id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09254v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09254v1 | TextGrad: Advancing Robustness Evaluation in NLP by Gradient-Driven Optimization | 2022-12-19T05:55:58 | 2022-12-19T05:55:58 | Bairu Hou, Jinghan Jia, Yihua Zhang, Guanhua Zhang, Yang Zhang, Sijia Liu, Shiyu Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Robustness evaluation against adversarial examples has become increasingly
important to unveil the trustworthiness of the prevailing deep models in
natural language processing (NLP). However, in contrast to the computer vision
domain where the first-order projected gradient descent (PGD) is used as the
benchmark approach to generate adversarial examples for robustness evaluation,
there lacks a principled first-order gradient-based robustness evaluation
framework in NLP. The emerging optimization challenges lie in 1) the discrete
nature of textual inputs together with the strong coupling between the
perturbation location and the actual content, and 2) the additional constraint
that the perturbed text should be fluent and achieve a low perplexity under a
language model. These challenges make the development of PGD-like NLP attacks
difficult. To bridge the gap, we propose TextGrad, a new attack generator using
gradient-driven optimization, supporting high-accuracy and high-quality
assessment of adversarial robustness in NLP. Specifically, we address the
aforementioned challenges in a unified optimization framework. And we develop
an effective convex relaxation method to co-optimize the continuously-relaxed
site selection and perturbation variables and leverage an effective sampling
method to establish an accurate mapping from the continuous optimization
variables to the discrete textual perturbations. Moreover, as a first-order
attack generation method, TextGrad can be baked into adversarial training to
further improve the robustness of NLP models. Extensive experiments are
provided to demonstrate the effectiveness of TextGrad not only in attack
generation for robustness evaluation but also in adversarial defense. | [
-0.4461055994,
-1.0759919882,
-0.0287664142,
0.2649223208,
0.0114340074,
0.1689618677,
-0.3113724589,
0.1930954903,
-0.2871406674,
0.2915568948,
-0.5966809988,
-0.72035712,
-0.6553685665,
0.1224618405,
-0.5076664686,
1.4150321484,
0.2037663013,
0.007822576,
-0.1049822718,
-0.2218700796,
-0.1030864194,
-0.4542555511,
-1.0095055103,
-0.3767021298,
0.2302420139,
-0.3235920072,
0.7693751454,
0.3119359612,
0.8084353805,
0.2763291597,
-0.3460372984,
-0.1731236726,
-0.6617785096,
0.2647350132,
-0.0511320047,
-0.1893726289,
-0.3746802211,
-0.2239859551,
0.5197730064,
0.5777554512,
-0.2076945454,
-0.1100625619,
0.216873914,
0.7835079432,
-0.7348563671,
-0.3838542104,
-0.9691032767,
0.2773362398,
-0.039027188,
-0.1900313348,
-0.3161401451,
-0.2532052398,
0.4071931541,
-0.6612665057,
0.4295683205,
-0.3252772391,
0.7852755189,
0.588470161,
0.0316844992,
-0.4058004916,
-0.2423354983,
0.9835911393,
-0.6613432765,
0.0997141749,
0.1054186895,
0.0935017914,
-0.2818863988,
-0.823497355,
-0.1722176224,
-0.2669863105,
0.2202934772,
0.1363622844,
-0.4014654756,
0.1994283497,
0.2450158,
0.511721909,
-0.6847373843,
0.0473623127,
0.1031283811,
-0.2783572674,
0.4887430072,
0.0685474947,
0.5179209709,
-0.2098501921,
-0.5893970728,
-0.208676219,
-0.3790868223,
0.0506613106,
0.5438948274,
0.3148314357,
0.0305150263,
0.164842099,
0.023875773,
0.6119194031,
0.1237031594,
0.1057577357,
-0.0006080265,
-0.4388186336,
-0.1971045583,
-0.2305643409,
1.0188412666,
0.4147064388,
0.1185188815,
-0.1590881497,
-0.3466514349,
0.1577563584,
0.634041667,
-0.8331957459,
-0.4615794718,
0.2742213309,
-0.4430588484,
-0.9397287369,
-0.2216134071,
-1.3682435751,
-0.4954180717,
0.24699907,
0.297511369,
-0.481230557,
-0.0265108235,
0.3055826128,
-0.1032348275,
0.0919119045,
0.1198318079,
-1.0561747551,
0.4828915894,
0.7943438888,
0.8230934739,
-0.5154935122,
-0.2459254265,
-0.5614423156,
-0.2545048892,
-0.2312411368,
0.4147993922,
-0.3892561793,
-0.5362625122,
0.2194502056,
-0.5102707148,
-0.0804758295,
-0.4224327207,
1.1652312279,
-0.3623484671,
0.4203149378,
0.2071002573,
-0.1768375784,
0.0963637903,
0.6816961765,
-0.5687196255,
1.3047639132,
0.1722209603,
-1.2856837511,
0.2144552022,
-0.7598367929,
-0.4150055349,
-0.1434340775,
-0.0043273107,
-0.7068576217,
0.0627582371,
0.556376636,
0.2825362682,
-0.2588617206,
0.2318644673,
-0.2141463757,
-0.2114436179,
-0.0282581486,
-0.6551331878,
1.071413517,
0.0512702689,
-0.3095840514,
0.0220405925,
-0.8574216962,
0.1157654598,
0.1287157685,
-0.6292603612,
-0.4578549564,
0.2179763764,
0.0721032321,
-0.1791047305,
0.145170331,
-0.2931796312,
0.2673878074,
-0.879614532,
0.2375616133,
0.7956342697,
0.101684764,
0.6146959066,
0.0452532545,
0.8603405356,
-0.6103405356,
0.2858834267,
-0.1234164014,
-0.2687798738,
-0.5172336698,
-0.108736515,
0.380951792,
0.7597101927,
-0.8433929086,
0.3482055664,
-0.1647760272,
-0.3899463415,
-0.2470909059,
0.1850560755,
0.7034758329,
0.706158936,
0.4607414007,
-0.0094870282,
-0.3890762031,
-0.5596427321,
-0.676627636,
-0.2794628441,
-0.3304274678,
-0.0756568387,
0.3706545234,
-0.3375103474,
0.4994818568,
-0.5305076241,
-0.2100048363,
-0.1800812185,
0.2694058716,
0.0292937644,
0.5119529366,
0.8811728358,
-0.8103666306,
-0.3848908544,
-0.1466033012,
-0.5451091528,
-0.2545583546,
-0.2346972525,
-0.1847061813,
-0.1234932691,
0.496173501,
-0.3899415433,
0.2309846878,
0.5036991835,
-0.2026935518,
0.529712379,
-0.0071120453,
-0.0902485996,
-1.0174491405,
-0.0789932832,
0.2203769684,
-0.1237301901,
-0.7347581983,
0.5683972836,
-0.4609790444,
-0.3096701801,
-0.2216575146,
0.3371825218,
-0.0855486318,
0.3903256357,
-0.0985322297,
0.2483106703,
0.0572017953,
0.3424997628,
-0.4675497711,
0.6396480799,
0.7703077197,
-0.6424432397,
0.2693032026,
0.2960890532,
-0.1176704243,
0.6459290385,
-0.8018772602,
0.1597716063,
-0.0993654057,
0.0742499456,
-0.7662394643,
0.1086216047,
0.2031081915,
-0.7959276438,
0.5197586417,
-0.0494969338,
0.0192439593,
-0.2069218606,
-0.7401913404,
0.2901898921,
0.3248544335,
-0.5489256978,
0.6074314713,
0.1462048292,
-0.2877627909,
-1.0097714663,
-0.7315366864,
0.3359789848,
-0.2227206081,
-0.5857590437,
0.5324929357,
-0.1806908101,
-0.3970448077,
-0.3984439671,
-0.0600546524,
-0.1154626459,
0.4229132235,
-0.2050244361,
0.025844479,
-0.1863092929,
-0.2131212056,
0.1415873617,
-0.2667894661,
0.4093375206,
-0.2860386968,
0.4791996181,
-0.0392714702,
0.0730267093,
-0.3875821233,
0.3599471152,
0.4492433071,
-0.1297964901,
0.3931400478,
0.7955740094,
-0.4584414959,
-0.5001752377,
0.0301392227,
-0.0768182278,
-0.5165784359,
0.7083578706,
-0.3238453269,
-0.5079907775,
0.1875841469,
-0.1588127017,
0.2760805786,
0.5173504353,
0.4505396485,
0.006888615,
0.9844616652,
0.5573533177,
-0.1655800492,
0.3731418252,
-0.2424116582,
-0.0237006564,
-0.6702386141,
-0.0055041476,
-0.9078166485,
-0.0968406275,
-0.516024828,
-0.0429331064,
0.0747737363,
0.1897010058,
-0.1594006121,
0.1983018667,
-0.5898084044,
0.3975307941,
0.3432947695,
0.0193241574,
0.0468737334,
0.255767256,
-0.3812475204,
-0.4206704795,
-0.5617626905,
-0.4986868799,
0.9919686913,
0.2944470942,
0.7045125365,
0.0096913194,
0.5963056684,
0.5448907614,
0.1615790129,
-0.7799626589,
0.5756953359,
-0.5053411722,
-0.2632430196,
-0.0771242604,
-0.6426047683,
-0.7202610373,
0.2079222649,
-0.414114356,
-0.6653564572,
-0.0584620833,
0.1246889308,
-0.2556509674,
0.2575899661,
-0.3101925552,
0.7456178069,
-0.0001154216,
-0.2500735819,
0.0995914713,
-0.6060407162,
0.2556148171,
-0.2493444383,
0.1648927331,
0.2936162353,
-0.0749780685,
0.7260124683,
-0.3961223066,
0.4410952032,
-0.327161938,
-0.4124893248,
-0.0233034007,
0.2789254189,
0.4218178093,
0.3036490679,
-0.4436437786,
0.0106911473,
-0.2662829161,
-0.3941932917,
-0.8354625106,
0.7075400949,
-0.4308727086,
-0.5192734003,
-0.1719366461,
-0.2035703063,
-0.2446682304,
0.2487878948,
0.657830894,
0.6814121604,
-0.527359128,
0.227256462,
0.8094245195,
-0.46679914,
0.6325175762,
-0.0729061291,
-0.1370930225,
-0.852173388,
0.9086980224,
-0.4616995156,
0.3835452795,
0.6251494884,
0.2521090209,
-0.1978424639,
-0.981623888,
-0.4094817042,
-0.4584439397,
-0.6893041134,
-0.2947142124,
-0.5842304826,
0.0157333277,
-0.2183268219,
-0.4380914569,
-0.4849676788,
-0.3337825537,
-0.2893874943,
-0.0835062712,
-0.1175905317,
0.3472786844,
0.1780506521,
0.3297221959,
-0.4983089268,
0.5375926495,
0.1442757696,
0.1133434772,
-0.3226031661,
-0.478374064,
-0.0168364998,
-0.0631837845,
-0.4599876106,
-0.6663454771,
0.2843267322,
0.4307317436,
0.3018841147,
0.5408300757,
0.2310585976,
0.17285797,
-0.4223513901,
0.9170547724,
0.1883255094,
-0.945201695,
0.7175914049,
-0.5602763295,
0.2870340347,
0.9416623712,
0.1985885948,
-0.0475417525,
-0.3224782944,
-0.3880453408,
-0.8446638584,
0.2822396457,
0.4993410408,
0.3749011159,
0.0980328098,
0.6204238534,
-0.0023386853,
0.1305503696,
-0.8731719255,
-0.4743613005,
-0.3072578311,
-0.3080782592,
0.1552252769,
-0.1374367476,
-0.1499773413,
-0.0634962171,
0.7241271138,
-0.154182896,
0.1737505645,
0.1910580248,
0.1245576516,
0.2978123128,
0.1184074283,
0.4511811137,
0.3106865287,
-0.1109806523,
-0.0551101007,
0.1828775108,
-0.9554485083,
0.1164776161,
0.2810083628,
-0.6733675003,
0.1353458017,
0.3745783567,
0.5406604409,
0.0494547859,
-0.433818996,
0.7844096422,
-0.490332216,
-0.3270480931,
0.0451536141,
-0.0152211301,
-0.5418462157,
-0.1326554269,
0.4471605122,
0.45953089,
0.2840218842,
-0.0187380034,
0.2393366396,
0.6534019113,
-0.6061973572,
-0.1226152554,
0.9197537899,
0.3309144974,
-0.4730611145,
0.3677462935,
-0.202085495,
-0.8459317088,
0.5500000119,
0.404735744,
1.0806626081,
-0.2574424446,
0.2973717153,
0.3933289051,
0.6449308991,
0.0842478499,
0.0850602165,
0.0800090879,
-0.5518493056,
-0.2950010002,
-0.7195109725,
-0.320058912,
0.0797878802,
-0.8451964855,
0.3181895316,
-0.8288796544,
-0.304631114,
-0.2210615128,
0.0761898682,
-0.0910558105,
0.5856153965,
-0.2178713083,
0.773165524,
-0.3443993628,
0.2611404359,
0.6424072385,
-0.0581527315,
-0.0416384116,
0.484822005,
-0.0007423019,
-0.4068158567,
0.2563729882,
0.0962685123,
-0.3768846989,
-0.046113953,
-0.5651922226,
-0.2827889025,
0.6280809641,
0.66181463,
-0.2787524462,
-0.0660773441,
-0.1747292429,
0.6107570529,
0.0893781707,
-0.0047682398,
0.3105530739,
0.2318823934,
-0.274821341,
-0.2890672982,
0.0707981586,
-0.4728771448,
0.1157872006,
0.3340342343,
-0.4712468088,
0.6164740324,
-0.106799148,
-0.3046632111,
0.1644990295,
0.6837178469,
-0.1028792337,
0.2228438556,
0.4319844544,
0.8291231394,
0.7028089166,
-0.2699550986,
1.234194994,
-0.2690352201,
0.4112763107,
0.9233973622,
0.1783166379,
0.7593531609,
0.3326175213,
-0.2220495343,
0.4267044365,
0.4648444951,
-0.1677668542,
0.6395245194,
0.4015203416,
-0.4660532475,
0.1523836255,
0.0685692877,
-0.400741607,
0.3058125973,
0.3110804856,
-0.3262009025,
-0.2341335118,
0.0541548319,
0.2697404921,
0.4582391977,
-0.3222406209,
0.6906015873,
-0.0703056604,
-0.5632039905,
0.7974370122,
0.3108894825,
1.000706315,
-0.6215394735,
0.2295906097,
-0.2923701406,
0.2314905673,
-0.2650720179,
-0.2376672029,
0.2517565489,
0.2551411986,
-0.1550601721,
-0.2308185399,
0.7971402407,
-0.0253526829,
-0.3875364363,
0.3629939556,
-0.0371737555,
-0.2826476097,
-0.0754419565,
-1.003898859,
0.0168918837,
0.1463235468,
-0.4395131171,
0.2535558343,
0.2372137457,
0.5635751486,
0.591009438,
0.6037449241,
0.1525124311,
0.0396869518,
0.1860744804,
0.8572060466,
-0.2968685925,
-0.2225641757,
-1.2162899971,
0.2773973942,
-0.2425723821,
-0.7036138177,
0.683906436,
0.3660372198,
0.5847674012,
0.1716616154,
0.868078351,
0.2161011398,
0.2464840114,
-0.7637386918,
0.8606773615,
-0.4816551805,
0.3755532503,
-0.7776778936,
-0.9751858711,
-0.6254655719,
0.5986306667,
0.1103743315,
0.0391824841,
0.8022485375,
0.6887947321,
0.2017900944,
-0.0458537005,
0.0436652713,
0.0763309747,
0.4206131101,
0.5043390989,
0.5553466082,
-0.6641508341,
0.8292725086,
-0.1494844109,
-0.1940971762,
0.392686516,
-0.9962888956,
-1.1697964668,
-0.2334965318,
-0.5704881549,
-0.5379103422,
0.1785634011,
0.5846766829,
0.2865581512,
-0.6668181419,
0.3493362069,
-0.6450513005,
0.0371264406,
0.0519778505,
-0.3235451579,
0.4224480987,
-0.4410553277,
-0.8690370321,
0.5986391306,
0.3558868468,
0.0984475985,
-0.5564185381,
0.0239340886,
-0.0753710866,
0.1383654475,
0.4000713825,
0.1909476966,
-0.3839100301,
0.1965134889,
-0.1411145926,
-0.1595633477,
-0.0295022763,
0.7649636865,
-0.6065837741,
0.4547558129,
0.4261388481,
1.2997766733,
0.005583155,
0.1278385073,
0.8166816831,
-0.9906264544,
0.0762610212,
0.3494061232,
0.1189458594,
0.5173074603,
-0.32340464,
0.4604980052,
0.12388587,
-0.3911039233,
-0.9649412632,
0.2496510148,
-0.6401147842,
-0.1272091269,
1.0342694521,
-0.3035247624,
-0.0437111557,
-0.0495122895,
-0.2880884707,
-0.1088293344,
-0.2783617079,
0.8645540476,
0.7661914825,
0.4241378605,
0.0592173263,
-0.4230059981,
0.8833194971,
0.732514143,
-0.8757894635,
-0.0309874639,
0.2288363278,
-0.1736323088,
0.2116946727,
0.4122033417,
-0.2090205699,
0.1179954708,
0.2342711985,
-0.3567547798,
0.2748022079,
-0.1155060902,
-0.593955636,
0.5476540923,
-0.2666337788,
-0.0759670809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09252v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09252v2 | Mind the Knowledge Gap: A Survey of Knowledge-enhanced Dialogue Systems | 2022-12-19T05:17:33 | 2022-12-20T17:52:24 | Sagi Shaier, Lawrence Hunter, Katharina Kann | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Many dialogue systems (DSs) lack characteristics humans have, such as emotion
perception, factuality, and informativeness. Enhancing DSs with knowledge
alleviates this problem, but, as many ways of doing so exist, keeping track of
all proposed methods is difficult. Here, we present the first survey of
knowledge-enhanced DSs. We define three categories of systems - internal,
external, and hybrid - based on the knowledge they use. We survey the
motivation for enhancing DSs with knowledge, used datasets, and methods for
knowledge search, knowledge encoding, and knowledge incorporation. Finally, we
propose how to improve existing systems based on theories from linguistics and
cognitive science. | [
-0.8639783263,
-0.224440977,
0.9050037861,
-0.3032639027,
0.1246760786,
0.5275790095,
0.0324324593,
-0.4070581496,
0.4863004088,
0.2676368952,
-0.6589964032,
-0.1264435947,
-0.6418200135,
0.0825570598,
0.0485878885,
0.6789832711,
0.332171768,
0.1905626059,
-0.29603526,
-0.1096230298,
-0.303489089,
-0.5121725798,
-0.4407565892,
-0.2494992167,
0.2676772475,
0.4283975363,
0.5500485301,
-0.3230079412,
0.217018351,
0.2682102621,
-0.4488318563,
0.450499326,
-0.3041557968,
0.1361356229,
-0.2186028361,
-0.6455124021,
-0.2656450868,
-0.2925746739,
0.3247219324,
1.0122721195,
-0.091512464,
-0.1519000232,
0.1592403203,
0.7515952587,
-0.7641906738,
0.2102749944,
-0.1770221591,
0.2036890537,
0.0116894795,
-0.0440557301,
0.1873837262,
-0.7012401223,
0.6988397241,
-0.8133127093,
0.1725770086,
-0.0100612408,
0.3281009495,
0.355181545,
-0.6477202177,
-0.3552682698,
-0.8183102012,
0.6336170435,
-0.6137516499,
0.5214289427,
0.4729949534,
0.196047172,
-0.0959747136,
-0.2562589645,
-0.6024759412,
0.1019011736,
-0.2376293093,
0.2894899547,
-0.2245059013,
0.5097994804,
0.4176309407,
0.5698661804,
-0.1099059954,
-0.2534536421,
-0.5855714083,
-0.4877281189,
0.5013693571,
0.4015241563,
0.3959516585,
0.0079391766,
-0.0542951748,
0.0295951869,
-0.7290612459,
0.2329807729,
0.3873351216,
-0.2959061265,
0.1733814478,
0.4461143017,
-0.6408746839,
0.7982957959,
-0.0936856791,
-0.2455577403,
-0.0638560504,
-0.4805137217,
-0.119506456,
-0.0216159057,
0.3516416252,
0.5374099016,
-0.1018581912,
-0.1204668507,
-0.1424908936,
0.2590209544,
0.048143357,
-0.2011215389,
-0.1846367419,
-0.0716969371,
-0.1954626739,
-0.0314869732,
-0.0785184652,
-0.7100530863,
-0.8049921393,
-0.2915958166,
0.2922076583,
-0.5700756907,
-0.7251340747,
0.1974810064,
-0.7268670797,
-0.0197136533,
0.5491246581,
-0.8665344119,
0.6944172382,
0.3650510311,
0.6282894015,
0.0453779101,
0.2392457724,
0.2171521932,
0.2127858251,
-0.4174509943,
0.9267703891,
-0.6132976413,
-0.4782367945,
0.0362330489,
-0.289090097,
0.0860252008,
-0.6962037086,
0.4341603816,
-0.4684007168,
0.5939919949,
-0.8787667155,
-0.8470749855,
-0.4390207529,
0.0310674179,
-0.366143167,
0.6903782487,
0.3440558314,
-0.7061779499,
0.5028792024,
-0.9964137077,
-0.1901618838,
0.1620596349,
-0.4088820517,
0.4708855152,
0.2353458405,
0.2953008711,
0.1215559021,
-0.386465013,
0.2206495255,
-0.2099729776,
-0.4437765777,
0.1472364515,
-0.2150380164,
0.8422361612,
0.4116982818,
-0.1509582549,
-0.303324759,
-0.5605543256,
0.0477598831,
-0.3160094321,
-0.2295004725,
-0.4722301066,
-0.0182138439,
-0.7602951527,
0.0394813195,
0.1255790889,
-0.7112746835,
0.131982699,
-0.4988537729,
0.1598291397,
0.6227059364,
0.2406357676,
0.4542572498,
-0.5542266369,
0.6217182279,
0.5074597597,
0.0063890596,
-0.1936756968,
-0.5899633765,
-1.2173420191,
0.0642175302,
0.0614528097,
0.668849349,
-1.0234782696,
0.5524798036,
-0.11170616,
-0.2556362748,
-0.5495046377,
0.005507037,
0.3119900227,
0.1317071617,
0.1678439081,
-0.6001803875,
-0.5453937054,
-0.8490612507,
-0.3129837513,
-0.2288084477,
-0.328319639,
0.4005752504,
0.0102188112,
0.0698033497,
1.1278231144,
-0.7760831714,
-0.0386716276,
-0.1712632477,
-0.0576289259,
-0.0659828037,
0.2187661678,
0.1383394003,
-0.3304978311,
-0.0821680725,
-0.2071903199,
-0.9341451526,
-0.087962769,
0.3786033392,
0.2349678576,
0.0086150514,
0.5445389152,
-0.6223737001,
0.5434877276,
0.2344627678,
-0.4198480546,
0.434056133,
-0.0662659481,
0.2307020426,
-0.9848805666,
-0.3352059424,
0.0884630606,
0.1624786109,
-0.8560638428,
-0.5908846855,
-0.1964226365,
-0.1681213677,
0.0663603768,
0.4084886014,
-0.6332535744,
-0.1869461387,
-0.1020962968,
0.3932808936,
0.0865833461,
0.5918049812,
0.1258468926,
0.6832404733,
0.7377173305,
-0.9800206423,
0.6096380949,
0.3899603784,
-0.7521998882,
0.8179466128,
-0.2397958785,
0.2865549922,
-0.2124940008,
0.3423777521,
-0.831597805,
-0.4621608257,
0.359246403,
-0.4175129831,
0.1330285519,
0.0134805813,
-0.1099328399,
-0.5036070943,
0.1621108502,
0.3526132405,
0.4450855851,
-0.2459130734,
0.1821188033,
0.6796129346,
-0.642377615,
-0.4515298903,
-0.1636635363,
0.3090831339,
-0.1862073392,
-0.648004055,
0.0540570952,
0.0295637101,
-0.5745069385,
-0.0456931703,
-0.2320153564,
-0.2175421417,
-0.146896407,
-0.0958938226,
0.0000275977,
-0.2447167188,
0.5831710696,
0.2793539762,
0.0244765282,
0.133925423,
-0.4164654613,
0.338772893,
-0.0738131031,
-0.5452134609,
-0.5716121793,
0.4340569973,
0.6407185197,
0.1497973949,
0.4567914903,
0.092927672,
-0.3278552294,
0.1107043102,
-0.8343859911,
-0.4493924081,
-0.4184899926,
0.0050228164,
-0.4078846574,
-1.1699668169,
0.3830373287,
-0.5192090869,
-0.2981944978,
0.2797453403,
-0.1043149903,
-0.1546107978,
1.1246097088,
0.8963954449,
0.070393838,
0.4555138052,
-0.0106525635,
0.4908908904,
-1.009766221,
-0.3437664211,
-0.3779183626,
-0.1668379903,
-0.3865323961,
-0.1794131249,
0.7434334159,
0.1732869595,
-0.1478732526,
0.1887971461,
-0.3573596776,
0.1972902715,
0.7194501758,
0.2264762223,
0.5364876986,
-0.3393653631,
-0.2694659233,
-0.1154391542,
-1.1808102131,
-0.3881162703,
0.9137134552,
0.2162018269,
0.736354351,
0.2117603272,
0.5471108556,
0.3722724319,
-0.2221837789,
-0.5920125842,
0.6151205301,
0.4117273092,
-0.6002395153,
-0.4743266404,
-0.4458512664,
-0.6053927541,
0.0069049685,
-0.090005137,
-0.9172679782,
0.4969166815,
0.0270873439,
-0.7745693326,
0.2959403098,
-0.878382206,
0.279366225,
-0.1015043035,
-0.1113381907,
-0.3533670306,
-0.6914820671,
0.7328867912,
0.0910061821,
0.2234228551,
0.1145336777,
0.1558905244,
0.9670271873,
-0.638181746,
0.821048975,
-0.4862503707,
-0.3347910643,
0.3677240312,
0.0058542183,
0.1606188565,
-0.1037430391,
0.2741695642,
-0.1275307834,
0.2997975051,
-0.3243592381,
-0.9643607736,
0.1277730018,
-0.6482217908,
-1.0841232538,
-0.4165259302,
-0.3395450115,
-0.8263344765,
0.0593913049,
0.0882517248,
0.4345292449,
-0.3904610872,
-0.0868358016,
1.0134557486,
-0.4867726266,
0.1150997207,
0.3406617641,
-0.1289482862,
-0.3719573915,
0.6877329946,
0.1456324458,
0.378025949,
-0.0079701263,
-0.0751580894,
-0.3254387975,
-0.4077786803,
-0.371845603,
0.0178197473,
-0.6146785617,
-0.2642864287,
-0.735856235,
-0.4619651735,
-0.8143763542,
0.1031781137,
-0.069145143,
-0.6908145547,
-0.1406442225,
-0.3407008052,
0.4534367025,
1.4243093729,
-0.2546046376,
0.4035354853,
-0.9552723765,
0.2959818542,
0.6039765477,
0.6783666015,
-0.0964535773,
-0.1976051033,
-0.3241987228,
0.3603102267,
-0.4008672535,
-0.9403305054,
0.0589585751,
-0.0755660608,
0.8342301846,
0.796207428,
0.1859576851,
0.6029226184,
0.0234846957,
1.1383106709,
0.4923348725,
-0.96485883,
0.708973527,
-0.2774951458,
0.2541516423,
0.353007704,
0.3496538103,
-0.7905181646,
-0.4854351878,
-0.7632863522,
-0.3506899178,
0.9253011942,
0.064997673,
-0.0759406686,
0.1890407056,
0.0201681703,
0.076537475,
0.2850604355,
-0.2228139043,
-0.1865618974,
-0.2050608397,
-0.129464671,
-0.0319409184,
-0.059778858,
-0.5594240427,
-0.3940862715,
0.5376436114,
-0.1600430161,
0.4105888605,
0.4264750779,
-0.1157381013,
-0.1142829359,
0.496552825,
0.6570228934,
0.5709229708,
0.0834342763,
-0.0016133413,
0.3661544621,
-0.3161128759,
0.3303735554,
-0.3201803267,
-0.1248310208,
-0.1169023663,
-0.0994575024,
1.0300747156,
0.1422493905,
-0.605786562,
0.3220046759,
-0.149432987,
-0.1944411248,
-0.3413293362,
0.4661212265,
0.0504651144,
0.520489037,
0.2730003297,
0.3520310521,
0.2825812697,
-0.7023820281,
0.0237673726,
0.4934027195,
-0.604552865,
-0.1876241118,
0.0992255434,
0.6208892465,
-0.3697685003,
0.3087048829,
-0.116049841,
-0.6717517376,
0.1877349764,
0.2255188972,
0.8107767701,
-0.0340158269,
0.2706099451,
0.2424877286,
0.3466562927,
-0.0774535164,
0.2557243407,
-0.5006973147,
-1.0694793463,
0.0026249376,
-0.3816635609,
-0.7931486368,
0.1513518542,
-0.6853135824,
0.0953851193,
-0.4003399014,
-0.3942731023,
-0.3578937054,
0.0602702349,
-0.8636791706,
0.2147335708,
0.1753060669,
1.0819965601,
-0.6438321471,
0.5150415301,
0.6478024721,
-0.0859086365,
-0.5350928307,
0.0748350248,
0.0944307595,
-0.5801647305,
0.3430238068,
-0.2927046418,
-0.3717209101,
0.0378636234,
-0.4682688415,
-1.1722429991,
0.9738279581,
0.0926789269,
-0.3001591265,
-0.2005126029,
0.0781052038,
0.4386323094,
-0.4415949881,
0.4155836999,
1.0041356087,
0.6509779692,
-0.1398482621,
-1.0055392981,
-0.2029284388,
-0.3603359461,
-0.0180269498,
0.0583471693,
-0.5549088717,
0.1970001012,
-0.3429174423,
-0.3845260441,
0.0927557945,
0.4181142747,
-0.0011883401,
0.4330588877,
0.6152338982,
0.7533640862,
1.1351339817,
-0.2555754781,
0.6943923831,
-0.2214764059,
-0.2319434881,
0.8354274631,
-0.2655858696,
0.0311764479,
0.2330919504,
-0.412445426,
0.7401343584,
0.6167581677,
0.4787962437,
0.4783915579,
0.0626248941,
-0.7700422406,
-0.2920042276,
-0.3471325934,
-0.5200588107,
0.4897068441,
1.0098427534,
-0.140399754,
0.056667041,
-0.0857459456,
-0.3365721107,
-0.252538383,
-0.2101440877,
1.4922937155,
0.102175422,
-1.0693573952,
0.4782786667,
-0.4722419679,
0.6491786838,
-0.6541385651,
0.0626992583,
-0.37178123,
-0.3855349123,
-0.1623239219,
-0.8585141897,
0.0778566897,
-0.0988595709,
-0.0421314947,
-0.1714204997,
1.09755826,
-0.3586388528,
-0.0830802768,
0.166118145,
1.0016467571,
0.1897602081,
0.1192202345,
-0.1078566611,
-0.2471871674,
0.1114394292,
0.02340932,
0.2105271369,
0.560737133,
0.0586417802,
0.8134323955,
0.4188379049,
0.2749054134,
0.0801241919,
0.1282220334,
1.0546001196,
-1.054318428,
-0.4270277917,
-0.1696185619,
0.4143087864,
-0.6114125252,
-0.2112657577,
0.6146636009,
0.3165053725,
0.7408815622,
0.1467465162,
1.5219795704,
-0.0670195892,
0.9671401978,
-0.4295482039,
0.6214826703,
-0.3706688285,
0.2835298479,
-0.4842208922,
-0.8875581622,
0.1908014566,
0.3291583955,
-0.3000141978,
-0.0298837833,
0.7666418552,
0.9024706483,
0.14878802,
0.7649228573,
0.5579168797,
0.0281044692,
-0.0478599332,
0.5587072372,
1.4460040331,
-0.182284236,
0.3811328709,
-0.0755552351,
-0.5911363363,
-0.0463637635,
-0.3020932674,
-0.5301117301,
-0.6697403193,
-0.0445404612,
-0.0607423149,
0.1518958062,
0.5997875333,
0.6308104992,
-0.724899888,
-0.1859698594,
-0.1876562238,
0.3772594929,
-0.0427991189,
-0.2220426053,
-0.3100626469,
-0.5173409581,
-0.4741075337,
0.6915524006,
0.4282868505,
0.1997416764,
-0.3838391602,
-0.0649030954,
0.2026466876,
0.2776964903,
0.5411140919,
0.4430483878,
-0.8135911822,
-0.584117353,
0.2216130495,
0.1948561072,
0.0307088122,
1.2393180132,
-0.9704138041,
0.6896306276,
0.4576751888,
0.3717107773,
0.1841363609,
-0.2109813988,
1.0478842258,
-0.3574365079,
-0.1085631624,
0.3969240189,
0.501614511,
0.4277888238,
-0.2426300496,
0.3463819325,
0.5458219647,
-0.4539808035,
-0.4516609609,
0.6473296881,
-0.6343048811,
-0.1986386031,
0.8418637514,
-0.0904688835,
0.381518364,
-0.7705094218,
-0.3686508536,
0.3183888197,
-0.4270009995,
0.9503309131,
1.127910614,
-0.5487007499,
-0.1964411736,
-0.236205399,
1.0269249678,
0.4914881587,
-0.774512887,
-0.0297088176,
0.7461118698,
0.1436820924,
0.4194661975,
0.8930131793,
0.0012255935,
0.1525572538,
0.2239355296,
-0.1344828904,
0.409879595,
-0.25250265,
-0.2537102997,
-0.0472836345,
0.0421278737,
0.2470401973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09251v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09251v1 | Discovering Language Model Behaviors with Model-Written Evaluations | 2022-12-19T05:13:52 | 2022-12-19T05:13:52 | Ethan Perez, Sam Ringer, Kamilė Lukošiūtė, Karina Nguyen, Edwin Chen, Scott Heiner, Craig Pettit, Catherine Olsson, Sandipan Kundu, Saurav Kadavath, Andy Jones, Anna Chen, Ben Mann, Brian Israel, Bryan Seethor, Cameron McKinnon, Christopher Olah, Da Yan, Daniela Amodei, Dario Amodei, Dawn Drain, Dustin Li, Eli Tran-Johnson, Guro Khundadze, Jackson Kernion, James Landis, Jamie Kerr, Jared Mueller, Jeeyoon Hyun, Joshua Landau, Kamal Ndousse, Landon Goldberg, Liane Lovitt, Martin Lucas, Michael Sellitto, Miranda Zhang, Neerav Kingsland, Nelson Elhage, Nicholas Joseph, Noemí Mercado, Nova DasSarma, Oliver Rausch, Robin Larson, Sam McCandlish, Scott Johnston, Shauna Kravec, Sheer El Showk, Tamera Lanham, Timothy Telleen-Lawton, Tom Brown, Tom Henighan, Tristan Hume, Yuntao Bai, Zac Hatfield-Dodds, Jack Clark, Samuel R. Bowman, Amanda Askell, Roger Grosse, Danny Hernandez, Deep Ganguli, Evan Hubinger, Nicholas Schiefer, Jared Kaplan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | As language models (LMs) scale, they develop many novel behaviors, good and
bad, exacerbating the need to evaluate how they behave. Prior work creates
evaluations with crowdwork (which is time-consuming and expensive) or existing
data sources (which are not always available). Here, we automatically generate
evaluations with LMs. We explore approaches with varying amounts of human
effort, from instructing LMs to write yes/no questions to making complex
Winogender schemas with multiple stages of LM-based generation and filtering.
Crowdworkers rate the examples as highly relevant and agree with 90-100% of
labels, sometimes more so than corresponding human-written datasets. We
generate 154 datasets and discover new cases of inverse scaling where LMs get
worse with size. Larger LMs repeat back a dialog user's preferred answer
("sycophancy") and express greater desire to pursue concerning goals like
resource acquisition and goal preservation. We also find some of the first
examples of inverse scaling in RL from Human Feedback (RLHF), where more RLHF
makes LMs worse. For example, RLHF makes LMs express stronger political views
(on gun rights and immigration) and a greater desire to avoid shut down.
Overall, LM-written evaluations are high-quality and let us quickly discover
many novel LM behaviors. | [
-0.2387788743,
-0.7418881059,
0.5629435778,
-0.0344908498,
0.3117231429,
-0.0883189142,
-0.3263777792,
-0.2779165208,
0.0742199719,
0.7415792942,
-0.7739834785,
-0.3731056452,
-0.3896266222,
-0.1648961455,
-0.3732484579,
1.2377538681,
0.1169964373,
0.2439276576,
-0.1525581777,
-0.1192033365,
-0.3547239602,
-0.5104909539,
-0.6677818298,
-0.636105597,
0.5909863114,
0.5261642933,
0.8184323311,
0.595212996,
0.4270061851,
0.2789173722,
-0.0637354404,
-0.1236322299,
-0.8340681195,
0.1383131146,
-0.0696267784,
-0.2667661905,
-0.5117883682,
0.2181756198,
0.5350180864,
0.8290877938,
-0.4227602482,
0.5139017701,
0.0729372054,
0.9130661488,
-0.4037134945,
0.2246980518,
-0.5117087364,
0.0739626065,
-0.0425152369,
0.0706749186,
-0.5319469571,
-0.3791186512,
0.0006811572,
-0.293232739,
0.1380033344,
0.1879710108,
0.7906406522,
-0.0328425094,
-0.4491534829,
-0.4011364281,
-0.898289144,
0.8891213536,
-0.7219808102,
0.2909269333,
0.6090095043,
0.2641506791,
-0.2912937701,
-0.5615978837,
-0.5419427156,
-0.508780241,
-0.1566196829,
-0.1472618133,
-0.3593594432,
0.0625271425,
0.4281863868,
0.357137084,
-0.6896324158,
0.1601587832,
-0.401098907,
-0.3373122811,
0.7754006386,
0.5933651328,
0.3239067793,
-0.1971274316,
0.0092625245,
-0.2362332344,
-0.7831879854,
0.1839480847,
0.5735267401,
0.367151022,
0.1340168566,
0.6205682755,
-0.2056208253,
0.8047802448,
-0.1063599214,
-0.0028578816,
0.2705613673,
-0.4330665767,
-0.0825255066,
-0.4638115168,
0.8002685905,
0.5615953207,
0.4912548959,
-0.0726628304,
-0.545365572,
-0.0562882721,
0.1216600686,
-0.8619184494,
-0.1060287803,
0.0888574198,
-0.9267506599,
-0.4887767434,
-0.1078080907,
-0.6323900819,
-0.9037748575,
-0.4787915945,
0.5636175871,
-0.2346516848,
-0.5462465286,
0.1691710055,
0.0120542739,
0.2117293924,
0.1855653375,
-0.7717087269,
0.4736739397,
0.5976332426,
0.7250156999,
-0.0468693934,
-0.3373644352,
-0.7067487836,
-0.3283192217,
-0.3994279504,
0.6897659898,
-0.4831569195,
-0.3942732215,
-0.0598116368,
-0.0918707028,
-0.1311919689,
-0.7930595875,
0.4642158151,
-0.2409595698,
0.4170994461,
-0.3453119695,
-0.6119005084,
0.0699300542,
0.2333004475,
-0.7605319023,
1.1117727757,
0.1102786809,
-0.647870481,
0.3553221524,
-1.0276268721,
-0.2466765344,
-0.1004161686,
0.0343370959,
-0.3394584358,
0.174919188,
-0.0424651466,
0.541567266,
-0.2884780467,
0.3603565991,
-0.3505885899,
-0.179550305,
0.4898069203,
-0.3102171421,
0.7908313274,
0.2709738314,
-0.2052104771,
0.461964637,
-0.7236245275,
0.0716929138,
0.2612279952,
-0.3161348701,
-0.2877514958,
0.2726011872,
-0.060132809,
0.251500994,
0.1278834939,
-0.5287376642,
0.1580320001,
-0.2805316448,
0.3780507445,
0.7599009275,
0.0830293074,
0.3737514913,
-0.4782315195,
0.751631856,
-0.2596692443,
0.346771419,
-0.2351532429,
-0.2949616015,
-0.8935112357,
0.1722429097,
-0.1321912706,
0.4172106385,
-0.3738260269,
0.257552743,
-0.2276036888,
-0.7543439269,
-0.5252298117,
0.3392600119,
0.4716465473,
0.5741846561,
0.1090490073,
-0.3473970294,
-0.4725605547,
-0.975558877,
-0.3779305518,
-0.4840701222,
0.0201630834,
0.3354769647,
0.4339611828,
-0.1157182232,
0.9718310833,
-0.6719564199,
-0.1248442829,
-0.4169047177,
0.3770599365,
0.2234430909,
0.0979807451,
0.3639495671,
-0.4426289797,
-0.1847085953,
-0.2572780252,
-0.4306180477,
-0.3036073446,
-0.0723564923,
-0.0220577698,
0.201311335,
0.628667593,
-0.2829563618,
0.179948613,
0.5760340095,
-0.4681870043,
0.7070717812,
-0.1871866882,
-0.0775091797,
-0.8788998723,
0.0758478269,
0.1554009467,
-0.1972431988,
-0.7558481693,
0.0914219096,
-0.1975015849,
-0.1717988849,
-0.2581771314,
0.5333806872,
-0.6024581194,
-0.1119581312,
-0.0981783047,
0.1010731533,
-0.2881352007,
0.4661352038,
0.0767329931,
0.3927964866,
0.347661674,
-0.3249736428,
0.3662251532,
-0.3112641573,
-0.5437172055,
0.1594350636,
-0.6418642402,
0.3117410839,
-0.2890046537,
0.1719241887,
-0.9770250916,
-0.0550531186,
0.1098242775,
-0.2303612381,
0.0303029791,
-0.1953673512,
-0.5377696753,
-0.4637997746,
-0.4546349049,
0.024117725,
0.4096493125,
-0.208992511,
0.2857470214,
0.6659318805,
-0.1872801334,
-0.3233242333,
-0.3641411364,
0.1913250238,
-0.273529619,
-0.4226461351,
-0.3324603438,
-0.2751203477,
-0.4375795424,
-0.0631280392,
0.1435533017,
-0.0311667211,
0.2766430974,
0.3870101869,
0.1969910711,
-0.3459040523,
0.2730644047,
-0.3266947865,
0.0126966368,
0.2623287439,
0.0205731802,
0.695687592,
-0.5224665999,
-0.4170228541,
-0.1497767717,
0.2826922834,
0.5510628223,
-0.1859842837,
0.5380221009,
0.6234971285,
-0.4247517288,
-0.0974556059,
-0.4314102232,
-0.4537903368,
-0.4129078984,
0.5584307313,
-0.1069526821,
-0.8277404904,
0.3916009963,
-0.0229571033,
0.1613838673,
0.4098294079,
0.7747024894,
0.0085198423,
1.201479435,
0.6775878668,
-0.1497477293,
0.5638328791,
-0.2411540449,
0.2353767455,
-0.4094112515,
-0.20181714,
-0.5349724293,
-0.3312579989,
-0.5442776084,
-0.3599602878,
0.2546875775,
0.0988772735,
-0.1390374154,
0.3867703974,
-0.3588804007,
0.5481078029,
0.311358273,
-0.0443601087,
0.4307801127,
-0.1716825962,
0.0113621419,
-0.1925945729,
-0.6904016733,
-0.8031046391,
1.1556158066,
0.5342370868,
0.8727463484,
0.1594364494,
0.7594786286,
0.4724572897,
0.8794776797,
-1.0510867834,
0.7238516808,
0.1036958918,
-0.6241136193,
-0.6925272942,
-0.5223616958,
-1.0307782888,
0.1381171793,
-0.3379368186,
-0.793050766,
-0.0630760789,
0.4461273849,
-0.1561561674,
0.1229845732,
-0.9057313204,
0.9821165204,
-0.2642343342,
-0.2559303641,
-0.4152794182,
-0.5425034761,
0.4537772238,
0.0490898155,
0.5669617057,
-0.170189023,
0.1732490957,
0.7360724807,
-0.5522920489,
1.0588163137,
-0.3534587026,
-0.4258587062,
0.4026266634,
0.4498727024,
0.5386357307,
-0.293893218,
-0.1799429059,
-0.1149523631,
-0.0021770836,
-0.0171541497,
-0.7600444555,
0.5767669678,
-0.5733328462,
-0.4226536155,
-0.1283254772,
-0.4731024504,
-0.1748667806,
0.185108304,
-0.0373845957,
0.4437496364,
-0.5236900449,
-0.0301164072,
0.4479373097,
-0.1459488422,
0.3310769796,
0.7761340737,
-0.7719994187,
-0.0521606877,
1.143611908,
0.0861221701,
0.24990125,
0.3330024779,
0.5304270387,
-0.1573161185,
-0.3151530921,
-0.4435535073,
0.1911537796,
-0.4725302458,
-0.1068514884,
-0.3248497248,
-0.0352786034,
-0.3765941858,
0.3528650701,
-0.3799971044,
-0.5310242772,
-0.0011606911,
-0.1603209227,
0.2150268555,
1.0892399549,
-0.1721850932,
0.2030073404,
-0.5767815709,
0.1128295586,
0.2470471263,
0.3378966451,
0.2937271595,
-0.4621502757,
-0.400021553,
0.1090043932,
-0.3893075585,
-0.8468751907,
0.3790746629,
0.2649430037,
0.4913223386,
0.5405362248,
-0.1178622693,
0.5519839525,
-0.3947054148,
0.741127491,
-0.0056186882,
-0.9706067443,
0.4649129808,
-0.3355730474,
0.002121943,
0.1888953894,
0.3311527967,
-0.9658458829,
-0.3274794817,
-0.3953002095,
-0.8570069671,
0.708973825,
0.1088222712,
0.3261671662,
0.1183760464,
0.206057623,
0.2323845923,
0.0778383315,
-0.9820926785,
-0.2331801206,
-0.1752795726,
-0.0454472452,
-0.1735897064,
-0.3029546142,
-0.0411270261,
-0.1768287569,
0.5383752584,
-0.0867570043,
-0.0456029773,
-0.1219261661,
-0.2975634038,
-0.2847242951,
0.465919733,
0.703907311,
0.6506224871,
-0.3155465424,
0.1473291218,
-0.0268021077,
-0.1908940673,
0.071269691,
-0.1839434952,
0.0013079743,
-0.2402863204,
0.5905541182,
0.9103789926,
0.0016580693,
-1.0119093657,
0.5778380036,
-0.1127160192,
-0.0923290625,
-0.3525930643,
0.1572843194,
0.2532909214,
-0.0279107559,
0.2762947977,
-0.2334080338,
0.2469893694,
-0.715991199,
0.0763206631,
0.4009794891,
-0.5015428066,
-0.4910968542,
0.1943486631,
0.2791468501,
-0.4296473265,
0.4848599434,
-0.3099436462,
-0.376549691,
0.4712745845,
0.3590201735,
0.904730618,
-0.2368396521,
0.4768843353,
0.3555174768,
0.5209508538,
-0.2060151696,
0.3256034553,
-0.159476012,
-0.9265267849,
-0.4764624536,
-0.5335257649,
-0.4163250923,
0.5243136883,
-0.9432669878,
0.2658402026,
-0.2459767759,
-0.2073213756,
-0.0711285695,
-0.0402218141,
-0.5708584189,
0.0239966661,
0.0194639228,
0.6635685563,
-1.2358340025,
0.5466689467,
0.8408816457,
-0.2922196686,
-0.7753433585,
-0.0142080989,
0.2000408918,
-0.989078939,
0.7121942043,
-0.0572640002,
-0.194266215,
-0.1222296432,
-0.6038427353,
-0.7266967893,
0.821682632,
0.3704880476,
-0.6203873754,
0.0412623622,
0.1894477755,
0.8981989026,
-0.4210866094,
0.4361073077,
0.507807374,
0.5421619415,
-0.3611305058,
-0.9098628163,
0.1485614926,
-0.3354320526,
-0.0977768525,
0.3019354045,
-0.4911175668,
0.7816525698,
-0.6038216949,
-0.2374779731,
0.0548166074,
0.3859603405,
0.029896345,
0.3743800521,
0.767826438,
0.4011805058,
0.669026196,
0.1661219746,
1.0255978107,
-0.0975725129,
0.4311563373,
1.306853056,
-0.3526508212,
0.8267067075,
0.4652419984,
-0.2098258883,
0.541913569,
0.595923245,
0.0430951379,
0.0650241077,
0.7741437554,
0.0643973425,
-0.3885936141,
-0.2143225074,
-0.0409078486,
0.5082200766,
0.3114337325,
-0.3410799503,
-0.3167664111,
-0.0777693018,
0.1667268723,
0.2969887853,
-0.1862691641,
0.7947359681,
-0.0633132532,
-0.5860030055,
0.3823404312,
0.0826309025,
0.5133475065,
-0.4738123715,
-0.0839110091,
-0.4411192536,
-0.0051216949,
-0.1809754074,
-0.7980208993,
0.2377174646,
0.164529711,
-0.4481936693,
-0.5374610424,
0.7274928093,
-0.5263130069,
-0.4965284169,
0.2963951528,
0.775813818,
0.4832423031,
0.0123801772,
-0.6002629995,
-0.0379249379,
0.0663750023,
-0.6431365609,
0.3796820343,
0.3708063662,
-0.3216814101,
0.9205290079,
0.6089996696,
0.4464050829,
-0.0788943544,
0.3999952376,
0.651163578,
-0.6816679835,
-0.0015066921,
-0.8361889124,
0.2259822935,
-0.1211833358,
-0.2950913012,
0.6993980408,
0.6344519854,
0.830037117,
-0.0995137393,
0.7551717162,
-0.050410904,
0.6253861189,
-0.5021798611,
0.7616568208,
-0.4256834388,
0.2974944413,
-0.390860945,
-0.7384138703,
-0.0562729239,
0.5400637388,
-0.2824911773,
0.1291204095,
0.382689327,
1.161516428,
0.1397376209,
-0.2304720879,
0.3747465014,
0.3901370764,
0.3917616904,
0.3956531286,
0.9621673822,
-0.1588339955,
0.75141114,
-0.150995627,
-0.2642024159,
-0.1612350196,
-1.1529265642,
-0.7171711326,
-0.8399546742,
-0.4144218266,
-0.3783121109,
-0.2740104198,
1.025559783,
0.6424182057,
-0.7281051278,
-0.7271280885,
-0.0544973984,
0.3734313846,
-0.1281583905,
-0.3545403779,
0.1555461287,
-0.2456986904,
-0.5498105884,
0.2621372342,
0.0509882569,
-0.0018185542,
-0.5662336946,
-0.3154401481,
0.1862517893,
-0.0037299299,
0.6957017779,
0.4130600691,
-0.6127105951,
-0.2929829061,
0.0286901835,
-0.1141514778,
-0.307492435,
1.2849388123,
-0.6528109312,
0.3825617433,
0.4683431685,
0.1851889193,
0.3010097742,
-0.2013348639,
0.6933694482,
-0.4826191366,
-0.303425312,
0.2558138072,
0.2836634815,
0.3282398582,
0.0023312466,
0.3962181509,
0.1128139123,
-0.5763773918,
-1.068983078,
0.3277031481,
-0.4947926998,
-0.1662016064,
1.2927798033,
-0.0127622085,
0.0801453739,
0.0675597191,
-0.4059098661,
-0.0343161896,
-0.4714026153,
0.8649078608,
0.8936321139,
-0.4625683725,
-0.0143722212,
-0.4524029791,
0.5961381793,
0.3381146193,
-0.6823106408,
0.4435313642,
0.6903336048,
0.414652884,
0.0775636807,
0.6856628656,
-0.0586110316,
-0.0755802318,
-0.2103977203,
0.2033581585,
-0.0639777035,
-0.0652375519,
-0.4179559052,
0.03960374,
0.3961456716,
0.1429468393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09248v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09248v1 | Natural Language to Code Generation in Interactive Data Science Notebooks | 2022-12-19T05:06:00 | 2022-12-19T05:06:00 | Pengcheng Yin, Wen-Ding Li, Kefan Xiao, Abhishek Rao, Yeming Wen, Kensen Shi, Joshua Howland, Paige Bailey, Michele Catasta, Henryk Michalewski, Alex Polozov, Charles Sutton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | Computational notebooks, such as Jupyter notebooks, are interactive computing
environments that are ubiquitous among data scientists to perform data
wrangling and analytic tasks. To measure the performance of AI pair programmers
that automatically synthesize programs for those tasks given natural language
(NL) intents from users, we build ARCADE, a benchmark of 1082 code generation
problems using the pandas data analysis framework in data science notebooks.
ARCADE features multiple rounds of NL-to-code problems from the same notebook.
It requires a model to understand rich multi-modal contexts, such as existing
notebook cells and their execution states as well as previous turns of
interaction. To establish a strong baseline on this challenging task, we
develop PaChiNCo, a 62B code language model (LM) for Python computational
notebooks, which significantly outperforms public code LMs. Finally, we explore
few-shot prompting strategies to elicit better code with step-by-step
decomposition and NL explanation, showing the potential to improve the
diversity and explainability of model predictions. | [
-0.388217479,
-1.0663093328,
0.1088016108,
0.2955442667,
-0.1098905206,
0.2089496851,
-0.4023159742,
-0.416526556,
0.0965883136,
0.4305145442,
-0.5020780563,
-0.5046103001,
-0.1649837792,
0.529884994,
-0.3737834692,
1.369726181,
-0.0574569106,
-0.1753875017,
-0.593305707,
0.1171312407,
-0.3690210283,
-0.2884971797,
-0.3726646006,
0.1042146161,
0.1683578491,
0.3751441836,
0.6149038076,
0.2321898341,
0.2996489406,
0.3503009379,
0.0583283864,
0.3807017207,
-0.5352928042,
0.1940349489,
0.3328355253,
-0.495042026,
-0.270146668,
-0.1672420353,
0.4358797371,
0.7132903337,
0.0348058529,
0.0996046364,
-0.1573819667,
0.6993800998,
-0.3492914736,
0.4947492182,
-0.5385270715,
-0.0230337903,
-0.1813417971,
0.039975401,
-0.4899134636,
-0.4452691078,
-0.1714174002,
-0.8508787155,
0.1929788738,
0.0822714195,
0.4571166933,
0.3549867272,
-0.1742287725,
-0.4671389461,
-0.5056321621,
0.5063102841,
-0.5793867707,
-0.2190672755,
0.2538030446,
0.3507096469,
-0.5931791067,
-0.7124254107,
-0.7886850238,
-0.4880518615,
0.0274512339,
-0.037997894,
-0.4163782299,
-0.0375717171,
0.4316659272,
0.0772563443,
-0.5620584488,
-0.0619031861,
-0.699338913,
0.0491748266,
0.7758298516,
0.4214805365,
0.3644262552,
-0.5077707171,
0.1099800989,
0.0136751942,
-0.391826421,
0.2660740316,
0.5126687288,
0.1153018624,
-0.2577332556,
0.7225627899,
-0.0949064046,
0.9212172031,
-0.1226945594,
0.0281063113,
-0.0819271132,
-0.702542901,
-0.1577292979,
0.1008044928,
0.8496148586,
0.3046398461,
0.4140399098,
-0.1154190972,
0.0103471018,
0.361243695,
0.659075141,
-0.7762311101,
-0.4896112084,
0.2808050811,
-0.2639971673,
-0.618524313,
-0.1004972979,
-0.7803553343,
-0.4430365264,
-0.3502281606,
0.041648034,
-0.4651491344,
-0.0518222377,
-0.1723385751,
-0.2178365588,
-0.072174415,
0.3453142643,
-0.6085920334,
0.5167132616,
0.8312860727,
0.8613424301,
-0.3090893924,
-0.2421115041,
-0.8663580418,
-0.0268852003,
-0.5168048143,
0.7090736628,
-0.4760365784,
-0.572152555,
-0.0075108814,
-0.4413760304,
-0.1850458533,
-0.3556541502,
0.1262025237,
-0.2625961006,
0.214099884,
0.2249369025,
-0.6361272931,
-0.0016638616,
-0.0462273248,
-0.7284529805,
1.02404356,
0.309310168,
-0.8632159233,
0.2604961991,
-0.8675354123,
-0.5169355869,
0.3196206391,
-0.5122050047,
-0.4561393559,
0.1087615043,
0.0637068078,
0.4111298025,
-0.196091935,
0.5410817862,
-0.1666661799,
-0.4440664649,
0.6370487809,
-0.0849874467,
0.6941921711,
0.1588997841,
-0.1052878723,
0.3808119297,
-0.7975310683,
-0.064968586,
0.1562392116,
-0.4232977331,
-0.0844465941,
-0.0405595489,
0.1360530108,
-0.0171691719,
-0.0189416856,
-0.3599452972,
0.5671787262,
-0.259858042,
0.5230695009,
0.3688518405,
-0.0343671329,
0.2240241021,
-0.4421878457,
0.8241740465,
-0.1508416831,
-0.0654639378,
-0.3658929765,
-0.9041854143,
-0.4199238718,
-0.2699804008,
0.1250487715,
0.2596535981,
-0.828371942,
0.3898227513,
-0.209258616,
-0.4434580803,
-0.6709535718,
0.2488036901,
0.2844794989,
0.6552820206,
0.2945096791,
-0.4858979881,
-0.4590616822,
-0.5609003901,
-0.0504840054,
-0.1816550046,
0.0897050947,
0.5717858672,
0.5484665632,
-0.3803659081,
1.0426231623,
-0.362313211,
0.080643937,
-0.6059475541,
0.544537425,
0.2156237364,
0.3782638907,
0.439912498,
-0.5314849019,
-0.5489126444,
-0.1119040027,
-0.5388143063,
-0.1393563151,
-0.2186975181,
-0.0349829867,
0.6378532648,
0.4371927381,
-0.4879218936,
0.6146748662,
0.4669046402,
-0.0474498942,
0.7869436145,
-0.3606541753,
0.0690117106,
-0.8603829145,
0.5602492094,
-0.0804543719,
-0.0248831697,
-0.6857601404,
-0.0957912505,
-0.0606069565,
-0.4127698839,
-0.2183739692,
0.3132852316,
-0.1705210507,
-0.235132128,
-0.2239215821,
0.1820530891,
0.1025474668,
0.4340790212,
0.1473212242,
0.898450017,
0.5880858898,
-0.5052499771,
0.4626302123,
0.3331025839,
-0.5760191083,
0.2584463656,
-0.8309065104,
0.2468957454,
-0.1156910956,
0.6859645844,
-1.0486830473,
-0.6435590982,
-0.0661009476,
-0.4720871449,
0.126257062,
-0.422305882,
-0.5590566397,
-0.5039280057,
-0.3715725839,
0.4596689045,
0.5147268772,
-0.3651206493,
0.0277748983,
0.2785620093,
-0.252836138,
-0.3046325147,
-0.3122099042,
0.2610696554,
-0.2309582382,
-0.9485608339,
0.4345753193,
-0.2673329711,
-0.3240600824,
-0.1073540673,
0.2166662663,
-0.2012688369,
0.3265690506,
0.3987721801,
0.5060827732,
-0.0330376029,
0.0106533654,
0.1088980213,
-0.1182943508,
0.3496896029,
-0.0374019258,
0.5020968318,
-0.1148892045,
0.0274437722,
-0.2826788723,
0.3876109719,
0.314543426,
-0.3790622056,
0.6377691627,
0.5491544604,
-0.2154773921,
-0.3168728054,
-0.0082399826,
0.0847688019,
-0.4128288329,
0.0535282046,
-0.3241252601,
-0.5285203457,
0.4146391153,
-0.1384816319,
0.0448313877,
0.1083010361,
0.5256419778,
0.1531361938,
1.0492221117,
0.5479233265,
-0.1246110797,
0.3196097016,
-0.3928590417,
0.2751885056,
-0.6852821708,
-0.2881112397,
-0.6898178458,
-0.1828808337,
-0.5951991081,
-0.4647760689,
0.5256801248,
0.2360914499,
0.016037561,
0.5023729205,
-0.6288684607,
0.5910804272,
0.6580228209,
-0.2356493324,
0.1811840832,
-0.2182771116,
-0.1182260066,
0.1217051521,
-0.7985398769,
-0.3372015059,
1.1684414148,
-0.0775014833,
0.7669329643,
-0.0235590823,
0.9914262891,
0.2249867469,
0.0616683885,
-0.650292933,
0.3727058768,
0.0481127091,
-0.3339351118,
0.0701633915,
-0.6178817153,
-1.0667705536,
-0.3006518483,
-0.1424872726,
-0.8673620224,
-0.3830591142,
0.0347448289,
-0.5811027884,
-0.2182343304,
-0.6436505318,
1.2864613533,
-0.2595255077,
-0.6867964864,
-0.3709041774,
-0.7300928831,
0.5305363536,
0.0958175212,
0.3045159876,
0.1190630347,
0.1836644113,
0.6623584628,
-0.4128360748,
0.6847417951,
0.035386879,
0.1194962189,
0.5891663432,
0.5177785158,
0.399314642,
0.2961142063,
-0.1111782268,
-0.0437426828,
-0.0641164631,
-0.1547316313,
-0.3694069386,
0.8341383338,
-0.5929639339,
-0.1925746351,
-0.1618033648,
-0.6715136766,
0.1456902325,
0.053461276,
0.1461112797,
0.6445554495,
-0.1970915943,
0.028477639,
0.2860647142,
-0.4919107556,
0.4770034552,
0.1289331317,
-0.2864896655,
-0.169885546,
0.8541685939,
-0.2690280378,
0.0538897961,
0.0886211991,
0.0579045415,
-0.0501653962,
-0.4306338131,
-0.6948304176,
-0.0371662565,
-0.3375069499,
-0.2328144312,
-0.493719697,
-0.0076501756,
-0.3927309811,
-0.5391456485,
-0.1019551381,
-0.6512563229,
-0.3001610935,
0.2161020935,
0.5986096859,
0.9915147424,
-0.0421055481,
-0.057478305,
-0.7449335456,
0.5141724944,
0.0769754723,
0.1751766354,
-0.2200553119,
-0.115779005,
-0.2347084433,
-0.0822366923,
-0.3195734918,
-0.7963628173,
0.6143282652,
0.1284267008,
0.4014762938,
0.0108677493,
0.0668509826,
0.6958631873,
-0.3139009774,
0.8902099729,
0.0195404422,
-0.9328758717,
0.8727642894,
-0.3045917153,
0.1959735751,
0.4901164174,
0.4236657321,
-0.5200679898,
-0.4440762401,
-0.7053371668,
-0.6447575092,
0.8900031447,
0.4447289705,
0.0397124141,
-0.178926006,
0.0757406279,
0.3059685528,
0.3567092717,
-0.5322824717,
-0.0350032896,
-0.3635990024,
-0.3048762381,
0.1148191616,
0.4854450226,
-0.1966961324,
-0.2295650691,
0.2799831927,
-0.5047829151,
0.3860095739,
-0.0504779406,
-0.1480706483,
-0.2032794654,
0.1546650082,
0.6834977865,
0.5094217062,
-0.1535463035,
-0.0250596181,
-0.4137324989,
-0.1454326212,
-0.3905154467,
0.4020944238,
-0.0472368337,
-0.0735695064,
0.3370777071,
0.5838448405,
0.2196532637,
-1.0502015352,
0.482755959,
-0.3298789561,
0.2118304819,
-0.1076563522,
0.6426869631,
-0.0309731085,
-0.1368328482,
0.0744929239,
0.1443011016,
0.1765072495,
-0.585682869,
0.2021055222,
0.4137478769,
-0.0414668806,
-0.3058427274,
0.7844156027,
0.4966353476,
-0.4333880544,
0.8728577495,
-0.5075345039,
-0.5143699646,
1.0442157984,
0.6031185985,
0.626542151,
0.4278873205,
0.386715889,
0.5277068615,
-0.1717590243,
0.2673418522,
0.1371365339,
-0.4529906213,
-0.2792576253,
-0.4199013412,
-0.398802191,
-0.484679848,
-0.1232997403,
-0.5889043212,
0.3483363092,
-0.4143311083,
0.1160318628,
0.2951775789,
0.3016470671,
-0.691675961,
-0.345443964,
0.2086423934,
0.64096421,
-0.518922925,
0.9187491536,
0.6617735624,
-0.5360981822,
-0.6433279514,
-0.3922273219,
0.0533261709,
-0.6767544746,
0.5345154405,
0.5408120751,
0.316029489,
-0.1313421428,
-0.7845262885,
-0.2443810999,
0.8728406429,
-0.0815584883,
-0.2655459642,
0.2001796216,
0.0235742331,
0.6919475198,
-0.5441941619,
0.456505388,
0.5887371898,
0.2255755216,
-0.2652140856,
-1.0987979174,
-0.2166499496,
-0.5271956325,
-0.1180506796,
0.3287491202,
-0.418110013,
0.7331628203,
-0.5462900996,
0.0397479609,
0.1855127513,
0.4612582028,
0.410575062,
0.5682246685,
0.0431290269,
0.1999909282,
0.8075692654,
0.1472412348,
1.3691442013,
-0.4818007648,
-0.052540686,
1.0166926384,
-0.3739058077,
0.6436607838,
0.3591641188,
-0.2921248674,
0.7798887491,
0.2482865751,
-0.0036742378,
0.2654078007,
0.5332953334,
-0.1774044633,
-0.0949155614,
-0.2190462053,
-0.1750695556,
0.4733947217,
0.4962973893,
0.0192692,
0.0245630555,
-0.10364981,
0.0985209271,
0.2558718324,
-0.0028805165,
0.9010618925,
-0.1251958609,
-1.1302070618,
0.5617387891,
0.091936782,
0.4803273976,
-0.522190392,
-0.2351722866,
-0.4272140861,
-0.0803562775,
-0.189369902,
-0.8573631644,
0.2147051841,
0.4857057035,
0.1730120778,
0.0615590625,
0.5276526213,
-0.3080715239,
-0.4422326386,
-0.1287887692,
0.2073369324,
0.2985387444,
0.2117733657,
-0.6956655979,
0.2469062358,
0.0646331459,
0.0446467027,
0.2115177363,
0.3823912144,
-0.0936871842,
0.6735503078,
0.6691733599,
-0.1477705836,
0.3418856859,
-0.0016891405,
0.9068747163,
-0.5151259899,
-0.4381552339,
-0.4298267663,
0.5717858076,
-0.2261891663,
-0.5587798357,
0.6182798147,
0.6466780901,
0.7055791616,
-0.1126787812,
0.8530421853,
-0.41027385,
0.076007925,
-0.3357185721,
0.4758567512,
-0.1185683161,
0.3308123052,
-0.403101474,
-0.71626544,
-0.1715364605,
0.8134788275,
-0.0624367669,
-0.1090564802,
0.4562230706,
0.8484833241,
-0.0107912738,
0.2368350923,
-0.1529778242,
0.0242230352,
0.5216307044,
0.7328723669,
0.807924509,
-0.3125335276,
0.5874637961,
-0.5518391728,
-0.1954225749,
-0.3026347458,
-0.9491980672,
-1.0143505335,
-0.4050489366,
-0.5746247768,
-0.2899768054,
-0.2117737532,
1.0439776182,
0.4129091799,
-0.590177238,
-0.4064331353,
-0.5628132224,
0.1904809773,
-0.2155136913,
-0.2633247674,
0.1461607814,
-0.4969799221,
-0.6829472184,
0.611573875,
0.144767791,
-0.032820832,
-0.3384002447,
-0.3166740537,
0.124776192,
-0.0005803938,
0.3642522395,
0.3399561942,
-0.3906216621,
0.156324923,
0.071252875,
-0.1718341261,
0.0520824827,
1.0680525303,
-1.1801877022,
0.7999728918,
0.6046358943,
0.6167694926,
0.561999321,
0.0981424302,
0.6061666012,
-0.9017911553,
0.075361535,
0.2608819306,
0.0888846964,
0.3256496787,
-0.1284762621,
0.5585044026,
-0.0068533504,
-0.7222334146,
-0.9121104479,
-0.0622439794,
-1.0959054232,
-0.4008789361,
1.0306210518,
-0.1190454513,
-0.25861606,
-0.1996417344,
-0.4150796235,
0.1182236746,
-0.5539000034,
1.0473424196,
0.3703621328,
-0.5867666602,
0.3335985243,
-0.5197054744,
0.7753483653,
0.2044020295,
-1.1679280996,
0.1610181481,
0.7826918364,
-0.1345878541,
0.1557070166,
0.4856806695,
0.1822539717,
0.5999943018,
0.2446532696,
-0.2142917961,
-0.3445853293,
-0.4746314883,
-0.230308935,
-0.0047745053,
-0.0014301501,
0.1961106807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09246v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09246v3 | I2D2: Inductive Knowledge Distillation with NeuroLogic and Self-Imitation | 2022-12-19T04:47:49 | 2023-05-26T17:14:27 | Chandra Bhagavatula, Jena D. Hwang, Doug Downey, Ronan Le Bras, Ximing Lu, Lianhui Qin, Keisuke Sakaguchi, Swabha Swayamdipta, Peter West, Yejin Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Commonsense capabilities of pre-trained language models dramatically improve
with scale, leading many to believe that scale is the only winning recipe. But
is it? Here, we investigate an alternative that a priori seems impossible: can
smaller language models (e.g., GPT-2) win over models that are orders of
magnitude larger and better (e.g., GPT-3), if powered with novel commonsense
distillation algorithms? The key intellectual challenge is to design a learning
algorithm that achieve a competitive level of commonsense acquisition, without
relying on the benefits of scale. In particular, we study generative models of
commonsense knowledge, focusing on the task of generating generics, statements
of commonsense facts about everyday concepts, e.g., birds can fly.
We introduce I2D2, a novel commonsense distillation framework that loosely
follows the Symbolic Knowledge Distillation of West et al. but breaks the
dependence on the extreme-scale teacher model with two innovations: (1) the
novel adaptation of NeuroLogic Decoding to enhance the generation quality of
the weak, off-the-shelf language models, and (2) self-imitation learning to
iteratively learn from the model's own enhanced commonsense acquisition
capabilities. Empirical results suggest that scale is not the only way, as
novel algorithms can be a promising alternative. Moreover, our study leads to a
new corpus of generics, Gen-A-tomic, that is the largest and highest quality
available to date. | [
-0.1144501418,
-0.4687936604,
0.4970236123,
0.0749602169,
-0.1133016348,
0.0233050361,
-0.2537593246,
-0.3680066466,
-0.0586049519,
0.1928488016,
-0.1649821252,
0.1544923186,
-1.1184550524,
0.0607041381,
-0.4364000857,
0.9397134185,
0.2894335389,
0.1657918692,
-0.3474552333,
-0.0913008228,
-0.0399748646,
-0.235374406,
-0.6528447866,
-0.7316347361,
0.385486871,
0.4051130712,
0.5347859263,
0.8356556892,
0.4019058049,
0.2360592186,
-0.1801787168,
0.11672315,
-0.482953459,
-0.088596642,
-0.4663846493,
-0.5303584933,
-0.171348691,
0.2799647152,
0.3456354737,
0.6434979439,
-0.3418104649,
0.0548965633,
0.2937852442,
0.8431462646,
-0.3115587234,
0.2253724039,
-0.8615368009,
-0.1065291539,
-0.0478673354,
0.1640929878,
-0.3983706236,
-0.2791175544,
-0.0005309668,
-0.7821941376,
0.1086306721,
-0.1185507253,
0.6942286491,
0.4032202661,
-0.4751102626,
-0.7647547722,
-0.6474277377,
0.4905701578,
-0.855882287,
-0.08993458,
0.3307253718,
0.4058597088,
-0.0898952335,
-1.2073984146,
-0.8536595702,
-0.3124291599,
-0.0149715235,
0.1898698658,
-0.4901101887,
-0.0714170709,
0.206284076,
0.2639939189,
-0.5284788013,
0.4233085811,
-0.6101708412,
0.3420186043,
0.3480573595,
-0.1293215305,
0.3418826759,
-0.0679994449,
-0.464881897,
-0.080797337,
-0.6066277027,
-0.2536540329,
0.3759612143,
0.1824213862,
0.0150161451,
0.3990270197,
-0.2389530689,
0.3778363764,
0.3486880958,
-0.1349960864,
0.0377653651,
0.0111205811,
0.0772742406,
-0.0505759642,
0.5710909367,
0.4482869506,
0.3598558903,
-0.0368457399,
-0.1420138776,
0.0032067616,
0.0321611837,
-0.8374942541,
-0.6640736461,
0.1381273568,
-0.4280758202,
-0.5163665414,
-0.3471111655,
-0.7385650277,
-0.6435420513,
-0.4002820253,
0.5685299635,
-0.3736774623,
-1.0429394245,
-0.0248896554,
-0.4747278988,
0.1743456423,
0.2468309999,
-1.4148962498,
0.4308741093,
0.9383809566,
0.9789521694,
0.0427892394,
-0.4186641872,
-0.1017459258,
-0.0294401906,
-0.4773263633,
0.6729771495,
-0.4579156041,
-0.4081555009,
-0.3625445664,
-0.43678689,
0.1623762846,
-1.0385278463,
0.0285769999,
-0.4113207757,
0.0148616768,
-0.4177061021,
-0.576340735,
-0.1492552906,
0.0426541716,
-0.5857786536,
0.8559159636,
0.3004949093,
-0.722546339,
0.458260864,
-0.7525531054,
-0.4609012008,
0.1391256601,
-0.1067774072,
-0.1317096949,
0.4901566207,
-0.0368843786,
0.2776280046,
-0.6826389432,
0.2354103923,
-0.4358537197,
-0.1354353279,
0.1220081523,
-0.6216356754,
0.9123492837,
0.5242219567,
-0.3415649533,
-0.4470047951,
-0.6353467703,
-0.1042164937,
0.3591622412,
-0.0909490436,
-0.4606172144,
-0.0494576544,
-0.1059603393,
0.2336803526,
0.2583245933,
-0.4741204381,
0.2721263468,
-0.1425205767,
0.939622283,
0.7583439946,
-0.0035380183,
0.6142023206,
-0.350661248,
0.2208575755,
0.124424085,
0.0443107188,
0.2833711207,
-0.4727791548,
-0.484649837,
-0.3057377934,
0.2157832682,
0.2811858058,
-0.740083158,
0.1771734804,
-0.546216011,
-0.6445971727,
-0.3101522028,
0.1453561485,
0.3091037571,
0.4919325113,
0.238625899,
0.009977309,
-0.2688929737,
-0.6969248056,
-0.4296803176,
-0.3537828326,
-0.0822280794,
0.0035430996,
0.4872553349,
0.086812757,
0.8041353226,
-0.4368225336,
-0.268222779,
-0.3714826107,
0.4548156559,
0.1041393504,
0.7436388135,
0.5426698923,
-0.7272020578,
-0.4650700092,
0.0268488154,
-0.86172539,
0.0605436116,
-0.0308390204,
0.2846899331,
-0.056162484,
0.6436882019,
-0.4564913511,
-0.1033310145,
0.5341472626,
-0.2095504403,
0.2551009357,
-0.6500253081,
-0.0975689739,
-1.1245440245,
-0.2491315305,
-0.0827720165,
0.3026564717,
-0.6291611195,
0.1459942311,
0.2061370462,
0.0182499643,
-0.2147720754,
0.6249190569,
-0.4001680911,
0.0002394297,
-0.4557986856,
0.2196443379,
-0.1190790161,
0.3077435791,
0.0790862069,
0.7918921113,
0.3101756871,
-0.3162932694,
0.2744237185,
-0.1840250194,
-0.5250246525,
0.6224876642,
-0.6421083808,
-0.0144896852,
-0.3401944339,
0.2189178467,
-1.2473090887,
-0.2692265809,
-0.2614195347,
-0.580580771,
0.4409121871,
-0.1618641615,
-0.5665115714,
-0.482735604,
0.0481657311,
0.3561020792,
0.8769148588,
-0.9780262113,
0.4333658814,
0.1268704832,
-0.1592109352,
-0.4223748147,
-0.980964303,
0.2588286996,
-0.3083524108,
-0.2198621482,
-0.0913633779,
0.1506886035,
-0.5045105219,
0.1369806081,
-0.1164168641,
-0.208677873,
0.1659262776,
-0.0229065008,
-0.0794315338,
-0.1241529658,
0.2603783607,
0.3508994281,
-0.266333431,
0.060010422,
-0.7826038003,
0.231486544,
-0.0721342415,
-0.1018194631,
-0.4836685061,
0.1528317183,
0.8218688965,
-0.1296070218,
0.3173448145,
0.4121662378,
-0.2999491096,
-0.4479576945,
-0.4638327062,
-0.5574865341,
-0.4981734455,
0.6328847408,
-0.655493319,
-0.6118765473,
0.0900048912,
-0.5516761541,
0.047479026,
0.6053066254,
0.4136789143,
-0.2090401947,
0.587276876,
0.3540479839,
0.234439522,
0.2126481831,
-0.5302034616,
0.1898316145,
-0.8357152343,
-0.1382351667,
-0.3455325961,
-0.582182169,
-0.5235608816,
-0.4708973467,
0.534414351,
0.1825215966,
-0.2585770786,
0.2653623521,
-0.6084822416,
0.7777442336,
0.805061996,
-0.0207701959,
0.3696237206,
0.0965997949,
0.0671849176,
-0.0963147208,
-0.8337997794,
-0.4443052411,
1.4759391546,
0.2768522203,
0.6289401054,
0.3475588262,
0.885936439,
0.3258332908,
0.4931386411,
-0.5414417386,
0.3188005388,
-0.6512099504,
-0.6536165476,
-0.4186728597,
-0.3210560083,
-0.6335387826,
0.4595571756,
0.0608828627,
-0.4668767154,
0.1408084929,
0.1049942002,
-0.4108994305,
0.6149334311,
-0.9105916023,
0.738509059,
-0.0829803497,
-0.3182111681,
-0.4798853397,
-0.5159127712,
0.651181519,
-0.0257113818,
0.237952292,
-0.0790945515,
-0.1245812327,
0.6284657717,
-0.3635644019,
0.7509399652,
-0.4315984249,
-0.1549613774,
0.5032348037,
0.2948207557,
0.6386355758,
0.1027596742,
-0.1226508021,
0.1836020201,
0.121376209,
-0.5047437549,
-0.9156391025,
0.8499698639,
-0.9543921351,
-0.6191089749,
-0.4053703547,
-0.3121564388,
-0.1079029664,
-0.0111758159,
0.4986883402,
0.5149089098,
0.0235531535,
0.1290216744,
0.6565638185,
0.1136532649,
0.5819956064,
0.4303758442,
0.154760927,
-0.518224895,
1.090546608,
0.4543853104,
0.6811313629,
0.4944125116,
0.495398283,
-0.6025543213,
-0.5779764652,
-0.4629991949,
0.1188782826,
-0.7244158983,
-0.1898176223,
-0.6936333179,
-0.1205551177,
-0.4815582037,
-0.2075001299,
-0.55343014,
-0.7721928954,
-0.4112475812,
-0.2414930463,
0.420740366,
1.2051029205,
-0.7600421906,
0.1121677607,
-0.1131030247,
0.2530806065,
0.9181579351,
0.1483507305,
0.2987982929,
-0.7136355639,
0.1715943664,
0.0472547188,
-0.0958047956,
-0.591691792,
0.1797402203,
0.1616210192,
0.238046065,
0.5107151866,
0.210999459,
0.4466863573,
-0.3350250423,
0.8557828665,
0.4189310968,
-0.6741111279,
0.130090192,
-0.2121099383,
0.2777547836,
0.5066089034,
0.2308235168,
-0.4419944584,
-0.2232690603,
-0.6840273738,
-0.5389235616,
0.4633561075,
-0.0555550233,
0.3824639022,
-0.1258226633,
0.481656909,
0.3437314928,
0.0122076757,
-0.7240393162,
-0.0630297512,
-0.4656954706,
-0.3768312037,
-0.1657099873,
-0.4216558635,
-0.0168415755,
-0.2717250288,
0.5501796603,
-0.1267441511,
0.0797907338,
-0.0047704545,
0.1554680169,
0.1871348321,
0.0778328478,
0.551358521,
0.4444036484,
0.070576407,
0.6139057279,
0.1377577931,
-0.5048818588,
0.3991135657,
-0.1422332972,
-0.1260559559,
-0.2491985708,
0.3656369448,
0.4652739465,
-0.0278042648,
-0.4637046754,
0.5464075208,
0.1695555896,
-0.5754960179,
-0.1583664268,
0.0226220675,
0.3348898292,
0.5396360159,
0.3441506326,
0.0629074126,
0.1402831376,
-0.4835080206,
0.255956769,
0.29337883,
-0.1696562767,
-0.2660936415,
0.8750829101,
0.2315076739,
-0.10431391,
0.7107046843,
-0.5176808834,
-0.1879793704,
0.836400032,
0.7127143741,
0.9456897378,
-0.0837389976,
0.3581547439,
0.7669124007,
0.3580524027,
-0.3245973289,
-0.0593352094,
-0.2660211325,
-0.5911943913,
0.1077974141,
-0.4703370035,
-0.2461380064,
0.1896139383,
-0.5500389934,
-0.0534828305,
-0.825173974,
0.104882881,
0.1091413349,
-0.0277264901,
-0.2008046061,
0.0016514881,
-0.1217248738,
0.770240128,
-0.796866715,
1.1638410091,
0.3447572887,
-0.5361395478,
-0.7774395347,
0.1106648371,
0.1063717753,
-0.8215017915,
0.9302108884,
-0.1427841336,
0.1777707338,
0.3753417134,
-0.4628692865,
-0.8870919347,
1.2735898495,
0.1918690801,
-0.5665834546,
-0.2264211327,
0.0233117212,
0.4491130412,
-0.2439845949,
0.2584459484,
0.6460449696,
0.3988175094,
0.4333941936,
-0.8202685714,
-0.0015710747,
-0.0789828002,
0.3143102229,
-0.0852102786,
-0.834176302,
1.0383548737,
-0.6328884363,
-0.1399736106,
0.2596857548,
0.6989153028,
-0.0003148245,
0.19046022,
0.2753759325,
0.6881558299,
0.7114395499,
-0.0799297914,
0.6638947725,
-0.2674579322,
0.3512600064,
1.5375944376,
-0.1935923994,
0.9137547612,
0.5016416907,
-0.3043026328,
0.4555838704,
0.3108196557,
0.0004238468,
0.6888615489,
0.2965422869,
-0.409692198,
-0.0233369675,
0.2839161456,
-0.399111867,
0.5471817255,
0.4234469235,
-0.183423847,
-0.4716047645,
0.2368500084,
0.1401738971,
0.5865536332,
-0.0013687916,
1.107278347,
0.0422642305,
-0.670468986,
0.8907755613,
-0.0848758072,
0.7178612351,
-0.4793056846,
0.0266396794,
-0.4731020629,
0.3509909511,
0.1537909955,
-0.5587916374,
0.1560315043,
-0.1987578124,
-0.1017677262,
-0.2296720296,
0.1952109486,
-0.5632896423,
-0.2474402487,
0.0672667027,
0.2678287923,
0.1324654371,
-0.025198387,
-0.4396086037,
-0.2531155348,
-0.1614895314,
0.0192339513,
0.3466756046,
0.6588353515,
0.3159501255,
0.6210132241,
0.3211762905,
0.1736557484,
0.1164651439,
-0.3885538876,
0.6017971635,
-0.3029130101,
-0.294623822,
-0.6687998772,
0.153235808,
-0.1447721273,
-0.3247117698,
0.5337204337,
0.5034479499,
0.8849536777,
-0.282507062,
0.9815046787,
-0.2607282996,
0.3352107704,
-0.3896596134,
0.8159767985,
-0.6640162468,
-0.0088767214,
0.1027213633,
-0.6057429314,
-0.068994835,
0.3965577185,
-0.218588084,
-0.1207854599,
0.736823082,
0.8696849942,
-0.0196996592,
0.1617300957,
0.5480381846,
0.4488349855,
0.4691596925,
0.7731046677,
0.7096918225,
-0.434099555,
0.3461292684,
-0.1508878469,
-0.5417361259,
-0.1770671308,
-0.617536664,
-0.6894575953,
-0.9433358312,
-0.29302001,
-0.4473734796,
0.0935143828,
0.9674233794,
0.6066039801,
-0.5082989335,
-0.3305609226,
-0.6270714402,
0.0201633926,
-0.558321774,
-0.1695723534,
0.2744564712,
-0.634406209,
-0.9770724773,
0.2064267397,
0.2361620665,
0.365914613,
-0.2614533901,
-0.1049519479,
-0.0045149415,
0.2529695034,
0.6323625445,
0.4696522057,
-0.9377593994,
-0.0716119856,
-0.4266444147,
-0.2075790018,
-0.2492648959,
0.7875252366,
-0.6230890155,
0.6868646741,
0.2587528825,
0.4980656207,
0.4870447218,
-0.3459854126,
0.2787972391,
-0.1933902651,
0.3230603039,
0.1767573357,
-0.0083382903,
0.1277014017,
-0.1748917848,
0.5851091743,
0.5032656789,
-0.2634711564,
-0.6732130647,
0.3400852382,
-0.6225410104,
-0.6687096953,
1.3992859125,
-0.0652474239,
0.0119276652,
0.1159469336,
-0.1118850708,
0.0323619545,
-0.1311014146,
1.0336414576,
0.5250554085,
0.0687457025,
-0.0362960212,
-0.353441,
0.7546791434,
0.1823692322,
-0.589094758,
0.4407197833,
0.334079504,
0.5842398405,
0.0129818711,
0.6648259759,
-0.3151372075,
0.2126720399,
0.7205975056,
-0.1535541862,
-0.2931998968,
-0.4189819396,
-0.3263668716,
0.3661088645,
0.4107096195,
-0.0465055034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09235v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09235v2 | PAL: Persona-Augmented Emotional Support Conversation Generation | 2022-12-19T04:12:54 | 2023-05-29T06:59:14 | Jiale Cheng, Sahand Sabour, Hao Sun, Zhuang Chen, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Due to the lack of human resources for mental health support, there is an
increasing demand for employing conversational agents for support. Recent work
has demonstrated the effectiveness of dialogue models in providing emotional
support. As previous studies have demonstrated that seekers' persona is an
important factor for effective support, we investigate whether there are
benefits to modeling such information in dialogue models for support. In this
paper, our empirical analysis verifies that persona has an important impact on
emotional support. Therefore, we propose a framework for dynamically inferring
and modeling seekers' persona. We first train a model for inferring the
seeker's persona from the conversation history. Accordingly, we propose PAL, a
model that leverages persona information and, in conjunction with our
strategy-based controllable generation method, provides personalized emotional
support. Automatic and manual evaluations demonstrate that PAL achieves
state-of-the-art results, outperforming the baselines on the studied benchmark.
Our code and data are publicly available at https://github.com/chengjl19/PAL. | [
-0.4552205801,
-0.6864091158,
0.6082030535,
0.5259216428,
0.1161820367,
0.2788182199,
0.2191558182,
-0.4321283102,
0.5931131244,
0.6580973864,
-0.9892961979,
0.1681126207,
-0.0341404751,
0.0407259353,
0.0626907796,
0.8294788003,
0.2755959332,
0.052995339,
-0.0953099504,
0.0789902136,
-0.729934454,
-0.3664797843,
-0.9153439999,
-0.3663479686,
0.3769111633,
0.422390908,
0.4949505627,
0.0408087112,
0.3313878179,
0.2805131674,
0.0848608986,
0.1383957714,
-0.390537262,
0.5430155993,
0.0211852584,
-0.6801609993,
-0.8398842812,
-0.0302936286,
0.5546392202,
0.4591799378,
-0.7742202878,
-0.0498893112,
-0.199568212,
0.6197607517,
-0.5381895304,
0.236934796,
-0.6345623732,
0.2765900791,
-0.3264491856,
-0.2954370975,
-0.5067262053,
-0.194027707,
0.44138515,
-0.5326709747,
0.0983599648,
0.1828420311,
0.5163276792,
0.1231407449,
-0.5131465197,
-0.1911039352,
-0.7053061724,
0.3932212889,
-0.4696422815,
0.2355437428,
0.5191954374,
0.8203055859,
-0.2756720781,
-0.4807904363,
-0.5285506845,
-0.1422208548,
-0.2313058078,
0.2874824405,
-0.1945870817,
0.4441578388,
0.3528541028,
0.3539265692,
-0.2596275508,
-0.3242845237,
0.1291487366,
0.0821404383,
0.5347379446,
0.2454954237,
0.4236700237,
-0.2988681793,
-0.2550597787,
0.1285546869,
-0.4250776768,
0.2979216278,
0.4296247661,
0.0579200275,
-0.2634836435,
0.6979976892,
-0.2894484997,
0.2694995403,
0.7171922922,
-0.1751718819,
0.0652078912,
0.1938236505,
-0.1630695611,
0.2454267889,
0.54057616,
0.5058695674,
-0.0481766015,
0.0634444281,
-0.1807123721,
-0.0140641909,
0.3075034618,
-0.9494203329,
-0.2833907604,
0.211685136,
-0.6773719788,
-0.053212788,
-0.0381075256,
-1.1149847507,
-1.0192414522,
-0.2288403064,
-0.110470131,
-0.524695158,
-0.6206667423,
0.0136096096,
-0.1140667349,
0.1679970324,
0.3880245984,
-0.964538455,
0.2103702724,
0.5125311613,
0.7987701297,
0.1739291847,
0.1023896709,
-0.9257817864,
0.1741874665,
-0.0746685565,
0.7411888838,
-0.8581371903,
-0.5941941738,
0.1333241016,
-0.0031118428,
0.0098731834,
-0.42201823,
0.3911214173,
-0.2791365981,
0.5735931396,
-0.705965519,
-0.4828922749,
0.2187027633,
0.2975912988,
-0.5547175407,
0.5879721642,
0.5491449833,
-0.7116636038,
0.2546993792,
-0.8470902443,
-0.0182485338,
0.7104135752,
-0.1968608052,
-0.002115373,
0.2555052638,
0.1277971417,
0.3828518391,
-0.4146042764,
0.3380855024,
-0.3423368931,
-0.0255889837,
0.3785276711,
-0.326795578,
0.5591172576,
0.1712252051,
-0.4576185346,
-0.1113301665,
-0.6571596265,
-0.3522228301,
0.2413160354,
-0.2656204998,
-0.1298211366,
0.2935133278,
-0.146358192,
0.1429950595,
0.0241543986,
-0.7494885921,
-0.0185747929,
-0.4418535829,
0.0886674523,
0.6926026344,
0.2508057356,
0.5198948383,
-0.3118933439,
0.979234755,
-0.2116924822,
0.1022033244,
-0.4526171982,
-0.51549685,
-0.3871932626,
-0.5402498841,
-0.1366597116,
0.5456963778,
-0.9250369668,
0.2336640507,
-0.0166467875,
-0.2711761594,
-0.5857765079,
-0.3116934299,
0.3835868537,
0.9658013582,
0.0076213223,
-0.5316222906,
-0.6974061131,
-0.818202436,
-0.0832431242,
-0.6948163509,
-0.1999323815,
0.7423112988,
-0.2234549224,
-0.4272448421,
1.1110303402,
-0.4179610312,
0.0169861484,
-0.2761704922,
-0.0097920913,
-0.2870257199,
0.223917231,
0.8817975521,
-0.7515079975,
-0.8166065216,
-0.1906778216,
-0.7198764682,
-0.6012442112,
-0.3363976777,
-0.6142266989,
0.1075974852,
0.041511666,
-0.783605516,
0.3855538964,
0.3844794929,
-0.7956424356,
0.6464966536,
-0.0658144131,
0.2505912185,
-0.9327970743,
0.2803561091,
0.3038028777,
-0.487565279,
-0.8021658063,
-0.1550870389,
-0.3306133449,
-0.386667788,
-0.3738827407,
0.7866766453,
-0.0192941669,
0.1927178502,
-0.447753191,
0.0419374295,
0.073607415,
0.4061425328,
0.2448554486,
0.4045597017,
0.4678333402,
-0.1404781342,
0.7840672135,
0.5379231572,
-0.0887924209,
1.6081403494,
-0.5607076287,
-0.0809654519,
-0.3475209475,
0.6973547339,
-0.9431416988,
-0.5656905174,
0.6643325686,
-0.2820732594,
0.4417422712,
-0.1133621782,
-0.3189610541,
-0.3999604285,
0.0186896566,
-0.0000266487,
0.3801914752,
-0.5979036689,
0.9534641504,
0.6185656786,
-0.4717594087,
-0.0476243086,
-0.2921960056,
0.1848522127,
-0.6740252376,
-0.6271221638,
0.4393574893,
-0.5041873455,
-0.4302493334,
-0.3159011006,
-0.0156833939,
0.1427489668,
-0.0162331406,
0.4816383123,
0.1235833168,
0.1109312549,
0.2713223994,
-0.0579867512,
-0.0705796704,
0.4643106163,
0.3220291138,
0.9410428405,
-0.361777544,
-0.2071415484,
-0.6322346926,
0.7407514453,
0.6167455316,
-0.2677282691,
0.8998676538,
0.3543643653,
-0.4305882752,
0.062685445,
-0.780839324,
-0.2654134929,
-0.5753071308,
0.0522188805,
-0.3626279533,
-0.4001854956,
0.7022785544,
-0.1070669815,
-0.1595444381,
-0.0803547129,
0.4153721333,
-0.2133862078,
1.6030080318,
0.5892758965,
0.095413819,
0.8952038288,
0.2217104733,
0.0845188648,
-0.6976197362,
-0.6327931881,
-0.1169568896,
-0.3433920741,
-0.4855774045,
0.1249594539,
0.1369401366,
-0.2705227137,
-0.5503206849,
-0.1049823761,
-0.4732226133,
-0.0396981202,
0.4942944646,
0.4167607427,
-0.1742573082,
0.03702683,
0.1421993822,
-0.3630643487,
-0.4154987633,
-0.4065009952,
0.4347830117,
0.6143174767,
0.6033249497,
0.3403719068,
0.3223728836,
0.3960830569,
0.2439268976,
-0.5862072706,
0.797360003,
0.2242886126,
-0.6435796022,
0.0996760651,
-0.4412593246,
-0.8171852231,
-0.0121585168,
-0.3455206156,
-1.0554095507,
0.3553704321,
0.2346468419,
-0.5126209855,
-0.0052326918,
-0.8030771017,
0.4903284907,
-0.4829226732,
-0.3075737059,
-0.0717005581,
-0.8622154593,
0.2836531699,
-0.1653962135,
-0.3686514795,
-0.2189703584,
0.2805112302,
0.656027317,
-0.5753455162,
0.9083110094,
-0.6867029071,
0.0992038175,
0.2583171725,
0.2835786045,
0.5765459538,
0.3508060575,
-0.3022947013,
-0.6025552154,
0.1565082222,
-0.3704199195,
-0.7462942004,
0.6035245061,
-0.6029182673,
-0.7273241282,
-0.144728601,
-0.501375258,
-0.5070616007,
0.0159093887,
0.0402440093,
0.1367044896,
-0.0320204049,
0.2825740576,
0.7492808104,
-0.579693079,
0.3734160066,
0.5668167472,
-0.4203126431,
-0.4558958411,
0.6090370417,
-0.2300809026,
0.0355655476,
0.3085396886,
0.3506252766,
-0.2329069972,
0.4477201104,
-0.1840884387,
0.554746151,
-0.5188782215,
-0.051756613,
-0.812269032,
0.0003441762,
-0.3037239611,
-0.2877943218,
-0.3648270667,
0.0489673093,
-0.2701503038,
-0.2234498709,
0.3146585822,
0.3196522593,
0.1831072718,
0.8995940089,
-0.5812250376,
0.3021608591,
0.582087636,
0.47130391,
-0.0251261741,
0.1665604264,
-0.0724928156,
0.4174321592,
-0.4051164389,
-1.4574210644,
0.646291852,
0.3286771774,
0.7838133574,
0.6232705712,
0.1501399726,
0.715088129,
-0.3139919937,
0.9260749817,
0.2902531922,
-0.9546718001,
1.0118200779,
-0.5950804353,
0.0209090784,
0.5589140058,
0.0944589227,
-0.7556844354,
0.1196106896,
-0.9129104614,
-0.5221480727,
0.9152525663,
0.0816924572,
0.1206134409,
-0.216547817,
0.6687346697,
-0.1274667978,
0.6938730478,
-0.5823159814,
-0.1782556176,
-0.1157286391,
-0.1560709327,
0.2673964202,
-0.4894138277,
-0.1916538924,
0.0597941205,
0.5208414197,
-0.3094130456,
0.7183496356,
0.0084635355,
0.3834166825,
-0.606194973,
-0.2727974355,
0.1397168189,
0.3163202107,
-0.3771047294,
-0.0992729068,
-0.0100843897,
-0.1696470976,
-0.0718992576,
0.2886901796,
0.0702880993,
0.0337073319,
-0.3335735202,
1.1165474653,
-0.0822099671,
-0.9668851495,
0.4956762493,
-0.3440926373,
0.2693767846,
-0.2584287524,
0.1454501599,
-0.1978315413,
0.5238505602,
0.2155041844,
-0.2072431594,
0.1189833358,
-0.633395493,
0.0586526878,
0.6680398583,
-0.4161494076,
-0.5284613371,
0.7041672468,
0.3612470627,
-0.7434534431,
0.691000998,
-0.1262376755,
-0.4343943298,
0.3702131212,
0.7327694297,
0.7400411367,
-0.6881238818,
0.7250351906,
-0.0167545024,
-0.3389320672,
-0.1631017327,
0.4383585453,
-0.0862945169,
-0.4429204166,
-0.0482051522,
-0.4101285338,
-0.7774752378,
-0.0816657469,
-0.6027569175,
0.3070287406,
-0.1907803118,
-0.3636679947,
-0.4534264803,
0.2703650594,
-0.7479445338,
0.2091323584,
0.4811678529,
0.6883767247,
-0.7356683016,
0.4299051464,
0.8341644406,
-0.2070350796,
-0.6742997766,
-0.0778914616,
0.1740778238,
-0.6067556143,
0.2676047981,
0.298800081,
0.1733933538,
-0.0988355577,
-0.4474309683,
-0.6806845665,
1.2528203726,
0.7843188047,
-0.2790782154,
-0.3131402731,
0.2722001374,
0.8337006569,
-0.7419700623,
0.4987674654,
0.4785095453,
0.2601023912,
0.3037326038,
-0.7328338623,
-0.1171132103,
-0.6554203629,
0.1014391482,
-0.0685084984,
-0.9251071215,
0.4634797275,
0.3405471742,
-0.264246881,
0.2008624226,
0.4085702002,
0.8191342354,
0.4754483998,
0.6811419725,
0.2338824123,
1.1672546864,
0.0655914471,
1.1090643406,
-0.3980738819,
-0.0094427085,
1.1701157093,
-0.6186485887,
0.5211404562,
0.3868618608,
0.0733279064,
0.8077720404,
0.7150362134,
0.1601735801,
0.6232165098,
-0.1514374018,
-0.6682982445,
-0.1200711876,
-0.7078253627,
-0.2825689614,
0.2859952748,
0.6488921642,
-0.517845571,
0.1063617691,
0.3288641274,
-0.0610419475,
-0.1702197343,
-0.1685818583,
0.5940816998,
-0.0513731726,
-0.8756468296,
-0.0445691273,
-0.1795595139,
0.3856908083,
-0.6124269366,
0.0649162307,
-0.5560486913,
-0.0317033008,
-0.1780006438,
-0.4625013173,
0.1342253983,
0.1081325188,
-0.1847456545,
-0.5077462196,
1.0144590139,
-0.3627811968,
-0.3316873312,
0.1482904404,
0.7014681101,
-0.0755279735,
-0.209832564,
-0.6525717974,
-0.3085799813,
-0.0197135247,
-0.436978519,
0.4620121717,
0.4595605135,
0.1475666314,
0.7951027155,
0.4016146958,
0.1402866691,
-0.0712834895,
-0.0860465169,
0.6749030948,
-0.3315460682,
-0.6673572063,
-0.7034297585,
0.8642550707,
-0.2820321918,
-0.1149132699,
0.6145176291,
0.1901614219,
0.1633953601,
0.1910368949,
0.6443536878,
-0.236383602,
0.570907712,
0.0821573213,
0.6887077093,
-0.4584451914,
0.4710809588,
-0.3875513971,
-0.9002178907,
-0.0437970981,
0.5900334716,
-0.1223300099,
0.0090151159,
0.0459149331,
0.8020123839,
0.1771478951,
0.2034690827,
-0.0467291288,
-0.0587888807,
0.9992724061,
0.526481092,
0.9934860468,
0.0841646045,
0.0527164564,
-0.4913133979,
-0.3409857154,
-0.2086559236,
-0.8674511313,
-0.7387107611,
-0.6262949705,
-0.4625046253,
-0.555075109,
0.0086770291,
1.0492734909,
0.7825090885,
-0.2685648799,
-0.0965320468,
-0.336171478,
-0.3099951148,
0.1219809726,
-0.3295775354,
-0.1432024539,
-0.0754593089,
-0.6917372346,
0.40659073,
0.1565988809,
0.1114962846,
-0.4229693711,
-0.2186342478,
-0.0159942545,
0.4122469127,
0.5909264684,
0.4895315766,
-0.5445913076,
-0.2664436996,
0.2793488204,
0.016946245,
0.1533862501,
0.7150524855,
-1.20307827,
0.9376631379,
0.4859833419,
0.5772853494,
0.188084498,
0.3744751513,
0.9274780154,
-0.9762724042,
-0.0130056906,
0.224748835,
0.6454674006,
0.5771428943,
-0.8183363676,
0.5651468635,
0.2126502991,
-0.7231192589,
-1.0686616898,
0.3111013174,
-0.9534956813,
0.2225610167,
1.2934833765,
-0.2416545898,
0.0424152836,
0.2579661012,
-0.8271197677,
0.3339237273,
-0.6765357852,
0.7946593761,
0.5129275322,
-0.5745227933,
-0.6862119436,
-0.2735361159,
0.3313577473,
0.290212065,
-0.8763054609,
-0.1270285994,
0.6622398496,
-0.1437568665,
0.0977636129,
0.6911712885,
0.3398065269,
0.1315534711,
-0.2721404433,
-0.0977196023,
0.2975757718,
-0.1504784971,
-0.1696250141,
0.3055128455,
-0.0137013393,
0.0836181641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09233v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09233v2 | OASum: Large-Scale Open Domain Aspect-based Summarization | 2022-12-19T04:04:17 | 2023-05-25T22:29:45 | Xianjun Yang, Kaiqiang Song, Sangwoo Cho, Xiaoyang Wang, Xiaoman Pan, Linda Petzold, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect or query-based summarization has recently caught more attention, as it
can generate differentiated summaries based on users' interests. However, the
current dataset for aspect or query-based summarization either focuses on
specific domains, contains relatively small-scale instances, or includes only a
few aspect types. Such limitations hinder further explorations in this
direction. In this work, we take advantage of crowd-sourcing knowledge on
Wikipedia.org and automatically create a high-quality, large-scale open-domain
aspect-based summarization dataset named OASum, which contains more than 3.7
million instances with around 1 million different aspects on 2 million
Wikipedia pages. We provide benchmark results on OASum and demonstrate its
ability for diverse aspect-based summarization generation. To overcome the data
scarcity problem on specific domains, we also perform zero-shot, few-shot, and
fine-tuning on seven downstream datasets. Specifically, zero/few-shot and
fine-tuning results show that the model pre-trained on our corpus demonstrates
a strong aspect or query-focused generation ability compared with the backbone
model. Our dataset and pre-trained checkpoints are publicly available. | [
-0.7620148063,
-0.764914453,
0.4263826311,
-0.1306722164,
-0.1599646509,
-0.1637631208,
-0.103251487,
-0.3491520286,
0.7359426618,
0.645558238,
-0.4169521034,
-0.5824401975,
-0.40456146,
0.0584633835,
-0.4479742646,
1.3034006357,
-0.2447093427,
-0.2555323839,
-0.3367803395,
-0.4745023251,
0.0847751573,
-0.4956327677,
-0.3934699595,
0.221428901,
0.7154211402,
0.8610962629,
0.4583817124,
0.7089648843,
0.4817292988,
0.1493484676,
-0.0836796165,
0.6559363604,
-0.8671686649,
0.2239701748,
-0.5868749022,
-0.1075574607,
-0.8234654665,
-0.1187045723,
0.7002266645,
0.8213937283,
-0.0326612145,
0.5781878233,
0.0429285578,
0.8219741583,
-0.8251594901,
0.0607534237,
-0.5334958434,
-0.2627763748,
-0.3556844592,
0.0327496789,
0.1296631396,
-0.2804379463,
0.0501953177,
-0.8057693243,
0.4855499864,
0.0804109126,
1.0341625214,
-0.0492995419,
-0.3660398126,
-0.2243469507,
-0.5943508148,
0.538572073,
-0.5765640736,
-0.149038434,
0.4793097377,
0.3892162442,
0.0689538941,
-0.5579379201,
-0.6528990269,
0.2827915549,
0.0930797309,
0.0024968076,
0.0484415516,
-0.2332811356,
-0.1594498158,
0.8361078501,
-0.6019645333,
-0.0076195863,
-0.3758676946,
0.1200474203,
0.6540127993,
0.3428678811,
-0.0826609954,
-0.3809646368,
-0.0525030158,
0.0638508797,
-0.691809535,
-0.2811540067,
0.3957040906,
0.4412516356,
-0.1655105948,
0.9746632576,
-1.0401880741,
0.5312968493,
0.1085964292,
-0.0628878921,
0.0038608173,
-0.4258925021,
-0.0465921648,
-0.1312614679,
0.7377285957,
0.4629611075,
-0.0861427337,
-0.0812659338,
0.0314480513,
-0.5502521992,
0.202889666,
-0.9894837737,
-0.0872557163,
0.5945127606,
-0.4858241677,
-0.0769050196,
0.392531842,
-0.8795826435,
-0.4615877569,
-0.3187877834,
0.3822381794,
-0.5014610291,
-0.2507636845,
-0.0408975892,
-0.1585026085,
-0.2810970545,
0.4998130798,
-0.6465722322,
0.1039868891,
0.7444912791,
1.1049255133,
-0.2390074283,
-0.5311924219,
-0.7496986389,
0.2900576591,
-0.1230898276,
0.9107894897,
-0.18140769,
-0.3032103777,
0.05402283,
-0.1681829691,
0.2286777496,
-0.4694594443,
0.0988245681,
-0.5989041328,
0.0247808509,
-0.4940723479,
-0.4575528204,
-0.3531642258,
0.3090075254,
-0.6400912404,
0.6822659373,
0.1826455742,
-0.6946703792,
0.4169795215,
-0.6776096821,
-0.6298266053,
-0.1927965283,
-0.1978547126,
-0.5833474398,
0.4154748619,
0.4800710976,
0.3390497267,
-0.0971315503,
0.0435042121,
-0.3254022002,
0.2375134677,
0.1381941438,
0.0949051231,
0.3662083447,
0.2695667744,
-0.1823869199,
0.1531067938,
-0.7671085596,
-0.3209247589,
0.1791699976,
-0.0467468128,
-0.4275444448,
0.0944181755,
-0.1241496429,
0.0038832647,
0.3508999944,
-0.4397148788,
0.2911453843,
-0.1918704212,
0.243060872,
0.2784106433,
0.4725244045,
0.3744567335,
-0.434087038,
0.2442879677,
0.2078283876,
0.1403660476,
-0.6737937331,
-0.3001382053,
-0.9646879435,
-0.2485991865,
0.1729342788,
0.1555168629,
-0.9269500375,
0.5650312304,
-0.5253605247,
-0.691336751,
-0.2326738983,
0.1406443715,
0.3351109922,
0.5852442384,
0.4760159254,
-0.6912433505,
-0.0859287456,
-0.6676071286,
-0.0363623053,
-0.1665500998,
-0.2262425274,
0.460408479,
0.7130974531,
0.4126855433,
1.201646924,
-1.0555298328,
-0.6963306069,
-0.2859448195,
0.3755487204,
-0.020602908,
0.2351763099,
0.666226685,
-0.6615362167,
-0.2157963514,
-0.0522596128,
-0.8646995425,
0.1974191368,
0.141695708,
-0.5170735121,
0.1272587031,
0.2408270538,
-0.5567724705,
0.3984574974,
0.2201115936,
-0.3164274096,
0.4075296521,
-0.2143629789,
0.5742462873,
-1.3559595346,
0.2608426511,
-0.0265269689,
-0.1819693297,
-0.2424154878,
0.4196498692,
0.0508854054,
-0.4238744378,
-0.5240056515,
0.4283180833,
-0.3546387851,
-0.0984605923,
-0.4186639786,
0.2865923047,
0.2246580571,
0.5628233552,
0.2743758261,
0.5073959827,
0.4352538586,
-0.8757542968,
0.1832509488,
0.4377049804,
-0.2918593884,
0.7826230526,
-0.5151441097,
0.0465202034,
-0.2839993536,
0.4206425548,
-0.5768692493,
-0.9551948905,
-0.0452130474,
-0.449572444,
0.0519890413,
-0.1852981746,
-0.3881104887,
-0.0716846734,
-0.5255723596,
0.3578808606,
0.0910372064,
-0.686657846,
0.4143782854,
0.6672407389,
-0.5743963122,
-0.1934534013,
-0.2858117819,
0.0818435773,
0.0142756654,
-0.6080147624,
0.3321867883,
0.2942224145,
-0.3227363527,
0.2330458462,
-0.1461673081,
-0.1135939136,
-0.2189371884,
0.3082363009,
-0.0805945545,
-0.3055280447,
-0.0662199333,
0.2968592942,
0.1781800389,
-0.253672123,
-0.5571817756,
0.4046342373,
0.1634467542,
-0.5576295257,
-0.1123334765,
0.6949055195,
0.4393476844,
-0.5540140867,
0.8484331369,
0.1455862373,
-0.3783505559,
-0.2777192891,
-0.3475588858,
0.0874526799,
-0.3736158907,
0.4916635752,
-0.0538105071,
-0.8816233277,
0.4781686962,
0.1698293388,
0.5242136717,
0.8430005312,
0.5289230347,
-0.0101986136,
0.5279239416,
0.5807691813,
-0.5489265323,
0.3764790893,
-0.4012050927,
-0.2232809961,
-0.4671678841,
-0.0683266446,
-0.7737757564,
-0.2553946972,
-0.0844296142,
-0.4223936796,
0.5781443715,
0.2705376446,
-0.0907477885,
0.3268444538,
-0.2479385138,
0.4982409179,
0.5617028475,
0.1259662509,
0.6519111991,
0.1990941465,
0.6407400966,
0.5013609529,
-0.4098944068,
-0.4662844241,
1.1936664581,
0.090437606,
0.5803258419,
0.4368568361,
0.6952502131,
0.4311027527,
0.2862519324,
-0.5093694925,
0.4782353342,
-0.2064683288,
-0.7127136588,
-0.6559540629,
-0.705960393,
-0.8062951565,
-0.0048512295,
-0.1096379608,
-0.4342939258,
0.1846030951,
0.3230191767,
-0.4315749407,
0.5089290142,
-0.4858985245,
0.4621432424,
0.0362474434,
-0.2041171938,
-0.4374928772,
-0.3845672905,
0.4938642383,
-0.1600459963,
0.1669214219,
-0.1176024824,
-0.1847819537,
0.5359912515,
-0.9576258659,
0.5576065779,
-0.1119816154,
-0.0688031763,
0.6058036685,
-0.0378960222,
0.1820040792,
0.4919190109,
-0.0520687401,
0.5603048205,
-0.4560340345,
-0.6218056679,
-0.341047287,
0.9189455509,
-0.6960206032,
-0.4672443271,
-0.2324909717,
-0.346334964,
-0.3498569131,
0.2346244454,
0.5360077024,
0.6008834839,
-0.4339899123,
-0.0790280774,
0.58076334,
-0.301615715,
0.3454174995,
0.8084037304,
-0.4016487002,
-0.6633397937,
1.302285552,
0.4119936228,
0.2332856208,
0.3933741152,
-0.2455693036,
0.1819490343,
-0.6044352055,
-0.8618800044,
0.2146497667,
-0.311994791,
-0.4396655262,
-0.620739162,
-0.2215932012,
-0.6165158749,
-0.1221656948,
-0.3578168154,
-0.6454376578,
-0.2398117781,
0.0265290216,
0.605702877,
0.8062883615,
0.0657023266,
0.241146192,
-0.8972225785,
0.6599422097,
0.2577794492,
0.5814977288,
0.1784727722,
-0.3816421926,
-0.6614557505,
-0.0436957031,
-0.5552128553,
-0.5134823322,
0.3049870729,
0.4494214952,
0.2287383676,
0.8005687594,
0.3691756427,
0.5911444426,
-0.3157691956,
1.1904124022,
0.0712398961,
-0.7352859974,
0.7215448618,
-0.5231618285,
0.3237808347,
0.8275981545,
0.4427387714,
-0.3001302779,
-0.6488319039,
-0.5741467476,
-1.0676854849,
0.8301205635,
0.4084636271,
-0.0280711595,
-0.0500263423,
0.3822384775,
0.5709161162,
0.316729039,
0.1328889281,
-0.3737793863,
-0.4271423817,
-0.0444912463,
-0.2928313613,
0.0664714426,
-0.0563638806,
0.1604934633,
0.9182474017,
-0.1556077451,
-0.225689739,
0.3081163466,
-0.2666714191,
-0.1584361792,
0.1540443301,
0.5819725394,
0.7869644165,
-0.2702922225,
0.040400669,
0.0096764006,
-0.8087749481,
-0.2258397192,
0.357353121,
-0.5031651855,
0.2704624236,
0.2147668153,
0.6809413433,
-0.181951642,
-0.7483445406,
0.4264263511,
0.1004756987,
-0.2632189989,
-0.1026676372,
0.1144295037,
-0.1940826327,
0.1469237208,
0.6028509736,
-0.1752952933,
0.2053630054,
-0.4816586077,
-0.017777076,
0.1509761065,
-0.1338410527,
-0.3465287983,
0.7626494765,
0.441683948,
0.0018822796,
0.2958347797,
-0.2678546906,
0.082330972,
0.4829767644,
-0.3216155469,
0.8607653379,
0.0654555038,
0.1978477091,
0.4764872491,
-0.0258511771,
0.0426305458,
0.2307421714,
-0.1871540844,
-0.1753327101,
-0.4488938749,
-0.6452669501,
-0.7415733337,
0.2974446416,
-0.9012564421,
0.1226802617,
-0.2441805899,
-0.1398598403,
0.1875931025,
-0.1200257763,
-0.2531540692,
0.1462321132,
-0.2755109668,
1.0857764482,
-0.4882218242,
0.4793483615,
0.7983128428,
-0.8177773356,
-0.3587291837,
0.3418960273,
0.0868320167,
-0.3394558132,
-0.0558187738,
-0.0507499315,
0.1204087138,
-0.3080864549,
-0.394477427,
-0.8122677207,
1.0648114681,
0.1406775266,
-0.3287698328,
-0.1285206079,
0.2413075864,
0.2874110341,
-0.2126638889,
-0.0437928811,
0.2515128553,
0.1243878379,
-0.0022774516,
-0.8693550825,
-0.2499813437,
-0.1144794971,
-0.2602674067,
0.4932544529,
-0.9205260277,
0.9031953216,
-0.1386347413,
-0.0521935895,
0.1705328822,
1.3658976555,
0.1404455006,
0.6145505309,
0.3328666687,
0.522328198,
0.4940635264,
0.0712675527,
0.8505555987,
-0.3512607813,
0.2346388698,
1.3803491592,
-0.2538666427,
1.0617860556,
0.2045784444,
0.0147182066,
0.2203020155,
0.439565599,
0.2752914131,
0.4749910533,
-0.2003062963,
-0.2642737031,
-0.033455871,
-0.1921015829,
-0.4816830158,
0.2616286278,
0.2552497685,
-0.4820243418,
-0.5927985907,
-0.003885862,
0.1625476778,
-0.0408021174,
-0.8405746222,
1.0748177767,
0.0457563698,
-0.9323037267,
0.0535456985,
0.1931577921,
0.4569018781,
-0.6114961505,
0.1686819047,
-0.6073350906,
-0.0783614516,
-0.3407725394,
-0.8493557572,
0.2523120046,
0.4453622401,
-0.4277969301,
0.0735870972,
0.57321316,
-0.3287611008,
-0.2798193693,
-0.3985371292,
0.4939463437,
0.2577385306,
-0.4586813152,
0.1039744169,
-0.3677392006,
-0.2443970293,
-0.4556473196,
0.641418457,
0.7580800653,
-0.1256710887,
0.1598618478,
0.3954499364,
0.1701145172,
-0.3889245987,
-0.0553116761,
1.0078449249,
-0.5520311594,
-0.7329861522,
-0.4430222213,
0.4435230196,
-0.417929858,
-0.6409310699,
0.8772267103,
1.1012632847,
0.7667935491,
-0.0979209617,
0.9353414178,
-0.1970784068,
0.7790110707,
-0.4328124225,
0.9590703845,
-0.6357007027,
-0.0642943084,
-0.125140816,
-0.8171180487,
0.055707965,
0.0515122041,
-0.1400927156,
-0.1240358576,
0.2786693573,
0.6541238427,
-0.2203267664,
0.123058334,
0.0097166747,
0.0375790037,
0.1575866193,
0.2284179926,
0.3630959094,
-0.0284551177,
0.6978138089,
-0.2100186944,
-0.4687144756,
-0.5560635924,
-0.7381790876,
-0.876211822,
-0.831648767,
-0.410512954,
-0.5489775538,
-0.1153032035,
0.5781511664,
0.7564616799,
-0.8859836459,
-0.0290519651,
0.1079862639,
0.0200308803,
-0.277279526,
-0.2178500444,
0.5438614488,
-0.1728428453,
-0.5892665386,
0.1424588114,
0.4349488914,
-0.2105213404,
-0.5948790312,
0.018920185,
0.2554618418,
0.3933077157,
0.6101557612,
0.6392610073,
-0.3099725544,
-0.0750470459,
-0.1012848169,
-0.1475049704,
-0.0552952662,
0.8843716979,
-0.4563386738,
0.2323177308,
0.4947632849,
0.3918146789,
0.6914992929,
0.3381229639,
0.4683411121,
-0.856477201,
-0.2090750337,
-0.1658590138,
0.2758570611,
0.0751946792,
-0.22203587,
0.3530835509,
0.0056360397,
-0.3756021261,
-0.5288890004,
0.1444018632,
-0.9896633029,
-0.3764667511,
1.2078530788,
-0.2256930321,
-0.2656287551,
-0.1217046902,
-0.2086292952,
0.2305116504,
-0.6491709352,
0.9699879885,
0.4035185575,
-0.1907034814,
0.4363552332,
-0.1472290456,
0.3591523468,
-0.0607224368,
-1.324192524,
0.2466907501,
0.8495865464,
0.2136674672,
0.3322663605,
0.4350887239,
-0.0099128708,
0.2161627114,
0.0160526652,
0.0920502543,
-0.4504816532,
-0.2390668541,
-0.0550676472,
0.8352583051,
-0.1274020821,
-0.3429674208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09196v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09196v3 | Emergent Analogical Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2022-12-19T00:04:56 | 2023-08-03T03:44:47 | Taylor Webb, Keith J. Holyoak, Hongjing Lu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The recent advent of large language models has reinvigorated debate over
whether human cognitive capacities might emerge in such generic models given
sufficient training data. Of particular interest is the ability of these models
to reason about novel problems zero-shot, without any direct training. In human
cognition, this capacity is closely tied to an ability to reason by analogy.
Here, we performed a direct comparison between human reasoners and a large
language model (the text-davinci-003 variant of GPT-3) on a range of analogical
tasks, including a non-visual matrix reasoning task based on the rule structure
of Raven's Standard Progressive Matrices. We found that GPT-3 displayed a
surprisingly strong capacity for abstract pattern induction, matching or even
surpassing human capabilities in most settings; preliminary tests of GPT-4
indicated even better performance. Our results indicate that large language
models such as GPT-3 have acquired an emergent ability to find zero-shot
solutions to a broad range of analogy problems. | [
-0.422603339,
-0.7810405493,
1.2857028246,
-0.2208241522,
-0.1890013516,
-0.1281035095,
-0.0551589131,
-0.5241238475,
-0.1838988662,
0.1235647276,
-0.3301827312,
-0.1253186911,
-0.5304023623,
0.164996013,
-0.4262343645,
0.8150478005,
-0.3119941652,
-0.1094508395,
0.0543117262,
-0.0272309147,
-0.4409818351,
-0.4791690707,
-0.6864191294,
-0.5227279067,
0.5108600855,
0.1733286977,
0.7174012661,
0.9348933697,
0.353577733,
0.3369040489,
0.1337003708,
-0.1774452776,
-0.1390620023,
0.1625400484,
-0.4961752295,
-0.4604993165,
-0.4516051412,
0.0616708547,
0.6664085388,
0.6441881061,
-0.1281316429,
0.0474221595,
-0.1101625636,
0.6059890985,
-0.4475581646,
0.2421409488,
-0.8137712479,
-0.0579178222,
-0.0574663281,
-0.1289522499,
-0.2832630575,
-0.0821978375,
0.139390707,
-0.8087679148,
0.5587687492,
-0.0389430523,
0.6955209374,
-0.1179847345,
-0.2024685144,
-0.2260089815,
-0.9669877291,
0.7251840234,
-0.5524402857,
0.1878810376,
0.1597091109,
0.4178351164,
-0.1671171039,
-0.6709628701,
-1.0618132353,
-0.3350939453,
0.251553297,
0.1009585038,
-0.3988385201,
0.0208178628,
0.5781440139,
0.2384771258,
-0.6950982809,
0.0917298943,
-0.4036699235,
0.2559388876,
0.167781651,
0.1451980323,
0.478310436,
-0.014230378,
-0.2126002163,
-0.0756255984,
-0.6269276738,
-0.2800643444,
0.2714345753,
0.05326657,
0.0934771672,
0.5419518948,
-0.2194594145,
0.9178388715,
-0.0288514476,
0.0975935832,
-0.088077791,
-0.0991378725,
-0.1619622856,
-0.0083854524,
0.588173449,
0.2527609468,
0.6298354268,
-0.1666826159,
-0.2357503474,
0.3839526176,
0.1689680964,
-0.637329936,
-0.1966598481,
-0.0275995638,
-0.3037159741,
0.0982994139,
0.2057427168,
-0.3131381273,
-0.2891183197,
-0.4193472564,
0.6342201829,
-0.5703206062,
-0.4630153775,
0.3553732336,
-0.3404478431,
0.4235145748,
0.5442907214,
-1.0751174688,
0.2310742736,
0.7361238599,
0.9649910331,
-0.1123217046,
-0.4264868796,
-0.2391226143,
0.1776717752,
-0.5766987205,
0.9569581747,
-0.5644578934,
-0.0474820472,
-0.2483084947,
-0.2235646397,
-0.1464879662,
-0.5949684978,
0.4206841886,
-0.3971933722,
0.1546938866,
-0.3362374306,
-0.3336789012,
-0.3282470703,
0.4625669122,
-0.5587950945,
0.4675615132,
0.2307459563,
-0.5545389056,
0.4377337098,
-0.8772373199,
-0.173628062,
0.3452832699,
-0.5989518762,
-0.1132308617,
0.1057486683,
0.2008036077,
0.3690106869,
-0.6615161896,
0.0216009095,
-0.5740666389,
-0.6364334226,
0.2785551548,
-0.4680004716,
0.7457110882,
0.2060212791,
-0.6155331135,
-0.1118791774,
-0.5073270798,
0.1521582603,
0.4489413202,
0.1170661375,
-0.2974990904,
-0.0246941093,
-0.4904807508,
0.4480744004,
-0.0876963958,
-0.6637473702,
0.1213270649,
-0.2851169407,
0.7294610143,
0.5965016484,
0.0596273094,
0.2544400394,
-0.5724961162,
0.5373343825,
0.1234382242,
-0.2314162552,
-0.3512595296,
-0.755643189,
-0.8399875164,
-0.3344421685,
-0.0666065812,
0.4073579311,
-0.9478102326,
0.0995237231,
-0.4740990102,
-0.4099886119,
-0.224525094,
-0.0820694268,
0.2346463948,
0.3685641885,
0.3297308683,
0.0299610607,
-0.3979198039,
-1.0234128237,
-0.2819621265,
-0.3279473186,
-0.4333687723,
0.0706695393,
0.7546819448,
-0.0524384975,
0.8184703588,
-0.3250810504,
-0.030771615,
-0.2729619443,
0.3325195611,
0.4657066464,
0.3488150239,
0.4208085835,
-0.5254840255,
-0.4056420624,
0.2030937523,
-1.0443484783,
0.079568848,
-0.2206697166,
0.1338361353,
-0.02853911,
0.5427468419,
-0.7025666237,
0.246098578,
0.1432749182,
-0.2134827077,
0.5055491328,
-0.3337673247,
0.1333063096,
-0.941654861,
0.19328098,
0.0650690123,
0.0191639252,
-0.6696506143,
0.0741578192,
-0.1035983413,
-0.1445006728,
-0.2962280512,
0.5365719795,
-0.5222448707,
-0.0660142154,
-0.2821351886,
0.2395067215,
-0.1409165859,
0.3821395636,
0.3574809134,
0.6928650141,
0.5360234976,
-0.4081370533,
0.236131981,
-0.0310698003,
-0.3762879372,
0.4413685501,
-0.8648476601,
0.1782809943,
-0.2009727657,
0.3337263167,
-0.6666142941,
-0.2836813927,
0.0633758083,
-0.3535883725,
0.0297330618,
-0.0139210215,
-0.5773360133,
-0.5912330747,
-0.1144671068,
0.6202874184,
0.7008516788,
-0.4737909436,
0.401443541,
-0.1749585867,
-0.1811076701,
-0.2478540093,
-0.4758094847,
0.118851006,
-0.2818960845,
-0.385987401,
0.099419564,
0.0587452725,
-0.4704718292,
-0.0586038828,
-0.0989334807,
-0.1111110076,
-0.0173811521,
0.0898431838,
0.2987326086,
-0.3578171134,
-0.1899335086,
-0.2431905419,
-0.1797962934,
0.1102156267,
-0.4821404815,
0.237445429,
-0.5456240177,
-0.5969459414,
-0.253815949,
0.4090565443,
0.8501009345,
0.0448333733,
0.6919530034,
0.2171875387,
-0.3303976953,
-0.0956785306,
-0.5345002413,
-0.1584712118,
-0.3793871403,
0.3350592256,
-0.5239626169,
-0.7923158407,
0.4607897997,
0.2929033041,
-0.1792452037,
0.3960940242,
0.7616589665,
0.0033774581,
1.0625855923,
0.0810315609,
0.5333582759,
0.3479568064,
-0.2176703513,
0.2224675417,
-0.7668800354,
0.0307073593,
-0.1527072936,
-0.0835157856,
-0.4972046018,
-0.4487364292,
0.3557020426,
0.1203788221,
-0.627297461,
0.3308011889,
-0.4056185782,
0.6818413734,
0.3782139122,
0.0010705316,
0.3890784681,
-0.1102675647,
-0.2123092264,
0.1597100794,
-0.7267673016,
-0.598756969,
0.953951478,
0.3560847342,
0.3473073542,
0.3100845814,
0.4703198671,
-0.1362662911,
0.5491907001,
-0.5287706852,
0.5902392864,
-0.0004699962,
-0.7725728154,
-0.1672699302,
-0.4667131901,
-1.0303598642,
0.4552122951,
-0.3039885759,
-0.8951009512,
0.1629928946,
0.17824395,
-0.3583824337,
0.5336511731,
-0.9148377776,
0.8060804009,
0.0934475884,
-0.2303866297,
0.042345304,
-0.4608786404,
0.7429752946,
-0.3639447689,
0.088764064,
-0.1649331003,
0.0840243176,
0.5381137133,
-0.308203131,
0.4232225418,
-0.0102057988,
-0.0806411952,
0.4966512918,
0.3427675366,
0.3247013092,
-0.1247167215,
-0.0118535403,
0.2281850427,
0.0128745055,
-0.5692517757,
-0.9189359546,
0.6295749545,
-0.6064674258,
-0.8284774423,
-0.7354374528,
-0.5901266336,
-0.2176520228,
0.3076535165,
0.2354365438,
0.2491795719,
-0.1181773618,
0.2896130085,
0.4618626535,
0.0639683381,
0.6691316962,
0.7486772537,
0.0549151488,
-0.1582583785,
0.8315413594,
0.0896349549,
0.5917710662,
0.3685364425,
0.1428127289,
-0.1245388314,
-0.6180486083,
-0.5971165895,
0.1583496481,
-0.4905026555,
-0.0801715553,
-0.4606033564,
-0.290099144,
0.1045312062,
-0.2385132164,
-0.199580878,
-0.3357479274,
0.0743852854,
0.2120853215,
0.016261166,
0.8408850431,
-0.1093432084,
0.0194560122,
-0.6468186378,
0.4787589014,
0.7183941007,
0.318829596,
0.3372026384,
-0.5159432888,
-0.1563698947,
0.1817724258,
-0.3891774416,
-0.7136681676,
0.0365612544,
-0.0917889997,
0.5099182725,
0.571749866,
-0.2269829363,
0.5246990919,
-0.7296826839,
0.7039894462,
0.4871767163,
-0.7596719265,
0.207275033,
-0.9558111429,
0.5371729732,
0.2128450722,
0.3412843645,
-0.297706008,
-0.325381577,
-0.7079017162,
-0.4502155483,
0.5223927498,
0.6079164147,
-0.0981177315,
-0.4064156711,
0.4495765269,
0.0693417415,
-0.0385276228,
-0.8950391412,
0.2633756101,
-0.3439585268,
0.1423425227,
-0.1614188999,
0.0723525062,
0.0663791224,
-0.3200671673,
0.2443297505,
-0.1359538436,
0.3388688862,
0.1351865232,
0.1256647557,
-0.1421951354,
0.433466047,
0.6447328925,
0.8941771984,
-0.2120097727,
0.4017705023,
0.0994860455,
-0.3233350217,
0.4883156121,
0.1130500734,
-0.0299177654,
-0.3455614746,
0.7245076299,
0.5814713836,
-0.0269287694,
-0.637778461,
0.5636690855,
-0.0304145794,
-0.6449980736,
-0.279393822,
0.2499700338,
0.0784605443,
0.2266450375,
0.3766744137,
0.0014403643,
-0.0261225887,
-0.870282948,
0.0141493883,
0.482324779,
-0.2454350889,
-0.3113319576,
0.7249853611,
-0.0961798728,
-0.219684884,
0.6861838698,
-0.326587975,
-0.2650691569,
0.4970538616,
0.895845294,
0.9931772351,
-0.0562325604,
0.0293633137,
0.352306217,
0.2996594012,
-0.37489447,
-0.0436457396,
-0.0843281075,
-0.9658877254,
-0.6315331459,
-0.43564412,
-0.251196295,
0.4342493713,
-0.5850057006,
0.0828641132,
-0.4312230945,
0.1415270269,
0.2997217178,
-0.3428426385,
-0.5398331285,
0.1415382922,
0.1330115497,
0.607766211,
-0.9830010533,
0.8953436017,
0.668310523,
-0.5868496299,
-0.6618668437,
0.1770277172,
-0.2013107091,
-0.8276567459,
0.7737157345,
0.2568692863,
-0.1939243078,
0.1072729453,
-0.2737483978,
-0.6707835197,
1.1299539804,
0.6919443011,
-0.4938411713,
-0.0841890052,
-0.194926843,
0.674241364,
-0.5053975582,
0.2698191404,
0.7965286374,
0.3444174826,
0.4159117937,
-0.8404257894,
0.1360435039,
-0.2960356176,
0.0906730667,
0.3462617397,
-0.1276457906,
0.9638870358,
-0.4389038682,
-0.3405852616,
0.1875195354,
0.4722628295,
0.5172156096,
0.0593869686,
0.6077286005,
0.7415238619,
0.2137891352,
0.035289079,
1.1870334148,
0.0689264983,
0.0413738601,
1.073274374,
-0.4408420622,
0.7800494432,
0.4243885875,
-0.1803137958,
0.8025081158,
0.3226584196,
0.1179867834,
0.1845034957,
0.1930383742,
-0.4621144235,
-0.4548915327,
0.2729090452,
-0.3686470091,
0.5547210574,
0.1778740436,
-0.2559010088,
-0.4675413966,
-0.3167300522,
-0.0485355817,
0.2262691557,
-0.3253395855,
0.7264079452,
0.0739587098,
-0.8407783508,
0.7395492196,
-0.0380425192,
0.0334839895,
-0.460983336,
-0.4325591624,
0.1839701384,
0.2733807564,
0.1970702708,
-0.8001434803,
0.235059768,
-0.0976248011,
-0.3270157576,
-0.1125665531,
0.2550867796,
-0.1522087306,
-0.4124296904,
0.0214047227,
0.7739480138,
0.2216323465,
-0.1694907993,
-0.5561139584,
-0.2877848446,
-0.139929384,
0.109729223,
0.3302080631,
0.5777873993,
-0.3102213442,
0.6303022504,
0.6811009645,
0.185707435,
-0.2164779454,
-0.1895571351,
0.809042275,
-0.7353916168,
-0.4456603527,
-1.1526697874,
0.16470626,
-0.063127391,
-0.1361636519,
0.63348943,
0.3900688589,
0.4424671531,
-0.1675695032,
0.7912064791,
-0.0030388676,
0.3399118185,
-0.3705898225,
0.4483219683,
-0.2878708541,
0.1138493121,
-0.4074211419,
-1.2292809486,
-0.3994753063,
0.7058190703,
-0.6072063446,
0.350682348,
1.1142854691,
0.5109626651,
-0.4016412497,
0.1058717594,
0.4612423778,
0.3987476528,
0.3564725518,
0.8486406803,
0.9032946825,
-0.0903303474,
0.4481680989,
0.4342032969,
-0.4658716917,
0.0337406173,
-1.1539106369,
-0.923038125,
-0.6777722836,
-0.0347877443,
-0.3125419319,
0.0003739213,
0.6800478101,
0.5179521441,
-0.5843936205,
-0.0385035798,
-0.7563070655,
0.0076427311,
-0.3005716801,
-0.159220174,
0.2430513799,
-0.1330335289,
-0.4518048763,
0.3385248184,
0.3225589395,
0.3537347913,
-0.2070326656,
0.0013529634,
-0.2255741954,
0.1944839358,
0.5302635431,
0.5555871725,
-0.9780757427,
-0.4412724078,
-0.2904698551,
0.2165761441,
-0.1270501763,
0.9939488173,
-0.7832655907,
0.6135095358,
0.2378140688,
0.2970349491,
0.6698110104,
-0.0764107481,
0.8533011675,
-0.2522373497,
0.3175664246,
0.2059751749,
0.4820388556,
0.3424608111,
0.0955002382,
0.3784128726,
0.3662345409,
-0.4954156876,
-0.6738708615,
0.5589064956,
-0.7919121385,
-0.3313002586,
1.1641658545,
-0.1576357782,
-0.0176160522,
-0.271710515,
-0.1237910688,
0.0425224751,
-0.1030259356,
0.7709309459,
0.7280210853,
-0.3850304782,
-0.2019514441,
-0.8169223666,
0.3136909604,
0.175466463,
-0.6215620041,
0.0016981325,
0.2889174223,
0.1869394332,
0.1978425831,
0.6241443753,
-0.102996096,
0.5506466627,
0.2649303377,
-0.1526363939,
-0.1204960868,
-0.1262984276,
-0.2253066003,
0.2299176306,
0.2445839792,
-0.0277640857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09180v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09180v3 | Don't Forget Your ABC's: Evaluating the State-of-the-Art in Chat-Oriented Dialogue Systems | 2022-12-18T22:07:55 | 2023-07-28T20:55:09 | Sarah E. Finch, James D. Finch, Jinho D. Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite tremendous advancements in dialogue systems, stable evaluation still
requires human judgments producing notoriously high-variance metrics due to
their inherent subjectivity. Moreover, methods and labels in dialogue
evaluation are not fully standardized, especially for open-domain chats, with a
lack of work to compare and assess the validity of those approaches. The use of
inconsistent evaluation can misinform the performance of a dialogue system,
which becomes a major hurdle to enhance it. Thus, a dimensional evaluation of
chat-oriented open-domain dialogue systems that reliably measures several
aspects of dialogue capabilities is desired. This paper presents a novel human
evaluation method to estimate the rates of many dialogue system behaviors. Our
method is used to evaluate four state-of-the-art open-domain dialogue systems
and compared with existing approaches. The analysis demonstrates that our
behavior method is more suitable than alternative Likert-style or comparative
approaches for dimensional evaluation of these systems. | [
-0.4438453019,
-0.6028088927,
0.2623155117,
0.5472806692,
-0.0624514371,
0.3939053416,
0.0323216096,
-0.2801253498,
0.3294412196,
0.2062663287,
-0.7066065669,
-0.3951430321,
-0.2391630411,
-0.0136732096,
0.1163483188,
0.6708548665,
0.2599495053,
0.1122855991,
-0.3675774336,
-0.3533043265,
-0.7145038247,
-0.5972701311,
-0.5173957944,
-0.0987895578,
0.179238528,
0.2385910302,
0.6663342714,
-0.1439581662,
0.5780148506,
0.3286380768,
-0.2045330107,
0.3507501185,
-0.7231653333,
0.1045805365,
0.0590031147,
0.0282581169,
-0.8913726211,
-0.1225246489,
0.4168489575,
0.6753532887,
-0.2777417302,
0.1150084808,
-0.0703459159,
0.6233310103,
-0.6666691303,
0.5545349717,
-0.246799171,
0.3460803032,
0.2383611649,
-0.3377487361,
-0.2428857684,
-0.5828645229,
0.5401183367,
-0.6370958686,
-0.3574388921,
-0.006017575,
0.2904943526,
0.0124192834,
-0.231599912,
-0.2144961655,
-0.8164966702,
0.9891654253,
-0.6159195304,
0.4575158358,
0.4914254844,
0.4655687213,
-0.3074759543,
-0.3136919737,
-0.3897094727,
-0.4282197952,
0.16164653,
0.0542084686,
-0.4799208045,
0.075663805,
0.0526332557,
0.3340785801,
-0.3399226367,
0.0624447502,
-0.0985613912,
-0.4256929159,
0.7345927954,
0.3789578974,
0.3363366425,
0.1893874407,
-0.322188139,
0.033375565,
-0.3091875613,
0.204569608,
0.3949267566,
0.2004473209,
0.0639488399,
0.3522469997,
-0.4596735239,
0.4055206478,
0.2528960109,
-0.3754289746,
0.2934219539,
-0.5413538814,
-0.4015233815,
-0.36000368,
1.0084857941,
0.6490649581,
0.2095525116,
-0.1453770697,
0.0187645219,
-0.1119159609,
0.5066699982,
-0.4360092282,
0.0008403953,
0.0704832375,
-0.638348639,
-0.2564122975,
-0.3880890906,
-0.7693265676,
-0.2901004553,
0.0279359724,
0.6175376773,
-0.7320336103,
-0.2740114629,
-0.1024370864,
-0.1228833273,
-0.0145183373,
0.4082074463,
-0.8546131253,
0.5317234993,
0.742862761,
0.6578617096,
-0.1294729263,
-0.0795870796,
-0.2974052131,
-0.3852548301,
-0.6046626568,
0.7775620818,
-0.8400439024,
-0.6971641779,
-0.0045526111,
-0.4908432961,
-0.0196888614,
-0.5044645071,
0.7692520022,
-0.5533840656,
0.0873232186,
-0.1516215056,
-0.4689952731,
-0.0854763985,
0.0811198801,
-0.3557339609,
0.6456791162,
0.3130294979,
-0.4154542387,
0.4152306318,
-0.8444055319,
-0.2893999517,
0.1792283058,
0.0219338089,
-0.3707426488,
0.0146123795,
0.1444755197,
0.101673618,
0.1251543462,
0.0336905681,
-0.3006160855,
-0.6393747926,
0.5049558878,
-0.6327577233,
0.9501735568,
0.2362142503,
0.0955521315,
0.0644348562,
-0.6378474832,
0.2701885104,
-0.3798386157,
-0.4328643978,
-0.4162683487,
0.0638606399,
-0.5297397971,
-0.0841420144,
0.3594584465,
-0.822604835,
0.2210634202,
-0.2577355206,
0.1575099379,
0.5521528125,
0.2434514761,
0.3656821549,
-0.3476505876,
0.5422104597,
-0.0290698241,
0.3812659085,
-0.2259398848,
-0.5344166756,
-0.6974713206,
-0.4692876041,
-0.0387624428,
0.4617278278,
-0.5807640553,
0.811206162,
-0.284185797,
-0.7500085831,
-0.3159480691,
-0.1760073751,
0.6934913397,
-0.0472260043,
0.121531792,
-1.1048281193,
-0.3327256441,
-0.6326102018,
-0.4200831056,
-0.5592101812,
-0.2771004438,
0.3908564746,
0.0496155582,
0.005219148,
1.0044806004,
-0.34916085,
-0.283796072,
-0.028467644,
0.175711289,
-0.1222291589,
0.4067295194,
0.590020597,
-0.125324443,
-0.3741918504,
-0.0488274395,
-0.5549829006,
0.0367823429,
0.1509595364,
-0.1598008871,
0.4865325093,
0.1905944645,
-0.6994550228,
0.7663553357,
0.3299965262,
-0.3468484581,
0.5741365552,
-0.2032361776,
0.3962363601,
-0.2631868124,
-0.2576502264,
0.1257324815,
-0.0343319923,
-0.7007604837,
-0.2480321825,
-0.0532003492,
-0.1636286676,
-0.2838270664,
0.2739581168,
-0.2621018589,
-0.3025808632,
0.1954629421,
0.2070084661,
-0.0432849452,
1.0473177433,
-0.1561371684,
0.6066004634,
0.5746524334,
-0.6800217628,
0.5029870272,
0.539786458,
-0.7125694156,
1.0966242552,
-0.2429242879,
0.4265933931,
0.0699027404,
0.4431552887,
-1.0865761042,
0.1053737774,
0.3893172443,
-0.668505609,
0.2026269734,
0.02169374,
-0.127624616,
-0.3983124197,
-0.3306527734,
0.1397663951,
0.3888216317,
-0.1516228765,
0.4326363206,
0.4579235613,
-0.2846862972,
-0.6730414033,
-0.090667136,
0.2590366006,
-0.1574641615,
-0.5378134847,
-0.2277561277,
-0.1937694252,
-0.1131156161,
-0.3320719004,
-0.5894843936,
-0.3056253195,
0.0793131441,
0.1184638143,
0.1145102829,
-0.266680181,
-0.0799169242,
0.0131254848,
-0.0456991717,
0.0966103598,
-0.3725527823,
0.4009003937,
-0.2569177449,
-0.6393882632,
-1.0729184151,
0.1818123013,
0.7484611273,
-0.1006059423,
0.3818114698,
0.3195821941,
-0.0896090269,
0.1369972974,
-0.4479261935,
-0.0575649627,
-0.4568956792,
0.7038862109,
-0.3304464221,
-0.4987884164,
0.1433413178,
0.1978010386,
0.376037091,
-0.0383224562,
0.3926297724,
-0.1150109321,
1.0048612356,
0.6356908083,
0.0952973887,
0.4365977347,
0.1086849496,
0.7736606598,
-0.6901378632,
-0.4282607436,
-0.5510776639,
-0.2607270181,
-0.4768319428,
-0.4936224818,
0.4425433278,
-0.1703233719,
-0.5037632585,
0.4266521335,
0.0455629043,
0.1768155098,
0.4234110415,
-0.0386142321,
0.6622529626,
0.1303006262,
-0.0765982047,
-0.0274407901,
-0.4462916553,
-0.7150313258,
1.1363632679,
0.5950067043,
0.7099262476,
0.3904681802,
0.4813708067,
0.5096911788,
0.3245996535,
-1.1851836443,
0.6754788756,
0.0221132096,
-0.3529892266,
-0.8889504671,
-0.5261556506,
-0.893963933,
0.3206893206,
0.0090576261,
-1.2533134222,
0.2123379111,
-0.0568700023,
-0.677536726,
0.2024661899,
-0.6059746742,
0.5759651065,
-0.0507787876,
0.3450501561,
-0.4985181689,
-0.2991894484,
0.2160451263,
-0.3013908267,
0.0137402685,
-0.2351507992,
0.1224129349,
0.7496310472,
-0.4943260849,
0.8978316784,
-0.2178573608,
-0.2129980475,
0.4484172761,
0.4216355383,
-0.1622162908,
-0.2916622758,
-0.005350742,
0.5048538446,
0.2378043979,
-0.2850956023,
-0.8885329962,
0.5558227301,
-0.9061728716,
-0.4288727343,
-0.271010071,
-0.4256177247,
-0.6645566821,
-0.0918256491,
-0.3681951463,
0.6296728253,
-0.9466173053,
0.1117795184,
0.340183109,
-0.3890476823,
0.3717465103,
0.7041255832,
-0.153040573,
-0.216584295,
1.0093519688,
0.0221892614,
0.4129241109,
0.4303377569,
0.0222993344,
-0.0900228769,
-0.217656672,
-0.4553155899,
0.0205664337,
-0.4446740746,
-0.340387702,
-0.7198009491,
0.0159231964,
-0.4591741562,
0.3035402,
-0.2580016553,
-0.7753192782,
0.0608141646,
-0.013674181,
0.1016229242,
0.7140981555,
-0.0222045872,
0.5834326744,
-0.8399784565,
0.1806394905,
0.5740252733,
0.7825471163,
0.3657801151,
-0.3944146633,
-0.3324009776,
0.2380780876,
-1.0734587908,
-0.5308014154,
0.3355214894,
0.2749278247,
1.0097450018,
0.7360531092,
0.0313488729,
0.4916028678,
-0.3755277097,
0.8293169141,
0.3781679869,
-1.0879049301,
0.2626081705,
-0.1293633729,
-0.0675665215,
0.2987481654,
0.313256681,
-0.6204294562,
-0.3068514168,
-0.6671156883,
-0.3396373689,
1.0282953978,
0.4852914214,
0.25251019,
-0.0609101579,
-0.1453710198,
-0.1114448383,
0.289087981,
-0.0595524497,
-0.2746075988,
-0.2470484972,
-0.0895678475,
0.1812582463,
-0.0885544717,
-0.0838205069,
0.1174490452,
0.5186372995,
0.0903106853,
0.4727056921,
-0.0049562478,
-0.0166629106,
-0.4711199105,
0.3231470585,
0.3474904895,
0.9554801583,
-0.4965618253,
-0.6305084825,
0.1816766262,
-0.6071420312,
0.0851267129,
-0.464001447,
0.1803420484,
-0.1155553237,
0.2290015072,
0.9331077337,
0.2307816595,
-0.752974689,
0.7578820586,
-0.3274917305,
0.0809205621,
-0.2468642145,
0.204478085,
-0.1966021955,
0.2086956799,
0.2265089154,
0.5097019672,
0.0544965416,
-0.9966503978,
-0.0375695564,
0.5009014606,
-0.9383162856,
-0.3305740654,
-0.1796238869,
0.6664429903,
-0.8590168953,
0.4562688768,
-0.1769500524,
-0.4366386235,
0.5142564178,
0.2110929936,
1.1375843287,
-0.5524682403,
0.4125813842,
0.2606510818,
0.243664518,
0.1808890402,
0.1627356112,
-0.2512087524,
-0.7840211987,
-0.4108994305,
-0.6761729121,
-0.5376244783,
0.0972471312,
-0.6100517511,
0.128360033,
-0.5157479048,
-0.5197825432,
-0.1502655447,
0.126525566,
-0.7542310357,
-0.1269261539,
0.2664782107,
1.0663280487,
-0.64672333,
0.3026195765,
0.3764244318,
-0.1392780393,
-0.3690808117,
0.1462153196,
0.1845370233,
-0.7937268019,
0.6193134189,
-0.2230721414,
-0.4560957253,
-0.4212403893,
-0.2048684806,
-0.890347898,
0.7603465915,
-0.2950742841,
-0.4818937778,
0.1165329516,
-0.1354037523,
0.9189815521,
-0.7112764716,
0.7894715667,
1.1517877579,
0.4931123853,
0.0311592128,
-1.4328802824,
-0.3428586721,
-0.0505095832,
0.1525148898,
-0.0208538566,
-0.7363647819,
0.2816708088,
-0.4376306534,
-0.371909976,
0.6044002771,
0.6605035663,
0.1825824827,
0.5549010634,
0.6909865141,
0.2807462513,
0.7557046413,
0.0030553592,
0.7662909627,
0.047603365,
0.3552563488,
0.8093761802,
-0.4239004552,
0.7222152352,
0.1300351471,
-0.5914112329,
0.5391336083,
0.276509434,
0.3543458283,
0.429292053,
0.3862434924,
-0.2062263787,
-0.2020178735,
0.1018193588,
0.126048848,
0.6989458799,
0.776971817,
0.3240023255,
-0.1772812307,
-0.1946484149,
-0.0020497276,
-0.0380501561,
-0.157774806,
1.1751484871,
-0.0637841299,
-0.7053752542,
0.7127913833,
-0.1335933506,
0.37573874,
-0.4895978868,
-0.0774203613,
-0.4078263938,
-0.0542455427,
-0.107988745,
-0.6525659561,
-0.0045772037,
0.0874924362,
0.3441178501,
-0.0581924915,
0.1429633945,
-0.2534855902,
-0.2627738416,
0.1771794409,
0.5389714241,
0.6055414081,
0.1427826881,
-0.3151707947,
0.0219980255,
0.172391966,
0.0188233256,
0.2419861257,
0.6249816418,
-0.3139158487,
0.8368047476,
0.4157008827,
-0.0565524064,
-0.2472296059,
0.2831233144,
0.7324621081,
-0.5697280765,
-0.4200980961,
-0.4653941393,
0.2598246634,
-0.1580919772,
-0.4241654873,
0.6311262846,
0.3272270262,
0.6034862995,
0.0888283402,
0.9303256273,
0.0080865007,
0.8098322153,
0.0175333116,
0.624062717,
-0.0299364142,
0.4583414197,
-0.6637580991,
-1.199652195,
0.0832647607,
0.5927842259,
-0.3359303772,
0.0716993138,
0.741920352,
0.7153035402,
-0.0607540496,
0.493188858,
0.6432427168,
0.3888049722,
0.4906446338,
0.3622991741,
1.1728597879,
-0.2815343738,
0.801268816,
-0.1181537285,
-0.9222611785,
-0.5611406565,
-0.7064442039,
-0.8219090104,
-0.3400786519,
-0.4285650849,
-0.1375428289,
-0.0056357104,
0.8347409964,
0.6416230798,
-0.7294700742,
-0.4925548434,
0.7332817912,
0.188512519,
-0.6877067685,
-0.2019277513,
0.2240614146,
-0.5891612768,
-0.8278684616,
0.6148104072,
0.5835930109,
-0.143860817,
-0.5023543239,
-0.0784340277,
0.1917469651,
0.5171849132,
0.77918154,
0.2897189856,
-0.7618308067,
-0.5030040741,
-0.1114736125,
-0.0218014158,
0.1693293303,
0.912846148,
-0.7794741988,
0.6540577412,
0.5445201397,
0.1608218551,
0.0772876143,
0.2807402313,
0.703917861,
-0.5726451874,
-0.0568854921,
0.3153112829,
0.1127928272,
0.3442537487,
-0.0742376298,
0.1466438621,
0.0016274576,
-0.6564483047,
-0.5795001984,
0.4281806648,
-1.0198130608,
-0.0588004775,
0.6378723979,
-0.5213703513,
-0.0302156396,
-0.5154390931,
-0.3708145022,
0.0404790863,
-0.813139677,
0.9398394823,
0.6307843924,
-0.3811672032,
0.3919720948,
-0.2252663076,
0.4756272137,
0.1292380989,
-0.4727413058,
-0.0272090975,
0.5635311007,
0.2243967503,
0.6293085814,
0.8684902191,
-0.210247457,
0.0471424982,
-0.037887726,
-0.1227438822,
0.3192423284,
-0.4224025607,
-0.1160919592,
-0.232900396,
-0.1156369969,
-0.3483204842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09171v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09171v2 | Rainproof: An Umbrella To Shield Text Generators From Out-Of-Distribution Data | 2022-12-18T21:22:28 | 2023-11-01T19:06:58 | Maxime Darrin, Pablo Piantanida, Pierre Colombo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Implementing effective control mechanisms to ensure the proper functioning
and security of deployed NLP models, from translation to chatbots, is
essential. A key ingredient to ensure safe system behaviour is
Out-Of-Distribution (OOD) detection, which aims to detect whether an input
sample is statistically far from the training distribution. Although OOD
detection is a widely covered topic in classification tasks, most methods rely
on hidden features output by the encoder. In this work, we focus on leveraging
soft-probabilities in a black-box framework, i.e. we can access the
soft-predictions but not the internal states of the model. Our contributions
include: (i) RAINPROOF a Relative informAItioN Projection OOD detection
framework; and (ii) a more operational evaluation setting for OOD detection.
Surprisingly, we find that OOD detection is not necessarily aligned with
task-specific measures. The OOD detector may filter out samples well processed
by the model and keep samples that are not, leading to weaker performance. Our
results show that RAINPROOF provides OOD detection methods more aligned with
task-specific performance metrics than traditional OOD detectors. | [
-0.2788040042,
-0.531778276,
0.5369304419,
0.0132870162,
-0.3946067989,
-0.1193751097,
-0.1544217616,
-0.6479310989,
-0.2433981448,
0.7630961537,
-0.30724141,
-0.4787865281,
-0.685939908,
-0.1818580031,
-0.627037406,
1.0891849995,
-0.0884019807,
-0.7003147602,
-0.2149561048,
-0.1826092303,
-0.153456971,
-0.5212073922,
-0.1402961612,
-0.5075373054,
-0.1235237792,
0.3219051957,
0.8547068238,
0.3615093231,
0.5628498793,
0.2627147138,
-0.2072948068,
0.0782843232,
-0.3551290929,
0.512976408,
-0.2562869787,
-0.8035313487,
-0.1974966675,
-0.3354919553,
0.3886788189,
0.2053616941,
-0.4374201,
0.1122928634,
0.3416208029,
0.3876699507,
-1.1794382334,
0.2750512958,
-0.7034742832,
0.3084902465,
-0.4168421924,
-0.5314616561,
-0.502250433,
0.2188744247,
-0.100864321,
-0.3147147,
0.4325492382,
0.1684309691,
0.5724940896,
0.3335867524,
-0.1115058139,
-0.3131766617,
-1.0769511461,
1.0033197403,
-0.7162284255,
0.0491991341,
0.7507626414,
0.4478686154,
-0.3891919553,
-0.1591849625,
-0.6703580022,
0.0517562702,
0.2230774909,
0.2266213447,
-0.1938401908,
0.2142815739,
-0.1420039237,
0.3288497329,
-0.1184641421,
-0.0121845622,
-0.0035738372,
0.1004014239,
0.7755875587,
-0.0298375171,
0.2149978429,
-0.347589463,
-0.4814893305,
-0.1637047678,
-0.5476382971,
-0.1171635985,
0.6210214496,
0.1885985583,
-0.306220293,
0.6791545153,
0.2329192013,
0.3821794391,
-0.0870047882,
-0.5096020103,
0.2690432072,
-0.4258435071,
-0.2431970537,
0.2174133956,
0.7746080756,
0.0251499508,
-0.2195800245,
-0.2716370225,
-0.8436562419,
-0.3096613884,
0.2995354235,
-0.7742252946,
0.0306631383,
0.329229027,
-0.6605420113,
-0.704559505,
0.2096764892,
-0.7469927073,
-0.6754875183,
0.2612871528,
0.5682500601,
-0.2616252899,
-0.6757676005,
0.2950046957,
-0.5660632253,
-0.3399624527,
-0.1068295985,
-0.7197722197,
0.3137694597,
0.6894424558,
1.0125672817,
-0.1887519509,
0.0925158411,
-0.2473967224,
0.4008966386,
-0.3106150031,
0.5789645314,
-0.1682134867,
-0.1291251034,
0.2814844251,
-0.1268443912,
-0.011489016,
-0.5268386006,
0.3626767695,
-0.3406119645,
0.1066186801,
0.4679993987,
-0.3091215193,
-0.1785802394,
-0.0877963006,
-0.4922429919,
0.996819973,
0.4263183475,
-1.1280914545,
0.4757343531,
-0.464735955,
-0.2205898166,
0.104110308,
-0.3184472919,
-0.7923804522,
0.3233668506,
-0.0487308204,
0.4077167511,
-0.181254521,
0.2254980803,
-0.6931205392,
-0.3895732462,
0.155217737,
-0.516356647,
0.6187736988,
0.0019567041,
-0.9062211514,
-0.2301225513,
-0.8813669086,
-0.0682983696,
0.0506336614,
-0.2150230855,
-0.6369504333,
0.3908042014,
0.2165037692,
0.0550267138,
-0.031829413,
-0.7070999742,
-0.1813468337,
-0.6919295788,
0.6407305002,
0.6791411638,
0.0087488377,
0.6550201178,
-0.1959276944,
0.892139852,
0.1671691835,
0.2478550524,
-0.1514987946,
-0.7778919935,
-0.4082860351,
-0.4711363614,
-0.0279830154,
0.7485715747,
-0.9508972764,
0.8905380368,
0.0822919831,
-0.4326836467,
-0.3491101265,
0.4088914394,
0.5235785842,
0.3290195465,
0.2622767091,
-0.4086760879,
-0.266277343,
-0.4221616387,
-0.0162728168,
-0.2448128015,
-0.0589542203,
0.0176235307,
0.7162447572,
-0.1848802269,
1.3184344769,
-0.5394464135,
-0.7281086445,
-0.7038182616,
-0.0456994027,
0.341645509,
0.4360700846,
0.7243506312,
-0.8022440076,
0.1102212146,
-0.1281321347,
-0.8001683354,
-0.186231941,
0.1311197728,
0.1241883412,
0.1789366305,
0.576425612,
-0.6560224891,
1.007650733,
0.68527776,
-0.2824190855,
0.5093454123,
-0.6421148181,
-0.3780067861,
-0.8484869003,
-0.1354041547,
-0.2754381597,
-0.4032313824,
-0.4302715659,
0.1842119992,
-0.1359428167,
-0.1839345247,
-0.3158952594,
0.3122526407,
-0.3604916632,
0.1510020345,
-0.6169973016,
0.0622238889,
0.2905954123,
0.056605015,
0.1210490838,
0.5649729967,
0.5763816237,
-0.688252151,
0.0990588069,
0.3191719949,
-0.6468860507,
0.4100835919,
-0.6568110585,
0.008354702,
-0.5163754225,
0.3431782126,
-0.926633656,
0.0667583048,
0.4721930325,
-0.0588468239,
0.1748519391,
-0.4458404481,
-0.6695489287,
-0.1386620402,
-0.4574046135,
0.4692155719,
0.6334904432,
-0.4114383459,
0.4344631433,
0.5267053843,
0.073935248,
-0.5498443246,
-1.240577817,
-0.2438899726,
-0.3042952418,
-0.3990546465,
0.4463503361,
0.1384128928,
-0.1744914353,
0.0924646929,
-0.0701753348,
-0.3676376939,
0.1584478617,
0.7867344618,
-0.1322841644,
-0.2478390336,
0.1979268044,
-0.0586391762,
-0.0833178014,
0.0387810767,
-0.4168547094,
0.3683387339,
0.4130100608,
-0.700004518,
-0.0654898658,
0.2836658657,
0.1843888313,
0.0242531989,
1.0500404835,
0.4685091972,
-0.5055657625,
-0.7315163612,
-0.1244448647,
-0.1974491477,
-0.5509328246,
0.1786964387,
-0.1398210973,
0.0963948593,
0.2527154386,
0.4682566226,
0.0339611359,
0.1394551545,
0.0380896553,
-0.0829561353,
1.0200992823,
1.2483860254,
-0.0407688543,
0.7322773337,
-0.3399455547,
0.4758835137,
-0.4272783995,
-0.0925720334,
-0.5220376849,
-0.1016133055,
-0.4566529393,
-0.3160144985,
0.316493839,
0.4225087166,
0.2299512625,
0.5014388561,
-0.7070937157,
0.1986432821,
0.5055934191,
0.3104538321,
0.2493277043,
-0.1054469049,
0.1956680566,
0.3032869101,
-0.7540901899,
-0.4660564065,
1.0365059376,
0.4410270751,
0.6761838198,
0.0700369477,
1.0604153872,
0.431648612,
0.1023983583,
-0.3133556545,
0.4890034497,
0.0195417106,
-0.6946759224,
-0.3006269038,
-0.4966318309,
-1.004191041,
0.2821962237,
-0.2002679706,
-0.7431117892,
0.568429172,
0.2894836068,
-0.3459596932,
0.4576721191,
-0.7104761004,
0.6283811331,
-0.1237910986,
0.0192920715,
-0.0068820659,
-0.1438400447,
0.3486554027,
0.0288101826,
0.6618503928,
-0.379101634,
-0.2750878632,
0.618822515,
-0.5260177851,
0.8770857453,
-0.3162119985,
-0.2230027765,
0.51868999,
-0.0001400879,
0.3388198316,
0.1359078735,
-0.1032179147,
0.1439950764,
0.18195948,
-0.2589871883,
-0.3710092902,
0.2714669406,
-0.5548539162,
-0.3593496382,
-0.604685843,
-0.4945202768,
0.0635552481,
0.1380743831,
0.6777187586,
0.609256804,
0.2924383283,
0.2064869851,
0.41334638,
-0.367342025,
0.6837866306,
0.2591699362,
-0.3469824195,
-0.4115352631,
0.9688678384,
0.2703453004,
0.4150566161,
0.4291347265,
0.4379065335,
-0.2402294129,
-0.931289196,
-0.409509033,
-0.2145474404,
-0.827496469,
-0.5108333826,
-0.3789400458,
-0.3240495026,
-0.297126025,
0.0028121087,
-0.1345304251,
-0.3304648399,
-0.1516806334,
-0.064031139,
0.3500256538,
0.8230671883,
0.0566372685,
0.4877747893,
-0.4248839319,
0.567706883,
-0.2411291301,
0.3504810929,
-0.1915291846,
-0.5884431005,
0.0340645947,
0.0264264978,
-0.58738029,
-0.9474898577,
0.5052289963,
0.6207076907,
0.3215411603,
0.8731639385,
0.5543640852,
0.5487865806,
-0.3184655309,
0.5451434851,
0.1826637536,
-0.841352582,
0.6465039253,
-0.0387464687,
0.1820084751,
0.4724860489,
-0.1296125799,
0.1500203907,
-0.9876144528,
-0.770440042,
-1.1525566578,
0.8404084444,
0.5605434775,
0.1067905053,
0.20426853,
0.0211862754,
0.2783505023,
0.7531806231,
-0.5484947562,
-0.0623201244,
-0.3107081354,
-0.4017342925,
-0.4372624457,
-0.1889085323,
-0.0913248062,
0.2992625237,
0.5313664079,
-0.0167493057,
0.2212773263,
0.2883658111,
-0.2514404058,
-0.1875486225,
0.2383190244,
0.215179652,
0.6015907526,
-0.3878885508,
0.4401814044,
-0.1895906329,
-0.8310802579,
0.1014745981,
0.2429889888,
-0.7350899577,
0.4219433963,
0.6161085367,
0.5415672064,
0.3535631597,
-0.8776404262,
1.008734107,
0.3198322058,
0.1458690614,
-0.3643544316,
0.3428736031,
-0.4387555122,
0.0862595811,
0.438598305,
0.3431854546,
0.4015851319,
-0.7379949689,
0.1932665855,
0.5649837255,
-0.470302701,
-0.4354967475,
0.6425105929,
0.0665140897,
-0.2320684344,
0.0086096441,
-0.2183337063,
-0.5173177719,
0.668356657,
0.6334969401,
0.8496890664,
-0.0433532558,
0.3681518435,
-0.307200402,
0.5388498902,
-0.3141728938,
0.4980088174,
-0.2732803822,
-0.816223979,
-0.1237259656,
-0.6526720524,
-0.3881647885,
0.2092851549,
-0.5957647562,
0.2338369191,
-0.3570668697,
-0.4034538269,
-0.0741559714,
-0.3619309664,
-0.6026961207,
0.0071265474,
0.1345280558,
0.9541062117,
-0.8380875587,
0.4341407716,
0.2132171392,
-0.2286266536,
-0.2734916508,
0.0476348996,
-0.2281330675,
-0.4728703499,
0.0761188418,
0.4939373136,
-0.104417026,
-0.456106931,
-0.3144618571,
-0.6573681831,
0.8068273664,
0.7771175504,
-0.4170378447,
0.1676113755,
0.4079633951,
0.4207910299,
0.0395232551,
0.5661298037,
0.3661575317,
0.3958801925,
-0.4896166921,
-0.8878844976,
-0.0696416721,
-0.0420796014,
-0.1901180744,
0.3569909036,
-0.1106962562,
0.3841237128,
-0.168355003,
-0.3151066005,
0.0414749309,
0.5071151853,
0.2777229846,
0.8027021885,
0.6904602647,
0.2806974947,
0.4735042751,
-0.0692644119,
1.227047205,
-0.1605827212,
0.2209166288,
0.8164250255,
-0.215043962,
1.0008867979,
0.4893504083,
0.0234558173,
0.3900138736,
0.126004681,
0.1772027761,
0.9025298953,
0.1079384536,
-0.2857944071,
0.0380041003,
-0.1401284784,
-0.485088557,
0.3290237784,
0.1417492628,
-0.3658061326,
-0.1724921018,
0.3745550811,
-0.1606671512,
0.1610454917,
-0.3381769657,
0.5995265245,
0.2915681601,
-0.4437515736,
0.5795292854,
0.0955438912,
0.8147901297,
-0.599057436,
0.0937369093,
0.2229253203,
0.7091697454,
-0.5010469556,
-0.9801492095,
0.3569332361,
-0.194848448,
-0.0956782475,
-0.3945032358,
0.9135221839,
-0.5175274014,
-0.3283267319,
0.4941813052,
0.1748613268,
0.0579271242,
-0.3359990418,
-0.4113277197,
-0.1253701001,
-0.6465163231,
-0.2992314398,
0.3803067207,
0.5563970804,
0.0134814484,
0.8138626218,
0.5734030008,
0.3642392159,
0.2949976325,
-0.0461051092,
0.5071860552,
-0.3755958676,
-0.8758274913,
-0.8295820951,
0.208546415,
-0.1621359736,
-0.4175213575,
0.7946258783,
0.3174764216,
0.5034652948,
-0.2072037607,
1.0361909866,
-0.1313875318,
0.0987017825,
-0.3425832391,
0.6587541699,
-0.3427627683,
0.0790648684,
-0.2708922625,
-0.7627049088,
-0.0087476345,
0.2378342301,
-0.1781041175,
-0.2859359682,
0.444599092,
0.5821528435,
-0.2586679757,
0.0976375714,
0.2630280256,
-0.1038665771,
0.3378742635,
0.4143091142,
0.7255853415,
-0.4307017326,
0.9353663325,
-0.5406684279,
-0.3662897646,
-0.3442078531,
-1.1444987059,
-0.8840502501,
-0.4738504887,
-0.3036342561,
-0.3821744621,
0.189224571,
0.4113349319,
1.0458194017,
-1.043032527,
0.0191241838,
-0.493963331,
0.4532057643,
-0.6574594975,
-0.2266356796,
0.1428185701,
-0.1633068174,
-0.3351633847,
0.5305392742,
0.4527610242,
0.1170682013,
-0.3950130343,
0.1207166612,
0.5617243648,
0.2735073864,
0.2963880599,
0.1575315595,
-0.342020154,
-0.160736084,
-0.5321859121,
0.1075731441,
-0.0966985002,
0.5539522171,
-0.5858251452,
0.2368545979,
0.7821152806,
0.3166926503,
0.2552620471,
-0.028198652,
0.6439817548,
-1.1279613972,
0.7732411027,
0.3379394412,
0.3752730489,
0.2826667726,
-0.4070292413,
0.2912861109,
0.1045915037,
-0.4335198104,
-1.5204870701,
0.2313237637,
-0.5173476934,
-0.154422611,
1.1492636204,
-0.2220438123,
-0.5473859906,
-0.6537571549,
0.0361391045,
-0.1518790275,
-0.4525846541,
0.9120919108,
0.4013555646,
0.2766872346,
-0.041619651,
-0.83020854,
0.6092085838,
0.0923481658,
-0.7575551867,
-0.1396895647,
-0.4065176249,
0.2258484811,
0.5654441118,
0.5540598035,
0.1527185291,
0.2004041225,
-0.0450333394,
0.0922947973,
-0.0734164864,
-0.4221543968,
-0.2038238645,
0.6383683681,
-0.0590728447,
-0.6809058785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09170v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09170v2 | On Isotropy, Contextualization and Learning Dynamics of Contrastive-based Sentence Representation Learning | 2022-12-18T21:11:49 | 2023-05-26T20:40:57 | Chenghao Xiao, Yang Long, Noura Al Moubayed | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Incorporating contrastive learning objectives in sentence representation
learning (SRL) has yielded significant improvements on many sentence-level NLP
tasks. However, it is not well understood why contrastive learning works for
learning sentence-level semantics. In this paper, we aim to help guide future
designs of sentence representation learning methods by taking a closer look at
contrastive SRL through the lens of isotropy, contextualization and learning
dynamics. We interpret its successes through the geometry of the representation
shifts and show that contrastive learning brings isotropy, and drives high
intra-sentence similarity: when in the same sentence, tokens converge to
similar positions in the semantic space. We also find that what we formalize as
"spurious contextualization" is mitigated for semantically meaningful tokens,
while augmented for functional ones. We find that the embedding space is
directed towards the origin during training, with more areas now better
defined. We ablate these findings by observing the learning dynamics with
different training temperatures, batch sizes and pooling methods. | [
-0.1592578441,
-0.4293073118,
0.3799457252,
-0.0444300696,
-0.530439198,
-0.2053841203,
-0.3300388455,
-0.2613753974,
0.1170997694,
0.1149506196,
-0.5659104586,
-0.419386059,
-0.5200183988,
0.1623601019,
-0.2929591238,
1.0740940571,
-0.0372139104,
0.146850884,
-0.1720904559,
-0.4155988693,
-0.2604885101,
-0.4045870304,
-0.4057095945,
-0.2442433536,
0.5602310896,
0.2173102647,
0.6923958659,
0.9373694658,
0.530566752,
0.2578225136,
-0.1817703545,
-0.2691904306,
-0.5242832303,
0.5869762301,
0.0513832159,
-0.7055206895,
0.6597255468,
0.1721906513,
0.7441337109,
0.8053497672,
-0.2979943454,
-0.4198814631,
0.461753279,
0.6612291932,
-0.6339498162,
0.2713139951,
-0.5981447697,
0.4740959108,
0.0378786996,
-0.3390775323,
-0.3735158443,
-0.0681447461,
0.1687321514,
-0.7131497264,
0.1438459754,
0.0588178672,
0.9185470343,
0.332079798,
-0.7617880106,
-0.4881216586,
-0.3150592744,
0.5990521312,
-0.4053785503,
0.5249254704,
-0.1735290438,
0.0512935966,
-0.0672262311,
-0.8179930449,
-0.2339935601,
-0.5648211837,
-0.3158973157,
0.2718833983,
0.1184646562,
0.0847753584,
0.2569640875,
0.0325904153,
-0.2504931688,
0.264809221,
-0.3071295619,
0.2148115337,
0.2271382213,
0.2063306868,
0.290389806,
-0.1020877957,
-0.9207365513,
-0.2526672184,
-0.6995369196,
0.2459767163,
0.116811119,
0.5768302083,
-0.2852317989,
0.367705673,
0.0152339041,
0.3730635643,
0.0121477935,
0.2069577128,
0.2632273138,
-0.1595306098,
-0.0921147615,
-0.0609011017,
0.6558044553,
0.3045189083,
0.2150954008,
-0.3295888603,
-0.0456077047,
-0.2536109984,
0.3384098113,
-0.7585576177,
-0.0220741741,
-0.089692831,
-0.5655015707,
-0.2510547936,
0.4043909907,
-0.5315462947,
-0.1953373402,
-0.6532953978,
0.1295333952,
-0.9393264055,
0.1581825018,
-0.1842850447,
-0.2546732426,
0.3205631375,
0.2607687712,
-1.0288194418,
0.2848813534,
0.5610168576,
0.7310795188,
-0.1368081123,
-0.4947202504,
-0.3804970384,
0.2178294063,
-0.5497514606,
0.6010243893,
-0.72571522,
-0.1284765899,
0.2974235415,
-0.1881642342,
-0.2423932701,
-0.6757282019,
0.1394659579,
-0.6591732502,
0.2457333803,
-0.3814657331,
-0.6210295558,
-0.0437938757,
0.2100025713,
-0.5388650894,
0.6304224133,
-0.2218049616,
-0.9104923606,
0.8171866536,
-0.3987916708,
-0.3326809704,
-0.0524501503,
-0.2905225754,
-0.1254045665,
0.4487739503,
-0.2698470354,
0.3583045602,
0.2125737965,
0.0404722095,
-0.0486241579,
-0.5998659134,
0.2962016463,
-0.0827791989,
0.8417332768,
0.3725526333,
-0.238594979,
0.2197303325,
-0.5310974717,
-0.2873814702,
-0.1405521184,
-0.4553277791,
-0.4398217499,
-0.0713572279,
0.0758258849,
0.1962894499,
-0.1927022338,
-0.1618299335,
0.0123393098,
-0.2408726215,
0.3832795322,
0.5905300975,
0.1121756136,
0.5931500196,
-0.0219382159,
0.5082104802,
0.5191317797,
-0.3539061248,
-0.2826262414,
-0.089572154,
-0.5967031717,
-0.0745918378,
0.2097604573,
0.4615451694,
-0.6896495819,
0.162029162,
-0.0592461303,
-0.0632894263,
-0.2621973157,
0.1795685589,
0.3381334543,
0.6141816974,
0.5325154066,
-0.0439635664,
-0.4320756495,
-0.8179805875,
-0.3828713,
-0.1005365923,
0.0969539657,
0.0700986758,
0.456685245,
-0.0811110884,
0.672801137,
-0.2426919788,
-0.3467368782,
-0.1777731627,
0.3959311247,
-0.1645113528,
0.4835797846,
0.5941196084,
-0.9641888142,
-0.4474503696,
-0.1151349172,
-0.8846658468,
-0.0731803998,
-0.2464052439,
0.0772249624,
0.235549897,
1.3543130159,
-0.527674675,
0.2133830041,
0.2397721112,
-0.2753492892,
0.314684093,
-0.3558870852,
0.0433080383,
-1.1194196939,
-0.0090622455,
0.2125336081,
-0.0233509634,
-0.3260837197,
0.4142879248,
0.1022654474,
-0.113154605,
-0.4652471542,
0.0762285665,
-0.7231648564,
-0.0209743194,
-0.1487220079,
0.4810997844,
-0.3398262262,
0.4594699442,
0.0925327167,
0.7018634081,
0.4962238669,
-0.5581333041,
0.0793968514,
-0.0433432721,
-0.2110318393,
0.5064637065,
-0.3627135456,
-0.4128014743,
-0.4205068946,
0.3518388569,
-0.9430924654,
0.1165881231,
0.1051050946,
-0.1311551034,
0.3908396065,
-0.0104267746,
-0.2919552326,
0.3953846991,
-0.3221383393,
0.4554990828,
0.5711598992,
-0.3553459644,
0.3556671739,
0.0966430306,
0.1840532273,
-0.9027366638,
-0.7302353382,
-0.0102233347,
-0.4961557984,
-0.1574138105,
0.6593981385,
0.3573163152,
-0.5563148856,
0.2939873636,
-0.0161994454,
0.2358249128,
0.0708350167,
0.0745198876,
-0.0947230533,
-0.2470437735,
0.5053298473,
-0.0165643245,
-0.2741972208,
0.1329759955,
-0.312898308,
0.4396348894,
-0.0227626711,
0.0406247377,
-0.3673791885,
0.1703810096,
0.1304837763,
0.1385542303,
0.9933529496,
0.7097584605,
-0.0405389518,
-0.20120655,
0.0495306179,
-0.2094439119,
-0.3865516782,
0.4385442734,
-0.5272704959,
-0.9135481119,
0.6326082349,
-0.0502976067,
-0.1206016466,
0.366522789,
0.3178907335,
-0.4264389575,
0.326059103,
0.6641286016,
0.3548228443,
0.8540713787,
-0.2167579085,
-0.0090990802,
-0.941188693,
-0.4140693843,
-0.4232464135,
-0.465895623,
-0.9056814313,
-0.3735706508,
0.2507607043,
0.3966760933,
-0.292363435,
0.3731682599,
-0.002151829,
0.4994306564,
0.4142389297,
0.109906584,
-0.0312478039,
0.0099401884,
-0.6154477,
-0.4010584652,
-0.6445003152,
-0.2057792395,
0.6369104981,
0.0223830566,
0.8213717937,
0.0863125622,
0.8830230236,
0.0150851877,
0.0552579537,
-0.5247221589,
0.545073092,
-0.3482838869,
0.0296853092,
-0.1593521535,
-0.471450597,
-1.1087508202,
0.6424399018,
-0.367743969,
-0.6768952012,
0.3814685047,
0.038843859,
0.1130430549,
0.1278163344,
-0.6337866187,
0.9729905128,
0.070961237,
-0.5449767113,
-0.3829495311,
-1.1182043552,
-0.0608163252,
0.5298297405,
-0.0166955553,
0.2622053325,
-0.4952710271,
0.4020641148,
-0.3570889235,
0.8841247559,
-0.2848055065,
0.0284342859,
-0.0278760847,
0.2572100759,
0.0799747631,
-0.0117673287,
0.1622634679,
-0.2211334705,
-0.3056582808,
-0.4990065694,
-0.8846829534,
0.6769190431,
-0.6298453808,
-0.6132215261,
-0.373259902,
-0.6822760105,
-0.1736855358,
-0.1278154701,
0.392398417,
0.4311690331,
-0.2901202738,
0.5763986707,
0.6329015493,
-0.0618869215,
0.5420278311,
0.016178716,
-0.1653788537,
-0.1196090877,
0.5228874087,
0.08552742,
0.3397098482,
0.9308103919,
0.0626922995,
-0.2733410001,
-0.5171189308,
0.0169291068,
0.1377559155,
-0.9114552736,
0.0200841911,
-0.476518631,
-0.0876794085,
-0.4032258391,
-0.3474802077,
0.1356611997,
-0.4251716435,
-0.490485847,
-0.4098193645,
0.0599786155,
0.495895654,
-0.3192311823,
0.133528918,
-0.392493248,
0.0886063725,
0.1343816519,
-0.0531355254,
-0.1165728346,
-0.7242026329,
-0.3564182222,
-0.3280014694,
-0.1446717829,
-0.7196561694,
0.3273376524,
0.3857441247,
0.5300709605,
0.5009973049,
-0.0963741168,
0.6843602657,
-0.517948091,
0.7303472161,
0.1179250553,
-0.8271340132,
0.4965393543,
-0.1230823919,
0.308950901,
0.6929204464,
0.6313045621,
-0.6406524777,
-0.3971262574,
-0.4847375751,
-0.9971507788,
0.5167216659,
-0.1192955524,
0.5169964433,
-0.0494566299,
0.5841375589,
0.1875989586,
0.2099002302,
-1.0701473951,
-0.111341089,
-0.3050556779,
-0.3644722998,
-0.0648101643,
-0.2454189956,
-0.0821421444,
0.1041271016,
0.3526660204,
-0.2320975512,
0.1048041657,
0.1805604398,
-0.3021515608,
0.2284676582,
0.2876040637,
0.5124879479,
0.3860270679,
-0.2410517335,
0.407772541,
-0.0569295362,
-0.1311159134,
0.0357039571,
0.0974674746,
-0.198890388,
-0.1107429489,
0.8130113482,
0.9642387629,
0.6593928933,
-0.6418806911,
0.4969573915,
0.1938631833,
-0.0312835798,
-0.0409350097,
0.0850532427,
-0.0511788949,
0.3258934319,
0.2758987546,
0.0497219786,
0.1823756993,
-0.9408045411,
0.2295201719,
0.4712322056,
-0.7767468095,
-0.1311924011,
0.5987932682,
0.0137537913,
-0.0746189579,
0.8252372742,
-0.0946549475,
-0.507763207,
0.5621612668,
0.7258813381,
0.6920257807,
0.0038440663,
0.2708503604,
0.3486607075,
0.0967993066,
0.2068665326,
-0.1450064033,
-0.4694003761,
-0.9148925543,
0.0329610072,
-0.2044588625,
-0.214888081,
-0.4356288612,
-0.9407286048,
0.241742,
-0.3998167515,
0.2850092053,
-0.3004801273,
-0.3027776182,
-0.3010618687,
0.2348084897,
-0.0008122809,
0.8799442649,
-0.9665368199,
0.7344142795,
0.8095407486,
-0.6978706717,
-0.5166515112,
0.5662249923,
0.0511515997,
-0.7190115452,
1.2531126738,
0.4063036144,
-0.1944265664,
-0.2168015838,
-0.5703283548,
-0.5813993812,
1.1710305214,
0.4214905202,
-0.3560039401,
-0.133332476,
-0.1267552674,
0.8901783824,
-0.7664091587,
0.0467289351,
0.0542214364,
-0.0522364266,
0.0851600468,
-0.1561390758,
0.1407456249,
-0.2332857102,
0.4301189482,
-0.0167673063,
-0.6009774208,
0.7426823378,
-0.2883729935,
-0.5174757838,
-0.1673481464,
0.8579286337,
0.367983371,
-0.001587834,
0.3538281322,
0.6474309564,
0.4249161482,
-0.2303459942,
1.1955513954,
-0.3549932241,
0.2484314889,
0.9365239143,
-0.2844501734,
1.0037064552,
0.887793541,
0.1123607531,
1.0716466904,
0.4226644635,
0.1615826488,
0.8113676906,
0.3826728761,
0.0206591561,
-0.0776890814,
-0.0930567086,
-0.1290302873,
0.1929204464,
0.2303810269,
-0.5314655304,
-0.3214943111,
0.2930790186,
-0.2112734914,
0.4536053538,
0.006464194,
0.8533596396,
0.2071023583,
-0.3583084345,
0.2525213063,
-0.1885157526,
0.5585072041,
-0.6054793596,
-0.0732938573,
-0.301638186,
0.0374285951,
-0.0234192368,
-0.7325114012,
0.2934272885,
-0.4099784493,
0.0076835002,
-0.398247987,
0.4013887942,
-0.6275790334,
0.0183589216,
0.7065289617,
0.3028273582,
0.0155292517,
0.4941759109,
-0.7079229951,
0.157178089,
-0.1435847729,
-0.2447855175,
0.4880620539,
0.861692965,
0.208987385,
0.6208772659,
0.030333735,
-0.0494089015,
-0.0255200192,
0.1872893572,
0.6605757475,
-0.8989627361,
-0.6608928442,
-0.7307346463,
0.617385447,
0.0377334468,
-0.5067641735,
0.4549048543,
0.4719858468,
1.1401492357,
-0.1104489565,
0.212174058,
-0.1757467538,
0.0491340384,
-1.1752624512,
0.1686421931,
-0.5314350128,
0.3238400221,
0.0529345982,
-1.0235558748,
-0.5412663221,
0.7440364957,
-0.2156177908,
0.223461777,
1.1967661381,
0.6333116293,
-0.1132735386,
-0.1148077324,
0.26311782,
0.3499108255,
0.042618867,
0.3380555809,
0.9644010663,
-0.4356705844,
0.5307977796,
-0.1126403809,
-0.0387024693,
-0.1983729005,
-0.8632119894,
-0.5464756489,
-0.9943636656,
-0.2900852263,
-0.3331698179,
0.2932104468,
1.1896059513,
0.6523721218,
-0.6110215187,
-0.4263779819,
-0.5468685627,
-0.05963232,
-0.4194653332,
-0.3351231515,
0.3462138176,
-1.0996745825,
-0.6090112925,
0.257778585,
0.3806690872,
0.0370711759,
0.0605070181,
-0.0780669153,
-0.3623886108,
-0.1048293039,
0.3635066152,
0.2320978194,
-0.7128083706,
-0.2616071701,
-0.4091521502,
-0.3977274001,
0.2955566645,
1.249076128,
-0.8736770153,
0.1617591381,
0.5388016701,
0.5250456929,
0.588625133,
0.041924268,
0.5195837617,
-0.8352857828,
0.4174970984,
0.0634060055,
0.4575000703,
0.2336206436,
-0.1592777222,
0.6348118782,
0.4351285696,
-0.2863427997,
-0.6455176473,
0.5795589089,
-0.930296123,
-0.6015611887,
0.9117430449,
-0.267611444,
-0.1089197993,
0.2271177173,
-0.0629604831,
0.1636696309,
-0.3278237283,
0.8591447473,
0.614779532,
-0.4840264022,
-0.5207354426,
-0.0109620523,
0.6454088092,
0.4187108278,
-0.6936483383,
0.1483515799,
0.5896748304,
0.1439567953,
0.2720122337,
0.1488405764,
-0.2153939456,
0.0516955033,
0.1848952621,
-0.2542894185,
0.0821450502,
-0.4222881794,
-0.62422961,
0.3940754533,
-0.1062192246,
0.0297965147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09146v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09146v3 | Can Retriever-Augmented Language Models Reason? The Blame Game Between the Retriever and the Language Model | 2022-12-18T19:27:41 | 2023-11-02T19:12:52 | Parishad BehnamGhader, Santiago Miret, Siva Reddy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Augmenting pretrained language models with retrievers has shown promise in
effectively solving common NLP problems, such as language modeling and question
answering. In this paper, we evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of popular
retriever-augmented language models, namely kNN-LM, REALM, DPR + FiD,
Contriever + ATLAS, and Contriever + Flan-T5, in reasoning over retrieved
statements across different tasks. Our findings indicate that the simple
similarity metric employed by retrievers is insufficient for retrieving all the
necessary statements for reasoning. Additionally, the language models do not
exhibit strong reasoning even when provided with only the required statements.
Furthermore, when combined with imperfect retrievers, the performance of the
language models becomes even worse, e.g., Flan-T5's performance drops by 28.6%
when retrieving 5 statements using Contriever. While larger language models
improve performance, there is still a substantial room for enhancement. Our
further analysis indicates that multihop retrieve-and-read is promising for
large language models like GPT-3.5, but does not generalize to other language
models like Flan-T5-xxl. | [
-0.3399136066,
-0.511959672,
0.6402179599,
0.1279530376,
-0.0565723293,
-0.0525795631,
-0.0754013956,
-0.8039500713,
-0.1221955568,
0.5684396029,
-0.2446778268,
0.0415452905,
-0.6272997856,
0.3760358691,
-0.3858926296,
0.7459535003,
0.1054126993,
-0.1154215336,
-0.2056299895,
-0.2866462767,
-0.6902573705,
-0.8231327534,
-0.4123487175,
-0.5171089172,
0.5219125748,
0.2201132327,
0.7977823019,
0.2939202487,
0.5559504628,
0.3859045208,
-0.0949231535,
0.3043512404,
-0.2956841886,
0.2702603638,
-0.470220834,
-0.5138400197,
-0.4248189628,
-0.2121609449,
0.2144804001,
0.692953825,
-0.2834796011,
-0.170813933,
-0.0729673728,
0.7470834851,
-0.7754686475,
-0.1491493434,
-0.6900910735,
-0.2021822184,
-0.1960314065,
-0.0053705117,
-0.6153916121,
-0.2914810181,
0.4164194465,
-0.6065763235,
0.4677356482,
0.1826255023,
0.9622157216,
0.0462298915,
-0.3955579698,
-0.4979980588,
-0.901403904,
0.8984935284,
-0.6970635653,
0.5009040833,
0.4456631541,
0.3675666153,
-0.0259087421,
-0.5611107349,
-0.5826182961,
-0.2503175735,
-0.3262879848,
-0.0427961275,
-0.304009378,
0.0588143244,
0.5071948767,
0.5075545311,
-0.5141763687,
0.062003281,
-0.2437084317,
0.0166170392,
0.3876074255,
-0.0189566314,
0.3320894241,
-0.1441654712,
-0.3731511831,
-0.0477284193,
-0.809260428,
-0.0997415632,
0.2104824781,
0.3650469482,
0.3585746586,
0.5340952873,
-0.2298710346,
0.8142124414,
0.1068436727,
0.136738345,
0.197097525,
-0.2363843173,
-0.2763745189,
-0.1212896258,
0.6160704494,
0.0923941359,
0.3047488928,
-0.5484753847,
-0.4231086075,
-0.1219863594,
0.319178015,
-0.6285158992,
-0.366232127,
0.3515227735,
-0.439828366,
0.1152861863,
-0.0549481772,
-0.4508537352,
-0.2952950299,
-0.2805503309,
0.5620850921,
-0.6119793057,
-0.6781709194,
0.3228119612,
-0.2097702473,
0.241616413,
0.4506944418,
-1.0048747063,
0.3356552422,
0.8211901188,
0.6488358378,
-0.1013196483,
-0.3149359822,
-0.5265019536,
-0.1040310636,
-0.2905488908,
0.9426915646,
-0.5387758613,
-0.3328499794,
-0.0407394618,
0.0140786935,
-0.2497157454,
-0.8176028728,
0.5573502779,
-0.8505956531,
0.1348599195,
-0.7251653075,
-0.7067757249,
-0.1138500124,
0.6155026555,
-0.9681300521,
0.7078018188,
0.0877896026,
-0.8502944708,
0.3305054605,
-0.4199222624,
-0.3833622634,
0.0553969629,
-0.0046705711,
-0.1567136198,
0.2860602438,
0.3716058731,
0.079641968,
-0.3360279799,
0.3001568019,
-0.3056998849,
-0.4375805855,
0.4190689921,
-0.2132499218,
0.7616662383,
0.3495947123,
-0.1260197312,
-0.1237482503,
-0.7266159654,
-0.0028110961,
0.0962943137,
-0.4401273727,
-0.4881041348,
0.2357538342,
-0.1699225307,
0.3017068207,
0.1292186081,
-0.5096368194,
0.184831515,
-0.5280380249,
0.0426361561,
0.5463085175,
-0.3810055554,
0.4335465431,
-0.3377636373,
0.6220891476,
0.1824784875,
-0.3585918844,
-0.2446854562,
0.0040267971,
-0.6814956069,
0.0172592085,
0.2482084632,
0.4761764705,
-0.8879931569,
-0.1359940916,
-0.2777711749,
-0.4368899167,
-0.5728946924,
-0.0525462441,
0.5837287903,
0.7554580569,
0.5604940653,
0.1322730035,
-0.5337435603,
-0.8151957393,
-0.8619908094,
-0.0199511703,
0.000682471,
0.3000823557,
0.2927348018,
0.06344264,
0.7861078978,
-0.0432406142,
-0.0927493274,
-0.5060596466,
-0.0833218321,
0.3655369878,
0.4486241043,
0.5888949633,
-0.8731696606,
-0.2598543167,
0.1101978719,
-0.7555454969,
-0.0587182976,
0.026697224,
0.1179932877,
0.2004598528,
0.229985252,
-0.8089918494,
0.2489226907,
0.3392211795,
-0.1718485206,
0.8123720288,
-0.2182666659,
0.2243983895,
-0.79308635,
0.2722213566,
-0.0411446393,
-0.2014280409,
-0.7636341453,
0.4338773787,
-0.0333999731,
-0.0536969267,
-0.4280094802,
0.6854807138,
-0.6303663254,
-0.039386943,
-0.3770219386,
0.1584461182,
0.2691520154,
0.1656208038,
0.3022013605,
0.7209072709,
0.5219969749,
-0.814398706,
0.5574367046,
0.2936133742,
-0.3055599332,
0.3279877901,
-0.9779638052,
0.3582285941,
-0.1520095915,
0.1146937311,
-0.7110115886,
-0.1955868006,
-0.0238499623,
-0.270825088,
0.303617537,
-0.1745850444,
-0.5412945151,
-0.2817771137,
-0.0005901654,
0.4087668359,
0.1632898897,
-0.8087957501,
0.7158279419,
0.0724901482,
0.0470924154,
-0.8409692645,
-0.7467965484,
-0.052121181,
-0.1998631656,
-0.6698250175,
0.1976020336,
0.2557091713,
-0.3387982845,
-0.044319544,
-0.1246261001,
0.0771618783,
0.0394334979,
0.0392927527,
0.0135896346,
-0.3825495243,
0.3079811037,
-0.3860720396,
-0.1913450211,
-0.0030596373,
-0.0914778709,
0.4226592779,
-0.4251995385,
-0.6003231406,
0.0638511553,
0.4565141201,
0.2975873649,
-0.4600347877,
0.9486292601,
0.1276322007,
-0.3145304024,
0.1470536739,
-0.8786672354,
-0.2458368987,
-0.4574442208,
0.2707537413,
-0.7378470302,
-1.0388292074,
0.6749717593,
-0.0948265269,
0.0672359467,
0.4938206971,
0.2324410081,
-0.0124166971,
1.1653447151,
0.3954069316,
-0.0018924283,
0.2567476332,
-0.0230792258,
0.2850097716,
-0.7282258868,
-0.191466257,
-0.7145961523,
-0.3345918357,
-0.6570821404,
0.2313504815,
-0.080478549,
0.3385407031,
-0.2332099974,
0.3085179329,
-0.387942642,
0.561948657,
0.6671776175,
0.0031476414,
0.4604845345,
0.032207761,
-0.0708870441,
-0.1796183139,
-0.7282485962,
-0.4564324617,
0.8186674714,
0.1194261238,
0.6647208929,
0.3312437832,
0.5666227341,
-0.2121108621,
0.219065845,
-0.4624371231,
0.3728634119,
-0.2553206384,
-0.9788247943,
0.0323176868,
-0.5402761102,
-1.1252157688,
0.5567098856,
0.1041121483,
-0.7702521086,
0.4577383697,
0.389547348,
-0.2795404494,
0.3200918436,
-0.8604217172,
1.1281930208,
-0.2626586854,
-0.1749318093,
-0.1476785243,
-0.594183743,
0.5549511909,
0.0540270209,
0.2404926866,
0.1602532268,
0.4034645557,
0.3600337505,
-0.8642094731,
0.3672954738,
-0.2458853275,
-0.1188240945,
0.4180113673,
0.3926641941,
0.5466690063,
-0.2832186222,
-0.3867513239,
-0.3032038212,
0.3037507236,
-0.3664577007,
-0.7786322236,
0.5663462281,
-0.5202175975,
-0.7800840735,
-0.4803642929,
-0.4082488418,
-0.146247685,
0.3091790676,
0.1783584207,
0.6470007896,
0.066664204,
0.1929174662,
0.4581766725,
-0.1331978887,
0.3130624592,
0.5349953175,
-0.5011016726,
-0.0687737912,
1.0862987041,
-0.0488648638,
0.4568618238,
0.408223778,
0.1183460057,
-0.3815689385,
-0.4810338318,
-0.0795680806,
0.1603396237,
-0.719517529,
-0.1431206167,
-0.5721956491,
-0.0743597373,
-0.1633452922,
0.1072818488,
-0.3224819005,
-0.404817313,
-0.2541641295,
-0.0024447597,
0.2689843774,
0.358490169,
-0.150062874,
0.3470620215,
-1.0568495989,
0.3865983188,
0.2497245967,
0.2899532914,
0.1442729235,
-0.5514178872,
-0.1489212811,
0.1163707823,
-0.2580055296,
-0.9021970034,
0.404912591,
0.0323169827,
0.3130813539,
0.2242775112,
-0.0171388574,
0.7336646318,
-0.4844626188,
0.6338331103,
-0.0490370318,
-0.6126278639,
0.6190626621,
-0.2756308317,
0.2615337074,
0.4758795202,
0.2483766526,
-0.4306060672,
-0.3715397418,
-0.737046957,
-0.5935818553,
0.82761693,
-0.0761920437,
-0.0145920683,
-0.3630223572,
0.3640647531,
0.0614233427,
0.1607624888,
-0.8127813935,
0.0868205056,
-0.2603963614,
0.1377916038,
0.2324476093,
-0.2488504499,
0.1839678138,
-0.037725836,
0.5909500122,
0.0193607677,
0.0829847679,
0.1906216294,
-0.3982894421,
0.0244815778,
0.4391448498,
0.3040140569,
0.7847364545,
-0.2639115155,
0.3521384895,
-0.0794806182,
-0.2887735665,
0.0738986507,
0.4482252002,
-0.0871546865,
0.0111906715,
0.4933360815,
0.7711156607,
0.1268494576,
-0.7622289658,
0.4738195539,
-0.0791733488,
-0.0624013767,
0.0029173077,
0.0766361356,
0.0796664432,
0.3687755466,
0.3546708524,
0.2384513319,
0.1106615216,
-0.4325633645,
-0.0529837124,
0.5809625983,
-0.1276993752,
-0.4484530687,
0.6839974523,
-0.0187197905,
-0.2727900147,
0.8753595948,
-0.2236665338,
-0.6305021048,
0.466896832,
0.7866185308,
0.4811870456,
-0.2807262838,
-0.034651462,
0.3587807417,
0.339777559,
-0.4709049761,
0.2870547473,
0.1221392602,
-1.1248321533,
-0.8007887006,
-0.4129624963,
-0.2389002293,
0.341340363,
-0.597649157,
-0.0212921612,
-0.081896171,
-0.0441682115,
-0.1483575255,
-0.0320377797,
-0.7963503599,
0.243395865,
-0.3414990008,
0.8073518872,
-0.5651730895,
0.6461735964,
0.5740948319,
-0.7771017551,
-0.9716283679,
-0.2298467159,
-0.1637835056,
-0.4701969624,
0.8244270086,
0.1611177325,
0.0149921849,
0.0018255407,
-0.4267029464,
-0.8326051235,
0.6982339621,
0.5645614862,
-0.8053512573,
-0.3426501751,
-0.041930981,
0.5151457191,
-0.0987143964,
0.37294662,
0.6069662571,
0.2371807545,
0.1360051632,
-1.0081663132,
-0.0178361014,
-0.1013633534,
-0.122483626,
0.2374481112,
-0.3001589477,
0.768386662,
-0.2836126089,
-0.2489341199,
0.0418990254,
0.5599114895,
0.8291897774,
0.1416676491,
0.401522547,
0.754894793,
0.6467400789,
-0.1242938489,
1.5299395323,
0.1559227407,
0.2417619079,
1.226367116,
-0.3217575848,
0.8798072338,
0.3633397818,
-0.4174950421,
0.3181240559,
0.3933812976,
0.2354185134,
0.5120549202,
-0.082033813,
-0.1493672878,
-0.4274497628,
0.121472165,
-0.4613075256,
0.2696748972,
0.3711218536,
-0.1874459982,
-0.3847207725,
-0.1049648449,
-0.1960974187,
0.0855151042,
-0.1169192716,
0.5500358939,
0.2545974553,
-0.7818527818,
0.6209588647,
-0.0942894146,
0.4843594432,
-0.2399207056,
0.0529657677,
-0.2968503833,
0.4358403385,
-0.2106918991,
-0.5417945385,
0.4837906063,
-0.0055060466,
-0.1831663549,
-0.2046467662,
1.1671416759,
-0.4504160881,
-0.3956398368,
0.1722862273,
0.7920529246,
0.2892002165,
-0.3484459221,
-0.5615368485,
0.0139960907,
-0.2167901248,
-0.2890819907,
0.3139607608,
0.7083157897,
0.0481325127,
0.7392838001,
0.581415832,
0.1351708621,
0.1299536079,
0.3869871199,
0.7373178601,
-0.4299092591,
-0.1561773419,
-0.9624345899,
0.4564056098,
0.0411830992,
-0.0125726508,
0.7787078023,
0.5949280858,
0.6819591522,
-0.0084350724,
0.5290846229,
-0.0379491523,
1.089048028,
-0.5133913755,
0.4983487427,
-0.6182696223,
0.3407129943,
-0.3954988718,
-0.9991258383,
-0.2720863223,
0.6997926831,
-0.4616646767,
0.3294452131,
0.5534448028,
0.5656241775,
-0.3540068269,
0.1105587184,
0.124134481,
0.1071304232,
0.6384723783,
0.621088028,
1.0800751448,
-0.4571543634,
0.6503751874,
0.053802561,
0.0376061983,
-0.1616186202,
-0.9559696913,
-0.6322183609,
-0.4232103825,
-0.2101964802,
-0.4450925291,
0.0923252031,
0.5254361033,
0.3106097281,
-0.7453263402,
0.0681153685,
-0.3985740244,
0.2338552177,
-0.2436240613,
-0.2251135707,
0.3808466792,
-0.5631710291,
-0.4719065726,
0.4001984894,
-0.0202336665,
-0.1839768142,
0.0095966402,
-0.1424254179,
-0.4026656747,
-0.2419910729,
0.4970892966,
0.6570885777,
-1.0166445971,
-0.3859467804,
0.209935829,
-0.0098637836,
-0.0174078848,
0.7878923416,
-1.0212699175,
0.5943413973,
0.4836392701,
0.8496872187,
0.5233005881,
0.1600748599,
0.6254871488,
-0.8095588684,
0.0786121562,
0.2692694366,
0.4512667358,
0.4546821713,
0.028185606,
0.3505640328,
0.0422420576,
-0.7799308896,
-0.9038314223,
0.2970167994,
-0.3945633769,
-0.26950562,
0.9482728839,
-0.134579286,
0.0346369259,
-0.0745766014,
-0.1032289416,
0.0683104247,
-0.041810751,
0.6369559765,
0.9934080839,
-0.1232461408,
-0.4807952344,
-0.5918567181,
0.5219146013,
0.6326895356,
-0.6804367304,
0.1089879572,
0.7013394833,
0.2315332592,
0.4230600595,
0.8018169403,
-0.08387582,
0.2924243212,
-0.1264753789,
-0.1757536978,
0.0364550911,
-0.1192652211,
-0.2405208647,
0.0410546996,
0.2445066869,
-0.0697187483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09140v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09140v2 | Unsupervised Discontinuous Constituency Parsing with Mildly Context-Sensitive Grammars | 2022-12-18T18:10:45 | 2023-06-09T15:42:50 | Songlin Yang, Roger P. Levy, Yoon Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | We study grammar induction with mildly context-sensitive grammars for
unsupervised discontinuous parsing. Using the probabilistic linear context-free
rewriting system (LCFRS) formalism, our approach fixes the rule structure in
advance and focuses on parameter learning with maximum likelihood. To reduce
the computational complexity of both parsing and parameter estimation, we
restrict the grammar formalism to LCFRS-2 (i.e., binary LCFRS with fan-out two)
and further discard rules that require O(n^6) time to parse, reducing inference
to O(n^5). We find that using a large number of nonterminals is beneficial and
thus make use of tensor decomposition-based rank-space dynamic programming with
an embedding-based parameterization of rule probabilities to scale up the
number of nonterminals. Experiments on German and Dutch show that our approach
is able to induce linguistically meaningful trees with continuous and
discontinuous structures | [
-0.2710251212,
-0.8339008689,
0.7070081234,
0.2365672737,
-0.4645118117,
-0.1593393087,
-0.3751354814,
-0.0330074169,
0.0460926704,
0.2196281403,
-0.7084032297,
-0.5324326158,
-0.1905364394,
0.0181929059,
-0.4464101493,
0.5512188077,
0.4392917156,
0.0722408444,
-0.3426706195,
-0.0879919752,
-0.0103528006,
-0.4580398202,
-0.5725085735,
-0.112534076,
0.6315250993,
0.5974847674,
0.5247228742,
0.7527050972,
0.0554625578,
0.3012234867,
-0.6384236813,
0.0805807263,
-0.3690410554,
0.2800751328,
-0.2082245499,
-0.3575819731,
-0.0803337023,
-0.3723677993,
0.7745252252,
1.2917478085,
-0.2318902165,
-0.1474819779,
0.0864001289,
0.6441544294,
-0.4727616906,
0.3001070917,
-0.7074546218,
0.0700736716,
-0.0553487092,
-0.2051845044,
-0.6680063605,
-0.3206773996,
-0.1196135506,
-0.2402279228,
0.4272002876,
-0.275143981,
0.4632769525,
0.302410692,
-0.4400584698,
-0.0675611719,
-0.5846425295,
0.7476952672,
-0.6609328985,
0.6775290966,
0.1162496433,
0.2282020897,
-0.6277500391,
-0.794950664,
-0.2641936839,
-0.0022672785,
-0.161368534,
-0.2347146273,
-0.0991274863,
0.3613140285,
0.2786484957,
0.1706004143,
-0.3266507089,
0.1766301543,
0.0111959307,
0.1045408398,
0.3512656093,
-0.0557259619,
-0.1480932236,
-0.3657770455,
-0.1232935563,
0.0778264701,
-0.6331305504,
0.3012161255,
0.1805658937,
0.5731868744,
-0.0657396615,
0.390892297,
-0.5160964727,
0.7670086622,
0.1419632733,
0.1561669111,
-0.1155456826,
-0.2435994744,
-0.3561564386,
0.0411485545,
0.5104824305,
0.2265106589,
0.1427391469,
-0.4460940957,
-0.1337375194,
0.2041175812,
-0.3398830891,
-0.6147576571,
-0.2730863392,
0.261654079,
-0.4878288805,
-0.5696858764,
-0.0461169444,
-0.8886998296,
-0.1675519794,
-0.3728857338,
-0.1326645315,
-0.2682197392,
-0.1828471869,
0.0588454641,
-0.1087369621,
0.1345287412,
0.2413097322,
-1.1399009228,
0.1613158584,
0.646628201,
0.3872922659,
0.3825091124,
-0.129530549,
-0.752294302,
0.0773396641,
-0.2637114227,
0.8250132799,
-0.8783531189,
-0.3135562837,
0.1683035344,
0.0443090871,
-0.0419158973,
-0.5698132515,
0.5763788819,
-0.4443374574,
0.3902623057,
-0.5868498683,
-0.4126543105,
-0.1248965859,
0.0058190823,
-0.3956858218,
1.0234731436,
0.3683474362,
-0.5755349994,
0.6849210262,
-0.3786748052,
-0.3689169288,
-0.22487773,
-0.4018327594,
-0.2789963484,
0.4274176657,
0.2400795519,
0.6164857745,
0.014693574,
0.6521162391,
-0.4217280447,
-0.2383039594,
-0.041279681,
-0.4103811085,
0.8950107098,
-0.0717495903,
-0.4457058012,
0.2010928243,
-0.8615604043,
0.1559518725,
-0.1324166954,
-0.6015179157,
-0.1211159527,
0.3751110435,
0.0188274495,
0.4929516017,
-0.1250345111,
-0.528226912,
0.1617407799,
-0.6411709189,
0.6644254327,
0.7018431425,
0.1649344563,
0.4753980935,
-0.0873521939,
0.0393677577,
0.1606332064,
0.092487976,
0.0251836069,
-0.2592524588,
-1.0464001894,
-0.3884653449,
0.5161710978,
0.3224003911,
-0.702246964,
0.65300107,
-0.0248848479,
-0.1533483267,
-0.0645783544,
0.1003872752,
0.4065250754,
0.5007961988,
0.3859901428,
0.1218343079,
-0.6868750453,
-0.9023977518,
-0.1384206712,
-0.2968954146,
0.0323120207,
0.0074564251,
0.1404676437,
-0.0628539398,
0.8582088351,
-0.2308819592,
-0.143892169,
-0.3620701134,
-0.0180466361,
0.2465182394,
0.4548361599,
0.4714684784,
-0.6429938078,
-0.1846659034,
-0.2486716211,
-0.6904276609,
-0.2793545127,
-0.1481204331,
-0.0994903967,
0.3264214098,
0.93148911,
-0.623814404,
0.3015975356,
0.3396120369,
-0.6373795867,
0.0965628773,
-0.0568793453,
-0.3276673555,
-1.0196530819,
-0.0650893003,
-0.1433440149,
-0.6546964049,
-0.6257326007,
-0.0299451184,
-0.1411700696,
0.1536287814,
-0.7198642492,
0.1167807877,
-0.521949172,
-0.1347851157,
-0.0648768768,
-0.0925074294,
-0.1400972903,
0.5321447849,
0.143945232,
0.1871498674,
0.4480104446,
-0.4459944963,
0.1551354527,
-0.0400607064,
-0.1752662212,
0.2989217043,
-0.2726704478,
-0.2540311515,
-0.3023906052,
0.2317113876,
-0.9637453556,
-0.107431151,
0.1734247655,
-0.206847474,
0.2436811775,
-0.3292580247,
-0.4788700044,
0.1434310526,
-0.3623432815,
0.390265435,
0.367672503,
-0.6961598396,
0.2248508334,
0.1085151508,
-0.0203427095,
-0.2382122874,
-0.4741894007,
-0.0143355587,
-0.3092993796,
-0.42290923,
0.4177587628,
0.2885449529,
-0.3475375473,
0.2359603643,
-0.0032311575,
0.2002174258,
0.153703019,
0.2300548553,
-0.3147036433,
-0.3751832247,
-0.1852262467,
0.5761676431,
-0.289386481,
0.0724784583,
-0.2211750299,
0.4886896908,
-0.1801915318,
-0.5148707628,
-0.6242055297,
0.6898568273,
0.6862170696,
0.0899006277,
0.4790090024,
0.1818361878,
-0.5347089171,
-0.4905649424,
-0.2416971177,
-0.2535906732,
-0.480160743,
0.1551241428,
-0.3063368201,
-1.1075652838,
0.5019508004,
-0.3794933558,
0.0122888768,
0.3884422779,
0.7050424814,
-0.0468244553,
0.9668337703,
0.7211540341,
0.1437041312,
0.5259487629,
-0.024493074,
0.1325684786,
-0.4896844625,
-0.3957132399,
-0.4553565383,
-0.3786153793,
-0.8322857022,
-0.4379994571,
0.0943696573,
0.3656387627,
-0.1106387153,
0.0282915495,
-0.3881670833,
0.71972996,
0.7228808999,
-0.0337347127,
0.0956429169,
0.1823869348,
-0.5550167561,
-0.0870208219,
-0.7458681464,
-0.2839043438,
0.5550838709,
0.301268965,
0.5096697211,
0.3269051611,
0.8691640496,
0.138018012,
-0.1277373582,
-0.749078393,
0.5844765306,
-0.3934258223,
-0.2293238193,
-0.414830178,
-0.417046845,
-0.6971607804,
0.4413599372,
-0.0113267219,
-0.9288036823,
0.7438259721,
0.1317788213,
-0.3779048026,
0.2869807482,
-0.6806248426,
0.7075026035,
-0.0039512753,
-0.4563103914,
0.237922892,
-0.7842024565,
0.2276013494,
0.1178379059,
0.0824415758,
-0.1939442605,
0.0853802413,
0.6161497235,
-0.4258161187,
1.0579733849,
-0.6024870276,
0.1699787825,
0.1324520558,
0.3349671066,
0.2820379436,
0.5540629029,
-0.077934593,
0.0533126369,
0.2089819312,
-0.3581289649,
-0.5351199508,
0.7894921899,
-0.4056062698,
-0.5311970115,
-0.5036361814,
-0.3693358898,
-0.3706219196,
0.3594577909,
0.1605342627,
0.373811394,
-0.1622837633,
0.5748313665,
0.5291410685,
0.1446346045,
0.9406888485,
0.3544921875,
-0.0002319484,
-0.3746227622,
0.601918757,
-0.1183879972,
0.010509843,
0.6091113687,
0.3276509941,
-0.6867499352,
-0.444883287,
-0.4875506759,
0.2378259152,
-0.8025900126,
-0.1136567146,
-0.45376724,
-0.1466771811,
-0.3028728366,
-0.4239150882,
-0.3273933232,
-0.6686438918,
-0.4437187314,
-0.1112300307,
-0.022418391,
0.5404932499,
-0.2502955794,
0.2568529248,
-0.3728590012,
0.1368956119,
0.2627178729,
0.3530568779,
-0.3364448547,
-0.3293500543,
0.2381449044,
0.0179723091,
-0.0487500988,
-0.7972431183,
0.1345524937,
0.4817237258,
0.5482693315,
0.8458713889,
0.2543594837,
0.7799398899,
-0.6432321668,
0.6856822968,
0.0295432732,
-0.9414485693,
0.5288183093,
-0.5278713107,
0.1766663194,
0.9390582442,
-0.0746397823,
-0.5364876986,
-0.6106366515,
-0.6099566221,
-0.9363538623,
0.7613277435,
0.1208633035,
0.1567499787,
-0.1904291809,
0.4957885742,
0.0030681121,
0.1110165194,
-0.6020705104,
0.0385775901,
-0.0180926882,
-0.2088720351,
-0.0315806381,
-0.7809278369,
-0.1385602057,
-0.4997222126,
0.4004888237,
-0.1270287633,
0.249680385,
0.1495775282,
0.0328702368,
-0.1868844479,
0.3504347205,
0.8160012364,
0.7118939757,
-0.3202263117,
0.6122829318,
0.0300840251,
0.1522168666,
0.2878118157,
0.0563039631,
-0.198427245,
0.2679881752,
0.4932524562,
0.4659475684,
0.5836961865,
-0.3007178903,
0.3700588942,
-0.3292140663,
-0.4011316597,
-0.2781156003,
0.0065744263,
0.311373055,
0.4049555659,
0.0225586612,
-0.1468761712,
-0.0667941049,
-0.2058545649,
0.5419766903,
0.3908123672,
-0.4151421785,
-0.3338449001,
0.7096714973,
0.2296567112,
-0.1338255405,
0.5201551318,
-0.2032987326,
-0.3325383961,
0.3752658963,
0.6272046566,
0.8103502393,
-0.320389986,
0.2635469735,
0.0516658984,
0.3089234531,
0.0626165941,
0.4292930663,
-0.3131024539,
-0.4638696909,
-0.2506841123,
-0.8781368732,
-0.2397944629,
0.2121635675,
-0.6003437638,
0.4031318128,
-0.6987420917,
0.1555629373,
0.2445032746,
-0.2785700858,
-0.1512185186,
0.1616589278,
0.0453144833,
0.8548856378,
-1.1679042578,
0.7507801056,
0.8211824894,
-0.0688881725,
-0.5741752386,
0.1261232644,
0.1188097,
-0.5056757927,
0.5234717727,
0.2396776527,
-0.0230073091,
0.1080169529,
-0.0997550562,
-0.7269984484,
0.79100281,
0.71719414,
-0.4366044402,
-0.1220893785,
0.3443183303,
0.4368996322,
-0.1327922791,
-0.069363758,
0.5665804148,
0.1233233511,
0.1995832771,
-0.5316101313,
0.283262372,
-0.031025853,
0.1818978339,
0.3958953619,
-0.5634339452,
0.8293855786,
0.0314899459,
-0.2258365303,
-0.0770413131,
0.6698865294,
0.0994720161,
0.2735247016,
0.6965133548,
0.7407623529,
0.6324411035,
-0.0896086171,
0.5266108513,
-0.339533776,
0.4613751471,
0.923178792,
-0.156819731,
0.9198898077,
0.8327645659,
-0.0850017965,
0.6493173838,
0.9298683405,
0.4129369557,
0.7808316946,
0.1093726158,
-0.7340009212,
-0.6142370105,
-0.215977639,
-0.3040392101,
0.6781677008,
0.2463334203,
-0.6648676395,
-0.8728311062,
-0.2715040743,
0.3004988432,
0.1323915571,
0.1422537863,
0.7697414756,
0.1542862952,
-0.597633481,
0.7887280583,
0.3864673972,
0.130387634,
-0.2918533981,
-0.1126444042,
-0.4927783906,
0.1898391396,
-0.3523891568,
-0.3309940994,
0.4118038416,
-0.0452215672,
-0.3260584772,
-0.4019069672,
0.4432116449,
-0.388561964,
-0.6475032568,
0.2611590326,
0.5459792614,
-0.0423813276,
0.1015269905,
-0.4694779515,
-0.1247441173,
0.0659523532,
-0.3918270171,
0.4574852884,
0.6141344309,
-0.2633300424,
0.3282664716,
0.8296494484,
-0.0421261452,
-0.0691746622,
0.2079189271,
1.4175493717,
-0.7032803297,
-0.5793742537,
-1.0441095829,
0.62867558,
0.1007065624,
-0.0300902203,
0.4758266211,
0.6653710604,
0.7999475598,
0.0603657179,
0.426687628,
-0.1323119849,
0.2401030362,
-0.6438401341,
0.5289075971,
-0.5471255183,
0.3772628605,
-0.090926975,
-0.9899789095,
-0.8599547148,
0.5330376029,
-0.2402904332,
-0.0231152661,
0.7569975853,
0.9054748416,
-0.2878555357,
-0.1653905809,
0.5943441987,
-0.0935874507,
0.3647398353,
0.6307494044,
0.8737226129,
0.1373277009,
0.199249208,
-0.6249907017,
-0.4292865396,
-0.3359375596,
-0.995138526,
-0.9682453871,
-0.4794025421,
-0.2513948977,
-0.2934437394,
-0.0494041182,
0.7286038995,
0.6758210659,
-0.8726524115,
-0.0684760362,
-0.4623422027,
0.3477431536,
-0.0324345715,
-0.2497785538,
0.5218215585,
-0.5343291759,
-0.6112944484,
0.7383326888,
0.3039235473,
-0.3132392764,
-0.1569349617,
0.2156829536,
-0.444090277,
-0.1722893864,
0.8409619331,
0.3298179507,
-0.8061887622,
-0.4999428093,
-0.1334197819,
0.1879227459,
-0.0425405055,
0.7732943892,
-0.6736372113,
0.3379630446,
0.5644490719,
0.3767099679,
-0.0324029252,
0.3566242158,
0.089325957,
-1.2896068096,
0.6275786161,
0.2529576123,
0.4500368237,
0.2168870121,
-0.4482572675,
0.1477045566,
0.6462487578,
-0.3645385802,
-1.1398338079,
0.3822986782,
-0.9450983405,
-0.3692903817,
1.3173763752,
-0.0274036136,
-0.3243114352,
-0.1632968932,
-0.007922424,
0.189996779,
-0.3080036938,
0.4403024018,
0.325137347,
-0.5683084726,
-0.3343271017,
-0.1792902499,
0.6912783384,
0.5169453025,
-0.6034986377,
0.3493719697,
0.6618030071,
0.3282657266,
-0.1888534129,
0.7220756412,
-0.1920625716,
0.2357038558,
0.0554337427,
-0.2370152324,
-0.1094852164,
-0.494410336,
-0.5937643647,
0.4833540022,
0.4000077844,
-0.365850389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09125v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09125v1 | Recall, Expand and Multi-Candidate Cross-Encode: Fast and Accurate Ultra-Fine Entity Typing | 2022-12-18T16:42:52 | 2022-12-18T16:42:52 | Chengyue Jiang, Wenyang Hui, Yong Jiang, Xiaobin Wang, Pengjun Xie, Kewei Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Ultra-fine entity typing (UFET) predicts extremely free-formed types (e.g.,
president, politician) of a given entity mention (e.g., Joe Biden) in context.
