.0016126349,
-0.0307443235,
-0.0299784783,
-0.0067709107,
0.0084788529,
-0.090968363,
0.0267581642,
0.0150946667,
0.068622686,
-0.0515594408,
0.0308215339,
0.0100417966,
-0.0302845147,
0.0012474447,
-0.0462461226,
0.0412127264,
-0.0739479735,
-0.029904183,
0.0268074796,
-0.0423463359,
0.0220658015,
-0.0435345732,
-0.0204893891,
0.0580644831,
0.1025795639,
-0.0043928251,
-0.0672289357,
-0.0190673582,
0.0377158783,
-0.0369807966,
0.0354090706,
0.0835601166,
0.0172655378,
-0.0058767111,
0.0385199264,
0.0597894751,
-0.0981969535,
0.003887177,
-0.0199802276,
0.0538159981,
0.0394556336,
0.0624373034,
0.0175170507,
0.0044615865,
-0.0174903255,
-0.016255673,
0.0297054779,
-0.0191335864,
0.0050220848,
-0.0053610443,
0.0423974544,
-0.0070032664,
0.0154758114,
-0.0578443296,
-0.0044740504,
0.0096697481,
-0.0471141003,
0.0178865958,
0.0274163242,
0.0329538137,
-0.0249669086,
0.0877414718,
0.0209365487,
0.0609265491,
-0.0284641441,
-0.0674104691,
0.0098462254,
-0.0149214668,
0.0314574875,
-0.0188618787,
-0.0281987898,
0.0761971176,
0.0364362039,
0.0255631637,
0.0086009474,
-0.022872692,
0.0386615917,
-0.0379072875,
-0.0005572645,
-0.0172421429,
0.0315810889,
-0.0156307276,
0.0269961841,
0.0297117829,
-0.038005691,
-0.0269986726,
-0.0082928054,
-0.0278706476,
-0.024446493,
-0.0203256365,
0.0107978219,
-0.0165587254,
0.0102733625,
-0.0740560591,
0.0353930183,
-0.0034155797,
-0.006228351,
0.0624025688,
-0.0350530446,
-0.0369154625,
0.0048186383,
2.551e-7,
-0.0304415226,
0.0006218183,
0.0084551694,
0.0072953715,
0.0292737354,
0.0193304066,
-0.0405124389,
0.0263615716,
0.0101193041,
0.0192249306,
0.0332544222,
0.0251471624,
0.0915030241,
-0.0031058213,
-0.0292188786,
-0.0416324772,
-0.0415200181,
0.0116574606,
0.0045319805,
0.0024466731,
-0.0164659861,
0.0377884954,
-0.0029780457,
-0.0258177277,
0.0507483259,
0.0220557563,
0.0720605925,
-0.0229348,
-0.0044796555,
-0.0559398755,
-0.0151118301,
0.0221923832,
-0.0630537421,
0.0138616506,
-0.0309398063,
0.0182843748,
0.0610884354,
0.0465862527,
-0.0065090228,
-0.0223961733,
-0.0009199586,
0.0485760942,
-0.0624364503,
0.0143501442,
0.019663984,
0.0238177683,
-0.0292912778,
-0.0395379886,
-0.0213177614,
0.049225729,
0.0098259104,
0.0167245511,
-0.0175148994,
0.0124847153,
0.0454821438,
-0.0057317214,
-0.0101471096,
-0.0148349544,
-0.016824428,
-0.0301422328,
-0.0449548997,
-0.0156689622,
-0.0466768518,
0.012230698,
-0.0399317183,
0.0334367417,
-0.0448141061,
1.635545302e-34,
0.0108954599,
-0.0334542952,
0.0237478577,
-0.0457363315,
-0.0081151556,
-0.0494514704,
-0.0165656656,
0.0430328026,
-0.0120767383,
-0.0052407654,
-0.0672136694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15194v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15194v2 | PokeMQA: Programmable knowledge editing for Multi-hop Question Answering | 2023-12-23T08:32:13 | 2024-02-15T03:10:29 | Hengrui Gu, Kaixiong Zhou, Xiaotian Han, Ninghao Liu, Ruobing Wang, Xin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-hop question answering (MQA) is one of the challenging tasks to
evaluate machine's comprehension and reasoning abilities, where large language
models (LLMs) have widely achieved the human-comparable performance. Due to the
dynamics of knowledge facts in real world, knowledge editing has been explored
to update model with the up-to-date facts while avoiding expensive re-training
or fine-tuning. Starting from the edited fact, the updated model needs to
provide cascading changes in the chain of MQA. The previous art simply adopts a
mix-up prompt to instruct LLMs conducting multiple reasoning tasks
sequentially, including question decomposition, answer generation, and conflict
checking via comparing with edited facts. However, the coupling of these
functionally-diverse reasoning tasks inhibits LLMs' advantages in comprehending
and answering questions while disturbing them with the unskilled task of
conflict checking. We thus propose a framework, Programmable knowledge editing
for Multi-hop Question Answering (PokeMQA), to decouple the jobs. Specifically,
we prompt LLMs to decompose knowledge-augmented multi-hop question, while
interacting with a detached trainable scope detector to modulate LLMs behavior
depending on external conflict signal. The experiments on three LLM backbones
and two benchmark datasets validate our superiority in knowledge editing of
MQA, outperforming all competitors by a large margin in almost all settings and
consistently producing reliable reasoning process. | [
0.0374910235,
0.0425928123,
-0.0039104591,
0.0282233134,
-0.0506006852,
0.014762993,
0.0057718246,
-0.0380476527,
0.010611007,
-0.0501567796,
-0.0457733348,
0.0098255901,
-0.0314124487,
0.0409447178,
0.0118959108,
-0.0057104104,
0.0946062431,
-0.0335964635,
0.0107106781,
0.0090844026,
-0.0101836165,
0.012210656,
-0.0257717408,
0.0122217285,
-0.0128238872,
-0.0459611155,
-0.0422140025,
0.0262147672,
0.018270364,
0.0011420683,
0.0180407502,
0.0572166517,
0.00994696,
0.0415496677,
0.0000021563,
-0.051739186,
-0.0419687219,
0.0093241632,
-0.0459224954,
0.0070135351,
-0.0511786416,
0.02326064,
0.0048321984,
0.0106589198,
-0.0406678431,
0.0103216199,
0.0203186497,
0.0647877753,
0.0926228017,
0.0754514858,
0.0059271115,
-0.0180941429,
0.0024897328,
-0.0158194993,
0.0020628406,
-0.0495290905,
0.0486178696,
0.0286814347,
-0.0153982574,
0.0370865911,
-0.0233539995,
0.0224019065,
0.0345793664,
-0.0041020871,
-0.0384882614,
0.0226379707,
-0.014742611,
0.0036971692,
-0.0159202851,
0.0684169605,
-0.0122119086,
-0.0204231068,
-0.0017708155,
0.0110046091,
0.0266833417,
-0.0103337988,
-0.0378132015,
-0.0100202514,
0.0008049562,
-0.005667374,
-0.0040126746,
-0.0318751335,
0.0172110759,
0.0388076529,
-0.0187031534,
0.0654103085,
0.0250358414,
-0.0325781666,
-0.0330259204,
-0.0083561074,
-0.0214680526,
-0.0799953118,
0.0198276266,
0.091039069,
-0.0607318878,
0.0173431262,
-0.0439044386,
0.0000098459,
0.0281710513,
-0.0235354677,
-0.0201299582,
0.0464861691,
-0.0162286554,
0.0878452286,
-0.014988848,
0.0269838702,
-0.0255345963,
0.0063295537,
-0.0317891054,
-0.0232797451,
-0.0292439852,
-0.045489464,
-0.0473280996,
0.0515013821,
-0.0651126578,
0.011793091,
-0.0073953657,
0.0637867749,
-0.006651978,
0.0149323037,
-0.0033081246,
0.0140779996,
0.0005252365,
-0.0184648633,
-0.0577152558,
0.0494140573,
-0.0686423853,
0.0198805425,
0.0152471103,
-0.0348414257,
-0.0516535118,
-0.0007080855,
0.0068920911,
-0.0308401585,
0.0114171617,
0.0585500002,
-0.0595599115,
-0.0083746733,
-0.0183191933,
-0.0704718679,
0.0025970698,
-0.0510749444,
-0.0050628702,
-0.0535508133,
0.0919509009,
-0.0172738917,
-0.0393357016,
-0.0090942513,
-0.0035573866,
0.0297921412,
-0.0289847776,
0.0731604695,
-0.0197059456,
-0.0075001563,
0.0408525541,
0.0193802398,
-0.0341177918,
0.0650383905,
0.0149162505,
-0.0236642752,
0.0522776358,
0.0245252363,
-0.0163288154,
0.0066311704,
0.0286761168,
-0.0060785082,
0.0222359039,
0.0371741392,
0.0048302161,
0.0016600917,
0.014184108,
0.0567949563,
-0.0465816036,
-0.0207417235,
0.045298934,
0.0052558165,
0.0098228147,
0.0149321379,
0.0304791387,
-0.0101556536,
0.0091136219,
0.0380123034,
-0.0531603806,
0.0563354678,
-0.0596178025,
0.0170613881,
0.0380202532,
0.0423117653,
-0.0295697581,
-0.0423170514,
0.0150981816,
0.0226651952,
0.0044101295,
0.0228080377,
0.0279026125,
0.0164540354,
-0.0447012931,
0.0625148416,
0.0000418631,
-0.0115147727,
-0.0080590649,
-0.0678502098,
0.0447435193,
0.0549370721,
0.062519215,
-0.0354045816,
-0.0611401759,
-0.0205198862,
-0.0058484883,
0.0314409137,
0.0405112728,
-0.0291724782,
0.0255737919,
-0.0286477711,
-0.0058012693,
-0.0598884039,
0.0091044111,
-0.0343451649,
0.0553812124,
0.0000121775,
0.0065067215,
-0.0098703038,
0.0439068712,
0.0226816032,
-0.0231880471,
0.0097938087,
-0.0064683422,
0.0014342667,
-0.0094228499,
0.0181233305,
-0.0063506039,
0.0143903075,
0.0392074957,
-0.0195436571,
-0.0302376654,
-0.0039464831,
-0.0395213813,
-0.07676965,
0.0390071422,
0.0138862729,
-0.0324842483,
-0.0044324477,
-0.0560555644,
-0.0306297485,
-0.0157079808,
-0.0113218613,
0.013754311,
-0.0712074265,
-0.0002100269,
0.0340075232,
-0.0232512336,
-0.0175818745,
0.0674425587,
-0.0184256732,
-0.0172354989,
0.0057437574,
0.021061141,
-0.0110302875,
0.0048779044,
-0.0081499321,
-0.0099063199,
-0.0024915731,
-0.021463478,
-0.0298106596,
0.0097970879,
-0.0419642814,
-0.0422993079,
-0.0728350431,
0.0269025266,
-0.0161822923,
0.0044352035,
0.0477735661,
0.0140013807,
-0.0011751968,
-0.0154581405,
-0.0295074712,
0.0031448589,
0.0296705216,
0.0286406111,
0.0627802834,
0.0125244334,
0.0190047007,
-0.0177575853,
0.0095553054,
-0.0149216652,
0.0547545254,
-0.0058446778,
-0.0248123817,
-0.076140359,
-0.0082179038,
-0.080601275,
0.0318187699,
0.0035392407,
-0.0298979692,
0.0136855142,
0.0007969763,
0.0689515918,
0.0548855066,
0.0041411924,
-0.008778655,
0.084682554,
-0.0257902481,
-0.0319827162,
0.0707803667,
-0.0000882073,
0.0184678677,
0.0018856288,
-0.0222569015,
0.0243527964,
0.0642811805,
-0.0200154614,
-0.0309831295,
-0.0125864828,
0.0328236744,
0.0352508537,
-0.0112824664,
-0.0581150651,
-0.0414308086,
-0.0166674815,
0.0407348908,
-0.0486490205,
-0.0075273397,
0.1116883382,
0.0034395128,
0.011131051,
-0.0531221405,
0.0083676195,
-0.0397325084,
0.0763615817,
-0.0403494202,
0.0297511015,
-0.0202795211,
0.0121034505,
-0.0702495277,
-0.0317217074,
0.0000888864,
-0.0474056751,
0.0337068103,
-0.0716325939,
0.0117739504,
-0.008789558,
-0.0291186813,
-0.0456962399,
0.0103454171,
-0.0138284983,
0.0249160472,
0.0008042244,
0.0143636111,
0.01392709,
0.0048512225,
0.0431662574,
0.0472293682,
-0.0242106616,
-0.0090941107,
-0.0167755727,
0.0403003357,
0.0841955915,
0.0712286085,
0.0229964033,
-0.0204717182,
0.0297026746,
0.0713010877,
-0.0025977148,
-0.0407054648,
0.0341872238,
-0.0065158661,
-0.0056848684,
-0.0330613442,
0.0171173736,
-0.0316149108,
0.0883735642,
-0.0553220212,
-0.0301647168,
0.0968757644,
0.0565006025,
-0.0183043759,
-0.0092493044,
-0.0474742725,
-0.0070540407,
0.0132039906,
0.065643169,
-0.111472562,
-0.047667563,
-0.0036727895,
-0.0071773045,
0.0019362485,
-0.0188827664,
-0.0285602789,
-0.0865654126,
-0.0030238389,
-0.0269335136,
-0.0573529042,
-0.0655957684,
-0.0188629348,
0.0008871855,
0.0187149234,
0.0139295347,
0.0433432534,
0.032941658,
-0.008509364,
-0.0333733149,
0.0307700951,
-0.0163619779,
0.0390497111,
-0.0132180881,
0.0173393674,
0.0610094555,
0.0040721367,
0.0300957002,
-0.0204457324,
0.0337769315,
-0.0159991961,
0.0164128877,
-0.0129069341,
0.0034618068,
-0.0227585472,
-0.0163324364,
-0.0439321585,
0.0314221717,
0.0043067434,
-0.0424945503,
0.0322113745,
0.0744778439,
-0.0226379894,
0.0033817121,
-0.0113659194,
0.0132650537,
-0.0053065061,
0.0907056481,
0.0393182971,
-0.0315708444,
-0.0419261418,
-0.0306184068,
-0.0279595777,
-0.0552790277,
0.0115313949,
0.0034605192,
0.0051654354,
0.0430427007,
-0.0791228563,
-0.0306950826,
0.0336425528,
0.0380237773,
-0.0254986193,
0.0025508257,
0.0208752677,
0.0096585704,
-0.0482236221,
0.0003103144,
-0.0303040091,
0.001286247,
-0.0255545508,
0.0078217499,
0.0375308692,
-0.0173160229,
-0.0220611263,
0.0469739623,
-0.1056944206,
-0.0435497873,
-0.0015412013,
0.0512166284,
0.0218516793,
0.0491903722,
-0.0181821045,
-0.0125093414,
-0.0089073358,
0.0280845594,
-0.0306758285,
0.0386758931,
0.0024266285,
0.0337277241,
-0.0239426307,
0.0337850899,
-0.0634098649,
-0.0100629861,
0.004160617,
0.0622393787,
-0.0423461087,
-0.0424212813,
0.0021348798,
0.001551196,
-0.0019863588,
0.0442965068,
0.0010703299,
-0.0163250007,
0.0524924211,
-0.0192681476,
-0.0249936022,
-0.013458387,
0.0041008457,
-0.0191706717,
-0.0551048405,
0.0127988113,
0.0064387904,
0.010985001,
0.0209824014,
0.0023024627,
-0.0323515236,
-0.0123114167,
-0.0025095281,
0.0293084178,
-0.0318940207,
-0.044594992,
0.031251125,
-0.0040862216,
0.0193408877,
-0.0246259328,
0.0775507018,
0.0370297953,
-0.0295555014,
-0.0521005541,
0.0240386855,
-0.0938173607,
-0.0268432144,
0.0102375206,
0.0061185658,
0.0412851982,
0.0311865453,
0.0146642905,
-0.0074426397,
-0.0412858613,
-0.0067707496,
0.0091856485,
0.0399619341,
-0.0011960547,
0.0453122184,
0.0337104797,
0.004090487,
0.0118694929,
0.0725678578,
-0.0556947887,
0.0573928207,
-0.0165483616,
-0.0094159581,
-0.0346509218,
-0.0517147332,
-0.0411111787,
0.0242228415,
-0.0387749635,
0.0008697613,
-0.0414326489,
-0.0490608364,
-0.0209461264,
0.0083648283,
0.0037196144,
-0.0113843447,
0.0114366626,
0.0531633236,
0.0359678306,
-0.0394928232,
-0.0091366339,
0.0463581309,
0.0217669345,
-0.0247170012,
0.0040193889,
-6.722609581e-33,
-0.0220994074,
-0.0489306375,
0.0432557091,
-0.079858169,
-0.0339788049,
-0.003958805,
-0.0500331372,
-0.02269876,
-0.0547040887,
-0.0209683869,
-0.0082484493,
0.0137589294,
-0.0080557177,
0.0209722314,
-0.0072603961,
-0.0230296273,
0.0583175533,
-0.0057130866,
-0.0244381074,
0.023007337,
0.0555573441,
0.0188116375,
0.0203980282,
0.0459084548,
0.0244484823,
-0.0112628536,
-0.0196423419,
0.0679727867,
-0.0801958367,
0.0610198341,
-0.0288351532,
0.0084591126,
0.042280782,
-0.0306647755,
-0.011319248,
0.0066861231,
-0.0941861048,
-0.0600336678,
0.0359759815,
-0.0213676114,
-0.0560914539,
-0.0475062653,
0.0503254198,
0.0130672157,
0.0374739952,
-0.0163580813,
-0.0145218708,
-0.0121533712,
0.0017766861,
-0.0158997495,
-0.0324614383,
-0.0029376175,
-0.0135046588,
-0.0584186465,
-0.0529594906,
0.0217433479,
0.026955571,
0.0014998906,
-0.0853088647,
0.0010135188,
0.02161384,
0.0075392127,
0.0427789986,
0.0070320121,
-0.0057405122,
0.0453518964,
0.0035191483,
0.0034110937,
-0.0380694456,
-0.0020607121,
-0.0080658412,
0.019488452,
0.0480992086,
0.0475230627,
0.016710991,
0.0084133754,
-0.0813791677,
0.0135790184,
0.0140846772,
0.021311719,
0.0144520085,
0.0181537643,
0.0362552628,
-0.0027726858,
-0.0288987253,
0.0269014612,
-0.0483364351,
-0.009243872,
0.0195006095,
0.0268201549,
-0.0300599281,
-0.0062682433,
0.0216475409,
-0.0154384505,
0.0307799019,
0.0369557999,
-0.0124948407,
0.0243675169,
0.0108184591,
0.0259750802,
-0.0181393865,
0.034197215,
0.063939549,
-0.0101377536,
-0.0091135846,
0.0326486006,
0.0336265936,
-0.0091604888,
-0.0622012503,
0.0240490846,
-0.0347017199,
0.0489927121,
-0.018634757,
-0.0271877125,
0.0212242715,
0.0254578684,
-0.0180821046,
0.0321408585,
0.0125565361,
0.0080523565,
-0.0232110303,
0.0393696949,
-0.0015540804,
0.0463748686,
-0.0067720409,
0.0332513042,
-0.0116042159,
0.0325458571,
-0.0506853014,
-0.0454038195,
-0.0131099541,
0.0429587774,
2.86e-7,
0.0589195713,
0.0370073169,
0.0383938774,
0.0602609403,
0.0378394946,
0.0193413403,
-0.0160401836,
0.015631998,
0.013994718,
-0.0177124515,
-0.0050670649,
0.0582345575,
0.0103732357,
0.0425398797,
-0.0708249435,
-0.0157047156,
-0.0317310467,
-0.0379514582,
-0.0767181665,
-0.0211229324,
0.0744594485,
0.0374284312,
0.016600119,
0.0009722895,
-0.0122645171,
0.0118973134,
0.0283870772,
0.009744483,
-0.0342334695,
0.005043156,
0.0164029617,
-0.0036017366,
0.0152731547,
0.0452826805,
-0.0213259812,
-0.0044703744,
-0.0145144146,
0.0819185451,
0.0043849908,
-0.0461231396,
-0.0141741689,
0.0077834683,
0.0318870582,
-0.0760458037,
0.1198623329,
-0.0375269614,
0.0027910531,
-0.0393162593,
-0.0114364251,
0.0033527978,
-0.0003027272,
-0.0401572101,
-0.0380155146,
0.0134376977,
-0.0087890187,
0.04046648,
0.0128989965,
-0.0778331682,
-0.0159413368,
0.0207828656,
-0.0390972979,
-0.0530004129,
-0.0419183038,
-0.0640403628,
0.0431349128,
-0.0594437644,
-0.0050952621,
2.665345967e-34,
0.0218544398,
-0.0058639208,
0.0365308039,
0.0405327082,
0.0334918424,
-0.0121932421,
-0.0349635184,
-0.0175800771,
0.0167880598,
-0.0720204711,
-0.0254444126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15185v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15185v1 | emotion2vec: Self-Supervised Pre-Training for Speech Emotion Representation | 2023-12-23T07:46:55 | 2023-12-23T07:46:55 | Ziyang Ma, Zhisheng Zheng, Jiaxin Ye, Jinchao Li, Zhifu Gao, Shiliang Zhang, Xie Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.MM, cs.SD, eess.AS | We propose emotion2vec, a universal speech emotion representation model.
emotion2vec is pre-trained on open-source unlabeled emotion data through
self-supervised online distillation, combining utterance-level loss and
frame-level loss during pre-training. emotion2vec outperforms state-of-the-art
pre-trained universal models and emotion specialist models by only training
linear layers for the speech emotion recognition task on the mainstream IEMOCAP
dataset. In addition, emotion2vec shows consistent improvements among 10
different languages of speech emotion recognition datasets. emotion2vec also
shows excellent results on other emotion tasks, such as song emotion
recognition, emotion prediction in conversation, and sentiment analysis.
Comparison experiments, ablation experiments, and visualization comprehensively
demonstrate the universal capability of the proposed emotion2vec. To the best
of our knowledge, emotion2vec is the first universal representation model in
various emotion-related tasks, filling a gap in the field. | [
-0.041987747,
0.0852127299,
-0.0071392101,
0.0101532554,
0.0604800284,
0.0120134652,
0.0253061596,
-0.0354570039,
0.0174261425,
-0.0169110447,
-0.0603590496,
-0.0010910437,
-0.0758177117,
0.0296892356,
-0.0305553041,
-0.0510764718,
0.0120426137,
0.0273686778,
0.0534043051,
-0.0112521471,
0.048226092,
0.0348511524,
-0.0229646135,
0.0190934297,
-0.0595203415,
-0.0087702144,
-0.0551962592,
0.035351567,
0.0211013369,
-0.0304249227,
0.0388474464,
0.0433912091,
0.0680930912,
-0.0119495904,
0.0000021142,
-0.0023850272,
-0.0091777518,
-0.0168600697,
-0.044546444,
0.0159838609,
0.0319328979,
0.0097236484,
-0.0116578331,
0.0051799277,
-0.025802603,
-0.0283798147,
0.0429287031,
0.061417684,
0.0989414528,
0.0509197004,
-0.0249214787,
-0.013857903,
-0.0239955205,
-0.0167826004,
-0.0001972705,
0.0047117751,
-0.0205057319,
-0.0129132764,
-0.0226457268,
-0.06071667,
-0.0345975459,
-0.0105206855,
-0.0120751858,
0.0264908057,
0.0266909376,
-0.0141534917,
-0.0785839558,
-0.023750741,
-0.01510657,
0.0840915367,
-0.0123881511,
-0.0208538342,
-0.0305866357,
0.020671349,
0.00440754,
-0.0639543235,
-0.0238124002,
-0.0290967841,
0.0533874482,
0.0412613899,
-0.0261424966,
0.0701512098,
0.0009370899,
-0.0040566884,
-0.0241256896,
0.0058896891,
-0.0445867069,
-0.0131940572,
0.0360566676,
-0.0168359801,
-0.039538119,
0.0170457996,
0.0187545791,
-0.0287305638,
0.0046504992,
-0.0330533013,
-0.0415099673,
-0.0113735422,
-0.0498140454,
-0.0593659095,
0.0102840392,
0.0213642158,
-0.049170848,
0.0370137021,
-0.0133712972,
0.0204501133,
0.0143998209,
-0.0200442467,
-0.0268639382,
-0.0060871667,
-0.0615701973,
0.0308977682,
-0.0260272846,
0.0339416564,
-0.0242945049,
-0.0312500447,
-0.064299874,
-0.0349149778,
-0.076714471,
-0.0183105748,
0.0039184582,
0.0236464366,
0.0025967807,
-0.0059756204,
0.00048338,
0.0339468382,
-0.0162327327,
0.052224651,
-0.0077971411,
-0.0687207505,
-0.0083355652,
0.016626453,
0.0364352763,
0.0280362628,
0.0674494281,
0.0449522287,
0.0055226795,
-0.0335645229,
0.0056796977,
-0.0148163149,
-0.0301329158,
-0.0626444966,
-0.0156679787,
-0.0338520072,
0.0634628907,
-0.0335510895,
0.019809505,
-0.0261636321,
0.0036656994,
-0.0807396621,
-0.0004083462,
0.0674865246,
-0.0049882634,
0.005450584,
-0.00524288,
0.0117314672,
0.0533332452,
0.0147113428,
-0.0052575655,
0.0472547784,
0.0266962126,
-0.0467452854,
0.0224967059,
0.0087779928,
0.0431199782,
-0.0296933185,
-0.0113066509,
-0.0126666855,
-0.0211997181,
0.0252239108,
0.0893592611,
0.0150595987,
-0.0462933891,
-0.014597523,
0.0385718048,
0.0323578157,
0.0108329589,
0.0509814285,
-0.0476852804,
0.0440383926,
0.0366992392,
-0.0593520664,
-0.0316900797,
0.0351353697,
0.0097559597,
-0.0196595509,
0.0430033654,
-0.0133069493,
-0.0469178967,
-0.0317054912,
0.0071839555,
-0.0212770998,
-0.0071041454,
0.0371362194,
0.0264238138,
-0.0091056386,
-0.0186783653,
0.0797735527,
-0.0144503154,
-0.0925604329,
0.0064558634,
-0.0135100083,
0.0168247148,
0.0366207212,
-0.0019636748,
-0.0425692536,
-0.0175396446,
-0.0526802316,
0.0063823126,
-0.0239901822,
0.0208500456,
-0.0003635848,
0.094406344,
-0.0512290373,
-0.0203468036,
-0.0294412356,
-0.0150216855,
0.0341691189,
-0.0382279344,
0.0492243022,
-0.007653119,
-0.0417771712,
0.0114736846,
-0.0138117988,
0.0009343834,
-0.0352553017,
0.0151437605,
0.0112655992,
0.0510540679,
0.022696102,
-0.0326101296,
-0.0362541564,
0.0675044581,
-0.001161447,
-0.013543277,
0.0047491207,
-0.0470948592,
-0.0613109209,
0.0471245311,
-0.0444213748,
0.0280545484,
0.0572344139,
-0.0692053884,
-0.0392042547,
0.0473657995,
0.0452672057,
0.0408164375,
-0.018815292,
0.0196440313,
-0.0268014129,
0.0511351824,
0.0440149195,
-0.0178981591,
-0.0076626088,
-0.0385413431,
-0.0344907977,
0.0138731198,
0.0167793054,
-0.0009409421,
-0.0924469531,
0.0106268981,
-0.005030232,
0.0349648036,
0.0039174184,
-0.0192187596,
-0.0327289775,
-0.0322636813,
-0.0962296948,
0.0214698296,
-0.0120000299,
-0.0345672108,
-0.015686458,
0.0034868114,
-0.030413311,
-0.043902535,
-0.0319804922,
-0.0145276943,
0.016355658,
-0.006327169,
-0.0332032479,
-0.0215103757,
0.0254199542,
-0.0608240068,
-0.001613581,
0.0200684462,
-0.0458913334,
-0.0659136102,
-0.005481631,
0.0133315427,
0.0189315416,
-0.0058485703,
0.0334760211,
-0.0110677704,
-0.0611918829,
-0.0284639653,
-0.029157415,
-0.0146220792,
0.0344172418,
-0.0145358276,
0.062769793,
0.0340914875,
0.0263635386,
-0.0227069221,
0.056457147,
-0.0127471397,
0.0353877135,
-0.0375070497,
0.0357182622,
-0.0648117065,
0.0576390401,
0.0176328551,
0.0109492056,
-0.0155277876,
-0.042191118,
0.0189390332,
-0.0461725928,
-0.0416320115,
-0.023448376,
-0.0112293866,
0.0069872616,
0.0105469171,
-0.0578084737,
0.0073013483,
-0.0093422085,
-0.044693552,
-0.0580502935,
-0.0485523939,
-0.0191966817,
0.0689126626,
-0.0427766591,
-0.0167677701,
-0.016460374,
0.014739247,
-0.0288808886,
-0.0212512892,
-0.0105044479,
-0.0661752149,
-0.0035701366,
0.0180352461,
-0.0356148854,
0.0259665363,
-0.0298293475,
-0.0208043084,
-0.0667388141,
-0.0353878029,
-0.0141271185,
0.0065064961,
0.0238617864,
-0.0242650583,
-0.011698938,
0.0156381298,
-0.027238762,
0.0139654875,
0.010316344,
-0.0027914261,
0.0426908061,
0.0186759345,
0.0321440771,
0.0179008208,
0.0220500734,
0.0600908399,
0.0230759159,
0.0559086949,
0.003851905,
-0.0300915614,
0.0598749891,
0.0297289509,
0.040165823,
0.0009708527,
-0.0195851214,
0.0387413874,
-0.0265565254,
0.0502168685,
0.103309609,
0.027343927,
-0.0256321747,
0.0044705654,
-0.0109805549,
-0.0022714559,
0.0232661087,
-0.0095925042,
-0.0417128131,
-0.0389249958,
0.0135302311,
0.0307426266,
0.061788667,
-0.000872624,
0.0379250757,
-0.034056142,
0.0322347954,
0.0244276803,
0.0253339261,
-0.035201475,
-0.0128657408,
0.0036518972,
-0.0657026917,
-0.0026040957,
-0.0668772683,
0.0090248864,
-0.0010161708,
0.0355929621,
-0.0497800782,
-0.0274502374,
0.0327273831,
-0.0355070792,
0.0527613834,
0.0340614878,
0.0809755772,
-0.0106503833,
-0.01740239,
0.0195884556,
-0.0056462605,
-0.0148577895,
-0.0271457657,
0.085998483,
0.0201913137,
-0.0106823258,
-0.0116402581,
0.0471930914,
-0.0353759974,
0.0085267127,
-0.019694509,
0.0653106496,
-0.0178991947,
-0.0408918224,
-0.0330047645,
0.0265803058,
0.0264533982,
0.032660529,
0.0216441136,
-0.0226792414,
-0.0383120738,
-0.0103081679,
0.0439507663,
-0.001267611,
-0.0435950756,
0.0019170148,
0.0070325015,
-0.0324329212,
0.0046260725,
-0.0491039567,
-0.0028903708,
0.0193075258,
-0.0342344269,
-0.0263456125,
-0.0139318295,
-0.0157531835,
-0.0460783616,
0.0473396368,
0.0400912687,
0.0036559547,
-0.000795505,
-0.0140417293,
0.0400623754,
0.0270612724,
-0.014293002,
0.0193835627,
-0.0074451212,
-0.0413579307,
0.0356695317,
0.0427074805,
0.0080717402,
0.0331790224,
0.019536959,
-0.0328959227,
0.121124737,
0.0028180277,
-0.053789027,
-0.0086209662,
0.0789217651,
0.023237437,
-0.0134328716,
0.0163910259,
-0.0216182843,
0.0876348689,
-0.01603733,
0.0140126254,
0.0158680193,
-0.0495985262,
0.0084175505,
-0.0081464332,
0.0974799693,
0.0331161954,
0.0043874639,
-0.0320906565,
-0.00428615,
-0.0025834867,
0.0261547975,
-0.0502007008,
-0.0081289541,
0.016242085,
0.0081552695,
-0.0424468704,
0.0059186267,
0.0014417806,
-0.0432896018,
0.0307136364,
0.0358502343,
0.0255950559,
0.0276185814,
0.0048937467,
0.0542963557,
0.0337848477,
0.02622265,
0.0300936773,
-0.0273361243,
-0.0037155931,
0.0205996633,
-0.0120840101,
0.0297240485,
0.0053547998,
0.0426018499,
-0.0116096828,
-0.0239423215,
-0.0020752731,
-0.0012342178,
0.0268379096,
-0.0531992652,
0.0600657575,
-0.0131992884,
0.0237618741,
-0.0308394227,
-0.0008262299,
-0.0483505912,
-0.0060958667,
0.0213337094,
-0.0233739521,
-0.0569676794,
-0.0109445788,
0.0246731974,
-0.0326592848,
0.0595124066,
-0.0171040595,
0.0380053297,
-0.0495896712,
0.0053903162,
0.058242701,
0.0126844486,
0.0125715043,
0.0132725202,
-0.012560592,
-0.0315598361,
0.0255363025,
-0.0683544204,
-0.0559928603,
-0.0412709154,
0.0355231017,
0.0097317696,
-0.0220238473,
0.0486383103,
-0.0018341022,
-0.0269454457,
-0.0377617776,
-0.0348207913,
0.016635539,
-6.149918651e-33,
0.0200880449,
0.0525078103,
-0.0617435053,
-0.005018801,
-0.0343859866,
0.0387996621,
-0.0040275464,
0.039635174,
-0.008153772,
0.0327006504,
-0.0324975774,
0.0603546277,
0.0075597581,
0.0023740889,
0.006990857,
-0.0209829267,
0.0677426159,
-0.0337012485,
0.0091296928,
0.0370610356,
0.0321938954,
0.0467411056,
0.0684472099,
-0.0944250301,
-0.0231750607,
0.0023519888,
-0.0165541284,
-0.0450830646,
0.0776400939,
0.023960555,
0.0143692913,
0.0773703083,
-0.0089757433,
0.0046630446,
-0.0411690027,
-0.0017116714,
-0.0391207524,
-0.0092209233,
-0.0483749993,
0.0093310578,
-0.0330104418,
-0.0042706933,
0.0044585564,
0.0501558483,
-0.0064366125,
-0.0378571935,
0.0241240188,
0.0033292032,
0.0135504175,
-0.0591653436,
0.0176673494,
0.0042487145,
-0.0624568909,
-0.0367260166,
0.0595724061,
0.0610849261,
0.0223274827,
-0.0204069819,
-0.0748885497,
0.0225809552,
-0.0340570398,
0.0011621745,
0.0232749302,
-0.0425745659,
-0.0007940646,
0.070129253,
0.0619830824,
-0.0207780637,
-0.0068451837,
0.0348106809,
0.028990563,
0.0670543313,
-0.0007213149,
0.0520948842,
0.0198580101,
-0.0401784591,
0.0269834381,
0.0613226183,
0.0249449145,
0.0202883184,
-0.0029003881,
0.0506127104,
0.006932477,
-0.0067163571,
-0.0231069606,
-0.0194949973,
0.0046423129,
-0.0307271164,
0.0397272222,
-0.0264804363,
0.0295197126,
-0.0262932908,
0.0062405556,
-0.0428494848,
0.0091195153,
0.04093327,
-0.0334302522,
0.0135778897,
0.0105401352,
0.028717814,
-0.0090298746,
-0.0395115539,
0.0471367873,
-0.0078684483,
0.0488058962,
-0.0256888587,
-0.030510053,
0.0533157699,
-0.0429411978,
-0.0160302725,
-0.0016777546,
0.0198304784,
0.0188380033,
0.0047884774,
-0.0146537246,
0.0233040489,
0.0153464358,
-0.0072728298,
-0.0003162721,
0.0501147434,
0.0025519412,
-0.039450556,
0.0101799984,
0.0477952585,
-0.0330399647,
0.0035107778,
-0.0707833841,
-0.0591435768,
0.0050673317,
-0.0497878902,
-0.0119144404,
-0.0110322023,
2.773e-7,
-0.0363415889,
0.0013567747,
0.0191878397,
-0.0511808582,
0.0319799706,
0.0424407534,
-0.0104682278,
0.0270091053,
-0.0023114299,
-0.027385259,
0.057771679,
0.0421662815,
0.0650851429,
0.0008608968,
-0.0652105063,
0.0002071752,
-0.0215860251,
0.0428916402,
-0.0063421708,
0.0113609135,
0.0653516948,
0.1171279177,
0.0401472338,
-0.0009638745,
0.0202408787,
0.0412921086,
0.0231952854,
-0.0420764983,
0.0151047623,
0.0029767815,
-0.0694587901,
-0.0047803312,
-0.0571937002,
-0.0253726766,
-0.0246360991,
0.035907913,
0.0563637279,
0.0526305921,
0.0312184636,
-0.0780005828,
0.0261533167,
0.0491480567,
-0.0249012429,
0.0026813403,
0.0500876606,
-0.0355547629,
-0.0402600653,
-0.0484124608,
-0.0525996014,
-0.0064289919,
0.0668912157,
-0.0067588524,
-0.0177407488,
0.0183171555,
-0.0229551177,
-0.013888225,
-0.0454180911,
-0.0879017636,
0.0249191932,
0.008132535,
-0.0236754473,
-0.0020542415,
-0.0335861072,
0.0301493574,
0.0912444964,
-0.0019856577,
0.016620582,
1.928780748e-34,
-0.012856788,
-0.0097839041,
0.0113772955,
-0.0028925196,
-0.0076346523,
-0.0256550238,
-0.0404333621,
-0.0212677922,
0.0520544536,
-0.0369522795,
-0.0138441753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15181v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15181v1 | Multilingual Bias Detection and Mitigation for Indian Languages | 2023-12-23T07:36:20 | 2023-12-23T07:36:20 | Ankita Maity, Anubhav Sharma, Rudra Dhar, Tushar Abhishek, Manish Gupta, Vasudeva Varma | cs.CL | cs.CL | Lack of diverse perspectives causes neutrality bias in Wikipedia content
leading to millions of worldwide readers getting exposed by potentially
inaccurate information. Hence, neutrality bias detection and mitigation is a
critical problem. Although previous studies have proposed effective solutions
for English, no work exists for Indian languages. First, we contribute two
large datasets, mWikiBias and mWNC, covering 8 languages, for the bias
detection and mitigation tasks respectively. Next, we investigate the
effectiveness of popular multilingual Transformer-based models for the two
tasks by modeling detection as a binary classification problem and mitigation
as a style transfer problem. We make the code and data publicly available. | [
0.0557143241,
0.0627828464,
-0.0312148482,
0.0670414269,
-0.0425056666,
0.038296245,
0.0282276906,
0.0228430405,
0.0382023826,
-0.0492255799,
0.0101789674,
-0.0130715724,
0.0289428029,
-0.038363304,
0.0038448952,
-0.0278025027,
0.0201198012,
0.0218355432,
0.0223734118,
-0.0496892743,
0.0330141596,
0.0491808616,
-0.0342286229,
0.0237892177,
-0.0289548393,
-0.0039303894,
0.068305254,
0.016684588,
0.0118932109,
0.0145659922,
0.0460692234,
0.0628137365,
-0.032469146,
0.0276359338,
0.0000015413,
-0.0442867242,
0.004780056,
0.0046930625,
0.05168828,
-0.0335614011,
0.0457079858,
-0.0343078561,
0.0031352371,
0.0152919618,
0.0052056545,
0.0024283566,
0.094680585,
0.0425357521,
0.067700386,
0.0700772703,
-0.0217669252,
-0.0566723458,
-0.0187530629,
0.0281128529,
0.0189651251,
0.0115951169,
0.061971996,
-0.0330576934,
-0.0907137096,
-0.048583623,
-0.0336780585,
0.0240360778,
-0.0107360147,
-0.0309256818,
-0.0060005509,
-0.0314301699,
-0.0344131216,
-0.0302326158,
0.0522283539,
0.0615994446,
-0.0266584437,
-0.0494344085,
0.0259667523,
0.0063270731,
0.0190001521,
0.0427845642,
-0.021099817,
0.0417334363,
-0.0644729882,
0.031808354,
0.0325033329,
-0.0179275889,
0.0004872336,
0.0226170532,
0.0189885292,
0.0279748347,
0.0413842164,
-0.0234836563,
-0.0085218539,
0.0478217714,
0.0187836662,
-0.0072880001,
0.0351316482,
-0.0115047395,
0.0089362552,
0.0085073132,
-0.0217697509,
-0.0613689721,
0.0173109192,
-0.0940679312,
-0.045108743,
0.0190684181,
-0.0354544409,
0.0256189127,
-0.0104646049,
-0.0026366855,
-0.0381145775,
0.0514776967,
0.0012516429,
-0.0327023529,
0.0213614684,
-0.0107804919,
0.0252061039,
-0.0157076959,
0.0053641647,
0.0753438845,
-0.0353069119,
-0.0273524728,
-0.0307081155,
-0.020877948,
0.0491453893,
-0.0406719968,
-0.0452025756,
-0.0391375311,
0.0006859538,
0.0894345567,
-0.0063074017,
0.0400018133,
-0.0594941303,
-0.076023154,
-0.0210458618,
0.0492860749,
-0.0138729103,
-0.0588485561,
-0.010952861,
0.0232334826,
0.002040681,
0.0140633099,
-0.0673073009,
0.0200637355,
0.0149051622,
-0.0344208702,
-0.0127279395,
-0.0790871531,
0.031066915,
0.0266838316,
0.0281879976,
-0.0720516443,
-0.0173151866,
0.0125534944,
-0.060487695,
0.0786655843,
-0.0102359317,
-0.006998973,
0.0638396516,
0.0296505261,
-0.0054435474,
0.0951310173,
-0.0007622203,
-0.0213374142,
0.0698367432,
-0.0111611029,
-0.0028078293,
0.0370211974,
0.0172134265,
0.0151890339,
0.0107815843,
0.0067511266,
-0.0060446225,
-0.0157426205,
0.0436736643,
0.0288381148,
0.0091918837,
-0.0276160333,
0.0501791276,
-0.0143234907,
-0.0155046526,
0.0359515995,
-0.0100630652,
0.0067006443,
-0.0130025176,
0.0392658524,
-0.0352315158,
0.0080455346,
-0.0270383507,
-0.0303062387,
0.0179233085,
0.0556165762,
-0.0229323786,
0.0380306281,
0.0305088554,
-0.0214748029,
0.0094835795,
-0.0456949882,
0.0344464891,
0.0259931628,
-0.0117809987,
0.0798343718,
0.0620297603,
-0.0609841384,
0.0751461387,
-0.0528210253,
0.031172106,
0.0110978931,
-0.0054510455,
-0.0309735928,
0.0037487352,
-0.0377869979,
0.0027043247,
0.0529398434,
0.0304622743,
-0.0388727337,
0.0144076711,
-0.0458389297,
-0.0250624921,
0.0117190909,
0.0056161974,
0.0225748811,
-0.0060582766,
0.0418647714,
0.0018394189,
-0.02005901,
-0.0265620928,
0.0293742903,
0.0119389398,
0.0045677498,
-0.0069025271,
0.0280216653,
0.0154948859,
-0.0008251391,
-0.0426852405,
-0.0500059463,
-0.0050741732,
-0.0251438059,
-0.0026578438,
0.0325165503,
0.0080155032,
-0.0507354736,
0.0326323584,
-0.116011925,
-0.014625174,
0.0755941495,
-0.0241208319,
-0.0256631821,
0.0082368208,
-0.0022636775,
-0.0178575944,
0.0147805838,
0.0082421061,
-0.0463829264,
0.0229032505,
-0.0234339423,
0.0247049835,
0.001265165,
0.0157118998,
0.0360605307,
-0.0651782677,
0.0439268537,
-0.0157365799,
-0.033998277,
0.018931793,
0.0270381402,
0.0197442602,
0.0411241651,
-0.0045426767,
-0.0139419632,
-0.0263140965,
-0.0680153593,
-0.0466138534,
-0.0228890404,
0.0155241815,
0.0208340753,
0.0163537432,
0.004711268,
-0.0144100729,
-0.0343042947,
-0.0198206529,
0.0105489464,
0.0433469266,
0.0260119215,
-0.0322219916,
0.0160785541,
0.0141778272,
-0.0353687368,
-0.0310957674,
0.0686868951,
0.0332758799,
-0.050832849,
-0.0720607042,
-0.0252676532,
-0.0020416325,
-0.0051406287,
-0.0102607906,
-0.0213033557,
-0.0306098126,
-0.0050613834,
0.0075215525,
0.0275296867,
0.0486894101,
-0.0192190353,
0.0285831746,
-0.0285399817,
-0.0447249301,
-0.036480397,
0.0115751186,
0.020694064,
-0.0230441652,
-0.0629333705,
0.0185451265,
0.0154773211,
0.0005828782,
-0.0155776814,
-0.0611793511,
-0.0054804715,
-0.0142136123,
-0.0025744338,
-0.0006220266,
-0.0041517224,
-0.004779323,
0.0340964496,
-0.0150893927,
-0.02262461,
0.0679174215,
0.0132210413,
0.0535963736,
-0.0512702763,
0.0323079191,
-0.031191444,
-0.0341700539,
-0.0395437963,
0.0466395244,
0.0078904172,
-0.0255707037,
-0.0681544319,
0.0036845787,
0.060017515,
-0.0238925684,
0.0196150206,
-0.0195774119,
0.0239348263,
-0.0469931811,
-0.0105873412,
-0.0300203115,
-0.0547065996,
0.0449318215,
-0.0377801098,
0.0559038818,
-0.0025821284,
-0.0067303795,
0.0550195798,
-0.0076371566,
0.0016574475,
-0.0073709814,
0.0121969804,
0.0464265235,
0.0244633108,
0.0400644951,
-0.0137253944,
0.0284891818,
0.0095509058,
-0.0227832794,
0.0083557125,
-0.008193641,
0.0069284025,
0.0425407551,
-0.0050769937,
0.0551047809,
-0.0624525212,
-0.0094325831,
-0.0519905575,
0.026207082,
0.0221766718,
0.0052279253,
0.0724039748,
0.0090480885,
-0.1305733025,
-0.0524253845,
-0.0506015606,
-0.0408502743,
0.0083610294,
0.002523897,
-0.0839710012,
0.0157606434,
0.0006539839,
-0.000572211,
0.0009909461,
-0.0366605669,
0.0083982227,
-0.0979870781,
-0.0436962061,
0.0094508128,
-0.0432917923,
-0.069675222,
-0.034609627,
0.0001882165,
-0.0344739556,
0.0050940514,
0.0056726951,
0.0232250746,
-0.0112748519,
0.0123594301,
-0.0104717109,
-0.0568818599,
-0.0371059142,
-0.0357532278,
0.0289334487,
-0.0055191647,
0.0211377833,
-0.0484771952,
-0.0317874812,
0.0004565518,
-0.0266956389,
-0.080121465,
-0.0242753364,
0.0742287487,
-0.0260169376,
-0.0252652299,
0.0031156265,
0.0293166619,
0.0036507321,
0.0216501094,
0.0132270632,
0.0330953076,
0.064241305,
-0.0337155908,
-0.0187343433,
-0.020273678,
0.0503178611,
0.0227556005,
0.0192722976,
-0.0456240624,
0.0137924878,
-0.0651345253,
-0.0015303543,
-0.0391706787,
-0.0712541416,
0.0105607426,
0.0019474996,
-0.0706261173,
-0.0500468984,
-0.0108542871,
-0.0237440094,
0.0126666687,
0.0410853811,
-0.0152532225,
0.0138027025,
-0.007076202,
-0.0045511331,
-0.0254212059,
-0.0473889671,
0.0443484969,
-0.0305088125,
-0.0053951261,
0.005652098,
-0.0239909943,
-0.0092465682,
-0.0291296765,
-0.0377831757,
-0.0546515994,
0.0297425129,
0.0844001696,
0.0136712426,
0.0114041762,
-0.0321298838,
-0.0602738447,
0.0313400067,
0.0851783901,
-0.0122268572,
-0.0244842377,
0.0126649123,
-0.0148829846,
0.0034604801,
0.060039781,
-0.0440171212,
0.0012215537,
0.004291499,
-0.0048908358,
0.00361456,
-0.0160585865,
0.0068527069,
0.0224086829,
0.0310596973,
-0.0435878932,
0.0409620553,
-0.0581375025,
-0.0044531957,
0.0189037472,
-0.0459408946,
0.0269398503,
-0.0035908537,
0.0544038564,
0.0077709313,
-0.0092639402,
0.0175527316,
0.004743333,
-0.0102048563,
-0.0449471585,
0.0561410449,
0.0420251153,
0.0654037446,
0.0128297573,
0.0123961903,
-0.0011318226,
-0.0171074718,
0.0338230878,
0.0153409475,
-0.0137053244,
0.0301465243,
0.0394854769,
-0.0006474846,
0.0430438854,
0.0100616515,
0.0155845843,
0.035819523,
-0.0251899324,
-0.0207701661,
0.0802297965,
-0.0126571609,
0.0799260661,
0.0322524272,
-0.0238046478,
-0.0013641772,
0.007893499,
0.0149233965,
0.0110503966,
0.0707238987,
-0.0051037767,
-0.0080215363,
0.0346263871,
0.0721516907,
-0.025741851,
0.0397831947,
-0.0027782253,
-0.079783529,
-0.0133326696,
-0.0400124975,
-0.0188669469,
-0.0149161723,
-0.0082984883,
-0.0241536256,
-0.0384561531,
-0.0549721941,
-0.0011052762,
-0.0514259301,
0.0386018641,
0.00882129,
-0.0097839758,
0.0645276383,
0.0359027758,
0.0004151068,
-0.0197048485,
0.0283684656,
-0.0418956541,
0.0036892372,
0.0055165733,
-5.330002525e-33,
-0.02381563,
-0.0099872546,
-0.0555411913,
0.0177601855,
0.0184183586,
-0.0430118553,
0.0016972201,
-0.0015100508,
-0.0528549924,
0.0366436541,
0.0167624224,
0.0316173881,
0.0181990825,
-0.0083146663,
0.0041118087,
-0.0146817025,
0.0377819389,
0.0563464127,
-0.0398695283,
0.0142764114,
0.0254630018,
-0.0224930421,
0.1108681485,
-0.0629686266,
0.0461556092,
-0.0239139367,
-0.0180916432,
0.0165554043,
-0.0242971163,
0.0378233381,
0.0285658501,
0.0954420865,
0.0555772297,
-0.0246333815,
0.0090354634,
-0.0101601994,
-0.0369935073,
-0.0019138348,
0.0257166848,
0.0934091955,
0.0448414646,
-0.0386756845,
0.0683435127,
0.0083823837,
-0.0137601728,
-0.0030662329,
0.0616450831,
0.0125915818,
0.02871955,
0.0011141407,
-0.0432912409,
0.0314535201,
-0.01651375,
0.0243310947,
-0.0155840954,
0.0467879996,
0.0442916863,
0.0039366893,
-0.0784726813,
0.0150771579,
-0.004547419,
0.0190576166,
0.0253040567,
-0.007162028,
-0.0378321931,
0.013619246,
0.0234775264,
0.0299928188,
-0.0117077669,
-0.0177685786,
-0.0042779082,
-0.0408836938,
0.0318440087,
0.0880742744,
0.036660891,
-0.0758206397,
-0.0399330072,
0.04439364,
0.0161960181,
0.0672232211,
0.0154594881,
-0.0205360278,
-0.0225553308,
-0.0410265662,
0.0052062613,
-0.10107328,
-0.0379239544,
-0.0102722524,
0.0165329184,
-0.0169838406,
-0.051581692,
0.0544368774,
0.0334161073,
-0.0465466827,
-0.0058918176,
0.0525060073,
-0.0520205125,
0.0187827665,
-0.0025571289,
-0.0038003665,
-0.0480843261,
-0.0125037767,
0.0040124394,
0.0388801508,
0.0201891232,
0.0100278538,
0.0363019928,
0.0141483769,
-0.0750447065,
-0.0096807247,
-0.0105213718,
0.0007255711,
0.0067669102,
0.0512606241,
0.0050099604,
-0.0175576471,
-0.0176111683,
-0.0364354588,
0.0655325651,
0.0040495391,
-0.0038096923,
-0.0352698155,
-0.0014127633,
0.0078145349,
-0.0260268636,
-0.0051277759,
-0.0148447305,
0.0045854044,
-0.0207244009,
-0.063891165,
-0.0120930169,
-0.041252356,
2.387e-7,
-0.0075079338,
0.0476540811,
-0.0005669027,
-0.0206524115,
0.0195201728,
0.0067413594,
-0.0158505701,
0.0425253697,
-0.0207978562,
-0.0006572932,
-0.0421392322,
0.0131930057,
-0.0155312419,
0.040308971,
-0.0723128393,
-0.0226142611,
-0.0511090942,
0.056820441,
-0.0234870967,
-0.0111562489,
-0.0126727335,
0.024429867,
0.0115513336,
-0.0248824451,
-0.0139538236,
-0.0014833661,
0.0611634441,
0.0110064233,
0.0295332279,
0.031835366,
0.0592211932,
-0.0213504713,
0.0116168987,
0.0314539485,
-0.0056033521,
-0.0105802035,
0.0340255275,
0.0340287164,
0.0081747426,
0.0574156865,
-0.0190631486,
-0.0032358188,
0.0242516678,
-0.0542074107,
0.0390849449,
0.0525404736,
-0.0386488289,
-0.0434251204,
-0.0648081377,
-0.0155742001,
0.0446122587,
-0.0187711306,
-0.042233035,
0.0092183026,
0.0138021931,
0.006894106,
-0.0236721393,
-0.0560765043,
-0.054845795,
-0.0510777794,
-0.0082229655,
-0.0508990102,
0.0236016233,
-0.0066006342,
0.002912869,
-0.010064546,
0.0651538,
1.603618347e-34,
0.0418328904,
-0.0201399531,
0.0054418682,
-0.0063728974,
0.0263130683,
-0.0270546395,
-0.0276792776,
-0.0088714277,
0.0133830402,
-0.036528714,
-0.0133068152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15166v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15166v3 | SOLAR 10.7B: Scaling Large Language Models with Simple yet Effective Depth Up-Scaling | 2023-12-23T05:11:37 | 2024-04-04T01:53:38 | Dahyun Kim, Chanjun Park, Sanghoon Kim, Wonsung Lee, Wonho Song, Yunsu Kim, Hyeonwoo Kim, Yungi Kim, Hyeonju Lee, Jihoo Kim, Changbae Ahn, Seonghoon Yang, Sukyung Lee, Hyunbyung Park, Gyoungjin Gim, Mikyoung Cha, Hwalsuk Lee, Sunghun Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce SOLAR 10.7B, a large language model (LLM) with 10.7 billion
parameters, demonstrating superior performance in various natural language
processing (NLP) tasks. Inspired by recent efforts to efficiently up-scale
LLMs, we present a method for scaling LLMs called depth up-scaling (DUS), which
encompasses depthwise scaling and continued pretraining. In contrast to other
LLM up-scaling methods that use mixture-of-experts, DUS does not require
complex changes to train and inference efficiently. We show experimentally that
DUS is simple yet effective in scaling up high-performance LLMs from small
ones. Building on the DUS model, we additionally present SOLAR 10.7B-Instruct,
a variant fine-tuned for instruction-following capabilities, surpassing
Mixtral-8x7B-Instruct. SOLAR 10.7B is publicly available under the Apache 2.0
license, promoting broad access and application in the LLM field. | [
0.031776458,
0.0790894628,
0.013936271,
0.0318479501,
-0.0128199877,
0.0206226725,
0.0302051064,
-0.0273674466,
-0.0037486071,
-0.0523549244,
-0.0488618091,
-0.0125711858,
0.0088496478,
0.0292585324,
0.0089905299,
-0.0521872044,
0.0463337526,
-0.063766852,
-0.0441879183,
0.0095574837,
-0.0082770409,
0.0298746545,
0.0089216186,
0.0375963561,
-0.0002939862,
-0.0007107462,
-0.0137934471,
0.0034515187,
0.0149053559,
-0.0137964562,
-0.0017637806,
0.0508429073,
0.0760904402,
0.0317472406,
0.00000231,
-0.0059300475,
0.0042132176,
-0.017016422,
-0.0332914628,
0.0607032552,
0.0341438986,
-0.0403816402,
0.0111347679,
0.0205549709,
-0.005653732,
-0.0494652838,
0.0403625853,
0.0478610694,
0.0524559505,
0.0791115686,
0.0003766713,
-0.0664205551,
0.0749508291,
-0.0431627333,
-0.0547894798,
-0.0322792977,
0.0365801826,
-0.001055453,
-0.0160518885,
0.0543355756,
0.0076971054,
0.0330702178,
0.0185563229,
0.0182514526,
0.0108459285,
0.0307483394,
0.0245522615,
-0.0112230564,
-0.0029523892,
0.069772698,
-0.0507963896,
0.0027538764,
-0.0205501467,
-0.0127634108,
-0.0384656116,
-0.0201407522,
-0.0248180646,
0.0208123717,
0.0314902663,
0.0144280083,
0.014376563,
0.0008394739,
0.0552255102,
0.0283081289,
-0.0224440265,
0.0517135523,
0.0368710048,
-0.0038762731,
-0.0077731684,
-0.0069250963,
-0.0121579636,
-0.0440113991,
0.0292667039,
0.0130458716,
-0.0381238051,
0.0204034988,
-0.0315067582,
-0.012246768,
0.0151136192,
-0.0596617348,
0.0351537578,
0.0377540067,
-0.0022074343,
0.0720366985,
-0.0210118778,
0.0063598873,
-0.0267621838,
0.0154800275,
-0.0218737945,
-0.007323442,
-0.0039437008,
0.0018565685,
-0.0420745909,
0.0051951036,
-0.0380669497,
-0.0586531796,
-0.0427429974,
0.0025576749,
0.0190838035,
-0.0258782785,
0.0403919667,
0.0169839896,
-0.0413997732,
-0.0277423225,
0.0013679236,
0.0695125833,
-0.0341521651,
0.0323179998,
-0.0078944378,
-0.0361671038,
-0.0169254541,
0.0268025063,
0.0118768569,
-0.0217823908,
0.0501101501,
0.0545296296,
-0.0043023727,
-0.0614404269,
-0.066433996,
0.0090723243,
-0.0082796393,
-0.0728438571,
-0.0402477458,
-0.0743896663,
0.0578905232,
-0.0104128439,
0.0199259371,
-0.0548596717,
0.0273686405,
0.0321309157,
-0.0408167541,
0.0910440907,
-0.0099469377,
0.0062637883,
0.0156043312,
0.0150654735,
-0.0049355468,
0.0600216761,
0.0418743864,
0.0452575237,
-0.0020375391,
-0.0040418496,
-0.0339795016,
0.0242743716,
-0.0078224987,
0.0232639555,
-0.0318185203,
0.0008601628,
-0.0217768885,
0.0516609736,
0.0517930686,
0.0628007501,
-0.042992834,
-0.0093484828,
0.0543649644,
0.0549025536,
0.0117536485,
0.0554063767,
0.0564447641,
0.0091338493,
-0.0282315109,
-0.0305967834,
-0.0591998696,
0.0148746753,
-0.0227370188,
-0.0137126315,
0.0693803057,
0.0710530728,
-0.0273083746,
-0.0355403423,
-0.013435252,
0.0046257921,
-0.0005827553,
0.0066228076,
0.031474553,
-0.0009387719,
-0.0251683164,
0.0567154624,
0.0563126653,
-0.0366722867,
0.0077556479,
-0.0224427972,
0.002127168,
0.0772986785,
0.0412102677,
-0.029067874,
0.0210626386,
-0.0067061842,
0.0243159123,
0.0476423316,
0.0261990149,
-0.0024663596,
0.0474684089,
-0.0857397467,
-0.0139478445,
-0.0163202155,
0.0146241263,
0.0348663591,
0.0382303782,
0.003701081,
0.0157338586,
-0.0069506294,
-0.0063406406,
0.0314075053,
-0.0546492897,
-0.0457264595,
0.0229532924,
-0.0206209179,
0.0044870418,
-0.0044375453,
-0.0160388201,
0.0003494502,
0.0052548922,
-0.031698484,
-0.0150774391,
-0.0411118716,
-0.0726401359,
-0.0763721019,
0.0221771244,
-0.0002275582,
0.014653259,
0.0070604309,
-0.0377198756,
-0.0336841159,
0.0396011472,
-0.0276185442,
0.0388196111,
-0.0408199839,
0.0272747912,
0.0080916723,
0.055889111,
-0.0344940759,
0.0522348918,
-0.0279593822,
-0.0080384864,
0.0218848288,
0.0133808721,
-0.0179890152,
-0.0183816403,
-0.0243840609,
-0.0017977285,
0.0176534802,
0.0240618698,
-0.0252468083,
0.0072272648,
-0.0200307779,
-0.0265268628,
-0.0912692174,
0.0183564536,
-0.0331974961,
0.0088089807,
0.0173536316,
0.0472097583,
0.0055910787,
-0.0261369962,
0.0152682848,
0.0096758986,
-0.0130991694,
0.0177690294,
0.0010820311,
-0.0034060318,
-0.0071505508,
-0.0481174551,
-0.0444262698,
-0.0056523061,
0.0511572547,
-0.0209031031,
-0.0082875527,
-0.0490578637,
0.0288530197,
-0.0041493415,
0.0508210137,
0.0082974443,
-0.0245929155,
-0.0079099042,
-0.0236328822,
0.0605082698,
0.0621924959,
0.010678553,
0.0116440319,
0.0719038397,
-0.0232131053,
-0.0535691902,
0.0434269272,
-0.0138309151,
0.0084680961,
-0.0498960018,
-0.0066885385,
-0.0167220645,
0.0834277794,
-0.0117280129,
-0.0009855374,
-0.0351723209,
-0.0095750447,
-0.0061237146,
-0.0341218039,
-0.0095824888,
-0.0219392572,
-0.0123096844,
0.0025164133,
-0.0022059784,
-0.0565090105,
0.0428595953,
-0.0673230439,
-0.0016872644,
-0.0348560847,
-0.0312861577,
-0.0440615974,
0.0700448155,
0.0207029451,
0.0143756829,
-0.0372530594,
-0.0275991,
-0.018152345,
0.034556672,
-0.0147073204,
0.0006716904,
0.0607971884,
-0.0502252579,
0.0368050002,
-0.0336363651,
-0.0268480405,
-0.0333261192,
-0.0325857922,
-0.0467959009,
0.0076719285,
0.0305105951,
-0.040882878,
-0.0491497032,
0.0032694365,
0.0343450867,
0.0636703223,
0.0033492544,
-0.0062849824,
-0.0334992558,
0.0136281522,
0.0328197815,
0.0203150567,
0.0359379239,
-0.0394130871,
0.025443295,
0.0453969091,
-0.0079134293,
-0.0085416734,
-0.0709945634,
-0.005226539,
0.0184017997,
-0.023620395,
-0.0095645338,
-0.0060898825,
0.0566245094,
-0.0678106099,
-0.0062605161,
0.1169613898,
0.021082703,
-0.0655326247,
0.025997078,
0.038263727,
0.0453334935,
0.0124022178,
0.0244490374,
-0.0599566959,
-0.0568679608,
0.0062289019,
-0.006153069,
0.0268382765,
-0.0254645012,
-0.0153297987,
-0.0960945636,
0.0233099908,
0.0102407988,
-0.0120399613,
-0.0335832871,
-0.0572414435,
0.0094069643,
-0.0297865756,
0.0466535613,
0.0030142996,
-0.0336042717,
-0.0243388098,
-0.0030499755,
-0.0023242764,
-0.0418809764,
0.0569022037,
-0.0392853729,
0.049230136,
0.0120930439,
0.0081061032,
0.0280024223,
0.0022118748,
0.0286785979,
-0.005066704,
0.0239723809,
-0.0334513485,
0.0481040739,
-0.02888822,
-0.0105655482,
0.0026733868,
0.0058140638,
-0.0509933084,
0.0051139011,
-0.006501399,
0.0498075522,
-0.0110655325,
-0.002608354,
-0.0182558689,
-0.0026180523,
-0.0193282403,
0.0609620661,
0.0364892446,
-0.0241455287,
-0.0324900113,
-0.0180580951,
-0.0466065556,
-0.0222401228,
-0.0321937986,
0.0087168571,
-0.010235101,
-0.0090157548,
-0.0325149298,
-0.0153563581,
0.0362266488,
0.0162996743,
-0.0071998406,
-0.0080620162,
0.0085173659,
0.0074541736,
-0.0133152828,
0.0414084941,
-0.0249541905,
0.0176733732,
-0.0485663712,
-0.0057531814,
0.0485089757,
0.0135723744,
-0.0008290409,
0.0186158866,
-0.1201210693,
-0.072865814,
-0.0157493427,
0.0165263433,
0.0120860981,
0.0448941402,
-0.0158113856,
-0.0932588354,
0.0434945598,
0.0088218581,
-0.0376748256,
0.0183301046,
0.0092187645,
-0.0086310524,
-0.0039762175,
0.0576744527,
-0.0013499238,
0.034303043,
-0.0078411717,
0.0543872304,
-0.0298456997,
-0.065122366,
-0.0170404203,
-0.0029510201,
0.0068653221,
-0.0034707417,
0.0183213968,
-0.0457846038,
0.0153524848,
-0.0395783484,
-0.0045703365,
-0.0462367572,
0.0093071582,
0.0440030359,
0.0029446643,
-0.0100178868,
-0.0016573614,
0.0405880138,
0.0028412892,
-0.0157796554,
0.0266654827,
0.0071345414,
-0.0172706284,
0.0423551425,
-0.0014494502,
-0.0379707702,
0.0478315316,
-0.0269902069,
0.0129617974,
-0.0443053804,
0.0272373129,
-0.0104468763,
-0.0242104549,
-0.059316922,
0.0243357755,
-0.0485154018,
-0.0793248117,
-0.0519447699,
0.0497422628,
0.0537325107,
-0.0017966965,
0.0655370653,
-0.0115388026,
-0.012648562,
-0.0213230308,
0.0119453482,
-0.0167970192,
-0.0123055661,
0.0300207529,
0.0314919129,
-0.0220497269,
0.0298119634,
0.0681007057,
0.0304325018,
0.0369766578,
0.0192122664,
0.0101348041,
-0.0272959303,
-0.046551697,
-0.0034442556,
0.0556489937,
-0.0499843657,
0.0426677503,
0.0077871196,
-0.0482904762,
-0.0583045222,
-0.0047960356,
-0.0130204102,
-0.0097399205,
0.0297508966,
0.0295230709,
-0.0131337643,
-0.0326444507,
-0.0192990564,
0.0259487871,
0.0172297657,
-0.0485705771,
-0.0040082894,
-7.202178215e-33,
-0.0336908214,
0.0405778997,
0.0272722803,
-0.0581091754,
-0.0098107131,
0.0134245772,
-0.0152860899,
0.0081158765,
-0.0327169858,
0.0099448739,
-0.0267795231,
0.0202086475,
0.0107275369,
0.0490472205,
0.0370148085,
-0.0049367058,
0.0965953246,
-0.0063032014,
0.006237282,
0.0376481786,
0.0229762774,
0.0222467054,
0.0611855984,
-0.0334345847,
-0.0512723476,
0.041165445,
-0.0186249129,
0.0411940962,
-0.0094691468,
0.0237200186,
-0.065727964,
0.0183623992,
0.0177274272,
-0.0261431821,
-0.0340711661,
-0.0088826166,
-0.0757839158,
-0.0003473637,
-0.0001229331,
0.0101595456,
-0.0804485232,
-0.0103695011,
0.046559602,
0.0091218073,
0.0191496685,
-0.0463636704,
0.0170254521,
-0.0242091697,
-0.0184306782,
0.0045324769,
-0.0480842851,
0.057259623,
0.0117263235,
-0.0044716429,
0.0226646326,
-0.0132031571,
-0.0078879427,
0.0278189983,
-0.0266744159,
-0.0109346928,
0.0400589742,
0.0594096556,
0.0322362371,
0.0325546339,
-0.0001988432,
0.0489696078,
-0.017855389,
0.001900835,
-0.0272433609,
-0.007392833,
0.0214468352,
0.0880580992,
0.0061164554,
0.0224252045,
0.0292079505,
0.0223361868,
-0.0665688217,
-0.0032064747,
0.0486009642,
0.0359375179,
0.0154065834,
0.0294867549,
-0.0220801421,
-0.0247321855,
-0.0277445577,
-0.0091556367,
-0.0325457528,
-0.0386020169,
0.0214587804,
0.0455164425,
-0.0279617477,
-0.0132488739,
0.0419432297,
-0.0577699468,
-0.0231819432,
0.0143439714,
0.0141883194,
-0.0107951676,
0.0075633633,
0.0379680805,
-0.0786300227,
-0.020236047,
0.0161382183,
-0.029554436,
-0.0089632357,
-0.0001686631,
-0.0016074351,
0.0226678159,
-0.0771386102,
-0.0266910736,
-0.0072880429,
-0.0144090671,
0.0072988309,
0.0793566629,
0.0198472086,
-0.0134845832,
0.000888418,
0.0573162064,
-0.0015819424,
0.0098896613,
-0.0171361491,
-0.0499146134,
0.03341645,
0.0372432284,
-0.0374359526,
0.0054782713,
-0.0656167567,
-0.0710294619,
0.0489682294,
-0.0823440924,
-0.0310304407,
0.0250339881,
2.924e-7,
0.0269755069,
0.0684330687,
0.0178504921,
-0.0125875548,
0.0101527451,
0.0086109042,
0.0134154977,
0.0379459187,
-0.0013330842,
-0.0189623181,
0.0129486965,
0.0572054237,
0.0466774181,
0.0266805217,
-0.0677009523,
-0.0092596849,
-0.0653875396,
0.014824992,
-0.0799054727,
-0.0647804663,
0.0142942565,
0.1305511147,
0.0138978744,
-0.0285491422,
0.0246148519,
-0.0368857719,
0.0483123809,
0.0051281583,
-0.0124272853,
0.0279854797,
0.0374491699,
0.046624314,
-0.0132301627,
0.0159937385,
-0.0127804801,
0.0465299711,
0.0007748429,
0.1173701063,
-0.0261761919,
0.00959804,
0.0241979118,
-0.0252258815,
-0.009211258,
-0.0705676898,
0.0556539558,
-0.0266688168,
0.0052241418,
-0.0589261167,
-0.001802724,
-0.0127578722,
0.0153563889,
-0.0146160899,
-0.0114939874,
0.0263866782,
0.0405388363,
-0.0273926016,
-0.0466209799,
-0.1056255549,
-0.0399908014,
-0.0050592721,
-0.0539718792,
-0.0202802811,
-0.0429763682,
-0.0253055282,
0.0345118791,
-0.0339163579,
0.0057360777,
2.874341516e-34,
0.0550711676,
-0.0122615835,
0.0105313538,
-0.0003242157,
0.031450212,
-0.0118679889,
-0.0250419471,
-0.0068901405,
-0.0205328204,
-0.1394663453,
-0.028722981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15159v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15159v2 | Understanding the Potential of FPGA-Based Spatial Acceleration for Large Language Model Inference | 2023-12-23T04:27:06 | 2024-04-07T06:03:02 | Hongzheng Chen, Jiahao Zhang, Yixiao Du, Shaojie Xiang, Zichao Yue, Niansong Zhang, Yaohui Cai, Zhiru Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.AR, cs.CL | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) boasting billions of
parameters have generated a significant demand for efficient deployment in
inference workloads. The majority of existing approaches rely on temporal
architectures that reuse hardware units for different network layers and
operators. However, these methods often encounter challenges in achieving low
latency due to considerable memory access overhead. This paper investigates the
feasibility and potential of model-specific spatial acceleration for LLM
inference on FPGAs. Our approach involves the specialization of distinct
hardware units for specific operators or layers, facilitating direct
communication between them through a dataflow architecture while minimizing
off-chip memory accesses. We introduce a comprehensive analytical model for
estimating the performance of a spatial LLM accelerator, taking into account
the on-chip compute and memory resources available on an FPGA. Through our
analysis, we can determine the scenarios in which FPGA-based spatial
acceleration can outperform its GPU-based counterpart. To enable more
productive implementations of an LLM model on FPGAs, we further provide a
library of high-level synthesis (HLS) kernels that are composable and reusable.
This library will be made available as open-source. To validate the
effectiveness of both our analytical model and HLS library, we have implemented
BERT and GPT2 on an AMD Alveo U280 FPGA device. Experimental results
demonstrate our approach can achieve up to 13.4x speedup when compared to
previous FPGA-based accelerators for the BERT model. For GPT generative
inference, we attain a 2.2x speedup compared to DFX, an FPGA overlay, in the
prefill stage, while achieving a 1.9x speedup and a 5.7x improvement in energy
efficiency compared to the NVIDIA A100 GPU in the decode stage. | [
0.0264315382,
0.0735434368,
-0.0362215973,
0.0493868887,
-0.0358789526,
0.0173645951,
0.060708601,
-0.0278406907,
0.0139722228,
-0.0369806327,
0.0129060717,
-0.057691399,
0.0065163854,
0.0104162944,
0.0402966216,
-0.0510584377,
0.027849732,
-0.0370520726,
-0.0538651682,
-0.054043334,
0.0018881023,
0.0264372341,
0.013387097,
0.036242567,
-0.0146560594,
0.0080149518,
-0.0228742734,
-0.0060891374,
0.0245166477,
0.0468185581,
-0.0051432052,
0.031117171,
0.033166796,
0.0525265709,
0.0000023514,
0.0149122374,
-0.0092019327,
0.0301427208,
-0.0019656033,
0.0581149273,
0.0591813326,
-0.0034483529,
-0.0423232727,
-0.006024159,
0.0078093777,
-0.0523726121,
0.0813733861,
-0.0106402375,
-0.0177201293,
0.0266009774,
-0.0150436843,
-0.0698860362,
0.0555782728,
-0.0319171771,
-0.0315575935,
-0.0032450743,
0.0270462967,
-0.0295138825,
0.0207019299,
-0.0229283031,
-0.0043569719,
0.0524567217,
0.0244820099,
0.0414742343,
-0.0222757887,
0.0361015387,
-0.0403013639,
0.0127535602,
-0.0201705415,
0.0500334576,
-0.0536824688,
-0.0541185066,
0.0400234051,
0.0121816956,
-0.063838385,
0.0197077245,
-0.0119007705,
0.0388642289,
-0.0293894149,
-0.0036221363,
0.0487726927,
-0.0567742586,
0.0078415005,
-0.0075530526,
-0.0366118662,
0.0433060974,
0.0913963392,
0.0235805865,
-0.0811498314,
0.0042030262,
-0.0556307137,
-0.0639833957,
0.0251581557,
0.0161913168,
-0.0130035067,
0.0367627591,
-0.0785531923,
-0.0217016432,
-0.0171979461,
-0.0826566815,
0.0098046074,
0.0595668554,
0.0150239673,
-0.0039316774,
-0.0584388338,
0.0235897936,
-0.0744813085,
0.0252910145,
-0.040327061,
-0.0199489463,
0.0381239802,
-0.0075930553,
-0.041544266,
-0.0014152488,
-0.0455217101,
-0.0016102169,
-0.0442317612,
0.0354589112,
-0.0116302706,
-0.0228566714,
-0.0420349576,
0.0054775449,
-0.0181121193,
-0.0075690076,
0.0336839445,
0.0083928937,
-0.0065288409,
0.005230288,
-0.0660066605,
-0.0836975873,
-0.0088173384,
0.0193330348,
0.0365156308,
-0.0072983378,
0.0209655445,
0.0364198834,
-0.0112498719,
-0.0827741995,
-0.0329903662,
0.0039480701,
0.0139952078,
-0.0618383512,
0.0421160869,
-0.0779286921,
0.0508432277,
0.0340493843,
-0.0124926567,
0.0211393666,
-0.0008027404,
0.0218540635,
-0.0213837381,
0.0074778521,
-0.0099412277,
0.0180998594,
0.0505131483,
-0.0168596171,
0.0388821885,
0.0688381568,
0.019513689,
0.0502227917,
-0.015297018,
0.003640593,
-0.0127480319,
0.0693360046,
0.0016740649,
0.0016807076,
-0.0805606022,
-0.0060813408,
0.0063540339,
0.0137625951,
0.0515559018,
0.0433739237,
-0.0440574773,
-0.0106155965,
0.0342547074,
0.0598307997,
0.0020244285,
0.0694347396,
0.0657945424,
0.0214669742,
0.0107708424,
-0.0421685539,
-0.0072168917,
0.0204180479,
0.007695673,
0.000643222,
0.0512523539,
0.0666535944,
-0.0153218703,
0.0250949729,
-0.0151055548,
-0.0134942252,
-0.0226058718,
0.0310754199,
0.0598355122,
-0.0324275792,
-0.0349185802,
0.0574568734,
0.0437233485,
-0.0577779636,
-0.0734613538,
-0.0498884395,
0.0658155158,
0.0635645464,
0.0473058261,
-0.0092536407,
-0.0367178358,
0.0537424721,
-0.0099382261,
0.0147936447,
0.0282822363,
0.0118542742,
0.0049867462,
-0.0328553393,
-0.0053164866,
0.0237632655,
0.0165534113,
0.084854804,
0.0728912801,
0.0079237847,
0.0093991086,
-0.0123247942,
-0.0107949292,
-0.0038301949,
0.0094451793,
0.0126452921,
-0.0192201287,
0.0193058476,
0.0042258231,
-0.0161507167,
-0.0299389418,
-0.0015522863,
0.0118934838,
-0.0519748405,
0.0152614843,
-0.006027766,
-0.0244818851,
-0.0163955204,
0.0009255374,
0.0033964284,
0.002848167,
-0.0029118224,
-0.042206198,
-0.035551127,
0.0852021277,
-0.0553357191,
0.0761655942,
-0.0272780806,
0.0157482009,
0.0120230122,
0.0204148311,
-0.0023832729,
0.0559172295,
-0.012429202,
0.0288681295,
0.0444083698,
0.0338723734,
0.0151970088,
-0.0127798216,
-0.0110653033,
-0.0167856775,
0.0015848427,
-0.0080902018,
-0.0297145117,
-0.0339107737,
0.0129359849,
-0.0220222566,
-0.0804607272,
0.0004232624,
-0.0318253078,
0.0456038378,
0.0363692194,
0.0106817419,
-0.0163642429,
-0.0014941376,
0.0062143886,
-0.0057716724,
-0.0104203513,
0.0382536724,
-0.0183428209,
-0.024747761,
-0.0653560013,
-0.0257274192,
-0.051544223,
-0.0119840764,
0.0573870279,
-0.0030993633,
-0.0669478998,
-0.0188720003,
-0.041928947,
-0.0196363367,
0.092616424,
-0.0295736026,
-0.0207191277,
0.0158103686,
-0.0375912525,
0.07136558,
0.0503931791,
-0.0234550051,
-0.0138127971,
0.0434579216,
-0.0166518167,
-0.0212795343,
0.0420043357,
-0.0251689386,
-0.0131040756,
0.0133902421,
-0.0215092059,
-0.0602959022,
0.0674589053,
0.0084124347,
-0.0353992954,
-0.0346298069,
-0.0369064435,
0.0158161763,
-0.0153413909,
-0.0090821153,
-0.0195753109,
0.0079457508,
0.0043088146,
-0.0253283456,
-0.0592227131,
0.0051370873,
-0.0730089247,
0.0070779854,
0.0084977271,
0.0169101227,
-0.0175431184,
0.057290338,
0.0417827591,
0.0451208279,
-0.0581790321,
-0.0011101245,
0.0437609404,
0.0368610173,
-0.0284313858,
-0.0266611986,
0.0476283357,
-0.04512069,
0.0296987016,
-0.0427073874,
-0.0071272086,
-0.001142557,
0.0048219743,
-0.0417722724,
-0.0017865426,
0.0252091177,
-0.062069349,
0.0155444415,
0.046496205,
-0.0022121493,
0.0497919321,
-0.0178199075,
0.002453933,
-0.0170551017,
0.011136095,
0.0608980395,
0.0265616011,
-0.0305824764,
0.0263156947,
-0.0397282392,
0.0124897501,
0.0132655529,
-0.0023604361,
-0.0874061808,
0.0178416613,
0.0564471185,
-0.0011546278,
-0.0282458346,
0.0273824818,
0.0412598029,
-0.0620181672,
-0.0216128379,
0.0595663078,
0.0182763729,
0.0090466728,
-0.0098871524,
0.0593892075,
0.0469792113,
0.0100308144,
0.0590786412,
-0.070208177,
-0.0249327105,
0.0070419027,
-0.0337622799,
-0.0146757308,
0.0129581774,
-0.0129839936,
-0.0879020914,
0.0869658366,
-0.0074699195,
-0.0045903507,
-0.0531092174,
-0.039872162,
-0.0023302075,
0.033054769,
-0.0300600901,
-0.0050714426,
-0.0074198619,
0.0198898613,
0.007157966,
-0.0306333173,
0.0413764492,
0.0317474827,
0.0048911339,
0.0010846158,
0.0252415985,
0.0188692231,
0.0117300395,
-0.0717355758,
-0.0123765795,
0.0111085149,
0.0092267385,
-0.0148076266,
0.0079617584,
0.0093311509,
-0.0371257886,
-0.0422283523,
0.0135314828,
0.0139867784,
-0.0103441626,
-0.0496416017,
0.0563373901,
-0.012910041,
0.0187969059,
-0.0206582546,
-0.0000081981,
-0.0377908498,
0.0122585436,
0.0097958194,
0.0091367727,
-0.0582246929,
-0.0335471965,
-0.0469979569,
-0.0247237533,
0.0094493451,
-0.0227451716,
-0.0020329051,
-0.0270675737,
0.007819172,
0.0515605584,
0.0066668,
0.0165113453,
-0.0059098317,
-0.0057805539,
0.0254009459,
-0.027836781,
-0.0873851329,
0.0420097411,
-0.0360405706,
0.042657312,
-0.0118991416,
-0.0233625025,
0.0160824209,
-0.0304112863,
-0.0114411013,
0.0864763856,
-0.0771250352,
-0.0778652579,
0.0056658606,
0.0150195267,
0.0088101877,
0.0358494148,
-0.0073073516,
-0.0072060772,
0.0433907695,
0.0323889777,
0.0099548055,
0.0522282608,
0.008109279,
-0.0147913955,
-0.0128598027,
0.0105540166,
0.001774241,
0.0296060201,
0.0329990834,
0.0012750928,
0.0302451085,
-0.0447428375,
-0.0289741643,
0.007840124,
0.0520683788,
-0.0024260012,
0.0131983152,
-0.0232121982,
0.0289464239,
-0.0110812606,
0.0171859041,
-0.0489182249,
-0.0002206727,
-0.0068392083,
0.0041417759,
-0.0361989029,
-0.0293815602,
0.0568064414,
0.0059913616,
-0.0305024851,
-0.0128925163,
-0.0416762009,
-0.0197652262,
0.0003285569,
-0.0280187149,
-0.0029014917,
-0.0123074492,
0.0096939504,
0.0256256834,
-0.053985633,
0.0385622643,
-0.012551601,
-0.0054575666,
-0.0485736765,
0.0326093771,
-0.0237575397,
-0.0712711811,
-0.0791865885,
0.0380663276,
0.0590995029,
-0.0086606173,
0.0402900055,
-0.0426261015,
-0.0112879314,
-0.0158782937,
0.0288014989,
-0.0267883576,
-0.0467430949,
0.0574793071,
0.0024667419,
0.000746827,
-0.0243495516,
0.0360015966,
0.0329752713,
0.0563028157,
0.0030918708,
-0.0326611549,
0.0165888555,
-0.0832679719,
0.0155895259,
-0.0377466083,
-0.0216668509,
-0.0155607043,
-0.0224481709,
-0.0374361165,
-0.0062536281,
0.0101773478,
-0.0209867973,
-0.0145483157,
0.0420202389,
0.057021834,
-0.0040338198,
-0.0566601902,
-0.0145139312,
0.0314320773,
0.0235733092,
0.0067456192,
0.0181435626,
-6.832563853e-33,
-0.0264727212,
0.0105615379,
0.0361493491,
-0.0153501369,
-0.019796377,
0.0190454014,
-0.0225803424,
-0.0139925973,
-0.0088694599,
-0.0117971003,
-0.0107532823,
0.0028324556,
0.0011587179,
0.0011698843,
-0.0235447511,
0.0047957855,
0.0223559532,
0.0221181307,
0.0199493412,
0.0434925519,
0.0202148836,
0.0104812505,
0.072956942,
-0.0026093021,
-0.0645943582,
-0.0219004937,
0.0436456688,
-0.0339731574,
-0.0486900657,
0.0116237076,
-0.0582810007,
0.0425705686,
0.0008644125,
-0.0632462949,
0.0176625997,
0.0239610095,
-0.0801971257,
-0.0266716275,
0.0332975686,
0.0195110366,
-0.0126425726,
-0.0247650854,
0.0341470875,
0.0597451366,
-0.0318097323,
-0.0056505487,
-0.0319092982,
0.0191570912,
-0.0396973491,
-0.023218181,
-0.0553561226,
0.0329249687,
0.0441496111,
0.0224011727,
0.0619972087,
-0.0192754213,
-0.0125091569,
-0.0332274362,
-0.0068997387,
-0.0098196408,
0.0813241974,
0.0641593486,
0.0717127547,
0.0169849154,
0.0514761768,
0.0283210203,
0.0490169376,
-0.0159590133,
-0.0327665806,
0.0235156231,
0.0336713381,
0.0359572396,
-0.0166789014,
0.0193203203,
0.0434979908,
0.025366677,
-0.0645074919,
-0.0152297663,
-0.0093069309,
0.0186029077,
0.0388771929,
-0.0041404725,
-0.0171004161,
-0.0352692902,
-0.0307844933,
0.02929781,
-0.0252900477,
0.0194516089,
0.0153386043,
0.0171766542,
-0.0139375394,
-0.0040247464,
0.0116128977,
-0.0287193097,
0.0128129199,
-0.0138864107,
-0.0014576687,
0.0165620279,
0.0146765886,
0.0602420457,
-0.0171929915,
-0.0582878813,
-0.0058613606,
-0.0269134995,
0.005282619,
-0.0221943241,
-0.0095187249,
0.0584751442,
-0.0587381683,
0.0130700497,
-0.0637018308,
-0.0037303481,
-0.0274827462,
0.0416111611,
0.036375057,
0.0285786092,
0.0249158777,
0.0140458811,
-0.018369263,
0.0542843565,
-0.0125976428,
0.0094521297,
-0.0035222061,
0.0184909049,
-0.0446401425,
-0.0053260392,
-0.0716667101,
0.0249692574,
0.0218954049,
-0.0991854221,
-0.0485506207,
0.0171355531,
3.176e-7,
0.0251352508,
0.0377740115,
0.0444638729,
0.0400895588,
0.0308691338,
-0.011640029,
0.0429674275,
0.0284452159,
0.0117407255,
0.0300131589,
0.0345726758,
0.0321283303,
0.0383548848,
-0.0209314339,
-0.0315352008,
0.0523792617,
-0.0372887105,
0.0173386056,
-0.0513534211,
-0.0121696452,
0.003840537,
0.0973897055,
-0.0054954076,
-0.0180358291,
0.0385422073,
0.0047878893,
0.0281902514,
0.0089801354,
0.0237284023,
0.0077278013,
0.031641528,
0.0139808347,
-0.0273427144,
0.0184910279,
0.0167345591,
-0.0166275874,
-0.0355223939,
0.0846660584,
-0.0181019716,
0.0012498733,
0.0558020547,
-0.0536735021,
-0.0510218702,
-0.0909834728,
0.0670012087,
-0.0057084039,
0.0017650024,
-0.0573583357,
0.0195402708,
0.018984938,
-0.0292330291,
0.0027336804,
0.0759711415,
0.0154729802,
0.0289329421,
-0.0508622527,
-0.0170612056,
-0.0708322525,
-0.0324228331,
0.0177548323,
-0.0660653487,
-0.0448636673,
-0.0853917524,
-0.0037226442,
0.0182631835,
-0.0282436553,
-0.0022318275,
3.045823183e-34,
-0.0043880474,
0.0217116829,
-0.0304118562,
0.0164317153,
0.0198913496,
-0.0417998433,
0.0090414369,
0.0241037142,
-0.0488926619,
-0.0931789279,
-0.0402060449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15156v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15156v2 | Large Language Models as Zero-Shot Keyphrase Extractors: A Preliminary Empirical Study | 2023-12-23T03:50:49 | 2024-01-10T10:46:49 | Mingyang Song, Xuelian Geng, Songfang Yao, Shilong Lu, Yi Feng, Liping Jing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Zero-shot keyphrase extraction aims to build a keyphrase extractor without
training by human-annotated data, which is challenging due to the limited human
intervention involved. Challenging but worthwhile, zero-shot setting
efficiently reduces the time and effort that data labeling takes. Recent
efforts on pre-trained large language models (e.g., ChatGPT and ChatGLM) show
promising performance on zero-shot settings, thus inspiring us to explore
prompt-based methods. In this paper, we ask whether strong keyphrase extraction
models can be constructed by directly prompting the large language model
ChatGPT. Through experimental results, it is found that ChatGPT still has a lot
of room for improvement in the keyphrase extraction task compared to existing
state-of-the-art unsupervised and supervised models. | [
0.0753626153,
0.0440746695,
0.0176025834,
0.0453579463,
-0.0538832359,
0.0252450295,
0.0173236784,
0.0222897809,
0.046665255,
-0.0593490079,
-0.0527938567,
-0.0106909042,
-0.0791963488,
0.0472418182,
0.0134468973,
-0.0391519591,
0.0308702458,
-0.0523596331,
0.0187852345,
-0.0021642614,
0.0068684258,
0.0006578857,
-0.0053301547,
0.0137108499,
0.0390339904,
-0.0172217973,
-0.0305566993,
-0.0511009656,
0.0069155144,
-0.014830512,
0.0221158396,
0.0480890684,
-0.0065544196,
0.0442650877,
0.0000015926,
-0.0269276164,
-0.0207520723,
-0.0219617672,
-0.0418414809,
0.0487788096,
0.0644182265,
-0.0076594581,
0.0043309908,
0.006993481,
-0.0389440544,
-0.0508321114,
0.0466324985,
0.0421992838,
0.0618820302,
0.0400778167,
-0.0266059153,
-0.0564646274,
0.0093370834,
-0.0469127744,
-0.0014650429,
-0.0795229226,
0.0453330055,
-0.0421003774,
-0.0114600258,
0.0502601489,
0.0194316804,
0.0479998849,
-0.0145796454,
0.0101302667,
0.0608839467,
0.0489918962,
-0.0642546862,
-0.0491999201,
-0.0423238538,
0.0968917757,
-0.0297759585,
0.025013255,
0.0596689321,
-0.0285314023,
0.0042368034,
0.0262861382,
-0.0604154393,
0.0205308329,
-0.0065579428,
-0.00423533,
-0.0100793326,
-0.0178438202,
0.0119379666,
0.0232829731,
-0.0505732372,
0.0310473423,
0.0349400043,
-0.0287451018,
0.019485563,
-0.0043788636,
-0.0732952803,
-0.0444874093,
-0.0129845208,
0.017361911,
0.0266812928,
0.0381082073,
-0.0136788562,
0.0065211602,
0.0488300472,
-0.0945141464,
-0.0152696325,
-0.0300688986,
-0.0365069173,
0.0749405921,
-0.0257455688,
0.0486237891,
-0.0025039865,
0.0359586924,
-0.0162602253,
0.0026903609,
-0.0358778387,
-0.0254387408,
-0.0289864726,
0.0438293405,
0.0172421411,
-0.032966841,
-0.0350806341,
0.008088368,
0.0402457714,
0.0195284858,
0.0064840443,
-0.0039732386,
-0.0197240058,
-0.0152191306,
0.0619276352,
0.004951539,
-0.0169058144,
0.0046631582,
0.0020034146,
-0.0592768565,
-0.0209131353,
0.0156629197,
0.0704533085,
-0.0282253735,
0.0458012447,
0.0326790251,
-0.0098513654,
-0.0554282665,
0.0130328154,
-0.0230958946,
-0.0316541195,
-0.0102361003,
0.005943445,
-0.0573231392,
0.0378860757,
0.0116038499,
0.0017260184,
0.004271857,
0.0190298036,
0.0138251456,
-0.0818447769,
0.0640190244,
-0.0001247048,
-0.0131527297,
-0.0011591687,
0.0020265423,
-0.0063389838,
0.0321140066,
0.0043943594,
0.0544945374,
0.074716799,
-0.0262858849,
0.0280675683,
0.0698827282,
0.0185703691,
0.0166676156,
0.0096248481,
0.0063888403,
0.0411185585,
-0.0150556164,
-0.0224015508,
0.0296702664,
-0.0250493679,
0.0240321867,
0.047718998,
0.09089531,
-0.001973216,
0.0263961051,
0.0004702217,
0.0405135602,
0.0215868391,
-0.0119406683,
-0.0016725877,
-0.0395206399,
-0.0284529664,
0.0387183242,
0.0340859741,
0.0111761931,
-0.0109945415,
-0.016970627,
-0.0225345921,
0.0073145279,
-0.0154896285,
0.0044394103,
0.0897943079,
-0.01698827,
-0.0433660857,
0.0355934463,
0.0279763825,
-0.0512736887,
-0.0262988079,
-0.0568961762,
0.0135040702,
0.0212541465,
0.0473688692,
-0.0292146485,
-0.038965378,
0.012103417,
0.042783875,
0.0510435626,
0.0156594086,
-0.0256908443,
0.0086131115,
-0.0423291884,
-0.036049068,
0.0107862791,
0.0212178268,
-0.0027261376,
0.0397431962,
0.0132093895,
0.0210202429,
0.0041353637,
-0.013123706,
0.0216260422,
-0.0064415811,
-0.0867249221,
-0.0175876673,
-0.0297269542,
0.0131775783,
0.0120064011,
-0.0382871144,
0.0139956065,
0.0467031188,
-0.0453493409,
-0.0162398499,
-0.018060362,
-0.0136682838,
-0.005160809,
0.0353785269,
0.0227463786,
0.02265287,
-0.0102323005,
-0.0418012328,
-0.0264728125,
-0.0381073877,
0.0202386659,
0.0441503264,
-0.0303955358,
0.0186151061,
-0.0232344083,
0.0055852258,
-0.0481590927,
0.0709480047,
0.0250112526,
0.0028556893,
-0.0318063721,
-0.0313878283,
-0.0152525119,
-0.0048597967,
-0.0290725827,
0.0628363267,
0.0047597354,
-0.0058499202,
0.0459652171,
0.01917772,
-0.0385903046,
-0.0251857266,
-0.1034326702,
0.0175489578,
-0.0026475459,
0.0223103892,
0.0176359043,
0.0337618701,
-0.0301759858,
-0.0285153799,
-0.0383784138,
-0.0330631211,
-0.0002095609,
0.0250596777,
0.0198053271,
0.031059945,
-0.0151928961,
-0.0531613044,
0.0086998837,
-0.0058366843,
0.0438941009,
0.0434482209,
-0.0753355399,
0.016727332,
0.0647127852,
0.0196352173,
-0.0147246988,
0.0087542934,
-0.0493844822,
-0.0139840245,
-0.0404333845,
0.0175090749,
0.0285267457,
0.0290426128,
-0.0148333758,
-0.0033970773,
-0.0289116595,
-0.0497890934,
-0.0262783375,
-0.0259971935,
-0.0864824429,
0.0157728121,
0.0028369729,
0.0526622199,
0.0764376521,
-0.01357101,
0.0142547945,
-0.0445858985,
0.0149875861,
-0.0080433385,
0.0087107606,
-0.0731933489,
0.0185316913,
-0.0188560504,
0.0160807502,
-0.0276830327,
-0.0318226367,
0.0212493595,
-0.0388401188,
-0.0098664938,
-0.0141309779,
-0.004747692,
-0.0195251033,
0.0507649034,
-0.0213204678,
0.0027098747,
0.0316094458,
-0.0191979911,
0.0258172452,
-0.0343988538,
0.0161364861,
-0.0633483678,
0.0150620639,
-0.0247169454,
0.0198478028,
-0.0081264814,
-0.0067883953,
-0.0587786399,
-0.0900667161,
-0.0407039262,
-0.0195171013,
0.011782594,
-0.0196214654,
0.0385285988,
0.0248865522,
0.025178561,
0.0596272014,
-0.0205409899,
0.0136957346,
-0.0055585373,
0.0423272215,
0.0820993632,
-0.0469902828,
-0.0408624299,
-0.0353574604,
0.050851468,
0.0428629927,
0.0742768124,
0.0129475398,
0.0064096712,
-0.0055621732,
0.0348175354,
-0.0392354801,
-0.0075104539,
-0.0210648645,
0.0194241442,
-0.0188214388,
-0.006226867,
0.1221316531,
0.0374296829,
-0.0806619003,
-0.0244543068,
-0.0065304828,
-0.0077135828,
-0.0092122452,
0.0176838487,
-0.0700360909,
-0.0418027826,
-0.0014787536,
0.0219538193,
-0.0221261587,
-0.0269157961,
-0.0176584199,
-0.1034918725,
0.0379848555,
0.0180416871,
-0.0299445931,
-0.0117031261,
-0.0476454198,
-0.0002648455,
-0.050477609,
-0.0315280333,
-0.0022533555,
-0.0589074045,
0.0281726345,
0.005270856,
-0.030164497,
-0.0575987026,
0.0420298055,
-0.0690396503,
0.0131216124,
0.0840477794,
0.0057592769,
-0.0290813167,
0.0020911323,
0.0471526012,
0.0061646188,
-0.0392167158,
0.0113502955,
0.0370747671,
-0.0525722913,
-0.0166995302,
-0.0036891738,
0.0304487608,
-0.0259211995,
0.00512949,
0.076690942,
0.024616966,
0.0150822029,
0.0159407742,
0.0334236883,
-0.0193841942,
-0.0077992617,
0.0715129599,
0.0314177759,
-0.0348125733,
-0.0224674828,
-0.0000110814,
-0.0071578822,
-0.0460330583,
-0.0857179686,
-0.0374633633,
-0.0532302931,
0.0119648846,
-0.0546424426,
-0.0437083989,
0.0482990034,
0.0095910802,
-0.0068933107,
0.0182435848,
-0.019860981,
0.0174334608,
-0.0171855707,
0.0211234633,
-0.0426685065,
-0.0471723527,
-0.0843664408,
-0.0201112367,
0.0498935468,
-0.0184536595,
-0.0334383547,
0.0208810605,
-0.0413486138,
-0.0418855548,
0.0415990539,
0.0371508226,
0.0195219088,
0.0102560706,
-0.0140658636,
-0.028200509,
0.0686591193,
0.07027933,
-0.0346416123,
-0.0070007793,
0.0419146605,
0.005921009,
-0.0132357478,
0.0322874226,
-0.0544836558,
0.0250724778,
0.0288164653,
0.0518297702,
-0.0607871115,
-0.047546044,
-0.0022381896,
0.0318457521,
0.0830553994,
-0.0068113687,
-0.0061487271,
-0.0506334789,
-0.0116773946,
0.0027804363,
-0.0276680999,
-0.0381745435,
0.0334805697,
0.0129051432,
-0.0216796733,
-0.0198803432,
0.0182060711,
-0.0576428548,
0.0421350822,
-0.0420848019,
0.0061347494,
0.014529258,
-0.0104245599,
0.0129036736,
-0.0328048952,
-0.0333327465,
0.0164600946,
0.0098869679,
0.0085890656,
-0.0145556889,
0.0355316922,
0.0126666632,
-0.0569435507,
-0.0170061048,
0.0682135075,
-0.0766671225,
-0.0288964473,
-0.0326023474,
0.0515414141,
0.0847725123,
-0.0192664657,
0.0217626747,
-0.0263502002,
-0.0400428772,
-0.0086793676,
0.0250050183,
0.0219865926,
0.0047341464,
-0.0148168346,
0.0478490815,
-0.043097131,
0.0131529598,
0.0836710781,
0.0523442887,
0.0441101119,
0.0204436108,
-0.0243055765,
-0.0145499269,
0.0321625918,
0.0425422192,
-0.0173250772,
-0.0084524779,
0.0289006587,
-0.0243094712,
-0.0231004953,
0.034251634,
-0.0219370313,
-0.0186412763,
-0.0117852436,
0.0144528812,
0.0687848926,
-0.0179945901,
-0.0112366453,
-0.0713398829,
0.0541093238,
0.0048492993,
-0.0183199681,
0.0022919618,
-6.313351672e-33,
-0.0164480247,
-0.0071037966,
-0.0044881478,
0.030276021,
0.0038115261,
0.0147587238,
-0.0173079651,
-0.0020279246,
0.0030171319,
-0.0018077944,
-0.0370864607,
-0.0045263022,
0.0364683941,
0.0073016882,
0.0409867354,
-0.050791461,
0.0312051717,
0.0007721365,
-0.0113006877,
0.0356875397,
0.0017520422,
0.0471966825,
0.0532699227,
-0.0240050349,
0.046043843,
-0.0797484443,
0.0157457795,
-0.0065845461,
0.0629359111,
0.0561022572,
-0.0396239199,
0.0203383453,
0.0109828645,
-0.0758721828,
0.0153305233,
0.0321373194,
-0.0639448985,
0.010160421,
-0.0011539225,
-0.009183622,
0.0061901445,
-0.0475264229,
-0.0105781741,
-0.0360474661,
0.0087163001,
0.0243357625,
0.0350938439,
-0.0232288148,
-0.0277219471,
-0.0099651609,
-0.0398471765,
0.0305962339,
0.0321755074,
-0.0052300114,
0.059393432,
0.0236475784,
-0.0196624342,
0.0561485551,
-0.0062561547,
0.0026685293,
0.0716066509,
0.0303937458,
0.0393674485,
0.0917853266,
0.0363481268,
0.0489540771,
0.012482577,
-0.03177239,
-0.0108450521,
0.0272495169,
0.0150628034,
0.0207257178,
0.0081902016,
0.0452181324,
0.0644294396,
0.029326221,
-0.0257945657,
-0.0014377894,
0.0165873189,
-0.0114988927,
0.0351614542,
0.0002375175,
-0.040857885,
0.0151978489,
-0.0126187159,
-0.0151873231,
-0.0393529162,
-0.018837342,
0.0312873535,
0.0213660244,
-0.0785810798,
0.0327047743,
0.0439299233,
0.0107809156,
0.009252036,
0.0101404265,
0.0355410948,
0.0159440432,
-0.0335631743,
0.0243397206,
-0.0540227853,
-0.0296459254,
0.0135490233,
0.0112270601,
0.0202287398,
-0.0029157561,
0.009494409,
0.0019776407,
-0.0540878475,
-0.0182511229,
-0.02421882,
-0.0019109513,
-0.0282314643,
0.024717696,
0.0131112048,
0.015419228,
-0.0157117732,
0.0579277053,
0.0217959154,
0.0123227714,
0.0148946,
-0.0114553515,
-0.0102474382,
0.0050909924,
0.0022272663,
0.0025545056,
-0.0159455892,
0.0240345076,
-0.0136922197,
-0.0396618508,
0.0033800583,
-0.0070777703,
2.386e-7,
0.0007030413,
0.034104716,
0.0389234386,
-0.0042615845,
-0.0183522142,
0.0461934209,
-0.0033341572,
0.013991287,
-0.0052174102,
-0.0151997358,
0.0300217997,
0.0430069342,
0.0325243846,
-0.0099144699,
-0.104591839,
-0.0242876019,
-0.0835640356,
0.0006496292,
-0.0492728986,
-0.0232785512,
0.0528513305,
0.077589184,
0.0028633717,
0.0063101812,
-0.0125390412,
-0.0658788905,
0.0402806252,
-0.0268850196,
-0.0340562277,
0.027115576,
0.0290472489,
0.0410098881,
-0.0273584872,
0.0301442891,
0.024568744,
0.0111617204,
0.064772062,
0.0667368025,
0.0045163496,
-0.0117290802,
-0.0076257032,
-0.0178940631,
0.0068343175,
-0.0277077034,
0.1126131639,
-0.0692722648,
-0.0117845852,
-0.0664450228,
-0.0493567586,
-0.0058668321,
-0.0185828246,
-0.0579663925,
-0.0193730295,
0.0352438428,
0.0074872961,
-0.0185073093,
-0.0444873348,
-0.0564404018,
0.0164156165,
-0.0095028076,
-0.010025477,
-0.0211664122,
-0.0414640382,
0.0095968088,
-0.0271465294,
-0.0533590429,
0.0347311646,
1.992594938e-34,
0.0280471016,
-0.0163038112,
-0.0240484681,
0.0427130982,
0.0161556229,
-0.0125233298,
-0.0116940103,
0.0152066592,
-0.010716713,
-0.0738414899,
0.0106822792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15099v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15099v2 | Moderating New Waves of Online Hate with Chain-of-Thought Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2023-12-22T22:34:49 | 2024-05-10T17:01:55 | Nishant Vishwamitra, Keyan Guo, Farhan Tajwar Romit, Isabelle Ondracek, Long Cheng, Ziming Zhao, Hongxin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, cs.SI | Online hate is an escalating problem that negatively impacts the lives of
Internet users, and is also subject to rapid changes due to evolving events,
resulting in new waves of online hate that pose a critical threat. Detecting
and mitigating these new waves present two key challenges: it demands
reasoning-based complex decision-making to determine the presence of hateful
content, and the limited availability of training samples hinders updating the
detection model. To address this critical issue, we present a novel framework
called HATEGUARD for effectively moderating new waves of online hate. HATEGUARD
employs a reasoning-based approach that leverages the recently introduced
chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting technique, harnessing the capabilities of
large language models (LLMs). HATEGUARD further achieves prompt-based zero-shot
detection by automatically generating and updating detection prompts with new
derogatory terms and targets in new wave samples to effectively address new
waves of online hate. To demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach, we
compile a new dataset consisting of tweets related to three recently witnessed
new waves: the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine, the 2021 insurrection of the
US Capitol, and the COVID-19 pandemic. Our studies reveal crucial longitudinal
patterns in these new waves concerning the evolution of events and the pressing
need for techniques to rapidly update existing moderation tools to counteract
them. Comparative evaluations against state-of-the-art tools illustrate the
superiority of our framework, showcasing a substantial 22.22% to 83.33%
improvement in detecting the three new waves of online hate. Our work
highlights the severe threat posed by the emergence of new waves of online hate
and represents a paradigm shift in addressing this threat practically. | [
0.0701754391,
0.0744208619,
-0.0064626853,
0.0106099732,
-0.025873106,
0.0236727763,
0.0405204445,
0.013194493,
0.0385622829,
-0.0404039882,
0.0257928539,
-0.0366627499,
-0.0399927162,
0.0271881577,
0.0009520365,
-0.0417764634,
0.0274879467,
0.0003232277,
0.0530374721,
-0.0071497131,
0.0590576939,
0.0243245456,
-0.0224230178,
0.0233672969,
-0.0518690869,
-0.0014103398,
0.0180455558,
0.0051217675,
0.0557585247,
-0.0435929522,
0.0465868264,
0.0433719493,
0.0267590005,
0.0684109405,
0.0000020633,
-0.0533801652,
-0.0168883838,
-0.029878689,
-0.0002350786,
-0.0802686065,
0.0824847147,
-0.0357843451,
0.0106450105,
0.0331434794,
-0.0306893066,
0.0255655963,
0.0206094813,
0.0663667321,
0.077850394,
0.0800979584,
-0.0076264977,
-0.0417382419,
0.0197947789,
0.0071450253,
-0.0101561928,
0.0227402281,
0.0312287156,
-0.0593340807,
-0.0388381593,
0.0071425592,
0.0245268513,
0.0045526144,
0.0068101846,
0.0087690577,
0.0186155234,
-0.0005505612,
-0.0111732082,
-0.0214047972,
-0.0132916523,
0.0586787835,
-0.0320770703,
-0.0218175389,
0.02009256,
-0.0036391779,
0.0032233777,
-0.022463277,
-0.0393291637,
-0.0162735302,
-0.0320251882,
0.0077239671,
0.0201348308,
0.0093132621,
0.045766633,
0.0712131634,
-0.0276069492,
0.0347013958,
-0.0293152947,
-0.0431120396,
0.0033354873,
-0.0196548495,
-0.0075739631,
-0.0383968912,
0.0250734016,
0.0355659872,
-0.0568325371,
0.0073885545,
-0.0448897071,
-0.031535387,
-0.0085998066,
-0.0686466247,
0.0190150905,
0.0319191068,
0.0078285877,
0.0160000324,
0.0276348572,
0.0148269022,
-0.0231440142,
-0.0228496436,
0.0121018905,
0.0068375575,
-0.0507606119,
0.0267801639,
-0.0011346256,
0.0061693033,
0.0278574321,
0.0287475437,
-0.0071225618,
-0.0055611841,
-0.0536254272,
0.0100942068,
-0.0469258502,
-0.0117140431,
0.0343625024,
-0.009625433,
-0.0284560937,
0.0345225893,
-0.0526200794,
0.0091959815,
-0.0113140866,
-0.046344731,
-0.004717052,
0.0070941122,
-0.0114963222,
-0.0257437043,
0.0138769588,
0.0408026427,
0.0267533772,
0.0011135135,
-0.0340473019,
-0.0598846376,
-0.0137668466,
-0.0487058014,
0.019107433,
-0.075017117,
0.0108970767,
-0.0078801382,
-0.0218959376,
-0.0358656682,
0.0247739982,
0.0249362197,
-0.0650295615,
0.0676994175,
-0.0218054634,
-0.0136732683,
0.0183845703,
0.0452406257,
0.010936047,
0.0568283126,
-0.0108699184,
0.0456285626,
0.0335503221,
0.0216016229,
0.0001487727,
0.034475483,
0.0287431348,
0.0315896384,
-0.0546548031,
0.0187493302,
-0.068498455,
-0.0246752631,
-0.0229545347,
0.0424985066,
-0.0136274928,
-0.0203587431,
0.0627205074,
0.0334774032,
-0.0806281343,
0.0269955304,
0.0565425418,
0.0128089339,
-0.0386595875,
-0.0341343805,
-0.0480304956,
0.0110917687,
-0.0513891429,
-0.0592109412,
0.0060381694,
0.0473317727,
-0.0218074564,
-0.0364020132,
-0.0237175729,
0.0000377049,
0.0310353059,
-0.0244876165,
0.0079881307,
0.0016374342,
-0.017865587,
0.00463627,
0.0447066315,
-0.0171335936,
-0.0071918722,
-0.0517224371,
0.0228482056,
0.0784130991,
0.0235578045,
0.0006910705,
-0.0640671179,
-0.0644606277,
0.0310995374,
0.0385747068,
-0.0014716673,
-0.0043517798,
-0.0299052,
-0.0468302965,
-0.0139026791,
0.0471635014,
0.0076618758,
-0.0139872329,
0.044092752,
0.0270701107,
-0.0180360712,
0.0543951988,
-0.0151351066,
0.011943032,
0.0316209048,
-0.0221663546,
0.0081297662,
0.0387475193,
0.053191971,
0.0169114098,
-0.0013287935,
-0.0257115215,
0.0103206281,
-0.0156883951,
-0.0678236708,
-0.0058231265,
-0.0298954621,
0.0160929039,
0.0430430919,
-0.0193903986,
-0.038793385,
0.0407941341,
-0.0129651818,
0.0339236632,
0.0711304694,
0.0097089317,
-0.0427912585,
-0.0036685159,
-0.0357423574,
-0.0549463667,
0.0115642017,
-0.005122202,
0.0967982635,
-0.0364526808,
-0.0132503277,
0.0372037478,
-0.0641541332,
0.0182470474,
0.0526231043,
-0.0389352217,
-0.0290803742,
-0.011086938,
-0.0015104816,
0.0086240908,
0.0114425216,
-0.0338791609,
-0.0013023273,
-0.0833208486,
-0.0010996958,
-0.020809548,
0.0008804832,
0.0172830764,
-0.0100615192,
-0.0068724928,
0.0299345776,
-0.0118613578,
-0.0038683373,
0.0360252336,
0.0202308428,
0.0025228835,
-0.045394171,
-0.0240107421,
-0.0336070918,
-0.0030088669,
-0.035054639,
0.0244387928,
0.0067791785,
-0.0524072237,
0.0419331044,
-0.0117822355,
-0.0761388615,
0.0141304964,
-0.0116765732,
-0.0374011248,
0.0387459509,
-0.0230393764,
0.0392224379,
0.0216129515,
0.0565751977,
0.0848781168,
0.0503956154,
0.0095795793,
-0.0360019803,
0.0155016053,
-0.0315466486,
-0.0050782254,
-0.0395893902,
0.0031122847,
-0.0148063982,
0.0838086009,
0.0289539546,
-0.0051623904,
-0.0744808167,
0.0574691482,
-0.0617547259,
-0.0145184547,
-0.0482267067,
-0.0624889918,
0.0114873154,
-0.005547408,
-0.0491705872,
-0.0308822747,
0.0797161013,
0.023591172,
0.0361969508,
-0.0264691338,
-0.0358287133,
-0.0079544205,
0.0385699011,
-0.0072551006,
0.0163409468,
-0.0143463174,
0.0258722845,
-0.0099568842,
-0.0690392405,
0.0144627113,
-0.0303031504,
-0.016431978,
-0.0530785695,
0.0175050758,
0.0193732027,
-0.0356745608,
-0.0692508444,
-0.0491134748,
-0.075361371,
-0.0522698835,
-0.0064570196,
-0.0079722796,
-0.0030928419,
-0.0051978538,
0.0541098081,
-0.0179846399,
0.0003940674,
-0.0344157256,
0.0247229263,
-0.0042823069,
0.0184762143,
-0.0493215062,
0.044499509,
0.0137700988,
0.0328880809,
0.0548548847,
0.0066461619,
0.003392363,
-0.0288746301,
0.0273599867,
0.0248257108,
0.0163354296,
-0.0010397735,
0.0091951629,
0.0306892432,
-0.0152781764,
0.0044600656,
0.1096594706,
0.0335361995,
-0.0262340885,
-0.0069743125,
0.0028072568,
0.0212579649,
0.0159221962,
-0.0313673764,
-0.0740225092,
-0.0093799606,
-0.0119624073,
0.0185372978,
-0.0564089753,
-0.0687176138,
-0.015695909,
-0.0659247413,
0.0072711767,
-0.0066742939,
0.0167506225,
0.0003007594,
-0.0163847767,
0.0229123943,
0.0184679516,
-0.0126884319,
-0.0311948713,
0.0178708639,
0.0187877696,
0.0161308609,
-0.0538263917,
0.0099469526,
0.0186614115,
-0.0292094741,
0.034593299,
0.0212492663,
0.0679842681,
-0.0007468879,
-0.0121127805,
0.057568036,
-0.0117085092,
-0.0150747821,
-0.0679259226,
0.0410077982,
0.0269265268,
-0.0228495859,
-0.0519064479,
0.0562143549,
-0.0044130259,
-0.0180249009,
0.0310870074,
0.0811376497,
0.0149366688,
-0.004164231,
-0.0445309021,
0.0435771346,
0.0301851295,
0.0528044589,
0.02570289,
-0.0555774942,
0.0361780226,
-0.0554529577,
-0.0209006052,
-0.0419720262,
-0.0834995732,
-0.0078950888,
0.0057542864,
-0.0201704372,
-0.0371736996,
-0.0270426665,
0.0216813385,
0.0290030669,
0.0083666136,
-0.0207494721,
0.0155441612,
-0.0142586203,
-0.0206872877,
-0.0144918049,
-0.0173210669,
0.0512676574,
-0.0144152679,
0.02231206,
-0.039004989,
0.0083011575,
-0.0335356258,
0.053408891,
-0.0755360946,
-0.0412654243,
0.0196794942,
0.0587497018,
0.0269937404,
0.0235773418,
-0.0328488685,
-0.0242642257,
0.0720800981,
0.0581763014,
0.0080937501,
-0.0304223709,
0.0408090092,
0.0202898774,
0.0434480309,
0.0287732482,
0.0067163748,
0.0192212295,
0.041869361,
-0.0374247953,
-0.0660363287,
0.010602423,
-0.0158388838,
-0.0241665356,
0.0520645604,
0.0060846126,
-0.0663258731,
-0.0139915459,
-0.012061731,
0.0126268947,
-0.0558778122,
0.0208305139,
0.0237619206,
0.0074686366,
-0.004673312,
-0.0508105792,
-0.017707536,
-0.0214740355,
0.0083233174,
-0.0546687394,
0.0099291969,
0.0231258534,
0.0634474754,
0.0631344095,
-0.0056996332,
-0.0144598577,
0.0315785632,
0.020848712,
-0.0369770378,
-0.0311612189,
0.0322494768,
0.0111388322,
-0.009536244,
0.0083843954,
-0.0261312481,
-0.0116947498,
-0.0584506206,
-0.0014254162,
-0.0263751484,
-0.0046643643,
-0.0042195632,
0.0281668156,
0.0250308402,
-0.0188482795,
-0.0062455209,
0.0193576645,
-0.0262938663,
-0.052906923,
-0.0081526041,
0.0273345895,
-0.0344849639,
0.0051611173,
0.0260917451,
-0.0377327912,
0.0424927436,
0.0936433226,
-0.0449050739,
-0.0092708543,
0.0020496349,
-0.0074409279,
0.0293696281,
0.0220530983,
0.0636755899,
-0.0785581917,
-0.0441657156,
0.0127456803,
-0.0524182096,
0.0082995305,
0.0149626853,
-0.0080615012,
0.0378086641,
0.0052978271,
0.0278777964,
-0.0250906534,
0.0227808971,
0.0070776409,
-0.0935135633,
-0.008365008,
-6.361203108e-33,
0.0166432261,
-0.0220088828,
0.0052030324,
-0.0412306078,
-0.0152633581,
-0.0107763717,
0.0145320399,
0.0072469544,
-0.0226067267,
0.0423098244,
-0.0051745079,
0.0155149437,
-0.0046365126,
0.0069031431,
-0.020656025,
-0.0334924981,
0.037295904,
-0.0167155731,
0.0059103495,
0.0278335158,
0.0787200257,
0.0093607977,
0.0060507441,
-0.0448335223,
0.0422586091,
-0.0143991224,
-0.012409308,
0.0279593933,
0.0096978452,
0.0423614942,
0.0021605885,
0.0540208369,
0.0396363363,
-0.0346253701,
0.0112466197,
0.042607218,
-0.046923887,
-0.0351723246,
0.0226974878,
-0.0302447826,
0.0319567546,
-0.0253416821,
-0.0028030761,
0.0243991371,
-0.0276707243,
-0.0195418186,
0.0110813836,
-0.0102390191,
0.03213742,
-0.0542480908,
-0.0568428598,
0.0122512346,
-0.0633104816,
-0.0157661717,
-0.0259330273,
0.0402547196,
0.0306085348,
0.014588817,
-0.0891529173,
0.0461146608,
-0.0185531713,
-0.0179703962,
0.0035107087,
-0.0447533689,
-0.0139771681,
0.0556722917,
-0.0289567485,
0.0191377718,
-0.0525654256,
0.0507106967,
-0.0005324797,
0.0358964205,
0.0488471203,
0.0443479568,
0.0340778083,
-0.0838907585,
-0.0905822888,
-0.0085408557,
0.0314260498,
0.0374010839,
0.0228519645,
-0.0126909968,
-0.0393997543,
-0.0163375232,
0.0066134585,
-0.0942555517,
-0.0393856093,
-0.0183042679,
-0.0043265698,
0.0093474537,
-0.0280714594,
-0.0410539135,
0.0330025777,
0.0012446231,
-0.0348318592,
0.0593781099,
-0.0072885118,
-0.0084313005,
0.0531689338,
0.054711815,
-0.0412331522,
0.0149312485,
0.0117567172,
-0.0118329357,
0.0309072472,
-0.0020022548,
0.0640827864,
0.034016829,
-0.0731017739,
0.001095686,
-0.0372431725,
0.0904948041,
-0.0381091088,
0.0399484374,
0.0046077487,
0.0590768605,
-0.0010456254,
-0.0020063638,
0.0516366102,
-0.0478704646,
0.0069174864,
0.0474020801,
-0.0478328951,
-0.0023602152,
-0.0022028843,
-0.0179379899,
-0.0352364108,
0.0311179925,
0.0218241885,
-0.1021360978,
0.0018272926,
-0.0430943295,
2.73e-7,
-0.0256121941,
0.0668067485,
-0.0106167961,
0.0221605506,
0.0423603691,
0.0579349585,
0.0248785447,
0.0150990123,
-0.0158669129,
-0.0249770358,
0.0008690289,
0.0766529217,
0.003364743,
0.0560941435,
-0.0166322552,
-0.0423494652,
-0.0527857989,
-0.0139803393,
-0.0904979259,
0.010840199,
0.0527154803,
0.0688688383,
0.0922608823,
-0.024250593,
-0.0087087704,
-0.0025245445,
0.0063988254,
-0.026895944,
-0.0116994008,
-0.0159550738,
0.061208833,
-0.0084571736,
0.0081724925,
0.0111422101,
-0.004085423,
0.0016276587,
-0.0366456583,
0.0204079598,
0.037573196,
0.0191587247,
0.0190731026,
0.003215747,
0.0111619746,
-0.0562246442,
0.0743434429,
-0.0033856544,
-0.0130421473,
-0.0428881943,
-0.017585041,
-0.0071486444,
0.0279256124,
-0.0115439249,
-0.0380405299,
0.0081591411,
0.020813508,
0.0314107426,
0.0176960994,
-0.0801782832,
0.0162787102,
0.0094896201,
-0.0393173397,
-0.0427942388,
-0.0312956497,
0.0035890061,
0.044817701,
0.0279161278,
0.0544896945,
2.456698705e-34,
0.0179426409,
-0.0115804849,
-0.0037854735,
-0.0302411616,
0.0455974713,
0.0270352103,
-0.0431954041,
-0.0079286173,
0.057072401,
-0.0513166413,
-0.0091898208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15098v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15098v1 | Unsupervised Auditory and Semantic Entrainment Models with Deep Neural Networks | 2023-12-22T22:33:54 | 2023-12-22T22:33:54 | Jay Kejriwal, Stefan Benus, Lina M. Rojas-Barahona | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speakers tend to engage in adaptive behavior, known as entrainment, when they
become similar to their interlocutor in various aspects of speaking. We present
an unsupervised deep learning framework that derives meaningful representation
from textual features for developing semantic entrainment. We investigate the
model's performance by extracting features using different variations of the
BERT model (DistilBERT and XLM-RoBERTa) and Google's universal sentence encoder
(USE) embeddings on two human-human (HH) corpora (The Fisher Corpus English
Part 1, Columbia games corpus) and one human-machine (HM) corpus (Voice
Assistant Conversation Corpus (VACC)). In addition to semantic features we also
trained DNN-based models utilizing two auditory embeddings (TRIpLet Loss
network (TRILL) vectors, Low-level descriptors (LLD) features) and two units of
analysis (Inter pausal unit and Turn). The results show that semantic
entrainment can be assessed with our model, that models can distinguish between
HH and HM interactions and that the two units of analysis for extracting
acoustic features provide comparable findings. | [
-0.0225072466,
0.0293017589,
-0.0244506933,
0.0507204346,
-0.0166715439,
0.0028125921,
-0.0211536121,
-0.0320476815,
-0.0426891819,
-0.0376041308,
-0.0389957093,
0.021775797,
0.0081536314,
-0.0051255911,
0.0283628497,
-0.0609812289,
0.0170232896,
-0.0150979655,
-0.0122063952,
-0.0284032729,
0.0114570875,
0.0014463236,
-0.0498056412,
0.0602954477,
-0.0084280567,
-0.0027485467,
-0.0461108051,
0.0092449589,
-0.0026798847,
0.0228386,
0.0099280654,
0.042480275,
0.0730982646,
0.0086162305,
0.0000020031,
-0.0306224059,
0.0475513935,
-0.0550930426,
-0.0352903232,
-0.0205659159,
-0.0211797245,
-0.0021350102,
0.0070568672,
0.0229487326,
-0.01664095,
-0.0280144084,
-0.020104453,
0.014397963,
0.0428755023,
0.0542940758,
0.0013698681,
-0.027760366,
0.057005059,
-0.0164784864,
-0.0050310432,
-0.0304921158,
-0.0019863918,
-0.0276051927,
-0.0461844169,
-0.0204822887,
-0.0246170256,
-0.0001756342,
0.0134626562,
0.0197045803,
0.0574099794,
0.0312843174,
-0.0248163063,
0.0049904371,
-0.0098918136,
0.0855207667,
-0.0095951334,
-0.0092779519,
-0.0004502935,
0.0337379612,
0.011570082,
-0.0010652941,
0.0037506127,
-0.0285902508,
0.0426042899,
0.0038674301,
-0.0434096567,
-0.011291598,
0.0266972277,
-0.0056374851,
0.0007166102,
0.0268081147,
0.0026199673,
-0.0508315861,
0.0196156576,
-0.0224208478,
0.0122972168,
-0.0560991764,
0.0341062918,
-0.0055356491,
-0.0065945857,
0.0018774341,
-0.0351029113,
-0.0173754636,
-0.0080348784,
-0.0510139875,
-0.0346157551,
0.0143292006,
-0.0706236959,
0.0090615684,
-0.0141547117,
0.0535718612,
-0.0187939443,
0.0156174535,
0.0074945949,
-0.0052109677,
-0.0614727587,
-0.0230424423,
-0.0473215207,
0.0304849111,
-0.0068687298,
-0.0363312848,
-0.0476486087,
0.0193055607,
-0.0199464634,
0.0079016462,
-0.0252738614,
0.0262902379,
-0.049367357,
0.0334403254,
-0.0173314847,
0.0067803771,
-0.0324278623,
0.0680113584,
0.0014138257,
-0.0772814974,
0.0118289301,
0.0226173587,
0.0544614717,
-0.0050629782,
0.0282208472,
0.0414807312,
-0.0000856864,
-0.0416447297,
-0.0231469385,
0.0054477011,
-0.0200195182,
-0.0206243936,
0.0020589377,
-0.0472674482,
0.0586147346,
-0.0571416169,
0.0063573937,
-0.0402906127,
-0.0385139585,
-0.0011986983,
-0.0003550267,
0.0617894381,
-0.0144071048,
0.0443610586,
0.0697761327,
0.0009176867,
0.0492144786,
0.0336513668,
0.0856396332,
-0.0381254405,
0.01174118,
-0.0644177124,
-0.0135634961,
0.0487383306,
0.0057002064,
-0.0206457153,
-0.013703377,
-0.0319719836,
-0.0065602292,
0.0790050328,
0.038545277,
0.0048774285,
-0.0704398975,
-0.0390349925,
0.0616640374,
0.0881643295,
0.0130463364,
0.0379689373,
0.0448855348,
0.0402675532,
-0.0271255597,
0.0202169754,
-0.0336739197,
-0.0216678903,
0.0132011762,
-0.0284983683,
0.0414159149,
-0.0126693882,
-0.032147862,
0.005249395,
0.0182498954,
-0.0356480293,
-0.0062358505,
-0.0166126247,
0.0177572854,
0.0104949269,
-0.0010861174,
0.0347564667,
0.0158524886,
-0.0570128337,
0.0333516859,
-0.0050232224,
-0.0083364835,
0.0706849098,
0.0099123605,
-0.0014427747,
-0.0072249332,
-0.0427112766,
-0.0381120183,
0.0381589569,
0.0145675205,
-0.0154550569,
0.0568369478,
-0.0370233245,
0.0028934097,
0.0076843714,
-0.0151950773,
0.0388219357,
-0.0620223545,
0.0195113048,
0.0010311308,
-0.0442741252,
0.0626174212,
0.028700931,
-0.0102609824,
-0.0078785382,
0.0062658959,
0.0189722721,
0.0673824251,
0.0406543612,
-0.0393978693,
-0.0307965335,
0.0370492116,
-0.0264757257,
-0.0080338931,
0.0740992129,
-0.0716895387,
-0.0293846522,
0.0086639896,
-0.0408764556,
0.0075942716,
0.048473835,
0.0117012989,
-0.0578276739,
0.0332787447,
-0.0555395931,
0.0885656923,
-0.0751765519,
0.0016268059,
-0.015210635,
0.0243582334,
0.0096222665,
0.0097293211,
-0.0033526388,
-0.0119157191,
-0.0328475274,
-0.0262188483,
0.0257480629,
-0.0781693235,
-0.0430911407,
0.0391345359,
-0.0324173681,
0.0009229169,
-0.0034889474,
-0.0167441219,
-0.0457953215,
0.0058420221,
-0.1229910925,
0.001564667,
-0.0096812462,
0.0191693399,
0.0091862492,
-0.0011055359,
-0.0041908082,
-0.0140597364,
-0.0487804525,
-0.0223832279,
-0.0146685923,
0.027188288,
0.0021728938,
-0.0000362231,
-0.0287134144,
-0.0249086265,
0.011571914,
-0.0058660759,
0.0189151075,
-0.0298242103,
0.0131806917,
-0.0323453806,
-0.0388726257,
0.0034544549,
0.0509054959,
-0.0074652219,
-0.0524770766,
0.0013372306,
0.0271117985,
0.0452887975,
0.0331505574,
0.0429566205,
0.0308674984,
0.0092720725,
0.0103932964,
-0.0712308437,
0.0246011335,
-0.0100307874,
0.0072543821,
-0.0754453465,
0.0106675904,
0.0076651163,
0.0426463746,
0.0232170317,
0.0305909161,
-0.039906621,
-0.0540987477,
0.0299540274,
-0.0648868158,
-0.0479785949,
-0.0556439646,
-0.0642513111,
0.0140796434,
-0.0057735932,
-0.0165081136,
0.039034497,
-0.0731198415,
-0.0617336929,
-0.0592556335,
-0.0364851914,
0.0348804295,
0.0121051148,
0.0203171372,
-0.0063729063,
-0.0289445259,
-0.0346231088,
-0.019529989,
0.0191753469,
0.0389477648,
-0.0084335208,
0.0344662182,
0.0047002821,
-0.0243400075,
0.0350228734,
-0.0192119349,
-0.0505795591,
-0.0359966122,
-0.0049390178,
0.0253052115,
0.0058567533,
-0.0101919454,
-0.0079045808,
-0.0259710252,
0.01969059,
0.0486073941,
0.0163108185,
0.016681822,
-0.0517724119,
0.0579560883,
0.0304432064,
0.044470638,
-0.0667226836,
-0.0084167849,
0.0277792215,
0.0069508348,
0.02693386,
0.0284478161,
-0.0829606727,
0.0028375965,
0.0110626398,
0.0000766207,
-0.0053138169,
0.046047572,
0.006598176,
0.0001161372,
-0.0201278552,
0.0963270888,
0.0034332422,
-0.0559452362,
0.041743692,
0.0199099407,
0.0367930196,
-0.004634595,
-0.0098155728,
-0.0863321051,
-0.0231823921,
0.0466702171,
0.0214694533,
0.0259051919,
0.0113509465,
0.0229148101,
-0.0863249302,
0.0064446349,
-0.0067421435,
-0.0790313259,
-0.0350426808,
-0.0417415947,
0.0035319186,
0.0005947554,
0.0364589468,
-0.0272307228,
0.0160065722,
-0.0232804362,
0.0361196138,
-0.060774371,
-0.0527205803,
0.0391790308,
-0.071273081,
0.0590847731,
0.0553431548,
0.0476728417,
-0.0344702005,
-0.0493268035,
0.0248847567,
-0.0124994181,
0.0095512979,
0.0168030616,
0.0652653277,
-0.0361119509,
-0.0013050131,
0.0141271912,
0.0724225864,
-0.0224127471,
0.0038991137,
0.0140890004,
0.0479325093,
-0.0540069342,
0.0155537054,
0.0080158683,
0.0276414901,
0.0189658012,
0.0490040705,
0.0627368391,
-0.0718906969,
0.016541224,
0.0243972745,
0.0626475811,
-0.0428598449,
0.0096464949,
0.0025651651,
0.0204232857,
-0.0123075061,
-0.0542682111,
-0.0512084588,
-0.0435735062,
-0.0248936117,
0.0299510173,
-0.0251081828,
0.0358696505,
0.0162154827,
-0.0251586176,
0.0422213078,
0.0161443688,
0.0444494449,
-0.0018597783,
-0.0343566164,
0.0572067276,
-0.0256876145,
-0.0430850945,
-0.0393105149,
-0.0250181761,
-0.0434390865,
0.0181772392,
-0.0120804328,
0.0081877671,
0.1074244678,
-0.0131221479,
-0.0550128035,
0.0372402035,
0.0010759175,
-0.0315661915,
0.0132262651,
0.000886281,
0.0055086911,
-0.0249588024,
0.0037986841,
-0.0175650008,
0.0366548486,
-0.0432781689,
-0.0352569707,
-0.0212982912,
-0.0856840163,
-0.0160943065,
-0.0340126939,
0.0788910761,
0.0330934189,
0.0226409435,
-0.0553227253,
0.0482612848,
0.053549137,
0.0439861193,
-0.0303954445,
-0.0570302159,
0.01852802,
0.0463078357,
-0.008688814,
-0.0002686075,
-0.0072622141,
0.0128690097,
-0.0136371031,
0.0563654788,
0.018650176,
0.0542159192,
-0.0195302814,
0.052494593,
0.0015983828,
0.0185535848,
-0.0107179787,
0.0239242483,
-0.0042488216,
0.0297167748,
0.0438377149,
-0.0138280811,
0.0313442536,
0.0223817583,
-0.0137972319,
0.0048395027,
-0.0201887749,
0.0159598105,
0.0722920448,
-0.0153431334,
0.0076371017,
0.0322161205,
0.0491438285,
0.0045229797,
0.0154480701,
-0.0786590949,
0.0028599871,
0.0553455465,
-0.0018680383,
-0.0465143621,
-0.008112398,
0.037783958,
-0.0114584733,
0.0572957769,
-0.033889994,
0.0380376428,
-0.0517494157,
-0.0262732059,
0.0268326607,
0.0733213648,
-0.0236831848,
0.0178724453,
0.0396308415,
-0.0351468958,
-0.005465047,
0.0218717046,
0.0431167446,
0.020172324,
0.075800471,
0.0265833959,
-0.0539127998,
-0.0138562201,
0.0180837996,
-0.0288149994,
-0.0349263288,
-0.0367470048,
-0.0052540577,
-6.059084529e-33,
-0.0247210879,
-0.0067592859,
-0.0026758711,
0.0183573402,
-0.0539814085,
-0.0457602181,
-0.0309350435,
0.0119326012,
-0.0006754609,
0.0239392836,
0.0104317181,
0.0144973546,
0.0028941848,
0.0276175831,
0.0167933907,
-0.026989989,
0.0466441549,
-0.0197862927,
0.0168816391,
0.0293404851,
0.0557809509,
0.0371687002,
0.0644069389,
-0.0852645263,
-0.0362899341,
-0.0209254939,
0.0053093098,
-0.0039688773,
-0.0072524813,
0.0123400176,
-0.0028352034,
0.0480987653,
0.0036213023,
-0.0154179865,
0.0019558445,
0.0640956759,
-0.078228645,
-0.008193437,
-0.0230594426,
0.0403336138,
-0.0346035063,
-0.0170885548,
0.0492822751,
0.0083599994,
0.0039162431,
0.0085504018,
0.0740458369,
0.0210689381,
0.0095433304,
-0.0038334429,
-0.0467702448,
0.0051239273,
-0.0476827435,
-0.0372665152,
0.0264594015,
0.0611885898,
-0.0083269672,
-0.0327937603,
-0.0773638263,
0.033807423,
-0.0196669437,
0.0048162807,
0.0301138647,
0.0166343283,
0.0117549542,
0.0735852048,
0.0449184552,
-0.0265400894,
0.0164828934,
-0.0381681472,
0.0925378203,
0.0434002504,
0.0009834351,
0.0097576939,
0.0025654885,
-0.0265496355,
-0.0318517387,
0.0112218391,
0.0421548858,
0.0072099548,
-0.0330812484,
0.0337872691,
-0.0200633798,
-0.0167262908,
-0.0473810434,
-0.0147271734,
0.0020625135,
-0.0414912477,
0.0569472201,
-0.0260865726,
0.0387484618,
0.0289751645,
0.044904884,
-0.040031381,
0.022481909,
0.0181911476,
-0.014121715,
-0.0130154518,
0.009031089,
0.0036815114,
-0.050350152,
-0.0680311695,
0.0584061556,
0.0209903326,
0.0597862601,
0.00168074,
0.0115037374,
0.0044497079,
-0.0243601166,
0.0006735931,
-0.0055254851,
-0.0228750445,
-0.034639772,
0.0195612591,
0.0081753889,
0.0161552522,
-0.0335052945,
0.0351206139,
-0.0052548633,
-0.0038580426,
-0.0551461726,
-0.0302493162,
-0.0024132498,
0.0422820412,
-0.019420471,
-0.0114639653,
-0.0060144947,
-0.0209563468,
0.0386830382,
-0.027646685,
0.0206847377,
-0.0139145553,
2.862e-7,
-0.0428188071,
0.0242202953,
0.0590885766,
-0.0432072096,
0.0817196444,
0.0249744207,
-0.0176267419,
0.0392381586,
-0.0007779801,
-0.0060336133,
0.0338319056,
0.0047955094,
0.0550515018,
0.0040825284,
-0.0935435444,
-0.022812048,
-0.122281082,
0.0202294402,
-0.0244156569,
-0.0290697757,
0.026409572,
0.0323936455,
-0.0118997404,
-0.0294768102,
0.0155875515,
-0.0124966372,
0.011871716,
-0.0542833805,
0.0158174373,
-0.009529328,
-0.0131132742,
0.0208676308,
-0.0157923903,
0.0797382444,
-0.0253814664,
0.0850891471,
0.0128725683,
0.0404562391,
-0.0490147397,
-0.0535036922,
-0.0256862342,
0.0661550984,
-0.0542096049,
-0.0087585542,
0.0222729556,
-0.0351221114,
-0.0591091998,
0.0018737956,
-0.047718104,
-0.008835095,
0.0210245214,
0.018946385,
0.0091033699,
0.0269476753,
0.0075581921,
0.0062107835,
0.0026882789,
-0.0486047231,
0.0422686897,
0.0472374558,
-0.1041288897,
-0.0133590754,
-0.0304152314,
-0.0351071842,
0.0316324756,
-0.0021367823,
0.0128392214,
1.222611815e-34,
-0.0208924077,
0.0455495194,
0.0477686562,
0.0164564531,
-0.0101774363,
-0.0303049088,
0.0662523136,
-0.0007537276,
0.0252779108,
-0.0403037816,
-0.0014382236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15068v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15068v2 | Refining GPT-3 Embeddings with a Siamese Structure for Technical Post Duplicate Detection | 2023-12-22T21:14:37 | 2024-03-04T17:03:42 | Xingfang Wu, Heng Li, Nobukazu Yoshioka, Hironori Washizaki, Foutse Khomh | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG | One goal of technical online communities is to help developers find the right
answer in one place. A single question can be asked in different ways with
different wordings, leading to the existence of duplicate posts on technical
forums. The question of how to discover and link duplicate posts has garnered
the attention of both developer communities and researchers. For example, Stack
Overflow adopts a voting-based mechanism to mark and close duplicate posts.
However, addressing these constantly emerging duplicate posts in a timely
manner continues to pose challenges. Therefore, various approaches have been
proposed to detect duplicate posts on technical forum posts automatically. The
existing methods suffer from limitations either due to their reliance on
handcrafted similarity metrics which can not sufficiently capture the semantics
of posts, or their lack of supervision to improve the performance.
Additionally, the efficiency of these methods is hindered by their dependence
on pair-wise feature generation, which can be impractical for large amount of
data. In this work, we attempt to employ and refine the GPT-3 embeddings for
the duplicate detection task. We assume that the GPT-3 embeddings can
accurately represent the semantics of the posts. In addition, by training a
Siamese-based network based on the GPT-3 embeddings, we obtain a latent
embedding that accurately captures the duplicate relation in technical forum
posts. Our experiment on a benchmark dataset confirms the effectiveness of our
approach and demonstrates superior performance compared to baseline methods.
When applied to the dataset we constructed with a recent Stack Overflow dump,
our approach attains a Top-1, Top-5, and Top-30 accuracy of 23.1%, 43.9%, and
68.9%, respectively. With a manual study, we confirm our approach's potential
of finding unlabelled duplicates on technical forums. | [
0.0277573634,
0.0403640196,
-0.0068734572,
0.0462894142,
0.0038716204,
0.0106170978,
0.0051088771,
0.0083767744,
0.0104853809,
-0.0483301096,
-0.0171559937,
0.0159879886,
-0.0411594957,
0.0277026687,
0.0166228767,
-0.013496805,
0.0348814577,
0.0557922311,
-0.0285440143,
0.0163575057,
0.0420421511,
0.0213100351,
0.0058744769,
0.0403456464,
-0.0046873861,
-0.053855326,
0.0460422747,
0.0053324345,
0.0422305465,
-0.047289893,
0.0094491886,
0.067792885,
0.0156313553,
0.0503357053,
0.0000020632,
-0.0238346793,
-0.0012134196,
-0.0151562979,
-0.005882205,
0.0595359132,
-0.0117266104,
0.0319165848,
0.0314614438,
0.039798364,
-0.0811960027,
-0.081221424,
0.0068644988,
0.0653232932,
0.0711269677,
0.0083957417,
-0.0146352313,
0.0115574002,
0.0573347583,
-0.0248966869,
0.0264719557,
-0.0327535309,
-0.0240599997,
0.0307103544,
0.0079361796,
0.059268333,
0.0243957564,
0.0160070267,
0.012844759,
-0.0038230612,
-0.0122671332,
0.0414208286,
-0.0190632604,
0.0418963023,
-0.0013330942,
0.0990764871,
-0.028530525,
-0.0502848178,
0.0365417153,
0.0072943796,
-0.0107894829,
0.0360714979,
-0.0455807187,
-0.0298464224,
-0.013883898,
0.0218100622,
-0.0014674888,
0.0321059264,
0.0022248265,
-0.0476078875,
0.0240592193,
-0.0789444521,
0.0208984967,
0.0257988852,
-0.019597007,
0.0217366405,
-0.0380385518,
-0.0156549141,
0.0133436779,
0.0147862714,
-0.015885178,
-0.0353460014,
-0.0192495622,
-0.042236235,
0.0215890165,
-0.0538744889,
0.0139220748,
0.0292308126,
0.0068446277,
0.0532344207,
-0.0734672621,
0.0009141814,
-0.0336754248,
0.0473348983,
-0.034996368,
-0.0012400757,
-0.0684990957,
-0.0356779099,
-0.0359560624,
0.0634933263,
0.0651970878,
-0.032623671,
0.0282363743,
0.0361887515,
-0.0230981354,
0.017750347,
-0.0254116487,
-0.0058250548,
-0.0011791671,
0.0059596882,
0.0418253019,
-0.026792014,
-0.0597130843,
0.0030342638,
-0.0169229358,
-0.0354003683,
-0.0193282813,
0.0435893498,
0.0219482146,
0.000297472,
-0.0178790279,
-0.0125817498,
0.0119905705,
-0.0049872021,
-0.0210379623,
0.0014900912,
0.0572933666,
0.0312171001,
-0.0356538296,
-0.0726376474,
0.0437753834,
0.0054746056,
-0.0074010282,
-0.0195257384,
-0.036469996,
0.0419931412,
0.002609903,
0.0329443589,
-0.045421578,
-0.0051483959,
0.0455640331,
0.0548904054,
-0.0088068331,
0.0280597992,
-0.0331090949,
0.0214383993,
0.0247386713,
0.0266689025,
-0.009541058,
-0.0000551818,
0.0092836237,
-0.0107290177,
0.0408458114,
0.0117916036,
0.0082770707,
0.0201446284,
0.0299554653,
0.0407330282,
-0.0466629937,
-0.035785865,
-0.0262854397,
0.0338951312,
0.0140709523,
0.0311215855,
0.0371461064,
0.052752614,
-0.0285404641,
0.0026203792,
-0.0019564044,
0.0351963714,
-0.0206745546,
-0.0452693179,
0.0184142776,
0.0633392558,
-0.0807937905,
0.0025456927,
0.0248168595,
-0.0121776583,
-0.0438113958,
-0.0174510833,
0.008805275,
0.0089034587,
0.0213258546,
0.0630316734,
0.0001072947,
0.0161757246,
-0.0134034306,
-0.0304476153,
0.004388676,
-0.0184380952,
0.0371205173,
-0.0229009092,
-0.0358725041,
-0.0079847518,
0.0143984165,
-0.0212368686,
0.0695388243,
-0.0340092778,
-0.0439675897,
-0.0652550533,
-0.0593111441,
0.0028699432,
0.0060613886,
0.0230085421,
0.0213371683,
0.0567272753,
0.0485903062,
-0.007160034,
0.012605926,
0.0233043246,
-0.0161564946,
0.0264591835,
-0.0290967692,
-0.0247400738,
0.0029245133,
0.0184047632,
-0.0010236389,
0.0091577489,
0.0500447303,
-0.0539659187,
-0.044289384,
-0.0331745483,
-0.0663341358,
-0.0311396979,
0.0541062467,
-0.0932463259,
-0.0377268046,
0.0648131445,
-0.0698481426,
-0.0081644971,
-0.0060047773,
-0.0409431383,
-0.0251399856,
-0.0409607701,
-0.0417102575,
-0.0171978213,
-0.0123813478,
-0.026645178,
0.0376430452,
-0.0008096189,
0.0315495916,
-0.0192822441,
-0.026383644,
0.0583339408,
-0.0309410039,
-0.0258819722,
-0.0266486518,
-0.0119015109,
0.0229719393,
0.0191354975,
-0.0077821454,
-0.008873445,
-0.0150913252,
-0.0501777865,
-0.0232200921,
-0.0078795655,
0.0177783519,
0.0561286584,
0.0065115993,
0.0117792115,
-0.0185694043,
-0.0790697262,
-0.0017796694,
0.0084396722,
-0.0173707902,
0.0406208225,
-0.0344056636,
-0.0236441344,
-0.0054483539,
-0.0169826988,
-0.050999973,
0.0320357196,
0.0092623904,
-0.0326963477,
-0.0648355037,
0.0480664484,
-0.0012285539,
-0.0033348543,
0.0004838723,
0.022762971,
-0.0007237806,
-0.0087246653,
0.0113379946,
0.0176758692,
0.020900039,
0.0177895986,
-0.0028212075,
0.0680684894,
-0.0787504837,
-0.0190635044,
-0.0399624966,
0.05138506,
0.001604362,
-0.0226108618,
0.0621243492,
-0.0027477208,
-0.0019224664,
-0.0095611457,
-0.0289801098,
0.0281033553,
-0.0153450035,
0.0172428228,
-0.014893597,
-0.032043986,
0.037125811,
-0.0155694028,
-0.0005710972,
0.0097575486,
0.0669809803,
0.0051111905,
0.0073375395,
-0.0404338241,
-0.0024319317,
-0.0697223097,
0.0534199737,
0.0106245354,
0.0247258078,
0.0186971594,
0.0018786349,
-0.0200951882,
0.0173722599,
0.0485686623,
-0.0160829015,
-0.0050934218,
0.0193591733,
0.0277464036,
-0.029050203,
-0.0587698631,
-0.0088003324,
-0.0393606611,
0.0055191256,
-0.0048788204,
-0.0415514447,
0.0259595625,
-0.0207489636,
0.0161713082,
-0.0128581896,
0.045026537,
0.0181421619,
-0.0477024093,
-0.0085958755,
0.0820844844,
0.0540594198,
0.0184564907,
0.0140146166,
0.0146127148,
0.0082278801,
0.0798691064,
0.0151029658,
0.0531564429,
-0.0316257998,
-0.018789243,
0.0073244539,
-0.0633065328,
-0.0066494681,
-0.0292143244,
-0.0145821087,
0.0076832147,
0.0091199605,
0.0950043872,
0.0453045107,
-0.0207579359,
-0.0034989237,
-0.0022104373,
0.0415391549,
0.0377861746,
-0.0015440228,
-0.0957301632,
-0.0258370135,
-0.0175880846,
-0.0166268442,
0.0320272371,
-0.017117722,
0.0177210011,
-0.0920650288,
0.0046232492,
-0.0024720391,
-0.0208062176,
-0.0279631875,
-0.0470347293,
-0.0026814209,
0.0007638703,
-0.0253667105,
-0.0177604854,
-0.0080319401,
0.01818523,
0.0175526347,
-0.0691630766,
-0.0149549572,
0.0049499492,
-0.0599133819,
-0.0101039633,
0.0036230788,
0.0076112119,
-0.0097340457,
-0.0252134074,
0.0215503443,
-0.0300020333,
-0.0243075341,
-0.0032402335,
0.0444885865,
-0.0155936601,
0.0155826136,
-0.0213905871,
0.0418979861,
-0.0802194029,
-0.001746063,
0.0046906811,
0.0824987292,
-0.0218055267,
-0.0345820189,
-0.0660152137,
-0.0089670056,
-0.0111634526,
0.047662925,
0.0477567725,
-0.0097008385,
-0.0365750678,
0.0219588764,
0.0393824652,
-0.0088571031,
-0.042304296,
-0.0096608847,
0.0609586388,
0.0194901749,
-0.0521828383,
-0.0268780254,
-0.0269468166,
0.0039583435,
-0.0067198579,
0.0016340008,
0.0141547732,
-0.0302857608,
-0.0676283166,
0.0073547573,
-0.0265012551,
-0.0110153304,
-0.021074038,
0.0396575779,
0.0441736467,
0.0419348404,
-0.0760178417,
-0.0024039107,
-0.0422692858,
-0.0420101583,
-0.0659543797,
-0.0203295723,
0.008794684,
-0.0187797658,
-0.051527936,
-0.0089504058,
-0.0051507778,
0.0310605299,
-0.0022887385,
-0.0175445471,
0.0020678595,
-0.0653233454,
-0.0058583608,
0.0261460077,
-0.017455129,
0.0440377519,
0.0024234015,
-0.0006452447,
0.010431651,
0.0024089196,
0.0057991128,
0.0477451123,
0.0572438091,
0.0748493671,
0.058541961,
-0.063265264,
-0.0252098907,
0.0385552794,
0.038052965,
-0.0283551682,
0.0544974171,
0.0291629899,
-0.0086147785,
-0.0192945749,
0.0109007787,
0.047968816,
0.037726026,
-0.0380025394,
-0.0160624459,
-0.0071182912,
0.0330553241,
-0.0247870293,
-0.0163713172,
-0.0544078872,
-0.0238836184,
0.0250141788,
0.0136841275,
-0.0549462885,
-0.0017962372,
0.0498331077,
-0.0081889983,
-0.0170038231,
0.0639616996,
-0.0697153062,
-0.0853741467,
-0.0415655859,
-0.0359062031,
0.0562359765,
0.0057668812,
0.0437370874,
-0.0333540328,
-0.0173504334,
-0.0396474153,
0.0218837857,
-0.0091663944,
0.0053464542,
0.0197739899,
0.0325331688,
-0.0353251547,
-0.013268454,
0.0879683048,
-0.0596645065,
0.0021679753,
-0.0064258683,
-0.0494924225,
-0.0342980698,
0.0191435609,
0.0361022688,
0.02613548,
-0.0122555308,
-0.0113821123,
-0.0086525558,
-0.0183074921,
-0.0211566892,
0.0123100411,
0.0100409025,
0.0686689839,
0.0495818704,
0.0527968891,
-0.0023955309,
-0.0106249601,
0.0103437575,
-0.016567912,
-0.0229730848,
-0.0791995227,
-0.0146116735,
-6.215328667e-33,
0.0269198641,
-0.0252358764,
-0.0327985995,
0.0415059216,
-0.0189704057,
0.0055913855,
-0.0256865434,
-0.0213026553,
-0.0665082335,
0.0070157228,
0.0137713291,
0.0255872402,
-0.005389547,
-0.0037871425,
0.0097376388,
0.0171790589,
0.038132146,
0.0366879851,
-0.0010357376,
0.096688509,
0.0123887239,
-0.0116301682,
0.0143443812,
-0.057867121,
-0.047298193,
-0.0243176688,
0.0191194937,
0.0204772279,
0.0204542596,
0.0796219707,
-0.0401345901,
0.0395907983,
0.0747660771,
-0.0348927453,
-0.0167741608,
0.0029666827,
-0.1035115197,
-0.0802504346,
-0.0737567768,
-0.0398775265,
0.0173090026,
0.0205634702,
0.0229607392,
-0.0278980918,
-0.0153535018,
-0.027035458,
0.067597881,
0.0282064993,
-0.0196854658,
-0.0043952218,
-0.0502823852,
0.026783919,
-0.0108354716,
0.0507813916,
-0.0165151078,
0.079296127,
0.0327047445,
0.065104343,
-0.0776509047,
0.0138518615,
-0.0785267651,
0.0363880321,
0.0064917132,
-0.0566321351,
-0.0047770655,
0.0509561636,
0.0122615723,
-0.0659871101,
0.006608027,
-0.0253000986,
0.006374266,
-0.023568647,
0.0755424201,
0.0042695873,
0.0555501729,
-0.0189623479,
-0.090647392,
0.0441092663,
-0.0061396505,
0.0305832028,
0.0545708649,
0.0410327129,
-0.044051975,
-0.0242328532,
-0.0267967544,
0.0058086263,
-0.0233979076,
-0.0459412858,
0.0375667177,
0.0222435594,
-0.0137189962,
0.0394196436,
0.0008171206,
-0.059492629,
-0.0348852761,
0.0214239676,
0.0292598568,
0.022247171,
0.027755538,
0.0276192799,
-0.0011608031,
-0.0294678546,
-0.0231805705,
0.0042722095,
0.0445522666,
-0.0310774948,
0.0544951595,
-0.0284307953,
-0.0665082261,
0.0248079058,
0.012466142,
-0.0686495155,
-0.0552943796,
0.0116846431,
0.0029986957,
0.0194815826,
0.0297836326,
0.0369100794,
0.0287666768,
0.0036594092,
-0.0481683351,
0.0171804689,
0.0066903709,
0.0184186772,
0.0273965728,
0.0101979692,
-0.0610183775,
0.0214537084,
0.0247634128,
-0.0578646623,
-0.0062247459,
-0.0201471224,
2.744e-7,
0.0232760403,
-0.000933774,
0.0460184738,
-0.0291022584,
0.0379268155,
0.0390135907,
0.0258720368,
0.0780782178,
-0.0133899199,
0.0161516275,
0.0053658662,
0.0541813374,
0.0142028825,
0.0218107123,
-0.0664312392,
0.0130946888,
-0.0840659514,
-0.0224543586,
-0.0494378805,
0.0175501779,
0.0842614919,
0.0746167898,
-0.0179624818,
0.0235839188,
0.0317807421,
-0.036699459,
0.0222178511,
-0.0175669696,
0.0366215706,
0.0489964224,
0.0349219218,
-0.0044245101,
0.0175786782,
-0.0277286675,
-0.0208607335,
0.0023033039,
0.0607605763,
-0.0134627605,
0.0175972469,
0.0020174417,
0.0138980011,
-0.0209842846,
0.0288857948,
-0.0874590427,
0.0546764322,
-0.0693206415,
-0.0284561217,
-0.0295274016,
-0.0104397498,
-0.0198059417,
0.0590243638,
0.0246461947,
-0.0350759774,
0.0123230331,
0.0244926047,
0.0011200357,
-0.0159665421,
-0.0789103508,
0.0290757623,
0.0444246158,
-0.0678456649,
-0.040477138,
-0.0327995494,
0.004248831,
0.0573395379,
0.0295251496,
0.0168014951,
2.597816342e-34,
0.0112810126,
-0.0053121168,
0.0602674447,
0.0044095926,
0.0206990205,
0.0071199923,
-0.0439446941,
-0.0164292976,
-0.0016163364,
-0.036530897,
0.0060762889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15033v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15033v1 | Sparsity-Guided Holistic Explanation for LLMs with Interpretable Inference-Time Intervention | 2023-12-22T19:55:58 | 2023-12-22T19:55:58 | Zhen Tan, Tianlong Chen, Zhenyu Zhang, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved unprecedented breakthroughs in
various natural language processing domains. However, the enigmatic
``black-box'' nature of LLMs remains a significant challenge for
interpretability, hampering transparent and accountable applications. While
past approaches, such as attention visualization, pivotal subnetwork
extraction, and concept-based analyses, offer some insight, they often focus on
either local or global explanations within a single dimension, occasionally
falling short in providing comprehensive clarity. In response, we propose a
novel methodology anchored in sparsity-guided techniques, aiming to provide a
holistic interpretation of LLMs. Our framework, termed SparseCBM, innovatively
integrates sparsity to elucidate three intertwined layers of interpretation:
input, subnetwork, and concept levels. In addition, the newly introduced
dimension of interpretable inference-time intervention facilitates dynamic
adjustments to the model during deployment. Through rigorous empirical
evaluations on real-world datasets, we demonstrate that SparseCBM delivers a
profound understanding of LLM behaviors, setting it apart in both interpreting
and ameliorating model inaccuracies. Codes are provided in supplements. | [
0.0164359063,
0.0533490628,
-0.0393560603,
0.0548134781,
-0.0129106212,
-0.0026267895,
-0.0228921864,
-0.0083267838,
-0.04812821,
-0.0118326647,
0.0061249617,
-0.0231238902,
0.0221021604,
0.0346288048,
0.0476277806,
-0.046763055,
0.0370364822,
-0.0224227943,
-0.0188811589,
0.0272335336,
0.0246703401,
-0.005030822,
0.026588073,
0.0700454712,
0.0075188763,
-0.0231292471,
-0.0427907445,
0.0261362046,
-0.0086797774,
-0.0179684665,
-0.0317147151,
0.0459913053,
0.066083312,
0.0448598079,
0.0000021473,
-0.0301947165,
0.0169002991,
0.0100624487,
-0.0749418214,
0.0359924734,
0.0026180618,
-0.033925537,
0.045856718,
-0.0247374754,
0.0124792177,
0.0185382515,
0.0540955663,
0.0504166558,
0.0266176295,
0.0338472091,
0.0009151285,
-0.0072940094,
-0.0188457966,
-0.0321216732,
0.0002477758,
-0.0362235382,
-0.0030151731,
-0.03418798,
-0.0133926151,
0.027112918,
-0.0488903895,
0.0052938624,
0.0051649064,
-0.0082744602,
0.0579819083,
0.0105716428,
-0.0038089596,
-0.0426232852,
0.0120838862,
0.0426510349,
-0.0211896561,
-0.0035830934,
-0.0073606949,
-0.0052590752,
-0.0137204314,
0.0155686773,
-0.0720172897,
-0.0148657123,
0.0153956329,
0.0319705978,
0.0180372465,
-0.030633498,
0.0570918918,
0.0378862731,
-0.0640259385,
0.0644685626,
-0.0273114387,
-0.031458158,
-0.0352180563,
-0.009586107,
-0.0114660319,
-0.042972073,
0.0145357968,
0.0512603074,
-0.0212812163,
0.0273839254,
0.0140229147,
0.0035136295,
0.0452936776,
-0.014037976,
0.1005388498,
0.0229500197,
-0.0403874032,
0.0411001965,
0.005908981,
0.0290402994,
-0.0219887756,
-0.0044064652,
0.0003931207,
0.0056712613,
-0.035003379,
-0.0337691382,
0.0015828048,
0.0190842655,
-0.0143069606,
-0.0173165966,
-0.0178439859,
0.0139282374,
-0.0281585623,
-0.0194460694,
-0.0021549482,
0.0248637386,
-0.042950511,
-0.0065877568,
-0.0435848609,
0.0325354412,
-0.027808981,
0.0379691571,
0.0108387843,
-0.0530162565,
-0.0662998855,
0.0284479,
0.0016805425,
-0.0306504611,
-0.0343557298,
0.0554287843,
0.0120317349,
-0.0153138582,
-0.0420776531,
-0.0477732234,
-0.0293607078,
-0.0477315672,
-0.0393445268,
-0.048849009,
-0.0098886378,
0.0215560384,
0.0130922748,
-0.0783501342,
0.0026364583,
-0.0149579477,
-0.0667908415,
0.0767872706,
-0.0168335289,
0.0071730129,
-0.0413849279,
0.0132514359,
0.0038120237,
0.0638310015,
0.0098211253,
0.0048902296,
-0.004059562,
-0.0294854175,
-0.0032625252,
0.0206883084,
0.0117738564,
0.0112398574,
-0.0489812307,
-0.0145354532,
-0.0492712781,
0.0254279766,
0.0708613247,
0.0025406545,
-0.0080940332,
-0.0057468298,
0.062656194,
0.0712081194,
0.035783127,
0.0153763993,
0.0361992046,
0.0372271687,
-0.0242280439,
0.0310635436,
-0.0683800876,
0.0297250692,
-0.0310528334,
-0.0026328901,
0.02481189,
-0.005811871,
-0.0031715753,
-0.0425341539,
-0.0239728633,
0.0374213345,
-0.0060214987,
0.0088397609,
0.0704881325,
-0.0015012104,
0.0069334558,
0.086205475,
0.0566904396,
-0.0062913108,
0.0083661554,
-0.0797765478,
0.0133084888,
0.0479791276,
0.0326568559,
-0.0454144143,
0.0115602473,
0.01003672,
0.0185401868,
0.0481907539,
-0.0232474804,
0.0279507339,
0.0146107841,
-0.0147276213,
-0.0368295461,
-0.050627932,
0.0374949388,
0.016051773,
-0.0118879117,
-0.0381148793,
0.0037254668,
-0.0378674492,
-0.0305716395,
0.0356574692,
0.0248853024,
0.0089717191,
0.0048842495,
-0.0038835094,
0.0373446047,
0.0198717527,
0.0045830542,
0.0168765821,
0.02749216,
-0.0258761104,
-0.0015652635,
-0.0278106742,
-0.0105974553,
-0.0238069165,
0.0110484129,
-0.0285247825,
-0.0082852133,
0.0196737871,
-0.0359696597,
-0.0363680013,
0.0237898454,
-0.0495387763,
0.0279956907,
-0.0173610784,
0.0036765274,
0.0007330869,
0.0420053713,
-0.0475391634,
0.0589448251,
-0.0341287628,
-0.0068860613,
0.0256906338,
-0.0000808183,
-0.0098052584,
-0.0364753157,
-0.0054378584,
0.0056787506,
-0.0124205528,
-0.0194467697,
-0.0117238956,
-0.0163350031,
-0.0260803811,
0.0177449826,
-0.0336522274,
-0.0266499911,
-0.0186562035,
-0.0029146178,
0.0125071798,
0.0031590485,
0.0252176616,
0.0158956069,
0.009953334,
0.0233265739,
0.0063346014,
0.0217931662,
0.0258753709,
0.0029220895,
-0.0437479168,
-0.0456718095,
-0.0113195945,
0.0054751388,
0.0611819029,
-0.0131028984,
-0.0198481213,
-0.0741705894,
0.0346311443,
0.0066162064,
-0.0198988095,
-0.0278020445,
-0.0191952065,
0.0273534264,
-0.0300191063,
-0.0070994827,
0.0300650578,
-0.0047541768,
0.1041753069,
0.0600078218,
0.0201209262,
-0.0548710525,
-0.0100938836,
-0.022891311,
-0.0006464004,
-0.0522645973,
-0.0361006185,
-0.0018098284,
0.1064398736,
0.0007778482,
-0.0049935901,
-0.0405073948,
0.0051098312,
-0.0118765542,
-0.0344993882,
-0.0716056973,
0.0043109073,
-0.0168806631,
0.0654600039,
-0.0446003452,
-0.0769776255,
0.0716995448,
-0.021553224,
0.0059889373,
0.0445172191,
-0.0374411866,
-0.0494412854,
0.0633726418,
-0.0002902523,
-0.0145016536,
0.0075594638,
-0.0400946625,
-0.024339499,
-0.0044841776,
-0.0148319239,
0.0104977759,
0.1006618887,
-0.0459001288,
-0.0053759133,
0.0123613412,
0.0227402579,
-0.0408307016,
-0.0242684893,
-0.0272475109,
0.0115936315,
0.0579691902,
0.0040488751,
-0.0402007848,
0.0247672666,
0.0321206041,
-0.0135102505,
-0.0171411373,
-0.0189369563,
-0.0372642875,
0.0121506732,
0.031475693,
0.0514074005,
0.0394851305,
-0.0262923054,
-0.018167153,
0.0672590137,
-0.0072773364,
-0.0279666036,
-0.0391433351,
0.0268676635,
0.0192439854,
-0.0146351177,
-0.0140947513,
0.016756257,
0.0544382818,
-0.1117463484,
-0.0105794398,
0.1093393117,
0.012911424,
-0.0526286215,
0.0650274307,
-0.0392906182,
0.0381864794,
0.0459717549,
-0.0074342429,
-0.030966131,
-0.0497773066,
-0.0008807966,
0.0280017219,
-0.0044692657,
-0.0225007758,
0.0048046461,
-0.0556473024,
0.032741677,
-0.0021977704,
-0.0199833419,
-0.0196293313,
-0.0919578373,
0.0181098953,
-0.0064783972,
0.00352534,
0.0072368565,
0.006217272,
-0.0161913913,
0.0159496106,
-0.0378052369,
-0.0453244485,
0.0298378319,
-0.0015869231,
0.034318883,
-0.0016048346,
0.0182290804,
-0.0251213051,
-0.0050267167,
0.0126079824,
-0.0318385176,
0.0584874041,
-0.0330580436,
0.0390688181,
0.0164345354,
-0.0036927185,
-0.016550513,
0.0225945823,
-0.0217916165,
-0.0320939645,
-0.0193720739,
0.0968176499,
-0.0374194868,
-0.0055701993,
-0.0150996726,
-0.0215793829,
0.0123554319,
0.0930002108,
0.0794816911,
-0.0243295152,
-0.0449029654,
-0.017712824,
-0.0368093848,
-0.0030082879,
-0.0670049414,
0.0259989556,
0.0087582655,
-0.0406387374,
0.0321017578,
-0.0235860944,
0.0245628804,
-0.0208074339,
0.0042704218,
0.0251698773,
-0.0097863432,
-0.0238687452,
-0.0125233326,
0.0873699635,
-0.0129837124,
0.0194756817,
-0.0307609718,
-0.0360791385,
-0.0066731246,
-0.0189354699,
-0.0046633361,
0.0362591594,
-0.0660241321,
-0.0410908423,
0.0137183042,
0.005218952,
0.0262056328,
0.0413772762,
0.0086792,
-0.0831318125,
0.040666189,
0.0071886424,
-0.0236468576,
0.0288516842,
0.0224703345,
-0.0123419324,
-0.0027911798,
0.073990196,
-0.0201672651,
0.0127589274,
-0.0013019625,
0.0580095723,
-0.0485216305,
-0.015470203,
0.0209335387,
-0.0252083112,
0.0669610575,
-0.0090609482,
-0.0271054432,
-0.0297387633,
-0.0132904854,
0.003882285,
0.005087263,
-0.0408488922,
-0.0412383564,
0.0054345056,
-0.0369597673,
-0.00179982,
-0.0229210611,
-0.0473762639,
0.0238691568,
-0.049743209,
0.0560132489,
0.0213248078,
-0.0426856019,
0.0292856209,
0.0293696783,
-0.0163420849,
0.0193258189,
-0.0600038432,
0.0043840958,
0.0201049317,
0.0439141542,
-0.0007337634,
0.0275787283,
-0.0532207489,
0.0106926281,
-0.0617819726,
-0.0261916984,
0.0537425466,
0.0082867509,
0.0270895604,
-0.0261497777,
0.0795239359,
0.0029590835,
-0.0121205747,
-0.0149486875,
0.0597794838,
0.0069774315,
-0.0247767083,
0.0266244784,
0.0442333259,
-0.0376516134,
0.0211540423,
0.0928652212,
0.0164649077,
0.0273009855,
-0.013214577,
-0.0219591837,
-0.0136877028,
-0.0305823311,
0.0587351695,
0.0708303973,
-0.0139360428,
0.0174217634,
-0.0859371647,
-0.0914045051,
0.0029972051,
-0.0365964659,
-0.0033950873,
-0.0591754317,
0.02059347,
0.0547824092,
0.0062587941,
-0.0051902058,
-0.0208593123,
0.0086429818,
-0.0099256253,
-0.0086103128,
-0.0151373679,
-7.070928393e-33,
-0.0174956731,
-0.0712082461,
-0.0237777848,
-0.0232819244,
-0.0309817139,
0.0315672047,
-0.0577959344,
0.0102312081,
-0.0001533222,
0.0444311202,
-0.0022217168,
0.0221270639,
-0.0080763958,
0.0426602624,
-0.0010404928,
-0.0082919691,
0.044838164,
0.0412826724,
-0.0018080948,
0.0235457271,
0.0496185608,
0.0332294479,
0.0355339423,
-0.0305691492,
0.0705517679,
0.0204729233,
0.0049533178,
0.0231111869,
-0.0107253641,
0.065697141,
-0.0231195707,
0.0708434135,
0.0432125628,
-0.0750816092,
-0.0292268731,
-0.0064240955,
-0.0500090085,
-0.0095189093,
0.0669212714,
-0.0034311658,
-0.0148863262,
-0.058942385,
0.0636746138,
0.0234884769,
0.0216736607,
-0.0667034239,
0.0466037616,
-0.0196670908,
-0.0628255308,
0.0078326594,
-0.0505966954,
0.0290284641,
-0.0553132929,
-0.0088318391,
0.0143038733,
-0.002659648,
-0.029138647,
0.0421164744,
-0.0401519239,
-0.0212962627,
0.0472941957,
0.0440840311,
0.0880763754,
0.0498707406,
-0.0083310744,
0.0427560136,
-0.0184086934,
0.0012542008,
-0.0577559471,
-0.019670371,
0.0329518467,
0.0672955364,
0.0271284562,
-0.0199726261,
0.0210927408,
0.0287060998,
-0.0843702182,
-0.0067035076,
-0.0275385268,
0.0988685861,
0.0574381649,
0.0381817222,
-0.0220673922,
-0.0272172522,
-0.0194738861,
-0.0290932227,
-0.0475068949,
-0.0152789084,
0.0159510355,
-0.0259870123,
-0.0412312634,
-0.0081796506,
0.0272309426,
-0.0438781939,
0.0113742342,
0.0167954136,
0.0150716025,
0.004230516,
0.0396230295,
-0.0057846825,
-0.0236680824,
-0.0147043932,
-0.0058637317,
0.0015191101,
0.0315238461,
0.0198194794,
0.0360820517,
-0.0177356824,
0.0042911875,
-0.0300992541,
-0.0534666665,
-0.0345352888,
-0.0530163571,
0.014994313,
0.0439799465,
-0.0003817763,
-0.0316622481,
0.0611476302,
0.0049430938,
0.0162649155,
0.0111011984,
0.0087449905,
-0.0231882669,
0.021293547,
-0.0381791219,
-0.0208433624,
-0.0442264825,
-0.0248938873,
0.0651336089,
-0.0435334481,
-0.051620543,
-0.0102148782,
2.763e-7,
0.0491096564,
0.0455319919,
-0.0126571702,
0.0581782162,
0.0516367257,
0.0127131678,
-0.0001478058,
0.0096417097,
-0.0064473725,
-0.0626398176,
0.0022965681,
0.0609316751,
0.0504625365,
-0.0085457759,
-0.0252724234,
-0.0220095478,
-0.0405597575,
-0.0199981406,
-0.0476640053,
0.0080548115,
0.0720061436,
0.0849000067,
-0.0063184542,
0.0010389629,
0.0093479175,
0.0101087075,
0.0256051868,
-0.0333407,
0.0186984781,
-0.0132615827,
0.0298048183,
-0.009543146,
0.0236921255,
0.0059187734,
0.0115812542,
0.008222973,
-0.0163108259,
0.0836352706,
-0.0560909249,
-0.0094301589,
-0.0330703594,
-0.0239026044,
0.0135618029,
-0.0860580876,
0.0742059723,
-0.0638513193,
-0.0652908683,
-0.009455638,
0.0279288702,
-0.033633545,
-0.0167480949,
0.0135170398,
0.0052242689,
0.0063686701,
-0.0049315519,
-0.0283108335,
-0.0326352157,
-0.0628179908,
-0.0214255825,
0.0147204762,
-0.0573547147,
-0.0256581586,
-0.0498484597,
-0.0243256819,
0.0534253605,
-0.0405043848,
-0.0161265917,
2.810412531e-34,
0.0322707444,
0.0269424357,
0.0171653144,
0.0170302782,
0.0367832147,
-0.0069320071,
-0.0093359165,
0.0301554184,
0.0407852307,
-0.1164798588,
-0.0094031775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15021v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15021v1 | Towards a Unified Multimodal Reasoning Framework | 2023-12-22T19:07:00 | 2023-12-22T19:07:00 | Abhinav Arun, Dipendra Singh Mal, Mehul Soni, Tomohiro Sawada | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in deep learning have led to the development of powerful
language models (LMs) that excel in various tasks. Despite these achievements,
there is still room for improvement, particularly in enhancing reasoning
abilities and incorporating multimodal data. This report investigates the
potential impact of combining Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning and Visual
Question Answering (VQA) techniques to improve LM's accuracy in solving
multiple-choice questions. By employing TextVQA and ScienceQA datasets, we
assessed the effectiveness of three text embedding methods and three visual
embedding approaches. Our experiments aimed to fill the gap in current research
by investigating the combined impact of CoT and VQA, contributing to the
understanding of how these techniques can improve the reasoning capabilities of
state-of-the-art models like GPT-4. Results from our experiments demonstrated
the potential of these approaches in enhancing LM's reasoning and
question-answering capabilities, providing insights for further research and
development in the field, and paving the way for more accurate and reliable AI
systems that can handle complex reasoning tasks across multiple modalities. | [
0.0216966104,
0.0448379032,
-0.0213692915,
0.0484764315,
-0.0457716323,
0.0094752423,
0.0327443741,
-0.0100190602,
0.035506703,
-0.0298823994,
-0.0013969759,
-0.0246852543,
-0.0111310864,
0.0349922255,
0.0576182641,
-0.0650770441,
0.0310741868,
-0.0329348706,
0.0041095805,
-0.0098788859,
0.0109620541,
0.0171508435,
-0.0242500473,
0.0335956961,
-0.0398812927,
-0.0456333421,
-0.0344581641,
-0.0098978095,
0.0418228544,
-0.034182433,
-0.0259188171,
0.0508937426,
0.0718043298,
0.0253508445,
0.0000021508,
-0.0143991457,
-0.0016506434,
0.0077842139,
-0.0116274673,
-0.0089367172,
-0.0306509752,
0.0045098485,
0.0571109876,
0.0241478495,
-0.0349460654,
-0.0206317659,
0.0427702069,
0.0140224779,
0.0672354251,
0.0007325267,
-0.0123698208,
-0.0327145979,
0.0317939408,
0.0051926929,
0.0152744325,
-0.0263397358,
-0.0024872299,
0.0356818102,
0.0251636282,
0.0258807205,
-0.0527019762,
0.0524661914,
0.0426822603,
0.0120832399,
-0.0320045054,
0.0470803864,
-0.0239754654,
-0.0283177998,
-0.0111525515,
0.1129716486,
-0.0146010956,
-0.0132590951,
-0.0461220704,
0.0031175732,
0.006384192,
0.0188605152,
-0.055118043,
0.0399704576,
-0.0139181968,
0.0010774757,
-0.0450572073,
-0.0115370182,
0.0038339829,
0.0149277812,
-0.0175812915,
0.0111684175,
0.0109713795,
-0.0036156764,
0.0263039712,
0.0125995949,
-0.0530239828,
-0.0300800446,
0.002339442,
0.0472193956,
-0.00239291,
0.0212004036,
-0.0122847641,
-0.0277830176,
0.0003729845,
-0.0098179532,
0.0331245624,
0.0454741344,
-0.0647646636,
0.0525450855,
-0.0388663299,
0.050209716,
-0.0523734577,
0.0523005165,
-0.0260653328,
-0.0440480039,
-0.0527264811,
-0.0451246127,
-0.0329230279,
0.0255560596,
-0.0362671018,
-0.0463760942,
0.012378756,
0.0301634911,
0.0080262832,
-0.003264837,
-0.0040011746,
0.0373160094,
0.020383006,
-0.004993889,
-0.0754364654,
0.0620834678,
-0.0552543476,
0.0277260467,
0.0195060354,
-0.0261240099,
-0.0003868054,
0.0127787776,
0.0261133555,
-0.033820942,
0.0466599353,
0.0526695773,
-0.0449330807,
-0.0183187835,
-0.0051576365,
-0.0298720375,
-0.0176829677,
-0.0655531436,
0.0561170541,
-0.0734387934,
0.0303282533,
0.0073170578,
-0.0181017127,
0.0042358902,
0.0044916612,
0.0492036641,
-0.0222452227,
0.0949546471,
-0.0037856456,
-0.0204012915,
0.0307352282,
0.0097866384,
0.0009361,
0.0447615124,
0.0412194505,
0.0293950848,
0.0473808274,
-0.0129788201,
0.0269223396,
0.009763293,
-0.0006665941,
-0.0206386186,
-0.0129610226,
0.0122322161,
-0.009277218,
0.0418237634,
0.0031921274,
0.0510216951,
-0.0174832735,
-0.0328111202,
0.0664351508,
0.0563824959,
0.01422654,
-0.0210764464,
0.0285388958,
-0.0158916395,
0.0203674082,
0.010003102,
-0.0350093171,
0.0854803175,
-0.0191628858,
0.0045230617,
0.034671668,
0.0451576971,
-0.0324057192,
-0.0415540226,
-0.0223068204,
0.0278363973,
0.0238828603,
0.062054757,
0.0363446698,
-0.006805222,
-0.0457505248,
-0.0149216065,
0.0035240438,
-0.0245103911,
-0.024816988,
-0.0202452987,
0.0296176728,
0.0363464169,
0.0514469519,
0.001365865,
-0.0381661244,
-0.0016157943,
0.0281333271,
0.0327301733,
0.0094130933,
0.005036972,
0.0177768674,
-0.0499731712,
-0.0375643373,
-0.0409376658,
-0.0328668579,
0.0275916159,
-0.0246708877,
0.0057984008,
-0.0195898172,
-0.037464533,
0.0703068227,
0.016924601,
0.0368308015,
0.0111895092,
-0.0304340664,
0.0443716981,
-0.0229603983,
-0.0017657594,
0.0105606942,
0.0052935118,
0.0033369816,
-0.0352087282,
-0.0303454213,
0.0029868574,
-0.0556550808,
-0.0491193384,
0.0227892343,
-0.0834850967,
-0.019522313,
0.0402891301,
-0.0400969982,
-0.024940284,
0.0036150941,
-0.0478709489,
-0.0384151936,
-0.0527049676,
-0.04600228,
0.0232324693,
0.0294479188,
-0.0322917104,
0.0759933367,
-0.0273137614,
-0.014462905,
0.0067616631,
0.0507766753,
0.0618609302,
-0.0077750748,
-0.0077369311,
0.0287901852,
0.0048814532,
0.0043640411,
-0.0121212984,
0.0132390633,
-0.0562416911,
0.0164387133,
-0.0944369361,
0.0036982701,
-0.0014675708,
-0.0253969636,
-0.0056863655,
-0.0039608222,
0.0071697142,
-0.0310851056,
-0.0600052811,
0.0213880707,
0.0217725765,
0.0211709179,
0.0576297417,
-0.0131524708,
0.016157534,
-0.0119090099,
-0.0153164659,
-0.0360811129,
0.090987891,
-0.0152984494,
0.0012150608,
-0.0060867369,
-0.0319996141,
-0.0670709684,
0.0459856056,
0.0032125833,
-0.0166320596,
0.05244679,
-0.0141186696,
0.0671843886,
0.0646548718,
-0.0086963652,
0.0096930452,
0.0589441955,
-0.0023176759,
-0.0274617374,
0.0366442911,
-0.0008390041,
-0.0076901894,
0.0162675604,
-0.0155544197,
-0.0621008016,
0.0105031403,
0.0066761253,
-0.0228485055,
-0.0580047965,
0.0372358114,
0.0493411981,
-0.0222619977,
-0.0636011586,
0.0066954866,
0.0162983537,
0.0656966716,
-0.0202982388,
-0.0307656992,
0.0771609172,
-0.0293362048,
-0.002387031,
-0.0236221496,
0.0044991272,
-0.0421019942,
0.1022505984,
0.0241885353,
0.0029393351,
0.0017167452,
0.0124080824,
-0.077075839,
-0.0145371519,
0.0146674979,
-0.0190859772,
0.0433290675,
-0.0563510098,
-0.0186904036,
-0.0084433239,
-0.0193821136,
-0.0424457788,
-0.0050068474,
-0.0353164561,
0.0069247694,
-0.0250702817,
0.0173722785,
-0.0029179542,
0.0134023419,
0.0624906681,
-0.0046388712,
0.0057969755,
-0.0168556739,
-0.0286799092,
0.0791545659,
0.0558350049,
0.045394063,
-0.0000976859,
-0.0101550762,
0.0253671948,
0.0392155871,
0.0104822079,
0.0003670068,
-0.048787605,
0.0302822143,
-0.0001070256,
0.046462547,
-0.0188277792,
0.0050754668,
0.0311474111,
-0.0622349307,
-0.0007808408,
0.0664943755,
0.0419554636,
-0.0291145053,
-0.004913094,
-0.0185403116,
0.0349501222,
0.032001093,
0.0381312929,
-0.099172093,
-0.0620290376,
0.0014179215,
-0.0366585366,
0.0175474603,
-0.0099101095,
-0.0051818541,
-0.098195374,
0.0410981551,
-0.0387571827,
-0.0243093353,
-0.0529480949,
-0.0286084767,
-0.0058767088,
0.0359714217,
0.0005933837,
-0.0097744269,
0.0316399224,
0.0080249738,
0.0037272512,
0.0034440525,
0.0112508126,
0.029737113,
-0.0509663559,
-0.0341873541,
0.0443269238,
0.0332544595,
-0.0038952671,
-0.0779911801,
0.0162642524,
-0.0182812866,
0.0064575933,
-0.0060857479,
0.0506859832,
-0.0063026883,
-0.0214728285,
-0.019923361,
0.0401914716,
0.012166799,
-0.0142397694,
0.0054387823,
0.098865971,
-0.0245487839,
-0.0259868391,
-0.047735475,
0.0236479323,
-0.0505082831,
0.0343462825,
0.0361712426,
-0.0392977037,
-0.0604166612,
-0.0372267254,
0.015008498,
-0.0406662859,
-0.0398105569,
0.0113992635,
0.0482407138,
0.0335813537,
-0.0463849865,
-0.0409668759,
0.0591627136,
0.0572977699,
-0.0233632438,
0.0056827636,
-0.0198294222,
0.0491282716,
-0.024236463,
0.0392210595,
-0.0199262779,
0.0324378908,
0.0092543913,
0.0318722613,
-0.004280895,
-0.0576753281,
-0.0373215377,
0.0143930456,
-0.0643397272,
-0.0221819803,
-0.0694814026,
0.0292517375,
0.0107498029,
0.0121889217,
0.0304105338,
-0.0538241602,
0.0239509102,
0.0092053264,
0.0283477828,
-0.0025949043,
-0.0139203854,
0.0096052261,
0.0094082123,
0.0060203192,
-0.0335061923,
-0.0054764925,
-0.0291115213,
0.0426902957,
0.0096752057,
0.0038292527,
0.0300113391,
-0.0084014116,
0.0169871319,
0.0047183526,
-0.0210259613,
-0.0154740261,
0.0210550167,
-0.013305217,
-0.0144434413,
-0.040943969,
0.0275584087,
0.0107593779,
-0.0183079932,
0.0091809453,
-0.0600323156,
0.0222613979,
0.0352519155,
0.0060884198,
0.0023450642,
0.0601314791,
0.0315017104,
-0.0284774918,
0.0022255979,
-0.0167145394,
0.0041810246,
-0.0309980866,
0.0519537218,
-0.0118194008,
0.0896890908,
0.0346979424,
-0.0585670285,
-0.0242519975,
0.0328685269,
-0.0751224682,
-0.0455158167,
0.0235204939,
0.0229149032,
0.0526307896,
0.0241103675,
-0.0354878865,
-0.026950473,
-0.0207386762,
0.0224254727,
0.0121321632,
0.0210542865,
-0.0282455478,
0.0714154914,
0.0238445271,
0.0051329872,
-0.021894848,
0.0416965224,
0.0192352664,
0.0101413038,
0.0109937731,
-0.0145437596,
-0.026220968,
-0.036813654,
-0.0134388739,
0.034940321,
0.0151432194,
0.0169859696,
-0.0442266017,
-0.0833901912,
-0.0059653395,
0.0139441947,
-0.0204167906,
0.0265225079,
0.0263185967,
0.0480224267,
0.0382785909,
-0.0507800393,
0.009257474,
0.0209562089,
-0.027836116,
-0.0227553435,
0.0023405754,
-6.205613941e-33,
-0.0090565411,
-0.0455470011,
0.0567226447,
-0.025375722,
-0.0056870203,
0.0034015183,
-0.0292029474,
0.0026537371,
-0.0617287569,
0.018762026,
-0.0093674203,
-0.021039281,
-0.0091019869,
0.0564160421,
-0.019371232,
-0.0335212313,
-0.0309294052,
-0.0039611179,
-0.0163505115,
0.0120344134,
0.026498748,
-0.0004288811,
0.0334092081,
-0.018777119,
-0.0126480721,
0.0269544926,
-0.0052379896,
0.0309270751,
-0.0575779453,
0.0700622648,
-0.0467179641,
0.0212625451,
0.0287201479,
-0.0109238653,
0.0034707412,
0.0426832326,
-0.0708910823,
-0.0305568557,
0.0199125912,
-0.004671657,
-0.1154381558,
-0.0019986001,
0.0155671006,
-0.0195995234,
0.0375538617,
-0.0672688857,
0.0595482923,
-0.0064062048,
0.0073175873,
-0.0086539397,
-0.0198380016,
-0.0162892453,
-0.0318510346,
-0.0242668297,
0.0075448258,
0.0624845773,
0.0223311782,
0.0532203987,
-0.0546545871,
0.0070000179,
-0.0266085695,
-0.0253468156,
0.0836646035,
0.0032247796,
-0.0011329532,
0.0343907215,
0.0155086722,
-0.0604634844,
-0.073122032,
-0.0318168849,
0.0210614018,
0.0532127619,
0.1119549423,
0.0519182906,
0.0203047059,
0.0349449329,
-0.0728025883,
-0.0019997417,
-0.0348302498,
0.0317821205,
0.0131991394,
-0.000154484,
-0.0043057371,
-0.0043646223,
-0.0685784817,
0.0045222719,
-0.0468679965,
-0.0107454797,
0.0535030328,
-0.027369488,
0.0013467242,
0.0163963027,
0.0690440461,
-0.0339657813,
0.0053219977,
0.0296221524,
-0.0202572569,
0.0643791854,
0.0226068888,
0.0619158931,
-0.0013230685,
0.0447358601,
0.0564763285,
0.0047421441,
-0.0030244461,
-0.0079370588,
0.0319418684,
0.004239826,
-0.0219073463,
-0.014317736,
-0.0605779253,
-0.0124813812,
-0.0235717259,
-0.0021939431,
0.0182590783,
0.0200059693,
-0.0341826156,
0.0106812613,
-0.0096845943,
0.0055736168,
-0.0394280292,
-0.0440545306,
-0.0348760635,
0.0100717321,
-0.0252947379,
0.0140695609,
-0.0554502755,
-0.0540953837,
0.0006465719,
-0.0899542868,
0.0020782382,
0.0700413734,
2.671e-7,
0.0533857644,
0.0417345092,
0.0097599141,
0.0234668124,
-0.0005172058,
0.0430052616,
-0.0002736031,
0.0068654851,
0.0219257753,
-0.0571629666,
-0.012937203,
0.0754152983,
0.0237861332,
0.0202092249,
0.00007188,
-0.0030710555,
-0.0053495178,
-0.0370576307,
-0.0675404742,
0.0059017255,
0.0793394521,
0.0577103756,
-0.0095936963,
-0.0396823026,
0.0127822785,
-0.0162558518,
0.0449483283,
-0.0147911366,
0.0156779643,
-0.033654999,
0.008014393,
-0.0000150424,
-0.0012009804,
0.0421350934,
0.0139651084,
-0.022506319,
0.0328369774,
-0.0086816261,
0.0162422098,
-0.0632512122,
-0.0437821262,
0.0042436705,
-0.0166863333,
-0.0785928965,
0.1227909997,
-0.0395280272,
-0.0239641648,
0.0113016739,
-0.0240443405,
-0.0168637298,
0.0336756036,
-0.0107721481,
-0.0224573631,
0.0126546826,
0.0099494001,
-0.0274589527,
0.0090612359,
-0.0942066088,
-0.0052875862,
0.0041979784,
-0.0453439429,
0.0012641221,
-0.035617061,
-0.0283929799,
0.0735842437,
-0.0292133465,
-0.0617935881,
2.281535812e-34,
0.0135644609,
-0.0223215539,
0.0482928641,
-0.0070063812,
0.0266848225,
-0.0155755058,
0.0016136027,
-0.0344581231,
0.0328021161,
-0.1102294102,
-0.0331870653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14890v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14890v4 | NPHardEval: Dynamic Benchmark on Reasoning Ability of Large Language Models via Complexity Classes | 2023-12-22T18:07:44 | 2024-02-12T17:30:25 | Lizhou Fan, Wenyue Hua, Lingyao Li, Haoyang Ling, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CC, cs.CL, cs.LG | Complex reasoning ability is one of the most important features of current
LLMs, which has also been leveraged to play an integral role in complex
decision-making tasks. Therefore, the investigation into the reasoning
capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) is critical: numerous benchmarks
have been established to assess the reasoning abilities of LLMs. However,
current benchmarks are inadequate in offering a rigorous evaluation of the full
extent of reasoning abilities that LLMs are capable of achieving. They are also
prone to the risk of overfitting, as these benchmarks, being publicly
accessible and static, allow models to potentially tailor their responses to
specific benchmark metrics, thereby inflating their performance. Addressing
these limitations, our research introduces a new benchmark, named NPHardEval.
