id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10544v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10544v2 | Pretraining Without Attention | 2022-12-20T18:50:08 | 2023-05-09T01:08:20 | Junxiong Wang, Jing Nathan Yan, Albert Gu, Alexander M. Rush | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Transformers have been essential to pretraining success in NLP. While other
architectures have been used, downstream accuracy is either significantly
worse, or requires attention layers to match standard benchmarks such as GLUE.
This work explores pretraining without attention by using recent advances in
sequence routing based on state-space models (SSMs). Our proposed model,
Bidirectional Gated SSM (BiGS), combines SSM layers with a multiplicative
gating architecture that has been effective in simplified sequence modeling
architectures. The model learns static layers that do not consider pair-wise
interactions. Even so, BiGS is able to match BERT pretraining accuracy on GLUE
and can be extended to long-form pretraining of 4096 tokens without
approximation. Analysis shows that while the models have similar average
accuracy, the approach has different inductive biases than BERT in terms of
interactions and syntactic representations. All models from this work are
available at https://github.com/jxiw/BiGS. | [
-0.126380682,
-0.3469424844,
0.7513622642,
0.3426764607,
-0.3063668311,
-0.1480455995,
-0.1809547842,
0.0025311494,
0.4479259849,
0.3830418289,
-0.997136116,
-0.2860892713,
-0.5233473182,
-0.2043663263,
-0.5829110146,
1.0300811529,
0.1444064528,
0.106908232,
-0.2586777806,
0.2282561958,
-0.1538514197,
-0.6194583178,
-0.5465119481,
-0.0791404843,
0.6796731353,
-0.1435230672,
0.5690290332,
0.50881356,
0.3057917655,
0.3603735566,
-0.2911251485,
0.0370746218,
-0.3337338865,
0.006205908,
-0.4280313253,
-0.4365999401,
-0.4998380542,
0.1457365155,
0.8008124828,
0.7349224687,
-0.1586561799,
0.1223735809,
0.01299504,
1.0436605215,
-0.6361194253,
0.1437587738,
-0.7652977109,
0.3298954964,
-0.2530483007,
-0.013306886,
-0.5648471117,
-0.1835454851,
0.443859458,
-0.5393143296,
0.4434857666,
0.0444167107,
1.0747258663,
0.6638197899,
-0.1467219889,
0.0473302305,
-0.8139613271,
0.6613160968,
-0.7239630818,
0.5537196398,
0.2788806558,
-0.0099974303,
-0.3071201742,
-0.9275217056,
-0.6253688335,
-0.0137644019,
-0.042176608,
0.3559288383,
0.0681766793,
0.3583751619,
0.5680456161,
0.2176892757,
-0.5448297262,
0.1532752812,
-0.4444682002,
0.1523945034,
0.4014777243,
-0.2834420204,
0.0713570043,
-0.1489650607,
-0.8656743765,
-0.1638057828,
-0.6051139235,
0.1238226816,
0.1240927055,
0.3664944172,
-0.0103513962,
0.3055180013,
0.0621437021,
0.6776902676,
0.3606005013,
0.3722952008,
0.1854528487,
-0.000336603,
-0.3907150328,
0.0412668101,
0.8051886559,
-0.1965853423,
0.1762025654,
-0.5575459003,
0.0144414278,
0.0074050222,
0.9258114696,
-0.4522799551,
-0.2336962223,
0.2815847397,
-0.2564651072,
0.0332603529,