State-of-the-art (SOTA) methods use the cross-encoder (CE) based architecture.
CE concatenates the mention (and its context) with each type and feeds the
pairs into a pretrained language model (PLM) to score their relevance. It
brings deeper interaction between mention and types to reach better performance
but has to perform N (type set size) forward passes to infer types of a single
mention. CE is therefore very slow in inference when the type set is large
(e.g., N = 10k for UFET). To this end, we propose to perform entity typing in a
recall-expand-filter manner. The recall and expand stages prune the large type
set and generate K (K is typically less than 256) most relevant type candidates
for each mention. At the filter stage, we use a novel model called MCCE to
concurrently encode and score these K candidates in only one forward pass to
obtain the final type prediction. We investigate different variants of MCCE and
extensive experiments show that MCCE under our paradigm reaches SOTA
performance on ultra-fine entity typing and is thousands of times faster than
the cross-encoder. We also found MCCE is very effective in fine-grained (130
types) and coarse-grained (9 types) entity typing. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/modelscope/AdaSeq/tree/master/examples/MCCE}. | [
-0.6781067848,
-0.5655349493,
0.5344025493,
-0.0090610366,
-0.3482545316,
0.1499600112,
-0.1393410712,
-0.6393660307,
0.3015675545,
0.6773009896,
-0.2554831505,
-0.4182648361,
-0.563195467,
0.1498274207,
-0.5424799323,
0.8880305886,
0.0155542595,
-0.0129804891,
0.00730919,
-0.090135552,
-0.0525684059,
-0.6984549165,
-0.606074214,
0.0548000485,
0.0688931942,
0.4831187129,
0.4927946627,
0.4486237466,
0.5353292227,
0.1815995127,
-0.0852449983,
0.2937042713,
-0.4356268346,
-0.0201509446,
-0.1601088792,
-0.393389374,
-0.385771811,
-0.2304482162,
0.7289515734,
0.3150867522,
-0.2184215784,
0.2590520978,
-0.1616428792,
0.4387085438,
-0.7933700681,
-0.0080352863,
-0.8943352103,
-0.1091630608,
-0.324188441,
-0.3178675473,
-0.5579655766,
-0.1830925494,
0.2838254869,
-0.4203223586,
0.1732754707,
0.3501366973,
0.961610496,
0.0822027847,
-0.5804648399,
-0.1208491176,
-0.9180068374,
0.4537540376,
-0.5314432383,
0.7467195392,
-0.0919751599,
0.3275981843,
-0.1542425603,
-0.7890293002,
-0.6039780378,
-0.2415113002,
0.0035229365,
-0.0332238302,
0.2050649524,
0.4655313194,
0.2344616801,
0.5579175949,
-0.3463878036,
0.0180792119,
-0.0930687487,
-0.1813456416,
0.3287295103,
-0.1380289197,
0.3022146821,
-0.1373702139,
-0.4778670967,
0.0878801346,
-0.8569640517,
0.0069373455,
-0.0646651685,
0.11407841,
0.3993600011,
0.5897017121,
-0.3607755005,
0.5525317192,
0.1888283342,
0.2399841994,
-0.0592301488,
-0.3698084652,
-0.3336873353,
0.0285343938,
0.7304409146,
-0.0326905288,
0.2597299814,
-0.1542427093,
-0.2440437227,
0.0884614438,
0.1001804546,
-0.8262481093,
-0.1297656298,
0.0044012382,
-0.4877900183,
0.1276573241,
0.1011928469,
-1.0382306576,
-0.1377217472,
-0.0566546954,
0.526322484,
-0.5269608498,
-0.0111905541,
0.1513043046,
0.1318763644,
-0.2151217461,
0.0645826459,
-0.8013575673,
0.3643656969,
0.2456484288,
0.3906646073,
0.0368380025,
-0.1832205206,
-0.6934357285,
0.2116057128,
-0.0485801362,
1.0739361048,
-0.9622020125,
-0.3238241971,
0.0256120916,
-0.3551038802,
-0.259249717,
-0.4688341916,
0.7108508348,
-0.9703958035,
-0.2216438949,
-0.1573172957,
-0.7632153034,
-0.2546226382,
-0.1145832017,
-0.9672273397,
1.1211689711,
0.1013878509,
-0.8182058334,
0.6417360306,
-0.8844357133,
-0.2237757742,
0.0688316226,
-0.3212804794,
-0.3771453202,
0.1483160406,
0.4755046964,
0.6153769493,
-0.4378410876,
0.2262717932,
-0.4344789982,
-0.4543902278,
0.0661213249,
-0.1493297815,
0.3598505557,
0.20363684,
-0.5068052411,
-0.0122470437,
-0.9932975769,
-0.0982625186,
-0.0612645932,
-0.5374726653,
-0.3726307452,
-0.2821400166,
0.0256270338,
0.4450549185,
0.0238537192,
-0.6992823482,
0.0476396345,
-0.0148928175,
0.4716256857,
0.3392356634,
0.1826602221,
0.4276830852,
0.0676306784,
0.2502027452,
0.2447550893,
0.0424785949,
-0.1003348306,
-0.4296462834,
-0.6979011893,
-0.3994218707,
0.7616109252,
0.6227334738,
-0.7860623002,
0.2854298353,
-0.4900235236,
-0.3687966466,
-0.7943741679,
0.0348101258,
0.4865534306,
0.2618111968,
0.6289340854,
-0.2705140412,
-0.7830705047,
-0.7965355515,
-0.4144570827,
-0.1701466143,
0.0139639871,
0.382365942,
0.5889880657,
-0.1759753227,
0.6663540006,
-0.2365649045,
0.0458599739,
-0.1132385954,
0.1128680259,
-0.2640821636,
0.4856985211,
0.2312717289,
-0.9108758569,
-0.3443292677,
-0.1173149422,
-0.4556309581,
0.4394610226,
-0.1863480657,
-0.1507053822,
0.1463339627,
0.5831286907,
-0.73615098,
0.4041149914,
0.2777232826,
-0.3846093714,
0.4131992757,
-0.1054748893,
0.4289173484,
-0.8703189492,
-0.0125264162,
-0.0561284088,
-0.2583798766,
-0.4504849613,
0.2312128544,
0.239263013,
-0.033638753,
-0.3890552223,
0.4408142567,
-0.7977460623,
-0.2892507613,
0.2058396786,
0.0168754365,
-0.2074908316,
0.435803771,
0.1794076711,
0.8891934156,
0.4822081029,
-0.8456014395,
-0.1194674745,
0.1601989716,
-0.2985392511,
0.5545091629,
-0.2891254127,
0.236188367,
-0.1610059887,
0.3656224012,
-0.8422980309,
0.1711691171,
-0.4486870766,
-0.3381563127,
0.6035599709,
0.0602235124,
-0.6302903295,
-0.6595447659,
-0.0776604339,
0.3350131512,
0.2746486664,
-0.6520488858,
0.7261419892,
0.4392299056,
0.0995812863,
-0.4802894294,
-0.5187703967,
-0.0239821076,
-0.0502340272,
-0.3884379566,
0.4480132759,
0.0019794283,
0.2932581902,
0.1802001745,
-0.2237206548,
-0.1939529777,
-0.0620155521,
0.0215665251,
0.3933655322,
-0.3388732374,
-0.0406536572,
0.207368955,
0.1290741414,
-0.3510245085,
-0.4733783603,
0.540702045,
-0.189292863,
-0.1451676637,
-0.4193680584,
0.5455518961,
0.6440067291,
-0.5266007781,
0.7248369455,
0.6274101138,
-0.5931854844,
0.0357076414,
-0.7189661264,
-0.254127413,
-0.3430954814,
0.5810634494,
-0.9542161226,
-1.3157287836,
0.4727874696,
-0.187877506,
0.2443196476,
0.7480427027,
0.2161000073,
0.0206825435,
0.8638592362,
0.5569161177,
0.0046043135,
0.3892140388,
-0.4013424218,
0.179271102,
-1.1752068996,
-0.2447987199,
-0.5663220286,
-0.1424667388,
-0.6591688395,
-0.5486129522,
0.0412761979,
0.3042408824,
-0.1569554508,
0.666039288,
-0.3933493495,
0.3098414242,
0.6722570062,
0.1144699454,
0.4358294606,
-0.0493058078,
-0.5235899091,
-0.000909063,
-0.7376684546,
-0.4707262814,
1.4645061493,
0.2919664085,
0.4776104987,
-0.1891824156,
1.1342623234,
0.0632811487,
0.3400588334,
-0.434989959,
0.7024736404,
-0.601804316,
-0.8558053374,
-0.4764040411,
-0.3245233893,
-0.5822609067,
0.1403826475,
-0.4723579586,
-0.7750182152,
0.5191568732,
0.2541112602,
-0.8472658992,
0.637686789,
-0.4986060858,
0.6791840792,
0.1031884477,
0.1168613285,
-0.3164349794,
-0.6435597539,
0.4741377234,
-0.0279682186,
0.0114805931,
0.0287536159,
-0.0616318174,
0.8526825309,
-0.0475743562,
0.3435726166,
-0.0977407396,
0.23900868,
0.5460210443,
0.13539204,
0.6866329312,
0.263387084,
-0.0321234539,
0.2642849684,
-0.0727364644,
-0.3791635036,
-0.5205069184,
0.6813615561,
-0.5757474303,
-0.2806251049,
-0.0791302994,
-0.280251503,
-0.3415999711,
0.1727829129,
0.5036718845,
0.4226470888,
-0.4372227788,
0.1996893436,
1.0196720362,
0.098284781,
0.4326423109,
0.3321191072,
0.1256245971,
-0.369879216,
0.7395678163,
0.2732071877,
0.1899094135,
0.8778586388,
-0.346060276,
-0.4977031648,
-0.5593335032,
-0.7146163583,
0.1461446583,
-0.5395143032,
-0.2612420321,
-1.1535121202,
-0.2957440019,
-0.4715595543,
0.0535466373,
-0.6130481958,
-0.5380554199,
-0.2429712564,
-0.1337754875,
0.1641257554,
0.4665015638,
0.1019343063,
0.3254118264,
-0.8318690062,
0.4230834544,
0.5185624361,
0.4512316883,
-0.2066604942,
-0.4741292,
-0.0348242745,
-0.1853548139,
-0.1254269779,
-0.9027980566,
-0.0662761778,
0.4139266908,
0.6208463907,
0.4137660563,
-0.1140598804,
0.7744649649,
-0.6373172402,
0.5060939193,
0.0282112621,
-0.8302639723,
0.4566394389,
0.1824877262,
-0.0630703792,
0.9137162566,
0.468904227,
-0.3790464103,
-0.3249747753,
-0.7962172031,
-0.6693201065,
0.5291984677,
0.1843805611,
-0.2880278826,
-0.2106204629,
0.5089176297,
0.0848650336,
0.2643999457,
-0.3557481468,
-0.405087024,
-0.0408589952,
-0.0714368895,
-0.1218072399,
-0.6724685431,
0.2424200922,
-0.14276205,
0.656916976,
0.003317087,
0.6781770587,
0.4500858784,
-0.3471000791,
0.1096076667,
0.592037499,
0.4856521785,
0.2423384637,
-0.3644382656,
0.2591258585,
0.1635465324,
-0.4713022709,
-0.0110357981,
0.449093461,
-0.3271152079,
0.1603238583,
0.0265586302,
0.9486985803,
0.6842211485,
-0.4869011939,
0.2179460824,
0.0214737188,
-0.0565629788,
0.1030654907,
-0.1227287054,
0.2352142781,
0.0575790592,
0.0962778255,
0.1129392236,
0.7559956312,
-0.7264190316,
0.5461438894,
0.3015761077,
-0.3825218081,
-0.2432278544,
0.9201598763,
0.4063499272,
-0.0277693346,
0.4996778369,
-0.3713803291,
-0.5178647637,
0.4270997047,
0.7247180939,
0.9561675191,
-0.4938548505,
0.192339167,
0.4851768315,
0.2738543451,
-0.2293986678,
0.5695515871,
-0.0374463908,
-0.6065179706,
-0.3727911711,
-0.8354901075,
-0.1334677041,
0.0289312527,
-0.5769518614,
0.0683083311,
-0.4676084518,
-0.2633149922,
0.0974182412,
0.1756445915,
-1.0122426748,
0.3978301585,
0.0559929982,
1.2047903538,
-0.7476322651,
0.8435255289,
0.9026951194,
-0.4505349398,
-0.8652076125,
-0.0862870365,
-0.2373775542,
-0.7906205654,
0.308329314,
0.1453865021,
0.1821301579,
0.338822484,
-0.0384586379,
-1.1747694016,
1.0443416834,
0.260253489,
-0.9319352508,
-0.4381287992,
-0.0379452407,
0.2866138518,
-0.6980749965,
0.654419899,
0.9448282719,
0.3420822322,
0.1390457451,
-1.1087062359,
0.2036277354,
0.1280706078,
0.3844473958,
0.4723015428,
-0.7504585981,
0.664691925,
-0.3187154233,
-0.2696229517,
-0.1229697987,
0.9004002213,
0.316244334,
0.05602438,
0.6896455884,
0.7839980125,
0.8268630505,
0.170706898,
0.7966296673,
-0.320102632,
0.3114173412,
1.2620192766,
-0.1488128304,
1.0122210979,
0.3749710917,
-0.0574910194,
0.6372241378,
0.6614060998,
0.1548114419,
0.402944684,
-0.042561695,
-0.1473720074,
-0.3777886629,
-0.0374926552,
-0.3149399459,
0.4403051734,
0.318636924,
-0.4367989898,
-0.0790547207,
-0.0370612703,
-0.0628042296,
0.0587377027,
-0.4285711646,
0.6194279194,
0.0773386434,
-0.59180516,
0.3046149015,
-0.0857647285,
0.7365853786,
-0.178711012,
-0.1599933505,
-0.0773514584,
-0.0361424908,
-0.0243501589,
-0.6808232665,
0.1279703528,
-0.2824385762,
-0.1265933812,
0.2653590143,
0.7877607346,
-0.60394454,
-0.2490122318,
0.3475102782,
0.2381470203,
0.103058666,
-0.3928358853,
-0.5973793864,
-0.3278063834,
-0.0696980208,
-0.4141417444,
0.1771697849,
0.7000814676,
-0.4052550495,
0.6147151589,
0.5458328724,
0.1069143414,
0.4462170899,
0.0710332692,
0.7879282832,
-0.7146670222,
-0.5845913291,
-0.5792524815,
0.3194934726,
-0.1976441145,
-0.3515211046,
0.2804752588,
0.805239737,
0.8049963117,
-0.1066810191,
0.5377994776,
-0.0068650609,
0.5450789928,
-0.5365617275,
0.5225127935,
-0.4472051859,
-0.0570525527,
-0.3231027722,
-0.9553679824,
-0.1507505625,
0.0969101414,
0.0270881914,
0.0556799658,
0.9612972736,
0.4456080794,
0.034287747,
0.0386902355,
0.4769097865,
0.1018141061,
0.102961354,
0.8753029108,
0.3469597101,
-0.5993981957,
0.8394852877,
-0.1709855795,
-0.4017529786,
-0.5800926089,
-0.3802023232,
-0.8911321759,
-0.6598832607,
-0.2906542718,
-0.1685905904,
0.0459157303,
0.6786743999,
1.0063091516,
-0.8721471429,
0.2079206556,
0.0645976961,
-0.0685239136,
-0.2523220778,
-0.151181832,
0.4054736197,
-0.105380401,
-0.6244529486,
0.1451744884,
0.5136663914,
-0.0170755982,
-0.008885961,
0.0620230734,
-0.5674951673,
0.2944254577,
0.5993408561,
0.344602555,
-0.6810805798,
-0.2627786398,
0.1330468506,
-0.0941436514,
0.0655352473,
0.9153560996,
-0.7097324133,
0.4985818565,
0.2562360168,
0.9004508257,
0.6956486106,
-0.1936659962,
0.3242008984,
-0.2698646188,
-0.2159777135,
0.2565616369,
0.5312746167,
0.1305534244,
-0.7620105743,
0.4749787152,
0.3104424477,
-0.5409103632,
-0.626304388,
0.2555452287,
-0.8105594516,
0.0810442567,
0.8686692715,
-0.1600610465,
-0.2433505505,
-0.1155185178,
-0.1046017185,
0.5050298572,
-0.6674852371,
0.621109426,
0.4766125083,
-0.1909228563,
-0.259524107,
-0.4441688657,
0.6830012798,
0.3954193294,
-0.750346899,
-0.1212154999,
0.2308013886,
0.3620188236,
0.2716675103,
1.0039088726,
-0.3941910565,
0.5457952619,
0.1184370071,
0.3977037072,
0.1265560091,
-0.6658087373,
-0.0205477886,
0.2579191625,
-0.0188909788,
-0.409858793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.11126v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.11126v2 | Chatbots in a Botnet World | 2022-12-18T16:08:40 | 2022-12-22T17:20:36 | Forrest McKee, David Noever | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Question-and-answer formats provide a novel experimental platform for
investigating cybersecurity questions. Unlike previous chatbots, the latest
ChatGPT model from OpenAI supports an advanced understanding of complex coding
questions. The research demonstrates thirteen coding tasks that generally
qualify as stages in the MITRE ATT&CK framework, ranging from credential access
to defense evasion. With varying success, the experimental prompts generate
examples of keyloggers, logic bombs, obfuscated worms, and payment-fulfilled
ransomware. The empirical results illustrate cases that support the broad gain
of functionality, including self-replication and self-modification, evasion,
and strategic understanding of complex cybersecurity goals. One surprising
feature of ChatGPT as a language-only model centers on its ability to spawn
coding approaches that yield images that obfuscate or embed executable
programming steps or links. | [
-0.1283123046,
-1.4067450762,
0.1935010105,
-0.1162298918,
0.1053303108,
0.382535547,
0.2332088798,
-0.5339853764,
0.0133075761,
0.696849823,
-0.3381118476,
-0.0919003338,
-0.5283186436,
-0.170072943,
-0.7121094465,
1.274263382,
0.2378812134,
-0.1189406291,
0.077480562,
0.4293504357,
-0.3259369731,
-0.9486786127,
-0.8966651559,
-0.1003152952,
0.3703078926,
0.430872649,
0.7658036947,
0.1927748173,
0.8851920366,
0.2498097122,
0.115523003,
-0.2892434001,
-0.3970161378,
0.0531455502,
0.085218966,
-0.8241971135,
-0.3609670103,
0.0470140055,
0.0180363636,
0.2971243858,
-0.2154669166,
0.0160957687,
-0.1571825892,
0.3034583628,
-0.325656563,
-0.014645352,
-0.7274405956,
-0.0981404632,
-0.0329890959,
-0.3913565278,
-0.6032865047,
-0.2239437252,
0.1424314529,
-0.3491794765,
0.2849770486,
0.1428262591,
0.5334117413,
-0.0289468672,
-0.3703110218,
-0.4962593317,
-0.8018042445,
0.1440162659,
-0.2759849727,
0.1268044859,
0.3834994733,
0.655764699,
-0.4153427482,
-0.8923920393,
-0.4939593673,
-0.3276375234,
-0.0748477727,
0.2099283189,
-0.611577034,
0.1668923944,
0.2075592875,
0.2829915583,
-0.8896247149,
-0.0901245326,
-0.7909722924,
-0.1978184879,
0.4729542732,
-0.0026797599,
0.5171055198,
-0.3177722692,
-0.316835016,
-0.1494211555,
-0.6349075437,
0.2294616699,
0.6889742613,
0.0903427303,
-0.3803841472,
0.7062025666,
-0.1312133074,
0.4704988003,
-0.2976202071,
0.338513881,
-0.2145372778,
-0.1922539771,
-0.1635712832,
-0.058658801,
0.5616161227,
0.0602187812,
0.3719119132,
-0.1907688081,
-0.047939755,
0.0961365104,
0.6675285101,
-0.6220439076,
-0.8201501966,
0.6748728156,
-0.6118670106,
-0.7192234397,
0.1966390312,
-0.6780548096,
-0.6256579757,
0.0571995601,
0.46167925,
-0.3290922642,
-0.2599252164,
0.2828473747,
-0.6035077572,
0.4087334573,
0.4498435557,
-0.3078309,
0.4539274275,
0.6642290354,
0.7763531208,
0.0545332134,
0.0256785583,
-0.4095951021,
-0.3262063563,
-0.1034131423,
0.7320640683,
-0.545384407,
-0.3674621582,
-0.012534135,
-0.0791125149,
0.0579861067,
-0.1398795247,
-0.1650819927,
-0.7349220514,
0.4083412588,
0.4094922245,
-0.270460546,
-0.2194301635,
0.5603613257,
-0.4643417299,
0.5680411458,
-0.0927234441,
-0.6473039389,
-0.1379089206,
-1.1735415459,
-0.2458491176,
0.2618493736,
-0.0003855468,
-0.0926444754,
-0.2009218633,
-0.0653338581,
0.4398001134,
-0.1768024117,
-0.0460894108,
-0.1747483015,
-0.1282675266,
0.787868917,
-0.5696311593,
0.8541383147,
0.1891760379,
-0.1632202119,
0.2554332614,
-0.5827671289,
0.0364224352,
0.5103609562,
-0.1544644237,
0.1477278173,
0.1782752723,
0.1714805514,
-0.0849597454,
0.1524995565,
-0.8059151173,
0.4028774798,
-0.2833153009,
0.9498814344,
0.531637907,
0.3086292744,
0.276120007,
-0.4549615085,
0.7870320082,
-0.0738786757,
0.6172984242,
-0.5230646729,
-0.8514541388,
-0.5938550234,
-0.0987048149,
0.2368347347,
1.043954134,
-0.6723637581,
-0.1559140235,
-0.0210942868,
-0.7708476782,
-0.3156432807,
-0.378133744,
0.3082490265,
0.2494461834,
0.2369766384,
-0.3894555569,
-0.316952765,
-0.9846845269,
0.0788777247,
-0.2945097983,
-0.1276798397,
0.1405642033,
0.7521184683,
-0.0426142067,
0.8416313529,
-0.6524567604,
0.1704046279,
-0.4111647904,
0.2913063169,
0.1703003943,
0.659815073,
0.2143377066,
-1.2540272474,
-0.3226350248,
0.0447771139,
-0.5047843456,
0.3597000241,
-0.2723546028,
0.0575404949,
-0.2293180376,
0.5735726953,
-0.4273146093,
0.7592864037,
0.4193471372,
-0.1375143081,
0.6492403746,
-0.337767154,
0.4000215828,
-1.0623233318,
0.2364614606,
-0.4983204007,
-0.5791371465,
-1.0892945528,
0.5549696684,
0.1080986336,
-0.6917393804,
-0.6242187023,
0.3924004436,
0.014197614,
0.1172276214,
-0.3211707473,
0.2856120467,
-0.3398637772,
0.7360022664,
-0.127873227,
0.8563180566,
0.5040051341,
-0.4117001295,
0.7569720745,
0.2345873266,
-0.1268271208,
0.4838783145,
-1.2577570677,
0.4343784451,
-0.1421954185,
0.3689292669,
-1.2235146761,
-0.600317657,
0.6591334343,
-0.9194074273,
0.0578466691,
-0.3938095272,
-0.6355182528,
-0.3397231996,
-0.2852361202,
0.523917973,
0.9028192759,
-0.0388225988,
0.3433952034,
0.4584445059,
-0.0588075444,
-0.3038760424,
-0.6233504415,
0.2231399715,
-0.1619527191,
-0.5726559162,
-0.0498680435,
-0.0681328326,
-0.3122794628,
-0.2156279236,
0.1789191514,
-0.3027565777,
0.3883346021,
0.4497082531,
0.2529416382,
-0.1459168494,
-0.1343612522,
-0.4688366354,
-0.087770842,
0.0654684231,
-0.4158158004,
0.859602809,
-0.1352075189,
-0.7618407607,
-0.3852003813,
0.6486136317,
0.1969133765,
-0.3028874099,
0.4058148563,
0.199423939,
-0.4267147779,
0.0900404006,
-0.3731431365,
-0.2342172116,
-0.4646049738,
0.4158468544,
-0.3527831137,
-0.9621140361,
0.867208004,
0.2036408931,
0.279737711,
0.1626153439,
0.5827162862,
-0.1595890969,
0.8257872462,
0.6118596196,
0.1318600476,
0.4494560361,
-0.104324989,
0.4431842566,
-0.2803530395,
-0.2399792522,
-0.5967519283,
-0.1183919534,
-0.6480103135,
-0.3141628802,
0.5529515743,
0.1674460024,
-0.3797364533,
0.7292767763,
-0.5428727865,
0.6329060197,
0.7312917709,
0.4785306454,
0.1154643446,
-0.2825642824,
0.2795698345,
0.5857279897,
-0.7610361576,
-0.5204511881,
1.1300137043,
0.2798996568,
0.6060624719,
0.2271534353,
0.3856641054,
0.7619501352,
0.0479287058,
-0.5858402848,
0.4029244184,
0.1683604866,
-0.8965488672,
-0.3543732762,
-0.1097004265,
-1.4062455893,
-0.0429139175,
0.1480593532,
-1.1897159815,
-0.2642365694,
0.3830191493,
-0.3183944523,
0.3562995195,
-0.6651806831,
1.0005463362,
0.1298065186,
0.0899033248,
-0.2808411717,
-1.0222219229,
0.3282410502,
-0.0069744103,
0.1711520106,
0.0895844325,
0.1681086272,
0.3894159198,
-0.1846623123,
1.0779747963,
0.1607723087,
-0.0229116566,
0.5888464451,
0.4916552901,
0.4066870213,
0.2738618851,
0.3399609029,
0.0075176577,
0.1681638807,
-0.541939795,
-0.6613247395,
0.0337568223,
-0.5376292467,
-0.6212976575,
-0.2788258195,
-0.4009280801,
-0.0219096337,
0.1722550392,
0.0969976932,
0.8078176379,
-0.2711418569,
0.3061257899,
0.7436739802,
-0.5007019043,
0.3505111337,
0.2698736787,
-0.2847084701,
-0.1492856443,
0.7983038425,
-0.427457571,
0.8335852027,
0.6780501008,
0.1511135548,
0.2151521593,
-0.2417829335,
-0.5721667409,
-0.2346184999,
-0.7807091475,
-0.3691766262,
-0.7002876997,
-0.7425600886,
-0.40698421,
-0.2548522055,
-0.2771102488,
-0.4128154814,
0.2963110805,
0.1470209807,
0.5875249505,
0.8527310491,
0.118990235,
0.6978026628,
-0.8836774826,
0.2874804139,
0.2500164807,
0.0273702703,
-0.1356535554,
-0.2407947928,
0.022317782,
0.4310814738,
-0.4489281178,
-1.1921312809,
0.021468183,
-0.1263844371,
0.3298932314,
0.0114988573,
0.0428064577,
0.3014897406,
-0.4212234318,
1.1171580553,
0.1455834955,
-0.8471012712,
0.7989112735,
-0.6868060231,
0.2202171832,
0.1329482794,
0.3356063366,
-1.0532710552,
-0.5109117031,
-0.8667117953,
-0.4447718561,
0.7266916037,
0.7229160666,
0.515591085,
0.0821897089,
0.1069714203,
-0.005799653,
0.30571118,
-0.7744088769,
-0.1797577739,
-0.1612033546,
0.0997684449,
0.2606082857,
-0.0069226404,
-0.1807834208,
0.3518252075,
0.2336418182,
0.0456483588,
0.7824554443,
0.1571772695,
-0.0354193524,
0.3563726544,
0.2888175547,
0.6258240342,
0.2786191702,
0.1583539397,
0.0399727933,
-0.0340478383,
-0.5693361163,
0.0800064728,
-0.2758123875,
0.0075784619,
-0.5003398061,
0.3534985185,
0.4124500751,
-0.0786273181,
-0.8569865823,
0.8240992427,
-0.0105381832,
-0.1667933315,
-0.4719027579,
0.4471641481,
-0.2655950785,
0.3402625322,
0.2194806486,
0.2625936568,
0.1342397779,
-0.7195625305,
0.3214737475,
0.3109815419,
-0.4666975737,
-0.3884106874,
0.705014348,
0.1166374162,
-0.7569925785,
0.8924846053,
-0.146950677,
-0.8836815953,
0.9683898687,
0.5270702243,
0.7685754299,
-0.0437566675,
0.3057409525,
0.0169719849,
0.517092824,
0.2348278761,
0.5807244778,
-0.1853470504,
-0.6179073453,
-0.0115032326,
-0.0624790043,
-0.5802623034,
-0.0734286904,
-0.4001998007,
0.3308990002,
-0.483705759,
0.1366338134,
0.0382155217,
-0.5846066475,
-0.6998001933,
0.0021248942,
-0.1247738302,
0.7855315208,
-0.440276444,
0.5052473545,
0.5137552619,
-0.5009180903,
-0.4854893684,
-0.1080435812,
0.1432882547,
-1.1006233692,
0.4476656616,
0.2575001717,
0.2026808411,
-0.0040397588,
-0.9638821483,
-0.7011632919,
0.6139362454,
-0.0975486413,
0.0040438804,
-0.1362044066,
0.3820834756,
0.4000738561,
-0.0338047333,
0.3806064725,
0.2455903888,
0.2067599893,
-0.0083536152,
-0.9898664951,
-0.0961474031,
-0.5057488084,
-0.3819339573,
0.3771422803,
-0.4556418955,
0.7412542701,
-0.0832713172,
-0.144925639,
0.1245281175,
0.3329338729,
-0.2963827252,
-0.023710655,
0.347984761,
-0.0206545535,
0.3425575495,
-0.1570255607,
1.1344325542,
-0.2300564796,
0.0373205729,
0.8385634422,
0.1209559962,
0.7521817088,
0.2230987549,
-0.2407540977,
0.2903048992,
0.6306521297,
-0.2321650833,
0.1404881328,
0.5900246501,
0.0873304531,
-0.2463002652,
-0.0232419111,
-0.1557048261,
0.7162801623,
0.1850865632,
-0.0210842788,
-0.2216019332,
0.3888478875,
0.1472062618,
-0.2287559658,
0.0170495249,
0.8690195084,
-0.1069322079,
-0.4030824304,
0.0585191324,
0.1628892124,
0.3521953225,
-0.8539391756,
-0.1455361992,
0.1048948169,
-0.0642652437,
-0.0434693433,
-0.8824781179,
0.3939642906,
0.1057391614,
0.1329270154,
-0.2225265503,
0.7970327735,
-0.0356374681,
-0.1467416584,
-0.1933588088,
0.3433537483,
0.6253764629,
-0.3907562196,
-0.7054805756,
-0.349365443,
-0.0345902704,
-0.3325387836,
0.0684536397,
0.2212339938,
-0.0406648703,
0.9617020488,
0.6854195595,
-0.105386667,
0.2115749419,
-0.2686702311,
0.7158875465,
-0.3301720321,
-0.5910033584,
-0.9488120079,
0.7428310513,
-0.3274556398,
-0.4317163825,
0.7119448781,
0.4789170325,
1.007263422,
-0.0221031457,
0.8881050944,
-0.5018005967,
0.2038676888,
-0.3712786436,
0.6596729755,
-0.4885879159,
-0.1000591889,
-0.1053850502,
-0.5907418728,
-0.3101646304,
0.3062683046,
-0.108399123,
-0.1977365315,
0.4671637416,
0.8866690993,
-0.1534075737,
0.3374569118,
0.318107754,
-0.2694297135,
0.7043939829,
0.4849347174,
0.9673410058,
-0.549277842,
0.6610301733,
-0.1504924595,
-0.3275438249,
-0.1438704431,
-0.5659321547,
-1.00867033,
-0.5676362514,
-0.2586556375,
-0.3861778975,
0.1806260943,
0.8415843248,
0.7322619557,
-0.7115480304,
-0.1825080365,
-0.1668858975,
-0.0812137276,
0.0064881351,
-0.2183474153,
0.0186877102,
-0.4026376307,
-0.4794193506,
0.1673191786,
0.2422166467,
0.3570450544,
-0.2708835304,
0.4220830202,
0.0331317559,
0.2194956243,
0.3574353456,
0.3035457432,
-0.4839563966,
-0.3985628784,
0.280723244,
-0.1458344609,
-0.0365711041,
1.0867345333,
-0.3826195002,
0.3628602326,
0.7282611728,
0.7959644794,
0.1015780792,
0.0069562122,
0.7864215374,
-0.5682246089,
0.2529718578,
0.3024922013,
0.1615711153,
-0.18761985,
-0.39617154,
0.5677535534,
0.1158065423,
-0.603087604,
-0.74469769,
0.5028941035,
-0.9377753139,
-0.4511978328,
0.8550595045,
-0.2552968562,
-0.0755650774,
-0.3548615873,
-0.3837576509,
0.0808754489,
-0.1804449558,
0.6854494214,
0.7037463188,
-0.1010419652,
-0.0057856878,
-0.9021891952,
0.3439799249,
0.0983207524,
-0.9528245926,
0.1592660993,
0.1719713956,
-0.0402944647,
0.2296970934,
0.6603032947,
-0.1843700856,
0.4317936301,
0.3328516185,
0.0014385729,
-0.0501059107,
-0.6166269183,
0.0170177948,
0.3880054951,
-0.2375204563,
-0.3214818537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09114v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09114v2 | CAPSTONE: Curriculum Sampling for Dense Retrieval with Document Expansion | 2022-12-18T15:57:46 | 2023-10-29T09:32:07 | Xingwei He, Yeyun Gong, A-Long Jin, Hang Zhang, Anlei Dong, Jian Jiao, Siu Ming Yiu, Nan Duan | cs.CL | cs.CL | The dual-encoder has become the de facto architecture for dense retrieval.
Typically, it computes the latent representations of the query and document
independently, thus failing to fully capture the interactions between the query
and document. To alleviate this, recent research has focused on obtaining
query-informed document representations. During training, it expands the
document with a real query, but during inference, it replaces the real query
with a generated one. This inconsistency between training and inference causes
the dense retrieval model to prioritize query information while disregarding
the document when computing the document representation. Consequently, it
performs even worse than the vanilla dense retrieval model because its
performance heavily relies on the relevance between the generated queries and
the real query.In this paper, we propose a curriculum sampling strategy that
utilizes pseudo queries during training and progressively enhances the
relevance between the generated query and the real query. By doing so, the
retrieval model learns to extend its attention from the document alone to both
the document and query, resulting in high-quality query-informed document
representations. Experimental results on both in-domain and out-of-domain
datasets demonstrate that our approach outperforms previous dense retrieval
models. | [
-0.5644506812,
-0.6673072577,
0.6808124781,
-0.2861981988,
-0.1074006706,
0.3044170737,
-0.2813336253,
-0.2020949721,
0.2748706341,
0.7230411768,
-0.5339598656,
-0.4508847892,
-0.5249347091,
-0.3006427586,
-0.4350912869,
0.8185312152,
0.3038390279,
0.1544032991,
-0.6315677166,
-0.1520827115,
-0.604236424,
-0.3928000331,
-0.5351383686,
-0.1182446331,
0.3218189478,
0.6179996729,
0.2546709776,
0.2581975758,
0.4205195606,
0.1495973319,
0.3031026721,
0.3153561354,
-0.9117959738,
0.1748284698,
-0.0090092467,
-0.5517388582,
-0.0763676763,
0.1601853967,
0.9278011322,
0.9116219282,
-0.1538983583,
0.0789769143,
0.0569299981,
0.6341699362,
-0.9732156992,
0.0430361852,
-0.620344162,
0.0033531142,
-0.2729452252,
-0.2512952387,
-0.5391128063,
-0.384744823,
0.3361574411,
-0.7116131783,
0.7358515859,
0.2276362181,
0.6442131996,
-0.1186564714,
-0.4650827646,
-0.4714938402,
-0.5266497731,
0.9540393353,
-0.0357048661,
0.4992733598,
0.7352284789,
0.4921246767,
-0.0171008706,
-0.9830754399,
-0.4724977016,
-0.0739216954,
-0.0107897371,
0.5316225886,
0.4519232512,
0.311937809,
0.3184872866,
0.7458834648,
-0.7392066717,
-0.1919175386,
-0.6487550139,
-0.2600237131,
0.3811663091,
0.0446744934,
0.294300735,
0.1531279385,
-0.1783388853,
-0.4350050688,
-0.6013114452,
-0.0720027238,
0.5279648304,
0.1953185946,
0.3473131657,
0.7002297044,
-0.0910422355,
0.9312739372,
0.2552133203,
0.3665071726,
-0.0120262392,
-0.4165429473,
-0.1179829165,
0.2095387876,
0.3464105129,
0.2384477854,
-0.0581061207,
-0.1510998607,
-0.2873056531,
-0.2213487774,
0.7506308556,
-0.9142218828,
-0.2387772799,
0.2234757543,
-0.337417841,
0.0948220789,
0.1300092489,
-0.9734829664,
-0.0974307209,
-0.514192462,
0.3537612259,
-0.6369324923,
0.1395311803,
0.2542208135,
-0.1697309017,
0.0192263387,
0.3005053103,
-0.8833755255,
0.417988658,
0.3868265748,
0.6688987017,
-0.0953965783,
0.0214022603,
-0.7054901123,
0.191993624,
-0.2196357548,
0.8032659888,
-0.9465430975,
-0.5633271337,
0.3549661934,
-0.2409489453,
-0.0429699793,
-0.6492816806,
0.4158830643,
-1.129173398,
0.3710472584,
-0.6261330247,
-0.5723074675,
0.1539639086,
0.2100034654,
-0.780929327,
1.4578871727,
0.5545099974,
-0.6624422073,
0.5675547123,
-0.2332050204,
-0.2922252417,
0.0691042542,
-0.4864773154,
-0.3582053781,
-0.1677212715,
0.1937095076,
0.0402443707,
-0.3706093431,
0.2090280056,
-0.088919811,
-0.7964527607,
-0.4264792502,
0.0455408543,
0.4797810316,
0.2005081624,
0.0631802604,
-0.2261532694,
-0.6338204145,
0.1171795055,
0.0035689538,
-0.4201296568,
-0.4468069673,
-0.4809103608,
-0.057741642,
-0.0077618598,
0.2397552431,
-0.5214936733,
0.4760787487,
-0.4544276595,
0.0020333631,
0.3629649282,
0.3135875463,
1.1140376329,
-0.5235294104,
0.5632872581,
-0.0992904305,
-0.1881789863,
-0.358612299,
-0.4194719791,
-0.7102175951,
-0.5155915618,
0.1330183148,
0.1531872004,
-0.7252005339,
0.2069372237,
-0.2525399327,
-0.4247502387,
-0.5676683784,
0.122012876,
0.3116213381,
0.5404930115,
0.8461953402,
-0.6036256552,
-0.5212376118,
-0.4853809178,
-0.1922297925,
-0.1136712208,
-0.0694536492,
0.4955657721,
0.3104739785,
0.0882821232,
1.1719694138,
-0.9965695739,
-0.3708051443,
-0.2001134753,
0.4274019003,
0.2561377883,
0.505415082,
0.5045057535,
-0.9037755728,
-0.4320957959,
-0.5623589754,
-0.5422984362,
0.0164978206,
-0.4800157547,
-0.5433348417,
-0.5372476578,
0.3888179064,
-0.5046896935,
0.4855920374,
-0.1941026449,
0.1783721447,
0.6178269386,
-0.3533506989,
0.2878298461,
-0.8250620365,
-0.1168276742,
-0.2231822014,
0.1907688379,
-0.1779108346,
0.2009669393,
0.4482776523,
-0.3136469126,
-0.0298843086,
0.7509577274,
-0.9697263241,
-0.2240642011,
-0.1461294591,
0.0787282735,
0.3982693851,
0.194750011,
0.2310856283,
1.0903077126,
0.4136199057,
-0.6478077769,
0.1363828927,
0.3167234361,
-0.442027688,
0.753919661,
-0.3074424565,
0.0940410048,
-0.3986957669,
0.5894690156,
-1.0974773169,
-0.121397242,
-0.3089624345,
-0.2662986815,
0.8412366509,
-0.3687895536,
-0.6185935736,
-0.7454546094,
-0.4037579894,
0.5523939729,
0.3614310026,
-0.598195672,
0.4723367989,
0.2863284647,
0.2706411481,
-0.7560901642,
-0.8230090141,
-0.00002228,
0.2687606215,
-0.4041525126,
0.5730829239,
-0.2458904982,
0.0337010175,
-0.1321710348,
-0.2919921279,
-0.3676661253,
-0.3977509439,
0.1833245158,
0.136857301,
-0.3501912057,
0.2097909003,
0.5023980737,
0.2404476702,
-0.1491939723,
-0.7355940342,
0.5778639913,
0.3611534536,
-0.6603796482,
-0.0503970906,
0.3987731636,
0.3561775982,
-0.4532886446,
0.8030159473,
0.4306937754,
-0.2814098597,
-0.4951800108,
-0.9529197216,
-0.7876910567,
-0.4375468791,
0.1427169293,
-0.4368855655,
-0.7240651846,
0.2768855691,
0.0443592742,
0.0000720397,
0.1182390675,
0.3308919072,
-0.2018378973,
0.3555061817,
0.4611609578,
0.2193529308,
0.6517585516,
-0.8140981197,
0.0139125641,
-1.2200508118,
-0.2626039982,
-0.4651348591,
-0.1770223379,
-0.1075968444,
-0.8868432045,
0.1652377546,
-0.1249371618,
-0.0340595171,
0.4918108881,
-0.6611665487,
0.4592880607,
0.7620967627,
0.3559399247,
0.0182688218,
0.3381212354,
-0.6146635413,
-0.2934746444,
-0.6254645586,
-0.1913147718,
1.6511243582,
-0.4079194665,
0.3620586097,
0.0525946841,
0.9805659652,
0.2307090759,
0.3336929679,
-0.6546992064,
0.4639418721,
0.08214055,
-0.8133314848,
-0.0737292096,
-0.3502258956,
-0.9005880356,
0.4212459028,
-0.079706803,
-0.4652667046,
0.375423789,
-0.2201428413,
-0.4406840801,
0.1539182067,
-0.4791467488,
0.5773041248,
0.0280731879,
-0.7952659726,
-0.2594873905,
-0.6715002656,
0.2413057536,
-0.4256325066,
0.0665968359,
0.3201189041,
0.065040499,
0.6363118887,
-0.3308478892,
0.6666871905,
-0.1410695314,
0.2593806386,
0.7614108324,
0.0860106796,
0.4085335732,
0.2754621804,
-0.5496413708,
-0.2876446247,
-0.2264044732,
-0.6866443753,
-0.5583248138,
0.700494647,
-0.7559256554,
-0.7017536759,
-0.592431426,
-0.6419765353,
-0.4812061489,
0.4996123314,
0.200551033,
0.4979627728,
-0.3342880607,
0.2571031451,
1.0719549656,
-0.1099012494,
0.060499642,
0.6057108641,
0.2357448339,
-0.0830517709,
0.7076010704,
0.5913814306,
0.2775390446,
0.6452373266,
-0.1097355112,
-0.4231293499,
-0.5959777832,
-0.444626689,
0.4213345647,
-0.8187277317,
0.0115550244,
-1.1585034132,
-0.1863501072,
-0.7205385566,
-0.5192645788,
-0.1943879426,
-0.2421713024,
-0.4942163527,
-0.1009876207,
-0.2163943946,
0.2206012309,
0.1518236846,
0.4607723355,
-0.7982342243,
0.297236532,
0.4171335101,
0.0103094243,
0.0726669207,
-1.0044506788,
-0.1730934381,
-0.0642572492,
-0.3447452784,
-0.7697505355,
0.2296453267,
0.2307904661,
0.7008820772,
0.5237865448,
0.3137666583,
0.8605848551,
-0.4557813406,
0.6676084399,
-0.0748586655,
-0.2212640643,
0.5593215227,
-0.3029591143,
0.4593858123,
1.2705663443,
0.6346516609,
-0.1366399974,
-0.4173760414,
-0.5570312142,
-0.8647491932,
0.7731411457,
0.0964997113,
0.4180313647,
-0.2101882249,
0.6812902689,
0.009498422,
0.3274392784,
0.0293268878,
0.0716488957,
-0.2752349377,
-0.2412264049,
0.2989913821,
-0.5660063028,
-0.0716736019,
-0.0722917989,
0.5101928115,
-0.2003261447,
0.1936735958,
0.1494947821,
-0.2391650975,
0.0018058717,
-0.0929684639,
0.1555223912,
0.5580360889,
-0.6775555015,
0.1867434382,
0.0627754182,
-1.0195022821,
-0.0637971833,
-0.1309549809,
-0.098059833,
-0.2076121271,
0.2556194663,
0.2245779335,
0.5573670864,
-0.6172263026,
0.700371027,
-0.1539265811,
0.042523995,
-0.2739020884,
0.0430854522,
-0.1207359582,
-0.1114629731,
0.6686822772,
-0.065409191,
0.4260100126,
-0.493637681,
0.6083449125,
0.4172617197,
-0.4023007751,
0.0012246389,
0.7099366784,
-0.0525951311,
0.3702100217,
1.0679309368,
-0.1025377661,
-0.1641330421,
0.8137578964,
0.6535285711,
0.5118503571,
-0.0057849768,
0.0562991649,
1.0313532352,
0.2812387645,
-0.3498545885,
0.1682456881,
-0.6156877279,
-0.5212490559,
0.1003637239,
-0.8383204937,
-0.2938076854,
-0.1147095039,
-0.9568037391,
0.421215713,
-0.3883654475,
-0.1999477744,
-0.4621404409,
0.328147769,
-0.6018850803,
0.7279759049,
-0.089653939,
0.9255251884,
-0.5196900368,
0.9705740809,
0.5831930041,
-0.884337008,
-0.4074417651,
0.2038420141,
0.0524964333,
-0.8873844147,
0.7282064557,
0.1963706911,
-0.0633677617,
0.1838032007,
-0.0987348408,
-0.7897459269,
1.1761723757,
0.0409396738,
-0.6736204028,
-0.4107241631,
0.0283835158,
0.4277151227,
-0.1839591265,
0.7905507088,
0.1055405065,
0.3401646912,
0.6013525724,
-0.0802017748,
-0.0491340235,
0.1131508574,
0.055568479,
0.0486443602,
-0.4402860999,
0.6164516211,
-0.2809575796,
-0.3552907109,
0.0898904279,
0.9988161325,
0.2418403774,
0.3986398876,
0.1810936332,
0.7030717134,
0.9615141153,
-0.0923813879,
1.2425439358,
-0.4635930657,
0.3369787633,
1.4790554047,
-0.3604275286,
0.6345936656,
0.4145008922,
-0.1170081422,
0.1505561769,
0.9119018912,
-0.0131738205,
0.6989796162,
0.2218870223,
-0.4036913216,
-0.2777790427,
-0.061240714,
-0.5695223212,
0.1407220364,
0.5587400794,
-0.3665014207,
-0.3563293517,
-0.0322071202,
-0.1990206987,
0.1900975257,
0.0044820737,
0.5217057467,
0.093569234,
-0.8927701116,
0.3974231482,
-0.1496163607,
0.31663692,
-0.5853377581,
-0.0566876158,
-0.4713439047,
-0.1074895412,
-0.1647858769,
-0.7234920859,
0.2161215693,
-0.4605477452,
-0.2810072005,
-0.2591802478,
0.6970285177,
-0.6334981322,
-0.2677603662,
0.2513938546,
0.285135299,
0.0534293018,
-0.2098516226,
-0.5036101937,
-0.1416694671,
-0.2821797431,
-0.2513480484,
0.707457602,
0.5018133521,
-0.096504055,
0.1836717278,
0.9868102074,
-0.0062559098,
0.1750632375,
0.247375384,
1.1664321423,
-0.2425707728,
-0.4175060391,
-0.2244826257,
0.1506688893,
-0.3117690086,
-0.0281570759,
0.5878663063,
1.1019345522,
0.8355624676,
0.0509506725,
0.5952976942,
0.1948305964,
0.1006818339,
-0.4320167899,
0.7974530458,
-0.7599675655,
0.1986581385,
0.0852268338,
-1.2089438438,
-0.2137043029,
0.46582371,
-0.770413518,
0.2242064476,
0.8486264348,
0.8555881977,
-0.3829789758,
-0.0089504961,
0.4526881576,
-0.1507816911,
0.1980218887,
0.4317176342,
0.5186030269,
-0.4439791739,
0.4377300739,
-0.043470569,
-0.3475866914,
-0.5956225395,
-0.3476836383,
-0.8980674744,
-0.6340118647,
-0.10426341,
-0.4793094397,
0.1275711954,
0.4801867008,
0.8726942539,
-0.6156172752,
-0.1497015953,
0.0463837832,
-0.0841256231,
0.068606481,
-0.2580197453,
0.4591789842,
-0.6347719431,
-0.8139909506,
0.5416794419,
0.2977977991,
-0.2277548313,
-0.0536703616,
0.2642537951,
-0.5716334581,
0.471870631,
0.3613611758,
0.2978973985,
-0.2610803545,
0.002289217,
0.0659424067,
-0.5014187098,
0.1814391166,
1.182314992,
-0.9251097441,
1.0536220074,
0.4923094511,
0.9407398105,
1.1484048367,
0.0187512916,
0.3389059603,
-0.8596845865,
0.178166762,
0.500956893,
0.2200657427,
0.2300279289,
-0.6598449349,
0.4536446035,
0.4011923671,
-0.2984161377,
-0.6698473692,
0.1124340892,
-0.9617158175,
-0.2204669416,
0.8635816574,
-0.0556287915,
-0.2540285587,
-0.1933222115,
-0.2640104294,
0.38357535,
-0.4669907093,
0.7273160815,
0.6261963844,
0.3200813234,
-0.0469297245,
-0.7883406878,
0.1246556118,
0.4441460967,
-0.3977011442,
-0.2864281833,
0.4474677742,
0.1146133244,
0.1244007796,
0.945492208,
-0.3768902719,
0.337465167,
0.0193954613,
0.0222581048,
-0.0328826904,
-0.3602533638,
0.2874028385,
0.519094348,
-0.1284188479,
-0.0296126921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09104v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09104v1 | LaSQuE: Improved Zero-Shot Classification from Explanations Through Quantifier Modeling and Curriculum Learning | 2022-12-18T15:10:05 | 2022-12-18T15:10:05 | Sayan Ghosh, Rakesh R Menon, Shashank Srivastava | cs.CL | cs.CL | A hallmark of human intelligence is the ability to learn new concepts purely
from language. Several recent approaches have explored training machine
learning models via natural language supervision. However, these approaches
fall short in leveraging linguistic quantifiers (such as 'always' or 'rarely')
and mimicking humans in compositionally learning complex tasks. Here, we
present LaSQuE, a method that can learn zero-shot classifiers from language
explanations by using three new strategies - (1) modeling the semantics of
linguistic quantifiers in explanations (including exploiting ordinal strength
relationships, such as 'always' > 'likely'), (2) aggregating information from
multiple explanations using an attention-based mechanism, and (3) model
training via curriculum learning. With these strategies, LaSQuE outperforms
prior work, showing an absolute gain of up to 7% in generalizing to unseen
real-world classification tasks. | [
-0.0332055911,
-0.7709900141,
0.4881197214,
-0.2914883494,
-0.0334292315,
-0.0607245006,
-0.0562170148,
-0.2185526937,
-0.1317673475,
0.6484972239,
-0.6104594469,
-0.7256132364,
-0.4528537095,
-0.2378823906,
-0.3683341742,
1.311771512,
0.1067159474,
0.0243130792,
-0.1661647856,
-0.0719344914,
-0.3788828254,
-0.4980151951,
-0.8198584318,
-0.3640536666,
0.9424391389,
0.5179601908,
0.5512186885,
0.779931426,
0.2141900361,
0.164209187,
0.4511256516,
0.0818476975,
-0.3845971525,
0.0527973585,
-0.0285395682,
-0.7380497456,
-0.2616071701,
-0.0754456669,
0.5049699545,
1.0400466919,
-0.1531428844,
0.1079488918,
-0.1844884455,
0.5896447897,
-1.1929769516,
0.2757707238,
-0.5975731611,
0.2933571041,
0.0863705426,
-0.2685358226,
-0.654972434,
-0.2541902065,
0.0608961582,
-0.6171545386,
0.3657711446,
-0.2665524185,
0.8208672404,
0.4586045146,
-0.3941710889,
-0.1289278269,
-0.7741683125,
1.2555904388,
-0.4200921357,
0.4847809076,
0.3996243179,
0.6166110635,
0.0705331787,
-0.6300296783,
-0.4765330553,
-0.1489598006,
-0.1138053015,
0.2631896138,
0.0917533189,
0.1115158424,
0.3282211721,
0.0712327212,
-0.6470609903,
-0.0488361493,
-0.4203076959,
-0.2183332592,
0.6423422098,
0.086837776,
0.1884285808,
0.1448546946,
-0.271618247,
-0.3151414692,
-0.7448900938,
0.4025424123,
-0.0521659777,
0.1920357496,
0.0316901058,
0.2375222296,
-0.4460959733,
1.2034609318,
-0.3123314977,
-0.190494135,
-0.0426007509,
-0.0280937739,
-0.4732614756,
0.1323079467,
0.4940094948,
0.1969935596,
-0.0668755844,
-0.2874912918,
-0.0140444133,
0.1288055778,
0.1265279949,
-0.782075882,
-0.4914801717,
0.2675205469,
-0.1223558858,
-0.28461954,
0.0802994519,
-0.7132470012,
-0.2953283489,
-0.3683932424,
0.5945190191,
-0.4149043858,
0.2504728138,
0.4590238035,
-0.0875014737,
0.5611616373,
0.4861709774,
-1.010304451,
0.1345491707,
0.4524843097,
0.6511635184,
0.0865962803,
-0.2315223813,
-1.0490771532,
0.1541895866,
-0.3033904433,
0.9219506979,
-0.3766533732,
-0.1047838628,
0.0522206202,
-0.155335933,
-0.0728788674,
-0.1318845451,
0.6917581558,
-0.4840326905,
0.5192927718,
-0.016674852,
-0.4623869061,
-0.5860695243,
-0.015528312,
-0.349324435,
0.5703903437,
0.0138427457,
-0.3801505268,
0.5278112888,
-0.817062676,
-0.3347349465,
0.2191686928,
-0.079471536,
-0.4968306422,
-0.0443602055,
0.2813224494,
0.7199459672,
-0.0589468293,
0.1516359448,
-0.2615487874,
-0.6339660287,
0.1760304123,
-0.3721209168,
1.0727508068,
0.1663619131,
-0.2659668624,
-0.0922478065,
-0.6822429299,
0.0290965531,
0.1742471606,
0.0044034468,
-0.178999573,
0.0422815047,
-0.6016095281,
0.0100104697,
0.1275372654,
-0.3332765996,
0.0038086427,
-0.7306597829,
0.2531397641,
0.2458520979,
0.0453691036,
0.7595452666,
-0.505384028,
0.629584074,
-0.2498248369,
0.185662806,
-0.6524474621,
-0.3087770641,
-1.1037602425,
-0.358666569,
0.2038446367,
0.5749548674,
-0.6837711334,
0.2324136943,
-0.0669506416,
-0.430885911,
-0.5104746819,
0.0870925114,
0.4530648589,
0.6659110785,
0.5387015939,
-0.115050979,
-0.5380557179,
-0.489865303,
-0.3225908279,
-0.1254214346,
-0.2876654565,
-0.0338556357,
0.3645685017,
-0.0045908759,
0.9534387589,
-0.5970734954,
-0.2092411667,
-0.1158237308,
0.4052757919,
0.2013270706,
0.0289597139,
0.6070145369,
-0.6794599295,
-0.4587849975,
0.0244731046,
-0.877012372,
-0.0913134888,
-0.392580092,
-0.1615551114,
0.200677067,
0.5158780813,
-0.152888447,
0.4801291227,
0.0726214573,
-0.0993059948,
0.5094254613,
0.0087186825,
-0.1677496284,
-0.5198579431,
-0.3033344448,
0.1023849249,
-0.1777105331,
-0.9706058502,
0.3556189239,
0.0639689043,
0.0849433839,
-0.7870040536,
0.7375622392,
-0.1416134089,
0.276240617,
-0.2712773085,
0.2212798893,
0.2352965772,
0.8064271212,
0.179055199,
0.1477513611,
1.0037702322,
-0.7531369925,
0.5884628892,
-0.1347303092,
-0.0072454968,
0.5851278305,
-0.6411750317,
-0.0589885153,
-0.5184633136,
0.1936075091,
-1.031483531,
-0.449342519,
0.2249830663,
-0.7635933757,
0.1267716587,
-0.1022720411,
-0.1932438761,
-0.2793795168,
-0.5185759068,
0.0717738196,
0.5381598473,
-0.4741451442,
0.6458920836,
0.046496179,
0.2275664955,
-0.6128007174,
-0.7369251251,
-0.2586477101,
-0.4773734212,
-0.0671257451,
0.27365008,
0.0082132649,
-0.237228319,
-0.2524561584,
-0.1298656166,
-0.5014827847,
0.415720731,
0.4164926112,
0.3955658376,
-0.1799837202,
0.4828282595,
0.113658756,
-0.1468818337,
0.0901975185,
-0.4343730509,
0.2166252136,
-0.2059185356,
-0.3496051133,
-0.6412521601,
0.0694809407,
0.424711585,
-0.2557766736,
0.901419878,
0.8722525239,
-0.2171543539,
-0.3957864642,
-0.292111069,
-0.4989897013,
-0.3673264384,
0.3045321405,
-0.299598664,
-0.8786101937,
0.1667561233,
0.211205557,
0.4565957785,
0.4668488801,
0.4303575754,
-0.3666107357,
1.0969229937,
0.6808530092,
0.123101674,
0.4390009642,
-0.412441045,
0.3877021968,
-0.2840620875,
-0.4389365911,
-0.5268322825,
-0.0355894528,
-0.1599860191,
-0.3403633237,
0.2517401576,
0.339314729,
-0.4420174956,
0.4543928504,
-0.5193465352,
0.7987675071,
0.7171981335,
0.0730338395,
0.262697041,
0.2103683352,
0.1035433933,
0.0641970932,
-0.7972939014,
-0.3285878599,
1.0740950108,
0.1877570897,
0.5290893316,
0.144395858,
0.8062779903,
0.0342352055,
0.3735390007,
-1.071826458,
0.3856481016,
-0.2448436916,
-0.301922828,
-0.5278987288,
-0.4102254212,
-0.8984829187,
0.2974399924,
-0.3785599172,
-0.6754661202,
-0.0925876722,
0.1880571991,
-0.9436917901,
0.0751414001,
-0.6814393401,
0.8562912345,
-0.2697719336,
-0.2927335203,
-0.0207495689,
-0.6664230824,
0.5307566524,
-0.3061311841,
0.4090849757,
-0.1335829943,
-0.0744121224,
0.54553473,
-0.3704366684,
0.9704690576,
-0.1366547942,
-0.0840824395,
0.2406062186,
0.1518436372,
0.0052391863,
0.0140892873,
-0.2037210464,
0.0916813985,
0.049050305,
-0.7848274708,
-1.0396751165,
0.389464587,
-0.7064038515,
-0.3886204958,
-0.1564856321,
-0.5550701618,
-0.0554822348,
-0.0904533118,
0.135247916,
0.3687137365,
0.1423507035,
0.2480189055,
0.7114813924,
-0.1491109431,
0.4614723623,
0.6790574193,
-0.1627754569,
-0.0799028724,
1.0910065174,
-0.1427411139,
0.1699550897,
0.9002091289,
0.2206558287,
-0.3574133515,
-0.2074122429,
-0.3050461411,
0.1649024636,
-0.6556425691,
-0.2631192803,
-0.6336402893,
-0.3361024559,
-0.2001289576,
-0.5490652323,
0.0929867849,
-0.5218750238,
-0.3096308708,
0.0732866004,
0.2456025183,
0.3858975768,
0.0703579262,
0.617251277,
-0.642752707,
0.2773301899,
0.8981800079,
-0.0409787446,
0.1387449652,
-0.8986463547,
-0.3061437011,
0.4249108136,
-0.3884636164,
-0.8744434714,
0.485988915,
0.649608314,
0.5723350048,
0.620644629,
0.1665178388,
0.7692531943,
-0.3072710633,
0.7469466329,
0.2819225192,
-0.9491907954,
0.7989018559,
-0.2138357908,
0.3933366239,
0.3443267643,
0.787396431,
-0.3898055851,
-0.3945932388,
-0.4617426693,
-0.602448225,
0.7694838643,
-0.0333980955,
0.2375809848,
-0.0836405009,
0.4931541681,
-0.005152056,
0.0419874974,
-1.0222952366,
-0.0745770708,
-0.3122217357,
-0.1391544491,
0.0696366578,
-0.1192086264,
0.0040478739,
-0.2387908101,
0.7047424316,
-0.2702866793,
0.0020011859,
-0.0227269307,
-0.3227894902,
0.0944234654,
0.1392674595,
0.6437174678,
0.4365872741,
-0.1624098122,
0.3400499225,
0.4166055024,
0.0463818125,
-0.0076727117,
-0.1898225695,
-0.1531650424,
0.0240153875,
0.5660737753,
0.92344594,
0.1922903657,
-0.9081650972,
0.5250436068,
-0.0395764075,
-0.5270483494,
-0.0975912511,
0.5067301989,
-0.1842118353,
0.1886804104,
0.2957750559,
-0.2264559418,
0.134487614,
-0.5668166876,
0.2777929306,
0.396337837,
-0.6964469552,
-0.1783451438,
0.6939364672,
-0.2427763194,
-0.2204753011,
0.2795811296,
-0.4370360672,
-0.3276817501,
0.4964959323,
0.3170880675,
0.5346921086,
-0.4089310467,
0.7564474344,
0.422834456,
-0.1343938112,
-0.1467019022,
-0.0769039914,
-0.4966167212,
-0.7291701436,
-0.8734067678,
-0.8228399754,
-0.6245517135,
-0.1177259758,
-0.6196448803,
0.4304023385,
-0.3797519505,
0.2670907676,
0.4215294719,
-0.1732722819,
-0.3391504884,
0.1600620151,
0.1388949603,
0.4121322334,
-1.0473587513,
0.9437717795,
0.7364659905,
-0.682626605,
-0.6985216737,
-0.1529167295,
-0.1320367157,
-0.9366287589,
0.9301766753,
0.1288022399,
-0.2582374513,
0.061685361,
-0.5326730013,
-0.5282974243,
0.8776692748,
0.4555983245,
-0.3349465728,
0.0833938122,
0.0148979714,
0.6109586358,
-0.191566363,
0.4109148681,
0.471688807,
0.1191804856,
0.5718816519,
-0.3927159607,
-0.4091281593,
0.1551838964,
-0.1611257643,
0.2970415056,
-0.231115818,
0.6934323907,
-0.3577179313,
-0.1872949302,
0.0133276032,
0.6658906341,
0.2510077953,
0.3950172663,
0.4088873863,
0.3932272792,
0.8386710286,
-0.1817972511,
0.8868556619,
-0.0565136336,
0.5109939575,
1.1817016602,
-0.180249989,
0.8804658651,
0.1183231771,
-0.2354218364,
0.9644209743,
0.5257573724,
-0.0194293763,
0.6507307291,
0.1918889135,
-0.5629906058,
-0.3778785169,
-0.333129406,
0.2092964798,
0.6269235015,
0.4119150341,
-0.1475920975,
-0.5624737144,
0.2753557861,
0.0104880445,
0.1849117577,
-0.5501731038,
0.7132098675,
-0.059330944,
-0.6309419274,
0.9946667552,
0.0010558694,
0.4522208571,
-0.305978924,
-0.3222236335,
-0.180252105,
0.0409293994,
-0.2468199581,
-0.5284362435,
0.5067089796,
-0.0790663064,
-0.0341905989,
-0.3802904785,
0.5438314676,
-0.6506158113,
-0.4325151742,
-0.0665041506,
0.3891911805,
0.413136363,
-0.0928856805,
-0.6700991392,
-0.3849962056,
0.1808988452,
0.4194032252,
0.2428444773,
0.3948033452,
-0.1042128503,
0.7028204203,
0.6201490164,
-0.0002096651,
0.0154570648,
0.1080584079,
0.4030498266,
-0.6404192448,
-0.0589826778,
-1.1502064466,
0.4750050902,
-0.018697191,
0.2378903925,
0.5738534927,
0.2088593841,
0.9600743651,
-0.1349155307,
0.5248679519,
0.326117456,
0.4502229095,
-0.5054009557,
0.5084084272,
-0.6101695895,
0.1220932156,
0.1392672211,
-0.7942403555,
-1.076674819,
0.9772496819,
-0.2882882059,
-0.1278514564,
0.6848542094,
0.6871007085,
0.1461749524,
-0.0066550877,
0.7578091025,
0.0538505986,
0.1155865043,
0.8345650434,
0.6945867538,
-0.374045819,
0.5858897567,
-0.4987198412,
-0.3494912684,
-0.3952659369,
-0.9373642802,
-1.1320010424,
-0.4014403224,
-0.4487955272,
0.1107172891,
0.2172178179,
0.6000143886,
0.9687205553,
-0.8449648619,
-0.2476638705,
-0.3057112992,
0.3952918351,
-0.2214774787,
-0.2517962456,
0.3010872602,
-0.6466033459,
-0.7127509713,
0.2184253633,
0.4582832754,
-0.0097094662,
-0.2641652822,
0.01397717,
0.1963916123,
-0.0015182232,
0.8551766872,
0.5477858186,
-0.8523151875,
-0.0426932052,
0.2192513347,
0.1742667258,
-0.1223690882,
0.482362926,
-1.1519633532,
0.5262848735,
0.3290300369,
0.4836530089,
0.2728426158,
-0.2081438005,
0.3709225059,
-0.7882327437,
0.2800065577,
0.2146006674,
0.2083395869,
0.1122969091,
-0.1594674289,
0.4801519215,
0.0149408169,
-0.4149415195,
-0.6822344661,
0.336771518,
-0.83577317,
-0.3425898552,
0.7500259876,
-0.2959270179,
-0.2739143968,
-0.2246142179,
-0.1740059108,
0.444154799,
-0.2700085342,
0.9134081602,
0.3641197979,
-0.239818871,
-0.4907443821,
-0.8681247234,
0.3014174402,
0.5210655928,
-0.8383026719,
-0.1108011827,
0.3486525416,
-0.0567085296,
0.1529016495,
0.373214215,
-0.0145587223,
0.6394143701,
-0.4584640265,
0.1935928613,
0.181596294,
-0.5134906173,
-0.5218651891,
0.2213705182,
0.0126741342,
-0.2351597697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09097v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09097v2 | Continual Knowledge Distillation for Neural Machine Translation | 2022-12-18T14:41:13 | 2023-06-12T12:00:20 | Yuanchi Zhang, Peng Li, Maosong Sun, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | While many parallel corpora are not publicly accessible for data copyright,
data privacy and competitive differentiation reasons, trained translation
models are increasingly available on open platforms. In this work, we propose a
method called continual knowledge distillation to take advantage of existing
translation models to improve one model of interest. The basic idea is to
sequentially transfer knowledge from each trained model to the distilled model.
Extensive experiments on Chinese-English and German-English datasets show that
our method achieves significant and consistent improvements over strong
baselines under both homogeneous and heterogeneous trained model settings and
is robust to malicious models. | [
0.1115467176,
-0.4228638113,
0.7451037169,
0.4401037097,
-0.2866621912,
0.1728179306,
-0.5652974844,
-0.3039194047,
-0.2652867734,
0.5135104656,
-0.2856054306,
-0.5176366568,
-1.0196957588,
0.1244414747,
-0.6858339906,
1.1831659079,
-0.2699174285,
0.404178828,
-0.2321524918,
-0.3461689353,
-0.5448643565,
-0.5978134274,
-0.5587368608,
-0.562913239,
0.6182611585,
0.0786513016,
0.5551735163,
0.6522715092,
0.6452652812,
0.3401136994,
-0.1887615025,
0.2492838204,
-0.5923442841,
0.399035424,
-0.3981746137,
-0.7766794562,
-0.1308691502,
0.037469279,
0.6051557064,
0.9445114732,
-0.2178982794,
0.1550459415,
0.4033672214,
0.7596696615,
-0.4391619265,
-0.0423746593,
-0.9605468512,
0.1304652393,
-0.1580937207,
-0.0541328378,
-0.4597964585,
-0.5589122772,
0.282281816,
-0.5796777606,
0.0942136422,
-0.0556195118,
0.7782663107,
0.5453938246,
-0.1757787615,
-0.10539639,
-0.9313784838,
0.847863853,
-0.7850343585,
0.1716639102,
0.3854377568,
0.5116900206,
-0.0643024147,
-1.3143123388,
-0.4679269195,
-0.5731528997,
-0.1724070758,
0.0614467636,
-0.3038825095,
-0.1586543322,
0.1557219326,
0.338448137,
-0.3188764751,
-0.0084202299,
-0.553724587,
-0.0051967623,
0.385287106,
0.0992740095,
0.360629946,
0.34604159,
-0.652262032,
0.1527862102,
-0.6817344427,
-0.5078494549,
0.0755207166,
0.1053335145,
0.0942799151,
0.3869152367,
-0.0325453728,
0.6885799766,
0.1813082099,
-0.1238851026,
0.2559601665,
-0.5085629821,
-0.1858484298,
0.2226078957,
0.6979550123,
0.2728172839,
0.1801947504,
-0.5597762465,
-0.2552496493,
-0.1213413924,
0.26820153,
-0.8021246791,
-0.4404267967,
0.1586211473,
-0.4577209651,
-0.2903499901,
-0.1721566617,
-0.5394431353,
-0.2954104245,
-0.7804337144,
0.3508121073,
-0.3763538599,
-0.3461254537,
0.1324193627,
-0.5044007301,
-0.5329685807,
0.0962273553,
-0.7758644223,
0.228797242,
0.4945452511,
1.196087122,
-0.3280169666,
-0.5162629485,
-0.4740694463,
0.3077421486,
-0.3519797623,
0.1005200669,
-0.149027735,
-0.1037441194,
-0.1038286537,
0.1239470318,
-0.1567109376,
-0.7815330029,
0.0726035088,
-0.6178514957,
0.1377181411,
-0.1318179816,
-0.4950487018,
-0.0975976586,
0.2713906169,
-0.4292368591,
0.7184410095,
-0.0498902798,
-0.7581522465,
0.2531531155,
-0.5272763371,
-0.2750188112,
-0.1235951632,
0.1902157813,
-0.2449670285,
0.2870306373,
0.1412861645,
0.4424253404,
-0.1176889017,
0.7238061428,
-0.3597322106,
0.0149298701,
0.3230683208,
-0.5947070122,
0.8838899732,
0.46458745,
-0.4064914286,
-0.081677936,
-0.6498440504,
-0.421914041,
0.0320570469,
-0.2182809561,
-0.8103885055,
-0.03909529,
-0.2796854973,
0.2132878751,
0.5483192205,
-0.5021190643,
0.3610588908,
-0.115044862,
0.6381950378,
0.626452446,
0.2288384289,
0.6201474667,
-0.2896748483,
0.2651188076,
0.5085094571,
0.2434130013,
0.0217058603,
-0.6012784839,
-0.6871678829,
-0.2013659179,
0.4460853636,
0.5514523983,
-1.0114957094,
0.2447109669,
-0.5086536407,
-0.5121908784,
-0.6031261683,
0.4377638996,
0.3701705337,
0.6549079418,
0.5991715789,
-0.0575114749,
-0.3634136021,
-0.7152374983,
-0.0383691452,
0.0467053726,
-0.272292465,
-0.3106353879,
0.3543924391,
-0.1218815446,
0.4978337586,
-0.3629844189,
-0.2419280708,
-0.0210023355,
0.4440502822,
0.2265382409,
0.6080154777,
0.6741882563,
-0.8278803825,
-0.7070336342,
0.2564284503,
-1.1676464081,
-0.0283374153,
-0.3269655108,
-0.393989712,
-0.0825546682,
0.7980561256,
-0.2453302145,
0.2667273581,
0.6837466955,
0.0627296865,
0.2452332377,
-0.4091177881,
0.0458592027,
-1.4076619148,
0.3438200355,
-0.2526224256,
-0.4745555818,
-0.7299211025,
0.0050503309,
0.1095041037,
0.1714612544,
-0.5909379721,
0.2155305445,
-0.5200220346,
0.324298501,
-0.4556130469,
0.2373225987,
-0.0297138989,
0.2375853956,
-0.0125144748,
0.6230048537,
0.5640714169,
-0.7645506859,
0.5495832562,
0.2084905505,
-0.4262304604,
0.346069634,
-0.7480841279,
0.1753345281,
-0.063972868,
-0.0473303348,
-0.8500542045,
0.0399789587,
0.2062637955,
-0.3179199696,
0.3735212088,
-0.3627350032,
-0.4181266725,
-0.2653591037,
0.4088761508,
0.0882434174,
0.6362081766,
-0.8093981147,
0.2443156987,
0.1544654667,
-0.2315002978,
-0.6373255849,
-1.0630486012,
0.1987019777,
-0.4904193878,
-0.6144539118,
0.564230144,
0.0257045962,
-0.3545334637,
0.2165338993,
-0.0937140286,
-0.3502595723,
0.1393399984,
0.0215411652,
0.3337439597,
-0.2035085708,
0.1102178395,
0.2604033947,
-0.0043866714,
0.0625801682,
-0.9130014181,
0.3826409876,
0.0571108535,
-0.125075981,
-0.4375838339,
0.2122475803,
0.6911121607,
-0.1399053782,
1.0900201797,
0.4865095317,
-0.4309662282,
-0.2586784959,
-0.3596704006,
-0.207870096,
-0.464792788,
0.3114303648,
-0.3601070642,
-0.760573864,
0.5850585699,
-0.2728358507,
0.1471655816,
0.3096812069,
0.5609530807,
-0.0157808177,
0.8947404623,
0.8277811408,
-0.4440077543,
0.4039177299,
-0.1346074343,
0.0107147023,
-0.4106622934,
-0.254604131,
-0.5003420115,
-0.5828108191,
-0.2441067994,
-0.1918580532,
0.328256011,
0.4613135755,
-0.0377228484,
0.7040987611,
-0.5708014965,
0.4079251885,
0.6237302423,
0.3330312073,
0.5941604972,
0.1801536828,
-0.3327054679,
-0.0827016905,
-0.8097839355,
-0.3187820315,
1.1458672285,
0.4004845917,
0.3605992496,
-0.0036483738,
0.9049949646,
0.1679616868,
0.5308700204,
-0.3529757857,
0.117809929,
-0.2400219887,
-0.6930258274,
-0.216853708,
-0.7448157668,
-0.7859002352,
0.0245872457,
0.1700710952,
-0.5591436028,
0.2901284099,
0.1145237163,
-0.2395814061,
0.5012845993,
-0.542023778,
0.7699636221,
-0.4538727999,
-0.4165394604,
-0.1952412874,
-0.6726182699,
0.577929914,
-0.5096940398,
-0.0577390455,
0.0228571463,
0.0884261131,
0.5360403657,
-0.5947805047,
0.7171611786,
-0.3910194635,
0.0432595983,
0.1751271635,
0.0181456748,
0.3897796571,
0.0796160549,
0.0240989365,
0.5632033348,
0.0484170057,
-0.4011386335,
-0.6767138839,
0.5052263737,
-0.7882786393,
-0.5579676628,
-0.2815279961,
-0.5593578219,
-0.0474060178,
0.3471846282,
0.4772914052,
-0.1392333508,
-0.0594703816,
0.3821718693,
0.7597762346,
-0.0597695373,
0.3255320787,
0.465953052,
-0.3612583876,
-0.3410449326,
0.7903992534,
0.2280541062,
0.4959407151,
0.3023367524,
0.1930607259,
-0.2898508608,
-0.9015460014,
-0.4804030955,
-0.0734844208,
-0.6582528949,
-0.2253096551,
-0.6282454729,
-0.4319841564,
-0.2412103713,
0.0856907368,
-0.4749296308,
-0.4658815265,
-0.1585577875,
-0.0804129988,
0.4031731486,
0.6543498635,
-0.428809613,
0.3343614936,
-1.1114732027,
0.4531506598,
0.1522493958,
0.1340443641,
-0.1522968113,
-0.9384367466,
-0.3952923119,
0.4441282153,
-0.2519488633,
-0.7640678287,
0.6045956016,
0.1725934297,
0.6894926429,
0.3824796379,
0.0389379226,
0.6485632658,
-0.7105823159,
0.6599671245,
0.4858257771,
-0.7662407756,
0.4010704458,
-0.232788682,
0.3049925566,
0.884121716,
0.8686758876,
-0.5632391572,
-0.4570263326,
-0.2740856111,
-0.7841158509,
0.4031419456,
0.2980585098,
0.1890438795,
0.1120618433,
0.3146228194,
0.1760072112,
0.3252854645,
-0.4321408272,
-0.2357188612,
-0.300115943,
-0.1713570356,
-0.0339946821,
0.1066399068,
-0.2847945094,
-0.5082694888,
0.9050030112,
0.2637738287,
-0.0517447777,
0.0513912253,
-0.2178204209,
0.3065877855,
-0.1492467225,
0.3490272462,
0.7476767302,
-0.1228298023,
0.0998057202,
0.1615704894,
-0.670332551,
0.3453355432,
0.1869017184,
-0.2893841267,
0.3664570451,
-0.1480885744,
0.6119788885,
-0.0394235812,
-0.1276655793,
0.3119166195,
-0.0578395128,
-0.4903928936,
-0.34413746,
-0.1413053125,
0.4379732311,
0.3370105922,
0.1521977186,
0.378093034,
0.0254511405,
-0.3162707984,
0.4997365177,
-0.3644167185,
-0.2743191719,
-0.1005887315,
0.8455996513,
0.0319683924,
0.1765632629,
1.0850663185,
-0.0872101784,
-0.4090510011,
0.4439497888,
0.4297758341,
0.9018082023,
-0.3900540471,
0.040664807,
0.5374217629,
0.3130086958,
-0.7222900987,
-0.1788072586,
-0.0194948912,
-0.5728551745,
-0.3383061886,
-0.6250827909,
-0.2475755513,
0.2674197257,
-0.798052907,
0.0800147876,
-0.2806120813,
-0.2979743183,
0.1080148593,
-0.4521522522,
-0.6169191003,
-0.1293506175,
0.2030163705,
0.8349013925,
-0.6644122005,
1.3435386419,
0.3278205395,
-0.7027801275,
-0.5262608528,
0.0421318263,
-0.0668560937,
-0.5986618996,
0.8223981261,
-0.0609212741,
0.1776372939,
0.0092540262,
-0.6613135338,
-0.7757192254,
1.1849155426,
0.6889569759,
-1.0608260632,
-0.1052198932,
0.4178378582,
0.6796427965,
-0.1738325655,
-0.3526454866,
0.5640913844,
0.5476665497,
-0.0573575348,
-0.8618636131,
-0.2036336809,
-0.4250533581,
0.1861658841,
-0.1377150565,
-0.3552619219,
0.5935485363,
0.218239218,
-0.1790812463,
0.174683854,
0.7798445821,
0.1001270488,
0.3845250309,
0.2951631248,
0.5716468096,
1.0099394321,
-0.1978874803,
0.7266376019,
-0.6517735124,
0.0424046852,
1.6016316414,
-0.2305319905,
0.7635640502,
0.6113621593,
0.0448817909,
0.3901041448,
0.3550599813,
-0.3084590137,
0.8061612248,
0.3982068002,
-0.5259586573,
-0.1318778843,
-0.0221104436,
-0.493645668,
0.3044643402,
0.2303381413,
-0.7616888881,
-0.2007119358,
0.388995856,
0.241189912,
0.3704688549,
-0.1257352829,
0.8408823609,
0.4372442067,
-0.9786211848,
0.8964781761,
0.0964549631,
0.6360855699,
-0.6853124499,
0.1476847678,
-0.4422076941,
0.4642340243,
-0.1196610928,
-0.3816283047,
0.690957725,
0.2341673821,
-0.4217792153,
-0.4829230905,
0.5564546585,
-0.7393837571,
-0.4308508337,
0.5360302329,
0.5043202043,
0.3757679462,
-0.2819878459,
-0.7210940719,
-0.2416483909,
0.0676764622,
-0.0754773766,
0.4627462327,
0.668233037,
0.0976303667,
0.5605216026,
0.6670020819,
0.3103133738,
0.532600522,
0.0059257206,
1.0175856352,
-0.1531923413,
-0.2341269255,
-0.9497683048,
0.6455334425,
-0.286637038,
-0.0856310129,
0.857414782,
0.3636502922,
1.0695194006,
-0.1926772147,
1.1458249092,
0.0914693326,
0.2118771821,
-0.5581583381,
1.2878547907,
-0.482911557,
0.2483964413,
0.1997310221,
-0.9950705171,
-0.0728238821,
0.3409386575,
-0.2673366666,
-0.3543958962,
0.8048947453,
0.6946344972,
-0.2456258088,
-0.1217708737,
0.4810777307,
0.3348116875,
0.0261003599,
0.5740439296,
0.8211573362,
-0.4051746428,
0.5468470454,
-0.511259973,
-0.1578138024,
0.3514360785,
-0.9337964058,
-0.9405784607,
-0.6836919785,
-0.4201704264,
-0.4146939814,
0.4407567978,
0.4818507433,
0.7528275847,
-0.8860542774,
-0.1272221357,
-0.446223408,
-0.1307635009,
-0.4776795506,
-0.1390486658,
0.1183908358,
-0.7251245975,
-0.8210333586,
0.6058098078,
-0.0115243178,
-0.0387557335,
-0.3374658227,
-0.0541064367,
-0.1319286227,
-0.1140483245,
0.2804709971,
0.1318649054,
-0.2876547277,
0.0374256782,
-0.0439631417,
-0.1867881715,
-0.053969726,
0.6449967027,
-0.361805886,
0.5980477929,
0.5840283632,
0.9460914135,
0.6182956696,
-0.2134159207,
0.8878977895,
-0.928017199,
0.3552508354,
0.1517950147,
0.4507211149,
0.3124748766,
-0.3646270931,
0.459628582,
0.4227137566,
-0.5515835285,
-0.6361409426,
-0.0538101904,
-0.6388226151,
-0.4989837706,
1.0924973488,
-0.8676561713,
-0.2181146145,
-0.2134422064,
0.1896217465,
0.6584572196,
-0.0937557518,
0.9471203089,
0.6899905801,
0.5621290207,
0.0797010213,
-0.7393734455,
0.436201483,
0.2867821157,
-0.6024098992,
0.0745424032,
0.4115003049,
0.4939627051,
0.2585304677,
0.4237526357,
-0.4873218238,
-0.0332975797,
0.1599118859,
-0.0638117045,
-0.3073474467,
-0.7856907845,
-0.3813586235,
0.1412025541,
-0.1431709528,
-0.3576848209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09095v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09095v2 | Rethinking the Role of Scale for In-Context Learning: An Interpretability-based Case Study at 66 Billion Scale | 2022-12-18T14:36:07 | 2023-08-16T09:09:53 | Hritik Bansal, Karthik Gopalakrishnan, Saket Dingliwal, Sravan Bodapati, Katrin Kirchhoff, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models have been shown to perform better with an increase in scale
on a wide variety of tasks via the in-context learning paradigm. In this paper,
we investigate the hypothesis that the ability of a large language model to
in-context learn-perform a task is not uniformly spread across all of its
underlying components. Using a 66 billion parameter language model (OPT-66B)
across a diverse set of 14 downstream tasks, we find this is indeed the case:
$\sim$70% of attention heads and $\sim$20% of feed forward networks can be
removed with minimal decline in task performance. We find substantial overlap
in the set of attention heads (un)important for in-context learning across
tasks and number of in-context examples. We also address our hypothesis through
a task-agnostic lens, finding that a small set of attention heads in OPT-66B
score highly on their ability to perform primitive induction operations
associated with in-context learning, namely, prefix matching and copying. These
induction heads overlap with task-specific important heads, reinforcing
arguments by Olsson et al. (arXiv:2209.11895) regarding induction head
generality to more sophisticated behaviors associated with in-context learning.
Overall, our study provides several insights that indicate large language
models may be under-trained for in-context learning and opens up questions on
how to pre-train language models to more effectively perform in-context
learning. | [
-0.3327349424,
-0.4312869608,
0.455122292,
0.1780773848,
-0.1275251359,
-0.4013013542,
-0.4721015394,
-0.6392789483,
-0.2030797005,
0.3699250221,
-0.4043067396,
0.1181446016,
-0.8389976025,
0.2100079209,
-0.3382366598,
0.9242940545,
0.2598646283,
-0.0548755676,
-0.3360290229,
-0.1848818511,
-0.4229004681,
-0.217020303,
-0.8307607174,
-0.5802582502,
0.4732592106,
0.6365730762,
0.5852622986,
0.9772099257,
0.7330179811,
0.2119198442,
-0.1670080572,
0.1092463434,
-0.6748843789,
-0.1286604106,
-0.2825886905,
-0.5121427178,
-0.604136765,
0.1262392253,
1.0766572952,
1.2329756021,
0.3250177801,
0.1245808229,
0.3283680975,
0.6039264798,
-0.6120129824,
0.2363215834,
-0.626663506,
-0.1677318662,
0.0087710116,
0.1697701663,
-0.7930731773,
0.0829389542,
0.4743611515,
-0.6391387582,
-0.0666582808,
0.0283819512,
0.5246559381,
0.4110488296,
-0.4973526597,
-0.2129871547,
-0.5145706534,
0.974850595,
-0.7549004555,
0.229871124,
0.4796512127,
0.1168238819,
-0.0150810927,
-0.6928260922,
-0.2257499397,
-0.1755359769,
-0.0268801395,
-0.1350667924,
-0.1050696373,
-0.0667151436,
0.6489075422,
0.3084506392,
-0.3147089481,
0.1970528513,
-0.311263293,
0.2068383396,
0.369608283,
0.0784873143,
0.2435697168,
0.0106018521,
-0.3321495354,
-0.0734384581,
-0.9199182987,
0.2753521204,
-0.0497215874,
0.5843099952,
-0.1818316728,
0.2724002004,
-0.3689510524,
1.0286554098,
0.3541752696,
-0.0579607598,
0.1855873615,
-0.1441471279,
-0.4205746353,
0.0921102688,
0.5400643945,
0.2282009721,
0.5380833745,
-0.335873574,
-0.0169209074,
-0.2166231573,
0.5718607306,
-0.9341627955,
0.1938309819,
-0.063584879,
-0.3343560696,
0.0392642468,
0.0321883224,
-0.3576482534,
-0.1623409986,
-0.4836075008,
0.6756752133,
-0.3859124184,
-0.3488067091,
0.1110093519,
0.0842112452,
0.3722842932,
0.2570244074,
-0.9132360816,
0.1937042773,
0.7569276094,
0.6689590812,
-0.1396402568,
-0.5823749304,
-0.3181860149,
-0.0334429666,
-0.3120341301,
0.4634861052,
-0.8096305728,
-0.3233957887,
-0.1180879548,
0.0806236938,
-0.5031778216,
-0.7070254683,
0.2571267486,
-0.4571403861,
-0.0432305969,
-0.5561031699,
-0.639760673,
-0.3021410406,
0.0644953027,
-0.5650240779,
0.7083387971,
0.3120816648,
-0.7545127273,
0.6359330416,
-0.5601106286,
-0.5099199414,
0.1883352548,
-0.0848377272,
-0.0145345442,
0.2712641656,
-0.1268810779,
0.561639905,
-0.3730620444,
0.1613518149,
-0.3215844035,
-0.7246395946,
0.1029927284,
-0.2720729411,
0.7639029622,
0.1136780381,
-0.699976027,
-0.1464116424,
-0.6342640519,
0.1497291028,
-0.2756401896,
-0.2620299757,
-0.5436642766,
-0.0039574504,
-0.082186006,
0.4434801638,
0.0876993537,
-0.4138099253,
0.0818071514,
-0.4592447281,
0.6315926313,
0.3560413122,
-0.2784611583,
0.8702557683,
-0.122092776,
0.2879711688,
-0.0229204167,
-0.037851613,
-0.2038951963,
-0.3766833544,
-0.5069118738,
-0.2208006978,
0.1195074767,
0.1139253899,
-0.4291806519,
0.3265037239,
-0.6071388721,
-0.4286610484,
-0.3604345918,
-0.046152927,
0.5391599536,
0.7613616586,
0.2351913005,
-0.5166137218,
-0.1882248372,
-0.970448494,
-0.3569086194,
-0.0629402623,
-0.168296963,
0.2996632755,
0.5479291677,
-0.2590702176,
1.1298863888,
-0.2173665911,
-0.2188933492,
-0.3323540092,
-0.0037990694,
-0.0199966747,
0.6301884651,
0.4435833395,
-0.9655143619,
-0.4702286422,
0.2084912062,
-0.9440563321,
-0.0449530557,
-0.0161468666,
0.0014347142,
-0.0437115617,
0.6680706143,
-0.3917747736,
0.1427586973,
0.3174056709,
-0.3106324375,
0.1880275607,
-0.2344792485,
-0.1451806724,
-1.0228085518,
0.1229666024,
0.2366865426,
-0.0651710853,
-0.7345163226,
0.2783227861,
0.5852384567,
0.2654412091,
-0.4803126454,
0.3722230792,
-0.2725476921,
-0.153858155,
-0.5375036597,
0.0678651258,
-0.15996705,
0.5677136779,
0.0465750061,
0.6562202573,
0.6628426313,
-0.5774076581,
-0.2252001017,
-0.020147074,
-0.3797935545,
0.8040238619,
-0.6274725795,
-0.1051862016,
-0.0999107361,
0.4205692708,
-0.9715884924,
-0.3551698625,
-0.1215330064,
-0.2130975723,
0.4048845768,
0.1939519197,
-0.2338774949,
0.0299205128,
0.0135033205,
0.6877571344,
0.350897789,
-0.4395323694,
0.5271999836,
0.291169405,
0.1857260168,
-0.6104938984,
-0.6499964595,
-0.0772301108,
-0.525093317,
-0.4616921842,
0.283149153,
-0.0010808107,
-0.5286539793,
-0.1494257152,
-0.3972158432,
-0.1204053983,
0.1468456537,
0.3843877017,
-0.0356838964,
-0.2752082646,
0.2148547918,
-0.2952007651,
0.1278104633,
0.3637061715,
-0.4737301469,
0.1551257968,
-0.2618265748,
-0.0199644249,
-0.2085578442,
0.2272163481,
1.0563557148,
-0.132724002,
0.7487913966,
0.2224550843,
-0.4147704244,
-0.3514962494,
-0.2660834193,
-0.2504617274,
-0.4200545549,
0.5773574114,
-0.4356001318,
-0.8470811844,
0.5326452851,
-0.1904769391,
0.1334623247,
0.6160248518,
0.4212636948,
0.0202468261,
0.7003107667,
0.8005435467,
-0.1584027708,
0.6389588714,
-0.4150204957,
0.1227278486,
-1.2697672844,
-0.1257709861,
-0.4423835576,
-0.4519291222,
-0.6245814562,
-0.301533103,
0.2700446844,
-0.2506733835,
-0.5035886168,
0.4322098494,
-0.1889605075,
0.6303876638,
0.3505652249,
0.2690244019,
0.2247722894,
-0.2624615133,
0.126809299,
0.0161515828,
-0.8161378503,
-0.1988786012,
1.1611274481,
0.2443109155,
0.5921561718,
-0.2115367204,
0.3555204868,
-0.0001115066,
0.3741479814,
-0.9137055874,
0.3963370323,
-0.2591812015,
-0.5845566988,
-0.6382855773,
-0.4483168721,
-0.7592020631,
0.6173593998,
0.3038282096,
-0.6869693398,
0.308110714,
-0.035978809,
-0.3455472589,
0.2314378023,
-0.8780149817,
1.0032138824,
0.2328362018,
-0.3770731091,
-0.1976446062,
-0.9376434684,
0.1890303642,
-0.3950922489,
0.4064103663,
0.1773954183,
0.0020148731,
0.7394827604,
-0.035327848,
1.0617954731,
0.0561560392,
-0.2515477836,
0.1348759234,
-0.0446715988,
0.4977697134,
-0.0875857696,
0.0084504737,
0.0124462126,
-0.4773278236,
-0.3582564294,
-0.4744724333,
0.7454719543,
-0.8174078465,
-0.4691184759,
-0.1590546519,
-1.055119276,
-0.3494891226,
0.2004928589,
0.4680506587,
0.8942719698,
0.1675494313,
0.7227228284,
0.9478767514,
0.3962102234,
0.5947893262,
0.343277365,
0.2550538778,
0.1296330243,
0.7758048177,
0.389642328,
0.8960164785,
0.6166058779,
0.0821274742,
-0.0732256398,
-0.3242920041,
-0.2520988584,
0.2459888309,
-0.7725006938,
0.2300932556,
-0.6696546674,
-0.0446081571,
-0.114328824,
-0.3474406302,
-0.3656071723,
-0.2172668576,
-0.1340132952,
0.0504876971,
0.0029215228,
0.738276422,
0.0795720816,
0.5241845846,
-0.2587552369,
-0.0319373757,
0.4749467671,
0.2138885409,
0.4107069969,
-1.0930057764,
-0.6820132136,
0.0455026738,
-0.0848888978,
-0.4164406955,
0.1585693806,
0.367171824,
0.3515625,
0.6725462675,
-0.0626531392,
0.7902024388,
-0.6696311831,
0.4908961356,
-0.072366178,
-0.9715378881,
0.0841381699,
-0.4390438497,
0.907431066,
0.4845154583,
0.5402595997,
-0.5632346869,
-0.6627255082,
-0.7094633579,
-0.9366943836,
0.961371541,
-0.0758107081,
0.0953482762,
0.1973226517,
0.4009186625,
0.2438613921,
0.1247271225,
-0.6357320547,
-0.0826456696,
0.0589828715,
0.0534613244,
-0.4633547366,
-0.0953511298,
0.0753171667,
-0.3344858885,
0.2970858812,
-0.3483266532,
0.0849124119,
0.0256349202,
-0.2870492935,
-0.2221190184,
0.1025341824,
0.5353291035,
1.1689977646,
-0.3379404247,
0.2569308877,
0.1367531121,
-0.7756128907,
-0.1586875916,
-0.2190808803,
-0.0312303584,
-0.5078898072,
0.7076695561,
0.7203621268,
0.8359735012,
-0.5478907824,
0.1755260527,
0.133427754,
-0.2127989084,
-0.11611595,
0.1357714981,
0.0601443313,
0.239701733,
0.5504965782,
0.194202438,
0.1946665198,
-0.6387984753,
0.240858376,
0.3494867384,
-0.7027168274,
-0.4019623697,
0.614384532,
0.0944879204,
-0.1545443833,
0.7596419454,
0.0927654728,
-0.3419763446,
0.909974277,
0.6003102064,
0.8602515459,
-0.0788774565,
0.0237229522,
0.294184804,
0.4886368811,
-0.4387137294,
-0.1179984212,
-0.1779818535,
-0.7238410115,
-0.5968332291,
-0.3644729555,
-0.507419467,
0.1114288568,
-0.8782257438,
-0.1806481928,
-0.1189863086,
0.0433409065,
0.1807192266,
-0.1363403797,
-0.6313002706,
0.6180787086,
0.0416418239,
0.8398641944,
-0.9812572598,
0.917411685,
0.8104640245,
-0.2198958844,
-0.9727698565,
0.3019414246,
-0.147862047,
-0.6112049222,
0.8588298559,
0.5605081916,
-0.1255333871,
0.2013898343,
-0.4250902832,
-1.0532445908,
0.8995202184,
0.2985784411,
-0.2788522243,
-0.251945436,
0.0783852041,
0.4581944346,
-0.7776446342,
0.3780834973,
0.6250144243,
0.1937944591,
0.170646593,
-1.2913583517,
0.15172939,
0.0616163872,
0.0296911094,
0.1192827672,
-0.7424426079,
1.1287084818,
-0.1800391227,
0.1137025505,
-0.5279906988,
0.4297100604,
-0.1381395757,
0.0655460134,
0.5699810386,
0.5158771873,
0.3565988839,
0.0017336237,
1.0609697104,
0.0034359908,
0.4141925275,
0.882338047,
-0.1935809106,
0.9259047508,
0.6272209883,
-0.0920168981,
0.2926792204,
0.7123310566,
0.5127039552,
0.6625957489,
0.0303442348,
0.0416129977,
-0.4215434194,
-0.080952093,
-0.2282607704,
0.6563672423,
0.368468672,
-0.4340302944,
-0.3257215917,
0.2199580669,
0.1288738251,
-0.1616716385,
-0.6411072016,
0.4940273762,
0.2540199757,
-0.8004509807,
0.5788891912,
-0.4546873569,
0.6326715946,
-0.6496994495,
0.120434992,
-0.1579433233,
0.5022745728,
-0.0893239006,
-0.4973332286,
0.2808141708,
-0.2488791943,
-0.5165782571,
-0.3646837771,
0.3670813143,
-0.3114618659,
-0.2060168535,
0.3184732795,
0.4642061889,
0.1470484287,
-0.4617585242,
-0.1951772869,
-0.0501008481,
-0.0479834378,
-0.3834838569,
0.7807629108,
0.6837180257,
-0.1773566902,
0.6782181859,
0.145030126,
-0.0821329877,
-0.0043752128,
-0.2169506252,
0.6532984376,
-0.4685120285,
-0.5668031573,
-0.8969759941,
0.3973382413,
0.0592746958,
-0.4242631495,
0.9297813177,
0.2553448975,
1.2101154327,
-0.1266371161,
0.5866875648,
-0.2493987978,
0.0603006892,
-0.0760201365,
0.5809729695,
-0.7825633287,
-0.1389446408,
-0.2579626739,
-0.8711566925,
-0.107061848,
0.597584486,
-0.5298166871,
0.1416722834,
0.962192893,
0.4053220153,
-0.0021148482,
0.141951263,
0.486571759,
0.0864087418,
0.0019592287,
0.7901027799,
0.4580572248,
-0.2635939717,
0.2437510043,
-0.0353155844,
-0.5117884874,
-0.3494294882,
-0.6704611182,
-0.7839857936,
-0.6782950163,
-0.181450218,
-0.0030379822,
-0.3317866325,
0.8555185199,
0.8193014264,
-0.4887800515,
-0.4975282252,
0.0177041963,
-0.1201877147,
-0.7640251517,
-0.1656965613,
0.3723056018,
-0.5615733862,
-1.0159144402,
0.2832784355,
0.190647468,
-0.3981202841,
-0.1340013593,
0.1962168217,
-0.0408648364,
-0.0867542028,
0.7334112525,
0.3159680367,
-0.7067990303,
-0.2934099436,
0.0651664734,
-0.2669290006,
-0.0841050148,
0.6673057079,
-0.7501140833,
0.5004736185,
0.2461210191,
0.7657144666,
0.1583689153,
-0.1264970005,
0.6730297208,
-0.5477207303,
0.1639181376,
0.001581714,
0.2721046209,
0.2237454504,
-0.4043803811,
0.5052230954,
0.1284322143,
-0.732060194,
-0.7444068193,
0.1757845134,
-0.9811605215,
-0.2439981848,
1.2567129135,
-0.2481304407,
-0.1675160229,
0.0145753138,
0.114992559,
0.043268811,
-0.3134610355,
0.7966013551,
0.8666063547,
-0.0794337466,
0.1371672004,
-0.7872769237,
0.5563057661,
0.5265297294,
-0.4521446824,
0.2882792354,
0.2687905431,
0.2371889651,
0.3076266348,
0.2345631719,
0.0685944632,
0.3390417993,
-0.1009334102,
-0.2349209487,
0.1184148341,
-0.4755815864,
-0.521873951,
0.3378349245,
0.062742807,
-0.1646099687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09086v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09086v4 | PVGRU: Generating Diverse and Relevant Dialogue Responses via Pseudo-Variational Mechanism | 2022-12-18T13:36:07 | 2023-05-16T11:29:24 | Yongkang Liu, Shi Feng, Daling Wang, Yifei Zhang, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | We investigate response generation for multi-turn dialogue in
generative-based chatbots. Existing generative models based on RNNs (Recurrent
Neural Networks) usually employ the last hidden state to summarize the
sequences, which makes models unable to capture the subtle variability observed
in different dialogues and cannot distinguish the differences between dialogues
that are similar in composition. In this paper, we propose a Pseudo-Variational
Gated Recurrent Unit (PVGRU) component without posterior knowledge through
introducing a recurrent summarizing variable into the GRU, which can aggregate
the accumulated distribution variations of subsequences. PVGRU can perceive the
subtle semantic variability through summarizing variables that are optimized by
the devised distribution consistency and reconstruction objectives. In
addition, we build a Pseudo-Variational Hierarchical Dialogue (PVHD) model
based on PVGRU. Experimental results demonstrate that PVGRU can broadly improve
the diversity and relevance of responses on two benchmark datasets. | [
-0.4450786114,
-0.8652060628,
0.2299728692,
-0.0765061378,
-0.2866441011,
0.1512604803,
0.120660238,
-0.0581286997,
0.3112206161,
0.2675483227,
-0.9658923149,
-0.2268337458,
-0.0505498685,
0.0270329528,
-0.0299396198,
1.38762784,
0.5376458764,
0.0559283681,
-0.1472617537,
-0.2037220895,
-0.1913753599,
-0.3666245341,
-0.1414841115,
-0.3462061584,
0.619197309,
0.2012318075,
0.6134630442,
-0.1416420937,
0.2290799916,
0.4619641304,
-0.1077360958,
0.2410982549,
-0.8460888863,
0.1849454641,
-0.1826236546,
-0.9007083178,
-0.205521971,
-0.3461760879,
0.7390154004,
0.3269246519,
-0.5822479725,
-0.3190303743,
-0.0677253455,
0.3757461607,
-0.3428161144,
0.1428879201,
-0.7708289623,
0.125560388,
0.1392167062,
-0.2398779094,
-0.269192189,
-0.2916062176,
0.390214771,
-0.4397596717,
0.6324819922,
-0.1290340573,
0.7458977103,
0.1290250272,
0.0229845271,
0.0414241254,
-1.044272542,
0.7946282029,
-0.9234414101,
0.0454007722,
0.0430581942,
0.4433682263,
-0.383788228,
-0.7320567369,
-0.907450676,
-0.252492249,
-0.2167529911,
0.5999920368,
-0.2178082019,
0.2677248418,
0.0956381112,
0.7309180498,
-0.58859694,
-0.1420477778,
-0.0030945111,
-0.2040039301,
0.3048802316,
0.564035356,
0.2385073155,
-0.3617850542,
-0.1399175227,
-0.3375762999,
-0.3823377788,
0.1116170958,
0.7507061958,
0.4929037988,
-0.361474812,
0.5376138091,
-0.1386673003,
0.8717475533,
0.1695223749,
-0.2995585501,
0.4728318453,
-0.7557149529,
-0.3991969228,
-0.5909276605,
1.2061576843,
0.2841756046,
-0.4601978362,
0.0130117713,
-0.2047197968,
-0.0797334909,
0.4988920093,
-0.6221786141,
-0.3204517365,
0.0974837244,
-0.5756762624,
-0.2735664248,
0.0389688052,
-1.0232179165,
-0.1146583855,
-0.1639309376,
0.1869918853,
-0.2011839002,
-0.5790374875,
-0.1918035001,
-0.2172506601,
0.4959026873,
0.3060310483,
-0.8068387508,
0.0606117882,
0.2222372293,
0.7440730929,
-0.0703683347,
0.0117979515,
-0.4986314476,
-0.3545414209,
-0.0665011182,
0.4884910285,
-0.4938632846,
-0.9616411328,
-0.024173703,
0.0149130495,
-0.0779902786,
-0.434541434,
0.0843990669,
-0.3321936131,
0.627137363,
-0.0417323709,
-0.2406168282,
0.0358549654,
0.2075903118,
-0.5649091601,
0.5817037821,
0.5240259171,
-0.9748708606,
0.0440756083,
-0.3667629659,
-0.2843243182,
0.3027972281,
-0.6053634286,
-0.8179406524,
0.2030692697,
0.0389899425,
-0.0492685027,
-0.2850676775,
0.3053067923,
-0.2423335463,
0.0636160299,
0.4855189919,
-0.7777642012,
0.2518803775,
0.288974911,
-0.0609064661,
0.5663664341,
-0.6794702411,
0.0303915218,
-0.0303692613,
-0.1114550382,
0.1825161725,
0.0041248305,
-0.0289503876,
0.2180866003,
-0.0501768179,
-0.4321791232,
0.1790801585,
-0.5563376546,
0.2522463202,
0.6897030473,
0.1443962455,
0.4416167438,
-0.7311332226,
0.8038138151,
0.1673083454,
0.1730132848,
-0.3574862778,
-0.7174297571,
-0.704424262,
-0.2315396369,
-0.0053642364,
0.5246571898,
-1.3240122795,
0.3771754801,
-0.0467403196,
-0.4766762853,
-0.5571203828,
-0.1364258826,
0.4613508284,
0.5996831656,
0.2064095736,
-0.481501013,
-0.3830288947,
-0.8578478694,
0.0095722023,
-0.7156754732,
-0.2899197936,
0.9131832123,
0.0405944437,
-0.3259920776,
0.9766162038,
-0.4291039109,
-0.0666356757,
-0.6772617698,
0.6952280998,
0.3615920246,
0.1055391058,
0.3845197856,
-1.0506911278,
-0.2214759588,
0.1824543923,
-0.4830907285,
-0.0386530384,
-0.4307229817,
-0.1482509375,
0.0088871038,
0.0942506045,
-0.8084415197,
0.3873350024,
0.4271371961,
0.259221077,
0.5495727658,
-0.1962903738,
0.1581128687,
-1.3218809366,
-0.1722719371,
-0.0374156274,
-0.2789489329,
-0.6434742212,
-0.1842235476,
-0.3928700686,
-0.0403647274,
-0.5119211078,
-0.0105344476,
-0.0588259287,
0.0052403305,
-0.3744206727,
0.0291764848,
-0.3798211515,
0.6628752947,
0.0966977328,
0.7381655574,
0.4480205476,
-0.6369358897,
0.7611293793,
0.2113892287,
-0.1961993724,
0.4975059032,
-0.8154226542,
0.104588367,
-0.408400476,
0.4774053991,
-1.2011218071,
-0.3028983772,
0.3509452641,
-0.5689934492,
0.3306453824,
-0.301007241,
-0.0993043408,
-0.4451167285,
-0.1444865316,
0.4230409265,
0.6494440436,
-0.2559951842,
0.982329309,
0.2008348852,
-0.2512540221,
-0.4777635038,
-0.501585722,
-0.1936596334,
-0.1300343573,
-0.4751609862,
0.2881164849,
-0.3375484645,
0.0187647976,
-0.184728846,
-0.0245203562,
0.3144041896,
-0.326109916,
0.1047992259,
0.342756927,
-0.3451883197,
0.012365845,
-0.0476607047,
0.0117571624,
-0.0466753691,
-0.3842992187,
0.7490406036,
-0.3820775151,
-0.4305312932,
-0.4527290165,
0.4236538708,
0.4545500576,
0.0368400887,
0.6635175347,
0.5079808235,
0.2274581492,
-0.1113988012,
-0.0904595703,
-0.259811908,
-0.5296958089,
0.4988863766,
-0.4707496762,
-1.0244758129,
0.603718996,
-0.0465064645,
0.0440399013,
0.3502960801,
1.0190612078,
-0.12529248,
0.6730747223,
0.5684449077,
-0.0557505041,
0.7327703834,
-0.2005130798,
0.418649286,
-0.5408658385,
-0.3737914264,
-0.3231773973,
-0.1920478195,
-1.1287345886,
-0.5127346516,
0.3249938488,
-0.1612150073,
0.2830632925,
0.202090323,
-0.348950237,
0.1892932206,
0.5689210892,
0.0889214054,
-0.133135438,
-0.1704708636,
-0.1753853858,
-0.0141680744,
-0.9106917977,
-0.1680471003,
0.794246614,
0.0155731635,
1.240301013,
0.3238244057,
0.6006902456,
0.2253261209,
0.3351730108,
-0.7454795837,
0.4174967408,
0.2873859406,
-0.1974875033,
-0.4492045343,
-0.9537474513,
-0.9366334081,
0.4895287156,
-0.1111698598,
-0.7180873156,
0.0794351846,
0.2008255869,
-0.3065822124,
0.2146283686,
-0.6687194705,
0.4957592487,
0.0591782555,
-0.1352451742,
0.2600962818,
-1.1170898676,
0.3202957511,
0.1765379161,
-0.0103307236,
0.3431094885,
0.6011406183,
0.1813763678,
-0.6296424866,
1.0648782253,
-0.104044266,
-0.1129668131,
0.5515465736,
-0.1651128829,
0.5965868831,
0.4191624224,
0.5035425425,
-0.2177587003,
-0.4957621992,
-0.4149950445,
-0.7094922066,
0.5787293315,
-1.0553158522,
-0.8721022606,
-0.2419298738,
-0.5041062236,
-0.2079225332,
-0.0997489393,
0.6707643867,
0.0530387424,
-0.3871355653,
0.1984861493,
0.8450846076,
-0.4847691357,
0.5333552957,
0.4124338031,
-0.1666794568,
-0.3515439332,
0.8872798681,
-0.4695815742,
0.5483884811,
0.7959229946,
0.2470387369,
-0.4193067551,
-0.1765307784,
-0.6015965939,
-0.0312379971,
-0.311199218,
-0.2083186209,
-0.8467050195,
-0.4535834789,
-0.2451469302,
0.2505353391,
-0.3457332253,
-0.0434279405,
-0.4099881351,
-0.3027377427,
0.4212429225,
0.5658277273,
-0.0428516828,
0.4497567713,
-0.7246003151,
0.7578320503,
0.8331182003,
0.0713373944,
-0.0349487066,
-0.638899982,
0.2507883608,
0.3393545449,
-0.4690857232,
-0.727189362,
0.4996831417,
0.1754927635,
0.7568757534,
0.3101728559,
0.1009027883,
0.4600614607,
-0.469152838,
1.0999370813,
0.7613364458,
-0.6709984541,
0.6265420318,
-0.538646996,
0.4401193857,
0.1045253053,
0.1116193607,
-0.4524662793,
-0.66113168,
-0.644236505,
-0.8907756209,
0.9046504498,
0.6830957532,
0.7153554559,
-0.0855031013,
0.0034431361,
0.3092729151,
0.3169613183,
-0.7426617146,
-0.5935485363,
-0.8593320251,
-0.057083331,
0.0603875965,
-0.1681765616,
-0.237180233,
0.1839336306,
0.3541057706,
-0.1070122272,
0.5696915388,
0.1690640599,
0.2254322916,
-0.1062398031,
0.4947856665,
0.8992994428,
0.461291343,
-0.0533892363,
-0.1029007584,
0.022678921,
-0.3825528622,
0.1007091403,
0.0415876359,
-0.0892711133,
0.2471948415,
0.0720572472,
1.0682632923,
-0.3013589084,
-0.2635487914,
0.4708587825,
-0.4617395401,
-0.0671140105,
0.058318872,
0.2771321833,
0.1557053924,
0.1338479668,
0.2818481624,
0.2018756121,
0.1060743034,
-0.5094157457,
0.4049698114,
0.3443637192,
-0.3402619362,
-0.3714597523,
0.4323303998,
0.2007268965,
-0.6525275707,
0.6236245036,
-0.2245837748,
-0.3381533325,
0.4302969277,
0.6146320105,
0.85127455,
-0.5301699042,
0.7213053703,
0.2270667404,
-0.0135699064,
0.1719994545,
0.3842284381,
-0.3203593194,
-0.7891880274,
-0.393073976,
-0.5002223849,
-0.5311549306,
0.453080982,
-0.7988573909,
-0.1976499707,
-0.346272558,
-0.3451166749,
-0.1208095998,
-0.6991865635,
-0.5252815485,
0.2672747076,
-0.1501934975,
-0.0828702748,
-0.7617785335,
0.5072283149,
0.4005227089,
-0.5446400642,
-0.5404311419,
0.2706794441,
-0.1578264236,
-0.6142603159,
0.1247986108,
-0.2307869047,
-0.4347143173,
-0.4206512868,
-0.6258916855,
-0.4294314384,
0.5951441526,
0.1085920706,
-0.8837170601,
0.2128489763,
0.3424390852,
0.8319043517,
-0.3322074413,
0.6130062938,
0.1663622111,
-0.0373249128,
0.6124087572,
-0.7262588739,
-0.3763935864,
-0.6037660837,
0.4719316661,
0.2409431338,
-0.7751353979,
0.7553053498,
-0.2123574167,
-0.0785629004,
0.3586842716,
0.8309200406,
0.3850132823,
0.056599129,
0.1992745399,
0.4467573464,
0.5579202771,
-0.1612245291,
1.1459883451,
0.0400534868,
0.3866835237,
1.3225405216,
0.0260956082,
0.3071308434,
0.3901817501,
-0.4139021635,
0.709867537,
0.3756226301,
0.1978294849,
0.9032136202,
0.6571425796,
-0.67191571,
-0.301083535,
-0.0500104167,
-0.483769685,
0.0946849063,
0.4779053926,
-0.2404551059,
-0.2560208142,
-0.0240760464,
-0.4496549368,
-0.0937472209,
-0.0022440953,
1.1246235371,
0.2086559981,
-0.6638042927,
0.5448726416,
-0.1007742882,
0.5549654365,
-0.7314960957,
-0.0971537903,
-0.7381290197,
-0.0837457702,
-0.0628561899,
-0.5691959262,
0.0644700155,
-0.126776576,
-0.4011296332,
0.0020451513,
0.4550676942,
-0.5196777582,
-0.359320581,
-0.064807117,
0.4154928923,
0.0221560672,
0.3204056025,
-0.6559640765,
-0.2796683908,
0.2325542122,
-0.0976990834,
0.2363424003,
0.7575757504,
0.1920247972,
0.6185365915,
0.7083256245,
-0.2664384544,
0.0741560832,
0.7037517428,
1.0525795221,
-0.4550512731,
-0.60493505,
-0.6536305547,
0.6801131964,
-0.1063102931,
-0.3829543293,
0.3803573251,
0.1813411117,
0.7455672026,
-0.2447786331,
1.0123540163,
-0.0279733948,
0.1889404058,
-0.2969123423,
0.4301085174,
-0.3616536856,
0.2892049849,
-0.3779849112,
-0.8755230308,
-0.0577154905,
0.6658220887,
0.0184821114,
0.3213794529,
0.4211187363,
0.9037981033,
-0.0634706393,
0.122004278,
0.709194541,
0.219126761,
0.4937634468,
0.6341258883,
1.160046339,
-0.197266385,
0.6090916991,
0.3377945423,
-0.2019274533,
-0.2296696305,
-0.5726442933,
-0.9442350864,
-0.4976764321,
-0.1899167895,
-0.4185279608,
-0.1314014494,
0.3551579416,
0.6816506982,
-0.825638473,
0.0342732184,
-0.6832691431,
0.2451561391,
0.1367922127,
-0.3035488427,
-0.0902249888,
-0.4315983057,
-0.5478370786,
0.2607323825,
0.4506226182,
0.3959500492,
-0.169838354,
-0.1342183053,
0.1675527841,
0.1986666173,
0.3185198605,
0.4080302119,
-0.9230026007,
-0.0171952732,
-0.0138796289,
-0.0592961013,
0.356883347,
0.9696683288,
-0.6601638198,
0.8354209661,
0.6636083722,
0.5368864536,
0.8248035312,
0.0897586867,
0.8717235327,
-1.0100024939,
0.2025867999,
0.3479864001,
0.2737836242,
0.354542315,
-0.31332165,
-0.0452464633,
0.3765250742,
-0.3414497674,
-0.3348605037,
0.8297452331,
-0.9834749699,
-0.0356332362,
1.1496829987,
-0.4429699481,
-0.0578652807,
-0.1074996069,
-0.3074607253,
0.3648401201,
-0.5508223772,
0.7986767888,
0.4289018214,
-0.2335278541,
-0.4593601227,
0.1070168167,
0.4945961237,
0.5091592669,
-0.9522298574,
-0.1116132066,
0.4553394318,
0.0573775545,
0.2787817717,
0.7509049773,
-0.189860478,
0.1751413941,
0.1683195233,
-0.142520979,
0.5474255085,
-0.1715083271,
-0.0129033113,
0.0470589623,
-0.2548974454,
-0.336653173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09080v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09080v1 | Synthesis and Evaluation of a Domain-specific Large Data Set for Dungeons & Dragons | 2022-12-18T12:54:45 | 2022-12-18T12:54:45 | Akila Peiris, Nisansa de Silva | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper introduces the Forgotten Realms Wiki (FRW) data set and domain
specific natural language generation using FRW along with related analyses.
Forgotten Realms is the de-facto default setting of the popular open ended
tabletop fantasy role playing game, Dungeons & Dragons. The data set was
extracted from the Forgotten Realms Fandom wiki consisting of more than over
45,200 articles. The FRW data set is constituted of 11 sub-data sets in a
number of formats: raw plain text, plain text annotated by article title,
directed link graphs, wiki info-boxes annotated by the wiki article title,
Poincar\'e embedding of first link graph, multiple Word2Vec and Doc2Vec models
of the corpus. This is the first data set of this size for the Dungeons &
Dragons domain. We then present a pairwise similarity comparison benchmark
which utilizes similarity measures. In addition, we perform D&D domain specific
natural language generation using the corpus and evaluate the named entity
classification with respect to the lore of Forgotten Realms. | [
-0.833567977,
-0.7220022678,
0.2765869498,
0.1825011522,
0.0659158528,
-0.1760222614,
-0.2724984288,
-0.3459647298,
0.2540568411,
0.9357685447,
-1.0037887096,
-0.6731808782,
0.1753010899,
0.5301699042,
-0.1880467832,
1.2947845459,
-0.1940282136,
-0.4827324152,
-0.4166085124,
-0.1567560583,
-0.3609706461,
-0.2930590212,
-0.6869286895,
0.0551160239,
0.4209295511,
0.2185831815,
0.5144971609,
0.5725625157,
0.4501647949,
0.248560071,
0.163362965,
0.6815803647,
-1.1816574335,
0.2017110139,
-0.334818989,
0.1039447933,
-0.7937324047,
-0.0748263672,
0.5889635086,
0.5892028809,
-0.0117393238,
0.1544858962,
0.0874813944,
0.6255996227,
-0.2815203369,
0.0486800298,
-0.5564848185,
0.1827031821,
-0.3579076529,
-0.2596423626,
-0.1773650944,
-0.3911811113,
0.4027121663,
-1.327070117,
0.7868909836,
0.3490687013,
0.4674085975,
-0.1245648041,
-0.3243676424,
-0.4410330951,
-0.7563291788,
0.8417716622,
-0.7128708363,
0.53504318,
0.4332828224,
0.0972659811,
-0.5200337768,
-0.8118097782,
-1.1643964052,
-0.080260478,
0.0264054555,
-0.007031627,
-0.2788008451,
0.0337191336,
0.544909358,
0.3685997725,
-0.7601884604,
-0.1074895561,
-0.4303674102,
0.2141971141,
0.8603265882,
0.6273483634,
0.4340491891,
-0.2172586769,
-0.2729164958,
-0.0577831268,
-0.9863649011,
-0.5059387684,
0.5024800301,
0.1762581021,
-0.054078225,
0.6859671474,
-0.2984620333,
0.9131673574,
0.1836305708,
-0.4611338973,
0.1731992811,
-0.2696551383,
-0.3116903901,
-0.1315540224,
0.6796351075,
0.9074738026,
0.4229227304,
-0.466376543,
-0.2379927188,
-0.0938900337,
0.5573707819,
-0.5713914633,
-0.2511983216,
0.2603856325,
-0.4261032343,
-0.4360626936,
-0.2100669593,
-0.797226429,
-0.6950967908,
-0.338270396,
0.1780619323,
-0.2945916057,
-0.3010487556,
-0.0398575701,
-0.3434378207,
-0.1645752788,
0.1701214612,
-0.8793839216,
0.5207175016,
0.5993851423,
0.5304559469,
-0.7362539172,
-0.5019853711,
-0.0027539942,
0.4801728129,
-0.6361209154,
0.8273132443,
-0.2650974989,
-0.8411373496,
-0.0022781147,
0.2027563155,
0.0642507821,
-0.600107491,
0.734565556,
-0.5902142525,
0.324357003,
-0.1239615306,
-0.6276353598,
0.0102456929,
0.208755061,
-1.254742384,
0.6949715614,
0.2428665459,
-1.0305433273,
0.4991728961,
-0.4600356817,
-0.6472136974,
0.2397285998,
-0.0249077063,
0.0357910432,
0.0119300438,
0.0508403219,
0.3087176979,
-0.5553611517,
0.1051612496,
-0.2759257853,
-0.3526614308,
0.3983077109,
-0.3854677379,
0.5171932578,
0.0477176197,
-0.0771476775,
-0.4059334993,
-0.6779821515,
0.2970623672,
0.0272622481,
-0.1378804296,
-0.5480797291,
0.2670962512,
0.0179536622,
0.0237693451,
0.0927040428,
-0.4929595888,
0.2381375134,
-0.3780125976,
-0.097500585,
0.564067781,
0.6771192551,
0.1781910807,
-0.3515590131,
0.3017493486,
-0.4600120783,
0.1922127008,
0.2890562415,
-0.4187592864,
-0.3787579834,
-0.1185233295,
0.2279113531,
0.2595330477,
-1.1900860071,
0.5473329425,
-0.5659382343,
-0.3998044431,
-0.3061736524,
-0.2713511884,
0.115874581,
0.47435534,
0.1318007857,
-0.1090217456,
-0.523424685,
-0.7395453453,
0.0985784158,
-0.3005913794,
-0.2180879265,
0.6807080507,
0.1714622527,
-0.3382781744,
0.9822858572,
-0.8418059349,
-0.2479556799,
-0.013711608,
-0.199307546,
0.2067019045,
0.1670796722,
0.5367102027,
-0.7971354723,
-0.5354143381,
0.4262291789,
-0.779776752,
-0.0549390838,
0.0648529381,
-0.2099548876,
0.0929973498,
-0.0852481276,
-0.6918814778,
0.3747486174,
0.5047819614,
-0.24703376,
0.7587623,
-0.1457318068,
0.9124216437,
-0.9469465017,
0.3527975678,
-0.2830140591,
0.3102716208,
-0.7733437419,
-0.0886765197,
-0.3350880146,
-0.2847714722,
-0.0765420645,
0.7982279062,
-0.4131582081,
0.109750554,
-0.0952021703,
0.4292117357,
0.1518521756,
0.4602055252,
0.2385634035,
0.5919450521,
0.3994083405,
-0.8951941729,
0.8451840878,
0.3547385931,
-0.3619708717,
0.8406825066,
-0.6805669665,
0.2356699556,
0.2560569942,
0.0710768327,
-0.6027943492,
-0.3469796777,
0.1142684668,
-0.3691146374,
0.2441041321,
-0.116543375,
-0.465775609,
-0.5568764806,
-0.2628907859,
0.1520573199,
0.3200114071,
-0.5877376199,
0.0201249663,
0.794347167,
-0.3308931887,
-0.3933879435,
-0.3198115528,
0.0536992699,
-0.2885816097,
-0.6214706302,
0.4165711403,
-0.379535079,
-0.3963713646,
0.2638847828,
-0.0965723246,
-0.3449437618,
-0.35062626,
0.301838249,
0.1821116358,
-0.3372562826,
0.0477273427,
0.2208803743,
0.1319190264,
-0.1360997558,
-0.3278726041,
0.1239062548,
0.3513484895,
-0.1038770005,
0.1304702461,
0.5351836681,
0.3761784434,
0.0106240287,
0.3218711019,
0.041845791,
-0.719727397,
-0.8872147799,
-0.228545174,
0.1231270954,
-0.4460293353,
0.3595217764,
-0.444065094,
-0.8001643419,
0.2882957458,
0.0223401971,
0.3992776275,
0.7939606905,
0.2928910255,
0.1507491767,
0.7368304133,
0.4655852914,
0.1486613452,
-0.1530875415,
-0.1541147977,
0.2230354548,
-0.4917321205,
-0.1812582165,
-0.3999397159,
-0.236049518,
-0.5186863542,
-0.5631898642,
0.3111634851,
0.1245959327,
0.0469389111,
0.4881793559,
-0.394130975,
0.5356562138,
-0.0132657373,
-0.1776838154,
0.3096717298,
0.5706212521,
-0.0068967738,
-0.3555752039,
-0.4401832223,
-0.5402306318,
1.2542897463,
0.0046859127,
0.7007879019,
0.2686136067,
0.5066151619,
0.8825366497,
0.3267279267,
-0.4300269783,
0.3738346994,
-0.6148660779,
-0.6182588339,
-0.5482542515,
-0.6247987747,
-0.8361856341,
-0.1564062238,
-0.3016968369,
-0.333106935,
0.1761875153,
-0.3590114415,
-0.2747094035,
0.4671299756,
-0.4956011474,
0.7014287114,
0.2751412988,
-0.070904471,
-0.0685044155,
-0.0037097472,
0.3838659525,
-0.3176647127,
-0.0604563877,
0.1522869766,
0.0596562959,
1.0921325684,
-0.058062233,
0.42247051,
0.0108458409,
-0.3578168154,
0.6408755779,
0.3478834927,
0.1610458195,
0.1771313548,
-0.0727281421,
0.1933200061,
0.0817775726,
0.1259969622,
-0.4953159392,
1.4058874846,
-0.6130511761,
-0.1439997554,
-0.1047041491,
-0.3800519407,
-0.558514595,
0.3571057618,
0.3143300116,
0.7725324631,
-1.1150329113,
-0.0804501846,
1.1265844107,
-0.2189737111,
-0.0352023914,
0.7232661843,
-0.188672021,
-0.5946739912,
1.0619647503,
0.1432122439,
0.055527702,
0.2798351049,
-0.3991343975,
-0.2244868129,
-0.4333924651,
-0.7320343256,
0.2379178852,
-0.4803153872,
-0.3239884973,
-0.5986964107,
-0.3673194647,
-0.482180506,
-0.0779538974,
0.0845261365,
-0.4190731645,
-0.2546669245,
-0.2122979015,
0.4038569629,
1.3654367924,
0.0106270323,
0.0579918735,
-0.5774442554,
0.6787726283,
0.3955028653,
0.6352081299,
0.0779980943,
-0.1180327311,
-0.1435672045,
0.151470378,
0.1292918473,
-0.9280754924,
0.265711695,
0.148920998,
0.7849835157,
0.3803195655,
0.1013188288,
0.4175240993,
-0.8708173633,
1.0093812943,
0.1636957526,
-0.4413667023,
0.29807055,
-0.2916017771,
-0.2142256051,
0.4067916274,
0.3974716663,
-0.9244322777,
-0.1123870686,
-0.8533294797,
-0.4554117918,
0.8350343108,
0.1730482429,
-0.0150031252,
-0.3407279253,
0.3004180193,
0.6478333473,
0.1822441518,
-0.1717882901,
-0.587843895,
0.1961938292,
-0.1065357178,
-0.0943869874,
-0.2203538567,
-0.2822841108,
0.117048189,
0.6598037481,
-0.058370132,
0.3015730381,
-0.001402915,
0.2000967711,
-0.4037466645,
-0.016645126,
0.3042668402,
0.9372527599,
-0.1203468293,
-0.0751874372,
0.2501283884,
-0.9368424416,
-0.195399791,
0.0680361614,
-0.2626079917,
0.3507765234,
0.5408011675,
0.7909993529,
-0.1085473895,
-0.5287294388,
0.3605231941,
-0.2039680183,
-0.1907214969,
0.0096936096,
0.2518197596,
0.0006262377,
-0.0016009565,
0.4388596416,
-0.1527712941,
0.2742028832,
-0.1789325476,
0.4985684454,
0.0690848306,
-0.4054722786,
-0.3563653231,
0.3236453831,
0.2589786947,
0.0299442131,
0.5167547464,
-0.2785590887,
-0.2190851122,
0.551571846,
0.6246961951,
0.9257252812,
-0.1214897856,
0.5318274498,
0.5352665782,
0.3396181762,
0.2482928634,
0.1836176515,
0.0560384542,
-0.518958807,
-0.1091281921,
-0.8041903973,
-0.0379782766,
0.2215328813,
-0.4186556637,
0.162434116,
-0.3873856664,
-0.0939911008,
-0.0146682421,
0.4315875173,
-0.735041976,
0.4431064427,
-0.1949632317,
0.8999420404,
-0.6102544665,
0.5935438871,
0.4891450703,
-0.0735769421,
-0.4590454102,
0.2177260816,
-0.2182906568,
-0.3107825518,
0.3425301611,
-0.464761585,
0.0396646708,
0.0001537007,
-0.5957022309,
-0.6152042747,
1.0201005936,
-0.2696907222,
-0.4864910841,
-0.0433125608,
0.1736636013,
0.7872579098,
-0.5517148972,
-0.3640521467,
0.5556651354,
0.380486995,
-0.0397287048,
-0.9477111101,
-0.0584208295,
-0.2602250576,
-0.0418411046,
0.3409413993,
-0.0813449174,
0.7602276802,
-0.161865741,
-0.703851521,
-0.018305447,
0.6946175694,
0.2260115296,
0.3190771937,
0.504314363,
0.5328719616,
0.7067815065,
-0.0556921512,
0.8841844797,
0.1445023865,
0.3427343965,
0.9248133302,
-0.5504003167,
0.631419301,
0.0353723876,
-0.4816398919,
0.179494679,
0.4129216671,
0.0062182043,
0.7467554212,
0.3578693569,
-0.4471941292,
0.2516871095,
-0.2116459459,
-0.6940087676,
-0.2106559575,
0.5141817331,
-0.1044717953,
-0.1046239436,
-0.2233413458,
-0.0752464607,
-0.092801936,
-0.2538662851,
0.9975594878,
-0.057074815,
-0.5838662386,
0.5343926549,
0.1819804311,
0.4346040487,
-0.7953093648,
-0.2357050627,
-0.5598291755,
-0.0365626067,
-0.2755611837,
-1.060136795,
0.0076698982,
0.3477010429,
-0.4831905663,
0.0957723558,
0.8024994135,
-0.5914545059,
-0.2566073239,
0.0198804159,
0.3413127959,
0.2036150247,
0.2155892104,
-0.3421738744,
-0.0562398918,
0.2628281415,
-0.14907372,
0.0571742989,
1.2056010962,
-0.209621951,
0.1287852526,
0.574968636,
0.3508842587,
-0.1053071171,
-0.0622784607,
0.898337841,
-0.4905529618,
-0.5227408409,
-0.184277758,
0.0536308214,
-0.2894924581,
-0.7400994301,
0.9450355172,
0.6322730184,
0.8235464692,
-0.3253102899,
1.0098929405,
-0.6304555535,
0.7102446556,
-0.3586486578,
1.1203838587,
-0.3888191879,
-0.1155806407,
-0.3192388117,
-1.1068109274,
0.0413803421,
0.1458306015,
0.0437028334,
-0.1638257653,
0.5889146328,
0.6084281802,
-0.1581053585,
0.3627913892,
0.4164327979,
0.1570034325,
0.010428722,
0.5113487244,
0.710303843,
-0.2407999635,
0.1653950512,
-0.1811196655,
-0.3089527786,
0.256665796,
-0.6036709547,
-0.9666711688,
-0.9749919176,
-0.1524837911,
-0.4927100837,
0.0586925521,
0.3296071589,
0.2591410577,
-0.957760632,
-0.2938925624,
0.5536038876,
0.1899407208,
-0.2155008167,
-0.3060061932,
0.5368321538,
0.2943848372,
-0.5766566396,
0.4589118958,
0.1443232298,
-0.1305900961,
-0.5017229915,
-0.37636289,
0.0233985092,
0.1359355748,
0.5957722664,
0.3243662417,
-0.3465696871,
-0.2325188518,
0.1759800613,
-0.2999269962,
-0.5326216221,
1.0227087736,
-0.6375662684,
0.5010915399,
0.6446755528,
0.3714126348,
0.2412500381,
-0.220926106,
0.6625083685,
-0.9464773536,
-0.2500454485,
0.1859371662,
-0.1233300194,
0.3260902166,
-0.3225217164,
0.5855160356,
0.4298433065,
-0.3298897147,
-0.769918561,
-0.0320633762,
-0.702822566,
-0.301212579,
1.1398804188,
-0.0157106426,
-0.3092953265,
-0.1745654643,
-0.3050040007,
0.0706008673,
-0.0664212033,
0.5562179089,
0.7005025744,
0.1416611969,
0.6706077456,
-0.5754292607,
1.0801105499,
-0.7023308873,
-0.9124949574,
0.4058883786,
1.0576218367,
0.2634017766,
0.2389095128,
0.7540256977,
-0.1413767487,
0.1160899848,
0.3938522637,
0.1216156855,
0.0254295506,
-0.5555484295,
0.1619998515,
0.1328543574,
-0.4658427835,
0.1161572114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09072v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09072v1 | Let's Negotiate! A Survey of Negotiation Dialogue Systems | 2022-12-18T12:03:53 | 2022-12-18T12:03:53 | Haolan Zhan, Yufei Wang, Tao Feng, Yuncheng Hua, Suraj Sharma, Zhuang Li, Lizhen Qu, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Negotiation is one of the crucial abilities in human communication, and there
has been a resurgent research interest in negotiation dialogue systems
recently, which goal is to empower intelligent agents with such ability that
can efficiently help humans resolve conflicts or reach beneficial agreements.
Although there have been many explorations in negotiation dialogue systems, a
systematic review of this task has to date remained notably absent. To this
end, we aim to fill this gap by reviewing contemporary studies in the emerging
field of negotiation dialogue systems, covering benchmarks, evaluations, and
methodologies. Furthermore, we also discuss potential future directions,
including multi-modal, multi-party, and cross-cultural negotiation scenarios.
Our goal is to provide the community with a systematic overview of negotiation
dialogue systems and to inspire future research. | [
-0.85760355,
-0.2645631433,
0.5335221291,
0.0903176516,
-0.1320279986,
0.4573377371,
-0.2713526487,
-0.8627073765,
0.6417356133,
0.2710232139,
-0.4817814529,
-0.055167485,
-0.7473509312,
0.2324904948,
0.0116705764,
0.43950966,
0.3966720998,
0.3218858838,
0.1058546454,
-0.3832370341,
-0.5326769948,
-0.527038753,
-0.8498008847,
-0.4894705415,
0.4728137255,
0.3610514104,
0.746820569,
-0.2896415293,
0.6975417137,
0.4523997009,
-0.310146749,
-0.1176510453,
-0.1882038414,
0.6932219267,
-0.405651927,
-0.0932978019,
-0.5281473398,
0.2878980339,
0.3587256074,
0.827724278,
-0.184179768,
0.074708879,
-0.1245659813,
0.4354127049,
-0.4428812861,
0.1332771778,
-0.7253900766,
0.2212152928,
0.2419483215,
0.122841984,
-0.2115347534,
-0.7529640198,
0.4458662271,
-0.7313743234,
-0.1520066559,
0.013281866,
0.5586186647,
0.0661957264,
-0.7460263968,
-0.1877994537,
-0.7334290743,
0.5580165982,
-0.367039144,
0.3226228952,
0.4041292965,
0.6710547209,
-0.2832918465,
-1.0009971857,
-0.2651896477,
-0.3034234941,
-0.1172727793,
0.4847297966,
-0.1559265405,
0.2277728021,
0.2841196358,
0.1986183822,
-0.3358750343,
-0.1606052816,
-0.6469373703,
-0.3411200345,
0.8826732635,
0.1686610878,
0.3098459542,
0.0491778925,
-0.4876580834,
0.0869325548,
-0.2175746262,
0.2284955382,
0.1829268485,
0.2457908839,
0.3082954884,
0.2791820168,
-0.7005902529,
0.5208485723,
0.0493605807,
0.1202339754,
-0.3075852692,
-0.5803733468,
-0.0969592854,
-0.2181058526,
0.8769152164,
0.6545296311,
-0.026777165,
-0.0578494556,
-0.19206357,
0.170300141,
0.3307210803,
-0.5105028749,
0.1121458039,
0.211580649,
-0.7283424735,
-0.1423221081,
0.0108535755,
-0.7173864841,
-0.2012002468,
-0.2626492977,
0.1348379701,
-0.1405832171,
-0.6795967817,
0.2580705583,
-0.6810653806,
0.4466828108,
0.424079746,
-0.6491282582,
0.9445442557,
0.508428812,
0.5177873969,
0.3920578957,
-0.3184129596,
-0.0913606584,
-0.2515126169,
-0.445799619,
0.8943676353,
-0.7155141234,
-0.7287611365,
0.0756109431,
-0.4124396443,
0.0262445752,
-0.40908131,
0.6854997277,
-0.5616834164,
0.0951887518,
-0.5879921913,
-0.1501139849,
0.0389440767,
0.8936697245,
-0.6286473274,
0.3800150752,
-0.1138910577,
-0.2599929273,
0.3281459808,
-0.4585025907,
-0.2048463821,
0.2712960839,
-0.2780184746,
-0.037527997,
0.078678377,
-0.0386473164,
0.0946466029,
-0.6235513687,
0.296330452,
-0.0955768451,
-0.3781968057,
0.6736950278,
-0.0500876307,
0.614644289,
0.5073324442,
0.0038854836,
0.309279263,
-0.1008694991,
0.1017002389,
0.0293726027,
-0.1550176591,
0.016117109,
-0.0810431316,
-0.1118988097,
0.360350579,
0.317718327,
-0.6679031849,
0.6169384122,
0.0253978707,
0.4975283444,
0.5268393159,
0.0412865691,
0.6551944613,
-0.5125355721,
0.8405716419,
-0.4142483175,
0.557507515,
0.0132097239,
-0.559415102,
-0.7892882228,
0.1410364658,
0.3433757126,
0.2808787823,
-0.7981312871,
0.0680630356,
-0.1916288584,
-0.5094490647,
-0.3773987591,
-0.5212369561,
0.4524847269,
-0.0773808658,
0.0981231108,
-0.6759384274,
-0.3950515985,
-0.6112154722,
-0.4816192985,
-0.4732556641,
0.0455082133,
0.1506557167,
0.025608927,
0.1877905428,
0.8792182803,
-0.1761501729,
-0.3756557405,
-0.4622970819,
0.3386755586,
-0.2321757525,
0.3295673728,
0.5612498522,
-0.6731610298,
-0.5819150805,
0.1544205993,
-0.5097441673,
0.4183154702,
-0.0183345396,
0.0066088797,
-0.1663801819,
0.8885683417,
-0.5474180579,
0.4311112761,
0.2646360695,
-0.2872743309,
0.4346464574,
-0.0245292857,
0.5149447918,
-0.5756736398,
-0.1174114645,
-0.2412149161,
-0.1669622213,
-0.6711291075,
-0.0084944014,
-0.2400443554,
-0.5014654398,
-0.3373414278,
0.2582495809,
-0.7073667645,
-0.002821171,
-0.032986939,
0.3200784326,
-0.187471047,
0.4472983181,
0.2741700113,
0.2725262642,
0.5067610145,
-0.6291314363,
0.4726481736,
0.5572066903,
-0.2986948192,
0.8242329359,
-0.5600778461,
0.2733059525,
0.1495202035,
0.8353765607,
-0.5369734168,
-0.3108910918,
0.7561298013,
-0.5857335329,
0.2190212309,
-0.3327254057,
0.1065166146,
-0.1541490257,
-0.3602742255,
0.612911284,
0.2663144469,
0.0591134056,
0.5714470744,
0.3869274855,
-0.415892005,
-0.6694756746,
-0.247708872,
0.567691803,
0.0814433545,
-0.5048030019,
0.1485285163,
-0.1135339662,
-0.587932229,
-0.2623740137,
-0.028785361,
-0.1743553579,
0.0018205502,
-0.0643402413,
-0.2355122119,
0.2034029514,
0.1039727703,
0.0188696533,
-0.4703783989,
-0.0322744064,
0.0121808108,
0.5292502642,
-0.1348430663,
-0.538166821,
-0.4147887826,
0.7882448435,
0.6487792134,
-0.5366334319,
0.383240521,
0.2020129412,
-0.3169790804,
0.4192202985,
-0.4789605737,
-0.4551579058,
-0.4445112348,
0.180224508,
-0.5911690593,
-0.791670382,
0.5518438816,
-0.7264344096,
0.1696458012,
0.0939274877,
0.0357101224,
-0.0910527036,
1.0884869099,
0.5830998421,
0.0481985547,
0.5559595823,
-0.1301199496,
0.5336675048,
-0.7036579847,
-0.3392200768,
-0.8310421109,
-0.5843849778,
-0.6488457918,
-0.23123236,
0.4844067693,
0.130996719,
-0.0468716472,
0.2500485778,
-0.5202414393,
0.368288964,
0.2010915428,
0.0054299873,
0.4133732319,
-0.6374644637,
0.0457136892,
-0.0375735275,
-0.5789262652,
-0.446780175,
0.6872299314,
0.2672419548,
0.4907741249,
0.3975419402,
0.5761905909,
-0.0257115103,
0.3259275854,
-1.057703495,
0.9832009077,
0.5369756818,
-0.6485866904,
-0.5582306981,
-0.2078925967,
-1.4049360752,
0.4858565032,
-0.131207034,
-0.8054669499,
0.4111474454,
-0.3789947331,
-0.1435833871,
0.1922933608,
-0.2538950443,
0.4779351652,
-0.2872221768,
-0.1783764362,
-0.5686351657,
-0.8516874313,
0.1719060838,
0.5230983496,
0.2626298666,
-0.2460863888,
-0.0650492236,
0.592885673,
-0.0449573174,
0.6651807427,
-0.1081151813,
0.0675461665,
0.1119526625,
0.2890369594,
0.2094675601,
-0.049642846,
-0.2491876483,
0.0310050882,
0.1177303866,
-0.385271281,
-0.7124521136,
0.2849911153,
-0.4063802958,
-0.7632658482,
-0.8703006506,
-0.4005437195,
-0.3703389168,
0.0681543276,
0.1525267661,
0.144023478,
-0.7928128839,
-0.1823314279,
0.2463278472,
0.4687665999,
0.5335412621,
0.4250418246,
-0.336690098,
-0.4089478254,
0.8899649978,
0.2119820714,
0.3452431858,
-0.2669071555,
-0.1260071695,
-0.1464958191,
-0.6602050662,
-0.1348401308,
0.0196313914,
-0.662709713,
-0.3563413322,
-0.1358905733,
-0.2003783733,
-0.5561050773,
-0.3705224395,
-0.3115234375,
-0.7627361417,
0.2872581482,
-0.1911518574,
0.1307041645,
1.2375733852,
-0.3019589186,
0.2338820249,
-0.885204792,
0.1603043377,
0.5717548728,
0.4396648407,
-0.1361436248,
-0.0258682687,
-0.2851121128,
-0.0277021714,
-0.6583085656,
-1.0571871996,
0.2721978724,
-0.0884603932,
0.8487050533,
0.3903251886,
0.4059351981,
0.4951455295,
-0.1601710171,
1.2312334776,
0.4735561907,
-0.9732869267,
0.6713712811,
-0.3022639155,
0.0516556501,
0.6645238996,
0.4017055035,
-0.8297938704,
-0.3671300411,
-0.785625577,
-0.9320910573,
0.6211593747,
0.1184435412,
0.0250788517,
0.2839844525,
0.1064302251,
-0.0716594458,
0.3393059969,
-0.5263115764,
-0.0429966338,
0.1473873705,
0.4587292969,
0.180012852,
0.0602182224,
-0.7170415521,
-0.1575361192,
0.3699487746,
-0.245447576,
0.0902877748,
0.1704581827,
-0.0032435965,
-0.2324377447,
0.7216955423,
0.3762467206,
0.8031896949,
-0.0545954518,
-0.208174035,
0.2617659271,
-0.2732749879,
0.3051120043,
0.0773956403,
0.2731721997,
-0.1673823893,
-0.0021435404,
0.3676937521,
0.262822181,
-0.4644788802,
0.3663050532,
-0.8253282309,
-0.7111623883,
-0.0912797377,
-0.1780833453,
-0.2331873029,
0.7036347985,
0.2543388605,
0.2525623143,
0.3486265838,
-0.7656816244,
-0.2639641464,
0.7032188177,
-0.6941691637,
-0.1461036652,
0.0735246241,
0.8499888778,
-0.6966314316,
0.5762228966,
-0.1031346768,
-0.7715089321,
0.2334536761,
0.022892125,
0.7014961839,
-0.3024826944,
0.3963096738,
0.1620977968,
0.4336464703,
0.1071823835,
0.3388362527,
-0.7319997549,
-0.7493963242,
-0.0123508992,
-0.1865402013,
-1.1933501959,
-0.3450843394,
-0.9978892207,
0.0690359697,
-0.3612166047,
-0.6507619023,
-0.2694453895,
0.2439945787,
-0.8147137165,
0.0116117615,
-0.0348862484,
1.010618329,
-0.6143208146,
0.5010330677,
0.7475075722,
-0.6020975709,
-0.3120682538,
0.0678222701,
-0.2087558359,
-0.0387245491,
0.3016125262,
-0.1414371431,
-0.4509762228,
-0.1994311064,
-0.7637294531,
-0.5626467466,
1.0413134098,
0.4897154868,
-0.3346042037,
-0.056579534,
-0.1148990393,
0.3512917757,
-0.0210977625,
0.5901183486,
1.1428232193,
0.849203229,
-0.0038658683,
-1.3208253384,
-0.1349543333,
-0.4063670039,
-0.1521776915,
-0.0624986552,
-1.3016556501,
0.5558765531,
0.1561349332,
-0.1789484918,
0.4913722277,
0.5356654525,
0.2151541561,
0.385951072,
0.5412446856,
0.1660507023,
0.5870552659,
-0.3795142472,
0.8113224506,
-0.1497264504,
0.1740115434,
0.6790646911,
-0.4315497875,
0.5912013054,
0.5798351765,
-0.1886376441,
0.3225278556,
0.837389946,
0.7211447954,
0.1036464423,
0.460071981,
-0.4789464474,
-0.7305325866,
-0.5272818804,
-0.4813514948,
0.5052031875,
0.6112118363,
0.2951350212,
-0.1929338425,
-0.1635991335,
-0.3906912208,
0.0676373392,
-0.0126032885,
1.1032327414,
0.2667087615,
-0.8149294853,
0.1039630026,
-0.1935883909,
0.4679616988,
-0.9530801177,
-0.2425826937,
-0.02166434,
-0.4326400757,
-0.0872508362,
-0.643904984,
0.0603431053,
-0.5808276534,
0.0928403661,
-0.9409989715,
0.9357207417,
-0.1314611286,
-0.0006033394,
0.5132742524,
0.7376667261,
0.3780931532,
0.0857615173,
-0.5799725652,
0.4796437025,
-0.3352646232,
-0.3255434632,
0.5226384401,
0.3474206328,
0.129924193,
0.6709452868,
0.5054441094,
0.2163397372,
-0.1256534606,
0.0058512986,
1.1316684484,
-0.8687906861,
-0.2802608311,
0.0322746001,
0.8478137255,
-0.3952225447,
-0.3338501751,
0.3811035752,
0.1656578183,
0.7097343206,
0.3958027363,
1.0464334488,
-0.0693136305,
0.276904285,
-0.4127971828,
0.6727291942,
-0.3144910932,
-0.0718668699,
-0.0499755628,
-0.5746766329,
-0.110037744,
0.7122311592,
-0.1523559839,
-0.0950994641,
0.8265810609,
0.3048071861,
0.0185778048,
0.5668990612,
0.607627213,
-0.1361848563,
0.3900112212,
0.222963959,
1.3564425707,
-0.548868835,
0.6658570766,
-0.1156882867,
-0.1461485028,
-0.2639464438,
-0.5252782106,
-0.4432259798,
-0.7782268524,
-0.2016371787,
-0.1970417947,
-0.0194301438,
0.9071334004,
0.7834558487,
-0.3334318101,
-0.600427568,
0.333100915,
0.464115262,
-0.4904038608,
-0.0915706307,
-0.3349890113,
-0.4961149693,
-0.9521991014,
0.8006490469,
0.2234293967,
0.0714857578,
-0.3467252851,
-0.1705762595,
-0.1284464151,
0.323356837,
0.4178067148,
0.6181251407,
-0.7318315506,
-0.2944235802,
0.0703307018,
-0.0779921561,
-0.0353079736,
1.6015207767,
-0.8216571808,
0.4939213097,
0.552125752,
0.2651017904,
0.4907262623,
-0.3499462903,
0.8898169398,
-0.3543450236,
0.3388970792,
0.7171697021,
0.4041594565,
0.097741507,
0.1476597935,
0.4365825653,
-0.2434565127,
-0.7135339975,
-0.5594284534,
0.6838625669,
-1.0362704992,
-0.1108262464,
0.4913066328,
-0.2042351514,
0.3087117672,
-0.6532226801,
-0.5770618916,
0.2351891398,
-0.6180884838,
0.516264677,
0.790825367,
-0.6117972732,
0.0498898029,
-0.0105392709,
0.4595935643,
0.3848890364,
-0.6261258721,
-0.2252174914,
0.5592666268,
-0.2850412428,
0.4239714146,
1.1617189646,
0.1616133004,
0.4026204944,
0.0405967571,
0.0058602174,
0.6246086955,
-0.565566361,
-0.4007838368,
0.2310346365,
0.4137166142,
-0.0241099279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09058v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09058v1 | BEATs: Audio Pre-Training with Acoustic Tokenizers | 2022-12-18T10:41:55 | 2022-12-18T10:41:55 | Sanyuan Chen, Yu Wu, Chengyi Wang, Shujie Liu, Daniel Tompkins, Zhuo Chen, Furu Wei | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | The massive growth of self-supervised learning (SSL) has been witnessed in
language, vision, speech, and audio domains over the past few years. While
discrete label prediction is widely adopted for other modalities, the
state-of-the-art audio SSL models still employ reconstruction loss for
pre-training. Compared with reconstruction loss, semantic-rich discrete label
prediction encourages the SSL model to abstract the high-level audio semantics
and discard the redundant details as in human perception. However, a
semantic-rich acoustic tokenizer for general audio pre-training is usually not
straightforward to obtain, due to the continuous property of audio and
unavailable phoneme sequences like speech. To tackle this challenge, we propose
BEATs, an iterative audio pre-training framework to learn Bidirectional Encoder
representation from Audio Transformers, where an acoustic tokenizer and an
audio SSL model are optimized by iterations. In the first iteration, we use
random projection as the acoustic tokenizer to train an audio SSL model in a
mask and label prediction manner. Then, we train an acoustic tokenizer for the
next iteration by distilling the semantic knowledge from the pre-trained or
fine-tuned audio SSL model. The iteration is repeated with the hope of mutual
promotion of the acoustic tokenizer and audio SSL model. The experimental
results demonstrate our acoustic tokenizers can generate discrete labels with
rich audio semantics and our audio SSL models achieve state-of-the-art results
across various audio classification benchmarks, even outperforming previous
models that use more training data and model parameters significantly.