This benchmark is designed to evaluate the reasoning abilities of LLMs across a
broad spectrum of 900 algorithmic questions, extending up to the NP-Hard
complexity class. These questions are meticulously chosen to represent a wide
range of complexity class below the NP-hard complexity class, offering a
rigorous measure of the reasoning ability of LLMs. Through this study, we shed
light on the current state of reasoning in LLMs, providing an objective and
rigorous perspective through the comparison of LLMs' performance across complex
classes. Moreover, this benchmark is designed with a dynamic update mechanism,
where the datapoints are refreshed on a monthly basis. Such regular updates
play a crucial role in mitigating the risk of LLMs overfitting to the
benchmark, promoting a more accurate and reliable assessment of their reasoning
capabilities. The benchmark dataset and code of NPHardEval are available at
https://github.com/casmlab/NPHardEval. | [
-0.002092211,
0.0523540899,
0.0007650374,
0.0335583054,
-0.0601740479,
0.0422238894,
-0.0171385314,
0.0078331344,
0.0171719454,
-0.0230178405,
0.0037931632,
-0.0052952729,
-0.0089266011,
0.0324354172,
0.0057592648,
-0.0166714843,
0.0336083323,
-0.0631847531,
0.0159921683,
-0.0169929732,
-0.0334931202,
-0.0132070426,
-0.0148170153,
0.0058652922,
0.0324969329,
-0.0189736728,
-0.0067169536,
-0.0232409462,
0.003166938,
-0.0280737877,
-0.0115320925,
0.0391796231,
0.0294062588,
0.0491466261,
0.0000022257,
-0.058437407,
-0.0124265002,
0.0095939832,
-0.0621761493,
0.0293792523,
0.0159412753,
0.0017752037,
0.0014634203,
0.0424409732,
-0.0281190723,
-0.0039742915,
0.0163976029,
0.0128332227,
0.0213601738,
0.0703227296,
0.0122233685,
-0.010254004,
0.0108299712,
-0.0088321809,
-0.0020990672,
-0.0610627271,
-0.0007295968,
0.0214443505,
0.0339149274,
-0.0204447787,
0.0123164169,
0.0198704563,
0.0485057086,
0.0105065089,
-0.038901709,
0.0394173712,
-0.0308846235,
0.0151129803,
0.0136859715,
0.0369888693,
-0.0173119698,
0.0181115363,
-0.0193510968,
0.0020650586,
-0.0232078508,
-0.0128373196,
-0.030877931,
0.0261742603,
-0.0269119795,
0.0142383361,
0.0304326974,
0.0106478995,
0.0602329448,
0.0142096272,
-0.0558042638,
0.0968330428,
-0.0049450188,
-0.003773872,
0.0306850914,
-0.0434435941,
-0.0262564216,
-0.0504011773,
-0.0044926708,
0.0559091978,
-0.0485392623,
0.0142446412,
0.0432397462,
0.0347246639,
0.0290440936,
-0.0334895663,
0.0620609224,
0.0356536061,
0.0076888744,
0.0674060136,
-0.0463127829,
0.0964131355,
-0.0078444201,
0.0210373793,
0.0054696416,
-0.0159826521,
-0.0300386138,
0.0040912651,
0.0146818645,
0.0447119065,
-0.0022553811,
0.0242008939,
-0.0532203242,
0.0054081329,
-0.0359897614,
0.0612104684,
-0.0105994185,
-0.0405596346,
0.025489388,
-0.0415784493,
-0.0677452534,
0.0046778587,
-0.0426167212,
0.015197101,
0.0045666131,
-0.0542260185,
0.0299993902,
-0.0303757675,
0.0035212177,
-0.0203665327,
0.0415044203,
0.0856093541,
-0.0081701744,
-0.0054530366,
-0.068157129,
-0.032418061,
0.0137310512,
-0.0969172642,
-0.0080317995,
-0.082997106,
0.0324236117,
0.0303816404,
-0.0241447873,
-0.0415234789,
0.0048722592,
-0.0032254418,
-0.00799846,
0.0846829936,
0.0397125296,
0.0247623492,
-0.014785815,
0.0252476819,
-0.0315968953,
0.0612327829,
0.0350117572,
0.0014306748,
0.0289821457,
-0.0046575195,
0.0122176288,
0.0259887613,
-0.0255508646,
-0.0110751046,
-0.0317217633,
0.0536621399,
-0.024061881,
0.0125060296,
-0.0604626574,
0.0716637745,
-0.00901997,
-0.0346578173,
0.0227982234,
0.0097611314,
0.0329832248,
0.0143703762,
0.0198160838,
-0.0241803583,
0.0200200509,
-0.0176159143,
-0.0702550113,
0.0491943061,
-0.0662161112,
0.0098518608,
-0.0018460769,
0.0153044267,
-0.0074414825,
-0.1022857428,
-0.0384938158,
0.0026540607,
0.0194916911,
0.023980923,
0.0717009082,
-0.0346813723,
-0.0452512912,
0.0204226188,
0.0222740192,
-0.0331126861,
-0.0358576663,
-0.0669515803,
0.0356613472,
0.0401081666,
0.0385520719,
-0.0524346046,
-0.0448852181,
0.0148784285,
-0.0028523053,
-0.0006960524,
0.0507683679,
-0.0056759762,
0.0101619819,
-0.0430602618,
-0.0125160348,
-0.0259778481,
0.0182163324,
0.0207532104,
0.0321438275,
0.012700554,
0.0027541849,
-0.0593767948,
-0.0373629332,
0.003187645,
-0.057171464,
-0.0093566421,
-0.0351848677,
0.0114783812,
0.0293422248,
-0.0115285749,
-0.0069864038,
0.0251591075,
0.0067129689,
-0.0302659348,
-0.0218104459,
-0.0238233805,
-0.0207962375,
-0.0129882339,
0.0370397642,
-0.0409389324,
-0.0461271256,
0.054038085,
-0.0497340262,
-0.0224605594,
0.0575286038,
-0.0062702177,
-0.0061412244,
-0.0410726853,
0.0192786735,
-0.0339999348,
0.0057683187,
-0.0081430618,
0.0813499317,
-0.0334455334,
0.0427042879,
0.0183192845,
0.005047821,
0.0303866286,
0.0015377187,
-0.0348682106,
0.0431565121,
-0.0195541978,
0.0066179098,
0.0016691118,
-0.0139241535,
-0.0475615524,
-0.0512282215,
-0.0383613408,
0.0153443804,
-0.0123285986,
0.0163429026,
-0.0000773233,
-0.024303792,
0.0101339044,
0.0319115967,
-0.0376965776,
0.0167046785,
0.0138463341,
0.031072842,
0.0471788831,
0.0189097766,
-0.0345528685,
-0.0240324885,
-0.0118570914,
-0.040409755,
0.0282844696,
-0.0008450395,
0.0243504234,
0.0112622445,
0.031230377,
-0.046545662,
0.0018895327,
-0.0445816107,
-0.0136563266,
0.0207911097,
-0.0329314023,
0.0123132253,
0.0716499239,
-0.0214809179,
-0.0088288402,
0.0591464154,
-0.0226750672,
-0.042023655,
0.0409632809,
-0.0105474638,
-0.02986959,
-0.0448539481,
-0.0518843718,
-0.0250901971,
0.0843509361,
-0.0492384806,
-0.0279120579,
-0.0333459489,
0.0181529373,
-0.0298976768,
0.0235117096,
-0.0188700818,
0.039086353,
0.0244912319,
0.0765778348,
-0.0381489471,
-0.0483740084,
0.0580833927,
-0.006043944,
-0.0214113146,
-0.0216299538,
-0.0234325249,
-0.073559843,
0.0931930691,
0.0246627014,
-0.0015034954,
0.0086651919,
-0.0132383574,
-0.0434673019,
-0.0462285206,
0.0318390653,
-0.0484456271,
0.0635066852,
-0.0428196751,
-0.0073317569,
-0.008689221,
-0.0396414213,
-0.0256149732,
0.023737967,
-0.0601927638,
0.0309920087,
-0.0195414945,
-0.0533240624,
-0.0120587638,
-0.003286964,
-0.0180432331,
0.0193517078,
0.013800947,
-0.0199595448,
-0.0092720725,
-0.0224565193,
-0.0027664998,
0.0470279194,
0.050308384,
-0.0325264037,
0.0602307506,
0.0497546718,
0.0510714166,
0.0062125544,
-0.051850114,
0.0361981839,
0.0066025849,
-0.0124213435,
-0.0102090286,
0.0411596447,
-0.0028031559,
-0.0727655664,
0.0041851117,
0.1271657795,
0.0253975,
0.006917472,
0.0133875487,
-0.0338416472,
0.0368594006,
0.0698542893,
0.0425952896,
-0.0431298018,
-0.0340118483,
0.035785418,
0.0057334965,
-0.0373325348,
-0.0806559548,
-0.0173820592,
-0.1256566942,
0.036564365,
-0.0072919093,
-0.0139479227,
-0.0248738322,
-0.0472651199,
0.0055890898,
-0.0148440311,
-0.0114996172,
0.0173599664,
0.0350084677,
-0.0234547965,
0.0121387001,
-0.0548178591,
-0.0205116402,
0.0807055607,
-0.0223450735,
0.0348497182,
0.0026126087,
0.0512488969,
-0.0300816,
-0.0331257619,
0.0888583735,
0.0186502691,
-0.0177921951,
-0.0068550291,
0.0120433383,
0.0434710644,
-0.0051972787,
0.0056623481,
0.027617218,
-0.0306080803,
-0.0085920803,
0.0394199006,
0.1140211523,
0.0125171524,
-0.0507752746,
0.0058583613,
-0.0028906059,
-0.0502105877,
0.0728495717,
0.0078767436,
0.0113789877,
-0.0672914982,
-0.0602589026,
-0.0440165289,
-0.0359803885,
-0.0149700511,
0.0508681126,
0.0332701914,
0.0096397791,
-0.0209529791,
0.0119208358,
0.0336994007,
0.0150367096,
-0.0160981547,
-0.0001392398,
0.0282300506,
0.0078871287,
-0.063601099,
0.017933758,
-0.0327419974,
0.0549519397,
-0.043459367,
0.0221911725,
0.0231488552,
-0.0042562536,
-0.0254691485,
-0.0082407799,
-0.061942935,
-0.0476496555,
-0.0078304932,
0.0074915867,
0.0315361023,
0.0264639016,
-0.0016682041,
-0.0427984819,
0.0143633671,
0.0154905254,
-0.029287491,
0.0064164558,
0.0578699559,
0.000571509,
0.0193632152,
0.046919208,
-0.0137138627,
0.0105537223,
-0.0000403621,
0.0271579903,
-0.0016943489,
0.0222895518,
0.0179211199,
0.0433677137,
-0.0192905571,
0.0540627986,
-0.0294060595,
-0.0167080574,
0.0357835926,
-0.0061259628,
-0.0495902672,
-0.0553123467,
-0.0070668962,
0.0332633294,
0.0073726103,
0.002254836,
0.0091642849,
0.0403204598,
0.0235542841,
0.0099916272,
0.0366319455,
0.0373973735,
0.0109418901,
0.0374390483,
-0.0352173969,
-0.002718322,
-0.0106096584,
-0.0155267799,
0.0593023226,
-0.0102725048,
0.048817154,
0.0226275194,
0.0036815437,
-0.0613827035,
-0.0279785804,
-0.0684115216,
-0.0497683324,
0.0543740951,
0.0153229507,
0.0297296792,
0.0112987878,
-0.0151048098,
-0.0485757068,
-0.0048235008,
-0.0277469568,
-0.005572543,
0.0001752323,
-0.0271709301,
0.0332548283,
0.0492483936,
-0.0030255204,
0.0157252084,
0.0625010654,
0.007100217,
0.0351027735,
0.0162242688,
-0.0020838224,
-0.0450093783,
-0.0347551182,
-0.0302659739,
0.0165159162,
-0.0063918191,
0.0195351634,
-0.0626700819,
-0.0931201503,
0.0149538983,
0.0134563604,
0.0082140686,
-0.0132504301,
-0.0097317668,
0.0578420088,
-0.0027060385,
-0.0026332375,
-0.0210866872,
-0.0086597838,
-0.0130948229,
0.0044314191,
0.0071335277,
-6.291197276e-33,
-0.0068180752,
-0.0221269615,
0.0451023579,
-0.0397173502,
-0.006405748,
0.0144970333,
-0.0449800156,
0.0230365954,
-0.0279893782,
0.0208505746,
-0.0142403394,
0.0095286993,
-0.0089747533,
0.0039937519,
-0.0088546425,
-0.0362178758,
-0.0024049308,
0.0174475424,
-0.0449890681,
-0.0013696686,
0.0161757153,
-0.0171366055,
0.017812714,
-0.0585999079,
-0.0125864446,
0.0246372204,
-0.0069523337,
0.0483660214,
-0.0715970099,
0.0700369105,
0.0112923644,
0.0141229611,
0.033308249,
-0.0503000841,
0.0048067737,
-0.0064380304,
-0.0622060262,
-0.0186398458,
0.0156545322,
-0.002348436,
-0.0318271331,
-0.0388997868,
0.0323016942,
0.0216503106,
-0.0154400868,
-0.0525911413,
-0.002811922,
-0.0647694394,
0.0178586319,
0.0174919311,
-0.0098991683,
0.045618996,
-0.0433518402,
0.0030689,
0.0076080095,
0.0229638983,
-0.0202564914,
0.0425932482,
-0.0184227377,
0.0146725057,
0.0278004855,
0.0085978387,
0.0611943156,
0.0069576507,
-0.0177531429,
0.0389916971,
0.0564273596,
0.0015064587,
-0.0223063454,
0.0151256276,
0.0178914145,
0.0965336412,
0.0626343042,
0.0290007368,
0.0433833599,
0.0406353734,
-0.0865555108,
0.0053706528,
0.0330450833,
0.0303113796,
0.0498892851,
-0.0035837211,
-0.049301751,
-0.0437138863,
-0.0705612749,
0.0214775689,
-0.0633638948,
0.016912153,
0.031370353,
-0.0090546794,
0.0039869971,
-0.0527118705,
0.007602205,
-0.0675096214,
-0.0215983558,
0.0298668556,
0.0008127921,
0.0160415545,
0.0228915922,
0.0522256345,
-0.0118225245,
-0.0258020014,
-0.0411472395,
-0.0184015017,
0.0260707438,
-0.0253346022,
0.0326016843,
0.0375510044,
-0.0591650866,
-0.0323639214,
-0.0763677582,
0.0106581263,
-0.0047414936,
0.066272676,
0.0342595577,
-0.0043715681,
0.0011163373,
0.0089591863,
-0.0013620883,
0.0241687801,
-0.026367845,
0.0514602251,
-0.0089276815,
0.0302567538,
-0.0110717332,
-0.048255913,
-0.0489403307,
-0.0016206795,
0.0362496562,
-0.0212740954,
-0.0087192059,
0.0270636771,
2.928e-7,
0.0192497689,
0.0530083776,
-0.0070699095,
0.032994464,
0.0426797681,
0.0380547978,
-0.0629865676,
-0.044102896,
-0.0045384751,
-0.0274286624,
0.0017090415,
0.0488526858,
0.0691292062,
0.0579099506,
-0.0378903896,
-0.0132489642,
-0.0182633344,
-0.0295143556,
-0.0524112545,
0.0298407543,
0.0338725485,
0.0685304478,
0.0234621782,
-0.023582248,
0.0139577473,
-0.0877837315,
-0.0016035815,
-0.0500860289,
0.0152079985,
0.0128050381,
0.0145339286,
0.0415920727,
0.0390471481,
0.0208054446,
0.0150572602,
0.0177753679,
-0.0130712017,
0.0818869025,
0.0332153179,
-0.0174307339,
-0.0020901437,
-0.0390632637,
-0.0091502378,
-0.0492999889,
0.1066998243,
-0.0349737145,
-0.0828541145,
-0.031448707,
0.025566414,
-0.0298065674,
0.0110898213,
0.0190315042,
0.004408021,
0.006317717,
-0.0034783152,
-0.0475153401,
0.0063173356,
-0.069111906,
-0.029705409,
0.0096837692,
-0.0451867655,
-0.0573755093,
-0.0639792979,
0.0245433711,
0.0319187753,
-0.0400855355,
-0.016270699,
3.225654303e-34,
0.0509826802,
-0.0238740202,
0.013519071,
0.0067475806,
0.0658125058,
-0.0122130811,
-0.0461165868,
0.0099759158,
0.0241369754,
-0.0824394971,
-0.0011768457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14877v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14877v2 | Robust Knowledge Extraction from Large Language Models using Social Choice Theory | 2023-12-22T17:57:29 | 2024-02-08T17:29:54 | Nico Potyka, Yuqicheng Zhu, Yunjie He, Evgeny Kharlamov, Steffen Staab | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large-language models (LLMs) can support a wide range of applications like
conversational agents, creative writing or general query answering. However,
they are ill-suited for query answering in high-stake domains like medicine
because they are typically not robust - even the same query can result in
different answers when prompted multiple times. In order to improve the
robustness of LLM queries, we propose using ranking queries repeatedly and to
aggregate the queries using methods from social choice theory. We study ranking
queries in diagnostic settings like medical and fault diagnosis and discuss how
the Partial Borda Choice function from the literature can be applied to merge
multiple query results. We discuss some additional interesting properties in
our setting and evaluate the robustness of our approach empirically. | [
0.0410067104,
0.0422671475,
-0.0110647157,
0.0145288026,
-0.0198483206,
0.012847729,
-0.0280820802,
0.0445992947,
0.0715172365,
-0.0240954384,
-0.0031018804,
-0.0459635444,
-0.0083432095,
0.0006165545,
0.0104875118,
-0.0392853022,
0.0083944164,
-0.0296901092,
0.0291527957,
-0.0352518149,
-0.0149028394,
0.0048625483,
-0.0065117041,
0.0106328474,
0.0567064211,
0.0012607051,
0.0248275176,
-0.0325370841,
0.0459141582,
-0.0414057933,
-0.0249687564,
0.048238121,
-0.0232093595,
-0.0114248218,
0.0000018491,
-0.0746467263,
-0.0402948521,
0.00909869,
-0.0344802141,
-0.0468134359,
0.013573816,
0.0369876213,
0.0202372279,
0.0310075544,
-0.0453850739,
-0.0070087668,
0.0214650016,
0.0246390048,
0.0301729999,
0.0396007635,
0.0057965,
-0.0220405273,
-0.0120968856,
-0.038644474,
-0.0098431502,
-0.082679987,
0.0737504289,
-0.0105636315,
0.1109014079,
0.026800517,
0.0187402852,
0.0272838492,
-0.0339831337,
-0.022366656,
-0.0196425803,
0.0491915531,
-0.0073965266,
0.0100165689,
0.005932312,
0.0693524107,
0.0564173535,
0.01893178,
0.0394397117,
0.0115628699,
0.0197977275,
0.0769799948,
-0.0433285721,
-0.0051924745,
-0.0343438052,
-0.0106129926,
0.0117517514,
0.030066818,
0.0169836115,
-0.005122907,
-0.0264275633,
0.0547132157,
0.0096715894,
-0.0136550087,
0.0297535881,
-0.023494266,
-0.0133115649,
-0.0527131222,
0.0244867932,
0.050638441,
-0.0873627812,
0.003400842,
0.0011290251,
0.0093300911,
0.0604864173,
-0.0706386492,
-0.0023583416,
-0.015114272,
0.0306371972,
0.0781710446,
0.0631391779,
-0.0105178459,
-0.0259077754,
0.0188848134,
-0.0668414161,
-0.005294201,
-0.0681080446,
-0.0234246366,
-0.0060747322,
0.0538159572,
-0.0357327834,
0.001887723,
-0.051392056,
0.0207678769,
-0.0258355737,
0.0292570833,
-0.0024416221,
0.053239204,
-0.0321215093,
0.0006998876,
-0.0513148606,
0.0177491624,
0.0002460913,
0.0051619196,
-0.0081830528,
0.0107127354,
0.0288463552,
-0.0233087838,
0.0304637905,
-0.0273466296,
0.0008601765,
0.0584313311,
0.0097819446,
-0.0107451417,
0.0159581173,
-0.0318747908,
-0.0424104929,
-0.0490702279,
-0.0304664336,
-0.0634921789,
0.0441774093,
0.0358519889,
-0.0071520661,
-0.0361117385,
0.0051747356,
0.0134522831,
-0.0611623749,
0.0366880633,
0.0069199405,
0.0143027781,
0.022562163,
0.0218417235,
-0.0008481155,
0.029791085,
-0.011671545,
-0.0016367864,
0.0470188223,
-0.0155335823,
0.0276739262,
0.0135630975,
-0.0028355913,
0.0064978665,
0.0162603427,
0.0497484691,
0.0349479802,
0.0282178875,
-0.0577303655,
0.0562335141,
-0.0122967567,
-0.0320006981,
0.0548708476,
0.0443301164,
0.0149832927,
-0.046778053,
-0.0437357761,
-0.009550442,
0.0248856582,
0.0141238868,
0.010831832,
0.0172120072,
-0.0531054325,
-0.0060923058,
0.0065655047,
0.0223944876,
-0.0114668729,
-0.0274891257,
-0.0352238491,
0.0172621813,
-0.0162692238,
0.0661791191,
0.0704980418,
-0.0413162112,
-0.0061798389,
0.0048371474,
0.0426896848,
-0.0203771554,
-0.0091719823,
-0.0500547588,
0.0166498702,
0.064669989,
0.056890171,
-0.0794993713,
-0.0187160354,
0.0366929099,
-0.0326218605,
-0.0364283845,
0.0258993898,
-0.0575364903,
-0.0061763865,
0.0039487979,
-0.0162368957,
0.0833459795,
0.0119853709,
-0.0172910038,
-0.0021388642,
0.0118824346,
-0.0418320149,
-0.0190001279,
-0.0221149735,
-0.0104794754,
-0.0221935101,
0.0060566836,
0.0010111671,
0.003301553,
0.04616208,
0.0269923992,
-0.0297009032,
0.0480425507,
0.0381909162,
-0.0457153469,
-0.042233292,
0.0126280459,
-0.0032776236,
-0.0187545214,
0.0191137567,
-0.0137554649,
-0.0295282695,
0.008442902,
-0.0217219759,
-0.0159913301,
-0.0402098112,
-0.0209627058,
0.0291269124,
-0.0043765311,
0.0203131251,
0.0288527291,
-0.0609972998,
-0.0735660642,
0.082343623,
0.0113935294,
-0.0154513735,
0.0011740852,
-0.0381634533,
-0.022013614,
-0.0830772743,
-0.0321702771,
0.0823394209,
0.0386749096,
0.0133612705,
0.0427651852,
-0.0360880122,
-0.0347829051,
-0.0220928118,
-0.1175692901,
0.0043315892,
0.0001288168,
-0.0248022899,
0.0024389506,
0.0435230844,
0.0107704382,
-0.0108912503,
-0.067112729,
-0.0095132748,
0.02881453,
0.0257352665,
0.0282286201,
0.063562423,
-0.0192309059,
-0.0380208716,
-0.0234409589,
-0.0391874202,
0.0330499709,
0.0046967883,
0.0061456491,
-0.0322450921,
0.0361676104,
-0.0646311939,
0.0151028745,
-0.0298508108,
-0.0112113571,
-0.0110235568,
-0.0576590449,
-0.0134107051,
0.0689222217,
0.0254355073,
0.022725407,
0.0476912223,
0.0113631543,
-0.0132601103,
0.0000899435,
-0.0739545822,
-0.0129501866,
-0.0083604138,
-0.0275023095,
0.0108740898,
0.0141060315,
0.0306142103,
-0.0209286287,
-0.0259622522,
0.0028695194,
-0.0090013491,
-0.0116658341,
-0.0705466494,
-0.0019231995,
0.0109106526,
0.0552526601,
0.0146477008,
-0.00355518,
0.0845651403,
0.0122067025,
0.0267142039,
-0.0523840338,
-0.0218544025,
-0.039484892,
0.0477227569,
0.0001407547,
0.0565409437,
-0.0100426413,
-0.0040482283,
-0.0124015426,
-0.0512996092,
0.0567270704,
-0.0685670823,
0.044601813,
-0.0440733097,
0.0379807651,
0.0166747272,
-0.0868357047,
-0.0246941987,
-0.0469618142,
-0.0391378105,
-0.0096142609,
0.0251327716,
-0.0162495207,
-0.0029135572,
-0.0082824789,
0.0217815321,
0.01684797,
0.0110558067,
-0.0010881721,
0.0038217641,
0.032457076,
0.0407654345,
0.0080471765,
0.0136021562,
-0.0251995083,
0.0205703042,
0.0930366814,
0.0408769362,
-0.0044393674,
0.0038318469,
0.0047920533,
0.0467329025,
-0.0358277373,
-0.0007992675,
0.022534769,
-0.0142168328,
0.0021771353,
0.017470587,
0.0902111158,
0.0302796997,
-0.0117784366,
0.0086824074,
0.0040356289,
0.0075911195,
-0.0080975229,
0.0427704342,
-0.0247645415,
-0.0015896908,
-0.009643415,
0.029494429,
-0.011805553,
-0.04316663,
0.0229900759,
-0.1075781956,
0.0331625901,
-0.006876952,
0.0134840691,
-0.0187561065,
-0.0310417898,
0.0402129553,
-0.0277976468,
-0.0627339929,
0.0254057217,
-0.0202923603,
-0.0096412944,
0.017749127,
0.0000351993,
-0.0540521629,
0.0534027815,
-0.0202003065,
0.037534114,
0.0433933549,
0.0400884822,
-0.0312488992,
-0.017579468,
-0.0302957594,
0.0342213064,
-0.0283029024,
-0.0251345672,
0.0527559146,
0.0089202709,
-0.0036119088,
-0.0591225922,
0.0215863753,
-0.0130853336,
-0.0006998832,
-0.0001028296,
0.0626082122,
-0.0109556606,
-0.0342853293,
-0.0240920112,
-0.0025723143,
0.0062113549,
0.0801152363,
-0.0416337289,
-0.003658118,
-0.0101925777,
0.0089476705,
0.0026251932,
0.0282172598,
-0.0404410735,
0.0270470344,
-0.0370134413,
-0.0364221893,
-0.0757580325,
0.0097031053,
0.0496914126,
0.0561368801,
0.0158105697,
0.0490830429,
0.0860005543,
0.0237055123,
-0.0014682171,
-0.004832597,
0.0158374663,
0.0032506597,
-0.0461748615,
-0.025202157,
0.0788192526,
-0.0138197141,
-0.0485496931,
-0.0533683039,
0.0087792892,
-0.0497021526,
0.0101243863,
0.0208930857,
0.0330364108,
-0.0019356376,
-0.0456320606,
-0.057955049,
0.0119621167,
0.0533671379,
-0.0049945661,
0.0227222051,
-0.0021488671,
-0.0121700652,
-0.0096221967,
0.0401921421,
-0.0450753607,
-0.0044852505,
-0.0038087543,
0.0244542342,
-0.050172586,
-0.0469465479,
0.0322748534,
0.0588228181,
-0.0040817875,
0.0017610682,
-0.0156574007,
-0.0289035756,
0.0185759868,
-0.0551538654,
-0.0343709849,
-0.030955581,
0.0157699883,
0.0136554921,
-0.0189742818,
0.0126275923,
-0.0617281534,
-0.0048771081,
0.0223421846,
-0.0433881544,
-0.0013146679,
0.0459420122,
-0.0297171939,
0.0928509608,
-0.0104399109,
0.0076893494,
0.0183271952,
0.0230691228,
0.0693695024,
-0.0055264733,
0.033550065,
0.0383368805,
-0.0312133487,
-0.0107815238,
0.0417880379,
-0.0833011791,
-0.0990144089,
0.0079165474,
0.0312521569,
0.015808586,
-0.0153871235,
0.0210348107,
0.0015737925,
-0.0182892289,
-0.0301125348,
-0.0169026535,
0.0086280406,
0.0342956558,
0.0238907542,
0.0486013368,
0.0023638448,
0.028587576,
0.0985889509,
0.0169421677,
0.0117373066,
-0.0117628528,
-0.0595588461,
-0.0263749622,
-0.0441800021,
0.0112582687,
0.0273090247,
-0.0427433066,
-0.0171966553,
-0.0998516455,
-0.0476758927,
0.014253105,
-0.0060651079,
-0.033885818,
-0.0203241054,
0.0519957021,
0.0898640156,
0.0358331576,
0.0016405957,
-0.0600996241,
0.0353193767,
-0.0683972389,
-0.0049305609,
0.0297840759,
-6.21955163e-33,
-0.0160617623,
-0.047883518,
0.0022078713,
-0.0459004752,
0.0120767057,
-0.0214198809,
-0.0146758994,
0.0012602087,
-0.0032678728,
0.031000942,
-0.0321557522,
-0.0121694906,
0.0086260755,
0.014289475,
0.0096292952,
-0.0536876917,
0.0015168228,
0.0243430417,
-0.0195322279,
0.017330816,
0.0570578799,
0.0063997842,
-0.0132843126,
-0.0824902803,
0.0150889521,
0.0085198032,
0.0333032459,
0.0520395488,
-0.0182588864,
0.0663199574,
0.0039820918,
0.02919342,
0.021627577,
-0.024555251,
0.014609647,
0.0064501488,
-0.0687411427,
-0.0165144224,
0.0190314185,
-0.0483358242,
0.0068542999,
0.0045920764,
0.0158413034,
-0.001136248,
-0.0043156752,
-0.0123586617,
0.0235405434,
-0.0284475945,
-0.0351084173,
-0.0065733651,
-0.0062010544,
0.0077719553,
0.0088304235,
0.0253930762,
-0.0115981139,
0.0003208716,
-0.022776084,
0.0559831858,
0.0179620292,
0.0358492695,
0.0232458357,
0.0284066442,
-0.0126125347,
0.0185764078,
-0.0138482386,
0.0567338504,
-0.0294721778,
-0.0304415803,
-0.0137839327,
-0.0135676991,
-0.0899420679,
0.0736516267,
0.026045559,
0.0801923797,
-0.0326751098,
-0.0028312549,
-0.0938554108,
0.0418884493,
0.0004629581,
-0.0040415758,
0.0213175118,
-0.0030225301,
-0.0871173516,
-0.0395675264,
-0.0145077603,
0.0060540112,
-0.0213323291,
0.0034285313,
0.0256776512,
-0.0059036496,
-0.0387976021,
0.0214182846,
0.0329178907,
-0.0344416983,
-0.0553746596,
-0.0026421985,
0.0190386474,
0.0052502863,
-0.0242093913,
-0.0007297758,
-0.0249330681,
0.0079011032,
-0.0142664993,
-0.0003409356,
-0.0016239805,
0.0294723772,
-0.033124961,
-0.024422545,
-0.0275891032,
0.0113861682,
0.0099159759,
-0.0353827588,
-0.0138500035,
-0.0057138158,
0.0386343747,
0.030514298,
0.0260199085,
0.0398934707,
0.0118762692,
0.031558834,
-0.0653293952,
-0.0311193075,
-0.0107595995,
-0.0392128788,
-0.0072270646,
-0.0163367968,
-0.010251632,
0.030908931,
0.0445183367,
-0.0030344289,
-0.0223811939,
-0.0320256613,
2.762e-7,
0.051565364,
0.0206143875,
-0.0228057671,
0.0351596624,
0.0173516572,
0.0644793436,
0.0002492771,
0.0393881798,
0.0590960756,
-0.0176134221,
0.0155955805,
0.0192876104,
-0.0049780775,
0.0466967262,
-0.0695867911,
-0.0592429787,
-0.0459027328,
-0.0484663732,
-0.0112681361,
-0.0419327281,
0.0643778071,
0.0467834137,
0.0113573298,
0.0038329014,
-0.000934558,
-0.0447469763,
0.0455314368,
-0.0285584256,
-0.0235108994,
0.0264506023,
0.0100080706,
-0.0186662376,
0.0169123411,
0.0353712812,
-0.0049804859,
-0.0037590091,
0.0283255279,
0.0601054654,
-0.0229608659,
-0.0124744773,
-0.0134958234,
-0.0355618745,
0.0398700461,
-0.0392526388,
0.0849769711,
-0.0385575257,
-0.0430263579,
0.0004232986,
-0.0075663389,
-0.0685753748,
0.0158950891,
0.0084807882,
-0.0366551578,
-0.0054175779,
-0.0046717171,
0.0259861089,
0.0114134755,
-0.058526203,
0.0252102651,
0.022087492,
-0.0294815712,
-0.1068022773,
0.0462989993,
0.0117950672,
-0.0044077206,
-0.0860779658,
0.0002617538,
2.793652553e-34,
0.0396551639,
0.0639191195,
-0.0130980723,
0.0143222595,
0.0389853567,
-0.0179955158,
-0.0172841828,
-0.0065737786,
0.0575604178,
-0.1194893569,
-0.0175000113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14870v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14870v1 | Numerical Reasoning for Financial Reports | 2023-12-22T17:46:36 | 2023-12-22T17:46:36 | Abhinav Arun, Ashish Dhiman, Mehul Soni, Yibei Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Financial reports offer critical insights into a company's operations, yet
their extensive length typically spanning 30 40 pages poses challenges for
swift decision making in dynamic markets. To address this, we leveraged
finetuned Large Language Models (LLMs) to distill key indicators and
operational metrics from these reports basis questions from the user. We
devised a method to locate critical data, and leverage the FinQA dataset to
fine-tune both Llama-2 7B and T5 models for customized question answering. We
achieved results comparable to baseline on the final numerical answer, a
competitive accuracy in numerical reasoning and calculation. | [
0.0162481982,
0.0585383251,
0.0010979179,
0.0446979553,
0.0053559393,
0.0124923727,
-0.0143784713,
-0.0074004605,
-0.0194566119,
-0.0361419767,
-0.0416653529,
-0.0189179704,
-0.0073568691,
0.0177161265,
0.0241618101,
-0.0266105365,
0.0193736814,
-0.0396180861,
0.0090736244,
-0.0247368217,
0.0441051833,
0.0243024752,
0.0226235054,
-0.0160940085,
0.0278324168,
-0.0529227667,
0.0140980221,
-0.0212217495,
-0.0017248421,
0.0033026058,
0.0143680489,
0.0390481502,
0.0050514638,
0.0229199976,
0.0000021384,
-0.0405847766,
-0.0232794043,
0.0170250814,
-0.0422923341,
0.0824427158,
0.0074157608,
-0.0199520458,
0.0523498096,
0.025893949,
-0.0584769696,
0.0237193368,
0.029533131,
0.0280686114,
0.1040009335,
0.0214439481,
0.0082675507,
-0.0578577891,
-0.0239951406,
-0.0087963017,
0.0037887145,
-0.1287243813,
-0.0001340334,
0.0705405846,
0.0381941013,
-0.0345037133,
-0.0157473274,
0.0454427786,
0.0372624584,
-0.0031787232,
-0.0232856758,
0.0161730181,
-0.0386583097,
0.0175221581,
-0.0096625844,
0.0853531435,
0.022272611,
0.0178006012,
-0.009329644,
-0.0115441745,
-0.001134405,
-0.0249541607,
-0.0672392547,
-0.0035349941,
-0.0368911959,
-0.0178437661,
0.0185740739,
-0.0117534893,
0.0115418108,
0.0503197052,
-0.046530433,
0.0511377044,
-0.0116515467,
-0.032504309,
0.0249387026,
0.0075309263,
-0.0479980856,
-0.0254839063,
0.0392129011,
0.0707775429,
-0.0172170438,
0.0162822343,
-0.0195716377,
-0.01448642,
0.0068400712,
-0.0833456516,
0.031509269,
0.0349362344,
-0.0083705951,
0.0723478198,
-0.0152883576,
0.0552915856,
-0.0235230736,
-0.0264218803,
-0.0414047353,
-0.0069775973,
-0.0031245619,
-0.0369184911,
-0.042809315,
0.0580562428,
-0.0660608187,
-0.0312556438,
-0.0221265536,
-0.001435697,
0.0127385966,
0.003905454,
0.0346723497,
0.0144019062,
-0.0120983915,
-0.0293602124,
-0.0394813381,
0.0029761728,
-0.0868823752,
0.0120890262,
-0.0180040225,
-0.0420060754,
0.0039867498,
0.0018682089,
-0.0045466512,
-0.0192942098,
0.0239359755,
0.0543141924,
-0.0040217685,
0.0164460856,
-0.0398992561,
-0.0334968045,
0.0001305224,
-0.0529462993,
-0.0389769077,
-0.0526583642,
0.0422550328,
0.0127161015,
-0.0445179977,
-0.0086447941,
0.0254607983,
0.0134163909,
0.0036902195,
0.0749131963,
0.0000358617,
-0.003318599,
0.0344958343,
-0.0172337424,
0.0470973216,
0.0841027349,
0.0342065021,
0.0208641719,
0.0411407873,
-0.0021640467,
0.0043351906,
0.0588566326,
0.0009058415,
-0.0380007178,
0.0070539382,
0.0739925727,
-0.0394424051,
0.0182705596,
0.0217193905,
0.0396743119,
-0.0150003182,
0.0005837367,
0.0483700484,
0.0351880901,
0.0483178049,
0.0436580144,
0.02282135,
0.0148743885,
0.0577505752,
-0.0288661085,
-0.0109586958,
0.0357538387,
-0.0112733971,
0.040295016,
0.0332040042,
0.0146706812,
-0.0316243432,
-0.0618557259,
-0.004353432,
0.0392186977,
-0.0593913086,
0.0451045968,
0.0232751127,
-0.0147237806,
-0.0455372632,
0.0584839918,
0.0013656563,
-0.0061576366,
0.0092486879,
-0.0260381587,
0.0774584487,
0.0771304965,
0.0426737517,
-0.0485387184,
-0.0150073739,
0.0046068812,
0.0078902794,
0.0124766184,
0.0547391325,
-0.0140107796,
-0.0258617103,
-0.0532318503,
0.0223642625,
0.0062907827,
0.0113670025,
-0.0078927819,
0.0132290591,
0.0100464066,
0.0138043435,
-0.0503094867,
-0.0294010658,
0.0099037588,
-0.0022141088,
-0.0480322205,
-0.0059375032,
-0.0074408287,
-0.0149383349,
0.0174413323,
0.0108879479,
0.0352904387,
-0.0119208265,
-0.0204655416,
0.0156001663,
-0.0347386748,
-0.0084219128,
0.0108565558,
0.0452948362,
-0.013249645,
-0.01753648,
0.0127351601,
-0.0524213873,
-0.0040203976,
-0.0141532049,
-0.0618635938,
-0.0069509433,
-0.0622045435,
-0.0407256186,
0.0305939503,
0.0318857767,
-0.0156188188,
0.0721111223,
-0.0040529021,
0.041080527,
-0.0169889648,
-0.0274944548,
-0.0066148983,
-0.0468520001,
0.0189290885,
0.0127832219,
-0.0138255153,
0.0294474065,
0.0099064158,
0.0251744613,
-0.034522675,
-0.0225953571,
-0.0772791132,
-0.0083828913,
-0.0182231497,
0.0426473506,
0.0385802574,
0.0184596349,
-0.0273118634,
-0.006526167,
-0.0281812269,
-0.0721834078,
0.0010047564,
0.0078575192,
0.0571916774,
0.0350582264,
-0.0072405897,
-0.0702367201,
-0.02599255,
-0.0148943439,
0.0345138498,
0.039955277,
-0.0066405381,
-0.0583107509,
0.0083251875,
-0.0465100333,
0.0070934715,
0.0073438059,
-0.0283667371,
-0.0010097919,
-0.0221329667,
0.0191169791,
0.082985878,
-0.0125917429,
0.0461326353,
-0.01732824,
-0.0284510888,
-0.0528845377,
0.0165456031,
0.0028246669,
-0.0020506468,
-0.0142500307,
-0.0346611366,
0.000967328,
0.0289835446,
-0.0264093,
-0.015843831,
-0.0499778017,
0.0581101738,
-0.0285957735,
0.0005969091,
-0.0381371602,
0.034715008,
-0.0156536326,
0.0853733197,
-0.0053137019,
-0.0159015693,
0.051148098,
-0.0243208576,
-0.0117043704,
-0.040255066,
0.019432161,
-0.0605438948,
0.0455577932,
-0.0478834733,
-0.0000910822,
-0.0376841016,
-0.0457001477,
-0.0262005217,
-0.0284273978,
0.0306511763,
-0.048646152,
0.0781703517,
-0.0422711074,
0.0129748369,
-0.0004435447,
-0.0275110658,
0.0012241303,
-0.0686015561,
-0.040098507,
0.0040387721,
0.0031376716,
-0.030542355,
-0.0633473769,
0.0042410488,
0.0321190543,
-0.000997092,
-0.0597540438,
-0.0172325633,
-0.0115946978,
0.0312754512,
0.0837492049,
0.0342612974,
0.0578643903,
-0.0567932799,
0.0383384377,
0.0198300425,
0.0585817173,
0.0319266804,
0.0112291798,
-0.0233019218,
0.0132373832,
-0.0334414281,
0.0145198666,
0.0248978566,
0.0212529376,
-0.0615244433,
-0.0218781605,
0.1058622971,
0.0405042283,
0.0207821261,
-0.0211293753,
-0.0342616178,
0.001715463,
0.0185339153,
0.1004764885,
-0.0588982254,
-0.0264627188,
0.0050010299,
0.0500220433,
0.0248392932,
-0.0492545888,
-0.002770263,
-0.1179368719,
0.0380081981,
-0.0168471672,
-0.0206989683,
-0.0605934113,
-0.0492825098,
-0.0080290232,
-0.0188356992,
0.0165788289,
0.0242651626,
-0.0252675619,
0.0146476449,
0.0238506645,
-0.0734065324,
0.000373312,
0.0438997224,
0.0057729217,
-0.0549526289,
0.0515238084,
0.0326579139,
-0.0374231003,
0.0008007727,
-0.0175758488,
-0.0121013131,
-0.0224049333,
-0.0268123951,
0.0307205357,
0.0023966469,
-0.0322473571,
-0.018528359,
0.0577235147,
-0.0245179683,
0.0625138879,
0.0188591518,
0.0500153415,
-0.0018563737,
-0.0001168564,
0.0188228749,
0.0561378375,
-0.0319202095,
0.0698090047,
0.0367420688,
-0.0391622745,
-0.037804991,
-0.0472555272,
-0.0271115471,
-0.0652155727,
-0.0230621155,
0.0146312788,
0.0170994662,
0.004043615,
-0.0808491409,
-0.0634531006,
0.0774097517,
0.0439704582,
0.0009514734,
-0.0070554577,
0.0112812752,
0.0028435341,
-0.0217656437,
0.0248831939,
-0.0507782027,
0.0486152507,
-0.0457076766,
0.049826961,
0.0330901742,
-0.0048352261,
-0.057654988,
0.0599779375,
-0.0889943317,
-0.0241510682,
-0.0090450235,
0.0274348147,
0.0275147576,
-0.0384436622,
-0.0475165918,
-0.0347442068,
0.0144084385,
0.0443057008,
-0.0907749534,
-0.0079978788,
0.0161052961,
0.0075544585,
0.0045569306,
0.0391669795,
-0.0510713905,
-0.0296150036,
-0.004829329,
0.0746710226,
-0.0270736571,
-0.0328831188,
0.021431474,
0.0309266094,
-0.0356808379,
0.032048367,
-0.0284385849,
-0.0187758263,
0.0141449049,
0.0087905228,
-0.0355296321,
-0.0303229,
0.0023245509,
0.0274707209,
-0.0124598583,
-0.0156124141,
0.0278285593,
-0.0085467799,
0.0191129446,
-0.0489049032,
0.0360489339,
0.0232477523,
0.0159396771,
0.0181073546,
-0.0372740924,
-0.0226479862,
-0.0403416753,
0.0249769557,
0.0489640571,
0.0117757432,
0.0337309763,
0.0145041132,
0.0295870025,
-0.0496818461,
0.015944995,
-0.0116111385,
-0.096970804,
-0.0140951462,
0.019734038,
0.0161796249,
-0.0034798137,
-0.0323988274,
-0.0202058312,
-0.0060692513,
0.0086416136,
0.0072711557,
0.0335685872,
-0.0006468164,
0.0656752363,
0.0406497605,
-0.0081327427,
-0.0324387364,
0.0824014992,
-0.0112325102,
0.0331077427,
-0.0113268588,
0.0020312637,
-0.0360302478,
-0.0692114383,
0.0105502792,
-0.0021394587,
0.0136401039,
-0.006563344,
-0.0508572012,
-0.0603205971,
0.0293115638,
0.0234081186,
-0.0629321784,
-0.01088202,
0.0424839258,
0.0948139504,
0.0306930915,
0.0118414126,
-0.0260965675,
0.0310538802,
-0.0466105342,
-0.0391569622,
-0.032270655,
-6.584582299e-33,
-0.0277329721,
-0.0136683192,
0.0308251157,
0.0022428222,
0.0025200176,
-0.0033269513,
-0.0016306622,
-0.0182169545,
-0.0339344777,
0.0130868778,
-0.0442181192,
0.0432415865,
0.0224056039,
-0.0024696786,
-0.0313491039,
-0.0436850563,
0.0077063399,
-0.0277992953,
-0.0157608334,
-0.0265078843,
-0.0042130607,
0.0409953855,
0.0421897508,
-0.0277814846,
0.0350143798,
-0.0048848335,
-0.026096411,
0.0477986224,
0.0000318326,
0.0680962205,
-0.0138377007,
0.0138131017,
0.010634182,
-0.0646283627,
-0.0027547844,
0.0245061666,
-0.0665328354,
-0.0279610492,
0.0674644858,
0.0212340634,
0.0183123723,
-0.0140391551,
0.0439294018,
0.0052009039,
0.0351021625,
-0.0249655172,
0.0214100052,
-0.0273801032,
0.0134682059,
-0.0557085611,
-0.0371757485,
0.0165990125,
-0.0341496542,
0.0143037271,
0.0155181792,
0.0680854172,
-0.0363320224,
-0.0001487954,
0.0054185013,
-0.0232835505,
0.0248347465,
0.0429418758,
0.0604660176,
0.0245032851,
0.0190906618,
0.0038187969,
-0.0210326388,
-0.0215575006,
-0.0281295888,
0.0020116873,
0.0123801064,
0.0233285837,
0.0418977141,
0.0206758119,
0.0130600687,
0.0296803638,
-0.0751469061,
0.025784675,
-0.005337731,
0.0436582118,
0.0285168421,
-0.0233141705,
-0.029268289,
-0.0167186856,
-0.0436444618,
0.0592543893,
-0.0474354401,
0.0084720096,
0.0228975508,
-0.0299162343,
-0.0343315825,
0.0025505442,
0.0162906665,
-0.0289939418,
-0.0261124279,
0.011093772,
0.0318346694,
0.0419700369,
0.0068302173,
0.0332005993,
-0.0279176179,
0.0376476459,
-0.0547736958,
-0.0111225499,
-0.0065985699,
-0.0081458744,
-0.005329486,
-0.0040486641,
-0.0452742875,
0.0018189418,
-0.0248945821,
0.0290399678,
-0.0070226421,
0.0248384085,
0.0189833287,
0.0212171208,
-0.0215565581,
0.0183821376,
-0.0124664688,
0.0041913688,
-0.0048917644,
-0.0193301942,
0.0133715495,
0.0407920294,
-0.0288554579,
-0.0294107161,
-0.031485945,
0.0288861822,
-0.0020791914,
-0.0366316065,
-0.0204124413,
0.0707944855,
2.825e-7,
0.0718106925,
0.0375868902,
0.0081282938,
0.0543267094,
0.0105445487,
0.0060751094,
0.0196808372,
-0.0207989886,
0.016589772,
-0.019591717,
0.0361642018,
0.0481144153,
0.0540135913,
0.0413126647,
-0.0725015327,
-0.0451554991,
-0.0727399513,
-0.0085120387,
-0.0745365098,
-0.0307602677,
-0.0025257696,
0.0905831531,
-0.0000712758,
-0.0056835525,
-0.0021823302,
-0.0865061581,
0.0431716219,
-0.0174455754,
-0.0256785173,
0.0416770726,
0.0370632559,
-0.0043363119,
-0.015539811,
-0.0201566964,
0.0068996078,
0.0137192914,
0.0589197651,
0.058909554,
0.0299711563,
-0.0027120179,
-0.0322785564,
-0.0556116365,
0.0056346953,
-0.0480732732,
0.0689379051,
-0.0331771486,
-0.0284703597,
0.0084880833,
-0.014976236,
-0.0179473944,
-0.0072733145,
-0.0395759605,
0.0309696943,
0.0369201154,
0.0078548109,
-0.0309345145,
0.010887472,
-0.0419404954,
-0.0106554143,
0.0366986729,
-0.0372507088,
-0.0081893122,
-0.0271210577,
-0.0161148347,
0.0010146762,
-0.0216696654,
0.0204775948,
2.295926434e-34,
0.0479656495,
-0.0104979938,
0.0064179166,
0.0511119254,
0.0907734111,
0.0015921099,
-0.0304053072,
0.0307221338,
0.0250853803,
-0.1060298979,
-0.007023456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14867v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14867v2 | VIEScore: Towards Explainable Metrics for Conditional Image Synthesis Evaluation | 2023-12-22T17:45:19 | 2024-06-03T16:59:20 | Max Ku, Dongfu Jiang, Cong Wei, Xiang Yue, Wenhu Chen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM | In the rapidly advancing field of conditional image generation research,
challenges such as limited explainability lie in effectively evaluating the
performance and capabilities of various models. This paper introduces VIEScore,
a Visual Instruction-guided Explainable metric for evaluating any conditional
image generation tasks. VIEScore leverages general knowledge from Multimodal
Large Language Models (MLLMs) as the backbone and does not require training or
fine-tuning. We evaluate VIEScore on seven prominent tasks in conditional image
tasks and found: (1) VIEScore (GPT4-o) achieves a high Spearman correlation of
0.4 with human evaluations, while the human-to-human correlation is 0.45. (2)
VIEScore (with open-source MLLM) is significantly weaker than GPT-4o and GPT-4v
in evaluating synthetic images. (3) VIEScore achieves a correlation on par with
human ratings in the generation tasks but struggles in editing tasks. With
these results, we believe VIEScore shows its great potential to replace human
judges in evaluating image synthesis tasks. | [
0.0038540915,
0.0768131986,
0.008674413,
0.0170461014,
-0.022508746,
0.0286528934,
0.0612276904,
0.0035365743,
-0.0254348312,
-0.0199427605,
-0.0335124098,
-0.0394767858,
-0.0198526643,
0.046963796,
0.0511838794,
-0.1015080363,
-0.0346141979,
-0.0286839139,
-0.018480083,
0.0004216704,
-0.0040051937,
0.0026746623,
0.0034962457,
0.0532726683,
-0.0010640008,
-0.0254467241,
-0.006175647,
0.0358117893,
0.0223773457,
-0.0020748961,
-0.0553396381,
0.0559462048,
0.0319992192,
-0.028052669,
0.0000021843,
-0.0401168466,
0.0118199177,
0.0005272796,
0.018592665,
0.0159864817,
0.0059313932,
-0.0347435921,
-0.0160592813,
-0.0140767442,
-0.0376831703,
0.0030418967,
0.078566812,
0.0339584984,
0.0897008851,
0.0320441313,
-0.0085544446,
-0.040854726,
-0.0427440628,
-0.0142654758,
0.0423887074,
0.0047279261,
-0.0315442458,
0.0267749354,
-0.0222041216,
-0.004583816,
-0.026024906,
0.0256128367,
0.0607081465,
-0.0473589376,
0.0289762486,
0.0286431164,
0.008705751,
-0.0486579873,
0.0243558157,
0.0265111625,
-0.0497056842,
0.0043182909,
-0.0034535604,
-0.0196518805,
0.0199666172,
0.0293701533,
-0.0621542707,
0.0081860898,
-0.0033230558,
0.002807044,
-0.0511801168,
0.0189381707,
0.0176457278,
-0.0169737935,
-0.0087116072,
-0.0092492225,
0.037765462,
0.0212777611,
-0.0583943017,
0.0194379147,
-0.0642175376,
-0.0517287627,
0.0155131938,
0.0171606801,
-0.0240291525,
-0.0360495336,
-0.0414788947,
0.0016143202,
-0.0170027856,
-0.0182451271,
0.0731333792,
0.0167091358,
-0.0246949717,
0.0278630666,
-0.0433505401,
0.0902226865,
-0.0074375914,
-0.0009012682,
-0.0324036889,
-0.0045923735,
-0.0435112901,
-0.0122937215,
0.0129721453,
-0.047767166,
-0.0422816724,
-0.0232337825,
-0.0485060662,
0.0058176895,
-0.0409339704,
0.0219442192,
0.0201102253,
0.046581693,
-0.0412310362,
-0.0107781105,
-0.0584360026,
-0.0063222009,
-0.0162136033,
0.021534685,
0.0117240828,
-0.0259929001,
-0.0025241436,
0.0657240897,
-0.0042177285,
-0.0068739238,
0.0113607869,
0.1004161611,
-0.0229526069,
0.0237908456,
-0.0183058549,
-0.0402972363,
0.017664643,
-0.0711446479,
0.0335411131,
-0.0445452221,
-0.0220135041,
-0.0180706289,
-0.0053063747,
-0.000687563,
-0.0043913387,
-0.0008721061,
0.0352657214,
0.0672773346,
-0.0061412188,
0.0081987726,
-0.0000313263,
0.0040933499,
-0.0150511684,
0.0232674237,
0.0373555459,
0.0590671599,
0.0011820999,
-0.0666574538,
0.0453861952,
0.001833163,
-0.0118305748,
-0.0209472813,
-0.043549858,
-0.0162295066,
-0.0362767205,
0.0326518007,
0.0741593391,
0.0368082486,
-0.0254219882,
-0.0136561515,
0.0732061788,
-0.0002840414,
0.0686783567,
0.0116244033,
0.1136168838,
-0.0204561874,
-0.0226205029,
0.0534563847,
-0.0396218896,
0.1121654734,
0.0013143328,
0.0394681878,
0.0016893921,
0.0605820157,
-0.0313079506,
-0.0623077825,
0.0151728867,
-0.0189854484,
-0.0259442311,
-0.001184013,
0.0406138711,
0.0234283749,
-0.0596933216,
-0.0114496462,
-0.0037883462,
-0.0592257679,
0.016866155,
-0.0623141639,
0.0384377539,
0.0938279927,
0.0263728518,
0.0383679308,
-0.003373049,
0.0004499541,
0.0045335782,
0.05345181,
-0.0137097929,
0.0169179197,
0.0292308964,
-0.060223382,
-0.0395952165,
-0.0555447973,
0.0105788643,
0.010380784,
0.0050009652,
-0.0291730538,
-0.0079479823,
-0.0188644212,
-0.0231031869,
0.024244573,
0.0083702495,
-0.020009255,
-0.0023020664,
0.0158875864,
0.0207199194,
-0.0089760795,
-0.0065319301,
0.0262992568,
0.0150128715,
-0.0299882088,
0.0186725892,
0.02257373,
-0.021953335,
-0.0266128294,
-0.0214484297,
-0.0886187106,
-0.0046819411,
0.0224247687,
-0.0287542809,
-0.0199219491,
0.0265406575,
-0.0169667937,
-0.002292562,
-0.0475225262,
-0.0078237122,
0.028758077,
-0.0009334476,
-0.026051756,
0.0399579555,
-0.0278021041,
-0.0058845184,
0.0264971424,
0.0332019255,
-0.0223966707,
-0.0270745829,
0.0160559025,
-0.0247277338,
-0.0072137089,
-0.012472122,
0.0044538104,
0.0409274511,
-0.0342496894,
-0.0171484482,
-0.0556042418,
-0.010240634,
-0.0108602382,
-0.0156088909,
0.017366128,
-0.0252757184,
0.0030676126,
-0.0008141039,
-0.0230429936,
0.0187615752,
-0.0003533795,
0.0012110797,
0.0351817571,
-0.0364222787,
-0.0227072556,
-0.0342910066,
0.0095977336,
0.0454869233,
0.0714451894,
0.057621181,
0.0313673243,
-0.0433693789,
0.0429635532,
-0.0258105751,
-0.010033574,
-0.009986476,
-0.0452330634,
0.0411636904,
-0.0102860117,
0.041345831,
0.0703240633,
0.0224357136,
0.0184323862,
0.024125576,
0.0023244554,
0.0117231645,
-0.0217094794,
-0.0171042401,
-0.0127335209,
0.0029428322,
-0.0504693203,
-0.0378516242,
0.0195740052,
0.0187459141,
0.0236852039,
-0.0872355551,
0.0546067208,
0.0154124098,
-0.0542958342,
-0.0105760703,
0.0080461903,
0.0076617477,
0.024242159,
-0.0458989665,
-0.0877623782,
0.0495820343,
-0.0382364765,
-0.016590625,
0.0363767408,
-0.0091444282,
0.0060251062,
0.0625700355,
0.0084461998,
0.0329275727,
-0.0271627344,
0.0115003726,
-0.0570500903,
0.0034279074,
0.0420228727,
-0.0128043098,
0.016259674,
-0.0788243636,
-0.0276525896,
-0.0162564833,
0.0071167392,
-0.0249820556,
0.0203975663,
0.0055287834,
0.0162885021,
0.0511429571,
-0.0275872275,
0.0089595485,
0.0388995707,
0.0273417309,
-0.0090607554,
-0.0041497019,
-0.0199309904,
-0.0014914926,
0.02136131,
0.0453866124,
0.0219984744,
-0.0006628946,
-0.0765298083,
0.0147854965,
0.0158210639,
0.0310080331,
0.0112818843,
-0.0898758024,
0.0507172905,
-0.0246505532,
0.0457882956,
0.0150521686,
0.0515559316,
0.0896322206,
-0.0494005568,
0.0092150765,
0.0851308778,
-0.0187624153,
-0.0023549073,
-0.0013914597,
0.0356308036,
0.0299024452,
0.02222641,
-0.0167961232,
-0.0486553982,
-0.0286696609,
-0.024088813,
0.0100846719,
-0.0198660642,
-0.0057966337,
-0.0422444828,
-0.0592115521,
0.1062909663,
0.0175712444,
-0.0281515997,
-0.0564213097,
-0.0206775144,
-0.01173067,
-0.0222934056,
-0.0401633866,
0.0088004302,
0.0019485484,
0.0421716906,
0.0196337327,
0.0000937705,
-0.0644597858,
0.0144404909,
-0.0466029681,
0.0258925352,
0.0650475472,
0.0256486963,
0.0290939175,
-0.0859927014,
0.0003281549,
0.0243444536,
0.0375861079,
-0.0027772239,
0.0572378114,
0.0361005925,
-0.0200692434,
-0.0425568596,
0.0462824814,
0.0128667513,
-0.0284286197,
-0.0127053177,
0.0248548072,
-0.0327363536,
-0.02759232,
-0.0408341512,
0.0321070962,
-0.0072915028,
0.0267719794,
0.0859249011,
-0.0191168468,
-0.0556791127,
0.0058270283,
0.0107821738,
-0.0784397945,
-0.0245036334,
-0.0066653001,
0.0066500758,
-0.0411656462,
-0.051689297,
-0.0182953086,
0.0395133905,
0.0547408499,
-0.0330783725,
-0.01412067,
-0.0468584076,
-0.0059684478,
-0.0390311927,
0.0739303082,
0.0200970769,
0.003297132,
-0.0376194157,
-0.0299479384,
0.0020659282,
-0.042665571,
-0.0036135537,
0.029898189,
-0.0523414239,
-0.01129111,
-0.0441202484,
0.0797083899,
0.0269751754,
-0.0051750918,
0.0411142558,
-0.0631972551,
0.0013774916,
0.0446102023,
0.0107294852,
0.0177366957,
0.0289901029,
0.0078440728,
0.0006498084,
0.0071862852,
-0.0151349604,
0.0418882929,
0.0121280355,
0.006665457,
0.0192321744,
-0.0117940018,
0.0269401465,
-0.0160539858,
0.0321331322,
-0.0894538015,
-0.0036350321,
-0.0493366607,
-0.028813649,
-0.0034031114,
0.0062765828,
-0.0891896486,
-0.0058998717,
0.0384215415,
0.0278054141,
0.016970003,
-0.0172029193,
-0.011969286,
-0.0004488016,
-0.0676589906,
0.0038412106,
0.0045147524,
0.0017015233,
0.0131364791,
0.0227591135,
0.0246227756,
0.0213170294,
-0.0451893024,
0.0134013798,
0.0342766121,
0.0718031079,
0.0082895486,
0.0211601052,
0.0107208965,
0.0594519041,
-0.0204876866,
-0.0684888288,
-0.041958712,
0.040393766,
0.0870992914,
0.0025001573,
0.0751968324,
-0.0007814945,
0.0050264988,
-0.0188245568,
0.0782056451,
0.0405096337,
-0.0233172514,
0.0374056511,
-0.0004956713,
-0.0028704281,
-0.0573386103,
0.0792549103,
-0.0107746758,
0.0204083454,
-0.0561500005,
0.0088724364,
-0.0291321427,
-0.0423775204,
0.0386321396,
-0.0174127463,
0.0181287751,
0.0355598778,
-0.0477516912,
-0.0541932732,
-0.0250786059,
0.0542077273,
-0.0063090338,
0.0050732573,
0.0610988177,
0.0612817407,
-0.050969284,
-0.0196324214,
0.0012110133,
-0.0309303906,
0.028903719,
-0.002142305,
-0.0100514665,
-6.570070822e-33,
-0.0410335548,
-0.0535722375,
0.0488971435,
-0.0336042121,
0.0191778112,
-0.0234703757,
-0.0541780367,
-0.0078271106,
0.0156117454,
0.0312844217,
0.0506034382,
-0.0337461606,
-0.0117699681,
0.0289928373,
0.017059233,
0.006940552,
0.0397525057,
0.0301337484,
-0.0515100807,
0.0219153967,
0.0233549885,
-0.017993059,
0.0244939588,
-0.0568562932,
-0.0366438217,
0.0242840219,
-0.0494403467,
-0.0212917496,
-0.0392489657,
0.0489310548,
-0.0051459093,
-0.0058467491,
0.0197436549,
-0.0354165062,
-0.0359295122,
-0.0146740377,
0.009238991,
-0.0312091783,
0.0220423564,
-0.030108979,
-0.0830290392,
-0.0292956382,
0.0501093976,
-0.0097829439,
-0.0451190285,
-0.0461711474,
0.0550237261,
-0.0219170041,
0.0424445905,
-0.0246951897,
-0.0274669714,
0.0200912897,
-0.0441856273,
-0.0607654713,
0.0195866693,
0.0508696698,
-0.0139687052,
0.0062249806,
-0.0294195358,
0.0536963716,
0.0218769293,
0.0105799362,
0.1040430889,
0.0247683227,
0.0156381037,
0.0428898856,
0.058328677,
-0.038264893,
-0.0020304241,
0.0058175996,
-0.0055033476,
0.0881957933,
0.0797929466,
0.0545539372,
0.0147381732,
0.0130798751,
-0.0485074371,
0.0485211685,
-0.0884632394,
0.0442013294,
0.0142020136,
0.0381562486,
0.0264020097,
-0.0034252054,
-0.0244189166,
-0.0273556001,
-0.0443565436,
-0.0209583826,
0.0249270946,
-0.0148829389,
-0.0210669432,
-0.0239185803,
0.0400761738,
0.0165638942,
0.0318218209,
-0.0171738956,
-0.0490409695,
0.0468127243,
0.0028026195,
-0.0327298008,
-0.0106685534,
0.0084559415,
0.0957209617,
0.0179901309,
0.0286862627,
0.0305980295,
-0.0073281634,
0.0441708788,
0.0013247142,
-0.0099492921,
-0.0685596988,
0.0126848668,
0.0161100775,
-0.0166899152,
0.0009410988,
-0.0151419882,
-0.0696857125,
-0.0077018728,
-0.0167525467,
-0.0072540641,
-0.0168513488,
-0.0125150317,
-0.0123731112,
0.0127995834,
-0.0326020829,
0.0205073878,
-0.04761637,
-0.0573402382,
0.0208932851,
-0.0547148511,
-0.0471354574,
0.0102214944,
2.874e-7,
-0.0026388646,
0.0185622778,
-0.0305892415,
-0.0027387782,
0.0064209634,
0.0412064232,
-0.0251492877,
-0.0110999616,
0.0116086816,
-0.0338244624,
0.0127085447,
0.0497690849,
0.0343594626,
-0.0004322383,
0.0278137755,
0.022734791,
-0.0325807594,
-0.0224610325,
-0.0104849478,
-0.0070009427,
0.0720214769,
0.0215185266,
-0.011285767,
-0.0397683941,
0.0770395771,
0.0000618542,
0.0629896447,
-0.0309575684,
-0.0250989068,
-0.0450769961,
0.0232536625,
0.0069313571,
0.0034637344,
0.0463343486,
-0.0196429975,
-0.0597797073,
0.0250383876,
0.0391890705,
-0.0322934724,
0.0010192652,
0.0279415678,
0.0194670167,
-0.0002188231,
-0.0584831908,
0.047113888,
-0.0226152241,
-0.0300634373,
-0.0130716907,
-0.0254576337,
-0.0053278115,
0.0158915389,
-0.0413995609,
-0.0185716562,
0.0123584997,
0.0187042691,
0.0243098196,
-0.0144029567,
-0.0209159311,
-0.0496716127,
-0.0035813716,
-0.0483469218,
-0.0226038527,
-0.0576560721,
-0.0198802929,
0.0354773812,
0.0095365541,
-0.0504877195,
2.554777178e-34,
-0.0007395885,
0.0371690243,
0.0173774436,
-0.0265362412,
0.0491819903,
0.0246774815,
-0.0529630706,
0.032140065,
0.0082016326,
-0.0277494751,
-0.0340571068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.15006v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.15006v2 | Assessing the Impact of Prompting Methods on ChatGPT's Mathematical Capabilities | 2023-12-22T17:39:40 | 2024-02-20T18:44:20 | Yuhao Chen, Chloe Wong, Hanwen Yang, Juan Aguenza, Sai Bhujangari, Benthan Vu, Xun Lei, Amisha Prasad, Manny Fluss, Eric Phuong, Minghao Liu, Raja Kumar, Vanshika Vats, James Davis | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | This study critically evaluates the efficacy of prompting methods in
enhancing the mathematical reasoning capability of large language models
(LLMs). The investigation uses three prescriptive prompting methods - simple,
persona, and conversational prompting - known for their effectiveness in
enhancing the linguistic tasks of LLMs. We conduct this analysis on OpenAI's
LLM chatbot, ChatGPT-3.5, on extensive problem sets from the MATH, GSM8K, and
MMLU datasets, encompassing a broad spectrum of mathematical challenges. A
grading script adapted to each dataset is used to determine the effectiveness
of these prompting interventions in enhancing the model's mathematical analysis
power. Contrary to expectations, our empirical analysis reveals that none of
the investigated methods consistently improves over ChatGPT-3.5's baseline
performance, with some causing significant degradation. Our findings suggest
that prompting strategies do not necessarily generalize to new domains, in this
study failing to enhance mathematical performance. | [
-0.0145883644,
0.0696886703,
-0.0319719724,
0.0336819328,
-0.0699566528,
0.0179414246,
0.0358962975,
0.0037745661,
-0.0061475174,
-0.0101493644,
-0.0269863643,
-0.0191371758,
0.0261221547,
0.0194650982,
0.0057640783,
-0.0499706231,
0.0226057693,
-0.0588616058,
0.0395746417,
-0.0112170307,
-0.0249864645,
-0.0164004546,
-0.0606821217,
0.0529159568,
-0.0384924971,
-0.0703608543,
-0.0150590995,
-0.0703766719,
-0.0076737194,
-0.038637992,
-0.018403912,
0.0635317862,
0.0002177137,
0.0423115566,
0.0000023094,
-0.0629973263,
0.0241387915,
0.0146135828,
-0.0468961596,
0.0211066436,
0.0336228944,
0.0037564074,
0.0115238084,
0.0267484691,
-0.0673318207,
0.0324887671,
0.0176185258,
0.0299648605,
0.0546930954,
0.0619194359,
-0.0070028044,
-0.0289252531,
0.0268697422,
0.0038702977,
0.0425123312,
-0.0656448528,
0.012539655,
0.0517351776,
0.0434596948,
0.0120807737,
-0.0373815224,
0.0486462638,
0.0814274922,
-0.026580207,
0.0072611724,
0.0358898342,
-0.0527121052,
-0.0085078273,
0.0021940931,
0.069104813,
0.0484141856,
0.0123227313,
-0.0359950066,
0.0071892682,
0.0250588581,
0.0114048421,
-0.0807431564,
0.0171543509,
0.002482841,
-0.0007287535,
-0.0349653438,
-0.0110511528,
0.0043320558,
0.0318949744,
-0.0154126668,
0.0508441031,
0.0106382715,
-0.0309259966,
-0.0292227659,
0.0090700816,
-0.0645031035,
-0.0438933186,
-0.002349166,
0.0622072108,
0.004699687,
0.0165684503,
-0.0028066356,
-0.034888614,
-0.0290886629,
-0.0284660608,
0.0184229594,
0.1036887541,
-0.0209473781,
0.000203334,
-0.0129718278,
0.0595897511,
0.0364673845,
0.0270335451,
-0.0108442763,
0.0594287626,
-0.0507420227,
-0.0303515028,
-0.0315813348,
0.0385245681,
0.0335196368,
-0.0078265416,
-0.059622962,
0.0420858525,
-0.0242850464,
0.0021052328,
0.0063723638,
-0.0276296232,
-0.0124163451,
-0.0031461271,
-0.0710019022,
-0.0021887361,
-0.0512381345,
0.0070771775,
0.0210403465,
-0.0912714228,
-0.0217770208,
0.0168169774,
-0.0311336778,
-0.0120656202,
-0.0106923757,
0.0611491166,
0.0051971842,
-0.0269109719,
0.0154420491,
-0.0018507736,
0.0156260915,
-0.0764316693,
-0.0005105084,
-0.0683279261,
0.0259405635,
0.0111621749,
-0.0383280106,
-0.0080800857,
0.0059295059,
0.0111979861,
0.0374350548,
0.062731497,
0.0159082599,
0.0223090965,
0.0393607654,
0.0050046211,
-0.0678574964,
0.0546628088,
0.047965426,
-0.0454712957,
0.0006860393,
-0.0083066095,
0.0276922807,
0.0458371863,
0.00887,
-0.00733069,
0.0009989232,
0.0064059389,
0.0214423463,
0.0455917381,
-0.0257085897,
0.0479512736,
-0.0602774732,
0.0133198453,
0.0315489732,
0.0630018264,
-0.0196265671,
0.0317815617,
0.0248417705,
-0.0146669,
0.0534988642,
0.014696165,
-0.0804199055,
0.0199481416,
-0.0175325889,
0.0119234463,
-0.000864284,
-0.00413178,
-0.0156669766,
-0.0772934556,
-0.0096266344,
0.0033134643,
-0.0084955823,
-0.0030501711,
0.0634409785,
0.0071917479,
0.0164971575,
0.0240402911,
-0.0066948915,
-0.0432926044,
-0.0199431125,
-0.0920729339,
0.0270172488,
0.0196734518,
0.055996459,
-0.0391414724,
-0.029193528,
0.0057658409,
0.0306551065,
0.035517808,
0.069986783,
0.0044663288,
-0.0400893502,
-0.0325653069,
0.0072682519,
-0.0434986763,
0.0229224302,
-0.0071916804,
0.0517897084,
0.0088771563,
0.0152398655,
-0.0069298265,
0.0169210788,
0.0230110008,
-0.052892562,
-0.0536516681,
-0.0196973402,
-0.021851141,
-0.001536516,
-0.0122048147,
0.0214221608,
0.0479589924,
-0.0097456081,
-0.0002435071,
-0.0042825318,
0.0085316002,
-0.0615223907,
-0.0391502455,
0.0643614754,
-0.0010143397,
-0.0445173495,
-0.0009480372,
-0.0171209499,
0.000770525,
0.0539480001,
-0.0161375348,
0.0379638709,
-0.010125407,
0.0236799493,
-0.0175945368,
-0.0087014986,
-0.0089842081,
0.060844373,
0.0416779146,
-0.0033818758,
0.0560144261,
0.0349571779,
0.0037956196,
-0.0123978518,
0.0079723038,
-0.0214152355,
-0.0139822103,
0.0159138907,
-0.0272831786,
0.0187270548,
-0.0421177596,
-0.0159075297,
-0.059554182,
-0.0301427115,
-0.0004438832,
0.0363323167,
0.0019718967,
-0.0216001049,
-0.0294359308,
-0.0018457406,
-0.0326010846,
-0.0006802008,
-0.0162095744,
0.0227462407,
0.0352683142,
0.0080920793,
-0.0373632796,
-0.0178588349,
-0.0013814712,
-0.0398548916,
0.0292546283,
0.0468230955,
0.0260236431,
0.001340228,
0.0656426921,
-0.0671709478,
-0.0055707861,
-0.0179267842,
0.0097010517,
0.065936096,
-0.0351990797,
0.0807797909,
0.0419939384,
-0.0124316961,
0.0668930188,
0.0129121318,
-0.0308830142,
-0.0644895956,
0.0124763278,
-0.0145189241,
-0.0222193208,
0.0193240885,
-0.0116252899,
-0.0300303493,
0.0489026271,
-0.0212268718,
-0.0105666267,
-0.0378514268,
0.0436165221,
-0.021996364,
-0.0152695859,
-0.0186522845,
0.0205544457,
-0.020958731,
0.0449113399,
0.0006207445,
-0.0616075397,
0.0534510277,
0.0013479412,
-0.0270830318,
-0.0498483516,
0.0137194348,
-0.0577699207,
0.0562024638,
-0.0198154841,
-0.037803933,
-0.0187042411,
-0.0177955255,
-0.045870617,
0.002290485,
0.0250540357,
-0.0282739475,
0.0324666128,
-0.0353808962,
0.011726141,
-0.0089296894,
-0.0310352482,
-0.0580474436,
0.0161626618,
-0.0133305527,
0.0321424603,
-0.0012738451,
-0.0198926795,
0.0047318749,
-0.0029230032,
0.0186144132,
-0.0013225435,
-0.0566210784,
-0.0274196155,
-0.0050862697,
-0.0403661318,
0.0074927504,
0.0483747423,
0.0401851386,
-0.0638058111,
0.0864388198,
0.0201569851,
0.035817273,
0.0050417278,
-0.0173580498,
-0.0007339212,
-0.0017699139,
-0.0084057422,
-0.019327268,
0.0494974405,
0.0232085846,
-0.0599701442,
-0.0131017333,
0.1114826277,
0.040849369,
-0.0298839845,
-0.0032212632,
-0.0920699909,
0.0400723666,
-0.0051166127,
0.0192316994,
-0.1067950875,
-0.0017609892,
0.027397491,
-0.0121208848,
-0.0131731499,
-0.0284666587,
-0.0194504019,
-0.1292336136,
0.0282507706,
0.004166177,
-0.0471225306,
0.0269191321,
-0.0288928673,
0.0153036918,
0.0179664046,
0.0329751223,
0.0248434898,
-0.013146379,
0.027446596,
0.0177504737,
-0.0532910004,
-0.0561665297,
0.0185664706,
-0.0148615129,
0.0148794604,
0.0095033459,
0.0236711185,
-0.0150722424,
-0.0491438098,
0.0493548773,
0.0870335102,
-0.0038727911,
-0.0021111278,
0.0250803605,
-0.0069572418,
-0.003606919,
-0.0463612787,
0.0127682919,
-0.0374314971,
-0.0376485437,
0.0366004035,
0.0845202208,
-0.0318435766,
0.0036724857,
-0.0101709254,
0.0429492518,
-0.03466627,
0.0464771353,
0.0437719785,
-0.0099508893,
-0.0257720649,
-0.0471987911,
-0.024293581,
-0.0212023556,
-0.0271086283,
-0.004232801,
0.0292676631,
-0.045038633,
-0.0296343621,
-0.0612260029,
0.0557586141,
0.0204972904,
0.0127415629,
-0.0239197426,
0.0045526838,
0.0396319181,
0.025037311,
0.0491733812,
-0.0388740376,
0.0279170778,
-0.043170318,
0.0172811877,
-0.0107700694,
-0.0239678659,
-0.0018393385,
-0.0066559454,
-0.0869598538,
-0.0462477207,
-0.0112199979,
0.034215644,
0.0262307301,
-0.0191673525,
0.004761796,
0.0063048331,
-0.036556758,
0.0366403572,
-0.0373961739,
0.0149499075,
0.0373550951,
0.0311029926,
0.0444555469,
0.0102286451,
0.0247997362,
0.0056246123,
-0.0078054783,
0.0535745136,
-0.0251859743,
-0.0394535735,
0.0216821078,
0.0664881989,
0.0025855149,
0.0335902944,
-0.001272775,
-0.0227651782,
0.0080859829,
-0.054651726,
-0.0019945966,
-0.0358083211,
0.0028788024,
0.000361485,
0.0273568518,
0.0162742622,
-0.0260321535,
-0.0252964012,
0.0166890286,
0.027632108,
0.0418774113,
-0.0108423578,
0.0267302487,
0.0223705806,
-0.0095450897,
0.0011055366,
-0.0196038205,
-0.0242372323,
0.0203073528,
0.0069320383,
0.0825420693,
0.0007588013,
0.0215380713,
0.0190179683,
-0.0063134125,
-0.0402083434,
-0.107302092,
0.0310611855,
0.0598779544,
0.0076742633,
0.0203690678,
-0.0222239196,
-0.0565273501,
0.0165883526,
0.0010344777,
0.0269851126,
0.012873943,
-0.0412395447,
0.0267710593,
0.022386156,
0.0110456785,
-0.060533192,
0.0332046896,
-0.0812142119,
0.0132975271,
0.0011485693,
0.02446541,
0.0045341128,
-0.0485529341,
0.0311599318,
-0.0076665096,
0.0033943835,
0.0001181182,
-0.0815650374,
-0.0812016949,
-0.0310438797,
-0.0051975618,
-0.0248692166,
-0.0151755195,
0.0419472232,
0.0647279248,
-0.0388915055,
-0.0105532482,
-0.0021408533,
0.0148157291,
-0.039561525,
-0.014166655,
-0.0124238692,
-5.814077344e-33,
-0.0286545213,
-0.036881946,
0.0710547045,
0.0393027514,
-0.0229298472,
-0.0279996693,
-0.0373691246,
0.0523582622,
-0.0106102899,
0.0026924419,
-0.0292916726,
0.0439104401,
0.0028657082,
-0.0135848662,
0.0166107751,
-0.0392212905,
-0.009275727,
-0.0279495008,
-0.0417885967,
-0.0229536239,
-0.0157972071,
-0.0034331132,
0.0383134149,
-0.0509295948,
0.0543816499,
-0.0117453141,
0.0018239148,
0.0000080863,
-0.0459286161,
0.0641217828,
-0.0212935023,
0.0412655659,
0.0150283799,
-0.0106433332,
-0.0239193439,
0.02776305,
0.0051784781,
-0.0582917742,
0.0158071145,
0.0353082158,
-0.042758666,
-0.0448628366,
0.0043748948,
0.0085013686,
-0.0527368411,
-0.016423963,
0.0289818905,
-0.0380898863,
-0.010618262,
0.0550228246,
-0.0461936072,
0.0303495601,
-0.0094089955,
-0.0466110855,
0.0171746127,
0.0426172391,
-0.0411392264,
-0.0338108391,
0.0089889411,
0.030007273,
0.0260156691,
0.0079350891,
0.0350128338,
-0.0170535408,
0.0196515359,
0.0201377831,
0.0350641347,
0.0184100717,
-0.0447215959,
-0.0459477603,
0.0542477109,
0.0392153189,
0.0711516291,
0.0014142074,
0.0416411497,
0.0122059649,
-0.0315691568,
0.0094696069,
0.0449180305,
0.0108524645,
0.0019849732,
-0.0185790621,
-0.0488193296,
-0.0151566789,
-0.0210044309,
0.0450261086,
-0.0541725308,
-0.0556257442,
0.021377435,
-0.0407201871,
0.0241266601,
-0.0315668397,
0.025223041,
-0.0255591441,
-0.0218036417,
-0.0191446207,
-0.0086575486,
0.0585221648,
-0.0148089891,
0.0233607274,
-0.0489728414,
-0.0093140323,
-0.0001886069,
0.0170714185,
0.0396976992,
0.0247377753,
0.002872281,
0.0140795019,
-0.0280790441,
-0.0398111716,
-0.0443787128,
-0.01331711,
0.0792982057,
0.0531774089,
0.0086773867,
0.0312277339,
-0.0118654594,
0.0382464863,
-0.0292425733,
-0.0157042332,
-0.0602918603,
0.029922165,
-0.0272869822,
-0.011077499,
-0.0220920928,
-0.0353214592,
-0.043633543,
0.0307874512,
0.0250842012,
-0.0806824341,
-0.0217863563,
-0.0134938592,
2.982e-7,
0.0650481954,
0.0584486872,
0.0106725292,
0.0575985759,
0.0051096496,
0.003176678,
-0.0481120311,
-0.0430585034,
0.0387080684,
0.0160776116,
0.0315628387,
0.0728672892,
0.0381035581,
0.0360519662,
-0.0838601515,
-0.0134379501,
-0.0588541068,
-0.0294528697,
-0.047376167,
0.0394258685,
0.0897767171,
0.0428876057,
0.0230169203,
0.0135738207,
-0.0135966977,
-0.0424872637,
0.0699867979,
-0.0224064458,
-0.0054128058,
0.0266066678,
0.0039968262,
-0.0122368708,
0.0287291277,
0.0178969298,
0.0171851814,
-0.0049785692,
0.0280630141,
0.0719387159,
0.0353229158,
0.0198029056,
0.0090876967,
-0.0039361487,
-0.0131593803,
-0.0316745639,
0.0467262194,
-0.0781880245,
-0.0459709205,
-0.0067871283,
0.022125354,
-0.0308379177,
0.0486230738,
-0.0222575646,
0.0109294001,
0.0135041941,
0.0132761337,
-0.0308649037,
0.0045561898,
-0.0175189674,
-0.0114754774,
-0.0081718238,
-0.063885279,
-0.0670544878,
-0.0577690452,
-0.0024196047,
0.0351425186,
0.0041445559,
-0.002902176,
2.750383341e-34,
0.0463887304,
-0.0319153443,
0.0475655235,
0.0828050822,
0.0388234034,
0.0130226305,
0.0261487421,
0.0370771214,
0.0400287695,
-0.06034033,
-0.0363947302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14862v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14862v1 | YAYI 2: Multilingual Open-Source Large Language Models | 2023-12-22T17:34:47 | 2023-12-22T17:34:47 | Yin Luo, Qingchao Kong, Nan Xu, Jia Cao, Bao Hao, Baoyu Qu, Bo Chen, Chao Zhu, Chenyang Zhao, Donglei Zhang, Fan Feng, Feifei Zhao, Hailong Sun, Hanxuan Yang, Haojun Pan, Hongyu Liu, Jianbin Guo, Jiangtao Du, Jingyi Wang, Junfeng Li, Lei Sun, Liduo Liu, Lifeng Dong, Lili Liu, Lin Wang, Liwen Zhang, Minzheng Wang, Pin Wang, Ping Yu, Qingxiao Li, Rui Yan, Rui Zou, Ruiqun Li, Taiwen Huang, Xiaodong Wang, Xiaofei Wu, Xin Peng, Xina Zhang, Xing Fang, Xinglin Xiao, Yanni Hao, Yao Dong, Yigang Wang, Ying Liu, Yongyu Jiang, Yungan Wang, Yuqi Wang, Zhangsheng Wang, Zhaoxin Yu, Zhen Luo, Wenji Mao, Lei Wang, Dajun Zeng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As the latest advancements in natural language processing, large language
models (LLMs) have achieved human-level language understanding and generation
abilities in many real-world tasks, and even have been regarded as a potential
path to the artificial general intelligence. To better facilitate research on
LLMs, many open-source LLMs, such as Llama 2 and Falcon, have recently been
proposed and gained comparable performances to proprietary models. However,
these models are primarily designed for English scenarios and exhibit poor
performances in Chinese contexts. In this technical report, we propose YAYI 2,
including both base and chat models, with 30 billion parameters. YAYI 2 is
pre-trained from scratch on a multilingual corpus which contains 2.65 trillion
tokens filtered by our pre-training data processing pipeline. The base model is
aligned with human values through supervised fine-tuning with millions of
instructions and reinforcement learning from human feedback. Extensive
experiments on multiple benchmarks, such as MMLU and CMMLU, consistently
demonstrate that the proposed YAYI 2 outperforms other similar sized
open-source models. | [
0.0429400355,
0.0613378286,
0.0146846566,
0.0548963994,
-0.0104598096,
0.0111749489,
0.021781832,
-0.0113984235,
0.0129652601,
-0.0455061309,
-0.0752927288,
-0.0682466701,
-0.0017690901,
0.0374812149,
0.0143796196,
-0.0139014786,
0.0427318253,
-0.0371137932,
0.0229924675,
-0.0037130713,
-0.0076190261,
0.0378563516,
0.0038046124,
0.0533860736,
-0.0003932152,
-0.019820964,
-0.0098240031,
0.0100588696,
-0.0017098219,
-0.0241256617,
0.0231822245,
0.049050048,
0.0050860401,
0.0470580496,
0.0000019428,
-0.0519972667,
-0.0020410931,
-0.0268148612,
-0.017964758,
0.03745858,
0.0606236681,
-0.0100001218,
-0.009252877,
0.0327076353,
-0.0437295847,
-0.017299341,
0.0172348246,
0.068324998,
0.0630556569,
0.081142433,
0.0035126086,
-0.0442442559,
0.0271834061,
-0.032373067,
-0.0147314901,
-0.0465599671,
0.0320936255,
-0.0249153469,
0.0086512463,
-0.0081158336,
-0.0002094216,
-0.0043272893,
0.017170893,
0.0080683827,
-0.0291075632,
0.0365483984,
-0.0409322903,
-0.049706839,
-0.0252150856,
0.1132897288,
-0.0440853685,
-0.0257873908,
-0.0051594144,
0.0003936244,
-0.0064427489,
-0.0514652357,
-0.0493929274,
0.0484665632,
0.0236499235,
0.0325145051,
0.0281550735,
-0.0352743603,
0.0270135142,
0.0441878699,
-0.0436635502,
0.0397074558,
0.0103706457,
-0.0106004942,
0.001299198,
-0.0226806607,
-0.0331704281,
-0.0526299737,
0.012315277,
0.0467639789,
-0.0616245978,
0.0130760344,
-0.0614699647,
-0.017300345,
0.0268942192,
-0.0626625791,
0.005687769,
0.0385788158,
-0.0209390689,
0.0424646363,
-0.0233247411,
0.0422706045,
-0.0402804241,
0.0184163488,
-0.0518138371,
-0.0418400168,
0.0074531715,
-0.0082594398,
-0.0290851686,
0.0423938781,
-0.0576853752,
-0.0537740402,
-0.0255030468,
0.0138101215,
0.0070048557,
0.0026064399,
0.0294645447,
0.0085849632,
-0.0264898818,
-0.0172281358,
-0.0157482326,
0.0020209544,
-0.0329790153,
0.0133138997,
0.0100995954,
-0.0914193392,
0.0026418148,
0.03845191,
0.0229085591,
-0.014265243,
0.0200397149,
0.0702344179,
-0.0025042892,
-0.0292773675,
-0.0459813252,
-0.0262912996,
-0.0116336346,
-0.0821482837,
-0.0125352973,
-0.0585674569,
0.0421031006,
-0.0053108665,
0.0065445323,
-0.0131339962,
0.0345061682,
0.0198987294,
-0.0501096137,
0.0439922102,
-0.0026036855,
0.0088458685,
0.0065461653,
-0.0060927803,
0.0179686081,
0.0744076818,
0.0304736085,
0.029181594,
0.0546473674,
0.0131160999,
-0.0124709345,
0.0465914272,
0.003197138,
-0.0027136805,
0.0109820412,
0.0098342681,
0.0046496992,
0.0485558175,
0.0415470898,
0.0672298595,
-0.0422789305,
-0.0047113965,
0.0677770525,
0.0362254046,
0.0047475733,
0.0336800627,
0.0670571178,
0.039653372,
0.0070251636,
-0.0369445868,
-0.0376108922,
0.0205270462,
0.0104303099,
0.0055735516,
0.0494071655,
0.0512477607,
-0.0554596372,
-0.0376563221,
0.002621673,
-0.0377101712,
-0.0062715989,
0.0045171324,
0.0388076045,
-0.0079246238,
-0.0404325537,
0.0557976179,
0.05291868,
-0.0408741385,
0.0141674913,
-0.0335793793,
0.0639493093,
0.0862115771,
0.0402053893,
-0.01516815,
-0.0227998514,
-0.0240586456,
0.0020672106,
0.0633625314,
0.0495415144,
-0.0097471457,
0.0238810312,
-0.0859331191,
0.0046109743,
-0.0161765609,
-0.0176243279,
0.0495413579,
0.023452526,
0.0162569825,
0.0230911765,
0.0089624776,
-0.0263172723,
0.0425018743,
-0.039744392,
-0.0059076627,
0.0264926665,
-0.0108305709,
0.050636664,
0.0336013213,
-0.0259676427,
-0.000375419,
0.032325387,
-0.028078014,
-0.023377955,
0.022403542,
-0.0662226602,
-0.0454710275,
0.0566207618,
0.0073365243,
0.0178690441,
0.0469452515,
-0.0473328978,
-0.0440443978,
0.0169855952,
0.0117502352,
0.0412396044,
-0.0688635856,
0.0341368839,
0.0202637669,
0.0499015972,
0.0076083625,
0.0398771763,
-0.0023909057,
0.0017508155,
0.0078318287,
0.037032865,
0.0195227992,
-0.0419576019,
-0.0504984073,
0.0240735579,
-0.0258287638,
0.0201513842,
0.014039577,
0.0526297726,
-0.0257623531,
-0.026534237,
-0.115966998,
0.0363534838,
-0.0368188508,
-0.0129005229,
0.0217502899,
0.0070219385,
-0.0185335111,
-0.0028763553,
-0.0485697873,
0.0057109622,
0.030901745,
-0.0108214077,
0.0301700216,
-0.0048210882,
-0.0104391919,
-0.0427616052,
0.0056363582,
0.021788748,
0.0384876058,
-0.0156694464,
-0.0050394027,
-0.0390136838,
-0.0067854444,
-0.0196230821,
0.0290154628,
0.0049903975,
-0.0614135638,
-0.0150077101,
-0.0084562134,
0.0623787642,
0.0647938699,
0.0347677805,
0.0206658561,
0.0114699351,
0.0164896958,
-0.0520942323,
0.024799956,
-0.0128214061,
-0.0429970548,
-0.0312404372,
-0.0100713968,
-0.0040245238,
0.0642829016,
-0.0030989754,
-0.0090800142,
-0.0538701601,
0.0067752129,
-0.0013963489,
-0.036804609,
-0.0125291022,
0.0110358633,
-0.0303523,
0.0058654924,
-0.045057565,
-0.0194750633,
0.0375013761,
-0.0619742908,
-0.0100265332,
-0.0368997976,
-0.0133886822,
-0.0581584349,
0.0284994971,
-0.0058087865,
0.0337143168,
-0.0085842917,
-0.0129876044,
-0.0345012769,
0.022959765,
-0.0330889709,
-0.0241677873,
0.0204870477,
-0.0348964296,
0.0060866014,
0.0013146745,
-0.0410674512,
-0.0545391701,
-0.04149938,
-0.0290823877,
0.0215491187,
0.0432995558,
-0.0218709055,
-0.0201578066,
0.0042425301,
0.0108481729,
0.0328223482,
-0.0216957908,
0.0232622325,
-0.0365687162,
0.0134895528,
0.0659110025,
0.0038033929,
0.0301554278,
-0.0399202555,
0.0343438238,
0.0516308658,
0.033094082,
0.0011138176,
-0.0169584136,
0.011626821,
0.0207435191,
-0.0296805687,
-0.0099998387,
0.0121698063,
0.040724922,
-0.0340103991,
-0.0021487633,
0.1302263439,
0.024485385,
-0.0382519364,
0.013153485,
-0.0165154133,
0.0202518553,
0.0219139047,
0.00745583,
-0.0954177454,
-0.0407364182,
-0.0090329396,
-0.0056410916,
0.0112204691,
-0.0237431694,
-0.0049758619,
-0.1473718882,
0.0300223213,
0.0096931541,
-0.0485573709,
-0.0201659352,
-0.0192879532,
-0.0230513681,
-0.0176656805,
0.0186829399,
0.0156269073,
-0.0019360016,
-0.0266122464,
0.0084027853,
0.0003692204,
-0.055566147,
0.0442800857,
-0.0450508855,
0.0393187106,
0.0339500047,
0.0518697686,
0.0098988898,
0.0062659765,
0.025302818,
-0.0010367939,
-0.0107002584,
-0.0226488225,
0.0229594093,
-0.013398828,
-0.0144563317,
-0.0270443168,
0.0496485718,
-0.0422633141,
-0.0027877497,
-0.0036444096,
0.0411360413,
0.0111300731,
-0.0058942898,
0.0037308112,
0.0138427811,
-0.0003040605,
0.0864330456,
0.0211259983,
-0.0590362065,
-0.0606008582,
-0.0046433844,
-0.0360258855,
-0.0388397053,
0.0011949508,
0.0151525605,
-0.0136336023,
-0.0235213358,
-0.1038042158,
-0.0429350249,
0.0184314493,
0.0047738175,
-0.0093005486,
0.0029190716,
0.0049297535,
-0.0043922714,
-0.0131670395,
0.025324503,
-0.028725462,
0.0071662543,
-0.0896462724,
0.0093616927,
0.0260122232,
-0.0503325798,
-0.0197365358,
0.0412538089,
-0.0798635855,
-0.081664592,
-0.0234986711,
0.0511720888,
0.0132568367,
0.0489989519,
-0.0191798415,
-0.0397050716,
0.0518099628,
-0.0101350704,
-0.0546408184,
0.0124431839,
0.0099866185,
0.03132011,
-0.0010449336,
0.0488189384,
-0.0322168656,
0.034436021,
0.0021034323,
0.0497785322,
0.004933279,
-0.0399064869,
0.004689577,
0.0216761753,
0.0089291483,
-0.0243496355,
-0.0148534402,
-0.0449065082,
0.0307207312,
-0.0266695954,
-0.0251365863,
-0.0461607762,
0.0092902975,
0.0419758223,
-0.0163066182,
-0.0157730225,
-0.0159548093,
-0.0049483152,
0.0377667397,
0.0171229821,
-0.0134923067,
-0.020568084,
0.0179225765,
0.0261638202,
-0.0150097106,
-0.03097854,
0.0050931135,
-0.0025144485,
0.0214987844,
-0.0492232516,
0.0806230158,
-0.0187888853,
-0.0161830261,
0.0002003733,
0.0321003273,
-0.0362113379,
-0.0595439188,
-0.0126502747,
0.0526435822,
0.0776710659,
0.0081872838,
0.0718695819,
-0.0231091622,
-0.006018097,
-0.0413699932,
0.0462225117,
-0.0185589343,
-0.029710969,
0.0275090579,
0.0030098171,
-0.0555397421,
0.0063914671,
0.0936434641,
0.0265637431,
0.0317568853,
0.0009153634,
0.0286255796,
-0.0370144658,
-0.0270377491,
0.0188346226,
0.0249416996,
-0.0314499326,
0.0289324503,
-0.0154935066,
-0.0445962846,
-0.0093205608,
-0.0061937887,
-0.0190951601,
-0.0155124059,
0.0382799096,
0.0664708465,
-0.0080211684,
0.0035031806,
-0.0658594966,
-0.0208395068,
-0.000815314,
-0.0212003607,
0.0069196839,
-6.870153223e-33,
-0.0195748918,
0.0092674345,
0.0384746753,
-0.0124033261,
-0.013645784,
-0.0203449335,
-0.0090426998,
-0.0161086842,
-0.0478821807,
-0.0130555043,
-0.0121686477,
0.0113421064,
0.0203290749,
0.0324640684,
-0.0011918362,
0.0062803775,
0.0448741093,
-0.0052214619,
0.0000910566,
0.0431543551,
0.0607510582,
0.049777668,
0.0382445455,
-0.0210880674,
-0.0232196171,
-0.0236645862,
-0.0023017456,
0.019543292,
-0.0068336786,
0.0545883402,
-0.0373563878,
0.0275116004,
0.0264657103,
-0.0148781324,
-0.0187912043,
0.0400452018,
-0.0803369209,
0.0021386053,
0.0291383658,
0.0231508594,
0.0044475282,
-0.0238609519,
0.0272488091,
-0.0134903984,
0.0204650909,
0.0172529314,
0.0226630997,
-0.0152959479,
0.0031116172,
-0.0130277108,
-0.0708409473,
0.0265857875,
-0.0029505768,
-0.0108893262,
-0.0117055532,
0.0555034503,
-0.0289346948,
0.047849711,
-0.0494556054,
0.0126063144,
-0.0079508247,
0.0131779406,
0.0541487634,
0.012479635,
0.0109716086,
0.0510543399,
0.008194752,
-0.0088429274,
-0.0252745636,
0.0018524938,
0.0111607704,
0.0716198906,
-0.0091317557,
0.0637136549,
-0.0092573743,
-0.037448816,
-0.1164837703,
0.0037784597,
0.0362786688,
0.0450504534,
0.0383155048,
-0.0119338585,
-0.0159655977,
-0.0029859673,
-0.0324708149,
0.0026279343,
-0.0403704122,
-0.0231589917,
0.0399653725,
0.0358805247,
-0.0132745784,
-0.0411913246,
0.0536667779,
-0.0282147955,
-0.0001522179,
0.0450164005,
-0.0178422946,
-0.0035106204,
-0.0347349085,
0.0501868464,
-0.0876972377,
-0.0817132592,
0.0101226913,
-0.0357065946,
-0.0156418756,
0.0187209286,
0.0275738779,
0.0071836915,
-0.0690027624,
0.0126029905,
-0.0312544778,
0.0230086111,
0.0028628409,
0.0272764098,
0.0264354348,
-0.0032324041,
-0.0102008637,
0.0679848716,
0.0033555813,
0.0077934181,
-0.0267899334,
-0.0690141097,
0.0050606872,
0.0127438996,
-0.0400265157,
0.02825284,
-0.0439631827,
-0.0078370674,
0.031893041,
-0.0620534346,
-0.0171571691,
0.0058848364,
2.677e-7,
0.0022618189,
0.0253634118,
0.0155725414,
0.0310612097,
0.010007007,
0.0366960913,
-0.011168805,
0.053718172,
-0.0142889228,
0.0338220149,
0.0135675985,
0.0476373695,
0.0558178239,
0.0009924804,
-0.0994338766,
-0.0012402125,
-0.0751551464,
-0.0100476332,
-0.0755659193,
-0.0357088111,
0.025502013,
0.123239629,
-0.0128052067,
0.0049096756,
0.0020792924,
-0.0632145032,
0.0808088481,
-0.0125719504,
-0.0368734151,
0.0512902513,
0.0229211468,
0.046463728,
-0.0242620818,
-0.0190291815,
0.0027682255,
0.0390007831,
0.0176903959,
0.1059682891,
0.0177711025,
-0.0263375025,
0.0385816619,
-0.0260738377,
-0.0150224101,
-0.0736056343,
0.0815532058,
-0.0367522761,
-0.0307957381,
-0.0512337014,
0.0164073631,
-0.0181042328,
0.0079924446,
-0.0599788129,
0.0040301462,
0.0333516411,
0.0100734513,
-0.0267019365,
-0.0065315864,
-0.078345187,
-0.018621793,
-0.0071492987,
-0.0558064766,
-0.0344743617,
-0.0399372987,
-0.0105878357,
0.0423307531,
-0.0134213092,
0.0253888331,
2.147684887e-34,
0.0421289876,
-0.0171070267,
-0.0010225656,
0.0303361714,
0.0475700162,
-0.0172490533,
-0.0076196622,
0.0173764061,
-0.0011407369,
-0.0763988644,
-0.0216743555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.09454v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.09454v1 | Voila-A: Aligning Vision-Language Models with User's Gaze Attention | 2023-12-22T17:34:01 | 2023-12-22T17:34:01 | Kun Yan, Lei Ji, Zeyu Wang, Yuntao Wang, Nan Duan, Shuai Ma | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In recent years, the integration of vision and language understanding has led
to significant advancements in artificial intelligence, particularly through
Vision-Language Models (VLMs). However, existing VLMs face challenges in
handling real-world applications with complex scenes and multiple objects, as
well as aligning their focus with the diverse attention patterns of human
users. In this paper, we introduce gaze information, feasibly collected by AR
or VR devices, as a proxy for human attention to guide VLMs and propose a novel
approach, Voila-A, for gaze alignment to enhance the interpretability and
effectiveness of these models in real-world applications. First, we collect
hundreds of minutes of gaze data to demonstrate that we can mimic human gaze
modalities using localized narratives. We then design an automatic data
annotation pipeline utilizing GPT-4 to generate the VOILA-COCO dataset.
Additionally, we innovate the Voila Perceiver modules to integrate gaze
information into VLMs while preserving their pretrained knowledge. We evaluate
Voila-A using a hold-out validation set and a newly collected VOILA-GAZE
Testset, which features real-life scenarios captured with a gaze-tracking
device. Our experimental results demonstrate that Voila-A significantly
outperforms several baseline models. By aligning model attention with human
gaze patterns, Voila-A paves the way for more intuitive, user-centric VLMs and
fosters engaging human-AI interaction across a wide range of applications. | [
0.0195023026,
0.0100009711,
0.0041692075,
0.0037678818,
0.0321688205,
-0.0019833122,
0.0112268794,
-0.0166617967,
0.0341877677,
-0.0346585885,
-0.0207664371,
-0.0212490447,
0.0200262759,
0.0685606003,
0.0342138819,
-0.0594815575,
-0.0172596481,
-0.0394029953,
-0.0329624042,
0.0413317978,
0.0523241945,
0.0455486104,
-0.0156217981,
0.0671707019,
-0.0480198674,
-0.0254933126,
-0.0307465475,
0.0420140699,
0.0653801113,
-0.0117464494,
0.0221969187,
0.0340537317,
0.0164422579,
-0.004729385,
0.0000021572,
-0.0128558818,
0.0290910266,
-0.021538442,
-0.0081134392,
-0.0280589908,
0.0016418499,
-0.01599323,
0.023749141,
0.0125513701,
-0.0168152191,
-0.0373781621,
0.087059997,
-0.0148546034,
0.0540612303,
-0.0056196889,
-0.020575488,
0.020664867,
0.0402777791,
-0.0301206242,
0.0103663178,
-0.0452651158,
0.0055027776,
0.0379935615,
-0.0035371501,
-0.0073706182,
-0.0316116586,
0.045960363,
0.0044456068,
0.0457511917,
0.06516736,
0.0398389772,
-0.0417314097,
-0.0587599315,
-0.0295129847,
0.0778286606,
-0.0125864791,
-0.0696606413,
0.0084606856,
0.0102294236,
0.0367553048,
0.0178396106,
-0.0225579441,
0.0078195343,
-0.031903889,
0.0267071761,
-0.0361134894,
0.0251863413,
0.0130201392,
-0.0303031951,
-0.0160104912,
-0.0182560328,
-0.0069857542,
-0.0048804232,
-0.0079930117,
-0.0107362578,
0.0085758008,
-0.0470989868,
0.0290653333,
0.0025246912,
0.0158397239,
0.0001805736,
-0.1032327637,
-0.0200089999,
-0.0329919532,
-0.0154035632,
0.0877248943,
0.0130424248,
-0.0618927963,
0.0547335222,
0.0258475859,
0.078143172,
-0.0263531059,
-0.0384250432,
-0.0266400147,
-0.0302508138,
-0.0168830715,
-0.0016007882,
-0.0267210659,
-0.0605727844,
-0.0283711646,
-0.0615495406,
-0.0143175572,
0.0396603048,
-0.002183968,
0.022054242,
-0.0314262658,
0.0155723197,
-0.022020353,
-0.0077861673,
0.0075931656,
0.0630650595,
-0.0086911982,
0.0275321975,
-0.0230872221,
-0.1048806161,
-0.0189675726,
0.0447496735,
0.0066082315,
0.0227981601,
-0.0176970456,
0.0298292972,
0.0033676047,
-0.0300412551,
0.0039340104,
0.0180077013,
-0.005277263,
-0.0198485404,
-0.0007256958,
-0.0293349605,
0.0342048854,
-0.0102093648,
0.0045103291,
-0.0219969433,
0.0321342535,
0.0298443902,
-0.0214816779,
0.0531276651,
-0.0325780809,
0.0315929279,
-0.0303843431,
-0.0175395943,
0.0114067374,
0.0125988219,
0.0460816249,
0.0528013557,
-0.0117861638,
-0.0288835689,
0.0778908506,
0.053664431,
-0.0200504865,
-0.0003776413,
-0.043021176,
-0.0059219263,
0.0042026029,
0.0333784036,
0.0270455386,
0.0319692977,
0.0143898297,
-0.0270878486,
0.1006639525,
0.0583175868,
-0.014777082,
-0.0116665643,
0.0037082098,
0.0119556477,
0.0102398209,
-0.0665464625,
-0.0625081807,
0.0356962308,
-0.0240450781,
-0.0375586376,
0.0005285112,
-0.0184258334,
-0.0373839326,
-0.0428087339,
-0.0346432701,
-0.0106449397,
0.0200474914,
0.0422530882,
0.0459563024,
-0.0244700573,
-0.0137016242,
0.0118637085,
0.013525215,
-0.0574608333,
-0.0107952217,
-0.0157362595,
0.0400755517,
0.0875045657,
-0.0009574959,
-0.002223908,
-0.0490174927,
-0.0123293679,
0.0193995275,
0.022413969,
0.002033527,
0.0090613961,
0.0356242731,
-0.0400892347,
-0.0130710974,
-0.005767982,
-0.0010460849,
-0.0024661077,
-0.0312593207,
-0.0193418935,
0.0283906665,
0.0049806978,
-0.0475299023,
0.0283413716,
-0.0069619701,
0.0109709036,
-0.0645279214,
0.0193857718,
-0.023620896,
0.0260494277,
0.0081892284,
-0.0141003644,
0.0427933484,
-0.0133061456,
0.0882845595,
0.0406913534,
0.0432003774,
0.0625421107,
0.056737829,
-0.0618984699,
-0.0023972942,
0.0270486344,
0.0209924784,
0.0033112536,
0.0009004062,
-0.0548376553,
-0.0021547552,
-0.0075457571,
0.0291868113,
0.0335920081,
0.0326649584,
-0.0275224298,
0.0340195,
-0.0397813134,
-0.0074913977,
-0.0167359058,
-0.0104469741,
0.0076359184,
-0.0307370741,
0.0200845432,
-0.000878936,
0.0181411691,
0.004575504,
0.0187217928,
-0.0071643135,
-0.0563948266,
0.0129875857,
-0.0924042016,
-0.0323254727,
-0.0370661654,
-0.0274167638,
0.0033882519,
-0.0011030486,
-0.0355702899,
-0.0572463386,
-0.0335411765,
0.0240932722,
-0.0230071004,
-0.0481113084,
0.0111700399,
-0.0217500087,
-0.0032167907,
-0.0470956415,
0.0126767782,
0.0036538276,
0.0304261651,
0.0573342368,
0.0274369288,
-0.0680581704,
0.0046420675,
0.0028741516,
0.050762821,
-0.041343607,
-0.0174749009,
0.023855878,
-0.0313389227,
-0.005222558,
0.0960455611,
-0.0032147074,
0.0461410731,
0.0488346815,
-0.0183131509,
-0.0422981717,
0.0176025927,
0.025289705,
0.0000538697,
-0.0753367767,
-0.0179662984,
0.0286022238,
0.0249449965,
-0.0038721701,
0.0228756685,
-0.0966994017,
0.024641199,
0.0226300415,
-0.0827716365,
0.0179732572,
0.030639505,
-0.0234642364,
0.0439322591,
-0.0037014959,
-0.0649988502,
0.025392428,
-0.0470513031,
-0.0590832569,
0.0352410264,
0.0222049616,
0.0134803327,
0.0512414649,
0.0164688434,
-0.007077246,
-0.0106752394,
0.0129702883,
-0.0072702686,
0.028007092,
-0.0656265691,
-0.0167648699,
0.0765648112,
-0.0515820906,
-0.023587171,
0.0076988162,
0.0094481828,
-0.0460010655,
-0.0002732785,
-0.0593349636,
-0.0391297117,
-0.0427110121,
-0.0187354721,
-0.0646957308,
0.0227249227,
0.0276292898,
0.0261877347,
0.0058822823,
-0.0310095418,
-0.0120427385,
-0.0391307995,
0.0820169449,
0.0465517156,
-0.0530862398,
-0.0192389041,
-0.0492707975,
0.0793664381,
0.0419114456,
-0.0158619788,
-0.0781517774,
0.0023815527,
0.0626698285,
0.0119417012,
0.0046989862,
0.0421874598,
0.0310934093,
-0.0417253636,
0.0216940045,
0.0805454254,
0.025637133,
-0.0144462707,
0.0108606368,
0.0094269523,
0.0419604257,
0.0280735102,
0.0190075431,
-0.0626138449,
-0.0303693339,
-0.0030783548,
0.0219168756,
0.0641927794,
-0.0015501985,
-0.0137473103,
-0.0374903977,
0.0453363247,
0.0182002485,
0.0034766293,
-0.0289170388,
0.0240583271,
0.0499283038,
-0.0494535118,
-0.0292805023,
0.0072368747,
-0.0477563776,
0.0202264525,
0.0100628352,
0.0312874913,
0.0454903059,
0.0246820096,
-0.0248158332,
0.0229882691,
0.0545797832,
0.0328250788,
0.0188220851,
-0.0578508861,
-0.0712960511,
0.0069695381,
0.0132235987,
-0.0088466415,
0.0270173959,
-0.0787236392,
-0.0338879935,
-0.007454121,
0.0472096801,
-0.0414169915,
-0.019572055,
0.0156650506,
0.0349117555,
-0.0232019499,
0.0296345036,
-0.0305257738,
-0.0252384543,
-0.0279556401,
0.0219334699,
0.0170380566,
-0.0463234633,
-0.0045775743,
-0.0194291174,
0.0148633262,
-0.004481391,
-0.074489288,
0.0105633764,
0.0346277691,
-0.068352364,
-0.0269486252,
-0.0791898295,
0.0416756719,
0.0291436333,
0.0120982872,
-0.0486840867,
0.046875041,
0.0317163952,
-0.0314472392,
0.0887833759,
-0.0158892088,
0.0050241495,
-0.0330262892,
-0.0229014866,
-0.0138754286,
-0.0764136314,
0.001977718,
0.0482105203,
-0.0709893033,
-0.0450497419,
0.0075642774,
0.0710994452,
0.0222417694,
0.0564753003,
-0.0281344838,
-0.0279797111,
0.0009262763,
-0.0259387679,
-0.002896725,
0.0254003853,
0.0098197144,
-0.0019031999,
0.0036479775,
0.0130793313,
-0.0581937023,
-0.0020006271,
-0.0094136083,
-0.0065377364,
-0.0336040221,
-0.0751564279,
0.042917911,
0.0031775995,
0.0801634341,
-0.0376068503,
0.0100911977,
-0.0171582438,
-0.0081694834,
0.0059967581,
0.007984885,
-0.0891308561,
0.006990192,
0.0144241061,
0.0326917507,
0.0035409597,
-0.0380948186,
-0.0330869034,
-0.0167910028,
-0.0835807994,
0.0048996336,
-0.0084494455,
-0.024947118,
0.0038055282,
0.0049888706,
0.006196212,
0.0192949921,
-0.0391467474,
0.0680536926,
0.0329871476,
0.0352653563,
0.0111185424,
-0.033792492,
-0.0085294433,
0.0719054937,
-0.0155548416,
-0.0375843495,
-0.0000062136,
0.0168000255,
0.0407307632,
-0.0371012427,
0.0430748612,
-0.0189419147,
0.0296416115,
-0.0243705306,
0.0541388281,
0.0064756246,
-0.0371623188,
-0.0100162048,
0.0157115571,
-0.0320071653,
-0.0285126399,
0.0201292019,
0.0151126496,
0.0072976216,
-0.0000025364,
-0.0367380008,
-0.0501317754,
-0.0197482575,
0.0549459197,
-0.0213787686,
-0.0355851129,
0.0494436733,
-0.0439100526,
-0.0547399893,
-0.0089159515,
0.0191478841,
0.0106834751,
-0.0192760993,
0.0731670558,
0.0395157561,
-0.0229153857,
0.0109604793,
-0.0408664308,
-0.0315074287,
-0.0255191922,
-0.0118858293,
-0.009948005,
-6.01440656e-33,
-0.0029894209,
-0.0142063107,
-0.002132111,
0.002006009,
-0.0391596556,
0.017747758,
-0.0190718882,
0.0165228359,
-0.0159674678,
-0.0124972602,
0.0136104338,
-0.004409736,
-0.0040143435,
0.0044618961,
-0.0188353825,
-0.0207781475,
0.008201546,
0.0361857451,
-0.0322136953,
0.0067297067,
0.023742402,
0.00280562,
0.0405206047,
-0.0578940734,
0.015936939,
-0.0133622112,
-0.0164249949,
-0.0174413901,
-0.0057574613,
0.0683886111,
-0.0088825328,
0.027590178,
-0.0003340209,
0.0077013685,
0.0122464793,
0.0344515517,
-0.0189456381,
0.0145341931,
0.0210481919,
0.064230755,
-0.069412522,
-0.007996127,
0.0586638153,
-0.0085929753,
-0.0340042673,
-0.0255190916,
0.0657705069,
-0.0347707495,
-0.0115251746,
0.0211398322,
-0.0368916765,
-0.0096681258,
-0.0316421129,
-0.073439613,
0.0566768683,
0.0936832353,
0.026502315,
0.0175727066,
-0.0385935158,
0.0322986804,
-0.0174567364,
-0.0051724846,
0.1195062175,
0.0559916943,
0.0203394014,
0.0557057969,
0.007933842,
-0.051091332,
-0.0817442834,
-0.0117151579,
0.0170888696,
0.0610763989,
-0.001752089,
-0.0280651487,
-0.0224188454,
0.0278008431,
-0.0174856074,
0.0089377919,
-0.0455725901,
0.1019274294,
0.0333177783,
0.0309405699,
-0.1120353043,
0.0422217622,
-0.0052181431,
0.0008571862,
-0.0335416086,
-0.0117820567,
0.0516273305,
0.0126546957,
-0.0161299966,
0.0378179401,
0.0520885661,
-0.018266838,
0.0353604816,
0.005581344,
-0.0160084181,
0.0222381651,
-0.0038484223,
0.0247275308,
-0.0096876081,
0.0267827921,
0.0478781238,
-0.027145179,
0.0327354409,
0.0114404066,
-0.0271247681,
0.0030645235,
0.0046501039,
-0.013186777,
-0.0125091858,
0.0048376489,
-0.0150432512,
0.0364364944,
0.0781628788,
-0.0015071791,
-0.0487107188,
0.0137365451,
-0.025285298,
-0.0252600182,
-0.0437026173,
-0.0125358161,
0.0027806072,
-0.0199248921,
-0.0458764769,
-0.0097095398,
-0.05859337,
-0.0088660559,
0.0097126253,
-0.040429499,
-0.0290630162,
0.0200055093,
2.801e-7,
0.0012265589,
0.0475791022,
0.0051093511,
0.0055387886,
0.0034112192,
0.0636129826,
-0.0094142491,
0.0824980065,
-0.0147038633,
-0.0423980579,
0.0144064799,
0.0385204963,
0.0612955838,
-0.0579703487,
-0.0526176803,
0.0011545635,
0.038955491,
0.0192338675,
-0.0370729119,
0.0510469116,
0.0261338297,
0.0643507093,
0.0257743988,
0.007622465,
0.0730221048,
0.0037574663,
0.0186688304,
-0.0304012559,
-0.0080659762,
-0.0112729985,
0.0471676476,
0.0025923545,
-0.0512326434,
-0.0105530173,
-0.0049642497,
-0.0022889536,
0.0412072688,
0.0330563374,
-0.071485661,
-0.0097931465,
-0.0397725627,
0.0128813004,
-0.0029674913,
-0.0784100071,
0.0334448554,
0.0075542578,
-0.0040952819,
0.0180944446,
-0.0150383785,
0.022258345,
-0.0083828848,
0.019924935,
-0.0078452006,
-0.0098926034,
0.0151795894,
-0.0497108214,
-0.0278070308,
-0.0470841154,
-0.0655470118,
-0.0475460887,
-0.0439869985,
-0.0118362661,
-0.0554264933,
-0.0197262838,
0.0142046576,
-0.006821115,
-0.0004077995,
1.86572971e-34,
-0.0046895072,
0.0263143536,
0.0023009172,
0.0176745243,
0.0284215547,
-0.017117396,
-0.0173947737,
0.0625214875,
0.0603611693,
-0.0640450791,
-0.0052746264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14845v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14845v1 | On the Use of Metaphor Translation in Psychiatry | 2023-12-22T17:19:33 | 2023-12-22T17:19:33 | Lois Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Providing mental healthcare to individuals with limited English proficiency
(LEP) remains a pressing problem within psychiatry. Because the majority of
individuals trained in providing psychiatric care are English speakers, the
quality of mental healthcare given to LEP patients is significantly lower than
that provided for English speakers. The provision of mental healthcare is
contingent on communication and understanding between the patient and
healthcare provider, much more so than in the realm of physical healthcare, and
English speakers are often unable to comprehend figurative language such as
metaphors used by LEPs. Hence, Figurative Language Translation is invaluable to
providing equitable psychiatric care. Now, metaphor has been shown to be
paramount in both identifying individuals struggling with mental problems and
helping those individuals understand and communicate their experiences.
Therefore, this paper aims to survey the potential of Machine Translation for
providing equitable psychiatric healthcare and highlights the need for further
research on the transferability of existing machine and metaphor translation
research in the domain of psychiatry. | [
0.0344768018,
0.0221385453,
-0.0396363959,
0.0149003686,
-0.0261239503,
0.029687427,
-0.0117029091,
0.0032427341,
0.0241055898,
-0.0276810639,
0.01001608,
0.0101460554,
0.0400123671,
-0.0404149406,
0.0087435348,
-0.094370842,
-0.0040464611,
0.0383909792,
-0.021654984,
-0.0188972969,
-0.0473582856,
0.0506703146,
-0.0391716845,
0.0663814396,
0.0413703881,
-0.0069940663,
0.0409187078,
0.053210292,
0.0289227571,
-0.031533964,
-0.086135,
-0.022437878,
0.0113953147,
-0.0076392828,
0.0000017633,
-0.0125481403,
0.0212258864,
0.0064763417,
0.0348408632,
-0.0816731751,
0.0858677328,
-0.1146180034,
0.0076304059,
-0.0139598744,
0.0197435375,
-0.0061915242,
0.0294866115,
0.0562399551,
0.0129461093,
0.009526711,
-0.0014583648,
-0.0270231087,
-0.0251677781,
0.0025782576,
-0.0249554086,
0.0120955538,
0.0045649712,
0.0334901698,
0.0527201034,
-0.0632700771,
-0.0483043529,
0.070694983,
-0.0248394031,
0.0483793952,
-0.056548547,
0.0267102588,
0.0000566587,
0.0276116356,
0.021010479,
0.0458187535,
0.0695059448,
0.0235262532,
-0.0116757946,
0.0055715437,
-0.0122317541,
0.0290040504,
-0.0080981161,
0.0127631268,
-0.004368261,
0.0285266154,
0.0435602069,
-0.0038418083,
-0.0253920872,
-0.0055961898,
-0.0077085653,
-0.0122534595,
0.0011403734,
-0.0062490995,
0.0159285832,
-0.0494019426,
-0.0563392863,
-0.0382571071,
0.0239629839,
0.0321582295,
-0.0251555983,
0.0286768582,
-0.0409475304,
-0.0830766335,
0.0148693891,
-0.0593249239,
0.0510905609,
0.0640359223,
-0.0178937241,
0.0110921459,
0.0294120237,
0.0324531235,
-0.0138681727,
0.0872008875,
-0.0742755309,
0.0029944615,
-0.0630659983,
0.0062611578,
-0.0664233714,
-0.0176910814,
0.0057990379,
-0.0212501921,
-0.0679786354,
-0.012027625,
-0.000459427,
-0.0212273076,
-0.0197625961,
-0.0095393145,
-0.0646909848,
-0.0050207595,
-0.0225034859,
0.0027602073,
-0.0610460937,
0.016131388,
-0.0426613539,
-0.0524759777,
0.052557908,
0.0166263189,
-0.0542447008,
-0.0335119553,
0.0062305769,
0.0882046148,
0.0154677667,
-0.0115552973,
-0.0281217005,
-0.0211435165,
0.0109077729,
-0.0026419847,
-0.0025813479,
-0.0101562897,
0.0084736133,
0.023992911,
0.0452271253,
-0.0485233329,
0.0281441808,
0.0216550343,
-0.0868582577,
0.0679378882,
-0.0378257819,
-0.0004810904,
0.0041819448,
0.028189633,
-0.0650567338,
-0.0049009058,
0.0270555653,
-0.0127490694,
-0.0221931357,
-0.0290647373,
-0.0095151346,
-0.0238425508,
-0.02961565,
-0.0452881455,
-0.0290768873,
0.004635423,
-0.0221435223,
0.0984285399,
-0.0052386662,
0.0281599965,
-0.0121333329,
0.0613244884,
0.0130399717,
0.0851282105,
0.0318838172,
0.0470346622,
0.0324602313,
-0.008133376,
-0.028248217,
0.0056592906,
-0.0085483324,
-0.0278001577,
0.0303358529,
-0.016374087,
-0.0142158968,
0.0128564592,
0.0149381142,
0.0193099622,
-0.0142477751,
-0.002013613,
-0.0140852686,
-0.0099274693,
-0.0256224293,
0.0199190471,
0.0256146044,
0.0561189093,
0.0060043391,
0.0212899521,
-0.0242126081,
-0.0273024254,
-0.0717346892,
0.0997628719,
0.0255129058,
-0.0192139987,
0.0422453843,
-0.0482160896,
-0.0038826275,
0.0350000896,
-0.0164797492,
0.0332009979,
-0.0153634446,
0.0098968744,
0.0362604149,
0.0439005904,
0.004215959,
0.0087607028,
-0.0731841996,
0.1001569256,
0.00704377,
0.0047628521,
-0.0234443918,
0.0505494662,
-0.0308747422,
-0.0010683665,
0.0107978433,
0.0004903883,
0.0249649212,
0.0164958872,
-0.0250220988,
0.0127165271,
0.008674683,
-0.0551624522,
-0.0448966399,
0.1024054363,
-0.0511019826,
0.0115651302,
-0.0034168626,
-0.092026554,
0.0163133517,
-0.0024541288,
0.0240982715,
-0.0204981081,
0.0257873032,
-0.0707803145,
0.0683131367,
0.0033177845,
0.025591556,
-0.0066797649,
0.0424950831,
-0.0074130544,
-0.0288354512,
-0.0071746339,
0.0497311912,
0.0125337113,
-0.053707391,
-0.0152666913,
0.0467500873,
-0.019502474,
0.0273151007,
0.0190801378,
0.0334982723,
-0.0578549057,
-0.010677563,
-0.0353725106,
0.0219860673,
-0.1099774241,
0.0160788056,
0.0046703527,
-0.0270126499,
0.0533491857,
-0.0265925061,
-0.0254807044,
0.0013275689,
0.0097240219,
0.021519009,
0.0220968761,
0.0022596254,
-0.0212691147,
0.017485708,
-0.0216517337,
0.0292042755,
0.0093236556,
-0.0484214537,
0.0357031189,
-0.028338287,
0.016201755,
-0.0235331617,
-0.0075901169,
-0.0407823399,
-0.055786144,
-0.0091863889,
-0.0533792637,
0.0171274673,
0.049511604,
0.0490672141,
-0.0309934411,
-0.0191073865,
0.0161875188,
0.0497268215,
-0.0235638842,
0.0125803025,
-0.0468274467,
0.0463837944,
-0.0369767696,
-0.0637223497,
-0.108326681,
0.0097048152,
0.0247704927,
0.0609304979,
0.0110625857,
-0.0125035523,
-0.0006964356,
-0.0079690535,
0.0380123667,
0.0135697601,
0.0131990062,
0.0005336988,
0.0191632826,
0.0291918144,
0.0284308381,
0.0692235157,
-0.016048925,
0.0006178754,
-0.0343744829,
-0.0261983555,
-0.0180921331,
0.0334113352,
-0.0350615866,
0.0557123609,
-0.0027845111,
-0.016967928,
0.0297092851,
-0.0516903251,
-0.0134168016,
-0.0139740538,
0.043218825,
-0.0497226231,
-0.0044862297,
-0.0026958345,
0.0207721256,
-0.0067990413,
0.0095211044,
-0.0498583503,
0.0213792939,
-0.0080744717,
0.0099803554,
-0.0629723072,
-0.0288118552,
0.0457885899,
0.0384635553,
0.0175894834,
-0.0431470349,
-0.0292268191,
-0.0489477254,
0.0151023054,
-0.0054535945,
0.019146841,
0.011148965,
0.0022710196,
0.0310034435,
-0.0739160776,
0.0010108679,
0.0026862368,
0.0008908802,
-0.0047138375,
-0.0233620163,
-0.011575385,
-0.0034147343,
0.0253906064,
0.0053526727,
-0.0317367278,
0.0539511815,
-0.0042458521,
-0.00831897,
0.0479451194,
-0.0669896826,
-0.0534944497,
0.0065621701,
-0.0022420199,
-0.0534911081,
-0.0222515948,
-0.0109974267,
0.0584511906,
-0.028934652,
-0.0141701149,
-0.0354951806,
0.0073190071,
0.0136638172,
0.0176877081,
-0.0514470413,
-0.0621378683,
0.0530518442,
-0.0183499958,
0.0215281136,
0.0118172495,
-0.0254465397,
-0.0146948704,
0.0096088015,
-0.026439324,
0.0114490641,
-0.0244389642,
0.0102675566,
-0.0009328881,
0.0591406673,
-0.0264852643,
0.0481704101,
-0.0234582443,
-0.0496419892,
-0.0445389599,
0.0228187758,
0.0248910394,
0.0096047651,
-0.0145495329,
-0.0053752926,
0.0215195119,
-0.0379397497,
0.0007497086,
-0.0479121022,
-0.0168567952,
0.0076734326,
0.0635938048,
-0.0511416122,
-0.0178042538,
-0.0120597845,
0.0218289495,
0.028337907,
0.0552794524,
0.0466789044,
0.0023912189,
0.0254135299,
-0.0091330539,
-0.0181834362,
0.0565480515,
-0.0029553799,
0.0082003875,
-0.089203462,
-0.0198389217,
-0.0706357285,
-0.0255596712,
0.0288798846,
0.0398921743,
0.0355410203,
-0.0415469483,
-0.0156353004,
-0.0137947425,
-0.0631194562,
0.0385819525,
-0.0073259817,
0.0348316096,
0.0015297337,
-0.005341785,
0.0433282852,
-0.0165662263,
-0.0179298203,
0.0243954808,
0.0244257525,
-0.0247358661,
0.0388060883,
0.0218914468,
0.0155118015,
-0.0085561825,
0.0422571823,
-0.0156052979,
0.0205399785,
0.0164554417,
-0.0219035149,
-0.0073247664,
-0.0151921436,
0.0352264941,
0.0045555192,
0.0350434296,
0.035919711,
0.0480779447,
0.0070950515,
0.0327179916,
-0.0124678686,
0.0312222149,
0.0032931,
0.0436667502,
-0.0147188501,
-0.0365016572,
-0.0686019883,
0.0029980699,
-0.03942772,
-0.0232660137,
-0.017883515,
-0.0142724197,
-0.0290227085,
0.0514213666,
0.0080393478,
-0.0172230881,
-0.1007322073,
-0.0822870135,
-0.0668892041,
0.0825840756,
0.0326586626,
0.0110302214,
0.0402134396,
-0.0071083214,
0.0138784871,
-0.0141173396,
0.0035256699,
-0.0296949632,
0.0802620649,
-0.0222714283,
0.0577258617,
0.0242236946,
0.002793544,
-0.0014944415,
0.0128119066,
0.0226997063,
-0.1292094439,
0.0144952163,
0.0024098079,
0.0358669758,
-0.0025773963,
0.0288901683,
-0.0326921381,
0.0349944532,
0.0299008396,
0.0036048389,
-0.0024817979,
-0.0071029919,
-0.0085922293,
-0.0174237005,
0.0140698897,
-0.0336094089,
-0.025708545,
-0.1001176909,
0.0003979565,
0.0044313287,
-0.0248595811,
-0.0026247101,
0.007436506,
-0.02154704,
-0.014051226,
-0.0053152754,
0.0029258016,
-0.0350171588,
-0.0578541979,
0.04881851,
-0.0228757411,
-0.0220036805,
-0.0303780027,
0.0174698979,
0.0317340456,
0.0434683338,
-0.0406779014,
-0.0638572201,
0.0792207867,
-0.0421229005,
0.0303000286,
-0.0277245604,
-4.901545855e-33,
-0.0345717035,
-0.0137495119,
0.0192461275,
-0.052946832,
-0.0125993919,
-0.0240018535,
-0.0465687811,
0.0055123679,
-0.0018562095,
0.0312908776,
0.0298809949,
0.0101179704,
-0.0015460376,
-0.0001825579,
0.0263840575,
0.0305580199,
0.0063819066,
0.0412383936,
-0.0319219716,
-0.0284783486,
0.0022732329,
0.041294001,
0.1074458733,
-0.0319221318,
0.0253556203,
0.005376501,
0.0237260014,
-0.0077201044,
0.0659768954,
-0.0388307087,
0.0029656319,
0.031514965,
0.0309584029,
0.006565548,
0.00981222,
0.0013599781,
-0.0095924875,
-0.0384392068,
0.0734976903,
0.0028134519,
0.0015329968,
-0.0178938452,
0.0447196327,
-0.028226221,
-0.0023354762,
0.0091603426,
0.0314252935,
-0.049571313,
0.0369089171,
0.0213033799,
-0.0357999839,
-0.0343284495,
-0.0197892934,
0.0216366146,
-0.0027076988,
0.0209623743,
-0.0556242578,
0.0586329661,
-0.0478557348,
-0.0036574181,
-0.020003384,
-0.0180240199,
0.0372762531,
-0.0596242659,
-0.0098944083,
0.0119446078,
0.0030518635,
-0.0237106625,
-0.0417405441,
0.0489202142,
0.0374640338,
-0.0085947132,
0.0544872023,
0.0022386431,
0.0378025249,
-0.0261390246,
0.0276658274,
-0.0021159721,
-0.0073392061,
0.0224261116,
0.0465546399,
-0.0084501132,
-0.0141232628,
-0.0146773467,
-0.0438188575,
-0.016632488,
0.0261494759,
-0.0469954647,
-0.0080882879,
-0.0292479508,
-0.0083274478,
0.0236758962,
0.0164019484,
-0.007932879,
-0.0198475495,
-0.0680026561,
0.013047873,
0.0183343999,
-0.0380137227,
0.0099796345,
-0.0031035687,
-0.0183518119,
0.01320446,
0.0046123499,
0.0729058757,
0.0118815964,
0.0255320463,
-0.0646087676,
-0.0412935652,
0.001061125,
0.0035280434,
-0.0057917936,
0.0001823748,
-0.0280135851,
-0.0087158736,
0.0331445746,
-0.0250040051,
-0.0178661402,
0.0286803953,
-0.0297249705,
-0.0696849748,
0.060333889,
-0.0185112823,
0.0298626255,
-0.0646237805,
-0.0150791397,
-0.0510040969,
0.0274706017,
0.0685409009,
-0.0622871183,
-0.0235411804,
-0.0456441976,
2.583e-7,
0.0430980101,
0.0521655157,
-0.0063631879,
0.0266665686,
-0.0188612789,
0.0065956642,
-0.0008331509,
0.036838837,
0.0185712408,
-0.0035575682,
0.0048311651,
0.0411819629,
0.0000735021,
0.0691311359,
-0.0285146814,
0.0217014849,
-0.0309979636,
-0.0026442776,
-0.0471973903,
0.0455354042,
0.0808240473,
0.008483002,
-0.0138910469,
-0.0194105282,
0.0146671943,
-0.0408567823,
0.0078597339,
-0.0604820661,
0.0604040697,
0.0284404214,
0.0283541642,
0.0520083979,
-0.0029086496,
0.0217298567,
0.0374890678,
-0.0269225184,
0.0170696937,
0.0221467651,
-0.0664332211,
0.0073800134,
-0.0065594311,
-0.0000054347,
-0.0085807946,
-0.0183775406,
-0.0051549878,
-0.0987687856,
-0.0441071279,
0.0044542891,
-0.0214533154,
-0.0116223255,
0.088978827,
-0.0068853977,
-0.0468740314,
0.0616888292,
0.0617823713,
0.0198585074,
0.0157665052,
-0.0248671528,
0.0241660494,
0.0320397578,
-0.0248620696,
0.0313349403,
0.0297925137,
-0.0196896922,
-0.0309768002,
-0.0933218151,
-0.0017703674,
1.650214415e-34,
0.0390087254,
0.0270503629,
0.0525951497,
0.0088711409,
0.0505138487,
0.030075483,
0.0305998679,
0.0185347088,
-0.0362736546,
-0.0220471416,
-0.0306043625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14798v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14798v1 | Semantic Parsing for Complex Data Retrieval: Targeting Query Plans vs. SQL for No-Code Access to Relational Databases | 2023-12-22T16:16:15 | 2023-12-22T16:16:15 | Ben Eyal, Amir Bachar, Ophir Haroche, Michael Elhadad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have spurred progress in text-to-SQL, the task
of generating SQL queries from natural language questions based on a given
database schema. Despite the declarative nature of SQL, it continues to be a
complex programming language. In this paper, we investigate the potential of an
alternative query language with simpler syntax and modular specification of
complex queries. The purpose is to create a query language that can be learned
more easily by modern neural semantic parsing architectures while also enabling
non-programmers to better assess the validity of the query plans produced by an
interactive query plan assistant.
The proposed alternative query language is called Query Plan Language (QPL).
It is designed to be modular and can be translated into a restricted form of
SQL Common Table Expressions (CTEs). The aim of QPL is to make complex data
retrieval accessible to non-programmers by allowing users to express their
questions in natural language while also providing an easier-to-verify target
language. The paper demonstrates how neural LLMs can benefit from QPL's
modularity to generate complex query plans in a compositional manner. This
involves a question decomposition strategy and a planning stage.
We conduct experiments on a version of the Spider text-to-SQL dataset that
has been converted to QPL. The hierarchical structure of QPL programs enables
us to measure query complexity naturally. Based on this assessment, we identify
the low accuracy of existing text-to-SQL systems on complex compositional
queries. We present ways to address the challenge of complex queries in an
iterative, user-controlled manner, using fine-tuned LLMs and a variety of
prompting strategies in a compositional manner. | [
0.0288242828,
0.0811545402,
-0.0151863778,
0.0041716266,
-0.0297228023,
0.0189155322,
-0.0326259583,
-0.0015775659,
-0.0014586305,
-0.0251276232,
0.0091606285,
-0.0120672369,
-0.0410216339,
0.0332314223,
0.0273788981,
-0.0508337915,
0.0247079525,
0.0085744634,
-0.0115402546,
0.0444686338,
-0.0166860744,
0.0108871721,
0.0205826927,
0.0017656579,
-0.0117517915,
0.003362678,
-0.0643045902,
0.0339978077,
-0.076519087,
-0.0406449661,
-0.0204095785,
0.0429892838,
0.0290959571,
0.0086937686,
0.0000018868,
-0.0476808138,
-0.0470980369,
0.032872837,
-0.0529204011,
-0.0113758473,
0.0377177298,
-0.0269970112,
0.0505580045,
0.026036866,
-0.0515367016,
-0.0292462856,
0.0327173471,
0.0223071072,
0.0533223934,
0.0711282417,
0.0007677481,
-0.0675767511,
-0.0138091277,
0.005414255,
0.0470309481,
-0.0603339672,
0.0041960925,
0.0009692443,
0.0602428317,
0.0250319559,
0.0243015215,
0.0277521592,
0.0265053716,
-0.0195763037,
0.000957045,
-0.0036933818,
-0.0316873193,
-0.0122041572,
-0.0036006884,
0.0442621373,
0.0162482746,
-0.0115095051,
0.0320755988,
0.0258336551,
0.0097646164,
-0.0005128672,
-0.0454052649,
0.0344171524,
-0.0090334313,
0.0002909589,
-0.0377322622,
-0.0082457773,
0.0114772953,
-0.0175567418,
-0.0404956937,
0.051187031,
-0.019367557,
-0.0553445816,
0.0473521762,
-0.033242777,
0.0461971983,
-0.0377446525,
0.0386661366,
0.0682451054,
-0.0543500632,
0.0346576273,
-0.0291956104,
-0.0150098847,
0.0028930006,
-0.0289923754,
0.0176695734,
0.0599635616,
0.0130563574,
0.0484724455,
-0.0082696648,
0.0165536497,
0.0192108396,
0.0421066433,
-0.0543456972,
-0.0236471985,
-0.0714528635,
-0.0003156885,
-0.0706219003,
0.040667735,
-0.0888199955,
-0.0009888267,
-0.0008327755,
0.030280875,
0.0215698611,
0.0446566083,
0.0218952503,
0.0593514666,
-0.0231562834,
0.0079378132,
-0.0916768685,
-0.0091341343,
-0.0182045829,
-0.0368766114,
0.0076027638,
-0.0869673789,
-0.022964105,
0.0059125391,
0.0232626963,
-0.0166441556,
0.0075020888,
0.0614121296,
-0.0186260771,
0.0228144079,
-0.0826081336,
-0.0686803609,
0.0256179683,
0.0098344004,
0.0319167748,
-0.0252394583,
0.0789442286,
-0.0177154802,
-0.054161936,
-0.0354515389,
-0.0078505231,
0.0826242194,
0.0081429686,
0.0623822771,
-0.0192232449,
0.0255581979,
0.0180581138,
-0.0102530299,
0.0067012757,
0.0716932788,
0.0146353701,
0.022144394,
0.0125364829,
0.0273439027,
-0.0030107729,
-0.0046954625,
0.0216164589,
-0.0123706199,
-0.0508443452,
0.0741005465,
-0.0194056276,
0.0478788242,
-0.0390082859,
0.0701283142,
-0.0210066587,
-0.0108091654,
-0.0169763137,
0.0240446255,
0.0507126302,
0.0118548963,
0.0553758927,
0.0289246682,
0.0024326593,
-0.0161452107,
-0.0463338234,
0.0334781744,
-0.0200722441,
0.0039236764,
-0.0243340414,
-0.0377711765,
-0.0322688743,
-0.0662239864,
-0.0008722356,
0.0073305112,
0.0343414731,
0.0218279287,
0.003902802,
0.0176989604,
-0.0287557412,
-0.0016002578,
-0.0242293347,
-0.0413549468,
0.0201312266,
-0.0273133349,
-0.009331895,
0.0741343945,
0.0128152566,
-0.0582566969,
0.0057521649,
0.0079815267,
0.0060024131,
0.0248737019,
-0.0070103919,
-0.03627529,
0.0089011248,
-0.0393428579,
-0.0248861592,
0.0043995976,
0.009831978,
-0.0246543381,
0.0045042797,
-0.0406195074,
0.0211237464,
-0.027766617,
-0.031830579,
0.0442383848,
-0.0130389435,
-0.0367728584,
0.0058762203,
0.0171033945,
0.0161334723,
0.0412700772,
0.0124816922,
0.065291889,
0.0504759923,
-0.0056744399,
-0.0549663976,
-0.0472468697,
-0.0035325594,
-0.0251839422,
0.0091881743,
-0.0373015516,
-0.0137259196,
-0.0570019968,
-0.047096476,
-0.0458852723,
0.0338079445,
-0.0438020006,
-0.0131074507,
-0.0381555706,
-0.0077619534,
0.0071410262,
-0.0611358732,
-0.0697873905,
0.0517591499,
0.0281255618,
-0.0022036843,
0.0261402186,
-0.0579189248,
0.0334690139,
-0.0687685534,
0.0032574313,
-0.0091729397,
-0.0082824687,
0.0200865045,
-0.0090913316,
0.0273211282,
-0.046655219,
0.0049684173,
-0.0507705733,
0.01465551,
-0.0270987768,
0.0324813686,
0.0268821456,
0.0312901251,
0.008292241,
-0.0436297283,
-0.06243838,
-0.0178447515,
-0.0123033114,
0.0026443966,
0.0554821864,
0.0438036732,
-0.0167907644,
-0.0167966858,
-0.0453344062,
-0.0459878929,
0.023968121,
0.0005863471,
-0.0585322827,
0.0185387488,
-0.0016717265,
-0.0080369078,
0.0185585842,
0.0221042614,
0.0108452747,
0.0147410138,
-0.0612159893,
-0.0190719813,
0.0606883429,
-0.0280338302,
-0.0202916134,
0.0148628028,
-0.0111840805,
-0.0438961424,
0.0385567509,
-0.0220401976,
0.0000157764,
0.0149864098,
-0.0617078878,
0.0754841939,
0.0022037639,
-0.004330806,
0.0032534059,
-0.0344819874,
0.0297033805,
0.032612361,
0.0091697834,
-0.040982943,
0.0025080647,
0.0412071757,
0.0536731295,
0.0027311216,
0.0129590882,
0.0751427934,
0.0094887931,
-0.0344112553,
-0.0276165213,
-0.0116190435,
-0.0744425133,
0.0775910839,
0.0137625514,
0.0212682523,
-0.0044768299,
-0.0572805144,
-0.0386095718,
-0.0361364596,
-0.0086398274,
-0.0062490888,
0.0710924715,
-0.0255785901,
0.0029086797,
-0.0072874837,
-0.0071310461,
-0.0229032319,
0.016574461,
-0.0403398387,
0.0491681471,
0.0307275206,
-0.0048435857,
0.0112543395,
-0.0321765766,
0.0087268874,
0.027823586,
-0.0044318521,
-0.0338610262,
0.0043423111,
-0.0438772812,
-0.0148393586,
0.057324253,
-0.0193624739,
0.0072767907,
0.0270956885,
0.0092582162,
0.025311742,
-0.0270139892,
0.0111724343,
0.0169789586,
-0.0017641452,
-0.0190639831,
0.021379305,
0.0633429885,
-0.0488855653,
-0.0614936575,
-0.0161890928,
0.0678183287,
0.0368760228,
0.0210085344,
-0.0044481056,
-0.0021640805,
0.0187397227,
0.0476977378,
0.0806333125,
-0.1002253145,
-0.0243692137,
-0.0160609987,
0.0346398875,
0.0243512355,
-0.0605201907,
-0.0187419113,
-0.1083789244,
0.0287429094,
-0.0528280102,
-0.0192779228,
0.0133572146,
-0.0366954617,
-0.0444802605,
-0.0286997017,
0.0042026578,
0.080601722,
-0.0366272442,
-0.003696386,
0.000544653,
-0.0071924864,
-0.042460423,
-0.0048668026,
-0.0276317261,
-0.0272659753,
0.060581997,
0.0038416204,
-0.0039212243,
-0.0283325128,
0.0348381475,
-0.0028929485,
0.023546461,
-0.037449006,
0.063998647,
0.0015034366,
0.0186408684,
-0.0044465777,
-0.0029602644,
-0.0321696289,
0.0452922955,
-0.0004228193,
0.0811740831,
-0.0478043109,
0.0302804857,
-0.0127115641,
-0.0140358564,
-0.0198544264,
0.06498833,
0.0294545349,
0.02131919,
-0.0596785843,
-0.0298882183,
-0.0160445645,
-0.0902547836,
0.0175053496,
0.0739433467,
-0.027204372,
-0.0058624242,
-0.0376303345,
-0.0300495215,
0.0625988469,
0.0309786294,
0.0193028208,
-0.0070699295,
0.0775499493,
-0.0092162834,
-0.0352362841,
-0.0180634819,
-0.0169242434,
-0.0054194229,
-0.0288116504,
0.0106224827,
-0.0121663827,
-0.0417308137,
-0.0231109001,
-0.0750239268,
-0.0421598889,
-0.0297371838,
-0.0210864972,
0.0226376876,
0.0183047131,
-0.0230507236,
-0.0050398661,
-0.0691393763,
-0.0379775092,
0.0688190237,
-0.0520445704,
-0.0560838953,
0.0080342023,
0.0199290998,
0.0106312158,
0.0541664548,
-0.0580925457,
-0.0133959772,
-0.0410751402,
0.0358512066,
-0.037479382,
0.0357797481,
0.083193846,
0.0716412067,
0.0012399928,
0.0556487106,
-0.007171121,
-0.0052764211,
0.0264570899,
-0.0829363018,
-0.0525116958,
-0.0623610541,
0.0219022948,
0.0039948751,
0.012468297,
0.043633882,
-0.0326164588,
-0.0252802856,
0.0358085521,
-0.0133864339,
0.0199477747,
0.0420043655,
-0.0222141743,
-0.0023517103,
0.001686705,
0.0021736084,
0.036398638,
-0.010393911,
0.0523294583,
-0.0206860676,
-0.0099600935,
0.0460373871,
0.0119692748,
-0.0594504401,
-0.023947563,
-0.0473693125,
-0.0728313625,
0.0505444556,
-0.031055307,
-0.0138966627,
0.0184696224,
-0.0323425159,
-0.0165762492,
-0.0024715262,
0.0134204039,
0.0034987682,
0.0401943624,
-0.0233877525,
0.0588620193,
0.0285050143,
-0.0105712758,
-0.0709688216,
0.0471791662,
-0.0029185123,
-0.0063406075,
-0.0173407868,
-0.038850572,
-0.0384909958,
-0.0338074043,
0.0374994166,
0.0301679671,
-0.0456476584,
-0.0586803295,
-0.0263146386,
-0.0065058451,
0.0116546415,
0.0307603106,
-0.0180053171,
-0.0081776008,
0.0847488791,
0.0536532365,
0.0539739616,
-0.0355610438,
-0.0102635995,
-0.0032450571,
-0.0309114847,
-0.0512501486,
-0.0024512964,
-5.956302609e-33,
-0.0304447692,
-0.0252690036,
0.0673269406,
-0.0295838285,
0.0100809233,
-0.0313026682,
-0.0441010557,
-0.0200275015,
-0.0553269051,
-0.0126944538,
-0.0409325622,
0.0152553665,
0.0283773728,
0.0256482027,
0.0345855653,
-0.0556129105,
0.0313208848,
-0.0221024193,
0.0169534683,
-0.0248042103,
0.0323097818,
0.027352836,
-0.0009419467,
-0.0175303705,
0.0162643548,
0.0257953294,
-0.002831788,
0.0764011443,
-0.0041306806,
0.0382171385,
-0.0056672175,
0.0098322332,
0.0218076371,
0.0164448656,
-0.0131799551,
0.0084488885,
-0.0723888204,
-0.0527178347,
0.0161262788,
-0.0077641117,
-0.0301564168,
0.0012517781,
0.0900673121,
-0.0450728238,
-0.0056252927,
0.0119741932,
0.0152231976,
0.009649883,
-0.010074717,
-0.0328670666,
-0.0096333241,
0.0131424125,
0.0236311238,
0.0215635356,
0.03336481,
0.0656145662,
-0.0027134002,
0.051785633,
-0.0357791707,
0.0172748566,
-0.000096337,
0.0345373787,
0.016261369,
0.0386519544,
0.0258015785,
-0.0086974902,
0.0472512394,
0.0050256602,
-0.0450314619,
0.0727581605,
0.0034294305,
0.0737907067,
0.0189600531,
0.012377006,
0.0339692123,
0.0276244059,
-0.0864024758,
0.0247901026,
-0.0417261496,
0.0417294987,
-0.0195323452,
0.0190915298,
-0.0494955592,
-0.0608983785,
-0.0309258513,
0.0229914449,
-0.056095887,
-0.0066844388,
0.0255968831,
0.0133208977,
0.0149614913,
-0.002951924,
-0.0050871442,
0.0000334167,
-0.020587584,
0.0114516634,
-0.0047690403,
-0.0328930281,
0.0103550581,
0.0177528616,
-0.0405617133,
-0.0026474486,
0.0236820709,
-0.0065523144,
-0.0044503342,
0.0410416387,
0.0144465156,
0.0401629359,
-0.0441928655,
-0.0035065284,
-0.014771075,
0.0132744405,
-0.0221939608,
0.013474728,
0.0108186286,
0.0341880508,
0.0038799222,
0.0304331742,
0.011461311,
-0.0167132895,
-0.0295712966,
-0.0169283152,
0.023810856,
0.0015894162,
0.0256077237,
0.0148376422,
-0.0003894469,
-0.0085218921,
0.0245475043,
-0.03182761,
0.0098901661,
0.0705558807,
2.645e-7,
0.065656513,
0.024400888,
0.0379100554,
0.0916208997,
-0.0298190415,
0.0007143054,
0.0154155837,
-0.0015120414,
-0.0180940237,
-0.0358663388,
0.0291241594,
-0.0095455842,
0.0134087289,
0.0582850277,
-0.0737080947,
-0.0074433344,
-0.0157050509,
-0.0574691109,
-0.0593267269,
0.0052776975,
0.0985339135,
0.0518030189,
-0.0300234277,
0.022800589,
-0.0040024268,
-0.0556602105,
-0.0059742979,
0.0028912276,
0.0005984246,
0.037012741,
0.0114914794,
0.0112627298,
0.0157629643,
0.0240725521,
-0.0185604692,
0.0258231238,
0.0059877676,
0.0601813383,
-0.0074756485,
0.0162834954,
0.022446584,
-0.0855683759,
0.0041941362,
-0.0134576643,
0.054698471,
-0.0575936437,
0.0183238052,
0.1101400554,
0.0041529476,
-0.021727683,
0.0045694732,
-0.0148299681,
0.0143282861,
-0.0337727033,
0.0340139493,
0.0020405171,
0.0265029967,
-0.0326230749,
0.0060389531,
0.0362109803,
-0.0249998067,
0.0165562406,
-0.0335128568,
0.0416217223,
-0.0241136681,
0.0183548033,
-0.0142013486,
2.523566196e-34,
0.0414964817,
0.0181529,
0.0328132547,
-0.0222239997,
0.0533666946,
0.0228671897,
-0.0149528962,
0.0074151051,
-0.0001286241,
-0.0944676325,
-0.0506357104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14769v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14769v3 | Large Language Model (LLM) Bias Index -- LLMBI | 2023-12-22T15:38:13 | 2023-12-29T11:07:09 | Abiodun Finbarrs Oketunji, Muhammad Anas, Deepthi Saina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG, I.2.7, I.2.7 | The Large Language Model Bias Index (LLMBI) is a pioneering approach designed
to quantify and address biases inherent in large language models (LLMs), such
as GPT-4. We recognise the increasing prevalence and impact of LLMs across
diverse sectors. This research introduces a novel metric, LLMBI, to
systematically measure and mitigate biases potentially skewing model responses.