0.0728993267,
-0.5349428058,
-0.0814054012,
-0.5076961517,
0.7046432495,
-0.41114676,
-0.1014903933,
0.218785882,
0.1576749235,
0.4221507311,
0.1413544863,
-0.8313984275,
0.1271767467,
0.76713866,
0.9165579081,
-0.2796965539,
-0.4549380541,
-0.4659379721,
0.2298015058,
-0.4690792263,
0.520673871,
-0.3060015738,
0.002267817,
-0.1770582795,
0.1292432249,
-0.4590775669,
-0.1752180159,
0.451667577,
-0.995801568,
0.1460636705,
-0.0961593539,
-0.5465970635,
-0.2751638889,
-0.0651130006,
-0.7309113145,
0.7722121477,
0.0473925024,
-0.5479457378,
0.2724572122,
-0.7144397497,
-0.7277107835,
0.0474703573,
0.0014865641,
-0.3135765493,
0.103171356,
0.1811396927,
0.5696524978,
0.2113172561,
0.4014083147,
-0.2185909897,
-0.4622987509,
-0.2212430984,
-0.201230377,
0.5520659089,
0.0331103839,
-0.5625416636,
0.4567637146,
-0.7326287627,
0.2326768935,
-0.0487182215,
-0.2346036732,
-0.1569485366,
0.2334938943,
-0.3666883111,
0.7437668443,
0.0537462234,
-0.3238612711,
-0.1014062762,
-0.7689250112,
0.485627532,
1.0208598375,
-0.4084944725,
0.7227288485,
-0.0606962256,
0.4965847135,
0.4651208818,
-0.041349642,
-0.1814755946,
-0.1723005176,
-1.038143158,
-0.1397510171,
0.3999474049,
0.3688256145,
-0.8405559063,
0.7872551084,
-0.4347479939,
-0.4539569914,
-0.6107981801,
0.0637853071,
0.4234633148,
0.4363470674,
0.6758663654,
-0.4759814143,
-0.504794836,
-0.6978516579,
-0.1220241934,
0.1672460884,
-0.1121193171,
-0.0989274085,
0.1730564982,
-0.1603973657,
0.7275724411,
-0.3586558104,
-0.2776971459,
-0.2434801161,
-0.0666662902,
0.3530681133,
0.6892925501,
0.1801772565,
-0.4986779392,
-0.1229721084,
-0.5972604752,
-0.5305690765,
0.4661372304,
-0.1262985021,
-0.4850509465,
0.1028703377,
0.684773922,
-1.1011345387,
0.445587188,
0.6084131598,
-0.0071166013,
0.3762467206,
-0.1020236686,
-0.3511025608,
-0.9804620743,
0.0722890422,
0.1744112521,
-0.0729866028,
-0.7835959792,
0.0500698201,
0.1622069031,
-0.4356086552,
-0.6904935837,
0.459020704,
-0.5305930376,
-0.1936930716,
-0.0330928527,
0.1433970779,
0.132593289,
0.9166509509,
0.4056380093,
0.5994082093,
0.5205819011,
-0.7450451255,
0.0275541134,
0.306607008,
-0.4074423015,
0.1241778284,
-0.7961381674,
0.5173783898,
-0.3853239119,
0.3856675029,
-0.853028059,
0.1110970229,
0.1335854828,
-0.29155761,
0.5752719045,
-0.1976805329,
-0.1338481754,
-0.674908042,
-0.2698898613,
0.23202838,
0.6179955006,
-0.5648127198,
0.5242615938,
0.0547823645,
-0.1714552939,
-0.6441355348,
-0.4567708075,
-0.3157896996,
0.0374394469,
-0.4690080285,
0.3291182518,
0.1470066458,
0.5505568385,
-0.153902173,
-0.4365260601,
-0.0797790587,
0.0377087966,
0.3528659344,
0.3730403483,
-0.4300481081,
0.1929525137,
-0.1030056924,
-0.2019853294,
0.1353055537,
-0.6411069632,
0.5954139233,
-0.2106285244,
-0.4990059435,
-0.5217378736,
0.1523384452,
0.5319130421,
-0.5441554189,
0.8905927539,
0.6679170728,
-0.1877229363,
-0.4246781468,
-0.4040240943,
-0.1611115634,
-0.5545570254,
0.4121017456,
-0.0987661555,
-0.9411553144,