Specifically, we set a new state-of-the-art mAP 50.6% on AudioSet-2M for
audio-only models without using any external data, and 98.1% accuracy on
ESC-50. The code and pre-trained models are available at https://aka.ms/beats. | [
-0.3892800808,
-0.1909829974,
0.4403663278,
0.0845882371,
-0.4367232025,
0.2498899102,
-0.1527658105,
-0.3450754583,
0.4975935817,
0.2886662185,
-0.9635922909,
-0.6968739033,
-0.6295173764,
-0.0178326033,
-0.395337224,
1.039624095,
0.2719728351,
0.2729552984,
-0.1939155161,
-0.0312893838,
-0.5011066794,
-0.4089023173,
-0.5252040029,
-0.3106973767,
0.197308436,
0.0607680343,
0.2389194369,
0.357424438,
0.3604578972,
0.3836876154,
-0.2186422646,
-0.1618575454,
-0.2544229925,
0.0633610263,
0.1071181819,
-0.1882920712,
-0.6698673368,
0.3575635254,
0.2671744525,
0.6297827959,
-0.2462585568,
0.5900951624,
-0.1179275438,
0.3569943905,
-0.4089024067,
0.0363344066,
-0.853151381,
0.171331346,
-0.2750695646,
-0.5197114348,
-0.3584600687,
-0.0618770793,
0.0606005117,
-0.9349415302,
0.1100892201,
0.0259024091,
0.6604281068,
0.6151679754,
-0.1685869396,
-0.4669901133,
-0.9057702422,
0.6037328243,
-0.5897926092,
0.9746448398,
0.5562890172,
0.5392263532,
0.1298256069,
-1.1007173061,
-0.512704134,
-0.0321985371,
0.463842392,
0.6283197999,
0.1529930979,
0.217814073,
0.0894340873,
0.5959034562,
-0.2398962826,
0.0771375969,
-0.5200181603,
-0.3218837082,
0.3992449343,
-0.2165317088,
0.2368079722,
0.105066292,
-0.5116872787,
-0.1102557555,
-0.6616377234,
0.2623175383,
0.4678462148,
0.5069288611,
-0.1894923449,
0.1777810901,
0.0618626066,
0.7484987378,
0.292832166,
-0.6066028476,
0.5805910826,
-0.3791479468,
0.1001717746,
0.6217928529,
0.7048375607,
-0.108891964,
0.2040507197,
-0.1737019569,
-0.4250805378,
0.1896718591,
0.3454329967,
-0.8229638338,
-0.25168854,
0.4202071726,
-0.2872977555,
-0.0384995975,
-0.1276006252,
0.0078235371,
0.0135584632,
-0.9118822813,
0.8000750542,
-0.2738215625,
-0.2370110601,
0.275077641,
-0.1903974116,
-0.113099657,
0.1411037892,
-0.69354105,
0.2454927713,
0.5502200723,
0.7124741673,
-0.1455343217,
-0.2313062549,
-0.6760426164,
0.2687512934,
-0.3354186118,
0.5105829239,
-0.345192492,
-0.6036183238,
-0.0682915598,
-0.2535118759,
0.1753424257,
-0.5509912372,
0.5296715498,
-0.4626041651,
-0.0574928299,
0.0434864275,
-0.6787875891,
0.2093868703,
-0.1587962061,
-0.3749994338,
0.7081803679,
-0.234542802,
-0.6967334151,
0.498437345,
-0.368352294,
-0.5082118511,
0.0862606689,
-0.2722711265,
-0.6071192026,
0.0325804166,
0.033093676,
0.2183497101,
-0.0725010037,
0.2974185944,
-0.3372484148,
-0.6600675583,
0.0933672637,
-0.0911052823,
0.8793535829,
0.148195371,
-0.4708545506,
0.2658214867,
-1.107593298,
-0.2420816422,
-0.1819279939,
-0.2491278499,
-0.0952841118,
-0.0995038971,
0.1927965581,
0.2314357758,
-0.1670858562,
-0.8462443352,
-0.1499808878,
-0.3109719753,
0.497698009,
0.9580699801,
-0.299307704,
0.3551370203,
-0.0976333395,
0.5344244242,
0.0852326453,
0.1640062779,
-0.2998372018,
-0.2127196342,
-0.5047363639,
-0.6341884136,
0.471508503,
0.388499856,
-0.2519613206,
0.5976957679,
-0.3041505218,
-0.4960578978,
-1.1723963022,
0.0966710523,
0.2995196879,
0.694750011,
0.7579176426,
-0.5454927087,
-0.7666943669,
-0.4950756431,
-0.1634585261,
-0.1094006449,
-0.3605790436,
0.1599671394,
0.2709120214,
-0.4585731328,
1.0799371004,
-0.0292560123,
-0.7408789396,
0.2390875965,
0.3636280298,
0.2841531336,
0.7569838762,
0.2083293945,
-0.7285679579,
-0.052284535,
-0.494071722,
-0.3297333717,
-0.162171796,
-0.1008078828,
0.0674600229,
-0.3865325749,
0.6966872811,
-0.2856889665,
0.2958549559,
0.4722828865,
-0.0407861918,
0.5899024606,
0.0493053049,
0.0165128782,
-0.9001665711,
-0.2158097923,
-0.370739013,
-0.261270076,
-0.4926394224,
-0.5708120465,
-0.1190291494,
-0.4773264825,
-0.4600897133,
0.3153204322,
-0.2028423995,
-0.5054588318,
-0.1789287925,
0.1479018331,
-0.0849079788,
0.4326612651,
0.3669087291,
0.8004332781,
0.6030430198,
-0.557805419,
0.1415758431,
0.3144226074,
-0.2956239581,
0.5549243689,
-0.8313589692,
0.4369951785,
-0.1343240738,
0.466437459,
-0.9329761863,
0.2669918835,
-0.1828643978,
-0.7204009295,
0.4863625467,
-0.3789159954,
-0.2469223291,
-0.676065743,
-0.0024674048,
0.5844060779,
0.6538665295,
-0.7210373878,
0.7385497689,
0.5593602657,
0.004774109,
-0.3402958512,
-0.6287862659,
-0.2833515406,
-0.0886614621,
-0.1873778552,
0.5567473769,
-0.5893180966,
0.1688397378,
-0.1842118502,
-0.5323337317,
-0.1011674777,
0.0606788993,
0.7058156729,
0.2001351267,
-0.0274895802,
0.2356808037,
-0.2533705533,
-0.4583021402,
0.1741064638,
-0.8167747855,
0.3517919481,
-0.133066833,
-0.5510741472,
-0.7891010642,
-0.0127692185,
0.4569212198,
-0.6407408714,
0.0077485647,
0.5411661863,
-0.0896535292,
-0.1106450111,
-0.4594914019,
-0.1151029915,
-0.5736727118,
0.2671757042,
-0.7459706068,
-0.7064121962,
0.275421083,
-0.2729564607,
-0.0590665229,
0.0923338979,
0.3983166218,
-0.5347300172,
0.8498858213,
0.4194659591,
-0.0624338575,
0.4174855649,
-0.4923684299,
0.097284846,
-0.6560700536,
-0.1522767693,
-0.4382293522,
-0.0811730921,
-0.4582248926,
-0.3061741889,
0.3310043812,
0.0149992397,
-0.3395070434,
0.3946799636,
-0.5099285841,
0.385948658,
0.8331165314,
0.0889734179,
-0.0046689981,
-0.15472956,
-0.145912841,
-0.0397765227,
-0.373768419,
0.118930161,
1.1600140333,
0.4190507233,
0.4571022093,
-0.3407713473,
1.2427309752,
0.3484596908,
0.052935522,
-0.8543390632,
0.1747842729,
0.0150885861,
-0.4779344797,
-0.3012109995,
-0.2475400418,
-0.593023777,
-0.0157088134,
-0.2024633586,
-0.2180355042,
0.0752086937,
0.3566755056,
-0.4406053722,
0.2530319691,
-0.1946270615,
0.6796175241,
-0.1750955731,
-0.006111145,
-0.0172014721,
-0.55202806,
0.0151715595,
-0.3006779552,
0.6364030242,
-0.2185816914,
0.2956970036,
0.9717711806,
-0.435066849,
0.6362247467,
-0.5780066252,
-0.1067260429,
0.4945190549,
-0.1177872568,
0.3433575332,
-0.1702524722,
0.2843465805,
0.3797643483,
-0.0923077986,
-0.4273392558,
-0.2923492491,
0.2298867553,
-0.7560886741,
-0.4124392867,
0.0265125167,
-0.2488972247,
-0.5773922205,
0.2703032792,
0.4432799816,
0.817858398,
0.192110762,
0.0860359669,
0.5702686906,
-0.1424078494,
0.3908854127,
0.416236788,
-0.0216985364,
-0.5522431135,
0.9339821339,
0.1824555993,
0.0694759786,
0.0780617893,
0.1842945367,
-0.3584245443,
-0.8294584751,
-0.2626464367,
0.0525888242,
-0.589512527,
-0.1984063834,
-0.6106962562,
-0.1085525006,
-0.6595130563,
-0.2581466436,
-1.023583889,
-0.2979307175,
-0.0885247812,
-0.4116344452,
0.1073375419,
0.488109678,
-0.234784469,
0.414799571,
-0.6095212698,
0.6932957768,
0.6479068995,
0.4675607085,
-0.3734811842,
-0.9301202297,
-0.19673118,
-0.0509166345,
0.1425930411,
-0.7810934186,
0.0627982467,
0.19629471,
0.2689042687,
0.5029457808,
0.0794509202,
1.0425457954,
-0.8233709335,
0.552203238,
0.4177375138,
-1.0681601763,
0.6539868712,
-0.2102976441,
0.1996902674,
1.0494400263,
0.4574400485,
-0.275085628,
-0.3840228617,
-0.5962228179,
-0.9683288336,
0.358007133,
0.1595399976,
0.1110395044,
0.0777304396,
0.0872600302,
0.0745656639,
0.3804078996,
-0.6502742767,
-0.4457051456,
-0.8253827691,
-0.263592422,
-0.3287425935,
-0.2545801997,
0.1251948774,
-0.6010919213,
0.9797130823,
-0.0373771861,
0.1594813764,
0.3235165477,
-0.3477530777,
0.1514211744,
0.1186642274,
0.310577929,
0.4633193016,
-0.4494083524,
0.1266926825,
-0.0654261187,
-0.4937902987,
0.4126910865,
0.1190501601,
-0.1667925417,
0.1066132039,
0.4002650976,
1.0799646378,
0.5754306912,
-0.5618555546,
0.8513579369,
-0.065671429,
-0.1606492996,
-0.8320878148,
-0.47234115,
0.2626783252,
0.0073459735,
0.2743564844,
0.0004913813,
0.4330486655,
-0.3807168305,
0.5400379896,
0.089428179,
-0.8398721218,
-0.4900898337,
1.1124266386,
0.2917262018,
-0.4774572849,
0.5722067356,
-0.1704920381,
-0.5475233793,
0.3787733912,
0.6741127372,
1.0896259546,
-0.3993276358,
0.0439104922,
0.5183122754,
0.0390375257,
0.2939424217,
0.0802492276,
-0.8704453707,
-0.5345646143,
-0.4358871281,
-0.991597712,
-0.3589105606,
-0.0670578405,
-0.78336972,
0.2233892083,
-0.3740431666,
-0.2374735475,
0.0577059612,
-0.2813540697,
-0.9036632776,
0.4204429984,
0.3712001443,
0.802559793,
-0.8901754618,
0.8833473921,
0.3909565806,
-0.5579084754,
-0.7956455946,
-0.2543525696,
-0.0153595712,
-0.5959070921,
0.8504447937,
0.3451093435,
-0.3522798121,
0.3341584802,
-0.2823788524,
-0.7090622783,
0.9671108723,
0.0841500834,
-0.932772398,
0.0755631477,
0.1922550797,
0.2931010127,
-0.1968026459,
0.3019652963,
0.5173336864,
0.2426739782,
0.2466143817,
-0.8563863635,
-0.4543906152,
-0.2898091078,
-0.1523490995,
-0.0713714361,
-0.2954061925,
0.7563080192,
-0.1814304739,
-0.104190886,
-0.3005765378,
0.8955745697,
0.4013119638,
0.4513344467,
0.976195097,
0.7384132743,
0.8709080815,
-0.1149899438,
0.8657569885,
-0.5827947259,
0.0515260473,
1.5351747274,
-0.0361351445,
0.7563833594,
0.464304477,
-0.309848696,
0.4488681853,
0.7096886635,
0.0831463262,
0.7280632854,
0.5395603776,
-0.3285359144,
-0.420263052,
-0.0512965247,
-0.4703537226,
0.7732540369,
-0.0952773243,
-0.0428144485,
0.2573291361,
0.4576806724,
-0.2334698886,
-0.0877748877,
-0.3701919317,
0.9381970167,
0.0409273468,
-0.0837330669,
0.5357106924,
-0.5038789511,
0.8505949378,
-0.5573406219,
0.0974339321,
-0.0722220615,
-0.1360591203,
-0.0442558117,
-0.0868503749,
0.1437510699,
-0.2374463677,
-0.0249752924,
-0.4890016615,
0.6361295581,
-0.5260783434,
-0.3206320405,
0.5293501616,
0.0407135338,
0.2278881818,
-0.2168195695,
-0.5143743753,
0.0332677886,
-0.3059898317,
-0.1461215615,
-0.0250576641,
0.1932992637,
0.4614703953,
0.3944662511,
0.847690165,
0.4414100349,
0.3321907222,
0.3455047905,
0.5836314559,
-0.6773199439,
-0.8798445463,
-0.2631776631,
0.4951865077,
0.00004829,
-0.0772849396,
0.3934617937,
0.6880823374,
1.2412295341,
-0.1235596165,
0.5928364992,
0.6082897782,
0.7058262229,
-0.4960172772,
0.6062175035,
-0.5317988396,
0.0877955109,
-0.4340226352,
-0.6469726562,
0.0419009216,
0.3610711992,
-0.0681018531,
-0.078375712,
0.2741126418,
0.4598990083,
0.0043931776,
0.1143176034,
0.309266448,
0.1415127963,
0.1827043146,
0.2082629055,
0.7522406578,
-0.5400788784,
0.4210971296,
-0.5712611079,
-0.1088343635,
0.1534902453,
-0.5405154824,
-0.7608174682,
-0.7919566631,
-0.4862895906,
-0.2319975495,
0.204881072,
0.8716052771,
1.0932871103,
-0.8973938227,
-0.2108640522,
-0.1216403097,
-0.0106330914,
-0.1357456893,
-0.1508269012,
0.4789488018,
-0.5651003122,
-0.7651467919,
0.8946169615,
0.297346741,
0.359326303,
0.0187606011,
-0.279746592,
0.1932567656,
0.1328962147,
0.5651386976,
0.2722021937,
-0.6281698346,
-0.1950021833,
-0.4402611256,
0.1521805376,
0.2721935213,
0.8565118909,
-1.0116912127,
0.8540105224,
0.1812131852,
0.8050464988,
0.8565220833,
-0.1720834076,
0.1967604011,
-0.765596807,
0.3114931881,
0.2302164733,
0.3454458714,
0.2889053226,
0.1524416506,
0.3554072678,
0.3630447686,
-0.3027242124,
-0.9065878391,
0.1967391372,
-0.9860874414,
-0.1693564057,
0.7497072816,
-0.0400440209,
-0.1551777273,
-0.0355439484,
0.0041268757,
0.6499761343,
-0.0743002295,
0.6577085257,
0.2578669488,
0.1563910544,
0.2157110125,
-0.3743370473,
0.8096746206,
0.4523963332,
-0.5302599072,
-0.2110333294,
0.372736305,
0.2024492621,
0.272197634,
1.154487133,
-0.2831101418,
0.1787568331,
0.1032682732,
0.3475344777,
-0.5188741684,
-0.6550915241,
-0.2477028966,
0.1169385612,
-0.0848219097,
-0.6618946195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09056v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09056v1 | Beyond Digital "Echo Chambers": The Role of Viewpoint Diversity in Political Discussion | 2022-12-18T10:18:15 | 2022-12-18T10:18:15 | Rishav Hada, Amir Ebrahimi Fard, Sarah Shugars, Federico Bianchi, Patricia Rossini, Dirk Hovy, Rebekah Tromble, Nava Tintarev | cs.CL | cs.CL | Increasingly taking place in online spaces, modern political conversations
are typically perceived to be unproductively affirming -- siloed in so called
``echo chambers'' of exclusively like-minded discussants. Yet, to date we lack
sufficient means to measure viewpoint diversity in conversations. To this end,
in this paper, we operationalize two viewpoint metrics proposed for recommender
systems and adapt them to the context of social media conversations. This is
the first study to apply these two metrics (Representation and Fragmentation)
to real world data and to consider the implications for online conversations
specifically. We apply these measures to two topics -- daylight savings time
(DST), which serves as a control, and the more politically polarized topic of
immigration. We find that the diversity scores for both Fragmentation and
Representation are lower for immigration than for DST. Further, we find that
while pro-immigrant views receive consistent pushback on the platform,
anti-immigrant views largely operate within echo chambers. We observe less
severe yet similar patterns for DST. Taken together, Representation and
Fragmentation paint a meaningful and important new picture of viewpoint
diversity. | [
-1.0887490511,
-0.5346649885,
0.7038197517,
-0.0866706148,
-0.7795078158,
0.5933509469,
-0.0437421687,
-0.4905722737,
0.791223228,
0.2359947413,
-0.4408501983,
-0.271722883,
-0.6957008839,
-0.102974005,
-0.4118725955,
0.9756472707,
0.3212784231,
0.1411704123,
0.1647837013,
-0.2228782326,
-0.0898112282,
-0.4164549112,
-0.1343548149,
-0.0047849151,
0.5884661078,
0.1906348765,
0.7887256742,
0.4709118009,
0.4312463701,
0.2958750129,
-0.3106097579,
0.0522035584,
-0.6373654604,
0.0994150192,
-0.3358947337,
-0.6249742508,
-0.1281887442,
0.0017997456,
0.6165302992,
0.8284655213,
-0.1499180943,
-0.0614636652,
0.1461511254,
0.8652320504,
-0.6267361641,
-0.1892029941,
-0.7061641216,
0.3000528514,
-0.0509473421,
-0.1156532541,
0.2319642752,
-0.6047492623,
0.2310850471,
-0.3962911963,
0.1552619785,
-0.2187202573,
0.5634550452,
0.05434094,
-0.8104492426,
-0.1783514768,
-1.0835039616,
0.8409519196,
-0.3118669093,
0.36404863,
0.0615397915,
0.4851887226,
0.2324075699,
-0.214526251,
-0.5769621134,
0.4097290039,
0.1452181488,
0.2707488537,
-0.4823085666,
-0.1721295118,
-0.1788335741,
0.6452866793,
-0.0217066556,
-0.3849232495,
-0.6547240615,
-0.0606520288,
0.2932877541,
0.4026072323,
-0.0231057759,
-0.3266999424,
0.1142657846,
0.1077528447,
-0.1674028784,
0.0658621117,
0.8647220135,
0.468077302,
-0.1700997949,
0.1622728109,
-0.1789644212,
0.3784120381,
0.2684130371,
0.2220744044,
0.0552621335,
-0.4892380536,
-0.066252619,
-0.3609127998,
0.4320263863,
0.8180503845,
-0.078962177,
0.2106538117,
0.1826122701,
0.0492447615,
0.5271905661,
-0.6885122657,
-0.0429263674,
0.1544143558,
-0.7430912852,
-0.2142159939,
0.858289957,
-1.1133089066,
-0.9250359535,
-0.1650882065,
-0.3433657587,
0.0787626132,
-0.4750900269,
-0.179082647,
-0.3048494756,
0.0957340226,
0.7759872675,
-0.2648127079,
0.3863203824,
0.9333483577,
1.0903984308,
-0.3004724979,
0.3900243342,
-0.140074566,
-0.4369980991,
-0.5515824556,
0.899289906,
-0.7066209912,
-0.5777220726,
0.1073991433,
-0.0380538292,
0.3947477639,
-0.5923198462,
0.3803890049,
-0.5114176869,
0.673224926,
-0.7453160882,
-0.4950824678,
-0.3808842599,
0.6050969958,
-0.6431029439,
0.2590334415,
0.0172565039,
-0.8160172105,
0.6374937892,
-0.6525018811,
-0.1401927769,
0.034961883,
-0.421043545,
-0.1225503013,
0.2329978794,
0.12710464,
-0.0892724097,
-0.0942538455,
0.0695360005,
-0.4490150809,
-0.390271008,
0.2839885652,
-0.3332134783,
0.6873477101,
0.2997016311,
-0.5636914372,
0.178256467,
-0.4684970379,
-0.1686416566,
-0.2837243378,
-0.1933666617,
-0.3214879334,
0.3870961368,
0.165085718,
0.1130076274,
-0.2235227972,
-0.5974184275,
-0.11078614,
-0.4891206026,
0.5318003297,
0.8860580921,
0.2499804795,
0.5680363178,
-0.5750932693,
0.6070867777,
0.3887993693,
0.172318235,
0.0859640315,
-0.4084249139,
-0.8185406327,
0.0426144525,
-0.2035955787,
0.5426775217,
-0.2694784403,
0.6050434113,
-0.2629827261,
-0.6827692389,
-0.5366697311,
-0.2506073415,
-0.1325273216,
-0.349953562,
0.1445661634,
-0.4472881258,
-0.4818178117,
-0.7677643299,
-0.6460055113,
-0.3522043824,
0.0544154719,
0.5818536878,
0.3200879097,
-0.2270755321,
0.8115987778,
-0.1907687932,
-0.2263544649,
-0.2411534488,
-0.105314292,
0.2764499784,
-0.0350985564,
0.506860733,
-0.8605615497,
-0.6114286184,
-0.0926164538,
-0.3704719841,
0.1460538507,
-0.1503911465,
-0.0324650891,
-0.0762199759,
0.0159908049,
-0.1658271402,
0.3572080731,
0.4468052685,
-0.5544876456,
-0.107254222,
0.2955718935,
0.7155988812,
-1.3179280758,
-0.528709352,
-0.1426881254,
-0.2546675205,
-0.4506231546,
-0.2832893431,
-0.4214763641,
0.2445640713,
-0.5851624608,
0.1473697573,
-0.1966125518,
0.0243329015,
-0.3792591095,
0.1844984442,
-0.0165508334,
-0.2302163839,
-0.1409390122,
0.3326360285,
0.459490478,
-0.0697728172,
0.3506883085,
-0.0058875731,
-0.662296176,
0.809454143,
-0.2180882543,
0.320235461,
-0.2432520986,
0.6952620149,
-0.9057468772,
-0.165838033,
0.1807117909,
-0.0102470573,
-0.4565768838,
-0.2354632169,
-0.1940118074,
-0.1490020752,
-0.6762051582,
0.4839760363,
0.2899792492,
-0.4315859675,
0.3948802352,
0.8576514125,
-0.0723896027,
-0.3051205277,
-0.6720251441,
0.1539839953,
-0.3193256259,
-0.5377255082,
0.4783952236,
0.0444845185,
-0.971693635,
0.1824199408,
-0.0694287568,
0.0486638322,
-0.2808475792,
0.3257935643,
0.0623882785,
-0.2950383127,
0.1176478267,
-0.0517021976,
0.181610167,
-0.2501629293,
-0.5048046708,
0.6642525196,
-0.271669209,
-0.6247219443,
-0.5885597467,
0.7162572742,
0.6766918898,
0.26172328,
0.8330230117,
0.4890850782,
-0.289367795,
-0.0800015628,
-0.7017266154,
-0.2948561311,
-0.44448331,
0.2366838306,
0.2998162508,
-1.0653783083,
0.8611029983,
0.4140701592,
0.3661057949,
0.3747375011,
0.6071506739,
-0.1606272012,
0.6795252562,
0.6824275255,
0.0759872794,
0.8643618822,
-0.0233763121,
0.4173746407,
-0.4336574078,
-0.0734407082,
-0.3310205042,
-0.6851679087,
-0.6749339104,
-0.5212462544,
0.1861136556,
-0.0870635062,
-0.1716235131,
-0.1558939219,
-0.7503290772,
0.7237827182,
0.1646808535,
-0.1360472441,
0.2050189674,
0.1566563398,
0.456752032,
-0.4479295611,
-0.2344409674,
-0.5615910292,
0.9332865477,
0.1140844002,
0.5581280589,
0.0762759224,
0.6309572458,
0.5601005554,
0.1794139594,
-0.6778743267,
0.4149237573,
-0.2257585824,
-0.7432183623,
0.0219550971,
-0.5038120151,
-0.6400449276,
0.6040282249,
-0.0981206521,
-0.6204886436,
0.5393337607,
-0.2990693748,
-0.5298581123,
1.0878410339,
-0.2206981182,
0.5212910771,
-0.2219355404,
-0.204922542,
-0.619329989,
-0.3364232779,
0.003602484,
0.1100388467,
0.5676633716,
-0.3308135867,
0.0105617847,
0.6797591448,
-0.2788972557,
0.8230364919,
-0.3121685982,
0.239986226,
0.4703335762,
0.0535377562,
-0.1040781289,
0.0930770338,
0.0127203763,
0.4432862401,
0.1458169967,
-0.2681878507,
-0.1857398301,
0.6891196966,
-1.1720399857,
-0.6094367504,
-0.4729284942,
-0.4246868789,
0.0950992629,
-0.1401564777,
0.3860383332,
0.185358122,
-0.3944984376,
0.740527153,
0.0861044973,
-0.0909821987,
0.2366936505,
0.0880699828,
-0.2567254007,
-0.6197595,
0.4840882123,
0.5917384624,
0.1924559176,
0.1649666131,
0.2749065459,
-0.1033062488,
-0.2093154639,
-0.0408010818,
-0.1585180908,
-1.0059766769,
0.013558927,
-0.7312158346,
-0.0215192083,
-0.191479817,
-0.4605763555,
-0.398311466,
-0.6715745926,
-0.0921547487,
-0.2721236348,
0.1302209944,
0.9783867598,
-0.0700113028,
0.3553386629,
-0.5175675154,
-0.0232520476,
0.329836607,
0.4515051544,
-0.2823066115,
-0.3280615509,
-0.1133702099,
-0.0363981426,
-0.7053049803,
-1.0160728693,
-0.0336191058,
0.0502364263,
0.481513381,
0.7901583314,
0.2358805686,
0.5553483367,
-0.1841592044,
1.374257803,
0.0656491667,
-0.6586168408,
0.5122606158,
-0.4218468964,
0.1542829424,
0.6111229658,
0.1416296065,
-0.5578846931,
-0.9603793025,
-0.7440195084,
-0.7914698124,
0.6128911376,
0.1997836977,
0.4916672707,
0.0767817944,
-0.158839047,
0.3780851364,
0.4083546698,
-0.7141600847,
-0.1634731889,
-0.5514612198,
0.1978172064,
0.0666662455,
-0.0723754019,
-0.5956212282,
-0.2702385187,
-0.0319387391,
0.1851612478,
0.2344209403,
0.1260543615,
0.5074532032,
-0.5144386888,
0.5937415957,
0.3504582942,
0.752323091,
-0.1402136832,
0.2337706238,
-0.0207747221,
-0.3142656386,
0.0164373741,
-0.1765183657,
-0.0636548772,
0.1982015073,
0.2956312001,
0.5333193541,
-0.4263262451,
0.0815798044,
0.2086725235,
-0.2972318828,
-0.1584853232,
-0.3650088906,
0.1267583221,
0.2610936761,
0.4550277889,
0.3829979002,
0.4786008,
0.2071198225,
-1.1120889187,
0.0722400993,
0.5745124221,
-0.709135592,
-0.3379006982,
0.4025262892,
0.5418239236,
-0.7108343244,
0.198759377,
-0.1436490864,
-0.6318230033,
0.5689925551,
0.206301868,
1.1406619549,
0.0836080313,
0.2638990581,
0.1169261858,
0.3151264787,
0.2149097174,
-0.0102377431,
-0.3810583949,
-0.8766937852,
0.3017139435,
-0.4258016944,
-0.5778337121,
-0.0217043068,
-0.5955704451,
0.0731667802,
-0.8047775626,
-0.7784953117,
0.0017092527,
0.3021047115,
-0.4128294289,
-0.0986192226,
0.3688422143,
0.4083731472,
-0.817304194,
0.3028211892,
0.6206961274,
-0.0799498782,
0.0112671973,
0.7965058088,
0.6370670199,
-0.0165580679,
0.0153440014,
0.2392336279,
-0.5746020079,
-0.7789227366,
-0.2799193263,
-0.454446733,
0.6618532538,
0.3815968037,
-0.4960955381,
0.2417129725,
0.2925477326,
0.6848552227,
-0.6559912562,
0.3602818251,
0.3641181588,
0.4078807831,
-0.0236439817,
-0.7729699016,
-0.230239585,
-0.4314910769,
-0.2468553334,
0.3055866659,
-0.8291801214,
0.9117411971,
0.1176539361,
-0.570897758,
-0.5534902215,
0.0513773859,
-0.0137398271,
0.3313841522,
0.9810147285,
-0.1255260557,
0.5532519221,
-0.2907036543,
0.9234635234,
-0.3652967215,
0.2400855571,
0.6384646893,
-0.1734995991,
0.6887911558,
0.6197213531,
-0.5139269233,
0.6497587562,
0.6782940626,
0.1635307819,
0.3845840096,
-0.117475383,
-0.1418307871,
-0.2608593404,
-0.122945115,
-0.5092610121,
0.1087478176,
0.2855319679,
-0.1918603033,
-0.2442800254,
-0.1020236164,
-0.136525616,
0.41004017,
0.0018268356,
0.9256869555,
0.1367640793,
-0.5234949589,
0.0081108939,
-0.204005599,
0.7024524212,
-0.3382108808,
0.1771721393,
-0.2899794579,
0.1353821605,
-0.4508645236,
-1.1941077709,
0.6688733101,
0.0884025767,
-0.3576192558,
-0.3024179637,
0.3656973243,
-0.2128767818,
-0.5537445545,
0.7218769193,
0.6380468011,
-0.0682752877,
-0.0769337714,
-0.607662499,
0.3878026307,
0.2275172621,
-0.2341583669,
0.1839653701,
0.4106376767,
0.1310725808,
0.2429506034,
0.5615050197,
0.2588542104,
0.0294598769,
0.1946656406,
0.9573999047,
-0.4516840577,
-1.0603580475,
-0.8719021678,
0.6057656407,
-0.5205390453,
-0.3985882401,
0.4411436915,
0.5492773652,
0.8961498141,
0.3229537606,
0.8817526102,
-0.1691541672,
0.8021382093,
0.0289623551,
0.8243989944,
-0.8232094049,
0.5511505604,
-0.2537804842,
-1.1887896061,
-0.2326776236,
0.8539809585,
-0.5487170219,
0.1036338806,
0.3758641779,
0.7021530271,
-0.2994782627,
0.395167619,
0.1417781562,
-0.0670807585,
0.653783083,
0.0687587038,
1.2841830254,
0.0534671508,
0.8547793031,
-0.3591860533,
-0.1893584877,
-0.3865177929,
-0.3846887052,
-0.7957615256,
-0.6764528751,
-0.2775657773,
-0.3717257977,
-0.0226877183,
1.2412745953,
0.9000903964,
-0.8544030786,
-0.4675990939,
-0.0050704703,
0.145208627,
-0.0769028217,
-0.2885383368,
0.0877440572,
-0.0430722646,
-0.7419672012,
0.0292249266,
0.5898893476,
-0.2635549903,
-0.566701293,
0.2534139156,
0.3304986358,
0.4103463292,
0.3857390881,
-0.1141077802,
-1.0262970924,
-0.4057812989,
-0.1031087041,
-0.1054221988,
0.4704887867,
0.9872863889,
-0.4723072648,
0.848613143,
0.8122261167,
0.2558582127,
0.326838851,
0.3285535574,
0.5715246201,
-0.1751383543,
0.3004806042,
0.5500223637,
0.2421652973,
0.4850899875,
-0.1352358758,
0.0790712908,
0.3647862375,
-0.5084859729,
-0.7532586455,
0.5808777809,
-0.75949049,
-0.2961062193,
0.8588436246,
0.2127709389,
0.2931681573,
-0.3779823482,
-0.1670633554,
0.0193867479,
-0.6682679057,
1.205886364,
0.8994444013,
-0.258235395,
-0.2115898132,
-0.484439373,
0.399243921,
0.0655852258,
-0.8546869159,
-0.0744883567,
0.3885720372,
0.0694112256,
0.6010684371,
0.8763347268,
-0.2892227471,
0.0312620737,
0.1456738412,
-0.7144750357,
0.5839627385,
-0.2513545752,
-0.1120376959,
0.3833493888,
-0.303835094,
-0.203403309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09052v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09052v1 | A Better Choice: Entire-space Datasets for Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction | 2022-12-18T09:57:40 | 2022-12-18T09:57:40 | Yuncong Li, Fang Wang, Sheng-Hua Zhong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect sentiment triplet extraction (ASTE) aims to extract aspect term,
sentiment and opinion term triplets from sentences. Since the initial datasets
used to evaluate models on ASTE had flaws, several studies later corrected the
initial datasets and released new versions of the datasets independently. As a
result, different studies select different versions of datasets to evaluate
their methods, which makes ASTE-related works hard to follow. In this paper, we
analyze the relation between different versions of datasets and suggest that
the entire-space version should be used for ASTE. Besides the sentences
containing triplets and the triplets in the sentences, the entire-space version
additionally includes the sentences without triplets and the aspect terms which
do not belong to any triplets. Hence, the entire-space version is consistent
with real-world scenarios and evaluating models on the entire-space version can
better reflect the models' performance in real-world scenarios. In addition,
experimental results show that evaluating models on non-entire-space datasets
inflates the performance of existing models and models trained on the
entire-space version can obtain better performance. | [
-0.2858995199,
-0.5030249953,
0.9111788273,
0.6241358519,
-0.3743469715,
0.0048044072,
-0.1461837292,
-0.5636139512,
0.450402528,
0.5812281966,
-0.4940930307,
-0.4081433415,
-0.4188221693,
0.0916654617,
-0.4672282934,
1.1999845505,
-0.2643752396,
0.0696140304,
-0.349017024,
-0.1320235282,
-0.3537279367,
-0.4081596136,
-0.423579514,
-0.2278105617,
0.2319675237,
0.4384344816,
0.642141521,
0.3811415732,
0.6773453951,
0.1523717344,
-0.048638165,
-0.0965582952,
-0.0625654235,
0.1848191619,
0.0419742912,
0.0146620702,
-0.6241707802,
0.2336482704,
0.4531745315,
0.6964532137,
0.1954143941,
0.2239217609,
0.1150710359,
0.9236856699,
-0.4369928539,
0.2032683939,
-0.1615352035,
0.0995873138,
0.0023104323,
-0.0827743635,
0.0967095122,
-0.6350026131,
0.2493573278,
-0.5352852941,
0.2391319722,
0.21520105,
0.9501764178,
0.0480352864,
-0.4297653437,
-0.1635433882,
-0.7461873889,
0.5517464876,
-0.7512003183,
0.2805661559,
0.0477009006,
-0.0043898872,
0.1597514749,
-0.2456178814,
-0.6513722539,
-0.1603117734,
0.0206385106,
0.3668364882,
-0.1054264531,
0.1147969365,
0.1163491383,
0.9593087435,
-0.188605085,
0.0323456004,
-0.4548099935,
-0.0182489827,
0.6036996841,
-0.0277468115,
0.0888865963,
-1.0094059706,
-0.3121282458,
-0.2466224134,
-1.1355469227,
0.0911436379,
0.47592628,
0.3929874599,
-0.0394966602,
0.7582959533,
-0.130866915,
0.4475112855,
-0.0732548609,
0.3677243888,
0.4444164932,
-0.3425871134,
-0.2696139514,
-0.3512589037,
1.0231076479,
0.4761690199,
-0.0014424069,
-0.2071565241,
-0.333992511,
-0.1686400324,
0.3902894855,
-0.4941613972,
-0.3636719584,
0.3737625182,
-0.4831042886,
-0.393047601,
0.3889989555,
-1.0403727293,
-0.4048649371,
-0.4463634789,
0.5804409385,
-0.5925502777,
-0.3748591244,
-0.0373692773,
-0.0095305387,
0.0281936955,
0.305152595,
-0.3799097836,
0.1930121928,
0.8651850224,
1.0857008696,
-0.3791582286,
-0.2976767719,
-0.2117324024,
-0.434340775,
-0.3394266665,
1.1096739769,
-0.6497880816,
-0.4896993041,
-0.0939697996,
-0.1621505171,
0.042446848,
-0.4039227664,
0.7046898007,
-0.4813694358,
0.3462201953,
-0.5100193024,
-0.5881226063,
-0.590510428,
0.2079278976,
-0.9167621136,
1.0616087914,
-0.0591488034,
-0.5524272919,
0.513433516,
-1.4706557989,
-0.5071727633,
-0.2897509634,
-0.3009894788,
-0.6391755939,
0.360298723,
0.4355041385,
0.5028855205,
-0.2196353376,
-0.1287402362,
-0.4269174933,
-0.0418007895,
0.1035773307,
-0.067494221,
0.6049319506,
0.0415438786,
-0.2533003092,
0.199598223,
-0.3771038055,
0.1085727066,
-0.0307169221,
-0.2693945169,
-0.26025787,
0.1921866536,
0.2495557517,
0.2323432267,
0.1374104768,
-1.1489467621,
0.069051832,
-0.5844612122,
0.3937229514,
0.6956588626,
0.2219151407,
0.5232906938,
-0.2922844589,
0.5516847372,
0.3445055187,
0.217018649,
0.1088240221,
-0.4869534373,
-0.831828475,
-0.1226444393,
0.3884296119,
0.2601653039,
-0.790844202,
0.4736087024,
-0.5913638473,
-0.2623945475,
-0.7570009232,
-0.1470904797,
0.3985209167,
0.0268427227,
0.3790023625,
0.1587159783,
-0.7443702817,
-1.0320943594,
-0.378126502,
-0.1129449531,
0.1396693438,
0.173383683,
0.7190341353,
0.3244622946,
1.2845723629,
-0.7319387197,
-0.090300791,
-0.3215699494,
0.0139286267,
0.1522952169,
0.238639012,
0.4984713793,
-0.9320999384,
-0.5577524304,
-0.0811381489,
-0.6832690239,
0.1147767007,
0.1804619282,
-0.0478646196,
0.1549684107,
0.2161732316,
-0.4498610795,
0.5509856939,
0.4474703074,
-0.4377308786,
0.4401851892,
0.2041593343,
0.4608437121,
-1.3496286869,
0.0654450357,
0.2559082806,
-0.341489315,
-0.6464743018,
0.2106760144,
0.3059057295,
0.033870969,
-0.304141432,
0.3169626892,
-0.4107300043,
-0.3724908233,
-0.0620095506,
0.0195268206,
0.3605334759,
0.2743660808,
0.1714582741,
0.8568456769,
0.3756696582,
-0.3768208027,
0.3316276968,
0.2836532891,
-0.4298708737,
0.3226640224,
-0.3836114109,
0.2883241177,
-0.0903811008,
0.2369267493,
-0.7034595013,
0.0563010313,
0.0778483972,
-0.3974387348,
0.0622908995,
0.2376365662,
-0.6531149149,
-0.5504065156,
-0.9049879313,
-0.0520040654,
0.1506220102,
-0.7779564857,
0.4219660163,
0.3236728609,
0.0070816437,
-0.4197558463,
-0.3846799731,
0.0797096416,
-0.4688088,
-0.4591705501,
0.2149819881,
-0.0153247751,
-0.204204753,
0.1285015941,
-0.248578012,
0.1478203684,
-0.1559405625,
0.5099817514,
0.5431472659,
-0.5386183858,
-0.1424826086,
-0.2143034488,
-0.1040568575,
-0.0850649178,
-0.0625108033,
0.2794504762,
-0.4270447195,
-0.271430403,
-0.0820184872,
0.7534914017,
0.4492209256,
0.2746088207,
0.5149203539,
0.0324376747,
-0.2949247062,
0.1516070515,
-0.7759353518,
0.1133076027,
-0.3828656077,
0.4136032164,
-0.4196813405,
-0.8119966388,
0.4256738126,
0.2082614154,
0.387122333,
0.6485151052,
0.0732933506,
-0.4395439029,
0.7905271649,
0.9165281653,
-0.327665031,
0.4783045948,
-0.1695853025,
0.7282223105,
-1.4052574635,
-0.1997998953,
-0.4286176264,
-0.2480208576,
-0.2367234975,
-0.1411794573,
0.4805089831,
0.0691837743,
-0.1821040511,
0.382976234,
-0.5749175549,
0.6172249317,
0.3339704275,
0.2580305338,
0.5101079941,
0.4065195918,
0.4396404624,
-0.2180064321,
-0.1006097347,
-0.6414327025,
1.2262927294,
0.2330621928,
0.257818222,
0.41007936,
0.4228497148,
0.1699188948,
0.1673142761,
-0.9065384865,
0.2987698615,
-0.5687146783,
-0.4796933532,
0.0284713991,
-0.5643786192,
-0.7783746123,
0.3209109604,
-0.1319273114,
-0.8572181463,
0.0494492203,
-0.1361551285,
-0.8883039951,
0.4807612598,
-0.6921285987,
0.6046667099,
0.1103981957,
0.1923650801,
0.0868536308,
-0.4628371298,
0.1656446904,
-0.1438766569,
0.1841126084,
0.0164305419,
0.1025486663,
1.0580257177,
-0.3933865428,
0.5757424831,
-0.1487874836,
0.1161062643,
0.1833211035,
0.0884590149,
0.0173885729,
0.0600235127,
-0.1834479719,
0.4195744097,
0.0487893894,
-0.1599273831,
-0.5051457882,
0.8424901366,
-1.2430613041,
-0.6260124445,
-0.320969522,
-0.1822218448,
-0.5974831581,
0.0364890657,
0.5107206106,
0.4333882034,
-0.1256058067,
0.2031011283,
0.367436409,
-0.0448922403,
0.70577389,
0.4594932795,
-0.393081516,
-0.2481034845,
0.5966775417,
-0.0156195471,
0.1557737887,
0.3187120259,
0.1614688039,
-0.267215699,
-0.431125164,
-0.531036377,
0.131894663,
-0.6506554484,
-0.6693916321,
-0.967492342,
-0.5663122535,
-0.4607421458,
-0.1810199767,
-0.571780324,
-0.7006511092,
-0.1819116771,
-0.2572101653,
0.8654435277,
1.1259355545,
-0.1870138347,
0.3996204138,
-0.7493094206,
0.3033236861,
0.0332846195,
0.3542524576,
-0.1048551425,
-0.4068823159,
0.0505778939,
0.1276422739,
-0.6308029294,
-0.9747698307,
0.2733033895,
0.2620048225,
0.1102788001,
0.0254907254,
-0.4220600128,
0.8475929499,
-0.1503471136,
1.1451699734,
0.1887679398,
-1.00948596,
0.5961975455,
-0.3649817407,
0.0312553011,
0.7419807911,
0.1406908333,
-0.4917345047,
-0.1134538278,
-0.805016458,
-1.1704233885,
1.0776523352,
0.4734126031,
-0.0475501791,
0.3377908766,
0.6685301065,
0.430123359,
0.4451029003,
-0.9654477239,
-0.164904967,
-0.3910493553,
-0.2937055826,
0.0401126631,
-0.0029799165,
0.1506024152,
-0.2321329564,
0.6379500031,
0.173321262,
0.3953877985,
0.0631070137,
-0.0715067759,
-0.1750927716,
0.1970303506,
-0.1009031758,
0.2593758404,
-0.3227031827,
0.0018220961,
-0.0897965282,
-0.6383113861,
-0.1663605422,
-0.191845119,
0.0064888461,
-0.1102385893,
0.3732439876,
0.8607546091,
0.0015005255,
-0.1759274155,
1.0896821022,
-0.0299881194,
-0.0566460751,
-0.5410875082,
-0.1562960148,
-0.0911839381,
0.1198175773,
0.1863400936,
0.5878056884,
0.4361157417,
-0.5338951349,
-0.0083558215,
0.1104364619,
-0.4862242043,
-0.5147716999,
0.1103244945,
0.0962701663,
-0.0257541258,
0.7593545318,
-0.1160966456,
-0.6748832464,
0.7360810637,
0.3341022432,
0.9542939663,
-0.0408256054,
0.2577690184,
0.3372015655,
0.2034505755,
-0.3475196362,
0.369491607,
0.0435982756,
-0.8044115901,
-0.6663857102,
-0.9042197466,
-0.2261662781,
0.4575488269,
-0.8215221167,
0.1916221827,
-0.5485212803,
0.0289962906,
-0.0049521048,
0.0193454381,
-0.7090032697,
0.1237084195,
0.2016146481,
0.5780711174,
-1.1701409817,
0.582644701,
1.2512285709,
-0.4996881783,
-0.886723578,
0.2239633203,
0.1038304344,
-0.6332938671,
0.3177486658,
0.1766579002,
-0.0726997778,
-0.3310753703,
-0.5437179208,
-1.0161124468,
0.7665379047,
-0.1303662062,
-0.1222616062,
0.0290314164,
0.0604608394,
0.4643398225,
-0.5951780677,
0.2701736987,
0.7086008191,
0.394263953,
0.2426026016,
-0.983086884,
0.102447778,
-0.5183262229,
0.0988992378,
0.3300037384,
-0.5543010235,
1.1209715605,
0.1475625634,
-0.1848298013,
-0.0433556028,
0.7254264355,
0.1824961752,
-0.097900033,
0.7291485071,
0.2827108502,
0.314786464,
-0.1900108606,
0.9366137385,
0.0873469487,
0.5472726226,
1.0623795986,
-0.257034421,
1.1603711843,
0.3904393017,
-0.270785898,
0.4792294502,
0.6858486533,
0.0748064667,
0.6231737733,
-0.3425116837,
0.012563006,
-0.0761815533,
0.3607089221,
-0.2127927393,
0.3317836821,
0.5208981633,
-0.0542971417,
-0.3113447726,
0.1617574394,
0.4811305404,
-0.1209918857,
-0.2432491034,
0.9114519954,
0.136090368,
-0.596172452,
-0.0621476397,
-0.0953058526,
0.9076683521,
-0.2067813724,
0.1834739447,
-0.2444421202,
-0.0065101115,
-0.7116285563,
-1.2178797722,
0.6525276899,
0.312792331,
-0.275352329,
-0.1629579812,
0.3307681978,
-0.0416485593,
-0.5745483637,
0.1422927678,
0.3978340328,
0.1857077926,
-0.6160899401,
-0.6627396345,
-0.1248762086,
0.4384866357,
-0.4241428673,
0.0969239026,
0.3960330188,
0.0772280619,
0.1708375365,
0.4275736511,
0.3244332075,
-0.2813612521,
-0.0545832887,
0.9264925718,
-0.8591145873,
-0.6968047023,
-0.9008165598,
0.4900562465,
-0.6365160942,
-0.4149137735,
0.9045353532,
0.6837294698,
0.1197951883,
0.2440507412,
1.0816886425,
-0.4572993815,
0.7631774545,
-0.6362864375,
0.4334520698,
-0.7278462648,
0.4247137904,
-0.4500025511,
-1.383652091,
-0.2755120099,
0.912245214,
-0.5309433937,
0.1986511797,
1.3409274817,
0.5918898582,
-0.321038425,
1.0078513622,
-0.0282958839,
0.4002888501,
0.4892654717,
0.3238475025,
1.011534214,
-0.6710988879,
0.1640550792,
-0.2826123238,
-0.4046087563,
-0.0817020535,
-0.8935551643,
-0.6494287252,
-0.8454584479,
-0.4015628397,
-0.4108372927,
-0.3065329194,
1.0336670876,
0.619502604,
-0.8016831875,
-0.0234451257,
0.1687619686,
-0.2611598969,
0.024370268,
-0.273815304,
0.7828884125,
0.0832430571,
-0.3804342449,
0.4182521999,
0.4301396608,
-0.1909502149,
-0.1835303009,
0.615881145,
0.0134685608,
0.0451694205,
0.6244603992,
0.0461776406,
-0.4692361653,
-0.8418038487,
-0.1643028855,
0.1648345143,
0.549967885,
0.8683331609,
-0.3821034729,
0.0704625249,
0.3287771642,
0.1147987619,
0.5876338482,
0.0240375232,
0.4830420911,
-0.7021422982,
-0.0615706705,
0.3157262802,
0.4626103044,
0.7416014075,
-0.5960149169,
0.4487908483,
-0.2140601873,
-0.53067559,
-0.4076813757,
0.0776458234,
-0.9755277634,
-0.2688491344,
1.6403337717,
-0.0825441703,
-0.4778037071,
-0.2166209221,
-0.0670030266,
-0.0879866108,
-0.7338095307,
0.8809977174,
0.7638192773,
-0.4541274309,
0.4259645641,
-0.7644014955,
0.457495153,
0.4217571318,
-0.7656575441,
0.0656858161,
0.4568117857,
0.4529242218,
0.3209295571,
0.7194337845,
-0.4348704219,
-0.1628198922,
-0.1741446704,
0.2790539265,
0.1134230345,
-0.2433506399,
-0.4334307015,
0.2053927332,
-0.0392600596,
-0.1622686535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09045v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09045v1 | Task Preferences across Languages on Community Question Answering Platforms | 2022-12-18T09:37:20 | 2022-12-18T09:37:20 | Sebastin Santy, Prasanta Bhattacharya, Rishabh Mehrotra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.SI | With the steady emergence of community question answering (CQA) platforms
like Quora, StackExchange, and WikiHow, users now have an unprecedented access
to information on various kind of queries and tasks. Moreover, the rapid
proliferation and localization of these platforms spanning geographic and
linguistic boundaries offer a unique opportunity to study the task requirements
and preferences of users in different socio-linguistic groups. In this study,
we implement an entity-embedding model trained on a large longitudinal dataset
of multi-lingual and task-oriented question-answer pairs to uncover and
quantify the (i) prevalence and distribution of various online tasks across
linguistic communities, and (ii) emerging and receding trends in task
popularity over time in these communities. Our results show that there exists
substantial variance in task preference as well as popularity trends across
linguistic communities on the platform. Findings from this study will help Q&A
platforms better curate and personalize content for non-English users, while
also offering valuable insights to businesses looking to target non-English
speaking communities online. | [
-0.6225049496,
-0.8005677462,
0.5770712495,
0.4598588049,
-0.0758848563,
0.1259748191,
-0.4241917729,
-0.531601131,
0.8829789758,
0.3953561783,
-0.3902608156,
-0.5693495274,
-0.6325210333,
0.0842190608,
-0.1493163258,
0.8578938246,
-0.2909259498,
-0.0375253409,
-0.4972248077,
-0.381275773,
-0.5381693244,
-0.7411316037,
-0.5477412939,
0.0649698377,
0.7748497128,
0.5874894261,
0.4536868632,
0.1524926722,
0.1755751669,
0.1647739857,
0.203305766,
-0.0251779091,
-0.3402182758,
0.1612172723,
-0.2628738284,
-0.6275987625,
-0.0486598499,
-0.2674662173,
0.2872624993,
0.8706895113,
-0.1363276988,
0.377672255,
0.2506343126,
0.1992741227,
-0.5685596466,
0.1122826338,
-0.6168887019,
-0.0774971545,
-0.2964737415,
-0.0504941046,
-0.1017054915,
-0.3225150108,
0.100148432,
-0.8162408471,
0.2106623203,
-0.0050794105,
0.6781525612,
0.0276647825,
-0.6866427064,
-0.5046867728,
-0.4451537132,
0.8596124053,
-0.2197733223,
0.7436893582,
0.3914006948,
0.0407273024,
0.1309049726,
-0.4021561742,
-0.3408533335,
-0.0862538293,
-0.1088679358,
-0.247768566,
-0.3456552327,
-0.161241293,
-0.0727704614,
0.1484543234,
-0.7012634277,
0.1134499758,
-0.1043657959,
-0.109091498,
0.2204931676,
0.1025761738,
0.6154475212,
-0.4628190994,
-0.2320836335,
0.2109688967,
-0.5076630712,
0.3776653111,
0.2383216023,
0.2038164139,
-0.0137332277,
0.6595897079,
-0.3559705317,
0.3610962033,
0.3745877147,
0.1945531815,
0.3647746444,
-0.3608201146,
0.0898128524,
-0.2127454728,
0.6176249385,
0.2825321555,
-0.0173904877,
-0.2565051317,
0.0755882636,
-0.0904585943,
0.1349747628,
-0.3922885954,
-0.0556125864,
0.2657629251,
-0.4632958174,
0.2456243932,
-0.2199791074,
-0.3889419138,
-0.270739466,
-0.2805557847,
0.1181857586,
0.1627335101,
-0.5736040473,
0.0009744949,
-0.0872580856,
0.092291303,
0.1554401964,
-0.8995918632,
0.1617546529,
0.70271492,
0.7164607644,
-0.5230615139,
0.0131391603,
-0.2246154249,
-0.1674608737,
0.0099828364,
0.6955670118,
-0.5256581903,
-0.4406939745,
0.2127485424,
0.3566249013,
-0.2387548089,
-0.5265514255,
0.2788258493,
-0.9042575955,
-0.0005780072,
-0.828558743,
-0.3434152007,
0.0282763913,
0.5585872531,
-0.6766545177,
1.155883193,
-0.0994083062,
-0.7486400008,
0.627193749,
-0.6150029302,
-0.2597584724,
0.0581584536,
-0.0966520384,
-0.0293067712,
-0.148783192,
0.3994254172,
0.5080640316,
-0.1660567522,
0.3284949064,
-0.3948218524,
-0.1114186421,
0.422439605,
-0.0328717157,
0.8621945381,
0.2716730833,
-0.4935622811,
-0.2794668674,
-0.0079278946,
-0.114844881,
-0.1366757751,
-0.293543756,
-0.7918096185,
0.1103533059,
0.19883582,
0.3487739265,
0.8128382564,
-0.7416903377,
0.0043778066,
-0.3479034305,
0.5115832686,
0.3056266308,
0.539663434,
0.3197589517,
-0.2422450185,
0.7106742859,
0.3076735437,
0.1361588389,
0.3715591133,
-0.7820109129,
-0.4965401888,
0.0808870867,
-0.025038261,
0.5539785028,
-0.7550364733,
0.0026531813,
-0.3119532168,
-0.6484479308,
-0.4575384855,
0.45465523,
0.2569183111,
0.1514335424,
0.3441346586,
-0.2961552739,
-0.3224688768,
-1.1254556179,
-0.1335497499,
-0.1331208646,
-0.0174024533,
0.6757264733,
0.3486429453,
-0.0112558892,
0.8242967129,
-0.6377000809,
0.0324603915,
-0.4979924858,
0.0440281183,
0.2446852922,
0.1810688972,
0.7098171711,
-1.1684658527,
-0.858474195,
-0.0209545903,
-0.3964217901,
0.0191758946,
0.1585914791,
-0.2845462859,
0.2026803941,
0.2444997877,
-0.510932982,
0.0747012571,
0.6827549934,
-0.1183113605,
0.1298794895,
0.2121018469,
0.6665536165,
-1.3866292238,
0.1172761545,
0.126400575,
-0.1102908701,
-0.5955572128,
0.2601212561,
0.0108502433,
-0.0634920597,
-0.5488805771,
0.5687994957,
-0.3073821366,
-0.2193348259,
-0.0492865667,
0.4558209777,
-0.0877518803,
0.5289355516,
0.457270503,
0.6499531865,
0.4941687584,
-0.7172353864,
0.0482924134,
0.5062012672,
-0.393396467,
0.3549833894,
-0.8013091087,
0.3086445034,
-0.0947649106,
0.0674642697,
-1.1876633167,
-0.0875067115,
0.2251222432,
-0.5161979198,
-0.2638022602,
-0.3035840094,
-0.5710956454,
-0.0814151987,
-0.0524616577,
0.5747605562,
0.1161291674,
-0.2333525419,
0.254347831,
0.829566896,
-0.3873818517,
-0.7883464098,
-0.77784127,
-0.0563062429,
-0.259405911,
-0.3902941346,
0.2138474882,
-0.1814861,
-0.2922620773,
0.1942116767,
0.0889852569,
-0.377129823,
0.2315298915,
0.3719995022,
-0.0269439407,
-0.2015119493,
0.255022496,
0.2105293125,
0.1617615074,
0.0537882522,
-0.4715812206,
0.6199971437,
0.0693227947,
-0.5460967422,
0.1071716323,
0.6762136221,
0.3632617295,
-0.5396576524,
0.8573575616,
0.3234531581,
-0.4280594289,
-0.024462821,
-0.6316815615,
-0.0406750143,
-0.4432846308,
0.4068197906,
-0.096989654,
-1.4291492701,
0.6711134911,
0.2973466516,
0.2787413001,
0.3881284595,
0.8737472892,
-0.2633461654,
0.776620388,
0.470108211,
-0.1736775339,
0.3538382947,
0.0478729047,
0.1479774266,
-0.4578059912,
-0.1922163665,
-0.6874697804,
-0.6186056733,
-0.7673096657,
-0.5308052897,
0.5596057177,
-0.1009295136,
0.0300630257,
0.5768378377,
-0.2453014404,
0.177245751,
0.5240428448,
0.2260420024,
0.1345197409,
-0.0680544525,
-0.0634696931,
-0.1768149883,
-0.6398083568,
-0.2157628089,
1.0684593916,
0.0504846685,
0.2191374004,
0.3645479977,
0.8513534665,
0.394590497,
0.2057929486,
-0.6645236611,
0.2913095355,
-0.2994267046,
-0.9206285477,
-0.2912415862,
-0.1332643181,
-1.2617768049,
-0.0146057867,
-0.2636940479,
-0.62022084,
0.490968585,
0.3832352757,
-0.0930449739,
0.3171427846,
-0.3448038697,
1.062556982,
-0.0627224669,
-0.048726365,
-0.3972331285,
-0.320497036,
-0.0011947504,
-0.0474821739,
0.3770896792,
-0.1384956986,
-0.3155549169,
0.5524197817,
0.1406503618,
0.9808644652,
-0.3257460594,
0.0010689587,
0.4132537544,
-0.0359395035,
0.3956635296,
0.2364486456,
-0.0333041586,
0.1679679751,
0.0734370276,
-0.6220162511,
-0.4309337735,
1.0013986826,
-0.8177993298,
-0.7292259932,
0.0421965681,
-0.2772082984,
-0.4419499338,
-0.0608828813,
0.1811486781,
0.4820167124,
-0.3815392256,
0.2070856541,
0.8848116994,
-0.1586430371,
0.2426729351,
0.4158353806,
-0.1641249657,
0.0782280043,
0.7388686538,
0.1669974774,
0.2682148516,
0.615108788,
-0.1768087745,
-0.4700493813,
-0.4337436259,
-0.5024050474,
0.1730823368,
-0.7376954556,
0.1505808532,
-0.9332954288,
0.2229114324,
-0.2792556882,
-0.1647399366,
-0.0472568013,
-0.4646507204,
-0.3366378546,
-0.1324682236,
0.306060344,
0.5421909094,
0.3659537137,
-0.0731638893,
-0.8096001744,
0.1879579723,
0.3755839467,
0.188615486,
-0.1188182756,
-0.2297303081,
-0.373262167,
0.1730644703,
-0.1089061648,
-1.2405490875,
0.1753914058,
0.1390373856,
0.8300726414,
-0.0508115552,
0.0387081094,
0.2209003419,
-0.1396105438,
1.0458078384,
-0.0577721857,
-0.549951911,
0.4359823167,
-0.5569613576,
0.2065021396,
0.6853961945,
0.9967160225,
-1.1374534369,
-0.6188408732,
-0.3206124306,
-0.8598977327,
0.1775969416,
-0.0009743426,
0.5498657227,
-0.3963909149,
0.3364650607,
0.1761283726,
0.4900954664,
-0.7949771285,
-0.4192842543,
-0.1851231605,
-0.061197184,
0.0211252086,
0.1576242745,
0.0566500425,
0.0055192164,
0.4241637588,
-0.0700280368,
0.3273727298,
0.0022861492,
-0.3746845722,
0.0103335325,
0.6253026724,
0.0834338218,
0.8055924773,
0.184711203,
-0.0715717971,
0.3470508456,
-0.3334680796,
0.0930343047,
0.0036172688,
-0.3877061009,
0.0621965826,
-0.1459361911,
0.6379920244,
0.4999223351,
-0.6984199882,
0.5494987369,
-0.004907045,
-0.3581269383,
-0.4275578856,
-0.0527477153,
0.549859941,
0.173835516,
0.4600901008,
-0.0725105852,
0.3613570035,
-0.5010604858,
0.0708525404,
0.4180904031,
-0.481631279,
-0.3203803301,
0.4859158397,
0.1832597405,
0.0602824725,
0.217802465,
-0.2336888313,
-0.4692688584,
0.6165781021,
0.1374941021,
0.6720334291,
0.0271525811,
0.5727588534,
0.4464457333,
0.1878981888,
0.1200698987,
0.4750989377,
-0.0638755262,
-0.8201530576,
-0.3480306566,
-0.5804491043,
-0.4609138668,
-0.2394275218,
-0.7654109597,
0.1932544112,
-0.1489070505,
-0.3723534048,
-0.0533527546,
-0.0312693976,
-1.0216447115,
0.0854741931,
0.0417918228,
0.5672805309,
-0.9543411732,
0.6184825897,
1.213478446,
-0.2093469948,
-0.645813942,
0.0046685552,
0.0371982828,
-0.7123246193,
0.5724233389,
-0.1453438699,
0.0966233686,
-0.0947545394,
-0.1707052439,
-1.0893741846,
0.9732100368,
0.139056623,
-0.516037643,
-0.0808924139,
0.4111174047,
0.5922958851,
-0.4335050583,
0.024204703,
0.1391588151,
0.2386121601,
-0.4347630739,
-1.147238493,
-0.0581044592,
-0.2327110022,
-0.1632797122,
0.5819978118,
-0.6857948899,
0.5688376427,
0.1743869334,
-0.176465854,
-0.3266066611,
0.4995634258,
0.2484998852,
0.5031496286,
0.8056154847,
0.1832372993,
0.6571655273,
-0.0046548345,
0.7793953419,
-0.5764377117,
0.2262155563,
0.8090677261,
-0.0566769317,
1.2110641003,
0.5185222626,
-0.0647200048,
0.7614587545,
0.7923849821,
0.1775306463,
0.2825983465,
0.0984809026,
-0.0960779041,
-0.6239170432,
-0.4973891079,
-0.1256956756,
0.3861477971,
0.4420095682,
-0.2237467468,
-0.0685109943,
0.384339571,
0.0578565076,
0.2176819891,
-0.4343175888,
0.4411841631,
-0.0686532333,
-0.962479949,
0.2155722231,
0.0375111997,
0.769335866,
-0.4349048436,
0.2307998687,
-0.1895550489,
-0.5662232637,
-0.1536827534,
-1.0000778437,
0.2595015168,
0.0407460295,
-0.2164813727,
-0.2486617267,
0.4736572802,
-0.5989769697,
-0.2338180691,
0.38279742,
0.8782854676,
0.1357814223,
-0.1107582077,
-0.8169511557,
-0.2834293544,
-0.0757170171,
-0.2166787386,
0.4138688743,
0.1701795459,
-0.3510497808,
0.501978755,
0.36924541,
-0.1649312824,
0.2296436727,
-0.1348892599,
0.8339136839,
-0.0529542193,
-0.5426895022,
-0.2722665071,
0.4443904757,
0.2158308625,
-0.6042730808,
0.9340219498,
0.5909811854,
0.8981356621,
-0.012660956,
0.8164134622,
-0.4499675035,
0.6754930019,
-0.2281950861,
0.4875291586,
-0.9602972865,
0.0062177149,
-0.1050943807,
-0.8919549584,
0.2566202581,
-0.1288500428,
-0.4412610829,
0.029423371,
0.466073066,
0.8080055118,
-0.0972628519,
-0.0827169046,
0.0765676349,
-0.1500213891,
-0.14195171,
0.6516658664,
0.6678406,
0.0557266586,
0.7269794941,
-0.2559190691,
0.0497376844,
-0.040867202,
-0.5792782903,
-0.7657443285,
-0.9375348091,
-0.4141315818,
-0.1569200009,
-0.0143725434,
1.1946125031,
0.462130338,
-1.1371744871,
-0.2444659024,
0.3555300534,
-0.01766387,
-0.2302613705,
-0.2348966151,
0.2593437433,
-0.0950998589,
-0.7631103396,
0.0611855425,
0.006749786,
-0.3634000719,
-0.3074471056,
0.1171716005,
-0.328329742,
-0.0564539693,
0.3085827529,
0.4544050992,
-0.7800462246,
-0.2798087597,
0.8996240497,
-0.2078378946,
0.0618213601,
0.9584725499,
-0.3204343319,
0.2850528061,
0.5511367321,
0.7579354048,
0.5953813791,
-0.0487439334,
0.4154244661,
-0.9928603172,
-0.2098055631,
0.2014889568,
0.3114769459,
0.2917076945,
-0.5083053112,
0.0151629122,
0.2027805597,
-0.6578610539,
-0.3304109573,
0.0335584767,
-0.8733410239,
-0.20018287,
1.1219490767,
-0.3098988831,
0.1330259293,
-0.6914752126,
0.1025462747,
0.0553498641,
-0.4544697702,
0.6327672005,
0.8535962105,
-0.0700630844,
-0.2872291505,
-0.8728511333,
0.3829078972,
0.4237709641,
-0.7858549953,
-0.1146691889,
0.3806808889,
0.5836120844,
0.2388469428,
0.8092451692,
0.2440508306,
0.5786332488,
-0.4821414649,
-0.052936025,
0.2757035196,
-0.0850788206,
0.0946129113,
0.4822006524,
0.3607414067,
-0.0550995991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09028v1 | Neural Coreference Resolution based on Reinforcement Learning | 2022-12-18T07:36:35 | 2022-12-18T07:36:35 | Yu Wang, Hongxia Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL | The target of a coreference resolution system is to cluster all mentions that
refer to the same entity in a given context. All coreference resolution systems
need to solve two subtasks; one task is to detect all of the potential
mentions, and the other is to learn the linking of an antecedent for each
possible mention. In this paper, we propose a reinforcement learning
actor-critic-based neural coreference resolution system, which can achieve both
mention detection and mention clustering by leveraging an actor-critic deep
reinforcement learning technique and a joint training algorithm. We experiment
on the BERT model to generate different input span representations. Our model
with the BERT span representation achieves the state-of-the-art performance
among the models on the CoNLL-2012 Shared Task English Test Set. | [
-0.7842261791,
-0.6735902429,
0.4504742324,
0.0352518409,
-0.4949971735,
0.2208560705,
-0.7143707871,
-0.7134845257,
0.6891678572,
0.1143740937,
-0.6906383038,
-0.0809649602,
-0.8689101338,
0.1905973256,
-0.0654450059,
1.3353250027,
0.0382539742,
0.1099408567,
-0.2090441138,
-0.0855247602,
-0.3863686919,
-0.5096568465,
-0.8869000673,
-0.6804781556,
0.8168512583,
0.4532176852,
0.3878047168,
0.0724509284,
0.4478353262,
0.336311847,
-0.2554001808,
0.4741026461,
0.0276005752,
0.1980214566,
-0.5735630989,
-0.1385212243,
-0.2324642688,
0.1059898362,
0.6365062594,
0.4638531804,
0.1789278686,
-0.1969587058,
-0.0385186411,
0.077507332,
-0.5297073126,
0.1877394468,
-0.7374033928,
-0.0286299363,
0.1591616422,
0.065115951,
-0.3490307629,
-0.2319113165,
0.229718551,
-0.3968216479,
0.0696110576,
0.3356031179,
0.8710401654,
0.0579703264,
-0.2915354073,
-0.2069970965,
-0.6039572954,
0.6783077717,
-0.6100044847,
-0.0927778557,
0.1793222129,
0.2767887414,
0.0475338213,
-0.4298602939,
-0.8222808838,
-0.5021645427,
-0.3161309659,
-0.0543783307,
-0.2423328906,
0.3557903469,
0.0621299408,
0.2499017864,
-0.3016398847,
0.2968992889,
-0.2628784776,
-0.2484033853,
0.4269947708,
-0.2159331888,
0.0814690515,
-0.2008936256,
-0.5193078518,
0.0413821004,
-0.3760222495,
0.0583681874,
-0.1427296102,
0.4654364288,
0.3669345975,
0.1471012235,
0.0394659378,
0.1618726999,
0.6564642191,
0.0951273963,
0.0500526652,
0.1683933437,
-0.2085341066,
0.5047335029,
0.6964762211,
0.1844032407,
0.4603329897,
-0.4367368817,
-0.211537838,
0.4024383426,
0.4259358943,
-0.4227574468,
0.0183338169,
-0.0687813237,
-0.1390373856,
-0.1903406531,
-0.0996265188,
-0.0928039923,
-0.629085362,
-0.3204637766,
0.4377972782,
-0.6704124808,
-0.4421190917,
-0.4064960778,
-0.1547125131,
-0.1072326973,
0.3023920357,
-0.861027956,
0.6219069958,
0.579983592,
0.4903491735,
-0.2000916004,
-0.6040527821,
-0.4539479017,
-0.0424216799,
-0.3011397123,
1.1481804848,
-0.4931577742,
-0.4423460066,
-0.0671292916,
-0.2066259086,
-0.1673720926,
-0.7544271946,
0.3113342822,
-0.4424324632,
-0.1987360716,
-0.3473009765,
-0.7417544723,
-0.1458102912,
0.8202552199,
-0.6844494939,
0.9513986111,
-0.1479170173,
-0.5233247876,
0.3215632141,
-0.3939145803,
-0.4457753897,
0.1537699252,
-0.3613770902,
-0.1584257782,
0.026215924,
0.3970583379,
0.7140587568,
-0.2062408924,
0.5962760448,
-0.1892997772,
-0.5677028298,
0.3191899061,
0.1002124771,
-0.0325992294,
-0.0442360751,
-0.2887429893,
0.6817921996,
-0.3355318904,
-0.1486028284,
-0.2425894737,
-0.1551688015,
-0.3790667057,
-0.0307469368,
-0.2369902432,
0.3664454222,
0.2605460584,
-0.7574216127,
0.1603886932,
-0.2020214498,
0.1072460264,
0.6610814929,
0.1528992206,
0.5466150641,
-0.3478497565,
0.2320598811,
0.4619641006,
-0.0522798635,
0.1185233146,
-0.1158170551,
-0.9798394442,
-0.048932761,
0.2452215105,
0.2883470058,
-0.7566178441,
0.6042912006,
-0.3419653177,
-0.4782576263,
-0.236515671,
-0.2336567193,
0.6489500403,
0.3854946792,
0.5843585134,
-0.3256296515,
-0.8325624466,
-1.0562978983,
-0.2269864529,
-0.4530960917,
0.291538626,
0.4470136762,
0.702286303,
0.1173246279,
0.7791737914,
-0.1875664443,
-0.3520767093,
-0.6270181537,
0.4814180136,
0.1124766171,
0.6415681243,
0.3093486428,
-0.5180081725,
-0.2808815837,
-0.0250276458,
-0.1565314382,
0.2468196601,
-0.0030818076,
0.0496977679,
0.0407262817,
0.6392093897,
-0.4677318335,
0.165155232,
0.3895274997,
-0.2962448001,
0.9672269821,
0.0238793325,
-0.0571159869,
-1.1828514338,
0.1402490735,
0.1825222075,
-0.4854113758,
-0.1422401071,
-0.1242330447,
-0.2165215909,
0.0496452041,
-0.1530755162,
0.4118089974,
-0.1256566197,
-0.0179197565,
-0.5630322099,
0.1237626225,
-0.3002298772,
1.0862972736,
0.5156072974,
0.5546998978,
0.1038815454,
-0.8181304932,
0.5100260377,
0.0782774314,
-0.3577334583,
0.8505769372,
-0.4509290755,
0.0607362539,
-0.0171181448,
0.6871418953,
-0.9098049998,
0.1486270726,
0.2025186419,
-0.6601973772,
0.0851032138,
0.1426439583,
-0.351367712,
-0.2524872422,
0.0755429417,
0.2288235128,
0.2835086584,
-0.6358605027,
0.5811250806,
0.3307073414,
-0.2020788342,
-0.7371632457,
-0.4709436893,
-0.1043234468,
0.1633306444,
-0.1017011553,
0.8312885761,
0.035075698,
0.1107004359,
0.3395223618,
-0.2547649741,
-0.256424278,
-0.1494534165,
0.3304902911,
0.2407535762,
0.1126812175,
0.5814528465,
-0.0027680565,
-0.0020370877,
0.1771394461,
-0.2504534423,
0.4827077985,
-0.3417364359,
0.1010691226,
-0.1369762719,
0.6637952924,
0.2560707927,
-0.3221929967,
0.5243420005,
0.7241168618,
-0.5380796194,
-0.5337585211,
-0.613795042,
-0.3745694458,
-0.3541072309,
0.441971004,
-0.274094522,
-1.2255415916,
0.4559263289,
-0.5938519835,
-0.0755776092,
0.5255173445,
0.5367094874,
-0.3469835818,
0.4589744508,
0.4755542576,
-0.267675817,
0.5722271204,
-0.2510780394,
0.1911119074,
-1.1301971674,
-0.3451617658,
-0.5246408582,
-0.7758716345,
-0.0620869845,
-0.449465394,
0.2470899224,
0.1452008039,
-0.4395383,
0.5413478017,
-0.4574343562,
0.2866476476,
0.7632112503,
0.3599584699,
0.1638395935,
-0.2806527019,
-0.8740711212,
-0.0060205185,
-0.4029783309,
-0.0793144926,
0.2721723616,
0.1501575261,
0.3314017355,
0.1135244146,
0.780933857,
0.4856205583,
0.4751172364,
-0.8606446981,
0.7765236497,
-0.1841057539,
-0.6943860054,
-0.1487423182,
-0.133386746,
-0.619672358,
0.2512454093,
-0.3182686865,
-0.8831512332,
0.3527007401,
0.0421889983,
-0.6006276011,
0.4997425675,
-0.1543461829,
0.6423449516,
0.2043120414,
-0.0995137021,
-0.6305093169,
-0.4461068511,
0.3219404817,
0.6112365723,
-0.1599020958,
-0.2082029432,
0.2792289853,
0.8330239654,
-0.1300607175,
1.1429126263,
-0.2000650913,
0.275026679,
0.4459558725,
0.171373114,
0.5775453448,
0.0788152888,
0.3317049444,
-0.2781254053,
-0.2259537131,
-0.0456050932,
-0.5924201608,
0.737046361,
-0.6575182676,
-0.222961247,
-0.7238265872,
-0.5480262637,
-0.4333661199,
0.0093500996,
0.0805136934,
0.0755786672,
-0.6048650742,
0.0302652027,
0.617772758,
0.0460948944,
0.7313702703,
0.5336015224,
-0.0834619999,
-0.6672834754,
0.5835590363,
-0.073766835,
-0.2849857509,
0.3088757694,
-0.0587149523,
-0.3543403745,
-0.277235806,
-0.2057508081,
0.2849286795,
-0.600726366,
-0.3919543624,
-0.352173388,
-0.4334591627,
-0.3516506553,
-0.1006689668,
-0.3484269083,
-0.058138106,
-0.0492724925,
-0.3043925166,
0.2234497517,
0.5813716054,
-0.1201511398,
0.3919698298,
-0.560577035,
-0.0534232184,
0.4714342952,
0.4377033114,
0.2780442834,
-0.392390877,
-0.5447405577,
-0.4191267192,
-0.297110796,
-0.6619294286,
0.1820867509,
0.1506221145,
0.3953973353,
0.2575888336,
0.11990197,
0.6124075651,
-0.5379037857,
0.8212461472,
0.4246280491,
-1.0246738195,
0.5183294415,
-0.0812817439,
0.247172147,
0.6547973752,
0.3465573788,
-1.0513345003,
-0.2168414444,
-0.7903573513,
-0.6496682167,
0.4786750376,
-0.2044745535,
-0.0780120715,
-0.3845310807,
0.315872103,
-0.0660653561,
0.1909574866,
-0.697992146,
0.0860267431,
0.3760476112,
0.0699894205,
-0.211057961,
-0.2965940535,
-0.1358472556,
-0.3996100128,
0.8906384706,
-0.2579330802,
0.5694470406,
0.4933537245,
-0.3516220152,
-0.0931400284,
0.5918397903,
0.4953302145,
0.2317653447,
-0.3057816923,
0.3330267966,
0.2739483714,
-0.1740034074,
0.1351564676,
0.1818173975,
0.3329404593,
0.2208773643,
0.4414277375,
0.9943138361,
0.6398631334,
-0.501632154,
0.4177168012,
0.1962909997,
-0.426726222,
-0.580455184,
-0.0021697802,
0.2973561585,
0.483030647,
0.4353624582,
0.5143603086,
-0.0985839814,
-0.5529853106,
0.471837312,
0.1948497593,
-0.7775561213,
-0.1497372389,
0.1448875368,
0.576290071,
-0.0158364344,
0.6368802786,
-0.348680228,
-0.9276592731,
0.6161490679,
0.5550678372,
0.9414249063,
-0.3196762502,
0.3346541226,
0.5599814653,
0.1294607967,
0.1057421491,
0.3166661859,
-0.3768583536,
-1.0597776175,
-0.6826310754,
-0.3841068447,
-0.6245910525,
0.1305388212,
-0.7804421782,
-0.1843063086,
-0.9278156757,
-0.2915532589,
0.0404705815,
0.4332633615,
-0.4884141386,
0.4853078425,
0.5308436751,
0.8433893323,
-0.7447168827,
0.9923219681,
0.9528203607,
-0.4949806631,
-0.9010850191,
-0.2596284449,
-0.2703593075,
-0.3604623377,
0.7089157104,
0.2020635307,
-0.140513882,
-0.0223309286,
-0.4109183252,
-0.6469132304,
0.9350722432,
0.0978742018,
-0.5927523971,
-0.1642364115,
-0.3909391463,
0.4554288983,
-0.5858936906,
0.4078677893,
0.5323905349,
0.3849466741,
-0.0384397209,
-1.2199813128,
0.1925306171,
-0.3720629811,
0.030381456,
0.0919598043,
-0.7162150741,
0.9280167818,
0.098752223,
0.0157981943,
-0.1499460042,
1.0772759914,
0.3305005133,
0.0331263691,
0.9238095284,
0.6591179967,
0.6143351197,
-0.108588703,
0.7516921163,
-0.0690465942,
0.4286420047,
1.3746068478,
-0.238821283,
0.967774868,
0.5332413316,
-0.0836544186,
0.9489896894,
0.6346811652,
0.0000935821,
0.4437270164,
0.4510756433,
-0.5916246176,
-0.4002209902,
-0.7170649767,
-0.04127305,
0.2023711652,
0.6209136844,
-0.6320766807,
-0.4436018467,
-0.0313257873,
0.1546524465,
0.3052900732,
-0.6908317208,
0.9468249083,
0.1049216464,
-1.183413744,
0.2376781702,
0.0826320201,
1.0334614515,
-0.660161376,
-0.0300752074,
-0.1129961684,
0.4003125429,
-0.0263504386,
-0.4021700621,
0.3336142898,
-0.0677004308,
-0.4583496451,
-0.06453906,
0.8540706635,
-0.5826281309,
-0.1988339126,
0.532377243,
0.2388138771,
0.0106484964,
-0.3084101975,
-0.5848330259,
-0.163971737,
-0.4071420133,
0.0063314382,
0.2038509846,
0.0343190283,
-0.0105997529,
0.2535894811,
0.1917561293,
0.205708757,
-0.0496294238,
0.0432765484,
1.0374873877,
-0.8356087804,
-0.7419721484,
-0.5188341737,
0.2941759825,
-0.4619442225,
-0.5391207337,
0.1649819314,
0.1618742496,
0.7880595326,
-0.007554844,
0.9320734143,
-0.3609754145,
0.7039036751,
-0.1989251971,
0.3260844648,
-0.2160300314,
-0.2212291509,
-0.2321719676,
-0.6963589191,
-0.202911377,
0.6246323586,
-0.4527700543,
0.0934532583,
1.1943172216,
0.4219769537,
0.0828089789,
0.0115343221,
0.3088093102,
0.0358572491,
0.1771199107,
0.9880728126,
0.617218852,
-0.1900321543,
0.5684083104,
-0.2971252799,
0.02855937,
-0.4150660932,
-0.7076404095,
-0.8477962613,
-0.8673894405,
-0.2389833629,
-0.6274525523,
0.2641019821,
1.3308546543,
0.7908443809,
-0.8602997065,
-0.1317640692,
-0.0322097577,
-0.0818381682,
-0.8944596052,
-0.1680583656,
0.4288707078,
-0.6474921703,
-0.8301292658,
0.459356904,
0.0055761668,
-0.5371861458,
-0.4186214209,
-0.0969609395,
-0.701382339,
0.0984124988,
0.3802042902,
0.2744785249,
-0.8528832197,
-0.4603337049,
-0.3871359527,
-0.3559912145,
-0.0905510932,
1.1606729031,
-1.0779711008,
0.1555220038,
0.2886329293,
0.7756659985,
0.5672231913,
-0.0916195512,
0.4401129186,
-1.16852808,
0.0769206434,
0.6636235118,
0.4248938262,
0.0571196042,
-0.3569291532,
0.2434985489,
0.2733929455,
-0.4531050622,
-0.3091432452,
0.3439205289,
-1.1473528147,
-0.5229099989,
0.7599061728,
-0.3958013058,
-0.2916258276,
0.1211266592,
-0.2603259981,
0.4737358689,
-0.621042788,
0.6189150214,
0.9735809565,
-0.1495954841,
-0.5629718304,
0.1883515269,
0.466064781,
0.6870637536,
-0.3835594952,
-0.1422208399,
0.332505703,
0.3054060042,
0.5210893154,
0.672305584,
0.1162578613,
0.5681031942,
-0.0445886962,
0.6556236744,
-0.2409883142,
-0.5448226929,
-0.1348561496,
0.1656611264,
0.1364368647,
-0.2356628925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08999v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08999v1 | Sentence-level Feedback Generation for English Language Learners: Does Data Augmentation Help? | 2022-12-18T03:53:44 | 2022-12-18T03:53:44 | Shabnam Behzad, Amir Zeldes, Nathan Schneider | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we present strong baselines for the task of Feedback Comment
Generation for Writing Learning. Given a sentence and an error span, the task
is to generate a feedback comment explaining the error. Sentences and feedback
comments are both in English. We experiment with LLMs and also create multiple
pseudo datasets for the task, investigating how it affects the performance of
our system. We present our results for the task along with extensive analysis
of the generated comments with the aim of aiding future studies in feedback
comment generation for English language learners. | [
0.0316888168,
-0.7469733357,
0.4610266089,
0.1943986267,
-0.015202458,
-0.017902324,
-0.3473765552,
-0.553788662,
0.0982435197,
0.3708395958,
-0.8691852689,
-0.2949021757,
-0.271590203,
0.6492645741,
-0.4263089299,
1.2663552761,
-0.0900570229,
0.4029374421,
-0.6545758843,
0.3500353992,
-0.648116827,
-0.5358870029,
-0.7388246059,
0.0404549092,
0.5767139196,
0.9366225004,
-0.0062021306,
0.3309822083,
0.4861407578,
0.3833462,
0.3417395949,
0.4973127842,
-0.5810246468,
0.4219073653,
-0.1286896467,
-0.8017258644,
-0.4381553233,
-0.2342790365,
0.7870288491,
0.8560478687,
0.2093201429,
-0.0469252802,
0.3462585211,
0.6519107819,
-0.420180738,
0.0672174841,
-0.3658246994,
0.1784208566,
-0.0840275288,
-0.3560971022,
-0.4779400527,
-0.6714296341,
-0.1216217279,
-0.5195184946,
0.4156525135,
0.1836180985,
0.6042522788,
0.3368170559,
-0.2133668661,
-0.3802150786,
-0.8581896424,
0.8882449865,
-0.8956217766,
0.0645988211,
0.2762437463,
-0.0095749004,
-0.0662018508,
-0.6605960131,
-0.617927134,
-0.514829278,
-0.2392962575,
0.310749054,
0.2254785448,
0.0309668109,
0.4468940198,
0.6280522943,
-0.3418008983,
-0.0334205739,
-0.4888116419,
-0.1278345883,
0.7173820734,
0.2781452537,
0.1972601563,
-0.1904538125,
0.0926540419,
0.249409318,
-0.8459014893,
0.1761698723,
0.6014698148,
0.299526155,
0.0438737981,
0.8164327145,
-0.2383831143,
0.7378075123,
-0.016440928,
-0.2622883022,
0.4172028005,
-0.5207349062,
0.0633032769,
-0.2880604565,
0.5428001881,
0.7949110866,
0.3612622619,
-0.250470221,
-0.4262310266,
0.2001171112,
0.2556714118,
-0.6023443937,
-0.2403611243,
-0.0272847079,
-0.293620199,
-0.5856192112,
0.4736490548,
-0.5497590303,
-0.1993582696,
-0.2388418913,
0.2551491261,
-0.1856803298,
-0.0022534283,
-0.079776302,
-0.0020871651,
-0.1748127043,
0.359752506,
-0.7127562761,
0.4958253801,
0.1948481947,
0.34272331,
-0.1291415542,
-0.6204394698,
-0.5926871896,
0.1731577069,
-0.3038526475,
0.8233855367,
-0.4300308228,
-0.633742094,
0.2705929577,
0.1779077202,
0.1407748908,
-0.5481866598,
0.4270807803,
-0.0792880803,
0.7851910591,
-0.3031119406,
-0.9313668013,
0.128648445,
0.093728222,
-0.602435112,
1.241388917,
0.1919994503,
-0.8282973766,
0.4201750755,
-0.5742552876,
-0.8076190948,
0.2264958173,
-0.0682635903,
-0.369708389,
0.2506450415,
0.1866180003,
0.5201692581,
0.1405797899,
-0.1817145795,
-0.1002610698,
-0.3750714958,
0.4986825287,
-0.1661993563,
0.1973373592,
0.0380814932,
-0.4709427059,
-0.0437045395,
-0.9351223111,
0.1428717524,
-0.0712953806,
-0.7431858778,
0.1672459543,
0.2429657429,
0.1403569728,
-0.0148208831,
0.4000273645,
-0.6945617795,
0.2338372171,
-0.4140665233,
0.0732428953,
0.5468468666,
0.5191202164,
0.2577472329,
-0.3452170193,
0.6261080503,
-0.0546671599,
-0.1245596558,
-0.5726551414,
-0.0946017727,
-1.0490363836,
0.2782427073,
0.2643836737,
0.6063081026,
-0.8489818573,
0.5902816653,
-0.0045921034,
0.0744913295,
-0.5059957504,
0.6502135992,
0.4597312212,
0.602533102,
0.297822535,
-0.0324980803,
-1.0907006264,
-0.6599400043,
-0.0155778015,
-0.3967061341,
-0.1317078173,
0.042262245,
0.2556582391,
0.025951596,
0.7430830598,
-0.693862617,
-0.1272875816,
-0.5640654564,
-0.085038282,
-0.2730182409,
0.4340437055,
0.3399081528,
-0.1551029533,
-0.507109642,
-0.2587482631,
-0.5954892039,
-0.5104712248,
-0.3398196101,
0.1397922784,
0.283993721,
0.7611584067,
-0.1772926003,
0.0348428749,
0.3060046136,
-0.0106901294,
0.2923234999,
-0.130340904,
0.174285084,
-1.3595217466,
-0.2402910292,
0.2485998273,
-0.396894753,
-0.4606774151,
-0.1331243068,
-0.0792654604,
0.2509299517,
-0.0601351038,
-0.0350317992,
-0.3536010981,
0.3355828822,
-0.5245212317,
0.2156687975,
-0.0561456904,
0.1987060457,
0.0119024841,
0.6800475717,
0.4342008829,
-0.4001803398,
0.4415505528,
-0.1406015158,
-0.1617394686,
0.6365526915,
-0.4783191085,
0.2014246583,
-0.1405412406,
0.2084927261,
-1.2729794979,
-0.4087526798,
-0.0893486366,
-0.7418058515,
0.3996780813,
0.3964785337,
-0.249275893,
-0.4978840649,
-0.614123404,
-0.2597799897,
0.3089963794,
-0.2480512559,
-0.0994590893,
0.3685729206,
-0.4661242962,
-0.5728093982,
-0.83072716,
0.100897558,
0.0506865419,
-0.5186003447,
0.0385026261,
-0.3928219974,
-0.3836203218,
0.0012506753,
0.1950493306,
0.2217738181,
-0.1200278774,
0.2623578608,
0.2761524022,
-0.1149026155,
0.3702738583,
-0.0165802054,
0.1319241673,
0.3257277608,
-0.043044772,
0.1438069344,
0.0096068233,
-0.114062123,
-0.1821129918,
0.5480018258,
0.0744993687,
0.2246757001,
0.4328913689,
0.0870902613,
-0.2914532721,
-0.721432507,
-0.4645422697,
-0.3295908272,
-0.422919929,
0.5325710177,
-0.3568448424,
-0.9863132238,
0.2354477942,
0.1651823074,
0.2264768034,
0.4214685857,
0.6222186685,
-0.5793744326,
1.0436507463,
0.8041660786,
0.0060746763,
0.4592092633,
-0.2613661885,
0.1977818757,
-0.4765099287,
-0.319024384,
-0.4744113982,
-0.2713742554,
-0.4763851762,
0.0285180137,
0.1161838099,
0.0072259526,
0.3497754931,
0.0732598603,
-0.2849401534,
0.5765787363,
0.4452985525,
0.1826643944,
0.1058015004,
-0.0395124331,
0.0485499911,
-0.4152047336,
-0.608674109,
-0.4310952723,
1.1125341654,
0.210365817,
0.8077612519,
-0.0495935529,
0.8587038517,
0.3906684816,
0.3276949227,
-0.7244250774,
0.6314736009,
-0.0811220631,
-0.124051027,
-0.240135625,
-0.4221757352,
-0.725887239,
-0.2190696001,
-0.3212885857,
-0.4108776152,
-0.3059536219,
0.2262375355,
-0.0900884271,
0.0415119417,
-0.8599198461,
0.3249377012,
0.0151943062,
-0.497538656,
0.0573514067,
-0.6742434502,
0.100245364,
0.2718869448,
0.1209394187,
0.4679469764,
0.0285833366,
0.819603622,
-0.9480481744,
1.1388083696,
-0.3563469052,
-0.2358914465,
0.5353842378,
-0.2317560464,
0.4252451658,
-0.0783439875,
0.1999766678,
-0.581060946,
-0.4440209866,
-0.2576890588,
-0.5535891652,
0.7636413574,
-0.756373167,
-0.5871706605,
-0.0021313273,
-0.7514164448,
-0.5590050817,
-0.1536368728,
0.3146426678,
0.3660083413,
-0.0082240291,
0.2351510972,
0.3923502862,
0.3577826917,
0.5531964898,
0.5691658854,
-0.1194576845,
-0.5288405418,
0.8768984079,
0.2642166317,
0.08847785,
0.4563773572,
-0.1162093133,
-0.3800354004,
-0.6849374771,
-0.4260759652,
0.2043305039,
-0.8478726745,
-0.2692614198,
-0.2643841207,
-0.1383923888,
-0.5344957709,
-0.1554242373,
0.1090162545,
-0.78795439,
-0.0987866595,
-0.7724930048,
0.300339222,
1.3769899607,
-0.0886922404,
0.2715851367,
-0.5665070415,
-0.0053755306,
0.1507381052,
0.1845666766,
-0.05963175,
-0.4888238907,
-0.7638026476,
-0.1422761977,
-0.2488420457,
-0.9756074548,
0.047067862,
0.0776084065,
0.4441213608,
0.0816923305,
-0.3368254304,
0.5321336985,
-0.5289677978,
1.3729170561,
0.0876329765,
-0.8435138464,
0.8376566768,
-0.0203689672,
0.2956665456,
0.5055419803,
0.1020619646,
-0.4710271358,
-1.0754468441,
-0.5336123705,
-0.9885469079,
0.5293526649,
-0.0050356393,
0.3669275939,
-0.1786577404,
0.6652400494,
0.2863111794,
0.2448739111,
-1.0960097313,
-0.2625488043,
-0.1243042648,
-0.4656600952,
-0.0781778097,
-0.4177729189,
0.0881582052,
-0.3380812407,
0.8782163858,
-0.1579450071,
-0.12998119,
0.3299144208,
-0.3617981374,
-0.5664116144,
0.2334805578,
0.6840909123,
0.6623336673,
0.1527220607,
0.2065034956,
0.4475071132,
-0.5776400566,
0.1025073305,
-0.090439938,
-0.2934550345,
0.1371746212,
0.7743430138,
0.5460259914,
0.0060804305,
-0.3666301072,
0.4754538834,
0.0226429775,
-0.4495109022,
-0.163340345,
0.3020341396,
-0.07402201,
-0.2410703301,
0.5039297342,
-0.167252928,
0.0423425175,
-0.5169485211,
0.501712203,
0.2159829289,
-0.1559303701,
-0.2836587727,
0.4601125717,
0.5360324383,
-0.259893775,
0.238665536,
-0.0809922516,
-0.4510433674,
0.4296132028,
0.8541560769,
0.8076606393,
-0.4112139046,
0.1755829751,
0.3775273263,
0.3700995147,
0.2608392537,
0.6826350689,
-0.1317792982,
-0.5706853271,
-0.90111655,
-0.2748788595,
-0.600969851,
0.3573866189,
-0.6399914026,
0.3452514112,
-0.3263715506,
0.1070010886,
-0.0650880039,
0.1255175322,
-0.2253886908,
0.5691138506,
0.2032908052,
0.5096142888,
-1.088537097,
0.609355092,
1.2041777372,
-0.7024592757,
-0.948876977,
0.2486770302,
-0.3276455998,
-0.527262032,
0.553501904,
0.1673831493,
-0.3799545467,
-0.0995867923,
-0.7301030159,
-0.4840334654,
0.614051342,
0.1454329044,
-0.5962335467,
0.0756100491,
0.5420257449,
0.9339832664,
-0.5317456126,
0.4408688545,
0.1544123143,
0.3242881894,
-0.2186795622,
-0.5207927823,
0.0409499481,
-0.6820340157,
0.1666352898,
-0.0348198377,
-0.4887882173,
0.6272065639,
-0.1491999626,
0.040056996,
0.1696999073,
0.8242750764,
-0.1739442199,
0.0065437844,
0.6450804472,
0.6249574423,
0.7167844772,
-0.1199114844,
1.1980321407,
-0.4122755527,
0.1972485334,
1.1817548275,
-0.2688482106,
0.8523581624,
0.7484063506,
-0.3481381536,
0.9279840589,
0.5175908804,
-0.0337882489,
0.2948591113,
0.5363388658,
-0.3896028399,
0.2487294674,
-0.0072890306,
-0.2865490913,
-0.1523815244,
0.1874575615,
-0.5334889293,
0.0495402962,
0.0586741194,
0.075996764,
0.3190773129,
-0.4416139424,
1.0053418875,
-0.1540301591,
-0.9433974624,
0.2330843061,
-0.0643216521,
0.7732236385,
-0.4766450226,
-0.3190442622,
-0.4735649228,
0.3545136452,
-0.7893728614,
-0.843102932,
0.2965857983,
0.3470046818,
-0.5839351416,
-0.2913570702,
0.6732946038,
-0.7931498289,
-0.5746875405,
-0.0315597951,
0.5436598659,
0.0455317013,
0.5846168995,
-0.1425522268,
-0.1551761925,
0.3060596585,
-0.5315592885,
0.0618309677,
0.3241508603,
0.1692587733,
0.2759824395,
0.4751169384,
0.3903257847,
0.224899143,
0.4394319952,
0.7996356487,
-0.4835265279,
-0.3935614824,
-0.6158934236,
0.8261668086,
-0.2827666402,
-0.1777129024,
1.1180456877,
0.8187681437,
1.1399291754,
-0.291336745,
1.287735939,
-0.1592627764,
1.0404696465,
-0.581572175,
0.2510332763,
-0.4397951365,
0.3408784568,
-0.1923416257,
-1.0005930662,
-0.2827340066,
0.5446272492,
-0.2634315193,
0.0038319123,
1.1012630463,
0.9298665524,
0.3004159033,
0.0593834445,
0.1830680966,
0.2811472118,
0.0050055268,
0.4969038069,
1.1551570892,
-0.3469691277,
0.5358365178,
-0.3984144926,
-0.0882638544,
0.0979086384,
-0.5811458826,
-0.8678031564,
-0.5164920092,
-0.416659832,
-0.5907232165,
0.0940305442,
0.6611985564,
0.3132033944,
-0.9760276079,
-0.3804121912,
-0.4964363575,
0.0632610768,
0.113841556,
-0.3686074615,
0.1296731532,
-0.958072722,
-1.0401736498,
0.5133377314,
-0.0046440805,
-0.039450027,
-0.5424280763,
-0.2634684443,
0.1862049252,
0.0635223314,
0.4299594462,
-0.0390063301,
-0.447137475,
-0.5298410058,
0.1512407959,
-0.2212023884,
0.1000492349,
1.0878423452,
-0.629638195,
0.2893612981,
0.5119200349,
0.3474555314,
0.3784128428,
-0.0994023532,
0.75249511,
-1.3693467379,
0.1085904241,
0.07639388,
0.3977792561,
0.6391767263,
-0.6010303497,
0.4926474988,
0.3413061798,
-0.4795207083,
-0.854454577,
0.1047882736,
-0.5938717127,
-0.0672842786,
1.0931152105,
-0.3024851084,
0.0837461054,
0.2517836988,
-0.4829070866,
0.1112065911,
-0.2655348182,
0.6755815744,
1.0278875828,
-0.3528268337,
-0.27815184,
-0.3621602952,
0.700255394,
0.7753891945,
-1.2348878384,
-0.2464579046,
0.8357934356,
0.3168440759,
0.1173898429,
0.5014624,
0.0167302862,
0.5085491538,
0.0097145848,
0.1336761266,
0.0307233427,
-0.4178241491,
-0.3657439351,
0.2940430343,
0.3879256248,
-0.1537332237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08995v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08995v1 | Impact of Sentiment Analysis in Fake Review Detection | 2022-12-18T03:17:47 | 2022-12-18T03:17:47 | Amira Yousif, James Buckley | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Fake review identification is an important topic and has gained the interest
of experts all around the world. Identifying fake reviews is challenging for
researchers, and there are several primary challenges to fake review detection.
We propose developing an initial research paper for investigating fake reviews
by using sentiment analysis. Ten research papers are identified that show fake
reviews, and they discuss currently available solutions for predicting or
detecting fake reviews. They also show the distribution of fake and truthful
reviews through the analysis of sentiment. We summarize and compare previous
studies related to fake reviews. We highlight the most significant challenges
in the sentiment evaluation process and demonstrate that there is a significant
impact on sentiment scores used to identify fake feedback. | [
-0.4343194664,
-0.5124142766,
0.629308939,
0.3009825647,
-0.1819091588,
0.3403193951,
0.4844072461,
-0.9095571041,
0.5957503915,
0.2958121598,
-0.5734068155,
-0.0526080653,
-0.6290996075,
0.2369971126,
-0.3308038116,
1.1626864672,
0.0382599421,
0.6297550201,
-0.2891153693,
-0.3864895105,
-0.2232138962,
-0.7094178796,
-0.2913405001,
0.1173191741,
0.4882549644,
-0.2171670645,
0.3471422493,
-0.2338378131,
0.4164417684,
0.2416881472,
-0.2942870557,
0.3013996184,
-0.2402523011,
-0.3122071624,
-0.0611283034,
-0.3776453733,
-0.4311344326,
0.8036113977,
0.379647553,
0.4057864249,
0.3458288312,
0.3251615465,
-0.0941911414,
0.7641124129,
-0.4827660322,
-0.0513394736,
-0.2666575313,
0.1816527992,
-0.2693254948,
-0.2122414708,
-0.3497928381,
-0.6582640409,
0.1968379915,
-0.235765487,
0.4122708142,
0.0388802961,
0.8486073017,
-0.2884092033,
-0.381729573,
-0.647560358,
-1.1089916229,
0.7293258905,
-0.5430392623,
0.0897101313,
-0.2923974693,
0.2202571183,
-0.0209360179,
-0.2630213499,
-0.9264618158,
-0.1801884323,
-0.1316255182,
0.4305909276,
-0.2054583132,
-0.3100655973,
0.1481064111,
0.7167823315,
-0.3676714003,
-0.3944511414,
-0.4365972877,
-0.3249585927,
0.7600394487,
0.0754498094,
0.3614534438,
-0.4182105958,
-0.3748140633,
-0.0802509561,
-0.3048890233,
-0.0109748207,
1.0360876322,
-0.0596161559,
0.3240072429,
0.2650805116,
-0.1956176758,
0.1783972979,
0.2374021411,
0.0512290001,
0.5119942427,
-0.3577417731,
-0.1166490167,
-0.0718785003,
0.82458812,
0.2104922533,
0.0884372741,
0.3110290468,
-0.4838543832,
0.3657293022,
0.6740683913,
-0.4734320939,
0.0959892794,
0.0990499556,
-0.8534908295,
-1.1291296482,
0.7547230721,
-0.8480245471,
-0.7671630979,
-0.1761387587,
0.5599820018,
0.1326306164,
-0.8216718435,
-0.1215768158,
-0.4229696989,
0.3761301935,
0.5965612531,
0.1206471696,
0.3956975043,
0.868524611,
0.6834599972,
-0.1070697308,
0.0171301756,
-0.0138972234,
-0.5974902511,
-0.6016010046,
0.9558205009,
-0.2626312375,
-0.3653779924,
0.0286581721,
0.2426036447,
0.1764909029,
-0.4882844388,
0.567050159,
-0.5235661268,
0.5175078511,
-0.5460197926,
-0.3839927912,
-0.3617146015,
0.630756855,
-0.7295862436,
0.8974433541,
0.1150161549,
-1.018535018,
0.2879970372,
-0.5486268401,
-0.2764127553,
-0.015110787,
0.288073808,
-0.5637764335,
0.6759933829,
0.0804006085,
-0.0203016661,
0.1882158071,
-0.0430908278,
-0.5385987759,
-0.1703600734,
0.6258608699,
-0.3488683403,
1.1071256399,
0.2700400054,
-0.4609666169,
0.0025469023,
-0.4493689239,
-0.0464937985,
0.0940925777,
0.2103830874,
-0.2944179177,
-0.2079928219,
0.336138159,
0.0968406945,
-0.1388818175,
-0.6838570237,
0.240962401,
-0.4573936462,
-0.0186305549,
0.6171063781,
0.6788455248,
0.2483088374,
-0.1602336168,
0.8781621456,
0.1589977294,
0.6172195077,
0.0385705233,
-0.721277833,
-0.6880230904,
0.1803850085,
0.7055618167,
0.6060421467,
-0.396651119,
0.1432055533,
-0.0274671987,
-0.4739544094,
-0.7005182505,
-0.1853225231,
0.5380067229,
0.2612576485,
0.2120093405,
-0.5706186891,
-0.3780421019,
-0.8622112274,
-0.8143122792,
-0.2408614159,
0.265044719,
-0.1479048282,
0.6978194714,
-0.2137727439,
0.9011433125,
-0.2928737402,
-0.6836971045,
-0.1941359341,
0.4251915812,
-0.1568703502,
0.2152942717,
0.5719229579,
-0.9294525385,
-0.3788334429,
-0.2432883084,
-0.5512798429,
-0.2430726141,
-0.0163845327,
0.0595003106,
0.4219575226,
0.2028493434,
-0.3391164541,
0.5048732758,
0.432754904,
-0.1056457981,
0.7964403629,
0.3001722097,
0.4308977425,
-0.6034554839,
0.094037801,
0.2643932104,
-0.0020910453,
-0.7110576034,
-0.0148359751,
-0.0869893953,
-0.2415079325,
-0.3108101785,
0.6939595938,
-0.3944369853,
0.0512080565,
-0.4192946255,
-0.3467185795,
0.1979109347,
-0.0178303327,
0.0817720219,
0.2196819335,
0.0282059051,
0.137220487,
0.21493949,
-0.1441769898,
-0.5808874965,
0.5361487269,
-0.51472193,
0.3502373695,
-0.0930224508,
0.6151964068,
-1.0627471209,
-0.2180800736,
0.7339047194,
-1.0110187531,
0.0996763706,
-0.3584187031,
-0.5007926226,
-0.4014859796,
-0.5585680008,
-0.1822586656,
0.3645092249,
-0.4428825974,
0.8453800082,
0.4205227494,
0.2740733922,
-0.6571636796,
-0.1277917027,
-0.1607487798,
-0.0908230096,
-0.3184893429,
0.0727871805,
0.2057350874,
-0.7316861153,
0.0299188737,
-0.4987153411,
0.0347454436,
-0.1350998878,
0.3665928245,
0.0366661027,
0.1318336874,
-0.2482284158,
-0.1752052903,
-0.0798823833,
0.5786417723,
0.3014220595,
0.1281781197,
-0.2850295603,
0.0148477387,
-0.6453084946,
0.2860552073,
0.7678602934,
-0.1230375245,
0.41127038,
0.7404382229,
-0.24346973,
-0.4376922548,
-0.7933219671,
-0.1875733435,
-0.4785856605,
0.0255541075,
-0.0499610715,
-0.1688120216,
0.2408523262,
-0.0080957804,
-0.3660060167,
0.3367350698,
0.222221747,
-0.44746539,
1.2391654253,
0.7162446976,
-0.2788269222,
0.330901444,
-0.0054303645,
0.4945949912,
-0.3331409693,
-0.3688027263,
-0.389113158,
-0.2056298405,
-0.5023533106,
-0.3325617611,
0.3336850405,
-0.0874011368,
0.7462007999,
-0.3418205678,
-0.7523104548,
0.4803881645,
0.5304390192,
0.1728903651,
0.1664342731,
-0.0571192242,
0.1437876225,
-0.074717395,
-0.148668021,
-0.6237820387,
0.803342402,
0.5102397799,
0.1847370863,
-0.3257087767,
0.4368259609,
0.7606067657,
0.8146417737,
-0.9980589151,
0.5922070146,
0.2283079028,
-0.7367596626,
0.2291541994,
-0.1743359268,
-0.3133989573,
0.0686041787,
-0.3004123569,
0.2031399906,
0.2371653169,
0.1213732287,
-0.0454936475,
0.032663893,
-0.6448883414,
0.5332967043,
-0.2895325124,
-0.1441273093,
-0.2110474855,
-0.3826071024,
0.5726574659,
0.1317288876,
0.5567985177,
0.0594957024,
0.5672031641,
1.0318722725,
-0.4576628208,
0.9604636431,
-0.8070799708,
-0.0219101384,
0.5650157928,
0.170946613,
0.290620476,
0.2189882845,
0.2348292172,
0.2640224695,
0.0861776695,
-0.2499293983,
-0.535875082,
0.7601502538,
-0.5234633684,
-0.6659222841,
-1.031230092,
-0.0061669638,
-0.3952078223,
-0.0733136237,
0.0941053778,
0.1562721729,
-0.2850850224,
-0.3544177711,
0.64672333,
-0.2094211578,
0.2934189737,
0.4172751606,
-0.3852921724,
-0.6972639561,
1.0293074846,
0.3961269855,
-0.3279904425,
-0.1053166166,
0.6603941917,
-0.2667735815,
-0.5680227876,
-0.4118131399,
0.4262335896,
-0.4272994995,
0.0908007547,
-0.574464798,
0.0932080001,
-0.5311371088,
0.1924743503,
-0.4897001088,
-0.2080273032,
-0.0631089658,
-0.1646303833,
0.180210799,
0.9648849368,
-0.1749489009,
0.0810656473,
-0.5034601688,
0.3118188381,
0.4048531353,
0.2639274597,
0.1128537133,
-0.3112935126,
-0.059276253,
-0.2819517851,
-0.3237901032,
-1.2623554468,
0.5225031972,
-0.4545907378,
0.3224187791,
0.8041422963,
-0.0439431705,
0.5512410998,
0.0619774722,
0.8246062994,
-0.0382468216,
-1.0829370022,
0.5599606633,
-0.3615347743,
-0.116067104,
0.4166704416,
0.7888159156,
-0.2260319144,
-0.0295459796,
-0.7581666708,
-0.2874141037,
0.3260858059,
-0.0189532451,
0.2886894345,
0.2073491961,
0.3755831122,
0.144961834,
0.2893078327,
-1.0276361704,
-0.1156900749,
-0.3221718371,
0.239318952,
0.2515409887,
-0.5800722837,
-0.2775589526,
-0.3614159822,
0.5511987805,
0.0987097099,
0.432803154,
0.2379698306,
-0.0240167361,
-0.2913477421,
-0.0058132191,
0.5411645174,
0.5065783858,
-0.2151808292,
-0.1505720764,
-0.1093569696,
-0.5615078807,
-0.0461298227,
-0.49642542,
-0.3157762885,
0.4384490848,
0.4403574765,
0.3518334627,
-0.2549871504,
-0.2230621725,
0.8545952439,
0.1111133024,
-0.5140949488,
-0.896538198,
-0.2919365466,
-0.2130628377,
-0.0693692341,
0.4960708618,
0.5646052957,
0.3771179318,
-0.8669008017,
-0.1073802114,
0.7392705083,
-0.8620297909,
-0.9209516048,
0.1261473596,
0.2151186913,
-0.3001342118,
0.350143075,
-0.2582207322,
-1.1796816587,
0.6532992721,
0.1649258286,
0.7613261342,
-0.3882501721,
0.5385158658,
0.2809094489,
0.4656881988,
-0.2897183001,
0.4984616339,
0.1571466178,
-0.6255751252,
-0.0543484837,
-0.7393696308,
-0.7258111835,
0.3468516767,
-0.8117684722,
0.3696841002,
-0.5408844352,
-0.1215133816,
0.0448247418,
0.3506801128,
-0.0692520738,
0.5720680952,
0.2875561714,
0.5613911152,
-1.1722761393,
0.5835854411,
0.605189383,
-0.2964476943,
-0.3602185547,
0.1174648777,
0.562761426,
-0.2091095299,
0.4754534662,
0.4307860434,
-0.5207507014,
-0.5739252567,
-0.869124651,
-0.2435344607,
0.3127276897,
-0.2418155968,
-0.2410195768,
0.2450584024,
-0.0897541195,
1.0314539671,
-0.3435296416,
0.3819750547,
0.2917994261,
0.5781505704,
-0.2551119924,
-0.3989678919,
-0.0822071731,
-0.5610774755,
-0.1916720569,
-0.0075857965,
-0.8112316132,
0.4841229618,
0.1377714723,
-0.341932416,
-0.351804018,
0.4474929273,
0.2534623742,
0.7959614396,
0.660558939,
0.3602505922,
0.4994129539,
-0.1231560633,
0.941883564,
0.0930155367,
0.3775412142,
0.6711826921,
-0.4256412089,
0.6959644556,
0.5706971884,
-0.0053170887,
0.7509148121,
0.5113659501,
-0.4760582149,
0.4593527317,
0.4736020267,
-0.3448262811,
0.0559322983,
0.0805782303,
-0.4389465153,
0.3075293005,
0.5712167621,
-0.3615804315,
0.4611137509,
0.2088082433,
0.2292258888,
-0.1330463439,
-0.4276687801,
0.5880075693,
-0.0304681268,
-0.3748933375,
-0.0542495996,
-0.0938157514,
0.8199685812,
-0.2930158079,
-0.1356342584,
-0.5477291942,
0.0532158948,
-0.5565633774,
-0.3439863324,
0.5600871444,
-0.0101793204,
-0.3166130781,
-0.5631230474,
0.8377627134,
0.3432332277,
-0.4946062863,
0.4496383667,
0.6492176056,
-0.0021146741,
-0.3829754889,
-0.5481927991,
0.087636441,
-0.1051184312,
-0.724406004,
0.4757670164,
0.2678028047,
-0.1013693064,
0.3427759111,
0.8673469424,
0.1273354292,
0.1851396412,
-0.0989314094,
0.4445919991,
-0.7309487462,
-0.4559244215,
-0.5771906376,
0.2635022402,
-0.3599843085,
-0.3756101429,
1.0209492445,
0.5059612989,
0.7864615321,
-0.6195139885,
0.8352481127,
-0.031277433,
0.9269912839,
-0.0822627544,
1.0877839327,
-0.5351623893,
0.1665640026,
-0.5745215416,
-0.9158365726,
-0.4043335617,
0.3960356414,
-0.4670204222,
0.0597529151,
0.7721915245,
0.6549534202,
-0.0279990882,
0.1036298946,
-0.020097807,
0.1871774495,
0.0829337165,
-0.4371364117,
1.1272617579,
-0.6301800013,
0.5479233861,
-0.4509590864,
-0.0531808846,
-0.2996479273,
-0.6770114303,
-0.8426943421,
-0.1864086539,
-0.5763388872,
-0.8869616389,
-0.2755412161,
0.4085817337,
0.5821897388,
-1.1723462343,
0.0110337324,
-0.0046617053,
0.1168174744,
-0.5702815652,
-0.3995273411,
0.1615983695,
0.0435092039,
-0.8417184949,
0.4168467522,
0.1342630982,
-0.0423065647,
-0.5072568655,
0.1138047129,
0.2551367879,
0.4831090868,
0.5763460398,
0.2866217494,
-0.720895946,
-0.329718858,
0.1181266308,
0.1088160127,
-0.0397151746,
1.2509713173,
-0.9082071185,
0.4605153799,
0.5064627528,
0.1751366109,
0.3571100235,
0.1801154912,
0.4245219827,
-0.5727825165,
-0.3178268075,
0.3596133292,
0.0725896731,
-0.0034125773,
-0.4400936663,
0.4474523962,
0.7478874922,
-0.335665077,
-1.3947482109,
0.0352922715,
-1.2505731583,
-0.2023745179,
0.8942210674,
-0.0263160989,
-0.1968613267,
-0.2852360308,
-0.2934961021,
-0.1666406393,
-0.1836557537,
1.0798555613,
0.9028124809,
-0.4199153483,
-0.3026634157,
-0.2571208775,
0.6554794312,
0.353278935,
-0.9971106648,
-0.2964113951,
0.3155337572,
0.4335424304,
0.5369117856,
0.5720340014,
-0.5844207406,
0.1810706705,
-0.0203270819,
0.0340107083,
0.0507928133,
-0.3331140876,
-0.7002319098,
0.6393659115,
-0.3049232662,
0.1430822462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08992v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08992v1 | PoE: a Panel of Experts for Generalized Automatic Dialogue Assessment | 2022-12-18T02:26:50 | 2022-12-18T02:26:50 | Chen Zhang, Luis Fernando D'Haro, Qiquan Zhang, Thomas Friedrichs, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chatbots are expected to be knowledgeable across multiple domains, e.g. for
daily chit-chat, exchange of information, and grounding in emotional
situations. To effectively measure the quality of such conversational agents, a
model-based automatic dialogue evaluation metric (ADEM) is expected to perform
well across multiple domains. Despite significant progress, an ADEM that works
well in one domain does not necessarily generalize to another. This calls for a
dedicated network architecture for domain generalization. To tackle the
multi-domain dialogue evaluation task, we propose a Panel of Experts (PoE), a
multitask network that consists of a shared transformer encoder and a
collection of lightweight adapters. The shared encoder captures the general
knowledge of dialogues across domains, while each adapter specializes in one
specific domain and serves as a domain expert. To validate the idea, we
construct a high-quality multi-domain dialogue dataset leveraging data
augmentation and pseudo-labeling. The PoE network is comprehensively assessed
on 16 dialogue evaluation datasets spanning a wide range of dialogue domains.
It achieves state-of-the-art performance in terms of mean Spearman correlation
over all the evaluation datasets. It exhibits better zero-shot generalization
than existing state-of-the-art ADEMs and the ability to easily adapt to new
domains with few-shot transfer learning. | [
-0.5055559278,
-0.7274420261,
0.3088978529,
0.2552283406,
-0.0342589319,
0.5059601068,
-0.0005177961,
-0.209459722,
0.414063096,
0.442042768,
-0.2110466063,
-0.2711243331,
-0.7532921433,
0.0433094837,
-0.1029928401,
0.9040014744,
0.0936847925,
-0.2704065144,
-0.1324899942,
-0.3743251562,
-0.5100730062,
-0.3332360685,
-0.889793396,
-0.1358038038,
0.084343493,
0.0962083787,
0.6493929625,
0.0700646341,
0.5403781533,
0.4832059443,
0.3133482039,
0.7318008542,
-0.3732950091,
0.000544989,
-0.2359319776,
-0.1919248402,
-1.142713666,
-0.1757486016,
0.4734661281,
0.5547042489,
-0.0349602401,
0.1117300987,
0.0885835886,
0.4097957909,
-0.4839074016,
0.4452798367,
-0.8698117137,
0.0276404601,
0.4327012897,
-0.2787796855,
-0.4885570705,
-0.1398226321,
0.477057308,
-0.8033081889,
0.2729250789,
0.215060845,
0.628534317,
0.3313092291,
-0.5762620568,
0.0880378112,
-0.6698688269,
0.7342494726,
-0.3047592938,
0.1000229269,
0.0546659753,
0.5226957202,
-0.1724994332,
-0.5831648707,
-0.6630240679,
0.0638962686,
-0.1088222414,
0.397808373,
-0.5258523822,
0.4772959352,
-0.0330175683,
0.2033335418,
-0.6272435784,
-0.2665014565,
-0.0920985267,
-0.3456889987,
0.6903653741,
0.4220301509,
0.3680515587,
0.0462822206,
-0.4327143133,
0.1469406784,
-0.0404405296,
0.0451011769,
0.497200489,
0.0573875792,
0.0401486196,
0.0375077501,
-0.3115206361,
0.7675116658,
0.1104646996,
0.0508877374,
0.3117870986,
-0.5486389399,
-0.3051517904,
-0.3803992569,
1.1468946934,
0.6836633682,
0.2090751827,
-0.1440832019,
-0.008815486,
0.1318976432,
0.6057738066,
-0.4364024997,
-0.4286451936,
0.0670507103,
-0.4827573597,
-0.2141803801,
-0.1478893459,
-0.8852941394,
-0.2856443226,
-0.32849437,
0.5455141068,
-0.0973921418,
-0.4033404589,
0.1969305128,
-0.2111944854,
-0.1216427237,
0.7356271148,
-0.5638303757,
0.8465231061,
0.4724007845,
0.7174817324,
-0.4068902433,
-0.1882490069,
-0.4227797091,
-0.2573646903,
-0.3041252792,
0.9608111382,
-0.7206905484,
-0.2421658635,
-0.1589670479,
0.074395135,
-0.7317739725,
-0.3400600553,
0.4411673546,
-0.5610727668,
0.1785806865,
0.4099549651,
-0.3973011672,
-0.4007939398,
0.4387300909,
-0.4960914552,
0.6937942505,
0.0512655377,
-0.4115279615,
0.1416341513,
-0.9298704267,
-0.0770485327,
0.1563921571,
-0.1960556954,
-0.2073402256,
-0.1675616652,
0.4300844967,
0.4416218102,
-0.2427477837,
0.4958440959,
-0.2682857513,
-0.2365178168,
0.1872096807,
-0.699849844,
0.4225898087,
0.0204361565,
-0.1393321157,
0.2978647053,
-0.7795682549,
0.0709857717,
-0.2279037386,
0.0308612268,
-0.1731556803,
-0.1879033148,
-0.2021938711,
0.185565114,
-0.0190376211,
-0.7270441651,
0.2172845453,
-0.3056663573,
0.3308659196,
0.6917006969,
0.3214346766,
0.3027396798,
-0.3383198977,
0.6140129566,
0.0429999977,
0.2601616979,
-0.3047202528,
-0.8390843868,
-0.902355969,
-0.2704607844,
0.0657825246,
0.6959571242,
-0.92459023,
0.7359859943,
-0.4962981939,
-0.3862782717,
-0.6432679892,
0.1011014581,
0.5213295221,
0.5160777569,
0.4923917949,
-0.8661066294,
-0.2151424438,
-1.0751389265,
0.0158575531,
-0.2711090446,
-0.1572839171,
0.5925108194,
0.2685892284,
-0.3238783181,
1.1045393944,
-0.5444227457,
-0.3748536408,
-0.3014122844,
0.3165905178,
0.1314758062,
0.2719044685,
0.417917788,
-0.5011112094,
-0.7899549007,
0.1106621251,
-0.5913564563,
0.1340376884,
-0.2551846802,
-0.2378485203,
-0.2006416172,
-0.0819077641,
-0.6203220487,
0.4010584354,
0.4164521694,
0.0335093029,
0.5484737754,
-0.1271627098,
0.3590229154,
-0.9818427563,
0.1106243804,
0.1012728512,
-0.3713208437,
-0.9043807983,
-0.4274506569,
-0.3185540438,
-0.2660283148,
-0.2659634352,
0.6963953376,
0.0584800504,
0.0317476057,
-0.2504571378,
0.2588299513,
0.4787332416,
1.0718131065,
0.0511099473,
0.8478901982,
0.7151380181,
-0.5589625239,
0.7136621475,
0.556933403,
-0.3236595988,
0.6243029833,
-0.847889781,
0.5953668952,
0.1952632219,
0.6814456582,
-1.2476327419,
-0.0198176038,
0.218888402,
-0.5516576171,
0.1166816652,
-0.2500802875,
-0.1220383644,
-0.4032763839,
-0.0648998544,
0.4042561054,
0.1919681877,
-0.3576794267,
0.751584053,
0.6776538491,
-0.2630317807,
-0.8036821485,
-0.0688023642,
0.2910527289,
-0.0549784377,
-1.0134323835,
0.1483836174,
-0.1732928902,
-0.1151597127,
-0.2274082154,
-0.0915457457,
-0.4238215983,
-0.0282389279,
0.1979086101,
0.1533633024,
-0.2258515656,
0.1810199916,
0.029028574,
-0.2610148191,
0.0284808874,
-0.2606464624,
0.2894486785,
-0.4502805769,
-0.3917466402,
-0.6670629382,
0.215743795,
0.4584602714,
-0.0928636938,
0.1667478979,
0.5979198813,
-0.0428860709,
-0.3283426464,
-0.6343912482,
-0.0289331656,
-0.4799420834,
0.4474459291,
-0.5946954489,
-0.7285631895,
0.6592653394,
-0.3664724827,
0.1578071713,
0.5673997998,
0.3380818963,
0.00700062,
1.0498012304,
0.5070081949,
-0.1688882858,
0.0547260679,
-0.3900726438,
0.3957025409,
-0.8937115669,
0.0652859136,
-0.1887015998,
-0.2765178084,
-0.1181718931,
-0.6293208599,
0.3857930601,
-0.5010380149,
0.031512741,
0.5579536557,
-0.517560184,
0.4126650095,
0.2369255424,
0.0914600641,
0.2667128146,
-0.1588765234,
0.064585641,
0.2986680865,
-0.6550992131,
-0.6925221086,
1.1065535545,
0.5335412621,
0.4784672558,
-0.0374554209,
0.1022720486,
0.6507816315,
0.0271602627,
-0.8970646262,
0.5744236708,
-0.1980678588,
-0.4127824605,
-0.3086287975,
-0.4331392646,
-0.9131535292,
0.4987078011,
0.2248815894,
-0.7697047591,
0.345610708,
0.0936021954,
-0.7442301512,
0.1973905563,
-0.7751422524,
0.8892593384,
0.0930621698,
-0.1353847235,
-0.3374020755,
-0.8894085884,
0.3007216454,
-0.0177460965,
0.0735376701,
-0.2753927112,
0.273016572,
0.8876464963,
-0.1559775323,
0.8720605373,
-0.3427528739,
0.1608891636,
0.6992946267,
0.0603378899,
0.192272827,
0.1098422036,
-0.040925324,
0.2720585465,
-0.2018836737,
-0.233110249,
-0.880812943,
0.3674151599,
-1.0772043467,
-0.5164685845,
0.0760297328,
-0.3573976755,
-0.6984956264,
-0.1547780633,
-0.191794157,
0.8538883924,
-0.4967199266,
0.1039144099,
0.5716030598,
-0.2481799871,
0.1944575459,
0.5635278225,
0.2905049324,
-0.3808759451,
1.1329935789,
-0.253159374,
0.3309199214,
0.4319198728,
0.0423911549,
-0.1479234546,
-0.2539925575,
-0.6729968786,
-0.3662409484,
-0.6419888735,
-0.3503302932,
-1.0020091534,
-0.3601980507,
-0.3108458519,
-0.0076248678,
-0.5707373023,
-0.5497142673,
0.1079849675,
-0.1639479995,
0.1496047378,
0.5471191406,
0.2878674269,
0.7071923018,
-0.9751151204,
0.3617328405,
0.6915634274,
0.2677063942,
-0.0200585481,
-0.5686727762,
-0.1400920153,
-0.0410669371,
-0.6551465392,
-0.3181077242,
0.22502096,
0.6473841667,
0.8838472366,
0.4898430705,
0.1329615116,
0.5373304486,
-0.5391095281,
0.8937535286,
0.2329999954,
-0.9253469706,
0.3449777961,
-0.3780978024,
0.0976760164,
0.6980395317,
0.1243520603,
-0.512221694,
-0.5211979747,
-0.738298595,
-0.478848666,
0.664534986,
0.2422620058,
0.4700530171,
0.0494506285,
-0.1125638559,
0.4128212035,
0.3450424969,
-0.2093781233,
-0.097830683,
-0.4176286161,
-0.1635356098,
0.1123124212,
0.1609436721,
-0.5073723793,
-0.0615371764,
0.3822079599,
-0.5825969577,
0.749283433,
0.1768791974,
-0.1605134308,
-0.0592038967,
0.3208315074,
0.4734900296,
0.8773858547,
-0.1906712949,
-0.0033683004,
0.2722855508,
-0.3819336295,
0.1753523946,
-0.0814684704,
0.5021768808,
0.1650460213,
0.4784878492,
1.2738828659,
-0.0483021066,
-0.3379987776,
0.7681145072,
-0.3714248538,
-0.287032783,
-0.0045074411,
0.2767464519,
-0.5598096848,
-0.0176398028,
0.3642404079,
0.7179247141,
0.3756438792,
-0.3445734382,
0.5252041221,
0.2193578035,
-0.4353008568,
-0.6597653627,
0.2315215617,
0.9301247597,
-0.3207299709,
0.3939807713,
-0.3154594302,
-0.7921541333,
0.7792257071,
-0.0653657541,
1.1200741529,
-0.3595108092,
0.468052268,
0.3324917555,
0.1545772552,
0.2745726109,
-0.0802840963,
-0.1318250448,
-1.1301656961,
-0.3943779767,
-0.3780010939,
-0.7865501046,
0.0227802992,
-0.371547997,
0.0638518706,
-0.2524992824,
-0.3506058156,
-0.1133557037,
0.000064365,
-1.0192805529,
0.2871353626,
-0.1469745934,
0.5195806623,
-0.8159524798,
0.7745395303,
0.4788950086,
-0.0233575478,
-0.4278542995,
-0.147377193,
-0.0087274145,
-1.0468064547,
0.5812324882,
0.1312213689,
-0.2916815877,
-0.1859214753,
-0.218565315,
-0.5341809988,
0.7986890078,
-0.0794353932,
-0.5288460255,
0.0998706743,
0.0936729908,
0.8207892776,
-0.7229041457,
0.9719915986,
0.3718844056,
0.2272190601,
0.025399534,
-1.4444339275,
-0.2064914852,
-0.5812010169,
-0.3337282538,
-0.0674346015,
-0.9236100912,
0.3412726521,
0.0992358699,
0.0636570007,
-0.3302747607,
0.3600385785,
-0.228634432,
0.4460785985,
0.8923593163,
0.3076195717,
0.6388043761,
0.1084529161,
0.6479848623,
-0.5596513152,
0.2616175413,
1.15014112,
-0.3240666091,
0.4976606667,
-0.1193204671,
-0.3093324006,
0.4440050423,
0.4143294394,
-0.0502617992,
0.330183655,
0.1324727535,
-0.219810918,
-0.3656076491,
-0.1713914126,
-0.0887726098,
0.6870258451,
0.7309899926,
-0.231860891,
-0.1739023775,
0.0074813445,
-0.3697315753,
-0.1973183602,
-0.098390907,
1.157083869,
0.0840574801,
-0.5657872558,
0.3120070994,
-0.2476590276,
0.4483040869,
-0.5911280513,
-0.0655214563,
-0.051207304,
0.1620579213,
-0.1364607215,
-0.8063005209,
0.4153080583,
-0.2394296378,
0.2135268301,
-0.2456703037,
0.9844340086,
-0.3511407971,
-0.188657999,
0.4423868954,
0.630744338,
0.2687666416,
-0.1029106826,
-0.7724887133,
-0.127248168,
-0.2302258313,
-0.224999696,
0.2144438028,
0.3344041109,
0.141145587,
0.5964968801,
0.2815911174,
-0.2338301688,
-0.1657462269,
0.2559456825,
0.9248732924,
0.0477732122,
-0.3969248831,
-0.3957607448,
0.7215934396,
-0.3890325725,
-0.5525829196,
0.5859581828,
0.4227468073,
0.4770299196,
0.0009265823,
1.011117816,
0.3015461266,
0.3972034156,
0.0013384341,
0.6022350788,
-0.3655905724,
-0.0815010965,
-0.3328478634,
-0.9382272363,
-0.0920001268,
0.6225233078,
-0.2747743726,
-0.2320728153,
0.6594879031,
0.6169658303,
-0.2293536067,
0.3216200471,
0.4680560529,
0.0999167189,
0.5894435644,
0.534047842,
0.7517839074,
-0.5740658045,
0.667348206,
-0.0011321119,
-0.4753098488,
-0.0455845296,
-0.3974573016,
-1.0487009287,
-0.5734331012,
-0.6095571518,
0.0690825731,
0.0906462893,
0.9643570781,
0.791328311,
-0.8500591516,
-0.2352270931,
0.1383847147,
0.0003785892,
-0.2850365341,
-0.261425674,
0.3878872395,
-0.5578535795,
-0.740187943,
0.7610787153,
0.5548107624,
-0.5022613406,
-0.1364499032,
0.0827094465,
0.1668943614,
0.2590668797,
0.6230841279,
-0.0899343193,
-0.5381393433,
-0.5446333289,
-0.0374446027,
0.0603317544,
0.2442191392,
0.7376770973,
-0.58305794,
1.0869048834,
0.5699623227,
0.87067765,
-0.0360162221,
0.2278446406,
0.9743574858,
-0.8228558898,
-0.0845340863,
0.3478880823,
0.3608956933,
0.1270222217,
-0.2560260296,
0.5296880603,
0.3445350826,
-0.8947950006,
-0.4981445074,
0.0425431281,
-1.0466696024,
0.2876751125,
0.8943935633,
-0.6749991179,
0.1246699467,
-0.7916762233,
-0.3739600182,
0.0387716517,
-0.8176227808,
0.7905228734,
0.7935757041,
-0.4023907483,
-0.0252591744,
-0.5450927019,
0.4149985015,
0.3182679713,
-0.8975162506,
0.0627038181,
0.1403646767,
0.0616051108,
0.5482110977,
0.9821410179,
0.4134049416,
0.0393197536,
0.0692520812,
-0.0327189378,
0.0548441075,
-0.6570453048,
-0.0771356672,
0.1877514124,
-0.3796136677,
-0.4664426446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08987v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08987v1 | A Robust Semantic Frame Parsing Pipeline on a New Complex Twitter Dataset | 2022-12-18T01:59:49 | 2022-12-18T01:59:49 | Yu Wang, Hongxia Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Most recent semantic frame parsing systems for spoken language understanding
(SLU) are designed based on recurrent neural networks. These systems display
decent performance on benchmark SLU datasets such as ATIS or SNIPS, which
contain short utterances with relatively simple patterns. However, the current
semantic frame parsing models lack a mechanism to handle out-of-distribution
(\emph{OOD}) patterns and out-of-vocabulary (\emph{OOV}) tokens. In this paper,
we introduce a robust semantic frame parsing pipeline that can handle both
\emph{OOD} patterns and \emph{OOV} tokens in conjunction with a new complex
Twitter dataset that contains long tweets with more \emph{OOD} patterns and
\emph{OOV} tokens. The new pipeline demonstrates much better results in
comparison to state-of-the-art baseline SLU models on both the SNIPS dataset
and the new Twitter dataset (Our new Twitter dataset can be downloaded from
https://1drv.ms/u/s!AroHb-W6_OAlavK4begsDsMALfE?e=c8f2XX ). Finally, we also
build an E2E application to demo the feasibility of our algorithm and show why
it is useful in real application. | [
-0.1038047895,
-0.7528510094,
0.5465240479,
0.0759640783,
-0.4789876342,
0.2070463896,
-0.1169319153,
-0.4941990077,
0.3264300823,
0.6317747235,
-0.6332061291,
-0.7592202425,
-0.7515960336,
-0.1153694689,
-0.7270820141,
0.5606967211,
0.0762162507,
-0.0018315158,
0.3293660879,
-0.3408698738,
-0.4136306345,
-0.0025081497,
-0.6363574862,
-0.3020592928,
0.2163333446,
0.4333846569,
0.5059392452,
0.8302585483,
0.3159122467,
0.2555049062,
-0.1161725298,
0.2793928683,
-0.5777873397,
0.6479024291,
-0.2953962088,
-0.048286736,
-0.3950873315,
-0.5999137759,
0.7127528191,
0.5416215658,
-0.1874409914,
0.4010927677,
-0.0658688769,
0.4188704491,
-0.6213927269,
0.299333334,
-0.8942511678,
-0.0607072935,
-0.4047155082,
-0.0998414531,
-0.5352728963,
0.1787031442,
-0.097925745,
-0.5116862655,
-0.0074813925,
0.173991099,
1.0931237936,
0.2643916011,
-0.0483291037,
-0.1054384112,
-0.3672788441,
0.8252554536,
-0.6747387052,
0.5692279935,
0.1599323601,
0.5106603503,
-0.3485348821,
-0.8674989939,
-0.3990823328,
0.1838728935,
0.0710791945,
-0.1695445925,
-0.3042751253,
-0.1925747842,
0.1388839483,
-0.0240721554,
-0.5085241199,
0.1349056214,
0.060312558,
-0.2025805712,
0.1732729077,
0.1153707281,
0.3060778081,
-0.322024405,
-0.5799524188,
0.1034678519,
-0.4928051829,
0.0394543037,
0.1197562069,
0.4275911748,
-0.0019971908,
0.7564208508,
-0.3081277311,
0.8316861987,
-0.1817565709,
-0.0098251766,
0.2390165031,
-0.3316214681,
-0.2666768134,
0.1152467579,
0.5329959393,
0.3947033584,
0.2230496705,
-0.2037150711,
-0.4321090281,
0.1908891797,
-0.0570542254,
-0.6214215755,
-0.0646647811,
0.206500262,
-0.4566009939,
-0.184685111,
0.2192945033,
-0.7813301682,
-0.1823800206,
-0.1545247585,
0.0939557105,
-0.559228003,
-0.4000871778,
0.5424849987,
-0.2737954855,
0.3332483768,
0.2448708415,
-0.8337269425,
0.3076964617,
1.0803723335,
1.042047143,
-0.1888105273,
-0.1756484658,
-1.1946229935,
0.2054925412,
-0.0454028361,
0.8676063418,
-0.6196349263,
0.1384747475,
0.0040086517,
-0.1035497487,
-0.0077123628,
-0.3146373332,
0.4031411707,
-0.5697718263,
-0.1284788698,
-0.0740561262,
-0.6249841452,
0.2021607608,
0.1977122724,
-0.5633901358,
0.9388514161,
0.1501089931,
-0.8911132812,
0.5265101194,
-0.8179334402,
-0.2217293531,
-0.0581792034,
-0.1394216418,
-0.2031677961,
0.0354807414,
0.450928688,
0.5024562478,
-0.1360902488,
0.4198482931,
-0.6893108487,
-0.2305186391,
-0.1518227905,
-0.176927045,
0.9549012184,
0.4562667608,
-0.3223665655,
0.1217545494,
-0.9534522891,
0.3136214614,
0.0548901483,
-0.0641228929,
-0.2934163809,
0.1221939251,
0.2201729119,
0.2580666244,
-0.1179493591,
-1.0103538036,
-0.172805205,
-0.4870136678,
1.0511751175,
0.7282161713,
-0.2250928879,
0.4356484711,
-0.0396485552,
0.159901619,
0.1235018149,
0.0443724953,
-0.3775779903,
-0.546412468,
-0.6219879985,
-0.3734088242,
0.0128156021,
0.504278183,
-0.9491470456,
0.6284469962,
-0.6301754713,
-0.0620802082,
-0.5437274575,
0.1554843783,
0.3076848388,
0.522806406,
0.2088742107,
-0.1816301197,
-0.5942438245,
-0.5660303235,
-0.4409390092,
-0.1364627928,
-0.0521424897,
0.0518130437,
0.3664805889,
-0.1181999519,
1.3969453573,
-0.2751580775,
-0.1016044915,
-0.5667660236,
-0.1393868029,
0.2678301632,
0.4495302141,
0.4528741241,
-0.6691918969,
-0.2165068537,
0.0108568873,
-0.6098411679,
-0.1478171796,
0.2070313692,
-0.4818150997,
0.1010019183,
0.6106817126,
-0.6633046269,
0.4742719829,
0.5730894208,
-0.8572130799,
-0.1596955359,
0.384218961,
-0.3236494958,
-1.2779701948,
-0.0639163479,
-0.1254903227,
-0.8368755579,
-0.6316192746,
0.0163584538,
-0.1195001826,
-0.2195935994,
-0.8227360249,
0.4671319723,
-0.1882644743,
-0.2714887559,
0.0482852273,
0.2539609969,
0.4748425782,
0.1504198611,
-0.0115317777,
0.2064679563,
0.5239049792,
-0.0218065251,
0.6038648486,
0.1419686526,
-0.6578040123,
0.0827476382,
-0.6931999326,
0.190340966,
-0.2594614625,
0.2674117982,
-1.0337955952,
-0.267336905,
0.4726325572,
-0.583188355,
0.4390046,
-0.2604072094,
-0.605553925,
0.1188482344,
-0.3707818985,
0.348184824,
0.210976094,
-0.6251395345,
0.6613034606,
0.4216571748,
0.1567563713,
-0.6376532912,
-1.0435359478,
0.1755917221,
-0.1955421865,
-1.2274280787,
0.197054863,
0.48886168,
-0.3738889098,
0.33736673,
-0.0922115296,
-0.1141395345,
0.0620983392,
0.0694613606,
0.28972736,
-0.6618093848,
-0.0540196598,
-0.0304008219,
-0.4381059706,
-0.1321210861,
-0.5453052521,
0.8702161908,
-0.3039153218,
-0.3870595992,
-0.5387020111,
0.5413972735,
0.5041409731,
-0.0591990575,
0.7828890085,
0.9023254514,
-0.5253785849,
-0.2280555069,
-0.5093957186,
-0.0314399302,
-0.40654549,
0.4060609639,
-0.0842504576,
-0.9888249636,
0.4154087901,
0.215236783,
0.1241567731,
0.35278216,
0.3519112468,
0.0992117822,
0.8079289794,
0.2481223643,
-0.1254873276,
0.6849524975,
-0.3770649433,
0.2438537627,
-0.5665442944,
0.0521006584,
-0.3877564669,
-0.1744217128,
-0.4204261303,
-0.32679075,
-0.2042364925,
-0.0435256921,
-0.2014618218,
0.4453553557,
-0.1751597077,
0.4472569823,
0.4764203131,
0.1274241954,
0.2083019018,
0.1447243392,
0.1253860146,
0.1969012618,
-0.6008947492,
-0.5413377881,
0.6807588935,
0.6641866565,
0.7948204875,
0.2809806168,
0.7000142932,
0.4001787901,
-0.1834099144,
-0.7315917015,
0.4433549047,
-0.2104477435,
-0.2773081064,
-0.4710465372,
-0.3478495479,
-0.649133265,
0.190004319,
-0.2135447413,
-0.9260061383,
0.3517748415,
0.0680652186,
-0.3027076125,
0.623357594,
-1.0192103386,
0.9415107369,
0.1386178136,
-0.2419967651,
0.1532036811,
-0.838255465,
0.1616403908,
0.2104214132,
0.1644767523,
-0.6306205988,
-0.1902663857,
0.4362086654,
-0.519472301,
0.7002986073,
-0.3879559636,
0.1719164699,
0.225902006,
-0.0889192,
0.5835095644,
0.2221346945,
-0.2455366552,
0.2076423317,
-0.0168616585,
-0.6324709058,
-0.4508270025,
0.7562814951,
-0.5372512937,
-0.1809731722,
-0.2933056951,
-0.2937802076,
-0.126721248,
0.3390765488,
0.4976429045,
0.7003947496,
0.1750014424,
0.4101825356,
0.326869756,
0.061683666,
0.6148681641,
0.1094164103,
-0.1243142113,
-0.3687014878,
0.8529604077,
-0.1411259919,
0.408863157,
0.473028928,
0.3206520081,
-0.4086173475,
-0.7521865964,
-0.6909629703,
-0.0242248029,
-0.8451065421,
-0.4217752218,
-0.531586647,
-0.1761816442,
-0.5680324435,
0.0611163564,
-0.4225362539,
-0.4973685145,
-0.2891687155,
-0.2092480958,
0.2961656749,
0.7771942019,
0.3273996413,
0.1591166407,
-0.8315059543,
0.2774838507,
-0.0378935449,
0.4531962872,
-0.2072429657,
-0.4693130255,
0.0110186469,
0.1034047827,
-0.1203047335,
-0.5762744546,
0.3874319792,
0.5122389197,
0.3126731515,
0.5172522664,
0.3069079518,
0.9068635702,
-0.5430070162,
0.8527463675,
0.3211944401,
-1.0810474157,
0.6661182642,
-0.4272441864,
0.1837681681,
0.4833335876,
-0.3040381968,
-0.4739891887,
-0.6087145209,
-0.3757635653,
-1.0073990822,
1.0255513191,
0.445758462,
0.0857915655,
-0.3380533159,
0.2338811457,
0.2058487833,
0.0783216357,
-0.547349453,
-0.1720026433,
-0.5016341805,
-0.3536068797,
0.2491916567,
-0.3909774721,
0.172872752,
-0.0125017175,
0.4605506659,
0.0165511724,
0.195250988,
0.1012633368,
-0.3425631523,
-0.0919081494,
0.3001700044,
0.4833442867,
0.7672862411,
-0.2689419389,
0.1480789632,
0.0191248842,
-0.4382541478,
-0.1056670174,
-0.0991549268,
-0.1386247128,
0.3396111429,
0.5706526041,
0.9799659848,
0.1848912686,
-0.7754353881,
0.5787792802,
-0.0731168762,
-0.0097388355,
-0.3000923097,
-0.0572896004,
-0.1067133322,
0.3859599233,
0.117829375,
0.370123148,
0.0428064317,
-0.5545529723,
0.3305003643,
0.0383586213,
-0.4110707343,
-0.1551921964,
0.5288307667,
0.08825019,
-0.3631344438,
0.5211964846,
-0.1538347304,
-0.0710091367,
0.2377894074,
0.5450776815,
0.9808151126,
0.2094944268,
-0.0098785684,
0.0208602007,
-0.0692673773,
-0.1519367695,
0.2641895711,
-0.0781940445,
-0.9233543277,
-0.5714438558,
-0.7440626621,
0.0488864817,
-0.0454998724,
-0.8631685376,
0.6022408009,
-0.4073015451,
-0.2115820795,
0.0057625244,
-0.5918168426,
-0.5670166016,
-0.0845365897,
0.2039086223,
1.0765078068,
-0.6690502763,
1.1261558533,
0.5414911509,
0.0936783329,
-0.602845192,
-0.0501715653,
0.0531258956,
-1.2225475311,
0.5641801953,
0.3029851913,
-0.4687320888,
-0.0074171,
-0.1622553915,
-0.8993902802,
1.0707191229,
0.7227606773,
-0.5166014433,
-0.2178172618,
0.2043357491,
0.219936341,
-0.6197659373,
-0.0111234961,
0.6827499866,
0.2327459306,
0.4077571034,
-0.5127711296,
0.0245228019,
-0.2989376485,
0.1769250631,
0.4526239336,
-0.2172097713,
0.6174504757,
-0.1412666291,
-0.3691073358,
0.1149974391,
0.6982441545,
-0.070587337,
0.7098250389,
0.8222210407,
0.7440419197,
0.4000187814,
-0.3041483164,
0.7557339668,
-0.2932787538,
0.6769920588,
1.2943532467,
-0.22204189,
1.1641414165,
0.6660988331,
0.1561133265,
0.3563156128,
0.3811352849,
0.3320342004,
0.5572832823,
0.0315566175,
-0.0467220917,
-0.5638132691,
-0.2231127322,
-0.1479013413,
0.6478427649,
0.444136858,
-0.3546788692,
-0.6389479637,
-0.0051088179,
0.0728313029,
0.1473142207,
-0.2276129425,
0.7589464784,
0.0816676393,
-0.3513861597,
0.4248044789,
-0.1093095243,
0.5165621638,
-0.6055435538,
0.0042161481,
0.1016181409,
0.2333829552,
-0.2486062795,
-1.0273447037,
0.7606444955,
0.1283346266,
0.1052990705,
-0.4532952607,
0.7480453849,
-0.308232069,
-0.4048349857,
0.5129423738,
0.3175742328,
-0.0617200434,
0.073674351,
-0.6561181545,
0.2974712849,
-0.0817059875,
-0.2112101465,
0.1150654629,
0.6032028198,
0.1465653181,
0.6206119061,
0.594201386,
0.1222091466,
0.3446944952,
0.3645884395,
0.9470931888,
-0.633754015,
-0.5098967552,
-1.1018297672,
0.5034114718,
-0.2600529194,
-0.2489244044,
0.5327099562,
0.3983241916,
0.8243176341,
0.2133139074,
0.4426270425,
-0.2309274226,
0.6620520949,
-0.8483290672,
0.4149257839,
-0.5590217113,
0.5385903716,
-0.2232584655,
-0.7366397381,
-0.509753406,
0.5503487587,
0.047108043,
-0.3597624898,
0.5532678962,
0.6663805246,
-0.2214077413,
0.1875539273,
0.3772604465,
0.1731431633,
0.5358927846,
0.4723663926,
0.8316069245,
-0.2561881542,
0.6353819966,
-0.177377373,
0.029311657,
-0.2724930048,
-1.0831929445,
-0.8203068972,
-0.4877901077,
0.0311647058,
-0.7664042115,
0.2913472056,
1.2845703363,
0.6767480969,
-0.9526565075,
0.0363167077,
-0.3514414132,
0.1946162134,
0.0558476336,
-0.219742924,
0.3157977164,
-0.5975750089,
-0.5531187654,
0.1854755878,
0.5872655511,
-0.20418109,
-0.0082332995,
0.0553396754,
-0.0664561093,
-0.2309931517,
0.7358410358,
0.0279317554,
-1.0181559324,
-0.7990406156,
0.1037918329,
0.1627558023,
0.1533522308,
0.8705039024,
-0.4167852402,
0.5421763062,
0.7504255176,
0.7350303531,
0.3167409003,
-0.0581711233,
0.4497013986,
-0.6834372282,
0.2338591069,
0.3043694794,
0.8475371003,
0.3669678867,
-0.1061938927,
0.2516458333,
0.3654188216,
-0.2297639847,
-0.8750350475,
0.3044915795,
-1.2849100828,
0.0314530991,
1.2998839617,
-0.3364097774,
-0.5217383504,
-0.5147140622,
-0.0553553477,
0.14778018,
-0.8760119081,
0.3397268355,
0.6169844866,
0.0162705835,
-0.0382686332,
-0.5178674459,
0.0794037879,
0.2042843103,
-0.3516527414,
0.1761572957,
0.1669788808,
0.2976233363,
-0.0812200904,
0.487160027,
-0.0895592719,
0.1611807048,
-0.0620312691,
-0.6184345484,
-0.3310628831,
-0.1835629493,
-0.1124848425,
0.0782545209,
-0.0211174041,
-0.7075265646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08986v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08986v2 | Low-Resource Authorship Style Transfer: Can Non-Famous Authors Be Imitated? | 2022-12-18T01:57:30 | 2023-08-23T16:31:34 | Ajay Patel, Nicholas Andrews, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL | Authorship style transfer involves altering text to match the style of a
target author whilst preserving the original meaning. Existing unsupervised
approaches like STRAP have largely focused on style transfer to target authors
with many examples of their writing style in books, speeches, or other
published works. This high-resource training data requirement (often greater
than 100,000 words) makes these approaches primarily useful for style transfer
to published authors, politicians, or other well-known figures and authorship
styles, while style transfer to non-famous authors has not been well-studied.
We introduce the \textit{low-resource authorship style transfer} task, a more
challenging class of authorship style transfer where only a limited amount of
text in the target author's style may exist. In our experiments, we
specifically choose source and target authors from Reddit and style transfer
their Reddit posts, limiting ourselves to just 16 posts (on average ~500 words)
of the target author's style. Style transfer accuracy is typically measured by
how often a classifier or human judge will classify an output as written by the
target author. Recent authorship representations models excel at authorship
identification even with just a few writing samples, making automatic
evaluation of this task possible for the first time through evaluation metrics
we propose. Our results establish an in-context learning technique we develop
as the strongest baseline, though we find current approaches do not yet achieve
mastery of this challenging task. We release our data and implementations to
encourage further investigation. | [
0.013332963,
-0.4978272915,
0.5239133835,
0.242830351,
-0.2348413318,
0.1492779553,
-0.3642168641,
-0.7404123545,
0.6100775003,
0.7412754893,
-0.522749424,
0.1493103653,
-0.8931871057,
0.4046405554,
-0.5077086687,
1.0013004541,
-0.2182982117,
-0.4717331231,
-0.2711181045,
-0.2319410592,
-0.3688898981,
-0.2497517467,
-0.4035529792,
-0.1712868214,
0.5282383561,
0.6862627268,
0.1710281074,
0.4461542964,
0.5701389909,
0.2350717187,
0.2563811243,
0.1850225329,
-0.8506184816,
-0.1891222149,
-0.4566604793,
-0.2719387412,
-0.3822380602,
0.5115472674,
0.5759984255,
0.5399885178,
0.2807635069,
0.6776023507,
0.1439384818,
0.5909891725,
-0.9826567173,
-0.1223220453,
-0.5697413683,
-0.2005703449,
-0.2673637867,
-0.4141867161,
-0.8153800964,
-0.6651762128,
-0.0500513539,
-0.6281725764,
0.0382597968,
0.2533091605,
0.3809086382,
-0.0652433038,
-0.3900803924,
-0.4388633966,
-0.9381885529,
0.9491618872,
-0.2559827268,
-0.1570061147,
0.5102799535,
0.1037514582,
0.2405457199,
-0.7868698835,
-0.6540099978,
-0.1813184917,
-0.5051558018,
-0.0739604905,
-0.3155453503,
-0.3207858205,
0.4010335207,
0.1179145202,
-0.3140559196,
-0.0744244978,
-0.5667744875,
0.0913473666,
0.7559015751,
-0.170368135,
0.24131383,
-0.3608448803,
-0.4532570839,
-0.2549932301,
-0.5286898017,
0.0358115248,
0.3078621924,
0.4880047441,
-0.1654513925,
0.3809687197,
-0.114337936,
0.6172561646,
0.1320424825,
-0.2644233704,
-0.0551134571,
-0.4351067543,
0.0680672452,
0.198547855,
0.636744976,
0.3241094053,
0.4433719814,
-0.1383298188,
-0.146155417,
-0.4494404197,
0.3706733584,
-0.6035955548,
-0.2768125534,
-0.4040507972,
-0.4988577664,
-0.2237748206,
0.1493749171,
-0.9959284663,
-0.8418495655,
-0.3883707523,
0.8461347222,
-0.2338376492,
-0.2414547354,
-0.3820451498,
-0.1472460777,
0.1589212418,
0.4625522196,
-0.8170195222,
0.0862844959,
0.3469844162,
0.8734591007,
-0.2860152125,
-0.4470309317,
-0.8141535521,
0.132885173,
-0.3473128676,
0.6818450689,
-0.5170680285,
-0.139222458,
-0.1003446057,
0.1283300519,
-0.3335063756,
-0.1370655149,
0.1030093729,
-0.3598459363,
0.0721581951,
-0.4427986145,
-0.4612259269,
0.2134970576,
-0.2664570808,
-0.6358219981,
0.554674983,
0.5061768293,
-0.3224494457,
0.4065330029,
-0.6018418074,
-0.5855098367,
0.0283508487,
0.3631721139,
-0.2805678248,
0.1365062147,
-0.1217851341,
0.4566306472,
-0.172002241,
-0.5296071172,
-0.3844166994,
-0.7759613395,
0.3616777062,
0.0531411543,
0.7938575149,
0.2676595151,
-0.2772902846,
-0.180045113,
-0.615110755,
0.1339484006,
-0.0353085548,
-0.1847613603,
-0.5025810003,
-0.7611221671,
0.4400809109,
-0.1240896806,
0.2207428962,
-0.557215631,
0.5545120239,
0.1836753786,
0.5186681747,
1.0010267496,
0.2204372138,
0.7655916214,
-0.9477974176,
0.7010902762,
-0.9468356371,
-0.0128506981,
0.1972337812,
-0.1890724003,
-0.3126991391,
-0.4879817963,
0.3101603985,
0.6689293981,
-0.6671158075,
0.0304243937,
-0.3222617507,
-0.7216581702,
-0.4896118045,
0.4513768256,
0.4013220072,
0.3241642416,
0.4749848843,
-0.1913668662,
-0.3315061927,
-0.6548212171,
-0.9085381627,
-0.2675569952,
0.0949198753,
0.1445014775,
0.5505030751,
0.3047650456,
0.6283673048,
-0.4109075069,
-0.7143535018,
-0.3384908438,
0.6998633742,
0.047865361,
0.7767711282,
0.9038056135,
-0.5947510004,
-0.8195396066,
-0.0789901987,
-0.5446974635,
-0.1348561645,
-0.7060237527,
-0.2742359936,
0.0167159978,
0.9535621405,
-0.2413746417,
0.2742851079,
0.4126245379,
-0.2319709361,
0.4777653813,
-0.1499366164,
0.5601181984,
-1.1414322853,
0.401927501,
-0.0272682309,
-0.111763604,
-0.3434097171,
-0.2215539068,
0.0320617072,
0.0924047306,
-0.3595766127,
0.8865921497,
-0.6969070435,
0.0887205452,
-0.2463571876,
-0.1402533352,
-0.2057849765,
0.6130239367,
-0.2858115137,
0.702568233,
0.1477081478,
-0.2384801656,
0.4166102707,
0.3908610642,
-0.8932668567,
1.2074458599,
-0.2630223036,
0.6318259239,
-0.0998802707,
0.057800632,
-1.118940711,
-0.3175666928,
0.2374824584,
-0.1976554245,
0.6011434793,
-0.6486713886,
-0.7996760011,
0.0031741404,
-0.1043308079,
0.3788456917,
0.8975632191,
-0.3868839443,
0.3686881959,
0.1113148779,
-0.4046013057,
-0.4071555436,
-0.5994688869,
0.2514919639,
-0.4657806456,
-0.0719843879,
0.524926722,
-0.0445890501,
-0.1035367176,
0.1937745959,
0.2166846842,
-0.3437589705,
0.1168610379,
-0.0248149168,
-0.0033933669,
0.0977057889,
-0.1153105944,
0.0744748861,
0.3443179727,
-0.200210616,
-0.0076527945,
-0.1551780552,
0.1267180741,
-0.3695656359,
-0.8930957317,
0.3751119077,
0.836163342,
0.009334215,
0.7594769001,
0.5241903067,
-0.2353876978,
-0.577724576,
-0.4033699036,
-0.4554216564,
-0.3830932975,
0.1048656628,
-0.0439039581,
-0.4817179739,
0.186280489,
-0.2036453933,
0.1070690826,
0.0822628662,
0.0999246091,
-0.485267669,
0.1849539429,
1.0062600374,
-0.1174216121,
0.9209763408,
-0.1695157439,
0.1378616095,
-0.6106618643,
0.2335652411,
-0.38968876,
-1.0021771193,
-0.6399206519,
-0.228028968,
0.4298174083,
0.0122925611,
0.123489745,
0.8758862615,
-0.4919392467,
0.5882229209,
0.8401295543,
0.1931613684,
0.2639788985,
-0.0043485784,
0.5154664516,
-0.0445449874,
-0.375175029,
-0.5118781924,
1.0771433115,
-0.4106775224,
1.0078940392,
0.2252178341,
0.666647315,
0.9149084687,
0.5963177681,
-0.6967535615,
0.5252867937,
-0.2877370715,
-0.3268922865,
-0.4860184491,
-0.273039341,
-0.5539624691,
-0.1002799794,
-0.5153896809,
-0.7684003711,
0.4300945997,
0.3859685957,
-0.2713943124,
0.5412417054,
-0.7360915542,
0.5704467893,
0.1862148941,
-0.6077747345,
-0.051857207,
-0.6175785661,
0.1583307981,
-0.3958998322,
0.2152981758,
0.1803522706,
0.4237496555,
0.9137617946,
-0.0549625941,
1.033723712,
-0.0536361448,
0.2365283966,
0.2865492105,
0.4670135379,
0.732696712,
-0.4020023942,
-0.2416444272,
-0.1101104766,
0.1026782542,
-0.5098175406,
-0.6179268956,
0.6130051613,
-0.492621243,
-0.2868712842,
-0.3440540433,
-0.233336404,
-0.1032757834,
0.3150736392,
0.4859270453,
0.231148392,
-0.2119811028,
0.4685154855,
0.1614501774,
0.2286895812,
0.4347644746,
0.1211616844,
0.639842689,
-0.3847048879,
0.7573161721,
0.3997980654,
0.2713279128,
0.4739746153,
0.0673281327,
0.0324615315,
-0.35331586,
-0.5991749763,
0.4557715654,
-0.5699540973,
0.0461694635,
-0.3879820704,
-0.0462400429,
-0.4578514099,
-0.9128383994,
-0.3776184022,
-0.5754209757,
-0.3838202655,
0.2626368403,
0.5345928073,
0.74491781,
-0.2410674542,
0.4899820089,
-0.4987174869,
0.0878540426,
0.5221943259,
0.1318764538,
-0.0629326478,
-0.8401704431,
-0.1661938429,
-0.2958087921,
-0.2179825753,
-0.8681272268,
0.162610814,
0.2582588792,
0.4162746966,
0.2209421843,
0.661011219,
0.582079649,
-0.1574236006,
0.4717647433,
-0.0094829351,
-0.9500284791,
0.4610231817,
-0.1621733457,
-0.0647816882,
1.0045461655,
0.1228716448,
-0.666472435,
-0.3040033579,
-0.4312438369,
-0.438557744,
0.8813789487,
0.2646937668,
0.3249268532,
0.3942455947,
0.6756407022,
0.2263329327,
0.2259808779,
-0.7548471689,
0.1791441143,
0.0305025559,
0.0189784579,
-0.1513369083,
-0.2250879705,
-0.2051684111,
0.0019526754,
0.6440531611,
-0.4181554019,
0.3519719541,
0.3542779684,
-0.4118117988,
-0.2357247025,
0.2768466175,
0.6599913836,
0.9018864632,
-0.1710343808,
0.2354650646,
0.0911262184,
-0.2923814654,
0.1712161899,
-0.0581686459,
-0.0343339145,
-0.2369662374,
0.9339894056,
0.4333540797,
0.1796253026,
-0.1947773099,
0.7310298085,
0.219670862,
-0.2955189347,
-0.3751200736,
0.0699004158,
-0.1899616569,
0.1975821257,
0.1282949597,
0.3033896685,
-0.2441590875,
-0.631275177,
0.144137606,
0.336855948,
-0.4740943909,
-0.6811224818,
0.7104158998,
0.1693561375,
-0.2711904943,
0.5455085039,
-0.30848068,
-0.0194585435,
0.4922529459,
0.4307303429,
0.7877928019,
-0.0529819056,
0.2679619193,
0.4674717486,
0.4112600088,
-0.2483708709,
0.0601726584,
-0.3830557168,
-0.308224231,
-0.3109888136,
-0.5830982924,
-0.753377378,
0.0995047167,
-0.695192337,
0.519639194,
-0.5587126017,
0.0094693294,
0.0340967439,
-0.2239212692,
-0.4895656407,
-0.3815657198,
-0.2079312056,
0.3721497655,
-1.223300457,
0.5075130463,
0.8950116634,
-0.1378304809,
-0.2357357442,
0.2073005736,
0.1901796907,
-0.7670250535,
0.5560829043,
-0.1037660167,
-0.3881958425,
0.1614132077,
-0.7297039628,
-0.4732000828,
1.0249321461,
0.5255247355,
-0.0364606641,
-0.0038900266,
-0.177533716,
0.416279614,
-0.2991651297,
-0.2042535245,
-0.0604656599,
0.531930089,
0.2748198509,
-1.071041584,
0.2994928658,
0.0122735137,
-0.2842229307,
-0.040127527,
-0.9129376411,
0.9523819089,
-0.4303569496,
-0.3079865575,
0.4856685102,
0.4997949898,
-0.0059845578,
0.3170384765,
0.5208616257,
0.1298393011,
0.7348775268,
0.2936691642,
0.8636126518,
-0.253996402,
0.2870911956,
1.1093466282,
-0.1665770262,
0.7281634808,
0.5716633797,
0.0431479402,
0.6383947134,
0.1691952646,
-0.168440789,
0.6783990264,
0.1258317977,
-0.204989627,
-0.2357386053,
-0.2977747619,
-0.0765399709,
0.7309028506,
-0.3261949122,
-0.6314926744,
0.1542571336,
0.1241375878,
0.3029795587,
0.362431258,
-0.0434861071,
0.7637762427,
0.1912045926,
-0.6936049461,
0.5258765817,
-0.2875986993,
0.5311905146,
-0.5414456129,
-0.2856959701,
-0.0393329971,
0.2786404192,
-0.072922349,
-0.5862624049,
0.2192708403,
-0.0758869648,
-0.1374890953,
-1.1122945547,
0.6180183291,
-0.2887794375,
-0.4599407017,
0.0004085079,
0.6840620041,
0.2481238991,
-0.1151162535,
-0.115112029,
-0.4829409719,
-0.1492903978,
-0.2100441605,
0.4578243792,
0.513466835,
-0.0583498217,
0.2727677226,
0.5548679829,
0.2883135676,
-0.3555376828,
-0.404918164,
0.4087450206,
-0.5723014474,
-0.5610104799,
-0.7647824287,
-0.0295648295,
-0.0718195587,
-0.4624926448,
0.7078502178,
0.2344007194,
0.830349803,
-0.4130564034,
0.7308475375,
-0.3617920876,
0.433236897,
-0.5804420114,
1.1810184717,
-0.8046298623,
-0.2286545038,
-0.7413374186,
-0.7510515451,
-0.0796232447,
0.3720140755,
-0.0435754955,
0.0516017601,
0.74742347,
0.5794443488,
-0.1966643929,
-0.0317559913,
0.1895703822,
0.0220683236,
-0.0367786363,
0.5242490768,
0.6329284906,
-0.1241395772,
0.6053620577,
-0.5608180165,
-0.5697512627,
-0.5140755773,
-1.0976423025,
-0.791549623,
-0.9951466322,
-0.4999243021,
-0.2695070207,
-0.0689508319,
1.0160727501,
1.0316580534,
-0.3983128369,
-0.322099179,
0.3245068192,
0.2525497675,
-0.7934857011,
-0.2223914564,
0.3632847071,
0.2083081156,
-0.9587838054,
0.3305915594,
-0.0522076078,
0.0630734265,
0.1966461241,
0.5607267022,
-0.0664296225,
0.0611796789,
0.6404548883,
0.4527588785,
-0.3159161806,
-0.498599112,
-0.0889792368,
-0.061685618,
-0.1265965998,
0.9942191839,
-0.5160306692,
0.431660682,
0.5628207326,
0.5881924033,
0.2702306807,
0.1857887357,
0.0558079556,
-0.7775071859,
-0.2280886769,
0.1994566768,
0.1186314151,
0.2255924791,
-0.6149708033,
0.32695207,
0.6739802957,
-0.4885738194,
-0.8267167211,
0.2294266224,
-1.1545419693,
-0.3212659061,
1.1134104729,
-0.0064340658,
-0.1272323132,
0.2012376487,
-0.0565678664,
0.0020719536,
-0.3726950586,
0.9624999166,
0.8793589473,
-0.6008048654,
-0.1663298905,
-0.5421404243,
0.6201130152,
0.2375671417,
-0.712082088,
0.3502982855,
0.2569268048,
0.3659912944,
0.2157367468,
0.9557163715,
0.0685991794,
0.2414504737,
-0.0938815549,
-0.0612230152,
-0.0726251751,
-0.3156448007,
0.0862957537,
0.3851576149,
-0.0504786186,
-0.0788683817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08979v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08979v1 | Language model acceptability judgements are not always robust to context | 2022-12-18T00:11:06 | 2022-12-18T00:11:06 | Koustuv Sinha, Jon Gauthier, Aaron Mueller, Kanishka Misra, Keren Fuentes, Roger Levy, Adina Williams | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Targeted syntactic evaluations of language models ask whether models show
stable preferences for syntactically acceptable content over minimal-pair
unacceptable inputs. Most targeted syntactic evaluation datasets ask models to
make these judgements with just a single context-free sentence as input. This
does not match language models' training regime, in which input sentences are
always highly contextualized by the surrounding corpus. This mismatch raises an
important question: how robust are models' syntactic judgements in different
contexts? In this paper, we investigate the stability of language models'
performance on targeted syntactic evaluations as we vary properties of the
input context: the length of the context, the types of syntactic phenomena it
contains, and whether or not there are violations of grammaticality. We find
that model judgements are generally robust when placed in randomly sampled
linguistic contexts. However, they are substantially unstable for contexts
containing syntactic structures matching those in the critical test content.
Among all tested models (GPT-2 and five variants of OPT), we significantly
improve models' judgements by providing contexts with matching syntactic
structures, and conversely significantly worsen them using unacceptable
contexts with matching but violated syntactic structures. This effect is
amplified by the length of the context, except for unrelated inputs. We show
that these changes in model performance are not explainable by simple features
matching the context and the test inputs, such as lexical overlap and
dependency overlap. This sensitivity to highly specific syntactic features of
the context can only be explained by the models' implicit in-context learning
abilities. | [
-0.1847533286,
-0.8476477265,
0.7194746733,
0.134225443,
-0.0937715471,
-0.3382660747,
-0.5039841533,
-0.6806464791,
-0.4375177026,
0.1884500086,
-0.1525738239,
-0.1475806087,
-0.7099073529,
0.1579710841,
-0.5498948693,
1.0275071859,
-0.1367144883,
0.1382598281,
-0.3186285496,
-0.6054369807,
-0.5186601281,
-0.5825724006,
-0.3179081976,
-0.1309485584,
0.1301612109,
-0.0130425114,
0.8792498708,
0.3554511666,
0.3174069524,
0.3285856843,
-0.3230511248,
-0.1889687777,
-0.3680947125,
0.3719758689,
-0.3123265207,
-0.4338065088,
-0.2954321206,
-0.0482226573,
0.7258833647,
0.7845041156,
-0.110043712,
-0.0434659906,
0.3328041732,
0.260463655,
-0.694209516,
0.0682301074,
-0.9720035791,
-0.3466227055,
-0.0545271374,
0.1920156181,
-0.6508507133,
0.0194204971,
0.4865096211,
-0.2581488192,
0.1452008784,
-0.1677848995,
1.0991014242,
0.3297128081,
-0.3002563715,
-0.1763593704,
-0.7211983204,
0.5080550313,
-0.6767247915,
0.4496082664,
0.4593606591,
0.4541924894,
-0.0160375945,
-0.2572631538,
-0.335327208,
-0.3839132786,
-0.2584033608,
-0.0914952531,
-0.2809779048,
0.1275186241,
0.3760959506,
-0.0226834044,
-0.5311009884,
0.2396840453,
-0.089875713,
-0.2286665887,
0.1457961947,
0.0965441838,
0.3181196749,
-0.2917401195,
-0.3469125628,
-0.0329756029,
-0.5548599958,
0.4667729437,
0.244322136,
0.6528062224,
-0.0640237406,
0.658855319,
-0.0952490047,
0.9291221499,
0.1246287152,
0.0251769647,
-0.1108971238,
-0.4901695251,
-0.2501672804,
-0.2272566557,
0.5124319196,
0.3827970028,
0.3026153743,
-0.0464584157,
-0.4017725587,
0.3920225203,
0.3168174028,
-0.4774300456,
0.0814828575,
0.2330137044,
-0.1920506358,
-0.1695224494,
-0.0102511756,
-0.3261213303,
0.0889952406,
-0.0599831901,
0.4650206566,
-0.4651759863,
-0.0153660849,
0.067318134,
0.0467788354,
0.0917768776,
0.3462735415,
-0.9953172207,
0.4312070906,
0.398034662,
0.7143748999,
-0.1055144221,
-0.4675513208,
-0.3545978367,
-0.1515512317,
-0.2112461925,
0.625074923,
-0.7092872858,
-0.0193213988,
-0.0737079456,
0.1339612156,
-0.5226554871,
-0.5611165166,
0.3358682394,
-0.4890471995,
0.299865216,
-0.295383513,
-0.3108139336,
0.0024442289,
0.211217925,
-0.5466145873,
0.7506040931,
0.2741552889,
-0.7443780303,
0.8871645331,
-0.4106310308,
-0.403654933,
-0.258174628,
-0.0695792884,
-0.2517002821,
0.1975065917,
0.0489305891,
0.2142942995,
0.0623577088,
0.5100804567,
-0.5837972164,
-0.4143996239,
0.2010330558,
-0.442704469,
0.7459712029,
0.0285173431,
-0.3301984966,
0.3369334638,
-0.7465093136,
0.0828895792,
0.1144599542,
-0.5042734146,
-0.3899038434,
0.1363575608,
0.1739361882,
0.4349678457,
-0.052056089,
-0.2221319526,
0.0051321615,
-0.5494229794,
0.5728834867,
0.76301229,
-0.3051241636,
0.533536315,
-0.2424646765,
0.5055899024,
0.0720133036,
-0.0392620862,
-0.0034987582,
-0.3024795651,
-0.6202331185,
0.0625896081,
0.3751175106,
0.4229180813,
-0.4216423333,
0.14145419,
-0.321475178,
-0.1985910237,
-0.1460258365,
0.0401466638,
0.4929708838,
0.526665628,
0.1014320254,
-0.286860764,
-0.4136896133,
-1.0703727007,
-0.6014437675,
-0.4026302993,
0.2914536595,
0.3904188871,
0.5307263136,
0.0136374738,
0.9370120764,
-0.025683159,
0.2245374471,
-0.4675557613,
-0.2791618109,
0.0804420635,
0.3814184964,
0.874396503,
-0.6980814338,
-0.330172956,
-0.1773302555,
-0.4552219808,
0.0368931964,
0.1413070858,
0.0539974608,
0.3850093484,
-0.0165465344,
-0.7199059129,
0.3479278982,
0.6255754232,
-0.5849650502,
0.6137503386,
0.0295657665,
-0.1457881927,
-0.8045313954,
0.1108955443,
-0.0055437298,
-0.4652431011,
-0.5190380812,
0.1661445796,
0.1328162402,
0.0427588373,
-0.4845798016,
0.6482294202,
-0.0610985868,
-0.1427828372,
-0.1317395717,
0.0064872303,
0.0878124759,
0.2706608772,
0.0716525391,
0.8091403842,
0.6235794425,
-0.6844321489,
-0.2324344516,
0.2307783365,
-0.4652201235,
0.3439228237,
-0.6942911744,
0.0589159504,
0.0059706713,
0.215889141,
-0.9033847451,
-0.4347443283,
0.1177092493,
-0.3831391931,
0.3386180401,
-0.2358533889,
-0.2081892043,
0.0979046449,
0.1195412502,
0.5678056479,
0.309379369,
-0.4663237035,
0.3067083955,
0.2132032216,
0.0162460562,
-0.7115892768,
-0.6319825649,
-0.2201011926,
-0.2695257068,
-0.7199613452,
0.0786010846,
-0.0744926855,
-0.3834799826,
0.0494196005,
-0.3742675185,
-0.1782302409,
0.3155190349,
0.3231573999,
0.1812010705,
-0.2553012669,
-0.0001351791,
-0.1238831058,
0.1539034545,
0.0179666989,
-0.2160997689,
0.4394050539,
-0.1972023398,
-0.1598405242,
-0.0321733281,
0.135921061,
0.7970809937,
0.0220186077,
0.8438488245,
0.1807331592,
-0.539624989,
-0.358743608,
-0.2710138261,
-0.1092102602,
-0.389431566,
0.4672957659,
-0.6990183592,
-1.0159726143,
0.6537091136,
0.4592880309,
-0.0920843184,
0.5649295449,
0.5348614454,
0.1163345948,
1.0852464437,
0.6329716444,
0.0705302656,
0.3951416612,
0.1197009012,
0.0115739321,
-0.7157922983,
0.1888037473,
-0.5528828502,
-0.0058401297,
-0.4461029768,
0.1126527339,
0.1608470082,
0.0391010642,
-0.1028232425,
0.5624879599,
-0.2181175947,
0.4718480408,
0.1435317695,
0.0735640824,
0.0309371948,
-0.1148394272,
-0.5276050568,
-0.0978865176,
-0.8710237741,
-0.6225157976,
0.9222844243,
0.4053428769,
0.5183361173,
0.230824858,
0.0842533484,
-0.0559455343,
0.0967172384,
-0.5729842782,
0.3264225125,
-0.1374334097,
-0.7131991982,
-0.2000256479,
-0.4349901676,
-0.7779742479,
0.2823444605,
-0.1102806255,
-0.9709421992,
0.2497459948,
0.1509675086,
-0.4516632259,
0.0789141506,
-0.7739569545,
1.1499404907,
-0.2192680538,
-0.5599753261,
0.1946240962,
-0.570704937,
0.278293401,
-0.0929824933,
0.2140310705,
-0.1099483296,
0.2541009784,
0.4838457704,
-0.3343856037,
0.6801178455,
-0.156095922,
-0.0320777707,
0.1203132123,
0.5553206205,
0.3746109605,
-0.0143062826,
-0.1688178927,
0.0820454955,
0.1063789651,
-0.3169854879,
-0.7216767073,
0.4855825603,
-0.6273198128,
-0.5719587803,
-0.262907654,
-0.4956558049,
-0.3654692769,
0.3429645598,
0.5004047155,
0.6106383801,
-0.1609130055,
0.0023031067,
0.1606072187,
-0.0638227016,
0.3474810123,
0.4017110169,
-0.1810741425,
-0.0423656665,
0.5399855971,
0.1732106209,
0.8446881175,
0.0498996228,
0.0402722433,
-0.3091806769,
-0.6523960233,
-0.4150798023,
-0.1411349326,
-0.9476085901,
0.089183867,
-0.4527539313,
-0.1438838542,
-0.25520432,
-0.0427880958,
-0.3445210159,
-0.4779256284,
0.1296025813,
-0.1183755249,
-0.1468490362,
0.772002697,
0.1552362591,
0.0664570704,
-0.4652204812,
-0.0533043556,
0.1116678715,
0.4856329858,
-0.2436929941,
-0.7958465219,
-0.1703203171,
-0.112422958,
0.0759800151,
-0.8260141611,
0.0471247472,
0.3008262515,
0.4252800941,
0.3566612899,
-0.1063823402,
0.4650648534,
-0.3716824055,
0.7253338695,
-0.2771464586,
-1.0608955622,
0.6786003709,
-0.6126637459,
0.535528779,
0.7527012825,
0.1320832372,
-0.1244205683,
-0.5793427825,
-0.4552770257,
-0.7880157232,
0.9145783186,
0.221302703,
0.2129315436,
-0.0709967911,
0.5099852085,
0.2193403691,
0.0925778896,
-1.1120764017,
0.1214299574,
-0.1288259327,
0.0148976771,
-0.0684257075,
-0.338868171,
-0.0983005986,
-0.1700707525,
0.3688002825,
-0.1731857359,
0.039100565,
0.0477979556,
-0.3683799207,
-0.1727946401,
0.3033262789,
0.6676579714,
0.8766146302,
-0.4621909857,
0.1308168918,
0.1261803508,
-0.3553239405,
0.1964738369,
-0.0999158323,
-0.4544711113,
0.0029947518,
0.3894193172,
0.9665739536,
0.6900640726,
-0.6889101267,
0.6152678132,
-0.2619000971,
0.0956230536,
-0.1550960094,
0.2586029172,
-0.3089419007,
0.014837875,
-0.1483103484,
0.6180328727,
0.0642885044,
-0.5956002474,
0.22481139,
0.6292552948,
-0.3703286052,
-0.4660096169,
0.8142110705,
-0.1462759227,
-0.0157692954,
0.4738022685,
-0.1657552123,
-0.7471045852,
0.5964593887,
0.7743951678,
0.8070966601,
-0.0270260647,
0.0138232252,
0.4430914819,
0.3569665849,
-0.1744349599,
-0.0922613814,
-0.0626352802,
-1.0555983782,
-0.1741399616,
-0.7115697265,
-0.3641247451,
-0.0378836058,
-0.746301055,
0.3298165202,
-0.6066527963,
-0.4283331931,
-0.1542822868,
-0.4818018973,
-0.6981192827,
0.3110026717,
-0.1174469665,
0.6565840244,
-0.9461408854,
0.6801345348,
0.7591019869,
-0.2079268545,
-0.859469533,
0.1087301001,
-0.0296008121,
-0.6523326635,
0.454226464,
0.3748385012,
-0.0075363158,
-0.3969427347,
-0.3492289186,
-0.9636895061,
0.6694929004,
0.7296766639,
-0.4036575854,
-0.1410708129,
-0.0860730261,
0.5718616247,
-0.4718382061,
0.3178827167,
0.5229195952,
0.3168614507,
-0.1518979669,
-1.3523492813,
0.2580195367,
-0.3497202694,
-0.0815854222,
0.0516960137,
-0.591306746,
0.8625714183,
-0.3144945204,
-0.3672934175,
0.1597960889,
0.0754685625,
0.2887780964,
0.129671976,
0.6350167394,
0.6783778667,
0.3420032561,
-0.3139709532,
1.3338625431,
-0.3615153432,
0.487934947,
1.1672320366,
-0.3243370056,
0.9826157093,
0.1379555166,
-0.2597703636,
0.4174742997,
0.6875221133,
0.05511944,
0.4419296384,
-0.1748610884,
0.1651315093,
-0.3447785079,
-0.0580397397,
-0.1300860494,
0.8566224575,
0.2170610875,
-0.3502687812,
-0.3343209326,
-0.0964355916,
-0.0792779475,
0.0315398052,
0.1247078106,
0.4656948149,
-0.0179428291,
-0.79706043,
0.6757987142,
-0.0230574347,
0.4048623145,
-0.6636494994,
0.2396230549,
0.0615094379,
0.0753322393,
-0.222956121,
-0.4741860032,
0.497257024,
-0.0374487303,
-0.3716092706,
0.0741848499,
0.6819702983,
-0.1221572086,
-0.3262152672,
0.5933178067,
0.619370997,
0.0111569799,
0.0651354045,
-0.6012788415,
0.2756032944,
-0.2247841507,
-0.2438014597,
0.5218476057,
0.1560802609,
0.0086789411,
0.419311434,
0.3644426763,
0.1634557992,
-0.0547694489,
0.09789785,
0.6240449548,
-0.4719930589,
-0.3019191921,
-0.9120261669,
0.6221196651,
0.3311035037,
-0.5731322765,
0.7248445153,
0.2830515504,
1.0522235632,
0.2143055052,
0.6826220751,
-0.0594160371,
0.0642963424,
-0.6579043269,
0.7328606248,
-0.5862114429,
0.4309561849,
-0.4118705094,
-1.1528584957,
-0.1316030771,
0.5698328018,
-0.4940750003,
0.5532819033,
0.7004808187,
0.4807091653,
-0.1501196921,
-0.1421582401,
0.3975340426,
0.4391992986,
0.1223888472,
0.6887277365,
0.7626931667,
-0.2499042004,
0.1899347454,
-0.1630943716,
-0.0654068887,
-0.0845329016,
-0.6952320933,
-0.7678927779,
-0.6029552817,
-0.0728240982,
-0.5810588598,
0.2108767778,
0.7422235012,
0.8140473962,
-0.8478215933,
0.0379475392,
-0.2773538232,
0.0695642307,
-0.0704489052,
-0.3012975454,
0.3645887971,
-0.3628979027,
-0.6777193546,
0.5322784185,
0.3134191334,
0.0541371033,
-0.1403481066,
0.0427558534,
-0.0340289064,
-0.073568292,
0.3893893659,
0.2108012289,
-0.9600419402,
-0.6050587296,
0.0052522528,
-0.1586767882,
0.08730077,
0.4943529963,
-0.7614566684,
0.5892167687,
0.2396044433,
0.4828999937,
-0.0699682012,
0.0658178627,
0.6989150643,
-0.5178783536,
0.1807188392,
0.0973516852,
0.6078596711,
0.2541345358,
-0.3928221762,
0.3475527167,
0.1835253388,
-0.4953121841,
-0.9487163424,
0.2552357912,
-0.890865922,
-0.2676377296,
1.1139019728,
-0.2627454996,
-0.076013267,
0.0411141664,
0.1399699748,
0.0408210121,
-0.2440108359,
0.6552088857,
1.1225948334,
-0.1453515738,
0.0555363894,
-0.6880095005,
0.4925498068,
0.8810916543,
-0.2994556129,
0.0355319083,
0.4979421198,
0.605502069,
0.0805239454,
0.4222172797,
-0.0993983597,
0.5426915288,
0.1026858091,
-0.5848118663,
0.1017466635,
-0.5374898314,
-0.7270082235,
0.2828463614,
0.5527809858,
0.2613832057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08950v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08950v1 | Beyond the C: Retargetable Decompilation using Neural Machine Translation | 2022-12-17T20:45:59 | 2022-12-17T20:45:59 | Iman Hosseini, Brendan Dolan-Gavitt | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.PL | The problem of reversing the compilation process, decompilation, is an
important tool in reverse engineering of computer software. Recently,
researchers have proposed using techniques from neural machine translation to
automate the process in decompilation. Although such techniques hold the
promise of targeting a wider range of source and assembly languages, to date
they have primarily targeted C code. In this paper we argue that existing
neural decompilers have achieved higher accuracy at the cost of requiring
language-specific domain knowledge such as tokenizers and parsers to build an
abstract syntax tree (AST) for the source language, which increases the
overhead of supporting new languages. We explore a different tradeoff that, to
the extent possible, treats the assembly and source languages as plain text,
and show that this allows us to build a decompiler that is easily retargetable
to new languages. We evaluate our prototype decompiler, Beyond The C (BTC), on
Go, Fortran, OCaml, and C, and examine the impact of parameters such as
tokenization and training data selection on the quality of decompilation,
finding that it achieves comparable decompilation results to prior work in
neural decompilation with significantly less domain knowledge. We will release
our training data, trained decompilation models, and code to help encourage
future research into language-agnostic decompilation. | [
-0.1581531465,
-0.3710750639,
0.3991915286,
-0.0318269394,
-0.246157214,
0.4380580783,
-0.3556854725,
-0.4119258225,
0.2232967615,
0.3229291439,
-0.0980844945,
-0.5190744996,
-0.5442796946,
-0.1231131479,
-0.6664142013,
0.8114449382,
-0.1432605833,
-0.1974571496,
-0.0626864657,
0.1481991112,
-0.2610683143,
-0.8481882215,
-0.584115684,
-0.2145929933,
0.4841733277,
0.0309007242,
0.7315592766,
1.0422888994,
0.2284546942,
0.3007199764,
-0.0950982943,
-0.3800480068,
-0.337498039,
0.0568093844,
-0.0899534225,
-0.4217299521,
-0.2511010766,
-0.2660135329,
0.6200823784,
0.6240323782,
0.0840817168,
0.1691800058,
-0.0939252004,
0.8692094684,
-0.6766273379,
0.2320782244,
-0.5987235308,
0.1420989782,
0.1307056248,
-0.1451362669,
-0.4906668067,
-0.4979969859,
-0.383392036,
-0.1965088397,
0.3765896559,
-0.2864805162,
0.7497072816,
0.5789836049,
-0.2027351111,
-0.0011976906,
-0.6173121333,
0.7378747463,
-0.7201533914,
0.743660748,
0.151762262,
0.2916463614,
0.0016223616,
-0.8543571234,
-0.2865453959,
-0.399516046,
-0.0542292856,
-0.1854484528,
-0.3102170527,
0.0634198859,
0.0555496924,
0.5813310742,
-0.4357635975,
0.0375752822,
-0.5683200359,
-0.2807931602,
0.38676548,
-0.0669389963,
0.6355707645,
-0.0716866031,
-0.1744973212,
-0.139095515,
-0.9202349782,
-0.212890476,
0.3625885248,
0.0965471491,
0.2967301309,
0.513681531,
-0.0913587436,
0.5577335954,
-0.2355727851,
0.3862504959,
0.0804344788,
-0.3628669083,
-0.3453967869,
0.168067351,
0.4187061489,
-0.0059007411,
0.0597366579,
-0.5316419601,
-0.2960393131,
0.1593762934,
0.6766830087,
-0.8417465091,
-0.6840279102,
0.149394542,
-0.7484353185,
-0.1574768722,
-0.229732886,
-0.1976037323,
0.1860840619,
-0.3685138524,
0.0946054012,
-0.4536592066,
-0.4026200175,
-0.0713582709,
-0.2585353851,
0.4436974525,
0.0430033244,
-0.7942460775,
0.1690623462,
0.7195536494,
0.6542156935,
-0.0283153187,
-0.2425066233,
-0.3328270316,
-0.0853899419,
-0.6407094002,
0.6563754082,
-0.4207389057,
-0.3271362185,
-0.3109821677,
-0.1187127829,
0.0033218681,
-0.6176281571,
0.1903584898,
-0.7883638144,
-0.1053951308,
-0.2028280199,
-0.1890664995,
-0.4251242578,
0.4229573607,
-0.5447942019,
0.3641382158,
0.07596118,
-0.4439629316,
0.2087084502,
-0.4858923256,
-0.5636317134,
-0.2921930254,
-0.3258314431,
-0.1610866785,
0.3205714524,
0.1408747733,
0.1973812878,
-0.3507918417,
0.383731693,
0.0880625471,
-0.5060816407,
0.0042503262,
-0.5712499022,
0.8096426129,
0.4167739749,
-0.4197612405,
0.1590464413,
-0.6661638618,
0.2131980807,
-0.0399163924,
-0.9015942812,
-0.1463847458,
0.0574814938,
-0.1338286549,
0.2023546249,
0.2718221843,
-0.4627094865,
0.0452513769,
-0.7101433277,
0.572853446,
0.6202450395,
-0.1461444944,
0.3673197627,
0.1603028625,
0.6496316791,
-0.2217491567,
-0.2117052823,
-0.2447605878,
-0.2065344006,
-0.6809318066,
-0.1792034507,
0.3588176072,
0.5359145999,
-0.7613829374,
0.300783366,
-0.2867997885,
-0.1877055615,
-0.5407994986,
0.0655915365,
0.9806449413,
0.4266643822,
0.5257763267,
-0.0099383034,
-0.5664044023,
-1.0389606953,
-0.421995312,
-0.2010533214,
-0.2285824716,
-0.1964479834,
0.2138069123,
-0.2250973582,
0.6237146854,
-0.6043785214,
0.2077075243,
-0.1614770591,
-0.0359811746,
0.0138348332,
0.7185612321,
0.2130785137,
-0.7891819477,
-0.159036234,
0.2931805849,
-0.6263418198,
0.2035757452,
-0.1048138961,
0.0467045642,
0.3035317063,
0.9979191422,
-0.4091062248,
0.3894806802,
0.4046270549,
-0.2116789222,
0.5516417027,
-0.2825159132,
0.2115502059,
-1.1166443825,
0.5900461078,
-0.5226572752,
-0.0523722097,
-0.4605050683,
0.5281436443,
0.1338943988,
-0.3698307574,
-0.5856579542,
0.1844739765,
-0.6873241663,
-0.4420320094,
-0.4005702436,
-0.2217967957,
0.0236356985,
0.468090564,
0.3132769167,
0.6597419977,
0.270434469,
-0.4269842207,
0.1101612076,
0.1610594094,
-0.0274285413,
-0.2409206182,
-0.7902055383,
0.2717263997,
-0.1608758122,
0.0850450099,
-0.9147849679,
0.1470811218,
0.3803221285,
-0.6992396116,
0.5444934368,
-0.4343956709,
-0.3271814585,
0.0413765572,
-0.2619239688,
0.5660387874,
0.4212223589,
-0.6053162813,
0.4416029453,
0.1374486089,
-0.102970846,
-0.8816224337,
-1.1788330078,
0.4323096871,
0.0021645247,
-0.428956002,
0.4771607816,
-0.0374308974,
-0.2159472704,
0.1648160517,
-0.434995532,
-0.2734054029,
0.0576571338,
0.1911710501,
0.1569216996,
-0.5439419746,
-0.0358622596,
0.3600998819,
-0.5072422028,
0.3269994259,
-0.4362258613,
0.4188583195,
-0.0445328839,
-0.3786967397,
-0.1002297103,
0.4334662557,
0.3972001076,
-0.3205748796,
0.6345067024,
0.3533583879,
-0.4582587481,
0.0700309575,
-0.2765181661,
-0.033964105,
-0.4449421465,
0.4444229305,
-0.4759162068,
-0.6616318822,
0.4807291031,
0.008902071,
0.2681103349,
0.1746903062,
0.427316457,
0.4847602248,
0.857940793,
0.7357395887,
-0.1212725341,
0.3907980323,
-0.4444878101,
0.3752053082,
-0.6628147364,
-0.0755517036,
-0.7032340169,
-0.5176289082,
-0.2904443741,
-0.4723793566,
-0.1241265759,
0.1300680339,
-0.2277469635,
0.8584067225,
-0.7086954117,
0.7917312384,
0.461920917,
-0.0466540456,
0.3013258576,
-0.2051270008,
0.0767904297,
0.2031659335,
-0.6034528613,
-0.3454634249,
0.784692347,
0.3806850314,
0.3301145136,
-0.0562909544,
0.9678909183,
0.0862228051,
0.4265432358,
-0.8328409195,
0.3949052095,
-0.2897085547,
-0.5219765306,
-0.1394368708,
-0.4334027469,
-0.8232918382,
0.2186425775,
0.3463184536,
-0.4876026213,
0.5217139125,
0.2493666559,
-0.3148332834,
0.1519093513,
-0.8725283742,
1.081389904,
-0.0028658218,
0.186314106,
-0.2778868377,
-0.7265704274,
0.4806036055,
0.093128778,
-0.0528652184,
0.27151829,
-0.3081985116,
0.5838561654,
-0.3868737817,
0.7254725695,
-0.1409934759,
-0.2518327832,
0.3629817963,
0.5095662475,
0.2564701736,
-0.0675877333,
-0.0100750308,
0.3269463778,
-0.1134008244,
-0.4419959188,
-0.6237766743,
0.8811036944,
-0.6054736376,
-0.5373868942,
-0.0012515853,
-0.2659462392,
0.1616063714,
0.3546367586,
0.2812989652,
0.2923189998,
-0.1229116246,
0.0108861001,
0.358037442,
-0.509490788,
0.5504480004,
0.1828808933,
-0.1239740476,
-0.5790454745,
1.2561633587,
-0.0168947708,
0.3107562959,
0.6112205982,
0.0177715905,
-0.2901944518,
-0.9058388472,
-0.4142788053,
-0.124372147,
-0.8758203983,
-0.440903157,
-0.6630004644,
-0.2393307388,
-0.3195324838,
-0.5417612195,
-0.5969647765,
-0.61805439,
-0.3288585246,
-0.327783078,
-0.1687989831,
0.3960036337,
-0.048166886,
-0.0076279878,
-0.8883814812,
0.5385336876,
0.0484054983,
0.0368904881,
-0.0666861311,
-0.4863790274,
-0.208663553,
0.0301121362,
-0.051963985,
-0.72613132,
0.5217606425,
-0.0147680398,
0.4893541336,
0.1678340435,
-0.0135945342,
0.6771581769,
-0.2805037498,
0.5932167768,
0.1483976245,
-0.988771379,
0.3676845133,
-0.1013900116,
0.3365744948,
0.547231853,
0.2736366093,
-0.3380616009,
-0.3608455658,
-0.4859333336,
-1.1462112665,
0.487834841,
0.0716141835,
0.1807401776,
-0.2231360078,
0.3249816597,
0.0857496783,
0.3152888417,
-0.6269003153,
-0.0176081825,
-0.4718357623,
0.0092918407,
-0.1156016663,
-0.0382611081,
0.3326377869,
-0.136044547,
0.3201809525,
-0.0999325365,
0.3486045897,
0.1144589931,
-0.2951703966,
0.0458119772,
0.2491321266,
0.3127113879,
0.5129118562,
-0.0316262729,
0.3007988036,
-0.1475199759,
-0.387886554,
0.0693077669,
0.0500698239,
-0.2333855629,
-0.162609905,
0.2480796725,
0.2878299356,
0.2460120022,
-0.642835021,
0.1109505072,
0.1484163105,
-0.139216572,
-0.2112231404,
0.0248591825,
0.3747416139,
0.2044388801,
0.239993915,
0.4387922883,
0.4091635048,
-0.6470159888,
0.5031512976,
0.3636972904,
-0.2636574805,
-0.3519038558,
0.7574444413,
0.1071161032,
-0.3091625273,
0.9140210152,
-0.1919540018,
-0.4871734977,
0.7289816737,
0.6572697163,
1.1015547514,
-0.0667936876,
-0.0451744944,
0.2387889177,
0.4819745421,
0.0374498628,
0.1604975909,
-0.309805125,
-0.5284610391,
-0.893542707,
-0.4690191746,
0.071386829,
-0.2370079756,
-0.4559378326,
0.038017381,
-0.792476356,
0.2046724856,
-0.1392448545,
-0.3988276124,
-0.2254623473,
0.1080319211,
0.175982669,
0.9709253907,
-0.4588486254,
0.9568349719,
0.6502578855,
-0.5919196606,
-0.5681859851,
0.250015527,
-0.1783695668,
-0.6416400075,
0.9055533409,
0.0817756429,
-0.2007547617,
0.2815431952,
-0.2943925261,
-0.6208490133,
0.8781284094,
0.9778769016,
-0.3332578838,
-0.2335397899,
-0.1511871815,
0.5832105875,
-0.0043222201,
0.0369826965,
0.7324670553,
0.336707741,
0.1366248131,
-0.6136134863,
0.2608604431,
-0.3186753094,
-0.0683780834,
0.4966216683,
-0.3784924746,
0.6665027738,
-0.3114605248,
-0.5073785782,
-0.0421582311,
0.5841181278,
0.0360874496,
0.0889639333,
0.0115562724,
0.3489488959,
0.0631914586,
0.1965925694,
0.9613089561,
-0.3005598783,
0.0093250778,
0.9681952,
0.4134729207,
0.9813634157,
0.6821671128,
-0.1028031334,
0.337600857,
0.3648242652,
0.3370631039,
0.3277170062,
0.5296625495,
-0.1280185133,
-0.1735726744,
0.1681250483,
-0.3521713316,
0.2320877761,
0.2691048682,
-0.6697100997,
-0.3592391312,
-0.305678308,
0.1107167825,
0.2451215684,
-0.1488633007,
0.5458612442,
0.1699427068,
-0.4278024137,
1.1520600319,
0.1186817437,
0.4938926399,
-0.2946875095,
-0.2426893711,
-0.3186024427,
0.1538128406,
-0.2314901203,
-0.4566659629,
1.1121293306,
-0.1156440079,
-0.1827676147,
-0.4790128171,
0.9123289585,
-0.2960793376,
-0.235999018,
0.2874267101,
0.4380537868,
0.477586776,
-0.580606997,
-0.6848834753,
0.2210717648,
0.3384118974,
-0.4023244977,
0.4299262762,
0.0866693482,
0.1494642049,
0.6400097609,
0.8024324179,
-0.0453158394,
0.1895112246,
-0.3256755471,
1.1700057983,
-0.9406225085,
-0.3598624468,
-0.7565833926,
0.5879374743,
0.4522285461,
-0.0786153972,
0.5538060665,
0.7193392515,
0.8151504397,
-0.2451164722,
0.5716252923,
-0.2766335607,
0.1073143408,
-0.4555363059,
0.8727288246,
-0.2810652256,
0.315569073,
-0.1673205346,
-1.0554307699,
-0.5681738853,
0.4148776829,
-0.2703120708,
-0.0805423558,
0.5621161461,
0.7420028448,
-0.0906015188,
-0.4490358531,
0.4562804699,
-0.0336022936,
0.3746531606,
0.6644915938,
0.6957091093,
-0.3926946223,
0.90060395,
-0.0549276732,
0.0520597771,
0.0336744636,
-0.824633956,
-0.5519981384,
-0.4789418578,
-0.4061166644,
-0.2070112973,
0.2112956643,
0.694087863,
0.4888665676,
-0.7290104628,
-0.0182832219,
-0.4446423352,
0.2628676295,
-0.2932627797,
-0.1952349842,
0.4532480836,
-0.3490162492,
-0.5565166473,
0.8445074558,
0.3013612032,
-0.0177479796,
-0.3767428994,
-0.162956953,
-0.0230805296,
-0.3461739123,
0.5612339377,
0.7434073687,
-0.5802183151,
-0.1997456998,
0.1570023,
0.2107709646,
0.1802209467,
1.2024509907,
-1.0311791897,
0.1695285439,
0.8802973628,
1.0715123415,
0.1651108414,
0.1172493696,
0.7910285592,
-0.7191483378,
0.0023054965,
0.4109202921,
0.180397585,
0.1615806967,
-0.4604806602,
0.2556928396,
-0.0253489967,
-0.4361076951,
-0.7522910237,
0.2274646908,
-0.4236130714,
-0.63694942,
0.9096934199,
-0.3808535635,
-0.4848599434,
-0.376835227,
-0.2369056046,
0.4378155172,
-0.2593175471,
0.7616740465,
0.1958881468,
-0.1259755492,
-0.1727710664,
-0.2660473287,
0.3355216086,
0.3815784156,
-0.6665582061,
0.5293217897,
0.6904909015,
0.2556277215,
0.5058981776,
0.5296612382,
-0.4347461164,
0.3487972617,
0.470379591,
0.4734015465,
-0.2872330248,
-0.444460541,
-0.5503687859,
0.1534509957,
0.2279752493,
-0.4508304894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08946v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08946v1 | Towards leveraging latent knowledge and Dialogue context for real-world conversational question answering | 2022-12-17T20:36:17 | 2022-12-17T20:36:17 | Shaomu Tan, Denis Paperno | cs.CL | cs.CL | In many real-world scenarios, the absence of external knowledge source like
Wikipedia restricts question answering systems to rely on latent internal
knowledge in limited dialogue data. In addition, humans often seek answers by
asking several questions for more comprehensive information. As the dialog
becomes more extensive, machines are challenged to refer to previous
conversation rounds to answer questions. In this work, we propose to leverage
latent knowledge in existing conversation logs via a neural Retrieval-Reading
system, enhanced with a TFIDF-based text summarizer refining lengthy
conversational history to alleviate the long context issue. Our experiments
show that our Retrieval-Reading system can exploit retrieved background
knowledge to generate significantly better answers. The results also indicate
that our context summarizer significantly helps both the retriever and the
reader by introducing more concise and less noisy contextual information. | [
-0.361798048,
-1.0059244633,
0.6468527317,
-0.1141970605,
-0.4076189697,
0.2445048839,
-0.0642643943,
-0.5391568542,
0.2269310802,
0.5417225957,
-0.621465981,
-0.1030425504,
-0.2408532947,
-0.1558494121,
-0.2309793532,
1.1247055531,
0.3640035391,
-0.2422442883,
-0.3814904988,
-0.0267519318,
-0.5686902404,
-0.6638829708,
-0.6981725097,
-0.4693087935,
0.7180496454,
0.4525602758,
0.4609831274,
-0.016114613,
0.1680603921,
0.2374200225,
-0.3110310435,
0.1960808188,
-0.7961242795,
0.4165382683,
-0.0831240788,
-0.6554753184,
-0.2503522635,
-0.3247282207,
0.4563134313,
0.8150767088,
0.0332352221,
-0.0678101033,
-0.044884488,
0.2285761088,
-0.5752420425,
-0.058158543,
-0.4829378128,
0.2376486808,
0.2504265308,
-0.5858713388,
-0.167362988,
-0.3193785846,
0.634019196,
-0.5688735247,
0.2950561047,
-0.1670895219,
0.7958276868,
0.3493644893,
-0.6807569265,
-0.1440031528,
-0.7630969286,
0.6153526306,
-0.7071572542,
0.2889818847,
0.5930011868,
0.4267305136,
0.180976823,
-0.8249992132,
-0.572686851,
0.0965035409,
-0.5426036119,
0.1747598648,
0.2090911418,
0.0877770334,
0.2072833031,
0.3230497539,
-0.3965293467,
-0.3290625215,
-0.4885697365,
-0.3334246874,
0.3952622712,
0.1666988581,
0.2591794729,
-0.3079250157,
-0.0433438234,
0.0259064399,
-0.6019920111,
0.1571209878,
-0.0444216914,
-0.1186899021,
-0.0519847572,
0.3260191381,
-0.3068179488,
0.9534133673,
-0.1309865415,
-0.2312807292,
-0.0056455573,
-0.6017584801,
-0.0959425569,
-0.0350678191,
0.3454754949,
0.6854811311,
0.1891222,
-0.4166510999,
0.0264938027,
-0.6846605539,
0.2312515229,
-1.0892602205,
-0.0189485215,
0.2389872372,
-0.4683682024,
-0.3587638438,
0.0050944951,
-0.9513293505,
-0.0342252031,
-0.1139309108,
0.2570640445,
-0.1803224087,
-0.3184907436,
-0.3716875911,
-0.6398890018,
0.3679066598,
0.5707568526,
-1.0028178692,
0.087580815,
0.6279569268,
0.8812215328,
0.1090390384,
0.2957133651,
-0.7173262835,
0.2634640336,
-0.289151758,
0.7832090259,
-0.4699100852,
-0.5763326287,
-0.135197863,
-0.0548331626,
-0.0357775576,
-0.3689023554,
0.1233708411,
-1.0219000578,
0.5563458204,
-0.4115807116,
-0.4221711457,
-0.2217692435,
0.633241713,
-0.4470784366,
0.7746279836,
0.0820293501,
-0.8167985082,
0.0521189384,
-0.5078403354,
-0.5252358317,
-0.0120280245,
-0.2263329178,
0.1098388806,
0.1244245917,
0.3195213377,
0.4841003716,
0.0117541151,
0.4965367913,
0.0690420344,
-0.4397221208,
0.3429640234,
-0.6306141019,
0.6725891232,
0.2325758934,
-0.1783813685,
-0.1652732641,
-0.4377886653,
-0.0126115168,
-0.1510417461,
-0.2713723779,
-0.4255345762,
-0.0835661367,
-0.1363452971,
0.0735152438,
0.2723775506,
-0.5539909601,
0.0046941414,
-0.6000944972,
0.3760344982,
0.5288577676,
0.5319547057,
0.5151070952,
-0.5318219066,
0.4157838821,
-0.0621685237,
-0.4818771183,
-0.6167632937,
-0.2779139876,
-0.8628639579,
0.2969349027,
0.1233753264,
0.7134753466,
-1.0022907257,
0.3105437458,
-0.3314516544,
-0.2771354318,
0.1649625897,
0.0869351253,
0.4125243723,
1.1211508512,
0.2786821723,
0.0725796223,
-0.3378259242,
-0.7009869814,
-0.0310739093,
-0.3839198947,
-0.2905879617,
0.8885626793,
0.2948516309,
0.2025415003,
1.2053594589,
-1.0584095716,
-0.1455112249,
-0.2337166965,
-0.0965084732,
0.176617831,
0.3782057464,
0.4322147369,
-1.0430663824,
-0.2101814747,
-0.11652527,
-1.0517348051,
-0.0140161905,
-0.0906183571,
-0.2742382884,
-0.0090991473,
0.8379844427,
-0.4121687114,
0.2525708377,
0.2786854506,
-0.6120650172,
0.3372883499,
-0.0812405944,
0.2556976378,
-1.4013521671,
0.4482584298,
-0.4986965954,
-0.4102369845,
-0.7124977112,
-0.1014320776,
-0.0768127143,
-0.2830598056,
-0.3559012115,
0.6722129583,
0.0241380427,
0.0521878041,
-0.0728833079,
0.3014962375,
0.2579761744,
0.6205522418,
0.2941368222,
1.133351326,
-0.2946387827,
-0.7392241359,
0.3689337075,
0.4838825464,
-0.2145541608,
0.5598443151,
-0.7621002793,
0.1929751039,
-0.3655768931,
0.5409698486,
-1.1126301289,
-0.3359821439,
0.0021046184,
-0.4831171632,
0.2445919067,
-0.1586306095,
-0.2704705894,
0.0284634475,
0.1081644595,
0.3199158013,
0.3324643373,
-0.5704154968,
0.6985322833,
0.3080457747,
-0.5945721865,
-0.7040485144,
-0.7018941641,
0.1471377313,
-0.2146926671,
-0.6811733246,
0.3981273472,
-0.2169671655,
-0.3730349541,
-0.0993917435,
-0.2985033393,
-0.2843830884,
0.2572371066,
-0.0605699122,
0.0407452472,
-0.3144350946,
0.626198113,
0.1989524215,
-0.1362234354,
0.0264839437,
-0.3068783283,
0.5095151067,
0.1906729788,
0.0412618369,
-0.2864645123,
0.5061963797,
0.2480432093,
-0.1654982716,
0.6228399277,
0.4048885405,
-0.3047663569,
0.1690938175,
-0.687549293,
-0.5359058976,
-0.4507466555,
0.3161926866,
-0.4469181895,
-1.31881392,
0.5644224882,
0.0149629572,
0.1660032868,
0.2807272971,
0.3354209363,
-0.4532391429,
0.5947543979,
0.4594024718,
-0.0355468243,
0.7525650859,
-0.2903977334,
0.2122304142,
-0.6855689287,
-0.4477649927,
-0.4608178735,
-0.2238616943,
0.0869698972,
-0.3106698096,
0.2689334154,
0.081852898,
0.2174692601,
0.0201293938,
-0.1982744336,
0.6116715074,
0.3796613216,
0.4605716169,
0.5667082667,
-0.1269864738,
-0.0588551573,
-0.059401527,
-0.5115070343,
-0.4554953873,
0.9115852118,
-0.0284755137,
0.471655041,
0.3414490521,
0.42752859,
0.2579739988,
0.1199476272,
-0.6387143731,
0.4361286163,
0.2771591842,
-0.7503719926,
-0.4072788656,
-0.5028936267,
-0.7332060337,
0.4491806328,
-0.1009439602,
-0.8701629639,
0.1673941016,
0.1820728928,
-0.6360247731,
0.2218361497,
-0.7079049349,
0.7470331192,
-0.082462661,
-0.2303984463,
-0.264968127,
-0.8064736724,
0.1938464046,
0.0096382378,
0.0106363548,
0.1069401428,
-0.1199239865,
0.8491002321,
-0.6070076227,
0.93778795,
-0.2851829827,
-0.4045881331,
0.3797084391,
-0.1984964907,
0.3300845325,
0.4428021312,
-0.0859897658,
-0.2286835462,
0.1814371198,
-0.4311993718,
-0.9950241446,
0.6297061443,
-0.7144095898,
-0.8352806568,
-0.2379518598,
-0.4457378685,
-0.3269185424,
0.2778098285,
0.299646914,
0.7554027438,
-0.577878356,
0.5251018405,
0.9773740768,
-0.0860528797,
0.5769212842,
0.4226970971,
-0.0230181608,
-0.2035359293,
0.833982408,
0.1283440441,
0.2258774191,
0.881144464,
0.0452682376,
-0.2659218311,
-0.2179788649,
-0.5269756913,
0.0109479316,
-0.7505311966,
-0.2419402152,
-1.2213767767,
-0.2987223268,
-0.3933801353,
-0.2075433582,
0.234793067,
-0.6625054479,
-0.5987485051,
-0.2992019951,
0.2466181368,
0.4826421142,
0.2682971954,
0.6027724147,
-0.8575905561,
0.3824512959,
0.856554389,
0.3218930662,
0.2043457478,
-0.4870316684,
-0.1962225437,
0.1981335431,
-0.2979589999,
-0.8935607076,
0.259221822,
0.3482952118,
0.4766376019,
0.3680179119,
0.249251157,
0.8220999837,
-0.2530056238,
0.9429631233,
-0.1567623466,
-0.5433555841,
0.6305048466,
-0.3705858886,
0.5924498439,
0.7540322542,
0.18750076,
-0.8292286396,
-0.2456973046,
-0.6630690694,
-0.7180803418,
0.6737607121,
0.2401874512,
0.5092166662,
0.2072622478,
0.4369437397,
-0.0197801683,
0.2590145469,
-0.1351055354,
-0.0880892724,
-0.3288452923,
-0.139768824,
-0.3473306,
-0.3116271794,
-0.255556047,
-0.1182143688,
0.6124675274,
-0.3467701674,
0.3045030534,
0.4129938483,
-0.4554200172,
0.1351292878,
0.3435349762,
0.62950176,
0.7152552605,
-0.4234183133,
0.0267063566,
0.4772545397,
-0.479583174,
0.0013051425,
0.1161088869,
-0.2324684113,
-0.0689524487,
0.3654812872,
0.5923489928,
0.355239749,
-0.9066814184,
0.5218297243,
-0.5352630615,
-0.023779247,
-0.6422685981,
0.3398627639,
0.2728403211,
0.2690019906,
0.8941712379,
-0.1068102419,
0.2118218988,
-0.2665722966,
0.425953716,
0.3050458431,
-0.5596662164,
-0.1031834409,
0.2658720016,
0.5039968491,
-0.384318471,
0.8246840239,
0.3663701415,
-0.4816801548,
0.722515583,
0.5384879708,
0.3537005186,
0.1422721446,
0.0957865417,
0.3169219196,
-0.2457630783,
0.3209929466,
0.1295630038,
-0.8661473989,
-0.627109766,
-0.4846152365,
-0.4392672777,
-0.5165202618,
0.1120222434,
-0.4227057397,
-0.0827863291,
-0.4593924582,
0.0133805731,
-0.115123257,
0.1811643541,
-0.4392393529,
0.3512906134,
-0.2268653363,
0.646330893,
-0.5077920556,
0.5603405237,
0.3546706438,
-0.3657158017,
-0.4540860057,
0.2577667832,
-0.1120432094,
-0.4729522765,
0.5701102018,
0.3623988628,
0.021817822,
0.2899762392,
-0.5756636858,
-0.8450998068,
1.2960186005,
0.1811548769,
-0.2877352238,
-0.4053251445,
-0.300470382,
0.6635214686,
-0.2450635731,
0.4964011014,
0.5948849916,
0.1139486656,
0.4916238189,
-0.7501917481,
0.0453869551,
-0.5264246464,
-0.2306507677,
0.1279524863,
-0.6615121365,
0.2970832884,
-0.2601816654,
-0.179061383,
0.1631174833,
0.8706012368,
0.1234004349,
0.3433866501,
0.3981620371,
0.2991867065,
0.7810846567,
-0.11582537,
0.9151570797,
-0.2751599848,
-0.0196900368,
1.3123893738,
0.3019366264,
0.8115075231,
0.5433831811,
0.1730472744,
0.6373196244,
0.5788430572,
0.421315074,
0.5272477269,
-0.1032295153,
-0.619787097,
-0.314094156,
-0.3799226284,
-0.4107964933,
0.4052668214,
0.6354842782,
-0.3462205827,
-0.3325178325,
-0.0617584698,
0.1017959192,
-0.1322764605,
0.1562334895,
1.3096362352,
0.2411447614,
-1.0202922821,
0.483553648,
-0.2892276049,
0.619817853,
-0.4354477227,
-0.2834549248,
-0.465080142,
-0.0894811377,
-0.2003182173,
-0.7225989699,
0.5082944036,
-0.0019905898,
-0.2219421864,
-0.2536252737,
0.7423186898,
-0.4348727167,
-0.1208727658,
0.0543706305,
0.61346066,
0.1947075278,
-0.0693126023,
-0.2211395949,
-0.4382608235,
0.0206940882,
-0.2685218453,
0.1504712999,
0.2743151784,
-0.0139924316,
0.5985769033,
0.7936731577,
-0.2614581585,
-0.2969469428,
-0.0995362028,
1.0558338165,
-0.86241436,
-0.9028413296,
-0.5663517714,
0.4674873054,
-0.4423033893,
-0.2714006007,
0.3463013172,
0.3999899924,
0.5966185927,
0.2771761119,
0.8521149158,
-0.2283813506,
0.5041486621,
-0.4321379364,
0.9976798296,
-0.5500428677,
0.2409582287,
-0.1496124119,
-0.8695595264,
-0.2066180408,
0.6115358472,
-0.2708133161,
-0.0647038221,
0.4613711238,
0.7242260575,
-0.0286977179,
0.3586562872,
0.4114704132,
0.0892814919,
0.5301020145,
0.5358009338,
0.6557650566,
-0.3731811345,
0.9707778692,
-0.121249482,
-0.1648906618,
-0.3239090443,
-0.7294665575,
-1.2009074688,
-0.6688061953,
0.1224408299,
-0.4457074404,
0.2432846576,
0.6699520946,
0.6722713113,
-0.6813316345,
-0.0178300794,
0.1769724935,
0.2977093458,
0.1614627987,
-0.2863581777,
0.3031498194,
-0.4587804973,
-0.6311943531,
0.4164069593,
0.0783995986,
0.1313574761,
-0.0053193453,
-0.0202040337,
-0.3031075895,
-0.1150326058,
0.6625023484,
0.2836861312,
-0.3662287593,
-0.3448473215,
0.1568597555,
-0.0372505039,
0.0915588364,
1.0532698631,
-1.1153383255,
0.5192558765,
0.8230572939,
0.8297997117,
0.8627122045,
0.2565071881,
0.9914758205,
-0.979890883,
0.2510302961,
0.3045695424,
-0.0081547266,
0.4368040264,
-0.6002088189,
0.4117727876,
0.174581185,
-0.3058652878,
-0.4552617073,
0.1802324951,
-0.5690573454,
-0.3531251848,
0.803552568,
-0.2263304591,
-0.0481326878,
-0.5540909171,
-0.3381545842,
0.3398276865,
-0.6847304106,
0.5185215473,
0.7085254788,
-0.0574797913,
-0.5480273962,
-0.3945804238,
0.5959293842,
0.5001097322,
-0.8451038003,
-0.096400775,
0.5589676499,
0.3491384685,
0.2423224598,
1.0525813103,
0.025430521,
0.2374854684,
-0.2135563791,
-0.6334626079,
0.0146816261,
-0.1763960272,
-0.1753177196,
0.4499294758,
-0.2816957831,
0.3706487119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08929v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08929v2 | Modeling Instance Interactions for Joint Information Extraction with Neural High-Order Conditional Random Field | 2022-12-17T18:45:23 | 2023-05-28T09:48:24 | Zixia Jia, Zhaohui Yan, Wenjuan Han, Zilong Zheng, Kewei Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prior works on joint Information Extraction (IE) typically model instance
(e.g., event triggers, entities, roles, relations) interactions by
representation enhancement, type dependencies scoring, or global decoding. We
find that the previous models generally consider binary type dependency scoring
of a pair of instances, and leverage local search such as beam search to
approximate global solutions. To better integrate cross-instance interactions,
in this work, we introduce a joint IE framework (CRFIE) that formulates joint
IE as a high-order Conditional Random Field. Specifically, we design binary
factors and ternary factors to directly model interactions between not only a
pair of instances but also triplets. Then, these factors are utilized to
jointly predict labels of all instances. To address the intractability problem
of exact high-order inference, we incorporate a high-order neural decoder that
is unfolded from a mean-field variational inference method, which achieves
consistent learning and inference. The experimental results show that our
approach achieves consistent improvements on three IE tasks compared with our
baseline and prior work. | [
-0.1933531165,
-0.8466784954,
0.635628581,
-0.0829042792,
-0.0291780829,
-0.3238706589,
-0.188736707,
-0.9940651059,
0.2198708355,
0.46518296,
-0.2520763278,
-0.549675107,
-0.5944487453,
-0.0660780892,
-0.1201787591,
0.86054492,
-0.0618008263,
-0.1337267309,
-0.4365434349,
-0.374954164,
-0.2261262536,
-0.8110536337,
-0.449311465,
-0.424503535,
0.5696739554,
0.3854437768,
0.4487036467,
0.3056527078,
0.6792958379,
0.3758105338,
0.0595484935,
-0.0503586307,
-0.457249105,
0.3190060556,
-0.3710450232,
-0.3910048902,
-0.5785028338,
0.2366547585,
0.3683723211,
0.661690414,
-0.1411369443,
0.1135500669,
-0.1057308093,
0.0075492696,
-0.8170505762,
0.5711297393,
-0.6140079498,
0.1356617063,
0.0898942649,
-0.3574689627,
-0.5059298277,
0.235220924,
0.4303409457,
-0.7540997863,
0.3891532123,
-0.0428811014,
0.8832888603,
-0.4092731774,
-0.3303168714,
0.1453764737,
-0.6563618779,
0.8567202091,
-0.7166085839,
0.3858348131,
0.4156616032,
-0.019028822,
-0.2827688456,
-0.7612066269,
-0.332238555,
-0.0814962089,
-0.1450624168,
0.438087672,
-0.0948971212,
0.4259817004,
0.2354092151,
0.1951953918,
-0.0601456426,
0.2931948602,
-0.2690498233,
-0.0650715455,
0.4694935381,
0.18650648,
0.2763229907,
-0.1239555553,
-0.6197105646,
-0.0329531133,
-0.6020418406,
0.3059443831,
0.266192764,
0.2368763983,
-0.1316521764,
0.6188883781,
-0.1550013423,
0.5257214308,
-0.0035209493,
0.1906914264,
0.0216959082,
-0.2107565403,
-0.369994849,
-0.1460034102,
0.8382430673,
0.2376165837,
-0.1911271214,
-0.3556086123,
-0.2615470588,
-0.2474444062,
0.1916240007,
-0.6844671965,
0.057144735,
0.1902987808,
-0.7599414587,
-0.3450496495,
0.34613958,
-1.1038155556,
-0.1882894933,
-0.3459433019,
0.5974514484,
-0.4986461103,
-0.438624531,
-0.0104681635,
-0.128011778,
0.1430935115,
0.3178551495,
-0.9809075594,
0.3527360857,
0.4976260662,
0.4048357904,
-0.00131673,
-0.532464087,
-0.9274399877,
0.4063018858,
0.0083909361,
0.7945900559,
-0.8214498162,
-0.3042925894,
0.2061567903,
-0.2402290702,
-0.2791599929,
-0.3914104402,
0.3261674345,
-0.6931542158,
0.2297165841,
-0.1104621291,
-0.5829819441,
-0.3862911761,
0.0344664231,
-0.7207999825,
0.8021648526,
0.263096422,
-0.7899066806,
0.4997224212,
-0.6914380789,
-0.256474793,
0.2179783583,
-0.4867629707,
-0.4361699522,
0.3291403949,
0.1020202935,
0.4959662855,
-0.4578500986,
0.119685255,
-0.8120584488,
-0.2522678971,
0.0777210295,
-0.2295200378,
0.581644237,
-0.1974828541,
-0.2946102023,
0.168374151,
-0.7659749389,
0.0679047406,
-0.0606580861,
-0.3278776705,
-0.485386759,
0.1973448098,
-0.0359585732,
0.1473954171,
0.1084556282,
-0.5637702942,
0.2100774199,
-0.0289375447,
0.2889334261,
0.4849461615,
0.3954690397,
0.5653611422,
0.1887575239,
0.2206130475,
0.4934473932,
0.1534533501,
0.1540507972,
-0.465456754,
-0.4521441162,
-0.2199801058,
0.3969657123,
0.3553617895,
-0.579223752,
0.473251611,
-0.2738855183,
0.154203862,
-0.2299913466,
0.0332576483,
0.4780336022,
0.5540405512,
0.4571798146,
-0.2512500584,
-0.5087170005,
-1.0314736366,
-0.1186655238,
-0.4701112211,
-0.069364816,
0.1064475551,
0.3145695329,
0.0841740146,
1.0225977898,
-0.2246961296,
-0.2648471892,
-0.2967222929,
0.92456007,
0.1481226683,
0.4806975126,
0.4525828063,
-1.0940458775,
0.0227509476,
0.2123074979,
-1.1431186199,
0.1868438721,
-0.0859527066,
-0.1892643422,
0.0179726463,
0.4665705264,
-0.593634665,
0.8901572824,
0.1958519071,
-0.2988294959,
0.3910477757,
-0.3467785418,
0.4257182777,
-0.9351819754,
-0.032277327,
0.4280286133,
-0.0926241279,
-0.7045714855,
0.2585887313,
0.0234654322,
0.0045401086,
-0.3809757531,
0.1625099331,
-0.8111778498,
-0.3179712296,
-0.1565137655,
-0.2952567339,
0.1096926183,
0.4901678264,
0.3036625683,
0.6114606857,
0.376752913,
-0.242308408,
-0.1276627928,
0.1021788418,
-0.3105115592,
0.5467664599,
-0.5396376848,
0.1650366932,
-0.031968791,
0.0883251652,
-0.2805629075,
-0.2197599113,
0.0543961227,
-0.2811647654,
0.5146043897,
-0.5274313688,
-0.5210998058,
-0.1453775018,
-0.0462357402,
0.5623561144,
0.2112430632,
-0.7012116313,
1.1360493898,
0.4297161698,
0.0266477056,
-0.6470883489,
-0.4181011021,
0.1248474121,
-0.0606616214,
-0.7567484379,
0.6356745958,
0.0847196802,
-0.4260046184,
0.3267680705,
-0.2054045647,
-0.5784923434,
-0.0221896674,
0.2650846839,
0.5294638872,
-0.510810256,
-0.2050777525,
-0.0533673875,
-0.0252933223,
0.0579708479,
-0.0035589847,
0.2867127061,
-0.1579891443,
-0.0484850779,
-0.398493737,
0.9636232853,
0.569429934,
-0.3778580725,
0.7340945005,
0.5241558552,
-0.6220759153,
-0.0480339937,
-0.6590796113,
-0.2109891921,
-0.4308415949,
0.5636657476,
-0.7130920887,
-0.6882485151,
0.6961169243,
0.2315958738,
0.0426524878,
0.4214232862,
0.3828102946,
-0.2849423885,
1.0138622522,
0.7566126585,
-0.1045710146,
0.6307464242,
-0.4170135558,
0.2750853002,
-0.7414406538,
-0.185771361,
-0.1607735157,
0.0138208345,
-0.1325074136,
0.0182351619,
0.4828777313,
0.6420584917,
0.2322730273,
0.3533620238,
-0.017920956,
0.648629427,
0.7917093039,
0.3672960103,
0.1759218872,
0.0906044841,
-0.1213907897,
0.1781865209,
-0.6344900727,
-0.060068801,
0.7537166476,
0.1023625284,
0.4702487886,
0.0546352267,
1.0265785456,
0.0814356059,
0.3257975876,
-0.5095738769,
0.486523211,
-0.0924848691,
-0.5036211014,
-0.1307241619,
-0.5107777119,
-0.9413722157,
0.3034451604,
-0.6209366322,
-1.3400094509,
0.6933427453,
-0.063184239,
-0.3806360662,
0.4291112423,
-0.9312523603,
0.6541074514,
0.2283567339,
-0.7159852982,
-0.3366420269,
-0.5981062055,
0.5180827975,
0.2924364805,
0.0430828854,
0.028180955,
0.2887194157,
0.7306938767,
-0.3858282268,
0.8886281252,
-0.277626276,
0.1787576377,
0.4993443191,
0.1202953234,
0.5085220933,
0.335535109,
-0.3346001804,
0.4077718556,
-0.0953281373,
-0.3533956409,
-0.6930063367,
0.6673212051,
-0.6899682283,
-0.5822351575,
-0.3631606996,
-0.7912386656,
-0.1422306448,
0.2772077322,
0.3548187912,
0.7175373435,
-0.027047677,
0.2483347952,
0.4309899509,
0.1190715358,
0.6993178129,
0.4400066733,
0.2281085551,
-0.5433795452,
0.7798715234,
0.1825941354,
0.0516009033,
0.585537672,
-0.0247398522,
-0.0576287508,
-0.6253356934,
-0.2645610273,
-0.043353539,
-0.6361016035,
-0.414033711,
-0.5326215625,
-0.2976411879,
-0.4284616709,
0.0270523801,
-0.0381894968,
-0.2518983185,
-0.405715704,
-0.1458833665,
0.1110794544,
0.7058758736,
-0.1450233608,
0.1449464262,
-1.032600522,
0.424523592,
0.2506989539,
0.4659642577,
-0.1755522341,
-0.0619914271,
-0.334136337,
-0.1563442498,
-0.1792137325,
-0.8914468884,
0.2120155692,
-0.0617696308,
0.6939653158,
0.235411942,
-0.140888229,
0.6237276793,
-0.2924143076,
0.5247187018,
0.5302668214,
-0.7651775479,
0.1592343003,
-0.4529423118,
-0.185875684,
0.5914061069,
0.20370996,
-0.153945148,
-0.1110893115,
-0.8069024086,
-0.9335383773,
0.9389236569,
0.3540399969,
-0.499337256,
0.0619655326,
0.4108069539,
0.13578403,
-0.2072247118,
-0.7742650509,
-0.1537985951,
0.0829848722,
-0.3379030228,
0.2828496397,
-0.3683157265,
-0.1855790615,
0.0158362146,
0.4949767292,
0.119148083,
0.4971397221,
0.2949534953,
-0.3379674852,
-0.2943741679,
0.1479955465,
0.1974394619,
0.558942318,
-0.5194472671,
0.1780113578,
-0.1361227483,
-0.2044028044,
-0.0272082612,
0.4540706277,
-0.1293615401,
-0.1857295036,
0.5359431505,
0.6761060953,
0.4827087522,
-0.0995084047,
0.5847265124,
-0.3008881509,
-0.418900311,
0.0029957106,
0.0150792282,
-0.0418933257,
0.452747941,
0.3727011681,
0.1141920239,
0.3562623262,
-0.4350219071,
0.4037943482,
0.2111399025,
-0.3319033384,
-0.4224098921,
0.5121593475,
0.168673709,
-0.3771422803,
0.5176767707,
-0.032416787,
-0.3937408328,
0.819118917,
0.6007609963,
0.9322216511,
0.0383989997,
0.1043522134,
0.1654554009,
-0.0172098614,
-0.0842950344,
0.3494640887,
-0.1504351348,
-0.6337106228,
-0.4678934216,
-0.3554781675,
-0.4481644332,
0.361251086,
-1.0605245829,
0.1985481977,
-0.2195949107,
-0.0532372221,
0.3415352404,
-0.1637665778,
-0.8855055571,
0.20540227,
0.0359024592,
0.4300539792,
-0.7196882367,
1.0016593933,
0.6260586381,
-0.8830392957,
-0.5859405994,
-0.0335622951,
-0.1963499784,
-0.4498199821,
0.766726613,
0.2828397155,
0.0500804223,
-0.0663223192,
-0.405382067,
-0.8859866261,
0.8307554126,
0.0652174503,
-0.4139628112,
-0.1359262615,
0.1015198231,
0.3248434365,
-0.455994308,
0.7032681108,
0.2985262573,
0.3263147473,
-0.3595032394,
-0.4122793078,
-0.0247519109,
-0.427184999,
-0.037381418,
0.3321074247,
-0.44988662,
0.5358985662,
-0.0384968519,
-0.1110303029,
0.0141782211,
1.0967258215,
0.0479112342,
0.366019547,
0.6640074253,
0.4915291965,
0.2826679945,
0.1692103893,
0.7675302029,
-0.2932444513,
0.3431108296,
1.2057739496,
-0.4729199409,
0.9443616271,
0.6049708128,
-0.023355728,
0.5165948868,
0.3317754567,
0.0564217083,
0.2720393538,
-0.2363941669,
-0.5884258151,
-0.4854972661,
-0.0306009557,
-0.1068931073,
0.482553333,
0.4384541512,
-0.4557383358,
-0.3328868747,
-0.1795582324,
-0.4713260531,
-0.0696270019,
-0.0393021591,
0.749859035,
0.0662432835,
-0.619271636,
0.2192763686,
0.0541322157,
0.5170573592,
-0.3817200363,
-0.4245598912,
-0.2007028311,
0.0700507239,
-0.1508474797,
-0.6102464199,
-0.1397067159,
-0.2802337408,
-0.7615154982,
0.097682327,
0.7873381376,
-0.6240505576,
-0.4688041806,
0.7277172208,
0.3333415985,
-0.2473179251,
0.2747232914,
-0.5188933015,
-0.1280457228,
-0.3001327515,
-0.6151742339,
0.7459484339,
0.3873370886,
-0.1556321383,
0.125137642,
0.5218494534,
0.004482734,
0.1289458424,
0.1629056185,
0.5536398888,
-0.6033301353,
-0.2356874198,
-0.4995167255,
0.3797423542,
-0.4740798771,
-0.3298303485,
0.1205996498,
0.4117363393,
0.5694749355,
0.1000764221,
0.7163470387,
-0.2273942977,
0.2667278647,
-0.6470873952,
0.4575972557,
-0.3802903295,
0.2252044082,
-0.0080815563,
-1.0549042225,
-0.3615927398,
0.2726319134,
-0.2884731889,
-0.0920435637,
0.7826524973,
0.6279705167,
-0.6318891644,
0.356439501,
0.4320698082,
0.2867707312,
0.5707874298,
0.6538851857,
0.5700984001,
-0.4525117874,
0.5772625804,
-0.7418433428,
-0.4328813255,
0.0286206976,
-0.9970881939,
-0.8216611147,
-0.4450574815,
-0.2915074527,
-0.4094846547,
0.2229065448,
1.0253567696,
0.8633989096,
-0.7005451322,
-0.251983285,
-0.272066623,
-0.1323327571,
-0.3663678169,
-0.3377268016,
0.4578262866,
-0.4560835361,
-0.632909596,
0.6129697561,
0.3536601067,
-0.1076271161,
0.3317770064,
0.2573376894,
-0.3507576883,
-0.2546259463,
0.5647293329,
0.4867046475,
-0.4327640533,
-0.6578094959,
-0.3189160824,
-0.0059464648,
0.3013579547,
0.9739168286,
-0.666375339,
0.3528317213,
0.5428308249,
0.5280690789,
0.7314561009,
-0.0230536554,
0.9302891493,
-0.4754868448,
0.1161508188,
0.1943547726,
0.7588628531,
-0.0811148286,
-0.5886495113,
0.4737021029,
0.3994333446,
-0.5125806928,
-0.6369562149,
0.1757892817,
-1.0893661976,
-0.2229113579,
0.978472352,
-0.508338511,
-0.3868594468,
-0.0894499421,
0.2495771945,
0.3661999106,
-0.3801544309,
0.8488514423,
0.3756085634,
-0.2386529148,
-0.1586066037,
-0.1728704274,
0.0094465222,
0.6644232273,
-0.8145618439,
0.1640562862,
0.5048264265,
0.1792784035,
0.1120017096,
0.3372361064,
-0.1958438605,
0.425535351,
0.0539736003,
0.4192913175,
-0.1085777134,
-0.524189055,
-0.2000306547,
0.3644893765,
-0.3348029554,
-0.0606772564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08926v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08926v1 | A Simple Baseline for Beam Search Reranking | 2022-12-17T18:22:20 | 2022-12-17T18:22:20 | Lior Vassertail, Omer Levy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Reranking methods in machine translation aim to close the gap between common
evaluation metrics (e.g. BLEU) and maximum likelihood learning and decoding
algorithms. Prior works address this challenge by training models to rerank
beam search candidates according to their predicted BLEU scores, building upon
large models pretrained on massive monolingual corpora -- a privilege that was
never made available to the baseline translation model. In this work, we
examine a simple approach for training rerankers to predict translation
candidates' BLEU scores without introducing additional data or parameters. Our
approach can be used as a clean baseline, decoupled from external factors, for
future research in this area. | [
-0.2413491905,
-0.2748103738,
0.5648831129,
0.0285982806,
-0.1632570922,
0.0281030927,
-0.1580078155,
-0.2403380722,
0.0931805521,
0.3045732081,
-0.5521913171,
-0.6341310143,
-0.9121947289,
0.1321799159,
-0.3642404974,
0.8461438417,
0.2306100428,
-0.0314595178,
-0.0709250793,
-0.2074477971,
-0.5939693451,
-0.2300202101,
-0.411562264,
-0.3907408714,
0.5882703066,
0.6523712873,
0.7612014413,
0.5214538574,
0.5604179502,
0.2364580929,
-0.2034589052,
0.0560466424,
-0.8490220904,
0.0223715622,
-0.3790802658,
-0.3612856865,
-0.2473840117,
0.3610657156,
0.8237538338,
1.2405617237,
0.0444217362,
0.3131245077,
0.0636377633,
0.8161394596,
-0.7915169597,
0.0777524486,
-0.7295006514,
0.131436184,
-0.0718541369,
-0.461325556,
-0.9189403057,
-0.4597135186,
-0.1942231357,
-0.4176034927,
0.605086267,
0.1572477818,
1.1906533241,
0.427249819,
-0.7528316975,
0.0639608651,
-0.4466358125,
0.9886319041,
-0.185821563,
0.8779304624,
0.5427049994,
0.2707972825,
0.037524499,
-0.5798097849,
0.1070459634,
-0.3531775773,
-0.4832127392,
0.3004837334,
-0.0566030629,
0.0666342601,
0.1917708367,
0.3962883651,
-0.7407535911,
0.0393421315,
-0.7323511839,
-0.0721978918,
0.5467335582,
-0.0635170639,
-0.1815899312,
-0.0979625881,
-0.3911452889,
0.0392417945,
-0.7542424202,
0.1387225837,
-0.1399879009,
0.3968988955,
-0.0565670244,
0.6907784343,
-0.5425118208,
0.5990429521,
0.1772978157,
0.2367310077,
0.4828289747,
-0.458134979,
-0.3510355651,
0.0516605079,
0.5172898173,
0.2193014324,
0.0189982951,
-0.431345433,
-0.2200024128,
-0.1838090867,
0.4644547105,
-0.771936357,
-0.0769284517,
0.1364424229,
-0.5899863839,
-0.2904743552,
0.0509615578,
-0.3643099666,
0.1393877119,
-0.3492347002,
0.405901581,
-0.2806048393,
0.2850260437,
-0.3683499098,
-0.1425228566,
0.3012807071,
0.3066625893,
-0.7668039203,
0.0922282636,
0.5175136924,
0.8808013201,
0.1376300454,
-0.4743376076,
-1.0405703783,
0.0861813948,
-0.6243043542,
0.4395642281,
-0.4345679581,
-0.5242721438,
0.0975720808,
0.1102993935,
-0.0725953504,
-0.4869819582,
0.7252836227,
-0.5514439344,
0.0505347438,
-0.165386036,
-0.81420964,
-0.062889047,
0.0335671529,
-0.4796287119,
0.6824810505,
0.2431720942,
-0.5896218419,
0.6784374714,
-0.222511515,
-0.3347200751,
0.2266437262,
0.1145888939,
-0.3521501124,
0.6469210982,
0.2543332577,
0.3229872882,
-0.0047923969,
0.1928698421,
-0.2751587629,
-0.5783204436,
-0.162661612,
-0.1595630795,
0.6575732231,
0.3209610879,
0.0353431627,
-0.1082348526,
-0.3866927624,
0.2791216075,
-0.3119326234,
-0.6161013842,
-0.2572318614,
-0.1211119518,
-0.0365880877,
-0.0845993087,
0.5156541467,
-0.7149130702,
0.1500191689,
-0.4851708412,
-0.148450613,
0.705067873,
-0.2442093343,
0.5133618116,
-0.2120339572,
0.2677946091,
-0.3747317195,
-0.1755635887,
-0.1075820401,
-0.3944073319,
-0.5803174973,
-0.2904325426,
0.6295022368,
0.5179408193,
-0.3677493036,
0.5172573924,
-0.6473489404,
-0.6671540737,
-0.9022895098,
0.621268034,
0.732368052,
0.2736074626,
0.4572611153,
-0.0750854835,
-0.6535108685,
-1.02292943,
-0.2667865455,
0.0247594751,
-0.1606040597,
-0.0748088956,
0.3856312037,
-0.1784031987,
0.6888536215,
-0.5716481209,
-0.4511736333,
-0.3315373957,
0.0630266741,
0.4727134407,
0.5776162744,
0.010272176,
-0.9400265813,
-0.4269734919,
0.2800603211,
-1.0778330564,
-0.0447455831,
0.2860182822,
-0.1748121381,
-0.1666962504,
0.926248312,
-0.3840349615,
0.3392513394,
0.7858882546,
-0.1471526176,
0.3219806254,
-0.2886080742,
0.2496418655,
-0.9391041398,
0.3861136436,
0.0475670695,
-0.4190395474,
-0.6261789203,
0.3769807518,
0.2692153156,
-0.4625400603,
-0.3879283369,
0.8251353502,
-0.3609346151,
-0.0242574848,
-0.2905040681,
0.2428245842,
-0.0375591926,
0.3283404112,
0.214847967,
0.4726716578,
0.3173993826,
-0.5649055243,
-0.1043550298,
0.4371463656,
-0.3596965671,
0.5442276597,
-0.6360847354,
0.0972418487,
0.0124596469,
0.1181676015,
-1.0583081245,
0.0665844902,
-0.3258734941,
-0.7336940765,
0.4651587903,
-0.6356352568,
0.0139552364,
-0.1175622344,
-0.096051082,
0.6184208393,
0.4599218369,
-0.5502148271,
0.1019878983,
0.2621735036,
-0.2047103792,
-0.6711977124,
-0.6337378025,
-0.0327055193,
0.0953473821,
-0.5691446662,
0.610845983,
-0.0061036521,
0.1602018923,
-0.0628560409,
-0.1785156429,
-0.0871357396,
0.1361861378,
0.2741785645,
0.191527769,
-0.2912786007,
-0.006745616,
0.1591621786,
-0.5401145816,
-0.2638753951,
-0.1434381008,
0.1813785583,
-0.0972756892,
-0.2494024932,
-0.2058421969,
0.2446079105,
0.2925559282,
-0.4312325418,
0.7739796638,
0.5095709562,
-0.4112237096,
-0.106869638,
-0.4840518832,
-0.0246015042,
-0.4634463787,
0.4564932883,
-0.4877191782,
-0.7501206398,
0.101024963,
-0.1001139656,
0.1143741757,
0.0717429519,
0.7657282352,
-0.2530141175,
0.7853061557,
0.7599914074,
-0.0464497283,
0.4514197111,
-0.2507592142,
0.2449169755,
-0.7912877202,
-0.1976931393,
-0.5456765294,
-0.523006916,
-0.8601130247,
-0.175519377,
0.2847569287,
0.3823408484,
-0.1592176259,
0.2736973166,
-0.2448581308,
0.5997393131,
0.664880991,
0.1063889861,
0.2598837018,
-0.0372201204,
-0.1502192318,
0.032257311,
-0.4949323237,
-0.3079951704,
1.2707929611,
0.1321871877,
0.4539841712,
-0.0233744979,
1.2645287514,
0.2986026406,
0.628557384,
-0.749548018,
0.3123657107,
-0.4110548198,
-0.7999816537,
-0.4432355165,
-0.7264351845,
-1.30397439,
0.6549688578,
-0.0387863703,
-0.6876392365,
0.3402766883,
0.0808417872,
-0.0576017648,
-0.1719592363,
-0.7236915231,
1.1296811104,
-0.0098624602,
-0.1548450142,
-0.2358075529,
-0.50224334,
0.2535798848,
-0.0244098883,
0.5000992417,
-0.1056008041,
0.0803459957,
0.6680173278,
-0.1934726238,
0.3820869625,
-0.3029558659,
0.3757397234,
-0.2326012403,
0.2541140914,
0.096614331,
0.1998445839,
-0.2015403211,
0.1323866695,
0.0015167481,
-0.9436855912,
-0.3924318552,
0.6992670894,
-0.688986659,
-0.5831118226,
-0.2304655015,
-0.4584078193,
-0.2063586116,
0.4790165722,
0.5253810883,
0.1412198395,
-0.6289685965,
0.6240526438,
0.4818749428,
0.1191953421,
0.1270401329,
0.5038816929,
-0.1964134574,
-0.3677344322,
0.8589517474,
-0.0436142199,
0.0280445516,
0.8435078263,
0.1619933099,
-0.3031113446,
-0.6003800035,
-0.2050332427,
0.2458153069,
-0.6720618606,
-0.2808517814,
-0.0665368587,
-0.1332749426,
-0.3723151386,
-0.548146069,
-0.569896102,
-0.1107781082,
0.3529883623,
-0.3730498552,
-0.4144173265,
0.4845795333,
-0.1077984795,
0.1152493358,
-0.8798592687,
0.3586605191,
0.0233374257,
0.194144398,
-0.3076451123,
-0.7169122696,
-0.8160912395,
0.1125752553,
-0.3535301089,
-0.6895471811,
0.4859457016,
0.2558195293,
0.8552475572,
0.0718458444,
-0.0425506122,
0.5532191396,
-0.632260859,
0.4217163324,
0.107489869,
-1.0259660482,
0.7870338559,
0.0136182681,
0.3425270617,
0.9599973559,
0.5288898349,
-0.5831624269,
-0.3675341606,
-0.3411943018,
-0.7015747428,
0.6171586514,
0.399630487,
0.0313988589,
0.0764945671,
0.1082031652,
-0.0105697988,
0.1297346503,
-0.7455257773,
-0.268040061,
-0.1265049875,
-0.1445456594,
-0.7498747706,
-0.0781136379,
-0.0965335593,
-0.2733792663,
0.5524746776,
0.1382895559,
0.0021289212,
0.1080098003,
-0.5881057382,
-0.1174049377,
0.0693874955,
0.2108754665,
0.5331204534,
-0.6344133615,
-0.0880440995,
0.2110402733,
-0.1305383444,
0.4038747549,
-0.0489424728,
-0.2514621019,
0.2227038741,
0.5224117637,
0.4923325479,
0.5287416577,
-0.3913063705,
0.4855155647,
0.2489721328,
-0.356311053,
-0.1136244461,
-0.4245702624,
0.043858204,
0.0507224277,
0.3164511919,
-0.0133431563,
0.0507181063,
-0.5066515207,
0.5560734868,
0.2781811059,
-0.6728873253,
-0.1118137017,
0.4877399206,
0.214777872,
-0.2683410048,
0.7111262679,
-0.3414708674,
-0.1215474382,
0.2060569823,
0.3335720301,
0.7664729357,
-0.5866979361,
0.1407674402,
0.4229640663,
0.4909406304,
-0.0631240904,
-0.243272692,
0.219118908,
-0.6744792461,
-0.3662264049,
-0.8285142779,
-0.361487031,
-0.1720405519,
-0.8008201718,
0.572743237,
-0.2773661017,
0.0278010126,
0.0488399491,
0.1921544522,
-0.9608812332,
0.3412329853,
0.3420839906,
0.8753516674,
-0.8443830013,
1.0163055658,
0.6317458153,
-0.6790678501,
-0.4607641101,
-0.1064023897,
-0.0959020257,
-0.6210916638,
0.8760080934,
0.293102771,
-0.1250362396,
-0.066518046,
-0.2188173681,
-0.9953405857,
0.9386630654,
0.536339283,
-0.2035357952,
-0.4295319319,
-0.1684805155,
0.34123981,
-0.2369449586,
0.1708682477,
0.3932363987,
0.395470798,
-0.0547306091,
-0.9159708619,
0.0367028452,
-0.3083976805,
-0.0730412304,
0.1243297756,
-0.4896841645,
0.6323930621,
-0.0870847702,
-0.2605904639,
0.1887802929,
0.711445272,
0.1854533553,
0.5802211165,
0.0099307019,
0.5430483222,
0.8221583962,
-0.1023277566,
1.2134361267,
-0.2319516391,
0.7493081093,
0.9661103487,
-0.04373933,
1.1130073071,
0.314319998,
-0.0925488099,
0.2862190306,
0.5119212866,
-0.0020098842,
0.6742671132,
0.1144251227,
0.2613075674,
-0.4425415695,
0.2399050593,
-0.3428848982,
0.5375572443,
0.1254907101,
-0.3062120676,
-0.4179857969,
-0.0501851179,
-0.1893391013,
0.3079774082,
-0.3735852838,
0.5699025989,
0.4111207426,
-0.6605525017,
0.9731383324,
0.2146708369,
0.4877955616,
-0.5090425014,
0.120836854,
-0.5674228668,
0.2991841733,
-0.2396682352,
-0.5473728776,
0.2562941909,
-0.194187358,
-0.3419913948,
-0.3589982092,
0.2130526304,
-0.347178489,
-0.7675584555,
0.4395709038,
0.7887869477,
0.2362581939,
0.0246443208,
-0.6185297966,
-0.2349911332,
0.1270037889,
-0.2235273719,
0.4772549272,
0.3838782907,
0.129708752,
0.925994873,
0.5735747814,
-0.0899723917,
0.0728747696,
-0.1414818466,
0.4137706757,
-0.7270987034,
-0.3599431217,
-0.6900004745,
0.3277355134,
0.1553490907,
-0.2370217294,
0.6995790601,
0.9863573313,
1.0824522972,
-0.1015929133,
0.5145664811,
0.1540494859,
0.5669035316,
-0.6641458869,
0.6550301909,
-0.7768558264,
0.0579699613,
-0.2486691475,
-1.0826487541,
-0.2665085495,
0.5670990348,
-0.3668806851,
0.045384042,
0.7954754829,
0.8103179336,
-0.2435686886,
-0.4881761372,
0.8184871078,
0.0580605529,
0.2379548103,
0.585944891,
0.4291963279,
-0.4079684615,
0.67765522,
-0.1100576818,
-0.185803473,
-0.5055553913,
-0.5558819771,
-0.6389772296,
-0.4119481444,
-0.2291188985,
-0.2347452044,
0.2230378687,
0.6296806335,
0.8113511205,
-0.8911445737,
-0.5716924667,
0.2553248107,
0.3490145802,
-0.3836022317,
-0.1205055863,
0.3735769093,
-0.7439882159,
-0.793145299,
0.7889024019,
-0.054892011,
-0.5121270418,
0.2121794969,
-0.3411543071,
-0.2812774181,
-0.0206434932,
0.4943685532,
0.2662632167,
-0.6168219447,
-0.2630469799,
-0.1805323362,
-0.2558441162,
0.1824540496,
0.5688161254,
-0.8382861614,
0.3752402067,
0.4504470229,
0.5634425282,
0.7775909305,
0.2641350329,
0.7179555893,
-1.15335536,
0.2280696779,
-0.0076878108,
0.5505118966,
0.2304618508,
-0.0088652754,
0.5793662071,
0.1616634279,
-0.5111039877,
-0.9643205404,
0.2899824083,
-0.9419659376,
-0.2845015526,
0.8011149764,
-0.3191910684,
0.0747912824,
0.0377869569,
-0.0240455363,
0.2111277878,
-0.2590250373,
0.5671918392,
0.4636605382,
0.3323544264,
-0.0875206962,
-0.5229216218,
0.4252882898,
0.6397429109,
-0.200752303,
0.0955410823,
0.2102296352,
0.3073091209,
0.2264279574,
0.5918513536,
0.0604390092,
0.4531012177,
0.1908319741,
-0.0465809777,
-0.0853403732,
-0.3568629324,
-0.1853159517,
0.3524968028,
0.363270849,
-0.1776828766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08913v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08913v2 | Claim Optimization in Computational Argumentation | 2022-12-17T16:30:27 | 2023-09-07T09:01:20 | Gabriella Skitalinskaya, Maximilian Spliethöver, Henning Wachsmuth | cs.CL | cs.CL | An optimal delivery of arguments is key to persuasion in any debate, both for
humans and for AI systems. This requires the use of clear and fluent claims
relevant to the given debate. Prior work has studied the automatic assessment
of argument quality extensively. Yet, no approach actually improves the quality
so far. To fill this gap, this paper proposes the task of claim optimization:
to rewrite argumentative claims in order to optimize their delivery. As
multiple types of optimization are possible, we approach this task by first
generating a diverse set of candidate claims using a large language model, such
as BART, taking into account contextual information. Then, the best candidate
is selected using various quality metrics. In automatic and human evaluation on
an English-language corpus, our quality-based candidate selection outperforms
several baselines, improving 60% of all claims (worsening 16% only). Follow-up
analyses reveal that, beyond copy editing, our approach often specifies claims
with details, whereas it adds less evidence than humans do. Moreover, its
capabilities generalize well to other domains, such as instructional texts. | [
-0.392383337,
-0.7241170406,
0.5896517634,
0.0709289685,
-0.2472478002,
0.2013136894,
-0.3302263916,
-0.3664143085,
0.2274034768,
0.2373328805,
-0.0972425789,
-0.2175586969,
-0.4136978984,
0.2230050564,
-0.0179565549,
0.9826705456,
-0.1667558104,
-0.0860098451,
-0.7602552176,
-0.0512701124,
-0.4602459967,
-0.3441840708,
-0.8327600956,
-0.3955794275,
0.4543882906,
0.5420557261,
0.8256111741,
0.9230409861,
0.1727670282,
0.3981665969,
0.0768244341,
0.2993213832,
-0.2383369356,
0.2434208542,
-0.4469387829,
-0.6490501165,
-0.2427818924,
-0.1222870722,
0.6816051006,
0.6722212434,
-0.0698995516,
0.1347883046,
-0.1343867928,
0.5804210901,
-1.0135041475,
-0.1615505368,
-0.854883492,
0.0539701991,
-0.0981446281,
-0.2261987031,
-0.5394146442,
-0.5389521718,
0.3381767571,
-0.8889171481,
0.3158713877,
0.3373782933,
1.1403878927,
0.3217714131,
-0.1980776489,
-0.2456027269,
-0.4657682478,
0.8451645374,
-0.6840903759,
0.0760332718,
0.3819330335,
0.1931503266,
-0.200754717,
-0.7220423222,
-0.3297884464,
-0.5054157972,
-0.0231222026,
0.1262921244,
-0.7121824622,
0.3976565897,
0.162730962,
0.0551591851,
-0.581995666,
0.1905012876,
-0.3213587403,
-0.773483634,
1.0644162893,
-0.0060995352,
0.0874442831,
-0.1118906513,
-0.009233186,
-0.2789573371,
-0.5278767943,
0.1245572492,
0.6193153262,
0.1494005919,
0.3485870957,
0.3774330318,
-0.1819588095,
0.7395210862,
0.272115916,
0.059703283,
-0.1471341848,
-0.2997663617,
-0.1862281412,
0.0859567523,
0.8416163325,
0.2071854919,
0.0774867088,
0.0370945036,
-0.0230187271,
0.052918613,
0.7125788927,
-0.6571019888,
-0.0277932603,
0.3814001083,
-0.5075473785,
-0.3943814039,
-0.1420453936,
-0.7885791659,
-0.2738036811,
-0.4060949981,
0.2895847857,
-0.3921390474,
-0.0096117631,
0.2070925236,
-0.1734154671,
-0.2990288734,
0.2405094653,
-0.6958155632,
0.3432807326,
0.6259041429,
0.4407455921,
0.0127904136,
0.001691988,
-0.6176899076,
-0.0310489126,
-0.8601143956,
1.3327450752,
-0.5601499677,
-0.2370549589,
0.1315916032,
-0.3458233178,
0.0077801379,
-0.7053029537,
1.4251506329,
-0.4926049113,
0.3213284314,
-0.2763012946,
-0.8222662807,
-0.1985702217,
0.2652127147,
-0.6746205091,
0.5234859586,
-0.0501963049,
-0.4293670058,
0.5575927496,
-0.8620999455,
-0.5688239932,
0.1497170925,
-0.1053434759,
-0.54195261,
0.6140894294,
0.2620318532,
0.2343904972,
-0.5272655487,
0.2866765261,
0.1454785764,
0.0678621382,
0.2218168527,
-0.2512152791,
0.4965642691,
0.5176577568,
-0.3782579303,
0.2405178547,
-0.4206936955,
0.3011895418,
0.2316002846,
-0.5627318621,
-0.2867956758,
0.5130576491,
-0.3269272149,
-0.249133423,
0.1056132764,
-0.7972173095,
0.1003957316,
-0.8249249458,
0.4606129825,
0.7015094757,
-0.2260976732,
0.2329926193,
-0.3214072585,
0.7750602961,
-0.3005336821,
0.0305494368,
-0.0194991864,
-0.1516225636,
-0.6461873651,
-0.1526010782,
0.8067035079,
0.4598122537,
-0.6409941316,
0.123889938,
-0.2346386909,
-0.268212378,
-0.6958099008,
-0.1353473812,
0.4512740672,
0.4071853459,
0.2737852633,
-0.0147200897,
-0.5486981869,
-1.354847312,
-0.6696477532,
-0.5822312832,
0.1457072943,
0.3083344698,
0.1644029468,
-0.0224660821,
1.2225667238,
-0.6075999737,
0.1480308622,
-0.2117521614,
0.1723769754,
-0.0387197845,
0.2893862426,
0.6554511189,
-0.7156692147,
-0.5662114024,
0.0613483265,
-0.4464422464,
-0.391648829,
-0.6538002491,
-0.2957083583,
0.3735037148,
0.2057863772,
-0.5226711631,
0.2530112565,
-0.0411985479,
-0.0002799003,
0.8513094783,
-0.3114295006,
0.039956212,
-0.902290225,
-0.0682044923,
0.1260892153,
-0.3512075841,
-0.3448459804,
0.0975223556,
-0.215002045,
-0.13707003,
-0.1986065209,
0.5129335523,
-0.3461014926,
0.2904983163,
-0.4809500277,
0.1348599792,
0.2054315209,
0.2800453901,
-0.118107602,
0.6195073724,
0.3868002594,
-0.3597686291,
0.3468902707,
0.0424744077,
-0.1733362228,
0.9140697718,
-0.8374757767,
0.1241298839,
-0.236446619,
0.3662932813,
-1.0497701168,
-0.2957534492,
0.0437588766,
-0.5711065531,
0.2641872764,
0.0770715624,
-0.1318080276,
-0.401188761,
-0.4385113418,
0.2952010334,
0.1466142237,
-0.7081350088,
0.6773217916,
0.4448673725,
-0.3503268659,
-0.6462635398,
-0.2558924854,
0.5409696698,
-0.4155873954,
-0.6375085115,
0.8560240269,
0.1771887541,
-0.3542161286,
-0.0011404892,
-0.0376433432,
0.0034070273,
-0.0844237059,
-0.0947866738,
-0.0379129127,
-0.2426633537,
0.2194001228,
0.5503874421,
-0.4138364494,
0.239807263,
-0.3327476978,
0.0471392758,
-0.1064869612,
-0.3808222711,
-0.6482834816,
0.9261305332,
0.3123482764,
-0.0207372215,
0.3156373799,
0.2126843631,
-0.4300732613,
-0.2146136165,
-0.8351978064,
0.0072086384,
-0.4975704849,
0.5568003654,
-0.5357125401,
-0.6436007023,
0.0912135467,
-0.5173469186,
0.6167522073,
0.753698647,
0.3212052584,
-0.1691174656,
1.1210762262,
0.2594665885,
-0.1444495171,
0.3313964307,
-0.1387189031,
0.3882287145,
-0.432274282,
0.1264093965,
-0.829341352,
-0.0607665181,
-0.4141343236,
-0.2487247288,
0.2767219245,
0.2031100392,
-0.3052596748,
0.3681128621,
-0.8837999105,
0.6156600118,
0.5972163677,
-0.1616470218,
0.0986735821,
0.4381041527,
-0.2344811559,
-0.3307760656,
-0.907513082,
-0.8071600199,
0.9955374599,
0.4533217847,
0.3494238853,
0.0607056208,
0.7598668337,
0.664910078,
0.4061875045,
-0.8709955215,
0.6018599868,
-0.0683273375,
-0.5041333437,
-0.0619042218,
-0.4166769981,
-1.2539103031,
0.5367206931,
-0.4309916198,
-0.5785394311,
0.1335764676,
0.4756747782,
-0.5449000597,
0.1857330948,
-0.6475462914,
0.8837037683,
-0.3236765265,
-0.4062415063,
-0.7348565459,
-0.6689734459,
-0.0741254762,
0.0979791954,
0.010077158,
0.1733259857,
0.0722650662,
0.9095224738,
-0.6335707903,
0.5056279898,
-0.2592855096,
-0.0362132601,
0.6130552292,
-0.0154264038,
0.5415773392,
-0.1706723273,
-0.3710827231,
-0.160851419,
0.2808943689,
-0.4469658136,
-0.6339591146,
0.1777235419,
-0.6514966488,
-0.8156579733,
-0.2430856526,
-0.1229364946,
-0.1395677775,
0.0130882487,
0.3612920642,
0.300067246,
-0.5201981664,
0.1144022942,
0.2426077127,
-0.5436409116,
0.3325055242,
0.1256954521,
0.5291397572,
-0.7880823016,
1.3503841162,
-0.1579339206,
0.2241311967,
0.1270021498,
0.7306444645,
-0.6899329424,
-0.7209843993,
-0.6067868471,
0.2548797429,
-0.7501196861,
-0.4912193716,
-0.6745797396,
0.1941455454,
-0.3092946708,
-0.4762912691,
-0.5219617486,
-0.5624217987,
-0.056320563,
-0.0128216455,
-0.1525878906,
0.3556028306,
-0.2647882104,
0.2748294175,
-0.4328486323,
0.2138459235,
0.2535367012,
0.0736214295,
-0.1749223322,
-0.2323941588,
-0.2299085557,
0.1325175762,
-0.9614091516,
-0.6056750417,
0.2894736826,
0.4179347456,
0.8538088202,
0.5414670706,
0.3172907233,
0.7125669718,
-0.4913682938,
0.742467463,
0.2773533463,
-0.8980439305,
0.6877627969,
-0.1216307133,
-0.3508547843,
0.8161286116,
0.1892742068,
-0.2257876992,
-0.2080990374,
-0.7609508038,
-0.9278401732,
0.3542792499,
0.0000487789,
0.2456054688,
-0.088165924,
0.6306865811,
0.0193835292,
0.0207015853,
-0.432738632,
0.0694586486,
-0.1436136961,
-0.1688526869,
0.3300580382,
-0.3449471891,
-0.3616369367,
-0.2091495842,
0.609328866,
-0.4057707787,
0.3194051087,
0.3144634664,
0.0188158546,
-0.1479194611,
0.3609937727,
0.9095093012,
0.6360142231,
0.3012791872,
-0.1461251229,
0.2489077151,
-0.2674928904,
0.2624025941,
0.070148237,
-0.1284841001,
0.2641720176,
0.5212283731,
0.7973046899,
-0.2825937569,
-0.7559844851,
0.2482831925,
0.0920669064,
-0.3984948099,
-0.1937324256,
0.0823581442,
-0.1030881479,
0.1827062964,
0.3138151169,
0.0192852989,
0.2554490268,
-0.2713095248,
0.052037403,
0.6493269801,
0.1552894861,
0.003243915,
0.7519776225,
0.3504474163,
-0.7183122039,
0.3353351057,
-0.0132694915,
-0.5988336802,
0.715364933,
0.6209762096,
0.8594203591,
-0.118002288,
0.3935297132,
0.6387914419,
0.0402545035,
-0.0679122433,
-0.1834376305,
-0.0321023278,
-0.668241322,
-0.626578927,
-0.3757217228,
-0.714918077,
-0.3014196455,
-0.4673055708,
0.0611129366,
-0.4347851276,
-0.4506693184,
0.2523311079,
0.3244479597,
-0.2112742513,
0.1648377329,
-0.027609475,
0.5889894962,
-0.6691391468,
0.2039476037,
0.6592770815,
-0.1320445687,
-0.641859591,
-0.0730903968,
-0.1284727901,
-0.3573072553,
0.5755828023,
-0.2262074351,
-0.3838672638,
-0.2356102318,
-0.7694131136,
-0.5462968349,
0.4500184953,
0.9879274964,
-0.2578074336,
0.2633146346,
0.1826184988,
0.5390434265,
-0.5782837868,
0.140709132,
0.3046366274,
0.6239558458,
0.0045055929,
-0.7852429152,
0.0684721619,
-0.1144461632,
0.1635845602,
-0.1098744422,
-0.422457397,
0.2627271712,
-0.4200598896,
-0.2724299133,
0.0229091421,
0.8957993984,
0.377640903,
0.2816180885,
0.6405504346,
0.4868444204,
0.8266888261,
0.1559639424,
1.2792615891,
-0.0541863553,
0.1528729796,
0.995459199,
-0.0432675518,
0.7808353305,
0.3283087015,
-0.4047224224,
0.5396212339,
1.1390647888,
0.1249713451,
0.1542598307,
0.8276679516,
-0.2833292782,
-0.4161912799,
-0.322792232,
-0.1229379922,
0.3966883421,
0.3773781061,
-0.2136680484,
-0.1757595837,
-0.290053606,
0.2099906057,
0.4181266427,
0.0614086166,
0.764867425,
-0.2734442949,
-1.2901979685,
0.9016817212,
0.3863992691,
0.5021509528,
-0.1606178731,
-0.1713837087,
-0.1106836647,
0.0163395926,
-0.3397612572,
-0.3693641424,
0.4278205633,
0.033111088,
-0.1769479513,
-0.1954826266,
0.7003819942,
-0.2396090925,
-0.4498546422,
-0.0619975068,
0.2240120322,
0.2867245376,
-0.0470307246,
-0.9650471807,
-0.0679730177,
0.0598808452,
-0.2603805065,
0.0469549522,
0.1621908545,
-0.3510808051,
0.6600469947,
0.7466158271,
0.3184894919,
-0.3099966347,
0.0025261492,
0.8866789937,
-0.3719501495,
-0.4255715907,
-0.8991913199,
0.4895768464,
-0.4736260176,
-0.2188066691,
0.1939155608,
0.6803185344,
0.3847475946,
0.2877953649,
0.8196142912,
0.0215448514,
0.4019522071,
-0.190902248,
0.5623142719,
-0.5919317603,
-0.1031962633,
-0.5826435685,
-0.8561787009,
-0.4248565435,
1.0294433832,
-0.2063916624,
-0.23109743,
0.6640511155,
0.641782701,
0.0889895409,
0.1193410456,
0.1044262275,
-0.1151653454,
0.6925891638,
0.6750922203,
0.8139457703,
-0.3515530229,
0.4734054208,
0.183642745,
-0.2503060102,
-0.1615118086,
-1.174110055,
-0.5010688901,
-0.4145382643,
-0.7970220447,
-0.4429874718,
-0.0351858512,
0.9495514631,
0.9514641166,
-0.6661401987,
-0.1807947308,
-0.0169344842,
0.2149756849,
-0.2776024342,
-0.1998708695,
0.6332477927,
-0.6211749315,
-0.5092915297,
0.5433741808,
0.002335764,
-0.4318772256,
-0.064748764,
-0.1064976081,
-0.0939365476,
0.4813057482,
0.6852077246,
0.6320284009,
-0.857480526,
-0.4378260374,
-0.233531639,
0.1303389966,
0.221674934,
1.0267915726,
-0.6238826513,
0.642983377,
0.3380282521,
1.2465703487,
0.2787622213,
0.4093054533,
0.8712352514,
-0.4641696513,
-0.1285288632,
0.4649741352,
0.3989978433,
0.2421968132,
-0.3441514373,
0.4577920735,
0.0712700412,
-0.6111731529,
-0.8866938949,
0.0888163745,
-0.8923534751,
-0.3700479269,
1.014033556,
-0.343873173,
-0.0511382893,
-0.1509346515,
-0.5910350084,
0.0237835124,
-0.3170868754,
0.8593600988,
0.913643837,
-0.5011060834,
0.1193062589,
-0.5017015934,
0.5722171664,
0.8749786019,
-0.8666914105,
0.2486873865,
0.8088254929,
0.2357246429,
0.5163412094,
0.5247517824,
-0.037578024,
0.307734251,
0.0112445075,
-0.068841815,
0.1363564581,
-0.2106158733,
-0.1407691687,
0.5557365417,
0.1371826231,
-0.4040967822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08911v1 | AdaTranS: Adapting with Boundary-based Shrinking for End-to-End Speech Translation | 2022-12-17T16:14:30 | 2022-12-17T16:14:30 | Xingshan Zeng, Liangyou Li, Qun Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | To alleviate the data scarcity problem in End-to-end speech translation (ST),
pre-training on data for speech recognition and machine translation is
considered as an important technique. However, the modality gap between speech
and text prevents the ST model from efficiently inheriting knowledge from the
pre-trained models. In this work, we propose AdaTranS for end-to-end ST. It
adapts the speech features with a new shrinking mechanism to mitigate the
length mismatch between speech and text features by predicting word boundaries.