We formulated LLMBI using a composite scoring system incorporating multiple
dimensions of bias, including but not limited to age, gender, and racial
biases. To operationalise this metric, we engaged in a multi-step process
involving collecting and annotating LLM responses, applying sophisticated
Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques for bias detection, and computing
the LLMBI score through a specially crafted mathematical formula. The formula
integrates weighted averages of various bias dimensions, a penalty for dataset
diversity deficiencies, and a correction for sentiment biases. Our empirical
analysis, conducted using responses from OpenAI's API, employs advanced
sentiment analysis as a representative method for bias detection. The research
reveals LLMs, whilst demonstrating impressive capabilities in text generation,
exhibit varying degrees of bias across different dimensions. LLMBI provides a
quantifiable measure to compare biases across models and over time, offering a
vital tool for systems engineers, researchers and regulators in enhancing the
fairness and reliability of LLMs. It highlights the potential of LLMs in
mimicking unbiased human-like responses. Additionally, it underscores the
necessity of continuously monitoring and recalibrating such models to align
with evolving societal norms and ethical standards. | [
0.0410099849,
0.0734364763,
-0.0287085623,
0.0436319187,
-0.0350109041,
0.0246878471,
0.0347179174,
-0.0111576496,
0.0502292775,
-0.0883309022,
0.0040679541,
-0.0426405221,
0.016227873,
0.0229711551,
0.0096756117,
-0.0330784172,
0.0354341194,
0.0353239812,
0.0590807199,
-0.005874441,
0.0160083789,
0.0469571054,
0.0249473564,
0.0710482821,
-0.0290437881,
-0.0132736014,
0.0563238449,
0.0016763567,
0.0149267018,
-0.0458796024,
0.0427363031,
0.054637637,
-0.0112524172,
0.064007625,
0.000002141,
-0.0715586394,
0.0087213432,
0.0187332109,
0.0395257212,
0.0181977898,
0.0953451097,
0.0009994954,
-0.0118217394,
0.051992178,
-0.0403451324,
0.0068527409,
0.0600390397,
0.0195479859,
0.0287805945,
0.0395817235,
-0.0089257788,
-0.0099795945,
-0.0223485101,
0.0051504751,
-0.0437504575,
-0.0105441064,
0.0245952532,
-0.0087373015,
-0.0668886527,
-0.0318938717,
-0.0004484538,
-0.0030056185,
0.000381835,
0.0092780748,
0.0087797418,
0.0058152867,
-0.0218720324,
-0.0441676863,
-0.0019529387,
0.0499598905,
0.0374318995,
0.0042815264,
-0.0145263877,
-0.036915943,
0.0213493127,
-0.0125179114,
-0.0447732657,
0.0566217266,
0.0075553181,
0.0181541163,
-0.0119964965,
0.0211059693,
0.0092562679,
0.0695864558,
0.0046339589,
0.0726169869,
0.0192930102,
-0.0331621356,
-0.0052720164,
0.0271249693,
0.0179485194,
-0.0212140456,
-0.0060377987,
0.0067362096,
-0.0335638411,
0.0316435806,
-0.0103050526,
-0.0082335826,
0.048821371,
-0.0881149545,
0.0190974735,
0.0202560313,
0.0067782206,
-0.0027708716,
0.0111210551,
0.0151157528,
-0.0025047676,
-0.0253364556,
-0.0139344642,
0.0004900084,
-0.0100397579,
-0.0307905637,
0.0284859389,
0.0085549382,
-0.015582718,
0.0092354808,
-0.0629918575,
0.0073778741,
-0.0452190936,
-0.0212922581,
0.0216317624,
0.0285391305,
-0.0131098861,
-0.0008450302,
-0.0455320925,
0.0665706098,
-0.0333787575,
0.0393358134,
-0.0015239738,
-0.0781970397,
0.0285224747,
0.0333203264,
-0.0241577923,
-0.0370632149,
-0.0127543872,
0.0527856648,
0.0343406163,
-0.0033842034,
-0.0518636145,
-0.0557716675,
-0.0196482409,
-0.0609254949,
-0.018719526,
-0.0598373227,
0.0034300426,
0.0280477069,
-0.0148087842,
-0.0347673483,
0.0112114409,
0.0299186651,
-0.046557188,
-0.0042642821,
-0.0299860649,
0.0220617149,
0.0596584603,
0.0218397584,
0.0120855616,
0.0956773385,
0.0504229739,
0.008642504,
0.0541177839,
-0.0031848464,
-0.0076120263,
0.0331296809,
-0.0141885988,
0.0217054281,
-0.033068765,
-0.0025744392,
-0.035146717,
0.0097045964,
0.0446515754,
0.0524151698,
0.0083735436,
0.0320080742,
0.0938112587,
0.0500809625,
-0.0331827402,
0.0285349824,
-0.0012108397,
0.0243367031,
-0.0151681108,
-0.0385195464,
-0.0273051579,
0.0187229048,
-0.0096181305,
-0.0080885347,
0.028941337,
0.0564323738,
0.0040167966,
-0.0372540168,
-0.0148663009,
0.0160441045,
0.0340777151,
-0.0041626836,
0.0017832562,
-0.0402203798,
-0.0307584312,
0.0444577597,
0.0376615413,
-0.0826429874,
0.0138181178,
-0.0614559837,
0.0162757169,
0.0596219189,
0.0051416177,
0.0112232501,
0.013484668,
-0.0087022856,
-0.0203294102,
0.0792841092,
0.0656414255,
0.0156580694,
-0.0276498143,
-0.0477352031,
-0.0191835202,
0.0151983127,
0.0250901878,
0.0071029305,
0.0206759553,
0.0304412469,
0.0403882749,
-0.0361628793,
-0.0823373497,
0.0321199559,
0.0053115389,
-0.0313227139,
-0.0142440358,
-0.0055326065,
0.0474367663,
0.0407612324,
-0.028539924,
0.0177763458,
-0.0082467515,
0.0214275345,
-0.0030671428,
0.0148170227,
-0.0265319292,
0.0366121083,
0.0200500246,
-0.0444584191,
-0.011799817,
0.0481531508,
-0.0198397618,
0.0052331579,
0.0361802727,
0.0022959707,
0.0160194188,
-0.0275779497,
-0.0049482295,
-0.0344433412,
-0.0015895396,
-0.0437874906,
0.0494970642,
0.0038062464,
-0.0066499957,
0.0162460674,
-0.0423665866,
0.035860572,
-0.01950185,
-0.0524018258,
0.028386116,
-0.0074022817,
0.0409250185,
0.0584022775,
0.0130547388,
-0.0520294942,
-0.0151217328,
-0.1088982895,
0.0016336079,
-0.0154823652,
0.0011576554,
0.0277738068,
-0.0046254145,
-0.0316553116,
0.014458145,
-0.0329528823,
-0.028095929,
0.0330207385,
0.0475004502,
0.010813091,
-0.0287666097,
-0.0067763366,
-0.0350165181,
-0.0114880502,
-0.0360199809,
0.0404313244,
0.0615638979,
-0.003135083,
-0.0395599753,
0.0065519698,
-0.0481092073,
-0.0341788419,
0.0116918255,
-0.0354018211,
0.0226766299,
0.0416329354,
-0.0020038956,
0.0432423353,
0.037075121,
0.0136637148,
0.0266304836,
-0.013253374,
-0.0275844354,
-0.0390366316,
-0.0211541746,
-0.0023410169,
0.0069709257,
-0.0589130633,
0.0281997882,
0.0314327069,
0.0369020067,
-0.0132313306,
-0.0584520623,
0.0355766267,
-0.0892227739,
-0.0431782641,
-0.008443933,
-0.0228989385,
-0.0353013426,
0.0297047645,
-0.0091975396,
-0.0811320171,
0.0113006281,
0.0114274258,
0.0557034537,
-0.059020821,
0.0130019067,
-0.0404994227,
0.0453393012,
-0.0153725324,
0.0444119871,
0.0088653294,
-0.0057425769,
-0.0534884036,
-0.0007648988,
-0.008181016,
-0.0347976163,
0.0338037163,
-0.053301584,
0.0047901846,
-0.0068153171,
-0.0160263777,
-0.0073720254,
-0.0357159227,
-0.03424697,
0.0121474359,
0.0474433079,
-0.0209442992,
0.0076352926,
0.0044669332,
0.0132338619,
-0.0021649958,
-0.0357658677,
0.0035748661,
-0.0016674275,
-0.0263671577,
0.0653951392,
-0.0106267957,
0.0714731142,
-0.0074402443,
0.0044105197,
0.03078999,
-0.0080508068,
0.0167971607,
-0.0216974989,
-0.0169515852,
0.0321284421,
-0.0455463417,
-0.0042665908,
0.0478971265,
0.0638514236,
-0.0490435883,
0.0207310077,
0.1038278341,
0.0058416403,
-0.0744511262,
0.0117925946,
-0.0062938384,
0.0283988323,
0.0203668773,
-0.0067321002,
-0.0732775033,
0.0025534611,
-0.0046550706,
0.0298614986,
-0.0465172008,
-0.017558286,
-0.0126133421,
-0.1420719475,
0.0274715405,
0.0110188611,
-0.0192608051,
-0.0108828954,
-0.0288130473,
-0.0079540992,
0.0009381166,
0.0536126755,
-0.0002136693,
0.0001237634,
0.0010848446,
0.0194199961,
-0.0877981782,
-0.0748369768,
0.0054617324,
-0.0538419746,
0.0690609142,
0.0660209879,
0.0477071628,
-0.037656378,
0.0065871133,
0.0440587848,
-0.019272862,
-0.0053653079,
-0.0203608181,
0.042729605,
-0.036958877,
-0.0006806446,
-0.0818807483,
0.0105567286,
-0.0255172048,
0.0086611696,
0.0175206158,
0.0464703627,
0.0282681789,
-0.0196129214,
-0.0481152572,
-0.0095376298,
0.0008716561,
0.0817913637,
0.0129411947,
-0.0334622823,
-0.0234738756,
-0.0366114415,
0.0011221446,
-0.0035437341,
-0.0396699421,
0.0070465547,
-0.008802426,
-0.0174517352,
-0.0460593328,
-0.0602528937,
0.0085709868,
-0.0279662907,
0.0359984636,
0.0020006397,
0.0431969203,
-0.0167851541,
-0.0242027044,
0.0180519503,
-0.0255727489,
0.0372084118,
-0.0332479365,
-0.0085702464,
0.0023535499,
-0.0186479241,
-0.004264331,
0.0017860521,
-0.0306826811,
-0.0570369996,
0.0193518326,
0.0450604036,
0.0274671353,
-0.0049370578,
0.0265590176,
-0.0768964514,
0.0414708592,
0.0528200679,
-0.0323529802,
0.0259805564,
-0.017370047,
0.0342412591,
0.0003661934,
0.0156590585,
-0.0446916856,
-0.0081740934,
0.0051785717,
0.0222695973,
0.017165618,
-0.0463476144,
0.0106001589,
0.020787349,
0.0121335033,
-0.0572332479,
0.0109044528,
-0.0390076414,
-0.041920498,
-0.0366223194,
-0.0456824675,
-0.0340448506,
-0.0206685737,
0.0195356514,
0.0297699403,
-0.0431041531,
-0.0090398099,
-0.0398606397,
0.0074082902,
-0.0494378433,
0.0426195748,
-0.0261844378,
0.0436012708,
-0.0023706935,
-0.0136616789,
-0.0382899567,
-0.0156035414,
-0.0474994481,
0.0102174468,
0.0351221301,
0.0623894148,
0.0085820546,
0.006339943,
0.009141719,
0.0369037986,
-0.0271533541,
-0.033919286,
-0.0132994605,
-0.0029077474,
0.0330075808,
-0.0177130625,
0.0879761353,
-0.0115905246,
0.0048908163,
-0.0030554109,
0.0146833165,
0.0119476523,
-0.0250803139,
0.0294793956,
-0.0188625194,
-0.051356107,
-0.0160572305,
0.0903117582,
0.0180884339,
0.0366207138,
-0.0225150604,
-0.0232980009,
-0.0062743491,
-0.0486717708,
0.0468413942,
-0.0081184581,
-0.03619311,
-0.0292679891,
-0.0907656178,
-0.0480739437,
-0.0303630829,
-0.0307695735,
0.0364491642,
-0.0449146293,
-0.0070555606,
0.0609401464,
-0.0207587332,
-0.0404245779,
-0.0402112789,
-0.0307873655,
-0.0772500411,
0.0079404349,
-0.0234641619,
-6.769587478e-33,
-0.0133514702,
-0.0392380655,
-0.0078332927,
-0.0263931341,
-0.0350092798,
-0.0053644418,
-0.0162280556,
0.0347725563,
-0.0289168358,
0.0155889485,
0.0203533117,
0.0002226021,
0.0142164333,
0.0180103723,
0.0393632762,
-0.0151139125,
0.0289170574,
0.0066134273,
-0.0272301622,
0.0130658075,
-0.0003900531,
-0.003791187,
0.0491409637,
-0.0565525852,
0.0981270075,
-0.0154340165,
-0.0196329523,
-0.011558339,
-0.0075097117,
0.0380076952,
-0.0276086591,
0.0988758504,
0.0500890389,
-0.0233409144,
-0.0025156261,
0.0432704389,
0.0419612415,
-0.0024900825,
0.0373348817,
0.0185725056,
0.0510288626,
-0.0342745408,
0.0363414064,
0.0189172216,
-0.1018518582,
0.0128311682,
0.0554156154,
-0.0117668184,
0.0204409342,
-0.018102549,
-0.0772096887,
0.0283502433,
-0.026916435,
0.0476151444,
-0.0454072766,
0.0358463861,
-0.0131634474,
0.0557076484,
-0.0554705672,
0.0186614413,
0.0196458697,
-0.0014172746,
0.0519052707,
0.0174547713,
0.0028178145,
0.0817645639,
0.0261117071,
0.0261376258,
-0.0438053682,
-0.0513434038,
0.0276364349,
-0.0189859793,
0.0281018522,
0.091190353,
0.0138487145,
-0.0353806168,
-0.0498561785,
-0.0066825189,
0.031289503,
0.0344131291,
0.0692493916,
-0.0345848985,
-0.0673324093,
-0.0543856695,
-0.025061477,
-0.0402666964,
-0.0354184061,
-0.0207066238,
0.0631153286,
-0.014201385,
-0.0238055214,
-0.010350775,
0.0372416861,
-0.052520927,
-0.0119767711,
0.0090417964,
-0.0351432972,
-0.0068684253,
0.0039179465,
0.0256824307,
-0.0838408172,
-0.0022381034,
-0.0150491036,
0.0361227132,
0.0216675699,
0.0099489968,
-0.014595083,
0.0097252233,
-0.063245818,
0.0187842399,
-0.0121522127,
-0.0133030163,
0.0292001255,
0.0090780677,
0.012076146,
-0.0112581318,
0.0026811459,
0.0318655446,
0.0254492685,
0.0177366212,
-0.0240928177,
-0.0373311602,
-0.0184842572,
0.0067613791,
-0.0461546443,
-0.0055297473,
0.0009785246,
0.0110954382,
0.0436204113,
-0.0307322759,
-0.0347971134,
-0.0263224486,
2.767e-7,
0.0308894087,
0.0632058904,
-0.0436906107,
0.0163396131,
-0.0080314204,
0.0414264649,
0.0362302959,
0.033065863,
0.0495646261,
0.014391277,
-0.0185873695,
0.0000982841,
0.0215723999,
0.0216001235,
-0.0570208132,
0.0137799783,
-0.0835440531,
0.0299783424,
-0.0686560199,
0.0342407674,
0.0434695557,
0.0593934506,
-0.0100378161,
-0.0021804851,
-0.0375311412,
-0.0135629363,
0.0520482324,
-0.0586697757,
0.0016076794,
0.0176850632,
0.0298000947,
0.0163567364,
0.0262485072,
0.0187258739,
0.0026489268,
0.0170670971,
-0.0001709042,
0.0436867848,
-0.0121072344,
0.014130462,
0.0240887646,
-0.007156387,
0.010086949,
-0.1175220013,
0.0502216406,
0.0020722297,
-0.0545267351,
-0.0840251669,
-0.0181586556,
-0.032013014,
0.0432943963,
-0.0402805246,
-0.0292918514,
-0.0008044557,
0.0112496568,
0.0041457275,
-0.0127551928,
-0.0340876542,
-0.0211937409,
-0.0576751307,
-0.0176671911,
-0.0801891834,
-0.0175680947,
0.0492811427,
0.0079466403,
-0.0260155555,
0.0726229995,
2.586944627e-34,
0.032640364,
-0.0138907488,
0.0228935257,
-0.005243062,
0.0602337644,
0.0451302752,
-0.0103223044,
0.0085141715,
-0.0014712084,
-0.037530072,
-0.0060013831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14737v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14737v1 | Computational Semantics and Evaluation Benchmark for Interrogative Sentences via Combinatory Categorial Grammar | 2023-12-22T14:46:02 | 2023-12-22T14:46:02 | Hayate Funakura, Koji Mineshima | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LO | We present a compositional semantics for various types of polar questions and
wh-questions within the framework of Combinatory Categorial Grammar (CCG). To
assess the explanatory power of our proposed analysis, we introduce a
question-answering dataset QSEM specifically designed to evaluate the semantics
of interrogative sentences. We implement our analysis using existing CCG
parsers and conduct evaluations using the dataset. Through the evaluation, we
have obtained annotated data with CCG trees and semantic representations for
about half of the samples included in QSEM. Furthermore, we discuss the
discrepancy between the theoretical capacity of CCG and the capabilities of
existing CCG parsers. | [
0.0578412749,
0.0303231347,
-0.0164822508,
0.0181125216,
-0.0492847525,
0.0538609922,
-0.0208229627,
-0.0151955923,
-0.0470471084,
-0.0569703914,
-0.0157320686,
-0.0129529862,
-0.0254174694,
-0.0253132228,
-0.0008910327,
-0.0091422377,
0.0429511331,
-0.01865042,
-0.0249412805,
-0.0035060742,
0.0197920855,
0.0280034933,
-0.0264791679,
0.032318417,
-0.0148728788,
-0.0217597485,
-0.0416685678,
0.0080164736,
-0.0085010463,
-0.0427080654,
0.0251338277,
0.0127079943,
-0.0009737656,
0.0091540972,
0.0000018633,
-0.0688373297,
-0.0259202961,
0.0204400569,
-0.0259346105,
-0.0658569783,
0.0807463303,
-0.0033543988,
0.0303809438,
0.0029541424,
-0.0581937879,
-0.0071021784,
0.0337771662,
0.007060043,
0.0691715255,
0.0621103644,
-0.0003211607,
-0.0717093796,
0.0081948591,
0.0243805144,
0.0096600438,
0.0005646877,
0.010372337,
0.0185016114,
0.0175970364,
-0.0316731967,
-0.0240631048,
0.009802863,
0.0544747859,
0.0058311797,
-0.0244076308,
0.0134784281,
-0.0507671796,
0.0246443246,
0.012305323,
0.0396908596,
0.0359270796,
-0.0426248647,
0.008065667,
0.0156160453,
0.0079819988,
-0.0267163031,
-0.0329214372,
0.0754981712,
-0.0380968489,
-0.009667024,
0.0542330258,
0.011165997,
-0.0390789397,
-0.0118162353,
-0.0287567433,
0.0906252861,
0.026528256,
-0.0513232239,
0.0088732615,
0.0018828535,
0.0127951419,
-0.0540013798,
-0.0129008051,
0.0201516636,
-0.0368550345,
-0.004083571,
-0.0110842362,
0.0165536944,
0.0400390215,
-0.0482365862,
0.0405721627,
0.0455144085,
0.0150158918,
0.0532973483,
0.032433033,
0.035748776,
0.0081013385,
0.0389847197,
-0.0643413737,
-0.0391600691,
-0.074871622,
-0.0415048338,
-0.0577808022,
0.0616471432,
-0.0440044105,
0.036461331,
-0.0175896231,
0.0048824889,
0.0340181142,
-0.0056580785,
0.0433688313,
0.0255281162,
-0.0369469598,
0.029671656,
-0.0406346358,
0.0327432938,
-0.0535416007,
0.0004480576,
-0.0045001428,
-0.0523742214,
0.0253789239,
0.0193327889,
0.01980941,
-0.0513481013,
0.012160887,
0.0288993455,
0.0204816274,
-0.0064384555,
0.00951532,
-0.0362500548,
-0.0428372286,
-0.0246682931,
0.0190812033,
-0.0650143474,
0.0275076739,
0.0293464269,
-0.0132814208,
-0.0003839575,
0.0097293034,
0.0276897252,
0.0354088768,
0.0512752384,
0.0123582706,
-0.0204579048,
0.0004944944,
-0.0377779193,
0.0009567077,
0.0446498282,
0.0260590427,
-0.0039799511,
0.0336627439,
-0.0311835259,
-0.0044107479,
-0.0431298018,
-0.0135258446,
-0.0498045534,
-0.0265460107,
0.0871204808,
-0.0216055773,
0.0064652124,
-0.0143064242,
0.0755895078,
0.0016296762,
-0.0692180321,
-0.0091696018,
0.0110636288,
-0.0162423551,
-0.0170695782,
0.0463267639,
0.012836515,
-0.0032206799,
0.0037501536,
-0.019423604,
0.0271042585,
-0.0273418054,
0.0041310349,
-0.0306378286,
0.0150546217,
-0.0095110219,
-0.0712687075,
-0.0039438424,
0.0360989198,
0.0380512327,
0.0156874228,
0.0108863013,
0.0120445257,
0.0073978598,
0.0387647338,
0.0172912851,
-0.0637291223,
-0.0257853884,
-0.0168962795,
0.038979236,
0.0016076739,
0.0204197206,
0.0081680603,
-0.0446651541,
-0.0067705386,
0.0114783691,
0.0297916736,
0.0357434191,
-0.0186635945,
0.0093130311,
-0.0143189374,
0.0256971363,
-0.0319265872,
-0.0066775265,
0.0187465325,
-0.0220406093,
-0.0021052172,
-0.0031682814,
-0.0295495111,
-0.0201018509,
0.0285028443,
0.087365225,
0.0059077181,
0.0042436263,
-0.0097171916,
0.0320808738,
0.009671364,
-0.0203261152,
0.0557825342,
0.0317434482,
-0.0403200239,
-0.0520343371,
0.0247375332,
-0.0193142686,
-0.0921084583,
0.0224582199,
-0.0612906478,
-0.033113163,
0.0022793657,
-0.0258182082,
-0.028732786,
0.0303403195,
-0.0579367951,
0.0279741324,
-0.0663970932,
0.0010359149,
0.0233113766,
-0.0088706566,
-0.0760429353,
0.0751749873,
0.0319035351,
0.0537593253,
-0.0435317643,
-0.0427115187,
0.0398057401,
-0.0423963107,
-0.0261108968,
0.0257395934,
-0.0289665926,
-0.0318433978,
0.0093507972,
0.0043458827,
-0.0563757084,
-0.0117531046,
-0.0755226314,
0.016372392,
-0.0122572361,
0.0647611767,
0.048613105,
-0.0083369231,
0.0172634386,
-0.007470008,
-0.0280015171,
-0.0178876594,
0.0148298182,
0.0386700965,
0.0651663244,
0.0241429657,
-0.0201212279,
-0.0075721592,
-0.0212694127,
-0.0450027026,
0.0238738768,
-0.00931009,
0.0228975248,
0.0240777619,
-0.0105826836,
-0.0234931055,
-0.010070012,
-0.0012260402,
-0.0318126008,
0.0500360429,
-0.0231013913,
-0.0293446947,
0.0507744737,
-0.0088645546,
-0.0195590705,
-0.0060979906,
-0.0328311548,
0.0055919616,
0.0288814176,
-0.0033157934,
-0.0449529253,
-0.0284759626,
-0.0365526117,
-0.0030747198,
0.0744815618,
0.0180223081,
0.0133035379,
-0.0076992912,
0.0233199485,
-0.0704604983,
-0.0266975015,
-0.0846820995,
0.0262717586,
-0.0034800023,
0.0588986538,
-0.0029625497,
0.0173296537,
0.0704144165,
0.0121851973,
-0.0806564391,
-0.0979343131,
-0.0042727739,
-0.0640540347,
0.0846337825,
-0.0017203446,
0.0028277314,
0.0254474133,
-0.0351324566,
-0.0690008625,
-0.0583989471,
0.0057927407,
-0.0008576573,
0.0015041578,
-0.0314556696,
0.0061284103,
-0.0330409221,
-0.0448280908,
-0.0325967297,
-0.0349834971,
-0.0174513217,
0.0099787647,
0.0192063898,
0.0302178562,
0.0529836528,
0.034357693,
-0.0260503255,
-0.007075185,
-0.0298850089,
-0.0149378944,
-0.0044455761,
0.0724368617,
0.0407056138,
0.0516777337,
-0.0004477691,
0.0840247348,
0.0260642488,
0.068645671,
-0.0143854963,
0.0423395857,
-0.0068812906,
0.018464556,
-0.0129442671,
-0.0257116165,
-0.0279255547,
-0.0131305344,
0.030777799,
-0.081553638,
0.0010965008,
0.0820153728,
0.0723975971,
0.0144800125,
0.0154327871,
-0.0317280367,
-0.0133217126,
0.0375688411,
0.0650245845,
-0.1059059277,
-0.0238737613,
-0.0027584743,
-0.0298618004,
-0.0364852771,
-0.0117205363,
-0.0164547209,
-0.0989984795,
0.0085798856,
-0.0258105919,
-0.0316858143,
0.0037887758,
0.0059522372,
-0.0081710983,
-0.0070579881,
-0.0577975661,
0.0580222495,
-0.0113112004,
0.0399721041,
0.0083918441,
-0.0286349356,
0.0394435823,
0.0346419774,
0.0304501262,
-0.0449281447,
0.0355473608,
0.0284116194,
-0.014179525,
-0.0383000784,
0.0382303298,
-0.0835389644,
0.0008845487,
-0.0249051619,
-0.0312807485,
0.0145611465,
-0.0188958161,
-0.0215566065,
0.0214642864,
-0.0368884318,
0.035904631,
0.0238282382,
0.0569990985,
-0.0341347866,
-0.0028096039,
-0.0107793193,
0.0084214453,
-0.0126971984,
0.0559620745,
0.0388072655,
0.0184569824,
-0.0435959287,
-0.0522788949,
-0.0236195251,
-0.0554175787,
-0.0221140552,
0.0541151538,
0.1011765376,
0.0064106504,
-0.079453513,
-0.0366618596,
0.037129987,
-0.0204669852,
-0.059667509,
-0.0028212683,
-0.0193276908,
0.0162119605,
-0.048280295,
-0.0051827393,
-0.0012998467,
0.0257309712,
-0.0263643507,
-0.014022938,
0.0383866131,
0.0011536482,
-0.0684264079,
-0.0315193534,
-0.0225675665,
-0.0334167071,
0.0074737114,
0.028747201,
0.0125201438,
-0.0279068332,
-0.0227328502,
0.0012481055,
-0.0697167069,
0.0800872445,
-0.0385067239,
0.0454170555,
0.032480523,
0.0461629517,
0.0001281061,
0.0291284472,
-0.0155054918,
0.0133528281,
-0.0200994462,
0.0591227114,
-0.0269668736,
0.0027182689,
0.0610658005,
0.0350706242,
-0.0058650747,
0.0194889531,
0.0122003546,
0.0428523496,
0.0329680741,
-0.0447891541,
-0.0346012488,
-0.0464479402,
-0.0310461856,
-0.0005721969,
-0.0178792924,
-0.0271189958,
-0.0362423919,
-0.0505419187,
0.0308300797,
0.0173911564,
0.0367854796,
0.086909689,
-0.0076871105,
-0.0251272172,
0.0302725118,
-0.0270802099,
-0.0352499485,
0.0113099627,
0.0624756515,
0.0069879112,
0.0294538476,
0.0111702308,
-0.0268563852,
-0.0216112938,
0.0112756854,
-0.0434428565,
-0.0214937106,
0.0545505211,
0.0085690636,
0.0139086861,
0.0323234722,
-0.0190133527,
-0.0084018698,
-0.0145749124,
0.0248703528,
-0.0009306119,
0.063730754,
-0.0367828347,
0.1156710982,
0.0262578744,
-0.0294086933,
-0.0465388298,
0.0567775182,
0.0037170337,
-0.0027952578,
0.0334046595,
0.0168812871,
-0.0359275527,
-0.0279082414,
0.0024562969,
0.0126885436,
0.0129551878,
0.0205510873,
-0.0549575202,
-0.0526414514,
0.0010675766,
0.0229385532,
0.013462157,
-0.0226125196,
0.0557874255,
0.033119943,
0.033444684,
-0.0669789538,
-0.0266718529,
0.0477191173,
-0.0520187281,
-0.0139222061,
-0.0375194065,
-6.139640422e-33,
-0.0328743011,
0.0121583613,
0.0111020254,
0.0021910041,
-0.0032341743,
-0.0159914475,
-0.0174090769,
0.0228516441,
-0.0030205362,
0.0119187068,
-0.0253933184,
0.0084684035,
0.007864899,
0.036984425,
-0.0024628001,
-0.060096316,
-0.0094361547,
-0.0292615164,
0.0048671342,
-0.0078800032,
0.0268075075,
0.011161563,
0.0141182216,
-0.0438155644,
0.0122603476,
0.0131164044,
-0.0077679167,
0.0350468569,
-0.0383928083,
0.0563984998,
0.0016632508,
0.0369226187,
0.013414341,
-0.0265740212,
0.0382138155,
0.0229498334,
-0.0429798812,
-0.0588964261,
0.050528612,
0.0188119225,
-0.063228339,
-0.0441692844,
0.0162974894,
-0.008674344,
0.0333036259,
0.0241882354,
-0.0034602582,
0.001357046,
0.0114123691,
-0.0336667635,
-0.0139971059,
0.0048740595,
-0.0108850142,
0.0104858354,
-0.0229804069,
0.0530012697,
-0.013338224,
0.051269576,
-0.011809431,
-0.0178008527,
-0.0276026037,
0.0219088513,
0.0215341859,
-0.0029807785,
0.0114630023,
-0.0063788746,
0.0479102284,
-0.032653477,
0.000074345,
0.0747995153,
-0.056530796,
0.0216959715,
0.0403897539,
0.0543203428,
0.0612842888,
0.0470843203,
-0.030188797,
0.0104108155,
0.010366126,
0.0566697717,
-0.0091193877,
-0.0212550461,
-0.0252257343,
-0.0226622317,
-0.0357075296,
0.0281562693,
-0.0320180878,
-0.0092076082,
0.0644617081,
-0.045843441,
-0.0282315183,
0.0209103674,
0.0256687161,
-0.0751740709,
-0.0059244805,
0.0187940225,
-0.0023783958,
0.0274798404,
0.031542141,
0.0396841057,
-0.0171336215,
0.0209727753,
0.0202875845,
-0.010738451,
0.0390313938,
-0.0070069009,
0.0453900024,
0.0058657047,
-0.0273302831,
-0.0043482906,
-0.0032782843,
0.0123438165,
-0.0719666183,
0.0203999523,
-0.0174652711,
0.0881267488,
-0.0212679822,
0.0184613597,
-0.0165098403,
0.022682799,
-0.0529454723,
-0.049792517,
-0.0223157704,
0.0346831493,
-0.0060822018,
-0.0085607385,
-0.0066514192,
0.012415464,
-0.010336752,
-0.0192311555,
-0.0018347151,
0.02178373,
2.707e-7,
0.0986679941,
0.0198407006,
0.0305642858,
0.0450470075,
0.0130082695,
-0.0147715276,
0.0196342971,
-0.0062256712,
0.0117856544,
-0.0408199504,
-0.001668942,
-0.0124861822,
0.0161830448,
0.0269915387,
-0.0973435417,
0.0267051253,
-0.0391098298,
-0.0189833697,
-0.0421166159,
0.0417638756,
0.1122644246,
0.0759496689,
-0.014977308,
-0.0010645501,
-0.0472283065,
-0.0030403119,
0.0141519289,
0.0132814366,
0.0237185173,
-0.01248834,
-0.0401214696,
-0.0332532041,
0.0355434306,
0.0329709649,
0.032984104,
-0.0048721405,
0.0003378291,
0.0125064021,
-0.0171770677,
-0.0370852463,
-0.0074613476,
-0.0384615995,
-0.0126208551,
-0.0727325752,
0.1090217307,
-0.0850149691,
-0.0111847678,
0.0143635133,
-0.0096433396,
0.0130694984,
-0.0141073437,
0.0015030667,
-0.0252471063,
-0.0159480628,
0.0440453514,
-0.0446111001,
0.0180480313,
-0.022740867,
-0.0079469588,
0.0065695881,
0.0263060853,
-0.0429650657,
-0.006066998,
0.083125256,
0.0118920486,
0.0065003857,
-0.0194284003,
2.099814028e-34,
0.0574381165,
0.015291729,
0.0354982466,
-0.0147139868,
0.0549266674,
-0.0002963762,
-0.038761843,
-0.0270233825,
0.0192584507,
-0.1123674214,
-0.0146717271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14708v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14708v1 | Balancing the Style-Content Trade-Off in Sentiment Transfer Using Polarity-Aware Denoising | 2023-12-22T14:06:54 | 2023-12-22T14:06:54 | Sourabrata Mukherjee, Zdeněk Kasner, Ondřej Dušek | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text sentiment transfer aims to flip the sentiment polarity of a sentence
(positive to negative or vice versa) while preserving its sentiment-independent
content. Although current models show good results at changing the sentiment,
content preservation in transferred sentences is insufficient. In this paper,
we present a sentiment transfer model based on polarity-aware denoising, which
accurately controls the sentiment attributes in generated text, preserving the
content to a great extent and helping to balance the style-content trade-off.
Our proposed model is structured around two key stages in the sentiment
transfer process: better representation learning using a shared encoder and
sentiment-controlled generation using separate sentiment-specific decoders.
Empirical results show that our methods outperforms state-of-the-art baselines
in terms of content preservation while staying competitive in terms of style
transfer accuracy and fluency. | [
-0.0150159774,
0.0740768909,
-0.0074282116,
0.0337630473,
-0.0213380754,
0.0052615269,
-0.0471988283,
0.0001115697,
-0.0398635082,
-0.0129380934,
-0.0345632099,
-0.0293481387,
-0.0216859858,
0.0298437681,
-0.0283366274,
-0.0472507887,
0.0110852662,
0.0485199653,
0.0519768745,
-0.0234093275,
0.0504726022,
0.0133924978,
0.0188625306,
-0.0374936722,
-0.0033867611,
0.0085263215,
0.0105380192,
0.053889107,
0.0263838265,
0.0072347336,
0.0211256649,
0.0193677675,
-0.0062618791,
-0.0533854812,
0.000001895,
0.0080058668,
-0.0364547111,
-0.0219776295,
0.0809374824,
-0.0101480391,
0.1379275471,
-0.0433308408,
0.0065114424,
0.0004301712,
-0.028535964,
0.002923809,
0.0536695085,
0.0812028572,
0.0907158554,
0.0792469308,
-0.0341371074,
-0.0265302043,
-0.0022733957,
-0.0154043222,
-0.0013471987,
-0.0151800569,
0.0115946131,
0.0050131585,
-0.0530483499,
-0.0163233951,
-0.0311365984,
0.0321846232,
-0.0031343193,
-0.0051557301,
0.03271918,
-0.0231310874,
0.0202661995,
0.0310702231,
0.0000276632,
0.0592289306,
-0.017483253,
-0.0261254385,
0.0012554794,
-0.000773319,
0.0013870484,
-0.0267026164,
-0.0351036936,
-0.0133799864,
0.0254989471,
0.0643786639,
-0.0132049294,
0.0529877245,
0.0187730622,
-0.0120650642,
-0.0074291583,
-0.0162263699,
0.0095874527,
-0.0450570211,
-0.0255455114,
0.056603387,
0.0165760424,
0.015714664,
0.0407740772,
-0.0160819385,
0.0542927533,
-0.0167542621,
-0.0493580066,
-0.0365166068,
-0.0420534089,
-0.0361277573,
-0.00128045,
-0.0046204114,
-0.000252047,
0.0423800834,
-0.0275830664,
-0.0205086451,
-0.005676691,
0.0010204621,
-0.0338122956,
-0.027830828,
-0.0372470096,
-0.0115227932,
0.0125931306,
0.0352322794,
0.0085204178,
-0.0157093406,
-0.0153847421,
-0.0629022121,
-0.0536889508,
-0.0307588037,
0.0209547728,
0.0261990391,
-0.01140894,
-0.0398334824,
0.0008043937,
0.0964709893,
-0.0182423294,
0.0448597446,
-0.0082468512,
0.0314276442,
-0.0190502722,
0.0540662557,
0.054203283,
-0.0204310957,
-0.0085911136,
0.0106729371,
-0.0150285559,
0.021332521,
-0.0601026677,
0.007375591,
-0.0027553376,
-0.0317063928,
0.0300722606,
-0.0446404479,
0.0143039823,
-0.0312284529,
-0.0101212692,
-0.0849865153,
0.0082861027,
-0.0045536868,
-0.0260621253,
0.0635705888,
0.0025605753,
-0.0507482998,
0.0024230378,
0.0077707521,
0.0204576962,
0.0496396311,
0.0035090467,
0.0661589056,
0.0138437869,
-0.037896663,
0.0187803768,
-0.0192802809,
0.0658250526,
0.0126315383,
-0.0586266965,
-0.0394679345,
-0.0026891856,
-0.0057668537,
0.0825174823,
0.0660377145,
0.004486084,
-0.0355789587,
0.0834818184,
-0.0548842587,
-0.0291699134,
0.0231348313,
-0.0152402632,
0.04786966,
-0.0472878665,
0.0093818484,
0.002400279,
0.056919314,
-0.0155747635,
-0.0141274063,
0.0299908482,
0.0229653008,
-0.0341416784,
-0.0119859362,
0.0290439799,
-0.0506729372,
0.0563541353,
-0.0492794178,
0.0206410997,
0.0671880022,
-0.0543447882,
0.009569129,
0.0331902057,
-0.0726170763,
0.0272427946,
-0.0058105895,
0.0391446054,
0.0635468885,
-0.0199370403,
0.0221408103,
-0.0074217743,
-0.0236554239,
-0.0321125984,
0.0099290945,
0.0397793837,
0.006433337,
0.0159772225,
-0.0707179978,
0.0045345942,
-0.0192254391,
0.003600209,
0.0040793526,
-0.0306473542,
0.0533350334,
0.0176155418,
0.0077907592,
-0.0016919397,
0.0065089674,
0.039780803,
-0.0126330573,
0.0485608131,
0.0018830409,
0.0380489342,
0.0199859906,
-0.0243455693,
-0.0110242032,
0.0091111483,
-0.04751366,
-0.0841945037,
0.0399740599,
-0.080857642,
-0.0909512565,
-0.0043894616,
-0.0565935038,
0.0083714882,
0.0435132459,
-0.0349708535,
-0.0340607613,
0.0596927591,
-0.0336267911,
0.0167942885,
-0.0129348813,
-0.0086740684,
0.0098977359,
0.0276157949,
0.0064757904,
0.0358122811,
-0.0189905465,
-0.0684578046,
-0.0247174725,
-0.0350259729,
-0.0099973809,
0.0354615785,
-0.0050932905,
-0.0249132402,
0.0164508857,
0.0091852322,
0.0222170595,
-0.0011933938,
-0.0122486511,
-0.0469053127,
-0.0277766045,
-0.0052807219,
0.0040759146,
0.0136993583,
0.0435067639,
-0.0127529381,
0.028632421,
0.0159678124,
-0.0842781439,
0.0115952911,
-0.0242310371,
0.0103489477,
0.0286454242,
-0.0155190639,
0.0183480438,
-0.0360283293,
0.0049009454,
0.0317238905,
0.0094081499,
-0.023277957,
-0.018496044,
-0.0135789588,
0.0403148122,
-0.0075851316,
-0.017102344,
0.0166286323,
-0.059794493,
-0.035620518,
-0.0483434834,
0.0160323828,
0.0419502631,
0.0254683048,
-0.0095988354,
0.0233087689,
-0.0185761768,
-0.0211718827,
-0.0012603172,
-0.0504253171,
0.0596942753,
0.0065274164,
-0.0428003967,
0.0094403066,
0.0311930608,
0.0073236302,
0.0117948465,
-0.073338449,
-0.0038379699,
-0.0043743597,
-0.0104645081,
0.0366733,
0.0159213599,
-0.0094321398,
-0.0169945024,
-0.032895945,
-0.0110130925,
0.0375389457,
0.0052255606,
0.0096815573,
-0.0249487236,
0.0280558541,
-0.0245451853,
0.0358045734,
-0.0203383751,
0.0023289262,
-0.0300754253,
0.014604223,
-0.0126857413,
-0.0303303245,
0.0451545566,
0.0072171711,
-0.0191781726,
-0.0273234136,
-0.0041020638,
-0.0002458817,
-0.0455278642,
0.0182558149,
-0.0298528858,
-0.0017565825,
-0.0004440561,
0.0537868738,
-0.0271408744,
0.0137918275,
-0.0094615677,
-0.0183018036,
-0.0207637101,
-0.0213023238,
0.0118616372,
0.0230630729,
0.0661479905,
0.0356183462,
-0.0024506226,
0.0095502334,
0.0104758609,
-0.0290091131,
0.0458197556,
-0.0563273542,
0.0184429623,
-0.0081238169,
0.0025707807,
0.0202588495,
0.0134102609,
0.0035576583,
-0.0416525826,
0.0854004249,
-0.0338176452,
-0.0162231084,
0.0739441961,
0.007719357,
-0.0759002492,
-0.0297511686,
-0.0024574336,
0.0042978115,
0.0064482447,
-0.0213766489,
-0.037135601,
-0.0431071296,
-0.0233785864,
0.0234961919,
0.0274654254,
0.0044676866,
0.0017532596,
-0.1045071557,
-0.023768248,
0.0222909786,
-0.0200432651,
-0.0634660274,
-0.0139707411,
-0.001629523,
-0.0160695091,
-0.0135145504,
-0.0270372257,
0.0144875618,
0.0085319858,
0.01196652,
-0.0236314442,
-0.0195462853,
-0.013742039,
-0.0079976404,
0.0591681786,
0.0405294076,
0.0576590784,
-0.0071775648,
-0.0612787902,
-0.0139886821,
0.0024105762,
-0.0058251694,
-0.0239601154,
0.0798474997,
-0.006138497,
-0.0042057941,
0.0009504219,
0.011232744,
-0.0503868759,
0.0019215927,
0.0106357178,
0.025671849,
0.0113188522,
-0.0692846626,
-0.0253359638,
0.0239743888,
0.0333296061,
0.0705293566,
0.0410980582,
-0.0518835783,
-0.0284851864,
-0.0134216249,
0.0219961684,
-0.0713566393,
-0.0276943129,
-0.0340280533,
-0.0024433089,
-0.0072240275,
-0.1302874088,
-0.0145013286,
-0.0137006426,
0.0162648782,
-0.0052405191,
-0.0153514976,
0.0027291744,
-0.0434810147,
-0.0156198591,
-0.0419424325,
-0.0052650459,
-0.0014463456,
-0.0040858001,
-0.0285732374,
0.0190930758,
-0.0201934874,
-0.0044890698,
-0.0397291966,
-0.0135467369,
-0.0218239482,
0.0141957104,
0.0764699802,
0.0012903553,
0.0219114609,
-0.0113950334,
-0.0363254957,
0.0220644791,
0.1164847314,
-0.0588766225,
-0.0041425722,
0.0627715588,
0.05829034,
0.0306357089,
0.0433183052,
-0.0110754305,
0.0536277406,
0.0216239616,
-0.000523133,
-0.0043819817,
-0.0262485817,
0.0043680309,
-0.0150205251,
0.0165049434,
0.0375337005,
0.0077832681,
0.0028375452,
0.0020937021,
-0.0417816676,
-0.0151552418,
-0.0516623408,
-0.0038944539,
0.0232015084,
0.0213476419,
-0.0399186723,
0.036727909,
0.0296062976,
0.0340568088,
-0.020005187,
0.0142782172,
0.0402565934,
0.0331260674,
-0.0238997396,
0.0589562096,
-0.0288963411,
-0.006624694,
0.0294736791,
-0.0024677149,
-0.0166436397,
0.0070696305,
0.019517649,
0.0125050368,
-0.0263080169,
0.0041310405,
-0.0260968693,
0.0264311209,
-0.0354390331,
-0.0394146219,
0.0022299362,
-0.0006676862,
0.0893590003,
0.0180944297,
-0.00584837,
-0.0060945074,
0.031377364,
0.0053030066,
-0.0078619104,
0.015086974,
-0.0251522791,
0.0033460187,
-0.0208941121,
0.0611442812,
-0.0786975026,
0.0338463075,
-0.0050539016,
0.0224961936,
-0.0296454206,
-0.0057139616,
0.0473774672,
-0.0023835134,
0.0393672176,
0.0352167934,
-0.0132008391,
-0.0629591197,
0.0504499413,
-0.0596767664,
0.046550028,
0.0014356467,
0.0424757488,
0.0074717179,
-0.0081886286,
0.0052310387,
-0.025540093,
0.0334453136,
-0.0198148098,
0.0084349196,
-0.0267984904,
-6.249905099e-33,
-0.0050887237,
0.0223904233,
-0.047400143,
0.0307417177,
-0.0153156277,
-0.0098961843,
-0.0432940312,
0.0103919236,
0.0199627671,
0.0704378784,
0.0185556225,
0.0364170335,
-0.016119821,
0.0409894548,
0.002944641,
0.024407994,
0.0679119974,
0.0167961065,
-0.0097988183,
0.0534339137,
0.0624563918,
0.0261384416,
0.0571111664,
-0.1287734956,
-0.0262094475,
0.0037728192,
-0.0419234857,
-0.0233639739,
0.0676551685,
-0.019953154,
0.0014101649,
0.0479927287,
0.0190252084,
-0.0351565629,
-0.0267017037,
-0.0050350809,
-0.0168839749,
-0.0412978306,
-0.0156745464,
-0.0099386135,
-0.0160581563,
-0.0382343158,
0.0482661314,
0.0140707623,
0.0180633906,
0.0130075337,
0.0197674017,
-0.0247933939,
0.0240510143,
-0.1064607427,
-0.0708492249,
0.0239884388,
0.0043766447,
-0.0380574986,
0.0328069404,
0.0006093094,
0.0057529202,
0.0234277118,
-0.0500070229,
0.0152206104,
-0.0869412199,
0.0213528126,
-0.0179935824,
-0.0402160734,
-0.0120421899,
0.0646852925,
-0.0507294238,
0.0298811924,
-0.0496375449,
0.0298019815,
0.0110447919,
0.0345938429,
0.0445317812,
0.0880576819,
0.0166225675,
-0.0629475564,
0.003823055,
0.0435438752,
0.0319512226,
0.0323481932,
0.0181783959,
0.0313549787,
-0.0038463264,
-0.0047326484,
0.0013803631,
-0.0740553439,
-0.0142277218,
-0.013522462,
-0.0041171242,
0.0257683024,
-0.0559464693,
-0.0182449967,
0.0091818348,
-0.0413615704,
-0.0203984845,
0.0226039384,
-0.0725779384,
0.0193262193,
0.0055805543,
-0.0293765087,
-0.0481964909,
-0.0199055392,
0.0334389284,
0.0185153056,
-0.0125954524,
-0.0104084285,
0.0909647346,
0.0289971083,
-0.0844479948,
-0.0194361545,
-0.0258765221,
0.0383325703,
0.0170275252,
0.0186976492,
-0.0143302502,
0.0251358058,
-0.0256734919,
0.0459337533,
0.0331379287,
0.0674188286,
0.0152342441,
-0.0126478765,
0.0229226388,
0.0029609774,
-0.065094769,
-0.0368551277,
-0.0157323889,
-0.04834098,
-0.0188545566,
-0.0695997924,
-0.032229729,
-0.0005943055,
2.644e-7,
0.0350928716,
0.0369221494,
0.0108870929,
-0.0264774486,
0.0281216055,
0.0582998022,
0.013563104,
0.0392218754,
-0.0083846496,
-0.0077893259,
-0.0074133608,
0.0412099995,
0.0220710039,
0.0060103862,
-0.0647503361,
0.0417964347,
-0.0237485673,
-0.0001474124,
0.034196429,
-0.0122045837,
0.0890477523,
0.0412746333,
0.0365106575,
-0.0122728283,
0.0468243398,
0.0388606824,
0.0936535373,
-0.0294734128,
0.0350700952,
-0.0095254043,
-0.0153775802,
-0.0599792674,
-0.0324159712,
-0.0272626691,
-0.0032061124,
-0.010267809,
0.0072805821,
0.0604046658,
0.0093941139,
-0.0536819994,
-0.0116552711,
0.0348951183,
0.0090697696,
-0.0103568844,
0.0640493929,
-0.065968357,
-0.0520259067,
-0.1129651666,
-0.0965278521,
0.035541337,
0.0318793058,
0.0198919699,
-0.0269766096,
0.0103192236,
0.0027349868,
0.0493051894,
-0.069713369,
-0.098121129,
-0.0129034901,
-0.0408366621,
-0.0033859678,
-0.0058326521,
0.0076008285,
0.061475344,
0.0094473092,
-0.0076462883,
0.0521797873,
1.84237514e-34,
0.0381977484,
-0.0444166362,
-0.010959819,
-0.0105898911,
0.006149299,
-0.0033789647,
-0.0353928357,
0.0029646887,
0.0271494128,
-0.0297290813,
0.0114485631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14646v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14646v1 | Collaborative Synthesis of Patient Records through Multi-Visit Health State Inference | 2023-12-22T12:28:29 | 2023-12-22T12:28:29 | Hongda Sun, Hongzhan Lin, Rui Yan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Electronic health records (EHRs) have become the foundation of machine
learning applications in healthcare, while the utility of real patient records
is often limited by privacy and security concerns. Synthetic EHR generation
provides an additional perspective to compensate for this limitation. Most
existing methods synthesize new records based on real EHR data, without
consideration of different types of events in EHR data, which cannot control
the event combinations in line with medical common sense. In this paper, we
propose MSIC, a Multi-visit health Status Inference model for Collaborative EHR
synthesis to address these limitations. First, we formulate the synthetic EHR
generation process as a probabilistic graphical model and tightly connect
different types of events by modeling the latent health states. Then, we derive
a health state inference method tailored for the multi-visit scenario to
effectively utilize previous records to synthesize current and future records.
Furthermore, we propose to generate medical reports to add textual descriptions
for each medical event, providing broader applications for synthesized EHR
data. For generating different paragraphs in each visit, we incorporate a
multi-generator deliberation framework to collaborate the message passing of
multiple generators and employ a two-phase decoding strategy to generate
high-quality reports. Our extensive experiments on the widely used benchmarks,
MIMIC-III and MIMIC-IV, demonstrate that MSIC advances state-of-the-art results
on the quality of synthetic data while maintaining low privacy risks. | [
0.0316126198,
0.092621319,
-0.0032842671,
-0.0408792347,
-0.0505590066,
0.0178941917,
0.0171690509,
0.0068022339,
0.0472925045,
0.0134016518,
0.0518800579,
-0.0421446934,
0.0023439515,
0.0655084476,
0.0000320877,
-0.0639774352,
0.0360912941,
0.025488548,
-0.0215865038,
-0.002953147,
-0.0408942252,
0.0294845905,
-0.0147401579,
0.0550931916,
-0.0000356138,
-0.0078394124,
-0.0387431234,
0.037481539,
0.0322477818,
-0.0524424016,
-0.0423661992,
0.0488653481,
-0.0199801195,
-0.0364314541,
0.000002071,
-0.0103684971,
-0.0464656539,
0.0396783501,
-0.0088505931,
-0.046879895,
0.0335581154,
-0.0714805275,
0.0058250674,
0.0274915658,
-0.0324928425,
-0.0626141354,
0.0221961048,
0.0268792193,
0.0546327978,
0.0654684752,
-0.0384103283,
0.0064260894,
-0.0151260672,
-0.0299663842,
0.018153213,
-0.0301787984,
0.0126654869,
0.0042278511,
0.0060884203,
-0.0554405414,
0.004491807,
0.0434515961,
0.010745897,
0.0299040042,
-0.0035194124,
0.0344239734,
0.0260698013,
-0.0017210359,
-0.0044149016,
0.0373451002,
0.0033567054,
-0.0027599509,
0.0687840879,
0.0111525236,
0.0085339285,
0.0169714279,
-0.0013698818,
0.0006930009,
-0.0788749307,
0.0294072274,
0.0077973646,
0.0193576887,
0.0205501951,
-0.031849768,
-0.0072287191,
-0.0365024731,
0.0198766328,
-0.000853933,
-0.0788776651,
-0.0022644647,
0.0350940153,
-0.0545429699,
0.0561357141,
0.0287175421,
-0.0232740082,
-0.0063473727,
-0.0661119223,
-0.0071873441,
0.0369840898,
-0.014376618,
0.0337126032,
0.0051683695,
0.0520112813,
0.0274232533,
0.0306082722,
-0.0465383232,
-0.0254290979,
-0.0006724377,
-0.0424413867,
-0.0093859779,
-0.034184698,
0.0201151501,
-0.0146574909,
0.036060296,
-0.0252915956,
0.0036057376,
-0.0733269006,
0.0305780787,
0.0019919106,
0.0404853523,
0.0452029109,
0.0392128155,
-0.0576353185,
0.0002427106,
-0.0168848243,
-0.0236052461,
0.0008558633,
-0.0078867106,
0.0111084171,
-0.0466173105,
0.0215270016,
0.0092507144,
0.0446235985,
0.0320674516,
-0.0421646237,
0.0394781306,
-0.0018033782,
0.0087669762,
-0.0177586302,
-0.0918552056,
0.0179843083,
-0.0222245324,
0.0055830497,
-0.0295742676,
0.0629442856,
-0.0014848834,
-0.0215331018,
-0.0801052228,
0.0054079667,
0.0077250656,
-0.0204889905,
0.0355513059,
-0.0485685617,
-0.0019943747,
0.0016064963,
0.0255788639,
0.0250509214,
0.0108500374,
0.0400703326,
0.0139223905,
-0.020882681,
-0.0078412443,
0.0497473776,
-0.0068611116,
0.0363413654,
-0.0336740017,
0.0214734878,
-0.0297086406,
-0.018729372,
0.0201143604,
-0.0329576693,
0.0536446795,
-0.0205994435,
-0.0020446288,
0.0538270511,
-0.0137394499,
0.0510492474,
0.0332227796,
0.0353175104,
0.0043657222,
-0.0378644429,
0.0005633527,
0.0093540819,
0.0192445815,
0.0275663901,
-0.0047986847,
0.0277806502,
0.018787574,
-0.0178036541,
-0.0276801866,
0.0041647409,
-0.0642285049,
0.0108931158,
-0.0235313755,
0.0272772368,
0.0205991659,
-0.0459131151,
0.0189869087,
0.019807741,
-0.0448395684,
-0.0078023304,
-0.045405902,
0.0043381671,
0.1106817648,
0.0888390467,
0.019626027,
-0.022295231,
-0.0181155819,
-0.0308197327,
-0.0129550388,
0.0433170237,
-0.0232442301,
0.0503594279,
-0.057145033,
-0.0498616956,
0.059241794,
0.0100505669,
0.0191913303,
-0.0178443119,
0.0091812611,
0.0087136021,
-0.0149886506,
0.0010299149,
-0.0039647575,
-0.0380931199,
0.0066597662,
0.0320612267,
0.0110453507,
0.0644141808,
0.0449611172,
0.0105101541,
0.0456456244,
0.033535447,
-0.0423841439,
-0.019197423,
0.060843125,
-0.0134675438,
-0.0619998388,
-0.0480914079,
-0.0445777886,
0.0244338047,
-0.0164879002,
-0.0413270146,
-0.0422217734,
-0.0208880119,
-0.0392103456,
0.0112671293,
-0.0383382812,
-0.005647494,
0.0888010561,
-0.001397172,
-0.0021662624,
0.0027082837,
-0.0594436787,
-0.0347943082,
0.0026912263,
-0.0099345073,
0.0029547117,
-0.0426763222,
0.0340798013,
0.011731091,
-0.0059888302,
0.0102512082,
-0.0131343082,
-0.015692573,
-0.0151353171,
-0.0251838323,
-0.0887804106,
-0.0102138994,
0.004378703,
0.0247091725,
0.0303086247,
0.0200007111,
0.0055493675,
-0.0309163202,
-0.0543368906,
-0.0243603811,
0.0037497054,
-0.0039555249,
0.0119878957,
0.0252375323,
-0.0251838155,
0.0105101261,
-0.0176736247,
-0.0251109283,
0.0471875146,
0.0213538576,
-0.0109444195,
-0.0658294484,
-0.0484114885,
-0.0375015512,
0.0088073248,
0.0157170352,
-0.0014897482,
-0.0159041453,
-0.0151710082,
0.0513958484,
0.0079396432,
-0.008275874,
0.0291814078,
0.0269385278,
-0.0204666182,
-0.0270448215,
0.0185864028,
-0.0737102479,
0.0344024673,
0.0092515899,
-0.1021355614,
0.0211600251,
0.0065495134,
0.0572808199,
-0.0061047194,
-0.0581814609,
0.0222802274,
0.0167379882,
-0.0134683745,
0.0185342897,
-0.0018517617,
-0.0203998163,
0.0073424396,
-0.0070576412,
-0.0283846501,
0.0746601894,
0.0006646527,
0.0450329855,
-0.0322093405,
-0.0198245868,
-0.0179443657,
0.031731654,
0.0029474068,
0.0394101292,
0.0112042483,
-0.008324503,
0.0051263766,
0.0403168648,
0.0550568551,
-0.0666852668,
-0.0283432323,
-0.0144413868,
0.0008289339,
0.0115324128,
-0.032733202,
-0.0362124704,
-0.0122140935,
0.0330499709,
0.0003124852,
-0.0038086015,
0.0190241914,
-0.0572367311,
0.0317645706,
-0.0456739739,
0.073539339,
0.033212211,
-0.0151142236,
-0.0086676646,
0.0280198548,
0.0087720193,
-0.047520224,
-0.0463561192,
-0.0459395647,
-0.0049011111,
0.0914482623,
0.0416157544,
0.0633274391,
0.0238814652,
-0.0133781731,
-0.0089272521,
-0.01476603,
-0.0076889344,
0.0376529284,
0.0114100398,
-0.0452290289,
0.0152250854,
0.0431696251,
0.0216927137,
-0.0680318028,
0.0276399758,
0.0293821543,
-0.0030302485,
-0.0253215916,
0.0095676575,
-0.0599585287,
0.01139165,
-0.0038960776,
0.0570228286,
-0.0444941185,
-0.0437751189,
0.0045361714,
-0.0233789328,
0.04096644,
0.000090778,
-0.0137420325,
-0.0681993961,
-0.0408421494,
0.0037932089,
0.0149017107,
-0.0645071566,
-0.0154352179,
0.0027971219,
-0.0114665935,
0.0053207916,
-0.0561031923,
-0.0966282338,
-0.0404517986,
-0.0126056764,
0.0648173094,
0.0453575701,
0.0446097814,
0.0194153525,
-0.0396140851,
-0.0309795961,
0.0269667767,
0.0215174332,
-0.0284623373,
0.0946822539,
0.0149850762,
0.0097396579,
-0.0521065183,
0.0473827384,
0.0170585234,
-0.0490965061,
-0.0161312409,
0.0335683152,
-0.062880002,
-0.0494051017,
-0.0348715894,
0.0229629707,
0.071085982,
0.0403639562,
0.005378597,
-0.008117266,
-0.0407178961,
0.0142742423,
0.0890442505,
-0.0664375275,
0.0399825722,
0.0219147261,
-0.0366701633,
-0.0400078148,
-0.0721931607,
-0.0355868451,
0.0251730699,
0.0285590161,
-0.0206922647,
-0.0034896014,
0.0546900108,
-0.0383475944,
-0.0636112094,
-0.0100765731,
0.0100321956,
-0.0123419007,
0.0016715206,
-0.0632124841,
0.0083997911,
0.0279621761,
-0.0126088411,
0.0367686562,
-0.022245124,
-0.0247798711,
0.0113044055,
0.0524295568,
0.0250481497,
0.0066907536,
-0.0076317145,
-0.0058446126,
0.0421360619,
0.0563749112,
-0.0085882405,
-0.0302158967,
-0.0104047172,
-0.0015148779,
-0.0368205942,
0.0035763427,
-0.0027978616,
0.0132402945,
-0.0033814721,
0.0312620997,
0.0080430536,
-0.0537608638,
-0.006227714,
0.0312948078,
-0.0141835287,
-0.0289347488,
0.0271648858,
-0.0295761004,
0.0416826867,
-0.0597974621,
0.0400475748,
-0.0369951315,
0.0117293037,
0.0040538083,
-0.007850402,
0.0229179766,
0.0369362757,
-0.0299722869,
-0.0023448197,
-0.0940103009,
0.00340415,
-0.0117092999,
-0.0049037393,
0.0521751493,
-0.0444757268,
-0.0249340422,
0.0328959785,
0.0191384684,
0.0136733092,
-0.0261771847,
0.0542113595,
0.0201993957,
0.0316860005,
-0.0223647486,
0.051937066,
-0.0415921696,
-0.0222488344,
-0.0445464738,
0.0331925005,
0.0383395441,
0.0859577879,
0.0431190319,
-0.06166045,
0.0100167133,
-0.0262483489,
0.0729507953,
0.0133232921,
0.0000391627,
0.0077735805,
-0.0007849042,
-0.0182286631,
-0.0228541233,
0.0928245261,
0.0085683884,
0.0486651473,
-0.056994576,
-0.0513091758,
-0.0755674094,
-0.0357732587,
0.0287445448,
0.014916339,
-0.0479445346,
-0.0273905396,
-0.0739954337,
-0.0496624932,
0.0648068413,
0.0141862463,
0.0023796386,
-0.0148666492,
0.0443432778,
-0.0003566978,
0.0095567442,
-0.0225102473,
-0.0292809084,
0.037116088,
0.0042770058,
-0.0234127436,
0.0203162078,
-6.308077375e-33,
0.0071073114,
-0.0405919477,
-0.0047354647,
-0.0155851571,
0.0062714028,
-0.0138275661,
-0.0489878096,
-0.0312038213,
0.0579591654,
0.0057854997,
-0.009753786,
-0.0009803259,
0.0318352394,
0.0334364437,
-0.0229213089,
-0.0062264237,
0.0754433945,
0.0055380547,
-0.0285128579,
0.0442670099,
0.0164075196,
0.042374596,
0.0030705277,
-0.0924445093,
0.0014670012,
-0.0008353846,
-0.0347435884,
-0.0324902609,
-0.01377152,
0.0358772352,
-0.0116146663,
-0.010145464,
0.0350422598,
-0.0245044213,
-0.0044211401,
-0.0020311424,
-0.071106568,
-0.0161543489,
-0.013217194,
-0.0621310472,
-0.0564550497,
-0.0412396155,
0.013123014,
-0.0047000675,
-0.0007063753,
-0.0112237409,
0.0061963811,
-0.0030954748,
-0.0514086485,
-0.103258945,
0.0192107558,
0.0526321493,
-0.0049777045,
0.0293667596,
-0.0049094493,
0.032568831,
-0.0194678307,
-0.0253790319,
-0.0276660156,
0.0229204744,
0.0052275751,
-0.024528008,
0.0107309427,
-0.0444645546,
0.0040884563,
0.0292660631,
0.0405276641,
0.0098060267,
-0.0990042835,
0.0501403026,
-0.0551165491,
0.0456440561,
0.0120334532,
0.0647555515,
-0.0008551033,
-0.0419176333,
-0.0665214956,
0.0889651552,
-0.051069364,
-0.0153647801,
0.0676732883,
-0.0112184947,
-0.0344073847,
-0.0121484967,
-0.0350132249,
-0.0101180915,
-0.0053332862,
-0.0226464607,
0.0254014973,
0.0421323478,
-0.0538152456,
0.0367069654,
0.0029546097,
-0.0144092888,
-0.0182390027,
0.0020957084,
0.0466284193,
-0.0194439925,
-0.0549003594,
-0.0220908746,
-0.0023731296,
-0.0200593192,
0.0657490939,
-0.0140041048,
0.0354889892,
0.0132110287,
0.02069287,
-0.0111336457,
-0.0688327029,
0.0020930856,
0.0204695165,
0.036393784,
-0.0253557768,
-0.0306230988,
0.05174141,
-0.0129745444,
-0.0000332406,
0.0251578614,
0.0286507886,
0.0655751899,
-0.035202466,
0.0075310543,
0.0132191414,
0.0256751999,
-0.0131213805,
0.0071669831,
-0.0553209223,
-0.0184113178,
0.0674601644,
0.0028464699,
-0.018581165,
0.0153271342,
2.825e-7,
0.0487545207,
0.0112383505,
0.0366003178,
0.0119304685,
0.0289983898,
0.0028450803,
0.0319110416,
0.0414630212,
0.0083418265,
0.0136393346,
0.0423407592,
0.0073116883,
0.0444054529,
0.0678269491,
-0.0510721132,
0.0048820791,
-0.0570848174,
-0.0009095689,
-0.0301007926,
0.0015904499,
0.0834056735,
0.0218307711,
-0.000685874,
-0.0202817302,
0.0517774932,
0.0335817747,
0.0344933122,
-0.0224049799,
-0.0331161655,
0.0085836258,
0.0556799769,
-0.0246447008,
0.0244736522,
0.0362796411,
-0.0348990895,
-0.054311391,
-0.0294822492,
0.1216095611,
-0.0221409332,
0.0090648215,
0.0458954163,
-0.0335559696,
0.0012361122,
0.0006471801,
0.0689786375,
-0.0582038313,
-0.0325580947,
0.0460126698,
-0.0409542173,
0.012426923,
0.015362476,
0.009984104,
-0.0364645235,
0.0525821187,
0.0099574644,
0.0474881753,
0.0184364356,
-0.0283319037,
-0.0183108542,
-0.0208833646,
-0.0376247577,
-0.0476581566,
0.0515196361,
-0.0146042807,
0.0160466973,
-0.0504386388,
0.010626669,
2.840291899e-34,
0.0397133827,
0.0292336755,
-0.0240481719,
0.0096923402,
0.0249300022,
-0.0354277268,
0.0333183967,
0.0320915505,
0.0204240009,
-0.0676940084,
-0.0411728248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14609v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14609v1 | BLSTM-Based Confidence Estimation for End-to-End Speech Recognition | 2023-12-22T11:12:45 | 2023-12-22T11:12:45 | Atsunori Ogawa, Naohiro Tawara, Takatomo Kano, Marc Delcroix | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Confidence estimation, in which we estimate the reliability of each
recognized token (e.g., word, sub-word, and character) in automatic speech
recognition (ASR) hypotheses and detect incorrectly recognized tokens, is an
important function for developing ASR applications. In this study, we perform
confidence estimation for end-to-end (E2E) ASR hypotheses. Recent E2E ASR
systems show high performance (e.g., around 5% token error rates) for various
ASR tasks. In such situations, confidence estimation becomes difficult since we
need to detect infrequent incorrect tokens from mostly correct token sequences.
To tackle this imbalanced dataset problem, we employ a bidirectional long
short-term memory (BLSTM)-based model as a strong binary-class
(correct/incorrect) sequence labeler that is trained with a class balancing
objective. We experimentally confirmed that, by utilizing several types of ASR
decoding scores as its auxiliary features, the model steadily shows high
confidence estimation performance under highly imbalanced settings. We also
confirmed that the BLSTM-based model outperforms Transformer-based confidence
estimation models, which greatly underestimate incorrect tokens. | [
-0.0138583528,
0.0235835966,
0.0366860293,
0.0348302051,
-0.0312028602,
-0.0025877377,
-0.0022355434,
-0.0419100448,
-0.0182651468,
-0.0233290661,
-0.016128907,
-0.092233561,
0.0428181477,
0.0219057985,
0.0050517712,
0.0175541714,
0.0239169728,
-0.0279808529,
0.0363397188,
0.0000774876,
0.0006731971,
-0.0327375829,
-0.0311394203,
0.0439117663,
-0.0117735751,
0.0156575665,
0.0193342101,
0.0124161625,
0.0288302656,
-0.0545854196,
0.0169189628,
0.0220713355,
0.0242090505,
0.0476610065,
0.0000018511,
-0.0136399576,
-0.049965661,
-0.0032879773,
-0.0718635321,
-0.0508470498,
-0.0240312535,
0.0361801088,
-0.0184476916,
0.0590682104,
0.0308921207,
0.0119418781,
0.0678449273,
0.0606934726,
-0.0213968791,
0.0217137486,
0.0201596059,
-0.0239383914,
0.00613826,
0.0037207226,
-0.0048633968,
-0.0167721398,
0.014234486,
-0.048282519,
-0.0337027684,
-0.0385921821,
-0.0314319246,
0.0396132767,
0.0295188893,
0.0041109188,
0.0056488924,
0.001880156,
-0.0454424769,
-0.007221288,
-0.0216228869,
0.0361366235,
-0.0062869866,
-0.0457642376,
-0.0144539448,
-0.0059440206,
-0.0152271129,
-0.0645410344,
0.0067317882,
0.0556447841,
-0.0263355784,
0.0151833864,
0.0032524811,
0.0430823043,
0.0343116671,
-0.008119151,
-0.0295005944,
0.0224691257,
0.0134259062,
-0.0353231318,
-0.0184572302,
0.0108234324,
0.0214363262,
-0.0161690451,
0.08159329,
0.0479141995,
-0.0354635455,
0.0207958575,
-0.012579605,
-0.0356958844,
-0.0012869058,
-0.0160672981,
-0.0260527041,
0.0253898147,
-0.0791453049,
0.0124972817,
-0.0121503957,
0.0391882174,
0.0776007473,
0.0084782187,
0.009660379,
-0.0362879783,
0.0228950214,
0.0347510427,
-0.0454265252,
0.0324466005,
0.0171290245,
-0.0032233514,
-0.0800516009,
-0.0130732721,
0.0023956378,
0.0270277876,
0.0289370883,
-0.0020099911,
-0.0469800308,
-0.0242447872,
0.0299375765,
0.0398806967,
0.0796713084,
0.0085973684,
0.0068666479,
-0.0808611065,
-0.021123711,
0.0229634214,
0.022971971,
-0.0176128037,
-0.0079685561,
0.0739601925,
-0.0014443442,
-0.094012171,
-0.068930313,
0.0143722836,
-0.0568578169,
-0.0185207203,
-0.031933561,
-0.0559325032,
-0.0101987422,
0.0078650825,
0.019529134,
0.0194635987,
0.0203546453,
-0.021749936,
0.0253606308,
0.0686116815,
-0.0174191054,
-0.0334713869,
0.0289926231,
-0.0143055534,
0.0020485071,
0.014555553,
0.0778780878,
0.0160150025,
0.0482906401,
-0.0240093619,
0.0510130487,
0.0011140871,
0.0076989974,
-0.0230837762,
0.0033906989,
-0.0131389583,
0.0179730505,
0.0183777679,
0.020949129,
0.0631629229,
-0.0111191645,
-0.0057035568,
0.0665689558,
-0.0108524291,
0.0236672498,
-0.0145741301,
0.0017223306,
-0.0108400406,
-0.0299731996,
-0.0088105556,
-0.035036765,
0.0427510515,
-0.0110053783,
0.0339464284,
0.0701505542,
0.0177060924,
0.0059175426,
-0.0344342925,
-0.0424597152,
-0.0337474234,
-0.0500913039,
0.0332597196,
0.0720108598,
-0.0212028399,
-0.0799131915,
0.0702776387,
-0.0294540431,
-0.0291647092,
0.0304250866,
-0.0633017346,
0.0096892752,
0.027580712,
0.0204819776,
-0.0210053213,
-0.0269599464,
-0.0503016375,
-0.0295177419,
0.0210336614,
-0.0187188648,
0.0291357934,
0.0546039678,
-0.0603175648,
-0.0293564294,
0.0937441289,
0.0003602605,
0.0743292868,
-0.0441987552,
0.0430439711,
0.0167322978,
-0.0286020618,
-0.0147890421,
-0.0030447999,
0.0385163054,
-0.0543476976,
0.0508720912,
0.01450596,
0.0558750592,
0.0092914756,
-0.0323142372,
0.0116246669,
0.0555916987,
-0.0063088476,
-0.0514599904,
-0.0103330696,
-0.0743098333,
-0.0268369187,
0.0898804963,
-0.0164475217,
-0.0208466928,
0.0325597227,
-0.0068242094,
-0.0844460577,
0.0127900904,
-0.0512939505,
0.0217592642,
-0.0573525243,
0.0867721513,
0.0278829392,
0.00717485,
0.0124752363,
-0.0363339186,
-0.0094453404,
0.0207692701,
-0.0058658333,
-0.032151144,
-0.0000568953,
-0.0710178986,
-0.0509322286,
0.0239660237,
-0.0315328911,
0.0129599907,
0.01634131,
-0.0035886171,
-0.024061976,
0.0056043318,
-0.0645169318,
-0.0269457623,
-0.058483541,
0.0474794544,
-0.0443981178,
-0.0116232019,
-0.0039504957,
-0.0486944169,
-0.006450322,
-0.0588942282,
-0.0134405401,
-0.0169336665,
-0.0080702417,
-0.0113270739,
-0.0532408692,
0.0023083957,
0.0159270708,
-0.0279585626,
-0.0165351871,
-0.0125813549,
-0.0461712405,
-0.0681019574,
0.0021030605,
0.0430427007,
0.0180929061,
0.0170739684,
-0.0311599988,
0.0041026315,
0.0246077031,
0.0340522379,
0.0104321921,
0.0378679447,
-0.0435766578,
0.0420869105,
-0.0380784385,
-0.0073497584,
-0.008884076,
0.0095714219,
-0.0141145363,
0.0356336012,
-0.0136548383,
-0.0220761672,
0.0404550955,
0.0164800491,
0.0171832256,
-0.000575621,
-0.07812085,
-0.0076070232,
0.0197231229,
0.0016679333,
-0.0254163388,
-0.0413682461,
-0.0183096565,
-0.0108837942,
-0.0111844093,
0.0318507105,
-0.0885480046,
-0.0155246546,
-0.015649179,
-0.024700325,
0.0050697462,
-0.0246434771,
0.0286153685,
-0.0127171502,
-0.0012386646,
-0.0658735037,
-0.0038285935,
-0.0308465213,
0.0054335101,
-0.079450652,
0.0113046337,
-0.0338357762,
0.0055540022,
-0.0196561888,
-0.0126427636,
-0.0494795665,
0.0490484945,
-0.0455760099,
0.0300392769,
0.0081433915,
-0.0343118683,
-0.0407833904,
0.0194651801,
0.0408983491,
0.0618271157,
-0.0091261771,
0.0196461435,
0.0026590542,
0.0386123732,
0.0395951159,
0.01514873,
0.0665875599,
0.0129436664,
0.0131615847,
0.0167065673,
0.0244178288,
0.0236695427,
-0.030883301,
-0.0424447954,
0.0172471758,
-0.0272172373,
0.0390448086,
0.0353354812,
0.0186088961,
-0.0396757275,
0.0104243988,
0.1229149774,
0.0046068034,
-0.0528061315,
-0.0353553779,
0.0026802307,
-0.029136641,
0.0115179932,
-0.05957729,
-0.0445473269,
-0.0504009426,
0.0370422713,
0.0601058342,
-0.0208691675,
0.0040061628,
0.0084031094,
-0.0812235624,
0.0440021232,
0.0136477714,
-0.0512334406,
-0.0898536816,
-0.0592941605,
-0.0293373968,
-0.0486386195,
0.1074940488,
0.0348434597,
0.001347249,
-0.0172053706,
0.0592342578,
-0.1116154864,
-0.0569625683,
-0.0150935361,
-0.0648378357,
0.043051865,
0.0369451158,
0.0082479287,
-0.0251879618,
-0.0188122187,
0.0184397344,
-0.0386397876,
-0.0135887591,
0.0116133345,
0.0247978289,
-0.0476650186,
-0.0130114881,
0.0184722189,
0.0243958365,
-0.0607858784,
0.0206389576,
0.0130119147,
0.0447925739,
-0.0095186662,
0.0122787757,
0.0154442722,
-0.021501679,
0.029264342,
0.0618739612,
0.0222462341,
-0.003639892,
0.005062751,
0.0169132426,
0.0481395908,
-0.0341109335,
0.056978073,
0.0195447523,
-0.0155672543,
-0.0336337686,
-0.0374412946,
-0.0093117785,
0.0297018774,
0.0129665621,
-0.021282509,
0.0372805186,
-0.035829179,
0.0294414256,
-0.0522610582,
-0.0346282311,
-0.0250708442,
0.0776278302,
-0.1093889773,
0.0548573136,
0.0103839068,
-0.054739479,
-0.0117554581,
0.044269409,
-0.0673906654,
-0.0492662005,
0.0111492025,
-0.0016080269,
0.0046461932,
0.0427077934,
-0.0170591604,
-0.0191461295,
0.0798885599,
0.0481340922,
-0.0181880221,
-0.0139697837,
0.0288411994,
-0.0005702007,
-0.0520819128,
-0.0043080617,
-0.0455317348,
-0.0030904077,
0.0129719777,
0.0394085869,
0.0010738556,
-0.0189109351,
0.0093405806,
0.0373489186,
0.1146231517,
-0.022117164,
0.0140236672,
0.006189819,
0.0729979426,
0.049947802,
0.0243803561,
0.0338180363,
0.0357012078,
0.0208362266,
0.0081796311,
-0.0445469134,
-0.0137649532,
-0.0404369794,
-0.0470941588,
0.028127702,
0.0511988588,
-0.0146020567,
0.0171975065,
0.0105873719,
-0.025291102,
-0.0013819336,
-0.0031792934,
0.071723856,
0.036440704,
0.0553015284,
-0.0045713987,
0.0081819464,
0.0330661424,
0.0212731399,
0.0228915308,
-0.0386858918,
0.0244160984,
-0.0421934202,
0.0313105248,
0.045359727,
0.0002679426,
-0.0031330939,
-0.0374423675,
0.0212890971,
-0.0549324676,
0.0273643844,
-0.0480577722,
0.017616896,
0.0159649309,
0.0052445172,
-0.0181016624,
0.0330181345,
0.044934649,
0.0071460535,
0.0254188944,
-0.0240029078,
-0.0281828176,
0.0009367582,
-0.0024041152,
0.0213920902,
0.0127068097,
-0.0349636972,
-0.0450641289,
-0.000459354,
-0.0778355896,
0.0963602141,
0.0392794274,
0.0846804753,
-0.0287248679,
-0.024003705,
0.0277446155,
-0.007388684,
0.0146761369,
0.0169583578,
-0.0283559468,
0.040025007,
0.0135741262,
-0.0256556571,
-6.192054614e-33,
-0.0132292099,
-0.0412464738,
0.0040755738,
-0.0102927545,
-0.0132604148,
0.0264543705,
-0.0121858763,
0.024004491,
0.0238388535,
-0.014771047,
-0.0175112039,
0.0015198539,
0.0458230376,
0.0145090055,
0.0441186167,
0.0038753271,
0.0632072166,
0.0255182106,
-0.0089425435,
-0.0119981207,
0.0471277051,
0.0520745665,
0.0872949958,
-0.0559600107,
-0.0229256172,
0.0181342084,
0.0184846409,
-0.0024829984,
-0.0009089204,
0.0492802747,
0.0112460786,
0.0670073032,
0.0058443896,
-0.0292981137,
-0.0025605024,
-0.0182950422,
-0.0646627396,
-0.0050344784,
-0.0373366661,
0.0714366063,
0.02532777,
-0.0288361944,
0.0333973393,
0.018928552,
-0.0527791604,
0.0098724738,
0.0237508956,
-0.0265663546,
-0.0151054664,
-0.0577263422,
0.0113331042,
0.0400903858,
0.0024985182,
-0.0226636641,
0.009693753,
-0.0062139612,
-0.0145883448,
-0.0106875887,
-0.0653662458,
0.0032139153,
0.0147576397,
0.0152311893,
0.0506253056,
0.0422190875,
-0.0401759669,
0.0259052198,
0.048675105,
-0.0321697146,
0.0314157568,
-0.0334010161,
0.0138488039,
-0.0347921699,
0.0866743103,
0.020317167,
0.0736490041,
0.0019769322,
-0.0253210329,
0.0019067486,
-0.0063471007,
0.0371479727,
0.0257560387,
0.0497709438,
-0.0426615812,
0.0079093035,
-0.0359848738,
-0.0722762123,
-0.0303604584,
0.0013565138,
0.0352388807,
0.0174637642,
0.0015420673,
0.0027730563,
0.0603058338,
0.0155256968,
-0.0196402892,
-0.025054682,
0.041230496,
-0.031272687,
-0.0211817808,
0.0417064279,
-0.0578602403,
-0.0001567219,
0.0353634842,
0.0248343255,
-0.0555170812,
-0.0200078059,
0.0299248267,
0.0265058056,
-0.0486977361,
0.0125507405,
0.0104320869,
0.0198598336,
0.0118123358,
0.0400786176,
0.0403653346,
-0.0262314025,
0.0003392888,
0.0402835608,
-0.0567205697,
-0.0028974849,
0.0023412362,
-0.0040826225,
-0.0228303485,
-0.0051352642,
-0.0328799523,
-0.0057603559,
0.020630328,
-0.0068750903,
0.0057711867,
-0.0246934518,
0.0051020868,
-0.0219219942,
2.722e-7,
-0.0261430014,
-0.0001617022,
0.0539938807,
-0.0350058489,
0.0004409178,
0.0119448826,
-0.0263911802,
0.0189083051,
0.0103742452,
-0.0313285962,
0.0073552835,
-0.0318366922,
0.0469405763,
-0.0022073754,
-0.0668085441,
-0.0496506765,
-0.0328092836,
0.0374465622,
0.0283829942,
0.0135666756,
0.0362459607,
0.0756486282,
-0.0046867123,
-0.0486818478,
0.0205507744,
-0.0290894192,
-0.0019476031,
0.0091112312,
0.0230454709,
-0.0139874313,
0.0347685963,
-0.0091895387,
0.0000393792,
0.0509666167,
-0.0228087604,
0.0124087948,
-0.0156516321,
-0.037051186,
-0.0287478119,
-0.0413357913,
-0.022805199,
0.0913290381,
0.0033419747,
0.0204709955,
0.0278737135,
-0.0293143354,
0.010236159,
-0.0396073088,
-0.0629694313,
-0.0074864575,
0.0122405887,
0.0119832931,
0.0110177761,
0.0220192932,
-0.0231601056,
0.016228158,
-0.0200310983,
-0.0680570751,
0.0198303666,
-0.0203182995,
-0.0415205359,
-0.0422139168,
-0.0199645571,
0.0002926207,
0.0264980197,
-0.0268392246,
-0.0089838961,
1.908568214e-34,
0.0574736297,
-0.0520125143,
0.0018826872,
0.0180635899,
0.0224520285,
-0.0214087814,
-0.0175489653,
0.0079385638,
-0.0178073812,
-0.008562264,
-0.0535098054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14591v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14591v4 | Reasons to Reject? Aligning Language Models with Judgments | 2023-12-22T10:29:43 | 2024-06-06T04:16:54 | Weiwen Xu, Deng Cai, Zhisong Zhang, Wai Lam, Shuming Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL | As humans, we consistently interact with our peers and receive feedback in
the form of natural language. This language feedback allows us to maintain
appropriate behavior, and rectify potential errors. The question arises
naturally: can we use language feedback to align large language models (LLMs)?
In contrast to previous research that aligns LLMs with scalar rewards, we
present the first systematic exploration of alignment through the lens of
language feedback (i.e., judgment). We start with an in-depth investigation of
potential methods that can be adapted for aligning LLMs with judgments,
revealing that these methods cannot fully capitalize on judgments. To
facilitate more effective utilization of judgments, we propose a novel
framework, Contrastive Unlikelihood Training (CUT), that allows for
fine-grained inappropriate content detection and correction based on judgments.
Our results show that, with merely 1317 off-the-shelf judgment data, CUT
(LLaMA2-13b) can beat the 175B DaVinci003 and surpass the best baseline by
50.84 points on AlpacaEval. CUT (LLaMA2-chat-13b) can also align LLMs in an
iterative fashion using up-to-date model-specific judgments, improving
performance from 81.09 to 91.68 points on AlpacaEval. Further analysis suggests
that judgments hold greater potential than rewards in LLM alignment. | [
0.1048052385,
0.0763951764,
-0.0147035914,
0.0271037333,
-0.0586228035,
0.0331345424,
-0.01664076,
0.001008904,
0.0187712628,
-0.039769195,
-0.0841105357,
-0.0509920865,
-0.006435276,
0.0154335527,
0.0204468109,
-0.0413890406,
0.0613422394,
-0.0011634957,
0.070594959,
-0.0043030558,
0.0352647379,
0.000997874,
0.0200923271,
-0.0009524752,
0.0043299729,
-0.0254326705,
0.015153707,
0.0136906682,
0.0509950183,
-0.0110356174,
0.0600796826,
0.057948526,
-0.0069993078,
0.0535760112,
0.0000019412,
-0.0446401536,
0.027069252,
-0.0150732659,
0.0105553148,
0.0334712714,
0.0575338304,
-0.0017389114,
0.0084141819,
-0.002882302,
-0.052464433,
-0.0032424747,
0.0477934256,
0.0641422197,
0.0504990853,
0.0664049536,
0.0099948486,
-0.0168875661,
-0.0116619719,
-0.0169324558,
-0.0010163885,
-0.0125765679,
0.0266437102,
-0.0154444063,
-0.0239039715,
0.0326188989,
-0.0018151053,
0.0251209121,
0.0015513879,
-0.0160641447,
0.0581450313,
0.0302766617,
-0.0073485742,
-0.0460338779,
-0.0104941959,
0.0640709028,
0.0429795347,
-0.0468029976,
-0.0233045537,
-0.0145470323,
0.022347983,
-0.0052397633,
-0.0064500584,
0.0062090722,
0.0263640676,
0.0304259863,
0.0240888093,
-0.0013462693,
0.0279835872,
0.0377397425,
0.0535082258,
0.0439355969,
0.0131754456,
-0.0688675344,
0.0251242779,
0.0338288546,
-0.0408722796,
-0.047707092,
-0.0022826677,
-0.0120041426,
-0.0558942594,
0.0132251913,
-0.050033208,
0.0345270522,
0.0471584015,
-0.0436117128,
0.0259850472,
0.0333281308,
-0.0027691228,
0.0492451675,
0.0005850949,
0.0670444816,
-0.0205772389,
0.0380039997,
-0.0540000834,
0.0045375912,
0.0019136763,
-0.018182585,
0.0339696333,
0.023890689,
-0.0353510194,
-0.0083990302,
-0.0417296588,
-0.0040349732,
-0.0692238137,
0.0254226159,
0.0036483563,
0.041389998,
-0.0225156527,
-0.0036512718,
-0.0691525564,
0.0170998238,
-0.0204600208,
0.0446710996,
0.0086491229,
-0.0435370877,
-0.026947083,
0.0129931848,
-0.0132435365,
-0.0314742029,
0.0161424391,
0.0835999995,
-0.0108626503,
-0.0323552974,
-0.0231234543,
0.0023514235,
-0.0425650477,
-0.0657628402,
-0.0235788729,
-0.0517742559,
0.0134542463,
-0.0149690472,
-0.0179667175,
-0.0465445146,
0.0153750824,
0.0200298503,
-0.0556308515,
0.0724139288,
-0.0159974843,
-0.0083544524,
-0.0217021555,
0.0265040714,
0.0006675914,
0.0381173901,
0.0042738835,
0.0157377105,
0.0278641991,
0.0136661939,
-0.0099834623,
0.0123104928,
0.0196823869,
-0.0175458658,
-0.0649029687,
0.0145855779,
0.0088845184,
0.029584052,
0.0721913502,
0.0718718693,
-0.0129706329,
-0.0439339317,
0.0854856744,
0.0421672314,
-0.0271003786,
0.0245146919,
0.0143772643,
0.0308429003,
-0.0218381565,
0.0311129596,
-0.0892940983,
0.0341129266,
-0.0442059003,
-0.0090450011,
0.0385858305,
0.0071650366,
-0.0399649404,
-0.041302193,
-0.025618501,
-0.0163216405,
0.049178008,
0.0072249486,
0.0011334212,
0.0167071167,
-0.0442594476,
-0.0256060809,
0.0781332105,
-0.0345365666,
0.0117082139,
-0.0439563021,
0.063178122,
0.0731201768,
0.0439695828,
0.0026157433,
-0.0290321335,
0.0046066488,
-0.0603824407,
0.06984929,
0.0518871583,
-0.0329246856,
-0.0282185301,
-0.0490235202,
-0.0351314582,
-0.0212834757,
0.0126793804,
0.0010632814,
0.0505773239,
-0.0165157076,
-0.0044883275,
0.0025087295,
-0.0662685111,
0.0502966829,
-0.0023900978,
-0.0278462525,
-0.0263081156,
0.0076207947,
0.0505471043,
-0.0114400163,
-0.0043781153,
-0.018394541,
0.0169436913,
0.0017322985,
-0.0258495435,
-0.0030891704,
-0.0619633123,
-0.0559984148,
0.0504200831,
-0.0301501397,
-0.0308769271,
0.0812766626,
-0.0446589552,
-0.0059547597,
0.018617006,
-0.0284296684,
0.0372209437,
-0.0200667158,
0.0294055752,
-0.0341928042,
-0.0007717544,
-0.0414549187,
0.0612600185,
-0.0164592378,
0.0422775112,
-0.0183840562,
-0.0235888287,
-0.0208316129,
0.0019584047,
-0.0497329049,
-0.0181454327,
-0.0005137468,
0.0123066464,
0.0322065763,
0.0268641785,
-0.0617034957,
-0.0454133488,
-0.0812972635,
-0.0038441536,
-0.0000782601,
-0.0088679269,
0.0303283893,
-0.0333626047,
0.008416729,
-0.0000323058,
-0.0459252521,
0.005145546,
0.0243640244,
0.0093597863,
0.0410383753,
-0.006877963,
-0.0108976066,
-0.0691805333,
0.0012974219,
-0.0198682658,
0.0164700933,
0.0025123514,
-0.0020130237,
-0.0414122008,
0.0659202412,
-0.073426865,
0.0179175902,
-0.0105082681,
-0.0547477975,
0.0012284538,
0.0654268488,
0.0430209339,
0.0665469021,
0.0421518981,
0.0203504059,
0.0604132675,
0.0346538052,
-0.0689700991,
-0.0080928188,
-0.0145647442,
-0.0337501056,
-0.0302898474,
-0.0604358763,
0.0036843016,
0.0842595696,
0.0256004576,
-0.0062005538,
-0.0743129998,
0.0398383252,
-0.0045659402,
-0.0471629873,
0.0111404201,
-0.05272175,
-0.0256490018,
0.0076899813,
-0.048349373,
-0.0686926469,
0.1225950941,
-0.0034467964,
-0.0019495554,
-0.03064931,
-0.0157310981,
-0.0016269983,
0.0284771957,
0.0103997029,
0.027742397,
-0.0168655533,
-0.0187652204,
-0.0351765938,
-0.029664671,
0.0288416054,
-0.022110492,
0.0518101454,
-0.0446625166,
0.0118069137,
0.00441173,
-0.0419071019,
-0.0727990195,
-0.0630603731,
-0.015769206,
-0.0215223525,
0.0052979044,
0.0028473209,
-0.047932744,
-0.0241742712,
-0.000173159,
0.0109084798,
-0.0206764899,
-0.0012724127,
-0.0054277363,
-0.0077780904,
0.0587688126,
-0.0102471048,
0.0506876037,
-0.0251911189,
-0.0044294186,
0.065440841,
-0.0103075812,
0.0078552254,
0.0113824112,
0.0059457808,
0.0330356583,
0.000961633,
0.0150053715,
0.0099764196,
0.0517372936,
0.0027512603,
-0.0267914552,
0.1015207097,
0.0309294853,
-0.0525371805,
0.0047257384,
-0.0109591037,
0.0333504155,
0.0293459538,
-0.0288801417,
-0.0559596047,
-0.0258082729,
-0.0027342741,
0.0166244116,
-0.0287329108,
-0.0214375257,
0.0038856894,
-0.1083837748,
0.0091556208,
0.024765322,
-0.0016289472,
-0.0482274704,
-0.0138668772,
0.0322731696,
-0.0187988728,
0.0200178456,
0.0162090044,
0.0056786016,
-0.0244246051,
-0.0065148524,
0.0234177746,
-0.03084068,
0.0349285565,
-0.0193542838,
0.1122297347,
0.040492136,
0.0556928478,
0.0139082177,
-0.066532135,
0.0158492103,
-0.0098439828,
-0.0129648009,
-0.0176001489,
0.0326326676,
-0.0207394175,
0.0040917336,
-0.0586977787,
0.026221551,
0.0175536107,
-0.0248025786,
-0.0261904653,
0.0570215024,
0.0024521914,
-0.0404724665,
-0.0386187881,
0.0540142842,
0.0094061596,
0.0976501703,
0.0043970854,
-0.0449461564,
0.0041822465,
0.0137774535,
-0.0263748374,
-0.0004846659,
-0.0267977007,
-0.0129816225,
0.0262812525,
0.015127331,
-0.0677252784,
-0.0460882336,
-0.0342065096,
-0.0176906809,
0.0147257689,
-0.0391107835,
-0.0132531654,
-0.0262083691,
-0.0037475436,
0.031643156,
-0.0481828116,
-0.0143921124,
-0.0221906547,
-0.0048342817,
-0.0116370637,
-0.0088669015,
-0.0266305618,
0.0071961661,
-0.062804319,
-0.0791923404,
0.0057225795,
0.0454595573,
0.0171449315,
0.0619739182,
-0.0073012984,
-0.0269776899,
0.0073475209,
0.0432785451,
-0.0387059525,
0.0394111909,
0.0176960938,
0.0172972213,
0.0175958425,
0.039882984,
-0.0037472809,
0.0060428092,
0.0559977703,
0.0311275795,
-0.0015544659,
-0.0527154803,
0.0438762233,
0.0060997568,
0.0489087068,
-0.003814345,
-0.0097204512,
-0.0612285919,
-0.0252743717,
-0.0062533328,
-0.0502116531,
-0.0096671423,
-0.0367344022,
0.0393737368,
0.0125507489,
-0.0321946107,
0.0104924412,
-0.066412054,
0.0525083542,
-0.0279485267,
-0.0178449508,
0.0277333707,
0.0043370505,
-0.0029204006,
0.0176641662,
-0.0592838787,
-0.0079896096,
0.0052806335,
0.038703151,
0.0034143706,
0.0585011058,
0.0231580883,
-0.0057890168,
-0.0156220449,
0.0053226277,
-0.0385856777,
0.0190275703,
-0.0454730354,
0.005842993,
0.0014763778,
-0.0239834227,
0.0283589177,
-0.0277626533,
-0.0041955872,
-0.0028764228,
0.0190457124,
-0.0313333906,
-0.0467216708,
0.046174448,
0.0182279963,
-0.0255250428,
0.0057050046,
0.0272748712,
-0.0407936722,
0.0226854458,
-0.0027121459,
-0.0126443477,
-0.0273228493,
-0.0430425406,
0.0386913046,
0.0179348234,
-0.0451158024,
-0.0011096285,
-0.0500206053,
-0.0529191159,
-0.0065682186,
0.0339601859,
-0.0045497548,
-0.0189176071,
0.0290829595,
0.0538312383,
-0.0198494606,
-0.0225152019,
-0.0081259022,
-0.0166069213,
0.018654732,
-0.0006249755,
-0.0881132632,
-6.341961735e-33,
-0.0396017209,
-0.0146996761,
0.0031274853,
-0.0083150798,
-0.0495636836,
-0.015304503,
0.0036067807,
0.0208490137,
-0.0184726343,
0.0276183225,
0.0180229433,
0.0308138002,
-0.0006678467,
-0.0082618827,
0.006742829,
-0.018549867,
0.0591274835,
0.0016635712,
-0.0429887958,
0.0052806446,
-0.011957759,
-0.0064556948,
0.0769421756,
-0.0747580305,
0.0740921646,
0.0087909577,
-0.0250006318,
0.0333925709,
-0.0150045557,
0.023935793,
-0.019809749,
0.0502349883,
0.0134023381,
0.0310845282,
0.0132067548,
0.0299298298,
-0.0437124297,
-0.0248179454,
0.0923117921,
-0.000712141,
-0.0181395933,
-0.0402155258,
0.0455089658,
-0.0155260088,
-0.0718438178,
-0.0032396757,
0.0269562304,
-0.0193925072,
0.0080690561,
0.0493538417,
-0.080290392,
-0.0124125248,
-0.0044546486,
-0.0110725844,
-0.0165596083,
0.0627437904,
0.0061826478,
0.0228262004,
-0.0937566087,
0.0414716676,
0.005533067,
-0.0044368347,
0.0525039248,
-0.0011926343,
0.0200674757,
0.0970974341,
0.0219591781,
0.0186665505,
0.00924832,
-0.0511260927,
0.0253294799,
-0.0059217638,
0.0254980568,
0.0539260097,
0.0111238863,
-0.0535989627,
-0.0414554439,
0.0021232241,
-0.0456132442,
0.0371806957,
0.0554035828,
0.0216366053,
-0.0555608161,
-0.0289428756,
-0.0131340921,
-0.0281774066,
-0.040230561,
-0.0171700157,
0.0137862787,
0.0271954723,
-0.0073678824,
-0.0326611325,
-0.0228825323,
-0.0280396175,
0.0058713891,
0.0307359062,
-0.0221190266,
-0.0013536508,
-0.0021068146,
0.0141765624,
-0.0829576105,
-0.0103572849,
0.0173266716,
0.002132827,
-0.0096556405,
0.0089872824,
0.0558993183,
0.0187244732,
-0.0612312481,
0.0293239765,
-0.0276193693,
0.0316385776,
-0.0227726437,
-0.0262636133,
0.0451384299,
0.0103699155,
-0.0237154681,
0.022380637,
0.0319543406,
0.012585897,
-0.0668650866,
0.0148540707,
-0.0252588168,
0.0043660752,
-0.0231128056,
0.0024363981,
-0.0201373547,
0.0178760961,
-0.0051062265,
-0.0400384888,
-0.0025308763,
0.0169120487,
2.609e-7,
-0.0164027754,
0.0393316261,
0.0099470625,
-0.0067496379,
0.0016587632,
0.06778384,
-0.001799395,
0.0448692255,
0.0478101261,
0.0016285148,
0.0269660503,
0.0169776399,
0.0184317566,
0.0228524059,
-0.0165920965,
0.0116621489,
-0.0990017727,
-0.0609731823,
-0.0145241898,
-0.0269145481,
0.0503654294,
0.0888000727,
0.052734714,
-0.0141671384,
0.0091441227,
-0.0253877304,
0.0755177662,
-0.0419564843,
-0.0442705825,
0.0001482721,
0.0170122515,
0.0015418677,
0.0061621959,
0.0225336831,
0.0371236317,
0.033063408,
-0.0384795554,
0.0684066117,
-0.0172054898,
-0.0125148995,
-0.0412664264,
0.022406945,
0.0047046952,
-0.0564167276,
0.0382033736,
-0.0473532379,
-0.0333776064,
-0.0296494812,
-0.016492011,
0.0078053949,
0.0413927399,
-0.0086033605,
-0.0457232818,
0.0048931856,
0.031068569,
0.0443651974,
-0.0315066576,
-0.0700740442,
-0.0220116843,
0.0346994102,
-0.0380744375,
-0.0600596592,
-0.0169341452,
0.0378524959,
0.0178573262,
-0.0716959536,
0.0466475189,
2.294630176e-34,
0.0194669347,
-0.004578548,
0.0343044251,
-0.0110581666,
0.0266203657,
0.0347748771,
-0.0001711085,
0.0045656534,
0.0487335511,
-0.0492080562,
0.0008629178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14590v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14590v2 | SIG: Speaker Identification in Literature via Prompt-Based Generation | 2023-12-22T10:29:18 | 2024-02-19T09:25:44 | Zhenlin Su, Liyan Xu, Jin Xu, Jiangnan Li, Mingdu Huangfu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Identifying speakers of quotations in narratives is an important task in
literary analysis, with challenging scenarios including the out-of-domain
inference for unseen speakers, and non-explicit cases where there are no
speaker mentions in surrounding context. In this work, we propose a simple and
effective approach SIG, a generation-based method that verbalizes the task and
quotation input based on designed prompt templates, which also enables easy
integration of other auxiliary tasks that further bolster the speaker
identification performance. The prediction can either come from direct
generation by the model, or be determined by the highest generation probability
of each speaker candidate. Based on our approach design, SIG supports
out-of-domain evaluation, and achieves open-world classification paradigm that
is able to accept any forms of candidate input. We perform both cross-domain
evaluation and in-domain evaluation on PDNC, the largest dataset of this task,
where empirical results suggest that SIG outperforms previous baselines of
complicated designs, as well as the zero-shot ChatGPT, especially excelling at
those hard non-explicit scenarios by up to 17% improvement. Additional
experiments on another dataset WP further corroborate the efficacy of SIG. | [
0.0185906235,
0.0429964922,
0.008378638,
0.0135765374,
-0.0304058325,
0.0110543678,
0.0789980367,
-0.0191870145,
0.0360807478,
-0.0435756966,
0.0123615311,
-0.0361213349,
0.0046534995,
0.0134526286,
0.0104144495,
0.0031843677,
0.0025766003,
-0.0303977467,
0.0347343944,
0.0157904569,
-0.0329871476,
0.0461058505,
-0.0090875439,
0.0423961617,
0.0213278383,
-0.0724207759,
-0.0204131305,
0.0280807707,
0.0458157696,
0.0057702418,
0.0364432894,
0.0450556092,
0.0011152013,
0.0543851145,
0.0000020288,
-0.0506660752,
-0.0194099098,
-0.0318816677,
-0.0318615623,
-0.0251809396,
0.0238982104,
0.052301228,
0.0049606049,
0.0108909374,
0.0068704733,
-0.013536403,
0.0151726604,
0.0630060658,
-0.0011524451,
0.0818542317,
-0.0127660334,
-0.0072959741,
0.0183923505,
0.0202371832,
0.0147592193,
0.0196604058,
0.0194941219,
-0.088720791,
0.0015079534,
0.0272678863,
0.0129235601,
0.0386270471,
-0.0198480934,
-0.0055935341,
0.0295468438,
0.0201543961,
-0.000945267,
0.0153084407,
-0.0080328118,
0.0559655279,
0.0281612054,
-0.0200792812,
0.0197475795,
-0.0030729463,
-0.0035331305,
0.0273623206,
-0.0124446554,
0.0358640328,
-0.0480194502,
-0.0229133442,
0.0156253073,
0.0424003378,
-0.0067546498,
-0.0105745178,
0.0068094949,
0.0046041906,
0.0279971398,
0.0035540869,
0.0105034299,
-0.0123980008,
-0.047635708,
-0.0789611414,
-0.0023287907,
0.0033839897,
-0.0463745967,
-0.0294164103,
-0.0076053399,
-0.0395087898,
-0.0407468602,
-0.0023338492,
0.0354052112,
0.0290088169,
-0.0259563345,
-0.0058771027,
-0.0333953686,
0.033730004,
0.0078448635,
-0.0085170995,
-0.0117627876,
-0.0043429118,
-0.0449528359,
-0.0050614816,
-0.0344393551,
0.0043844827,
-0.0212028325,
-0.0246932022,
-0.0306709036,
0.0201480594,
0.0052108625,
-0.0096089887,
-0.0374923013,
0.032516811,
-0.0306716431,
0.0369348712,
-0.0292829294,
0.0288486928,
-0.0046694819,
-0.0239968523,
-0.0068831719,
-0.0405877903,
-0.0297278017,
0.0425926447,
0.0297730751,
-0.0112330373,
0.0215787794,
0.0452190675,
-0.013752996,
-0.0536792576,
-0.0217898395,
-0.0525870584,
-0.0401710495,
-0.0692397058,
0.003792719,
-0.0395843759,
0.0054986202,
0.0049846894,
0.0008558396,
-0.0363760553,
0.0158173572,
0.0400433056,
-0.0066832262,
0.0335271247,
0.0117482729,
-0.0131982751,
0.0253402684,
-0.0095129674,
-0.0051807496,
0.0406828374,
0.0330053791,
0.015172773,
0.0317298174,
0.0358406231,
0.0383222662,
0.061755877,
-0.0002489001,
0.0183151215,
-0.0071734521,
0.0081588095,
0.0592226312,
0.0325987972,
0.0212210305,
0.0221217368,
-0.0240497831,
-0.0113273561,
0.0610168166,
0.0505476333,
-0.025252359,
-0.0166943111,
0.1060574353,
0.0346274041,
0.0090106688,
0.0010987358,
0.003605528,
-0.0367501155,
0.0116705904,
-0.0100195827,
0.0053142952,
0.0084182099,
-0.0291545987,
0.020791661,
-0.0024887603,
-0.019182479,
-0.0281011555,
0.017436631,
0.0049890256,
0.0252862349,
-0.0594840311,
0.0218389407,
0.0253735837,
-0.0693660975,
-0.0187405534,
-0.0353747159,
0.0438606516,
0.0094220769,
0.0598127879,
-0.0094436351,
0.0100826416,
-0.0752275512,
0.0129696401,
0.0317113809,
-0.012665445,
-0.0352708288,
0.0264369845,
-0.0288927257,
-0.0007681781,
0.0121571645,
-0.0061654388,
0.0605022721,
-0.0065512857,
0.0063992157,
0.0451020226,
-0.0123200743,
-0.0225984193,
0.0145423189,
-0.0525987372,
-0.0828084797,
0.0576486364,
0.0065914029,
0.0051036589,
0.0437136926,
-0.02356329,
-0.0387126654,
0.0029715754,
-0.0439995378,
-0.0096862661,
0.0333218314,
-0.0621689595,
-0.0607252568,
0.0209924597,
-0.0379292183,
-0.00680649,
0.0093507459,
0.0065071979,
-0.067937009,
0.0194426812,
-0.0135026155,
0.0228825118,
-0.0654438436,
0.0071623353,
0.0119926929,
0.0023357091,
-0.0461877175,
0.0682353973,
0.0601414405,
0.030868819,
0.0529778227,
0.0368227437,
0.0360766351,
-0.0578779764,
-0.0205474421,
-0.025424445,
0.0077404059,
-0.0066801724,
0.0206122454,
-0.0033514213,
-0.0248589143,
-0.0384089313,
-0.1114831194,
0.0445072167,
-0.0243458226,
0.0125865899,
0.0032933073,
0.0238623917,
-0.0425731726,
-0.005880218,
-0.0437062234,
-0.0450480767,
0.0053718262,
-0.0123709738,
0.0106344167,
-0.0040063746,
-0.0111111579,
0.0229787193,
0.0458142832,
-0.0371109582,
0.091263026,
0.0288561638,
0.0037213319,
-0.0216791891,
0.0259180423,
-0.0283298045,
0.0049701589,
-0.0164128058,
0.0467226617,
-0.013181,
-0.0037158015,
0.0553765781,
-0.0067990189,
-0.0252466202,
-0.0017814511,
-0.0165471174,
-0.0545141995,
-0.0328136943,
0.0200102273,
0.0094053131,
-0.0085300496,
0.0115590794,
0.0025409299,
0.0071984064,
0.0222543608,
0.0319315493,
-0.0442412682,
-0.0290405564,
0.0295350794,
0.0135488659,
-0.0076446147,
-0.0129371705,
-0.0300563462,
-0.0401543565,
0.02344325,
-0.0074041751,
0.0153412214,
0.0400097184,
-0.0591237694,
-0.0042112665,
-0.0566467978,
-0.0196528174,
-0.0399045236,
0.0315959267,
0.0220452156,
0.0289326552,
0.0778782889,
-0.0411882252,
-0.036828056,
0.0130338203,
0.0209609959,
-0.0225371365,
0.0214079693,
-0.0170469321,
-0.0001767474,
-0.0041318582,
-0.0201593544,
-0.0792418644,
-0.0742746443,
-0.0151166869,
0.0123014022,
0.0015718036,
-0.0329600461,
-0.0138844354,
-0.0024622241,
0.0163608696,
0.0306232814,
-0.051897224,
-0.0096364031,
-0.0538144149,
0.0567207634,
0.0270083398,
0.0114786886,
-0.0327581502,
-0.0440875925,
0.031128753,
0.003380731,
-0.0107062263,
0.0146842469,
-0.0151729379,
-0.0188428741,
0.0415041745,
-0.0241204798,
-0.0261929389,
0.0305766854,
0.0797601193,
-0.0276437979,
0.0061154286,
0.1225017458,
0.0216237083,
-0.0688089281,
-0.0387020335,
-0.0070012012,
0.0442909636,
0.0077208458,
0.0253521968,
-0.0862520039,
-0.0432454944,
0.0218419284,
0.0558709204,
-0.0519844592,
-0.0761117339,
-0.0535785519,
-0.11386659,
0.0562111922,
-0.0088112457,
-0.0219067596,
0.0319166407,
-0.0343655646,
-0.0075801467,
0.0110585913,
-0.0151551021,
0.0133416988,
-0.0417933017,
0.0352304429,
-0.0033942319,
0.0006845254,
0.001550019,
0.012353193,
-0.0550595522,
0.0168506596,
0.022101067,
0.0415725559,
0.0334735774,
-0.0063717957,
-0.0387843326,
-0.0369009562,
0.0020541048,
-0.0059468071,
0.0734806061,
-0.0130935088,
-0.0027195867,
-0.0408619419,
0.072154671,
-0.0150426328,
-0.0287900791,
0.0556035675,
0.0417144373,
-0.0086654229,
0.037998382,
0.0042951885,
0.0583384708,
0.0546721816,
0.0611101724,
0.0265931971,
-0.0430157259,
-0.0502061658,
-0.0311518852,
0.0239702892,
-0.0281388704,
-0.0196067132,
0.0073861694,
-0.0124578811,
-0.0565684699,
-0.0448905453,
-0.0252187829,
-0.0025108198,
0.0447216667,
0.0518461429,
0.0104116555,
-0.0366630703,
-0.0019083475,
-0.0391191766,
0.027444873,
-0.0691794902,
0.0175107028,
-0.0058143693,
0.0054455479,
0.058447253,
-0.0745548457,
0.0131862881,
0.0723197833,
-0.0499902964,
-0.0561719835,
-0.0249170028,
-0.0239139367,
0.0135792661,
0.0518872999,
-0.0186437983,
-0.0310136154,
0.1002788693,
0.0395345688,
-0.0269998796,
0.0415608548,
0.0325887911,
0.0522763617,
-0.0426036231,
0.0089221122,
-0.0103604272,
0.0079648644,
0.0215038303,
-0.0455615297,
0.0138996374,
-0.0303878132,
-0.0057001924,
0.0069468729,
0.0454468913,
-0.0379336439,
-0.0161259472,
-0.0516485646,
-0.0156147005,
-0.0143348882,
-0.0135969277,
-0.0018485334,
0.0396880358,
-0.0001648295,
-0.0018728568,
-0.0122217713,
0.0025307117,
-0.0587636717,
0.0726165324,
-0.0388170406,
-0.0045201653,
0.0213553403,
0.012119174,
-0.0030032294,
0.0075024785,
-0.0224370919,
0.0033615693,
0.0104742283,
0.0519181043,
0.0122978641,
0.0681585595,
0.0122034084,
0.0228104051,
0.0014969108,
0.0041562188,
-0.097879298,
-0.0044734906,
-0.0167109799,
0.0091551226,
0.0202281605,
-0.0172291361,
0.0504711866,
0.0096004866,
-0.0015370554,
-0.0207487345,
0.0428682007,
-0.0145532386,
-0.0084642041,
-0.04908894,
0.010159337,
-0.0186822116,
0.0261340067,
0.041771058,
0.001501631,
0.0164185017,
0.0117895715,
-0.0187938139,
-0.0624955855,
-0.019917462,
0.0199508574,
0.0218087174,
0.0322317556,
-0.0075538293,
-0.055321984,
-0.0286112167,
0.0599123873,
-0.0056910049,
0.012878499,
0.0066904244,
0.0338029638,
-0.0033822784,
-0.0281652212,
-0.0155631499,
-0.0630479679,
0.0118930349,
-0.0033137759,
-0.048697345,
-0.0084098363,
-5.662576693e-33,
-0.0297301058,
-0.0133378142,
0.0088575743,
0.0057948008,
-0.0420653336,
-0.0040864618,
-0.0191260148,
-0.0011352188,
0.0574141145,
-0.0051804171,
-0.0428647622,
-0.0231484994,
0.0194194354,
0.0369044207,
-0.0260355528,
-0.0204408728,
0.0723132491,
-0.0053768759,
-0.0316306278,
0.0656840652,
0.1196359545,
0.0298792981,
0.0313050002,
-0.0590946339,
0.0467222631,
-0.0797340274,
-0.0242473017,
-0.0143402359,
0.0488906018,
0.0056466758,
-0.0266931057,
0.0510495976,
-0.0073281708,
-0.0246525686,
0.0014719135,
0.0412363037,
-0.0628972203,
-0.0403014533,
-0.0310583469,
0.0165349934,
0.0110483374,
-0.071655564,
-0.0384191573,
-0.0149371317,
-0.0139012961,
-0.0111556472,
0.0775555149,
0.0050840089,
0.0248788726,
-0.0247766748,
-0.0502841473,
0.0187999997,
-0.0346403867,
-0.0379460193,
0.0015121668,
0.098638162,
0.0160266068,
-0.0380710736,
-0.0605233163,
0.0173016638,
0.0219946839,
-0.012881754,
-0.0183059704,
0.0652564093,
-0.0237327013,
0.0538435392,
0.0461072847,
-0.0536614656,
-0.0223066695,
-0.0068387436,
0.0091591701,
-0.0095951799,
0.0106093474,
0.1034481004,
0.0238846242,
-0.0044934279,
-0.0772549212,
0.0394953415,
0.0561446808,
-0.0618240796,
0.0136457225,
-0.0660523698,
-0.0206344109,
-0.0509587191,
-0.0366419591,
-0.0502980836,
-0.0141245173,
-0.0029272102,
0.0365656465,
-0.0166180748,
-0.0317988843,
-0.0410925709,
0.0727439374,
-0.0567972325,
0.0367441587,
0.0125834476,
-0.0453968942,
0.0267712101,
0.0007333796,
0.0082794679,
-0.0096493578,
-0.0508886538,
0.0649850443,
0.0155612165,
0.0192093719,
-0.0235245153,
0.0121777961,
0.0398407876,
-0.0591667369,
0.0104226079,
-0.0084923357,
0.0739094689,
-0.0226994697,
0.0697616562,
-0.0179080144,
-0.0024616146,
0.0075225015,
0.0408792235,
0.0282880124,
0.0034086208,
-0.0171158314,
-0.0065243496,
-0.0045157182,
-0.0125120357,
-0.0304996688,
0.0324392132,
0.0381362513,
0.0270210635,
0.0250778086,
-0.0613080598,
0.0091494555,
-0.0065920195,
2.756e-7,
-0.0117081152,
-0.0188148879,
0.0274981596,
-0.0055877273,
0.0217187125,
0.0492366105,
0.0319701359,
0.0373338982,
0.0228487607,
-0.017413985,
0.0039671604,
-0.0063114325,
0.0740580335,
0.0434994735,
-0.1745936573,
0.0190724507,
-0.0583192892,
0.0075105024,
-0.0694096684,
0.0134240435,
0.0664831176,
0.0406638235,
0.0273860581,
-0.0218371134,
0.0163426902,
-0.0252877511,
0.0521513857,
-0.0048494004,
-0.0364727676,
0.0257190093,
0.0561099835,
-0.0413980484,
0.0139445569,
0.0354439542,
0.0011105346,
0.0607153326,
0.014329032,
0.018402677,
0.0465465784,
-0.040083807,
-0.0224133432,
0.011137696,
0.0011820418,
-0.021868974,
0.0738785639,
-0.0026499042,
-0.0107608754,
-0.0345903076,
0.002251938,
-0.0118375309,
0.0338639915,
-0.0173024777,
-0.0099201836,
0.034409482,
0.0095451474,
-0.0065404316,
0.0096920459,
-0.0517245494,
0.0019070935,
0.0013996704,
-0.0467706993,
-0.0585465096,
0.01947915,
-0.0183939189,
0.0290679261,
-0.0997788906,
0.0568524264,
2.745767918e-34,
-0.0022214781,
0.0298631061,
-0.0104570622,
-0.0176392067,
0.0196956359,
-0.0149406185,
0.024197137,
0.0065064225,
0.0545514822,
-0.0496203415,
-0.0329199657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14557v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14557v2 | Aurora:Activating Chinese chat capability for Mixtral-8x7B sparse Mixture-of-Experts through Instruction-Tuning | 2023-12-22T09:30:41 | 2024-01-01T09:24:47 | Rongsheng Wang, Haoming Chen, Ruizhe Zhou, Yaofei Duan, Kunyan Cai, Han Ma, Jiaxi Cui, Jian Li, Patrick Cheong-Iao Pang, Yapeng Wang, Tao Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing research has demonstrated that refining large language models (LLMs)
through the utilization of machine-generated instruction-following data
empowers these models to exhibit impressive zero-shot capabilities for novel
tasks, without requiring human-authored instructions. In this paper, we
systematically investigate, preprocess, and integrate three Chinese
instruction-following datasets with the aim of enhancing the Chinese
conversational capabilities of Mixtral-8x7B sparse Mixture-of-Experts model.
Through instruction fine-tuning on this carefully processed dataset, we
successfully construct the Mixtral-8x7B sparse Mixture-of-Experts model named
"Aurora." To assess the performance of Aurora, we utilize three widely
recognized benchmark tests: C-Eval, MMLU, and CMMLU. Empirical studies validate
the effectiveness of instruction fine-tuning applied to Mixtral-8x7B sparse
Mixture-of-Experts model. This work is pioneering in the execution of
instruction fine-tuning on a sparse expert-mixed model, marking a significant
breakthrough in enhancing the capabilities of this model architecture. Our
code, data and model are publicly available at
https://github.com/WangRongsheng/Aurora | [
0.0367844589,
0.0530666523,
-0.0111357374,
0.0353712961,
-0.0059472341,
0.0008820361,
0.0326770283,
-0.0093584424,
-0.0063127121,
-0.0361118764,
-0.0673116595,
-0.0331530236,
-0.0009163051,
0.0249026269,
0.0343976393,
-0.0364671089,
0.042674344,
-0.023977764,
0.0074603739,
-0.0073705208,
0.0354098268,
-0.0011749131,
-0.0274712294,
0.030387044,
0.0053612008,
0.0009863173,
-0.0475323126,
0.0331022106,
-0.0075010974,
0.0055336845,
0.0054588006,
0.1123463437,
0.035109356,
0.0137689747,
0.0000021112,
-0.0079256203,
0.0009683607,
-0.026938457,
-0.0355291069,
0.0207033828,
0.0592526197,
0.0001501517,
-0.0298119653,
0.0086872224,
-0.0091466932,
-0.0155713465,
0.0455416702,
0.0382462703,
0.0689158589,
0.1144772768,
0.0055840746,
0.0055270093,
0.0450407825,
-0.0066373614,
0.0280458201,
-0.0409811176,
0.0040622712,
0.0427487083,
0.0216320902,
0.0455048829,
-0.0230304711,
0.0152809396,
0.0215088464,
-0.0125444131,
0.0074811978,
0.0170227122,
-0.0110270344,
-0.0330699757,
-0.0469760336,
0.0863419399,
-0.0071033933,
-0.0147306575,
-0.0150875039,
0.0100587932,
-0.0293028429,
-0.0549275018,
-0.0532146432,
0.0019791247,
0.0214781463,
-0.0031592315,
0.0006422909,
-0.0124858301,
0.0063384525,
0.0063387132,
-0.0120286979,
0.0230248403,
0.0145444479,
-0.0264969859,
-0.0419706292,
-0.0211385656,
0.0316485241,
-0.0726162121,
0.0125551857,
0.0469878353,
-0.0528479517,
0.0138299018,
-0.0438709892,
-0.0140551925,
-0.0145347314,
-0.0019089456,
0.0452539697,
0.0847671628,
-0.0252426006,
0.0505075604,
0.0170876253,
0.0285225473,
0.0030892123,
0.0077827084,
-0.023769591,
0.0279547255,
-0.0595082045,
0.0065994314,
-0.0400884561,
0.0284834988,
-0.0534271896,
-0.0395054258,
-0.0312970504,
0.0317745097,
-0.0035173593,
0.0150853833,
0.0113015622,
-0.0013456495,
-0.0485633649,
-0.018233953,
-0.0171873253,
0.0347050987,
-0.0194315035,
0.0056689205,
0.033149749,
-0.0956370756,
0.0102651212,
0.034908168,
-0.00218409,
-0.0221409742,
0.0033851415,
0.0679631159,
-0.0471512154,
-0.0224569663,
-0.0016335072,
0.0102225328,
0.0007461314,
-0.0638943464,
0.0018627654,
-0.0528102182,
0.0396846905,
-0.0147698503,
0.0233337209,
-0.0294672847,
0.0117594125,
0.0072053857,
-0.0168648791,
0.0370228365,
-0.0400504768,
0.0163589176,
0.0028136242,
0.020431146,
-0.0424249806,
0.0779259428,
0.0079099601,
0.0022381353,
0.0261135306,
-0.0123008583,
0.0267069843,
0.0140627287,
0.0051809363,
0.0120607736,
-0.0279398132,
0.0170223862,
-0.0396067873,
0.007626947,
0.0328289196,
0.0632763654,
-0.0567937307,
-0.0185884181,
0.0656965673,
0.0115933809,
-0.0127400914,
0.0507257953,
0.0443871841,
0.0540989973,
0.0122343935,
0.0252987221,
-0.0374396183,
0.0510386713,
-0.0571819544,
0.002805741,
0.0698667243,
0.0391387828,
-0.0566773936,
-0.0387312546,
0.0136739444,
-0.0058020465,
-0.0231352784,
0.0139873689,
0.0314246528,
-0.0416820236,
-0.0482447669,
0.0190642271,
0.0462414362,
-0.0472815782,
-0.0317969099,
-0.0515078343,
0.014225591,
0.0969610438,
0.0147992829,
0.0138103934,
-0.0435642712,
0.0012188586,
0.0099441959,
0.0173608325,
0.0323519073,
-0.0161420088,
0.0010701596,
-0.0857752264,
-0.021496268,
-0.0287524313,
0.0151422666,
0.039126832,
0.0199210607,
-0.0212153886,
-0.0006482916,
0.0279044099,
-0.0162196886,
-0.0027643379,
-0.0400686897,
0.0007685597,
-0.0344456919,
0.0013617018,
0.0207085349,
0.0333379805,
-0.0301522668,
0.0143034607,
0.0114432974,
0.0024864697,
-0.0048650159,
-0.006996518,
-0.083026953,
-0.0367687158,
0.0294862799,
0.0020327987,
-0.0046553747,
-0.0120058954,
-0.0213976372,
-0.0644829497,
0.0206593834,
-0.0175561476,
0.0380941778,
-0.0508059897,
0.0269346926,
0.0104316194,
0.0139254844,
-0.0025242709,
0.0497539416,
-0.0262917597,
0.0156985354,
0.0560734868,
0.0449551865,
-0.00098607,
-0.0611770824,
-0.0328845643,
-0.0038941677,
0.0022274356,
0.0412509106,
-0.0013030305,
0.0279290844,
-0.0376058333,
-0.049252823,
-0.1325992495,
0.0196007434,
-0.0521054268,
-0.0155822681,
0.0512189232,
0.0153291235,
-0.020976454,
0.0022853573,
-0.0450547524,
0.0115987603,
0.0044531398,
0.0082626669,
-0.0220127609,
0.024733657,
-0.0464983173,
-0.0442158058,
-0.0216286816,
0.0085397698,
-0.0060693496,
-0.027332129,
-0.0028246953,
-0.0142000383,
0.0206556059,
-0.0151821859,
0.0329184681,
-0.0359854177,
-0.0633438677,
0.0070432923,
-0.0430504158,
0.0636840388,
0.045228973,
0.0062538879,
0.0478306487,
0.0175771024,
-0.0370553769,
-0.0475482419,
0.0482493453,
-0.0013076351,
-0.0204181187,
-0.039826557,
-0.0298284926,
-0.0452982672,
0.0624574311,
-0.0121476548,
-0.0004770778,
-0.053550519,
-0.0242906641,
-0.0033733819,
-0.0593773611,
-0.0050312532,
0.0440129414,
-0.0314697474,
0.0234082658,
-0.0477686636,
-0.0495966263,
0.0663409457,
-0.0323233828,
-0.0411536582,
-0.0502772592,
-0.0429483503,
-0.0062325289,
-0.0123330429,
-0.0122794947,
0.020294182,
-0.0481048673,
-0.0019280009,
-0.0286459159,
0.0310745705,
-0.030184269,
-0.0167490747,
0.0135813653,
-0.042670615,
0.0171095934,
-0.0012971858,
-0.0062556481,
-0.0115312384,
-0.0019428303,
-0.0288863834,
0.0306898616,
0.0808408633,
-0.04121463,
-0.0086178053,
0.0334029943,
0.0251816865,
0.0345084332,
-0.0339889117,
0.0098899994,
-0.0432412364,
-0.0068472358,
0.0365911238,
0.0232809335,
-0.0354973599,
-0.0502542555,
0.061076764,
0.0327196456,
0.064333491,
-0.0354026109,
-0.026509054,
0.0416860655,
0.0354896076,
0.0212965496,
-0.0234324839,
0.0526600778,
0.1005320176,
-0.0460369289,
0.0115328198,
0.1178570166,
0.0109686526,
-0.048583582,
-0.005506672,
0.0026789773,
0.0283163842,
0.0056687938,
0.0350161493,
-0.1035278589,
-0.0206693131,
0.0026085486,
-0.0063641686,
0.0183447581,
-0.0100053912,
0.0043525393,
-0.0943649858,
0.0254205596,
0.0134606613,
-0.0475769863,
-0.0288193785,
-0.0255516004,
-0.0063898875,
-0.0151532153,
0.0456344001,
-0.0040699337,
0.0013347776,
-0.0358724035,
0.0181322619,
0.0190377645,
-0.1040066332,
0.0340923592,
-0.0067099724,
0.1186155155,
0.0483023226,
0.0006977262,
0.0122055681,
0.0161744338,
-0.01307745,
0.0269550867,
0.0044002468,
-0.0070244297,
0.0326955989,
-0.017659612,
-0.0104804011,
-0.0054416694,
-0.0015780026,
0.0081377635,
0.0214763638,
-0.0023900343,
0.048705481,
-0.0282591265,
-0.0068134782,
-0.0072949403,
0.0208654404,
0.0244773757,
0.0795488805,
0.0241345186,
-0.0347166732,
-0.014082877,
-0.0421223976,
-0.0431148261,
-0.0619640537,
-0.0228397474,
0.0345116705,
-0.0111074373,
-0.031996768,
-0.0363932177,
-0.0625975952,
0.0437486917,
0.0335596353,
-0.002388417,
-0.0013754475,
0.0044392468,
0.0163763817,
0.0059017213,
0.0154147614,
-0.0210304651,
0.0147417448,
-0.1099854931,
-0.0783963576,
0.0057474347,
-0.0226812791,
0.0288472716,
0.0072559435,
-0.0963299572,
-0.0797022134,
-0.0207033344,
0.065451473,
0.0156014571,
0.0550417006,
-0.0103005804,
-0.0459076352,
0.0381141044,
-0.009287416,
-0.0699361041,
0.0153396912,
0.0256124511,
-0.0334122367,
-0.003233854,
-0.0013957391,
-0.0048395195,
0.0436201431,
0.0197383072,
0.046988558,
-0.0464087836,
-0.0265469197,
0.0181751288,
0.0033010908,
-0.0206579939,
0.0085476087,
-0.0007641313,
-0.0251667388,
0.0462442003,
-0.0413559303,
0.01833985,
-0.0592353083,
-0.0368894897,
0.0198672172,
-0.0003631638,
0.0210201647,
0.0248379167,
-0.0052356212,
0.0298195966,
-0.0178300459,
0.0417051874,
-0.0059357872,
-0.0045739748,
0.0240327027,
0.003239115,
-0.0228349417,
0.0118861543,
0.0240244642,
0.020540148,
-0.0109492848,
0.091343224,
0.0005454315,
-0.0361372009,
0.0190902948,
0.0438473821,
-0.0605185851,
-0.0319784842,
-0.0246551223,
0.0736690685,
0.0572936796,
-0.0082434351,
0.0454471633,
-0.029444309,
0.0133910952,
-0.0427659675,
0.0424496457,
-0.0024165038,
-0.0206330996,
0.0203245748,
0.0484680273,
-0.0044331611,
0.0141388774,
0.0669215545,
0.0052522081,
0.0407055765,
0.0230241138,
0.0248217247,
-0.0381706655,
0.0129915541,
0.0610642806,
0.0302732699,
-0.0087082358,
0.0357267298,
-0.0096253222,
-0.0450241789,
-0.0405467302,
0.0049691852,
-0.0032615596,
-0.0165671241,
0.0294372588,
0.0467920303,
-0.0217886157,
0.0088253636,
-0.0335354097,
-0.0265418161,
0.0010915771,
0.0062523261,
-0.0014506441,
-7.152710474e-33,
-0.0316201448,
-0.0046766098,
0.0616985299,
-0.0675267205,
0.0210610759,
-0.0192684904,
-0.0520974211,
0.0070983628,
-0.044976145,
-0.0114297792,
-0.0372017846,
0.0126790954,
0.011917809,
0.0424302258,
-0.0007005,
0.0491475686,
0.0589186139,
-0.0165632628,
0.0141344797,
0.0569289029,
0.0061679794,
0.0245686322,
0.0180651639,
-0.0318943858,
-0.0104392003,
0.0002464501,
0.0062150839,
0.0168331508,
0.004229195,
0.0626822188,
-0.0244110208,
0.0295348372,
0.0153314378,
-0.0146589503,
-0.0563837811,
-0.0350933634,
-0.0545975529,
-0.0267077237,
0.0184117276,
0.0116121015,
-0.0160451997,
-0.0170750599,
-0.0145815825,
-0.0220504887,
0.0169095192,
-0.0202423725,
0.0071611241,
-0.0115133226,
-0.0112822223,
0.0094422949,
-0.0459632687,
0.0409329496,
-0.0050519519,
-0.0214694496,
0.0240935162,
0.0007167538,
-0.0078161219,
-0.0427565984,
-0.0179242752,
0.0291113257,
0.0662768111,
0.0740489438,
0.0683827326,
0.0266811512,
0.0082576452,
0.0076769185,
0.0401362665,
0.0281612575,
-0.0188082047,
0.0240680408,
0.0371676646,
0.0544364043,
-0.0163224563,
0.0119676292,
0.0114266444,
0.0126548773,
-0.0191283356,
-0.0073913014,
0.0657254681,
0.0221155845,
0.048491925,
0.0388051867,
-0.0662951097,
-0.0309252664,
0.0163630918,
0.0195764303,
-0.0452574939,
-0.0831518993,
0.0302727222,
0.026719017,
-0.0234604832,
-0.0126245683,
0.0660895407,
-0.0462547243,
-0.0054539042,
-0.0090366714,
-0.0166876838,
0.0290105343,
0.0001717872,
0.0276936926,
-0.0959101841,
-0.0674445853,
0.0643758699,
-0.0169799719,
-0.0151202148,
0.0445519462,
0.0019714155,
0.0349703506,
-0.0318498202,
-0.0232060961,
-0.0265025217,
-0.0052835033,
0.03218209,
0.0195716992,
0.005143601,
0.006817996,
-0.0283059385,
0.0696130246,
-0.0264649447,
0.0166857745,
-0.0359689258,
-0.0600167997,
-0.0071711871,
0.017908765,
-0.0387589447,
0.0291531757,
-0.0810789987,
-0.0462898239,
-0.0025226371,
-0.0171784069,
-0.0246508438,
0.0022533219,
2.86e-7,
-0.011250657,
0.0290973559,
0.0209151208,
0.0057101292,
0.0048537948,
-0.0095987339,
-0.0459363982,
0.0025460797,
0.0217152331,
-0.0544757657,
0.0447952487,
0.0768715814,
0.037438374,
-0.0055707344,
-0.0800990537,
-0.0371151082,
-0.0217056833,
-0.0179974064,
-0.0489389524,
-0.0181236546,
0.0396250337,
0.112472102,
-0.0162116326,
0.0324130431,
0.0196969751,
0.0217671804,
0.02118228,
-0.013040673,
-0.0231589619,
0.0441254079,
0.060868226,
0.0187108666,
-0.038473025,
0.0093817199,
0.008910019,
0.0212032795,
0.0031254026,
0.1126794592,
-0.0279830322,
-0.0175836906,
0.0401518904,
0.0145255085,
-0.0327867195,
-0.0067494302,
0.0472649895,
-0.0146783562,
-0.0004897668,
-0.0006192558,
-0.0159649663,
-0.0057697943,
-0.0110730082,
-0.0239195395,
-0.0203730315,
0.0196204204,
0.0070191775,
-0.0220186841,
0.0068381783,
-0.0428067595,
0.0149122123,
0.0200459752,
-0.0586174987,
-0.0919557363,
-0.034040723,
-0.0296628289,
-0.0043444885,
-0.0004386573,
0.011144666,
2.580514994e-34,
0.0250918996,
0.0167472344,
0.0334224813,
0.0381499864,
0.0366274975,
-0.0298119225,
-0.0523214228,
0.0202835165,
0.014920868,
-0.0949043557,
-0.0508329459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14542v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14542v1 | Automatic Data Retrieval for Cross Lingual Summarization | 2023-12-22T09:13:24 | 2023-12-22T09:13:24 | Nikhilesh Bhatnagar, Ashok Urlana, Vandan Mujadia, Pruthwik Mishra, Dipti Misra Sharma | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual summarization involves the summarization of text written in one
language to a different one. There is a body of research addressing
cross-lingual summarization from English to other European languages. In this
work, we aim to perform cross-lingual summarization from English to Hindi. We
propose pairing up the coverage of newsworthy events in textual and video
format can prove to be helpful for data acquisition for cross lingual
summarization. We analyze the data and propose methods to match articles to
video descriptions that serve as document and summary pairs. We also outline
filtering methods over reasonable thresholds to ensure the correctness of the
summaries. Further, we make available 28,583 mono and cross-lingual
article-summary pairs https://github.com/tingc9/Cross-Sum-News-Aligned. We also
build and analyze multiple baselines on the collected data and report error
analysis. | [
0.0161234178,
-0.0074025858,
0.0060254945,
0.0456521325,
-0.0279989634,
0.0089632422,
-0.0522708446,
0.0188524965,
0.0059621874,
-0.0293649826,
0.007229486,
-0.0201674886,
0.0200534984,
0.0218156427,
-0.0158597659,
-0.1047075987,
0.041715689,
0.0051431777,
-0.0136531601,
-0.0073894109,
0.0287411604,
0.0401729159,
-0.0084416214,
-0.0262973607,
-0.0057491492,
0.0387667567,
0.0206802227,
-0.0324038975,
0.0490566343,
-0.0289122108,
-0.023397645,
-0.005567268,
0.0784142688,
-0.0398686156,
0.0000016906,
-0.0618327036,
-0.0362152345,
0.0064266659,
0.058054965,
0.0051083663,
0.0337512717,
-0.0759210512,
0.0308499672,
-0.0123692323,
0.0076952428,
-0.0029917357,
0.0144121815,
0.0108489543,
0.04255227,
0.0990051702,
-0.041016899,
-0.052537594,
0.0118090045,
0.0194287803,
0.0122523019,
-0.0252110846,
-0.0241756439,
0.020644566,
0.0201230403,
0.0011070259,
-0.0145645328,
0.0356667452,
-0.0300913006,
-0.0140939075,
-0.0489509702,
0.015033043,
-0.0692160502,
-0.0213444699,
0.0367204063,
0.0454244502,
0.0103043178,
0.015145408,
0.0557118505,
0.0302038044,
-0.0266038068,
0.0088463202,
-0.0925651342,
0.0800998062,
-0.0268477146,
0.0361165814,
0.0273964517,
0.0446357094,
-0.0371253863,
0.0130385589,
0.0512974411,
-0.0118343905,
0.0313341692,
0.0169147588,
-0.0564551465,
-0.0137927849,
0.034244068,
-0.05369642,
0.0282692481,
0.0120307142,
0.0328562632,
-0.011885277,
-0.0384480171,
-0.0661289468,
0.0129482085,
-0.0844155848,
-0.0387819707,
0.0102147916,
-0.0011784936,
0.0921537802,
-0.0128542464,
-0.0021226467,
0.0092219962,
0.0019917982,
-0.0497599095,
-0.0437026359,
0.0081784567,
0.0328802057,
0.0144068133,
0.0269302204,
-0.0548817106,
0.0052411244,
-0.0638375506,
0.0150179081,
0.0151562691,
-0.0003881939,
-0.0070668436,
-0.0162505526,
-0.0088638132,
-0.0351875871,
-0.0105682341,
0.0162487924,
-0.0658946112,
-0.0141682988,
0.0104408134,
-0.0050823223,
0.0063737202,
0.0098764701,
0.0359626748,
-0.0016990569,
0.0061395532,
0.030402666,
-0.0384686776,
-0.0182154831,
-0.0354952142,
-0.002702632,
-0.0131623922,
-0.0180425625,
-0.0281269699,
-0.0795012265,
0.0592409447,
0.00510005,
-0.0259853173,
0.0028316684,
0.0091009624,
0.0224805251,
-0.0628965497,
0.0453018472,
-0.0000738632,
0.0183264278,
0.0541315153,
0.0148480488,
0.0416962355,
0.0855186731,
0.0218253992,
0.0278190691,
0.0861691982,
0.0271553695,
0.0053060232,
0.0331182927,
-0.0181405284,
0.0219237432,
-0.0333149396,
0.005475637,
-0.0110401548,
-0.0368749425,
0.0082729533,
0.010488566,
-0.0310846251,
0.0663277954,
0.0180206206,
0.0510474406,
-0.0218217503,
0.018600734,
-0.0179728772,
0.0316763259,
0.0198047888,
0.0540288575,
0.0418310761,
0.0552617796,
-0.0233929232,
0.0399544723,
0.099564746,
0.0394696556,
-0.0676348433,
-0.0163627211,
0.0389542133,
-0.0083428668,
0.0415139049,
0.0088775065,
0.0299469717,
-0.0143994205,
-0.0051010051,
0.0335415155,
0.0369660519,
-0.0824446306,
0.0708518997,
-0.0118486118,
0.0147344591,
-0.0074187177,
-0.0051201833,
-0.0412520804,
0.0261292756,
0.0031936499,
0.0334525108,
-0.0182076227,
0.0338206515,
-0.020218581,
-0.0139237922,
-0.0505218804,
-0.0094383564,
0.0059014312,
-0.0171352159,
0.0040497449,
-0.0275717843,
0.0571727343,
0.0490149893,
0.0021352691,
-0.0259831715,
0.0009827245,
0.0035634094,
0.017757602,
0.018429026,
0.0036685257,
-0.0021255172,
0.0350326151,
-0.0051178564,
-0.0123007456,
0.0269902404,
0.0014606905,
0.0088798245,
0.0373176038,
0.0307257157,
-0.0247984901,
-0.0028669396,
-0.1192154288,
0.0241077021,
0.0348772258,
0.0058805258,
-0.0707968995,
0.026585035,
0.0038210636,
-0.0123207299,
-0.0490716025,
0.0438752957,
0.0149888294,
-0.0022390394,
-0.0101329591,
0.0534781776,
0.0377818346,
0.0144749423,
0.0051212879,
-0.0622802638,
0.0342886895,
-0.0435436256,
-0.0031346928,
0.0241087507,
-0.0035162428,
0.0403096341,
0.0949793309,
-0.0179855507,
-0.0485198535,
-0.0232816637,
-0.1021370217,
0.008564515,
0.0036470976,
0.0142226303,
0.0243119448,
0.0349412784,
-0.006381561,
-0.0026484267,
-0.0292099975,
-0.0256899931,
0.0571884401,
0.0116827954,
0.0373134725,
0.0350046419,
0.0502055064,
-0.0349224471,
-0.017861845,
-0.0143579645,
0.0434059054,
0.0115004098,
-0.0571446009,
-0.0125743244,
0.0049216123,
-0.0101047745,
-0.0119781392,
-0.0196059234,
-0.0106633138,
-0.0368703417,
0.0108172642,
-0.0121329632,
0.031227367,
0.0468249209,
-0.0304209627,
0.0326445438,
-0.0330499709,
-0.0133726243,
0.0043323324,
-0.0015177933,
0.0079156244,
0.0142045729,
-0.0337983295,
0.0316443406,
-0.0455709398,
-0.00160171,
0.0102841379,
-0.0221932624,
-0.0286195148,
-0.0182813779,
0.0231591891,
-0.038324438,
0.0077878986,
-0.000058076,
0.0899011269,
-0.0199052952,
-0.0078329407,
0.0298441481,
-0.0179087222,
0.0466933772,
-0.0736176819,
-0.0028366181,
-0.0676464885,
0.0579124242,
-0.0449957773,
0.0468554497,
-0.0602211729,
-0.0209210198,
-0.0330052376,
-0.0634339899,
0.0663879514,
-0.0265173651,
0.0577522516,
-0.0307855736,
0.032622166,
-0.0393728279,
-0.0151116364,
-0.0093832137,
-0.0473826565,
0.005181436,
-0.0278225001,
-0.0073729008,
0.0107055902,
-0.0513472036,
0.046520561,
0.0502823405,
0.0053272927,
-0.0216168053,
0.0138321845,
0.0431690328,
0.0747238174,
0.0757528096,
-0.0397949405,
-0.053755831,
-0.0107815079,
0.0135295782,
0.0013329971,
0.0396170728,
0.0205687471,
0.0484251641,
0.0019872114,
0.0086425645,
-0.0433723852,
-0.0108476505,
-0.0243615974,
0.0416393019,
-0.0140413763,
0.0295540392,
0.0807025582,
0.0251540486,
-0.0598747842,
-0.0641826615,
-0.0083454205,
-0.0766109973,
0.0229482111,
0.0335147046,
-0.0686577633,
0.0242425576,
0.003697037,
-0.0154007729,
0.0195848718,
0.0152677055,
-0.0444652624,
-0.0667327493,
-0.0113017904,
0.0190839712,
-0.0688226223,
-0.0613186844,
-0.0354758725,
-0.0106359515,
-0.0252439007,
-0.0242912509,
0.0044443556,
-0.0359004512,
-0.0233822688,
0.0046861274,
-0.0405310653,
-0.005351882,
-0.01232599,
-0.0494372509,
-0.0432817228,
0.0191290639,
0.0476749688,
-0.0444104448,
0.0141556952,
-0.0028994703,
-0.0485028923,
-0.0616870485,
0.0157385021,
0.0693682283,
-0.0339219607,
-0.0102677811,
0.0148787452,
0.0247635227,
0.068139106,
-0.0171036404,
0.0287445206,
0.0180249251,
0.0381783061,
0.0292166118,
-0.0359259881,
0.032234177,
-0.0171245225,
0.0383864157,
-0.0123780053,
0.0003001953,
0.044779215,
0.004219647,
-0.0228225626,
-0.0691264272,
-0.0617986433,
0.0147554707,
-0.0959292948,
-0.0694615021,
-0.0263048112,
-0.0709015951,
0.0261338875,
0.0115665244,
0.0162528381,
0.0195713192,
-0.015260865,
0.0307204928,
-0.0439740941,
0.0019851604,
-0.0129800225,
0.0151117155,
-0.019463433,
0.0164891332,
0.0391852558,
-0.0243789237,
-0.014487179,
-0.0011223867,
-0.0211619306,
-0.0386776663,
-0.0136571312,
0.0339859352,
0.0145228328,
0.0505966805,
0.0304656271,
0.0099560069,
0.0409096517,
0.0231995713,
0.032556504,
-0.0065797749,
-0.0237659458,
0.0297172777,
-0.0532243587,
0.0120549006,
-0.0850754827,
0.0161344465,
-0.0517998897,
0.0150910607,
-0.0383168124,
-0.031502001,
0.0180415511,
0.0332128219,
-0.0039357101,
-0.0577159226,
-0.0104304552,
-0.0421743467,
-0.0464882404,
-0.018921636,
-0.0236884579,
-0.0004737836,
0.0096005723,
0.0037648901,
-0.0142938681,
-0.0011740519,
0.090105094,
-0.0156573541,
-0.0081548523,
-0.0550871715,
0.0186017994,
-0.0069436906,
0.0171510894,
-0.0690661967,
0.0123482943,
-0.0160245039,
-0.0242588092,
-0.0141948555,
0.00785142,
-0.0480068736,
0.0025484108,
0.0010845207,
0.0161283761,
0.0033863168,
0.0518635586,
-0.0089863706,
0.0453025214,
-0.0326990634,
0.0044060084,
0.0808011889,
-0.101294741,
0.0298035797,
0.0097098928,
-0.0191438831,
-0.0213243384,
0.0159391984,
-0.0049420628,
-0.0105808163,
-0.0127108842,
-0.0035328658,
0.0109528946,
0.0162611771,
0.083894752,
-0.0680899769,
-0.0236430932,
0.0642330348,
-0.048024755,
-0.0140762888,
-0.0092373863,
0.0126270559,
-0.0009507235,
-0.0119241569,
-0.0592212938,
-0.0304461289,
0.0050625755,
0.0225659385,
-0.012785689,
0.0095380284,
0.012992858,
0.0213949792,
0.0447570421,
0.0454238281,
0.0479489453,
-0.0313864425,
-0.0115795927,
-0.0555863902,
-0.005649738,
0.0405891091,
-5.559035477e-33,
-0.0250296332,
0.0321703777,
-0.0273474529,
0.0401817597,
-0.0377814919,
0.0300525445,
-0.0225251447,
-0.0002807886,
-0.0195989124,
-0.0033399209,
-0.0139290355,
0.0218902323,
0.0282111615,
0.0004045891,
0.0432449318,
0.0248333719,
0.0044908035,
0.0112106707,
-0.0231630486,
0.0169959776,
0.043813657,
-0.0027987054,
0.0653309152,
-0.0455379151,
0.017876422,
-0.0032894032,
-0.0149989631,
-0.0264810938,
0.1063311324,
0.0053688227,
0.0123561276,
-0.0130749187,
0.0227128305,
-0.0058017108,
-0.0146624083,
0.0226270556,
-0.0661467835,
0.007428268,
0.0502331108,
0.0064981463,
-0.0194969773,
-0.0271847751,
0.0074333153,
-0.0443284959,
0.0003635597,
-0.009957552,
0.0443324223,
-0.0442946069,
-0.0262806024,
-0.0490478985,
-0.0060971072,
0.014948085,
-0.0467311367,
-0.0212876592,
0.0551808588,
0.0353849381,
0.0481799021,
-0.0088981101,
-0.0129690757,
0.0631871819,
-0.0375319757,
0.0725115314,
0.0701542348,
-0.0203008968,
-0.0169516299,
0.0554671586,
-0.0117969168,
-0.0608120114,
0.0112341037,
0.0144900726,
-0.0105840107,
-0.0093498472,
-0.0366257168,
0.051257778,
0.0390559472,
-0.0531173199,
-0.0570331775,
0.1062595844,
-0.0045398031,
0.0488765761,
-0.0156578906,
0.0016147805,
0.0019932115,
-0.0090893814,
0.0138110705,
-0.000751438,
-0.0279139541,
-0.0469139293,
-0.0175617561,
0.0079758568,
-0.0224772431,
0.0201967862,
0.0382469632,
-0.0217121374,
0.0435801893,
0.0153239407,
-0.0258525517,
0.0200619325,
0.0108959479,
0.013258094,
-0.0126235699,
-0.0398846269,
-0.0052953074,
0.0399569683,
0.0064709438,
0.0023580883,
0.0268649645,
-0.0027987375,
-0.055139266,
0.0056277039,
0.0302396435,
-0.0004298423,
-0.0620149821,
0.0286297314,
-0.0230457541,
0.0386013761,
-0.0079506543,
0.0097947353,
0.0053810985,
0.0042219199,
0.0208641011,
-0.0463697799,
-0.005399432,
0.0391809233,
0.0299162399,
0.0561198965,
-0.0428662896,
0.0050767642,
0.0143786157,
-0.0267605893,
-0.0210579149,
0.0237707924,
2.461e-7,
-0.0009706311,
0.0220989361,
0.0354598537,
0.0085817175,
-0.0585194714,
0.0001570917,
-0.0691917986,
0.0471675694,
0.0100034485,
-0.001827428,
0.0255910084,
0.0237751082,
0.0262288861,
0.0843817964,
-0.0993884727,
-0.0113246962,
-0.0477457345,
-0.0580301099,
-0.0467099734,
-0.003353494,
0.0042252494,
0.0442741588,
-0.0019968317,
0.0062475386,
-0.0275615063,
-0.0322563946,
0.049772691,
-0.0190766528,
-0.1170321256,
0.0021811558,
0.00582889,
0.016197497,
-0.0539048277,
-0.0300683212,
-0.0147698121,
0.0066416287,
0.0889460444,
0.0042402232,
0.0077141272,
0.0222397707,
0.0063930387,
0.0214395244,
-0.0073416955,
0.0236641578,
0.0614040643,
0.0024239791,
-0.0037262661,
-0.0424443074,
-0.0444827266,
0.037800476,
0.0230575185,
0.0172452573,
-0.0586871691,
0.044343926,
0.0156828146,
-0.0173657965,
0.0111726793,
-0.0384167545,
-0.0088575417,
0.0319947228,
0.0328212008,
-0.0089750122,
0.0022041225,
-0.0011765199,
0.0017108694,
-0.0275439397,
0.0114066638,
1.772414285e-34,
0.0958119035,
0.0275534913,
-0.0445807651,
-0.0638170466,
0.0064396998,
-0.0284038633,
-0.0340110809,
0.0046378034,
-0.0088093504,
-0.0484690703,
-0.014891129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14504v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14504v2 | Theory of Hallucinations based on Equivariance | 2023-12-22T08:08:45 | 2024-01-04T02:49:21 | Hisaichi Shibata | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This study aims to acquire knowledge for creating very large language models
that are immune to hallucinations. Hallucinations in contemporary large
language models are often attributed to a misunderstanding of real-world social
relationships. Therefore, I hypothesize that very large language models capable
of thoroughly grasping all these relationships will be free from
hallucinations. Additionally, I propose that certain types of equivariant
language models are adept at learning and understanding these relationships.
Building on this, I have developed a specialized cross-entropy error function
to create a hallucination scale for language models, which measures their
extent of equivariance acquisition. Utilizing this scale, I tested language
models for their ability to acquire character-level equivariance. In
particular, I introduce and employ a novel technique based on T5 (Text To Text
Transfer Transformer) that efficiently understands permuted input texts without
the need for explicit dictionaries to convert token IDs (integers) to texts
(strings). This T5 model demonstrated a moderate ability to acquire
character-level equivariance. Additionally, I discovered scale laws that can
aid in developing hallucination-free language models at the character level.
This methodology can be extended to assess equivariance acquisition at the word
level, paving the way for very large language models that can comprehensively
understand relationships and, consequently, avoid hallucinations. | [
0.0039099874,
0.0465497002,
-0.0416429527,
0.039951887,
-0.0362469591,
0.0333666727,
-0.0141864521,
0.0014022636,
-0.0124477623,
-0.0361288376,
-0.0408184156,
-0.0926869884,
0.0074690226,
-0.0115290796,
0.0275164675,
-0.0501733907,
0.0469261296,
-0.0468928516,
-0.0580257848,
-0.0256771147,
-0.024347581,
-0.0103748599,
-0.0085289627,
0.0023913577,
-0.0103136953,
-0.0306023881,
-0.0086049922,
-0.0175221488,
0.0047838236,
0.0159913432,
-0.0163127948,
0.0738670379,
-0.0009417644,
0.052100651,
0.0000021052,
-0.069455944,
0.0214165039,
-0.0238106865,
0.0111971628,
-0.0041479021,
0.0442818888,
-0.0410713814,
-0.0058133677,
-0.0142767411,
0.0025361804,
-0.0007631735,
0.0891102105,
0.0490154773,
-0.0097708628,
0.0323808081,
-0.0127510447,
-0.1083488911,
0.0235178526,
-0.0229695588,
0.0528451279,
0.019565301,
0.0556490086,
0.0246218108,
0.0057076928,
-0.0469333865,
-0.0582225695,
-0.0002003972,
0.0159484707,
0.0278293919,
0.021498695,
0.0331526771,
-0.0161606781,
-0.0511391722,
0.0075936662,
0.055848863,
-0.0308312941,
-0.0731697008,
0.0067567965,
0.0286057126,
0.0044810139,
0.0345515683,
-0.0144135728,
0.0159352683,
0.0184315797,
0.0128162289,
0.0413081273,
-0.0198736899,
0.0237050187,
-0.0299920514,
-0.0779178441,
0.04481408,
0.0226448998,
-0.0273373127,
-0.0158952866,
-0.0032680896,
-0.0346769281,
-0.053894002,
0.0033145903,
0.0190916583,
-0.014893543,
-0.0001940625,
-0.0195575822,
-0.0091856867,
0.0349934585,
-0.127687782,
-0.0233292449,
0.0026311425,
-0.0188568942,
0.0266969781,
-0.0270683728,
0.0485712513,
-0.0276650246,
0.0716943666,
-0.0433093719,
-0.0008249376,
-0.024900021,
-0.0214102902,
-0.0459525734,
0.014167415,
0.0219445247,
-0.0209522471,
-0.0266366303,
0.0006469404,
-0.0059876004,
-0.0035827984,
-0.0366815366,
-0.0291259624,
-0.0057489104,
-0.0231087245,
-0.0048204102,
0.010771744,
-0.0332085676,
-0.0133624952,
-0.0291139819,
-0.0674783736,
0.006519678,
-0.0254502632,
-0.0294892658,
-0.0275915433,
0.0041948864,
0.0504057966,
0.055230245,
-0.0146314288,
-0.0048710722,
0.0239858609,
-0.0310842879,
-0.044201199,
0.0165202003,
-0.0538113452,
0.006866137,
0.034160722,
-0.0176379941,
-0.0444153734,
0.023044711,
-0.0186578725,
-0.0765391961,
0.0712959841,
0.0060615591,
0.0285378993,
0.0064180074,
-0.0102989841,
0.0410652086,
0.0666981936,
0.0327765979,
-0.0152863404,
0.0012766334,
-0.0658602118,
0.0522832796,
0.0237988885,
-0.0156292599,
-0.0196218919,
-0.0513285883,
-0.0334863253,
0.0385512076,
0.0088042794,
0.0313154832,
0.0722683221,
-0.0049810223,
-0.0439514965,
0.0603363179,
0.036567755,
0.0035107718,
0.0476709679,
-0.0089896657,
-0.0166041888,
-0.0200290475,
0.0385081396,
-0.072110258,
0.0177314058,
0.0043756082,
0.0008307198,
0.0069965795,
0.0134767471,
-0.0319431685,
-0.005230784,
-0.0261663236,
0.0039077476,
0.0342083499,
-0.0216440875,
0.0477564633,
0.0160532072,
-0.0137664499,
0.0507509559,
0.0235065185,
-0.0516167134,
0.0297830794,
-0.0123276217,
0.025545435,
0.0692958683,
0.0202410053,
0.0021053783,
0.0466275513,
-0.0200104322,
0.0223135836,
0.0671396554,
0.0491647758,
0.0281655286,
-0.0101427101,
-0.0438426733,
0.0451362766,
0.0266150068,
0.0251407232,
0.0138895158,
-0.0752234086,
0.0215872731,
-0.0111335674,
-0.0259578079,
-0.0184187666,
0.0322764628,
-0.0173148867,
-0.0346576646,
-0.0587427728,
-0.0055815405,
0.0163375884,
-0.0212708563,
-0.0444258787,
0.0523426794,
0.0050130789,
-0.0428040773,
-0.0175351072,
0.0649134368,
-0.0540559068,
0.0329102762,
0.024770014,
0.0023526442,
0.0556227118,
0.0003025293,
0.0268906914,
-0.001260882,
0.0711487085,
-0.0444472656,
0.0966235697,
-0.0206542592,
0.0662464052,
-0.0228657667,
0.0810367242,
-0.0036803461,
0.0821618959,
0.0004880733,
0.02868025,
-0.0304914284,
-0.0027006371,
0.0065518618,
0.0070302482,
-0.0299110934,
0.0491430201,
0.0140741942,
0.0090593379,
-0.0003989625,
-0.0481239706,
-0.0152986795,
-0.0580291934,
-0.0334201716,
0.0057109059,
-0.0077616912,
0.016696481,
0.0403285958,
-0.0093949595,
-0.0057388623,
0.003397966,
-0.0124575626,
0.0283000171,
0.0058444301,
0.0639722794,
0.0161868799,
-0.0240530893,
-0.1059595421,
-0.0046869847,
-0.0178747531,
-0.0323308446,
0.0576388948,
-0.0112458756,
-0.0235605557,
-0.0561418049,
0.041856274,
-0.0340517797,
0.0265316255,
0.001769208,
-0.0522539616,
0.0314288586,
0.0102774799,
0.0763632134,
0.0488205925,
0.0466915928,
0.0604119338,
0.0544568673,
-0.0345963426,
-0.0074659772,
-0.0464194082,
-0.0219080243,
-0.0157135613,
-0.0096327001,
-0.0652374774,
-0.0458710939,
0.1171396077,
-0.0100800032,
-0.0106677171,
-0.0935527235,
0.0056256861,
-0.0203849245,
-0.0485114157,
0.0178449973,
-0.0293886643,
-0.023682924,
0.0014642564,
-0.0590209179,
-0.0194537118,
0.0369279347,
-0.0122122476,
-0.0090812035,
-0.0140162082,
0.0294129178,
0.0199340694,
0.0415276103,
0.0440693609,
0.019798357,
0.0000143148,
-0.0274027959,
-0.0455921032,
-0.0089584142,
-0.0115079815,
-0.0465604961,
0.0251726713,
-0.0356247574,
0.0021891613,
0.0172261726,
0.0003031495,
-0.0409065597,
0.002847153,
-0.0039214538,
-0.0066038123,
-0.0002999014,
-0.0164426416,
-0.0144022396,
0.0509444959,
0.0222786199,
0.0037596612,
0.0120694786,
-0.0081647616,
-0.0003976687,
-0.0109185725,
0.0261978302,
-0.0154179689,
0.0542205609,
-0.062640585,
0.0345680006,
0.0471406914,
0.0255567376,
0.0534648784,
0.0006977443,
0.0156990569,
0.0197323989,
-0.0255642496,
-0.0440662354,
0.0259805527,
0.0361732095,
-0.0230107661,
-0.0272391438,
0.0775570571,
0.0140510434,
-0.0041293073,
0.0657752007,
-0.069890067,
0.0288424715,
0.0122735165,
-0.0164172351,
-0.0653497204,
0.0110913916,
-0.0012795718,
-0.0329412632,
-0.0074225669,
-0.0448443405,
0.0250000805,
-0.0613645986,
-0.031060582,
0.0525092334,
-0.0482974537,
-0.0491258167,
0.0021905003,
0.0214058813,
0.0227356069,
0.0429142676,
0.0164465345,
-0.0115522128,
-0.0176391602,
0.0022867047,
-0.0122484742,
0.0109973624,
0.0331867673,
-0.0405664109,
0.0645421445,
0.0556449965,
0.0361415297,
-0.0431543924,
-0.0892184675,
0.006645082,
-0.0117066167,
-0.0282431897,
0.0382482782,
0.0167717673,
0.0244474709,
-0.0073168338,
0.0028455027,
0.0138439322,
-0.0547036454,
-0.039606072,
-0.0407187901,
0.0461004898,
-0.0186520237,
-0.1142588407,
0.0054290053,
0.0073701846,
-0.0232031718,
0.083446689,
0.0339993648,
-0.0441967174,
-0.0655399784,
-0.0129720736,
0.0311574861,
0.0109853074,
-0.0691441447,
0.0418276191,
0.0956683308,
-0.0734000802,
-0.0584839359,
-0.0146281067,
0.0002060526,
0.0027222408,
0.0463631824,
0.0182739552,
-0.0002281539,
-0.0514332913,
0.0074011511,
0.0081621259,
-0.0282117762,
0.0188051052,
-0.0337829925,
-0.0062305438,
0.0168663245,
-0.0109108407,
-0.0043640486,
-0.0111355567,
-0.0536651947,
-0.0696190521,
0.0867948979,
-0.0211279746,
0.0332346484,
0.0215525646,
-0.0208059326,
-0.0321126543,
0.032217931,
0.0207538549,
0.0090946127,
0.0462724157,
-0.0045562247,
-0.0076220972,
0.0249125827,
0.0228658225,
-0.0050846697,
0.0058519659,
0.0061041294,
0.0242350716,
-0.0061313724,
-0.0219337549,
0.0467757061,
0.0041821864,
-0.0258893557,
0.0013224663,
-0.0010743343,
-0.0101612424,
-0.0196090899,
-0.047091607,
0.0100312009,
-0.0164710972,
-0.0502089076,
0.0448908694,
0.0372059904,
-0.0062763989,
-0.059506461,
-0.0282197334,
0.0027317279,
0.0122929411,
-0.0082891192,
-0.0095433947,
0.0333750024,
0.0496520177,
0.0006159885,
-0.005670608,
0.0094626779,
-0.0212455466,
0.0774226189,
0.0016691175,
0.0501514412,
0.009874153,
-0.0252195392,
-0.0275428779,
0.0226331577,
-0.0338900648,
-0.0573676601,
-0.06034844,
-0.0074684573,
0.0291706398,
-0.0075550107,
0.0496876314,
-0.0701506361,
0.042774789,
-0.0156780574,
0.0384256542,
0.0271308944,
-0.0225769524,
-0.0022490567,
0.0250668507,
-0.0109205786,
0.0014224387,
0.0443372689,
-0.0248742197,
0.0432862863,
0.000231159,
0.0070358291,
-0.0101951966,
-0.0281748045,
-0.0098231807,
-0.0302465186,
-0.0405101553,
-0.0328151211,
-0.0678117424,
-0.0674960017,
-0.0157682095,
0.011128054,
0.016666675,
0.0035994593,
0.0056684394,
0.0544307269,
-0.0396536179,
-0.0291950759,
-0.0132513409,
0.022171963,
0.0591613986,
0.0074009034,
0.0090930983,
-6.412066014e-33,
-0.0113068447,
0.0103539359,
0.0003085905,
-0.0215994176,
-0.0162573792,
-0.0786789209,
-0.0275755916,
0.0308207683,
-0.0202393457,
0.025417123,
0.0171040837,
0.0077480865,
0.0129196132,
-0.0160254072,
0.0335840248,
-0.0092704585,
0.0323678479,
-0.0165343955,
0.0009798382,
0.0077011068,
0.0201983452,
-0.0122047197,
0.0817708448,
-0.0769324154,
0.0468408689,
-0.0396060199,
-0.0161117278,
0.0131475264,
0.0014848651,
-0.0224305391,
-0.0400433354,
0.0256625619,
0.0352032669,
-0.012820472,
-0.0141827241,
0.0197507925,
-0.0147559242,
-0.0163191166,
0.005243117,
0.0409973226,
-0.0054223808,
-0.0217030458,
0.0505342409,
-0.0273575373,
0.0065879375,
0.001519053,
0.01692109,
-0.0294012763,
-0.0058005899,
0.0811614469,
-0.0720152557,
-0.029337218,
0.0033346638,
-0.0199613757,
0.0178501755,
0.0268266778,
-0.0393172875,
-0.0266914815,
-0.0416621082,
0.0375554524,
-0.0003310175,
0.0096799508,
0.0291719511,
0.0130810151,
0.0510650873,
0.0622390583,
0.1051525921,
0.0068059298,
-0.0219131149,
-0.0194229838,
0.0634466857,
0.0216494035,
0.0134335719,
0.0107489023,
0.0820003897,
-0.0078036739,
-0.0286769457,
-0.0464395657,
-0.0201388523,
0.0282736477,
0.0567465797,
0.0045520593,
-0.0769324601,
-0.0398552343,
0.007951376,
-0.0295236558,
-0.040324267,
-0.0448605418,
0.0118393982,
-0.0419718139,
0.0027289696,
-0.0098506343,
0.0407267474,
-0.0604968257,
-0.0530273505,
0.0044488912,
-0.0111055151,
0.0556216352,
-0.0041935327,
0.0015214444,
0.0045509529,
-0.0764212608,
0.0063350438,
0.0261754617,
0.0297520868,
0.0410633646,
-0.0161477122,
0.0025779812,
-0.04512145,
-0.0150873838,
-0.0119481478,
-0.0463983305,
0.0454593897,
0.015786089,
0.0428346023,
0.002890476,
-0.0098407557,
-0.0440116599,
0.0359331258,
-0.0156864021,
-0.0104832426,
0.0634131655,
-0.0387781151,
0.0283232871,
-0.0043657301,
-0.0501601435,
-0.0624874532,
0.0095392205,
0.0971271321,
-0.0501173586,
-0.00526236,
-0.011898933,
2.975e-7,
0.003168561,
0.0370452628,
0.021412693,
-0.0108320005,
0.0304527301,
0.0227171928,
0.0113185858,
0.0431147628,
0.0309045929,
-0.0548136793,
-0.0097806053,
0.0499258935,
0.0547442771,
0.0396831222,
-0.0402142666,
-0.0237963088,
-0.0484471843,
0.027749449,
-0.0330313742,
-0.0017856756,
0.0042132796,
0.047470089,
0.0163655654,
0.0035605645,
-0.0020599633,
-0.0396088138,
0.029497616,
-0.0585580915,
0.0546649247,
0.0408550166,
-0.021843316,
-0.0131230392,
0.0125164846,
0.0882326588,
0.0151159074,
0.0092687104,
0.01483915,
0.0023100416,
-0.0403600298,
0.0073572495,
-0.0073930658,
-0.0337539241,
-0.0192889683,
-0.0707469881,
0.0437129103,
-0.0363740474,
-0.0221108776,
0.0523278713,
-0.0445041433,
0.0063358159,
0.0325039402,
0.0165187772,
-0.0089721614,
0.0136334654,
0.0380256549,
0.0494318195,
-0.0011907736,
-0.0458209813,
-0.0017037822,
0.008204422,
-0.0142296562,
-0.0103224944,
-0.0191446599,
-0.004694941,
0.0023506598,
-0.0260613505,
0.0083202906,
2.723413781e-34,
0.0037112844,
-0.0016076083,
0.0677995309,
0.0204595122,
0.0100347875,
-0.0464743525,
0.0563462749,
0.0229438432,
0.0256347656,
-0.0576185584,
-0.0122563941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14488v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14488v1 | Language Model is a Branch Predictor for Simultaneous Machine Translation | 2023-12-22T07:32:47 | 2023-12-22T07:32:47 | Aoxiong Yin, Tianyun Zhong, Haoyuan Li, Siliang Tang, Zhou Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The primary objective of simultaneous machine translation (SiMT) is to
minimize latency while preserving the quality of the final translation. Drawing
inspiration from CPU branch prediction techniques, we propose incorporating
branch prediction techniques in SiMT tasks to reduce translation latency.