0.0263573378,
-0.1604270637,
0.0272466131,
0.2193992883,
0.1705860794,
-0.4630384147,
0.8347864151,
0.6437910199,
-0.1924744546,
0.5150300264,
-0.2082287073,
0.6472656131,
-1.0332506895,
-0.0507809669,
-0.442097187,
-0.5765097141,
-0.3965042531,
-0.6295188069,
0.0704860538,
0.3348741531,
-0.5852904916,
0.3628148139,
-0.4297749996,
0.4367449582,
0.833976388,
0.2679207623,
-0.2429027259,
-0.0073016686,
0.0444945619,
-0.1395500302,
-0.9921025634,
-0.442772001,
1.0132968426,
0.1402875483,
0.8506623507,
-0.1496269256,
0.5385418534,
0.0583768785,
0.0566377044,
-0.7755274177,
0.6462185383,
-0.2756075561,
-0.4595613182,
-0.5078739524,
-0.3183785379,
-1.0719729662,
0.276935041,
-0.1920703202,
-0.7650398016,
0.0024412579,
0.2737846076,
-0.7476235628,
0.4556328654,
-0.7700180411,
0.9205914736,
-0.2339664102,
-0.4327354729,
0.0011351748,
-1.1011884212,
0.2476888746,
-0.0169636253,
-0.2314844728,
0.0456156544,
0.3648706973,
0.8528338671,
-0.3788329065,
0.6379477978,
-0.2392648607,
0.2122533023,
0.1108644009,
-0.2157318592,
0.4942431152,
-0.5104607344,
0.0205910094,
0.2026602924,
-0.2509754598,
-0.5345313549,
-0.4223445058,
0.5438959002,
-0.8073533773,
-0.8088989854,
-0.3481881022,
-0.2568404078,
-0.4526264071,
0.3741485178,
0.0919944569,
0.3099930882,
0.067945756,
0.1233660281,
0.9284226894,
-0.2153686732,
0.6606924534,
0.2486278713,
0.1522360146,
0.1131517366,
0.5942153335,
-0.0686145872,
0.1529214978,
0.4564057887,
-0.1409130841,
-0.6435710192,
-0.481198281,
-0.4192432761,
0.2690650225,
-0.4041255116,
-0.079961434,
-0.8775577545,
-0.7205756903,
-0.4936952889,
-0.1343119889,
-0.7107726336,
-0.1579808891,
-0.4058918357,
-0.290642947,
-0.1455979049,
0.5576202869,
0.2122986913,
0.5384826064,
-0.9732910991,
0.3931450248,
0.4538400471,
0.5735923648,
0.5443512201,
-0.5320542455,
-0.3924634755,
-0.0281455461,
-0.403396219,
-0.5815884471,
0.3461350799,
0.2158013731,
0.5146953464,
0.5333737135,
0.0067332662,
0.881300807,
-1.0567016602,
0.8647158742,
0.3599986136,
-1.113301754,
0.7347339392,
-0.1021317318,
0.2984051406,
0.4749763012,
0.8034561276,
-0.2720883489,
-0.1565249264,
-0.7641618252,
-0.952013731,
1.1122165918,
-0.0693763271,
0.1359174103,
-0.0554330125,
0.1694822907,
-0.2951127589,
0.4145260155,
-0.7358175516,
-0.0937742293,
-0.3029714227,
-0.2603501081,
-0.330091089,
-0.1836853027,
0.075941965,
-0.2755099237,
0.7448000312,
0.1706962287,
0.3629608154,
0.1900431663,
-0.4061498642,
0.0007531149,
0.1798644215,
0.5503379107,
0.7346793413,
-0.1221584454,
0.097696647,
-0.1399092674,
-0.3992165029,
0.4119310081,
0.1318904012,
-0.1573937386,
0.0724164918,
0.2571734786,
1.0921041965,
0.4738303423,
-0.2715287507,
0.8229508996,
0.1832327992,
-0.0983207226,
-0.2036077678,
0.1556232274,
0.2694823444,
0.2517899871,
0.0949126557,
0.2411017567,
-0.241254136,
-0.0289153829,
0.2251489311,
0.2866086066,
-0.6802520752,
-0.534642756,
1.0104676485,
0.3739098608,
-0.3129462898,
0.8561989069,
-0.0316348001,
-0.4937328696,
0.5021387339,