Experiments on the MUST-C dataset demonstrate that AdaTranS achieves better
performance than the other shrinking-based methods, with higher inference speed
and lower memory usage. Further experiments also show that AdaTranS can be
equipped with additional alignment losses to further improve performance. | [
-0.5879307389,
-0.7149512172,
0.4259826839,
-0.0500489995,
-0.5394409895,
-0.0670560524,
-0.2594583035,
-0.5673741698,
0.3715756834,
0.4570662081,
-0.8420810103,
-0.3669172823,
-0.7246500254,
0.0850382373,
-0.2952744663,
0.8773604631,
-0.2051440179,
0.057771612,
-0.3349593282,
-0.3713727593,
-0.4645781219,
-0.4014004469,
-0.7097574472,
0.0140810786,
0.1979021877,
0.3454740644,
0.7266112566,
1.0865007639,
0.4787353873,
0.2266148627,
-0.5511383414,
0.1337274611,
-0.4553998411,
0.1178625375,
-0.1399787664,
-0.3785814345,
-0.5360859036,
-0.3245320618,
0.7524399161,
0.6107539535,
-0.2902826667,
0.2205913216,
-0.0816343352,
0.6266134381,
-0.4767534435,
-0.3879744411,
-0.5524341464,
0.0328762084,
-0.3308439553,
-0.1386395842,
-0.2489010841,
-0.2102227807,
0.2583261132,
-0.5735501051,
0.1691075265,
0.2005864084,
0.9259281754,
0.7056574821,
-0.364599973,
-0.0810037479,
-0.6978511214,
0.5683392286,
-0.7476584315,
0.8035341501,
0.2428785414,
0.3356077075,
-0.1079864278,
-0.5727956891,
-0.5244207978,
0.0933711827,
0.2382528037,
0.0573924519,
-0.3498138487,
0.0522470847,
0.1039656624,
0.3294094503,
-0.7548052073,
0.2006268352,
-0.5208807588,
-0.43996346,
0.4503284991,
0.0989286602,
0.2929650545,
0.259896934,
-0.4676008523,
-0.0381131247,
-0.8123817444,
0.0410353318,
0.2876913548,
0.2937881052,
-0.238379851,
0.1500523984,
0.1491330862,
0.9137147665,
-0.1693681777,
0.0612173304,
0.5821047425,
-0.0835939497,
-0.2925157547,
0.1468360871,
0.5050481558,
0.3225631416,
0.1087722257,
-0.1020019501,
-0.1012573689,
-0.0031099657,
-0.2454285771,
-0.7480108738,
0.0493324362,
-0.1093470305,
-0.3453888297,
0.3800669014,
-0.3239862919,
-0.4981179535,
0.0494705327,
-0.5137388706,
0.2285048813,
-0.4309536815,
-0.0499052443,
0.0935973153,
0.0467119627,
0.4519720972,
0.3472647965,
-0.6484154463,
0.6840097904,
0.1949341595,
1.4360268116,
-0.4324434996,
-0.2112383842,
-0.7720345855,
0.1609342247,
-0.4839000404,
0.8970730901,
-0.4925628603,
-0.3667680621,
-0.3046055138,
0.0359876975,
-0.2649725974,
-0.4979038239,
0.8142929077,
-0.3535310626,
0.1600859463,
-0.0147891408,
-0.5854900479,
-0.2243736237,
-0.2235115916,
-0.7003576756,
0.5081177354,
0.0479131825,
-0.478730768,
0.1138650626,
-0.5973798037,
-0.7302638888,
-0.1514517218,
0.3088308871,
-0.7573711276,
0.2304411978,
0.3936046064,
0.0044430331,
-0.400316447,
-0.1462180465,
-0.12744537,
-0.1323355138,
0.3154788017,
-0.4601869583,
0.6722711325,
0.4875366688,
0.1156996712,
0.3333425224,
-0.5269829035,
-0.0462572053,
-0.0433396399,
-0.1740323305,
-0.4089424312,
-0.093527399,
0.20604451,
0.3090300262,
0.0307914075,
-0.5477264524,
-0.0602662303,
-0.6859461069,
0.583681047,
0.8277224898,
-0.1223682612,
0.5594481826,
-0.417805016,
0.6510680914,
-0.1291487068,
0.1885503232,
-0.1170205474,
-0.3149656355,
-0.7116861939,
-0.3066889644,
0.5772369504,
0.6925039887,
-0.4188518822,
0.4280866683,
-0.5485204458,
-0.0857205018,
-0.8477338552,
-0.056846302,
0.3303270042,
0.5904382467,
0.5340948701,
-0.6323977709,
-0.6200665236,
-0.7851214409,
-0.1213594526,
0.0901421458,
-0.2473928183,
0.1813373119,
0.1883020848,
-0.2823176086,
0.7658314705,
-0.3510119319,
-0.5077183247,
-0.1769448966,
-0.3751520514,
-0.0174657404,
0.3927397132,
0.3835210502,
-0.9041237831,
-0.4425620139,
-0.0173039362,
0.0633822307,
-0.3171011806,
-0.1861702204,
-0.1290727556,
0.1377141178,
0.5385283232,
-0.36248523,
0.6798008084,
0.6605010033,
-0.4206609428,
0.2510164678,
-0.1666282713,
-0.0364551805,
-1.161542058,
-0.0161807314,
-0.0417906344,
-0.5366249084,
-0.8119987845,
-0.5563215613,
-0.0096975658,
-0.1265182197,
-0.5620968342,
0.395442009,
-0.6127424836,
-0.2525997758,
-0.3345622718,
0.2389965504,
-0.040935874,
0.4058020711,
0.2139404118,
0.8704119325,
0.689722538,
-0.8337579966,
0.3099394739,
0.8503605127,
0.0462444797,
0.3819763362,
-0.4013931751,
0.1832783669,
-0.243431583,
0.2119794488,
-0.9283203483,
0.1133438796,
0.2684067488,
-0.7347412109,
0.4600762427,
-0.219924435,
-0.0305197854,
-0.1055002809,
-0.2647343576,
0.4428095222,
0.6040767431,
-0.426966995,
0.362519592,
0.494938314,
-0.6515833139,
-0.1413402706,
-0.8317572474,
0.5861406922,
-0.3042367101,
-0.5463293195,
0.5204475522,
-0.4230746329,
0.1804361939,
-0.0664398149,
-0.3033051789,
-0.1716603488,
-0.1063067839,
0.0264245328,
0.0294721257,
-0.1116370931,
0.0752255246,
0.3184048235,
-0.2388155758,
-0.075116694,
-0.4996037185,
0.3356973827,
0.0003878902,
-0.2269963026,
-0.3029273748,
0.4882534742,
0.6759630442,
-0.5713014007,
0.660102427,
0.4148092568,
-0.3450807333,
-0.2132052481,
-0.3610325754,
0.0524849482,
-0.400438875,
0.6185740232,
-0.4546253383,
-0.8780447245,
0.5820249319,
-0.4191327989,
-0.0689802542,
0.4156179428,
0.3805549443,
0.1258267164,
0.7547793388,
0.8871039748,
-0.0310263839,
0.4845435917,
-0.0910810009,
0.0544578508,
-1.2971434593,
-0.1686743051,
-0.3906335533,
-0.4465509057,
-0.2204720825,
-0.492069006,
0.1437236369,
-0.1577641219,
-0.0134003153,
0.5104706287,
-0.5561065078,
0.3526210785,
0.2760719955,
0.0386691876,
-0.038523294,
0.0972133428,
0.2252293229,
-0.1809093058,
-0.7017264962,
-0.0496912301,
0.8530540466,
0.4223672748,
0.7071992755,
0.3657009304,
0.3671580553,
0.2784680128,
0.0991101563,
-0.8023834229,
0.3774122894,
-0.3037861288,
-0.2421535254,
-0.7082212567,
-0.6449281573,
-0.7837708592,
0.1900987774,
0.1195994839,
-0.5512794852,
0.2815580368,
-0.0131628802,
-0.1707479805,
0.374356091,
-0.5561426282,
0.6978068948,
-0.3581504822,
-0.2112659812,
0.0151756601,
-0.9719579816,
-0.1537167579,
-0.0851777568,
0.3442202806,
-0.1839116067,
-0.3740133643,
1.0847862959,
-0.6400204301,
0.5275527239,
-0.1085250303,
-0.1373805553,
0.3670611978,
0.0998602659,
0.5611101985,
-0.317410171,
0.2142468393,
0.1814645678,
-0.2867668271,
-0.2183227539,
-0.3872151673,
0.3328862488,
-0.4196454883,
-0.4674398899,
-0.2031730413,
-0.549377203,
-0.2169320732,
0.1354577392,
0.5185065269,
0.3352639079,
-0.1445583999,
0.0076664626,
0.8652101755,
-0.0005819253,
0.5354778767,
0.4888516665,
0.1409989595,
-0.6630954146,
0.7413986325,
0.243840158,
0.3605748117,
0.3679312766,
0.2225489169,
-0.6845104098,
-0.914432466,
-0.8591477871,
0.1003512293,
-0.4985061288,
-0.377720952,
-0.3600171208,
-0.3933734596,
-0.6464082599,
-0.2466587871,
-0.3902306855,
-0.5447035432,
-0.3204403818,
-0.2276275307,
0.6645083427,
0.2375530601,
-0.3892789185,
0.6693477035,
-0.6278172135,
0.3272050023,
0.0420327224,
0.5492205024,
-0.3600187302,
-1.5432311296,
-0.5626758337,
-0.1486487538,
-0.0354200788,
-1.0169869661,
0.5807353258,
0.8657591343,
0.3588529229,
0.2838685513,
-0.0370879658,
0.8475419879,
-0.8152756095,
0.3682083189,
0.4888606668,
-1.1637493372,
0.4956190586,
-0.1040524468,
0.4325633645,
0.2209903896,
0.2231388986,
-0.7617625594,
-0.1357432455,
-0.2870724201,
-1.2206412554,
0.7121382356,
0.4201154411,
0.0021772569,
0.5225484967,
0.371578306,
0.1525881588,
0.0262531843,
-0.52578336,
-0.4047697186,
-0.2569693625,
-0.2319053113,
-0.1236223951,
-0.2287317812,
0.1052311212,
-0.1181341261,
0.6695194244,
-0.0016710071,
0.1201568246,
0.4585852921,
-0.4504038692,
-0.2869090438,
0.4764041901,
0.766941309,
0.6168814898,
0.0616369136,
-0.0610467829,
0.7353034616,
-0.5554353595,
0.3288265169,
0.2835683525,
-0.0381243527,
0.1219515577,
0.3288980424,
1.1194312572,
-0.3335829079,
-0.5981459618,
0.4499324858,
-0.0051281303,
-0.3187792003,
-0.2686325908,
-0.3060529232,
0.0777360946,
0.0329035074,
0.2397363633,
0.3492104113,
0.2974886,
-0.1889881045,
0.6331136823,
0.0036754946,
-0.7369539142,
-0.3966443539,
0.8579692245,
0.1972405463,
-0.3725045621,
0.2572117746,
0.0509878248,
-0.5447759032,
0.4040796757,
0.6398457289,
1.0092540979,
-0.993499279,
-0.1254084557,
0.0772867277,
0.4314243495,
0.1757420897,
0.057773374,
-0.150118202,
-0.2483411878,
-0.8168364763,
-0.5423132181,
-0.1913320571,
0.0298204608,
-0.6239609122,
0.1860532612,
-0.3074076474,
-0.2795929313,
-0.2785319984,
-0.4873052537,
-0.4595380127,
0.3574981689,
0.4035063088,
0.9045239091,
-0.9602298737,
0.6032324433,
0.6732832193,
-0.0905793756,
-0.2676683962,
-0.119881317,
-0.0396762379,
-0.5045645237,
0.262336731,
-0.0223042183,
-0.3020907044,
0.0048296284,
-0.4331889749,
-1.200914979,
0.7007732987,
0.6556196809,
-0.8988472223,
-0.0055963965,
0.1925961822,
0.4245865047,
-0.3985979259,
-0.0137111722,
0.4906822741,
0.2945103943,
0.2557789385,
-1.1653596163,
0.1190879419,
-0.1957350224,
0.192751348,
0.4508521855,
-0.6256073713,
0.7233694196,
-0.1950526088,
-0.3730463386,
0.0308690127,
0.8510186672,
-0.2200412303,
0.3504460454,
0.6619509459,
0.6797141433,
0.5006549954,
0.0647145957,
0.2739693522,
0.0035681161,
0.1430509239,
1.1219215393,
-0.2132224888,
0.7333284616,
0.4363168776,
-0.1330570728,
0.3529834449,
0.7796503305,
0.227452442,
0.720287323,
0.6634553671,
-0.0716890991,
-0.2407253087,
-0.1288384795,
-0.3770880401,
0.2750018537,
0.6641477346,
-0.0012492434,
-0.1733304709,
0.3508038223,
-0.1125719547,
0.1800155193,
-0.3570399582,
0.9327201247,
0.268588841,
-0.1620995104,
0.8394594789,
-0.0079373084,
0.540253818,
-0.6655326486,
-0.0148323905,
-0.2069365233,
-0.0880138651,
-0.1396235526,
-0.4907111228,
0.4568169713,
-0.0047890558,
-0.0713524595,
-0.2176000625,
0.6347780228,
-0.5940992236,
-0.2249842286,
0.3336380124,
0.5005275607,
0.2985278964,
0.0351513736,
-0.6131416559,
0.0872556046,
0.2484203279,
-0.2391819358,
0.1137520447,
0.5961731076,
-0.1202594712,
0.856756866,
0.6209182143,
0.3901801705,
0.1617055088,
0.0152937295,
0.8578708768,
-0.6709484458,
-0.9182702899,
-0.7117239237,
0.4564323425,
0.0617380925,
-0.2346397638,
0.5027009845,
0.8359305263,
0.7367982268,
0.2516028881,
0.9640167952,
0.1619523466,
0.7382905483,
-0.6430200338,
0.5609179139,
-0.5011147261,
0.299942404,
-0.0891029537,
-0.9465200901,
-0.3182752728,
0.3932166696,
-0.1275569052,
-0.0688781142,
0.56962502,
0.5041187406,
-0.1586354971,
-0.4238524139,
0.4739243984,
0.0095877508,
0.2716065645,
0.8367868662,
0.564347446,
-0.4941641688,
1.0103156567,
0.1972370595,
-0.4156399071,
-0.190830335,
-0.3547048867,
-0.6389347315,
-0.8592423797,
-0.3839468658,
-0.1657845527,
0.3673585951,
0.490223974,
0.7967234254,
-0.6661169529,
-0.1068682075,
-0.0734631047,
-0.0340118632,
-0.2212371379,
-0.0830332339,
0.7570548654,
-0.133395344,
-0.5406563282,
0.5165085793,
0.2518754303,
0.5218863487,
0.246639207,
-0.3732650578,
-0.0228169169,
0.0630672425,
0.2869178951,
0.5011142492,
-0.5855570436,
-0.1704527438,
0.054222323,
0.3319217563,
0.2898989618,
0.8214424849,
-0.7645725608,
0.4381599128,
0.3227209151,
0.8277904391,
0.6461836696,
0.0625068694,
0.7059128881,
-0.7418798208,
0.3106799722,
0.3102932572,
0.3250945807,
0.4947424233,
-0.1710924953,
0.2707737982,
0.1865962744,
-0.3603612185,
-0.7445138693,
0.4403028786,
-0.7148596644,
-0.3063431084,
0.9871525764,
-0.0050117322,
-0.4752389193,
-0.1332483441,
-0.1844130009,
0.6225578189,
-0.3709745109,
0.4163492322,
0.3494691849,
-0.0856969729,
-0.337625891,
-0.434209317,
0.6078769565,
0.5421795845,
-0.6234074235,
0.4099985957,
0.4685865939,
0.1950607449,
-0.0667691827,
0.4233238697,
-0.0675373003,
0.3108263314,
-0.0472540893,
0.2210143358,
-0.1994589567,
-0.3679650426,
-0.6162874103,
-0.4225490391,
-0.0288666505,
-0.6097369194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08909v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08909v2 | Controlling Styles in Neural Machine Translation with Activation Prompt | 2022-12-17T16:05:50 | 2023-05-29T02:59:07 | Yifan Wang, Zewei Sun, Shanbo Cheng, Weiguo Zheng, Mingxuan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Controlling styles in neural machine translation (NMT) has attracted wide
attention, as it is crucial for enhancing user experience. Earlier studies on
this topic typically concentrate on regulating the level of formality and
achieve some progress in this area. However, they still encounter two major
challenges. The first is the difficulty in style evaluation. The style
comprises various aspects such as lexis, syntax, and others that provide
abundant information. Nevertheless, only formality has been thoroughly
investigated. The second challenge involves excessive dependence on incremental
adjustments, particularly when new styles are necessary. To address both
challenges, this paper presents a new benchmark and approach. A multiway
stylized machine translation (MSMT) benchmark is introduced, incorporating
diverse categories of styles across four linguistic domains. Then, we propose a
method named style activation prompt (StyleAP) by retrieving prompts from
stylized monolingual corpus, which does not require extra fine-tuning.
Experiments show that StyleAP could effectively control the style of
translation and achieve remarkable performance. | [
-0.2168708444,
-0.6233090162,
0.2927915752,
0.7683030367,
-0.4176062047,
0.2503238916,
-0.6026400924,
0.0350432545,
0.3189189434,
0.2048742771,
-0.7905037403,
-0.5389023423,
-0.5833117366,
0.6498374939,
0.154266566,
0.7439920902,
-0.3944829404,
0.0126837604,
0.1211977825,
-0.4388820827,
-1.0157854557,
-0.6378931999,
-0.9600462914,
-0.1835742444,
0.6228441,
0.285567075,
0.6120880246,
0.4797610044,
0.4340797663,
0.4122696221,
-0.0876044184,
0.5242357254,
0.1015110984,
0.7172347307,
0.1224161983,
-0.3505704701,
-0.4744613469,
-0.0980109274,
0.7439615726,
0.4333035052,
0.0707640424,
0.0069564003,
0.1814078689,
0.6948906779,
-0.3344367146,
0.1596604139,
-0.572706759,
0.1658652723,
-0.1872413605,
-0.7763876915,
-0.6444808245,
-0.2419959009,
-0.1248417497,
-0.6054614186,
-0.3225285411,
0.0853130668,
0.8291190267,
0.3020757139,
-0.6091727018,
-0.1499186903,
-0.4863435626,
0.7485025525,
-0.4745996594,
0.483220011,
0.1880643666,
0.5076486468,
-0.0263355169,
-0.6770597696,
-0.1990585029,
-0.2813114822,
-0.1767833382,
0.0518088751,
-0.1609583944,
-0.2603602707,
0.3571856022,
-0.2407619506,
-0.5004923344,
-0.083640404,
-0.1887127161,
-0.2441054732,
0.129515931,
0.0759372264,
0.3810347319,
-0.2949962914,
-0.7457675934,
-0.276879102,
-0.4900797606,
0.0727554038,
0.1647970378,
0.5879092813,
-0.0203362815,
0.2607832253,
-0.2968542576,
0.268801719,
-0.044738356,
-0.031140402,
0.5517523289,
-0.5342486501,
-0.0598951243,
0.0989144593,
0.8832296133,
0.4537234008,
0.1442229301,
-0.188810125,
-0.534750998,
-0.4093252718,
0.5119882822,
-0.8350112438,
0.3233031929,
0.1700531989,
-0.2869628668,
-0.0391775705,
-0.3300897479,
-0.8168926239,
-0.4023444653,
-0.5578964353,
0.5675466657,
-0.8096089959,
-0.2254188359,
-0.1641160101,
-0.0263831504,
0.3287258446,
0.4771180451,
-0.8613785505,
0.1234058291,
0.4060708284,
1.2525023222,
-0.3326920271,
-0.3286884725,
-0.3145317137,
-0.4150022864,
-0.5630939007,
0.4659979939,
-0.3047055602,
-0.1205979437,
0.0038136162,
-0.0382414833,
-0.3436658978,
-0.2364904135,
0.4513911307,
-0.7369756699,
-0.0075147087,
-0.4660930037,
-0.0326238014,
-0.1445460021,
0.3350494206,
-0.2450697273,
1.0932246447,
0.0520358421,
-0.3682767749,
0.3611069918,
-0.7206581235,
-0.5993517041,
-0.0554242283,
-0.1361477077,
-0.3150390089,
0.1386198699,
0.1402942985,
0.24338229,
-0.0487495027,
0.3831921518,
0.0973027498,
-0.2491116524,
0.3741841614,
-0.5334007144,
0.6625249386,
0.3367573917,
-0.4419293404,
0.5656191111,
-0.7781255245,
0.1997119486,
0.165580079,
-0.0697475597,
-0.3205365539,
-0.5092295408,
0.0270393398,
0.5703349113,
0.2393164784,
-0.113681592,
0.4084477723,
0.1194584742,
0.5102433562,
1.0333018303,
0.0415615812,
0.307525456,
-0.101075843,
0.7071028948,
-0.0447713695,
0.0652371719,
-0.4157694578,
-0.4028999209,
-0.6169076562,
-0.3063289821,
0.3966499567,
0.4678767025,
-1.112377286,
0.3256652355,
-0.1545525342,
-0.3931032121,
-0.5262747407,
0.0333267562,
0.4438037872,
0.4496391714,
0.7812170386,
-0.2744284868,
-0.3227371275,
-0.7954044342,
-0.3416065574,
0.3028661013,
-0.0317294076,
0.1696893424,
0.3677664697,
0.0889185891,
0.5821154714,
0.0088520339,
0.0267215539,
-0.1219277605,
0.5965995789,
0.3136846423,
0.8425421715,
0.4927726686,
-0.7390955091,
-0.4351519346,
-0.0389951319,
-0.6317874193,
-0.4107747972,
-0.5675678253,
-0.3342246115,
0.0515600331,
0.6704748273,
-0.3254525363,
0.131666407,
0.2764472663,
-0.3126517534,
0.6564128399,
-0.2159800231,
0.5728474259,
-0.9655843973,
0.3698276877,
-0.0856950358,
-0.0236120448,
-0.7850025296,
0.0516640097,
0.55519104,
-0.0713959634,
-0.5562976599,
0.5616298914,
-0.4849124253,
0.2292771786,
0.009591273,
-0.1280768961,
0.3220492303,
0.9081299305,
-0.0188103206,
0.9015957713,
0.3417046964,
-0.5226834416,
-0.0179641452,
0.0204936042,
-0.0754162744,
0.7574782372,
-0.7943804264,
0.5563723445,
-0.0603310987,
0.2033084035,
-1.31052351,
0.0661906376,
0.3285658956,
-0.2905160189,
0.7532504797,
-0.2465829849,
-0.7419931293,
0.1785112321,
-0.3265869617,
0.3158749342,
0.2947247326,
-0.2804895639,
0.6358880401,
-0.338020891,
-0.2886689007,
-0.5851992369,
-0.4646648765,
0.3215625584,
-0.3208049536,
-0.461640358,
0.337844044,
-0.2076920122,
0.0134711694,
-0.6651034951,
-0.4313769042,
0.0676818341,
0.3782308102,
0.0763100162,
0.3990898728,
-0.4040672481,
-0.0351753868,
0.4782299995,
-0.2191680819,
0.0124921715,
-0.3067087233,
0.8446579576,
-0.1303251833,
-0.1122536585,
-0.7285277843,
0.3500120938,
0.755815506,
-0.613645196,
0.5618050694,
0.6845335364,
-0.0576721616,
-0.0724499375,
-0.1935618818,
-0.3999940455,
-0.5343193412,
0.148125276,
-0.8037279248,
-0.3630948961,
0.4359281957,
-0.2857719362,
0.1227837652,
0.2901101708,
0.4309588373,
0.1149345413,
1.069756031,
0.3298194706,
0.3630971611,
0.7891340256,
0.0727835894,
-0.3469395936,
-0.9517431259,
-0.0700959787,
-0.709253788,
-0.7199873924,
-0.5579398274,
-0.1770023704,
0.474062562,
0.2559953034,
-0.1917163432,
0.649233222,
-0.4886122048,
0.1858564317,
0.7105613947,
0.0550464094,
0.1955922842,
-0.0376961268,
-0.5181293488,
-0.2448058873,
-0.4228826761,
-0.5002271533,
0.9852697849,
0.2729458809,
0.3602794111,
0.2590400279,
0.5942897797,
0.1171440557,
0.1370538175,
-0.7066289783,
0.4386173487,
0.0825242251,
-0.2855437994,
-0.046413444,
-0.4892664552,
-0.7622700334,
0.4540861845,
-0.1872663647,
-0.6797100306,
0.2963701487,
0.1286558807,
-0.3526255488,
-0.1968011409,
-0.6792423725,
1.0191242695,
-0.1994734704,
-0.3630512059,
0.2855064571,
-1.0125479698,
-0.1059571579,
0.0338720083,
0.0345294587,
-0.1042301655,
-0.3481939733,
0.5686540604,
-0.106111072,
0.6149396896,
0.0308537409,
0.0153887589,
-0.1353608966,
0.3200381994,
0.5375455022,
-0.1024441347,
-0.1628673226,
0.2815296054,
-0.0515138283,
-0.3694626093,
-0.8530215025,
0.4443046451,
-0.4606120288,
-0.1950252205,
-0.3673277199,
-0.5739082694,
-0.5931161642,
0.5754758716,
0.3782101572,
0.685863018,
0.0577093177,
0.1002415866,
0.5230454206,
-0.175240159,
0.3708256185,
0.3301211596,
-0.2438518107,
-0.5572575331,
0.7820806503,
0.2706522942,
0.5863845944,
0.3173390329,
0.3531400561,
-0.4487720132,
-0.5505139232,
-1.0824432373,
-0.1114080176,
-0.7509391308,
-0.1372553706,
-0.722551465,
0.07086882,
-0.5352313519,
-0.1604120582,
-0.4026497006,
-0.5482134223,
-0.0558276027,
0.3689484,
0.3404139876,
0.3090959489,
0.340652436,
0.3683339357,
-0.5003054738,
0.2272028774,
-0.0481881872,
0.2707936168,
-0.2671374083,
-0.7694254518,
0.0525595844,
-0.4098364115,
-0.3172808588,
-0.9364521503,
0.2432963252,
-0.0340784825,
0.2062295675,
0.2635931671,
-0.0362801589,
0.4828575552,
-0.837901473,
0.6395106316,
0.0409214087,
-0.8237673044,
0.4933690429,
-0.3286641836,
0.5450622439,
0.7419354916,
0.5575205684,
-1.0599974394,
-0.2803311348,
-0.4835700095,
-0.9053884745,
0.5843495131,
0.2274239063,
0.2879638076,
-0.0231429655,
0.196422413,
0.0816491395,
0.5692642927,
-0.1740423441,
-0.5581918359,
-0.4070088267,
0.0868479759,
0.1658066213,
0.0121100917,
-0.1289302558,
-0.0777106732,
0.5577581525,
-0.3781578541,
0.2247304618,
0.0836349055,
0.0053098779,
0.0919336751,
0.6469100714,
0.9997444749,
0.5821071863,
-0.1620324105,
0.3085996807,
0.0740003958,
-0.2435990274,
0.0101719499,
0.0010000984,
-0.495259732,
0.2921571732,
0.2100480944,
0.9164427519,
0.3173397779,
-0.1362193823,
0.2000838667,
-0.1515639573,
0.120485045,
0.3017376959,
-0.1256825477,
-0.2717326581,
-0.032743156,
0.2266036123,
0.6465450525,
0.0550065115,
-0.4665319622,
0.1373091787,
0.3227282763,
-0.4802537858,
-0.3567523956,
0.5537555814,
0.1166527197,
-0.3016781509,
0.3325285614,
-0.3989903927,
-0.6809268594,
0.4367637932,
0.7132035494,
1.0295600891,
-0.3375263214,
0.0276230779,
0.5246347189,
0.5422669053,
-0.0254807062,
0.5191046596,
-0.1345627606,
-0.4570351243,
-0.2837061286,
-0.575068891,
-0.4680608213,
-0.0879107788,
-0.6917020082,
0.4002019167,
-0.6079826355,
-0.1873656213,
0.0640002713,
-0.275154233,
-0.5506201982,
-0.0380821191,
-0.0628045052,
1.0307712555,
-0.6183456779,
0.7738342285,
0.6666307449,
-0.4763600528,
-0.5861116648,
-0.0968592092,
0.504101336,
-0.7847932577,
0.6379830241,
0.4396030903,
-0.2466230541,
0.1137649789,
-0.3831901252,
-0.5548472404,
0.8463209271,
0.3337561488,
-0.306044966,
0.1120373681,
-0.1438645571,
0.3797217906,
-0.2105556428,
0.2540429533,
0.6694327593,
0.810079217,
0.1576963514,
-0.8030982614,
0.328160584,
-0.4580506384,
0.2247466296,
0.2395733893,
-0.5461281538,
0.7674490213,
0.1517777294,
-0.4324462712,
0.1357720494,
0.7779082656,
0.0230812561,
0.0408055298,
0.4978168607,
0.0100596668,
0.6595633626,
-0.264496088,
0.9371959567,
-0.4204389155,
0.1132329106,
1.2171158791,
0.0876368359,
0.6333141327,
0.6507367492,
-0.0368640907,
0.2537097037,
0.660736382,
0.1917833984,
0.3537009954,
0.1792485416,
-0.1194036305,
-0.1263196766,
-0.3650578856,
-0.5839314461,
0.3800928593,
0.1444862485,
-0.41537112,
0.0153601458,
-0.1139616817,
0.5306575298,
0.0539253354,
-0.0921495706,
0.5999521017,
0.0196259469,
-0.881937325,
0.7979543805,
0.0380357802,
0.698720336,
-0.986849606,
-0.2170730084,
-0.3423650861,
-0.2756460309,
0.0668876246,
-0.4726292491,
0.0249320865,
-0.1692143083,
0.1017594039,
-0.7226631641,
0.4474892318,
-0.4977091849,
-0.2840297818,
-0.0616516843,
0.4189534485,
0.0382999741,
-0.2924434245,
-0.800427556,
0.3521115482,
-0.3370094895,
-0.4853507876,
0.3251518905,
0.8085643649,
-0.0937742591,
0.3310628533,
0.6289166808,
-0.0477009527,
0.2411112338,
0.1284997612,
0.6263176799,
-0.5615760088,
-0.3881435394,
-0.9860682487,
0.4887927473,
-0.1050991267,
-0.8582832813,
0.8847536445,
0.1841460019,
0.3208363056,
-0.0567343123,
0.3315857947,
-0.0588854961,
-0.2072874904,
-0.706330359,
0.8147598505,
-0.6181175113,
0.0277667064,
-0.4731067717,
-0.6537950039,
-0.4879042208,
0.3112757504,
0.002863833,
0.2137985975,
1.0257509947,
0.8041269183,
0.1001296863,
0.0533654727,
0.2868965864,
0.0112293251,
0.1047021747,
0.0999224186,
0.6827613115,
-0.2925567925,
0.3603754938,
-0.4689757228,
-0.3868821561,
-0.2701806128,
-1.0992637873,
-0.5299405456,
-0.5867856145,
-0.2888735235,
-0.6443250775,
-0.0543586016,
1.4269713163,
0.7953312397,
-0.8896720409,
-0.0763677284,
0.3716704249,
0.196943745,
-0.9011350274,
-0.1079456657,
0.4122902751,
-1.0004341602,
-0.7396708131,
0.8210889697,
0.5815119147,
-0.072447449,
-0.0856376663,
0.1047699675,
-0.1731898338,
0.0551479943,
0.5988025665,
0.1881767511,
-0.4844064713,
-0.2092744261,
0.2005008608,
-0.3738610148,
0.467010498,
1.0531307459,
-0.2423507273,
0.727833271,
0.4553766847,
0.8524782658,
0.0194498971,
-0.0730145872,
0.5235520005,
-1.1754688025,
-0.1563408822,
0.0019649575,
0.4202440679,
0.2035264224,
-0.228618145,
0.4642619491,
0.2458905876,
-0.3250010908,
-0.6049715877,
0.1380009055,
-1.0952426195,
-0.0413963757,
1.0452420712,
-0.101748772,
-0.2564911842,
0.0354353003,
-0.4663975537,
0.2713665962,
-0.6172059178,
0.4198557734,
0.6986165643,
-0.0373076908,
0.0506419986,
-0.8421946764,
0.6433015466,
0.7222982645,
-0.6551001668,
0.1459660828,
0.2010334134,
0.0287858192,
0.3726060688,
0.5980818272,
-0.0993463099,
0.3734387755,
-0.0894124582,
0.1341986209,
-0.1865352541,
-0.7820556164,
-0.6526914239,
0.2265284359,
-0.0628550351,
-0.3166477978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08902v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08902v2 | Know What I don't Know: Handling Ambiguous and Unanswerable Questions for Text-to-SQL | 2022-12-17T15:32:00 | 2023-05-19T14:27:31 | Bing Wang, Yan Gao, Zhoujun Li, Jian-Guang Lou | cs.CL | cs.CL | The task of text-to-SQL aims to convert a natural language question into its
corresponding SQL query within the context of relational tables. Existing
text-to-SQL parsers generate a "plausible" SQL query for an arbitrary user
question, thereby failing to correctly handle problematic user questions. To
formalize this problem, we conduct a preliminary study on the observed
ambiguous and unanswerable cases in text-to-SQL and summarize them into 6
feature categories. Correspondingly, we identify the causes behind each
category and propose requirements for handling ambiguous and unanswerable
questions. Following this study, we propose a simple yet effective
counterfactual example generation approach that automatically produces
ambiguous and unanswerable text-to-SQL examples. Furthermore, we propose a
weakly supervised DTE (Detecting-Then-Explaining) model for error detection,
localization, and explanation. Experimental results show that our model
achieves the best result on both real-world examples and generated examples
compared with various baselines. We release our data and code at:
\href{https://github.com/wbbeyourself/DTE}{https://github.com/wbbeyourself/DTE}. | [
-0.3824896812,
-1.379553318,
0.943379581,
-0.0197646618,
-0.3256416321,
-0.1593895108,
0.0116105778,
-0.3594034314,
-0.1320460588,
0.4722248912,
-1.0008530617,
-0.5407799482,
-0.3901399672,
0.3225312531,
-0.9579396248,
1.0937259197,
-0.0460777208,
-0.232894823,
-0.3017285466,
-0.1449717283,
-0.7931665182,
-0.3118369281,
-0.4209850729,
0.0484232381,
-0.0013892625,
0.6928402781,
0.6185829639,
0.1862964034,
0.171378091,
0.2895499766,
0.0780585632,
0.2039392143,
-0.4448952079,
0.0720807984,
-0.6793088913,
-0.4793323278,
-0.3312885463,
-0.401150912,
0.0454678275,
1.0020281076,
-0.073615633,
0.1389763653,
-0.3200424016,
0.4269309938,
-0.4218322337,
-0.2358846217,
-0.9543848038,
0.0113824382,
0.0084760692,
-0.0691464394,
-0.3808295131,
-0.2209219187,
0.1157611534,
-0.4983430803,
0.4606202841,
-0.0065466608,
0.7923504114,
0.2779193521,
-0.8428887725,
-0.2617999315,
-0.7910227776,
0.5587359667,
-0.695948422,
0.0186107811,
0.2256960571,
0.5075352192,
-0.3961788118,
-0.793202579,
-0.844391644,
0.2340997458,
-0.5438466668,
0.0396372192,
-0.4069908261,
-0.1470427215,
0.2818181217,
0.1387042254,
-0.7496839762,
-0.0659420118,
-0.1003100052,
0.1171984971,
0.5288157463,
0.1592315733,
0.310454458,
-0.199426651,
-0.2653190494,
0.3324746192,
-0.4905454814,
0.0615701638,
0.1517053246,
0.2592122853,
-0.2037657946,
0.9360897541,
-0.367629081,
0.9546259046,
0.3262033761,
0.6305983067,
-0.0471795797,
-0.3851064742,
-0.2553467751,
-0.1042016745,
0.5570967793,
0.3301337957,
0.2221053988,
-0.4645277262,
-0.2070023865,
-0.051671315,
0.4101051092,
-0.5281690359,
0.0262548607,
0.7368742824,
-0.333362788,
-0.4796083868,
-0.1665246189,
-1.0343198776,
-0.3840258718,
-0.2085259706,
0.6663838029,
-0.0583173595,
-0.3120141029,
-0.1945817173,
-0.2348497659,
-0.0395748466,
0.2727613449,
-0.7223097086,
0.4448381066,
0.2448773682,
0.2082207799,
-0.2853311002,
0.0787164196,
-0.5020908713,
0.2032256275,
-0.3930828869,
0.8918756843,
-0.3558827639,
-0.4271681309,
0.014719571,
0.2319741845,
0.0223138928,
-0.4939994514,
0.4408327043,
-0.3631176353,
0.6256012321,
-0.3139542043,
-0.5602588654,
-0.0513390936,
0.2126293182,
-0.2572291493,
1.0123518705,
0.1795180291,
-0.7528401017,
0.2588085532,
-0.7013062239,
-0.3308930993,
0.0759649873,
-0.3474077582,
-0.7040746212,
0.2788133323,
0.2870392799,
0.2838256061,
-0.3448634148,
0.595176518,
-0.1466753334,
-0.4781384468,
0.0767053515,
-0.2601699233,
0.7958438993,
0.0216683298,
-0.5574278831,
-0.0290393382,
-0.648863852,
0.2227878273,
0.5150415897,
0.0112135643,
-0.277810514,
0.0778957605,
0.0356574357,
0.1355345398,
0.2976281643,
-0.3861663938,
-0.0672390386,
-0.414699614,
0.4563261867,
0.2280467898,
0.3997268975,
0.3616987467,
-0.1543955952,
0.2161831856,
0.478279531,
0.0998449475,
-0.0008089262,
-0.3854269087,
-0.6830132604,
0.4189113379,
0.0195549298,
0.8377614021,
-1.2534737587,
0.3441114724,
0.1459494829,
-0.3900139332,
-0.1168878078,
0.0641363189,
0.3523361385,
1.0580203533,
0.7481442094,
0.3084838986,
-0.6644269228,
-1.0627515316,
-0.8183619976,
-0.3639070988,
-0.0127656441,
0.3727625012,
0.6685876846,
-0.1417650133,
1.4093170166,
-0.6039335132,
-0.1199941635,
-0.0906422958,
0.4357359707,
0.148284018,
0.5016284585,
0.6491473913,
-0.9976595044,
-0.2018428892,
-0.1364990175,
-0.9133473635,
-0.1051281393,
-0.229399547,
0.1354968995,
0.4091687202,
0.7188616395,
-0.5351474285,
0.6039774418,
0.1972990632,
-0.4548036158,
0.3506298363,
-0.2120818645,
0.2748552561,
-1.2246295214,
-0.1681501418,
-0.0076169544,
-0.0954797193,
-0.7390512228,
-0.1874939799,
0.1265675575,
-0.316062957,
-0.5306892991,
0.3355041146,
-0.2087944746,
0.0299518928,
0.2274999768,
0.2033049017,
-0.0363311656,
0.4252943397,
0.1439818889,
0.6768997312,
0.4759260416,
-0.5663203597,
0.2784246504,
0.2255267948,
-0.0525609404,
0.9667050242,
-0.8814970851,
0.1927652061,
-0.3920768797,
-0.1658916026,
-1.3361588717,
-0.2215298414,
0.1869663149,
-0.4521580637,
0.2371026278,
-0.5758232474,
-0.4546675384,
-0.3730482459,
0.1393224299,
0.2965778708,
0.4998313785,
-0.7128216624,
0.7043942213,
0.0896518007,
-0.0558394119,
-0.6478145719,
-0.9020535946,
0.2987598181,
-0.4497241378,
-0.364677459,
0.3465248644,
0.0527264662,
-0.4065562487,
0.3723393381,
-0.1946772039,
-0.6007299423,
0.0625078008,
0.2018631697,
0.1742612869,
-0.3089904487,
0.4208364785,
0.5089556575,
0.0625521988,
0.1356063485,
-0.1952115595,
0.0033040941,
-0.1695739776,
-0.3109720051,
-0.0873687789,
0.7535022497,
0.0732783899,
0.0731696934,
0.651170969,
0.4713371992,
-0.4836457372,
-0.4083723426,
-0.467800051,
-0.4329479933,
-0.4489862621,
0.5564177632,
-0.4394370914,
-0.5544480681,
0.5698222518,
-0.3551109135,
-0.0916895941,
0.4939238429,
0.3040854335,
-0.4449943006,
0.8800603151,
0.4172697365,
0.687423408,
0.0292029735,
0.2040718347,
0.4934776425,
0.102620624,
-0.3221177459,
-0.7557223439,
0.1517925262,
-0.7652696371,
-0.3713377416,
0.4642471969,
0.1246048212,
-0.1628670245,
0.5445786119,
-0.4804875255,
0.581063807,
0.105402194,
-0.0669067949,
0.4597695768,
0.028840242,
0.0523206778,
-0.1776133627,
-0.5993199348,
-0.394051224,
0.6461478472,
-0.1552055627,
0.7063592076,
0.3110687733,
0.6316024065,
0.4195004702,
0.0522584878,
-0.4204258025,
0.5154081583,
-0.3888325095,
-0.8302941322,
-0.4662022591,
-0.4424925148,
-0.7305204272,
0.137367636,
-0.4595732093,
-0.739648819,
0.2942897081,
0.3015545011,
0.1979730427,
0.3164634407,
-1.3907032013,
1.1149742603,
-0.1288091242,
-0.4619850218,
0.2987195849,
-0.6746841669,
0.463857621,
-0.216347307,
0.220745787,
0.1930209696,
-0.1039170027,
0.3234578669,
-0.5461669564,
0.8864008784,
-0.3291119933,
-0.0838298202,
0.4339037836,
0.2780401111,
0.6407412887,
0.2804650962,
-0.1959272027,
0.1681409329,
0.0711516812,
-0.4215815961,
-0.8335956931,
0.6114780307,
-0.3965713382,
-0.7234010696,
-0.2391555011,
-0.4437862337,
-0.4995497167,
0.24268803,
0.3861062825,
0.232629478,
-0.2322179228,
-0.085524708,
0.6590353251,
-0.3222718835,
0.5951610804,
0.8127152324,
0.0989374891,
0.292136997,
0.8036245108,
-0.0041468237,
0.000969874,
0.6232271194,
-0.0563492812,
-0.6485621929,
-0.5974560976,
-0.7291477323,
0.005372745,
-0.7133489251,
-0.0761360973,
-0.665915668,
0.0552460067,
-0.1824264675,
-0.0766532496,
-0.2258319706,
-0.5851327777,
-0.5504946709,
-0.0295837782,
0.5564193726,
0.7156181335,
0.4056902826,
0.2403262556,
-0.457197845,
0.5589738488,
0.3739959896,
0.3020608723,
-0.2780356407,
-0.3911456466,
0.2374771535,
-0.0541130751,
-0.0910421014,
-1.2454071045,
0.1186383888,
0.0042866203,
0.4877299666,
0.033945404,
0.6412138343,
0.540394485,
-0.467392236,
0.7318745255,
0.0323489644,
-1.1188459396,
0.9347746968,
-0.2937742174,
0.0151237985,
0.7162846923,
0.3151219189,
-0.1707110107,
-0.542791605,
-0.6631855965,
-0.9273171425,
0.7063261271,
0.4082110226,
0.1171226874,
-0.0862393901,
0.4089073539,
0.1424948275,
0.2846598327,
-0.8289618492,
-0.5123173594,
-0.3005023599,
-0.2692841291,
0.0063589732,
-0.1981020719,
-0.0861849263,
0.0236746147,
0.3299223185,
-0.1923384368,
0.1771006435,
0.1555152982,
-0.2515987754,
-0.0562531427,
0.7374568582,
0.5490517616,
0.6404355168,
-0.4376552403,
0.3000541031,
0.3914273083,
-0.100617677,
0.0532252342,
0.2245509177,
-0.2525582612,
0.1058835238,
0.1226466969,
0.3438180983,
-0.2084122002,
-0.6988174319,
0.6325369477,
-0.3134595454,
-0.3336888254,
-0.2627990544,
-0.1053254753,
0.2216670066,
-0.1059108078,
0.3925038576,
0.1037086844,
0.3024644554,
-0.3644548655,
0.2193213701,
0.399112016,
-0.5791385174,
0.002279531,
0.703045249,
0.2820988894,
-0.1495522559,
0.4411582947,
-0.363804996,
-0.1903634965,
0.7926896811,
0.6362991333,
0.4463981688,
0.1247081682,
0.3603035212,
0.16017735,
0.5227078795,
0.3034459352,
0.6212511063,
-0.0026092369,
-0.3885485828,
-0.1433055252,
0.0884603336,
-0.3179212213,
0.1917115003,
-0.652332902,
0.3597053289,
-0.0979845822,
-0.0611734204,
0.2836667299,
-0.2210450321,
-0.5079543591,
0.4391818941,
-0.6249197125,
0.5890774727,
-1.2523190975,
0.5141969919,
0.8127214909,
-0.5750948787,
-0.4566075802,
-0.0003801003,
-0.102971822,
-0.6846936941,
0.5406115055,
-0.3815107346,
0.1773490459,
-0.2734741569,
-0.4959561527,
-0.2982567549,
0.7018534541,
0.3987624049,
-0.6000443101,
-0.0956384614,
0.5863665938,
0.6175442338,
-0.1492408812,
0.3205684721,
0.6020932198,
0.4325998127,
0.1286430061,
-0.505540967,
0.326446861,
-0.1915957779,
-0.0260796268,
0.2538606226,
-0.1259626001,
0.7401595712,
-0.6008682251,
0.1081045121,
-0.0563491546,
0.308960557,
-0.0050557093,
0.6689757109,
0.6538847089,
0.445749253,
0.4515238702,
-0.3069725633,
0.8709412813,
0.1904036701,
0.2605599463,
1.4916534424,
-0.1858676076,
0.5845108628,
0.7422110438,
-0.0169753786,
0.4185816944,
0.6302707195,
-0.1972645372,
0.3571365774,
0.1703060716,
-0.1106106937,
-0.3689878881,
-0.195573017,
-0.4398451149,
0.2720692456,
0.4810892642,
-0.3468580842,
-0.8187775016,
-0.1560359895,
-0.2560287416,
0.4983874559,
-0.0341824032,
0.8044980764,
-0.1248807386,
-0.5826545358,
0.4805379212,
0.1402551532,
0.3323093653,
-0.2221832275,
-0.3321677744,
-0.3892216086,
-0.0752269328,
-0.4729860723,
-0.9917790294,
0.6188234091,
0.2958833873,
-0.4311670363,
-0.0358519368,
0.686580658,
-0.4526201785,
-0.3410977423,
0.058253739,
0.8290688992,
0.208166644,
0.062293075,
-0.7255547643,
-0.3585411012,
0.0780373737,
0.0896921232,
0.1524220109,
0.8250509501,
-0.4381372333,
0.4191430807,
0.3056526482,
-0.3302841485,
-0.1718514562,
0.0995648652,
0.6125249863,
-0.4647903144,
-0.3767795265,
-0.5951475501,
0.6905423403,
-0.1229070723,
-0.2690600157,
0.7273703814,
0.5061593652,
0.5894375443,
-0.3747369647,
0.5108925104,
-0.1713881642,
0.7890262604,
-0.2646896541,
0.4877885282,
-0.8612488508,
0.5340207815,
-0.3044423163,
-0.542719841,
-0.0027862561,
0.1013277099,
-0.4278491735,
0.2689168155,
0.8036608696,
0.7848908305,
-0.0544794276,
0.1264851093,
0.2811766863,
0.3234769404,
0.1772468239,
0.6441438794,
0.8139033914,
-0.7001134753,
0.9972710013,
-0.2332577705,
0.1339099258,
-0.0415300317,
-1.163615346,
-1.0037032366,
-0.6955477595,
-0.6681155562,
-0.4027501643,
0.1406187564,
0.3919345737,
0.7417463064,
-1.0163857937,
0.0112900259,
-0.5311228037,
0.6377629638,
-0.067112118,
-0.2737186849,
0.350874573,
-0.2964012325,
-0.6683990955,
0.3274863362,
-0.0039616581,
0.4533664286,
0.3736389875,
0.5360854864,
-0.1969464719,
0.0838736072,
0.3753633797,
0.3904447854,
-0.4460336268,
-0.0388786234,
-0.1671524644,
0.0691100881,
-0.170167461,
0.7331137061,
-0.824857831,
0.2556151748,
0.2334070951,
0.6235269904,
0.561543107,
0.1935692728,
0.3656804562,
-1.2116302252,
0.0308972355,
0.2594863772,
0.0417241529,
0.1905001104,
-0.7476921678,
0.3591822386,
0.2984224856,
-0.0959561467,
-0.933701694,
0.3765614033,
-1.1511325836,
-0.6892541647,
0.7080325484,
0.0404623486,
-0.0102943517,
-0.7171438336,
-0.0295665823,
0.129898876,
-0.335437566,
0.8099265099,
0.3836384416,
-0.1619747132,
-0.1942563057,
-0.5600301623,
0.5732381344,
0.7179145217,
-1.2679971457,
0.1221929416,
0.2546004951,
0.4527029097,
-0.1053234786,
0.2448295504,
-0.1071708351,
0.3435527086,
0.0516290478,
-0.2833601236,
0.0142665384,
0.149834156,
-0.2294782251,
0.3778992891,
-0.2232371718,
-0.0855051056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08897v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08897v2 | PolQA: Polish Question Answering Dataset | 2022-12-17T15:20:18 | 2024-02-22T13:24:49 | Piotr Rybak, Piotr Przybyła, Maciej Ogrodniczuk | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently proposed systems for open-domain question answering (OpenQA) require
large amounts of training data to achieve state-of-the-art performance.
However, data annotation is known to be time-consuming and therefore expensive
to acquire. As a result, the appropriate datasets are available only for a
handful of languages (mainly English and Chinese). In this work, we introduce
and publicly release PolQA, the first Polish dataset for OpenQA. It consists of
7,000 questions, 87,525 manually labeled evidence passages, and a corpus of
over 7,097,322 candidate passages. Each question is classified according to its
formulation, type, as well as entity type of the answer. This resource allows
us to evaluate the impact of different annotation choices on the performance of
the QA system and propose an efficient annotation strategy that increases the
passage retrieval accuracy@10 by 10.55 p.p. while reducing the annotation cost
by 82%. | [
-0.5948617458,
-0.5988481045,
0.5537928343,
0.1528199762,
-0.382361263,
0.0073702154,
-0.1427526176,
-0.3213792443,
0.1905550361,
0.6483761668,
-0.5626536012,
-0.4327485561,
-0.2655255198,
0.3276898861,
-0.101986222,
0.7920496464,
-0.0510084443,
0.3727691472,
-0.144999519,
-0.122623302,
-0.059749227,
-0.756388545,
-0.2823940217,
0.0468934365,
0.2984884083,
0.5639485121,
0.7955511808,
0.1709360033,
0.2816466391,
0.1811203808,
-0.1446217448,
0.3808812201,
-0.3786387146,
-0.0432406738,
-0.109059386,
-0.4034362733,
-0.3254478872,
0.0426881127,
0.6066815257,
0.6243141294,
-0.0076092337,
0.6270546317,
-0.3270448744,
0.6798936129,
-0.770311892,
0.2197220623,
-0.4156032801,
0.1777670532,
-0.5060327649,
0.0851236433,
-0.437635988,
-0.4931242466,
0.2736941576,
-1.2405934334,
-0.0706171468,
-0.0366849042,
0.7921748757,
0.0606621988,
-0.1537927389,
-0.2709596157,
-0.5913570523,
0.6017606258,
-0.4979734123,
0.1509239376,
0.497505486,
0.5491495132,
-0.104809843,
-0.7374215722,
-0.5844352841,
0.3074826002,
0.1072672978,
0.1378255486,
0.2907855511,
-0.0018805009,
0.1470748037,
0.511464715,
-0.465646714,
-0.3205320239,
-0.6269554496,
-0.4916521609,
0.8116768599,
0.2772680819,
0.4717715383,
-0.1014765799,
-0.2808688581,
-0.0104212398,
-0.6584915519,
0.2407584339,
0.3158037364,
0.5674775243,
0.2359434217,
0.6519127488,
-0.7561787367,
0.6078499556,
-0.1481862366,
0.2128766328,
0.52621454,
-0.4701399803,
-0.033811193,
-0.0371441431,
0.8289276958,
0.066047363,
0.3976430297,
-0.1167647913,
0.1369317919,
-0.4783236384,
0.2812509835,
-0.6060718894,
-0.3376095891,
0.4221202135,
-0.269533664,
-0.1623522192,
0.3393650651,
-0.7440778017,
-0.2521161437,
-0.0451640263,
0.6643316746,
-0.2827028334,
-0.1729812622,
0.4088147283,
0.0239697602,
0.2508296669,
0.5629367232,
-0.5963494778,
0.3987134993,
0.696759522,
0.5932893753,
0.0124219321,
-0.0031029896,
-0.6852164865,
-0.2882986963,
-0.6935534477,
0.6608266234,
-0.4033874571,
0.106413193,
0.1143494919,
0.3219236732,
-0.0384577103,
-0.4381961524,
0.4900149107,
-0.8485949636,
0.7022428513,
-0.5251796842,
-0.5063011646,
-0.3888204396,
0.0564736612,
-0.8869372606,
1.2206550837,
0.3277845979,
-0.8214482665,
0.3732944131,
-0.7185037732,
-0.0340099595,
0.4435128868,
-0.0565957576,
-0.1380413473,
-0.0979441553,
0.4117183387,
0.0037357199,
-0.2948296666,
0.1030658334,
0.068460457,
-0.5281417966,
0.3217232525,
0.0868730694,
1.1500715017,
0.2567085624,
-0.2175297886,
-0.1308031678,
-0.6208638549,
0.2976740301,
0.0310948417,
-0.5399403572,
-0.3566215038,
0.0453241542,
0.0073786601,
0.4694446921,
0.2411458343,
-1.1934103966,
0.1555243731,
-0.5707162619,
0.1782170832,
0.4557400048,
0.0729604363,
0.1989872158,
-0.1047916561,
0.7364488244,
-0.0143346069,
0.6600360274,
0.3427084386,
-0.9088176489,
-0.3597873449,
-0.1741980314,
0.7823300362,
0.7472609282,
-1.0951197147,
-0.0675413907,
-0.1061026379,
-0.2406805754,
-0.9799165726,
0.1337952167,
0.2876830101,
0.4607195556,
0.4031820595,
-0.0048594079,
-0.2717563212,
-1.1027584076,
0.0789273307,
-0.4107496142,
-0.2349693477,
0.3496564329,
0.4402897656,
0.7895367742,
0.8880744576,
-0.4609855711,
-0.2275815606,
-0.0746203363,
-0.1589424163,
0.2468899488,
0.0210753381,
0.4385305345,
-0.8831304908,
-0.6226807833,
-0.2591521144,
-0.6178245544,
-0.1934427619,
0.165536359,
-0.5420449972,
0.0648216233,
0.2634161413,
-0.4417390525,
0.227664277,
0.3534525335,
-0.4498354793,
0.4015755057,
0.051034566,
0.2267640084,
-0.7308931351,
0.1726396978,
-0.6658061743,
-0.1396280378,
-0.7158375978,
0.0050147572,
0.2524417937,
-0.2326168567,
-0.979264617,
0.5301172733,
-0.2709001005,
0.1606823057,
0.1802835613,
0.5137194395,
0.2203655243,
0.554921627,
0.0526670478,
1.2530601025,
0.3479308784,
-0.3333497345,
0.258053124,
1.0451700687,
-0.5651919842,
0.0049461271,
-0.4859383702,
0.2531911731,
-0.2456234843,
-0.094669804,
-0.8340530992,
-0.0747142807,
0.7353351712,
-0.5154927969,
-0.2433838695,
-0.0863456279,
-0.5421824455,
-0.1719421148,
-0.4445551336,
0.214680478,
0.3266401887,
-0.5088120103,
0.4439537823,
0.3907283843,
-0.5393295884,
-0.8957252502,
-0.390175283,
-0.0479206592,
0.1831992567,
-0.556065321,
-0.0216969009,
-0.0200314503,
-0.2053343058,
0.0245715994,
0.1024417728,
-0.3041236103,
0.1037996933,
0.1149775311,
0.1745878756,
-0.3604754806,
0.5946764946,
0.0100810779,
0.0549473837,
0.1790216714,
-0.0799454078,
0.2804418206,
-0.0328314379,
-0.0401492938,
-0.0807710737,
0.6389846802,
0.4446190894,
-0.5015217066,
0.9050560594,
0.2499617487,
-0.2214110792,
-0.1741470546,
-0.2260463238,
0.1398637891,
-0.4052477479,
0.1423548907,
-0.3492405117,
-0.6240648031,
0.5872749686,
0.1893452704,
0.2466692328,
0.493347317,
0.4544344544,
-0.0418793894,
0.9094494581,
0.4031437933,
-0.024132492,
0.2058816552,
-0.0310694519,
0.0989127457,
-0.6864694357,
-0.3638980687,
-0.464754045,
-0.0458166189,
-0.3002535403,
-0.492957145,
0.4777355194,
0.1159342751,
-0.2353755236,
-0.0934509635,
-0.5880899429,
0.3492677212,
0.7444866896,
0.4262028933,
0.4901098609,
-0.1008284017,
0.034748558,
0.1511252373,
-0.8530164957,
-0.6860774159,
1.4224562645,
0.1914248317,
0.2327997833,
0.1728164405,
0.3338977993,
0.0861697197,
0.1674857587,
-0.4933860004,
0.6475615501,
-0.1558591425,
-1.1651623249,
-0.7960677147,
-0.3055255711,
-0.6385113001,
0.220386073,
-0.467284441,
-0.3575281799,
0.2260289043,
-0.0804320425,
-0.5653615594,
0.2853518724,
-0.3378276825,
0.812225461,
-0.0423199423,
-0.0559974723,
0.2756293714,
-0.7017173171,
0.1129326373,
-0.2753880918,
0.054201819,
-0.3258742094,
-0.320666343,
1.0258803368,
-0.5944324732,
0.3688176274,
-0.5010780692,
0.1110842377,
0.5156535506,
-0.175458014,
0.1206144467,
0.1552906185,
-0.2812913954,
0.1666429639,
0.4067143798,
-0.6712052822,
-0.4966403544,
-0.1470705718,
-0.539691925,
-0.3566910028,
-0.2802010775,
-0.4859414399,
-0.4756045043,
0.2001432776,
0.4433864057,
0.4740696549,
-0.2115325928,
-0.0266740583,
0.9147677422,
-0.5821068883,
0.1581619531,
0.5669721961,
-0.3498066664,
-0.581358254,
0.6422929764,
0.2536234558,
0.2700310946,
0.1007270068,
0.0641122833,
-0.2458306253,
-0.6819483638,
-0.7528824806,
0.3388044238,
-0.6745746732,
-0.1605889648,
-0.4605867863,
-0.2036948353,
-0.1488522738,
0.3815072477,
-0.3580836058,
-0.9165478349,
0.0107825054,
-0.0551427789,
0.6454692483,
0.6243442893,
0.1676816344,
0.1300718933,
-0.5748826265,
0.3463053405,
0.3621623814,
0.6673886776,
-0.4709535241,
-0.2183285356,
-0.4003935754,
0.1471160352,
-0.0288433842,
-0.9275416136,
-0.0664229915,
0.4732178152,
0.4229262769,
-0.0157978628,
0.7062377334,
-0.0079808487,
-0.3936724663,
1.1340403557,
-0.440613091,
-0.7548249364,
0.5600791574,
-0.2511231303,
0.1764414459,
1.0425294638,
0.7204524875,
-0.4010721743,
-0.5078458786,
-0.3300036192,
-0.7556849122,
0.8708587289,
0.1671663672,
0.0304019134,
-0.1993560046,
0.4776486158,
0.2584692538,
0.3379515409,
-0.1900111437,
-0.3099096417,
-0.0774353296,
-0.322503835,
0.0286794789,
-0.246574223,
-0.2270855755,
-0.226814121,
0.8624566793,
-0.1749860942,
0.2469319403,
0.5459228158,
-0.2224921435,
-0.089315474,
0.3089753687,
0.4303902686,
0.8628386259,
-0.3096460402,
-0.3875776231,
0.2063643783,
-0.9190309644,
0.0746784955,
-0.0681917518,
-0.5789136291,
0.3442682922,
0.063200362,
0.408773452,
-0.2466138303,
-1.0098154545,
0.8472307324,
-0.141543746,
-0.5819013715,
-0.5325001478,
-0.2066657543,
-0.0929080695,
0.2727530897,
0.512791276,
-0.736014843,
0.3596763313,
-0.3563438058,
0.2236584425,
0.1991021931,
-0.4083627164,
-0.1035977155,
0.5899059176,
0.1493030787,
-0.0994923636,
0.8716537356,
0.0357727073,
-0.7795723677,
0.3551625609,
-0.1667171717,
0.5008233786,
-0.1322476119,
0.6405531764,
0.3330364227,
0.295922339,
0.013874758,
1.1440039873,
0.0482402071,
-0.3895631731,
-0.5886574388,
-0.4533186853,
-0.8268377781,
0.1149448976,
-0.8311316967,
0.0548367463,
-0.4182920754,
-0.1814620048,
-0.0594864599,
0.2647772133,
-0.4022766054,
0.1514066607,
0.235743314,
1.3324328661,
-1.0217349529,
0.5033193231,
0.7420275807,
-0.4527235627,
-0.6749507785,
-0.4444928169,
-0.2930289805,
-0.4644943476,
0.6610623002,
-0.2351069897,
0.1494804621,
-0.4393348992,
-0.5307136178,
-0.7529955506,
0.8019446731,
0.2436586767,
-0.1194628254,
-0.0447354689,
0.5316793919,
0.541018188,
-0.3839514852,
-0.0150562273,
0.3568126857,
0.4376333654,
-0.3941298425,
-1.0610607862,
0.0430673845,
-0.5972220302,
-0.3542584181,
0.4379259646,
-0.5834524632,
1.0287641287,
0.0820132047,
-0.3655798435,
0.1221584305,
0.2988189757,
-0.0850823745,
0.3030599952,
0.3133026659,
0.1601177752,
0.6994177103,
-0.1797518879,
0.6601109505,
-0.2859464884,
0.2434325367,
1.1233891249,
-0.0075525986,
1.0061175823,
0.3149009943,
-0.1897106916,
0.4646653235,
0.7004590034,
0.124223657,
0.5443472266,
0.1971577853,
-0.2327865362,
-0.4801888466,
-0.0525514483,
-0.3297865391,
0.2621966898,
0.2232265174,
-0.2835025489,
-0.2125299275,
0.2670821548,
-0.1898456663,
0.0857215524,
-0.2946588695,
0.9115319252,
-0.3148331046,
-0.4599922895,
0.4206856191,
-0.5120093822,
0.1048753783,
-0.4259508252,
-0.1300092489,
-0.1962178499,
-0.3283344805,
-0.2007374018,
-0.9799930453,
0.0799586549,
-0.0886302888,
-0.0826540291,
-0.0050839083,
0.2611095607,
-0.5478899479,
-0.4289822578,
0.0869301185,
0.6881656051,
0.4156572521,
-0.3549261391,
-0.5453256369,
-0.2773342729,
-0.2456658334,
-0.3076241016,
0.1040391102,
0.5008826852,
-0.1905689538,
0.6254969239,
0.2496503592,
0.3718153834,
0.4138937891,
-0.1924516559,
0.9175899625,
-0.4241891801,
-0.5128135681,
-0.0989870131,
0.5827796459,
-0.1540769339,
-0.5292198062,
0.5481315255,
0.6007236838,
0.740383625,
-0.1184227541,
0.7631011009,
0.0026259008,
1.0183796883,
-0.4785330296,
0.6382563114,
-0.3917430639,
-0.016252568,
-0.1095326766,
-0.6675294042,
-0.0796037912,
0.2971529961,
-0.4513747096,
-0.4945811033,
0.4936528504,
0.4890939891,
0.1287026554,
0.2857050002,
0.1255670786,
-0.0867345184,
-0.0209915768,
0.7953003049,
0.902977705,
-0.7835805416,
0.691627562,
-0.5881524682,
-0.1063807681,
-0.033737272,
-0.4143373072,
-0.7490660548,
-0.6728583574,
-0.3308138549,
-0.3602820337,
0.1362067908,
0.886272788,
0.5584436655,
-1.0503842831,
0.0654115751,
0.5670512319,
-0.0723167434,
-0.1982094944,
-0.180080682,
0.4746821523,
-0.2651467919,
-0.4179145992,
0.2105830759,
0.014768715,
-0.2804559767,
-0.0728006512,
0.0566471964,
-0.4005713463,
0.3317111135,
0.4659643471,
0.4724536538,
-0.5522280931,
-0.4788918793,
0.3538829982,
0.044198487,
0.3967709839,
0.6611942649,
-0.6808222532,
0.7117580771,
0.6333426833,
0.6183135509,
0.4447331727,
0.2666753829,
0.6775774956,
-0.4868533909,
-0.1044783518,
0.4236510694,
-0.0532808006,
0.0798378885,
-0.3933448195,
0.7177183032,
-0.1929404736,
-0.3970665038,
-0.7693171501,
-0.0687746406,
-0.7969123721,
-0.4226793945,
0.6589994431,
-0.3547585309,
-0.2757606506,
-0.7047712207,
-0.2018494457,
0.0134584634,
-0.1826807708,
0.7237698436,
1.0410920382,
-0.2250400335,
-0.0657571107,
-0.9863195419,
0.7750730515,
0.3747110963,
-0.7763461471,
0.3519097865,
0.4702297747,
0.485584408,
0.2373964339,
0.8183141947,
-0.5671460629,
0.6840359569,
-0.069585003,
0.2007524967,
-0.4183083177,
-0.3752800226,
-0.4688972235,
0.4137715697,
0.0490471013,
-0.5411913395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08888v1 | Exploiting Rich Textual User-Product Context for Improving Sentiment Analysis | 2022-12-17T14:57:52 | 2022-12-17T14:57:52 | Chenyang Lyu, Linyi Yang, Yue Zhang, Yvette Graham, Jennifer Foster | cs.CL | cs.CL | User and product information associated with a review is useful for sentiment
polarity prediction. Typical approaches incorporating such information focus on
modeling users and products as implicitly learned representation vectors. Most
do not exploit the potential of historical reviews, or those that currently do
require unnecessary modifications to model architecture or do not make full use
of user/product associations. The contribution of this work is twofold: i) a
method to explicitly employ historical reviews belonging to the same
user/product to initialize representations, and ii) efficient incorporation of
textual associations between users and products via a user-product
cross-context module. Experiments on IMDb, Yelp-2013 and Yelp-2014 benchmarks
show that our approach substantially outperforms previous state-of-the-art.
Since we employ BERT-base as the encoder, we additionally provide experiments
in which our approach performs well with Span-BERT and Longformer. Furthermore,
experiments where the reviews of each user/product in the training data are
downsampled demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach under a low-resource
setting. | [
-0.664064467,
-0.438888669,
0.3583955169,
0.518222332,
-0.577915132,
-0.0495933704,
-0.3983770013,
-0.4357688129,
0.4265998602,
0.4451628327,
-0.7351348996,
-0.8026365042,
-0.4750037789,
-0.0366278775,
-0.193810299,
1.4308826923,
0.2592528164,
0.460236311,
-0.2822330892,
-0.4723280966,
-0.1856749505,
-0.8545732498,
-0.1347028613,
-0.2162158787,
0.6812128425,
0.1907426268,
0.7397485971,
-0.4657235146,
0.2214179635,
0.0828240514,
-0.1769293398,
0.013865767,
-0.5828853846,
0.4899992049,
-0.2618865669,
-0.1558821797,
-0.4180849493,
0.2222110927,
0.1472824067,
0.570854187,
0.2221208364,
0.0789860711,
0.3537547886,
0.6912009716,
-0.5299924612,
0.1612123847,
-0.3522849083,
0.1793315262,
0.0911826268,
-0.0076259146,
-0.4862984717,
-0.2313169688,
0.4240484536,
-0.4114709496,
0.2718053162,
-0.0684938207,
0.7747301459,
-0.2405733466,
-0.3916466236,
-0.3788053393,
-0.8292350173,
1.0896896124,
-0.8555252552,
0.3857725859,
0.1455958188,
0.0778834745,
0.0230622329,
-0.3023785055,
-0.7549256682,
0.000472514,
-0.2912029624,
0.5463926196,
0.0041212221,
-0.133983478,
0.1273748875,
0.2466388196,
-0.1123907343,
-0.3494210243,
-0.2666265368,
0.0062618866,
0.5969623327,
-0.081735827,
-0.0618824661,
-0.7864537239,
-0.8690301776,
-0.205384165,
-0.5146719217,
0.2320689708,
0.347432822,
0.2259395272,
0.0386251733,
0.8113728166,
-0.1330027431,
0.112877287,
0.0271428563,
0.4072695076,
0.6472684741,
-0.3925310969,
-0.1574591696,
-0.1158451512,
0.958470881,
0.7976334691,
0.2506279349,
0.1214954183,
-0.6145799756,
0.0497987606,
0.2413118482,
-0.624376893,
-0.0201180745,
0.2135720253,
-0.658575058,
-0.1206698865,
0.5237343907,
-1.0837241411,
-0.7589006424,
-0.4795293808,
0.460606575,
-0.1847707629,
-0.2176051587,
-0.0828631371,
-0.4464334249,
0.3036135137,
0.2415940762,
-0.5982098579,
0.1976647824,
0.7147817612,
0.6199215651,
0.0276411567,
-0.0398848355,
-0.3433016539,
-0.0983853862,
-0.1072891057,
0.6730011702,
-0.2903359532,
-0.5454983711,
0.3168842494,
-0.1330883503,
0.3502775133,
-0.5260167718,
0.6249739528,
-0.8352588415,
0.5335915685,
-0.6410651207,
-0.3001174927,
-0.2831125557,
0.3726709187,
-0.7720018029,
1.0779610872,
0.3454741836,
-1.0781216621,
0.5741036534,
-0.4255397022,
-0.7917593718,
-0.4185780287,
0.121830076,
-0.6423514485,
0.4588113427,
0.7132257819,
0.689273715,
-0.0259439368,
0.0775189474,
-0.5930216908,
-0.3065327108,
0.4028557837,
-0.0421678014,
0.9240166545,
0.1475688815,
-0.319699496,
-0.0005825509,
-0.2483733743,
-0.5107884407,
-0.0874167904,
-0.2612343431,
-0.6389243603,
0.1739079654,
0.5933936834,
0.1991307735,
0.259925127,
-0.6474606991,
0.0949312523,
-0.5572600365,
0.2021693587,
0.7317867279,
0.3117000461,
0.548668921,
0.1340216547,
0.391196996,
0.3021809459,
0.398683399,
-0.0243591648,
-0.4198636711,
-0.6148397923,
-0.0109740114,
0.0738422573,
0.25567168,
-0.616396904,
0.4840277731,
-0.2804574072,
-0.0777625069,
-0.2468578815,
0.4070893228,
0.0774280205,
0.4156132638,
0.5825641751,
-0.6910549402,
-0.6581162214,
-0.8230710626,
-0.433247894,
-0.6080377698,
-0.246392265,
0.5464766622,
0.0326864868,
-0.7486515045,
1.2506984472,
-0.4067773819,
-0.6247639656,
-0.4283340573,
0.6245131493,
0.579174161,
0.0634668022,
0.5670853853,
-0.7568227649,
-0.575540781,
0.0237958282,
-0.6995045543,
-0.0751862973,
-0.0819574073,
-0.1652626097,
0.3633857071,
0.2217506766,
-0.4231749475,
0.0679503158,
0.4833802283,
-0.2880449295,
0.2659110129,
0.206272915,
0.1292471886,
-1.204851985,
-0.0763632879,
0.4121833444,
-0.124549225,
-0.3457593024,
-0.5518963933,
0.0111734606,
-0.0041143592,
-0.2994645536,
0.2882127762,
-0.4044290483,
-0.1917122006,
0.1490897983,
0.0095619764,
0.2291174084,
0.53628093,
0.0511203632,
0.6516202092,
0.06310004,
-0.0984190702,
-0.0347210132,
0.2016434669,
-0.3706333339,
0.5983504653,
-0.6961501837,
0.0587516315,
-0.5004335642,
0.2047945708,
-1.1656663418,
-0.0616939552,
0.1884366423,
-0.6310010552,
0.227826491,
-0.0871862769,
-0.3155750036,
-0.2373390198,
-0.926946938,
0.1507476121,
0.7326494455,
-0.7103340626,
1.0683037043,
0.4334192574,
-0.215903759,
-0.7588368058,
-0.5646642447,
-0.0001051073,
-0.3449136615,
-0.5208547711,
0.227231428,
0.074966915,
-0.1949670762,
0.0350506194,
0.0147212939,
0.1731280237,
-0.1907413602,
0.1927334368,
0.4489733279,
-0.2185672969,
0.394313693,
0.0747347474,
-0.0155325187,
0.2960386276,
0.0128067667,
0.4368382394,
-0.2501003742,
0.2212242484,
-0.2293581516,
0.4284548461,
0.6051917672,
0.0303706285,
0.6471874118,
0.6569540501,
0.0140793528,
-0.6648293138,
-0.6591562033,
-0.3314332366,
-0.3838397861,
0.3675149083,
0.1246870011,
-0.573413074,
0.4559167624,
0.0559186526,
-0.0263624322,
0.3237133622,
0.7425761223,
-0.7621210217,
1.1236689091,
0.6357492208,
-0.5930350423,
0.8159338832,
-0.2012725472,
0.5679908991,
-0.8144544959,
-0.2240018249,
-0.1090860441,
-0.3954122066,
-0.3207656741,
-0.3489961028,
0.5614155531,
0.0873928741,
-0.1017208248,
0.2996990979,
-0.1808633208,
0.111836575,
0.4774434566,
0.2692073584,
0.1620165259,
0.4193436801,
0.0556229725,
-0.2795615196,
-0.2535607219,
-0.3693397045,
1.2200033665,
0.6061494946,
0.9551209807,
-0.1449259818,
0.7020263672,
0.6797633171,
0.7785143256,
-1.0312583447,
0.2711954415,
-0.3969143927,
-0.5359393954,
0.0460894294,
-0.1780924797,
-0.4990918934,
0.1291237921,
-0.4376948774,
-0.1821568757,
0.407797575,
0.2059215009,
-0.2023390383,
-0.2690180838,
-0.8624170423,
0.6261901855,
-0.2772755921,
-0.4868720472,
-0.2774470448,
-0.6818720102,
0.1885947883,
0.3513209522,
0.3978964388,
-0.0813347995,
0.0769955516,
0.8845079541,
-0.1474152803,
1.1040998697,
-0.5581650734,
0.0568177104,
0.3747809827,
-0.184730202,
0.2226807028,
0.3524446189,
0.0058445144,
0.2312556058,
-0.4843773544,
-0.226465866,
-0.7254049778,
0.6842817068,
-1.0168346167,
-0.4342408478,
-0.3387749493,
-0.1846487075,
-0.5298344493,
-0.0524199568,
0.029205218,
0.2641764581,
-0.3620038331,
0.2997627556,
0.5921887159,
0.0149594452,
0.3736468852,
0.0626408756,
-0.1509295404,
-0.9096798897,
0.626535058,
-0.0277962685,
-0.0706929192,
0.1526734233,
0.3658547997,
-0.4469610751,
-0.2493214309,
-0.2458707392,
0.337521106,
-0.9544990063,
-0.3372558355,
-0.7177774906,
-0.0302016307,
-0.3150160313,
-0.0964041203,
-0.2833481729,
-0.3110352159,
-0.3120533824,
-0.1173125952,
0.1546206325,
0.9589599371,
0.3206021786,
0.3208762109,
-0.5903907418,
0.2715533972,
0.4467561245,
0.3491930664,
-0.0913364738,
-0.2005445659,
-0.3664719164,
-0.1421935111,
-0.1236844435,
-1.1163794994,
0.4143970013,
0.1632267684,
0.4901824296,
0.5375813246,
0.3133967519,
0.2195105404,
-0.0036947562,
1.0395153761,
0.2146687359,
-1.0254876614,
0.4667437673,
-0.263283968,
0.1419665515,
0.7873822451,
0.6587066054,
-0.4620120227,
-0.1384503096,
-0.0963388681,
-1.1567004919,
0.4467207491,
0.002788876,
0.5349929333,
-0.0154508241,
0.1049845964,
0.419739753,
0.2776107192,
-1.0996899605,
0.1681928933,
-0.6174657345,
-0.4581690729,
-0.359415859,
-0.6728470325,
-0.1111376807,
-0.3089594841,
0.8119991422,
-0.2159552574,
0.1038447171,
0.4823098183,
-0.2295658737,
-0.0244731735,
0.3572407663,
-0.0657699555,
0.3303789198,
-0.5102688074,
0.1897268891,
-0.0686483458,
-0.348672539,
-0.3048994839,
-0.1609810889,
-0.2270002216,
0.099932678,
0.358252883,
0.4566024244,
0.1923014373,
-0.5562775731,
0.9542572498,
-0.1080728769,
0.1131030545,
-0.3220156133,
-0.4532221556,
0.0988536328,
0.2866595089,
0.3265428543,
0.1225550473,
0.4119527042,
-0.737670958,
0.0607100278,
0.5858610868,
-0.9296594858,
-0.5672834516,
0.2249517292,
0.4600864053,
0.1287388206,
0.645314157,
0.0224050935,
-0.8672908545,
0.2426387966,
0.3487443924,
1.2263034582,
0.0953413099,
0.2305637896,
0.5478939414,
0.1373228282,
0.1368589997,
0.3581017554,
-0.4023920596,
-0.8699234724,
-0.0770289525,
-0.6646258235,
-0.3406092525,
-0.2536759973,
-0.7820379138,
0.5723237395,
-0.6253414154,
-0.6061728001,
-0.1150299087,
-0.180987522,
-0.4766561687,
0.1552384198,
0.2683586478,
0.576446414,
-1.2430831194,
0.4864326119,
0.819704473,
-0.5356535316,
-0.2616536021,
0.3255826831,
-0.0747774318,
-0.2843278348,
0.6580511332,
0.5271499157,
-0.2995785773,
-0.722137928,
-0.558432281,
-0.2135760784,
0.8434205651,
-0.1922253966,
-0.4551350474,
0.3197612166,
-0.088519156,
0.771733284,
-0.5618080497,
0.1392652094,
0.5054996014,
0.1887287349,
-0.0956270546,
-0.1852496266,
-0.0901750475,
-0.4444687665,
0.1652162373,
-0.0855584517,
-0.2548770607,
0.7968758345,
0.157042712,
-0.380491823,
-0.2720657587,
0.8620100021,
-0.0074550319,
0.4468593895,
0.8039969802,
0.3517031372,
0.1646349877,
0.1360300779,
1.0067874193,
-0.1223721802,
0.6770985723,
0.8439804912,
-0.3712099791,
1.3527349234,
0.9340070486,
-0.1382355094,
0.9105972052,
0.2577291131,
-0.0249686278,
0.7714825273,
-0.164653495,
-0.2731701136,
-0.1327440739,
-0.1987057179,
-0.2238780111,
0.0911499485,
0.2782493234,
-0.8056706786,
-0.0304215439,
-0.0825822428,
0.0238705724,
0.1872756183,
-0.1985564232,
1.0390688181,
0.1764899194,
-0.6251192689,
0.2213030905,
-0.0613516942,
0.9739424586,
-0.4160506129,
0.1259489357,
-0.3223755658,
0.2635586858,
-0.3689363599,
-0.937887311,
0.1528622359,
0.0341323726,
-0.3535943627,
-0.3891700804,
0.8534473181,
-0.3171388507,
-0.5516425967,
0.8128208518,
0.4516180754,
-0.5821478963,
0.0782714412,
-0.3107825816,
0.0121396082,
0.0409482941,
-0.7574916482,
0.0014873712,
0.1339279413,
-0.1238782555,
-0.0971729159,
0.567520678,
-0.1107189208,
-0.1845100522,
0.5175352693,
1.2101397514,
-0.8278145194,
-0.5870857835,
-0.7238965631,
0.6697251797,
-0.4885516763,
-0.4046894312,
0.8429508209,
0.4739423692,
0.8899641037,
-0.4444948137,
0.8649463058,
0.0535790138,
0.3971800804,
-0.3218666017,
0.7593876123,
-0.4097554088,
0.4391034245,
-0.3812262416,
-1.3012074232,
-0.42015782,
0.5366891623,
-0.4708916247,
0.0955828428,
0.461537987,
0.7067685723,
-0.145674482,
0.2516024411,
-0.1294056475,
0.3725219071,
0.1590169519,
0.1664446443,
1.2385386229,
-0.2961847186,
0.1057209522,
-0.5161280632,
-0.2743468285,
-0.3666317463,
-0.8215670586,
-1.2049702406,
-0.2903762758,
-0.0315222219,
-0.5728853345,
-0.0786937401,
1.0542242527,
0.6187220812,
-1.1612049341,
-0.4315943122,
0.3469235003,
-0.005146997,
-0.190212056,
-0.2383026332,
0.0981840715,
-0.5875549912,
-0.5645471811,
0.1106395051,
0.2439426035,
-0.2115208656,
-0.5751763582,
-0.2113319337,
0.1775930375,
0.3316211402,
0.9485133886,
-0.1328222901,
-0.5775737166,
-0.2043498456,
0.1263407022,
-0.0533789955,
0.2682068348,
1.060931921,
-0.8486142159,
0.7997411489,
0.8953546882,
0.5137385726,
0.6024369597,
0.4615524411,
0.6477966905,
-0.8756120801,
-0.1202321425,
0.5074864626,
0.4881613553,
0.6132837534,
-0.3714233041,
0.1516864598,
0.1582672447,
-0.200452283,
-0.3495883346,
-0.052948188,
-1.4053041935,
-0.2806921899,
1.0711576939,
-0.0747355074,
-0.3295798302,
-0.0357287452,
-0.431414336,
-0.1937476099,
-0.7551404834,
0.9602133036,
0.6260481477,
-0.0326541401,
0.1702301651,
-0.2446930557,
0.2818612456,
0.5640060902,
-0.5882909298,
0.1096023619,
0.5217767358,
0.2734003365,
0.247599557,
0.3422443867,
-0.3863132894,
0.1967565417,
-0.2631215155,
0.1551784724,
0.1251404434,
-0.4230335653,
-0.5191143751,
0.4868782461,
0.1036507785,
0.0670198277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08864v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08864v1 | 'If you build they will come': Automatic Identification of News-Stakeholders to detect Party Preference in News Coverage | 2022-12-17T13:08:39 | 2022-12-17T13:08:39 | Alapan Kuila, Sudeshna Sarkar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | The coverage of different stakeholders mentioned in the news articles
significantly impacts the slant or polarity detection of the concerned news
publishers. For instance, the pro-government media outlets would give more
coverage to the government stakeholders to increase their accessibility to the
news audiences. In contrast, the anti-government news agencies would focus more
on the views of the opponent stakeholders to inform the readers about the
shortcomings of government policies. In this paper, we address the problem of
stakeholder extraction from news articles and thereby determine the inherent
bias present in news reporting. Identifying potential stakeholders in
multi-topic news scenarios is challenging because each news topic has different
stakeholders. The research presented in this paper utilizes both contextual
information and external knowledge to identify the topic-specific stakeholders
from news articles. We also apply a sequential incremental clustering algorithm
to group the entities with similar stakeholder types. We carried out all our
experiments on news articles on four Indian government policies published by
numerous national and international news agencies. We also further generalize
our system, and the experimental results show that the proposed model can be
extended to other news topics. | [
-0.706251204,
-0.4383530617,
0.7740694284,
0.4249319732,
-0.3478696942,
0.3469799757,
-0.1249526665,
-0.4733232856,
0.571367681,
0.2378821969,
-0.3445986509,
-0.2658074498,
-0.7409176826,
-0.0766940638,
-0.4842747748,
0.9979280829,
-0.1630507261,
-0.0650508255,
0.2162176967,
0.1076764315,
-0.446613729,
-0.1856028885,
-0.1719059348,
0.0053500468,
0.3775894046,
0.5104320645,
0.6426335573,
0.6005542874,
0.1623466909,
0.2418420166,
-0.151156351,
-0.0989817679,
0.1767321974,
-0.3892721236,
-0.3288901746,
-0.5378713012,
0.191232577,
0.5427267551,
0.5639979243,
0.3545142412,
0.0716088563,
0.4280917048,
0.201577276,
0.3168576956,
-0.6581075788,
0.1148726046,
-0.8822457194,
0.0993046537,
-0.1800835729,
-0.4227141142,
-0.3485630453,
-0.4238129854,
-0.0191555973,
-0.3776853085,
0.4382148087,
-0.0657993928,
1.0763311386,
0.0129499938,
-0.7253792882,
-0.5018643737,
-0.2830132246,
0.6221836805,
-0.4691826701,
0.3111917078,
0.333406508,
0.0349520072,
-0.3193113208,
-0.2029132098,
-0.5627411604,
-0.1738633215,
-0.2166789919,
0.0927883983,
0.290491432,
-0.4093272984,
-0.0120871179,
0.3295024335,
-0.2267117053,
-0.101421386,
-0.4742876291,
-0.2000921667,
0.6272110343,
-0.3773800135,
0.4035821259,
-0.9147923589,
-0.5517576337,
0.1665450037,
-0.5685302019,
0.3422060609,
0.8426564336,
0.3199299276,
-0.1911689788,
0.7483083606,
-0.1800903678,
0.3388791978,
0.792404294,
-0.2646189034,
0.3231325746,
-0.3620891273,
0.092809245,
0.6644103527,
0.239153415,
0.2754154801,
-0.1752601713,
-0.0334102325,
0.1257013977,
0.1246733814,
0.2972720265,
-0.3319410384,
0.1683802754,
0.2755919695,
-0.8297834396,
-0.5104687214,
0.3984912038,
-0.9667947292,
-0.5031548142,
-0.5015316606,
0.1684374958,
0.1093561724,
-0.5823516846,
-0.2937252522,
-0.4849883318,
0.751881063,
0.2118845433,
-0.6019932032,
-0.1632076055,
0.8551527858,
0.7513948679,
-0.4933046699,
0.1598065048,
-0.5182860494,
0.4887959659,
-0.5179712772,
0.7428668141,
-0.7202177048,
-0.4574647546,
0.0391337387,
0.0430472679,
0.1694104671,
-0.253455162,
0.5005774498,
-0.4905290604,
0.3852674365,
-0.5720210671,
-0.4045341909,
0.0712737665,
0.2499581277,
-0.5782302022,
0.4636683166,
0.1671448946,
-1.1560983658,
1.214445591,
-0.228980422,
-0.3353143036,
0.0272214469,
-0.6892938614,
-0.3908755183,
0.5357958674,
0.4104182124,
0.1984581351,
-0.0131565938,
0.6864767075,
-0.3777906299,
0.105358839,
0.0903493538,
0.0186557826,
0.6760624647,
0.3144595921,
-0.4384031892,
0.4131532311,
-0.7295352221,
-0.1083755419,
-0.3548051715,
-0.2445502877,
-0.5613806844,
0.3654493392,
0.0067128553,
0.500035882,
0.0566512421,
-0.7882065177,
0.2172575891,
-0.0771043077,
0.2368540317,
1.0123091936,
0.4620698988,
0.6809466481,
-0.1108006835,
0.3398810029,
0.5354282856,
0.2225746214,
-0.3277643621,
-0.3653951883,
-0.6676504612,
-0.5372682214,
0.5957115889,
0.3459402323,
-0.8337906003,
0.4282842577,
-0.0282241851,
-0.151378721,
-0.3606610894,
-0.1010833681,
-0.0798026174,
0.322715193,
-0.1065523401,
-0.3948925734,
-0.6061610579,
-0.9691850543,
-0.6886615157,
-0.3730812967,
-0.0872512013,
-0.1056472883,
0.2616347671,
0.0867890939,
1.4506883621,
-0.460172385,
-0.217358008,
-0.0462530926,
0.3267708123,
0.2578356266,
0.2254724205,
0.2963278592,
-1.3133779764,
-0.5727599859,
0.1061098278,
-0.5107317567,
0.0693714991,
-0.3187271953,
0.3028943539,
0.1018502489,
0.4278175235,
-0.5601780415,
0.6353560686,
0.1151514947,
-0.4059579074,
0.2170790136,
0.1305189282,
0.1785664707,
-1.3217656612,
-0.2558194995,
0.3017094731,
-0.1605872214,
-0.2381513268,
0.0227703247,
-0.0722629428,
-0.3183878958,
-0.3315505385,
0.3805857003,
-0.5669893026,
-0.2573006451,
-0.1851837337,
-0.0585722998,
-0.2461614162,
0.2413100004,
0.2878809869,
0.6234982014,
0.3986307085,
-0.5389861465,
-0.3697743118,
0.1515706778,
-0.4562165141,
0.6827355623,
-0.3600126207,
-0.1782582849,
-0.2906543911,
0.4411290288,
-1.0026017427,
-0.3629638553,
0.3347992003,
-0.7478641868,
0.0642341003,
-0.1828909665,
-0.4099482596,
-0.4306268394,
-0.3868921101,
-0.3616112471,
0.1833678484,
-0.4656450152,
0.5819908977,
0.7193343043,
-0.2051597089,
-0.3442897201,
-0.4840658903,
0.1892603785,
-0.5397666097,
-0.4220035076,
0.3646887541,
0.2564170063,
-0.1602157354,
0.5012079477,
-0.197444886,
-0.0219828524,
-0.084942095,
0.4874181449,
-0.0838667527,
-0.1090599522,
-0.0791573226,
0.2983342409,
-0.4532671273,
0.0550871901,
0.046836324,
0.0493844412,
-0.0371431559,
-0.4398589134,
-0.471657604,
0.9469998479,
0.5363566279,
-0.6169988513,
0.655997932,
0.6484882236,
-0.1200283021,
0.0435269028,
-0.9074747562,
-0.0591280162,
-0.4126390517,
0.171307832,
-0.3715410829,
-0.3606394529,
0.5964925885,
-0.2374156862,
0.0219027791,
0.6355600953,
0.4312520325,
0.2801264524,
1.1334387064,
0.993727982,
-0.473128587,
0.311519891,
0.0523301922,
0.34273386,
-0.2506456077,
-0.3175447881,
-0.5994539261,
-0.2300567925,
-0.8262327313,
0.0855570063,
0.3780982196,
-0.0799737647,
0.2861405611,
0.3016625941,
-0.7514025569,
0.2428362966,
0.4967631996,
-0.032312274,
0.5324266553,
0.1333764791,
0.169198662,
0.0699388087,
-0.3150838315,
-0.3794145286,
0.6610485911,
0.4938690662,
0.4562177062,
-0.0664956942,
0.9785114527,
0.5802845955,
0.6884016395,
-0.5329366326,
0.2058951557,
0.3089258373,
-0.902674973,
0.1620701253,
-0.1797519028,
-0.4290717244,
0.3412820399,
-0.0957391337,
-0.4554178417,
1.1816122532,
-0.210770756,
-0.2818259597,
0.3714175224,
-0.8204602599,
0.0594758764,
-0.1339118779,
0.0421622731,
-0.3298236132,
-0.543024838,
0.4282402694,
-0.2560149133,
0.3052779436,
-0.2047078162,
-0.2155632228,
0.4507372975,
-0.1386470348,
0.55647403,
-0.3671632409,
0.0357113853,
0.5979608893,
-0.641156435,
0.2826939523,
0.3562481999,
-0.3081053793,
0.1123185381,
-0.0487601161,
-0.3841796219,
-0.0792362541,
0.6517779827,
-0.9834675193,
-0.5348184109,
-0.7787855268,
-0.338155359,
-0.2629300058,
-0.0450907052,
0.4986997843,
-0.0023107501,
-0.1340194046,
0.2402018011,
0.2837106586,
0.1646356732,
1.1555153131,
0.4982591569,
0.1249496266,
-0.3807331622,
0.7697603106,
0.3294343948,
-0.3469400108,
-0.0585947894,
0.0410428606,
-0.0319202617,
-0.3156096339,
-0.5923682451,
-0.16370143,
-0.3384706974,
-0.1889523715,
-0.5923368931,
-0.2197079957,
-0.0736353323,
-0.2820043862,
-0.2262105793,
-0.1114852577,
-0.4166470468,
-0.063640736,
-0.0557360798,
0.576769948,
-0.1352172196,
0.413408041,
-0.4998494685,
0.5381363034,
0.3087192178,
0.2513938248,
-0.1785325408,
-0.1411541998,
-0.0279018711,
-0.1875240654,
-0.5127568245,
-1.1760908365,
0.5075147748,
-0.2389395833,
0.8243607879,
0.4753638208,
-0.0212329868,
0.4735451639,
-0.5395776033,
0.4879802167,
0.3265748918,
-0.9473333359,
0.6508821249,
-0.4374141395,
-0.0320328362,
0.9889016747,
0.8826197386,
-0.0449322127,
-0.2022035718,
-0.9062871337,
-0.7647608519,
0.4957598448,
0.0514922999,
0.2428516299,
-0.1844795644,
0.5666790605,
0.1384370029,
0.5322703719,
-0.8472861052,
0.1330743879,
-0.2484022528,
-0.0152503159,
0.1753708571,
-0.3905535936,
-0.0368994363,
-0.1274701804,
0.4541732967,
-0.1882814169,
0.1926080585,
0.4979702234,
-0.1172618419,
-0.4439361095,
0.4632087052,
0.3706919253,
1.1081804037,
-0.0913119614,
0.0167772602,
-0.3580459952,
-0.2480292618,
0.2375148237,
0.2177560329,
-0.2908623517,
0.2801209688,
0.1102330312,
0.4617251754,
-0.2366207987,
0.0113769798,
0.7510693669,
0.0970252156,
-0.0415996648,
-0.6318161488,
-0.2430804521,
-0.2416644543,
0.4922491014,
0.9271737933,
-0.0720038339,
0.2359419167,
-0.973133266,
0.6461802125,
0.5471755862,
-0.6803706884,
-0.2978722155,
0.4242156744,
0.3693192005,
-0.3325788975,
0.1363587677,
-0.2512889504,
-0.4445898533,
0.5522803068,
0.1398006678,
0.8060193658,
-0.3554388583,
0.2382328212,
0.1306174546,
0.4857474566,
0.2227848023,
-0.0106897959,
0.0982659757,
-0.3008133769,
-0.686755538,
-0.4319967926,
-0.1214698926,
0.0724803209,
-0.6692247987,
0.5681109428,
-0.3694452345,
-0.3856641054,
0.0873388425,
0.4471522868,
-0.2226400673,
0.077471137,
0.3669989705,
0.9780493975,
-1.5270243883,
0.7381878495,
0.3172520995,
-0.6385306716,
-0.562472105,
0.6243638992,
0.0871849954,
-0.3252520263,
0.4989105165,
0.0609924346,
0.5193425417,
-0.3751544356,
-0.5455104709,
-0.6636897326,
0.6527889371,
0.0309135932,
-0.5339776874,
-0.1174404845,
0.135185197,
0.1348913014,
-0.5599249601,
0.0477497503,
0.1645856351,
0.6589375138,
0.0887995884,
-0.8517302275,
-0.1224307865,
0.0500016175,
-0.0178450644,
0.3291066587,
-0.86192137,
0.8017243743,
-0.0241037458,
0.1468295753,
-0.3731820881,
1.113498807,
0.0645048767,
0.581746757,
0.871272862,
0.1021075174,
0.380246222,
0.2184790373,
0.9041268826,
-0.3413092792,
0.1511493623,
0.8535090685,
-0.0463625826,
0.6567839384,
0.7118403912,
0.145237267,
0.4964051247,
0.8109241724,
-0.0906204879,
0.98021245,
0.0711359456,
-0.1526811421,
0.0347818881,
-0.3398285806,
-0.553186655,
0.5855051875,
0.3950345218,
-0.3167890906,
-0.4312019646,
0.2076175362,
-0.038177561,
0.0818935037,
-0.3227618933,
0.6408253312,
0.0945031717,
-0.8865591288,
-0.3066832721,
0.3537549376,
0.5326220393,
-0.5780838132,
-0.0756121427,
-0.0437392853,
0.0439572409,
-0.4639312029,
-0.7694297433,
0.6093105674,
-0.2462260574,
-0.4010975957,
-0.1444377005,
0.8298919201,
-0.5234997869,
-0.578001678,
0.0275378972,
0.4558135271,
-0.4661922157,
-0.3629800975,
-0.4786240458,
0.3315443397,
0.1475115716,
-0.2122768909,
0.4381819665,
0.1853304058,
-0.3902262747,
0.0317772254,
0.6604788303,
0.1083570346,
0.0803208575,
-0.5378444791,
1.1553262472,
-0.3610589206,
-0.7708216906,
-0.6135482788,
0.5162215829,
-0.5839936733,
-0.3881449997,
0.8438190222,
0.6693017483,
0.5018753409,
-0.0834499076,
0.609021306,
-0.3428992331,
0.5343592763,
-0.0880213156,
0.6179846525,
-0.3806910813,
-0.0844027847,
-0.2059721947,
-0.7958536744,
0.0934062302,
0.3575893641,
-0.3512940705,
-0.1366787404,
0.4536215961,
0.4066429138,
-0.2689734995,
0.224360913,
-0.2263002098,
-0.3185364604,
0.3134619296,
0.0415627696,
0.7064450979,
0.0384567603,
0.3098351657,
-0.308657378,
-0.3561413288,
-0.0128371129,
-1.1720484495,
-0.773524344,
-0.7086458206,
-0.6103279591,
-0.124922432,
0.0793556869,
0.4579901099,
1.028554678,
-0.8777103424,
0.0464894064,
-0.0499367081,
0.4119459093,
0.2218426615,
-0.3093985915,
0.6080112457,
-0.3958831429,
-0.2660054862,
-0.0652769059,
0.1615810245,
-0.4971071184,
-0.3902071416,
0.5496166348,
-0.4069191515,
0.2179972827,
0.4764494896,
0.3470450938,
-0.698946178,
-0.3974137604,
-0.3626239002,
0.0853947401,
0.3403358161,
1.0559476614,
-0.849714458,
0.2013045698,
0.4564488828,
0.5932433605,
0.5964434743,
0.1572024673,
0.1543379128,
-0.7613603473,
0.6518777013,
-0.1775500923,
-0.2375942767,
0.1216113418,
-0.6740148067,
0.3960756063,
0.1257011443,
-0.2009990513,
-0.6789925098,
0.0761309192,
-0.8387513161,
-0.1883793026,
1.1845419407,
0.1852874756,
-0.3651438057,
-0.2761513889,
-0.1910171956,
0.0024564723,
-0.3963394463,
0.6577368975,
0.6383526921,
-0.0731764212,
-0.2686362565,
-0.514402926,
0.4269773066,
-0.0980294868,
-0.9144203663,
-0.4592298865,
0.2956610024,
0.3584845364,
0.5662209392,
0.7598670125,
-0.2369176596,
-0.00728954,
-0.1776998192,
-0.064157851,
0.2543702126,
-0.434155345,
-0.0725017413,
0.6530939937,
-0.0709996074,
-0.4506681561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08853v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08853v2 | HyPe: Better Pre-trained Language Model Fine-tuning with Hidden Representation Perturbation | 2022-12-17T11:56:21 | 2023-05-11T07:10:32 | Hongyi Yuan, Zheng Yuan, Chuanqi Tan, Fei Huang, Songfang Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models with the Transformers structure have shown great performance
in natural language processing. However, there still poses problems when
fine-tuning pre-trained language models on downstream tasks, such as
over-fitting or representation collapse. In this work, we propose HyPe, a
simple yet effective fine-tuning technique to alleviate such problems by
perturbing hidden representations of Transformers layers. Unlike previous works
that only add noise to inputs or parameters, we argue that the hidden
representations of Transformers layers convey more diverse and meaningful
language information. Therefore, making the Transformers layers more robust to
hidden representation perturbations can further benefit the fine-tuning of PLMs
en bloc. We conduct extensive experiments and analyses on GLUE and other
natural language inference datasets. Results demonstrate that HyPe outperforms
vanilla fine-tuning and enhances generalization of hidden representations from
different layers. In addition, HyPe acquires negligible computational
overheads, and is better than and compatible with previous state-of-the-art
fine-tuning techniques. | [
-0.5198069811,
-0.6002525091,
0.3087298572,
0.2365725338,
-0.3319513798,
0.4256049991,
-0.5477294326,
-0.1667674035,
0.141159147,
0.597176075,
-0.5032023787,
-0.6626269221,
-0.7025140524,
-0.1853542179,
-0.3411846459,
0.7646691799,
0.0702336207,
-0.3202643692,
-0.1706736237,
0.2383886278,
-0.1444859058,
-0.5349792838,
-0.2768036723,
-0.4310649037,
0.4071307182,
0.494633466,
0.9569364786,
0.9768576026,
0.3999807239,
0.240776211,
-0.2367881536,
0.3249358237,
-0.5728075504,
0.2191009223,
-0.0249902122,
-0.5389371514,
-0.4680331647,
0.1466302425,
0.4872475266,
0.5929245949,
-0.124306567,
0.1000093147,
0.3377325833,
0.5470710993,
-0.8276714087,
0.2073124498,
-0.8030304313,
0.0553058386,
-0.3868133128,
-0.4112622142,
-0.5309932828,
0.097201325,
0.0683467537,
-0.6974182129,
0.2347936779,
0.1338747442,
1.2255767584,
0.69197613,
-0.0276839603,
-0.0591949299,
-0.9823159575,
0.8497061729,
-0.7210967541,
0.4618026018,
0.5254775286,
0.4293554425,
-0.2337781042,
-0.5422194004,
-0.3171518743,
-0.3230799139,
-0.1780686229,
0.0201399252,
0.0191072337,
0.2993970811,
0.3133669496,
0.5572863221,
-0.0737685338,
0.3947095275,
-0.0165699311,
-0.4656139612,
0.3195379972,
-0.2666655481,
0.2021738142,
-0.0374656245,
-0.2443557829,
-0.2179649472,
-0.7706966996,
-0.0384837538,
0.7873765826,
0.4296782911,
-0.3144207895,
0.3971071541,
-0.2885299325,
0.6223313808,
0.3803787529,
0.1242821515,
0.299505055,
-0.0812366307,
-0.3158500791,
0.0333193131,
0.6612915993,
-0.0936066359,
0.4814994633,
-0.2214569896,
-0.1072002202,
0.1850999743,
0.1139544845,
-0.752051115,
-0.334059149,
0.1505795568,
-0.2859855294,
-0.2483772188,
0.2034042329,
-0.8809845448,
-0.353117615,
-0.3264523745,
0.3045506179,
-0.3116768897,
-0.2725907862,
0.506272018,
-0.1939852685,
-0.1134338304,
0.3061762452,
-1.0208536386,
0.2576492131,
0.7699846029,
0.3344508708,
-0.0268266872,
-0.2093975544,
-0.660974443,
0.3100180328,
-0.2525989115,
0.9039331079,
-0.9948019385,
-0.0037960145,
-0.1180296317,
-0.2962550223,
-0.0235317107,
-0.6999648809,
0.7231838107,
-0.1696856022,
0.2244246751,
-0.0047126971,
-0.4891846478,
0.3506480753,
0.0523621738,
-0.5771421194,
0.922850132,
-0.0456167534,
-0.5695373416,
0.3964852393,
-0.5536563993,
-0.4656520486,
-0.1156084836,
-0.1806754917,
-0.5522333384,
0.4633107483,
0.7393547297,
0.2295076847,
-0.1030073091,
-0.0230770614,
-0.150229305,
-0.5824822783,
-0.0195959844,
-0.3651527464,
0.2946154773,
0.1114501208,
-0.330742389,
0.2127033621,
-0.638659656,
-0.1337946951,
-0.1205726042,
-0.414698869,
-0.3284840286,
0.0504396595,
-0.5045959949,
-0.0024928541,
0.2850084305,
-0.5219982266,
0.1993711144,
-0.8863250017,
0.4189490974,
0.5132734179,
-0.0288247745,
0.8380669951,
-0.0098082554,
0.4898641407,
0.3442495167,
0.0685078278,
-0.3619655073,
-0.5800658464,
-0.8256804347,
-0.3575227857,
0.5881268978,
0.1357022524,
-0.6939663887,
0.5058107376,
0.0891383365,
-0.3707168996,
-1.0378482342,
0.2138891369,
0.3603353202,
0.2370461822,
0.4177730083,
-0.1505906433,
-0.7683364749,
-1.0058791637,
-0.7096987367,
0.088879019,
-0.1572297364,
0.1651588678,
-0.0083907899,
-0.4020589292,
0.9749172926,
-0.4710693061,
-0.494274199,
-0.1849156469,
0.3958235979,
0.261635989,
0.5330517292,
0.4218988717,
-0.561852634,
-0.6076827645,
-0.0136116231,
-0.1287224293,
-0.0220259856,
-0.0603720509,
-0.2173349261,
0.1488656253,
0.6773681641,
-0.805290997,
0.3132286668,
0.5855475068,
-0.3751208484,
0.4275222421,
-0.2023106366,
-0.2227820456,
-0.7878543139,
-0.3272325993,
-0.1020228192,
-0.1113264114,
-0.5326164961,
0.0144311637,
0.0584096685,
-0.0895030126,
-0.2259197682,
0.2419669479,
-0.7565879226,
0.3037047088,
-0.3726166189,
0.0328231864,
-0.0040834486,
0.5515992641,
-0.1799148768,
0.5651335716,
0.9485016465,
-0.5491507053,
-0.0575822107,
0.1041527838,
-0.3445030451,
-0.1607205272,
-0.4455914497,
0.3177463412,
-0.4624091387,
-0.0142713562,
-0.8214164376,
-0.2341909707,
0.153400138,
-0.4978624284,
0.5389434099,
-0.3555617034,
-0.7676007152,
-0.4277798235,
-0.1730033159,
0.0031138663,
0.7766152024,
-0.5334047675,
0.4435012043,
0.4781515002,
0.359390676,
-0.4529881477,
-0.5901504755,
-0.0127363047,
-0.075817965,
-0.2212132215,
0.6177611947,
0.0313679948,
0.0707282573,
-0.0744851977,
-0.6183552146,
0.0953261256,
0.2070783675,
0.2445585728,
-0.2967033088,
-0.4944241345,
0.1048631594,
0.3051010668,
-0.3424925506,
-0.065343067,
-0.3543219566,
0.9242938757,
-0.2812167704,
-0.3448673189,
-0.3336321712,
-0.1600415707,
0.5708818436,
-0.4655409455,
0.6075485349,
0.8106170297,
-0.4383042157,
-0.5412141681,
-0.3625914454,
-0.3991650939,
-0.6023766994,
0.2918498814,
-0.3016933501,
-0.9691325426,
0.2538804412,
-0.1125692949,
-0.0982793048,
0.3512982726,
0.5225225091,
-0.2735244334,
1.258259654,
0.884010911,
-0.0408208221,
0.4620934129,
-0.1513045877,
0.280063659,
-0.4788363874,
0.0937610418,
-0.6174257994,
-0.4978258014,
-0.5939947963,
-0.4999439418,
-0.0911439732,
0.4047748744,
-0.0952916741,
0.604826808,
-0.3879698217,
0.6943952441,
0.5288937092,
-0.0083378842,
0.3721737862,
0.4874868095,
-0.3267108202,
-0.2785075903,
-0.6512188315,
-0.5470023751,
0.7071931362,
0.6918136477,
0.8139101267,
-0.1842781156,
0.8445723653,
-0.1875442266,
0.1913874596,
-0.674752295,
0.3474850357,
-0.6019880772,
-0.5147627592,
-0.40042907,
-0.3154909611,
-0.7839666009,
0.2165880352,
-0.4670625329,
-0.7114108801,
0.3111825585,
0.5354904532,
-0.6260803342,
0.2699882388,
-0.830652833,
0.704197824,
0.0312108006,
-0.2223598063,
-0.3865721524,
-0.3070281446,
-0.0352714807,
0.1389789283,
0.0922907293,
-0.26934883,
0.1135964617,
0.481321305,
-0.2379200757,
0.9385505915,
-0.1446405202,
-0.3612708747,
0.2305556238,
0.107927084,
0.5519400239,
0.1432240307,
-0.2046959698,
0.1141231582,
-0.4073802531,
-0.3642312884,
-0.8120907545,
0.5935789943,
-0.6974228024,
-0.956882298,
0.1103589758,
-0.63744241,
-0.5282077789,
0.1918785274,
0.4694176912,
0.343224436,
0.3066194952,
0.4644429982,
0.5665763617,
-0.3685204685,
0.4473061562,
0.4319451153,
-0.1992421746,
-0.1052419618,
0.9629995823,
-0.0148816202,
0.2951374352,
0.5919567347,
0.3533942997,
-0.0265306402,
-0.5697978139,
-0.3050017953,
0.2205736041,
-0.2312275022,
-0.106522359,
-0.7086969018,
-0.3171382546,
-0.3448217511,
0.1901880205,
-0.7042415142,
-0.366104871,
-0.440454632,
-0.1092305109,
0.1092045978,
0.6994590163,
0.1526297033,
0.6609196067,
-0.6572710872,
0.5072632432,
0.1606311947,
0.9961835742,
-0.1843128353,
-0.4935153127,
-0.4427542686,
0.2056852877,
-0.3402969837,
-0.6054207683,
0.4245082438,
0.4571555853,
0.665137589,
0.5328467488,
0.0727721751,
0.7287949324,
-0.341846168,
0.4211472869,
0.0215308163,
-0.9425914884,
0.5332561731,
-0.4844756722,
0.409861505,
0.4649948478,
0.1150368601,
0.0234646238,
-0.7488787174,
-0.6041058302,
-0.7256754041,
0.5872538686,
0.4205534756,
0.2041801065,
0.2620868385,
0.0266467649,
0.2124504894,
0.5263679028,
-0.4688712358,
-0.3894024193,
-0.250379622,
-0.1878067106,
-0.2060793042,
-0.3919453919,
0.1991204768,
-0.5282882452,
0.2181958407,
-0.1353990734,
0.1964783818,
-0.0452766418,
-0.1919122785,
-0.6275375485,
0.3773258924,
0.3518952429,
0.2849964797,
-0.4776808023,
0.3360749781,
-0.0762668401,
-0.4959757924,
-0.2572518885,
-0.0708368197,
-0.0941603556,
0.122979328,
0.1603672951,
1.2086235285,
0.4564016163,
-0.4249176979,
0.2254216224,
0.099052377,
-0.1855590791,
0.204671517,
0.2887608111,
0.2098583132,
0.0184609462,
0.3648017049,
0.6004132628,
-0.1018170118,
-0.6752851605,
0.3577662706,
0.2495128065,
-0.6433793902,
-0.442086786,
0.5580340028,
0.2714377046,
-0.3704495132,
0.2382569909,
-0.2545104325,
-0.5242794156,
0.5527685285,
0.6904643774,
0.7601156235,
-0.0797673017,
0.3408910334,
0.1908487231,
0.5693796277,
-0.224592939,
0.0911012739,
-0.0066059362,
-0.8600757122,
-0.7261011004,
-0.8540480137,
-0.3139025867,
0.246495232,
-0.4913129807,
0.4400290847,
-0.5464939475,
-0.1103781834,
-0.1984478682,
-0.1278326362,
-0.5904176235,
-0.0043859114,
0.4120399654,
1.0189707279,
-0.573255837,
1.1149326563,
0.7711932063,
-0.1991827935,
-0.6306125522,
0.5754577518,
-0.5105387568,
-0.4771078229,
0.4258606434,
0.24635306,
0.0005196432,
0.3235507309,
-0.6472935677,
-1.2383688688,
0.4522190988,
1.0228224993,
-0.7854079008,
-0.0211302433,
0.3500722945,
0.8576080799,
-0.4351733327,
-0.0177937057,
0.8191795945,
0.6135766506,
-0.0511799715,
-0.9361125827,
-0.0836030766,
-0.0932596251,
-0.3614268303,
0.1492245644,
-0.3213022947,
0.8871228695,
-0.293636173,
-0.723995924,
-0.0915451124,
0.7480361462,
0.1999934912,
-0.0369430929,
0.5011580586,
0.4932673872,
0.7193857431,
-0.3482165337,
0.9390938878,
-0.4268215597,
0.2784928381,
1.1360291243,
-0.0402337126,
0.8005108833,
0.4852793813,
0.0707431212,
0.5321776867,
0.3034340143,
0.0743714571,
0.5173234344,
0.2278514951,
0.4437341094,
-0.6435319781,
0.0598316453,
-0.3518930972,
0.4271090627,
0.6398127079,
-0.1246413663,
-0.4677685499,
-0.0757732317,
-0.3254570365,
0.3614967167,
-0.3352178633,
0.5803284645,
0.3698891997,
-0.4988139272,
0.8021492958,
-0.1048694551,
1.1013532877,
-0.247043252,
0.0344037116,
-0.1087493971,
0.2772728205,
-0.3511441946,
-0.585046649,
0.3042158782,
-0.2862254083,
-0.0834595412,
-0.5561758876,
0.966816783,
-0.7494367957,
-0.2696453631,
0.4577289224,
0.435295403,
-0.2641939223,
-0.4874334931,
-0.4392810762,
-0.0625845566,
-0.014801871,
-0.1917682588,
0.1720419079,
0.3688432574,
0.1648112833,
0.6112691164,
0.5830739737,
0.3131084442,
0.1674173772,
0.3663858473,
0.8464078307,
-0.6092866659,
-0.598680079,
-0.9512964487,
0.4927826822,
-0.031441465,
-0.2983561158,
0.9555972815,
0.3525714576,
0.6819117665,
-0.3071791232,
0.5695678592,
0.5117490888,
0.6438273787,
-0.462266326,
1.0407116413,
-0.4153795242,
0.4545683563,
-0.3865656853,
-0.8538963795,
-0.3652210534,
0.3394218385,
-0.279297173,
-0.2060856819,
0.5514401793,
0.8347036242,
-0.2117914855,
0.0222490672,
0.3486648798,
0.6513286233,
0.0897988379,
0.2047726512,
1.0149326324,
-0.4497794807,
0.5387440324,
-0.3408221304,
-0.0375966579,
-0.280726254,
-0.8172131777,
-1.0437887907,
-0.4106832445,
-0.3995466828,
-0.1747827679,
0.0946648121,
0.9076992869,
0.922365725,
-1.0921550989,
-0.1998368651,
-0.166533947,
0.2828169465,
-0.1803316623,
-0.1538602412,
0.0763409883,
-0.5626339912,
-0.7662318349,
0.6643039584,
0.3859604597,
0.1189834848,
-0.2046724856,
-0.0637472421,
0.1691458821,
0.0647047758,
0.5962961316,
0.0433896035,
-0.5545236468,
-0.2383101881,
0.0943613648,
-0.07820189,
0.2478130311,
0.9308488369,
-0.9804070592,
0.1378193349,
0.5725646019,
0.4924177825,
0.543022275,
0.0085005034,
0.9812279344,
-1.1504696608,
0.367025286,
0.159326598,
0.3384667635,
0.2400701344,
-0.3851877749,
0.0744476169,
0.0222965367,
0.0540595539,
-1.0457231998,
0.4065676033,
-0.6927576661,
-0.3187856376,
1.2113752365,
0.3820131421,
-0.3413526416,
-0.1965314746,
-0.3228332102,
0.2898475528,
-0.6460167766,
0.8376068473,
0.458465904,
0.291780442,
-0.2163300067,
-0.1700250208,
0.943688333,
0.6014246941,
-0.5544908047,
0.1505309939,
-0.1029460281,
-0.1193081513,
0.3457219601,
0.1158840358,
-0.1904009283,
-0.1168372706,
-0.2222433835,
-0.1540805399,
-0.2480626404,
-0.6299527287,
-0.2327150255,
0.3940226734,
0.1756306142,
-0.1173864827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08841v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08841v2 | AugTriever: Unsupervised Dense Retrieval by Scalable Data Augmentation | 2022-12-17T10:43:25 | 2023-03-07T20:51:26 | Rui Meng, Ye Liu, Semih Yavuz, Divyansh Agarwal, Lifu Tu, Ning Yu, Jianguo Zhang, Meghana Bhat, Yingbo Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Dense retrievers have made significant strides in text retrieval and
open-domain question answering, even though most achievements were made
possible only with large amounts of human supervision. In this work, we aim to
develop unsupervised methods by proposing two methods that create pseudo
query-document pairs and train dense retrieval models in an annotation-free and
scalable manner: query extraction and transferred query generation. The former
method produces pseudo queries by selecting salient spans from the original
document. The latter utilizes generation models trained for other NLP tasks
(e.g., summarization) to produce pseudo queries. Extensive experiments show
that models trained with the proposed augmentation methods can perform
comparably well (or better) to multiple strong baselines. Combining those
strategies leads to further improvements, achieving the state-of-the-art
performance of unsupervised dense retrieval on both BEIR and ODQA datasets. | [
-0.546625495,
-1.024546504,
0.3632177413,
-0.1311987638,
-0.1164036319,
-0.2066379189,
-0.0912534744,
-0.5287198424,
0.3395089805,
0.9709239006,
-0.3001141548,
0.0703690276,
-0.3175157607,
0.0711012483,
-0.6509683728,
0.8655362129,
0.1750835329,
-0.1068300679,
-0.4078205228,
-0.3093410134,
-0.1371692568,
-0.5063419938,
-0.4374042153,
-0.0143712023,
0.2314752936,
0.411991328,
0.6711795926,
0.3168097734,
0.3992304504,
0.3118719757,
0.1244913861,
0.4962798059,
-0.730287075,
0.2053551078,
-0.0039532795,
-0.6558095813,
-0.0393880606,
-0.1604192555,
0.8171366453,
0.9733317494,
-0.0149316397,
-0.0507864691,
-0.006445202,
0.6624712348,
-0.7555598021,
-0.2982567549,
-0.7817494273,
-0.0433869213,
-0.1326466948,
-0.3577521741,
-0.2571022809,
-0.4441446662,
0.2816405296,
-0.7154608965,
0.3352371752,
0.2546256483,
0.5491482615,
0.3943566084,
-0.4756389856,
-0.2165686935,
-0.4370158315,
0.6212208271,
-0.4761432409,
0.3750587106,
0.4545283318,
0.2134321183,
0.0187762547,
-1.2914882898,
-0.5050413013,
-0.1601112932,
-0.3503702283,
0.1603726298,
-0.1916353405,
-0.0391417295,
0.2384468466,
0.7610045075,
-0.7208836675,
0.1120383963,
-0.4202958345,
-0.1078997478,
0.6274586916,
-0.1028961837,
0.2697267234,
-0.1763557792,
-0.2875463068,
-0.0225587524,
-0.4365323782,
-0.1121741608,
0.1285634339,
0.0907680988,
0.411385417,
1.0806983709,
-0.54773283,
0.820862174,
0.2190786004,
0.3692677021,
0.2356044799,
-0.595161736,
-0.0240519308,
0.0517754182,
0.6427471042,
0.3065001369,
0.0915657878,
-0.5484007597,
-0.3140748739,
-0.4158759415,
0.3524794579,
-0.9605061412,
-0.4584953785,
0.1678685397,
-0.5459656119,
-0.0406846516,
0.1567925662,
-0.727373302,
-0.2390892357,
-0.3353996575,
0.6851574779,
-0.4165493548,
-0.2472349554,
0.1212148741,
-0.2292711139,
0.2580834031,
0.141848594,
-0.7327267528,
0.1148404405,
0.2953432202,
0.6622821689,
-0.0860382393,
-0.0530982539,
-0.7222417593,
-0.0324701183,
-0.3586031199,
0.8175679445,
-0.5137315392,
-0.5223569274,
0.0437639356,
-0.0218038242,
-0.0286868364,
-0.4158677757,
0.8288221955,
-0.8278480768,
0.6049752831,
-0.406164974,
-0.6650337577,
-0.1792353839,
0.1863490194,
-0.669128418,
1.5227876902,
0.3776779771,
-1.0063574314,
0.214294672,
-0.541977942,
-0.2857179046,
0.3248745203,
0.0888073519,
-0.1228240132,
0.3006687164,
0.687861979,
0.2469808012,
-0.2536666989,
-0.0971776247,
-0.0938894525,
-0.4141539037,
-0.0403352045,
-0.1841253489,
0.6857410669,
0.1490787417,
0.0593962334,
-0.0402298123,
-0.7642626166,
0.3012344241,
0.2891622186,
-0.156982094,
-0.7908642292,
-0.2161052823,
0.0675736442,
-0.0931280255,
0.5120530128,
-0.5743803382,
0.4177494943,
-0.7436906695,
0.4040281773,
0.0463625304,
0.3879715502,
0.9120884538,
-0.1847270578,
0.1522797048,
-0.2257625014,
0.0093157934,
-0.3906058669,
-0.2837177813,
-0.7661446333,
-0.1777499318,
0.1117453501,
0.4621709585,
-1.2299877405,
0.3624785542,
-0.1362956464,
-0.5299470425,
-0.7075302601,
0.0672756881,
0.1775594056,
0.9189486504,
0.7990548611,
-0.1434046179,
-0.5850846767,
-0.710631907,
-0.2684215009,
-0.1021604165,
-0.2346637398,
0.409743607,
0.3180387914,
-0.2145191133,
0.9313427806,
-0.789870739,
-0.2388069928,
-0.1126000732,
0.3837205172,
0.0567616485,
0.529533267,
0.7501282096,
-1.0506210327,
-0.3493380845,
-0.1052683815,
-0.7637744546,
-0.2336933762,
0.0281235259,
-0.3187005818,
-0.1865232885,
0.7420107126,
-0.6698216796,
0.3441853821,
-0.2084931135,
0.0307919271,
0.5246434212,
-0.4005502462,
0.3649046421,
-1.0345883369,
-0.0441488698,
-0.1744139791,
-0.1839209944,
-0.4825735688,
0.1884838641,
0.1841121167,
-0.0525635108,
-0.2233153582,
0.5161415935,
-0.7203757167,
-0.2314668447,
-0.3682624102,
0.0558736548,
0.1985468417,
0.0679909289,
0.0439365804,
1.1358287334,
0.5419172049,
-0.530236721,
0.3980273306,
0.5855495334,
-0.2748917937,
0.6944776177,
-0.9159476161,
0.212490499,
-0.4339025021,
0.0834832191,
-1.1399520636,
-0.1473469287,
-0.1439160109,
-0.4905306995,
0.2415133864,
-0.2813628316,
-0.7207830548,
-0.3317418993,
-0.1481718868,
0.4499611557,
0.3742412925,
-0.8973786235,
0.5179527402,
0.3658393919,
-0.2274066806,
-0.423722595,
-0.6956055164,
0.1335172653,
-0.2260367125,
-0.6144678593,
0.5657200217,
0.0376999304,
-0.1427169442,
0.0496718176,
0.0304091461,
-0.4270019829,
-0.1381382942,
-0.0568108968,
0.2911430597,
-0.3220990598,
0.030132072,
0.2441026866,
0.1783270687,
0.0265502296,
-0.4013644755,
0.120336324,
0.0188962724,
-0.3352479935,
0.2011196911,
0.5311658382,
0.0799714327,
-0.7717778087,
0.6948909163,
0.9015292525,
-0.3720850945,
-0.2066926658,
-0.7992144227,
-0.4367801845,
-0.4464739561,
0.2321254909,
-0.2303480059,
-1.1976822615,
0.256768316,
-0.0257497728,
0.1873861253,
0.4998427629,
0.339258939,
-0.1524624527,
0.8991917968,
0.6137340069,
0.0943063721,
0.4020177424,
-0.3653408289,
-0.0863689929,
-0.800712049,
-0.3731669784,
-0.7336219549,
-0.0203473587,
-0.4676086009,
-0.5640511513,
0.4508774579,
0.3075511456,
0.0462665632,
0.2677114904,
-0.7370786071,
0.5088814497,
0.5601158142,
0.0098394249,
0.2662904859,
0.1256412268,
-0.0863560215,
-0.1881971806,
-0.669362247,
-0.0045342301,
1.2446243763,
-0.3236869872,
0.5342915654,
0.0904889926,
0.5581302643,
0.3523137569,
-0.0168606527,
-0.5585355163,
0.3617485762,
0.1308562607,
-0.5996030569,
-0.2296394259,
-0.6432317495,
-1.0323255062,
0.6328479052,
-0.5317383409,
-0.7605746388,
0.3615080118,
-0.2700329423,
-0.2064832896,
0.0849929079,
-0.7384428382,
0.5517767668,
-0.3404347599,
-0.5278452635,
0.0638851076,
-0.9173210263,
0.4076836407,
-0.1537658274,
-0.2173952758,
0.3782811463,
-0.1997007132,
0.6447172165,
-0.4405472875,
0.2754381299,
-0.1541902274,
0.3762743473,
0.5440157652,
-0.1107506007,
0.5552917719,
0.1920793504,
-0.1956172436,
-0.1643954068,
0.061150603,
-0.4234780371,
-0.6489582062,
0.8441958427,
-0.6153542995,
-0.2869612277,
-0.3122657537,
-0.6973879933,
-0.3100613654,
0.6281074882,
0.3393267989,
0.3489868343,
-0.1995908916,
0.587071836,
1.0399657488,
0.0150925899,
0.5191323161,
0.6223868132,
-0.1411583871,
-0.3161458373,
0.678642869,
0.2476726472,
-0.2458172441,
0.6146737933,
-0.1241335645,
-0.96781528,
-0.8060877323,
-0.2595832646,
0.3043059111,
-0.5234695077,
-0.1617064327,
-0.9343566298,
-0.2451132089,
-0.5236680508,
-0.2026010901,
-0.2937504649,
-0.5671240091,
-0.4553302228,
-0.2092516422,
0.3963259161,
0.276150018,
-0.0649000183,
0.4188303351,
-0.9315689206,
0.5486861467,
0.2108238041,
-0.083700709,
-0.1615162194,
-0.7259002924,
-0.1618281454,
-0.0505880527,
0.0047083148,
-0.6457657218,
0.4602934718,
0.2317341566,
0.6749427915,
0.3033872545,
0.5340024829,
0.7047253847,
-0.2299502939,
0.6498337388,
-0.0453778207,
-0.3758104444,
0.4613037705,
-0.2293016016,
0.0649377853,
0.9239449501,
0.6190215349,
0.1741669178,
0.1734700948,
-0.5793454051,
-1.1113190651,
0.5476186872,
0.3411515951,
-0.0058561265,
0.0262426641,
0.6541470289,
0.1536102444,
0.3110919595,
-0.2392192185,
-0.1733740866,
-0.464043051,
0.1904753,
-0.0410463661,
-0.3887919486,
0.0657327175,
-0.1375390291,
0.4435833991,
-0.1226710975,
0.0512389019,
0.5790277123,
-0.4444954097,
-0.0300707631,
0.0599152111,
-0.0558491386,
0.5119729638,
-0.4377962649,
0.012755556,
0.0491384305,
-0.3910135329,
-0.191461727,
0.8000327945,
-0.3677188456,
0.0204148088,
0.1317525804,
0.6176386476,
0.239379853,
-0.6036913991,
0.4450854659,
-0.1037584245,
-0.1816342026,
-0.2788303792,
-0.1758361906,
-0.136008516,
0.278975755,
0.7742519379,
-0.2838883102,
0.6430228353,
-0.1964092404,
0.548535347,
0.5950546265,
-0.2961902618,
-0.2039544433,
0.9799201488,
-0.0155264223,
0.255347997,
0.8264052868,
-0.0143986577,
-0.0790869519,
0.1722409576,
0.40577057,
0.4203715324,
-0.0542125516,
0.1073850319,
0.4957092106,
0.4787661135,
-0.2648251355,
0.2579132318,
-0.4269531071,
-0.4712898433,
-0.4926621616,
-0.5986533165,
-0.2337608486,
0.0390338451,
-0.9282571673,
-0.0477286801,
0.0116260042,
-0.0169330835,
0.0779457018,
0.2263333648,
-0.4073169827,
0.4224755466,
-0.2816192508,
0.7991272807,
-0.5337587595,
0.5368780494,
0.9038046002,
-0.8381948471,
-0.6187136173,
-0.1483040005,
-0.2842730582,
-0.8485639095,
0.166875422,
0.0107565019,
0.26164186,
0.4605443478,
-0.4006480873,
-0.7814338207,
0.9295896292,
0.1795209646,
-0.2019803375,
-0.3086326122,
0.096995607,
0.4762566686,
-0.0901283473,
0.7335215211,
0.4209914505,
0.373647809,
0.3674849272,
-0.4998908639,
-0.1203611866,
-0.1882552505,
-0.1148252785,
0.2891041636,
-0.3559250236,
0.6704524159,
-0.1524083614,
-0.0116416849,
0.3128969371,
0.9990182519,
-0.0056924764,
0.3625153303,
0.3399312198,
0.920813024,
0.6450859904,
-0.2035098225,
1.1252788305,
-0.1335377544,
0.1095562279,
0.9768612385,
-0.0912698582,
0.750369668,
0.3675782681,
-0.0837633908,
-0.1006139666,
0.5544005036,
0.1697189659,
0.485662818,
-0.2729281187,
-0.1503892243,
-0.1323573738,
-0.369771719,
-0.6594617367,
0.4535751045,
0.4205674827,
-0.1864742935,
-0.3832112253,
-0.0219979361,
-0.0505889468,
0.0799777433,
-0.4300989211,
0.8614121079,
0.0233957283,
-0.7607722282,
0.5868334174,
-0.1068994552,
0.5483261347,
-0.5701075196,
0.0143192681,
-0.4788832068,
-0.1128976643,
-0.402192533,
-0.7622902989,
0.3274393976,
-0.2024974674,
-0.0943170488,
-0.0034081358,
1.1458590031,
-0.521238327,
-0.4057385325,
0.0264145415,
0.8680481315,
0.1956320107,
-0.482578963,
-0.7875733972,
-0.3551394939,
-0.0332493968,
-0.337323159,
0.4851492643,
0.7280231714,
-0.0856106281,
0.3425129056,
1.0186727047,
-0.0386135802,
0.2997170985,
0.1164898723,
1.1450448036,
-0.4297130704,
-0.4218308926,
-0.1767953485,
0.4828540683,
-0.2087299526,
-0.0173439123,
1.0457910299,
0.7956413031,
0.684386611,
0.1381611377,
0.687479198,
0.0303299502,
0.642770946,
-0.4158194065,
0.619348526,
-0.8696817756,
0.024297405,
-0.1478297859,
-1.3416819572,
-0.0822540447,
0.3913007677,
-0.2350998968,
0.067438893,
0.4342364669,
0.7322132587,
-0.2349190563,
0.0381085612,
0.1520524323,
0.1325147152,
0.0674177706,
0.2315184176,
0.7801630497,
-0.3548976481,
0.6867589951,
-0.248996675,
-0.1995246112,
-0.3417878747,
-0.4809150994,
-0.8154361248,
-0.647277832,
-0.0607467256,
-0.0918499604,
0.0303437635,
0.2926024199,
0.5324255824,
-0.431786716,
0.2943844497,
-0.1644697636,
-0.2515315413,
0.1233056709,
-0.2810520232,
0.5239879489,
-0.291795224,
-0.6429743767,
0.7287731767,
0.1656370908,
0.0047375239,
-0.145709753,
0.2685723007,
-0.4592037797,
0.0567436926,
0.5431703925,
0.5592864752,
-0.2576191127,
0.1208332777,
0.1229471117,
0.1164667755,
-0.0464838333,
0.6882721186,
-0.969099462,
0.6370506287,
0.7597789764,
1.0758205652,
0.8450215459,
0.5780997872,
0.1207180843,
-0.902901113,
0.3457826674,
0.4900597632,
0.3076173663,
0.5581023097,
-0.4180994034,
0.5824010372,
0.0938156545,
-0.6772603989,
-0.8997340202,
-0.0238751061,
-0.9825609326,
-0.2356632203,
0.8831298351,
0.0966725796,
0.0870413259,
-0.2115634531,
-0.3165681362,
0.0816582218,
-0.3578333259,
0.3521036506,
0.1117743552,
-0.1427063495,
-0.3297186494,
-0.5696333647,
0.2298621535,
0.5253452063,
-0.7538896203,
-0.3015088439,
0.7835610509,
-0.069308728,
0.014104154,
0.7097100616,
-0.2516070008,
0.0635168031,
0.0802394003,
-0.114971824,
-0.4860630631,
-0.0817210227,
0.1336127669,
0.5086331964,
-0.0956057683,
-0.043179445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08822v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08822v1 | Better Datastore, Better Translation: Generating Datastores from Pre-Trained Models for Nearest Neural Machine Translation | 2022-12-17T08:34:20 | 2022-12-17T08:34:20 | Jiahuan Li, Shanbo Cheng, Zewei Sun, Mingxuan Wang, Shujian Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Nearest Neighbor Machine Translation (kNNMT) is a simple and effective method
of augmenting neural machine translation (NMT) with a token-level nearest
neighbor retrieval mechanism. The effectiveness of kNNMT directly depends on
the quality of retrieved neighbors. However, original kNNMT builds datastores
based on representations from NMT models, which would result in poor retrieval
accuracy when NMT models are not good enough, leading to sub-optimal
translation performance. In this paper, we propose PRED, a framework that
leverages Pre-trained models for Datastores in kNN-MT. Better representations
from pre-trained models allow us to build datastores of better quality. We also
design a novel contrastive alignment objective to mitigate the representation
gap between the NMT model and pre-trained models, enabling the NMT model to
retrieve from better datastores. We conduct extensive experiments on both
bilingual and multilingual translation benchmarks, including WMT17 English
$\leftrightarrow$ Chinese, WMT14 English $\leftrightarrow$ German, IWSLT14
German $\leftrightarrow$ English, and IWSLT14 multilingual datasets. Empirical
results demonstrate the effectiveness of PRED. | [
-0.4639112055,
-0.3057026565,
0.4766635299,
-0.0267124791,
-0.5380147099,
-0.117852129,
-0.2249287814,
-0.1480847448,
0.3457630277,
0.537566185,
-0.3263948858,
-0.6695896983,
-0.5860163569,
0.3534305394,
-0.2705179453,
0.9222514629,
-0.1350158155,
0.2334498763,
-0.2226595432,
-0.1317428946,
-0.462365061,
-0.7342934608,
-0.2311656922,
-0.2925916016,
0.5555816293,
0.244906351,
1.049737215,
0.8921565413,
0.7428950667,
0.3665282726,
0.1320337355,
0.0974778011,
-0.3679955602,
-0.083932139,
-0.1252966523,
-0.5182334781,
-0.4881040156,
-0.1069747582,
0.2951971889,
0.7149320245,
-0.0211815424,
0.006055031,
-0.0334591307,
0.6685492992,
-0.2972083092,
-0.0556610897,
-0.4613722563,
0.2529452145,
-0.4933660328,
-0.0409538448,
-0.2478307933,
-0.6197406054,
0.2759000361,
-0.7331477404,
0.0661444366,
-0.0056801876,
0.9470888376,
0.3314655423,
-0.6351881027,
0.0660300627,
-0.4471282661,
0.6238254905,
-0.9783467054,
0.8675739765,
0.51571244,
0.4175115526,
-0.2530263364,
-0.9285404682,
-0.6019508839,
-0.0556139275,
-0.2912822068,
0.1995230466,
0.1215468794,
-0.191946134,
0.042358622,
0.4485243559,
-0.7430266142,
0.09489768,
-0.0341146141,
-0.2210094482,
0.1220993027,
0.2094236165,
-0.0383478142,
-0.3850900233,
-0.4928191006,
-0.3265245855,
-0.601575017,
-0.4802465737,
0.3384515047,
0.5831928253,
0.1510363519,
0.4405822754,
-0.2401545346,
0.7158194184,
-0.0662734956,
0.1649609953,
0.4294891655,
-0.5883125067,
0.0426038727,
-0.0029948128,
0.8501181602,
0.5325306654,
0.0319817662,
-0.6180258393,
-0.5461792946,
-0.0923829228,
0.3767525852,
-1.0017750263,
-0.3854209781,
-0.1132535934,
-0.6565841436,
-0.4062504768,
-0.0443075933,
-0.7599553466,
-0.0596412793,
-0.5614761114,
0.6883209348,
-0.4617908001,
-0.5510476232,
-0.1408355236,
0.2528208792,
-0.1630192548,
-0.1602854878,
-0.56388551,
0.3205374777,
0.4742327034,
1.1198333502,
-0.4573322833,
-0.4952546358,
-0.2545020282,
0.1296318322,
-0.5515587926,
0.5102350712,
-0.2299056947,
-0.2902224362,
-0.258535713,
-0.1321309209,
0.0615862161,
-0.7729352713,
0.4584856331,
-0.8594083786,
0.2845735848,
-0.5583422184,
-0.5648422241,
-0.1186290756,
0.3838255703,
-0.7447807193,
1.0132448673,
0.3380919099,
-0.820659399,
0.3783798814,
-0.9141016603,
-0.4922112525,
-0.0690596253,
0.1330267489,
-0.3409109414,
0.2774053812,
0.4734309614,
0.4136736691,
-0.2237157226,
0.5138404369,
-0.1426786482,
-0.1139801294,
0.0771640241,
-0.3115208149,
0.4138987362,
0.4358676374,
-0.1401988268,
0.0591967031,
-0.5464589,
0.0780249014,
0.1458894163,
-0.1337305009,
-0.4923430383,
-0.1194050759,
0.0176390745,
0.540438652,
0.3057630956,
-0.3876346648,
0.1046388,
-0.5085343122,
0.3666376472,
0.8517786264,
-0.2950733304,
0.6607939005,
-0.1647867262,
0.551815331,
0.5121762753,
0.1098269746,
-0.1008148044,
-0.1293763518,
-0.3258831203,
0.0636318401,
0.7631130815,
0.420278877,
-1.3338717222,
0.2778044045,
-0.7246443629,
-0.2972038686,
-0.8205322623,
0.0675943941,
0.4705777764,
1.0258381367,
0.6346943974,
-0.3088174462,
-0.4997602105,
-0.9134886861,
-0.0990844965,
0.2964446545,
0.0688535273,
0.1749192029,
0.4059017599,
-0.3669905663,
0.9371017218,
-0.3267508447,
-0.3863269389,
0.1248011738,
-0.0799121186,
0.5640024543,
0.5479726791,
0.5184210539,
-1.0418335199,
-0.6565685272,
0.3480955064,
-0.7124946117,
0.0452978276,
0.2748457789,
-0.5201491714,
0.0160395764,
0.4674971998,
-0.6393582225,
0.2418256551,
0.4983251393,
0.0139446147,
0.5626822114,
-0.1367464513,
0.3605030477,
-1.6891342402,
0.2289628685,
-0.5757992268,
-0.3941844106,
-0.5963551402,
0.1171762496,
0.2437210679,
-0.1899805218,
-0.4295326769,
0.357339859,
-0.3543168604,
-0.4594631195,
-0.1588752419,
0.3134157956,
-0.0931121856,
0.3288390636,
0.1751020402,
0.97074157,
0.1836302876,
-0.6629597545,
0.2693785131,
0.39879179,
-0.4606276453,
0.6743764877,
-0.543150723,
0.2682376802,
0.1725894958,
0.0838909522,
-0.5999525189,
-0.2338534147,
-0.1097281724,
-0.4764887094,
0.3435245156,
-0.1986541003,
-0.8460629582,
-0.5515669584,
0.1107837185,
0.4346974194,
0.3503919244,
-0.9061146379,
0.3869024515,
0.0336827636,
-0.1479792297,
-0.6974058151,
-0.7543798089,
0.1562749296,
-0.1646329015,
-0.5843096375,
0.3884605467,
0.066403158,
0.2986448705,
0.2618786991,
-0.2008361071,
-0.2458389252,
-0.0479575098,
-0.1822051704,
0.1618261933,
-0.7064216733,
0.0592100434,
-0.0120406002,
-0.5828986168,
-0.1220178902,
-0.7846399546,
0.736150682,
-0.1175910681,
-0.2421747446,
-0.1642087996,
0.3251556754,
0.4304657578,
-0.319624275,
0.7399695516,
0.6754838228,
-0.3050452769,
0.2298633605,
-0.309656322,
-0.3855322897,
-0.5201851726,
0.6111788154,
-0.7107087374,
-0.6814467907,
0.6750696301,
-0.2782913148,
-0.0869030282,
0.2222495526,
0.2734637558,
-0.1074013114,
1.1348150969,
0.2769943774,
-0.1734690517,
0.4054707587,
-0.1626660228,
0.244576022,
-0.8444781303,
-0.1513661295,
-0.3945171833,
-0.6593145132,
-0.5360295773,
-0.4081356823,
0.0974543914,
0.3734188676,
-0.1170054972,
0.7543651462,
-0.4860420227,
0.7830924392,
0.6028422117,
0.1123808324,
0.1972381026,
0.0228656158,
-0.6428545117,
-0.6394707561,
-0.8323066831,
-0.5026524067,
1.0945402384,
-0.0905455798,
0.2385171354,
0.2712706327,
0.9409300685,
-0.1378784329,
0.5009863973,
-0.4684746861,
0.4100235999,
-0.3848252892,
-0.5918052793,
0.0248718206,
-0.8437986374,
-0.9318655729,
0.265573293,
0.0165480636,
-0.3221835494,
0.0342770293,
0.1546394825,
0.0808308944,
0.4384173751,
-0.7047071457,
1.194018364,
-0.4198152423,
-0.1875076294,
0.201249674,
-0.8617346287,
0.1949005425,
-0.4024229944,
-0.0500909723,
0.3011808395,
-0.0540913939,
0.4729447067,
-0.7868924141,
0.3257727623,
-0.4460389316,
0.1166411787,
-0.2678666115,
0.3603720069,
0.6587340236,
-0.2156348675,
-0.3495725989,
0.2825704217,
-0.0772346482,
-0.4791116416,
-0.7355769277,
0.7544791698,
-0.7089844346,
-0.1564578414,
-0.0196796264,
-0.5472158194,
-0.2711863518,
0.8118836284,
0.6426874399,
0.3632234335,
-0.1017070338,
0.2558998466,
0.4572591484,
-0.0630349889,
0.2310526669,
0.542858541,
-0.4205756485,
-0.7181918621,
1.0802675486,
0.2043187022,
0.2708474696,
0.5368712544,
0.2495829761,
-0.7471717,
-0.8178771734,
-0.468870014,
-0.129113853,
-0.7440944314,
-0.6465922594,
-0.6354449391,
0.0371066481,
-0.4313629568,
-0.2138277739,
-0.7183730006,
-0.3399090469,
-0.1834463775,
-0.1784687787,
0.3590310812,
0.6522761583,
-0.2067189664,
0.680644691,
-0.8050889969,
0.4359227717,
-0.0667195171,
0.516043961,
-0.037478812,
-0.3846428394,
-0.280977577,
0.2127932757,
-0.091824159,
-0.7807264328,
0.4946575761,
0.0149216466,
0.4877034724,
0.2521368861,
0.140138343,
0.9888706803,
-0.6542208195,
0.5678902268,
0.2092654258,
-0.7981595993,
0.4392325282,
-0.2580526769,
0.4548284709,
0.9381952286,
0.6665815115,
-0.5343016386,
-0.1226043701,
-0.4159173071,
-0.9148235917,
0.655759573,
0.2462741286,
0.0916677043,
-0.146439001,
0.3906119168,
0.3907028139,
0.2966439128,
-0.6913072467,
-0.1487120241,
-0.5062077045,
-0.5229738951,
-0.2079054415,
0.2546102405,
0.3604047894,
-0.2117514312,
0.6080722809,
-0.0590627864,
0.259955883,
0.1056308225,
-0.4806677103,
0.2694977224,
-0.1693365127,
0.366672188,
0.3952589929,
-0.1759712845,
0.1409858167,
0.1952124238,
-0.5504610538,
0.000016665,
0.1457067281,
-0.3669974208,
0.1735847145,
0.1470903754,
0.7500561476,
0.2349777222,
-0.0484912097,
0.5910806656,
-0.0964084789,
-0.1399023533,
0.2411812395,
-0.3397544026,
0.2849645317,
0.1370013207,
0.1168008,
0.2107773274,
0.0146137476,
-0.0417624265,
0.5947546959,
0.0688304603,
-0.2659457624,
-0.370632112,
0.7768729925,
0.0551243611,
-0.4404389262,
1.00451684,
-0.0695385933,
-0.9270197153,
0.3475804925,
0.7453886867,
0.6547842026,
-0.4604584873,
-0.0071210377,
0.4912939966,
0.3473314047,
-0.1453947127,
0.2141205221,
-0.2264261097,
-0.5600797534,
-0.5346841812,
-0.7190455794,
-0.0336932465,
-0.0103260325,
-0.8024923801,
0.1904205084,
-0.0796305537,
-0.4485043585,
-0.3852829039,
0.0535380393,
-0.8064768314,
0.0306556225,
-0.4921348691,
0.8098291755,
-0.5741842389,
0.9676020741,
0.5345490575,
-0.425968647,
-0.7707726359,
-0.0782889351,
-0.36041677,
-0.4875003397,
0.6496289968,
0.0399716608,
0.1465015709,
0.3092441261,
-0.2526046336,
-0.8645908833,
1.0222939253,
0.7113401294,
-0.6378825307,
0.1217447147,
0.5490312576,
0.5704870224,
-0.2616634369,
0.0678582564,
0.3522616625,
0.5957211256,
-0.1657053232,
-0.7796717882,
-0.0898530707,
-0.2750234902,
0.12990053,
0.5956616402,
-0.1879406869,
0.6584580541,
-0.0100513762,
-0.0157775022,
0.2052610219,
0.6327120662,
-0.0516561791,
0.2945503294,
0.280429244,
0.7849769592,
0.7384816408,
-0.214595139,
1.2176653147,
-0.1485463083,
0.019350417,
1.6148892641,
-0.0713026747,
0.9939786792,
0.4976154268,
-0.0376412682,
0.1008581445,
0.7018707395,
0.1591336131,
0.9447505474,
0.0752234459,
0.1234857813,
-0.1235090494,
0.0156354718,
-0.645293951,
0.294000417,
0.0321625061,
-0.3486820757,
-0.1658273637,
0.1036161035,
-0.106716305,
0.2345811576,
0.0465304404,
0.8482222557,
0.1073131189,
-0.3952870369,
0.531377852,
-0.1406859159,
0.6483901143,
-0.5156641006,
0.195494622,
-0.5983495712,
0.1949935406,
-0.0656109825,
-0.567366302,
0.3657076657,
-0.0399371795,
-0.3148702383,
-0.3187013268,
0.5033775568,
-0.6251596808,
-0.2579754293,
0.3123609126,
0.462680608,
0.3792770207,
-0.1092552543,
-0.7526880503,
-0.2092018872,
-0.1890332401,
-0.2650169432,
0.3951027393,
0.7265615463,
-0.1264084727,
0.3426996768,
1.0206235647,
0.1416509598,
0.2837801576,
0.0600910187,
0.7495709062,
-0.5965201855,
-0.6423895955,
-0.6839248538,
0.2349223346,
-0.187352255,
-0.3309767544,
0.7997657061,
0.7878088951,
1.0611619949,
-0.0930337608,
0.1505164206,
0.1494751722,
0.5049250722,
-0.4517339468,
0.9392774105,
-0.5323183537,
-0.0822722688,
-0.403472513,
-1.453342557,
-0.3507987559,
0.7525556087,
-0.2092559934,
0.177842468,
0.6464352608,
0.8637515903,
-0.5058768392,
-0.0132930959,
0.5112082362,
0.3300601542,
0.1944650263,
0.6075183153,
0.8971722722,
-0.7872604728,
0.6548002958,
-0.4734329283,
0.3312282562,
0.0124301026,
-1.0360958576,
-0.7137340903,
-0.6522459984,
-0.0902558714,
-0.2011264861,
-0.0944161639,
0.7923469543,
0.9176563621,
-0.707650423,
0.1271858066,
-0.233611241,
0.0639451742,
-0.0740812197,
-0.1773492694,
0.527258575,
-0.2773334682,
-0.570762217,
0.4721671641,
-0.0099869678,
0.187320739,
0.1614952385,
-0.5912563801,
0.0189122334,
-0.4240767658,
0.5524262786,
-0.0893127322,
-0.3314100504,
0.0498228595,
0.1971417814,
-0.2689117491,
0.1770236194,
0.6698121428,
-0.6513164043,
0.6189864874,
0.439884901,
1.0323822498,
0.6661646366,
-0.0580949374,
0.74148947,
-0.8449026942,
0.1425947994,
0.460526228,
0.0659722909,
0.4693169594,
-0.1577181965,
0.5914415717,
0.0045778113,
-0.4216112494,
-1.0501083136,
0.1023223773,
-0.4543540478,
-0.1211211458,
0.6041169167,
-0.269046545,
-0.2101951391,
-0.0954054669,
0.0104935374,
0.3172164857,
-0.0922944993,
0.4946743548,
0.7033663392,
0.4200099111,
0.088729158,
-0.8242803216,
0.4820232987,
0.6650896072,
-0.7584437132,
-0.0136739751,
0.2914944887,
0.0589742661,
0.0790694803,
0.5042003989,
-0.5353304744,
0.1444743574,
-0.093105644,
-0.1256553829,
-0.379661411,
-0.2565084696,
-0.1649595648,
-0.1273102313,
-0.1591708213,
-0.1598683149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08802v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08802v2 | Relational Sentence Embedding for Flexible Semantic Matching | 2022-12-17T05:25:17 | 2023-06-08T12:44:28 | Bin Wang, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present Relational Sentence Embedding (RSE), a new paradigm to further
discover the potential of sentence embeddings. Prior work mainly models the
similarity between sentences based on their embedding distance. Because of the
complex semantic meanings conveyed, sentence pairs can have various relation
types, including but not limited to entailment, paraphrasing, and
question-answer. It poses challenges to existing embedding methods to capture
such relational information. We handle the problem by learning associated
relational embeddings. Specifically, a relation-wise translation operation is
applied to the source sentence to infer the corresponding target sentence with
a pre-trained Siamese-based encoder. The fine-grained relational similarity
scores can be computed from learned embeddings. We benchmark our method on 19
datasets covering a wide range of tasks, including semantic textual similarity,
transfer, and domain-specific tasks. Experimental results show that our method
is effective and flexible in modeling sentence relations and outperforms a
series of state-of-the-art sentence embedding methods.
https://github.com/BinWang28/RSE | [
-0.1230622754,
-0.7423024774,
0.9265832901,
0.1853539795,
-0.4265399277,
-0.4221110344,
-0.1128942445,
-0.3542279303,
0.2913202941,
0.6454635859,
-0.5260388851,
-0.5479161143,
-0.3536545634,
0.236237973,
-0.187465176,
0.7144404054,
-0.2076795697,
0.1142395139,
-0.7828166485,
-0.506541431,
-0.5036261082,
-0.1023849249,
0.0327627286,
0.1340251118,
0.382475704,
0.3112150133,
0.9272054434,
0.7317559123,
0.649479866,
0.2141268253,
0.0307283048,
0.2185541689,
-0.4330077469,
0.5954850316,
-0.3787368238,
-0.4451469183,
-0.1792137772,
-0.1115989611,
0.6313055754,
1.0042915344,
-0.2752322853,
0.1852947026,
-0.2266231924,
0.6321075559,
-0.8706005812,
0.1877455413,
-0.629054606,
0.2453659326,
-0.1640339047,
-0.0509635955,
-0.4809192419,
-0.4445756972,
0.0765234306,
-0.7424504161,
-0.2152007967,
0.241475448,
0.844935596,
0.1816503555,
-0.6917788982,
-0.3590397835,
-0.54517591,
0.4417215586,
-0.4297594726,
0.7079153061,
0.3143278062,
0.345420301,
-0.1004368365,
-0.879912138,
-0.4514876604,
-0.3488164842,
-0.1215242445,
-0.0239985939,
0.1855596602,
-0.092921339,
0.2986599803,
0.3754177988,
-0.7134686708,
-0.3956065476,
0.1324054897,
0.2131699771,
0.456228435,
0.2205617577,
0.3648961186,
-0.1987262368,
-0.5604698658,
-0.1270979196,
-0.6581541896,
-0.260441035,
0.1243756488,
0.3659648001,
0.1559632421,
0.8472605944,
-0.3086664081,
0.6078724861,
-0.23789832,
0.4417603612,
0.1842419952,
-0.5821370482,
-0.0657624528,
-0.0961472914,
0.8490194678,
0.4686907232,
0.4671701789,
-0.4369647205,
-0.0247159507,
0.1557015926,
0.1718816608,
-0.6842647791,
-0.132615909,
-0.2692451477,
-0.4204783142,
-0.0996549129,
0.3421405852,
-0.6642003059,
-0.2059865892,
-0.0968143493,
0.3103402853,
-0.5851725936,
-0.1893747598,
0.3446157277,
-0.1598572135,
0.528729558,
-0.1769900769,
-0.8210635781,
0.5656417012,
0.573294282,
0.7782449722,
0.1363077015,
-0.1954326034,
-0.6852155924,
0.3968455791,
-0.1517980397,
0.6111395359,
-0.8636062145,
-0.2220958769,
0.1386680603,
-0.1665793508,
-0.1075662971,
-0.4052854776,
0.4127520621,
-0.6138473749,
0.2789852321,
-0.2220068127,
-0.9038054347,
0.0496516153,
0.3325944841,
-0.5540938973,
0.7850566506,
0.4081108272,
-0.7989932895,
0.1633786857,
-0.3808705807,
-0.4622173011,
0.023179559,
-0.2226332426,
-0.6850348115,
0.0692325756,
0.1290896386,
0.5573504567,
-0.2971515059,
0.0752206892,
-0.8459671736,
-0.1447634399,
0.1674239188,
0.1756134033,
0.5827506781,
0.0717148706,
0.2151573449,
0.0818756372,
-0.5126381516,
0.0587831512,
0.2341639698,
0.2707143426,
-0.6710387468,
-0.0799573362,
0.2141761333,
0.1967648417,
0.197211042,
-0.6803364158,
0.1768931001,
-0.4269115925,
0.6756682396,
0.2329636216,
0.2526573241,
0.679127574,
-0.2914049625,
0.4254949391,
0.0769765303,
0.101965718,
-0.1502598226,
-0.249603644,
-0.203659445,
0.1555320174,
0.4915159941,
0.655923605,
-0.551725328,
0.544698298,
-0.4959295392,
-0.1882598698,
-0.5066423416,
0.0953947455,
0.2838120162,
0.1574767828,
0.5547565818,
-0.3906626403,
-0.5029962063,
-0.949796319,
-0.6440203786,
0.1387207061,
-0.034295138,
0.2530280352,
0.4672239423,
-0.2077441067,
1.0906838179,
-0.6925910115,
-0.446311146,
-0.1934160143,
-0.3330850005,
-0.3089797199,
0.4634172916,
0.4856164455,
-0.9740042686,
-0.7524015903,
-0.1011339426,
-0.9537928104,
0.3232490718,
-0.1931078732,
-0.2645026147,
-0.2024527639,
0.8087192178,
-0.9095305204,
0.0231943913,
0.2333201915,
-0.5646343827,
0.0633427054,
-0.145575285,
0.0081992289,
-1.4606950283,
-0.2777948081,
-0.0770281404,
-0.6941019297,
-0.1457679868,
0.2190667242,
0.1828525513,
-0.1843749732,
-0.3153186142,
0.0798536539,
-0.5528838038,
-0.1375826597,
0.2760081887,
0.6780848503,
0.0477539822,
0.2787209451,
-0.1224615872,
0.3503348529,
0.4683527052,
-0.1690104306,
0.4893233478,
0.679874897,
-0.3501718044,
0.7091412544,
-0.5606668591,
0.261703074,
-0.1534222066,
0.3344281614,
-0.7780739665,
-0.009271577,
0.2498999983,
-0.3547773659,
0.2443671823,
-0.0565878935,
-0.4210623801,
0.0685222447,
-0.4727291763,
0.3505506217,
0.2594323158,
-0.2196920365,
0.6704909801,
0.3255470991,
-0.1068308279,
-0.3868723214,
-0.6726695895,
0.0973814279,
-0.1737538427,
-0.6995723844,
0.648820281,
0.2869939506,
-0.1150692254,
0.6837813854,
-0.2106368542,
-0.2447515279,
0.0818879232,
0.0649923235,
0.1202085167,
-0.531383574,
0.2205404639,
0.1263817847,
-0.0935647413,
0.1056986824,
-0.1991575211,
0.2546582222,
-0.1988663375,
-0.2499293834,
-0.2704970539,
0.614094615,
0.3622551858,
-0.4574260414,
1.0047966242,
0.4727810323,
-0.6028213501,
-0.1328801513,
-0.082714133,
-0.2725471556,
-0.4012902081,
0.5622133613,
-0.638985455,
-1.0199635029,
0.2125507146,
-0.2426632345,
-0.2181815058,
0.2860950828,
-0.1636739522,
-0.0511618853,
0.735717535,
0.6557619572,
0.1273246855,
0.3550698459,
-0.0970908403,
0.3600150645,
-0.8291425109,
-0.1562303752,
-0.3406232893,
-0.0468968265,
-0.8872118592,
-0.3728353679,
-0.0696420595,
0.3479138613,
-0.363283962,
0.6013041139,
-0.118447125,
0.5880585313,
0.2004396021,
0.1926946789,
0.0671581551,
-0.4181484282,
-0.0346433036,
-0.1620108038,
-0.589171648,
-0.4646805525,
0.8975346684,
0.0473206714,
0.5212407112,
0.2067403495,
0.716766119,
0.1085362956,
-0.0717969313,
-0.7113292813,
0.6275978684,
-0.1586211771,
-0.0354522616,
-0.259499073,
-0.6411632299,
-0.8573175073,
0.2648834288,
-0.6627072692,
-0.4506611228,
-0.1269335151,
-0.2050724477,
-0.201805532,
0.0653337911,
-0.5738145709,
1.334069252,
0.0693937987,
-0.3883824348,
-0.1923074871,
-0.8866331577,
0.1233567894,
0.3042112291,
-0.1017328128,
-0.1273216307,
-0.1015226096,
0.5005146861,
-0.1868863404,
0.3216360509,
-0.1063176394,
0.3511895239,
-0.0962146968,
0.2474504858,
0.4171527028,
0.4346525669,
-0.0021671657,
-0.2597568333,
0.3580535352,
-0.4675571322,
-0.9957768321,
0.8093797565,
-0.4944865108,
-0.3428627253,
-0.4507930279,
-0.4894165695,
-0.5593052506,
0.350150913,
-0.2211920172,
0.3289084435,
-0.5428465009,
0.5587777495,
0.5163705349,
-0.0490505174,
0.0521723554,
0.260579586,
-0.1127764136,
-0.4579282403,
0.5910840034,
-0.2686383724,
0.1905039996,
0.8943052888,
0.1096339598,
-0.5100366473,
-0.2374570072,
-0.1924831569,
0.4778243899,
-0.4776802957,
-0.3269810081,
-0.5791038871,
0.0513893962,
-0.5080227852,
-0.1797709614,
-0.4989219606,
-0.4286974072,
-0.1376016885,
-0.0698650479,
0.3661393523,
0.8783169389,
0.3720770776,
-0.100217849,
-0.8960246444,
0.2957195938,
0.1858560741,
0.5101420283,
-0.4365453422,
-0.0680517182,
-0.1104367003,
0.1183001399,
-0.243411988,
-1.0479637384,
0.0651657432,
0.4415714145,
0.4338296652,
0.0913902894,
0.5045548081,
0.6296207309,
-0.6748742461,
0.6450264454,
-0.0056014219,
-0.9594302177,
0.6630696654,
-0.1994365603,
0.0064998968,
0.7353532314,
0.5383609533,
-0.6417108774,
-0.2410271466,
-0.5109872818,
-0.803596139,
0.2843443751,
0.2314031273,
0.2088342011,
-0.2928534448,
0.7197173834,
-0.1639246196,
0.0885460526,
-0.642862916,
-0.0498249605,
-0.1154973879,
-0.6089192629,
0.0002740574,
-0.1954791546,
0.2421061993,
0.0651220158,
0.3451497257,
0.058214318,
0.2848501503,
0.2733252048,
-0.5568010807,
-0.0619318374,
0.297500968,
0.3200252056,
0.3578670621,
-0.2462984174,
0.1124961227,
0.2689556181,
-0.0293098222,
-0.1667894274,
0.1809207797,
0.0135635985,
-0.0177485049,
0.4273109734,
0.7445043921,
0.3878943622,
-0.5222996473,
0.8585836291,
-0.0894864947,
-0.0705195889,
-0.3169035017,
-0.1430043578,
0.4534763098,
0.2957737446,
-0.333750844,
0.05547316,
0.1926327795,
-0.6432269216,
0.5230625272,
0.5171995759,
-0.7531143427,
-0.1913643777,
0.7307585478,
0.0527606569,
-0.5072142482,
0.7998498082,
-0.1937741339,
-0.376257658,
0.2580925822,
0.6332412958,
0.7230958343,
-0.2223002762,
0.2479278296,
0.2440199256,
0.0984682515,
-0.1067987308,
0.1627451926,
-0.2482054383,
-0.7421436906,
-0.3869942725,
-0.431166023,
-0.4071621597,
-0.36002931,
-1.0497004986,
0.3565632403,
-0.0750165433,
0.3218988776,
-0.1876791269,
-0.0547622927,
-0.5274712443,
-0.2432350963,
-0.0567804128,
0.9364662766,
-0.9886805415,
0.8526600599,
0.8609192371,
-0.5636985898,
-0.5267365575,
0.0224353261,
-0.4549186528,
-0.2943406403,
0.3956146836,
0.3787818551,
-0.1239982173,
0.1018478274,
-0.0642472953,
-0.6120496392,
1.195515871,
0.5853216052,
-0.4340313375,
-0.1379743665,
0.3882458508,
0.4497901499,
-0.5782524347,
0.1473827809,
0.3250441551,
0.1080815792,
-0.3168039024,
-0.5546005964,
0.3937133551,
-0.241462335,
0.4515770972,
0.3895913064,
-0.2701818347,
0.4338476062,
-0.0969704911,
-0.1567408144,
0.0844235346,
0.8920659423,
-0.0527710021,
0.2237290293,
0.5774478316,
0.7610155344,
0.4884310365,
0.041512154,
0.9079381227,
-0.1841000617,
0.4977658689,
1.2371439934,
-0.6108711958,
1.3298273087,
0.4779141843,
-0.111237064,
0.9020088911,
0.45206213,
0.129455775,
0.7068564296,
0.1867474616,
-0.0913959071,
-0.4193533957,
-0.091472961,
-0.3238800764,
0.44462201,
0.346996516,
-0.3308154345,
-0.3054454625,
0.1601233482,
-0.3579221666,
0.8193526864,
0.1699401587,
0.891723156,
0.2273525447,
-0.4620311856,
0.2264727503,
-0.1437419355,
0.383325249,
-0.644334197,
-0.2138427198,
0.0140345423,
0.3404084444,
0.0133516397,
-0.8885948062,
0.6767362952,
-0.5215235353,
-0.1482168883,
-0.480343461,
0.5203069448,
-0.7971339822,
-0.0452239625,
0.3897115588,
0.4726475775,
-0.228702724,
-0.0891604722,
-0.551427424,
-0.2625961602,
-0.2249206901,
-0.1791042984,
0.4223736525,
0.8090128899,
0.0432617478,
0.4740017653,
0.3538998961,
-0.1701107472,
-0.1826501042,
-0.0772255212,
0.6936110854,
-0.8857140541,
-0.5258327127,
-0.7892277837,
0.1547664255,
-0.2201535851,
-0.2757364511,
0.7117018104,
0.8216573596,
0.9379553199,
-0.1522373408,
0.3415360153,
0.0771037415,
0.4060310423,
-0.5335062146,
0.3634335399,
-0.4052357078,
0.1184778214,
-0.1700845361,
-1.0841444731,
-0.5421034098,
1.0015323162,
-0.1970255971,
-0.1150761545,
0.9382828474,
0.7872763872,
-0.3340251744,
0.2649677694,
0.1360987574,
-0.0222203322,
0.016850926,
0.8528963327,
0.7905389071,
-0.7046504021,
0.588830471,
-0.2003120333,
0.0803498551,
0.0231728796,
-0.8525733352,
-0.7615438104,
-0.7939580083,
-0.4664581418,
-0.3042739332,
0.2984580994,
1.1089260578,
0.4425751865,
-0.5678473115,
-0.0476674289,
-0.5375256538,
0.0763641819,
-0.4111990929,
-0.2112334073,
0.3054108918,
-0.2881006896,
-0.4307988286,
0.2806825638,
0.2615175843,
-0.1936791092,
0.012904007,
0.0376352854,
-0.6077532768,
-0.159041062,
0.7338737249,
-0.0906141177,
-0.4864739478,
-0.5075408816,
0.2185215056,
-0.2385863364,
-0.1791505665,
0.7207057476,
-0.582269609,
0.2510125637,
0.5199565291,
0.9309680462,
0.6808244586,
-0.0882687196,
0.6875137687,
-0.826798439,
0.0049685631,
0.3978125751,
0.4029014707,
0.5056849122,
-0.1651924849,
0.4473913014,
0.2735435367,
-0.423815161,
-0.7984593511,
0.5006796718,
-1.2019209862,
-0.2609310746,
1.0736136436,
-0.4283906817,
-0.1510659903,
-0.0852785334,
0.0782889873,
0.3608702719,
0.0254592206,
0.2963947356,
0.5175748467,
0.0167071875,
-0.3092572689,
-0.184038654,
0.3370424211,
0.4431879818,
-0.6347594857,
0.0428288057,
0.2818160951,
0.3311533332,
0.0297652595,
0.2627931237,
-0.1092322394,
0.3293713033,
0.1261009723,
-0.2557836771,
-0.1870852858,
0.0448380075,
-0.0682725683,
0.2779249847,
0.0327045098,
-0.3836906254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08785v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08785v1 | Importance of Synthesizing High-quality Data for Text-to-SQL Parsing | 2022-12-17T02:53:21 | 2022-12-17T02:53:21 | Yiyun Zhao, Jiarong Jiang, Yiqun Hu, Wuwei Lan, Henry Zhu, Anuj Chauhan, Alexander Li, Lin Pan, Jun Wang, Chung-Wei Hang, Sheng Zhang, Marvin Dong, Joe Lilien, Patrick Ng, Zhiguo Wang, Vittorio Castelli, Bing Xiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, there has been increasing interest in synthesizing data to improve
downstream text-to-SQL tasks. In this paper, we first examined the existing
synthesized datasets and discovered that state-of-the-art text-to-SQL
algorithms did not further improve on popular benchmarks when trained with
augmented synthetic data. We observed two shortcomings: illogical synthetic SQL
queries from independent column sampling and arbitrary table joins. To address
these issues, we propose a novel synthesis framework that incorporates key
relationships from schema, imposes strong typing, and conducts
schema-distance-weighted column sampling. We also adopt an intermediate
representation (IR) for the SQL-to-text task to further improve the quality of
the generated natural language questions. When existing powerful semantic
parsers are pre-finetuned on our high-quality synthesized data, our experiments
show that these models have significant accuracy boosts on popular benchmarks,
including new state-of-the-art performance on Spider. | [
-0.3683197796,
-0.6520900726,
0.7250886559,
0.1671988219,
-0.1493636966,
0.1614263654,
-0.0640631169,
-0.4684354663,
0.2174920738,
0.5734726191,
-0.4766771495,
-0.5745612383,
-0.2057832927,
0.3780072927,
-0.7228250504,
1.0396286249,
0.246605292,
0.1317155957,
-0.1952112615,
-0.079991214,
-0.093193315,
-0.653634429,
-0.2136043012,
0.2036215961,
0.2588179708,
0.2177069783,
0.7123844028,
0.6914800406,
0.4022223651,
0.1745692044,
-0.0993745402,
0.5853796601,
-0.3792801201,
0.339214772,
-0.4939175248,
-0.3587763309,
-0.445145905,
0.0867218003,
0.7422504425,
1.0143181086,
0.0360966809,
0.1337700635,
0.1196655855,
0.8818929791,
-0.4883694947,
0.0519656688,
-1.1084218025,
-0.0946177766,
-0.3116457462,
-0.1303106099,
-0.6535249949,
-0.2282965928,
0.018717235,
-0.7100423574,
0.6179252267,
0.2095913589,
0.867417872,
0.0981134474,
-0.4396580756,
-0.2986345589,
-0.6975802779,
0.3582223654,
-0.686111331,
0.4421401918,
0.0480684154,
0.4669553041,
-0.6234269738,
-0.8884618282,
-0.6285889745,
-0.0956406817,
-0.2257857919,
-0.0849557146,
0.2851200104,
0.002604217,
0.0675904751,
0.4573494792,
-0.3811354637,
-0.2927369177,
-0.2362418622,
-0.1142538413,
0.6258447766,
0.3895458877,
0.1728069186,
-0.2873342633,
-0.3329477012,
-0.1462063342,
-0.8613981009,
-0.0513026379,
0.4015812874,
0.7417038679,
0.4771152735,
0.9430179,
-0.4960130453,
0.9998741746,
-0.0415949374,
0.4002445638,
-0.1869413704,
-0.7883399129,
-0.0880429223,
-0.1338335872,
0.6801413894,
0.4265556931,
0.0438268371,
-0.3271490335,
-0.1613712013,
0.2088820338,
0.2693537176,
-0.5902503729,
-0.4538376331,
0.4120692909,
-0.220191136,
-0.233298555,
-0.0180573221,
-0.9231802225,
-0.32690382,
-0.6411331892,
0.2943099737,
-0.4541602135,
-0.0346351042,
-0.1258995831,
-0.1468040049,
0.001541477,
0.2566766739,
-0.8958961368,
0.5887078047,
0.4897276163,
0.3313195109,
-0.3823386431,
-0.2349674404,
-0.5146580338,
0.4481489062,
-0.778737545,
0.98392272,
-0.3182924092,
-0.1424705684,
-0.2057074457,
-0.0690879971,
0.1449512094,
-0.7494056225,
0.2625092566,
-0.2109504789,
0.2455613017,
-0.378888458,
-0.6421735883,
0.3780692816,
0.1303319037,
-0.6941871047,
1.0709813833,
0.3501890004,
-0.5260955095,
0.5347667933,
-0.1884896159,
-0.5485759974,
-0.1517873257,
-0.1252529174,
-0.0823252648,
0.2669321299,
0.3912558258,
0.305382669,
-0.560566783,
0.1639731824,
-0.156003356,
-0.2537874281,
0.3292830288,
-0.0160089955,
0.4329992533,
0.2154609859,
0.1503342688,
-0.133147344,
-1.2053279877,
0.3522720337,
0.0616668314,
-0.286206156,
-0.1914267689,
0.2161926031,
0.0434791595,
0.0991430283,
-0.0070593678,
-0.4279164374,
-0.0710107237,
-0.8698940873,
0.4777607024,
0.4512189627,
0.1139423773,
0.5713000894,
0.0038135105,
-0.0343789309,
-0.0320961252,
-0.1752914041,
-0.1262325794,
-0.0204228237,
-0.7817146182,
-0.1380509138,
0.3663810492,
0.3925128579,
-0.7356504202,
0.5836681128,
-0.4339784384,
-0.4359445274,
-0.4072634578,
-0.1035690829,
0.1054268777,
0.3462077379,
0.660902679,
-0.1414027363,
-0.6612293124,
-0.7938995361,
-0.8122190833,
-0.1479160488,
-0.1492144316,
-0.0282694735,
0.1685954183,
0.252476275,
1.2755473852,
-0.6023279428,
-0.4053512216,
-0.2413655072,
-0.1433432847,
0.180588007,
0.7728679776,
0.423892349,
-0.3620924056,
-0.4687046409,
-0.0848740488,
-0.4881486595,
0.28822577,
-0.065196529,
-0.3851558268,
0.3174133897,
0.5876350999,
-0.9094077945,
0.2256087065,
0.1089236662,
-0.2817055285,
0.5620343089,
0.0398932435,
0.1902106702,
-1.2967689037,
0.1155167669,
-0.2390115261,
-0.0703794733,
-0.7046802044,
0.0388170443,
-0.1250380576,
-0.542893827,
-0.4241104722,
0.2569634318,
-0.4414874017,
-0.2028657496,
0.0994944721,
-0.171560213,
0.3189381063,
0.3604840338,
0.0722533911,
0.8547997475,
0.1633178592,
-0.6002268791,
0.1420176178,
0.3481557369,
-0.3159923255,
0.5922147036,
-0.7633343339,
-0.0427861884,
-0.0147305569,
0.348341018,
-1.0446617603,
-0.625007987,
-0.0357742496,
-0.6186932921,
0.2763510942,
-0.469530046,
-0.6955257058,
-0.0376633778,
-0.0430526547,
0.2696878612,
0.5414953232,
-0.5188112259,
0.564837873,
0.305301249,
-0.1038300022,
-0.1856294274,
-0.7945882678,
0.2615403533,
0.023765428,
-0.5215227008,
0.7192571163,
0.4734545946,
-0.0815776289,
0.0027302376,
-0.2462225705,
-0.3562745452,
-0.3913761377,
-0.3244054317,
0.1876623183,
0.0138163716,
0.170961231,
0.2399319112,
-0.1796239763,
0.1384323984,
-0.2016681433,
0.4588313699,
0.3001209497,
-0.2323434204,
-0.3669467866,
0.4817601442,
0.4700582027,
-0.2776398957,
0.6559202075,
0.1674333811,
-0.3854648471,
-0.5111941099,
-0.3584950566,
-0.4678081572,
-0.4171900451,
0.2379434258,
-0.4222888052,
-0.5758200288,
0.2994559109,
-0.1301956922,
-0.0011415782,
0.5431008339,
0.0223991126,
-0.3978809118,
1.1382949352,
-0.0059705931,
0.5291013122,
0.1377178729,
-0.0638017282,
0.4049244821,
-0.5068469644,
-0.1097123921,
-0.9326531887,
0.2372313291,
-0.694063127,
-0.4185617268,
0.4094201028,
-0.1460295469,
-0.250167042,
0.6192314029,
-0.703843832,
0.4908694327,
0.3000264764,
0.1469548941,
0.195255816,
0.4796552658,
-0.0519206561,
-0.334962368,
-0.5027599931,
-0.3206578195,
1.0109808445,
-0.1551110595,
0.6641828418,
-0.1482619792,
0.7007374763,
0.1034051105,
-0.3202900887,
-0.3525212407,
0.8137979507,
-0.3610916138,
-0.6160665751,
-0.1880430281,
-0.5176885724,
-0.7045119405,
0.3348927498,
-0.4645120502,
-0.2855902612,
0.2000492215,
0.264637202,
0.0025962999,
-0.031073859,
-0.933752358,
0.7235314846,
0.3076249957,
-0.7231436968,
0.016367754,
-0.7506078482,
0.1699788272,
0.1971140057,
0.0184539761,
-0.2741619051,
0.1879457384,
0.5042887926,
-0.8559640646,
0.3969547749,
-0.1590148658,
0.0516695455,
0.5076872706,
0.3147018254,
0.6387085319,
0.1334615648,
-0.2468979657,
-0.1562011987,
0.246956408,
-0.5654946566,
-0.8046468496,
0.5755604506,
-0.1606259048,
-0.6051203609,
-0.3989363909,
-0.3964570165,
-0.6888779402,
0.0562452115,
0.3116620183,
0.5089426041,
-0.1551757008,
0.1514666229,
0.3640995324,
-0.0544532053,
0.0481854267,
0.0722412318,
0.0288472287,
-0.7390135527,
0.9141047597,
0.1875209361,
0.4286590219,
0.3456445038,
-0.2796202302,
-0.4624396563,
-0.5508944988,
-0.7109916806,
0.0790181085,
-0.6371894479,
-0.2032888979,
-0.5101642609,
-0.192214027,
-0.4562202096,
-0.0225365683,
-0.7121730447,
-0.8058847189,
-0.2927334905,
0.0678217039,
0.3007119298,
0.3179160058,
0.3350684345,
-0.0479604453,
-0.8548383713,
0.4111758769,
0.0398456827,
0.2809028029,
-0.2165863067,
-0.0038396604,
-0.0426535048,
0.1727546453,
0.0114842709,
-0.8127018809,
0.2673808634,
0.2573345602,
0.2963730395,
-0.4184063077,
0.3081371188,
0.8413665891,
-0.6455696821,
1.0651394129,
0.1090804935,
-1.0178810358,
0.7707838416,
-0.3795256019,
0.0359703153,
0.964458704,
0.1573809385,
0.0047726911,
-0.4267058372,
-0.2669893801,
-1.0486593246,
0.6171569228,
0.6116492748,
0.1541337669,
-0.1169920042,
0.2736373544,
0.2215757817,
0.1536790282,
-0.5912125111,
-0.0433320254,
-0.2178895175,
-0.4186475277,
0.1447944194,
-0.0655779243,
0.1015791148,
-0.4257518649,
0.4461188018,
-0.2153662443,
0.3432368338,
0.2924741805,
-0.0052513522,
0.2601309121,
0.2978988588,
-0.0772261992,
0.7950761914,
-0.0224250965,
0.2050493956,
0.1456219405,
-0.2419683039,
0.2887538075,
0.3261166215,
-0.1735723019,
0.233721599,
0.1353962868,
0.361422807,
-0.2272259295,
-0.686154902,
0.2571656406,
0.0740225166,
0.0254522096,
0.0453062393,
0.1408421993,
0.1189518124,
-0.2478590459,
0.3796402514,
0.2537717223,
0.3451320827,
-0.5631667376,
0.0789273754,
0.3118416965,
-0.1314846724,
-0.1985438913,
0.6654417515,
0.193535611,
0.0037560996,
0.5862187147,
-0.0484641753,
-0.2315093577,
0.2697006166,
0.5256897807,
0.2959135473,
-0.1319695264,
0.0173967294,
0.4944900274,
0.1137207374,
0.0142961787,
0.5255390406,
-0.1923927963,
-0.2289509177,
-0.4173696935,
-0.6207339764,
-0.2908070982,
-0.4079810083,
-0.5735473633,
0.4764007032,
-0.310449332,
-0.1406001002,
0.0613252632,
-0.2278665751,
-0.3005462587,
0.4992013276,
-0.7839633226,
0.8260709643,
-0.5966354012,
0.593362689,
0.5340491533,
-0.5386189222,
-0.7473410964,
-0.0362204909,
-0.6095891595,
-0.2501213551,
0.2475591749,
0.0230369233,
0.2768438458,
0.1784849018,
-0.3558970392,
-0.8002163768,
0.5713556409,
0.5884296298,
-0.2743649781,
-0.2749159634,
0.7979248166,
0.7226459384,
-0.2404286861,
-0.1398622096,
0.6803616285,
0.118259415,
0.1351642162,
-0.5703578591,
0.2101256847,
-0.2273790687,
0.2710434496,
0.4266200662,
-0.1696845591,
0.7850971222,
0.081625469,
-0.3497474194,
0.1880813837,
0.7245364785,
0.3180871904,
0.3052621186,
0.2296765,
0.6063355207,
0.3734064102,
-0.4154758751,
0.7680320144,
-0.2753156126,
0.111165002,
1.2757310867,
-0.5986509323,
0.9411446452,
0.7526465654,
-0.5409416556,
0.3988277614,
0.5111983418,
0.1737203449,
0.5616698265,
0.2344484925,
-0.2791915536,
-0.2664472759,
-0.1098370403,
-0.5080744028,
0.3886906505,
0.5969650745,
-0.5085138679,
-0.4355605245,
-0.262575537,
-0.2595355809,
0.4322701395,
0.1947297454,
1.0472180843,
-0.18704772,
-0.8562794328,
0.7634586692,
-0.1869565398,
0.0991313532,
-0.4318281412,
-0.2641103864,
-0.2264265865,
0.0637993291,
-0.1701268405,
-0.8728449345,
0.616091907,
-0.1101049855,
-0.0691938996,
-0.0303872488,
0.6141680479,
-0.5441257954,
-0.3658577204,
-0.1818363369,
0.3510357141,
0.1365727931,
-0.250842452,
-0.1634339392,
0.0183793958,
-0.1458124369,
-0.0557583459,
0.3592957854,
0.4424014986,
0.0547601767,
0.2373365909,
1.0251874924,
0.1526464671,
-0.0248015765,
-0.2567431331,
1.0810838938,
-0.696059227,
-0.5889576674,
-0.6768601537,
0.6068267226,
-0.2475350797,
-0.2691892684,
0.5407992601,
0.6501416564,
0.72504884,
-0.2357389033,
0.5777785778,
-0.1008350775,
0.8325245976,
-0.7982338071,
0.7294288278,
-0.5123083591,
0.2797834575,
-0.1410698444,
-1.301943779,
-0.244148612,
0.1592466384,
0.309509635,
-0.2051445842,
0.7980236411,
0.9369755387,
0.0962725133,
0.1136538014,
0.0297951866,
0.0036962214,
0.4301510453,
0.358166188,
0.7525831461,
-0.7245211005,
0.6076342463,
-0.11580351,
0.2635704279,
0.0383536443,
-0.7452073693,
-0.5675075054,
-0.8942701817,
-0.0031692574,
-0.753752172,
0.3025229275,
1.0750159025,
0.6848865151,
-0.8159200549,
-0.1459007263,
-0.7657287121,
-0.1176430061,
-0.013334577,
-0.2224257588,
0.4673487246,
-0.6722635031,
-0.636313498,
0.4569782019,
0.0502045229,
0.2581353188,
-0.0361299179,
0.2770647407,
-0.1426924765,
0.1839400679,
0.7933937907,
-0.0597428456,
-0.5492327809,
-0.1089826375,
0.0420260057,
-0.2490923554,
0.1467947811,
0.6896135211,
-0.8982791901,
0.3203824461,
0.7933018208,
0.8028798699,
0.5269312263,
0.1999611706,
0.7068252563,
-0.8571012616,
-0.013807823,
0.3588363826,
0.1066123247,
0.4515320361,
-0.241560787,
0.6129227281,
0.3184018433,
-0.276374191,
-1.0474150181,
0.1294523925,
-0.8978059888,
-0.3374639153,
1.0379525423,
0.1274906993,
-0.5165448785,
-0.0995036364,
-0.4385709763,
0.1092085317,
-0.183643803,
0.4622750282,
0.6289533973,
-0.2085601836,
0.259347409,
0.0855849832,
0.9207535386,
0.4464845359,
-1.1731830835,
0.3828404844,
0.832064569,
0.1929209232,
-0.0256989021,
0.3486346304,
-0.3942920566,
0.3919365704,
0.2955498099,
-0.1596917808,
0.1837330759,
-0.3548720479,
0.3006158173,
0.3230342567,
-0.0356088653,
0.083897993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08780v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08780v1 | Improving Cross-task Generalization of Unified Table-to-text Models with Compositional Task Configurations | 2022-12-17T02:20:14 | 2022-12-17T02:20:14 | Jifan Chen, Yuhao Zhang, Lan Liu, Rui Dong, Xinchi Chen, Patrick Ng, William Yang Wang, Zhiheng Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | There has been great progress in unifying various table-to-text tasks using a
single encoder-decoder model trained via multi-task learning (Xie et al.,
2022). However, existing methods typically encode task information with a
simple dataset name as a prefix to the encoder. This not only limits the
effectiveness of multi-task learning, but also hinders the model's ability to
generalize to new domains or tasks that were not seen during training, which is
crucial for real-world applications. In this paper, we propose compositional
task configurations, a set of prompts prepended to the encoder to improve
cross-task generalization of unified models. We design the task configurations
to explicitly specify the task type, as well as its input and output types. We
show that this not only allows the model to better learn shared knowledge
across different tasks at training, but also allows us to control the model by
composing new configurations that apply novel input-output combinations in a
zero-shot manner. We demonstrate via experiments over ten table-to-text tasks
that our method outperforms the UnifiedSKG baseline by noticeable margins in
both in-domain and zero-shot settings, with average improvements of +0.5 and
+12.6 from using a T5-large backbone, respectively. | [
-0.1497424841,
-0.4189064205,
0.5510308743,
0.0530131273,
-0.5383061171,
-0.2021642625,
-0.4717931747,
-0.2182345092,
0.0180470683,
0.459566474,
-0.5371008515,
-0.7773728967,
-0.814696312,
0.2562362552,
-0.1380150765,
1.1886552572,
-0.2595609426,
-0.114502266,
-0.6017380357,
-0.1712521315,
-1.0965402126,
-0.4217535555,
-0.2505978346,
-0.5535088181,
0.6398080587,
0.5122113824,
0.2809117436,
0.6786088347,
0.3359682858,
0.2380746156,
0.4093405902,
0.3261165023,
-0.22244744,
0.3517324626,
-0.1839510649,
-0.335299015,
-0.2294172645,
-0.3717606962,
0.5227105618,
0.8862029314,
0.0227261819,
0.1908732057,
0.4499157965,
0.5162104368,
-0.8629086018,
0.3936364949,
-0.3860713243,
0.3224928081,
-0.1392115653,
-0.1183658913,
-0.5646909475,
0.3542506397,
0.0151536679,
-0.9094155431,
0.2314909846,
-0.1849375218,
0.465228647,
0.1314808279,
-0.7215309739,
0.0899028406,
-0.9719188809,
0.8298155665,
-0.4093354642,
0.6367209554,
0.1363168806,
0.1639520824,
-0.0360924006,
-0.7039238214,
-0.3088651896,
-0.0962071791,
-0.4882637262,
0.2740161419,
-0.2499438226,
0.2671818733,
0.1973410845,
-0.0280678887,
-0.8075997233,
-0.1009047478,
-0.0911177695,
0.0033676019,
0.4123723805,
0.3628410101,
0.233432129,
0.1898748428,
-0.2165103257,
-0.0312146787,
-0.4854148626,
0.1780773997,
0.0341587439,
0.5320939422,
-0.1580619961,
0.5898963213,
-0.6302921772,
1.1340661049,
0.4249984622,
0.0752890781,
0.002594938,
-0.4482878149,
-0.4590168595,
-0.2576637864,
0.6380962133,
0.3068889081,
-0.1641226709,
-0.8247889876,
-0.1132965982,
0.2579648197,
0.6050799489,
-0.6588621736,
-0.2043001056,
0.1437042803,
-0.3117840886,
0.0245481208,
0.0373954102,
-0.4292037487,
-0.0742979273,
-0.7694377899,
0.7755813599,
-0.131086871,
0.2928811312,
0.1340866387,
-0.3031697273,
0.0313768797,
0.4112100303,
-0.9113230705,
0.2926782668,
0.4162689149,
0.5320892334,
-0.4939959943,
-0.3481028676,
-0.5931181908,
0.5313173532,
-0.1243279129,
0.7629244328,
-0.7064933777,
-0.4918274581,
-0.0253990479,
-0.0405931957,
-0.5303174853,
-0.3430919945,
0.2403519005,
-0.2728648484,
0.2396860868,
-0.5735595226,
-0.5300670266,
-0.0909285098,
0.4287625849,
-0.5899396539,
0.7973694801,
-0.174338907,
-0.6938960552,
0.5199456811,
-0.8410950899,
-0.8072476387,
-0.0903089866,
-0.3339565396,
-0.3423627019,
0.2152186185,
0.458635807,
0.8421871066,
-0.3164290488,
0.2341859937,
-0.2242883742,
-0.3873344958,
-0.0112784067,
-0.0454623997,
0.4089798629,
-0.0679846779,
-0.3324842155,
0.284845084,
-0.5730533004,
0.0335471556,
0.0379721597,
-0.4855068326,
-0.1915522218,
-0.2507408559,
-0.148673594,
0.0623132661,
0.2212221324,
-0.5247939229,
0.2054060102,
0.1277125925,
0.1671066731,
0.2630028129,
0.0272997003,
0.743924737,
-0.6086478829,
0.4625276327,
0.1817655861,
0.1134740114,
-0.1301307827,
-0.3420495391,
-0.8116159439,
-0.1149837077,
0.300917685,
0.5893474817,
-0.9146250486,
0.4929959178,
-0.2770247459,
-0.4782081842,
0.0447304174,
-0.0087157078,
0.600823164,
0.5923885703,
0.5514937639,
-0.2947535813,
-0.5406402349,
-0.7358229756,
-0.5090575218,
0.4525202215,
-0.208672151,
0.1841176748,
0.587575078,
-0.058175426,
0.8856288195,
-0.4777905345,
-0.3498665094,
-0.4000670314,
0.2435773462,
-0.041129034,
0.674834609,
0.1835738122,
-0.6118224859,
-0.6527106166,
0.1268755347,
-0.6922382712,
0.251159817,
-0.2553750277,
-0.3004561961,
0.0110126361,
0.2161021382,
-0.6989418268,
0.4006581306,
0.3327599168,
-0.3157153726,
0.5477355719,
-0.2497315556,
0.1807730645,
-1.3276785612,
0.2161261141,
0.1572928429,
-0.0350386798,
-0.9762685895,
0.0474750325,
0.0923377797,
-0.1852840036,
-0.2440571189,
0.3599874079,
-0.5513414741,
-0.0033126022,
-0.0378400497,
-0.3157415986,
0.3049198389,
0.9619056582,
0.2006978244,
0.5711693168,
0.6250116825,
-0.7403374314,
0.2452147454,
0.4012707174,
0.0433456153,
0.7537398934,
-0.7402698398,
0.2620927095,
-0.1562382132,
0.5527401567,
-0.8534685373,
-0.2201620787,
0.2632995546,
-0.2525389194,
0.3926446438,
0.0289362948,
-0.2887995541,
-0.1585557908,
-0.156314224,
0.4580879807,
0.228941679,
-0.4627295434,
0.8988171816,
0.1145175099,
0.2459512949,
-0.7800111771,
-0.8715817332,
-0.042262245,
-0.1616780907,
-0.3866146207,
0.9535038471,
-0.0941148624,
0.2381213903,
-0.1302181929,
-0.5067039132,
-0.2563070655,
-0.2224498987,
0.4314471781,
0.1175767928,
0.0479792245,
0.2246458977,
0.3498335481,
0.014960506,
-0.160952419,
-0.4607260525,
0.394487381,
0.2822447121,
-0.2816607356,
-0.3559210896,
0.658900857,
0.2985655069,
-0.4481606185,
0.6311506033,
0.5942907333,
-0.357858628,
-0.4309270084,
-0.3031176925,
-0.2613518238,
-0.4521969557,
0.3083114326,
-0.4823493659,
-0.9996852875,
0.477771759,
0.0549400598,
0.3679479957,
0.3336106241,
0.2625107467,
-0.2190365046,
0.796225965,
0.6780413985,
0.1145313308,
0.4274712503,
-0.3776860237,
-0.00278759,
-0.8083947897,
-0.6098957062,
-0.6070718169,
-0.5231697559,
-0.039844539,
-0.463786602,
0.4629946053,
-0.2774736285,
-0.3289951086,
0.5868903995,
-0.6315795183,
0.6586340666,
0.7262686491,
0.4697798789,
0.3396314681,
0.0366788171,
-0.1791321784,
0.067724742,
-0.9415599704,
-0.03223617,
1.254585743,
-0.1964502931,
0.5333136916,
-0.2944606543,
0.9943135977,
0.373804599,
-0.0744418353,
-0.4118670523,
0.4861524701,
-0.6738179922,
-0.4139449894,
-0.3698445857,
-0.3196239173,
-1.0043717623,
0.3446398675,
-0.2985962927,
-0.6988623738,
0.3590245247,
0.3317392766,
-0.6170777678,
0.2175370008,
-0.4861520529,
1.2811667919,
0.0573190339,
-0.1307214797,
0.0055443859,
-0.6037845612,
0.2438430488,
0.2563115656,
-0.1580241472,
0.1868693233,
-0.1611627936,
0.7539941669,
-0.1750045568,
1.177292943,
-0.1064880788,
0.0190184712,
0.0505123399,
-0.0010119191,
0.6101287603,
-0.1316475272,
0.0988796651,
0.0815547854,
-0.2460026443,
-0.3518284261,
-0.6524245739,
0.3995203972,
-0.6369432211,
-0.2658249438,
-0.0890501812,
-1.0270783901,
-0.5607609749,
-0.0486364961,
0.6255853176,
0.8106802106,
-0.2549301088,
0.3369558156,
0.6884999275,
0.0921776816,
0.4970369041,
0.2437107861,
0.3948724568,
-0.4441920519,
0.7590925694,
0.0758228004,
0.0872138664,
0.8533130884,
-0.1504290998,
-0.43778795,
-0.4435846806,
-0.6652280688,
-0.2119409144,
-0.6192809939,
-0.3918129206,
-0.7446301579,
0.2053658664,
-0.4373308718,
-0.2481258661,
-0.0657338426,
-0.370729804,
-0.6282979846,
0.1305574328,
0.1057104543,
0.5654957294,
0.2927132845,
0.5378733277,
-0.9704723358,
0.4314766526,
0.5860072374,
0.4102578163,
-0.0713834316,
-0.6451249719,
-0.4698992074,
0.0494474694,
-0.3039478362,
-0.8888738155,
0.053596817,
0.3466634452,
0.6813286543,
0.1323146522,
0.1885757446,
0.7605790496,
-0.4673760831,
0.5244516134,
0.3553049266,
-1.0114359856,
0.2573854029,
-0.4964914024,
0.7278034091,
0.5983705521,
0.4226948917,
-0.5823518038,
-0.1571158767,
-0.1715696305,
-0.4178546965,
0.8405429125,
0.1183099672,
0.1554421782,
0.3800247312,
0.2571891248,
0.468498826,
0.2500145733,
-0.8571236134,
-0.1427109689,
-0.2778550982,
-0.2868395448,
-0.0172878485,
0.0243374743,
-0.2375939339,
-0.3508909047,
0.4431634545,
-0.2650411725,
0.4165027142,
-0.0245614331,
-0.3028608859,
-0.0426757224,
0.4517784417,
0.4892717898,
0.5289490223,
0.2820852399,
0.2084208876,
0.3701249957,
-0.207674548,
0.2298721373,
0.2333358973,
-0.1827145368,
-0.0098232552,
0.3182809353,
1.0350664854,
0.3609262705,
-0.2679650784,
0.278264612,
-0.0280562378,
-0.5054631233,
0.2255337536,
0.2978999317,
0.0860356465,
0.365326345,
0.0878570005,
0.1394806951,
0.2347517908,
-0.3881640136,
0.1265980154,
0.4841369689,
-0.1996858716,
-0.2831593752,
0.5810204744,
0.2940554023,
0.0055965441,
0.2227475196,
-0.2020973116,
-0.2506635785,
0.5927859545,
0.7102695107,
0.9069203734,
-0.1297991872,
0.5111525655,
0.2712209821,
0.1853654236,
-0.1609056592,
0.45007056,
-0.5685300231,
-0.6600137353,
-0.4219872653,
-0.4548645616,
-0.4907354414,
0.0024683743,
-0.5972871184,
0.0097465273,
-0.1450481117,
-0.0449068546,
0.0301308203,
-0.1264899373,
-0.8313457966,
0.3547823727,
0.0539150611,
0.3862398267,
-0.904016912,
0.7813336253,
0.9346830845,
-0.2614488602,
-0.7941613197,
-0.0558060855,
-0.4636052549,
-0.3319744468,
0.309881568,
0.2335278541,
0.3768752217,
-0.0536719225,
-0.1893339306,
-0.7962097526,
1.2293589115,
0.4709054828,
-0.7758399844,
-0.3525384963,
0.6868861914,
0.2841735184,
-0.4483872354,
-0.0293459259,
0.5059499145,
0.6468383074,
-0.0296669714,
-0.9368466139,
0.2850603163,
-0.209034726,
0.1339620501,
0.3006092012,
-0.2579347193,
0.9075427055,
-0.0565003939,
-0.181927368,
-0.1745782048,
0.5324683189,
0.0683732629,
0.3528961837,
0.4675044715,
0.701002121,
0.3093843758,
-0.178652972,
0.8721832633,
-0.101587303,
0.1007012203,
1.3339703083,
-0.2057211697,
0.3712961376,
0.2607510984,
-0.0077652954,
0.3807618022,
0.4068498909,
-0.2007508576,
0.5211097002,
-0.100710921,
-0.2871253192,
-0.4159136713,
-0.0799034536,
-0.1517428309,
0.4614400566,
0.1307964325,
-0.1577082723,
-0.4798604548,
0.3931550086,
-0.133278802,
0.009305561,
-0.3859830499,
0.9369199872,
-0.100538671,
-0.7990869284,
0.3522577882,
0.1192853525,
0.7588686943,
-0.5809849501,
-0.0412466377,
-0.0348913036,
-0.0422651097,
-0.2444650978,
-0.5484212637,
0.4020245075,
-0.1140329167,
-0.2812820375,
-0.230017215,
0.8568797112,
-0.8838289976,
-0.320836693,
0.0993963629,
0.6071031094,
-0.3506722152,
-0.523565352,
-0.4076304138,
0.0193629339,
-0.1638311893,
-0.0165300015,
0.4990375042,
0.2258874923,
-0.0263510495,
0.0719004497,
0.4087016881,
-0.4746201336,
0.0794869363,
-0.0980074257,
0.832947731,
-0.5435653329,
-0.5906844735,
-0.6251683831,
0.676195085,
0.1417905986,
-0.3641524017,
0.5828231573,
0.475427866,
0.9505786896,
-0.5305671096,
0.7968930602,
-0.1415385157,
0.0977801457,
-0.432186693,
0.6764642,
-0.6376120448,
-0.2419110835,
-0.0639366806,
-0.9427321553,
-0.5374163389,
0.0583475605,
-0.1338671148,
0.2394711524,
0.7268072367,
0.510522902,
-0.2929647565,
0.0538765788,
0.4515188336,
-0.3653982878,
-0.0211965181,
0.7395706177,
0.4198482037,
-0.2321634889,
0.6386398673,
-0.6701339483,
0.1399463862,
-0.1051693186,
-0.7593371272,
-1.1176526546,
-0.7389811873,
-0.2729194164,
0.0594383366,
0.3541360199,
0.8553543091,
0.9074761868,
-0.8504581451,
-0.3651459813,
-0.2113296837,
-0.1602940112,
-0.4746546745,
-0.0888899267,
0.2618957162,
-0.4521283209,
-0.4957328141,
0.4824420512,
0.0816722289,
-0.0243123807,
0.2682111859,
-0.0695139989,
0.0697946995,
0.0502494909,
0.6838836074,
0.2945548594,
-0.5216401815,
-0.0979258344,
0.0565637946,
0.0115322424,
-0.013624547,
1.0539262295,
-0.7190366387,
0.3250330389,
0.4900159836,
0.7565455437,
0.5205245614,
-0.1096296906,
0.6217617989,
-1.2143200636,
-0.1660589725,
0.1968114376,
0.4239740968,
0.1190693751,
-0.4066378772,
0.2578267753,
0.2088177353,
-0.3795752525,
-0.4460747242,
0.1370776892,
-1.1856803894,
-0.2748052776,
0.7764694691,
-0.1480326951,
-0.1123092398,
-0.1449082643,
-0.0414862856,
0.6321650147,
-0.5305006504,
0.8273044229,
0.395344615,
-0.3461762965,
0.0526287258,
-0.1403431296,
0.4131197631,
0.567971468,
-1.2506786585,
0.1191432923,
0.5646611452,
0.2251797467,
-0.0666802078,
0.3193531036,
0.107486099,
0.6016194224,
-0.1211869568,
0.3281448483,
-0.4655817449,
-0.7373006344,
-0.3722640872,
0.2658152878,
-0.5116779208,
-0.5102612376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08775v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08775v2 | RISE: Leveraging Retrieval Techniques for Summarization Evaluation | 2022-12-17T01:09:22 | 2023-05-22T16:53:58 | David Uthus, Jianmo Ni | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluating automatically-generated text summaries is a challenging task.