Specifically, we utilize a language model as a branch predictor to predict
potential branch directions, namely, future source words. Subsequently, we
utilize the predicted source words to decode the output in advance. When the
actual source word deviates from the predicted source word, we use the real
source word to decode the output again, replacing the predicted output. To
further reduce computational costs, we share the parameters of the encoder and
the branch predictor, and utilize a pre-trained language model for
initialization. Our proposed method can be seamlessly integrated with any SiMT
model. Extensive experimental results demonstrate that our approach can improve
translation quality and latency at the same time. Our code is available at
https://github.com/YinAoXiong/simt_branch_predictor . | [
0.0075345556,
0.0026773275,
-0.001951391,
-0.005104647,
-0.0075294091,
0.0304909274,
-0.0092569636,
0.0135621298,
-0.0340152197,
0.0103530083,
-0.0155241648,
-0.0136728445,
0.0215448663,
0.0017184442,
-0.0051652789,
-0.0537956879,
0.0469955653,
0.0020308984,
-0.0230731908,
-0.0111232735,
0.0078693517,
0.031397555,
0.040273577,
0.0293022003,
-0.0191741902,
-0.0118250446,
-0.0185487401,
0.0790031329,
0.0324487761,
-0.0206773523,
-0.0068642767,
0.0147917867,
0.0208027046,
0.0410890281,
0.0000023987,
0.0045259162,
-0.067745097,
0.0171844419,
-0.0073694503,
-0.0095970156,
0.0370127335,
-0.0720517486,
-0.0251918714,
0.0544482656,
-0.0069676139,
-0.0333037674,
0.0922865421,
-0.0394352339,
0.0730909482,
0.0537416153,
-0.0246332362,
-0.0275682602,
-0.0325360782,
-0.0477511957,
-0.0405017361,
-0.0050585764,
-0.0332151353,
0.0110477498,
-0.0707397163,
0.0042127846,
-0.0376630574,
0.0593910031,
0.0370697528,
0.010369272,
-0.0341242775,
0.0128006749,
0.0285132807,
-0.0392755643,
-0.0347721688,
0.0134309242,
-0.1198543385,
-0.0191207994,
-0.0141695896,
-0.0302679725,
-0.0421586446,
-0.0112709524,
-0.032670334,
0.033986643,
-0.0273301303,
-0.0253418237,
0.0211707018,
0.0237911697,
0.0398844369,
-0.0285225417,
-0.0307327639,
0.0144399405,
0.051703427,
-0.0144877983,
-0.0354087204,
0.0410456508,
-0.007225744,
-0.0469650626,
0.0487037078,
-0.0068000522,
-0.0197594389,
0.0322818793,
-0.0697990432,
-0.0479813665,
-0.0177692529,
-0.0488904305,
0.0011448528,
0.0949940383,
0.0090656159,
0.0089506609,
-0.0090278285,
0.0278396197,
-0.0076850555,
-0.0046438044,
-0.0730284005,
-0.0307082068,
-0.0049284082,
0.002270554,
-0.0434101112,
-0.0146417851,
-0.0589795709,
-0.0187261868,
-0.0134663479,
0.003148762,
0.0207997113,
-0.0427864641,
0.0814421326,
-0.0344780535,
-0.0622188188,
-0.0231657252,
0.0094513837,
0.0447686203,
-0.014041747,
-0.0207358804,
-0.0184149705,
-0.0278834496,
-0.0473536253,
0.0070300889,
0.0008569906,
-0.0198354404,
-0.0131027233,
0.070718348,
-0.0121510113,
0.0144078629,
0.012391638,
-0.0199573692,
0.0234590098,
-0.0339883566,
0.0056700446,
-0.0420168601,
0.0622890741,
0.0085126869,
0.0346592814,
0.0132980691,
0.0037396757,
0.0201124456,
0.0250085685,
0.0411107503,
-0.0282786023,
-0.0029178604,
0.0380472541,
0.0222802144,
0.0027644793,
0.0692180172,
0.0406722538,
0.0409790277,
0.0085075675,
-0.0037849511,
-0.0294936765,
0.0854851678,
0.0021569165,
-0.0066689877,
0.0183400605,
-0.0142383054,
0.0126563516,
0.0040029306,
0.0246626902,
0.0424647219,
-0.0371977203,
0.0328231975,
0.0469448045,
0.0289391223,
0.0072692987,
0.0438171811,
0.0832768381,
0.0309102777,
-0.0529884137,
-0.0199714582,
-0.0087872576,
0.0508222096,
0.0096758222,
0.0132280225,
0.057832621,
0.0526777245,
-0.0096872263,
-0.0044350903,
-0.0004108687,
-0.0325359516,
-0.0074752606,
-0.0073062866,
0.0228527822,
0.0091666179,
-0.0902776867,
0.0511312447,
0.0059962552,
-0.064492695,
0.0126203541,
-0.0004958057,
-0.0509614758,
0.0908915624,
0.0399204828,
0.0489457212,
0.0020260296,
-0.0005023996,
-0.0084078871,
0.0193462055,
0.023501778,
0.0044806604,
0.0448402725,
-0.0551041327,
-0.0337749459,
0.0666163489,
-0.0144558642,
0.059627939,
0.0370226167,
0.0365723595,
0.0458391234,
0.0330473557,
-0.0327928625,
0.0295434184,
-0.0485195592,
0.0239007063,
0.0115996888,
0.0150244022,
0.0137029141,
-0.0000496858,
-0.0165572595,
0.0032482792,
0.0239783246,
-0.019797381,
-0.0242283344,
0.0292275976,
-0.0503616594,
-0.0549189635,
0.0185030438,
-0.0207787212,
0.0309598651,
0.0188161246,
-0.0187653769,
-0.0719146207,
-0.0120433802,
-0.0414238796,
0.0025476872,
-0.0164505299,
0.0675726309,
0.0082557499,
0.0225567706,
-0.0290887672,
0.0253760424,
-0.0190540925,
0.0086410912,
0.0349046588,
0.0139690805,
-0.0073494115,
-0.0056935502,
-0.0119579975,
0.0470136777,
0.0345693603,
0.0086465264,
0.0431869216,
0.0239046998,
-0.0017631567,
-0.0275669247,
-0.1085761711,
0.0232688151,
-0.0281119198,
0.0041139596,
0.0315279178,
0.0227371138,
0.0056301109,
-0.0042587481,
-0.0070914598,
0.0537620075,
0.0052613174,
0.0043300348,
-0.0445019193,
-0.0136841992,
-0.0081373826,
-0.0045680576,
-0.017649103,
0.035842374,
0.0455225855,
0.0186892152,
-0.0702290386,
-0.0809097737,
-0.0059616612,
0.0055093155,
0.0174474809,
0.0132145723,
-0.045089379,
-0.0119476039,
-0.0327505954,
0.0461921841,
-0.0110365096,
-0.0139890974,
0.0066018617,
0.0503505208,
-0.0263894852,
-0.0285392199,
0.0107687702,
-0.0229908004,
-0.0174268801,
-0.0038303875,
-0.0575944558,
-0.0076893354,
0.0518107153,
0.0243652593,
0.007543901,
-0.0875354558,
-0.0287894532,
-0.001837109,
-0.027716551,
0.0273132138,
-0.0431134701,
0.0020352425,
0.0298088826,
-0.0337858424,
-0.0605359264,
0.0284852069,
-0.0602089018,
-0.0202127341,
-0.0353585184,
0.0292329565,
-0.0181631688,
0.0486957841,
-0.0200799089,
0.017531028,
-0.0425074138,
-0.0190287735,
-0.0373180099,
0.0760037005,
0.0027841369,
-0.0272293594,
-0.0038890173,
-0.0591669269,
-0.0068971105,
-0.0050965371,
-0.0049535912,
-0.0058154338,
0.0431039184,
-0.0314625539,
0.0125378799,
0.0680537969,
-0.0387515649,
0.031736441,
0.0323455818,
-0.020212071,
0.0808461457,
-0.0208139382,
-0.0021563389,
-0.0126231667,
-0.0111737316,
0.007752568,
-0.0439827554,
-0.0063945306,
-0.0722605065,
0.0102701159,
0.0123231765,
0.0080414461,
-0.0096186195,
-0.0284094699,
-0.0225643162,
0.0585053414,
0.0019168495,
-0.0233064946,
0.0037485587,
0.0107819354,
-0.0651490539,
-0.0222107116,
0.1259816885,
0.018797325,
-0.0715916306,
-0.0116763571,
-0.0148377521,
0.0416452885,
0.0065421471,
0.0236696359,
-0.040186327,
-0.0447771177,
0.005499762,
0.0080760652,
0.0342071094,
0.0293943025,
-0.0532635823,
-0.0887161121,
0.0092354696,
0.0462683626,
-0.0365318209,
-0.0742947385,
0.00920597,
-0.0713799745,
-0.0057078139,
-0.0089013679,
0.0182002708,
0.0222475622,
0.0155548807,
-0.0018096929,
-0.002572387,
-0.0003014933,
0.0046914001,
-0.0207391381,
0.021170672,
0.0990958884,
0.0055945022,
0.0240250062,
0.0187562145,
0.085885331,
-0.0289663821,
0.0094402116,
-0.0339989066,
0.0119356774,
-0.031446781,
0.0033467968,
0.0445048474,
-0.044645641,
-0.0092905052,
0.0166859888,
0.0300303623,
0.0103319203,
0.0010183337,
-0.0040175202,
0.0052469256,
0.0086347852,
0.0156873278,
0.0084622456,
0.0188208725,
-0.046016831,
-0.0240662303,
-0.0350773185,
-0.0020082749,
-0.0304530207,
-0.0138235595,
-0.0075866063,
-0.020246461,
-0.0977560282,
-0.0558935925,
-0.0305379406,
-0.0127026886,
0.0471039079,
0.029952731,
0.02502333,
0.024358267,
0.0309395604,
-0.0415814184,
-0.0149111701,
-0.0074160378,
0.0010576075,
-0.0516027883,
0.0195675883,
0.0120531609,
-0.0236447118,
0.0037150071,
0.0403709449,
-0.1242968142,
-0.0571474843,
-0.0291456934,
0.0564378574,
0.0135334721,
0.0630192086,
-0.035875693,
-0.0445925109,
-0.0106841279,
-0.0341351628,
-0.0387023166,
0.0131373508,
0.0150338588,
-0.0001447167,
-0.0139196869,
0.0163879767,
-0.0141361346,
0.0042735888,
-0.01782519,
0.0180942267,
-0.0125989234,
-0.0255667064,
0.0024932656,
0.0144887054,
0.0380636454,
-0.0291246083,
-0.0210645627,
-0.0160399433,
0.0383128002,
-0.0272601787,
-0.0122533562,
-0.065444231,
-0.0006009949,
0.0334268063,
-0.0352538601,
0.0099115614,
-0.005642551,
0.0194905177,
-0.0988041088,
0.033774972,
-0.008862392,
-0.0378071591,
0.0588816404,
0.0268812124,
0.0213741809,
0.0000912174,
-0.0047592674,
0.0065167197,
-0.0030348196,
-0.0614737831,
0.0372944362,
-0.0049306215,
0.0261125993,
0.0148870032,
0.0400003344,
-0.0173661038,
-0.0644227341,
-0.066897504,
-0.0112393927,
0.0587948337,
0.005749308,
0.108765021,
-0.0120754316,
0.0137746725,
-0.0400672555,
0.042363327,
0.0108757447,
-0.058418408,
0.0058449442,
-0.0160009842,
-0.0279873069,
-0.0092327902,
0.0452798456,
0.0208186861,
0.0007764584,
-0.0014665495,
-0.0300079193,
-0.0051907464,
-0.0065405448,
-0.0297783967,
-0.0410505459,
-0.0309919659,
0.0144785801,
0.0046075811,
-0.0414871834,
0.0225017425,
0.0217241682,
0.0193880014,
0.0094514545,
0.032230638,
0.0727186203,
-0.0653310195,
0.0068657212,
-0.0354965664,
-0.0074707167,
0.0149323121,
-0.0256656706,
-0.0152900107,
-6.460644052e-33,
-0.0621639974,
-0.0328033864,
0.0358876698,
-0.0668669492,
-0.0329231285,
0.0259649213,
-0.0477371141,
-0.0089039197,
0.0043553561,
-0.0018790406,
-0.0027301412,
0.0480422527,
0.0301424917,
-0.0059713363,
-0.0014407609,
0.0205454864,
0.084715277,
-0.0008437464,
-0.0295961611,
0.0175141245,
0.0140828062,
0.0432331823,
0.059824042,
-0.0330213532,
-0.0105282329,
-0.0135556487,
-0.0312042292,
-0.0119263977,
0.0160477106,
-0.002843637,
0.0234707724,
0.0144858165,
-0.0135352584,
-0.072914429,
-0.052377332,
-0.0165387709,
-0.0488873683,
0.0038518608,
0.0024937415,
0.0549875684,
-0.0011160148,
-0.0370203964,
0.0064218892,
-0.0039002532,
-0.004289601,
-0.0352589376,
-0.0027622748,
-0.0041935099,
-0.0510433428,
-0.0454494245,
-0.0469340347,
0.0284534208,
-0.0090837376,
-0.0073628193,
0.1123250648,
0.0750842616,
-0.002168017,
-0.0349470787,
-0.0359750241,
0.0312240701,
0.0200543497,
0.0731483996,
0.0865865871,
-0.0144201573,
-0.0050755525,
0.0327620544,
0.0417707935,
-0.0309240464,
0.0290997233,
0.033134263,
0.0217147116,
-0.0032935969,
0.0557647012,
0.0013286399,
0.0247550681,
-0.0409786887,
-0.0293716956,
0.0328190215,
0.0134082465,
0.0085839359,
0.0260063708,
0.0226903241,
-0.0124613559,
-0.0236062724,
-0.0306668039,
-0.0515824929,
-0.0218609273,
-0.0161331277,
0.0188864451,
0.0416708924,
-0.008876957,
-0.0091456855,
0.0923110917,
0.0019632261,
0.0645463392,
0.0411888324,
-0.0330299884,
0.0246018339,
-0.029354129,
0.0631834045,
0.0017071691,
-0.0430899225,
0.0352779068,
-0.0078121861,
-0.0028015873,
-0.0096424576,
-0.0124833081,
0.0465889908,
-0.0468147919,
0.0158042926,
-0.0275568664,
-0.0098553095,
0.0161258187,
0.0159393065,
0.0369090326,
-0.00304229,
-0.0157887954,
0.0258038156,
0.0183308944,
-0.0300079361,
-0.0075209597,
0.011149276,
0.0259961504,
0.0305096731,
-0.0513563715,
0.0445482098,
-0.0214038398,
-0.0140634701,
0.0250698552,
-0.0511191338,
-0.0672452897,
0.0287743658,
2.897e-7,
0.0631260052,
0.0618677773,
0.0232618861,
0.044867456,
0.0204142425,
-0.0157232191,
0.0099562379,
0.0259048436,
-0.0006849185,
0.0376798883,
0.0402163714,
0.0059490362,
0.0642877519,
0.0093178488,
-0.0719627738,
-0.0411187857,
-0.0378364362,
0.0506500341,
-0.0320158936,
-0.0059254486,
0.0187055934,
0.0949070603,
-0.0246872026,
0.0060688346,
-0.012084025,
0.0338879675,
0.0438288786,
0.0004431921,
0.0091496129,
-0.0006286685,
-0.0540245697,
-0.0028373578,
-0.0718318149,
-0.0037038603,
-0.0515685268,
-0.0149124237,
0.077281557,
0.1002763882,
-0.0243473221,
-0.0082812412,
0.0752940029,
0.0298011396,
-0.0315149315,
0.0012865931,
0.0508232377,
-0.0080745248,
0.0103193307,
-0.018088745,
-0.0166367143,
0.0371461473,
0.0110704359,
-0.0098030539,
-0.0268413667,
0.0353929587,
0.0516685359,
0.0287679229,
-0.0186721683,
-0.0421592481,
-0.0585171059,
-0.0388872325,
-0.0265704393,
-0.037375208,
-0.0302041247,
0.0000642675,
0.0055128592,
-0.0160404779,
-0.0215665326,
3.012001547e-34,
0.0518481359,
-0.0219006725,
0.0253397767,
0.0512868203,
0.02358911,
-0.0606672838,
0.0251098871,
0.01929098,
-0.0229275934,
-0.0341930166,
-0.0854763985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14480v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14480v1 | MetaAID 2.5: A Secure Framework for Developing Metaverse Applications via Large Language Models | 2023-12-22T07:15:55 | 2023-12-22T07:15:55 | Hongyin Zhu | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.CY | Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being used in Metaverse
environments to generate dynamic and realistic content and to control the
behavior of non-player characters (NPCs). However, the cybersecurity concerns
associated with LLMs have become increasingly prominent. Previous research has
primarily focused on patching system vulnerabilities to enhance cybersecurity,
but these approaches are not well-suited to the Metaverse, where the virtual
space is more complex, LLMs are vulnerable, and ethical user interaction is
critical. Moreover, the scope of cybersecurity in the Metaverse is expected to
expand significantly. This paper proposes a method for enhancing cybersecurity
through the simulation of user interaction with LLMs. Our goal is to educate
users and strengthen their defense capabilities through exposure to a
comprehensive simulation system. This system includes extensive Metaverse
cybersecurity Q&A and attack simulation scenarios. By engaging with these,
users will improve their ability to recognize and withstand risks.
Additionally, to address the ethical implications of user input, we propose
using LLMs as evaluators to assess user content across five dimensions. We
further adapt the models through vocabulary expansion training to better
understand personalized inputs and emoticons. We conduct experiments on
multiple LLMs and find that our approach is effective. | [
0.047142107,
0.0277198683,
-0.0174341127,
0.0289657284,
-0.0220269803,
-0.0284742769,
0.0412845239,
-0.0091009429,
-0.0057907142,
0.0104686385,
-0.0022222351,
-0.0089629097,
-0.0167892426,
0.0384287909,
0.0426296704,
-0.0287327729,
0.0560277514,
-0.080243066,
-0.0110539682,
0.0052977875,
-0.0048127943,
-0.0133085465,
-0.0248981118,
0.0303357039,
0.0539917164,
-0.019377375,
-0.0157599486,
0.0169526637,
0.0668338686,
-0.0508487001,
-0.0071550906,
0.0030094357,
0.0196691304,
0.0211681239,
0.0000021537,
-0.0502319187,
0.0078229448,
0.0184184313,
-0.0549928695,
0.0429269858,
0.0468541719,
0.0243784375,
-0.0098150689,
0.0329368524,
-0.0055055437,
0.0080498401,
0.0731190145,
0.0163599905,
0.0935178027,
0.0347630382,
-0.0040969825,
-0.0120844627,
-0.0382456481,
0.0075573511,
-0.0110193044,
-0.0061597922,
0.0009069217,
0.000965092,
0.0523643494,
0.0412425399,
0.0143645583,
-0.0013466962,
0.0059647164,
-0.0109897759,
-0.0033259403,
0.0430718735,
0.0047015999,
0.0295894314,
-0.0189452078,
0.0292937458,
0.0071711456,
-0.0251699071,
-0.0004598004,
0.0166813824,
0.0123349363,
0.0791841373,
-0.0018116024,
-0.0184295643,
-0.0190874264,
-0.0386642441,
-0.029410189,
0.0302066822,
0.0532982722,
0.028780926,
0.0154800676,
0.050396096,
0.0249083731,
-0.0440231711,
-0.0778433383,
-0.0660965368,
0.0155305117,
-0.0251478739,
-0.0029322936,
0.0144897457,
-0.0126480516,
0.0235697497,
-0.0233212095,
-0.0363991931,
0.0538907833,
-0.051895041,
0.0394473486,
0.026353877,
0.0154149728,
0.0043854825,
0.052312471,
0.0053775529,
0.0026496071,
0.000299447,
0.0372007638,
0.0222902931,
-0.0411785021,
-0.036619924,
-0.0005550994,
0.0186395124,
0.0040127975,
0.0301703122,
-0.0128954137,
0.0322217457,
-0.0156663638,
0.051193323,
-0.0124188038,
-0.0273630396,
-0.0164797921,
-0.0001917812,
-0.0091985147,
-0.0172374714,
-0.0709403977,
-0.0179589484,
-0.0147829903,
-0.0438124463,
-0.0035767257,
-0.0096404469,
-0.0467692576,
-0.0218894351,
0.0121145481,
0.1389795989,
0.0628546849,
-0.0133521715,
0.001839073,
-0.0811347738,
-0.0197296236,
0.0059801154,
-0.0158225168,
-0.0564558655,
-0.0227530058,
-0.0272041373,
0.0102045853,
0.0178342555,
-0.0022460539,
0.0023737939,
-0.0121602854,
0.0990694985,
-0.0224870052,
0.0078076604,
0.0305217169,
0.0110127525,
0.03182742,
-0.0145326033,
0.0057159527,
0.0615551956,
0.0090550845,
-0.0123980548,
0.0605946928,
0.0307883583,
-0.0283349641,
0.0409289747,
-0.0227336474,
0.0106326221,
0.0381917581,
0.0130343596,
-0.0416895151,
0.009011603,
-0.0394661911,
0.0027668215,
0.0899201855,
0.0283087827,
-0.0297323894,
0.0076558515,
0.0376864709,
0.0233935751,
0.0105883256,
-0.0362909175,
-0.0189471655,
0.0418907367,
-0.0423082821,
-0.0167810656,
-0.0612999685,
0.0119214281,
-0.0099250339,
0.0511745848,
-0.0062531368,
-0.0398375914,
0.0362149514,
0.0281843096,
0.008830579,
0.024558194,
0.0179297198,
-0.0303237755,
0.0393237323,
-0.0754846483,
0.004171235,
-0.0723045021,
-0.0204388835,
0.1391087621,
0.0536473058,
-0.0030529029,
-0.0655261651,
-0.0631278753,
-0.0033939744,
0.0552685522,
0.0204846505,
0.0053379782,
-0.0087839104,
-0.0232230052,
0.0111867907,
-0.0184340142,
-0.0214702766,
0.1029135436,
-0.0395063199,
-0.0324335508,
-0.0126527837,
0.0317940265,
0.0032184068,
0.0073388619,
-0.0387800001,
-0.0441444926,
-0.0252541993,
0.001863595,
0.0330560617,
0.0212156605,
-0.0023588869,
0.0197110604,
0.0253237393,
-0.0057629142,
-0.0064216917,
0.0150311207,
-0.0028314355,
0.0776397437,
0.0793693736,
-0.0718943626,
0.0371106267,
0.034470804,
0.010660382,
0.0271658078,
0.060804937,
-0.0216901042,
0.0067830919,
-0.0081548924,
-0.0051075397,
-0.023113329,
0.0118192658,
-0.0300856717,
0.0211567748,
-0.0115714166,
-0.0339648314,
-0.0102277687,
-0.004960278,
0.0193764996,
-0.0293390397,
-0.0167787839,
0.0189891998,
-0.0117908204,
0.0324197449,
0.0291939266,
0.0020092383,
-0.026628362,
-0.0486439802,
-0.0667067096,
-0.0212442558,
-0.0061103133,
0.0297179371,
0.0553736798,
0.009727031,
-0.0576740168,
-0.014520607,
0.0009864438,
-0.0301302709,
-0.0063700001,
-0.0039191134,
0.0128410123,
0.009455367,
-0.0129115582,
-0.0049365438,
-0.0033487438,
-0.0130858626,
0.0415017754,
0.0016153485,
0.0344708711,
-0.0051984834,
0.0081659006,
-0.0349405296,
-0.0504922271,
-0.0146999368,
-0.0814682692,
0.0422024764,
-0.0260046665,
0.0080994973,
-0.0493724346,
0.0579099581,
0.0317394696,
0.0820250884,
-0.0124332309,
-0.0261810776,
-0.017040519,
0.02855861,
-0.0380831659,
-0.0505695641,
-0.0318316557,
0.0534897521,
0.0467240289,
0.021095084,
0.0320785493,
-0.0719292536,
0.06012192,
-0.0053075608,
-0.0417281352,
-0.0013984714,
-0.0560371093,
-0.0343972519,
-0.0297155585,
0.0045876373,
0.0002046033,
0.077740185,
-0.0488918722,
0.0003393989,
-0.031158736,
-0.0198964756,
0.0074522374,
0.0216446389,
-0.0604357123,
0.0236944221,
0.0339419432,
-0.0300709363,
-0.0198132806,
-0.0762817934,
0.0656111985,
-0.0269960742,
-0.0427689776,
-0.0168965012,
-0.0263792705,
0.0497539863,
0.0139328297,
-0.0324789025,
-0.0410841256,
-0.0611247122,
-0.020758003,
-0.0265972409,
-0.0268869717,
-0.0149094686,
-0.0303173214,
0.066014275,
-0.005527311,
0.0048890277,
-0.0270267874,
-0.0012679927,
-0.0401507951,
0.0322713777,
-0.0293457247,
-0.0272043385,
-0.0474050678,
0.0457546934,
0.041687943,
-0.0026373959,
-0.0508378632,
-0.0059101828,
-0.0021518799,
0.0379882902,
-0.0375017561,
0.0186825376,
0.0648009777,
0.0209467243,
-0.0325749852,
-0.0061057582,
0.0548642874,
0.033385694,
0.032936234,
0.0270130187,
-0.0618110001,
-0.020534208,
0.0220869407,
0.0260476843,
-0.0625473037,
0.0102537591,
-0.0072581042,
0.0393348783,
-0.032012295,
-0.0308120046,
0.0024835535,
-0.0537232049,
0.0197511688,
0.0129396524,
-0.0229719449,
0.0005981676,
-0.0294029918,
-0.0052712886,
0.0533312261,
0.0238632839,
-0.025211174,
-0.0089723878,
-0.0055007818,
-0.0012021556,
0.0024324825,
-0.0293036029,
0.0175211933,
-0.0353679545,
0.0744228438,
0.0620371066,
0.0170769319,
-0.0593003184,
-0.0284966528,
-0.0035909915,
0.0069457637,
0.024105357,
-0.007956855,
0.0294731613,
-0.0041452418,
0.0065834951,
-0.0203222055,
0.0095118992,
0.0065017133,
-0.0697206035,
0.0281402618,
0.0445410125,
-0.0394390784,
0.0012663248,
-0.0611146167,
-0.0045589809,
0.0615585223,
0.0294122491,
0.0166865755,
-0.0685258731,
0.0128786648,
-0.0358935408,
-0.0059229429,
-0.0000563289,
-0.0399822034,
-0.03106061,
0.0508535393,
-0.0042331046,
-0.0598073304,
-0.0487124883,
-0.0209917333,
0.032984592,
0.0057194429,
-0.0415914655,
-0.0165034551,
0.0232378207,
0.0188287571,
-0.0466325171,
-0.0699761286,
0.0459360406,
0.0026681311,
0.0333663113,
-0.0163963754,
-0.086153321,
0.0001215598,
0.0142248813,
-0.0066982242,
-0.0597818382,
0.0052609215,
0.0613807216,
0.0247029215,
-0.0399801619,
-0.0285784807,
-0.0355800167,
0.075219892,
0.0065774107,
-0.1029386222,
-0.0165218022,
0.0481004715,
-0.0021672517,
0.0213785134,
-0.0382566601,
-0.0020851537,
-0.0076595014,
0.0393488631,
0.0176173151,
-0.06246626,
-0.0476157181,
0.0246748384,
0.0769815817,
0.0131321158,
-0.0499135666,
0.0185189173,
0.0279164258,
0.0036233808,
-0.066372782,
-0.0240681972,
0.0504227057,
0.0019664294,
-0.004324601,
-0.0245777909,
0.0637733862,
0.0110346666,
-0.0362010971,
-0.0013574784,
0.0164680686,
0.0529593565,
0.0182044096,
0.0650293007,
0.0460412726,
0.0159861222,
0.0068583838,
0.0120719131,
-0.0129610179,
0.0101812715,
0.0179764256,
0.0323181376,
-0.0077541349,
-0.0176440291,
-0.0483933687,
0.049700059,
-0.0656114593,
-0.0473410599,
0.0531180464,
0.079433687,
0.0206866432,
0.0820916146,
-0.0125535894,
-0.0696176663,
0.0127394171,
-0.0403043032,
-0.0324154943,
0.0014751502,
-0.0442908183,
-0.0002834307,
0.026515143,
-0.0143084815,
-0.0129868174,
0.026676707,
-0.0409900174,
0.0625768602,
0.0186926164,
0.0018215143,
-0.0485023297,
-0.0071624233,
-0.0023372746,
0.0844262838,
-0.0609142333,
-0.0271171145,
-0.0857706144,
-0.0314144641,
0.0085194893,
0.0248313472,
0.0086412244,
-0.0152357696,
0.0163923278,
0.0197953787,
-0.0252652578,
0.0365208983,
-0.0652026013,
0.0496528856,
-0.0126227476,
-0.0516170114,
0.0036243873,
-5.932769212e-33,
0.0336642452,
-0.0215656273,
0.0189658701,
0.0191841163,
-0.0172032416,
-0.0310754981,
-0.0401613377,
0.0005731845,
0.0089428248,
-0.0184675232,
0.0301239472,
-0.0397597775,
0.0116821704,
-0.0105377538,
-0.0544009879,
-0.0386861302,
0.0449807309,
0.0357756689,
-0.0205067061,
0.0352576412,
0.052591525,
-0.008733416,
-0.0025994438,
-0.0971811563,
0.0476379022,
-0.0042921663,
-0.0237223264,
-0.013500846,
-0.0229599383,
0.0178134888,
0.0001236049,
0.0356819555,
0.000112668,
-0.0150223747,
0.0089408113,
0.0471893959,
0.0222992282,
-0.009218351,
0.0110094519,
-0.0442114137,
0.0305754896,
-0.1073203385,
-0.0167423785,
-0.0064785047,
0.0097799143,
0.0014142522,
0.0166316107,
0.0021804131,
0.0043434151,
-0.0111592533,
-0.0303503629,
0.004877415,
-0.051381927,
0.0117324209,
-0.0082078539,
0.0302609261,
0.0121059846,
-0.0021640514,
-0.0103100101,
0.0767262653,
0.01234682,
-0.0423859321,
0.039220497,
0.0213437863,
0.0022837117,
0.0539459139,
-0.0346087888,
-0.0091188187,
-0.0142291496,
0.0110370759,
0.0251852088,
-0.0108296247,
0.04733181,
0.1467506438,
-0.0020388267,
-0.0558290258,
-0.02122619,
0.007269199,
-0.014936069,
0.0577148199,
0.0518837385,
-0.0127061382,
-0.0760187134,
0.0164307114,
-0.008484914,
0.0009444887,
-0.0203237385,
-0.0800811723,
0.0224367939,
-0.0487831719,
-0.0808719918,
-0.0375701971,
-0.0022559853,
-0.0168632194,
0.0217683949,
0.0264411811,
0.0107253147,
-0.0053294725,
-0.0354717411,
0.0117686549,
0.0212201979,
0.0124118412,
-0.001753999,
-0.0585911907,
0.0212527141,
0.0141190393,
-0.0124892872,
0.0448387675,
-0.0423774272,
0.0042056618,
0.0141496528,
0.0317262486,
-0.0057757385,
0.0486926213,
0.0056457915,
-0.0171729457,
0.0128917759,
-0.0409066938,
0.0436042324,
-0.0688102916,
-0.0002850549,
0.0074840793,
-0.0403346159,
0.019134691,
-0.002255247,
0.0267742202,
-0.0585922822,
0.0360192545,
0.0646101609,
-0.0500254482,
-0.0169045031,
-0.0305943023,
3.031e-7,
-0.0212179832,
0.0429405421,
0.0231386814,
0.0012184146,
0.0009253498,
0.0848388448,
-0.0011782711,
0.0775618702,
0.0089921141,
-0.046822194,
-0.0027745841,
0.0101640224,
0.0397461727,
0.042496983,
-0.0390046425,
0.0068819807,
-0.0615282729,
-0.0043974449,
-0.0581168383,
0.0141465636,
0.0829143301,
0.0046340525,
0.0279420912,
-0.0225583185,
0.0076505635,
-0.0152433412,
-0.0040279757,
-0.0332333855,
-0.02995486,
-0.0174449999,
-0.0259600561,
0.0414050184,
0.0021419418,
0.0261105616,
-0.0359807983,
-0.0343118422,
-0.0391134545,
0.0363792926,
0.0207828768,
0.02570506,
-0.0341021307,
-0.037809778,
-0.0122391172,
-0.0452333279,
0.0256277248,
-0.0096742604,
-0.0304687526,
0.0118180616,
-0.0416645072,
-0.0030954948,
-0.0234877877,
-0.0711481869,
-0.0207415875,
-0.0164550226,
0.0035724097,
0.0292326417,
0.0201598015,
-0.0298586804,
0.006862809,
-0.0033295986,
-0.0271558892,
-0.0451199152,
-0.0010740281,
-0.0004870573,
0.0404792093,
-0.0316841491,
0.0432837121,
2.528456665e-34,
-0.0311600119,
0.0108965235,
0.0020892804,
-0.0317700952,
0.0147142923,
0.039102152,
-0.0108717009,
0.0419668965,
0.0407001153,
-0.0223639309,
0.0021521889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.17259v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.17259v2 | Empowering Working Memory for Large Language Model Agents | 2023-12-22T05:59:00 | 2024-05-28T05:34:52 | Jing Guo, Nan Li, Jianchuan Qi, Hang Yang, Ruiqiao Li, Yuzhen Feng, Si Zhang, Ming Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive linguistic
capabilities. However, a key limitation persists in their lack of human-like
memory faculties. LLMs exhibit constrained memory retention across sequential
interactions, hindering complex reasoning. This paper explores the potential of
applying cognitive psychology's working memory frameworks, to enhance LLM
architecture. The limitations of traditional LLM memory designs are analyzed,
including their isolation of distinct dialog episodes and lack of persistent
memory links. To address this, an innovative model is proposed incorporating a
centralized Working Memory Hub and Episodic Buffer access to retain memories
across episodes. This architecture aims to provide greater continuity for
nuanced contextual reasoning during intricate tasks and collaborative
scenarios. While promising, further research is required into optimizing
episodic memory encoding, storage, prioritization, retrieval, and security.
Overall, this paper provides a strategic blueprint for developing LLM agents
with more sophisticated, human-like memory capabilities, highlighting memory
mechanisms as a vital frontier in artificial general intelligence. | [
0.0602893084,
0.0159917586,
-0.0514599569,
0.0395448059,
-0.0347769745,
0.0037798537,
0.0168908201,
-0.0284980778,
0.0485719703,
-0.0400027931,
-0.0231087357,
-0.0780312046,
-0.0365181491,
0.0310756695,
0.0150686298,
-0.0647784621,
0.0391020924,
-0.0512767583,
0.0468411297,
-0.0069624307,
-0.0338685252,
-0.0222053993,
-0.0076880013,
0.0122158919,
-0.0195090789,
-0.0033465747,
-0.0255499091,
-0.0179295391,
0.0137351453,
-0.0345863104,
-0.0244382862,
0.0187582839,
0.017159408,
-0.0017160148,
0.0000022424,
-0.0713637397,
0.0175307356,
-0.0284607708,
-0.0577911735,
-0.0032272518,
0.0215586051,
0.042390082,
-0.0201080833,
0.0011414222,
-0.0403470248,
0.0103396513,
0.0265371352,
0.0366703644,
0.0403931141,
0.0409107395,
-0.0051850271,
-0.0050063734,
-0.0097544696,
-0.0065454477,
-0.0251139738,
-0.0739999488,
0.0276161693,
0.0074560051,
0.0031071971,
0.0009990525,
-0.0081397211,
0.0227202363,
0.0324404463,
0.0040639914,
0.0035067045,
0.0266991463,
-0.0107800597,
-0.040945977,
-0.0207073111,
0.0402228087,
0.0379958637,
-0.0133592449,
0.0003599343,
0.0116484743,
0.0053955205,
-0.0273625348,
-0.0508414581,
0.0702613592,
-0.0342852548,
-0.0278022829,
0.0136131644,
-0.0299718007,
0.0149002355,
0.0250184592,
-0.031840615,
0.010867496,
-0.0015525919,
-0.0119714206,
0.0031872361,
-0.0393958502,
0.0034142004,
-0.0493979305,
0.042794697,
0.0777877495,
-0.0407143086,
0.036589928,
-0.0170462318,
0.0293981656,
0.036139261,
-0.0774054751,
0.0135025624,
0.0158318207,
-0.0117058139,
0.0404877812,
-0.0319291204,
0.051943779,
-0.0437705517,
0.0054476075,
-0.010095302,
-0.0182976294,
-0.0603110716,
-0.0133876903,
-0.0312146787,
0.0623090379,
-0.0186871365,
-0.0259449966,
-0.0290100221,
0.0706396848,
0.0082101496,
0.0302825477,
-0.0117220543,
0.0199467149,
0.0279715378,
-0.0041406774,
-0.0581794269,
0.0029536067,
-0.0547113195,
-0.0091687487,
0.0076214829,
-0.0321717449,
-0.0067235716,
0.0065487614,
-0.025073804,
-0.0047979834,
0.0117149334,
0.0717688799,
0.0056867134,
-0.0289118495,
-0.0606756918,
-0.0126059866,
0.0064495006,
-0.0835427269,
0.0147407753,
-0.0236342419,
0.0377598777,
0.0426267833,
-0.031523563,
-0.0378630944,
0.0017719427,
-0.0056212619,
-0.0325594321,
0.0281931665,
0.0344518386,
-0.0239029173,
0.0508860983,
0.0300077349,
0.0054808389,
0.0237870477,
0.0479152128,
0.0171980653,
0.0127253383,
0.0152781578,
-0.0125598861,
-0.0124918902,
-0.0181422383,
-0.0360736437,
0.0004790326,
0.0122780828,
0.0375537351,
-0.0115359435,
0.0041535255,
0.0567218475,
-0.0061379722,
-0.0313422047,
0.0523992591,
0.067089811,
-0.0370859243,
0.0140264286,
0.0000921629,
0.0174397975,
0.0265145265,
-0.015914103,
-0.0622559935,
0.0693675354,
0.0042290604,
-0.0210797321,
-0.0323142074,
0.0298877209,
-0.0278257504,
-0.0040769307,
-0.0105497725,
0.004202974,
0.0101366499,
0.0385545455,
0.0199519992,
-0.0473690853,
-0.0462327488,
0.0616053417,
-0.0151106035,
-0.0347158164,
-0.0213368591,
-0.0777453333,
0.0174170919,
0.0828089416,
0.0075261267,
-0.0147230821,
-0.0255960152,
0.021795895,
-0.0022784967,
0.0369270816,
0.0289366674,
-0.0022757908,
0.0203166865,
-0.0441709869,
0.0104039935,
-0.0261480436,
0.0042950409,
0.0412784815,
0.0175177287,
0.0184757188,
0.0095343459,
0.0614542067,
0.011272029,
-0.0084134648,
-0.0242761355,
-0.0135539351,
-0.0547820218,
-0.0045895712,
0.024993604,
0.0091350367,
-0.0140951602,
0.0073866933,
0.0343752839,
-0.0290727951,
-0.0073566963,
0.0681080818,
-0.0809654146,
0.0508134477,
0.0053910078,
0.0405781344,
0.0337054394,
-0.0447775908,
0.0180614013,
-0.0523067266,
0.008311864,
-0.0220067557,
0.0680340827,
-0.0363966711,
0.0629846975,
-0.0103043821,
-0.0164389852,
-0.0212331675,
0.0788570568,
-0.0172874164,
-0.0217616539,
0.0176784154,
0.0540862568,
0.0030241618,
-0.0600107647,
-0.0005108379,
0.047850091,
0.0169581901,
0.003478931,
-0.0008437663,
-0.0579338819,
-0.0653775185,
-0.0370121635,
-0.0692584664,
-0.004506263,
0.0019642597,
-0.0064731874,
-0.0050894064,
-0.0459095798,
-0.0163972303,
0.0101235127,
-0.0232380908,
0.046090655,
0.0209789835,
0.0317116603,
-0.0197436921,
0.0204049069,
-0.0276135411,
-0.0179856513,
0.0156735554,
0.0155694894,
0.0054897349,
-0.0094908932,
-0.0355214626,
-0.0526499227,
0.0357135385,
-0.0167203676,
0.0352257863,
-0.0348018222,
-0.0291737076,
0.0259616617,
0.0002027502,
0.0480859913,
0.1207795739,
-0.0047377101,
0.0257057715,
0.0598716959,
-0.058572825,
-0.0347007811,
0.0260608289,
0.0025212516,
-0.001202521,
-0.0474466607,
0.0070472127,
-0.029302299,
0.0383925252,
0.0137978103,
0.0495165698,
-0.0111191403,
0.0047308975,
-0.0042136912,
-0.0703946948,
-0.0109931426,
-0.0367800891,
-0.0481445938,
0.0238345377,
-0.0147710051,
-0.0247079208,
0.0370468572,
0.0210581198,
0.0123713659,
-0.0057909219,
0.0110830916,
-0.026375642,
0.0859876722,
-0.012603594,
0.0145095475,
-0.0305010471,
-0.0285045486,
-0.0516512953,
-0.0425133556,
-0.0223150626,
-0.0530402251,
0.0065859254,
-0.0655392632,
-0.0222884938,
-0.0145991193,
-0.0328846276,
-0.0776602551,
0.0697130933,
-0.0617754646,
0.0056886473,
0.0126554864,
-0.0191011336,
-0.0608507209,
0.0040436303,
0.0658941716,
0.0010812049,
0.0052982508,
-0.0040539047,
-0.0097041186,
0.0014052476,
0.0083491746,
0.0223128125,
0.0358742252,
-0.0304689743,
0.0659228191,
0.0901043192,
0.0522261374,
-0.0079594096,
0.040315073,
-0.0017536461,
0.0238190703,
-0.0257387161,
-0.026954554,
0.0244695283,
0.0345604867,
-0.0607247502,
-0.0231400281,
0.1184247062,
0.0488463379,
-0.0729269311,
-0.0199685507,
-0.0713400617,
0.0054140892,
0.0530379787,
0.0386254452,
-0.0208127368,
-0.003287375,
0.0211607385,
-0.0359430835,
-0.0473189801,
-0.036385648,
-0.0197894406,
-0.0927396491,
0.0128728468,
0.0164254159,
-0.0013599019,
0.0103629753,
-0.0290208273,
-0.0283330102,
0.028231563,
0.0384019911,
0.0246839225,
0.011337583,
-0.0519199036,
0.0241368823,
-0.0089697894,
-0.0083858697,
0.0486758351,
-0.0291766394,
0.0578294098,
0.0061302227,
0.0240189563,
0.0191219971,
-0.031098498,
-0.01546265,
0.0107640633,
0.0438356176,
-0.0195447505,
0.0355028957,
-0.0232834797,
0.0006255308,
-0.0494807251,
-0.009546251,
0.0076885531,
-0.0529647991,
0.043917533,
0.0458462611,
-0.0500426665,
0.0078097722,
0.0172067378,
0.0068034064,
-0.0114729954,
0.0870648697,
-0.0014342451,
-0.0409842767,
-0.0459737554,
0.0014469132,
-0.0042315847,
-0.0379508175,
-0.0262557697,
0.0299548358,
0.026307974,
0.0320446938,
-0.0247143451,
-0.0379029699,
0.0349392928,
0.0284542739,
0.0348676108,
0.0042536473,
0.0048502856,
-0.0090659335,
-0.0379486866,
-0.0212971102,
-0.0533118136,
-0.0053449874,
-0.0768188164,
-0.0056761894,
0.0432695039,
-0.043435052,
0.0166734066,
0.021782577,
-0.0731183439,
-0.0367274918,
0.0459789708,
0.0462697931,
0.0245847665,
0.0335793532,
0.0419487655,
-0.0254484266,
0.0113033839,
-0.025576083,
-0.0526523106,
0.0329444632,
0.0165817421,
0.0204620808,
0.0094040586,
0.0258253645,
-0.0307196006,
0.0028712691,
0.0213841349,
0.0357725136,
-0.0451874398,
-0.0186666921,
0.004572778,
-0.0076315706,
-0.0391624011,
0.0024926935,
-0.0146324206,
-0.0235392954,
0.0667931959,
-0.0329806581,
0.009777505,
0.0022313031,
0.0092261517,
-0.013852587,
0.0050196555,
0.0250342432,
-0.0225461479,
0.0209900066,
-0.0097096572,
0.0478626788,
0.0030871134,
0.0150103401,
-0.019163426,
0.0054159164,
0.0262568071,
-0.0362033732,
0.0195532963,
-0.0109210806,
0.0692699626,
-0.009574715,
0.139432162,
-0.0028126419,
-0.0834116787,
-0.0340192169,
0.0278055016,
-0.0676843449,
-0.0849627852,
0.064391844,
0.0193348993,
0.0487665944,
-0.0298987422,
0.0156549606,
-0.0642935857,
0.0202960204,
-0.0132445646,
-0.0198663156,
0.0186412688,
-0.0317134447,
-0.0099455062,
0.0399287902,
-0.0106022572,
0.0271049831,
0.0182997957,
-0.0009658404,
0.0226686187,
-0.0080558686,
-0.0190861207,
-0.0192354545,
-0.0430196933,
0.0214495324,
0.0119031463,
-0.0194328632,
-0.0227351524,
-0.1024168953,
-0.0517477095,
-0.0018260035,
-0.0080480715,
0.0004463669,
-0.0432800576,
0.0099807149,
0.040222358,
0.0068000522,
-0.0354747437,
-0.008681478,
-0.0001872747,
0.0033913527,
0.0256355982,
0.0102279363,
-6.679673915e-33,
-0.003109219,
-0.0359460749,
0.0570539683,
-0.0333033465,
-0.0135373436,
-0.0168726072,
-0.037851274,
-0.0005717163,
-0.0359676927,
-0.0458396114,
-0.025457155,
0.0255789813,
0.03349052,
-0.000538139,
0.0124411359,
0.0202487502,
0.0294754747,
0.0318270437,
-0.0102488678,
0.0599412546,
0.0828009471,
0.0286956504,
0.0127091147,
-0.0455038585,
0.0216501821,
0.0077688545,
0.0524931476,
0.0206575785,
-0.0212275293,
0.0458946042,
-0.0370340124,
0.0241883732,
0.0203745048,
-0.0324613228,
-0.0003893513,
0.0295923501,
-0.0498051308,
-0.0185812488,
0.0468720682,
-0.006472521,
0.0230001844,
-0.0472137593,
-0.0187782664,
0.0006645665,
-0.0013611268,
0.0134465108,
-0.0002542548,
-0.0241429713,
-0.0353979021,
0.0536936298,
-0.0692423657,
-0.0185579751,
0.0183706172,
0.0481533334,
-0.0073819761,
-0.0323443785,
-0.0245760493,
-0.0244135074,
-0.0919164196,
0.0067954105,
-0.0373184606,
-0.0048688687,
0.0534857996,
0.0707350522,
0.0106270695,
0.0740214959,
0.0469126776,
0.0430526286,
-0.0296964366,
-0.0089755673,
0.0240293182,
0.0340020135,
0.0134873362,
0.0018668249,
-0.0045916988,
-0.0352513231,
-0.0397688784,
-0.0560470708,
0.0299968068,
0.0725575462,
0.092615746,
0.006974394,
-0.0299563706,
-0.0310241636,
-0.0374005176,
0.0702956021,
-0.0295962002,
-0.0271383114,
0.0404283293,
0.0155493524,
-0.0088982396,
-0.0423727296,
0.0394146889,
0.0150601538,
0.0363540538,
0.0401286297,
0.0274214186,
0.020205196,
-0.0233158711,
0.0253941864,
-0.0679500178,
-0.0123940585,
-0.0310809445,
0.0152252791,
0.0057127303,
0.0228755642,
-0.0181180164,
0.0079725683,
-0.0194639377,
0.0014422386,
-0.047391016,
0.0236963816,
0.0149919894,
-0.0153005216,
0.0036417134,
0.0310785361,
-0.0066950945,
0.0341965444,
0.003883539,
-0.0336118266,
-0.0162655339,
-0.0084324321,
0.0025383476,
0.0230585579,
-0.0128874565,
0.0087394807,
-0.0414366089,
0.0780669227,
0.0147873564,
-0.0552329831,
0.0377229042,
-0.0113935247,
3.01e-7,
-0.0458949283,
0.0428920165,
0.003482325,
0.0110207032,
0.0096481675,
0.0090937093,
0.0021426084,
0.0046482659,
0.0503782891,
-0.0477093533,
-0.0052097091,
0.097316727,
0.0066095525,
0.0327972136,
-0.0668723434,
-0.0471386127,
-0.0051223929,
-0.0397872664,
-0.0486915484,
0.0237609632,
0.0614793375,
0.0609177426,
0.0464427508,
-0.031462919,
-0.0212675687,
-0.0588258244,
0.0643071607,
-0.0509745516,
0.0256582256,
0.0018912359,
-0.009117364,
0.0326855518,
0.0143177183,
0.0710090175,
0.0285195392,
-0.0029558472,
-0.0769617781,
0.0552297272,
-0.0090727862,
-0.0659362003,
-0.0000990037,
-0.0010268764,
-0.0261536743,
-0.0382281095,
0.0482736863,
-0.0683013871,
-0.0486789905,
0.064840436,
0.0294412374,
-0.0053565702,
-0.0409106538,
0.0012668124,
0.0075594806,
0.00974169,
-0.0390051603,
0.0068897912,
0.0394198485,
-0.1011990756,
0.0178534426,
0.0210196357,
-0.0232904498,
-0.0645203814,
-0.0362572782,
-0.0241324697,
0.0110605666,
-0.0433600247,
0.0080288136,
2.634531026e-34,
0.0092284828,
0.0203097295,
0.0282162074,
0.0861473382,
0.0414842553,
0.0105117587,
-0.0013615943,
0.0243331175,
0.0346575156,
-0.0803553164,
-0.0236503445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14423v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14423v1 | Efficacy of Machine-Generated Instructions | 2023-12-22T04:01:30 | 2023-12-22T04:01:30 | Samaksh Gulati, Anshit Verma, Manoj Parmar, Palash Chaudhary | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large "instruction-tuned" language models (i.e., finetuned to respond to
instructions) have demonstrated a remarkable ability to generalize zero-shot to
new tasks. Nevertheless, they depend heavily on human-written instruction data
that is often limited in quantity, diversity, and creativity, therefore
hindering the generality of the tuned model. We conducted a quantitative study
to figure out the efficacy of machine-generated annotations, where we compare
the results of a fine-tuned BERT model with human v/s machine-generated
annotations. Applying our methods to the vanilla GPT-3 model, we saw that
machine generated annotations were 78.54% correct and the fine-tuned model
achieved a 96.01% model performance compared to the performance with
human-labelled annotations. This result shows that machine-generated
annotations are a resource and cost effective way to fine-tune down-stream
models. | [
0.0371998176,
0.0080131348,
-0.0327988863,
0.0148881776,
-0.002372944,
0.0165681168,
-0.0281679742,
-0.0209412333,
-0.0181188714,
-0.078273803,
-0.0351694077,
0.0065863435,
-0.019246906,
-0.0046352083,
0.06077585,
-0.0734550431,
0.0473703481,
-0.0396355912,
-0.0047105076,
0.0241659433,
-0.0026607416,
0.0274879485,
0.0032021555,
0.0688146576,
0.0084666237,
-0.0083292369,
-0.0288607329,
0.0314855985,
-0.0091423234,
-0.0072173863,
-0.016603943,
0.0732758045,
0.0360556245,
0.03295305,
0.0000018677,
-0.0455900878,
0.0045036143,
0.0138243958,
-0.0475062951,
0.0638309792,
-0.0154506965,
0.0052690883,
-0.048587162,
0.0113948379,
-0.0111706145,
0.0067834682,
0.0654835552,
-0.0171823837,
0.069500275,
0.086496301,
-0.0040389043,
-0.0095772939,
0.0272559207,
-0.0098249149,
0.0367825516,
-0.0272745918,
-0.0147661511,
0.0292210449,
0.0371869095,
0.0200645495,
0.0009509517,
-0.0001507236,
0.0135706551,
-0.0015220938,
-0.000734407,
0.0421525873,
-0.0525890775,
0.0054006414,
-0.0411271341,
0.053950198,
-0.036072135,
-0.0191618744,
0.0005494131,
-0.0217834525,
0.0129690822,
-0.0173107423,
-0.0295561478,
0.0383503251,
-0.0125921052,
-0.0005368964,
0.0248650853,
-0.0453427844,
0.0091581959,
-0.0179301817,
0.0163397007,
0.0714638233,
0.0232588947,
-0.0350352004,
-0.0299028568,
-0.0078719119,
-0.0470429435,
-0.0689636841,
-0.0108151687,
0.0322456956,
-0.0030770972,
0.013569383,
-0.0765716583,
-0.0134097431,
0.0272543672,
-0.0330649838,
0.0895420089,
0.0667504966,
-0.0079502417,
-0.0061171446,
-0.0275709312,
0.0606028177,
-0.0169884413,
0.0143949129,
-0.0114534432,
0.0367568284,
-0.0897790715,
-0.0064135268,
-0.0650658756,
0.0401038229,
-0.0325042792,
-0.0013898456,
-0.0431275405,
0.0737727359,
0.0262949597,
-0.00266477,
0.0074885562,
-0.0250940509,
-0.0659594387,
0.0056540202,
-0.0098256245,
-0.0059514479,
-0.0528632812,
-0.0016882344,
0.0040725558,
-0.0828257874,
0.0028003515,
0.0135013023,
-0.021246044,
-0.0256672744,
0.0216230061,
0.0668299943,
-0.0176638812,
-0.0185998473,
-0.0391960293,
-0.0314735174,
-0.0110263126,
-0.0407998748,
-0.0005331901,
-0.0524162203,
-0.0127756624,
0.022585474,
-0.010343763,
0.0014263253,
0.0154799055,
0.0296742339,
-0.0140867708,
0.0395672619,
-0.0353502594,
0.0226049796,
0.0213880315,
-0.0235371254,
-0.0121219344,
0.0595610179,
0.0679922476,
0.0192090329,
0.0042516305,
-0.0302570052,
0.0297841914,
0.0516746193,
-0.0119373417,
-0.0039824485,
-0.0031635556,
-0.0129768699,
0.0144501356,
0.0154427029,
0.047969956,
0.0396972634,
-0.0189323109,
0.0282659121,
0.0526262969,
0.0391776711,
-0.0153119015,
0.0352127813,
0.1058126837,
0.0327581838,
0.0106894094,
0.0206217244,
-0.052390527,
0.0274303891,
-0.0123853367,
0.0356205367,
0.0036776646,
-0.004546443,
-0.0268533379,
-0.0210699812,
-0.0259852409,
-0.0016787197,
-0.0080376081,
-0.0215443466,
0.0399840511,
-0.0125601385,
-0.0730329081,
0.0334626473,
0.0097492142,
-0.0338029191,
-0.0127166361,
-0.0847962722,
0.0049451939,
0.1101898924,
0.0502486937,
-0.0036621278,
-0.0532996953,
0.0017568768,
0.0196372904,
0.0334192961,
0.0550443865,
-0.0049801725,
-0.0160028897,
-0.0479513854,
-0.0266693868,
-0.0458765924,
0.017429322,
0.0530289188,
0.0101033067,
-0.0536960699,
0.0106327627,
-0.0287001524,
-0.0412970372,
0.0428678691,
-0.0056899237,
-0.0456972681,
-0.0154228881,
-0.0061459932,
0.0199190062,
0.0225163028,
-0.0502317995,
0.0338273086,
0.0221341141,
-0.0049443217,
0.0365758911,
-0.0168417301,
-0.0126100564,
0.0194459409,
0.0149415219,
-0.0142010786,
-0.0295813791,
-0.0045708315,
-0.0235712398,
-0.0314650871,
-0.00736879,
-0.08004383,
0.0479955785,
-0.0407546833,
0.0236649774,
0.0082825245,
-0.0317032635,
-0.0165829957,
0.0288260952,
0.0083577652,
-0.0190273654,
0.0452389531,
0.0140764806,
0.0243199579,
-0.0631456822,
-0.0201675463,
-0.0019112816,
-0.0055618347,
0.0056249113,
0.0213740617,
0.0407032594,
-0.0144161405,
-0.0132402852,
-0.107372053,
0.0155227352,
-0.0207141303,
0.0308284834,
0.0260092244,
0.0000698903,
-0.0105217146,
-0.009758668,
-0.0035419092,
-0.0236133784,
-0.0193721429,
0.0271874331,
0.0351458676,
0.0059628268,
-0.0431306958,
-0.0396557339,
-0.0162197147,
-0.0359604992,
-0.0146900862,
0.0166270528,
0.0019631269,
-0.0701702833,
0.0051494003,
-0.0002001521,
0.0437964872,
0.0143446997,
-0.0769643784,
0.0404912941,
-0.0056383754,
0.0405772738,
0.0554988161,
-0.0128478827,
0.0204734094,
0.034457799,
0.0029477575,
-0.0408002511,
0.0351713039,
-0.0092889573,
-0.068403095,
-0.0229383949,
-0.0416738242,
0.0106719509,
0.0823416561,
-0.0023248796,
0.0181383248,
-0.091111578,
-0.0019768151,
0.0077435896,
-0.0279866923,
-0.0104361949,
-0.0235916525,
-0.0348348245,
0.0127740009,
-0.0324514769,
-0.0877030492,
0.0820377097,
-0.0381158255,
-0.0076927422,
-0.0306573082,
0.0171259828,
0.0150507158,
0.0483191907,
-0.002742559,
0.0219635777,
0.0106495181,
-0.0218044054,
-0.0340122432,
0.0066939369,
0.0225499403,
-0.0078239245,
0.0223022681,
-0.0782841146,
0.0031176652,
-0.0012453082,
-0.0220090058,
-0.0358582139,
-0.0158918295,
-0.0121868001,
0.0331846364,
0.0743672326,
-0.0278042592,
-0.0170498826,
0.0261842161,
0.0196946133,
0.0508254208,
-0.01020886,
-0.013344219,
-0.0363670811,
-0.0317239054,
0.0259823985,
-0.0190604106,
-0.0471442752,
-0.0154357757,
0.0088643525,
-0.0005165921,
0.0375392102,
0.0178330652,
-0.0333701819,
0.0216172058,
0.0147671252,
-0.0493283272,
-0.0541864485,
0.0749747232,
0.0716130212,
-0.059119232,
-0.018385537,
0.1270005107,
0.035712298,
0.0018690218,
0.0179163869,
0.0150986295,
0.0273692273,
0.0140425283,
0.0572190471,
-0.096739158,
-0.0338739678,
0.0053421622,
0.057309106,
-0.0012007479,
0.0194615796,
-0.0012804993,
-0.1351351142,
0.0485969707,
-0.0054741134,
-0.0371681377,
-0.0215183813,
-0.0303650741,
-0.0156521834,
0.016189402,
-0.0035604492,
0.0050528315,
-0.0094724083,
0.0201683212,
0.0499189161,
-0.0381798111,
-0.0646159425,
0.0367318131,
-0.0312052779,
0.082426846,
0.137046352,
0.0139113273,
0.016432168,
-0.0480364896,
0.028216457,
-0.0146987019,
0.0496280417,
-0.0073243571,
0.0535854548,
-0.0327699296,
-0.0112770842,
0.0053394791,
0.0225856993,
-0.0099243848,
0.0058653885,
-0.0167170875,
0.0629159436,
-0.0250958949,
0.0208587013,
-0.0314652994,
-0.0156462025,
0.0071362308,
0.0499034151,
0.0416314825,
-0.0545804389,
-0.0378028378,
-0.0550251938,
0.0004718365,
-0.106895186,
0.0052964617,
0.0023973826,
-0.0730213821,
-0.0591454357,
-0.0555903725,
-0.0521568172,
0.0571144149,
0.0228503291,
0.0409056731,
-0.0246889889,
0.0180007704,
0.0091187432,
-0.0393693335,
0.0163849778,
-0.0131822731,
0.0224753357,
-0.0931383446,
-0.096378006,
0.0091879163,
-0.0152450874,
-0.0029216469,
0.0338451564,
-0.0326568894,
-0.0606248751,
-0.0023903279,
0.1080187038,
0.0251186565,
0.0289055314,
-0.011784967,
-0.041181922,
-0.0149703883,
0.0288707111,
-0.0143935969,
-0.0050657657,
0.0296972711,
-0.00818728,
-0.0047286493,
0.0122124217,
-0.0515259951,
0.0366341881,
0.0136005282,
0.0339675657,
-0.0058549647,
-0.0149691533,
0.0432067923,
0.0161984116,
0.0332995355,
-0.0437645502,
-0.0100903045,
0.0095277056,
0.000785356,
-0.0230383929,
0.00032443,
-0.0668923706,
0.0001752376,
0.001505402,
-0.0152368443,
0.0154565629,
-0.0264639221,
-0.0699229017,
0.0282502174,
-0.0529478341,
0.0086664343,
-0.0007580499,
0.0441850163,
0.0058328798,
0.0059771459,
-0.0195514262,
0.0284856632,
0.0121926852,
0.0304202773,
-0.009581632,
0.0588150658,
0.0001861884,
0.0219556261,
0.008048363,
0.0537573434,
-0.0234257355,
-0.0178048462,
-0.0687723458,
0.0418323502,
0.0632204041,
0.0186866857,
0.0559284911,
-0.0276971795,
-0.0090400493,
-0.0200807899,
0.036309395,
0.0005095882,
-0.0105696861,
-0.003012314,
0.039306026,
-0.0237428863,
-0.0721206293,
0.0790995285,
0.0205638558,
0.0667419136,
-0.0303650592,
-0.0269150417,
-0.0425523818,
-0.0017712328,
0.0111181112,
0.0070367637,
-0.0122521883,
0.0211258009,
-0.0406137519,
-0.0447418243,
-0.0332820788,
0.0497320257,
0.0328766368,
-0.0227152947,
0.063690491,
0.0410788804,
-0.0314162597,
-0.0579314642,
-0.035887789,
-0.0053097154,
-0.0342546627,
-0.0086566499,
-0.0402052179,
-5.666794881e-33,
-0.0728628859,
0.0004351322,
0.0186553206,
-0.008074672,
-0.0009333855,
-0.0001350491,
-0.0436161719,
0.0040317052,
-0.0066579292,
0.0021798832,
0.0082936008,
-0.0160538442,
0.0157909188,
-0.0070468122,
0.0502751544,
-0.0052193995,
0.0527859554,
-0.0189824905,
-0.0613579713,
0.0286045093,
0.0123569081,
-0.007879152,
0.058378052,
-0.0252798162,
0.0186775755,
-0.031194225,
-0.0217805225,
-0.0013707874,
0.0105339084,
0.0807508081,
0.0057453979,
0.017848812,
0.0065681455,
-0.0272198766,
-0.0204138868,
0.0013279472,
-0.0189375021,
-0.0181367639,
0.038877625,
-0.0076825996,
-0.0075057275,
-0.0520706587,
0.009499588,
-0.0196100902,
-0.0487112775,
0.0320418887,
0.0359364673,
-0.0064705517,
0.0064767408,
-0.0251819361,
-0.0825689957,
0.027183732,
-0.0014770386,
-0.0653490573,
0.003683971,
0.032833565,
-0.0011536373,
-0.0270772111,
-0.0071879001,
0.0241976082,
0.0689931586,
0.0557180606,
0.0878707692,
0.0311005022,
0.0162766203,
0.0050730654,
0.0154564558,
0.0399711952,
-0.0069032721,
0.0067936969,
0.0140935136,
0.0405693203,
0.0114664789,
-0.0174366888,
0.0287284255,
0.0265816916,
-0.0041228808,
0.0355398916,
0.0088489791,
0.0203778017,
0.0179207847,
0.0304297619,
-0.0719274953,
-0.0121626221,
-0.0178139564,
-0.0251029469,
-0.0132977907,
-0.045305375,
0.0524609499,
-0.0135740396,
-0.025289448,
0.0256536026,
0.044052422,
0.0043992843,
0.0193884838,
-0.0394768603,
-0.0397498459,
0.0383737497,
-0.0111766597,
0.0079958588,
-0.0283016004,
-0.0580272712,
0.0572774746,
0.0027568685,
0.0444346108,
0.0243478436,
0.0197941735,
0.0460678749,
-0.0442189425,
0.0048081498,
-0.0382274054,
0.0067206286,
-0.0277170725,
0.0024609852,
0.0286891423,
-0.0064269812,
-0.0046247914,
0.0361625254,
-0.0084248791,
-0.0255026966,
-0.027175663,
-0.0110120364,
0.0160379726,
0.0098657701,
-0.0310060829,
0.0413368456,
-0.0210945774,
0.0181952789,
-0.0233925171,
-0.0298543293,
-0.0402916819,
0.0220796186,
2.582e-7,
0.0507934876,
0.0509568378,
0.0583549105,
0.0282436218,
0.0143277803,
0.0189296454,
-0.0008114627,
0.0099556707,
0.0364735946,
0.0010077185,
0.0160908904,
0.0081238225,
0.0287992749,
-0.0108309621,
-0.0526534356,
-0.0049504344,
-0.039475929,
0.0476642586,
-0.0673648342,
0.0184246022,
0.0421716906,
0.060541559,
0.002520117,
0.0180179439,
0.0242574699,
-0.0096774958,
0.0240765568,
-0.0210502092,
-0.0021523088,
0.0289432947,
-0.0049433778,
0.0555192716,
-0.0384918451,
0.0410994999,
-0.0417877771,
-0.0090309232,
-0.0036488462,
0.0829089805,
-0.0612648018,
-0.0105433529,
0.0317683928,
-0.0292990766,
0.0164547302,
-0.0409418941,
0.0207330994,
-0.0453396551,
-0.0033874714,
0.0059399172,
-0.0290092733,
-0.0022944352,
-0.0265621934,
-0.0433503613,
0.0049919109,
0.0049451203,
0.0201870482,
-0.0028401949,
-0.0194904692,
-0.0243378952,
-0.0041997144,
0.0279632248,
-0.0378110074,
-0.0679684877,
-0.0581482463,
-0.0217218511,
0.0204362236,
-0.0441692472,
-0.0105546499,
2.426926325e-34,
0.0247931629,
-0.0130313206,
0.0398002192,
0.0256484244,
0.0368109196,
0.0362124853,
0.0023184395,
0.0225329828,
0.03778724,
-0.0576789193,
-0.0521663167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.17257v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.17257v1 | Evolving Large Language Model Assistant with Long-Term Conditional Memory | 2023-12-22T02:39:15 | 2023-12-22T02:39:15 | Ruifeng Yuan, Shichao Sun, Zili Wang, Ziqiang Cao, Wenjie Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the rapid development of large language models, AI assistants like
ChatGPT have widely entered people's works and lives. In this paper, we present
an evolving large language model assistant that utilizes verbal long-term
memory. It focuses on preserving the knowledge and experience from the history
dialogue between the user and AI assistant, which can be applied to future
dialogue for generating a better response. The model generates a set of records
for each finished dialogue and stores them in the memory. In later usage, given
a new user input, the model uses it to retrieve its related memory to improve
the quality of the response. To find the best form of memory, we explore
different ways of constructing the memory and propose a new memorizing
mechanism called conditional memory to solve the problems in previous methods.
We also investigate the retrieval and usage of memory in the generation
process. The assistant uses GPT-4 as the backbone and we evaluate it on three
constructed test datasets focusing on different abilities required by an AI
assistant with long-term memory. | [
0.0409780629,
0.0620396808,
-0.0467994884,
0.0273257773,
-0.0588784404,
-0.025298724,
-0.0304628275,
-0.0210296679,
0.0513979569,
-0.0389567688,
-0.0083977999,
-0.0782406405,
-0.0369362831,
0.0454496779,
-0.0049155406,
-0.0701278374,
0.0759161711,
-0.0369401686,
0.0063761813,
-0.0168364514,
-0.0178912822,
-0.0371990204,
-0.0060191816,
0.0123503525,
-0.0270033143,
-0.012012559,
-0.0412790254,
-0.0637430325,
-0.0092412988,
-0.0243604165,
-0.0078960052,
0.0123682395,
0.0097878808,
0.0319368914,
0.0000020037,
-0.0669095665,
-0.0152601963,
-0.0382197537,
-0.0357515402,
-0.0116744731,
0.0147243449,
0.0663433075,
-0.0340403989,
0.0191617925,
-0.0674989671,
-0.040840283,
0.0148801282,
0.0024274141,
0.0696462318,
0.0600768179,
-0.0058781053,
-0.034828987,
0.046073392,
-0.0190429967,
0.0490549468,
-0.0621353649,
0.0263143983,
-0.0071923197,
0.0100148898,
-0.0052388548,
0.0142712193,
0.0305944514,
0.0352137312,
-0.0100115808,
-0.0243331492,
0.0407875404,
-0.0040900977,
0.0094276201,
-0.0291990526,
0.0381863825,
0.030945437,
-0.0174741503,
0.0064996709,
0.0285254791,
0.0221717544,
-0.0258775987,
-0.0473942533,
-0.0043608611,
-0.0389149413,
-0.0174190942,
0.0153563591,
-0.03845172,
-0.0143089229,
0.0242055301,
-0.0388192609,
0.0250074901,
0.0295904931,
-0.0413299501,
-0.024582861,
-0.0544343479,
-0.0101718307,
-0.0286909062,
0.0355309695,
0.0732653514,
-0.0124324868,
0.0393612273,
-0.0459995866,
0.0148174856,
0.0040561808,
-0.0486997738,
0.0261824839,
0.0321517587,
-0.0085954508,
0.0423392393,
-0.0451330058,
0.0569051355,
-0.0203869976,
-0.0408018157,
-0.0199362542,
-0.0123578692,
-0.0775784403,
-0.0115958778,
-0.0634329543,
0.0467632189,
0.0256826319,
-0.0031056416,
-0.0141614489,
0.0572922789,
0.0201325454,
0.0242124796,
-0.000853253,
0.0054705921,
-0.0351098739,
0.0095485905,
-0.0698336288,
0.0210925341,
-0.0312203877,
-0.0050901575,
0.0117975986,
-0.0335426144,
-0.0044179568,
0.0029013345,
0.0150417285,
0.0019557565,
-0.0133398324,
0.0832019821,
-0.0103724049,
-0.027788965,
-0.0693102553,
-0.0205468312,
0.0052202507,
-0.0684306473,
0.0419462882,
-0.0139292311,
0.0309517775,
-0.0042102989,
-0.041414842,
-0.0172362048,
-0.0073234467,
0.0235544536,
-0.0196457803,
0.0236812066,
0.0053688856,
-0.0020961668,
0.0658501089,
-0.0025661525,
-0.013218537,
0.0365663171,
0.0407365002,
0.0076765497,
0.0150430612,
-0.0174446572,
0.0231643394,
0.0161378924,
0.0289342552,
0.0152373677,
-0.0058677318,
0.019928053,
0.0071655633,
0.0144481435,
-0.0176798292,
0.0520517714,
-0.0226555821,
-0.0351497345,
0.0591096506,
0.0610361584,
0.0328587219,
0.067587994,
0.0314717852,
-0.0063866857,
0.0170192122,
0.0254830495,
-0.0344639458,
0.0241143815,
-0.036695607,
0.0145585388,
-0.0232932325,
-0.0005516327,
-0.0371977538,
-0.0277627092,
0.0254645366,
-0.0088771712,
0.0249061082,
0.0018770921,
0.0239841398,
0.0063047484,
-0.0576937795,
0.0534102358,
0.0135898041,
-0.0445838347,
-0.0398392826,
-0.1036494598,
0.063656494,
0.087585628,
0.0259858519,
-0.0175914187,
-0.0441189706,
-0.008591502,
-0.0476395153,
0.0165377781,
0.0362081118,
-0.0145922275,
-0.0025083856,
-0.0291790441,
0.0213234965,
0.0180905815,
-0.0076611177,
0.0628473684,
0.0300587416,
0.0363441855,
0.0278023854,
0.0486158915,
0.0178114399,
-0.0014283429,
-0.0396653339,
-0.0267653298,
-0.0005667767,
-0.0268670022,
0.0412090756,
0.0078893621,
0.0183620863,
0.0096841138,
0.0416294597,
-0.0064669475,
-0.0221456327,
0.0378781222,
-0.1037615761,
-0.0126572223,
0.0560228638,
0.0329165123,
0.0284493864,
-0.0245013759,
-0.0039251889,
-0.0663060024,
0.0492087118,
-0.0528973341,
0.0975958779,
-0.054728426,
0.0416192636,
0.0044765486,
-0.0237612519,
-0.0109084453,
0.0817427188,
-0.0054289359,
-0.0389402695,
0.0113026146,
0.066811882,
0.0201353673,
-0.0600831546,
-0.0096147116,
0.0362022221,
0.0009626436,
0.033440128,
0.0358600281,
0.0117969401,
-0.05631686,
-0.0339594744,
-0.1107966527,
0.0229530558,
-0.0149154495,
-0.00297418,
0.00869112,
0.0118249049,
-0.0266027488,
-0.0097031808,
-0.0491746701,
0.0476413481,
0.0165421963,
0.0053678858,
-0.0058335396,
0.0181170329,
-0.0030151175,
-0.0596543923,
0.0120720025,
-0.0084264409,
-0.0001092527,
0.0008288309,
-0.0115840351,
-0.0743158981,
0.0318969525,
-0.0481715575,
0.0770548955,
-0.0164823346,
-0.0459101573,
0.015454974,
-0.0499868616,
0.0780110583,
0.0749676749,
0.025707284,
0.0288347267,
0.0467831045,
-0.0424967371,
-0.0324242935,
0.0549707524,
-0.0264920834,
-0.0400559381,
-0.0016126104,
0.022950897,
-0.0151692564,
0.0357103609,
0.0208632518,
0.0133100273,
-0.0422223546,
-0.0003413466,
0.0021502783,
-0.0038798123,
0.0234102532,
0.003429608,
-0.0629451126,
0.0113318264,
0.0049359933,
-0.0276386905,
0.0640259758,
0.0160813518,
0.0183418039,
-0.0696217045,
0.0177423377,
-0.0182234794,
0.0906315148,
-0.0111590037,
0.007892699,
-0.0132210813,
-0.0072320346,
-0.0307583809,
-0.0087885996,
-0.0022535045,
-0.0532506891,
0.0345470086,
-0.078700237,
0.030725481,
0.0131562687,
-0.028824985,
-0.0847949833,
0.0091789756,
-0.0132902302,
0.005299801,
0.0053963577,
-0.007848816,
-0.0090647731,
0.021456873,
0.0247562826,
0.0629498288,
-0.0099772038,
0.0082111172,
-0.0246837866,
0.0102993231,
0.0617418103,
0.0045444751,
-0.0226017982,
0.0057351971,
0.0474436767,
0.0350056551,
0.055741407,
-0.0136148427,
-0.0275072102,
0.0010877256,
0.0010151577,
-0.0356451496,
-0.0211744271,
0.0223785434,
-0.0067132981,
-0.0782679617,
-0.0141781624,
0.1025617495,
0.0354652889,
-0.0563763194,
-0.0318385959,
-0.0458483249,
0.0249803383,
0.0041148136,
0.0310584195,
-0.0649200454,
-0.0232380442,
-0.001936769,
-0.0042282105,
-0.0136046261,
-0.0272704028,
-0.0220090318,
-0.135007441,
0.0043640854,
0.0086215325,
-0.0162496921,
0.0186781511,
-0.0165140629,
-0.0024735071,
0.0340253375,
0.0354362726,
0.038103234,
0.0068623093,
-0.0337446071,
-0.0112426318,
-0.0133655127,
-0.0254221223,
0.0314665399,
-0.0050909892,
0.0608003028,
0.0882795379,
0.0491627418,
0.0291819498,
-0.0277627166,
0.0240953136,
0.0096877171,
0.0163000282,
-0.0053709806,
0.037210837,
0.0000287295,
-0.0029495843,
-0.0164719671,
0.0331066698,
0.0035950891,
0.0089164171,
0.0698609799,
0.0282291956,
-0.0515093133,
0.0007913238,
0.0099770464,
-0.0244280864,
0.011279529,
0.060502816,
0.0106921522,
-0.0444833413,
-0.0587706864,
-0.0154977012,
0.0033870419,
-0.0287584588,
0.0006586868,
-0.0001182295,
-0.0071630822,
0.0103647718,
-0.0759482309,
-0.0531814806,
0.0213959254,
0.0273201689,
0.0183000993,
-0.0167210158,
0.040529266,
-0.0001381128,
-0.0388655588,
-0.0269367676,
-0.0406769477,
-0.0250715986,
-0.0844488442,
-0.0362578742,
0.0826203898,
-0.0302206501,
0.0203776881,
0.0370649733,
-0.0716540068,
-0.0501147285,
0.0429811589,
0.0661284924,
0.0269319825,
0.0804368407,
0.0055789291,
-0.0118107749,
0.0137532298,
-0.0308068749,
-0.0346033052,
0.0017248775,
0.0317530334,
0.0568518713,
-0.0081917401,
0.0303169247,
-0.020722555,
0.0078445682,
-0.0274845641,
0.0295450091,
-0.037221726,
-0.0365275368,
0.0116372583,
0.0207358971,
-0.0015771943,
0.0092716161,
0.0018520224,
0.006655518,
0.0346217714,
-0.0390463322,
0.00626422,
-0.0200794097,
0.0088141058,
-0.007927238,
-0.0285051223,
0.0095939143,
-0.074621059,
-0.0201188978,
0.0199420806,
-0.020530263,
-0.0203366522,
0.0011744752,
0.0122297378,
0.0295464452,
-0.0026622051,
-0.0352443717,
0.0078608915,
0.0287529659,
0.0518625751,
-0.0216538124,
0.1137251407,
0.0008189499,
-0.0384341739,
-0.0190671291,
0.0284258369,
-0.0637642443,
-0.0829400495,
0.0165741406,
0.059146665,
0.0616217516,
-0.0124138882,
0.037564896,
-0.0556343198,
0.018240815,
-0.0278025791,
0.0086937016,
0.0206289608,
-0.0348358452,
-0.0108493445,
0.0145449638,
-0.0108516319,
0.0175834894,
0.0742841139,
-0.008440976,
0.0530606993,
-0.0232001878,
0.0098087974,
-0.052200634,
-0.0285688825,
0.0219546668,
0.0027999929,
0.0018037398,
-0.0044465405,
-0.0333358012,
-0.0372289307,
0.0051795673,
-0.0124841919,
0.0139373168,
-0.0201490447,
0.0399198383,
0.0500767715,
-0.0394762494,
-0.0165630039,
-0.0335233882,
0.0060936995,
-0.0173418112,
-0.025509825,
-0.0230077077,
-6.258814611e-33,
-0.0365476869,
0.0006235776,
0.0559275001,
0.0196401309,
-0.042821452,
-0.0290767867,
-0.0420178398,
-0.0100219771,
-0.0297567584,
-0.0501500964,
-0.0465324931,
0.0140138259,
0.0158295054,
0.0180860627,
0.004975386,
-0.052190572,
0.0402323455,
-0.0044360664,
-0.0006958005,
0.0695872679,
0.0532562286,
0.0412001908,
0.0121969469,
-0.0523646325,
0.0099798366,
0.0019484832,
0.0363935269,
0.0312823728,
-0.0323864408,
0.0600107983,
-0.0487773381,
0.0406779535,
0.0145362196,
-0.0280605555,
-0.0205303859,
0.0067742676,
-0.0564878769,
-0.0374276116,
0.0242189709,
-0.0053986418,
-0.0175391249,
-0.0242138393,
-0.0264771041,
0.0064177848,
-0.0018662836,
0.0153758163,
0.0124551943,
-0.0259692129,
-0.0262850821,
0.0142479064,
-0.0335098319,
0.0058011985,
0.002019146,
-0.039462328,
-0.0114302058,
-0.0108196894,
0.0069016181,
-0.0547568947,
-0.0337689817,
0.0219331235,
0.0175142214,
0.0072358735,
0.026257189,
0.0202467795,
0.0277150497,
0.0380946174,
0.027940359,
0.0109873032,
-0.0026701053,
-0.0290785599,
0.0093634529,
0.015053438,
0.0030462146,
-0.0144566046,
-0.0058604889,
-0.0360374488,
-0.0170059968,
-0.0237811115,
0.0685577914,
0.0836630836,
0.0307246484,
0.0181645304,
-0.028602384,
-0.0220198203,
-0.0383655988,
0.0289364401,
-0.0281528253,
-0.0276519377,
0.043552421,
0.0195278917,
-0.0138035547,
-0.0370118022,
0.0519408509,
-0.0155725637,
0.0045256913,
0.0319386125,
-0.0559396595,
-0.0073776245,
-0.0167474784,
0.0593823045,
-0.0219706595,
0.0001495957,
0.007982987,
0.003608929,
-0.0026337889,
0.0269853901,
-0.0355619453,
0.0450902693,
-0.0609744489,
0.0173335616,
-0.0272101499,
0.0317303501,
-0.0030659786,
-0.0226036683,
0.0145641258,
0.0194157623,
0.0095546721,
0.0791501626,
0.0384824984,
-0.0155028738,
-0.066441521,
-0.0339813307,
0.022013152,
0.0146121308,
-0.0321451761,
0.0285337381,
-0.0217254721,
0.0359952375,
0.0016381566,
-0.0428814888,
0.0211544763,
0.0058092251,
2.692e-7,
-0.0394991264,
0.0439388715,
0.0321888663,
0.0098957885,
0.0163422022,
0.0222341251,
-0.0221295934,
0.0036506427,
0.0446863174,
0.0212054681,
0.002809007,
0.0347599052,
0.0363351256,
0.0149199013,
-0.078508094,
-0.0112452367,
-0.0588888526,
-0.0514752865,
-0.0651490912,
0.009353797,
0.0905387625,
0.0725249052,
0.0140968757,
-0.0067302128,
0.0077487724,
-0.0592100322,
0.0736768767,
-0.0071165524,
-0.0147419209,
0.0180182438,
0.0285858829,
0.0564152114,
-0.0169187859,
0.0039973683,
-0.0049613123,
0.0108928923,
-0.0594564304,
0.0668874606,
0.0025987825,
-0.047241848,
0.0311200824,
0.0282599237,
-0.0005071163,
-0.0189730097,
0.0812374875,
-0.0387210064,
-0.0017628011,
-0.0120991366,
0.0076908935,
-0.015751088,
-0.0304451697,
-0.0207526665,
-0.0254558809,
0.0208736341,
-0.0238343272,
0.0179462489,
0.0028974283,
-0.103399165,
0.0152348401,
-0.0105931219,
-0.046263922,
-0.0412977003,
-0.0249713361,
-0.0055152918,
0.012336012,
-0.0552038029,
0.0396751948,
2.138398941e-34,
0.025820531,
-0.002402846,
0.0298943389,
0.0628326088,
0.049226474,
0.0115647195,
0.0534977913,
0.0570081882,
0.0480411276,
-0.0514767766,
-0.0490065664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14346v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14346v2 | Don't Believe Everything You Read: Enhancing Summarization Interpretability through Automatic Identification of Hallucinations in Large Language Models | 2023-12-22T00:31:46 | 2024-04-03T02:49:25 | Priyesh Vakharia, Devavrat Joshi, Meenal Chavan, Dhananjay Sonawane, Bhrigu Garg, Parsa Mazaheri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are adept at text manipulation -- tasks such as
machine translation and text summarization. However, these models can also be
prone to hallucination, which can be detrimental to the faithfulness of any
answers that the model provides. Recent works in combating hallucinations in
LLMs deal with identifying hallucinated sentences and categorizing the
different ways in which models hallucinate. This paper takes a deep dive into
LLM behavior with respect to hallucinations, defines a token-level approach to
identifying different kinds of hallucinations, and further utilizes this
token-level tagging to improve the interpretability and faithfulness of LLMs in
dialogue summarization tasks. Through this, the paper presents a new, enhanced
dataset and a new training paradigm. | [
0.0446582362,
0.0348602273,
-0.0010406016,
0.035090033,
-0.0277926195,
0.0356861614,
-0.0351007357,
-0.0093444046,
0.0238119122,
-0.0414960273,
-0.0104697114,
-0.0234768651,
0.0177688729,
-0.0030711433,
-0.0041862214,
-0.0774606243,
0.0541170686,
-0.0393585376,
0.0067982781,
0.0003642418,
0.0143281454,
0.0081280051,
0.0124112172,
0.0646435767,
0.0016787562,
-0.0341279358,
0.0046612076,
0.0165528152,
0.0073758196,
0.0155302417,
-0.0109377848,
0.037990354,
-0.0120285014,
0.0794644952,
0.000001863,
-0.0510978699,
-0.0283139646,
-0.0374181345,
-0.0039752042,
0.0203716476,
0.0245679542,
-0.0258664191,
0.0161118768,
0.0104365349,
-0.0222446546,
0.0028600472,
0.0110572875,
0.1228031218,
0.0936781913,
0.0775137842,
0.0057112612,
-0.0449918471,
0.0184972603,
0.0131896539,
0.0245272722,
-0.0225964617,
0.0358803086,
0.05668962,
-0.0040590437,
-0.0276056193,
0.000031695,
0.0254472289,
-0.0033416075,
-0.0128396852,
-0.0290906131,
0.0085791983,
-0.1042634994,
-0.0028266653,
0.0251909997,
0.0421156734,
-0.0143037662,
-0.0479971245,
0.0176185109,
0.0293867756,
0.0126440618,
-0.0059513259,
-0.0548602529,
0.0379432775,
-0.0162294004,
0.0341414437,
0.036049813,
-0.0062337033,
0.0151123386,
0.0146782482,
-0.0603623502,
0.0696166158,
0.0026043933,
-0.0167973209,
-0.0193942413,
0.0008399027,
-0.0406567827,
-0.0687661096,
0.0188527703,
0.0303039048,
-0.0527288653,
-0.0018656222,
-0.0613080822,
-0.0112569947,
0.0228426103,
-0.0900288001,
-0.0351999514,
-0.0126969982,
-0.0406689346,
0.0551268533,
-0.0366512947,
0.015871847,
-0.0027983726,
0.0647566691,
-0.0578010269,
-0.027084792,
-0.0314408019,
-0.0182267893,
-0.0606018417,
0.0345365554,
-0.0368671492,
-0.0230044406,
-0.0262829121,
0.004063562,
0.003404062,
0.0125787063,
-0.0356255919,
0.0055875569,
0.0143108359,
-0.0333652049,
-0.0046448326,
0.0228640307,
-0.0292925183,
-0.0214110017,
0.0168184396,
-0.0424637571,
-0.0279702768,
0.0369409882,
-0.0199003853,
0.0050782366,
-0.0165114477,
0.034004692,
0.0048032305,
-0.0019248843,
-0.0267623439,
-0.0462253727,
-0.0529403389,
-0.0506514646,
-0.0288101994,
-0.0453936122,
-0.013891398,
-0.0005694652,
-0.000727053,
-0.0083976304,
0.0192079339,
0.0121389264,
-0.0518791936,
0.0544761904,
-0.0345081165,
0.0089723021,
0.0446500108,
0.0193109959,
-0.0148858586,
0.0600748099,
0.027638698,
0.0541140549,
0.0640463382,
-0.0016352022,
0.0445085205,
0.0126127843,
-0.0090052197,
0.016209349,
-0.0230242256,
-0.0209315084,
0.0204600021,
-0.0149810305,
0.0036414419,
0.0684093088,
-0.0223830864,
0.0120181944,
0.0600863583,
0.0279440843,
-0.0246471241,
-0.0050524385,
0.0158273838,
0.0074846614,
0.014801437,
0.098848395,
-0.0435135774,
-0.0059824362,
-0.0341653489,
0.0343813002,
0.0841604397,
-0.0124444459,
-0.0027367007,
-0.0577720553,
-0.0185484216,
0.0242038239,
0.003533704,
0.0085291723,
0.0093459254,
0.0219765827,
-0.0435147732,
0.0597955547,
-0.003323992,
-0.0356478877,
0.0086826291,
-0.0528822355,
-0.0143010821,
0.0776858777,
0.0556898825,
-0.0489136614,
0.0038361668,
-0.0403005444,
0.0517896526,
0.0527555831,
0.0294499956,
-0.0073583014,
-0.0000959419,
-0.0357691944,
0.0242808238,
0.0015513281,
0.0591336079,
-0.007023931,
-0.0596660078,
-0.0398458913,
0.0061480077,
-0.0221352633,
-0.0700815096,
0.0477902256,
0.011350044,
-0.0251537915,
-0.0077356235,
-0.0290759373,
0.018737046,
0.0188556146,
-0.0028575314,
0.0270561744,
0.0031951331,
-0.0521282777,
-0.0206771437,
0.043228846,
-0.0333123431,
-0.0253512431,
0.035067413,
-0.0194899812,
-0.0157015603,
-0.0147964759,
-0.0247466061,
-0.0505183637,
0.0100230677,
-0.0594432354,
0.046226725,
-0.0486401096,
0.0538108982,
-0.0049066427,
0.0382909589,
-0.0214842465,
0.0834531784,
-0.0108378716,
0.0278392248,
0.0544255786,
-0.029218398,
0.0099168401,
0.005550758,
-0.0049706581,
0.0051489263,
0.0105132237,
0.0137005644,
0.024401091,
-0.043852061,
-0.0404229201,
-0.0413382202,
-0.1033072919,
0.0042136973,
-0.0396833532,
-0.0069224369,
0.0527916029,
-0.0125912139,
-0.0125506166,
0.0001283077,
-0.0142365815,
-0.0428067148,
0.0426594056,
0.017904304,
0.0039749499,
0.0201318357,
-0.0107076997,
-0.0313040279,
0.0044978554,
-0.0213930923,
0.0699031726,
-0.031282194,
-0.0555167459,
-0.1047413796,
0.0122027379,
-0.013346592,
-0.0090760654,
0.0049570361,
-0.0266069565,
0.0026597839,
0.0042941216,
0.0639960915,
0.0726614445,
0.0472818054,
0.0361329094,
0.064705804,
-0.036704462,
-0.0173559971,
-0.0267164521,
0.0001652332,
0.0055308575,
-0.0160527434,
-0.0594903193,
0.0358028263,
0.056143526,
0.0285963379,
0.0133339465,
-0.0351315029,
0.0233653467,
-0.0419894159,
-0.0551858097,
0.0015954647,
-0.044689171,
-0.0261784177,
0.0517244935,
-0.0210697819,
-0.0123202726,
0.0694494769,
-0.0318328924,
0.0149282273,
-0.0424548872,
-0.023661349,
-0.0484155342,
0.0365039296,
0.0167485122,
0.0176016949,
-0.0091702379,
-0.0395953581,
-0.018365752,
-0.0381581113,
-0.0136342552,
-0.0266521145,
0.0712467209,
-0.0331062041,
-0.0164308008,
0.0109403068,
0.0276113115,
-0.0513748042,
-0.0478772633,
-0.0393866599,
-0.0000124624,
-0.0078751035,
0.0198527947,
-0.0579728559,
0.0156321935,
0.0135686435,
0.0247179195,
-0.0545496047,
-0.0111989435,
-0.0171693116,
0.0500317663,
0.0818812251,
-0.0143924672,
0.056467142,
-0.0549465306,
0.045203317,
0.0550828576,
0.0042995322,
0.0180182867,
-0.0063224672,
-0.0338143222,
-0.006153218,
-0.0669180751,
-0.0137104951,
-0.0198262557,
0.0527804047,
-0.048897896,
-0.0073426142,
0.1313355714,
0.0453705974,
-0.0172457621,
0.0136179589,
-0.0541182235,
0.0603724606,
-0.0072382777,
0.0009843147,
-0.0556468666,
-0.0186586864,
0.0031201139,
-0.0009467097,
-0.0189279728,
-0.0261825081,
-0.0103350915,
-0.0562254153,
0.0084360903,
0.0296567939,
-0.0415636785,
-0.0273131058,
-0.0025003096,
0.0080678565,
0.0131497942,
0.0530208759,
0.0068788449,
0.0067257602,
-0.0192151275,
0.015170577,
-0.0438955016,
0.04506981,
-0.006194789,
-0.0158488806,
0.050893683,
0.0891685188,
0.0417072736,
-0.0093948618,
-0.0087359976,
0.0622226521,
-0.0127720488,
-0.0153676048,
0.0227351189,
0.0669804215,
0.0110752126,
0.007704861,
0.0043794727,
0.0404032692,
-0.0094936155,
-0.0314733759,
0.0261112954,
0.0311603975,
-0.0231653154,
-0.0509628914,
-0.020167524,
0.0637907162,
-0.0217746142,
0.0815807804,
0.0539123602,
0.0035925251,
-0.0558308735,
-0.0478262268,
0.0243530106,
-0.0340060443,
-0.0272451304,
0.0374530554,
0.0121063404,
-0.0097742416,
-0.0931408778,
-0.0540040098,
0.016123252,
-0.0100466497,
-0.0009033533,
0.0507697798,
-0.0346174799,
0.0073416661,
0.0140495664,
0.022225339,
-0.0385833345,
-0.0062736613,
-0.0357891582,
0.0134972362,
0.044143226,
-0.0092228185,
-0.0058380854,
0.0324668996,
-0.0765174404,
-0.0625065193,
0.0242518634,
0.0293183252,
0.0286208056,
0.0753177404,
-0.0080782603,
-0.0162301306,
0.0096590212,
0.0144282226,
0.0053804875,
0.0319411755,
0.0245522764,
0.0420813076,
-0.0061096647,
0.0397631787,
-0.0228922982,
0.0219068713,
-0.0162756424,
0.0258548036,
-0.0347582027,
-0.0464393646,
0.0396994203,
0.0108492142,
-0.0104602259,
0.0064873984,
-0.0071107307,
-0.0138706882,
0.0119422851,
-0.0383373685,
-0.0266119558,
-0.020036621,
0.0243673511,
-0.0008601287,
-0.0400624461,
-0.0019083828,
-0.0312545002,
-0.0465554558,
-0.0041372092,
-0.0090751657,
-0.0081677167,
-0.026186157,
-0.0162579641,
-0.0170171317,
-0.0207524262,
-0.0557165109,
-0.0039239717,
-0.0033141344,
0.045143161,
0.0146743692,
0.047355216,
0.0109185539,
-0.0339034833,
-0.0076898797,
0.0288766343,
-0.0661653802,
-0.0500062965,
-0.033244241,
0.0306770001,
0.0356184058,
-0.0277582724,
0.0885412022,
-0.0152284699,
0.0106955171,
-0.0296115484,
0.0280572027,
0.0781702697,
-0.0219670329,
-0.0580896959,
0.0236358512,
-0.031395629,
0.0037175708,
0.0739717409,
-0.0196960233,
0.0232363809,
0.0480991118,
-0.039558515,
-0.0411391892,
-0.0563920997,
-0.0563875884,
0.0210977383,
-0.0071340222,
-0.025548853,
-0.0546057522,
-0.0211394504,
0.0044736029,
0.0091321692,
0.0136084296,
-0.0171596073,
-0.0146994572,
0.0542512089,
-0.0034078136,
-0.0164966099,
-0.0517132543,
0.0090668537,
0.0721545219,
0.0046539479,
-0.0040644137,
-5.751927855e-33,
-0.0141086634,
-0.0392437689,
-0.01738232,
-0.0246666409,
-0.0281096753,
-0.0172230806,
-0.0333910882,
0.002229814,
0.0064543835,
0.0114626158,
-0.0071822414,
0.0255437493,
0.0239845384,
0.0221475083,
0.0153862229,
-0.016439585,
0.075369522,
0.0307459515,
-0.0273325983,
0.0238614809,
0.0394121073,
0.0052623353,
0.0491353981,
-0.0446924046,
0.0543362498,
-0.0377825834,
-0.0444677696,
0.0191344973,
0.0285967384,
0.020735452,
-0.0326992832,
0.0104845902,
0.0259144381,
-0.0470401868,
-0.0474046469,
0.0165917631,
-0.0532708615,
-0.0137666808,
0.0487410128,
0.0299110152,
-0.032364402,
-0.0493208356,
0.0439250022,
-0.0257240981,
0.0434734188,
-0.0226948056,
0.0459667109,
-0.0732139051,
-0.0278466772,
0.0207165424,
-0.0666443184,
0.0218923315,
-0.0159871783,
-0.0237125922,
0.0070142071,
0.0440495089,
-0.0111930138,
-0.0116280643,
-0.0258730631,
0.0199391767,
0.0297526903,
0.0321591012,
0.0299664587,
0.0036740403,
-0.0047735479,
0.088855952,
0.0574669279,
0.0118063148,
-0.0356366113,
-0.0035704542,
-0.0059865401,
0.0255693868,
0.0278150644,
0.0032744079,
0.056262251,
0.0199326314,
-0.032997597,
0.0203281734,
-0.0463446081,
0.0233940724,
0.0642557815,
-0.0161536969,
-0.0335919484,
-0.0134140216,
-0.0020515651,
0.0094384309,
-0.0191303305,
-0.0270930063,
0.0036357478,
-0.005286349,
-0.0429007784,
-0.0363236181,
0.0508913435,
-0.0636992902,
0.0143068293,
0.0216228832,
-0.0142436344,
0.002007548,
0.0037653758,
0.0024122081,
0.0214300528,
0.0123884175,
0.0256259851,
-0.0117278118,
0.035339348,
0.0180598535,
0.0416001193,
-0.0549496114,
-0.0485986732,
0.0265333857,
0.0106484946,
0.0232995767,
-0.0582506321,
0.0257680994,
0.0327123553,
0.0029744904,
-0.0142622832,
0.0052842083,
-0.0016198828,
-0.0108053163,
-0.0082747396,
0.052079536,
-0.0260469187,
0.0235379171,
-0.0440044962,
0.0077287988,
-0.0101576624,
0.0088519705,
0.0293863285,
-0.0613943338,
-0.0038384194,
-0.0167520232,
2.536e-7,
0.0356433466,
0.0729957521,
0.042511519,
0.0028915112,
0.0001483025,
0.0321928523,
0.0082729775,
0.0028964046,
0.0436390676,
-0.0448632166,
0.0137767289,
0.0068030655,
0.0728160217,
0.0476694778,
-0.1160706803,
-0.0288354307,
-0.0608971752,
-0.0053157173,
-0.0524448156,
-0.0328325033,
0.0640412495,
0.0956578702,
-0.0135761909,
-0.0015128599,
-0.0104807885,
-0.0542913564,
0.0310201459,
-0.0100985123,
-0.0331979692,
0.0527902171,
0.0536917113,
0.0013782858,
0.0169944689,
0.0280987266,
-0.0105208633,
-0.0436684899,
0.0237938073,
0.0274271742,
-0.0085822735,
-0.0410602652,
-0.0324731953,
-0.0205410011,
0.0373026542,
-0.0478890315,
0.0517469682,
-0.0397282168,
-0.0204530973,
-0.0134443156,
-0.0410488062,
-0.0207607914,
0.0264685676,
0.0007945311,
-0.0285279714,
0.0616572835,
-0.0009689066,
0.0142700104,
0.0051731784,
-0.0702709258,
-0.0377366506,
-0.0012236657,
-0.0084983427,
-0.0244813114,
0.011071153,
0.0102890274,
-0.011829474,
-0.0836590379,
0.0075763729,
2.532524289e-34,
0.0745259151,
-0.009878207,
0.0143971229,
0.0497804619,
0.0341284648,
-0.0169124994,
0.0379480645,
0.0200258978,
0.0102965571,
-0.0662341043,
-0.007582624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14345v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14345v2 | Logic-Scaffolding: Personalized Aspect-Instructed Recommendation Explanation Generation using LLMs | 2023-12-22T00:30:10 | 2024-01-17T22:05:50 | Behnam Rahdari, Hao Ding, Ziwei Fan, Yifei Ma, Zhuotong Chen, Anoop Deoras, Branislav Kveton | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | The unique capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs), such as the natural
language text generation ability, position them as strong candidates for
providing explanation for recommendations. However, despite the size of the
LLM, most existing models struggle to produce zero-shot explanations reliably.
To address this issue, we propose a framework called Logic-Scaffolding, that
combines the ideas of aspect-based explanation and chain-of-thought prompting
to generate explanations through intermediate reasoning steps. In this paper,
we share our experience in building the framework and present an interactive
demonstration for exploring our results. | [
0.0308255702,
-0.0056108921,
-0.0091271363,
0.0123752719,
-0.0155770369,
0.0011274149,
0.0658745542,
-0.0117494473,
0.0113933058,
-0.0169787761,
-0.0120129166,
0.0204555709,
-0.0104808034,
0.0754704997,
0.0074541504,
-0.0504998602,
0.0073860367,
-0.0393231846,
-0.0066561461,
-0.0024444,
0.0175962765,
0.0535276942,
-0.0099637881,
0.0297155064,
0.0356890969,
-0.0169720054,
-0.0557708591,
-0.0114083085,
0.0160509292,
-0.0264129862,
-0.0146670658,
0.0149145331,
0.0509818047,
-0.0155467764,
0.0000021756,
-0.0221514348,
-0.011656425,
-0.017055558,
-0.0254755467,
-0.0108955931,
0.0029632351,
0.0599616505,
0.0440823138,
0.0214700047,
-0.0074819424,
0.0384423845,
0.0142439781,
0.0823195651,
0.0509025753,
0.0664350614,
-0.0018515849,
-0.0361899026,
-0.0266313516,
-0.0110311983,
0.0358476117,
-0.0208018702,
-0.0543329157,
0.0077248779,
0.0462423339,
0.078363426,
0.0043442133,
-0.001902004,
0.0422752909,
-0.0424506031,
0.0564326644,
0.0392605402,
0.0389563404,
-0.0121984901,
-0.0206674039,
0.0803753734,
0.0353001878,
-0.0135830194,
-0.0130934361,
-0.0177035797,
0.0090321871,
0.0197726358,
-0.0446958095,
0.0178754367,
-0.011086653,
0.0179438852,
0.0372806154,
-0.0069523603,
0.0447786301,
0.0220796,
0.0148079088,
0.0748229101,
-0.0103161195,
-0.0047739889,
-0.0305757951,
0.0018100683,
0.0193831827,
-0.0867725089,
0.0104848854,
0.0893251449,
-0.074508816,
-0.0018358609,
-0.0056305984,
0.0727756619,
-0.0065585808,
0.0102239335,
0.0416021682,
0.0295577254,
-0.0239986833,
0.0454868004,
-0.0087344702,
0.0322194248,
0.0108354483,
-0.007983394,
-0.063128002,
0.0425986238,
-0.0502628647,
-0.0120152058,
-0.0243304837,
0.027392704,
-0.0713955164,
-0.0222143866,
-0.0316419266,
0.0215749983,
0.0178376436,
0.0244998038,
0.0257432777,
0.0438933112,
-0.0005066136,
-0.0407719053,
-0.0635694191,
0.0304377954,
-0.0849539787,
0.0020416428,
0.0601339526,
0.0228700358,
-0.0146488138,
0.0189606901,
0.0099973222,
-0.0037091069,
-0.0113396998,
0.0103913434,
-0.0096956147,
-0.0220968463,
-0.0814983845,
-0.0912491307,
-0.0166887194,
-0.0727609843,
-0.032294739,
-0.0572603345,
0.0016316911,
0.0336808786,
-0.018002674,
-0.0086506205,
0.0166182593,
0.0307460986,
-0.020799581,
0.0358347297,
-0.0637044236,
0.0052585513,
-0.0208923128,
0.0334274843,
0.0179453846,
0.0244245529,
0.0117929559,
0.0673689395,
0.0129411118,
0.0138360085,
0.0122685786,
-0.0501654521,
-0.004821789,
0.0005720931,
-0.0281258635,
0.0080383858,
-0.0705579221,
0.0346543938,
-0.0014721967,
0.0172902439,
-0.0389010757,
0.0255123843,
0.0357857235,
0.0026691665,
0.0517673977,
0.0612735823,
0.0802427754,
0.0352702774,
-0.0353654847,
0.0398929045,
-0.0124934325,
0.0897937715,
-0.0335577205,
-0.0132897934,
0.0269622523,
0.0019255604,
-0.0336714946,
-0.0797165111,
0.0086719049,
-0.0045824461,
-0.0061350134,
0.0038804121,
0.0391129218,
0.0285711549,
-0.0314043276,
0.0226418208,
0.0263089761,
-0.0446429737,
-0.001697905,
-0.0391867682,
0.1013866588,
0.1610650867,
0.0580436029,
-0.0043890364,
-0.0165462736,
-0.004957397,
-0.0088280011,
0.0125939287,
0.0030590263,
-0.033716239,
-0.0120226229,
-0.0618763603,
-0.0330746844,
-0.0528376997,
0.0101637365,
0.0151529629,
0.0054818378,
-0.0033952177,
0.0362193882,
-0.0410349853,
-0.0166734215,
-0.0019180528,
-0.0418458842,
-0.0327112228,
0.0249120649,
0.0099825468,
-0.0267168693,
0.0515984222,
0.0317598917,
0.0124474121,
0.0043655247,
-0.0235339012,
-0.0392548218,
0.0249363091,
-0.0317584723,
-0.0347674973,
0.0030067633,
0.0151794329,
0.0314409658,
-0.0785067752,
-0.0241698325,
-0.0556515604,
0.0116735986,
0.0030453466,
0.0014589576,
-0.0336997733,
0.0154557656,
0.0403729342,
0.0022202465,
-0.0259847604,
0.0756010264,
-0.0047270698,
-0.0004334431,
0.0246413499,
0.0274615567,
-0.0040595429,
-0.0260155853,
0.0448479243,
0.0082341731,
0.0073545123,
-0.0203939807,
0.0215855837,
0.0296390671,
-0.0411908962,
-0.010728674,
-0.0603358485,
-0.0050553461,
-0.0121166669,
-0.0056419251,
0.0209106579,
0.0290680751,
0.0221386831,
-0.0206560418,
-0.056388706,
0.0245711245,
0.0105790878,
-0.0028048535,
0.0425294414,
0.013801638,
-0.0370785668,
-0.0182963274,
0.0171576906,
-0.0088911923,
0.0403238349,
0.0314762257,
0.0354896635,
-0.1130916178,
0.0063946419,
-0.0260012988,
-0.0327461697,
-0.0133790411,
0.010392216,
0.0275617875,
-0.0073572905,
0.0197424646,
0.0235133097,
-0.0010768517,
0.0624202341,
0.0731086582,
0.0144202001,
-0.0607659742,
0.0123870596,
-0.0294200089,
0.0335899368,
-0.0354828648,
-0.0450382046,
-0.0124453353,
0.0666398332,
-0.0412144437,
0.0108853998,
-0.062141303,
0.0344184525,
0.0237537269,
0.0178318024,
-0.0218342729,
-0.0405333042,
0.0207369234,
0.0894969627,
-0.0098326495,
-0.0373985842,
0.1043768227,
-0.0274870675,
-0.0060890517,
-0.0232748371,
-0.0320232995,
-0.0521547794,
0.0604663417,
-0.0226832144,
0.0259831324,
0.0154974079,
0.0019245995,
-0.0105162999,
-0.0283987951,
0.0258492306,
-0.0304309893,
0.0328671336,
-0.0321145207,
-0.0184887275,
0.0273253936,
0.0042819735,
-0.0395935327,
-0.0394663885,
-0.0577790476,
-0.027939003,
-0.016853543,
-0.0294436179,
-0.0112975184,
-0.0174238179,
0.0205279384,
0.0022589304,
-0.0268766116,
-0.0273191873,
0.0055204253,
0.0159968119,
0.0620441921,
-0.0110235801,
0.0382884592,
-0.0426144972,
0.0771563351,
0.0279600918,
-0.0182467569,
-0.0202415772,
-0.0260432214,
0.0135233523,
0.0374750346,
-0.0136867836,
-0.0213074386,
0.0384321027,
0.0677978918,
-0.0515656397,
-0.0262858886,
0.1258019954,
0.0526083373,
-0.0557924211,
0.019425381,
-0.0381138735,
0.0368103608,
0.0116865737,
0.0409068353,
-0.0891088918,
-0.0285727419,
0.0001956968,
0.0190993249,
0.0104419235,
-0.0018412361,
-0.0312224161,
-0.0726070181,
0.067376107,
0.0043292511,
-0.0167460013,
-0.020372944,
-0.0584746264,
-0.0332178734,
0.0166525599,
-0.0039733918,
0.0331357531,
-0.0035463909,
0.0224142428,
-0.0044564581,
0.0123666497,
-0.007125074,
0.0238672495,
-0.0194915421,
0.0362452492,
0.0318408422,
0.029535789,
0.0430834107,
-0.0435584076,
-0.0131013691,
0.0021868621,
0.0303706657,
-0.0451450571,
0.0673037842,
0.0023103862,
0.0133804493,
-0.0484272763,
0.0519335121,
-0.0286742765,
-0.056270171,
0.0085154353,
0.0503448695,
-0.0386124887,
-0.0099020647,
-0.0090017309,
0.0423590466,
0.0023022385,
0.0549871996,
0.0340139903,
-0.0485395454,
-0.0050202287,
-0.0623024553,
-0.0323895067,
-0.0448952429,
-0.0284719151,
0.0075664264,
-0.0005999678,
0.0020314842,
-0.0553478599,
-0.0260287076,
0.022185754,
0.0399006493,
0.0088073835,
0.0015175788,
-0.0317319594,
-0.0251652524,
0.0132765854,
0.0256961398,
0.0020806475,
0.022376461,
-0.0113231055,
-0.006566592,
0.0051819291,
-0.0981648266,
0.0244730655,
-0.0047055432,
-0.0231959317,
-0.0424586572,
-0.054037232,
0.0226926096,
0.0221830793,
0.0668419823,
-0.0152912969,
-0.0709374771,
-0.0044075386,
0.016992351,
-0.0175290816,
-0.0375965275,
0.0062634707,
0.0403742418,
0.0306517258,
0.0446070619,
-0.0450551137,
-0.0126758134,
-0.0338284932,
0.0336368717,
-0.0416108407,
-0.0408526585,
0.0463477187,
-0.0041052108,
-0.0180845689,
-0.0372717157,
0.0113017382,
-0.0269581154,
0.0310127884,
-0.0490380935,
-0.0445736572,
-0.0481675155,
0.032705985,
0.0132135972,
-0.0467071459,
-0.009316043,
-0.037229415,
-0.0436574854,
0.0403549597,
0.0034821252,
0.023336526,
-0.0166284312,
-0.026008172,
0.0217474923,
0.0052060927,
-0.0127621461,
-0.0215270333,
0.0052425168,
0.0552258752,
-0.0012081505,
0.117052339,
-0.00618335,
-0.0044262898,
-0.0448013917,
0.0271671843,
-0.0320037864,
-0.0423148237,
0.0299514364,
0.018181866,
0.0133580072,
-0.036059577,
0.0534693412,
-0.0233234707,
-0.008999587,
0.0063772537,
0.0783287585,
-0.0002424778,
-0.0247413088,
0.0103248581,
0.0326961242,
-0.016249435,
-0.0104648042,
0.0673894659,
-0.0401002578,
-0.0110304691,
0.0331209525,
-0.0333300754,
-0.0121548921,
-0.0315457135,
-0.0538421161,
0.0654794872,
-0.0160293169,
0.0090607228,
-0.0596282519,
-0.0408797972,
-0.0441737846,
0.0079032518,
0.015007426,
-0.0309866983,
0.0235240478,
0.0714228153,
-0.0065568052,
-0.0114071481,
-0.0648412332,
-0.0030661833,
-0.0092021739,
-0.0098108156,
-0.0266447254,
-6.547753327e-33,
-0.0293098669,
-0.062451195,
0.0531924814,
-0.0095416941,
-0.0075739608,
-0.0235214196,
-0.0530036204,
0.0064701159,
0.0452516302,
0.0510762818,
0.0092262076,
-0.000935977,
-0.0086639151,
0.0171223804,
-0.0167677794,
-0.0341824032,
0.0438196398,
0.0254123043,
-0.0356246866,
0.0585888959,
0.0651718676,
0.0170995742,
-0.0038810186,
-0.0472955778,
0.027273776,
-0.0012802364,
-0.035296239,
0.0155360606,
-0.0364773534,
0.0462847464,
-0.0048234616,
0.0158247389,
0.0198314134,
-0.023222588,
0.0255008191,
0.0067379763,
-0.0587980337,
-0.0126459682,
0.0668629333,
-0.0295838844,
-0.0764773786,
-0.0623152405,
-0.0127323288,
-0.0029721321,
0.0081385365,
-0.0168573968,
0.0158670712,
-0.0278054811,
-0.0267472304,
-0.0320795923,
-0.0316890553,
0.0094575156,
-0.0347112752,
-0.0651881471,
0.0109754484,
0.0651656911,
0.0016309593,
0.0140212718,
0.0282250419,
0.0349721499,
0.0254402589,
0.0279867109,
0.0399411395,
-0.013764875,
-0.0469078906,
0.0358161777,
-0.0082076928,
-0.0327483192,
-0.0588722527,
0.0461353175,
-0.050455492,
0.0671937317,
0.0203413069,
-0.0068564652,
0.0017549507,
0.034714736,
-0.0338060968,
0.0431024693,
-0.0203467309,
0.0080390051,
0.02978402,
-0.0026440721,
-0.0297490526,
-0.0280623585,
-0.0229765084,
-0.0228326898,
-0.0417037159,
-0.0612050742,
0.0038801024,
0.0333686955,
-0.0498960018,
-0.0578364506,
-0.0324455276,
-0.0325920433,
-0.0085006403,
0.0229499545,
-0.0400203206,
0.0017326735,
0.0039097001,
0.0194196664,
-0.0196313262,
0.0134872645,
0.0140240286,
-0.0113179516,
-0.011478344,
0.0198265109,
0.0738688931,
0.0133953234,
-0.0214377809,
0.018635612,
-0.0570041724,
0.0211527161,
-0.0308734216,
-0.0033229778,
0.0003623598,
0.048703339,
-0.0773122311,
0.0995520428,
-0.0106960973,
0.020818878,
-0.0196631309,
-0.0337276906,
0.0030959307,
0.0410390273,
-0.0118144089,
-0.0157821123,
-0.0291585512,
-0.013603678,
0.0459402986,
-0.058793433,
-0.0383160934,
0.0322782397,
2.756e-7,
-0.0025883061,
0.0343202017,
0.0115634128,
0.0407654047,
0.0145410309,
0.0321323983,
0.0351227671,
-0.0178855043,
0.0273576267,
-0.0219860356,
0.0316472352,
0.0495712943,
0.0262000021,
0.0136191892,
-0.0457487814,
0.0496000089,
-0.0252955221,
-0.0335472114,
-0.0510392562,
-0.0058203675,
0.0593500845,
0.023193853,
0.0267135222,
-0.004041851,
0.0374798886,
0.01673197,
0.0341981128,
-0.0167041887,
-0.0264749937,
-0.0044370182,
0.02263554,
0.01089969,
-0.00254313,
-0.0222173277,
-0.021348577,
0.0028099609,
-0.0556656569,
0.0427124798,
0.0099348798,
-0.047131367,
0.0039086929,
-0.0342367776,
0.0318641104,
-0.0514600202,
0.0797905028,
-0.0056574242,
-0.0300173238,
-0.0216308869,
-0.029699631,
-0.0196282081,
-0.0263584573,
-0.0151176192,
-0.0093142996,
0.0172898099,
-0.0111492965,
-0.0391614996,
0.0235493314,
-0.0527198128,
-0.038524393,
0.0232699197,
-0.0004086685,
0.0039109928,
-0.0364447869,
0.0156807993,
-0.0113129029,
-0.0587354973,
-0.0094241183,
2.459995369e-34,
0.028883243,
0.0219807792,
0.0170177799,
0.0319799781,
0.040134225,
0.0142807933,
-0.0467032455,
-0.0108208684,
0.0807494,
-0.0244475082,
-0.0329471417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14335v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14335v2 | Context-aware Decoding Reduces Hallucination in Query-focused Summarization | 2023-12-21T23:42:13 | 2023-12-31T22:31:48 | Zhichao Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Query-focused summarization (QFS) aims to provide a summary of a single
document/multi documents that can satisfy the information needs of a given
query. It is useful for various real-world applications, such as abstractive
snippet generation or more recent retrieval augmented generation (RAG). A
prototypical QFS pipeline consists of a retriever (sparse or dense retrieval)
and a generator (usually a large language model). However, applying large
language models (LLM) potentially leads to hallucinations, especially when the
evidence contradicts the prior belief of LLMs. There has been growing interest
in developing new decoding methods to improve generation quality and reduce
hallucination. In this work, we conduct a large-scale reproducibility study on
one recently proposed decoding method -- Context-aware Decoding (CAD). In
addition to replicating CAD's experiments on news summarization datasets, we
include experiments on QFS datasets, and conduct more rigorous analysis on
computational complexity and hyperparameter sensitivity. Experiments with eight
different language models show that performance-wise, CAD improves QFS quality
by (1) reducing factuality errors/hallucinations while (2) mostly retaining the
match of lexical patterns, measured by ROUGE scores, while also at a cost of
increased inference-time FLOPs and reduced decoding speed. The code
implementation based on Huggingface Library is made available
https://github.com/zhichaoxu-shufe/context-aware-decoding-qfs | [
0.0284834988,
0.032568071,
0.0338382609,
0.0291846823,
-0.0258475374,
0.0089766793,
-0.0686296597,
0.0033702119,
-0.0454775952,
-0.0351469442,
0.0002597432,
-0.0311244018,
0.0361402482,
-0.0004562829,
0.002225257,
-0.0378775373,
0.05059148,
-0.0163116213,
-0.0243348274,
-0.0095718559,
0.0019962692,
0.031982027,
0.0321187451,
0.0230168961,
0.0057934872,
-0.0161087345,
-0.0166271683,
0.0331993364,
0.000847503,
-0.0141199883,
-0.0161085632,
0.0397409797,
0.0074203988,
0.0752350837,
0.0000022432,
-0.0492421463,
-0.0611469969,
0.0121694384,
0.0206382778,
0.0367801748,
0.0725619346,
-0.0285607688,
-0.0030690904,
0.0217593741,
-0.0094425911,
-0.0171634387,
0.0196468215,
0.0706624389,
0.0519807674,
0.0711348727,
-0.0058448422,
-0.0329154544,
0.0416733958,
0.0115047423,
0.0334052667,
-0.0412847474,
-0.0000942328,
0.0267693866,
0.0196013749,
-0.0035817225,
-0.0048331521,
0.0341227129,
0.0019726849,
0.0172667541,
0.0037190763,
0.0417878404,
-0.1132233888,
0.0018085637,
0.0250968225,
0.0421368591,
-0.0217898563,
-0.0415935479,
0.0123720085,
0.0413130708,
-0.008800609,
0.001458879,
-0.0698852316,
0.0330145881,
-0.0310650431,
0.0338475555,
0.0431513265,
0.0196590833,
0.0125886891,
0.0194698293,
-0.0601574592,
0.0489807837,
0.0090130772,
-0.0278050024,
-0.0141272135,
0.0205946732,
-0.0115653882,
-0.0394657776,
-0.0106845694,
0.0100686885,
-0.0565086156,
-0.0189296044,
-0.0529778674,
-0.0362325199,
0.0519876294,
-0.0502301566,
-0.0083670951,
0.0225291867,
0.0133838663,
0.0441367179,
-0.0219365731,
0.0042777746,
0.0031671328,
0.0326736681,
-0.056957636,
-0.0102468375,
-0.0002173303,
-0.0018009254,
-0.0559459738,
0.0417401716,
-0.0689962134,
-0.0397305787,
-0.0190638844,
0.0393548384,
0.028708946,
0.0141910417,
-0.0464113653,
0.0122907422,
-0.0339682214,
0.0044949241,
0.028911896,
0.0111447116,
-0.0018810995,
-0.0424719565,
0.0367728621,
-0.07054279,
-0.0364464559,
0.0123147229,
0.0330164693,
0.0043847221,
-0.0190305468,
-0.0042174743,
-0.0236374643,
-0.0278864037,
-0.0117400084,
-0.0539319813,
-0.0042109983,
-0.0365344323,
-0.0326720327,
-0.0941103846,
-0.0076636453,
0.0209590122,
-0.0030907416,
0.0005670978,
0.0048061344,
0.0345860012,
-0.046066463,
0.028110195,
-0.0489752069,
0.0038515769,
0.0358539745,
0.0372750536,
0.017769387,
0.1136986688,
-0.0030291509,
0.0674425662,
0.049743399,
0.0163013786,
0.0170403402,
0.0078661442,
0.0018383149,
0.0357951596,
-0.0050392263,
-0.0120880632,
0.0138705596,
-0.0391219445,
0.0368610807,
0.0673589185,
-0.047329165,
0.011036125,
0.0288988128,
0.0334611423,
0.0258215014,
-0.0050314972,
-0.0157865826,
0.0444728993,
0.0221270174,
0.0449819714,
-0.0248618424,
0.0129934438,
-0.0632277057,
0.0442026854,
0.1170798764,
0.0281935018,
-0.0234856009,
-0.0332842357,
-0.0001719068,
0.0121272663,
0.0002930338,
-0.0019483521,
0.0371814035,
0.0173472706,
-0.0573895499,
0.0060620522,
0.0106681418,
-0.0737986714,
0.0179138184,
-0.0127014518,
0.0108750192,
0.0498774014,
0.1015935317,
-0.0298794713,
0.0169439577,
0.0102442112,
-0.0137273651,
0.0177622065,
0.0254246965,
-0.009060367,
0.0130228046,
-0.0576643273,
-0.0324360766,
-0.0034583979,
0.0209407024,
-0.0248769224,
0.0141881118,
-0.0046208678,
0.0432778113,
-0.0303169005,
-0.0741476044,
0.0125529673,
-0.0074113305,
-0.0208069682,
-0.020238338,
-0.0371394455,
0.0286912229,
0.0287255216,
-0.0169347972,
0.0417807512,
0.0370257609,
-0.0324513912,
-0.011686177,
0.0201834794,
-0.0358663909,
-0.0515502207,
-0.0051327772,
-0.0355615988,
0.0264807157,
0.0068551865,
-0.0167915281,
-0.0520930178,
0.0151577611,
-0.0683382899,
0.0414110646,
-0.0616563261,
0.0368622839,
-0.0129726678,
0.0357450321,
-0.0199475158,
0.0814284012,
-0.0140393469,
0.0156978369,
0.0352651179,
0.0271367878,
-0.015249433,
-0.0283603799,
-0.0189121161,
0.0191446804,
-0.020385772,
0.0196299125,
0.0500890017,
-0.0101747997,
-0.0386356451,
-0.0076927552,
-0.0975089744,
0.0076739653,
-0.0348567478,
0.0004462783,
0.0307477433,
0.0434848107,
-0.0078061554,
0.0137686031,
-0.0264435671,
-0.0179678313,
0.0290109776,
0.0336833857,
0.0040638582,
0.0161607396,
-0.003563364,
-0.026802877,
-0.0142268771,
0.0119756069,
0.0592794232,
-0.0109675406,
-0.0352171697,
-0.0625747442,
0.0918269455,
0.0031254154,
-0.0226541478,
-0.0019927684,
0.0203141179,
0.0013539785,
-0.0634363666,
0.055679433,
0.0599679984,
0.0362879001,
0.0096136183,
0.0280159805,
-0.015321617,
-0.0403811298,
-0.0176089909,
-0.0501989461,
-0.003198501,
0.0092953164,
-0.0688564181,
0.0468691625,
0.0198487919,
0.0129702091,
0.0127283679,
-0.0467813313,
0.0195887294,
-0.0114096608,
-0.0349154919,
-0.0346635245,
-0.012758309,
0.008324909,
0.0674242973,
-0.0325176381,
-0.028741153,
0.0411425084,
-0.0375026017,
0.0089802388,
-0.0588902608,
0.0305816568,
-0.0439960882,
0.0355859511,
-0.019604519,
0.0415226705,
-0.0463782735,
-0.0431129076,
0.0056889337,
-0.0046661152,
-0.0013594598,
-0.0688601062,
0.0498145968,
-0.0305023212,
0.0124487607,
-0.0330749489,
-0.0021816946,
-0.0203439426,
0.0026628121,
0.0174265839,
-0.0161145832,
0.0176780913,
-0.0050113513,
-0.0285647474,
0.0157301035,
0.0289365128,
0.0613384396,
-0.051377859,
-0.0395511501,
0.0075697806,
0.0310544707,
0.0482896231,
0.002016634,
0.0587978326,
-0.0297962353,
0.0119175715,
0.102965802,
0.0766605139,
0.0190256368,
0.0291730296,
-0.0008053969,
0.0368095152,
-0.023171749,
-0.0210850537,
-0.0047706305,
0.0404672362,
-0.0450027175,
-0.0502181984,
0.092753984,
0.0505922996,
-0.0773351267,
-0.0054450878,
-0.0204693172,
0.0588124692,
0.0062809656,
-0.0054837619,
-0.0769039765,
-0.0055678249,
0.0103324177,
0.0589838997,
0.0010864635,
-0.0191568229,
-0.0036246309,
-0.0947222561,
0.0469664522,
0.026577808,
-0.0438783653,
-0.0608568154,
-0.0557079464,
-0.0109681692,
0.0088317012,
0.0073491074,
0.0581487231,
-0.0091363145,
0.0131912697,
0.0106874639,
-0.0201690253,
-0.0222438835,
-0.0410229452,
-0.0111918645,
-0.0155195165,
0.0770594105,
0.0234241486,
0.0079443371,
-0.0012316548,
-0.0057674823,
-0.0405168757,
-0.0267888643,
-0.0322217084,
0.0490202978,
-0.013555917,
0.0179705042,
0.0061606853,
0.0184816569,
-0.0277757496,
-0.0155701945,
-0.018426124,
0.0044224295,
-0.0249959175,
-0.0058229575,
-0.0525116287,
0.0195597149,
-0.0365042053,
0.0853813589,
0.036930915,
0.0301877037,
-0.0536407307,
-0.0342175625,
0.0278394315,
-0.0633811131,
-0.0206914525,
0.0396199487,
0.0075859209,
-0.0648727044,
-0.0682672858,
-0.0174867529,
0.0078427568,
0.0199033301,
-0.0337757394,
0.0529010557,
-0.0067221429,
-0.011457108,
-0.0725585371,
-0.0118081719,
-0.0217275843,
-0.0099616079,
-0.0007166523,
0.0053256215,
0.0496726371,
-0.0324238017,
-0.0015958634,
0.0276985336,
-0.0407163091,
-0.0492845625,
0.0098021477,
-0.0074275355,
0.0261144023,
0.0612832457,
-0.0155308601,
0.000191704,
0.0301710367,
0.0836431906,
0.0039266441,
0.0372767895,
-0.0013370664,
0.0180322789,
0.0051998999,
0.0096055055,
-0.073536098,
0.0052080876,
-0.0400495119,
0.0395781845,
-0.0186039861,
-0.0198183004,
0.0341588818,
0.0533884279,
-0.0274938457,
-0.034414608,
0.0131145157,
0.0170066822,
-0.0172886625,
-0.0424901433,
-0.0259974748,
-0.03829474,
0.040797554,
0.0049517951,
-0.0264130458,
0.0213270504,
0.0472918078,
-0.0028589352,
0.0390470624,
-0.0551861152,
-0.0082702683,
-0.0440968908,
-0.0055785156,
0.019574549,
-0.0267879926,
-0.0614907444,
-0.0351970382,
-0.024073001,
0.0343003049,
-0.0270069633,
0.0045536314,
0.0289127883,
-0.0199682973,
-0.0134464353,
0.0479556397,
-0.0935894176,
-0.0044514481,
-0.0519909635,
-0.0103203328,
0.0256462526,
-0.0290696677,
0.0882132575,
-0.0249058809,
0.0086292317,
-0.0321663469,
0.0116935987,
0.0672062337,
-0.0174228624,
-0.0601410829,
0.032335382,
-0.0026944422,
0.0007016751,
0.0996049121,
-0.0349946246,
-0.0083293729,
0.0188605115,
-0.0503196381,
-0.0428654738,
-0.0544939376,
-0.0028439956,
0.0581851192,
-0.0239723846,
-0.0374967903,
-0.0553003773,
-0.0191471688,
0.0244235694,
0.0031948427,
0.0249107964,
0.0026468728,
0.0386165082,
0.0835181624,
-0.0020404404,
-0.0162383523,
-0.0321216099,
0.0224670973,
-0.022687681,
-0.0170258228,
0.0316392928,
-6.925582925e-33,
-0.0170372184,
-0.0023554661,
-0.0324757323,
-0.0276069827,
-0.0327172056,
-0.0005140255,
-0.0534397885,
-0.0229610242,
0.0326285399,
-0.0252430066,
-0.0270301644,
0.0324741304,
0.0150183532,
0.0384887569,
-0.0279596504,
0.0255692862,
0.0398228578,
0.0221757405,
-0.0521038845,
0.0752071291,
0.0604838952,
0.0082547283,
0.0125936819,
-0.0520449392,
0.0121222949,
-0.0312184356,
-0.0201063994,
-0.0303381104,
0.027563598,
0.0160308965,
-0.0250033941,
0.0314382836,
0.0143591687,
-0.0208733883,
-0.041620966,
0.005098586,
-0.086277999,
-0.0098092435,
0.0082663465,
-0.0088305576,
-0.0255236998,
-0.0320471153,
0.0462303907,
-0.0155151412,
0.0002033194,
-0.0149502726,
-0.0013518292,
-0.0433222577,
-0.0774450302,
-0.0635996163,
-0.0302625187,
0.0413116217,
-0.0087823169,
0.0211054273,
0.031026328,
0.0265609268,
-0.0047521414,
0.0401411839,
-0.044021301,
0.039018292,
-0.0093596475,
0.0634415224,
0.0433417596,
0.0147402734,
0.0165797882,
0.0628639907,
0.0418658927,
-0.0118243312,
-0.0313810036,
0.0097288778,
0.0288873799,
0.0066566234,
-0.0062427665,
0.0264347121,
0.0765604749,
-0.0051960261,
-0.0384084396,
0.0884272382,
-0.0485019237,
0.0035930292,
0.082902059,
0.0074560954,
-0.0443111099,
-0.0435074717,
-0.0227384232,
0.0340170227,
-0.0234557316,
0.0118920552,
0.0111628855,
0.033001557,
-0.0766135529,
-0.0138806067,
0.0273295678,
-0.0367177092,
0.0243234094,
0.0204208121,
-0.031743817,
0.0265074652,
-0.0193693228,
-0.0142394975,
0.0197746083,
0.0167639479,
0.0324571356,
0.0013667999,
-0.0103223762,
0.0094343787,
0.0261972193,
0.0092900302,
-0.0555180311,
-0.0077194986,
-0.0111962296,
0.0247514825,
-0.022216076,
0.0061084363,
0.0159879606,
-0.0236608349,
0.0097003384,
-0.001119339,
0.0239659082,
0.0377698764,
-0.0271754079,
-0.0377822779,
-0.0218297187,
0.0229447298,
-0.0061407955,
0.021408692,
-0.0446567424,
0.0023995331,
0.0607779808,
-0.0554033965,
-0.0413108058,
0.0342669487,
2.986e-7,
0.0309856478,
0.0435673036,
0.0671344399,
0.0258510746,
-0.0015274393,
0.0140575571,
0.0254511796,
0.0364596955,
0.0108242165,
-0.0060181115,
0.0077442462,
0.0475486219,
0.0551762693,
0.0349021219,
-0.0926501229,
-0.0233665761,
-0.0532894433,
-0.0281302184,
-0.0418063812,
-0.0179154724,
0.036930386,
0.0629973859,
-0.042744834,
-0.0165884048,
0.0233157538,
-0.0306074005,
0.0226759128,
0.0029082566,
-0.0092767328,
0.0481685027,
0.0331278369,
0.0098734032,
0.0390034057,
-0.0257658958,
-0.0098527018,
-0.0313279144,
0.0405808128,
0.0167636182,
-0.0002013229,
-0.0426462889,
0.0264297351,
-0.0299672969,
0.0333632417,
-0.052821897,
0.0787479132,
0.0030621386,
-0.004141361,
-0.0018252141,
-0.0495718941,
0.0183916148,
0.0003465839,
0.0196556523,
-0.0252424981,
0.0443534218,
0.0090044448,
0.015319935,
-0.0030223336,
-0.0625087246,
-0.0260302071,
-0.0032199563,
-0.0006199593,
-0.0678831786,
-0.0186938103,
0.0199734624,
-0.0364424661,
-0.0730137974,
0.0000050144,
3.653880697e-34,
0.0893016458,
0.0146859754,
-0.0101504708,
0.0089420527,
0.0251297448,
-0.0280027203,
0.0237089228,
0.0144638875,
0.0063548591,
-0.0840161517,
-0.0212237015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14327v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14327v1 | Parameter Efficient Tuning Allows Scalable Personalization of LLMs for Text Entry: A Case Study on Abbreviation Expansion | 2023-12-21T22:52:44 | 2023-12-21T22:52:44 | Katrin Tomanek, Shanqing Cai, Subhashini Venugopalan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Abbreviation expansion is a strategy used to speed up communication by
limiting the amount of typing and using a language model to suggest expansions.
Here we look at personalizing a Large Language Model's (LLM) suggestions based
on prior conversations to enhance the relevance of predictions, particularly
when the user data is small (~1000 samples). Specifically, we compare
fine-tuning, prompt-tuning, and retrieval augmented generation of expanded text
suggestions for abbreviated inputs. Our case study with a deployed 8B parameter
LLM on a real user living with ALS, and experiments on movie character
personalization indicates that (1) customization may be necessary in some
scenarios and prompt-tuning generalizes well to those, (2) fine-tuning on
in-domain data (with as few as 600 samples) still shows some gains, however (3)
retrieval augmented few-shot selection also outperforms fine-tuning. (4)
Parameter efficient tuning allows for efficient and scalable personalization.
For prompt-tuning, we also find that initializing the learned "soft-prompts" to
user relevant concept tokens leads to higher accuracy than random
initialization. | [
0.0730156377,
-0.0106143961,
-0.0125800846,
-0.00758398,
0.0039417632,
-0.0010708588,
0.0242275447,
0.0476296768,
-0.0150551861,
-0.0256146435,
-0.0329997763,
-0.0418149531,
-0.0155032948,
0.0137127005,
0.0373530276,
-0.0517051183,
0.0561103709,
-0.0313446634,
-0.0054817563,
-0.0158168618,
0.0240790136,
-0.021386832,
0.0122012468,
0.0578553081,
0.0201252811,
0.0173934549,
0.0050974051,
0.0176440384,
-0.0396487154,
0.0081796171,
-0.0115009816,
0.0625699162,
0.0200687926,
0.0212874487,
0.0000017554,
-0.0571478605,
-0.0184616465,
-0.0409568325,
-0.0313976966,
0.002691522,
0.0490201488,
0.0380323939,
0.019576259,
0.0401616357,
0.0032250714,
0.0067829578,
0.0485635065,
0.0101414481,
-0.0041360012,
0.0420940071,
-0.0084245754,
0.0451185144,
-0.0199859925,
-0.0278839711,
0.0458506569,
-0.047088325,
0.0272452477,
-0.0888682082,
0.0304660536,
0.0338117182,
-0.0232966375,
0.0457358696,
-0.0128697259,
-0.0162993185,
0.0903578699,
0.0423951112,
-0.0173231829,
-0.0193438046,
-0.0193146169,
0.0828749165,
0.0309220497,
-0.003551818,
0.020432489,
-0.0082376497,
0.0334334448,
0.0068582501,
-0.0199616272,
-0.0617151968,
0.0002913779,
-0.0204155799,
-0.0157764573,
-0.0109535446,
0.0221481416,
0.0234370716,
-0.013615136,
0.0247205757,
0.0219952818,
-0.0452764556,
-0.0114674643,
-0.0178350564,
0.0253042039,
-0.0854588673,
0.0495099649,
0.033457119,
-0.0624326281,
0.0081761535,
-0.061134275,
-0.018214222,
0.0138377119,
-0.0203857869,
0.0607004017,
0.0461356305,
-0.000757265,
0.0255765002,
-0.0179891251,
0.008165421,
-0.0039542117,
0.0141918482,
-0.0039389054,
0.0092116743,
-0.051847551,
0.0114171505,
-0.0373446494,
0.0383234806,
-0.0052017127,
-0.0280067679,
-0.0509900004,
0.0832467079,
0.0383610427,
-0.0066664205,
0.0187586229,
0.0184235703,
-0.0389219187,
-0.0235178936,
-0.0547858477,
-0.0062063769,
-0.0663665757,
0.0126240691,
0.0412304476,
-0.0423891731,
0.0027971526,
-0.0106494427,
0.0345116146,
-0.0440647341,
0.0254779961,
0.0458308868,
-0.0244122855,
-0.0607163943,
-0.0099140983,
-0.0286552999,
-0.0235633049,
-0.0052741617,
-0.0353530459,
-0.0442491546,
0.0203835219,
0.0260983445,
-0.0258421004,
-0.0548551045,
-0.0045263772,
0.0304189175,
-0.0231675487,
0.0797611028,
-0.0624241866,
0.0092040151,
0.0664736852,
0.0072974321,
0.0099619608,
0.0208353736,
0.0231593437,
0.0741439462,
0.0397955105,
-0.0091188857,
0.0610084347,
0.0471787192,
-0.0106044961,
0.0182947647,
-0.0420792773,
0.0078189895,
-0.0094772894,
0.0540527776,
-0.0087743998,
0.0605753846,
-0.0207176898,
-0.0017682309,
0.068690069,
0.0702805221,
0.0565312281,
0.0165882353,
0.0330470353,
-0.0074547366,
-0.0037434534,
-0.0452213474,
-0.0140758753,
0.0214135218,
-0.0327157378,
0.0167812742,
0.0655915588,
-0.0067962781,
-0.0251306724,
-0.032468535,
0.0140023008,
-0.029706426,
0.0062052822,
0.0306065939,
0.0277294312,
-0.0106233414,
-0.0508345477,
0.0348670371,
0.018357303,
-0.0454364866,
0.0066426941,
-0.0569558665,
-0.0133595336,
0.1191854104,
0.0681624189,
-0.0140288174,
-0.0307830125,
-0.0316873789,
0.0034444733,
0.0228149351,
0.0186639372,
0.0022117186,
0.0101136668,
-0.0645644739,
-0.0095987422,
0.0557512231,
-0.0224175192,
0.0110125514,
0.0145568587,
0.019713616,
0.003540396,
-0.0390869156,
-0.0065598097,
0.0157558639,
-0.0341493301,
-0.0490357056,
0.0416204147,
0.0297551788,
0.0011072154,
0.0171785653,
0.002492816,
-0.0036476159,
-0.0122087961,
-0.0021329038,
-0.0026243648,
-0.0242214575,
-0.047631368,
0.0281686373,
0.001672665,
0.0364568532,
0.0155045604,
-0.0211172234,
0.0244771205,
-0.0576109365,
-0.0397373028,
-0.0352712236,
0.0486824252,
-0.0682347044,
0.0340778902,
-0.0033874561,
-0.0009768636,
-0.0364633128,
0.0296302941,
-0.0170821473,
-0.0089915898,
0.0183354504,
0.0044822153,
0.0194824841,
-0.0576041415,
-0.0329869315,
-0.0058456692,
0.0055605816,
-0.0142258024,
0.0381870158,
-0.0036592158,
-0.0329988338,
-0.029038351,
-0.0934437811,
-0.0066736797,
-0.0086685279,
-0.023798503,
-0.0144349281,
0.0557847023,
-0.034490291,
-0.0419034138,
-0.0130801406,
0.0257770214,
-0.0036035143,
0.0381985269,
0.0380217843,
0.027516963,
-0.0373184569,
-0.0526532121,
-0.0078564472,
-0.0133393109,
0.0210336298,
0.0051646419,
-0.0771480948,
-0.0429800339,
-0.0039635804,
-0.0456900448,
0.0286906715,
-0.0098775653,
-0.0373245962,
0.00969721,
-0.0226629488,
0.0236015562,
0.0359514654,
0.0344735123,
-0.0036230041,
0.0357214138,
0.0355778597,
-0.0489345901,
0.0144108571,
-0.0207784157,
-0.0065084118,
-0.0238590259,
0.0124934213,
0.0324552841,
0.0469895303,
0.0077283904,
0.0102181211,
-0.0644487888,
-0.0023416888,
0.0304525476,
-0.0391660817,
-0.0573099926,
-0.0038678092,
-0.0719527379,
0.0499529131,
0.0131717473,
-0.0628316253,
0.0785400569,
-0.0157608017,
-0.0098023675,
-0.0215773508,
-0.0321453363,
0.0030182209,
0.0226617251,
-0.0110332295,
0.0123263039,
0.010834245,
-0.0504765287,
-0.0241485909,
0.018304944,
0.0030009376,
-0.0236669648,
0.0625099167,
0.0001491732,
0.0126027958,
0.0394013599,
-0.0561348647,
-0.0459962748,
-0.0421239212,
-0.0308825858,
-0.0122894589,
0.0366364121,
-0.0468152948,
-0.039005544,
-0.0268081669,
0.0283885431,
0.0746135041,
-0.0102589866,
-0.0253548734,
-0.0232054442,
-0.0309510715,
0.032137882,
-0.017168317,
-0.0318486057,
-0.0417485572,
0.0146242892,
-0.0110160289,
0.0231228862,
-0.0418693125,
0.0154588027,
-0.0279281475,
0.0417784899,
-0.069231309,
-0.0083717257,
0.0754435137,
0.064533636,
-0.0038661328,
-0.020457048,
0.1188502833,
0.0403205305,
-0.1030295268,
0.0063700941,
-0.0126806218,
0.040753372,
0.0258017331,
0.0635803118,
-0.0938812792,
-0.0401584804,
0.0348436348,
0.0506193079,
0.0056077288,
-0.0302981623,
-0.0234728772,
-0.0609932989,
-0.012517957,
-0.0106586013,
0.0025480154,
0.0125783449,
-0.009251344,
0.0119045796,
0.0188306626,
0.0334036499,
0.0403898507,
-0.0346858688,
0.0122513203,
0.0087767104,
-0.0375679657,
-0.0664491728,
0.0036725269,
-0.0224556122,
0.0677865967,
0.0429896899,
-0.0070219035,
0.0075575188,
-0.0165726263,
0.006991352,
0.0272796676,
0.0477014519,
-0.0304120462,
0.0387368686,
-0.0155965881,
0.0029446457,
-0.0519248657,
0.02765432,
0.0099892905,
0.0068776784,
0.0067860512,
0.0314498208,
-0.057051111,
0.0169896819,
-0.0001583391,
-0.0271125715,
0.0237422679,
0.0799170285,
0.0559323318,
-0.0909908339,
-0.012794503,
-0.0389068425,
-0.0228060298,
-0.0342527032,
-0.0170653015,
-0.05172709,
-0.0426121913,
-0.0105757508,
-0.0720182136,
-0.0359555148,
0.0667022243,
0.0370185226,
0.0021577124,
0.0564178117,
-0.032275822,
0.0268492121,
-0.0117066028,
-0.0038018769,
-0.0017672005,
-0.0042493115,
-0.0977117568,
-0.0279134847,
-0.000995344,
-0.0564291887,
-0.0163185596,
0.0154234059,
-0.0260885637,
-0.0685377419,
0.0258449875,
0.0422899574,
0.0179075785,
0.0468144529,
-0.0155034661,
-0.1198543906,
0.0538432673,
0.060711734,
-0.0020800414,
0.0192580782,
0.0053955643,
-0.005680989,
0.006838847,
0.0376098715,
-0.036784552,
0.0033298016,
-0.0074730609,
0.0202719942,
-0.0355981924,
-0.0499674864,
-0.0166191589,
0.0291574486,
0.0299984775,
-0.0491233915,
-0.0411676355,
-0.0223275535,
0.0307474211,
-0.010164042,
0.0068752985,
-0.0301332343,
-0.0319752917,
-0.0020695834,
-0.0364471972,
0.001295157,
-0.0339951999,
-0.0650977716,
0.0382903889,
-0.0100115696,
0.0313267633,
-0.0238540526,
0.0115910983,
0.0682604462,
0.0046731299,
-0.0039112847,
0.05914836,
0.0343333706,
0.0141539797,
-0.0442377031,
0.0441428088,
0.0038598166,
0.0173105095,
-0.0321519673,
0.0631811693,
-0.0344253704,
-0.0342875458,
0.0015635259,
0.0738501772,
0.0104087889,
0.0374070965,
-0.0027162936,
-0.0325496756,
0.0058456743,
-0.0301630851,
0.0089311311,
-0.0086711599,
-0.0053609582,
0.0037640375,
0.0029486532,
-0.030674126,
0.0023556047,
0.0732374191,
-0.0168308262,
0.0096607767,
-0.0021389502,
-0.0183775928,
-0.0355194546,
0.0287550893,
0.0089973686,
0.0440173075,
-0.0592796467,
0.0024004194,
-0.0315394141,
-0.0265753195,
0.0290527213,
-0.0124186845,
-0.0347757749,
0.000326287,
0.0571466163,
0.0458115116,
0.0013029568,
-0.0026866831,
-0.0470819995,
-0.0264576152,
0.0018972426,
-0.0584866479,
0.0128657669,
-5.829093917e-33,
-0.0026076487,
0.0048243115,
0.0281661898,
-0.0036665294,
-0.0006016225,
-0.0036309562,
-0.023573745,
0.0275524035,
0.0060867802,
-0.0201481935,
-0.0737098902,
-0.0042203441,
0.0209594108,
0.0169829447,
0.0171497818,
-0.0143079273,
0.0500388965,
0.0163612496,
-0.0274313744,
0.012105355,
0.0484787188,
0.0911818519,
0.0434517078,
-0.0203866009,
0.0337163731,
0.006237119,
0.0093070613,
-0.0143912071,
0.0652419329,
0.0640871972,
-0.0076455516,
0.038735047,
0.0086946897,
0.0010133319,
-0.0160928704,
0.0349559784,
-0.0301179364,
-0.0437988602,
0.0294163935,
-0.0198734365,
-0.0249671005,
-0.0685667917,
0.068097733,
-0.0491016656,
-0.0545064658,
0.0412362032,
0.0301482175,
-0.0013846827,
-0.0415148884,
-0.0058664787,
-0.0228737518,
-0.0019473751,
0.0305556823,
0.0036199554,
0.01644665,
-0.0113128554,
-0.0043901214,
-0.0020392668,
-0.0108046634,
0.0367555507,
0.036445342,
0.044293616,
0.0181743372,
0.0244089141,
-0.0104223974,
0.0326853171,
0.0247093365,
0.0202778764,
-0.0079461792,
-0.0587597378,
0.0209843479,
0.0196574945,
0.0111921355,
0.0680926517,
0.0212397985,
-0.0181985404,
0.0127304289,
0.0272526611,
0.04434333,
0.0184278395,
0.0200473648,
-0.0024979266,
-0.0481779203,
-0.0121329091,
-0.0282663237,
0.066194661,
-0.0423579589,
-0.0697413087,
0.0575545654,
0.0013582958,
-0.0159270335,
-0.0176956039,
0.0460868366,
-0.0010003768,
-0.0232789442,
-0.012092622,
0.0040511764,
0.0291721988,
0.0236989465,
-0.0287878364,
-0.0438034758,
-0.0077910922,
0.0261721127,
-0.0359755605,
-0.0051264516,
0.0166020375,
0.0024299126,
0.0016576261,
-0.0656555519,
0.0040148092,
0.0192008223,
-0.0112822289,
0.0004362982,
-0.0214007013,
0.0407812484,
0.0164731182,
-0.0340502374,
0.0552481152,
0.0048418851,
-0.0196960792,
-0.0262168162,
-0.0908158198,
0.0172118265,
0.0331139825,
-0.0475509949,
0.0289080814,
-0.0443894155,
0.039477326,
0.0368548967,
-0.0316027403,
0.0024190356,
-0.008317518,
2.575e-7,
0.0359955169,
0.1042410657,
-0.0310135186,
0.022770036,
-0.0135420905,
0.0113205928,
0.0218972303,
0.0356403328,
0.0188828707,
0.0263433289,
0.0476603657,
0.0241098441,
-0.0043430319,
-0.0251114257,
-0.0966421962,
-0.007856993,
-0.066508837,
0.0600982271,
-0.0535795242,
-0.0091465479,
-0.0022618009,
0.0630741939,
0.0193110313,
-0.0041699214,
0.0410771295,
-0.0505115017,
0.0467318557,
-0.0741057545,
-0.0004623529,
0.0125006558,
0.0848629847,
0.0009253545,
-0.0035747983,
0.0099356119,
-0.0337861031,
-0.0168995224,
-0.0060647377,
0.0374322906,
-0.0621256232,
-0.0155192316,
0.0208713263,
-0.0198562108,
-0.0097016776,
-0.0460085869,
0.0583420992,
0.0198608469,
0.0272911061,
0.0123986267,
0.0168129224,
-0.0335692987,
0.0193580352,
-0.0342346579,
-0.0232717805,
0.0048495536,
0.0154680796,
0.0277873594,
-0.0037926279,
-0.0839214101,
0.0203757361,
0.0071484335,
-0.0289322566,
-0.032214947,
-0.0829127654,
-0.0174511485,
0.0068563838,
-0.0771696642,
0.0043475847,
2.233696406e-34,
0.0085887592,
0.0318212584,
0.024050314,
0.0322289504,
-0.0045065326,
0.0077776834,
0.0209421478,
0.0248493459,
0.0601756163,
-0.1016241908,
-0.0475263111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.17256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.17256v1 | From Bytes to Biases: Investigating the Cultural Self-Perception of Large Language Models | 2023-12-21T22:50:14 | 2023-12-21T22:50:14 | Wolfgang Messner, Tatum Greene, Josephine Matalone | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are able to engage in natural-sounding
conversations with humans, showcasing unprecedented capabilities for
information retrieval and automated decision support. They have disrupted
human-technology interaction and the way businesses operate. However,
technologies based on generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) are known to
hallucinate, misinform, and display biases introduced by the massive datasets
on which they are trained. Existing research indicates that humans may
unconsciously internalize these biases, which can persist even after they stop
using the programs. This study explores the cultural self-perception of LLMs by
prompting ChatGPT (OpenAI) and Bard (Google) with value questions derived from
the GLOBE project. The findings reveal that their cultural self-perception is
most closely aligned with the values of English-speaking countries and
countries characterized by sustained economic competitiveness. Recognizing the
cultural biases of LLMs and understanding how they work is crucial for all
members of society because one does not want the black box of artificial
intelligence to perpetuate bias in humans, who might, in turn, inadvertently
create and train even more biased algorithms. | [
0.0438726991,
0.0792736709,
-0.0540891886,
0.0133384774,
-0.031303212,
0.0226110257,
0.0291006546,
-0.0315247215,
0.0515477471,
-0.0114006316,
-0.01874483,
0.0031937207,
0.025603706,
0.0205959063,
0.0028696172,
-0.0222572908,
0.0185416136,
0.0199307408,
0.0417893492,
-0.0377602354,
0.0019713594,
0.0335017405,
0.0250519961,
0.0656986088,
-0.0122557702,
-0.0229225568,
0.0442202426,
-0.0338729098,
-0.0009039442,
-0.0224550534,
0.0175851136,
0.0337984599,
-0.008332015,
0.0426231101,
0.0000019076,
-0.0683872029,
0.0213700756,
-0.0125716981,
-0.0018362805,
0.0352985747,
0.0912900716,
0.0499306656,
-0.0195183139,
0.0315958969,
-0.0739031732,
-0.0122441752,
0.0336216763,
0.0167767704,
0.0112736477,
0.0305848327,
-0.0091067227,
-0.02826933,
-0.0361725055,
0.0009007833,
-0.030388955,
-0.0219723228,
0.0419371873,
0.0266804639,
-0.0388591923,
-0.0077247489,
-0.0178855844,
0.0276452154,
0.0080279643,
-0.0036183812,
-0.0258896127,
0.0261254255,
-0.0723957941,
-0.0503120497,
0.0180577114,
0.0419562049,
0.064553909,
-0.0169482902,
-0.0144269094,
-0.0059727156,
0.0223771408,
-0.0036725684,
-0.0105953803,
0.0761937872,
-0.0046682241,
0.0276624635,
0.0053207031,
-0.0088800509,
-0.0003041187,
0.0226021484,
-0.025211066,
0.0739092603,
-0.020152308,
-0.0177780408,
-0.0097570382,
0.012501657,
0.0247261915,
-0.0449408181,
-0.0047907941,
0.0140997516,
0.0020972998,
0.018922437,
0.008912744,
0.0255934969,
-0.0052471599,
-0.0809387788,
-0.028009003,
0.051271446,
-0.0545018688,
0.0065458952,
0.0190519821,
0.022365896,
-0.0052248305,
-0.0082794903,
-0.037135005,
-0.0028616639,
-0.0171644185,
-0.0188166499,
0.0129506364,
-0.011793646,
0.0147246467,
0.0141848875,
-0.0439710729,
0.014892932,
-0.0574467853,
0.0469245501,
-0.0277027767,
-0.0037117889,
0.0181517247,
-0.0103583783,
-0.0706407502,
0.051830899,
-0.0523018986,
-0.0046650204,
-0.023822207,
-0.0983039886,
0.0595597215,
0.0137478905,
-0.0258757677,
-0.0194130372,
0.0002068063,
0.0314178132,
0.0144184269,
0.0092046661,
-0.0480750389,
0.0072541265,
0.0131201977,
-0.0465750396,
0.0114555825,
-0.022091426,
-0.0065419907,
0.02719808,
-0.0057081771,
-0.0480492301,
0.013273932,
0.0390704982,
-0.050757695,
0.0465564132,
-0.0070929388,
0.0416165963,
0.0699060932,
0.0095166322,
0.0029450143,
0.0880156606,
0.0128920851,
0.0399529971,
0.0625425801,
-0.0096830251,
0.0086966129,
0.0212318841,
-0.0361107215,
-0.0255393889,
-0.0514307655,
0.0191862881,
-0.0249144454,
-0.0089124795,
0.0379036404,
0.0395535566,
-0.0066416487,
0.0451998897,
0.0593200661,
0.0604334325,
-0.0127062686,
0.0529361404,
0.0148163857,
0.0029430662,
-0.0093618417,
0.0148018384,
-0.0324560292,
-0.0129761202,
-0.0096816923,
-0.0093976017,
-0.0194768179,
0.057286974,
-0.0281631481,
-0.0413936675,
-0.0195607375,
0.0170837156,
0.0553699508,
0.0453613475,
0.0397759825,
-0.0374836288,
0.0119957775,
-0.0130809043,
0.0157958269,
-0.0390741043,
-0.0431994162,
-0.0620869994,
0.0327270739,
0.0751181245,
-0.0055793552,
0.0121273445,
0.0395451486,
0.0015353869,
-0.0212954022,
0.0477841236,
0.091549553,
-0.0031337282,
-0.0575821511,
-0.0142487977,
-0.0117953746,
-0.0058659804,
-0.0093210815,
0.0087769683,
0.0103092967,
0.0594564863,
0.0040325909,
-0.0077218376,
-0.0324590504,
0.0037795999,
-0.0298255812,
-0.0151913892,
-0.0371671617,
0.0253811404,
0.0178907532,
0.0396109633,
-0.0266543701,
0.0160428714,
-0.0149359992,
0.0008073045,
-0.0130271027,
0.059700951,
-0.0262380205,
0.0452217758,
0.0193202794,
-0.0608181581,
-0.030084746,
-0.0061965957,
0.0082563041,
0.0112169618,
0.0176845267,
-0.0010821113,
0.0511782095,
-0.0360364616,
0.002485886,
-0.0631292388,
0.0386517346,
-0.0216802452,
0.0320273899,
-0.0167476051,
-0.0149415648,
0.0042077755,
-0.0036550486,
0.0509373099,
-0.0210104249,
-0.0386976004,
0.0656980425,
0.0146394363,
0.0111867106,
0.0608169883,
0.0051661148,
-0.0425764956,
0.0157163553,
-0.1200853959,
-0.0456073694,
-0.0017914928,
-0.0163425226,
0.0055758315,
-0.0202429611,
-0.0335233994,
0.0122378254,
-0.083144106,
-0.0029232088,
0.0147023899,
0.0656737983,
0.0291951951,
-0.0279759113,
0.0018273632,
0.0212195721,
0.0063971924,
-0.0187857579,
0.0084897997,
0.038564492,
-0.0049214847,
-0.0666772425,
0.0082162665,
-0.0598366596,
-0.0044751731,
-0.0341587178,
-0.0265944153,
0.0253582336,
0.0184359085,
0.0411131196,
0.0672828108,
0.0230709612,
0.0292044804,
0.0581874847,
0.0080597149,
-0.030118946,
-0.0295810923,
0.0120976651,
-0.0060204044,
0.0317047313,
-0.0783552453,
-0.0205527227,
0.0384754613,
0.0231333245,
0.0146411825,
-0.0148653397,
0.0837959871,
-0.0626859441,
-0.0514970049,
-0.0215993058,
-0.0053616324,
-0.0066809836,
0.0889164358,
-0.0072007319,
-0.0672680959,
0.0387226418,
0.0340625197,
0.0093478458,
-0.0059416224,
-0.005301625,
-0.0150195146,
0.0431650132,
-0.023938112,
0.0390081033,
0.0336201936,
-0.0277118273,
-0.0482929461,
-0.0113887601,
0.0167063866,
-0.0494374223,
-0.0029355956,
-0.0331289284,
-0.0191718172,
-0.0118395975,
-0.0162083674,
-0.0482818522,
-0.0001100315,
-0.0367376693,
-0.0111625502,
0.055775281,
-0.0148012089,
0.0011290857,
-0.0061962721,
0.0482480787,
-0.0142882522,
0.0023790838,
-0.0023012969,
0.0319586545,
-0.0489612333,
0.0469767787,
0.0223535132,
0.0601636395,
0.0144318575,
0.0399494879,
0.0052156765,
0.0146005489,
-0.0146109257,
0.003127913,
-0.0120704388,
0.0440665185,
-0.0050900951,
-0.0088880099,
0.0272635445,
0.0353311114,
-0.0096292282,
0.0167762432,
0.0721816346,
-0.0010238244,
-0.0519987084,
0.0053194314,
-0.0439038835,
-0.0258843154,
0.0393451788,
0.0355612151,
-0.1280736625,
0.0283381976,
0.0022166963,
-0.0033226404,
-0.0665405169,
-0.0143739069,
-0.0297507849,
-0.1466143578,
0.0375279784,
-0.0045570419,
-0.013412199,
0.0019171047,
0.0052673407,
-0.0430691913,
-0.0176365487,
0.055252675,
-0.0228741895,
0.004827369,
-0.0018030728,
-0.0128573738,
-0.0640686676,
-0.0444533974,
0.0312858745,
-0.0200176649,
0.0366823934,
0.0702940375,
0.0444500931,
0.0006311661,
-0.0345634855,
0.0063184891,
0.0243587717,
0.0113467965,
-0.0070602573,
0.0242605042,
-0.0094076917,
-0.016054133,
-0.0065386132,
-0.0155760525,
-0.011475347,
0.0158069357,
0.0318721347,
0.028104512,
-0.0020441557,
-0.0542360619,
-0.0032441122,
-0.0060192375,
-0.0229285806,
0.0603309534,
-0.0142738819,
-0.0497523323,
0.0092248088,
-0.0527156033,
0.0065215649,
0.0261812415,
-0.0710898787,
0.0568008907,
0.0028323026,
-0.0549855754,
-0.0392400809,
-0.0915394202,
-0.0073990887,
-0.0145434821,
0.0423924401,
-0.0451993458,
0.0294672288,
0.0254540425,
-0.0195171814,
0.0066060037,
-0.0342756361,
0.0044956678,
-0.016359657,
-0.0230155252,
0.0093934229,
-0.0504040606,
0.0171225034,
0.0124933356,
-0.0065696933,
-0.0404861718,
0.0519402437,
0.0527298078,
0.0255074017,
-0.0073352256,
0.0185557455,
-0.0274469461,
0.0373409241,
0.0386397578,
-0.0227143187,
-0.0052065058,
0.0053096642,
0.051978413,
0.0020010821,
0.0169066805,
-0.0197674856,
0.0286233723,
-0.0080341278,
-0.0034658019,
-0.0228223223,
-0.0275322068,
0.0519704409,
0.0456516817,
0.0283039324,
-0.044567693,
0.0420908332,
-0.0384834483,
-0.0374984145,
-0.0447420776,
-0.0279319789,
-0.011950288,
-0.0471670441,
0.0256014373,
0.0077241161,
0.0186878648,
-0.0024947147,
-0.0475376844,
-0.0441596508,
-0.0370268784,
0.0468162633,
0.0197362583,
0.0878781006,
-0.004712536,
0.0050688423,
-0.0131336879,
0.0300061516,
0.0014749635,
0.0345866233,
0.0215663835,
0.0936036408,
0.0113718119,
-0.0075879018,
0.0348575413,
0.0245075263,
-0.0207282677,
-0.1093191355,
0.032305494,
0.0056347302,
0.0609703474,
-0.0400804281,
0.005787652,
-0.000685796,
0.0009606471,
0.0181067511,
-0.0055867019,
0.0231571514,
-0.0633390024,
-0.0182489771,
-0.0212312751,
-0.0672140047,
-0.0080617666,
0.0762016326,
-0.024613943,
0.0091897678,
-0.0228115506,
-0.0451959521,
-0.0277422033,
-0.0408764035,
0.0278630257,
-0.0146363396,
-0.0267464872,
-0.0037291641,
-0.0844184458,
-0.073602818,
-0.0914130583,
-0.0067231366,
0.011034769,
-0.0505266264,
-0.0033152003,
0.0767149702,
-0.0237376522,
-0.0385719687,
-0.0464280732,
0.01996677,
-0.0871353969,
0.0123626385,
-0.0115660615,
-6.154980991e-33,
0.0320749953,
-0.0278890189,
0.0240684189,
-0.0157804731,
-0.0073102391,
-0.0252382047,
-0.0235736612,
0.0487954132,
-0.0785205662,
0.0178599879,
-0.041089315,
-0.0035165432,
0.0144910347,
-0.0288973227,
0.0513140298,
0.0108454945,
0.0287972409,
-0.0097392229,
-0.0091339452,
0.0029651497,
0.0296941772,
0.0017390787,
0.0475287214,
-0.0712704509,
0.0806235075,
-0.0100669079,
-0.0185249019,
0.0140604051,
0.0345610417,
-0.0075618238,
-0.0401204415,
0.0530269332,
0.0285302531,
-0.047682777,
-0.0142090395,
0.0373314321,
-0.0089700352,
-0.027371984,
0.0262640063,
0.0343214087,
0.062565513,
-0.0295034647,
0.0100262621,
-0.0370441042,
-0.063774325,
0.0636464655,
0.0538094863,
-0.0212205257,
0.01813104,
0.0209555775,
-0.0490971543,
-0.0019245666,
-0.0172588229,
0.0574432649,
-0.0055148914,
0.0530425608,
-0.0235786401,
0.0236859731,
-0.044589065,
0.0443547517,
0.0190736242,
-0.0102298297,
0.0922949538,
0.0066300891,
0.0320701823,
0.0471454933,
0.0815047547,
0.0569385253,
-0.0445536375,
-0.05860845,
0.0318578742,
-0.0011429253,
-0.0166672133,
0.0579494387,
0.005053659,
-0.068008408,
-0.007916267,
-0.0052743694,
0.0552601852,
0.0064250887,
0.0127285812,
0.0056313179,
-0.0558331572,
-0.0501356348,
0.0187685825,
-0.0496402569,
-0.0291659217,
-0.0402065963,
0.0223238971,
-0.0209895838,
0.0090178084,
-0.0132050393,
0.0334436893,
-0.0524552949,
-0.0072922972,
-0.0220569093,
-0.026171593,
-0.0298344772,
0.0113026267,
-0.0062248944,
-0.0636434034,
-0.0088059921,
-0.0570973158,
0.0479768552,
0.0032740189,
0.0506410375,
-0.0325058065,
-0.0081085674,
-0.0389861688,
-0.0058932914,
-0.0263356511,
-0.0151575366,
0.0050146957,
-0.0406473204,
0.0415891185,
0.0040012514,
-0.0011580756,
-0.0287057701,
0.0520078689,
0.03068549,
-0.0609542653,
-0.0533749722,
-0.0285703335,
0.026505895,
-0.0494923927,
-0.02584517,
-0.0459920801,
0.0715787262,
0.0531724356,
-0.0384948291,
-0.0295703299,
-0.0188107733,
2.664e-7,
0.0012511628,
0.0618309826,
-0.0342911072,
0.0367209278,
0.010883593,
0.0425289683,
0.0020404065,
-0.0005217572,
0.0243300814,
0.0003486855,
0.0235367119,
0.0109188296,
0.0310916733,
0.0444560722,
-0.0874354616,
-0.0037952634,
-0.0539619252,
0.0258032493,
-0.0386462659,
0.0330025107,
0.0057602031,
0.0341050401,
-0.0076851812,
0.0007270046,
-0.0359105393,
-0.0304839779,
0.0334171169,
-0.0522733033,
0.0242857747,
-0.0081734126,
0.0089062927,
0.0276042707,
-0.001493593,
-0.0028195356,
0.0094184512,
-0.0041028517,
0.0147860479,
0.0443060212,
0.0105970884,
0.0117751537,
0.0027037517,
0.0129174776,
0.0107280994,
-0.0960226282,
0.0404959843,
-0.0320231654,
-0.0620349795,
-0.0437152609,
0.023261169,
-0.0305826776,
0.0395099446,
-0.0102619203,
-0.0214696284,
0.012778447,
0.0115086036,
0.0009688331,
0.0274231602,
-0.0264019072,
0.013053393,
-0.0338878036,
-0.0109906374,
-0.0613285191,
-0.008628713,
0.0374089107,
-0.0008823331,
0.0256733187,
0.0481563881,
1.968042259e-34,
0.0216758102,
-0.0106795169,
-0.0074428488,
0.0044155661,
0.0813528821,
0.0317867249,
0.0331925005,
0.0102639915,
0.010411514,
-0.0165258106,
-0.0122839231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14302v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14302v1 | Exploiting Novel GPT-4 APIs | 2023-12-21T21:22:41 | 2023-12-21T21:22:41 | Kellin Pelrine, Mohammad Taufeeque, Michał Zając, Euan McLean, Adam Gleave | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | Language model attacks typically assume one of two extreme threat models:
full white-box access to model weights, or black-box access limited to a text
generation API. However, real-world APIs are often more flexible than just text
generation: these APIs expose ``gray-box'' access leading to new threat
vectors. To explore this, we red-team three new functionalities exposed in the
GPT-4 APIs: fine-tuning, function calling and knowledge retrieval. We find that
fine-tuning a model on as few as 15 harmful examples or 100 benign examples can
remove core safeguards from GPT-4, enabling a range of harmful outputs.
Furthermore, we find that GPT-4 Assistants readily divulge the function call
schema and can be made to execute arbitrary function calls. Finally, we find
that knowledge retrieval can be hijacked by injecting instructions into
retrieval documents. These vulnerabilities highlight that any additions to the
functionality exposed by an API can create new vulnerabilities. | [
0.0191665906,
0.080697611,
-0.0119821224,
0.0610508434,
-0.0435854681,
-0.0179889295,
-0.0016100549,
-0.0062561836,
0.0207329877,
-0.0147457961,
-0.0314499699,
0.0104056774,
0.0062617231,
0.0481232665,
0.0712280273,
-0.0222054757,
0.0481288508,
-0.0246040113,
-0.0129547538,
-0.0240837075,
-0.0180263799,
0.0165797621,
0.0422324017,
0.0271030795,
0.0141821159,
-0.0121992752,
-0.0127640804,
0.018765565,
0.0172054972,
0.0216658898,
-0.006416494,
0.0211913884,
-0.0043886611,
0.082714729,
0.0000021286,
-0.000374151,
-0.0602966957,
0.0520567112,
-0.0093056317,
0.0353594981,
0.0030138972,
-0.0161469206,
-0.0072958847,
0.0196775999,
-0.0448529199,
-0.0064575085,
0.029305445,
-0.0107074091,
0.0756289065,
0.1061122939,
-0.0077286423,
-0.0143822934,
0.0326405056,
-0.0237385221,
0.0016371738,
-0.0513193309,
-0.0130245108,
-0.0447049253,
0.0025197743,
0.0628072321,
0.0352264978,
-0.0048711821,
-0.0001458721,
0.0410939492,
-0.0722537935,
0.0210281815,
-0.0729578286,
-0.0004253748,
0.0146149285,
0.0023796388,
-0.0313116536,
-0.0043946421,
-0.0014362521,
0.0183987226,
0.0133350855,
0.0060201893,
-0.0051119113,
0.0069658495,
-0.0076565738,
-0.0010423542,
0.029284535,
-0.0289794151,
0.0392198078,
-0.0156446714,
0.0130016552,
0.0752023086,
0.030729726,
-0.0300246365,
0.0109323617,
-0.056876149,
-0.0461818725,
-0.0054826047,
-0.0217563994,
0.0041677216,
0.0651821792,
0.0281890538,
-0.0624484234,
-0.0145531157,
0.0539039038,
-0.0147445081,
0.0034207834,
0.0623090751,
-0.0130504817,
-0.0082659014,
-0.0087092714,
0.032445889,
-0.0236849897,
0.010211356,
0.0208723117,
0.0002573406,
-0.0093343239,
-0.0303095784,
-0.0381068364,
0.0496341437,
-0.0320603251,
0.0068828054,
-0.0033192381,
0.0317854844,
-0.0137372985,
0.0305808093,
-0.0425300524,
-0.0032453905,
-0.0560278445,
-0.0171275958,
0.031910181,
-0.0141395805,
-0.0009999581,
-0.0508031137,
-0.0165162105,
-0.1002969071,
-0.0419865847,
-0.0219909847,
-0.0407320969,
-0.0361023024,
-0.0002389861,
0.0821279138,
0.0106549691,
-0.0344461463,
-0.0053551272,
-0.0958085954,
0.0086512649,
-0.0392074771,
-0.0033748879,
-0.0361513831,
-0.0561112016,
0.0209234562,
-0.0171250757,
-0.0396848284,
-0.007915861,
-0.0002618664,
-0.0602535345,
0.0503799394,
0.0016446795,
-0.0311208442,
0.0236558169,
0.0326897837,
-0.0271335412,
0.0580706485,
-0.0381283462,
0.0409535728,
0.0259475205,
-0.0195319094,
0.0403621718,
0.023811115,
0.0295940693,
0.0384039916,
0.0251117963,
0.028205961,
0.0442941599,
-0.0386168845,
-0.0063332575,
0.0522039719,
-0.0131402845,
-0.0343309604,
0.0936307609,
0.0497184731,
-0.038749855,
0.045145236,
0.0120601906,
0.0128897298,
-0.0022618182,
0.0267764833,
-0.0740091503,
-0.040488895,
-0.1180149987,
-0.0117764845,
-0.0035783607,
0.0514036044,
0.014456423,
0.0173255205,
0.0210494027,
-0.0244425535,
0.0035014271,
-0.0229526646,
0.0164535157,
0.02029741,
-0.0123454798,
0.030612452,
-0.0068740332,
-0.059231665,
-0.0498322248,
-0.0919387639,
-0.0375036411,
0.0199976526,
0.0772487596,
-0.051440414,
-0.0399964489,
0.0124105951,
-0.0358192362,
0.0150461271,
0.0218217541,
0.054224208,
0.0202213414,
-0.0224685688,
0.0149188899,
-0.0274635963,
0.0429680683,
0.0249267071,
0.0276702549,
0.0206625815,
0.0440006852,
-0.046433866,
-0.0305770729,
-0.0165038034,
0.0331830084,
-0.075853236,
0.0136204679,
0.0061953147,
0.0059231836,
-0.0044479892,
-0.0175271556,
0.0258848201,
0.0451386012,
0.0442152284,
0.028952824,
-0.0134101985,
-0.0259300172,
0.1000763774,
-0.0093700867,
-0.0228592586,
0.0240036603,
0.0851675794,
-0.0368785001,
-0.0273589361,
0.0687033832,
-0.0375277326,
0.0508603714,
-0.0261741374,
-0.0094623994,
-0.004720564,
0.0155604007,
-0.0101711471,
0.0434559807,
0.0280077178,
-0.0173310619,
-0.0282817744,
0.0418765321,
0.0161301605,
-0.0164545923,
-0.0494159944,
0.0052528777,
-0.0148185566,
0.0290603768,
0.0296143144,
0.0155695695,
0.0041462569,
-0.01373896,
-0.0668734461,
0.0291045867,
-0.0372803062,
0.0488286987,
0.0481154472,
0.0497828349,
-0.0431881398,
-0.0249416661,
-0.0187840946,
-0.0038731266,
-0.0203888863,
0.0218857266,
0.0049474915,
0.009525992,
-0.0014801517,
0.005183443,
0.0002037245,
-0.0004705141,
0.0435326621,
-0.0046627587,
0.0119420839,
-0.0176923051,
0.0181843992,
-0.0262798555,
0.0489171445,
-0.0125226136,
-0.0639760122,
0.0263216831,
-0.0272120889,
-0.0155405607,
0.0544737503,
-0.0004413044,
0.05731152,
0.0306482371,
0.0108446125,
-0.0174468122,
0.0050492482,
0.0001493619,
-0.0934031978,
-0.0269387923,
0.0099777402,
0.021151511,
0.0177628491,
0.039328713,
-0.0151449852,
-0.0524328463,
0.042916026,
0.0147750638,
0.0153327696,
0.048480358,
-0.0279598925,
-0.0387459584,
-0.0264882576,
0.0003461756,
-0.1185459346,
0.028714478,
-0.0528125837,
-0.0050946609,
-0.057457909,
-0.0365567207,
0.0261052605,
0.081371516,
0.0220568031,
0.0270770825,
0.0513331071,
-0.0094264895,
-0.0216629207,
0.0179351903,
0.0504298508,
-0.0616878718,
0.0384465642,
-0.0448745862,
-0.013425746,
-0.0327919424,
-0.040104907,
-0.0064542117,
0.0070899567,
0.010063678,
0.0128880702,
0.0365497991,
-0.0523965582,
0.010779324,
-0.031964343,
0.0528999008,
0.0493904576,
-0.0455240794,
-0.0045434688,
-0.0227642208,
-0.0290548466,
0.0248157326,
-0.0845226347,
-0.029892303,
0.0106640533,
-0.017902609,
0.0498185568,
0.0258120913,
-0.0169092771,
-0.0395406783,
-0.0185443535,
0.0106200697,
-0.008128155,
-0.0573777072,
0.0349193588,
0.0414645746,
-0.0581005737,
-0.0295842662,
0.0361914374,
0.0049300939,
-0.0719395354,
-0.0077320784,
-0.0102160955,
0.0351603329,
0.0084181055,
0.0476359986,
-0.0814177096,
-0.0121281641,
0.0323176235,
0.0913134366,
-0.034779314,
-0.0236153696,
-0.0019126118,
-0.1075143367,
0.0469838753,
0.0381013788,
-0.0384908952,
-0.0334842317,
-0.0166051593,
0.0070688226,
0.017984407,
0.0079199551,
-0.0086609004,
0.0092478329,
0.0402653627,
-0.021748418,
-0.0161591116,
-0.0284762699,
0.0132887261,
0.0116567723,
-0.0028501388,
0.0697376654,
-0.0155009236,
-0.0297087692,
0.0033539457,
0.0458298288,
-0.0337336659,
-0.0244863313,
0.003919296,
0.0392150432,
0.0032060975,
-0.021900136,
0.0271827858,
0.0474190228,
0.0041170418,
0.0217002966,
0.0133701609,
0.048190888,
-0.0259590968,
0.0095253643,
0.008826931,
-0.0366244018,
0.0540650189,
0.0397245623,
0.011472323,
0.0072096102,
-0.0372731201,
-0.0933128446,
0.0820913613,
-0.0328216031,
-0.0474742763,
-0.010533561,
0.0176777653,
-0.0267860871,
-0.0105192224,
-0.0141754644,
0.0030899826,
0.0191241633,
0.028262157,
-0.0032285615,
-0.0102665816,
0.0040207538,
-0.0565407164,
-0.0209999587,
-0.0169149302,
0.0084497835,
-0.0431293845,
-0.0473982319,
0.0120329903,
0.0057822601,
-0.0219121147,
0.0716139227,
-0.0254554655,
-0.0870247036,
0.0073906085,
0.0794669762,
0.0313113108,
0.0133349057,
-0.0197880827,
-0.0238016695,
0.0507886074,
0.0595742092,
-0.0499447845,
0.0147226229,
0.0628240928,
-0.0524431914,
0.0147436475,
0.0344859436,
-0.0335657671,
-0.0142373927,
0.0398942493,
-0.0422375277,
-0.0241983645,
0.0094650537,
0.0214439072,
0.056123659,
0.0565907843,
-0.0054344232,
0.0395498797,
0.0346124582,
0.0198686477,
-0.0143294707,
-0.0036060284,
-0.015237092,
0.0155837331,
-0.0017948477,
-0.0282006003,
0.036400076,
-0.027282875,
0.0324175023,
0.0452310629,
-0.01843559,
0.0076654064,
-0.0047294418,
0.017291544,
0.0705595315,
-0.023390159,
-0.0133410506,
0.0251994878,
-0.0089666899,
0.0443651266,
-0.044702027,
0.0396921337,
0.0211530179,
0.0016540006,
0.0277959965,
0.0523615181,
-0.0625479296,
-0.0954550803,
0.0062281932,
-0.0096635297,
0.0009735497,
-0.0001535883,
0.0482314788,
-0.0401648097,
-0.0062618935,
-0.0413099155,
-0.0207379181,
0.0125729935,
-0.0157710016,
-0.0307814125,
-0.0114666279,
-0.0086034769,
0.0150897792,
0.0893255919,
-0.0203314722,
0.0708863437,
0.0168502126,
-0.0447268523,
-0.039557714,
-0.0589369573,
0.0409190245,
0.0272617824,
-0.0050082626,
-0.0459509827,
-0.0493334904,
-0.0740636736,
-0.0355969034,
-0.0323102772,
0.0110084396,
-0.0227213185,
-0.0079724425,
0.0828116313,
-0.0127019789,
0.0005011539,
-0.0635722801,
0.0172298141,
-0.0369032025,
-0.0273122564,
0.040390227,
-6.286750969e-33,
0.0012831747,
-0.0061754389,
-0.0524560362,
0.0386555418,
0.0307312179,
0.0126934825,
-0.0108279176,
-0.016769411,
-0.0036902742,
-0.0293089021,
-0.0141829606,
-0.0065635303,
0.0113034388,
0.0226124134,
-0.0086429985,
0.0204278398,
-0.0279823467,
-0.0099648619,
-0.0427148715,
0.078857109,
0.0981921032,
0.0096627995,
0.0610433072,
-0.0453159064,
-0.0054130466,
-0.0148072783,
-0.0368372165,
-0.0204818938,
-0.0654336065,
0.0249013361,
0.0102413883,
0.0277437642,
-0.0091436617,
-0.018897377,
0.0014337972,
0.0082178731,
0.017079005,
-0.0139099983,
0.0050732861,
-0.0319007337,
0.00211038,
-0.0560637973,
0.0316771641,
-0.014341021,
0.014830892,
-0.0246488284,
-0.0300401393,
-0.0186275635,
-0.0213546921,
-0.010303244,
-0.0232576132,
0.0077439165,
-0.0093008727,
0.0369340926,
0.0005477386,
-0.0060827285,
0.0288270526,
-0.0142217353,
-0.016092876,
0.0245088693,
0.0639855117,
0.0310899355,
0.023138281,
0.0034433033,
0.0032628255,
0.0168983918,
-0.0223534238,
-0.0411925688,
-0.0106514916,
0.0105085019,
-0.0054643853,
0.0418389998,
0.0122838188,
0.0178507213,
0.0284763463,
-0.0671311393,
0.0043637217,
0.0229423754,
0.0054576155,
0.0273658466,
0.0423647054,
-0.0155188069,
-0.0737263039,
0.0097310264,
-0.0042011314,
-0.0400269628,
-0.0458190776,
-0.036921978,
0.0000118254,
-0.006889537,
-0.0302831139,
0.0541839041,
-0.0054863505,
-0.0158316847,
0.0476310477,
0.0307185967,
-0.0619537421,
-0.029684471,
-0.0211484358,
0.0167855248,
0.0353831984,
-0.0120906793,
0.003128337,
-0.032169532,
0.027274454,
0.0095331678,
0.0107060988,
0.058726456,
-0.0689653084,
0.0062003774,
-0.0422718301,
0.0773185045,
0.0000162784,
-0.0040884474,
0.026619643,
-0.0188883021,
0.0440141596,
-0.0314991884,
0.0328561254,
0.0305469409,
-0.0718278214,
0.0240761526,
-0.0103192301,
0.0073333369,
-0.0056321332,
0.0278079119,
0.0269242246,
0.0453161448,
0.0523015745,
-0.0171147231,
-0.0136862546,
0.0010193313,
3.115e-7,
0.0353279226,
0.0003800451,
0.003222768,
0.0351375602,
0.0196928773,
0.071419999,
0.0022130325,
0.0838022232,
-0.0003021149,
-0.0033226178,
-0.0248185508,
-0.0179694612,
0.0376365818,
0.0257351175,
-0.0490946397,
0.0470969304,
-0.0375619642,
-0.0189989209,
-0.0829530358,
-0.0094679911,
0.0316562168,
0.0736005604,
0.0060179508,
-0.0393632986,
-0.0072786869,
-0.0676890314,
0.0231981836,
-0.0051002083,
-0.0057536163,
-0.0341335125,
0.0129532842,
0.0992941186,
-0.0193245951,
0.011862942,
-0.0378415659,
-0.0115081379,
-0.049552042,
0.0503347628,
0.0216118023,
-0.0298375133,
-0.0172970127,
-0.0440225452,
0.0096087959,
-0.0701594725,
0.0578928627,
0.0247464571,
-0.0087309582,
0.0091339471,
-0.0391983353,
-0.0491605029,
-0.0224750508,
-0.051435858,
-0.0330147073,
0.025792215,
-0.0291925985,
0.0021828017,
0.0325676985,
-0.0496431999,
0.0026599085,
-0.0165900141,
-0.0334137715,
-0.0395904258,
-0.0265383683,
0.0051882616,
-0.0204894673,
0.0015342409,
0.0276811346,
3.286153692e-34,
-0.0059876358,
-0.0537968688,
0.0235279184,
-0.0195523836,
0.0410201438,
-0.0035925161,
0.0124566304,
0.0308560245,
-0.0274545345,
-0.0381174646,
-0.0362470895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14279v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14279v2 | Characterizing and Classifying Developer Forum Posts with their Intentions | 2023-12-21T20:17:01 | 2024-04-10T14:25:30 | Xingfang Wu, Eric Laufer, Heng Li, Foutse Khomh, Santhosh Srinivasan, Jayden Luo | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG | With the rapid growth of the developer community, the amount of posts on
online technical forums has been growing rapidly, which poses difficulties for
users to filter useful posts and find important information. Tags provide a
concise feature dimension for users to locate their interested posts and for
search engines to index the most relevant posts according to the queries.