0.4537810683,
1.0531677008,
-0.2842760086,
0.1304577887,
0.3609037995,
0.3058155477,
-0.2647823095,
-0.1065124273,
-0.2079884708,
-0.7697701454,
-0.8082754612,
-0.9439190626,
-0.1663137674,
0.3938816488,
-0.7770380378,
0.1879915148,
-0.7649954557,
-0.1780183464,
-0.0861029327,
-0.3095632195,
-0.89800632,
0.321235925,
0.368916899,
0.763678968,
-0.7748519778,
0.8911957145,
0.8451040983,
-0.130430162,
-1.0030246973,
0.1077405587,
-0.305314213,
-0.6130027175,
0.6416172385,
0.389117837,
-0.1668590158,
0.3304323554,
-0.4730495512,
-1.1038887501,
0.9123080373,
0.0571753494,
-0.741081655,
-0.4397064149,
-0.2420448512,
0.4079787433,
0.1516658962,
0.1616284847,
0.1964714676,
0.0666327327,
0.1772513837,
-0.532352984,
-0.008761622,
-0.1019846275,
0.3246459067,
0.1627610028,
-0.8404746652,
0.9050150514,
-0.2735439539,
-0.493881911,
-0.1692407131,
0.9193488955,
0.1168328524,
-0.1032277346,
0.5286703706,
0.924955368,
0.6063209176,
-0.1133568138,
0.7392954826,
-0.2658406198,
0.1947622895,
1.503491044,
-0.5138617754,
0.8870823979,
0.4821250737,
-0.5283170938,
0.5800136924,
0.4698007703,
0.317802906,
0.778293252,
0.349732846,
-0.0959311426,
-0.2766030431,
0.5137965083,
-0.5216735005,
0.2587633133,
0.1684013456,
-0.2301210165,
-0.2174573541,
-0.1145208105,
-0.0262848027,
-0.1316330135,
-0.456934005,
0.8146127462,
0.2365027219,
-0.7077538967,
0.3777880371,
-0.1851048172,
0.8958739042,
-0.9754329324,
0.1890466064,
-0.2001100332,
0.1634515822,
-0.0672970563,
-0.4269351065,
0.1338888407,
-0.0831382051,
-0.3975138664,
-0.4854449034,
0.6509310603,
-0.5122757554,
-0.2323628366,
0.2070127726,
0.4492652714,
0.1165865511,
-0.142794922,
-0.4826001823,
-0.4271554351,
-0.2028082907,
-0.5309495926,
0.3589740694,
0.3362833858,
0.1422358304,
0.6517675519,
0.8615943789,
0.1687972397,
0.4370706379,
0.1069044396,
0.7281975746,
-0.8777750134,
-0.7633262277,
-0.8354415298,
0.471411407,
0.0560561419,
-0.1446186155,
0.6363847256,
0.2772871554,
1.0495673418,
-0.4108965695,
0.3392708898,
0.2284087092,
0.5275670886,
-0.6702334881,
0.8004371524,
-0.332668215,
-0.1071734726,
-0.4230055213,
-0.9788395166,
0.0666026622,
0.6843445897,
-0.36261186,
0.1491016746,
0.7974224091,
0.5871961713,
-0.1585936844,
0.137956351,
0.2863891423,
0.2232679129,
0.0903587937,
0.7271534204,
1.0094718933,
-0.2637271583,
0.0851337165,
-0.0333882794,
-0.0367403477,
0.0004641065,
-0.9225267768,
-0.8873050213,
-0.427229017,
-0.01890295,
-0.2379043698,
0.0515556522,
0.8459883928,
1.1036053896,
-0.6629760265,
0.1023506448,
-0.0533871092,
0.1496797502,
-0.16973795,
-0.1890218258,
0.6195324063,
-0.8574537039,
-0.5304058194,
0.5621163249,
0.349986732,
0.0669606701,
-0.1488745809,
0.1762395948,
-0.5679965019,
-0.0141204344,
0.7810031176,
0.2205457985,
-0.5936338305,
-0.216906175,
-0.1956718564,
-0.099276863,
0.1717133671,
0.586617589,
-0.8339451551,
0.2346493155,
0.0978722647,
1.0143100023,
0.7682100534,
0.2706633508,
0.388802886,
-0.9516095519,
0.5157439709,
0.3680657148,
0.0810477659,