While there have been many interesting approaches, they still fall short of
human evaluations. We present RISE, a new approach for evaluating summaries by
leveraging techniques from information retrieval. RISE is first trained as a
retrieval task using a dual-encoder retrieval setup, and can then be
subsequently utilized for evaluating a generated summary given an input
document, without gold reference summaries. RISE is especially well suited when
working on new datasets where one may not have reference summaries available
for evaluation. We conduct comprehensive experiments on the SummEval benchmark
(Fabbri et al., 2021) and the results show that RISE has higher correlation
with human evaluations compared to many past approaches to summarization
evaluation. Furthermore, RISE also demonstrates data-efficiency and
generalizability across languages. | [
-0.1244371906,
-0.1299085021,
0.1095855683,
0.1089340746,
-0.2293850482,
0.5007506609,
-0.1108760238,
-0.2216188312,
0.4762954712,
0.4711596966,
-0.3603957295,
-0.2714145184,
-0.5905503631,
0.3791736066,
-0.3780340552,
1.2566999197,
0.135656029,
-0.1953337044,
-0.5731400251,
-0.0769945458,
-0.3820489943,
-0.6442170739,
-0.3452638984,
-0.3614175022,
0.2292457819,
0.422721535,
0.5489196181,
0.2991554737,
1.0125354528,
0.2390868962,
-0.1205983907,
0.3174721301,
-0.7605624795,
0.1743821651,
0.3726010919,
-0.5157891512,
-0.292861551,
-0.0712017342,
0.80990237,
0.6012347341,
0.0404044539,
0.3860452771,
-0.0462259352,
1.1554086208,
-0.8578065038,
-0.0826490372,
-0.3064568043,
0.166382134,
-0.1705479324,
-0.5514951348,
-0.2429938614,
-0.6594721675,
0.2449590117,
-0.2490733266,
0.4149473608,
-0.1446677893,
0.6551283002,
-0.0270972047,
-0.3826643229,
-0.368144393,
-0.4677391946,
0.641479671,
-0.4624404907,
0.1836270392,
-0.0273922291,
0.733463347,
0.1442371309,
-0.950889647,
-0.1012406573,
-0.4538824856,
-0.1935650408,
0.7204322219,
-0.1111696661,
-0.3260949254,
0.1403691471,
0.9578168392,
-0.4858756661,
-0.4249490798,
-0.5194359422,
-0.0483964272,
0.6692413688,
0.1986983418,
0.3634798825,
-0.276563853,
-0.2943373024,
-0.2748828828,
-0.5069103241,
-0.0713498145,
0.3396472335,
0.5281624198,
-0.1695624739,
0.7402842641,
-0.2474860102,
0.4764873385,
-0.0200759135,
0.2438371778,
0.4672272503,
-0.5362481475,
-0.123433955,
-0.0052691754,
0.3899012506,
0.7545496821,
0.1275304407,
-0.4033868611,
-0.0593104921,
-0.0715413019,
0.3512694538,
-0.9648461342,
-0.2455347776,
-0.0202491563,
-0.6903262734,
-0.4959825575,
0.2849832773,
-0.8827061057,
-0.5127016306,
-0.2074256688,
0.5053142905,
-0.0509899706,
-0.3882318139,
-0.0622649342,
-0.7521784902,
0.2092312425,
0.3580292463,
-0.9015405178,
0.4095557332,
0.4188250601,
1.1660164595,
-0.4442381561,
-0.0464921407,
-0.6699244976,
-0.0565299504,
-0.3479342461,
0.9996663928,
-0.4867722392,
-0.6347721815,
0.0606384873,
-0.3337913156,
0.0713554695,
-0.647993803,
0.7232426405,
-0.5885671973,
0.3806396425,
-0.2922576964,
-0.4543422461,
0.0440008268,
0.167350471,
-0.7409156561,
1.2272527218,
0.2664459944,
-1.0409361124,
0.3001813591,
-0.9348724484,
-0.7207080126,
0.1587727666,
-0.2457662821,
-0.2415832132,
0.3754258752,
0.4380898774,
0.1157827005,
-0.1512497962,
-0.2926078141,
0.2919939458,
-0.4508045316,
-0.1671331376,
-0.2391188145,
0.8003021479,
0.0484470353,
-0.023951754,
-0.1138638929,
-0.5409424901,
-0.0560765527,
0.1444117427,
-0.6008235216,
-0.6127444506,
-0.0203147475,
-0.0171370469,
-0.214395538,
0.3459953368,
-0.2422937155,
0.1899999976,
-0.7233216763,
-0.0989256278,
0.3181810379,
0.3888995051,
0.1257427782,
-0.6166137457,
0.6145134568,
-0.3073005676,
-0.1604611576,
-0.4504321814,
-0.2748839259,
-0.4836890697,
0.1304369867,
0.3205644786,
0.5657227635,
-0.5838947296,
0.4487923384,
-0.5566197634,
-0.5174635053,
-0.4751763046,
0.0391051397,
0.3055661917,
0.6646789908,
0.3694366515,
-0.3004097342,
-0.7534399629,
-0.7624909878,
-0.6471412778,
-0.1485720873,
-0.4966740608,
-0.0266868733,
0.3746269941,
-0.0888301581,
0.8072986603,
-0.6659460068,
-0.131677866,
-0.4318370521,
0.4788843989,
0.3673388958,
0.2213989645,
0.7224407196,
-0.9782906175,
-0.3217174411,
-0.0980113372,
-0.8059313893,
-0.0796445161,
-0.0948151425,
-0.2823312879,
-0.2786532342,
0.2212481499,
-0.1867901683,
0.3900417984,
0.0777982026,
-0.1014006361,
0.5391613245,
-0.3516225815,
0.7860236764,
-1.228105545,
0.2020519674,
-0.2602921724,
-0.2769943476,
-0.3624191284,
0.1274198592,
0.2217347026,
-0.180033192,
-0.1791880578,
0.3302191496,
-0.6141455173,
-0.3381753564,
-0.3383502066,
0.5210927725,
0.2057977319,
0.0558649972,
-0.0822962672,
1.0235724449,
0.1925614476,
-0.8150773048,
0.5001866817,
0.4359247983,
-0.4161870778,
0.5032811165,
-0.562469244,
0.0988968685,
-0.5291268826,
-0.0040478981,
-1.2241858244,
-0.2033259273,
-0.2490490526,
-0.7751429677,
0.1677270979,
0.0303084329,
-0.3635068536,
-0.6679598093,
-0.9318070412,
0.0029696741,
0.4555347562,
-0.7200211883,
0.5157185793,
0.6968369484,
-0.2791405022,
-0.6183707118,
-0.8126800656,
0.3566902876,
-0.1975443959,
-0.3609937131,
0.4991908073,
-0.4132349491,
-0.418070823,
-0.2822493613,
-0.370539695,
0.1077166945,
0.2149709761,
-0.0156450048,
0.2581633925,
-0.0564837754,
0.1885446012,
0.2237922251,
-0.0450377725,
0.0033109004,
-0.0366421007,
0.1240198463,
-0.2835185528,
-0.0218475349,
-0.0803500414,
0.3817370832,
0.418122977,
-0.189469561,
0.280174613,
0.3285467625,
-0.5239560008,
0.3105213046,
-0.4152449667,
-0.0802260563,
-0.4081631601,
0.4564214647,
-0.2853084505,
-0.3640468419,
0.4322951734,
-0.0558077209,
0.6602864861,
0.801046133,
0.7500550151,
-0.210751459,
0.9445869923,
0.5877071619,
0.0200103577,
0.616659224,
-0.2577714622,
-0.2072891593,
-0.8377456069,
-0.1328551173,
-0.708840847,
-0.2202577144,
-0.2523526251,
-0.0338618346,
0.5922093391,
0.1078300476,
0.3705225885,
0.4053970873,
-0.4354518652,
0.7427155972,
0.2145793289,
0.0535813086,
0.6750046015,
0.3363921046,
-0.0177923068,
-0.1171739474,
-0.3486449718,
-0.4323819876,
1.3057717085,
-0.117504485,
0.5977705121,
0.2912401557,
0.6358423233,
1.0399339199,
0.7021553516,
-0.7483363152,
0.2463018894,
-0.220339641,
-0.1540337354,
-0.0730606765,
-0.7017771006,
-1.1004410982,
0.5734474659,
-0.263975203,
-0.4118104577,
-0.2722417414,
-0.0904104635,
-0.5008109808,
-0.1226920485,
-0.9656799436,
0.480905205,
-0.4139935672,
-0.002921378,
-0.1589616537,
-0.5674068332,
0.1664544791,
0.2181408554,
0.2330658734,
0.032746572,
-0.2002125233,
1.155987978,
-0.2746506929,
0.3201844096,
-0.1372300535,
-0.0648100004,
0.2315899879,
-0.1455093622,
0.1361060739,
0.1803709269,
-0.3665508032,
-0.1368611902,
-0.0172933657,
-0.3805443347,
-0.9818124771,
0.5707416534,
-0.5797531009,
-0.2696685493,
-0.4321578145,
-0.2190674841,
-0.2445071638,
0.5220674276,
0.3479363024,
0.7949355245,
-0.2971355915,
0.2729409337,
0.0067734858,
0.1511534899,
0.4828674197,
0.461058557,
-0.277117461,
-0.838109374,
0.5468426347,
0.1135102138,
0.134340018,
0.7497537732,
0.359243691,
-0.5460699201,
-0.4240860641,
-0.7322551608,
0.0486466922,
-0.6463044286,
-0.3329035044,
-0.4684546292,
-0.1826158166,
-0.5747486949,
-0.01152418,
-0.180062741,
-0.6719264984,
0.0288914684,
-0.3918932974,
0.109152101,
0.6181080341,
0.0925406441,
0.0675296485,
-0.9711618423,
0.567663312,
0.2733901739,
0.2394046336,
-0.1924780607,
-0.6115137935,
-0.5054181814,
0.1183932945,
-0.2401603311,
-0.9694203138,
0.3170887828,
0.2242285013,
0.6497971416,
0.3006447852,
0.3586007059,
0.7584239244,
-0.2208341509,
0.7367364168,
0.1689142585,
-0.6367763281,
1.0058493614,
-0.1367880106,
0.4350658655,
1.0227357149,
0.3808661103,
-0.3281737864,
-0.1962027252,
-0.5145252943,
-0.8645237088,
0.3209843636,
0.5715360641,
0.256670475,
0.0581965409,
0.516744256,
0.1994858384,
0.544965744,
-0.2649792433,
-0.2294249684,
0.0344035439,
-0.1615084261,
-0.0430884771,
-0.1902408004,
-0.0922506228,
-0.0876690596,
0.4424361289,
-0.0698728561,
0.3615796566,
0.3478170335,
-0.4584474564,
-0.1558877379,
0.0626861304,
0.3045622706,
0.9475835562,
-0.6008210182,
0.0588225015,
0.1310412735,
-0.785829246,
-0.1727425009,
0.2491791099,
-0.2628675103,
0.2391872555,
0.4612054229,
0.5483566523,
0.3857934177,
-0.8667033911,
0.6594078541,
-0.4818514287,
0.012035598,
-0.2967132032,
-0.0246009417,
-0.3983342946,
0.0736466423,
0.8053457141,
0.2255155444,
0.5284181833,
-0.4349282384,
0.4107069373,
0.2056264579,
-0.2229398638,
-0.2101300359,
0.4815885425,
0.3700759113,
-0.3014977574,
0.4619713128,
0.0947095975,
-0.2567307651,
0.6079071164,
0.6694176197,
0.8958563805,
-0.0499410219,
0.0587702096,
0.402474463,
0.2325664163,
0.1861412823,
0.2685728073,
-0.316085726,
-0.4340029359,
-0.3562525809,
-0.5386980772,
-0.7962574363,
-0.1091704145,
-0.8974852562,
0.3175980747,
0.1324588805,
-0.204298526,
0.0274688117,
0.4052103162,
-0.3154367208,
0.0006541459,
-0.0514282621,
0.9979890585,
-0.6561379433,
-0.0775095373,
0.8247405291,
-0.4545253515,
0.0727202371,
0.2704404294,
-0.2531717122,
-0.5265225172,
0.2913177907,
0.5496563315,
-0.3464903235,
0.1056211367,
-0.0691837817,
-0.6181374192,
1.1112649441,
0.5135858059,
-0.018192362,
-0.1736590266,
-0.5701866746,
0.6326642632,
-0.2892968357,
0.833971262,
0.5503098965,
0.2354869843,
0.1104964092,
-0.594525218,
-0.2859326005,
-0.6347643137,
-0.1934197545,
0.1316590905,
-0.4597112238,
0.5275367498,
-0.5022810102,
-0.6520546675,
-0.0692456216,
0.8150998354,
0.1088792086,
0.2448459566,
0.2706566453,
0.2743400931,
1.0355986357,
0.096090056,
1.3574097157,
-0.0371796116,
0.4230811,
1.0412271023,
-0.0945672616,
0.9837525487,
0.0815484226,
-0.4532251358,
0.5397381186,
0.4668099582,
0.1347471178,
0.5615661144,
0.1318288743,
-0.2485930622,
0.0710583255,
0.0637046546,
-0.6448927522,
0.3041924238,
0.2059233785,
-0.2185456455,
-0.7401010394,
-0.1227222309,
-0.1731515825,
0.3217530847,
-0.5953166485,
0.9212452173,
-0.1551976651,
-0.745282948,
0.6133607626,
-0.0709040985,
0.5145027637,
-0.5002518296,
-0.1153515279,
-0.3354902267,
0.1301126331,
-0.2351870239,
-0.5572760105,
0.5303298831,
0.322091043,
-0.143228054,
-0.122727789,
0.7287412882,
-0.2045063972,
-0.575035274,
0.1957900673,
0.4769748747,
0.4197792411,
-0.1145370081,
-0.343565613,
-0.503298223,
-0.1641129702,
-0.1942899972,
0.2874905765,
-0.0371584781,
0.1336521208,
0.2445881516,
0.6348794103,
0.0981242061,
-0.1229701415,
0.4794857502,
0.9217877984,
-0.5895174742,
-0.845631659,
-0.9583103657,
0.4091242254,
-0.460634023,
-0.0821356103,
0.8066217303,
1.1393773556,
0.4415311813,
-0.156910643,
1.1927680969,
-0.0238476545,
0.7963557243,
-0.5339275002,
0.7261787653,
-0.5900196433,
0.0869060084,
-0.1999895573,
-0.8606745601,
-0.5093573928,
0.5403125882,
-0.3319414854,
-0.0504733026,
0.4639014006,
0.3158887327,
0.1219585389,
0.2094458789,
-0.017554244,
-0.0254995804,
0.1225783527,
0.3249978125,
0.7750317454,
-0.717148304,
0.7593496442,
0.0655085072,
-0.586135149,
-0.3553383648,
-0.9480992556,
-1.1091989279,
-0.3991167545,
-0.0695960298,
-0.2816794217,
0.2161252499,
0.8135724664,
0.4646886587,
-0.8732615709,
-0.3349615037,
-0.0178955514,
0.1569041312,
-0.5130494237,
-0.2745871842,
0.4599126577,
-0.4421519637,
-0.721411705,
0.619784236,
0.3180274963,
0.0908311829,
-0.0266738851,
0.0962185487,
-0.0801684558,
-0.1220799908,
0.5750037432,
0.1455976367,
0.0480815172,
0.0513848104,
-0.1094163805,
0.0707428977,
0.318361938,
1.0866975784,
-0.9237047434,
0.6225762963,
0.8331490159,
1.0124796629,
0.7032466531,
0.6502299309,
0.7331507802,
-0.9861541986,
-0.2198360711,
0.2334036827,
0.0850331262,
0.429040581,
-0.5486205816,
0.5382155776,
0.1834318042,
-0.2571795881,
-0.7378116846,
-0.042265892,
-0.7045453787,
0.3385420144,
0.5122490525,
0.009662156,
0.0245039631,
0.1008800641,
-0.3160577416,
0.2698738873,
-0.4190168679,
0.8993509412,
0.3841308653,
-0.3659717739,
0.0317061916,
-0.5794198513,
0.4004386365,
0.1068920642,
-1.1899805069,
0.1663608998,
0.4656718969,
-0.0292782038,
0.4245890677,
0.8920431137,
-0.3909057975,
0.3210198879,
-0.104536742,
-0.2399034947,
-0.1307278126,
-0.2817412019,
-0.3232709467,
0.4042262137,
-0.3519544005,
-0.3691083491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08756v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08756v4 | Multi-Scales Data Augmentation Approach In Natural Language Inference For Artifacts Mitigation And Pre-Trained Model Optimization | 2022-12-16T23:37:44 | 2023-03-16T21:31:25 | Zhenyuan Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.AP | Machine learning models can reach high performance on benchmark natural
language processing (NLP) datasets but fail in more challenging settings. We
study this issue when a pre-trained model learns dataset artifacts in natural
language inference (NLI), the topic of studying the logical relationship
between a pair of text sequences. We provide a variety of techniques for
analyzing and locating dataset artifacts inside the crowdsourced Stanford
Natural Language Inference (SNLI) corpus. We study the stylistic pattern of
dataset artifacts in the SNLI. To mitigate dataset artifacts, we employ a
unique multi-scale data augmentation technique with two distinct frameworks: a
behavioral testing checklist at the sentence level and lexical synonym criteria
at the word level. Specifically, our combination method enhances our model's
resistance to perturbation testing, enabling it to continuously outperform the
pre-trained baseline. | [
-0.5171622634,
-0.9954609275,
0.1379836053,
0.2164708227,
-0.1290801167,
0.0220369156,
-0.1513336152,
-0.496835798,
0.0566983372,
0.7680332661,
-0.8812832832,
-0.129893139,
-0.349680841,
0.1733535081,
-0.2810054123,
1.1551388502,
0.0128489668,
0.0371843092,
-0.4905467927,
-0.2234461308,
-0.4020374417,
-0.5941288471,
-0.5578263998,
-0.2532942891,
0.3159034252,
0.240379408,
0.724988699,
0.7010897994,
0.7612631321,
0.3023943305,
0.0153026674,
0.2773188055,
-0.3440881371,
0.1693620086,
0.1688030511,
-0.3126401305,
-0.2961886525,
0.196503222,
0.7137414217,
0.882283926,
0.0113456082,
0.2450738698,
0.0362186693,
0.6353851557,
-0.6867394447,
-0.1062290594,
-0.6501835585,
0.1177111343,
-0.2505042255,
-0.0512549765,
-0.289909631,
-0.2639020681,
0.1412184834,
-0.760856688,
0.2066430598,
0.127741158,
0.8613629937,
0.5471439362,
-0.4034385979,
-0.1048717946,
-0.5561076999,
1.017537117,
-0.8170396686,
0.3411186635,
0.4579641223,
-0.0108149629,
-0.1741499156,
-0.6937724352,
-0.6599364877,
-0.46816957,
-0.1605528891,
0.0782917961,
0.1682924032,
0.1246753111,
0.4684583247,
0.6819180846,
-0.5763979554,
0.2373278737,
-0.060394574,
-0.2959681749,
0.5802801251,
0.1029932201,
0.1915566176,
-0.2467321008,
-0.3878144026,
-0.2828281522,
-0.4345431626,
-0.1200462505,
0.4567333162,
0.4356355071,
0.2636254728,
0.447991997,
-0.1576059908,
0.6792482734,
-0.223274067,
0.1763813049,
0.5642468929,
-0.8900008202,
-0.1534589976,
-0.0379470512,
0.4775852859,
0.2224713564,
0.0618133172,
-0.2482257485,
-0.2634793222,
0.2383261025,
0.3992694914,
-0.6370779276,
-0.1139228567,
0.2564115822,
-0.4111603796,
-0.2855424881,
0.0168077368,
-0.6856014729,
-0.5002259612,
-0.6856245995,
0.743180871,
-0.4455199838,
-0.3070964217,
0.0032652759,
-0.3161363602,
0.0384701863,
-0.0750476718,
-0.6717136502,
0.3692772985,
0.7350284457,
0.6373141408,
-0.0072193602,
-0.6031319499,
-0.5370177031,
-0.0219996329,
-0.3686513901,
0.6070727706,
-0.5341129303,
-0.3126636744,
-0.1353390813,
-0.1853490919,
-0.1152641773,
-0.5555251837,
0.7990335226,
-0.3296260536,
0.2532428503,
-0.2276297063,
-0.7906847596,
-0.0986934304,
0.3056916893,
-0.954435885,
1.5470087528,
0.0497784987,
-0.9710995555,
0.5922960639,
-0.8905367255,
-0.5550830364,
-0.1069831401,
0.1605887413,
-0.5936099887,
0.1973981559,
0.2774197459,
0.2963483036,
-0.1770556867,
0.3353171945,
-0.5881973505,
-0.2744275928,
0.057302393,
-0.3804323375,
0.5283968449,
0.017092621,
-0.1959336549,
0.4086960852,
-0.9860146046,
-0.0127982758,
0.0157476291,
-0.1739067137,
-0.5721152425,
0.1555578113,
0.402282089,
0.1735999435,
0.1612082869,
-0.4360342026,
0.1015345752,
-0.3299206495,
0.2970321178,
0.6929152608,
-0.010595087,
0.3573315144,
-0.4117316008,
0.0208521709,
-0.1267918348,
0.2403673977,
-0.2544969022,
-0.3325849473,
-0.6811227798,
-0.3473868966,
0.2404866517,
0.6083818078,
-0.8159858584,
0.7160482407,
-0.4520199299,
-0.5164931417,
-0.601373136,
0.1537265927,
0.2558017075,
0.6628346443,
0.4282091558,
-0.3715969026,
-0.7043631673,
-0.8738890886,
-0.4097841978,
0.079018563,
-0.3481860757,
0.1101344153,
0.5246017575,
-0.2880431414,
0.9491549134,
-0.2127011716,
-0.2206843942,
-0.1306157857,
0.5172357559,
0.2398941964,
0.6038067937,
0.331132561,
-0.9063211083,
0.121760942,
-0.2957590222,
-0.4644857049,
-0.1972701848,
-0.312165916,
-0.1759818047,
0.0736299604,
0.5322523117,
-0.2123104632,
0.4462800026,
0.5753002763,
-0.2244860083,
0.6375157833,
-0.370586127,
0.2407549769,
-1.1573711634,
0.165632844,
0.1212975904,
0.0980669782,
-1.0122182369,
0.2521975338,
0.0606839545,
0.0201377422,
0.0453540236,
0.40046978,
-0.1448663473,
-0.2136798501,
-0.2246342152,
0.0945971161,
0.1629677713,
0.363101989,
0.2566592693,
0.6860451698,
0.4231701791,
-0.6790392399,
0.2130356878,
0.1940840334,
-0.2356549203,
0.5845596194,
-0.5823270679,
0.1401067376,
-0.0857552439,
0.2850903869,
-0.9974569678,
-0.1097462997,
-0.2004812211,
-0.1133133471,
0.1002517566,
0.2876169682,
-0.6171505451,
-0.3049838841,
-0.7139735818,
0.3604799211,
-0.0868080184,
-0.5507749915,
0.6162350178,
0.2245406061,
0.0736861229,
-0.4519136548,
-0.7434459925,
0.1052265987,
-0.3663000762,
-0.6334096193,
0.4022078216,
-0.2204648107,
-0.1276288033,
-0.3101500273,
-0.0911280736,
-0.3516769707,
0.3941655457,
0.2003579736,
0.5715705156,
-0.362970233,
0.3476585448,
-0.1657931358,
-0.0361772515,
0.040496584,
-0.1828557104,
0.4875452816,
-0.1293163598,
-0.4234213233,
-0.4058449864,
0.2409078628,
0.3880798519,
-0.3849914372,
0.7377057672,
0.8367138505,
-0.5027911067,
0.2700831592,
-0.7842728496,
-0.381195128,
-0.4149807394,
0.5088405609,
-0.3519361913,
-0.6172888279,
0.4023945034,
-0.1288598031,
0.1949352324,
0.3954363465,
0.0853743702,
0.21480757,
0.6481956244,
0.3642742038,
-0.5165920258,
0.4781345129,
-0.1019367054,
0.2408556789,
-0.8909690976,
0.2555173635,
-0.6931071877,
-0.1928364038,
-0.6910495162,
-0.3174776137,
0.1602185667,
0.003784897,
-0.3713493049,
0.1823976338,
-0.2836381793,
0.3089399636,
0.8490353823,
0.2122189105,
0.3476713002,
-0.0388565622,
0.1548601836,
-0.1388943344,
-0.4941727221,
-0.3931708932,
1.1510978937,
0.2030833066,
0.2882542312,
-0.0319037251,
0.496838212,
0.2982004583,
0.1873349696,
-0.598126173,
0.3210382462,
-0.1857004911,
-0.6711490154,
-0.5450527668,
-0.5144314766,
-0.8117101789,
0.1978016943,
-0.6828763485,
-0.6394974589,
-0.0945009962,
0.0779873505,
-0.1142849922,
0.2370125502,
-0.644926548,
0.9074188471,
-0.178874746,
-0.2596100569,
-0.2490216643,
-0.7315936685,
0.3156709075,
-0.2909365296,
0.3514663577,
0.1861436069,
0.0048872023,
0.6310294867,
-0.1911747456,
0.5241463184,
0.0404539444,
0.0738006458,
-0.0888694301,
-0.1023950502,
0.5462172031,
-0.0504813865,
-0.4083522856,
0.2967097163,
-0.1762270033,
-0.5882697701,
-0.5325888395,
0.4281672537,
-0.5037814379,
-0.137084648,
-0.065860033,
-0.6256623268,
-0.3966319263,
0.206217736,
0.1567494869,
0.4715260863,
-0.1558948159,
0.1056076363,
0.5183335543,
-0.098466821,
0.5234672427,
0.1206511632,
-0.043790143,
-0.3128284216,
0.9272531271,
-0.0765312612,
0.3728991151,
0.3127084076,
0.2651342452,
-0.3503008485,
-0.6871039867,
-0.3764229417,
-0.0299496278,
-0.4754811823,
0.1023574844,
-0.3021967113,
-0.1423407793,
-0.468989104,
0.1272928864,
-0.2433600575,
-0.2421712875,
-0.1342609525,
-0.1447304785,
0.2848098576,
0.5588267446,
0.0302327555,
0.2535558939,
-0.7685898542,
0.3736200333,
0.1015220508,
0.3097003698,
-0.1924687773,
-0.4712661803,
0.0043604774,
0.0570398271,
-0.0857879519,
-0.5374654531,
0.2691098452,
0.4417626858,
0.5209670067,
0.3700895607,
0.0590656027,
0.9146649837,
-0.4413667619,
0.6974135637,
-0.0509047732,
-0.9490972757,
0.5512077808,
-0.2669484913,
0.2625383437,
0.6022099853,
0.161357522,
-0.6232571602,
-0.4356988668,
-0.5840116143,
-0.9878422022,
0.487649858,
0.2988329828,
0.1040675715,
0.1464130729,
0.4123995602,
0.0417841449,
0.3641458452,
-0.7264758348,
-0.2673157454,
-0.1402018666,
-0.2998568118,
-0.3284035921,
0.0047268276,
-0.0429061353,
-0.1374679655,
0.7362148762,
-0.2875827253,
-0.0873541236,
0.1546837091,
-0.3089285791,
0.1907606572,
0.116651617,
0.4570419192,
0.4072629809,
-0.1764693856,
0.0174189918,
0.370524168,
-0.6781558394,
-0.2883423567,
0.3861685097,
0.084548831,
-0.1552096158,
0.6160743833,
0.8376978636,
0.2017477006,
-0.554469347,
0.2878475189,
0.0007903008,
-0.0691823661,
-0.1125327498,
-0.2149690986,
-0.194505468,
0.0136674419,
0.4809288979,
0.1287690699,
0.3883371949,
-0.2559768558,
0.4316713214,
0.4079686999,
-0.32578668,
-0.0296481252,
0.3383422196,
0.0348991267,
-0.2035015821,
0.8996094465,
-0.0960283428,
-0.2713706493,
0.621784389,
0.3075028658,
0.4984158576,
-0.1527315229,
0.1585784853,
0.3325011432,
0.4582380354,
-0.1947512776,
0.0334956944,
-0.0321640335,
-0.7407474518,
-0.7061440349,
-0.521130085,
-0.2617532611,
0.3338160813,
-0.8046090603,
0.1570098847,
-0.322963357,
0.0335402451,
0.0157397687,
0.1328442544,
-0.490909338,
0.3446907401,
0.087425448,
0.7720275521,
-1.1100884676,
0.5871422291,
0.4815143049,
-0.2983157933,
-0.6157212853,
0.2329063267,
0.0865424499,
-0.474858433,
0.3712095916,
0.3430178761,
0.0768036991,
-0.0450961813,
-0.1563016921,
-0.740811646,
0.6944063306,
0.2603806257,
-0.2027831376,
0.2173742205,
0.1959640682,
0.5501388311,
-0.0960969999,
0.4668835998,
0.8062576056,
0.5689684749,
-0.1397909075,
-0.9219992757,
0.0113442298,
-0.273168087,
0.0921075419,
0.3378352225,
-0.0850035027,
0.6408730149,
0.1727503836,
0.1318504065,
0.1113029569,
0.6015683413,
0.2535939217,
0.4381569326,
0.8473296762,
0.865888238,
0.904440999,
-0.0900161415,
1.0755892992,
-0.1391253471,
0.3336274624,
1.1826162338,
-0.2816746533,
0.8755627275,
0.6684170961,
-0.1649159342,
0.3640869856,
0.9345492125,
-0.0575016253,
0.2198189795,
0.3729876578,
-0.260666877,
-0.1670846492,
-0.2217476219,
-0.292614162,
0.4412697852,
0.2372015566,
-0.0175188873,
-0.0293952636,
0.0920237303,
-0.1731745899,
0.1785258949,
-0.1403571218,
0.8141303062,
-0.5481385589,
-0.5653672814,
0.3381004035,
-0.378682822,
0.6604238153,
-0.493970722,
0.0048579942,
-0.271263808,
0.0081290463,
-0.1365406364,
-0.2133065909,
0.3948202133,
-0.3713623881,
-0.07834813,
-0.0455975682,
0.5461698174,
-0.2849286199,
-0.7384460568,
0.1675841063,
0.2204868197,
0.0216712132,
-0.2458791435,
-0.7669677734,
-0.1882226765,
-0.2540234625,
-0.4000848532,
0.301227361,
0.2810574472,
-0.1009437367,
0.5530730486,
0.8358439207,
0.0935926661,
0.0943582878,
0.4259607196,
0.7999048829,
-0.3397807181,
-0.2922445536,
-0.8386149406,
0.4626039267,
-0.4872541726,
-0.2726005614,
0.6569923759,
0.6733243465,
0.7362433076,
-0.0290864278,
0.5990807414,
0.1745756567,
0.5555445552,
-0.5619328618,
0.3952695429,
-0.5159342289,
0.1653500199,
-0.5076751709,
-0.8397544622,
-0.5474198461,
0.5176848173,
-0.1602340341,
0.0675337464,
0.7261835337,
0.973598659,
0.0421187766,
0.2559500039,
0.0754855424,
-0.0513799712,
0.0875073448,
0.2248554528,
0.6707705259,
-0.4593133628,
0.3696686327,
-0.2994948626,
-0.2198103517,
0.0713227093,
-1.0906095505,
-0.6898622513,
-0.6469579339,
-0.3110856116,
-0.2756592929,
-0.1093691438,
0.7425430417,
0.6888470054,
-0.7944712639,
-0.179501012,
-0.4483228028,
0.1445946395,
-0.4222016335,
-0.2352830768,
0.410482347,
-0.7067075968,
-0.7250099182,
0.4195297062,
0.2219130248,
-0.1176317558,
-0.3294050694,
0.1485504955,
-0.4518254399,
0.0870520324,
0.4005258977,
-0.1495166719,
-0.6520739198,
-0.233644709,
0.0508592203,
0.1308938414,
-0.0124323573,
0.9037654996,
-0.5878081322,
0.515624702,
0.3296617568,
0.9781844616,
0.2603610456,
-0.0446425974,
0.4352611601,
-1.0368884802,
0.2926299572,
0.1149641499,
0.217810303,
0.3932336569,
-0.2728564739,
0.5740006566,
0.2066901028,
-0.4891281128,
-0.8830895424,
0.296529144,
-0.6062757969,
-0.3365158737,
0.8581669331,
-0.0573878959,
-0.0717804804,
-0.2746051848,
-0.2389701605,
0.2845793664,
-0.0229906011,
0.9525841475,
0.8579205275,
0.0417786278,
0.0958399251,
-0.6478274465,
0.5840260386,
0.593372643,
-1.0568540096,
0.0634775311,
0.3901349008,
-0.2008288503,
0.4120423198,
0.1627539545,
0.2544985116,
-0.0036606253,
0.0100096809,
0.1088089645,
0.160440892,
0.0113874255,
-0.3753410876,
-0.075893648,
-0.1452644467,
-0.3370231986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08724v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08724v3 | DuNST: Dual Noisy Self Training for Semi-Supervised Controllable Text Generation | 2022-12-16T21:44:34 | 2023-06-06T04:13:03 | Yuxi Feng, Xiaoyuan Yi, Xiting Wang, Laks V. S. Lakshmanan, Xing Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL | Self-training (ST) has prospered again in language understanding by
augmenting the fine-tuning of pre-trained language models when labeled data is
insufficient. However, it remains challenging to incorporate ST into
attribute-controllable language generation. Augmented by only self-generated
pseudo text, generation models over-emphasize exploitation of the previously
learned space, suffering from a constrained generalization boundary. We revisit
ST and propose a novel method, DuNST to alleviate this problem. DuNST jointly
models text generation and classification with a shared Variational AutoEncoder
and corrupts the generated pseudo text by two kinds of flexible noise to
disturb the space. In this way, our model could construct and utilize both
pseudo text from given labels and pseudo labels from available unlabeled text,
which are gradually refined during the ST process. We theoretically demonstrate
that DuNST can be regarded as enhancing exploration towards the potential real
text space, providing a guarantee of improved performance. Experiments on three
controllable generation tasks show that DuNST could significantly boost control
accuracy while maintaining comparable generation fluency and diversity against
several strong baselines. | [
0.0793683752,
-0.5983842015,
0.2082687467,
0.2924673259,
-0.1544384956,
0.311509341,
-0.3778430521,
-0.4004445076,
0.0754770562,
0.3415792286,
-0.6030480862,
-0.183354184,
-0.4021433294,
0.0674073845,
-0.2092736959,
1.3369104862,
-0.262829721,
-0.1643812805,
-0.0273689702,
0.0428507142,
-0.3744620681,
-0.7702490687,
-0.4435762763,
-0.1004761979,
0.589138329,
0.2473246008,
0.5815397501,
0.6007925868,
0.1423327327,
0.3252096176,
0.2220464349,
0.1872145832,
-0.7011308074,
0.4618598223,
-0.0282858796,
-0.1545960754,
-0.1155413762,
0.1067950502,
0.7048184276,
0.6135528088,
-0.1399738789,
-0.1550349593,
0.2307452112,
0.3000093997,
-0.6089115739,
-0.0269946195,
-0.5329235196,
0.2234000713,
-0.327819705,
-0.075413458,
-0.1194709614,
-0.0496277586,
-0.0423054546,
-0.44437024,
0.3534381986,
-0.011329974,
0.8484352231,
0.5503697395,
-0.3551555276,
-0.402074188,
-1.1192185879,
1.0387943983,
-0.4785376191,
0.5407978892,
0.3158164918,
0.0898037031,
-0.1168432608,
-0.9658265114,
-0.5238788128,
-0.2693899274,
-0.124037005,
0.4337169528,
-0.1542532444,
0.0732641667,
-0.058555834,
0.6166273952,
-0.4214956462,
0.2125208825,
-0.4898917079,
-0.5358591676,
0.5796592832,
-0.151225403,
0.4038384855,
-0.0728477612,
-0.5617297292,
-0.1821247786,
-0.3658995628,
0.1459346712,
0.7651965022,
0.1365631372,
-0.0730957091,
0.4338246882,
0.195239231,
0.5684688687,
0.2018239647,
0.0145958336,
0.0994731039,
-0.3077367544,
-0.1812781394,
-0.0292791612,
1.0875689983,
-0.0267789327,
0.0216944981,
-0.4273791909,
-0.2765567899,
0.0353685729,
0.3337735534,
-0.6055601239,
-0.845620811,
-0.1230756044,
-0.0321651623,
-0.6497173905,
-0.0118328677,
-0.6876389384,
0.000474885,
-0.35757339,
0.398907721,
-0.3779200613,
-0.3767847717,
0.1066321507,
-0.0298023336,
-0.295088917,
0.0255774558,
-0.9320964217,
0.1296498626,
-0.0378575064,
0.5695879459,
-0.3980339468,
-0.4570090175,
-0.2417621911,
0.4660114646,
-0.4965325892,
0.6281562448,
-0.1565227956,
-0.3900704384,
-0.2685153782,
-0.5331900716,
-0.0937068835,
-0.5409321785,
0.2747891843,
-0.3263387978,
0.6767894626,
0.2068931162,
-0.4171176851,
0.3455434442,
-0.0513946302,
-0.5466583967,
1.4884282351,
0.3888907433,
-0.8974785209,
0.6513169408,
-0.3611491323,
-0.5418727398,
0.0708703473,
-0.5627612472,
-0.8433808088,
0.0938060656,
0.0155019676,
0.2997986376,
0.3444890976,
0.4343188703,
0.0476467758,
0.0801871121,
0.0944596529,
-0.4881403744,
0.4091621935,
0.2508282661,
-0.6293767095,
-0.0325447656,
-0.8071681261,
0.1996773481,
0.2264819294,
-0.5940638781,
-0.4457710087,
-0.3580897748,
-0.1004781276,
0.2852772474,
0.4273116589,
-0.4043432176,
0.0665158257,
-0.5995979309,
0.1676518172,
0.7177588344,
0.012536549,
0.6190801859,
-0.0555286035,
0.4951705337,
0.0240331721,
-0.0383713432,
-0.0014928662,
-0.1121997833,
-0.9377507567,
-0.4327034354,
0.3823630214,
0.2306292504,
-0.7267078161,
0.6493124962,
0.2056588978,
-0.2123791277,
-0.5049224496,
0.5857414603,
0.437918961,
0.5691516995,
0.470567733,
-0.1203041673,
-0.562525034,
-0.9771586657,
-0.3635296226,
-0.0381160527,
0.0115627032,
0.3525905013,
0.0190387294,
-0.2449069619,
1.0968306065,
-0.2473346889,
-0.286531359,
-0.4599868357,
0.5701726079,
-0.2602596581,
0.5292099118,
0.494795233,
-0.7183278799,
-0.715416491,
-0.2878288329,
-0.6532184482,
-0.5005311966,
-0.4544408917,
-0.2082400173,
0.2646591663,
0.5670530796,
-0.1393115968,
0.5520369411,
0.6358651519,
-0.0517047867,
0.6258740425,
-0.6379881501,
-0.2722186446,
-0.9419586062,
-0.1489997655,
-0.359451741,
-0.3412443697,
-0.6349340677,
-0.3188742995,
0.3036428094,
-0.0276736207,
-0.1228023544,
0.3128972948,
-0.7953460813,
0.2347886562,
-0.5925024748,
-0.1531980187,
-0.0229786411,
0.478897959,
0.1438596547,
1.1012052298,
0.5261729956,
-0.7391055226,
0.0560169779,
-0.0299799908,
-0.0491957068,
0.1862273514,
-0.3146163523,
0.2714658678,
-0.1409016848,
0.1808476448,
-0.9592490792,
-0.1927485317,
0.2515425384,
-0.1733496487,
0.6358568072,
0.1874515414,
-0.3798182309,
-0.5194685459,
0.0743011832,
0.4496916533,
0.5350213647,
-0.6037320495,
0.2391664833,
0.3828151822,
-0.1054397672,
-0.3586460352,
-0.7963006496,
0.1672982424,
-0.2666647732,
-0.3734598458,
0.1305815279,
-0.2833529711,
0.0062280968,
-0.1863872856,
-0.4002909064,
0.1071369722,
-0.0527678281,
0.1538486332,
-0.0442985408,
0.0415148064,
0.2112869918,
0.5347266197,
-0.2511409223,
-0.0444579385,
-0.5912530422,
0.4005900025,
0.0876856968,
-0.0527035333,
-0.5147822499,
0.3018935323,
-0.102546744,
-0.1341753155,
0.552618444,
0.4024290442,
0.0813317671,
-0.87548244,
-0.2651596367,
-0.2005455792,
-0.5388401151,
0.2354257107,
-0.3995857835,
-1.0235729218,
0.0057135648,
-0.3444204926,
0.0935904533,
0.4307081401,
0.6753846407,
-0.5137388706,
0.6146648526,
1.0327193737,
0.0817797929,
0.4047338367,
-0.2814673781,
0.3861565292,
-0.2612288296,
-0.2228874564,
-0.2392458171,
-0.421847105,
-0.266171217,
-0.3966057897,
0.1963089257,
0.4114642441,
0.1372032315,
0.3509140611,
-0.6995515823,
0.4347862899,
0.5452857614,
-0.2224898338,
0.1841246337,
0.2641798854,
-0.514446795,
-0.5586724877,
-0.972292304,
-0.3350010514,
0.9285570979,
0.1950510591,
1.0482782125,
-0.1028987318,
1.073441267,
0.3418510258,
0.077130042,
-0.362735182,
0.2289241552,
-0.1442439705,
-0.3910603523,
-0.2341565192,
-0.7575805187,
-0.9801825285,
0.0404830948,
0.0792417899,
-0.5690946579,
0.0133891525,
0.4919235408,
-0.3775304854,
0.385486275,
-0.7756553888,
0.6795728803,
-0.5251027346,
-0.2711360157,
0.0435583927,
-0.697773695,
0.34327057,
-0.4189282656,
0.2439723015,
0.3075695336,
-0.0331592411,
0.833127737,
-0.3108548522,
1.0662724972,
-0.060067039,
-0.4576055408,
0.333299011,
0.3871997297,
0.4750797451,
-0.0426888354,
0.3687256277,
0.0754605085,
-0.3012079,
-0.2877315581,
-0.4790867567,
0.7018595338,
-1.0327723026,
-0.2537969649,
-0.4774567187,
-0.6732341051,
-0.2284348458,
0.2377253771,
0.72887218,
0.2427239269,
-0.1437440515,
-0.1241947189,
0.7374988794,
-0.2164450884,
0.3464142084,
0.1493475139,
-0.0798804462,
-0.4599930942,
0.9280446172,
0.1347402334,
0.4216185212,
0.2749549448,
0.4058827162,
-0.5085165501,
-0.3751901388,
-0.3927254081,
0.1603756994,
-0.2641617358,
-0.214879185,
-1.1143803596,
-0.5112755895,
-0.4716591239,
-0.1149558723,
-0.6102432013,
-0.6754899025,
-0.4817310274,
-0.1624420136,
-0.0046441536,
1.0191116333,
-0.6282622814,
0.7370651364,
-0.3324381113,
0.5402336717,
0.4857572615,
0.3752808273,
-0.3512971699,
-0.545871973,
-0.3588050008,
0.0089107128,
-0.3359313607,
-0.8098356724,
0.2822420597,
0.3514451683,
0.5948548317,
0.2895420492,
0.2600497305,
0.4800822735,
-0.4718847275,
0.690543592,
0.4681010246,
-0.5535319448,
0.6457839012,
-0.2407404333,
0.2163261324,
0.4846195877,
0.1388417184,
-0.2745815814,
-0.8989860415,
-0.9259383082,
-0.880807817,
0.8063562512,
0.4555322826,
0.3578057885,
0.332033366,
0.2597296536,
0.4488841593,
0.2744977772,
-1.1097247601,
-0.2640721202,
-0.5450991392,
-0.4109266698,
0.0069291438,
-0.4371016622,
-0.101737991,
-0.1208170727,
0.6279804707,
0.1283251792,
0.1183217168,
0.1502044946,
-0.1273694783,
-0.3081510365,
0.1825316548,
0.2686778307,
0.2101095766,
0.1124569848,
0.4543971419,
-0.0693496838,
-0.5480188131,
0.1886045486,
0.0477070212,
-0.3733425736,
-0.00756949,
0.1500489861,
0.7882546186,
0.3302543759,
-0.2453271598,
0.4168663323,
-0.0482767597,
-0.4561512172,
-0.2606619596,
0.4013088346,
-0.2573702931,
0.0112997023,
0.1882539988,
0.2194941342,
-0.0666611344,
-0.0176741965,
0.5475688577,
0.2453851253,
-0.3893030882,
-0.3568492532,
0.8993265033,
-0.0068100872,
-0.1976244897,
0.2134843916,
-0.3943706155,
-0.5265591145,
0.1632991582,
0.8027818203,
0.7820498943,
-0.2741835713,
0.280446142,
0.3265360594,
0.2686132193,
0.1221609935,
0.1603740752,
-0.48933056,
-0.6501659751,
-0.302490294,
-0.8012399673,
-0.1094317585,
0.3736125231,
-0.3023904562,
-0.0046604606,
-0.58585006,
-0.0601068214,
-0.2668820322,
0.0025856248,
-0.1952602118,
0.2639190853,
0.1020741537,
0.4239610434,
-0.7193612456,
0.8670844436,
0.6650903821,
-0.1948570907,
-0.9810869098,
0.2790232897,
-0.1892895103,
-0.4694684446,
0.4275398552,
0.0248684715,
-0.3994543254,
0.2960663438,
-0.7419427633,
-0.7148746848,
0.6614257693,
0.2159750164,
-0.4131210446,
0.0233344641,
0.3498127759,
0.6408607364,
0.0042757327,
-0.1828822792,
0.3240903914,
0.3522728086,
0.1850052178,
-0.6792634726,
-0.4224382937,
-0.076991342,
-0.0615465455,
0.1850432158,
-0.7339711785,
0.6161213517,
0.0316539183,
-0.461504817,
0.1228209734,
1.1105061769,
0.2167732418,
0.1512795389,
0.5402556658,
0.5790998936,
0.7422275543,
0.1615025997,
0.5786002874,
-0.125435248,
0.3083047867,
1.3982645273,
-0.0245674904,
0.2098962218,
0.4994235337,
-0.0988407806,
0.4174560308,
0.3536157906,
0.078660883,
0.7105973959,
0.2433982939,
-0.3541838527,
-0.3611724377,
0.2337836176,
-0.3234103322,
0.3916583061,
0.178202197,
-0.1340432912,
-0.5977471471,
0.3193491399,
0.012246212,
0.4908273518,
0.1112902239,
0.9121658206,
0.0727714673,
-0.3457254171,
0.491672039,
0.1599908024,
0.8773208261,
-0.8150963783,
0.224839583,
-0.3090741336,
0.2623268068,
0.1089943945,
-0.5339369178,
0.2593398988,
0.0882650539,
0.0274646804,
-0.8168154359,
0.934214592,
-0.821672976,
-0.5216684937,
0.342163831,
0.455196023,
0.2513073385,
0.1949240416,
-0.7525625229,
-0.3240396976,
0.2608724535,
-0.332698375,
0.3581112623,
0.8105112314,
-0.0301416181,
0.3792586327,
0.6280137897,
0.3458469212,
0.6454732418,
0.0695581585,
0.9112653732,
-0.4641429782,
-0.9479795098,
-0.5198947191,
0.3364517391,
-0.0579175614,
-0.3158732653,
0.7878610492,
0.824360311,
0.9512290359,
-0.0090199849,
1.0419129133,
-0.2464567572,
0.7373180389,
-0.3476759195,
0.9355082512,
-0.6743705869,
0.0003077799,
-0.0621591173,
-0.6312142611,
-0.2786978781,
0.5350339413,
-0.2998604178,
0.2528626621,
0.5235470533,
0.6446245313,
-0.5241122246,
-0.09365464,
0.5325208306,
0.2127729505,
0.2588750124,
0.2586943507,
1.1351274252,
-0.2240116894,
0.8154877424,
-0.6037374139,
-0.4241065681,
0.2152952999,
-0.6019899249,
-1.0810732841,
-0.5291784406,
-0.2163790762,
-0.1189094484,
-0.0304630175,
0.4549879134,
0.7680656314,
-0.759370625,
-0.1947940737,
-0.4205472767,
-0.3481329978,
-0.0131601244,
-0.2301633209,
0.4101754129,
-0.8716862202,
-0.7333251834,
0.6628034115,
0.2947026491,
0.5469532013,
-0.4307111502,
-0.206740737,
-0.0699454769,
-0.0586622097,
0.0970878676,
0.4170609415,
-0.2472672909,
0.068199262,
-0.2552663386,
-0.4571737349,
0.1686300933,
1.0641442537,
-0.8264350295,
0.5464708209,
0.1413028985,
0.5777125955,
0.6326348782,
0.1061723232,
0.7014214993,
-1.3528455496,
0.427736491,
0.3074684739,
-0.1656303853,
0.237841174,
-0.739158988,
0.1839302778,
0.3785366118,
-0.5488415956,
-0.6008467078,
0.3390789926,
-0.6179225445,
-0.420275569,
1.007398963,
0.1127543077,
-0.1494396627,
-0.1872093678,
-0.3903928697,
0.5606462955,
-0.3534953892,
0.8297919631,
0.3609828353,
-0.1964547932,
-0.31810835,
-0.3599866927,
0.9035627842,
0.6804437041,
-0.6041709781,
0.2388969511,
0.5593828559,
0.0971270278,
0.0164963733,
0.7919919491,
0.0478377268,
-0.1127907783,
-0.0782647058,
0.1887695044,
-0.3180792332,
-0.7279590964,
-0.2231554836,
0.0040081171,
-0.1692668349,
-0.1300278157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08718v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08718v1 | Neural Story Planning | 2022-12-16T21:29:41 | 2022-12-16T21:29:41 | Anbang Ye, Christopher Cui, Taiwei Shi, Mark O. Riedl | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automated plot generation is the challenge of generating a sequence of events
that will be perceived by readers as the plot of a coherent story. Traditional
symbolic planners plan a story from a goal state and guarantee logical causal
plot coherence but rely on a library of hand-crafted actions with their
preconditions and effects. This closed world setting limits the length and
diversity of what symbolic planners can generate. On the other hand,
pre-trained neural language models can generate stories with great diversity,
while being generally incapable of ending a story in a specified manner and can
have trouble maintaining coherence. In this paper, we present an approach to
story plot generation that unifies causal planning with neural language models.
We propose to use commonsense knowledge extracted from large language models to
recursively expand a story plot in a backward chaining fashion. Specifically,
our system infers the preconditions for events in the story and then events
that will cause those conditions to become true. We performed automatic
evaluation to measure narrative coherence as indicated by the ability to answer
questions about whether different events in the story are causally related to
other events. Results indicate that our proposed method produces more coherent
plotlines than several strong baselines. | [
-0.266690433,
-0.5239906311,
0.6636257172,
0.5306347609,
-0.2157341093,
-0.0953924954,
-0.1620093137,
-0.4685344398,
0.4441972077,
0.5213493109,
-0.936676085,
-0.5304306746,
-0.4396430254,
0.0611435845,
-0.2650890946,
1.091350317,
-0.1746980846,
-0.2091814578,
0.2170544565,
-0.0512044318,
-0.7659289837,
-0.3432202339,
-0.5202380419,
-0.4860982001,
0.7447219491,
0.2573594153,
0.9338366985,
0.627212584,
0.0551270433,
0.3184561133,
0.2715167105,
0.3164108694,
-0.3897138536,
0.6212317944,
-0.2737624645,
-0.2473523021,
-0.273060739,
-0.1112779379,
0.3020471931,
0.9069660306,
0.0426734798,
-0.0891752094,
-0.054663416,
0.5360606909,
-0.5226580501,
0.0064401911,
-0.2788672447,
0.2842736244,
0.4643825889,
-0.3354720175,
-0.1697606891,
-0.5965966582,
0.3305719793,
-0.6619657278,
0.2578468621,
-0.0519385673,
0.7785614729,
0.0865126848,
-0.2475337833,
-0.3310462534,
-0.9055042863,
0.7589276433,
-0.5248475075,
-0.0070083565,
0.3983000517,
0.1776701659,
-0.2318438292,
-0.6973528862,
-0.5319114923,
-0.2730644047,
-0.223924011,
0.1241674349,
-0.3509325385,
-0.0003386783,
0.2982136011,
-0.2186360508,
-0.5618781447,
0.0543781854,
-0.2965060174,
-0.0397490636,
1.0187129974,
0.5801507235,
0.5332356691,
-0.3096961379,
-0.1962346286,
-0.0882364735,
-0.436494112,
-0.1554824412,
0.6334360838,
0.163594529,
-0.0735805184,
0.609701097,
-0.4006864429,
0.6148898005,
0.0003396111,
0.0067401966,
-0.328053385,
-0.4805461466,
-0.0847337916,
0.1858875901,
0.7387972474,
0.706561923,
0.4848125279,
-0.2449757606,
-0.1881658137,
0.0029877399,
0.2417401075,
-0.6835149527,
-0.1333642751,
0.3052688539,
-0.3748538196,
-0.3886718154,
-0.5597609282,
-0.6949258447,
-0.3778292537,
-0.5490253568,
0.1673605293,
-0.652901113,
-0.1629489362,
0.1693979055,
-0.5159022808,
-0.0640068203,
0.3266980946,
-1.010461092,
0.0958340541,
0.5742086768,
0.6706787348,
0.2074675858,
-0.7447405457,
-0.2500660717,
0.5142802596,
-0.4342773259,
0.7362223268,
-0.016765302,
0.0171614569,
-0.0413912125,
-0.5285147429,
0.047413595,
0.0520823225,
0.2926911116,
-0.4591469467,
0.1719781011,
-0.1170614958,
-0.2168525308,
-0.2971090376,
0.4064847827,
-0.452038765,
0.1325197816,
-0.2502609491,
-0.5527318716,
0.570022583,
-0.0211812928,
-0.7855865359,
-0.2715810537,
-0.3311398625,
-0.0900522545,
0.0754953772,
0.483053714,
0.3439947963,
-0.2003663629,
1.2171645164,
0.0091138417,
-0.1256550252,
-0.0600535013,
-0.4771025777,
0.8172706962,
0.1396091878,
-0.3535995483,
0.4475796223,
-0.7364236712,
0.0794824883,
-0.030363461,
0.0319930837,
-0.2165489346,
0.1498881727,
-0.198371619,
0.1907827109,
0.0793894976,
-0.3006885946,
0.2100251466,
-0.6943286657,
0.2279267013,
0.5822678804,
0.25962919,
0.4735051095,
-0.5836613774,
0.4199815094,
-0.1698927879,
0.0521331877,
-0.5367175341,
-0.6868016124,
-0.8678542376,
0.3376193643,
-0.3726913333,
0.2800678909,
-0.6175359488,
0.6804846525,
-0.1953698248,
-0.5284346342,
0.2636339664,
-0.3179985881,
0.3983741105,
0.4706516266,
0.2105479985,
-0.1145311147,
-0.6907017827,
-0.8053587675,
-0.4077424407,
-0.324111104,
-0.077242516,
-0.1950921863,
0.4287428856,
0.3457719982,
0.9841656089,
-0.6895191073,
0.0084061259,
-0.5770503879,
0.5187307,
0.430084765,
0.5368849635,
0.0085173491,
-0.6115422249,
-0.1979026943,
-0.0834997967,
-0.9461022019,
-0.0417410694,
-0.787791729,
-0.2655437589,
0.0893415734,
0.5526607037,
-0.6247262359,
0.6725159883,
0.3871617317,
-0.730761528,
0.8411148787,
-0.4465746582,
-0.0298105795,
-1.0203037262,
0.0801076367,
-0.3308590651,
0.2295498699,
-0.6553203464,
-0.0442535654,
-0.3234951794,
-0.3969376385,
-0.0633781552,
0.5839076042,
-0.4942234159,
-0.1926457137,
-0.1052463949,
0.1665061712,
0.0749651641,
0.8920654058,
0.2401585132,
0.0626135096,
0.2151141614,
-0.6139354706,
0.2824614644,
0.533993423,
-0.1235229671,
0.3401576877,
-0.5835268497,
-0.1851872653,
-0.0727687851,
0.3601115644,
-0.7654029727,
-0.3098264337,
0.0095047187,
-0.4612347782,
0.1188173965,
0.0008893488,
-0.4160732627,
-0.2466425151,
0.136226505,
0.1319829077,
0.352067709,
-0.5856595635,
0.7176505327,
-0.0419068672,
-0.2563375831,
-0.3997608721,
-0.8976433873,
0.3390789926,
0.0080156969,
-1.2307573557,
0.1962853372,
0.1657147408,
-0.2384997308,
0.0565063506,
0.1254608333,
-0.2312980294,
-0.270501107,
0.3694916368,
-0.0163087696,
-0.325763762,
0.2109367698,
0.5867240429,
-0.3087552786,
0.1003170982,
-0.5005177259,
0.6516638398,
0.1384543031,
-0.2486577481,
-0.4614380002,
0.7158226371,
0.5066404939,
-0.1778980643,
0.5111836195,
0.2035601735,
-0.2035667002,
-0.3538806438,
-0.1230162308,
-0.1204081699,
-0.4148118198,
0.3189462423,
-0.1493704021,
-0.4823263586,
0.4821193516,
-0.0982714519,
0.1862175316,
0.3453902304,
0.3425481915,
-0.0072234287,
0.974399507,
0.7522107363,
0.3525823355,
0.114000544,
-0.2178895921,
0.1746412218,
-0.2553951442,
-0.178609103,
-0.1208313406,
-0.7656549811,
-0.3123702705,
-0.1060319468,
0.0291389488,
0.5082300901,
-0.539671123,
0.4333468676,
-0.4116180539,
0.6370366812,
0.5927858353,
-0.1941556931,
0.657112062,
-0.0794713423,
-0.3433504403,
-0.0322990529,
-0.9148927331,
-0.516942203,
0.7572882175,
0.0203782506,
0.536970377,
-0.0667591169,
1.0011774302,
-0.3483628333,
0.2587561011,
-0.3099301457,
0.6215756536,
-0.0521496646,
-0.5854175091,
-0.6073333621,
-0.1285926402,
-1.0870244503,
0.0575692728,
-0.3821302354,
-1.0218496323,
0.6918609738,
0.0066778832,
-0.6402676105,
0.1698672175,
-0.8805864453,
0.7162712812,
-0.497741133,
-0.3158200979,
-0.2492758483,
-0.6901171207,
0.6140421033,
-0.0562899075,
-0.4193228185,
-0.0011917215,
0.1310749352,
0.6184607148,
-0.5624760389,
1.0621136427,
0.0764767304,
0.1283486784,
0.440143615,
0.2498007119,
0.600168407,
0.0472850129,
-0.0147441356,
0.0631436631,
-0.4076948464,
-0.2228687555,
-0.4981957078,
0.6818355918,
-0.6379243135,
-0.5158053041,
-0.251068294,
-1.2044457197,
-0.1703246832,
0.4287936091,
0.3359442949,
0.3858782947,
-0.4152650833,
-0.51165694,
-0.038905479,
-0.6909233332,
0.8878043294,
0.2602891028,
-0.4423687756,
-0.558185339,
0.5845655799,
0.2043558806,
0.3664816022,
-0.016333323,
0.308573693,
-0.1974642873,
-0.6105663776,
-0.3514302373,
0.0145610068,
-0.497289896,
-0.0631438866,
-0.7545985579,
-0.3237617016,
-0.2805556953,
-0.7852248549,
-0.0616867766,
-0.55163908,
-0.0088392049,
-0.2278476357,
0.2832042277,
0.8529949784,
-0.3373611569,
0.4298282266,
-0.7991570234,
0.4241644144,
0.1692259908,
0.0873973221,
0.249591276,
0.1562464088,
-0.0378324576,
-0.1750275642,
-0.5781545043,
-0.8504644632,
1.0501996279,
-0.1334176809,
0.1907287538,
0.3159303665,
0.2378961444,
0.8229087591,
-0.6876456738,
0.5093362331,
0.7166277766,
-0.6386291385,
0.7515127659,
-0.791852951,
0.6416329145,
0.4858626425,
0.4503053129,
-0.5134937763,
-0.8087936044,
-0.8796152472,
-0.8541437387,
0.5943196416,
0.5668628216,
0.1245199144,
-0.0751064122,
0.0281353183,
0.1935563982,
0.1811079085,
-0.4992351234,
0.005689736,
-0.2070157528,
-0.0336062498,
-0.2179462612,
-0.0257812496,
-0.1793281585,
-0.2545957863,
0.0806380957,
0.0489351749,
-0.0458619297,
0.3354533315,
0.2412287146,
-0.4116930664,
0.0626151934,
0.6530169249,
0.8637552261,
-0.0072773728,
0.1073956192,
-0.1308600754,
-0.3744007945,
0.0038236668,
0.369673878,
-0.5898207426,
0.0163366329,
0.7425041199,
0.7719190717,
0.1728074998,
-0.4636939764,
0.2013025433,
-0.1182312369,
-0.2233709246,
-0.2433601469,
0.066308558,
0.3282777071,
0.6170406342,
0.1378372461,
0.5066736937,
-0.2978754342,
-0.5437541604,
0.5381537676,
-0.1890242398,
-0.1356552541,
-0.2080942839,
0.3921542168,
0.3523693979,
-0.4931658506,
0.8633784652,
-0.1108309701,
-0.4394450188,
0.9526401162,
0.8647193909,
1.078320384,
0.0797533542,
0.4352549613,
0.7923702002,
0.6020154953,
0.1284226775,
0.3622252941,
0.1622844189,
-0.7336470485,
-0.6744343638,
-0.6776431799,
0.0136963399,
-0.0174693391,
-0.1838886589,
0.4366022944,
-0.4305193722,
0.2214889824,
-0.2360425293,
-0.190618366,
-0.2241500616,
0.2794082165,
0.0303133875,
0.8258088231,
-0.6098245978,
0.5729979277,
0.0944556221,
-0.7473217249,
-1.1239423752,
0.3341548741,
-0.2255632579,
-0.7029427886,
0.9170719981,
0.1516815573,
0.1424176693,
-0.0323342048,
-0.2571181357,
-0.9358666539,
1.2610125542,
0.428471148,
-0.6554317474,
-0.5172752738,
0.1461094171,
0.8364098668,
-0.396892935,
-0.1171352491,
0.2445119768,
0.6023709774,
0.3446894884,
-0.5128727555,
0.2294001132,
0.0074383169,
-0.2783681154,
0.4376360476,
-0.1367741078,
0.6376864314,
-0.6689825058,
-0.5375962853,
0.4015186131,
0.8863226771,
0.4747439623,
0.7315631509,
0.2488161922,
0.6467748284,
0.5654598475,
0.1018560454,
1.2699192762,
-0.3317985237,
-0.1851324886,
1.510720253,
0.152519986,
0.571157515,
0.2892405689,
0.4215030074,
0.4960536063,
0.4183778465,
0.1303606927,
0.4615048468,
0.2537764609,
-0.0271238256,
-0.3468750417,
-0.0505718291,
-0.1085930169,
0.207780093,
0.0075462824,
-0.4590823948,
-0.6656281352,
-0.1424191594,
-0.1262074709,
0.3695743978,
-0.3559655547,
0.3685649931,
0.2614130974,
-1.299331069,
0.3124297559,
-0.2342074513,
0.2971771955,
-0.7697237134,
-0.0543820113,
-0.3777067661,
0.0446335748,
-0.006308699,
-0.9543335438,
0.8181288242,
-0.008625621,
-0.0867057443,
-0.4866743982,
0.8072861433,
-0.5345054269,
-0.3255106509,
0.2609863281,
0.5655089021,
-0.0873846114,
0.133376807,
-0.4175922275,
-0.2898558378,
-0.0674173608,
-0.1058912873,
0.1333550811,
0.5590310693,
-0.3296624422,
0.5134086609,
0.7594521642,
0.173483476,
0.0637912452,
-0.0042043445,
0.6953287721,
-0.8307759166,
-0.8755226731,
-0.6976512671,
0.6557793021,
-0.242734924,
-0.8031594753,
0.4618319571,
0.3014889956,
0.496284008,
-0.0251377802,
0.3625440001,
0.0779367611,
-0.2634860873,
-0.4497830868,
1.010477066,
-0.1345876902,
0.1311632395,
-0.139591381,
-0.7302162647,
-0.4781026542,
0.2587958574,
-0.5428967476,
-0.2019628137,
0.8922715187,
0.5510735512,
0.1578319371,
0.2302328795,
0.5467556715,
0.1458598673,
0.1450476199,
0.7368246317,
1.217128396,
-0.0189946797,
0.5139356852,
-0.1247365847,
-0.1399301738,
0.3927045763,
-0.9571772218,
-0.9433977008,
-0.5798537135,
-0.0232703127,
-0.0786440149,
0.2521667182,
0.2947302163,
0.6145225167,
-0.2925493121,
-0.4362525046,
-0.8077725172,
0.2344349623,
-0.1048382893,
-0.1936496198,
0.2712686658,
-0.5031626821,
-0.3487441838,
0.3445529938,
0.3893343806,
-0.180327639,
-0.2343211025,
-0.2375069261,
-0.4041404426,
0.1536532044,
0.432463944,
0.3267354965,
-0.3667587936,
-0.0818477347,
-0.4200623035,
-0.0787035078,
-0.3765499294,
1.0231175423,
-0.7246673107,
0.339692235,
0.6440746784,
0.2981258631,
0.5912780166,
-0.3899719417,
1.4196052551,
-0.9497336149,
0.138953954,
0.5983179212,
0.169943884,
-0.1712520868,
-0.5139058828,
0.4367686212,
-0.0275819786,
-0.4932309687,
-0.3701508045,
0.62819314,
-0.8070765138,
-0.5500468612,
0.9069575071,
0.1086029038,
-0.2060401738,
-0.2327773273,
-0.279974699,
0.4335704148,
-0.0868572667,
0.531011641,
0.3651936352,
-0.611051023,
0.1922868192,
-0.1102397218,
0.4016543031,
0.2009142339,
-0.8033712506,
0.2332083732,
0.7465615869,
-0.2505650222,
0.6475090384,
0.7348428369,
0.1841219515,
0.2219280154,
0.4002420008,
0.0647917241,
-0.2579002082,
-0.4875365496,
-0.108275421,
0.3246591389,
-0.4482938647,
0.288182348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08703v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08703v1 | Fast Entropy-Based Methods of Word-Level Confidence Estimation for End-To-End Automatic Speech Recognition | 2022-12-16T20:27:40 | 2022-12-16T20:27:40 | Aleksandr Laptev, Boris Ginsburg | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT | This paper presents a class of new fast non-trainable entropy-based
confidence estimation methods for automatic speech recognition. We show how
per-frame entropy values can be normalized and aggregated to obtain a
confidence measure per unit and per word for Connectionist Temporal
Classification (CTC) and Recurrent Neural Network Transducer (RNN-T) models.
Proposed methods have similar computational complexity to the traditional
method based on the maximum per-frame probability, but they are more
adjustable, have a wider effective threshold range, and better push apart the
confidence distributions of correct and incorrect words. We evaluate the
proposed confidence measures on LibriSpeech test sets, and show that they are
up to 2 and 4 times better than confidence estimation based on the maximum
per-frame probability at detecting incorrect words for Conformer-CTC and
Conformer-RNN-T models, respectively. | [
-0.1960610598,
-0.4564366043,
0.309653163,
-0.0022067258,
-0.3893378973,
0.0764413923,
-0.2399593592,
-0.522665441,
0.3633230031,
-0.1362195611,
-0.1697751582,
-0.5050744414,
-0.8797135353,
0.1406386495,
-0.84297508,
0.2907059193,
0.0345344506,
0.1640498936,
0.2314105779,
-0.1017626449,
-0.0499974526,
-0.3979568481,
-0.6522608399,
-0.1707957685,
0.5031647086,
0.1420972198,
0.3627354205,
0.5042613745,
0.3765997887,
0.3031150103,
-0.2143165618,
-0.1178869009,
-0.0304820221,
0.2371790856,
0.1987209767,
-0.4065078199,
-0.3204236627,
0.1014137343,
0.7321844697,
0.3991789818,
-0.2909244597,
0.374681592,
-0.1538376063,
0.2783906758,
-1.1121408939,
0.1517385095,
-0.6465255022,
0.2810485959,
-0.2851449847,
-0.5827329159,
-0.4724285007,
-0.4113457501,
0.3068944514,
-0.3475247025,
0.0363911502,
0.0328524262,
0.5612101555,
0.4057385027,
-0.1610300094,
-0.2105331868,
-0.7259387374,
1.0138226748,
-0.9685838819,
0.8338387012,
0.5929656029,
0.3526511788,
-0.0048270375,
-0.8070611954,
-0.5418237448,
-0.3275157213,
0.4349939823,
0.1204039156,
-0.0771745294,
0.3133359551,
0.118789427,
0.3118044436,
-0.7395430207,
0.2117083669,
0.015687339,
-0.4111578763,
0.6120786071,
-0.0482762456,
0.0244736653,
0.3853769898,
-0.1792206615,
-0.2162533104,
-0.0736765936,
0.2643166482,
0.0672174543,
0.1811141223,
-0.0940332487,
0.4587792456,
-0.1641919166,
1.0139483213,
0.0624536052,
-0.577039659,
0.3963622749,
-0.0591932163,
-0.42061764,
0.3886392713,
0.6698971391,
0.2144436389,
0.5238062143,
-0.4033818543,
-0.2927101851,
0.1209487319,
-0.2172162831,
-0.5017935634,
-0.0765617043,
0.2067763358,
-0.3392304778,
-0.2800242007,
0.1876745224,
-0.4453842342,
-0.2805377841,
-0.2807455063,
0.4211788774,
-0.359233886,
-0.0851863474,
0.087253198,
-0.3403937221,
0.4825983047,
0.2787903547,
-0.5203802586,
0.0356684551,
0.2869597971,
1.0086005926,
-0.2043258548,
-0.0663388595,
-0.4463672638,
-0.0035943966,
-0.6092399359,
0.6796606183,
-0.4927114546,
-0.1830648929,
-0.2973311543,
0.0201684162,
-0.3287523687,
-0.2432547361,
0.3186490238,
-0.5608606935,
0.1693919152,
0.5259782672,
-0.9523742199,
-0.1751190871,
0.1677211672,
-0.35648489,
0.6514347792,
-0.0335652269,
-0.9029482603,
0.2132979482,
-0.2331950068,
-0.4031012952,
-0.1392669082,
0.0951639563,
-0.3217746019,
0.2390785068,
-0.1054262668,
0.6164193749,
-0.3034650981,
-0.001938652,
-0.4924699068,
-0.4660173059,
0.5914238095,
-0.9033889174,
0.8264008164,
0.3880168796,
-0.286626488,
0.0287511218,
-0.9233739972,
0.6683590412,
-0.3508096635,
-0.2758288383,
-0.3526655436,
-0.2533587813,
-0.1627122313,
0.0489632823,
0.335444212,
-0.6645924449,
-0.4142919183,
-0.4324271083,
0.5501746535,
0.5652430654,
-0.0032514483,
0.295794636,
-0.1210562885,
0.3191332817,
-0.0392404087,
0.0482166782,
0.1694142371,
-0.5646978021,
-0.5956783295,
-0.252794832,
0.6187220812,
1.0339993238,
-0.5976649523,
0.8799837232,
-0.0857909843,
-0.8194779754,
-0.2174698561,
-0.2553048432,
0.4888253212,
0.5319770575,
0.2964183092,
-0.6136956215,
-0.5350843668,
-0.4238569736,
-0.3431002796,
-0.4728858769,
-0.3263113201,
-0.0649759918,
0.1706848592,
0.0266881865,
0.6504947543,
-0.3063296974,
0.0589025207,
0.2574290931,
0.4938763976,
0.0323992409,
0.3748432994,
0.0682705864,
-0.4227569699,
-0.5338414311,
-0.3783400059,
-0.5129311085,
0.2366142124,
0.1906908751,
0.4238266349,
0.3688432574,
0.340518713,
-0.1366941035,
0.8101962209,
0.5514098406,
-0.1855953783,
0.3040110767,
-0.0518824346,
0.1208169386,
-0.9997412562,
-0.1704304218,
0.3200901747,
-0.4856433868,
-0.9744448066,
-0.351220727,
-0.0249938592,
0.1957953572,
-0.4671106935,
0.4580921233,
-0.3565539718,
-0.107579425,
-0.2121141702,
-0.1137145236,
-0.4230349362,
0.3707616627,
0.404714644,
0.8265898824,
0.724888742,
-0.6832313538,
0.5103927255,
-0.0990837738,
-0.506170094,
0.439822197,
-0.528652966,
0.2709881663,
-0.1383242607,
0.1531566381,
-1.1506392956,
-0.1449785829,
-0.216799736,
-0.9634607434,
0.5824342966,
0.09710145,
-0.101093784,
-0.0993989334,
-0.0913247839,
0.3189156651,
0.5832793117,
-0.2382991612,
0.2584635317,
0.6454818249,
0.0387606286,
-0.6265843511,
-1.0827322006,
0.2870928347,
-0.3062299192,
-0.4465505779,
0.3271885514,
-0.0009438244,
-0.2158409655,
-0.5144454241,
-0.153593868,
-0.7800158858,
-0.0165753867,
0.1387161165,
-0.0552201532,
-0.0443713777,
0.2331021428,
-0.29980883,
-0.2552181184,
-0.3317992687,
-0.4870487154,
0.3971988857,
-0.2703152597,
-0.0580634438,
-0.8577292562,
0.139908269,
0.4454565048,
-0.1824989468,
0.4511301219,
0.9660457969,
-0.5070241094,
0.1229795963,
-0.66578269,
-0.3305841088,
-0.3853383362,
0.2983079255,
-0.0310007893,
-0.939230442,
0.3254321218,
0.207106933,
0.0771507695,
0.2171194702,
0.4341799617,
-0.2011882514,
0.5599864125,
0.5243644714,
-0.2388259917,
0.6663867235,
-0.1361331791,
0.146186024,
-0.5450714231,
0.0666973814,
-0.5424710512,
-0.2968459129,
-0.4857779443,
-0.4971929193,
0.4004918337,
-0.1602259576,
-0.5212548375,
0.3767256737,
-0.5536267161,
-0.0528671667,
0.684702754,
0.1079667285,
0.1744409949,
0.1913164109,
0.056559179,
0.1477233171,
-0.5286184549,
-0.0809607878,
1.0015867949,
0.349689573,
0.8746288419,
-0.0712255016,
0.7962757945,
0.2515354156,
0.0032941382,
-0.9613565207,
0.4471969903,
-0.2121657133,
-0.596303463,
-0.8415964842,
-0.4759460688,
-0.5343763232,
-0.3534816206,
-0.0256427787,
-0.7994786501,
0.5859360099,
0.1756329685,
-0.5551160574,
0.4875067472,
-0.6968516707,
0.1378416419,
-0.0324896388,
0.0113788657,
0.0426649898,
-0.9536882639,
0.1868874878,
-0.002407151,
-0.1992727667,
-0.117259115,
-0.3595073521,
0.9894946814,
-0.3888453841,
0.746783793,
-0.413623482,
-0.0100864461,
0.6866412759,
-0.0856362134,
0.4779865146,
-0.1932439059,
-0.3380710781,
0.4495423734,
0.0785036311,
-0.0588448234,
-0.5642652512,
0.2037855238,
-0.5042398572,
-0.1709255576,
-0.499709785,
-0.5205773115,
-0.4338172078,
-0.0816877186,
0.620044589,
0.509883225,
0.0927515328,
0.5180889368,
0.8633725047,
-0.0156698283,
0.7828315496,
0.4342764616,
0.694689393,
-0.7389855981,
0.8122863173,
0.4946292937,
0.1559016556,
0.7092224956,
0.1114491895,
-0.4255155921,
-0.5115007162,
-0.0419052355,
-0.2948595881,
-0.2467504442,
-0.3540510535,
-0.3274196088,
-0.6377394199,
-0.6742763519,
0.0562988482,
-0.4057078958,
-0.8167558312,
-0.1691001654,
-0.0853797495,
0.5166472197,
-0.0093117189,
-0.2773220241,
0.4263963699,
-0.5751746893,
0.0909199044,
0.3632360399,
0.4243407249,
-0.0950790867,
-0.9974820614,
-0.307749927,
-0.0605376884,
-0.0329327211,
-0.9559919238,
0.5006203651,
0.4915893674,
0.3155660331,
0.4634447992,
0.2864066064,
0.7686328888,
-0.3066759408,
0.7299836278,
0.4702517688,
-0.9094185233,
0.208276093,
0.3327958584,
0.040022362,
0.4226225913,
0.2930316925,
-0.4618327618,
-0.3129764795,
-0.4188581705,
-0.6771073341,
0.187033087,
0.1584655493,
-0.193268612,
0.0868659168,
0.3298139572,
-0.4339810014,
0.2189927399,
-0.3978378177,
-0.1979992241,
-0.3754146397,
-0.5651838779,
-0.232859537,
-0.3106161356,
0.1092832834,
-0.2259334028,
0.7250929475,
-0.1439464837,
0.6096149087,
0.6092619896,
-0.0479355231,
0.0084057515,
0.5175593495,
0.6481209397,
0.2701022029,
-0.4359619021,
0.1570313722,
0.5454477668,
-0.5670710802,
0.6682237387,
0.0907593444,
-0.1346237361,
0.2692260444,
0.5025109649,
0.6833643317,
-0.0572334491,
-0.3951451778,
0.4834225774,
-0.130749464,
-0.2922103107,
-0.8396956921,
0.1425727308,
-0.1150666401,
0.1993564963,
0.0882838815,
-0.0457880907,
0.2102708519,
-0.1458673775,
0.326292038,
0.512737751,
-0.8342319131,
-0.1735843122,
0.3669702411,
-0.0765034482,
-0.3511174917,
0.5177184343,
-0.1374149919,
0.0157607887,
0.4678083062,
0.3837761879,
1.435552001,
-0.9263287187,
-0.1575904191,
0.43929407,
0.1911696941,
-0.2720618248,
0.4633360505,
-0.1880329549,
-0.8635320663,
-0.4083561599,
-0.5803417563,
-0.3336089551,
-0.1200133264,
-0.5801703334,
-0.0290375967,
-0.4687397778,
-0.6421846747,
-0.0968169421,
0.0289078467,
-0.3047665954,
0.4476152062,
0.2005085796,
1.0728503466,
-0.539747715,
1.0318492651,
0.2885474563,
-0.0833626091,
-0.8993608952,
0.0833800361,
0.1734994799,
-0.8083797693,
0.3511873782,
-0.0263547711,
-0.4786762297,
0.1295041889,
-0.5627963543,
-1.0285694599,
1.3472191095,
0.2214743644,
-0.791723609,
-0.3673388362,
0.0096726101,
0.4244692922,
-0.218822822,
0.3347726464,
0.504181087,
0.5718662143,
0.2425550371,
-0.9969767928,
-0.3310244083,
-0.04193791,
0.0989554077,
-0.1283677369,
-0.3916647136,
0.6174622178,
-0.0928197429,
-0.2255895436,
0.2775482535,
0.7921186686,
0.219781518,
0.5694186687,
0.9177514911,
0.6870447993,
0.9462595582,
0.0512623675,
0.6173943877,
-0.7828019857,
0.1651778668,
1.2021448612,
-0.0379798673,
0.9478904605,
0.3460541964,
-0.2437177449,
0.4164785147,
0.7877275944,
0.1856317669,
0.3946358263,
0.3407775462,
-0.4619434476,
-0.2475376725,
-0.1119967103,
-0.2546420097,
0.4792816043,
0.5072972178,
-0.4338396788,
0.0275154579,
-0.1652001888,
-0.2132528275,
-0.465305537,
-0.3268672526,
0.8618301749,
0.4815078676,
-0.2504185438,
0.873021841,
0.1034751311,
0.9020795822,
-0.6099665761,
0.2984855771,
0.1255755723,
-0.0495374538,
-0.3420204818,
-0.6010733843,
0.2955760658,
0.1355844587,
0.0846290216,
0.1484538913,
0.7989504337,
-0.5748129487,
-0.4729542136,
0.0287529156,
0.2914705873,
0.4258708954,
-0.1006419212,
-0.5049397945,
-0.3968803883,
-0.174118191,
-0.2661960125,
0.0847156644,
0.3677932918,
0.0131387571,
0.6645474434,
0.3039296269,
0.2590176165,
0.4082005918,
-0.0831556916,
0.1938980967,
-0.675116241,
-0.5743587613,
-0.6567997932,
0.2643955648,
0.0853572935,
-0.2138002664,
0.4452734888,
0.2815954983,
0.594289422,
0.187053591,
0.6881764531,
0.0722939447,
0.6716290116,
-0.3838286996,
0.5315159559,
-0.4988254011,
-0.1499355584,
-0.2606787682,
-0.5986200571,
-0.5506105423,
0.6745599508,
-0.0492932238,
0.1480749398,
0.544603765,
0.8804876804,
0.195401147,
0.097357899,
0.6225973368,
0.2450300157,
0.1457771808,
0.646841526,
0.4458208084,
-0.367960006,
0.4053670764,
-0.3951871097,
-0.5860036612,
-0.017062068,
-0.7943561077,
-0.4411177635,
-0.7176606059,
-0.3018040359,
-0.3848435879,
0.1917871833,
1.072348237,
0.8790594935,
-0.98849684,
-0.4248870909,
-0.0504268259,
0.0496948771,
-0.4080275297,
-0.2141922563,
0.4620882869,
-0.4312016964,
-0.5114411116,
0.3925750852,
0.3381994367,
0.359225899,
-0.1230074167,
-0.1762916595,
-0.1426417828,
0.259757489,
0.4048722684,
0.5059311986,
-0.4656375051,
-0.3590689003,
-0.0601969585,
0.1128424853,
0.0403363146,
0.514993012,
-0.5688404441,
0.4557820559,
0.8742814064,
0.482984215,
0.1790822297,
-0.1412994862,
0.5019713044,
-0.6795162559,
0.4357714355,
0.3468360305,
0.3863796294,
0.2569493949,
-0.1137785241,
0.4906336963,
0.3430132568,
-0.4876077771,
-0.7940945625,
0.2377379686,
-0.7515438199,
0.1298403144,
0.7187079191,
-0.3765420616,
-0.4103737175,
-0.1667750776,
0.5799816251,
0.6243517399,
-0.4575437605,
0.6712773442,
0.4778643548,
-0.3269890249,
-0.2132400274,
-0.2296310514,
0.4962205887,
0.0282095633,
-0.4677334428,
-0.1040419787,
0.1097254306,
0.4710248113,
0.411421299,
0.7075680494,
-0.3009777665,
0.1460082233,
-0.1567230225,
0.239906922,
-0.0779414326,
-0.5388137102,
-0.5314114094,
0.1740775406,
-0.0536543615,
-0.3524092734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08700v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08700v2 | Rarely a problem? Language models exhibit inverse scaling in their predictions following few-type quantifiers | 2022-12-16T20:01:22 | 2023-05-26T07:18:15 | James A. Michaelov, Benjamin K. Bergen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | How well do language models deal with quantification? In this study, we focus
on 'few'-type quantifiers, as in 'few children like toys', which might pose a
particular challenge for language models because the sentence components with
out the quantifier are likely to co-occur, and 'few'-type quantifiers are rare.
We present 960 English sentence stimuli from two human neurolinguistic
experiments to 22 autoregressive transformer models of differing sizes. Not
only do all the models perform poorly on 'few'-type quantifiers, but overall
the larger the model, the worse its performance. This inverse scaling is
consistent with previous work suggesting that larger models increasingly
reflect online rather than offline human processing, and we argue that the
decreasing performance of larger models may challenge uses of language models
as the basis for natural language systems. | [
-0.3395219743,
-0.6117352843,
0.2924542129,
0.1278472096,
0.0405013412,
-0.3724437058,
-0.1000348255,
-0.4393180311,
-0.0269479714,
0.3285267055,
-0.7074756622,
0.5180928707,
-0.5781353712,
0.2962563038,
-0.7349478602,
0.8494265079,
0.2735251486,
-0.0730951428,
-0.3369902968,
-0.3020599186,
-0.0011075611,
-0.4667710662,
-0.5956809521,
-0.6600449085,
0.340086937,
0.3177145422,
1.1975975037,
0.527582407,
0.7803438306,
0.2670972645,
-0.1060115471,
-0.3573890328,
-0.4435076714,
0.0006883584,
0.188514486,
-0.6435641646,
-0.3198008835,
-0.0155339735,
0.4357513189,
1.1023497581,
-0.0978346244,
0.2194413543,
0.0935814902,
0.5664737821,
-0.4075108171,
-0.074027054,
-0.4702163935,
-0.040102724,
0.2062710077,
0.4812597632,
-0.3773440719,
-0.2626984119,
0.2112677246,
-0.4875036776,
0.3155540526,
0.2795016766,
1.0860191584,
0.2905857265,
-0.6386201978,
-0.1111427024,
-0.9189360738,
0.7754839659,
-0.8003618717,
0.0263041519,
0.6382101178,
0.0893373042,
0.0214897804,
-0.7060991526,
-0.7454324365,
-0.3563992083,
-0.7465975285,
-0.3514273465,
-0.7837152481,
0.0045201988,
0.4367438853,
0.1865045428,
-0.6633010507,
0.3239192665,
-0.1495050341,
0.0585786253,
0.285128504,
0.4439405501,
0.2401471138,
-0.3253964782,
-0.0290543754,
-0.0968907252,
-0.8180728555,
0.0967008993,
0.3803301454,
0.2207989246,
-0.32959041,
0.5962296724,
0.0291066822,
0.7870487571,
0.2698551416,
-0.1146850735,
0.0852592438,
-0.2800386548,
-0.144224599,
-0.4869782925,
0.7933166027,
0.0950904414,
0.4308412075,
-0.0634713694,
-0.3380432427,
0.1915464699,
0.0196090788,
-0.7493795753,
-0.5770837665,
-0.241023168,
-0.6111118197,
-0.2944197059,
-0.1996836662,
-0.3775337636,
-0.4371522963,
0.0656073838,
0.6949076056,
-0.1057653278,
-0.1692598611,
-0.1479058266,
-0.0673386306,
0.1050403863,
-0.0755420029,
-0.9466581345,
0.7838626504,
0.4143707752,
0.5459048152,
-0.0889708474,
-0.1243794784,
-0.3784451783,
-0.3284020722,
-0.1785518378,
0.7910202146,
-0.6443877816,
-0.2799426019,
-0.3685599267,
0.2331437618,
-0.1078926399,
-0.7274669409,
0.4225818217,
-0.1757459939,
0.3583670259,
-0.0940194204,
-0.3450748622,
0.0972270221,
0.0126831578,
-0.8637132645,
0.5578252673,
0.2197034508,
-0.7259380817,
0.381780684,
-0.3359428346,
-0.5104171634,
-0.0313413292,
-0.1027099118,
-0.5237761736,
0.6164895892,
0.0346441306,
0.1568690538,
-0.4917088449,
0.1882325113,
-0.4133623838,
-0.59041363,
0.4522478878,
-0.8138500452,
0.6932422519,
-0.0611182079,
-0.3740539551,
-0.4062380791,
-0.9092217684,
0.0696720034,
0.4126265347,
0.005869031,
-0.3732406497,
0.0542720594,
0.1596640795,
0.5380257368,
0.0877196491,
-0.5463967919,
0.4124464989,
-0.6505485177,
0.7850704193,
0.3947625756,
-0.1776331216,
0.7034104466,
-0.5207286477,
0.7943387032,
0.1871827692,
0.1282285899,
-0.0527932532,
-0.6875059009,
-0.9640384912,
-0.0856829509,
0.0928651169,
0.2306623012,
-0.4509088099,
0.0456164964,
-0.6488519907,
-0.3051283658,
-0.7040344477,
-0.1053553447,
0.2594574988,
0.309863925,
0.1123847812,
0.1013134345,
-0.4132416248,
-1.4615107775,
-0.5332175493,
-0.3518954515,
-0.4155540168,
0.3371834755,
0.4646879137,
-0.0787085369,
1.3272100687,
-0.5721270442,
-0.2782273293,
-0.1346135139,
0.4177876413,
0.3079965413,
0.2416901439,
0.4743731618,
-0.9013620615,
-0.3584391475,
-0.3259423673,
-0.2811662257,
0.0526456088,
-0.0367724374,
0.6846051216,
0.1738596857,
0.1736392677,
-0.5388456583,
0.3757171929,
0.7509307265,
-0.3950766027,
0.0038143292,
-0.2519498169,
-0.3571490645,
-0.6618948579,
0.1076102182,
0.0229271092,
-0.2957350016,
-0.581114769,
-0.073974371,
0.0658502504,
-0.0618312843,
-0.4419728518,
0.4952524304,
-0.2385009527,
-0.1140570417,
-0.2497887611,
0.1703182161,
0.2450546026,
0.2285287976,
0.0304638278,
0.6554024816,
0.2977995276,
-0.516200006,
0.0158585813,
-0.0196865406,
-0.0471707955,
0.369784832,
-0.9142517447,
0.192657724,
-0.3532453775,
0.0472969487,
-1.1085585356,
-0.1982483864,
-0.2283051014,
-0.1752564311,
0.0886463299,
-0.1521691233,
-0.6777453423,
-0.5829798579,
-0.2383573353,
0.4330633879,
0.7461159825,
-0.2694801688,
0.5501452684,
0.1694595963,
0.0825536028,
-0.2271685302,
-1.0952018499,
-0.1135666594,
-0.3506698012,
-0.5434663892,
0.0343906283,
-0.1759060472,
-0.502654016,
0.1547838002,
-0.2227984071,
-0.4300979972,
0.2730197012,
0.3778021336,
-0.0527418926,
-0.555611074,
0.4112941027,
-0.0537280291,
-0.0125350133,
0.1786431968,
0.0207530186,
0.313744694,
-0.368162632,
-0.1341046542,
-0.1031532139,
0.1112677231,
0.3904888332,
0.3628776968,
0.7939588428,
0.2649850249,
-0.4761898518,
0.0363907665,
-0.3061466515,
-0.4544855654,
-0.5237407088,
0.3124774694,
-0.5703645945,
-0.7648944855,
0.458144933,
0.232829988,
-0.2594631612,
0.6626435518,
0.2191855758,
-0.2899784744,
1.0726579428,
0.7069183588,
0.0850311592,
0.0397909321,
-0.1082814336,
0.5121751428,
-0.5712512732,
0.2521535158,
-0.6378568411,
-0.3660934865,
-1.0432716608,
0.1843846589,
0.4101734757,
0.0830192193,
-0.2624979019,
0.7055493593,
-0.4235769212,
0.5518864989,
0.4497131705,
-0.1278424859,
0.5624920726,
-0.1749611795,
0.1883903742,
-0.2294586152,
-0.9860649705,
-0.6038188934,
0.845400095,
0.2038002759,
0.8159546256,
0.2317884713,
0.4812562764,
0.0417930782,
0.3547027111,
-0.7428920865,
0.2710912526,
-0.4819343388,
-0.9945500493,
-0.4320262671,
-0.4677715898,
-1.1164848804,
0.3908671439,
-0.1888776571,
-0.804489851,
0.3269091845,
0.1510464549,
-0.7140976787,
0.1968320608,
-0.8620769978,
0.8111533523,
0.1204220653,
0.020263806,
0.0184667036,
-0.6682039499,
0.443431288,
-0.2771131396,
0.6490035057,
0.0241167657,
-0.1503823102,
0.5570065379,
-0.2458218485,
0.944357276,
0.1988048404,
-0.1455708146,
0.3236176968,
0.4826894104,
0.6984437108,
-0.0415740013,
0.2113522291,
-0.2686047852,
0.0958485082,
-0.5511247516,
-0.7176978588,
0.7764255404,
-0.9056515694,
-0.5125281215,
-0.2174969614,
-0.2644948065,
-0.1735582501,
0.0700189248,
0.580780983,
0.366620034,
-0.1249122098,
0.2186667621,
0.3104832172,
-0.0738802627,
1.0321115255,
0.482162267,
-0.0776903853,
0.0182757266,
0.8512129784,
0.4134970307,
0.5560619831,
0.3935126662,
0.4505821168,
0.1578884721,
-0.1142378896,
-0.0283241365,
0.3289998174,
-0.5929211974,
-0.1070615351,
-0.7110953927,
0.0121298824,
-0.3138400018,
0.1105982065,
-0.3114866316,
-0.9339468479,
-0.4080634117,
0.0827314034,
0.2067206651,
1.127568841,
0.0507445745,
0.5794256926,
-0.7376102805,
0.665325582,
0.6683899164,
0.2898795903,
0.1007150412,
-1.0538561344,
-0.0968600884,
0.0860417932,
-0.1229904816,
-0.506101191,
0.5415084362,
0.4617901444,
-0.0119714458,
0.4528983533,
0.1846834272,
0.6045004129,
-0.51809901,
0.9017245173,
0.0123445457,
-0.8966025114,
0.0999178812,
-0.1848137677,
0.5875820518,
0.296702981,
0.4129473269,
-0.3702886701,
-0.3321959078,
-1.0520671606,
-0.6609505415,
0.7091161609,
0.4353731275,
0.580239892,
-0.1785984188,
0.1972117126,
0.2684525847,
0.2580218613,
-1.1683176756,
-0.58333534,
-0.2249154747,
0.0071400693,
-0.3519814909,
-0.2971086502,
0.4183171391,
-0.1252333671,
0.2453044355,
-0.0225974936,
0.2277156115,
-0.1502613872,
-0.1770471036,
-0.6420624256,
0.4021129012,
0.7136715055,
0.3132301867,
-0.206577599,
0.2247403711,
0.0565616563,
-0.3159896731,
0.4207693338,
-0.2006516308,
-0.2682174444,
0.0099358577,
0.6356211305,
0.8067121506,
0.391264081,
-0.5030978322,
0.6859693527,
-0.1161110699,
0.2112532258,
-0.5930658579,
-0.1059363633,
0.2491453439,
0.0143433083,
0.4595608711,
0.2577134669,
0.1519839764,
-0.4863835573,
0.1627568603,
0.3252130151,
-0.3986202478,
-0.7665355802,
0.618878901,
0.0204357039,
-0.5570488572,
0.8552059531,
-0.3457541466,
-0.2526500225,
0.8269295096,
0.545329392,
0.8837696314,
0.1420334131,
0.1616051942,
0.2704916298,
0.626932621,
-0.2205448002,
-0.2251210809,
0.2801695168,
-0.7148160934,
-0.3487437665,
-0.303661257,
-0.1500362158,
0.2727115154,
-0.6174256206,
0.3221412897,
-0.0262239445,
-0.4230935574,
0.0588162243,
-0.3501556218,
-0.7868246436,
0.0999967977,
0.0932517201,
0.1866603643,
-1.2728780508,
0.7926291823,
0.6703510284,
-0.4759013057,
-0.570535183,
0.1089070663,
-0.211707145,
-0.4387210011,
1.0519123077,
-0.1698550135,
-0.02417689,
0.174853012,
-0.5724917054,
-1.237326622,
0.5069551468,
0.5018640161,
-0.585168004,
-0.5478980541,
0.3140635788,
0.8790713549,
-0.1865065694,
0.6232742667,
0.4644608796,
0.4213598967,
-0.234275043,
-1.2613850832,
-0.0350566246,
0.0978879258,
-0.0005756767,
0.2711673677,
-0.6804207563,
1.1324535608,
-0.1316549629,
-0.2341304868,
0.15808779,
0.2910601199,
-0.150742352,
0.0432765149,
0.441755563,
0.4277479351,
0.1068415046,
0.147088632,
1.2657642365,
-0.0018499314,
0.6656790972,
1.278804183,
-0.0761067867,
0.8649065495,
0.6027251482,
-0.5526291728,
0.3140764832,
0.2151334286,
0.1600515991,
0.3297422826,
0.376539439,
0.2304570079,
-0.361677438,
0.1100435182,
0.1483891457,
0.3679123223,
0.1692952216,
-0.1773749292,
-0.267201215,
0.389911294,
-0.0994040444,
0.129415527,
-0.0957188457,
0.6976792216,
0.3243896365,
-0.2934688926,
0.8792269826,
-0.0719800219,
0.7783609033,
-0.133343026,
0.0683361664,
-0.604293406,
0.0271638613,
-0.143952176,
-0.333488673,
0.3424046338,
-0.1733846962,
-0.2212239653,
-0.0775086507,
0.3893480897,
-0.2156183571,
-0.4748196006,
0.0683846623,
0.5032932162,
0.0763830468,
-0.0294339396,
-0.3353648484,
-0.3459509015,
-0.1067413762,
-0.5151067376,
0.4858302176,
0.5545430779,
-0.0358206779,
1.0870529413,
-0.1234646216,
0.043655619,
0.2935374975,
-0.1587122083,
0.5757367015,
-0.7079470158,
-0.0811112747,
-0.8151183128,
0.4487282038,
0.2986418903,
-0.3474113643,
0.6185886264,
0.3846289515,
0.6649983525,
-0.2928883135,
0.3932520449,
-0.0032868525,
0.435551852,
-0.0205332693,
0.5825443864,
-0.4622674584,
0.1956626028,
-0.2021367699,
-0.937769413,
-0.2858742774,
0.6663384438,
-0.211348787,
0.0260567348,
0.8457942605,
0.5145173073,
-0.2093073577,
-0.1669609696,
0.7395402193,
0.4599201381,
0.0657709762,
0.4929751158,
0.8945046067,
-0.7056714296,
0.634529531,
-0.6027944088,
0.3240244091,
-0.18342866,
-0.71985811,
-0.8693528175,
-0.6578765512,
-0.5028370023,
-0.1395733953,
-0.3028361797,
0.9359548688,
0.6067419648,
-0.8181496859,
-0.1285438687,
-0.3564560413,
-0.0094419494,
-0.015043187,
-0.2892454863,
0.1821469069,
-0.1074122116,
-0.6805608273,
0.1134674773,
-0.1581617445,
0.3747416437,
-0.3489655554,
0.3708474636,
0.0882410929,
0.183947593,
0.4718559086,
0.132568419,
-0.9135046005,
-0.4006237984,
0.1378765702,
-0.335075587,
0.1854222119,
0.7194433212,
-1.2876209021,
-0.0097651873,
0.3956399262,
0.1290732622,
0.4493484497,
-0.0294551365,
0.3432516456,
-0.8246792555,
0.3139790595,
0.5427371264,
0.1540264189,
0.1779770404,
-0.1733041406,
0.3080416024,
0.1513044238,
-0.3128288686,
-0.9420176148,
0.3727732897,
-0.4093419313,
-0.2955891788,
1.055147171,
-0.1210975572,
-0.2368871123,
0.0694605634,
0.1841445863,
-0.2114803046,
-0.2201333344,
0.5960484743,
0.8340777755,
-0.231249243,
-0.4409071803,
-0.2673920691,
0.3640719354,
0.5698217154,
-0.3298591673,
0.0053070863,
0.3040077984,
0.213374868,
0.2666961253,
0.1843845248,
0.199552983,
-0.0464740694,
0.2072947025,
-0.1986489296,
0.3901927769,
-0.0291862898,
-1.040553689,
0.4010722935,
0.5527254939,
0.1474865824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08686v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08686v2 | Evaluating Step-by-Step Reasoning through Symbolic Verification | 2022-12-16T19:30:01 | 2024-03-28T08:20:12 | Yi-Fan Zhang, Hanlin Zhang, Li Erran Li, Eric Xing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models (LMs) have shown remarkable reasoning performance
using explanations or chain-of-thoughts (CoT)) for in-context learning. On the
other hand, these reasoning tasks are usually presumed to be more approachable
for symbolic programming. To understand the mechanism of reasoning of LMs, we
curate synthetic datasets containing equivalent (natural, symbolic) data pairs,
where symbolic examples contain first-order logic rules and predicates from
non-parametric knowledge bases (KBs), supporting automated verification of
intermediate reasoning results. Then we revisit neuro-symbolic approaches and
propose to learn from demonstrations containing logic rules and corresponding
examples to iteratively reason over KBs, recovering Prolog's backward chaining
algorithm and supporting automated verification of LMs' outputs. Comprehensive
experiments are included to systematically compare LMLP with CoT in deductive
reasoning settings, showing that LMLP enjoys more than $25\%$ higher accuracy
than CoT on length generalization benchmarks even with smaller model sizes. | [
-0.1765359193,
-0.9091963172,
0.928394556,
0.0695354491,
-0.2118480504,
0.1208905205,
-0.2558613718,
-0.2737145722,
-0.2518363297,
0.4927036166,
-0.8137832284,
-0.6688360572,
-0.5246923566,
0.2969404161,
-0.6165938377,
0.6995841265,
-0.3083674908,
0.1345186383,
-0.3280755281,
0.0453835912,
-0.500787735,
-0.5271469951,
-0.6717215776,
-0.5240082741,
0.2441480011,
0.0432396494,
0.6945232153,
0.4020273983,
0.1477776915,
0.3137921393,
0.2314660251,
0.3375815153,
-0.2560904026,
-0.0132489214,
-0.3232138455,
-0.5806689858,
-0.2018284351,
0.0800849497,
0.4509429038,
0.6333945394,
0.1061454862,
0.2428189963,
-0.0865503028,
0.6669408083,
-0.5313661098,
0.2953980267,
-0.5441742539,
-0.0079831816,
0.3486912251,
-0.3626633584,
-0.8119280338,
-0.6507276893,
-0.0702966228,
-0.5288244486,
-0.123798646,
0.0570957288,
0.6474344134,
0.3014975786,
-0.4462477863,
-0.4043484628,
-0.867349565,
0.8463029861,
-0.6432782412,
0.6878106594,
0.6215039492,
0.5089936852,
-0.4704441726,
-0.907361865,
-0.5752568245,
-0.6824845672,
-0.4310579598,
-0.3562808633,
-0.1517495215,
0.0506383106,
0.6248037815,
0.0798928961,
-0.6544240117,
-0.2409851253,
-0.2484413981,
-0.0036822078,
0.6027172208,
0.0764397383,
0.3411387503,
0.1580406278,
-0.2256009579,
-0.2453248352,
-0.9901714325,
-0.0120162815,
0.0935968757,
0.2066951543,
0.0802368745,
0.3763673604,
-0.277387619,
1.0692960024,
0.0589251556,
0.1301305741,
0.0258706082,
-0.4649087787,
-0.3115949333,
0.0923046991,
0.6535339355,
0.1946459264,
0.6497152448,
-0.2302550226,
-0.3302723765,
0.1928666085,
0.3348884284,
-0.5329968929,
-0.266797781,
0.4368755519,
-0.3720785379,
0.0194446854,
-0.2040979862,
-0.1822686046,
-0.2543458045,
-0.8028674722,
0.849234581,
-0.5860969424,
-0.1210877523,
0.2987606823,
0.0766275525,
0.191216588,
0.3812132478,
-0.4779353738,
0.5646001101,
0.9526500702,
0.5671738982,
0.153993696,
-0.4130944014,
-0.4262310863,
-0.1943479925,
-0.6983844042,
0.5993290544,
-0.525799036,
0.0151248137,
-0.2257868052,
-0.0272413306,
-0.1209459603,
-0.5070145726,
0.1814225465,
-0.5593005419,
0.0510829054,
-0.4523562491,
-0.5288446546,
-0.3198955357,
0.486376524,
-0.4818273485,
0.8791384697,
0.0458676219,
-0.5840969682,
0.3781607151,
-0.5245881677,
-0.4214667976,
-0.3794512451,
-0.372309804,
0.0977960899,
0.1457784772,
0.2164415866,
0.3107121587,
-0.4139244556,
0.4332289994,
-0.2908467352,
-0.4940191209,
0.2172155231,
-0.2459376305,
1.004776597,
0.0278007425,
-0.5599294305,
0.3637788594,
-0.7964795232,
0.1822070628,
0.294447571,
0.1300015152,
-0.4492047727,
0.2147705704,
-0.6889013052,
0.6468396783,
0.0021707753,
-0.269788295,
0.1544850916,
-0.4351394176,
0.3557831347,
0.7791150212,
-0.0932069346,
0.3339393437,
-0.0243236441,
0.2259294391,
0.1110584065,
0.4568782747,
0.0047052479,
-0.1915747225,
-0.8319192529,
0.1931285709,
0.3002934456,
0.3857755363,
-0.9238561988,
0.4441134036,
0.0374704823,
-0.4743544757,
-0.159790352,
-0.0141561283,
0.5041304231,
0.6983574629,
0.5701414943,
-0.1943304241,
-0.5845267773,
-0.7426858544,
-0.4424266815,
-0.504108429,
-0.1096685603,
0.0579088703,
0.7079190612,
-0.041675359,
0.7664465308,
-0.2128419876,
0.2731483877,
-0.3321486115,
0.1475708783,
0.48102808,
0.437910676,
0.1624664664,
-0.2894768715,
-0.1688223332,
-0.1872942448,
-1.0419594049,
-0.0940648094,
-0.3556403816,
-0.364806056,
0.2336685061,
0.5642756224,
-0.6935187578,
0.4867180884,
0.0472908206,
-0.4565579593,
0.8069270849,
-0.285381645,
0.1547456235,
-0.4403891563,
-0.1427739859,
-0.0895908251,
-0.2651303113,
-0.6170694232,
0.1628010273,
-0.0690467432,
0.2200651914,
-0.3253539205,
0.3850261271,
-0.5223428011,
-0.2646186352,
-0.2452824414,
0.1776126623,
-0.1156263724,
0.566700995,
0.2850129306,
0.3828471005,
0.7028496265,
-0.7376486659,
0.2858038545,
-0.0865743235,
-0.2732816041,
0.3301685452,
-0.6555261612,
0.3479464352,
-0.2102656811,
0.6401625276,
-0.8157707453,
0.3108062744,
0.2958386838,
-0.2335595042,
-0.0172286723,
-0.0019305011,
-0.7582572103,
-0.3222423494,
-0.1925572008,
0.3081567585,
0.6476558447,
-0.7177702188,
0.7385235429,
-0.045085106,
0.3311849535,
-0.5965507627,
-0.147883907,
-0.0140668824,
-0.0280295145,
-0.2112487853,
0.0239832867,
0.1346165836,
-0.5568447113,
-0.2529039383,
-0.444535315,
0.0766152963,
0.189042002,
0.166313827,
0.1414853483,
-0.2456855774,
0.2538149357,
0.099578701,
-0.2139677703,
0.6454498172,
-0.5528337955,
0.6714835167,
-0.3606944382,
-0.6742730737,
-0.336340934,
0.0739832073,
0.2759080231,
-0.0352821276,
0.5540128946,
0.3062229156,
-0.6823602319,
-0.409047395,
-0.2601011097,
-0.6764107347,
-0.397584945,
0.140371114,
-0.5161675811,
-0.3024492562,
0.0620925687,
-0.2377834469,
0.2734476626,
0.3865607083,
0.4371014833,
-0.0419284627,
1.1158676147,
0.270537287,
0.2742745876,
-0.1075153798,
-0.3531002104,
0.3855798542,
-0.1996069551,
-0.4348118901,
-0.4726873636,
-0.4325110018,
-0.420942843,
-0.4738268256,
0.0516781919,
0.3716089725,
-0.5740671158,
0.6815787554,
-0.317160964,
0.7035028934,
0.5790757537,
0.3583211899,
0.3926768005,
-0.3003671169,
-0.2358262092,
0.2880335152,
-0.5479436517,
-0.6731457114,
0.889829874,
0.1814546436,
0.7453472018,
-0.2040830553,
0.8303349614,
0.1842559874,
0.3548516929,
-0.5781285763,
1.0432980061,
-0.0413499624,
-0.3216295242,
-0.1449920535,
-0.2483278215,
-0.5444663167,
0.0308231115,
-0.1088955402,
-0.7837105989,
-0.0593761094,
0.4359762669,
-0.1522106379,
0.1522964835,
-0.6077001095,
0.8946175575,
-0.5489638448,
-0.3241350651,
-0.5620627403,
-0.85364151,
0.4609941244,
0.0830951855,
0.0250614118,
0.0670997128,
0.2696405947,
0.4998212159,
-0.7016616464,
0.8023664951,
-0.2777764201,
-0.2631027997,
0.3454238474,
0.562585175,
0.554343462,
-0.0635599643,
0.1794082373,
0.1919832826,
0.1627088487,
-0.108084701,
-1.0810139179,
0.5566566586,
-0.4605214596,
-0.7665903568,
-0.2518254519,
-0.4234877229,
-0.4077221155,
-0.060046684,
-0.11560224,
0.2754826844,
0.1575737894,
-0.1411060244,
0.5249947309,
-0.2470404506,
0.1581012905,
0.2130240649,
-0.5300431848,
-0.0035547325,
0.7207489014,
-0.1708788276,
0.303263247,
0.6015019417,
0.2648477554,
-0.6709293723,
-0.2623521388,
-0.4403377175,
0.1497467309,
-1.1057549715,
0.1411301345,
-0.5752645731,
-0.1788901389,
-0.0269052684,
0.0228685234,
-0.3105091155,
-0.6382058263,
0.0891246945,
-0.1162940487,
0.2111522555,
0.7938412428,
0.1294704676,
-0.0664763898,
-0.578268528,
0.4443658888,
0.2512901127,
0.1509378701,
0.1664803326,
-0.2904068828,
0.0476533361,
0.0933050886,
-0.2932156622,
-1.0674505234,
0.0564717762,
-0.1563952863,
0.4859741926,
0.2198563963,
-0.0252043828,
0.7648765445,
-0.5998782516,
0.6754105091,
0.0005584054,
-1.1514209509,
0.8512066603,
0.1436507553,
0.0413101949,
0.3550824523,
0.6957420707,
-0.1649110168,
-0.3222160637,
-0.7007427216,
-0.5944916606,
0.4601954222,
0.1977830827,
-0.2622081935,
-0.1712891608,
0.3654729128,
0.1566735506,
0.0654198751,
-0.6575098634,
-0.07510712,
-0.097205691,
-0.2718761265,
-0.0972520784,
0.181904614,
-0.1300907582,
-0.4121037126,
0.6486156583,
-0.217356801,
0.2036455572,
0.1345293373,
-0.4369153976,
0.2341587245,
0.1120957732,
0.6831609607,
1.0624959469,
-0.1029912531,
0.5674165487,
0.2809952199,
0.0552712493,
0.3116615117,
-0.1711364388,
0.0147691974,
0.2125352472,
0.4614713788,
0.7862334847,
0.0993924588,
-0.7636239529,
0.2525587678,
-0.0719918385,
-0.1233409345,
-0.1873400956,
0.1089437678,
0.0934965611,
0.3677972555,
-0.0102537861,
-0.1887809932,
0.1570308805,
-0.5437489152,
0.2755551338,
0.4219707549,
-0.1537429392,
-0.5120846629,
0.56597054,
-0.2241930515,
-0.3857515156,
0.681928277,
0.0130894436,
-0.4166177213,
0.6858550906,
0.692530334,
0.9266099334,
0.0668637604,
0.2132960558,
0.497341305,
0.435916394,
-0.3521715403,
0.4945761263,
-0.5936601758,
-0.5019344091,
-0.6410954595,
-0.5089575052,
-0.4668453932,
0.0688487142,
-0.3453846276,
0.3379964828,
-0.6831470728,
-0.0455618985,
-0.215390265,
-0.369912684,
-0.549641788,
0.4023393393,
0.0923309997,
1.1300235987,
-1.0408681631,
0.7861381769,
0.4688192606,
-0.4319559038,
-0.876788795,
0.0483438224,
-0.2605028152,
-0.8672388196,
1.1584179401,
0.3373672366,
-0.2540347278,
-0.1688145697,
-0.5678849816,
-0.4670103192,
0.8296874762,
0.4955812395,
-0.5709118247,
-0.1428589225,
0.1989780664,
0.6574627757,
-0.2386353761,
0.4674859345,
0.7399441004,
0.4355145693,
-0.0370739475,
-0.8044131398,
0.4558193982,
-0.0629225001,
-0.214070037,
0.2729171216,
-0.0557614081,
0.6932457089,
-0.3407479525,
-0.0196139608,
-0.2487416714,
0.5480511189,
0.7943530679,
0.379385978,
0.6586477757,
0.5193137527,
0.472119391,
-0.1905252934,
1.0451390743,
-0.319958657,
0.0740608647,
1.1640520096,
-0.3581240773,
0.7873679996,
0.7345414162,
-0.3868052363,
0.9456626773,
0.6842371225,
0.4214796722,
0.3694782555,
0.6978307366,
-0.0555360056,
-0.5347297788,
0.1308667064,
-0.1962149441,
0.3006410301,
0.2199864388,
-0.5980197787,
-0.3864796758,
-0.3561233878,
-0.1682501435,
0.1715989113,
-0.432865411,
0.6228052378,
0.2278886735,
-0.9485073686,
0.9740666151,
-0.1014310792,
0.1043155864,
-0.5433470607,
-0.3670449853,
-0.018672226,
0.2835678458,
-0.1208941638,
-0.6989772916,
0.4915143251,
-0.0170735493,
0.1713562757,
-0.4593982995,
0.8531990647,
-0.1496516615,
-0.3176826239,
0.2624195814,
0.6095728874,
0.353161782,
-0.0671248212,
-0.7239566445,
-0.1942957193,
-0.2800295651,
-0.2248203754,
0.2357463241,
0.222183466,
-0.5380143523,
0.7627127767,
0.5652635098,
-0.09491992,
0.0048531373,
0.3030372858,
0.6772947907,
-0.7032310367,
-0.321669966,
-1.2984206676,
0.3285360336,
0.0416308045,
0.1151009649,
0.5510826111,
0.2636775672,
1.1285140514,
-0.3599639833,
0.3874504566,
0.069173947,
-0.0387732349,
-0.8396847844,
0.4481379688,
-0.4392050803,
0.1965228468,
-0.1545181572,
-0.654812634,
-0.2752767503,
0.9018661976,
-0.3708931208,
0.1432465315,
1.0261358023,
0.8119968176,
0.0656082407,
0.3207840323,
0.2071047723,
0.2608808279,
0.0830050558,
0.9627292156,
1.1246792078,
-0.4196932614,
0.166818887,
-0.3722072244,
-0.1658435017,
0.4168206155,
-1.1759160757,
-0.9762625098,
-0.5425202847,
-0.33725214,
-0.6089046597,
0.2359304577,
1.1598670483,
0.5369013548,
-0.7926381826,
-0.4040094316,
-0.614176333,
0.2905857861,
-0.6096376181,
-0.1737739593,
0.311285466,
-0.393071115,
-0.3479295373,
0.4358656406,
0.3218315542,
-0.201708585,
-0.3613308966,
-0.2527027428,
-0.2542869747,
0.2022664398,
0.7754585743,
0.2023973763,
-0.8699842095,
-0.1999731511,
0.0488955379,
0.1461495757,
-0.1436508596,
1.0258703232,
-1.2142124176,
0.0863030031,
0.763872683,
0.5620536804,
0.167970404,
-0.1326080412,
0.578009367,
-0.6005756259,
-0.1005457118,
0.1226254702,
0.4635777473,
-0.0130661335,
-0.1149925143,
0.5489883423,
0.1825989634,
-0.3296284378,
-1.0650244951,
0.4245934486,
-0.7122249007,
-0.3642658293,
1.0393203497,
-0.2260920703,
-0.2233802676,
-0.0202502906,
-0.0734718442,
0.3665564358,
0.2329257876,
0.8321778774,
0.5528317094,
-0.4172277749,
-0.1279813051,
-0.3400867581,
0.5418704748,
0.3788578212,
-1.0730905533,
0.2399285436,
0.4844698608,
0.2330456525,
0.1837479025,
0.6947277188,
-0.2407601178,
0.3444488943,
-0.1003046706,
-0.252050519,
-0.0415425636,
-0.6482312679,
-0.1778824031,
0.0201775786,
0.0977919772,
-0.0887694806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08635v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08635v3 | Self-Prompting Large Language Models for Zero-Shot Open-Domain QA | 2022-12-16T18:23:43 | 2024-03-28T06:06:59 | Junlong Li, Jinyuan Wang, Zhuosheng Zhang, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Open-Domain Question Answering (ODQA) aims to answer questions without
explicitly providing specific background documents. This task becomes notably
challenging in a zero-shot setting where no data is available to train tailored
retrieval-reader models. While recent Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-3
have demonstrated their effectiveness in zero-shot ODQA using direct prompting
methods, these methods still fall short of fully harnessing the potential of
LLMs when implicitly invoked. In this paper, we propose a Self-Prompting
framework to explicitly utilize the massive knowledge encoded in the parameters
of LLMs and their strong instruction understanding abilities. Concretely, we
prompt LLMs step by step to generate multiple pseudo QA pairs with background
passages and explanations entirely from scratch. These generated elements are
then utilized for in-context learning. Experimental results show that our
method significantly surpasses previous state-of-the-art zero-shot methods on
three widely-used ODQA datasets and even achieves comparable performance with
various customized fine-tuned models on full training data. Our code is
available at https://github.com/lockon-n/self-prompting. | [
-0.3069679439,
-0.9633329511,
1.0538055897,
-0.1414684057,
-0.1264913827,
-0.2320540249,
-0.0912762135,
-0.0262711588,
-0.0939054489,
0.3792181611,
-0.7585780621,
-0.5601798296,
-0.0461382195,
0.2596375048,
-0.1323676407,
0.8608856201,
-0.3204622567,
-0.0793003887,
0.0040074466,
-0.0300158784,
-0.6885672212,
-0.3099583387,
-0.4514414668,
-0.1255358905,
0.7015901208,
0.6752131581,
0.2480531335,
0.4429888129,
-0.3464781642,
0.1264302731,
0.1989548057,
0.0401813686,
-0.4161855876,
0.4124135375,
-0.2513236701,
-0.2608619034,
-0.3019325137,
-0.0191240683,
0.7173597813,
0.414506495,
-0.0528764687,
0.3722259402,
-0.0661226213,
0.3443977237,
-0.7895108461,
0.0555195287,
-0.6625119448,
0.0443191379,
0.1364800632,
-0.1773143411,
-0.3857812285,
-0.1415661573,
0.0276509169,
-0.6180106997,
0.2261853963,
-0.3041902184,
0.552246213,
0.217954725,
-0.3732833266,
-0.2911046147,
-0.5157706738,
0.5967761278,
-0.5758707523,
0.2320270389,
0.4174449742,
0.349804163,
-0.0333473571,
-0.4230720997,
-0.8669558764,
-0.2625528574,
0.2541739643,
0.3372895718,
0.0075556803,
-0.0951612741,
0.2872169018,
0.2920240164,
-0.8035937548,
0.097548008,
-0.3455706239,
0.1686133742,
0.159515366,
0.1245136634,
0.1368966699,
-0.07496012,
-0.3623983264,
-0.0268732626,
-1.0101569891,
-0.0444048829,
0.1978139579,
0.326458931,
0.0119655346,
0.5875332952,
-0.5490707159,
0.9648261666,
0.336357832,
0.2041482925,
-0.0581564084,
-0.2655354738,
-0.3729559779,
-0.110730812,
0.6873881817,
-0.1294044554,
0.2080956697,
-0.0699349493,
-0.1489291191,
-0.3929498196,
0.1937028617,
-0.9539638758,
-0.1775000095,
0.5486831665,
-0.0511243455,
-0.0360851884,
-0.1558268368,
-0.6476333737,
-0.181725353,
-0.246548444,
0.9602640867,
-0.3718833327,
-0.1483145058,
0.3163030744,
0.1531699002,
0.5404511094,
0.4059333801,
-0.7585669756,
-0.1760369837,
0.316265583,
0.7540816665,
0.1284163892,
-0.3709167242,
-0.8579007983,
0.2595611811,
-0.4450752139,
0.5657265782,
-0.2729316354,
-0.3065640628,
0.1133487672,
-0.215272218,
-0.1103595942,
-0.2784063816,
0.2137314677,
-0.8396351337,
0.5043655634,
-0.4063878953,
-0.4072881937,
-0.1420618296,
0.5216348171,
-0.1739877015,
0.9126819968,
0.2063305676,
-0.375300765,
0.2404728234,
-0.7988967896,
-0.1639190167,
0.2427341193,
-0.3721644878,
-0.137068674,
0.109699592,
0.6795386076,
0.7290614843,
-0.1037593782,
0.192383498,
-0.2755397558,
-0.3038702905,
-0.0915071368,
-0.4566364884,
0.6442264915,
0.1007255837,
-0.3647878468,
0.1519110501,
-0.5476235151,
0.2306283265,
0.5129444003,
-0.0549252853,
-0.2396806628,
-0.4695883393,
-0.6409749985,
0.3484169841,
0.2083547413,
-0.6523692608,
0.4369720817,
-0.3237298131,
0.382197082,
0.7083034515,
0.2950861752,
0.3670670092,
-0.1499195397,
0.7540521622,
-0.0690392405,
0.0655305162,
-0.7838067412,
-0.3562017977,
-0.3709747791,
-0.4272894859,
0.1267582625,
0.3696545959,
-1.2144150734,
0.1776540279,
0.0492008738,
-0.2224363089,
-0.4076617658,
0.1327114254,
0.4836932123,
0.7508172989,
0.5720475912,
-0.0105985664,
0.0115679409,
-0.4193187654,
0.0129031083,
-0.2049901336,
-0.2699100375,
0.4126946926,
0.4514286518,
0.1335851401,
1.1111121178,
-0.6934409738,
-0.3649954796,
-0.1182582378,
0.1514678895,
0.2559124529,
0.3245605826,
0.5493457317,
-0.419981271,
-0.5998229384,
-0.370792836,
-0.925118804,
-0.0948857665,
-0.0050503938,
-0.2172457874,
0.0537233241,
0.5680418015,
-0.5873638391,
0.2337889969,
0.4404155612,
-0.2279338241,
0.712436676,
-0.2924953401,
0.1211869344,
-1.0132189989,
0.0797638819,
-0.146645546,
-0.0163092501,
-0.6732445955,
0.349821806,
0.3137968183,
-0.363620162,
-0.6517022252,
1.0229575634,
-0.6172171831,
0.1572351009,
-0.2440854013,
0.2321007103,
0.1338196248,
0.5933725834,
0.3210065961,
1.0156334639,
0.6748270392,
-0.7061129212,
0.1151366904,
0.4563516676,
-0.1081935465,
0.6682586074,
-0.8510763645,
0.3771795928,
-0.3860619068,
0.4631313086,
-0.9673886299,
-0.3447414041,
0.3923710585,
-0.3658500612,
0.2194393575,
-0.4845152497,
-0.4726037085,
-0.536657095,
-0.2619954944,
0.6309600472,
0.5405516028,
-0.9467055798,
0.4057877958,
-0.1908339709,
-0.1812205017,
-0.5878357887,
-0.2793429494,
-0.1371928155,
-0.0194590762,
-0.4141729474,
0.0477271602,
-0.3561163545,
0.2468497604,
-0.1556483656,
-0.1314711869,
-0.2294332832,
-0.0194390193,
0.1280822456,
0.3230564296,
-0.4775363207,
0.2433260083,
0.0468756706,
0.0899016336,
0.0447821133,
-0.7919054031,
0.4261730611,
0.0390869305,
-0.470149368,
-0.4535160661,
0.3307448626,
0.2924551368,
-0.4405164123,
0.7717846632,
0.485737592,
-0.1672998667,
-0.4863152504,
-0.4305715561,
-0.5376814604,
-0.4743256569,
-0.007357697,
-0.593091011,
-1.1392844915,
0.2885168791,
0.2181241363,
0.0649862066,
0.1721174717,
0.7704224586,
-0.0510332733,
0.9076586962,
0.278380543,
0.0466840118,
0.369858712,
-0.2312220186,
0.10101372,
-0.6844065189,
0.025224749,
-0.5040006042,
0.2598342896,
0.0654109046,
-0.5862319469,
0.5562109947,
0.1316523552,
-0.3836506903,
0.0908244699,
-0.4027511775,
0.7792627811,
0.5436986089,
0.047730241,
0.2118952572,
-0.0419939682,
-0.3454253078,
0.4348868728,
-0.7736225724,
-0.2250222415,
1.1028658152,
0.2114932537,
0.7103517056,
0.0780878738,
0.9065468311,
0.0411812738,
0.1746407896,
-0.8167530298,
0.4056033492,
0.3498310447,
-0.7054368258,
-0.6632799506,
-0.5787855387,
-0.9813042283,
0.2071608901,
0.1407091916,
-0.6115268469,
0.120580852,
0.2575710416,
-0.9282538295,
0.1484026611,
-0.5712022781,
0.9280474782,
0.0005772561,
-0.3433138728,
0.1736598611,
-0.3031843305,
0.5326523781,
-0.1732595414,
-0.1166241914,
-0.1403266191,
-0.0295787323,
0.2999971807,
-0.2710530758,
0.8790564537,
-0.4740208387,
-0.5419934988,
0.5441076159,
0.4086481929,
0.4461275339,
0.202565521,
-0.1422141343,
-0.0672808811,
0.1249352396,
-0.6037656665,
-0.7443729639,
0.7533330321,
-0.6037089825,
-0.6730357409,
-0.3096629381,
-0.3840655684,
-0.5568361282,
0.1700649559,
0.1360911429,
0.6874012351,
-0.0672760382,
-0.0009432118,
0.8356845379,
-0.3248930275,
0.3574336767,
0.9997037649,
-0.1423917115,
-0.2324253619,
0.9274278879,
0.0807233229,
0.3765031695,
0.1881021708,
0.2768442333,
-0.6050515175,
-0.4967209697,
-1.0167648792,
0.4002141953,
-0.6365160942,
-0.3989186883,
-0.6619365215,
-0.0992464274,
-0.4612075686,
-0.1884447038,
-0.053279303,
-0.1673872769,
-0.2911124229,
0.0238380674,
0.2650689483,
0.840862155,
0.0322170109,
0.2478556484,
-0.9063742161,
0.6135424972,
0.7527936697,
0.3976588547,
0.2827605009,
-0.7493553758,
-0.1147862449,
-0.0313299894,
-0.2471566498,
-0.9352960587,
0.2166434973,
0.14784953,
0.3965371549,
0.2687054574,
0.5028527379,
0.5279041529,
-0.7223166227,
1.0154297352,
0.0598317981,
-0.9097288847,
0.6093796492,
-0.6766620874,
0.7558299303,
0.564683795,
0.7191153765,
-0.3339443803,
-0.2539934516,
-0.4048529267,
-0.6421436071,
0.8823547363,
0.0207591243,
0.3870902658,
-0.2569553256,
0.6364753246,
0.1962017715,
0.0899028853,
-0.650868535,
-0.072667554,
-0.2270062864,
-0.2900970578,
0.1212975904,
-0.2653961778,
-0.1821294129,
0.0212029442,
0.779864192,
-0.7405330539,
0.2152085751,
0.5603317022,
-0.1522289664,
-0.1448749751,
0.3299202323,
0.5163538456,
0.7052775621,
-0.1598134637,
-0.0602205247,
0.2150396109,
-0.1671998799,
0.3842933178,
-0.0675777197,
-0.3928457499,
-0.3322635889,
-0.0366849378,
0.5463115573,
-0.0610009991,
-0.57485044,
0.7286913991,
-0.1855029762,
-0.4824012518,
-0.1760219783,
0.0633166507,
-0.2494113743,
0.1763386726,
0.5866984129,
-0.7118099332,
-0.0444955751,
-0.5534288287,
0.1513073444,
0.3653915226,
-0.5298100114,
-0.297374934,
0.5855073929,
0.0783915147,
0.1510945708,
0.4911723733,
-0.3571504653,
-0.4183237553,
0.3530373275,
0.5712202191,
0.7752025127,
-0.2900291383,
0.6233246922,
0.4549393654,
0.0212517343,
-0.0971428901,
0.4337108731,
-0.4434697032,
-0.6142771244,
-0.6499249935,
-0.4982104301,
-0.6216840148,
0.4500729442,
-0.5200837851,
0.0871732682,
-0.6235560179,
0.3536986411,
-0.211575985,
-0.1519051492,
-0.5207509398,
0.2627646923,
0.1623582244,
0.8674098849,
-0.5309560299,
0.8326104879,
0.5837206841,
-0.6762723923,
-1.0007727146,
0.3685728908,
0.0305995978,
-0.8927560449,
0.4655333161,
0.0750107318,
-0.0681541562,
0.2582188249,
-0.6746327877,
-0.6234486699,
0.9384373426,
0.352224052,
-0.1791436225,
-0.12593472,
-0.1096659973,
0.3543209732,
-0.281720221,
0.4502502978,
0.1572327018,
0.3145474195,
0.4039790034,
-0.6675316095,
0.2684348822,
0.1869058013,
-0.2819325328,
0.0251002517,
-0.5421841741,
0.8568293452,
-0.2514126003,
-0.1966730356,
0.1892924011,
0.6962718964,
0.3558836877,
0.1881510019,
0.4110384881,
0.1745870709,
0.5028649569,
0.3111111522,
0.9379652739,
-0.2132277638,
0.1976341009,
1.3107905388,
-0.5199586749,
0.9351902008,
0.0777003169,
0.125345856,
0.4331370592,
0.4249183536,
0.2265067697,
0.2284558117,
0.0051802387,
-0.4454718232,
-0.3733049929,
0.0357438959,
-0.4463292658,
0.4680234194,
0.1503198892,
-0.0910963416,
-0.5400948524,
0.0891699642,
-0.0397246853,
0.0353982374,
-0.4781314135,
0.7933173776,
0.065595381,
-0.801992476,
0.906193614,
-0.0877022147,
0.3963683844,
-0.692278266,
-0.16762878,
-0.2997196317,
-0.2086559832,
0.0870622396,
-0.9616234303,
-0.05257966,
0.0979614481,
-0.1571889073,
-0.3776391745,
0.4654012918,
-0.6002110243,
0.0071350764,
0.2171926796,
0.847469449,
0.1011603028,
-0.5187920928,
-0.6335690022,
-0.3787952662,
-0.1502453983,
-0.1360902786,
0.5003034472,
0.6407275796,
-0.0118073504,
0.4222454131,
0.775652349,
-0.2086955011,
-0.0893290192,
0.1213718429,
0.803168714,
-0.6616514921,
-0.4770321548,
-0.6005842686,
0.3076752424,
0.2654247284,
-0.1305826902,
0.824262917,
0.096681416,
0.768176198,
-0.2725390494,
0.6948890686,
0.132104829,
0.5788496733,
-0.7171968222,
0.6846170425,
-0.6481941938,
-0.0592621826,
-0.0663218126,
-0.863509655,
-0.1212946326,
0.3497844934,
-0.4415495992,
0.2067903578,
0.4547812045,
0.7843982577,
-0.0802771971,
0.0422165096,
0.7748413086,
0.2714838982,
0.1669045836,
0.5247846246,
0.9745935202,
-0.1789833903,
0.5574577451,
0.1494751424,
-0.2223433554,
-0.2393645942,
-0.8600063324,
-1.1136262417,
-0.5893539786,
-0.2082934976,
-0.386682719,
0.1588842869,
0.8638936281,
0.8128752112,
-0.7372317314,
0.067958273,
0.14250049,
0.1077234969,
-0.0611786544,
-0.1950107217,
0.2912846804,
-0.4934306145,
-0.5964670181,
0.858490169,
0.1922645867,
0.2031950653,
-0.5343031883,
0.0190866422,
-0.0396855846,
0.3488163352,
0.6258573532,
0.7856746316,
-0.5716893673,
-0.3460379839,
0.0940094292,
-0.0036860844,
-0.0361027122,
0.7959593534,
-1.0763893127,
0.4272148907,
0.3831088543,
0.6816661358,
0.4435617626,
0.0929937959,
0.6833803654,
-0.8400745392,
-0.207974717,
0.2209863961,
0.011761032,
0.1980520487,
-0.4583270252,
0.3883732557,
-0.086886391,
-0.4839599431,
-0.6456444263,
0.3414050937,
-0.5863120556,
-0.4015358388,
1.1580660343,
-0.4210725129,
-0.3058520555,
-0.3202117085,
-0.2791750431,
-0.1408097893,
-0.518630743,
0.6206077337,
0.3065317273,
0.0168334804,
-0.3075048327,
-0.5114353895,
0.4747582078,
0.4957963228,
-0.7611347437,
0.1585762203,
0.6223914623,
0.4124270082,
-0.154815793,
0.8944146037,
0.0064570513,
0.4618530869,
-0.297157824,
0.0405890346,
-0.3916378617,
-0.6093661785,
-0.7579555511,
0.3760468662,
0.0378298536,
-0.1337440908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.09523v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.09523v1 | Natural Language Processing in Customer Service: A Systematic Review | 2022-12-16T18:17:07 | 2022-12-16T18:17:07 | Malak Mashaabi, Areej Alotaibi, Hala Qudaih, Raghad Alnashwan, Hend Al-Khalifa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Artificial intelligence and natural language processing (NLP) are
increasingly being used in customer service to interact with users and answer
their questions. The goal of this systematic review is to examine existing
research on the use of NLP technology in customer service, including the
research domain, applications, datasets used, and evaluation methods. The
review also looks at the future direction of the field and any significant
limitations. The review covers the time period from 2015 to 2022 and includes
papers from five major scientific databases. Chatbots and question-answering
systems were found to be used in 10 main fields, with the most common use in
general, social networking, and e-commerce areas. Twitter was the second most
commonly used dataset, with most research also using their own original
datasets. Accuracy, precision, recall, and F1 were the most common evaluation
methods. Future work aims to improve the performance and understanding of user
behavior and emotions, and address limitations such as the volume, diversity,
and quality of datasets. This review includes research on different spoken
languages and models and techniques. | [
-0.5265752673,
-0.784271121,
-0.0039113243,
0.5790547132,
0.0730342641,
0.3410346806,
-0.1767665446,
-1.1184417009,
0.1363587081,
0.8743190169,
-0.6759591699,
-0.2281103283,
-0.1874665767,
0.6916329265,
-0.6730568409,
0.6812295318,
0.1815588325,
0.4142043591,
-0.0918520167,
-0.1276529878,
-0.3386780322,
-0.8739500046,
-0.9533939362,
-0.4874183536,
0.3326582611,
0.5040428638,
0.8264056444,
-0.0460667312,
0.9239920378,
0.3844800293,
-0.1494566798,
0.2441027761,
-0.0785796344,
0.4409792125,
-0.0678601563,
-0.2712732255,
-0.2968951464,
-0.1581071466,
0.4126415551,
0.9434625506,
-0.3010635972,
0.2025819421,
-0.0032754184,
1.1050921679,
-0.1837303936,
-0.0369780436,
-0.3885899782,
0.301546663,
0.1259176284,
-0.0267103706,
-0.2549567819,
-0.7203142643,
0.656349957,
-0.6429319382,
0.2223193645,
0.2367195636,
0.5679003,
0.102821745,
-0.0225936882,
-0.7640838027,
-1.2559530735,
0.884553194,
-0.5770783424,
0.271946907,
0.6618435383,
0.716593802,
0.0301388428,
-0.6400822401,
-0.4612616897,
-0.1474451572,
-0.2971114814,
-0.0770878941,
-0.3268825114,
0.1220096573,
0.4515661001,
0.4081722796,
-0.5821344256,
0.0063413251,
-0.535830915,
-0.1109822169,
0.8388673067,
0.4165487289,
0.3664461374,
-0.0976012647,
-0.2233131081,
0.1204519421,
-0.1742004603,
0.498255074,
0.2080019712,
0.3063422441,
0.2378502339,
0.7868741751,
-0.7440313697,
0.8181111813,
-0.3186182678,
-0.0187801085,
0.1413540244,
-0.4773558974,
-0.4613558948,
-0.0407860018,
0.9678664804,
0.571064651,
0.4919995368,
-0.2303331047,
-0.1386264265,
0.0239074454,
0.3970124125,
-0.4302914441,
0.2083614618,
0.3942837715,
-0.3984626532,
-0.0020505092,
0.0192558262,
-0.7240129113,
-0.2137337923,
-0.5000270009,
-0.6101440787,
-0.3987636566,
-0.2249631137,
0.1945119649,
-0.3072719574,
0.3069759905,
0.1354477853,
-0.8083266616,
0.98391819,
0.7749881744,
0.7199430466,
-0.2382837385,
-0.0719582513,
0.0581851527,
-0.2865115106,
-0.2583103776,
1.0362683535,
-0.540736258,
-0.2620869577,
0.4797564149,
-0.0370927416,
0.0302099548,
-0.8698530793,
1.0517104864,
-0.6736877561,
0.4446451366,
-0.28406021,
-0.4754989147,
-0.2851766348,
0.3272698224,
-0.7452091575,
1.1014983654,
0.1426792741,
-0.5466867685,
0.3420476913,
-0.733299315,
-0.6025936604,
0.3287734687,
0.3444477618,
-0.3994143903,
0.0255082492,
0.3635803759,
0.2409607768,
-0.3607954979,
0.1816615164,
-0.0882540569,
-0.3320461214,
0.4427509904,
-0.0455491692,
0.7813189626,
0.6107208133,
0.0653390065,
0.0756243765,
-0.7386897206,
0.0502351634,
0.0021617631,
-0.0613152795,
-0.1686521471,
0.0915850475,
0.4867794514,
0.380318135,
-0.0814548731,
-0.623670578,
-0.0266185999,
-0.8015431166,
0.6008979082,
0.1132233143,
0.2723464966,
0.5887471437,
-0.3682659566,
0.5600308776,
-0.3055741787,
0.5064454079,
-0.0480150692,
-0.9302179217,
-0.6767713428,
0.2907355726,
0.0550790466,
0.6712872982,
-0.8744805455,
0.4264901876,
0.0201722477,
-0.6106613278,
-0.798377037,
-0.0725462213,
0.1614279449,
0.5480710268,
0.4843853712,
-0.2497683167,
-0.7856870294,
-1.1059943438,
-0.4348377883,
-0.3215739131,
-0.0759153068,
0.2894103825,
0.0748569891,
-0.3904619515,
1.2181527615,
-0.3443315625,
-0.3972332776,
-0.4144704938,
0.212123394,
0.2038396597,
0.2343157232,
0.1293034256,
-0.8641991615,
-0.6320835948,
0.0508911684,
-0.7027900815,
-0.1595213413,
-0.0534632243,
0.2040757388,
0.7194373012,
-0.0815577582,
-0.5088011622,
0.5324471593,
0.3467591703,
-0.1989379078,
0.2571416497,
0.1088140234,
0.5062890649,
-0.372597307,
0.1965624541,
0.2270305902,
-0.2578577399,
-1.1317722797,
-0.5248647332,
-0.1445976645,
-0.4246854186,
-0.3397656977,
0.3404319584,
-0.1887021065,
-0.3576886058,
-0.5348350406,
-0.0929358378,
-0.0483248234,
0.1890210509,
0.1370960623,
0.6398491263,
0.2343590409,
-0.7034295201,
0.7198435664,
0.5512760878,
-0.4956178665,
0.5505501628,
-0.7606759667,
0.1558497399,
0.0628602505,
0.1398984045,
-0.9365087748,
-0.0427190363,
0.5073378682,
-0.7119153142,
-0.2774214149,
0.0545439646,
-0.5583367348,
-0.6168689132,
0.0743871853,
-0.1390540004,
0.40040797,
0.0858361199,
0.4707079828,
0.5097799301,
-0.6262837648,
-0.3598564863,
-0.8555501103,
0.4612147212,
0.0611110106,
-0.914478302,
0.0918181464,
0.0739654228,
-0.5339010954,
-0.2393446863,
-0.0732536614,
-0.4195840359,
0.1517437994,
0.0708473399,
0.1656748801,
0.1209341437,
0.1828265488,
-0.3759437799,
-0.1330446005,
0.2706348598,
0.1782485396,
0.8969243765,
-0.1100022793,
-0.0975953043,
-0.7659391165,
0.6370853782,
0.1372982562,
-0.0340118222,
0.5288505554,
0.6531916261,
-0.3582350612,
-0.0009701616,
-0.6586456895,
-0.289410919,
-0.4235517383,
0.0105480189,
0.1532033384,
-0.8733561635,
0.5641782284,
0.2713683546,
0.220810473,
0.3627427518,
0.3230562806,
-0.5215565562,
1.1807037592,
0.6917982101,
-0.1389498711,
0.4729839563,
0.0005453388,
0.740201056,
-0.5085350275,
-0.4284531474,
-1.0685629845,
-0.3047144115,
-0.6988157034,
-0.0448575057,
0.0328285918,
-0.0824394748,
0.1924317479,
0.2607598305,
-0.6499617696,
-0.0520816706,
0.4798776507,
-0.2931906283,
0.544795692,
0.158110708,
0.3994960785,
-0.1369906366,
-0.4231304526,
-0.8396010995,
0.7262346148,
0.4252564013,
0.6202170253,
-0.2351602912,
0.2464496493,
0.4494792223,
0.3677482903,
-0.7999918461,
0.5746405125,
0.0313094109,
-0.8219239116,
-0.5279200673,
-0.3747766912,
-1.1381858587,
-0.1225021258,
-0.1848790348,
-0.4935674667,
-0.3169397414,
-0.113665618,
-0.3167907298,
-0.0795325041,
-0.8389744163,
0.3393901885,
-0.1558581293,
0.1030066013,
-0.0557535999,
-0.6649019718,
0.2834392786,
0.3486483693,
0.2393599153,
-0.0603200085,
0.0665250421,
1.0264514685,
-0.1291459203,
0.5033115149,
-0.1834156811,
0.0114870081,
0.2994430065,
-0.2530771792,
0.2100653052,
0.1094635203,
-0.3007244468,
0.2469349056,
0.3339094818,
-0.270585835,
-0.7245650887,
0.2276820689,
-0.511140883,
-0.2951903939,
-0.8168488145,
-0.2301777601,
-0.5814733505,
0.1281500608,
-0.1082631126,
-0.0392508693,
-0.4071266949,
0.1659519523,
0.3497127891,
-0.2079578936,
0.5021566749,
0.4812819362,
-0.5014033318,
-0.3414269686,
0.5423548222,
0.0879166871,
0.0219018348,
0.1407068223,
-0.0179765765,
-0.3423120677,
-0.6511313319,
-0.1368259639,
0.1174570248,
-0.5447321534,
0.0638195723,
-0.8447127938,
-0.4136149585,
-0.6912626028,
0.0445508324,
-0.210569188,
-0.3488707542,
-0.090757452,
0.0897646472,
0.2188082039,
0.8444601893,
0.4354192615,
0.5423207283,
-0.7873646021,
0.6315518618,
-0.0350160375,
0.6582159996,
-0.1236381233,
-0.0967729762,
-0.2765123248,
0.0420774631,
-0.0410377719,
-0.7234692574,
0.621080935,
0.1259856671,
0.6163294911,
0.0087547926,
-0.0145829609,
0.4965035021,
-0.2177190632,
1.062656045,
0.1857126206,
-0.6658177376,
0.4645131826,
-0.0568443984,
0.4099399745,
0.7342125773,
0.6360407472,
-1.3804490566,
-0.2564316988,
-0.5278055072,
-0.8789402843,
0.9308597445,
0.3844870329,
0.0843702927,
0.2379949987,
0.0747437626,
-0.0045619067,
0.3824991286,
-0.3930935264,
-0.492672056,
0.1705798656,
0.0007698734,
0.0296790991,
-0.2110741436,
-0.063697964,
-0.1789878607,
0.4869193137,
-0.142486766,
0.4516108632,
0.4172707498,
-0.0230336916,
-0.3271493912,
0.2739232481,
0.3646413684,
0.8193692565,
-0.2983802259,
-0.5130550861,
0.0329028182,
-0.4779649079,
-0.2893493474,
0.0331159607,
-0.2635432482,
0.2563643754,
0.1686220616,
0.3508294821,
0.0984206051,
-0.9369975924,
0.1252599061,
-0.634819448,
-0.2577901483,
-0.7283599973,
-0.1112226248,
-0.1608490944,
-0.0446431972,
0.5521870852,
0.4690770507,
0.4585142732,
-0.4077451527,
0.1576804966,
0.3054621816,
-0.7481929064,
-0.1242884025,
-0.1765808016,
0.3313290179,
-0.8386902213,
0.7673307657,
0.0904717222,
-0.301086396,
0.3586385846,
0.1214014888,
0.8571895361,
-0.2653591335,
0.3873143196,
0.3007923663,
0.4065551162,
-0.003682022,
0.6152801514,
-0.0179847945,
-0.5715950131,
-0.3718992472,
-0.4874395132,
-0.8775008321,
0.04299796,
-0.7457162738,
0.2961989045,
-0.6778591871,
-0.3339598477,
0.3288865983,
0.1100883484,
-0.9199445248,
0.2197177112,
0.2189280689,
0.9869419932,
-0.5512108207,
0.4369731843,
0.6510391831,
-0.2755575478,
-0.2454288453,
-0.2921894789,
-0.0079373168,
-0.5931808352,
0.5746110678,
0.169559896,
-0.0637754276,
-0.3963409066,
-0.5927058458,
-0.5845461488,
0.8034451008,
-0.2322632968,
-0.4649215043,
-0.081662707,
0.5993878841,
1.0027512312,
-0.3640645146,
0.4671034813,
1.0334205627,
0.3830541968,
-0.0020073694,
-0.9314581752,
-0.395697087,
-0.2824548185,
-0.0179347768,
-0.1020562872,
-0.4372128248,
0.2608494461,
0.3836596906,
-0.5743201375,
0.0979580134,
0.51514256,
0.1688915342,
0.5574322939,
0.4184505641,
0.3160487413,
0.6738462448,
-0.2111822516,
1.0641938448,
-0.1051723361,
0.0854309946,
0.6864866614,
-0.554851234,
0.7491243482,
0.7226956487,
-0.4340749383,
0.3189582527,
0.5992848873,
0.0179567542,
0.1793303788,
0.1536889225,
0.1022489518,
0.0801035687,
-0.4795501232,
-0.0975047797,
0.2991983891,
0.4724165797,
-0.1809663028,
-0.1224929392,
-0.025265336,
-0.2584643066,
0.1770838499,
-0.1406947672,
1.2705260515,
0.0800988004,
-1.028272748,
0.5845543742,
0.084043473,
0.6432734728,
-0.6014428735,
-0.0216618292,
-0.0563432612,
-0.1730110496,
-0.4471374452,
-1.0383228064,
0.9181153178,
0.3338835239,
0.0037139941,
-0.7057992816,
0.9523835182,
0.0366681777,
-0.4674649239,
0.3855443597,
0.4966671765,
-0.0685462877,
-0.1942123622,
-0.9931710958,
0.0463851802,
-0.0444467589,
-0.4626084268,
-0.028355632,
0.1210840568,
0.0997908488,
0.987867415,
0.8121448755,
0.2399365604,
0.21954979,
0.3426182568,
0.7520541549,
-0.9526148438,
-0.4280411601,
-0.4219837189,
0.4517431259,
-0.4065687656,
-0.650827229,
0.845200479,
0.4668931663,
0.8509591818,
0.1829904914,
0.9219893217,
0.0318956636,
1.1175649166,
-0.3183661103,
0.268096447,
0.0643719658,
0.2768263817,
-0.2724805176,
-0.8551807404,
-0.4920581877,
0.4697308838,
-0.5331438184,
-0.1578390151,
0.6278333664,
0.5012210608,
0.4015396237,
0.8771584034,
0.0996536463,
-0.2461263388,
0.5275909305,
-0.042705927,
1.1723020077,
-0.5810088515,
0.385461539,
-0.5501568913,
0.0836680382,
-0.3852546513,
-0.2923994958,
-0.7346016169,
-0.5903589725,
-0.0759669617,
-0.2355301678,
-0.142521888,
0.9370993972,
0.6153216362,
-1.0336623192,
-0.4787323773,
0.0641089752,
0.1089874133,
-0.5763773918,
-0.2363776714,
-0.2068086416,
-0.7608371973,
-0.6994630694,
0.2352021039,
0.4639052749,
-0.0700278655,
-0.2962527871,
-0.0647757053,
-0.3585840762,
-0.247344777,
0.5428832173,
0.3628757298,
-0.6504629254,
0.2584947646,
0.5649948716,
-0.3172733784,
0.198117882,
1.0676492453,
-0.4828156829,
0.3517661691,
0.7274993062,
0.8522577882,
0.356582433,
0.1577272713,
0.6170098186,
-0.3896696568,
-0.0724942908,
1.0106004477,
0.1756117642,
0.6110346913,
-0.3260799348,
0.5633003116,
0.0738326162,
-0.6734088063,
-0.6426321268,
0.2123385966,
-0.9895484447,
-0.1595132947,
0.9685344696,
0.2611821592,
-0.1793164015,
-0.9391967654,
-0.4521105886,
-0.0201050024,
-0.6938542128,
0.7610615492,
0.9344313145,
-0.4196512103,
-0.2784720361,
-0.856187582,
0.7422860265,
0.2989304066,
-1.1106942892,
0.0230339784,
0.1534047425,
-0.1429205686,
0.2547411919,
0.5923042297,
-0.0172205381,
0.0416354984,
-0.6413855553,
0.0948683619,
0.3642188907,
-0.1799700409,
-0.6092754006,
0.1510331929,
0.0294013619,
0.4027255476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08632v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08632v2 | Enhancing Multi-modal and Multi-hop Question Answering via Structured Knowledge and Unified Retrieval-Generation | 2022-12-16T18:12:04 | 2023-08-07T03:02:06 | Qian Yang, Qian Chen, Wen Wang, Baotian Hu, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Multi-modal multi-hop question answering involves answering a question by
reasoning over multiple input sources from different modalities. Existing
methods often retrieve evidences separately and then use a language model to
generate an answer based on the retrieved evidences, and thus do not adequately
connect candidates and are unable to model the interdependent relations during
retrieval. Moreover, the pipelined approaches of retrieval and generation might
result in poor generation performance when retrieval performance is low. To
address these issues, we propose a Structured Knowledge and Unified
Retrieval-Generation (SKURG) approach. SKURG employs an Entity-centered Fusion
Encoder to align sources from different modalities using shared entities. It
then uses a unified Retrieval-Generation Decoder to integrate intermediate
retrieval results for answer generation and also adaptively determine the
number of retrieval steps. Extensive experiments on two representative
multi-modal multi-hop QA datasets MultimodalQA and WebQA demonstrate that SKURG
outperforms the state-of-the-art models in both source retrieval and answer
generation performance with fewer parameters. Our code is available at
https://github.com/HITsz-TMG/SKURG. | [
-0.2952963412,
-0.8852542043,
0.7087609172,
0.1148690805,
-0.398696214,
0.1942318976,
0.1342476457,
-0.3913701773,
0.1385054439,
0.3018355072,
-0.4691887796,
-0.1411471963,
-0.1401097476,
0.2377734482,
-0.0599061623,
0.6645235419,
0.3195102811,
0.2342299521,
-0.4901165962,
-0.2269612998,
-0.7222943306,
-0.5522777438,
-0.2501552701,
-0.1409857273,
0.4411310554,
0.3528611362,
0.4264827371,
0.3585986197,
0.3188806474,
0.266959995,
-0.07386069,
0.2740058899,
-0.2252254188,
0.4641012847,
-0.1779564172,
-0.1548565179,
-0.2663732469,
-0.4503499866,
0.6652600169,
0.9430693984,
-0.1143601984,
0.167737335,
-0.1044211388,
0.4683406353,
-0.7691659927,
-0.1691848636,
-0.8350109458,
-0.2876465619,
-0.1380149722,
-0.4891301095,
-0.6456050873,
-0.3514370024,
0.0215450954,
-0.8020966053,
-0.0579801127,
-0.0010563154,
0.4826846123,
0.2200851142,
-0.9449698329,
-0.3001038432,
-0.6390666962,
0.5659517646,
-0.5828362107,
0.6168564558,
0.0593460202,
0.2926706672,
-0.222195521,
-0.8182815313,
-0.4077593982,
0.1050740778,
-0.2717292011,
0.2934522033,
0.1498902887,
0.1871600598,
0.1064185798,
0.0875266045,
-0.8065401316,
-0.4249016345,
-0.6762176752,
-0.4752220511,
0.6259964108,
-0.0359169766,
0.1566795856,
-0.6787060499,
-0.4834969938,
-0.0461369604,
-0.4734081626,
0.3068463206,
0.2767128646,
0.4302822351,
0.556217432,
0.7985184193,
-0.5278887153,
0.7652434707,
0.3130877614,
-0.1853030771,
0.3596890271,
-0.6293006539,
-0.1622781903,
0.0151490159,
0.6331620812,
0.0770301595,
-0.2609702051,
-0.2745917141,
0.1197263598,
-0.0800269619,
0.4318351448,
-0.6746233106,
-0.0654761195,
0.2977184057,
-0.3487680554,
-0.1971924454,
0.1002976522,
-0.7582426667,
0.0870646015,
-0.1087344512,
0.8622160554,
-0.5960168839,
-0.2408623248,
0.0783141255,
-0.3761821985,
0.4061835706,
0.2232585102,
-0.3748477697,
0.1772627383,
0.2876418233,
0.4280515611,
0.1970771253,
-0.1211585104,
-0.8502002358,
0.3257448673,
-0.1533153206,
0.7800610065,
-0.5960770845,
-0.2658912241,
-0.0844849721,
-0.2121010125,
-0.2230671197,
-0.1130383834,
0.3517716825,
-0.9373956919,
0.5292691588,
-0.4236117899,
-0.4534154534,
-0.2517638206,
0.2326831818,
-0.5224568844,
1.3027309179,
0.0930714905,
-0.8945420384,
0.2966250479,
-0.7588059306,
-0.5518687963,
0.2852865458,
-0.3809772134,
0.1204217151,
0.212006852,
0.3883303106,
0.2936645746,
-0.1006780937,
0.4195360839,
-0.1117545962,
-0.4545941949,
0.0688494518,
-0.1261218786,
0.649017334,
0.2426339388,
-0.0072355797,
0.1783144474,
-0.7656828761,
0.3462557793,
0.232239753,
-0.7457560301,
-0.5425603986,
0.0893789828,
-0.1548417658,
0.5146884322,
0.0949362814,
-0.7247162461,
0.3760668039,
-0.3944464326,
0.3218421638,
0.6399646401,
0.3659832776,
0.6359175444,
-0.1454681009,
0.4804250896,
0.2793126702,
0.0086872792,
-0.4261436164,
-0.4270665646,
-0.301750809,
0.0303881485,
0.3918498158,
0.3263248503,
-1.1554479599,
0.097759299,
-0.2777442932,
-0.2150476575,
-0.818908453,
0.0672734156,
0.2393127084,
0.8213635087,
0.5703094006,
-0.3551443219,
-0.5552346706,
-0.7115013003,
-0.2610963881,
-0.2106708735,
-0.1826159805,
0.4531769753,
0.3017775416,
0.1020240709,
0.9616546631,
-0.4651541114,
0.2894400954,
-0.2569576204,
0.0731278509,
-0.0984720141,
0.3005016446,
0.2838710248,
-0.9683127999,
-0.2092903703,
-0.2383536547,
-0.7346026301,
0.1518172771,
-0.0670187175,
-0.3845078647,
0.0020914015,
0.5149260163,
-0.6187019348,
0.0955706313,
0.3741610348,
-0.378028661,
0.6852388978,
0.0456361584,
0.3711817861,
-1.5968846083,
0.280477792,
-0.5060276389,
-0.1934652328,
-0.6120358706,
0.2958420515,
0.0142970905,
-0.1233945638,
-0.397663027,
0.3108089864,
-0.302375257,
-0.2119389176,
0.0131820953,
0.3011031747,
0.3380987942,
0.5790244937,
-0.0729636401,
0.9254842997,
0.3228644431,
-0.5848649144,
0.1789895147,
0.4456325769,
0.0013781401,
0.4259210229,
-0.8741189241,
0.4138136506,
-0.3090008199,
0.3876033425,
-1.127836585,
-0.5914025903,
0.119451344,
-0.5852321386,
0.1839110106,
-0.3901183307,
-0.3923443258,
-0.2497535944,
-0.2095887512,
0.6872569919,
0.2906290591,
-0.4312307239,
0.9384862185,
0.0601609237,
-0.2696658671,
-0.7719840407,
-0.3233352005,
-0.2813205719,
0.0708374456,
-0.8691720963,
0.2515574396,
-0.3616450727,
0.0688582212,
0.0193763636,
-0.411237359,
-0.3033686578,
0.0262890402,
0.0299993418,
0.1829660833,
-0.3384566307,
0.5787306428,
0.515022397,
0.1194520965,
0.0515295491,
-0.2371306568,
0.6229213476,
-0.0612395704,
-0.5041490197,
-0.0065445392,
0.778467536,
0.7899832129,
-0.4622734189,
0.6780446172,
0.615404129,
-0.1412709355,
0.2010114491,
-0.4664872587,
-0.3393248022,
-0.4461831152,
0.2034121603,
-0.6069261432,
-0.9523573518,
0.2347414196,
-0.3780242503,
0.0773291513,
0.3833691776,
0.426761806,
-0.3356033266,
1.1375262737,
0.3933448493,
0.2473143935,
0.0262236092,
0.147003755,
0.2335955054,
-0.9369474053,
-0.6067185402,
-0.4772040546,
-0.1679495573,
-0.3561022282,
-0.2762384415,
0.550473094,
0.5320276618,
-0.1577224135,
0.304107219,
-0.600286305,
0.1061767861,
0.8023443818,
0.2182513624,
0.5781533122,
-0.1411400884,
-0.5086057782,
0.2276798934,
-1.0836335421,
-0.1667676419,
1.1516622305,
-0.2201250941,
0.5678461194,
0.1327565759,
0.614405036,
0.0051254611,
-0.2714379728,
-0.5090589523,
0.5035808086,
0.5411765575,
-0.7016649246,
-0.3350479603,
-0.6169749498,
-0.7608554363,
0.531491816,
-0.2984871864,
-0.4958077073,
0.167199105,
0.1213790253,
-0.4982152581,
-0.0498029888,
-0.625875473,
0.6538592577,
-0.0032387034,
-0.064570263,
0.0281830952,
-1.0614107847,
0.4173406363,
0.0570318475,
0.0748253465,
0.1508567482,
0.2846129537,
0.5772717595,
-0.1340963542,
0.3620067537,
-0.2280780077,
0.2196046859,
0.401969105,
0.0916350037,
0.3567699492,
0.3296639323,
-0.1872649938,
-0.1413974762,
0.2620808482,
-0.488199085,
-0.712865293,
0.4232220948,
-0.600092113,
-0.286434114,
-0.217214033,
-0.8690040112,
-0.4255695641,
0.3032594621,
0.4740000069,
0.6918049455,
-0.0839226246,
0.4617770612,
0.6286676526,
-0.0159785412,
0.2632102072,
0.2565557957,
0.0028030591,
-0.4106432498,
0.492798537,
-0.0290942322,
0.2664586604,
0.3383138478,
0.1253969371,
-0.5782703757,
-0.291554749,
-0.6815288663,
0.032521911,
-0.6146438718,
-0.6163238287,
-0.9387108088,
-0.2153213322,
-0.6551783681,
-0.2312518209,
-0.221920222,
-0.6118985415,
0.1223315969,
0.0106566222,
0.2763361931,
0.4725459218,
-0.0496021174,
0.1169600114,
-0.8842324018,
0.5018891692,
0.6260408163,
0.2794585824,
-0.1455699801,
-0.2482623905,
0.0524098799,
0.2394187003,
-0.3127572536,
-1.1820588112,
-0.2235520482,
0.238047868,
0.5250243545,
0.1382503211,
0.3783388436,
0.741314292,
-0.4964873493,
0.6584251523,
0.1361241788,
-0.7616783381,
0.8522623181,
-0.2885775864,
0.4928505421,
0.7996535897,
0.329708308,
-0.5102126002,
-0.2349047065,
-0.4428770244,
-0.8592361212,
0.5651347041,
0.2549711764,
0.0553431287,
-0.0924516842,
0.3839110732,
0.0771003962,
0.4131632149,
-0.6385963559,
-0.0783730298,
-0.4170357585,
-0.0984619632,
0.4712083638,
-0.2410202324,
-0.2446404546,
-0.2443910837,
0.5555118918,
-0.4357866049,
0.3976852894,
0.3586966991,
-0.4666220844,
-0.1631450355,
0.6693581939,
0.4646283984,
0.815705657,
-0.1050509661,
0.016091289,
0.1091721281,
-0.3366214335,
0.1427541822,
0.2361362129,
-0.4999563694,
0.1110339463,
0.13312684,
0.387604326,
0.2697579265,
-0.598202765,
0.5990610123,
0.0018148078,
-0.2769245803,
-0.0047561931,
-0.0495876707,
0.1611337364,
0.3271606565,
0.7273480892,
0.1732458472,
0.2699590325,
-0.4986043274,
0.3081720471,
0.3323380649,
-0.2123039812,
-0.3743720055,
0.5575459599,
0.2056094259,
-0.0852105767,
0.8406087756,
-0.1182718277,
-0.4190053642,
0.1476890892,
0.7161386609,
0.4321960509,
-0.3840583265,
0.3459954858,
0.471418947,
0.1679397374,
0.2550182939,
0.6242158413,
-0.1939409673,
-0.6007282734,
-0.8034615517,
-0.7664394379,
-0.0972117856,
0.0353421681,
-0.925158143,
-0.2175479531,
-0.0451828614,
0.168843329,
-0.160154283,
-0.0961390734,
-0.6656475067,
-0.0453632735,
-0.2580952644,
0.8763694763,
-0.7845503688,
0.5137081742,
0.9012947083,
-0.6341204047,
-0.99445647,
-0.0289313458,
-0.1100414246,
-0.397087127,
0.315590322,
-0.0361869074,
-0.0887053609,
0.1119560525,
-0.5177203417,
-0.8400387168,
1.3229130507,
0.3191925287,
-0.052173689,
-0.4005822539,
-0.0673076436,
0.2513816655,
-0.2830195725,
0.1858238578,
0.2365275174,
0.3270062804,
0.3730421066,
-0.7346153855,
0.1072322875,
-0.2372923642,
-0.1245219558,
0.2877738476,
-0.342001617,
0.5234023333,
-0.2290060818,
-0.2430399656,
-0.0094968136,
0.6842278838,
0.5603532791,
0.2689742446,
0.434998244,
0.4240047336,
0.6231068373,
-0.0367845334,
0.7683050632,
-0.2827524841,
0.1377709806,
1.1503305435,
-0.1167808175,
0.8951874375,
0.6479215026,
0.2193713933,
0.6312003732,
0.4069557488,
0.3845542967,
0.6107138991,
-0.2061543763,
-0.2633683085,
-0.5860724449,
-0.2011848092,
-0.4534579217,
0.8361893892,
0.036529664,
0.0045998851,
-0.5529227257,
0.0682733431,
-0.2742901742,
-0.0003872847,
-0.1438713372,
0.9681685567,
-0.2806731761,
-0.5770359039,
0.2367163897,
-0.1742017567,
0.3336861134,
-0.7303133607,
-0.3233269751,
-0.212800324,
-0.3812620938,
0.0133209061,
-0.6043660045,
0.2906472087,
-0.28410694,
-0.3794438541,
-0.0224522743,
1.0395059586,
-0.5978247523,
-0.4833729565,
0.165030539,
0.9423139095,
-0.0616789125,
-0.1880230755,
-0.5969474912,
-0.1124229282,
-0.2689711452,
-0.2599361539,
0.2286008745,
0.4733665884,
0.10452874,
0.4284262359,
0.9241674542,
-0.2992516756,
0.3472546041,
-0.0268530753,
1.1302777529,
-0.3611163199,
-0.4183618724,
-0.2637839019,
0.7780689001,
-0.1399940401,
-0.1646267325,
0.7127343416,
0.5739774108,
0.8294504881,
0.0857691616,
0.5872561336,
-0.4701050818,
0.5180049539,
-0.3069804907,
0.5250442624,
-0.648445189,
-0.1449497491,
-0.4358630776,
-0.894967556,
-0.0394031592,
0.4264645875,
0.1823706329,
0.063510716,
0.5194680691,
0.6350326538,
-0.1930755228,
-0.1650683284,
0.3694244921,
0.1372024864,
0.1572562903,
0.5073245764,
0.705326438,
-0.6889079809,
1.0409597158,
-0.2297373116,
0.0778167918,
-0.2027121931,
-0.5711824298,
-0.5403158069,
-0.8017521501,
0.0536532588,
-0.3202105761,
-0.006604352,
0.8028440475,
0.75841254,
-0.5161022544,
0.2215654254,
0.1056175381,
0.101888001,
-0.2769829333,
-0.2716369331,
0.3428743184,
-0.5881777406,
-0.2849465013,
0.7935632467,
0.3561813533,
-0.4173822105,
-0.0732453614,
0.0041669393,
-0.6376515627,
0.2287876159,
0.9431170821,
0.1904969215,
-0.6244197488,
-0.6113802195,
0.639262557,
0.0161034297,
0.2594141066,
0.9349538684,
-0.9629664421,
0.6065602899,
0.6351103187,
0.7974332571,
0.2607219517,
0.4243484139,
0.6072050929,
-1.1331870556,
-0.2038122416,
0.4692334831,
0.2187124342,
0.093385458,
-0.4435084164,
0.3409480751,
0.2157146931,
-0.6095107794,
-0.6421937346,
0.4421239495,
-1.1511596441,
-0.3768378198,
0.8991554379,
0.1938371807,
0.064598158,
-0.4982622266,
-0.0842283592,
0.2262943387,
-0.3658681512,
0.5205253363,
0.3710829616,
-0.2428591698,
-0.0487561226,
-0.4615747631,
0.2220508456,
0.2856208682,
-0.715236187,
-0.1725823879,
0.7349321842,
0.5060225129,
0.2628865838,
0.8845593929,
-0.1830270886,
0.6157877445,
0.0283497777,
0.041756276,
-0.2243112028,
-0.6152191758,
-0.139054209,
0.651915133,
-0.208032608,
-0.157908842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08620v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08620v2 | POTATO: The Portable Text Annotation Tool | 2022-12-16T17:57:41 | 2023-03-23T18:45:37 | Jiaxin Pei, Aparna Ananthasubramaniam, Xingyao Wang, Naitian Zhou, Jackson Sargent, Apostolos Dedeloudis, David Jurgens | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG | We present POTATO, the Portable text annotation tool, a free, fully
open-sourced annotation system that 1) supports labeling many types of text and
multimodal data; 2) offers easy-to-configure features to maximize the
productivity of both deployers and annotators (convenient templates for common
ML/NLP tasks, active learning, keypress shortcuts, keyword highlights,
tooltips); and 3) supports a high degree of customization (editable UI,
inserting pre-screening questions, attention and qualification tests).
Experiments over two annotation tasks suggest that POTATO improves labeling
speed through its specially-designed productivity features, especially for long
documents and complex tasks. POTATO is available at
https://github.com/davidjurgens/potato and will continue to be updated. | [
-0.4416977167,
-0.5945163965,
0.5234491825,
0.5322784185,
-0.3259616494,
0.224323824,
-0.3024855554,
-0.7168265581,
0.6752514839,
0.3896704316,
-0.0503570177,
-0.6142530441,
-0.7213141322,
0.3039565384,
-0.2919112146,
1.1178740263,
-0.071144633,
-0.3755567372,
-0.0637443811,
-0.503366828,
-0.398768723,
-0.2904168069,
-0.5366266966,
-0.2043019533,
1.1404954195,
0.7282057405,
0.7602662444,
0.8105338812,
0.8301256895,
0.3013127148,
0.0054026311,
0.1427613795,
0.0609350018,
0.5963045359,
-0.1616654247,
-0.2342193723,
-0.4866372645,
0.1620959044,
0.4089591801,
0.3814026713,
0.4344285727,
0.4750835299,
-0.1583711952,
0.7499167919,
-0.9321042299,
0.1070794165,
-0.3365398347,
-0.0137047218,
-0.475762099,
-0.1881781667,
-0.6410773993,
-0.6031517386,
-0.2761583626,
-0.882579565,
0.0694636256,
-0.2072057724,
0.9268084764,
0.2613032758,
-0.4889033735,
-0.286801219,
-0.5713090897,
0.395447582,
0.0959564,
0.2878024578,
0.3237241507,
0.6040839553,
0.1917379051,
-1.1570923328,
-0.3849234879,
-0.2768985927,
-0.1651625782,
0.1902049929,
0.2023762614,
0.2280059606,
0.070779033,
0.3194401562,
-0.1321299374,
-0.1274815053,
-0.1602668315,
-0.08700113,
0.3096196949,
-0.2959009111,
0.2681921422,
-0.135428071,
-0.3920226097,
-0.1539190114,
-0.1618959904,
-0.1017512679,
0.0766685233,
0.2797786295,
-0.0022107996,
0.8503338695,
0.0142747061,
0.4810088277,
-0.2631030083,
-0.0466795713,
0.5679081082,
-0.2470768839,
-0.1411268711,
0.1205731481,
0.8978443742,
0.3779429197,
0.0451899581,
-0.1042444259,
-0.3077427149,
0.0995158777,
0.0590257049,
-0.7023406625,
-0.6150180101,
0.2089096606,
-0.3897158802,
-0.2901808023,
0.2336575091,
-0.6808961034,
-0.7734897137,
0.0733309612,
0.602175951,
-0.4170721471,
-0.132574901,
-0.1732471883,
-0.8476593494,
-0.3893532455,
0.4326560795,
-0.8353199363,
-0.0707208812,
0.5147458911,
1.3154219389,
0.2083202899,
-0.0842802599,
-0.8393681049,
0.3879458606,
-0.352317661,
0.8985350728,
-0.6407084465,
-0.5676335096,
-0.2778995931,
-0.0047048572,
0.0144141037,
-0.1937110126,
0.716063261,
-0.0924296975,
-0.0080186129,
-0.3735463619,
-0.2854883671,
-0.3296092153,
0.2562577128,
-1.0439674854,
1.3847283125,
0.2540178001,
-1.3304274082,
0.5337978601,
-1.2487921715,
-0.3684723973,
0.5136358142,
-0.1260032654,
-0.267313689,
-0.1313424557,
0.0134101361,
0.6335324049,
0.0569886416,
0.0335138403,
-0.1829446405,
-0.2647151053,
0.1609280407,
0.0777599737,
0.643650949,
0.2996085584,
-0.2782807946,
0.6030441523,
-0.7226865292,
-0.2882786095,
0.0265001412,
-0.6377705932,
-0.408007443,
-0.1489272863,
0.5857274532,
0.0055001993,
0.3013489544,
-0.8136264086,
0.4830217659,
0.1317431033,
0.1292116642,
0.4617715776,
-0.0635301322,
0.3882357776,
-0.214690879,
0.5467862487,
-0.1444268376,
0.1873521954,
-0.5330013633,
-0.8141957521,
-0.5785744786,
-0.9743900895,
0.8272354603,
0.8565900922,
-1.0094784498,
0.4911762774,
-0.2926775217,
-0.8409686089,
-0.5880374312,
-0.0428600423,
0.2141337693,
0.4471538663,
0.3236381114,
-0.2449335307,
-0.5849250555,
-0.9337533116,
-0.2078299224,
-0.0765899867,
-0.2336277515,
-0.1411215812,
0.605181396,
-0.3610326052,
1.0183368921,
-0.4377914071,
-0.6276873946,
-0.4181068242,
0.5591651201,
-0.3027293384,
0.2819164097,
0.7653850913,
-0.9233901501,
-0.7574850917,
0.2301315963,
-0.5532740951,
-0.3258411288,
-0.1121013239,
0.0610183254,
0.3430528045,
0.542542696,
-0.6356351972,
0.223034814,
0.6428735852,
-0.5461155772,
0.3197941184,
-0.372210145,
0.181490466,
-1.1239871979,
0.5266256332,
0.2287571281,
-0.4971048832,
-0.3361018598,
-0.028117951,
0.4680593908,
0.0828019679,
-0.321231544,
0.7298179269,
-0.3224637806,
0.1375314444,
-0.194421649,
0.3242834508,
0.1838221401,
-0.1850891113,
-0.062459521,
0.8832448721,
0.3214238286,
-0.3041297495,
0.3749818504,
0.0652316585,
-0.0671487227,
0.2271956652,
-0.3052930534,
0.1136689931,
-0.1955303401,
0.4817920327,
-1.0964995623,
-0.3829448819,
0.6318535209,
-0.5836070776,
0.0517306514,
-0.0204006694,
-0.8411615491,
-0.0313843526,
-0.7560748458,
-0.0634230897,
0.1736177504,
-0.4817960262,
1.0507007837,
0.3823705316,
-0.0545665622,
-0.2933041453,
-0.7693734765,
0.1397710592,
-0.0868197531,
-0.5091258287,
0.2130272239,
-0.0213223752,
-0.1963010132,
0.0915274695,
0.1401229352,
-0.1229903549,
0.2283478528,
0.6701524854,
0.0008539021,
0.0155977299,
0.626152873,
0.0132157914,
-0.4214880168,
-0.2750093937,
0.0915459692,
-0.0062428839,
0.0012028269,
0.2937815189,
-0.003380859,
0.5011979938,
0.3673658967,
-0.4981289208,
0.5930492282,
1.0526593924,
-0.3340129852,
0.0586844459,
-0.4594977498,
0.3199512661,
-0.4928246439,
0.1675010771,
-0.6258479953,
-0.7356866002,
0.2791457176,
-0.2021787912,
0.3919776678,
0.6334069371,
0.224875465,
-0.1111728474,
0.5877472162,
0.9647371173,
0.424400121,
0.6619333029,
0.0541840419,
-0.0906517133,
-0.6457875371,
-0.4661507308,
-0.8432751894,
-0.5214277506,
-0.5768360496,
-0.6237435937,
0.0635180995,
-0.0542240851,
0.1047272906,
0.0507714897,
-0.9947906137,
0.7381994128,
0.868429482,
-0.2252893895,
-0.0156919491,
-0.5304486156,
0.0299291108,
-0.0033752951,
-0.4233781099,
-0.8260532022,
0.930136323,
0.5365097523,
0.3508517444,
-0.1966793984,
0.937318027,
0.2052753717,
0.8850539327,
-0.7416245341,
0.5968220234,
-0.4627132714,
-0.8171646595,
-0.1141569987,
-0.2544448972,
-0.7663137317,
0.1868397295,
-0.5344415903,
-0.8274031281,
-0.1183473915,
0.3523983955,
-0.3044959605,
0.5100883245,
-1.3624813557,
1.0826165676,
-0.2184364498,
0.0395654775,
0.4726194143,
-0.6942154765,
0.0797301307,
-0.1447847039,
0.3218097389,
-0.4093050957,
-0.5463155508,
1.0476199389,
-0.0052322126,
0.6951494217,
-0.5276603699,
0.3328453898,
0.2353743762,
0.2133922428,
0.2548139393,
-0.0392598584,
0.0617789626,
-0.0133743854,
0.08229018,
-0.2732865214,
-0.2217130661,
0.5853049755,
-0.3281369209,
-0.109703429,
-0.6760465503,
-0.5374187827,
0.1862444133,
0.3097573221,
0.1851954311,
-0.2472020686,
0.159511134,
0.4085940421,
0.6567784548,
-0.1991711706,
0.6175297499,
-0.0969659761,
-0.640781939,
-0.7139959335,
0.9096633196,
0.4066221416,
-0.0991698951,
0.5823761821,
0.4074932635,
-0.125943616,
-0.364906013,
-0.3608480394,
0.0854376704,
-1.0304249525,
-0.2473989427,
-0.9783365726,
0.1847284585,
-0.1753895581,
-0.4019875228,
-0.4413381517,
-0.9309388995,
-0.2216778547,
-0.3255937397,
0.7433652878,
0.9329739213,
-0.1355537027,
0.5361011028,
-0.9617760777,
0.7331428528,
0.0386947654,
0.5562593937,
-0.6164687872,
0.1784137934,
-0.333892256,
-0.426315397,
-0.3911985457,
-1.068991065,
-0.0935385972,
0.2466393113,
0.145811379,
0.1940829307,
-0.0082432171,
0.0493042432,
-0.2776215672,
1.0537141562,
0.3150808811,
-0.9136040807,
0.6130872965,
-0.3010394275,
0.5341682434,
0.8097509146,
0.5757209659,
-0.5723612905,
-0.3890444934,
-0.2475504428,
-1.32916677,
0.1665187627,
0.0529735759,
-0.3165578544,
-0.2486340553,
0.1752075404,
0.4917749166,
0.0783417299,
-0.7271798253,
-0.433932215,
-0.4419807196,
-0.4552329779,
-0.2764886022,
-0.5093320012,
0.0099619739,
-0.1567170322,
0.8325938582,
-0.0322353207,
0.0734315291,
0.3469869792,
0.0217341445,
0.0447939895,
0.07448598,
0.3952635527,
0.6380179524,
-0.6541746855,
0.372781992,
-0.2823447287,
-0.8822686076,
0.0920082852,
0.4498829246,
-0.2676485479,
0.6447592378,
0.2035074383,
0.4586788714,
-0.1486073285,
-0.404887259,
0.3677325249,
-0.3000737727,
-0.4298141897,
-0.2562652528,
-0.2024425566,
0.3592424691,
0.1358667165,
0.2866718471,
0.0593670681,
0.1774471551,
-0.2064928561,
0.0603658296,
0.0812803507,
-0.4005590379,
-0.1260458082,
0.8331355453,
0.7106076479,
-0.5812645555,
0.1650569141,
-0.4441966116,
-0.331332624,
0.237790674,
0.1632236689,
1.1625486612,
-0.203635931,
0.52536726,
0.0087340008,
0.6735613346,
0.0574286431,
0.5082110763,
0.0454394445,
-0.0982215032,
-0.5311592221,
-0.3046453893,
-0.5333499312,
-0.2385736555,
-0.2182268053,
0.2314000428,
-0.4291736782,
-0.5324748158,
0.7485160232,
0.03308402,
-0.4892031848,
0.369882226,
0.1057015061,
1.3034750223,
-0.9154955149,
0.9516444206,
1.367243886,
-0.5205491185,
-0.3734027743,
-0.1790415943,
-0.1025302187,
-0.0211869571,
0.7781578898,
0.7688975334,
-0.2812125981,
-0.3432419002,
-0.3054291606,
-0.4705553353,
1.0789983273,
0.4467509687,
-0.3770894408,
0.1147390231,
0.0434593745,
0.3150425851,
-0.1269382983,
0.2031775266,
0.2716448307,
0.81058079,
-0.0886391401,
-1.0148451328,
-0.0100121954,
-0.4166938961,
-0.1636795849,
0.692461431,
-0.4163427055,
0.5934965014,
0.0308645535,
-0.1115149632,
-0.1688950956,
0.4935199618,
-0.1534834504,
0.627523005,
0.5297704935,
0.6160034537,
0.7347247601,
-0.3968366385,
0.975307703,
-0.0431994684,
0.0823221579,
1.1368249655,
-0.0004924973,
0.8211189508,
0.834002316,
0.3158058524,
0.2252644897,
0.5664328933,
0.1957632452,
0.1305578053,
0.072301589,
-0.370012641,
-0.0745122507,
-0.3149889112,
-0.2798940837,
0.0272147916,
0.2625822127,
-0.4438885748,
-0.1282780468,
0.2912863195,
0.2816626132,
0.0940035731,
-0.096216768,
0.6099386215,
-0.0747951344,
-0.2724983692,
-0.1138742939,
0.22223939,
0.7572005391,
-0.7534157634,
-0.175639838,
0.0251535159,
0.1887060255,
-0.4005325139,
-1.095851779,
0.4432554543,
-0.0622390546,
-0.0951676369,
-0.3997181058,
0.8353597522,
-0.0581320003,
-0.4397090077,
0.3286038339,
0.1189809218,
0.0928966478,
-0.3420765996,
-0.4672257006,
0.5031235218,
-0.1142080277,
-0.4793220758,
0.0491022058,
0.7377763987,
0.0101335468,
0.7149319649,
0.4545766413,
0.2419008464,
0.2498172671,
-0.129621014,
0.7920110226,
-0.8290411234,
-0.5741649866,
-0.6083502173,
0.9286568761,
-0.2193452567,
-0.3570539653,
0.6204863787,
0.815120995,
0.7736899257,
-0.232720837,
0.9898304939,
-0.4355440438,
0.7087579966,
-0.1784230769,
0.8067317605,
-0.2694825828,
-0.1484396458,
-0.2033690214,
-1.1070605516,
-0.7464391589,
0.418307215,
-0.1983879805,
-0.0654205531,
0.9049850106,
0.2764004767,
-0.0617923774,
-0.2359836698,
0.0811028108,
-0.2445503622,
0.4939625561,
0.0443337709,
0.4651393592,
-0.1511070132,
0.6182625294,
-0.6126412153,
-0.3915168345,
-0.1775936633,
-1.1474138498,
-0.9298121929,
-0.839476943,
-0.6222753525,
-0.0952454433,
0.1668235511,
1.0389220715,
0.5418287516,
-0.3722309768,
-0.09391395,
0.3550832272,
-0.0557752959,
-0.0754342526,
-0.2168481499,
0.3897317946,
-0.3342559636,
-0.3263196647,
0.0318084992,
0.5545493364,
0.1012305021,
0.2097885013,
0.2476180047,
-0.547028482,
0.0133808926,
0.6535765529,
0.1731414944,
-0.3338632882,
-0.4333670735,
-0.502282083,
0.0182985403,
0.1966398954,
0.7239478827,
-0.6716138124,
0.9249300957,
0.5282252431,
0.7557476163,
0.1010742784,
-0.0256368406,
0.0120309098,
-1.1020526886,
0.3484036028,
0.2782848775,
0.1652189493,
0.6169530153,
-0.2253214419,
0.5976424813,
0.0380912386,
-0.6054249406,
-0.7987693548,
-0.0371691994,
-1.1436187029,
-0.3430963755,
1.0043206215,
-0.3177531362,
-0.3316389918,
-0.0633170456,
-0.7856898904,
0.4559370875,
-0.4882891178,
0.6402797103,
0.6322280169,
-0.0196117908,
-0.1998205334,
-0.7358632088,
0.5427809954,
-0.078747645,
-0.9867873788,
0.0583789386,
0.4379558265,
0.1613994688,
0.7268089056,
0.7240626812,
0.2644381821,
0.2356591523,
0.0939721838,
0.5610574484,
-0.4005232155,
-0.5359970927,
-0.0032292935,
0.3978104591,
0.5125212669,
-0.9479818344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08619v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08619v1 | Planting and Mitigating Memorized Content in Predictive-Text Language Models | 2022-12-16T17:57:14 | 2022-12-16T17:57:14 | C. M. Downey, Wei Dai, Huseyin A. Inan, Kim Laine, Saurabh Naik, Tomasz Religa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | Language models are widely deployed to provide automatic text completion
services in user products. However, recent research has revealed that language
models (especially large ones) bear considerable risk of memorizing private
training data, which is then vulnerable to leakage and extraction by
adversaries. In this study, we test the efficacy of a range of
privacy-preserving techniques to mitigate unintended memorization of sensitive
user text, while varying other factors such as model size and adversarial
conditions. We test both "heuristic" mitigations (those without formal privacy
guarantees) and Differentially Private training, which provides provable levels
of privacy at the cost of some model performance. Our experiments show that
(with the exception of L2 regularization), heuristic mitigations are largely
ineffective in preventing memorization in our test suite, possibly because they
make too strong of assumptions about the characteristics that define
"sensitive" or "private" text. In contrast, Differential Privacy reliably
prevents memorization in our experiments, despite its computational and
model-performance costs. | [
-0.093313992,
-0.7867450714,
0.3205974102,
0.0872806683,
-0.0150912665,
0.2563160062,
-0.4115303159,
-0.291466713,
-0.3835708797,
0.7181134224,
-0.3049628139,
-0.4451780319,
-0.5464243889,
-0.2534115314,
-0.5631964207,
1.215821147,
-0.1077440381,
-0.3141808212,
-0.2016193867,
-0.0564090125,
-0.1761837453,
-0.9458369017,
-0.3724648654,
-0.1291747242,
0.5898244381,
0.3126368821,
0.7360407114,
0.7997027636,
0.4903672636,
0.3000212014,
-0.3968861997,
-0.1016243696,
-0.5373886824,
0.3650601804,
-0.1217735633,
-0.6961346865,
-0.2145571262,
-0.037335135,
0.8594023585,
0.6564669609,
-0.2342918217,
0.0529145859,
0.1978636533,
0.7646659017,
-1.0392137766,
0.0700954571,
-0.7691374421,
0.1153818518,
-0.1998890638,
-0.0979504287,
-0.6394763589,
-0.3368696272,
0.2129579335,
-0.4167161584,
0.3628599942,
-0.0914786011,
0.8676174879,
0.2236510962,
-0.2005830705,
0.0092610233,
-1.1325042248,
0.8591461182,
-0.5922259688,
0.1988136768,
1.202632308,
0.1951033324,
0.0968763828,
-0.3524431288,
-0.1546984166,
-0.3219455779,
-0.2460936457,
0.1763134748,
-0.0962099954,
0.0913641676,
0.6296271086,
0.5186561942,
-0.3726468086,
0.0772400498,
-0.5224441886,
-0.4075944722,
0.6083533168,
0.050706856,
0.1919003278,
0.0148525527,
-0.3320193589,
-0.253685385,
-0.8079108596,
0.1498342454,
0.7185037136,
0.1127780378,
0.1109342277,
0.6311175227,
-0.137353152,
0.0467993803,
-0.2687363923,
-0.0456416532,
0.0526361391,
-0.3080564737,
-0.171792388,
-0.1456938386,
0.8019085526,
0.0028896311,
0.6214440465,
-0.5633032918,
-0.3061578274,
0.0686931089,
0.2031558156,
-0.7090329528,
-0.4657617807,
0.1106809825,
-0.2358468026,
-0.3896863163,
-0.1908854693,
-0.7410520315,
-0.4275405109,
0.1071580872,
0.4024446309,
-0.5562298894,
-0.1108980402,
0.0250516944,
-0.1490536928,
-0.5049845576,
0.0569146574,
-1.1656899452,
0.709292233,
0.5597633719,
0.6350371242,
-0.0894967914,
-0.3406068981,
-0.4853125811,
0.5179373622,
-0.3123910427,
0.2923650444,
-0.3554751277,
-0.654091835,
0.1152443141,
-0.1156082824,
-0.1679650694,
-0.4872403741,
0.3881774545,
-0.4720036387,
0.5035028458,
-0.3449040353,
-0.6048920751,
-0.2627398074,
0.2393611372,
-0.7776578069,
0.7847827077,
0.03046236,
-0.9872766733,
0.0415329039,
-0.2210036069,
-0.6206459999,
-0.241338253,
-0.0026514346,
-0.9815825224,
0.2001961768,
-0.1261366308,
0.3824311793,
0.0598750412,
0.1615374386,
-0.1408570707,
-0.3934569955,
0.4687379301,
-0.6035121083,
0.6205151081,
0.1032585427,
-0.5599001646,
-0.0699746385,
-0.7543736696,
-0.1000292525,
0.2253142148,
-0.4353847802,
-0.6313096285,
0.0255075116,
-0.1403951496,
0.0501965024,
0.2417277992,
-0.2820494473,
-0.078201443,
-0.5454340577,
0.3202876449,
0.9705839157,
0.0256394111,
0.9016571045,
-0.4258256555,
0.5755431056,
0.0013893364,
0.2394677401,
-0.3911229372,
-0.3084392846,
-0.6363108754,
-0.3132055104,
0.4237097204,
0.6474937797,
-0.1525667906,
0.082222417,
-0.0873112306,
-0.3411359787,
-0.0160353146,
0.2916304171,
1.0458096266,
0.298941642,
0.2033189684,
-0.2546204329,
-0.2405072451,
-0.9324190617,
-0.4073387086,
-0.038539324,
0.0038951798,
0.3893324435,
0.4046952724,
-0.1020197198,
0.6604773402,
-0.5238708854,
-0.3780016899,
0.0467065573,
0.0467701368,
-0.4787068963,
0.687004149,
0.376725167,
-0.8794755936,
-0.5418358445,
-0.2122264057,
-0.4522765577,
0.1301661879,
-0.0619681254,
0.1608129591,
0.4593110085,
0.3017874062,
-0.5242851973,
0.7328984141,
0.494905889,
-0.204399839,
0.3254342675,
-0.6109389067,
-0.1393820345,
-0.8958608508,
0.1239401922,
-0.286809355,
-0.3640090525,
-0.7082331777,
0.0961812511,
0.3040262759,
0.0089336298,
-0.3488288224,
0.5391629934,
-0.6466124058,
0.0548062585,
-0.169822067,
-0.159106493,
0.0952208117,
0.5170522928,
0.0079488279,
0.9304779768,
0.3557649851,
-0.6733071208,
-0.3917714357,
0.2813848555,
-0.1082262248,
-0.1411221474,
-0.4452649057,
0.3662005961,
-0.1617296636,
-0.092875585,
-0.7290557027,
-0.0997798443,
0.1842421442,
-0.3740836382,
0.5451552272,
-0.0746396706,
-0.7091082335,
0.0401085839,
-0.5157752633,
0.2279242873,
0.8216242194,
-0.3321748674,
0.4587094188,
0.3473180234,
-0.1700665653,
-0.702878654,
-0.7805281281,
-0.0568597987,
-0.4125064909,
-0.2253218889,
0.4501170218,
-0.2562381923,
-0.2719678283,
0.0474827252,
-0.09411823,
-0.2847953141,
0.6219059229,
0.562020421,
0.2183087021,
0.1663207412,
-0.0153702972,
0.0630852431,
-0.2408332825,
0.1479331702,
-0.172720626,
0.4655971825,
-0.014099692,
-0.2096413523,
-0.4462286234,
0.5202258229,
0.2456571907,
-0.4755152166,
1.0780410767,
0.3150421977,
-0.6154291034,
-0.2385221571,
-0.6402568221,
-0.4408565462,
-0.491499275,
0.3044461608,
-0.0976004303,
-0.7648015618,
0.6611787081,
0.0692200586,
0.0810507238,
-0.0295272972,
0.3231384754,
-0.1365455091,
1.0490498543,
0.7898446321,
-0.2344481051,
0.5904226899,
-0.2884204686,
0.1100617275,
-0.69887501,
-0.1487422585,
-0.626396656,
0.0091028735,
-0.698502779,
-0.0956929997,
0.0429176576,
0.2142779976,
-0.1561532915,
0.3584012389,
-0.2046705931,
0.7108486891,
0.8071282506,
0.0865471885,
0.4384216964,
0.2003033608,
-0.0040403339,
-0.1829146296,
-0.4511529505,
-0.5879346132,
1.2768816948,
0.4855871499,
0.7148190737,
0.1219914183,
0.8693248034,
0.02204106,
0.1391485333,
-0.2707903981,
0.4513326585,
-0.5161072612,
-0.9144309163,
-0.415026933,
-0.5150720477,
-0.7108187675,
0.040658135,
-0.113328822,
-1.1208860874,
-0.068343997,
0.5171008706,
-0.4240968823,
0.2072892934,
-0.8519534469,
0.7174947858,
-0.0531341918,
-0.7330905795,
-0.120884873,
-0.5896593332,
0.3166756332,
-0.2837456167,
0.2945074141,
0.0620340109,
0.0465857498,
0.703012228,
-0.1254655272,
0.9393897057,
-0.2144530267,
-0.0637379065,
0.0082648853,
0.3861961365,
0.7316460013,
0.0903444886,
0.0448495783,
-0.0251491368,
-0.0315275118,
-0.4109739661,
-0.5281720757,
0.6049472094,
-0.7323040962,
-0.8190880418,
-0.2549207807,
-0.7164742947,
-0.1424866319,
0.3693202436,
0.5011498928,
0.1571149528,
-0.192934081,
0.2580651939,
1.114069581,
-0.297357738,
0.4927698672,
0.45746243,
-0.0653257892,
-0.3642065227,
1.0414444208,
0.2311027348,
0.6533403993,
0.3339132965,
0.5240734816,
-0.2653532028,
-0.8427016139,
0.0535163395,
0.1224663109,
-0.7064576149,
-0.0094270352,
-0.7768905759,
-0.3804596364,
-0.3823990822,
0.0897568315,
-0.481461674,
-0.7369970083,
-0.3244558573,
-0.2811568379,
0.229518652,
0.4922812879,
-0.068307519,
0.377473563,
-0.7373401523,
0.1841612905,
0.1092724577,
0.2211496383,
-0.2359307408,
-0.2945998013,
-0.1325171441,
-0.0119912382,
-0.2757785618,
-0.6546491385,
0.4553844035,
0.2479055822,
0.4451307058,
0.349406004,
0.1985559762,
0.2375722975,
-0.6298559308,
0.555123806,
-0.1212460399,
-0.8517467976,
0.5016189814,
-0.4976563454,
0.1211017519,
0.7566741109,
0.204399243,
-0.2433296889,
-0.7369863391,
-0.7519086599,
-0.9346846342,
0.6464875937,
0.4478904009,
0.4005486071,
0.2779708207,
0.4658107162,
0.1824739873,
0.3530988395,
-0.7250524163,
-0.2290021032,
-0.015906876,
-0.2028528303,
-0.338137567,
-0.6610232592,
-0.2552390397,
0.0910875052,
0.6295272708,
0.2627508938,
-0.2510697842,
-0.0775663406,
-0.1167266518,
0.0287153423,
0.2747386992,
0.700539887,
0.2411239445,
-0.2746358812,
0.1694632322,
0.029197,
-0.6969500184,
0.1014082879,
0.2305891067,
-0.8421526551,
-0.2143317908,
0.1337779313,
0.551862359,
0.2409097403,
-0.5643854141,
0.6284403801,
-0.244294256,
-0.3276147246,
-0.5205988884,
0.3786457479,
0.172980994,
-0.1403265595,
-0.1298137456,
0.1261716038,
0.1076120064,
-0.3706490397,
0.0704940706,
0.3957127631,
-0.368680805,
-0.3779094517,
0.8192971945,
-0.1929828227,
-0.4755605757,
0.4566606581,
-0.0565617792,
-0.69973737,
0.4904405773,
0.5243611336,
0.8742164969,
-0.4977596998,
0.0624223053,
0.2106430233,
0.3835524619,
-0.3529393673,
0.1371546388,
-0.2385596186,
-0.4762341976,
0.1518942416,
-0.2030457854,
-0.3560073078,
0.1796757132,
-0.7462525964,
-0.0922184214,
-0.8287301064,
-0.1735457629,
-0.1366721094,
0.0636767149,
-0.43689996,
0.1946695596,
0.0579865128,
0.7149071097,
-0.7402278781,
0.8380076289,
0.1492602378,
-0.372094512,
-0.6940312386,
0.3630737662,
0.0273197051,
-0.390560478,
0.4971072078,
0.227987498,
-0.0543936975,
-0.1353334635,
-0.1238831729,
-0.7230955958,
0.8517392874,
0.4513413012,
-0.715004921,
-0.0245603044,
0.3478511274,
0.4668696523,
0.3223804235,
-0.1617347896,
0.5076293349,
0.3148017526,
-0.3220925033,
-0.7591176033,
0.0616068728,
-0.0911365375,
0.0235253125,
0.1269659847,
-0.5932116508,
0.8954436183,
-0.2704170942,
-0.4322181046,
0.1958033144,
0.3202791214,
0.1012923121,
0.2553305924,
0.4556629658,
0.419146955,
0.9582967758,
0.0967695117,
1.1343752146,
-0.2281499207,
0.2701489627,
1.23731637,
-0.2679376006,
0.7905412912,
0.4676349759,
0.0776652619,
0.0284097902,
0.2998014987,
0.1283502579,
0.9162611961,
0.4384759068,
-0.3657665551,
0.0396591388,
-0.0539198369,
-0.3382361531,
0.3011121154,
0.0895636827,
-0.4550580382,
0.1406417787,
-0.0600346141,
0.3633233011,
0.7309908867,
0.100435771,
0.9590383768,
0.0527947657,
-0.7553287148,
0.5085686445,
0.0125184506,
0.4302614033,
-0.5506700277,
0.3571321666,
-0.3577621877,
0.7099790573,
-0.0716029927,
-0.3066443503,
0.5441260338,
0.1236159652,
-0.3819992244,
-0.3905980289,
0.5856928229,
-0.5121100545,
-0.3724618554,
0.4049975872,
0.1863612682,
-0.1698783189,
-0.2473570555,
-0.3836658299,
-0.1579233408,
-0.1086478755,
-0.5130369067,
0.58175385,
0.1900682747,
-0.1579943299,
0.742182374,
0.5638778806,
0.1505991966,
0.106612213,
0.1777787209,
0.9431586862,
-0.5954831243,
-0.5345505476,
-1.1796329021,
0.3486688137,
-0.1185114458,
-0.0900234357,
0.9582948685,
0.7716992497,
0.8621556163,
-0.0062708752,
0.8368089199,
0.6429136395,
0.5630806088,
-0.6221235394,
1.1153976917,
-0.2775005102,
0.4706476331,
-0.2603546977,
-0.5631445646,
-0.3371946812,
0.3336414993,
-0.3141435087,
-0.0448553599,
0.8101044893,
0.7687858939,
0.0877338797,
0.038031511,
0.3565821052,
0.0494954437,
0.4215474129,
0.6560432315,
1.1355836391,
-0.4189972281,
0.7188516855,
-0.899928689,
-0.2891323268,
0.1818132848,
-0.8555164933,
-1.3571000099,
-0.580337286,
-0.3702659607,
-0.3827503026,
0.4305985868,
0.2309857011,
0.7778556943,
-0.7081571817,
-0.0019310397,
-0.2367550433,
0.0804657862,
0.0073212693,
-0.0820175484,
0.3761370778,
-0.0963488221,
-0.6379749179,
0.1813597083,
0.1324985474,
0.4547808468,
-0.334179312,
0.1000706106,
0.2642183304,
0.0679865628,
0.051098939,
0.3488587141,
-0.582221806,
-0.1127065346,
0.220701009,
-0.2322682738,
-0.047099039,
0.769792676,
-0.5900579095,
0.1369408667,
0.384488821,
0.6360583901,
0.4970908761,
0.0284986086,
0.6702407598,
-0.9968577623,
0.4137821794,
0.2924502194,
0.1671065986,
0.5242868066,
-0.7624306679,
0.2458636612,
-0.0096790381,
-0.4340830743,
-0.9941993952,
0.2203331143,
-0.4368689656,
-0.3173505068,
1.1748665571,
-0.6240971088,
-0.3565363884,
0.0230061021,
-0.1173952073,
0.1711214632,
-0.261177361,
1.1768426895,
0.7405827641,
0.5644178987,
0.011828756,
-0.6061316729,
0.7883643508,
0.6401651502,
-0.70497334,
0.5396802425,
0.166278705,
0.3446631134,
0.1154292077,
0.7313185334,
-0.2007312775,
0.2227597684,
-0.2060388476,
-0.3890488446,
-0.2295379639,
-0.613735497,
-0.472868681,
0.0933424532,
0.0881604925,
-0.367961973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08607v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08607v1 | MURMUR: Modular Multi-Step Reasoning for Semi-Structured Data-to-Text Generation | 2022-12-16T17:36:23 | 2022-12-16T17:36:23 | Swarnadeep Saha, Xinyan Velocity Yu, Mohit Bansal, Ramakanth Pasunuru, Asli Celikyilmaz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Prompting large language models has enabled significant recent progress in
multi-step reasoning over text. However, when applied to text generation from
semi-structured data (e.g., graphs or tables), these methods typically suffer
from low semantic coverage, hallucination, and logical inconsistency. We
propose MURMUR, a neuro-symbolic modular approach to text generation from
semi-structured data with multi-step reasoning. MURMUR is a best-first search
method that generates reasoning paths using: (1) neural and symbolic modules
with specific linguistic and logical skills, (2) a grammar whose production
rules define valid compositions of modules, and (3) value functions that assess
the quality of each reasoning step. We conduct experiments on two diverse
data-to-text generation tasks like WebNLG and LogicNLG. These tasks differ in
their data representations (graphs and tables) and span multiple linguistic and
logical skills. MURMUR obtains significant improvements over recent few-shot
baselines like direct prompting and chain-of-thought prompting, while also
achieving comparable performance to fine-tuned GPT-2 on out-of-domain data.