However, most tags are only focused on the technical perspective (e.g., program
language, platform, tool). In most cases, forum posts in online developer
communities reveal the author's intentions to solve a problem, ask for advice,
share information, etc. The modeling of the intentions of posts can provide an
extra dimension to the current tag taxonomy. By referencing previous studies
and learning from industrial perspectives, we create a refined taxonomy for the
intentions of technical forum posts. Through manual labeling and analysis on a
sampled post dataset extracted from online forums, we understand the relevance
between the constitution of posts (code, error messages) and their intentions.
Furthermore, inspired by our manual study, we design a pre-trained
transformer-based model to automatically predict post intentions. The best
variant of our intention prediction framework, which achieves a Micro F1-score
of 0.589, Top 1-3 accuracy of 62.6% to 87.8%, and an average AUC of 0.787,
outperforms the state-of-the-art baseline approach. Our characterization and
automated classification of forum posts regarding their intentions may help
forum maintainers or third-party tool developers improve the organization and
retrieval of posts on technical forums. We have released our annotated dataset
and codes in our supplementary material package. | [
0.0854511559,
0.0089242291,
-0.0227845572,
-0.0062817042,
0.0118252384,
-0.0302650537,
-0.0155189848,
0.0308930892,
0.0188967194,
-0.0614346154,
-0.0084061697,
-0.0115096802,
-0.0140074287,
0.0387227014,
-0.0224554315,
-0.0284616165,
0.012326614,
0.0139634106,
0.0266501345,
0.082614243,
0.0496047214,
0.0278952178,
-0.0078887669,
0.0737250671,
-0.0306893047,
-0.0385695733,
0.0383050181,
0.0155274644,
-0.0075232871,
-0.0313688889,
0.0511094369,
0.0475812852,
-0.008434576,
0.001347331,
0.0000022201,
-0.0453173034,
-0.0405596606,
-0.0416857041,
-0.015271618,
-0.0151139824,
0.0299020745,
0.0209437553,
0.0087122135,
0.0528962538,
-0.0910033137,
-0.0089601539,
0.0326590277,
0.0709252506,
0.058929693,
0.0404004119,
-0.0220071767,
-0.0175549649,
0.0095554339,
0.0365047269,
0.0409255177,
-0.0141564934,
0.0094476165,
0.0331550762,
0.0033491033,
0.0512594692,
0.0264691506,
-0.0098249232,
-0.0362134501,
-0.0144094666,
0.0884888992,
0.0178151876,
0.0193992481,
-0.082965903,
0.0350349247,
0.0077434587,
0.0475284047,
-0.0388003401,
0.0320316143,
0.0037201138,
-0.0165738855,
0.083564274,
-0.0276117809,
0.0013866404,
-0.0168864485,
-0.0211312547,
0.0439877547,
0.0429109745,
-0.0039186887,
-0.0252821352,
-0.006414325,
0.0019234013,
-0.028972419,
0.0001609216,
-0.0229736548,
0.0150936488,
0.0257448349,
-0.0559971146,
0.00850101,
0.0473899655,
-0.0261437707,
0.0315751173,
0.0007663712,
-0.0145555036,
0.024871381,
-0.0486620702,
-0.0215218756,
0.0128194438,
0.0265647657,
0.025703907,
-0.0044445922,
-0.0692211986,
0.0253231693,
0.0038374972,
-0.0341309533,
0.0227822214,
-0.0570407286,
-0.0239684414,
-0.058167886,
0.041069787,
0.0439018644,
-0.01983211,
-0.0171507448,
0.065124087,
0.008111963,
-0.0160038341,
0.0175642855,
-0.0183032826,
-0.0321151316,
0.0030347011,
-0.0024485867,
-0.0009778322,
-0.0320258439,
0.040394254,
-0.0065520285,
-0.0312894545,
0.01380073,
0.029254742,
0.0140047483,
0.0042745494,
0.0012214257,
0.037969254,
0.0458276086,
0.0116176065,
-0.0652275234,
-0.0613406375,
0.0248857979,
0.0530937314,
-0.0156699196,
-0.0226194952,
-0.0271192305,
0.0329430923,
0.0076599889,
-0.0293523297,
-0.0235428419,
0.0410936289,
0.0295455735,
0.0182967596,
-0.0676218644,
0.0238950085,
0.1007477865,
0.0570698418,
0.0025864842,
0.0417918637,
-0.030489672,
0.052640602,
0.0593837909,
-0.0261334516,
0.039198719,
0.0104959151,
-0.0349952057,
-0.0465513468,
0.0517483838,
0.0383456424,
0.0107452441,
-0.0143227447,
-0.0174502842,
0.0047546676,
-0.0019711708,
-0.0027309724,
-0.0139486371,
0.0337667279,
0.0339396372,
0.0170244239,
0.0167426746,
0.0512897484,
-0.0323170274,
-0.0405208468,
0.0341088548,
0.0479092933,
-0.0688385665,
-0.021966394,
0.0216226503,
-0.0062964945,
-0.0181853808,
-0.0460193045,
-0.0235536713,
-0.0045337449,
0.0155836139,
-0.018088609,
0.0305670612,
-0.0003753339,
-0.0282053761,
0.0492198132,
0.0140474616,
0.0167541932,
-0.0098613994,
-0.0700786486,
0.0289980378,
0.0069580758,
0.0083479062,
-0.0682593659,
-0.0624791346,
-0.0433166586,
0.0072274567,
-0.049713295,
0.0631051883,
-0.0069086174,
-0.0866147056,
-0.0364698619,
-0.0325822569,
0.0018050639,
0.0050820378,
-0.0225972943,
-0.0022807559,
0.0117591172,
0.0039271386,
-0.0037964846,
-0.0374989323,
0.0363079868,
0.0103946915,
0.0099745691,
-0.011137574,
-0.0031292816,
0.008122351,
0.0236096065,
0.0210573375,
0.0006428479,
0.0435740389,
0.0065759262,
-0.039073661,
-0.0332192034,
-0.0075340779,
0.0276573095,
0.0201641824,
-0.0376242399,
-0.0036264062,
-0.0036655976,
0.0001050162,
0.0042170361,
0.0352532081,
-0.05154562,
-0.0192145202,
0.0131777367,
-0.0320052207,
-0.0087387552,
-0.0455752537,
-0.02909052,
0.0095844418,
0.059675809,
0.0363519751,
-0.0270473007,
-0.0512570888,
0.0430964269,
0.0288457237,
-0.0078805443,
-0.0329261348,
-0.0641722083,
0.0184618831,
0.0768284276,
0.0186046343,
-0.0506904423,
0.0010187405,
-0.1137854084,
-0.0591525808,
-0.0427348763,
0.0095926607,
0.0320840739,
0.015129501,
0.0219832268,
-0.0038076953,
-0.0510073751,
-0.012952067,
-0.0249593165,
-0.0370934345,
0.0359594934,
-0.0034757112,
0.0056818877,
0.010467709,
-0.0167290196,
-0.0448709391,
0.0041215876,
0.0627568066,
-0.0732184872,
-0.0760385618,
0.0698296726,
-0.0251112748,
-0.0327482037,
-0.0209257007,
-0.0353515968,
-0.0098802522,
-0.0401655734,
-0.0149002951,
0.0340985097,
0.0502894446,
0.0124197025,
-0.0208946411,
0.0720751882,
-0.0590783805,
0.0031039724,
-0.0249213967,
0.0082248263,
-0.0140379146,
-0.0717253685,
0.0946480855,
0.0782201663,
-0.0070908829,
-0.0036566872,
-0.057907667,
-0.0015935276,
-0.0456609391,
0.0178174134,
0.005648498,
-0.0096554542,
0.0465076305,
0.0525790118,
0.0282315351,
-0.0214445498,
0.079387933,
-0.0032260648,
-0.0317676626,
-0.0523856916,
-0.0384497568,
-0.063396588,
0.0271507893,
-0.0165157672,
0.0200816002,
0.082876347,
0.0112127531,
-0.0045465534,
0.0173086654,
0.0144637004,
-0.0206351355,
-0.004115711,
-0.0008230236,
0.026308246,
0.0130510693,
0.0059267045,
0.0089754127,
-0.0650705993,
-0.0107583273,
-0.0326995514,
0.0236870889,
0.0068026511,
0.0105127636,
0.0375095047,
0.006771795,
0.0174878798,
0.0469330624,
-0.0818715915,
0.0325840339,
0.0126723293,
0.036882259,
0.0096207969,
0.0007321066,
0.0018480738,
-0.0465118065,
0.0478946269,
-0.0171597153,
-0.0114671402,
-0.0162089132,
-0.0639886111,
0.0539285131,
-0.0474680699,
-0.0239363424,
0.0297555588,
0.0364632905,
-0.0098759551,
-0.0042771939,
0.0786923915,
0.0668820813,
-0.0055069034,
-0.0094865039,
-0.0113416659,
0.0275777392,
0.0488209762,
0.0172790214,
-0.0850640088,
-0.0321580693,
-0.0331026837,
0.0163337793,
-0.0159337912,
-0.0109654199,
0.0169888083,
-0.0526112206,
0.0006231003,
-0.0231749676,
-0.0008657078,
0.0471047834,
-0.0860569552,
-0.0146247633,
-0.030583676,
-0.0620214455,
-0.0329945162,
-0.0178585574,
0.0069330754,
0.0422384553,
-0.1231588945,
-0.0200176481,
-0.0123920664,
0.0167934373,
0.0550819226,
0.0505648553,
-0.0133441593,
-0.0259514712,
-0.0206137989,
0.0212585032,
-0.0155297574,
0.0029125635,
-0.0285402406,
0.0483896472,
-0.0124793733,
0.0228332132,
0.0256772097,
-0.0016849735,
-0.1007349342,
-0.0065704156,
0.0219065193,
0.0807161927,
-0.0311383214,
-0.0200966559,
-0.0447367691,
0.0262421537,
0.0192502234,
0.0540349744,
0.0032264076,
-0.025403643,
-0.0009180494,
-0.0485802256,
0.0324199647,
0.001937659,
-0.0190104265,
-0.0634166151,
0.0053226505,
0.0036038323,
-0.0618248731,
-0.0346400067,
0.0035229633,
0.0179635715,
0.0250876416,
0.0011258969,
0.0604516231,
0.0122266943,
-0.0802080855,
0.0404826701,
0.0140655907,
0.0122604119,
-0.0263526011,
-0.0273118,
0.0463617668,
-0.0220001675,
-0.0303550716,
0.0043793372,
0.0036401676,
-0.0113732433,
-0.0257935915,
0.0400507227,
0.0210143197,
-0.0468071587,
-0.0411988236,
-0.0413682237,
-0.0370575301,
0.00490828,
-0.0567730553,
-0.0239668451,
0.0227453746,
0.0149451699,
-0.0247485582,
-0.0030614487,
-0.0368079022,
0.0299935173,
-0.0285004899,
-0.0371804088,
-0.0395028591,
-0.0414819419,
0.0178960897,
0.00951757,
0.0339788981,
0.0472867228,
-0.0007657253,
-0.0040474641,
-0.0197784305,
0.0404028371,
0.0011330515,
-0.0003171401,
0.0069388677,
0.0248827673,
-0.0349148326,
-0.0150716519,
0.0670991987,
-0.0325504355,
0.0123573355,
-0.0380388536,
0.0276141558,
-0.0062764622,
0.0197459441,
-0.0053327736,
0.0111537986,
-0.0204554182,
-0.040235918,
0.0631095171,
0.0458299778,
-0.0002155458,
0.0540206656,
0.0191937126,
0.0180569831,
0.0398184024,
0.029317962,
-0.0480678678,
-0.0802928582,
0.0038431408,
-0.0046088328,
-0.0250041988,
0.0170578901,
0.0176628251,
-0.0064873323,
0.0124386158,
-0.0246602278,
0.07365679,
-0.0023635328,
-0.0311288964,
0.026627006,
0.0000159647,
-0.0351907797,
-0.0389775895,
0.039505545,
-0.0967962891,
-0.0376517475,
-0.0151826916,
-0.0406560414,
-0.0555745848,
0.041002579,
0.0569511726,
0.0000394339,
-0.012163165,
-0.0281533897,
-0.0290026385,
-0.017781131,
0.0070399689,
-0.0481505319,
0.0545652173,
-0.00761477,
0.0551057942,
0.0747207999,
0.0074915816,
0.0155128324,
-0.0382603109,
-0.044542525,
-0.0813691318,
0.0142992111,
-0.0602341108,
-6.055341682e-33,
0.0131561663,
-0.0441068187,
-0.0042338739,
0.0150783109,
0.0027128365,
-0.0321203284,
-0.000266987,
0.0129533606,
-0.0201867148,
-0.0248989798,
0.0294438303,
0.0270544589,
-0.0108039165,
-0.0014769417,
0.0330563076,
0.0216434151,
0.0553988442,
0.0265226513,
-0.0047056633,
0.0965632945,
0.0015006814,
-0.0039396607,
-0.0147131206,
-0.0690900534,
0.0168279447,
-0.0005979305,
-0.0076451511,
0.0033780513,
0.0708401054,
0.0670251772,
-0.0168988127,
-0.0026615676,
0.0402205437,
-0.0291878525,
0.0109283887,
0.0283371098,
-0.0400556475,
-0.0269221198,
-0.0119316941,
0.0057757343,
0.010940806,
0.0111634973,
0.0514356606,
-0.0229011364,
-0.0103341583,
-0.0053919358,
0.0847009793,
0.0320838317,
0.0224623401,
-0.0634280071,
-0.0519925095,
0.0025261231,
-0.0286434665,
0.0067376238,
0.0106682107,
0.104882285,
0.0160979014,
0.0323071368,
-0.0487247705,
0.0059353551,
-0.0475122482,
0.0482528843,
0.0349106342,
0.0206406005,
-0.0279426798,
0.0304450691,
-0.0082640368,
0.0166414138,
0.0067411838,
-0.0002021095,
0.0223315544,
0.0113673266,
0.0272202324,
-0.0105759595,
0.0442685932,
-0.0167937744,
-0.0389931537,
0.0503913537,
-0.0451053604,
0.0147182196,
0.0578497797,
0.0240562689,
-0.0533757135,
-0.0102779884,
0.0173215456,
0.0158605371,
-0.0267792139,
-0.0372722186,
-0.0158940703,
0.0267555229,
-0.0188759081,
0.0084462296,
0.0058829654,
-0.069466427,
-0.0104329046,
-0.012992003,
-0.0231078397,
0.0297679994,
-0.0169269722,
0.0153941559,
-0.0042407061,
-0.0004013869,
-0.0167743564,
0.0097408555,
0.0363077745,
0.0042926879,
0.0151925543,
-0.0283584297,
-0.0477415919,
-0.0263907053,
-0.0043173446,
-0.0155796949,
-0.0517331362,
0.0579338744,
0.0151976673,
0.0422495082,
0.0127948783,
0.02503266,
0.0064503835,
0.0295723882,
-0.0643335506,
-0.0071753841,
-0.0045904899,
-0.0258473214,
-0.0186861977,
-0.0453867391,
-0.0086904215,
0.0539255552,
-0.0078772586,
-0.0473208055,
-0.0297013838,
-0.0339277163,
2.9e-7,
0.0311957393,
0.0604075193,
-0.025634557,
0.0106978528,
-0.0158605501,
0.0493595377,
0.0323553123,
0.0256942753,
0.041412849,
-0.008490718,
-0.0018872952,
0.0086583002,
0.0089843022,
0.0062486641,
-0.0592490993,
-0.0753395706,
0.0250501223,
0.0196130369,
-0.0280820839,
0.0647673309,
0.1153241917,
0.0491908379,
-0.0402771868,
0.0108143287,
0.0038616306,
-0.006807283,
-0.0005408088,
-0.0407783054,
0.025918141,
0.1150007024,
0.0594456866,
0.0151830073,
-0.0088922698,
-0.0102099469,
-0.050840348,
-0.0377283134,
-0.0364489593,
0.020848684,
-0.0128352456,
-0.015571394,
0.0058350852,
-0.0009774069,
0.0438868478,
-0.0626309216,
0.000864032,
-0.0755747333,
-0.036183212,
-0.0032901564,
-0.0142163131,
-0.0255086031,
0.0039788228,
-0.0172472429,
0.015152826,
0.0043120971,
-0.0098333778,
-0.0332144387,
-0.0377282612,
-0.0785381123,
-0.0067618545,
0.0504686572,
-0.0351053327,
-0.0252925958,
-0.0395709723,
0.0143968863,
0.0411366969,
0.0098605966,
0.0304800365,
2.510868102e-34,
0.0271307938,
0.0110332863,
-0.0206136014,
0.026665628,
0.028694652,
-0.0003786552,
-0.0334958956,
0.0286493693,
-0.0001984665,
-0.0399078839,
0.0110811302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14069v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14069v1 | EmphAssess : a Prosodic Benchmark on Assessing Emphasis Transfer in Speech-to-Speech Models | 2023-12-21T17:47:33 | 2023-12-21T17:47:33 | Maureen de Seyssel, Antony D'Avirro, Adina Williams, Emmanuel Dupoux | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | We introduce EmphAssess, a prosodic benchmark designed to evaluate the
capability of speech-to-speech models to encode and reproduce prosodic
emphasis. We apply this to two tasks: speech resynthesis and speech-to-speech
translation. In both cases, the benchmark evaluates the ability of the model to
encode emphasis in the speech input and accurately reproduce it in the output,
potentially across a change of speaker and language. As part of the evaluation
pipeline, we introduce EmphaClass, a new model that classifies emphasis at the
frame or word level. | [
-0.0283997878,
0.0368860811,
0.0107241813,
-0.0149190128,
-0.0096502965,
-0.0460959859,
-0.0413847715,
-0.0172926094,
-0.1027231589,
0.0001341686,
-0.0521325879,
-0.0249282382,
0.0259759724,
0.0103844572,
0.0403687656,
-0.1086591482,
0.019780878,
-0.0206386764,
0.000309795,
0.004104035,
0.0283737443,
-0.0079160593,
-0.0467100367,
0.0400670804,
-0.0110824667,
0.0240576677,
-0.0191443283,
0.0624473728,
0.0547630526,
0.0156164858,
-0.0120147234,
-0.0020905011,
0.0221402887,
-0.0329135023,
0.0000017928,
-0.0243175924,
-0.0331140012,
-0.0153229265,
-0.0190435834,
0.0471419841,
0.0655751079,
-0.0040117824,
-0.0416678749,
0.0281607863,
-0.0057250676,
0.0232788101,
0.0494748056,
-0.0168575626,
-0.0084974822,
0.051575169,
-0.0144256912,
-0.0191334169,
0.0140188495,
-0.0450647511,
-0.0630734488,
0.0114151957,
0.0036142129,
-0.0455576964,
-0.0055279629,
-0.0094897412,
-0.0226785094,
0.0628254414,
-0.0054426943,
0.0335787386,
0.0399360247,
-0.0241583697,
0.0268684495,
-0.0052986895,
-0.0261000004,
0.0596199967,
-0.0513773412,
0.0004409887,
0.0138923926,
-0.000767721,
-0.0230541416,
-0.0240413249,
0.0097686341,
-0.0159286913,
0.0593213588,
0.0108565651,
0.037491791,
0.0661061406,
-0.0041713575,
-0.0301601179,
-0.0084115546,
0.0018859291,
0.0598903522,
-0.0177777987,
0.008880984,
-0.0312598236,
-0.0502358153,
-0.0079921894,
0.0529997014,
0.0141567411,
0.0240626764,
-0.0068370756,
-0.0203131307,
-0.0392988175,
-0.0320288092,
0.0291647594,
-0.0077670077,
0.0177573636,
-0.049881503,
-0.0209882446,
-0.0059674899,
0.0619727261,
-0.0100742728,
-0.0074096969,
-0.0389644727,
-0.0053860554,
0.0150745129,
0.0442087986,
-0.0405144803,
0.0043753833,
-0.0335945897,
-0.0239558108,
-0.0495066047,
-0.0282143932,
-0.0380556211,
0.0066074841,
-0.0244524889,
-0.0103432667,
-0.0416501351,
-0.0079208603,
0.0349252596,
0.0832540393,
-0.0167063009,
0.0378960595,
0.0095428685,
-0.067344889,
-0.0133453701,
0.0099051706,
0.0173940901,
0.0011574128,
0.0108622918,
-0.0208055358,
-0.0001087834,
-0.0194756985,
-0.0155131714,
-0.0204437878,
-0.0504813455,
-0.0136996275,
-0.0220063534,
-0.0647821352,
0.0062304377,
-0.0067144376,
0.0005094068,
-0.0409238711,
-0.0015769633,
-0.0388446599,
0.0355223902,
0.0267462656,
0.0000615566,
0.0463185757,
0.0233139247,
-0.0017853663,
-0.0248510819,
-0.0060570566,
0.0436987653,
-0.0034205806,
0.0067780651,
-0.0150439171,
-0.0128396899,
0.0606625192,
0.0226092692,
0.0265838206,
-0.0514124297,
-0.0250155479,
0.0317026824,
0.0341476761,
0.0595734976,
0.0463256203,
-0.0277013052,
-0.0258520786,
0.1020777673,
0.0279224478,
0.0018993387,
-0.0101289945,
0.0133458767,
0.0229078531,
0.0201416221,
-0.0059204651,
0.0129509727,
-0.0183141194,
0.0393289886,
-0.0072302665,
0.0409633629,
0.0268578399,
-0.0287978482,
0.0235189069,
0.0104106851,
-0.028663557,
-0.0332623012,
-0.0276519563,
0.0053574084,
0.0345779657,
-0.0522818491,
0.0673889145,
0.0002924076,
-0.0704125464,
0.0261828937,
-0.0155569278,
-0.0302474033,
0.0155981388,
-0.0220453832,
-0.016518997,
0.0298137497,
-0.0244611762,
-0.0228024665,
0.0446555912,
0.0088533945,
-0.0080085136,
0.0660326928,
-0.0426989682,
0.0414700918,
-0.0243061017,
0.0255830679,
0.0200084727,
-0.0312935561,
0.0523008332,
0.0134717226,
-0.0070821838,
0.0362436101,
-0.0237551369,
0.0109781977,
-0.0005968775,
-0.001518673,
-0.0132767912,
0.0307256691,
0.0178145338,
-0.0339589976,
0.0351594202,
0.0232265517,
-0.0451162271,
0.0038138342,
0.0461614318,
-0.041044835,
-0.0041186372,
0.0502154343,
-0.0526240803,
0.038505163,
0.0352143571,
0.0369246826,
-0.0757043362,
0.0408832319,
-0.0431942977,
0.1033133641,
-0.0132778464,
0.0460546017,
-0.0007325844,
0.0428216383,
0.0197974667,
-0.0427153073,
0.0026232849,
-0.0144883497,
0.0394596644,
0.0201967042,
-0.0343606435,
-0.0607621334,
0.0196882468,
0.0074471761,
-0.004169968,
0.0243616235,
-0.0451210067,
-0.0618200377,
-0.0177953336,
-0.0625991076,
-0.0529856458,
0.0215747859,
0.0011106888,
0.0353307091,
0.0474864207,
0.0004457836,
-0.0051836153,
0.007884278,
-0.0298011098,
-0.0434159152,
-0.0452904813,
-0.0139222378,
-0.0199737344,
-0.0381802768,
-0.0098641645,
-0.0314688422,
0.0094177695,
0.0390166007,
0.0006155405,
-0.0374599621,
0.0098585719,
0.0011292705,
-0.0306565333,
0.035610497,
-0.0112729277,
0.030189693,
-0.0652221069,
-0.0282093287,
0.0217187162,
0.0453776568,
0.0269822199,
0.007044713,
0.0005187131,
0.0063713496,
-0.0752553493,
-0.023310883,
-0.0340235271,
-0.0056245234,
0.040848162,
-0.0130483098,
-0.0180037096,
-0.0000755425,
0.0134281395,
0.044594802,
0.0421416648,
-0.0647259876,
-0.0512360223,
0.0009135147,
-0.0404981226,
0.0375625528,
-0.0190174952,
-0.0383852869,
-0.0514492877,
-0.045809634,
-0.0012600614,
0.0213766713,
-0.0777844861,
-0.0513314642,
-0.0234289803,
-0.0038238817,
0.0234802309,
-0.0534714237,
-0.0630922019,
0.0131558701,
-0.0114251049,
-0.0165037941,
-0.0065921149,
0.035296794,
-0.0132010747,
-0.0666906834,
0.0165118556,
-0.0358647779,
-0.0381852016,
0.0009243867,
-0.0442477837,
0.0101961112,
-0.0341269523,
-0.0262051579,
0.0589344166,
0.0309665166,
-0.0451209508,
0.0190513097,
0.0033223554,
0.0205657072,
0.0350036509,
-0.005709846,
0.0197990704,
0.000754006,
0.0253086388,
0.0312106926,
0.0398157202,
-0.0134120621,
-0.0379922166,
0.0010812549,
0.0234997664,
0.0703668967,
0.0178133156,
-0.1005240828,
0.0255880672,
0.0305636376,
-0.0083961347,
0.0067350483,
-0.0142111788,
0.0947207287,
-0.0102330549,
0.0669665486,
0.081891723,
-0.031431254,
0.035076905,
0.0450169556,
-0.0125881806,
0.0534054562,
0.0144579643,
-0.0190769602,
-0.057702478,
-0.0579510815,
0.049832873,
0.0623520464,
-0.0077789742,
0.0201777369,
0.0058018067,
-0.1086215228,
0.0468391329,
0.0202190913,
-0.0102356467,
-0.0065086125,
-0.0192076787,
0.0183467306,
-0.0187740345,
-0.0097206971,
0.0323982574,
-0.0198848713,
-0.0058822278,
0.0461795554,
-0.0183532573,
-0.0407237522,
-0.0046148365,
-0.0638106018,
0.0752715021,
-0.0147072887,
0.0235865563,
0.0049248631,
-0.0514315441,
-0.0136036007,
-0.0584971495,
-0.03062254,
0.0052302978,
0.014164662,
0.0142803378,
-0.0303900894,
-0.01134062,
0.0580110326,
-0.0140722813,
0.0033744439,
0.0195608698,
0.0307605322,
0.0037270905,
0.028026728,
0.0223562848,
0.0263187476,
0.0101640141,
0.0570398457,
0.0446590409,
-0.047826238,
0.0105710477,
-0.0075099855,
0.031698294,
0.0193375107,
-0.0115417298,
-0.0107843867,
0.0215220321,
-0.0111493096,
-0.0768770799,
0.0231198668,
-0.0488937385,
0.0190271381,
0.0153822675,
-0.0619900152,
-0.0161414705,
-0.0413580872,
-0.0142908422,
0.022313999,
0.0215271302,
0.0708870813,
-0.062548168,
0.0043266881,
0.0239375327,
-0.0292538386,
-0.0090405764,
0.0006035432,
-0.0279492326,
-0.0545629077,
0.0530341491,
0.0072533619,
0.020301044,
0.0294763874,
-0.0264700819,
-0.0146864597,
0.0398464687,
-0.0343118981,
-0.044457797,
0.0748209134,
0.094532147,
-0.0402366705,
-0.0216683671,
0.0234656632,
0.0028556413,
0.0410887115,
0.0069647981,
0.0229939967,
-0.0035769725,
-0.1130980775,
-0.0050537088,
0.0098391157,
0.0695373937,
0.0093309823,
-0.0468393974,
-0.018435318,
0.0282336026,
-0.0010696747,
0.0766667202,
-0.0506976768,
-0.0060731107,
0.0540316552,
0.0501398332,
0.0028938188,
0.005776485,
-0.026751915,
-0.0516037717,
0.0015284347,
0.0385541208,
-0.0035505365,
0.0250773747,
-0.0266260821,
0.0363223888,
-0.0266600884,
0.0305524301,
-0.0172928162,
0.0302108098,
-0.016419515,
0.0227582064,
0.0079695098,
-0.052702792,
0.0371811651,
0.0333396867,
-0.0194051303,
0.0578864813,
-0.0094340127,
-0.0349265896,
0.0481405631,
0.0026871236,
0.1116771996,
-0.0131645901,
0.0328483917,
-0.0260386411,
0.0126065696,
-0.0851703435,
0.0269470029,
-0.0027185436,
-0.0165528897,
0.0072918581,
0.0787998363,
-0.0044974298,
-0.0455572084,
0.022326041,
-0.0170498397,
0.0603483208,
0.0051941052,
-0.0347392336,
-0.0221735761,
-0.0460058935,
-0.0024097872,
-0.0354585424,
-0.0192055777,
-0.0480763949,
0.0542534515,
0.0059526996,
0.0230868589,
-0.0417041071,
0.0280316379,
-0.0207816511,
-0.0532929972,
-0.0315403976,
-0.005091833,
-0.0412823968,
0.0034124688,
0.0159141216,
0.0357079618,
-6.138539866e-33,
0.0047328016,
0.0488097221,
-0.0246365834,
0.0126142222,
-0.0853057504,
0.0410636999,
-0.0441109315,
0.0146546839,
0.0133248912,
0.0035502047,
0.0057506328,
-0.000627352,
0.0265620276,
0.0126322443,
-0.0263556279,
0.0156561043,
0.0625799298,
0.0031649636,
-0.0226521604,
0.0064755445,
0.0195445437,
-0.0037258423,
0.0248574391,
-0.0737351999,
-0.0447113141,
0.0094112018,
-0.0293644425,
-0.0135055063,
0.0212954506,
0.0157177057,
0.0168690402,
0.0444466323,
-0.0281611066,
-0.0928862244,
-0.0108634401,
0.0178304203,
-0.0382677391,
-0.0113704167,
0.0238443371,
0.0087704333,
-0.0710519254,
-0.0125991069,
0.0225334037,
0.032021597,
-0.0253325459,
-0.0106716631,
-0.0194460209,
-0.0551867224,
0.0480927937,
0.0261696167,
-0.0189030655,
0.0400821902,
-0.0266966168,
-0.0232671369,
0.0595295951,
0.0460158326,
-0.0177680757,
-0.069934018,
-0.0119375968,
-0.0077893566,
0.0184314586,
0.0500608683,
0.0425079726,
0.0264246538,
-0.0142614041,
0.0264339875,
0.0315273143,
-0.0574271977,
0.0916615129,
0.0135023491,
0.0368245989,
0.0692804754,
0.0693233535,
0.0091754617,
-0.0027695491,
0.0157933049,
-0.0061653601,
-0.0198414139,
0.0177672375,
-0.0107122408,
-0.0125664007,
0.0261320695,
0.0194350798,
0.0117488317,
-0.0804882571,
-0.0453707948,
0.0039017086,
0.0110580893,
0.0160453655,
-0.0070003998,
0.0126245944,
0.0753915757,
0.0667910203,
0.0166819356,
0.0193181485,
-0.0388859697,
-0.0646583736,
0.0446060598,
-0.0187778827,
0.0133488486,
-0.0308204349,
0.0002052756,
0.0792955607,
0.0363667011,
0.0364143327,
-0.0036887156,
-0.0362969562,
0.0474945195,
-0.0288818534,
0.0077374312,
-0.0013953374,
0.0213949401,
-0.066807203,
-0.0124413595,
0.0185540486,
0.0135346809,
0.0029343995,
0.062764816,
-0.0133849438,
0.0413253568,
0.0158186574,
-0.0221974198,
0.0610112734,
0.0712348521,
-0.0493181422,
0.0332416855,
0.0158364493,
0.0125913508,
-0.002146811,
-0.0311392304,
-0.0302567016,
0.010621937,
2.573e-7,
0.0034304885,
0.0077720806,
0.0681052059,
-0.0302193817,
0.0251383614,
0.0244099218,
-0.0453224704,
0.0404746979,
0.0187189318,
-0.0152954236,
-0.0145848226,
0.0128927771,
0.127035439,
-0.0014714947,
-0.0545212217,
-0.0373577811,
-0.1026617587,
0.0028925778,
-0.0245223269,
0.0051390105,
0.0056669251,
0.0402786545,
-0.0070304777,
-0.0227830913,
0.0050242059,
0.0275066067,
0.0150772193,
-0.0248351116,
0.0332515053,
-0.0190260317,
0.0396609642,
-0.0262304284,
-0.0271268934,
0.0414798148,
-0.0480383225,
0.0292264204,
0.0466052257,
0.0793238431,
-0.0410543904,
-0.0920783281,
0.019702075,
0.0279080458,
-0.0712156445,
-0.0207467061,
0.0409134254,
-0.0142863393,
0.0003183816,
-0.0006130108,
-0.0693696663,
0.0239588507,
-0.0213970747,
-0.0442864224,
-0.017556686,
-0.0226485711,
0.0101122074,
0.0338509679,
-0.0666250885,
0.0064224931,
-0.0260625873,
0.0294444393,
-0.0191871151,
-0.0209798366,
-0.0265328288,
-0.0201333631,
-0.0297659487,
-0.0517601669,
-0.0265995953,
1.996422412e-34,
0.0004684546,
-0.047369834,
0.0475876965,
-0.0173069052,
0.0032080021,
-0.0322325081,
-0.0044970298,
0.0087753078,
0.0097495541,
-0.0217061266,
-0.0285282917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14033v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14033v3 | T-Eval: Evaluating the Tool Utilization Capability of Large Language Models Step by Step | 2023-12-21T17:02:06 | 2024-01-15T03:18:25 | Zehui Chen, Weihua Du, Wenwei Zhang, Kuikun Liu, Jiangning Liu, Miao Zheng, Jingming Zhuo, Songyang Zhang, Dahua Lin, Kai Chen, Feng Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLM) have achieved remarkable performance on various
NLP tasks and are augmented by tools for broader applications. Yet, how to
evaluate and analyze the tool-utilization capability of LLMs is still
under-explored. In contrast to previous works that evaluate models
holistically, we comprehensively decompose the tool utilization into multiple
sub-processes, including instruction following, planning, reasoning, retrieval,
understanding, and review. Based on that, we further introduce T-Eval to
evaluate the tool utilization capability step by step. T-Eval disentangles the
tool utilization evaluation into several sub-domains along model capabilities,
facilitating the inner understanding of both holistic and isolated competency
of LLMs. We conduct extensive experiments on T-Eval and in-depth analysis of
various LLMs. T-Eval not only exhibits consistency with the outcome-oriented
evaluation but also provides a more fine-grained analysis of the capabilities
of LLMs, providing a new perspective in LLM evaluation on tool-utilization
ability. The benchmark will be available at
https://github.com/open-compass/T-Eval. | [
0.0443007872,
0.0178273432,
-0.0148043344,
0.0519629233,
-0.0368355028,
0.0308274925,
0.003949285,
-0.0109965997,
-0.0197754577,
-0.0443720184,
-0.046358835,
0.0034768067,
-0.0181642417,
-0.0073001324,
-0.0002269846,
-0.0494862162,
0.0308951661,
-0.0357108861,
-0.0333934203,
0.0259209499,
0.0012598308,
0.0204129089,
-0.0058610858,
0.0764831901,
0.0182543155,
-0.0147979883,
0.0171566028,
-0.017072482,
-0.0033781365,
-0.0256646555,
-0.0163978096,
0.0484804213,
0.0014635926,
0.0642223358,
0.0000020505,
-0.0657090023,
-0.0301298015,
0.0204518773,
-0.0273880959,
0.0330990776,
0.0820380524,
-0.0111251138,
0.009200789,
0.020454701,
-0.0254403371,
-0.0150476275,
0.0220124647,
0.0171401855,
0.044171527,
0.060919486,
0.0141210323,
-0.0070609963,
0.0240854193,
-0.0172313359,
-0.0548655018,
-0.0470776744,
-0.0063110567,
0.03655871,
0.0457869396,
0.0289668944,
0.0116525823,
0.0712115616,
0.0505483076,
-0.0202697609,
0.0010662302,
0.0100584682,
-0.0158640686,
-0.0222550686,
0.0072433013,
0.0376194976,
0.004328398,
-0.0047285352,
-0.0138956634,
-0.0045796284,
-0.0173000358,
0.0460418835,
-0.0768426284,
0.041475974,
0.0098430393,
0.0068277232,
0.0125101022,
-0.0141269807,
0.0381462574,
0.0248278193,
0.0025477163,
0.0730816275,
0.0107858395,
-0.0094892588,
0.0193426609,
0.0296567529,
-0.0103254197,
-0.0564084835,
-0.0129476441,
0.0381072387,
-0.0561618656,
0.0370656736,
0.0089105275,
0.0026104744,
0.0373347402,
-0.0527799055,
0.0822734833,
0.0206146203,
-0.0028700905,
0.0482856818,
-0.0204232167,
0.045435667,
-0.0050703185,
0.0144046536,
-0.0491573624,
-0.0280839279,
-0.0864447206,
-0.017771095,
-0.0197512172,
0.0047134729,
-0.0413093194,
-0.0329421051,
-0.0092206653,
0.0143403262,
-0.0011830075,
-0.0012247706,
0.0352399424,
-0.018959254,
-0.0098520108,
-0.0111435084,
-0.0480432473,
0.0180219244,
-0.0289461408,
0.0252763443,
-0.0095479526,
-0.0602865294,
-0.0079345396,
0.0119151725,
-0.0365013666,
-0.0681697279,
0.0095540415,
0.1026787907,
-0.0001129351,
0.0044212262,
-0.0381359272,
-0.0306650139,
0.0024401904,
-0.0882704705,
0.0022288167,
-0.0870555192,
0.0000924071,
0.042493172,
0.0190333091,
-0.0260638893,
-0.0025403092,
-0.0038114507,
-0.0247742534,
0.0307836682,
0.0159743167,
0.0192603767,
-0.0137898326,
0.0076813861,
-0.0064065955,
0.0823288858,
-0.0071945777,
0.0337283835,
0.0165369995,
-0.0022053346,
-0.0225166623,
0.0541203544,
-0.0115783252,
0.0057739615,
-0.0473898202,
0.025246609,
0.0075468253,
0.0146735497,
0.0128489984,
0.0369458571,
-0.0230007172,
0.0111270677,
0.024697246,
0.0325512588,
0.0609771758,
0.0077282265,
0.0846751183,
-0.0013234843,
0.023197988,
-0.0082794409,
-0.0551116504,
-0.0108921407,
-0.050340686,
0.0019641274,
0.0010527415,
0.0266146585,
-0.0010646885,
-0.0344641879,
-0.0620377846,
0.0243845154,
-0.0161281824,
0.0166559462,
0.0439247712,
0.0189091358,
-0.0032092493,
0.0509491004,
0.0134313973,
-0.0280799903,
0.0055879988,
-0.0554039143,
-0.0130739836,
0.0518491045,
0.075812839,
-0.0195659325,
-0.0400369205,
0.0157521237,
-0.001583952,
0.033965271,
0.0533886291,
-0.0260386001,
0.0066084736,
-0.0190117676,
-0.042917911,
-0.049595993,
0.0145951593,
0.0149695799,
0.0680805072,
-0.0115855895,
0.007908212,
-0.0913333744,
-0.0262579042,
0.0433052815,
-0.025925206,
-0.0229225866,
-0.038107127,
-0.0049775518,
0.0196886398,
0.0163617767,
-0.0420863144,
0.0323582031,
0.0275767595,
-0.0220307801,
-0.0278361272,
-0.0042854436,
-0.0111886011,
-0.0230027959,
0.048953265,
0.0067105298,
-0.0215008818,
0.0268300269,
-0.0060693016,
-0.025873512,
0.0222289674,
-0.0173854772,
0.0401412398,
-0.020320151,
0.0228886995,
-0.0320925824,
-0.0152513077,
-0.0684214085,
0.0617020465,
-0.0017668438,
0.0417559184,
0.0291248634,
-0.0034631372,
-0.0032044656,
-0.0074136439,
-0.0339300409,
0.0418262333,
0.0022670121,
0.0207360759,
0.0167594552,
0.0474417731,
-0.0657693222,
-0.0441367067,
-0.1161269769,
0.0258638188,
-0.0307726301,
0.0250745397,
0.0353621244,
-0.0196073577,
0.0023641477,
0.0229771286,
-0.0037783273,
-0.0340391621,
0.0133945085,
0.0295407083,
-0.0000679541,
0.0144814514,
-0.0053933891,
-0.0302511267,
-0.0250540413,
-0.0005642329,
0.0528572984,
0.0173300467,
0.0173248444,
0.0021018318,
0.0637408122,
-0.0086333239,
-0.0151928896,
0.0136173265,
-0.0069365809,
0.027001176,
-0.0123907328,
0.0041132001,
0.0191656556,
-0.0480646901,
0.0419911258,
0.0466596223,
-0.0364192985,
-0.090820618,
0.0080344947,
0.0139757236,
-0.0551102944,
-0.0668258965,
-0.023965694,
0.0003228408,
0.0718717501,
-0.0016910776,
0.0105263861,
-0.0064990697,
-0.0038389757,
-0.0531150065,
-0.0583065748,
-0.0230913274,
0.0125467628,
-0.0004546106,
0.0430505723,
-0.0191728286,
-0.0530256703,
0.0476463214,
-0.0330132693,
-0.0310931746,
-0.0419020802,
-0.0221697111,
-0.0691561997,
0.0825229362,
-0.0128337583,
0.0124051142,
-0.0210481975,
-0.0164630841,
-0.0255002789,
-0.0162244234,
0.0078457929,
-0.0335682891,
0.0574282929,
-0.0680935755,
0.0305503178,
-0.0115623344,
0.0095805097,
-0.0302324072,
-0.0026286258,
-0.0270069856,
0.0548155792,
0.0239704866,
-0.0243538655,
-0.0227396488,
0.0062360158,
0.0528997593,
0.000455376,
-0.0061235297,
-0.0232465658,
-0.003019582,
0.0355125219,
0.0404660702,
0.006390064,
0.0437065735,
-0.0299757849,
0.0424887054,
0.0448780619,
0.0511512272,
-0.0109336236,
-0.0463006198,
0.0259320624,
0.0275332313,
-0.0345719792,
-0.0134618757,
0.0154324267,
0.0671787038,
-0.0767732784,
-0.0022710352,
0.1155219153,
0.0432762802,
-0.0147125823,
-0.0014049711,
0.0125358477,
0.0121705476,
0.035682328,
0.0221229624,
-0.0455715731,
-0.0286237746,
0.0152573455,
0.0108880363,
-0.008150259,
-0.0345688611,
-0.0096297357,
-0.1471950412,
0.0341963284,
-0.0228809714,
-0.0105980709,
0.0184168424,
-0.0362041406,
-0.004696833,
-0.0344794244,
0.021846503,
0.0156517457,
-0.0452995598,
0.0069798515,
0.0200967845,
-0.0272178687,
-0.0498367921,
0.0679138675,
-0.0213226229,
0.0412412882,
0.0465213507,
-0.0005349639,
-0.0177379809,
0.0089127952,
0.0780039281,
-0.021868661,
0.017043937,
-0.043090824,
0.015049939,
0.0057583461,
0.0011092828,
0.0155329052,
-0.0133445356,
-0.0309047848,
-0.0061225807,
0.0064214696,
0.0926867276,
-0.0078558512,
0.0146729518,
-0.0135659352,
-0.0157230552,
-0.0272246972,
0.0726361871,
0.0291577913,
-0.0185800269,
-0.0295007713,
-0.0150793083,
-0.0624356531,
-0.0415464602,
-0.0537699461,
0.009410372,
0.0045855641,
0.0136295455,
-0.0298033953,
-0.0558525436,
0.0541854352,
0.0217968393,
0.0102296872,
0.0261167865,
-0.047589168,
0.0049120779,
-0.0292022806,
0.0643099844,
-0.0327554569,
0.0546220504,
-0.0446384661,
-0.0038785927,
0.0039038418,
0.0100520924,
-0.0168160331,
0.0189105049,
-0.079011254,
-0.0733926743,
-0.0233300347,
0.0265632626,
0.0338923298,
-0.0006546549,
-0.0202739406,
-0.067963548,
-0.0022620659,
0.0026414581,
-0.0518647321,
0.001711937,
0.0231170505,
0.0213296637,
0.0050433823,
0.0383839905,
-0.0197247881,
-0.0008104021,
0.0215612464,
0.0599220097,
0.0024039927,
-0.0279633012,
0.0175693277,
0.0297391172,
0.0101458421,
0.0037838174,
-0.0003260398,
-0.0412133746,
-0.0327769853,
-0.0068018679,
-0.0140078366,
-0.0563758016,
0.0095990542,
0.0256405193,
-0.0027780116,
0.0009152378,
0.0363712646,
0.004602096,
0.0185965486,
-0.0452741534,
0.049911093,
0.0058709951,
-0.038445808,
0.0165881831,
0.0228339676,
-0.0123144314,
-0.0163791403,
-0.0150223179,
0.0297019966,
-0.0000805467,
0.045991376,
-0.0113327606,
0.0099027492,
-0.0163933728,
0.0186241679,
-0.0544111244,
-0.0893610567,
0.0126518169,
0.0333488025,
0.0532476604,
-0.0456303693,
0.0715090483,
-0.0303088296,
-0.0005681478,
-0.0394727401,
0.0082918396,
0.0028340255,
-0.0135473134,
0.0255804062,
0.0344937071,
-0.0321280956,
-0.0134674702,
0.0552946515,
0.0070458902,
0.0368984602,
-0.0075547802,
-0.0137708057,
-0.0357877985,
-0.0597338229,
0.0256996211,
-0.0280225743,
-0.0276165195,
0.0269798003,
-0.074233979,
-0.0760190561,
-0.0214150064,
0.0027454416,
-0.0210445281,
-0.0219585169,
0.0163657665,
0.0877491534,
0.0190284196,
0.0093677202,
-0.0687831789,
-0.0192269199,
0.0143278847,
-0.0230893195,
-0.0055136667,
-6.38861931e-33,
-0.0254842769,
-0.0251782667,
0.052592203,
-0.0451580063,
-0.0063135121,
0.0154591436,
-0.0318907723,
0.0272437129,
-0.0463619567,
-0.0017405963,
-0.0128043778,
-0.0055081747,
0.0071201241,
0.0048812842,
0.0297887549,
0.0220633149,
0.030293867,
0.0190895163,
-0.0148019977,
-0.0032615226,
0.0085542984,
0.0071344166,
0.0572458841,
-0.0324428119,
0.0345250927,
0.0287923999,
0.0120879868,
0.0117864013,
-0.0116611319,
0.0903586373,
-0.0243322495,
0.0278072376,
0.0404335745,
-0.0786687806,
-0.0229047649,
-0.0409735739,
-0.0591536537,
-0.0276712067,
0.0619691536,
0.0026526623,
-0.0379984751,
-0.0088577513,
0.037874613,
0.013447104,
-0.039960064,
-0.0362524725,
0.0168324932,
-0.0198067743,
-0.0164241977,
0.0038950348,
-0.0635627136,
0.0466160215,
-0.011441485,
-0.0303747207,
0.0417767763,
0.0264071114,
-0.0036415588,
0.0211417601,
-0.0291912574,
-0.0161838122,
0.0304746218,
0.0352022462,
0.0982141793,
0.0078769876,
-0.0085069742,
0.0609507002,
-0.0124809761,
-0.0211004056,
0.0067067882,
-0.0163532626,
0.0327235721,
0.0740977377,
0.0105717285,
-0.0026777731,
-0.0294383857,
0.0369855985,
-0.0331311747,
0.0258041769,
0.0315146931,
0.095376201,
0.0365994498,
0.0278572552,
-0.0207969137,
-0.0073176427,
-0.0805609375,
-0.0063937451,
-0.0369845256,
-0.0223829336,
0.0494228117,
0.0089647928,
-0.0084536383,
-0.0074396553,
0.0435471125,
-0.055575341,
-0.0210457295,
0.044541385,
-0.0172536913,
0.0487347879,
0.0065720859,
0.0556778088,
-0.0614491738,
-0.0016817966,
-0.0099489391,
-0.0163721219,
0.004801461,
-0.0307401512,
0.0034341114,
0.016461134,
-0.0698796511,
0.0001503383,
-0.073841773,
0.0280366968,
-0.0179477204,
0.0475965254,
0.0501916073,
-0.0154002178,
-0.0149366707,
0.0208326746,
-0.0062352153,
-0.0212193951,
-0.0432565808,
0.0072762845,
0.0075249579,
-0.0371442586,
-0.0238054264,
0.011235049,
-0.0340685621,
0.0008918481,
0.0208755713,
0.006635855,
-0.0074325488,
-0.0107536577,
2.744e-7,
0.0781301856,
0.0409603082,
-0.0060874987,
0.0550431833,
0.0033478751,
0.0149051314,
-0.0652330741,
-0.0081433868,
0.017993724,
-0.0145229464,
-0.0357224941,
0.0454448983,
0.0873854086,
0.0439953394,
-0.0380483456,
0.0151503198,
-0.0306552611,
-0.0021956167,
-0.0518633202,
-0.01185604,
0.0320728682,
0.0842707157,
0.0062311036,
-0.0158420205,
-0.041654326,
-0.0861309171,
0.048613213,
-0.0431591719,
-0.0320897214,
0.0203003976,
0.0227949563,
0.0484449156,
0.0443771295,
-0.0107248332,
0.0196129195,
0.0345125459,
0.009088832,
0.1000860929,
0.0137605211,
-0.0125991181,
0.0082214391,
-0.0625981912,
-0.0032069797,
-0.0819028839,
0.0820897594,
-0.0421171039,
-0.0328755863,
-0.0322753303,
0.0273965057,
0.0030746765,
0.0105269877,
-0.0176788624,
-0.004887423,
0.0442244411,
0.0113790827,
-0.0335995592,
-0.0435312241,
-0.0642556995,
-0.0431812517,
0.0398238376,
-0.039243944,
-0.0678136274,
-0.0462841354,
-0.0083690127,
-0.0324198641,
-0.0516554192,
-0.0254363753,
2.849616186e-34,
0.0446510762,
0.0044177161,
0.0356719531,
0.0407173075,
0.047562588,
0.0120711951,
-0.0048951977,
0.0249736756,
-0.039908804,
-0.0990255475,
0.0071163219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14226v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14226v1 | Deep de Finetti: Recovering Topic Distributions from Large Language Models | 2023-12-21T16:44:39 | 2023-12-21T16:44:39 | Liyi Zhang, R. Thomas McCoy, Theodore R. Sumers, Jian-Qiao Zhu, Thomas L. Griffiths | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML, I.2.6; I.2.7 | Large language models (LLMs) can produce long, coherent passages of text,
suggesting that LLMs, although trained on next-word prediction, must represent
the latent structure that characterizes a document. Prior work has found that
internal representations of LLMs encode one aspect of latent structure, namely
syntax; here we investigate a complementary aspect, namely the document's topic
structure. We motivate the hypothesis that LLMs capture topic structure by
connecting LLM optimization to implicit Bayesian inference. De Finetti's
theorem shows that exchangeable probability distributions can be represented as
a mixture with respect to a latent generating distribution. Although text is
not exchangeable at the level of syntax, exchangeability is a reasonable
starting assumption for topic structure. We thus hypothesize that predicting
the next token in text will lead LLMs to recover latent topic distributions. We
examine this hypothesis using Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA), an
exchangeable probabilistic topic model, as a target, and we show that the
representations formed by LLMs encode both the topics used to generate
synthetic data and those used to explain natural corpus data. | [
0.0163015183,
0.0634630173,
-0.0143743856,
0.0360797681,
-0.0196763612,
0.0108420718,
-0.0250556692,
-0.0284912158,
-0.0602130294,
-0.0179110579,
-0.0142137734,
-0.0475730337,
0.0014802503,
0.0726262033,
0.0287927706,
-0.0659963265,
-0.0031108735,
-0.0535847098,
0.0414103828,
-0.0025061937,
0.0352759659,
-0.0229981802,
0.0047206674,
0.0249432214,
0.0010894631,
-0.0062648701,
-0.0395522565,
-0.0266334806,
-0.0004858345,
0.0062080943,
0.0157316364,
0.0272584725,
0.0481914356,
0.002685931,
0.0000017695,
-0.0003502681,
-0.0353545956,
-0.0301251579,
-0.0021912712,
0.0171592198,
0.0449902788,
-0.0461085141,
0.0133586656,
-0.008789341,
-0.0229827575,
-0.0032661629,
0.0314579532,
0.0825514942,
-0.0007719137,
0.0820254087,
-0.0223966483,
-0.0384395048,
0.0661746338,
-0.0501318723,
0.0676230937,
-0.0220922399,
0.012048888,
-0.0053698672,
-0.0262906887,
0.0733416751,
-0.0058532516,
0.0148034589,
0.0183935799,
-0.0306318738,
0.0420352705,
0.0569522902,
0.027653439,
-0.0223424248,
-0.0041633528,
0.0523651615,
-0.0121027827,
-0.0231036562,
0.042721916,
-0.0324050225,
-0.0247219279,
0.0248400085,
-0.0580824725,
0.0532531925,
0.0013805078,
0.0623368174,
0.0931410864,
-0.0284223296,
0.0465192087,
-0.0236879364,
-0.0228600632,
0.0565903038,
0.0316032432,
-0.0002596664,
-0.0367731862,
0.0059146392,
-0.0304189473,
-0.0869930312,
0.0205584671,
0.0018540277,
0.049757801,
0.01785082,
-0.0204449184,
-0.0559263565,
-0.0021931794,
-0.0219834745,
0.000897392,
0.0041065249,
-0.037521936,
0.0167956799,
0.018655723,
0.0111557012,
-0.0557847619,
-0.0076672137,
-0.0534818992,
0.010537059,
-0.0116183674,
-0.0018893522,
-0.0174819119,
0.0324991159,
-0.0236067586,
-0.0247874297,
0.0076495656,
0.028077811,
0.0298096575,
-0.0591631681,
0.0023135163,
0.0217717998,
-0.0591058023,
-0.0117442161,
-0.0326310471,
0.0170688517,
-0.0259003416,
0.0370626859,
0.010024,
0.0104206754,
0.00334867,
0.0360334925,
0.0069145313,
-0.0171893444,
-0.039810475,
0.0335953943,
-0.0271800403,
-0.0017741369,
-0.0535981245,
-0.0046527777,
-0.0338461697,
-0.0095407832,
0.0821882263,
-0.0845696852,
0.0100552244,
0.0105918357,
-0.0285919905,
-0.0264650248,
-0.0018231568,
0.0148837101,
-0.0370977372,
0.070753485,
0.0001043199,
-0.0005953193,
0.0614760257,
0.0118855918,
0.0159186628,
0.0495136715,
0.0309569892,
0.0587035753,
0.0203482136,
0.0284942891,
-0.0083260722,
0.0068391254,
0.025206808,
0.0421985723,
-0.0195117351,
-0.0039805439,
-0.0026817396,
0.0093987277,
0.0935652852,
0.0390369482,
-0.0353832394,
-0.0393461324,
0.0300675277,
0.0244221222,
0.0283189733,
0.011317851,
0.0632931665,
-0.0007120431,
-0.0187651608,
0.0534548722,
-0.0073269755,
0.0270658787,
0.0377298072,
-0.0254174341,
0.0737865642,
-0.0331221335,
-0.0323943309,
-0.0256771371,
0.0136385262,
-0.029643679,
-0.0160573963,
-0.060351491,
0.0685278922,
-0.0107301157,
0.0029242339,
0.0654506981,
0.0437734984,
0.0145430462,
0.0071374346,
-0.009354773,
0.0520972721,
0.0506116897,
-0.0004986271,
-0.0201211963,
-0.0070115859,
-0.001688356,
0.0114068734,
0.0333933309,
-0.0087497216,
-0.0127151562,
-0.0187079459,
-0.0100339474,
-0.0089359591,
-0.0539341532,
0.0266092326,
0.0658162162,
-0.0529161319,
0.004955369,
0.0071592373,
-0.0637917668,
0.0343209952,
0.0299837869,
-0.0356068239,
-0.0001480542,
0.0255856235,
-0.0319936909,
0.0386146903,
-0.0101162447,
0.0023122763,
0.0368568003,
0.038968049,
-0.0639405549,
-0.0449268743,
-0.022962613,
-0.0628478751,
-0.0218548514,
0.0312734693,
-0.0592272207,
0.0300227311,
-0.0443137214,
-0.0138942543,
-0.0363905914,
0.0614242218,
-0.0322960094,
0.0193469115,
-0.0231307447,
-0.0171077102,
0.0313508958,
0.0203350671,
-0.0129671553,
0.061138425,
-0.0293863621,
0.0001390167,
0.0283460077,
0.0110952863,
0.0228607599,
-0.0190799981,
0.0510917939,
0.0037803557,
0.0153531926,
0.0108544203,
0.058416035,
-0.0056779436,
-0.0061713383,
-0.0482895635,
-0.0702529773,
0.0311775859,
-0.0320583247,
0.0051362612,
0.0443542637,
-0.0005061188,
0.012493887,
0.0047491635,
-0.0585337393,
0.004652143,
-0.0229690168,
-0.0011083931,
0.0389521793,
0.0016060995,
0.013768971,
-0.0453250632,
-0.0270451084,
-0.0535179935,
0.0562447682,
-0.0222700667,
-0.0030504179,
-0.0707619563,
0.0377750657,
0.0102059441,
0.0064223995,
-0.036173854,
-0.0173095465,
0.0042185797,
-0.0647595003,
0.1198180616,
0.0454761311,
0.0276383627,
0.0491461419,
0.0471490733,
-0.0257073902,
-0.0321431234,
-0.0380979627,
-0.0313807167,
0.0299757961,
-0.0382209755,
-0.0417721197,
-0.0154631939,
0.0695225671,
0.0143632879,
0.0084586069,
-0.0332816243,
0.0329870321,
0.000247921,
0.0018195823,
-0.001770228,
0.0064254762,
-0.0087768193,
0.0269067027,
-0.0215366557,
-0.0748334676,
0.0279233903,
-0.0224054344,
0.0450828224,
-0.0471332744,
-0.0115902415,
-0.0324750207,
0.0466528684,
0.0346762054,
-0.0281521901,
0.0040004975,
-0.0117204469,
-0.0420183428,
0.0265342202,
0.002844705,
0.0148840891,
0.0459355637,
-0.031210782,
0.0165565144,
-0.0060909633,
-0.0010138279,
-0.0313687958,
-0.0744341239,
-0.0018881236,
0.0405209325,
0.0157913826,
-0.0215451624,
-0.0372550786,
-0.0264755562,
0.0231204387,
0.0424946286,
-0.0340466425,
-0.0021930421,
-0.0170553252,
0.0711764395,
0.0619220585,
-0.043838501,
-0.0166250076,
-0.0427867472,
-0.0048123011,
0.0258400701,
0.0383415446,
0.0390377864,
-0.0544006079,
0.0079599516,
0.0050197509,
-0.000844908,
-0.068356365,
-0.004577422,
0.0145700471,
-0.0204519592,
-0.0004669364,
0.0884130523,
0.0077213245,
-0.1006695032,
-0.006264606,
-0.0223560631,
0.0082680322,
-0.0176351089,
0.0140781244,
-0.0906421989,
-0.010497517,
-0.0020988516,
-0.0125024533,
0.0173588842,
-0.0372137241,
0.0011529359,
-0.0557517372,
0.0103695355,
0.0000627197,
-0.0093005775,
-0.0245001297,
-0.0717407092,
-0.0108210566,
0.0077080242,
-0.0081618186,
-0.0015357378,
0.0014411566,
0.0270686429,
0.0326601118,
-0.006116325,
-0.0358511172,
-0.0098831598,
-0.0316767991,
0.0360460132,
0.0525645092,
0.0265658647,
-0.0010667967,
0.0157905594,
-0.0319532491,
-0.0418426618,
-0.0399498232,
0.0237101726,
0.0521240234,
-0.0094813509,
0.0079047168,
0.0218556114,
0.05082082,
-0.0673267618,
-0.0300855674,
0.0178148076,
0.0813536495,
-0.0438164957,
-0.0337075852,
-0.049197372,
-0.0150128426,
0.0252337027,
0.0629433692,
0.0301506333,
-0.0384842306,
0.000887788,
-0.0421465151,
0.042420812,
0.0412247367,
0.0225561652,
-0.0005852493,
0.0121620605,
-0.0593011007,
-0.0702060387,
-0.0230312888,
-0.0018075209,
0.0104546696,
-0.0089213429,
0.017213909,
-0.0007552842,
-0.0533769205,
-0.0393427238,
0.0238838922,
-0.0295193773,
-0.0400922857,
-0.0398841873,
-0.0461861864,
0.0370926261,
-0.0430468023,
-0.0089932811,
-0.0202650987,
-0.0958457813,
-0.0673744977,
0.0027915335,
0.0105717592,
0.013292836,
0.0376394056,
-0.0058777411,
-0.0788410977,
0.0124231996,
0.0247045029,
-0.0530478954,
0.034398552,
-0.0047746166,
0.0163326412,
0.022934448,
0.03283602,
-0.0577648729,
0.0273511615,
-0.0184779093,
0.0108040161,
-0.0089679994,
-0.0568455979,
-0.0074740024,
-0.0148564093,
0.0602381192,
-0.0004725063,
-0.0143670198,
-0.0659253746,
-0.0214052834,
-0.0357914865,
0.0122797899,
-0.0447089486,
0.0318618082,
0.0489462093,
0.0193390697,
-0.0287772343,
0.0140965031,
-0.0303754229,
0.0487690493,
-0.005924108,
-0.0070063034,
0.037445955,
0.0137869241,
0.0203035679,
0.0086177364,
0.0306691956,
0.007059542,
-0.020559961,
0.0493975542,
-0.0370982848,
0.0242421608,
0.0377804339,
-0.0031211115,
0.0001400146,
-0.018530963,
-0.1041426659,
-0.054938592,
-0.0071650189,
0.0427976064,
0.0368369967,
-0.0135763297,
0.0455751568,
-0.058573585,
-0.0044344799,
-0.0382932052,
0.0301949363,
0.0088474629,
0.0006795722,
0.0170549564,
0.0262058135,
-0.0489038527,
0.021013407,
0.0975205749,
0.0457673185,
0.003248224,
0.0161079261,
0.0147433793,
-0.0162254497,
0.0421893075,
0.0264503863,
0.0359535813,
0.0050590821,
-0.0037191184,
0.0025301313,
-0.025505282,
0.0371063277,
-0.0140467156,
-0.0355121791,
-0.0142553886,
0.0355655476,
0.1068375856,
-0.0407260582,
0.0134762628,
-0.0672264248,
0.0439547561,
0.0037895539,
-0.0355497599,
-0.035251461,
-6.295127101e-33,
-0.0017244589,
-0.0429386385,
-0.0026373547,
0.0206399877,
-0.022926528,
0.0217425022,
-0.0517430678,
-0.0057607512,
0.0342441201,
0.0377452113,
-0.0083879177,
0.0446595587,
0.0046525989,
0.0288284123,
0.0132621992,
-0.0352378413,
0.033397764,
-0.052222956,
-0.0150223719,
0.0538322181,
0.0432727076,
0.0302879158,
0.0421688072,
-0.0244152956,
0.0127687231,
-0.0266165957,
0.0329788476,
0.027974721,
0.0593765415,
0.0487647504,
-0.027803028,
0.0210598689,
0.0329424664,
-0.0177386142,
-0.0234000795,
0.0427083373,
-0.0349947847,
-0.0586594455,
-0.0102953874,
-0.0318486132,
-0.0232966561,
-0.0872289985,
0.0276677795,
0.0132456608,
0.0409428515,
-0.0362805873,
0.0588330589,
0.0063175946,
-0.0143015422,
-0.0389432088,
-0.0275052898,
0.0357643589,
-0.0044119623,
-0.0003554068,
0.0239222012,
-0.0449728556,
0.0312512591,
0.0263116024,
0.0089224102,
0.0233877916,
-0.0054600704,
0.0598254502,
0.0028718461,
-0.0006149522,
0.0167710278,
0.0724501982,
0.0344737396,
0.009151007,
-0.0359766223,
-0.0101091536,
0.0581798144,
0.0244182311,
-0.0136409122,
0.0035181674,
0.0278173499,
0.0469450541,
-0.0583523996,
0.0209044106,
0.0100835524,
-0.0149531029,
0.0236772075,
0.0376104452,
0.0129395891,
-0.0347382501,
-0.0540535338,
-0.0265144669,
0.0020620802,
-0.0191334095,
0.0082210228,
0.0085444218,
0.005078536,
-0.0415871106,
0.0618254319,
-0.0234798528,
-0.0122312661,
0.0472460501,
-0.0291846711,
0.0143386908,
0.0052325004,
0.0395222604,
-0.1035421714,
-0.0377554148,
0.0097643398,
0.0002655029,
-0.0141950371,
0.0387899093,
-0.0010651998,
0.0044515515,
-0.0230452865,
-0.0308043212,
-0.0392230451,
-0.0279993471,
-0.0205571447,
0.050586652,
0.0293059163,
0.0222544782,
0.0023022969,
0.0637588724,
0.0397122316,
0.0379169174,
-0.016483793,
-0.0286665428,
0.0023327707,
0.0344802924,
-0.0548657924,
-0.0065687047,
-0.0429238416,
0.0038738244,
0.0761023834,
-0.070569545,
-0.0098731313,
0.002800222,
2.518e-7,
0.0653806627,
0.0207905043,
0.0349774249,
-0.022520097,
0.0578017905,
0.0446132608,
0.0007342581,
0.0343121886,
0.0038373189,
-0.0588376559,
0.011114331,
0.0386557952,
0.0043760575,
0.0391364172,
-0.096149601,
0.0379987136,
-0.0504839793,
-0.0042682788,
-0.0039046139,
-0.0289039277,
-0.0144988662,
0.1087943092,
0.0183688942,
-0.00878332,
0.0250002593,
-0.0254941359,
0.085099332,
-0.010958463,
-0.0522270612,
0.026778657,
0.0380086862,
0.0073687783,
-0.02018518,
-0.0189969055,
-0.0061656102,
0.0084781135,
0.0081391912,
0.0623521321,
0.007860723,
-0.0063271183,
0.0172032155,
-0.0553420708,
-0.0115943896,
-0.0161353294,
0.0215741284,
-0.0739734396,
-0.0435263105,
-0.058348164,
-0.0267739818,
-0.008586782,
-0.0083372993,
0.0077156913,
-0.014822945,
0.0242709294,
-0.0127541265,
-0.012575808,
0.0107412022,
-0.0446536206,
-0.0146691035,
0.0168546122,
-0.0695263594,
-0.0201893095,
-0.0663608015,
-0.0170186833,
0.0503536053,
-0.0581461713,
0.0203986727,
2.43779873e-34,
0.0464764498,
-0.0201181863,
-0.0459065102,
-0.0000854124,
0.0180499796,
-0.0341273844,
-0.0231674742,
0.0361076333,
0.0196332,
-0.0826327801,
-0.0299916156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13961v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13961v1 | ChatGPT as a commenter to the news: can LLMs generate human-like opinions? | 2023-12-21T15:46:36 | 2023-12-21T15:46:36 | Rayden Tseng, Suzan Verberne, Peter van der Putten | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | ChatGPT, GPT-3.5, and other large language models (LLMs) have drawn
significant attention since their release, and the abilities of these models
have been investigated for a wide variety of tasks. In this research we
investigate to what extent GPT-3.5 can generate human-like comments on Dutch
news articles. We define human likeness as `not distinguishable from human
comments', approximated by the difficulty of automatic classification between
human and GPT comments. We analyze human likeness across multiple prompting
techniques. In particular, we utilize zero-shot, few-shot and context prompts,
for two generated personas. We found that our fine-tuned BERT models can easily
distinguish human-written comments from GPT-3.5 generated comments, with none
of the used prompting methods performing noticeably better. We further analyzed
that human comments consistently showed higher lexical diversity than
GPT-generated comments. This indicates that although generative LLMs can
generate fluent text, their capability to create human-like opinionated
comments is still limited. | [
0.0850536153,
0.0458810404,
0.0017077669,
0.0355562307,
-0.0220126398,
0.0289445519,
0.0117412033,
0.0106979888,
0.0106816115,
-0.0447903536,
-0.0325014032,
-0.0581259578,
-0.0226816181,
-0.0198192932,
0.0548040457,
-0.0913816467,
0.0272896178,
0.0103094764,
0.0237382222,
-0.0232554469,
0.0418628231,
0.0384304263,
0.0082408851,
0.0498465449,
-0.0395388864,
-0.0180843323,
0.0019274182,
0.0273749866,
0.0441408344,
0.0208901633,
0.0134240622,
0.0822800025,
0.0201562438,
0.047265172,
0.0000016589,
-0.0178064182,
0.0494278297,
-0.0212619863,
0.0596877784,
0.0028942281,
0.0519586802,
-0.0047738585,
-0.0236299783,
0.0096270721,
-0.0382531211,
-0.0330775455,
0.0265823305,
0.053653907,
0.0794451609,
0.0894254968,
-0.024239175,
-0.0458147228,
0.0049920306,
-0.0268802047,
0.0431511402,
-0.0081511391,
0.0032083103,
-0.0051759304,
-0.0053361505,
0.0053981282,
0.0324210189,
-0.0094587309,
-0.0170921497,
-0.0127040558,
0.0103844479,
0.0336910561,
-0.0040627974,
-0.0101993764,
0.0145277614,
0.048192624,
0.0180928428,
-0.0332901515,
-0.0026042534,
0.02846976,
0.024986526,
0.0289594848,
-0.0125995586,
0.0229044966,
-0.0127188703,
0.0262952559,
-0.0108879386,
0.009226623,
0.0013982756,
0.0321437716,
0.0248160381,
-0.0354348272,
0.0336180143,
-0.0371844284,
-0.0238661375,
0.0356761515,
-0.0319035836,
-0.0717221126,
-0.0220663305,
0.016497029,
0.0011952417,
-0.0041500442,
-0.068659097,
-0.0114115374,
0.0335062705,
-0.0434845425,
0.0159000773,
0.0311773978,
-0.0402711667,
0.0275727045,
-0.0287604034,
0.0417893641,
-0.0273377262,
-0.0058804723,
-0.019945452,
-0.0041913223,
-0.0656737387,
-0.0128660817,
-0.048418656,
0.0240483768,
-0.0105391387,
-0.029880248,
-0.0320308618,
0.0296149068,
-0.0236195512,
-0.0130982334,
0.0131611163,
0.0171949584,
-0.0062047485,
-0.0041548726,
-0.0530628897,
-0.0239430293,
-0.0560647957,
0.0002742521,
-0.0193932373,
-0.0340309888,
0.0196484551,
0.0349012092,
0.0005972759,
-0.0245252717,
0.0009059613,
0.0526792705,
-0.0092908451,
-0.0187442806,
-0.0065557817,
-0.0125384042,
-0.0051863967,
-0.0757231563,
-0.0028717518,
-0.0759111717,
0.0131712146,
-0.0299886167,
-0.00495813,
0.0083628828,
0.0139557645,
0.0246114153,
-0.0199527573,
0.0654178932,
-0.0021516364,
0.0278247707,
0.0157559998,
0.0008986713,
0.0080244746,
0.0331294313,
-0.0122029567,
-0.0020388467,
0.0002140896,
0.0016073741,
0.00369322,
0.0383735262,
-0.0176526774,
0.0055113132,
-0.006387128,
-0.0239988584,
-0.0086820582,
0.0392503142,
0.0513997376,
0.0856862366,
-0.0384996608,
-0.0396179408,
0.0749749243,
0.0761641711,
-0.0501475856,
0.0707125515,
0.0617700256,
0.0477917492,
0.027524624,
0.0425894372,
-0.048709482,
0.0186125785,
-0.0085127233,
-0.0031902413,
0.0134795969,
0.0160207376,
-0.0527432337,
0.0215264056,
0.010925984,
-0.0205615871,
0.0338444784,
-0.0579085536,
-0.0147458706,
0.0065732156,
-0.0352125056,
0.0260462705,
0.0232478902,
-0.0482576638,
-0.0165702198,
-0.0639828146,
0.0267242901,
0.0995157883,
0.0265062191,
0.0122227324,
-0.0074926778,
-0.0289893709,
0.0067602927,
0.0968866572,
0.0743876621,
-0.0112755811,
-0.0222879257,
-0.0178366993,
0.0188990273,
-0.0061374856,
0.0128599722,
0.0639726743,
0.0377560183,
0.0200140644,
0.0182873067,
0.0061212573,
0.023490699,
0.024440363,
-0.0255317725,
0.0075192098,
-0.0125396447,
-0.004907968,
0.0122383116,
0.0465142913,
-0.0401411802,
0.0056285909,
-0.0142935235,
-0.0193837006,
-0.0391918682,
0.0428144075,
-0.0340840966,
-0.0434546918,
0.0115556978,
-0.0768004507,
-0.0239293687,
0.0270582847,
-0.0085531715,
-0.0317966864,
0.0024694342,
-0.0441237763,
0.0664955229,
-0.0841404274,
0.0126096075,
-0.0161193777,
0.0019276185,
-0.0144489119,
0.0775377452,
0.0149966758,
0.0045368453,
0.0215732455,
0.0221588854,
-0.0076613314,
-0.0565053672,
-0.0236808024,
-0.0474124178,
0.0319047645,
0.0232914705,
0.0181022994,
0.0330608301,
-0.0216118582,
-0.0570983142,
-0.1381560713,
-0.0157460477,
0.010552356,
0.0050314008,
0.0333636887,
-0.0091179302,
-0.0249945354,
-0.0051616551,
-0.090875797,
-0.0168166123,
0.0106626647,
0.0149230007,
0.0463988446,
-0.035435576,
0.0143930186,
-0.0300788898,
0.0142797902,
-0.017705122,
0.0251769368,
0.0177424625,
-0.0319771394,
-0.046561446,
0.0165004171,
-0.046207197,
0.0239471011,
0.0179225877,
-0.0360290855,
0.0456627831,
-0.0059442148,
0.0597323216,
0.0358018652,
0.0797271505,
0.0305272434,
-0.0312814303,
0.0326478593,
-0.031557072,
-0.0056412164,
-0.0350977294,
0.0153445872,
0.011010306,
-0.038483128,
0.0335430317,
0.0140492804,
0.006069249,
0.0047357464,
-0.0981100127,
0.069668889,
0.0396452583,
-0.0264533777,
0.0387760699,
-0.0086365109,
-0.0219765417,
-0.0086921332,
-0.0322498567,
-0.020028647,
0.0709152445,
-0.0369476527,
0.021025598,
0.0179766156,
0.0102786776,
-0.0242385603,
0.0370700136,
0.0290295016,
0.0360699296,
-0.0246480182,
-0.0063160751,
-0.013176729,
0.0130763007,
0.0233540554,
-0.0114706662,
0.0308546387,
-0.0015780074,
0.0221092738,
0.0206285808,
-0.0653037727,
-0.0251994897,
-0.0737205222,
-0.028863823,
-0.0012583588,
0.0290937535,
-0.047542382,
0.008341141,
0.0100856172,
-0.0056113708,
0.0109736938,
-0.0336336829,
0.0080205537,
-0.0311859138,
0.0544291474,
0.0335892104,
-0.0030641945,
-0.0059618601,
-0.0348328836,
0.0025573366,
0.0261377543,
0.0120177111,
0.0194674805,
-0.0307109952,
-0.0097475955,
-0.0069266637,
-0.0079736542,
-0.0341725275,
-0.0412154794,
0.067197755,
-0.0083024511,
0.0154250888,
0.1386790723,
0.0050167758,
-0.0486658849,
0.001762245,
-0.0012308046,
0.0316312537,
-0.0039594811,
0.0196120124,
-0.0905524418,
-0.0233334918,
-0.0152191957,
0.0023543839,
-0.0441264324,
-0.0259459354,
-0.008604899,
-0.1286091954,
0.0340937674,
-0.0076652942,
-0.0316942595,
-0.004259076,
-0.0043791435,
0.000799779,
0.0142541146,
-0.0175925363,
-0.0149618611,
-0.012061215,
0.006264701,
0.0040067793,
-0.0039279996,
-0.0342254154,
0.0204235483,
-0.0299722943,
0.0704501569,
0.0536349565,
0.0673878863,
0.0114379385,
-0.0494087562,
0.0146340514,
-0.0015203601,
0.0159013532,
-0.0001051983,
0.04786117,
-0.0309660323,
-0.0181155838,
-0.080377467,
0.0377037786,
0.0226203706,
0.0153369438,
-0.0252032112,
0.0136027578,
-0.028587278,
-0.0418298431,
-0.036010813,
0.0299019609,
0.0154650332,
0.0844826847,
0.0502455719,
-0.0697664544,
-0.0387293026,
-0.0049465862,
0.0445921905,
-0.0643496513,
-0.0451967828,
-0.0107328314,
-0.0302201882,
-0.044664491,
-0.0894887745,
-0.0541868284,
-0.0342533886,
0.0259516556,
0.0015127572,
-0.0398700535,
-0.0007356987,
0.0119068976,
-0.0046835397,
0.0307693593,
-0.0237151626,
0.0068474724,
-0.0442680791,
-0.0517940782,
0.0661325231,
-0.0420120694,
-0.019453831,
-0.0316941887,
-0.0745238736,
-0.0669491589,
-0.0159881171,
0.048081398,
0.0283221249,
0.070713222,
-0.003136215,
-0.0339044854,
0.0218023974,
0.044308614,
0.0324958265,
0.0200616103,
-0.017903829,
0.0405127332,
-0.0209358893,
0.034032058,
0.0054556341,
0.0591925085,
0.0006881027,
-0.0147645157,
-0.0265354402,
-0.0691233724,
-0.0002228733,
0.0168540105,
0.0186555199,
-0.0058673825,
0.0308067631,
-0.0395400487,
-0.050963901,
-0.0216588527,
0.0228517782,
-0.0501653142,
-0.0500272289,
0.0173129812,
0.0076469067,
-0.0240076743,
-0.0309614055,
-0.0726630017,
0.0582279712,
-0.0516897701,
-0.0146784605,
0.0161318276,
0.0483012646,
-0.005940537,
-0.0267450176,
-0.0336959362,
0.0641732886,
-0.025189979,
0.0047119432,
-0.0153782517,
0.0439624526,
0.0069659599,
-0.0065069995,
0.0310893599,
0.0348753482,
-0.0567949377,
-0.0264565442,
-0.0533024669,
0.0567089766,
0.0423992313,
-0.0067042466,
0.0739729106,
-0.0257618856,
-0.0028316362,
0.0088246446,
0.0321248844,
0.0036769174,
-0.0354820043,
0.0116101913,
0.0100632729,
-0.0136629716,
-0.0178011861,
0.0749194697,
-0.0075840694,
0.029681135,
0.0123057356,
-0.0488165431,
-0.0353872627,
-0.0145514542,
0.0293739326,
-0.0266937725,
0.0102655021,
0.0161522515,
-0.0481774732,
-0.043926809,
-0.0011655345,
0.0271027368,
0.0041884421,
0.004465438,
0.037295837,
0.035434667,
-0.0077790064,
0.0042646201,
-0.044831071,
0.0251399353,
-0.0419942178,
-0.049042955,
-0.0059838942,
-6.04044523e-33,
-0.0260813106,
0.0048508677,
-0.0172440838,
0.0167284179,
-0.0621672869,
-0.0366380848,
-0.0385405123,
0.0229925551,
-0.001009268,
0.0302345995,
-0.0021233836,
-0.0096575245,
0.0101035284,
0.0071660792,
-0.0150318444,
-0.0016131921,
0.0399435237,
-0.0155156394,
-0.0080474596,
0.0484467708,
0.0304123573,
-0.0092975842,
0.0188805722,
-0.0620093457,
0.0230158847,
-0.0590115786,
-0.0144900875,
0.0170205366,
0.0440351218,
0.037573453,
-0.0305247586,
0.0359960832,
0.039009165,
0.0152236996,
-0.0200530868,
0.0791566819,
-0.0369090848,
-0.0230083857,
0.017002387,
-0.0304128304,
0.0029753214,
-0.0471466668,
0.0313441828,
-0.0396701917,
-0.0420244299,
0.0326859243,
0.059295319,
-0.0064078262,
0.0458123833,
-0.0403983891,
-0.0813669711,
0.0054048174,
-0.0090242112,
-0.0301795416,
-0.0161305368,
0.0625088662,
-0.0119102597,
-0.0043119551,
-0.0381902307,
0.0514395349,
-0.0259361938,
-0.0181228984,
0.0173043609,
-0.0111165764,
0.0248972271,
0.0782491565,
0.048814062,
0.0295447391,
-0.064723894,
0.000699138,
0.0291222781,
0.0292741079,
0.027670227,
0.0875727534,
0.0116104139,
-0.0295144208,
-0.0221422091,
0.0477743894,
0.0713292286,
-0.0178563036,
0.0379354656,
-0.0270029251,
-0.0151919099,
0.0059771081,
0.019332869,
-0.0746531636,
-0.0164218694,
-0.0439682752,
-0.0016516767,
-0.0150367562,
-0.0156243304,
-0.024241861,
0.0222163014,
-0.0134594282,
0.0095451996,
-0.0106518175,
-0.0562523194,
0.0082110306,
-0.019016102,
0.023198111,
-0.0388627276,
-0.0621112622,
0.0435477905,
0.0273949523,
0.0168576632,
0.0472064726,
0.0393739119,
-0.0156548545,
-0.0715311989,
0.0013306114,
-0.0206621196,
0.0501399972,
-0.0339214541,
0.0337001868,
0.0235050749,
-0.0033645949,
-0.0049017128,
-0.0148538472,
0.0081731789,
-0.0016694367,
-0.0348451324,
0.0113482252,
-0.0168882664,
0.0078204591,
-0.0187728349,
0.0282460898,
-0.0351106785,
0.0100520542,
0.0052780719,
-0.0609163865,
-0.0147050284,
0.006149421,
2.42e-7,
-0.0111400932,
0.0224779751,
0.0294738915,
-0.0214413255,
0.0623743907,
0.0537477173,
0.001946874,
0.0715483725,
0.0214367751,
-0.026821604,
0.0152228642,
0.0290586557,
0.0527439304,
0.0318910778,
-0.1176183075,
0.0112322159,
-0.0793039352,
0.0027924876,
-0.0381938219,
0.0115568079,
0.0752173215,
0.0433063991,
0.0063453633,
-0.0375026502,
0.0045192922,
-0.0355644263,
0.0772035271,
-0.0084112184,
-0.0510153659,
-0.0128548359,
0.0453912579,
0.0049625137,
0.0036797076,
0.0511567108,
0.0177322943,
-0.0034946017,
0.0401210226,
0.0420811139,
-0.0145532796,
-0.0074655791,
0.0225345604,
0.0162620693,
-0.005883785,
-0.0250637121,
0.0500042178,
-0.0159592833,
-0.0116499327,
-0.0479443781,
-0.0168804768,
-0.0075190687,
0.0087372493,
-0.032350976,
-0.0686276704,
0.0407295227,
0.0371054076,
-0.0289014988,
0.003770771,
-0.0463379025,
-0.0026785778,
-0.031804163,
-0.0872272477,
-0.0407584682,
-0.017362617,
0.0198866539,
0.0235964321,
-0.0206032228,
0.037081968,
1.719711731e-34,
0.0195987336,
0.033259932,
0.0206208546,
-0.0233422481,
0.0291272625,
0.0485691279,
0.0099089006,
-0.0019314421,
0.0188908018,
-0.0472217202,
-0.0203420296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13951v1 | Typhoon: Thai Large Language Models | 2023-12-21T15:38:41 | 2023-12-21T15:38:41 | Kunat Pipatanakul, Phatrasek Jirabovonvisut, Potsawee Manakul, Sittipong Sripaisarnmongkol, Ruangsak Patomwong, Pathomporn Chokchainant, Kasima Tharnpipitchai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Typhoon is a series of Thai large language models (LLMs) developed
specifically for the Thai language. This technical report presents challenges
and insights in developing Thai LLMs, including data preparation, pretraining,
instruction-tuning, and evaluation. As one of the challenges of low-resource
languages is the amount of pretraining data, we apply continual training to
transfer existing world knowledge from a strong LLM. To evaluate the Thai
knowledge encapsulated in each model from the pretraining stage, we develop
ThaiExam, a benchmark based on examinations for high-school students and
investment professionals in Thailand. In addition, we fine-tune Typhoon to
follow Thai instructions, and we evaluate instruction-tuned models on Thai
instruction datasets as well as translation, summarization, and
question-answering tasks. Experimental results on a suite of Thai benchmarks
show that Typhoon outperforms all open-source Thai language models, and its
performance is on par with GPT-3.5 in Thai while having only 7 billion
parameters and being 2.62 times more efficient in tokenizing Thai text. | [
0.0532207601,
0.0096328212,
0.010443992,
0.0216280688,
-0.0072030332,
0.0310509056,
-0.0199251268,
-0.0172597896,
-0.0216653906,
-0.0436127633,
-0.0428410172,
-0.0515542924,
0.0084034372,
0.0140900137,
0.0100327181,
-0.1223321483,
0.0217839014,
-0.0469130762,
-0.0169171002,
-0.0100837462,
0.0237129144,
-0.0039776601,
0.0157412924,
0.0545030311,
0.0273874532,
-0.0194413476,
-0.0058852066,
0.0304707959,
0.0043567927,
-0.0195389558,
0.014902832,
0.0313772075,
0.0036541526,
0.020057261,
0.0000019955,
-0.0345475562,
0.0185885653,
-0.0399693213,
-0.0132116694,
0.0712655336,
0.0631967783,
-0.0521280468,
0.0195550248,
0.058568567,
-0.0297184289,
-0.0277156848,
0.0366382971,
0.0401386619,
0.0888400897,
0.0672973692,
-0.0000314711,
-0.045328252,
0.0274797752,
-0.0331493616,
-0.042428378,
-0.0177137777,
0.0268864054,
-0.0049652481,
0.0041619181,
-0.0039392565,
0.0015528592,
0.0472119227,
0.0329442173,
0.0231275186,
0.0426826812,
0.0157542937,
-0.0328349285,
-0.0135830557,
-0.0190825462,
0.0534730107,
-0.0034863548,
-0.0100797648,
-0.0294700712,
0.0120620066,
0.0003487887,
-0.0341270305,
-0.0474037156,
0.0369497314,
0.0239260606,
0.0273920391,
0.02184093,
-0.0132482611,
0.0028150026,
0.0238328278,
-0.0297628585,
0.0077439975,
0.0030337851,
-0.0301337261,
-0.0537890941,
-0.0187078938,
0.008991817,
-0.0439162552,
0.0152232526,
0.0503309406,
0.003283696,
0.0152731491,
-0.0324391052,
0.0030604682,
0.0450507849,
-0.0667554215,
-0.0288581233,
0.0467349254,
-0.0495861322,
0.027417399,
-0.0145998904,
0.0770615414,
-0.0044965441,
0.0673138052,
-0.0864973366,
-0.0365382396,
-0.0407037549,
-0.0137985544,
-0.0591462217,
0.0406564735,
-0.0458738394,
-0.0325269103,
-0.0663799793,
0.010616404,
0.0412342176,
-0.0270663723,
0.0369886644,
-0.0161577482,
-0.0590310805,
0.0105226384,
0.0058856872,
0.0364799388,
-0.0231799074,
-0.0080070458,
0.0188979656,
-0.0355197154,
0.0235210583,
0.0093271155,
0.0062219603,
-0.0205103252,
0.0143398866,
0.04307089,
-0.0434075333,
0.0002139706,
-0.046676822,
0.0181786455,
0.0080604432,
-0.0418628417,
-0.0444596261,
-0.0693497509,
0.0295962337,
0.0219287258,
0.0234343335,
-0.0198227167,
0.0143709527,
0.0152566154,
-0.0211404357,
0.0647127554,
-0.0184008293,
0.0253681876,
0.0265052989,
0.0150686093,
0.0188081767,
0.0602207445,
0.0219112281,
0.0216321647,
0.0389042459,
-0.0139038377,
-0.0339560099,
0.0584019087,
-0.0118904645,
0.0255831201,
0.0058136089,
0.0324417539,
0.0180341471,
0.0265504532,
-0.0036405495,
0.0671004429,
-0.0068892324,
0.0588285401,
0.0692914054,
0.0181798004,
0.0038829555,
0.0289060809,
0.0444504619,
0.0235405732,
0.0273541119,
0.0173262339,
-0.0397046395,
-0.0307919979,
-0.0487015396,
0.0665967315,
0.0181344599,
0.0231985636,
-0.0398330763,
-0.0558638796,
-0.0118806493,
-0.034786772,
-0.0270314552,
0.0136093162,
0.0441459641,
0.0045827171,
-0.0337065943,
0.0744035468,
0.0427016504,
-0.0246819835,
0.0207537785,
-0.0344601274,
-0.0041853138,
0.103662841,
0.0091775423,
-0.0183247011,
-0.0220049825,
-0.0062765121,
0.0375281014,
0.0520859137,
0.0403458588,
-0.0170296226,
-0.0189185459,
-0.0605795383,
0.0433315262,
0.0429985411,
0.0148744918,
0.0247074589,
0.028222736,
0.0336361751,
0.0170730911,
-0.000226192,
-0.0896830335,
0.0384255834,
-0.0009513432,
-0.0302289072,
-0.0109758871,
0.0059064026,
0.0348739959,
0.0370657891,
0.0113904942,
-0.010500202,
0.0338595472,
-0.0694260895,
-0.0107660042,
0.0086931689,
-0.0499609113,
-0.0334072001,
0.0496224947,
-0.0037014983,
-0.0032598316,
0.0293887015,
-0.0273463465,
-0.041416999,
-0.0144898146,
0.01529021,
-0.0062806909,
-0.0734768063,
0.0425343253,
-0.022916263,
0.0329914317,
-0.0227776077,
0.0569757037,
0.0074317739,
-0.0180698484,
0.0353379212,
0.0103402063,
-0.0020945354,
-0.0340753645,
-0.023340676,
0.0409008451,
-0.0020143038,
0.0434180498,
-0.00261051,
0.0497796349,
-0.0368508585,
-0.0428565368,
-0.0943395048,
0.0403401107,
-0.0381982028,
0.0215553045,
0.0112449965,
0.0145620853,
-0.0338702574,
-0.017490644,
-0.0234776307,
-0.0490787067,
0.0316790268,
0.0153648183,
0.0042881947,
0.0248629004,
0.0264630355,
-0.0456280895,
-0.0098412232,
0.0395476967,
0.0268970933,
0.011219155,
-0.0658384785,
-0.0428666547,
0.0255251862,
-0.0258850101,
-0.0392022207,
0.0158294663,
-0.0657610223,
-0.0190165397,
-0.0252619777,
0.0585292839,
0.0087766694,
0.0182178821,
-0.000004841,
-0.0259590819,
0.0021318817,
-0.0486363694,
0.0008043608,
-0.010291148,
-0.0437415242,
-0.0711123496,
-0.0205638967,
-0.0338627845,
0.0479478911,
-0.0047515859,
0.0029331183,
-0.0557500795,
-0.0118818758,
-0.0553507321,
-0.0039604963,
-0.0722785741,
0.0044412664,
-0.0321802571,
0.0014504606,
-0.0082405293,
-0.0437008701,
0.0576501116,
-0.0120829167,
-0.0049258908,
-0.0742455274,
-0.0257855058,
-0.0712043792,
0.0492053404,
-0.0169154331,
0.0095682377,
-0.0316260904,
-0.0325804874,
-0.0060069826,
-0.0162581392,
-0.0130016394,
-0.036990758,
0.0773159787,
-0.0377101488,
-0.0008221962,
-0.0190423746,
-0.0185942631,
-0.0325880274,
-0.0274686702,
-0.0555195324,
0.0276163463,
0.0408475064,
-0.001438499,
-0.0317072906,
0.044338543,
0.0131548131,
-0.0159454569,
-0.0182869583,
0.0117258327,
-0.0229464713,
0.0343545601,
0.0451080538,
-0.0170346722,
0.0178756919,
-0.0593806021,
0.0651237071,
0.0135049,
0.0887743309,
-0.035762269,
-0.0168798454,
-0.0169652589,
0.0268345997,
-0.0724382028,
0.004624512,
0.0024053163,
0.0144969812,
-0.0399607979,
0.0333072171,
0.1262225807,
0.0382048674,
-0.0513171703,
-0.007397132,
-0.027713649,
0.0317761339,
0.0112444349,
0.0415772647,
-0.058260411,
-0.0319042541,
0.0030958925,
0.0038775655,
0.017416643,
0.0101736402,
-0.0218399968,
-0.104789339,
0.0179026518,
0.0029716603,
-0.0315565765,
-0.0317569934,
0.0088723833,
-0.0215421692,
-0.0141460616,
0.0550899133,
0.019574184,
-0.040655192,
-0.0093608489,
0.0460505784,
-0.0494143516,
-0.0524276197,
0.0331934206,
-0.0665964931,
0.0222844891,
0.0112293996,
0.0114401979,
-0.0255887359,
0.024830509,
0.0135415019,
-0.0364517234,
0.0015425058,
0.0000678517,
0.0398913175,
-0.0053749825,
-0.0155788325,
0.003154408,
0.0229143146,
-0.0513998196,
0.0214687996,
0.0714205429,
0.0533634201,
0.0111451605,
-0.0095520401,
0.0289641824,
-0.0228489246,
0.00129105,
0.0565478951,
0.0239447784,
-0.0589932017,
-0.0121657029,
-0.0358810537,
-0.0363729857,
-0.0559409559,
-0.0283699855,
0.0030750856,
-0.0341209546,
-0.0104387412,
-0.0827751905,
-0.0593433008,
0.0621459559,
0.0211305209,
0.0281303208,
0.0301789846,
0.0018739827,
0.0027013137,
-0.0029353073,
0.0301560964,
-0.0498062931,
0.0188447125,
-0.0757581666,
-0.0358653553,
0.0363305248,
-0.0400262401,
-0.0097307814,
0.0331538245,
-0.0490794219,
-0.0506449714,
0.0239700042,
0.0252675321,
0.0229955129,
0.0391679928,
-0.0068771397,
-0.0412133038,
0.0011973917,
0.0105371652,
-0.0320036486,
0.0087968828,
0.0253925268,
-0.0202419311,
-0.0010491526,
0.0496799722,
-0.0333888941,
0.0012915587,
-0.025550209,
0.0506462865,
-0.0214990359,
-0.0409910455,
0.0246221963,
0.0484038256,
-0.003852916,
-0.0292085372,
-0.0653189942,
-0.0584156364,
0.0256459042,
-0.0101237176,
-0.0110604037,
-0.0210710894,
-0.0000063352,
0.0330274776,
0.0038429354,
-0.026774548,
0.0354654118,
0.0043686978,
-0.0195768829,
0.0022534882,
0.0456119031,
-0.0034990364,
0.0270332862,
0.0305386093,
-0.0071191513,
-0.0144981537,
-0.0352711342,
0.0195983369,
0.0097313803,
-0.0022736026,
0.0311960652,
0.0116959084,
-0.0145110581,
0.0106160203,
0.0319555514,
-0.0055150129,
-0.0604416169,
-0.0015179033,
0.0086987726,
0.0571634471,
0.0085286079,
0.0386911258,
-0.0393992998,
-0.0173088983,
-0.0270942505,
0.0141385533,
0.0022685304,
-0.0350894369,
0.002321169,
0.0050994596,
-0.0274174586,
0.040070992,
0.091179736,
0.0216071513,
0.0381813198,
0.0228369758,
0.0132913981,
-0.0314674228,
-0.0098547349,
-0.0056331633,
0.0429117531,
-0.031504184,
-0.0060595647,
-0.0520002283,
-0.0387408808,
0.0027889484,
0.0067355749,
-0.0297402423,
-0.0021897568,
0.0322767012,
0.0296022613,
0.0076531214,
0.0269067995,
-0.0577075183,
0.0022733591,
-0.0401092805,
0.0238005463,
0.0145206898,
-6.339866416e-33,
-0.0466727167,
0.0136816408,
0.033620622,
0.0107493876,
-0.0194944106,
0.0155071095,
-0.0036040801,
0.0057497439,
-0.0193228666,
-0.0240168106,
-0.0429532267,
0.0013767534,
0.0321867578,
0.0426879972,
0.028121708,
-0.0041436446,
0.0252269059,
0.0158576872,
0.0068839658,
0.0344502889,
0.0074605928,
0.0464394651,
0.0675252602,
-0.0162233021,
0.0079666823,
-0.0294133089,
-0.0202976,
0.0089839548,
0.0160590522,
0.0804430544,
-0.0393427946,
0.0725633129,
0.0074627805,
-0.0433761291,
-0.0438529626,
-0.0105627878,
-0.0827236995,
-0.0099993069,
0.0470739789,
0.0333398916,
-0.0289721526,
-0.0599029139,
-0.0075955018,
-0.0166984797,
-0.0047673807,
-0.0270114783,
0.0357775614,
-0.0565293059,
-0.010681564,
0.0116955359,
-0.056691315,
0.0245081391,
0.0018123779,
-0.0124774696,
0.0155208036,
0.0273164865,
-0.0167432707,
0.0132169658,
-0.0799322575,
0.0220299624,
0.0849493369,
0.0191536117,
0.0552716851,
0.0329800956,
-0.0077075446,
0.0143268602,
0.0434836783,
-0.0465226807,
0.0095039997,
-0.0330387764,
0.0313586444,
0.0297699906,
0.0510962307,
0.0225431025,
0.0139315734,
-0.0040239864,
-0.0459241532,
0.0063847308,
0.0022578102,
0.0276876148,
0.0362707227,
-0.0132721737,
-0.0593857244,
-0.0311584268,
-0.0286688115,
0.0191184543,
-0.0279543959,
-0.0429433174,
0.0556059927,
0.030927876,
-0.0254318267,
0.0201004948,
0.0574020594,
-0.0537563898,
0.0096977502,
0.0512062088,
-0.0079763187,
0.0249164272,
-0.0384595506,
0.0292732306,
-0.0559108518,
-0.0196239427,
-0.0203665011,
-0.0149659384,
-0.0270690955,
-0.0157762766,
0.0419162773,
0.0130574536,
-0.0613188818,
0.02419094,
-0.0090213763,
0.0422297828,
-0.0400157869,
0.0347779319,
0.005040538,
0.0241495613,
-0.0081079938,
0.0453221165,
0.0010945785,
-0.0071546766,
-0.0489410348,
-0.0117414901,
0.014828627,
0.0174468569,
-0.0278454032,
0.0477771126,
-0.0419952385,
0.0292881038,
-0.0018314397,
-0.0114323907,
0.0007206047,
0.0544049256,
2.54e-7,
0.0643150732,
0.0702140108,
0.0597990677,
0.0054679965,
-0.0055024754,
0.0222790949,
-0.0255816523,
-0.0288082156,
0.011419801,
0.0272926856,
0.0529448017,
0.0576160662,
0.0716110915,
0.0095076002,
-0.1355095208,
0.013087688,
-0.0721627325,
0.0005193622,
-0.0713982061,
-0.02752655,
0.0201795977,
0.1224894747,
-0.0259149875,
-0.0125963697,
-0.0058928709,
-0.0515290499,
0.0529350229,
-0.018287465,
-0.0379794054,
0.0551930852,
0.0396453068,
0.0341624469,
0.0074304971,
0.0082784453,
-0.0243795086,
-0.0119538102,
0.0490808859,
0.089677617,
0.0034757345,
-0.0002460032,
0.0121563589,
0.0011036868,
-0.0438942239,
-0.0775641426,
0.0586784445,
-0.0403366573,
0.0091038411,
0.0307101663,
-0.0251353905,
0.0055330326,
-0.0121734738,
-0.0117577519,
-0.0406633392,
0.0598619506,
0.0365200378,
-0.0451893695,
-0.032512676,
-0.0148333926,
-0.0366139784,
-0.0101431254,
-0.0182446446,
-0.0204484146,
-0.0519105792,
0.0218071826,
-0.0170354284,
-0.0773663372,
0.028451968,
2.256516149e-34,
0.0620841943,
0.0009247331,
-0.0064535243,
0.0250333678,
0.0188663583,
-0.0186446831,
-0.0021749546,
0.0034709754,
-0.011954762,
-0.0850344896,
0.010615957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13933v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13933v5 | Structured Probabilistic Coding | 2023-12-21T15:28:02 | 2024-05-02T05:18:45 | Dou Hu, Lingwei Wei, Yaxin Liu, Wei Zhou, Songlin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper presents a new supervised representation learning framework,
namely structured probabilistic coding (SPC), to learn compact and informative
representations from input related to the target task. SPC is an encoder-only
probabilistic coding technology with a structured regularization from the
target space. It can enhance the generalization ability of pre-trained language
models for better language understanding. Specifically, our probabilistic
coding simultaneously performs information encoding and task prediction in one
module to more fully utilize the effective information from input data. It uses
variational inference in the output space to reduce randomness and uncertainty.
Besides, to better control the learning process of probabilistic
representations, a structured regularization is proposed to promote uniformity
across classes in the latent space. With the regularization term, SPC can
preserve the Gaussian structure of the latent code and achieve better coverage
of the hidden space with class uniformly. Experimental results on 12 natural
language understanding tasks demonstrate that our SPC effectively improves the
performance of pre-trained language models for classification and regression.
Extensive experiments show that SPC can enhance the generalization capability,
robustness to label noise, and clustering quality of output representations. | [
0.0055147335,
0.0730932951,
0.0034689254,
-0.0039655371,
0.0092034778,
0.0370052978,
-0.0131888222,
-0.0066373809,
-0.0048716133,
-0.0351184197,
0.0101428712,
-0.0281277094,
0.0127580501,
0.096054554,
0.0404502898,
-0.0688729137,
0.0108756283,
-0.0080919228,
0.0389166139,
-0.0066156359,
0.0188606512,
-0.0106786741,
-0.0136879915,
0.0285450313,
-0.0276331995,
0.0305790622,
-0.024969887,
-0.0263792202,
0.0016222044,
-0.0042131292,
0.0245657489,
0.0458794385,
0.0799249187,
-0.0566745624,
0.0000021663,
-0.0045006284,
-0.0176658686,
-0.0412178636,
-0.0071411566,
-0.0388439074,
-0.0048571122,
-0.0388185717,
0.0112776058,
-0.0089362152,
-0.015816519,
-0.0615362972,
0.0906820074,
0.0810628757,
-0.0017387531,
0.0710188001,
-0.0211436506,
-0.0540461764,
0.0208766125,
-0.005835325,
0.0444218405,
-0.0057315282,
0.0160333179,
0.0541236773,
-0.0069553461,
0.051308807,
-0.0414866097,
-0.0001831859,
0.009862191,
0.0037046501,
0.0552379377,
0.0525058582,
-0.0165075082,
-0.0247668345,
0.0070227543,
0.0608589016,
-0.0380777046,
-0.0528324097,
-0.0570782423,
-0.0419632085,
-0.0454113111,
0.0109988321,
-0.0171598811,
0.0293879956,
-0.0034984415,
0.0597927645,
-0.0063349572,
0.0412910916,
0.0306839701,
-0.0356461667,
0.0108059123,
0.0412545875,
-0.0073768045,
-0.0019657784,
-0.0057989815,
0.019458808,
-0.0012760048,
0.0159625635,
0.0076134508,
0.0143360915,
0.0277630016,
0.0036558136,
-0.0364432894,
-0.0152870677,
-0.0460232794,
-0.0468655154,
0.0063257567,
0.0622843839,
-0.0068701091,
0.0468359515,
-0.0249532685,
0.0543207303,
-0.0057998179,
0.0219796281,
-0.0398126915,
0.0091213854,
-0.0548829585,
0.0097780637,
-0.0118721258,
0.0434763804,
0.015718339,
-0.015624213,
-0.0065842476,
0.0353453681,
-0.0049525676,
0.0022101132,
-0.0016045449,
0.0388690494,
-0.0170516074,
0.0110039692,
-0.0189942345,
-0.0019089384,
-0.0198977962,
0.0300928429,
-0.0367519893,
-0.0042926404,
0.0036429691,
0.0175931603,
0.0276627671,
-0.0044040303,
-0.0189954564,
0.0317024142,
-0.0170581248,
-0.0236937013,
-0.0390765294,
0.0120938076,
0.010721093,
-0.0136544993,
0.0008368944,
-0.0323494598,
0.0342613421,
0.0056685479,
-0.0014293011,
-0.0573483855,
-0.0137404623,
-0.0324459001,
-0.0289974045,
0.1014199778,
-0.0408095308,
-0.0283628684,
0.0323588513,
0.0283565614,
0.0053407941,
0.0617282689,
-0.0072828126,
0.0067948648,
-0.0035303086,
-0.0422863625,
-0.019067606,
-0.0031079077,
0.0086859949,
-0.0333956778,
0.006037862,
0.003171955,
0.0333301723,
-0.0099955359,
0.0637181997,
0.0069336304,
-0.0493194945,
-0.0099828346,
0.0351946875,
-0.003044354,
-0.0110405032,
0.0210804418,
0.0235284772,
0.0002026765,
0.0128800385,
0.0149266105,
-0.0269750282,
0.0144939721,
-0.0199102145,
-0.0180541743,
0.0122940177,
-0.0706682876,
-0.0559201241,
-0.009141841,
0.0100636892,
-0.0603546724,
0.0504285842,
0.0001573933,
0.0754723549,
-0.017485708,
-0.048458837,
0.0525438562,
0.0293474812,
-0.0208102129,
0.0530717485,
-0.0098274183,
0.0396806374,
0.0475914702,
0.0111150937,
-0.0589701198,
0.0245679151,
-0.0274577327,
-0.0302093998,
-0.0202029273,
0.0064604613,
-0.0235957578,
0.0238971543,
-0.0489454791,
-0.0876750872,
-0.0050223581,
-0.0109917605,
0.0149586406,
-0.0151506616,
0.0032969746,
0.0182613321,
-0.0128611475,
0.0190388784,
0.0295182019,
0.0224797521,
-0.0416171625,
0.0212508962,
-0.0047978652,
0.0586797036,
-0.0180890094,
-0.0106873652,
0.0175923184,
0.0313182883,
-0.0556694195,
-0.0095983641,
-0.0391328894,
-0.0687388703,
-0.0635203421,
0.0030202148,
-0.0180577114,
0.0252300631,
0.0267055575,
-0.030674303,
-0.0536142923,
0.020068571,
-0.0349518023,
0.0473847911,
-0.039553076,
-0.0288978331,
0.0132659553,
0.0159435887,
-0.0273101423,
0.0511907861,
-0.0121197859,
0.0125055667,
0.0025850222,
0.0028147399,
0.0266316663,
-0.0128221279,
-0.0096688569,
-0.0115606859,
-0.0092353374,
0.0174759179,
0.0485533476,
-0.0075894762,
-0.0140414564,
0.0086628664,
-0.0480630249,
-0.0431611501,
-0.0064336658,
-0.0105016017,
-0.0005477115,
0.0193657205,
0.028003145,
-0.0208247881,
-0.0719300136,
0.0040090424,
-0.0216378551,
0.0011432697,
-0.0175310876,
0.0131974742,
-0.0151631758,
-0.0242940616,
-0.0251931362,
0.0078957258,
0.02099525,
-0.0017873476,
-0.0400844254,
-0.0813341141,
0.0395107977,
0.0130480304,
0.0353057347,
-0.0229010638,
-0.0130087426,
0.0147695541,
-0.043934647,
0.0536755547,
0.0160948448,
-0.0101372907,
0.0380034447,
0.0632394701,
0.0267194323,
-0.0350310169,
-0.0183362942,
-0.0599258877,
-0.0048802304,
-0.0475633591,
-0.0252016373,
-0.0331452265,
0.044029396,
0.0761948973,
0.0017855321,
-0.1189381853,
-0.0514425449,
0.0182827655,
-0.0379246436,
-0.0609488077,
-0.0291614141,
-0.0173476953,
0.0488147326,
-0.0194841735,
-0.0447918028,
0.0505342707,
-0.0034572084,
0.0266200136,
-0.0141397053,
-0.0243539289,
0.0264149122,
0.0289208721,
0.0565260239,
0.0157199204,
-0.0156679712,
-0.0580211394,
-0.0525635891,
0.0237581171,
0.007371672,
-0.0179653242,
-0.0314204544,
-0.0212703366,
0.0195731111,
0.0006541843,
0.0004029647,
-0.0388838463,
-0.063194178,
0.0094488859,
0.0438386537,
0.0275425296,
0.0377040133,
-0.0177470874,
0.0398952439,
-0.0472538285,
0.0161266699,
-0.0217444059,
-0.0026478646,
-0.0106785027,
0.0227608979,
0.0070752543,
-0.0129020549,
-0.0178487189,
-0.0153142195,
-0.0584274381,
0.0500406586,
-0.0282634739,
0.0150024528,
-0.0472234599,
0.0540253185,
0.0267332718,
0.0125158401,
-0.028826056,
0.0153132528,
0.0387959741,
-0.0320532024,
-0.0161940362,
0.1232107207,
0.0161002353,
-0.0680929422,
-0.0104628503,
-0.0205894057,
0.0364652015,
0.0188614354,
0.0136570595,
-0.0188133847,
-0.0201950297,
-0.0245431159,
-0.0040355944,
0.0126401521,
-0.0494001731,
0.0359726995,
-0.0671607703,
0.0074041737,
0.0291865505,
-0.0144081609,
-0.0876745507,
-0.0587405935,
-0.0201932471,
-0.0072628511,
-0.0166132692,
-0.0138328755,
0.0199898742,
0.025194725,
0.0399443097,
-0.0496424511,
-0.0508038551,
0.0086019551,
-0.0094098542,
0.0525862947,
0.0648926198,
-0.0042406656,
0.0012602459,
-0.0015807308,
-0.0039344118,
0.0042837695,
-0.0077538826,
-0.0216707271,
0.0673342124,
-0.0167681649,
0.003197456,
0.0250372905,
0.0130334748,
-0.0316361897,
-0.0378618278,
-0.0331682861,
0.0815076232,
-0.0629956797,
-0.0116273779,
-0.0133717088,
-0.0058111809,
0.0501184016,
0.0802091733,
0.0232286248,
-0.0125343008,
-0.0276945904,
-0.0355009921,
0.0468146242,
0.0249523558,
0.0136236241,
0.0450654365,
0.0211713016,
-0.0601717941,
-0.0374663919,
-0.0188603159,
0.0617642887,
-0.0017235847,
0.00485521,
-0.005530546,
0.0198432636,
-0.0338036828,
-0.0692002997,
-0.0164092835,
0.0051837033,
-0.0134002306,
0.0094348742,
-0.0667135119,
0.0096357306,
-0.0240054149,
-0.0096657984,
-0.0424146987,
-0.0794263035,
-0.033640977,
-0.0173881929,
0.0592270754,
0.0036238236,
0.0610237792,
-0.0044131409,
-0.0476585068,
0.0332718231,
-0.0514716543,
-0.0414384305,
0.0021307159,
0.0285897739,
-0.0104242722,
-0.0089896377,
0.0108716162,
-0.0674395487,
0.0061264969,
-0.0256620627,
0.0155985504,
-0.0233220272,
-0.0516624972,
0.0260913745,
-0.0432274379,
0.074246414,
-0.0250950493,
-0.0124819987,
-0.0491481945,
-0.0277861431,
-0.0297358334,
0.0150601799,
-0.029550245,
0.0162660424,
0.0571883023,
-0.0352067165,
0.0031880511,
0.0407274626,
-0.0397166014,
0.0266510192,
0.0018016801,
-0.0039092256,
0.0638476089,
-0.000614076,
0.0269062165,
0.0312715508,
-0.0246350933,
0.0195982568,
0.0083184689,
-0.0012925442,
-0.0018662162,
0.0278286338,
0.009524052,
0.0412587598,
-0.0159035474,
-0.0239384361,
-0.055328045,
-0.0383863784,
-0.0125126233,
0.0004187804,
0.0132857813,
-0.0242412947,
-0.0134733133,
-0.035504058,
-0.0041987356,
-0.0365348682,
0.0372738801,
0.0135059562,
-0.0130782938,
0.1078875065,
-0.0184626486,
-0.0227419809,
-0.0238131117,
0.0936126262,
0.050849624,
0.0300073177,
-0.0381087177,
0.0202306509,
-0.0487203151,
0.0242285095,
0.0375146233,
0.0937726051,
-0.0080110328,
0.0422701463,
0.0468753166,
-0.0447726175,
-0.0205528196,
-0.0205920413,
-0.0285887662,
0.0020007535,
0.0743679553,
0.037854746,
-0.0325595848,
-0.0106819728,
-0.0277976263,
-0.0139013911,
0.0487177558,
0.0010399166,
-0.0313121639,
-7.107262189e-33,
-0.0150397755,
-0.0119070765,
-0.0232342407,
-0.0003092877,
-0.0064995899,
0.0053002667,
-0.0280546322,
0.0136390803,
-0.0034782316,
0.012585111,
0.025070766,
0.0259564202,
-0.001743247,
0.0467345379,
0.007191,
-0.0245571509,
0.033064004,
-0.0273485146,
0.028257316,
0.0277125109,
0.0472846627,
0.016772015,
0.0673388839,
-0.1021875516,
0.017338533,
0.0052713812,
0.0024516485,
-0.0074070217,
0.0985272229,
0.0133251054,
-0.0252084993,
0.0401310213,
0.0485241823,
0.0135900695,
-0.0285523571,
0.0338949263,
-0.0811740533,
-0.0324929059,
-0.0006141728,
0.0229631923,
-0.0672300383,
-0.0239261929,
0.0234464519,
-0.0117006609,
0.0230980311,
-0.0368204825,
0.0636905134,
-0.035933774,
-0.0231231749,
-0.0392431282,
-0.0157518405,
0.0150036458,
-0.0065587433,
0.0156840794,
0.0059662727,
0.0506575443,
0.0024667045,
0.0141204875,
-0.0202245917,
0.0157295354,
-0.0512455143,
0.0502496548,
0.0107970126,
0.0490099825,
0.0336588733,
0.049779959,
0.0018076944,
-0.0520149767,
-0.0517707095,
0.0214268304,
-0.009201644,
0.0196406078,
0.0012527996,
0.0151887732,
0.0141300885,
-0.0164711252,
-0.0867240578,
0.0483330414,
-0.0008749595,
0.022779258,
0.0304505136,
0.0476519614,
-0.0452544093,
-0.0520891808,
-0.0153871803,
-0.041748438,
0.0166055318,
-0.0456513278,
0.011979498,
-0.0058925292,
0.0090060784,
-0.0132795107,
0.0587397479,
-0.0510478802,
-0.0022468921,
0.0370892882,
-0.0087656118,
0.0032410193,
0.0189289935,
0.0165204499,
-0.0678067207,
-0.0295701697,
0.0408179387,
-0.0556585863,
0.0058443462,
0.0231708419,
0.0074855844,
0.0498475507,
-0.018557962,
-0.0292770714,
-0.0134895621,
-0.0504883602,
0.0181225836,
0.0881288126,
0.0388437249,
0.033888679,
0.0065987413,
0.0830684304,
-0.0211004373,
-0.0082206074,
0.0095313182,
-0.0145731103,
0.0551042147,
0.048319757,
-0.0536228977,
-0.0213231388,
-0.0500640422,
-0.0117552867,
0.0572701991,
-0.0562797971,
-0.0024713578,
0.0467142761,
2.781e-7,
0.078192547,
0.0027212177,
-0.006615445,
0.0018139572,
0.0341308601,
0.0435341038,
0.0233445615,
0.0410246775,
-0.0064300545,
-0.0636242554,
0.0276663303,
0.0314726122,
-0.0044361847,
-0.003566188,
-0.0601195432,
-0.0149085447,
0.0064926329,
0.0242557973,
0.0220481753,
0.0220356509,
0.1363988221,
0.1418228894,
0.0052806353,
0.0045270189,
0.0534692965,
-0.0143870767,
0.0910245478,
-0.0146546746,
-0.0018872432,
-0.0001043283,
-0.0504394248,
0.0282341726,
-0.0100604948,
0.02210401,
-0.035828501,
-0.0129555045,
0.0261744969,
0.0849637538,
-0.0532451011,
-0.0500333533,
0.0020029407,
-0.0098695662,
0.0001284013,
-0.0005099523,
0.0892903581,
-0.0586522594,
-0.0413328074,
0.0267771687,
-0.0205380563,
0.0028608206,
-0.0075325635,
0.0272934418,
-0.0448862985,
-0.0077866036,
0.025616087,
-0.0024509488,
-0.0182150733,
-0.0748402104,
0.0127688013,
0.0010426239,
-0.0550325215,
-0.0049852799,
0.0252947025,
-0.0447916426,
0.0824103281,
-0.0054025236,
-0.010688833,
2.509390928e-34,
0.0079702763,
0.0137731582,
0.0018296072,
0.0044101654,
-0.0381797217,
-0.0458350778,
-0.0041374057,
0.0058713169,
0.0495664813,
-0.0555974394,
-0.0421927124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13905v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13905v2 | Domain-Specific Fine-Tuning of Large Language Models for Interactive Robot Programming | 2023-12-21T14:51:04 | 2024-04-21T09:24:39 | Benjamin Alt, Urs Keßner, Aleksandar Taranovic, Darko Katic, Andreas Hermann, Rainer Jäkel, Gerhard Neumann | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG, 68T40, I.2.9; I.2.5; I.2.6; I.2.7 | Industrial robots are applied in a widening range of industries, but robot
programming mostly remains a task limited to programming experts. We propose a
natural language-based assistant for programming of advanced, industrial
robotic applications and investigate strategies for domain-specific fine-tuning
of foundation models with limited data and compute. | [
0.0176548623,
0.0477173142,
-0.0118970694,
0.0203291979,
-0.0283953287,
0.0074843341,
-0.0073670805,
-0.0474627204,
-0.0043472131,
-0.0294184163,
-0.0195111129,
0.0114545599,
-0.0062753679,
0.0534587242,
0.0001159041,
-0.0564306937,
0.0554043427,
-0.0425055847,
-0.0100536039,
0.0216675866,
-0.0116662513,
0.0231915545,
-0.0479154177,
0.0764905065,
0.0027180626,
0.0005342001,
-0.0330640003,
-0.0107097328,
-0.0041269441,
0.0007737532,
-0.0076775681,
0.0461255461,
0.0681280196,
-0.0213927403,
0.0000018589,
-0.0788153559,
-0.0054898425,
0.03000612,
-0.0165920947,
-0.0291524623,
0.0347315446,
0.0022037944,
-0.0018027567,
0.0436189063,
-0.0410848223,
-0.0075180181,
0.0546553805,
0.0169582162,
0.0591848008,
0.0474492311,
0.0094620446,
-0.0415454507,
-0.0111249732,
0.0211243089,
-0.0435062237,
-0.0529498905,
0.0184733048,
0.0348780714,
0.0735556111,
-0.017660575,
-0.0018698034,
0.0044577098,
0.0343456939,
-0.027935423,
-0.0053963391,
0.0127816079,
-0.0225233305,
-0.027998019,
-0.0054795761,
0.0390961692,
0.0238743071,
-0.0061652921,
-0.0029714254,
0.0098647214,
0.0315920301,
-0.0167533867,
-0.0019942098,
0.0234070569,
-0.0050676349,
-0.0396061279,
-0.0037716762,
-0.0499552637,
-0.0255137179,
0.0051827622,
-0.0202145092,
0.0767013654,
0.0014818582,
-0.0125902453,
-0.0114784613,
-0.0308457501,
-0.0110859396,
-0.0500088185,
0.0128465286,
0.0604263209,
-0.0576848201,
0.017208809,
-0.0578650609,
0.025432799,
-0.0291759502,
-0.0075236498,
-0.0187740475,
0.0435748361,
0.0190122891,
0.0227052439,
-0.0018704616,
0.0603039898,
-0.0015150993,
-0.0193063952,
-0.0061623324,
-0.0110385707,
-0.0722514763,
-0.0001626534,
-0.1074455529,
0.0194736756,
-0.0296609197,
-0.0098294066,
-0.0112310089,
0.0702013001,
0.0063736187,
0.0170604791,
-0.0320284441,
-0.0079266541,
-0.0355312303,
-0.0191646069,
-0.0617507063,
0.0136041567,
-0.054816287,
0.0192089528,
-0.0010615585,
-0.0521146059,
0.01424261,
0.0242643449,
-0.0079738554,
0.0015558536,
-0.0023020965,
0.1017990112,
0.0181332156,
-0.0137755545,
-0.0174753908,
-0.0208488442,
0.0398739316,
-0.0531922728,
-0.0010132717,
-0.0655744299,
0.0010605002,
0.0298000276,
0.0114558348,
-0.0588783994,
-0.0098222112,
0.0187879466,
0.0194700249,
0.069763273,
-0.0373651236,
0.0010466817,
0.0014182255,
-0.0400667489,
-0.0135988593,
0.0271043647,
0.0155299148,
0.0097886557,
-0.0165332295,
-0.0172230955,
-0.0081601525,
0.0204999074,
-0.0776398852,
-0.0319487713,
0.0074180104,
0.036784526,
-0.0034884545,
0.0391891114,
-0.0314853564,
-0.0169465002,
0.0084764725,
0.0475481376,
0.0137558393,
0.0217695646,
-0.0008021811,
0.049589552,
0.0572085194,
0.0310258456,
0.0118098818,
-0.030877037,
-0.0634993166,
0.0361307189,
-0.0354570784,
0.0197039023,
-0.0516375862,
0.0126019185,
0.0059568426,
-0.0521119833,
0.0305183027,
0.0042181145,
0.0389251113,
-0.0270634424,
0.0651888177,
0.0321486183,
-0.0485248156,
-0.0292274039,
0.0037102161,
-0.0286750831,
-0.0423234291,
-0.0060094814,
-0.0322197527,
0.0518254749,
0.0280877315,
-0.0671612993,
-0.056165155,
-0.0002093174,
0.0082563609,
0.0522772558,
0.0215466488,
-0.0196812134,
-0.0201768838,
-0.0130415875,
-0.0103826271,
-0.0127919633,
0.0235995091,
0.0263943784,
-0.012412102,
-0.0228028409,
-0.0086904056,
-0.0073980535,
-0.0019018023,
0.0223172698,
-0.0134323779,
-0.0134111792,
-0.0025356677,
0.0372941755,
0.0226048864,
0.0190391373,
-0.0233168099,
0.0176442489,
0.0166633315,
-0.003578129,
0.0006204486,
0.0008904674,
0.0214599241,
0.0052075759,
0.0355108865,
-0.0092393076,
-0.0485208891,
0.0150880711,
-0.018389143,
-0.0149533544,
0.0151513629,
-0.0120547181,
0.0197990742,
0.0289889295,
0.0499812327,
-0.0237604585,
-0.0366554148,
-0.0244505499,
0.0207051951,
0.0406097956,
0.0076225614,
0.0554587804,
0.0091162222,
0.0101296902,
-0.060829144,
-0.0058556017,
0.0019855131,
-0.0214422792,
0.0228021722,
0.0463822149,
0.039643798,
0.0031217239,
-0.0057437066,
-0.0480153672,
-0.0099687204,
-0.0034845662,
-0.0293702129,
0.0276467539,
0.0058420161,
-0.0183779448,
-0.0269034114,
0.0043948335,
0.0225476567,
-0.0316551551,
-0.0046771998,
0.0274806228,
0.0231252853,
-0.0911767632,
-0.0422660895,
0.0139809726,
-0.0338847414,
-0.0299280286,
0.0580615699,
-0.0267709456,
-0.0863938704,
0.0551972911,
-0.0217688251,
0.0728151798,
-0.0016087985,
-0.0542746037,
0.0282539427,
-0.0173747484,
0.0117719341,
0.0937096551,
-0.0560976341,
0.0329387225,
0.0904111192,
0.0096935928,
-0.021089213,
0.0240498688,
-0.020863967,
-0.0084454166,
-0.00900089,
0.0132291932,
0.0323202647,
0.0483359955,
-0.000336316,
0.0026668371,
-0.0315832198,
0.0294954423,
0.0014892849,
0.0234473385,
0.0133995246,
0.021302646,
-0.0084645059,
0.0695003942,
-0.0024867079,
-0.0306076426,
0.0902755186,
-0.0344756097,
0.0032367287,
-0.0133144297,
-0.0412438288,
-0.0262401458,
0.0326535553,
0.0095359934,
0.0210600384,
0.0619890615,
-0.0492115766,
-0.0466058441,
0.0394768976,
0.0099259373,
0.0203742068,
0.0334249921,
-0.0695536062,
0.0451110639,
-0.002939584,
-0.0514758229,
-0.0269484054,
0.0005083335,
-0.0385244973,
0.0544405393,
0.0250152107,
-0.0690044835,
-0.0297020394,
-0.0182703938,
0.0087145176,
0.0276258066,
0.0212458037,
-0.0309409946,
-0.0526147,
-0.0234234985,
0.020145921,
0.0450771563,
-0.0464072973,
0.0158105455,
0.0113009447,
-0.0237440132,
0.0139845125,
-0.0248844046,
-0.090048559,
0.0053625065,
0.0280003045,
-0.027905805,
0.0250451714,
0.0358770452,
0.0252556037,
-0.0436408706,
-0.0213515721,
0.1083975732,
0.0031012238,
-0.0014658702,
0.0268549565,
0.002367663,
0.0134811569,
0.0691115707,
0.0508780293,
-0.0649826452,
-0.0659366921,
-0.0010267902,
0.0308788512,
0.025752563,
-0.0331688039,
-0.0076363753,
-0.1315216124,
0.0263251308,
-0.0161747355,
-0.0597141907,
-0.1094147339,
-0.021366179,
0.0235625561,
-0.0233737342,
-0.025891494,
0.0389301889,
-0.0276353117,
-0.0086727943,
0.0017512242,
-0.0148212463,
-0.083838895,
0.0221117977,
-0.0251742844,
0.0184541289,
0.077156432,
0.003194053,
0.0027266284,
0.0489506088,
0.01508197,
0.0521551035,
0.0305043831,
-0.0503485203,
-0.0310588293,
0.0142309675,
-0.0452181064,
-0.019144034,
0.018365657,
-0.0255517084,
-0.0121964021,
-0.0080143129,
0.0320519619,
-0.0416192971,
0.0312499851,
-0.0019063478,
-0.037505839,
0.0162927154,
0.0268246587,
0.0112261325,
-0.0292175114,
-0.0268211234,
-0.0593285263,
-0.05622961,
0.04745882,
-0.0435436442,
-0.0067519587,
-0.0323693752,
-0.0074145226,
-0.0571632199,
-0.0052886819,
0.0936753079,
0.0313555449,
0.0279795416,
-0.0172802769,
0.0821532607,
0.0331693664,
-0.038016811,
0.0463314615,
-0.0246642046,
0.0284755677,
-0.0642526746,
-0.0187070202,
0.0230317656,
-0.0305311605,
-0.0335704237,
0.0094885221,
0.0130640632,
-0.0602369569,
-0.002774646,
0.0610486791,
0.0203333478,
0.0210499112,
-0.0367260836,
-0.0563813075,
-0.0510695465,
0.0177163407,
-0.0372438692,
0.0137151321,
-0.0029916044,
0.0058784764,
0.0087475963,
0.0248566065,
-0.0756341964,
0.0018280976,
-0.0364391021,
0.0074145095,
-0.0017789811,
-0.0621596612,
0.0445282683,
0.0511930212,
0.0175718777,
0.0288846921,
0.023831062,
-0.0424667038,
0.0107489703,
-0.0323042497,
-0.029698614,
-0.0582259037,
0.0153601272,
-0.0224707406,
-0.0205188841,
0.0719715729,
-0.003907586,
-0.0418924503,
0.0488142036,
0.0061788098,
0.0372930393,
0.0152418045,
0.0449858271,
0.04208358,
0.0064703035,
-0.0071672341,
0.0066345874,
-0.0080833929,
0.0495263599,
-0.0082959812,
0.0508084334,
0.0195847396,
0.0200907718,
-0.0485283174,
0.0341442265,
0.02175886,
-0.1377251148,
-0.0119205834,
-0.0014927958,
0.0539920926,
-0.0009853488,
0.0182672925,
-0.0765004605,
0.018056158,
-0.0246545114,
0.0570727997,
0.0281726681,
-0.0320697613,
0.0540439971,
0.0252132714,
0.0103868665,
-0.004672878,
0.0672557727,
0.0087306714,
0.0425270721,
-0.02227352,
-0.0066818274,
-0.0442587137,
-0.0149504747,
0.0248707905,
-0.0096567897,
-0.002563756,
-0.0090558473,
-0.0385230668,
-0.0584762134,
-0.0632521585,
0.0224937238,
-0.0073865862,
-0.0079259295,
0.0659772828,
0.0225991458,
0.0073981788,
-0.026789397,
0.0043956651,
-0.0200655051,
-0.0187652111,
-0.0262028445,
-0.0400534049,
-5.313403443e-33,
-0.049878113,
-0.0333213769,
0.0284095351,
-0.0140622668,
0.0200504269,
-0.039188318,
-0.0281592887,
0.0238491669,
-0.0286965314,
0.0056733829,
0.018013468,
0.006516668,
0.0019030167,
-0.0276951976,
0.0088168951,
-0.0068140998,
0.0651962087,
0.0185531229,
-0.0360473432,
-0.0185227394,
0.0140828956,
-0.0144196004,
0.01781944,
-0.0729547441,
0.0173845198,
-0.0046600532,
-0.0187331997,
0.0467594117,
0.0090784244,
0.0141333882,
0.0033622368,
0.0385998189,
0.0047845673,
-0.0172373261,
-0.0414971225,
0.0367512591,
-0.061867319,
-0.0372593664,
-0.0015630041,
0.0347747132,
0.0041214786,
-0.0166288447,
0.0480363257,
-0.0090092504,
-0.0381892174,
0.0606234856,
0.0439461432,
-0.0314661637,
0.0441503935,
0.0292863976,
-0.0868596211,
-0.0001251343,
-0.0313781388,
-0.064176023,
0.001445775,
0.0153216859,
-0.0089311674,
0.0010081357,
0.0407783426,
-0.0090789869,
0.0273460988,
0.0382254459,
0.0736813396,
-0.0118670249,
0.0223214906,
-0.0134909377,
0.0076194885,
0.0154005885,
0.0451648384,
0.0270982049,
-0.0130161559,
0.0802601948,
0.0063857776,
0.0394211784,
0.0126697617,
0.0474568568,
-0.0377240591,
0.0027351391,
-0.0245130695,
0.1028075889,
-0.0196218994,
0.0031487895,
-0.028102478,
-0.0096026128,
-0.0467892103,
0.0244614985,
-0.0048193838,
-0.0101288902,
0.0312590897,
-0.005659943,
-0.0123449024,
-0.0412104651,
0.0014863131,
0.0066109183,
-0.0142193083,
0.025659889,
-0.0407879986,
0.0381110907,
-0.0216082819,
-0.0126219196,
-0.0126423454,
-0.0316849276,
-0.0042421562,
-0.0366395004,
0.0746924579,
0.0153348185,
-0.0565597937,
0.0612046905,
-0.0312937461,
0.0102758622,
-0.0474805348,
0.004144337,
0.0230717082,
0.036019735,
0.0431043915,
-0.0116495769,
-0.0181024019,
0.1015176252,
-0.0156835336,
-0.0685478523,
-0.0311914422,
-0.0038133857,
0.0201125834,
-0.0052636503,
-0.0343778469,
-0.0472494364,
-0.0281704944,
0.0430565961,
0.0124699231,
-0.0295468643,
-0.0274813659,
-0.0183334108,
2.625e-7,
-0.0028777849,
0.0661309734,
0.0220061317,
0.0989490449,
-0.0109296339,
0.0568564907,
-0.0043953382,
0.0128785064,
-0.0133275669,
0.008078686,
-0.0404089242,
0.0205437355,
0.0058152657,
-0.0132887131,
-0.0765908286,
0.0114830621,
0.032400921,
0.0139009152,
-0.0700891167,
0.0174000338,
0.0821318775,
0.0830370039,
0.0016123787,
0.0279738996,
0.0072566555,
-0.0800111666,
0.0017673108,
-0.0164885614,
0.0295333974,
0.0197926331,
-0.0328468755,
0.0382695422,
-0.0193423219,
0.0015605835,
0.0028533919,
0.0141016888,
-0.0208536517,
0.0682394728,
-0.0311639626,
0.0412415117,
0.0489576757,
-0.0163433086,
-0.0322784968,
0.0043973178,
0.0352874473,
-0.0877059028,
-0.0005813795,
0.001045038,
0.0069179093,
-0.0168182105,
-0.0401663668,
-0.0154186236,
0.0201357324,
-0.017496245,
-0.0095001869,
-0.0269079395,
-0.0423069447,
0.0028931347,
0.0124776131,
-0.0013577081,
-0.0392200127,
-0.023879189,
0.0090966355,
-0.038708806,
0.0320955776,
-0.0010063861,
0.0239073448,
2.170152901e-34,
0.0117000667,
0.0026359081,
0.0569328889,
0.0834198818,
0.0461148918,
0.019849332,
-0.0369708799,
0.0347779542,
0.0418267883,
-0.0830446929,
-0.0312656499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13881v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13881v1 | Diversifying Knowledge Enhancement of Biomedical Language Models using Adapter Modules and Knowledge Graphs | 2023-12-21T14:26:57 | 2023-12-21T14:26:57 | Juraj Vladika, Alexander Fichtl, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in natural language processing (NLP) owe their success to
pre-training language models on large amounts of unstructured data. Still,
there is an increasing effort to combine the unstructured nature of LMs with
structured knowledge and reasoning. Particularly in the rapidly evolving field
of biomedical NLP, knowledge-enhanced language models (KELMs) have emerged as
promising tools to bridge the gap between large language models and
domain-specific knowledge, considering the available biomedical knowledge
graphs (KGs) curated by experts over the decades. In this paper, we develop an
approach that uses lightweight adapter modules to inject structured biomedical
knowledge into pre-trained language models (PLMs). We use two large KGs, the
biomedical knowledge system UMLS and the novel biochemical ontology OntoChem,
with two prominent biomedical PLMs, PubMedBERT and BioLinkBERT. The approach
includes partitioning knowledge graphs into smaller subgraphs, fine-tuning
adapter modules for each subgraph, and combining the knowledge in a fusion
layer. We test the performance on three downstream tasks: document
classification,question answering, and natural language inference. We show that
our methodology leads to performance improvements in several instances while
keeping requirements in computing power low. Finally, we provide a detailed
interpretation of the results and report valuable insights for future work. | [
0.0664346516,
0.0124614472,
0.0296083093,
-0.0079542398,
-0.012643653,
0.0126815923,
0.018347811,
0.0215983186,
0.0825795531,
-0.039163392,
-0.0149194598,
0.0108747082,
-0.0184035916,
0.0453764237,
-0.0029139069,
-0.0020638795,
0.0506782643,
0.003115681,
0.0201047082,
-0.0215140879,
-0.0033881152,
0.0280997176,
0.0017802918,
0.0106854886,
0.0376014002,
-0.0126891909,
0.0174745806,
-0.0103201205,
0.0011470568,
-0.0201512091,
-0.0055566831,
0.025267899,
0.0052714115,
0.0172675177,
0.0000017857,
-0.0468990095,
-0.0329642296,
0.0514670573,
-0.0414341092,
-0.01403955,
0.025481984,
-0.0324360505,
0.0434273034,
0.0181499496,
-0.0283592958,
-0.0398992598,
0.03248965,
0.0570267513,
0.0196530726,
0.048944965,
-0.0117103318,
0.0041267588,
0.0669758394,
0.0060454388,
0.0220089927,
-0.0080456799,
0.0582151487,
0.0078614894,
0.0644356757,
0.0136197703,
0.0098244641,
0.0538196042,
-0.0184703954,
0.0094799036,
0.0632082522,
0.023617778,
-0.0266844667,
0.0106525831,
-0.0146372626,
0.0506763794,
-0.0295172203,
-0.0357070602,
-0.0008767902,
-0.0160253793,
-0.0368440002,
0.0547757819,
-0.0161636062,
-0.0258633569,
-0.0315798186,
-0.0063447705,
0.0197510514,
-0.0335252322,
0.0542859957,
0.0168505441,
-0.0211561397,
0.0873437598,
0.0145366509,
-0.0027482782,
0.036925599,
0.0149749406,
-0.0001425579,
-0.0301442519,
0.0172970202,
0.0460021906,
0.0044526486,
0.0346886404,
-0.0087674176,
-0.0244654678,
0.052415695,
-0.0778594986,
0.0206019375,
-0.0108239762,
0.0055650664,
0.0698490441,
-0.039770443,
-0.0431222506,
-0.0321629085,
0.0355579294,
-0.0449642874,
-0.0314659551,
-0.0746193081,
-0.0272962246,
-0.0198273733,
0.0481055677,
-0.0458029881,
-0.0221249573,
-0.0581926703,
0.0367635079,
0.012208825,
-0.032505393,
0.0322965458,
0.0550166778,
0.0163939353,
-0.0317398049,
-0.0466826521,
0.0476768427,
0.0243127141,
0.0195686258,
-0.0420434102,
-0.0581708625,
-0.0088859266,
-0.001105214,
0.0309707355,
-0.0438774377,
0.0277322829,
0.0613539182,
0.0200319272,
-0.0452001989,
-0.0015424666,
-0.0468470417,
-0.0248712711,
-0.0437602028,
0.0279702768,
-0.0794911087,
0.059128169,
0.0366945677,
-0.0112056043,
-0.0427634418,
0.0095118517,
-0.0205150861,
-0.0921594277,
0.0882840678,
-0.045951318,
-0.022051312,
-0.0167544875,
0.017180698,
-0.0227823276,
0.0247044321,
0.0093166204,
-0.0786727369,
0.0117594656,
-0.0039271852,
-0.0342229158,
-0.0101973582,
0.024985183,
-0.0506188869,
0.0212098919,
0.0312213097,
-0.0227403343,
0.0449232981,
-0.0241850875,
0.0158316772,
0.0079412879,
0.0053017219,
0.0140181361,
0.0359909385,
0.0413878411,
0.0086162956,
0.0000636275,
-0.0028179181,
0.0311926752,
-0.0340984054,
-0.0119237537,
-0.005477801,
-0.0439914726,
0.0129963998,
-0.0058804736,
0.0363718122,
-0.0145825595,
-0.0218662731,
-0.0259003527,
-0.0127394637,
-0.0006266967,
0.0157050677,
0.0640327558,
-0.0143472021,
-0.019977143,
0.0844059512,
0.0666628033,
-0.0242992193,
0.0287393481,
-0.0087586269,
-0.0073018847,
0.069825463,
0.0466474742,
-0.0585826114,
-0.0553046614,
0.0102995671,
-0.0384619534,
0.0118402122,
0.0080115786,
-0.0222552624,
0.0299559496,
-0.031112941,
-0.0028897785,
0.0098394444,
0.0020923729,
-0.0257402416,
0.0266942382,
0.0168293696,
-0.0271197446,
-0.0593150966,
-0.0252063666,
0.0085814092,
-0.0558732599,
-0.0067484318,
0.0035527002,
-0.0288055558,
0.0284088776,
0.0012328784,
-0.0041474197,
0.0468335673,
0.0517340116,
-0.0472352318,
-0.0527017824,
-0.0159133673,
-0.020819027,
-0.0707672313,
0.0391162969,
0.0009596317,
0.0038962944,
-0.0220465884,
-0.0290873442,
-0.0422404706,
-0.0122913709,
-0.0026343542,
0.072018519,
-0.0132002048,
-0.0023779068,
0.0133135766,
-0.0069204029,
-0.034794189,
0.0324487127,
0.0020777506,
0.0082400395,
0.00012771,
-0.0792345852,
0.0068174014,
0.0236597285,
-0.0263427738,
-0.0313514285,
0.0255330019,
0.0153720723,
0.0059450078,
-0.0499654338,
-0.0415839441,
0.0189941116,
-0.1014342755,
0.0080374321,
0.041746933,
0.0339285322,
-0.000924144,
0.0596360117,
0.0293377917,
-0.0195258502,
-0.0365452431,
-0.0041590794,
0.0254973322,
0.0115911923,
0.0177174434,
0.0196608342,
0.0425569154,
-0.0162075516,
-0.0120120216,
-0.0436147191,
0.0637219697,
-0.0091734594,
-0.0054944651,
0.0293239094,
-0.0072917468,
-0.0389249958,
0.0357141718,
0.0039852303,
0.0242579561,
-0.0222664475,
0.0096978424,
0.004096041,
0.0446707569,
-0.0175632499,
0.0232025739,
0.0419602022,
0.016535785,
-0.0383267701,
0.0167992041,
-0.0448320135,
0.0228935182,
-0.0380024053,
0.0334448814,
0.005652321,
0.0573818423,
-0.0036278365,
-0.0528896451,
-0.0287524089,
0.0066043842,
0.0109322229,
-0.0146819465,
-0.0329978056,
0.0050148377,
0.0101426942,
0.000448116,
-0.0237464588,
-0.0237139165,
0.083040446,
-0.0179774631,
0.0240246821,
-0.0549116619,
-0.0246814378,
-0.0369112901,
0.0155516863,
0.0244936086,
0.0308123175,
-0.0001374633,
0.0469881929,
-0.0060950974,
0.0010475207,
0.0019322882,
-0.0509102456,
0.0464450382,
-0.03426392,
0.046528358,
0.0159929302,
-0.0209356677,
-0.0326229893,
0.0250163786,
-0.0546288937,
0.0376819149,
-0.001344296,
-0.0267190114,
-0.0407429896,
0.0332880989,
0.0240036584,
0.0249888506,
0.0111240819,
-0.0153859844,
-0.0028010295,
0.0491428822,
0.0429221764,
0.0055752373,
0.0376246832,
0.0180504043,
0.0190695375,
0.0657727346,
-0.0175019205,
-0.0314670578,
-0.0020678237,
0.0007636392,
0.0238093603,
-0.0641191527,
-0.0018253782,
-0.0145705491,
0.0278473292,
-0.059329614,
0.0148883015,
0.1051983759,
0.0412602201,
-0.013141782,
0.0011403891,
0.0022709523,
-0.0085730571,
-0.0156361833,
0.0456594676,
-0.082524769,
-0.0324293561,
-0.0454908051,
0.0170746911,
-0.0161045641,
-0.0492322817,
0.0083278725,
-0.0603086501,
0.0080161868,
0.009956751,
-0.0409913696,
-0.0214838404,
-0.0483196005,
-0.0229655802,
-0.0068294434,
-0.0232330374,
-0.022592796,
-0.0092475787,
-0.0056394222,
0.0230613388,
-0.0407979079,
-0.0915886462,
0.0182720814,
-0.0184001345,
0.0462448634,
-0.0159088597,
0.0044204202,
0.0033246921,
0.0001329549,
0.0063777925,
-0.0110286614,
0.0179448482,
-0.0232337918,
0.025314467,
-0.0018172121,
0.0085260849,
-0.0645712614,
-0.0143923927,
-0.0589767285,
-0.0326246396,
-0.0397299342,
0.1196671799,
-0.0199577175,
-0.024774611,
-0.0523823984,
-0.0212873835,
-0.0223676823,
0.0795621872,
-0.0248097386,
0.0003967087,
-0.0276088715,
0.0117354002,
-0.0071959589,
-0.0120887337,
-0.022597922,
0.0449181646,
-0.0646840408,
0.0062498492,
-0.0388963372,
-0.0132561726,
0.0657891482,
-0.0166235305,
-0.0147505496,
0.0643637776,
0.0557622388,
-0.0236198865,
-0.0765197128,
0.0653837398,
-0.0001742436,
-0.0103909308,
-0.0090769874,
-0.0757202506,
0.0373676717,
-0.0069534373,
-0.032268703,
0.0175279286,
0.0020311195,
-0.0797628388,
-0.0165308844,
0.0368204601,
0.0229772944,
0.0536860079,
-0.0194113255,
-0.0236659255,
0.0784518942,
0.0625298768,
-0.0472682938,
-0.0228937212,
-0.0024265863,
-0.0165704712,
-0.0125169978,
0.0338127762,
-0.0444703698,
-0.0094167953,
0.0040478623,
0.0232341569,
-0.026991846,
-0.060697943,
0.0238571484,
0.0323230997,
0.0227972306,
0.0078755962,
-0.0079329358,
-0.0325962342,
0.0266939029,
-0.0230319034,
-0.0023437568,
-0.0371729955,
-0.0303532369,
0.0238088295,
0.0018795809,
-0.016882753,
0.028868489,
-0.0305701811,
0.0167254433,
-0.008273433,
0.0191241782,
0.0395247638,
-0.0294462591,
0.0535762832,
-0.0209574532,
-0.0001106077,
0.0151891811,
-0.0224813297,
0.0013615236,
-0.0436323658,
-0.0066435519,
0.0026810062,
0.0022996429,
-0.0387541391,
0.022733191,
-0.0853440687,
-0.0323162749,
0.0144594265,
0.0280702244,
0.0191080719,
-0.0269138906,
0.0461340994,
-0.0150184855,
-0.0236404613,
-0.0320116468,
0.0189089309,
-0.0012978333,
0.0362714529,
0.0678532794,
0.0402486585,
-0.0195592102,
-0.0215737037,
0.0767738894,
0.039706707,
0.0786535069,
0.0167817716,
-0.0761688501,
-0.024064431,
-0.0377114937,
0.0282405429,
0.0493803844,
-0.0633418113,
0.0408558138,
-0.0737628713,
-0.0596828125,
0.0541220158,
-0.0165173151,
-0.0357584581,
-0.0115385316,
0.0569067076,
0.006461978,
0.0531852543,
-0.0380348973,
-0.0153745404,
0.0426519327,
-0.0607665293,
-0.016621083,
0.0530864783,
-6.303990328e-33,
0.0168033503,
-0.0333180539,
0.0191082098,
0.0076944889,
0.0108154686,
0.0193054862,
-0.0280299634,
-0.0120701985,
-0.0250789989,
0.0437851287,
-0.0071116933,
0.0062912963,
-0.0105185555,
0.041914735,
-0.0277058724,
0.0038979212,
0.0100963153,
0.0446898863,
0.0077088708,
0.0036323851,
0.0196519587,
0.0709937215,
0.044671271,
-0.0379922874,
0.0054798536,
0.0114035597,
0.0655393079,
0.0124095101,
-0.0200227499,
0.0726519153,
-0.0373954363,
0.0810090154,
0.0365034118,
0.007027769,
0.0055264598,
-0.0017505966,
-0.1184390485,
-0.0068446398,
0.05493512,
-0.0100271571,
-0.0425712019,
-0.0178271905,
0.060458675,
0.0159382336,
0.026366083,
-0.0521640107,
0.0258874837,
-0.024326453,
-0.0443622507,
-0.059325248,
-0.051215671,
0.0395735241,
0.0178271476,
0.0240454823,
-0.0144450217,
-0.0427582599,
-0.0148182176,
0.0257998686,
-0.0371399857,
-0.0152130751,
0.0215186179,
0.0341636091,
0.016139945,
0.0056479103,
-0.0038299332,
0.0372828059,
-0.0234172121,
-0.0290605407,
-0.0246399492,
0.0329775885,
-0.0235497504,
0.0394971631,
0.0212442297,
0.0122200605,
0.0102766752,
0.0188334249,
-0.0896887109,
0.0228803325,
-0.0147931818,
0.0350837857,
0.0032997688,
0.0126031861,
0.0217419416,
-0.0209826659,
-0.0253614262,
0.0427362323,
-0.0306484047,
-0.0424277596,
-0.0169704184,
-0.0225128923,
-0.0308414809,
0.0266124681,
-0.0111210849,
-0.0518425778,
-0.0026022561,
0.0071307733,
0.0646240637,
-0.0159419607,
0.0036532823,
0.054404635,
-0.0640057549,
0.0026135927,
0.0352472812,
-0.0531014651,
0.0070937094,
0.0116332518,
0.020103395,
-0.0084572546,
-0.0403954908,
-0.0075719561,
-0.0384008251,
-0.0240623001,
-0.0023843972,
0.0655047596,
0.0284905955,
0.0836743936,
0.0087054055,
0.0242439602,
0.0043511395,
0.010499659,
0.0037927406,
0.0106296772,
0.0102298586,
-0.0006026994,
-0.0410082042,
-0.0048169428,
-0.0390157737,
0.0191489663,
-0.0147904595,
-0.0654276982,
-0.0183177013,
-0.0014373907,
2.831e-7,
0.1465695947,
0.0378863849,
0.0079462109,
-0.0033863457,
0.0413198359,
-0.0027579202,
0.007533717,
0.0159650128,
-0.0201266035,
-0.0138269207,
-0.0004330337,
0.0413103551,
-0.0172005072,
0.0156026501,
-0.0526390225,
-0.0326284282,
-0.0271368176,
-0.0413332768,
-0.0230769049,
-0.0169067215,
0.0471894071,
0.070892185,
-0.0209221859,
-0.0314420164,
0.013913569,
-0.0522887222,
0.0527133159,
-0.0026469501,
-0.0116008287,
0.0216510184,
0.0344474725,
0.0150567088,
0.0096541941,
0.0777402297,
-0.0118969148,
-0.0036538851,
-0.0280860476,
0.0637136102,
-0.0702716336,
0.0066200844,
0.0503341332,
-0.0354374945,
0.0331775807,
-0.0407330468,
0.0796673894,
-0.0511200316,
-0.0473435037,
-0.0332057104,
-0.0114658978,
-0.0181379877,
0.008697737,
0.0011995351,
-0.0068836641,
0.0115743466,
0.0151196802,
-0.0109889302,
-0.0136505757,
-0.0765209645,
-0.0200746953,
0.0675257966,
-0.0180084687,
-0.0630608127,
-0.0070573259,
-0.0238883197,
0.0548706576,
-0.0988357365,
0.0146604721,
2.664436796e-34,
0.0123069622,
0.0348453,
-0.0134672122,
0.0311848801,
0.0251859948,
-0.0415190198,
-0.0247512106,
-0.0003081059,
0.0143895177,
-0.1327971071,
-0.002871932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13876v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13876v1 | Capture the Flag: Uncovering Data Insights with Large Language Models | 2023-12-21T14:20:06 | 2023-12-21T14:20:06 | Issam Laradji, Perouz Taslakian, Sai Rajeswar, Valentina Zantedeschi, Alexandre Lacoste, Nicolas Chapados, David Vazquez, Christopher Pal, Alexandre Drouin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | The extraction of a small number of relevant insights from vast amounts of
data is a crucial component of data-driven decision-making. However,
accomplishing this task requires considerable technical skills, domain
expertise, and human labor. This study explores the potential of using Large
Language Models (LLMs) to automate the discovery of insights in data,
leveraging recent advances in reasoning and code generation techniques. We
propose a new evaluation methodology based on a "capture the flag" principle,
measuring the ability of such models to recognize meaningful and pertinent
information (flags) in a dataset. We further propose two proof-of-concept
agents, with different inner workings, and compare their ability to capture
such flags in a real-world sales dataset. While the work reported here is
preliminary, our results are sufficiently interesting to mandate future
exploration by the community. | [
0.0128101902,
0.109951213,
-0.0398934223,
0.0343300886,
-0.0550020784,
0.0072624357,
-0.0227131415,
-0.0004750724,
0.0091445614,
-0.0393047743,
0.0234490708,
0.0027161387,
-0.0279797148,
0.0862448812,
-0.0250702333,
0.0167456232,
0.0027025477,
-0.0495519191,
0.0483203232,
0.0190753993,
-0.0229389481,
-0.0087473979,
0.030401228,
0.0181255359,
0.011513154,
-0.007609698,
-0.0228674803,
-0.0338215344,
0.0255242679,
-0.0228840951,
-0.0296791252,
0.0103475675,
0.0390374959,
0.0657474026,
0.0000020316,
-0.0776894912,
-0.0469303057,
0.0107969511,
-0.0515200458,
-0.0046444465,
0.0454477966,
-0.0096451454,
0.0035720489,
-0.0029934538,
-0.0553722642,
-0.0155385416,
0.0390110649,
0.0302785952,
0.0309670717,
0.0427815914,
-0.0161056835,
-0.0078780036,
-0.0105637573,
0.0091326302,
0.0025436895,
-0.0371996909,
0.0524309501,
0.0225358866,
0.0096125798,
-0.0168289375,
0.0061118114,
0.019272903,
-0.0082072373,
-0.0221679881,
-0.0444233455,
0.061922662,
-0.0388040468,
0.0373762064,
-0.0163755752,
0.0220756643,
-0.0247720256,
-0.0055730208,
0.0071326639,
-0.0023394038,
0.0071231066,
0.0106649986,
-0.0264088959,
0.0237982329,
-0.0054313354,
0.0269059353,
0.0155081954,
0.0054560425,
0.0233112331,
0.02684916,
-0.0730605051,
0.0932277292,
-0.0416787937,
-0.0244515128,
0.0117658284,
-0.0226964783,
-0.0042171818,
-0.0596492402,
-0.0224214792,
0.0673478097,
-0.0269840453,
0.0032023804,
0.0170305241,
0.0299165174,
-0.0014240678,
-0.0765351728,
0.029249873,
-0.0080583012,
-0.0032636854,
0.0705352128,
-0.0298548155,
0.0351870134,
-0.0080099069,
-0.0182013903,
-0.0177346766,
-0.0150076812,
-0.0449751131,
-0.0132190343,
-0.0216107927,
0.0394899994,
0.0021303652,
-0.0138107399,
-0.0261500217,
0.0148926387,
-0.0314680636,
0.0447990224,
-0.0604795851,
-0.0268951897,
0.017162364,
-0.0037148264,
-0.0562150665,
-0.0318774991,
-0.036530219,
0.0239488333,
-0.0142877642,
-0.0443516485,
0.040061634,
0.0197621007,
0.0089037018,
-0.0041593206,
0.0380967632,
0.0549249463,
0.0266360212,
0.0015246982,
-0.0803743601,
-0.0702389255,
0.0235915277,
-0.0755933076,
-0.0351445042,
-0.0665295199,
-0.018306002,
0.0197304673,
-0.0260648429,
-0.0326220393,
-0.003419131,
-0.0226112623,
0.0126283821,
0.065079838,
-0.0237782151,
0.042268645,
-0.0037778697,
-0.0169672631,
0.0145767024,
0.0813973248,
0.0204633903,
0.0647926554,
0.0427680276,
-0.0114097688,
0.0620356686,
0.0206131581,
-0.0247801803,
0.0031194773,
-0.0355175473,
0.0393494256,
-0.0243620053,
-0.022312928,
-0.0058722929,
-0.0021078202,
-0.0126028825,
0.0369684771,
0.0616056994,
0.053387519,
0.0178702548,
0.0168939326,
0.0364764519,
0.0263487846,
-0.0217206441,
-0.0625906885,
0.0333618186,
0.0025334707,
-0.0362130515,
-0.015920449,
-0.0384807885,
0.0260864198,
-0.0186846014,
-0.0530378893,
0.004473987,
-0.0035299589,
0.0299340431,
0.0487042852,
0.044940196,
-0.029772155,
0.0003307735,
0.0104851462,
-0.0050704349,
-0.0226064324,
-0.0313221291,
-0.0934993178,
0.0205334518,
0.0723145232,
0.0564760938,
-0.0629770607,
0.0134178558,
-0.002357237,
-0.0011381311,
-0.0040389742,
0.0220066216,
-0.0221554823,
-0.0302046351,
-0.0077811107,
-0.0136659397,
0.0122260768,
0.017182583,
0.0197680499,
-0.0017861922,
-0.002111332,
-0.0225434825,
-0.0212269668,
-0.0318613537,
0.0208196789,
0.0351892598,
-0.0205041468,
0.0164547861,
0.0347631834,
0.0290067457,
0.0000219898,
-0.0047727097,
0.0216200668,
0.0408894345,
-0.0304643866,
-0.0369981378,
0.0065117837,
0.0678087249,
0.0357678346,
0.0254327767,
-0.0240668431,
-0.0233809073,
0.0237589944,
-0.0218661819,
0.0089722471,
0.0234612692,
-0.0488878563,
0.0289479531,
-0.0257862806,
0.0047617201,
-0.0414857157,
0.018128084,
-0.0230818819,
0.0842203274,
-0.0012759545,
0.0027981715,
0.0053093336,
-0.0356567465,
0.0196722709,
0.0070281224,
0.0353821442,
0.046197325,
-0.0044987695,
0.0457767136,
0.0359523967,
-0.008417231,
0.0165432338,
-0.0359454416,
-0.0533034764,
0.0081845205,
0.0146127585,
0.0016309313,
0.0021642088,
-0.0023358027,
-0.0236729775,
0.0221077837,
-0.0224281885,
0.0078430483,
0.0171657465,
0.0161343757,
0.063857764,
0.0270730071,
-0.0876373053,
-0.0024322446,
-0.0051653692,
-0.0210387278,
0.0469963215,
0.0554586388,
0.0150991445,
-0.0768612027,
-0.0000507075,
-0.0223371536,
0.0034151312,
-0.0189808533,
-0.0296048056,
-0.0095616346,
-0.0558630936,
-0.023216622,
0.0668930188,
-0.0293552205,
0.0298246332,
0.0532360114,
-0.0360410027,
-0.0353648104,
-0.0060824575,
-0.0570008643,
0.0120159909,
-0.0317207947,
-0.0101288278,
0.0382756107,
0.0283180419,
-0.0091990912,
-0.0255646072,
-0.0215494242,
0.0481715053,
0.0028555752,
-0.0170363206,
-0.0523293018,
-0.0053570946,
0.0105096968,
0.1343333125,
0.0059882491,
-0.0700135455,
0.0586524084,
0.015623522,
0.0119272675,
-0.0290482584,
-0.0364098065,
-0.0965410024,
0.0633841604,
-0.0245097894,
0.0239815786,
-0.0256339964,
-0.0236968957,
0.0171970986,
-0.0115442118,
-0.0025325583,
-0.0306770429,
0.1129951105,
-0.0562826581,
0.0044195722,
0.0069762748,
-0.0461980216,
-0.0376503989,
-0.0460220464,
-0.0443173796,
0.0142967869,
0.038994547,
-0.0242340565,
-0.0790753812,
-0.0004904553,
0.0312168635,
0.0185909476,
0.0038297845,
-0.0405201651,
-0.0066082408,
-0.0496034957,
0.0092008132,
-0.0227021873,
0.0388304777,
-0.012382309,
0.0716891438,
0.0204276014,
-0.0025953711,
0.031343136,
-0.0593789443,
0.0259982925,
0.0084955776,
-0.0311546642,
0.0522391312,
0.0441129655,
-0.0067483229,
-0.0477991439,
-0.0048541203,
0.0946827009,
0.018344745,
-0.0070639262,
0.0275749024,
-0.024263965,
0.0027042397,
0.0318457298,
0.0504649505,
-0.0565194339,
-0.017458681,
-0.0069491179,
0.010970938,
-0.0251177624,
-0.0694533512,
-0.0159166753,
-0.118361406,
0.0844605044,
-0.0051385621,
-0.006744998,
-0.0831914917,
-0.0671368688,
-0.0100176735,
-0.0442454256,
-0.0387549512,
0.0104140686,
-0.0001280444,
-0.0289877951,
-0.0037740937,
-0.0117133725,
-0.0540120713,
0.0718582049,
-0.0132675497,
-0.0183191579,
0.0893816799,
0.0657455027,
-0.0203590114,
0.003535954,
-0.0442771241,
0.046480719,
0.0117817316,
0.0126724821,
0.0531308092,
0.0156248799,
-0.0099803293,
-0.0077881259,
0.041271124,
-0.0456001908,
0.0187864527,
0.0485312864,
0.0873497054,
-0.0021128915,
-0.0445602462,
0.0095162112,
-0.0131514315,
0.0235973727,
0.068143487,
-0.0031977647,
-0.0487195477,
-0.0158580132,
-0.0395483337,
-0.0212216061,
-0.0188332628,
-0.0624228232,
0.024733888,
0.0146550722,
-0.0417668112,
-0.0374115855,
-0.0260678791,
0.0704529732,
0.0121968063,
0.0264047738,
0.032606218,
0.003723236,
0.0122765927,
-0.0357800312,
-0.0185818411,
-0.0448670052,
0.0614501834,
-0.0416098312,
0.0085783694,
0.0092430422,
-0.0592068024,
-0.0350545011,
-0.0201315675,
-0.0516443662,
-0.0466985889,
0.0217147041,
0.012071589,
0.0352804214,
0.006095455,
-0.0068943226,
-0.0395522341,
-0.0173974074,
0.0673029125,
-0.0408935137,
-0.045901306,
0.018123256,
0.0169554409,
0.0350017175,
0.030999016,
-0.0400247909,
0.043954581,
0.0121185472,
-0.0266894959,
-0.0599625409,
0.0102193831,
0.0580282994,
0.0393643044,
0.0072738212,
0.0075003956,
-0.0430946238,
-0.0196371451,
0.0024622269,
0.0052055181,
-0.0456118472,
-0.0519335046,
-0.0018684426,
0.014658249,
-0.0084227649,
0.0176020712,
0.034961924,
0.006847898,
-0.0251636934,
-0.0298855063,
0.0428421646,
-0.0103440182,
0.0656544268,
0.0532791167,
-0.0229614154,
-0.0051884963,
0.0012906652,
-0.000086164,
0.0373748355,
0.015281246,
0.053086251,
0.0298398864,
-0.0077616624,
-0.0320377946,
-0.0106209898,
-0.0407461748,
-0.066923894,
0.038082324,
0.0238466673,
0.0314262845,
0.0062795491,
-0.0067549562,
-0.0674498975,
-0.0024692728,
0.0039126389,
0.0117637878,
0.0059135118,
-0.0306128133,
0.0162360128,
0.0326504745,
-0.0474624075,
-0.0510346331,
0.060374558,
-0.0206049588,
0.0299184974,
-0.0266774278,
-0.0616393723,
-0.0620131418,
-0.0158464946,
0.0626690835,
-0.0330396369,
-0.0034407498,
0.0331302322,
-0.0982528254,
-0.0297452286,
-0.0184740257,
0.0283713657,
0.0232590809,
-0.0105373999,
-0.0098269349,
0.0638796017,
0.0139056938,
0.000586659,
-0.0883585662,
-0.0217529032,
-0.0382488295,
0.010210529,
-0.0221027508,
-5.938067753e-33,
-0.0022330682,
-0.032850828,
0.0271443781,
0.0041631744,
0.0285026804,
0.0077515747,
-0.0265052803,
-0.0118400399,
0.0113886371,
0.0146860918,
0.008835189,
-0.0142964981,
0.0035809244,
-0.016043501,
0.0321366824,
-0.0101235034,
0.029793648,
0.0156820659,
-0.0377780125,
0.0062143933,
0.0130653335,
-0.019565044,
0.0048136986,
-0.0451005213,
0.0122688599,
-0.0024964919,
-0.0192269851,
0.0514004044,
-0.0203747209,
0.070547998,
0.0056906636,
0.0144768106,
0.0071804756,
-0.0356129296,
-0.0276011117,
0.0209626574,
-0.0016764471,
-0.0184999704,
0.001770015,
0.003345605,
0.0335709304,
-0.0135012595,
0.0126010356,
-0.0007816779,
-0.0165212899,
0.0141632836,
0.0375559591,
-0.0654758662,
0.0281516407,
-0.0357522927,
-0.0728035718,
0.0354148597,
-0.023210682,
0.0021419101,
0.0734919012,
0.0200069826,
-0.0157197453,
0.012627515,
-0.0171753149,
0.0671236366,
0.094633773,
0.0015569009,
0.0433584675,
0.0184960477,
0.021066511,
0.056663204,
0.0237918273,
0.014888851,
0.0042070495,
0.0199126322,
-0.0112052066,
0.0946738869,
0.0093928752,
0.0320709683,
0.024331389,
0.0318556912,
-0.0781447366,
0.0377149247,
0.0002159168,
-0.00550575,
0.0526364818,
-0.0016877932,
-0.0855816901,
-0.0222893152,
-0.0296472963,
0.0367257558,
-0.029686721,
-0.007281593,
0.0284358058,
0.0071282075,
-0.0454391167,
0.0125185894,
0.0312816054,
-0.0528026707,
-0.0622700304,
0.0176514052,
-0.0114075076,
0.0101098455,
0.0021406331,
-0.0139956493,
-0.0364093669,
-0.0112905242,
-0.0092388112,
-0.0179548096,
0.0335481316,
-0.0038826987,
-0.0018186212,
0.0573460087,
-0.0425255969,
-0.0005342099,
-0.0245917067,
0.0061290949,
-0.0062990766,
-0.0206630714,
0.0138290338,
-0.0004507973,
0.0146862818,
0.0179608967,
0.021071963,
-0.0454730876,
-0.0088900654,
0.0398923047,
-0.0054475875,
0.011478059,
-0.0186906848,
-0.0244620815,
-0.0441402718,
-0.0233181641,
0.0618319735,
-0.0389607139,
-0.0200283471,
0.0341675952,
2.745e-7,
0.0182539821,
0.0504724532,
-0.0323557332,
0.0745199025,
0.0052803149,
0.0664273351,
-0.0291373748,
-0.0290171113,
0.0329426676,
-0.0082966983,
0.042044308,
0.0231997613,
0.0275871605,
0.0474723056,
-0.0465442166,
0.0125696566,
0.0210568607,
-0.0417392291,
-0.0845798925,
-0.0196124185,
0.0315064304,
0.0625847057,
0.0282349866,
-0.0129807563,
0.027414877,
-0.0487184823,
-0.0013517691,
-0.0762455985,
0.0308858156,
0.0611411072,
-0.0134745901,
0.0171427298,
-0.0056736185,
0.0385600515,
0.0067833615,
0.0381016284,
-0.0216120277,
0.0608754717,
0.0195581876,
0.0352981798,
0.0029540835,
-0.0497775488,
-0.0159390625,
-0.0436589867,
0.0606581643,
-0.057017263,
-0.075162299,
-0.0315243937,
0.0155695481,
-0.0332584009,
-0.0381894633,
-0.0318140909,
-0.0001003884,
-0.0009291538,
-0.0328464657,
-0.0282232612,
0.0383670069,
-0.0215048734,
0.0338085964,
0.0108016245,
-0.0437858589,
-0.0344863981,
-0.0039656549,
0.0150842583,
0.012697584,
-0.0306504369,
0.0401165262,
2.680270842e-34,
0.0280031413,
0.0167226885,
-0.0121048801,
0.0321246423,
0.0791197792,
0.0206382163,
-0.0223725922,
0.0127610276,
0.0337841995,
-0.0565942861,
-0.0098572234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13871v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13871v2 | Evaluating Task-oriented Dialogue Systems: A Systematic Review of Measures, Constructs and their Operationalisations | 2023-12-21T14:15:46 | 2024-04-08T07:36:48 | Anouck Braggaar, Christine Liebrecht, Emiel van Miltenburg, Emiel Krahmer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | This review gives an extensive overview of evaluation methods for
task-oriented dialogue systems, paying special attention to practical
applications of dialogue systems, for example for customer service. The review
(1) provides an overview of the used constructs and metrics in previous work,
(2) discusses challenges in the context of dialogue system evaluation and (3)
develops a research agenda for the future of dialogue system evaluation. We
conducted a systematic review of four databases (ACL, ACM, IEEE and Web of
Science), which after screening resulted in 122 studies. Those studies were
carefully analysed for the constructs and methods they proposed for evaluation.