0.1421909332,
-0.2096664011,
0.37426579,
0.2042532861,
-0.4638642967,
-0.4205026031,
0.1522691548,
-0.9441146255,
-0.0441928394,
0.7864227295,
-0.4736448526,
-0.4928257167,
0.2149485052,
0.2271150947,
0.2670111358,
-0.0385659821,
0.6331400871,
0.7633365989,
0.0491959862,
0.0213157944,
-0.3609172404,
0.6776242852,
0.8342352509,
-0.6897439957,
-0.3356670737,
0.295319587,
0.0378821567,
0.1932230741,
0.7186957598,
0.0305493064,
0.0051023811,
-0.2610505819,
0.1223209053,
0.0482430235,
-0.7188484669,
-0.3564328253,
-0.0898812786,
-0.2145117819,
-0.5011667609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10543v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10543v2 | Detoxifying Text with MaRCo: Controllable Revision with Experts and Anti-Experts | 2022-12-20T18:50:00 | 2023-05-26T20:26:06 | Skyler Hallinan, Alisa Liu, Yejin Choi, Maarten Sap | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text detoxification has the potential to mitigate the harms of toxicity by
rephrasing text to remove offensive meaning, but subtle toxicity remains
challenging to tackle. We introduce MaRCo, a detoxification algorithm that
combines controllable generation and text rewriting methods using a Product of
Experts with autoencoder language models (LMs). MaRCo uses likelihoods under a
non-toxic LM (expert) and a toxic LM (anti-expert) to find candidate words to
mask and potentially replace. We evaluate our method on several subtle toxicity
and microaggressions datasets, and show that it not only outperforms baselines
on automatic metrics, but MaRCo's rewrites are preferred 2.1 $\times$ more in
human evaluation. Its applicability to instances of subtle toxicity is
especially promising, demonstrating a path forward for addressing increasingly
elusive online hate. | [
-0.0957577899,
-0.9172798991,
0.6273662448,
0.1810621768,
-0.1065022871,
0.359873414,
-0.2533123195,
-0.5214356184,
0.3920070231,
0.6591076851,
-0.4224210382,
-0.4969733357,
-0.5136882663,
0.1650240123,
-0.4569999874,
1.360096097,
-0.020992063,
-0.1178586334,
0.257596761,
-0.0279627498,
-0.1914194375,
0.0073436094,
-1.0786601305,
-0.4196205735,
1.4021083117,
0.5206042528,
0.9690004587,
0.7124807239,
0.4053405523,
0.2641704679,
-0.2473104149,
-0.0452627912,
-0.5132463574,
0.4154835939,
-0.6508330703,
-0.3023624718,
-0.1307730675,
-0.0583972931,
0.16835545,
0.3736926317,
-0.1081113592,
-0.1703430265,
-0.1580370069,
0.7683467865,
-0.5984739661,
-0.2874982953,
-1.0903004408,
0.1148595288,
-0.0129648745,
-0.2839161456,
-0.6410236955,
-0.4387300313,
-0.1353889853,
-0.6290314198,
-0.1088491455,
-0.0368907526,
0.9103257656,
0.6639661193,
-0.5395503044,
-0.450537622,
-0.9285962582,
0.948556602,
-0.6796671152,
0.0563492998,
0.1633782983,
0.2167004496,
-0.2080301344,
-0.617836535,
-0.2772473097,
-0.1545735002,
-0.0397869721,
0.0325493142,
-0.3260349631,
0.1724901199,
0.0011149111,
0.1571406871,
-0.3248274922,
0.2120821327,
-0.4212647974,
-0.0247399472,
1.0105191469,