Moreover, human evaluation shows that MURMUR generates highly faithful and
correct reasoning paths that lead to 26% more logically consistent summaries on
LogicNLG, compared to direct prompting. | [
-0.0961822644,
-1.1027727127,
0.7547149658,
0.4391989112,
-0.3839134574,
-0.0319243856,
0.0177672412,
-0.1276109219,
0.0916633829,
0.285382241,
-0.7121106982,
-0.7277802229,
-0.3703829348,
0.3848482668,
-0.6632192731,
0.8615162373,
0.1420099139,
-0.1836300641,
-0.2610068023,
0.3818428218,
-0.6095341444,
-0.355855912,
-0.7850003242,
-0.2474521101,
0.4645326138,
0.4211800396,
0.4142567515,
0.5172933936,
0.1527729034,
0.3434948921,
-0.1483787,
0.6672093272,
-0.4054902792,
0.4764565527,
-0.0897838846,
-0.4779886603,
-0.421089381,
-0.1214408204,
0.6561897993,
0.1969037205,
-0.2072801739,
0.2259787917,
-0.1887533963,
0.8673261404,
-0.162842229,
0.3853909671,
-0.7854851484,
0.2039818317,
-0.4260058999,
-0.3834002316,
-0.8269934058,
-0.3440182805,
-0.142181322,
-0.6730491519,
0.1447673738,
0.1353015155,
0.2865795493,
0.4786886275,
-0.5204988122,
-0.3072983921,
-0.47283113,
0.6062119007,
-0.6259729266,
0.2053163797,
0.2612793148,
0.1489019543,
-0.6027866602,
-1.0320843458,
-0.7913989425,
-0.112046659,
-0.0790578127,
0.3181856573,
-0.1201831624,
-0.0473096557,
0.4140529931,
0.0494341701,
-0.6131253242,
-0.4800204933,
-0.4687109888,
-0.5041775107,
0.7394845486,
0.2503505647,
0.3688013256,
-0.5288134217,
-0.2500448227,
-0.058556959,
-0.4426108301,
0.1457190812,
0.3872111738,
0.5695897341,
0.080038853,
0.709273994,
-0.2265789211,
0.7688980103,
0.2640210986,
-0.2671371698,
0.0798652247,
-0.4418928921,
-0.0085858265,
0.3861681819,
0.8064867258,
0.1030419618,
0.2765679359,
-0.0563694574,
-0.1082747802,
0.4437843859,
0.3749231696,
-0.5468441844,
-0.2914408743,
0.4035427868,
-0.4442287982,
-0.6620491743,
-0.1500663012,
-0.597448349,
-0.2767832577,
-0.3418859541,
0.4991341233,
-0.4107374549,
-0.0549861118,
0.1432735473,
-0.3862344623,
-0.0918411314,
0.214523986,
-0.6325942278,
0.1586788893,
0.5748963952,
0.8412920237,
-0.3285313845,
-0.2547103465,
-0.8127612472,
0.2679718435,
-0.5745627284,
0.9881615639,
-0.577883482,
-0.4668852091,
-0.1516923159,
-0.3923983276,
-0.0590766333,
-0.3363670707,
0.6850866079,
-0.2335706949,
0.2680273354,
-0.2380272299,
-0.4401548803,
-0.1298592389,
0.284001261,
-0.5493105054,
1.5398511887,
-0.170427084,
-0.8911790848,
0.4536283314,
-0.5458168983,
-1.037173748,
-0.2469163537,
-0.327639401,
-0.2429085821,
0.1901655048,
0.347466439,
0.5639630556,
-0.3132275343,
0.4598680437,
-0.0525503308,
-0.2553741038,
0.1399143934,
-0.4468547106,
0.3386447728,
-0.1978682727,
-0.5664081573,
0.3811930716,
-0.7130651474,
0.2177686989,
-0.089051351,
-0.4411995411,
-0.101924181,
0.3750446141,
-0.196336478,
0.5759811401,
-0.0156422295,
-0.6208500266,
0.16382505,
-0.3321405649,
0.6195757985,
0.8062435985,
0.1487028003,
0.2774305642,
-0.4625160396,
0.075190559,
0.3620941937,
0.3322894275,
-0.3262948096,
-0.9214187264,
-0.6464810371,
-0.1896740645,
-0.0558478869,
0.3899618387,
-0.8298619986,
0.1561255902,
0.0656928644,
-0.4686445892,
-0.3807197511,
-0.3023208976,
0.1809859127,
0.8389663696,
0.6293744445,
0.0097674066,
-0.337267369,
-0.7765367627,
-0.1771616191,
-0.4394260347,
0.3225379288,
0.2864209414,
0.365767628,
-0.0048126183,
0.7649327517,
-0.5106138587,
-0.1326343119,
-0.1345418543,
0.4142473638,
0.2235355973,
0.2906009853,
-0.1562687308,
-0.7216380239,
-0.4750784338,
0.0325426571,
-0.6780288219,
0.0821511969,
-0.2473859042,
-0.4697296321,
0.3207628131,
0.5575906634,
-0.9646250606,
0.4953384399,
0.1687049121,
-0.2738482356,
0.7642459869,
-0.1226669773,
0.18770428,
-1.3693101406,
0.0582666136,
-0.170270443,
-0.2696353197,
-0.618237257,
-0.1775937527,
-0.1739134192,
-0.1668530554,
-0.1677533984,
0.5512050986,
-0.2458509803,
0.0815451816,
-0.1830512881,
0.1637837142,
-0.1953803152,
0.4553923905,
0.0296572056,
0.7053800821,
0.7832989693,
-0.7258591056,
0.3167889416,
0.4357582331,
0.0947383791,
0.5347596407,
-0.6072053313,
0.4383132458,
-0.183272019,
0.6862488389,
-1.0307331085,
-0.2258635014,
0.0719648823,
-0.6643889546,
0.0735115632,
-0.0290533323,
-0.6473847628,
-0.5003361106,
-0.2740007937,
0.3925085068,
0.565079987,
-0.3988474309,
0.6807897091,
0.2924035192,
-0.1828033626,
-0.4207575321,
-0.5896229148,
0.0496057048,
0.054200355,
-0.9159806967,
0.2510975003,
-0.0012367439,
-0.0025296924,
-0.1193119138,
-0.3965590298,
-0.0914062709,
-0.4005069733,
0.1467030197,
0.2287975401,
-0.0883242115,
0.2403804362,
0.5451766253,
-0.4051633477,
0.2089894116,
-0.9325431585,
0.4241479039,
0.076689072,
-0.4583181441,
-0.4554196298,
0.3766146302,
0.6930505633,
-0.2551328242,
0.17609106,
0.522092998,
-0.3678222895,
-0.7609787583,
-0.2085878849,
-0.4775173962,
-0.4437375367,
0.0527789295,
-0.267862618,
-0.8461081982,
0.2371383756,
-0.2282779813,
0.225997448,
0.5956150293,
0.7184674144,
-0.191505149,
1.1482753754,
0.252078712,
0.1204286218,
-0.2121142447,
-0.0384066068,
0.2557945549,
-0.4600948691,
-0.5705705285,
-0.4965893924,
-0.5433449745,
-0.3704020083,
-0.888147831,
0.640004158,
-0.1711099446,
-0.0511235222,
-0.0641077533,
-0.7412469983,
0.2056556791,
0.4553992152,
0.2243705243,
0.5935346484,
0.1686855704,
-0.5171928406,
0.1113523394,
-0.7737843394,
-0.2855282724,
0.9613054395,
-0.1534562409,
0.6497410536,
-0.1430506855,
0.6856857538,
0.4134940207,
0.1054428145,
-0.7820413113,
0.7658296824,
-0.1874992996,
-0.7128439546,
-0.470084995,
-0.5271534324,
-0.6612813473,
0.0175664723,
-0.318695575,
-0.5409171581,
-0.2431060374,
0.4152321219,
-0.0502893738,
0.1811650991,
-0.2927794755,
0.5368304849,
0.0744736344,
-0.3274902701,
-0.4107585549,
-0.6981929541,
0.5376791954,
-0.1453587413,
0.022063205,
0.0877311751,
0.094372578,
0.4215232432,
-0.6350520253,
0.7943483591,
-0.1027981788,
0.1330816448,
0.5858483911,
0.3072760701,
0.8722503781,
0.0905002281,
-0.2177177817,
-0.1539096087,
-0.2141741365,
-0.3312814236,
-0.5683197379,
0.4826926589,
-0.2330616415,
-0.3298687041,
-0.2930259109,
-0.6937465072,
-0.4806451797,
0.2256452292,
0.4635159075,
0.703517139,
0.1681753397,
-0.1177103966,
0.7399578094,
-0.0354931168,
0.3019052446,
0.0684842393,
-0.2886070609,
-0.2265577763,
0.9722626209,
-0.2459548563,
0.1450810283,
0.3752685785,
0.3866836131,
-0.6345614791,
-0.407763958,
-0.8102169037,
0.1212664843,
-0.4639901221,
-0.0593857951,
-0.6894638538,
-0.2121499479,
-0.0361062102,
0.0643919483,
-0.2702367902,
-0.5608876944,
-0.0152068874,
-0.1399207413,
0.4422009289,
0.9321311712,
0.1086290553,
-0.2266640961,
-0.9290431738,
0.3889980614,
0.3489570618,
-0.0394943543,
0.2041100711,
-0.2863183916,
0.1497093588,
-0.128959462,
-0.2006218135,
-1.073336482,
-0.2104136497,
0.1175820008,
0.4259579778,
0.0227993205,
0.0006968857,
0.7225649953,
-0.8161026835,
0.7981757522,
0.2822647095,
-0.9712619185,
0.7534638047,
-0.6239526868,
0.1729717702,
0.4136844277,
0.1781637967,
-0.5493359566,
-0.5317183733,
-0.6414812207,
-0.7657415867,
0.5788827538,
0.5584349632,
0.1230615675,
-0.2497353554,
0.3952188194,
0.1054566577,
0.3098044693,
-0.3167286217,
-0.1974817663,
-0.1223939955,
-0.2481207252,
0.3280248642,
0.2750555277,
-0.0395711996,
-0.3355354667,
0.7219142914,
-0.4248918891,
0.2451841384,
0.5055468678,
0.1131317541,
-0.0563420169,
0.1090006381,
0.5307690501,
0.3552190661,
0.582801044,
0.2191507071,
0.1575945169,
-0.5649536848,
0.1927333772,
-0.0975894406,
-0.4296766818,
0.2100107223,
0.3179426789,
0.6455483437,
0.1209527701,
-0.3926625252,
0.4344680309,
-0.0314615965,
-0.4238429666,
0.2620497644,
0.0621269979,
0.2716816664,
0.2501206696,
0.2151693404,
0.3536397219,
0.2535747886,
-0.4101243317,
0.496071279,
0.1924292296,
-0.4667882323,
-0.3737639487,
0.7206460834,
0.1624196172,
-0.1892506182,
0.804143548,
-0.3152106404,
-0.391511023,
0.3805709779,
0.8242999315,
0.8362367153,
0.083173275,
0.7694455385,
0.4856078327,
0.3313899636,
-0.4074651301,
0.7754353881,
-0.1542433947,
-0.3453031182,
-0.5823424459,
-0.6882473826,
-0.1976976842,
-0.2153359801,
-0.2034407407,
0.2913036644,
-0.3926643431,
-0.2516170144,
-0.154975757,
-0.3983826935,
-0.1432358325,
0.2076317221,
0.0430519432,
1.1724733114,
-0.7517915368,
0.4975738525,
0.80614537,
-0.2219697237,
-1.4382380247,
0.2766573429,
0.2025652677,
-0.555447042,
0.3241187632,
0.0873044729,
-0.191521287,
0.2367344201,
-0.3275384009,
-0.5114581585,
1.0289671421,
0.3357725143,
-0.3051879704,
-0.0474095754,
0.0969865322,
0.5587906241,
-0.0853859112,
0.1462729573,
0.2959670722,
0.7506075501,
0.4473488629,
-0.7217165828,
0.2719034851,
-0.380415082,
-0.259418726,
0.5011321306,
-0.6739556193,
0.9162601829,
-0.3162719905,
-0.195340082,
-0.064583391,
0.6117430925,
0.6858423948,
0.4658687711,
0.4819995165,
0.679635644,
1.2419905663,
-0.0867129713,
0.9769766331,
-0.2362364084,
0.0825861841,
0.7763527632,
-0.135873124,
0.8867536783,
0.3742443025,
0.0245526507,
0.7274496555,
0.5799371004,
0.3526491523,
0.2210701108,
0.3018448651,
-0.2290488482,
-0.4726672173,
-0.0353389643,
-0.1070291921,
0.2917255759,
0.0518880375,
-0.0305174813,
-0.2790493369,
-0.4189394414,
0.0592825972,
0.0374289453,
-0.2271261364,
0.6739977002,
0.1241430342,
-0.9604078531,
0.1532901376,
0.0069837957,
0.2774727046,
-0.6525450945,
-0.2472517788,
-0.2144162357,
-0.2124123871,
-0.50559479,
-0.7621120811,
0.2629464269,
0.2069995552,
-0.3401149213,
-0.078611739,
1.0912691355,
-0.324254483,
-0.5693805218,
0.0218102913,
0.6189593673,
0.264087826,
-0.2235492468,
-0.5860897303,
-0.2127308846,
0.009582445,
-0.2449357957,
-0.069784835,
0.6503525376,
-0.4322046041,
0.4498728216,
1.1337503195,
0.0610879436,
0.3585138917,
0.1409895122,
0.8325602412,
-0.6429306865,
-0.6975877881,
-0.8441355824,
0.8365616798,
-0.2147196978,
-0.5030440092,
0.403535068,
0.7134653926,
0.2332984209,
0.0285171084,
0.8282680511,
-0.1230636761,
0.0728545263,
-0.7019615769,
0.5854552388,
-0.604231298,
-0.1602502316,
-0.2458363622,
-0.9701070786,
-0.1033901423,
0.4813813865,
0.1361112595,
-0.0079110339,
1.1691234112,
0.9057155252,
-0.1251639426,
0.5379033685,
0.1166170835,
0.4409947991,
0.2210107148,
0.452888608,
0.9681463242,
-0.2014312744,
0.5067148209,
0.222644493,
-0.231032297,
0.2869934142,
-0.9032248855,
-0.9763961434,
-0.7516253591,
0.0442401767,
-0.2471188009,
-0.0744827315,
0.5406085253,
0.7993800044,
-0.4163339436,
-0.0170794297,
-0.466008693,
0.0621063188,
-0.1725476533,
-0.187055245,
0.2430086285,
-0.6807656884,
-0.3557018638,
0.7229601741,
0.814648211,
-0.4133229256,
-0.3209485412,
-0.0493417196,
-0.0964493379,
0.3809576333,
0.7652706504,
-0.140562132,
-0.5830467939,
-0.1823035777,
0.2882550061,
-0.1861474961,
-0.0217439532,
0.9840238094,
-0.7524321675,
0.3363513649,
0.8167223334,
0.5171023011,
0.7442290187,
0.0609141327,
0.4993082583,
-0.7563672066,
-0.1742496192,
0.2413156033,
0.0157952756,
0.1135785133,
-0.4665258825,
0.2735782564,
0.4852528572,
-0.4156529009,
-0.599571228,
0.279920131,
-1.1062357426,
-0.1491241157,
1.0588873625,
0.3195800185,
-0.2205464095,
-0.1049068347,
-0.4392794967,
0.3250543773,
-0.4763714373,
0.8169218302,
0.6501269937,
-0.4659808576,
0.437947154,
-0.4259343445,
0.6431097984,
0.3812487423,
-1.2740736008,
0.0559248142,
0.5333780646,
-0.0501151383,
0.1651929468,
0.9113302231,
-0.4105960727,
0.4928809106,
0.1760897785,
-0.390285641,
-0.1476754397,
-0.6918407679,
0.28215909,
0.1934649348,
-0.2497566342,
0.0886769891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08597v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08597v2 | Detecting and Mitigating Hallucinations in Machine Translation: Model Internal Workings Alone Do Well, Sentence Similarity Even Better | 2022-12-16T17:24:49 | 2022-12-20T16:11:02 | David Dale, Elena Voita, Loïc Barrault, Marta R. Costa-jussà | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | While the problem of hallucinations in neural machine translation has long
been recognized, so far the progress on its alleviation is very little. Indeed,
recently it turned out that without artificially encouraging models to
hallucinate, previously existing methods fall short and even the standard
sequence log-probability is more informative. It means that characteristics
internal to the model can give much more information than we expect, and before
using external models and measures, we first need to ask: how far can we go if
we use nothing but the translation model itself ? We propose to use a method
that evaluates the percentage of the source contribution to a generated
translation. Intuitively, hallucinations are translations "detached" from the
source, hence they can be identified by low source contribution. This method
improves detection accuracy for the most severe hallucinations by a factor of 2
and is able to alleviate hallucinations at test time on par with the previous
best approach that relies on external models. Next, if we move away from
internal model characteristics and allow external tools, we show that using
sentence similarity from cross-lingual embeddings further improves these
results. | [
-0.2852449119,
-0.5950893164,
0.7975013852,
0.2075672746,
-0.4338493347,
-0.3298879564,
-0.4208778739,
-0.7783885002,
0.5247503519,
0.8887069821,
-0.4280874431,
-0.2825503945,
-0.8052705526,
0.3437215686,
-0.7611111403,
0.9485607743,
0.1231111735,
0.3505344689,
-0.0653728917,
0.0184909757,
-0.5566574931,
-0.7432801127,
-0.535019815,
-0.2981639802,
0.4328071773,
-0.1059904397,
0.7391471267,
0.4652869701,
0.6686656475,
0.2708876729,
-0.1985020339,
0.3242917955,
-0.4277162552,
0.3421839774,
-0.0371363722,
-0.4689747393,
-0.0567193739,
-0.4001786411,
0.3982383609,
0.7556216121,
-0.0387430899,
-0.2773048282,
0.13554506,
0.6443575025,
-0.2132261395,
-0.0140789645,
-0.7387092113,
0.4701879025,
0.0599228516,
-0.2399750352,
-0.6310027242,
-0.2960655987,
-0.081067197,
-0.2984919548,
0.3448601961,
0.0171849821,
0.5495676994,
0.5033268332,
-0.4317712784,
-0.5212669969,
-0.8179590106,
0.4577541947,
-0.5901338458,
0.5032918453,
0.3824183345,
0.1843938977,
-0.2853135765,
-0.6543933153,
-0.3673955798,
-0.7391781211,
-0.1980758607,
-0.1254237145,
-0.3759294152,
-0.0942101479,
0.3478228152,
0.3327970207,
-0.6968912482,
0.0840597153,
-0.6116046906,
-0.4986112118,
0.4819655418,
0.1751957685,
0.4992653131,
-0.1766075641,
-0.1853648126,
-0.2151122689,
-0.5743188262,
-0.3990994096,
0.4571081102,
0.3006231487,
0.3149435222,
0.7494279742,
-0.0519543402,
0.2376619726,
-0.0854173601,
0.1606874317,
0.2452662438,
-0.1639082134,
-0.1566108912,
0.3219151497,
0.6015414596,
0.4096264243,
0.2574342489,
-0.6219392419,
-0.4209873974,
0.2523679137,
0.7422907948,
-0.7892882228,
-0.3958378136,
0.1470963061,
-0.729324162,
-0.2264340222,
0.1594492197,
-0.7937814593,
-0.7122828364,
-0.2799847126,
0.5248301029,
-0.4690330327,
-0.2617864907,
0.0530913919,
-0.1143592745,
-0.0430880636,
0.1138930097,
-0.5334801674,
0.289265573,
0.5863115191,
1.1029149294,
-0.5700722337,
-0.2140141279,
-0.709369123,
-0.1566428393,
-0.585390687,
0.8326874375,
-0.2788031697,
-0.3288485706,
-0.0368155129,
0.1688778102,
0.1864087284,
-0.8932740688,
0.5873413086,
-0.1436450183,
0.2624977231,
-0.4033643603,
-0.4663717747,
-0.281588614,
0.0114992103,
-0.6644662619,
0.7369514108,
-0.0820225552,
-0.4807842374,
0.0486940667,
-0.3382186592,
-0.6257837415,
-0.2128676027,
0.1575393677,
-0.3794847429,
0.889015615,
0.2596335709,
0.2293151319,
-0.0499221683,
0.2703346908,
-0.2559522986,
-0.375433892,
0.3968975544,
-0.3804659843,
0.783696413,
0.3272526264,
-0.4528583884,
0.3755406737,
-0.4576174617,
-0.2570275366,
0.1204456836,
0.2836821377,
-0.4207629561,
-0.1970175356,
0.0757527798,
0.2386230975,
-0.0782861933,
-0.2782675624,
0.0627005026,
-0.6621385813,
0.1707814038,
0.6400161386,
0.172816664,
0.4549437761,
-0.3215931654,
0.5298703313,
0.2956108451,
0.1365361214,
0.0220976043,
-0.5887924433,
-0.8595422506,
-0.0981911421,
0.0198768657,
0.4229436815,
-0.6203596592,
0.604765892,
0.0954504013,
-0.3999480307,
-0.7400698066,
0.0524695739,
0.2720185518,
0.4302774668,
0.6633589864,
-0.4730229974,
-0.5527250171,
-0.9177153707,
-0.3533855379,
0.0091438238,
-0.2098477185,
-0.2973649502,
0.6437079906,
-0.3302274942,
0.1064308137,
-0.4699845314,
-0.7399629951,
-0.1218813136,
0.0102526611,
0.0213449132,
0.3922493756,
0.4084394276,
-0.6618434191,
-0.2818022072,
0.1357854605,
-0.9725826383,
-0.2122785449,
-0.3335799873,
-0.1173628718,
0.3339725733,
0.5260686874,
-0.7615690231,
0.5493947864,
0.3235586286,
-0.2442569137,
0.4735264182,
-0.353774339,
0.1428434998,
-1.0476995707,
0.0082384404,
-0.3520863354,
-0.0186613109,
-0.6901699901,
0.202021271,
-0.1400880814,
0.0032828699,
-0.1987067163,
0.2955486178,
-0.4312690496,
-0.1102589518,
-0.6968727708,
0.1988258958,
-0.0612562336,
0.282604754,
0.0496900678,
0.4855248928,
0.4523181319,
-0.4391346574,
0.3732977509,
0.114988029,
-0.4443309009,
0.4042890966,
-0.3470899165,
0.3107651174,
-0.1533841044,
0.1538079828,
-0.6511540413,
-0.1531460136,
0.6451352835,
-0.5100556016,
0.1688566357,
0.1579114199,
-0.5770939589,
-0.1089334711,
-0.1673728377,
-0.0843130648,
0.6156557202,
-0.4134556353,
0.5360292792,
0.2503978014,
0.1028435826,
-0.1789627671,
-0.9790284634,
0.4155231416,
-0.3879911005,
-0.3729466498,
0.4575598538,
-0.1681420207,
-0.3605250716,
0.0820435584,
-0.3146104217,
-0.1063889265,
0.1802745759,
0.2322648913,
-0.0521079488,
-0.3114235699,
0.3031809628,
0.1923401356,
-0.1953784376,
0.3933155835,
-0.4411020279,
0.542576313,
0.0678508505,
-0.3990043104,
-0.4282183349,
0.6218206882,
0.5226771832,
-0.0903639197,
0.9240235686,
0.7862861156,
-0.7751081586,
-0.1883077919,
-0.5258632898,
-0.6972745657,
-0.3694245517,
0.5157744288,
-0.5805399418,
-0.3900484443,
0.6577451825,
0.2122079283,
-0.5120387673,
0.4901952147,
0.5860522389,
0.1381634772,
1.2173756361,
0.6764893532,
-0.0365722477,
0.2172949165,
0.0434204116,
0.6070898771,
-0.6906582713,
-0.4877036512,
-0.5708178878,
-0.1715424806,
-0.6704236269,
-0.2604031563,
0.3469444215,
0.1021501347,
0.399414897,
0.4375248849,
-0.7546259761,
0.4330684543,
0.4615715742,
0.1779316664,
0.4134241939,
0.1168521643,
-0.0425858758,
-0.3744209409,
-0.3259492517,
-0.5240048766,
0.7753667235,
0.087042354,
0.4730505943,
-0.0425160639,
0.7471503019,
0.2584905028,
0.2134774178,
-0.731166482,
0.5081000924,
-0.1015256122,
-0.4228992164,
-0.071469456,
-0.6020109653,
-0.6933681965,
0.4521270692,
-0.1459449083,
-0.8646356463,
0.1337269694,
-0.116225481,
-0.1383471042,
0.4725001752,
-0.6131199002,
0.7440610528,
-0.3883889019,
-0.0410006009,
-0.2842352092,
-0.418553561,
0.4085441232,
-0.3027932048,
0.007773893,
0.1296908706,
0.1189328656,
0.541534543,
-0.1867897213,
0.631542027,
-0.0112543087,
-0.2757104039,
0.043108657,
0.421666801,
0.4772186875,
-0.1784528494,
-0.0379810147,
0.3531376123,
-0.0775669739,
-0.0159898195,
-0.8504669666,
0.8005453944,
-0.4846157432,
-0.6389648318,
-0.3870386481,
-0.6506916881,
0.076492615,
0.1781799197,
0.6072478294,
-0.0007622409,
-0.1281344891,
0.3283305466,
0.5381395817,
-0.2586374283,
0.1899719536,
0.1459887624,
-0.6105750203,
-0.4567650259,
0.8592634201,
0.0502467379,
-0.02614397,
0.2606619298,
0.2663366497,
-0.2678268254,
-0.6826562285,
-0.3441301584,
0.2150883079,
-0.8793863654,
-0.110252142,
-0.9040213823,
-0.2393668145,
-0.5794783831,
0.1246541664,
-0.4099863768,
-0.3704547286,
-0.3191016018,
-0.116974622,
0.1776538938,
0.7537516356,
-0.1754584759,
0.0260163918,
-0.7088150978,
0.5957581401,
-0.109228529,
0.003249146,
0.0048982808,
-0.8444860578,
-0.289043963,
0.0927600786,
-0.3295389116,
-1.1403423548,
0.8518491387,
-0.102359876,
0.4332297444,
0.4977926314,
0.2384233326,
0.7823092341,
-0.3191394806,
0.7394234538,
0.0802510455,
-1.0059953928,
0.4494594634,
0.3056742251,
-0.0112324068,
0.3689402938,
0.4687887132,
-0.5584912896,
-0.7516446114,
-0.346411705,
-0.7101613879,
0.373931706,
0.4587732852,
0.275198698,
0.0162814576,
0.2819276452,
0.4408760965,
0.1510236561,
-0.9098034501,
-0.0124302134,
-0.1834344417,
-0.1436674297,
-0.1465505213,
0.0451610237,
-0.015366327,
-0.3625189066,
0.6462526321,
-0.0024482484,
0.3737314343,
0.3139264882,
-0.4021751285,
-0.3069522083,
-0.1041347608,
0.7710603476,
0.3707055151,
-0.1204620227,
0.4165632427,
0.2894561291,
-0.3826264143,
-0.0396690406,
-0.0021541053,
-0.3199495673,
0.2431926131,
0.5070517063,
0.7516028285,
-0.0660648867,
-0.5289825797,
0.3005602658,
0.0333347991,
-0.0346481726,
-0.3827856183,
-0.0099316649,
-0.0299401637,
0.4844228327,
0.2830210626,
0.3177749813,
0.3981140852,
-0.6148964167,
0.227660507,
0.3608590662,
-0.7116082907,
-0.5136446953,
0.6496032476,
-0.1383699924,
-0.7770056129,
0.7601177096,
-0.1209454238,
-0.7815417647,
0.6018637419,
0.7641327381,
1.3647456169,
-0.2522707283,
0.0702643022,
0.2781610191,
0.7831860781,
-0.3555333018,
-0.0042085061,
0.102922678,
-0.47710675,
-0.2757588625,
-0.4017770588,
-0.2790188193,
0.3101193905,
-0.7703961134,
0.2243667394,
0.0756916627,
0.0034537751,
-0.230128482,
-0.271507889,
-0.4193992317,
-0.0664427876,
0.3439730704,
0.4890937805,
-0.9153261781,
0.9603703022,
0.3321247995,
-0.5917782784,
-0.0373201594,
0.4248043895,
-0.2000845373,
-0.3295083642,
0.441806674,
0.6633135676,
-0.2317468673,
-0.1596867889,
-0.3384325206,
-0.5332461596,
0.5240747929,
0.6059685946,
-0.4683906734,
-0.0884119272,
0.1357791573,
0.8204253912,
-0.4088532031,
-0.0250211842,
0.4362532198,
0.5837801099,
-0.1487127542,
-0.6833572388,
0.2458587885,
-0.1785357744,
-0.1040041819,
0.1826908141,
-0.0475548469,
0.4990774691,
-0.3767600954,
-0.3374056816,
0.0879134834,
0.6019974351,
-0.2237859964,
0.4299221337,
0.4698078334,
0.3783003688,
0.9040587544,
0.0457832739,
0.9927095175,
-0.3080870509,
0.0283118971,
1.1951779127,
-0.3503296077,
0.740336895,
0.7920239568,
0.364959836,
0.2403386384,
0.4013148248,
-0.2306531966,
0.7443780899,
0.3112756014,
0.0822710395,
-0.2866412103,
-0.1995109618,
-0.5878722668,
0.3159620762,
0.0975159556,
-0.5859112144,
0.0355166011,
0.4684785008,
-0.1413377374,
0.293677181,
0.1006451249,
0.7505446672,
0.4841372669,
-0.8178995848,
0.4457787275,
-0.0473891199,
0.3587119281,
-0.3242476583,
-0.162264809,
-0.5048843622,
0.2784792185,
-0.0007713098,
-0.3557785153,
0.9726111293,
0.0319196433,
-0.0580142513,
-0.2744139135,
0.569282949,
-0.4530942142,
-0.420766145,
0.8131958246,
0.4080926776,
0.5056980252,
-0.6563709378,
-0.3395002484,
0.1800639927,
-0.0408599637,
0.0337326005,
0.2913647294,
0.6118223071,
-0.1235165894,
0.5047702193,
0.6325728297,
0.3570226431,
0.0796175078,
0.0916119069,
0.6918358803,
-0.8610091805,
-0.3066006601,
-1.0369399786,
0.2381552905,
-0.2096762806,
-0.347063452,
0.7751728296,
0.5127789378,
0.9277042747,
-0.3497898579,
0.3293997645,
0.2619229853,
-0.0454509147,
-0.5652248263,
0.9898284674,
-0.645555675,
0.239272818,
-0.1611393392,
-1.2877057791,
-0.567861259,
0.7379086018,
-0.0557182059,
-0.2698164284,
1.219959259,
1.0088855028,
0.0066662263,
-0.0704747736,
0.6375901103,
0.3454470038,
0.0731883645,
0.5502369404,
1.0655730963,
-0.5265656114,
0.7870494723,
-0.5837107897,
0.2065829635,
-0.3163011074,
-0.7079150677,
-1.0251374245,
-0.7255869508,
-0.4032618701,
-0.4831279516,
0.0894121081,
0.8783681393,
0.5114092827,
-1.0341377258,
-0.0531294979,
-0.1476624459,
0.2775863409,
-0.6202287078,
-0.1779530942,
0.3114630878,
-0.3956755996,
-0.5977805257,
0.5775435567,
0.3184228241,
0.0650175512,
-0.4283822477,
-0.1230598763,
0.3170122504,
0.1123792008,
0.5949565172,
-0.3024186194,
-1.0935152769,
-0.3130947948,
0.2306571901,
-0.2485469133,
0.1223276705,
0.8592028618,
-0.5118908882,
0.6169164777,
0.5025504827,
0.5453591347,
0.4033927321,
-0.361066401,
0.4748311937,
-0.3040297031,
0.212890774,
0.3257145286,
0.2962255478,
0.4308441281,
-0.570290029,
0.6044557095,
0.2204842418,
-0.2715749443,
-1.2152274847,
0.1153809205,
-0.6570988894,
-0.4453788102,
0.8707784414,
0.0333855487,
-0.1876355112,
-0.0759117678,
-0.3681245744,
0.3864325285,
-0.0481438413,
1.4273266792,
0.6998877525,
0.0218847189,
-0.0624300577,
-0.6065126061,
0.4967746139,
0.5804780126,
-0.8679223657,
-0.0395059735,
0.4213487506,
-0.1473539174,
0.4021285772,
0.1926765889,
-0.1184264272,
0.0801657587,
0.085916996,
0.1689560562,
0.0466600768,
-0.6642853618,
-0.6787938476,
0.2342223525,
-0.1208457053,
-0.1794416308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08550v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08550v1 | Fine-grained Czech News Article Dataset: An Interdisciplinary Approach to Trustworthiness Analysis | 2022-12-16T16:00:19 | 2022-12-16T16:00:19 | Matyáš Boháček, Michal Bravanský, Filip Trhlík, Václav Moravec | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7; K.4.0 | We present the Verifee Dataset: a novel dataset of news articles with
fine-grained trustworthiness annotations. We develop a detailed methodology
that assesses the texts based on their parameters encompassing editorial
transparency, journalist conventions, and objective reporting while penalizing
manipulative techniques. We bring aboard a diverse set of researchers from
social, media, and computer sciences to overcome barriers and limited framing
of this interdisciplinary problem. We collect over $10,000$ unique articles
from almost $60$ Czech online news sources. These are categorized into one of
the $4$ classes across the credibility spectrum we propose, raging from
entirely trustworthy articles all the way to the manipulative ones. We produce
detailed statistics and study trends emerging throughout the set. Lastly, we
fine-tune multiple popular sequence-to-sequence language models using our
dataset on the trustworthiness classification task and report the best testing
F-1 score of $0.52$. We open-source the dataset, annotation methodology, and
annotators' instructions in full length at https://verifee.ai/research to
enable easy build-up work. We believe similar methods can help prevent
disinformation and educate in the realm of media literacy. | [
-0.2299136072,
-0.9865465164,
0.7222797275,
0.1909344792,
-0.2647668719,
0.1834558547,
-0.2962728143,
-0.7175678611,
-0.011686529,
0.5073447227,
-0.4018273056,
-0.6216033101,
-0.6849479675,
0.0538673401,
-0.3808283806,
1.2594304085,
-0.0264602471,
0.3201639354,
-0.2643466294,
-0.0572089963,
-0.1454721391,
-0.3420164585,
-0.2564327717,
-0.2181102633,
0.3383900821,
0.5017258525,
0.5759363174,
0.7265702486,
0.5404676199,
0.2253215313,
-0.0080008507,
0.0669386238,
-0.7020324469,
0.0951610357,
-0.5249217749,
-0.3800162375,
-0.2418804765,
0.158344999,
0.3335737288,
0.4127877355,
0.1570974886,
0.5732319951,
0.2216788232,
0.7345721722,
-0.4836530983,
0.0118125034,
-0.8121978641,
-0.0935589224,
-0.4336007237,
-0.1475021392,
-0.5613090396,
-0.6210135221,
0.0140475016,
-0.689315021,
-0.1894903928,
0.1584256887,
1.2172957659,
0.1102955416,
-0.2093805969,
-0.0476800017,
-0.8918340206,
0.7657835484,
-0.347594291,
0.0902533159,
0.6300929189,
0.2408835292,
-0.0762343779,
-0.6887106299,
-0.3195018172,
-0.1978418678,
0.0477707572,
0.034889821,
-0.436083436,
-0.4490798712,
-0.0313425437,
0.565846324,
-0.4040513635,
-0.0335590132,
-0.5192052722,
-0.5489186049,
0.5565256476,
0.1910744756,
0.0070597553,
-0.0034745249,
-0.6513363719,
0.0680530667,
-0.55420959,
0.0664748102,
0.7665631175,
0.2795066833,
-0.1216319501,
0.7533718944,
-0.7166419029,
0.5287650228,
0.2538043559,
-0.0935183764,
0.3161891401,
-0.9536135793,
-0.0922240838,
0.2520498633,
0.7017781138,
0.5105024576,
0.2950898111,
-0.2016766816,
0.0923117474,
0.2427304387,
0.5453259349,
-0.5859385729,
-0.3753237724,
0.1298155189,
-0.4025940895,
-0.83579427,
0.2180231065,
-0.6760479808,
-0.3553594649,
-0.5596312284,
0.7827371955,
-0.610458374,
0.0788873881,
0.0865987316,
-0.088187255,
-0.0551393069,
0.423538655,
-0.3766434193,
0.3281140029,
0.5977166295,
0.7465884089,
-0.0552031323,
-0.235260725,
-0.4376717806,
-0.0534131341,
-0.1436484307,
1.0034430027,
-0.5333967209,
0.0604344383,
0.1114200428,
-0.0358597264,
0.3548489809,
-0.0508591831,
0.8806919456,
-0.4417962432,
0.1572102904,
-0.3657850027,
-0.5806595683,
-0.1432401091,
0.5794993639,
-0.7707485557,
0.9711130261,
0.4163194001,
-0.9815071225,
0.7245363593,
-0.0354038998,
-0.2935184538,
-0.1834044755,
-0.0801595449,
-0.3727957606,
0.0167632885,
-0.0049694106,
0.3433983624,
-0.0145304799,
0.2345220596,
-0.5809161663,
-0.1883023232,
0.3507525027,
-0.7196054459,
0.9010170102,
0.1873949468,
-0.1198741123,
-0.0824565515,
-1.0480239391,
0.0933681279,
-0.3407231569,
-0.4396744967,
-0.6966286898,
-0.3237878382,
0.338917613,
0.1770872325,
0.607489109,
-0.6472323537,
-0.1343260705,
-0.0920066461,
0.1417947561,
0.6124250293,
-0.0172239747,
0.4072580338,
-0.4013093114,
0.0039246827,
0.1350536197,
0.5161352158,
-0.1753576547,
-0.100749515,
-0.1949564517,
-0.3035257757,
0.3134841621,
0.5945930481,
-0.53404212,
0.4461887479,
-0.2238821983,
-0.7558459044,
-0.466165483,
0.132206127,
0.4895810783,
0.447372824,
0.3104505241,
-0.1698004007,
-0.3175537586,
-1.1519676447,
-0.5087997317,
-0.1072382405,
0.0394264348,
-0.048130732,
0.4060488045,
0.255630821,
1.0334233046,
-0.1583472937,
-0.2333534807,
0.2478441745,
0.3691468239,
-0.0392814614,
0.5155320168,
0.5944479108,
-0.7759051323,
-0.4406915307,
0.2932213247,
-0.5396199226,
0.0486809723,
0.0252051037,
-0.1333949268,
0.3008950353,
0.1606302708,
-0.4358046353,
0.4494209588,
0.5832796097,
-0.8177155852,
0.7996178269,
0.0322246552,
0.4921587408,
-1.1928366423,
0.0067662075,
0.2240098566,
-0.3485917747,
-0.4621399939,
-0.0837167352,
-0.1939828843,
0.41806826,
-0.547208786,
0.3598587513,
-0.1303807944,
0.0815047622,
-0.1735524833,
0.0870773196,
0.2547853291,
0.1380521208,
-0.2887563407,
0.5486367345,
0.5500685573,
-0.4199084938,
0.2193466723,
0.2104075551,
-0.5034989715,
0.9750810862,
-0.3766264915,
-0.2984350622,
0.1496986151,
0.0532656014,
-0.6893540621,
-0.2607131302,
0.4895781875,
-0.6028907895,
0.1597248316,
0.0230358131,
-0.4983592033,
-0.025319716,
-0.6539888978,
0.1827918142,
-0.047970444,
-0.3777886927,
0.3486969471,
0.4704096019,
-0.3374106288,
-0.6870085001,
-0.6616231799,
0.1165131405,
-0.2574996352,
-0.6318503022,
0.1640211046,
-0.0732971579,
-0.5992019773,
0.4712020457,
-0.3731053174,
-0.7614377141,
0.1405890435,
0.053538356,
0.3451147377,
-0.2119978517,
-0.1116724983,
0.225803107,
-0.0798690096,
0.152171433,
-0.156490624,
0.2668069601,
-0.3385185897,
0.0334682539,
-0.5287075639,
0.268186897,
0.4010095894,
0.0052614999,
0.5855749846,
0.7758792043,
-0.4877978861,
-0.0323185548,
-0.5736852288,
-0.3235708177,
-0.4023526311,
0.2162847817,
0.0153495055,
-1.0591441393,
0.6604394913,
-0.0488518365,
-0.016235169,
0.525944829,
0.4879160225,
0.1708708405,
0.3724506795,
0.646884799,
-0.4163956642,
0.1986367404,
0.1848329604,
0.0388890281,
0.0763203651,
-0.2736348212,
-0.8944257498,
0.0283535309,
-0.5070557594,
-0.1870696098,
0.0314079113,
-0.0034567355,
-0.1769053042,
0.4433320761,
-0.4587183297,
0.6447892785,
0.4878905118,
0.2210713774,
0.8706882596,
0.2330934256,
0.301469326,
-0.0830292404,
-0.3318674862,
-0.9192445874,
1.1029708385,
0.3975153267,
0.8462865949,
-0.2979509532,
0.5471836925,
0.5264053941,
0.2379776835,
-0.6087195277,
0.2446133196,
-0.012860937,
-0.8892292976,
-0.4566117525,
-0.2499960214,
-0.4272271693,
-0.2869031131,
-0.5378687978,
-1.1003770828,
0.2866840661,
0.1440676153,
-0.3478640318,
0.112356253,
-0.3316527307,
0.6014273763,
0.1150169894,
-0.6986845136,
-0.4669724703,
-0.6535972953,
0.7197293043,
-0.4701570868,
0.1736725271,
-0.1969031692,
0.1887374669,
0.4379803836,
-0.242666021,
0.7312529683,
0.200673297,
0.0202759951,
0.3635808229,
-0.0100714071,
0.4462174177,
0.5212609768,
-0.1010024399,
0.6083199978,
0.2395744324,
-0.3652898669,
-0.1868903041,
0.767726481,
-0.5079920888,
-0.1830641031,
-0.4711891711,
-0.3462938368,
-0.1660936177,
0.4277389348,
0.4412824214,
0.4162816703,
-0.5540496111,
0.4226923883,
0.8606743813,
0.2767966986,
0.1953797787,
0.4731286764,
0.1578668058,
-0.612880826,
0.8102389574,
0.2679609656,
-0.0081492672,
0.2608036399,
0.0307999272,
0.0156408045,
-0.6488722563,
-0.3698531687,
-0.1592663378,
-0.3706566393,
-0.4513092637,
-0.3410162926,
-0.244230628,
0.0671172142,
-0.2141097039,
-0.7384287119,
-0.5366495252,
-0.1639598608,
-0.2854580879,
0.6328654289,
0.6558881402,
-0.0857707709,
0.2851589322,
-0.6900142431,
-0.0636511445,
-0.1165775582,
0.4932073355,
-0.6386496425,
-0.2162479907,
-0.8061643243,
0.0461751036,
-0.4632241428,
-0.6281684637,
-0.1334825307,
-0.3360620141,
0.4035197198,
0.451259464,
0.4193069339,
0.4183627367,
-0.6588945389,
0.9643114209,
0.0155114615,
-1.0305057764,
0.1733761728,
-0.5848432183,
-0.364249438,
1.3210818768,
0.4491707385,
0.2288756222,
-0.9310055375,
-0.7420712113,
-0.9777212143,
0.4445991516,
0.4403866827,
0.1809649616,
0.1660810709,
0.314866215,
0.6125915647,
0.2812412083,
-0.5696769953,
-0.2248981297,
-0.3038327992,
-0.2981473505,
0.2586694956,
-0.3488944173,
-0.5473306775,
-0.1854221225,
0.8090119362,
0.0740047097,
0.0023299851,
0.3671133816,
0.1168936342,
-0.1611195207,
0.2670770288,
0.5716632009,
0.8815154433,
-0.0721667707,
0.0827383474,
-0.0252121445,
-0.7576587796,
0.0718854889,
0.2328798771,
-0.2043608874,
0.2672209144,
0.194214955,
0.3186671138,
0.2523938715,
-0.363445431,
0.58409971,
-0.1504165381,
-0.5321792364,
-0.6749019027,
-0.0341434516,
-0.1412858963,
0.4236546159,
0.3662093282,
0.2413595766,
0.4346085191,
-0.2638731003,
0.5969635844,
0.3198139668,
-0.4101931751,
-0.5013588071,
0.5710794926,
0.0347631238,
0.0696668625,
0.1335337013,
0.0768180862,
0.0073864171,
0.2202988267,
0.1849590093,
0.6169539094,
-0.0917215943,
0.5220072865,
0.2000829577,
0.6050933599,
-0.543277204,
0.2740013003,
0.089388527,
-0.7344080806,
-0.4899153709,
-0.4759810269,
-0.4769000411,
0.2931643724,
-0.8044555187,
0.3592232168,
-0.3679914474,
-0.2667494714,
0.1220078468,
0.5004913211,
-0.4823405743,
0.2755140364,
0.0306078158,
1.1726168394,
-1.1203434467,
0.7338970304,
0.6168996096,
-0.2946261764,
-0.7224696279,
0.1596968472,
0.1083589867,
-0.3627320826,
0.1843256205,
0.0265805013,
-0.1102423817,
-0.2567689717,
-0.8246435523,
-0.7123476267,
1.0410019159,
0.4903587997,
-0.5279499888,
0.3213533163,
0.0002578263,
0.3594661057,
-0.3041259646,
-0.0849833786,
0.6096534729,
0.9351696372,
-0.4631007612,
-0.8517374396,
0.0594349056,
-0.206032455,
-0.352252692,
-0.1044940352,
-0.8009536266,
0.6917615533,
0.2019820958,
0.0408492014,
0.1071365103,
0.6187120676,
0.0889917612,
1.0468291044,
0.297400713,
0.5853480101,
0.8256164193,
-0.010024433,
0.6737626195,
-0.5058660507,
0.4176867008,
1.2000943422,
-0.014491355,
0.747451067,
0.5440666676,
0.0909711719,
0.5365404487,
0.463055104,
-0.1655073762,
0.5846369863,
-0.1925925165,
-0.2635537684,
-0.4327741265,
-0.2773626745,
-0.1254150718,
0.5368903875,
0.0458658077,
-0.4962650836,
-0.3765815794,
0.0184112508,
0.5284329653,
0.5774888396,
-0.2841655314,
0.5248035789,
0.0255093481,
-0.1580606997,
-0.2459688485,
-0.2409160286,
0.3837708533,
-0.4427738786,
0.1153708324,
0.118936114,
0.062772654,
-0.2541181147,
-0.9368209839,
0.5799341202,
0.0631121844,
-0.4202121198,
0.1331319958,
0.9509536624,
-0.4273116887,
-0.5203807354,
0.0546986386,
0.615655303,
-0.0169789791,
0.043065805,
-0.3429846764,
0.387485981,
-0.2576907873,
-0.6143803596,
0.4026426375,
0.857311666,
-0.1077876464,
0.2912774086,
0.5006939173,
0.0219085999,
-0.3551049531,
-0.4149862528,
1.0943969488,
-0.4666813314,
-0.5062279105,
-0.9515029788,
0.698536694,
-0.4582834542,
-0.5324071646,
1.1817384958,
0.7217455506,
1.0942780972,
-0.0705043897,
0.8242154717,
0.0577679984,
0.3279727399,
-0.5467101932,
0.9400603175,
-0.2495797276,
-0.0503769927,
-0.4638161361,
-0.5495666862,
-0.3836762011,
0.4438832104,
-0.1094811484,
-0.333824873,
0.6716358066,
0.620347023,
0.0646912605,
0.3234349787,
0.2108091861,
0.2460354418,
-0.116025351,
0.1574012488,
0.6317061186,
-0.2139345556,
0.5340789557,
-0.5344204307,
-0.1826600581,
-0.295001924,
-1.0522097349,
-0.9604448676,
-0.5473780632,
-0.3926315904,
-0.5418635607,
0.325997144,
0.7074418068,
0.550937891,
-0.6248555779,
0.301168561,
-0.0334230773,
0.2227422148,
-0.449973613,
-0.2771500349,
0.0632012635,
-0.2824260294,
-0.5907392502,
0.1253238022,
0.1698131263,
-0.2228496075,
-0.331425041,
0.1590487957,
0.1952816099,
0.1973271221,
0.5622878075,
0.1635820866,
-0.347189337,
-0.7110478878,
-0.1206995547,
-0.2378141731,
0.0003433883,
0.6422986388,
-0.6999152899,
0.1870821565,
0.4187626541,
0.5649613738,
0.1071490496,
0.1915283352,
0.3432732821,
-0.5197422504,
-0.0082017025,
0.1078579202,
0.1358278841,
0.1875061989,
-0.7805851698,
0.3071255684,
0.1095584407,
-0.7290548086,
-0.9271603227,
-0.0794345513,
-1.3269773722,
-0.244855389,
0.9894518256,
-0.2544734478,
-0.6044130325,
-0.4209347963,
-0.106684044,
0.1225839779,
-0.683483839,
1.0917059183,
1.079811573,
0.1708358973,
0.331602633,
-0.4964717925,
0.4796816707,
-0.0697756186,
-0.7840344906,
0.3302038014,
0.8371255994,
0.458679527,
0.3966960907,
0.3762692511,
-0.3791992664,
0.3390967846,
0.2181081176,
-0.083998844,
-0.3887065053,
-0.7008716464,
-0.3256834149,
0.344183445,
-0.0210613236,
-0.068005532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08542v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08542v2 | Context-aware Fine-tuning of Self-supervised Speech Models | 2022-12-16T15:46:15 | 2023-03-28T21:20:11 | Suwon Shon, Felix Wu, Kwangyoun Kim, Prashant Sridhar, Karen Livescu, Shinji Watanabe | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Self-supervised pre-trained transformers have improved the state of the art
on a variety of speech tasks. Due to the quadratic time and space complexity of
self-attention, they usually operate at the level of relatively short (e.g.,
utterance) segments. In this paper, we study the use of context, i.e.,
surrounding segments, during fine-tuning and propose a new approach called
context-aware fine-tuning. We attach a context module on top of the last layer
of a pre-trained model to encode the whole segment into a context embedding
vector which is then used as an additional feature for the final prediction.
During the fine-tuning stage, we introduce an auxiliary loss that encourages
this context embedding vector to be similar to context vectors of surrounding
segments. This allows the model to make predictions without access to these
surrounding segments at inference time and requires only a tiny overhead
compared to standard fine-tuned models. We evaluate the proposed approach using
the SLUE and Libri-light benchmarks for several downstream tasks: Automatic
speech recognition (ASR), named entity recognition (NER), and sentiment
analysis (SA). The results show that context-aware fine-tuning not only
outperforms a standard fine-tuning baseline but also rivals a strong context
injection baseline that uses neighboring speech segments during inference. | [
-0.9102567434,
-0.5607990026,
0.4385580719,
0.1210171655,
-0.3399529755,
-0.4572470784,
-0.4120747149,
-0.5056557655,
-0.0381752811,
0.5111753345,
-0.7767464519,
-0.2951765358,
-0.2239846587,
-0.0460226201,
-0.3920429945,
0.7097599506,
0.2658916116,
-0.1757512987,
-0.2735257447,
-0.2498435676,
-0.8261699677,
-0.5286905766,
-0.5213269591,
-0.1693951339,
0.5270715952,
0.4190879166,
0.3585255146,
0.8894274235,
-0.0581014752,
0.3196407557,
-0.1120233089,
0.1260988414,
-0.2875320017,
0.1074118167,
-0.4942243993,
-0.0910235271,
-0.3406369388,
0.0606332906,
0.5344212651,
0.4814387858,
-0.0223873667,
0.2767951787,
0.3346600831,
0.4778253436,
-0.8578135371,
-0.053511411,
-0.813503921,
-0.0154182138,
-0.2038620263,
-0.3777267635,
-0.1523159146,
0.2680597901,
0.1934391111,
-0.4892554879,
0.3390166163,
-0.0105052637,
0.4419880807,
0.9290196896,
-0.2480270416,
-0.0224548429,
-0.6342622042,
0.6806012392,
-0.5016039014,
0.5907304883,
0.382674545,
0.3880986273,
-0.0202178564,
-0.558891058,
-0.4727925658,
0.100071311,
-0.2959447801,
0.1841422915,
-0.1812143624,
0.2753508687,
0.131679669,
0.1817061454,
-0.1636015475,
0.1831421107,
-0.1774605811,
-0.3108658791,
0.4154471457,
-0.0416864306,
-0.1340829581,
-0.150401175,
-0.4291814268,
0.1319451928,
-0.5896769762,
0.1059963927,
-0.048111178,
0.4680904448,
-0.0544370115,
0.2653675377,
-0.6983221769,
0.7954485416,
0.4559615552,
0.1807778478,
0.0826925263,
-0.3372870088,
-0.398547262,
0.4173685312,
0.4081492722,
0.3764431775,
0.3035162687,
0.0070458166,
-0.2242898345,
0.0324437767,
0.2399456352,
-0.726142168,
-0.3862702847,
0.1535919458,
-0.1292899102,
0.1039773375,
-0.3578768969,
-0.149985835,
0.0900727138,
-0.795953095,
0.7310506105,
-0.3126976192,
0.1756397933,
-0.0474649705,
0.2924194336,
0.165796563,
0.2872182131,
-0.8554122448,
-0.0000554574,
0.6660405397,
0.7029447556,
-0.1384554803,
-0.2521058321,
-0.9039108753,
0.4282358587,
-0.0694232285,
0.8240567446,
-0.3989596069,
-0.2990889251,
-0.3066776097,
0.0395079926,
-0.0605269521,
-0.4075494707,
0.6755982637,
-0.2519338727,
0.0431058519,
0.0413442999,
-0.7455766201,
-0.0364671536,
-0.0463512279,
-0.1819738448,
0.8012239337,
-0.0855005756,
-0.6468513012,
0.3648881614,
-0.4104602337,
-0.6502328515,
-0.0849308297,
-0.2676789761,
-0.4738465846,
0.3085126281,
0.5965329409,
0.7747703195,
0.3001801968,
0.12691468,
-0.3254640698,
-0.3703423738,
-0.1220335215,
-0.2279070616,
0.2277694643,
0.2441516519,
-0.318254143,
0.4909096956,
-0.7302783728,
0.1664096713,
-0.3950167596,
-0.0185704157,
-0.5151059031,
0.0214583129,
-0.041505836,
0.1717417985,
0.288064003,
-0.4606954157,
-0.0846692771,
-0.4907071292,
0.5520207882,
0.7576599121,
0.0417497493,
0.6519750953,
-0.0115713403,
0.1577949971,
0.0483627766,
0.2145861089,
-0.3919682503,
-0.0423190333,
-0.8910130858,
-0.3125379682,
0.4315701723,
0.2167072743,
-0.3464582264,
0.634257257,
-0.0719465092,
-0.4056366384,
-0.5542887449,
-0.0296212286,
0.3598478138,
0.9153947234,
0.6695639491,
-0.0012988016,
-0.6173557639,
-1.0409127474,
-0.3395359516,
0.4663440585,
-0.1099795327,
0.6383901834,
0.1536577791,
-0.3630096018,
1.1193008423,
-0.3087721467,
-0.6716339588,
0.1857512444,
-0.1433667094,
-0.1044457331,
0.8722067475,
0.3572692275,
-0.5783701539,
-0.4474779963,
-0.1248118281,
-0.149887532,
-0.1896966845,
-0.1042676046,
-0.1080752835,
0.0380585194,
0.8366057277,
-0.1025717631,
0.2934092879,
0.484382093,
-0.2231478244,
0.2070610523,
-0.2574596107,
-0.2262351215,
-0.9260718226,
-0.1369210929,
-0.0971788839,
-0.489295274,
-0.7440561056,
-0.375359863,
0.35424757,
0.0890276358,
-0.4741161466,
0.4988340735,
-0.3306509554,
-0.1796690822,
-0.5264498591,
0.1568674147,
0.0888506696,
0.4287847281,
0.1508485675,
1.0376610756,
0.6456284523,
-0.8055056334,
-0.3045444787,
0.15620704,
-0.4294007421,
0.5164411664,
-0.6977627873,
0.1817385554,
-0.0262728427,
0.1515627056,
-0.7276027799,
-0.1696494818,
-0.0977229029,
-0.2895146906,
0.2684972882,
-0.2687996626,
-0.0945098847,
0.0160258245,
0.2236860096,
0.5471075773,
0.3872872591,
-0.6610168219,
0.531964004,
0.5279812813,
0.039159894,
-0.3152152896,
-0.4670630097,
-0.1690726727,
-0.5081811547,
-0.4968031347,
0.8037877679,
-0.0281172059,
0.3383999765,
-0.2679789066,
-0.3883798718,
-0.0026636049,
0.2264049649,
0.3408603668,
-0.291757524,
-0.1450583041,
0.1750599593,
0.3969557583,
-0.2729810774,
-0.1686610579,
-0.3474754095,
0.3924015462,
-0.1927628666,
-0.1948911399,
-0.6008802652,
0.2276199907,
0.2503326535,
-0.5657680035,
0.176607132,
0.8215127587,
-0.3225269318,
-0.2899516523,
-0.736010015,
-0.4066704512,
-0.5592258573,
0.1443229467,
-0.5890837312,
-1.3396270275,
0.4456070065,
-0.0521190464,
-0.3001600206,
0.4220675826,
0.4254895449,
-0.2596695423,
1.1240813732,
0.724581182,
-0.1625666618,
0.7738481164,
-0.2116011977,
0.0667351484,
-1.2301979065,
-0.0450309478,
-0.4920800626,
-0.2010626942,
-0.5815231204,
-0.3645550907,
0.5645517707,
0.2744747698,
-0.1192247197,
0.5452139378,
-0.5748410225,
0.4625445008,
0.6642987728,
0.0025437535,
0.1334647089,
-0.1548322141,
0.0619515255,
0.0209745169,
-0.7965919375,
-0.1718584299,
0.4539609849,
0.2819379568,
0.4989100099,
-0.4797553718,
0.7780665755,
0.2160933465,
-0.0370603055,
-0.6870442033,
0.3218197525,
-0.1240812391,
-0.478756398,
-0.5023220778,
-0.2202090174,
-0.8204020858,
0.3953150809,
-0.0496487021,
-0.7169822454,
0.3550293446,
0.5440906286,
-0.9146739841,
-0.2770421207,
-0.6397228837,
0.9569442272,
-0.1172155961,
-0.3705025017,
-0.5275297165,
-0.6242234707,
-0.1269904971,
0.0891532972,
0.2080038637,
-0.5192558765,
0.2606498599,
0.5151885748,
-0.1031708866,
0.7251175046,
-0.3774260581,
-0.0959761366,
0.207427159,
-0.0931392387,
0.1384595931,
0.3134354055,
0.0752728954,
0.1753271669,
0.1703713387,
-0.1579868197,
-0.5230278373,
0.8851268888,
-0.5823128819,
-0.6587767005,
-0.118256934,
-0.2624104321,
-0.4667606652,
0.3665867746,
0.3252753019,
0.7428544164,
0.0206707586,
0.4299044013,
0.4209418595,
0.0198486149,
0.5321136713,
0.4555557668,
0.1400555223,
-0.2566061318,
0.8249776959,
0.1433476061,
0.0307275709,
0.196402058,
0.3223781586,
-0.4430850446,
-0.5865864754,
-0.3796877265,
-0.0899587274,
-0.5606472492,
-0.3527023792,
-0.5607031584,
-0.1865083575,
-0.4527027905,
-0.1812490225,
-0.6613600254,
-0.1661392152,
-0.4925065637,
0.1375492066,
0.0529200695,
0.2797056437,
-0.1411873102,
0.550668776,
-0.4985417724,
0.2504500151,
0.4544059038,
0.569927454,
-0.157421276,
-0.6625444889,
-0.5243442059,
0.1373787224,
-0.0201733354,
-0.3476694524,
0.25570333,
0.5394217372,
0.5026685596,
0.3512140512,
0.1428471655,
1.0859792233,
-0.7586833835,
0.4359063804,
-0.1635888815,
-1.0858635902,
0.8170078397,
-0.4187712073,
0.5764566064,
0.7458885908,
-0.1154728606,
-0.3207716942,
-0.1297120452,
-0.2792817354,
-0.6536041498,
0.5772371292,
0.2211311311,
0.1849927008,
0.0306887422,
0.4088739753,
-0.0356820524,
0.0903705731,
-0.4042401314,
-0.1794338375,
-0.4698985517,
0.0359563977,
-0.3949956894,
-0.1497262418,
0.0412881784,
-0.6829029918,
0.4260032773,
-0.3256144226,
0.0758166462,
0.5833624601,
-0.1631111354,
0.0710132197,
0.3149651289,
0.6269874573,
0.3349695504,
-0.0908802897,
0.1075596735,
0.4668967426,
0.097912848,
-0.1509507746,
0.1422616243,
-0.0596958175,
-0.284584105,
0.0865523517,
1.0168539286,
0.6816294789,
-0.2926659584,
0.3483804166,
-0.0589212663,
0.1075151265,
-0.5710567832,
0.3833125234,
-0.0051697404,
0.3939575553,
0.1937738061,
0.1339255273,
0.5110648274,
-0.2544848323,
0.3925228119,
0.461892128,
-0.7109469771,
-0.2015463263,
0.6210117936,
0.3060088456,
-0.1155277267,
0.1610289663,
0.0322135203,
-0.3739436567,
0.4119791389,
0.4695022106,
0.869086206,
-0.3121052086,
-0.3176124394,
0.2574061751,
-0.0850062743,
0.3023585975,
0.0786831304,
-0.5382865071,
-0.6429258585,
-0.5813980103,
-0.8050832748,
-0.1985524148,
0.0817141086,
-0.60596627,
0.1868899167,
-0.1653105617,
-0.2401013374,
0.1898003817,
-0.2518673539,
-0.6512113214,
0.5757710934,
0.3113654256,
0.7307548523,
-0.3048062027,
1.0658471584,
0.460837543,
0.2171824127,
-0.697573781,
0.116628617,
-0.4177923501,
-0.4592932463,
0.1666680127,
0.6802294254,
-0.5692620873,
0.3240207136,
-0.3221483231,
-1.0473579168,
0.9055762887,
0.2213324755,
-0.8163669705,
0.0801116973,
-0.1546491086,
0.5572526455,
-0.5717839003,
-0.104277119,
0.6426500082,
0.324875772,
-0.1508282423,
-0.9426673651,
-0.1152789518,
0.1846459806,
0.0684086159,
-0.0941793546,
-0.721446991,
0.7169165015,
0.1487993449,
-0.353343308,
-0.0923784375,
1.0449386835,
-0.1835127175,
0.3492897749,
0.8950068951,
0.2895052433,
0.4118213952,
-0.0968232527,
0.6289228797,
-0.793845892,
0.3350411355,
1.4139995575,
0.0982713401,
0.8435628414,
0.3497540057,
0.3580993116,
0.2685670853,
0.4396809936,
0.1442565918,
0.9121874571,
-0.0941313803,
-0.0149861882,
-0.5684326291,
-0.1624161601,
-0.4436389208,
0.9819382429,
0.4254492819,
-0.1409425437,
0.0039004309,
0.236105293,
-0.4094867408,
0.0650253594,
-0.5746095777,
0.9490802884,
0.2237533778,
-0.8010561466,
0.5705633759,
-0.0760160238,
0.6497948766,
-0.1642008871,
0.310385257,
-0.0087257354,
0.2095002234,
-0.2133964002,
-0.5437943935,
0.5389671326,
-0.2800536752,
-0.1015140265,
-0.2037346065,
0.8537200093,
-0.5367942452,
-0.1160494834,
0.287760973,
0.2686618268,
-0.2978105843,
-0.6250984669,
-0.4904261529,
-0.0502298176,
-0.1049086377,
-0.2463184744,
0.23401016,
0.2545239031,
0.1177555472,
0.572424829,
0.4097766876,
-0.3907611072,
0.0634169579,
0.2117041647,
0.8136859536,
-0.584137857,
-0.8286504149,
-0.7491404414,
0.3499943614,
0.0096877757,
-0.3601327837,
0.7675246596,
0.4820193648,
0.9913776517,
0.0382867269,
0.5565719008,
0.3651610315,
0.7242357731,
-0.5890636444,
0.7640557885,
-0.6836729646,
-0.2498302013,
-0.2856859267,
-0.7048296332,
-0.0836953819,
0.7443164587,
-0.3543321788,
0.0162485186,
0.1792121083,
0.5847030878,
-0.4247762561,
0.0330961719,
0.5794457793,
0.0842011571,
0.0712713152,
0.0751899332,
0.5779883265,
-0.1503652185,
0.2399019897,
-0.6093574762,
0.0725145489,
-0.3905539513,
-0.7533857822,
-0.9600800872,
-0.6520584822,
-0.2073851824,
0.1674228609,
-0.0810597613,
0.6780694127,
1.2167985439,
-0.9589338899,
0.1346538365,
-0.0225734934,
-0.2228687108,
-0.0105444659,
-0.1569842398,
0.2302014381,
-0.4517675042,
-0.6595858335,
0.8208212852,
0.3090196252,
0.1383567899,
-0.3185350299,
0.1324257106,
0.1437859535,
0.0269627906,
0.7086623907,
0.0241128132,
-0.8969179392,
-0.7841815948,
-0.1466389596,
0.1076810658,
0.2192876339,
0.7186422348,
-1.0519858599,
0.5273367763,
0.1611034721,
0.5746403337,
0.7645484209,
0.4144981205,
0.5580206513,
-1.0509622097,
0.1467354745,
0.2102986276,
0.5214136839,
0.4100814164,
-0.3954064846,
0.2832204998,
-0.2195965499,
-0.6524097323,
-0.5542294979,
0.377605617,
-0.9491204619,
-0.1336328238,
0.6829521656,
0.0110993534,
-0.0710417852,
0.0623168163,
-0.3715299368,
0.5890651941,
-0.4471030533,
0.7957331538,
0.2999253273,
-0.3178606033,
-0.1322504282,
-0.357761085,
0.7707757354,
0.7744802237,
-0.5389757752,
0.1742388159,
0.4837878048,
0.2937845886,
0.0472325645,
0.3205749094,
0.3866147697,
0.0715370476,
-0.4674426913,
-0.2967015803,
-0.2393959612,
-0.6199045181,
-0.5145636201,
0.0879924148,
-0.2181849778,
-0.299939543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08514v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08514v1 | Check-worthy Claim Detection across Topics for Automated Fact-checking | 2022-12-16T14:54:56 | 2022-12-16T14:54:56 | Amani S. Abumansour, Arkaitz Zubiaga | cs.CL | cs.CL | An important component of an automated fact-checking system is the claim
check-worthiness detection system, which ranks sentences by prioritising them
based on their need to be checked. Despite a body of research tackling the
task, previous research has overlooked the challenging nature of identifying
check-worthy claims across different topics. In this paper, we assess and
quantify the challenge of detecting check-worthy claims for new, unseen topics.
After highlighting the problem, we propose the AraCWA model to mitigate the
performance deterioration when detecting check-worthy claims across topics. The
AraCWA model enables boosting the performance for new topics by incorporating
two components for few-shot learning and data augmentation. Using a publicly
available dataset of Arabic tweets consisting of 14 different topics, we
demonstrate that our proposed data augmentation strategy achieves substantial
improvements across topics overall, where the extent of the improvement varies
across topics. Further, we analyse the semantic similarities between topics,
suggesting that the similarity metric could be used as a proxy to determine the
difficulty level of an unseen topic prior to undertaking the task of labelling
the underlying sentences. | [
-0.5585628152,
-0.5867213607,
0.7351109385,
0.031480886,
-0.3337000906,
0.1719647497,
0.1753275543,
-0.7422564626,
0.3339083195,
0.6218239665,
-0.2537972331,
-0.4807691276,
-1.045158267,
0.20697622,
-0.5752714276,
1.1193612814,
-0.2783145308,
-0.5658921599,
-0.2518118322,
-0.4046863616,
-0.3061568737,
-0.0163722578,
-0.4094254971,
-0.4265710711,
0.3850563467,
0.7081751823,
0.6414393187,
0.4241634309,
0.4958165288,
0.2004262358,
-0.1996733844,
0.6032711267,
-0.0678891689,
-0.0889817327,
-0.2343201339,
-0.4262144268,
-0.4037075341,
-0.0491121523,
0.6230660677,
0.5749743581,
0.0463241115,
0.2038555145,
0.1233524755,
0.7314488888,
-0.9139912128,
0.1294086277,
-0.7454932928,
-0.1245349571,
-0.3522595763,
-0.0571504645,
0.001995631,
-0.4937511384,
0.1994952261,
-0.2277780771,
0.3676318824,
-0.0472292975,
1.3152117729,
0.2425937206,
-0.6256754398,
-0.269811213,
-0.3283841014,
0.4992975295,
-0.5839553475,
0.0351644009,
0.7739691734,
0.0971921086,
0.0839983076,
-0.3464766443,
-0.8586802483,
-0.3567948937,
-0.2312707752,
0.1071270555,
-0.7311737537,
-0.2830128074,
0.25999856,
0.3156857789,
-0.4113871455,
0.0574664436,
-0.0872977972,
-0.5020797849,
0.5268500447,
0.0253306404,
0.2038566023,
-0.4686304033,
-0.1705760211,
0.1279318631,
-0.6139217615,
0.1522745788,
0.4640536606,
0.3194208741,
-0.3170416057,
0.7348104715,
-0.7627982497,
0.4778307676,
0.0018192383,
-0.1085180044,
0.2026279271,
-0.4317185581,
0.1286783963,
0.1837287992,
0.3280936182,
0.1832550615,
-0.1101043448,
-0.1386927068,
-0.3147613406,
0.3757354915,
0.1353253275,
-0.7377649546,
-0.198321715,
0.3068135977,
-0.5569625497,
-0.3635961413,
0.2399940938,
-0.2403248996,
-0.5911128521,
-0.006985629,
0.5685161948,
-0.2394177318,
-0.4347406924,
0.0193054341,
-0.0553052239,
0.0075840568,
0.5190057158,
-0.3947338164,
0.0691783354,
0.8172758222,
0.9700778127,
-0.1823578626,
-0.0892661586,
-0.6966685057,
0.1748368591,
-0.6898829341,
1.4595669508,
-0.6279249191,
0.0849001557,
-0.0181212742,
-0.1276156306,
0.3241111934,
-0.5171175599,
0.7679982185,
-0.6764966846,
-0.0644068345,
-0.3565943539,
-0.6804638505,
-0.0861251205,
0.6182608604,
-0.923763752,
0.7219413519,
0.0734132528,
-0.9440313578,
0.7655662298,
-0.7007166147,
-0.4624224305,
0.0483992733,
-0.0792025551,
-0.8106993437,
0.1925876588,
0.3130278885,
0.3254630268,
-0.194462046,
0.1722769439,
-0.0994821191,
-0.1582884192,
0.3955509663,
-0.2373100072,
0.503770411,
0.2435044199,
-0.3865167499,
-0.0124354558,
-0.8306596875,
-0.0844871104,
-0.2279770374,
-0.3694016337,
-0.4477212131,
-0.0940436199,
-0.1319091022,
0.0168548059,
0.2417123765,
-0.7201936841,
0.0840480849,
-0.4311911762,
0.1097244248,
0.4514362216,
0.1539537013,
0.1190373749,
-0.6870903373,
0.3953258097,
0.3095080853,
-0.2205839306,
-0.1614110619,
-0.3151821196,
-0.883503139,
-0.2107235044,
0.6963029504,
0.4892062247,
-0.8481465578,
0.4463605583,
-0.032197766,
-0.5830345154,
-0.536570549,
0.1389697343,
0.0965376347,
0.5149209499,
0.4219168723,
-0.4293392897,
-0.2420346141,
-0.981353879,
-0.6135452986,
-0.3206092715,
0.0683788583,
0.0906878486,
0.4908786118,
-0.191113919,
1.1357988119,
-0.5959612727,
-0.4236524999,
-0.1075654775,
0.5269441605,
0.116554372,
0.4211668074,
0.5274389982,
-0.846806109,
-0.3514662981,
0.0079272427,
-0.5316033363,
-0.2171560526,
-0.1072139367,
0.1110137329,
0.267888993,
0.2791773081,
-0.6074874401,
0.7229148746,
0.243103236,
-0.4087027013,
0.4566798508,
0.1420277655,
0.4253494442,
-0.8582617044,
-0.0443582237,
0.0521855839,
-0.3260010481,
-0.3088183701,
-0.0534507111,
0.1459205151,
-0.0745652467,
-0.3180161715,
0.4666118622,
-0.1753378659,
0.1963051707,
-0.9817937613,
-0.1543496251,
-0.0986908525,
0.1704061627,
-0.0415075012,
0.6325258017,
0.8028194308,
-0.8196950555,
-0.0836470723,
0.194894731,
-0.586137712,
0.7342085242,
-0.6499137282,
-0.0394933261,
-0.181344524,
0.3409565985,
-0.9583584666,
-0.1378786117,
0.1633291095,
-0.6253558397,
-0.1516898721,
-0.1433747113,
-0.4759637713,
-0.0825111493,
-0.3075684011,
0.2257554084,
0.1115108654,
-0.5722731352,
0.6171511412,
0.447519213,
-0.1167340726,
-0.6296356916,
-0.4646317661,
0.4121101797,
-0.3818022311,
-0.3230936825,
0.4902479947,
0.5273891091,
-0.3039481938,
0.3625446558,
-0.3474659622,
-0.2293848693,
0.2319540828,
0.1990645826,
0.0141361933,
-0.0447004139,
0.2694610953,
0.093556188,
-0.5215941072,
-0.0695670247,
-0.3839857876,
0.2301077098,
-0.0921820104,
-0.4008635879,
-0.5488259196,
0.5280929208,
0.1951377094,
-0.3761191666,
0.8473200798,
0.7506323457,
-0.5924672484,
0.0299558509,
-0.7971087694,
-0.0699380785,
-0.4153112471,
0.1444536448,
-0.2802639902,
-0.9171110392,
0.4680592716,
-0.3516599834,
0.1606214494,
0.9484533072,
0.4028883874,
-0.2152813077,
0.7693219781,
1.0251713991,
-0.2517649233,
0.3969204128,
-0.2658004165,
0.4316054285,
-0.3279254138,
-0.1147780642,
-0.8981230855,
-0.0191689897,
-0.7379461527,
-0.1615994275,
0.3915022612,
-0.062703751,
-0.0757903978,
0.3511199951,
-0.1261155605,
0.4447983801,
0.3333585858,
0.3776238859,
0.6033691764,
0.2450234443,
0.3330440223,
0.1054408774,
-0.51488024,
-0.6800228357,
0.860668242,
0.1824304163,
0.5914496779,
0.3215004206,
0.8231519461,
0.874098897,
0.3206930459,
-0.5780186653,
0.3478973806,
-0.2109529525,
-0.3492885232,
-0.1976910681,
-0.5355808735,
-1.0450348854,
0.050565023,
-0.5014494061,
-0.6014028192,
0.1458256096,
0.1561871171,
-0.4887251854,
0.3964953125,
-0.3181300163,
0.3455913067,
0.0647214651,
-0.3666794598,
-0.6604865789,
-0.3578730822,
0.3848376572,
-0.1275951564,
-0.0344900601,
-0.2016254514,
-0.1050427854,
0.971141994,
-0.6212980151,
0.6998358369,
0.0016318575,
-0.2882290184,
0.588740468,
-0.0782747418,
0.4616717994,
0.1260475814,
0.0228544064,
0.1057306528,
-0.1266288161,
-0.7749559879,
-0.4635738432,
0.4843450487,
-0.5954474211,
-0.650534153,
-0.6922776699,
-0.3850112855,
-0.2582551241,
0.2478307784,
-0.035269253,
0.4000158906,
-0.1103712022,
0.0610295422,
0.4649523795,
-0.0375267081,
0.3390314579,
0.6026751399,
0.2410394698,
-0.072859779,
1.1298021078,
0.1499413103,
-0.0979770198,
0.379303664,
0.2252316773,
-0.2665006816,
-0.7451252341,
-0.3527331948,
-0.0149837369,
-0.4921207726,
-0.5624781847,
-1.029482007,
-0.0566641614,
-0.2354275137,
0.0694631636,
-0.4458449483,
-0.7679077983,
-0.0595821477,
-0.068394497,
0.7023699284,
0.6195204258,
-0.3588905334,
0.2718856037,
-0.7770667672,
0.7917847037,
0.3280980885,
0.3881510198,
0.0624023043,
-0.5258018374,
-0.2177548856,
-0.0263297465,
-0.5428313017,
-0.6137967706,
0.0631134212,
-0.0140030934,
0.4705519676,
0.4401465952,
0.3226940334,
0.5743266344,
-0.0961879492,
0.7113824487,
0.0286436994,
-0.8938211203,
0.8443490863,
0.0165565666,
0.0041941716,
0.8298712373,
0.5469807982,
-0.2650587857,
-0.5335960388,
-0.8520629406,
-0.8632444739,
0.4353112876,
0.3917871118,
0.2764764428,
0.1077682376,
0.2080363929,
0.2676875591,
0.1491543204,
-0.5810938478,
-0.1640982777,
-0.0703491792,
0.0065515842,
0.3305955827,
-0.108304143,
-0.1249706,
0.0380376019,
0.7214514017,
-0.2873047292,
0.0942782089,
0.2262722701,
-0.18087928,
-0.1026323587,
0.4996265769,
0.3943347931,
0.6539601684,
-0.0446071066,
0.2398322821,
0.1726344973,
-0.5030883551,
0.2064382881,
0.3848841488,
-0.3217174709,
0.1356281191,
0.7101824284,
0.5736585259,
-0.1010868102,
-0.4964657426,
0.3973077238,
0.1176649183,
-0.1033516526,
-0.009726055,
0.1379647702,
-0.2800323665,
0.3202108145,
0.6455051899,
0.3157535493,
0.1963200122,
-0.6870796084,
0.4615824819,
0.373934567,
-0.2352695018,
0.0834334195,
0.2525829971,
0.0846893638,
-0.1505692005,
0.3097835481,
-0.3069033325,
-0.8594571948,
0.8176324368,
0.1972444504,
0.5639700294,
0.2162110358,
0.3837210238,
0.3537805974,
0.3903395832,
-0.1031043604,
0.1806128323,
-0.3280866146,
-0.7785743475,
-0.3512082398,
-0.2645027339,
-0.6863617301,
0.0797440037,
-0.5492317677,
0.2696663737,
-0.1407053173,
-0.2332939506,
0.1991360933,
0.4354343116,
-0.6560578942,
0.197175324,
-0.1197671741,
0.7516350746,
-1.0551155806,
0.6161723137,
0.5502712131,
-0.4515734017,
-0.6708184481,
0.5111469626,
-0.0150378905,
-0.6453659534,
0.4497142136,
0.071419403,
-0.3109070063,
-0.2802302837,
-0.6319741607,
-0.6515993476,
0.7800385356,
0.2924724817,
-0.1492515504,
0.4228910506,
0.0885193497,
0.293413043,
-0.1972052157,
0.2093832344,
0.4403134286,
0.448294282,
0.0284980256,
-0.8722669482,
-0.0045163096,
-0.0096484013,
-0.5102838874,
0.1922798157,
-0.7738822699,
0.6291325688,
-0.301822871,
-0.1806350499,
0.0267967228,
1.1175438166,
0.3569374084,
0.7343568206,
0.8383302093,
0.6614574194,
0.9384910464,
0.0625308529,
1.085529089,
0.0246117767,
0.3349444866,
0.8227902651,
-0.2090730369,
0.6207754612,
0.2335617244,
-0.1528736204,
0.4517548084,
0.6289306283,
-0.1081178561,
0.5970070362,
0.100120917,
-0.2667251527,
-0.4567002952,
-0.7627594471,
-0.4918897152,
0.7556957603,
0.3322463632,
-0.075615339,
-0.5240957141,
-0.0807053819,
0.0623966046,
0.2313161194,
-0.3215061426,
0.8378801346,
-0.0908544287,
-0.7846729755,
0.3722032011,
0.2099083811,
0.7612847686,
-0.4478475749,
-0.4491607249,
-0.256577462,
-0.1586566269,
-0.4673008621,
-0.8268696666,
0.5154477954,
0.4195267856,
-0.2559365332,
0.2081650645,
1.0355679989,
-0.3510597646,
-0.5105810761,
-0.010669319,
0.7620404363,
0.1593360156,
-0.1949368715,
-0.5798639059,
-0.0090300571,
-0.1674472243,
0.0970546678,
0.1698040217,
0.467025578,
-0.3837886155,
0.6440120339,
0.6562749743,
0.0882163793,
-0.5782485604,
0.1391688883,
0.8667421937,
-0.4922428429,
-0.8921812177,
-0.8498969674,
0.1107616872,
-0.2007105947,
-0.1944298893,
0.8119035959,
0.6070508361,
0.6373499036,
0.277087152,
0.774343431,
-0.1118828729,
0.6186746955,
-0.6770687699,
0.939840436,
-0.6697121263,
0.2341597825,
-0.5380027294,
-0.7250241041,
-0.2892848849,
0.6616498828,
-0.1625258327,
-0.145751223,
0.6378275156,
0.8568616509,
-0.1353137791,
0.2082444429,
0.09710107,
-0.0024185893,
0.2666332126,
0.5052780509,
1.1204197407,
-0.4565935433,
0.4690005183,
-0.1943524182,
-0.1717748195,
-0.0658894926,
-1.1604286432,
-0.7662404776,
-0.5751113892,
-0.9333353639,
-0.5092543364,
-0.0582386367,
0.6231223941,
0.7376331091,
-1.0982230902,
0.273502171,
-0.0071391151,
0.5004775524,
-0.2905716896,
-0.2169986814,
0.7979187369,
-0.1005730256,
-0.2183862031,
0.0317391716,
0.0101556014,
-0.0637321249,
0.1058812216,
0.2132478356,
-0.324056983,
0.1774437129,
0.435171932,
0.3582570851,
-0.5697215796,
-0.4454393983,
-0.3996497691,
-0.059497755,
0.026485607,
1.0700948238,
-0.9426359534,
0.0061582658,
0.2813059986,
1.119636178,
0.6161335111,
0.1191267669,
0.0091790762,
-0.6818529963,
-0.0282879956,
0.139360249,
0.2809333205,
0.3829680383,
-0.4043309093,
0.5450226068,
0.1135825068,
-0.1669509262,
-0.8434888721,
0.1904055029,
-0.9350403547,
-0.1852160543,
0.6986515522,
-0.1479091793,
0.081199035,
-0.4566498399,
-0.1364248395,
0.2031809092,
-0.4894340634,
1.2264480591,
0.8503090143,
-0.1338605732,
-0.1023697779,
-0.4853889942,
0.3890661597,
0.7140514255,
-0.9881041646,
-0.002627064,
0.3028574884,
0.1909439266,
0.2853601575,
0.6147064567,
-0.0067183976,
0.6380694509,
-0.1425426155,
-0.4248710573,
0.0372548588,
-0.2683047652,
-0.1451390684,
0.3529531956,
0.0444215424,
-0.3506262302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08489v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08489v2 | Effectiveness of Text, Acoustic, and Lattice-based representations in Spoken Language Understanding tasks | 2022-12-16T14:01:42 | 2023-03-17T13:26:14 | Esaú Villatoro-Tello, Srikanth Madikeri, Juan Zuluaga-Gomez, Bidisha Sharma, Seyyed Saeed Sarfjoo, Iuliia Nigmatulina, Petr Motlicek, Alexei V. Ivanov, Aravind Ganapathiraju | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS, I.2.7 | In this paper, we perform an exhaustive evaluation of different
representations to address the intent classification problem in a Spoken
Language Understanding (SLU) setup. We benchmark three types of systems to
perform the SLU intent detection task: 1) text-based, 2) lattice-based, and a
novel 3) multimodal approach. Our work provides a comprehensive analysis of
what could be the achievable performance of different state-of-the-art SLU
systems under different circumstances, e.g., automatically- vs.
manually-generated transcripts. We evaluate the systems on the publicly
available SLURP spoken language resource corpus. Our results indicate that
using richer forms of Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) outputs, namely
word-consensus-networks, allows the SLU system to improve in comparison to the
1-best setup (5.5% relative improvement). However, crossmodal approaches, i.e.,
learning from acoustic and text embeddings, obtains performance similar to the
oracle setup, a relative improvement of 17.8% over the 1-best configuration,
being a recommended alternative to overcome the limitations of working with
automatically generated transcripts. | [
-0.039895799,
-0.5236831903,
0.6602627635,
0.24327977,
-0.1301158965,
-0.1389223486,
-0.4275375009,
-0.3618356884,
-0.0057811635,
0.307099551,
-0.0973750651,
-0.6250648499,
-0.5834256411,
-0.0358653702,
-0.4148855209,
0.5708057284,
0.0312175788,
0.2528002262,
-0.2604172826,
-0.3567784429,
-0.6786565781,
-0.2856635451,
-0.7258777618,
-0.6100188494,
0.1738247871,
0.2447722256,
0.6451877356,
0.3948510289,
0.1767321974,
0.3181114197,
0.02888708,
0.1937424541,
-0.2088045478,
0.224378854,
-0.0347090885,
-0.3050508499,
-0.225513652,
-0.0273453649,
0.9934497476,
0.4639748037,
-0.39373824,
0.0366663262,
0.078813836,
0.5975261927,
-0.747698307,
0.3851926625,
-0.5173627734,
0.1640686691,
-0.0350889973,
-0.1802960187,
-0.8965358734,
-0.0531239435,
0.1557551473,
-0.7152977586,
-0.2258244157,
-0.0354362503,
0.4229997694,
0.216044873,
-0.2721197903,
-0.7983106375,
-0.8270357847,
0.9303107858,
-0.8026104569,
0.8616130948,
0.5620999336,
0.1979166418,
0.1209606379,
-0.6271035075,
-0.3675469756,
-0.3141488731,
-0.4990415275,
0.1588485688,
-0.2235670835,
0.3182145357,
0.3352664113,
0.3222672045,
-0.7854650617,
0.1384099573,
-0.2324894071,
-0.3048859835,
0.5970893502,
0.0180256218,
0.4816761315,
-0.3233131468,
-0.0829088092,
-0.0507040583,
-0.2453581244,
0.4020991623,
0.0735060349,
0.3276356757,
-0.0238238461,
0.445420742,
-0.0778814107,
0.7484058738,
-0.1903327554,
-0.3522484601,
0.390563041,
-0.4363667965,
-0.4141816795,
0.3823067844,
0.8771563768,
-0.0044931998,
-0.0480392911,
-0.2186962068,
-0.4280812144,
0.0256852768,
0.2974893749,
-0.2712960243,
0.2113146633,
0.2100799531,
-0.5708832741,
0.0998466462,
-0.1521854252,
-0.0492068306,
-0.2777275741,
-0.4297218919,
0.5208463073,
-0.6659926176,
-0.3176185489,
0.0935197696,
-0.1694224626,
0.3309363127,
0.3864607513,
-0.9552375674,
0.5756227374,
0.6640667915,
0.8716489077,
-0.3532528281,
-0.0881284326,
-0.5548540354,
0.4013008177,
-0.1251687109,
0.6614391804,
-0.5475937724,
-0.5097168684,
0.0059848279,
-0.3268222511,
-0.4914587438,
-0.4299266636,
0.7385389805,
-0.2941532433,
0.1004689112,
-0.0852140263,
-0.6702405214,
-0.3004619777,
0.0495031066,
-0.7844377756,
1.0269885063,
-0.2772648036,
-0.4654366076,
0.3296400309,
-0.8950099945,
-0.5979071259,
0.3187225163,
-0.4926516116,
-0.0726257637,
0.1408884674,
0.1188803911,
0.4709379673,
0.1192336529,
0.2256272137,
0.2816997766,
-0.5722020268,
0.3671540618,
-0.4871406853,
0.5294195414,
0.1919617951,
-0.5485126376,
0.1423153132,
-0.582713902,
0.0688253269,
-0.221444279,
-0.4380879104,
-0.5351086259,
0.2591908276,
0.0293519031,
-0.1688404083,
0.1491458863,
-0.528958261,
-0.091537118,
-0.2365826219,
0.3609295189,
0.631008029,
-0.3860507011,
0.6391829252,
-0.1313611865,
0.3074827194,
-0.0504704714,
0.1739297658,
-0.1698018312,
-0.6038564444,
-0.5609017015,
0.0521330088,
0.1450601369,
0.557998538,
-0.7042540908,
-0.1726564765,
-0.2450924516,
-0.3127910793,
-0.6035118699,
0.0364154391,
0.8281373382,
0.0549058095,
0.3307672739,
-0.2899915278,
-0.3854210675,
-0.8197702169,
-0.3923009932,
-0.3696360588,
0.3040709198,
0.8906296492,
0.0550727323,
-0.0898976848,
0.7480633259,
-0.306414783,
-0.2334066182,
-0.4207253754,
0.2609942853,
0.3171035051,
0.3175454438,
0.2205375433,
-0.9723769426,
-0.6134309173,
0.4554569125,
-0.8541296124,
0.123002097,
-0.0334972665,
0.552850008,
0.3317933083,
0.6272059679,
-0.3250741959,
0.5622473955,
0.6722267866,
-0.0811146498,
0.5869746804,
-0.2235541642,
0.28350389,
-0.7567802072,
-0.0121846432,
0.0076459618,
-0.2690429091,
-1.1659032106,
-0.1474334151,
0.0582251251,
-0.1396540105,
-0.5157165527,
0.3223702312,
-0.5828120112,
-0.5550949574,
-0.065117009,
0.5763078928,
-0.2052761167,
0.4316747487,
0.2673315108,
0.8238430619,
0.3930566013,
-0.7136436105,
0.2286588252,
0.0145616401,
-0.4759624004,
0.2554486692,
-0.6689506173,
0.2841241658,
-0.158743456,
0.1986595392,
-1.1139698029,
-0.0129503682,
0.1748676449,
-0.6050831676,
0.3811586201,
-0.1310296804,
-0.1882485151,
0.062349394,
-0.0112341335,
0.5302703977,
0.3996444643,
-0.2297959477,
1.0340313911,
0.3643297553,
-0.1439509243,
-0.9635307789,
-0.7074449062,
-0.0026033153,
0.0370866023,
-0.532197535,
0.2941760123,
0.0899228007,
-0.4276877642,
-0.1020274386,
-0.0400125086,
-0.0556395464,
-0.0324223526,
0.4652415514,
-0.1021625176,
-0.4385460019,
0.3644024432,
0.0624831989,
-0.0797065496,
-0.1655854881,
-0.1517845839,
0.6238760948,
-0.3516218662,
-0.5054590106,
-0.8616526127,
0.293073684,
0.5640337467,
-0.1363767982,
0.4706258774,
0.6447247863,
-0.2326608747,
-0.2683873475,
-0.5802933574,
0.0585630387,
-0.463221699,
0.0970492437,
-0.4139995873,
-0.8725082278,
0.3460757434,
0.1494882256,
0.3427173197,
0.1551143676,
0.255071491,
-0.1105851606,
0.8613476753,
0.2679389119,
-0.1286519021,
0.5905329585,
-0.2724490166,
0.2211566567,
-0.9237321019,
-0.3608118296,
-0.4865815938,
-0.2539491653,
-0.3883906901,
-0.4581336379,
0.2470860183,
-0.1336174458,
0.3950152397,
0.5682601929,
-0.38545385,
0.1182680428,
0.4111838341,
0.1348661929,
0.5242578983,
-0.0413055643,
-0.188694939,
0.1388358325,
-0.7056156993,
-0.511333406,
0.830942452,
0.3439991176,
0.6494785547,
0.2710008025,
0.7303815484,
0.4406557083,
0.2126111686,
-0.9250291586,
0.5522311926,
-0.386079222,
-0.3306623101,
-0.7779223323,
-0.4047956467,
-1.0166538954,
0.4792662859,
-0.0691085309,
-0.7407634258,
0.1669723839,
0.1254047602,
-0.2703362703,
0.0668141171,
-1.0313757658,
0.6502622366,
-0.1850448698,
-0.0247771051,
-0.523191452,
-0.2476327717,
0.0418069437,
0.3066508174,
0.5481721163,
-0.0507705212,
-0.0489883795,
0.8726077676,
0.2023795247,
0.6454750299,
-0.4213634133,
0.000929291,
0.3045655787,
-0.222229287,
0.3120208681,
0.1139686629,
-0.3466216028,
0.0341043621,
-0.2263389081,
-0.139558807,
-0.793836236,
0.5823847651,
-0.816321671,
-0.4507390261,
-0.3064367175,
-0.6476883888,
-0.117467992,
0.1355770379,
0.0746530816,
1.1170541048,
-0.3676363528,
0.3324206471,
0.7934663296,
-0.1725776345,
0.6699017286,
0.607863903,
-0.208459571,
-0.1922899336,
0.9802882075,
0.0943911672,
0.2945339978,
0.5180286169,
0.2354554832,
-0.4599582255,
-1.0639077425,
-0.4571758509,
0.1880979389,
-0.7829621434,
0.1565513164,
-0.6785196662,
-0.2921877801,
-0.761413753,
-0.0019135104,
-0.2092348337,
-0.2441452891,
-0.3412021399,
0.0897236317,
0.094262898,
1.0849534273,
0.0182549246,
0.4124803543,
-0.6817464232,
0.2065840811,
0.2963064015,
0.3664529324,
-0.0283859335,
-0.519567728,
-0.320705086,
0.1180374846,
-0.0308305379,
-0.812143445,
0.1353084594,
0.4933894277,
1.1084315777,
0.4112997055,
-0.085861437,
0.5337494016,
-0.325653553,
0.8549054861,
0.2128438205,
-1.0873908997,
0.6812952161,
-0.1673027426,
0.3738121688,
0.6945667863,
0.3837687373,
-0.8339141607,
-0.3272410929,
-0.4254981279,
-0.5958518386,
1.014010191,
0.3900271952,
-0.1782324463,
0.1752547771,
0.2729351819,
0.0496769622,
-0.0390705392,
-0.8516232967,
-0.4192627668,
-0.1371805519,
-0.1100247949,
-0.3833469748,
-0.0363121703,
0.2759816051,
-0.0028678,
0.7543452978,
-0.0047364202,
0.1652027518,
0.2922774553,
-0.7116323709,
0.3093394935,
0.5382051468,
0.7407152057,
0.6309126616,
0.0195293408,
0.1229598001,
0.1667255759,
-0.7908121347,
0.001334868,
-0.1026412249,
-0.2076872289,
0.3131414354,
0.3685820997,
1.1441373825,
0.4494509101,
-0.6489973664,
0.5362806916,
-0.3914103508,
-0.1463333666,
-0.1678828299,
0.1814117432,
-0.0336230695,
0.1068372205,
0.2982634306,
-0.1699900031,
0.5723350048,
-0.6787853241,
0.133307144,
0.4849180579,
-0.79488796,
-0.1912194788,
-0.1520328522,
0.2419448495,
-0.5993008614,
0.5068364143,
-0.2102965415,
-0.4107690752,
0.3858696818,
0.5519490242,
0.7131202221,
-0.6679323316,
0.4019000232,
0.3129171729,
0.3092618585,
-0.0100096148,
0.2543161809,
-0.546995759,
-0.8847171664,
-0.4637543857,
-0.5014454126,
-0.4574529231,
0.125840351,
-0.8233172894,
0.1124083325,
-0.2377938479,
-0.114412047,
0.2203103006,
-0.2267177254,
-0.3411169648,
0.0572453775,
0.2141649723,
0.5916541219,
-0.9101583362,
0.8509421945,
0.9906507134,
-0.0067495531,
-1.0063892603,
-0.3050985932,
-0.0355928801,
-0.8532449603,
0.5515810251,
0.1570211947,
-0.3936023116,
-0.1338511556,
-0.0769274235,
-0.8138907552,
1.1037405729,
-0.0114808977,
-0.5773009062,
0.030306885,
0.1410249323,
0.3487658501,
-0.2670398653,
0.6131131649,
0.6669529676,
0.4210761487,
-0.0265322682,
-1.2500519753,
-0.1635885388,
-0.3121944666,
-0.0550315604,
0.3494134843,
-0.2650199234,
0.5061001182,
0.059084747,
-0.5372594595,
-0.1765102148,
0.6104145646,
0.181373328,
0.7652654648,
0.8606032133,
0.4687517881,
0.6409453154,
-0.1567609459,
0.8700523376,
0.0555854626,
0.1930933148,
1.1058601141,
-0.051018361,
0.9689958692,
0.3504066169,
-0.2720627487,
0.5826016665,
0.2403416634,
0.4375562966,
0.3766489625,
-0.0169769544,
-0.3193889558,
-0.0505245663,
-0.2176207453,
-0.2943999767,
0.7114086151,
0.9093177319,
-0.3568996191,
-0.0304031335,
0.3042742908,
-0.3798806965,
0.0885946751,
-0.5145002007,
1.1833719015,
0.23938407,
-0.7578004003,
0.4145719111,
-0.3315373361,
0.7055840492,
-0.559938252,
-0.0075571556,
0.125386551,
-0.0035225374,
-0.5187017918,
-0.8804370761,
0.1228212193,
-0.2061311007,
-0.1098817512,
-0.4616645277,
1.0243781805,
-0.4397132397,
0.0162604135,
0.3741442561,
0.1779693365,
0.5145680904,
0.1769495159,
-0.6923512816,
0.3551357388,
0.0883439109,
0.0585264713,
0.0544143841,
0.1999525726,
0.0474437848,
0.6104082465,
0.4859216213,
0.0088842241,
0.1451800168,
0.4498305023,
0.5499253869,
-0.3854680061,
-0.5614682436,
-0.6983700991,
0.2894524932,
-0.1610315293,
-0.1435776055,
0.8539726734,
0.592218399,
0.6433702111,
0.1843127012,
0.8223957419,
0.0371987894,
0.259726584,
-0.5609741807,
0.4916023016,
-0.3547555208,
0.1544396579,
-0.4960386455,
-0.678186357,
0.0280027278,
0.7034552097,
-0.3577222526,
-0.1328899711,
0.812512219,
0.5146040916,
0.0097275497,
0.5558506846,
0.5090304017,
0.1140855923,
0.1869840026,
0.3779788613,
0.9161266088,
-0.4691152573,
0.5090414882,
-0.0922469348,
-0.3498325944,
-0.2030706555,
-0.5210125446,
-0.6232301593,
-0.8165491223,
-0.1059903353,
-0.1442842185,
0.1662040651,
0.681743443,
0.7063422203,
-0.7605863214,
-0.722902,
0.0988126174,
0.234173134,
-0.2925450504,
-0.148860693,
0.2737165391,
-0.5183613896,
-0.4490294158,
0.6409500241,
0.4761344194,
-0.2505889237,
-0.1816424727,
-0.4450303316,
-0.2535902262,
-0.1104102358,
0.9031330943,
0.1942058504,
-0.9027224183,
-0.2596889436,
0.1272100806,
-0.1031525657,
-0.0141323162,
1.1306488514,
-0.6237763762,
0.5429067016,
0.6237832904,
0.5554078221,
0.6481285691,
-0.1311636716,
0.550114572,
-0.5844943523,
-0.0546282008,
0.5045517683,
0.4755437076,
0.1844430417,
-0.4018033445,
0.249160558,
-0.0759631842,
-0.5853767991,
-0.715200007,
0.1661684662,
-1.3507605791,
-0.2024067938,
1.4061408043,
-0.1273678541,
-0.1536964923,
-0.6280965209,
-0.1312161684,
0.2656808496,
-0.8237383366,
0.1224116087,
0.580401957,
-0.4210864604,
-0.1748146713,
-0.5296958089,
0.4837180376,
0.4422638118,
-0.6158470511,
0.1040826067,
0.2558375597,
0.0049795643,
0.4701401293,
0.9059678316,
-0.1861891747,
0.5010204315,
-0.3020618558,
-0.0493240058,
0.1019500419,
-0.2214452624,
-0.4423208833,
-0.0300462022,
0.0475981273,
-0.0950225666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08486v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08486v1 | BLASER: A Text-Free Speech-to-Speech Translation Evaluation Metric | 2022-12-16T14:00:26 | 2022-12-16T14:00:26 | Mingda Chen, Paul-Ambroise Duquenne, Pierre Andrews, Justine Kao, Alexandre Mourachko, Holger Schwenk, Marta R. Costa-jussà | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | End-to-End speech-to-speech translation (S2ST) is generally evaluated with
text-based metrics. This means that generated speech has to be automatically
transcribed, making the evaluation dependent on the availability and quality of
automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems. In this paper, we propose a
text-free evaluation metric for end-to-end S2ST, named BLASER, to avoid the
dependency on ASR systems. BLASER leverages a multilingual multimodal encoder
to directly encode the speech segments for source input, translation output and
reference into a shared embedding space and computes a score of the translation
quality that can be used as a proxy to human evaluation. To evaluate our
approach, we construct training and evaluation sets from more than 40k human
annotations covering seven language directions. The best results of BLASER are
achieved by training with supervision from human rating scores. We show that
when evaluated at the sentence level, BLASER correlates significantly better
with human judgment compared to ASR-dependent metrics including ASR-SENTBLEU in
all translation directions and ASR-COMET in five of them. Our analysis shows
combining speech and text as inputs to BLASER does not increase the correlation
with human scores, but best correlations are achieved when using speech, which
motivates the goal of our research. Moreover, we show that using ASR for
references is detrimental for text-based metrics. | [
0.0197081156,
-0.3069821,
0.2110583782,
0.5042549372,
-0.5867687464,
0.1644709855,
-0.565593183,
-0.3989796937,
0.0583989285,
0.1102991402,
-0.1206761226,
-0.1648046076,
-0.8905895352,
0.3169800937,
-0.5353899002,
1.1035749912,
0.007654578,
0.4418371022,
-0.406295836,
-0.0699124411,
-0.3431286216,
-0.5029709935,
-0.5458368659,
-0.2811780274,
0.362082094,
0.1369439662,
0.5023041964,
0.602633059,
0.7686662078,
0.2521266341,
-0.2308882922,
0.1254277229,
-0.3252536952,
0.0742353201,
-0.5005254149,
-0.1778546274,
-0.2235784084,
-0.0781348422,
0.8138952851,
0.3402114809,
-0.0882735625,
0.4751610756,
0.0913611725,
0.4578610957,
-0.560258925,
0.1074621305,
-0.3786237836,
0.0260969773,
-0.3208427131,
-0.0850031376,
-0.5347757339,
-0.6185964942,
-0.0382557623,
-0.0314483307,
0.0550649427,
-0.2020556331,
0.9265576601,
0.7921229005,
-0.4399755597,
-0.4197860658,
-0.6957736611,
0.7215307355,
-0.3401843607,
1.1054452658,
0.2455831468,
0.6986519098,
0.2159416229,
-0.4997106493,
-0.6520794034,
-0.0585249774,
-0.1701100022,
0.5585330129,
-0.5475507379,
0.0223711804,
-0.1980623454,
0.2830216885,
-0.7482790947,
-0.0349046215,
-0.5753283501,
-0.4214671254,
0.6786884665,
-0.0809126943,
0.135189116,
-0.3533714116,
-0.4325197637,
-0.1700656414,
-0.3225079775,
0.1070659012,
0.0193949044,
0.3287202418,
-0.0813383609,
0.7573825121,
-0.0656851232,
0.3143574595,
0.2473727167,
0.0101214414,
0.6277495027,
-0.5884468555,
-0.0599371269,
0.2885792851,
1.0288199186,
0.6055089235,
0.1341892779,
-0.6894543767,
-0.2992036641,
0.5578107834,
0.2239087969,
-1.0077955723,
0.2367340028,
-0.0158621278,
-0.4453664124,
0.1892238408,
-0.0642370135,
-0.875341475,
-0.0485973284,
-0.0546011366,
0.5210341215,
-0.2935780287,
0.0413057208,
-0.1082091108,
-0.2923147082,
0.2345835716,
0.2881667316,
-0.5639691949,
0.3128576577,
0.3626813293,
0.9915280342,
-0.3414248228,
-0.262929976,
-0.9303357601,
0.159174934,
-0.3830786943,
0.7409681082,
-0.3370231092,
-0.6617157459,
-0.1117540225,
-0.085373804,
-0.052631598,
-0.3931158185,
0.6679894328,
-0.2527091801,
0.2661809623,
0.0799294114,
-0.7297806144,
-0.2453794479,
-0.1100085452,
-0.3486845791,
0.9416232705,
-0.0942441225,
-0.3401049674,
0.5049019456,
-0.6009871364,
-0.5362839699,
0.3537427187,
-0.2884651423,
-0.2444344312,
0.0980838463,
0.2290572226,
0.195856452,
-0.4423925877,
0.3593340516,
0.2573070526,
-0.2756577432,
0.2417510152,
-0.4599032998,
0.5070943832,
0.1815618426,
-0.3729481101,
0.3921846747,
-0.6142024398,
0.0717981607,
-0.2553781569,
-0.5492505431,
0.0679013133,
0.0441749282,
0.3074082434,
0.3962221742,
0.4552919269,
-1.0792675018,
-0.5931481123,
-0.5347795486,
0.2776349783,
0.5839363933,
-0.0717400461,
0.4143071175,
-0.0298392493,
0.2795222998,
-0.2878124714,
0.0776722357,
0.0206352882,
-0.5375621319,
-0.9328334928,
-0.2572749853,
0.0780864581,
0.8992974162,
-0.5365095139,
0.7334703803,
-0.7053667903,
-0.7052297592,
-1.0950107574,
0.1578967571,
1.1065313816,
0.3994491696,
0.6626570225,
-0.4589023888,
-0.353151381,
-0.8348813057,
-0.4242435694,
-0.204944849,
-0.1782843322,
0.0866009369,
0.4032974243,
-0.2985683084,
0.8845664263,
-0.1045257747,
-0.8018781543,
-0.2935616076,
-0.2752157152,
0.0020754044,
0.4412456453,
0.0941020176,
-0.552049458,
-0.586514771,
0.1369373798,
-0.7286478877,
-0.0695631728,
0.0743665546,
0.0389463641,
0.2326491475,
0.463760674,
-0.4674763083,
0.4581112266,
0.5767718554,
-0.4796971977,
0.3961890042,
-0.1891728491,
0.1355415732,
-0.96519804,
0.3497971892,
-0.0450951122,
-0.3195045292,
-0.7100149393,
0.0746140778,
0.2156570405,
-0.1947675347,
-0.5298399329,
0.8328086138,
0.0238814317,
-0.2134140134,
0.0285465885,
0.4451839924,
-0.0210061818,
0.3601772189,
0.0361188464,
1.1734900475,
0.0357779935,
-0.3148663044,
0.3723767102,
0.8760085702,
-0.4908760488,
0.6745964885,
-0.7669450641,
0.5240297318,
-0.0840599015,
0.217918247,
-0.9833709598,
0.0216871146,
0.1614968181,
-1.0519787073,
0.107279405,
0.0731955245,
-0.6778382659,
-0.0596261173,
-0.0090892613,
0.1018366814,
0.4230844378,
-0.6026200652,
0.2880484462,
0.300214529,
-0.3669189811,
-0.1507350951,
-0.9611774683,
0.2901032865,
0.120282039,
-0.7085154057,
0.3936342597,
-0.1439655572,
0.1772304028,
-0.0016646492,
-0.1145993471,
0.0122896545,
-0.4096440375,
0.2193902582,
-0.0297950301,
-0.0252513997,
0.0221539084,
0.2839795053,
-0.3680924177,
-0.1391238868,
-0.0342062972,
0.3114172518,
-0.1115030348,
-0.2048651427,
-0.8312353492,
0.4923937321,
0.3624383807,
-0.5370621085,
0.2111827582,
0.6426484585,
-0.3225158453,
0.2918189466,
-0.5815882683,
-0.0115854535,
-0.4553214014,
0.6286830902,
-0.3104311824,
-0.8984817863,
0.1003364772,
0.1491807252,
0.0663832501,
0.2678677738,
0.624996841,
0.0577708185,
1.0626760721,
0.3254649639,
0.0428739823,
0.3680507243,
0.0876915008,
0.2209725529,
-0.9372735023,
-0.4572141171,
-0.5628273487,
-0.1852196902,
-0.3384080827,
-0.7207830548,
0.3591654003,
-0.0765640885,
-0.2055425644,
0.3589283824,
-0.5044674873,
0.2530222535,
0.4084999263,
-0.0938850865,
0.1574243605,
0.0799548104,
0.1359553188,
-0.3515172005,
-0.2024962604,
-0.4997686446,
0.8260068893,
0.3039749265,
0.2869809568,
0.445682317,
0.7440413833,
0.3307529986,
0.077253066,
-0.9913715124,
0.5264038444,
-0.7880425453,
-0.5258862376,
-0.3568751514,
-0.6769838333,
-0.6501761675,
0.40798527,
0.0909532681,
-0.8116606474,
0.0925172344,
0.0299953204,
-0.1001212299,
-0.2502755225,
-0.6168063879,
0.7416498065,
-0.4224763513,
-0.264269501,
-0.3001921177,
-0.7018020153,
-0.2859128118,
0.0341557823,
0.2910098135,
-0.0010760452,
0.0629874766,
1.0983188152,
-0.1064819396,
0.5324067473,
-0.3919910192,
0.1666465253,
0.0481871441,
0.1219280586,
0.2918879986,
-0.2523880601,
-0.2826242447,
0.3675219715,
-0.1118126884,
-0.0574741364,
-0.5854071379,
0.2048459947,
-0.8681635857,
-0.2369756103,
-0.3508773148,
-0.2689156532,
-0.2398372889,
0.3666805923,
0.4540163577,
0.2368201017,
-0.2413364202,
0.284763515,
0.0836951956,
-0.2020002156,
0.2947013676,
0.4800252914,
-0.2853184938,
-1.0320597887,
1.2928123474,
0.0562735498,
0.284065783,
0.4367501438,
0.2259209901,
-0.8289662004,
-0.26441136,
-1.0727182627,
0.2504143119,
-0.7216109037,
-0.3382819593,
-0.5183140635,
-0.3516373336,
-0.3284362257,
-0.320391953,
-0.4608700275,
-0.4492920935,
-0.1412276477,
-0.2104143351,
0.2088107467,
0.2760020196,
-0.134583205,
0.5493549109,
-0.7915799022,
0.1541806608,
0.0856548771,
0.2533663511,
-0.2533033192,
-0.7148134112,
-0.3851850629,
0.1325327009,
-0.3169853687,
-0.6900687218,
0.423265636,
0.7470808029,
0.4428193569,
0.3479714692,
-0.2330506295,
1.0237244368,
-0.838283062,
0.8200529814,
0.5839939713,
-1.3185266256,
0.6766275764,
0.1093360484,
0.2657375336,
0.7384486794,
-0.0217886791,
-0.8165305853,
-0.5774232745,
0.036266651,
-0.8198367953,
0.5851162672,
0.2003779709,
0.1448598057,
-0.1158602834,
0.0202365331,
0.0148808453,
0.2364758849,
-0.3890610337,
0.0085701812,
-0.5790300965,
-0.2550911903,
-0.5464122891,
-0.0658805296,
0.0937799513,
-0.176464051,
0.4071879089,
0.1516810954,
0.4459646344,
0.282491982,
-0.4548649788,
-0.1150469556,
0.4284675419,
0.2620458901,
0.0769222602,
-0.2927752733,
0.0471748076,
0.126748547,
-0.4445320666,
0.2603214979,
0.1885753125,
-0.2961915731,
0.3025435507,
0.1643527448,
0.7809592485,
0.1573775858,
-0.7012104988,
0.888383925,
0.0708341151,
-0.1178086326,
-0.2013219297,
-0.2376407087,
-0.1819024235,
0.3073054254,
0.1781873852,
0.1371575594,
0.3034427464,
-0.1217794269,
0.4258013368,
0.1196607724,
-1.1405280828,
-0.4079068601,
0.7705196738,
0.4474770725,
-0.5104440451,
0.5348274112,
-0.5917925835,
-0.5169297457,
0.0275362022,
0.8622053862,
1.0101399422,
-0.6638461947,
0.1212109253,
0.3546597958,
0.3829672337,
0.1301609725,
0.4097200036,
0.0030550743,
-0.5470812321,
-0.5887050033,
-0.991091609,
-0.3892127872,
-0.3425783813,
-0.8390088081,
0.2131368965,
-0.2687741518,
-0.2254126817,
0.0163016617,
-0.1824077517,
-0.5112881064,
0.3011079729,
0.0564498901,
0.7567967176,
-0.6236575842,
0.6071107984,
0.6538905501,
-0.6693778634,
-0.4024170935,
-0.0860466212,
0.1475315988,
-0.560591042,
0.7841384411,
0.299800247,
-0.5221582055,
0.0720269978,
0.2317723334,
-0.7942285538,
0.8765842319,
0.4719874263,
-0.4385941327,
-0.0462311096,
0.2349109948,
0.6760447621,
-0.0042460156,
0.1386042684,
0.3341920078,
0.3090160787,
0.0949577317,
-1.4083498716,
0.1033006981,
-0.5089322925,
0.0444479361,
0.2786547244,
-0.7624413967,
0.4415442348,
-0.0355615355,
-0.5683474541,
0.0679038316,
0.6399242878,
-0.0556842498,
0.3860614598,
0.2411841601,
0.3737156689,
0.4508194625,
0.1026974097,
0.6721617579,
-0.230026558,
0.2834065259,
1.1643255949,
-0.215693593,
1.3029907942,
0.5967959762,
-0.1798250526,
0.1949969679,
0.1075164825,
-0.2533757389,
0.7369250655,
0.1702949405,
-0.2307396233,
0.0051811258,
-0.4097330868,
-0.2026491761,
0.865678668,
0.4282502234,
-0.2014123648,
-0.3401033282,
0.0888897181,
0.1583268493,
0.2183317095,
-0.0569324382,
1.1079162359,
0.1718913317,
-0.4091087878,
0.4523066282,
0.0784204975,
0.751493454,
-0.4892815053,
0.1939579695,
-0.1785099655,
0.3513125777,
-0.2158434838,
-0.6714527011,
0.6877000332,
0.5960822105,
-0.1373257786,
-0.3557522893,
0.3311757445,
-0.4992736876,
-0.6107060909,
0.7296835184,
0.6239510775,
0.5604305863,
0.0364626013,
-0.3055529296,
-0.099779211,
0.054980807,
0.1080999672,
0.2852449119,
0.1851721406,
-0.0030623362,
0.5501189828,
0.8457097411,
0.2830584049,
0.1392847002,
0.1127236411,
0.5898712277,
-0.5354241729,
-0.6094933152,
-0.8158530593,
0.3664250076,
0.0176149458,
-0.4337777197,
0.7846820951,
1.0179831982,
0.7778140306,
0.2396423221,
0.8848272562,
0.0743647292,
0.7497291565,
-0.2296606451,
1.1048641205,
-0.5466247201,
-0.3049533665,
-0.3867349327,
-0.8449527025,
-0.4557279944,
0.8392420411,
-0.1871362627,
-0.4284777939,
0.5357470512,
0.7117409706,
0.0162994694,
-0.1060376242,
0.4354346693,
-0.106210269,
0.5125555396,
0.3000042737,
0.7023095489,
-0.4340067804,
0.9498412609,
0.1013400406,
-0.4263324142,
-0.2779688537,
-0.4019151628,
-0.5738332868,
-0.622502327,
-0.1195872203,
-0.2570053935,
0.3871083558,
0.9141063094,
0.3737842143,
-0.6669535637,
-0.5762249827,
0.199249357,
-0.3356621265,
-0.1982414871,
-0.1374261528,
0.4829272032,
-0.3851253688,
-0.6431872249,
0.6788678169,
0.4459019601,
-0.2616912723,
0.0963241756,
-0.3992969096,
0.1027722061,
0.016922554,
0.8265786767,
-0.1885152459,
-0.787211895,
-0.5318306684,
0.1329247653,
0.0088724634,
-0.0286125895,
0.2781980634,
-0.4438097477,
0.8615999222,
0.2656004727,
0.8308113217,
0.5466399789,
-0.1239219606,
0.529428184,
-0.7821242809,
0.134052515,
0.2879788876,
0.1154903024,
0.5716332197,
-0.0494011454,
0.4035181105,
-0.0668096095,
-0.6068617702,
-0.9001210928,
0.1875672638,
-0.8438872099,
0.3312475681,
1.2429246902,
-0.4182999432,
0.0724318027,
-0.0159700625,
-0.1568623632,
0.6807816625,
-0.8558710814,
0.710670352,
0.4352437854,
-0.1880613565,
-0.096616663,
-0.4142742157,
0.4095036387,
0.4213718474,
-0.6457950473,
-0.0166888535,
0.3923222721,
0.0627610534,
0.4113076627,
0.6168929338,
-0.2102919817,
0.4184472263,
0.0406624675,
0.2553576231,
0.1102967113,
-0.1788349003,
-0.3840990961,
-0.3184897006,
-0.0910886079,
-0.5562120676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08482v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08482v2 | Implementation of general formal translators | 2022-12-16T13:55:22 | 2022-12-22T09:04:07 | Iosif Iulian Petrila | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.FL, cs.PL, cs.SC | The general translator formalism and computing specific implementations are
proposed. The implementation of specific elements necessary to process the
source and destination information within the translators are presented. Some
common directives or instructions, such as classes and procedures, were unified
and generalized in order to allow general translations implementations. In
order to cover general cases, two levels of processing are required, related to
the source and destination information appropriate transformations, with the
related control and processing instructions. The proposed general translator
elements are useful for processing natural or artificial information described
through any types of languages or systems. | [
-0.2784664035,
-0.6906958222,
0.8693409562,
0.4077942967,
-0.3980053961,
-0.2362738848,
-0.1521565169,
-0.8757673502,
0.1981168836,
0.5699803829,
-0.4231811762,
-0.3100281954,
-0.4080462158,
0.1514757127,
-1.0071123838,
0.8587859869,
-0.5803055763,
0.1612809598,
0.1910507083,
0.0817898214,
-0.5053347349,
-0.6966714859,
-0.4182689488,
-0.3061405718,
0.1034561843,
0.3515404463,
1.0981504917,
0.571161449,
0.9021924734,
0.4753398001,
0.2326513082,
0.0043801269,
-0.0668091476,
0.1399268061,
-0.8851191401,
-0.6725876331,
-0.5227639079,
-0.1605740786,
1.0267241001,
0.5817174315,
0.0544393957,
0.0929055214,
-0.1599848866,
0.364153266,
-0.5607159734,
0.0412472636,
-0.2945490479,
0.3617413938,
-0.1950593442,
-0.972299099,
-0.546026051,
-0.5693529248,
-0.1552274525,
-0.665151298,
0.2198403478,
-0.2205048651,
0.6347032785,
-0.1201159433,
-0.5315457582,
-0.7421255708,
-1.4684764147,
0.8569869399,
-0.3056552708,
0.1777286232,
0.3186445534,
0.5869114399,
-0.5110456347,
-0.8309993148,
-0.2999257147,
-0.0173807349,
-0.3082059622,
-0.027826475,
-0.2811442316,
0.5489607453,
0.1371955723,
0.8263424635,
-0.2528750002,
-0.1922408193,
-0.4553864896,
-0.1041737497,
0.6056885719,
0.3319729269,
0.861356914,
0.1752915829,
0.184903264,
0.4773930907,
-0.6135243773,
-0.2328781188,
0.3386590481,
0.0829238147,
-0.2514815629,
0.4704035819,
-0.5521523952,
0.8077309132,
-0.0521257967,
0.2242411822,
0.1110355407,
-0.9292724133,
-0.3016219735,
-0.2960453928,
0.4184685647,
0.0668452904,
0.3552551568,
-0.5385411382,
-0.2182646543,
0.0762824342,
0.3520016074,
-0.4806803167,
0.192448467,
0.111746408,
-0.3242190182,
-0.3172918856,
0.1295802593,
-0.4747895598,
0.2392528504,
-1.0040272474,
0.2699195147,
-0.1300152689,
-0.0977646261,
0.0920443609,
-0.1352909803,
0.7116837502,
0.6558489203,
-1.1532871723,
0.7965208292,
0.6639175415,
0.7698447704,
0.1919074655,
0.1470637918,
-0.4646604359,
0.5487366915,
-0.3767217994,
0.564997673,
-0.8767570853,
-0.3579187989,
0.405913651,
0.1788226664,
0.06416592,
0.0443462916,
1.0667484999,
-0.605055809,
0.3917402923,
-0.2204405963,
-0.4019511044,
-0.1671899855,
-0.2314221859,
-0.5392501354,
0.3154279292,
0.2706640959,
-0.5811495781,
-0.1382054687,
-0.8206647635,
-0.8868959546,
0.2509049177,
-0.3753086627,
0.358931005,
0.5067187548,
-0.1058784872,
0.3084393144,
-0.580951035,
0.0015342475,
0.4326552749,
-0.7451285124,
-0.1473523378,
-0.0511643291,
0.7424285412,
0.5081850886,
-0.3310204148,
0.3769767582,
-0.5792128444,
0.2472806573,
0.0630559027,
-0.6803321242,
-0.2455219924,
0.3026513755,
0.2061634213,
0.1347569078,
0.4751914144,
-0.2572334409,
0.6786248684,
-0.2165654749,
0.7802193165,
0.5267431736,
0.2418293059,
1.0768131018,
0.230106771,
0.5002555251,
-0.1473572403,
0.342828989,
0.1360774487,
-0.5955806375,
-0.7902795672,
0.2492626011,
0.2016397566,
0.9290860891,
-0.8898596168,
0.4633859098,
-0.229681626,
-0.19737418,
-0.4639055431,
0.0400723517,
0.4915896058,
0.0643871725,
0.5236993432,
-0.2965384126,
-0.7894057035,
-0.9407777786,
-0.0992478728,
0.0434378274,
-0.3901442885,
-0.3036026359,
0.2079189867,
-0.5346711278,
0.7260991931,
-0.2621341646,
-0.160864532,
-0.192231521,
0.2477296591,
0.2731305659,
0.666318059,
0.5001702309,
-0.9863708019,
-0.1673646569,
0.5472566485,
-0.8512442112,
-0.1913107187,
-0.2209524214,
-0.4661449492,
0.1998591721,
0.5310437679,
-0.132518962,
0.481754601,
0.5601488352,
-0.1969100386,
0.316003114,
-0.4179833531,
0.5942083001,
-1.0493932962,
0.3309266865,
-0.2869715393,
-0.5348215699,
-1.0537286997,
0.6978852749,
-0.0786669031,
0.0249712057,
-0.4009297192,
0.1463428736,
-0.3292790651,
-0.3638340235,
-0.1116602272,
-0.0053221565,
-0.2055316865,
0.1913280487,
0.1774309129,
0.6396553516,
0.4084139466,
-0.9224538803,
0.7358644605,
-0.0010027966,
-0.1587756276,
0.9300441146,
-0.6792366505,
0.4055167437,
-0.11487028,
0.0424136557,
-0.6910258532,
-0.3022262156,
0.9035232663,
-0.2130519301,
0.3393105268,
-0.1997853816,
-0.5051422715,
-0.2392333448,
0.1475520879,
0.3582771122,
0.5010302067,
0.0502637848,
0.7277628779,
0.1204646006,
-0.2331170291,
-0.3004580736,
-0.9556181431,
0.2940163016,
0.2812930346,
-0.4903533459,
0.263104707,
-0.1384745091,
-0.0354773067,
0.3933387399,
0.1592254788,
-0.3066073954,
-0.0677298754,
0.1200635582,
0.0208185036,
0.0589522757,
-0.2320248187,
0.2526003122,
-0.172361359,
0.0135723986,
-0.3923279941,
0.451996237,
-0.3348768055,
-0.4695160091,
-0.7102351189,
0.7532920837,
0.3873412609,
-0.1341789961,
0.4449180067,
0.5579800606,
-0.4002562463,
0.1515475363,
-0.339592129,
0.2756041288,
-0.50613904,
0.4863810837,
-0.9759642482,
-0.5873877406,
0.7171633244,
0.0331214517,
0.1345038712,
0.5930837393,
0.5058322549,
0.2399770916,
1.1889537573,
0.6919279099,
-0.3784730434,
0.5502650142,
-0.0577216707,
0.251411289,
-0.6145009398,
-0.1460535675,
-1.0431748629,
-0.4921040833,
-0.3939276338,
-0.3694328666,
0.0322529115,
0.276825875,
-0.0936055258,
0.5809236765,
-0.7327919602,
0.6696462035,
0.7397722602,
-0.3557357788,
0.7073623538,
0.3637501299,
-0.2793255746,
0.2396894544,
-0.3353772759,
-0.4142542779,
0.7176548839,
0.2832130194,
0.9624398351,
0.1314940006,
0.7432716489,
0.4759561718,
0.1086988151,
-0.535337925,
0.7352548838,
-0.1488101184,
-0.5422773361,
-0.277051717,
-0.6957806349,
-0.8031380773,
-0.097728923,
0.0895417407,
-0.6422226429,
0.2730397284,
-0.0449082702,
0.5268387198,
0.1939830482,
-0.4842887521,
0.4984686375,
-0.0257616714,
0.2033361644,
-0.7474286556,
-0.7628386021,
0.356890142,
0.1435829848,
0.2138956189,
0.287933737,
0.0945594534,
0.3509797752,
-0.0781361163,
0.5619834065,
-0.0380295888,
-0.192194894,
0.2750075459,
0.2736817598,
0.3914750218,
-0.245028317,
-0.1031124145,
0.1747023761,
0.2947548032,
-0.3974554241,
-0.5704450011,
0.4496401548,
-0.9281873703,
-0.3810183406,
-0.4892837405,
-0.535237968,
0.1347946078,
0.3612276614,
0.4248156846,
0.1242521554,
-0.4505669475,
-0.3054181039,
0.0605135299,
0.0515362918,
-0.0216806456,
0.6656826735,
-0.2979961634,
-0.2350350767,
0.7605134845,
0.00590618,
0.3511420786,
0.8929776549,
-0.2685443163,
-0.1648006737,
-0.6220662594,
-0.4316944182,
-0.0003476981,
-1.0394594669,
-0.0088687614,
0.0322827734,
-0.6082992554,
-0.2584228516,
-0.4732302129,
0.1984717995,
-0.6184512377,
-0.2083319426,
0.2326382101,
-0.0338200778,
1.1426177025,
-0.2346426696,
0.2497456074,
-0.8387015462,
0.576256752,
0.3122292757,
0.4612697065,
-0.3507380188,
-0.3760971725,
-0.5909049511,
0.206786871,
-0.1726053357,
-0.7737810016,
-0.0992382169,
0.3682645261,
0.8705037236,
0.4495231807,
-0.3671799004,
0.6575503945,
-0.7770840526,
0.4707046747,
0.0659980327,
-1.4045007229,
0.78563416,
-0.1922793835,
0.2410136908,
0.4580883682,
0.4453963339,
-1.0564495325,
-0.5364536643,
-0.0731213316,
-0.4741746187,
0.6873630881,
0.2257661521,
0.0736300573,
0.1364823133,
0.7193655372,
-0.4989776015,
0.1991371363,
-0.3802784085,
0.0736503676,
0.2362059504,
-0.0179033242,
-0.0448276177,
-0.2322488874,
-0.1669354141,
-0.2342659682,
0.447181493,
0.3270950615,
0.6242573261,
0.2360168099,
-0.1839337945,
-0.4517654181,
0.7152242661,
0.7593328357,
0.5863133073,
-0.1535897702,
0.1295612007,
-0.2581757903,
-0.5982475877,
0.5188300014,
-0.2688524723,
-0.67624861,
0.0665474087,
0.2616325319,
0.4250680208,
0.2472047061,
0.0519342013,
0.0989540294,
-0.0892013311,
-0.1024978012,
-0.2368766069,
0.2598518729,
-0.1100653931,
-0.0515617579,
0.0314732566,
0.0981311649,
0.6322512627,
-0.8286154866,
-0.06867145,
0.1690136194,
-0.0656885132,
-0.7800012827,
0.5833138824,
0.5863109231,
-0.2231087834,
0.6965301037,
-0.54626441,
-0.3696370721,
0.0919777676,
0.6937660575,
1.137830019,
-0.8087177873,
0.2372392565,
0.1677488536,
0.4014292657,
-0.3216362894,
0.7262393236,
-0.0861545131,
-0.5588812232,
-0.7900998592,
-0.7168065906,
-0.7140643001,
-0.4086410403,
-0.5647702217,
0.2938216925,
-0.3373375237,
0.0011507793,
-0.2023846209,
-0.354362756,
-0.9529855847,
-0.1385798305,
0.2487988919,
0.86229074,
-0.9659641981,
0.839889586,
0.9299327135,
-0.600431025,
-0.5043830872,
-0.6548737288,
-0.2057497352,
-0.571334064,
0.7259379029,
-0.6312714815,
-0.3377710581,
-0.2173752189,
-0.3849902451,
-0.7382528186,
0.6769058704,
0.4854700267,
-0.5608969331,
-0.3680493534,
0.8742423654,
0.551615417,
-0.2334344536,
0.0131989736,
0.8500183225,
0.6830046177,
0.2858562469,
-1.2190158367,
0.1874939501,
-0.3734344542,
0.2911939323,
0.2957633734,
0.1280032545,
0.6872470379,
0.5476554036,
-0.5159800053,
0.3395921886,
0.4722790718,
-0.3869919181,
-0.1969050169,
-0.0682599023,
0.3935987949,
0.6644074917,
-0.2712123394,
1.1447632313,
-0.471014142,
-0.0626252145,
0.9045500159,
0.1340154856,
0.6248003244,
0.349589318,
-0.3424499035,
0.5149057508,
0.1502112299,
0.0505552143,
0.361668855,
0.3246507943,
-0.4684906602,
0.2205228806,
-0.1375044286,
-0.6155251861,
0.0721925348,
0.6001778245,
-0.5614899397,
-0.2728851438,
-0.2502326369,
-0.0558027737,
-0.2459924668,
-0.8465073109,
0.5335789323,
0.0275209881,
-0.6518632174,
0.5260179639,
0.7147368193,
0.3857383132,
-0.9257433414,
-0.1333678961,
0.0542982109,
0.0708601177,
-0.6881785989,
-0.8698708415,
0.5988402367,
-0.1845565736,
-0.2432830334,
-0.329990387,
0.8831843734,
-0.4062176645,
-0.5363568664,
0.1741146445,
0.0056589288,
0.4107242525,
-0.1213330328,
-0.2184235901,
0.0713738427,
-0.1157938316,
-0.0066633425,
0.0480101928,
0.5236451626,
-0.1807430089,
0.3426853418,
0.4552613497,
0.5318615437,
0.4246127903,
0.2465323806,
0.752692163,
-0.8126053214,
-0.8067805767,
-0.4319632351,
0.3973074555,
0.1199011058,
0.0939739496,
0.6383554339,
0.3894291818,
0.727635026,
-0.4211218953,
1.0645115376,
-0.1020111442,
-0.1220185906,
-0.6680640578,
0.1467083842,
0.0442002937,
-0.0425113589,
-0.4886285067,
-1.4205492735,
-0.404004693,
0.7582071424,
-0.4966639578,
-0.3305657208,
0.6580308676,
0.1982949078,
-0.1576712728,
0.0320255272,
0.1514615268,
-0.0750020444,
0.6541926861,
0.8542442918,
0.5051473379,
-0.4244387448,
0.3456718326,
0.0867398307,
-0.2544621229,
-0.3150482774,
-0.6428229809,
-0.2987752557,
-0.5660399795,
-0.1005094945,
-0.1381746829,
0.1014861166,
0.4285937548,
0.5884063244,
-1.0272703171,
-0.3637791276,
-0.5191221833,
0.0834486037,
-0.156554535,
-0.217237711,
0.1583435833,
-0.7121164799,
-0.949680388,
0.2699661851,
0.5336849689,
0.2369620055,
-0.4244249761,
-0.3607524037,
-0.0363719314,
0.3033827543,
0.5838850141,
0.7991096377,
-0.5669727921,
-0.6211863756,
-0.2854596674,
-0.281406343,
-0.1006912887,
1.1161775589,
-0.3098080158,
0.3779808283,
0.8968986273,
0.4471824169,
0.3162720799,
0.1134614423,
0.92085886,
-0.8365626335,
0.3879958093,
0.2187675834,
0.3075429499,
0.0009713001,
-0.2396250963,
0.8476919532,
0.0934769884,
-0.7830577493,
-0.3196473718,
0.8296224475,
-0.9175924659,
-0.0291417986,
0.9271523952,
0.0199215282,
-0.0571251698,
-0.364530623,
-0.3699114621,
0.3439573646,
-0.1056358144,
0.2216694951,
0.8585426211,
0.0070508081,
0.2323113531,
-0.5585756898,
0.3428198099,
-0.1711865067,
-0.8156527281,
-0.5594840646,
0.4938386083,
0.0890038237,
0.5396081209,
0.9323611856,
-0.5796015859,
0.2518036664,
-0.3270322382,
0.4813463986,
0.2600079179,
-0.3514637053,
-0.4556289911,
-0.0142626017,
-0.0166423228,
-0.3203440011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08459v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08459v1 | Experiments on Generalizability of BERTopic on Multi-Domain Short Text | 2022-12-16T13:07:39 | 2022-12-16T13:07:39 | Muriël de Groot, Mohammad Aliannejadi, Marcel R. Haas | cs.CL | cs.CL | Topic modeling is widely used for analytically evaluating large collections
of textual data. One of the most popular topic techniques is Latent Dirichlet
Allocation (LDA), which is flexible and adaptive, but not optimal for e.g.
short texts from various domains. We explore how the state-of-the-art BERTopic
algorithm performs on short multi-domain text and find that it generalizes
better than LDA in terms of topic coherence and diversity. We further analyze
the performance of the HDBSCAN clustering algorithm utilized by BERTopic and
find that it classifies a majority of the documents as outliers. This crucial,
yet overseen problem excludes too many documents from further analysis. When we
replace HDBSCAN with k-Means, we achieve similar performance, but without
outliers. | [
-0.7634521723,
-1.009442091,
0.8780401945,
0.1953870207,
-0.6668442488,
0.1622998267,
-0.3288093209,
-0.3021548688,
0.4963712096,
0.2387094498,
-0.3574433923,
-0.5967367887,
-0.7460398674,
-0.1965169162,
-0.4096542895,
1.2823215723,
0.2604298294,
-0.2400139123,
-0.3069712818,
-0.3025434613,
-0.3389087617,
-0.5926353931,
-0.0996075422,
-0.1409937739,
0.5253658891,
0.4753737152,
0.8475627303,
0.1733086854,
0.913983345,
0.1740173697,
-0.4119369984,
0.111345537,
-0.5631453395,
0.0511895679,
-0.4219028056,
-0.2683436573,
-0.3718368411,
-0.2062250078,
0.8329105973,
0.8889869452,
-0.0881311074,
-0.2968021035,
0.006998945,
0.7137543559,
-0.4370348155,
-0.3745264709,
-0.6678257585,
-0.247331202,
-0.4316859841,
-0.1265988946,
-0.1760307252,
-0.2960856557,
0.7680769563,
-0.4204131365,
0.7489598393,
-0.0361621305,
0.868421495,
-0.0816700459,
-0.3444503248,
-0.6401132941,
-0.6743525863,
1.1227982044,
-0.4472136497,
0.2358840108,
0.3539834023,
0.1954567581,
-0.224575147,
-0.3579491377,
-0.4465135038,
0.0483313985,
-0.032445997,
0.1348528415,
-0.1109332293,
-0.0383800678,
-0.1486195922,
0.2957894504,
-0.678123951,
0.351445049,
-0.4397910535,
-0.0529289469,
0.406871736,
0.0331359208,
0.1225657463,
-0.2965518534,
-0.1885068119,
0.0149254333,
-0.5267636776,
-0.1006233394,
0.5099793077,
0.3052047193,
-0.0420015752,
0.3348212242,
0.0635867938,
0.4484733641,
-0.1399461627,
0.2284149379,
0.0740281269,
-0.4557477832,
0.0210313443,
-0.2687585652,
0.1376233697,
0.2167574763,
-0.139424935,
-0.1442909092,
0.0956496969,
-0.2040120661,
0.4067131281,
-0.7831863761,
-0.3675810099,
0.5074878335,
-0.7360455394,
-0.0553028099,
-0.0211257748,
-1.08476758,
-0.1471573859,
-0.036155235,
0.4821579456,
-0.3122278452,
0.0592549294,
-0.2462447882,
-0.3669751585,
-0.1452833861,
0.4476450384,
-1.1395866871,
0.2458554655,
0.7595970631,
1.0588926077,
-0.7699157596,
-0.2586451471,
0.055489596,
0.0744174868,
-0.418515265,
1.0970607996,
-0.5572910905,
-0.6535201669,
-0.2024787217,
-0.1499772668,
-0.0745240524,
-0.4694060981,
0.5087785721,
-0.7187806964,
0.3139661252,
-0.508063674,
-0.7548727393,
-0.038640637,
-0.0268078856,
-0.765458703,
0.7344427705,
-0.0247539524,
-0.8289558291,
0.5346804857,
-0.7864111066,
-0.2790182233,
-0.351691246,
-0.1915333867,
-0.8504840136,
0.1414640695,
0.1797499806,
0.6666653752,
-0.1679287255,
0.4450710118,
-0.3440636992,
-0.6692456603,
0.1863202453,
-0.1351946592,
0.5493334532,
0.2442626506,
-0.116094768,
0.1827427894,
-0.2896881402,
-0.2774661481,
0.0559833124,
-0.2216165513,
-0.7692099214,
0.3359357715,
0.118159838,
-0.1879315078,
0.1398609579,
-0.4878927171,
0.2229621708,
-0.4716216624,
0.2098156512,
0.786149621,
0.2731203139,
0.4958487749,
-0.4639024138,
-0.0214834996,
0.1810304224,
-0.0026257902,
0.0891881138,
-0.9846621752,
-0.5389149189,
-0.6728710532,
0.4371711016,
0.1650060713,
-0.5600220561,
0.4892854393,
-0.1018479392,
-0.5845200419,
-0.0935995802,
-0.0641001761,
-0.0158839077,
0.0528552234,
0.2265622914,
-0.6346693635,
0.0144241014,
-1.075807333,
0.205339551,
0.2120817006,
0.1874273419,
0.3587305844,
0.686830163,
-0.5198700428,
1.2489105463,
-0.8525636196,
-0.1451593339,
-0.1429511011,
0.5644510388,
0.4211505353,
0.5159035325,
1.138001442,
-0.9807401896,
-0.7536234856,
-0.1282196492,
-0.3508343399,
0.1838986725,
0.0131326774,
-0.4066725373,
0.1235243753,
0.05703694,
-0.486441046,
0.4328929186,
0.5001166463,
-0.1964702159,
0.4883607924,
-0.5974605083,
0.1510956585,
-1.1290975809,
0.0073507475,
-0.0474043004,
-0.011041685,
-0.745579958,
-0.1087004691,
-0.0979323015,
-0.3268776834,
0.0106103262,
0.3046047688,
-0.1760605127,
-0.2969116867,
-0.7195582986,
0.3067115247,
-0.1484516859,
0.4905760884,
0.1438613236,
0.8407536745,
0.6088622808,
-0.6413980722,
0.0914616585,
0.2573623359,
-0.2899160087,
0.53494519,
-0.5004687309,
0.0885064378,
-0.4187275171,
0.2462837398,
-1.1660203934,
-0.0704240873,
-0.1071951166,
-0.1483593881,
0.0151802758,
0.137141034,
-0.3421227634,
-0.1575289518,
-0.5666535497,
0.2613884211,
0.4777516127,
-0.7007283568,
0.1682906002,
0.2903951406,
-0.6426529288,
-0.502230823,
-0.1982176155,
-0.2292734534,
-0.3495201766,
-0.472209692,
0.6260116696,
-0.4597049654,
-0.0752736554,
0.2853318155,
-0.0330989473,
-0.7006195784,
0.1740333587,
-0.0321718715,
-0.0187663827,
-0.0473772809,
0.3628149033,
0.650393486,
0.2227119654,
-0.3545056283,
0.0557237156,
0.3202797472,
-0.0110510746,
-0.3976556659,
-0.1564861983,
0.808475554,
0.3090960681,
0.1291707158,
0.6276308298,
0.3406652212,
-0.3540849388,
-0.4186874926,
-0.2592245936,
-0.3142011166,
-0.3839311898,
0.4417706132,
-0.1565925032,
-0.9058977365,
0.6594038606,
-0.069419682,
0.1987640858,
0.5136247873,
0.6399474144,
-0.4479535222,
0.459597975,
0.9731194377,
-0.0378216654,
0.4381885827,
-0.2891942859,
0.3360991478,
-0.4193781614,
0.2306456715,
-0.758724153,
-0.2077069283,
-0.7923613787,
-0.536742568,
0.3754114807,
-0.0183185097,
0.4948654473,
0.2580690086,
-0.4617627859,
0.5211006999,
0.7105442286,
0.0756763667,
0.1492569745,
0.329335928,
0.0952924863,
-0.2959920466,
-0.433868438,
-0.424031347,
1.0699566603,
0.275380224,
0.4394174218,
0.3187873662,
0.9494882822,
0.7973783016,
0.3365339935,
-0.6422909498,
0.2518272996,
-0.8120160103,
-0.9504671097,
-0.664999783,
-0.194846943,
-0.9749910831,
0.6772602797,
-0.061959561,
-0.7794146538,
0.6976886392,
-0.048167374,
-0.3628344834,
0.2888867855,
-0.6585221291,
0.6710491776,
-0.0139089199,
-0.0286760684,
-0.6774493456,
-0.469183594,
-0.0837278217,
-0.7523462772,
0.0153879449,
-0.4122951627,
0.1816909313,
1.0462422371,
-0.186413452,
0.6541593075,
-0.1358793974,
-0.1496326476,
0.4266519845,
-0.4391258955,
0.1278667599,
0.042427469,
0.0351737626,
0.2454219162,
0.1904256642,
-0.7840857506,
-0.5861428976,
0.542987287,
-0.8319798112,
-0.5625978112,
-0.4549836814,
-0.3948837817,
-0.3285100162,
0.375395149,
0.196589008,
0.2909930646,
-0.5369312167,
0.4315515459,
0.7132203579,
-0.2157277465,
0.6311731339,
0.486238867,
0.1456973106,
-0.1846664697,
1.2710666656,
0.2636952996,
0.0745656714,
0.509871006,
0.3542624414,
-0.0628138408,
-0.8502541184,
-0.234656468,
0.1059288457,
-0.736512363,
0.150449723,
-0.6471297145,
0.0201780647,
-0.1801444441,
-0.5932844281,
-0.2932468951,
-0.3377856612,
-0.2788137197,
0.1657085866,
0.0699613765,
0.5551955104,
-0.1715851426,
0.7120163441,
-0.5990954638,
0.4900974631,
0.5347691774,
0.2745666504,
-0.092503041,
-0.2817132175,
-0.3104239702,
-0.3451434374,
-0.395950824,
-0.9134691358,
0.1345529258,
0.1500336677,
0.6118451953,
0.3074855804,
-0.0653122962,
0.1824406236,
-0.2604767978,
0.7036936283,
0.0156274028,
-0.9619874954,
0.4051886499,
-0.58158952,
0.0274524167,
0.4807880223,
0.5692277551,
-0.3066187799,
-0.3345708847,
-0.5919211507,
-0.7912901044,
0.5642015338,
0.5424675941,
0.1931764185,
0.1505252868,
0.3103021681,
0.580258131,
0.3957839608,
-0.2717496157,
-0.1102163568,
-0.0654496551,
-0.1482156366,
-0.1815392524,
-0.6077522039,
-0.1251948774,
0.094694078,
0.5850790739,
-0.2945890129,
0.6083050966,
0.0919027999,
-0.021676898,
0.101638712,
0.5465057492,
0.7462978959,
1.1171616316,
-0.7395786643,
0.0104008522,
-0.1347010583,
-0.6215894222,
0.0984633341,
0.3579571247,
-0.1436733902,
0.2072354704,
0.2774245739,
0.326648891,
0.1143505797,
-0.5986779928,
0.5310934782,
0.0052562249,
-0.0881833136,
0.2834850848,
-0.30066517,
-0.0268970057,
0.1911243945,
0.4348452985,
-0.1327706873,
0.2872227132,
-0.5483426452,
0.4138426483,
0.2549257874,
-0.0897038206,
-0.2228137255,
0.1808344722,
0.4778650999,
0.2863246202,
0.5116753578,
-0.1517029703,
-0.4412350953,
0.9150003791,
0.2604869604,
0.7524052858,
0.0924007967,
0.5433548093,
-0.2140061706,
0.197160095,
0.1996212304,
0.3815125823,
-0.03950027,
-0.9047239423,
-0.2880294323,
-0.4933674634,
-0.8796063662,
-0.246660471,
-0.5036466122,
-0.2215036303,
-0.2554565966,
-0.3474038243,
0.5745078325,
0.311789304,
-0.2149486989,
0.2460009158,
-0.2450354099,
0.4784513414,
-0.9975268245,
1.0271650553,
0.700570941,
-0.1185023338,
0.0454552844,
0.3959955871,
-0.4551072419,
-0.3627743721,
0.5568025112,
-0.0578613505,
0.1983813494,
-0.3234005868,
-0.3095234931,
-0.8694806695,
0.8206689954,
-0.0373002961,
-0.3611054718,
0.0201529022,
-0.0622152016,
0.6885539889,
0.0028185549,
-0.2758462429,
0.4575043619,
0.2633719444,
-0.1340483427,
-0.8605896235,
-0.3239068389,
0.1899145544,
-0.0000045435,
0.3207200468,
-0.8225959539,
0.978505969,
-0.1667038947,
0.0755598992,
0.1896847337,
0.7319030762,
0.1890509129,
0.7135643363,
0.3658880293,
0.3860058784,
0.9682649374,
-0.1202817783,
0.6866123676,
0.2330580354,
0.8046123385,
0.8379848003,
-0.3876926303,
0.6250870228,
0.4602766335,
-0.2208661437,
0.4704040587,
0.8100622296,
-0.0941792279,
0.9603380561,
0.0461824872,
-0.0660346746,
-0.0720155388,
-0.0625714585,
-0.3355387449,
0.2881840765,
0.4864085317,
-0.1461235285,
-0.4328508079,
0.0784818307,
-0.1730972081,
0.064974077,
-0.0970109776,
0.5696209669,
0.0041275173,
-0.3241685927,
0.0736506358,
0.4397476614,
0.891944766,
-0.5485397577,
0.0271691866,
-0.2378522754,
0.1083981693,
0.0372987315,
-0.7692101002,
0.5216724277,
-0.16605407,
-0.5682075024,
0.0350687578,
0.9183239341,
-0.2535755336,
-0.1473425329,
0.1610936075,
0.6046631932,
0.2011315823,
0.0144709973,
-0.5714519024,
-0.0300285853,
-0.196034655,
0.0630353242,
0.3807277381,
0.2638914287,
-0.4226361215,
0.3040465415,
0.325202018,
-0.1494956613,
-0.0527460054,
-0.0557887293,
0.8177380562,
-0.6960551739,
-0.974026382,
-0.4605123103,
0.0153781222,
-0.1600941271,
-0.3199787736,
0.7806903124,
0.476665467,
0.5482642651,
-0.1008753404,
0.675830543,
-0.0017501625,
0.7415959835,
-0.4371586144,
0.6293944716,
-0.5463442802,
-0.1130896062,
-0.4691270888,
-0.9717300534,
-0.1657295823,
0.3393784165,
-0.407431066,
0.1045300737,
0.76931566,
0.4502571821,
-0.1762219369,
0.1633116305,
0.4145696759,
-0.2056743503,
0.563816011,
0.1768862158,
0.6864477992,
0.0789308548,
0.2518344522,
-0.5771300793,
-0.3719779849,
-0.517835319,
-0.7299771905,
-1.1059765816,
-0.6605153084,
-0.2142328471,
0.1614890248,
0.3978480101,
0.6242660284,
1.0069433451,
-1.0580085516,
-0.239569068,
0.2546577156,
0.5860618949,
-0.1859150678,
-0.1771940887,
0.9818362594,
-0.1958621889,
-0.890184164,
0.3161619008,
0.2558463514,
0.229288891,
-0.1583258212,
0.2483554184,
-0.2301027477,
0.3636011779,
0.6832740307,
0.048844941,
-0.424743861,
-0.28202039,
-0.2120772898,
-0.1067249179,
0.0316301696,
1.0408351421,
-0.1396620423,
0.4375838339,
0.6178998947,
0.7191791534,
0.3763059378,
0.2880533934,
0.2626042664,
-0.9302841425,
0.2967012823,
0.1369277388,
0.1774505973,
0.0554323159,
-0.4175270796,
0.2978332937,
0.4996907711,
-0.6081140041,
-0.6479172707,
-0.0247898996,
-1.0422209501,
-0.8499368429,
0.6405005455,
0.1650924236,
0.0994009599,
-0.2031164169,
-0.239719063,
-0.317338258,
-0.615383327,
1.0230307579,
0.952091217,
-0.3864390254,
0.3127505481,
-0.3549732864,
0.3873018026,
0.6763547063,
-0.9699309468,
-0.2512577474,
0.4020896256,
0.3106112182,
0.3888817728,
0.8324159384,
0.2408196479,
0.3786644936,
-0.3169567287,
-0.3112618029,
0.7052919865,
-0.7286370397,
-0.291805625,
0.3771068752,
0.1992204338,
-0.1028900146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08458v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08458v1 | Fast Rule-Based Decoding: Revisiting Syntactic Rules in Neural Constituency Parsing | 2022-12-16T13:07:09 | 2022-12-16T13:07:09 | Tianyu Shi, Zhicheng Wang, Liyin Xiao, Cong Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Most recent studies on neural constituency parsing focus on encoder
structures, while few developments are devoted to decoders. Previous research
has demonstrated that probabilistic statistical methods based on syntactic
rules are particularly effective in constituency parsing, whereas syntactic
rules are not used during the training of neural models in prior work probably
due to their enormous computation requirements. In this paper, we first
implement a fast CKY decoding procedure harnessing GPU acceleration, based on
which we further derive a syntactic rule-based (rule-constrained) CKY decoding.
In the experiments, our method obtains 95.89 and 92.52 F1 on the datasets of
PTB and CTB respectively, which shows significant improvements compared with
previous approaches. Besides, our parser achieves strong and competitive
cross-domain performance in zero-shot settings. | [
0.0523476973,
-0.8622888327,
0.5649290085,
0.3956699371,
-0.6422955394,
-0.1888999492,
-0.2777564228,
-0.1951412857,
0.2152316719,
0.3202035129,
-0.2868589163,
-0.4013307095,
-0.6144375801,
0.1429123878,
-0.2831004858,
0.3464138508,
0.4326491654,
0.5311923623,
-0.0787841976,
-0.0629949719,
-0.3850910962,
-0.749769032,
-0.3062940538,
-0.168529883,
0.3473780155,
0.230806306,
0.5048518181,
1.1723519564,
0.5195015073,
0.3363902271,
-0.254847616,
-0.0002783942,
-0.1763142645,
0.0207864381,
0.2421971858,
-0.5257735252,
-0.467726469,
-0.5123435855,
0.4833457768,
0.6034260988,
-0.4191700518,
-0.2314490676,
-0.0590780228,
0.351888895,
-0.7124404311,
0.6852794886,
-0.5604544878,
-0.0227807332,
-0.2878618538,
-0.6713285446,
-0.7477875352,
-0.4894529879,
-0.2879782617,
-0.7810972333,
0.6152018905,
-0.2437071502,
0.6735717654,
0.09190429,
-0.2384577543,
-0.1793755889,
-0.1757430583,
0.3433113396,
-0.8346770406,
0.7284734249,
0.0385361724,
0.0566363148,
-0.2899563611,
-0.8659853935,
-0.5593698025,
-0.0709272102,
-0.191102311,
-0.1386989057,
-0.0345551223,
0.4350709021,
0.2767663896,
0.2599005401,
-0.5570005774,
-0.0836610943,
-0.0058932528,
-0.3321401775,
0.4241713583,
0.2352687567,
-0.0490766317,
-0.5444742441,
-0.0156511925,
-0.3511191308,
-0.7458270788,
0.0303987172,
0.4947708845,
0.4442183673,
-0.149283722,
0.3374184668,
-0.6055078506,
0.6898683906,
0.2431688905,
0.0917864218,
0.1144942194,
-0.3687472939,
-0.2240401208,
0.1644915342,
0.6188932061,
0.4321090281,
0.1995226443,
-0.2914605141,
0.0873314887,
0.194494471,
-0.1243792102,
-0.9681236744,
-0.6534195542,
-0.1554942876,
-0.8027379513,
-0.1172568798,
-0.2154727727,
-0.8451699018,
-0.3889853358,
-0.478636682,
0.1727818698,
-0.4754996896,
-0.3447324932,
0.3438076377,
-0.2404562831,
0.5427625775,
0.3340785205,
-1.2150779963,
0.3329766393,
0.8976112008,
0.5741347671,
0.425980866,
-0.0853361711,
-0.7030367255,
-0.2660765052,
-0.1980260462,
0.5986422896,
-0.678806603,
-0.1911441833,
0.1522038132,
-0.0154883591,
-0.1803777516,
-0.6922687888,
0.5533466935,
-0.5582356453,
-0.3189622462,
-0.7030958533,
-0.4347708523,
-0.0601200201,
0.0501690097,
-0.437227428,
0.439828217,
0.1397532374,
-0.5487911105,
0.6552464962,
-0.3740519881,
-0.7283180952,
0.2087551057,
-0.1183204874,
-0.0806554928,
0.5151284337,
0.5311561823,
0.4239685833,
0.0024020937,
0.502904892,
-0.5482830405,
-0.2979723513,
-0.0090243304,
-0.3830835223,
0.9653344154,
0.1317704916,
-0.2985349596,
0.2291321009,
-0.977958858,
0.3533732295,
0.1001152843,
-0.3315410316,
-0.0973086804,
0.3738638461,
0.0053103659,
0.0101166572,
-0.0882594511,
-0.6045389771,
0.2819434106,
-0.2011496127,
0.7136170268,
0.6805999279,
-0.1273460984,
0.2949708104,
0.2713024616,
0.1553184986,
0.1056011245,
-0.0167011134,
-0.1656286567,
-0.4589494765,
-0.767319262,
-0.2312162966,
0.5876578689,
0.5029844046,
-0.9207094312,
0.5052106977,
-0.2410271913,
-0.0353744514,
-0.6623366475,
-0.1649424434,
0.2305770516,
0.4143672884,
0.5253158212,
-0.2790629566,
-0.5192568898,
-0.7880212069,
-0.4011313319,
-0.4365341365,
0.1586490422,
0.2284152359,
0.1888573766,
0.4167150259,
0.4203878045,
-0.4276593626,
0.0243584774,
-0.5535036922,
0.0452212133,
0.1585107148,
0.5846189857,
0.2420423329,
-0.5207269192,
-0.274315387,
-0.0671975464,
-0.7930424809,
-0.1076627299,
-0.1377075464,
-0.0578057431,
-0.0351139531,
0.5225191116,
-0.9373464584,
0.5618373752,
0.2523727119,
-0.4407632053,
0.4617612362,
-0.2918085754,
0.0605505556,
-0.7260038853,
-0.1730909795,
-0.0017129673,
-0.3131552637,
-0.5971777439,
0.3038832247,
0.3139098287,
0.0855355933,
-0.3823685646,
0.0896668211,
-0.4819544554,
0.1886422783,
-0.274983108,
-0.4018723667,
-0.1936517507,
0.5858325958,
0.3699688911,
0.5088019371,
0.5513578057,
-0.3667043746,
0.2833220959,
0.2380260676,
-0.2259189636,
0.2866867781,
-0.6647645831,
-0.0130846342,
-0.0202888325,
0.2419424504,
-0.5535773039,
-0.1282178164,
0.4636340141,
-0.3745345175,
0.4786643684,
-0.3516826332,
-0.7114787102,
0.0534736551,
0.0136247491,
0.7759407163,
0.5715661049,
-0.8166847229,
0.3674716949,
0.2693209052,
0.1115744933,
-0.4752694666,
-0.4324782789,
0.1228786632,
0.0257994197,
-0.6079273224,
0.4145247638,
0.2183252722,
-0.2089355737,
0.1039990783,
0.0142057473,
-0.0113997255,
-0.142646715,
0.030209709,
-0.0612943769,
-0.5687950253,
-0.5620472431,
-0.1486648172,
-0.0898633078,
0.2984094024,
-0.2254640162,
0.6672993898,
0.1766102165,
0.0518632382,
-0.8221052885,
0.4942390621,
0.2216981351,
-0.2082994282,
0.3644688427,
0.3204672635,
-0.2771497369,
-0.2675077021,
-0.2663932145,
-0.5108548999,
-0.5072378516,
0.3779848218,
-0.4086497426,
-0.6056984067,
0.5211052299,
0.0691842064,
-0.5451114774,
0.2226855308,
0.5985447764,
0.2276954204,
0.9520689845,
0.6352571845,
-0.0453672931,
0.43357867,
-0.1690948159,
0.3051738739,
-0.5222058892,
-0.3168193996,
-0.6390197873,
-0.4004948437,
-0.7804868817,
-0.3754399419,
0.0243697073,
0.1195125356,
0.2762523293,
0.3908340037,
-0.238504827,
0.540079236,
0.6852341294,
0.3899819553,
-0.0404159464,
-0.0540574566,
-0.3411110938,
-0.0926103666,
-0.9284068346,
0.2485360503,
0.968293786,
0.0195855256,
0.8736730814,
-0.1564983428,
0.4622153342,
0.2006481439,
0.1119420379,
-0.8286265135,
0.967670083,
-0.2857273817,
-0.3496170044,
0.1849975139,
-0.7966355681,
-0.5523889065,
0.479554534,
-0.0057128966,
-0.7246690392,
0.6539022923,
0.2881109118,
-0.2271938473,
0.4514228404,
-0.6786935329,
0.9942834377,
-0.0056506228,
-0.5590903163,
-0.2363526374,
-0.72181952,
0.2888872027,
0.5436595678,
-0.4622306228,
-0.0055645043,
0.3810152411,
0.5229181647,
-0.6130082607,
0.5036140084,
-0.7307309508,
0.3449749649,
0.1613761932,
-0.0807684883,
0.2982673347,
0.1668422669,
0.0474908203,
0.4012562335,
-0.0774502754,
-0.5392404795,
-0.5766922832,
0.5117316246,
-0.3940513432,
-0.5592601895,
-0.5073024631,
-0.6613947749,
-0.1656536609,
0.0812130272,
0.1699192375,
0.7308847904,
-0.0067338441,
0.5700124502,
0.5414583087,
0.0878702924,
0.6812651157,
0.2500787675,
0.4637108445,
-0.6155923605,
0.825055182,
-0.0511506721,
-0.1633168161,
0.7133768797,
-0.0183645766,
-0.6652154922,
-1.0596625805,
-0.6284011006,
0.2764491439,
-0.5229769945,
-0.3299586177,
-0.3949775398,
-0.0359067619,
-0.5011447668,
0.0703249425,
-0.1368589401,
-0.5847401619,
-0.08698228,
0.0750941411,
-0.2247083634,
0.4348029196,
-0.0634520277,
0.5916498899,
-0.60926193,
0.4871940911,
-0.0734951496,
0.3372738361,
-0.1719926596,
-0.150627315,
-0.0920060724,
-0.2045276463,
-0.3350450397,
-1.0626411438,
0.5563135147,
0.0676863641,
0.5806105733,
0.508146584,
0.130882442,
0.9293146133,
-0.5610235929,
0.4848876894,
0.0142370937,
-1.030092001,
0.2660419047,
-0.3564792871,
0.2845903337,
0.5009406209,
-0.0049076215,
-0.2602991462,
-0.1473519206,
-0.5262543559,
-0.7241895795,
0.7959015965,
0.0942351446,
0.128234908,
-0.1257827282,
0.4363442361,
0.1574959308,
0.1761129946,
-0.370038271,
-0.0764857158,
-0.224578619,
-0.3848887682,
0.047242146,
-0.1572363377,
-0.0153768221,
-0.6324168444,
0.4438697994,
-0.4364333451,
0.4314801395,
0.292206049,
-0.2763454914,
0.0644591749,
0.2822760046,
0.6520290375,
0.6695880294,
-0.3590345383,
-0.0403754972,
-0.2217812687,
-0.5148165822,
0.0757431984,
0.5250810981,
-0.3426156342,
0.0962209329,
0.1542507261,
0.8390160799,
0.1882331222,
-0.2379526198,
0.5022376776,
-0.5401985645,
-0.4538400471,
0.1686186045,
0.0320862606,
-0.013682886,
0.3428460956,
0.1494580507,
0.111001201,
0.2154398561,
-0.3623017371,
0.2649768889,
0.4811194539,
0.1097343341,
-0.6787061095,
0.8960950971,
0.2817378044,
-0.1853279322,
0.8328280449,
-0.1678707153,
-0.5549279451,
0.5695140958,
0.7781279087,
0.9025984406,
0.0062433314,
0.096519351,
0.3002476692,
0.1246604025,
0.027771702,
0.7245204449,
-0.4203359783,
-0.6197535992,
-0.4674346447,
-0.6985697746,
-0.2329646647,
0.2656549811,
-0.7589954138,
0.0999540165,
-0.6308699846,
-0.0496915728,
0.1638720781,
-0.0400171801,
-0.586258769,
0.2293045074,
0.0909104347,
1.1252501011,
-0.4041600227,
1.0740714073,
0.4557910264,
0.0931402519,
-0.7648727298,
0.1691225916,
-0.0434609577,
-0.8190558553,
0.4431233406,
0.195766896,
0.30856359,
-0.0121177305,
-0.2822416425,
-0.2720849812,
0.6827609539,
0.7311339378,
-0.6177803874,
-0.1417728215,
0.2756953835,
0.4117379785,
-0.2716361582,
0.1577596664,
0.5339869857,
0.3430659175,
-0.2664827406,
-0.6501255035,
0.2195254117,
-0.3505630791,
-0.2631507218,
0.4855519533,
-0.5920603871,
0.7845468521,
-0.2710418999,
0.0108832214,
0.2549188733,
0.7601000071,
-0.0114844367,
0.4612753093,
0.4254709482,
0.9021730423,
0.3487541378,
-0.4090060294,
0.9908183217,
-0.6648482084,
0.2362573296,
0.7239498496,
-0.1487649977,
1.0163340569,
0.5058877468,
-0.0898654163,
0.4566116631,
0.5657388568,
0.1199386939,
0.793233335,
0.1631521285,
-0.3008592427,
-0.4961774945,
-0.0704629645,
-0.4812124372,
0.7584739923,
0.2743552625,
-0.4642390609,
-0.425642848,
-0.5600579977,
0.0339612663,
-0.109409146,
-0.3257561624,
0.7431455255,
-0.1010592803,
-0.6072610021,
0.6131099463,
0.2075046152,
0.4092280865,
-0.7866891623,
-0.3826799095,
-0.2684962153,
0.5734032393,
-0.0857997537,
-0.4335813522,
-0.0032741532,
-0.2753885686,
-0.167737782,
-0.2230443209,
0.7943874598,
-0.4959430099,
-0.2420028001,
0.2353974134,
0.459341377,
-0.1217891648,
-0.0909686908,
-0.4713401198,
0.1299254447,
-0.0824435279,
0.0630916357,
0.4123533964,
0.2764770687,
0.0803472921,
0.2461952418,
0.8235517144,
0.2742422223,
0.3942638338,
0.1003840566,
1.0233294964,
-0.807169199,
-0.7619399428,
-0.8517680764,
0.4020029008,
-0.0218400937,
-0.2935750484,
0.6464056969,
0.6246840358,
1.0241212845,
-0.1050841659,
0.4743966758,
-0.435102433,
-0.3201675713,
-0.7356796861,
0.746988833,
-0.3903151751,
-0.0679638982,
0.3346388042,
-0.6449021697,
-0.452147007,
0.3737095892,
-0.1159491539,
-0.009554862,
0.6837980747,
1.0171169043,
-0.1974957585,
0.3978330493,
0.3313157856,
0.0282871872,
0.2133214176,
0.6737539172,
0.6586595178,
-0.2975739539,
0.3939668536,
-0.5271014571,
-0.0528454073,
-0.3007459641,
-0.7559377551,
-0.5442479849,
-0.3663492203,
-0.1985842139,
-0.5514019728,
0.5335313678,
0.6647005677,
1.0899082422,
-0.8653542995,
-0.2497683316,
-0.2287382334,
0.0728618279,
-0.4341335297,
-0.26498878,
0.3830861449,
-0.4336497188,
-0.4977695942,
0.6813628078,
0.0964320153,
-0.5727244616,
0.1709777266,
-0.286262095,
-0.1051721498,
-0.0745012388,
0.4708808959,
0.331189543,
-0.5095241666,
-0.2010284662,
0.0633687899,
0.1049139798,
0.4472126961,
1.4926389456,
-0.9599651098,
0.4143968523,
1.009719491,
0.7261490226,
0.3057014048,
0.2760072052,
0.4252313972,
-0.6747376323,
0.1475720257,
0.2847149968,
0.4886029363,
0.3152222633,
-0.3384809792,
0.1913985461,
0.8731604218,
-0.4782946408,
-0.8034726977,
-0.0276803914,
-1.2352645397,
-0.0571082123,
0.9174454808,
-0.136115104,
-0.5442718267,
0.1748130322,
0.08320456,
0.1731668115,
-0.5318285227,
0.5173875093,
0.5143220425,
-0.3540411592,
-0.403857708,
-0.3387951553,
0.4598016143,
0.4749404192,
-0.6911026835,
0.5102145076,
0.6252651811,
0.4203313589,
-0.1831000894,
0.645370543,
-0.2451235801,
0.6354308724,
0.5787174702,
-0.3047734201,
-0.1785446256,
-0.6559976339,
-0.5589466691,
0.7350435853,
-0.2375939339,
-0.290974021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.14672v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.14672v1 | Twitter's Agenda-Setting Role: A Study of Twitter Strategy for Political Diversion | 2022-12-16T11:34:49 | 2022-12-16T11:34:49 | Yuyang Chen, Xiaoyu Cui, Yunjie Song, Manli Wu | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.SI | This study verified the effectiveness of Donald Trump's Twitter campaign in
guiding agen-da-setting and deflecting political risk and examined Trump's
Twitter communication strategy and explores the communication effects of his
tweet content during Covid-19 pandemic. We collected all tweets posted by Trump
on the Twitter platform from January 1, 2020 to December 31, 2020.We used
Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) regression analysis with a fixed effects model to
analyze the existence of the Twitter strategy. The correlation between the
number of con-firmed daily Covid-19 diagnoses and the number of particular
thematic tweets was investigated using time series analysis. Empirical analysis
revealed Twitter's strategy is used to divert public attention from negative
Covid-19 reports during the epidemic, and it posts a powerful political
communication effect on Twitter. However, findings suggest that Trump did not
use false claims to divert political risk and shape public opinion. | [
-0.3856968582,
-1.0586336851,
0.2948631048,
0.3224793077,
-0.421661675,
0.3124617338,
-0.2143469006,
0.1446428746,
0.6297969818,
0.4686883986,
-0.6847900748,
-0.1605284959,
-0.5834226012,
-0.0863888115,
-0.5862187147,
1.0654401779,
0.3374382257,
-0.5234335065,
0.3438061476,
0.2426631004,
-0.3694165051,
0.0500556603,
-1.1168545485,
-0.3549554348,
1.0139853954,
0.51828897,
0.9001370072,
0.6223660111,
0.7351471186,
0.0845630318,
0.2289123684,
-0.2538196146,
-0.9408467412,
-0.0521699637,
-0.4170681238,
-0.1600265801,
-0.0787005499,
0.4365468919,
0.4908978045,
0.052907411,
-0.2184536159,
0.2571579218,
-0.1166537106,
0.6900711656,
-0.316231966,
-0.4051340222,
-0.6875510812,
-0.3755200505,
-0.527752161,
-0.7399311662,
-0.2127928883,
-0.2821799219,
0.2784974575,
-0.2775656283,
0.1078672037,
0.1369915158,
0.775452733,
0.093620725,
-0.6852678657,
-0.1078977212,
-0.9885451794,
0.6927150488,
-0.2629886568,
-0.2112771273,
0.4767874181,
0.502450645,
-0.148143366,
-0.4024952948,
-0.1323264539,
0.3983115256,
0.4379413426,
0.136710465,
-0.1819714308,
-0.1627125442,
-0.0846978351,
-0.1381305605,
-0.1431920826,
-0.3663021326,
-0.9205620885,
-0.0022116983,
0.8998724222,
-0.1280790567,
0.5309048891,
-0.0503641926,
-0.5159981847,
0.0201134365,
-0.8031227589,
0.1549383551,
-0.0170203187,
0.4554767311,
-0.3855952024,
0.4925680161,
0.1670494974,
0.2553707063,
0.1585914642,
-0.1430593133,
-0.3650797606,
-0.2825363874,
-0.4714083672,
0.4385945797,
0.5916302204,
0.5650568008,
0.1484312117,
-0.0811711177,
-0.0709501058,
-0.2544782162,
0.6521155238,
-0.5589446425,
-0.0903365687,
0.3571175635,
-0.5142314434,
-0.4412962496,
0.225349769,
-1.1380186081,
-0.7489491701,
0.1431642473,
0.6272423863,
-0.293309927,
-0.4616824687,
-0.0541673191,
-0.5345426202,
0.0918679833,
0.4931949079,
-0.3623119295,
0.3473854661,
0.5622937679,
0.9537391067,
-0.2649423778,
0.3560366035,
-0.714762032,
0.363357693,
-0.8759719133,
0.4413312674,
-0.5258427262,
-0.4034181833,
0.387211144,
-0.3363975883,
-0.1521237344,
0.0355399586,
0.5611470938,
-0.563929379,
0.191257,
-0.6873303652,
-0.0487290882,
-0.1437302828,
0.2448919564,
-0.6774389148,
0.416660279,
-0.405290693,
-0.7035963535,
0.4840248525,
-1.0776821375,
-0.4996225834,
-0.128217712,
-0.0540594533,
-0.1940955222,
0.0520928279,
0.2914715409,
0.4311082959,
-0.4535066783,
0.128626585,
-0.1102016494,
-0.1013509184,
-0.2171974927,
-0.4317668974,
1.059147954,
0.1548578739,
-0.5923702121,
0.1803260148,
-0.3136444092,
-0.2939555645,
0.2406659275,
0.0201730374,
-0.415546149,
0.1195239201,
-0.0148628484,
0.5291887522,
-0.0368038826,
-0.5512997508,
0.0904738083,
-0.124450013,
0.5720682144,
0.4856146574,
0.7742174864,
0.594186604,
-0.7370243669,
0.7095693946,
-0.1975729764,
0.3918135166,
0.5024809837,
-0.6861361265,
-0.4540325701,
0.1900752634,
-0.3505603373,
0.7892855406,
-0.6527727246,
-0.1186203286,
-0.2271577418,
-0.3144346178,
0.02645717,
-0.5820326805,
0.1121452078,
0.2194303721,
0.1675803065,
0.369772315,
-0.5658715963,
-0.5880963206,
-0.3884347081,
0.0901914686,
0.6008856297,
-0.0429927036,
0.5482048988,
0.2344481647,
0.7319905162,
-0.0391922072,
-0.219411552,
-0.3556700349,
0.2810550928,
-0.0099171428,
0.2289647311,
0.5529802442,
-0.9543769956,
-0.5792398453,
-0.1609749496,
-0.0941080898,
-0.070263952,
-0.3106102347,
-0.3060598075,
-0.0038772861,
0.5224633217,
-0.2053396106,
0.9960796237,
0.3530733585,
-0.3235572278,
0.1882264316,
0.0749492198,
0.5139094591,
-1.3749207258,
-0.2583667636,
0.0962995291,
-0.1684886515,
-1.0642722845,
-0.5753327608,
-0.3166763186,
0.0370735601,
-0.3147805035,
0.4784709215,
-0.2017619759,
0.3069010973,
-0.3060075343,
0.2764725983,
0.0351862758,
-0.5946721435,
-0.3677403629,
0.5325317383,
0.411244303,
-0.3919868767,
-0.1158536226,
0.0215262324,
-0.0428598337,
0.435801357,
-0.6048102379,
0.2526274323,
-0.0931579843,
0.1638295352,
-1.227696538,
0.0056732357,
0.4342063665,
-0.4659748971,
0.2487587184,
0.1206564233,
0.0223349985,
-0.5169236064,
-0.2711834908,
-0.0490610562,
0.3101841807,
-0.1481795609,
0.5510371923,
0.4398680031,
0.1691080034,
-0.3977094293,
-0.700745523,
0.4817077518,
-0.7581129074,
-0.5066764355,
0.6569231153,
0.6153553128,
-0.6968559027,
-0.0117065171,
-0.3348171711,
0.0446439348,
-0.0023065226,
0.1203810498,
-0.2149933875,
0.1143390387,
0.0706228614,
-0.165140301,
0.2108015418,
0.2042170912,
-0.1128041223,
0.7339719534,
0.1911153942,
0.0013645057,
-0.5263393521,
0.7024726868,
0.3546123803,
-0.1417300999,
0.9829633236,
0.5959119201,
-0.403741926,
0.003806799,
-0.4842282236,
-0.1243393645,
-0.4382872283,
-0.0274820477,
-0.0181555506,
-0.4345018268,
0.5254973173,
0.0317773446,
0.3619711399,
0.7363201976,
0.2765742242,
-0.0221572481,
0.5559042096,
0.5750541091,
-0.197050035,
0.4307852387,
-0.430226624,
0.440746069,
-0.3717297018,
-0.1815010905,
-0.5992594361,
-0.3179692924,
-0.5693981051,
-0.23796992,
0.1908817142,
-0.1565441787,
-0.4009367526,
-0.030825844,
-0.4566208422,
0.0010223547,
0.6855357885,
0.222806558,
-0.3010320663,
-0.085887894,
0.4224228561,
0.1130333096,
-0.6050115824,
-0.4296140969,
0.7116109729,
-0.0021160734,
0.6109501719,
0.0282911919,
0.8165182471,
0.6457176805,
0.0779047534,
-0.1865253597,
0.4890522957,
-0.0498055518,
-0.8183898926,
-0.68242836,
-0.0436760932,
-0.9395510554,
-0.3047249317,
-0.1015341729,
-0.7003635764,
0.148108542,
-0.1068263128,
-0.2448820919,
0.4533074796,
-0.5446369648,
0.326062113,
-0.2208923101,
-0.261177063,
-0.5715684295,
-0.5912325978,
0.0218859762,
0.184263438,
0.1816045046,
-0.5193169713,
-0.4699900746,
1.0991004705,
-0.1848797947,
0.7148413062,
-0.5054659843,
0.2676427066,
0.0978549942,
-0.1775492877,
0.5125603676,
0.263364166,
-0.0410675444,
-0.1618983746,
0.0121552432,
-0.5127882957,
-0.0561587289,
0.5764378905,
-0.6846005917,
-1.0691627264,
-0.4672335982,
-0.6036310792,
0.016933931,
0.2515737116,
0.529776454,
0.5086534619,
-0.5236323476,
0.4875737429,
0.3770677447,
-0.0489150323,
0.7415730357,
-0.3052569628,
-0.1849715263,
-0.5671045184,
0.3704748154,
0.3849119842,
0.3375542164,
0.5435052514,
0.8198005557,
0.0426200218,
-0.2902542949,
0.091363512,
-0.0152510488,
-0.1125967577,
-0.1067798883,
-0.1608234793,
-0.3081428707,
-0.5166327357,
-0.352071166,
-0.2308241874,
-0.1508968174,
-0.1991489232,
0.2055131048,
0.7758554816,
0.7610400319,
0.0154088335,
0.6981984973,
-0.0814093426,
0.2039745748,
0.0588252172,
-0.0505335853,
-0.2432425618,
-0.1980511993,
-0.2564804852,
0.2859427929,
-0.4120641649,
-0.9524855018,
0.4955637753,
0.4924885929,
0.3402520418,
0.8415842652,
0.5041849613,
0.6736652851,
-0.4751805961,
0.828134954,
0.1679525822,
-0.5018446445,
0.8398981094,
-0.913541615,
0.2711908519,
0.3304806352,
0.4934992492,
-0.5385454297,
-0.4013490975,
-0.8128511906,
-0.4974923432,
0.6527190804,
0.5550021529,
0.0568789355,
-0.1638001651,
0.3251337111,
-0.1562443525,
0.2516781092,
-0.0367399491,
-0.5653092265,
-0.2981716096,
0.1733650118,
-0.0541799814,
-0.3380018473,
-0.7377569675,
-0.2434301674,
0.4743016064,
0.5696575046,
0.499558568,
0.3155733347,
0.681978941,
-0.2392740846,
0.1409213096,
0.9555034637,
0.9665572047,
-0.3770422935,
0.0505349301,
-0.4891429245,
-0.7115507722,
-0.0359097607,
-0.0129302554,
-0.1346871406,
0.0289789494,
0.1366144568,
0.4371168017,
-0.4925381541,
0.1552783549,
0.360440433,
0.0499233045,
-0.3590635359,
-0.2823001742,
-0.1079764366,
0.2307203412,
0.325320214,
1.0313545465,
0.0411014482,
-0.1236966774,
-0.5532668233,
0.246958524,
0.6429371834,
-0.4583192766,
-0.5249298811,
0.8529546857,
0.2918300629,
-0.7676540613,
0.3117792606,
0.1813119352,
-0.3918373883,
0.7851328254,
0.6083536744,
0.977557838,
-0.6225547791,
0.3760367632,
0.045074407,
0.732842207,
0.122788094,
0.586579144,
0.4404260218,
-0.5039826632,
-0.2733362913,
0.2910455763,
0.0353495888,
0.5288378,
-0.5473860502,
0.3004788756,
-0.5498868823,
-0.7438120246,
0.092265144,
0.2204976976,
-0.4340188503,
0.3738825023,
-0.2648233473,
1.1037033796,
-0.8958377242,
0.5406398773,
0.4648830593,
-0.1986080557,
-0.5666523576,
0.774415493,
0.2444312274,
-0.6577560902,
0.2943557501,
0.2225346118,
-0.1937773079,
-0.0915741771,
-0.8780483007,
-1.06001544,
1.0849472284,
0.0851228014,
0.021725107,
0.2286471725,
0.2309032232,
0.1725562513,
-0.6577586532,
-0.49381724,
0.26519382,
0.3282182217,
0.1838733554,
-0.7404178977,
0.1281314641,
-0.2849741876,
0.065412119,
0.6314408183,
-0.8714434505,
0.4497689307,
-0.0817628503,
-0.2901394367,
-0.4874050021,
0.2481627613,
-0.2736080289,
0.7479736805,
0.5391251445,
0.2306403518,
0.4003943801,
-0.1451149732,
0.9053830504,
-0.2592939138,
0.0085637877,
0.593872726,
0.1460342258,
0.5562919378,
0.9334077239,
0.1735249758,
0.0552234203,
0.5641524196,
0.4295214713,
1.0121277571,
0.1431365162,
-0.0603880733,
0.1529967189,
-0.3932642639,
-0.2669718564,
0.0624339245,
0.6999675035,
-0.3237838745,
-0.3879611492,
0.2139705569,
0.2351848781,
0.0734841228,
-0.3820343018,
0.3086716235,
-0.0361585803,
-0.5428114533,
0.2270728201,
-0.236676544,
0.2161185145,
-0.2945527732,
0.0030111431,
0.1998707503,
0.0003530041,
-0.1427987516,
-0.6289594173,
0.878120482,
-0.5186635852,
0.1149543673,
-0.3141791224,
0.7919077277,
-0.2079354972,
-0.3136710227,
0.0052902335,
0.62275213,
-0.2941878736,
-0.1364973187,
-0.7760357857,
-0.0531808771,
-0.1274251044,
-0.3556306362,
0.0193763711,
0.6291413307,
-0.16969724,
0.6641766429,
0.3990620673,
0.2239573002,
-0.165145129,
0.1127664447,
0.3974399567,
-0.5978010893,
-0.4237310886,
-0.9428028464,
0.1953017265,
-0.5256307125,
-0.4394887984,
0.8389444351,
0.4437409639,
0.1864551306,
0.162887603,
0.7386438251,
-0.6760002971,
0.5502055883,
-0.0015956813,
0.8159159422,
-0.5263553262,
0.0394285768,
-0.1217026487,
-0.1746886969,
-0.2867265344,
0.2654198706,
-0.8560487032,
0.1245412454,
0.5951731205,
0.4946036935,
0.3278052807,
-0.0594201125,
0.0994678587,
-0.0963637903,
0.6068800688,
-0.0518023819,
0.3846902847,
-0.0314009562,
0.7336142063,
-0.5180912614,
-0.2713420987,
-0.5547299385,
-0.7320549488,
-1.1593558788,
-0.9884340763,
-0.1970663518,
-0.6738980412,
0.608782053,
0.990693152,
0.5906326175,
-0.3139446378,
-0.145473361,
-0.2708650231,
0.0021589051,
-0.4053589106,
-0.2659819722,
0.6849393249,
0.1045761108,
-0.4105114043,
-0.3126007318,
0.5435647964,
-0.2790678442,
-0.2029846758,
0.6389520168,
-1.0056784153,
0.4430632293,
0.5083668232,
0.1038798913,
-0.7009552717,
-0.5629252791,
0.4609187245,
-0.3182435632,
0.2589399517,
0.5226673484,
-0.2777855098,
0.0867578983,
0.6389698386,
0.3858038485,
0.0899795219,
0.2787389159,
0.8660790324,
-0.4522761106,
-0.1146940589,
0.3884921968,
-0.0631352291,
0.2141634077,
-0.7980861664,
0.4729973972,
0.0108442195,
-0.6199352145,
-0.3927558661,
-0.0213937648,
-1.0722885132,
0.0839651003,
1.4851930141,
0.4269981086,
-0.3620963395,
-0.4064817727,
-0.2555431426,
0.3983627856,
-0.9565660954,
1.1578891277,
0.7820965648,
-0.1335908473,
-0.2700873315,
-0.9947171807,
0.5529720783,
-0.3297622502,
-0.5975722671,
-0.3938077092,
-0.1424374878,
0.1089666635,
0.0870549679,
0.7729569674,
0.1975565851,
0.267559588,
-0.2275148332,
-0.5563353896,
0.3010292053,
-0.3696594834,
0.2104374021,
0.0785768181,
-0.4728297591,
-0.6718159914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08410v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08410v3 | Teaching Small Language Models to Reason | 2022-12-16T11:24:42 | 2023-06-01T12:17:01 | Lucie Charlotte Magister, Jonathan Mallinson, Jakub Adamek, Eric Malmi, Aliaksei Severyn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Chain of thought prompting successfully improves the reasoning capabilities
of large language models, achieving state of the art results on a range of
datasets. However, these reasoning capabilities only appear to emerge in models
with a size of over 100 billion parameters. In this paper, we explore the
transfer of such reasoning capabilities to models with less than 100 billion
parameters via knowledge distillation. Specifically, we finetune a student
model on the chain of thought outputs generated by a larger teacher model. Our
experiments show that the proposed method improves task performance across
arithmetic, commonsense and symbolic reasoning datasets. For example, the
accuracy of T5 XXL on GSM8K improves from 8.11% to 21.99% when finetuned on
PaLM-540B generated chains of thought. | [
-0.6018920541,
-0.7499856353,
0.9604073763,
-0.3608800769,
-0.3315087855,
-0.1747165769,
-0.384183228,
-0.2020035535,
-0.1873756051,
0.5258091688,
-0.3414496779,
0.000695513,
-0.5109642744,
-0.0349437073,
-0.3767759502,
1.0003204346,
0.196619004,
-0.0683935583,
-0.0309283771,
0.1753697246,
-0.4059937,
-0.4645144939,
-0.8195250034,
-0.5266298652,
0.5207538009,
0.6828815937,
0.5696801543,
0.422316581,
0.1537230313,
0.2408031374,
-0.0163085125,
0.3865809739,
-0.4528282881,
-0.1073204577,
-0.6635647416,
-0.7094790339,
-0.2992881835,
-0.0451416336,
0.3920219541,
0.8749509454,
-0.1779421866,
0.3083363175,
0.1795336306,
0.9819651246,
-0.4809808731,
-0.0647838637,
-0.8186750412,
-0.4135411978,
0.0356803238,
0.1538128704,
-0.7492426634,
-0.5432094336,
0.3834516704,
-0.4607758522,
0.0451241471,
0.1975273937,
0.4282537997,
0.2988813519,
-0.4791043103,
-0.3547533751,
-0.7477734685,
0.6728838086,
-0.8363714814,
0.1195810959,
0.436037451,
0.4770922065,
-0.2652505636,
-0.9747372866,
-0.8467095494,
-0.0635663345,
0.0564948618,
-0.268389672,
-0.2226816565,
0.0729237273,
0.8360317945,
0.3318370581,
-0.0172897764,
-0.2099920064,
-0.7321765423,
0.220032841,
0.6192221045,
0.0437104851,
0.0487925485,
-0.1222425699,
-0.0485917106,
-0.2939512134,
-0.6849737763,
0.0740442201,
0.290822506,
0.3691698313,
0.1835839003,
0.3991336823,
-0.2874082327,
1.0306116343,
0.2934142947,
-0.2205369174,
-0.4236316681,
-0.1553819925,
-0.47350052,
0.175374642,
0.5368527174,
0.1322239488,
0.5102943182,
0.299844116,
-0.0263606012,
-0.0314378552,
0.2774718106,
-0.8497179151,
-0.8606205583,
-0.0147441775,
-0.2800470591,
-0.2066168934,
-0.0238209143,
-0.5871801376,
-0.4220695198,
-0.6620413065,
0.5168396831,
-0.4550391138,
-0.315371871,
0.5294281244,
-0.3272610903,
-0.4006893039,
0.6001355052,
-1.1317631006,
0.4133065045,
0.4305397868,
0.5782907605,
0.1497091502,
0.0349949412,
-0.2984361351,
0.0793311745,
-0.3842359185,
0.5512828827,
-0.5203489661,
-0.0739050657,
-0.4242785871,
-0.1107194275,
-0.2180324942,
-0.5639696717,
0.4998805821,
-0.3091011047,
0.0872708634,
-0.674429059,
-0.5622976422,
-0.4713926613,
0.1354696602,
-0.7020207644,
0.9797514677,
0.0097493269,
-0.6995484829,
0.2813957036,
-0.5406197906,
-0.4025951028,
-0.1325042546,
-0.0490723513,
0.1489709318,
0.3476811349,
0.3393204212,
0.4646948576,
-0.5792655349,
0.4009923935,
-0.46882236,
-0.1503700167,
0.1986138374,
-0.5867678523,
0.7339963913,
0.4127477705,
-0.324894309,
-0.1352094114,
-0.7819228768,
0.3473207057,
-0.0252253059,
-0.0619818047,
-0.9061469436,
-0.1391687244,
-0.5656015873,
0.4762165248,
-0.1021964028,
-0.2808068097,
0.6445843577,
-0.2619688809,
0.8386261463,
0.588909328,
0.1057622433,
0.4753976166,
-0.3396832943,
0.2482831329,
0.2051557153,
-0.1568116248,
0.1347741336,
-0.5690792799,
-1.1871542931,
0.0507381558,
0.2539532781,
0.1106812954,
-1.1376818419,
0.1055481508,
-0.1855434328,
-0.6727722287,
-0.6095994711,
0.167571336,
0.1254169196,
0.7059900761,
0.3679811954,
0.1081776768,
-0.3979968131,
-0.7348374724,
-0.1973336041,
-0.3055959046,
-0.0160969887,
0.0836015716,
0.6540488005,
0.2137055099,
0.7278051972,
-0.6470549703,
0.1356133521,
-0.4285157621,
0.0760188848,
0.4553143084,
0.5122926235,
0.2739386559,
-0.4119250774,
-0.4054083824,
0.1845336705,
-0.5279973745,
0.0817936063,
-0.1881954372,
-0.3798160851,
0.0294671375,
0.2955419123,
-0.5067982674,
0.3188971281,
0.335219413,
-0.2502111495,
0.4631130993,
-0.3549105227,
0.1485430151,
-1.094020009,
0.0499647893,
0.0456931926,
-0.2636403739,
-0.5362519622,
-0.2067790926,
-0.0152340196,
-0.0300617851,
-0.4282717109,
0.3818961978,
-0.2954313159,
0.102338165,
-0.4051074088,
0.2272628546,
0.1638762206,
0.4043815732,
-0.0328765213,
0.677151978,
0.5471254587,
-0.9353609085,
0.4897792041,
-0.0839039832,
-0.5200607181,
0.5582486987,
-0.5865696669,
0.3331230879,
0.1831206381,
0.1981164664,
-0.9175900221,
-0.179637447,
-0.0438964739,
0.1127930582,
-0.0491334386,
-0.2644824088,
-0.4440941811,
-0.7939831614,
0.0738345608,
0.3160107434,
0.6538721323,
-0.8532974124,
0.3723468781,
0.1133372858,
0.0184224639,
-0.1809178442,
-0.7093952894,
-0.2247064114,
-0.4262475967,
-0.6149095297,
-0.1048383862,
0.0790454745,
-0.5315143466,
-0.1071895882,
-0.2391437441,
0.0190311968,
-0.029123066,
0.069193013,
0.2281773984,
-0.1186461747,
0.4363769591,
0.4866125584,
0.1540460587,
0.2823675871,
-0.8568738103,
0.3773101866,
-0.3037833869,
-0.2426489145,
-0.4004735947,
-0.1013275906,
0.5957043767,
0.1322751641,
0.7898460627,
0.1032839417,
-0.3116339147,
-0.7364413142,
-0.4640825391,
-0.5794734359,
-0.5140149593,
-0.1233932376,
-0.700252533,
-0.8782544136,
0.3557560742,
-0.4424826801,
-0.1954093128,
0.4426966608,
0.3355413079,
-0.0295008663,
1.026709199,
0.4086631835,
-0.0343421623,
0.1703213602,
-0.4572538137,
0.430911392,
-0.6906246543,
-0.0980690271,
-0.3163476884,
-0.3230415881,
-0.3925348222,
-0.5577206016,
0.2737145722,
0.5536752939,
-0.3964232802,
0.2691528797,
-0.6608310938,
0.6737801433,
0.6661933661,
0.3362043202,
0.4655311704,
0.0988084003,
-0.3161619604,
0.0882632285,
-1.063909173,
-0.7103501558,
0.9575740695,
0.1731674671,
0.9123253822,
0.1054115072,
0.6555196047,
0.2444725782,
0.1995128542,
-0.6736601591,
0.6434782743,
-0.280619055,
-0.5856490135,
-0.4114209116,
-0.4304201007,
-0.4484192729,
0.3386258483,
0.0044946847,
-0.7797846198,
0.2088594735,
0.2796836793,
-0.5271036029,
0.581237793,
-0.9345013499,
0.6842176914,
-0.063000381,
-0.339451313,
-0.3694714308,
-0.3620947003,
0.68652004,
-0.0741069838,
0.1272621751,
0.0355699584,
0.5074244738,
0.9279425144,
-0.7705962658,
0.8035659194,
-0.1408092976,
-0.3709237874,
0.7901728153,
0.2757895589,
0.7045869827,
-0.1263289303,
-0.2232133299,
-0.1555348486,
0.1162364781,
-0.2381412983,
-0.9220719934,
0.7230716944,
-0.4628086686,
-1.0620658398,
-0.0421660766,
-0.5547862649,
-0.2052710056,
0.3081384003,
0.1085890606,
0.2546047866,
0.3928666711,
0.1591246426,
0.6847593784,
0.2899758816,
0.5134286284,
0.1505526751,
-0.2559016645,
-0.2481589913,
0.7703965306,
0.2901497483,
0.7827131748,
-0.1728289127,
0.4157007039,
-0.3518404961,
-0.2201400399,
-0.6887339354,
0.1122438014,
-0.9240244627,
-0.1000670716,
-0.4959540367,
-0.089132309,
-0.2476991266,
-0.0586406216,
-0.3875434697,
-0.7514680624,
-0.2214229852,
-0.293586731,
0.7220565677,
0.8737372756,
0.029236434,
0.2573240399,
-0.6227523685,
0.1004606485,
0.6864061952,
-0.0161085967,
0.6268512607,
-0.7848143578,
-0.2359695435,
0.3864084482,
-0.3250103891,
-0.6896586418,
0.2894943953,
0.1136783659,
0.3033160269,
0.5899170637,
0.4599009454,
1.10513556,
-0.3486230373,
0.658028245,
0.3278576732,
-1.3435108662,
0.9947701693,
-0.3291198313,
0.3013626635,
0.4992925227,
0.5067222118,
-0.3771991432,
-0.4057289064,
-0.7866348028,
-0.2946205437,
0.6992914081,
0.0264463909,
-0.0915107653,
-0.0127076516,
0.4100180566,
0.1588215232,
0.0729163885,
-0.5292807221,
-0.0579826571,
-0.0075857509,
-0.1467493922,
0.2596719563,
0.0009507612,
-0.1140785441,
-0.7054060102,
0.6998950839,
-0.4321966171,
-0.1496382803,
0.1710999757,
0.1248632744,
-0.1487123966,
0.405046761,
0.5671333075,
0.7733615637,
0.1653086096,
0.7323477864,
0.4645574987,
-0.2927154303,
0.3485991955,
-0.2943659425,
-0.0604792275,
-0.3561106026,
0.1859137416,
0.8414173126,
0.0649619326,
-0.3907022476,
0.0412217602,
0.1608897746,
-0.3352155387,
0.1809498668,
0.6508185863,
0.1980093271,
0.4908539653,
0.3924536407,
0.1654946506,
0.1652443707,
-0.5807572007,
0.0980852991,
-0.0554805361,
-0.1280229092,
-0.3068065643,
0.5811024904,
0.1799315214,
0.1438278556,
0.7690814137,
-0.0786274523,
-0.5102248788,
0.5522244573,
0.711350739,
0.3535737991,
-0.0720400065,
0.1825111657,
0.6289845705,
0.2849939764,
-0.7171802521,
0.2734919786,
-0.2248843461,
-0.7205634713,
-0.4879876673,
-0.3168077767,
-0.3351980746,
0.1271548271,
-0.7184904814,
0.1451901048,
-0.5062238574,
-0.3132096529,
0.2128885239,
0.1885238886,
-0.450820297,
0.3460237086,
0.0964139178,
0.7862164974,
-0.9838967919,
1.4786092043,
0.5271039605,
-0.4747065008,
-1.445520997,
-0.2977749407,
-0.2348391116,
-0.5014331937,
0.9676913023,
0.1235488132,
-0.1044393182,
0.2518194914,
-0.5473941565,
-0.7382550836,
1.0919944048,
0.5354062319,
-0.9500738978,
0.0535746254,
0.0883055851,
0.5412210822,
-0.458358705,
0.0819862038,
0.7916984558,
0.3749403954,
0.4085840881,
-1.0350939035,
0.3865707219,
-0.0593577586,
0.0054918113,
0.2278558165,
-0.3444641829,
1.0279833078,
-0.6469367146,
-0.1617503166,
-0.2266798168,
0.5816509724,
0.5579910278,
0.3373655379,
0.54604882,
0.8124334812,
1.2765853405,
-0.1015484035,
0.8879010081,
0.0006750072,
0.2992705703,
1.1740552187,
-0.2230798453,
0.9137681723,
0.6656868458,
-0.2394823581,
0.7291446328,
0.4775315821,
0.1686612666,
0.4873814285,
0.4317428172,
-0.2762695253,
-0.5566761494,
-0.0199951548,
-0.2464590073,
-0.0248167645,
0.4036676884,
-0.4246826768,
-0.0106826369,
0.3062336743,
-0.0521662943,
0.1391145885,
-0.6306417584,
0.5735652447,
0.406842798,
-1.0908287764,
0.8032928109,
-0.3244327009,
0.3063745201,
-0.1120917276,
-0.1529881507,
-0.033625517,
0.4709746838,
-0.1549552381,
-0.8409515023,
0.1866813451,
-0.0733605549,
-0.3167114556,
-0.2283669412,
1.0085887909,
-0.6022155285,
-0.493938148,
-0.0126593756,
0.4590247571,
0.3020516932,
-0.1074861735,
-0.3771979511,
-0.1653040648,
0.2479870319,
-0.0260883328,
0.1578681469,
0.8817436695,
-0.2404429913,
0.7833001614,
0.7184049487,
0.1367576718,
0.1522781402,
0.1381642222,
1.0746936798,
-0.6168183684,
-0.5100743175,
-1.0297981501,
0.4479170442,
-0.1585600674,
-0.1599996239,
0.88048172,
0.1879889667,
0.9306698442,
-0.3241450191,
0.6725333333,
-0.1794780046,
0.1254814267,
-0.618160665,
0.6431239843,
-0.3091954589,
0.3464861512,
-0.2032452375,
-0.6741656661,
0.2065581828,
0.7369964719,
-0.7034716606,
-0.0211681388,
0.908644259,
0.3254748583,
-0.065930672,
0.3815113604,
0.5071738362,
0.0733915269,
0.3076449037,
0.8679785728,
0.9033405781,
-0.4322037697,
0.1955783367,
-0.4059948921,
-0.0395753793,
0.0124109946,
-0.7816384435,
-1.2279419899,
-0.5286843181,
-0.4042435288,
-0.405162096,
-0.0925553814,
0.7870761156,
0.8404427767,
-0.626111269,
-0.1344706416,
-0.5755172968,
0.2171375453,
-0.2340223789,
-0.220181495,
0.2757857144,
-0.2026088536,
-0.5463945866,
0.1962400377,
-0.0172215607,
0.0108655412,
-0.24707973,
-0.0895222202,
-0.2154295295,
0.1714976877,
0.6456362605,
0.0422708727,
-0.8358130455,
-0.4097947776,
-0.212316364,
-0.0150106251,
-0.4318243563,
0.8769219518,
-0.790476799,
0.447591722,
0.4519515336,
0.3643341362,
0.5276928544,
-0.0775111616,
0.6171950102,
-0.5594018102,
0.2039324343,
0.0211087465,
0.2576598227,
0.0439139679,
-0.3643864989,
0.565146327,
0.2135510445,
-0.4185277522,
-0.6827113628,
0.1328309327,
-0.8946445584,
-0.3247916102,
1.017457366,
-0.3108106256,
-0.2060969174,
0.053947825,
-0.3389541209,
0.2813673317,
-0.3369978368,
0.7837210298,
0.827423811,
-0.0948544368,
-0.3395982385,
-0.4837626517,
0.5581867695,
0.3667382002,
-0.9737385511,
0.2360978425,
0.4248870611,
0.1993313134,
0.126651898,
0.3739174008,
0.260024339,
0.180551663,
0.0943477005,
-0.1553502828,
-0.1593788713,
-0.4692868888,
-0.0436658189,
0.2021895051,
0.164217785,
0.1291856617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08408v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08408v2 | Decoder Tuning: Efficient Language Understanding as Decoding | 2022-12-16T11:15:39 | 2023-05-24T14:30:50 | Ganqu Cui, Wentao Li, Ning Ding, Longtao Huang, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | With the evergrowing sizes of pre-trained models (PTMs), it has been an
emerging practice to only provide the inference APIs for users, namely
model-as-a-service (MaaS) setting. To adapt PTMs with model parameters frozen,
most current approaches focus on the input side, seeking for powerful prompts
to stimulate models for correct answers. However, we argue that input-side
adaptation could be arduous due to the lack of gradient signals and they
usually require thousands of API queries, resulting in high computation and
time costs. In light of this, we present Decoder Tuning (DecT), which in
contrast optimizes task-specific decoder networks on the output side.