We found a wide variety in both constructs and methods. Especially the
operationalisation is not always clearly reported. Newer developments
concerning large language models are discussed in two contexts: to power
dialogue systems and to use in the evaluation process. We hope that future work
will take a more critical approach to the operationalisation and specification
of the used constructs. To work towards this aim, this review ends with
recommendations for evaluation and suggestions for outstanding questions. | [
0.0781543925,
-0.0247869939,
-0.0334095098,
0.0517193712,
-0.0357716978,
0.0165990889,
0.04005263,
-0.0444300994,
0.0130554447,
-0.0276021976,
-0.0774715543,
-0.053448759,
-0.0061162258,
0.0666648522,
0.0093678255,
-0.0682360679,
0.0449021347,
-0.0260639936,
0.0435186289,
0.0287497062,
0.0423404314,
-0.0060513811,
-0.0559775345,
0.0582304224,
0.0259734895,
-0.0193420723,
-0.045316834,
-0.0178546105,
0.021273734,
-0.0258582998,
-0.004342691,
0.0207225271,
0.0190651342,
0.0282593071,
0.0000021533,
-0.0960522816,
0.0321768709,
0.0118793305,
-0.0720770657,
0.000053526,
0.0272009019,
0.0565493889,
-0.0128934747,
0.0293269716,
-0.0253974609,
-0.0104268622,
0.038946446,
0.0390099138,
0.0587401874,
0.0399248004,
-0.0021113018,
-0.0019116295,
-0.0235733073,
0.021181399,
-0.0296871867,
-0.0726537704,
-0.0125724161,
0.0670235157,
0.046584636,
0.0192589257,
0.0445948876,
0.0164379291,
0.0148336114,
-0.0825722218,
-0.0216298718,
-0.0117073013,
-0.0332432799,
-0.0407918058,
-0.046527572,
0.0615437441,
0.0793083534,
0.0330360606,
-0.0366292223,
-0.0159733258,
0.0250468813,
-0.032548584,
-0.0626404434,
-0.020668814,
-0.0069438079,
-0.0230243355,
-0.0411626883,
0.0476920158,
-0.0251659267,
0.0075761937,
0.0146694109,
0.054179363,
-0.0115403505,
-0.0310602766,
-0.0052065095,
-0.0250769798,
0.025205614,
-0.0572089776,
-0.0180489421,
0.042464219,
-0.1117810309,
0.0084815118,
0.033335574,
-0.0165694505,
0.0353940502,
-0.0708888248,
0.0633707866,
0.0090312818,
0.0155213932,
0.0346486941,
0.0543247685,
0.0692973211,
0.0091699827,
-0.0045581581,
-0.0217215009,
-0.0092862798,
-0.0727794394,
-0.0045297109,
-0.060014423,
0.0366862714,
-0.0509389453,
-0.0424244367,
-0.000800324,
0.061712075,
-0.0143166073,
0.005075343,
0.001152036,
0.0147857284,
-0.0176583938,
0.0026139708,
-0.0760917366,
0.0167174097,
-0.010800791,
0.0410413072,
-0.0081207696,
-0.0285997484,
0.0487914495,
0.0261829626,
-0.0049486798,
0.0155262975,
-0.0256533381,
0.0691120178,
-0.0067795822,
-0.0211418606,
-0.0051205261,
-0.0145079382,
-0.031650804,
-0.067119427,
-0.0559773296,
-0.030117387,
0.0016815873,
0.013604342,
-0.0231664144,
0.038392365,
0.0233883243,
0.0183934961,
0.0010786236,
0.0296186134,
-0.0249872804,
0.0344996229,
0.0486537814,
0.0118653569,
-0.0096149268,
0.0481722131,
0.0485107042,
0.0072776815,
0.0367029123,
0.0038486135,
-0.0094358483,
0.0033731051,
-0.056947086,
0.0014141342,
0.0579385757,
0.0754044876,
-0.0512969345,
0.0086178184,
-0.0502046347,
0.0932001024,
-0.0264906138,
0.0294456519,
0.0455018133,
0.0224532299,
0.010235087,
-0.0081957839,
0.0319791064,
0.0238458272,
0.0280040335,
-0.0151963271,
0.0378509723,
0.0173595622,
0.0198244192,
-0.0016775216,
0.0603948757,
-0.003362831,
-0.0228709653,
-0.0832632929,
0.0047834902,
0.0275491849,
0.0084392335,
0.0306900311,
0.0296115689,
0.0005784874,
-0.0273476858,
-0.0084058642,
-0.0312134624,
-0.0426395163,
-0.0226397961,
-0.0512548909,
-0.0093001677,
0.0867732763,
0.051735118,
-0.0044612889,
-0.0715162605,
-0.0181717928,
0.0027698358,
0.0601773113,
0.0442694612,
-0.0320766494,
0.0036113467,
-0.0275689475,
-0.0190153532,
0.0094147436,
-0.0209521875,
-0.0146405613,
-0.0525259264,
-0.0234909803,
0.0056947917,
0.0272903219,
-0.0489621088,
-0.016807789,
0.0154161723,
-0.0114409318,
-0.0114831207,
0.016303828,
0.037674997,
0.0765655786,
-0.0108824819,
0.0303429179,
0.0097295502,
0.0100313881,
0.0037276838,
0.0432909578,
-0.0292692501,
0.0063454262,
0.0093171159,
-0.0074043637,
0.0106417276,
0.0272435658,
0.009706541,
-0.0638630986,
0.0080941198,
-0.0711021721,
-0.0006169354,
-0.022977706,
0.037243057,
-0.0281654485,
-0.0316776782,
-0.0331617631,
-0.0053006406,
0.0310169347,
0.0292099714,
0.0486866944,
0.0184979085,
0.0716819465,
-0.0549127273,
-0.0456856824,
0.0103855124,
0.0048372606,
0.0098098889,
0.0408878922,
-0.0019186933,
-0.0548749454,
-0.0130701093,
-0.1352855265,
-0.0139286462,
-0.0147514632,
0.0334124528,
0.0048880153,
0.017786378,
0.0011491077,
-0.0076676877,
-0.0281112939,
0.0003167543,
0.0607646592,
0.0141164539,
0.031252224,
0.042976547,
-0.0351488665,
-0.0328760445,
0.0107045248,
0.0133690685,
0.0240517966,
0.0337039828,
-0.0109178079,
-0.0528667122,
0.0276563056,
-0.0376524739,
-0.0203950889,
0.009689711,
-0.0351870395,
0.0665408894,
0.0648217946,
0.035657607,
0.0093887905,
0.037018504,
-0.003205671,
-0.0542140603,
-0.0509911403,
-0.041456826,
0.0056989822,
-0.0186210014,
-0.0290915128,
-0.0395890698,
-0.0237438846,
0.040437296,
-0.0019783527,
0.0106565533,
0.0208405126,
-0.0285551678,
-0.0020772705,
-0.0270103421,
-0.0353246592,
-0.0345437936,
-0.031194739,
-0.0489556715,
0.0459236801,
-0.0014017868,
-0.0134339817,
0.0429306552,
-0.0271265805,
-0.0104921171,
-0.0711359233,
-0.0413376763,
-0.0651665553,
0.0418164209,
-0.0471293591,
0.0174343381,
0.057964351,
-0.0362636857,
-0.0260749459,
-0.0097757867,
0.0028279163,
-0.0226917155,
0.0360762477,
-0.046853818,
0.0019388213,
0.0004797805,
-0.0254777055,
-0.035682749,
-0.0043708044,
-0.016773412,
0.0376012474,
0.0646888316,
-0.0086877793,
0.0116898017,
0.0500995889,
0.0249148756,
0.0128159812,
0.0106477486,
-0.0219635759,
-0.0271861907,
-0.0040438497,
0.0237600747,
0.0316875204,
0.0410474688,
0.0445743576,
0.0641137213,
0.014497173,
0.0693951398,
-0.0355164707,
-0.0238180384,
-0.0372707583,
0.0093209222,
-0.0163084231,
-0.0148219503,
0.0140152741,
0.0514776893,
-0.023878362,
-0.0067389109,
0.0918377638,
0.0269187707,
-0.0174503308,
-0.0223631151,
-0.0346806906,
-0.0311113317,
0.0135076335,
-0.0176015403,
-0.0568153113,
-0.0047843978,
-0.0102652395,
-0.0005656439,
-0.0287073683,
-0.0321338028,
-0.0034305723,
-0.0581123047,
0.035510987,
-0.0474315658,
0.0173617452,
-0.0242380612,
0.0167650599,
0.0284670237,
0.0184256881,
0.0493822917,
0.0401744246,
0.0057084188,
-0.0289164353,
0.0445243344,
-0.0297221038,
-0.0331766196,
0.0360700227,
-0.0234754719,
0.0766215622,
0.0593445189,
0.0280786492,
0.0303767771,
-0.0183967277,
0.0103709446,
0.0118964668,
-0.0122739691,
0.028452538,
-0.0079489732,
0.0149927819,
-0.0019059702,
-0.0527942255,
-0.0302359611,
0.0009413047,
0.0167167038,
0.0433014892,
0.0402672216,
-0.0604760088,
0.0488341413,
-0.0154805947,
0.0068513751,
0.0417340621,
0.0514748283,
0.0321373902,
-0.0388351269,
-0.0262656305,
-0.0017031677,
-0.0459609516,
-0.0280337092,
-0.0001265267,
-0.0042179981,
0.0058765784,
-0.0034703023,
-0.0521109998,
-0.0535442755,
0.0146130826,
0.026074592,
-0.0139759053,
0.0100491168,
0.0250367522,
0.0456210151,
0.0112092625,
-0.0227120686,
0.0099563925,
0.0543163829,
-0.0865101367,
-0.0042661605,
0.0246034712,
0.0177251212,
0.0035107068,
-0.0047280793,
-0.0594486073,
-0.0400391631,
-0.0326595046,
0.0461714938,
0.018207781,
-0.0592740141,
-0.0028598416,
-0.0437380746,
-0.0358395949,
-0.0168131646,
-0.0260352399,
-0.022387905,
0.0159077086,
0.0473163612,
0.0020924928,
0.0201070365,
-0.0395153537,
-0.0083473967,
-0.0650529861,
0.0472905859,
-0.0141058667,
-0.0643862262,
-0.0007192644,
0.0227371138,
0.0132540232,
0.0193194617,
-0.0404562876,
-0.0241647363,
0.0209566392,
-0.0435620807,
-0.03547002,
-0.070454888,
0.0130217336,
-0.0622913428,
0.0050735287,
0.0351577513,
0.0044676894,
-0.0766332299,
0.0231688321,
0.0109442296,
0.0311100129,
0.0163030047,
-0.0097464537,
-0.0218058061,
-0.0180086643,
-0.0262391418,
-0.0062167337,
0.0078786537,
0.0121837808,
0.0145060113,
0.0994021818,
0.0052190539,
-0.0248866696,
0.0264952313,
0.0640669614,
-0.0427148417,
-0.0538403578,
0.0144543257,
0.0230839998,
0.0088183964,
0.0622406043,
0.0267408416,
-0.031916175,
0.0282611959,
-0.0249386169,
0.0340126194,
0.0124856718,
-0.0144418115,
0.0187795386,
0.0309970994,
-0.0106337555,
-0.0102730179,
0.0395319574,
-0.0133640477,
-0.0467332192,
-0.0082575884,
-0.0082137706,
-0.0632319525,
-0.0354644433,
-0.0288336203,
0.0214701965,
-0.0177537017,
-0.0052110939,
-0.0765291303,
-0.0287688728,
-0.012536047,
0.0364160314,
0.0431407839,
-0.0397871695,
0.0523079857,
0.0507536493,
0.0246950556,
-0.0287711807,
-0.0415237062,
-0.0085372142,
-0.0406897031,
0.0327515528,
-0.0541605353,
-5.935901538e-33,
-0.0180227458,
-0.0352916345,
0.057769455,
0.0119683901,
-0.0168698709,
-0.0282238349,
-0.0072379583,
0.0382912531,
-0.0110774999,
0.0076215109,
0.0016767255,
-0.0142680937,
0.0065535242,
0.0063515753,
-0.0039853244,
-0.0310329441,
0.0321664512,
-0.0153558301,
-0.0185822118,
0.0360065661,
0.0459244736,
-0.0492116027,
0.0180063136,
-0.0727891549,
0.0919136256,
0.0034547783,
0.0021047848,
0.0280037653,
0.0251082256,
0.0601857975,
0.0099134408,
0.0833234191,
0.0365543254,
-0.0545150936,
-0.0109480042,
0.0576171614,
-0.0213161912,
-0.0137785701,
0.0592746735,
0.0126112914,
-0.0178130344,
0.0241321437,
-0.0272072274,
0.0017707346,
-0.0278920829,
0.0414106995,
-0.01316786,
-0.0189442802,
0.0069342703,
0.0002777236,
-0.0733876228,
0.0214468855,
-0.0202378277,
-0.0582311936,
-0.0060245534,
0.0533744767,
-0.0133959623,
-0.0709290579,
-0.0045356317,
0.0240700189,
0.0235297997,
-0.0312252697,
0.0474914573,
0.0437756069,
-0.0132244062,
0.0137326075,
-0.0164958872,
0.0395402052,
-0.005537943,
-0.0249771364,
-0.0159809943,
0.0359545499,
0.0403435528,
0.0341156051,
-0.0714976192,
0.0354021825,
-0.0429560952,
0.0282455795,
0.0157288481,
0.0573279411,
0.0374218971,
0.0084133865,
-0.0457476042,
-0.0183618329,
-0.0401068963,
0.0256659426,
-0.0224757008,
-0.0417723954,
0.0443196706,
-0.0081287576,
-0.007328013,
0.0032195488,
0.0464384072,
-0.0017998599,
-0.0157069638,
0.0292934906,
0.0086700832,
0.0188815147,
-0.0017574268,
-0.0251357611,
-0.0709955171,
0.0329000242,
0.0222137794,
0.0639234632,
0.0126502551,
-0.0257641915,
-0.0081124622,
-0.0096450411,
-0.0209395699,
0.0114927907,
-0.0385610424,
0.0426056497,
-0.0412046872,
0.0305206068,
-0.0147460755,
-0.0290076453,
-0.0380796231,
0.0992842838,
-0.0322399735,
-0.0572703443,
-0.0658364594,
-0.0141694713,
0.0076704542,
-0.0106591228,
-0.0437376425,
0.0213768184,
-0.0101010157,
0.009367411,
0.015457402,
0.026167497,
0.0117552262,
-0.0148718022,
2.771e-7,
0.0044901087,
0.0205105245,
0.0098884255,
0.055237364,
0.0094887353,
0.0549767315,
0.0269642975,
0.0153633067,
0.0342754647,
-0.0025437863,
-0.0017415268,
-0.0175113045,
0.0365947373,
0.012852028,
-0.0761528686,
-0.0725865737,
-0.049203001,
-0.0193382222,
-0.0352461338,
0.010320805,
0.0757556334,
0.0047714529,
-0.0226876568,
0.0220919568,
-0.0449725874,
-0.0232839249,
-0.0014606639,
-0.0280091986,
-0.0214542765,
0.0405942276,
0.0625652149,
-0.0046852464,
0.0387302488,
0.0095347231,
0.0163414367,
0.0481648035,
-0.0090423776,
0.0286841523,
-0.0131909922,
-0.06079771,
-0.0117098596,
-0.0485210456,
0.022388272,
-0.0498477966,
0.0135525409,
-0.0667994395,
-0.0193220265,
-0.0169003941,
0.0019435192,
-0.0194491725,
0.0281157121,
-0.0161891412,
-0.0452129357,
0.0214312356,
0.0030929036,
-0.0368747264,
0.0267900173,
-0.0500166379,
0.0357982665,
-0.0067466488,
-0.0095459847,
-0.0770209879,
-0.0215231441,
-0.0640048981,
-0.0290340539,
-0.0099744331,
0.0133777764,
1.811813091e-34,
0.0349637941,
-0.0133747775,
0.0535243973,
0.0444169007,
0.0556923933,
0.0474772751,
-0.0282392073,
-0.0067758942,
0.0390946008,
-0.0717559904,
-0.0070488108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13866v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13866v2 | Understanding Inter-Session Intentions via Complex Logical Reasoning | 2023-12-21T14:03:30 | 2024-06-14T07:47:47 | Jiaxin Bai, Chen Luo, Zheng Li, Qingyu Yin, Yangqiu Song | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Understanding user intentions is essential for improving product
recommendations, navigation suggestions, and query reformulations. However,
user intentions can be intricate, involving multiple sessions and attribute
requirements connected by logical operators such as And, Or, and Not. For
instance, a user may search for Nike or Adidas running shoes across various
sessions, with a preference for purple. In another example, a user may have
purchased a mattress in a previous session and is now looking for a matching
bed frame without intending to buy another mattress. Existing research on
session understanding has not adequately addressed making product or attribute
recommendations for such complex intentions. In this paper, we present the task
of logical session complex query answering (LS-CQA), where sessions are treated
as hyperedges of items, and we frame the problem of complex intention
understanding as an LS-CQA task on an aggregated hypergraph of sessions, items,
and attributes. This is a unique complex query answering task with sessions as
ordered hyperedges. We also introduce a new model, the Logical Session Graph
Transformer (LSGT), which captures interactions among items across different
sessions and their logical connections using a transformer structure. We
analyze the expressiveness of LSGT and prove the permutation invariance of the
inputs for the logical operators. By evaluating LSGT on three datasets, we
demonstrate that it achieves state-of-the-art results. | [
0.0477617607,
0.0016046424,
0.0005038957,
0.0220869873,
-0.0190793201,
-0.0330435,
-0.0062686289,
-0.0379312709,
0.0129922368,
-0.0371999219,
-0.0552821942,
-0.0151238516,
0.0029087865,
0.0312682427,
-0.0296892282,
-0.0348219797,
0.0313190781,
0.0015347577,
-0.0388547815,
0.0415545627,
0.024421595,
0.0411171839,
-0.0149786361,
0.0175353717,
0.0149337668,
-0.0282093491,
-0.044320032,
0.0183822252,
0.0040521785,
-0.0292666685,
0.008442617,
0.0251071546,
0.0096944943,
-0.0381418392,
0.0000021414,
-0.0346659459,
-0.0534265228,
-0.0400478318,
-0.0247680191,
-0.0559924506,
0.0140461028,
0.0398315564,
0.043988999,
0.0051803454,
-0.0521430485,
0.0084049646,
0.0028128007,
0.0917188823,
0.0263508819,
0.0336065628,
-0.0133968992,
-0.0246532597,
-0.0265716966,
0.0233647153,
0.0659437105,
-0.0274679027,
0.0315010697,
-0.018750865,
0.0157245956,
-0.0367585011,
0.0366855264,
-0.0260817166,
-0.0180625077,
0.0110080782,
0.022740433,
-0.0016295124,
-0.0140540563,
-0.0045892615,
0.0000556995,
0.098384425,
0.0061964416,
0.000810303,
0.009564749,
0.0362225324,
0.0054863556,
0.0393877402,
-0.0283179637,
-0.0368899107,
-0.030858418,
-0.0081389034,
0.0083421571,
0.0313226022,
0.0153671158,
-0.0000615512,
-0.0596887656,
0.108090505,
0.0091943135,
-0.0111694876,
-0.0196611285,
-0.0314220749,
-0.0194482617,
-0.0522502363,
0.0159382839,
0.0240774341,
-0.1279021949,
0.0386189222,
-0.0113188736,
0.0591194667,
-0.0285432842,
0.0055712531,
0.041315902,
0.0560390688,
0.0439164154,
0.0211550575,
0.005413536,
0.0110332724,
0.02082978,
0.0382175408,
-0.0853195488,
0.0084451027,
-0.0587149002,
0.0052644261,
-0.0359160043,
0.0241026804,
-0.0299392454,
-0.0241723508,
-0.0334771536,
0.0413748622,
-0.0052023777,
-0.0040111155,
0.0110915117,
0.0448984951,
-0.0290465169,
0.0044022356,
-0.0775011778,
0.0346185602,
-0.0565196611,
0.0437532179,
0.0076581142,
-0.017274294,
0.0153438887,
0.0237182975,
0.041884739,
-0.0528694578,
-0.0325697027,
0.03396938,
-0.0250872783,
0.0031296422,
-0.0649024248,
-0.1122966036,
0.0406037346,
-0.0334162004,
0.0132289715,
-0.0366938375,
0.0471674092,
0.0218521673,
-0.0078472169,
-0.0045079817,
-0.00129701,
0.0307171643,
-0.0001030062,
0.0764734149,
0.0587284118,
0.0032861982,
-0.0286434367,
0.0068742735,
-0.017133709,
0.0113473479,
-0.0186762046,
0.0826372579,
0.0102732228,
0.012015664,
0.0124981711,
-0.0037229205,
-0.0048154639,
-0.0251407996,
0.0122417761,
0.0441437438,
-0.0096849436,
0.0043750205,
-0.0311941653,
0.0417028666,
-0.0482469276,
-0.0082596308,
0.0340042002,
0.0213839002,
0.031965591,
-0.0085923951,
0.0135698048,
0.0091225142,
-0.0461834222,
0.0296650361,
-0.0176332239,
0.0692059025,
-0.0269782674,
-0.0453054644,
0.0152090127,
0.0091752093,
-0.0274689049,
-0.0504419021,
0.0488860421,
-0.0076764957,
0.1103964671,
0.0136985844,
0.0046019237,
-0.0089801559,
-0.0361711383,
0.0283306707,
-0.009137704,
-0.023466168,
-0.0104971956,
-0.0638322756,
0.0279557891,
0.1379054338,
0.0357354619,
-0.0190158449,
-0.0270775165,
0.0033367295,
-0.0009294813,
-0.0621113069,
0.0494089052,
-0.0238668825,
0.0098356986,
-0.0425742716,
-0.0678113848,
0.008966771,
-0.0122597618,
0.0216553081,
-0.0204436518,
-0.0191424992,
-0.0142925056,
-0.0045209574,
0.035490118,
-0.02273429,
0.0257453769,
0.028951766,
0.0169097967,
0.0558111258,
0.0257036071,
0.035718102,
0.0746624991,
0.0227215122,
0.0159630366,
-0.003152543,
-0.0503952093,
0.0398036093,
-0.0014529778,
-0.0126594324,
0.0327418596,
-0.0688157305,
-0.000303889,
-0.0143058775,
-0.0001734741,
-0.0561715476,
0.0222608708,
-0.0268907305,
0.07026501,
0.0047009955,
-0.0171142537,
0.0103654778,
-0.026314849,
-0.0231074616,
0.0628191829,
0.0207106918,
-0.0054928726,
0.0066474909,
-0.0460637212,
0.025458809,
-0.0269842669,
0.0127080129,
-0.0156088751,
0.006932159,
0.0305522811,
0.0224586278,
-0.0191710833,
-0.0469746962,
0.0168598909,
-0.0599328764,
0.0011251137,
-0.016383376,
0.0017490091,
0.018530149,
0.0423745662,
0.0381535143,
-0.0158189293,
-0.0433657691,
0.0547449514,
-0.0153658679,
0.0245402046,
0.0229686145,
0.0298537184,
-0.0535479598,
0.0075405366,
-0.0166630186,
-0.0458475314,
0.014014191,
0.0046402831,
0.015183229,
-0.0226253234,
-0.0111826165,
-0.046892982,
-0.0109888278,
-0.0012274955,
0.0155296139,
-0.0052593588,
-0.0499006175,
0.002534267,
0.0605975799,
0.0190385319,
-0.0050413227,
0.0290764216,
-0.0381851569,
-0.0604395829,
-0.0070290491,
-0.0291450266,
0.0238644294,
-0.0402807035,
-0.0569234267,
0.0343750492,
-0.0005344823,
-0.0223007295,
-0.004143558,
-0.0537512712,
-0.0275545307,
0.0218119379,
-0.0085648699,
-0.0026019791,
0.0270590745,
0.0306218453,
0.0947081074,
0.0167016238,
0.011841218,
0.0785066113,
0.0418433584,
0.009680382,
-0.0480309017,
-0.0042123324,
-0.0529560409,
0.0187451318,
0.0065432801,
0.0443193577,
-0.0102201914,
-0.0407949015,
-0.0688246638,
-0.0154951885,
0.0289685931,
-0.0480974019,
0.0607602783,
-0.021033423,
0.0158782061,
0.0272335168,
-0.0192423575,
-0.0180212464,
-0.058721602,
0.0013727862,
-0.0344764367,
0.0087540532,
-0.0430186763,
-0.0809319988,
-0.0110524045,
-0.0117145069,
-0.0071285609,
0.0123974979,
-0.0535236746,
-0.0012828698,
0.0046508522,
0.0729014277,
0.0416456982,
-0.0036953792,
0.0047418461,
-0.0073482716,
0.065194495,
-0.0086441543,
-0.0767985657,
-0.0014527268,
0.0079950513,
0.0334166922,
-0.0041174991,
0.0210168734,
0.042779576,
-0.014753974,
0.0083377669,
0.0254151579,
0.0578814708,
0.0585439093,
-0.0642275587,
0.0034044208,
0.002029099,
0.0276790187,
0.0330124162,
0.0271934159,
-0.1128427982,
-0.0351187401,
-0.011808496,
0.031429369,
0.0080884006,
-0.0376392044,
-0.005068325,
-0.0643314794,
-0.0104879094,
0.0039594849,
-0.0092792166,
0.0290222522,
-0.0542235263,
0.0105347866,
-0.0350568257,
0.0183707252,
-0.0181352533,
-0.0208172463,
-0.0088670617,
-0.0200302042,
0.0326594785,
-0.0223115236,
0.0481611565,
-0.0117079495,
0.0236059856,
0.0249456279,
0.0343824886,
0.0159162842,
-0.0517185852,
-0.0142556615,
0.0151713956,
-0.0186400954,
-0.0199622773,
-0.007994662,
0.0144429998,
0.0356068946,
-0.0360484645,
0.0274400674,
-0.076171726,
-0.0367604941,
-0.0026376683,
0.0659629554,
-0.0312764607,
0.0056086387,
-0.021486586,
-0.023648221,
0.0050711865,
0.0686770901,
-0.0135713061,
0.0005733829,
-0.0122089311,
-0.0831201971,
-0.0149923479,
-0.0160768088,
-0.0094098346,
0.0137788961,
-0.0089180442,
0.027254615,
-0.0407832935,
-0.0262919087,
0.0174141545,
0.0300396997,
-0.0027489099,
-0.0277612619,
0.0613054186,
-0.0001745957,
-0.0394524857,
0.0147779854,
-0.0068229223,
0.080272615,
-0.0212700367,
0.0446357094,
0.0154034849,
-0.0376053303,
-0.001065266,
-0.0280877315,
0.0424351245,
-0.0344439261,
-0.0446529165,
0.0266857147,
0.0295326579,
0.0468744822,
-0.020193385,
-0.011492651,
-0.061140433,
0.0163565911,
-0.0224989429,
-0.0572832711,
0.0343260579,
0.0504190624,
0.0050005112,
0.052446194,
-0.0494780354,
-0.0280902721,
-0.0319951214,
0.0384265482,
-0.0722358376,
-0.0182116311,
0.0800471902,
0.016092103,
-0.0120496592,
0.0496333502,
0.0500167422,
0.0077384319,
0.0378594697,
-0.0183106102,
-0.0568759218,
-0.0261138547,
-0.0133371893,
0.0317947976,
-0.0047448995,
-0.0126887085,
-0.0052927774,
0.0002250188,
0.0054429923,
-0.0373005345,
-0.0232856832,
-0.015211028,
-0.046312362,
0.0132049667,
-0.0115181329,
0.0092560602,
-0.0073533794,
0.0441836901,
0.0531141311,
-0.030676404,
0.0546821021,
0.0459352694,
-0.0285470225,
-0.0982787013,
0.0404762328,
-0.0445795879,
-0.0303675663,
0.0379003808,
-0.0338459648,
-0.0253245421,
-0.0110999411,
0.0206104312,
-0.0051643793,
-0.0133041451,
0.0004603118,
0.0483271964,
0.0098151937,
-0.0089172041,
0.0291920528,
0.0397933945,
0.0053403932,
-0.0420760736,
0.0500379615,
-0.0820293128,
0.0067163953,
-0.0343749374,
-0.0706240758,
-0.0481980518,
-0.0118496381,
-0.0155487908,
0.0414535776,
-0.0415370427,
-0.0294616185,
-0.0264933221,
-0.0130417487,
-0.0024176261,
-0.0323167481,
0.0369527601,
-0.027074445,
0.0660079867,
0.0684340447,
0.0273658223,
-0.0339273103,
-0.0158433914,
-0.0455163978,
-0.0285711568,
-0.011461121,
-0.0471175574,
-6.397943918e-33,
0.0172082335,
-0.0213289633,
0.0277192034,
-0.0092912717,
-0.0113845514,
-0.0426067375,
-0.0244058631,
-0.0087083234,
0.015196668,
-0.0048349719,
-0.0052995742,
-0.0089993263,
0.0239967443,
0.0089807613,
0.0287746694,
-0.0417167358,
0.027504487,
0.0288201068,
-0.0431152135,
0.0220067352,
0.0605452433,
-0.025151141,
-0.0063599367,
-0.0678704754,
-0.0062650316,
0.0024927116,
-0.0188993309,
0.0418366529,
-0.0333279036,
0.0482597984,
0.0199035611,
0.011694097,
0.0209163185,
-0.0252508782,
0.0294334851,
0.0416126773,
-0.0726109073,
-0.0252884459,
0.0546469688,
0.0429059081,
-0.0531634949,
0.0004050217,
0.014169421,
-0.0158684067,
0.040339902,
0.0041788118,
0.0087945769,
0.0051969714,
-0.0136826057,
-0.0020037128,
-0.0202086829,
-0.0254798084,
-0.0355997793,
-0.0236159824,
0.0215065908,
0.102393426,
-0.0163919814,
0.0007198098,
-0.0566108935,
0.0668801889,
-0.0910564288,
-0.0424510725,
0.0192298312,
0.0286410395,
-0.0198193882,
0.0408979058,
0.0305801816,
0.0126500465,
-0.0080770683,
0.0483826026,
-0.0398166738,
0.0824071318,
-0.0177836642,
-0.0187102556,
0.0147611042,
0.0347883925,
-0.0554108806,
0.0472915322,
0.0231019873,
0.0278887395,
0.0125147207,
0.0397944227,
-0.033424098,
-0.0433869176,
0.0014682424,
0.0382106192,
-0.0620932057,
-0.0242346916,
0.0089280596,
0.037998639,
-0.0497334413,
0.0468182229,
0.0257173982,
-0.0496590994,
-0.0643807873,
-0.0048936857,
0.0183531456,
-0.0116358325,
-0.0000461272,
0.0119304834,
0.0197051391,
-0.0179794654,
0.0176123548,
-0.0645526573,
-0.0002268001,
0.0409869775,
0.0329808742,
-0.0020170454,
-0.001941846,
-0.015172801,
-0.0203335844,
-0.035624668,
-0.0505917668,
-0.0150679164,
0.0772771686,
0.0550939515,
-0.0298863463,
0.0561303534,
0.0173765179,
0.0171859302,
-0.0557721779,
-0.0193844177,
0.012820649,
-0.0032323268,
-0.0205518585,
-0.0265398193,
-0.0460974798,
-0.0663604066,
0.0251276959,
-0.0464533344,
-0.0372609384,
-0.0113935322,
2.955e-7,
0.0065314383,
0.0054822559,
-0.0071179033,
0.0787506849,
-0.0244035963,
0.0352319628,
0.0146144573,
0.0241624378,
0.0193530452,
-0.0252927579,
0.0581811741,
0.0158369876,
-0.0037639679,
0.0293783117,
0.0003321118,
-0.0160057507,
0.0282823425,
-0.0645841509,
-0.0424541421,
0.0354706012,
0.0832754001,
0.062768504,
0.022010874,
0.0231051911,
0.0091755716,
-0.03918707,
0.0077281622,
-0.0054145567,
0.0057864096,
-0.0002924271,
0.0409376472,
-0.0104685007,
0.0148829184,
0.0253844056,
-0.0123785483,
0.0145752914,
0.0156644639,
0.0250314139,
-0.0119145848,
-0.0695375651,
-0.0110262632,
-0.0492133684,
0.0163482781,
-0.0036043907,
0.0801300481,
-0.0627763867,
-0.0076104505,
0.0405264832,
-0.0558710769,
0.0237474889,
-0.0077893864,
0.0112215793,
0.0120193902,
0.0070983623,
0.0354492031,
0.0266507734,
0.0177220702,
-0.0539642423,
0.0094624832,
0.0098989904,
-0.0247304291,
-0.0095103467,
-0.0210788697,
0.0717658773,
-0.0073373965,
-0.0153805949,
-0.0190668274,
2.685929287e-34,
0.0549786575,
0.0450292379,
0.0066206139,
0.0126844598,
0.0678806901,
-0.0414322689,
-0.066320926,
0.0118704988,
0.056297265,
-0.1017129645,
-0.0249699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13816v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13816v1 | Team Flow at DRC2023: Building Common Ground and Text-based Turn-taking in a Travel Agent Spoken Dialogue System | 2023-12-21T13:08:09 | 2023-12-21T13:08:09 | Ryu Hirai, Shinya Iizuka, Haruhisa Iseno, Ao Guo, Jingjing Jiang, Atsumoto Ohashi, Ryuichiro Higashinaka | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.RO | At the Dialogue Robot Competition 2023 (DRC2023), which was held to improve
the capability of dialogue robots, our team developed a system that could build
common ground and take more natural turns based on user utterance texts. Our
system generated queries for sightseeing spot searches using the common ground
and engaged in dialogue while waiting for user comprehension. | [
0.049719885,
0.0162337162,
-0.0128016351,
0.0134193953,
-0.0295064282,
-0.0288574584,
-0.0139082354,
-0.0282234866,
-0.015839519,
-0.0201026052,
-0.0265518874,
-0.0116866436,
-0.0079937708,
0.0349749625,
-0.0211732257,
-0.1107582599,
0.0178152807,
-0.0658745542,
0.0000622804,
0.0098823588,
-0.0077448287,
0.0153751541,
-0.0732220784,
0.062879242,
0.0054120766,
0.0029122145,
-0.0468910113,
0.0074353078,
0.0446212701,
-0.0537856221,
-0.0407378487,
0.0125324829,
0.0643261895,
0.0382479466,
0.0000017227,
-0.0198090058,
0.0080656167,
-0.0168907046,
-0.046711646,
-0.074259229,
-0.0127841271,
0.0844886154,
0.0329154208,
0.0218715798,
-0.0241167843,
-0.0020107888,
0.0304822698,
0.0529112443,
0.0541527718,
0.0614371784,
0.0102929669,
0.0005699189,
-0.0381276645,
0.0169720817,
-0.0008101712,
-0.1133058444,
-0.0301861279,
0.0127637619,
0.068425335,
-0.0062529915,
-0.0162814967,
0.0041739591,
0.0076446896,
-0.0315408632,
-0.0153558776,
0.0638784617,
-0.091569148,
-0.0400994681,
-0.0290805958,
0.0982378051,
0.0670513138,
0.0096932668,
-0.0042257514,
0.0074503934,
0.0048724799,
0.0070626708,
0.003709493,
-0.006623751,
-0.0348167755,
-0.0112714041,
-0.0877010971,
0.0148648517,
-0.0171452183,
0.0056785122,
-0.0303461384,
0.0873183459,
-0.0016638291,
-0.0215951148,
0.0052691605,
0.0213841926,
0.0487674735,
-0.0566377901,
0.0550364666,
0.0509756021,
-0.0816339925,
0.0224319845,
0.0062583219,
0.0580558628,
-0.0283444338,
-0.0319157578,
-0.0157654192,
0.0311695524,
-0.0299431086,
0.0451755337,
0.0482538678,
0.0505521856,
-0.0168068837,
0.0258314013,
-0.0229223035,
-0.0284026824,
-0.027869001,
0.0443089716,
-0.1086566448,
0.0062587303,
-0.0691215098,
-0.0209967569,
0.0289925132,
0.0557964928,
0.0368966684,
0.0236215461,
-0.0044261171,
0.0251138154,
-0.0082911374,
-0.0193821471,
-0.0279649626,
0.0278896149,
-0.0209550411,
0.0027886017,
0.0169590469,
-0.0048787827,
0.0003560022,
0.0377649888,
0.0243029986,
-0.0137912212,
-0.0390979908,
0.0535921827,
0.0014358836,
-0.0258980952,
-0.0050542555,
-0.014060447,
0.005679402,
-0.0876424685,
-0.0190625321,
-0.0101424288,
0.037318062,
0.0162858926,
-0.012556293,
0.0180672165,
0.0268584788,
0.0292365029,
-0.0165820289,
0.0673175976,
0.0042563789,
0.0171527863,
0.0478620753,
0.014620807,
0.0040362556,
0.0162035972,
0.0429871231,
0.0650798827,
0.0433811024,
0.0085023511,
0.020121647,
0.003968942,
-0.021967439,
-0.019913977,
0.0677873194,
0.0351759493,
-0.0106117139,
0.0543361902,
-0.0364866816,
0.0474479608,
-0.0318270139,
0.0438912734,
0.0445094071,
0.0442810282,
-0.0188649166,
-0.0511900224,
0.0355913714,
-0.0008515457,
-0.0202005822,
-0.0147391073,
-0.01600435,
0.0175776724,
0.0115162311,
0.0120209279,
0.030427251,
0.0269646272,
-0.0347528048,
-0.019587351,
0.0113645494,
0.0294220243,
0.0788685307,
0.0203342587,
0.0304468889,
-0.0135787567,
-0.0672530234,
-0.0170567073,
-0.0281937029,
-0.0741357431,
-0.0039147963,
0.0074963197,
-0.0107556758,
0.0614103675,
0.0088301767,
0.0269359238,
-0.017017914,
-0.0170827266,
0.0176235475,
0.0479632095,
0.0468722135,
-0.0146495737,
0.0339453183,
-0.0558619238,
-0.0351153053,
0.0639980584,
-0.0292345881,
0.0216189288,
-0.0271684024,
0.0613527298,
0.0014092089,
-0.0205413513,
0.0435030796,
0.0031950325,
0.0407667831,
0.0134571055,
-0.0151104331,
0.0406034701,
0.0279276967,
0.0443261936,
-0.0422509573,
-0.0249665175,
0.04361628,
0.030170612,
-0.0093217967,
0.1019429043,
-0.0144815557,
-0.0237877164,
-0.0006559383,
-0.0565981716,
-0.0792751983,
0.023871379,
0.0045148479,
-0.0307448041,
-0.0147027969,
-0.054565452,
0.0326130353,
0.0174877737,
0.0497844331,
0.0327543244,
0.0004358943,
-0.0193660595,
0.0149140283,
0.0033849017,
0.0027346509,
0.0319448225,
0.024419561,
0.0453733094,
-0.0775223374,
0.001744637,
0.0552481115,
0.0427756496,
-0.0047923122,
0.0342271887,
0.0176896416,
-0.0391666554,
0.0227598064,
-0.0790124759,
-0.0338044502,
-0.0113971988,
-0.015274181,
0.0002540101,
0.0018494215,
-0.0095241638,
-0.030348707,
-0.0092025623,
0.0013591467,
0.0317840762,
-0.0211521108,
0.0259303153,
0.0195026938,
-0.0615814477,
-0.0125564989,
0.0444613509,
0.0002306258,
-0.0087292856,
0.0351925641,
-0.0105610732,
-0.0684286803,
-0.015803827,
-0.0356054865,
0.0167949907,
-0.0054113371,
-0.048346743,
0.0585029684,
0.0037999877,
-0.0208513979,
0.0199177284,
0.0408187881,
-0.016224755,
0.0269721262,
-0.0454591066,
-0.0353035443,
0.0446575806,
-0.0009173132,
0.0331802107,
-0.0293300897,
0.0006961263,
0.0280028172,
-0.0150471656,
0.0008258908,
0.0589512587,
-0.0544075631,
-0.0552530661,
0.0276961904,
-0.0802064985,
0.0174873602,
0.0154451141,
-0.0576174483,
0.0347243696,
-0.0146845449,
-0.0020282189,
0.0546269752,
-0.0299806464,
-0.0566144288,
-0.0595149733,
-0.0097430181,
-0.0167761929,
0.0551700257,
-0.0450801961,
0.0383559801,
-0.0033729638,
-0.0597138442,
0.0122814151,
-0.0349018537,
-0.0161917582,
-0.0208577868,
0.0478213616,
-0.0523514412,
0.0035906592,
0.0282850005,
-0.0340078175,
-0.0201497637,
0.0316191986,
-0.0312615186,
-0.018023869,
0.0435911678,
-0.0745791495,
-0.0160800777,
0.0524827465,
0.0333511978,
0.0289186314,
0.029561311,
-0.0071128705,
-0.0005981025,
-0.0091655832,
0.0334902294,
0.1012052521,
-0.0114279194,
0.0289652422,
0.0238324888,
0.0308545996,
0.077620402,
-0.0415478759,
-0.001030539,
0.000885669,
0.0402616784,
-0.0066065965,
-0.0152782639,
0.0185909439,
0.045256786,
-0.0210016239,
-0.0227255262,
0.0653307661,
0.014780011,
-0.0594551452,
-0.0125877252,
-0.0304587092,
-0.007731311,
0.0109119043,
0.0151958512,
-0.0333525762,
-0.0015328581,
0.0008481609,
0.0127564324,
0.0002185952,
-0.0219845995,
-0.0280051138,
-0.0986271873,
0.0510970056,
-0.0099805212,
-0.0340134427,
-0.0574951023,
-0.0307771433,
0.0179411694,
0.006924035,
0.0193199888,
0.0125129698,
-0.0026706806,
-0.0230532661,
0.0066156471,
-0.007484206,
0.023470575,
0.0046426523,
-0.0443813056,
0.0357023925,
0.0473161936,
0.0876411125,
0.0299960226,
-0.0508236289,
-0.0558547303,
-0.0054966211,
0.0564079098,
-0.0409072675,
0.0272644069,
-0.0567012839,
-0.0223394539,
-0.0028639534,
0.0306519996,
-0.0300437454,
-0.0076155672,
0.011794555,
0.0294426773,
-0.075541757,
0.0435587093,
-0.0172862187,
0.0573604032,
0.0325639136,
0.0279079806,
-0.0135363471,
-0.0193017609,
-0.0387488492,
-0.029283544,
0.0028699993,
-0.0451573022,
-0.0462359153,
-0.0163756218,
0.0140988929,
-0.0011021408,
-0.0603586733,
-0.0676705465,
0.05507458,
0.0601510219,
-0.0219443981,
0.0091133025,
-0.0197935663,
0.0780248716,
0.0131739406,
-0.0150244394,
-0.0299023744,
0.0433987267,
-0.0657552332,
-0.0088721989,
0.0022616361,
-0.0453898944,
-0.0189770833,
0.0283433273,
0.0040016999,
-0.0724468306,
0.0209979266,
0.0073131868,
0.0226363968,
0.0201709904,
0.0023023761,
-0.0022863818,
-0.0098150522,
-0.0157700293,
-0.0302912686,
0.0015551384,
0.0199909508,
0.0660670996,
-0.0354201235,
0.0160342995,
-0.058702521,
-0.0459077284,
-0.041736681,
0.0585509129,
-0.0860864669,
-0.0778147131,
0.0249133073,
0.011899922,
0.0429981202,
0.0261579081,
0.0364560708,
-0.0161942001,
0.0435160659,
0.0001901419,
-0.0142751969,
-0.0389696546,
-0.014782506,
-0.0473158509,
-0.0206011385,
0.0286283698,
0.0262901504,
-0.0633132979,
0.0093904482,
0.0062232977,
0.0037022918,
0.0561795346,
0.0230872184,
-0.0070239757,
0.0045543164,
0.0325374417,
0.011611687,
-0.0087035224,
0.0251421221,
0.0442075916,
0.0804660618,
0.0413213223,
-0.0333875492,
-0.0003237638,
0.0529373288,
-0.0817773342,
-0.0671046972,
0.0269376729,
0.0162782446,
0.0620360151,
0.0317912586,
-0.0121086063,
-0.0267077312,
0.0420303158,
0.0055166646,
-0.0015040427,
-0.0082299951,
-0.0339210294,
0.0438073501,
0.0043810625,
-0.0012405551,
0.0079414006,
0.0345408693,
-0.0213071927,
0.0417638272,
0.0179099105,
-0.0194209274,
-0.0560625605,
-0.0430681035,
-0.0056897234,
-0.0007352351,
-0.0244787447,
0.0368358418,
-0.0459250547,
-0.009234475,
-0.0157216936,
0.0226385761,
-0.0018004628,
-0.0407865681,
0.0458499119,
0.0217461511,
0.0016097714,
-0.0525383428,
-0.0208734721,
-0.0376178697,
-0.0294629857,
0.0079013761,
-0.0694068447,
-5.486290377e-33,
-0.0216535833,
-0.0604137331,
0.0532975644,
0.0272296444,
-0.0615815371,
-0.0513337255,
-0.0210450329,
0.0200245921,
-0.0436768979,
0.0092614042,
-0.0399345756,
0.012625128,
0.0144689288,
-0.0022707488,
-0.009410535,
-0.0188989155,
0.058073815,
0.0158039983,
-0.0370883867,
0.0207685363,
0.0663875937,
0.0066935848,
0.029451808,
-0.1080735177,
-0.0224173293,
-0.0112586673,
-0.0439811312,
0.0372179896,
-0.0050576767,
0.0015785581,
0.0297303479,
0.0088289697,
0.0036984687,
-0.0215165932,
-0.0012376331,
0.0012178223,
-0.0065107062,
-0.0164044835,
0.020356847,
0.0661445558,
0.0090206079,
-0.003908575,
-0.0331688859,
-0.0247161798,
0.0124267805,
0.0367867351,
0.0188351646,
0.0129838074,
-0.0214639585,
0.0518830493,
-0.0327545889,
0.0057644635,
-0.0271311738,
-0.0861362442,
0.0070621581,
0.0725332126,
-0.0007151219,
-0.0278204177,
-0.0497616678,
0.0664621219,
-0.0535674393,
-0.0126989251,
0.0248592291,
-0.0068700886,
0.0243020635,
0.040396452,
0.0205953419,
-0.0366442949,
-0.0372396633,
-0.0400110334,
-0.0299558528,
0.0705299377,
-0.0116048418,
0.0381882489,
-0.0604267567,
-0.0097462544,
0.0150782,
0.0181900747,
0.0012665092,
0.068423517,
-0.0277501196,
0.0467314087,
-0.0388803631,
0.0126948236,
-0.0301523115,
-0.0181458741,
0.010796872,
-0.051775068,
0.0241376664,
0.0387008488,
-0.018141374,
0.0045032878,
0.0537432171,
0.0091020921,
0.0058917152,
0.0323548876,
0.0150905838,
0.0091704736,
-0.0218235105,
-0.0082740067,
-0.0799183175,
-0.0121404631,
0.0282380749,
0.0156551562,
0.014293639,
0.0080342181,
-0.0714732036,
0.0448683612,
-0.0073788539,
-0.0130724935,
-0.0183167998,
0.0038622867,
-0.0309779048,
0.0104092127,
0.0331048667,
-0.0131614022,
-0.0502396561,
0.0530734584,
-0.0328114666,
-0.0072517712,
-0.0408108532,
-0.0422954969,
-0.0063358634,
0.0096854856,
-0.0373477936,
0.001853466,
-0.0019101603,
0.008645446,
0.0359550118,
-0.0261451583,
-0.022739388,
0.0162955802,
2.561e-7,
-0.02906367,
0.0223600958,
0.0327500962,
0.0629769266,
-0.0262435805,
0.0327059329,
0.0013263014,
0.0170129482,
0.0130609488,
0.0006960452,
0.0258140936,
0.0026539599,
0.019500237,
0.0255538095,
-0.0863404348,
-0.0324294157,
-0.0313270465,
-0.0441978201,
-0.0238570385,
-0.0114759216,
0.0453756154,
0.0319302008,
-0.0113523873,
0.0183685627,
0.0034057507,
-0.0244960915,
0.0033630328,
-0.0324651673,
-0.0012628207,
-0.0109006725,
-0.0012711254,
-0.0420321785,
-0.0467465743,
-0.0063543264,
0.0025280972,
0.0171996001,
0.0150736757,
0.0053607496,
-0.0075592473,
-0.0702514946,
-0.0249029808,
0.0085217655,
-0.0255228467,
-0.0109070167,
0.0072180647,
0.0044684359,
0.0211871006,
0.000822867,
-0.0141515359,
-0.017014958,
0.0071214549,
0.0267467443,
-0.0112232668,
-0.0047274781,
-0.0036519836,
0.0354383588,
0.0295274034,
-0.0770657137,
0.0617145076,
-0.0415234827,
-0.0425046571,
-0.0380099565,
-0.0087710293,
-0.0372974053,
-0.0140550015,
-0.018586807,
-0.025563471,
1.372197374e-34,
0.0200907588,
-0.0256198943,
-0.0155949108,
0.0608115271,
0.049164746,
0.0074900002,
0.0509621166,
0.00018846,
0.0476317406,
-0.0298294909,
-0.0279991254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14215v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14215v2 | SimLM: Can Language Models Infer Parameters of Physical Systems? | 2023-12-21T12:05:19 | 2024-02-06T10:15:01 | Sean Memery, Mirella Lapata, Kartic Subr | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.6 | Several machine learning methods aim to learn or reason about complex
physical systems. A common first-step towards reasoning is to infer system
parameters from observations of its behavior. In this paper, we investigate the
performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) at performing parameter inference
in the context of physical systems. Our experiments suggest that they are not
inherently suited to this task, even for simple systems. We propose a promising
direction of exploration, which involves the use of physical simulators to
augment the context of LLMs. We assess and compare the performance of different
LLMs on a simple example with and without access to physical simulation. | [
-0.0277834628,
0.0792478248,
-0.0052440139,
0.0803480819,
-0.0105765956,
0.002971221,
0.0533348992,
-0.0102420207,
-0.0103016598,
-0.0060887956,
0.009739561,
-0.0389056243,
0.0043253927,
-0.0088511501,
0.054261364,
-0.0397425741,
0.017762946,
-0.0797858685,
-0.0201360229,
-0.0122100972,
-0.0272160973,
-0.0023427964,
0.0001605203,
0.0303633567,
0.0084884102,
0.0117114075,
-0.0117247561,
-0.01147753,
0.0163129903,
0.0037215201,
-0.0353272296,
0.0261578579,
0.0580021515,
0.0428861789,
0.0000018524,
-0.0308445599,
0.0232763253,
0.0181733146,
-0.0233474094,
0.0339429453,
0.0559682809,
-0.0593298301,
0.0070366468,
0.0246973131,
-0.0166852903,
-0.0189879537,
0.0696904585,
-0.0166089665,
0.0106471535,
0.0423959792,
0.0064066369,
-0.0152875651,
0.0028015915,
0.0020583128,
-0.0112293223,
-0.007121698,
0.0329502597,
0.0493679456,
0.065564163,
0.0104498155,
-0.0251082946,
0.0604271293,
0.0409952551,
-0.0028884106,
-0.0276683792,
0.0653116107,
-0.0043455679,
0.0603011288,
0.0073469193,
0.0563211516,
-0.0366567038,
-0.0468103699,
0.0058197188,
-0.0251796376,
-0.0494682007,
0.0169306863,
-0.0217690412,
0.0112450104,
0.0108606452,
-0.0036256711,
-0.0028228431,
-0.0016901596,
0.069931522,
0.0033300787,
-0.0387904495,
0.1072405502,
0.0163123943,
0.0148662999,
-0.0293227434,
-0.0151833175,
0.0100462409,
-0.0612620078,
-0.0300836992,
0.0365402736,
0.0048820209,
0.0272753332,
-0.0124478824,
0.026249513,
-0.029769998,
-0.0446925201,
0.0458034575,
0.0072292485,
0.0444938503,
0.0558420606,
-0.015113282,
0.0187247396,
-0.0394407287,
0.0185344946,
-0.0353747904,
-0.0187401511,
-0.0709648207,
-0.0219733808,
0.0102220364,
0.0199105423,
-0.013392373,
-0.020054806,
0.0068451641,
0.0225117877,
0.0118721835,
-0.0191407576,
-0.0422717966,
0.0020345198,
0.0187453851,
-0.041307345,
-0.0360848419,
0.0081202537,
-0.0095170913,
0.0411535241,
-0.0096227955,
-0.0722851008,
-0.0088454997,
-0.010698501,
-0.0144345537,
-0.0152840205,
0.0034984269,
0.0759023651,
0.0312818773,
-0.0135197341,
-0.0139357978,
-0.0090003386,
-0.0001816029,
-0.0735319033,
-0.0146408482,
-0.0825378224,
0.0286024678,
0.029163111,
0.0063159443,
-0.0499510691,
0.0279832724,
-0.0269164871,
-0.0274959803,
0.1137791201,
0.0146111855,
-0.0028125965,
0.0204193722,
-0.0015834115,
0.0117966458,
0.0809295326,
0.0455043465,
-0.0049783862,
-0.0016055718,
-0.000397674,
0.0366018303,
0.0595269762,
0.0108964806,
0.0098164678,
-0.0696950033,
-0.0247832201,
-0.0081453612,
0.0150308711,
-0.0094894562,
0.0441647395,
-0.0214031525,
0.004207253,
0.0343411192,
0.0230876096,
-0.0184288919,
0.0580820367,
0.0486896336,
0.0044969087,
0.0419873074,
-0.0252589919,
-0.025863491,
0.018854918,
-0.0207480788,
0.0158411954,
0.027649831,
-0.0044054082,
-0.0240836013,
-0.0558919124,
-0.0447212271,
-0.0435676873,
-0.0215200949,
-0.0154390372,
0.0912981629,
-0.0297421943,
-0.0186222624,
0.0160651058,
0.0547773242,
0.0036110221,
-0.0158402957,
-0.0308585837,
0.0382430926,
0.0540487207,
0.0345597789,
-0.0497139469,
0.0020176028,
-0.0045314743,
0.0320714824,
0.0249002092,
0.0257213227,
0.0129427416,
0.0207278207,
-0.0135323964,
0.0054175612,
-0.0028229067,
0.0332493372,
0.003858258,
-0.0096586682,
-0.0245008152,
0.0240842849,
0.0201171525,
-0.0317853913,
0.0187218897,
-0.0515241995,
-0.028451426,
0.0098626856,
-0.0257616173,
0.0355192684,
-0.0304618254,
-0.0303403437,
0.0151192034,
0.0005275297,
-0.058964733,
0.0013378268,
0.0250927694,
-0.0023462144,
-0.0146772685,
0.0303280782,
-0.0116173085,
0.01707053,
0.0252676141,
-0.0268637426,
-0.0235445313,
0.0593664311,
-0.0323235169,
0.0462039299,
-0.0161411893,
-0.0298891477,
-0.0164589528,
0.0110514378,
-0.0018958569,
0.01852764,
0.0090372646,
0.0154009182,
0.0370478742,
0.0432264544,
-0.0006127854,
-0.024739515,
-0.0287515149,
0.0033482132,
-0.0059839282,
-0.0008469932,
0.0008210294,
-0.0550359003,
0.0191873834,
0.0205826052,
-0.0692070574,
-0.038719926,
-0.0113004008,
-0.0084557896,
0.0249503553,
-0.0282022096,
-0.0061089825,
0.0222020615,
0.0469218157,
0.0206653792,
-0.0091252653,
-0.033628732,
0.0455387607,
-0.0160004944,
-0.0637803376,
-0.055549968,
-0.0168840848,
-0.05410292,
0.0978286341,
0.0249277446,
0.0311712846,
-0.0779102594,
0.0284385383,
-0.0049599861,
0.0258527584,
-0.0070304517,
-0.0524972118,
0.0131332772,
-0.0621001385,
0.0179091375,
0.0670359358,
-0.018642202,
0.0374741703,
0.0681358501,
-0.0309779625,
-0.0439535901,
-0.0073889387,
-0.0532020032,
0.0112867923,
-0.0486620255,
-0.0268910825,
-0.0257984623,
0.0702098012,
-0.0226001795,
-0.0089305509,
-0.00792778,
0.0824972168,
-0.028261032,
-0.0164451096,
-0.0352911688,
0.0449793898,
0.0098362099,
0.0343322307,
0.0245881937,
-0.0319758207,
0.0689646676,
-0.0398596674,
-0.0158371776,
-0.0157862604,
-0.0069303294,
-0.0125292288,
0.0549645238,
-0.0004216076,
0.011822829,
-0.0002950364,
0.0478678793,
0.0211266782,
0.0039886194,
0.000759161,
0.0220337939,
0.0102591263,
-0.0780687332,
0.0259611811,
0.0156654865,
-0.0151925487,
-0.0198590234,
-0.0273158196,
-0.0621986315,
0.0323409736,
-0.0292181,
-0.0819819495,
-0.0286927223,
0.0051410515,
0.0322872438,
0.0072509833,
-0.007604267,
-0.0215841811,
-0.0420650356,
0.011039149,
0.0722530335,
-0.0054359511,
0.050252378,
-0.0637382716,
0.0455773696,
-0.0032443963,
0.0272179078,
0.0270448998,
-0.1011707187,
-0.0215683822,
0.0139514431,
0.022919286,
-0.0024972474,
0.0419293568,
0.0063946582,
-0.0431210697,
-0.0377698503,
0.1056549326,
0.006128002,
0.0080928607,
0.0127947628,
0.0320215002,
0.0217619445,
-0.0066999523,
0.0281240493,
-0.0441904813,
-0.0189995617,
-0.0015464688,
-0.0065542888,
0.0070843846,
-0.0111705689,
-0.0150837079,
-0.1053178385,
0.0125299525,
0.022385519,
-0.0476351604,
-0.072040014,
-0.0724525601,
-0.0331817567,
-0.0257028621,
0.0004320716,
0.0227147341,
0.0036641643,
-0.0208832249,
0.0215447582,
-0.048093304,
-0.0795600042,
0.042427592,
-0.0411154144,
0.0511694849,
0.0090942392,
0.0326290391,
-0.0382302366,
-0.033399336,
0.0220987368,
0.0184616353,
-0.0197832305,
-0.0199952275,
-0.0194490813,
0.0592120923,
-0.0128625687,
-0.0145362969,
0.0648035482,
-0.0501322597,
-0.0173070356,
-0.0222454891,
0.0760149956,
-0.0244571641,
-0.0470218211,
-0.0072526881,
-0.0017377238,
0.0110683432,
0.0639132261,
0.0143775512,
-0.0379660353,
-0.0683781356,
-0.0345280692,
-0.0671170354,
0.0066812318,
-0.0454055481,
-0.0335628726,
0.0456753448,
-0.0244993567,
-0.0240051728,
0.0206504371,
0.0027135755,
0.0244766623,
-0.0003569031,
-0.0014857494,
0.0473109186,
-0.0193243437,
-0.0164270364,
0.018891355,
-0.0334039703,
0.0401387848,
-0.0042952956,
-0.0109141115,
0.0657131374,
-0.0297419578,
-0.0378201306,
0.0123639442,
-0.0958216786,
-0.096044451,
0.0096819131,
0.0566199161,
0.0287502054,
0.0471896268,
-0.0308209211,
-0.0455070138,
0.0020013612,
-0.0055372049,
-0.0325416289,
0.0101362811,
-0.0131855812,
-0.009672164,
0.0194949657,
0.0018118683,
0.012484815,
0.0412707925,
0.0141443936,
-0.0218191501,
-0.0388791338,
-0.0372580998,
0.0050375108,
0.0082323905,
0.0410326608,
0.0318436287,
-0.0557932816,
-0.0105103962,
0.0055801831,
-0.0256040115,
-0.0016221881,
-0.048493728,
-0.0108248573,
0.0235803276,
0.0165964589,
-0.0234490279,
-0.0650248304,
0.0287792906,
0.0378378816,
0.0414488651,
0.0224198643,
0.0230852924,
0.0148375733,
0.0494247861,
-0.0371372141,
0.0251678582,
0.0404536799,
-0.0148928063,
0.0559800677,
-0.0084320484,
0.0046556257,
0.0380701497,
-0.0017115879,
-0.0545989238,
-0.0159218367,
-0.056054011,
-0.085133478,
-0.0282860175,
0.0381748527,
0.0351396166,
-0.0151104042,
0.0260790344,
-0.0853519589,
0.0078321928,
-0.03368444,
0.0418606065,
0.001930677,
0.0049220067,
0.0692076832,
0.0331504531,
-0.0466669947,
0.0034434954,
0.0437219068,
0.0547328405,
0.0265993737,
0.0153863681,
0.0174288284,
-0.0196582358,
0.0155073423,
-0.0129873799,
-0.0228084233,
-0.0230974127,
0.0250512715,
-0.0515816808,
-0.0697168633,
-0.0085835075,
0.0350344777,
0.0124046328,
-0.0252363421,
0.0301824976,
0.063657172,
-0.0031600746,
0.0173119288,
-0.0183340777,
0.0020160037,
-0.0169997085,
-0.013166178,
-0.0068158209,
-5.870388666e-33,
-0.0137794986,
-0.009515346,
0.0333516262,
0.0304007195,
0.0321339928,
-0.0193164926,
-0.050257802,
-0.0078343116,
-0.0064003454,
0.0279670376,
0.0143492995,
0.0096822185,
0.0116917929,
-0.0028921191,
0.0023349321,
-0.0245577022,
0.0299242958,
0.0183428302,
-0.0076974086,
0.0128242234,
0.0616065823,
0.0104991561,
0.0254027434,
-0.0623416305,
0.0127448831,
-0.0186197646,
0.0102931559,
0.0068202387,
-0.0544287004,
0.0487278812,
-0.0540069006,
0.0254971217,
-0.0220616497,
-0.0280273575,
-0.0098785926,
0.0167038999,
-0.0286063664,
0.016386766,
0.0011255763,
0.0268989075,
-0.0031696178,
-0.0444621406,
0.0353125669,
0.0167481638,
-0.059057571,
-0.0161865205,
0.0415085703,
-0.0356664993,
0.0252898801,
-0.0155236674,
-0.0746575892,
0.0251721423,
-0.0147155523,
0.0093107782,
0.0732236579,
-0.0094248904,
-0.0429101996,
0.0174632017,
-0.0084272148,
0.0140350591,
0.0660324693,
0.0449544676,
0.0841033235,
0.0029902777,
-0.0020876522,
0.0478214957,
0.0082835304,
-0.0397603028,
-0.0466257967,
0.0097860452,
0.0543053113,
0.0671614707,
0.035269741,
0.0299414564,
0.0253391117,
0.0001050518,
-0.0866978243,
-0.0344102606,
0.0340987258,
0.0212749299,
0.0452780351,
-0.0063496605,
-0.012261074,
-0.0213836823,
-0.0470408462,
0.0233762953,
-0.0154539431,
-0.0342095755,
-0.0050423658,
-0.0190904774,
-0.027757898,
-0.0328445062,
0.0432862751,
-0.0997171402,
-0.0477012992,
0.0303782187,
0.0362705626,
-0.0028241945,
0.0019262453,
0.0114999963,
-0.0651931018,
-0.0581955798,
-0.0428357311,
0.009622422,
0.0207799207,
-0.0079926588,
-0.0189979095,
0.0646832511,
-0.0368255414,
-0.0247769002,
-0.044021681,
-0.0426098891,
0.0178654715,
0.0182234664,
0.0500559732,
0.0198347513,
-0.0047276295,
0.0275443587,
-0.0150295356,
-0.0318890475,
0.0282242782,
0.0282619279,
-0.0267787315,
0.0065617864,
-0.010789427,
-0.0747447759,
-0.055556722,
0.0029532262,
0.0558757633,
-0.032063026,
-0.0225101952,
0.0397182815,
2.6e-7,
0.0334670581,
0.0819359198,
0.0263067167,
0.014899645,
0.0278194156,
0.0137747508,
-0.052441366,
-0.0108579136,
0.0191766657,
-0.007401471,
0.000766429,
0.0077040135,
0.0767387599,
0.0288936496,
-0.0988136753,
-0.0078065461,
-0.0572609082,
-0.0008027571,
-0.0517356284,
-0.0517473184,
0.0244945958,
0.1226569116,
0.0377701633,
0.0246993843,
0.0390867852,
-0.0305596776,
0.0636544824,
-0.0460083373,
0.0025288523,
0.0427469015,
0.0089736832,
-0.0373283997,
-0.0047050472,
0.0276596993,
-0.0102705257,
0.0218788125,
-0.0114922021,
0.0781744346,
0.0154238828,
0.004000166,
0.0024683555,
-0.0317041166,
0.0192308873,
-0.0675970539,
0.0532313287,
-0.0518969595,
-0.0154268062,
-0.0339932628,
0.0212471932,
-0.0156570934,
0.0233651046,
-0.0083683589,
0.0142085711,
-0.0120681245,
-0.0261599422,
-0.0497728512,
0.0234396346,
-0.0500011183,
-0.0541198514,
0.0280468035,
-0.059441641,
-0.0355062038,
-0.0259152874,
-0.0362761095,
0.0566480644,
-0.044847995,
0.006428441,
2.320717426e-34,
0.0282303877,
0.0174269583,
-0.0281860419,
0.0534298196,
0.0074066143,
0.0002310936,
0.0125665739,
0.0389000028,
0.0316392817,
-0.0741705224,
0.0050680754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13772v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13772v2 | On Task Performance and Model Calibration with Supervised and Self-Ensembled In-Context Learning | 2023-12-21T11:55:10 | 2023-12-22T21:03:03 | Chengzu Li, Han Zhou, Goran Glavaš, Anna Korhonen, Ivan Vulić | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Following the standard supervised fine-tuning (SFT) paradigm, in-context
learning (ICL) has become an efficient approach propelled by the recent
advancements in large language models (LLMs), yielding promising performance
across various tasks in few-shot data setups. However, both paradigms are prone
to suffer from the critical problem of overconfidence (i.e., miscalibration),
especially in such limited data setups. In this work, we deliver an in-depth
analysis of the behavior across different choices of learning methods from the
perspective of both performance and calibration, as well as their interplay.
Through extensive controlled experiments, we find that simultaneous gains for
both task performance and calibration are difficult to achieve, and the problem
of miscalibration exists across all learning methods in low-resource scenarios.
To address this challenging trade-off between performance and calibration, we
then investigate the potential of self-ensembling techniques applied at
different modeling stages (e.g., variations of in-context examples or
variations in prompts or different ensembling strategies). We justify the
feasibility of self-ensembling on SFT in addition to ICL, to make the
predictions more calibrated and have comparable or even better performance. Our
work sheds light on which learning paradigm to choose and how to enhance both
task performance and calibration of LLMs. | [
-0.0144551452,
0.0048518791,
-0.0118453978,
0.0434811935,
-0.0046057338,
0.0203110836,
0.0251407102,
-0.03406303,
-0.0268393345,
-0.0408949442,
-0.0929262787,
-0.0321572945,
0.0468933843,
-0.0063491971,
0.0400331914,
-0.0107203061,
0.0217345823,
-0.0436649956,
-0.0359710716,
-0.0194918457,
-0.007466088,
-0.0110067474,
-0.00988096,
0.0472037047,
0.0261605829,
-0.0321926661,
-0.0111874472,
0.0432035625,
-0.0038607798,
0.0044903359,
0.0471630432,
0.0807684287,
0.0293485373,
0.0494723506,
0.0000020074,
-0.0523187593,
-0.0106471628,
-0.0274432395,
-0.0603313893,
0.0169080626,
0.0197809227,
0.0006907409,
-0.011434909,
0.0427589752,
-0.0125541734,
0.0163332336,
0.0423047282,
0.0146178119,
0.0202164091,
0.0777618214,
0.0113881901,
-0.002148621,
-0.0129004819,
-0.0341478214,
-0.0376180932,
-0.0324207842,
0.0003642452,
-0.0155072026,
-0.0305951685,
0.0027183089,
-0.0169532504,
0.0163867809,
0.0135502378,
-0.0019913507,
0.0058015594,
0.0287356656,
-0.0382579863,
-0.0073288148,
-0.0321901068,
0.0504500158,
-0.0314485282,
-0.0214531068,
-0.0236228034,
-0.0321975835,
0.0014981651,
-0.0154037615,
-0.0287984796,
0.0120200226,
-0.0046040067,
0.0356895104,
-0.0061997245,
0.0144675411,
0.0552458689,
-0.0011277089,
-0.003799126,
0.0603979602,
-0.0017108065,
-0.0349227227,
-0.0243846439,
0.0216859635,
-0.0401330031,
-0.0467709117,
-0.0281916391,
0.0088347159,
-0.0759135336,
-0.0052028522,
-0.0507786907,
-0.0533158183,
0.0078078513,
0.0243674032,
0.0594564602,
0.0340553969,
-0.0010687409,
0.0430575386,
-0.0151933869,
0.0669010282,
0.0129775964,
-0.0010431644,
-0.0580564402,
-0.0090080509,
-0.0562603101,
0.0077227191,
-0.0396828093,
-0.0031909032,
-0.0470895581,
-0.0031100549,
-0.0633995235,
0.0263452474,
0.0052090255,
0.0052853427,
0.0211808197,
-0.0102874292,
-0.075748764,
-0.0142149273,
0.0170176979,
0.0392404832,
-0.0063364003,
0.0245509762,
0.0340032578,
-0.0389329232,
-0.0289247502,
0.0026666082,
-0.0062410017,
-0.0436513387,
0.0226922799,
0.0177478027,
-0.0051005916,
-0.0559124947,
-0.0010486862,
-0.0106031718,
-0.0473786406,
-0.0912710354,
-0.0214764532,
-0.0552309901,
0.0129201757,
0.0299029425,
0.0138470707,
-0.0231805872,
-0.0185757596,
-0.0178194158,
0.0065492881,
0.0670336038,
-0.0057775802,
0.0231377855,
0.0075384779,
0.0073821843,
0.0013952034,
0.1049094722,
0.0087675052,
0.0294098929,
0.0041623064,
-0.0102564152,
0.0307163633,
0.0520474277,
0.0332604013,
0.0102826059,
-0.0233002808,
0.0195980389,
0.0648417249,
0.0245528501,
0.0415004343,
0.0162422061,
-0.0268962737,
0.0344812833,
0.0977399722,
0.0142404288,
0.0270269252,
-0.0215499271,
-0.0361517631,
-0.0021025909,
0.0118739232,
0.0077551096,
-0.0788778216,
0.0242644697,
-0.0122060096,
-0.0042237691,
0.052972652,
0.0368900783,
-0.028973829,
-0.0348055325,
-0.0222565625,
-0.0097172661,
-0.0323176198,
0.0530899577,
0.0476574451,
-0.0070226481,
-0.0390555374,
0.0020383308,
0.0318991877,
-0.0203188416,
-0.0066549061,
-0.0550171323,
-0.0111974645,
0.0624348819,
0.0388273299,
-0.0191438887,
-0.0380107276,
-0.0264566652,
0.0474743769,
0.0316700749,
-0.0054851132,
-0.0201729983,
0.0477950796,
-0.0526496135,
-0.044749368,
-0.0254463442,
0.0101482067,
-0.0045675393,
0.0358303003,
-0.0092130238,
0.0005721202,
-0.0302227903,
0.0113468692,
0.0263866242,
-0.035984911,
-0.0494921543,
0.01208256,
0.0176516734,
0.0046575461,
-0.0115540782,
-0.0298037361,
-0.0115408376,
0.0211570617,
-0.0236765221,
-0.0010758211,
-0.0122698145,
-0.0879866853,
-0.0546961874,
0.019988196,
0.0334097743,
-0.0159638319,
-0.0117968982,
-0.041951362,
-0.0663054287,
-0.0222338047,
-0.0064331591,
0.0181385912,
-0.0375965163,
0.0316117853,
-0.0603266843,
0.0243096258,
-0.0648226291,
0.0311219376,
0.0209640674,
0.0083623724,
-0.0100249918,
0.0105156684,
-0.0005394575,
-0.0213830713,
-0.0356952511,
0.0083354386,
0.0094026662,
0.0234280266,
0.0116394758,
-0.0299401842,
-0.0454538614,
-0.0227152836,
-0.1173191816,
0.0215354841,
-0.0603533946,
0.0071948217,
0.0361694098,
0.0193340071,
-0.0304994453,
-0.0373693593,
0.0079232259,
-0.0224382114,
0.0102992421,
0.0348221511,
0.0071953801,
0.0031929328,
-0.0160039961,
-0.0404098183,
-0.0161319058,
-0.0069407145,
0.0111792134,
-0.0116033349,
-0.0252603497,
-0.0887362137,
0.031166805,
0.0098165395,
0.0143352253,
-0.0214058738,
-0.0157226399,
0.0038700062,
-0.0037250344,
0.0505970865,
0.1000524312,
-0.0280067492,
0.0056383586,
0.0625891984,
0.0291138347,
-0.0460881069,
0.0081298044,
-0.0025660899,
-0.038359087,
-0.046432782,
0.0432437323,
-0.0031982681,
0.0582922772,
0.0071952678,
0.0091494257,
-0.034764383,
0.022225637,
-0.0325977914,
-0.0224912465,
-0.0604010224,
-0.0082673999,
-0.0087123811,
0.0219246522,
-0.0251987539,
-0.073965393,
0.055541005,
-0.0043218825,
-0.0275028888,
-0.0501325093,
-0.0166074373,
-0.0094850408,
0.0505626984,
0.0104735177,
0.0028439031,
0.0415124632,
-0.0194788165,
-0.0813385621,
-0.0151279001,
0.0305756722,
-0.0130018415,
0.0539899878,
-0.0133656077,
-0.0009247352,
-0.0333831236,
-0.0946965963,
-0.0351774991,
-0.0596695691,
-0.0144789321,
0.017497316,
0.001335141,
-0.0122616654,
-0.0219466817,
-0.0055855056,
0.0013030906,
0.0360333771,
-0.0348135568,
-0.0197543986,
-0.0218006261,
0.0193818286,
0.0434619412,
0.0084354896,
0.0321590528,
-0.0467853434,
0.0443666577,
0.0102717038,
0.0788914561,
0.0010291997,
-0.0352756903,
0.0048014713,
0.043629542,
-0.0075611095,
-0.0157414991,
0.0380426012,
0.1036969423,
-0.0533864424,
-0.017705176,
0.1423240155,
-0.0003093691,
-0.0449938402,
-0.0029821161,
0.0001099035,
0.0195157509,
0.0367417857,
0.0123000601,
-0.0187942274,
-0.0552022271,
0.0266668294,
0.0284644514,
0.0256386064,
-0.0152201522,
0.0319627114,
-0.1117743999,
0.0391307771,
0.0178504959,
-0.037539266,
-0.0348710828,
-0.0527710579,
0.0251206439,
-0.0250642747,
0.0753301308,
0.0310927648,
-0.0117062572,
0.0068154521,
0.0455252118,
-0.0032166424,
-0.0957325324,
0.0196496919,
-0.0765575916,
0.0815510899,
0.0709952787,
-0.006178434,
0.0233772807,
0.0240665581,
0.0421508029,
-0.01338543,
0.0209591333,
0.0130068315,
0.0599301308,
0.0045860615,
-0.0068208752,
0.0006744573,
0.0217667688,
-0.0263993405,
-0.0066359676,
0.0052251252,
0.0496878847,
-0.0234457422,
0.006227978,
0.0148774972,
-0.0714725628,
0.0536797084,
0.0807091072,
0.0160403904,
-0.0487101004,
-0.0388420038,
-0.0066547859,
0.0089058205,
-0.0228390396,
0.0381392092,
0.0271906275,
0.0162431691,
0.0092515461,
-0.028480066,
-0.036980737,
0.0509970076,
0.0441133566,
0.0155581878,
0.0531080775,
-0.0371513516,
0.0193792824,
-0.0423590131,
0.0110881031,
-0.0453870259,
0.0535906889,
-0.0499370806,
0.0021859002,
0.0276007578,
-0.004234707,
0.0220013168,
-0.0016828835,
-0.1040906757,
-0.0798841417,
0.0116039515,
0.0253664125,
0.0199877135,
0.0812391788,
-0.0062404089,
-0.0580534972,
0.0809107199,
0.0435007922,
-0.0120925028,
0.0338035002,
0.0156444255,
-0.0114025576,
-0.0149848415,
0.0494600683,
-0.0412556231,
0.0117709087,
0.0502254888,
0.0271797497,
-0.0180205461,
-0.0226159319,
0.0219059549,
-0.026844373,
0.0848563462,
-0.0368602052,
-0.0054295855,
-0.0123863332,
0.0192298274,
0.0153233623,
-0.0212965123,
-0.0147675918,
-0.0307331216,
0.030464204,
0.0208596569,
0.010954354,
0.0565987714,
0.0282233935,
0.0313373841,
-0.0512308292,
0.0029389374,
-0.0090487758,
0.0184088387,
0.0560018532,
0.0329621993,
-0.0125709157,
0.0282903351,
0.0324607939,
0.0327973031,
0.0030200193,
0.0422773398,
0.0349388756,
0.0156112779,
-0.0561937988,
0.0485291444,
-0.0673543811,
-0.014289326,
-0.0566634908,
0.0332057625,
0.0595010221,
-0.0212761555,
0.0508416817,
-0.0033702462,
-0.0202772673,
-0.048572652,
0.0218856111,
-0.0112757161,
0.0136415213,
0.0237385742,
0.0103310738,
-0.0254371334,
0.0124273431,
0.0882261395,
-0.0087842438,
0.0433189422,
0.0371916294,
0.0193679128,
-0.017031353,
-0.0168919098,
-0.0130744446,
0.0076121907,
-0.0247811954,
0.0081882412,
-0.0049192165,
-0.0558984801,
-0.0047864434,
0.0333467498,
0.0052798111,
-0.0354131423,
0.0236073639,
0.044519484,
-0.0133539243,
-0.00982536,
-0.020757826,
-0.0153996944,
-0.0035684875,
0.0055607175,
-0.0198054407,
-6.233084509e-33,
-0.0333234407,
0.0043973727,
0.0200056806,
-0.006166582,
0.0142054567,
-0.004168456,
-0.0304716025,
0.0181217995,
-0.0068368712,
-0.0112861414,
-0.0383947268,
0.0172127038,
0.0354730971,
0.0308174137,
0.0200937856,
-0.0139057804,
0.0759615153,
-0.0183535013,
-0.060199596,
0.0128075434,
0.020316951,
0.0248107407,
0.0570206642,
-0.0127033908,
-0.0170213822,
-0.0068483935,
-0.0012125188,
0.0204956792,
-0.014727002,
0.0307320729,
0.0091771549,
0.0400434732,
0.0113959378,
-0.0309500154,
-0.0385031737,
0.0409336984,
-0.0589880049,
-0.0287545472,
-0.0180564336,
0.0169011597,
0.0035677322,
-0.0037909485,
0.0298367776,
-0.0139880525,
-0.0555644706,
-0.0221569017,
0.0103678731,
-0.0201589875,
-0.0363363214,
-0.0049443822,
-0.0415675379,
-0.0018792005,
0.0078449985,
-0.0485200547,
0.0189770013,
0.0238395799,
0.0130977789,
0.0057825139,
-0.0767196938,
-0.0232773181,
-0.0085987188,
0.0598691143,
0.0653635561,
0.1025679111,
-0.0100602815,
0.0455790237,
0.0495865978,
0.0619871356,
-0.0134898033,
-0.0358280204,
0.0345189273,
0.0171024334,
0.0305872206,
0.0422548167,
0.046192117,
0.006395801,
-0.0705936477,
0.0289669838,
0.0244464725,
-0.0052741729,
0.0361239351,
0.0335071757,
-0.0527572557,
-0.0504915155,
-0.0500853211,
-0.0050152694,
-0.0201725792,
0.0073343664,
0.038875632,
0.0257437322,
-0.0085408604,
-0.0027377945,
0.0503133945,
-0.0421683043,
-0.0287600085,
0.0138863847,
-0.0054629762,
-0.0128123472,
0.0165635571,
0.0278862678,
-0.056546174,
-0.0349822119,
-0.0007719208,
0.0612547547,
0.0203117765,
-0.0112496419,
0.0658831149,
0.0239142478,
-0.0637515411,
-0.0012647179,
-0.0324495994,
0.0306372028,
0.0098833861,
-0.0025291436,
0.0447181314,
0.00341007,
-0.0088654431,
0.0186931007,
0.0276696682,
-0.0361833647,
-0.0168305561,
-0.0331805386,
0.0013665541,
-0.0136872213,
0.0156960934,
-0.0042317635,
-0.0476757325,
-0.0232519377,
0.0364692062,
-0.0270961057,
-0.0104114851,
0.0041761058,
2.61e-7,
0.0288336314,
0.0336230807,
-0.0035872837,
-0.0238077696,
0.0330526046,
0.0579140559,
-0.0524380803,
0.0104240179,
0.0319596529,
-0.0177041236,
-0.0009225112,
0.0331609733,
0.065207772,
0.0037600743,
-0.0783296973,
0.0154386936,
-0.0468825437,
0.0562607907,
-0.0339930132,
0.0026900133,
-0.0192676689,
0.0968714133,
0.014340464,
-0.0372839086,
0.005502163,
-0.037477389,
0.0615207553,
-0.0419277102,
0.0079333689,
0.0293306578,
-0.0359153152,
0.0293495525,
-0.0097609097,
0.0449761078,
0.0037468816,
0.0389100537,
-0.0177047085,
0.0319867134,
-0.0192709956,
0.0041316347,
-0.0351384692,
0.0096430033,
0.0164827779,
-0.0619460605,
0.0802864656,
-0.0979036167,
-0.0247885156,
-0.0509547852,
0.0153084658,
-0.0313425474,
0.0505836196,
0.000158627,
-0.016137762,
0.0202694014,
0.0233504381,
-0.013536511,
-0.028275134,
-0.0829257146,
-0.0585905463,
0.0647720546,
-0.0352419093,
-0.05953262,
-0.0313980915,
-0.0123039922,
0.0300371908,
-0.0691495463,
0.0163048375,
2.47306953e-34,
0.0133130429,
-0.0180920567,
0.0524511673,
0.0268800613,
-0.0025039637,
-0.0312008262,
-0.0464289114,
-0.0033600146,
0.0234572235,
-0.0559099987,
-0.0069503263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13766v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13766v1 | Exploiting Contextual Target Attributes for Target Sentiment Classification | 2023-12-21T11:45:28 | 2023-12-21T11:45:28 | Bowen Xing, Ivor W. Tsang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing PTLM-based models for TSC can be categorized into two groups: 1)
fine-tuning-based models that adopt PTLM as the context encoder; 2)
prompting-based models that transfer the classification task to the text/word
generation task. In this paper, we present a new perspective of leveraging PTLM
for TSC: simultaneously leveraging the merits of both language modeling and
explicit target-context interactions via contextual target attributes.
Specifically, we design the domain- and target-constrained cloze test, which
can leverage the PTLMs' strong language modeling ability to generate the given
target's attributes pertaining to the review context. The attributes contain
the background and property information of the target, which can help to enrich
the semantics of the review context and the target. To exploit the attributes
for tackling TSC, we first construct a heterogeneous information graph by
treating the attributes as nodes and combining them with (1) the syntax graph
automatically produced by the off-the-shelf dependency parser and (2) the
semantics graph of the review context, which is derived from the self-attention
mechanism. Then we propose a heterogeneous information gated graph
convolutional network to model the interactions among the attribute
information, the syntactic information, and the contextual information. The
experimental results on three benchmark datasets demonstrate the superiority of
our model, which achieves new state-of-the-art performance. | [
0.0436910726,
-0.001626418,
0.0259374212,
0.0568229891,
-0.0244722459,
-0.0103047108,
-0.0093014995,
-0.023848163,
-0.0125360051,
-0.0823475868,
-0.0751431063,
-0.034623649,
-0.0250088349,
0.0741789192,
0.005173685,
0.0022492108,
0.013941328,
0.039136406,
0.0294348802,
0.0069220676,
0.0040861811,
0.0404193103,
0.0441237502,
0.0204476323,
-0.0079601556,
-0.0185196102,
0.025108872,
0.0401580371,
-0.0063935407,
-0.0289118383,
0.0215296503,
0.054055173,
0.0118651511,
0.0166919418,
0.0000019405,
-0.0286498237,
-0.0052683484,
-0.0315838158,
0.0136744073,
-0.020620646,
0.0802496672,
-0.0449947566,
0.0289639924,
-0.0079448344,
-0.0354616828,
-0.0646532401,
0.0187221691,
0.0824251994,
0.0425076336,
0.1098787859,
-0.0260242019,
0.0015291428,
-0.011753357,
-0.0335622504,
0.0292267334,
-0.0494699255,
0.0003262628,
-0.0135060102,
-0.0009506717,
0.0492393076,
-0.0233439803,
-0.0009798981,
0.0295340139,
-0.02459451,
0.0673644096,
0.0035861579,
0.0395927168,
0.0252568293,
-0.01570509,
0.0768941641,
0.0117544681,
-0.0505632088,
-0.022550337,
0.0026819669,
-0.0026590931,
-0.0215054825,
-0.0128498916,
-0.0156681277,
0.0134500079,
0.0257637892,
0.0112985279,
0.0343706459,
0.0297195856,
0.0168374255,
0.0151908388,
0.0304482896,
-0.0216726214,
-0.0321594626,
0.0088159572,
0.0716692433,
-0.018456623,
-0.0221498907,
-0.0351101197,
-0.0205892436,
-0.0270741526,
-0.0231507123,
-0.047933042,
-0.0031230981,
0.0095139043,
-0.0259555858,
0.0336137451,
-0.0309734214,
-0.0241237339,
0.0381058417,
-0.0226906836,
-0.0004637848,
-0.00403638,
-0.0196891688,
-0.054081779,
-0.0004298283,
-0.0764134526,
0.0097679002,
-0.0053667496,
0.0359906182,
-0.0080806501,
-0.0363181196,
-0.0667971,
0.0346745551,
-0.0284091737,
0.0005755975,
0.0056492505,
0.0358501226,
-0.0114576994,
0.0019468997,
0.0149611011,
0.0308906231,
-0.0348319933,
0.0254536644,
-0.010137842,
-0.0091629755,
-0.0225817095,
0.063813068,
0.0232909434,
-0.0248125549,
0.0053273351,
0.060191378,
0.0318145417,
-0.0524485558,
-0.0240079872,
-0.0341276452,
-0.0385106206,
-0.0591867827,
0.0059835687,
-0.0527455322,
0.0108339181,
-0.0004208416,
-0.0281361099,
-0.0287244935,
0.0044342275,
-0.0023889507,
-0.0084567387,
0.0655367747,
0.0165625177,
-0.0657690316,
-0.0347389355,
-0.0225174762,
-0.0072670793,
0.0664359555,
-0.0087601775,
0.0524655506,
0.0062443814,
0.0043097697,
-0.0165975075,
-0.0201463774,
0.0433619134,
-0.0088408543,
-0.0663434267,
0.0162559915,
-0.0392552651,
-0.0191028751,
0.0319478288,
0.0192506798,
-0.0090340748,
-0.0332151949,
0.0566273518,
-0.0062513966,
-0.0375253186,
0.0478675663,
0.0380899496,
0.0343284942,
-0.0509816222,
-0.0036925299,
-0.0539955869,
0.0184718352,
-0.0373004042,
0.0186509024,
-0.0068110451,
-0.0024681813,
-0.0516899712,
-0.0447540767,
-0.0031230154,
-0.0503253862,
0.0336256102,
-0.0044720597,
0.0639177114,
0.0441078134,
-0.0599887632,
0.0122752581,
0.0359590985,
-0.0163257271,
-0.0054592569,
-0.025791591,
0.0048176143,
0.0815763399,
0.0217914917,
-0.003408832,
-0.0232679173,
-0.0516789295,
-0.0025348002,
0.0198260881,
0.0588435531,
-0.0071148495,
-0.023982266,
-0.0291358009,
-0.0442358628,
-0.060521286,
0.0087879095,
0.0082156435,
-0.009237132,
0.0067708176,
0.0348297432,
-0.0188746061,
-0.00430862,
-0.0133869657,
0.0657180846,
-0.0011674108,
0.0439154543,
-0.0033580479,
0.0266961586,
0.0511025377,
-0.0219839904,
0.006847715,
0.0097594028,
-0.032023225,
-0.0475081429,
0.0107809547,
-0.0351779461,
-0.0719861686,
-0.0076230671,
-0.0462385304,
-0.003453014,
0.0430430621,
-0.0305730961,
-0.0437484421,
0.0407699496,
-0.0402063131,
0.0393135995,
-0.0334980302,
-0.0160353053,
-0.0085447636,
0.0227893759,
-0.0048343288,
0.0730698258,
-0.0019131086,
0.0013844208,
-0.0259724893,
0.0430723168,
-0.025332002,
-0.0025422981,
-0.010154929,
-0.0275278445,
0.0297824573,
0.014074632,
0.0480394661,
0.038972985,
-0.0198731981,
-0.0307090245,
-0.0813090354,
-0.0176961962,
-0.0305711534,
0.0285349917,
0.0198425055,
-0.0011487707,
0.0119852172,
-0.0016105656,
-0.0461907871,
0.0132755339,
0.0182262696,
0.0147482501,
0.0377909318,
0.0083443243,
0.0172582455,
-0.0436557978,
-0.0213082433,
-0.0082784565,
0.0683926567,
0.0457928516,
-0.0477898121,
-0.0284241643,
0.0468205139,
-0.0221108198,
0.0103910407,
0.0129640726,
0.0030131491,
-0.0272735991,
-0.0151013983,
-0.0267252438,
0.025326306,
-0.0062573627,
0.0211466923,
0.0051252204,
0.0102472603,
-0.0472617261,
0.0043668067,
-0.0594034977,
0.0433359034,
-0.0043021636,
-0.0110341357,
0.024256127,
0.0722922608,
0.019040484,
-0.0035013696,
-0.0553316213,
0.0126706697,
-0.0178666785,
-0.0052202591,
0.0036715716,
-0.0025072556,
0.0372844897,
-0.0360791646,
-0.029953042,
-0.0263100695,
0.1096783802,
0.002355309,
-0.00132317,
-0.0669244826,
-0.0059825489,
-0.063468881,
0.0440414138,
0.034572728,
0.0301841144,
0.0395876728,
0.0026561725,
0.0141551709,
-0.0091096489,
-0.0153109571,
0.00952031,
0.0546662062,
0.0082979947,
0.029069541,
0.0213649087,
-0.0380884372,
0.0054022372,
-0.0461832844,
-0.0059378142,
-0.0022914642,
0.0165844858,
-0.0294011626,
0.0317214578,
0.0201549381,
-0.0365373567,
0.0057654441,
-0.0317360982,
-0.0300782416,
-0.0094698668,
0.0470636673,
0.0654550865,
-0.0262381453,
0.0184147898,
0.0040984107,
-0.0131226862,
0.061479561,
0.0149060665,
0.0173565038,
-0.0418389998,
-0.0160758365,
0.0105347447,
0.0062135346,
-0.0086774994,
-0.045105014,
0.0522692725,
-0.0493034311,
-0.0160684623,
0.1151508465,
0.0202667285,
-0.0989159197,
-0.0106720375,
0.0292455722,
0.0174439419,
0.0306996964,
-0.0071042054,
-0.0789544657,
-0.0431850776,
-0.0442601107,
0.0203292314,
0.0057945373,
-0.0000013044,
-0.0051350323,
-0.0892646164,
0.0178495347,
-0.0175775401,
-0.0391355157,
-0.0650893375,
-0.0286774002,
0.0046342914,
-0.0006160445,
0.0184024572,
-0.0400422253,
-0.0063465652,
0.0041686846,
-0.0205919482,
0.0094730863,
-0.0524926409,
0.0701003894,
-0.0017355118,
0.0329247639,
0.0572852492,
0.0160592683,
-0.012793473,
0.0228131134,
0.0624232739,
-0.0441207737,
-0.0031432267,
-0.0356538519,
0.0393023193,
-0.0124200843,
-0.0008589604,
0.0068495059,
0.0447709821,
-0.0799915642,
0.0311603826,
-0.0312568992,
0.0369931422,
-0.0199518278,
-0.0327114351,
-0.0063803117,
0.0253018122,
0.0393697508,
0.0882240534,
0.0417057909,
-0.0674228519,
-0.0541799702,
-0.018507285,
-0.008991072,
-0.0648642927,
-0.0334904119,
-0.0168383922,
0.002293959,
-0.031701453,
-0.0714627355,
-0.0671441555,
0.0097342134,
0.0242501236,
-0.0380042866,
-0.0022229857,
-0.0249787066,
-0.04251628,
-0.0411076248,
0.0656928122,
0.0021378053,
0.0050048535,
-0.0195301529,
-0.0276301168,
0.0624289066,
-0.0351049267,
0.0057474198,
0.004500974,
-0.0529607646,
-0.0305901803,
-0.0641573891,
0.0385001563,
0.005505749,
0.0643471703,
-0.0295295883,
-0.0050717448,
0.018861765,
0.0044740541,
-0.0499068089,
0.0021489051,
0.0469996482,
0.0131195523,
-0.0030458644,
0.0550516918,
-0.0506601408,
0.074259147,
0.0082858158,
-0.0023396555,
-0.0078047612,
-0.0178248137,
0.0268226806,
-0.0343349874,
0.0611384325,
0.0263340101,
0.0273471624,
-0.0402217284,
0.015071745,
-0.0319898352,
-0.0167004559,
-0.06559176,
-0.0209901594,
-0.0037476129,
-0.0093469443,
-0.0284604896,
-0.0412645489,
-0.0253645591,
0.0630702972,
-0.088568449,
0.0595104881,
0.0225166436,
0.0050701238,
0.0209549628,
0.0024529144,
-0.0407452509,
-0.0067757163,
0.0101345144,
-0.0098252445,
-0.0030066085,
0.0479317047,
0.0222862456,
0.0026731789,
-0.0347943306,
0.0161169972,
-0.030244397,
0.0911124051,
-0.0457924977,
-0.0279771294,
0.0279994849,
-0.0148937851,
0.0557527356,
-0.0346017443,
-0.0026860726,
0.0052813566,
0.0553619191,
-0.0106575945,
-0.0306271017,
0.0313860551,
0.0118557317,
-0.0129572973,
0.0115794558,
0.0605873391,
-0.0021023809,
0.0226286259,
0.0317811966,
-0.0253015943,
-0.0528440811,
-0.0137674157,
-0.0198445208,
0.0155850602,
0.0160824768,
0.0456613749,
-0.0378531143,
-0.063601926,
0.065976046,
-0.022534024,
0.0141257858,
0.0142739452,
0.0518902391,
0.0613892004,
0.0116101401,
0.0178090278,
-0.0692729801,
0.0149770528,
0.0397451669,
-0.0256409869,
-0.0207537524,
-6.45007195e-33,
-0.000202658,
-0.0404187217,
-0.0126732644,
0.0591561198,
-0.0131083271,
0.0503096692,
-0.0397792272,
-0.0104532791,
0.0164749064,
0.0293608997,
0.0237402469,
0.0219104271,
-0.0094265509,
0.0645916909,
-0.0110692643,
-0.0180281885,
0.0463477001,
-0.0058732773,
0.0052892645,
0.0693525374,
0.0377951376,
0.0089883357,
0.0618700758,
-0.0562968627,
0.0669221207,
-0.0243340153,
0.0069028437,
0.0072250213,
0.0454090051,
0.0602627583,
0.0059569557,
0.1020682454,
0.057125546,
-0.0545232035,
-0.0040794336,
0.0420328081,
-0.0537347011,
-0.0362375788,
-0.0156314839,
-0.0076072435,
-0.0235285629,
-0.0130380597,
0.0412373878,
0.0064070234,
0.0062413164,
-0.019424554,
0.0286368411,
-0.000817609,
-0.0046605435,
-0.073480472,
-0.0598855466,
0.0345853195,
0.0013962755,
0.0071253898,
0.0277506728,
0.0620906986,
0.0162884891,
0.0150028206,
-0.0544003956,
0.0243537501,
-0.0424522087,
0.0213313438,
-0.0011425038,
0.0083416384,
-0.014485321,
0.0556002408,
-0.0148667777,
0.0282873902,
-0.0316283777,
0.0639952198,
-0.0056085414,
0.0210213233,
0.0029442899,
0.0334103927,
-0.0281305946,
-0.0176243242,
-0.0708183944,
0.0014681199,
0.0580443367,
0.000015579,
0.0538899861,
-0.0241117608,
-0.0501404852,
-0.0216893479,
0.0285192356,
-0.0153695745,
-0.0400452465,
-0.0229412038,
0.0021659343,
0.0229852255,
-0.0310343374,
0.01636138,
-0.0020239518,
-0.0511593111,
-0.0156582519,
0.073272638,
-0.0335357636,
0.0363807641,
0.0196187813,
0.0051500257,
-0.0483179763,
-0.0272285622,
-0.021391863,
-0.002457354,
-0.0063079176,
0.0163882095,
0.0658823848,
0.0293955989,
-0.0628165677,
-0.0028075785,
-0.029548509,
0.0291814599,
-0.0419067591,
0.0223029964,
0.0079380609,
0.0308731887,
-0.0163869467,
0.0938142985,
0.0253845081,
0.0241083652,
-0.0069360398,
0.0410015397,
-0.0124671515,
0.0307410546,
-0.0378433056,
-0.0257641114,
0.0196069349,
-0.0004449624,
0.0146918455,
-0.0713920668,
-0.0058259894,
0.0046717254,
2.694e-7,
0.0575023331,
0.0561238751,
-0.0096451966,
0.001547877,
0.0179420728,
0.0523063838,
0.0130990315,
0.0536016487,
-0.0084431618,
-0.0179721583,
0.0292089693,
0.0253780819,
-0.0172895845,
0.0355753899,
-0.0881308764,
0.0913079306,
-0.0353522934,
0.0258168038,
-0.0044463901,
0.0294846576,
0.0460863523,
0.0983893052,
-0.0085796611,
-0.0270563159,
-0.0100855557,
-0.0104517778,
0.0614326596,
-0.0326162688,
-0.0525384694,
0.0350441895,
0.0319742896,
-0.0340621322,
-0.031952098,
0.030938914,
-0.027018588,
0.027803123,
-0.0088315578,
0.033522442,
0.0164155103,
-0.0745793208,
0.0207596906,
-0.0244000778,
0.0186346732,
-0.0173853878,
0.0725214928,
-0.0665078387,
-0.0292000659,
-0.0882404894,
0.0059679965,
0.0255332533,
0.0186641775,
-0.0228401925,
-0.0171609782,
0.0287149195,
0.0046040006,
-0.0327529013,
-0.0422639661,
-0.077505894,
-0.0302558839,
0.0084086368,
-0.0181495864,
-0.0108599076,
-0.0030249578,
-0.0027791979,
0.009821048,
-0.0140866553,
0.0072335713,
2.854420331e-34,
0.0735206753,
-0.0365412086,
-0.0085565913,
-0.0430948175,
0.0080981953,
-0.0101488717,
-0.0607089847,
-0.0107773673,
0.03859891,
-0.0558704101,
0.0075891116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13764v1 | A Semantic Space is Worth 256 Language Descriptions: Make Stronger Segmentation Models with Descriptive Properties | 2023-12-21T11:43:41 | 2023-12-21T11:43:41 | Junfei Xiao, Ziqi Zhou, Wenxuan Li, Shiyi Lan, Jieru Mei, Zhiding Yu, Alan Yuille, Yuyin Zhou, Cihang Xie | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper introduces ProLab, a novel approach using property-level label
space for creating strong interpretable segmentation models. Instead of relying
solely on category-specific annotations, ProLab uses descriptive properties
grounded in common sense knowledge for supervising segmentation models. It is
based on two core designs. First, we employ Large Language Models (LLMs) and
carefully crafted prompts to generate descriptions of all involved categories
that carry meaningful common sense knowledge and follow a structured format.
Second, we introduce a description embedding model preserving semantic
correlation across descriptions and then cluster them into a set of descriptive
properties (e.g., 256) using K-Means. These properties are based on
interpretable common sense knowledge consistent with theories of human
recognition. We empirically show that our approach makes segmentation models
perform stronger on five classic benchmarks (e.g., ADE20K, COCO-Stuff, Pascal
Context, Cityscapes, and BDD). Our method also shows better scalability with
extended training steps than category-level supervision. Our interpretable
segmentation framework also emerges with the generalization ability to segment
out-of-domain or unknown categories using only in-domain descriptive
properties. Code is available at https://github.com/lambert-x/ProLab. | [
0.0145210344,
0.0226338301,
0.0101034651,
0.0476029068,
0.0008665488,
0.027688263,
-0.0020245963,
-0.0132420259,
-0.0189994238,
-0.0497473143,
-0.0138595002,
0.0201921258,
0.0157243665,
0.0244198553,
0.0084638614,
-0.1096242592,
0.0161691587,
-0.0191343632,
-0.0210075565,
0.030767519,
0.0099686654,
0.0037656906,
-0.0122601213,
0.0225175787,
-0.0479041114,
-0.0143993367,
-0.0252334848,
0.0008707479,
0.0391449705,
-0.0375019908,
0.0031752321,
0.0263667125,
0.0548595376,
-0.0061621624,
0.0000021123,
-0.0363196023,
-0.021003183,
-0.0036023632,
0.0312043186,
-0.0382418558,
0.0405275747,
-0.0519973002,
0.035227444,
-0.0736795217,
0.0342772529,
-0.0155269559,
0.051496122,
0.0488092154,
0.034742713,
0.0493060723,
-0.0175228622,
-0.0935596898,
-0.0054509579,
0.0034544314,
0.0232821777,
-0.042275209,
0.0167803019,
0.0181205049,
-0.0186601374,
0.0289753396,
-0.0271418132,
0.0060933949,
-0.0007153476,
-0.0056159855,
0.0352157392,
0.0353856906,
-0.0317761637,
-0.0556438677,
0.0179828294,
0.0870913342,
-0.0110637443,
-0.0107510714,
0.0193409864,
0.0119102616,
0.0000236916,
-0.055206988,
-0.0354694426,
0.0416957401,
-0.0198513623,
0.0140882228,
-0.0292456709,
0.0771954879,
0.0487518646,
-0.0074786963,
-0.0216767509,
0.0617693961,
-0.0017802065,
0.007734247,
0.0090676202,
0.0056542298,
-0.026521733,
-0.0027959673,
-0.0172836315,
0.0221275296,
0.0220733043,
0.0431633741,
-0.0283562895,
0.0334242471,
0.0101875849,
-0.0186787359,
-0.0290535074,
-0.0057276972,
-0.0459725223,
0.0734279081,
-0.0167624466,
0.0628244653,
0.0027449972,
0.0457793139,
-0.0603162572,
-0.0578748994,
-0.0730101764,
0.0097373286,
-0.0304475501,
0.0054344442,
-0.0015596075,
0.0045025381,
-0.0331964381,
0.0366379619,
-0.0242799688,
0.0526249632,
0.0039047252,
0.0027091303,
-0.0281382985,
-0.0197389238,
0.0034110793,
-0.0432937071,
-0.0495213307,
-0.0316776112,
-0.011945121,
0.004577463,
0.0065749865,
0.0430655107,
-0.0072926315,
-0.0244494136,
-0.0358413644,
0.0440013446,
-0.0099549331,
-0.0235838071,
-0.0390125439,
-0.0500743985,
-0.0338992923,
-0.0275431406,
0.0094584646,
-0.0569317453,
-0.0041399575,
-0.0036692929,
0.0308370478,
-0.0866869837,
-0.0282267444,
-0.0152108911,
-0.0077449023,
0.0611098036,
-0.0397965834,
0.0173967164,
0.0322983153,
0.0465482175,
0.0425444804,
0.0679276735,
0.0056610303,
0.0424642265,
0.0595263354,
0.0041385265,
0.005279148,
0.0114016235,
0.0000534582,
-0.0104546985,
-0.0535200387,
-0.0094274553,
0.0191660486,
0.0326542556,
0.0550667979,
-0.011942328,
-0.0021521545,
-0.0470317528,
0.0311570037,
0.0561696291,
-0.0152133293,
-0.0027647216,
0.0434123911,
0.0431645028,
-0.0201014839,
-0.0385050029,
-0.0261734352,
-0.0213198941,
-0.0145287691,
0.0183909573,
0.0062414468,
-0.0118746553,
-0.0327556208,
-0.0221585799,
-0.0362155959,
-0.0179679506,
0.0419135913,
-0.006165084,
0.0778780282,
0.0296187866,
0.0315835476,
0.06169305,
0.0270893406,
-0.0340702273,
0.0133716809,
-0.048466187,
0.0164482631,
0.063159503,
-0.0130392872,
-0.0415013805,
0.0347513817,
0.025583623,
0.0774615556,
0.0288733765,
0.0144519303,
-0.0427102856,
0.0270664357,
-0.0409137644,
-0.0371971391,
-0.0181312375,
0.027956659,
-0.0253329836,
0.0328064784,
-0.001216859,
0.0613121316,
-0.1153976247,
0.0251307152,
0.0350537598,
0.0647615343,
0.010380662,
-0.0322236307,
0.0080239661,
-0.0002343772,
0.0151929967,
0.0123366257,
-0.0341136158,
0.0116657224,
-0.006799404,
0.0309856571,
0.0488891751,
-0.0558385588,
-0.0536905453,
0.0102089327,
-0.0094381319,
-0.0477637909,
0.0063252249,
-0.0833652094,
0.0012221849,
0.0344499983,
-0.0152081195,
0.0125103965,
-0.0276648365,
0.0004366287,
0.0005712821,
-0.0282362271,
-0.0462145992,
0.0858555734,
-0.0127981035,
-0.021825118,
-0.0201450251,
0.0302039571,
0.0043098722,
-0.018214114,
-0.0117291296,
-0.0119922878,
-0.0056898142,
0.0281756278,
-0.0092242761,
-0.0098979818,
-0.0495633334,
0.0351547338,
-0.0474335738,
-0.0397293232,
-0.0055662533,
-0.030294152,
0.0250969119,
-0.0004682771,
-0.0001610574,
-0.0256770998,
-0.0122094527,
0.0263219904,
-0.0594507121,
0.0081056636,
0.043256931,
-0.0166559592,
-0.0366135016,
0.0233977884,
0.0078969365,
0.012560579,
0.0622171536,
0.0067646001,
-0.0324066542,
-0.036212042,
0.0216911212,
0.0006691364,
-0.0061470345,
-0.0185570065,
0.0070389831,
-0.0014563848,
-0.0330636688,
-0.0175525993,
0.0375044532,
0.0125718862,
0.0428907238,
0.0141098285,
-0.0216240585,
-0.005910323,
-0.0238050055,
-0.0009749812,
0.0137993442,
-0.0380818583,
-0.0484241769,
0.030896496,
0.1138506755,
-0.0144935986,
0.0179229509,
-0.0439182669,
-0.0423750505,
-0.040522743,
-0.0552670844,
-0.0800235569,
0.0216199234,
0.0035296753,
0.0554251149,
-0.0458402932,
-0.0499526374,
0.0638371855,
-0.0469952673,
-0.0338548571,
-0.0075930264,
-0.0338280499,
-0.0263060369,
0.0810506195,
0.016103344,
0.0393406339,
0.010586,
-0.0184029508,
-0.0265277233,
-0.0357244536,
-0.0014739601,
0.0199565403,
0.0135357166,
-0.0819853321,
-0.0132544665,
0.0082271639,
0.0060187029,
-0.0290772319,
-0.0021117758,
-0.043876376,
0.0296959504,
-0.0050842832,
-0.001328922,
-0.0069238236,
0.0572059341,
0.0195001792,
0.0599195138,
0.0141260726,
-0.0188024472,
-0.008772172,
0.0234037917,
0.0464992635,
0.0058936607,
-0.063026078,
-0.0317448601,
-0.0132073052,
0.0582874157,
-0.0125596672,
-0.0367781073,
-0.0525369085,
0.0448231734,
0.0138244089,
-0.0281921439,
-0.027038347,
0.0144079514,
0.0664406419,
-0.0568387955,
-0.0504774228,
0.0910422951,
0.0534290932,
-0.0181215797,
-0.0059117163,
0.0032928921,
-0.0048172981,
0.0348289944,
-0.0295975357,
-0.0048463051,
-0.0579852574,
-0.0234339815,
0.0121850427,
0.0469589792,
-0.0156334601,
-0.0132255396,
-0.0676174164,
0.0369132049,
0.0007858404,
-0.1009103656,
-0.0598670021,
-0.0375990607,
0.0060948194,
-0.0191139523,
-0.0223089438,
-0.0185782462,
0.0049553411,
-0.0294208005,
0.0319938548,
-0.0370502137,
-0.0152355898,
0.0348104313,
-0.0291241165,
0.0297240689,
0.0403934494,
0.0180870071,
0.0065816594,
-0.0176644288,
0.0214711931,
-0.0559633784,
0.0083127683,
-0.0029359637,
0.027975319,
-0.0314927287,
0.0154745243,
0.0165178142,
0.0237388182,
-0.031135533,
-0.0517742783,
0.0041081468,
0.0405801013,
-0.0218617711,
-0.0069080777,
-0.0394178331,
-0.0013347014,
-0.0001639613,
0.0901230276,
0.0193841979,
-0.0051072636,
0.0110887466,
-0.0236696098,
-0.0129233366,
-0.0036685376,
0.0041677072,
-0.0280877035,
-0.0176357292,
-0.0403992198,
-0.0482338741,
-0.0371249393,
0.067185007,
-0.0027776016,
-0.0065039732,
-0.0465887897,
0.0059429877,
0.0055650035,
-0.1106336862,
0.0824810043,
-0.0642852262,
-0.0170546453,
-0.0242628995,
-0.010425183,
0.0526608564,
-0.0360996351,
-0.0522683673,
0.0348143466,
-0.0607799962,
-0.00606609,
-0.0029929567,
0.0418179221,
0.0128193637,
0.0715940073,
-0.0359392539,
-0.0346842669,
0.0416894928,
-0.0014503406,
-0.0200409163,
-0.0148599911,
0.0335163884,
0.0346601084,
0.0278691575,
0.0335024446,
-0.0609669387,
0.0384400599,
0.015361988,
-0.0255367067,
-0.0784220472,
-0.0385325812,
-0.0166770499,
-0.0226355549,
0.0431448519,
-0.0093111591,
0.0268943496,
-0.051846616,
-0.0066472916,
0.01011129,
-0.0245488733,
-0.0192754697,
0.0266199335,
0.0443831496,
-0.0026064408,
0.0134084001,
0.0344924033,
0.013648265,
0.0169120226,
0.0085914005,
-0.0338997021,
0.0283093601,
0.0523740016,
0.0057033012,
0.0393082649,
-0.018871503,
-0.0019842908,
-0.0310020782,
0.0305160303,
0.0011745507,
0.0536797717,
0.0151715167,
-0.0314027481,
-0.0562038384,
0.0671061799,
-0.0181699749,
0.0016046088,
-0.0259473994,
0.0744662583,
-0.0070331725,
-0.0142666232,
0.0230912138,
-0.0236188285,
-0.012765009,
-0.0173559394,
0.0606420822,
0.0516525283,
-0.082660988,
0.0290546454,
0.0328110978,
-0.0328367203,
-0.0490765944,
0.0462304056,
0.0132140117,
0.004776841,
-0.0005262396,
-0.0142985312,
-0.0504683852,
0.0221391115,
-0.008048146,
0.0498146899,
-0.0290584918,
0.0138586229,
-0.0438863412,
-0.0542263687,
0.0337534361,
-0.0469526947,
0.0030455657,
0.0779338107,
0.0722462609,
0.0549468361,
0.0036572595,
-0.0363046229,
-0.0032345608,
-0.0332643464,
0.0185240936,
-0.00715385,
0.0144670578,
-6.161081807e-33,
-0.0243057366,
-0.0285910163,
0.0052755321,
-0.0492913015,
0.0214593895,
-0.0055677034,
-0.0558594614,
-0.0042433357,
0.0042761858,
0.0240672659,
0.0124987271,
0.0150247207,
0.0175492633,
0.0529946573,
0.0055024964,
-0.0269279946,
0.0583738573,
0.0349454172,
-0.0343359746,
0.0458040498,
0.0336259902,
0.0072056125,
0.0733391345,
-0.0579159297,
0.0128640076,
0.005334192,
-0.0169357862,
0.0508713908,
0.0533570908,
0.0327335112,
-0.0451878607,
0.0476620831,
0.0419753864,
-0.0208061803,
-0.0351050012,
-0.0166315436,
-0.0880643055,
-0.0067462791,
0.0082157468,
0.0585019104,
-0.0225204397,
-0.003129052,
0.0168283023,
-0.0039603999,
0.0579223931,
-0.010583384,
0.0803987384,
-0.0455683768,
-0.0385578088,
-0.0251544882,
-0.0408275239,
0.0357602052,
-0.0097050481,
-0.0359337889,
0.0869344696,
-0.020004468,
0.0237815604,
0.0453215353,
-0.0425832383,
0.0315157846,
-0.0388517305,
-0.0130616184,
0.0766307786,
0.05869966,
0.0005849248,
0.0702218935,
-0.0018524452,
-0.0313462131,
-0.0183863919,
0.0334630087,
0.0127832368,
0.0548517816,
0.0069131549,
0.0359583609,
-0.010152624,
0.0031449096,
-0.0278745163,
0.0421630554,
-0.0385680571,
0.0091135111,
-0.0027241446,
0.0360102542,
-0.0630148947,
-0.0230316892,
0.0070773438,
-0.0475917272,
-0.043905057,
0.010863075,
0.0211019311,
-0.0120404502,
-0.0586750396,
0.0443060882,
-0.0045411801,
-0.0057443972,
0.0051826183,
0.0208574962,
0.0005699972,
0.0270599667,
-0.0106021576,
-0.0029021776,
-0.0106548164,
-0.0723481104,
0.040902596,
0.026419796,
0.01826673,
0.0184656903,
0.055211179,
-0.0166193713,
-0.0050650076,
0.0032129956,
-0.0247343387,
-0.0344018415,
-0.0210278817,
0.0347742401,
0.0192143675,
0.0107826442,
-0.0367421657,
0.0587191433,
0.0267656762,
-0.0215294156,
0.0275653061,
0.0043369727,
-0.0063635139,
0.0295256134,
-0.0280179568,
-0.0305861738,
0.0236190148,
-0.0657228827,
0.0726238117,
-0.0388086103,
-0.0073395763,
-0.0090502258,
2.673e-7,
0.0138925593,
0.0021264893,
0.0342007242,
-0.0005194905,
-0.0032436182,
0.0451245606,
0.0201872122,
0.0247984175,
-0.0383557342,
-0.0547018684,
0.0127488039,
0.0596105158,
0.0427414291,
0.0385678187,
-0.0892173424,
0.0523675904,
0.0082120681,
-0.0292056911,
-0.0622381009,
-0.0001395464,
0.0411532149,
0.0786392763,
0.024615759,
-0.015393571,
0.0237324405,
-0.0750477761,
-0.0116017424,
-0.0551654212,
0.0474252962,
0.0237031095,
0.0035287736,
0.0721949264,
0.0043884432,
0.0379771069,
0.0125638582,
-0.0421055071,
0.0551726706,
0.0792104006,
-0.0040305443,
0.0049965936,
-0.0255247504,
-0.0333477817,
0.0188093428,
-0.0666184202,
0.0444392115,
-0.0465748906,
0.0177650135,
0.0060246345,
0.016016759,
-0.0234559327,
-0.0110646719,
-0.0015626525,
-0.0132895065,
0.0224774182,
0.0130620124,
-0.0196793191,
-0.0068322644,
-0.0839171782,
-0.0543896891,
-0.0172782019,
-0.0366767123,
-0.0312750787,
0.003183485,
0.0445906892,
0.0113473358,
-0.038111385,
-0.037737079,
2.340811262e-34,
0.0235037524,
0.046814438,
-0.0417947583,
0.0124592558,
0.0287321378,
-0.0063242274,
-0.0547171049,
-0.0010146482,
-0.0170149934,
-0.0257458184,
0.0214367416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14211v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14211v1 | Experimenting with Large Language Models and vector embeddings in NASA SciX | 2023-12-21T10:19:58 | 2023-12-21T10:19:58 | Sergi Blanco-Cuaresma, Ioana Ciucă, Alberto Accomazzi, Michael J. Kurtz, Edwin A. Henneken, Kelly E. Lockhart, Felix Grezes, Thomas Allen, Golnaz Shapurian, Carolyn S. Grant, Donna M. Thompson, Timothy W. Hostetler, Matthew R. Templeton, Shinyi Chen, Jennifer Koch, Taylor Jacovich, Daniel Chivvis, Fernanda de Macedo Alves, Jean-Claude Paquin, Jennifer Bartlett, Mugdha Polimera, Stephanie Jarmak | cs.CL | cs.CL, astro-ph.IM, cs.AI | Open-source Large Language Models enable projects such as NASA SciX (i.e.,
NASA ADS) to think out of the box and try alternative approaches for
information retrieval and data augmentation, while respecting data copyright
and users' privacy. However, when large language models are directly prompted
with questions without any context, they are prone to hallucination. At NASA
SciX we have developed an experiment where we created semantic vectors for our
large collection of abstracts and full-text content, and we designed a prompt
system to ask questions using contextual chunks from our system. Based on a
non-systematic human evaluation, the experiment shows a lower degree of
hallucination and better responses when using Retrieval Augmented Generation.
Further exploration is required to design new features and data augmentation
processes at NASA SciX that leverages this technology while respecting the high
level of trust and quality that the project holds. | [
0.067080006,
0.0748906061,
-0.0037203722,
0.0365567841,
0.0094590671,
0.0033597173,
0.0240880866,
-0.0089776646,
0.0210919883,
-0.0471159443,
-0.0102875922,
-0.0426964946,
-0.0475078598,
0.0391227044,
0.0181651693,
-0.0377540179,
0.0390617661,
-0.0154392598,
0.0230792463,
-0.0205518566,
0.0243856143,
-0.0012446069,
0.0055286973,
0.0206777453,
0.0162604488,
-0.0298130382,
0.0105212918,
0.0107759852,
0.0024335254,
-0.0239588246,
-0.010314554,
0.0757581666,
0.0506179444,
0.0856889263,
0.0000018501,
-0.0904443488,
0.006120713,
0.0241886973,
-0.0367469676,
0.0102338176,
0.0591995269,
0.0296978857,
0.0216949638,
-0.0060427259,
-0.0431869067,
-0.0050206902,
0.0336510688,
0.0160906482,
0.0698585063,
0.0226540435,
-0.004139089,
-0.0320308805,
0.0111338235,
0.0103896922,
0.0614214204,
0.0056437282,
0.0037248901,
0.0208824258,
0.0654000863,
0.05861184,
0.0103863021,
0.0621347576,
0.0267762244,
-0.0088138031,
0.0530321263,
0.0338939168,
-0.0427746251,
-0.0174045451,
-0.0057930029,
0.0547202602,
0.0588428639,
0.0061125159,
0.0028212068,
0.0240006559,
0.0090958783,
0.0127786584,
-0.0900841877,
0.023675207,
-0.0118852155,
-0.0319740102,
0.0115002654,
-0.019367421,
0.0072414447,
0.0146450158,
-0.0116608785,
0.0805365667,
0.0314400196,
-0.0450118557,
-0.0268071629,
-0.0144391311,
0.0231802072,
-0.0396951884,
0.0095290821,
-0.0001194563,
-0.047324568,
0.0288418252,
-0.0136440489,
-0.0577806607,
0.0598458983,
-0.0698429048,
0.0058132587,
0.0324882157,
-0.0439549983,
0.0571961999,
-0.0007436518,
0.0352331772,
-0.0227453541,
0.0293801241,
-0.0399713181,
0.0010864247,
-0.0352597088,
-0.0369090848,
-0.043733459,
0.0536309704,
-0.0600062795,
-0.0349414982,
-0.0262453109,
0.0489910021,
0.0083538368,
0.0393226109,
-0.0526786409,
0.0329486132,
-0.0246592388,
-0.013043222,
-0.0170111954,
-0.0048305187,
-0.0407917202,
-0.0085957469,
0.039295081,
-0.0714274496,
0.0112047661,
0.0273390412,
0.0091249719,
-0.0225862898,
-0.0342669226,
0.0191254262,
0.0238273777,
-0.0321279876,
0.0057933461,
-0.0808955804,
0.0081053684,
-0.0215663835,
-0.0006398878,
-0.0547210351,
0.042081099,
0.0367515236,
-0.0338248499,
-0.0159384757,
0.0154623426,
0.0491404571,
-0.0494262762,
0.0625413731,
-0.0175136626,
-0.0036271908,
0.043130476,
0.0368151851,
0.0133367321,
0.0666360259,
-0.0287299808,
0.043733824,
0.0628019944,
0.002028561,
0.0323999301,
-0.0021885065,
-0.0165334828,
0.0187909529,
-0.0338407978,
0.0579954088,
0.0010481183,
0.0418886617,
-0.000637045,
0.0672080442,
-0.0404986478,
0.0175363868,
0.030667467,
0.0672195107,
0.0105552534,
-0.0209736042,
0.041744139,
0.0126408059,
-0.0067537562,
-0.0185066871,
-0.0347884893,
0.0187451597,
-0.0482681282,
-0.0107279234,
0.0492014289,
-0.0023787876,
-0.025942713,
-0.004067915,
-0.0280313678,
0.0288642254,
0.0277397539,
0.0204713512,
0.0120528871,
0.0212815106,
0.0008050438,
0.0160906017,
0.0043218243,
-0.0611137599,
0.0208073501,
-0.0124848131,
0.0469626226,
0.0773380399,
0.0993835703,
-0.0177390929,
-0.0075698835,
-0.0373954475,
0.0441091955,
0.0568088144,
0.0721133277,
-0.0103966119,
-0.050252974,
-0.0286199152,
-0.0423568711,
-0.0057580001,
0.0001837321,
-0.0013476193,
-0.0349210016,
0.0154651692,
0.0358461849,
-0.0230571534,
-0.0222193226,
0.0350232311,
-0.0387161747,
-0.0380554534,
-0.0313296989,
-0.0044085635,
0.0132678058,
0.0514902025,
-0.0007951848,
0.044230964,
0.0434759632,
-0.0357311964,
-0.0346087366,
0.0071983496,
-0.0316895694,
0.0171453245,
0.0141471596,
-0.0133096781,
0.0303476769,
0.0073242686,
0.0024430782,
-0.024761932,
0.0188343432,
-0.0590142161,
0.0465008728,
-0.0528129302,
-0.0135540143,
-0.016930636,
0.0285828076,
-0.0397477821,
0.051484108,
-0.0207495838,
0.0432343073,
0.0370107293,
0.0153235169,
0.0251218844,
-0.0503388681,
-0.0081901941,
0.0413466878,
-0.0129571063,
0.0014088599,
0.023808755,
-0.0818961188,
-0.0647265092,
0.03103026,
-0.0717149079,
0.0081219664,
-0.0342373215,
0.0118596461,
0.0070533957,
0.0180012137,
-0.009528216,
-0.0060414183,
-0.0505203903,
-0.022764938,
0.0088688582,
0.0620870329,
0.0149726169,
0.0248036589,
-0.0040761288,
-0.0113920178,
-0.0235212985,
-0.0207442529,
0.0481681861,
0.0380220264,
-0.0111720022,
-0.098251991,
0.0322197154,
-0.0483730286,
-0.0201809537,
-0.0082124732,
0.0174280889,
0.0205848161,
-0.0554409735,
0.023943495,
0.0176579021,
0.0390320793,
0.0257439539,
0.0242444351,
-0.0150119085,
-0.0505123474,
-0.0073414152,
-0.0396542735,
-0.0013107697,
-0.0099767586,
0.0151138529,
0.0366989151,
-0.0209702794,
-0.0102396915,
0.0023304881,
-0.0308625922,
0.0568448864,
-0.0502821505,
-0.0357006527,
-0.0676829442,
-0.0398731343,
-0.0292468499,
0.0588562824,
-0.0060044527,
-0.015817102,
0.07485006,
-0.0119850487,
-0.0299030505,
-0.0488825589,
0.0080762925,
-0.0357011594,
0.0276838951,
-0.017703874,
0.0450020023,
-0.024686303,
-0.0202596523,
-0.0047574448,
0.0162431244,
-0.0183819458,
-0.0640287921,
-0.0070450921,
-0.0045382283,
-0.0181535166,
-0.0140807964,
0.0027514047,
-0.0793580711,
-0.0488499962,
-0.0046955468,
0.0003720183,
0.0235985219,
-0.0135884294,
-0.0396634862,
0.0045939195,
0.0437191613,
0.0292613097,
-0.0143056568,
-0.025928203,
-0.0154929748,
0.0358948112,
0.0602530763,
0.0217259899,
0.0207522139,
-0.0020035682,
0.0003867162,
0.0511631295,
0.0479988679,
-0.0252605248,
-0.0041671395,
-0.0209726319,
0.0418454669,
-0.0420541316,
-0.0048605041,
0.0048832139,
0.0528411418,
-0.0487487875,
-0.0127106896,
0.0803115964,
0.0658765957,
-0.0395649299,
-0.0103907408,
-0.0453398228,
-0.0134531818,
0.0296171345,
0.0282118265,
-0.1157334074,
0.0135741141,
0.0044032326,
0.0270206332,
0.001200887,
-0.0255509242,
-0.0096328612,
-0.0922968015,
0.0588582903,
-0.0100637386,
-0.0457677245,
-0.0157880839,
-0.0683903918,
0.0131177632,
0.0267944243,
0.0096868034,
0.0226899274,
-0.0074461596,
-0.0097696446,
-0.0054978156,
0.0135824075,
-0.0591391325,
-0.0070400713,
-0.0361595377,
0.0403951667,
0.0782559812,
0.031370163,
-0.0063286345,
-0.1177714691,
-0.0187767688,
-0.0543737635,
0.0102928067,
0.0046757152,
0.0308295749,
-0.003074374,
0.0271418933,
-0.0309234131,
0.0720697343,
-0.0247712526,
-0.0065603144,
-0.0209839791,
0.0668384135,
-0.043339856,
-0.0027710618,
-0.0703035891,
-0.0094726691,
0.0142840538,
0.0742954984,
0.018732775,
-0.0498720482,
0.0110046593,
-0.0310962051,
0.0339303315,
-0.007187753,
-0.0180383045,
0.0078239469,
0.0368654132,
-0.0000432215,
-0.079288803,
-0.0561999977,
0.0041906149,
0.0197443403,
0.0005014605,
0.0399972498,
-0.0387190059,
-0.0164798778,
-0.0316218063,
0.0420740359,
-0.0300071724,
0.0156198237,
-0.0093339626,
0.0172152929,
0.0032280271,
-0.0234269686,
-0.0227024406,
0.0221749377,
-0.0107665528,
-0.049623996,
0.025628861,
0.0225009639,
0.0325022116,
0.0054898565,
-0.0193563141,
-0.0466875695,
0.0697746202,
0.0798253939,
-0.0134839751,
-0.0112875905,
-0.0215880256,
0.0285454243,
-0.0075319787,
0.0080530541,
-0.0631021634,
0.0013072971,
-0.0025053148,
0.0233829059,
0.0040824707,
-0.0255006198,
0.022783434,
0.0595234297,
0.0188111421,
-0.0208710879,
0.0270122718,
-0.0314940177,
0.0040526181,
-0.0485218354,
-0.0204805229,
-0.0049842205,
0.029048292,
-0.0115125328,
-0.0359266773,
0.0430818237,
0.0266331527,
-0.0468552299,
0.0391225331,
-0.0502722822,
0.0045775161,
0.0045785941,
0.0020844289,
0.0496479273,
0.0092641301,
-0.0268423706,
0.0108368779,
-0.0222502295,
0.0464091711,
-0.0197579339,
0.0694217831,
0.0292598084,
-0.0216201097,
-0.015945863,
0.0346991979,
-0.0942743272,
-0.0938047618,
-0.0220287498,
0.0176026579,
-0.0114236753,
0.0310055297,
0.0078316722,
-0.0348124839,
-0.0131643079,
0.0084847845,
-0.0131404921,
0.0501063652,
-0.06165139,
0.0387026668,
0.0496006459,
-0.019061124,
-0.0246287212,
0.0480193831,
-0.0450533107,
0.0319075435,
-0.0280570667,
-0.0089543834,
-0.0639145151,
-0.0249145087,
0.0056569241,
0.0561183058,
-0.0502121113,
-0.0103804674,
-0.0760844797,
-0.0232568476,
-0.0188538972,
-0.0065027415,
-0.0269219037,
-0.012503338,
0.0446091741,
0.0468007997,
0.0029816057,
-0.0492780581,
-0.0179132205,
0.0340615958,
-0.0862393007,
-0.0476904474,
-0.0198326986,
-6.454206017e-33,
0.0283360146,
-0.0143487584,
0.0159542914,
-0.0374385789,
-0.018500153,
-0.0120367119,
-0.0229678117,
0.0047577489,
0.0092251273,
-0.0094408831,
-0.0123290205,
-0.0183336996,
0.0119255707,
0.0297392011,
-0.0017479374,
-0.0041240952,
0.0563054644,
0.0011328498,
-0.0242033526,
0.0567072704,
0.050645303,
0.0254914705,
-0.0341076627,
-0.1092742831,
0.0720504671,
-0.0540999845,
0.0018790341,
0.041520685,
0.0139722181,
0.0521057211,
-0.0605919734,
0.0497401096,
0.0013348145,
-0.0741345063,
-0.00391101,
0.0556260608,
-0.018692039,
-0.0033025814,
0.0269563943,
-0.0051164413,
-0.0609762929,
-0.0352944471,
0.0133732483,
-0.0326538943,
0.0086723845,
0.0412333161,
0.0390312634,
-0.0201568101,
-0.0363697857,
-0.029068023,
-0.0633400753,
-0.0002248286,
0.01044014,
0.0211558715,
0.0341330469,
0.0482781641,
0.0103607159,
0.0522630848,
-0.0371594802,
0.0324858353,
-0.030151194,
-0.0298574436,
0.0725947022,
-0.0065870648,
0.0043406747,
0.0526062697,
0.0388298295,
0.0229698177,
-0.0164838284,
-0.0185934138,
-0.008419862,
0.0241914932,
0.0313620828,
0.0548894294,
0.0471997112,
-0.0296783093,
0.016915014,
0.0203036927,
-0.0418675207,
0.0145556843,
0.0592913404,
0.0031774398,
-0.0560658164,
0.0053724828,
-0.0097261574,
-0.0017320003,
-0.0596035868,
-0.0573745258,
0.028442286,
0.0139548779,
-0.0565026142,
0.0259627849,
0.0209208298,
-0.0414875299,
-0.0106268069,
0.035253197,
0.0003775091,
-0.0169831496,
-0.0088037318,
-0.0095496131,
-0.0325379297,
0.0180879068,
0.0497660451,
0.0001227536,
-0.0056260605,
-0.0051945522,
0.0226679966,
-0.0011053729,
-0.0415763631,
0.0074203522,
-0.0157143343,
0.0071743433,
-0.0081534386,
-0.0211323258,
0.0311320089,
0.0167006329,
-0.0086369989,
0.0177477151,
0.0613161214,
0.035758812,
-0.0315108858,
-0.0350640826,
-0.0234370753,
0.0112191718,
-0.01830961,
-0.0010479109,
-0.0146574983,
0.0338151976,
0.0583438799,
-0.0582096614,
-0.0004171879,
-0.0036430547,
2.679e-7,
0.0183606874,
0.0399126299,
0.0125441849,
-0.0340552405,
0.0180872902,
0.0114444625,
0.0334902704,
0.0477723256,
0.0139612053,
-0.0142327612,
-0.0204804037,
0.0107650319,
0.0326999538,
0.0446992181,
-0.1185323745,
-0.0418430567,
-0.0462619551,
-0.0178836565,
-0.0750304833,
-0.0001892721,
0.0780867487,
0.0506462865,
-0.0098929452,
-0.0328571498,
0.0219570845,
-0.0716528296,
0.0322423913,
0.0112269251,
-0.0035561437,
0.0260113683,
0.0162533708,
0.0758326352,
0.0155423535,
-0.0072687054,
0.0032996503,
-0.0053856303,
0.0034896196,
0.0003883611,
0.0149778835,
-0.0350182839,
-0.0102975797,
-0.0095044784,
0.0396227315,
-0.055359114,
0.0476102531,
-0.0411570929,
-0.0157958977,
0.0002262227,
-0.0310272221,
-0.0103917485,
0.0018460621,
-0.0393761694,
-0.0007971739,
-0.0073807035,
0.0028370267,
0.0063224738,
0.0055508367,
-0.0824151933,
-0.0090128975,
0.0011748074,
-0.051595822,
-0.0616894364,
-0.0242957287,
0.0146567887,
0.0034177518,
-0.064923197,
0.0154331103,
2.426668956e-34,
0.0393902771,
0.0204364713,
-0.0083279153,
0.0152760614,
0.0067722895,
0.0001976639,
0.0329160765,
0.0112703638,
0.0439658314,
-0.0808493122,
-0.0003011785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13694v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13694v1 | Data Transformation to Construct a Dataset for Generating Entity-Relationship Model from Natural Language | 2023-12-21T09:45:13 | 2023-12-21T09:45:13 | Zhenwen Li, Jian-Guang Lou, Tao Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL | In order to reduce the manual cost of designing ER models, recent approaches
have been proposed to address the task of NL2ERM, i.e., automatically
generating entity-relationship (ER) models from natural language (NL)
utterances such as software requirements. These approaches are typically
rule-based ones, which rely on rigid heuristic rules; these approaches cannot
generalize well to various linguistic ways of describing the same requirement.
Despite having better generalization capability than rule-based approaches,
deep-learning-based models are lacking for NL2ERM due to lacking a large-scale
dataset. To address this issue, in this paper, we report our insight that there
exists a high similarity between the task of NL2ERM and the increasingly
popular task of text-to-SQL, and propose a data transformation algorithm that
transforms the existing data of text-to-SQL into the data of NL2ERM. We apply
our data transformation algorithm on Spider, one of the most popular
text-to-SQL datasets, and we also collect some data entries with different NL
types, to obtain a large-scale NL2ERM dataset. Because NL2ERM can be seen as a
special information extraction (IE) task, we train two state-of-the-art IE
models on our dataset. The experimental results show that both the two models
achieve high performance and outperform existing baselines. | [
0.0752105638,
0.0830457583,
-0.0001092718,
0.0524804927,
-0.0303962044,
-0.0163115114,
-0.0545387119,
-0.0149997566,
-0.009952344,
-0.0523489602,
0.0009880636,
-0.0046085529,
-0.0135976132,
0.0425036028,
0.0024538834,
-0.0350927189,
-0.000623476,
0.0302642398,
-0.0244157165,
0.0486659445,
0.0164741874,
0.0709928349,
-0.0046099056,
0.0114154499,
-0.035953559,
-0.0068049952,
-0.0226949565,
0.0304084718,
-0.0018449927,
-0.0442949906,
0.0059576686,
0.0231367983,
0.0074335998,
-0.0427599102,
0.000001994,
-0.0533100665,
-0.0820293203,
-0.0256821159,
-0.0352792963,
0.0057425471,
0.0308178253,
-0.0534088649,
0.0150737446,
0.0472658388,
-0.0535491779,
-0.0126830172,
0.0223530158,
0.0797357187,
0.0386354141,
0.0789831951,
-0.0396379344,
-0.0431638695,
0.0416590199,
-0.0394997634,
0.0004584086,
-0.0239332058,
0.0183469523,
0.0119045405,
-0.0140435724,
0.0321217813,
0.0343642235,
0.0002433397,
0.0177090932,
-0.0019442315,
0.0309139602,
0.0019981239,
-0.0247705374,
-0.0085525466,
-0.009804952,
0.1062884405,
-0.0271264575,
0.0126052173,
0.0305135921,
0.0040222751,
0.0031008236,
0.0077155377,
0.0191288851,
0.0118855648,
-0.0138244424,
0.0220484156,
0.0130094634,
-0.0138751436,
0.0082361782,
-0.0234933682,
-0.0507244803,
0.0473293252,
-0.0160232373,
-0.0239575803,
0.0161585975,
-0.0430923253,
-0.0109200897,
-0.0330308229,
0.031252373,
0.0359149612,
-0.0301394779,
0.0477832071,
-0.0548159927,
0.0020456514,
0.0093372623,
-0.0337342843,
-0.0001846554,
-0.0206204616,
0.0046839868,
0.0353007726,
-0.0403824821,
0.0128504476,
0.0034094043,
-0.0179890003,
-0.0334020853,
-0.0210894439,
-0.0466020927,
0.0034136705,
-0.0347382762,
0.0762229413,
-0.0337640606,
-0.0301453732,
-0.0421324857,
0.0164875612,
-0.016953459,
0.0559484139,
0.0178685281,
0.0607490018,
-0.0235700123,
-0.0240683667,
-0.066065751,
-0.034124352,
-0.0066033774,
0.0169218313,
-0.0290694907,
-0.0245116781,
0.0355203152,
-0.0081531685,
0.038838543,
-0.0147694899,
0.0299270544,
0.0636145845,
0.0585124381,
-0.0113929631,
-0.0877698287,
-0.0560638867,
0.0282365046,
-0.0203109328,
-0.0073490785,
-0.0427482761,
0.0520055071,
-0.0085509904,
-0.0372462906,
-0.05901381,
0.0378591716,
0.0114967655,
-0.0360632055,
0.0774514675,
-0.0689064115,
0.0290589444,
0.0106724678,
0.0008016155,
0.0341335498,
0.0198641438,
0.0808359161,
-0.0074036419,
0.0509845205,
-0.0036977248,
-0.0000337681,
0.0457129106,
0.0018338745,
-0.0282075945,
0.0093782181,
0.0426923558,
-0.0407040007,
0.0065948949,
0.0244933795,
0.0673316941,
0.0158147812,
-0.0056785434,
0.0129145132,
-0.0000583132,
0.0554254316,
0.0361008383,
0.0438704714,
0.0759886056,
-0.0085382117,
-0.0154741546,
0.0011834032,
0.0122385686,
0.0070299469,
0.0094858287,
-0.0302781295,
0.0060245646,
-0.0534397885,
-0.0342352614,
0.026488794,
-0.0446064174,
-0.000306756,
-0.0082217716,
0.0480132625,
0.0473707318,
-0.0657912493,
0.0867249742,
0.024855515,
-0.0106999744,
0.0094710886,
0.0115380688,
-0.0112018427,
0.0560030155,
0.0365391411,
-0.0668848082,
0.0029659353,
-0.0198880229,
-0.0344416574,
0.0576115623,
0.0315801054,
-0.0330879651,
-0.0068436228,
-0.0266094953,
-0.0185543802,
-0.0180905033,
-0.0152840717,
-0.0237501021,
0.0179344825,
0.005002562,
0.0379750989,
-0.0022826581,
-0.0318152271,
0.0506668054,
-0.0496870913,
-0.0143245906,
0.0360107124,
0.0335304141,
0.0145505592,
0.0501297414,
-0.0146350544,
0.0212341473,
0.054344669,
-0.026849702,
-0.0389391296,
-0.0268561915,
-0.0092825275,
-0.0124212801,
0.0109435944,
-0.0421792492,
0.0219236501,
0.0139511004,
-0.0393872671,
-0.0362701453,
-0.0220873058,
0.001183842,
0.0210782643,
0.0161671601,
0.0110117467,
0.0319850408,
-0.0049294871,
-0.0241316482,
0.042617809,
0.0160323624,
0.0029202718,
-0.0181462076,
-0.0406709127,
0.0046709115,
-0.0019902124,
0.0013020657,
-0.0164165739,
-0.0494444519,
0.017289266,
0.0202654488,
0.0393236987,
-0.053819716,
-0.0042522037,
-0.0459782109,
0.0269739721,
0.023744477,
0.0459704585,
0.0325546451,
0.0009503748,
0.0006745015,
-0.0026096629,
-0.0513668582,
-0.0169556625,
-0.0494477525,
-0.052885849,
0.055792734,
0.0072493446,
-0.0230187364,
-0.032123968,
0.0062885168,
-0.0409724861,
0.0275175273,
0.000801982,
-0.0240323767,
-0.0438743308,
0.0944886506,
-0.0142666828,
0.0447052419,
0.0110249463,
0.0197014529,
-0.0055348421,
-0.0025596458,
0.0520350263,
-0.0236728415,
0.0111943372,
0.0037595094,
-0.0077114268,
0.0107417172,
-0.0451304279,
0.0107043302,
-0.0282871723,
0.0642757118,
0.0069246865,
-0.0772390887,
0.0478502735,
0.0109830098,
0.0032302386,
0.0014804117,
-0.0244634803,
0.0208441932,
0.0441877171,
0.0352073871,
0.001272358,
0.0068074251,
0.0236760098,
0.0232464168,
-0.0292715151,
0.0210100599,
0.0404598638,
-0.0244517773,
0.0129836099,
-0.0409964137,
-0.0144749554,
-0.0556761324,
0.0844279677,
0.0170636289,
0.0184512157,
0.0396550484,
-0.0269282181,
-0.0514552183,
0.0127952546,
-0.008313071,
-0.0169674382,
0.0691537112,
-0.0348984227,
0.0161519367,
-0.0059875385,
0.0077250046,
-0.0628905967,
0.0140647832,
-0.0057709776,
0.022469651,
0.0234697368,
-0.0006971632,
-0.0064207264,
-0.0028225493,
-0.0284675863,
0.038481798,
0.0334167965,
-0.032282088,
-0.0127536077,
0.0039417609,
0.1021164134,
-0.0052022012,
0.0012167909,
0.0385870785,
0.0438687056,
0.0186836217,
-0.0021468354,
0.0240879674,
-0.0359008051,
-0.026913885,
-0.0164974015,
-0.0407337397,
0.0249216668,
0.0179360006,
-0.0240656864,
-0.0403077938,
0.0071652061,
0.0817662925,
0.0248219352,
0.0159341022,
0.0274432413,
0.0407883786,
0.0139623331,
0.041864574,
0.0187448785,
-0.091142945,
-0.0171457566,
-0.0365218185,
-0.0082009416,
0.0301254354,
-0.0506605133,
-0.0182019845,
-0.1271716207,
-0.001400627,
-0.0409555137,
-0.0433506966,
-0.0334060192,
-0.0389230847,
-0.022484947,
-0.0212133992,
0.0112967584,
0.0104505168,
-0.0371756032,
-0.0323719755,
-0.0036557782,
-0.0820042491,
-0.047442425,
0.0303133633,
-0.0673427805,
0.018381197,
0.0439327024,
0.0297942348,
-0.0020542785,
0.0365965143,
0.005648375,
0.0100884195,
-0.0344073698,
-0.0011512336,
0.084744826,
-0.0136562511,
-0.0137334056,
0.0031313137,
0.0202273075,
-0.1025858074,
0.0253771693,
0.0170684159,
0.0585454032,
-0.0091057569,
0.0094673494,
-0.0178535003,
-0.0281533524,
0.009099911,
0.0781165361,
-0.0045528398,
-0.0527261272,
-0.0089246212,
-0.0023595549,
0.001835937,
-0.084841609,
-0.0259434879,
0.0144157102,
-0.0462805852,
0.0132132666,
-0.0921388417,
-0.0520141721,
0.0450837538,
0.0082407398,
0.0426059179,
0.0239750203,
0.0783849955,
-0.0278016031,
-0.059550833,
0.0151841557,
-0.0006759154,
0.0059998343,
-0.0014258906,
-0.0272620898,
0.005027201,
-0.0080105718,
-0.0179405212,
-0.0340213142,
-0.037948288,
-0.0096644601,
-0.0524327904,
0.0051666643,
0.0151432464,
0.0381522812,
-0.0041608992,
-0.0007969924,
-0.0255513489,
0.0565825552,
-0.066332683,
-0.0966637507,
0.0060195797,
0.0157428551,
-0.0302867815,
0.0439751148,
-0.0501218699,
0.002893904,
-0.0157398656,
0.0465054475,
-0.0178317111,
-0.0321269482,
0.0551466458,
0.0002479026,
0.0032274195,
0.0321935751,
-0.0125042815,
-0.066661343,
0.0240852386,
-0.0340366848,
-0.0193740968,
-0.0800331831,
0.0542018563,
0.0398049839,
-0.0022450946,
0.02283879,
-0.0342687517,
0.0062424731,
0.0157549884,
-0.0071466495,
-0.0170247853,
0.0298363473,
0.0283296481,
0.0332360268,
-0.0321540609,
0.0070291013,
0.0152772609,
0.0175726097,
0.0192931257,
-0.0136493864,
-0.0005491195,
0.0221176855,
0.0193722378,
-0.0096162148,
0.004119494,
0.0298352353,
-0.0178196132,
-0.0293632373,
-0.0314743631,
0.0405661091,
-0.0050502704,
0.0339707211,
-0.0340487361,
0.0183461383,
-0.0113251526,
0.0590596348,
-0.0165231302,
0.0046439129,
0.0232349504,
0.0194668435,
-0.0534757823,
0.0114710247,
0.0409319587,
-0.0038840238,
0.0447105207,
-0.0323124342,
-0.0354176685,
-0.0804534107,
-0.0007265328,
0.0226940606,
-0.0190932825,
-0.0592068918,
0.0047503845,
-0.0298560765,
-0.0426893681,
-0.0120793367,
-0.0086649666,
0.006931209,
0.0120704724,
0.0513912998,
0.0579327978,
0.0171062723,
-0.0128572518,
-0.0352553837,
-0.0269418173,
-0.0473331548,
-0.0633820072,
-0.027918255,
-5.885042672e-33,
-0.0059029981,
-0.0398543403,
0.0174016654,
0.0050594853,
0.0195816644,
0.015517557,
-0.0175098591,
-0.0189761762,
-0.0474049337,
-0.0058044204,
-0.0062804613,
0.0054474664,
0.0132841375,
0.0164040439,
0.0032461577,
-0.0200558472,
0.0167161599,
-0.0156147387,
0.0181120392,
0.0242721271,
0.007634507,
0.0550314747,
0.0573936477,
-0.0938934758,
0.0236394443,
-0.0098174186,
-0.0160305984,
0.0334508196,
0.0195777286,
0.0714571625,
-0.0276990458,
0.0436421335,
0.0265328195,
-0.049727302,
0.0161476806,
0.0085595399,
-0.1075752154,
-0.0117986631,
-0.0303920936,
-0.0193217732,
-0.0323946662,
-0.0048852772,
0.0808892548,
0.0019599348,
0.0429742374,
-0.0018571558,
0.0672453344,
-0.0248366389,
0.0153851071,
-0.0605868176,
-0.0802153796,
0.014479191,
0.0205618981,
-0.0189205967,
0.0068107164,
0.0586066879,
0.0117741358,
-0.0047056009,
-0.0461193062,
-0.0197534617,
0.0149634816,
0.0348647423,
0.0231024008,
-0.014945887,
-0.0153802708,
0.0282656122,
0.0012500937,
0.0062357085,
-0.0252682641,
0.0475806631,
0.0070296335,
0.1304344982,
-0.0075376397,
-0.0191454608,
0.0128971878,
0.0086564776,
-0.0973117724,
0.0479301661,
-0.0142593905,
0.0312168635,
0.0008652792,
-0.0260420013,
-0.0349253155,
-0.0029292633,
0.0135668889,
0.0190954506,
-0.0318273678,
-0.0213872716,
0.0398956835,
0.0384599976,
-0.0107829794,
0.0123075116,
-0.0129394736,
-0.0660193637,
-0.0699974671,
0.0335280001,
-0.0493143201,
-0.0083141886,
-0.0083705792,
-0.0005211023,
-0.0437337533,
-0.0482818522,
0.0184997059,
-0.0098951114,
0.0269616246,
0.0678906664,
0.0517159663,
-0.0038239888,
-0.0537131391,
0.010267511,
-0.0281751473,
0.0016305661,
-0.0464773551,
0.0504144095,
-0.0132420259,
0.0085463123,
-0.0137327835,
0.0351985246,
0.0122276871,
-0.0211021882,
-0.0367560461,
0.0293495711,
0.0166154746,
0.0490059331,
0.00950367,
-0.0286145229,
-0.0318554863,
-0.0221304055,
0.0363901146,
-0.0221099015,
-0.0364991091,
-0.0178497378,
2.647e-7,
0.0452682562,
0.0224515386,
0.0392574109,
0.0677551851,
-0.0081600863,
0.0386860333,
0.0130864251,
0.0268426389,
-0.0108416118,
-0.0346330106,
0.0278083626,
-0.0065096989,
0.0242768303,
0.0232539102,
-0.0956685096,
-0.0478687845,
-0.0241236798,
-0.0290284343,
-0.0701763257,
-0.0078172321,
0.1106898487,
0.0870487168,
0.02276605,
-0.0257277023,
-0.0355472192,
-0.0125436438,
-0.0092760557,
-0.0371485725,
0.0241693165,
0.0873384774,
0.0435246862,
0.0282944348,
-0.0572746918,
0.043616388,
-0.0236548129,
0.0183381699,
-0.000835532,
0.0636237785,
-0.0014746176,
-0.0002459206,
0.0230247378,
-0.0582040325,
0.0180054642,
-0.0344822966,
0.0551486015,
-0.0333045051,
-0.0071405577,
0.0359612778,
-0.0211618971,
0.014825155,
-0.0289684776,
-0.0083796391,
0.0274405405,
-0.0349137895,
0.0346670039,
-0.0326301157,
-0.0401208699,
-0.0732827336,
0.0179163143,
0.0817802995,
-0.0152505487,
0.0227766111,
-0.0093578026,
-0.0038379682,
-0.0004610544,
-0.0094854767,
0.039423693,
2.372991798e-34,
-0.0129886093,
0.0160679314,
-0.008272565,
0.0218534023,
0.0510580726,
-0.0261932164,
-0.0448865108,
-0.0018541735,
-0.0549338683,
-0.0418542735,
-0.021893885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13671v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13671v1 | Text2Analysis: A Benchmark of Table Question Answering with Advanced Data Analysis and Unclear Queries | 2023-12-21T08:50:41 | 2023-12-21T08:50:41 | Xinyi He, Mengyu Zhou, Xinrun Xu, Xiaojun Ma, Rui Ding, Lun Du, Yan Gao, Ran Jia, Xu Chen, Shi Han, Zejian Yuan, Dongmei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Tabular data analysis is crucial in various fields, and large language models
show promise in this area. However, current research mostly focuses on
rudimentary tasks like Text2SQL and TableQA, neglecting advanced analysis like
forecasting and chart generation. To address this gap, we developed the
Text2Analysis benchmark, incorporating advanced analysis tasks that go beyond
the SQL-compatible operations and require more in-depth analysis. We also
develop five innovative and effective annotation methods, harnessing the
capabilities of large language models to enhance data quality and quantity.
Additionally, we include unclear queries that resemble real-world user
questions to test how well models can understand and tackle such challenges.
Finally, we collect 2249 query-result pairs with 347 tables. We evaluate five
state-of-the-art models using three different metrics and the results show that
our benchmark presents introduces considerable challenge in the field of
tabular data analysis, paving the way for more advanced research opportunities. | [
0.0388799682,
0.0845352337,
-0.0082175694,
0.0235937871,
-0.0185417645,
0.0444171689,
-0.0202350039,
0.0059893704,
0.0028300821,
-0.0142841302,
-0.0023780747,
-0.0251422226,
-0.039376922,
0.0255160518,
0.0354374573,
0.0020115161,
0.0408832356,
0.0081949383,
-0.0500729978,
0.034698192,
0.0306962803,
-0.0073027587,
-0.0139822494,
0.0230785199,
-0.0008870039,
0.000134009,
-0.0444520265,
0.007369007,
-0.029346196,
-0.0021641909,
0.0114269806,
0.070097059,
0.0020183127,
0.0567517653,
0.0000018228,
-0.0045154933,
-0.0458844602,
-0.0045784484,
-0.0112825381,
0.0204052776,
0.0218642708,
-0.0137710152,
0.0392138213,
0.0040276498,
-0.0597701855,
0.0141681489,
0.0140184453,
0.0322914831,
0.0658034533,
0.0344660692,
0.0006851617,
-0.021915894,
-0.0275661461,
-0.0068725138,
0.0573982224,
-0.0803536475,
-0.000226745,
0.0036633194,
0.022097433,
-0.0179067571,
0.0105477367,
0.0562926419,
0.0181317795,
0.0080154566,
-0.0002202768,
0.0303753614,
-0.0719191134,
0.0232794099,
0.0091334125,
0.0958607644,
0.0241358131,
-0.0188218337,
-0.0021399381,
0.0014035419,
0.0088648498,
-0.0064071948,
-0.0338594206,
-0.0373074263,
-0.0121955918,
-0.0242407117,
0.0032011296,
-0.0033613516,
0.0057022069,
0.0012183083,
-0.0430254303,
0.0618517809,
-0.0128151076,
-0.0390621684,
0.0394720733,
-0.0040873028,
-0.0344522595,
-0.0241318196,
0.0148280617,
0.0483910069,
-0.047569681,
0.0333025567,
0.0211969651,
-0.0577909127,
0.0237114541,
-0.0621587038,
0.0303382799,
0.045968473,
0.0079541951,
0.0427966192,
-0.0184410755,
0.0243688021,
0.0074053905,
0.0208911877,
-0.0523371436,
-0.0456718057,
-0.0345834605,
-0.0207786188,
-0.0759728104,
0.0046559931,
-0.0577136129,
-0.0087784361,
0.0215874985,
-0.0027150998,
-0.0081237694,
0.0276946574,
0.0063510286,
0.0473861881,
-0.0206441227,
0.024168225,
-0.0577391759,
0.0024050055,
-0.0629766062,
0.0032442934,
-0.02120311,
-0.0948450118,
-0.0084625641,
-0.0117390817,
0.0076766424,
-0.0338910632,
0.045022022,
0.0533008389,
-0.0435587987,
-0.0044622621,
-0.0300355479,
-0.0319733769,
-0.0162593871,
-0.0284605995,
-0.0220730975,
-0.0484241359,
0.0663914233,
0.0311150663,
-0.0091645932,
-0.0369814932,
0.0106493412,
0.0594344698,
-0.0276988205,
0.0742008761,
0.0117871109,
0.0338039212,
0.0036267312,
-0.0032105998,
-0.0171312001,
0.0963341966,
0.0174305849,
0.0110757435,
0.0039271549,
-0.014423199,
0.0077777002,
0.0604738928,
0.0510281399,
0.004766488,
-0.0310686026,
0.0787490234,
0.0007234473,
0.0345983915,
-0.0210431237,
0.0322121605,
-0.0004170905,
0.0113411536,
0.0114534963,
0.0440625511,
-0.0231057368,
0.0294388924,
0.0248240922,
-0.004309942,
0.0321855471,
-0.002265309,
0.0070843054,
0.0149261011,
0.0109372279,
-0.0053147674,
0.0280873068,
-0.0195904765,
-0.033757627,
-0.0513504595,
-0.0015576592,
0.0307247248,
-0.0143140843,
0.0044635166,
0.0076722498,
0.0132450834,
-0.0433484875,
0.0068542096,
0.0034483843,
-0.0324557833,
0.006665803,
0.010190255,
0.0267482754,
0.0471087992,
0.0330359936,
-0.062905252,
-0.0001248846,
-0.000835069,
0.0381064862,
-0.0032568141,
0.0449238196,
-0.0501971543,
-0.0064531933,
-0.0028381106,
-0.0184046701,
0.0305736437,
0.0212028455,
-0.0299351793,
0.0235041417,
0.0024205886,
-0.0111668631,
-0.078991808,
-0.0369692855,
0.0066936221,
0.0213226452,
-0.0085674506,
-0.0090576205,
0.0018237642,
-0.001016909,
0.022225596,
0.0169945527,
0.0543630309,
0.0447944775,
-0.0280717537,
-0.0076512336,
-0.0097876098,
0.0134308971,
0.0078696962,
0.0222618971,
-0.0068910019,
-0.0597016215,
0.0050520664,
-0.0451747142,
-0.03518641,
-0.0046449318,
-0.0588312075,
-0.0117637962,
-0.0320382565,
-0.010817132,
-0.0062144171,
0.0065775337,
-0.0393461958,
0.080069676,
-0.0112539427,
0.0642495453,
0.0147702647,
-0.0866537541,
0.0168098621,
-0.010652612,
0.0039941291,
-0.0463032611,
-0.0122999754,
0.0434601791,
0.0046932134,
-0.0007545588,
-0.0904217437,
0.0063018757,
-0.1015957817,
0.0415597484,
-0.053047549,
0.0362337492,
0.0474109985,
0.0193838179,
-0.0177031737,
-0.0302364156,
-0.077728048,
-0.0208072979,
-0.0004922987,
0.0269192159,
0.0719587579,
0.0271231625,
0.0014932846,
-0.0416233353,
-0.0123519329,
-0.0408850648,
0.026525218,
-0.0062393411,
-0.0307154916,
0.0131344888,
-0.025580164,
-0.0082398951,
0.0235441532,
0.0060498379,
-0.0050425986,
-0.0060947384,
-0.0407252647,
0.030946631,
0.025903523,
0.0017430757,
-0.000413504,
-0.0025177437,
-0.0046579582,
-0.0491297729,
0.0307500064,
-0.0058176601,
0.006608068,
-0.0066440245,
-0.0807212964,
0.0478052124,
0.040445976,
-0.0253675375,
0.0030224859,
-0.0308880042,
0.0202715453,
-0.0097879544,
0.0042533968,
-0.1017986834,
0.0805670992,
0.004153016,
0.0200995114,
-0.0181803163,
0.0125213591,
0.0320833214,
-0.0212155674,
0.00615471,
-0.0457150936,
0.0107877105,
-0.0436015762,
0.0656188279,
0.0181093477,
0.0068631088,
-0.0408453941,
-0.026833022,
-0.0281157903,
-0.0135886893,
-0.0025309713,
-0.0432078764,
0.1044236645,
-0.035032019,
0.0114059243,
-0.0057490077,
-0.0079904525,
-0.0241115801,
-0.0674373657,
-0.0660192147,
0.0071333782,
0.0377705246,
-0.017466506,
-0.0044259937,
-0.0172787458,
0.0033921702,
0.0300531611,
-0.0173046961,
-0.0324578173,
-0.0203239247,
0.0533008091,
0.0757163763,
0.032961458,
-0.042301923,
-0.012399286,
0.0269411132,
0.0511561073,
0.019541664,
-0.0130436812,
-0.0213040747,
0.0153940674,
0.0047922148,
-0.0179826338,
0.0128604695,
0.032695584,
-0.0012586913,
-0.034833122,
-0.0343626849,
0.0772656128,
0.045098383,
0.0176532324,
-0.017434258,
-0.0159177221,
0.0452750213,
0.0310919993,
0.0401954986,
-0.0885419697,
-0.0624170899,
-0.0077438182,
0.0285323653,
0.0234520398,
-0.064684242,
-0.003845406,
-0.1225895658,
0.0029666615,
-0.0650940314,
-0.0664585829,
-0.0493261181,
-0.041373346,
0.0023439447,
-0.0401597396,
0.0103464695,
0.0465013199,
-0.0145174125,
0.0450851135,
0.0490369648,
-0.0245936792,
-0.0247596521,
0.025906343,
-0.0486556515,
0.0058796434,
0.0429523923,
0.0290950537,
-0.0184906684,
0.0108913658,
-0.0011882477,
-0.0317025706,
0.0014570524,
0.0074628992,
0.0730970129,
0.0302887131,
-0.0190803222,
-0.0100874165,
0.0073301098,
-0.0271218307,
0.043096628,
0.044974234,
0.076064609,
-0.0265713241,
0.0136249447,
0.0122478539,
-0.0083006639,
0.0007495897,
0.0957815275,
0.0589883476,
-0.0009493718,
-0.0637467951,
0.0044126618,
-0.0410834961,
-0.1036727354,
0.0039872313,
0.0377021916,
0.0245945025,
0.0145235267,
-0.0549727529,
-0.0553565286,
0.0802522525,
0.0431214906,
-0.0100003155,
0.0708641112,
-0.0283553656,
-0.010104415,
-0.0435152315,
-0.0035249626,
-0.054537788,
0.0362364165,
-0.0066079656,
-0.0409362875,
-0.0215335153,
-0.0020499432,
-0.0384697318,
0.026919907,
-0.0999101475,
-0.0078233592,
-0.0058876257,
0.0038280922,
0.0211525112,
-0.0052602231,
-0.0140859624,
-0.0248981658,
-0.0380883813,
0.0363893546,
-0.0680361837,
-0.0496852361,
0.0037474828,
-0.0010392342,
0.008557654,
0.0381596722,
-0.0307528097,
-0.0403088108,
-0.0206324831,
0.0544537827,
-0.033809647,
0.0164244212,
0.0549927168,
0.0142823514,
-0.010092821,
0.0356867053,
-0.0494492464,
0.0072295009,
0.0246597212,
-0.0376091935,
-0.0546568222,
-0.0152387777,
0.0181769505,
0.0157877486,
-0.0221832637,
-0.0425120257,
0.0088288561,
0.0065283724,
0.0391335823,
-0.064585112,
-0.0131198093,
0.0760312527,
-0.0163683686,
0.0222756751,
-0.0323120952,
-0.0061120857,
-0.0445857979,
0.0337756947,
0.0641822517,
0.0079097254,
0.0037284503,
0.0287511926,
-0.0229840446,
-0.0149923237,
0.0309516918,
-0.0675145239,
-0.0592145994,
0.0118452096,
0.0063693756,
0.0185567234,
-0.02816559,
-0.002712359,
0.0175856967,
-0.0270868558,
0.0211003348,
-0.0059917015,
0.0410133861,
0.0051288367,
0.053126771,
0.0080372989,
-0.010507728,
-0.0078313677,
0.0755198747,
0.003380164,
0.0373506956,
-0.0069148685,
-0.0199568234,
-0.0504354499,
0.0251723044,
0.0061323163,
-0.0087992046,
-0.0329893343,
-0.017208064,
-0.0430508964,
-0.0401301272,
0.0252856072,
0.0039466652,
-0.0268208608,
0.0185026471,
0.0502299368,
0.0641103238,
0.0463214926,
0.009561236,
-0.0510448441,
0.0416898578,
-0.0403871797,
-0.028945975,
-0.0326595642,
-6.08432423e-33,
-0.0197602212,
-0.0108418548,
0.0173027851,
-0.0711740553,
0.0088353036,
-0.0004664975,
-0.0470818952,
-0.0267256182,
-0.019664498,
-0.0075816857,
-0.0302444026,
0.0387717783,
0.0165870171,
0.0008448004,
0.0282166339,
-0.0943119526,
0.0033599413,
-0.0036875815,
-0.0127110789,
0.0067994059,
0.032191392,
0.0396362357,
-0.0051374203,
0.014840086,
0.0484465472,
-0.0356859453,
-0.0341534987,
0.0217637215,
0.0033414431,
0.0385808572,
-0.0280717071,
0.0193074606,
0.0488362275,
-0.047183454,
-0.0289755892,
0.0020052569,
-0.1328265518,
-0.0353083313,
-0.0122941881,
0.0120692234,
-0.0352937765,
0.0094772242,
0.0181270167,
-0.0059847431,
0.0011087342,
0.0106135514,
0.0276344474,
-0.0274442378,
0.0024285738,
-0.0183870737,
-0.0025571429,
0.0185465962,
-0.0245667808,
0.0002296022,
0.0246776156,
0.0901597887,
0.0352811441,
0.013603867,
-0.0361829102,
-0.0075466083,
0.0113476068,
0.030914193,
0.0340959132,
-0.0201743133,
-0.006052135,
0.0159874428,
0.0186466742,
-0.0130962553,
-0.0300429016,
0.0279405992,
-0.0334222764,
0.0356834866,
0.0647301003,
0.0141988769,
0.0291497596,
0.0137650967,
-0.0562054962,
0.0904470384,
0.0191969592,
0.0125116911,
-0.0341555849,
-0.037145637,
-0.0498318896,
-0.0104338275,
-0.0490431748,
0.0456225649,
-0.0568626709,
0.0207684245,
0.0380495675,
-0.0066351579,
0.0177546814,
0.0124548916,
0.0090721594,
-0.0173180234,
-0.0201389641,
0.0498534143,
-0.0256829578,
-0.002145306,
0.0254764277,
0.0395621955,
-0.0098731071,
-0.0070056142,
0.0168721694,
-0.0077167391,
0.0240464844,
0.030665366,
0.0215144288,
0.0046079378,
-0.0686816722,
-0.0174653511,
-0.0441069901,
0.0320513658,
-0.0442985594,
-0.0021442191,
0.0228210073,
0.0217406377,
-0.0072995801,
0.0587976351,
0.0301981103,
0.0438504256,
-0.020539077,
-0.013045609,
-0.0147337187,
-0.0157239735,
0.0286237933,
0.0122748306,
-0.0168094914,
-0.0018048725,
-0.0019794814,
-0.0371037908,
-0.0002844927,
0.005277337,
2.345e-7,
0.1123535633,
0.0090926541,
0.0471595936,
0.0644588619,
-0.0188351274,
0.0189045332,
-0.0081790211,
0.0012603159,
-0.0319401287,
-0.0171830058,
0.0271975864,
-0.0203402396,
0.0493798666,
0.0443863682,
-0.0333545133,
-0.0360548683,
-0.0887964815,
-0.0073650805,
-0.0602302961,
0.0065991213,
0.0592445247,
0.0886299461,
-0.0246619713,
-0.0111353658,
-0.0206478946,
-0.0503558889,
0.0197129343,
-0.0250186846,
0.0178916566,
0.0417812988,
0.0498977005,
-0.007536408,
0.0346426517,
0.0419441722,
-0.0336367898,
-0.0015730506,
0.039656017,
0.0236638486,
0.0091955466,
0.0123258131,
-0.0313636772,
-0.0942788497,
0.0392447673,
-0.0694837123,
0.12254823,
-0.029295275,
0.0022694492,
0.070895426,
-0.0024608723,
0.024107093,
0.0326347798,
0.0320740081,
-0.0229086243,
0.0043391618,
0.0220200736,
0.0086847963,
0.0023188381,
-0.0355373658,
-0.0190319214,
0.0143067129,
-0.019165365,
-0.0066016815,
-0.0358400308,
0.0045080562,
-0.0315170698,
-0.0581661016,
-0.0124045173,
1.977898963e-34,
0.06575609,
0.0114257457,
0.03184928,
0.0354033522,
0.0574002303,
-0.0329572968,
0.0101177907,
-0.0040382543,
0.0152119379,
-0.0903423354,
-0.0114218947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13655v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13655v1 | Compositional Zero-Shot Learning for Attribute-Based Object Reference in Human-Robot Interaction | 2023-12-21T08:29:41 | 2023-12-21T08:29:41 | Peng Gao, Ahmed Jaafar, Brian Reily, Christopher Reardon, Hao Zhang | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Language-enabled robots have been widely studied over the past years to
enable natural human-robot interaction and teaming in various real-world
applications. Language-enabled robots must be able to comprehend referring
expressions to identify a particular object from visual perception using a set
of referring attributes extracted from natural language. However, visual
observations of an object may not be available when it is referred to, and the
number of objects and attributes may also be unbounded in open worlds. To
address the challenges, we implement an attribute-based compositional zero-shot
learning method that uses a list of attributes to perform referring expression
comprehension in open worlds. We evaluate the approach on two datasets
including the MIT-States and the Clothing 16K. The preliminary experimental
results show that our implemented approach allows a robot to correctly identify
the objects referred to by human commands. | [
-0.0033737568,
0.0065512913,
0.0416694805,
-0.0037432155,
-0.0098067215,
0.0110661732,
0.0361207463,
-0.0158499442,
-0.005316895,
-0.092206426,
-0.0404543616,
-0.004234991,
0.0129495915,
0.013837493,
0.0124011626,
-0.0250640474,
0.0327821076,
-0.0022454297,
-0.0105620222,
0.0250334665,
-0.0261273757,
0.0033872677,
-0.0634195432,
0.0374674425,
0.00920677,
0.025243504,
-0.0442347862,
-0.0063720844,
0.0368193313,
-0.0248205792,
-0.0648012906,
0.0260851458,
0.016169006,
0.0008752007,
0.000001587,
-0.0377945304,
0.0158604346,
0.0166319795,
-0.0193400383,
-0.0870365873,
0.0394633859,
0.0080626495,
0.0194196962,
0.0017648226,
-0.0103830406,
-0.0634673834,
0.080659464,
0.0506677702,
0.042889379,
0.0192403737,
-0.0210970026,
-0.047069218,
-0.0254311822,
0.0091982735,
0.0618190244,
-0.0739321932,
0.0378534794,
-0.0236150324,
0.0659674108,
-0.0074545131,
-0.0330752693,
0.0050537987,
0.0017920817,
0.0184828714,
0.0293599125,
0.0681385025,
-0.0479814485,
-0.0198921971,
0.0391600765,
0.1090443581,
-0.0008066886,
-0.0065918504,
-0.006105416,
0.0071712951,
-0.000700378,
0.0009681329,
0.0011757987,
0.0306760408,
-0.0193874259,
-0.010985055,
-0.1197400466,
-0.0150560336,
-0.0233483016,
0.0113519672,
-0.0233702231,
0.0435031429,
0.0011366616,
0.0203878842,
-0.0094943307,
-0.0106507465,
-0.0120267943,
-0.0578090101,
-0.0476728007,
0.0426471792,
-0.0257121697,
0.0171641,
-0.0614618547,
-0.0275123678,
-0.0367991291,
0.0002133341,
0.0487510934,
0.0332107842,
-0.02471756,
0.0808286518,
-0.037926212,
0.0566234216,
-0.003638247,
0.0152564002,
-0.0226406846,
-0.028724838,
-0.0957963243,
0.0241159685,
-0.0487633012,
0.0243729092,
0.0213748999,
-0.0255684443,
-0.0169420727,
-0.0052874954,
-0.0273286905,
0.0322353505,
-0.0397265069,
-0.0041977568,
-0.0260894187,
-0.018947443,
-0.0287881996,
0.003124462,
-0.0117568029,
0.0261037797,
-0.0419989787,
-0.0076573691,
-0.0058187582,
0.0174941625,
0.0574943461,
-0.0191159844,
-0.0228121448,
0.0643667132,
-0.0018085926,
-0.0313207358,
0.0318590738,
-0.02375976,
0.0150728319,
-0.0505179986,
0.0285145044,
-0.0107993595,
-0.017062569,
-0.00423053,
0.0032131432,
-0.0756675154,
0.0122437123,
0.0176016781,
-0.0541477576,
0.1145813167,
-0.0023703477,
-0.0230829418,
-0.0684176087,
0.0041141612,
0.009238014,
0.0550715439,
0.0193694886,
0.017253587,
-0.0478591546,
0.04542806,
0.026982598,
-0.0339350551,
-0.0018118208,
-0.0069747837,
-0.0387463756,
-0.0268784761,
0.0209055245,
0.0380339473,
-0.0032197258,
-0.018311929,
-0.0295390189,
-0.042046804,
-0.0049128025,
-0.0390978381,
-0.0098835947,
-0.0205845982,
0.0403159633,
0.0361329801,
-0.0095768133,
-0.0616813563,
-0.0325419679,
0.0759580731,
-0.037448056,
-0.0066474937,
-0.0483193435,
-0.0278460048,
-0.0653194711,
-0.0088094464,
-0.0045925318,
-0.0126118865,
0.0399917252,
0.0027208009,
0.0735920817,
0.011565485,
-0.0085256891,
-0.0119916871,
0.0173387378,
-0.0274102688,
-0.0394095108,
-0.0164729673,
0.0178784542,
0.0377415679,
-0.0020466689,
-0.0293220505,
-0.0285935812,
-0.0106772408,
0.0708893836,
0.0282559935,
-0.0429076031,
-0.0145531474,
0.0731632262,
-0.0010745337,
-0.0628089756,
-0.0239995904,
-0.0138191944,
0.0351288617,
-0.0388487801,
-0.0080035003,
-0.0022467684,
0.0051246099,
0.0696465373,
0.0539518856,
0.0582351312,
0.0135737583,
0.01634565,
0.0519149564,
-0.0095118303,
0.0103887953,
-0.0090857483,
-0.0000810251,
0.0052538053,
-0.0015236253,
-0.0308299847,
0.0574277751,
0.026625637,
-0.0311455838,
0.0263267234,
-0.0451021306,
-0.0256883595,
-0.0540245175,
-0.0339272767,
-0.0521554388,
0.0496332012,
-0.0189572182,
0.0096796127,
0.0103365881,
-0.0177307315,
0.0031538552,
0.007958347,
0.0086474502,
0.0309141651,
0.0192442108,
-0.0054229284,
0.0157798771,
0.0361960605,
0.033512868,
-0.0324503928,
-0.0222701542,
-0.003894222,
0.0223361887,
-0.0008226851,
0.0182695836,
0.008696679,
-0.0313542336,
-0.0015810113,
-0.0021980458,
-0.0545218177,
0.0362715572,
-0.019635804,
-0.0382986031,
-0.0339049809,
0.0089440504,
-0.0391275845,
0.0136678647,
0.0529073775,
-0.045827385,
-0.0047908518,
0.0362064429,
0.0598605834,
-0.0467410125,
0.0143807856,
0.025379017,
-0.0149171464,
0.036805857,
0.0326297246,
0.0028206122,
-0.0446709953,
0.0173169468,
-0.0324893668,
0.0345248841,
0.0069934148,
-0.024859393,
0.0381740369,
-0.0276778881,
-0.0076162796,
0.0911660194,
-0.0428712256,
0.0025828194,
0.0729483441,
-0.0267018471,
-0.0344801284,
0.0008524497,
0.008414411,
-0.0255019758,
-0.0008418185,
0.0532887913,
-0.0150191728,
0.0302007869,
-0.0357775986,
0.0003069458,
-0.0750361979,
0.0458753034,
0.0014728082,
-0.0651632324,
-0.0410976596,
0.0508767217,
-0.0149520524,
0.0001152554,
-0.0319789238,
0.0331145115,
0.0354106128,
-0.0124732908,
-0.0095037809,
0.0360741951,
0.0326917917,
0.0116889281,
0.0195163731,
0.0162302684,
0.0222136751,
0.0669754595,
-0.0050345487,
-0.0186688565,
0.0161004737,
0.0079058344,
0.0450763404,
-0.0397555605,
-0.050437402,
0.0585824288,
-0.0160445198,
-0.0050939512,
-0.0079084635,
0.0391106196,
-0.0344119892,
0.0385427214,
-0.1055970415,
-0.0363849699,
-0.0724332258,
0.0093405871,
0.0253315344,
0.0001561797,
0.0109644271,
-0.0192283895,
-0.0323195048,
0.0009078726,
0.0234817266,
-0.0046453024,
-0.0654171556,
0.008995831,
-0.0170017276,
0.0397901274,
0.0282392111,
0.034664765,
-0.0395376347,
0.0026182227,
0.0160297938,
0.0128608216,
0.0124358106,
0.0240921471,
0.0188606605,
-0.0185301844,
-0.030553421,
0.0615186058,
0.0175165441,
-0.0621669404,
-0.0341290869,
-0.0073158029,
-0.0274556335,
0.055025842,
0.0248931237,
-0.1095987931,
-0.0508528985,
0.0093485983,
-0.0402665511,
0.0166919213,
-0.0679453239,
-0.0152422637,
-0.1232388318,
-0.0136027755,
-0.0138950692,
-0.0871022344,
-0.0721605197,
-0.0169124603,
0.0620756745,
-0.0535218902,
-0.0395370126,
-0.0016944861,
-0.006678489,
0.0024274746,
0.0096270163,
0.0370908566,
-0.025231624,
0.0370236188,
-0.0258729402,
0.0180415325,
0.0182851031,
0.066676043,
-0.0115520488,
-0.0058813151,
-0.0529843047,
-0.0116498815,
-0.0206784904,
-0.0221397541,
0.0041195648,
-0.0495759733,
-0.0193099361,
0.0423293039,
0.0384281129,
0.0041985027,
-0.0364029929,
-0.0481492132,
0.0357295126,
-0.0228416603,
0.0217112638,
-0.0199367832,
-0.0247319639,
0.0254973546,
0.052044712,
0.0188977327,
-0.0242829677,
-0.0263726152,
-0.0232013278,
-0.0379013903,
-0.0179715324,
-0.0207467414,
0.0115383156,
-0.0511511862,
-0.0392959639,
-0.0713032857,
-0.0109193688,
0.082019195,
0.0628540888,
-0.0219725352,
-0.0425557159,
0.0206204802,
0.0688135251,
-0.0415693,
-0.0113778021,
-0.057800401,
0.0422116071,
-0.0169720072,
-0.0235935766,
0.0485912338,
-0.0326874703,
-0.0297285318,
-0.01776742,
0.0137675256,
-0.0310705733,
-0.0029395688,
0.0704184696,
0.0150058186,
0.0153541462,
-0.0230309032,
-0.0680135563,
-0.0011622248,
0.0197304729,
0.0103645111,
0.0365388207,
0.0195540413,
0.0063931704,
0.0157908127,
0.0311653838,
-0.0346169956,
0.0349303521,
0.0117988065,
-0.0020320348,
-0.0296584051,
-0.0337562338,
0.0217710324,
-0.0181316156,
0.0321270488,
0.0020511618,
0.0423704237,
-0.0031863372,
-0.0098681813,
-0.0319659971,
0.0104257157,
-0.0638918355,
0.0303667281,
-0.028397914,
-0.0020870387,
0.0284394249,
0.0110656992,
-0.0249982085,
0.0807863399,
0.0238655005,
0.0262816511,
0.067408286,
0.0155587764,
-0.0110875815,
0.0189844221,
0.0100938734,
-0.0092332559,
-0.0104986122,
0.0478145592,
0.0098557286,
0.0813525021,
0.0524574444,
0.0044064098,
-0.0694969893,
0.047128275,
-0.006984672,
0.007978416,
-0.0038556641,
0.0382472053,
0.0221765898,
0.0243961606,
0.0098694358,
-0.0454244427,
-0.0132753775,
0.0177513119,
0.0817383677,
-0.0067444802,
-0.062393792,
0.0649724752,
0.0476340838,
0.0059330636,
0.0236715414,
0.0639225692,
0.0726061165,
0.0457479954,
-0.0078785773,
0.0226352438,
-0.0394741558,
0.013019165,
0.0001782963,
0.0182219259,
0.0086918883,
0.0597131997,
-0.0396776311,
-0.0392107628,
-0.0084202141,
0.0059016757,
-0.0063363342,
-0.0004493049,
0.0503182411,
-0.0208526701,
0.0340593234,
-0.0198776722,
-0.0205215011,
-0.0510497168,
0.0205067992,
0.0124251284,
-0.0097632557,
-4.539614817e-33,
-0.0631076917,
-0.0456620418,
0.0291958377,
-0.0022572828,
-0.0090878187,
-0.0157507882,
-0.0456600077,
0.0044799745,
-0.0416840427,
0.0200073905,
0.0050833388,
-0.0289137308,
0.0106558921,
0.0047898628,
0.0382836387,
-0.0247224215,
0.0187846031,
0.0037838388,
0.0084607145,
0.036804013,
0.0711442903,
0.0026281262,
0.0594913922,
-0.055695232,
-0.0116837258,
0.0351208895,
-0.0118548358,
0.0353682861,
0.0609256476,
0.0043578343,
-0.0081749363,
0.0022372527,
-0.0152041819,
-0.0189626999,
-0.0022787936,
-0.0097786514,
-0.07599774,
-0.0123220505,
-0.0279833749,
0.0489948057,
-0.0067159128,
-0.0052647567,
0.0046636681,
-0.0049944012,
0.0151640512,
-0.0121872062,
0.0355327055,
-0.0563928857,
-0.0249808896,
-0.0027287039,
-0.0678457245,
0.0119081214,
0.0015492666,
-0.065996334,
0.0739379004,
0.0313566998,
-0.0022358517,
0.0100545743,
-0.0347347856,
0.0133120762,
-0.0517603122,
-0.0025188236,
0.0317039154,
0.0253427699,
0.0552121773,
0.0450194068,
0.0459397286,
-0.013574549,
-0.039755024,
0.0171788931,
0.0401736647,
0.0830067247,
-0.002205018,
0.0788487792,
0.0103125805,
0.027096333,
-0.015326459,
-0.0042015491,
-0.0091591952,
0.126712963,
-0.0297124255,
0.0271732695,
-0.0261308905,
0.0169699565,
-0.0133535694,
-0.0061303135,
-0.0335183665,
-0.0221677199,
0.0133229056,
0.0151267806,
-0.0490990989,
0.016918743,
0.0864682496,
-0.028549049,
-0.0093428837,
0.0294915363,
0.0088564698,
0.0419175513,
-0.0189210009,
-0.0288987067,
-0.075901404,
-0.0476381481,
0.0543346219,
0.012826344,
0.0229569245,
0.006970224,
0.0201852769,
0.0427236967,
-0.0070382571,
-0.0409743115,
-0.0404911749,
-0.0244045313,
0.0046660844,
0.00791963,
0.018084107,
0.0331905,
-0.0193002913,
0.0624598488,
-0.0342938043,
-0.0339291394,
0.0269281492,
-0.0050411397,
0.0110013215,
-0.0286808237,
-0.0600251891,
-0.0339737535,
-0.0224546492,
-0.0411361195,
0.0230785757,
-0.046815183,
0.0055186264,
0.0366246551,
2.433e-7,
-0.0108230058,
0.0021557815,
0.0194029994,
0.0166922528,
-0.026970448,
0.0658778697,
-0.0181702878,
0.0602889508,
-0.0164970327,
-0.0059213019,
0.0190958939,
0.0225977991,
-0.0031719389,
-0.0163479913,
-0.0784007385,
0.0363564454,
0.0230068341,
-0.0234512873,
-0.0390740037,
-0.0280498397,
0.0458010621,
0.061585892,
0.010693579,
0.0262231082,
0.0411724299,
-0.0245950129,
0.0760658085,
0.0117285484,
0.0475170501,
-0.0406200849,
0.0253708269,
0.0036687609,
-0.0006157681,
0.0105235921,
0.022663299,
-0.0004820751,
0.0387258232,
0.0274648946,
-0.0225527175,
-0.0352259986,
-0.0084870765,
-0.0128789982,
0.001103156,
0.0073374808,
0.087077111,
-0.0989203826,
-0.013633729,
-0.0046625654,
-0.0401855111,
0.0218699649,
-0.0338195004,
0.0309297983,
-0.0137960585,
0.0118351672,
0.0093212062,
-0.0392875373,
-0.0092806295,
-0.0721040517,
-0.0316387825,
-0.0377421081,
-0.0359151587,
0.0310402717,
0.0470332988,
0.0033718352,
0.0121269515,
-0.0346834026,
-0.046405416,
1.132689023e-34,
-0.0091526052,
0.0015663605,
-0.0071550296,
0.0617194884,
0.0064060721,
0.0143123828,
-0.0642781705,
0.0290957037,
0.0293249767,
-0.0425981246,
-0.0199637692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13614v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13614v1 | Structure-Aware Path Inference for Neural Finite State Transducers | 2023-12-21T07:03:15 | 2023-12-21T07:03:15 | Weiting Tan, Chu-cheng Lin, Jason Eisner | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Neural finite-state transducers (NFSTs) form an expressive family of
neurosymbolic sequence transduction models. An NFST models each string pair as
having been generated by a latent path in a finite-state transducer. As they
are deep generative models, both training and inference of NFSTs require
inference networks that approximate posterior distributions over such latent
variables. In this paper, we focus on the resulting challenge of imputing the
latent alignment path that explains a given pair of input and output strings
(e.g., during training). We train three autoregressive approximate models for
amortized inference of the path, which can then be used as proposal
distributions for importance sampling. All three models perform lookahead. Our
most sophisticated (and novel) model leverages the FST structure to consider
the graph of future paths; unfortunately, we find that it loses out to the
simpler approaches -- except on an artificial task that we concocted to confuse
the simpler approaches. | [
-0.011552833,
0.1006821245,
0.0074883737,
-0.0189205538,
-0.0317231715,
-0.0125996228,
-0.0293615162,
-0.02910267,
-0.0658882037,
0.0196448192,
-0.001989851,
-0.0520159528,
0.0428047292,
0.0336504057,
0.074552834,
-0.0294984952,
0.0257490128,
-0.0779794976,
-0.0005053564,
0.0093078008,
-0.0056585744,
-0.0024941759,
-0.0411971211,
0.0788497254,
-0.0216146149,
-0.0005624747,
-0.0338391736,
-0.0138871456,
0.0284661129,
-0.0159665886,
-0.0382024497,
0.0148138693,
0.0218132641,
0.0553144701,
0.0000018509,
-0.0194167104,
-0.0164998043,
-0.0092444047,
-0.031288255,
-0.0101324525,
-0.0050895265,
-0.0031712137,
-0.0357078314,
0.0147902239,
0.014088585,
0.0073284637,
0.1108509898,
0.0069231829,
0.0283973813,
0.0530322641,
0.0100204451,
-0.000515495,
0.0074295397,
-0.0594093949,
0.0544015802,
-0.0366309956,
0.0272759013,
-0.0343099758,
-0.0320537575,
-0.0139451502,
-0.0246000458,
0.0067459568,
0.0148861613,
-0.0075657759,
-0.0059973239,
0.0535604395,
0.0095715942,
0.0130287437,
0.0059878235,
0.0799018368,
-0.0295575727,
-0.0221958123,
-0.0081399865,
-0.0139053529,
-0.0419306606,
0.022306731,
-0.0442214943,
0.026420651,
-0.0239728466,
0.0471410155,
0.0551535115,
-0.0347401351,
0.0656080022,
-0.0142208226,
-0.026106298,
0.0553583615,
0.0259196721,
0.0103996703,
-0.0326624177,
-0.0065700551,
-0.0011148324,
-0.0466492437,
0.0426246971,
0.0108674141,
0.0176913254,
0.0162313804,
-0.001334475,
-0.0650294647,
-0.0334750153,
0.000676638,
0.0529111288,
0.0422640704,
0.0048167487,
0.0102982977,
-0.0212703347,
0.0249385945,
-0.0538776629,
-0.006354691,
-0.0090361722,
-0.0110531719,
-0.0075652571,
0.0001958265,
0.0149458675,
0.0085081533,
-0.0006686086,
0.0068818475,
-0.0337576084,
0.0131131951,
0.011085866,
-0.0263870563,
-0.0047351765,
0.0162113793,
-0.0964053646,
0.0050026448,
-0.0256473534,
0.0676066354,
-0.0175496507,
0.0029194562,
-0.0092457319,
-0.013907739,
-0.0556206927,
0.010494967,
0.0229381863,
0.0130121689,
-0.0106902197,
0.0710912868,
0.0066977735,
-0.0459559746,
-0.0847933441,
-0.0084911957,
-0.0244281609,
-0.0196744446,
0.0734126866,
-0.053605821,
0.0178815145,
-0.02166906,
-0.0191149935,
-0.0503663905,
0.0122626321,
0.0136333862,
-0.0121406931,
0.0658153743,
0.0415098146,
-0.0292626619,
-0.0058468636,
-0.0293760467,
0.0258797035,
0.0021405462,
0.0516028367,
0.042008847,
-0.0403420925,
0.0215921104,
0.0180722028,
0.0376756117,
0.0152933476,
-0.0160780232,
-0.0245208684,
-0.0502678938,
-0.0215291306,
0.0379297547,
0.0787580386,
0.0301408619,
-0.0527114868,
-0.0261654016,
0.0110998945,
0.0547390245,
0.0369363129,
-0.0199147314,
0.095162347,
-0.019779738,
-0.0360851325,
0.0060211071,
-0.050827302,
0.0449082479,
-0.0011464799,
0.0419834778,
0.0612744391,
0.004967446,
0.0012768375,
-0.0363805182,
0.0305311065,
-0.0205510948,
-0.0406123996,
-0.0207671057,
0.0749691203,
-0.0142855989,
-0.0631409287,
0.0246987566,
0.0119647486,
-0.0087954607,
-0.0004525719,
0.0006758303,
0.0400343463,
0.0194638092,
0.0365985259,
-0.0388961025,
-0.0368158743,
-0.0078996299,
-0.0531328954,
0.0325725935,
-0.0331900008,
-0.0194100142,
0.0417105369,
-0.0136149814,
-0.038423676,
0.027304193,
0.0220730752,
0.070763506,
-0.0284695085,
-0.0094656162,
0.0261943694,
-0.0616231523,
-0.0302970838,
0.010676071,
-0.0093701771,
-0.0339641534,
0.0272256583,
0.0331382118,
0.0645339191,
0.0083328271,
-0.0213311911,
0.068672806,
0.0303559769,
-0.0191544071,
0.0185605679,
-0.0129911406,
-0.0366091579,
-0.0598124266,
0.0549040549,
-0.0515719801,
-0.0074381232,
-0.0190919358,
-0.0442096442,
-0.0762426332,
0.0535097532,
-0.0724346414,
-0.0026511075,
0.011647013,
0.0121261934,
0.0815880448,
0.0138994996,
-0.0090796808,
0.026080057,
-0.0200468469,
0.0040242877,
0.0111375125,
-0.0244973153,
0.0249905512,
-0.0443609022,
0.029604407,
0.0048825536,
-0.0079687107,
-0.0610919297,
0.0248672571,
-0.0313149132,
0.0175192822,
-0.022132162,
-0.0111265779,
-0.0210824292,
-0.0135411965,
0.0741992444,
0.0091377031,
-0.0016921605,
0.0180154629,
-0.0043983962,
-0.0230703596,
0.0017548448,
-0.0142543288,
0.0029741961,
0.017800916,
-0.0035492238,
-0.0422022454,
-0.0601370931,
-0.0331610963,
-0.0668157712,
0.0558005571,
-0.001231782,
-0.05691671,
-0.0629969016,
-0.0443818644,
-0.0172338542,
0.0236638468,
-0.0355834365,
-0.017916834,
0.0263381228,
-0.0268350504,
0.0452616662,
0.0299446192,
-0.0327742845,
-0.0161235109,
0.0145392139,
-0.0161416754,
-0.0012941866,
-0.0137829343,
-0.0326138623,
0.0602445714,
-0.05499487,
-0.073589623,
0.004086439,
0.0885436684,
0.0120463017,
0.0167280138,
-0.0438180417,
0.0332202725,
0.0121698249,
0.0032176441,
0.0347286649,
-0.0129789282,
-0.025760103,
0.0145697407,
-0.0187576972,
-0.0276360773,
0.0838744119,
-0.0859433785,
0.0319477357,
-0.0176673792,
0.0057910243,
-0.0231405515,
0.0753189847,
0.0510274321,
-0.0043355017,
0.0766205937,
-0.0443188176,
-0.0086676003,
0.0286675878,
0.0225282945,
-0.01067321,
0.0326131955,
-0.0523930714,
0.0305335373,
0.0128021203,
-0.0068887356,
-0.0178543068,
0.0083762798,
-0.036570631,
-0.0007052436,
0.0282262489,
-0.0417817123,
-0.0148902871,
0.0196600202,
0.0255958792,
0.065749988,
0.0085398648,
0.0094907572,
-0.0304724146,
0.0404362604,
0.0544880405,
-0.0328716002,
0.0470752269,
-0.0149981547,
-0.0137859946,
0.0217760522,
0.0643679574,
0.0386537015,
-0.03006614,
0.0106518557,
-0.0027651107,
-0.0345154591,
-0.0026014228,
0.0425055623,
0.0194320511,
-0.0207737405,
-0.0191560388,
0.0727803335,
0.0168178733,
-0.0308130737,
0.0451151021,
0.0293674786,
0.0457375236,
-0.0082751149,
0.016398631,
-0.0674043968,
-0.0320785157,
0.0259986445,
0.0345458202,
-0.001636517,
-0.0353301205,
0.0107862875,
-0.0794334039,
0.011904222,
0.0214376599,
-0.0282777585,
-0.0305256918,
-0.0388285667,
0.0185339767,
-0.030732194,
-0.0126927728,
0.0179083738,
-0.0112616308,
0.0619814992,
0.061142128,
0.001605978,
-0.0161657091,
0.0054651713,
-0.023844203,
0.0403941721,
0.0898404121,
0.0109527437,
0.0223568454,
-0.0042000241,
0.0117256846,
-0.0282287002,
0.0150810834,
0.0053565297,
0.05043488,
0.0116862068,
-0.0203212146,
-0.0121561904,
0.0583929159,
-0.036206428,
0.0108130956,
-0.0397176482,
0.0537828356,
-0.0329067037,
0.0005226592,
-0.0117466375,
-0.0261597447,
-0.0082741594,
0.0412266441,
0.0384279415,
-0.0002183465,
-0.0264497679,
-0.0639603138,
0.0210475419,
-0.0306780487,
-0.04001645,
-0.0403070264,
0.0216308516,
-0.0623511299,
-0.0941445082,
-0.0336251855,
0.038677521,
0.0654333085,
-0.0185517222,
0.0066478988,
0.0386280976,
-0.0532617792,
-0.015407919,
0.0425795652,
-0.0225497317,
0.031514734,
-0.0509557202,
0.0078322021,
0.0095283752,
0.0100789433,
-0.052336026,
0.0314661935,
-0.0897333249,
-0.0735612065,
-0.0265666042,
0.0470230952,
0.0220038556,
0.0252878349,
-0.0415007621,
0.0108215204,
0.0144924773,
-0.0151190218,
0.018719878,
-0.0032517549,
0.0430431999,
-0.0126905795,
-0.0088595431,
0.030559307,
-0.0091987392,
-0.0088074366,
0.0087290118,
0.0503048748,
0.0017585201,
-0.0301333107,
0.0411955379,
-0.005974161,
0.0932149813,
0.0183893573,
0.0139705092,
-0.0298700985,
-0.0023973125,
0.0100948596,
0.0167689379,
-0.0458756723,
0.0421726406,
0.023392817,
0.0249204151,
-0.0205532983,
-0.0685397536,
0.0301798452,
-0.0057856156,
-0.0083510932,
-0.0027171115,
0.0490120053,
-0.0063832514,
-0.0082454598,
-0.050981313,
0.0354995243,
0.0405814089,
0.0025054747,
0.0451475941,
-0.0263333544,
0.0319004804,
0.0203072336,
0.0394081138,
-0.0167222656,
-0.0332284793,
-0.0550924577,
-0.0090281814,
-0.0452263057,
0.0227978826,
0.0637413412,
-0.0134311626,
0.0356619209,
-0.0198449437,
0.0383766517,
0.0056487364,
0.0421906039,
-0.0069016437,
-0.0138879688,
0.0414547697,
0.0377985612,
0.0286085457,
0.0101426207,
0.100851737,
0.0558125488,
0.0663675591,
-0.0094015226,
-0.0058986335,
-0.0093519278,
-0.0330225229,
-0.0565017425,
0.0026765666,
-0.0360591635,
0.0140380105,
-0.022901712,
-0.0784487501,
0.028792277,
0.0122145433,
0.0110756261,
-0.0282385629,
0.0485491008,
0.0227078535,
-0.0338929854,
-0.0272137988,
-0.0025284905,
-0.0136782806,
0.0070731728,
-0.0671990588,
-0.0584340543,
-6.421866698e-33,
-0.0283778943,
-0.0201834813,
0.0019524937,
-0.0239316672,
-0.0344261676,
0.0094698835,
-0.0821546912,
-0.015955491,
-0.0160617381,
0.0136061357,
-0.0063777678,
0.0408567935,
0.0167008899,
0.0253972262,
-0.0044509522,
-0.0357708968,
0.0434752218,
0.0089648254,
-0.009883455,
-0.0079148337,
0.0264271758,
0.0147885252,
0.112131238,
-0.0275977552,
0.0039175982,
0.0377918221,
0.0103882607,
0.0143464478,
-0.0171603635,
0.0125462953,
-0.0225070249,
0.0096295634,
-0.0063924398,
-0.0691634193,
-0.0090899644,
-0.0331953689,
-0.057738509,
-0.048195865,
0.0107214516,
-0.0260561779,
-0.0299616195,
-0.0498583391,
0.0547447503,
-0.0131008616,
0.009315514,
0.0190869309,
0.0112962918,
-0.0218027513,
-0.0228399727,
-0.0015642943,
-0.0356258452,
0.0472831801,
-0.0136306817,
0.0044555105,
0.0119662117,
0.0285838526,
0.0297109075,
-0.0438683294,
-0.0190417785,
0.0111194272,
0.0370050892,
0.0857299268,
0.031823054,
0.0253097527,
0.0433491431,
0.0116502261,
0.0196181796,
-0.0719340965,
-0.0294505674,
-0.0189931896,
-0.0146649033,
0.0045550168,
0.0105780205,
-0.0370947234,
0.0347680002,
0.0585761853,
-0.0424696058,
0.0129140401,
0.0370688029,
0.0628684983,
-0.012960826,
0.019634407,
-0.0393186025,
-0.0148562323,
-0.0432890803,
-0.0441954285,
-0.0036703052,
-0.0093610035,
-0.002256965,
-0.0137689579,
-0.0243270546,
0.0069604865,
0.0493142456,
0.0078889597,
-0.0268506538,
0.0149083482,
0.0158367176,
0.0228826907,
-0.004706745,
0.0027115764,
-0.0538960285,
0.0080089951,
0.0108517017,
-0.0117341094,
0.0350172967,
-0.0052330382,
-0.0066994689,
0.0177054256,
-0.0321285911,
-0.0300528985,
-0.0573295951,
-0.0196083803,
-0.0217362382,
0.0139281861,
0.0991293937,
-0.0074238437,
-0.0088131493,
0.013751491,
-0.0053046378,
0.046074383,
0.0105155148,
0.0340179577,
-0.0182653572,
0.0498306006,
-0.0512555428,
-0.0270398073,
-0.0266998727,
0.0160104334,
0.025049679,
-0.0911213458,
-0.040498171,
0.0603357367,
2.871e-7,
0.0514070019,
0.0004010075,
0.0759442374,
0.0412475616,
0.0366984904,
0.0287755989,
0.0117170969,
-0.0469947383,
0.0051163342,
-0.0403566733,
0.0195745807,
-0.012998648,
0.0114632137,
-0.0126451124,
-0.0678236261,
-0.0204856638,
-0.0436417162,
0.0259479284,
-0.0475906953,
-0.0213154834,
-0.0382581614,
0.1277967542,
-0.0031947384,
-0.0148713561,
0.0407738164,
-0.0050775083,
0.0253216643,
0.0561565161,
0.0290124174,
-0.0028386102,
0.0102836546,
-0.0746399835,
0.0015818708,
0.0150203072,
-0.0174706224,
0.0152816912,
0.0007636485,
0.0195298158,
-0.0260909554,
-0.0360913016,
-0.0130043048,
-0.000580987,
0.0063846326,
0.0077437637,
0.040014822,
-0.0422582328,
-0.043518208,
0.0068291556,
-0.055464752,
0.0335072353,
-0.0092855599,
0.0516389646,
0.0013642693,
0.0043497146,
0.016662864,
-0.0133841773,
-0.0151854008,
-0.040703997,
-0.0171718951,
-0.0151030729,
-0.0273716804,
0.0310765915,
-0.0676494464,
-0.0127317039,
0.035198316,
-0.0769118369,
-0.0889880136,
2.74650972e-34,
0.0257776286,
-0.0341467895,
0.017397631,
0.0017823122,
0.0473416559,
0.0022482653,
-0.0196620207,
0.0085298885,
0.0355758518,
-0.0756213143,
-0.0878523886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13608v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13608v1 | Argue with Me Tersely: Towards Sentence-Level Counter-Argument Generation | 2023-12-21T06:51:34 | 2023-12-21T06:51:34 | Jiayu Lin, Rong Ye, Meng Han, Qi Zhang, Ruofei Lai, Xinyu Zhang, Zhao Cao, Xuanjing Huang, Zhongyu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | Counter-argument generation -- a captivating area in computational
linguistics -- seeks to craft statements that offer opposing views. While most
research has ventured into paragraph-level generation, sentence-level
counter-argument generation beckons with its unique constraints and
brevity-focused challenges. Furthermore, the diverse nature of
counter-arguments poses challenges for evaluating model performance solely
based on n-gram-based metrics. In this paper, we present the ArgTersely
benchmark for sentence-level counter-argument generation, drawing from a
manually annotated dataset from the ChangeMyView debate forum. We also propose
Arg-LlaMA for generating high-quality counter-argument. For better evaluation,
we trained a BERT-based evaluator Arg-Judge with human preference data. We
conducted comparative experiments involving various baselines such as LlaMA,
Alpaca, GPT-3, and others. The results show the competitiveness of our proposed
framework and evaluator in counter-argument generation tasks. Code and data are
available at https://github.com/amazingljy1206/ArgTersely. | [
0.0417730138,
0.0290609263,
0.034782894,
0.0298496559,
-0.0614665225,
0.0134950904,
0.0051504094,
-0.058592651,
0.0039361827,
-0.0676054284,
-0.0012543097,
-0.0342282429,
-0.0156453941,
-0.0059151817,
0.0257811956,
-0.038302213,
0.0269052722,
0.0174095947,
0.0979088545,
-0.0335655361,
0.023467131,
-0.009316545,
-0.0364427865,
0.0425645448,
-0.0031427611,
-0.0362424627,
0.0081965942,
0.0076991864,
0.0683385208,
-0.0792996287,
0.0644138753,
0.0167721491,
-0.0416784771,
0.0523012765,
0.00000183,
-0.0390339047,
-0.0118886819,
-0.0155498078,
-0.017508883,
0.0390403233,
0.0320565216,
0.0665604323,
-0.016524652,
0.0366131589,
-0.0379911326,
0.0486871153,
0.041122105,
0.0820932761,
0.0773923397,
0.1016710028,
0.0013465342,
-0.0317244306,
-0.0006037658,
-0.0498889126,
-0.0390220024,
0.013595026,
-0.004170388,
-0.0153093608,
-0.0166639965,
-0.010283893,
0.0101244701,
0.0184194054,
0.0147240646,
-0.0109747453,
-0.0140574044,
0.0184660945,
-0.0608668067,
0.0005292845,
-0.0148821147,
0.0475926176,
0.0095954007,
-0.0705003962,
0.0121241743,
-0.0150325838,
0.0239478964,
-0.0301284548,
-0.0276004914,
0.0502036288,
-0.0046732356,
0.0516969711,
0.028732866,
0.0370664075,
-0.0024276946,
0.0268155225,
0.0073404489,
0.0158196203,
0.021021869,
-0.037994083,
0.0301327594,
0.0113014318,
-0.0345545225,
-0.0648527667,
0.0180100203,
0.0169968884,
-0.0128669487,
0.005859891,
-0.042703215,
-0.0443491526,
0.0550295487,
-0.0856665522,
0.038971819,
0.0056142369,
0.0056012492,
0.0036111327,
-0.0257151444,
0.0168889016,
-0.0213482548,
0.0001442702,
0.015602611,
-0.0131535046,
-0.022243306,
-0.0188654587,
-0.0567974895,
0.0238329116,
-0.0351504311,
-0.0085856244,
-0.0334515609,
-0.0234124009,
-0.0543865673,
0.0038138165,
0.0117275435,
0.0318032987,
0.0021165793,
-0.0030768313,
-0.0189830177,
0.005757445,
-0.053437911,
0.0049271057,
0.046748668,
-0.0289404448,
-0.005265099,
0.0282144062,
-0.0216515549,
-0.0304724872,
0.0078130877,
0.0355914384,
-0.0464889482,
0.0291417707,
0.010119725,
-0.0290571023,
-0.0650981292,
-0.0687200204,
-0.0014646997,
-0.0816093907,
-0.0146744382,
-0.0076461062,
-0.0006481097,
-0.0306934919,
0.0153111964,
0.0354543626,
0.0237123221,
0.0112334751,
-0.0088179884,
-0.0594957136,
0.0408414118,
0.0242034551,
-0.0051742834,
0.0279977042,
0.0369336717,
0.0268773381,
0.039156083,
0.035711173,
-0.028305674,
-0.022865301,
0.0436807945,
-0.0281917881,
0.0041171028,
0.0035077597,
-0.0649482757,
0.0301262718,
-0.0084113916,
0.0558682121,
-0.0413373969,
-0.0698718727,
0.0443204232,
-0.0020663266,
-0.0021662754,
0.0130102951,
0.0237832963,
0.0195700359,
0.0192769784,
0.0251623094,
0.0167409014,
0.0132239377,
-0.0333337747,
-0.0033930389,
0.0312198773,
0.0178134609,
0.0064246827,
-0.0439587682,
-0.0035976171,
-0.011228987,
-0.0049788351,
-0.0387507156,
0.0004759996,
0.0351491198,
-0.0315167457,
0.0012606467,
-0.0172851197,
-0.0608264878,
-0.0396689586,
-0.0072191237,
0.0347299948,
-0.0077788653,
0.0263865981,
-0.0145855555,
-0.0340314694,
0.0034153205,
0.0095867468,
0.0922045931,
0.0951234102,
-0.0320037752,
-0.0038809741,
-0.0321423449,
0.0069565889,
-0.0900395736,
0.031507872,
0.0368384607,
-0.0040484392,
0.0142575875,
0.0454718396,
-0.0024410251,
-0.0435148217,
0.0313780904,
0.0285986587,
-0.0050411155,
0.0413892828,
0.0170397386,
0.0195451565,
0.0269696284,
-0.0294973422,
0.0281813219,
0.0281899571,
-0.0280447658,
-0.0144537603,
0.0219446905,
-0.0075888229,
-0.0804862157,
0.0386402793,
-0.0787789151,
-0.0032314863,
0.045809757,
-0.0290980153,
-0.0254409239,
0.02237859,
-0.0403316878,
0.057546407,
-0.0203544218,
0.007923143,
0.0364974625,
-0.0040815379,
-0.0492153354,
0.0495583788,
0.0211569462,
0.010400706,
-0.0067847166,
0.0148722287,
0.0620168895,
-0.0709960684,
-0.0241918173,
-0.0008966466,
0.0010305952,
-0.0044829291,
0.055666022,
0.0017501459,
-0.0296537299,
-0.0272008907,
-0.11010921,
0.0120936893,
-0.0209865309,
0.0492752716,
0.0602835789,
-0.0685423017,
0.0112844063,
-0.0046592229,
-0.0420982949,
-0.0153471399,
-0.0025448645,
0.0048766821,
0.0654789656,
-0.0031062402,
0.0226999,
-0.0601838715,
0.0109646628,
-0.0151969483,
0.0402083546,
0.0104078762,
0.0081111146,
0.0066390489,
-0.0584333651,
-0.0386032946,
0.005222918,
0.0081972629,
-0.0440547317,
0.0721321627,
0.0525410771,
0.0519420356,
0.042704463,
0.056476336,
0.0142687755,
0.0370130204,
-0.0017495003,
-0.0303557459,
0.002771961,
0.0095264697,
0.0631550327,
0.0042874059,
-0.0298185367,
0.0398217663,
0.0780554563,
-0.0000271031,
0.0221267138,
-0.0493441001,
0.0741927326,
0.0232426971,
-0.00598402,
0.0022466138,
-0.025019927,
-0.0197343528,
0.0395468324,
-0.0312507153,
-0.006521577,
0.0569557287,
-0.0514367297,
0.0146636134,
-0.0543473847,
0.0132949548,
-0.0182501543,
0.0234664325,
-0.002595474,
0.0183220431,
0.0141686657,
0.0305609535,
-0.0078102802,
-0.0158381835,
0.0295595583,
-0.0141492514,
0.0066229454,
-0.063853167,
0.0002536167,
-0.005721279,
-0.0493125655,
-0.0444479398,
-0.0347247273,
-0.0303195976,
-0.0289079882,
0.0094678272,
-0.0133894337,
-0.0145557467,
-0.0259438809,
-0.024749212,
0.0208774414,
-0.0212774128,
-0.0021158061,
0.01446201,
0.0547194853,
0.0133462623,
0.0328453928,
0.0506255627,
0.0168645401,
0.0118509354,
0.0550219044,
-0.0181644838,
-0.0076354421,
-0.0397866704,
-0.0420350097,
-0.0340086371,
-0.049394682,
-0.0240467153,
-0.0458539166,
0.0605965927,
-0.0485534556,
-0.0105127851,
0.0669685155,
0.0370409936,
0.0345059186,
0.0122952703,
-0.0310742836,
0.0832279772,
-0.0030693328,
0.0122732697,
-0.0688493699,
-0.0262712892,
-0.0291274097,
0.0510100648,
-0.0629862025,
-0.0116055962,
-0.0412972495,
-0.1161004156,
0.0244984161,
0.004075544,
0.0305682607,
0.0238623153,
0.0014927343,
-0.0067516002,
-0.0167081412,
-0.0344887339,
0.0261943564,
-0.0035327314,
0.0398075506,
0.0229518674,
-0.0115947956,
0.009305777,
-0.0072418568,
0.007950115,
0.0427035503,
0.0199833736,
0.0692109764,
0.0242944937,
-0.0262827575,
0.0496277511,
-0.0367782563,
-0.0259899851,
-0.028010847,
0.027840877,
-0.0027743808,
-0.0231701359,
-0.0443842746,
0.0247858558,
0.0174339823,
-0.0508849248,
0.02415918,
0.0278450251,
-0.0225562342,
-0.0249305051,
-0.0164259542,
0.0504864343,
0.0136673711,
0.0776449218,
0.0532798246,
-0.0274843741,
-0.070377849,
-0.0363962762,
-0.0131512089,
-0.1245173961,
0.0219207536,
-0.0422178246,
0.0296111051,
0.0302854422,
-0.131946072,
-0.0524674207,
-0.0447335765,
0.0417808369,
-0.0207193512,
-0.0394579433,
-0.0130868321,
-0.0163290482,
-0.0560185723,
-0.0093202116,
-0.0023200912,
0.0070372391,
-0.0340685695,
-0.0205696989,
0.0228890441,
-0.0122811655,
-0.0497299396,
0.0293766297,
-0.0327923819,
-0.0951172113,
-0.01496269,
0.0614618622,
0.0218415,
0.032868661,
-0.0089615351,
-0.0262089092,
0.0297584683,
0.0252072643,
0.0470215529,
0.0130006419,
0.074730739,
-0.0021673515,
-0.0090246443,
0.0233319253,
0.0196889862,
0.0087768342,
0.0014323619,
0.0410101712,
-0.0021866818,
0.0099644996,
0.0056697777,
0.007795034,
0.0302204192,
-0.016772164,
-0.0185360219,
-0.0165582597,
0.0177904591,
-0.0718338862,
-0.0106253736,
-0.0292870011,
0.0010219193,
-0.0255577993,
-0.0250406358,
-0.0326411277,
0.0159725361,
-0.0475649349,
0.0397122465,
-0.0155558214,
0.0467140228,
0.0085890889,
0.0388192572,
-0.0288920812,
-0.0334363468,
-0.0438671336,
0.0007574001,
0.023141982,
0.0589355752,
-0.0078519927,
0.0351807326,
0.0281267017,
-0.0173086207,
0.0264493264,
0.0328413397,
-0.0377242155,
0.0213754214,
-0.0336199738,
0.0144022265,
0.0127410358,
-0.0161799658,
0.0841613188,
-0.0400844775,
-0.0137301227,
-0.0139126768,
0.0280618034,
0.0001133781,
-0.008460057,
0.0139441825,
-0.0081483256,
-0.029820824,
0.0136297159,
0.0550306402,
-0.0146955159,
0.0364218764,
0.0142481392,
-0.0130168647,
-0.0636514202,
-0.0550845973,
-0.0316534154,
0.0243316777,
0.0076018362,
-0.0332274139,
-0.0335408486,
-0.0059822919,
0.0003968137,
0.0521806143,
0.0526787639,
0.0166590754,
0.0153755601,
0.0340082236,
-0.0106049664,
0.0164685696,
-0.0329247639,
0.0262159277,
-0.0018403486,
0.0153132286,
-0.0333753191,
-6.162232322e-33,
-0.0130565371,
-0.0368274376,
0.0095822681,
-0.016285954,
-0.0064829807,
-0.0150820855,
-0.054641217,
0.0257737152,
-0.0018711857,
0.0706165135,
0.025592139,
-0.0024579519,
0.0050320732,
0.0210505854,
-0.0280045737,
0.0099233771,
0.0571012311,
0.0157257188,
-0.0589756966,
0.0220056605,
0.0173857287,
-0.0157984588,
0.0271719415,
-0.0698641241,
0.0189540908,
-0.0031524519,
-0.0267349537,
-0.0261796787,
-0.0476618484,
0.0322166197,
-0.0094692521,
0.038783811,
0.0286995135,
0.0132133598,
0.0100958413,
0.0165184196,
-0.0301531125,
-0.036056228,
0.0285430606,
-0.0333087221,
-0.0250544678,
-0.0427257009,
0.0190567914,
0.0072727771,
-0.0212688968,
0.0512525253,
-0.0055516902,
-0.035510052,
0.0292975213,
-0.0241879541,
-0.0806398392,
0.0416076407,
-0.0223614033,
-0.0400357731,
-0.0412926152,
0.0579689927,
-0.0044350717,
0.0407359302,
-0.0442673787,
0.0178499091,
0.0260869563,
-0.0118751545,
0.0246715676,
-0.0474337973,
-0.0241997354,
0.0676942244,
0.0054217936,
0.0014357276,
-0.0099450927,
0.0249693543,
-0.0276165772,
0.0325730294,
0.0660879686,
0.0673724413,
0.0492378362,
0.0071990471,
-0.0976016149,
0.0063025672,
0.0270135235,
0.0101236198,
0.0293797068,
-0.0131909074,
0.0172437411,
0.0254168846,
-0.0220725443,
-0.1063733026,
-0.0025959588,
0.0003908703,
0.018644888,
0.0248821843,
-0.0500950515,
0.0073304898,
-0.0199585482,
0.0078080385,
0.0042998483,
0.0153043978,
-0.0515302084,
-0.0014779975,
0.0243292768,
0.0046358113,
-0.0320067592,
0.0379451178,
0.0406362377,
0.044560913,
0.0360203683,
-0.0186603125,
0.0589694716,
-0.0344257876,
-0.0621244162,
0.0326855704,
-0.0223607998,
0.0496196821,
-0.043128252,
0.0306510441,
0.0079722349,
-0.0010517415,
-0.008341549,
0.0356620178,
-0.0008378475,
-0.0029057323,
-0.0365452096,
-0.0154693676,
0.0154587086,
0.0045053097,
-0.0179568734,
0.0191457681,
0.0121714696,
0.0592996739,
-0.0278029107,
-0.0435896404,
0.0022899013,
-0.0162282828,
2.49e-7,
0.0486415848,
0.069346413,
0.0562277213,
-0.0187391657,
0.0237259716,
0.0223211851,
-0.022755757,
0.028384896,
-0.0148323728,
-0.0101560252,
-0.0318484195,
-0.0107554737,
0.0453130454,
0.0349413343,
-0.0248110332,
-0.0262509324,
-0.1077508032,
-0.0253884811,
-0.0381636508,
-0.0230128374,
0.111775443,
0.0552245788,
0.0013221258,
0.0038900871,
0.0053911973,
0.0194545984,
0.0880289674,
0.0147616658,
0.0157516804,
0.004912836,
0.0770951957,
-0.0496592186,
-0.0162450522,
0.0081114294,
-0.0218322817,
0.0057754973,
-0.0398241505,
0.0518692695,
0.002128426,
-0.0681808963,
0.0269189067,
-0.0003068984,
0.0062159589,
-0.0685197115,
0.0417172611,
-0.0458698459,
-0.0109730372,
-0.0339605361,
-0.0514844917,
0.0225938186,
0.0293759163,
-0.0550018474,
-0.0589879826,
-0.0236093067,
-0.0077504818,
-0.0091938544,
0.0092983171,
-0.0687623993,
-0.0406419598,
0.0260306988,
-0.0241104607,
-0.0157162696,
-0.038723506,
0.0055224421,
0.0227682292,
-0.037047334,
0.0306827817,
1.756593669e-34,
0.0648651421,
-0.0257438272,
-0.0046519311,
-0.0303024594,
0.0306225829,
0.0269175656,
0.0122097181,
-0.0199398603,
0.0237052105,
-0.0158706736,
-0.0020340187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13594v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13594v1 | Towards More Faithful Natural Language Explanation Using Multi-Level Contrastive Learning in VQA | 2023-12-21T05:51:55 | 2023-12-21T05:51:55 | Chengen Lai, Shengli Song, Shiqi Meng, Jingyang Li, Sitong Yan, Guangneng Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Natural language explanation in visual question answer (VQA-NLE) aims to
explain the decision-making process of models by generating natural language
sentences to increase users' trust in the black-box systems. Existing post-hoc
methods have achieved significant progress in obtaining a plausible
explanation. However, such post-hoc explanations are not always aligned with
human logical inference, suffering from the issues on: 1) Deductive
unsatisfiability, the generated explanations do not logically lead to the
answer; 2) Factual inconsistency, the model falsifies its counterfactual
explanation for answers without considering the facts in images; and 3)
Semantic perturbation insensitivity, the model can not recognize the semantic
changes caused by small perturbations. These problems reduce the faithfulness
of explanations generated by models. To address the above issues, we propose a
novel self-supervised \textbf{M}ulti-level \textbf{C}ontrastive
\textbf{L}earning based natural language \textbf{E}xplanation model (MCLE) for
VQA with semantic-level, image-level, and instance-level factual and
counterfactual samples. MCLE extracts discriminative features and aligns the
feature spaces from explanations with visual question and answer to generate
more consistent explanations. We conduct extensive experiments, ablation
analysis, and case study to demonstrate the effectiveness of our method on two
VQA-NLE benchmarks. | [
0.0395587794,
0.0266813952,
-0.0066480013,
0.0698246658,
-0.0335480645,
0.0234293081,
0.0397799984,
-0.0139375748,
-0.0025247997,
-0.0163547117,
0.0225755535,
-0.0097536361,
-0.0000213307,
0.0559469424,
0.0340834036,
-0.0933491737,
0.0387665778,
-0.0244653877,
-0.0133457612,
-0.0015802277,
0.0302470122,
0.0143142827,
-0.0106954668,
0.0265412591,
-0.0154203186,
-0.0404196866,
-0.0367637761,
0.0051388899,
0.0230565704,
-0.0052230614,
-0.0302807856,
0.0395291895,
0.0534437969,
-0.036710497,
0.0000022807,
-0.0042943219,
-0.0284310319,
0.0159547031,
-0.0567100644,
0.0060702334,
-0.0152435964,
0.0137189496,
0.0311706271,
0.0097224414,
-0.0251026042,
0.0180125348,
0.0721173957,
0.0580774024,
0.0895661414,
0.0287553091,
-0.0009057101,
-0.0537237227,
-0.02415994,
0.0268618949,
0.0114779742,
-0.0304269549,
-0.0427206047,
0.0374077745,
-0.0102126095,
0.0140702957,
-0.0320660137,
0.0093158251,
0.0423795655,
-0.0179784819,
0.0123711945,
0.049321603,
-0.0002932927,
-0.0197408497,
-0.0156363174,
0.0794483498,
0.0086812805,
-0.0033899411,
-0.0398179404,
-0.0083836298,
-0.0022174174,
0.0499666855,
-0.006784339,
-0.0027147722,
-0.0286063887,
-0.0076233447,
-0.0119929416,
0.0228993483,
-0.0001146153,
0.02435527,
0.0161026213,
0.0005941887,
-0.0043381802,
0.0108156726,
-0.058148399,
-0.0086315861,
-0.039327126,
-0.0584186949,
-0.0057289139,
0.0584821664,
-0.0213804748,
0.0010788183,
0.0132398661,
-0.0216089375,
-0.028921945,
-0.0408545099,
0.0432479866,
0.0252325144,
-0.0783735067,
0.0682409182,
0.0057699699,
0.0824084431,
-0.0174615439,
-0.0071866708,
-0.0283268336,
-0.0045750262,
-0.0344656706,
-0.0166381877,
-0.0326496661,
0.0272991881,
-0.0730554089,
0.0005435742,
-0.0087583913,
-0.0199338142,
-0.0117313154,
-0.0052691996,
0.007299846,
0.0667768866,
-0.0325545371,
-0.0337145068,
-0.0795643628,
0.0660571381,
-0.0470955968,
0.008055822,
-0.0080409497,
-0.0426195636,
-0.0077324482,
0.0141260074,
0.0135080628,
-0.0305962581,
0.0152595835,
0.0798329636,
-0.0165074021,
-0.0071193678,
-0.0579923689,
-0.0256070308,
-0.0382019132,
-0.0555927083,
-0.0239111576,
-0.0521136448,
-0.0091317026,
-0.0130912969,
-0.0369725823,
-0.0277449973,
0.0018038452,
0.0030223331,
-0.0494135246,
0.120637916,
-0.0365620591,
-0.0327022411,
0.0208492205,
0.0028537852,
0.0037151359,
0.023800781,
0.0241652578,
0.0218540765,
0.0492136069,
-0.0374636985,
0.0458415374,
-0.0238547027,
0.0085857566,
-0.0310931932,
-0.0601223186,
0.0221800208,
-0.033539515,
0.0234831739,
0.0488217846,
0.0285075475,
-0.0308120642,
-0.0287913159,
0.0670573711,
0.0229089186,
0.0136768529,
0.0197872184,
0.0220624767,
-0.0050060325,
-0.0076048831,
0.069566533,
-0.0447070859,
0.0897659659,
-0.007311258,
0.012581028,
0.0214826465,
0.0257581193,
-0.0368561931,
-0.0901906714,
-0.0006964504,
0.0028969215,
0.0209150948,
0.00825423,
0.0498460643,
0.0008788554,
-0.0470005348,
-0.0063473107,
0.0248161219,
-0.0269019119,
0.0104336822,
-0.032949321,
0.0743297413,
0.0933465809,
0.0169492718,
-0.002356505,
-0.0061917789,
0.0012386006,
-0.0075241369,
0.0454953015,
-0.0016386817,
0.008083608,
0.0167251844,
-0.0333190002,
-0.0713914484,
-0.0704295412,
-0.021918023,
0.0089370264,
-0.0101686958,
-0.0351677053,
-0.0078033796,
-0.0449033715,
-0.0132746939,
0.0305844583,
0.0265404508,
-0.020111654,
0.0087371049,
0.0311298296,
0.003789817,
0.0134382294,
0.0052766744,
-0.001702572,
-0.0222727768,
-0.0143670319,
-0.0010232645,
0.0139187425,
-0.0332697444,
-0.0830882937,
0.0256363563,
-0.0660048649,
-0.0017033743,
0.0433751754,
-0.0693203583,
-0.0341213755,
0.025551796,
-0.040540766,
-0.0273391344,
-0.0573196337,
-0.030059563,
0.0385924764,
0.0175304301,
-0.0256604105,
0.0883885548,
-0.0181750376,
-0.0344720744,
-0.0192557741,
0.0288778618,
0.0396283455,
-0.0192305502,
0.0476431139,
0.0011022211,
-0.0073094023,
0.0079175439,
0.0108055454,
-0.002834873,
-0.0440976284,
0.0240365602,
-0.0287984591,
-0.0240693651,
-0.0315824039,
-0.0098603684,
0.0433009043,
0.007137741,
0.0191126484,
-0.0512055978,
-0.0214150324,
0.0131792128,
-0.001407024,
-0.0137780579,
0.0755869225,
-0.0010111143,
0.0192021746,
-0.0346638151,
-0.0084841475,
-0.0099393269,
0.0859203711,
0.0134835821,
0.0125393514,
-0.0697042122,
-0.0030221592,
-0.0341894925,
0.0302771386,
0.0109773269,
-0.0403057672,
0.0181927867,
0.0307889078,
-0.0029958817,
0.0725880638,
0.0235597976,
0.04440834,
-0.0002836617,
0.0221746825,
-0.0343272239,
0.0231964979,
-0.011032355,
-0.0123625193,
0.0129856281,
-0.0704144761,
-0.0438955538,
0.0666062534,
-0.0070057819,
-0.0047402945,
-0.0796550065,
0.0340230875,
0.0373672135,
-0.0208772905,
-0.0362794623,
-0.0084189055,
0.0109806499,
0.0616119988,
-0.0530632511,
-0.0708529577,
0.09408205,
-0.0205678605,
0.0042329258,
-0.0153176449,
-0.0234148335,
-0.0125470413,
0.0607382767,
-0.0135371638,
0.0243314803,
0.0214364231,
-0.0072728978,
-0.0408292003,
-0.0796492547,
0.0577697866,
-0.000945317,
0.0219977237,
-0.0602396987,
-0.0142517667,
0.0106375832,
-0.0235664919,
-0.0455096103,
-0.0540390946,
-0.0184608176,
0.0101984981,
-0.0347583704,
-0.0275021549,
0.0270833895,
0.0381535888,
0.0426282287,
0.0018853978,
-0.0112156114,
-0.0071814456,
-0.0230301544,
0.0535984822,
0.0610539839,
0.0569602922,
0.0498705283,
-0.0047622141,
0.0284965578,
0.0405513607,
-0.0037001364,
-0.031520769,
-0.0434035026,
0.0306489002,
-0.0170227773,
0.0053769271,
-0.0266744774,
0.0344852619,
0.0531525277,
-0.0682951286,
-0.013670722,
0.0905974954,
0.007425651,
0.0137777999,
0.0043320428,
-0.0223892368,
-0.0046543158,
0.0244003367,
0.0296334308,
-0.0564569794,
-0.0435409024,
-0.0417057276,
0.0308692679,
0.0347984172,
0.0174506698,
-0.0077423267,
-0.0878022686,
0.0752351284,
-0.009578729,
-0.0398860574,
-0.0332622863,
-0.0365388431,
-0.0157547444,
-0.019635722,
0.0050482182,
0.0046493704,
0.0199351888,
0.0293713808,
0.0359840579,
-0.0072019058,
-0.0085570887,
0.0260029975,
-0.0462469459,
-0.0126349879,
0.0489588492,
0.019472992,
-0.0302116293,
-0.0727862343,
-0.0104388865,
-0.0331465229,
0.0374199562,
-0.0118389912,
0.0980109796,
-0.0029204858,
-0.0328501202,
-0.0263637993,
0.0421102419,
0.0249657109,
-0.0317185335,
-0.0498322845,
0.039133504,
-0.0194929056,
0.0035867325,
-0.0252598543,
0.0203889757,
-0.0118588675,
0.0431062467,
0.0337199271,
-0.0226820353,
-0.0640682802,
-0.0156924669,
0.0032645457,
-0.0253442507,
-0.026746057,
0.020246705,
0.0315589979,
-0.002974205,
-0.0372145362,
-0.0173954163,
-0.003861622,
0.0718288422,
-0.0420790315,
0.0025026056,
-0.0034455752,
-0.0027297318,
-0.0260005742,
0.0500114411,
-0.0065269102,
0.0411359668,
0.0394953862,
0.0110823987,
-0.000671429,
-0.0575057417,
-0.0154691236,
-0.0259440187,
0.0265631061,
-0.016732214,
-0.0291285068,
0.0764022395,
0.0118725197,
0.0796729997,
0.0412316881,
-0.0533009134,
0.0134283565,
-0.0171598997,
0.0237223692,
-0.0357550159,
0.0177512411,
0.0072969804,
-0.0069662267,
0.0110413982,
0.0045118346,
-0.0131949559,
0.020274898,
0.0427719988,
-0.0220659859,
-0.0226566028,
0.0532390364,
-0.0272794645,
0.0594628453,
-0.0198267959,
0.0159140732,
-0.0164692272,
0.0288517494,
-0.0139272539,
-0.0196519084,
-0.0608560741,
0.0244503096,
-0.0074591977,
-0.0170118585,
0.0187266227,
-0.0618145987,
-0.0666100457,
-0.005768484,
-0.0024388642,
-0.0119005116,
0.0399645083,
0.0082002692,
-0.0306608062,
0.0080465646,
-0.0047544283,
-0.0204249993,
0.0054937783,
0.0660036132,
0.0254622251,
0.1059312522,
0.0297250263,
-0.0080088414,
-0.0383177735,
0.0045011239,
-0.0281119701,
-0.0090639312,
-0.0241564922,
-0.0025200166,
0.0508262552,
-0.0129075386,
-0.0207674168,
0.0192501917,
-0.0152221899,
0.006279239,
0.0459768996,
0.0179414749,
-0.0226048622,
0.0776157603,
0.0204343721,
-0.0113136228,
-0.0058996035,
0.0541369133,
-0.0020422156,
0.007760827,
-0.0138537614,
0.0004099751,
-0.03415047,
-0.0190455802,
0.018344352,
0.0220058188,
0.0025233394,
0.0329769999,
-0.0471178852,
-0.0822468176,
-0.0008955254,
0.0356065035,
-0.0203558058,
0.0009495313,
0.0451886207,
0.0473896712,
0.0346567221,
-0.0559417643,
-0.0158763751,
0.0040776604,
-0.0200786237,
0.0389021114,
-0.0182604007,
-7.032038632e-33,
-0.026142491,
-0.0866963863,
0.0332788825,
-0.0254369956,
0.0161772221,
0.0186810605,
-0.0153269628,
-0.0136771966,
-0.0144815603,
0.0361456722,
0.0103444047,
0.0127567854,
0.0145663694,
0.031066997,
-0.0282926671,
-0.0391336344,
0.0328276157,
-0.0003669426,
-0.0294895321,
0.0231699552,
0.0126781231,
-0.0109831635,
0.0797973275,
-0.1034968719,
0.0153802587,
0.0265664794,
-0.0204169843,
0.0411430262,
-0.0178729985,
0.0655279085,
-0.032016959,
0.0086654974,
0.0031957589,
-0.0473043211,
-0.0018084882,
-0.0060852929,
-0.0567887239,
-0.0135455038,
0.0564174466,
0.0072736731,
-0.1106497422,
-0.018774718,
0.0045803883,
-0.0092000067,
0.0103755733,
-0.0493187718,
0.0539577119,
-0.0193212703,
0.0098316064,
0.0307638701,
0.0016053193,
0.012662502,
-0.0482586659,
-0.045973856,
-0.021052381,
0.043139562,
0.0116585214,
-0.0096413149,
-0.0322148837,
-0.0148713877,
0.0243294463,
-0.0114962626,
0.1071036682,
0.0115758246,
-0.0063795079,
0.0370894819,
0.0445722677,
-0.0052268552,
-0.0431231,
-0.0391955413,
-0.041870635,
0.0697334483,
0.1203428134,
0.0721678585,
0.0287284479,
0.058645986,
-0.0692095831,
0.0228145774,
-0.0830342323,
0.0722292289,
-0.0094378013,
0.0126845296,
-0.0312378462,
-0.0102252103,
-0.0446296036,
-0.0294264425,
-0.0325692147,
-0.0350982025,
0.0200673509,
0.0073354538,
-0.0417456403,
0.0169764012,
0.0227365643,
-0.0523883849,
0.0037454984,
-0.006078457,
-0.0054012383,
0.0032495554,
0.0268782377,
0.0373918563,
-0.0244822502,
0.0133807184,
0.0112904152,
0.0065022842,
0.0007940879,
0.0268583503,
0.0247021206,
0.0102535812,
-0.0141633293,
0.012447726,
-0.0466657393,
-0.037880253,
-0.0513180941,
-0.0196151789,
0.0200508367,
0.0101407757,
-0.0658233315,
0.0155376419,
0.0129548172,
-0.0034394462,
-0.0045799711,
-0.0352950208,
-0.014492901,
0.0414811149,
-0.0032330309,
0.0085198982,
-0.0360635072,
-0.038856294,
0.0091120675,
-0.037798427,
-0.0196083691,
0.0591722131,
2.891e-7,
0.0313397944,
0.0111940214,
0.0386045799,
0.0033144637,
0.0031369687,
0.071907185,
0.0045476421,
-0.0312950425,
0.0167948995,
-0.0304074623,
0.0186358988,
0.05122732,
0.0398929082,
0.005342857,
0.0371806212,
0.0512808673,
-0.0449760221,
-0.0200169254,
-0.0534430929,
0.0181692746,
0.10076195,
0.0344009809,
0.0002579327,
-0.0303255524,
0.0198094603,
-0.0174390469,
0.0519024841,
0.0090378299,
0.0041351379,
-0.0420388728,
0.0301247966,
-0.0069705578,
0.0053045228,
0.0143394675,
-0.0046844953,
-0.0065542432,
0.0105311545,
0.0354877003,
-0.0296778288,
-0.0596065037,
-0.0427376255,
0.0014651585,
0.0168681964,
-0.0713783205,
0.0725690573,
-0.0354918055,
-0.0277112313,
-0.0365622379,
-0.053389933,
-0.0194055941,
0.0350344069,
-0.0065972158,
-0.0198702104,
0.0130318049,
0.0154393446,
-0.0300003495,
-0.0343270935,
-0.0377843119,
-0.0226377435,
0.03592363,
-0.0044297627,
0.0183005333,
-0.018848652,
0.0180560462,
0.0729020461,
-0.0058554341,
-0.047014948,
2.178803345e-34,
0.0161531754,
0.0195770971,
0.0182721205,
0.0183866937,
0.0295597818,
0.0036182094,
-0.0536067076,
-0.0345241278,
0.0520572551,
-0.0500179045,
-0.0183021463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13585v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13585v1 | Speech Translation with Large Language Models: An Industrial Practice | 2023-12-21T05:32:49 | 2023-12-21T05:32:49 | Zhichao Huang, Rong Ye, Tom Ko, Qianqian Dong, Shanbo Cheng, Mingxuan Wang, Hang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Given the great success of large language models (LLMs) across various tasks,
in this paper, we introduce LLM-ST, a novel and effective speech translation
model constructed upon a pre-trained LLM. By integrating the large language
model (LLM) with a speech encoder and employing multi-task instruction tuning,
LLM-ST can produce accurate timestamped transcriptions and translations, even
from long audio inputs. Furthermore, our findings indicate that the
implementation of Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting can yield advantages in the
context of LLM-ST. Through rigorous experimentation on English and Chinese
datasets, we showcase the exceptional performance of LLM-ST, establishing a new
benchmark in the field of speech translation. Demo:
https://speechtranslation.github.io/llm-st/. | [
-0.0023286529,
0.050050579,
0.0133433016,
0.0499042198,
-0.0351790562,
0.001360583,
0.0529159792,
-0.026204383,
-0.0369004533,
-0.0139915338,
-0.060949225,
-0.0400605351,
0.0420523994,
-0.0116747394,
0.0184075907,
-0.0287609454,
0.0388198532,
-0.0347451866,
-0.0272159129,
0.0130862826,
-0.0231558457,
0.0064104823,
-0.0166121777,
0.0228778981,
-0.0050257985,
-0.0124309454,
-0.0040632775,
0.0625517964,
0.0399474874,
-0.0214215331,
-0.0249617379,
0.0029530735,
0.0456991009,
0.0821674392,
0.0000021186,
-0.0331821032,
-0.0131992288,
-0.0012934988,
-0.0315786526,
0.0278307125,
0.0108478852,
-0.0129024787,
-0.0289443638,
0.0560368262,
-0.0171521232,
-0.0205159914,
0.0306465738,
0.0336814299,
0.0586896166,
0.1183230206,
-0.0233515017,
-0.0456668213,
0.0084870663,
-0.0498865135,
-0.0237770397,
-0.0516759753,
0.0068047917,
-0.0027757892,
-0.0293900874,
0.0142107205,
-0.0191774163,
0.0482168458,
-0.0072014634,
-0.009473973,
0.0013471675,
-0.0031235218,
-0.0063537834,
-0.0195701774,
-0.0450281985,
0.0771013349,
-0.037254218,
0.0094586397,
-0.008037311,
0.0120647997,
-0.0320047997,
-0.0368336104,
-0.0424213596,
-0.0086015202,
0.0366763175,
0.0113441311,
0.0300282389,
0.0469521955,
0.028264882,
-0.0285257585,
-0.0315778106,
0.0128214695,
0.0256970711,
-0.0366646573,
-0.0124896951,
0.0010513149,
0.0187443756,
-0.016086597,
0.0751454234,
0.0165811833,
-0.0368967466,
0.00746495,
-0.0322252996,
-0.0309474282,
-0.0421741121,
-0.0454335809,
0.0220636986,
0.0621080734,
-0.0299297404,
0.050632026,
-0.0280904006,
0.0702011883,
-0.0356448106,
-0.0086145913,
-0.0771481991,
-0.0193060078,
-0.03179105,
0.0430054367,
-0.0352612101,
-0.0387414061,
-0.040990673,
-0.0275126509,
-0.0134931691,
0.0030376406,
0.0193709601,
0.0261443201,
0.0348226242,
-0.0469749123,
-0.0526004247,
-0.0296164863,
-0.0048612133,
0.069490321,
0.0148308733,
0.0290838405,
-0.0060675861,
-0.0315395892,
-0.0380364098,
0.0317280553,
0.0252535716,
-0.0297482368,
0.0194849782,
0.0574512146,
-0.0295535568,
-0.0021222008,
-0.0322903879,
0.0012618888,
-0.0081487484,
-0.0425207578,
-0.0233904328,
-0.0625996217,
0.0642625093,
-0.0100969654,
0.0306461826,
-0.0184426978,
0.0099510113,
-0.010019619,
-0.0187555794,
0.0549060255,
0.0058936072,
0.0482924804,
0.0316691287,
-0.0082872892,
-0.001454548,
0.0407399759,
0.0841073245,
0.0231257845,
0.0143527091,
-0.0188614167,
-0.0224382952,
0.0786909387,
-0.0079269074,
0.0211179201,
-0.0076791081,
0.005621315,
0.0279026832,
0.0356057175,
0.0264207814,
0.0526584871,
0.00434179,
0.0440831147,
0.0804067031,
0.016359102,
-0.0165756736,
0.0277433638,
0.0468287989,
0.026554171,
-0.0175006501,
-0.0374048427,
-0.0168135427,
0.0130507313,
-0.0017650858,
-0.0120383557,
0.0525562502,
0.0340143107,
-0.0251179989,
-0.0006242081,
0.0138856992,
-0.0187286288,
0.0056905462,
0.0183732994,
0.0224470627,
-0.0104712378,
-0.0762374327,
0.037167009,
-0.0097610522,
-0.0237677116,
0.0323699042,
-0.0115481773,
-0.0255995691,
0.0877933055,
0.0355497412,
0.0036262216,
-0.015017096,
-0.0736284554,
0.0155812632,
0.0675865933,
0.0458350405,
-0.0055545154,
0.0225644838,
-0.0631175637,
-0.004550573,
0.0441245064,
-0.0150974607,
0.0181389004,
-0.01728056,
0.0530000366,
0.0341215022,
0.0100193322,
-0.0383782648,
0.0071409983,
-0.0171890315,
-0.0345757976,
0.0230527036,
0.0202990677,
0.0413691662,
0.0313797668,
-0.0372374691,
0.0023035868,
0.0238082875,
-0.0564576685,
0.0091964938,
0.0309788398,
-0.0764499381,
-0.0586200766,
0.0201883391,
-0.0085416986,
0.0014718781,
0.0236067791,
-0.0361066163,
-0.1003930867,
-0.0334945992,
0.0081326338,
0.0261491984,
-0.0150489751,
0.0731407776,
-0.0156277344,
0.0167744737,
-0.0037769917,
0.0003860661,
0.0269972403,
-0.03348241,
0.0380641483,
0.0152600175,
0.0007666115,
-0.0537067838,
-0.0298904348,
0.0569398478,
0.0193074867,
0.0209087841,
0.0160282291,
0.0235512611,
-0.0215042587,
-0.0294140205,
-0.1039869934,
0.0306455866,
-0.0262951851,
0.026215015,
0.0161761511,
0.012217219,
-0.0040324777,
-0.0002769115,
-0.0406018198,
-0.0086159511,
-0.0209782235,
-0.0114062047,
-0.0257471893,
-0.0229141116,
-0.0228954814,
-0.0171540882,
0.0167178251,
0.0289059076,
0.0055010007,
-0.0081994021,
-0.0461958386,
-0.0705524087,
0.0607150793,
0.0152676906,
0.0027497269,
0.0097922198,
-0.0194907896,
-0.0262147058,
0.0052912179,
0.0943039581,
0.0454722904,
-0.0022482732,
-0.0216137953,
0.0251136366,
-0.028378794,
-0.0534453019,
0.0162456743,
0.0007476826,
-0.0221199226,
-0.0445752963,
-0.0212161951,
-0.0187358987,
0.0550440215,
0.0415134579,
0.022618847,
-0.0603223965,
-0.0507318303,
-0.0244981088,
-0.0146985985,
-0.0138502335,
-0.014942795,
-0.0340633541,
0.0240391847,
-0.0197999757,
-0.0168827716,
0.033291094,
-0.0771573633,
-0.0453740507,
-0.0376276597,
-0.0155336205,
-0.0183019545,
0.0520962775,
-0.0313533507,
0.0056532617,
-0.0085192416,
-0.0251684394,
-0.0216344949,
0.0395596251,
-0.0218846463,
-0.0461115502,
0.0187910479,
-0.0357292555,
-0.003139185,
-0.0190669596,
-0.0122591918,
-0.0310877357,
-0.0207657479,
-0.0340378769,
0.0039270851,
0.001113723,
-0.0246072449,
-0.0260022227,
0.0273437891,
0.005228309,
0.0679367185,
-0.0078987097,
0.0244997218,
-0.0253278408,
0.0304852203,
0.0304630641,
0.0045729866,
0.0100856703,
-0.0336964764,
0.0609534457,
-0.0043282625,
0.0477681085,
0.014564991,
-0.0405706726,
-0.0259439517,
0.0207910016,
0.0080439318,
-0.023258077,
0.0126530519,
0.0742350444,
-0.0425333604,
-0.0010416183,
0.1385462582,
-0.0038638427,
-0.0613751113,
-0.0061318758,
0.0024984966,
0.0017502804,
0.0136063946,
-0.0006350142,
-0.0664775595,
-0.0413989723,
0.0423089825,
0.0242570229,
0.0360179879,
0.0236581489,
-0.0101951677,
-0.0952862725,
0.0332534164,
0.0556716397,
-0.0082391817,
-0.0441252291,
-0.0236558653,
-0.0234029163,
-0.0263843555,
0.0414823256,
-0.0015319893,
0.0148365106,
-0.031568706,
0.0220527779,
0.0081255082,
-0.0494518243,
0.0466375574,
-0.0237314422,
0.0745681673,
0.0558874272,
0.0464301668,
0.0021049355,
-0.0126530342,
0.0214803834,
0.0176713709,
-0.0163052548,
0.0083382297,
-0.0167347789,
-0.0131181479,
-0.0159742702,
0.0295466613,
0.0437396131,
-0.0420996584,
0.0402147472,
0.0600075647,
0.0709536448,
-0.0238621142,
0.0099084713,
0.0434607677,
-0.0162797756,
0.0160529111,
0.0868600681,
0.0178321432,
-0.0574751236,
0.019735422,
-0.0064595575,
-0.0440896563,
-0.0538762845,
-0.0391086042,
0.0141534014,
-0.0302553494,
0.0072583766,
-0.0765686929,
-0.0113783833,
-0.0030622836,
0.02810877,
0.0354872942,
0.0165736247,
0.0370827578,
0.0186295416,
-0.0198160503,
0.0096807387,
-0.0401272587,
0.0482285842,
-0.0880145431,
0.0112426952,
0.0477980934,
-0.0353828073,
0.016132379,
0.0513080545,
-0.0991643965,
-0.0548472777,
-0.0415742435,
-0.0100805247,
0.015479953,
0.0560359396,
-0.028898932,
0.0168502778,
0.04109063,
-0.0317746066,
-0.0307597965,
0.0052724937,
0.0286988597,
0.0017574314,
-0.0247906689,
0.0356116071,
-0.0455457978,
0.0172048863,
-0.0183702204,
0.0662442669,
-0.0058415085,
-0.0697452649,
-0.0020539577,
0.0293437187,
0.0558005124,
-0.0127870785,
0.0206894856,
-0.0280072354,
0.0514464937,
-0.0163119473,
0.0065766373,
-0.0543152764,
-0.0181033965,
0.0605240054,
0.0046738074,
-0.0036010633,
-0.002607849,
0.0231994018,
-0.0612444766,
-0.0201429594,
0.0118867345,
-0.0536515601,
0.0238870233,
0.0278032757,
0.0052910447,
-0.0265061297,
0.0142978448,
0.0313592963,
-0.000732617,
-0.0176501889,
0.0513298213,
-0.0112010762,
0.0299826823,
-0.0083052982,
0.0055939341,
-0.0349102393,
-0.0327010676,
-0.0165203959,
-0.0113638835,
0.0922600254,
-0.012595566,
0.1267306656,
-0.006304773,
0.0116649736,
-0.0298491791,
0.0628314838,
-0.0069166236,
-0.0089492099,
-0.014001579,
-0.0263945181,
-0.0148677537,
0.0350331925,
0.0442524739,
0.0002757522,
0.0213040151,
0.026151251,
-0.0008210029,
-0.021354828,
-0.0345183909,
-0.0102076521,
-0.0539511926,
-0.0217158273,
-0.0209312458,
0.0002848388,
-0.0403912216,
-0.0000856774,
-0.022763703,
0.0153214131,
-0.0235339068,
0.0103607671,
0.0420030616,
-0.0436057299,
0.0191669054,
-0.0119435312,
-0.0247194804,
0.0221699905,
-0.0399611183,
-0.0367574319,
-6.127765358e-33,
-0.0151779316,
0.0155902021,
0.0162523873,
-0.0068742437,
-0.0580014773,
-0.0172313619,
-0.0535447858,
-0.0218958389,
-0.0084398938,
-0.0184298661,
-0.0270564873,
-0.0092140865,
0.0333619602,
0.0184848215,
0.006316646,
0.0068244911,
0.0882975832,
-0.0232892707,
-0.0124689359,
0.0333247259,
0.0465044715,
0.0268148892,
0.0347480997,
-0.0561053343,
-0.0011573978,
-0.015882697,
-0.0066619501,
0.0178133734,
0.028689459,
0.0113243358,
0.0150235882,
0.0255549327,
-0.0058163796,
-0.0653044134,
-0.0441086888,
0.0241863448,
-0.1103691235,
0.0309235305,
0.0127630597,
0.0562481172,
0.0050358172,
-0.037248522,
0.006174454,
-0.0050994311,
-0.0065584714,
-0.0119279195,
-0.0044804686,
-0.064415969,
-0.0152209355,
-0.0502855256,
-0.0576704182,
-0.0028088444,
-0.037737973,
-0.0396088883,
0.0829370022,
0.0606685206,
-0.0182612203,
-0.0294836108,
-0.0717304945,
0.0258438047,
-0.0152057661,
0.0411710367,
0.0650057048,
0.0328485332,
-0.0088711809,
-0.0026280689,
0.0097307479,
-0.012866091,
0.0278709289,
0.0292037521,
0.0198224261,
0.0148909194,
0.017748164,
-0.0190562606,
0.0145321265,
-0.0217411369,
-0.0549318083,
0.0127350222,
0.0207352694,
-0.0148685835,
0.0461559221,
0.0385286584,
-0.0080727898,
-0.0029687244,
-0.0492926463,
0.0005786548,
-0.0074406387,
-0.0156796947,
0.0236339383,
0.0280396324,
0.0026998427,
-0.0117883701,
0.1133932769,
-0.013056295,
0.0280388705,
-0.0039927727,
-0.0434412025,
-0.0085374266,
-0.0496491119,
0.0376156084,
-0.0384099074,
-0.0552659966,
0.0516216159,
0.0092810243,
0.0152243888,
-0.0282042157,
0.0158669315,
0.039945133,
-0.0462331064,
-0.0073856208,
-0.0153061738,
-0.0074545755,
-0.0070759421,
0.0191215537,
0.0142664909,
-0.0189797319,
0.0066761998,
0.0627017692,
-0.0220199674,
0.0069612977,
-0.0062381392,
-0.0152677251,
-0.0031004241,
0.0307010934,
-0.0625353307,
0.036060378,
-0.0372209884,
-0.0116972011,
0.045482982,
-0.037775103,
-0.0402443074,
-0.0103708506,
2.761e-7,
-0.0300030019,
0.0662350804,
0.0086688921,
0.0272087213,
0.0302832481,
0.0031490335,
-0.0327947401,
0.0341046341,
0.0069095469,
0.0180167202,
0.0562691055,
0.0224251654,
0.1397119015,
-0.0094551388,
-0.0907285064,
-0.0677568614,
-0.0538232066,
0.0397187732,
-0.066960156,
-0.0079844203,
0.0363418683,
0.1048976034,
-0.0175942574,
0.0080980165,
-0.0024590921,
-0.0082274172,
0.0419451147,
-0.0258394629,
-0.0091728931,
0.0025192376,
-0.0017918083,
0.0190571155,
-0.0724035278,
0.0100398045,
-0.0276464354,
0.0382837132,
0.031025527,
0.1055227146,
0.0271089897,
-0.0103394045,
-0.0226967949,
0.0176034402,
-0.0106106382,
-0.0146788871,
0.0571627058,
-0.0240637828,
-0.0174915865,
0.0098387934,
-0.0239097811,
0.0264250785,
0.0047881408,
-0.0275789555,
0.0194058921,
0.0049894624,
0.0485433564,
0.0039670183,
-0.0344404355,
-0.0358591191,
-0.0222049356,
0.0053049168,
-0.0466127321,
-0.0463165455,
-0.0132574672,
-0.0145150051,
-0.0072811875,
-0.0208538529,
0.0014069922,
2.367629982e-34,
0.0319541246,
-0.0354789868,
0.021959411,
0.0028511537,
0.0380103141,
-0.0419277512,
-0.0215547569,
-0.003434405,
-0.0182026755,
-0.0905134752,
-0.0565751046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14203v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14203v1 | Shai: A large language model for asset management | 2023-12-21T05:08:57 | 2023-12-21T05:08:57 | Zhongyang Guo, Guanran Jiang, Zhongdan Zhang, Peng Li, Zhefeng Wang, Yinchun Wang | q-fin.PM | q-fin.PM, cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper introduces "Shai" a 10B level large language model specifically
designed for the asset management industry, built upon an open-source
foundational model. With continuous pre-training and fine-tuning using a
targeted corpus, Shai demonstrates enhanced performance in tasks relevant to
its domain, outperforming baseline models. Our research includes the
development of an innovative evaluation framework, which integrates
professional qualification exams, tailored tasks, open-ended question
answering, and safety assessments, to comprehensively assess Shai's
capabilities. Furthermore, we discuss the challenges and implications of
utilizing large language models like GPT-4 for performance assessment in asset
management, suggesting a combination of automated evaluation and human
judgment. Shai's development, showcasing the potential and versatility of
10B-level large language models in the financial sector with significant
performance and modest computational requirements, hopes to provide practical
insights and methodologies to assist industry peers in their similar endeavors. | [
0.0121277086,
0.0952252373,
-0.0071111447,
-0.001451283,
-0.0049967365,
0.012295885,
0.0519992001,
0.0466118902,
-0.0084553361,
-0.0142709222,
-0.0327781215,
-0.0084537659,
-0.0626851618,
0.0511200838,
0.0325568207,
-0.044968538,
0.0316544399,
-0.0721016452,
0.0368577354,
0.0064671175,
0.0342565514,
-0.0092338556,
0.0084767221,
-0.0142177437,
-0.0216906779,
-0.0080578662,
-0.0235294923,
-0.0326715745,
0.0206723828,
-0.0035423019,
-0.0160262957,
0.0417388715,
0.0271372516,
0.0473332852,
0.0000020673,
-0.0684927851,
-0.0442994647,
0.0222917516,
0.01156836,
0.0222047102,
0.0664588287,
-0.0114355944,
0.0060205297,
0.0126857255,
-0.0397408791,
0.0145828445,
0.0537574068,
0.0430101305,
0.065344885,
0.0473888777,
-0.0000914368,
-0.0302331336,
0.0178521257,
-0.0517261103,
-0.0621356741,
-0.1210585311,
0.0266705062,
0.0422918983,
0.0234442111,
-0.0302387401,
-0.0106003331,
0.039702829,
0.0352873169,
-0.0220403615,
0.0233279988,
0.003913647,
-0.0674522221,
0.0216984209,
-0.0327316895,
0.0183987413,
0.0173447356,
0.0566587299,
0.0215141978,
-0.0308591146,
0.0159794111,
0.0036779002,
-0.043025434,
0.0634147972,
0.0203845352,
-0.0308984295,
-0.026509352,
0.0454027206,
0.0138829481,
0.0189084765,
-0.0158998594,
0.0258432906,
-0.0104816044,
-0.0486006737,
0.0293852333,
0.0173908994,
-0.0489106476,
-0.0606545843,
0.0379093997,
0.0538810641,
-0.0167950448,
0.0020447229,
0.0270590913,
-0.0184611939,
0.0378054865,
-0.0519020185,
0.0081892414,
0.006144728,
-0.0361344554,
0.0506376736,
-0.0286792051,
0.0880014673,
-0.0020409115,
-0.0679631159,
-0.0087262616,
0.0220217016,
-0.0823877007,
-0.037323989,
-0.0546469428,
0.0694502071,
-0.0357641354,
-0.0236060452,
-0.0754591972,
0.008817995,
-0.0327840857,
0.0362467878,
0.0574079901,
-0.0179600623,
-0.0163466781,
-0.0029334519,
-0.0582580343,
-0.0255635194,
-0.0701580122,
0.018790355,
-0.0183114763,
-0.0045880233,
0.031999819,
0.0296034943,
-0.0481182784,
-0.0294541344,
0.024305433,
0.0804272816,
0.0170422141,
0.0003073839,
-0.0703474581,
-0.0530513786,
-0.0132418368,
-0.03359228,
-0.0252629239,
-0.0480482765,
-0.0324187279,
-0.0310833436,
-0.0114184571,
0.0071287588,
-0.0081682689,
-0.0209661871,
-0.0132767949,
0.0381010771,
-0.0036693555,
-0.0218779556,
-0.0053202338,
-0.00035267,
0.0351282023,
0.0473649465,
0.0274234544,
0.0581938177,
0.0275710933,
0.0165718682,
0.0104677817,
0.0331406295,
-0.036005225,
-0.0243523959,
-0.0127969673,
0.0453681313,
0.0167190898,
0.0036246474,
0.0237511899,
0.0559232086,
0.008462552,
-0.0309311301,
0.0714319274,
0.0388990864,
0.0462803841,
0.0344012976,
-0.0049342541,
0.0371561907,
0.0178040285,
-0.0631973669,
0.0019069628,
0.0215069968,
-0.0055431868,
0.032147035,
-0.0357761271,
0.0165360011,
-0.027074689,
-0.028655231,
-0.0016023749,
-0.0181521997,
0.0028022255,
0.0262411516,
0.0366551802,
-0.030277133,
-0.0321390927,
0.0357401818,
0.0132371411,
-0.0160684548,
-0.0142797353,
-0.0516979024,
0.0450301208,
0.0775115266,
0.0375273153,
-0.0363621116,
0.0030572084,
-0.0199175999,
-0.00699224,
0.0583169237,
0.0544141941,
-0.013957697,
-0.0176814608,
-0.0379378051,
-0.0213999785,
0.042973049,
0.0201878119,
0.0235281643,
-0.0553817376,
0.0066820225,
-0.0192505009,
-0.025532892,
-0.0273360088,
0.0248969384,
0.0116577493,
-0.0440674126,
-0.0478862524,
-0.0036783058,
-0.0205039922,
0.0131284343,
-0.0175596029,
-0.0152007863,
0.011651936,
0.0211589001,
-0.0403072648,
-0.0170332231,
-0.021016622,
0.0873481855,
0.0462184511,
0.0039075329,
-0.0133757647,
0.0037790083,
-0.0552426241,
-0.0276005156,
-0.0076730261,
-0.0054497654,
-0.006181438,
-0.0743822679,
0.012987216,
-0.0196631439,
-0.024909595,
-0.0410997234,
0.0762474015,
0.0063740155,
-0.0021550443,
-0.0279034935,
0.0071527339,
0.0343339257,
-0.0638544038,
-0.006327149,
0.042333588,
-0.0076414612,
0.0653828084,
0.0618310384,
0.0525726452,
-0.000850294,
-0.0203842577,
-0.0642466471,
-0.0226445775,
-0.0204092395,
0.0482986756,
0.0031406761,
-0.0002332056,
-0.0115061281,
-0.0169151425,
-0.0304613952,
-0.0111798877,
-0.0035294073,
0.0103009362,
0.0608326457,
0.0135771092,
-0.0432400554,
-0.0356436186,
-0.0253193919,
-0.0073812641,
-0.0106277987,
0.0579588823,
0.0294644907,
-0.0375065841,
0.0273008347,
-0.027219817,
0.0268094577,
0.0176465996,
-0.0179483537,
0.0391993858,
-0.0198113788,
-0.0089916931,
0.0482914709,
-0.0110279555,
0.0550944172,
-0.0078093251,
-0.0402932279,
-0.0072134193,
0.0050980509,
0.0180940442,
-0.0563426539,
-0.0025110496,
0.0524215177,
0.014190956,
0.0450643711,
-0.0353946835,
-0.0086929221,
-0.0833158344,
0.0222149696,
-0.0267240033,
0.0034589213,
-0.0511897989,
0.0037231313,
-0.0041606887,
0.0976545215,
0.0149348173,
-0.0081198476,
0.0468748063,
0.0025850264,
-0.0029983069,
-0.0334364362,
-0.0370318182,
-0.0476955138,
0.0513617583,
-0.0392435044,
0.012658081,
0.0154021699,
-0.0469955988,
-0.0732209608,
-0.0354042649,
0.0272982884,
-0.0218028501,
-0.0116257044,
-0.0640421957,
0.0158160366,
0.0181330573,
-0.0247789305,
0.0029704764,
-0.041106943,
-0.0296359714,
0.0365176648,
0.0188254248,
-0.0510816574,
-0.0594674163,
0.0502597839,
-0.0122203631,
-0.0009046156,
-0.0048820493,
-0.0281717908,
0.0084568439,
0.0086411918,
0.0585615076,
-0.022398036,
0.0396287888,
-0.02772687,
0.0527973585,
0.0583940111,
0.0644225031,
0.0204114635,
-0.0792962834,
0.0283519831,
-0.0059631122,
-0.0622331314,
0.0110942805,
0.0413832739,
-0.0274283532,
-0.0722357184,
-0.0189091209,
0.1081893146,
0.0143427467,
0.0227683298,
0.0039442144,
-0.0036939522,
0.0129086366,
-0.0289951786,
0.0531201586,
-0.0959639028,
-0.0076406081,
-0.0300185215,
0.0369689651,
0.023034459,
-0.0541721769,
0.0372982398,
-0.1041145846,
0.0772453621,
-0.0138453832,
-0.0203730818,
-0.0196222179,
-0.0154251922,
-0.0086741513,
-0.0697437897,
0.0184634626,
0.0259331968,
-0.0110598011,
-0.0054477081,
0.0286961086,
-0.0389013886,
-0.0001807576,
0.0654589757,
-0.0674202517,
-0.0350361615,
0.0859618187,
-0.0041386625,
-0.0186266825,
-0.0236750375,
-0.0404450223,
-0.0160268005,
0.0037585287,
0.0252652969,
0.0380205512,
0.000143286,
-0.0108567812,
-0.0129162399,
0.001944958,
-0.0332239084,
0.0194443297,
0.0324629098,
0.0516720526,
-0.0284652505,
0.0005954527,
0.010590055,
0.0062448056,
0.0093067046,
0.0349030606,
-0.0110052042,
-0.0373233892,
-0.0356219821,
-0.0442713685,
-0.0210814197,
-0.028899882,
-0.0037363472,
0.0040565431,
-0.0092268595,
-0.0128965704,
-0.0705558285,
-0.0833125636,
0.0318766981,
0.0204392355,
0.0077393292,
-0.0320039876,
0.0688770041,
-0.0119549297,
-0.0258939825,
0.0258301627,
-0.0400200896,
0.0391945094,
-0.0427855551,
0.0348172337,
0.0325660519,
-0.0000364578,
-0.0559706576,
0.0224554837,
-0.0470732413,
-0.0231799148,
0.0355477147,
0.0405742377,
0.0369081944,
-0.0783394575,
-0.0474008992,
-0.0210758522,
0.0262242481,
-0.0017978586,
-0.0701637864,
-0.0152048087,
0.0163101889,
-0.0371403061,
-0.0131304599,
0.0155155379,
-0.0599527173,
0.0408404954,
-0.0274994522,
0.0181260835,
-0.0616423599,
0.0419984683,
0.001463808,
0.0192909036,
-0.0018020382,
0.0124134617,
-0.0279823262,
0.0013184166,
-0.0279060844,
0.0091909245,
-0.000333797,
-0.0134997405,
0.0063880072,
0.0637914166,
0.0038360292,
-0.0051852334,
0.0482510887,
-0.0059956927,
-0.0302058682,
-0.0109169455,
0.0123862056,
0.0364679843,
0.0104250265,
0.0356918238,
-0.0192039814,
0.007806675,
-0.0230062474,
0.0273554139,
0.0296809971,
0.0196707733,
0.0498309173,
0.0164996032,
0.0187119581,
-0.0076567833,
-0.0050134286,
-0.0086337924,
-0.0643921122,
0.0279454943,
0.0363792852,
0.0453809611,
-0.0155456765,
-0.0058597783,
-0.0855596066,
0.024843527,
-0.0056390767,
-0.0087446384,
0.0312246121,
-0.0314392932,
0.0186491478,
0.0337808281,
-0.0271282643,
-0.0429441929,
0.0815368742,
0.0403004773,
0.0269011632,
-0.0720923617,
-0.0106394915,
-0.0393022522,
-0.0433181003,
0.0542042032,
0.0244972538,
-0.0054283529,
0.0081920382,
-0.087371327,
-0.0295312051,
-0.025314955,
0.0491181724,
0.0037866321,
-0.0439073518,
0.0283414349,
0.0357416719,
0.0141080068,
0.01047864,
0.0036129893,
-0.0404106453,
-0.0340880938,
-0.0014412407,
-0.0852618888,
-6.139695524e-33,
-0.0282129329,
-0.0492123812,
0.0426016189,
-0.021351954,
0.0137830935,
-0.0454387292,
0.0092514399,
-0.0203381367,
0.0298724584,
-0.0011403522,
0.0043341424,
0.0280088,
0.0117463153,
-0.0022975351,
0.0640585944,
-0.015288149,
0.016951466,
-0.0353450924,
-0.0391472131,
-0.036395859,
0.0309763812,
0.0448810495,
0.0639123395,
-0.010240172,
0.0412806682,
0.0097447839,
-0.0501923487,
0.0100558912,
0.033350572,
0.0709800124,
-0.0054689366,
0.0286662728,
0.0075073573,
-0.1068576127,
0.0200835466,
0.0093823373,
-0.020700682,
-0.0310094338,
0.0158723108,
0.0526787825,
0.0237047765,
-0.0098983571,
0.000427592,
-0.0070417137,
-0.0177421235,
-0.0113686705,
0.0078146756,
-0.0124138081,
0.0454919003,
-0.0375020839,
-0.0517927706,
0.0331002772,
-0.0160109513,
0.0525808223,
0.0550306626,
0.0217725858,
-0.0190131459,
0.0108743785,
-0.0440272763,
-0.003683479,
0.008023547,
0.0110123018,
0.0311937965,
0.011150267,
-0.049951788,
0.0415158197,
-0.0297700837,
0.0037334247,
0.0361087546,
0.0074549769,
-0.0020062025,
0.0820590556,
0.0278617907,
0.023872057,
0.0305485558,
0.0198050644,
-0.0609425269,
0.034927059,
0.0026509245,
0.1040639728,
-0.0072006723,
0.0405915156,
-0.0159948058,
-0.0294879563,
-0.0163220204,
-0.0074439435,
-0.0226469319,
0.0006883984,
0.0441068485,
-0.0090568615,
-0.0215217583,
0.0445323251,
0.0297529195,
-0.0236527231,
-0.0389894508,
-0.0170426983,
-0.0163152777,
0.0160535686,
-0.0016701365,
0.0619854406,
-0.0300037563,
-0.0009048338,
0.0023744574,
-0.0006721207,
0.003641224,
-0.0202459581,
0.0286887735,
0.0568137467,
-0.0283740591,
0.0161942411,
-0.0020371096,
0.0267240014,
0.0121808555,
0.0091441497,
-0.0201683324,
0.0004070433,
0.018654,
0.0162354652,
-0.0038783532,
-0.0304629281,
-0.0118975081,
-0.0038372497,
-0.0061976486,
0.0005634846,
0.0200398602,
0.0154038621,
0.000673188,
0.005092931,
0.0666215494,
-0.017905293,
-0.0115271853,
0.06009892,
2.755e-7,
0.0674194992,
0.0470364317,
0.0139150778,
0.0382413268,
-0.0108586736,
0.054652635,
-0.0567952916,
-0.0208370723,
-0.0174152907,
0.0150056034,
0.0375107154,
0.0153138125,
0.0735952333,
-0.0054859831,
-0.0230062492,
-0.0842768103,
-0.0340710022,
-0.0006910005,
-0.1030652449,
0.036747586,
-0.0061268862,
0.0550857633,
-0.0057160472,
-0.0295159128,
0.0015145006,
-0.0764160082,
0.0373892598,
-0.0347753651,
-0.0094689773,
0.0132468883,
0.0510471947,
0.02861901,
-0.0151944738,
0.0341032818,
0.0046473481,
-0.0019767201,
0.0186083987,
0.0875663385,
0.0009739142,
0.0287202336,
-0.0034751461,
-0.0496536084,
-0.0003471159,
-0.02540382,
0.0085784961,
-0.0407348685,
-0.0351001546,
-0.0371021442,
-0.063269794,
-0.0165189113,
0.0200588815,
0.0056531858,
-0.0056837788,
0.0194305759,
-0.0032361655,
-0.014726731,
0.0156861208,
-0.0156097766,
0.0078268042,
0.044605352,
-0.0377891287,
-0.0071729841,
-0.0394182317,
0.0050612255,
0.0045082052,
-0.0720986649,
0.0018855247,
2.35289911e-34,
0.0258357786,
-0.028902268,
-0.0249530096,
0.0102058165,
0.0613893755,
0.0219487622,
-0.0382318497,
0.0362441875,
0.0047118478,
-0.0684176683,
-0.0006776614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14202v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14202v1 | Illuminating the Black Box: A Psychometric Investigation into the Multifaceted Nature of Large Language Models | 2023-12-21T04:57:21 | 2023-12-21T04:57:21 | Yang Lu, Jordan Yu, Shou-Hsuan Stephen Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study explores the idea of AI Personality or AInality suggesting that
Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit patterns similar to human personalities.
Assuming that LLMs share these patterns with humans, we investigate using
human-centered psychometric tests such as the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator
(MBTI), Big Five Inventory (BFI), and Short Dark Triad (SD3) to identify and
confirm LLM personality types. By introducing role-play prompts, we demonstrate
the adaptability of LLMs, showing their ability to switch dynamically between
different personality types. Using projective tests, such as the Washington
University Sentence Completion Test (WUSCT), we uncover hidden aspects of LLM
personalities that are not easily accessible through direct questioning.
Projective tests allowed for a deep exploration of LLMs cognitive processes and
thought patterns and gave us a multidimensional view of AInality. Our machine
learning analysis revealed that LLMs exhibit distinct AInality traits and
manifest diverse personality types, demonstrating dynamic shifts in response to
external instructions. This study pioneers the application of projective tests
on LLMs, shedding light on their diverse and adaptable AInality traits. | [
0.0596816838,
0.0435542986,
-0.0853716955,
0.0097520342,
-0.0612326637,
0.0035039501,
0.0244186595,
-0.0109316539,
0.0231987536,
0.0080819977,
-0.0246821772,
0.0012405238,
0.0150862439,
0.0242552739,
0.0439205877,
-0.0333967134,
0.0324272066,
-0.0114166941,
0.0329908617,
-0.0062470385,
-0.0258467998,
0.0512076579,
0.0028419604,
0.0377019793,
-0.0009266601,
-0.0332083553,
-0.012043193,
-0.0346829928,
0.0099896174,
-0.0143054798,
0.0244012419,
0.0504408553,
0.0104253339,
0.0371402018,
0.0000018292,
-0.0611487776,
0.0232978296,
-0.0269404016,
0.0021946509,
-0.0001595981,
0.0193290152,
0.0684271902,
0.0362535268,
0.032394439,
-0.0654316396,
0.0067748465,
0.0279197246,
0.0596495047,
0.0199390762,
0.053053569,
0.0035934895,
-0.0001503753,
0.031572137,
-0.01983843,
0.0181098711,
-0.0186866112,
0.0255819112,
-0.0538380556,
0.0038064327,
-0.0135333147,
0.006591985,
-0.0085117063,
0.027361121,
0.0209619198,
-0.0382332839,
0.0068535539,
-0.0250077192,
-0.01920099,
0.0069843829,
0.036078807,
0.0346353538,
-0.0274054483,
-0.0107479021,
0.0067810249,
0.0378882661,
0.0136792492,
-0.0065620183,
0.0366165899,
-0.0059038475,
-0.0326911472,
0.0484298207,
0.0073752766,
0.0067839455,
0.0002754122,
-0.0187886152,
0.0448750854,
-0.0074883732,
-0.0281260833,
0.004456053,
0.0122911837,
-0.0057304176,
-0.0901845694,
-0.0046028127,
0.0168681461,
-0.0451772325,
0.0213780981,
-0.0642621592,
0.003681784,
0.0361034051,
-0.0403714068,
0.0502508543,
0.0104909474,
-0.0411017537,
0.0123296827,
0.0346890911,
0.0592700541,
0.0348698311,
0.0384829603,
-0.023965301,
0.013405594,
-0.0412513576,
-0.03950065,
0.0139223468,
0.0186460521,
0.0541376323,
-0.0050078952,
-0.0298247319,
0.0047681169,
-0.0427299403,
0.0191701278,
-0.0008732164,
-0.0001498597,
0.0170403291,
0.0082823681,
-0.0551835522,
0.0195311215,
-0.0652866289,
0.0062070913,
-0.000530629,
-0.0357314982,
0.0351010412,
-0.0109395133,
0.0004329725,
-0.0498051234,
0.053145688,
0.0476989411,
0.0116353529,
-0.0579443276,
-0.0407042876,
-0.0227001254,
-0.0149533553,
-0.0945554599,
0.0016745217,
-0.0349905454,
0.0148365339,
0.0153655568,
-0.0205599982,
-0.0654042363,
-0.0080910036,
0.0427578092,
-0.0088145602,
0.0550997742,
0.0102807218,
0.0187438894,
0.0168781579,
0.0023009335,
0.0109896455,
0.0436775126,
0.0306718368,
0.0058159367,
0.0287644938,
-0.048167821,
0.0456139743,
0.0417946018,
-0.04178489,
-0.0088840304,
-0.0258157291,
-0.0063569653,
-0.0209072307,
0.0017288892,
0.0151248993,
0.0538647249,
0.0123776477,
-0.011468445,
0.0943985805,
0.0655108988,
0.0079544131,
0.0358739197,
0.0465153754,
0.0094508193,
0.0572210886,
0.0368957222,
-0.0357441567,
0.0050575524,
-0.0173939597,
-0.0148706166,
-0.0332683921,
0.0407876559,
0.0097187581,
-0.0543622673,
-0.0116322273,
-0.0021390743,
0.0433910601,
0.0358857326,
-0.0013201962,
-0.003670841,
0.0120381219,
-0.0258288588,
0.0266943052,
-0.0240874104,
-0.0293693207,
-0.0816950649,
0.0288481265,
0.0927014053,
0.0219662599,
-0.0314577296,
0.0013704734,
-0.0049143522,
-0.040294271,
0.0692989156,
0.0385909975,
-0.0040243296,
-0.0311144087,
-0.0100606428,
0.0332651585,
-0.0241914876,
0.0139452843,
0.034398526,
-0.0221145637,
0.0279158242,
-0.0290111341,
-0.0052215694,
-0.0129359867,
0.0235132296,
-0.0991431624,
-0.0488216616,
-0.0163768698,
0.0285323784,
0.0243565664,
0.0156900138,
-0.0055946577,
-0.0031921742,
0.0047806823,
-0.0015470841,
-0.0256520081,
0.0122333784,
-0.0030943837,
0.059687607,
0.019116329,
-0.000353996,
-0.014652296,
0.036068026,
0.0588060841,
-0.0037366769,
0.0173543729,
-0.0455379151,
0.0407560021,
-0.0033777694,
0.0281745344,
-0.0547014698,
0.0816579163,
-0.0212221593,
0.0455234908,
-0.0206064563,
0.0149465408,
0.0271674134,
-0.0425660349,
-0.0040276852,
-0.0167733226,
-0.0115321334,
-0.0005213798,
-0.0053410102,
0.0286566447,
0.0401009172,
-0.0127762128,
-0.051516939,
-0.0340047516,
-0.0684150979,
0.0021250644,
0.0263111144,
-0.0068618455,
0.0119314045,
-0.0258609392,
-0.0476701595,
0.0409242548,
-0.0220450126,
-0.0150963385,
-0.0044634943,
0.0370114967,
0.0380784944,
-0.012720353,
-0.0197537895,
-0.0452384129,
0.0046395804,
-0.0481283739,
0.0238777343,
-0.0122243362,
0.062319044,
-0.0570616722,
0.0051383148,
-0.0379304662,
-0.0087309657,
-0.0068736882,
-0.0661485642,
0.0622167401,
-0.0145355836,
0.0263446737,
0.1140319109,
0.0367403589,
0.0432291962,
0.0601593181,
-0.0035171949,
-0.0347325504,
0.0089677898,
0.0316930003,
-0.0169689134,
-0.044724118,
-0.0796392336,
-0.0030289071,
0.0746603757,
0.017926963,
0.0204192922,
-0.0457576625,
0.0497278236,
0.0063861813,
-0.0693015829,
0.0480247363,
-0.0063579911,
-0.0276498608,
0.0625541508,
0.0201402716,
-0.0085551906,
0.0734857097,
-0.0254650675,
0.0156784058,
-0.0104428018,
-0.0506980456,
-0.0109244436,
0.0848236829,
0.0255600568,
-0.0236173868,
0.0513198674,
-0.0072864289,
-0.0681270659,
-0.0438796431,
-0.0186140891,
-0.0304127987,
0.0247085113,
-0.0234706216,
-0.0494236872,
0.0667970926,
-0.0025495924,
-0.051496122,
-0.0432042517,
-0.0694132298,
-0.0285739563,
0.0313627459,
-0.0680051446,
-0.0248226169,
-0.0645531118,
0.0586010441,
-0.0001903722,
-0.0295055993,
-0.0240952503,
-0.0121573405,
-0.0230388213,
0.0805522352,
0.0179840624,
0.0362745486,
-0.0467930697,
-0.0042826231,
-0.0043755556,
-0.0536565967,
0.0343429632,
-0.029306978,
-0.0066425833,
0.0255011469,
-0.0154009527,
-0.0206521396,
0.0473448522,
0.0106165567,
-0.0316220708,
0.000525375,
0.1168769747,
0.0313770249,
-0.0302115381,
0.0449427217,
-0.0197908487,
0.027735237,
0.0353124551,
0.0495574549,
-0.0488811173,
-0.0107091619,
-0.0027317421,
0.0018943016,
-0.0844856054,
-0.040545851,
-0.0265472438,
-0.1054000705,
0.0057628579,
-0.0089674583,
-0.0186553132,
0.0080891056,
-0.0032535102,
0.0158883445,
-0.0010677812,
0.0303759556,
-0.0332484916,
0.0005567682,
-0.012232854,
-0.0205969214,
-0.0526064411,
-0.0015412756,
0.0810405612,
-0.0113964565,
0.0560230315,
0.0218660608,
0.0291619878,
-0.0534515232,
-0.0130826542,
-0.0422675125,
-0.0001557144,
0.0108879199,
0.0355101079,
0.0549907871,
-0.0219537821,
0.0174721964,
-0.0626176149,
0.011227794,
-0.0073063741,
0.0055091856,
0.0433781631,
0.0833177045,
0.008591542,
-0.0836502165,
-0.0130448435,
-0.0023630438,
0.0164685212,
0.0589520968,
0.0037266833,
-0.1032777205,
0.0051799421,
-0.0177894328,
0.0200199131,
-0.0218742993,
-0.0910353139,
0.0083364798,
0.0254177116,
-0.0035272744,
-0.0473436341,
-0.0760713667,
0.0047106128,
0.0023218959,
0.0052552898,
-0.0114049101,
0.0134548862,
0.0298881121,
-0.0268094279,
0.0157360621,
-0.0014154172,
0.0299370401,
-0.0197626892,
-0.0395481922,
0.0244497675,
-0.0699407756,
-0.0068964772,
0.0329357833,
-0.0433602668,
-0.0516016372,
0.0567724332,
0.01198758,
0.0249380432,
-0.0027528668,
0.0200215746,
-0.0654134229,
0.0090165483,
-0.012796348,
-0.0126516288,
0.0580316857,
-0.010216753,
0.0176754985,
0.0008614237,
0.0271252394,
-0.0302990973,
-0.0079686558,
-0.0159594379,
-0.0295570809,
-0.017538486,
-0.0784724057,
0.0254278295,
0.0356623828,
-0.0162356794,
-0.0276553668,
-0.0092786355,
-0.006745093,
-0.0203653034,
-0.0474247001,
-0.025029866,
0.0022647891,
-0.0768976212,
0.011701881,
0.0087558134,
-0.0151556693,
-0.0310516041,
-0.0124087548,
0.0111432979,
-0.0238095894,
0.0154159758,
0.0108216144,
0.0284160431,
-0.0026895031,
0.0063549196,
-0.0073739234,
0.0184457526,
-0.0068938397,
0.064042002,
0.0140139144,
0.0688767657,
-0.0148787722,
-0.010993626,
-0.0227911379,
0.0514099114,
-0.0478076264,
-0.0363753252,
0.0519028567,
0.0237154644,
-0.0030681726,
-0.015459829,
0.0389465354,
-0.0546385311,
0.0186099112,
-0.0105792601,
0.0170292147,
0.0005377904,
-0.0265679173,
-0.0194100663,
0.023157008,
-0.0325635411,
-0.0131866103,
0.0566782914,
0.0053169038,
0.040171288,
-0.0262167528,
-0.014189845,
-0.0413076542,
0.000232544,
-0.0112172998,
0.0267366059,
-0.0194943454,
0.0015723673,
-0.0766550452,
-0.0843900666,
0.0223205965,
0.0095684975,
0.0110109188,
-0.0566456057,
-0.0219497122,
0.0666825324,
-0.0168001782,
-0.0440485589,
-0.0279515516,
0.0094248503,
-0.0142349796,
-0.0064007724,
-0.0303988829,
-5.789903302e-33,
-0.0338777527,
-0.0301310495,
0.0136840902,
-0.0224778559,
-0.0179134179,
-0.0288022514,
-0.0092444057,
0.0542477593,
-0.0269842967,
-0.0012338214,
-0.048280485,
0.005371979,
0.0034977477,
-0.0179252643,
0.0384184755,
0.0066028908,
0.0356284231,
-0.0158614721,
-0.0244195294,
0.0022264235,
0.0068538445,
-0.0240586102,
0.046918489,
-0.0627616122,
0.0122010717,
-0.0197791681,
-0.0054739094,
-0.0126945581,
-0.0351164117,
0.0507590696,
0.0052866437,
0.0339055881,
0.036480628,
0.0196679607,
-0.0026011509,
0.0430895798,
-0.0154437078,
-0.0485383905,
0.0275338516,
0.0262771752,
-0.0260564387,
-0.0812471732,
0.0155307474,
-0.0368198901,
-0.0349358022,
-0.0272832904,
0.0524022579,
-0.0144415013,
0.0662457123,
0.0560765862,
-0.0570893511,
-0.025454184,
-0.0413600616,
-0.0134260515,
-0.0473051406,
0.0150620881,
-0.0175309312,
-0.0222256817,
-0.0450592786,
0.053130731,
-0.0310972277,
-0.0052301027,
0.0328026153,
0.0223599356,
0.0098311333,
0.0448268913,
0.0878742561,
0.0788773149,
-0.0214098059,
-0.0040004249,
0.0589178167,
0.0432649888,
0.0444679447,
0.065270558,
-0.0181352105,
-0.0347459204,
0.0030186144,
-0.0166579541,
0.0910866857,
-0.0321236216,
0.0532094836,
-0.0267638359,
-0.0552818142,
-0.0333384275,
-0.0124595156,
-0.019683592,
-0.0007051461,
-0.0348035842,
0.0235209148,
-0.0300891232,
0.0050408645,
-0.0346212983,
0.0364066996,
-0.0571968816,
0.0004276586,
0.0372590013,
-0.0651091263,
0.0568323769,
0.023301132,
0.0050061238,
-0.019897921,
0.0100192698,
-0.0038523823,
0.0131967878,
0.0737162083,
0.0413893871,
0.0106083248,
0.0371466279,
-0.0488603264,
-0.015902916,
0.0096574211,
0.0155196255,
0.0066460855,
-0.0053471876,
0.0159564614,
0.0169042666,
-0.0135695273,
-0.0048862011,
0.0108955782,
-0.002340917,
-0.0578524433,
0.0001971508,
-0.0276276618,
-0.0112553881,
-0.0154723544,
-0.0268512815,
-0.0782257318,
0.0246204566,
0.0390670262,
-0.0427898429,
0.0091950605,
-0.0212052595,
2.651e-7,
-0.0396560617,
0.0919181183,
-0.0417195857,
0.0809090883,
0.0305645615,
0.0484277233,
0.0031003074,
0.0149459895,
0.0275417194,
-0.0377991162,
0.0106522338,
0.0204063263,
0.0507590473,
0.0468363501,
-0.0540979207,
0.0135107161,
-0.0293424577,
0.0390244611,
-0.0776110068,
0.0058906004,
0.0557935871,
0.0514134094,
0.0547725186,
-0.014321683,
-0.004859319,
-0.0377999507,
-0.0086968988,
-0.00614205,
0.0070407093,
0.0162797906,
0.00331251,
-0.0072233388,
0.0346379131,
0.0554957911,
0.0047968854,
0.0080267489,
-0.0219299588,
0.0384116806,
-0.0172740091,
-0.0154643012,
-0.0007824033,
0.0150266858,
-0.0279433336,
-0.0539176688,
0.0703850016,
-0.0163284447,
-0.0591013506,
-0.0338005312,
-0.0005133817,
-0.0602059066,
0.0227836147,
-0.000076094,
-0.0091264322,
0.0380725488,
0.0082461806,
-0.0188113973,
0.0140682952,
-0.0296375975,
0.005362378,
0.0159108713,
-0.0458993129,
-0.0406398363,
-0.0263707582,
-0.0093615195,
0.0237562768,
-0.0606670678,
0.037407916,
2.195798422e-34,
-0.0158411283,
0.0376583785,
0.0272871424,
-0.02290974,
0.0854870975,
0.006990571,
-0.0134035563,
0.0487487726,
0.0341094621,
-0.0845734924,
-0.0266599245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13558v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13558v1 | The Truth is in There: Improving Reasoning in Language Models with Layer-Selective Rank Reduction | 2023-12-21T03:51:08 | 2023-12-21T03:51:08 | Pratyusha Sharma, Jordan T. Ash, Dipendra Misra | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Transformer-based Large Language Models (LLMs) have become a fixture in
modern machine learning. Correspondingly, significant resources are allocated
towards research that aims to further advance this technology, typically
resulting in models of increasing size that are trained on increasing amounts
of data. This work, however, demonstrates the surprising result that it is
often possible to significantly improve the performance of LLMs by selectively
removing higher-order components of their weight matrices. This simple
intervention, which we call LAyer-SElective Rank reduction (LASER), can be done
on a model after training has completed, and requires no additional parameters
or data. We show extensive experiments demonstrating the generality of this
finding across language models and datasets, and provide in-depth analyses
offering insights into both when LASER is effective and the mechanism by which
it operates. | [
0.0304017067,
0.1091503352,
-0.0106146084,
0.0653210506,
-0.0079663787,
0.0283066407,
0.028563153,
-0.00023215,
0.0027730316,
-0.0092186928,
-0.0446533225,
-0.009903118,
0.0106012514,
-0.0074635441,
0.0070884516,
0.0014123844,
0.0098493574,
-0.0537844263,
-0.043577794,
-0.0157555267,
-0.0245103557,
0.0095157893,
0.0276063941,
0.030897731,
0.0571989082,
-0.0068260836,
0.0000953618,
-0.0141527727,
-0.0005559694,
0.0380803198,
-0.009780691,
0.0424519181,
0.0336056016,
0.0569249839,
0.0000020402,
-0.0012287304,
-0.0100110965,
-0.0021533668,
-0.0218750965,
0.0409465879,
0.0060217786,
-0.0337067731,
-0.0158142019,
0.0176571142,
-0.0206692666,
-0.0075549218,
0.0337156393,
0.0626122281,
0.0510752425,
0.0509166606,
-0.0034048073,
-0.0645738915,
0.0057867118,
-0.0316682681,
-0.0158480201,
-0.0385755971,
0.0323833302,
0.0018916463,
-0.0269782171,
0.0160171706,
-0.0242983643,
0.0224779733,
0.0247059539,
0.0029636044,
-0.016636055,
0.0504277349,
-0.04873541,
-0.0224565044,
0.0281141773,
0.0705990344,
-0.0655282661,
-0.0177383646,
0.003485135,
0.0037368464,
0.0136398776,
0.005522219,
-0.0459419712,
0.0447337702,
0.0536923967,
0.0509467833,
0.0184859931,
-0.0252709445,
0.0624464564,
-0.0082373191,
-0.0818295404,
0.0988584533,
0.0271805897,
-0.0353391729,
0.0034811443,
-0.0022415384,
-0.0151126944,
-0.0136652431,
-0.0105601801,
0.0265505575,
-0.0058147893,
0.0216517076,
0.0138986716,
-0.0107916836,
-0.021481961,
-0.0432220213,
0.0551186055,
0.0492499359,
0.0144102378,
0.0463865958,
-0.0548559502,
0.0661090314,
-0.0147648575,
0.0326616764,
-0.03141113,
-0.0289982595,
-0.0075331111,
-0.0239200033,
-0.0166110173,
0.0359214544,
-0.0465771593,
-0.0033928552,
-0.0536902472,
-0.006711599,
-0.0144608291,
-0.0004808112,
0.0153173795,
0.0140534788,
-0.0096449256,
-0.0466058329,
0.019322997,
0.0621359348,
0.0542134866,
0.0373397507,
-0.0506773628,
-0.0212393422,
-0.012996627,
0.0200776048,
0.0161994044,
-0.0352959447,
0.0200565066,
0.0155996168,
-0.0317956619,
-0.0535433106,
0.0069288434,
0.0316944085,
-0.02638302,
-0.0720277652,
0.0012466443,
-0.0547266416,
0.0190845709,
0.0064616739,
0.0091211023,
-0.0213993937,
0.0264971871,
0.0312666669,
-0.0639528781,
0.0821048692,
0.0423324369,
0.0207691286,
0.0048471903,
0.0158862378,
-0.0107226782,
0.0121457707,
0.0157507863,
0.0213312227,
0.0142294755,
-0.0609791577,
-0.0044414904,
0.0556392632,
-0.0069411858,
-0.0109325638,
-0.0268857852,
-0.0122162187,
-0.017038038,
-0.0117355147,
0.0259832665,
0.0451084413,
-0.0208024643,
-0.0087800445,
0.0617239438,
0.0351661183,
0.05306945,
0.0624086186,
0.0021141719,
-0.0080498531,
0.0008256809,
0.0109152086,
-0.040913634,
-0.0014583048,
-0.0177592784,
-0.0110023916,
-0.0026296605,
0.0550260283,
-0.026345443,
-0.0361362435,
-0.0269036293,
-0.0204063039,
0.0459047295,
0.0268404149,
0.0673370808,
0.0083270594,
-0.0134781841,
0.0807460099,
0.0454519503,
-0.0613052398,
-0.0167311877,
-0.0719832852,
-0.0194474217,
-0.0025782238,
0.0148828356,
-0.0036427905,
0.0231624171,
0.0209153667,
-0.000820709,
-0.0004818215,
0.0081683658,
-0.0054290281,
0.017924428,
-0.0589583665,
0.0122875227,
0.0182403326,
0.0217263084,
-0.0134274671,
0.0040232688,
-0.0297693219,
0.025233645,
-0.0429829694,
-0.0487333946,
0.0204302035,
-0.0450586937,
-0.021908164,
0.0572388768,
-0.0118612032,
0.0126518682,
-0.0112575684,
-0.0004824437,
-0.0092456751,
0.038450662,
-0.048317045,
-0.0188455805,
-0.0100969225,
-0.0164499357,
-0.0221937913,
0.0256987959,
0.0023476614,
0.0058399444,
0.113642633,
-0.0254242364,
-0.0149631537,
0.0133027732,
-0.027333606,
0.0186590776,
-0.0435437299,
0.0367229357,
-0.0245146547,
0.0556452721,
-0.0323737003,
0.0672591329,
-0.0125740552,
0.0317957923,
0.0514626615,
-0.0140649602,
-0.0076049361,
-0.0258296523,
-0.0496327579,
0.0424015485,
-0.0094715971,
0.02674908,
0.0066188551,
-0.0262306053,
0.0098831169,
-0.0459998213,
-0.0892870799,
-0.0146834636,
-0.0360503905,
-0.0232841019,
0.0098523078,
0.0206359364,
0.0302647687,
-0.0204745755,
0.0047600078,
-0.0173007753,
0.0248198565,
0.0202085208,
0.0166421141,
-0.0219635293,
-0.0126856277,
-0.0196649004,
-0.0553933792,
-0.0032198627,
0.0932309255,
-0.0160031319,
0.0114023825,
-0.0584557913,
0.0352881216,
-0.0320425294,
0.014616468,
-0.0348238312,
-0.0259332508,
-0.022875268,
-0.0215900596,
0.0311582033,
0.0543554425,
0.0193598922,
0.0604577586,
0.1156017408,
0.0223266445,
-0.0324303135,
-0.0127838301,
-0.0369362012,
-0.0088090487,
-0.0390732102,
-0.0308372062,
-0.0185888205,
0.0734067261,
-0.0011351166,
-0.0242739413,
-0.0316301174,
0.0183594823,
-0.0115981502,
0.005264618,
-0.0402279757,
-0.0001968143,
-0.0252605006,
0.0008874074,
-0.0104770083,
-0.0249142963,
0.0364192091,
-0.0238240082,
-0.0201757289,
-0.037291985,
-0.0247511026,
-0.0521341376,
0.0249505881,
0.0286628045,
0.0214213897,
-0.0355671011,
-0.0111149922,
-0.0319151543,
0.0053454582,
-0.0089147687,
-0.0308570303,
0.0304138698,
-0.0250512362,
0.0272604115,
-0.0166365672,
-0.0524816327,
-0.029173268,
-0.0304937437,
-0.004063007,
0.0244874302,
0.0081481524,
-0.028209947,
-0.0233038068,
-0.000573793,
0.0386865027,
0.0425817743,
-0.0001815967,
0.0066343565,
-0.0119837057,
0.0507880151,
0.0258972533,
0.0206477921,
0.0560474657,
-0.0319821946,
0.0630138293,
0.0366947576,
0.0227333158,
-0.0116179278,
-0.0457313433,
0.0116033545,
0.0491903126,
-0.0080316905,
-0.0324587859,
0.0011988616,
0.0083150044,
-0.031798739,
0.0059513361,
0.1105713546,
0.0174334683,
-0.0396275148,
0.0215644483,
-0.0021879293,
0.0163763519,
0.0226139259,
0.0536495559,
-0.0698022172,
-0.0079135587,
0.0120335305,
-0.0061069913,
0.0249853134,
-0.0377168767,
0.0079974933,
-0.1249675378,
0.067942597,
0.0006668982,
0.0233766083,
-0.0351234302,
-0.0456160232,
-0.0077667083,
-0.0226517133,
0.017272668,
0.0140738674,
-0.0262950398,
-0.0334267914,
0.0167896766,
-0.0214704089,
-0.0471398644,
0.0268381685,
-0.0037659346,
0.0136966277,
0.0147920176,
0.0564863496,
-0.0335320942,
-0.0741791949,
0.0418234132,
-0.0115168411,
-0.0171531923,
-0.0008454975,
0.0135566406,
0.0366183333,
-0.0272097234,
-0.0039067082,
0.0208090059,
-0.0088852281,
-0.0246071685,
-0.0455879942,
0.0765359104,
-0.0236260723,
-0.0689973086,
0.0402730443,
-0.0234252401,
-0.0537982471,
0.0704716444,
0.003068743,
-0.0313553289,
-0.024178315,
-0.0254832599,
-0.0088378619,
0.0167777669,
-0.069538258,
0.0397275761,
0.0265941806,
-0.0034123913,
-0.0415485315,
0.0107642431,
0.0089657009,
-0.0086350925,
-0.0198537651,
0.0086872615,
-0.0013056612,
0.0072297212,
-0.0140162697,
0.0401056781,
-0.0196815617,
-0.0131707089,
-0.0266661905,
0.0149999261,
0.0317021422,
-0.0449141227,
-0.0328472406,
-0.0682103038,
-0.0642778724,
-0.0594765022,
0.0093733184,
0.021564588,
0.0232185684,
0.0374954343,
0.0042541781,
-0.0708828792,
0.0228703078,
0.0269058291,
0.0008951051,
0.0330695398,
0.0221981406,
-0.0748305619,
0.0026522272,
0.0512074716,
-0.0202083904,
0.035086453,
0.0432167277,
0.0382444039,
-0.0401510485,
-0.017563181,
0.0156315453,
0.0283802375,
0.0542526841,
0.0260518286,
-0.0211027097,
-0.0291760471,
0.0510211848,
-0.0474687368,
-0.0159824546,
-0.0377720818,
0.0034253995,
0.042532783,
0.0604265109,
-0.0172449779,
0.0015803443,
0.030408185,
0.0119000096,
-0.0561365075,
0.0206018053,
-0.013746406,
-0.0441760644,
0.0465017483,
0.01552446,
-0.0248549618,
0.0440437607,
0.0433633029,
0.029608028,
-0.0152906561,
0.0132094845,
0.0150106391,
0.0103485156,
-0.0772200972,
0.0251721703,
-0.0849898681,
-0.1064706519,
0.0055823065,
-0.0381242968,
0.0465723127,
-0.0166742131,
0.0299899559,
0.0081478823,
-0.0409649648,
-0.0041160262,
0.0055230954,
0.0402003787,
-0.0257304963,
0.0274987947,
0.0204181615,
-0.0162544213,
0.0460807867,
0.0658112243,
0.0422294885,
0.0276253689,
-0.0090697147,
-0.0277718622,
-0.0263512358,
-0.0519919917,
0.0019303474,
0.0060956134,
-0.0445279144,
-0.0004815968,
-0.0392780229,
-0.0849479139,
-0.010570216,
-0.0209307428,
0.0093604773,
-0.0467474274,
-0.010080982,
0.0725720748,
0.005056649,
-0.0055417069,
-0.0416183099,
-0.0315947011,
0.0249503329,
-0.0312646404,
-0.0179111846,
-6.182323724e-33,
0.0243903883,
-0.0101735219,
0.0142655009,
0.018895546,
0.0029725966,
0.0199912433,
-0.0232692659,
-0.0162845049,
-0.0250920597,
0.0366061665,
-0.0386322774,
0.0110319592,
-0.0053110113,
0.0219174512,
-0.0072411946,
0.0088577876,
0.0556966439,
0.0163655896,
-0.0195761248,
0.0319673829,
0.0354149602,
0.0390849076,
0.0222315434,
-0.0070341416,
-0.0190180447,
-0.0020635577,
-0.0207207222,
0.0173510257,
-0.0271933191,
0.0561328158,
-0.044215329,
0.0223224089,
0.0495718382,
-0.0686828792,
-0.0015124293,
0.0388606675,
-0.0612065494,
0.0448223352,
0.0029255436,
-0.0027607961,
-0.0020742037,
-0.0250507873,
0.0647447705,
0.0124911452,
-0.0393348075,
-0.0409274213,
0.0244801026,
-0.0233982932,
-0.0324541964,
-0.0519745797,
-0.0507946126,
0.0138312988,
-0.0161036234,
0.0095324153,
0.0335745923,
0.0184361394,
-0.0346533321,
0.0717580467,
-0.0555824712,
0.0052986569,
0.0039996658,
0.0494561754,
0.0358438976,
0.0171414725,
-0.0449513793,
0.0351935551,
-0.0011183269,
-0.012072552,
-0.0299323685,
-0.0125818131,
0.0385164507,
0.0583113246,
0.0738485754,
-0.0098232348,
0.0306054112,
-0.0050902753,
-0.10939309,
-0.0009137617,
-0.0309288744,
0.0317624435,
0.0466685481,
0.0199929867,
0.0129980007,
-0.0297445823,
-0.0343791731,
-0.0074098185,
-0.0481548533,
0.0022731181,
-0.0078087584,
0.0206739344,
-0.05450923,
-0.0156777799,
0.0387536399,
-0.090605773,
-0.0380157642,
0.0432878435,
-0.0095035899,
0.0061441646,
0.0132069075,
0.0031616504,
-0.0469282269,
-0.0000955214,
-0.0064337943,
-0.0070411805,
0.0240345579,
0.0022512693,
0.0306677185,
0.0266552903,
-0.0546871386,
-0.0262753442,
-0.0398573317,
-0.0049907002,
-0.0122100012,
0.1030339748,
0.0121227894,
0.026006693,
0.0040333997,
0.0434135981,
0.0201924853,
0.0456482284,
-0.0338449292,
-0.0037186029,
0.0394227505,
0.0193769038,
-0.0166947134,
-0.0130982995,
-0.0262484718,
0.0689847246,
0.0551526546,
-0.0550534949,
-0.0303622019,
0.0132063041,
2.719e-7,
0.0444065593,
0.03965028,
-0.0270309094,
-0.008784879,
0.0248914063,
0.0378354937,
-0.0108650066,
0.0138018448,
0.0288817175,
0.0499892198,
0.010430973,
0.0115298368,
0.0463320315,
-0.0094332173,
-0.0616460294,
-0.0165925305,
-0.0983769223,
-0.0398897976,
-0.0500120632,
-0.027478395,
-0.0147420159,
0.1107403785,
-0.0127335172,
-0.0347575471,
-0.0174510013,
-0.0003236133,
0.0606846176,
-0.0325079709,
-0.0018353132,
0.007857698,
0.0799201503,
-0.0229884908,
-0.0057898406,
0.001218893,
-0.02657938,
0.0384948328,
0.0021226762,
0.0730610117,
-0.0129071418,
0.0230002496,
-0.0042364523,
-0.0010375367,
0.0037598351,
-0.0895737708,
0.088583149,
-0.0582286492,
-0.0352440216,
-0.0121481223,
-0.0436050259,
-0.0099265641,
-0.0042379103,
-0.011949094,
0.0066394266,
0.0244738348,
0.0064667892,
-0.0322190113,
-0.0014826532,
-0.1157091036,
-0.0211599059,
0.0005554357,
-0.0561176352,
-0.0415621214,
0.0045947279,
-0.0549829192,
0.0414536074,
-0.0651801899,
0.0185094252,
2.808351054e-34,
0.0031167697,
0.0201322287,
0.0016289613,
0.0356156193,
0.0386211239,
-0.0257307328,
-0.0111543266,
0.0232345629,
-0.005809926,
-0.1440381557,
-0.0036671597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13547v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13547v1 | How to Prune Your Language Model: Recovering Accuracy on the "Sparsity May Cry'' Benchmark | 2023-12-21T03:11:30 | 2023-12-21T03:11:30 | Eldar Kurtic, Torsten Hoefler, Dan Alistarh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pruning large language models (LLMs) from the BERT family has emerged as a
standard compression benchmark, and several pruning methods have been proposed
for this task. The recent ``Sparsity May Cry'' (SMC) benchmark put into
question the validity of all existing methods, exhibiting a more complex setup
where many known pruning methods appear to fail. We revisit the question of
accurate BERT-pruning during fine-tuning on downstream datasets, and propose a
set of general guidelines for successful pruning, even on the challenging SMC
benchmark. First, we perform a cost-vs-benefits analysis of pruning model
components, such as the embeddings and the classification head; second, we
provide a simple-yet-general way of scaling training, sparsification and
learning rate schedules relative to the desired target sparsity; finally, we
investigate the importance of proper parametrization for Knowledge Distillation
in the context of LLMs. Our simple insights lead to state-of-the-art results,
both on classic BERT-pruning benchmarks, as well as on the SMC benchmark,
showing that even classic gradual magnitude pruning (GMP) can yield competitive
results, with the right approach. | [
-0.0143216448,
0.081633769,
0.0000364412,
0.0399078988,
-0.025822822,
-0.0006169929,
-0.026176488,
0.0616178624,
-0.0624853894,
0.0104677351,
-0.0146287968,
-0.0338323452,
0.0267902184,
-0.035291452,
0.0098247752,
-0.0238311328,
0.017522268,
-0.0101553248,
0.0269948915,
-0.0106042074,
0.0235244948,
-0.0106449416,
0.0340359285,
0.0458134748,
0.0004087827,
0.0101281386,
-0.0007708003,
0.016589148,
-0.0214592982,
0.0217161141,
0.0164320692,
0.0822284073,
0.0433436185,
0.0351787545,
0.0000020689,
-0.0333251841,
0.0088640377,
0.0226285774,
-0.0476131551,
0.0729754344,
-0.008576924,
-0.0189760011,
0.0249682423,
0.027146792,
0.0131944735,
-0.0381202325,
0.038257841,
0.0336875431,
0.0662553161,
0.0560129881,
0.0012222998,
-0.0210740659,
-0.016131388,
-0.0496249683,
-0.0393656157,
-0.0075101322,
0.0321803614,
-0.0420140959,
-0.0533543788,
-0.0347270332,
-0.0251138024,
-0.0003952632,
0.0078160875,
0.0494579934,
-0.0235556327,
0.0218218081,
-0.0758548602,
-0.0291979741,
0.0273101311,
0.0347514004,
-0.0378793292,
-0.0246628523,
0.0131849768,
0.0208439268,
-0.0033649353,
-0.0233110599,
-0.0328831598,
-0.0107391886,
0.0313158743,
0.0361705422,
-0.0311657954,
-0.0495390855,
0.0510998517,
-0.0003546913,
-0.0283774789,
0.0079789441,
0.0319943242,
-0.027890455,
-0.0136905676,
-0.0023048052,
-0.0397955664,
-0.0241851881,
-0.0138716055,
0.0155367674,
0.0294237621,
-0.0169708449,
-0.0572447889,
-0.0200359542,
0.0151769072,
-0.0129245771,
0.03558366,
0.0358674973,
0.0139442924,
0.0167881772,
-0.0136714112,
0.0315812379,
0.0617820695,
0.0311978087,
-0.0275054555,
-0.0062515666,
-0.0170877427,
0.0179401189,
-0.0363098346,
0.0447763987,
0.0040887683,
0.0004190873,
-0.0410336256,
-0.0378930606,
0.0012388884,
0.0107389633,
0.0383805931,
-0.01211341,
-0.0200818367,
0.0130556645,
0.0258725137,
0.0551703423,
-0.0399857722,
0.0262924396,
-0.0234323088,
-0.0341805927,
-0.062688835,
0.0254903845,
0.0159182213,
-0.0146627463,
0.0389757305,
0.0157599356,
0.0089904517,
-0.065301396,
-0.0356679261,
0.0247759763,
-0.0120202675,
-0.0568350293,
-0.0081283115,
-0.0693931356,
0.0314052217,
-0.0232249945,
0.0136569273,
-0.066090472,
-0.0091525512,
-0.0110597089,
-0.069706358,
0.0318048149,
-0.0069803884,
0.0236309804,
-0.0014038075,
0.0083992491,
0.0189165138,
0.0989991128,
0.0408035442,
0.0226717424,
0.0043042288,
-0.0442187339,
-0.0570902675,
0.0502269045,
0.0741212144,
0.0494282842,
-0.0479733162,
-0.035347458,
-0.0126135834,
0.0102870474,
0.0516317189,
0.0892662182,
-0.068469584,
-0.0601383336,
0.0563558377,
0.0436325558,
0.0336265266,
0.0497732162,
-0.0020310839,
0.0087329047,
0.0066665523,
0.0161655676,
-0.0189079437,
-0.0308224596,
-0.016190879,
-0.0107572982,
0.0374719352,
0.0252235457,
-0.0574542731,
-0.0093645025,
-0.0428994372,
-0.0173224956,
0.0170892961,
0.0125646768,
0.0326233432,
0.0024173139,
-0.0040343143,
0.132541284,
0.0450834595,
-0.0555553697,
0.0064453692,
-0.0527203456,
-0.034392409,
-0.0004551882,
0.0372548364,
-0.0119629623,
-0.0271712802,
0.0185773093,
-0.0146621531,
-0.0350097045,
0.0343337618,
-0.0152714411,
0.0554553531,
-0.0642807707,
-0.0109290415,
-0.0104530398,
0.0251377188,
-0.0238197353,
0.0133577501,
0.0037572614,
0.0051498078,
-0.0717356727,
0.0040960815,
0.0427828208,
-0.0243470222,
-0.0303529706,
0.0123030813,
0.0184662491,
0.0223828629,
-0.0240792651,
-0.0452513359,
-0.0099415565,
0.0630947277,
-0.0435509793,
0.0225064848,
-0.0361151211,
-0.0080917664,
-0.0835348219,
0.0602805726,
0.0100433109,
0.0420985967,
0.0757433325,
-0.0481392853,
-0.0266531538,
-0.0018065793,
-0.0459226221,
0.0541504808,
-0.0545011275,
0.0328967758,
-0.047123868,
0.0455626957,
0.0105669433,
0.0155428862,
-0.0654809922,
0.0270576123,
0.0177865941,
-0.0503648408,
0.0097635128,
-0.0454814583,
-0.0551907122,
-0.0000434367,
-0.0248240847,
0.0304670427,
0.0201688595,
0.014292594,
0.0130681926,
-0.0173300896,
-0.0887047425,
-0.0008121384,
-0.0439470112,
0.0246163364,
0.0111802947,
0.0237499475,
0.0054843053,
0.0030338985,
0.0053975093,
-0.0079520484,
-0.0110354228,
0.0345504098,
-0.0026624606,
-0.0047835833,
-0.0408054702,
-0.0008785756,
-0.0361473076,
0.036321003,
0.0730020478,
-0.0771891996,
0.0115038371,
-0.0375891663,
0.0380612165,
-0.0494276807,
0.0192262586,
0.0022001786,
-0.0567601062,
-0.0207146406,
-0.0108231427,
-0.0065537132,
0.0142926509,
-0.0016926029,
0.0694256872,
0.0701583847,
0.0346935764,
-0.0319347531,
0.0112805618,
-0.0225960352,
0.0053817467,
-0.0309115238,
-0.0632411912,
-0.0099751279,
0.076713942,
-0.0157433655,
0.0021545456,
-0.0795604885,
-0.0412723012,
0.0127270818,
-0.0342606455,
-0.0318964496,
0.0054103206,
-0.0159624647,
0.0057307063,
-0.0179140735,
-0.0657674894,
0.0402914509,
-0.0539050736,
0.0130234482,
-0.0051341443,
-0.0268087629,
-0.0261214487,
0.0284303576,
0.0233536847,
0.0293642953,
-0.0288546253,
-0.0004339716,
-0.0484583788,
-0.022232566,
0.0004498762,
-0.0158774294,
0.0298349969,
-0.0364095271,
0.028059423,
-0.0209346469,
-0.0458541214,
0.0045703156,
-0.0300682373,
0.0063632946,
0.0540997721,
0.0480044,
-0.039509356,
-0.0330499671,
0.02638782,
0.0000694564,
0.0556979775,
0.0308747217,
0.0319065042,
0.0203644782,
0.0550802834,
0.0502834842,
0.0145713789,
0.0347838998,
-0.0334160589,
0.0108338231,
0.033739768,
0.0769264475,
0.012511719,
-0.0465396009,
-0.0102437744,
0.0298805609,
-0.0041155829,
-0.0280641913,
0.0122456551,
0.0423011184,
-0.0262980107,
-0.0237050243,
0.0926968157,
-0.0090419631,
-0.0116786137,
0.0321821049,
0.0253498778,
0.1009736136,
0.0036009864,
0.0047928072,
-0.0306043848,
-0.0208470486,
0.0320336744,
0.0294638555,
0.0410602354,
-0.0400168747,
-0.0026900715,
-0.0782315806,
0.0151616847,
0.0022418955,
-0.0111626228,
-0.0035833989,
-0.0690707564,
0.0127631761,
-0.0202151891,
0.0285578668,
0.0023837623,
-0.0127052292,
-0.0153834587,
0.0403120965,
-0.0372444429,
-0.0639454275,
0.023666501,
-0.0051726326,
0.0403492637,
0.0018222787,
0.050415609,
-0.0171669945,
-0.0524915978,
0.0187935103,
-0.0019831781,
-0.0382930562,
-0.0274108201,
0.0481750444,
0.0250447951,
0.004608192,
0.0466094129,
-0.0010434218,
-0.0047788592,
0.0021614118,
-0.0111065637,
0.0570052527,
-0.0079141771,
-0.0594234727,
0.0101236552,
-0.0240827911,
-0.0382656418,
0.0908202827,
0.0552399121,
0.0015099254,
-0.0328930579,
0.0160139333,
-0.0014487925,
-0.0091222962,
-0.0035874501,
0.0266270936,
-0.0117490171,
-0.0521849096,
-0.0210716538,
0.0077178385,
0.0437547974,
0.0370161459,
-0.0193897542,
0.0152175892,
-0.0276256036,
0.042526871,
-0.0387607515,
0.0335819796,
-0.0187186766,
-0.0175912455,
-0.0664455071,
0.003725247,
-0.0081392098,
0.0122089246,
-0.0155350287,
-0.0275455602,
-0.1019091979,
-0.0625558123,
-0.0189071987,
0.0422870219,
0.0220713243,
0.0524525344,
0.0236828234,
-0.0746533945,
0.0635887533,
0.0563511364,
-0.0190650336,
0.0622594319,
0.0221546758,
-0.071829699,
-0.0117104324,
0.0667835623,
-0.0406513326,
0.0053966944,
0.0187078379,
0.068966493,
-0.0060494058,
-0.0197606478,
-0.0157178156,
0.0522003137,
0.0263570249,
-0.0215803161,
-0.0163400397,
-0.013832611,
0.0188818257,
0.0352621898,
0.0202458091,
-0.0431809649,
-0.0046989601,
0.0025752322,
0.0462684408,
-0.0170738753,
0.0310577154,
0.0215590782,
0.0061675045,
-0.0361345932,
0.0304436497,
0.0130298128,
-0.005104247,
0.0747789145,
-0.0025121057,
-0.0193502903,
-0.0103846621,
-0.021051826,
-0.0078365514,
-0.0435256213,
-0.0262048002,
0.0176827237,
0.0654581413,
-0.0636850446,
0.0278377887,
-0.025166655,
-0.0916656777,
-0.0458905511,
0.0307499468,
0.0255245212,
-0.0154415937,
0.0291831177,
-0.0267064739,
-0.0113524925,
-0.0454848856,
-0.0268128198,
-0.0023043177,
-0.0034077018,
0.0261199865,
0.0141607653,
-0.0186666064,
0.023395149,
0.0911446139,
0.0377779491,
0.0876684114,
-0.0133708874,
-0.0227521155,
-0.0504786335,
-0.0653407499,
0.0272059217,
0.0113884863,
-0.0185807757,
-0.0110738184,
-0.0293069948,
-0.0870124623,
-0.0116815818,
-0.030789163,
0.0133226709,
-0.0001345182,
0.0484010987,
0.0463493019,
-0.0096567133,
0.0027150433,
-0.0044661243,
-0.0307566822,
-0.0133756604,
-0.0477293395,
0.023881916,
-6.404295996e-33,
0.0294715911,
0.0564631857,
-0.0014965408,
-0.046579998,
-0.0147291766,
0.0238483306,
-0.0181602351,
-0.038479317,
-0.0305265263,
0.0244895145,
-0.0325167254,
-0.0060729422,
-0.004565028,
0.0434052274,
-0.0520505682,
-0.006780915,
0.1036120132,
-0.0109280506,
-0.0302147996,
0.0184936356,
0.0189977512,
0.0375008732,
0.0516938418,
0.0081682429,
-0.0643755421,
0.0154376905,
-0.015706582,
0.0349165723,
0.0368388146,
0.0096489908,
-0.0161174983,
0.0342976414,
0.0184363797,
-0.0046339761,
-0.0053371335,
-0.0046550897,
-0.0861700326,
-0.0222529508,
0.0264299642,
-0.0143359788,
-0.0182849504,
-0.0017144828,
0.0536072515,
0.0076894374,
-0.0155128259,
-0.0087822564,
-0.015101172,
-0.0096951621,
-0.0685325116,
-0.0444613658,
-0.0328143649,
0.018895559,
-0.0088628437,
-0.0525985174,
0.0361129567,
-0.0077114762,
-0.0308397263,
0.023537511,
-0.0482866578,
-0.0121132592,
0.0331225954,
0.0754293278,
0.0314828567,
0.0211894009,
0.0045851762,
0.0503797308,
-0.0332459919,
0.029160196,
0.0156848114,
0.0029062708,
0.087120086,
0.0611044839,
0.0295758937,
-0.0093419831,
0.0470027328,
-0.0401150845,
-0.0918965191,
0.0228091944,
0.0338860154,
0.0480234101,
0.0015029672,
0.0404242687,
-0.0107571576,
-0.0290323291,
-0.0498179756,
-0.009614001,
-0.0173261277,
-0.0066222362,
0.0025086289,
0.0372893289,
-0.0417984016,
-0.0320616886,
0.025983138,
-0.0340146758,
-0.0073915152,
0.0483718812,
-0.0151071977,
-0.0063574431,
0.0163788833,
0.0274229776,
-0.0643474162,
-0.0226142891,
0.0176498219,
-0.0277200323,
0.0092114592,
-0.0244064294,
0.0523344278,
0.0295499451,
-0.0327490717,
-0.0197579283,
-0.0376530141,
0.0138522787,
0.0148452837,
0.0528426096,
0.0409579091,
0.0067329584,
0.0183286089,
0.0016040514,
0.037537396,
0.0178627204,
-0.008702687,
0.036743369,
0.0354103297,
0.0186514463,
-0.0010446991,
-0.0064818966,
-0.0268912762,
0.0144407619,
0.0436070599,
-0.0620218217,
-0.0312758759,
0.0028437544,
2.673e-7,
0.0165415667,
0.0119463205,
-0.0201477371,
-0.0322311409,
-0.0158685967,
0.0176490024,
-0.0270922966,
-0.003519366,
-0.0252452865,
-0.014560964,
0.0267630331,
0.0272784345,
0.0572085343,
0.0140120853,
-0.0745153502,
0.0136825014,
-0.0819801539,
-0.0276596267,
-0.0088541731,
-0.0238018185,
-0.0430308804,
0.1170706898,
0.0243861396,
-0.0466939285,
0.0069757733,
-0.0212038495,
0.0327800773,
-0.049545154,
0.0225674845,
0.0293518323,
0.0335461535,
-0.0027184424,
0.0053725764,
-0.0054161665,
-0.0240726992,
0.0258190315,
-0.0146378949,
0.0757735223,
-0.0195856504,
-0.0005328949,
0.0051680552,
-0.0021877333,
-0.032510858,
-0.0480287634,
0.0451133624,
0.0026529862,
-0.0178262815,
-0.0271025877,
0.008336273,
-0.0162496064,
0.0305287,
-0.0317191072,
0.0015151014,
0.0485672504,
0.0149844307,
-0.0231107622,
-0.0250707585,
-0.0797535926,
0.0121641979,
0.0165487174,
-0.0571434572,
-0.0491769984,
-0.0348458439,
-0.0068445299,
0.0388879478,
-0.0711463988,
0.0138302632,
2.718193851e-34,
0.029223755,
-0.0288236178,
-0.0163334869,
0.0176096447,
0.0208872035,
-0.0370304659,
0.0304718167,
0.0101071093,
-0.0346861035,
-0.0764395371,
-0.0115045188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13545v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13545v2 | Developing Interactive Tourism Planning: A Dialogue Robot System Powered by a Large Language Model | 2023-12-21T03:09:38 | 2023-12-22T04:13:51 | Katsumasa Yoshikawa, Takato Yamazaki, Masaya Ohagi, Tomoya Mizumoto, Keiya Sato | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have rapidly proliferated and
have been utilized in various tasks, including research in dialogue systems. We
aimed to construct a system that not only leverages the flexible conversational
abilities of LLMs but also their advanced planning capabilities to reduce the
speaking load on human interlocutors and efficiently plan trips. Furthermore,
we propose a method that divides the complex task of a travel agency into
multiple subtasks, managing each as a separate phase to effectively accomplish
the task. Our proposed system confirmed a certain level of success by achieving
fourth place in the Dialogue Robot Competition 2023 preliminaries rounds. We
report on the challenges identified through the competition. | [
0.0692581236,
0.0334000513,
-0.0221389011,
0.0426492468,
-0.0254588891,
-0.0071401238,
0.0015363166,
-0.0092603154,
0.0414769165,
-0.0196168441,
-0.0506731905,
-0.0305987708,
-0.0030882335,
0.0476440936,
-0.0064098835,
-0.0793791488,
0.0360134728,
-0.0847817138,
0.0167510752,
-0.0053392677,
-0.0158851948,
-0.0016776747,
-0.0614074394,
0.0577639528,
0.0025361998,
0.0139285857,
-0.0649426803,
0.0065085683,
0.0232001431,
-0.0400510505,
-0.0558076873,
0.0105568478,
0.0611534938,
0.0238779373,
0.0000019363,
-0.0326262526,
-0.0042033377,
-0.0300852191,
-0.0151160723,
-0.0478629246,
0.0100246295,
0.0500723533,
0.0152814537,
0.0379143134,
-0.0167470966,
-0.0008458141,
0.0329284295,
0.0715505332,
0.0468000807,
0.0642584413,
0.0008871315,
-0.0215316452,
-0.0369040295,
-0.0040967683,
-0.0489008352,
-0.0789335445,
-0.0177572649,
0.0140135363,
0.0174623299,
-0.0151497871,
-0.0127719482,
0.0153006921,
0.0112033244,
-0.0354695022,
-0.0249803886,
0.0117129013,
-0.0673222765,
-0.049274534,
-0.0254842751,
0.0784768015,
0.0283721257,
0.0237857159,
0.0228244215,
0.0096074454,
0.0051609478,
0.0005560913,
-0.0193645973,
0.0327133164,
0.0125870164,
0.0123119242,
-0.0372030139,
0.0153954569,
-0.0084879566,
0.0209266823,
-0.0209557377,
0.0786689892,
0.0164550431,
-0.0191083886,
-0.0118935881,
0.0045065628,
0.0344069339,
-0.0757637098,
0.0437774435,
0.0564673841,
-0.0778905973,
0.0337386467,
0.0170482751,
0.0519685335,
-0.0121490723,
-0.0324518606,
0.0338662639,
0.0433079153,
0.0086670499,
0.0389838219,
0.0484225936,
0.0765720308,
0.0126189347,
-0.0014960344,
-0.0371462852,
0.0069956463,
-0.0245598014,
0.0236485358,
-0.0829630941,
0.0050577787,
-0.0737106353,
-0.0342601724,
0.0136412987,
0.0561477095,
0.041753497,
0.030961128,
0.0005294849,
0.0122178644,
-0.0181557406,
-0.0345265269,
-0.0525766276,
0.0141857211,
-0.0178585816,
0.0216363836,
-0.0169824231,
0.0007780217,
0.0313766114,
0.0473274104,
0.0153391259,
-0.0059478395,
-0.0471666716,
0.0830344036,
-0.024591703,
-0.0109527493,
-0.0094771683,
-0.0250829589,
-0.0174172837,
-0.102797702,
-0.0206063986,
-0.0393557586,
0.0356853902,
-0.0255846437,
-0.0145439524,
-0.014191662,
0.0256772041,
0.0132935448,
-0.0199673735,
0.0662124455,
0.0084043983,
0.0370841883,
0.0369269289,
0.0020359673,
0.0285981856,
0.0253976323,
0.0598845892,
0.0683927536,
0.0161113534,
0.0259681009,
0.0086199269,
0.0386138223,
-0.036086984,
-0.0055583762,
0.0169766936,
-0.0052888617,
0.0025533717,
0.031167822,
-0.0464852527,
0.0657634065,
-0.0148415323,
0.0684161335,
0.0734596103,
0.0139508555,
-0.0455628708,
-0.0012916403,
0.0432904214,
0.0057824035,
-0.0248579867,
-0.0226202067,
-0.0186722334,
-0.0049297074,
0.0100416662,
0.00079819,
0.0374090821,
-0.0004432877,
-0.0204764996,
-0.0421548449,
0.0070199622,
-0.0070735812,
0.0825407058,
0.0130082453,
0.0412710682,
-0.0139576467,
-0.0669054464,
0.0185521692,
-0.0093302708,
-0.0503879711,
-0.0094185434,
0.0104208719,
0.0116511174,
0.0851157084,
0.0084213289,
0.0224324986,
0.0055872137,
-0.0039560394,
0.020511087,
0.0628420413,
0.065077804,
-0.0236971602,
0.0194676854,
-0.0672590807,
-0.0057868497,
0.0426309668,
-0.021594055,
-0.0036752683,
0.0197932385,
0.0323847756,
0.0039692987,
0.0101901684,
0.0070608067,
-0.0145520242,
0.0073464322,
-0.0050037196,
-0.0212316159,
0.0272478834,
0.0418892726,
0.0458561555,
-0.032220006,
-0.0245237555,
0.0497510061,
-0.0242029745,
0.0195870213,
0.0608186536,
-0.0288921595,
-0.0488779694,
0.0366505682,
0.0048721167,
-0.039654687,
0.0284898169,
-0.0114635043,
-0.0531247593,
-0.0041900002,
-0.0238031503,
0.0378695391,
-0.0069829854,
0.0659331307,
0.022775298,
-0.007136282,
-0.0326185375,
0.0202019308,
0.0096257403,
0.0000570914,
0.0529772416,
0.0256763306,
0.0242745783,
-0.0876864716,
-0.0392880477,
0.0672666058,
0.0182014704,
-0.004137984,
0.0427682884,
0.0348840766,
-0.0369355641,
-0.0248833485,
-0.1309378594,
-0.0308170971,
-0.0060642115,
-0.0272500794,
-0.0172230434,
0.0006119904,
-0.0116667282,
-0.0246045701,
-0.021709336,
0.0237861983,
0.0155047765,
-0.0299372673,
0.0184668619,
0.0169488005,
-0.0775635913,
-0.0319066085,
0.0271762908,
0.0115104159,
-0.0189265981,
0.0461233743,
-0.0251260381,
-0.0736126304,
0.0019453904,
-0.0652196258,
0.0254632309,
0.0002290653,
-0.0704378262,
0.0221142359,
-0.0126452986,
0.0256887544,
0.0106636276,
0.0253818035,
-0.0160228424,
0.0600357093,
-0.0481829196,
-0.0465009175,
0.0455608964,
-0.0281439498,
-0.0026508716,
-0.062517032,
-0.0236094706,
0.0034006948,
0.0199778453,
0.0061622579,
0.0619557388,
-0.0621154495,
-0.0088044293,
0.0193921588,
-0.0555699915,
0.0159010421,
0.0150699914,
-0.0696954653,
0.0645317584,
-0.0014162679,
-0.0114875222,
0.0354968458,
-0.0431778133,
-0.0213020854,
-0.0329082012,
-0.0042701173,
-0.0182380043,
0.0673602745,
-0.0000347268,
0.055829972,
0.0106808161,
-0.0154023208,
0.0052407207,
-0.0131224832,
-0.0323268957,
-0.0415960848,
0.025259532,
-0.0750783086,
0.0173192732,
0.0170175992,
-0.0729437172,
-0.0332712978,
0.0202087406,
-0.0585841946,
-0.0132261952,
0.0173990875,
-0.0374745093,
-0.0293640308,
0.0156940594,
0.0289435238,
0.0411065929,
0.0304102506,
0.0146865034,
-0.0293530747,
0.0059895576,
0.0480878577,
0.1034241542,
-0.0318483002,
0.0080981785,
0.0438791923,
-0.0003573277,
0.0139327412,
-0.0064540361,
0.0025116247,
0.0206983238,
0.0304757394,
0.0173909012,
-0.0047504706,
0.0394118279,
0.0491176993,
-0.0227617733,
-0.0151420841,
0.1038596705,
0.0180392433,
-0.0490795299,
0.0023376474,
-0.0378155112,
0.0277598407,
0.006833123,
0.0282334425,
-0.0392772891,
-0.020402154,
0.0227913875,
-0.011006617,
-0.0136671262,
-0.017987866,
-0.0233459361,
-0.1186050177,
0.0461045019,
0.0047316155,
0.0053841961,
-0.0234739892,
-0.0209321696,
0.002941963,
-0.0054243831,
0.0038741566,
0.0036570872,
0.0087958649,
-0.0271483995,
-0.0182688683,
-0.022490792,
0.0117398286,
-0.001327436,
-0.0235424824,
0.0642119944,
0.0677064732,
0.080054827,
0.0059258589,
-0.0083901612,
0.0007657245,
0.0512857661,
0.0277034715,
-0.0343304351,
-0.0119758751,
-0.0004013452,
-0.0331108458,
-0.0007746219,
0.0093021691,
-0.0363764837,
-0.0102383746,
0.0357227512,
0.0343374684,
-0.040457923,
0.0363039449,
0.0144724706,
0.0386454239,
0.0264844429,
0.0636952221,
-0.0145470314,
-0.0597659051,
-0.0296387747,
-0.0444695204,
-0.0370493159,
-0.0259177461,
-0.0211637001,
0.0007058864,
0.0037489666,
-0.0014961772,
-0.0880619064,
-0.0448060483,
0.0404092185,
0.0218797643,
0.0146401227,
0.0031226675,
0.0075624865,
0.0528853238,
0.0173623785,
-0.0079739662,
-0.0443708748,
0.0125122732,
-0.0947208479,
0.002820872,
0.0296900235,
-0.0418648906,
-0.019586619,
0.0311764423,
-0.0371888392,
-0.085850887,
-0.0080972333,
0.0387599431,
0.0131873433,
0.0429247059,
-0.0036223966,
-0.0270462446,
-0.0268707238,
-0.0284621008,
-0.0125486851,
0.0153595926,
0.0033346424,
0.081512168,
-0.0176921263,
0.0430221334,
-0.0545779951,
-0.0136758154,
-0.035540808,
0.0691999197,
-0.0742504746,
-0.0651840419,
0.0137705803,
0.0445728861,
0.0106710978,
0.001104185,
-0.0040511275,
-0.0320520885,
0.0374349654,
-0.0265196059,
-0.0255967174,
-0.0775182024,
-0.0123357186,
-0.0127496896,
0.0091476217,
0.0302534997,
-0.0003285365,
-0.0246183425,
-0.0181177761,
0.0200672522,
0.0007577821,
0.0321012922,
-0.0331984013,
0.0221187323,
0.0149481427,
-0.0027008173,
0.0524071939,
-0.0187518783,
0.0101916883,
0.0068973782,
0.0824175552,
0.0168498158,
-0.0320527144,
-0.0316502899,
0.0268376805,
-0.0066484129,
-0.1077130884,
0.0374704599,
0.0308340937,
0.0666783005,
0.0165332537,
0.0219025891,
-0.0665460154,
0.0142778261,
-0.020854257,
0.0066693039,
0.0107585406,
-0.0399603397,
0.0466293767,
0.0146404421,
-0.0120282657,
0.02587712,
0.0197826959,
0.0100672282,
0.0170950871,
0.0045146034,
-0.0023711531,
-0.0660049766,
-0.01654041,
-0.0054925676,
0.0208477266,
-0.0128153414,
0.0298630893,
-0.0204125326,
-0.0434600301,
-0.0159382671,
-0.0031697885,
-0.0204531401,
-0.0507318825,
0.0663963854,
0.0080965683,
-0.0219694283,
-0.0397454351,
-0.0557114743,
-0.0309026968,
0.0208859257,
-0.0177385099,
-0.0431667715,
-5.854339862e-33,
-0.0375595205,
-0.0504439101,
0.0543462448,
-0.0135330604,
-0.0400109813,
-0.0501863323,
-0.0528342165,
0.0354748517,
-0.0325982012,
0.0002975619,
-0.0219735913,
-0.0178576969,
0.0156974308,
0.0325958207,
0.0027677799,
-0.0045671533,
0.0727141276,
0.0076830415,
-0.016982194,
0.0082424115,
0.0478951745,
-0.000400435,
0.0089384988,
-0.0845779479,
-0.0256943926,
-0.0025877333,
-0.0534093678,
0.0506898724,
0.0412174053,
0.0201045219,
-0.0088571394,
0.027387673,
0.0027225367,
-0.0276758187,
-0.0129273087,
0.0236057658,
-0.0317663066,
-0.0202240944,
0.0399490558,
0.0526668169,
-0.0041513126,
-0.0195631869,
-0.0200938974,
-0.0284101386,
-0.0065619415,
0.0401392169,
0.0053431103,
-0.0126033351,
-0.0139577268,
0.0608168133,
-0.0524115823,
0.006844155,
-0.0144348638,
-0.0552223399,
0.0518105142,
0.0580582879,
-0.0112842591,
-0.0021650491,
-0.0113480007,
0.0567581281,
-0.0130805429,
-0.0075444621,
0.0430539884,
-0.0089469971,
0.0055725938,
0.0498943739,
0.0123113878,
-0.0127229178,
-0.01797661,
-0.010732173,
-0.0276804548,
0.0762950853,
-0.0036888458,
0.0555399954,
-0.0539010204,
0.0000765977,
-0.0023180605,
-0.0207154211,
0.0338657685,
0.0423049331,
0.0237618238,
0.0269979239,
-0.0264043473,
-0.0067399316,
-0.0448973328,
0.0251774304,
0.0111991419,
-0.0555527844,
0.0456461608,
0.0481336042,
0.0002629949,
-0.0082917586,
0.0757131651,
-0.0237998124,
-0.0238042381,
0.0291919801,
0.0122168222,
0.0187277757,
-0.0256811772,
0.015545601,
-0.0839399323,
-0.0356757157,
-0.0154491896,
-0.0109442854,
0.0150932083,
0.0076820296,
-0.0706921369,
0.0265299436,
-0.0086475965,
0.0260604396,
-0.0149406688,
-0.003778484,
-0.0078962194,
0.0451306552,
0.027323639,
-0.0340614431,
-0.0461933352,
0.046594929,
0.0006238548,
-0.0508367196,
-0.0164949819,
-0.0697709695,
-0.0021359338,
0.0217563175,
-0.0458408855,
0.020196341,
-0.0245351549,
-0.013792797,
0.0148761934,
-0.0143742906,
-0.0141924284,
0.0041723461,
2.696e-7,
-0.0288857222,
0.0385828093,
-0.0240584258,
0.0435739644,
0.002893954,
0.0281018261,
0.0087262699,
0.0062852055,
-0.0313633904,
0.0136528658,
-0.0016918154,
0.0225053895,
0.0393831357,
0.0186437033,
-0.0889751837,
-0.0009449508,
-0.0530694574,
-0.0480797105,
-0.0541051179,
0.0173099954,
0.0372084342,
0.0907041878,
0.0001005677,
0.0124058323,
-0.005233678,
-0.0695045516,
0.0142408228,
-0.0552620515,
-0.0278978255,
0.0212119967,
-0.0090221073,
0.0087673208,
-0.0242034644,
-0.0148479473,
0.0044922493,
0.0321496092,
0.0121511156,
0.0670794249,
0.0074094636,
-0.0491350591,
0.0193481669,
0.00485342,
-0.0278934557,
-0.046230834,
0.0281139463,
0.0088411374,
0.0160418767,
0.0125704259,
0.0249337964,
-0.0210130848,
-0.0036167454,
-0.0025237116,
-0.0044790502,
0.0061835139,
0.0136864809,
-0.005084102,
0.0283871256,
-0.0695481747,
0.0243525077,
-0.0090381233,
-0.0715156123,
-0.023031801,
-0.0302710179,
-0.0394638106,
-0.0459057651,
-0.059257444,
0.007018059,
1.825793553e-34,
0.0262141414,
-0.0055144434,
-0.0197090413,
0.0746314377,
0.0598354749,
0.009925657,
0.0074838344,
0.0067237043,
0.0219902322,
-0.0745194033,
-0.0175366513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13533v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13533v2 | Automated Clinical Coding for Outpatient Departments | 2023-12-21T02:28:29 | 2023-12-24T08:16:46 | Viktor Schlegel, Abhinav Ramesh Kashyap, Thanh-Tung Nguyen, Tsung-Han Yang, Vijay Prakash Dwivedi, Wei-Hsian Yin, Jeng Wei, Stefan Winkler | cs.CL | cs.CL | Computerised clinical coding approaches aim to automate the process of
assigning a set of codes to medical records. While there is active research
pushing the state of the art on clinical coding for hospitalized patients, the
outpatient setting -- where doctors tend to non-hospitalised patients -- is
overlooked. Although both settings can be formalised as a multi-label
classification task, they present unique and distinct challenges, which raises
the question of whether the success of inpatient clinical coding approaches
translates to the outpatient setting. This paper is the first to investigate
how well state-of-the-art deep learning-based clinical coding approaches work
in the outpatient setting at hospital scale. To this end, we collect a large
outpatient dataset comprising over 7 million notes documenting over half a
million patients. We adapt four state-of-the-art clinical coding approaches to
this setting and evaluate their potential to assist coders. We find evidence
that clinical coding in outpatient settings can benefit from more innovations
in popular inpatient coding benchmarks. A deeper analysis of the factors
contributing to the success -- amount and form of data and choice of document