Specifically, DecT first extracts prompt-stimulated output scores for initial
predictions. On top of that, we train an additional decoder network on the
output representations to incorporate posterior data knowledge. By
gradient-based optimization, DecT can be trained within several seconds and
requires only one PTM query per sample. Empirically, we conduct extensive
natural language understanding experiments and show that DecT significantly
outperforms state-of-the-art algorithms with a $200\times$ speed-up. | [
-0.3874675035,
-0.5752609372,
0.4552978277,
0.4083955884,
-0.5987109542,
-0.0518550053,
-0.2196784019,
-0.0524064451,
0.0286054127,
0.7373543978,
-0.8868014216,
-0.4209235907,
-0.6714589596,
0.2027625144,
-0.1458320171,
0.8981500268,
0.3297159672,
0.0866870359,
-0.0137617644,
-0.0596013367,
-0.5371133685,
-0.2706032991,
-1.2601029873,
-0.1754739583,
0.2680164576,
0.2891510427,
0.474683553,
1.1434957981,
0.3436230123,
0.2362026423,
0.1019757092,
0.248612538,
-0.6107910872,
0.1349366456,
-0.1235971749,
-0.5800520182,
-0.1549742371,
-0.2297566235,
0.3799289465,
0.6986739039,
-0.0626182854,
-0.0188766178,
0.0320913792,
0.8080751896,
-0.6638553739,
0.3558567464,
-0.8316312432,
-0.1777803898,
-0.0428207107,
-0.5262150168,
-0.5179700255,
-0.1950855106,
0.0546510518,
-0.8829348087,
0.3105075359,
-0.0645112768,
0.8167127967,
0.7735840082,
-0.4359126091,
-0.2610159516,
-0.4054073095,
0.6746976972,
-0.6778227687,
0.4673686624,
0.7034606338,
0.2770377398,
-0.1605671495,
-0.5194742084,
-0.1333398968,
0.0699348897,
0.0087699881,
0.1208415404,
-0.2478506565,
0.260638088,
0.1666880399,
0.3443617821,
-0.5646025538,
0.1189196929,
0.0215870813,
-0.2648760378,
0.3096712828,
0.1809615642,
0.2144693434,
0.1122344136,
-0.1297739893,
-0.0346364863,
-0.5464570522,
0.1022914574,
0.2774171531,
0.436499238,
-0.0458712317,
0.161151126,
-0.1991733909,
1.123698473,
0.3594757915,
0.1343005002,
-0.0110377353,
-0.4750475883,
-0.2480219901,
-0.0719968304,
0.6694866419,
0.1503105015,
0.3770178258,
-0.3567759395,
-0.1816331744,
0.0284255818,
0.3506396711,
-0.9984576106,
-0.5535390973,
-0.0308320038,
-0.3493367136,
0.0029480613,
-0.3083556294,
-0.5943523645,
-0.4318305552,
-0.4621795416,
0.3445557654,
-0.5956771374,
-0.2211885005,
0.4427306056,
-0.1052026525,
0.1794850975,
0.1504920572,
-1.2364118099,
0.3791877627,
0.6582680345,
0.9490625858,
0.0958648175,
-0.0976331607,
-0.9590057135,
-0.177369222,
-0.3643582165,
0.7658603787,
-0.6725316644,
-0.3564279974,
-0.1588218063,
-0.0709050447,
-0.4599266946,
-0.3185866773,
0.7487318516,
-0.914553225,
0.1073250473,
-0.4818574488,
-0.4777956307,
-0.1782474369,
0.0256117415,
-0.6062895656,
0.7093231082,
-0.0364846922,
-0.7435124516,
0.3850049675,
-0.8486801386,
-0.6988672614,
-0.1379621625,
0.2136547863,
0.020110257,
0.4070208371,
0.765673995,
0.3035108149,
-0.3570679426,
-0.0775452778,
0.0965090245,
-0.3731161356,
0.0452677198,
-0.4043841064,
0.7311379313,
0.457672596,
0.0336632058,
0.1775510311,
-0.9549112916,
-0.1442361176,
0.0076187849,
-0.5467974544,
-0.4941118062,
0.1067785174,
-0.3751864731,
0.0351903625,
0.1514565498,
-0.3072894514,
0.0391856171,
-0.7234705687,
0.7057695985,
0.6802457571,
-0.0924770162,
0.7717555165,
0.0005602643,
0.7125006914,
-0.0515046865,
-0.1399309039,
-0.513846755,
-0.291200906,
-0.872264266,
-0.3360589147,
0.2922346294,
0.3620851636,
-1.0414409637,
0.4233768284,
-0.3861002028,
-0.1733384877,
-0.9402529597,
0.1107008457,
0.3761919439,
0.8101160526,
0.3700951636,
-0.106362924,
-0.4649699032,
-0.8550992012,
-0.6098635197,
-0.0010316749,
-0.2198401839,
0.1326223612,
0.1661333144,
0.1095300913,
0.8653016686,
-0.4257808328,
0.0034092383,
-0.1292479932,
0.1602150351,
0.3684304655,
0.3102508783,
0.4394891262,
-0.5499683022,
-0.4091039896,
-0.1033331305,
-0.3437544703,
-0.3110550046,
-0.0452928431,
-0.2762107849,
-0.0613158047,
0.6026818752,
-0.3420120776,
-0.0113516906,
0.7736442685,
-0.4807041585,
0.133318007,
-0.42293787,
0.0754442513,
-1.1134258509,
-0.0045456341,
0.0120987929,
-0.3765109181,
-0.8024560809,
-0.1675831228,
0.2291617393,
-0.1602472961,
0.0251209717,
0.3540528119,
-0.6608316898,
0.0764806941,
-0.5566302538,
0.0009458166,
0.271507889,
0.5702683926,
0.1454210281,
0.9591396451,
0.6153151989,
-0.781524837,
0.1443852335,
0.1726026237,
-0.2461071014,
0.1934519112,
-0.4976540804,
0.386465013,
-0.3433744311,
0.11677403,
-0.9217982888,
0.1651080847,
0.3154877126,
-0.3471256793,
0.2733743489,
-0.6997033358,
-0.3134982884,
-0.005139302,
-0.0821820572,
0.2975670099,
0.4335345328,
-0.7849965692,
0.6910005808,
0.2029609531,
0.0147173926,
-0.5276880264,
-0.6547381878,
0.1458704919,
-0.1731846035,
-0.5007519126,
0.1469436437,
-0.0047639897,
0.0214700904,
-0.0939175263,
-0.1405064315,
-0.0969503298,
0.3034797609,
0.0349574275,
-0.3864228725,
-0.476749301,
0.2212141156,
0.3645979762,
-0.4391856492,
0.0747494027,
-0.4877927303,
0.6306552887,
-0.0217772629,
-0.2344744205,
-0.5385961533,
0.2605245113,
0.6413219571,
-0.4830897748,
0.8557109833,
0.4897721112,
-0.1186698973,
-0.3604908884,
-0.2221730053,
-0.4592916667,
-0.491648972,
0.4195880294,
-0.7527711987,
-0.6925035119,
0.5942878723,
-0.0225680377,
0.1289632767,
0.3278221488,
0.3530341685,
0.2550520301,
1.1952055693,
0.7158507705,
-0.0688919649,
0.6704978943,
-0.032553684,
0.2743101716,
-0.6038143039,
-0.0124959089,
-0.7383352518,
-0.1960563213,
-0.4773875177,
-0.3168994784,
0.0618227497,
0.1527960598,
-0.2341463864,
0.3089487255,
-0.4059494436,
0.6464653015,
0.5504025817,
0.0492906198,
0.3820007741,
-0.0340813622,
0.1673677713,
-0.0413411222,
-0.8801249862,
-0.3012968302,
0.8410242796,
0.3258829117,
0.7372536659,
0.077525869,
0.407774359,
-0.0393634029,
0.0247665104,
-0.9428080916,
0.3518643975,
-0.4591529369,
-0.2852913439,
-0.1065102816,
-0.6046698689,
-0.9791576266,
0.4389432669,
0.0188109688,
-0.4887683988,
0.2877910137,
0.3107379377,
-0.3045530021,
-0.0148560833,
-0.9209424257,
0.9056072235,
-0.0101205828,
-0.1101715788,
-0.1987451315,
-0.623488605,
0.2481908947,
0.0408908911,
0.1790254265,
-0.2165221274,
-0.0834236294,
0.7389289737,
-0.3274700344,
0.7120810151,
-0.3324298561,
-0.1377677172,
-0.1260011494,
0.1987470537,
0.3973115981,
0.2466763407,
-0.4298700094,
-0.1157358661,
0.172334969,
-0.5766552091,
-0.8219974637,
0.6743104458,
-0.8236839771,
-0.6600226164,
-0.199010551,
-0.7373837233,
-0.4388807118,
0.1026739404,
0.4022428095,
0.7357975245,
0.0125522548,
-0.0084255086,
0.7753251791,
-0.0418922156,
0.5081002116,
0.7122229934,
-0.01674865,
-0.1727705002,
0.9382307529,
-0.3554234505,
0.2636553347,
0.6378915906,
0.2751576602,
-0.5066131949,
-0.8467642665,
-0.651624918,
0.2489409596,
-0.6984974742,
-0.2153583616,
-0.6512809992,
0.0656095594,
-0.2648701668,
0.0508799888,
-0.490814209,
-0.2151377052,
-0.7364733815,
-0.0123812044,
0.5663026571,
0.4192481935,
-0.1024398655,
0.6169499755,
-0.8978453279,
0.4007418156,
0.1409622282,
0.4647616744,
-0.1852524877,
-0.8071753383,
-0.4227993786,
0.2234449089,
0.1917214096,
-0.8913446069,
0.4693626761,
0.5022374392,
0.3784802854,
0.7704867125,
0.1792784184,
0.6281205416,
-0.3196220994,
0.4943845272,
-0.0786186308,
-1.0338007212,
0.4579835534,
-0.3255012035,
0.664342165,
0.8110296726,
0.2344194204,
-0.4232210517,
-0.0090065962,
0.001831132,
-0.4133557081,
1.0451469421,
0.0085079111,
0.3902387917,
-0.0020884022,
0.4712633491,
0.3055577278,
0.0662129149,
-0.2968265116,
-0.1746010929,
-0.5293985009,
-0.3477618098,
-0.2084559202,
-0.2186720222,
-0.0025891024,
-0.302154392,
0.620785296,
-0.3961063325,
0.1913243979,
-0.1960042715,
-0.4154959321,
0.0657854825,
0.1602625251,
0.538972795,
0.7282322049,
-0.2061421126,
0.429915607,
-0.0154799288,
-0.4653476477,
-0.0480011217,
0.1234369874,
0.1014677957,
-0.0657975525,
0.1402998567,
1.1996359825,
0.1247628257,
-0.4791354537,
0.3163892925,
-0.534375608,
-0.1392076313,
0.3284383118,
0.1542892158,
0.1303592473,
-0.0176651925,
0.2288150787,
0.1416684687,
0.0510071293,
-0.2648293674,
-0.1033174694,
0.3980775177,
-0.3699781299,
-0.5397407413,
0.5289735198,
0.4187739491,
-0.3514834344,
0.7161630988,
-0.2848377228,
-0.3762201071,
0.4472570717,
0.6807249784,
0.9381084442,
-0.2962185144,
0.1752945632,
0.1585906893,
0.3010233939,
-0.0300304946,
0.217862919,
-0.2233732641,
-0.9487147331,
-0.7990345359,
-0.8954368234,
-0.0507929251,
0.1951197088,
-0.7782036662,
0.1002197191,
-0.3760296702,
0.0447407141,
-0.0849090442,
-0.0581357367,
-0.5487598181,
0.0498610176,
-0.2578322589,
1.1053000689,
-0.8569975495,
0.9621371031,
0.6431378126,
-0.240920797,
-0.4389046431,
-0.0705568865,
-0.3217506111,
-0.9952484369,
0.3482006192,
0.0399773493,
-0.3806801736,
0.5550816655,
-0.1824551672,
-0.7213172317,
0.5005801916,
0.9564650059,
-0.4542622268,
-0.0098076547,
-0.0345009081,
0.5374557376,
-0.3814965785,
0.2108561397,
1.0246167183,
0.3974365592,
-0.0546638183,
-0.6897672415,
0.0952699557,
-0.2660588324,
-0.0809762329,
0.3095909953,
-0.2745706439,
0.6110081673,
-0.0259937178,
-0.4239936769,
-0.0814349055,
0.4442571104,
-0.2054636329,
0.1298187226,
0.5504772663,
0.5372106433,
0.5058506131,
-0.0756968334,
1.1198854446,
-0.5016331077,
0.0945833325,
0.9652929306,
0.355886966,
0.5254386663,
0.5068364739,
0.0869318694,
0.2321170866,
0.9313006401,
0.3118288517,
0.9697516561,
0.1926507801,
-0.1841248274,
-0.5825914145,
-0.0256993584,
-0.3811729252,
0.5347827077,
0.4663161337,
-0.3868417144,
-0.3943917453,
0.1381291896,
-0.0283248555,
0.232308656,
-0.3522564471,
1.0739951134,
0.1426852494,
-0.590887785,
0.797783196,
0.0853207186,
0.4963958561,
-0.6091895103,
0.1823542416,
-0.3777582049,
0.0451215394,
-0.007983583,
-0.3028905094,
0.3510220349,
-0.200009197,
-0.3866560459,
-0.4124860168,
0.5214799047,
-0.2810086608,
-0.3820496798,
0.2297824025,
0.5944983959,
0.0929236412,
-0.3674328923,
-0.6239298582,
0.1336129606,
-0.0992488191,
-0.3189232945,
0.3579500616,
0.4384087026,
0.31180197,
0.6089773178,
0.689432025,
-0.0655441508,
0.149569869,
0.2704028189,
0.8927596211,
-0.4167377353,
-0.698126018,
-0.9238349795,
0.2118276358,
0.1655250639,
-0.3517446518,
0.6392804384,
0.3429371119,
0.4830236435,
-0.0473800227,
0.7380927205,
0.4072167873,
0.3073002398,
-0.8899433017,
0.7012336254,
-0.4066031873,
0.3975721002,
0.303663224,
-0.7994451523,
-0.213779673,
0.4635078311,
-0.4801288843,
-0.050485298,
0.5530458689,
0.8085162044,
-0.2299245,
0.3343024552,
0.2764405906,
0.0692328736,
0.3173008561,
0.6033094525,
0.6816033125,
-0.241796121,
0.4801178873,
-0.1529137194,
-0.1920991838,
-0.1500619799,
-0.889083147,
-0.9744114876,
-0.6607340574,
-0.1493359655,
-0.1309657693,
0.2269518077,
0.6638596654,
0.8252197504,
-0.8347106576,
-0.0319422632,
-0.4477247894,
0.2105992287,
-0.330019325,
-0.153141737,
0.4501100183,
-0.6687760949,
-0.8806277514,
0.8741820455,
0.229336828,
-0.3705897331,
0.0373862647,
-0.034096539,
0.031982515,
0.1106376797,
0.4966582656,
0.3139845133,
-0.4701564908,
-0.0418923721,
0.0307383928,
0.1231828034,
0.2358108163,
1.0985025167,
-0.8824326396,
0.6929964423,
0.6313083172,
1.0781724453,
0.668182373,
0.2031717747,
0.892216742,
-0.6108380556,
-0.011899244,
0.1835673004,
0.2023642212,
0.3405860364,
-0.3222494721,
0.0801838934,
-0.0888380334,
-0.3659752607,
-0.6591643691,
0.3909102678,
-0.7673538327,
-0.3118548095,
0.9193096161,
-0.0759956911,
-0.1885641664,
-0.3945983052,
-0.1395379007,
0.3390271068,
-0.5784797072,
0.6259587407,
0.4064364433,
-0.1684533209,
-0.4863418639,
-0.4017306864,
0.6788318157,
0.5097646713,
-0.6999791861,
0.2979293168,
0.246064648,
0.3019818664,
-0.2643733025,
0.5656535625,
0.2356513441,
0.014260483,
-0.0313351862,
-0.362772733,
-0.3683337271,
-0.114245899,
-0.755371213,
0.1525322795,
0.270257473,
-0.5762996078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08407v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08407v1 | Utilizing distilBert transformer model for sentiment classification of COVID-19's Persian open-text responses | 2022-12-16T11:06:48 | 2022-12-16T11:06:48 | Fatemeh Sadat Masoumi, Mohammad Bahrani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | The COVID-19 pandemic has caused drastic alternations in human life in all
aspects. The government's laws in this regard affected the lifestyle of all
people. Due to this fact studying the sentiment of individuals is essential to
be aware of the future impacts of the coming pandemics. To contribute to this
aim, we proposed an NLP (Natural Language Processing) model to analyze
open-text answers in a survey in Persian and detect positive and negative
feelings of the people in Iran. In this study, a distilBert transformer model
was applied to take on this task. We deployed three approaches to perform the
comparison, and our best model could gain accuracy: 0.824, Precision: 0.824,
Recall: 0.798, and F1 score: 0.804. | [
-0.6491885185,
-0.7332233787,
0.1680773944,
0.2300401032,
-0.3187152445,
-0.054747384,
-0.2939422727,
-0.3062988818,
-0.0657451078,
0.1461351067,
-0.4283811748,
-0.4804053903,
-0.7303646803,
0.3306144774,
-0.5580682158,
1.3546178341,
0.2626895308,
0.1171979979,
-0.0757028908,
0.2251459658,
0.0078272279,
-0.5983562469,
-0.5881676674,
-0.2296355069,
0.2526902556,
0.4271323383,
0.8035546541,
-0.4827712178,
0.7807651758,
0.2461019754,
-0.2593659163,
-0.3069804609,
-0.4164304733,
-0.1044636369,
-0.3268584311,
-0.4438226819,
-0.5833882093,
0.2341286838,
-0.0580530912,
0.0580933616,
-0.3414549232,
0.6344288588,
0.2203614861,
0.5173147321,
-0.2201752067,
-0.1675467193,
-0.247662589,
0.2990273833,
-0.2787312865,
0.0135267004,
-0.5379870534,
-0.4008620679,
0.2896782458,
-0.2186258435,
0.3802249432,
-0.1199218035,
0.828297019,
0.3701263368,
-0.4234572649,
-0.1462545246,
-1.1654199362,
1.0348372459,
-0.9185576439,
-0.0902393162,
0.0655774847,
0.4804588854,
-0.1437990069,
-0.3101634681,
-0.7750083804,
-0.0556103699,
-0.1244016141,
0.2731636763,
-0.3851786256,
-0.1928030252,
0.1621093601,
0.8225290179,
-0.5962077379,
-0.2634117901,
-0.3919751346,
0.1631751657,
0.8056349158,
0.1982971579,
0.4658772945,
-0.47985816,
-0.510412991,
-0.1945176721,
-0.1208986789,
0.3988409042,
0.0494547859,
0.2155470997,
-0.2449412346,
0.4028680921,
-0.1813428402,
0.4344174862,
0.4912445843,
-0.1752492636,
0.2910192907,
-0.1976176202,
-0.424212724,
0.1171226725,
0.8950893283,
0.2696222663,
0.0797345638,
0.1462907046,
0.166325599,
0.2783220708,
0.4640687108,
-0.8410688043,
-0.1712621748,
0.4325093329,
-0.5359665155,
-0.5064362884,
0.2449028194,
-1.1481896639,
-0.5784294009,
-0.2163368762,
0.0164391659,
-0.2428354174,
-0.3897497058,
0.3694190681,
-0.3561080992,
0.2831049562,
0.6592101455,
-0.4255921245,
0.6475515366,
0.5098239779,
0.6599604487,
-0.0787061006,
0.3707718551,
-0.316066891,
-0.6452798843,
0.1367891878,
0.6020776629,
-0.4145458043,
-0.2961252332,
-0.4553846717,
-0.3783398271,
0.0073554348,
-0.289250493,
1.167478919,
-0.380253315,
0.6590144038,
0.0377929471,
-0.0972832292,
-0.4849778116,
0.4370134771,
-0.7835718393,
0.9256107807,
0.2080844641,
-1.2827472687,
-0.0963750929,
-0.7334686518,
-0.0912705585,
0.0145524479,
0.1961075962,
-0.8117067218,
0.3201649487,
0.2896765172,
0.5902242661,
-0.6774886847,
0.5053338408,
-0.2467733324,
-0.0563401692,
0.4825967848,
-0.4416627288,
1.1648186445,
0.3430582285,
-0.368806988,
-0.0073003517,
-0.6627502441,
-0.245501712,
0.0917338952,
-0.1852188855,
-0.5193371177,
0.217279613,
0.2554795146,
0.6611016393,
0.1265123487,
-0.9959806204,
0.1948370934,
-0.5457271934,
0.1120533198,
0.4557430744,
0.1923142523,
0.5353277326,
-0.189845711,
0.8492558599,
0.419592768,
0.6957466602,
0.5920549631,
-0.5206432343,
-0.5251817107,
-0.2479216903,
-0.0834431127,
0.7179155946,
-0.3740358353,
0.3407533467,
-0.0925331712,
-0.9860780239,
-0.1098728254,
-0.4770102203,
-0.1000673175,
0.8054181337,
0.5506435037,
0.1494488567,
-0.6011576056,
-0.5847926736,
-0.1990392357,
-0.1221139282,
0.2501254082,
-0.118088752,
0.44710356,
-0.2829380333,
0.8671395779,
-0.7438462973,
-0.3285283148,
-0.3100184798,
0.2392699867,
0.6627104282,
0.0345740728,
0.5381284952,
-1.0131914616,
-0.8061457872,
0.089162536,
-0.4271498024,
-0.0633289814,
0.0916088074,
-0.0886587873,
-0.0646033213,
0.1170592085,
-0.2851841748,
0.8081499338,
0.6332718134,
-0.5873019695,
0.5226299763,
0.3735759556,
0.2773909867,
-1.5323125124,
0.1427424848,
0.3634331226,
-0.1234036088,
-0.9542441368,
-0.0077269054,
-0.0396170132,
-0.1894918382,
-0.5602573752,
0.2672596872,
0.2042027563,
0.6414611936,
-0.166788578,
-0.3654488921,
0.2807370722,
0.2114136368,
0.1790916771,
0.6218991876,
0.2790156603,
-0.3428551853,
0.7229084373,
0.5528522134,
-0.247470066,
0.5454309583,
-0.5822615027,
-0.1772720665,
-0.2496143132,
0.3496807814,
-0.8356349468,
0.1091635078,
0.4316119254,
-0.5099409819,
-0.0963693336,
0.3048094511,
-0.0145444656,
-0.6211403012,
-0.534832418,
0.2542602122,
0.5119891763,
-0.4147798121,
0.7651864886,
0.2018243074,
-0.2529634535,
-0.5307106972,
-0.56376791,
0.0290890187,
-0.6614328623,
-0.4307938516,
0.3762364089,
0.0805167705,
-0.6309629083,
-0.2185664922,
0.03764816,
-0.1920255125,
0.2810459435,
0.4251817763,
0.3042921722,
-0.1155930534,
0.0944873691,
0.0085761538,
0.0032094729,
0.1720871776,
0.3266365528,
0.5944885612,
-0.3292142451,
0.0065121274,
-0.4715002775,
0.351419121,
0.6334700584,
-0.4655929506,
0.7972780466,
0.537288487,
-0.2099223137,
-0.0483196042,
-0.071213007,
-0.0518722236,
-0.3957983851,
0.2339449823,
0.0168728828,
-0.509500742,
0.1943075061,
-0.3415225446,
-0.3007450402,
0.7274748087,
0.523594439,
0.1357983649,
0.7730785012,
0.6408789158,
-0.4758466184,
0.3069432974,
-0.042012617,
0.4961291552,
-0.7019013762,
-0.1515782773,
-0.9541309476,
-0.1899101585,
-0.5238946676,
-0.284445554,
0.7748044729,
0.0717098713,
-0.2487510741,
0.287845403,
-0.6827673912,
0.1505900174,
0.2996607721,
0.2519473135,
0.3143393397,
-0.0049435413,
0.1383524686,
0.1637505889,
-0.3691504598,
-0.6362712979,
0.7704788446,
0.4359823465,
1.0415015221,
0.3117482364,
0.9685151577,
0.6144735217,
0.1904192865,
-0.7491185069,
0.4028390646,
-0.4420776367,
-0.4167674482,
-0.4921130836,
-0.018444214,
-0.7067595124,
-0.1067606807,
-0.2293601632,
-0.5427969098,
0.4034733772,
-0.1365276873,
-0.636933744,
0.1150024906,
-0.2658042014,
0.808935225,
-0.1452854723,
0.0013820259,
-0.4500646591,
-0.5173040032,
0.4253413975,
0.0034112025,
0.3803892732,
-0.3074753881,
0.505653441,
0.4783810973,
-0.7491439581,
0.8415516019,
-0.3590635061,
-0.1772467792,
0.2597171068,
-0.2248319983,
0.2471498996,
0.1341484338,
-0.4858031869,
0.2882573903,
0.1517527401,
-0.128169775,
-0.3424246013,
0.3409547508,
-1.1815589666,
-0.4874462187,
-1.036947608,
-0.015302442,
0.1680803746,
-0.200280726,
0.2627967298,
0.5065511465,
-0.8007476926,
-0.0963821411,
0.6498709321,
-0.4518752694,
0.392015487,
0.2593206167,
-0.6294597387,
-0.1698753983,
0.4751679599,
-0.2139492631,
0.0697301179,
0.6251081824,
0.6749991775,
-0.1088244915,
-0.0602597333,
-0.55422014,
0.0233347658,
-0.4812883139,
-0.5265272856,
-0.3610703051,
-0.3355398476,
-0.3687528968,
0.1566352844,
0.0116199264,
-0.3112108409,
-0.5167225599,
0.0637424588,
0.695148766,
0.7613171339,
0.1535139531,
0.2175784111,
-0.8037950993,
0.4631124437,
0.2585158348,
-0.0179276094,
-0.0294390973,
-0.5760188103,
-0.384451896,
0.194505915,
-0.6144072413,
-1.0272936821,
0.7222789526,
0.4029391706,
-0.0031456451,
0.437207967,
0.6551532149,
0.5809318423,
-0.3034720421,
0.9889487028,
0.1205719188,
-1.1268476248,
0.6065589786,
-0.1722778529,
0.4617048204,
0.4412924945,
0.6731735468,
-0.9046489596,
-0.4697926641,
-0.3105451763,
-0.4886257052,
0.8559403419,
-0.0362065211,
0.0300387535,
-0.2173192054,
0.0277741626,
0.1840458512,
0.0031395555,
-0.6132916212,
-0.1797534674,
-0.5203175545,
-0.3365231454,
-0.1498481035,
-0.1228324696,
0.1509479582,
-0.565681994,
0.6898204684,
0.1553982049,
0.390825659,
0.3785518408,
0.0253283773,
-0.2659310699,
0.8364624977,
0.4843793511,
0.0814713538,
-0.2738174498,
0.2179825008,
0.0525804721,
-0.7504783869,
0.4034880698,
0.0462193787,
-0.0214432571,
0.0230646115,
-0.0284842085,
0.5043293238,
-0.4049067497,
-0.4301888049,
0.9311210513,
-0.5557746291,
0.0252633113,
-0.797483325,
-0.0092479885,
-0.0777699724,
0.1788462251,
0.485213995,
0.6532571316,
0.5853123069,
-0.4482209086,
-0.1589814276,
0.3947044015,
-0.1779473126,
-0.5949419737,
0.3953570724,
0.2279151082,
-0.1236412227,
0.6928758025,
-0.2157448232,
-0.8113609552,
0.4743560255,
0.3879514337,
0.8748947978,
-0.8000164628,
0.6226477623,
0.5721218586,
-0.0162310619,
-0.1464989781,
0.4983470738,
0.0967575684,
-0.6230579615,
-0.4860613644,
-0.934279263,
-0.2839184701,
0.0990302116,
-1.3526910543,
0.5337638259,
-0.3615377247,
-0.3877726197,
0.1057424843,
-0.1084817052,
-0.7676019669,
0.5886838436,
0.4580748975,
0.8587024212,
-1.1963322163,
0.7625212073,
0.6860290766,
-0.4224927425,
-0.6909239292,
0.1435312629,
-0.0767957419,
-0.2646067142,
0.5961232185,
0.2585079074,
-0.1804667413,
-0.173010096,
-0.5109140277,
-0.7452204823,
0.7774139643,
-0.1493540406,
-0.6556199789,
0.0899835452,
0.5859090686,
0.9153869748,
0.0809240639,
0.414507091,
0.3232440054,
0.3526832163,
-0.2611716092,
-1.1062445641,
-0.0641346797,
-0.5799962282,
-0.3002305627,
0.5101759434,
-0.6044245958,
1.1415635347,
0.3184082806,
-0.3108173013,
-0.1078072712,
0.3344464898,
-0.4121528566,
0.458725512,
0.3462776542,
0.7767515779,
0.5907028317,
0.0636594445,
0.9789766073,
-0.0943515599,
0.4918020666,
0.9272706509,
-0.2411571294,
1.1276893616,
0.455129832,
-0.5919843316,
1.0580422878,
0.1342558116,
0.2203819901,
0.4872283638,
0.2342579067,
-0.5278961062,
-0.0247780047,
-0.2038012445,
-0.2677151561,
0.7376278639,
0.4323317707,
-0.2524181902,
-0.4442962706,
0.4081216156,
-0.0401017405,
0.2948806286,
-0.5229247808,
0.8561947346,
0.0989744514,
-0.4740050733,
0.4822815061,
0.4523245692,
0.7129312754,
-0.1657990962,
0.049614694,
0.0663590282,
0.417601645,
-0.5077808499,
-0.6509078741,
0.8590848446,
0.2692303658,
-0.5660220385,
-0.0645419285,
0.7485920787,
-0.1817763299,
-0.6561175585,
0.0460839309,
0.4219606221,
-0.0738988295,
-0.5331918597,
-0.7362252474,
-0.2199271768,
0.0939512551,
-0.3265162706,
0.1657856256,
0.2993043065,
-0.3382332921,
0.0917736664,
0.2419315726,
-0.1654460877,
-0.0831085071,
-0.0539331324,
0.8528142571,
-0.592438519,
-0.4003354907,
-1.1690562963,
0.5177929401,
-0.3119204342,
-0.1619486809,
1.0390616655,
0.4992948174,
0.5968129039,
-0.4121806026,
0.9453460574,
-0.2225875854,
1.0068589449,
0.1183867604,
0.6353100538,
-0.1324569285,
-0.1258945018,
-0.417791158,
-0.6535128355,
-0.3259518147,
0.6240839362,
-0.7763047218,
-0.5091935992,
0.5119140148,
0.5195421576,
-0.0651862025,
0.3348708749,
-0.078894347,
0.1854860038,
0.2305205315,
0.4760849476,
1.0160095692,
-0.5000029206,
0.1197470501,
-0.3517998159,
-0.329675138,
-0.1908867955,
-0.8721318245,
-0.9500404596,
-0.4848899543,
-0.3127263784,
-0.387958616,
-0.4196136892,
1.3254268169,
0.0941227973,
-1.0373022556,
-0.2996630967,
-0.1483212113,
-0.2334315181,
-0.1780945063,
-0.2936449647,
0.3631498218,
0.1223544106,
-0.5374265909,
-0.1173559874,
0.239424482,
-0.0152417272,
-0.3327981532,
0.0019358221,
-0.2557998598,
0.2236858159,
0.6553734541,
0.0900738761,
-0.6850110292,
0.0083277486,
0.1934302449,
-0.2395948768,
0.1304355115,
0.46463117,
-0.8332346678,
0.3526673615,
0.6566434503,
0.2007618994,
0.2585116029,
0.3489539623,
0.3113168776,
-0.524551332,
0.0198770668,
0.4239950776,
0.1466948837,
0.369797647,
-0.6296015382,
0.160059765,
-0.0723925158,
-0.7966997623,
-0.4180086255,
0.1583899409,
-1.0287935734,
-0.1987716109,
0.8806039691,
-0.1072862148,
-0.410804987,
-0.2214074731,
-0.7713507414,
0.2675699592,
-0.5587832928,
1.1076146364,
0.3854334354,
-0.0814354122,
-0.0339546017,
0.0790604055,
0.4157877862,
0.0549831539,
-0.8607593775,
-0.3717288375,
0.3017125726,
-0.019109251,
0.2590313852,
0.425509721,
-0.0356059037,
0.2406583428,
-0.3317289352,
0.3105399013,
0.1683209091,
-0.1342219859,
-0.5159971714,
0.2273808569,
0.1854538321,
-0.0092112478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08395v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08395v1 | Metaphorical Polysemy Detection: Conventional Metaphor meets Word Sense Disambiguation | 2022-12-16T10:39:22 | 2022-12-16T10:39:22 | Rowan Hall Maudslay, Simone Teufel | cs.CL | cs.CL | Linguists distinguish between novel and conventional metaphor, a distinction
which the metaphor detection task in NLP does not take into account. Instead,
metaphoricity is formulated as a property of a token in a sentence, regardless
of metaphor type. In this paper, we investigate the limitations of treating
conventional metaphors in this way, and advocate for an alternative which we
name 'metaphorical polysemy detection' (MPD). In MPD, only conventional
metaphoricity is treated, and it is formulated as a property of word senses in
a lexicon. We develop the first MPD model, which learns to identify
conventional metaphors in the English WordNet. To train it, we present a novel
training procedure that combines metaphor detection with word sense
disambiguation (WSD). For evaluation, we manually annotate metaphor in two
subsets of WordNet. Our model significantly outperforms a strong baseline based
on a state-of-the-art metaphor detection model, attaining an ROC-AUC score of
.78 (compared to .65) on one of the sets. Additionally, when paired with a WSD
model, our approach outperforms a state-of-the-art metaphor detection model at
identifying conventional metaphors in text (.659 F1 compared to .626). | [
-0.5806204081,
-0.5800185204,
0.6145312786,
-0.0599284694,
-0.8538387418,
-0.2095362693,
-0.1517982036,
-0.3529153764,
0.4861788452,
0.126865238,
-0.3930233419,
-0.1950246096,
-0.7628073096,
0.2421638668,
-0.2249900401,
0.73551476,
-0.0281408131,
0.0161402989,
-0.6437885165,
-0.4506367147,
-0.2557216287,
-0.8399096727,
-0.5474358201,
-0.5243771672,
0.6024752855,
-0.2409515977,
0.6989980936,
0.6742265224,
0.4909523427,
0.3572100699,
-0.4550934434,
0.2179396152,
-0.0769102946,
-0.1496598572,
-0.5355039239,
-0.4633920491,
-0.0996709988,
0.4810317755,
0.3525712192,
0.7805734873,
-0.3747960627,
-0.0354029387,
-0.1426595449,
0.6318253875,
-0.8488494158,
0.0608751178,
-1.0125038624,
0.31422019,
-0.3141714633,
-0.205969885,
-0.2608533204,
0.1779765338,
-0.1377354264,
-0.4890486598,
-0.1158329397,
0.1300966591,
0.9188976884,
0.2140573412,
-0.3736147583,
-0.1587947607,
-0.4247204661,
0.6568183899,
-0.4547924697,
0.4005703628,
0.3124350607,
0.4265049994,
0.0035651876,
-0.8212338686,
-1.1053214073,
-0.4603573084,
0.0470854156,
0.082758069,
-0.2962552011,
0.0038226605,
0.5258867741,
0.3848968744,
-0.4985729158,
0.1942119002,
-0.170274958,
-0.0820586607,
0.3032072186,
0.0840107426,
0.2525594532,
-0.3194195926,
-1.0162820816,
0.0030041372,
-0.4388039708,
-0.1143112481,
0.4422982633,
0.0816979334,
-0.0495784692,
0.3535348773,
0.0638563409,
0.6552947164,
-0.4063744545,
-0.3876830339,
0.2588583827,
-0.0377821997,
-0.1910651922,
0.0523176193,
0.6399105191,
0.404329896,
0.6704845428,
-0.2605774999,
-0.4321862161,
0.8012793064,
0.3975439072,
-0.3120114803,
-0.2075767368,
-0.2441771477,
-0.4221888483,
-0.5639671683,
0.3057141602,
-0.1392403245,
-0.5154819489,
-0.5826550126,
0.5168789625,
-0.7193300724,
-0.3685520589,
0.2633209229,
-0.7824153304,
0.2159938812,
0.080139257,
-0.7039343119,
0.3108532131,
0.8427356482,
0.8988762498,
-0.3298330605,
-0.4722572863,
0.0713256821,
0.0885350704,
-0.3058485091,
0.8511345983,
-0.5463731885,
-0.1080569103,
-0.4358157516,
-0.2394583374,
-0.2716989815,
-0.7138481736,
0.4056456089,
-0.2280533463,
0.2704766095,
0.0468024425,
-0.7026877999,
-0.2419140339,
0.501776278,
-0.4528009892,
0.8166613579,
0.2891002893,
-1.2133973837,
0.445371747,
-0.3955694437,
-0.1449302882,
0.1001065001,
-0.4264609218,
0.1197443306,
0.3596312702,
-0.0293847453,
0.2481153607,
-0.4071751535,
0.3058849573,
-0.4082960486,
-0.4676322341,
0.4588680565,
-0.522575736,
0.9132336378,
0.1996932328,
-0.0486814156,
-0.1359626353,
-0.6135645509,
-0.1898074746,
0.3635452092,
0.2065018266,
-0.8126763105,
-0.0305054337,
0.0782974437,
0.5125800967,
0.0525265522,
-0.6295750737,
0.1066910252,
-0.3748900592,
0.4391550124,
0.8660852313,
-0.2903205454,
0.0732654259,
-0.5268191099,
0.617295444,
0.4334713519,
-0.0984900221,
-0.0509332865,
-0.3176088035,
-0.4804810882,
-0.4657957554,
0.5671477318,
0.426615715,
-1.0492398739,
0.7100612521,
-0.2642213404,
-0.5524445176,
-0.36018309,
-0.2193500102,
0.2530112863,
0.585906744,
0.3429500759,
-0.7075115442,
-0.3370176256,
-1.0475111008,
-0.4586509764,
-0.3301916122,
-0.2351716757,
0.1847047508,
0.7000809312,
-0.0114935944,
0.8617777824,
-0.3566590846,
-0.3966251612,
-0.3190007806,
0.2002619058,
0.0082773166,
0.2881496847,
0.7826945186,
-0.9720804691,
-0.1371801794,
-0.3552023768,
-0.7000542283,
-0.1185432747,
-0.0498249158,
0.2974716723,
-0.0276841521,
0.7294810414,
-0.692982018,
0.4412638247,
0.3557451069,
-0.3837383986,
0.9063569903,
-0.0998165458,
-0.1538804322,
-1.1934356689,
0.0374471396,
0.1702729613,
-0.153765738,
-0.3874958456,
0.4034228027,
0.0029475084,
-0.0446196906,
-0.6075279117,
0.6034294963,
-0.1173097938,
0.1244236454,
-0.4478370547,
0.3114923537,
-0.0608874187,
0.13446109,
0.3328649402,
0.503491044,
0.6772671342,
-0.5522731543,
0.680682838,
-0.1484178156,
-0.2653513849,
0.8560276628,
-0.3631037176,
0.05409839,
-0.4593993425,
0.3589102626,
-0.7979661822,
0.0999409705,
0.4115623236,
-0.3695503175,
0.0248359516,
0.0726542622,
-0.6309661269,
-0.5122520328,
-0.3838147521,
0.4218880832,
0.4833848178,
-0.7980793715,
0.2198217511,
0.2210209072,
0.4369249046,
-0.3391460776,
-0.6251166463,
0.1868418455,
-0.4010461569,
-0.4881729484,
0.4796548784,
0.1920155585,
-0.3170923591,
-0.1355688125,
-0.510094285,
-0.2453583032,
0.173564598,
0.0263705999,
0.158011958,
-0.0009601855,
0.1676438004,
-0.1797761023,
-0.3719792664,
0.2708083093,
-0.24595882,
0.6584430933,
0.1663809866,
-0.4153392613,
-0.3911967576,
0.2625975907,
0.7815129757,
-0.3864281476,
1.0605864525,
0.7241897583,
-0.6308576465,
-0.360951215,
-0.2240434736,
-0.3248788714,
-0.4685404301,
-0.0132448068,
-0.4917918444,
-0.4551917017,
0.1413405091,
-0.3750142455,
-0.5326659083,
0.2566018403,
0.1934045106,
-0.3053712845,
0.6001072526,
0.4406199157,
-0.081381768,
0.1606662273,
0.0338068455,
0.4246779084,
-0.7887138724,
-0.0059404187,
-0.4700100422,
-0.6158858538,
-0.7151587009,
-0.4222226143,
0.2462454289,
0.222479105,
0.070307903,
0.4016102254,
-0.4188638031,
0.514691174,
0.4575327039,
0.0312790014,
0.3228392899,
0.0513943136,
-0.6485888362,
-0.3722059429,
-0.7400277853,
-0.600959897,
0.7662680745,
0.2001360655,
0.2945160568,
-0.1323773116,
0.867624402,
0.1772687733,
0.0998087525,
-0.8969796896,
0.9555730224,
-0.145946756,
-0.2702561617,
0.2142302245,
-0.5432335138,
-0.8812881708,
0.6027135253,
-0.2655594349,
-0.9175696969,
-0.1073534265,
-0.0388389006,
0.1200955585,
0.7536501884,
-0.5693800449,
0.938703239,
-0.0484227054,
0.1538824886,
-0.2682773471,
-0.4658514261,
0.5100644231,
-0.0775363147,
0.1484172195,
-0.1898604035,
-0.2765214443,
0.5304613113,
-0.2488446981,
0.4397061765,
-0.2084362209,
0.1716902405,
0.1039855331,
0.1382862926,
0.1395800412,
-0.3035207391,
0.1054864675,
0.26066944,
0.2770682871,
-0.3448877335,
-0.642216444,
0.4697963297,
-0.264783442,
-0.4885836542,
-1.0753648281,
-0.587879777,
-0.1851477772,
-0.0495532975,
0.2038306445,
0.021646481,
-0.2047141194,
0.2027398646,
0.3030126393,
-0.2339101136,
0.3318368495,
0.438100338,
-0.0331008062,
0.0925044119,
0.9004672766,
0.0588808842,
0.0829139203,
0.1371606737,
0.4302590489,
-0.3625598252,
-0.4833706915,
-0.0594867952,
0.1794147342,
-0.3858608305,
-0.0612954795,
-0.2465692163,
-0.402933538,
-0.1612414569,
-0.0322913229,
-0.2187737674,
-0.3296874166,
0.0049435711,
-0.0464078523,
0.2742291093,
0.3069761097,
-0.0963967592,
0.0111519666,
-0.4553466737,
0.7672213316,
0.1637611985,
0.3377420902,
-0.1884070784,
-0.5399315357,
0.3174907267,
0.0835521817,
-0.3344383538,
-1.0284490585,
0.2530244887,
0.0802326351,
0.2345024347,
0.750526011,
0.2335088849,
0.4218972623,
-0.5530972481,
0.8208261132,
0.5862321258,
-0.8286242485,
0.5475227833,
-0.2808946967,
0.2040549666,
0.2728149593,
0.7064165473,
-0.8976935744,
-0.2941235602,
-0.8683949113,
-0.773750782,
0.4434896708,
0.1772239953,
0.3213895857,
-0.4783776104,
0.2943489254,
0.0890123695,
0.4384268522,
-0.8858550191,
-0.2403966635,
0.1865319461,
-0.0984195545,
-0.1571967155,
-0.1676515788,
-0.1738060564,
-0.5841864347,
0.4952594638,
0.0159347057,
0.1909520626,
0.0042381114,
-0.198012799,
0.3636526167,
0.1979095042,
0.1611835659,
0.7226532698,
0.0635442436,
0.3858614564,
0.007912172,
-0.3962516487,
0.1017498076,
0.0992153138,
-0.185285002,
0.3055465519,
0.2016542554,
0.6279406548,
0.0063762898,
-0.7304813266,
0.6312789917,
0.238504976,
-0.2032014728,
-0.3865531981,
0.1658957303,
0.2731110454,
0.0337822512,
0.1099245772,
0.1687525809,
-0.0088495957,
-0.617701292,
0.3736362159,
0.6254808903,
-0.2342210859,
-0.0472166128,
0.5446622968,
-0.1157593951,
-0.4311522245,
0.4574923515,
-0.6569130421,
-0.6079031229,
0.6520608068,
0.7213365436,
0.8325596452,
-0.19447954,
0.333840549,
0.1097129136,
0.4902765453,
0.0979650319,
0.2667322159,
-0.0865717232,
-1.1450799704,
0.0953070894,
-0.8282991648,
-0.2711420357,
0.4262643754,
-0.8544200659,
0.2528755963,
-0.4812859297,
-0.0246025417,
0.2751906514,
-0.3212784231,
-0.5056205392,
0.2275002003,
0.3841824532,
1.1525417566,
-1.0610816479,
1.1051011086,
1.0821942091,
-0.1849786639,
-0.6459112167,
0.1875884682,
0.1120063141,
-0.4468065798,
0.2771432996,
0.455295831,
-0.0522834137,
0.0112830754,
-0.3297979832,
-0.1565683931,
1.10153234,
0.5554962754,
-0.419859767,
0.1544656456,
0.2395837754,
0.6311307549,
-0.3361504972,
0.1301346123,
0.8045403957,
0.4726662934,
-0.0943292081,
-1.0665779114,
-0.085505344,
-0.1624760628,
0.2597534955,
0.2626329362,
-0.370998621,
0.8742598891,
0.1584564298,
-0.2603836954,
-0.0477077365,
0.4495300949,
0.4278564751,
0.4829286635,
0.818779707,
1.1666842699,
0.5946292877,
-0.3149446249,
1.2029359341,
-0.2541519403,
0.2437939197,
0.9205554128,
-0.1909506619,
0.7385037541,
1.0228716135,
-0.3268121183,
0.4000041783,
0.611209929,
0.0212740842,
0.3507067859,
0.4664892554,
-0.589600563,
-0.1657069474,
-0.3474478126,
-0.3027969301,
0.8358517289,
0.2698417902,
-0.468886435,
-0.5378559232,
0.1710675806,
-0.1010908335,
0.6456445456,
-0.3332620561,
0.7462593913,
0.3795377016,
-0.3455312252,
0.625038147,
0.4298475981,
0.920899272,
-0.7523910403,
0.0786497667,
-0.0650721043,
0.1005201787,
0.1294444352,
-0.3872253597,
0.3458078206,
-0.1709090769,
0.0422651283,
-0.0653805062,
0.7687987089,
-0.4866366982,
-0.3646900356,
0.3965989053,
0.7527965307,
0.1912278831,
-0.3725108504,
-0.8954055309,
-0.1622029543,
-0.4856499434,
0.0838350952,
0.5548610091,
0.5652916431,
-0.0679990873,
0.6821511388,
0.481826514,
0.2730007172,
-0.2969529033,
-0.0928808451,
0.7371293306,
-0.6109816432,
-0.7729852796,
-0.8523997068,
0.0629129112,
-0.0507426932,
-0.4134756923,
0.6187862754,
0.2856632769,
1.1310471296,
-0.3109865487,
0.4192943871,
-0.1027081236,
0.1565795988,
-0.4325769246,
0.7366789579,
-0.7089886069,
0.1779954135,
-0.308932364,
-1.0444564819,
-0.1775772125,
0.9398505688,
-0.2088728994,
-0.1006869525,
1.0622073412,
0.7428982258,
-0.5365534425,
0.1482736468,
0.3471167684,
-0.063402541,
-0.2942600548,
0.3845398128,
0.8512036204,
-0.1680686474,
0.0865060315,
-0.4188990593,
-0.1142613366,
0.259434402,
-1.0543084145,
-0.8124570251,
-0.7181174159,
-0.3078269958,
-0.2816184759,
0.1702265143,
1.067804575,
0.3794685006,
-0.4723275602,
-0.063192144,
-0.323625356,
0.1946302503,
-0.5726840496,
-0.2921803296,
0.0745135844,
-0.3043595552,
-0.6051508188,
0.3264963925,
0.2635170519,
0.0443479866,
-0.1824811846,
0.1408216506,
-0.4045898616,
0.2747609913,
0.6134661436,
-0.0547876693,
-0.8650972247,
-0.496787101,
-0.5719585419,
-0.0234876778,
-0.0971654728,
0.7840204835,
-0.973695755,
0.4576556385,
0.2722138166,
0.4828189611,
0.1306886077,
-0.0682420358,
0.3736805618,
-0.9376701117,
0.7879888415,
0.3565464914,
0.4383336306,
0.1522991508,
0.1779522598,
0.3991702497,
0.9765714407,
0.2466031909,
-1.0272479057,
0.580473125,
-0.9592146873,
-0.5489504933,
1.0283970833,
-0.1785838455,
-0.1721675098,
0.0935369506,
-0.1517739147,
-0.0380593091,
0.1880045831,
0.9695624113,
0.894220531,
0.2280710489,
-0.0041032592,
-0.3839520216,
0.4215549231,
0.4412664175,
-0.4815598428,
-0.2337105721,
0.2767695785,
0.3150834441,
0.0344221406,
0.4192651212,
-0.1277803183,
0.3541942239,
0.1604179293,
-0.0093155745,
-0.288389504,
-0.3907339871,
-0.3968197405,
0.1676064432,
-0.1555701047,
-0.4055000842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08390v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08390v2 | Lessons learned from the evaluation of Spanish Language Models | 2022-12-16T10:33:38 | 2023-09-22T07:55:52 | Rodrigo Agerri, Eneko Agirre | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Given the impact of language models on the field of Natural Language
Processing, a number of Spanish encoder-only masked language models (aka BERTs)
have been trained and released. These models were developed either within large
projects using very large private corpora or by means of smaller scale academic
efforts leveraging freely available data. In this paper we present a
comprehensive head-to-head comparison of language models for Spanish with the
following results: (i) Previously ignored multilingual models from large
companies fare better than monolingual models, substantially changing the
evaluation landscape of language models in Spanish; (ii) Results across the
monolingual models are not conclusive, with supposedly smaller and inferior
models performing competitively. Based on these empirical results, we argue for
the need of more research to understand the factors underlying them. In this
sense, the effect of corpus size, quality and pre-training techniques need to
be further investigated to be able to obtain Spanish monolingual models
significantly better than the multilingual ones released by large private
companies, specially in the face of rapid ongoing progress in the field. The
recent activity in the development of language technology for Spanish is to be
welcomed, but our results show that building language models remains an open,
resource-heavy problem which requires to marry resources (monetary and/or
computational) with the best research expertise and practice. | [
-0.5142988563,
-0.4225699604,
0.3432780206,
0.6062944531,
-0.0708887726,
0.2890268564,
-0.5120837092,
-0.8466612101,
0.1457705945,
0.5704618096,
-0.3740854263,
-0.085956119,
-0.617603302,
0.2074071616,
-0.4620594084,
0.9123555422,
0.2547847927,
0.267098099,
-0.0876327306,
0.0222561713,
-0.3598145843,
-0.6083849072,
-0.6857725382,
-0.441645205,
0.5545623302,
-0.0207921267,
0.7815054655,
0.506834209,
0.568844974,
0.3218295574,
-0.1592772305,
-0.2096033096,
-0.4302248061,
-0.0763118789,
-0.1848593801,
-0.0739015043,
-0.3247518837,
-0.0849490985,
0.5945419073,
0.9504957795,
0.0372914746,
0.1863422096,
0.3235822022,
0.803245604,
-0.5179145932,
0.2588278055,
-0.5595517755,
0.135755375,
-0.1666252762,
0.0155346906,
-0.6590124965,
-0.4746030867,
0.5218518972,
-0.0760998353,
0.2069774866,
0.0006213926,
0.809812367,
0.0618845671,
-0.25697577,
-0.5406791568,
-0.7737267613,
0.9538195133,
-0.5827231407,
0.6959355474,
0.1489730477,
0.3054769933,
-0.1463852972,
-0.3356412351,
-0.2479185611,
-0.4936839938,
0.1049900725,
0.0011027999,
-0.2428109199,
0.1209065914,
-0.1575266719,
0.343180716,
-0.4940220714,
0.404620558,
-0.7327956557,
-0.1316291839,
0.4141623378,
-0.4122040272,
0.010961826,
-0.0915876403,
-0.1304243952,
-0.4470530748,
-0.8536572456,
0.1188103035,
0.5683518052,
0.5086970329,
0.0836373866,
0.3604658842,
-0.014708749,
0.5855595469,
-0.1265977919,
-0.2343434095,
0.158599034,
-0.0599628538,
-0.5223398805,
-0.0684804097,
0.7733582258,
-0.1614111215,
0.5124166012,
-0.5157629848,
-0.1327975839,
0.0267424192,
0.1712215096,
-0.5410791039,
0.0094257342,
0.2332601696,
-0.5140017867,
-0.2758230865,
0.0719244331,
-0.7611026168,
-0.2808772326,
-0.1614227146,
0.2295293212,
-0.1103704944,
-0.2808541656,
0.408202678,
-0.034679316,
0.0662891865,
0.170097217,
-0.6219069958,
0.4993480444,
0.6233586669,
0.6827065945,
-0.114998661,
-0.2536623478,
-0.108223483,
-0.4562747777,
-0.4057348967,
0.6804171205,
-0.2598912716,
-0.4214706421,
0.252987504,
-0.032865122,
-0.1711853892,
-0.6426185369,
0.428354919,
-0.4988736212,
0.146572575,
-0.3177114129,
-0.1720379442,
-0.1845740974,
0.0126568899,
-0.8602182269,
0.8569529057,
-0.1961082518,
-0.5957024097,
0.2805993557,
-0.5871306658,
-0.3646365702,
-0.1840680689,
-0.0670239106,
-0.1932587326,
0.2020923644,
0.1501705796,
0.4445141852,
-0.4527506828,
0.4829766452,
-0.2569279075,
-0.0006385983,
0.3560068011,
-0.3207788765,
0.8962071538,
0.2229655534,
-0.3461633325,
-0.051677864,
-0.7618011236,
-0.0125184488,
0.0772841275,
-0.2774941027,
-0.1804607064,
-0.0642834008,
0.0296316575,
0.4419581294,
0.2233488858,
-0.6135255098,
-0.5128415227,
-0.5026222467,
0.1730427295,
0.6500313878,
-0.4578507841,
0.3842841089,
-0.2650161386,
0.6685588956,
-0.5161442161,
0.2753809392,
-0.1688252985,
-0.3767644167,
-0.8029122353,
-0.3606337011,
0.480612278,
0.2054837942,
-0.3901286721,
0.1317361891,
-0.2352935672,
-0.6961452365,
-0.7245330215,
-0.0626469702,
0.6900064349,
0.3790065646,
0.2184207141,
-0.4822517931,
-0.8067436218,
-1.0738041401,
-0.1458617747,
-0.0962317958,
0.0327841751,
0.0972966403,
0.5838065743,
0.1950470954,
0.8554095626,
0.1755940318,
-0.1255606562,
-0.3294886649,
0.106404148,
0.1210053414,
0.4493469596,
0.7382636666,
-0.2565332651,
-0.398355484,
0.3041820228,
-0.6673896909,
0.0931297764,
0.2685318291,
0.1841786802,
0.2739876807,
0.2486267686,
-0.1528276503,
0.1497458369,
0.9572231174,
-0.1119239256,
0.5323463678,
-0.4258891344,
0.0835484713,
-0.3068293333,
0.2386627197,
0.1028630883,
-0.2106620222,
-0.6120740175,
0.1576882601,
0.1871006042,
-0.0439712889,
-0.5588563681,
0.537576437,
-0.6187428236,
-0.3432350457,
-0.1427433342,
-0.0730717555,
0.0876072347,
0.4230749905,
0.3163212538,
0.6950978637,
0.4911908805,
-0.6258051991,
0.1588390917,
0.0062951869,
-0.7888874412,
-0.0492348596,
-0.9252581,
0.2427297533,
-0.3388994038,
0.0260618925,
-0.7450212836,
0.0943852887,
-0.115881674,
-0.1713027507,
0.2927457988,
0.0258710627,
-0.5362639427,
-0.6807317138,
-0.4446882308,
0.0560696088,
0.5201206207,
-0.5190074444,
0.065392144,
0.5404625535,
-0.3913875222,
-0.683818996,
-0.7681512237,
0.0620920807,
-0.0280019045,
-0.7224193811,
0.1793717593,
0.0074650743,
-0.4224638641,
-0.1486059129,
-0.2284830511,
-0.3377383947,
0.0872610286,
0.0112463264,
0.188427031,
-0.4394616485,
0.1201908141,
0.0242061932,
0.1541832238,
0.1239619926,
-0.1210831627,
0.5870389342,
-0.3704526722,
-0.2873167694,
-0.1501275152,
0.1115046218,
0.612998724,
-0.4778650403,
0.9364270568,
0.0258349031,
-0.2775866091,
0.0350880735,
-0.8982468247,
-0.040946722,
-0.4070470333,
0.4595346451,
-0.281234622,
-0.7055339813,
0.5496884584,
0.229035601,
-0.0086373482,
0.4856480956,
0.586214304,
0.0797580704,
0.790843606,
0.9838348627,
0.0341798812,
0.6018949151,
-0.1370031536,
0.2470716536,
-0.4682097435,
-0.482065469,
-0.9216915965,
0.0669569299,
-0.4124116302,
-0.229823187,
0.2975524962,
-0.1566685736,
-0.0996801704,
0.60083884,
-0.250454843,
0.4608747661,
0.4282132387,
0.0399360508,
0.4872730374,
0.0614328124,
-0.1347485632,
-0.1276571155,
-0.85774225,
-0.7014024258,
1.2550081015,
0.6779628396,
0.5664007068,
-0.1202379763,
0.3359959424,
0.0747900903,
0.4234123528,
-0.5470305681,
0.1934844404,
-0.2620318532,
-0.6222199202,
-0.3050639331,
-0.2438166142,
-0.9682044983,
0.6795025468,
-0.2804391086,
-0.5662413836,
0.4359034598,
-0.1279234886,
-0.2844058871,
0.0814489722,
-0.7922723889,
1.1184188128,
-0.4150031507,
-0.3167636991,
-0.2378004938,
-0.3426001072,
0.2428585142,
-0.3005322516,
0.6746214032,
-0.0417069606,
0.2139872611,
0.9677488804,
-0.3947826028,
0.56983006,
-0.0108767711,
-0.3301034272,
0.3227587938,
0.1447719634,
0.3152039945,
-0.295481503,
-0.3705040216,
0.2582125664,
0.0718327835,
-0.3509095311,
-0.2227491885,
0.5732707381,
-0.6566156745,
-0.1885186583,
-0.3150348663,
-0.4338144064,
-0.3140870929,
0.0813577622,
0.2303142995,
0.4613912106,
-0.5608761907,
0.3813144565,
0.6431251168,
-0.4317056537,
0.6563345194,
0.4702964127,
-0.4367063344,
-0.1077082232,
0.5748822689,
0.2626859248,
0.3119976223,
0.148584947,
0.1073156521,
-0.3155475855,
-0.5459765196,
-0.2779892981,
0.4904980361,
-0.4374746978,
0.0569040179,
-0.6334173679,
0.0128446789,
-0.5208338499,
-0.0042921579,
-0.9054355025,
-0.2189808488,
0.1777011603,
-0.0747541785,
-0.0569373965,
0.7963317037,
0.0586285368,
0.3538446128,
-0.5353124738,
-0.0238934439,
0.1209866479,
0.3562138677,
0.3005438447,
-0.4239245951,
-0.358726114,
0.1513029933,
-0.0813750699,
-0.7672606707,
0.4880393445,
0.08301384,
0.5586305261,
0.3731260896,
-0.2703304291,
0.7160049081,
-0.549733758,
0.3848501742,
0.1839274764,
-0.9367397428,
0.4847556055,
-0.1107251123,
-0.0344970077,
0.516001761,
0.3679747283,
-0.3739533722,
-0.4904120862,
-0.663683176,
-0.7255327702,
0.7384849787,
0.2230731696,
0.0882378295,
-0.043840088,
-0.2348645031,
0.5041386485,
0.5871588588,
-1.0672821999,
-0.099948056,
-0.0679351315,
0.2193104625,
-0.0416457988,
-0.2993423343,
0.3622922599,
-0.2587189972,
0.6885149479,
0.2871612906,
0.1911416203,
0.0320930369,
-0.348267287,
0.0084265368,
0.3508636653,
0.4464681745,
0.8292683959,
-0.3594185412,
-0.0912655666,
-0.0758195966,
-0.1998039931,
-0.3069524467,
-0.0909864232,
0.0586753674,
0.3770481944,
0.4123879373,
0.8173676729,
0.387477845,
-0.9700357914,
0.564215064,
0.2641008198,
-0.0645731911,
-0.1918970942,
-0.3876067996,
-0.2349118888,
0.0699945763,
0.2483464777,
0.1105129719,
0.0113201989,
-0.8373754621,
-0.1438711435,
0.4165017605,
-0.2709635794,
-0.3341225684,
0.3028973341,
0.2716463804,
-0.0901310295,
0.1634730399,
-0.0348392911,
-0.4927254915,
0.7789397836,
0.5555668473,
0.5747233033,
-0.3133365512,
0.4136892855,
0.3169923425,
0.6474586725,
-0.6210327744,
-0.0361721255,
0.063436605,
-0.606241107,
-0.5753522515,
-0.6169589162,
-0.5467407703,
0.3305298984,
-0.6096993685,
0.071530439,
-0.4835356176,
-0.0659069642,
-0.0905467346,
-0.0768931359,
-0.9926605225,
0.1740095466,
0.050197877,
0.8292169571,
-0.7752161622,
0.8262565732,
0.3989808261,
-0.5273096561,
-0.3728598058,
-0.5078038573,
-0.3133717477,
-0.8220633268,
0.7325614691,
0.039109692,
-0.3468743563,
-0.3311778009,
-0.1291053146,
-0.8960515857,
0.4301230013,
0.6344377995,
-0.5802960396,
-0.1536738276,
0.1667743474,
0.9490572214,
-0.3791600466,
0.3800704181,
0.4835843146,
0.4308688343,
-0.0751398429,
-1.4195559025,
-0.2974689007,
-0.0357631408,
-0.0119800372,
-0.098376289,
-0.3220919073,
1.0407161713,
0.046327617,
-0.3159488738,
0.1333103627,
0.5467315912,
-0.1607009172,
0.0799767524,
0.0717060864,
-0.0016250948,
0.7924762964,
0.0375192948,
1.1703647375,
-0.3024265766,
0.387960434,
1.0422914028,
-0.254961282,
0.9127871394,
0.4913431406,
-0.4209853411,
0.3766777813,
0.4573740959,
0.1175471246,
0.5622527599,
0.2568617165,
0.0867377296,
0.0639054775,
-0.1279400587,
-0.549495399,
0.3557713032,
0.152763322,
-0.4784758389,
-0.3939178586,
0.4019714594,
0.1897698492,
0.2799119353,
-0.3741144538,
0.3666844964,
-0.0387977399,
-0.7522021532,
0.4768123925,
0.2856476307,
0.8733284473,
-0.4547487199,
0.486843735,
-0.2520930767,
0.1012597904,
-0.1069598198,
-0.3617438376,
0.5455229282,
0.5172778368,
-0.0029726794,
-0.5797197223,
0.5307688713,
-0.2991802096,
-0.5160061717,
0.5564473271,
0.8968290091,
0.298748523,
-0.350112915,
-0.3851161003,
0.268306911,
-0.2447294295,
-0.0676151365,
0.2757781148,
0.1272702515,
0.0346032903,
0.6038495302,
0.4684385359,
0.3004282117,
0.3748206794,
0.2158505321,
0.4475071132,
-0.5590250492,
-0.3740942478,
-0.7404014468,
0.2704337835,
0.0140450168,
-0.1955846101,
0.7073670626,
0.5900635719,
1.1484830379,
-0.3532298803,
0.5797911882,
0.0724033788,
0.4888961911,
-0.4064751565,
0.6321342587,
-0.159491986,
0.2487301379,
-0.3850393891,
-0.9773241878,
-0.3314210474,
0.8715137839,
-0.385715127,
0.1467060298,
0.8692042232,
0.575078249,
0.0680579543,
-0.0126076387,
0.2834908068,
0.2776413858,
0.0777514055,
0.3875063658,
0.7791439891,
-0.5084277391,
0.5380075574,
-0.4659836888,
-0.2728308439,
-0.2297041863,
-0.9462072253,
-0.9231327176,
-0.4575308859,
-0.331957221,
-0.1482484192,
0.2801386118,
0.9182801247,
0.5528436303,
-0.911172092,
-0.6921124458,
-0.0773602203,
0.2542769611,
-0.2051030397,
-0.1056319326,
0.303078711,
-0.3456147909,
-0.8477881551,
0.5049318075,
0.2814004421,
-0.0189479124,
-0.436647743,
-0.0636397824,
0.0472301655,
0.2085184753,
0.802543819,
0.5479127765,
-0.7630390525,
-0.1660719663,
0.1463725865,
-0.2133740783,
0.2450766414,
0.7335060835,
-0.9476134777,
0.3876306415,
0.2590546608,
0.5777724385,
0.4879319072,
-0.5899549127,
0.5363426208,
-0.521330297,
0.3471990228,
0.1345718205,
0.4400836825,
0.3773536086,
0.157785356,
0.4701074958,
-0.1258530319,
-0.1372694075,
-0.9511091113,
0.0623424239,
-0.7518383265,
-0.2981250584,
0.8261061311,
-0.0402678251,
-0.2165793031,
-0.0042985119,
-0.1301283389,
0.1129677519,
-0.2295204401,
0.8041062951,
0.8800296187,
0.0384969376,
0.0192966759,
-0.6590890884,
0.3218766451,
0.4291059971,
-0.4973789155,
-0.2255788893,
0.2680456638,
0.037100412,
0.1719583571,
0.5522610545,
-0.4163416326,
0.124404639,
-0.0509815365,
0.2514778078,
-0.1242462099,
-0.6895843744,
-0.5572915077,
0.2802398801,
0.2751933932,
-0.1220575646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08388v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08388v1 | Homonymy Information for English WordNet | 2022-12-16T10:23:26 | 2022-12-16T10:23:26 | Rowan Hall Maudslay, Simone Teufel | cs.CL | cs.CL | A widely acknowledged shortcoming of WordNet is that it lacks a distinction
between word meanings which are systematically related (polysemy), and those
which are coincidental (homonymy). Several previous works have attempted to
fill this gap, by inferring this information using computational methods. We
revisit this task, and exploit recent advances in language modelling to
synthesise homonymy annotation for Princeton WordNet. Previous approaches treat
the problem using clustering methods; by contrast, our method works by linking
WordNet to the Oxford English Dictionary, which contains the information we
need. To perform this alignment, we pair definitions based on their proximity
in an embedding space produced by a Transformer model. Despite the simplicity
of this approach, our best model attains an F1 of .97 on an evaluation set that
we annotate. The outcome of our work is a high-quality homonymy annotation
layer for Princeton WordNet, which we release. | [
-0.307330966,
-0.4428122938,
0.4495547414,
0.2468940765,
-0.1136710346,
-0.1817892641,
-0.1836383641,
-0.6856001616,
0.8225533962,
0.1294762492,
-0.4178831577,
-0.0603213944,
-0.6523411274,
0.246757403,
-0.5762021542,
0.7019933462,
-0.0268153455,
-0.1420996487,
-0.5360867977,
-0.1648961157,
-0.2314375788,
-0.3274693191,
-0.2056174427,
-0.6639546156,
0.6573164463,
0.123719871,
0.8862405419,
0.8246350288,
0.7391858697,
0.3012600541,
-0.3217799664,
0.1212906688,
-0.2356631607,
-0.0822199285,
-0.3138064742,
-0.2776246667,
-0.3758648336,
0.3730517626,
0.660574317,
1.2337853909,
0.1554103345,
0.1758027673,
0.0204709228,
0.5118808746,
-0.586173296,
0.1235677823,
-0.7719310522,
0.0377140082,
-0.3091089725,
0.1711811125,
-0.1321254373,
-0.2422062308,
0.3668607771,
-0.664702177,
0.1730805337,
0.3540973961,
0.9856249094,
-0.0300999228,
-0.1283951104,
-0.1009094939,
-0.6922980547,
0.5515831709,
-0.4570201933,
0.4188738465,
0.4767259955,
0.247924,
-0.1240871772,
-0.724414885,
-0.7645085454,
-0.1638834774,
-0.383844763,
0.1474365741,
0.1160783023,
0.0395307392,
0.0618986934,
0.3693979681,
-0.428697139,
-0.2405388802,
-0.5885928273,
-0.1024593189,
0.6404753327,
0.1423678994,
-0.0081909215,
-0.6090703607,
-0.6075859666,
0.0047061136,
-0.4828873873,
-0.2816469967,
0.4465615749,
0.3321195841,
0.0543472171,
0.7760249376,
0.1929665208,
0.4607040584,
-0.2114976645,
0.1743723154,
0.2952069044,
0.0362187363,
-0.1757506281,
0.0778675526,
0.7189418674,
0.3759225011,
0.1383455396,
-0.4129554033,
-0.0669410005,
0.4096505642,
0.51504004,
-0.3383219838,
-0.4020119309,
0.2295428067,
-0.3511244357,
-0.1969933957,
0.5017197132,
-0.2621197999,
-0.0987348258,
-0.3272643983,
0.7543990612,
-0.4404421747,
-0.1139472276,
-0.2438305914,
-0.5650999546,
0.208200112,
-0.0010114812,
-0.6392086148,
0.2472046167,
0.9017484188,
0.8503859639,
-0.3422392309,
-0.590149045,
0.3244701624,
0.5107451081,
-0.3035573363,
0.5190503597,
-0.4816887975,
-0.1870859265,
0.0017029515,
0.2760498822,
0.0188595057,
-0.441598326,
-0.1652381867,
-0.2814293504,
0.4654659331,
0.1667825729,
-1.0527870655,
-0.2401782274,
0.343079716,
-0.7490381002,
0.749489665,
0.1719309539,
-1.2359741926,
-0.001443677,
-0.392025739,
-0.321464926,
0.3539402187,
-0.0190911666,
-0.0905134007,
0.4172337055,
-0.4930101633,
0.2662225068,
-0.1741664112,
0.3923659027,
-0.3107954562,
-0.5355282426,
0.1420169771,
0.0437895954,
0.7104259729,
0.0076748189,
-0.1722873151,
-0.1028337404,
-0.7784235477,
-0.4058565497,
0.1099595353,
-0.0552469008,
-0.7278191447,
0.2029064894,
0.1078621075,
0.0653085932,
0.3282702863,
-0.7991275191,
0.1228383631,
-0.6879510283,
0.2085619122,
0.5643797517,
-0.5273979306,
0.4484833479,
-0.517688632,
0.2737412453,
0.0591754466,
0.1759244353,
0.4059195518,
-0.7851105332,
-0.6373382211,
0.1390191168,
0.5565574765,
0.5998027921,
-0.5857954025,
0.6471136808,
-0.542827487,
-0.5732440352,
-0.6447527409,
-0.0530176722,
0.1822280586,
0.3236413002,
0.3677763939,
-0.4904184043,
-0.6623414159,
-1.1227724552,
-0.44837448,
-0.2714062333,
-0.01749341,
0.2076205909,
0.3765478432,
-0.6545497775,
0.9921726584,
-0.3152534068,
-0.2867718339,
-0.0429139882,
0.0938168764,
0.3618774414,
0.2046978921,
0.1251642853,
-0.7401393652,
-0.2440106869,
-0.050439205,
-0.6031965613,
-0.156376034,
0.2576680779,
-0.2094504237,
-0.1869732291,
0.6259053349,
-0.3370568752,
0.6434571743,
0.7479947209,
-0.2593216002,
0.4243744612,
0.1196620241,
-0.1895770878,
-1.4299088717,
0.1003980711,
-0.2542533278,
-0.2934412658,
-0.4207145274,
0.0455489457,
-0.0816075057,
0.1368611455,
-0.2835743725,
0.6239735484,
-0.3762644827,
0.1588927209,
-0.5229434371,
0.5238722563,
-0.071272105,
-0.062839143,
-0.1222205907,
0.326044023,
0.4288362861,
-0.3545836806,
0.7764409184,
0.6154685616,
0.1310112327,
0.2132947445,
-0.580857873,
-0.1499942541,
-0.1181337163,
0.0927668139,
-1.0502363443,
-0.297675997,
0.1449900568,
-0.3294247687,
0.1067295894,
-0.0629636496,
-0.1006342545,
-0.4875538051,
-0.5640046597,
0.5572078228,
0.4140725732,
-0.5550079346,
0.6033110619,
0.4886932075,
0.1735745668,
-0.166750744,
-1.0620051622,
0.0921512395,
-0.1394177377,
-0.808603406,
0.6806075573,
0.2359206825,
-0.4589162171,
0.2966071069,
0.0274634287,
-0.0498849526,
-0.0200928152,
0.5737255216,
0.2628731728,
0.1156818196,
0.3104818165,
-0.3469298482,
-0.1425446123,
0.3371161222,
-0.5143795013,
0.2819514871,
0.1995466799,
-0.0875407606,
-0.0148048503,
0.5502275825,
0.1484388262,
0.2693004608,
1.0764989853,
0.6452397108,
-0.6202306151,
-0.3110010624,
-0.4036056697,
-0.2042940855,
-0.3950923085,
-0.0613247007,
-0.1818218678,
-0.9063093662,
0.3110877872,
-0.1301010847,
-0.0625087544,
0.6771198511,
0.0478381515,
-0.1718638688,
0.3907648027,
0.6378050447,
0.1714160293,
0.3648628294,
-0.0060260468,
0.2890064418,
-0.9051445723,
-0.1420111358,
-0.4671958685,
-0.5641824007,
-1.0516825914,
-0.2633756399,
0.4633723795,
0.0344202518,
0.1967371851,
0.6413283348,
-0.2156289965,
0.1343521625,
0.665748179,
0.0260477103,
-0.019150177,
0.1798239201,
-0.343726337,
-0.0291315522,
-0.7537267208,
-0.363447845,
0.9050893188,
-0.0326760933,
0.5219236612,
0.2303327918,
0.8011078835,
-0.1302942336,
0.2492461205,
-0.5956320763,
0.5460385084,
-0.3788597584,
-0.5893343687,
-0.1428498924,
-0.6208008528,
-1.1728082895,
-0.1143336892,
-0.3600995243,
-0.681728363,
-0.2038377821,
0.0882180929,
-0.0339646898,
0.2802375853,
-0.5380244255,
0.4978343546,
0.3806526065,
-0.5164025426,
-0.1205434501,
-0.908662796,
0.2819010317,
-0.1126215607,
0.4195850492,
-0.1183664724,
0.1799425185,
0.7791894078,
-0.7669279575,
0.5588657856,
0.2142514288,
-0.0337372385,
0.1891615987,
0.2151662856,
0.150090158,
-0.2314526886,
-0.0738717616,
0.4105016887,
0.0911007747,
-0.3251104057,
-0.2917240262,
0.6306220293,
-0.5023012757,
-0.487202704,
-0.3354352117,
-0.6828107834,
-0.3959417045,
-0.0775336325,
0.2725877464,
0.2730837762,
-0.1641031504,
-0.0008523909,
0.1355104148,
-0.0144733246,
0.6381094456,
-0.2220070511,
-0.5441951752,
-0.4477534592,
0.5458320975,
0.2038686275,
0.0524536036,
0.4428668618,
0.5088056326,
-0.2828737795,
0.0318250582,
0.0897143781,
0.5033439398,
-0.5348947048,
-0.0997252092,
-0.2050740421,
-0.5098292232,
-0.5441070795,
-0.0153959589,
-0.1665520221,
-0.683116436,
0.0720079392,
0.2226874381,
0.4527429342,
1.2067518234,
-0.0214839801,
0.4090299904,
-0.8848136663,
0.3013833165,
0.6051497459,
0.592066884,
-0.1701225042,
-0.5610275865,
-0.356359154,
-0.133115381,
-0.1057570949,
-1.0455334187,
-0.0043819356,
0.3667191565,
0.1334328055,
0.223134324,
-0.4340434074,
0.6188497543,
-0.7876160741,
1.010850668,
0.2043205202,
-1.0457531214,
0.6928167939,
-0.0324086063,
0.1462422758,
0.3365430236,
0.6490195394,
-0.7398242354,
-0.1790444106,
-0.9183866382,
-1.0890702009,
0.4176511168,
0.2342032641,
0.1233524606,
-0.5187866092,
0.43937397,
0.1326902509,
0.2323610336,
-0.6056879759,
-0.3986943364,
0.2509683073,
-0.3330964446,
-0.1300927699,
-0.2184449732,
-0.0027387463,
-0.528678596,
0.8812811971,
-0.0329156816,
0.3521922231,
0.1617045105,
-0.1503875852,
-0.0819097757,
-0.1024462357,
0.0771529675,
0.8032457232,
-0.0595010445,
0.6046468019,
-0.0069319564,
-0.7178195715,
-0.0680089816,
0.2562421858,
-0.2178396583,
0.5555773973,
0.512656033,
0.579529345,
0.0599305928,
-0.2217468023,
0.8533153534,
0.163657099,
-0.2671628594,
-0.3898088038,
-0.0276420582,
0.4624592662,
0.1682757735,
-0.0179311745,
-0.1582132727,
0.1002296358,
-0.2892363667,
0.1835519224,
0.4805062711,
-0.4435364902,
-0.2869971693,
0.5784135461,
-0.1133729219,
-0.4666801989,
0.4319347739,
-0.3727686703,
-0.6379032135,
0.2113304138,
0.5653821826,
0.9548297524,
-0.4282387197,
-0.0816334784,
0.1791263968,
0.4122489691,
-0.0770868659,
0.5740357637,
0.3454071581,
-0.7035954595,
-0.2950141728,
-0.8947013617,
-0.246220991,
-0.2719939351,
-0.442694664,
0.3055024445,
-0.3451529443,
-0.1157547608,
-0.0466359966,
-0.270611763,
-0.6125736237,
0.2426612526,
0.1516806334,
0.8519631624,
-0.9664764404,
0.7220155001,
1.100681901,
0.0412047133,
-1.2004612684,
-0.020739736,
-0.2412923723,
-0.540609479,
0.337333709,
0.4532010257,
-0.0161301419,
0.0406799167,
-0.5118698478,
-0.5836805701,
1.0787676573,
0.1510051936,
-0.8448554277,
0.040512424,
0.4047397077,
0.4119075537,
-0.145214662,
0.2116651386,
0.2969928682,
0.5620815754,
-0.0913829803,
-0.9343918562,
-0.1974170506,
-0.3537109494,
0.3399864435,
0.4419366717,
-0.2873558402,
0.9280859828,
0.4636402428,
-0.0732270628,
-0.1806238741,
0.628349483,
-0.2651735246,
0.1404901743,
0.5912290215,
0.9361506701,
0.5487174988,
-0.103632167,
0.9546846151,
-0.3044151664,
0.5521440506,
0.9396597147,
-0.1163778454,
0.877931416,
0.9408801794,
-0.5057670474,
0.4856895804,
0.2153450847,
0.1216815114,
0.0248306822,
0.5667577982,
-0.1271880269,
-0.1761472672,
-0.1721274853,
-0.1730612665,
0.71604532,
0.2084555328,
-0.5703471303,
0.0405030884,
-0.1702725738,
-0.3262804151,
0.0135703404,
-0.2971859574,
0.9266750216,
0.2710800767,
-0.3836188912,
0.3185586035,
0.0271694101,
0.765663743,
-0.4307312667,
0.049413316,
-0.2292543948,
0.0493019223,
-0.3054259717,
-0.422984302,
0.603900373,
-0.4099255502,
-0.1366928965,
0.093856208,
0.6299493909,
-0.7480631471,
-0.5596627593,
0.5664812922,
0.6623514891,
0.3527655005,
0.0895353183,
-0.3222151399,
-0.1822091043,
-0.4020996094,
0.0334821604,
-0.1744929105,
0.4608177543,
-0.1060302705,
0.1253556609,
0.2556913197,
0.6507095098,
0.3247845769,
-0.0699563026,
0.504265368,
-0.7165380716,
-0.5437156558,
-0.9513670206,
0.202390939,
0.001714472,
-0.3282675743,
0.775598824,
0.3698768914,
1.0231283903,
-0.021515727,
0.5776868463,
-0.2308551073,
0.3785149753,
-0.2465724647,
0.5894747376,
-0.6849462986,
0.1499517709,
-0.376635462,
-1.3562046289,
-0.4103286862,
0.6072517037,
0.0036299778,
-0.1926292777,
0.8724978566,
0.7604168653,
-0.4460915029,
0.382725209,
0.3061693907,
0.2468042374,
-0.2681058645,
0.5527303219,
0.987580359,
-0.825586319,
0.124421753,
-0.4958332479,
-0.2379976809,
-0.1472369432,
-1.1321793795,
-0.7683426738,
-0.7994200587,
-0.2818770409,
-0.4671836793,
0.03698292,
1.2407193184,
0.5899384618,
-0.7358775139,
-0.2837224007,
-0.2092179954,
-0.0913566425,
-0.1041131094,
-0.1878290325,
0.1679436713,
-0.2180620432,
-0.4596616626,
0.2065556049,
0.2527833879,
-0.0428993404,
-0.3688749969,
0.0910014734,
-0.5276460648,
0.2305329293,
0.4091397524,
-0.3623322248,
-0.6566570997,
-0.6922780275,
-0.3455030024,
-0.202607587,
-0.024877334,
0.6282095909,
-0.5729804635,
0.3218745291,
0.603924036,
0.7955613136,
0.1092369929,
-0.1012967825,
0.3700816035,
-1.0855802298,
0.2397741228,
0.1350611299,
0.5051691532,
0.5090520978,
-0.0532777011,
0.429038465,
0.7711215019,
-0.3895782828,
-0.2891538441,
0.3175651431,
-0.8501878381,
-0.3704973757,
1.1763823032,
-0.0827924982,
-0.7621859908,
-0.0269467253,
0.2396098524,
0.4595602751,
0.5066007376,
0.8924772143,
0.876568675,
0.1945989132,
0.3817873895,
-0.1399373114,
0.3578735292,
0.4853560627,
-0.6195868254,
-0.1981882155,
0.3894732296,
0.1548936814,
0.6188237071,
-0.0743088871,
0.0927765891,
-0.0256944206,
0.008895942,
0.356110245,
0.0528085977,
-0.6038903594,
-0.3524215817,
0.2203114033,
-0.0338466018,
-0.200583756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08354v1 | FewFedWeight: Few-shot Federated Learning Framework across Multiple NLP Tasks | 2022-12-16T09:01:56 | 2022-12-16T09:01:56 | Weilong Dong, Xinwei Wu, Junzhuo Li, Shuangzhi Wu, Chao Bian, Deyi Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Massively multi-task learning with large language models has recently made
substantial progress on few-shot generalization. However, this is usually
performed in a centralized learning fashion, ignoring the privacy sensitivity
issue of (annotated) data used in multiple tasks. To mitigate this issue, we
propose FewFedWeight, a few-shot federated learning framework across multiple
tasks, to achieve the best of both worlds: privacy preservation and cross-task
generalization. FewFedWeight trains client models in isolated devices without
sharing data. It broadcasts the global model in the server to each client and
produces pseudo data for clients so that knowledge from the global model can be
explored to enhance few-shot learning of each client model. An energy-based
algorithm is further proposed to weight pseudo samples in order to reduce the
negative impact of noise from the generated pseudo data. Adaptive model weights
of client models are also tuned according to their performance. We use these
model weights to dynamically aggregate client models to update the global
model. Experiments on 118 NLP tasks show that FewFedWeight can significantly
improve the performance of client models on 61% tasks with an average
performance improvement rate of 30.5% over the baseline and substantially
outperform FedAvg and other decentralized learning methods. | [
-0.0604938529,
-0.3756895661,
0.2246509194,
0.3501189947,
0.1215489432,
-0.2610195279,
-0.2920479476,
-0.5106635094,
0.2480407208,
0.4015093148,
-0.6711884141,
-0.5608177781,
-0.5993012786,
0.1067886949,
-0.1199809611,
1.2124683857,
0.3469859958,
0.2950737178,
-0.237720117,
-0.4007519782,
-0.0096163349,
-0.2268916219,
-0.3303354681,
-0.7915347815,
0.5538805723,
0.5277622342,
0.4212090969,
0.4352051914,
0.7894200087,
0.3010680974,
0.4297649264,
0.0739460886,
-0.8798593283,
-0.0606730543,
-0.1771410406,
-0.871065557,
-0.6260128021,
0.0824405104,
0.7252725959,
0.7462356091,
-0.3505679667,
0.4957680106,
0.0473864935,
0.6001294255,
-0.8818752766,
0.2179292887,
-0.5979805589,
0.110226348,
-0.3264332712,
0.1348529011,
-0.3454090059,
0.0013222729,
0.1277662516,
-0.645105958,
0.2594857514,
0.2253013998,
0.5623559952,
0.3134372234,
-0.1187142581,
0.1818546653,
-0.4174244106,
1.113063693,
-0.5332567096,
0.4018543959,
0.6699072123,
0.2703107893,
0.0381797627,
-0.8826157451,
-0.239631176,
0.2370018065,
-0.1235500127,
-0.016882306,
-0.5246260762,
0.1394848078,
0.2679997981,
0.1254623681,
-0.621240437,
0.2191644609,
-0.0316627994,
-0.1576704532,
0.6115535498,
0.0884939507,
0.0067161778,
-0.1107186526,
-0.5690239668,
-0.0034349763,
-0.6253715754,
-0.0349714197,
0.4767028987,
0.7949177623,
-0.365496397,
0.4413636625,
-0.6169620156,
0.7205950022,
0.2378665805,
-0.596355021,
0.320200026,
-0.4437980354,
-0.5680010915,
-0.0054499595,
0.6769539118,
0.1502824575,
-0.3780971467,
-0.3767084181,
-0.2105946243,
-0.1495683044,
0.3428135812,
-0.8502698541,
-0.4079264998,
0.1717748195,
-0.652395606,
-0.1920098364,
-0.1732985079,
-0.547149241,
-0.3672990203,
-0.1628462374,
0.3511522412,
-0.1682891846,
-0.2861854136,
0.0903189629,
-0.0493078791,
-0.0184480324,
0.1245918423,
-1.2307505608,
0.7683992982,
0.9094645381,
0.9445697069,
-0.2702993751,
-0.4742685258,
-0.968757391,
0.0320517011,
0.0859678239,
0.6542866826,
-0.408931911,
-0.003463388,
-0.1313529313,
-0.0619378127,
-0.1605336219,
-0.2555304468,
0.234127298,
-0.405702889,
0.2425494641,
-0.5182640553,
-0.6926156878,
-0.0483140051,
0.5518695116,
-0.531075716,
0.7655348778,
0.0227574892,
-1.0715088844,
0.5940647721,
-0.6210918427,
-0.2671028674,
0.2805583477,
-0.0379166789,
-0.7712596059,
0.1113240868,
0.1772769094,
0.6815145016,
-0.0855777785,
-0.0141653512,
-0.5739488006,
-0.3130022585,
-0.2894524336,
0.0025282484,
0.8768588901,
-0.1145374402,
-0.2493165731,
0.0107760644,
-0.7387203574,
0.0778233036,
0.0365183242,
-0.4864472747,
-0.4905879498,
-0.3096543849,
0.264233768,
0.1713491678,
0.0551253185,
-0.8920485973,
0.2812366486,
-0.6139519215,
0.0633032843,
0.420727402,
-0.1161927357,
0.7708271742,
-0.6642290354,
0.5485215783,
-0.2567408979,
0.1031831875,
0.1654448956,
-0.4966651499,
-0.236433059,
-0.5589197278,
0.0868225619,
0.1933570504,
-0.6706857085,
0.1076470092,
-0.4375865459,
-0.5313732028,
-0.5286425948,
0.7394303083,
0.5304827094,
0.4985235929,
0.4552714527,
-0.2401102334,
-0.3870201409,
-0.6752520204,
-0.2913236022,
0.0001823064,
-0.2146724313,
0.273686707,
0.6752719283,
-0.0913129002,
0.9707500935,
-0.4482581615,
-0.9693093896,
-0.2606729269,
0.2608910203,
-0.1050416455,
0.7232006192,
0.8309531808,
-0.6618568301,
-0.3079863191,
-0.0877138525,
-0.6339891553,
0.1255265921,
-0.1749002635,
-0.1923931241,
-0.0860188827,
-0.0678284019,
-0.5838919282,
-0.1619280875,
0.9070515633,
-0.0078300778,
0.383638978,
-0.0137188509,
-0.3450589478,
-0.8667767048,
0.0527186915,
0.0819130093,
-0.5961400867,
-0.5614520907,
0.3065276742,
-0.0791989267,
-0.0450653471,
-0.6287582517,
0.583296001,
-0.3080789447,
-0.2419760823,
-0.5382630229,
0.0962310731,
0.0970501602,
0.5950375795,
-0.1272729188,
0.4203592539,
0.7746350169,
-0.3386716843,
0.5663844347,
0.2463231683,
-0.0053316588,
0.8209508061,
-0.3793901801,
0.3675291836,
-0.1986302584,
0.4368743598,
-0.7311920524,
-0.3393076658,
0.2192705572,
-0.1338053048,
0.1779548228,
-0.3092960715,
-0.5313088298,
-0.1628074199,
-0.3011261523,
0.1671448052,
-0.2176366895,
-0.6896644831,
0.7023938894,
0.4383587539,
0.1896432191,
-0.78400594,
-0.9582801461,
-0.1206566393,
-0.0339416713,
-0.3381073475,
0.4154812992,
0.1936718673,
-0.1280579269,
0.0781083405,
-0.4222554266,
-0.0966425762,
0.1356770098,
0.533046186,
-0.0547878407,
-0.1420366913,
0.4451726675,
0.0201178137,
-0.1177137345,
-0.1354220361,
-0.9145503044,
0.3943308592,
-0.2815755308,
-0.4651845694,
-0.4187229276,
0.3272272944,
-0.126317367,
-0.1021934524,
0.8582131863,
1.0143698454,
-0.6281877756,
-0.4212625027,
-0.6176522374,
-0.2727434337,
-0.4568331242,
0.1660526395,
-0.4131171405,
-0.9959152341,
0.3804498911,
-0.1906706393,
0.4540486038,
0.2041537166,
0.6897790432,
-0.1990460753,
0.5588651896,
1.2472550869,
-0.3949146271,
0.5468595028,
-0.4967932999,
-0.1216151193,
-0.4068081379,
-0.1886796206,
-0.5326390862,
-0.6967872977,
-0.4773474634,
-0.2422252595,
0.1998134255,
-0.100430131,
0.0376752354,
0.4145379364,
-0.3341355026,
0.6283604503,
0.692129612,
0.3953620493,
0.299235642,
-0.0574149452,
-0.0646570474,
0.0494102873,
-0.9848883152,
-0.1276331246,
1.3938579559,
0.1186240613,
0.8710049987,
0.1831682622,
1.2280082703,
0.1772334129,
0.423142314,
-0.752438724,
0.227769509,
-0.1973650008,
-0.8605965972,
-0.3234131038,
-0.6869165301,
-0.6993809342,
0.5405661464,
-0.6120961905,
-0.9349167347,
0.2496260256,
0.2270970345,
-0.622056663,
0.2701412737,
-0.5755437016,
0.7604978085,
-0.0842421949,
-0.7799742818,
-0.4297076762,
-0.6319642663,
0.5950776935,
-0.0204921383,
-0.0432965904,
-0.1619820595,
-0.0333500467,
0.9226416349,
-0.2687405646,
1.1191935539,
-0.3594224751,
0.3200395703,
-0.0482120104,
-0.1764153093,
0.6084279418,
0.2073679715,
-0.2176936418,
0.32386747,
0.0641477928,
-0.7387367487,
-0.3184144199,
0.8410659432,
-0.6550866365,
-0.219967708,
-0.2411841899,
-0.5291203856,
-0.2704832256,
0.4912787378,
0.1808575392,
0.2580820024,
-0.1872391999,
0.2915254235,
0.4655977786,
0.0645631775,
0.600871861,
0.4320404828,
-0.0201251414,
-0.2329380214,
0.755539,
-0.0750356689,
0.207315892,
0.558564961,
0.2228712738,
-0.1091499999,
-0.3241484165,
-0.1200964227,
0.2757642269,
-0.6702129841,
-0.5422450304,
-0.9275924563,
0.446300894,
-0.4095798135,
-0.22835958,
-0.7835775018,
-0.4049516618,
-0.2304940224,
-0.222056374,
0.1821248382,
0.2724754214,
-0.1990627348,
0.968177855,
-0.6984895468,
0.5916171074,
0.4538933933,
0.5386170149,
-0.1233918443,
-0.0490696877,
-0.3241879642,
-0.0435055271,
-0.2878667116,
-0.4161901176,
0.32897681,
0.4845792949,
0.5025586486,
0.735278368,
0.2537169456,
0.6894804835,
-0.3117112517,
0.4672816694,
0.5564824343,
-0.8687643409,
0.0992517695,
-0.063514553,
0.5417252183,
0.8956055045,
0.5087220669,
-0.2897284031,
-0.3327223063,
-0.5402764082,
-0.3489479423,
0.9709926248,
0.1189764664,
0.2194278687,
0.5272044539,
0.1432093084,
0.2698391974,
0.3826314509,
-0.8867340088,
-0.2632263005,
-0.2793536782,
-0.0709459707,
0.1920586079,
0.1959568113,
-0.5687960982,
-0.0899507403,
0.5669326782,
-0.6402174234,
0.1714445353,
-0.1437172741,
-0.3023016751,
-0.3119248152,
0.1961801499,
0.3768079281,
0.6331849098,
-0.2338012755,
0.190653041,
0.20663248,
-0.4662722647,
-0.0142463204,
0.3384806514,
-0.1090221182,
-0.0971684977,
0.5506210923,
0.7612057924,
0.5449128151,
-0.2906447053,
0.6766428947,
-0.1492087692,
-0.387858659,
0.1668949425,
-0.0082402285,
0.0600599498,
0.4691715539,
0.3667361736,
0.4146214426,
0.1219231039,
-0.2714864016,
0.4139583409,
0.6226314902,
-0.1504512131,
-0.4684436917,
0.7628456354,
0.2381940037,
0.112308763,
0.2593702376,
-0.4000746608,
-0.2448368073,
0.2464889139,
0.5211988688,
0.7527982593,
-0.0185883977,
0.3804028332,
0.1491657048,
0.3918776214,
-0.5198566318,
0.1438542902,
-0.4594554901,
-0.8169972897,
-0.4078231156,
-0.7708826065,
-0.5461878181,
-0.1362663507,
-0.5396778584,
0.0639245138,
-0.7197105885,
-0.5614951849,
0.1362735927,
0.512411356,
-0.9773466587,
-0.0267406367,
0.2888048887,
0.4441214204,
-1.0551365614,
1.0861234665,
0.7147618532,
-0.2285990417,
-0.5596936941,
-0.0773174614,
0.5388657451,
-0.5974492431,
0.5870295167,
0.1765304059,
-0.2011305094,
0.1489343494,
-0.5992919803,
-1.0035121441,
1.0000113249,
0.4582904577,
-0.6957284808,
-0.2984679937,
0.0328958668,
0.4621063769,
-0.384919703,
0.087115325,
0.219417721,
0.2813333273,
-0.1831427664,
-0.9949196577,
-0.1202125102,
0.2076734304,
-0.2364266664,
-0.166684866,
-0.7405651212,
0.6667174101,
-0.2254008651,
-0.1976739913,
-0.4580608904,
0.6561521888,
0.1579926908,
0.4896894693,
0.4659601152,
0.5183024406,
1.0607192516,
0.1938056201,
0.9623351693,
-0.1567922235,
0.6058982611,
1.4278392792,
-0.4664439559,
0.5942762494,
0.3545027971,
-0.1313029379,
-0.0190105718,
0.045508001,
-0.0877661407,
0.5834813118,
0.059721496,
-0.0305639934,
-0.2617474496,
-0.2321389616,
-0.0095399758,
0.8543768525,
0.0075634355,
-0.0789060891,
-0.5623282194,
0.6219691634,
0.0014994197,
-0.0744377524,
-0.3085259497,
0.7535610795,
0.3716492057,
-0.1292894036,
0.4042207003,
0.2490236312,
1.1111270189,
-0.7217186093,
0.1804727763,
-0.1263377219,
0.2923690677,
-0.6042794585,
0.077934444,
0.3423343301,
0.1002939269,
-0.2392201722,
-0.661960721,
0.8570761085,
-0.4484249055,
-0.5216262341,
0.334746182,
0.5916740298,
-0.1630164683,
-0.0992789716,
-0.7785243988,
-0.0921347514,
-0.3660552502,
-0.2552925348,
0.6772259474,
0.0102554979,
0.3028539717,
0.7815202475,
0.6546410322,
0.3845356107,
0.1781647801,
0.0910587832,
0.8940035105,
-0.065010719,
-0.585482657,
-0.6320986152,
0.0043789186,
0.0482071452,
-0.2988435924,
0.8774683475,
0.3821696341,
1.0691834688,
0.1688338518,
0.4000794888,
-0.0607720315,
0.4029431343,
-0.35330984,
0.9229527116,
-0.6090086102,
-0.0230698548,
-0.3756956458,
-0.7515263557,
-0.5766810775,
0.3586254716,
-0.3300459981,
-0.3585425317,
0.5828385353,
0.6332287788,
-0.289932549,
0.0733197704,
0.3418338895,
-0.1864282489,
0.1685459018,
0.5412431359,
-0.0270660073,
-0.5372975469,
0.4107674956,
-0.7803310156,
-0.0074884831,
-0.1643966287,
-0.6968414783,
-0.9146642685,
-0.3226490021,
-0.5512135029,
0.1870266795,
0.0680145025,
1.209028244,
1.3252923489,
-0.8537113667,
-0.0964720622,
0.1699120104,
0.2066787332,
-0.8289584517,
-0.1670922637,
0.2119601518,
-0.2972927392,
-0.7880639434,
0.5748586059,
0.1674571186,
-0.4194985926,
-0.1474699527,
0.1319546252,
-0.4986050129,
-0.4110846817,
0.4551006556,
0.3220212758,
-0.4594244659,
-0.0935480967,
-0.2286126018,
-0.3678229451,
-0.129689917,
0.7554424405,
-0.7906587124,
0.4758662879,
0.4867275357,
1.1120316982,
0.7030263543,
0.2798242569,
0.2548109293,
-1.4596085548,
0.508880794,
0.270450145,
0.3092087507,
0.3417533338,
-0.4711599946,
0.2681621015,
0.3124026358,
-0.4042917192,
-0.8150402308,
-0.060039822,
-0.8766088486,
-0.1845588237,
0.756460011,
-0.6213314533,
-0.0943741575,
0.0483282395,
0.5337287784,
0.0939954296,
-0.5158424377,
0.6786564589,
0.4697789848,
-0.2046462148,
-0.3174600601,
-0.5667380095,
0.6372855902,
0.4962074459,
-0.8364083767,
0.0043336148,
0.5209254622,
0.1656524092,
0.1960449219,
0.8395029306,
0.3638459742,
0.0619286187,
0.1826098412,
-0.0053577186,
-0.2526328266,
-0.4583724439,
-0.5015362501,
0.5722555518,
-0.3194580674,
-0.490341574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08353v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08353v1 | How to disagree well: Investigating the dispute tactics used on Wikipedia | 2022-12-16T09:01:19 | 2022-12-16T09:01:19 | Christine de Kock, Tom Stafford, Andreas Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Disagreements are frequently studied from the perspective of either detecting
toxicity or analysing argument structure. We propose a framework of dispute
tactics that unifies these two perspectives, as well as other dialogue acts
which play a role in resolving disputes, such as asking questions and providing
clarification. This framework includes a preferential ordering among
rebuttal-type tactics, ranging from ad hominem attacks to refuting the central
argument. Using this framework, we annotate 213 disagreements (3,865
utterances) from Wikipedia Talk pages. This allows us to investigate research
questions around the tactics used in disagreements; for instance, we provide
empirical validation of the approach to disagreement recommended by Wikipedia.
We develop models for multilabel prediction of dispute tactics in an utterance,
achieving the best performance with a transformer-based label powerset model.
Adding an auxiliary task to incorporate the ordering of rebuttal tactics
further yields a statistically significant increase. Finally, we show that
these annotations can be used to provide useful additional signals to improve
performance on the task of predicting escalation. | [
-0.9775240421,
-1.06889081,
0.4181298912,
0.29254812,
-0.1391184926,
0.0623043962,
-0.0325925499,
-0.5892606378,
0.4261135459,
0.3486178517,
-0.5502937436,
-0.1761701554,
-0.7489903569,
0.2256967276,
-0.2290291488,
1.1812537909,
-0.0554417595,
0.2520669699,
-0.1356584132,
-0.2929211855,
-0.4506955147,
-0.563937068,
-0.6382699013,
-0.5827155709,
0.8519818783,
0.6593449712,
0.524348855,
0.2161062807,
0.5133628249,
0.5185499191,
-0.3013482988,
0.123817198,
-0.5598499179,
0.6117054224,
-0.4538951218,
-0.2166352272,
0.0020246669,
-0.0114408741,
-0.1293353587,
0.2210456133,
-0.3362178504,
0.005015607,
-0.185805738,
0.3764365315,
-0.6651915312,
-0.1085827425,
-0.6246523261,
0.1371341944,
-0.2544021904,
0.0682502836,
-0.3872546256,
-0.0105620818,
0.4280395806,
-0.6873298287,
0.1164487451,
0.0550305136,
0.8732635379,
0.376455009,
-0.3704884052,
-0.4852828979,
-0.402256459,
0.6288095713,
-0.7448372841,
0.0532270335,
0.2655725777,
0.1984643638,
-0.2823142707,
-0.8389734626,
-0.6841138601,
-0.0571691617,
-0.3159734011,
0.2954865098,
-0.4162010252,
-0.0830366164,
0.5617305636,
-0.0122676445,
-0.1404241323,
-0.0098928194,
-0.3909034133,
-0.4541469514,
0.5849323273,
-0.224356398,
0.1884656101,
-0.622983098,
-0.4465972483,
0.1099250168,
-0.5299623013,
-0.0914328024,
0.3791273534,
-0.0923230425,
0.1199588478,
0.4740539193,
-0.3172157705,
0.5347436666,
0.4691169858,
-0.032474529,
0.0323368609,
-0.2493528724,
-0.1083995551,
0.1673413515,
0.9404752254,
0.6664410233,
0.1279455423,
-0.11484126,
0.0042076129,
-0.0976259261,
0.6769269705,
-0.6871997714,
-0.4486119449,
0.2177507728,
-0.2074601948,
-0.3585382402,
-0.2716971934,
-1.098601222,
-0.7960309386,
-0.1488290131,
0.5246972442,
-0.266941309,
-0.1916808635,
-0.3560678065,
-0.4602811337,
-0.1201514453,
0.4001798928,
-0.7658016086,
0.0420002602,
0.5578154325,
0.7489276528,
0.0267132409,
-0.1640430391,
-0.4410040081,
0.2969034314,
-0.4383069277,
1.3252005577,
-0.3561960161,
-0.581099689,
-0.0027714663,
-0.2380860746,
0.3190472722,
-0.6458056569,
1.0473240614,
-0.2903743684,
0.2033772916,
-0.6417405605,
-0.543454349,
-0.1604162902,
0.4769873321,
-0.8887712955,
0.7919610143,
-0.3424236476,
-0.9983463287,
0.2411837131,
-0.8193668723,
-0.4628705084,
-0.0566603243,
-0.0949281454,
-0.2947606444,
-0.0531291626,
-0.0087776789,
0.2161763161,
-0.2472186983,
0.0505661406,
-0.211526826,
-0.014337061,
0.396773994,
-0.1514456868,
0.7081469893,
0.4016956091,
-0.6095344424,
0.1094004065,
-0.4787579775,
-0.0380725451,
-0.0525125042,
-0.3360976577,
-0.4872325957,
0.3503972292,
-0.3187746108,
0.1587219089,
0.1572567821,
-0.5217404962,
-0.1044316739,
-0.2286257595,
0.4761689603,
0.6071452498,
0.2213471532,
0.1304226369,
-0.2734728456,
-0.0348676704,
0.0114703933,
0.3652229309,
0.1359925121,
-0.4568293691,
-0.909956336,
0.272561878,
0.1222484484,
0.3750417233,
-0.7985821366,
-0.2135333419,
-0.1225224063,
-0.8469122052,
-0.4722550809,
0.0590681322,
0.6149097085,
0.8376898766,
0.7154281735,
-0.1334106177,
-0.4191116989,
-0.9217557907,
-0.3949020803,
-0.5405951738,
0.3876598179,
0.2633511126,
0.1811460555,
0.2074942589,
0.8053825498,
-0.3608135879,
0.1296575814,
0.0985888913,
0.8788456321,
-0.3151487708,
0.331735909,
0.4564686418,
-1.1866693497,
-0.8661213517,
0.0039668106,
-0.691227138,
-0.207067132,
0.2127562463,
-0.3830065131,
0.207995683,
0.8399072886,
-0.514834702,
0.0982980207,
0.2158990502,
-0.1185025573,
0.5329276919,
0.2231271714,
0.5871933103,
-0.914252758,
-0.3514863551,
0.3130718768,
0.1048085988,
-0.8668759465,
0.054654628,
-0.1629989892,
0.3062532246,
-0.5999467373,
-0.0602471866,
-0.060507901,
0.6416496038,
-0.1662275493,
0.0099292966,
0.0939086825,
0.2985751927,
0.0873702988,
0.6943885684,
0.2450434268,
-0.4380731881,
0.6292145848,
0.2680531144,
-0.0672089607,
1.1274290085,
-0.8212898374,
0.238884598,
-0.1330458522,
0.2293667048,
-1.3048070669,
-0.1925658733,
0.4978193641,
-0.4113534987,
0.4600821733,
-0.4991954565,
-0.1386467367,
-0.245654434,
-0.4426722825,
0.1996173114,
-0.0453701578,
-0.3186576068,
0.6784350276,
0.4933834374,
-0.3864549398,
-1.1014156342,
-0.6092154384,
0.3026044369,
-0.6099190116,
-0.4518662095,
0.5961738825,
-0.1572803557,
-0.5573237538,
-0.1781216413,
-0.0475858934,
-0.1455652118,
-0.0498914234,
0.3339522183,
-0.0940239727,
-0.0695724338,
0.134854272,
-0.2055931538,
-0.1512363851,
0.4632276297,
0.1366645843,
0.3096707761,
0.0982619524,
-0.2341570109,
-0.0380569212,
0.573694706,
0.5173867345,
-0.0271113534,
0.5580814481,
0.327136457,
-0.1648090333,
0.1663967073,
-0.9415271282,
0.1038476527,
-0.4993160963,
0.2820351422,
-0.2644523084,
-0.3763948977,
0.4493058622,
-0.438970089,
0.4836918712,
0.6091046929,
0.5458928943,
-0.5894935727,
0.7862091064,
0.3786873221,
-0.1823267788,
0.4613303244,
0.0339239649,
0.1533188075,
-0.2735161185,
-0.5129903555,
-0.8717146516,
-0.4755375385,
-0.5052035451,
-0.1696115434,
0.1554671675,
0.2591494918,
-0.4652045369,
0.3953777254,
-0.368195653,
0.7671348453,
0.3427913785,
-0.0608353578,
0.3335015178,
0.2555713356,
-0.1359609216,
-0.3445276022,
-0.4974782467,
-0.3339619637,
0.4871691167,
0.2792370319,
0.7751373053,
0.5921504498,
0.8475833535,
0.4460172653,
0.5653312206,
-0.9583807588,
0.3773356378,
0.1629520506,
-0.7868497372,
-0.4360221028,
-0.4380096793,
-0.8076808453,
0.2212011367,
-0.3282804787,
-0.5946109295,
0.2414637208,
0.0151113877,
-0.2216882557,
0.188117668,
-1.0398842096,
0.9334923625,
-0.1686191112,
-0.4428030252,
-0.2473611385,
-0.6387322545,
0.2663832605,
0.0139238108,
0.3487353921,
0.1898508668,
0.15348728,
0.9659999013,
-0.4539944232,
0.7327102423,
-0.0976647139,
-0.3858969808,
0.474656105,
-0.1361891776,
0.2904044986,
-0.2122454196,
-0.041233737,
0.0899994373,
0.0607840978,
-0.1527838707,
-0.5255751014,
0.6402232051,
-0.8119202852,
-0.7819683552,
-0.2003880292,
-0.1517741829,
-0.27125296,
0.2966087461,
0.8301673532,
0.1889821738,
-0.3474568427,
-0.2307781577,
0.9141764045,
0.0280347206,
0.4506093264,
0.4877518415,
0.0634759739,
-0.4077473581,
1.1271127462,
0.4666334093,
0.3155907094,
0.1899982393,
0.1930979937,
-0.4942496419,
-0.4488590658,
-0.4064237177,
0.0445305109,
-1.1875741482,
-0.6338359118,
-0.3448906243,
-0.0545764752,
-0.3464680314,
-0.0108769881,
-0.3622310758,
-0.307056725,
0.2485438436,
-0.1742379069,
0.5140806437,
1.2599858046,
-0.1147979498,
0.2748917937,
-0.4680376649,
0.2391339093,
0.4652485549,
0.037410859,
-0.0471895076,
-0.3675966263,
-0.1096957102,
0.0263421591,
-0.913346231,
-1.5162862539,
-0.1408579201,
-0.3304754496,
0.6159014106,
0.3767175972,
0.4143202901,
0.886746645,
-0.556633234,
0.8328575492,
0.5145208836,
-0.9553028941,
0.5426033139,
-0.0342359953,
-0.5624921918,
0.4140641987,
0.7077063918,
-0.6245429516,
-0.3918420374,
-0.7631098032,
-0.9442307949,
0.3893291652,
-0.10883075,
0.0657701865,
-0.0385318287,
0.2483969182,
-0.2420947552,
0.0448627323,
-0.8041338325,
-0.5666999221,
-0.3989831507,
-0.011581203,
0.2164856344,
-0.3146784902,
-0.8811451793,
-0.1928709596,
0.5736483335,
-0.0118111745,
-0.0007846529,
0.1899553537,
-0.1972563714,
-0.3359277248,
0.5262431502,
0.5599592924,
0.7363286614,
0.364002794,
0.3831402659,
0.4114622772,
-0.2736399174,
0.3466432393,
0.2495192736,
-0.1436799467,
0.3055330515,
0.1735151112,
0.4231976271,
0.3701770604,
-0.2869890928,
0.3607542217,
-0.0584629253,
-0.3631879985,
0.1227370724,
-0.0244839657,
0.420124799,
0.6290805936,
0.1716851741,
-0.1317741722,
0.3418569267,
-0.4994563758,
0.2569258809,
0.2826287746,
-0.1854225099,
0.4038339555,
0.1672128886,
0.3864304423,
-0.3430737555,
0.3064245284,
-0.0009865267,
-0.7490006089,
0.4228540659,
0.2065156996,
0.1685909182,
-0.1830493361,
0.6524138451,
0.2127336413,
0.00545794,
-0.002634078,
-0.10262876,
0.0355063789,
-0.6182208061,
-0.4314790368,
-0.1782303602,
-0.6369176507,
0.1223648936,
-0.6704593301,
0.0823920816,
-0.6039932966,
-0.5472418666,
0.5333296657,
0.2947781682,
-0.2240995169,
-0.0511860661,
0.147207886,
0.9052212834,
-0.6346746683,
0.2367892861,
0.6095163822,
-0.6603600979,
-0.7466439605,
0.1603720635,
0.1394665986,
-0.2518777847,
0.5560481548,
-0.1025546789,
-0.2525760829,
-0.2036617696,
-0.9237575531,
-0.3823900819,
0.6927728653,
0.486631602,
-0.3277187943,
0.2053567171,
-0.1853077859,
0.3606779873,
0.1837943941,
0.2405550778,
0.5200384855,
0.6393347979,
0.2848561704,
-0.8591557145,
-0.0700543821,
-0.242492184,
-0.4570986331,
0.2041223496,
-0.8690522313,
0.7569754124,
-0.1357007176,
-0.1753061563,
-0.0102713294,
0.8579795361,
-0.0058197416,
0.4713805616,
0.5273271203,
0.5474261045,
0.8865085244,
-0.3879655302,
0.6826332211,
0.0878311023,
0.4143393636,
0.8211068511,
0.007003705,
0.9536584616,
0.7607631683,
-0.1221019179,
0.7824124098,
0.7427598834,
-0.0753147602,
0.4362199008,
0.3426195979,
-0.265291959,
-0.1682848185,
-0.3536110222,
-0.4495423138,
0.1395110488,
0.4514399469,
-0.0061110049,
-0.4205645025,
-0.3018128574,
0.3239817917,
0.1509482712,
-0.1713343412,
1.1656603813,
-0.1942275017,
-1.0274953842,
0.4227920175,
0.2209111452,
0.7779001594,
-0.4574326873,
-0.0893670246,
-0.1852532476,
-0.2500653565,
-0.4778108001,
-0.9611166716,
0.1064256057,
0.166628167,
-0.2755845487,
-0.0342633091,
0.674779892,
-0.4682103992,
-0.0387025848,
0.1713066399,
0.5202124715,
0.1307063848,
0.2199682742,
-1.1418136358,
0.122633785,
-0.1380904317,
-0.0400906131,
0.2697295845,
0.848107636,
0.1717033386,
0.2714564204,
0.3413172066,
-0.0905898064,
0.0725806728,
0.1459312737,
0.8985362053,
-0.2935682237,
-0.2408903688,
-0.837662518,
0.543432951,
-0.6304844022,
-0.2254718393,
0.6998473406,
0.0804154053,
0.7626820207,
0.32500121,
0.7367700934,
-0.3119589686,
0.4001660943,
-0.5513696671,
0.5729786158,
-0.4579796493,
-0.0663436949,
-0.4608241022,
-0.59712708,
0.0229063183,
1.1475968361,
-0.274384737,
0.0605252199,
0.5703424811,
0.5821090937,
0.1269711107,
0.3387659788,
0.0050377124,
0.3075400591,
0.6262854934,
0.4002023041,
1.1474003792,
-0.2228209674,
0.7186415195,
-0.4293043315,
-0.0444827788,
-0.030865537,
-0.9045604467,
-0.6304732561,
-0.4710564315,
-0.4396370053,
-0.7907016873,
-0.0693845972,
0.7975313663,
0.5090712309,
-0.7683742046,
-0.1023053899,
0.0966776907,
0.4615107477,
-0.0374663398,
-0.188494429,
-0.0150710391,
-0.6026208997,
-0.8243960142,
0.2106041163,
-0.1038316563,
0.1050096005,
-0.2497604936,
-0.3043254018,
-0.3665771484,
0.1157747805,
0.4505849481,
0.5747474432,
-0.7494162321,
-0.3944388926,
-0.3602585196,
-0.2223743796,
0.0458637476,
1.0706099272,
-0.266262114,
0.4992493391,
0.4109555781,
0.6366603971,
0.279014349,
0.1027081981,
0.4772107899,
-0.6781330705,
-0.2597064674,
0.0108630583,
0.3632539213,
0.4466643929,
-0.3660063446,
0.376349628,
0.2364738435,
-0.4879535735,
-0.5914738178,
0.2087208927,
-0.6719260216,
-0.5086278319,
0.9302096367,
-0.414797008,
0.1093974337,
-0.4234109819,
-0.4274948835,
0.3456279039,
-0.4562145472,
1.0156368017,
1.4241578579,
-0.2890235484,
0.135571748,
-0.4148562849,
0.7859836817,
0.5728258491,
-0.7242148519,
0.2729172409,
0.7646600604,
0.2171842158,
0.9055945873,
0.4843415618,
0.1288039237,
0.0853976533,
-0.0391044803,
-0.5823923945,
0.2228581607,
-0.5977673531,
0.1839928329,
0.3858419061,
-0.0504045747,
0.1654551029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08349v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08349v1 | Swing Distillation: A Privacy-Preserving Knowledge Distillation Framework | 2022-12-16T08:57:18 | 2022-12-16T08:57:18 | Junzhuo Li, Xinwei Wu, Weilong Dong, Shuangzhi Wu, Chao Bian, Deyi Xiong | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | Knowledge distillation (KD) has been widely used for model compression and
knowledge transfer. Typically, a big teacher model trained on sufficient data
transfers knowledge to a small student model. However, despite the success of
KD, little effort has been made to study whether KD leaks the training data of
the teacher model. In this paper, we experimentally reveal that KD suffers from
the risk of privacy leakage. To alleviate this issue, we propose a novel
knowledge distillation method, swing distillation, which can effectively
protect the private information of the teacher model from flowing to the
student model. In our framework, the temperature coefficient is dynamically and
adaptively adjusted according to the degree of private information contained in
the data, rather than a predefined constant hyperparameter. It assigns
different temperatures to tokens according to the likelihood that a token in a
position contains private information. In addition, we inject noise into soft
targets provided to the student model, in order to avoid unshielded knowledge
transfer. Experiments on multiple datasets and tasks demonstrate that the
proposed swing distillation can significantly reduce (by over 80% in terms of
canary exposure) the risk of privacy leakage in comparison to KD with
competitive or better performance. Furthermore, swing distillation is robust
against the increasing privacy budget. | [
0.0211937297,
-0.6303898692,
0.5335370302,
-0.0452000573,
-0.1607806683,
0.3832392395,
-0.0267106909,
-0.1420475543,
-0.2520170212,
0.4552687407,
-0.1712392122,
-0.6272158623,
-0.7285203338,
-0.4261937141,
-0.3743823767,
1.1947097778,
0.0936309844,
-0.0948944986,
-0.1979275644,
0.2196015865,
-0.2099996656,
-0.5394960046,
-0.3729299903,
-0.2676131725,
0.2816545367,
0.2475408167,
0.5275443792,
0.6316460371,
0.2900923789,
0.2860608697,
-0.2649911344,
-0.1644934863,
-0.6556810141,
0.4952330291,
-0.3786146343,
-0.7319040298,
0.0222317632,
-0.0895896927,
0.3344125748,
0.542409122,
-0.1970818043,
0.2532988191,
0.2497839034,
1.1699335575,
-1.2879968882,
0.4932739437,
-0.598981142,
0.2330112755,
-0.1689876914,
0.2140344232,
-0.3400093019,
-0.7426235676,
0.2557131052,
-0.3235062063,
0.1781468242,
-0.2561138868,
0.5716820955,
0.3652745485,
-0.4697637856,
0.0785579607,
-1.0347387791,
0.2633540034,
-0.595780313,
0.2233516723,
0.5346198082,
0.6815958023,
-0.1458502561,
-0.6259749532,
-0.466984868,
0.1046818048,
0.2247850597,
0.1328038722,
0.0740530118,
-0.0773906112,
0.147079736,
0.3724530935,
-0.2080806792,
-0.40679726,
-0.4046766758,
-0.0661603957,
0.6034958363,
-0.0491638072,
-0.246175915,
-0.0384820737,
-0.5018889904,
-0.5686753392,
-0.0761669427,
0.3300348222,
0.6381380558,
0.1287851632,
0.0724982694,
0.1777614206,
-0.2962906361,
0.3981286883,
0.3458718359,
-0.4407517016,
-0.0046347175,
-0.0755766034,
-0.1527681798,
0.3223491013,
0.6260789037,
0.2903524935,
0.1568874717,
-0.2629434466,
0.4106839001,
-0.1250100285,
-0.0890943035,
-0.9434424043,
-1.0707938671,
0.0088122478,
-0.3626921177,
-0.9720682502,
0.3279681206,
-0.7748410106,
-0.7364045382,
0.0278604478,
0.410169661,
-0.179010421,
-0.8497539163,
0.0830119029,
-0.5938718319,
-0.4552960694,
-0.059912093,
-0.968585372,
0.4952658415,
0.6921190023,
0.7820298076,
-0.1247551665,
0.0019336531,
0.0596819632,
0.7454122901,
-0.1604437083,
0.0281100255,
-0.5053915977,
-0.5689291954,
-0.2876915038,
0.0009175232,
0.3148276806,
-0.3489366174,
-0.0477120839,
-0.4941139817,
0.212042138,
-0.3324095309,
-0.6323114634,
-0.344669342,
0.1263198256,
-0.5788713694,
0.7305687666,
-0.0510286689,
-1.0324376822,
0.4515440464,
-0.6271361113,
-0.0345825106,
-0.2324064076,
0.0952608958,
-0.6769317985,
0.1884710044,
0.1896229684,
0.345672816,
0.3036476672,
0.2243594378,
-0.6508190632,
0.0349850133,
0.4965091944,
-0.6406648755,
0.8948238492,
0.3387080431,
-0.1945824921,
-0.3371330202,
-0.8454706669,
0.0083545363,
-0.0393226705,
-0.195723623,
-0.9685560465,
-0.3077607453,
-0.4380938411,
-0.1054063961,
0.4019081593,
-0.6180728078,
0.369012028,
-0.1789994538,
0.2288031429,
0.9480679035,
0.4126969576,
0.6986842155,
-0.2135627419,
0.4364386201,
0.4315706193,
0.3679737747,
0.1148149818,
-0.29675138,
-0.2221568525,
-0.2397634834,
0.5428512096,
0.3100630641,
-0.6090168953,
0.11358504,
0.0220011529,
-0.7727921605,
-0.1890373379,
0.1308561862,
0.367454648,
0.6407545209,
0.0203422047,
-0.1360972077,
-0.1225205809,
-0.4714697897,
-0.342533648,
-0.1677087098,
0.056866724,
0.171517536,
0.0989467278,
0.4329770207,
1.0948964357,
-0.8003342152,
-0.3192431331,
0.357454896,
0.2447753996,
0.2809480727,
0.7327142954,
0.5660298467,
-0.6326010227,
-0.6621292233,
0.0206073318,
-0.7009530663,
0.2290402949,
0.0909444466,
-0.4731245339,
-0.1284131557,
0.1623731852,
-0.3959896564,
0.5741263032,
0.5467374325,
-0.3795517087,
0.3422212601,
-0.2712686956,
0.2285708934,
-1.3767193556,
-0.0412454456,
-0.2635492086,
-0.5531788468,
-0.2431154102,
-0.1320220381,
0.2172914445,
-0.3107342422,
-0.5739765167,
0.0716470852,
-0.3139756024,
0.3014284372,
-0.6365549564,
-0.3960760236,
0.1578855813,
0.2625664771,
-0.1422834694,
0.3879881501,
0.8595952392,
-0.6371508837,
0.6047395468,
0.0705563501,
-0.0854011327,
0.4135469794,
-0.3004022241,
0.5267694592,
-0.1300439835,
0.3572314978,
-0.8559651971,
-0.1865116358,
0.3686583042,
-0.3370457292,
0.508091867,
-0.4424993694,
-0.3380115926,
-0.3228355944,
-0.2945911288,
0.1546778679,
0.6198704243,
-0.591003418,
0.4880895317,
0.2572207153,
0.0606273487,
-0.6191412807,
-0.6722773314,
-0.1751748621,
-0.5124142766,
-0.583491087,
0.2147819996,
0.0830852911,
-0.0365939736,
0.4532071352,
-0.665207088,
-0.5859994292,
0.3293210864,
0.5188113451,
0.1133062616,
0.1462193429,
0.044155065,
0.3295509815,
-0.1199219301,
0.3652901053,
-0.5945817232,
0.0354081541,
0.3165099919,
-0.1672306657,
-0.8358232379,
0.1156305224,
0.4762702584,
0.3827471435,
1.0691401958,
0.3982938528,
-0.373572439,
-0.3529169559,
-0.3860729933,
-0.530053854,
-0.5790722966,
0.1120702997,
-0.4556093514,
-0.451769948,
0.4515899718,
-0.4622004032,
0.1116115525,
-0.0949033499,
0.2720784843,
0.0410736762,
0.8303143978,
0.8136103153,
-0.3564131856,
0.5198504329,
-0.1059838608,
0.1806358546,
-0.2633329332,
-0.3667139709,
-0.4718170762,
-0.4907123446,
-0.4326312244,
-0.0841715708,
0.5794305205,
0.2065229714,
-0.2303005904,
0.2627623677,
-0.839941144,
1.1249388456,
0.7075310349,
0.3131347001,
0.5396153331,
-0.1569835693,
0.1569709182,
-0.0312031265,
-0.4159380496,
-0.1409982294,
1.5097907782,
0.3324674666,
1.1360294819,
0.2268974185,
1.1657099724,
0.308491677,
-0.2328192443,
-0.1231197566,
0.2448567748,
-0.0660083443,
-0.9767639041,
-0.4111145437,
-0.4917094409,
-0.6362064481,
0.25205639,
0.0429760665,
-0.9276276231,
0.3380274773,
0.3315638006,
-0.4131806791,
0.4676003754,
-0.8285960555,
0.557703197,
-0.0901159868,
-0.7337000966,
0.0557713658,
-0.6486902237,
0.8822094798,
-0.2364555448,
0.1395799667,
-0.1426106393,
0.4231176674,
0.8461893201,
-0.7838690877,
0.7691044807,
-0.782589674,
0.0767673999,
0.1510927081,
0.4800387323,
0.7011995316,
0.3105108142,
-0.0656424984,
0.0836549252,
0.6714540124,
-0.2955391705,
-0.8101167679,
0.6992413998,
-0.8827625513,
-0.7132829428,
-0.7240309119,
-0.6946591735,
-0.1992940903,
0.1480893344,
0.0803306624,
-0.3704928756,
0.1652180851,
0.5284293294,
0.7661595345,
0.1754494905,
0.3795599043,
0.6065140367,
-0.4706677198,
0.0207094066,
0.9693686366,
0.3147673309,
0.4216417372,
0.0486887433,
0.7347730994,
-0.491802156,
-0.422483027,
-0.1401254535,
-0.3495377004,
-0.6559551358,
-0.3387435675,
-0.4626834989,
-0.2910397351,
-0.6511170268,
-0.0115053589,
-0.7175090313,
-0.5909174085,
-0.3898754418,
-0.3125619888,
0.8215398192,
0.4707379043,
-0.3871805966,
0.2229737043,
-0.5335646868,
0.2972722948,
0.4973554909,
0.0739146844,
-0.1225529984,
-0.2807823122,
0.022832226,
0.1880145669,
-0.4627034664,
-0.9385434389,
0.3651975989,
0.2842082679,
0.1857367605,
0.645567894,
0.9529375434,
0.5644651651,
-0.097000055,
0.8133183122,
0.5683441758,
-1.0398089886,
0.5637135506,
-0.1999591142,
0.208258763,
0.8955144882,
0.4611606002,
-0.059330225,
-0.6669154167,
-0.7278371453,
-0.8629361987,
0.5298570395,
0.0078586387,
0.2558526099,
0.6096014977,
0.291982621,
0.4692582786,
0.4324833453,
-0.6351006031,
-0.2218290865,
-0.4251494408,
-0.295152247,
0.5073996186,
0.0450269841,
-0.4234620631,
-0.2805600464,
0.6360241771,
0.2972331047,
-0.2984772027,
-0.1502008736,
0.2763107419,
0.0735221654,
-0.0153567102,
-0.1543980688,
0.5840619206,
-0.3455262482,
0.4670926929,
0.0638954639,
-0.7870152593,
0.4581986666,
-0.0469637066,
-0.2996377051,
-0.0241770167,
-0.4362398982,
0.4118925631,
0.0281274412,
0.1116752476,
0.5804222226,
-0.1347075105,
-0.4650021791,
-0.1938639879,
0.6897842884,
0.2072553337,
0.5116997361,
0.2244033068,
0.1260756403,
0.3566230536,
-0.4983238578,
0.0908192471,
0.0999009237,
-0.1003821939,
-0.2183698714,
1.0935460329,
0.1008063182,
0.081050612,
0.2229926884,
0.0567959659,
-0.1834952533,
0.3018338978,
0.4368991256,
0.7045669556,
-0.4617075026,
0.1978435963,
0.1138261408,
-0.1584681123,
-0.1835052371,
0.1499840617,
-0.5211990476,
-0.2068408728,
0.2455829829,
-0.5109572411,
-0.606045723,
-0.0504409894,
-0.9869462252,
-0.0896804258,
-0.8758499026,
-0.2792946398,
0.0807268098,
-0.0801003054,
-0.5053155422,
-0.1865743846,
0.0381697528,
0.5584101081,
-0.9662075639,
1.1067494154,
-0.0046288292,
-0.1638687849,
-1.0521924496,
0.0840554088,
0.2427683473,
-0.3964727521,
0.5717766285,
-0.265843004,
0.0509371161,
-0.0760568753,
-0.496429652,
-0.8570323586,
1.2745294571,
0.5951936841,
-1.0642616749,
-0.0042346078,
0.18788445,
0.2328534871,
0.285951972,
-0.271802038,
0.5678812861,
0.4816090763,
0.372715652,
-0.8078271151,
0.03082815,
0.0627175272,
0.1225994676,
-0.0506341271,
-0.5740787387,
0.6947595477,
0.0850781873,
-0.0774328187,
-0.2503178418,
0.6519907713,
0.100921087,
0.7525702715,
0.3691151142,
0.4255389571,
1.2375127077,
-0.0335238576,
0.5299802423,
-0.3947833478,
0.4046518207,
1.2046679258,
-0.3829071522,
0.4958343506,
0.4709030986,
-0.3808566034,
0.3221417069,
0.3119321167,
0.1634599268,
1.2558181286,
0.4694807231,
-0.6466726661,
0.2654876113,
0.1373770088,
-0.7255802155,
0.3072882593,
-0.1289862394,
-0.3408884704,
-0.1162818745,
0.4670650363,
0.313364774,
0.1751854718,
-0.1866845936,
0.9875895381,
-0.0925157592,
-0.3511797488,
0.246074155,
-0.2627588511,
0.4447036982,
-0.5460256934,
0.2410089076,
0.0783302113,
0.5250401497,
-0.3355423212,
-0.5172612071,
0.3759719133,
0.0869737267,
-0.3616345227,
-0.2337476909,
0.7091451287,
-0.5622822046,
-0.5706933141,
-0.2148003876,
0.1098005548,
0.2697664201,
-0.2086226493,
-0.3928875029,
0.0518846177,
-0.1626023203,
-0.3166291118,
0.5120112896,
0.6899658442,
0.3557374477,
0.2195537984,
0.8120340705,
0.1526738405,
0.3585582674,
-0.223502934,
1.1143238544,
-0.3448909819,
-0.9176327586,
-0.9332597852,
0.3519871533,
-0.2999519408,
-0.0639023334,
1.0842665434,
0.4658220112,
0.7721199393,
-0.0273595899,
0.9602971673,
0.1840246618,
0.4364319444,
-0.3552632332,
1.2252864838,
-0.004403566,
0.1086841002,
-0.4068535566,
-0.8338787556,
0.0801432952,
0.5710681677,
-0.3504789472,
-0.1994152069,
0.4631799459,
0.6341648102,
0.0103510944,
0.3028186858,
0.3045732379,
0.1156070158,
0.6189339161,
0.5584335327,
0.6389706135,
-0.3379375935,
0.5169947743,
-0.9055722356,
-0.2204385102,
-0.0277795754,
-0.9281910658,
-0.8350276947,
-0.4843800962,
-0.7400667667,
-0.5346628428,
0.3877890408,
0.3423902094,
1.0549696684,
-0.5863958001,
0.1478674561,
-0.4241474271,
0.0736809373,
-0.4180123508,
-0.2690115273,
0.4373718798,
0.0166478939,
-0.6966927052,
0.29004246,
-0.0629264861,
0.0470813401,
-0.5148595572,
0.1515446007,
0.139048934,
-0.0066314358,
-0.0929702818,
0.3822215796,
-0.2026685327,
-0.2468840182,
-0.4148251712,
0.2162883431,
-0.3749150932,
0.4651212394,
-0.7460123301,
0.7377043962,
0.4666924477,
0.5502333045,
1.039596796,
0.1724756509,
0.3218973577,
-0.9778147936,
0.343839258,
0.1846720874,
-0.2363137156,
-0.0520639271,
-0.807880342,
0.1990255117,
0.2134233862,
-0.6334460378,
-1.0298097134,
-0.0236004367,
-0.8364685774,
-0.5802189112,
0.8434993625,
-0.6210468411,
-0.6372065544,
-0.1360115558,
-0.1440736949,
0.4536459744,
-0.6470544934,
1.4238671064,
0.7139425874,
0.123301886,
-0.0643153712,
-0.3155145347,
0.5070576668,
-0.077485323,
-0.4970611632,
0.239868328,
0.3071729541,
0.7282451987,
-0.0082043959,
0.2289340943,
-0.145219624,
0.0935639143,
0.309151262,
-0.3478569984,
-0.8559671044,
-0.4763953984,
-0.0279308613,
0.6664869189,
-0.1033981219,
-1.0035504103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08335v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08335v1 | Law to Binary Tree -- An Formal Interpretation of Legal Natural Language | 2022-12-16T08:26:32 | 2022-12-16T08:26:32 | Ha-Thanh Nguyen, Vu Tran, Ngoc-Cam Le, Thi-Thuy Le, Quang-Huy Nguyen, Le-Minh Nguyen, Ken Satoh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge representation and reasoning in law are essential to facilitate the
automation of legal analysis and decision-making tasks. In this paper, we
propose a new approach based on legal science, specifically legal taxonomy, for
representing and reasoning with legal documents. Our approach interprets the
regulations in legal documents as binary trees, which facilitates legal
reasoning systems to make decisions and resolve logical contradictions. The
advantages of this approach are twofold. First, legal reasoning can be
performed on the basis of the binary tree representation of the regulations.
Second, the binary tree representation of the regulations is more
understandable than the existing sentence-based representations. We provide an
example of how our approach can be used to interpret the regulations in a legal
document. | [
0.0114676235,
-0.5873286128,
0.9264501333,
0.0128233433,
-0.8154258728,
-0.0230909046,
0.029509224,
-0.6090963483,
0.2504230142,
0.8049631715,
-0.2688711882,
-0.5982952118,
-0.523829639,
0.0352347828,
-0.4964248836,
0.8701549768,
0.0202529412,
0.0886310637,
-0.4975287616,
-0.1214285567,
-0.6858733296,
-0.5398550034,
-0.3500526845,
-0.2599797845,
0.5119344592,
0.0211884622,
0.8818207979,
0.8274549842,
0.5563704967,
0.3260823488,
-0.2212746292,
-0.3484946489,
-0.0372070931,
-0.0467118882,
-0.3873556852,
-0.8559905291,
-0.0212358087,
-0.2011609972,
0.5658131242,
0.4018629789,
-0.1959006339,
-0.0946047306,
-0.5951080322,
0.6771667004,
-0.3773545325,
0.4433222413,
-0.5898892283,
0.2201593816,
-0.1110586151,
-0.6855657101,
-0.4821147919,
-0.5912941694,
-0.0588107184,
-0.7528849244,
-0.0928631127,
0.3853096962,
0.8964802623,
0.3861488104,
-0.8349213004,
-0.587423861,
-0.6555806994,
0.2046242058,
-0.9389431477,
0.43944031,
0.0550719164,
0.8147262335,
-0.0857547224,
-0.6833536029,
-0.5519489646,
-0.479044348,
-0.5370705128,
0.1267786771,
-0.2614259124,
0.246739015,
0.3089164197,
-0.0258807559,
-0.3657467067,
-0.0050822976,
-0.4928934276,
-0.4305362403,
0.6662927866,
-0.0798431635,
0.5150594115,
-0.5154361129,
-0.0606724247,
0.3490321934,
-0.6302357912,
0.1429811567,
0.4904745221,
0.2492023706,
0.3073193431,
0.6702677608,
0.1791405082,
0.6432614923,
-0.1434711367,
-0.1748126,
0.0047936561,
-0.4078103304,
-0.3469570279,
0.4795880616,
0.5827736259,
0.3571961522,
-0.0165859684,
-0.2316096276,
-0.3347288966,
0.0532488003,
0.18661277,
-0.653617382,
0.3051820695,
0.1714679748,
-0.7486454248,
-0.3107706308,
0.1993513256,
-0.2681385875,
-0.2960194945,
-0.734033227,
0.2814155817,
-0.5374422669,
-0.2864176333,
0.469265908,
-0.6517840624,
0.3331301808,
0.5536642075,
-0.7820859551,
0.5807065368,
0.9845099449,
0.4423570037,
0.6906070113,
0.3594024181,
-0.2495876998,
0.512827754,
-0.5924314857,
0.6430408955,
-0.7099945545,
-0.1482243687,
-0.2352085263,
-0.0886724591,
0.3968325853,
-0.2032682002,
0.6989135146,
-0.6405581832,
0.0909158587,
-0.0138784293,
-0.4413471222,
-0.6983724833,
0.0929242894,
-0.6279281378,
0.3859116137,
0.1811604351,
-0.8227874041,
0.7703897953,
-0.9946396351,
-0.7305570841,
0.554002583,
-0.7317307591,
-0.0515580103,
-0.0040234132,
-0.2415786535,
0.1948242635,
-0.347012639,
0.7749170065,
-0.1396701038,
0.00205593,
-0.1644701958,
0.0400403328,
1.4640519619,
0.545167923,
-0.2963250577,
0.3233465552,
-0.3944141269,
-0.0915923417,
-0.0701376274,
-0.4103468359,
-0.6065713167,
0.5473788381,
-0.262270689,
0.3021355867,
0.159390524,
-0.5574694872,
0.2547222376,
-0.5887749791,
0.625218451,
0.4868150651,
0.0974905863,
0.4311251938,
-0.2057118863,
0.4719108641,
0.1663514376,
0.0830934942,
0.269415766,
-0.5977615118,
-0.2155000418,
0.1228306144,
0.6527841687,
0.4988327026,
-0.4266288877,
0.5756221414,
-0.4837819338,
-0.2236857861,
-0.4821587205,
-0.2456183285,
0.0712159202,
0.2064912468,
0.0282609146,
-0.2628403902,
-0.9388247132,
-0.9443148375,
-0.163555488,
-0.5233079195,
0.2364532948,
0.4928946793,
0.9340078235,
-0.2724502981,
1.4301598072,
0.0106749432,
-0.1561457366,
-0.0553777441,
0.3771059215,
0.404079318,
0.2237625569,
0.5879990458,
-1.1163225174,
-0.3117536008,
0.4567068815,
-0.6871602535,
-0.0848195106,
-0.3869120181,
-0.278501302,
0.25573048,
0.6445262432,
-0.4079517722,
0.5450573564,
-0.2757429779,
-1.0671316385,
0.8113146424,
-0.2559185028,
0.0528787039,
-0.6424485445,
-0.101731427,
-0.1105562225,
-0.5312466621,
-0.3934493959,
0.3082904518,
-0.1232829541,
0.1292339861,
-0.3577775955,
0.1924096346,
-0.3082063198,
-0.2949724495,
-0.0632321015,
0.0173808802,
-0.0313905329,
0.0700628161,
0.1268500239,
0.3840441406,
0.6802895069,
-0.4886795282,
0.7139585614,
0.2132114172,
-0.1887009293,
0.7291119695,
-0.2310085595,
-0.4374417365,
-0.6585546732,
0.3448030949,
-0.2632626593,
-0.1285194606,
0.6497081518,
-0.4421937466,
0.1357500106,
-0.4055068195,
-0.8880618215,
-0.418084234,
-0.0135535365,
-0.0617925301,
0.4226305485,
-0.0154475207,
1.1647694111,
0.3140283227,
0.2050568014,
-0.4415569305,
-0.7202131152,
0.2258714885,
-0.351106286,
-0.6404858828,
0.1771232486,
0.2223252654,
-0.6521936655,
0.7924435735,
-0.1962160617,
-0.1983947009,
0.085946463,
0.2950383127,
0.0434226394,
-0.4650490582,
0.2698188722,
0.089347668,
-0.0283511896,
0.76176548,
-0.5099104047,
0.1118575186,
-0.0418603718,
-0.1972095966,
-0.3576029539,
0.4754595459,
0.5459110737,
-0.2264133692,
0.3126729429,
-0.103771314,
-0.3703503311,
0.1019851491,
-0.203146711,
0.1254377365,
-0.416742295,
0.0552279316,
-0.5177021027,
-0.646369338,
0.0241780858,
-0.127192229,
0.2655262947,
0.8754437566,
0.4358850718,
-0.2890214622,
0.6383781433,
0.5323072076,
0.0760780051,
0.2166212499,
0.2173428833,
0.2999708056,
-0.2780024111,
-0.6437903643,
-0.8531810641,
0.0424793251,
-0.4526202977,
-0.282458663,
0.0403295681,
0.0303527806,
-0.3110206127,
0.7157154679,
-0.4990950227,
0.6045239568,
0.6613979936,
0.0639215261,
0.4379006624,
-0.0037452923,
-0.5447286963,
0.4192531705,
-0.6283397079,
-0.8456041813,
0.7536651492,
0.3510822356,
0.4136378467,
0.3988601565,
1.0185902119,
0.3109459877,
0.0144738555,
-1.0417616367,
0.7619382143,
-0.0722918808,
-0.9564948082,
-0.3847908676,
-0.7229064107,
-1.0899041891,
0.121751219,
-0.5113827586,
-0.8739603758,
0.0618461929,
-0.1474389732,
-0.475826323,
0.4601079524,
-0.6694046259,
0.7279276252,
-0.5226092935,
-0.1100898683,
-0.6245108843,
-0.8763428926,
0.3954930902,
0.0299425162,
0.6815666556,
0.0043903543,
0.0564484373,
1.1194615364,
-0.643866837,
0.8116424084,
0.0024474259,
-0.099531807,
0.8387660384,
0.1925786585,
0.3162285388,
-0.0840806663,
-0.0469655804,
-0.3885468245,
0.8805550337,
-0.0312432759,
-0.9375771284,
0.0535156615,
-0.519746244,
-0.8032726645,
-0.8322198987,
-0.6871340871,
0.1893112957,
0.451564908,
-0.3027634919,
0.1644032449,
0.2313114852,
0.0736558214,
0.1944330633,
0.0438574292,
0.0403410494,
0.7418425679,
-0.4075962901,
-0.0973932967,
0.7650752068,
0.2792374492,
-0.1126775444,
0.6352468729,
0.5684756637,
-0.7227108479,
-0.6403697133,
-0.0624016933,
0.1472862065,
-1.1430598497,
-0.0107643148,
-0.4466677606,
-0.2747308016,
-0.5948760509,
0.0409705006,
0.5614657402,
-0.5981678963,
-0.1008062288,
0.0777372047,
0.6120291948,
1.0841435194,
-0.1194508299,
-0.0679835454,
-0.7508101463,
0.5021173358,
0.239680931,
0.5909282565,
-0.5677258968,
-0.4869685173,
0.2619419098,
-0.1866455972,
-0.0245994367,
-1.0439189672,
-0.0999657363,
-0.1964444667,
0.6954202056,
0.5971530676,
-0.1727050245,
0.5679993033,
-0.7006673813,
0.1693160385,
0.4772282839,
-0.9048801661,
0.7415072918,
-0.1533914953,
-0.3840304315,
0.4114964306,
0.4329934418,
-0.7020580173,
-0.4775551856,
-0.9943358302,
-0.4603563249,
0.5685534477,
0.3114547133,
0.0293972604,
0.4849156737,
0.5300302505,
-0.0925899893,
0.1728506535,
-0.8558080792,
0.1576247811,
-0.1960159689,
-0.2475409359,
0.4438298047,
-0.1618458778,
-0.186053142,
-0.5622186065,
0.6045950651,
0.2004768997,
0.2147245109,
-0.0757268518,
0.0514894873,
-0.0580309033,
0.6445049644,
0.3273883164,
0.7085677981,
-0.3293317854,
0.426954776,
-0.1589048803,
-0.2332862467,
0.2708910108,
-0.0391111635,
-0.4713154435,
0.2248066813,
0.2649288177,
0.5837032795,
0.0955778584,
-0.5444920063,
0.3153487742,
0.3398456275,
-0.7002182603,
-0.0465874486,
0.028418798,
0.385022819,
0.101972498,
0.0484917462,
0.3183736801,
0.3558495939,
-1.1416575909,
0.4522415698,
0.4573177099,
-0.1570226103,
0.2923837602,
0.5878996253,
0.2490350008,
-0.293561399,
0.1950406581,
-0.4223327637,
-0.5611709952,
0.8920225501,
0.6801761389,
0.2267687768,
0.3447896838,
0.3138085604,
0.486217767,
0.5329070687,
-0.2234359831,
0.2667700052,
-0.0445175469,
-0.4492783546,
-0.5256178975,
-0.453461498,
-0.2949319184,
-0.3508171737,
-0.1868324578,
0.3433587551,
-0.6824468374,
0.0426996164,
0.368930757,
-0.08819253,
-0.1654464006,
0.2513323128,
0.1056755111,
1.1017569304,
-0.7218649387,
0.8073197007,
0.7073695064,
-0.8401325345,
-0.9964086413,
-0.2725304067,
0.1349439621,
-0.5285906792,
0.9129744172,
-0.0075028152,
-0.1948503405,
-0.0998403877,
-0.7925243974,
-0.4999608397,
0.9620822072,
0.3021358252,
-0.8566940427,
-0.0484901816,
0.3073568642,
0.5318862796,
-0.2208288461,
0.1205428988,
0.778616786,
0.8908725977,
0.5041419268,
-0.5965394378,
0.3467917442,
-0.2101397216,
-0.144889161,
0.4003087282,
0.2286726236,
0.4778572917,
-0.1110952497,
-0.641027689,
-0.4798109531,
0.4356917441,
0.0456646271,
0.2484413981,
0.6538276672,
0.509642899,
0.9884724021,
-0.2378028482,
1.0529266596,
-0.191656217,
0.1873649061,
0.9339635968,
-0.1321366727,
0.568105042,
0.5624889731,
-0.2750838995,
0.8988085389,
0.6133330464,
-0.2952781022,
0.2961069643,
0.5790638924,
-0.2807076871,
-0.4035006464,
-0.243295148,
-0.0971029773,
0.1301449984,
0.3526672125,
-0.2129147798,
-0.520299077,
-0.3372015357,
-0.1855234653,
0.2487774938,
-0.5934294462,
0.7432363033,
0.009720901,
-0.5595296025,
0.0419206508,
0.2511486113,
0.363378346,
-0.5900828838,
-0.2887068987,
0.4661517739,
-0.4603027701,
-0.7059364319,
-1.3416279554,
0.7366537452,
0.0981441364,
0.1344264299,
-0.445147723,
0.7334761024,
-0.0793059394,
-0.6662375927,
0.2611685693,
-0.055286929,
0.721635282,
0.05265975,
-0.8592889309,
-0.4163195491,
-0.2531295717,
0.413466841,
-0.2758932114,
0.9824050069,
-0.5072842836,
0.5524613261,
0.5195191503,
0.3298857212,
0.0384468026,
0.0307923295,
0.7224240303,
-0.9201279879,
-0.7982718945,
-0.8238475323,
0.3486328125,
0.0445126295,
0.3013231158,
0.2079682052,
0.7609428763,
0.4711283445,
0.1537874043,
1.0003093481,
-0.806466341,
-0.0008832914,
-0.8272412419,
0.5675050616,
-0.4514833391,
0.1085393652,
0.0256619751,
-0.4640855193,
-0.5856201053,
0.5803555846,
-0.4725955129,
-0.2780401707,
1.0142281055,
0.6314889789,
-0.2615197599,
0.0404687189,
0.2677563727,
0.0956049487,
0.1768222302,
0.6238390803,
0.8016805649,
0.0245315339,
0.9539558887,
0.0102235479,
0.0871868134,
-0.1317358613,
-1.0019228458,
-0.5576578379,
-0.4419138134,
-0.2009524703,
-0.3951900303,
-0.1018421501,
1.0598531961,
0.502554059,
-0.8005470037,
-0.3176734746,
-0.6240255833,
0.4822921753,
-0.2410398275,
-0.1370927691,
0.222561717,
-0.461535573,
-0.0788742304,
0.0044874283,
0.2503593266,
0.1499865204,
-0.1221392304,
-0.4253455997,
-0.3453950882,
0.117072545,
0.5474402308,
0.3367718756,
-1.0463621616,
-0.3088185489,
-0.7411891818,
-0.245843485,
0.3850814998,
1.1059066057,
-0.5709897876,
0.6009184718,
0.6559388041,
0.4460224509,
0.4564277232,
-0.0531581603,
0.5537309051,
-0.2461253405,
0.0825846419,
0.5888025165,
0.5209799409,
-0.2372103035,
-0.4118029475,
0.6336144209,
0.2309754342,
0.0778917372,
-0.2934766412,
0.3281990588,
-1.1610790491,
-0.6025659442,
0.9276037812,
0.0323194824,
-0.6273509264,
-0.5230731964,
-0.5561729074,
0.2778717577,
-0.3629766107,
0.564475894,
0.7846479416,
0.137893036,
-0.1654148996,
-0.9248279333,
0.2996081114,
0.0895151794,
-1.124987483,
-0.1703861952,
0.6616820693,
0.3411389291,
0.4349860549,
0.7373897433,
-0.5124877691,
0.3529846668,
0.0450267419,
0.0356464237,
-0.0886820704,
-0.1465445012,
-0.1461312622,
0.0113308374,
0.1343435198,
0.2109104395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08329v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08329v1 | Text-to-speech synthesis based on latent variable conversion using diffusion probabilistic model and variational autoencoder | 2022-12-16T08:14:04 | 2022-12-16T08:14:04 | Yusuke Yasuda, Tomoki Toda | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, stat.ML | Text-to-speech synthesis (TTS) is a task to convert texts into speech. Two of
the factors that have been driving TTS are the advancements of probabilistic
models and latent representation learning. We propose a TTS method based on
latent variable conversion using a diffusion probabilistic model and the
variational autoencoder (VAE). In our TTS method, we use a waveform model based
on VAE, a diffusion model that predicts the distribution of latent variables in
the waveform model from texts, and an alignment model that learns alignments
between the text and speech latent sequences. Our method integrates diffusion
with VAE by modeling both mean and variance parameters with diffusion, where
the target distribution is determined by approximation from VAE. This latent
variable conversion framework potentially enables us to flexibly incorporate
various latent feature extractors. Our experiments show that our method is
robust to linguistic labels with poor orthography and alignment errors. | [
-0.1335230768,
-0.8128413558,
0.6147489548,
0.0997839794,
-0.356094718,
0.0931400582,
0.0378653482,
0.0767048076,
0.1311036348,
0.4199535549,
-0.5186231136,
-0.480004102,
-0.5357835293,
-0.2551246881,
-0.5761488676,
1.0759993792,
-0.1203803122,
0.0154821882,
0.0880156159,
0.3242605031,
-0.3173522353,
-0.3621129394,
-0.3867772818,
-0.1657443792,
0.2187309116,
-0.0649284422,
0.3868025541,
0.4467528164,
0.134921208,
0.2332618386,
-0.2827734947,
-0.0268634576,
-0.2423622012,
0.4332608879,
-0.0851356015,
-0.3758558929,
-0.4717980623,
-0.0118708685,
0.7710504532,
0.5667009354,
-0.3131748736,
-0.0605524816,
0.0805470198,
0.3400110006,
-0.5121039152,
-0.1065434515,
-0.3664315045,
0.1311729848,
-0.1549758464,
-0.0234001949,
-0.3924394548,
-0.5737778544,
0.2404340655,
-0.4160096049,
0.2556158006,
-0.3196321428,
0.2938788533,
0.3305180073,
-0.3811365962,
-0.0120458286,
-1.1968220472,
0.5555048585,
-0.6659571528,
0.7206293344,
0.2074362785,
0.2827398479,
-0.2810455561,
-0.7199099064,
-0.6682420969,
-0.1774556488,
0.3338073194,
0.2452643216,
0.0199952293,
-0.1614751518,
-0.2491325736,
0.3896399438,
-0.6359218359,
0.035407111,
-0.0052048075,
-0.2200584859,
0.4623769224,
-0.0454417318,
0.1096634343,
-0.2029780298,
-0.3690414429,
-0.4390313029,
-0.3039509356,
-0.179009676,
0.4881520271,
0.3543708324,
-0.1940253973,
0.7312871814,
0.4018543065,
0.6050144434,
0.2438616008,
-0.1788115054,
0.3249040842,
-0.3292224407,
-0.2517075539,
-0.1044760793,
0.9327654243,
0.0261018183,
-0.2261422575,
-0.1817318797,
-0.4673931301,
-0.1197791025,
0.2900491357,
-0.4900358021,
0.0053288657,
-0.0544454567,
-0.4633920491,
-0.240788281,
0.0655344054,
-0.8904768825,
-0.1756892502,
-0.1778483093,
0.5046987534,
-0.5094048977,
-0.3711383343,
-0.0830798149,
-0.1668433696,
0.0442502871,
0.2529733777,
-0.9035825729,
0.4237650037,
0.2203259766,
0.8868154287,
-0.5467597246,
-0.0846853405,
-0.5047267079,
0.4003768265,
-0.4558714628,
0.6641047597,
-0.3403049707,
-0.7844039202,
-0.1241721287,
-0.3104425371,
0.0405938104,
-0.5251325965,
0.2221378684,
-0.3458458185,
0.4885311425,
0.314134866,
-0.8041038513,
0.1892400533,
-0.389003545,
-0.6634509563,
1.0293560028,
0.4608787,
-0.5518660545,
-0.1072491258,
-0.7363901138,
-0.4474745989,
-0.1378777176,
-0.2112767249,
-0.4951552153,
0.4182280302,
0.0728392079,
0.3568627834,
-0.5546326637,
0.5053250194,
0.0729641616,
0.033806026,
0.5185771585,
-1.0543667078,
0.4546918869,
0.2431018651,
-0.3590068221,
-0.0908094496,
-0.7520686984,
-0.2220578939,
-0.1564635932,
-0.2603786588,
-0.1072086617,
0.2266007066,
0.4952445328,
0.0623838566,
0.1574698389,
-0.2251943499,
-0.0034913071,
-0.7213275433,
0.2509311438,
0.4421138465,
0.2940432131,
0.7720708251,
-0.0752119124,
0.5187330842,
0.0287964568,
-0.0445991866,
0.1027674079,
-0.5719262362,
-0.4429185987,
-0.145801276,
0.5116261244,
0.6134781241,
-0.7804792523,
0.8821923733,
-0.1238322183,
-0.4215619266,
-0.4330265224,
-0.4339078367,
0.1387415677,
0.5532667637,
0.4167467654,
-0.4784939587,
-0.2887790501,
-0.4910431802,
0.0043512774,
-0.5176575184,
-0.5347956419,
-0.1539193094,
0.1768453419,
-0.208213225,
1.1536405087,
-0.5365726352,
-0.3854300976,
0.2298523933,
0.4954558015,
-0.0796105713,
0.7806633711,
0.4838080108,
-0.8176734447,
-0.2346224487,
-0.0433135666,
-0.2266795188,
-0.3697543442,
-0.0744256154,
0.0539544299,
0.1352953464,
0.8351604342,
-0.1360861659,
0.6708223224,
0.5864679217,
-0.2942337096,
0.4900307655,
-0.2635225654,
0.2297479808,
-1.3588210344,
0.0151967844,
0.0654219165,
-0.4635971487,
-0.5539364219,
-0.4388455153,
-0.309928149,
-0.1082523912,
-0.4124130905,
0.4376519918,
-0.1184779406,
0.0088333301,
-0.3524720967,
-0.1665965468,
-0.0941190869,
-0.0532537885,
0.1592758447,
0.9855123162,
0.4509323537,
-0.5883387327,
0.3368869722,
0.0974914655,
-0.0055420119,
0.6637630463,
-0.505746007,
-0.0150606195,
0.0255465489,
0.1928945035,
-1.0722868443,
-0.0597344749,
0.292820245,
-0.4953844249,
0.4045924544,
0.0114648687,
-0.4154210687,
-0.0441996753,
-0.0702743381,
0.5033485293,
0.6233647466,
-0.1835525036,
0.8680745959,
0.5173465014,
-0.4791214466,
-0.0208898894,
-0.9426749945,
-0.0542128123,
-0.2437440306,
-0.2429005504,
0.896183908,
-0.2984264791,
0.26124686,
0.0700764358,
0.0299998075,
-0.4162529707,
-0.2279225737,
-0.0789256468,
0.1349769235,
-0.2684062719,
0.0784860551,
0.4404165745,
-0.2675116062,
-0.0376435481,
-0.6689800024,
0.3833447099,
0.3804904521,
-0.2798733413,
-0.4262449145,
0.5762053728,
0.5463267565,
-0.0248178169,
0.5420156121,
0.6975998282,
-0.427330941,
-0.1204545796,
-0.3052271307,
-0.0449353755,
-0.4194668829,
0.5008186698,
-0.361394316,
-0.7453995943,
0.487200439,
-0.4077371061,
-0.2838697433,
0.6268532276,
0.7779302001,
-0.2271192819,
0.9026209712,
0.7468842864,
0.2567947507,
1.0271024704,
-0.0253615268,
0.1066897064,
-0.7182176709,
-0.2011354715,
-0.4517716765,
0.0607235804,
-0.6050255299,
-0.873863101,
0.5142065287,
-0.102055043,
-0.1224381253,
0.176883325,
-0.6096150279,
0.1941502094,
0.4642603397,
0.0179191623,
-0.094890736,
0.3193841875,
-0.1142869517,
-0.3977087736,
-0.3173286617,
-0.6040080786,
0.9415404797,
0.3528091609,
0.7744028568,
0.3714636862,
0.6909920573,
0.4865088463,
0.0926360786,
-0.5744946599,
0.2207851261,
-0.5500163436,
-0.1702774167,
-0.4811090827,
-0.3885051906,
-0.7826716304,
0.0307675153,
-0.3788331151,
-0.8796108365,
0.3650278151,
-0.0754045397,
-0.0481643453,
0.121436514,
-0.7302635312,
0.5664386153,
0.0227798242,
-0.1154867038,
0.2091699243,
-0.6908872128,
-0.0674334764,
-0.3584007621,
0.2529848516,
0.3082035482,
-0.1241845936,
0.9490898848,
-0.3863861561,
0.9035333991,
-0.1736150682,
-0.5176032186,
0.23127608,
0.0672732592,
0.2529875934,
0.1047634408,
-0.1618887782,
-0.0889375955,
-0.1720525622,
-0.0035612779,
-0.650545001,
0.3215962946,
-0.8890318871,
-0.3490754962,
-0.2070077062,
-0.3388889134,
-0.2330729663,
0.1470555961,
0.6227844954,
0.1745814532,
-0.7556828856,
-0.1012074053,
0.7542771101,
-0.0049784933,
0.4968893826,
0.3173706234,
-0.1084723845,
-0.8664226532,
0.9401663542,
0.0761825591,
0.3319173455,
0.6740082502,
0.2499996722,
-0.4951019287,
-0.7171299458,
-0.3862942755,
0.1430590302,
-0.6142576933,
-0.0546828583,
-0.3226013184,
-0.5353248715,
-0.6209022403,
-0.1536934227,
-0.7392325997,
-0.4269748926,
-0.9333106279,
0.2260568142,
0.0706314892,
0.6904945374,
-0.1080826074,
0.6804712415,
-0.6431671977,
0.4498015046,
0.4608228803,
0.1586592346,
-0.319483906,
-0.8690139055,
-0.0923157334,
-0.0563014708,
-0.460719645,
-1.3965549469,
0.6067844033,
0.0776621997,
0.3619788885,
0.0157648828,
-0.1027053744,
0.3658262789,
-0.8732714653,
0.9231770039,
0.5366518497,
-1.2928730249,
0.6740515232,
-0.2092648745,
0.0708247125,
0.1365490258,
0.0497278236,
-0.3567575812,
-0.6390555501,
-0.7823019028,
-0.9918590784,
0.4416465163,
0.7013962269,
0.0631830916,
0.1279262155,
0.6150158048,
0.3506474495,
0.2635158598,
-0.7209538817,
-0.406935513,
-0.3101990223,
-0.6803587079,
-0.1320268661,
-0.097116746,
0.0552952178,
0.0421943441,
0.6886432767,
-0.0912578627,
0.5901844501,
0.1540096551,
0.1214310005,
-0.0340849571,
0.3299719691,
0.4852051139,
0.1437742859,
-0.1497705281,
0.1243161559,
-0.1035874188,
-0.561925292,
0.5402600169,
0.4542922378,
-0.3192204833,
0.3202878535,
0.0382440612,
0.8643377423,
-0.1471477002,
-0.1587381959,
0.6474315524,
-0.215516299,
-0.1262794286,
-0.1370542943,
0.0610934757,
0.2099059522,
0.2576178908,
0.5444849133,
0.1949015409,
0.2753319442,
0.0563875623,
0.2313019335,
0.0283222701,
-0.2570188046,
-0.3899491131,
1.0072143078,
0.1152425334,
-0.7168772817,
-0.1145005301,
-0.0772609189,
-0.0875910521,
0.4350346923,
0.7431414723,
1.0930428505,
-0.9319903255,
0.3976316154,
-0.0079826294,
0.1384381652,
-0.1669974029,
0.2803531289,
0.1064564735,
-0.3213659525,
-0.3956213593,
-0.6358183026,
-0.3991012871,
0.1137455776,
-0.6432725191,
0.2668632865,
-0.1411929131,
-0.4522595406,
0.1502093077,
-0.5967606306,
-0.4226319194,
0.58028543,
0.2103605717,
0.2091862708,
-1.177926898,
0.6935707927,
0.6145421863,
-0.2746561468,
-0.5409811735,
0.5771178007,
-0.3182391822,
-0.1531057358,
0.439904362,
-0.416721791,
-0.1447665393,
0.224241972,
-0.2769731879,
-1.0216151476,
0.7537006736,
0.7403851151,
-0.6440386176,
0.0219475012,
0.1950479448,
0.6264745593,
-0.5739735365,
0.1489651501,
0.3346338868,
0.1189537197,
0.1147338301,
-0.9403855801,
-0.113183178,
0.1326133907,
0.6639865637,
-0.0163524393,
-0.1452170908,
0.8244231939,
0.2083232254,
-0.0563855805,
0.0621500686,
1.0166267157,
0.118514739,
0.0031807257,
0.5298423171,
0.036161989,
0.8179503083,
0.0962260589,
0.5825134516,
0.145914048,
0.503480792,
0.9188255072,
-0.1459876001,
1.0551204681,
0.6100953817,
-0.3996923864,
0.6956282854,
0.4738704264,
0.339299053,
0.8860960007,
0.2079269439,
-0.4354950786,
0.0094587458,
0.2478726208,
-0.2999004126,
0.4311389923,
0.695086062,
-0.5245789886,
-0.0005270289,
0.351985991,
-0.4284925163,
0.0532418601,
0.1528868526,
0.9407398701,
-0.112702027,
-0.5046517253,
0.5420188308,
0.1471693069,
0.4787061512,
-0.4740808308,
0.0459797122,
0.1111461446,
-0.1160952076,
0.1191103309,
-0.6926189065,
0.4397810698,
-0.0224382412,
-0.6173600554,
-0.2666783929,
0.4882904887,
-0.7088556886,
-0.5028962493,
0.1328553557,
0.6254321337,
-0.0035348486,
0.1773649752,
-0.5434760451,
-0.0938808545,
0.0430457555,
-0.3181290329,
0.2087026685,
0.658015132,
-0.0209561307,
0.2333127707,
0.4358068109,
0.2545982599,
0.0488526411,
0.1756690294,
0.7914091945,
-0.6158553362,
-0.9346654415,
-0.6631891727,
0.4630447924,
0.1628740579,
-0.1229258105,
0.2058067918,
0.3550352752,
0.4146306515,
-0.1107479781,
1.0511103868,
0.0383668132,
0.4969908297,
-0.7541804314,
0.5307076573,
-0.5803349614,
0.331599623,
-0.3651160002,
-1.0662965775,
-0.2542650402,
0.8354980946,
-0.0153353084,
0.0939538106,
0.8284934163,
0.5756184459,
-0.0025284609,
-0.0424107909,
0.3159401715,
0.1152779311,
0.5807250738,
0.4413241148,
0.5039675236,
-0.5909798741,
0.4397439659,
0.1635091901,
-0.4169561267,
-0.045723889,
-0.9326673746,
-0.3766524196,
-0.8275806904,
-0.7038316131,
-0.524508059,
0.0424229912,
0.5577982068,
0.6012843847,
-0.7373074889,
-0.2127270699,
-0.4663588107,
0.0811733454,
-0.1021742225,
-0.2508579493,
0.5459784269,
-0.1413439512,
-0.9732196927,
0.479849577,
0.3713598847,
0.7899782658,
-0.3639185727,
0.0073808338,
-0.0656269491,
0.1908275485,
0.2575556636,
0.032238055,
-0.7765656114,
-0.0524850227,
-0.1995605826,
-0.2762919962,
0.155111596,
0.6372343302,
-0.7889755964,
0.6643006802,
0.4566668272,
0.5568583012,
0.7042399049,
-0.2728089392,
0.865908742,
-1.1317937374,
0.2529101074,
0.3894387782,
0.0077398149,
0.4385197759,
-0.2427019775,
0.0416954681,
0.4199290276,
-0.5084816813,
-0.6483741403,
0.3118970692,
-0.8373489976,
-0.3634041548,
1.1082090139,
-0.0021347087,
-0.4283312857,
-0.1101808399,
-0.2113045752,
0.7236241102,
-0.3274510503,
0.5258055329,
0.3615659773,
-0.0163011346,
0.0825636387,
-0.2220681608,
0.3860490024,
0.3736473918,
-0.7109674811,
0.0370991006,
0.4844247997,
0.2614346147,
0.3100807369,
0.7864099145,
-0.107848838,
0.2147596925,
0.0441198982,
0.1087026075,
0.5710021257,
-0.0589980595,
-0.3872452974,
0.1286522895,
-0.1140097305,
-0.3182627559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08330v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08330v2 | Convolution-enhanced Evolving Attention Networks | 2022-12-16T08:14:04 | 2023-04-28T06:44:48 | Yujing Wang, Yaming Yang, Zhuo Li, Jiangang Bai, Mingliang Zhang, Xiangtai Li, Jing Yu, Ce Zhang, Gao Huang, Yunhai Tong | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.NE | Attention-based neural networks, such as Transformers, have become ubiquitous
in numerous applications, including computer vision, natural language
processing, and time-series analysis. In all kinds of attention networks, the
attention maps are crucial as they encode semantic dependencies between input
tokens. However, most existing attention networks perform modeling or reasoning
based on representations , wherein the attention maps of different layers are
learned separately without explicit interactions. In this paper, we propose a
novel and generic evolving attention mechanism, which directly models the
evolution of inter-token relationships through a chain of residual
convolutional modules. The major motivations are twofold. On the one hand, the
attention maps in different layers share transferable knowledge, thus adding a
residual connection can facilitate the information flow of inter-token
relationships across layers. On the other hand, there is naturally an
evolutionary trend among attention maps at different abstraction levels, so it
is beneficial to exploit a dedicated convolution-based module to capture this
process. Equipped with the proposed mechanism, the convolution-enhanced
evolving attention networks achieve superior performance in various
applications, including time-series representation, natural language
understanding, machine translation, and image classification. Especially on
time-series representation tasks, Evolving Attention-enhanced Dilated
Convolutional (EA-DC-) Transformer outperforms state-of-the-art models
significantly, achieving an average of 17% improvement compared to the best
SOTA. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work that explicitly
models the layer-wise evolution of attention maps. Our implementation is
available at https://github.com/pkuyym/EvolvingAttention. | [
-0.5495247245,
-0.6855422854,
0.2378773391,
0.1210427284,
-0.3326908052,
-0.0416042209,
-0.2114566714,
-0.4554784596,
0.1541532427,
0.2342682779,
-0.9560143948,
-0.1088294685,
-0.6014552116,
-0.0049493862,
-0.4419872761,
0.9080423713,
0.1186634526,
-0.2634843588,
-0.0857647359,
-0.3573156297,
-0.3295542598,
-0.0560750067,
-0.8118111491,
-0.5345224142,
0.7279594541,
0.1414619386,
0.6329514384,
0.4246376455,
0.7660364509,
0.2516690195,
-0.1885235012,
0.3530057073,
-0.4169861674,
0.0380442403,
-0.1087181717,
-0.2016517371,
-0.3516976237,
-0.3622885644,
0.4507039785,
0.5853491426,
0.0079619111,
0.4609439373,
0.2345070392,
0.56467098,
-0.6112663746,
0.1716029495,
-0.6776618361,
0.1966678947,
0.2207765132,
-0.4968219697,
-0.4513884783,
-0.2553930879,
0.5306041837,
-0.4815192819,
0.0995292738,
-0.0942215174,
0.8016391993,
0.3711279333,
-0.0535454601,
0.0137066906,
-0.7595996857,
0.4912875295,
-0.5046662092,
0.2913836539,
-0.256492883,
0.540743649,
0.0993027464,
-1.1428272724,
-0.3538431227,
-0.2046135515,
-0.1281070858,
0.4519220889,
-0.1552720666,
-0.0856760889,
0.117923744,
0.4876869023,
-0.1785079241,
-0.101731956,
-0.3812819719,
0.208722949,
0.1348952502,
0.0774750262,
0.2893452644,
0.3545250595,
-0.8327280879,
0.2919687927,
-0.5900532603,
0.1755961329,
0.1116709933,
0.1966693699,
-0.3364857733,
0.2376675904,
-0.0290117022,
0.541220367,
0.4947392941,
0.4251278341,
0.14704898,
-0.1032367125,
-0.3754484355,
0.0744334832,
0.5804082751,
0.1655375063,
0.4799916446,
-0.3534061611,
0.0810896978,
-0.1055703312,
0.354582727,
-0.568855226,
-0.401362747,
0.1250879765,
-0.4456835389,
-0.4572511017,
0.032863088,
-0.7328656316,
-0.0651523322,
-0.4136757553,
0.6598739624,
-0.3961656094,
-0.4212921262,
0.2909958363,
-0.0102574676,
0.434681505,
0.1051266193,
-0.9112113714,
0.2925122678,
0.7283579707,
0.9432528019,
-0.2783333063,
-0.1534675509,
-0.5083303452,
0.1266884804,
0.0250595622,
0.6676957607,
-0.5678830743,
0.1590711176,
0.0393592864,
0.1812356859,
0.0178532749,
-0.4855209589,
0.4034486115,
-0.8291526437,
0.1490629166,
0.2457749695,
-0.3091225326,
-0.3799937963,
0.3726139665,
-0.6531374454,
0.8287685513,
0.2249830663,
-0.6889976859,
0.2053860873,
-0.9033455253,
-0.2862684727,
0.3667555153,
0.2171768248,
-0.7950975895,
0.0458926708,
0.3149839342,
0.3830114305,
-0.2359275669,
0.1936394125,
-0.6851590276,
-0.3412018418,
0.3514273763,
-0.4939755201,
0.6952946186,
-0.115454562,
-0.4197533429,
0.1133438572,
-0.6350696087,
-0.366964668,
0.1288531274,
-0.3292747736,
-0.1193502173,
-0.1304383874,
-0.02319571,
0.2508175373,
0.3881859481,
-0.483740449,
0.129922837,
-0.4974710345,
0.5856113434,
0.6633810401,
0.5112256408,
0.4621676505,
-0.1632458717,
0.3566451371,
0.3778472543,
0.7425560951,
-0.5789131522,
-0.2874019742,
-1.0470148325,
0.1375080347,
0.0095541049,
0.1038403437,
-0.4034874141,
0.4998441935,
-0.6010072231,
-0.3647838831,
-0.2664111555,
-0.2513620853,
-0.0294250976,
0.4205248356,
0.5530409217,
-0.1190890223,
-0.2464012504,
-0.8301941752,
-0.1578984261,
0.1362217814,
0.1041152328,
0.3133771122,
0.0127947628,
-0.3651726544,
0.8665381074,
-0.2798101604,
-0.1739613116,
-0.3666869998,
-0.1311406493,
0.2041680068,
0.4749682844,
0.579025805,
-0.8083299398,
-0.2667419314,
0.3449170291,
-0.3282045126,
0.0023463173,
-0.4373539388,
-0.4090423882,
-0.4102650881,
0.4583993852,
-0.5774841905,
0.2886546254,
0.455522567,
-0.1260459572,
0.3505834639,
0.1796492189,
-0.2862327397,
-0.8803236485,
0.3922917247,
0.0419606641,
-0.4645183682,
-0.5822629929,
0.2281639874,
0.1332010478,
-0.2236904055,
-0.4627866447,
0.3892309964,
-0.4444101155,
-0.0129010323,
-0.1723538637,
0.1189349666,
0.0127335349,
1.0759707689,
-0.3006842434,
0.0778426155,
0.7557806373,
-0.7165376544,
0.5972796679,
0.2203845531,
0.0265559126,
0.2399610281,
-0.5031372309,
0.2179186344,
-0.2782788873,
0.0280190408,
-0.9333789945,
0.1255980432,
0.3967630863,
-0.5313971043,
0.7479913235,
-0.2364201546,
0.0005490888,
-0.3271624744,
-0.2523601353,
0.4732431769,
0.3735265136,
-0.907879889,
0.8591916561,
-0.0171669666,
-0.0303873997,
-0.5446099639,
-0.6842391491,
0.075523369,
-0.2405031025,
-0.5366876721,
0.1793632805,
-0.0250005424,
0.1655189246,
0.3196065426,
-0.2805823088,
0.2388417423,
0.1609851122,
-0.0838936567,
0.1927146316,
-0.4071713686,
0.2406201214,
0.1714498103,
-0.1609281152,
0.1206876636,
-0.6626341343,
0.5987294316,
0.2537975013,
-0.2343976945,
-0.6983879805,
0.2475736588,
1.1093505621,
-0.5804159641,
0.555326283,
0.6467548013,
-0.3494055271,
-0.3672489524,
-0.3676831424,
-0.3803592324,
-0.5435188413,
0.487177074,
-0.1635913104,
-0.8151330352,
0.4597935677,
-0.5300843716,
0.3028438985,
0.5175830126,
0.4385587573,
0.0957149863,
0.6850908995,
0.5182802081,
0.005942923,
0.7956210971,
-0.4098243713,
0.2565262616,
-1.0837976933,
-0.4213854373,
0.0101529751,
-0.9214590192,
-0.3861098289,
0.0125968531,
0.2892667949,
-0.1465823501,
-0.3259660304,
0.3640685678,
-0.7000407577,
0.234545216,
0.1164747626,
0.3596293628,
0.0739610791,
0.113541916,
0.1221805289,
0.234054774,
-0.5396422744,
-0.0509292707,
0.8521440625,
0.5761272311,
0.8533596992,
-0.0359745733,
0.3468293846,
0.4575373828,
0.5168896914,
-0.7097546458,
0.4139726758,
-0.236216113,
-0.1596935242,
-0.2027128786,
-0.2479812354,
-0.8527443409,
0.1013190225,
0.1372824013,
-0.6409707665,
0.5026026964,
0.0969046503,
-0.4793784618,
0.2834953964,
-0.6955753565,
0.9391887784,
-0.1289931983,
-0.5052210093,
-0.3069500029,
-0.8505550027,
0.2401689589,
-0.0705189481,
-0.4444715381,
-0.0217995532,
-0.1403055489,
0.2955471873,
-0.1390604526,
0.6603358984,
-0.2031414211,
0.1537616849,
0.548599124,
-0.0371093154,
0.6948573589,
0.2816448212,
0.1268354654,
0.053842485,
-0.6167566776,
-0.3812149763,
-0.8562319279,
0.5707668662,
-0.5194081664,
-0.5836802125,
0.0580191053,
-0.4044835865,
-0.0421482585,
0.0074502407,
0.0085685533,
0.7527254224,
0.062054906,
0.3959638476,
0.4843946993,
0.0417790376,
0.5835217237,
0.2022659928,
0.0127169546,
-0.1960638314,
0.6726403236,
-0.108241573,
0.4726192057,
0.7022976875,
0.2442673445,
-0.2133232504,
-0.4070101976,
-0.1533669382,
0.055534862,
-0.6214931011,
-0.4101104438,
-0.8846884966,
-0.5193281174,
-0.172916159,
-0.0024959752,
-0.1486044377,
-0.351498872,
-0.4685897231,
-0.1920526475,
0.4629353285,
0.2471646219,
0.1940719783,
0.2457250506,
-0.5587280393,
0.2611721754,
0.682507813,
0.3479651511,
0.5378035307,
-0.760207653,
-0.4271246195,
-0.0931287333,
-0.5556214452,
-0.763484478,
0.2927244008,
0.407961309,
0.434370786,
0.6123995185,
-0.1350405365,
0.615790844,
-0.3557189703,
0.4518626332,
0.175064683,
-0.6618432403,
0.3286669254,
-0.2963299751,
0.5235612988,
0.176491484,
-0.1014693752,
-0.5114293694,
-0.4930979609,
-0.5632928014,
-0.7595393062,
0.948186934,
0.1849841028,
0.4161734581,
0.1451420486,
0.6622484922,
0.191477403,
-0.1450898647,
-0.7431043983,
-0.3303665519,
-0.2220762074,
-0.3754927516,
0.3632450104,
-0.1301288605,
0.1330134273,
-0.1112016514,
0.4704371989,
-0.2219843119,
0.4481527805,
0.3718847632,
-0.0572544038,
-0.1922179759,
0.0235473067,
0.4527362585,
0.3688952923,
-0.0887372792,
0.34400931,
0.294326216,
-0.6730871797,
0.1160188466,
0.235440284,
-0.1400545388,
-0.0523344353,
0.1200343594,
0.8842969537,
0.3405461609,
-0.1417670846,
0.4681490958,
-0.1758476645,
0.2627170682,
-0.2675949633,
0.0286453813,
0.2966737151,
0.4323703051,
0.5931589007,
0.4679720998,
0.2902857959,
-0.3355229199,
0.5374273658,
0.1922876686,
-0.6835657954,
-0.5643213391,
0.5867624879,
0.2738639712,
-0.4686344564,
0.2112365663,
0.0360455327,
-0.3936258554,
0.8129229546,
0.5385243297,
1.3689095974,
-0.2177731842,
-0.0005466522,
0.3195114434,
0.3515590131,
0.2448044419,
-0.1287568063,
-0.3986094296,
-0.3665934503,
-0.3405487835,
-0.6209509969,
-0.1302705854,
0.3546306491,
-0.4232272208,
0.6053882241,
-0.4052278697,
-0.1295603514,
-0.0066573722,
-0.6227513552,
-0.8299856186,
0.2954172194,
0.2367308438,
0.7334707975,
-0.5493307114,
0.4457501769,
0.8394668698,
-0.106865786,
-0.2684296668,
0.353788048,
-0.7648935914,
-0.7956001163,
0.3516417146,
0.4471024573,
-0.1641774178,
0.4796851277,
-0.5951330662,
-0.9935328364,
1.0237135887,
0.4039748013,
-0.7552871108,
0.0196486562,
-0.0323788114,
0.432133019,
-0.5082397461,
0.2144035697,
0.3612444699,
0.174678579,
-0.2064671516,
-0.0485537015,
0.0781666413,
-0.2762283087,
-0.1239500418,
0.2870957553,
-1.0572913885,
0.4418118298,
-0.1823082268,
-0.527208209,
-0.0014429545,
0.7111192942,
-0.1157250106,
0.3143258691,
0.4783155918,
0.5576863289,
-0.1163785681,
-0.1082251295,
0.7303943038,
-0.3872097731,
0.5911457539,
1.0409101248,
0.1858577877,
0.3890084326,
0.4402602911,
-0.0210219342,
0.5457687378,
0.5688958168,
-0.1869114637,
0.7262837887,
0.0674351975,
-0.2268975079,
-0.235445261,
-0.1605029553,
-0.0795569718,
0.1512324363,
0.3349716663,
-0.7148193121,
-0.300476253,
-0.0307200141,
-0.4470192194,
-0.2549681664,
-0.3029192388,
0.8608853221,
0.1883636862,
-0.6429330707,
0.3016617596,
-0.3317295313,
0.5047534108,
-0.5432709455,
-0.0356299691,
-0.3134557903,
0.2984905541,
-0.1620948613,
-0.6291071177,
0.1925636828,
-0.1556360722,
-0.1382170618,
0.1201994643,
0.6343175173,
-0.6341677308,
-0.438229084,
0.4068711102,
0.129532069,
-0.2304426134,
0.1532780528,
-0.6089373231,
-0.0665671229,
-0.2094085068,
-0.4658280611,
0.0017707539,
0.5569648147,
0.2310374081,
0.6706782579,
0.5102665424,
-0.2641637921,
0.4689306617,
0.4895132184,
0.8654984832,
-0.3219635785,
-0.667065084,
-1.038536191,
0.7905246019,
-0.1569849849,
-0.3291870058,
0.1702882797,
0.4059976041,
0.3053106666,
-0.1434699893,
0.5899791718,
0.3438747823,
-0.0736233592,
-0.2468971759,
0.6915897727,
-0.6055424809,
-0.1114142612,
-0.1015030369,
-1.2340666056,
-0.3650319278,
0.063445732,
0.056967143,
0.0725961626,
0.6086102724,
0.4475076199,
-0.430937171,
-0.0509280041,
0.2371373326,
0.1758749038,
0.4281164408,
0.8727741241,
0.8968259096,
-0.485257268,
0.8625028133,
0.008887846,
-0.1527307481,
-0.1761403233,
-0.4184399247,
-0.8264751434,
-0.3932740986,
-0.5491198897,
0.0191047341,
0.0430059731,
0.4414746761,
0.572704494,
-0.6340040565,
0.4569525123,
-0.5714554191,
-0.2640346885,
-0.4340753257,
-0.2787276208,
0.527841568,
-0.4968719184,
-0.6643900275,
-0.0679404438,
0.9670304656,
0.0541470386,
-0.543947041,
-0.0008370413,
-0.1484116316,
0.061888054,
0.3761696815,
0.1538310051,
-0.5990411639,
-0.518720746,
0.1511034667,
0.2167048454,
0.2634676099,
0.7331721783,
-0.6841860414,
0.72729671,
0.481072098,
0.8960712552,
0.6961496472,
-0.0145759499,
0.3831880093,
-0.8602905273,
0.1291870922,
0.2743428349,
0.4455232024,
0.6847140789,
-0.5161345005,
0.3277750313,
0.2488786727,
-0.5259843469,
-0.5879356861,
0.258251816,
-1.1682658195,
0.2639626265,
0.9333478212,
-0.1249844655,
-0.2926668525,
-0.1536776423,
-0.296842128,
0.633718133,
-0.4538638592,
1.0350416899,
0.2895329893,
0.036389526,
-0.6037048101,
0.0186737459,
0.2956703007,
0.306663096,
-0.8403036594,
0.2656425238,
-0.2426373512,
0.1320961118,
0.3491776586,
-0.0889345109,
-0.4006102681,
0.58571136,
-0.4100548029,
-0.1679754555,
-0.1959338486,
-0.2665251493,
-0.3997047246,
0.3601496518,
-0.3087290227,
-0.6968557239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.11219v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.11219v2 | On Safe and Usable Chatbots for Promoting Voter Participation | 2022-12-16T08:07:51 | 2022-12-28T08:09:45 | Bharath Muppasani, Vishal Pallagani, Kausik Lakkaraju, Shuge Lei, Biplav Srivastava, Brett Robertson, Andrea Hickerson, Vignesh Narayanan | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.CY | Chatbots, or bots for short, are multi-modal collaborative assistants that
can help people complete useful tasks. Usually, when chatbots are referenced in
connection with elections, they often draw negative reactions due to the fear
of mis-information and hacking. Instead, in this paper, we explore how chatbots
may be used to promote voter participation in vulnerable segments of society
like senior citizens and first-time voters. In particular, we build a system
that amplifies official information while personalizing it to users' unique
needs transparently. We discuss its design, build prototypes with frequently
asked questions (FAQ) election information for two US states that are low on an
ease-of-voting scale, and report on its initial evaluation in a focus group.
Our approach can be a win-win for voters, election agencies trying to fulfill
their mandate and democracy at large. | [
-0.3583682477,
-0.8787207007,
0.3250011206,
0.0432576872,
-0.3852725625,
0.2468947768,
-0.030259531,
-0.0430426858,
0.1885290444,
0.3234631717,
-0.3936997354,
-0.4533040822,
-0.2932421267,
-0.2082910091,
-0.4416998029,
0.8983320594,
0.5174254775,
-0.1884688139,
-0.2252080739,
0.2691059411,
-0.3694733381,
-0.6133691072,
-0.4959755242,
0.0330253839,
0.6316088438,
0.8593000174,
0.8994865417,
0.1235825866,
0.4431700408,
0.3730068207,
0.0087931165,
-0.0636029691,
-0.6743867993,
0.2613041401,
0.0350008272,
-1.0145962238,
-0.3529616296,
0.0170890838,
0.0752316713,
0.3937222064,
-0.2195365578,
0.015000551,
0.2003938109,
0.66962713,
-0.8310680985,
0.1344549209,
-0.8811046481,
-0.0793102384,
-0.4193213284,
-0.455801338,
-0.3495143652,
-0.9678569436,
-0.0044407574,
-0.3193517923,
0.5099340081,
0.1469187737,
0.1628558934,
-0.0040247855,
-0.4183340371,
-0.3524793983,
-0.8322604299,
0.3044038713,
-0.46825248,
0.1310048997,
0.4253130853,
0.47859025,
-0.4031957686,
-0.3350769579,
-0.6439950466,
-0.2925959527,
0.0659956485,
0.1524345428,
-0.1803506762,
0.1947917491,
-0.0855624452,
0.3432253003,
-0.4365465939,
-0.1317010671,
-0.3559993804,
-0.3219673038,
0.5411565304,
0.2989076376,
0.197625339,
-0.3308621645,
-0.44582057,
-0.1650763154,
-0.4632229805,
0.3405911922,
0.7462403774,
0.5456382036,
-0.3158818483,
0.6294139028,
-0.3740608096,
0.4581485987,
0.1772361249,
0.1715770066,
0.2724019289,
-0.6613479853,
-0.0870680213,
-0.2731423676,
0.6252059937,
0.2569676936,
0.2682920694,
-0.0024400267,
0.0100289965,
0.2697082758,
0.249909997,
-0.6156909466,
-0.3515273929,
0.4359600842,
-0.5951812267,
-0.5068535209,
0.2800805569,
-0.6283102632,
-0.6932983398,
-0.0212317575,
0.561743021,
-0.2085179985,
-0.2835915685,
-0.2052042335,
-0.2571934164,
0.0084654531,
0.8197112083,
-0.6291026473,
0.1224742755,
0.5229969621,
0.6345102191,
-0.0463765562,
0.2490957975,
-0.3992283046,
-0.2199765742,
-0.2148793489,
0.5379520059,
-0.3231624663,
-0.5386267304,
0.1270328462,
0.0838658959,
0.0917126313,
-0.4207397103,
0.2657402456,
-0.6403527856,
0.4704161882,
0.2713751495,
-0.2494632602,
0.0452872291,
0.2431905568,
-0.6125442982,
0.5476667881,
-0.0604795925,
-0.5235846043,
0.4030396938,
-0.5841989517,
-0.3036172986,
0.128774181,
0.0168217774,
-0.2478437275,
0.2295604497,
-0.0950423852,
0.6623285413,
0.2470648587,
-0.2785100639,
-0.1133344844,
-0.2039257288,
0.3879019916,
-0.6349361539,
0.5691103935,
-0.0287322197,
-0.1058923826,
0.4907734394,
-0.2975934446,
0.0209176801,
-0.0277574025,
-0.2052604407,
-0.2624540329,
0.067778863,
0.243920505,
-0.0264931228,
0.3557103574,
-0.5959432125,
-0.0525611378,
-0.3587837517,
0.1466581821,
0.8584331274,
-0.0579514578,
0.5743197799,
-0.2668993473,
0.55520612,
0.0742227435,
0.5559462309,
-0.4160973728,
-0.9658811688,
-0.5394244194,
0.0687267482,
0.4987579882,
0.7572388053,
-0.7117900252,
0.3793249428,
0.1041570008,
-0.6422303915,
-0.1737297475,
0.1129757687,
-0.1354712397,
0.3427191973,
-0.3121472597,
-0.4791429043,
-0.0347343609,
-0.6182174087,
0.0583582446,
-0.6652408242,
-0.2141360492,
0.3969773352,
0.3395040929,
0.1861451715,
0.8682585359,
-0.2718504667,
-0.4610165656,
-0.1153148264,
0.0053994749,
-0.089205876,
0.5399703979,
0.1078221276,
-1.0827202797,
-0.2234223187,
-0.0064408705,
-0.1053533107,
0.2293630987,
-0.1095262766,
0.0232727062,
0.0630757585,
0.150283739,
-0.114823021,
0.8679640293,
0.6687101126,
-0.4014217556,
-0.0823076665,
-0.2539460659,
0.4347476065,
-1.0138170719,
0.0201792549,
-0.4055309892,
-0.5919934511,
-0.8202672601,
-0.2140718102,
-0.04578989,
-0.4441141188,
-0.6434201598,
0.1392209977,
0.0653851554,
0.5182388425,
-0.4777874053,
0.4026505351,
-0.4807764292,
0.2292623818,
0.0318179242,
0.5962077379,
0.2204080671,
-0.4213632941,
0.1602135003,
0.2703356445,
-0.2177155465,
0.6135151982,
-0.7509492636,
0.5296429992,
-0.3405534327,
0.1813657284,
-1.4684129953,
-0.5299479365,
0.4058020115,
-0.9228479862,
-0.2040474862,
0.0908542797,
-0.2945578396,
-0.2199023068,
-0.1125190556,
0.1783690304,
0.4971850216,
0.1026573181,
0.3583016396,
0.8213294148,
-0.2464494407,
-0.0611148477,
-0.3243267238,
0.1293655932,
-0.1421905607,
-0.5854982138,
0.0350480527,
0.0904827788,
0.0879520103,
-0.0368825905,
0.2524282932,
-0.5022817254,
0.3138939738,
0.531621635,
0.2084888667,
0.1381224692,
0.3817236722,
-0.3379635513,
-0.31238392,
-0.4233427942,
0.5828824043,
0.6615666151,
-0.1860712022,
-0.5646114945,
-0.8826612234,
0.9139360785,
0.5198574066,
-0.024771506,
0.466255188,
0.4836285412,
-0.4865272939,
0.2930905521,
-0.6272912025,
-0.5834682584,
-0.4900872707,
0.0926848948,
0.2200442553,
-1.2080545425,
0.34842363,
-0.3060327172,
0.429243207,
-0.0046166922,
0.6363389492,
-0.2096092552,
1.2351610661,
0.6243083477,
0.1313625872,
0.6236124039,
0.4186937511,
0.014598324,
-0.1052724272,
-0.4868594706,
-0.9157651663,
-0.385971874,
-0.4504664242,
-0.7341219783,
0.3838485777,
0.0621041246,
-0.0877518803,
0.1641584933,
-0.6938483715,
0.2898813188,
1.0272680521,
0.4816766977,
0.1730162203,
-0.2597094774,
0.4806579053,
-0.0971697718,
-0.6661719084,
-0.7403194904,
0.8698117733,
0.0419264957,
0.9028311968,
0.0572167188,
0.920088172,
0.5975109935,
0.2506557405,
-0.7231331468,
0.4114991426,
0.1046727672,
-0.9291956425,
-0.4978165329,
-0.1497053653,
-1.2982274294,
-0.0431493744,
-0.3594061136,
-0.5798175931,
0.1885371953,
0.4500761628,
-0.3843984306,
0.1865238249,
-0.8115633726,
0.672064662,
-0.2130416334,
0.0398681127,
-0.4197408557,
-0.8729438782,
-0.0171796102,
0.0364118852,
0.2367136478,
-0.209012121,
-0.3308046758,
0.4296228588,
-0.3716347516,
1.2174117565,
-0.3687996566,
0.5505030155,
0.4390318394,
0.0181504209,
0.3572977185,
0.0492564067,
-0.0324072093,
0.0068753688,
-0.0782883987,
-0.2568639517,
-0.6221880317,
0.2857240438,
-0.5363919139,
-0.8318600655,
-0.1245936453,
-0.1750256419,
0.0001783421,
0.0679094195,
-0.1683128774,
0.0961338654,
-0.5350842476,
0.84808743,
0.2794103324,
0.2025579959,
0.2334149033,
0.2286060899,
0.0602975264,
-0.1966504306,
0.3981756866,
-0.238963902,
0.3271968365,
0.1886557341,
0.5054239631,
-0.2640858889,
-0.1968584359,
-0.3309937716,
-0.4784067571,
-0.4864171445,
-0.2023737729,
-0.2550517023,
0.052039735,
-0.1415453851,
-0.2560394406,
-0.3064495623,
-0.5940748453,
-0.2230987698,
0.2918356359,
0.3320100605,
0.6810643673,
-0.2207628638,
0.4432476461,
-0.5557860732,
0.3594706357,
0.6021880507,
0.1450052559,
-0.0469837151,
0.1469876319,
0.1468393058,
0.0301404931,
-0.4222458899,
-1.1886013746,
-0.259177804,
0.1560776383,
0.5174143314,
0.4735072255,
0.5529960394,
0.4571248591,
-0.3604780436,
1.1258636713,
0.2988370955,
-0.7325177789,
0.9352547526,
-0.1146876588,
0.1558362544,
0.8995246887,
0.1309890896,
-0.5473043323,
-0.5912232399,
-0.5496849418,
-0.8156608939,
0.4300572276,
0.6150557399,
0.9107947946,
0.0504458249,
0.0266570896,
0.1994330734,
0.5574862361,
-0.4437556863,
-0.3408646286,
-0.1827825755,
0.0100033423,
0.1941292137,
-0.0489223972,
-0.29753685,
0.0134456242,
0.1558288485,
-0.1140233502,
0.2309960723,
0.1566070616,
0.5027662516,
0.0371292904,
0.3822547495,
0.3440564573,
0.3137581348,
0.1107086316,
-0.1573116779,
-0.0304936934,
-0.351546675,
0.0502389893,
-0.4443570375,
0.0330336653,
-0.093033798,
-0.0561660342,
0.4146829844,
0.269215256,
-0.2029619962,
0.665887177,
-0.276214391,
0.0665006861,
-0.2875496745,
0.3653521538,
0.1944357902,
0.1176292375,
0.3767079413,
0.3649687469,
0.0113741923,
-0.7499170303,
0.2604486048,
0.7095329762,
-0.6393067837,
-0.2171837538,
0.8154947758,
0.9516413212,
-1.2577540874,
0.3410001099,
-0.017840866,
-0.5639127493,
0.4006968439,
0.3715770543,
0.7210675478,
-0.5146801472,
0.3021665514,
0.1352738738,
0.2966744602,
0.3627670407,
0.3473024666,
-0.5086128712,
-0.5955984592,
0.1125791967,
0.1880756021,
-0.9239986539,
-0.2123679072,
-0.2692896128,
0.2267977148,
-0.4969413877,
-0.6663064361,
-0.1908117235,
-0.2091498822,
-0.7958064079,
0.1092317402,
0.1038665771,
0.5843734145,
-0.6915182471,
0.1193484589,
0.5586948991,
-0.0331705771,
-0.4407099485,
0.0012081767,
0.1420709938,
-0.7324329615,
0.0221127383,
0.0479354262,
-0.2164298147,
-0.2553520799,
-0.6885439157,
-0.3916674554,
0.7254502177,
0.0825112537,
-0.5290879607,
0.0018231705,
0.2910315394,
0.3857086897,
-0.1689930707,
0.1754617393,
-0.1548055559,
0.3108904064,
0.1510314196,
-0.910888195,
-0.0995723009,
-0.1211461946,
-0.2086141109,
0.0107637532,
-0.7765514851,
0.6464176774,
-0.2493408471,
-0.3348331451,
0.284655422,
0.6175634861,
0.1397444755,
0.5276188254,
1.047965765,
-0.1799037308,
1.0365958214,
-0.1862134337,
0.7462821007,
-0.4571659863,
-0.0066061835,
0.6639537811,
0.0839807391,
0.946396172,
0.5918294191,
-0.0298045911,
0.5913174152,
0.2770309746,
0.5494215488,
0.2318788767,
0.1641045809,
-0.5476331115,
-0.7589608431,
-0.0980861112,
-0.2243794054,
0.7448861003,
0.2922677398,
-0.1266445816,
-0.1405421793,
-0.0084360605,
-0.0221539903,
0.1635502726,
-0.0621145889,
0.6682772636,
-0.0642554089,
-0.3834321499,
-0.2439375818,
-0.4218556285,
0.5569955111,
-0.5367137194,
-0.2006378621,
0.2527221739,
0.1103053391,
-0.2146645039,
-1.0169744492,
0.1117415279,
0.0153317498,
-0.0420174561,
-0.1072963923,
0.9616410136,
-0.0494005457,
-0.391572088,
-0.2523694932,
0.9041568637,
0.242506966,
-0.2524778545,
-0.7311874628,
-0.0269231163,
0.0200690608,
-0.2834230959,
-0.114561528,
0.151724413,
-0.0998175517,
0.829421699,
0.9695752859,
0.0683642328,
-0.2347783446,
-0.0056077843,
0.6546965241,
-0.5049755573,
-0.6133313179,
-0.5022697449,
1.0257991552,
-0.3442640901,
-0.5034726262,
0.7807211876,
0.5320774317,
0.4048883319,
-0.005624264,
0.781588614,
-0.3297623694,
0.6339517236,
0.1496784091,
0.8869075179,
-0.5295119286,
-0.1999025494,
-0.1287626177,
-0.4759093523,
-0.3881987333,
0.5579380989,
0.3076799214,
-0.1183844805,
0.019544689,
0.8420809507,
0.2340843529,
0.1763182133,
0.5117159486,
-0.4753282368,
0.3714747429,
0.55065763,
1.0239421129,
-0.1859914809,
0.8575685024,
-0.4110946357,
-0.4688671529,
-0.4702629745,
-0.6675405502,
-0.8980544209,
-0.7656118274,
-0.4413581192,
-0.2012510151,
0.0020776729,
0.6876700521,
1.0021336079,
-0.769015193,
-0.0552417226,
0.1155094504,
0.3645151258,
0.4249034524,
-0.2890376747,
0.0467662215,
-0.1659873873,
-0.9908000231,
0.1636936814,
0.1455047578,
0.1448854506,
-0.4321734309,
0.3883525431,
0.3962988555,
0.1800744534,
0.3907979727,
0.3141383529,
-0.5756806135,
-0.6231550574,
0.2221241295,
-0.1684361547,
0.0415781401,
0.8404561877,
-0.9720007777,
0.7740496993,
0.789988935,
0.1829854548,
0.0383946337,
0.3714118004,
0.5075893402,
-0.521830976,
0.3112873435,
0.6202648878,
-0.233757779,
0.3631100953,
-0.3167120218,
0.364759326,
-0.1006363332,
-0.7955559492,
-0.5772576928,
0.1411990672,
-0.966935873,
0.2249010652,
0.9693583846,
0.066527985,
0.095684506,
-0.6469993591,
-0.6495375037,
0.2151265293,
-0.7239906788,
0.8439051509,
0.371021688,
-0.3355885744,
0.0734571815,
-0.3454514444,
0.4435298145,
0.0876984447,
-0.6638712287,
-0.1689486802,
0.3143395782,
0.0493036695,
0.2921844721,
0.9447575212,
-0.1085609794,
0.6296241283,
0.0546537526,
-0.2873618603,
0.0786518902,
-0.3838621676,
-0.1616723537,
0.5969408751,
0.0193013493,
-0.6740401983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08322v1 | ReCo: Reliable Causal Chain Reasoning via Structural Causal Recurrent Neural Networks | 2022-12-16T07:48:02 | 2022-12-16T07:48:02 | Kai Xiong, Xiao Ding, Zhongyang Li, Li Du, Bing Qin, Yi Zheng, Baoxing Huai | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Causal chain reasoning (CCR) is an essential ability for many decision-making
AI systems, which requires the model to build reliable causal chains by
connecting causal pairs. However, CCR suffers from two main transitive
problems: threshold effect and scene drift. In other words, the causal pairs to
be spliced may have a conflicting threshold boundary or scenario. To address
these issues, we propose a novel Reliable Causal chain reasoning
framework~(ReCo), which introduces exogenous variables to represent the
threshold and scene factors of each causal pair within the causal chain, and
estimates the threshold and scene contradictions across exogenous variables via
structural causal recurrent neural networks~(SRNN). Experiments show that ReCo
outperforms a series of strong baselines on both Chinese and English CCR
datasets. Moreover, by injecting reliable causal chain knowledge distilled by
ReCo, BERT can achieve better performances on four downstream causal-related
tasks than BERT models enhanced by other kinds of knowledge. | [
-0.0310501456,
-0.8351458311,
0.5125387907,
0.2935133576,
-0.2611905634,
-0.0611651167,
0.0924490988,
-0.6146146059,
-0.1582281739,
0.5333941579,
-0.6193647385,
-0.1204725057,
-0.3791044056,
0.0021773491,
-0.3565297425,
0.9861873388,
0.1310839206,
0.1374729276,
-0.1208462119,
-0.0758628175,
-0.5609708428,
-0.22504282,
-0.9207448959,
-0.3841251433,
0.8191432357,
0.0048864069,
0.4055467844,
0.7143307328,
0.4887338281,
0.3035756946,
-0.1692728996,
0.4829283059,
-0.3256074488,
0.1974625885,
-0.3809483051,
-0.274818629,
-0.0464812666,
-0.5213499665,
0.7452628613,
0.4467151463,
-0.2913126945,
-0.2059706748,
0.2971808016,
0.8768637776,
-0.6035198569,
0.2053000778,
-0.7473217249,
-0.0042095962,
0.2369467914,
-0.0294100773,
-0.5714139342,
-0.3892811835,
0.1769621074,
-0.6082047224,
0.4600969553,
0.0197238699,
0.991502583,
0.5478218198,
-0.7310861945,
0.1739387661,
-0.6964107156,
0.5728676319,
-0.5046161413,
0.4790104032,
0.0238988046,
0.094047159,
-0.3675629497,
-0.9259958863,
-0.3704782426,
-0.3059369922,
-0.0610926002,
0.1214683652,
0.006281103,
-0.1072833836,
0.1355985701,
0.2598665953,
-0.2606275082,
-0.0754269883,
-0.2676133215,
-0.1906110644,
0.4095871449,
0.1568817794,
0.1701463312,
0.0466953889,
-0.705886662,
0.07565891,
-0.8098634481,
-0.0545795597,
0.1069039702,
0.4351697862,
0.0503373891,
0.0498471111,
0.142784521,
0.8253959417,
0.1841083616,
0.2338888049,
0.0564517528,
-0.486115396,
-0.2126840502,
-0.1324141622,
0.696749866,
0.2578123212,
-0.1457258612,
0.0370870158,
0.1150594205,
-0.2154828906,
0.2934546769,
-0.2481685728,
-0.0699999183,
0.1922417581,
-0.3896538019,
-0.2152011245,
-0.0657857507,
-0.5675923228,
-0.1756056696,
-0.2295431495,
0.2848240733,
-0.487201184,
-0.3001810014,
-0.1842670292,
-0.2453499138,
0.2195999324,
0.3573410809,
-0.4708997309,
-0.0930295214,
0.6149157882,
0.8546037078,
-0.002979639,
-0.4429925978,
-0.5816582441,
0.1802290827,
-0.3742938936,
0.6690181494,
-0.2526987791,
0.019638652,
0.0831525847,
0.1734534502,
-0.1329851151,
-0.2070188522,
0.3098607957,
-0.4505089819,
-0.089375861,
-0.3397138119,
-0.3171902895,
-0.159999758,
0.5021399856,
-0.8856518269,
0.9591853023,
-0.0166481659,
-0.6602137685,
0.5344849229,
0.0811871812,
-0.7376573682,
-0.1596929431,
-0.2429654449,
-0.4962067902,
-0.1331975907,
0.1911098063,
0.1957963407,
-0.2772786915,
0.7859063745,
-0.4153612256,
-0.0011828998,
0.2772488892,
-0.5725477934,
0.8298847079,
0.217333585,
-0.3360540271,
0.2537096143,
-0.8867108822,
-0.1411872804,
-0.1923066229,
-0.2901626229,
-0.4023861289,
0.3602784574,
-0.2313149869,
0.3845671117,
0.1281142384,
-0.4501028657,
-0.1822175086,
-0.2420350909,
0.6333817244,
0.9204152822,
0.3751415312,
0.0595752336,
-0.4528630078,
-0.0404363051,
0.1766540855,
0.1989348084,
-0.1269501895,
-0.574663043,
-0.6762663126,
-0.1027220488,
-0.193902269,
0.4449459314,
-0.9876487851,
0.5697538257,
0.0115930745,
-0.3098542094,
0.1702238023,
-0.1678546816,
0.5945878029,
0.8936156631,
0.2679902613,
-0.0804807991,
-0.5144469142,
-0.6847314835,
-0.1563920975,
-0.399643749,
-0.0244157705,
0.2814697623,
0.6466390491,
0.1081499904,
0.6839107275,
-0.3123072684,
-0.1948417276,
-0.2426472157,
0.1507653743,
0.1835778356,
0.8172847033,
0.1020352691,
-0.7083569169,
-0.1017078534,
0.132610783,
-0.7923336625,
0.3911277056,
-0.5565659404,
-0.3331555426,
0.1345846951,
0.4236417711,
-0.2156870961,
0.2664645314,
0.1222048998,
-0.2764832973,
0.4908606708,
-0.4277173877,
0.0766320378,
-0.9382630587,
0.2434592247,
0.3096871972,
-0.2102450579,
-0.4748194218,
0.2284265161,
-0.1067041457,
-0.0527232848,
-0.5241341591,
0.2089868486,
-0.1995587945,
0.1396521628,
0.0724387243,
-0.0470123291,
0.0923320204,
0.7921566963,
0.3479293883,
0.1382701546,
0.2726860344,
-0.8394833803,
0.2863807678,
0.3108914793,
-0.4859936833,
0.6211867332,
-0.8812675476,
0.0541645773,
-0.0086020408,
0.3311871886,
-1.1313465834,
0.0306282844,
0.1833810657,
-0.3681477308,
0.3849124908,
-0.1543923914,
-0.3635718524,
-0.1982185543,
0.0159970336,
0.4729032516,
0.0639497638,
-0.5397980213,
0.580794096,
0.2541584969,
0.4223622382,
-0.8911879659,
-0.7892551422,
-0.0893609747,
0.0325195938,
-0.623067677,
0.1049019247,
0.1569384634,
0.1538521647,
0.1421070546,
-0.3297767341,
-0.3732550442,
0.0776842237,
0.1873046607,
0.4328273833,
-0.0003252768,
0.1300062239,
0.0647033751,
-0.1972978562,
0.3359040916,
-0.4649475217,
0.0909482166,
-0.0526095182,
-0.2334395498,
-0.4087140858,
0.2469936758,
0.6756908894,
-0.1042024121,
0.7198181748,
0.2338494211,
-0.4304689467,
-0.2871339321,
-0.4521611333,
-0.0648219958,
-0.3535287082,
0.5123859644,
-0.3194172084,
-0.9925191998,
0.5469698906,
-0.0019924629,
0.0734727979,
0.3779143989,
0.3005550206,
0.1117175445,
0.9246174097,
0.4874503911,
-0.0828548372,
0.47996369,
-0.2350540906,
0.1046361774,
-0.8096556664,
-0.5777773857,
-0.3703838289,
-0.2004695982,
-0.4915420115,
-0.3190539479,
0.2877256274,
-0.0319175683,
-1.0409417152,
0.4103352726,
-0.7368974686,
0.2064379454,
0.7434025407,
0.4730032086,
0.2675009966,
0.1466082335,
-0.1240038276,
0.2996401489,
-0.920445621,
0.0295894407,
0.3650517166,
0.34216851,
0.7689691186,
-0.0839252695,
0.1827635914,
0.3279590905,
0.1084046662,
-0.2842746377,
0.4547877014,
-0.2164640278,
-1.0657012463,
-0.2742581964,
-0.6742084026,
-0.6680516005,
0.1305718422,
-0.1350615174,
-0.7124301195,
0.8702078462,
0.2405547351,
-0.3693473339,
0.5474306941,
-0.1706273109,
0.8216127157,
-0.2639350295,
-0.7267334461,
-0.2481608391,
-1.0589977503,
0.4923565984,
0.1916393638,
-0.1429740041,
0.0462740846,
0.1751414686,
0.6193977594,
-0.8846362233,
1.0086659193,
-0.0872453526,
0.0237914603,
0.7335749269,
0.0840264931,
0.712323606,
0.0125215258,
-0.0106360726,
0.6296143532,
-0.128351137,
-0.1216609254,
-0.6637535691,
0.5449884534,
-0.613701582,
-0.3689071238,
-0.5482794046,
-0.4384995997,
-0.0195577163,
0.2481096387,
0.4487986267,
0.3710168302,
0.0035161525,
0.1057209522,
0.4197053313,
-0.1754094809,
0.2642665505,
0.3413580954,
0.3125065267,
-0.9603298903,
0.8175605536,
-0.012598685,
0.4007183015,
0.6428151131,
0.1351258308,
-0.3012165129,
-0.1164721698,
-0.5341414213,
0.1705179662,
-0.4460261464,
-0.498768568,
-0.2229579687,
-0.5294511914,
0.1132685468,
-0.2740833461,
-0.5468546748,
-0.155644238,
0.0050248303,
-0.3598765731,
0.2174556404,
0.2807150483,
-0.4740586877,
-0.0875162184,
-0.8873171806,
0.1597044915,
0.3154089451,
0.2249994427,
0.4783484638,
-0.3611503839,
-0.3264844716,
0.2312469333,
-0.1171027943,
-0.6264175773,
0.1123649925,
-0.0222032424,
0.5569648743,
0.7510778308,
0.1771219522,
0.9169211984,
-0.632686913,
0.5661845803,
0.6334006786,
-1.0164365768,
0.7242099047,
-0.3588899374,
-0.0771862715,
0.5041160583,
0.3150022328,
-0.3442086577,
-0.6707802415,
-0.3433146477,
-1.0894058943,
0.6427526474,
0.3269820511,
-0.2487944216,
-0.5388906598,
0.4005766213,
0.0691209286,
0.0903548971,
-0.8590977788,
-0.4491295516,
-0.223366946,
0.0394264124,
0.5018007159,
-0.2467201948,
-0.1112936959,
-0.0200896282,
0.6680441499,
0.2419436425,
0.2738292813,
0.7704424858,
0.1174217984,
-0.31662637,
-0.0220378879,
0.481734544,
0.7683848143,
-0.2752919197,
0.2712487876,
0.1771145761,
-0.3152252734,
0.509154439,
0.016337784,
-0.364730984,
-0.1606164128,
0.6314299107,
0.5750672817,
0.3039638102,
-0.4495603144,
0.166827172,
0.0657583326,
-0.0452319644,
-0.3099044263,
0.0020957747,
-0.2843089104,
0.3370302022,
0.39496696,
0.2205071747,
-0.1515884697,
-0.5527807474,
0.6260718703,
0.1291873008,
-0.8337029219,
-0.0836221203,
0.8439326286,
0.4803046882,
-0.024968341,
1.0477080345,
0.052922897,
-0.4621757269,
1.0212398767,
0.8539898992,
0.7335110307,
-0.2982215285,
0.1463009566,
0.9267228842,
0.5364580154,
-0.4708892107,
-0.0000944833,
-0.0799038038,
-0.9820958972,
-0.6912689805,
-0.1031831875,
-0.1910436004,
0.0445956141,
-0.9019663334,
-0.0655004382,
-0.6481744647,
-0.0469870158,
-0.4377488792,
-0.390920192,
-0.272074312,
0.3647465706,
0.047645513,
0.8462432027,
-0.844917953,
0.5943778157,
0.3306689858,
-0.7154988647,
-0.8032428026,
-0.355312705,
-0.0877602696,
-0.7440935373,
0.8695734143,
0.1018869355,
-0.3336470127,
-0.2427065223,
-0.4908957779,
-0.9297206998,
1.0021495819,
0.1728326827,
-0.9244850874,
0.0965493694,
-0.3059305251,
0.3247403502,
-0.3183888495,
0.0027526072,
0.346812278,
0.2725116909,
0.4489105046,
-0.3636872172,
0.5673918724,
-0.3071162105,
-0.0714115053,
0.4037265778,
-0.7728232741,
0.5686548948,
-0.4417579472,
-0.3385421038,
0.2678429782,
0.9049268365,
0.5391349792,
0.7638827562,
0.7380137444,
0.7946123481,
0.71141994,
-0.1414690912,
0.8695434928,
-0.4293206632,
0.2733860016,
1.4765049219,
-0.3704481721,
0.7283688188,
0.1642908007,
-0.2104646564,
0.9998904467,
0.7046937346,
-0.1902174056,
0.7212629914,
0.0547224432,
-0.2915566266,
-0.5766690373,
-0.0252003912,
-0.4230495095,
-0.0479887053,
0.1092583686,
-0.365719676,
-0.0052172113,
-0.2941830456,
0.0399267189,
-0.1407343,
-0.3397401273,
0.483088553,
0.2639008164,
-0.7571802735,
0.1260237545,
-0.3432979286,
0.0495181605,
-0.7693671584,
-0.2004471868,
-0.3792051077,
0.2637070417,
-0.1506679356,
-0.5871028304,
0.4852111936,
-0.1339105815,
-0.3518073857,
0.154051289,
0.6861758828,
-0.4298774302,
-0.6612530947,
0.263037771,
0.249826774,
-0.1083989888,
0.0526022241,
-0.6200346351,
-0.2548517883,
0.0269669238,
0.2621846795,
-0.0078139808,
0.6508232355,
0.0615862235,
0.8416665196,
0.7940910459,
0.0318532884,
-0.2406396419,
0.0503307357,
0.7230830789,
-0.9187107682,
-0.5322434306,
-0.9507259727,
0.7572489381,
-0.146309793,
-0.2727873325,
0.6897996068,
0.4434634447,
0.5775386095,
0.0859918222,
0.4970771372,
-0.0522227958,
-0.0342539959,
-0.3437369764,
0.6933956742,
-0.4305775464,
0.3422622979,
-0.2122770697,
-0.6769442558,
-0.5473350286,
0.7224206924,
-0.1270637512,
0.039175462,
0.895848453,
0.6098287702,
0.243033722,
-0.1977911592,
0.0926117003,
0.3821836412,
0.2313512713,
1.040848732,
1.0812467337,
-0.4388209879,
0.7970379591,
-0.0622556433,
-0.0921524018,
0.0304674711,
-0.9654436707,
-0.7150794268,
-0.6443868279,
-0.6441029906,
-0.5757425427,
0.3917018473,
0.4007468522,
0.7575314641,
-0.6204764843,
-0.0847873464,
-0.7605983019,
0.9117350578,
-0.8245843649,
-0.2671302855,
0.5298470855,
-0.5501895547,
-0.2626181841,
0.1803778112,
0.4529168606,
-0.4501268268,
0.025568122,
0.015566336,
-0.4028585553,
-0.0728784427,
0.4762555957,
0.4243451059,
-0.56184268,
-0.570091188,
-0.2688217163,
0.1056837812,
-0.1574173272,
1.0291810036,
-0.7605056167,
0.3521482646,
0.7080823183,
0.5307654738,
0.3422385156,
-0.0499285273,
0.9102010727,
-0.589420259,
-0.1711999774,
-0.1337547004,
0.5978065729,
0.2321640998,
-0.5550323725,
0.6281995177,
0.4871330857,
-0.7227252126,
-0.6726073623,
0.2176174372,
-1.0223276615,
-0.4654533565,
0.9324232936,
-0.5084483027,
-0.3615938127,
-0.3142150044,
0.2920670211,
0.518193841,
-0.2141777128,
0.8649305701,
0.3096032441,
-0.2032239288,
-0.1763577014,
0.0831022188,
0.0638576671,
0.1916231811,
-0.4769113064,
0.0420072861,
0.5728986859,
0.2848598659,
0.1677738726,
0.3695009649,
-0.0303233098,
0.3556543291,
0.368301034,
-0.1295706183,
-0.4611730874,
-0.541893661,
-0.1410615742,
0.1545961499,
-0.3235815465,
-0.4696086645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08321v1 | Investigation of Japanese PnG BERT language model in text-to-speech synthesis for pitch accent language | 2022-12-16T07:47:03 | 2022-12-16T07:47:03 | Yusuke Yasuda, Tomoki Toda | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | End-to-end text-to-speech synthesis (TTS) can generate highly natural
synthetic speech from raw text. However, rendering the correct pitch accents is
still a challenging problem for end-to-end TTS. To tackle the challenge of
rendering correct pitch accent in Japanese end-to-end TTS, we adopt PnG~BERT, a
self-supervised pretrained model in the character and phoneme domain for TTS.