representation -- reveals the presence of easy-to-solve examples, the coding of
which can be completely automated with a low error rate. | [
-0.0028855754,
0.044110477,
0.0053657335,
-0.0398313664,
-0.005323221,
0.0711424127,
0.0274976771,
0.0203387402,
-0.0031357622,
-0.0008517817,
0.0283379927,
-0.0484156311,
0.0068336562,
0.0842297524,
0.0051016933,
-0.0098530585,
0.0134683903,
0.016209621,
0.0359737687,
0.0265291631,
-0.0518212542,
-0.0012813193,
-0.0252354387,
0.0579757392,
-0.0319527462,
-0.015418631,
-0.0123256911,
0.004388337,
-0.0025122841,
-0.0652973577,
0.0078111817,
0.0362467282,
-0.0002943761,
-0.0092001539,
0.0000018039,
-0.0135571929,
-0.011881955,
-0.0102574974,
-0.0791540146,
-0.0507562868,
-0.0012011901,
-0.0910403952,
0.0038926287,
0.0021830543,
-0.0234069657,
-0.1022867858,
0.0521424562,
0.0246070251,
0.0409292243,
0.0319515765,
-0.0302131716,
0.0010342451,
0.0040305541,
-0.0113679646,
0.0295661017,
-0.0443176702,
0.0434163809,
0.0186197143,
0.0166568272,
-0.0465127267,
0.0017748354,
0.0495178401,
0.0432427824,
-0.0019628343,
0.0434481241,
0.0434615575,
-0.0315523036,
0.0221299771,
-0.0102009661,
0.0675602928,
-0.0397599749,
0.0269863531,
0.0087168422,
-0.0342609622,
-0.0120148771,
-0.087662071,
-0.0272355806,
-0.0122803682,
-0.0220130235,
-0.0156537183,
-0.0269085076,
0.0393167883,
0.0332436003,
-0.0210111085,
-0.0080670416,
-0.036266014,
-0.0162833109,
-0.0116096046,
0.0273154881,
0.0178386681,
0.0012714878,
-0.0325988382,
0.0428248607,
0.0348450877,
-0.0370066985,
-0.0083082775,
-0.0437273122,
-0.0299163684,
0.0518795401,
-0.0333498791,
0.0401754119,
0.0008715665,
-0.0075208708,
0.0332427323,
-0.0322170891,
0.0287845936,
-0.0374337584,
0.047086291,
-0.0302389003,
0.0004878568,
-0.0543638431,
0.0221833978,
-0.0327157713,
0.0143014211,
0.0510783084,
0.0149638541,
-0.0586067885,
-0.0063704164,
-0.011672277,
0.0343696587,
0.0140872048,
0.0629294217,
-0.0231023282,
0.0067378441,
0.0185429826,
-0.0114856493,
-0.0078342594,
0.0028347024,
-0.0045935549,
-0.0160155203,
0.0365139879,
0.019571919,
0.0241084285,
0.0122687351,
0.0124445278,
0.0279357638,
-0.010973813,
0.0091742873,
-0.0097827725,
-0.0510874651,
-0.0137612224,
0.0423545018,
0.0225267876,
-0.0467618778,
0.02666739,
0.007917651,
0.0055394964,
-0.074753046,
-0.0063971048,
-0.0128254648,
-0.0301206447,
0.054146342,
-0.0526718125,
-0.0014509687,
0.0592485331,
0.0362779722,
0.0006458119,
-0.0212409254,
0.050751321,
-0.0191718079,
-0.0221188534,
-0.0600936748,
0.0674873963,
0.0095365597,
0.0031783106,
-0.0570934601,
0.0071609993,
-0.0020847982,
0.037149433,
0.089561075,
-0.0257321373,
0.036187347,
0.0041443282,
-0.0464413837,
-0.0111588417,
0.0248347931,
0.0583072677,
0.0149395568,
0.019893419,
-0.0677315891,
-0.0287283268,
-0.0599677041,
0.0212708004,
0.0514268242,
0.0892959759,
-0.0157412756,
0.0058295145,
-0.0603056438,
-0.0571926273,
-0.0491086245,
-0.0362705253,
-0.0329368636,
-0.0121270726,
-0.0267050173,
0.0299202409,
-0.0072721369,
-0.0465016887,
0.0316072404,
-0.0121135078,
-0.0247142389,
-0.0304978807,
-0.0634996668,
-0.0362886749,
0.0854355693,
0.0514993332,
-0.0199315175,
-0.00913982,
-0.0358976908,
0.0316240303,
-0.0278530009,
0.0404891223,
-0.0296146255,
0.0510886274,
-0.0693624392,
-0.0141262766,
0.029210953,
-0.0129845701,
-0.0054382328,
-0.0103876814,
-0.0047451355,
-0.0192459654,
-0.0064902906,
-0.0540263318,
0.0455444232,
-0.0578192063,
-0.0476838388,
0.0394180082,
0.0138872135,
0.0286433417,
0.0194055643,
0.0039499011,
0.0051733083,
0.0299235657,
-0.0373082794,
-0.0244023707,
-0.048956912,
-0.0373565257,
-0.0006464092,
-0.0215895157,
-0.0144013232,
-0.0367991403,
-0.0167125706,
-0.0368102305,
-0.0155093009,
-0.0521747209,
-0.0435204245,
0.0020003051,
0.0233162716,
0.0086155087,
0.0706822351,
-0.0102347331,
-0.0230334699,
-0.0025973385,
-0.028611321,
0.0224572942,
-0.0113898609,
-0.0010801821,
0.0394994803,
0.0209601782,
0.0239479393,
0.0053127632,
-0.0543447621,
0.0321478471,
-0.0284935404,
0.0290857963,
0.0076987948,
-0.0043761441,
-0.0829298571,
-0.0269318223,
0.0038283989,
-0.0550932623,
0.0293017402,
0.0140078943,
0.0192940794,
-0.0301815476,
-0.0565897748,
-0.0038335898,
-0.0069381138,
0.0067629046,
0.0517612398,
0.060275238,
-0.0353330076,
-0.0027174277,
-0.0216088239,
-0.044222068,
0.0238758624,
-0.0073100608,
-0.0396752879,
-0.0139326565,
-0.0099574076,
-0.0099185193,
-0.029648887,
-0.0083327601,
-0.0337147303,
0.0317254066,
-0.0317452736,
-0.0155203966,
0.0455721468,
-0.0276777521,
0.0321915336,
0.0445108898,
-0.0017795182,
0.0018697056,
0.0148288487,
-0.016912099,
-0.0428990573,
0.0326380208,
-0.0824243054,
-0.0011490949,
0.0682043508,
0.0022578535,
0.0215734039,
-0.0389083736,
-0.0342168435,
0.0032891864,
0.0235489924,
-0.0636021718,
0.0136662936,
-0.0182348527,
0.0835115612,
0.0237288475,
-0.0318985656,
0.0645955279,
0.0128120659,
0.0133529883,
-0.0478275754,
-0.0414145142,
-0.0331295244,
0.0325782336,
-0.0241286699,
0.0162059944,
-0.0159277041,
-0.0443882048,
0.0209509619,
0.0047428054,
-0.0336149111,
-0.0556893311,
0.0650584847,
0.0002549408,
0.0263988283,
-0.0261554047,
-0.0477973782,
-0.0314415842,
-0.0168588702,
0.0160879195,
0.0201482289,
-0.0011580336,
0.0071633263,
-0.0518734939,
0.0369241945,
-0.0412890166,
0.1098446697,
0.0273170006,
-0.0213015135,
0.0030261362,
-0.0005206665,
-0.0239694361,
-0.001796432,
-0.0323791504,
-0.0221984629,
-0.006038826,
0.0426389724,
0.0107554141,
0.0889838263,
-0.0152061051,
0.0444906056,
-0.0303459521,
-0.0070346775,
0.0103502693,
0.0511207879,
0.0007821962,
-0.0474751927,
-0.0008019421,
0.0605110005,
0.0507851914,
-0.1008044928,
0.0141567038,
-0.0210339613,
-0.0348813385,
-0.0048149852,
0.0120785972,
-0.0487462766,
-0.0124874273,
0.0094154598,
0.0461051427,
-0.010837866,
-0.0508676395,
0.0296562482,
0.0055644154,
0.0311332624,
0.0157465711,
-0.0293860976,
-0.060260728,
-0.0310942568,
-0.0273713917,
-0.0018347458,
-0.0586366989,
-0.0040779486,
0.0176309384,
-0.0502324514,
0.0155897541,
-0.0711589307,
-0.0452469289,
0.0311413873,
-0.0144712226,
0.0432776026,
0.0648381338,
0.0121375443,
-0.0232867878,
-0.0221729819,
0.0184664279,
0.0214260686,
0.0038480707,
-0.0232120082,
0.0731723234,
0.0160880759,
-0.0133480262,
0.0084231775,
0.0150009124,
-0.082771644,
-0.0367606729,
0.0062380391,
0.0561543964,
-0.0257491302,
-0.0234049316,
-0.0563023798,
0.018674802,
0.0454054549,
0.0230317619,
0.0063490639,
-0.0204608329,
-0.0275124609,
-0.0195038859,
0.0714592785,
-0.0088134659,
0.0198490787,
0.0387033559,
-0.0381949656,
-0.0550257638,
-0.0390772894,
-0.0302882101,
0.064134635,
0.0061382782,
0.0128556918,
-0.0445572473,
-0.0009222115,
-0.0019163304,
-0.089102909,
-0.0003718808,
0.0171050671,
-0.0023616394,
-0.0508590937,
-0.0481158532,
0.0355669558,
0.0485559218,
-0.0132959951,
0.0022405228,
-0.0000183142,
0.0296760034,
0.0578503907,
0.0363168642,
0.0138365794,
-0.0264608059,
0.033265084,
0.0035482722,
-0.0088324575,
0.0306689162,
-0.0076347496,
-0.0329593383,
0.0012930075,
-0.0400518589,
-0.0292543899,
0.0047104135,
-0.039382495,
0.0581876598,
-0.0300152116,
0.0055705779,
-0.043788027,
-0.0200509224,
-0.009465673,
-0.0204575192,
0.0103492541,
0.0231896993,
-0.0633301735,
-0.0208565798,
0.0352763981,
0.0225413404,
0.0156855285,
0.0012377892,
-0.0247456059,
0.0380326584,
0.0200375002,
-0.0166357532,
0.0522673614,
-0.0085550882,
-0.0411072448,
0.0127758896,
0.016453322,
0.024606904,
0.0457978025,
0.0269972999,
-0.0227325279,
-0.03950423,
0.0664286986,
0.0224944036,
0.0437186025,
-0.0081085963,
0.0359374918,
-0.0016921058,
0.0784612671,
-0.019804433,
0.0330416411,
-0.0265328847,
-0.046664305,
-0.0200547539,
-0.0289129857,
0.0145882424,
0.0260546934,
-0.0117903827,
-0.0428675488,
0.0094498647,
-0.0401292518,
0.0388109535,
-0.0179431643,
0.0305134878,
0.0203481074,
0.00582072,
-0.0038581027,
-0.0263860133,
0.0695669129,
0.0337847993,
0.0442390852,
-0.0170724224,
-0.0199988987,
-0.0622686334,
0.0199443735,
0.045929689,
0.016296085,
-0.015540624,
-0.0378381461,
-0.0069447523,
-0.0182533171,
0.0671190917,
-0.0147483116,
-0.0138319889,
-0.0058966456,
0.059189003,
0.0401954837,
0.002251721,
0.0021563126,
-0.0119245136,
0.0294255335,
0.007362497,
-0.0443066284,
0.0001972226,
-5.171302706e-33,
-0.0056718285,
-0.044827342,
0.0173039343,
-0.0122821731,
0.0477629118,
0.0251912437,
-0.0447746925,
-0.017400926,
0.0165600143,
0.0060198396,
-0.0190881249,
0.0004467109,
0.0211793892,
0.0347415954,
0.055466529,
-0.0475511402,
0.039275974,
-0.0099693639,
-0.0094411178,
0.0537044331,
-0.0296156947,
0.0389960594,
0.0137945069,
-0.0923208892,
-0.0111360783,
0.0153319836,
0.0406720154,
-0.018996615,
0.0058184229,
0.0388592519,
-0.0390626267,
-0.0085991127,
0.0410577245,
0.0018365924,
0.0042046015,
0.0319481976,
-0.0781888589,
-0.0285722408,
-0.0515039191,
-0.0081151696,
-0.0196030382,
-0.0596208237,
0.0281067677,
-0.003925472,
-0.0182020999,
-0.0343082733,
0.0359990895,
-0.0148753095,
-0.0124566583,
-0.0706010833,
0.0069977809,
0.0472062267,
-0.0259745494,
-0.0171002056,
0.0037883262,
-0.0164217278,
-0.0320024863,
0.0314279459,
-0.0820939317,
-0.0122394003,
-0.0137202237,
0.0272788759,
-0.0013848408,
-0.0331939086,
-0.0487192981,
0.0542579181,
0.0544658825,
0.0274183154,
-0.0351101607,
0.0247298945,
-0.038273938,
0.0204200186,
0.0632763654,
0.041904252,
0.0837546065,
-0.0268227533,
-0.0803254023,
0.0607930683,
-0.0816561207,
0.0185638387,
0.0176585875,
-0.0021908653,
-0.046893958,
-0.0190963801,
0.0079398872,
-0.0088877184,
-0.0057722707,
-0.0137455827,
0.0468818359,
-0.0100635709,
-0.0149795255,
0.0615980588,
0.0289726816,
-0.0100672198,
-0.0052080145,
-0.0115941465,
0.0683127716,
0.0846465975,
-0.0413686484,
-0.0089675309,
-0.0399257205,
-0.0362751111,
0.0429351144,
0.0096145924,
0.0931771249,
0.0359306335,
0.0537814945,
0.0052881902,
-0.0377992615,
-0.0287487116,
0.0639109984,
-0.0020465634,
-0.011670948,
0.0477286577,
0.0296062194,
-0.0015518215,
0.0346577652,
0.0577282868,
-0.0367529541,
-0.0167873763,
-0.0193189327,
-0.0419623554,
0.0271592755,
-0.0101461867,
-0.0233605523,
-0.0124675017,
-0.084172383,
0.0066924603,
0.0749174729,
-0.0399686098,
0.0148359854,
0.0180201642,
2.502e-7,
0.0748569667,
0.0308286138,
0.0561374724,
-0.0530735999,
0.0453407653,
0.0079336474,
0.0061062709,
-0.0012353843,
-0.0210426543,
-0.0322818793,
0.0619889908,
-0.0170200504,
0.0535581261,
0.067926079,
-0.0428548083,
-0.0206403434,
-0.0698685721,
0.0296643786,
-0.0410810299,
-0.0303694829,
0.054381568,
0.0634128675,
-0.0323216841,
-0.0346250907,
0.0325454064,
-0.0193379261,
0.0223519467,
-0.0246051569,
0.0571485423,
0.0263322145,
-0.0264080316,
0.0451849625,
-0.0035508366,
0.0501037426,
-0.0077362945,
-0.0291058607,
0.0049313391,
0.1170788035,
-0.049666699,
0.0105274692,
0.0130187757,
-0.0045057158,
0.0245176852,
-0.0104922596,
0.0436053686,
-0.0515790731,
0.0007334379,
-0.0059822756,
0.0060415226,
-0.0074993996,
0.1002910435,
-0.0146539062,
0.0079038264,
0.046070192,
0.0363917612,
-0.0072372924,
-0.0534040816,
-0.0660413876,
-0.0064198002,
0.0361012816,
-0.0149526987,
0.0198100712,
0.034557458,
-0.0021853002,
0.0283966921,
-0.0371602215,
0.0142406775,
2.166389023e-34,
0.0350876972,
-0.0120478244,
0.0044591185,
0.0233084764,
0.0056100073,
-0.0168373249,
0.0253601018,
0.01369943,
0.0019251219,
-0.0484981388,
-0.0088523058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01643v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01643v2 | L-TUNING: Synchronized Label Tuning for Prompt and Prefix in LLMs | 2023-12-21T01:47:49 | 2024-04-13T00:14:21 | Md. Kowsher, Md. Shohanur Islam Sobuj, Asif Mahmud, Nusrat Jahan Prottasha, Prakash Bhat | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Efficiently fine-tuning Large Language Models (LLMs) for specific tasks
presents a considerable challenge in natural language processing. Traditional
methods, like prompt or prefix tuning, typically rely on arbitrary tokens for
training, leading to prolonged training times and generalized token use across
various class labels. To address these issues, this paper introduces L-Tuning,
an efficient fine-tuning approach designed for classification tasks within the
Natural Language Inference (NLI) framework. Diverging from conventional
methods, L-Tuning focuses on the fine-tuning of label tokens processed through
a pre-trained LLM, thereby harnessing its pre-existing semantic knowledge. This
technique not only improves the fine-tuning accuracy and efficiency but also
facilitates the generation of distinct label embeddings for each class,
enhancing the model's training nuance. Our experimental results indicate a
significant improvement in training efficiency and classification accuracy with
L-Tuning compared to traditional approaches, marking a promising advancement in
fine-tuning LLMs for complex language tasks. | [
0.0556645133,
0.0295257289,
-0.0162069723,
0.0639341995,
-0.0230055638,
0.0224866569,
0.0040395106,
0.0039685005,
0.0053952336,
-0.0782201886,
-0.069881022,
0.0342835858,
-0.0354812108,
0.0042957896,
0.0199241173,
-0.0213903915,
0.0758281946,
0.0014525154,
0.0073580849,
0.0303970482,
-0.0028331683,
0.0255090576,
-0.0060460721,
0.0329529978,
-0.0266709961,
0.0177547615,
0.0190473534,
0.0203203186,
0.0107549718,
-0.0153309721,
0.022349488,
0.0665252954,
0.0256007705,
0.0218513366,
0.0000019223,
-0.0839675963,
0.0029599548,
-0.0188795533,
-0.0488622189,
-0.0012669051,
0.0316933021,
0.017988313,
0.0235960409,
0.0174357928,
-0.0223524515,
0.0062713218,
0.034651503,
0.0437085927,
0.0138079794,
0.0642807633,
0.0152548002,
-0.0296188649,
-0.0180929955,
-0.032917209,
-0.0266974084,
-0.0647231936,
0.0184174404,
-0.0350631177,
-0.0055178902,
0.0562045537,
-0.0198944863,
0.0289685782,
0.0159965865,
0.0255065653,
0.0190630127,
0.0250322744,
-0.0279999189,
-0.0248863865,
-0.0207256898,
0.0395385139,
-0.0208132155,
-0.033015877,
-0.022551246,
-0.0296294447,
0.014153067,
-0.0399453565,
-0.0132236993,
0.0233487692,
0.00566968,
0.0170441456,
0.0582404584,
-0.0105956001,
0.0388072766,
0.0292940419,
-0.0196431559,
0.0757626295,
0.0208909269,
-0.0371199027,
0.0052839085,
0.0008948271,
-0.0356661193,
-0.0551422723,
-0.0129110394,
0.0227790643,
-0.0618118905,
0.0352339223,
-0.0623717234,
-0.0191697683,
0.0280099642,
0.0032607024,
-0.0132061644,
0.029932918,
0.0036806504,
0.0533339567,
-0.0326799676,
0.0210420974,
0.0329777412,
0.0609310493,
-0.0538796075,
-0.0305478629,
-0.0351718217,
-0.0081669893,
-0.0604790673,
0.0097272592,
-0.0304882824,
-0.0138160428,
-0.0551269129,
0.0409233384,
0.0362137519,
-0.0040763114,
0.0186782088,
-0.027505124,
-0.0282027144,
-0.0177248009,
-0.0189090632,
0.0021271254,
-0.059940286,
0.0326593257,
-0.002764625,
-0.0679881126,
-0.0224908255,
0.0062622479,
0.0130678676,
-0.0370870568,
0.0286383703,
0.074258782,
0.0072672293,
-0.0645542368,
-0.0542930886,
-0.0067902491,
-0.0206269193,
-0.0364016108,
-0.0408954546,
-0.0485554375,
0.0354558118,
0.011965354,
0.0085077984,
-0.0183934271,
-0.0070878114,
0.0019074612,
-0.0422823653,
0.0925589055,
-0.0319027863,
-0.0003265023,
0.0152928988,
0.0023317714,
0.0051705698,
0.0663963109,
0.0146559859,
0.0238836389,
0.0583678558,
-0.0058651599,
-0.0187170319,
0.056797348,
-0.0080770329,
-0.0059642456,
-0.0210001338,
-0.0054283114,
0.0575034395,
0.0338031463,
0.0087900637,
0.0084622735,
-0.011442041,
-0.0050459523,
0.0365761109,
0.0542588495,
0.0369196162,
-0.0146590713,
0.0535836965,
0.0023212715,
-0.0141804311,
-0.0189169738,
-0.0828402713,
0.0023432288,
-0.0275143832,
-0.0118551049,
0.0174655989,
0.0320422873,
-0.0223687403,
-0.0530770198,
-0.0330044962,
-0.0218890328,
-0.0410662219,
0.0166663304,
0.0380843617,
0.0319528244,
-0.018580921,
0.0774464533,
0.0902168453,
-0.0010082864,
-0.0121977413,
-0.0681043714,
0.0092061097,
0.0594803058,
0.0328028314,
-0.0421414375,
-0.0433069803,
-0.0121696703,
0.0383743718,
0.0422762483,
0.0673705786,
-0.0185011979,
0.0124102291,
-0.0512143373,
-0.0190253612,
-0.0072295414,
0.0370934643,
0.0135759208,
0.0315950289,
0.0206683669,
0.0326414742,
-0.0480446331,
-0.0097883688,
0.0707854629,
-0.0254460312,
-0.062963061,
0.0170310866,
0.0509945899,
0.0211162996,
-0.0192423854,
0.0048237564,
-0.0136497831,
0.0165558942,
-0.0246720221,
0.0250096731,
-0.0363676883,
-0.0202521794,
-0.0354728177,
0.0294187982,
0.0369069874,
-0.0361449271,
-0.0079837712,
-0.0817244202,
-0.0172258057,
-0.043370977,
-0.0058047748,
0.0178812947,
-0.0623563603,
0.0201692637,
-0.016498534,
0.014695704,
-0.0630279109,
0.0334261544,
0.0079116644,
0.0145246312,
-0.0002983533,
0.0421519242,
-0.0034243108,
-0.0147724003,
-0.0167758521,
-0.0176263619,
-0.0119000636,
-0.0186211336,
0.0184400268,
0.0419954844,
-0.0436822549,
-0.0533445254,
-0.081787385,
0.0186970364,
-0.0419417359,
0.0015023146,
0.0126805771,
0.0112166917,
-0.0420475714,
-0.0321307071,
-0.0035535023,
-0.0217944086,
0.0043355878,
0.0202927142,
0.0413883291,
-0.0084402598,
-0.0575107411,
-0.0309427977,
0.0125254048,
-0.0126741556,
0.0223683398,
0.0025300854,
-0.0234292597,
-0.0535403788,
-0.018900577,
-0.022614222,
0.0176958311,
-0.0060001789,
-0.026580913,
-0.0011533658,
0.0019382491,
0.0454058088,
0.0719689652,
0.0186181068,
0.0063442518,
0.0310102068,
0.0189087689,
-0.0527405888,
0.0187560208,
-0.0195823852,
-0.0551614612,
-0.0351041071,
-0.0178489573,
0.0224246066,
0.0858274996,
-0.0090625063,
0.0010193294,
-0.0450655818,
0.0225986354,
0.0023947349,
-0.0364470407,
-0.0360431559,
0.0285022855,
-0.0160911083,
0.0003909167,
-0.004408699,
-0.0713035986,
0.0782080889,
-0.0483798161,
0.0178639665,
-0.0332474522,
-0.0550823808,
-0.052981548,
0.0596362725,
0.0059214355,
0.0174267665,
0.0223412663,
-0.0198336076,
-0.0428207181,
0.0028881016,
0.0079408186,
-0.0156384148,
0.0369471833,
-0.0130111631,
-0.0048032273,
-0.0028072719,
-0.0284174085,
-0.0562150218,
-0.0722568259,
-0.0719378144,
0.0101541551,
0.0067426208,
0.0071818358,
-0.0085609071,
-0.0041380166,
-0.0141315749,
0.0261880681,
-0.0121569782,
0.0195691083,
-0.0423674472,
0.0143615417,
0.0629207566,
0.0086361598,
0.0080331173,
-0.0049400274,
0.0071883234,
0.0078897914,
0.0049230652,
0.0109359939,
-0.0186938439,
-0.0038924674,
0.0253190957,
-0.0524466559,
-0.0077603199,
0.0330788307,
0.0384447761,
-0.0588512495,
-0.0178889036,
0.1536430866,
0.0309007373,
-0.0247655176,
-0.0000122756,
0.0035357568,
0.0381610841,
0.0413550548,
0.0366035067,
-0.0711196959,
-0.0826060623,
0.0251475051,
-0.0041692453,
-0.002274917,
-0.0003005945,
-0.030919129,
-0.1151603237,
0.0169677418,
-0.0109824194,
-0.0438733473,
-0.0184720047,
-0.0506707504,
0.0127523355,
0.0165952072,
0.0447060131,
-0.0110088764,
-0.003984422,
-0.0046765683,
0.0099423435,
-0.0004499815,
-0.0531284437,
0.0489223003,
-0.0624605678,
0.0538971201,
0.004066485,
0.0070050112,
0.0029001918,
-0.0475016423,
0.0909681544,
-0.021994818,
0.0137057649,
-0.0307307784,
0.0106830122,
-0.0580858998,
0.0041400008,
0.0050800471,
0.0198851451,
0.0037001665,
-0.0181578174,
0.0081246924,
0.0621215515,
-0.00821588,
0.0048992736,
-0.0062178397,
-0.0131141385,
0.0068920078,
0.0864354596,
0.050459493,
-0.0548649393,
-0.0100925528,
0.0004026716,
-0.017488081,
-0.0172933582,
-0.0141505124,
0.0136310356,
-0.0537947007,
-0.0172295365,
-0.0317283869,
-0.0194070544,
0.05242851,
0.021551419,
0.0098126465,
0.0271288212,
-0.0287580397,
-0.0009605337,
-0.0349207334,
0.0733613893,
-0.0745730773,
0.0294278823,
-0.0685757101,
0.0040314132,
0.0725334734,
-0.0195313431,
-0.0223116577,
0.0237129126,
-0.073186554,
-0.0610275678,
-0.0165051203,
0.0531317405,
0.008129851,
0.0791447684,
-0.0404207967,
-0.0459251963,
-0.0058108997,
0.0672465935,
-0.0124831535,
0.021850463,
-0.0035293582,
0.0109501584,
-0.0068487613,
0.0564400293,
-0.0614218861,
0.0246892888,
0.050494168,
0.0208655428,
-0.0150495507,
-0.0743020475,
0.0008135724,
0.0181136802,
0.0751490965,
-0.0240218788,
-0.0119609963,
-0.0389049016,
0.0346620791,
-0.0010459216,
-0.0476214103,
-0.0022648426,
-0.0039064405,
0.0041993638,
-0.0020564124,
-0.0242704917,
0.010125611,
-0.0047534094,
0.0381104015,
-0.0156342462,
0.0019238436,
-0.0096098101,
0.0181223825,
0.0091697387,
-0.0112822773,
-0.0389066935,
0.0132216783,
0.0153165162,
0.0422306359,
-0.0353001654,
0.0288620163,
0.0349737965,
0.005252663,
-0.0661553368,
0.038385585,
-0.0297589134,
-0.0207562465,
-0.0084025329,
0.0403596945,
0.0621216558,
-0.0320026837,
-0.0264212564,
-0.0127748773,
-0.0383227989,
0.0006040713,
0.0259579383,
-0.0015641417,
-0.0065800934,
0.0509166457,
0.0158241708,
-0.0430390313,
0.0011846118,
0.0266417935,
0.0313951857,
0.0419581346,
0.0067203566,
-0.000018291,
-0.0325412489,
0.0060169161,
0.000694055,
0.0170696899,
0.0031490014,
0.0324201323,
-0.0422085822,
-0.0670354888,
0.0088114282,
0.0243756101,
-0.0241307952,
0.0339786895,
0.0373181961,
0.061973758,
0.0007489115,
-0.0448936112,
-0.0141161252,
-0.0120228464,
0.0517923832,
-0.0275280159,
0.0039173737,
-6.599984949e-33,
-0.0369367115,
-0.0239566565,
0.01580582,
0.0097543877,
-0.038355194,
-0.0221973602,
-0.0055542109,
-0.032147292,
-0.0405445918,
-0.0037716147,
-0.0206224453,
-0.014100871,
0.0185442511,
0.0160320885,
-0.0050155944,
-0.0288802534,
0.0411618799,
0.0215141401,
-0.0240519345,
-0.0176769774,
0.0208895914,
0.0407245681,
0.0743857473,
-0.0182880796,
-0.012940309,
0.0007847813,
0.0089429794,
0.055827599,
-0.038173452,
0.044580508,
0.0072153341,
0.0398665965,
0.0383379832,
-0.0387495384,
0.0162145477,
0.063359946,
-0.1054092497,
-0.044264283,
0.0320600346,
0.010686771,
-0.0096987272,
-0.0275715366,
0.0332114697,
-0.0089045158,
-0.0183657948,
0.0044571902,
0.0276224501,
-0.0318123028,
-0.0134548675,
-0.0291228611,
-0.0475726649,
0.0290871579,
0.0169409718,
-0.0196540505,
0.0120049603,
0.0014642386,
0.0269949175,
0.0538368113,
-0.0312800594,
-0.003304234,
0.0323600881,
0.0481874123,
0.0380110703,
0.0588686168,
-0.0108089866,
0.0435143523,
0.0123435948,
-0.0004234473,
-0.0195650645,
-0.0006097182,
0.036575716,
0.0454791747,
0.0185735561,
0.0268176831,
0.0251185764,
-0.0275960192,
-0.0745735988,
-0.0021757074,
0.0220801365,
0.0197356008,
-0.0140950764,
0.0095349476,
-0.0252789352,
-0.0223750621,
-0.0812932253,
0.0008251917,
-0.0430033058,
0.030154543,
0.0552633926,
0.035232421,
-0.0151770208,
-0.0097105773,
0.0236236397,
-0.0311765168,
-0.0122876195,
-0.0224951766,
0.0287281126,
-0.0109645193,
-0.0240243729,
0.0292919874,
-0.040361546,
-0.0539058335,
0.017871676,
-0.0290723946,
0.0091634905,
-0.0156262051,
0.0783734396,
-0.0125893187,
-0.0644796044,
0.0218215771,
-0.0116490824,
-0.0048589972,
-0.0126497298,
-0.0040340615,
0.0437634513,
0.0409669578,
-0.0027409254,
0.093646735,
0.0517603308,
-0.0156902727,
-0.0161042791,
0.0040583345,
-0.0050949682,
0.0267630406,
-0.0142678022,
0.014913613,
-0.009770371,
0.0230052341,
0.0034399703,
-0.0628316402,
0.0056179836,
0.0212492049,
2.745e-7,
0.0474643484,
0.0600255206,
-0.0124253454,
0.0135538364,
0.0062751044,
0.0395881385,
0.0101341344,
0.0124961901,
0.0364094488,
-0.0411961414,
0.0148358131,
0.0318039246,
0.036241103,
-0.0073789856,
-0.1011270508,
0.0337959602,
-0.0593820997,
0.042364195,
-0.0719115585,
0.0078391079,
0.0447347984,
0.1305888295,
0.0478087962,
-0.0139903883,
-0.0145554803,
-0.0441440307,
0.0329171941,
-0.0385924429,
-0.0157195292,
0.0445178561,
0.0189604145,
0.0343378372,
0.0287825596,
0.0378626697,
-0.0325194858,
0.0490080491,
-0.0220590141,
0.0851109326,
-0.0165284835,
-0.0060617225,
-0.0095744543,
-0.0134240454,
-0.0216859989,
-0.0360999405,
0.0982638523,
-0.0630623847,
0.0131377531,
-0.0558906645,
0.0060647121,
-0.0059454208,
0.0242347345,
-0.0272299387,
-0.0330061316,
0.0357604213,
0.0401930101,
0.0053355019,
-0.0582578778,
-0.1226180345,
-0.0196177866,
0.007749727,
-0.0615862906,
-0.0321911685,
-0.0165362637,
-0.0153081138,
0.0547263101,
-0.0640511885,
-0.007661914,
2.604428268e-34,
0.0189031567,
-0.0258870982,
0.0322977379,
0.0218914077,
0.0442078188,
0.0014508703,
-0.0039417814,
0.0149679733,
0.0321859829,
-0.0902030841,
0.0025875799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14197v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14197v3 | Benchmarking and Defending Against Indirect Prompt Injection Attacks on Large Language Models | 2023-12-21T01:08:39 | 2024-03-08T07:58:48 | Jingwei Yi, Yueqi Xie, Bin Zhu, Emre Kiciman, Guangzhong Sun, Xing Xie, Fangzhao Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The integration of large language models (LLMs) with external content has
enabled more up-to-date and wide-ranging applications of LLMs, such as
Microsoft Copilot. However, this integration has also exposed LLMs to the risk
of indirect prompt injection attacks, where an attacker can embed malicious
instructions within external content, compromising LLM output and causing
responses to deviate from user expectations. To investigate this important but
underexplored issue, we introduce the first benchmark for indirect prompt
injection attacks, named BIPIA, to evaluate the risk of such attacks. Based on
the evaluation, our work makes a key analysis of the underlying reason for the
success of the attack, namely the inability of LLMs to distinguish between
instructions and external content and the absence of LLMs' awareness to not
execute instructions within external content. Building upon this analysis, we
develop two black-box methods based on prompt learning and a white-box defense
method based on fine-tuning with adversarial training accordingly. Experimental
results demonstrate that black-box defenses are highly effective in mitigating
these attacks, while the white-box defense reduces the attack success rate to
near-zero levels. Overall, our work systematically investigates indirect prompt
injection attacks by introducing a benchmark, analyzing the underlying reason
for the success of the attack, and developing an initial set of defenses. | [
0.0195684545,
0.034865059,
-0.0157122221,
0.0506987944,
-0.0203644559,
-0.0006806608,
0.032029558,
0.0009220569,
0.0388038941,
-0.0342973582,
-0.009446932,
-0.014069315,
0.0156116458,
0.0275880788,
0.0871881768,
0.0207899101,
0.0637598708,
-0.037319418,
-0.0381873809,
-0.0024154799,
-0.0090330681,
-0.0261621308,
-0.0059454371,
0.0298911445,
0.0092070624,
-0.0097000366,
-0.0349531732,
0.0399841778,
0.0113259517,
-0.014826878,
0.0000738406,
0.0088438131,
0.0157749821,
0.0757065192,
0.0000021632,
-0.0460805446,
-0.0255080201,
0.0292546488,
-0.06650915,
0.0565399714,
-0.0272387117,
0.001990479,
-0.0412828363,
0.0422082096,
0.0022324133,
0.0398568399,
0.0281002987,
0.0480299369,
0.0837839395,
0.0848657638,
0.0087104701,
0.0375203565,
0.0390099585,
-0.0292141531,
-0.0086415485,
-0.017796455,
0.0105975606,
-0.0395493358,
0.005124385,
0.0369735397,
0.0082542505,
-0.0123520466,
0.0320140608,
-0.0136854835,
-0.0679422989,
0.0338334665,
0.0183779411,
-0.0020563544,
-0.0435299873,
0.0400368385,
-0.0732979923,
0.0109942146,
0.00267673,
-0.0173644125,
0.0114509575,
-0.0076766494,
0.0041338294,
0.0282354038,
-0.0108639812,
-0.0304067675,
-0.0048276964,
-0.0144915674,
0.0280771442,
0.0025792595,
-0.0193460118,
0.0497931093,
0.0341313519,
-0.0389096029,
0.0236088485,
-0.0476260185,
0.0175856072,
-0.0671219379,
-0.035337694,
0.0372489654,
-0.027196357,
0.0163066443,
-0.071971342,
-0.0098442677,
0.0487262197,
-0.0191156566,
0.0541300327,
0.0470198691,
-0.0453401878,
0.0258140881,
-0.0265243631,
0.0669120997,
-0.0406444035,
0.049800545,
0.0524650887,
0.0417006947,
-0.0131283868,
-0.0217978004,
-0.0129710017,
0.0282268748,
-0.0004085268,
0.0170483589,
-0.0204781946,
0.065977335,
-0.0213543568,
0.0811811537,
-0.0257771499,
-0.0290232617,
-0.0151768541,
0.0172365978,
0.0293101016,
-0.0320034847,
0.0001522495,
-0.0213598516,
-0.0159288235,
-0.1015689895,
-0.0315272026,
0.0057796915,
-0.0684344321,
-0.0149972495,
-0.0032511265,
0.1138597578,
0.0374867059,
-0.0187807865,
-0.034275502,
-0.1066773683,
-0.0234355703,
-0.0295523368,
-0.0095855054,
-0.0585953183,
-0.0220478959,
-0.028418025,
-0.023236217,
-0.0541489646,
0.0017172467,
0.0071250475,
-0.0283656307,
0.0710821599,
0.0104662068,
-0.0356222652,
0.0335781351,
0.0416418537,
-0.0040177014,
0.0411246009,
-0.0106049441,
0.0637580752,
0.0375045948,
-0.0235748626,
0.0326190852,
0.0512325726,
0.0170468856,
0.0404645577,
-0.0144263804,
0.0313866474,
0.0899756476,
-0.0114297802,
-0.0121367313,
0.0547485389,
0.0028772934,
-0.0371000543,
0.0874227136,
0.0034892478,
-0.0646253899,
-0.019582795,
0.0454367846,
0.0284507331,
0.0026900505,
0.0022803801,
-0.0584458411,
-0.0111442367,
-0.0457298681,
-0.0214293227,
0.035798464,
0.0202151109,
-0.005974018,
-0.0060703387,
0.022657644,
-0.0323771797,
-0.0332444608,
0.0144498963,
0.0188931599,
0.0050302269,
-0.0283364467,
0.0118944887,
0.0251601208,
-0.0036651571,
-0.0308103785,
-0.077732563,
-0.0327702053,
0.0300898198,
0.0476654731,
-0.0297047347,
-0.005928304,
-0.0303068906,
0.000114941,
0.0280819777,
0.0296872165,
0.0212467238,
-0.0028322539,
-0.0185314268,
-0.018061351,
-0.0342738293,
0.0106554814,
0.0455963537,
0.0044051227,
0.0021369618,
0.0176401697,
0.0489448979,
-0.0036181237,
0.0395759679,
-0.030800283,
-0.0832807347,
-0.004811544,
0.0394770466,
0.0052799527,
0.007380195,
-0.0213984437,
0.030891357,
0.0542499088,
0.0111592347,
-0.0198467094,
-0.0468461551,
-0.036835596,
0.0234771445,
0.051454287,
0.0235820916,
-0.008319742,
0.0112648671,
-0.0255563911,
-0.0212455001,
0.0276025049,
-0.0506612062,
0.0018699578,
0.0011581484,
0.0080027804,
0.0015822934,
0.0277737286,
-0.0512504987,
0.0141885653,
-0.0016377881,
-0.0057731471,
0.0376582183,
0.0438945517,
0.0216959063,
-0.0290815681,
-0.0490686558,
0.0092766685,
-0.0301844962,
-0.0016925943,
-0.0160863698,
-0.0362132974,
-0.0045116907,
-0.0143293794,
-0.0451471433,
0.008887806,
-0.0127994204,
0.022178866,
0.0456471704,
0.0226651244,
-0.0211135205,
-0.0201861635,
-0.0137328859,
-0.019586904,
-0.017814165,
0.0289065633,
0.0214532167,
0.0012906682,
-0.0263004061,
-0.0248396136,
0.0035601202,
-0.0284862425,
0.0472136401,
-0.0151633052,
-0.0082986159,
-0.0375508741,
0.0424595401,
-0.0009944681,
0.0287592988,
-0.040458411,
-0.0429558195,
0.0466812029,
-0.0013521641,
-0.0007273949,
0.0858061686,
0.0228095688,
0.0049621286,
0.0790125653,
0.0069889203,
-0.0669055805,
-0.0096914135,
0.0323943086,
-0.0413580686,
-0.0349463411,
-0.0208089203,
0.039705094,
0.0730320662,
0.0500398166,
0.0032620323,
-0.0289893821,
0.0293395389,
-0.0151735619,
-0.0169406254,
-0.0319905281,
-0.0704417452,
-0.053621199,
0.0099157551,
-0.0081651872,
-0.0829117969,
0.085817568,
-0.0883239657,
0.0218542274,
0.0134474216,
-0.0298588779,
0.0105100693,
0.0105571086,
-0.0130874114,
-0.0063250405,
0.0321510807,
-0.0385065377,
-0.0767777264,
-0.0178819615,
0.0469958112,
-0.0217041206,
0.0138920564,
-0.0062780636,
-0.030374866,
-0.0267629307,
-0.0185435284,
-0.0634028837,
-0.0824824572,
-0.0285960715,
-0.005075125,
0.0141331749,
-0.0354397632,
0.0130115869,
-0.0351471938,
0.0525604412,
0.0183387939,
-0.0245823245,
-0.0148231303,
-0.0475443378,
-0.0152164409,
0.0370325297,
-0.051539544,
-0.0143070202,
-0.0272851437,
0.0551765338,
0.0523699708,
0.015756432,
-0.0150798177,
-0.031298697,
-0.0159061011,
-0.0004354762,
-0.0129289599,
-0.0062986296,
0.063360922,
0.0295309667,
-0.0439150818,
-0.0141055929,
0.0657598078,
0.0255429372,
-0.0366389528,
-0.0009601549,
-0.0208684299,
0.0024894627,
0.0239989646,
0.0340220667,
-0.0684516653,
-0.0137568498,
0.0255642813,
0.0457808003,
-0.0143712321,
-0.0114176851,
-0.0119827101,
-0.1465279758,
0.0005715765,
-0.0019929761,
-0.006952154,
-0.0255824961,
-0.0342858247,
-0.0110387933,
0.0604718775,
0.0245917663,
-0.022303097,
0.0055288365,
-0.00745722,
0.0264485609,
-0.0359830968,
-0.0167257898,
0.0222403854,
-0.0399410464,
0.0409275256,
0.0673316196,
-0.0333330706,
-0.0256697647,
0.0360650495,
0.0794999301,
-0.0358709805,
-0.006316998,
0.0299288221,
0.0531323105,
0.0156841185,
-0.0110314712,
0.0309421122,
0.0234644525,
-0.0005042729,
-0.0067336527,
0.0546150692,
0.0515199825,
-0.0333704054,
0.0246430691,
-0.0165239945,
-0.0021175919,
0.0555800572,
0.0453425646,
0.0266234223,
-0.0442378819,
-0.0106859664,
-0.0780695975,
-0.0022463209,
0.0013175099,
-0.0475075468,
0.0364573412,
0.0129238628,
-0.0445837937,
-0.0375244841,
-0.0235540941,
-0.0208328553,
0.0265573133,
0.05848727,
-0.0192217492,
-0.0239649098,
0.0034597481,
-0.0212759878,
-0.0182521734,
-0.0307920519,
0.0633025989,
-0.0676328018,
0.0492981225,
-0.0145381419,
-0.0208202396,
-0.0205025431,
0.0055661695,
-0.0536708906,
-0.103028208,
0.00559921,
0.0659324899,
0.0208026022,
0.0229400266,
-0.04433842,
-0.0548576191,
0.0718627125,
0.0345771648,
-0.0313850939,
-0.0016771117,
0.0628252774,
-0.0211588368,
0.0138712414,
-0.0046308148,
-0.0421242155,
-0.0360416248,
0.0966121182,
-0.039601773,
-0.0241597556,
-0.0451709665,
0.0069110603,
0.0451332331,
0.0533542,
-0.0238145813,
0.0293106958,
0.0155922538,
0.033235874,
-0.0213143807,
-0.0255776495,
0.0183045696,
0.0131986476,
-0.0037715172,
-0.0084022619,
0.0364474095,
-0.0318750031,
0.0110291867,
0.0321837664,
-0.0050991038,
0.0334147215,
0.0391651466,
0.0657585263,
0.0521534085,
0.0018120259,
-0.0181557648,
0.0602195598,
0.0194779728,
0.0471485853,
-0.0251687486,
0.0640767962,
-0.0018642549,
0.0117988614,
-0.0204141848,
0.0412782058,
-0.0526858531,
-0.0439839661,
0.0425544679,
0.0266388692,
0.0187571682,
-0.0033543999,
-0.0144443959,
-0.0003336241,
0.011429443,
-0.0314415209,
-0.0132950312,
-0.0081046438,
-0.0405207835,
0.0365606956,
0.0070067677,
-0.0098379552,
0.0382794514,
0.0606893152,
-0.0237397552,
0.0611805245,
0.0100187697,
-0.0158456825,
-0.0537084974,
0.0164404679,
0.0530974902,
0.004557434,
-0.0486904606,
-0.042902153,
-0.0634526387,
-0.0732276365,
-0.0104092378,
0.0219536237,
0.0114514669,
0.0249028001,
0.004222583,
0.0293935183,
0.0252928492,
0.0481541753,
-0.0649074838,
0.0647418499,
0.0115142809,
-0.065500617,
0.0124783404,
-5.593264036e-33,
-0.0086560966,
-0.0330308639,
-0.0313329548,
-0.0128658647,
0.0175708495,
0.022886835,
-0.0252434332,
-0.0084887408,
-0.0217790473,
-0.033148583,
-0.0246866699,
-0.0212847833,
0.0132697793,
-0.0067073889,
-0.0230463725,
-0.030314181,
-0.0082299132,
-0.0100048129,
-0.0418793894,
0.0381185748,
0.0643745363,
0.0121812634,
-0.0119889416,
-0.0613650717,
0.0404130854,
-0.0146726007,
-0.0131353,
-0.0092032235,
-0.0333557203,
0.074633792,
-0.0026272414,
0.0091690477,
0.0013309999,
-0.0321212858,
-0.0048252894,
0.0855719671,
0.0083347987,
-0.0205502883,
-0.0242239852,
-0.0032578018,
0.0040464806,
-0.0832553431,
0.0083374754,
-0.0383616984,
0.0150500769,
-0.0000600499,
0.0092446608,
-0.0042429822,
-0.0241336841,
-0.0165055376,
-0.0445957631,
-0.0023369319,
-0.0247861985,
0.000107456,
-0.0022375477,
0.0118575757,
0.0378720909,
-0.010284313,
-0.0260735638,
0.0352996886,
0.0105741676,
0.0392286256,
0.0334568173,
0.0149717983,
-0.0029508015,
0.0436340682,
-0.0057188752,
0.0006745785,
0.0118028745,
0.0158996359,
0.0079737203,
0.0151601546,
0.0608662628,
0.0436476767,
-0.0034858864,
-0.0254014824,
-0.0679053143,
0.0250576157,
0.04763183,
0.0105884122,
0.0285012852,
-0.0228240937,
-0.0773566291,
0.0144589553,
-0.0198408701,
-0.0147715975,
-0.0246434044,
-0.0279915612,
0.0274283271,
-0.0031809458,
-0.0053225644,
-0.046433948,
0.0288707726,
-0.0594501235,
0.02037994,
-0.0013238189,
-0.0179648474,
-0.0308272261,
-0.0009538752,
0.0100664888,
-0.0072548492,
-0.0219362713,
0.0093609076,
-0.0731436834,
0.0418885052,
0.0086587165,
0.0053397203,
0.0375870764,
-0.091562815,
-0.0063823736,
-0.0401268266,
0.0305641368,
0.0253351349,
0.040934898,
0.0389574021,
-0.0191510823,
-0.0091267554,
0.0060378099,
0.0085992664,
-0.055129312,
-0.0235099774,
0.0092484606,
-0.0151310489,
0.0162451956,
-0.0257558227,
0.0251424648,
-0.0016128521,
0.0734507442,
0.0226797275,
-0.0485568754,
-0.0052633095,
-0.0279219225,
2.931e-7,
-0.0086590871,
0.0168745872,
0.0424394235,
0.050334122,
0.0235226639,
0.0646144077,
-0.0380740352,
0.066853337,
-0.0149261709,
-0.0419283062,
-0.023551153,
-0.0083416896,
0.0398102477,
0.0139869563,
-0.0657287389,
-0.0109296711,
-0.0766048729,
0.0160985161,
-0.0810219944,
0.0050538904,
0.0516945943,
0.1125118881,
-0.0133281425,
-0.0218828712,
-0.002360723,
-0.0529406406,
0.0052872323,
-0.0035699066,
-0.0104711642,
-0.031501133,
0.0493036918,
0.0191980954,
0.0020838862,
0.0609933287,
-0.0468064398,
0.0047926866,
-0.0386446305,
0.0471118614,
0.0391695127,
-0.0172359757,
-0.008786262,
-0.0505497791,
0.0005604475,
-0.0509964041,
0.0645383075,
0.007794762,
-0.009843572,
-0.0183747821,
-0.0357444175,
-0.0576924346,
0.0290314499,
-0.0324426703,
0.0093108779,
0.0208323374,
-0.0082854936,
-0.0122607341,
0.0400627069,
-0.0446157977,
-0.0369943529,
-0.0184986014,
-0.019829331,
-0.0574596748,
-0.012472352,
0.0306326952,
0.0338820256,
-0.0011201599,
0.0042284802,
3.057848811e-34,
-0.0285101198,
-0.0533619374,
0.0394670852,
-0.0264505167,
0.030343676,
0.0156539679,
-0.0181212984,
0.0223332588,
0.0298339892,
-0.0342310816,
-0.0296358708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13495v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13495v1 | Decoupling Representation and Knowledge for Few-Shot Intent Classification and Slot Filling | 2023-12-21T00:16:21 | 2023-12-21T00:16:21 | Jie Han, Yixiong Zou, Haozhao Wang, Jun Wang, Wei Liu, Yao Wu, Tao Zhang, Ruixuan Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Few-shot intent classification and slot filling are important but challenging
tasks due to the scarcity of finely labeled data. Therefore, current works
first train a model on source domains with sufficiently labeled data, and then
transfer the model to target domains where only rarely labeled data is
available. However, experience transferring as a whole usually suffers from
gaps that exist among source domains and target domains. For instance,
transferring domain-specific-knowledge-related experience is difficult. To
tackle this problem, we propose a new method that explicitly decouples the
transferring of general-semantic-representation-related experience and the
domain-specific-knowledge-related experience. Specifically, for
domain-specific-knowledge-related experience, we design two modules to capture
intent-slot relation and slot-slot relation respectively. Extensive experiments
on Snips and FewJoint datasets show that our method achieves state-of-the-art
performance. The method improves the joint accuracy metric from 27.72% to
42.20% in the 1-shot setting, and from 46.54% to 60.79% in the 5-shot setting. | [
0.024271762,
0.046749901,
-0.0034132334,
0.0097480956,
-0.0193317719,
0.0234560277,
0.0122792264,
-0.0197343342,
-0.0209090486,
-0.0717244446,
-0.0565710291,
-0.0015625488,
-0.0068815756,
0.0069252164,
-0.0275849961,
-0.0207569413,
0.0559118614,
0.0231599454,
-0.0126065044,
0.0535674952,
-0.0190161914,
0.0194074977,
-0.0325006656,
0.0385368094,
0.0003592782,
-0.0274068527,
-0.0329766348,
0.0254206881,
0.0489550866,
-0.028251864,
0.0264597479,
0.052909229,
0.0433889516,
0.0121854013,
0.0000020221,
-0.0464616455,
-0.0364669748,
-0.0097905425,
-0.0816381648,
-0.0264992379,
0.0065549663,
-0.0085096508,
0.0322214961,
-0.008271913,
-0.0032419597,
-0.0531521663,
0.0213683639,
0.0373618416,
0.012781661,
0.039858792,
-0.0260479376,
-0.0305998735,
-0.0049985647,
-0.0430291705,
0.0673822165,
-0.0481945276,
0.0552786067,
0.003537121,
-0.0287993401,
0.0146789635,
-0.0216338933,
-0.009376416,
0.0013578669,
0.0201846827,
0.0357548371,
0.0126475943,
0.0221115425,
-0.0049214498,
-0.0048650489,
0.056541048,
-0.0077494774,
0.0085135531,
0.0061074053,
-0.0470424145,
0.0057365322,
-0.0297705438,
-0.0147445137,
-0.0178443082,
0.0098283058,
-0.0034337468,
0.0062612011,
0.0470345095,
0.0064527104,
0.0152838081,
-0.0117560895,
0.0111465398,
-0.0026116911,
-0.0108196847,
0.0132133448,
-0.0056920806,
0.0268779155,
-0.0544074625,
-0.0497928001,
0.0162240565,
-0.0145312324,
0.0160353146,
-0.0471476018,
0.0176129807,
0.011955101,
0.0390109718,
0.0311404821,
0.0446861796,
-0.0199918058,
0.0731280297,
-0.0140438592,
0.0049681892,
0.0419797227,
0.0259101689,
-0.0754531622,
0.0041433442,
-0.1159099787,
-0.0018037915,
-0.0190093145,
0.0586806089,
-0.0341706015,
-0.0026788372,
-0.0378833264,
0.0085437438,
-0.0159892868,
-0.0178981964,
-0.0295469481,
0.0174578559,
-0.0314779244,
0.0174898654,
-0.0355283357,
0.0723833963,
-0.0175461248,
0.0556940101,
0.0094179148,
-0.0058908942,
-0.0316057652,
0.0166568775,
0.0087801898,
-0.0688675269,
0.0047012633,
0.0569492392,
-0.0141243767,
-0.0744710937,
-0.0417088531,
-0.032992322,
-0.0162483845,
-0.0452143028,
-0.0109539302,
-0.0395594463,
0.068678759,
0.0014174446,
0.0130471038,
-0.0481007025,
-0.0070136711,
-0.0019860021,
-0.0330479816,
0.0995398462,
0.0051749218,
-0.0036386456,
-0.0122147985,
0.0299550146,
-0.0213887747,
0.051435139,
-0.0348512456,
0.0447733328,
-0.0141537422,
0.0211241525,
0.0055066459,
-0.0269071944,
0.0296914428,
-0.0107855471,
0.0462226979,
0.0073895473,
0.0225126259,
0.0038213592,
0.0572022125,
-0.0155006275,
-0.0693594441,
-0.0092578335,
0.0175878722,
0.0069415155,
0.0432439819,
-0.0288959183,
0.0217755251,
0.0337897129,
-0.0044662342,
-0.0050674803,
-0.0618828312,
0.0432400517,
0.0130323758,
-0.0386273041,
-0.0188660678,
0.0052418481,
-0.0460933074,
0.0141179496,
0.020558916,
-0.051677905,
0.033441741,
-0.0156277698,
0.0529679805,
0.0156953316,
-0.004665819,
0.0690414682,
0.0458009355,
0.0466123112,
-0.0119597176,
-0.0501698516,
-0.0031577868,
0.0030429263,
-0.0178579912,
-0.0377211198,
-0.0712553188,
-0.0499559008,
-0.0177402534,
-0.0333810635,
0.0379638039,
-0.0405861512,
0.0665981099,
0.0026908312,
-0.0609917007,
-0.0316599756,
0.0120390635,
0.0093598282,
0.0164215565,
0.0033635406,
0.0402854234,
-0.0324500464,
0.0901132151,
0.0126965335,
-0.0076991739,
-0.0341541171,
0.0259037558,
0.0266703237,
0.0489252545,
0.0231918022,
0.0309849009,
-0.0373011157,
-0.0049603535,
-0.013735041,
-0.0189930312,
0.0164325815,
-0.0385736972,
-0.0779193714,
0.0246935077,
0.0093060555,
-0.0220715739,
-0.0076393285,
-0.0455075279,
-0.0243666749,
-0.0108492896,
0.0457483605,
-0.0002431774,
-0.0697382316,
-0.0105644669,
0.0261248183,
0.0087674214,
-0.0284730624,
0.079616718,
0.0306842141,
-0.019399263,
0.0420455709,
-0.0409288928,
0.0394448154,
-0.0018333023,
0.0041607604,
-0.0630028099,
-0.0512188785,
0.0119222216,
-0.0175184812,
0.0143537512,
-0.068531476,
0.0133358696,
-0.0714838356,
0.0208055358,
0.0363765322,
0.0024591328,
-0.0024208042,
0.0058063855,
0.0227491446,
0.0059621544,
-0.0178487506,
0.0113057746,
-0.0383107066,
0.0117840478,
0.0205208976,
0.0260847379,
0.0145273106,
-0.0022541545,
0.048979044,
-0.0208531413,
0.0205015838,
-0.0495428145,
0.0023590531,
-0.0306015983,
0.0021051511,
-0.0048695486,
-0.0016916922,
0.0041401559,
-0.0338842757,
-0.0278231166,
-0.0008480576,
-0.083090663,
0.0234136265,
-0.039016638,
0.044618573,
0.03984759,
-0.0097783096,
-0.0609845407,
0.0317525193,
-0.010176179,
0.0294231717,
-0.0070719034,
0.0428763479,
0.0021689381,
0.0657867864,
0.0056321332,
0.0095450114,
-0.0424161032,
-0.0055952393,
-0.0146829579,
-0.0301947854,
-0.0434393287,
0.0292916745,
-0.0145184817,
-0.0149726197,
-0.0290618595,
0.0099673225,
0.0480982214,
0.040841762,
0.0001596834,
-0.0188156366,
0.0055859052,
-0.0092722261,
0.0609674715,
-0.0251163971,
0.0461564884,
0.0630086288,
-0.0220849272,
-0.0436004959,
-0.0309305713,
0.0029622565,
0.0112983594,
0.0268760584,
-0.020017935,
0.0149880368,
-0.03852446,
-0.0549214892,
-0.0389921702,
-0.0657440722,
-0.0105334502,
0.0218207184,
-0.0275866874,
0.0061376607,
-0.0389594287,
-0.0167136658,
0.0219408628,
0.016620297,
0.0188899729,
-0.0290830173,
0.0043361206,
0.0443441421,
0.0475913659,
0.0071319845,
-0.0699123964,
0.0122052943,
0.0234576203,
0.0590482913,
-0.0249235928,
0.0532725081,
-0.0012754835,
0.0301031116,
0.0244730636,
-0.0110692466,
-0.0250442214,
0.005839684,
0.0590084866,
0.0076340991,
0.0058074361,
0.099210754,
0.0351344459,
-0.0355547033,
-0.0147502255,
-0.0136438739,
-0.0133491158,
0.0250734836,
0.0149822691,
-0.0870214254,
-0.075654842,
-0.0159991458,
-0.0016068395,
0.0062503805,
-0.0143513605,
0.0088611171,
-0.1123451144,
0.0202684831,
0.015344074,
-0.0860584825,
-0.0119745927,
-0.0104271881,
0.0367030799,
-0.0031435152,
-0.0298936479,
-0.0154060619,
0.0026653886,
-0.0294139385,
0.0327691324,
0.0179238636,
-0.0577658452,
0.0558490567,
-0.018183995,
0.0828722417,
0.0023939654,
0.0289666187,
0.01280462,
0.0256471857,
-0.0444608219,
-0.0226576347,
0.0184479766,
-0.0174863953,
0.0697517619,
-0.0485582352,
0.0094550857,
0.0374650583,
0.0334551819,
-0.0626290366,
-0.0839045122,
-0.00765434,
0.0618146919,
0.0018878499,
0.0360180438,
-0.0239904486,
-0.0384682082,
0.0312375296,
0.0913576111,
0.0057207374,
-0.0393848084,
0.0118227117,
0.017823711,
-0.0223498717,
-0.0162506327,
0.0060441406,
0.0573444963,
-0.0035877167,
-0.029591864,
-0.0415916033,
-0.0361591764,
0.0601643026,
0.037066672,
0.0077120699,
0.0418973267,
-0.0117527973,
-0.002231285,
-0.0442451648,
-0.0210136287,
-0.041486118,
0.0346543975,
0.0017617804,
0.001377885,
0.0433239825,
-0.0621737652,
-0.0210488159,
-0.0280032624,
-0.0679990351,
-0.0148938615,
-0.0105558569,
0.0496975183,
0.0204498097,
0.0479538664,
-0.0414198861,
0.0267515816,
0.0385970697,
0.0608636551,
-0.02008898,
0.0029728503,
0.0463367552,
0.0200776625,
-0.0307162032,
0.0139646279,
-0.0486735217,
0.0103744091,
0.0399902761,
-0.0139284404,
-0.0433345661,
0.006722481,
0.0488363989,
-0.0144456653,
0.068610698,
0.0024100794,
-0.0249912199,
-0.0223284308,
0.0147456946,
-0.0099456953,
-0.0077263578,
-0.0538252555,
-0.0550259948,
0.0438024774,
0.0140397232,
0.0138901062,
-0.0484997928,
0.0264758412,
0.031251289,
-0.0281174313,
-0.0494767763,
0.0310123488,
-0.0141964527,
-0.0205461569,
0.0095945131,
-0.0242608376,
-0.0283628926,
0.015854558,
-0.0137148174,
-0.0408495218,
0.0945743993,
0.0358124115,
0.0073249559,
0.0140497666,
0.0336759612,
0.0018369198,
0.0026137203,
-0.036267899,
-0.0250184312,
0.0404559039,
-0.0376402885,
-0.0079723876,
0.0199505873,
0.0071661612,
-0.0188875683,
0.0724092424,
-0.0190008059,
-0.0107286284,
0.0237594433,
0.0171219483,
-0.0024532094,
-0.0024640623,
0.0780078247,
-0.0303023346,
0.0650039241,
-0.0008763003,
0.0052890438,
-0.0465227179,
0.0123219043,
0.0447229445,
0.0396929085,
-0.0271755531,
0.0032293752,
-0.0563798063,
-0.0408796705,
-0.0117546665,
-0.0496610813,
0.0010594319,
0.035099335,
0.0460353605,
0.023061404,
-0.0015043872,
-0.0588405058,
-0.0385308266,
-0.0442308411,
0.0160221662,
0.0236225035,
0.004842977,
-5.973999677e-33,
-0.0206317194,
0.037314482,
-0.0130955884,
-0.01249009,
-0.0213292073,
-0.0000448801,
0.0027736798,
-0.0265380498,
-0.0158826113,
0.0022624834,
0.014721089,
-0.0196899697,
0.0001401196,
0.011922651,
0.0252998564,
-0.0065622451,
0.0373414122,
0.0083752107,
-0.0147268279,
0.0177955646,
0.0172595344,
0.0333010368,
0.0371877812,
-0.0914459899,
-0.0288985129,
0.0289606638,
-0.0246527512,
0.0087975962,
0.0099666733,
0.0530142523,
-0.0040731686,
0.0050916011,
0.0290257391,
-0.064019911,
0.0219145473,
-0.0284931492,
-0.1087868288,
-0.0541091785,
-0.0147286998,
-0.0099053578,
-0.0111077037,
-0.0178304128,
-0.0270736478,
0.0119843213,
0.0535668917,
-0.062450923,
-0.0020331796,
-0.0180210788,
-0.0292028747,
-0.0128722042,
-0.0704232305,
0.0046941005,
-0.0001834519,
-0.0501792096,
0.0130490018,
0.0301512871,
0.0153034767,
-0.031163726,
-0.0644067973,
-0.0145986453,
-0.052552022,
0.0105592245,
0.0062084603,
-0.0106044887,
-0.0238882154,
0.0835094675,
0.0077111633,
-0.0327903181,
0.0185225327,
0.0212666728,
-0.018897986,
0.0854698643,
-0.0501410477,
0.0558269136,
0.0743634403,
-0.0296304487,
-0.0509510897,
0.0525397323,
0.0039988016,
0.0461977236,
-0.0013673905,
0.0335112847,
-0.0291401688,
-0.0102779064,
-0.0030347398,
0.008898532,
-0.0325034074,
-0.0527499095,
0.0405084901,
0.038462162,
-0.0298119877,
0.018690506,
0.0372261405,
-0.06416931,
0.0208017342,
-0.0045583392,
-0.0037688888,
0.0228578728,
-0.0104137976,
-0.0294170156,
-0.07036639,
-0.0912142843,
0.0455845445,
0.0089376066,
0.037497703,
0.0284338705,
0.0690175667,
0.0360525846,
-0.0159421358,
-0.0206937529,
-0.0259002801,
-0.0122949751,
-0.0156703666,
0.0219402295,
0.0012189428,
0.0395966023,
-0.0361570269,
0.0151564535,
0.0323829539,
-0.0239109527,
-0.0164331812,
-0.0429442003,
0.0265138913,
0.0051982105,
0.0047036624,
-0.0258343071,
0.0117677534,
-0.0761118084,
0.0123364367,
-0.0151917264,
-0.0039456468,
-0.0109655531,
2.881e-7,
0.014105645,
0.0116293095,
-0.0538520366,
0.0193707477,
0.0095536495,
0.0792016312,
-0.0149149336,
0.0766235366,
0.015369473,
-0.0072294674,
0.0488535948,
0.013826834,
0.011637507,
0.0228653084,
-0.1038121879,
0.0400914811,
0.0622509681,
-0.0241616108,
-0.0268089343,
0.0283301901,
0.0813548863,
0.0896129236,
0.0710040405,
-0.0190736633,
0.0439822637,
-0.0069669583,
0.0459258817,
-0.0049808249,
0.0134740984,
0.010940956,
0.0178282578,
0.0248085037,
-0.0000242201,
0.076969184,
-0.0400884971,
-0.0067854025,
0.0178093482,
0.0454349592,
-0.0247548819,
-0.0245371498,
-0.0275918711,
0.020356426,
0.052763056,
-0.0370559618,
0.082803674,
-0.1068546772,
-0.022789957,
-0.0068085161,
-0.0591787584,
0.0335457139,
0.0007791878,
0.0605117902,
0.0036166629,
-0.023585327,
0.0240239818,
0.0283080097,
-0.0628088936,
-0.1000057682,
0.0015027588,
-0.0092233233,
0.0090021919,
-0.0269969776,
0.0215478409,
-0.0460729785,
0.027389545,
-0.0984083712,
-0.0175115243,
2.359684146e-34,
-0.0372273996,
0.0183049496,
0.0121336058,
0.034632694,
0.000725034,
0.0006117902,
-0.0085107768,
0.0052661761,
0.0171048585,
-0.0031357671,
0.0150524313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13437v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13437v1 | A General Model for Aggregating Annotations Across Simple, Complex, and Multi-Object Annotation Tasks | 2023-12-20T21:28:35 | 2023-12-20T21:28:35 | Alexander Braylan, Madalyn Marabella, Omar Alonso, Matthew Lease | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Human annotations are vital to supervised learning, yet annotators often
disagree on the correct label, especially as annotation tasks increase in
complexity. A strategy to improve label quality is to ask multiple annotators
to label the same item and aggregate their labels. Many aggregation models have
been proposed for categorical or numerical annotation tasks, but far less work
has considered more complex annotation tasks involving open-ended,
multivariate, or structured responses. While a variety of bespoke models have
been proposed for specific tasks, our work is the first to introduce
aggregation methods that generalize across many diverse complex tasks,
including sequence labeling, translation, syntactic parsing, ranking, bounding
boxes, and keypoints. This generality is achieved by devising a task-agnostic
method to model distances between labels rather than the labels themselves.
This article extends our prior work with investigation of three new research
questions. First, how do complex annotation properties impact aggregation
accuracy? Second, how should a task owner navigate the many modeling choices to
maximize aggregation accuracy? Finally, what diagnoses can verify that
aggregation models are specified correctly for the given data? To understand
how various factors impact accuracy and to inform model selection, we conduct
simulation studies and experiments on real, complex datasets. Regarding
testing, we introduce unit tests for aggregation models and present a suite of
such tests to ensure that a given model is not mis-specified and exhibits
expected behavior.
Beyond investigating these research questions above, we discuss the
foundational concept of annotation complexity, present a new aggregation model
as a bridge between traditional models and our own, and contribute a new
semi-supervised learning method for complex label aggregation that outperforms
prior work. | [
0.0311706457,
-0.0175902564,
0.0167679749,
0.0085521163,
0.0039368859,
0.0581824854,
0.0221720599,
-0.022650307,
0.0287831817,
-0.0594757646,
-0.0054964819,
-0.0301153064,
0.0318553559,
-0.0260394309,
0.0112079028,
-0.0540936477,
0.0351180211,
0.003101506,
0.0219339877,
0.0274971835,
0.0291588604,
0.0079636686,
-0.0227866992,
0.0437242761,
-0.0417674035,
-0.008932773,
-0.0190592464,
0.0073514292,
0.0162244197,
-0.0229080115,
0.0216253269,
0.0765533671,
-0.0045116995,
0.0436845198,
0.000001917,
-0.0300246663,
-0.0457879566,
0.0183623247,
-0.0240777191,
-0.0108154314,
0.0110186134,
-0.0124808075,
0.001085508,
0.0253428817,
-0.0064449543,
-0.0629708096,
0.0600832663,
0.0294939242,
0.0649150684,
0.0404901803,
-0.0207871832,
0.002217368,
0.0166062582,
-0.0320891999,
-0.0063829371,
-0.0567877144,
0.0031743934,
0.0422370993,
-0.0113117965,
0.0342257097,
0.0057652104,
0.0215687677,
0.0148731247,
-0.0128465025,
0.0264559425,
0.045438379,
-0.0479390621,
-0.0363673232,
-0.0105834892,
0.0518335365,
-0.0140870344,
0.0276149474,
0.0215754788,
-0.0205125175,
0.0324987695,
0.0086289411,
-0.0399120897,
-0.0024698144,
-0.0195821021,
-0.0180905703,
-0.0062424191,
0.0683290139,
-0.0243426654,
-0.003086206,
0.0008691279,
0.0294811036,
-0.0138756707,
-0.0243923403,
0.0135877179,
0.0370602272,
-0.0385815576,
-0.0803907141,
-0.0055396692,
0.0184264705,
-0.0158444475,
0.0030062504,
-0.028524952,
-0.0425485745,
0.0348363593,
-0.0410350673,
0.0258326493,
-0.0010611712,
-0.0373622738,
0.0686224326,
0.0267487019,
0.0409753919,
-0.0062661916,
0.0201109592,
-0.055688899,
-0.0128286658,
-0.0771556944,
0.0175527669,
0.0070192055,
0.0420848764,
-0.0116818855,
0.0191012379,
-0.0413562693,
0.004941158,
-0.0369492546,
0.0175562631,
-0.0047027259,
-0.0073976037,
0.0011640557,
0.0076850946,
-0.0256378036,
0.029544631,
-0.0405465178,
0.0224846192,
0.0212303475,
-0.0226437878,
0.01097003,
0.0081954543,
0.0031322325,
-0.0417842381,
-0.0368900336,
0.0430079624,
-0.0161307752,
-0.022888422,
-0.008836831,
-0.0508953333,
-0.0613492988,
-0.0368618146,
0.0309296548,
-0.0590244904,
0.0532033667,
-0.0076337997,
-0.0009980809,
-0.0215345453,
-0.0128268953,
-0.0037149815,
-0.001402551,
0.0543586686,
0.0160426777,
-0.0018706027,
0.0598371066,
0.0053910417,
-0.0203553792,
0.0497304648,
0.0290582106,
0.0175624192,
0.0176800974,
0.0051716464,
0.0304020159,
0.0257729217,
-0.0000727266,
0.0178436209,
0.0397123992,
-0.0281395372,
-0.0114463912,
-0.0281499773,
-0.0242982432,
0.0645480379,
-0.0431363359,
-0.0052411333,
0.0126899071,
0.0342573449,
-0.0232949797,
-0.0437886678,
-0.0047002328,
0.0298369937,
0.0212395974,
0.0484092534,
-0.0186460372,
0.0709440038,
-0.0170699619,
0.0056553278,
0.0626589134,
-0.0127291493,
-0.021961892,
-0.0945685357,
-0.0594990626,
-0.0126311118,
0.0111377314,
-0.0087679932,
0.0420451947,
-0.0110286884,
-0.0081653176,
0.0224724002,
0.0086888522,
-0.0841600224,
-0.0280413497,
-0.0065420019,
0.008098647,
0.0191487968,
0.0075180358,
-0.0509660207,
-0.0529944077,
-0.0073816334,
0.0217770934,
0.0126407184,
0.0462666601,
-0.0335211009,
-0.0181703232,
-0.0298530757,
-0.0924740583,
0.0473095067,
0.022192277,
0.0296633448,
-0.0020943615,
-0.0698439851,
0.0208091736,
-0.0155881317,
-0.0519340411,
0.0408467278,
0.0054559452,
-0.0094753765,
-0.0189297833,
0.0149639389,
0.0360384621,
0.0315009765,
-0.0040161852,
0.0334978849,
0.0585071482,
-0.0162127167,
-0.0241249297,
-0.0019210553,
-0.0042440589,
-0.0373338275,
0.0307160355,
0.0061217765,
-0.0442256182,
-0.0226300582,
-0.0422609486,
-0.0668897778,
-0.0390453972,
-0.0509001985,
-0.0085208323,
-0.0297644529,
0.010027485,
0.0267996527,
-0.0335831046,
-0.072149381,
0.0656928271,
-0.0179551262,
0.002079265,
-0.0238497704,
-0.025334185,
0.0112290001,
-0.0439579599,
-0.0281426199,
0.0042228671,
0.0107457284,
0.0189110655,
0.0692668632,
-0.0397740416,
-0.0615236349,
-0.028469665,
-0.1066833958,
0.0272365939,
-0.0109133683,
0.0138768321,
-0.0210682023,
-0.0131415864,
0.0062157796,
-0.0263800994,
-0.0282077882,
-0.0176960006,
-0.0211572368,
0.052612748,
0.0240499694,
0.0131745823,
0.0013096279,
-0.0697506219,
-0.0264359582,
-0.0413251147,
0.0357118025,
0.0217479635,
-0.068369925,
-0.0008154395,
0.010402442,
-0.0612581037,
0.0069382573,
0.0219367035,
-0.0005711926,
0.035309922,
-0.0130978888,
0.0220166128,
0.0388322696,
0.0062382924,
0.018926451,
0.0605329722,
-0.0193389002,
-0.0631499588,
0.0241948012,
-0.0061097275,
-0.0243276861,
0.0480902158,
-0.0267738979,
0.0026146742,
0.0912134647,
-0.0451434478,
-0.0076300385,
-0.0516156852,
-0.0187337678,
-0.0675467029,
-0.0098582776,
-0.042422235,
-0.0046510617,
-0.0040197163,
0.0622800216,
-0.0435863286,
-0.0423085466,
0.0556768589,
-0.0091475118,
-0.0114621716,
-0.0267884284,
0.002054743,
-0.0431349017,
0.0829194486,
0.0263326056,
0.0065982868,
0.0169452839,
0.005643358,
-0.0287980586,
0.0264072437,
0.0245258044,
-0.0538138859,
0.054114636,
-0.0552874915,
0.0381306596,
-0.0418649949,
-0.028945813,
-0.0057501709,
0.0028593121,
-0.004875205,
0.0089623993,
-0.0201023519,
0.0000686903,
-0.0488021001,
-0.021246437,
0.0169051308,
0.0668049976,
0.0073039024,
-0.0262666643,
0.0094675701,
0.0323490128,
0.0146255987,
0.0062640728,
-0.0213851053,
-0.0263178553,
0.0071408418,
0.0569527484,
0.0231050532,
0.003314944,
-0.0140034594,
-0.0082045747,
0.0269920249,
-0.0317965485,
-0.0264669936,
0.0343113504,
0.0355613194,
-0.0360052288,
0.0248220898,
0.1180182174,
0.0558243394,
-0.0356535278,
-0.0490704402,
0.0276691094,
0.0542753823,
0.031061165,
-0.0027740377,
-0.0631433576,
-0.0022105502,
-0.0045631304,
0.0087498268,
0.0022254398,
-0.0456220917,
0.0027000525,
-0.1099519432,
0.0369227938,
0.0215267427,
-0.0843101442,
0.0347018912,
-0.0519856997,
0.013007394,
-0.0409323946,
-0.0181930866,
-0.0039559328,
0.0211508963,
0.0202830061,
0.0779724121,
-0.0517147556,
-0.007687964,
-0.0120985918,
-0.0491285734,
0.0207676739,
0.0328946263,
0.0326147415,
-0.0002080472,
-0.0287795067,
0.06885764,
0.025832653,
-0.027247984,
0.0097496221,
0.0846735835,
0.013095499,
-0.0092886295,
-0.0218289234,
-0.008660676,
-0.0078240866,
-0.0208251644,
-0.0314516164,
0.0532179922,
0.0199902523,
0.0590455271,
-0.0570993759,
-0.0347177461,
-0.0204700027,
0.0484856367,
0.0096052652,
-0.0366840959,
0.0099833542,
-0.0135309603,
0.0300928708,
-0.0246244874,
-0.0030708543,
0.0436382964,
-0.0688578635,
-0.0656009838,
-0.0986196995,
-0.0609757267,
0.0521117337,
0.0238294806,
-0.0223623645,
0.0048624435,
0.048859898,
-0.000279644,
-0.0338864401,
0.059494473,
0.0086488565,
0.0373380557,
-0.0174061563,
-0.0121329846,
0.0151265329,
0.021477703,
-0.02529018,
0.0201071743,
-0.0629789457,
-0.0586618483,
-0.019158544,
0.0381306782,
0.0195187572,
-0.0049018115,
-0.0076277438,
-0.0388044566,
-0.0283854641,
0.0262106881,
-0.0099442406,
-0.0165915806,
0.0142111899,
0.0099232914,
-0.0302594323,
-0.0015025125,
-0.0712740943,
0.070730038,
-0.0366350375,
-0.0008861183,
-0.0687312335,
-0.0597103238,
0.0325704031,
0.0008502916,
0.0550082438,
-0.0213852376,
-0.0144985514,
-0.0204763189,
-0.0340289362,
0.0310837142,
-0.0445501916,
-0.0304098222,
0.0050550164,
-0.003022253,
-0.0109934043,
0.0116957817,
0.0627262741,
0.0296649355,
0.0553996563,
-0.0538684279,
-0.036997132,
-0.0004502216,
-0.0198603142,
-0.0600387044,
0.0295977145,
-0.0179420095,
0.0077514597,
-0.0333900303,
0.0510567091,
0.0307213422,
0.0051047746,
-0.014939486,
0.0487029664,
-0.0023640853,
0.0424343087,
-0.0449937247,
0.0194167513,
-0.0239992924,
0.0231539104,
0.0560863502,
-0.049458947,
0.0817847475,
0.0232654102,
-0.0120014669,
-0.0324869864,
-0.0098326802,
-0.010958272,
0.0110761393,
-0.0056647104,
0.0526332743,
0.0121376719,
-0.0327596888,
0.0796551406,
0.0108178128,
-0.0131711131,
-0.0273351744,
-0.0011201558,
-0.0169112068,
0.0126947919,
-0.0273341518,
0.0281064771,
-0.003008232,
-0.0258990917,
-0.0409746282,
-0.0345868692,
0.0507643707,
0.0202685464,
0.0228000395,
0.043378111,
0.0307148099,
0.0323297121,
-0.0385923758,
-0.0171890799,
-0.0295682754,
-0.0621646196,
-0.0312028155,
0.026006829,
0.0010327587,
-5.952959063e-33,
-0.0664926246,
-0.074283421,
-0.0236583762,
0.0195381902,
0.0106746638,
0.0471656881,
-0.0096775237,
0.0455315821,
0.0228164084,
0.0162841305,
0.0236326139,
-0.0063977153,
0.0280539952,
0.0000553268,
0.0363955051,
-0.0051824069,
0.0338693,
0.0198861454,
-0.0200666338,
-0.0166021828,
0.042424012,
-0.035422992,
0.0088452706,
-0.1119767055,
0.085703209,
0.0178656597,
7.83e-8,
-0.003145823,
-0.0151979644,
0.0867641941,
0.0234959573,
0.0101880739,
0.0327038057,
-0.0176031385,
-0.0465342402,
0.0473319739,
-0.0756234303,
-0.0184646025,
-0.0185944308,
0.0124760317,
-0.0311988406,
-0.0149076292,
0.0220474172,
-0.0022454751,
0.0065573202,
-0.0358771421,
0.0603924021,
-0.026892012,
-0.0392894223,
-0.0434601419,
0.0005361318,
0.0459302999,
-0.0140584121,
-0.0380086564,
0.0640368536,
0.0549558029,
0.0352899432,
0.0147477398,
-0.0619074628,
0.023041755,
-0.0146762766,
0.0345529467,
0.0110943597,
0.055984471,
-0.013559903,
0.0688120276,
0.0172731262,
0.0260526426,
-0.0499677584,
-0.0109665953,
-0.0328506939,
0.0302060638,
0.0828396156,
0.0284237508,
0.0361982323,
0.0595010817,
-0.0379099995,
0.1033127829,
-0.0148934312,
0.0017585402,
-0.0424949042,
0.0608228371,
-0.0425038226,
-0.009579937,
-0.0500374958,
0.0078661051,
-0.0330662206,
0.0308590531,
0.013335906,
0.026721051,
-0.0344090462,
0.0586525835,
0.023242401,
0.0080133015,
-0.0199990384,
-0.0546932146,
0.0131844087,
0.0674480051,
-0.0056368746,
-0.0212598853,
-0.0375742093,
-0.0134251583,
0.0274602417,
-0.0104780616,
0.0073982254,
0.0184818301,
0.0856005624,
-0.0038231499,
-0.0507115535,
-0.0124172475,
0.0010104203,
-0.0317952298,
-0.0184838753,
0.007758698,
0.0383454077,
0.0038981994,
-0.0172069017,
0.0610203594,
0.0096007762,
0.0158988778,
-0.0325614698,
0.013348707,
-0.0324404091,
-0.0355426371,
0.0332387723,
-0.01373755,
0.0137141561,
0.0011885184,
0.0388450287,
0.0052627954,
-0.0135635277,
0.0015651607,
2.546e-7,
0.0545374677,
0.0293431189,
0.0543762669,
-0.0302710161,
-0.0024874706,
0.0328565761,
-0.0231850948,
-0.0059395642,
0.017167436,
-0.0549489558,
-0.0270309877,
0.0276017729,
0.068246752,
0.0769108757,
-0.0535986684,
-0.0668679103,
-0.0472023971,
0.0161108579,
-0.0404973514,
0.0308564827,
0.0754061788,
0.0500588305,
0.0086905649,
0.0044608144,
-0.0379450768,
-0.0138215208,
0.0601926818,
0.0017400354,
-0.0154287629,
-0.0032990666,
0.028213175,
0.039672602,
0.0140494974,
0.0703210831,
-0.0304073561,
-0.0006682245,
0.091703102,
0.044636894,
-0.0332315117,
-0.0234106891,
0.0087133981,
0.0109778484,
0.0183281805,
0.0259000678,
0.0482380465,
-0.0485861339,
0.0055163759,
0.0026599416,
-0.0128154652,
0.0482420623,
0.049950555,
0.0551996119,
-0.0032384687,
0.0351931006,
0.0014401622,
-0.0122380676,
-0.0108882776,
-0.0466488786,
-0.0579522736,
0.0403701477,
0.0111129191,
-0.0400953852,
-0.03640287,
-0.000101947,
-0.0454222187,
-0.0292112567,
-0.0419664234,
2.22920565e-34,
0.0125001613,
-0.0117736384,
0.011643053,
0.0196588691,
0.0086653763,
-0.0344442651,
-0.0904854462,
0.0158357192,
-0.0075285672,
-0.0449423604,
0.0264747888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13423v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13423v1 | VADIS -- a VAriable Detection, Interlinking and Summarization system | 2023-12-20T21:02:09 | 2023-12-20T21:02:09 | Yavuz Selim Kartal, Muhammad Ahsan Shahid, Sotaro Takeshita, Tornike Tsereteli, Andrea Zielinski, Benjamin Zapilko, Philipp Mayr | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.IR | The VADIS system addresses the demand of providing enhanced information
access in the domain of the social sciences. This is achieved by allowing users
to search and use survey variables in context of their underlying research data
and scholarly publications which have been interlinked with each other. | [
-0.0147471009,
-0.0296581164,
-0.041208379,
-0.0430116691,
0.0006257484,
0.0244005695,
0.0401588678,
0.0198133588,
-0.0114984903,
0.0157678016,
0.0761516169,
0.0036711057,
0.0303792451,
0.0721782893,
-0.0154873887,
-0.0331377089,
0.097122252,
0.0333357565,
-0.0170622822,
-0.0121534104,
-0.0155360866,
-0.0050331121,
-0.0202537775,
0.0103201848,
0.0147447372,
-0.0081758238,
-0.0126401763,
-0.0067245611,
0.040373452,
-0.0090639899,
0.0149772028,
0.0357460529,
0.0126219289,
0.0153096206,
0.0000020816,
-0.0223306008,
-0.06294927,
-0.0036189905,
-0.0679870397,
0.0267694816,
0.0335078873,
-0.0206762031,
0.0567154251,
-0.0213636886,
0.0081058796,
-0.1177937612,
0.0500464626,
-0.0789011121,
0.0165285207,
-0.0123487189,
0.014038777,
-0.0003824827,
-0.0565223359,
-0.0099263582,
0.0108748199,
0.0214266777,
0.0303735863,
0.0352082402,
0.073846221,
0.0173347108,
0.0177793726,
0.0387738235,
-0.0170422476,
-0.0276711695,
0.0687950924,
0.0368375704,
0.0214156099,
-0.0362801589,
-0.0252177268,
-0.0231628623,
0.1567975134,
-0.0217866749,
0.0525769517,
0.027180206,
-0.0236987229,
0.0382955931,
-0.033524178,
-0.0546120703,
-0.04743018,
-0.0198222678,
-0.0190956313,
0.0138434041,
-0.0130262543,
0.0114597939,
-0.0250233114,
-0.0154005364,
0.0063213194,
-0.0087378677,
-0.0160960872,
0.0064956131,
0.0292160306,
-0.0085237613,
0.0276825763,
-0.0162427891,
-0.0286845267,
-0.0370305441,
0.027760813,
-0.0985958502,
0.0175149664,
-0.0160430148,
0.0119802319,
-0.0305592138,
0.0138080223,
0.0192345157,
0.1171710789,
0.0134876901,
-0.0381729417,
0.0156394858,
-0.0395262018,
0.0351301432,
-0.0193252284,
-0.0596583821,
-0.0245957784,
0.0114696063,
-0.0240752678,
0.0110611171,
-0.0305996444,
-0.0230987296,
-0.0172745939,
-0.0014310787,
-0.0487588309,
0.0253088363,
0.0648034066,
0.0267628394,
0.0143972263,
0.0848934576,
-0.0340181887,
-0.0144360764,
-0.0134859988,
0.0691830292,
-0.0048496746,
-0.0011220849,
0.0196300801,
-0.0242470242,
-0.0234646332,
0.0456089824,
0.0354316942,
-0.0197016727,
0.0205684379,
-0.0219314434,
0.0010044988,
-0.0109520089,
0.0516409352,
0.0032710508,
0.0299986769,
0.0519268513,
0.0011524415,
0.0559049696,
-0.0162159167,
0.0291954223,
-0.0359616503,
0.0562650152,
-0.00714583,
0.0140303588,
0.0197910499,
-0.0035264257,
0.136130631,
-0.0128861377,
-0.0766755044,
-0.0159150586,
0.0257207807,
-0.0155467559,
0.0195654724,
-0.0009374549,
-0.0336620025,
-0.0129682655,
-0.0434002541,
0.0214453675,
0.0150710316,
-0.0629045963,
-0.0251579471,
-0.0141233532,
-0.0396251008,
0.0529960319,
0.0218591094,
-0.0050074705,
0.0548915192,
-0.0031196836,
-0.0122271795,
-0.0018263669,
0.0165993646,
-0.0560236648,
0.0278856214,
0.0452280715,
0.0364825167,
-0.0172594376,
-0.0046277754,
0.0145979831,
-0.0241992641,
-0.0324402414,
-0.0322520584,
0.0292766057,
-0.0037730506,
0.0007252194,
0.0195091795,
-0.0226265937,
0.0577484518,
-0.0043537966,
0.017313594,
-0.0116013158,
0.014633324,
0.0117085334,
0.0676321685,
0.0729734674,
0.0268338118,
-0.0115753058,
0.0011741313,
-0.0432395004,
0.0345819704,
-0.0234394632,
0.0612295568,
-0.0234689601,
-0.0290090032,
-0.0089638839,
-0.000389143,
0.0405505262,
0.0213030968,
0.0598476827,
-0.0425489508,
-0.0015574194,
-0.0435923338,
-0.0442440324,
0.0690003783,
-0.020503955,
0.0503149368,
0.0091481004,
-0.0095158238,
0.021966489,
0.0098842615,
0.0389720052,
-0.0062033283,
0.0267686658,
0.0072308723,
0.009617554,
0.0105761988,
-0.0177238304,
0.1290693879,
0.0572268367,
-0.0023681049,
-0.073089242,
0.0003795903,
0.0682660416,
0.0383990891,
0.0186780542,
0.0260003116,
-0.0498555116,
-0.0437820069,
0.0078999,
-0.0120897144,
0.0350162759,
0.0401026011,
-0.0119181052,
0.0247099064,
-0.0098761963,
0.0577695109,
0.0429440551,
-0.0186110046,
0.0211897101,
-0.0257877223,
0.0230061878,
-0.0437671058,
-0.0612576269,
0.0180591401,
0.0112792244,
-0.0070817429,
0.0340987146,
-0.0245517585,
-0.0690578073,
0.0185080227,
0.0139920795,
0.0009956759,
-0.0301527008,
0.0092845056,
-0.0191855654,
0.0134291118,
0.0409902222,
0.0018314751,
0.0503875278,
-0.0271140765,
0.0116791418,
-0.0307952538,
0.0171069354,
-0.0393980257,
0.0050353557,
-0.0129249413,
0.0343306027,
0.03529061,
-0.0424182117,
-0.0377433337,
-0.0852939636,
-0.0546046607,
-0.0347804539,
0.0284317564,
-0.0323283672,
-0.0235121455,
0.0215315726,
0.0290429369,
0.043193996,
-0.0041051484,
0.0146069042,
0.0209502466,
-0.0394391865,
-0.0277190674,
0.0057291598,
-0.0601143017,
0.0533731319,
0.0381315053,
-0.0152156716,
0.0329578593,
-0.0668656975,
0.0527591892,
-0.0027696183,
-0.0272498466,
0.0707306936,
0.0046547162,
0.008071648,
-0.0239159577,
0.0065762307,
-0.0696939602,
0.0551677421,
0.0092699742,
-0.0432171784,
-0.0518916547,
-0.0030365284,
0.0028197113,
-0.0342498273,
-0.0513183326,
-0.0064813914,
-0.0580882207,
0.016899338,
-0.0033277655,
0.006880654,
-0.003730126,
0.0061898539,
0.0652807504,
0.0064705228,
-0.0517522991,
-0.0522185713,
-0.0279153138,
-0.0138946688,
-0.001364878,
0.010559734,
-0.0170084592,
-0.003084294,
0.053708002,
-0.0025045334,
0.0573818386,
0.0086317826,
-0.0011450495,
0.0256424844,
0.0532580838,
0.0503536873,
-0.0046911221,
-0.0052532218,
-0.0278613772,
0.0053241961,
0.0018966671,
-0.0292045251,
0.0510028675,
-0.0348957255,
-0.0557165965,
0.0251049045,
-0.0502647758,
0.0173083227,
0.0017248065,
0.017726073,
0.0475748293,
-0.0231374074,
-0.0409154296,
-0.0235255957,
-0.0101094143,
0.0378303044,
-0.0035862236,
0.0275665596,
0.0011102388,
-0.0753232986,
-0.0140904309,
-0.0579393953,
-0.0427829362,
0.0462282151,
0.0105279097,
-0.095177643,
0.0872601569,
-0.0287557375,
0.0005295153,
0.0006079844,
-0.0111590605,
-0.0169596039,
0.0343862325,
0.0771211684,
0.0073853675,
-0.0536773875,
0.0267978422,
-0.0172201563,
-0.0002671157,
-0.0082830386,
-0.0501225069,
-0.021886019,
-0.0162941888,
0.0042733429,
0.0240563266,
0.0141442111,
-0.0033748136,
-0.0499907359,
-0.0119815981,
0.0384107977,
0.0889103562,
0.0480229966,
-0.0362381041,
0.0015656741,
-0.0293511376,
-0.0146116558,
-0.0437347963,
-0.0142684225,
0.0960784331,
-0.0119532878,
0.0152597716,
-0.0339280777,
0.0282044932,
0.0173631161,
0.008811363,
0.0075733792,
0.012794503,
-0.0252217632,
0.0155980028,
-0.0399217419,
0.0089480607,
0.0110772261,
-0.0035562639,
0.0245983694,
0.0269020814,
-0.0246900134,
0.0168975051,
0.0539370365,
0.0033213324,
-0.050395757,
0.00914382,
-0.0476825535,
-0.1053849235,
-0.0152400238,
-0.0199808124,
0.0135225495,
0.0669717789,
0.0085846866,
-0.011283949,
-0.0147508262,
-0.0118690319,
-0.0554098189,
-0.0157796666,
0.0242231544,
0.0341677628,
-0.0176777635,
-0.0019906578,
-0.0253403876,
0.0125412047,
-0.0488053821,
-0.0695100129,
-0.00865064,
-0.036349494,
0.0227376893,
0.0425677299,
0.0511765778,
-0.0232654456,
-0.0172647946,
0.017554203,
0.0122473761,
-0.0140432985,
0.0273874383,
0.0215381831,
-0.0586126409,
-0.0003571439,
-0.0222028196,
-0.0136691416,
0.0229894798,
-0.0219554827,
-0.0030005972,
-0.059777528,
-0.0030162835,
-0.0130179608,
-0.0167416744,
-0.0086877989,
0.0665509999,
-0.0108292326,
-0.0178301409,
-0.0203155093,
-0.0197807569,
-0.0426910371,
0.0136236083,
-0.0086557427,
-0.0092545394,
0.0009918213,
0.0339554548,
-0.0123674143,
0.0623465963,
0.0455693826,
0.0157183725,
-0.0524213985,
0.0020839153,
-0.0349767655,
0.0394022912,
0.0190227535,
-0.0036442098,
0.039624501,
-0.0216878913,
-0.0052146195,
0.0595954731,
-0.0254564099,
0.0069740145,
0.0002241264,
-0.0342052504,
0.029208377,
0.0168233179,
-0.0651694015,
-0.0834776163,
0.0287565663,
-0.0121145686,
-0.0129027748,
0.0163255408,
0.0025058109,
-0.0416228808,
0.0084674945,
-0.003656954,
0.0112039912,
0.021173887,
0.0627334863,
-0.0227929689,
0.0082421741,
-0.0320917256,
-0.0485081337,
0.0176457204,
0.0273870677,
-0.011946708,
-0.0810850933,
-0.0503293388,
-0.0508359671,
0.0002623652,
-0.0453032143,
0.0685591623,
-0.0193493012,
0.0083968043,
-0.0683118105,
-0.0069528236,
0.0137424329,
-0.0045636175,
0.0128101166,
-0.0249135979,
-0.0295412652,
0.0046979012,
-0.0033467968,
-0.065599218,
0.0436414517,
0.0346826501,
-0.1363894194,
0.0135904849,
-0.0237700678,
-6.826742952e-33,
-0.0362654403,
-0.0118095279,
0.0041943551,
-0.0344330557,
-0.0817288011,
0.0372618102,
0.0220942292,
0.0025521922,
-0.0346394889,
-0.0047368449,
0.0422249883,
-0.006259887,
0.0198667552,
-0.0160738174,
0.0395639203,
0.0028515887,
0.0353814811,
0.0191571321,
-0.0264868103,
-0.063160181,
0.023654934,
-0.0272253752,
0.0048222956,
-0.066267781,
-0.0020875894,
0.0174263772,
0.0407987945,
0.0507252924,
-0.0190161318,
0.0203573816,
0.0243084542,
-0.0460532531,
-0.0138981184,
-0.0217540469,
0.0348536186,
0.0843764618,
-0.0867099613,
0.0143618938,
0.0874396712,
0.0326499827,
0.0232508201,
-0.0239399523,
0.0184286684,
0.0373728275,
-0.0068169339,
-0.0092679933,
0.0292896386,
-0.0411390662,
-0.0361974761,
-0.0284799971,
0.0000081717,
-0.016542742,
-0.0347432718,
0.0695504919,
-0.0031550089,
0.0561650433,
-0.0268719625,
0.0283421595,
-0.0025500001,
0.0272615086,
0.0374501497,
-0.0011035254,
0.0243847519,
-0.0145006459,
0.0163480304,
0.0186405275,
0.0496526882,
-0.0950312242,
-0.0351516455,
-0.0526543073,
-0.0464057773,
-0.0041697542,
0.0428958982,
0.0319534317,
-0.0489652976,
-0.0592521317,
-0.0602248348,
-0.0113376081,
-0.0363226086,
-0.0054496103,
0.0127035864,
-0.0094772009,
-0.0611329973,
-0.0049056825,
-0.0269388407,
-0.0838695839,
-0.0173664689,
-0.0716617852,
0.0146554997,
0.0059452853,
-0.0288751703,
0.0098968241,
0.0112675019,
0.0064983126,
0.027066322,
0.0126982937,
0.0747594237,
0.0165627543,
-0.0125353206,
-0.0647544563,
-0.0332677066,
0.041156318,
0.0027562359,
0.031470377,
0.0301454049,
0.0148226321,
-0.041888088,
-0.0331917591,
-0.072503522,
0.0167008452,
0.0004360361,
-0.0049313689,
-0.027813483,
0.0403157771,
0.0557881333,
0.0064778142,
0.0337798782,
0.0390896238,
0.0212911516,
0.0101477308,
-0.019062113,
-0.0722519755,
-0.0227243267,
0.0047739809,
0.0002956082,
0.0137791252,
-0.0257669166,
-0.0055774911,
0.0045582294,
0.0047316467,
0.0291328039,
-0.0068615242,
2.757e-7,
0.0027776735,
0.0848942697,
0.0227114819,
-0.0297068711,
-0.0045199213,
-0.0343012437,
0.0149859032,
0.0230365191,
0.0112249404,
0.0036172862,
-0.0060945721,
-0.0255563017,
0.01107122,
0.0218551345,
-0.0341720805,
-0.0295928512,
0.0216854922,
-0.0484722443,
-0.0403190404,
-0.0395241491,
0.0777911469,
0.0079456037,
-0.0003938142,
0.034082029,
0.008255708,
0.0077790795,
-0.0267770812,
0.0104280831,
-0.0027392046,
-0.0014738074,
0.0073336852,
-0.0277359188,
-0.0211321246,
0.032618165,
-0.0498292781,
-0.0089682247,
-0.0279540699,
0.0495111756,
0.0151167624,
0.0332561098,
0.0260423124,
-0.0403184295,
-0.0039906451,
0.0111536989,
0.0519484505,
-0.033112742,
0.0396362916,
0.0217380021,
-0.0505600683,
0.0230263378,
0.0180912353,
0.0358948633,
-0.0026377987,
0.0123059331,
-0.0336547345,
0.014069383,
0.0193882305,
-0.0193139575,
0.0108577013,
0.0476309061,
-0.0110337576,
-0.0748071969,
0.0095296651,
0.0237218924,
0.0241625123,
0.0265626609,
-0.0236214548,
2.897918672e-34,
0.0161207151,
-0.0135419136,
-0.0010462037,
-0.0056463741,
0.0286814086,
-0.0446257629,
-0.0337893106,
0.0268256608,
0.0214101318,
-0.0274577644,
0.025525162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13401v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13401v2 | Time is Encoded in the Weights of Finetuned Language Models | 2023-12-20T20:04:45 | 2023-12-30T22:11:07 | Kai Nylund, Suchin Gururangan, Noah A. Smith | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present time vectors, a simple tool to customize language models to new
time periods. Time vectors are created by finetuning a language model on data
from a single time (e.g., a year or month), and then subtracting the weights of
the original pretrained model. This vector specifies a direction in weight
space that, as our experiments show, improves performance on text from that
time period. Time vectors specialized to adjacent time periods appear to be
positioned closer together in a manifold. Using this structure, we interpolate
between time vectors to induce new models that perform better on intervening
and future time periods, without any additional training. We demonstrate the
consistency of our findings across different tasks, domains, model sizes, and
time scales. Our results suggest that time is encoded in the weight space of
finetuned models. | [
0.0293978788,
0.0744325593,
-0.0195135083,
0.0137170879,
-0.049058754,
0.0240323301,
0.0486257821,
0.036549475,
-0.0375840552,
-0.0280146059,
0.0021329608,
-0.0285083465,
0.0183659755,
0.0140388487,
0.0222736038,
-0.0906666368,
0.0515679456,
-0.0125012929,
0.0088987155,
0.0010157267,
0.0000722136,
-0.0192800816,
-0.0210012365,
0.0412334763,
0.0128291557,
-0.0327392146,
-0.0269796699,
-0.0476866215,
0.0118610412,
-0.0145265507,
0.0205893796,
0.0566217005,
0.0313694142,
0.0746585503,
0.0000018142,
0.0068365922,
0.0177411139,
-0.0179864746,
-0.0265317988,
0.0436466411,
0.0512970537,
-0.0035182538,
-0.0094795898,
-0.0216759928,
-0.0617890209,
-0.0177609473,
0.0052496386,
0.0019680695,
0.0043622586,
0.0825849771,
-0.0243106578,
-0.0021937783,
0.0057141492,
-0.0522838868,
0.0011920537,
-0.0495922975,
-0.0163769443,
0.0083139092,
0.0286278017,
0.020836778,
-0.0443986058,
0.0324756764,
0.0108540682,
0.0072112288,
0.0707569569,
0.0891473815,
-0.0015437061,
0.0230109245,
-0.0381849557,
0.036013566,
-0.0458149426,
-0.0467695333,
-0.0145448782,
-0.0246920157,
-0.0229145736,
-0.0159651488,
-0.0463104583,
-0.0460894629,
0.0498388894,
0.0255162194,
0.0543948412,
-0.0064747799,
0.0357787795,
0.0268117171,
0.0005661789,
0.0738400146,
0.0189897027,
-0.0198288932,
-0.0393339694,
-0.0063098869,
0.0332822949,
-0.0378302857,
0.0060870424,
0.0395278521,
0.0418631025,
-0.0089838142,
-0.0471301451,
-0.0197114516,
-0.0051860898,
-0.0344768576,
0.0625028238,
0.0281065777,
0.0146218808,
0.0376930535,
-0.0153462887,
0.0491979942,
-0.0395652428,
-0.0086099766,
-0.0597490519,
0.0216471627,
-0.046256654,
-0.0141088124,
-0.0112263979,
-0.0256410837,
-0.0344448797,
-0.0152339954,
-0.0457987078,
0.0266646724,
0.030923998,
-0.0290719941,
-0.004057725,
-0.0022441833,
-0.0443302579,
-0.0168473236,
-0.0524972565,
0.0327178612,
-0.0297577363,
0.0377484635,
-0.0310247447,
-0.0446364023,
-0.0365742743,
0.0249503236,
0.0088601802,
-0.0684237853,
-0.0001678914,
0.0173502639,
-0.036249686,
-0.0036790874,
-0.0421519205,
-0.0331910327,
-0.0275563169,
-0.0245710611,
0.0250369087,
-0.0579028316,
-0.0092026349,
0.0173684321,
0.0002623754,
-0.0169124603,
-0.0130501287,
-0.0183163509,
-0.0525463298,
0.0566699877,
0.0099799205,
0.0410544351,
0.0311971139,
-0.028227549,
0.0486443862,
0.0322558656,
0.0441879593,
0.000360801,
0.0116349291,
-0.0055767586,
-0.0210294425,
0.0382161774,
0.0297417268,
-0.000514233,
-0.0793035552,
-0.0296672788,
0.0009072142,
0.0489487685,
0.0253191628,
0.0191560816,
-0.0232529156,
-0.0123046432,
0.0655364692,
0.0338021331,
0.0313752294,
0.0160236582,
0.0616894439,
-0.0796806365,
0.0089144791,
0.0066777472,
-0.036249347,
0.0432109609,
0.0050522173,
0.0007050279,
-0.0435133651,
0.0024613913,
-0.0349883623,
-0.0348040797,
-0.0137239723,
-0.0196972545,
0.0520785563,
-0.0094643161,
0.061105188,
0.0046009114,
-0.0248924997,
0.0510614179,
0.016373327,
-0.0052575818,
0.0083338255,
-0.0014427726,
0.0137505811,
0.0959965065,
-0.0140998159,
-0.0085111447,
-0.0320072286,
-0.003539664,
0.0810787827,
0.0343123302,
0.097765781,
-0.0037451379,
0.0094952751,
-0.0479819812,
-0.0168429278,
0.0205609705,
-0.0031973186,
-0.0038497325,
0.032678321,
0.0455642045,
0.0009550357,
-0.0148277842,
-0.0368293077,
0.0363459028,
-0.0379903428,
-0.0295136478,
-0.0205756854,
-0.0020170475,
0.0257225726,
-0.0039411345,
0.015360618,
0.0213724338,
0.043513909,
-0.0523441099,
-0.0221849103,
0.0328606926,
-0.0674057603,
-0.039768789,
0.0525152907,
-0.0009463336,
0.0031602487,
0.0275546443,
-0.0229252055,
-0.0277680401,
0.0632265434,
0.0107058939,
0.0614229068,
-0.0319643095,
-0.0185915548,
-0.0268327817,
0.0159887895,
-0.0858461335,
0.0516615734,
0.0026518402,
0.0135392416,
-0.002094548,
0.0295703076,
-0.0171439797,
-0.0067689018,
-0.0135590956,
0.0315638557,
0.0458759256,
-0.0051989136,
0.0109547228,
-0.0138065703,
-0.0464499444,
-0.0570932999,
-0.086234808,
-0.0321077704,
-0.0072042681,
0.0115483757,
-0.0021825982,
-0.0190904867,
0.0075375331,
-0.0118573736,
-0.0211173985,
0.0062542623,
-0.0329124555,
0.0301481374,
0.0438152403,
0.0217545517,
0.0144951921,
-0.0271594059,
-0.0470903181,
-0.0211559962,
0.0682027116,
-0.0067103505,
-0.0219528135,
-0.0151610095,
-0.013406503,
-0.046789173,
0.0180389173,
-0.0147127872,
-0.0273245797,
0.0276161749,
-0.0233243667,
0.0896952897,
0.0700617507,
0.0278028045,
0.059098132,
0.0695855245,
-0.025316285,
-0.0483764447,
0.0132673578,
-0.0630129203,
-0.0004840058,
-0.0731761232,
-0.003028743,
-0.0474667326,
0.0904659182,
0.0082696583,
0.0111083928,
-0.0800566077,
0.0336067565,
-0.0548052341,
0.0146523528,
0.0293427221,
0.0219956152,
-0.0468997471,
0.0110437665,
-0.0233955048,
-0.065243654,
0.0621831119,
0.0284629967,
-0.0240414664,
0.0153228184,
-0.0434626229,
-0.0159360953,
0.0654922947,
0.0181925036,
0.001882171,
0.0194050875,
0.0016284121,
-0.0483754799,
0.0140286013,
0.0601477474,
-0.034613952,
0.0059327404,
-0.0553986281,
0.0122950105,
0.0025155863,
0.0027562585,
-0.0185885374,
-0.0668601394,
-0.0403478369,
-0.0222173613,
-0.0569489449,
0.0071467189,
-0.0343235172,
0.0110588102,
-0.0304403696,
0.0442227162,
-0.0682666451,
0.014758057,
0.0009966739,
0.005495653,
0.0553175211,
0.0324523486,
-0.0029742124,
-0.0481305942,
0.0116080269,
-0.0199609548,
0.0292662606,
0.0013989042,
-0.0817164108,
0.0415265895,
-0.0059948987,
-0.0038010683,
-0.0416419432,
0.0198700875,
0.0236636903,
-0.0404215492,
-0.0149467876,
0.1164274216,
0.0235270206,
-0.0294890106,
0.0181006584,
0.0097467722,
0.0393561386,
0.0264117345,
-0.019204583,
-0.0065087741,
-0.0154783959,
-0.0049014427,
-0.006528012,
-0.0041849893,
-0.001083116,
0.0076297526,
-0.0670701191,
-0.0076695406,
0.04227034,
-0.0278213266,
0.0243415423,
-0.0203706548,
-0.0255536903,
-0.015765436,
0.0199531615,
-0.0018769742,
-0.0012547788,
0.0385171771,
0.0463778153,
-0.029671317,
-0.0697896555,
0.029969573,
0.0239027403,
0.0758582428,
0.0323201194,
0.0420092791,
-0.0229790341,
-0.0671604276,
0.0369706154,
0.0068336846,
0.0117444443,
-0.0294690244,
0.0469657034,
0.0328806266,
-0.0309003089,
0.010864499,
0.0363543108,
0.0019238699,
-0.0053690122,
-0.0222167112,
0.110955596,
-0.020102948,
-0.0150302695,
0.006943325,
-0.0422944985,
0.0057702372,
0.0459045023,
0.0173850711,
-0.0479993857,
-0.0162191484,
0.0201349799,
0.0186772384,
-0.0498705097,
-0.0608223677,
-0.0024139106,
-0.0040327888,
-0.0099229803,
-0.0619298778,
-0.037907254,
-0.0282208622,
0.0304603484,
0.007348455,
0.0201642439,
0.0108079305,
-0.0193099808,
-0.0916637406,
0.0430381447,
-0.010174376,
0.0405938253,
-0.0334782451,
-0.0518578626,
0.0261895154,
0.016826544,
-0.0266121328,
0.0115601374,
-0.0982498601,
-0.0688711479,
0.0313572735,
0.012127704,
0.0185105037,
0.0435749926,
0.0294818264,
-0.0474444218,
0.0713405684,
0.0006319245,
-0.013623707,
0.0364205204,
0.0351728871,
-0.0383473821,
0.0004646226,
0.0429378897,
-0.0299769212,
-0.0037716413,
0.0272293072,
0.0004764307,
-0.0305955317,
0.0112665007,
-0.0125532104,
-0.0287165865,
0.0785422698,
0.0063670757,
-0.0216250923,
0.0002351259,
-0.0084587261,
-0.0075394539,
0.0025309795,
-0.0332978107,
-0.0165511053,
0.0336858742,
0.0110125206,
-0.0271473918,
0.0228915252,
0.0198647249,
0.0073165558,
-0.0551557168,
0.0112025607,
-0.0315529183,
0.0563751869,
0.0313363932,
0.0552469306,
0.0080658859,
0.0143970046,
-0.0363942236,
-0.0060548559,
0.0083163632,
0.0026241837,
0.0381512344,
0.0567531139,
-0.0652679279,
-0.0108107431,
-0.1042933762,
0.0101363445,
0.0049578836,
-0.0372151025,
0.0496462807,
-0.0508741476,
0.0862202495,
-0.0111844409,
-0.023399869,
-0.0136191817,
0.0501506217,
0.01957101,
-0.0152675826,
0.0367138498,
-0.005573032,
-0.0212711673,
0.0135908462,
0.0713075399,
0.0008506819,
0.060518764,
0.0343494378,
0.0061559072,
-0.0187304486,
-0.0174755454,
-0.0407056697,
-0.0125731016,
-0.0140688969,
0.0105127981,
-0.0364211239,
-0.0334214605,
0.0377730392,
-0.0031647878,
-0.0131736044,
-0.0159259718,
0.0186721887,
0.0385370776,
-0.0234044027,
-0.022116255,
-0.0419518985,
0.0499192998,
0.0512335636,
-0.0499846898,
-0.071825169,
-6.353546966e-33,
-0.0041577141,
-0.0100092385,
0.0092496462,
0.0053156102,
-0.0387107357,
0.0308779702,
-0.0319892913,
0.0292597041,
-0.0209507234,
0.0117655294,
-0.0126287779,
0.013387098,
0.0065523228,
-0.0047499323,
0.0457147993,
0.0034393612,
0.0270546414,
-0.0526119694,
-0.0129060457,
0.0214959513,
0.0237021819,
0.0422961414,
0.0826160014,
-0.014362908,
-0.0029617702,
0.0270050671,
-0.0132126287,
0.0317457989,
0.0126704657,
0.0617647357,
-0.0255020242,
0.0175468661,
0.0224731043,
-0.0584587902,
-0.0378310978,
-0.0275491755,
-0.0871101394,
-0.0536622442,
0.0050711012,
0.0195623171,
-0.0151038598,
-0.044239115,
0.0323722288,
0.0003849194,
-0.0435237586,
-0.0236908309,
0.0391185433,
-0.0398706198,
-0.0414414704,
-0.0161156394,
-0.0374465995,
0.0370350927,
-0.0182614122,
-0.0189181063,
0.0597121082,
-0.0096455151,
0.0156442896,
0.0095321024,
-0.0214924719,
0.0104502421,
-0.0000339813,
0.0508400239,
0.0149513511,
0.0282963365,
0.0013549777,
0.0371917672,
0.0276384074,
0.0221231095,
0.007080344,
0.0562977865,
0.0908273384,
-0.0318660922,
0.0462768599,
-0.0226301905,
0.0488831848,
-0.0474144891,
-0.0274655279,
-0.0081672249,
0.0177225843,
0.0052074594,
0.0229394324,
0.0438829698,
0.0056621348,
-0.0001286691,
-0.0287141539,
-0.0180800632,
-0.0269026905,
-0.0043046866,
-0.00969519,
0.0315091945,
0.0099337138,
0.0175249502,
0.0315394998,
-0.011281929,
-0.0471471995,
-0.0192960147,
-0.0405516103,
0.0138442526,
0.0257283822,
0.0254453644,
-0.057583008,
-0.0187905822,
0.0353605933,
0.0296167284,
0.0212997869,
-0.0272819363,
0.0334690548,
0.0585135594,
-0.0680376217,
-0.0218442399,
-0.0356055424,
-0.0346287303,
0.0302750468,
0.0129316179,
0.0321105793,
-0.0104509089,
-0.0168793928,
0.0446468741,
-0.0002557675,
0.0040361672,
-0.0484429114,
-0.0220701117,
0.031680271,
0.0481603779,
-0.0543041937,
-0.0285238381,
-0.0274345949,
0.0515093058,
0.0721330643,
-0.0160429887,
-0.0151522867,
0.0215413943,
2.502e-7,
0.0287498999,
0.0687363297,
0.0114799645,
0.0178767834,
0.0471766964,
-0.0015564504,
-0.0196649563,
0.0040408089,
-0.0386503562,
0.023915315,
0.0326055996,
0.0182583127,
0.0735097378,
-0.0013210551,
-0.0132537335,
-0.0177230965,
-0.0739818364,
0.0094086453,
-0.0448283665,
-0.0120572969,
0.0137442704,
0.0974371433,
0.0827980638,
0.009847343,
0.0043686088,
-0.0200501867,
0.070003733,
-0.0343562998,
-0.0006845664,
0.0032909059,
0.0163054708,
0.0223532785,
-0.0370426066,
-0.019937519,
-0.0209896863,
0.0117402747,
-0.033588253,
0.025452584,
-0.0489894785,
-0.0027255893,
-0.036223039,
0.0234152842,
-0.0440593362,
-0.0234253015,
0.0707469434,
-0.0436638072,
-0.0129918493,
-0.0773530081,
0.0134112677,
0.052856449,
0.0501077399,
0.0108982604,
-0.0383018367,
0.04567191,
0.0225673113,
0.0034077915,
-0.0310882051,
-0.0900653303,
-0.0569161437,
0.0587252527,
-0.0463341065,
-0.0340100788,
-0.0699594989,
-0.0068379496,
0.0124427266,
-0.0391810574,
-0.0067210933,
2.058784454e-34,
0.0014717932,
-0.0061121923,
-0.0082447752,
0.0262143351,
0.0091755828,
-0.0096043237,
0.0267056786,
-0.0154319853,
0.030077571,
-0.0562638938,
-0.0415834635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13382v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13382v2 | DSPy Assertions: Computational Constraints for Self-Refining Language Model Pipelines | 2023-12-20T19:13:26 | 2024-02-02T18:20:03 | Arnav Singhvi, Manish Shetty, Shangyin Tan, Christopher Potts, Koushik Sen, Matei Zaharia, Omar Khattab | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.PL | Chaining language model (LM) calls as composable modules is fueling a new way
of programming, but ensuring LMs adhere to important constraints requires
heuristic "prompt engineering". We introduce LM Assertions, a programming
construct for expressing computational constraints that LMs should satisfy. We
integrate our constructs into the recent DSPy programming model for LMs, and
present new strategies that allow DSPy to compile programs with LM Assertions
into more reliable and accurate systems. We also propose strategies to use
assertions at inference time for automatic self-refinement with LMs. We report
on four diverse case studies for text generation and find that LM Assertions
improve not only compliance with imposed rules but also downstream task
performance, passing constraints up to 164% more often and generating up to 37%
more higher-quality responses. Our reference implementation of LM Assertions is
integrated into DSPy at https://github.com/stanfordnlp/dspy | [
0.0113341156,
0.0752403587,
-0.0042545469,
-0.0035874804,
-0.0193974487,
-0.0125188502,
-0.0009401453,
-0.033096876,
0.0333100483,
-0.0487205274,
0.0288565475,
-0.0096350806,
0.0106647471,
0.0351497382,
0.0277209431,
-0.0299364403,
0.0452492759,
-0.0355640054,
-0.022252528,
-0.0020207237,
-0.0293161999,
0.0230404362,
-0.0167887956,
-0.0000088518,
-0.0113863871,
-0.0382890068,
0.0142805772,
0.0300928317,
-0.0413060151,
-0.0021940835,
0.0176807754,
0.0791257843,
-0.0003667703,
-0.0071008964,
0.0000024661,
-0.0488740541,
-0.0083950544,
0.0136589967,
-0.0171629861,
0.0553530492,
0.0264094397,
-0.0195649825,
-0.0272054393,
0.0396174155,
-0.0207759272,
-0.0207997523,
0.024669813,
-0.0438169464,
0.0986672714,
0.0533544347,
0.0087930094,
0.0416535921,
-0.013841656,
-0.0006315861,
-0.0132963667,
0.0397929326,
0.01075025,
0.011243985,
0.0225586481,
-0.0210645497,
0.0714340582,
0.0270157009,
0.030053841,
-0.0358551554,
-0.02421364,
0.0130274305,
-0.0000875857,
-0.0475219972,
-0.0119807106,
-0.0003645763,
0.0213114116,
-0.0792639554,
0.0028533058,
-0.0248405412,
-0.0217478704,
-0.0371183343,
-0.0411314443,
0.0589211695,
0.0190401394,
-0.0098673003,
0.027809998,
-0.0235015173,
0.0287798122,
-0.0158425067,
-0.0343592018,
0.0815542713,
0.0401331894,
-0.0281982925,
-0.0485170893,
0.0251161698,
0.028164506,
-0.0784157887,
-0.0154169649,
0.0347368903,
-0.0507644191,
-0.0193040445,
-0.0621329993,
-0.0030914957,
0.0578916632,
-0.0245644506,
0.0235151462,
0.0100162495,
0.0049352716,
-0.008679512,
-0.0186778698,
0.0711348206,
-0.0007548999,
-0.0122635541,
-0.0498557277,
0.0392187834,
0.0201538503,
-0.0234890766,
-0.0528634004,
0.0029698065,
0.0151844239,
0.0463395417,
-0.0299017448,
0.0888620093,
-0.0085158236,
0.0736057609,
-0.0261697266,
-0.0460148826,
-0.0491222329,
0.0053206463,
0.0052272971,
-0.0053830775,
0.0003561295,
-0.0424793772,
0.0162366889,
-0.0467425734,
-0.0458052643,
0.0523117967,
-0.0204831809,
-0.0202802718,
0.0175423808,
0.0928268731,
-0.0130881369,
0.0246113632,
-0.0193606485,
-0.0473962575,
-0.0137273064,
-0.0646710768,
-0.0026425668,
-0.0950740576,
-0.0473449863,
0.0379031152,
-0.0158497784,
-0.0338799655,
-0.0141230924,
-0.0051161391,
0.032481838,
0.0160622224,
-0.0026767291,
0.0222712141,
0.008207988,
0.0113353077,
0.0094803395,
0.0584641099,
0.0295041464,
0.0051023588,
0.0309885517,
-0.0249622855,
0.0460545868,
0.0222713724,
0.0087459516,
0.0022784667,
-0.03974149,
-0.0000385967,
0.0076156412,
-0.0201968011,
0.0043413769,
0.0516608916,
0.0182224438,
0.0419971198,
0.0116423741,
0.0037442066,
0.0114672221,
-0.003570985,
0.0996625796,
0.0290914718,
0.0132356538,
0.0752420574,
-0.0283924565,
0.0351434499,
-0.0101080062,
0.0540153831,
0.0161364451,
0.0517681353,
-0.0146083981,
-0.090104416,
-0.0516556911,
0.0182515495,
0.0048359893,
-0.0064007039,
0.0277010649,
0.0013548592,
-0.0058681145,
0.0501710288,
0.0229831394,
-0.0927686393,
-0.0236998796,
-0.0416541174,
0.0136072543,
0.0732115954,
0.0483243987,
-0.0455208011,
-0.0014883658,
0.0015472632,
-0.0087585906,
0.0684880689,
0.063105002,
-0.0006399734,
0.0036466662,
-0.0163941123,
0.0082886862,
-0.0384052321,
0.0287356861,
-0.0107025467,
0.053563267,
-0.0280282777,
0.0442348011,
0.0036252951,
-0.057890214,
0.0576161779,
-0.0398616418,
-0.0343328603,
-0.0042402288,
0.0080788694,
0.0067797238,
0.0004274584,
-0.0551059023,
0.041977033,
0.0373739228,
0.0099100024,
-0.0011179439,
-0.0291002225,
-0.0583050065,
0.0045507387,
0.0220822524,
0.0237686187,
-0.0251366068,
-0.0099523393,
-0.0154524753,
-0.0235226545,
0.0615206473,
-0.0197256804,
-0.020109579,
-0.0279677883,
0.0591581501,
0.0098529123,
-0.0067024827,
-0.0044179135,
0.0200118273,
0.0277359542,
-0.0077682743,
0.0172513388,
0.0270921178,
0.0520386472,
0.0031204568,
-0.0484113507,
-0.0094760349,
-0.0149783259,
0.047861293,
0.0446405523,
0.0659773126,
0.0038031656,
-0.0339233726,
-0.0252489299,
0.0282509532,
-0.0319756828,
0.0211509019,
0.0207652748,
0.0213488229,
-0.0262448527,
0.0065553328,
0.0213783085,
-0.025074916,
0.0470992103,
0.0091096424,
0.064421989,
-0.0010111844,
-0.0568400882,
-0.0139111076,
-0.0218834765,
-0.0277958363,
0.0513204038,
0.010499387,
-0.000647452,
-0.0718541145,
-0.0110970195,
-0.0299935546,
0.0318681151,
0.0176451746,
-0.0159967095,
0.0374167822,
-0.0114851901,
0.0663337335,
0.0023884792,
0.0076109911,
-0.0061901435,
0.0774633065,
-0.0076084891,
-0.0272953045,
0.0182021949,
0.0162452646,
-0.0193459783,
0.0766827092,
-0.0145410979,
0.0258973297,
0.0955445841,
-0.0137318401,
-0.0203747544,
-0.0219322201,
0.0202772133,
0.0191951562,
-0.0172386821,
0.0526176058,
-0.0594290942,
-0.0003350373,
0.0431566425,
-0.0039603296,
-0.0975493044,
0.0762075335,
-0.0847673193,
-0.0067560948,
-0.0227009319,
-0.018441502,
-0.0352482758,
0.0725817606,
0.0194108114,
0.0048207296,
0.0679377466,
-0.0027176952,
-0.0194375943,
0.0327024646,
0.043531172,
-0.0109303249,
0.0594274998,
-0.0889175832,
0.0448294245,
-0.0205319263,
-0.0309659708,
-0.0672279745,
0.0302078407,
-0.0081208758,
0.0011102764,
0.0109472917,
-0.0205263961,
0.0464967042,
0.0164878517,
0.0145312855,
0.0384786762,
0.0131196221,
-0.0045207134,
-0.0149212601,
-0.0314065255,
-0.0371616893,
-0.0267905593,
-0.0186267942,
-0.0168512054,
0.0271318201,
0.0078951214,
0.0078415377,
0.0565265566,
-0.029970888,
-0.0036504895,
0.027973108,
-0.0358120613,
-0.0382214449,
0.0377076343,
0.0132752387,
-0.0646580756,
-0.0653938949,
0.081237711,
0.0394582301,
0.0027106684,
0.0280473586,
-0.0435582288,
0.090118356,
0.049392622,
0.0723050088,
-0.0880339146,
0.0061361445,
-0.0201777518,
0.0337400362,
-0.0263684038,
0.0397975035,
-0.0601247847,
-0.0673029572,
0.0494139791,
0.0329963565,
-0.0108207772,
-0.0061672488,
-0.0243502185,
-0.0270059891,
0.0302505009,
-0.0008403825,
0.0591253042,
-0.0320394784,
0.0243763346,
0.0088978224,
-0.0437573232,
-0.013459078,
-0.0245543625,
-0.0209087599,
0.0127084982,
0.0468706675,
-0.0051722378,
0.0016797074,
-0.0185233131,
0.0588144735,
-0.0201157667,
0.0002448648,
-0.0456884392,
-0.01890116,
0.0204100031,
-0.0161777418,
-0.0043919422,
-0.0145572433,
-0.0301667657,
-0.0277105551,
-0.0019684695,
0.052958291,
-0.0114389947,
-0.0323847085,
-0.0182290915,
0.0193302315,
-0.021016404,
0.0465235747,
0.0416238829,
-0.0150853209,
-0.0627411008,
-0.0486687459,
-0.064452149,
-0.0453978814,
-0.0237482525,
-0.003000062,
-0.0093043735,
0.0117350146,
-0.0734378472,
0.0125454916,
0.0273083318,
0.0115660569,
-0.0341655873,
-0.0052554435,
-0.0382538699,
-0.0289653074,
-0.0839173794,
0.004774271,
-0.0148001658,
-0.0230106972,
-0.0545728207,
-0.0239295382,
0.0062244586,
-0.0090665594,
0.0040657376,
0.0851047263,
-0.066255182,
-0.080293484,
-0.0159946699,
0.0641626418,
0.0274331495,
0.0366940089,
-0.0322250612,
-0.0327183753,
0.0138812894,
0.0751176253,
-0.0139516648,
0.0017340819,
0.01379003,
-0.041560825,
0.0018129045,
-0.0036778895,
-0.0263616592,
0.0225174334,
-0.0199797656,
0.0280352682,
0.0314876772,
-0.069656454,
0.0547316782,
0.0752241537,
-0.0020716276,
-0.018337952,
-0.0237647723,
-0.0146833584,
-0.0095212664,
-0.0407594703,
-0.0505626239,
-0.0478358343,
0.0619183406,
-0.0520206019,
-0.0201748703,
-0.001261048,
-0.0116612865,
-0.067304112,
0.0817275494,
0.0100298496,
0.0166848619,
-0.0385990068,
0.0247132834,
0.0395445749,
-0.0308099501,
-0.0122229727,
0.0366010405,
0.0060656881,
0.0226456579,
-0.0326745212,
0.0240555536,
-0.0083768433,
0.0404336043,
-0.0237002056,
0.0240625814,
-0.0180206411,
-0.0472800583,
-0.0600902587,
-0.0227295533,
0.035139244,
0.0334760919,
0.072180368,
-0.0661985576,
0.0105319768,
-0.0161046181,
0.0438540466,
0.0345923007,
-0.0459796116,
-0.0219579134,
0.0374109186,
-0.031666737,
-0.0343029797,
0.074194327,
0.0074428404,
-0.008308569,
0.017089501,
-0.0049937377,
-0.0569633693,
-0.0564825349,
-0.0371651053,
-0.0450058766,
-0.0297299754,
-0.0211689919,
-0.0393322036,
-0.0626293197,
-0.022109475,
0.0586839505,
0.0293373801,
-0.0134476768,
-0.0099321697,
0.0855929703,
0.0043633878,
-0.0135322595,
-0.0095543889,
0.0245911032,
0.0167382695,
-0.0234685354,
0.0268368516,
-6.659063825e-33,
-0.0556671247,
-0.0351285674,
0.0361929387,
-0.0052930629,
0.0192583818,
-0.0094249612,
-0.0620092936,
0.0222068205,
0.0458700657,
-0.0297954902,
0.0054684174,
-0.012711307,
0.0065806066,
-0.0269694254,
-0.0008174923,
0.0498293824,
0.021626588,
0.0159160774,
-0.0908508748,
0.0105084963,
0.0130387861,
-0.0234382972,
0.0276584215,
-0.0176364798,
-0.0044229194,
-0.0257221013,
-0.0113547985,
0.016291175,
-0.0598632507,
0.0384659432,
0.0050608516,
0.0117192725,
0.0120878462,
-0.0474606417,
-0.0385631323,
0.0192307066,
-0.0152391791,
-0.0314164907,
-0.0052625393,
-0.0409900583,
-0.0484421551,
-0.020997284,
0.0607297495,
-0.009515007,
-0.026293844,
0.015493934,
-0.0176268499,
0.0078832442,
0.0054540355,
-0.0052289139,
-0.0829363987,
0.0302037336,
-0.0028846904,
0.0095353201,
-0.0166104101,
0.0177055784,
-0.0011429008,
-0.0123282215,
0.0418492146,
0.0199460927,
0.0363739543,
0.070331417,
0.0965752304,
-0.0153256059,
-0.0301004834,
0.0147276623,
-0.0286271609,
0.0297360029,
0.0038795939,
0.0141343903,
0.0121700615,
0.020492373,
0.0270210057,
0.0242146067,
-0.0228866413,
-0.0072194794,
-0.0488398634,
0.0329651199,
0.0085039549,
0.0023680173,
0.0072946013,
-0.013420539,
-0.021300301,
-0.0378633961,
-0.0566193387,
-0.0021944605,
-0.0395003632,
-0.027861774,
0.0022019697,
0.0140748732,
-0.0781178623,
-0.0023076632,
-0.0067964187,
0.0108550927,
-0.0258508734,
0.0102430964,
-0.058914084,
-0.0084718205,
-0.0140837058,
0.049429521,
0.0305162352,
-0.0111021772,
0.0253531095,
-0.0111373104,
0.0466180965,
0.0370296873,
-0.0246218182,
0.0256886594,
-0.0475650914,
0.0156638306,
-0.0643084869,
0.0492106602,
-0.0096474774,
0.005965983,
0.0198053606,
-0.0152113521,
0.0012013544,
0.026262885,
0.0012858877,
-0.0620435663,
-0.072779499,
0.0675139651,
0.025094891,
0.0482278392,
-0.0174737517,
0.0083119851,
-0.0359472111,
0.0017785248,
0.0584808104,
-0.0182714481,
-0.0355309322,
-0.008268577,
3.192e-7,
0.0090905745,
0.0697845891,
0.057080999,
0.0600441433,
-0.0131876385,
0.0232069902,
-0.0269310325,
0.0123316096,
-0.0011939848,
0.0072281696,
-0.0052399933,
0.0151243303,
0.0414409488,
0.0355894007,
-0.0173279494,
0.0430297405,
-0.0427206233,
0.0082645724,
-0.0435372107,
-0.0283717662,
0.0126503445,
-0.0155030051,
-0.0242001172,
-0.0074846824,
-0.0212369617,
-0.0503278486,
0.013136114,
0.0141343996,
0.0219794344,
0.0695274845,
0.0123544494,
-0.0116156517,
0.0253733285,
0.0180587303,
-0.0333727822,
-0.0193953905,
-0.0102038281,
0.0633756444,
0.0245939232,
0.0101953549,
0.0274375603,
-0.0022517708,
0.0299652293,
-0.0778838545,
0.0438887738,
0.005583141,
0.0079235937,
-0.0687087849,
-0.0201780573,
-0.0119540943,
-0.0211467035,
0.0085854232,
0.0007301782,
0.0485468954,
0.0031357976,
0.03351463,
-0.0252871569,
-0.0435794368,
-0.0857411623,
-0.0166871175,
-0.0324928127,
-0.016985137,
-0.0216096696,
0.0374412127,
0.0026948275,
-0.0682624504,
-0.0040296232,
3.70383737e-34,
0.025977537,
-0.0165784843,
0.0333981253,
-0.0040003564,
0.0230494048,
0.008535428,
-0.0346365087,
0.0094181215,
0.0185142513,
-0.0283012372,
-0.0412341692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13264v1 | dIR -- Discrete Information Retrieval: Conversational Search over Unstructured (and Structured) Data with Large Language Models | 2023-12-20T18:41:44 | 2023-12-20T18:41:44 | Pablo M. Rodriguez Bertorello, Jean Rodmond Junior Laguerre | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR, cs.LG | Data is stored in both structured and unstructured form. Querying both, to
power natural language conversations, is a challenge. This paper introduces
dIR, Discrete Information Retrieval, providing a unified interface to query
both free text and structured knowledge. Specifically, a Large Language Model
(LLM) transforms text into expressive representation. After the text is
extracted into columnar form, it can then be queried via a text-to-SQL Semantic
Parser, with an LLM converting natural language into SQL. Where desired, such
conversation may be effected by a multi-step reasoning conversational agent. We
validate our approach via a proprietary question/answer data set, concluding
that dIR makes a whole new class of queries on free text possible when compared
to traditionally fine-tuned dense-embedding-model-based Information Retrieval
(IR) and SQL-based Knowledge Bases (KB). For sufficiently complex queries, dIR
can succeed where no other method stands a chance. | [
0.0270060841,
0.0553627573,
-0.0167154837,
0.0576541014,
-0.0152261462,
0.0025334675,
0.0070509771,
0.0085829291,
0.0462872386,
-0.038578853,
0.0122662755,
0.0125053916,
-0.0583306253,
0.0532302372,
-0.012893457,
-0.0201114062,
0.0312508866,
-0.0203519035,
0.05436882,
0.0184798334,
0.0260045677,
0.0059001734,
-0.000567461,
-0.0304022748,
0.0019276926,
-0.0064467927,
-0.061671935,
0.0015928322,
-0.0500017107,
-0.0209914763,
0.0091563025,
0.0233384985,
0.0739065707,
0.0255483259,
0.0000018313,
-0.0408066437,
-0.0554226153,
0.020013921,
-0.0539762788,
-0.0412302464,
0.0201401543,
0.0111999968,
0.0215176418,
0.0150082689,
-0.0749072433,
-0.0261985809,
0.0252819005,
0.0768010393,
0.0475232452,
0.0838267729,
-0.0275772102,
-0.0550641418,
-0.006503989,
0.0045480658,
0.0201993622,
-0.033980377,
0.027100062,
0.0522331633,
0.038722761,
0.0698712394,
0.0406479351,
0.0250681844,
-0.0325045958,
-0.0569115542,
0.0264014658,
0.0153522938,
-0.007783358,
-0.0038346916,
0.0012431199,
0.0692955032,
0.0505165495,
-0.0066239322,
0.0217285827,
0.0143158538,
-0.0051783696,
-0.0045554163,
-0.0450982414,
0.0185328219,
-0.0126196723,
0.00925007,
-0.0259407759,
0.0029747246,
0.0100525655,
-0.0143789919,
-0.0504957698,
0.0683928728,
-0.0090412507,
-0.0510922633,
0.0239756834,
-0.0460536852,
-0.0056694029,
-0.0617979653,
0.0064164302,
0.0532003604,
-0.0273582861,
0.0396792144,
-0.0054241614,
-0.0156189688,
0.0065185032,
-0.0544504412,
-0.0170800705,
0.0203055739,
0.0417367555,
0.0751878545,
0.0223332588,
0.0123882499,
0.0191849675,
0.011991269,
-0.0324156918,
-0.0436263494,
-0.0444833636,
-0.0026427459,
-0.0564226396,
0.0577096678,
-0.1122979149,
-0.0135955587,
0.0410486907,
0.0687331334,
0.0235488676,
0.0250673685,
0.0296973586,
0.0404479466,
-0.0167616811,
0.0190401804,
-0.0761372596,
0.0112538533,
-0.02992226,
-0.0246932842,
0.0172540005,
-0.0628851876,
0.0175500475,
-0.0011697367,
0.0370424353,
-0.0351364203,
-0.013104599,
0.0449588522,
-0.0215287693,
-0.0134687489,
-0.0379485637,
-0.0367215611,
0.0142984781,
-0.0258138105,
-0.0057707503,
-0.0326979347,
0.0659018904,
0.0027810575,
-0.0401226804,
-0.0524077751,
0.0331288949,
0.044262182,
-0.0142289642,
0.0569833256,
-0.0414478742,
0.000803524,
0.0291297827,
0.0046599773,
0.0188523158,
0.0461393893,
-0.0062287045,
-0.0120001668,
0.0687319487,
0.009032202,
-0.0147968978,
-0.0419734418,
0.0287772492,
-0.003693165,
-0.0129805673,
0.1037529409,
-0.0263482723,
0.0480858684,
-0.0202538725,
0.0518061593,
-0.0336531661,
-0.0021420673,
0.0103138015,
0.0358757824,
0.0307562221,
0.0101394923,
0.0040626638,
0.0644762814,
-0.0030377083,
-0.0340037718,
-0.0251529757,
0.0063095549,
-0.0230535734,
-0.0166579373,
0.012504017,
-0.0406517833,
-0.0272996817,
-0.0601112619,
0.017721355,
0.0277868323,
0.0447088666,
0.036459811,
0.0225371998,
-0.0060176244,
-0.0330727808,
0.0502604172,
-0.005043006,
-0.0543629453,
-0.0471631698,
0.0057077059,
0.0353443399,
0.072533749,
0.0312068425,
-0.0578604899,
-0.0307103191,
0.0044594444,
0.0178006999,
0.0319128707,
0.0015707671,
-0.0188261382,
-0.0028136584,
-0.0332471356,
-0.00352232,
-0.000730689,
0.0129915681,
-0.0003419798,
-0.0043248343,
0.0074748602,
0.0130502274,
-0.0307845548,
-0.0068385988,
0.0107785435,
0.0023838636,
-0.030324664,
0.022370996,
-0.0045320932,
0.0112177441,
0.0361416675,
-0.0059413319,
0.0365031995,
0.0443700738,
0.0032412256,
-0.076511994,
-0.0280981921,
0.0082283048,
-0.0441541374,
0.002807687,
0.0097388532,
0.0016724423,
-0.0315690488,
-0.0139679667,
-0.0425673313,
0.0212060194,
-0.0203866307,
0.0375737734,
-0.0448031574,
-0.0168745648,
0.0321773998,
-0.0265075006,
-0.0658131689,
0.0828147009,
0.0242796894,
0.0069500851,
0.0168535765,
-0.027142074,
0.0517860763,
-0.0642991513,
-0.0003945498,
0.0260426141,
0.0223840736,
0.0312862769,
0.01655766,
-0.0235546455,
-0.0343533419,
-0.0122092161,
-0.1052699313,
0.0379368477,
-0.013381619,
0.0005272039,
0.0120787406,
0.0332044736,
0.0253278334,
-0.0103464853,
-0.0722995624,
-0.0077114422,
0.0585705377,
0.0206588786,
0.0481663533,
0.0506535098,
-0.0142116137,
-0.0378627703,
-0.0075394553,
-0.007361548,
0.0248450991,
0.0020089501,
-0.0293906908,
-0.0045263278,
0.0199431311,
-0.0563018508,
0.0739837661,
-0.0163358171,
0.0169191547,
0.0118749877,
-0.0846438184,
-0.0177138541,
0.0736784488,
0.0137519352,
0.0193443336,
-0.032813888,
-0.0256165508,
-0.0733967647,
0.0399671495,
-0.0316574797,
0.0237520989,
-0.0317131467,
-0.0043163639,
0.0491463132,
-0.0009684579,
0.0139975101,
0.0177827515,
-0.0385144465,
0.01406225,
0.0575649776,
0.0139159672,
-0.0485283099,
0.0283202082,
0.0458706468,
0.0697335899,
-0.0145453792,
0.021892529,
0.0475341491,
-0.0090238508,
-0.020352779,
-0.0300400518,
-0.0309284497,
-0.0634016171,
0.0499918647,
-0.0176091939,
0.0251573045,
-0.0205535181,
-0.0356171317,
-0.0025877319,
-0.0416395739,
0.0303260032,
-0.0294114761,
0.0457061306,
-0.0193611551,
0.0373206064,
0.0191421621,
-0.0443008952,
-0.0211100634,
-0.0464198738,
-0.0475716405,
0.0123291966,
0.0129127214,
-0.0304312259,
-0.0349999815,
-0.0322701782,
0.0019041306,
0.0009737798,
-0.0027816743,
-0.0126186991,
-0.0207370557,
0.0139808385,
0.0182618462,
0.0425480381,
-0.0107933637,
0.0091665899,
0.0722162351,
0.0651570186,
-0.0154815912,
-0.0385062918,
-0.0097166058,
-0.0054714303,
0.0075861709,
-0.035227105,
-0.0094694896,
0.0001035254,
0.0035534513,
-0.025849022,
-0.0201939717,
0.1027951241,
0.0217697136,
0.01296796,
-0.0340898298,
-0.0278471168,
0.0249409247,
0.0196891446,
0.0644332394,
-0.0790577531,
-0.0366144702,
-0.0300161373,
0.0004195469,
0.0057324385,
-0.0585760623,
0.0083905654,
-0.0934144258,
0.0409897119,
-0.024644861,
0.0232789144,
-0.0196183361,
-0.037100412,
-0.0180555265,
0.0079945065,
-0.0509011298,
0.0500103533,
-0.0097955214,
-0.0117038814,
-0.0370731205,
0.0315720364,
-0.0173218828,
0.0155022806,
-0.0044661663,
0.0058054663,
0.0493176281,
0.0617900826,
0.0172109511,
-0.0538455024,
0.0082946299,
-0.0071919132,
-0.0241667014,
-0.0093504703,
0.0450342223,
-0.0137926815,
0.0188652016,
-0.0450349152,
-0.0015117511,
-0.0094239395,
0.0425889082,
0.0052301707,
0.0619429834,
-0.0619424507,
0.0381983779,
-0.0092146005,
-0.0088125924,
0.0243074186,
0.0638956279,
-0.0197304562,
0.0234625693,
-0.0660299137,
-0.0380517989,
-0.0061051673,
0.0071823308,
-0.0090395603,
0.0363506712,
-0.0018267434,
0.0162471235,
-0.0631937534,
-0.0218453687,
0.0161636397,
0.0165922921,
-0.0044892067,
0.0069659133,
0.0300605148,
0.014939351,
-0.0368048511,
-0.005229902,
-0.0308703519,
0.0179184806,
-0.0258319788,
-0.0113146519,
0.0017891137,
-0.0414389931,
-0.0331930742,
-0.066441603,
-0.0363568291,
-0.0340648815,
-0.0379198156,
-0.0134782726,
0.0163982585,
0.0483368598,
-0.0242072064,
-0.034449067,
0.0095407981,
0.0033509366,
-0.0662113428,
-0.023328485,
0.038691178,
0.058373183,
0.0194339007,
0.069565177,
-0.0392509811,
-0.0038918264,
-0.0563728213,
0.0328622721,
-0.062015973,
-0.0569875538,
0.0280606076,
0.0415292382,
-0.0040651457,
0.1105289608,
-0.0080869757,
-0.028379092,
0.051340133,
-0.0625911132,
-0.0591281839,
-0.0680449158,
0.0110969683,
-0.0194791313,
-0.0192108322,
0.021804966,
0.0117679965,
-0.0466929562,
0.0369267799,
0.0041912948,
0.0067734434,
0.0454406328,
-0.0381240547,
0.0253382232,
-0.0097440891,
-0.005381369,
0.05343109,
0.0065869461,
0.0664256662,
-0.0304451659,
0.0464038737,
0.0267682429,
-0.0439745858,
0.0042005433,
-0.0005708378,
-0.0866534188,
-0.0952012911,
0.035059493,
-0.0078006149,
-0.0113619706,
0.0192156229,
0.0036971855,
-0.0205833353,
0.0045235432,
-0.0149539253,
0.0009556434,
0.0293951295,
-0.0280509945,
0.03865299,
0.0320829116,
-0.0150546199,
-0.0053506084,
0.0274517518,
0.0101512456,
0.0043689418,
-0.0074782735,
-0.0584254488,
-0.0481397212,
-0.0230382271,
0.0302993804,
0.0515289493,
-0.0094224,
-0.0146109201,
-0.0079662772,
-0.0087201837,
0.0142753776,
0.002892853,
-0.0573319755,
-0.0388402492,
0.0531201363,
0.064046517,
0.0430784337,
-0.0032594737,
-0.0761466771,
0.027366003,
-0.0501772352,
-0.0221912451,
-0.0326202624,
-5.904465513e-33,
-0.025928745,
-0.0205282029,
0.0497489572,
0.0123183848,
-0.0291641951,
-0.0396702141,
-0.0444779582,
-0.0039443779,
-0.0429751128,
0.0314823091,
-0.0390952677,
0.0317178257,
0.0096041467,
0.0443017595,
-0.0164051838,
-0.0338585526,
0.0243958905,
-0.0046244967,
0.0302422233,
0.0203389283,
0.0691134706,
0.0343608148,
-0.0324176028,
-0.0760956481,
0.0294982903,
0.0008455192,
0.0224548206,
0.0941464305,
0.009417193,
0.0177678727,
-0.000377305,
0.0372720547,
0.0003312802,
-0.0019638515,
-0.0064898948,
0.0169351641,
-0.095553197,
-0.0257907324,
0.0169161614,
0.0036696983,
-0.0265775491,
0.0124357948,
0.031558495,
-0.0451536849,
0.0413414352,
0.0146292588,
0.0185779538,
-0.010397709,
-0.0188528616,
-0.0538378879,
0.0056372765,
0.0247820597,
0.0053804391,
0.0096314512,
0.016987456,
0.0029288437,
0.0345008895,
0.0290070288,
-0.0326454975,
0.0271220915,
0.0036374647,
0.0370338373,
-0.0443165153,
0.0095681008,
0.0141055817,
0.0173813757,
0.0233258735,
-0.0077670445,
-0.0319961496,
0.0292784832,
-0.0410838835,
0.0692806914,
-0.0101637561,
0.0461025313,
-0.0236222297,
0.0227406155,
-0.0533851571,
0.0112280268,
-0.0074161412,
0.0268273745,
-0.02152716,
0.0332409143,
-0.0821191221,
-0.0466143452,
-0.0363775045,
0.0333878286,
-0.0449180678,
-0.011572131,
0.0331935473,
-0.0000529933,
0.003875162,
-0.0270364359,
0.0215452816,
-0.0228783675,
-0.0286123175,
0.0278728046,
0.0111999298,
-0.0386748426,
-0.0059496877,
0.0088927951,
-0.0535409972,
-0.019908946,
0.0112838764,
-0.0235122405,
-0.0261367653,
0.0489979312,
-0.0265263468,
-0.0232690163,
-0.043128673,
-0.0092569282,
-0.0230037812,
0.0074759834,
-0.0543637723,
0.0518689193,
-0.0209631119,
0.0423865616,
-0.0035416689,
0.0744668096,
-0.019266665,
0.0372831598,
-0.0413959324,
-0.0344070308,
0.0279956013,
-0.0240382012,
-0.0087078456,
-0.0004230099,
-0.0249983873,
0.0043299184,
0.0252994094,
-0.045294404,
0.0363634899,
0.0326627083,
2.636e-7,
0.0058408319,
0.0215058252,
-0.006974414,
0.0367065668,
0.0273505617,
0.0509408303,
0.0131716523,
0.0026184914,
0.0160273947,
-0.0528516173,
-0.000591004,
0.0291213803,
0.0184383895,
0.0482268222,
-0.0889391378,
-0.0469671004,
0.006479878,
-0.0553979315,
-0.0404892713,
-0.0263764728,
0.0919659957,
0.0830950812,
-0.0079143373,
0.0311511103,
-0.0290554538,
-0.0342074968,
0.0328135863,
0.0173217468,
-0.009204777,
0.0147012724,
0.0291382447,
0.0188136175,
-0.0148381479,
0.0049092392,
-0.0015487028,
0.0377120785,
-0.0068045924,
0.0758669302,
0.0026629174,
-0.0109730484,
-0.0108284838,
-0.0635342449,
-0.0019261964,
0.0195254069,
0.0865482911,
-0.0324267633,
-0.0151919322,
0.0688113943,
-0.032246761,
-0.0446891561,
-0.0343281403,
0.0083569577,
-0.0262730364,
-0.0300115701,
0.0202953536,
-0.0153188137,
0.0633561984,
-0.06664671,
0.0160167981,
-0.0101684891,
-0.0609324649,
-0.0162141435,
-0.0389045142,
0.0144496933,
0.0057394248,
-0.0200786144,
0.0228266474,
2.429700446e-34,
0.0549865998,
0.0498992801,
-0.0060164467,
0.0089184772,
0.0640728325,
0.0000769825,
0.0077604474,
-0.022857016,
0.0506372191,
-0.1276942194,
-0.0061015971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13219v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13219v1 | Interactive Visual Task Learning for Robots | 2023-12-20T17:38:04 | 2023-12-20T17:38:04 | Weiwei Gu, Anant Sah, Nakul Gopalan | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV | We present a framework for robots to learn novel visual concepts and tasks
via in-situ linguistic interactions with human users. Previous approaches have
either used large pre-trained visual models to infer novel objects zero-shot,
or added novel concepts along with their attributes and representations to a
concept hierarchy. We extend the approaches that focus on learning visual
concept hierarchies by enabling them to learn novel concepts and solve unseen
robotics tasks with them. To enable a visual concept learner to solve robotics
tasks one-shot, we developed two distinct techniques. Firstly, we propose a
novel approach, Hi-Viscont(HIerarchical VISual CONcept learner for Task), which
augments information of a novel concept to its parent nodes within a concept
hierarchy. This information propagation allows all concepts in a hierarchy to
update as novel concepts are taught in a continual learning setting. Secondly,
we represent a visual task as a scene graph with language annotations, allowing
us to create novel permutations of a demonstrated task zero-shot in-situ. We
present two sets of results. Firstly, we compare Hi-Viscont with the baseline
model (FALCON) on visual question answering(VQA) in three domains. While being
comparable to the baseline model on leaf level concepts, Hi-Viscont achieves an
improvement of over 9% on non-leaf concepts on average. We compare our model's
performance against the baseline FALCON model. Our framework achieves 33%
improvements in success rate metric, and 19% improvements in the object level
accuracy compared to the baseline model. With both of these results we
demonstrate the ability of our model to learn tasks and concepts in a continual
learning setting on the robot. | [
0.009276907,
-0.0086301174,
0.0020235521,
0.0217160899,
-0.027748378,
-0.0005340662,
-0.0199932065,
-0.0309785102,
0.0150938295,
-0.0615977049,
-0.0181807075,
0.0181140695,
-0.0152580421,
0.0673617423,
0.0121169155,
-0.0753472298,
0.0084470678,
-0.0312563628,
0.0025566234,
0.0016248394,
0.0119031444,
-0.0077833724,
-0.0391970277,
0.0395048559,
-0.0436692201,
-0.0468972065,
-0.06142902,
-0.0250355937,
0.0153702488,
-0.0463713519,
-0.0180770233,
0.0083239144,
0.0816453919,
-0.0092010321,
0.0000020438,
-0.0217025429,
-0.0031900145,
-0.0164914411,
-0.0242048893,
-0.0804542229,
-0.0240415968,
0.0019941328,
0.0202157125,
-0.0078677516,
-0.053209696,
-0.0160033815,
0.0564669222,
0.0228670258,
0.0603670999,
-0.0034304701,
-0.0151715251,
0.0046911263,
0.0120123858,
0.015124592,
0.0475728661,
-0.0477154851,
0.0148664815,
0.0708729476,
0.0327891074,
-0.0058804527,
-0.0835613236,
-0.0004520304,
0.0533513911,
-0.0118048619,
0.0491026305,
0.0561095551,
-0.0061042486,
-0.0285154767,
-0.0199236665,
0.0954957083,
-0.044089701,
-0.0000315568,
-0.0452436507,
0.0109757734,
0.0211468264,
0.0131853428,
-0.0585300438,
0.0276253745,
-0.0437724143,
-0.0149079543,
-0.0495792516,
-0.0376484208,
-0.0339286141,
0.008730744,
-0.0023294543,
0.0411774442,
-0.0150984405,
0.0138727445,
0.0045093345,
-0.0034650452,
-0.0734963566,
-0.0448943935,
-0.0446879938,
0.0541556515,
-0.0400494188,
0.0337167084,
-0.0291096885,
-0.005463548,
-0.0278885067,
-0.0406186841,
0.0540699176,
0.0253220033,
-0.0616228841,
0.0765787736,
-0.0347702652,
0.0721976086,
-0.0123289069,
0.0000808011,
-0.0293708611,
-0.0051474366,
-0.0774826258,
-0.0111256093,
-0.0743141547,
0.0459905826,
-0.0282711536,
-0.0476866439,
0.012747989,
0.0553140976,
-0.0133914528,
-0.0143291363,
-0.0158944502,
0.0396172516,
-0.0352991894,
-0.0052659712,
-0.0419163182,
0.034322504,
-0.049168665,
0.0503193028,
-0.0232972018,
-0.0117306598,
-0.0231204703,
0.011586003,
0.0351469293,
0.0064866808,
0.0034562317,
0.0494946837,
-0.0513347797,
-0.0567995273,
-0.0104478514,
-0.015261611,
0.0011018238,
-0.0152481729,
0.0295849741,
-0.0482005365,
-0.0005151647,
-0.0308337864,
-0.0021937713,
-0.0183077715,
0.0122498432,
0.0142923221,
-0.0126150744,
0.1056422144,
-0.0380221903,
-0.014694117,
0.0080106854,
0.0177139677,
-0.0388816074,
0.0579191968,
0.0170447994,
0.037519604,
0.0181981269,
0.0316664763,
0.0369397067,
0.0198821127,
-0.0285350103,
0.0149215451,
-0.0141008925,
0.0079362532,
-0.020648919,
0.0414859205,
0.0206057057,
-0.0074476143,
-0.0378065333,
0.0058288015,
0.0412856378,
0.0291761905,
-0.0424823537,
-0.0230508,
0.0406868123,
0.0150079811,
0.0089928824,
-0.038744472,
-0.0523483157,
0.0593366474,
-0.0042996504,
-0.0022878251,
-0.0709974393,
-0.0470094606,
-0.0417291299,
-0.0304764807,
0.017021386,
0.0135710938,
0.0286676381,
0.0220430903,
0.0864798427,
0.0579218939,
-0.0179085806,
-0.0446599759,
-0.0004371688,
-0.0254887249,
-0.0040620998,
-0.009348629,
0.0484773442,
0.0695127398,
0.0270841923,
-0.0206806548,
-0.0280981809,
0.0109168012,
0.0277021695,
0.0254187491,
-0.058919549,
-0.0378829576,
0.0138847809,
-0.0041260249,
-0.055040352,
-0.0273877382,
-0.0149255442,
0.02634486,
0.0245919302,
-0.0281544607,
-0.0246598758,
-0.0402884781,
0.0097578783,
0.0362944752,
0.0392715894,
0.032498572,
0.0051310682,
0.0218539294,
-0.0159681812,
0.0055093924,
0.0153212156,
-0.0161037743,
0.0310398433,
-0.0150326975,
-0.0209250581,
0.0083433297,
-0.0102311019,
-0.0465212502,
0.0355487615,
-0.0553852506,
-0.0111647602,
0.012141943,
-0.0114008784,
-0.0140107209,
0.0112618404,
-0.0313819572,
0.0180574544,
-0.0099430438,
-0.0028217023,
0.0400332846,
-0.0150970044,
-0.0259831231,
0.0714311823,
-0.0278184861,
-0.0155996652,
-0.012227755,
0.0134443603,
-0.0019294416,
-0.0378477424,
0.0141939968,
-0.0102318618,
0.0102897426,
-0.0131352628,
0.0085049896,
0.0296974145,
-0.0648223609,
0.0178659968,
-0.0775594488,
-0.0298295878,
-0.0021115926,
-0.0382499993,
0.0087203057,
-0.0242460258,
0.0112914713,
-0.0755206272,
-0.0242063738,
0.0777648911,
-0.032709565,
0.0109487316,
0.0346008167,
0.0296197645,
-0.0145398295,
-0.0288109593,
0.0123418616,
0.0097828247,
0.0512155965,
0.0502966642,
0.0003222296,
-0.0073496238,
0.0316425711,
-0.0378635861,
0.0738735422,
-0.0163173787,
-0.0072278073,
0.0454980955,
-0.0258598961,
0.0346947387,
0.1001123115,
-0.0119033372,
0.0522733144,
0.0273816437,
-0.013644713,
-0.0491900295,
0.0015405593,
-0.0155928452,
-0.0609829985,
-0.0214569066,
0.0397459976,
-0.0346617326,
0.03022971,
-0.0162151903,
-0.0113732377,
-0.083549574,
0.0443151183,
0.0042345403,
-0.0374281891,
-0.0785209537,
0.0140463971,
0.0062404703,
-0.006415599,
-0.0527503602,
-0.0544474721,
0.0621109679,
0.0107641285,
-0.0218820032,
0.0118880998,
0.0004248836,
-0.004792253,
0.1079263762,
0.0450288095,
0.0146265859,
0.0179838333,
-0.012484299,
-0.0659512058,
0.0242466498,
0.0159411989,
0.0110084899,
0.0336110368,
-0.0810406655,
0.028290702,
-0.0048236065,
-0.0346236341,
-0.0519845113,
0.0210632719,
-0.0183523912,
0.0382379256,
-0.0395402685,
-0.0248840842,
-0.0028327112,
0.0022822632,
0.0500786826,
0.0230185837,
0.0190367047,
-0.0343715735,
-0.0283582043,
0.0217908416,
0.0719215721,
0.0663468838,
-0.0579395965,
-0.0124717429,
0.0317774154,
0.0482054353,
0.0305253435,
-0.0538806878,
-0.0484564155,
0.0609322377,
-0.0011913981,
0.0139776617,
0.0104433903,
0.0248049814,
0.0076546799,
-0.0441933386,
-0.0052801957,
0.0469795577,
0.0301283952,
-0.0281841122,
0.0085293055,
-0.0050409222,
0.0146879209,
0.0741942674,
0.0187634658,
-0.1109105349,
-0.0310473386,
-0.0077584968,
0.0052943518,
0.0178699289,
-0.054725375,
-0.0358700156,
-0.1032124832,
0.0121624265,
-0.0295474473,
-0.0586612448,
-0.0242040753,
0.0092148604,
0.0091988929,
0.0013357541,
-0.0372359492,
0.0138717545,
-0.0052605192,
0.000082481,
0.0040621664,
0.0173482113,
-0.0011372432,
0.0380008891,
-0.0373735502,
-0.0347104184,
0.0352783613,
-0.0022443456,
-0.0037624361,
0.0132383984,
-0.0129067739,
-0.0052731312,
0.0138536775,
-0.0161063895,
0.0420496687,
-0.0428001992,
-0.0454785489,
0.0003305009,
0.0516235605,
-0.0141082462,
-0.0496745706,
-0.0069441153,
0.0510925055,
-0.0359286852,
0.0021848227,
-0.0001818929,
-0.0243530255,
0.0006702216,
0.0301453322,
0.0034246014,
-0.0197025612,
-0.0044468334,
-0.0129419575,
-0.0135070216,
-0.0014682467,
-0.02260595,
0.0085504968,
-0.0247871168,
0.0068933144,
-0.0702111274,
-0.0086282864,
0.0966294631,
0.0832046941,
-0.0061432738,
-0.0194236208,
0.0170960333,
0.0477303602,
-0.0795325488,
0.0583597682,
-0.0218484439,
0.0025373949,
-0.0350355357,
-0.0431384034,
0.049300909,
-0.028188955,
-0.0173162278,
-0.0165631864,
-0.0106241964,
-0.0099314898,
-0.0180319156,
0.0707298964,
0.0123577304,
0.057660386,
0.0161091425,
-0.0282722916,
0.0316866189,
0.003775385,
0.001489225,
0.0323631316,
0.0020770626,
-0.0011541693,
0.0117319673,
0.0045143687,
-0.0656609163,
-0.0042795432,
-0.0068222261,
0.0068690279,
-0.0415775105,
0.0030761713,
0.0735310838,
-0.0127155082,
0.0474272482,
-0.0104651535,
0.0187492222,
-0.0173194408,
0.0064105731,
0.0070347339,
-0.0233588293,
-0.0979651362,
0.0247727931,
-0.0062900321,
0.0113802459,
0.0317952894,
0.0290349312,
0.0154662635,
0.0348710231,
0.0121235065,
-0.0444410704,
0.0318702199,
-0.0059757326,
0.0075508286,
0.0324331298,
0.0036266691,
-0.0286885276,
-0.0329825915,
0.0509924516,
0.0361387283,
0.0918483138,
0.0439348184,
-0.0445970334,
-0.0526890717,
0.0519771017,
-0.0348825827,
-0.0727268904,
-0.0209285747,
0.0272339825,
0.06724336,
0.0457646698,
-0.0274766516,
-0.0550187603,
0.0024555614,
-0.0047035096,
0.0157629885,
-0.000198376,
-0.0701454878,
0.063996844,
0.0368537456,
0.0184489582,
0.0219453946,
0.0825885758,
0.0197863784,
0.0349181667,
-0.0439416543,
0.0168923121,
-0.0351898931,
-0.0037534791,
0.0372693576,
0.0235688929,
0.0256769173,
0.0536173992,
-0.0133637153,
-0.0386901349,
-0.0108688427,
0.0424625017,
-0.0168632213,
0.0242361855,
0.0872750953,
0.0129808206,
0.0043893456,
-0.0540083311,
-0.0313096233,
0.0086004715,
0.0162746664,
-0.0037199161,
0.0092045376,
-5.465653104e-33,
-0.0505321734,
-0.0483443141,
0.0357493013,
0.0348285288,
-0.0090153469,
0.0097607849,
-0.0422741994,
0.0459421501,
-0.0009312698,
0.0258546956,
0.0287443437,
-0.0107525457,
-0.0041699163,
0.0241855085,
0.0189346634,
-0.0373813733,
0.0218153447,
0.0039858925,
0.0041867746,
0.0069490001,
0.0325973555,
0.004751089,
0.0260435902,
-0.0387481153,
-0.0084366985,
0.0066986126,
-0.014284947,
0.0606012493,
0.0340156443,
0.0326174609,
-0.0138210421,
-0.0032213801,
0.0309830867,
-0.024974145,
-0.034320198,
0.0181747917,
-0.095475696,
-0.0165884085,
-0.0013425223,
0.0412943512,
-0.1067856178,
0.0105019817,
0.0214825291,
-0.0105994968,
0.012735243,
-0.0183505472,
0.0483339205,
-0.0400504097,
-0.0173470136,
0.0234881751,
-0.0179235395,
-0.0213126708,
-0.0049820789,
-0.0716874003,
0.0005927231,
0.0534009375,
0.0271073077,
-0.0243774056,
-0.0287187062,
0.0218364112,
-0.0337703824,
0.0196815003,
0.0711009055,
0.0480165407,
0.0477558896,
0.0611507408,
0.0505429246,
-0.041760955,
-0.0141980471,
-0.0087645818,
0.0219653882,
0.0535913482,
0.0221577361,
0.0332735516,
0.0177008342,
0.0675664619,
-0.0287147202,
0.0162822474,
-0.0486103073,
0.0944913402,
-0.0507737026,
0.0312871896,
-0.0117534576,
-0.0017910382,
-0.0381675027,
0.0184720848,
-0.0324681997,
-0.0204142574,
0.0587829836,
0.0359875523,
0.0177957974,
-0.0052680238,
0.0434580743,
-0.0468370579,
0.0096862167,
0.0322706588,
-0.0274753962,
0.0662566125,
-0.0001909693,
0.0283848811,
-0.0161500722,
-0.0014035542,
0.057682313,
-0.0218809564,
-0.0064945747,
0.0276371185,
0.0050691343,
0.054422047,
-0.0245332252,
-0.0155983819,
-0.0215035174,
-0.025870759,
0.0075868936,
0.0143172871,
0.0199425686,
0.0168830864,
-0.0561993271,
0.0506614037,
-0.0077091376,
-0.0231308956,
-0.0235696305,
-0.0010447294,
0.0001068956,
0.0017001301,
-0.0153466128,
-0.031519115,
-0.027445741,
-0.0180889387,
-0.0299581699,
-0.0628928468,
0.0026529036,
0.0557535589,
2.688e-7,
-0.0123802833,
-0.0058173453,
0.0082646841,
0.0333020277,
0.0233649854,
0.0478695258,
0.0007744895,
0.0174609274,
-0.0205217265,
-0.0417347439,
0.0013122726,
0.0736244097,
-0.0208752528,
-0.0262561236,
-0.0717655271,
-0.004741434,
0.031494163,
-0.045731429,
-0.0646397471,
-0.0032829496,
0.0465262346,
0.0654956624,
-0.0001582386,
0.0121250413,
0.0520851463,
-0.054982312,
0.06845963,
0.0186775699,
0.0132372389,
-0.0469363555,
-0.0171268564,
0.0205255095,
-0.0167353321,
0.0621636361,
-0.0101579903,
-0.0202941503,
0.0150303012,
0.0100055551,
-0.041476734,
-0.0326185338,
-0.0107902559,
0.0357509665,
0.0124713155,
-0.0224899799,
0.0739124641,
-0.098450318,
-0.0150686735,
0.0241069328,
-0.0108521953,
-0.0029607276,
-0.0144699197,
0.0047638514,
-0.040810924,
-0.0151000945,
0.0303962026,
-0.0045747925,
-0.0138670709,
-0.062430162,
0.0206828266,
0.0025351727,
-0.0492209047,
-0.0190812666,
-0.0305932425,
-0.0116717527,
0.0010726902,
0.016480688,
-0.0468172431,
1.591492618e-34,
-0.0016213153,
0.0109597631,
0.0168307107,
0.076278545,
-0.0040731914,
-0.018185975,
-0.0297351684,
-0.0089386301,
0.0637985095,
-0.0370112285,
-0.0234573949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.13211v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.13211v1 | DSFormer: Effective Compression of Text-Transformers by Dense-Sparse Weight Factorization | 2023-12-20T17:27:25 | 2023-12-20T17:27:25 | Rahul Chand, Yashoteja Prabhu, Pratyush Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the tremendous success of large transformer models in natural language
understanding, down-sizing them for cost-effective deployments has become
critical. Recent studies have explored the low-rank weight factorization
techniques which are efficient to train, and apply out-of-the-box to any
transformer architecture. Unfortunately, the low-rank assumption tends to be
over-restrictive and hinders the expressiveness of the compressed model. This
paper proposes, DSFormer, a simple alternative factorization scheme which
expresses a target weight matrix as the product of a small dense and a
semi-structured sparse matrix. The resulting approximation is more faithful to
the weight distribution in transformers and therefore achieves a stronger
efficiency-accuracy trade-off. Another concern with existing factorizers is
their dependence on a task-unaware initialization step which degrades the
accuracy of the resulting model. DSFormer addresses this issue through a novel
Straight-Through Factorizer (STF) algorithm that jointly learns all the weight
factorizations to directly maximize the final task accuracy. Extensive
experiments on multiple natural language understanding benchmarks demonstrate
that DSFormer obtains up to 40% better compression than the state-of-the-art
low-rank factorizers, leading semi-structured sparsity baselines and popular
knowledge distillation approaches. Our approach is also orthogonal to
mainstream compressors and offers up to 50% additional compression when added
to popular distilled, layer-shared and quantized transformers. We empirically
evaluate the benefits of STF over conventional optimization practices. | [
0.0076619955,
0.040447481,
0.0279852841,
0.0561312921,
0.0284730606,
0.0119079715,
-0.0035020022,
0.0021172676,
-0.0328779332,
-0.0346667506,
-0.0145810209,
-0.0209653694,
0.0129301371,
0.0230940972,
-0.0050403364,
-0.0108349919,
0.0330032334,
-0.0248454567,
-0.0546392985,
0.0355068035,
0.002166945,
0.0135884583,
-0.0090992386,
0.0443995893,
0.0102417469,
-0.0040029096,
-0.0396698378,
0.0135929007,
0.00114686,
0.0030835602,
-0.0260924064,
0.0545809194,
0.0639871359,
0.024581302,
0.0000021486,
0.0049259397,
-0.021710895,
0.0062835086,
-0.074061662,
0.016627267,
0.0358571932,
-0.0443411134,
0.0097222198,
-0.0012756555,
-0.0268933196,
-0.0594571047,
0.0477149524,
0.0787539631,
0.0835215077,
0.043652039,
-0.0089886878,
-0.0258562006,
0.0214209147,
-0.0090531437,
-0.0229461137,
-0.059087351,
0.0040693367,
-0.0153784631,
-0.0464157835,
0.014197397,
-0.0388080478,
0.0121500716,
0.0183547605,
0.0210671406,
0.0120624397,
0.0278469138,
-0.0439102352,
-0.0282330699,
-0.0120866867,
0.08772856,
-0.0198776219,
-0.0117166899,
-0.0140293427,
0.0280564371,
-0.0186074469,
-0.0270126108,
-0.0288002193,
0.0164388251,
0.0277589224,
0.0233453922,
-0.009117621,
0.0261550024,
0.0215489324,
0.0143675786,
-0.0489846468,
0.0402748473,
-0.0018450582,
-0.0151788611,
0.0037394206,
0.0102766799,
-0.0149261467,
-0.0257167779,
0.0302834567,
0.0329001248,
-0.0245135296,
0.0074521136,
-0.0299931187,
-0.047250066,
-0.020307757,
-0.0154595636,
0.0033497214,
0.0448949672,
0.0003998831,
0.0424947515,
-0.0236593727,
0.0670018867,
0.005041251,
0.009678212,
-0.0473874025,
0.0038710174,
-0.0455930047,
-0.0050116228,
-0.0535999499,
0.0682118759,
-0.0415443294,
-0.0414479636,
-0.0204200633,
0.0174856,
0.0236031432,
-0.0170265473,
0.0680947378,
0.0414296985,
-0.0487591513,
-0.0107308514,
0.009570579,
0.0860513821,
0.0098868655,
0.0226498917,
-0.0152420523,
-0.0308240857,
-0.0376223773,
0.0009469546,
0.0240227822,
-0.0141264256,
0.0073892251,
-0.0003238832,
-0.0517375916,
-0.0460496359,
-0.0300056133,
0.0035372349,
0.019443959,
-0.0462368578,
-0.0257841609,
-0.0442638472,
0.0326001868,
-0.0033302989,
0.0398580842,
-0.0556402467,
0.0166495871,
0.0232988615,
-0.047070168,
0.0804819614,
0.0018286189,
-0.011895475,
-0.0124723166,
0.0272702854,
0.0010472952,
0.0495076962,
0.0030578473,
0.0305137336,
0.004232375,
-0.0313647538,
-0.0195076652,
0.0090418709,
0.0055667982,
0.0084395288,
-0.0004389667,
-0.0135063799,
-0.0617477931,
0.0008570476,
0.0683317184,
0.0780230165,
-0.0456893742,
0.0028706111,
0.041873794,
0.0455263667,
0.0348715708,
0.0763261318,
0.0296966005,
0.0624491908,
-0.0203791615,
0.0034984392,
-0.030877322,
0.0408498906,
-0.032851126,
-0.0221211705,
0.0052567371,
0.0542653278,
-0.0495832153,
-0.0289461352,
0.0040104543,
-0.0350567587,
0.0453923792,
-0.0011618003,
0.0349010564,
0.0375689566,
-0.0510333888,
0.1174921319,
0.0099837584,
-0.0808919221,
-0.0066338084,
-0.0297747813,
-0.0153127164,
0.0143876914,
0.0336286016,
0.0207919925,
-0.0104507022,
-0.016581919,
-0.0090187378,
0.0128703322,
0.0222208854,
-0.0144384988,
0.0096186446,
-0.0835744441,
-0.043220818,
0.0099724242,
-0.0039213141,
-0.0223621074,
-0.0210627522,
0.0069765574,
0.0263654944,
-0.035785377,
0.006555595,
0.034434624,
0.0310550947,
-0.0386125594,
0.0490929075,
0.0031845758,
0.0193566196,
0.0434270091,
-0.0048898426,
-0.0176343415,
0.0414088182,
-0.0279851109,
-0.0394210033,
-0.0192414522,
-0.0397337936,
-0.0608325005,
0.0117305145,
-0.041526828,
0.0092776874,
0.1110584065,
-0.0601698831,
-0.0473815463,
-0.0044953041,
-0.0625892282,
0.0112572452,
-0.0240285937,
0.0063600307,
0.0088364594,
0.032666754,
-0.013649716,
0.050322663,
-0.022050593,
-0.0056853355,
0.0076683718,
-0.0595822632,
0.0257599168,
-0.0061708051,
-0.053816393,
-0.0160105471,
-0.0523019992,
0.0063108676,
0.0088838087,
0.0025438815,
0.0016540636,
0.0068386653,
-0.0570468344,
0.0169041492,
-0.046501454,
-0.0017505672,
0.0276584011,
0.0444887727,
0.0562854037,
-0.0080718938,
-0.0522803329,
-0.0026083612,
-0.0072417664,
-0.0045824619,
-0.0176227111,
0.0053436826,
0.0057013831,
0.0012329279,
-0.0494207442,
0.0159315933,
0.0621646941,
-0.0315948948,
-0.0039276071,
-0.0709563345,
0.0444456898,
-0.0180129632,
0.0152434027,
-0.0176273007,
-0.0327261537,
-0.0160065349,
-0.0080780974,
0.0389605612,
0.0451081768,
0.027985191,
0.0467383191,
0.0656273067,
0.0346596837,
-0.0372883417,
0.0195332393,
-0.0444227196,
-0.0130766639,
-0.0447411686,
-0.0311139002,
0.0178809483,
0.0917529613,
-0.01658017,
-0.0125734946,
-0.0711357892,
-0.0594677739,
-0.0187764037,
-0.0148250619,
-0.0291231647,
-0.0099112997,
0.0042034802,
-0.0035897277,
0.0015228755,
0.0135407373,
0.0836483985,
-0.0418548621,
-0.0342284702,
-0.0524517708,
-0.0297887698,
-0.0455700792,
0.0072861337,
-0.0174154826,
0.0135962991,
-0.0174859092,
0.002513567,
-0.0426743552,
0.0362839587,
0.0076598139,
-0.0326726548,
0.0618951283,
-0.004967011,
0.0026168844,
-0.0480287038,
-0.0488033481,
-0.0312558189,
-0.0396496356,
-0.02241439,
0.0265347529,
0.0705130696,
-0.0194633696,
-0.0659132972,
0.0362349376,
0.0174732134,
0.0451202728,
0.009239411,
-0.0134878019,
-0.0236752387,
0.0612836927,
0.0493840724,
0.038207721,
0.0666218102,
-0.002032428,
0.0346742235,
0.0635735542,
0.0361636765,
-0.0420596898,
-0.0337822065,
0.0074218251,
0.0510443524,
-0.0152183315,
-0.021894373,
0.0207935218,
0.0242257379,
-0.0403174348,
0.0017063608,
0.1041620672,
0.0308719762,
-0.0792286247,
0.0165790636,
0.0008018993,
0.04239228,
0.0366210788,
0.0143066747,
-0.0801847801,
-0.043939475,
0.0137624145,
0.0195472911,
0.0627707615,
-0.027708495,
-0.0141817471,
-0.0710501894,
0.0244752783,
-0.0032378568,
0.0477598198,
-0.006049783,
-0.0474485643,
-0.0218454264,
-0.056265451,
0.0156862438,
0.0025810779,
-0.004445442,
-0.0042983484,
0.0244427659,
-0.0142805418,
-0.039441552,
0.0103083542,
0.0084398063,
0.0262374841,
-0.0139574865,
0.0138220293,
0.0137697579,
-0.0636666343,
-0.0121652102,
-0.0172004588,
-0.0057818466,
-0.0121298796,
0.0419336148,
-0.0041023218,
0.0001132613,
-0.0195282269,
0.0261516757,
-0.0501007214,
-0.0111898798,
-0.0363555066,
0.0840717033,
-0.0023031409,
-0.0256569367,
0.0173684657,
-0.0410438888,
-0.0208790395,
0.0860098302,
0.0073031061,
-0.0120661249,
-0.0500170328,
0.0043488257,
0.0183378812,
-0.0258980636,
-0.0938185602,
0.0339658707,
0.0212443545,
-0.0203566961,
-0.0244462192,
-0.0060052522,
0.0131287454,
0.0121805705,
-0.0221065804,
-0.0156218363,
0.0018865399,
0.0173449386,
-0.068313539,
0.0335537679,
-0.004732959,
0.0120941838,
-0.022526456,
0.0063856421,
0.0277257543,
-0.0026816176,
-0.0079485951,
0.0047642207,
-0.1057317555,
-0.009524283,
-0.0077623772,
0.0241992921,
0.0157089904,
0.0465644039,
0.0000955713,
-0.0408863164,
0.0454338752,
0.0160270743,
-0.0689602271,
0.021623848,
0.0241927169,
-0.0532183871,
-0.0029277226,
0.0395784415,
-0.0384225696,
0.0181765985,
-0.038752947,
0.0619581267,
-0.0506188497,
-0.033188276,
0.0363667458,
-0.001786769,
0.0456605144,
-0.0044686352,
0.0387029275,
0.0142093813,
0.0455505438,
0.0107466355,
-0.0016780369,
-0.0649778843,
0.0035512762,
0.0488384813,
0.0103593851,
0.0125742676,
0.05672713,
0.0073036351,
0.0380965509,
-0.0199745838,
0.0095093288,
0.0079717282,
-0.0480343252,
0.04655312,
0.0086319419,
-0.0265131239,
-0.0270399861,
0.041990649,
0.0105253346,
-0.0216530915,
0.0296123829,
0.001721655,
0.0298739541,
-0.0479023308,
0.0306835249,
-0.0446837619,
-0.040948391,
-0.0144252721,
-0.0242325868,
0.0194409452,
0.0027786174,
0.0535448343,
0.0088048605,
-0.0126809925,
-0.0020864545,
-0.0070099412,
-0.0119297784,
-0.0260154661,
0.0569684729,
0.0114397984,
0.0077594914,
0.0142416749,
0.1032807454,
0.0045630569,
0.0293615777,
-0.0208249819,
-0.0180556625,
-0.0665754676,
-0.031772878,
-0.0142104914,
0.0570808388,
-0.0075591351,
0.0059338729,
-0.0259479564,
-0.0658905208,
0.0147519894,
-0.0624261387,
0.001204389,
-0.0587185062,
0.0429945439,
0.0260689519,
0.0080877393,
-0.0281893238,
0.0073649152,
-0.0250918213,
-0.0372560211,
-0.0118285269,
-0.0233826842,
-6.564867055e-33,
0.0049096034,
0.013638583,
0.0061073997,
0.039531704,
-0.0246122219,
0.0373723507,
-0.0170555394,
-0.0103130322,
-0.0228515901,
0.0200611912,
-0.0140588675,
0.0053073331,
0.0037669849,
0.0452353433,
-0.0384316333,
-0.0033691912,
0.0768787414,
-0.0248470344,
-0.0101666721,
0.0238601547,
0.0090017691,
0.0426454842,
0.0321230404,
-0.0395311601,
-0.0358663127,
0.0122782215,
-0.0068258126,
0.0049169827,
0.0389009044,
0.0338042341,
-0.0494365618,
0.0439128764,
0.0379937701,
-0.0805305243,
-0.028608935,
0.0258339196,
-0.1066642776,
-0.000537337,
0.0227500089,
0.0269800685,
-0.0323985331,
-0.0122193638,
0.0252754446,
0.0197051298,
0.011939208,
-0.0510166138,
0.0210460629,
-0.00690619,
-0.0320601612,
-0.0786041096,
-0.0195928048,
-0.0050783842,
-0.0454299562,
-0.0371910818,
0.0595667399,
0.0662062913,
-0.0461928584,
0.0271246321,
-0.079470247,
0.0020203518,
-0.0160435606,
0.0596499667,
0.0624363683,
0.0063223196,
-0.0280816201,
0.0194121655,
-0.0303759277,
-0.025921192,
-0.0679791495,
-0.0120721897,
0.0084109176,
0.0592204183,
0.0298001543,
0.0452059321,
0.0572462603,
0.0215769559,
-0.0601853207,
0.0224737991,
-0.0055002947,
0.0625982657,
0.0360318609,
0.0360924937,
0.012372789,
-0.019455228,
-0.0472419672,
0.0401394032,
-0.0317791961,
-0.0197757073,
0.0113172187,
0.0550807156,
-0.0477916263,
0.0061901915,
0.0438798405,
-0.0760114789,
0.0162556227,
0.0396118574,
-0.0050936723,
0.005772599,
0.0201514997,
-0.0086448397,
-0.0590625405,
-0.0000963261,
0.0438228548,
-0.0091810059,
-0.0032615508,
-0.0051863641,
0.0523282029,
0.0480756238,
-0.0360256135,
-0.0328808576,
-0.0174678192,
-0.0112914871,
-0.0231896676,
0.0658609644,
0.0333894081,
0.0253709853,
-0.0372242108,
0.0194914248,
-0.0192365013,
0.0461519137,
-0.0090988381,
0.0165148489,
0.0371321775,
0.0302555002,
-0.0411511324,
-0.0224419292,
-0.0534634031,
-0.0132872453,
0.0545519926,
-0.0676498264,
-0.0294339955,
0.0266980659,
2.771e-7,
0.0344347097,
0.0137840295,
0.0032757276,
-0.0361952558,
0.0079058344,
0.0262060035,
0.03855462,
0.012060076,
0.0093115252,
-0.0263306666,
0.0326614752,
0.0487214625,
0.0153762223,
0.004116815,
-0.0786654875,
-0.0099680545,
-0.0523308553,
-0.0182767566,
-0.0372990221,
-0.026707137,
0.0546168536,
0.1168623418,
-0.0287502706,
-0.0228061266,
0.0194395334,
0.0394958518,
0.0557931811,
0.0092058666,
0.0322010405,
-0.0006601783,
0.0490115583,
-0.03052097,
-0.0170628652,
0.0101735052,
-0.01917555,
0.0303191785,
0.0085029127,
0.0677190796,
-0.0147710303,
-0.0166030824,
0.0149130989,
-0.0157689266,
-0.0096260896,
-0.0332396328,
0.0729356334,
-0.05950021,
-0.0237302165,
-0.0134193497,
-0.0538594611,
-0.0054616942,
-0.0303875376,
0.0154476166,
0.0450490899,
0.0283589456,
0.0283799693,
-0.0104110669,
-0.0292945597,
-0.1021312103,
-0.0200338997,
0.0024851204,
-0.0482851304,
-0.0124897975,
-0.0504406169,
-0.0562482737,
0.0571179837,
-0.0144550158,
-0.0045808982,
2.613724546e-34,
0.0176169984,
0.0229603853,
0.0306823757,
0.0243503693,
0.0038588697,
-0.0372722968,
-0.0023344713,
0.0060803699,
0.0085164299,
-0.1156813279,
-0.0047550355
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.