We investigate the effects of features captured by PnG~BERT on Japanese TTS by
modifying the fine-tuning condition to determine the conditions helpful
inferring pitch accents. We manipulate content of PnG~BERT features from being
text-oriented to speech-oriented by changing the number of fine-tuned layers
during TTS. In addition, we teach PnG~BERT pitch accent information by
fine-tuning with tone prediction as an additional downstream task. Our
experimental results show that the features of PnG~BERT captured by pretraining
contain information helpful inferring pitch accent, and PnG~BERT outperforms
baseline Tacotron on accent correctness in a listening test. | [
-0.612390697,
-0.8170535564,
0.3166491687,
0.3419569731,
-0.537515521,
0.2021329701,
-0.4108199477,
-0.412011534,
0.4611851871,
0.6667323709,
-0.6861589551,
-0.5550783873,
-0.2126819491,
0.2551864982,
-0.0492070094,
0.8436089158,
0.1718779355,
-0.0400598161,
0.6839675307,
0.3119607866,
-0.3492000103,
-0.6508666277,
-0.797049582,
-0.1986100078,
0.166103363,
0.6352424026,
0.677638948,
0.2668453157,
0.2054768056,
0.2089176476,
0.0030489659,
-0.0464863479,
-0.3437685668,
-0.0295669474,
0.1995715797,
-0.5893342495,
-0.4786922038,
-0.1170687899,
0.6592000723,
0.530788064,
0.1774950773,
-0.2024534345,
-0.0940207765,
0.402615428,
-0.1999175698,
0.1251159608,
-0.7633771896,
0.1492119133,
-0.2040463537,
-0.1572175771,
-0.5063580871,
-0.2221576571,
0.3494471014,
-0.7971574664,
0.6589619517,
0.0464305505,
0.9514725208,
0.3355928957,
-0.135734573,
-0.1089434549,
-0.4756480157,
0.4110590816,
-0.9307086468,
0.2767050862,
0.4064601362,
0.3032131493,
-0.3036001325,
-0.6441839933,
-0.6111747026,
-0.4048348963,
-0.0062357974,
0.3842363656,
0.3182289302,
0.5892330408,
0.1394271553,
0.4041318297,
-0.315036118,
0.3243176937,
-0.1065974608,
-0.4129630625,
0.5551338792,
-0.3451854587,
0.5002425909,
-0.5075546503,
-0.1140510887,
-0.4403778613,
-0.70040977,
0.1243348718,
0.5863132477,
0.7617747784,
-0.1016361788,
0.4240191579,
0.1125047505,
0.0731753707,
0.337960273,
0.065377444,
0.2104722857,
0.0127190324,
-0.023487635,
0.5900164247,
0.8532196283,
0.2354401052,
0.6323159337,
0.0708714277,
-0.1674454063,
-0.412522167,
0.2495298088,
-0.7285571098,
-0.3342860937,
-0.1236936748,
-0.4266951382,
-0.058996927,
-0.0156477708,
-0.632823348,
0.1018420309,
-0.2409265488,
0.6900836229,
-0.5926367044,
-0.57182163,
-0.1999149472,
-0.1226673052,
0.0031281738,
0.0739265308,
-0.9247882962,
-0.0561418496,
0.2871778607,
0.6326521039,
-0.0375609435,
-0.3782366216,
0.0335734859,
-0.0105530471,
-0.6871933341,
0.3278529346,
-0.3874524534,
-0.7434107661,
0.0710931867,
0.0593195111,
0.0755397528,
-0.4792362154,
0.5339514017,
-0.0731497556,
0.1095149592,
-0.1740341187,
-0.4283781648,
0.0248756688,
-0.4184202254,
-0.6738136411,
1.0980066061,
0.0932273567,
-0.4769826531,
0.4650790393,
-0.6179318428,
-0.8555694818,
-0.0023233213,
0.0629774779,
-0.696985364,
0.4158622324,
0.5542535782,
0.3927001953,
0.1557631344,
0.2772944868,
-0.268358022,
-0.513574481,
0.220307067,
-0.5214757919,
0.5207479596,
0.1665474474,
-0.5174332261,
-0.1007818431,
-0.9141256809,
0.1734880358,
0.2673169672,
-0.0175674092,
-0.2419177741,
-0.2541925013,
0.2328718901,
-0.0830834359,
0.2999891043,
-0.5078638792,
0.1180335879,
-0.4575313926,
0.4338878095,
0.4393334091,
0.2430070788,
0.1752638221,
-0.1178298518,
0.1975907981,
-0.313816458,
0.0845609531,
-0.6098871827,
-0.6374854445,
-0.7238531709,
-0.2953160703,
0.205820933,
0.2372591347,
-0.7939753532,
0.655118525,
0.1057057008,
-0.3220102787,
-0.818972528,
-0.5082629919,
0.4706412256,
0.425298214,
0.3617472947,
-0.5205519199,
-0.6180716753,
-0.8289294243,
-0.1331968009,
-0.4185659587,
-0.232958734,
0.3423305154,
0.0783573464,
0.2394517213,
0.9454900026,
-0.0590508059,
-0.2976918817,
-0.0310552008,
0.7960301638,
0.2872047424,
0.5718861222,
0.5340175629,
-0.5517770052,
-0.6441969275,
-0.0520043075,
-0.128624022,
-0.4905373454,
-0.2727800906,
0.0173868481,
0.2935669124,
0.4846972525,
-0.443610996,
0.1865126491,
0.2353074253,
-0.0474564582,
0.8288090825,
-0.3927990794,
0.5925703049,
-0.9706631899,
0.335827589,
-0.1570190936,
-0.1467502266,
-0.7783499956,
-0.1207674593,
-0.0344692506,
-0.4232569635,
-0.2238782197,
0.2381950319,
-0.2707273364,
-0.4922298491,
-0.4019534886,
-0.2697275281,
0.0198039357,
0.8210826516,
0.5333023667,
1.3628059626,
0.3670875728,
-0.440037787,
-0.1835929602,
0.2305208743,
-0.5048744678,
0.3054961562,
-0.6133666039,
0.5132520795,
0.0765837952,
0.1092135683,
-1.274694562,
-0.1472272277,
0.0228048842,
-0.766179502,
0.8133661151,
-0.4230489433,
-0.5191851258,
-0.207719937,
0.0270584635,
0.0929958597,
0.7492881417,
-0.6466476917,
0.3480965495,
0.2425536811,
-0.6443332434,
-0.2726100981,
-0.464409411,
0.1935859621,
-0.1501876414,
-0.2641619742,
0.7559075952,
0.2406989634,
0.3881827295,
-0.2933337092,
-0.0338134915,
-0.3035501242,
-0.0698788762,
-0.0961537138,
0.0208954271,
-0.4301351309,
-0.1891139001,
0.3512911201,
-0.0997983068,
0.0990212858,
-0.1055918857,
0.5959294438,
0.2476374209,
-0.2425657064,
-0.6741429567,
0.196583271,
0.8913491368,
-0.1165403277,
0.0821580067,
0.7150660157,
-0.0287986565,
-0.0921262503,
-0.578563869,
-0.4340940416,
-0.5064816475,
0.7542700171,
-0.5651628375,
-0.6594356298,
0.6120327711,
-0.1357929558,
-0.0705656707,
0.3986240327,
0.308385551,
-0.4682239592,
1.1560852528,
0.4983029664,
-0.1589514464,
0.7869989276,
-0.0696900338,
0.1544336677,
-0.8385519981,
0.0399964191,
-0.4537374377,
-0.0048147365,
-0.6772273183,
-0.1847895384,
0.5828289986,
-0.0501196086,
-0.2404137403,
0.4363071918,
-0.5544675589,
0.272010088,
0.6374712586,
0.2552376688,
0.0133146783,
0.1603292674,
-0.2171631008,
-0.4927151203,
-0.4682102501,
-0.2296833396,
1.0363783836,
0.4104053974,
0.6400945783,
-0.3699047863,
0.697108984,
0.2169150263,
-0.1965961903,
-0.5835642219,
0.4104455709,
-0.4198851585,
-0.6331785321,
-0.522994101,
-0.251198262,
-0.4204334021,
-0.0535480492,
-0.2681113183,
-0.5118416548,
-0.0833709463,
0.187624529,
-0.019539129,
0.0759299397,
-0.8482459188,
0.611962378,
-0.4607316256,
-0.0667816326,
-0.2863168716,
-0.8183142543,
-0.0803612843,
0.0025490168,
-0.0933898687,
-0.0624633208,
0.5387227535,
0.6433885098,
-0.2373500466,
1.0428010225,
-0.3271979392,
-0.2503699064,
0.3879942894,
0.060904447,
0.3975657523,
-0.0693908259,
0.0398092531,
0.3066442609,
-0.2370837331,
0.0506034307,
-0.4503841102,
0.2709804773,
-1.0237845182,
-0.5787103176,
0.0372571237,
-0.2794475257,
-0.447963506,
0.3146962821,
0.6461222172,
0.2708120346,
-0.2244987488,
-0.0437289365,
0.5921472311,
-0.3479037583,
0.326798141,
0.5203906298,
-0.1919919401,
-0.5088764429,
0.9527122974,
0.177463904,
0.3964530826,
0.4395215809,
0.2220968008,
-0.539957583,
-0.6297976971,
-0.476077646,
0.2762281597,
-0.5513573289,
0.2546970844,
-0.1911376417,
-0.3541436195,
-0.4539865851,
-0.139476344,
-0.7100585699,
-0.4063595533,
-0.2669586837,
0.1223703027,
0.2036325037,
0.3977475464,
0.066875428,
0.7447531819,
-0.6019082665,
0.4071267843,
0.1289283782,
0.41396451,
-0.1767720878,
-0.8314996362,
-0.1824522614,
0.1075752079,
0.0225079525,
-0.7553862333,
0.4547304809,
0.256296128,
0.4796741903,
0.2991342843,
0.057797242,
0.7377053499,
-0.6704842448,
0.7761008143,
0.2395511419,
-1.1194748878,
0.6770151854,
-0.4146670699,
0.3235633671,
0.5284757018,
0.2153504789,
-0.4117598534,
-0.7406446934,
-0.6323592663,
-0.7917796969,
0.7386059165,
0.4096758366,
0.0911016837,
0.0443951897,
0.4234864414,
0.2652828991,
0.2322430164,
-0.5515956283,
-0.1542936563,
-0.742616117,
-0.2159995139,
-0.0099038621,
-0.3529691994,
0.3314368427,
-0.0452026911,
0.8571190238,
-0.1945383251,
0.3944785297,
0.305182308,
0.0076216478,
-0.1844633967,
0.1989809126,
0.3223028481,
0.1688483208,
-0.4983956814,
-0.2538771331,
0.0694973022,
-0.5286592245,
-0.1552985013,
0.0391153097,
-0.1823005378,
0.4727309942,
0.2454099357,
1.1301047802,
0.3160114884,
-0.2081245184,
0.2756165862,
0.1946303993,
-0.0366621874,
-0.1927024424,
-0.0741882101,
-0.2406644523,
-0.217910096,
0.5535751581,
-0.3122816086,
0.1385169327,
-0.4530195892,
0.1021183953,
0.2621016204,
-0.1423636079,
-0.4473174214,
0.6043190956,
0.4823607802,
-0.3907729983,
0.5846169591,
0.1104486957,
-0.8584548831,
0.861739099,
0.9470077157,
0.9365432262,
-0.5939115286,
-0.0398888774,
0.5927246213,
0.2769620419,
0.1741594225,
0.2850964069,
-0.283018142,
-0.6269265413,
-0.5076054931,
-0.2724403739,
-0.7612060905,
0.2588052452,
-0.6706079245,
0.5143686533,
-0.5171099901,
-0.3664479554,
-0.1110534668,
-0.1866459697,
-0.2316675633,
0.5494590998,
0.4080924392,
0.3446462452,
-0.9157370925,
0.8379569054,
0.6386879683,
-0.4411029518,
-0.8311446309,
0.2974373698,
-0.3219871223,
-0.9826358557,
0.4678666294,
0.3399578333,
-0.1331020147,
0.2682472169,
-0.4228270054,
-0.7039809823,
0.4929950535,
0.3354263902,
-0.6020855904,
-0.1217675731,
0.6306436658,
0.5415667892,
-0.2513365149,
0.4672024548,
0.6554097533,
0.3298296034,
0.2034147978,
-1.4154677391,
-0.3265539408,
-0.2132275105,
0.2684972584,
0.0616082586,
-0.4791732132,
0.669441998,
0.0325464234,
-0.169949457,
0.0727479234,
0.6434337497,
0.0235679969,
-0.0725277737,
0.381753087,
0.2286053002,
0.4522205293,
-0.1739530712,
0.4634572268,
-0.5736533999,
0.2650709748,
0.9394666553,
-0.1892745495,
0.658280313,
0.3136996627,
-0.3094246686,
0.1635880172,
0.647017777,
0.1185563803,
0.7494587302,
-0.1381081939,
-0.0595726855,
-0.0092640575,
0.0054870681,
-0.3783819079,
0.4805499911,
0.584700048,
-0.2630097568,
0.1481305212,
0.1833829284,
-0.0347844176,
-0.0513063595,
-0.3305680454,
0.7595407963,
-0.1016204655,
-0.8643215895,
0.6467173696,
-0.2201834172,
0.8236811757,
-0.7219996452,
-0.1395579576,
-0.1942399144,
-0.1991958618,
0.0459753126,
-1.0436354876,
0.0967344493,
-0.0852970853,
-0.1700073332,
-0.1278118193,
0.5735421777,
-0.5012007952,
-0.2309442312,
-0.0103596505,
-0.2297907174,
0.2350684702,
-0.0752798691,
-0.4720626473,
-0.0854329243,
0.1108466461,
0.0035239421,
0.1626270115,
0.5745506883,
0.0855207667,
0.2768779993,
0.6690345407,
0.1785726994,
0.0745106936,
0.6362995505,
0.2864790559,
-0.5263205171,
-0.9744740725,
-0.4423813224,
0.3380753696,
0.055515077,
-0.3690748513,
0.3724601269,
0.2760975957,
0.7937677503,
-0.3342684805,
1.0601519346,
0.0463374332,
0.6357385516,
-0.9181278348,
0.9209343195,
-0.3334426284,
-0.2026897222,
-0.4381089509,
-0.8875588775,
-0.0185681935,
0.8167261481,
0.0237465594,
0.1400751621,
0.6175872087,
0.7282437086,
0.0690492988,
0.1122118384,
0.4228394032,
0.2497724146,
0.3561601043,
0.3161172569,
0.5608041883,
-0.1921542138,
0.3528901339,
-0.4756709635,
0.0070262975,
-0.3528847694,
-0.749311626,
-0.8912972212,
-0.7615491748,
-0.3316395283,
-0.0450132862,
0.2600812018,
1.0161596537,
0.7200484872,
-0.8422618508,
-0.2738288939,
-0.2192474604,
-0.3278269172,
-0.11468032,
-0.2542989552,
0.4969905615,
-0.6559489965,
-0.949824214,
0.4526121914,
0.2046798468,
0.3948739767,
0.0100728851,
0.0551261045,
0.2506432831,
-0.2025315315,
0.2919882536,
0.4924401641,
-0.792760551,
-0.3128434718,
-0.0412827171,
0.0043359608,
0.4858971536,
0.8405775428,
-0.5338141322,
0.8771330118,
0.1922916025,
0.5605886579,
0.786359489,
-0.0354988351,
0.789241612,
-1.1343635321,
0.3113770783,
0.1903080791,
0.4634902477,
0.4955919981,
-0.3987140954,
0.0655302107,
-0.0408133939,
-0.3465374708,
-0.5827023983,
0.0434877537,
-0.818757236,
-0.1063443124,
1.0129939318,
-0.1445414126,
-0.037978448,
-0.0185332168,
-0.7389397025,
0.7701649666,
-0.4581884146,
0.8600728512,
0.6178349257,
0.0726805851,
-0.3186946213,
-0.2196951956,
0.670809269,
0.8006133437,
-0.4933648407,
0.0595374443,
0.2359829247,
0.1905074269,
0.1204766408,
0.5333050489,
0.0286944956,
0.4693937302,
-0.1170176268,
0.350984633,
-0.1903465539,
-0.4894514084,
-0.103896223,
-0.2848931849,
0.3112584949,
-0.3486520648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08307v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08307v2 | Controllable Text Generation via Probability Density Estimation in the Latent Space | 2022-12-16T07:11:18 | 2023-05-24T10:02:31 | Yuxuan Gu, Xiaocheng Feng, Sicheng Ma, Lingyuan Zhang, Heng Gong, Weihong Zhong, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previous work on controllable text generation has explored the idea of
control from the latent space, such as optimizing a representation with
attribute-related classifiers or sampling a representation from relevant
discrete samples. However, they are not effective enough in modeling both the
latent space and the control, leaving controlled text with low quality and
diversity. In this work, we propose a novel control framework using probability
density estimation in the latent space. Our method utilizes an invertible
transformation function, the Normalizing Flow, that maps the complex
distributions in the latent space to simple Gaussian distributions in the prior
space. Thus, we can perform sophisticated and flexible control in the prior
space and feed the control effects back into the latent space owing to the
one-one-mapping property of invertible transformations. Experiments on
single-attribute controls and multi-attribute control reveal that our method
outperforms several strong baselines on attribute relevance and text quality
and achieves the SOTA. Further analysis of control strength adjustment
demonstrates the flexibility of our control strategy. | [
-0.0237298626,
-0.6436561346,
0.5113266706,
0.4597986042,
-0.3557779193,
-0.0313656181,
-0.0708435029,
0.1250456721,
0.3446904123,
0.6864491105,
-0.5408203006,
-0.413621515,
-0.6238452196,
-0.3096381724,
-0.4162690639,
1.2569032907,
-0.2878086865,
-0.3474302888,
-0.0582156628,
-0.0720364675,
-0.0499784984,
-0.3392691016,
-0.4419940412,
-0.1395574957,
0.6492633224,
0.2807272673,
1.0160306692,
0.2418437153,
0.527454257,
0.1537221819,
-0.1329763979,
0.0240687244,
-0.6488592029,
-0.046573706,
-0.1532631218,
-0.3179272711,
-0.4432570338,
0.0596884862,
1.1190087795,
0.6597815752,
-0.3578700721,
-0.3735693097,
0.2420278937,
0.5004338622,
-0.8077549338,
-0.33911255,
-0.4125654995,
0.2696056366,
-0.2774674594,
-0.5810020566,
-0.3131404519,
-0.5957379341,
-0.19802472,
-0.6180110574,
0.1123005524,
-0.1661847383,
0.9383334517,
0.4313229024,
-0.3797947168,
-0.2168247253,
-1.146561861,
0.8121089339,
-0.6800795794,
0.2314188033,
0.4721984863,
0.4476334155,
-0.3899802864,
-0.7154896855,
-0.9495332837,
0.1152237281,
-0.0142367817,
0.5856311321,
-0.0891101807,
-0.1894052476,
-0.1324009746,
0.0424612761,
-0.4106551111,
0.1828634143,
-0.1035009995,
-0.1760581434,
0.7918340564,
0.1279991865,
0.3031005859,
0.0455292948,
-0.4306150973,
-0.2824557424,
-0.5682249665,
0.2886920571,
0.5446442366,
0.0070612598,
-0.0734420717,
0.7184162736,
0.1146562323,
0.4829210639,
0.057091862,
-0.3738540411,
-0.0517796613,
-0.1819114983,
-0.3035004437,
-0.127957657,
0.8264535666,
0.1464364231,
-0.1973889619,
-0.0260399412,
-0.2940631807,
-0.1842358857,
0.2833616138,
-0.9371771216,
-0.1792854965,
0.1345653832,
-0.4757079482,
-0.5365633965,
0.3334209025,
-0.707921207,
-0.4763027728,
0.1828899384,
0.3649151921,
-0.4181252122,
-0.2639859021,
-0.0156881399,
-0.004270853,
-0.1155160144,
0.3262951374,
-0.9729778171,
0.20802176,
0.0987269431,
0.6976164579,
-0.6135593653,
0.1552707553,
-0.420262903,
0.5031733513,
-0.5953099728,
0.5545604825,
-0.5935621858,
-0.2016692758,
-0.0299322754,
-0.3744864464,
0.0901514441,
-0.3839612305,
0.2220094055,
-0.6907830238,
0.2564528584,
0.5327421427,
-0.4298473597,
0.1418860108,
-0.1860150248,
-0.8026456237,
0.7288473248,
0.3647635877,
-0.6722533107,
0.657948792,
-0.2248618901,
-0.4626257718,
-0.1554119885,
-0.4617592394,
-0.9166883826,
0.1215235069,
-0.2433970422,
0.7103897929,
0.0384935178,
0.2798541188,
-0.1720588952,
-0.0595745444,
0.4485727847,
-0.396707207,
0.4729059935,
0.4042420983,
-0.2773697376,
0.228528142,
-1.0747206211,
0.0200456902,
-0.1696143299,
-0.5047608614,
-0.2270358503,
0.2533937097,
0.2494820356,
0.1704528481,
0.0267011356,
-0.3150578439,
0.0884340703,
-0.2806688249,
0.0446505547,
0.5030884147,
0.3345962167,
1.1446063519,
-0.2272876799,
0.6763563156,
0.1726097763,
-0.2012080997,
0.3291485012,
-0.3945890069,
-0.3017834723,
-0.5733748674,
-0.0634425208,
0.4522815943,
-0.7253137827,
0.6023230553,
0.0565325134,
-0.6294136643,
0.0349088125,
0.1325512379,
0.0390120521,
0.3759225905,
0.3364952505,
-0.105741933,
0.1910647452,
-0.4640027881,
-0.0620332733,
0.261954993,
-0.3374401033,
0.2554430068,
0.099410139,
-0.067595385,
1.0493332148,
-0.6834622025,
-0.5073389411,
-0.3153376579,
0.318149507,
0.193822816,
0.8695670366,
0.6850149632,
-1.0907033682,
-0.5254256725,
0.0185155813,
-0.3912419975,
-0.2410116047,
-0.6777793765,
-0.4157579541,
0.2342634946,
0.4311624169,
-0.1514843553,
0.9068133235,
0.8297965527,
-0.7523881197,
0.4474082887,
-0.4705055654,
0.0130561804,
-0.9232250452,
0.0466555506,
-0.1120678633,
-0.1797169298,
-0.5190499425,
-0.1383666843,
0.2572699189,
-0.1975027323,
-0.1648442447,
0.293659538,
-0.1527853906,
0.2389909625,
-0.2762204111,
-0.1176417619,
-0.058387205,
0.4819978774,
0.1072894782,
0.5929182172,
0.3203496635,
-0.8428868651,
-0.1325438321,
0.106336318,
-0.2132857442,
0.6295195222,
-0.6006016135,
-0.2388425767,
-0.4891031086,
0.293571651,
-1.1482645273,
-0.2068205923,
0.1385610402,
-0.1556757092,
0.4657834172,
0.4001116753,
-0.454405278,
0.2522170246,
0.1154103354,
-0.0355922766,
0.5297380686,
-0.1629352719,
0.6933295727,
0.2124647647,
-0.3260519207,
-0.0907353088,
-0.8082292676,
-0.369100064,
-0.1521697342,
-0.580971837,
0.7424744368,
-0.3168640733,
-0.0469660051,
-0.0625759885,
-0.117222704,
-0.5238426328,
-0.0145635484,
0.1878426373,
-0.0268912669,
0.0490275733,
0.3906683922,
0.9219884276,
-0.1220556125,
-0.3289654255,
-0.2683939934,
0.3645835817,
0.7938271165,
-0.0825384855,
-0.4713429511,
0.4509139359,
0.1896811128,
-0.1863113046,
0.8247554898,
0.3939648271,
-0.2892125547,
-0.5464951396,
-0.1094073355,
-0.1589423418,
-0.4170066118,
0.3723039627,
-0.3895645738,
-0.9530501366,
0.5663392544,
0.0353447609,
-0.0365308337,
0.5501491427,
0.4449810386,
-0.4908507764,
1.0598986149,
1.0240377188,
0.3787951171,
0.7129643559,
-0.2828372121,
-0.0381240174,
-0.1730095893,
-0.1084977537,
-0.5249373317,
-0.7446228862,
-0.6468603611,
-0.492474556,
0.5716223717,
0.5027706623,
-0.2874650359,
0.0373741351,
-0.4685869217,
0.1908166707,
0.1805991679,
0.1573923677,
0.3313935697,
0.1535717845,
-0.1373586506,
-0.3705420494,
-0.6670110226,
-0.6583862305,
0.8490680456,
0.1909467876,
1.0718011856,
0.3782140315,
0.6526870728,
0.0212293901,
0.4460472465,
-0.0669845417,
0.1549009681,
-0.49532184,
-0.3727180064,
-0.6164955497,
-0.5890675187,
-0.7288916707,
0.0583004542,
-0.5278106928,
-0.7909497023,
0.4063941836,
0.2059958428,
-0.3650999963,
0.3936228156,
-0.5694134831,
0.5664542913,
0.0151116904,
-0.5067087412,
-0.2457571626,
-0.4763019681,
-0.0485975333,
-0.369278729,
-0.0673566312,
-0.0540224165,
-0.2684497535,
0.6034370661,
-0.5339022875,
0.7235940695,
-0.2479910403,
-0.2843743265,
0.328071475,
0.2828870714,
0.6346812248,
0.3010222018,
-0.0719229877,
-0.1700986624,
-0.2778072059,
-0.5755311847,
-0.8226649165,
0.5460159183,
-0.8171946406,
0.055838462,
-0.0654751807,
-0.4777805209,
0.0387693569,
0.5137677193,
0.6635833979,
0.2189865112,
-0.1908586472,
0.2875392735,
0.7137141824,
-0.3144221008,
0.6178752184,
0.216412127,
-0.0901495069,
-0.3149414361,
1.0085691214,
0.4846392572,
0.3982178271,
0.9293455482,
0.4632559717,
-0.2492199391,
-0.4403116703,
-0.2351302207,
-0.2044482976,
-0.3555241525,
-0.113801606,
-0.7258774638,
-0.1437277943,
-0.3733347952,
-0.5278427005,
-0.1736248881,
-0.546310246,
-0.7066135406,
0.0180998817,
0.0577235073,
0.6571290493,
0.1094265804,
0.8311569691,
-0.3792219758,
0.3333651721,
0.4115703106,
0.5031616092,
-0.3618392944,
-0.4236408472,
0.0204191394,
-0.2261950225,
-0.643897295,
-1.239682436,
0.6618434787,
0.3345706463,
0.3219555318,
0.5047687888,
0.0344796143,
0.1402693391,
-0.1948553473,
0.5462155342,
0.3361068666,
-0.8127860427,
0.6552811861,
-0.2709798813,
0.2706433535,
0.2390792221,
0.4709399939,
-0.043360889,
-0.86038661,
-0.7588719726,
-0.6061840653,
0.4227612317,
0.6373283267,
0.2684677541,
0.4350307882,
0.250330925,
0.2741526663,
0.4784044921,
-0.6677874327,
-0.1775950938,
-0.6591377854,
-0.379521668,
-0.302387327,
-0.1968404502,
0.0379575603,
0.0729573146,
0.457919836,
-0.2253071368,
0.1775873303,
0.3187396228,
0.1515801102,
-0.2390642762,
0.2794483304,
0.7482527494,
0.5521683693,
-0.1800765693,
0.3899878561,
-0.255035609,
-0.7115077376,
0.1602702588,
0.224473536,
-0.5485790372,
0.0148435449,
0.0426199511,
0.6835751534,
-0.0283004288,
-0.2125650495,
0.4976384938,
0.2223226428,
-0.1505534351,
-0.0064567979,
0.2922227979,
-0.1808448583,
0.0189469457,
0.5604972243,
0.3287287056,
0.074399583,
0.0640498921,
0.2381512225,
0.1869116873,
-0.6131061912,
-0.2432420999,
0.9824030399,
-0.0426898263,
-0.0147568742,
0.1541582048,
-0.3238503635,
0.0695078,
0.4986429513,
0.8391450047,
0.6712149978,
-0.0259822011,
0.38758111,
0.3700500429,
0.2746429145,
0.4005790651,
0.5174893737,
0.0106985895,
-1.1657911539,
-0.3549330235,
-0.5584833622,
-0.10562215,
-0.083190158,
-0.2333930582,
0.097436659,
-1.0432710648,
-0.1875356287,
-0.0013732807,
-0.0535333976,
-0.434997946,
0.5279594064,
-0.2471885085,
0.7850220799,
-0.9541938305,
0.7132642269,
0.726156354,
-0.6258812547,
-1.0071411133,
0.1008740142,
-0.2917363346,
-0.180112794,
0.3739694357,
-0.3103473186,
0.0490221828,
0.3307608962,
-1.0302935839,
-0.7838338017,
1.1585783958,
0.2004071772,
-0.2871187627,
0.2901399434,
-0.0747567564,
0.5893530846,
-0.4258894026,
-0.0569699854,
0.293805927,
0.5272593498,
0.1580630392,
-0.4597104192,
0.0491543636,
-0.1634054482,
0.2950752676,
0.1865894794,
-0.421146065,
0.7815567851,
-0.0426913127,
-0.4267010093,
-0.1378723681,
1.1446224451,
0.4371590912,
0.1254941821,
0.4341575205,
0.26187253,
0.7926478982,
-0.0531556383,
0.984872818,
0.1748499423,
0.1672804803,
0.9435235858,
-0.1737653315,
0.7719973326,
0.7400957942,
-0.0680067167,
0.7240962982,
0.0700009391,
0.4181345105,
0.7699263692,
0.2793532014,
-0.2978028059,
-0.0274272691,
0.0251214709,
-0.0810447857,
0.258069694,
0.3473766148,
-0.2925186753,
0.0109668979,
0.1518624723,
0.0449064001,
0.5359177589,
-0.0621814728,
0.6911023855,
-0.3130505979,
-0.4452188909,
0.2808235288,
0.1936695725,
0.6773595214,
-0.8149104714,
-0.0515814722,
-0.3103213906,
0.1003878862,
-0.335888505,
-0.9320669174,
0.3777307868,
-0.2139723599,
-0.3360818923,
-0.6708034277,
0.7583831549,
-0.6315563917,
-0.4115030468,
-0.2778425515,
-0.0110217398,
0.0236004088,
0.0326024406,
-0.1348259449,
-0.2140318602,
-0.0771541372,
-0.4372575283,
0.1829456687,
0.6765742898,
-0.3677432537,
0.4658799171,
0.6074740291,
0.5456264615,
0.2538134158,
-0.1594372243,
0.7653138638,
-0.4646078348,
-1.1830490828,
-0.3098818362,
0.7442296743,
-0.1883906424,
-0.656267643,
0.3701721728,
0.2360855788,
0.6228703856,
-0.0292889923,
0.8201130629,
-0.4218921959,
0.4570623338,
-0.5869650245,
1.4914720058,
-0.7823365331,
-0.3038055301,
-0.5210729837,
-0.8627292514,
-0.6899008155,
0.7797324657,
0.086403802,
-0.1704310179,
0.6643188596,
0.8503873348,
-0.0236553606,
-0.3351298869,
0.5104150772,
0.1410351992,
0.6425034404,
0.2928414643,
0.4656546116,
-0.2290887982,
0.3863152564,
-0.3080582917,
-0.6716548204,
-0.0235502869,
-1.2093821764,
-0.407751292,
-0.6336903572,
-0.2908713222,
-0.424507767,
-0.4922841489,
0.4143855572,
0.6979045868,
-0.9211307764,
-0.054999914,
-0.3914443254,
0.3201334476,
-0.5199414492,
-0.2526017129,
0.5657964349,
-0.179967925,
-0.6530355215,
0.1477756053,
0.5633625984,
0.4499836862,
-0.3312742412,
-0.4049777389,
-0.023757346,
0.1343888938,
0.3365146816,
0.2070910931,
-0.1857444495,
-0.0924550891,
-0.132383883,
-0.8195969462,
-0.2260682881,
0.8830910325,
-0.506790638,
0.6233485937,
0.9383253455,
0.4847762287,
0.4800765216,
-0.2549192905,
0.6773195267,
-1.1860494614,
0.4022816718,
0.4612057209,
-0.14150922,
-0.0560666248,
-0.5047122836,
0.2796112597,
0.1777009517,
-0.4864310026,
-0.3163925111,
0.1605434418,
-1.0625969172,
-0.1910675019,
0.9416030049,
-0.0057470552,
-0.1196908876,
0.2391089201,
-0.3124498129,
0.391648531,
-0.3458651006,
0.6005690098,
0.2724585235,
-0.1419129372,
-0.0890698805,
-0.288702935,
0.6751967669,
0.4086080492,
-0.8771885037,
-0.5069909096,
0.4655072689,
-0.1096550673,
0.2511339188,
1.0988166332,
-0.1390284151,
0.0793106928,
-0.3117094338,
0.1795868576,
0.3483995497,
-0.6232110858,
-0.2242047489,
0.3836085498,
-0.2594449818,
0.1736551374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08287v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08287v1 | Rich Event Modeling for Script Event Prediction | 2022-12-16T05:17:59 | 2022-12-16T05:17:59 | Long Bai, Saiping Guan, Zixuan Li, Jiafeng Guo, Xiaolong Jin, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Script is a kind of structured knowledge extracted from texts, which contains
a sequence of events. Based on such knowledge, script event prediction aims to
predict the subsequent event. To do so, two aspects should be considered for
events, namely, event description (i.e., what the events should contain) and
event encoding (i.e., how they should be encoded). Most existing methods
describe an event by a verb together with only a few core arguments (i.e.,
subject, object, and indirect object), which are not precise. In addition,
existing event encoders are limited to a fixed number of arguments, which are
not flexible to deal with extra information. Thus, in this paper, we propose
the Rich Event Prediction (REP) framework for script event prediction.
Fundamentally, it is based on the proposed rich event description, which
enriches the existing ones with three kinds of important information, namely,
the senses of verbs, extra semantic roles, and types of participants. REP
contains an event extractor to extract such information from texts. Based on
the extracted rich information, a predictor then selects the most probable
subsequent event. The core component of the predictor is a transformer-based
event encoder to flexibly deal with an arbitrary number of arguments.
Experimental results on the widely used Gigaword Corpus show the effectiveness
of the proposed framework. | [
-0.1982150227,
-0.4570145607,
0.4411173761,
-0.0446455516,
-0.2726729214,
-0.0517238155,
-0.3116296232,
-0.6496948004,
0.2141982168,
0.6191420555,
-0.6926056147,
-0.307933569,
-0.6378226876,
-0.0950504169,
-0.5546722412,
1.2091481686,
-0.0715984479,
0.0282340273,
-0.0402448662,
0.2683049142,
-0.3319532275,
-0.5193228126,
-0.3104186654,
-0.219504416,
0.5084207654,
0.3941991329,
0.6478831172,
0.9175232053,
0.6804026365,
0.1815889776,
0.1935258359,
-0.1229043603,
-0.4654769897,
0.2369245142,
-0.2258986831,
-0.4153220356,
-0.2419392616,
-0.1471294463,
0.3899005353,
0.6217573881,
-0.0182253551,
-0.0412551425,
-0.2273963094,
-0.1668032706,
-0.6046263576,
0.0614598356,
-0.7590306401,
0.1013416946,
-0.1610170603,
-0.1488840878,
-0.3475598991,
0.0550250001,
0.2051745951,
-0.2222044021,
0.4954942763,
-0.0916527435,
0.9138408899,
-0.0791437775,
-0.165209353,
0.0202881228,
-0.9349250793,
1.0165737867,
-0.6282322407,
0.2734875083,
0.5373858213,
0.5909797549,
-0.1726452857,
-1.0613691807,
-0.9102286696,
0.0847555995,
-0.0473164469,
0.1137994975,
0.0095089898,
0.1568014771,
0.0595464297,
0.2283890843,
-0.5674911141,
0.2421428859,
0.0076145716,
-0.2879954875,
0.658267498,
0.4640238881,
0.14548181,
-0.3235100508,
-0.4569452107,
-0.07731013,
-0.2855168879,
-0.2500342131,
0.4255708754,
0.1935197264,
-0.2274972349,
0.7399593592,
-0.3660902083,
0.4985613525,
0.052926261,
-0.2067542225,
-0.1371641308,
-0.3408074975,
-0.2156006694,
0.0669147,
0.6661666632,
0.4010360241,
0.4695088863,
-0.2005253136,
-0.1906694025,
0.2270935029,
0.0590779148,
-1.1607772112,
-0.0883696601,
0.448734045,
-0.5453394651,
-0.1515116692,
0.2825152576,
-1.2619533539,
-0.6738055944,
-0.1904079169,
0.2207836211,
-0.6075569987,
-0.1351843476,
0.1788717061,
-0.205940932,
0.4621516168,
0.5234575868,
-0.8131076694,
0.1103151813,
0.7065156102,
0.3682256639,
-0.27274701,
-0.5540325046,
-0.8471902609,
0.4266661406,
0.2569170594,
0.9063697457,
-0.9884063601,
-0.2324405611,
0.2440221906,
0.2144962996,
-0.0195242278,
0.0538854748,
0.5611620545,
-0.7600761652,
0.2825917304,
0.5330622196,
-0.7627571821,
-0.0312474184,
0.0395639613,
-0.7847980261,
0.5502050519,
0.1777074635,
-0.6445406675,
0.5917508602,
-0.2616729736,
-0.5766402483,
0.0689710453,
-0.0939721987,
-0.6006042957,
-0.060744714,
0.259693414,
0.72245121,
-0.1697062403,
0.3922290504,
-0.4262872934,
-0.2577698231,
0.5676380992,
-0.2210640162,
-0.024482822,
0.1105767861,
-0.2195634693,
0.4417423606,
-1.0212168694,
-0.1601253152,
0.0035143038,
-0.0520498492,
0.1528843939,
0.0952118561,
0.4086031318,
0.2236072421,
0.15183568,
-0.5299911499,
0.2240095735,
-0.6108785272,
0.0665406361,
0.5901882052,
0.235384047,
0.6345478892,
0.1147172898,
0.6300125718,
-0.0362294763,
0.2330409139,
-0.4923215806,
-0.4080354273,
-0.4387898743,
-0.2002520412,
0.1856712103,
0.3658840656,
-0.4515754879,
0.4960108399,
-0.1805150211,
-0.5271360278,
-0.1807652712,
-0.2006669492,
0.0965157822,
0.1924687028,
0.3207968771,
0.0739208981,
-1.2263997793,
-0.4859730303,
-0.3513867855,
-0.0133629218,
-0.0882461742,
-0.0738291144,
0.5232858658,
-0.6404438615,
0.8945697546,
-0.4239856005,
-0.304361701,
-0.9076249599,
-0.0252866112,
0.2273577154,
0.3907130659,
0.117817685,
-0.6680185199,
-0.29374668,
0.3581039906,
-0.2501510382,
0.2240817845,
-0.3475362659,
-0.0519461595,
0.0874422565,
0.077011466,
-0.5115730762,
0.709185183,
0.5826773047,
-0.4908868074,
0.601903379,
0.1596086472,
-0.0711127222,
-1.330527544,
-0.2688392997,
-0.164522633,
-0.1399618089,
-0.6024246216,
-0.2882393003,
0.0807311386,
-0.324053973,
-0.2586478889,
0.8087922931,
-0.0444431491,
-0.2380642295,
-0.493160814,
0.1138817891,
0.2323076427,
0.3559131622,
0.3152309656,
0.4178848863,
0.5981743336,
-0.4270044863,
0.4175491035,
0.2097579241,
-0.4719994366,
0.2018368393,
-0.5653350949,
-0.0918958709,
0.0561722182,
0.3731112778,
-0.8725146055,
-0.7577095628,
-0.3912065625,
-0.6224502325,
0.3213905096,
-0.38976565,
-0.3767070472,
-0.3166471422,
-0.0560347252,
0.0052158255,
0.3008520305,
-0.3700987995,
1.0333485603,
0.3113576472,
-0.0754386708,
-0.6915507913,
-0.651350975,
0.0976231024,
-0.0868932456,
-0.6511887312,
0.4493373334,
0.3570725918,
-0.0540333316,
0.0607118458,
-0.0369818248,
-0.2877751291,
-0.1916617006,
0.4552772343,
0.5760551095,
-0.1943891644,
0.1283263117,
-0.1426498592,
-0.3820224106,
-0.2807420492,
-0.4539650679,
0.7310058475,
-0.0058830804,
-0.4185017645,
-0.7353315949,
0.5344460607,
0.6096756458,
-0.4057385325,
0.9366558194,
1.0021533966,
-0.5712056756,
-0.193831265,
-0.5145564675,
-0.4333174229,
-0.2975994647,
0.4829801321,
-0.237333551,
-0.7191671729,
0.914245069,
-0.082819432,
-0.2805622518,
0.5898575187,
0.6076487303,
0.0458237194,
1.2807600498,
0.4834251702,
0.235655427,
0.7594850659,
-0.4529494047,
0.0186345968,
-0.6215322018,
-0.3316434026,
-0.4961232245,
-0.2595616877,
-0.2183826119,
-0.500511229,
-0.1576651931,
0.1937455237,
-0.2167855948,
0.6927425265,
-0.0813416168,
0.390451014,
0.2877643108,
-0.5251543522,
0.0412153564,
-0.2385698259,
0.0414574668,
-0.0723679736,
-0.573266685,
-0.6121361256,
0.9856427312,
0.1861742437,
1.0891934633,
-0.1335483193,
0.6487975121,
0.185346812,
-0.0110409576,
-0.6563327312,
0.3281863332,
0.1300026625,
-0.5051819086,
-0.3636044264,
-0.1749851555,
-1.0196236372,
-0.0217289142,
-0.2785015106,
-0.8568321466,
0.4561788738,
-0.4548436105,
-0.4234439135,
0.2352209091,
-0.6707239747,
0.9591047764,
-0.1017673761,
-0.4799681008,
-0.2239738256,
-0.7299466133,
-0.0302064903,
0.1112067625,
0.0740863383,
-0.1645099819,
0.0442921743,
0.8393778801,
-0.226679787,
0.9004707932,
0.0450654514,
0.3564482927,
0.4774318337,
0.2362587005,
1.1143556833,
0.3452652693,
-0.448432982,
-0.1003832296,
0.0949693322,
-0.2219685316,
-0.5826882124,
0.5681904554,
-0.9035006762,
-0.0364477485,
-0.0348549597,
-0.221621573,
-0.0910517499,
0.0995627418,
0.2582538426,
0.8924117684,
-0.2311449051,
0.1878426224,
0.4113007784,
-0.2365608513,
0.6009096503,
0.5580867529,
-0.1540730745,
-0.7571870089,
0.7255300879,
-0.2241743952,
0.1415612251,
0.5398204923,
0.2069142759,
-0.3609299064,
-0.6194013953,
-0.56913656,
-0.0304606408,
-0.8185623288,
-0.59601897,
-1.175257802,
-0.0308476705,
-0.5679850578,
-0.6204821467,
-0.4324068129,
-0.5145457983,
-0.4806230664,
-0.4121440351,
0.4522481561,
0.3559601009,
0.1456896812,
0.4886152744,
-0.7876185775,
0.4033227563,
0.0799436495,
0.7316142917,
-0.1503124684,
-0.4939179122,
-0.5358111262,
-0.2739717364,
-0.066118598,
-0.8245293498,
0.7548474669,
0.231498003,
0.6959692836,
0.5992064476,
0.2376986295,
0.680449605,
-0.1699266881,
0.883728683,
0.2187760025,
-0.7199286222,
1.0590445995,
-0.3839292526,
-0.0398655981,
0.3844709694,
0.0887243226,
-0.5089622736,
-0.3512222767,
-0.9610735774,
-0.6928556561,
0.9504584074,
0.0470171683,
0.1766530722,
-0.2837855518,
0.0101354904,
0.7304244041,
0.0101341736,
-0.5983765125,
0.1779302061,
-0.4186691344,
-0.1863519251,
0.1675786823,
-0.2917195857,
0.1274270713,
0.1347556561,
0.229634881,
-0.1994735152,
0.2625633478,
0.1727069467,
-0.168986246,
-0.3589430153,
0.3750857115,
0.4930968285,
0.4985026419,
-0.3498793244,
0.1956010014,
0.2475357801,
-0.3898002803,
-0.3326963782,
0.2792023122,
0.4133634865,
-0.0505118482,
0.8852943182,
1.0815743208,
0.2742803693,
-0.9698444009,
0.5893921852,
0.0432490073,
0.2204216719,
-0.3676920831,
0.1416255981,
-0.254217416,
0.2573953867,
0.3655964732,
0.0244458336,
0.0855424553,
-0.691663146,
0.535676837,
0.0140007352,
-0.7577196956,
-0.5265207291,
0.6899588704,
0.3558098674,
-0.2568853498,
0.2776702344,
-0.066012308,
-0.5325649977,
0.8044644594,
0.7202581167,
0.9829176068,
-0.1271394938,
-0.0377822556,
0.4457959533,
-0.0197318271,
0.2284659594,
0.3643517196,
0.2979792058,
-0.7466396093,
-0.8011509776,
-1.0177774429,
-0.4504294693,
-0.0374373682,
-0.3634423018,
0.5922537446,
-0.182596609,
-0.023818193,
-0.1362725943,
0.188027665,
-0.8830233812,
0.1632345915,
0.2488494813,
0.8071562052,
-0.4929905236,
0.9214304686,
0.5435429811,
-0.537314117,
-0.7573939562,
-0.0731066987,
-0.2850495279,
-0.5941014886,
0.3160575628,
0.1791899502,
0.1894272417,
-0.019269323,
-0.0939640403,
-0.8778199553,
0.9309545159,
0.1584510207,
-0.4649473131,
0.1931138486,
-0.0109246271,
0.4991485476,
-0.7456539869,
0.3215479255,
0.3637433946,
0.6152287126,
0.4028449357,
-0.7604045868,
-0.122000277,
-0.0014230459,
0.0266568642,
0.0973487198,
-0.0320824012,
0.735568583,
-0.588514924,
-0.3989385068,
0.0570308939,
0.9077426195,
-0.1539952457,
0.5648076534,
-0.0811477005,
0.0866755471,
0.5562726259,
-0.0349855535,
1.5411795378,
-0.2755781412,
0.3129009306,
1.0248259306,
-0.6681451201,
0.7311260104,
0.1468742937,
-0.0934770554,
0.7717527747,
0.3748063147,
0.0105851069,
0.5161110759,
-0.0798649639,
-0.1713926345,
-0.3597185314,
-0.114778325,
-0.3985411823,
0.7898560762,
0.4215034246,
-0.4521811604,
-0.1908345371,
0.284137845,
-0.2706674635,
0.0117417155,
-0.3363541663,
1.061942935,
-0.3859949112,
-0.5887134671,
0.0198615734,
0.2794914842,
0.3562577963,
-0.7787570953,
-0.024602009,
-0.0107029583,
0.4288806915,
-0.149963662,
-1.1637548208,
0.4638005793,
-0.0553222522,
-0.2523088157,
-0.0637338385,
1.3889147043,
-0.3889321089,
-0.3063996434,
0.34981215,
0.5264394283,
-0.1582103223,
-0.1478813142,
-0.1178143695,
0.2623155415,
-0.2604150772,
-0.4008612931,
0.5012341142,
0.8023158908,
0.0097708572,
0.5312385559,
0.6891446114,
0.0319610536,
0.1045116037,
0.3706541359,
0.803774178,
-0.9208203554,
-0.6110137701,
-0.8208087683,
0.6338098049,
-0.3151830137,
-0.2957085967,
0.4815722108,
0.5333932042,
0.4312006831,
-0.2729280889,
0.7908786535,
0.1525763571,
0.3913374841,
-0.2103782594,
0.3994489014,
0.0375882722,
0.0023717124,
-0.2001236826,
-0.7899534106,
-0.4222841859,
0.3566500843,
-0.2244096696,
-0.1925920844,
0.5499972701,
0.6590406895,
0.1110877171,
0.332994014,
0.5233715773,
-0.2057827264,
0.2211631984,
0.356715709,
1.0711946487,
-0.287707448,
0.7241510153,
-0.022442963,
-0.080017969,
-0.7937167287,
-0.8240542412,
-0.7445479631,
-0.6814110875,
-0.1955576241,
-0.4374209642,
-0.1199425161,
0.9934428334,
0.7818837762,
-1.0215429068,
0.0230302326,
-0.071840547,
0.2901902199,
-0.3628380299,
-0.2630630434,
0.3630771935,
-0.2487483919,
-0.6520689726,
0.3928581476,
0.3904782534,
-0.0009912121,
0.0067066923,
-0.0883561671,
-0.0294127073,
0.2016744763,
0.7806411386,
0.0257088505,
-0.6399011016,
-0.5665693879,
0.0072405217,
-0.2009565085,
-0.3573546708,
0.7798053622,
-1.0760308504,
0.3032301664,
0.4473505914,
0.6854971647,
0.5665927529,
-0.402222693,
0.7738438845,
-0.7159990668,
0.1021488607,
0.5397992134,
0.5690037608,
0.0926672146,
-0.4963154793,
0.5250501037,
0.2418277115,
-0.3670360744,
-0.8139446974,
0.4683393836,
-1.3201235533,
-0.0924490541,
1.4663197994,
0.1191198975,
-0.0582612678,
-0.3176037967,
-0.2987322807,
0.4593446255,
-0.2955352962,
0.5812985897,
0.4350663424,
-0.2486037612,
-0.2423404306,
-0.3032443821,
0.3218990266,
-0.2307191044,
-0.5893124342,
0.5429316163,
0.4225564599,
-0.1229911521,
0.0066808364,
0.1815015078,
-0.0789001063,
0.4041813314,
0.2764402926,
0.2860122919,
-0.2086989135,
-0.4781162739,
-0.0776827559,
0.4943143725,
-0.2840070128,
-0.0031517041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08286v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08286v2 | ALERT: Adapting Language Models to Reasoning Tasks | 2022-12-16T05:15:41 | 2023-07-07T17:43:12 | Ping Yu, Tianlu Wang, Olga Golovneva, Badr AlKhamissi, Siddharth Verma, Zhijing Jin, Gargi Ghosh, Mona Diab, Asli Celikyilmaz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current large language models can perform reasonably well on complex tasks
that require step-by-step reasoning with few-shot learning. Are these models
applying reasoning skills they have learnt during pre-training and reason
outside of their training context, or are they simply memorizing their training
corpus at finer granularity and have learnt to better understand their context?
To tease apart these possibilities, we introduce ALERT, a benchmark and suite
of analyses for assessing language models' reasoning ability comparing
pre-trained and finetuned models on complex tasks that require reasoning skills
to solve. ALERT provides a test bed to asses any language model on fine-grained
reasoning skills, which spans over 20 datasets and covers 10 different
reasoning skills. We leverage ALERT to further investigate the role of
finetuning. With extensive empirical analysis we find that language models
learn more reasoning skills such as textual entailment, abductive reasoning,
and analogical reasoning during finetuning stage compared to pretraining state.
We also find that when language models are finetuned they tend to overfit to
the prompt template, which hurts the robustness of models causing
generalization problems. | [
-0.1823510975,
-0.9171715379,
0.6730485559,
-0.1679674238,
0.0374070928,
-0.4954394996,
-0.2571851313,
-0.3854022622,
-0.7809218764,
0.6311351657,
-0.567848146,
-0.1944455206,
-0.5253314376,
-0.0248052757,
-0.4252510667,
0.9103515744,
0.1046359092,
0.0560477786,
-0.1735315621,
0.1045333371,
-0.6385064125,
-0.4579144716,
-0.6142494678,
-0.4453068972,
0.2459905893,
0.3420622051,
0.5490320921,
0.4235979915,
0.5470389128,
0.2837508023,
0.1604255587,
0.0300991759,
-0.4941838086,
0.0533860996,
-0.6611164808,
-0.8675609231,
-0.2918996811,
0.1037720889,
0.2919955552,
0.9834191203,
0.0487177372,
0.2419656962,
-0.0133867813,
0.4735904038,
-0.6998010874,
0.2740797997,
-0.9183339477,
-0.3846575618,
0.0790936053,
-0.0530765578,
-0.5344673395,
-0.194126457,
0.4844219089,
-0.6731527448,
0.1344108731,
0.1553076655,
0.6684032083,
0.5189950466,
-0.1725969762,
-0.2707315087,
-0.7406477332,
0.8579248786,
-0.6422106624,
0.3271970749,
0.4820914567,
0.5213264823,
-0.1795615852,
-0.6389356256,
-0.3572753072,
-0.3736110032,
-0.0426316224,
-0.075526908,
-0.3051073253,
0.039719969,
0.728738606,
0.1553614587,
-0.2722741067,
0.0159420799,
-0.2173979431,
0.019934861,
0.375213176,
0.0488482416,
0.3277850747,
-0.0659313351,
-0.1466044039,
-0.2198046297,
-0.369381398,
0.3666036129,
0.1563264281,
0.5523537397,
-0.0335637406,
0.4180381298,
-0.4383925498,
0.8677002788,
0.2591530383,
-0.033231236,
-0.0691154152,
-0.2798924744,
-0.452275604,
0.0663191453,
0.2890483737,
0.4032315314,
0.6940461993,
0.1061085165,
-0.3284801245,
0.0725575164,
0.2469173074,
-0.6186921597,
-0.4122187793,
0.1004346982,
-0.3804793954,
0.0175478216,
-0.2577480376,
-0.198061198,
-0.4253816009,
-0.7144065499,
0.6588885784,
-0.8360514045,
-0.2064071894,
0.551702261,
-0.1439773589,
0.3312210441,
0.6055948138,
-0.9018568993,
0.39136222,
0.906663239,
0.4642479718,
0.1238959581,
-0.4589076936,
-0.7229977846,
-0.2665132284,
-0.3193516433,
1.1133811474,
-0.6601445079,
0.0150330588,
0.003367024,
0.0564686321,
-0.5294707417,
-0.5420845151,
0.8172736764,
-0.2712564468,
-0.0434685759,
-0.2438251078,
-0.6467429399,
-0.3974838555,
0.4161632955,
-0.3536355495,
0.8406436443,
0.257197082,
-0.4402191043,
0.3370437026,
-0.566568315,
-0.432685703,
-0.1919349134,
0.0762128979,
-0.0034206489,
0.2206514925,
0.3652407825,
0.7915676236,
-0.5510438085,
0.1834403574,
-0.3535804451,
-0.0779471248,
0.251902014,
-0.252540499,
0.6635366678,
0.2834031582,
-0.1735094339,
0.2490566373,
-0.834426105,
0.182022348,
0.0996609479,
-0.0695664212,
-0.4501263201,
0.0159671176,
-0.277977258,
0.3097568452,
-0.1794514507,
-0.1199385524,
0.046643883,
-0.6453098059,
0.4801978767,
0.4092717171,
0.0089057023,
0.4813312888,
-0.604904294,
0.2570392191,
-0.015643606,
-0.0087092221,
-0.3382286131,
-0.1683057249,
-1.0116798878,
-0.0110323494,
0.2052829713,
0.8033375144,
-0.5013951063,
0.2903047204,
-0.1636838913,
-0.7034682631,
-0.4313672185,
0.0563122407,
0.628200829,
0.5220733285,
0.4896369874,
-0.0245049708,
-0.4697757065,
-0.609310329,
-0.626159966,
0.0330022834,
-0.0271286797,
0.0110307438,
0.6708166003,
-0.0955383554,
0.4918404818,
-0.2886933684,
-0.0169805195,
-0.3546374738,
0.0165007226,
0.0538294725,
0.6944345832,
0.5950257778,
-0.420936048,
-0.2464171052,
0.2618192136,
-0.6195403934,
-0.1770960391,
-0.4209601581,
-0.1725761592,
-0.0798826888,
0.8179535866,
-0.6424823999,
0.1896928847,
0.2288044095,
-0.3635904193,
0.7978997231,
0.0303562004,
0.0910043418,
-0.6048520207,
-0.067381613,
-0.0355110094,
-0.2659125626,
-0.8664599657,
0.1180650964,
-0.1737540513,
-0.0683677346,
-0.3453183472,
0.6331464648,
-0.4343319237,
-0.0414143652,
-0.2159826458,
0.0071774805,
0.1922684014,
0.3144948781,
-0.0128079923,
0.5401234627,
0.818885088,
-0.7906632423,
0.2042132914,
0.033998087,
-0.7293928266,
0.5890395641,
-0.5480729342,
0.0799153149,
0.0400821753,
-0.181989342,
-0.7000772357,
-0.3778439462,
-0.0789228603,
-0.2235182524,
0.1967746913,
-0.2041763067,
-0.2124565542,
-0.2012385428,
0.1418455839,
0.233396098,
0.4169973135,
-0.3376713097,
0.837385416,
0.1159481406,
-0.0494006649,
-0.1935165673,
-0.4806438088,
-0.5609546304,
-0.1505726725,
-0.4689380825,
-0.088431336,
0.0472456329,
-0.5855343938,
-0.1939495057,
-0.2587765157,
-0.1642758846,
0.4823789895,
0.1640580595,
0.0112864571,
-0.544845283,
0.1675307602,
-0.0542088039,
-0.2207283229,
0.1681602597,
-0.3505349159,
0.5034326911,
-0.2876365483,
-0.511915803,
-0.5195237398,
0.1991509646,
0.6983547807,
-0.2738725841,
0.6043998003,
0.4087564051,
-0.5970306993,
-0.1787612587,
-0.7535457015,
-0.3599902093,
-0.3871849477,
0.38697052,
-0.6788056493,
-0.6231000423,
0.4793764055,
-0.2365239114,
0.0888110474,
0.6158066392,
0.4731486142,
-0.1529626846,
1.0651487112,
0.539421618,
0.3723762929,
0.5713912249,
-0.0569101162,
0.133608833,
-0.6024769545,
-0.0751901418,
-0.6661864519,
0.044259835,
-0.2220062762,
-0.4671215117,
-0.3174687028,
0.4923695326,
-0.5758051872,
0.1983201057,
-0.3791732788,
0.5518590808,
0.6894076467,
0.0649528205,
0.1513081342,
-0.1932793707,
0.0804545656,
0.2807317674,
-0.6676057577,
-0.6067273617,
0.9750498533,
0.2313763648,
0.7249544859,
-0.2425021082,
0.229281202,
-0.1701716781,
-0.045766972,
-0.8410947323,
0.384904325,
-0.2693444788,
-0.5251176953,
-0.1184415147,
-0.1429104507,
-0.5655938387,
0.1230227873,
-0.4767748117,
-0.5597461462,
0.2353340387,
0.2911584377,
-0.7341428995,
0.0696635842,
-1.2525514364,
1.0380465984,
-0.2269832194,
-0.0626458973,
-0.144947812,
-0.4197045565,
0.3332927525,
0.0299621876,
0.2199687362,
-0.4621798098,
0.4571966529,
0.6201404929,
-0.1064587235,
0.8859818578,
-0.1416370869,
0.1440881938,
0.4608510435,
0.2448190451,
0.449305743,
-0.2524836063,
-0.2710116506,
-0.1794195324,
0.3566181958,
-0.4484075904,
-0.7058627009,
0.5049940348,
-0.7360386252,
-0.9204444289,
-0.2662604451,
-0.6851480007,
-0.3376312852,
0.3441809714,
0.2162586898,
0.5048841834,
-0.0745125934,
0.1443004012,
0.7740109563,
0.1581558138,
0.0944652334,
0.2838819921,
-0.11457932,
0.1342838258,
0.5576817989,
0.0874662623,
0.7347641587,
0.3376060128,
0.3229149282,
0.0661939606,
-0.7509875894,
-0.1036529243,
-0.0779530928,
-0.9699689746,
-0.1231446192,
-0.6891165376,
-0.1512068212,
-0.490791738,
-0.2585033476,
-0.3320129514,
-0.4367806613,
-0.2438731045,
-0.0363138542,
0.3871400058,
0.4218342006,
0.1886804998,
0.3605159223,
-0.7610639334,
0.2862754762,
0.5879306197,
0.1141968369,
-0.0778073072,
-0.704031229,
-0.0838026553,
0.015142614,
-0.0312120859,
-0.4569042027,
0.0080496836,
0.3993423879,
0.627632618,
0.3829776943,
0.1409547478,
0.7599014044,
-0.647269249,
0.4903766811,
0.1035312712,
-0.9974936843,
0.6906978488,
-0.4213121831,
0.6320661306,
0.5981093049,
0.3444634676,
-0.3006272316,
-0.1659405082,
-0.4334340096,
-0.2585724592,
0.7779284716,
-0.0185731258,
0.1180630103,
0.022651393,
0.4591878951,
0.2544394433,
-0.1283059865,
-0.515206337,
0.1980608553,
-0.3358666599,
-0.2473570704,
-0.0384175181,
-0.237575829,
-0.1828810722,
-0.4182772338,
0.4622274041,
-0.3632307053,
0.168905288,
0.1678592563,
-0.382833004,
0.0620833188,
0.5078904629,
0.5529369116,
0.5651339293,
-0.0539113469,
0.1759233475,
0.3818530142,
-0.2241723835,
-0.1735829413,
0.1814279556,
0.084335126,
-0.3778783679,
0.7681332827,
1.1357746124,
0.4655571282,
-0.7828816175,
0.3985468447,
-0.0059411307,
-0.1840183139,
-0.0430987366,
0.6756904721,
-0.0902416334,
0.4373868406,
0.0941463336,
0.5126364827,
0.1830536425,
-0.8017262816,
0.0049738535,
0.2205464244,
-0.5730857253,
-0.441472739,
0.3875330091,
0.0798847377,
-0.2343251407,
0.3260409534,
-0.0736555904,
-0.519516468,
0.5149011016,
0.7504060268,
0.739811182,
-0.2796765268,
-0.2876640558,
0.4855845869,
0.3409580886,
-0.3842443228,
0.1580442786,
0.1684311777,
-0.9006916881,
-0.5029834509,
-0.5413068533,
-0.2196887583,
-0.0224827826,
-0.6261203289,
0.3809935153,
-0.5996816158,
-0.0820247382,
0.3354339898,
-0.1682187766,
-0.9236205816,
0.5444701314,
0.0997677073,
0.9995152354,
-0.8573874831,
0.7382219434,
0.6977568269,
-0.2251583338,
-0.9979926944,
-0.1250960529,
0.0713982061,
-0.710528791,
0.5412601233,
0.4665454328,
-0.1278134286,
0.2010901868,
-0.4919120967,
-0.7283246517,
0.6709941626,
0.6043706536,
-0.5826809406,
-0.0929383263,
-0.1697171926,
0.3922078013,
-0.6412730813,
0.3822351694,
1.0588219166,
0.2223975062,
-0.0664667115,
-1.0310459137,
-0.0254787188,
-0.0955216885,
-0.3180169761,
-0.0378171653,
-0.0637966618,
1.0515166521,
-0.3746644258,
-0.2196037769,
-0.0824565515,
0.3914276659,
0.0135839563,
0.2497044951,
0.5965429544,
0.4192571938,
0.8944720626,
-0.3260505497,
1.1475350857,
-0.0469117053,
0.0984831825,
1.3925982714,
-0.249726668,
0.9589445591,
0.2371751815,
0.0248581804,
0.5547346473,
0.3861589134,
0.2970016897,
0.5354639888,
-0.0612289906,
0.0958542526,
-0.8541641831,
-0.0698931515,
-0.2850264311,
0.4960565269,
0.6117452383,
-0.0912338868,
-0.2919228673,
0.3838494718,
-0.1058163568,
0.3632648587,
-0.6781576872,
0.8236216903,
0.2683030665,
-0.9389885664,
0.8017576337,
-0.3342546225,
0.2607713342,
-0.4044406116,
0.0899570361,
0.1913161874,
0.5450885296,
-0.1614606827,
-0.7935211658,
0.3569377065,
-0.038635321,
-0.4378951788,
-0.1193513051,
0.8813569546,
-0.1536678076,
-0.3616562188,
0.2386274487,
0.5129513144,
0.0150065599,
-0.2118395269,
-0.8900553584,
-0.0505031012,
0.0174546111,
-0.1586734056,
0.2186505049,
0.7324153781,
-0.3097741306,
0.8422185183,
0.7674699426,
-0.1907908618,
0.2548739016,
0.3221266866,
0.7665085196,
-0.5648204684,
-0.2867773473,
-0.7750280499,
0.4891412854,
0.0307525489,
-0.4435308576,
0.5778654814,
0.0913172364,
0.9370059967,
-0.3525664806,
0.6521138549,
0.1403743178,
0.6119955182,
-0.8642477393,
0.4288677871,
-0.2664898932,
0.0798023194,
-0.1817573458,
-0.6391695738,
-0.4560483396,
0.8421785235,
-0.9767841101,
-0.0522818677,
0.8745798469,
0.6253079176,
-0.2208732069,
0.1382951736,
0.4590550661,
0.2110097259,
0.1727931499,
0.6308870912,
0.9141559005,
-0.3994202018,
0.3736914694,
-0.2914375663,
-0.1473062336,
-0.3272905052,
-0.8046040535,
-1.3355475664,
-0.4822781384,
-0.3890587091,
-0.0357490703,
0.0287358556,
1.0162084103,
0.7698095441,
-1.0971513987,
0.0815208405,
-0.3320831656,
-0.008635412,
-0.4857107103,
-0.1752613634,
0.252176404,
-0.8314459324,
-0.5522298813,
0.279275775,
0.1055724844,
0.0643291324,
0.2388778478,
0.2285334617,
-0.3856756389,
0.1918542087,
0.6412773132,
0.2670260668,
-0.8036791682,
-0.6868558526,
-0.0047108834,
-0.1244579479,
-0.1426211298,
0.7750347257,
-0.671669364,
0.4581706226,
0.5177730918,
0.6973069906,
0.1554528028,
-0.1186713874,
0.5165182948,
-0.3409653306,
0.4303425252,
0.23116754,
0.4738527834,
0.3150745034,
-0.2030444145,
0.3463605642,
-0.0995472521,
-0.6221808791,
-0.9059912562,
0.3313545287,
-0.853279531,
-0.2891963422,
1.0091855526,
-0.3444988132,
-0.3166467845,
-0.3936294317,
-0.3892855346,
0.2972693443,
-0.0777281597,
0.4225316346,
0.767875433,
-0.0595749617,
-0.1835790277,
-0.8950695992,
0.7351876497,
0.5709594488,
-0.8921169639,
0.3386550844,
0.3450654447,
0.3562627733,
0.2005573809,
0.2473076433,
0.2881337702,
0.6328821182,
0.0510153472,
-0.2053824812,
0.0503501594,
-0.4035182893,
-0.320861578,
-0.0565264486,
0.3872500956,
0.1069252789
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08283v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08283v3 | SceneGATE: Scene-Graph based co-Attention networks for TExt visual question answering | 2022-12-16T05:10:09 | 2023-08-07T08:32:54 | Feiqi Cao, Siwen Luo, Felipe Nunez, Zean Wen, Josiah Poon, Caren Han | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Most TextVQA approaches focus on the integration of objects, scene texts and
question words by a simple transformer encoder. But this fails to capture the
semantic relations between different modalities. The paper proposes a Scene
Graph based co-Attention Network (SceneGATE) for TextVQA, which reveals the
semantic relations among the objects, Optical Character Recognition (OCR)
tokens and the question words. It is achieved by a TextVQA-based scene graph
that discovers the underlying semantics of an image. We created a
guided-attention module to capture the intra-modal interplay between the
language and the vision as a guidance for inter-modal interactions. To make
explicit teaching of the relations between the two modalities, we proposed and
integrated two attention modules, namely a scene graph-based semantic
relation-aware attention and a positional relation-aware attention. We
conducted extensive experiments on two benchmark datasets, Text-VQA and ST-VQA.
It is shown that our SceneGATE method outperformed existing ones because of the
scene graph and its attention modules. | [
-0.5671414733,
-0.9665042758,
0.5456824303,
0.03871198,
-0.2181573063,
-0.0043608849,
0.4735339582,
-0.342546016,
0.0186106972,
0.6620562077,
-0.9530417919,
-0.5570276976,
-0.2033046335,
0.2256884426,
-0.4021882117,
0.3669097722,
-0.1396228224,
0.2625686824,
-0.7114163041,
-0.3213107288,
-0.5338265896,
-0.2886271179,
-0.7580696344,
0.0093757771,
0.6372058392,
0.1715494841,
0.61031425,
0.3502789438,
0.7658287287,
0.3463997245,
-0.2851554155,
0.3151387572,
-0.3914705813,
-0.1594115645,
-0.4625402987,
0.0297774393,
-0.2151170224,
-0.2670184672,
0.5140427351,
0.5256797671,
0.3830407262,
0.0708699152,
0.0675648376,
0.5601274371,
-0.4898511171,
0.2950693071,
-0.3046662509,
0.45224756,
0.3621891439,
-0.1679667532,
-0.3501833379,
-0.1908538789,
0.0907284468,
-0.8406327963,
0.0866873711,
0.3986043632,
1.1285653114,
0.5061437488,
-0.5908253789,
-0.1173108816,
-0.180976972,
0.4525623024,
-0.0422194228,
0.3575901687,
0.3468016982,
0.4338904321,
-0.0705796331,
-0.8643631339,
-0.575271368,
0.059422344,
-0.3306086957,
0.4621086717,
0.0202857964,
0.2617410421,
0.045851782,
0.3926432729,
-0.4935551882,
-0.409786433,
-0.1976397932,
-0.4578952491,
0.1130135506,
0.3472251594,
0.6967520118,
-0.5327378511,
-0.923579216,
-0.0003369022,
-0.4693118036,
0.3658631444,
-0.2065899521,
0.0997858196,
0.1819366813,
0.7598277926,
-0.2645032704,
0.8581197262,
0.0228284094,
0.1959166527,
0.0106636835,
-0.8162878752,
-0.1869238913,
0.019043155,
0.9579678178,
0.5073692203,
0.1807351559,
-0.1410783976,
0.2952179015,
0.0525684282,
0.1168179661,
-0.7185193896,
-0.0968410447,
0.0201204196,
-0.1794408411,
-0.1986983865,
-0.1262319237,
-0.6392064095,
-0.0753527731,
-0.1899264604,
0.8778185844,
-0.4300198257,
0.1335783303,
0.0159693025,
-0.3191562593,
0.6352068782,
0.6650589705,
-0.4759247899,
0.4581584632,
0.430083096,
0.6922222972,
-0.0729635656,
-0.1830010563,
-0.7256810069,
0.2904298306,
-0.3517302573,
0.8222002983,
-0.4845043123,
-0.04687519,
0.0162926167,
0.2831562757,
-0.301386863,
-0.3227024674,
0.1869983822,
-0.8547123075,
0.4851320088,
-0.487690568,
-0.3485329747,
-0.3434705436,
0.7497413754,
-0.81026721,
1.1839830875,
0.1304114014,
-1.0339816809,
-0.1218861714,
-0.2907992899,
-0.2107299864,
0.2149044126,
-0.5606832504,
-0.2719832361,
-0.4891210496,
0.727037251,
0.418328166,
-0.1644647568,
0.0914523005,
0.0616421998,
-0.4140118062,
0.3240377903,
-0.0554421879,
0.5693977475,
-0.0572183356,
0.0050797579,
0.1891136318,
-0.5139068961,
0.1481601,
-0.0478120558,
-0.0702408105,
-0.4963865578,
-0.0628284439,
-0.1533295065,
0.4115836322,
0.2180294096,
-0.6137880087,
-0.2369639874,
-0.3721733987,
0.5858344436,
0.228962034,
0.4517172277,
0.5752148628,
0.0874195993,
0.583337009,
0.3664530516,
0.1569733471,
-0.5400509238,
-0.5237336755,
-0.6572637558,
-0.0320743099,
0.0335228145,
0.6100110412,
-1.5290489197,
0.0439328291,
-0.104967162,
0.0590286851,
-0.2452836782,
-0.2986926138,
0.7602635026,
0.9684941173,
0.4638248384,
-0.4984322488,
0.0273891557,
-0.8730601072,
-0.1991862208,
-0.2041357756,
0.3519534767,
0.7086376548,
0.4618098438,
0.150063917,
0.9734550118,
-0.6011983752,
-0.6183083057,
-0.1478320956,
-0.1588218659,
-0.2609777451,
0.199984625,
0.3120238185,
-0.985453546,
-0.3343445361,
0.0233824681,
-0.6678609252,
0.2274021059,
0.1826850623,
-0.4398494065,
-0.0746621564,
0.921444118,
-0.0568060763,
0.5227943063,
0.4613336921,
-0.4661153257,
0.1242134571,
0.0121520655,
0.4292610884,
-1.3059788942,
-0.2421202809,
-0.0067592897,
-0.6009762287,
-0.4505819082,
0.0372150205,
0.0701769367,
-0.484725982,
-0.7720206976,
0.5433577299,
-0.3420770168,
-0.3075928688,
0.3008523881,
0.5623471141,
0.5187731385,
1.0397789478,
0.1625043452,
0.8297641873,
0.4417454004,
-0.4634517431,
0.3925539255,
0.8896529675,
-0.289204061,
0.6327492595,
-0.801446557,
0.0994003415,
-0.3155195415,
-0.0037443577,
-1.5538767576,
-0.2308278233,
0.7242361903,
-0.498703897,
0.0033340652,
-0.1172096953,
-0.1886263788,
-0.1955722868,
-0.0553988293,
0.7408400774,
0.0841476992,
-0.5522581935,
0.660559535,
0.2189351767,
-0.1305500716,
-0.8009604216,
-0.8394187689,
0.0783439204,
0.2259637862,
-0.8186523914,
0.203417331,
0.145646587,
0.1523002237,
0.5896498561,
-0.0687619671,
-0.652579248,
-0.3799973726,
0.1556490362,
0.1223201603,
-0.1805293858,
0.3066978753,
0.1917806715,
-0.1019091681,
0.027190065,
-0.1007755399,
0.2813850045,
-0.0864052549,
-0.2495267838,
-0.4478621185,
0.5277933478,
0.3888967931,
-0.5444204211,
0.4530258179,
0.3800924718,
-0.2904900312,
-0.1269059479,
-0.0274905581,
0.019763466,
-0.4466658533,
0.7027041316,
-0.4961775839,
-1.1551929712,
0.4797110558,
-0.1149242818,
-0.4996319711,
0.2101852149,
0.1747371107,
-0.1698444784,
0.6418805718,
0.4671594799,
0.3299779892,
0.4403801262,
-0.199324742,
0.0828855187,
-1.0830211639,
-0.5502705574,
-0.2689682245,
-0.0623274557,
-0.1305236965,
-0.7497207522,
0.3807666302,
-0.140031904,
-0.2858283222,
0.5469016433,
-0.652823329,
0.5581631064,
0.3199240863,
0.4249852598,
0.5003729463,
0.0725786388,
-0.0329320282,
-0.191705972,
-0.9184078574,
-0.1602184325,
0.3225045204,
0.0444973409,
0.8273465037,
-0.1753940731,
0.4031238258,
-0.0973743573,
-0.2602721453,
-0.9507573843,
0.8165405393,
0.0108615579,
-0.5626975894,
-0.5712889433,
-0.4248425364,
-0.7050693035,
0.4672368467,
0.0140475556,
-0.4849360585,
0.5136966705,
0.1027818471,
-0.1880515516,
-0.009870695,
-0.5222543478,
1.2991877794,
0.0335567705,
-0.6479998231,
0.0598227158,
-0.7533735633,
0.1985742599,
0.3969035447,
0.0735363215,
0.0413533524,
-0.2414739877,
0.5793111324,
-0.5641356111,
0.8181837201,
0.1765410304,
-0.0410280153,
0.6294425726,
-0.0355669744,
0.2606965899,
-0.0030027058,
0.4215900004,
-0.0313113704,
0.2190493792,
-0.2275503129,
-0.5972400904,
0.466670692,
-0.6488106251,
-0.4029368758,
-0.487716496,
-0.4651562572,
-0.1690098643,
0.2798625827,
0.2359752506,
1.1664600372,
-0.4002093375,
0.0560678989,
1.1134582758,
-0.3643175066,
0.4771510065,
0.0499637499,
-0.5010543466,
-0.684957087,
0.8544430137,
0.054946851,
0.3825112283,
0.9321401119,
-0.0022055469,
-0.2173566371,
-0.0800682008,
-0.6184745431,
0.0184841864,
-0.9272220135,
-0.2235923707,
-0.8125282526,
-0.4223659933,
-0.033627443,
-0.1174250692,
-0.1894246787,
-0.2622658014,
-0.1916238517,
0.2830325067,
0.4355914593,
0.4286357462,
0.6489334702,
0.1415002942,
-0.6969355941,
0.6864845753,
0.7251901031,
0.1828059107,
-0.109898068,
-0.435241133,
-0.1372082382,
-0.3162303865,
0.0568303093,
-0.9305437803,
0.1538927853,
0.2191603184,
0.0966355354,
0.01042102,
0.0471515097,
0.5556153655,
-0.7112677693,
0.6772987843,
0.3043752909,
-0.8745652437,
0.3322123289,
-0.3369824886,
0.5879548192,
0.5180270076,
0.229478538,
-0.7149628997,
-0.3412959576,
-0.1531184763,
-0.6426067352,
1.0036904812,
0.3676327765,
0.0768112466,
0.0253656581,
0.3828447163,
-0.3345991373,
0.3658599257,
-0.7458012104,
-0.184700042,
-0.4570376873,
-0.4974067509,
0.2864536941,
-0.1202007607,
-0.0311550219,
-0.2419501692,
0.237139076,
-0.2327190936,
0.4281495214,
0.7609718442,
-0.2251413167,
0.1505327374,
-0.0129591497,
-0.0391025953,
0.3945667446,
0.1443794072,
0.2609591186,
0.0398018919,
-0.7364025712,
0.2025934607,
-0.013733807,
-0.3413860798,
0.0087019214,
0.2872546613,
0.7026170492,
0.4334200919,
-0.4277589023,
0.8691772223,
-0.3378717601,
-0.313595593,
-0.1303406954,
0.0417486206,
0.4010252953,
0.2940508723,
-0.0738757402,
-0.0023931446,
0.3407855332,
-0.4021333456,
0.1682940423,
0.3605180979,
-1.2230942249,
0.0899268985,
0.6830774546,
0.3390507996,
-0.3578360677,
0.2906142175,
-0.0508076623,
-0.6165673137,
1.0554395914,
0.2761747539,
0.6583071351,
-0.0483318344,
0.462143451,
0.6047670841,
0.4049936235,
0.353638947,
0.4852045774,
-0.1970612705,
-0.6460841298,
-0.6028822064,
-0.2399666458,
-0.6079037189,
-0.1226910055,
-0.4931036532,
0.0986634418,
-0.2798978388,
0.1706613749,
-0.2159200907,
-0.2734586298,
-0.5326104164,
0.6002639532,
-0.2044674307,
0.7231587172,
-0.5804448128,
0.4496790171,
0.9468276501,
-0.6378041506,
-0.798024416,
-0.0141581884,
-0.4508275092,
-0.7807779908,
0.7337844372,
0.21766451,
-0.4511031806,
0.3879595101,
-0.5109593272,
-0.9498617649,
1.1587908268,
0.0328511372,
-0.4150440395,
-0.0148038082,
0.2472864389,
0.3157887459,
-0.2575726509,
0.0992430821,
-0.1832931787,
0.1408142447,
0.6215288043,
-0.2283217907,
0.150255844,
-0.1274638474,
0.1607082486,
0.2636186779,
-0.8491652012,
0.564807117,
0.0353437215,
-0.3416468501,
0.0389187522,
0.730399847,
-0.2464513183,
0.4357353449,
0.3372897208,
0.3871345222,
0.2368278205,
-0.2172094136,
0.8474757075,
-0.0962057337,
0.1867415011,
1.1866377592,
-0.0490227416,
0.7343615294,
0.5238572955,
-0.0063816872,
0.4175496399,
0.6167539358,
0.2911514938,
0.6008397341,
0.0214983001,
-0.1483517736,
-0.469461292,
-0.213864252,
-0.165022105,
0.0343885645,
0.1381652653,
-0.2694115937,
-0.350130707,
-0.0231457036,
-0.3214780986,
0.2266104221,
-0.5542203784,
1.0228230953,
0.2776108384,
-0.6738272905,
0.164874807,
-0.4266856909,
-0.1533108503,
-0.5141056776,
-0.2275908887,
-0.0643394291,
0.0922160745,
-0.0709088296,
-0.9133474231,
0.0784750506,
-0.3635529578,
-0.1671514809,
0.035945598,
0.9052900672,
-0.9009763598,
-0.3952041566,
0.1147259325,
0.3832195997,
-0.0146557027,
0.022868095,
-0.4720466137,
-0.1347099841,
-0.224996835,
-0.1684363782,
0.0961235389,
0.7318615913,
-0.1061234549,
0.4709046185,
0.0327095725,
-0.6470798254,
0.0467446372,
0.000354757,
0.9518420696,
-0.6194672585,
-0.5822279453,
-0.4164626598,
0.526283741,
-0.1494006813,
-0.2668857276,
0.7291189432,
0.3547587097,
0.5552124977,
-0.0293195155,
0.5327380896,
0.1642288715,
0.1705589145,
-0.6087752581,
0.4258904159,
-0.6990475059,
-0.3481323123,
-0.4990240932,
-1.0151458979,
-0.2314061075,
0.4566668272,
-0.2289273292,
-0.1856217682,
1.2167993784,
0.8842289448,
-0.0789828151,
-0.114714399,
0.4249384105,
-0.0702491924,
-0.0491167642,
0.9091508985,
1.0791648626,
-0.7687708139,
0.788824439,
0.0482629836,
-0.1137670577,
-0.0423741043,
-0.7340834141,
-1.1513067484,
-0.685012877,
-0.5867295861,
-0.2962555587,
0.0810546279,
0.2009213418,
0.2451396137,
-0.3911807835,
0.2257958502,
-0.2630592883,
0.2171304673,
-0.138766095,
-0.1689143628,
0.7523097992,
-0.28779158,
-0.710329771,
-0.0008868245,
0.6739288568,
-0.0377695374,
-0.3490303755,
-0.0022397633,
-0.3624980152,
0.292165339,
0.5678437352,
0.1124569699,
-0.3741388917,
-0.2480694801,
0.2805926502,
-0.4134401083,
0.184252575,
0.594224453,
-0.7937370539,
0.6808966398,
0.8030457497,
0.7877759337,
0.5613803267,
0.1690176874,
0.3002252281,
-0.6689506173,
0.2401525378,
0.1092147306,
0.1291976571,
0.4174851775,
-0.3375405371,
0.3068350255,
0.2623292208,
-0.4710620344,
-0.2567035258,
0.5552545786,
-1.0772132874,
-0.2876013219,
0.9331814051,
-0.1300772429,
-0.9183394909,
-0.3622411788,
-0.7020213008,
0.1228294447,
-0.1605703831,
0.0928973556,
0.6000885963,
0.1214620098,
-0.3326599002,
-0.3432682753,
0.5160199404,
0.3117693961,
-0.8497930765,
-0.193034932,
0.610368073,
-0.0657537803,
0.0917339474,
0.7113928795,
-0.3019125164,
0.3608617783,
-0.0407418385,
0.0192560516,
-0.2887816727,
-0.3391294181,
-0.2025380433,
0.3143157363,
-0.3587949872,
-0.5239845514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08279v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08279v1 | Werewolf Among Us: A Multimodal Dataset for Modeling Persuasion Behaviors in Social Deduction Games | 2022-12-16T04:52:53 | 2022-12-16T04:52:53 | Bolin Lai, Hongxin Zhang, Miao Liu, Aryan Pariani, Fiona Ryan, Wenqi Jia, Shirley Anugrah Hayati, James M. Rehg, Diyi Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Persuasion modeling is a key building block for conversational agents.
Existing works in this direction are limited to analyzing textual dialogue
corpus. We argue that visual signals also play an important role in
understanding human persuasive behaviors. In this paper, we introduce the first
multimodal dataset for modeling persuasion behaviors. Our dataset includes 199
dialogue transcriptions and videos captured in a multi-player social deduction
game setting, 26,647 utterance level annotations of persuasion strategy, and
game level annotations of deduction game outcomes. We provide extensive
experiments to show how dialogue context and visual signals benefit persuasion
strategy prediction. We also explore the generalization ability of language
models for persuasion modeling and the role of persuasion strategies in
predicting social deduction game outcomes. Our dataset, code, and models can be
found at https://persuasion-deductiongame.socialai-data.org. | [
-0.4579807818,
-0.9248402119,
0.7724094987,
0.3237094879,
-0.1995379627,
0.1576530337,
0.0802904814,
-0.0276302919,
0.3122467101,
0.6208984256,
-0.7319027781,
-0.7227993608,
-0.5452445149,
-0.1709685773,
-0.0485002846,
0.4740422666,
0.580508709,
0.3633417785,
-0.2449207902,
0.040359851,
-0.5560518503,
-0.6706956625,
-0.464345485,
-0.620895803,
0.6829022765,
0.4653649628,
0.6125261188,
0.2731842995,
0.0439265743,
0.3783818781,
0.2543059289,
-0.0313333385,
-0.5966890454,
0.3194594979,
-0.1988762766,
-0.4137919843,
-0.1167720109,
0.1863767654,
0.4498372376,
0.306140095,
0.0067182034,
-0.0390459187,
-0.0997432917,
0.3003582358,
-0.3283236623,
0.2416860014,
-0.6128266454,
-0.1207061112,
-0.0111959726,
-0.3028849959,
-0.7157298923,
-0.417483151,
0.2857591212,
-0.5954294801,
0.1918861568,
-0.1912301928,
0.4619148672,
0.0432141423,
-0.9643948674,
-0.3423022628,
-0.7392749786,
0.6980912089,
-0.4784984589,
0.3824925423,
0.4781174958,
0.2170847058,
-0.2611916661,
-0.6484733224,
-0.5278188586,
-0.1570942253,
-0.0133273099,
0.1667442471,
-0.7052280307,
0.2786801457,
0.4304884076,
-0.2687053084,
-0.3702673614,
-0.1372621804,
-0.3165334165,
-0.3279221058,
0.6940712333,
0.4798462689,
0.2174204737,
-0.3257627487,
-0.3307545483,
-0.6740813255,
-0.3831058443,
0.5368441939,
0.4996228516,
0.0245421734,
-0.2412969023,
0.4017655253,
0.1115437746,
0.4310542047,
0.3597411811,
-0.1103181615,
-0.0250452105,
-0.451449573,
-0.1194808707,
0.1104446799,
0.7061520219,
0.8499392867,
0.0045913765,
0.1564137787,
0.0401818827,
0.6244045496,
0.1551697701,
-0.6560929418,
-0.6140964627,
-0.0185210761,
-0.9968249798,
-0.4457097054,
-0.2363434881,
-1.1233733892,
-1.2282476425,
-0.1945365667,
0.3895129263,
-0.5140808225,
-0.5091573596,
0.193698734,
-0.5968899131,
0.3897160292,
0.2582967281,
-1.0015649796,
0.2976538837,
0.5938234925,
0.4838375151,
0.3547739089,
-0.1858092546,
-0.4003850818,
0.004014831,
-0.3886963129,
0.9151570201,
-1.0001153946,
-0.7145712376,
-0.0474485308,
0.1669610143,
0.0023386995,
-0.2072075009,
0.5025891662,
-0.1253929734,
-0.2310667336,
-0.545496285,
-0.5236912966,
-0.5116323233,
0.4777241647,
-0.9328621626,
0.3522704244,
-0.3833300471,
-0.3569826484,
0.6197217703,
-0.6770917773,
-0.3696513474,
0.0431385972,
-0.2186523676,
0.0595779158,
0.1736101657,
0.4522943199,
0.5533213019,
-0.259041369,
0.2603402734,
-0.4422610402,
0.0132269654,
0.5667580962,
-0.4209137559,
0.7885329723,
0.2555347085,
-0.141889438,
0.2722320259,
-0.3931828439,
-0.0989049375,
0.0447520427,
0.1389127523,
-0.6432728767,
0.2854225039,
-0.0987881422,
0.2371078134,
-0.16861099,
-0.6980617046,
0.284599632,
0.117905423,
0.4348445237,
0.8217611313,
0.1771171689,
0.4005765617,
-0.3642458916,
0.6663084626,
0.0268947072,
0.4225458801,
-0.3312729001,
-0.7139079571,
-0.2203764617,
-0.4691001475,
-0.0598493703,
0.4534763992,
-0.8477683663,
-0.125137791,
-0.0555341206,
-0.7336101532,
-0.3536072969,
-0.3943033218,
0.2685477734,
0.1557106972,
0.0063734339,
0.1244488433,
-0.6451883912,
-1.0211412907,
0.0692273602,
-0.5293764472,
0.121984072,
0.2969026566,
0.4663036466,
-0.2857635021,
0.9846047163,
-0.5420355201,
-0.0979271308,
-0.460516125,
0.4599977732,
0.0186143778,
0.2491710782,
0.7702798247,
-0.8691132069,
-0.2228436768,
-0.3864047229,
-0.661334455,
0.0048326887,
-0.2185290009,
-0.0560066886,
-0.3167191148,
0.3862825632,
-0.27158764,
0.3660056889,
0.7641602159,
-0.5728331208,
0.3192193806,
0.087017484,
0.7542137504,
-1.1110440493,
-0.5274952054,
0.2861854434,
0.0210246034,
-0.8453139663,
-0.3859339356,
-0.3301119208,
-0.1316855103,
-0.2140600979,
0.5674131513,
-0.2228686064,
0.2205525786,
0.1385585368,
-0.0279774126,
0.2119676322,
0.4651290476,
0.3645062745,
0.3899320364,
0.8892089128,
-0.5185438991,
0.7587912679,
0.516648829,
-0.4015814662,
0.9015371203,
-0.7705395222,
0.106838271,
-0.3693659008,
0.2947202623,
-1.4920600653,
-0.2078116387,
0.3162416816,
-0.3937141597,
-0.1666345149,
-0.1399263889,
-0.3126473129,
-0.2132316232,
-0.4408469498,
0.0609222315,
0.418620199,
-0.468115896,
0.8436214328,
0.6015950441,
-0.0437028147,
-0.2878710926,
-0.5244897604,
-0.0397124141,
-0.3529340327,
-0.6997699738,
0.0425154157,
-0.1088146493,
-0.4385172129,
-0.4649641216,
0.3442279696,
-0.1101127043,
-0.3097951114,
0.6242060065,
0.3055414259,
0.1413915008,
0.3395164013,
-0.1498455554,
0.0910853818,
-0.0262638815,
0.0525310412,
0.4763111472,
0.0238452628,
-0.4281671643,
-0.2987787724,
0.5003105998,
0.4393540919,
0.0739752799,
0.4434050322,
0.4136449993,
-0.1747896075,
0.2303844392,
-0.7644100785,
-0.7199147344,
-0.4463888109,
0.5358636379,
-0.3041169941,
-0.5153124332,
0.6063821316,
-0.2055011243,
0.1428634524,
-0.0899130851,
0.4321343005,
0.0848626867,
1.5283688307,
0.55017066,
0.118972674,
0.3974027634,
-0.1144497097,
-0.1007673666,
-0.4423753619,
-0.4242228568,
-0.4537916183,
-0.4880438745,
-0.3308255374,
-0.2255979925,
0.2265243679,
-0.0835041702,
-0.067400001,
0.4202360511,
-0.5298094153,
0.3558028936,
0.4709773064,
0.3532387316,
0.1839418709,
0.0764414743,
-0.1076273024,
-0.5131141543,
-0.4962747097,
-0.5335239768,
0.956867516,
0.3979241252,
1.1378426552,
0.311449796,
0.5395408273,
0.6062561274,
0.2539967895,
-0.7248317003,
0.7867826223,
-0.0245585181,
-0.7816240788,
-0.4573658705,
-0.2906866074,
-1.0264621973,
0.2539352775,
-0.7106480002,
-0.8831349611,
0.4688411057,
0.0983726308,
-0.276281327,
0.1550690681,
-0.7938668728,
0.9871620536,
-0.2175978869,
-0.2046421021,
-0.4160364568,
-0.4061585963,
0.3426374197,
0.3450731337,
0.1576500088,
-0.1553954184,
0.3412683308,
0.7929519415,
0.2600481212,
1.1670440435,
-0.3701712191,
-0.095881246,
0.2652254105,
0.0768878907,
0.4694028497,
0.2405271977,
-0.0430768095,
0.0484240167,
0.3647643626,
0.0490178838,
-0.5619368553,
0.4874742329,
-0.4883979261,
-0.4010723531,
-0.2934649587,
-0.5122519732,
-0.1505198479,
-0.1595838964,
0.4624783099,
0.7979912162,
-0.748328805,
0.3809881806,
0.5674372911,
-0.1743864119,
0.3765378594,
0.5574651361,
-0.0998116359,
-0.6083798409,
0.9794086814,
-0.2666377425,
0.1284617335,
0.1329645514,
0.3755998909,
-0.6929532886,
-0.1818661243,
-0.1694584787,
0.066765137,
-1.1002614498,
0.0643149689,
-0.5324454308,
0.3779308796,
-0.4714228213,
-0.1372470111,
-0.0456842333,
-0.1794016361,
0.0474818982,
-0.0726914182,
0.3523074389,
1.1480498314,
-0.1540867537,
0.5068717599,
-0.8239022493,
0.2676045597,
0.7676159143,
0.0749884173,
0.0263854787,
-0.0185365174,
0.2356630266,
0.383718282,
-0.3712022007,
-1.3318320513,
0.2982023954,
0.0389393121,
0.8387297988,
0.4565413296,
0.0389107578,
0.6803364158,
-0.1192511991,
0.8799369931,
0.4860608876,
-0.8116917014,
0.2624807656,
-0.3231033683,
0.2902022898,
0.4622732103,
0.3913931251,
-0.6948472261,
-0.179801181,
-0.4767198563,
-0.1597476155,
0.7843580842,
-0.0488985814,
0.1610077769,
-0.2151433825,
-0.0859781951,
0.209854871,
0.1764277518,
-0.93145293,
-0.2550298572,
-0.4747163355,
0.0085392362,
-0.1484033316,
-0.2198604345,
-0.4044222832,
-0.3236506283,
0.4106699228,
-0.1024124697,
-0.1035494432,
-0.0605823807,
-0.0537275933,
0.0189040378,
0.349960357,
0.5650905967,
0.6095080376,
-0.0417349599,
-0.0799759254,
0.0160131231,
-0.5857576728,
0.3654771745,
0.1096696183,
-0.0822019279,
-0.0010274157,
0.5582152605,
0.8811286688,
0.1927111894,
-0.4240604639,
0.4209407866,
-0.4848771989,
-0.3404557407,
-0.081044741,
-0.1940414011,
0.0463882908,
0.6612108946,
0.3578871489,
-0.2341371477,
0.350851357,
-0.7255280018,
0.1693442613,
0.8368701339,
-0.5299405456,
-0.4379240572,
0.5757744908,
0.5234168768,
-0.0277788434,
0.4197303951,
0.0624274276,
-0.4195263684,
0.5776197314,
0.4580799639,
0.6784003973,
-0.1924630553,
0.8165686131,
0.4627142847,
0.1458865106,
-0.0824786574,
0.0529995412,
-0.1218153238,
-0.635240376,
-0.1777183563,
-0.3482385278,
-0.3736321926,
0.2527061701,
-0.2997567654,
0.3948337436,
-0.3017442524,
-0.6206751466,
0.4911358356,
-0.2794140875,
-0.5077070594,
-0.2185313106,
0.3351245821,
0.5249717236,
-1.0475811958,
0.5749533772,
0.7455773354,
-0.4573988616,
-0.5431694984,
-0.3540740311,
0.2609763145,
-0.3923875093,
0.7135539651,
-0.0384913906,
-0.3210707009,
-0.1326776445,
-1.1202278137,
-0.3703375161,
0.748949945,
0.3749847114,
-0.4248223305,
-0.0899528936,
-0.0278030075,
0.2815029323,
-0.6424686909,
0.3678104579,
0.5303738713,
0.6626036167,
0.4099671245,
-0.4873981774,
0.0591019578,
-0.1349480748,
-0.0576349683,
0.0675216466,
-0.2160348445,
1.0164585114,
-0.1541476399,
-0.3329652846,
-0.0289482716,
0.336674273,
0.2552838326,
0.3930163085,
0.8245788813,
0.0215701871,
0.4016004503,
-0.2052630782,
0.7398348451,
0.0480880775,
-0.1033255011,
0.6694871783,
-0.5312047601,
0.1884793192,
0.2909543216,
0.1769343615,
0.5329148173,
0.4461692274,
-0.1156651452,
0.6403898001,
0.1403476,
-0.247209087,
-0.7539553642,
-0.1911951154,
-0.2810204923,
0.6659461856,
0.5767114162,
-0.2432331294,
-0.3689215183,
0.3334292173,
-0.2761992812,
0.4473148286,
-0.0914779827,
1.0452228785,
-0.2498064488,
-0.6054204702,
0.3542117178,
-0.4426298141,
0.6501815319,
-0.924130857,
-0.7118099928,
0.0592064038,
0.2232702076,
-0.0233110804,
-1.0292519331,
-0.2285056561,
-0.4899665713,
-0.198090449,
-0.1212692261,
0.6275656223,
-0.54814291,
-0.2456347048,
0.3893173635,
0.2854660153,
0.120576255,
-0.0291813239,
-0.6351824403,
0.2648593485,
0.116447635,
-0.0406883657,
0.1564927995,
0.4040892422,
-0.1686474383,
0.6482980251,
0.725935638,
-0.2605531216,
-0.1715398878,
0.2954019308,
0.8450883627,
-0.6477313042,
-0.4673674703,
-0.93978405,
0.530534327,
-0.3168365359,
-0.1409941912,
0.92995435,
0.2367221117,
0.130633682,
-0.3829895258,
0.731528163,
-0.0437361635,
0.2083039284,
-0.2881473601,
0.5803516507,
-0.4020658135,
-0.2357169688,
-0.573314786,
-0.7844364047,
0.1650238037,
0.4143402576,
-0.1323847175,
-0.2897529304,
0.3074775934,
0.8756775856,
0.1338093877,
0.4056147635,
0.4110077024,
-0.0539628156,
0.4711677432,
0.5455265045,
1.121045351,
-0.0375253633,
0.8040432334,
-0.1590023339,
-0.3681253195,
-0.0693893284,
-0.8322400451,
-1.3165819645,
-1.0432184935,
-0.0673417524,
-0.3762479424,
-0.1392181218,
0.8833554387,
0.7964859605,
-0.5052192807,
-0.3686434925,
0.4008201659,
0.0790600181,
-0.3222050965,
-0.1956180632,
-0.0616238862,
0.1666669399,
-0.6221147776,
0.4956834018,
0.0565584712,
0.0355794318,
-0.3620129824,
-0.1674226671,
-0.6330228448,
0.3161401451,
0.7393855453,
0.2140821069,
-0.8285243511,
-0.285367161,
0.3533681035,
-0.1393523961,
-0.1226186082,
0.9887939692,
-0.8777070045,
0.800157249,
0.522981286,
-0.160967648,
0.476829052,
0.2182665169,
0.9245257378,
-0.5335463881,
0.5563799739,
0.189430058,
0.2270667106,
0.3876162767,
-0.2291869372,
0.4371378124,
-0.0198025536,
-0.4540492594,
-0.5597712994,
0.381433934,
-0.7030773759,
-0.1873229444,
0.9428622127,
0.1880579144,
-0.1806358844,
-0.4566333294,
-0.7413952351,
0.0314157009,
-0.7565341592,
0.6051934958,
1.1005026102,
-0.2525158823,
-0.4181277454,
-0.1886898577,
0.802400887,
0.0434260406,
-0.6646491885,
0.3773295283,
1.0705639124,
-0.1410540938,
0.4493211806,
0.76517272,
0.0539009497,
0.4198455513,
0.4771932065,
0.1191344112,
-0.1195929572,
-0.2699322999,
-0.3045057058,
-0.126214847,
-0.2647379339,
-0.2853233218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08661v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08661v1 | EffMulti: Efficiently Modeling Complex Multimodal Interactions for Emotion Analysis | 2022-12-16T03:05:55 | 2022-12-16T03:05:55 | Feng Qiu, Chengyang Xie, Yu Ding, Wanzeng Kong | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Humans are skilled in reading the interlocutor's emotion from multimodal
signals, including spoken words, simultaneous speech, and facial expressions.
It is still a challenge to effectively decode emotions from the complex
interactions of multimodal signals. In this paper, we design three kinds of
multimodal latent representations to refine the emotion analysis process and
capture complex multimodal interactions from different views, including a
intact three-modal integrating representation, a modality-shared
representation, and three modality-individual representations. Then, a
modality-semantic hierarchical fusion is proposed to reasonably incorporate
these representations into a comprehensive interaction representation. The
experimental results demonstrate that our EffMulti outperforms the
state-of-the-art methods. The compelling performance benefits from its
well-designed framework with ease of implementation, lower computing
complexity, and less trainable parameters. | [
-0.6111764312,
-0.7562589645,
0.3887776136,
0.4774870574,
-0.2020579278,
0.0771242306,
-0.0277339928,
-0.5490695834,
0.3087895215,
-0.3379094601,
-0.6205563545,
-0.0649874732,
-0.5815745592,
-0.1507331431,
0.0436793081,
0.6975355148,
-0.2716196477,
0.1908548325,
-0.0254220534,
-0.2604449391,
0.0628920719,
-0.6169385314,
-0.3027296066,
-0.3820053637,
0.7913389802,
0.2718529105,
0.3393787444,
-0.4006147385,
0.4895140529,
0.3343847692,
0.1864612103,
0.2164593637,
-0.7272206545,
0.3766599596,
0.2103507519,
-0.1477563679,
-0.6291726828,
0.264945358,
0.3653506637,
0.5092933774,
-0.1688547432,
-0.1931388229,
0.0379772671,
0.3129257262,
-0.9993088841,
0.2351871133,
0.1768793017,
0.2649795115,
-0.1824154556,
-0.4987460673,
-0.4449647367,
-0.0347687639,
0.0053214328,
-0.3342793882,
-0.30321908,
0.1232542843,
0.6200066209,
0.1545955241,
-0.952370286,
-0.162414968,
-0.7006796598,
0.7342063785,
-0.5267542601,
0.568785131,
0.0310158413,
0.2426304519,
-0.1175461411,
-0.4199997783,
-0.8468605876,
-0.0839284658,
-0.2923784256,
0.5778113604,
-0.5259230137,
0.3921504915,
-0.0148485843,
0.332283318,
-0.5948539376,
-0.2334628254,
0.0369096585,
-0.2307984382,
0.5227734447,
0.3538804948,
0.2312076837,
-0.366328001,
-0.3593450487,
-0.1879472882,
-0.0465723276,
0.1589610875,
0.4004684687,
-0.2926771641,
-0.3525184393,
0.4544230103,
-0.0813428536,
0.5437850952,
0.04276466,
-0.2752165794,
0.4601411521,
-0.3700673282,
-0.2497973144,
-0.2873180211,
0.7677420974,
0.5410256982,
-0.2449536175,
-0.0642972216,
-0.152919054,
0.1480162591,
0.129873395,
-0.8254862428,
-0.1593135893,
0.5811957121,
-0.7010361552,
-0.2153425962,
0.0906955451,
-1.2358279228,
-0.3487000763,
-0.338398993,
0.6114162207,
-0.5737840533,
-0.77535218,
-0.11413344,
-0.0842622519,
0.30180493,
0.507822156,
-0.6524811387,
0.353543818,
0.4009582698,
0.8279435635,
-0.104042381,
-0.2450970411,
-0.5860875249,
0.1562053859,
0.1217492968,
0.5865142345,
-0.8056188822,
-0.3815279901,
-0.1543911397,
-0.1350159049,
-0.286352247,
-0.0593509972,
0.4248766005,
-0.5580083728,
0.1444035321,
0.0617838725,
-0.4306849539,
-0.3989890814,
0.3776037097,
-0.9791210294,
0.5719171166,
0.0351946801,
-0.8685824275,
-0.1730428487,
-0.9232504368,
-0.2373505086,
-0.3152981102,
0.0204477217,
-0.2083718777,
0.4245883226,
0.0064429347,
0.7180278897,
-0.17786856,
0.3446498811,
-0.4848277867,
-0.1747406721,
0.2378884107,
-0.3560551703,
0.3391044736,
0.6671065688,
-0.2300564498,
0.2744138241,
-0.6805053949,
-0.0897894949,
-0.1449942142,
-0.2570434213,
-0.1931733936,
-0.2113228589,
0.4900704622,
0.3713962138,
0.0546117872,
-0.6586453319,
-0.137365222,
0.202660799,
0.2812971175,
0.6635366082,
-0.0804193988,
0.6782793999,
-0.0736036897,
0.5435528755,
0.6452248096,
0.0603484437,
-0.3612139225,
-0.2644930482,
-0.5412737727,
-0.5020612478,
0.0412182659,
0.1808893681,
-0.8549617529,
-0.1452299803,
-0.171360746,
-0.5441612601,
-0.4249829054,
-0.2903250754,
0.3822747171,
0.2451285124,
0.028145371,
-0.2625360191,
-0.4046393931,
-0.8806295395,
-0.1081949845,
-0.1185801029,
0.059706971,
0.2181051075,
0.3756608963,
-0.4202973843,
1.0205535889,
-0.3879995644,
0.0409888998,
-0.1121469364,
0.8391783834,
-0.2449610531,
0.5869535208,
0.705548048,
-1.0782418251,
-0.1839915812,
0.1152169481,
-0.6652985215,
-0.1970909983,
-0.2115102112,
-0.4064844549,
0.0835427493,
0.2461508512,
-0.3552436531,
0.2900651395,
0.8550028205,
-0.3843029737,
0.0931279436,
-0.0874582902,
0.6653634906,
-1.0658271313,
0.2707725763,
0.1446319669,
-0.0222807806,
-1.0018165112,
0.0130711971,
0.1634316295,
-0.2479750663,
-0.5358313322,
0.3358845711,
-0.4770895541,
0.1228012145,
0.1159554422,
0.0481434092,
0.0616773777,
0.8575468659,
0.0494712517,
0.160773322,
0.2310231924,
-0.3378250897,
0.5643101335,
-0.1034469232,
0.2145414203,
0.99128443,
-0.368478179,
0.1396707147,
-0.458494544,
0.4200504124,
-1.3154866695,
-0.6716387272,
0.3874189258,
-0.3860448301,
0.4995914698,
0.1235621497,
-0.3961958885,
0.0000774884,
-0.5201773047,
0.5335268974,
0.160304904,
-0.4535357058,
1.6413236856,
0.2757564783,
-0.2447512448,
-0.3069440424,
-0.6287322044,
-0.0968660042,
-0.2260677218,
-0.971890986,
0.3152618706,
-0.209740296,
-0.2073710114,
-0.0444621444,
0.1693126261,
-0.3172878325,
0.0125400322,
0.5400143266,
0.1505806297,
0.0965240747,
0.1969699115,
0.1305018663,
-0.1146560907,
-0.1466750205,
0.5922356248,
0.5100076199,
-0.2849287093,
-0.6529829502,
-0.6535936594,
0.9527767301,
0.9089584947,
-0.3257341385,
0.4548129737,
1.1558368206,
-0.5821531415,
0.4005226493,
-0.5378009677,
0.0762164816,
-0.3814365566,
0.4204238057,
-0.6566588879,
-0.7979436517,
0.4631686807,
-0.3708276153,
-0.0240596309,
0.0787905604,
0.618062973,
-0.1832399666,
1.2971947193,
0.5383684635,
0.0936353281,
0.5873392224,
-0.1315947622,
0.4425424635,
-0.9151450992,
-0.6548796892,
-0.1837224513,
-0.5739976168,
-0.193525508,
-0.3805820942,
0.4452944398,
-0.0109084109,
-0.0528668985,
-0.2502877414,
0.0643488243,
0.0627636686,
0.2309776843,
0.1125526428,
0.0997871086,
-0.0017512236,
0.0045127175,
-0.2481946051,
-0.3856061399,
-0.3683145642,
0.4313947856,
0.5812992454,
1.1434434652,
0.73979038,
0.730427742,
0.0754197314,
0.4316457212,
-0.8793897033,
0.2820442617,
0.1932261735,
-0.3484568298,
0.1302061081,
-0.4781636596,
-0.7117189169,
0.6466289759,
-0.5246140361,
-0.7630078793,
0.6246317625,
-0.008640511,
-0.3970655203,
0.1631032825,
-1.2369441986,
0.8412253857,
-0.1544299275,
-0.4149540663,
-0.3813340664,
-0.6646693349,
0.5783694983,
-0.0635788068,
0.3485688865,
0.0593752824,
0.0067079836,
0.6581579447,
-0.2426751256,
0.8819969296,
-0.2820207477,
-0.0662490577,
0.058764074,
0.2974717319,
0.0857392028,
-0.1159870476,
-0.048848778,
-0.021650007,
0.1036247462,
-0.4039534032,
-0.8360009789,
0.6412757039,
-0.8324826956,
-0.2205136865,
-0.347281009,
-0.5067238212,
-0.2930106819,
-0.3224052191,
-0.069020994,
0.6333408356,
-0.2607856095,
0.0411288366,
0.4204525054,
0.109094739,
0.5421839356,
0.2837630212,
-0.0259819329,
-0.4802022576,
1.0464516878,
-0.178356111,
0.1429257095,
0.18316181,
0.0559289418,
-0.0799276829,
0.0652144924,
-0.1385337561,
0.1416733414,
-0.7669638991,
-0.158126846,
-0.959225595,
0.1544617712,
-0.2409241796,
-0.1116204336,
-0.1237187907,
-0.1475531757,
-0.3467670381,
0.0254137199,
0.1810478121,
0.7027651668,
-0.3769429624,
0.3432250321,
-1.0554349422,
0.408451438,
0.6083809733,
0.4650719762,
0.3433214426,
0.0199755281,
0.0667540953,
-0.0136451358,
-0.464746505,
-1.1932041645,
0.5310801268,
0.501386404,
0.5333896279,
0.725168705,
0.0573400259,
0.9587080479,
-0.1364925951,
0.8329712749,
0.6136006713,
-1.1904306412,
0.3490541279,
-0.0463706851,
0.0374405161,
0.1581614017,
0.6333184838,
-0.6084076166,
0.0356432535,
-0.4266212583,
-0.7672842145,
0.9307517409,
0.451226294,
-0.0328598879,
0.1434193105,
-0.0026513229,
-0.0251277667,
-0.0051389188,
-0.4730237424,
-0.0019249049,
-0.3976539969,
-0.6525676847,
0.0531054512,
-0.4891037345,
-0.2838020623,
-0.0690847412,
0.2053294331,
-0.1316772848,
0.5538634658,
0.1824084371,
-0.5563833714,
-0.1556193531,
0.2591836452,
0.6242036819,
-0.0693258271,
-0.3743228018,
0.4518500566,
-0.0579123944,
-0.4227845073,
0.2842171788,
0.2046417147,
0.8462336659,
-0.0185373574,
0.5542087555,
0.7705310583,
0.4670752287,
-0.7345292568,
0.7639352083,
-0.45472911,
0.1684242785,
0.0185756572,
-0.365255177,
0.2257214785,
0.6690826416,
0.2625653744,
0.0185713861,
0.5433684587,
-0.6325944066,
0.2244570255,
0.032227505,
-0.4630850554,
-0.6188659072,
0.3579716682,
0.6566891074,
0.0955704376,
0.4049129188,
-0.1528485864,
-0.6466822624,
0.2178213894,
0.2050263435,
0.7136970162,
-0.427729249,
0.1554040164,
0.2334851027,
-0.2761776149,
0.3545663357,
0.4047504067,
-0.2324025333,
-0.6736798286,
-0.3267320693,
-0.5166844726,
-0.3989870548,
-0.4436799586,
-0.7233999968,
-0.0287119336,
-0.1291864365,
-0.2260635793,
-0.0211817231,
-0.3266322613,
-0.6629257798,
0.1480348259,
0.5731918812,
0.4017772377,
-0.9735007286,
0.4782817066,
0.7838657498,
-0.5044974685,
-0.5687992573,
-0.2187117934,
0.4266938567,
-0.3195520937,
0.9548537135,
0.1892549396,
-0.5155532956,
-0.2159789056,
-0.4734084904,
-0.5478802323,
1.0810475349,
0.291133076,
-0.3917560279,
0.1311305165,
-0.1666757613,
0.3702559471,
-0.5998129249,
0.8047742844,
0.5870035291,
0.4788197875,
0.4604817331,
-0.7693502903,
-0.0851401687,
-0.8011758327,
0.062427368,
0.0662591979,
-0.6483591795,
1.0724937916,
0.0964460671,
-0.464515835,
-0.2534610629,
0.5607807636,
0.0458141081,
0.3835566342,
0.6862737536,
0.5440725684,
0.5905119777,
-0.3091974556,
1.0487143993,
-0.2370793372,
0.451559037,
0.7708448768,
-0.2120022774,
0.8911294937,
0.6880018711,
0.126704976,
0.4205498099,
0.7937035561,
0.532512784,
0.4596105218,
-0.0461248867,
-0.4690924883,
-0.4527362585,
-0.1709006727,
-0.0602748469,
0.6292851567,
0.4811034501,
0.1296905726,
-0.4032843113,
0.3551416993,
-0.0536514819,
-0.4003432393,
-0.0766884238,
0.7053182721,
-0.0377369076,
-0.0711088255,
0.3531992435,
-0.2856918275,
0.9338162541,
-0.4525389969,
-0.2712650597,
-0.1055454314,
-0.1173593923,
-0.5092810988,
-0.6593918204,
0.1213321313,
-0.1386931837,
0.0771643594,
-0.0079014534,
0.5748548508,
-0.7059960961,
-0.0526844561,
0.4992806017,
0.4519235492,
0.1673868597,
-0.0938005149,
-0.374192059,
0.5551277399,
-0.2233738154,
-0.6184339523,
0.0984444246,
0.4308451712,
0.1531352103,
0.4969395101,
0.4445092678,
-0.4893753231,
0.0796878785,
0.3680310547,
0.993857801,
-0.7232381105,
-0.2194083631,
-0.6954014301,
0.9817287326,
-0.1830274016,
-0.0545531102,
0.1266248226,
0.0429940857,
0.3319470882,
-0.0516350903,
0.6068934202,
-0.3108082116,
-0.0211293139,
-0.4677717388,
0.6358657479,
-0.8879232407,
-0.3251535892,
-0.5820733905,
-0.7968278527,
-0.3615245521,
0.648866415,
0.1118125319,
0.1487066895,
0.6902378201,
0.5989955664,
-0.1501630396,
0.2831844091,
0.4596923292,
0.2571173906,
0.5477986932,
0.8854703307,
1.1221885681,
-0.2462386638,
0.379730612,
-0.2781146765,
-0.5184332132,
-0.5324274898,
-0.8287111521,
-0.4521539807,
-0.8221236467,
-0.2246901989,
-0.1604027599,
-0.4508265555,
1.0619912148,
0.7870361805,
-0.5582583547,
-0.0546599589,
0.624250114,
-0.2486100942,
0.0431175604,
-0.2152819037,
0.0937973186,
-0.1099667624,
-1.0737520456,
-0.0266791359,
0.4388576448,
0.0537833534,
-0.4287369847,
-0.3847736716,
-0.2004602253,
0.1207043231,
1.0159389973,
-0.2046826929,
-0.6931073666,
-0.2578562796,
-0.1515226811,
-0.0855383426,
-0.0738953874,
0.9509554505,
-0.340585351,
0.8404311538,
0.6921007633,
0.494844079,
0.5698970556,
-0.1557582021,
0.6230928898,
-0.4800558388,
0.2128600627,
0.1159997582,
0.7579951286,
0.3708601296,
-0.1848078221,
0.311673075,
0.042759899,
-0.0453575663,
-0.6301272511,
0.4430636764,
-1.4102584124,
-0.0591716282,
0.9689586759,
-0.3562825918,
-0.4346426725,
0.0199386757,
-0.5675387383,
0.3123188913,
-0.5469008684,
0.3905729055,
0.8385741115,
-0.5398142934,
-0.5162469149,
-0.0735989586,
-0.0059653809,
0.2282477468,
-0.6933965087,
-0.1923042834,
0.7378852963,
-0.0163401756,
0.475209862,
0.4971323609,
-0.2724761665,
0.2099175155,
0.0287695974,
0.2591424286,
0.0378251374,
-0.1551270485,
-0.6644195914,
0.4861313105,
-0.2939010859,
-0.0457887277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08216v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08216v2 | Azimuth: Systematic Error Analysis for Text Classification | 2022-12-16T01:10:41 | 2022-12-19T04:01:57 | Gabrielle Gauthier-Melançon, Orlando Marquez Ayala, Lindsay Brin, Chris Tyler, Frédéric Branchaud-Charron, Joseph Marinier, Karine Grande, Di Le | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | We present Azimuth, an open-source and easy-to-use tool to perform error
analysis for text classification. Compared to other stages of the ML
development cycle, such as model training and hyper-parameter tuning, the
process and tooling for the error analysis stage are less mature. However, this
stage is critical for the development of reliable and trustworthy AI systems.
To make error analysis more systematic, we propose an approach comprising
dataset analysis and model quality assessment, which Azimuth facilitates. We
aim to help AI practitioners discover and address areas where the model does
not generalize by leveraging and integrating a range of ML techniques, such as
saliency maps, similarity, uncertainty, and behavioral analyses, all in one
tool. Our code and documentation are available at
github.com/servicenow/azimuth. | [
-0.2781040072,
-0.5450518727,
0.3141665459,
0.3252648711,
-0.2222682387,
-0.2386678457,
-0.081559293,
-0.3434379399,
-0.4165942073,
0.5844091773,
-0.7596619129,
-0.9899833202,
-0.5542469621,
0.0565135032,
-0.8303300738,
1.2637102604,
-0.1328620762,
0.1901273876,
-0.508657217,
-0.4147631526,
-0.3339962065,
-0.1984037459,
-0.6257938147,
-0.1591174901,
0.8655257821,
0.8719109893,
0.6821777821,
0.4859205186,
1.2708692551,
0.2103895247,
0.5884327292,
0.2184115946,
-0.1656393558,
0.4254001677,
-0.1438997388,
-0.4089820683,
-0.5711213946,
0.427970022,
0.5880791545,
0.5532212257,
-0.2354983091,
0.502643764,
-0.1002711728,
0.6872222424,
-0.5932501554,
0.2041001022,
-0.2097129226,
0.0406188443,
-0.3858891129,
-0.2548446953,
-0.5641772747,
-0.5063554049,
0.1759709865,
-0.6434800029,
0.3684442341,
0.56126827,
0.8716660142,
0.6531302929,
-0.0511766337,
-0.1703983098,
-0.978932023,
1.1484484673,
-0.7155176401,
0.1480054706,
0.4769637585,
0.666873455,
-0.0818946585,
-0.7342118025,
-0.8208248019,
-0.100639075,
-0.0512618199,
0.016682528,
-0.0534001552,
0.1883576661,
0.1777776778,
0.257324636,
-0.6453765035,
0.0199826434,
-0.3428425491,
0.0161877535,
0.992580235,
0.1418030709,
0.716576755,
0.1195361018,
-0.2610767484,
-0.2646744847,
-0.2432077527,
-0.1157449186,
0.5333402753,
0.3170058131,
-0.0603402965,
0.6449910402,
-0.0920582786,
0.787684679,
-0.336214453,
0.0153745068,
-0.0108782779,
-0.2135953605,
-0.2476560026,
-0.0463508479,
0.968110621,
0.3396694362,
0.0744915754,
-0.023949353,
-0.1635762155,
-0.0884861946,
0.6307711005,
-0.6619153619,
-0.369168818,
0.618424952,
-0.5033721924,
-0.5978932977,
0.6412339211,
-0.8708227873,
-0.7094793916,
-0.3022352457,
0.2764260471,
-0.3676398993,
-0.1152551174,
-0.0799140185,
-0.4051154852,
0.4212796688,
0.5466318727,
-0.2950415313,
0.2140045166,
0.7744017839,
0.8845251799,
-0.3842386603,
-0.5396615863,
-0.2852882147,
-0.1804052293,
-0.294400245,
0.9479988813,
-0.4662463963,
-0.1067559272,
-0.1399681866,
-0.3669679463,
-0.105725728,
-0.1329132766,
0.8771255016,
-0.5638183355,
0.3968830705,
0.3063909113,
-0.4057588875,
-0.7554841638,
0.3928138018,
-0.759549737,
1.0056941509,
0.3747086525,
-0.9481106997,
0.4627031088,
-0.915481627,
-0.1381600797,
-0.0960480422,
-0.0072181863,
-0.9354818463,
-0.1753741354,
-0.0797858238,
0.4446777999,
-0.4050301313,
-0.0845223963,
-0.4487608969,
-0.3305464089,
0.2867619395,
-0.2329585403,
0.952839911,
0.1176784113,
-0.4860272706,
0.5267012715,
-0.9761613607,
0.2389178723,
-0.0837052017,
0.1251361668,
-0.4083443582,
0.3960780203,
0.2466452122,
-0.1864143759,
0.0335648246,
-0.2945904136,
0.2528353035,
-0.1787472963,
-0.0114244558,
0.3102724552,
-0.0093137082,
0.4568499029,
-0.3009676635,
0.5765051246,
0.0527458042,
0.3769260347,
-0.1211107522,
-0.5496732593,
-0.9847257137,
-0.3618608415,
0.4672802687,
0.7431612015,
-0.2878097296,
0.7586182952,
-0.213432163,
-0.9853540659,
-0.5751095414,
0.3076283932,
0.1731308401,
0.2500128448,
0.4234746695,
-0.3067972958,
-0.4648044407,
-0.6794044971,
-0.1783745736,
-0.3539500535,
-0.0610185675,
-0.0069383141,
0.3324851692,
-0.5228627324,
1.0462555885,
-0.2244190574,
-0.7330953479,
-0.3257225156,
0.5298391581,
-0.1343529522,
0.5407073498,
0.6241512895,
-1.0140743256,
-0.3979967833,
0.0868507326,
-0.7944655418,
0.0024753138,
-0.1677684635,
-0.216395691,
0.0967753232,
0.3253988028,
-0.5820117593,
0.5643160343,
0.4319567382,
-0.4378937185,
0.4827487171,
0.0008846085,
0.2730915844,
-0.7160739303,
0.279281348,
-0.0109581035,
0.0573024526,
-0.5892862082,
0.2197411507,
-0.0516738668,
0.0616749264,
-0.0420079194,
0.2129012197,
-0.3230391145,
0.0305687673,
-0.3121066093,
-0.0040620854,
0.024369441,
0.1111674681,
-0.2408220917,
0.7090483308,
0.5121460557,
-0.5606774688,
0.6971397996,
0.110939756,
-0.1736410558,
0.685618639,
-0.6449232101,
0.2481014282,
-0.2024131715,
-0.1095612124,
-1.1224585772,
-0.681935966,
0.7565515041,
-0.9210960269,
0.28966555,
-0.0455602333,
-0.2759900093,
-0.2923985422,
-0.4244509935,
0.4276070595,
0.2748832107,
-0.3690484762,
0.7715185881,
0.1691121161,
-0.1391250789,
-0.7887178063,
-0.5224174857,
-0.2494696528,
-0.2220021486,
-0.5273541808,
-0.0245955028,
0.1423084438,
-0.6359127164,
0.1764804423,
0.1176279634,
-0.4467187226,
0.1802448183,
0.4100424647,
0.3264205456,
-0.2417744547,
-0.1423003972,
0.0319463424,
-0.3440609574,
0.0480643138,
-0.3594551682,
0.1241262332,
-0.0336850174,
-0.6706076264,
-0.7343534827,
0.0991999134,
0.9746823907,
-0.4267631471,
0.5849083066,
0.6019641757,
-0.4913090467,
-0.7369337082,
-0.2019042969,
0.0622448809,
-0.4254897833,
0.2573465705,
0.2350034416,
-0.1427102983,
0.2836073041,
0.4366809428,
0.5404612422,
0.6293110847,
0.2086496055,
-0.4113561809,
0.9553414583,
0.9707601666,
-0.170571506,
0.3720904887,
-0.2062526941,
0.2243511379,
-0.2536821067,
-0.2104242295,
-0.9934159517,
-0.2659116387,
-0.1889467239,
-0.3833049536,
0.125140518,
-0.093184799,
-0.1832762808,
0.0694583952,
-0.5938575864,
0.4413018525,
0.8532273173,
-0.1542636752,
0.3158227801,
0.0747897997,
0.4989230335,
-0.2128662318,
-0.4620803595,
-0.6837361455,
1.0814487934,
0.2364958078,
0.7323893309,
-0.1015777588,
0.6377879381,
0.6153560281,
0.6845247746,
-1.0288152695,
0.3539818525,
0.1259877831,
-0.5740195513,
-0.6436039209,
-0.365894258,
-0.6440727711,
0.0623346642,
-0.3743909001,
-0.3812781274,
-0.0364996381,
0.217790857,
-0.5562744141,
0.3249132037,
-0.5320600867,
1.0346814394,
0.0080138892,
-0.0598803088,
-0.277341485,
-0.5520482063,
0.4885331094,
0.0360839255,
0.1703163981,
-0.1672208011,
0.0036680503,
0.7977875471,
-0.3222253919,
0.7969619036,
-0.2176743448,
0.2689713538,
0.6316590309,
0.1313469261,
0.3307348788,
-0.1715674549,
-0.1932277977,
0.2973320782,
0.0036518273,
-0.3308796287,
-0.911242187,
0.4338293076,
-0.9545943737,
-0.132734552,
-0.8731464148,
-0.5063703656,
-0.0123880291,
0.3834516108,
0.0609554164,
0.1513733268,
-0.1477965415,
0.1667581499,
0.6400526762,
0.0663936585,
0.266166091,
0.277249068,
-0.1458123773,
-0.3551704884,
0.9539126158,
0.0983033553,
-0.2923067808,
0.1671779454,
0.0524539724,
-0.0019479062,
-1.0476822853,
-0.4419165552,
-0.0234710611,
-0.5202013254,
-0.4672652781,
-0.4186247885,
-0.2816490531,
-0.2990782559,
-0.0371273682,
-0.4232091904,
-0.3972775042,
-0.2488055974,
-0.0115069635,
0.5731195211,
0.6691881418,
0.2571435869,
0.6568797231,
-0.8828958273,
0.1569963098,
-0.0968163684,
0.438881129,
-0.1998721659,
-0.2880253494,
-0.2751911283,
-0.2288216352,
-0.437052995,
-0.7399070859,
0.2840158641,
0.3254008591,
0.5163831711,
0.8169749975,
0.412448734,
0.3121560216,
-0.1912785769,
0.8001740575,
-0.0522944443,
-0.6607623696,
0.6259422302,
-0.3207630217,
-0.1232536584,
0.8739753962,
0.5509556532,
-0.5642273426,
-0.5436480641,
-0.5876969099,
-0.8435877562,
0.861427784,
0.3492571414,
-0.3040126264,
0.5565950274,
0.4403147995,
0.2138510942,
0.0964770392,
-0.4880821407,
-0.2806603312,
-0.1396120042,
-0.8665064573,
-0.1319575459,
-0.0032674614,
-0.2314859629,
-0.196233511,
0.8912873864,
-0.1279721111,
0.1978010237,
0.3178650439,
-0.2438828051,
-0.2750432491,
-0.016060533,
0.4185986221,
0.6645610332,
-0.1554151922,
0.1764300764,
-0.0967992172,
-0.7916854024,
-0.0086714271,
0.1931962818,
-0.5368519425,
0.1226364896,
0.5074971914,
0.1096782759,
-0.0430168621,
-0.4509918988,
0.6060326099,
-0.1268408895,
0.0868164971,
-0.5216996074,
0.4725584388,
-0.3933065832,
0.1304280758,
0.3302763104,
0.3666142523,
0.4640718102,
-0.034991961,
0.381534189,
0.2681496441,
-0.6268031001,
-0.2206104845,
0.5481566787,
0.2226103097,
-0.3704305291,
0.8418671489,
-0.1308465153,
-0.3842519224,
0.7718372345,
-0.0834610537,
1.1673271656,
-0.1546820998,
0.3170082867,
0.4795749784,
0.4263786674,
-0.1509759873,
-0.0417541713,
-0.0513672233,
-0.7585304379,
-0.1133340523,
-0.5518394709,
-0.8920285702,
-0.3903016448,
-0.715061903,
0.4579351842,
-0.8590331078,
-0.1577389985,
0.0259032436,
0.0362299308,
-0.3206890225,
0.213589251,
-0.1706724763,
0.8692073226,
-0.6265572906,
0.596568346,
0.8493917584,
-0.56431216,
-0.4159689248,
0.0219985303,
0.3111771345,
-0.3262551427,
0.3188402057,
0.3731375933,
-0.3980912566,
-0.0148069309,
-1.0169522762,
-0.6191895604,
1.2465213537,
-0.2102933377,
-0.2825557888,
0.1020517573,
0.0626713783,
0.4479733706,
-0.2627852857,
0.2879980505,
0.424454689,
0.6694276929,
-0.1681807339,
-0.5849632621,
-0.1630174667,
-0.1266175807,
-0.3576744497,
0.1061495245,
-0.5663117766,
0.5250126719,
-0.3474039137,
-0.2687134147,
0.138798818,
1.0130491257,
0.0016085533,
0.8512752652,
0.3273382485,
0.36268273,
1.024422884,
-0.3221964538,
0.8594452143,
-0.1974406838,
0.5311217308,
0.947155416,
-0.1131459624,
0.9645002484,
0.4544675648,
-0.1918835193,
0.6112055779,
0.4967062771,
-0.338973552,
0.2077347338,
-0.1291589737,
-0.0657896176,
-0.1095778048,
0.3362823129,
-0.1206624582,
0.301697582,
0.3055928051,
-0.2421188354,
-0.2184711695,
-0.0049050022,
-0.0034928957,
0.059734568,
-0.2621974349,
0.5089992881,
0.0366493016,
-0.4765250683,
-0.1109913886,
0.2422685921,
0.6245852709,
-0.6336814761,
-0.1539013982,
-0.0329075828,
0.5637984872,
-0.4882004857,
-0.7133902311,
0.6417765617,
-0.0177613925,
-0.35537678,
0.0647705048,
0.850194037,
-0.2641943991,
-0.668674171,
0.0845282301,
0.1715826839,
0.085255146,
-0.1303168386,
-0.744002521,
0.0321605317,
-0.2743690312,
-0.3597377837,
-0.1743347198,
0.4014123082,
-0.1267306209,
0.9049831033,
0.6062299609,
0.0049933163,
-0.0523308367,
-0.1465675235,
0.3306537569,
-0.8408710361,
-0.235016495,
-0.7952692509,
0.6947058439,
-0.2785153091,
-0.4455129504,
1.0601092577,
0.2684279084,
0.754132688,
-0.0076124407,
0.8914980292,
-0.1216632947,
0.5352995992,
-0.152301833,
1.2361962795,
-0.4967363775,
0.0054721469,
-0.2494149357,
-0.9928438663,
-1.0302940607,
0.8219337463,
-0.1764314175,
-0.1905211955,
0.6627460122,
0.762149334,
-0.0984747335,
0.2357908636,
0.1356132627,
-0.0296541844,
0.2326322198,
-0.1814281344,
0.9406428933,
-0.5717009902,
0.5788779259,
-0.2644892931,
-0.551338613,
-0.31779176,
-0.613611877,
-0.9673476815,
-0.4279655218,
-0.6439402699,
-0.4603029788,
-0.0329382345,
1.0567833185,
0.6318489909,
-1.0147864819,
-0.0771126375,
-0.0739092454,
0.4714592993,
-0.4825210869,
-0.2716922164,
0.2699090838,
-0.6828232408,
-0.7281030416,
-0.095609583,
0.1936071217,
0.0153525406,
-0.4516797364,
-0.03298112,
0.2010665238,
0.1035061628,
0.3135645688,
0.4699183404,
-0.3347262144,
-0.2178910524,
-0.0447907932,
-0.2715235651,
-0.0185615905,
0.8910514116,
-0.0163212605,
0.2742596865,
0.7153078318,
0.5935432315,
-0.1004436687,
0.079834573,
0.6356933117,
-0.3794225752,
0.0606670156,
0.3983566165,
0.1457161754,
0.3090054393,
-0.3879788816,
0.3336871862,
0.2752513885,
-0.5933912992,
-1.02752316,
-0.0724286586,
-1.1011406183,
0.0283948053,
1.0698817968,
-0.2426457852,
-0.5470777154,
-0.2694159448,
-0.4795191884,
0.0997529551,
-0.1119654328,
0.8410205841,
0.9341934323,
-0.1966353506,
-0.00133856,
-0.5576171875,
0.7367113233,
0.139990747,
-0.9066801071,
0.0657400936,
0.6152345538,
0.2885000408,
0.3521344066,
0.2519866228,
-0.3038641214,
0.6112325788,
0.2659476101,
0.4603710175,
-0.0786764324,
-0.8250208497,
-0.3458223939,
0.2426402569,
0.3516135216,
-0.3172152936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08206v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08206v1 | Meeting Summarization: A Survey of the State of the Art | 2022-12-16T00:21:30 | 2022-12-16T00:21:30 | Lakshmi Prasanna Kumar, Arman Kabiri | cs.CL | cs.CL | Information overloading requires the need for summarizers to extract salient
information from the text. Currently, there is an overload of dialogue data due
to the rise of virtual communication platforms. The rise of Covid-19 has led
people to rely on online communication platforms like Zoom, Slack, Microsoft
Teams, Discord, etc. to conduct their company meetings. Instead of going
through the entire meeting transcripts, people can use meeting summarizers to
select useful data. Nevertheless, there is a lack of comprehensive surveys in
the field of meeting summarizers. In this survey, we aim to cover recent
meeting summarization techniques. Our survey offers a general overview of text
summarization along with datasets and evaluation metrics for meeting
summarization. We also provide the performance of each summarizer on a
leaderboard. We conclude our survey with different challenges in this domain
and potential research opportunities for future researchers. | [
-0.6070538759,
-0.5319577456,
0.2422797978,
0.1392204165,
-0.2164529562,
0.3790067136,
0.0604829825,
-0.8130266666,
0.5752399564,
-0.0259996988,
-0.5167105198,
-0.3196962178,
-0.3885138035,
0.0281776171,
-0.4668144286,
1.2519706488,
0.093843013,
-0.0305785537,
-0.6569519043,
-0.1605404913,
-0.2245123982,
-0.9746407866,
-0.3917683661,
-0.0949330106,
-0.0612844341,
0.356638521,
0.414883703,
0.0080539556,
0.6682700515,
0.3249347508,
-0.6350736022,
0.1896097511,
-0.7977056503,
0.1237475276,
0.0673151836,
-0.2894373834,
-0.6744158864,
0.1610283554,
0.4763168693,
0.7765360475,
-0.2387203425,
0.3704638481,
-0.1914806217,
0.7431316972,
-0.5055636168,
0.2165697366,
-0.38490659,
0.3678748906,
-0.039650213,
-0.1984284818,
0.2346939147,
-0.5074279904,
0.3877842724,
-0.469866842,
0.1200521737,
0.2692721188,
0.679090023,
0.022079058,
-0.1370792538,
-0.457888484,
-0.6560100913,
0.8048624396,
-0.5852178335,
0.2695706785,
0.1920341998,
0.4924745262,
-0.0365196764,
-0.8334692717,
-0.1466253251,
0.1790733635,
-0.0171907712,
0.5382817984,
-0.3430247903,
-0.1288026273,
0.1343835294,
0.9538747072,
-0.2988108397,
0.1436061114,
-0.6846306324,
0.0336179547,
0.606066823,
0.4722926915,
0.5653777719,
0.0804753155,
-0.2083944976,
0.3023579121,
-0.3458157778,
-0.1790916324,
-0.2769154906,
-0.3012866378,
-0.192167744,
0.3110029399,
-0.2837204933,
0.4970599413,
0.0663609356,
0.1540622413,
-0.0372410864,
-1.0773119926,
-0.1768533438,
0.3410757184,
0.7326370478,
1.3928509951,
0.0202343203,
-0.0072827977,
0.0590535589,
-0.4274208248,
-0.1756311804,
-0.8132699132,
-0.1630294174,
0.3156930506,
-0.4562830627,
-0.1752241701,
-0.0578494705,
-1.0878932476,
-0.4697428644,
-0.0843426511,
0.036177773,
0.0407824852,
-0.224985227,
-0.0056524277,
-0.8236655593,
0.2151181102,
0.7439761758,
-0.9351689816,
0.526142478,
0.5105875731,
1.1815624237,
-0.1651095748,
0.1154510453,
-0.3241769671,
-0.1533231437,
-0.3154857159,
0.5707559586,
0.0835810453,
-0.6749576926,
-0.0484909825,
-0.6540263891,
-0.0449505374,
-0.4711610377,
0.1513524801,
-0.1677217036,
0.8628258705,
-0.4067134261,
-0.4848556817,
-0.0435602404,
0.4301973283,
-0.4040583372,
0.8162695169,
-0.1016614214,
-0.8517481685,
0.5406993628,
-0.8379808664,
-0.2641646266,
0.0828980133,
-0.4743813574,
-0.6274415255,
0.1197395325,
0.5235103369,
0.3889880776,
-0.0873209611,
-0.1693606079,
0.2394675463,
-0.3901027441,
0.357947588,
0.3148709536,
0.5046749115,
0.3669320345,
0.0934754908,
0.1598187089,
-0.5977723598,
-0.1305048615,
-0.1334051043,
-0.2332485914,
-0.1551298797,
0.1315209121,
0.2763259411,
0.3147215843,
0.4176716506,
-0.4878783822,
0.0866246298,
-0.4397731423,
0.3841203749,
0.2162938565,
0.5534250736,
0.3195869923,
-0.5217952728,
0.5043370128,
-0.2240449041,
0.1644384116,
-0.2840723395,
-0.6814077497,
-0.2518621981,
-0.4288682938,
-0.0101020113,
0.5330790281,
-0.2325676084,
0.4622977078,
-0.4245342612,
-0.7793335319,
-0.3687719405,
-0.1667728424,
0.3230729401,
0.0283805281,
0.0956636891,
-0.2773399949,
-0.73320961,
-0.350438267,
-0.3209428787,
-0.0971905813,
0.0792158842,
0.2420331389,
0.4580101371,
0.2632339895,
1.0015605688,
-0.8109084964,
-0.4290273786,
-1.0341364145,
0.211596176,
0.2533848286,
0.1215869561,
0.7018649578,
-0.8700208068,
-0.3875906467,
0.0109882867,
-0.7210315466,
0.0042512449,
-0.091939114,
0.3644317985,
0.0742654577,
0.7951178551,
-0.3298923969,
0.3622309566,
0.4461301863,
-0.1379809082,
0.3816706836,
-0.1469759345,
0.5362413526,
-1.3157881498,
0.2470984161,
-0.2459898442,
-0.5094493628,
-0.7942186594,
0.0145609677,
-0.4786991477,
-0.3202720582,
-0.1787764132,
0.1231279448,
-0.655515492,
-0.1951181591,
-0.2503329217,
0.6112303734,
-0.0562939309,
0.3140974939,
-0.013756657,
0.6786630154,
0.3366551697,
-0.6865085363,
0.5445282459,
0.9302213192,
-0.4558243155,
0.4403863549,
-0.743309617,
-0.2540043294,
-0.3015019,
0.4613887966,
-1.0454022884,
-0.4830677211,
0.1386686414,
-0.635376215,
-0.1848406345,
0.2322820127,
-0.0945948064,
-0.2150607854,
-0.8971530795,
0.3348895609,
0.5059553981,
-0.2124708444,
0.2395774275,
0.8340661526,
-0.3811229169,
-0.2191977948,
-0.9747077227,
0.635412395,
-0.2018036395,
-0.2241607755,
0.132733494,
-0.2603513896,
-0.4467453063,
-0.3669093251,
-0.3628828228,
-0.2201159149,
0.0074171834,
0.4077523947,
0.1496617049,
0.2748586833,
-0.169749245,
-0.4557115138,
0.042133905,
-0.0429204553,
0.2957103252,
0.4882679284,
-0.1284533143,
-0.0446130931,
-0.7758747339,
0.6542429328,
0.7480878234,
-0.2210742682,
0.5961159468,
0.3182690144,
-0.3984225392,
0.5676929355,
-0.4326726794,
-0.0041241352,
-0.3450047374,
0.558606267,
0.2018831074,
-0.7794963717,
0.5561153889,
-0.411049962,
0.3753148317,
0.2809194922,
0.5421311259,
-0.0796940625,
0.7816433311,
0.6020848751,
-0.2574457526,
0.627661705,
-0.0986383036,
0.3600827456,
-0.4218022525,
-0.3289391994,
-0.5821547508,
-0.2856726646,
-0.3968495727,
0.191975072,
0.6109041572,
0.0286994111,
0.8235018849,
0.4854502678,
-0.4285493195,
0.3350470066,
0.4700799584,
-0.260006845,
0.4223857224,
-0.3140831292,
0.3768281639,
-0.1401388496,
-0.7676311135,
-0.1957170218,
0.3794008195,
0.0592242852,
0.4346133471,
0.1363984942,
0.6168364882,
0.2061145306,
-0.2062799186,
-0.7039957643,
0.6803597808,
0.2458675355,
-0.5350210667,
-0.5115001798,
-0.4688965082,
-0.7211699486,
0.1858300269,
-0.261179626,
-0.8644721508,
0.4279907048,
0.1884359717,
-0.3981425166,
0.1736706495,
-0.4656608403,
0.6716504097,
0.0864920318,
0.3638981283,
-0.2861807048,
-0.5893990397,
0.222340554,
-0.003909213,
0.3171757162,
-0.2181232274,
0.1517253965,
0.9829873443,
-0.4579289258,
0.5225457549,
0.1558320373,
-0.0154882558,
0.1505931616,
-0.5922858119,
0.362778008,
-0.2503547966,
0.0008408508,
0.0286853295,
0.2016683221,
-0.0918447897,
-0.5661817193,
0.3629517853,
-0.3199508488,
-0.2928370833,
-0.6588409543,
-0.2053597271,
-0.1323756576,
0.0419871509,
0.7033398747,
0.778273046,
-0.6897092462,
0.0845537484,
0.2216606438,
-0.1090729013,
0.7197952867,
0.0435646027,
-0.4080962539,
-0.8448218703,
0.9686797857,
0.3699831963,
0.3621288538,
0.4760892093,
0.0440633185,
0.0047487253,
-0.7245886922,
-0.3189863563,
-0.1967940629,
-0.3926135302,
0.0440837219,
-0.7662093043,
-0.3706643283,
-0.4379034042,
-0.2991174757,
-0.2364787757,
-1.0701805353,
-0.1212496981,
-0.1994765252,
0.1770190597,
0.7318707705,
0.202621758,
0.3022451103,
-0.7769877315,
0.3132937253,
0.2604131103,
0.1732476205,
-0.3075301647,
0.1904625595,
-0.6739013791,
-0.1514701396,
-0.3558017015,
-0.605851233,
0.2587473392,
0.4502545595,
0.4539380074,
0.469201237,
0.2188296467,
0.6947497129,
0.1037723571,
1.2340326309,
0.5763537884,
-0.7880823612,
0.6103397608,
-0.2268951237,
0.6143526435,
0.6423687935,
0.4079489708,
-1.0025689602,
-0.6459192634,
-0.5735313892,
-1.0690279007,
0.6635255814,
0.5598891973,
-0.3259842396,
0.3472305834,
0.0592774451,
-0.0413557068,
0.6087502837,
-0.1444628984,
-0.2753068805,
-0.1207806095,
-0.0588847511,
-0.0656797513,
-0.2378988862,
-0.0494259857,
0.0864819065,
0.4785330296,
0.446015209,
0.1858909726,
0.2693927288,
-0.0045978683,
-0.126219511,
0.5157573223,
0.7260909677,
1.2071180344,
-0.4433922768,
-0.2104897201,
0.3459078372,
-0.6500620246,
-0.3258703053,
-0.0995735899,
-0.1304065287,
0.3317219019,
0.2616118193,
0.5270910263,
0.1714506447,
-0.7115250826,
0.8360185623,
-0.379278928,
-0.23679474,
-0.1162343845,
0.0870224461,
-0.3397943377,
-0.0341574922,
0.4025132358,
0.0837487653,
0.6791327,
-0.8020631075,
-0.0215883385,
0.3179982007,
-0.5999695659,
-0.3219509721,
0.6807736754,
0.4344221354,
-0.1356780976,
0.1036444157,
0.1324971914,
-0.3183946311,
0.0853139982,
0.1620156914,
0.7220386863,
-0.117892772,
-0.0624485984,
0.3701308966,
0.0863189176,
0.1807975769,
0.2881423235,
-0.2275868952,
-0.0780442804,
-0.3092804253,
-0.1449091136,
-0.9140005708,
0.0064733028,
-0.548748672,
0.1193708032,
-0.1937208474,
-0.4908249378,
0.052688919,
-0.07959456,
-0.140886426,
0.0918028951,
-0.0586440079,
0.749247849,
-0.3675044477,
-0.400834322,
0.7737558484,
-0.4081228375,
0.2892464101,
-0.2358812243,
0.1575583667,
-0.2068227679,
-0.2088894695,
0.1435696185,
-0.1010563523,
-0.1376575679,
-0.4986561835,
-0.317066133,
1.0159440041,
-0.1115033776,
-0.4106875062,
-0.2019796669,
0.1555302441,
0.460739851,
0.1365971863,
0.2714406848,
0.3341769278,
0.1557275504,
0.1407093704,
-1.2374415398,
-0.1857275367,
-0.3432219028,
-0.2778542638,
0.2806402743,
-0.8085119128,
0.2987056077,
-0.1018424183,
-0.4662487507,
0.0341882966,
0.6680133343,
-0.0356288366,
0.7596929669,
0.130905658,
0.214372471,
0.5666263103,
-0.1749127954,
0.5320284367,
-0.1967961788,
0.1161693931,
1.2107646465,
0.1132550761,
0.5609492064,
0.3681187928,
-0.0941461474,
-0.1288233101,
0.329975754,
0.0045575299,
0.3327319622,
0.2641815543,
-0.1830265075,
0.0164491441,
-0.5054591894,
-0.5639910102,
0.4680495858,
0.4579620361,
-0.1210907996,
-0.5740117431,
0.0088630915,
0.0568007976,
0.0688110292,
-0.416378051,
1.4049504995,
0.1246638969,
-0.4733585715,
0.2272982597,
-0.1519524455,
0.4150187671,
-0.5771279931,
-0.0272872355,
-0.110513702,
-0.0276939608,
-0.3807461262,
-0.5654966235,
0.2163555175,
0.0168127865,
-0.0131319361,
-0.5393512249,
0.472086519,
-0.4133367836,
0.0802572146,
-0.3110259473,
0.5865916014,
0.5663563013,
-0.2541288435,
-0.0219978262,
0.1076367572,
-0.2315907478,
0.0902619287,
0.1385687739,
0.2807091773,
0.0123488577,
0.5652084351,
0.1269250065,
0.1054207906,
0.0019463671,
0.0119646108,
0.9071798921,
-0.757299304,
-0.8878903985,
-0.7584120631,
0.4463812113,
-0.5969802737,
-0.7062760592,
0.9973315001,
1.0509216785,
0.2206663489,
0.0001398817,
0.8382268548,
-0.0447623059,
0.5632323623,
-0.207847923,
0.8841741085,
-0.2933703959,
-0.2192429304,
-0.5070579052,
-0.5326394439,
-0.2153360695,
0.0231729522,
-0.0073705507,
-0.2343681157,
0.3232052028,
0.2362677604,
0.3594909608,
0.4397834539,
0.2709923983,
0.0256151166,
0.4330002069,
0.3550707698,
0.8290866613,
-0.5430421233,
0.6679333448,
0.1312706769,
-0.5531767607,
-0.8021927476,
-0.6732668281,
-0.9631624222,
-0.8603639603,
-0.6641768217,
0.2269711941,
0.2295086384,
1.1295626163,
0.4574186504,
-0.8168216944,
-0.1356937289,
0.0110428678,
-0.0277233012,
-0.4072496593,
-0.164320305,
0.2921527624,
-0.1759098321,
-0.6708316207,
0.3190449774,
0.4465323985,
0.4598867297,
0.2247246653,
0.3846993744,
-0.2919228971,
-0.0983282328,
0.5496160984,
0.5057107806,
-0.1233451441,
0.2308432609,
-0.2210908234,
-0.1630204469,
0.1725547612,
0.8347272873,
-0.334112525,
0.4757906795,
0.8666858077,
0.37812078,
0.5255823731,
0.2464318871,
0.9161090851,
-0.7238762975,
-0.343975395,
-0.055764731,
0.1474046707,
0.2740620971,
-0.4515551329,
0.4845688045,
0.0916941762,
-0.6872897148,
-0.6638416648,
-0.0337394327,
-1.1073961258,
0.0632606819,
0.6203747988,
0.1886895001,
0.004693653,
-0.4394537508,
-0.5411303043,
0.2736703753,
-0.4338157475,
1.0200487375,
0.7857251167,
-0.4643760622,
0.1246809512,
-0.2609910071,
0.9678285718,
-0.1415024549,
-1.1994744539,
0.0848556608,
0.5380939841,
-0.2966579795,
0.3600085676,
0.943043828,
-0.1393383741,
0.4583381116,
-0.2994371951,
-0.0139833977,
-0.1755303741,
-0.1073413789,
-0.1063237041,
0.2614498734,
-0.2528700531,
-0.4390214384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08205v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08205v1 | A unified information-theoretic model of EEG signatures of human language processing | 2022-12-16T00:15:45 | 2022-12-16T00:15:45 | Jiaxuan Li, Richard Futrell | cs.CL | cs.CL | We advance an information-theoretic model of human language processing in the
brain, in which incoming linguistic input is processed at two levels, in terms
of a heuristic interpretation and in terms of error correction. We propose that
these two kinds of information processing have distinct electroencephalographic
signatures, corresponding to the well-documented N400 and P600 components of
language-related event-related potentials (ERPs). Formally, we show that the
information content (surprisal) of a word in context can be decomposed into two
quantities: (A) heuristic surprise, which signals processing difficulty of word
given its inferred context, and corresponds with the N400 signal; and (B)
discrepancy signal, which reflects divergence between the true context and the
inferred context, and corresponds to the P600 signal. Both of these quantities
can be estimated using modern NLP techniques. We validate our theory by
successfully simulating ERP patterns elicited by a variety of linguistic
manipulations in previously-reported experimental data from Ryskin et al.
(2021). Our theory is in principle compatible with traditional cognitive
theories assuming a `good-enough' heuristic interpretation stage, but with
precise information-theoretic formulation. | [
-0.3326175511,
-0.8270227909,
0.4822119176,
0.19642663,
0.2254933864,
-0.2233158201,
-0.5134602785,
-0.5658005476,
0.276181072,
0.3054136932,
-0.5047659874,
-0.2076229602,
-0.5072339773,
-0.0587505847,
-0.657966435,
0.5184415579,
0.2603281438,
-0.0682522804,
0.0052945698,
0.1098112315,
-0.3857219815,
-0.6529771686,
-0.7864167094,
-0.5105963349,
0.5466102958,
0.2191678286,
0.3351122737,
0.2970617712,
0.2330911011,
0.1270632446,
-0.240628019,
-0.2632147074,
-0.0543840975,
-0.0117708761,
-0.1901088059,
-0.8382174373,
-0.5652843714,
-0.1062018648,
0.5315547585,
1.2999079227,
-0.4881668091,
0.029335618,
0.2458608598,
0.7579188347,
-0.6245149374,
0.1963745207,
-0.5740224123,
-0.1049503312,
-0.3922357559,
-0.3208155632,
-0.9280279875,
0.2100474536,
-0.0129514337,
-0.3880006969,
0.1542326957,
0.1559565365,
0.9450129271,
0.1374368817,
-0.1365748644,
0.0712421462,
-0.7399718165,
0.6645686626,
-0.7059699297,
0.5005148649,
0.5788809657,
0.0204205718,
-0.2757583261,
-0.4653196931,
-0.6871131659,
-0.0253306404,
-0.1027640253,
-0.0594107248,
-0.4438289404,
0.300093174,
0.5548363328,
0.0496739,
-0.4736765325,
0.2399906069,
-0.4200426042,
-0.2504547238,
0.3827242553,
0.0249072891,
0.6299211383,
-0.0633262321,
-0.2197686285,
0.1618771553,
-0.7178955078,
0.2321592867,
0.3341787755,
0.1023975015,
-0.0453955382,
0.4000001252,
-0.2148384154,
0.8532879353,
-0.0662918389,
0.3032533228,
0.0768150091,
-0.0797775611,
-0.021552762,
0.2085701376,
0.709769249,
0.3796446323,
0.2189417034,
-0.2911668718,
-0.0076543465,
0.2647627294,
0.2035566568,
-0.294221282,
-0.3467996418,
0.3247260749,
-0.3676296175,
0.0975251794,
0.0519649312,
-0.8512403369,
-0.2044896334,
-0.300159663,
0.2563560307,
-0.5785072446,
-0.5550521612,
0.5897711515,
-0.0231782701,
0.1288214177,
0.0067549469,
-0.9319784641,
0.5417221785,
0.352070272,
0.3531585932,
-0.0032583652,
-0.5538914204,
-0.0883967131,
0.2454413027,
-0.0918324888,
1.200688839,
-0.6047517657,
0.3320940733,
0.0556279793,
-0.2251293957,
-0.1880037338,
-0.2935394645,
0.6632903218,
-0.6224221587,
0.1748812944,
-0.3201875687,
-0.7372058034,
-0.4409285188,
-0.2889313698,
-0.8914772272,
0.866707027,
-0.1676971167,
-0.8261954784,
0.3234349787,
-0.7498187423,
-0.3931263089,
0.263574034,
-0.1159362495,
0.1567720771,
0.2684816718,
0.015412177,
0.3390756845,
-0.4447148144,
0.1653331667,
-0.0776069686,
-0.4245395362,
0.5051542521,
-0.4210443199,
0.9796487689,
-0.1034572199,
-0.5112017989,
-0.4301689863,
-1.0411342382,
0.4352807105,
-0.0509681962,
-0.5687146783,
-0.2819191813,
0.1787066907,
0.0296601336,
0.0204793941,
0.1858051866,
-0.5748896599,
-0.0203630887,
-0.3616925478,
0.4875433147,
0.3279074132,
-0.1361709684,
0.2207461894,
-0.0224245396,
0.2332404703,
0.1483906209,
-0.2111231238,
-0.4804034829,
-0.7032396197,
-0.631111443,
-0.1172072515,
0.6109016538,
0.7409015894,
-0.2775651515,
0.88664639,
-0.1708684266,
-0.058369834,
-0.4688768983,
-0.3977099657,
0.3369992971,
0.3300558925,
0.5149638653,
-0.3441977799,
-0.7412686348,
-1.0433449745,
-0.7762073278,
-0.260445267,
-0.231029287,
-0.3390832543,
-0.0156945176,
-0.1732443869,
0.8684519529,
-0.2529395223,
-0.1829150915,
-0.2005857378,
0.5944386721,
0.256478548,
0.155395627,
0.2515189946,
-0.3173622787,
-0.0277209412,
-0.1110850647,
-0.5103259683,
-0.4576105475,
-0.1027143523,
0.2081196308,
0.2320573479,
0.5311724544,
-0.4076984525,
0.6305966377,
0.510594666,
-0.6802318692,
0.2904887199,
-0.4035334587,
0.3759039342,
-0.7120081782,
-0.1427304149,
0.1122054383,
0.0940916464,
-0.8890691996,
-0.0794695988,
0.2787190378,
0.498660475,
-0.0403279588,
0.3176078498,
-0.5625127554,
-0.030730186,
-0.4392004311,
0.0820531771,
-0.1451251209,
0.6005116701,
-0.0168455094,
0.181090042,
0.4852474034,
-0.6513398886,
0.1717406809,
-0.2666323781,
-0.3136351109,
0.8065151572,
-0.3444253504,
0.11339771,
-0.5038840175,
-0.0292339083,
-1.1309126616,
-0.2798560262,
-0.2099696249,
-0.6769822836,
0.2810652852,
0.2394966781,
-0.6572756767,
-0.0070232954,
0.1778801233,
0.5540379286,
0.5923497677,
-0.3723190725,
0.5243662596,
0.4541246593,
-0.1006673276,
-0.2774363756,
-0.9692437053,
0.3454994559,
0.0425544716,
-0.6382741332,
0.3415304422,
0.1134582013,
-0.4079881012,
-0.0106346048,
0.1134131104,
-0.2925147116,
-0.0067913737,
0.2224199027,
0.1655253321,
0.0542062782,
0.0865676552,
0.0461515337,
-0.1543704122,
0.2432242334,
-0.2387910932,
0.6777194142,
0.002585795,
-0.3868981898,
-0.6888888478,
0.4308164418,
0.3427908719,
0.1279568225,
0.6220676899,
0.4471025467,
-1.0364626646,
0.0444431044,
-0.7147741914,
-0.3913095593,
-0.2827172279,
0.5229346752,
-0.5163249373,
-0.4153978527,
0.6290267706,
0.0649290532,
-0.0548967943,
0.5231535435,
0.3429883122,
-0.2607449889,
1.1274657249,
0.5148250461,
0.167447567,
0.3219731152,
0.0264751837,
0.4028437734,
-0.9917351604,
-0.2458944172,
-0.6488720775,
-0.3196785152,
-0.1916420162,
0.0272789709,
0.1087741181,
0.2626391947,
0.0111229317,
0.3663369119,
-0.1794764251,
0.6593146324,
0.4627342522,
0.0409050509,
0.2348353267,
0.3326570392,
-0.2487774789,
-0.5092740655,
-0.9450919628,
-0.6391739249,
1.0984038115,
0.2564663291,
0.5241115093,
0.007167669,
0.3817014098,
0.1764425784,
0.200366199,
-0.2636870742,
0.5914046764,
0.0470163822,
-0.6129511595,
-0.1918949634,
-0.0676861182,
-1.080929637,
0.0309629161,
-0.2543948591,
-1.3357969522,
0.2403294742,
0.1166312024,
-0.3372035325,
0.3520726562,
-0.9299401045,
0.4959104359,
-0.0277469736,
-0.283700496,
-0.4529813826,
-0.3934164643,
0.1641647965,
0.1699950546,
0.5812709928,
-0.0029808478,
-0.1063350886,
0.8807849288,
0.2007044703,
0.8757224679,
-0.1190201268,
-0.0794042498,
0.1550167501,
0.2055342644,
0.3429384828,
-0.0805500001,
-0.1122192591,
0.5337967873,
0.0774940401,
-0.4913441539,
-0.4453053772,
0.3486328721,
-0.5945549011,
-0.3639185727,
-0.2498145401,
-0.4794097245,
-0.1519295126,
0.1551714987,
0.7679966092,
0.322809428,
-0.0247389786,
-0.0066756834,
0.7932753563,
-0.0069321748,
0.5210959911,
0.4690726995,
0.0194701571,
-0.1931467503,
0.5260783434,
0.1728506386,
0.1841544807,
0.5828226805,
-0.164444074,
-0.0914414153,
-0.5482180119,
-0.0787685439,
0.2153001875,
-0.8054795265,
0.2677690685,
-0.4921370745,
0.0338878706,
-0.0722706392,
0.1472730488,
-0.2385352403,
-0.3060804904,
-0.0129999993,
-0.1128012687,
-0.0317336135,
0.6559990644,
-0.1204662174,
0.1159575954,
-0.6756281257,
0.245630011,
0.1832096577,
0.3900295794,
-0.1145359874,
-0.565764904,
-0.3239270747,
0.4308549762,
0.1690364182,
-1.353672266,
0.0775724798,
0.201294601,
0.7246857882,
0.2807076573,
-0.2443419993,
0.4354996383,
-0.4854064286,
0.9159331918,
0.4320520759,
-1.0762000084,
0.3855944574,
-0.1967251897,
0.2720121145,
0.4669754803,
-0.0062453747,
-0.7425161004,
-0.4891573787,
-0.8895784616,
-0.9675485492,
0.6325671077,
-0.0025591305,
-0.2416267693,
-0.1069338098,
0.6437173486,
0.0295729097,
0.0071697794,
-0.8611163497,
-0.3503006697,
0.2915582359,
-0.1960968226,
0.2580755651,
-0.5704845786,
-0.2301042229,
-0.137597546,
0.4024913907,
-0.0040970854,
0.619235158,
0.1761387736,
-0.1659836173,
-0.2302080989,
0.4585101604,
0.5330820084,
0.764716804,
-0.0120479064,
0.4140647054,
0.1864232719,
-0.5005658865,
0.1728128493,
-0.0836085156,
-0.1493566781,
0.0801944956,
0.5676002502,
0.6578584909,
0.2482999414,
-0.557903409,
0.3264745772,
-0.2023814619,
-0.1124914959,
-0.3662603796,
0.0671494007,
0.1470595598,
0.201080814,
0.5021046996,
0.1799601763,
0.225645408,
-0.4259789884,
0.1750364602,
0.2469793558,
-0.3122756779,
-0.7431124449,
0.6910799742,
-0.1833746135,
-0.5922247171,
0.3501611352,
-0.3761101663,
-0.3743488491,
0.4796255529,
0.4916940331,
1.0315301418,
-0.2971056402,
-0.1048477963,
0.5745835304,
0.4733959734,
-0.2360545248,
0.6396915913,
0.1279458404,
-0.8438385129,
-0.6679890752,
-0.5100031495,
-0.1536684334,
0.1160485595,
-0.9433078766,
0.2821764052,
-0.1911225021,
-0.0725999102,
0.3687746525,
-0.5266917348,
-0.8189908862,
0.2109039277,
0.2973610759,
0.6961271763,
-0.7471062541,
0.7241382003,
0.9560738206,
-0.1929782182,
-0.8374618292,
0.3860584497,
-0.2505818009,
-0.6914464831,
0.7325996161,
0.0169424433,
-0.0372969806,
0.1325935423,
-0.4169456661,
-0.8214815259,
0.7438082695,
0.5477946401,
-0.8118817806,
-0.1727708131,
0.1299852133,
0.5437415242,
-0.2224915177,
0.3120854199,
0.9735924602,
0.6007601619,
-0.3217412233,
-0.9330643415,
0.1488191038,
-0.2400776148,
-0.1175095066,
0.3738235533,
-0.0439052172,
0.7691553235,
-0.1847305149,
-0.4194687605,
-0.2763350904,
0.4022452831,
0.064381361,
-0.1319885999,
0.3692030013,
0.8363332152,
0.7449076772,
-0.2914571464,
0.8189951777,
-0.5932885408,
0.3244996965,
0.6224502921,
-0.0912564471,
0.9450276494,
0.6199032664,
-0.6150245667,
0.6709460616,
0.3493539393,
0.5850620866,
0.3402605057,
0.1672787815,
-0.2599714696,
-0.1860098243,
0.2886990607,
-0.0562724732,
0.3033542633,
0.7123121619,
-0.1541227847,
-0.0833636224,
-0.1022436395,
0.006576417,
0.0764174759,
-0.2125253677,
0.7328110337,
-0.0254132152,
-0.8953899145,
0.6577264071,
0.1599131376,
0.5564459562,
-0.3196820617,
-0.0923236012,
0.1452960819,
0.0611497723,
-0.384469986,
-0.8073291183,
0.2640519738,
-0.1765124798,
-0.3299728334,
-0.0777098984,
0.7046672702,
-0.5198883414,
-0.1081007123,
0.3063392341,
0.1950760931,
0.1805109829,
-0.2209747136,
-0.3164457083,
-0.0906122327,
0.0213513207,
-0.3131753802,
0.1299332678,
0.3951513469,
0.0939818174,
0.1678357422,
0.375518024,
0.5566949248,
0.4299461544,
0.059291251,
0.2083650082,
-0.9950962067,
-0.7695416212,
-0.8824497461,
0.6483325958,
-0.0182478465,
-0.1517606378,
0.2397812158,
0.1084521487,
0.7580265999,
0.1263473332,
0.9958868623,
-0.1143767983,
0.3899354339,
-0.7833528519,
0.2267745584,
-0.1100979373,
0.5823962092,
-0.1195302904,
-0.8940497041,
-0.4073470235,
0.7262773514,
-0.2051821202,
-0.1498741657,
1.178114295,
0.4318151772,
0.2424203902,
0.4244794548,
0.43087551,
0.3255260885,
0.0635463595,
0.9375,
0.6161351204,
-0.5546008348,
0.2504103482,
-0.0476184636,
-0.4851855636,
-0.2388750762,
-0.7635044456,
-0.5879833698,
-0.9619194865,
-0.454038918,
-0.3197596073,
-0.1714332551,
0.8122673631,
0.4702862799,
-0.5851393938,
-0.3106758595,
-0.4282354116,
-0.137282148,
-0.5367574692,
-0.2077546418,
0.1377782971,
-0.3752261698,
-0.5461546183,
0.3137675822,
0.5923634171,
-0.1463476419,
-0.2993774414,
0.1695837677,
-0.1479646415,
0.3080060184,
0.4558879137,
0.4012810588,
-0.7972050905,
-0.3660559654,
-0.0087634064,
-0.0322546773,
0.2216854244,
0.8194612861,
-0.6445378661,
0.3959589303,
0.5792028904,
0.4533992708,
0.0960230306,
-0.5510396957,
0.5153756142,
-0.7673006058,
0.3075293005,
0.0760989636,
0.744404912,
0.218719855,
-0.348175168,
0.2082671374,
0.2565615475,
-0.4134790003,
-0.9072543979,
0.6488348842,
-0.6954677105,
-0.230433166,
1.1214443445,
-0.002027696,
-0.418566674,
-0.1851670444,
-0.1370225847,
0.0490147173,
-0.1663108468,
1.0131598711,
1.1975446939,
-0.4755240381,
-0.2689763606,
-0.5921375751,
0.4375532568,
0.5589262247,
-0.9138430357,
0.1440493315,
0.4715000391,
0.0327825248,
0.579621017,
0.5891902447,
-0.0460373573,
0.5957837701,
0.076639384,
0.6181180477,
0.3814673424,
-0.3388670087,
-0.4542252421,
0.4291457236,
0.2361370623,
-0.0412611254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08204v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08204v1 | LegalRelectra: Mixed-domain Language Modeling for Long-range Legal Text Comprehension | 2022-12-16T00:15:14 | 2022-12-16T00:15:14 | Wenyue Hua, Yuchen Zhang, Zhe Chen, Josie Li, Melanie Weber | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | The application of Natural Language Processing (NLP) to specialized domains,
such as the law, has recently received a surge of interest. As many legal
services rely on processing and analyzing large collections of documents,
automating such tasks with NLP tools emerges as a key challenge. Many popular
language models, such as BERT or RoBERTa, are general-purpose models, which
have limitations on processing specialized legal terminology and syntax. In
addition, legal documents may contain specialized vocabulary from other
domains, such as medical terminology in personal injury text. Here, we propose
LegalRelectra, a legal-domain language model that is trained on mixed-domain
legal and medical corpora. We show that our model improves over general-domain
and single-domain medical and legal language models when processing
mixed-domain (personal injury) text. Our training architecture implements the
Electra framework, but utilizes Reformer instead of BERT for its generator and
discriminator. We show that this improves the model's performance on processing
long passages and results in better long-range text comprehension. | [
-0.1590773612,
-0.8351386189,
0.5071308613,
0.3130023181,
-0.526011765,
0.1269435436,
-0.2767477632,
-0.8636065722,
0.222864598,
1.0349317789,
-0.2034560591,
-0.5343062878,
-0.4500239789,
0.0556180142,
-0.3859982193,
1.2658749819,
-0.097468406,
0.1811569184,
-0.1891501993,
-0.6457778215,
-0.7782716751,
-0.90573138,
-0.5966249704,
-0.5161858797,
0.5014536977,
0.0742344037,
0.4260062575,
0.1593844593,
0.5684760213,
0.1921925396,
-0.086782515,
-0.0378113911,
-0.2112711817,
0.3760223985,
-0.3350045085,
-0.3996754289,
-0.4064771533,
-0.3601887226,
0.5146964192,
0.5704500079,
-0.4313452542,
-0.2250763476,
-0.5387024879,
0.8372269273,
-0.5139834285,
-0.2269187868,
-0.7232612371,
0.0081014084,
-0.1214710101,
-0.2471427768,
-0.5427554846,
-0.1771375537,
0.1794331223,
-0.6567291617,
0.2524608672,
0.1299954653,
1.0364288092,
0.3578895032,
-0.5792627335,
-0.3647567034,
-0.6430007219,
0.3672532141,
-0.6219208837,
0.513635397,
0.3553887606,
0.446770072,
0.0458859093,
-0.9578665495,
-0.6076123118,
-0.2606429458,
0.0393597409,
0.2546507418,
-0.422254771,
0.2282289118,
0.0242758971,
-0.1139002368,
-0.7010594606,
0.4865222573,
-0.442648232,
-0.123573862,
0.6835950017,
0.0509253815,
0.5085211992,
-0.0955744907,
-0.3943569362,
0.1749322265,
-0.8041949868,
-0.1391752511,
0.2457866818,
0.327845335,
-0.0066626803,
0.605096817,
-0.023840744,
0.8511866331,
-0.1462584883,
-0.0064487993,
0.2922688127,
-0.0239770822,
-0.5931170583,
0.0999419987,
0.6220503449,
0.0598555282,
0.2634494901,
-0.290840894,
-0.1641958505,
-0.1010567024,
0.4197103381,
-0.6747745872,
-0.089883253,
0.5161845088,
-0.4332860708,
0.0049271127,
-0.3077160716,
-0.7078713179,
-0.3999957442,
-0.6142469645,
-0.0191318635,
-0.6875284314,
-0.0989022851,
0.6652303338,
-0.2054246813,
0.1344688833,
0.3544841409,
-0.8228431344,
0.494885385,
0.6647679806,
0.6238678098,
-0.2151790112,
-0.1080485806,
-0.7590025663,
0.0711142793,
0.180038482,
0.9641469717,
-0.6147553325,
-0.1540505886,
0.2912966907,
-0.1663408875,
-0.2533334196,
-0.616699338,
0.9102418423,
-1.0088781118,
-0.0336880125,
0.2980706096,
-0.5740911365,
-0.3255997002,
0.2189358026,
-0.7648504376,
0.7687042356,
0.1421496868,
-0.9302129745,
0.5787689686,
-0.6763350368,
-0.8980200887,
0.4153869152,
-0.2792668641,
-0.8116779327,
-0.0213735159,
0.0957144871,
0.2377228886,
-0.2251475453,
0.6361722946,
-0.0866016895,
0.0230163056,
0.1332861483,
-0.1591197252,
1.0219471455,
0.1387319416,
-0.0015908588,
0.1899141967,
-0.7561655641,
-0.1268766224,
-0.0544166975,
-0.5114001036,
-0.8541137576,
0.1031202674,
0.4629095793,
0.3322070837,
0.11257983,
-0.5739329457,
0.065252319,
-0.4234317243,
0.3158661127,
0.2248394787,
0.0864312053,
0.4395611286,
-0.28110075,
0.7991730571,
0.0083997371,
-0.2378154248,
0.2469903231,
-0.5497956276,
-0.5921304822,
-0.5337847471,
0.4560287893,
0.5805522203,
-0.6532643437,
0.5031484365,
-0.3393743038,
-0.3168129623,
-0.6552138329,
-0.0808624327,
0.1210990995,
0.4740838408,
0.666811049,
-0.1964671165,
-0.786002934,
-0.7530286312,
-0.5167460442,
-0.1799757332,
0.0717782527,
0.316760838,
0.7134818435,
-0.5036591887,
1.1282581091,
-0.2311019897,
-0.6265085936,
-0.5814359188,
0.5024758577,
0.1255788654,
0.084245801,
0.7173560262,
-1.0374474525,
-0.5972201228,
0.2628771067,
-0.4573685825,
-0.3077152073,
-0.490753293,
-0.1096362621,
0.1188297123,
0.1538272053,
-0.6713255048,
0.3145783246,
0.4550108016,
-0.689696908,
0.7721986771,
-0.4526688159,
-0.1836059093,
-1.022228241,
0.2716941237,
0.1516268402,
-0.5076211095,
-0.8818743825,
0.4221444726,
0.1902893633,
0.0516851731,
-0.6509621143,
0.3942147195,
-0.420142293,
-0.1066661701,
-0.3583727479,
0.2843776345,
0.0541068539,
0.2733624876,
0.4938099086,
0.725767076,
0.2868980765,
-0.6202249527,
0.2489553243,
0.3564014137,
-0.2734920681,
0.8920174241,
-0.6794167757,
-0.0435247868,
-0.1952145696,
0.3503921926,
-0.1853693873,
-0.285381943,
-0.1296018511,
-0.0914979726,
0.3006574214,
-0.3708158433,
-0.3938753903,
-0.3923540711,
0.2095846385,
0.3341490626,
0.2887384892,
-0.4064216018,
0.8014765382,
0.6379081607,
-0.1020211726,
-0.6614272594,
-0.7413620353,
0.2478603721,
-0.3396195769,
-0.5117303729,
0.6145356297,
0.0501891114,
-0.4065553844,
-0.1241170987,
0.4016101956,
-0.7620843649,
0.0500027388,
0.2303673327,
0.1623809338,
-0.0977469012,
0.4018826783,
0.4709536135,
0.1291452795,
0.2204445899,
-0.0479609743,
0.6386392713,
0.1372762024,
-0.2276500016,
-0.2080262899,
0.5325281024,
0.5044156909,
-0.5644698143,
0.563942194,
0.0504056923,
-0.2323630899,
-0.4110278487,
-0.4130315781,
0.1077683195,
-0.3937485516,
0.4779244363,
-0.3028995991,
-1.0825570822,
0.6013697386,
0.0814676881,
0.2383435369,
0.6108981967,
0.783226788,
0.0486421473,
0.5007532239,
0.7060852051,
-0.2976641655,
0.4376152456,
0.0767198354,
0.1209190488,
-0.6513844728,
-0.0954577327,
-0.8202262521,
0.1576143205,
-0.3333685398,
-0.2765204906,
0.2123862952,
-0.3340306282,
-0.1129868031,
0.5961171985,
-0.4007030725,
0.4721117914,
0.5294343233,
0.3073469698,
0.5840739608,
0.2003550231,
-0.1678355187,
-0.002275506,
-0.6150889397,
-0.2970823348,
0.8966950178,
0.4907027781,
0.7294697165,
-0.0148576833,
0.9541743994,
0.2491798848,
0.3712770641,
-0.8576576114,
0.2451119572,
-0.400049001,
-0.9146284461,
-0.164315924,
-0.4389564693,
-1.2007832527,
0.3945737779,
-0.1016092971,
-0.3061191738,
0.240890041,
-0.2620213926,
-0.5133553743,
0.2284209579,
-0.1765419543,
0.5674919486,
-0.2776574194,
-0.1031502336,
-0.4765179157,
-0.6305785179,
0.2663679719,
-0.4407286346,
0.3394416571,
-0.0240849908,
0.2841057479,
0.8318604231,
-0.5488752127,
0.838072598,
-0.0262915492,
-0.1480924338,
0.4699893296,
0.0439957045,
0.2948071361,
0.0778557286,
-0.0053693051,
-0.095955275,
0.0425625853,
-0.1205578893,
-0.4132894278,
0.3689455986,
-0.5578867197,
-0.2076305598,
-0.5439059138,
-0.661018014,
-0.0905451253,
0.3578794301,
0.0603721589,
0.1010147259,
-0.3556939662,
0.1185647696,
0.64384377,
-0.1451977491,
0.3317379653,
0.9975289106,
0.0763554573,
-0.3468310833,
0.4998264611,
-0.040341612,
-0.1204853654,
0.3605291843,
-0.0713834912,
-0.271214366,
-0.7502261996,
-0.3901305795,
0.3626821935,
-0.7065558434,
-0.3527441621,
-0.7158851624,
-0.2496453375,
-0.0748180971,
-0.0827539265,
-0.11374598,
-0.3701056242,
-0.4131084681,
0.0487783439,
0.4719427824,
0.5709818006,
0.2930956483,
0.0555723943,
-0.8786460161,
0.4862295687,
0.2173405141,
0.3518614769,
-0.4723922908,
-0.8128558993,
-0.2435290962,
-0.0609455332,
0.0748938173,
-0.8435150981,
0.6879326105,
0.1768583804,
0.4974707663,
0.0682311803,
0.2518696189,
0.5821718574,
-0.9533568621,
0.4896541834,
0.3151569664,
-0.5704317689,
0.3642420173,
-0.3346596062,
0.0042010969,
0.9307438731,
0.2302735895,
-0.5249453187,
-0.7102954388,
-0.3609296083,
-0.7347790003,
0.2071281224,
0.1146218926,
0.3001203537,
0.003550163,
0.3187056482,
0.2258835137,
0.0000650214,
-1.0329773426,
0.2076322585,
0.127836749,
-0.4155057073,
0.3917188644,
-0.0719962195,
-0.3607266843,
-0.2593229413,
0.4935968518,
-0.0602117106,
0.1532386988,
0.1962808073,
-0.4873250425,
-0.1061183959,
0.4055251777,
0.7581792474,
0.6750470996,
-0.0378118828,
-0.067914322,
0.0501974933,
-0.7558218837,
0.1221766099,
0.3345888257,
-0.2505028546,
0.2965001464,
0.3614130616,
0.7778849602,
0.0586392134,
-0.910944283,
0.5041794777,
-0.0841218755,
-0.4715175927,
-0.4699158669,
-0.1785430908,
-0.1471241564,
0.174142018,
0.3412683606,
-0.041647125,
0.1876362711,
-0.3749379218,
0.4809049368,
0.2092212588,
-0.18958354,
-0.0989492014,
0.8242704272,
0.2583901882,
-0.2374972403,
0.515571177,
0.2542960346,
-0.6186746955,
0.6261230707,
0.6979734898,
0.8221555948,
0.1851652265,
0.2152086943,
0.1213843971,
0.0552632511,
-0.0869556963,
0.3639959991,
0.1415405273,
-0.5670613647,
-0.6293779016,
-0.6006115079,
-0.4399254322,
-0.0217002928,
-0.6372489333,
0.1963970363,
-0.2506866455,
-0.275259316,
-0.0254546814,
-0.1903766841,
-0.5816671252,
0.4235361516,
-0.1708410978,
1.0306288004,
-0.7299358249,
1.140771389,
0.6074834466,
-0.7193614841,
-0.3967033029,
-0.1087122634,
-0.6661050916,
-0.5709280968,
0.978697598,
-0.0023750805,
0.1244539544,
-0.1887657046,
-0.3865897954,
-0.2839714885,
0.766993165,
0.2176716179,
-0.8962484002,
-0.3206644356,
0.3733586371,
0.9764403105,
-0.3227551579,
-0.1463025957,
0.5966439247,
0.2196347415,
-0.282907784,
-0.8523760438,
-0.0203653183,
-0.0177149456,
-0.315959394,
0.1725742221,
-0.2482147515,
0.5356510878,
0.0788496211,
0.1099073216,
-0.0827549994,
0.7602875829,
0.3847727478,
0.4619815946,
0.4133878648,
0.7387590408,
0.8607628942,
0.1377569735,
1.1750712395,
-0.348785013,
0.4169373512,
1.3771768808,
-0.505856216,
1.1286180019,
0.5302769542,
-0.1833598763,
0.9590550661,
0.4207370579,
0.0802728534,
0.4432440996,
0.0461858474,
-0.4779113531,
-0.1817343086,
0.0669618025,
-0.0839176103,
0.3683903217,
0.2642529905,
-0.6703943014,
-0.1692744792,
0.1683554351,
0.0452555791,
0.2839029133,
-0.1583188325,
0.8171687722,
0.2426638156,
-0.7985958457,
0.4971956313,
0.2174288034,
0.4061889052,
-0.5167066455,
0.1377015263,
-0.2086720318,
0.0040270528,
-0.0555590205,
-0.8373996615,
0.3223403394,
0.2082040906,
-0.0623943433,
-0.0835359767,
0.9184391499,
-0.5914235115,
-0.3364544511,
0.5273280144,
0.2314172387,
0.030149065,
-0.039345447,
-0.8624171019,
-0.187347278,
-0.3166778088,
-0.0910167843,
0.3683058918,
0.4530329108,
-0.163041383,
0.7285701632,
0.5283818245,
0.2708487213,
0.0533307381,
0.6107316613,
1.0989470482,
-0.5098897815,
-0.7247652411,
-0.6097816229,
0.5950049162,
-0.2611773908,
-0.3755553067,
0.3848460913,
0.6367906332,
0.3964292407,
-0.056184724,
0.8479570746,
-0.0324683525,
0.5225650072,
-0.6388452053,
0.8366512656,
-0.4077239633,
-0.0567405298,
0.1072086096,
-0.6680133343,
-0.7547770143,
0.616009891,
-0.3055843115,
-0.1977633536,
0.6088782549,
0.2288722098,
-0.2499434799,
-0.3127087355,
0.3143269122,
-0.0584211051,
0.2825620174,
0.4619291127,
0.3985911906,
-0.1744615287,
0.4871790707,
-0.0262305811,
0.0588758476,
-0.4612643421,
-0.6072929502,
-1.2038031816,
-0.3123143911,
-0.1794322282,
-0.4855465591,
0.2248603851,
0.7095493078,
0.6406463981,
-0.8349097371,
-0.1764856875,
-0.3960679471,
-0.1164792404,
0.0371954851,
-0.2509907186,
0.3123441339,
-0.6269360781,
-0.4307425022,
0.4637765884,
0.164693594,
-0.0387182273,
-0.172121644,
-0.2078579217,
-0.4241904914,
0.3127444983,
0.6574375033,
0.5208149552,
-0.5699245334,
-0.2201135755,
-0.1920289844,
-0.362419486,
0.3181196749,
1.0671198368,
-0.6534959078,
0.6180213094,
0.4522918463,
0.7667012811,
0.6277998686,
0.180985257,
0.7955152988,
-0.5792090297,
0.304538995,
0.6158443093,
0.6566904783,
0.2020992488,
-0.2352742851,
0.5176789761,
0.1091672778,
-0.6283732057,
-0.6285282373,
0.366266042,
-0.9328721762,
-0.590898335,
1.0977835655,
-0.1911156923,
-0.1958967745,
-0.4941727519,
-0.3995531201,
0.3285605609,
-0.3031161726,
0.7862511873,
0.3582039475,
0.1543186754,
-0.1184889898,
-0.6414113045,
0.3942325413,
0.5168766379,
-1.0308694839,
0.0612267368,
0.6372296214,
0.3289414346,
-0.0114853038,
0.743342936,
-0.0830209926,
0.5349718928,
-0.2832880914,
0.2545857728,
0.1628704667,
-0.4041473866,
-0.5459667444,
0.1630159318,
-0.0998895541,
0.3217789233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08196v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08196v1 | Saved You A Click: Automatically Answering Clickbait Titles | 2022-12-15T23:41:20 | 2022-12-15T23:41:20 | Oliver Johnson, Beicheng Lou, Janet Zhong, Andrey Kurenkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Often clickbait articles have a title that is phrased as a question or vague
teaser that entices the user to click on the link and read the article to find
the explanation. We developed a system that will automatically find the answer
or explanation of the clickbait hook from the website text so that the user
does not need to read through the text themselves. We fine-tune an extractive
question and answering model (RoBERTa) and an abstractive one (T5), using data
scraped from the 'StopClickbait' Facebook pages and Reddit's 'SavedYouAClick'
subforum. We find that both extractive and abstractive models improve
significantly after finetuning. We find that the extractive model performs
slightly better according to ROUGE scores, while the abstractive one has a
slight edge in terms of BERTscores. | [
-0.4216954112,
-0.9881864786,
0.5776084065,
0.1424251199,
-0.3643945754,
-0.1895557344,
0.153762579,
-0.6276801825,
0.5004349947,
0.5527178049,
-0.4500924647,
-0.2486708313,
-0.3126274049,
0.4378316998,
-0.5264730453,
1.3311508894,
0.2198708802,
-0.1190021634,
-0.491065532,
0.3474952579,
-0.4237633646,
0.2360881269,
-0.8121879101,
-0.0506727919,
0.5965898633,
0.2751792073,
0.7231585979,
0.9333913326,
0.6682360768,
0.1776330769,
-0.0991377756,
0.1242412925,
-0.3640381396,
-0.355474174,
-0.5873773694,
-0.4394492507,
-0.3710671067,
0.416444838,
-0.0067399419,
0.6234428883,
-0.0763864592,
0.6876623631,
-0.0250556022,
0.5245318413,
-0.575506866,
-0.0036362051,
-0.534401536,
-0.2420036644,
0.3395237923,
-0.4770195484,
-0.487064749,
-0.769616425,
0.3484925628,
-0.4034561217,
0.3772648275,
-0.0325425565,
1.1681423187,
0.581589818,
-0.5548174381,
-0.0260362998,
-0.6151665449,
0.4431885481,
-0.6145107746,
-0.0373239107,
0.3567055464,
0.1619638056,
0.2105884254,
-0.6986277699,
-0.1879574358,
-0.0934734344,
-0.4246620238,
0.2252970338,
-0.2521348298,
0.0718216598,
0.2252717465,
0.1032899693,
-0.6079750657,
-0.3750992715,
-0.700265944,
-0.3178704679,
0.9401507378,
0.0965364352,
0.4425252974,
-0.5611307621,
-0.512861073,
0.0979285836,
-0.371093601,
0.3408212066,
0.3848499954,
0.0250144359,
0.1303076744,
0.460909754,
-0.1642034352,
0.8834919333,
0.5155699253,
-0.1122379526,
0.0639746934,
-0.1827717572,
0.0484136939,
0.042380102,
0.5002524853,
0.9519148469,
0.6532772183,
-0.2734149992,
0.1522043049,
-0.0895198062,
0.4591383338,
-0.6639652252,
-0.6292457581,
0.6036641002,
-0.8785598874,
-0.6001983881,
0.4810964465,
-0.4533724487,
-0.0408427045,
-0.3791688085,
0.6444587111,
-0.4615338445,
-0.0961201862,
0.177796334,
-0.4431700408,
-0.100856401,
0.5813576579,
-0.6723355055,
0.0686134398,
0.3184638321,
0.6983619928,
-0.5881063342,
-0.1736834645,
-0.7343400717,
0.1824762672,
-0.2267474085,
1.1384856701,
-0.2830092311,
-0.1942965835,
-0.1242625713,
0.5143406987,
-0.259935081,
-0.6025236249,
0.1096916795,
-0.9941098094,
0.1654488891,
-0.3926763237,
-0.5949199796,
-0.7821828127,
0.4876864254,
-1.0321055651,
0.7439714074,
-0.4184178412,
-0.7255476713,
0.3668727875,
-0.7823833227,
-0.4188452065,
0.0604570284,
0.3675581515,
-0.1677060276,
0.1406254172,
0.1591312289,
0.1262768358,
0.1052313745,
-0.1076452285,
0.0096215038,
-0.1515650749,
0.7514958382,
-0.2482320666,
0.6788367033,
0.0666638091,
-0.1844664514,
-0.0767720565,
-0.4584345818,
0.115481846,
0.1464667916,
-0.7862150073,
-0.3081299663,
-0.0306717791,
0.0680052638,
0.2801282406,
0.6292879581,
-0.5772677064,
0.0028579833,
-0.2636556327,
0.0260394644,
0.5380165577,
0.528064847,
0.2622672021,
-0.4055775106,
0.7612926364,
-0.0015131979,
0.038657628,
-0.3149474263,
-0.2904621959,
-0.5129210949,
0.0655649453,
0.6719686389,
0.6829918623,
-0.2637363374,
0.0995748416,
0.0584490895,
-0.1910611987,
-0.6457995176,
0.1695397049,
0.236992389,
0.3175234795,
0.3562105298,
-0.2547633946,
-0.1170909628,
-0.9166598916,
-0.567280829,
0.0838260651,
-0.0040061451,
0.3248259425,
0.574585557,
0.2999514341,
1.4237564802,
-0.9044927359,
-0.1934204847,
-0.2954968512,
0.435081929,
0.0075641484,
0.128625229,
0.4837457538,
-1.3170820475,
-0.7547803521,
-0.3885522187,
-0.835862577,
-0.3312302828,
-0.2939475179,
0.0433729477,
-0.1247794554,
0.6635004878,
-0.516933322,
0.4421508312,
0.122965537,
-0.2678283155,
0.6959913373,
-0.2712931633,
0.3677252829,
-0.9521472454,
0.3140224218,
0.1506845653,
-0.3369768858,
-0.3652070761,
-0.0252988115,
0.2271072119,
0.0483182073,
-0.63485533,
0.4325033426,
-0.4212285876,
-0.149620682,
-0.5078812838,
0.2638899088,
-0.0221579112,
0.1635260582,
0.1607451439,
0.794585526,
0.2093016654,
-0.9712088704,
0.2456556708,
0.3779256642,
0.3336941004,
0.2831549644,
-0.8513963223,
0.1153509989,
-0.4804829657,
0.243306309,
-1.1751610041,
-0.53368783,
0.1724107563,
-0.5200369954,
-0.0137683526,
-0.3308161497,
-0.6663789153,
-0.4737181365,
-0.4264197648,
0.3755372465,
0.1122806072,
-0.3932628036,
0.4329068661,
0.3134819865,
-0.1105727926,
-0.36311239,
-0.1764573604,
-0.0295124035,
-0.14884606,
-0.1846006513,
0.2291618884,
-0.3285686374,
-0.1163164452,
0.4872615337,
0.2499914765,
0.0856937021,
0.1145233065,
0.0547848865,
0.0592075028,
0.0838723779,
0.3460977077,
0.132031247,
-0.5150637031,
0.2137963027,
-0.1964472681,
0.5601064563,
0.1392282993,
-0.1093237102,
-0.8745093942,
0.2712214291,
0.4694441855,
-0.5533642173,
0.559135735,
0.5531843305,
-0.0917363465,
-0.0426778644,
-0.2922216654,
-0.5279479027,
-0.4443070292,
-0.0555886254,
0.0870360136,
-0.3425218165,
0.2667793334,
-0.1444746554,
-0.0143521074,
0.5422030687,
0.2289431989,
-0.2746844292,
1.255158186,
0.7866625786,
0.1424222291,
0.1739243269,
-0.1644911021,
-0.0219579581,
-0.3397221565,
-0.2165296078,
-0.0876087025,
-0.5548711419,
-0.441696316,
0.0411810875,
0.4597697854,
0.0067946371,
0.1907541007,
0.4586533904,
-0.6136062741,
0.7290841341,
0.4957145452,
0.2369455844,
0.4925530553,
-0.0555590168,
0.2851755917,
-0.1030569524,
-0.3101038635,
-0.5246706605,
1.1919857264,
0.0425272174,
0.820907414,
0.0639177635,
0.7255856991,
0.5694051981,
0.2270817012,
-0.6522751451,
0.6201557517,
-0.082100451,
-1.1275840998,
-0.1472183466,
-0.0929954946,
-0.9098694921,
0.0555757172,
-0.1970572919,
-0.8639950752,
-0.0493758023,
0.3550063372,
-0.6146688461,
0.1839403212,
-0.5123380423,
0.6441943645,
-0.3373793662,
-0.3251809776,
-0.2379945666,
-0.7128674388,
0.1974184811,
0.0038750588,
0.1438357234,
-0.1429949552,
-0.243869558,
0.8699618578,
-0.1402469873,
0.7208121419,
0.0312685966,
-0.0682840869,
0.5452864766,
0.2188701332,
0.1844203323,
0.0730187073,
0.1276456565,
-0.2848188877,
0.0194963682,
-0.3362520337,
-0.5073415637,
0.3279936314,
-0.3565432131,
-0.4467220306,
-0.2735646963,
-0.6923311949,
0.1554476768,
0.2986277938,
0.5181894302,
0.4614608884,
-0.2085132897,
0.0414031446,
1.063290596,
-0.0664175451,
0.7772023082,
0.5976169109,
-0.1585273296,
-0.336651206,
0.7274006605,
0.0988934264,
0.304885596,
0.4968523979,
0.1863580793,
-0.474673003,
-0.4461741447,
-0.6036766768,
0.5175252557,
-0.5971904397,
-0.2195202857,
-1.0268585682,
-0.1388865113,
-0.2491852641,
-0.2092273235,
-0.071072191,
-0.4417861104,
-0.4462370574,
-0.291325599,
0.649409771,
0.9709075689,
-0.4952886999,
0.322307229,
-1.214286685,
0.4840709567,
0.475780338,
-0.0840779021,
0.1230698824,
-0.195018068,
-0.4184269309,
-0.1921342313,
-0.5255131125,
-1.2565734386,
0.3630073965,
0.0103896009,
0.3375157416,
0.7469623685,
0.4422408938,
0.2249285132,
-0.1909248531,
0.9185590744,
0.0924457386,
-0.7044060826,
0.683077693,
-0.5871552825,
0.4274400473,
0.7673506141,
0.8612351418,
-0.0776011124,
-0.286095649,
-0.6857548356,
-0.822106123,
0.5231867433,
0.1082526892,
0.1318359822,
-0.1568569839,
0.3582741916,
0.2141596675,
0.5358029604,
-0.9643926024,
-0.211454004,
0.2013780326,
-0.0979800373,
0.1605928987,
-0.3050853908,
-0.0528924242,
-0.1031929329,
0.5025021434,
-0.1676477492,
0.0807421803,
0.0824054107,
-0.5862016678,
-0.2455438226,
0.0056475485,
0.0717714205,
0.8680023551,
-0.4791668355,
-0.1003994197,
0.0380746983,
-0.5260235071,
0.0184133183,
0.1845621914,
-0.6207379699,
0.1692483425,
0.1286049336,
0.1283271164,
0.4094386101,
-0.6888521314,
0.5464037657,
0.098733522,
-0.0082100825,
-0.3044809103,
0.2366620451,
0.2210068107,
0.1112218872,
0.5028054118,
-0.1127004698,
0.5440868139,
-0.4646968246,
0.4039859772,
0.334290117,
-0.235697493,
-0.2297031432,
1.0213481188,
0.3402697146,
-0.4052967429,
0.2125786692,
-0.0485259071,
-0.6341642737,
0.6658562422,
0.5952629447,
0.8866354227,
-0.1744192988,
0.6508786082,
0.5296500921,
0.1159507334,
-0.0273623839,
0.2578158379,
-0.1964263171,
-0.3375802934,
-0.2408153415,
-0.6674613953,
-0.4372064769,
0.1728208065,
-1.0240299702,
0.2676165104,
-0.163116619,
-0.2527534366,
0.299737066,
0.0273097642,
-0.3320657313,
0.7212833762,
-0.0348080061,
1.0729298592,
-0.9523137808,
0.1203714162,
0.9817381501,
-0.9116008282,
-0.7432714105,
0.5353190899,
-0.0610266179,
-0.2557944953,
0.4881771803,
0.1470211446,
-0.4209271073,
0.5458048582,
-1.0109001398,
-1.0417882204,
0.9846633673,
-0.089183867,
0.0547334291,
-0.3350614607,
0.1518650949,
0.3536290526,
-0.4262886643,
0.1838235557,
0.6129474044,
0.45753479,
-0.2391564101,
-0.9628978968,
0.1417936534,
-0.1144673154,
-0.3184249997,
0.1824966967,
-0.4730433226,
0.717358768,
-0.4243348539,
-0.2243678123,
0.1725490689,
0.2604953945,
-0.3121514022,
0.3868282735,
0.6961479187,
0.5017830729,
0.3091187775,
0.1685514897,
1.0504916906,
-0.3525915742,
0.5285156369,
0.7830239534,
0.2730172575,
0.8850280643,
0.2503273785,
-0.0029710107,
0.5882049799,
0.8337939978,
-0.0820610151,
0.5881091952,
-0.2146943957,
0.0787967369,
-0.5757877231,
-0.1053401604,
-0.1482028812,
0.6619126797,
0.0506288223,
-0.580956459,
-0.6134470701,
0.1759501994,
0.206864208,
0.1269789636,
-0.2876928747,
1.1214596033,
-0.0236666016,
-0.7508183122,
0.3041879833,
-0.1524890512,
0.420281291,
-0.4248592556,
0.0611653924,
-0.1235310882,
0.0713598356,
-0.4401190281,
-0.6354545355,
0.0023808996,
0.0944530517,
-0.6644574404,
-0.0431095399,
0.68145895,
-0.6926236153,
-0.3562903106,
0.2436813116,
0.7172609568,
0.3657422066,
-0.0620480962,
-0.8482659459,
-0.2828625441,
0.0496233664,
-0.0801128522,
0.1753271818,
-0.029469233,
0.2485557497,
0.5633600354,
0.8073660135,
0.0620866492,
-0.1868833899,
-0.4912114739,
0.6204257607,
-0.8640380502,
-1.0640072823,
-0.6231005788,
0.6771062016,
-0.3759900928,
-0.3181664348,
0.9740419984,
0.7327417731,
0.4268260002,
-0.5345285535,
0.7957869172,
-0.0134856636,
0.8632126451,
-0.4720277786,
1.1644650698,
-1.0450760126,
-0.1319512129,
-0.4293092489,
-0.738686204,
0.0271686371,
0.1745229214,
-0.4925894737,
-0.0616764054,
0.6953441501,
0.5482922792,
-0.3186327517,
-0.1146948189,
0.1079386994,
0.0899635628,
-0.0183868892,
0.1117221713,
0.5430822372,
-0.2862482071,
0.7201811075,
-0.1393992156,
-0.2168527395,
-0.7877019644,
-1.006919384,
-0.745279789,
-0.42054075,
-0.7771916389,
-0.4677498341,
0.1043513492,
0.76214993,
0.6050997972,
-0.6489987373,
-0.1417829245,
0.2432372123,
0.022955697,
-0.2725848258,
-0.3428235054,
0.4381105602,
-0.188185513,
-0.7053655982,
-0.0111522041,
0.1188962236,
0.059861552,
0.1068389341,
0.3772377074,
-0.3795701265,
0.5102350712,
0.4097006321,
0.4365943074,
-0.4048072696,
-0.3784390688,
0.0934488028,
0.175741449,
-0.2700935304,
0.7474310398,
-0.7945659161,
0.4591034651,
0.5645281076,
0.414847225,
0.4245481193,
0.8218294978,
0.5428517461,
-0.1033975631,
-0.2731678784,
0.0182427168,
-0.1321347952,
0.3647902012,
-0.5715965629,
0.2326198816,
0.2797083557,
-0.3871170878,
-0.4427444935,
0.3732063174,
-0.975823462,
-0.4387103021,
1.3309679031,
-0.0873708576,
-0.1506528854,
-0.3294667602,
-0.3953173459,
0.1093221307,
-0.3866820037,
0.9939819574,
0.3251404166,
-0.3562812507,
-0.1211636886,
-0.587398231,
0.832926333,
0.1094460636,
-0.98971802,
-0.3654787838,
0.518631041,
0.898383677,
0.4435952008,
0.3609437346,
0.0658117309,
0.920648396,
-0.2645973265,
-0.3938232064,
-0.2121090293,
-0.478158623,
-0.3569365144,
0.4723189473,
-0.1891655922,
-0.5690675974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08195v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.08195v1 | Improving Chess Commentaries by Combining Language Models with Symbolic Reasoning Engines | 2022-12-15T23:38:31 | 2022-12-15T23:38:31 | Andrew Lee, David Wu, Emily Dinan, Mike Lewis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite many recent advancements in language modeling, state-of-the-art
language models lack grounding in the real world and struggle with tasks
involving complex reasoning. Meanwhile, advances in the symbolic reasoning
capabilities of AI have led to systems that outperform humans in games like
chess and Go (Silver et al., 2018). Chess commentary provides an interesting
domain for bridging these two fields of research, as it requires reasoning over
a complex board state and providing analyses in natural language. In this work
we demonstrate how to combine symbolic reasoning engines with controllable
language models to generate chess commentaries. We conduct experiments to
demonstrate that our approach generates commentaries that are preferred by
human judges over previous baselines. | [
-0.2048435658,
-0.5750722885,
0.722253859,
0.2135034502,
-0.3885717988,
0.3047281802,
-0.4071458578,
-0.8235967755,
0.2827379405,
0.6222424507,
-0.6262782812,
-0.4247624278,
-0.4758044481,
-0.0722145438,
0.0039771567,
0.9050524831,
-0.0647127032,
0.4881154597,
-0.2648761868,
-0.0110879401,
-0.8666682839,
-0.5902879238,
-0.7254257798,
-0.4928875566,
-0.202253148,
0.0021646214,
0.8791110516,
0.5768006444,
0.6321285963,
0.4638088942,
0.1909501553,
0.4637947083,
-0.2990728915,
0.4206418693,
-0.3224209845,
-0.5342106223,
-0.4595478773,
0.1328226775,
0.2974068224,
0.4679695666,
-0.1870469302,
-0.288557142,
-0.2479242384,
0.3676056564,
-0.5028941035,
0.5761088133,
-0.4444729686,
0.1430109441,
-0.0226625167,
-0.1335006952,
-0.7633366585,
-0.3590331972,
0.1356556267,
-1.2280632257,
-0.277897507,
0.1017855629,
0.7655746341,
0.3678960502,
-0.1505012661,
-0.1127567142,
-1.0520784855,
1.0471456051,
-0.9300441146,
0.2954212427,
0.3548657,
0.5633264184,
-0.3577331007,
-0.6926810145,
-0.4183346331,
-0.6755710244,
-0.3459196389,
0.2526147664,
-0.4258846939,
0.1490645707,
0.2211730629,
-0.175631091,
-0.1704435647,
-0.4211036563,
-0.0869465247,
-0.1327729374,
0.9563913345,
0.1825378388,
0.6260325313,
-0.0160605088,
0.1345269829,
-0.3279674649,
-0.4468960762,
0.155481711,
0.3621990383,
0.1985649019,
0.1921204031,
0.2709824145,
-0.2057111263,
0.7551507354,
0.3085141778,
0.1590282172,
-0.3770383596,
-0.1271693707,
0.044669874,
0.269546032,
0.6448380351,
0.7393432856,
0.5081662536,
-0.4373365641,
0.064175792,
0.4994612932,
0.7386121154,
-0.3542938828,
-0.5044291615,
-0.0564188957,
-0.4868399799,
-0.4849993289,
0.2153246701,
-0.7736946344,
-0.6189194322,
-0.6744554043,
0.5446665883,
-0.4091415405,
-0.0441693142,
0.29215312,
-0.6151512265,
0.1773240268,
0.6213076711,
-0.8746647835,
0.5339082479,
0.678039968,
0.2972468734,
-0.2906548977,
0.0742297992,
-0.7544311285,
0.4103298783,
-0.6862307191,
1.0011348724,
-0.9618275762,
-0.5867448449,
0.0460045449,
-0.2879368663,
0.4031891823,
-0.7079691291,
0.3498186469,
-0.231632188,
0.1985379308,
-0.3482714295,
-0.2803446949,
-0.0996915102,
0.1803762764,
-0.9094768167,
1.0266805887,
-0.2549313903,
-0.7054948807,
0.3004850149,
-0.6491419673,
-0.6554068327,
0.0374124423,
-0.258884728,
-0.1588967443,
0.0280869957,
0.3817388713,
0.3282596767,
-0.4808062017,
0.6917726994,
-0.4460118711,
-0.4730001688,
0.3251178563,
-0.0291413069,
0.5282482505,
-0.0551290624,
-0.6490487456,
0.3512783349,
-0.691639185,
0.025487477,
-0.136861369,
-0.118121542,
-0.4948317707,
0.7949063182,
-0.3046746254,
0.1423787922,
0.138667345,
-0.4541165829,
0.2725257277,
-0.3799732924,
0.5319874883,
0.7675010562,
0.0215769578,
0.4775195122,
-0.2241487801,
0.4102857411,
-0.1092867255,
0.1836674958,
0.3359956443,
-0.4186572433,
-0.8670787215,
-0.1822552085,
0.0643532649,
0.6297131181,
-0.9370698333,
0.1248004884,
-0.2500365376,
-0.4282676578,
-0.8314946294,
-0.1015858874,
0.380841285,
0.054649584,
0.4192500412,
-0.298211664,
-0.7391167879,
-1.075455308,
-0.7591559291,
-0.4280534387,
0.1020077467,
0.3979947865,
0.2723512948,
0.3096990585,
0.8123533726,
-0.4205814898,
0.120479241,
-0.3703009188,
0.2533845007,
0.0660505444,
0.5601560473,
0.3299150467,
-0.3763282299,
-0.5317329764,
0.2413128316,
-0.9027334452,
-0.0843378007,
-0.4040219188,
-0.6715943217,
-0.1077778488,
0.7898293734,
-0.7337545753,
0.6809179783,
0.163695991,
-0.3116939664,
0.5711886883,
-0.0147166103,
0.3854842186,
-0.7558943033,
0.1344418973,
-0.0921624973,
-0.3295877278,
-0.7003210783,
-0.0135200908,
-0.4069845378,
0.2100939155,
-0.0747312531,
0.6363332272,
-0.3431122303,
0.2522585392,
-0.1806389689,
0.1647832394,
-0.1212125197,
0.6862049699,
0.4103718698,
0.4569339752,
0.3480963111,
-0.2906894088,
0.6245872378,
0.0459506772,
-0.1949453354,
0.6378157139,
-0.7934612632,
-0.1486285627,
-0.0351786092,
0.4481415749,
-1.071403861,
-0.2371541113,
0.3392955661,
-0.3357914984,
0.4730501473,
0.1501456052,
-0.3581310809,
-0.310942173,
-0.6393100023,
-0.0026037877,
0.5431779027,
-0.2680897415,
0.8755865097,
0.5888935924,
-0.2715691328,
-0.4983323514,
-0.5434114933,
0.0953605324,
0.1325548291,
-0.4309027791,
0.0808820203,
-0.2889866531,
-0.7264239788,
0.2449601293,
-0.2234534174,
-0.0933026746,
0.0866602734,
0.2899609506,
0.4448797703,
-0.2545982599,
0.1332098544,
0.3794974387,
-0.0860348567,
0.2936713398,
-0.374154985,
0.138039276,
-0.0588235967,
-0.3411577344,
-0.6160471439,
0.5924662948,
0.3884013593,
-0.4514269829,
0.6203064919,
0.0336023159,
-0.225208357,
-0.460916847,
-0.4891296923,
-0.3535808027,
-0.4784994721,
0.3036295474,
-0.1533341557,
-0.9881302118,
0.2063324749,
0.0133780912,
0.3063901067,
0.5073494315,
0.4504273236,
-0.209151268,
1.6294771433,
0.3398091793,
-0.0627446994,
0.2222765386,
0.087836206,
0.2970573008,
-0.478554666,
-0.2901796997,
-0.5695323348,
-0.516715765,
-0.65382725,
-0.303553164,
-0.0136227421,
-0.0620466247,
-0.3077021241,
0.2120306045,
-0.596178174,
0.7329514623,
0.782361865,
0.1521910131,
0.2765030861,
-0.1406329721,
-0.3499234021,
-0.3297948539,
-0.6088628173,
-0.6141132712,
0.9703505039,
-0.0704873875,
0.8664024472,
0.0378117859,
0.4999654591,
0.4847723544,
0.5453700423,
-0.4129999578,
0.7188969851,
-0.3268380165,
-0.7981233001,
-0.1461062133,
-0.0978912711,
-0.4643047452,
0.1777295768,
-0.3356747031,
-0.69585675,
-0.0084912162,
0.2137360424,
-0.3373346031,
0.2895584106,
-0.2116919756,
0.9578059316,
-0.1321025938,
-0.470905751,
-0.2713395655,
-0.822504878,
0.5014192462,
0.2519474924,
0.1412756592,
0.3255849779,
0.2684487998,
0.7793438435,
-0.5254650116,
1.1265324354,
-0.089635998,
0.0137347011,
0.5426595807,
0.4207603335,
0.4372543991,
-0.0324989967,
0.218624115,
-0.1806608886,
-0.1783335954,
-0.166251719,
-0.7657795548,
0.7634052634,
-1.1171807051,
-0.7606433034,
-0.4288643003,
-0.5890028477,
-0.51553303,
-0.0135574201,
-0.2601598203,
0.2220422328,
-0.3192811608,
0.0941760466,
0.6115040183,
-0.0480885021,
0.1440067589,
0.4136719406,
-0.1013607159,
-0.4454492331,
0.7508298159,
-0.2175770104,
-0.0315756202,
0.5756052732,
-0.0487835407,
-0.1740309596,
-0.196027115,
-0.1960535645,
0.5460063219,
-0.8555593491,
0.0201448239,
-0.4127706289,
-0.0749090239,
-0.1995727122,
-0.2484266013,
-0.3507591486,
-0.7168980241,
0.053545475,
-0.2432147712,
0.0908440426,
1.1784447432,
-0.0859394148,
0.5615136027,
-0.7775035501,
0.1132655293,
0.6935401559,
0.3788539767,
0.1988258064,
-0.2690407634,
-0.2540952563,
0.0277658235,
-0.267048806,
-1.0832675695,
0.2628541291,
-0.1191293746,
0.8965931535,
0.3481971622,
-0.2040624619,
0.8865001202,
-0.8154707551,
0.969491601,
-0.0573801622,
-1.1249916553,
0.6787272096,
-0.3808731735,
0.1698423773,
0.470110625,
0.2342554778,
-0.4282899499,
-0.7355937958,
-0.6011203527,
-0.3837364018,
1.0144714117,
0.0691891089,
-0.2770551443,
-0.2114002705,
0.1889861226,
0.0410245731,
0.3322944641,
-0.6157887578,
0.1029072329,
-0.3099407852,
-0.2597791851,
-0.1445706338,
0.1188425645,
-0.1515429765,
-0.2974873483,
1.0610772371,
0.1440909505,
0.1044138521,
-0.061554458,
-0.2057384849,
-0.4439845979,
-0.1202892661,
0.6911799312,
0.3252729774,
-0.0515610389,
0.1957981288,
0.0527588911,
-0.3556684554,
0.0136821931,
-0.0939881876,
-0.1882212013,
0.1774049103,
0.698333323,
1.0056210756,
0.4226175547,
-0.84393543,
0.2476062775,
-0.2299694717,
-0.2763083875,
0.1637740284,
0.0682532266,
0.4835143387,
0.407265991,
-0.2348868549,
0.2681037188,
0.0674943849,
-0.4924126565,
0.1251834631,
0.6227903366,
-0.5997416973,
-0.4860936701,
1.0144892931,
0.4074450135,
-0.1731360108,
0.6224274039,
-0.0447723977,
-0.6859108806,
0.3717545867,
0.4387087822,
0.9884788394,
-0.3413970768,
0.3390845358,
0.3606241643,
0.4473819137,
-0.2256250083,
0.4178729355,
-0.2132626623,
-0.4014032781,
-0.8977601528,
-0.4881590903,
-0.6013712883,
-0.1208703816,
-0.4881722927,
0.1323603541,
-0.6627915502,
-0.2840240896,
0.0490503013,
0.0962980986,
-0.2612309456,
0.0579496957,
0.3322937489,
0.7099548578,
-1.0143588781,
0.522351861,
0.9126039147,
-0.4811515212,
-0.8054699302,
-0.3547536135,
-0.0978911743,
-0.4724824429,
0.9461379647,
-0.0658291653,
-0.2775937617,
-0.3086633682,
-1.011177659,
-0.4970075786,
0.6125599742,
0.3641186357,
-0.3231767714,
0.153103739,
0.0693774223,
0.8127193451,
-0.3103707731,
0.1251943409,
0.4860083163,
0.8573476076,
-0.0044237529,
-0.6937326789,
-0.0668655634,
-0.6359081268,
-0.0194528066,
0.4706552029,
-0.4319202602,
0.7114711404,
0.1706775874,
0.0995651409,
0.0913595781,
0.965284884,
0.2486208379,
-0.0003416554,
0.2827675641,
0.5806003213,
0.5059282184,
-0.097388342,
1.1810948849,
-0.2935234308,
-0.0222207736,
1.3450533152,
-0.5229519606,
0.9776377678,
0.4250868857,
-0.1978911012,
0.7809378505,
0.246679917,
0.0764332563,
0.4011822343,
0.366890341,
-0.1050921828,
-1.0354778767,
-0.1370880157,
0.0512359738,
0.4147544205,
0.1654874682,
0.032341525,
-0.2663546205,
-0.2338839024,
0.3075784445,
0.4290555418,
-0.1604758203,
0.8293026686,
-0.1293680668,
-1.1745243073,
-0.0267826281,
0.1044243574,
0.3358588219,
-0.7914940119,
-0.6196495891,
-0.2916497886,
0.3665629625,
0.2817150354,
-0.5257607102,
0.0638090372,
0.1793669015,
-0.0546195246,
-0.1195931807,
0.7118173242,
-0.5636643767,
-0.4718058109,
0.2366113961,
0.4026415348,
0.0603577904,
0.079735294,
-0.3601792753,
0.1028027683,
-0.0062286761,
-0.1372182816,
0.1897621155,
0.4102907777,
-0.6210219264,
0.519769609,
0.707039535,
0.2448199391,
0.2907605469,
-0.1552823335,
0.9384813309,
-0.753578186,
-0.5944440961,
-1.0357376337,
0.4520958662,
-0.4712151885,
-0.0146990279,
0.5645570159,
0.3228286207,
0.5102531314,
-0.3965141773,
0.9142354131,
0.1369953603,
0.4140205383,
-0.3785435259,
1.0378116369,
-0.4583980441,
-0.1516638845,
-0.0316736214,
-0.6756823659,
-0.5226004124,
0.8719264269,
-0.1740273982,
-0.0608919337,
0.6508301497,
0.6024441123,
-0.0237852037,
0.2861912549,
0.0892854854,
0.5126546025,
0.5420809388,
0.6641477942,
1.0851970911,
-0.1342415959,
0.4215186238,
-0.1669455469,
-0.0623162054,
-0.1731565744,
-1.0453970432,
-1.1996190548,
-0.223494947,
-0.2724885345,
-0.2260805219,
0.4282553196,
0.7398573756,
0.5179192424,
-0.9719749093,
-0.5801136494,
0.0326836929,
-0.0736138299,
-0.2808757722,
-0.1773473471,
0.3733641207,
-0.4507414103,
-0.7593607903,
0.3028577566,
0.4540260136,
-0.4008074105,
-0.3103221953,
-0.3407830596,
-0.4474715292,
0.63961941,
0.5435304046,
0.200996235,
-0.8350221515,
-0.5105704665,
0.134024784,
-0.1353643835,
-0.1734731346,
0.8254629374,
-0.922162652,
0.7149832249,
0.7188212872,
0.6196526885,
0.239938736,
-0.0690740943,
0.9015057087,
-0.4512377381,
0.0377653763,
0.2101237178,
0.1796505004,
0.2540958524,
0.1168474779,
0.4281890988,
0.3982438445,
-0.2731135786,
-0.7248860598,
0.0407717042,
-0.9329014421,
-0.3816612959,
0.571834445,
-0.0260704365,
-0.3800775111,
0.321188122,
-0.5863496661,
0.4444192648,
-0.3620045781,
0.7804927826,
1.3091509342,
-0.1083370373,
0.3697331846,
-0.572845459,
0.7374925017,
0.4661489129,
-0.941748023,
0.0435258485,
0.5659943819,
-0.2070206553,
0.2286510915,
0.4513098001,
-0.0283573065,
0.7637232542,
0.0707762614,
0.2578601241,
0.0904843658,
-0.3718713224,
-0.155655697,
-0.1590441763,
-0.0231617354,
0.1247643456
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.