0.2952492535,
0.6591883302,
-0.1908454448,
-0.5719174743,
0.4063593745,
-0.8171328306,
-0.5425509214,
0.5761991143,
0.0337420814,
0.5544581413,
0.2320074439,
-0.1810625643,
0.2400415987,
0.0835697576,
0.1986222267,
0.2151601613,
-0.1691720188,
-0.2939921319,
-0.1029396355,
0.9181375504,
0.4042888284,
0.1407509446,
-0.1046770439,
-0.1872348934,
-0.1848010868,
0.7887057066,
-0.8336494565,
-0.7918016911,
0.4758851826,
-0.4483074248,
-0.7365683317,
-0.4221802652,
-1.051051259,
-0.6330485344,
-0.2443368137,
0.6393582225,
-0.5305743814,
-0.4056973159,
-0.0177010559,
-0.3774949312,
-0.1006677002,
0.364887923,
-0.5971036553,
0.0163291153,
0.2969705462,
0.4093455076,
0.0241428521,
0.1871327758,
-0.1958549023,
0.2749257088,
-0.5917649269,
0.5311473012,
-0.7425612807,
-0.1715662926,
-0.0693603233,
-0.2540089786,
0.2266882658,
-0.6173942089,
0.6845663786,
-0.7020274401,
0.2042473257,
-0.3020147681,
-0.2678698003,
-0.0743369758,
0.142288506,
-0.6147648096,
0.8803539276,
-0.0247066058,
-0.9515233636,
0.3340560794,
-0.5441997051,
-0.4172919095,
0.0162042659,
0.1649248302,
-0.7505130172,
0.1615024209,
-0.2411262989,
0.0082845567,
0.1921156645,
0.3489867449,
-0.2938722372,
-0.197686255,
0.2270134538,
-0.4796577096,
1.0588713884,
0.8057489991,
-0.6253160238,
0.5726983547,
-0.5887514949,
0.1711317748,
-0.1253927648,
-0.3557919562,
-0.7345315814,
0.3083857894,
0.2914857566,
0.3708239496,
0.0088570155,
-0.505432725,
-0.0501889884,
-0.2424007058,
0.5992783308,
0.7307676077,
0.586849153,
0.3221675754,
-0.4593400359,
0.353310883,
0.0354703106,
0.5753772259,
-0.0152159724,
-0.5675866008,
-0.9267812371,
-0.2401141077,
0.1432350576,
0.6002120376,
-1.2212513685,
0.4721428752,
-0.1435810775,
-0.8813323379,
-0.5552546382,
0.3430971801,
0.8184014559,
0.2346045822,
0.7595015764,
-0.0472852103,
-0.3186955154,
-1.1455279589,
-0.8996580243,
-0.002206773,
-0.3228599727,
0.1276035756,
0.4473118484,
-0.6126793027,
0.7057567239,
-0.4703237712,
-0.4877332747,
-0.1599624306,
0.5102164745,
-0.2129188925,
0.582056284,
0.4454626143,
-0.7248030305,
-0.8288813233,
-0.2153193653,
-0.3482690156,
-0.6822276115,
-0.5159019232,
-0.127287209,
-0.023610387,
0.7258948684,
-0.0290172473,
0.3941808343,
0.0766109824,
-0.2212819457,
0.3805629313,
-0.4752281904,
0.1949265599,
-0.6873859167,
0.0419702567,
-0.0804217011,
-0.0957104638,
-1.016117692,
0.4818402231,
-0.0035589123,
0.0809306353,
-0.6142954826,
0.4851184785,
-0.6525271535,
0.692573905,
-0.2199237943,
0.2336198837,
0.1331925392,
0.2788878083,
-0.0059902244,
0.1950218379,
-0.000715732,
-0.5050195456,
0.0651441664,
0.0098276669,
-0.0121438503,
0.556088388,
-0.4781353176,
0.0047524916,
-0.3451822102,
0.2401798666,
-0.8692517281,
-0.0862588361,
0.5222120881,
-0.1607271731,
0.3419518769,
0.1651147604,
-0.5261143446,
-0.2687068582,
-0.4816341996,
0.4106082618,
0.3844003677,
-0.2491325587,
0.3118773699,
0.3464942276,
-0.1711486727,
-0.4503113031,
-0.8899680972,
0.5640936494,
-0.5327632427,
-0.0123920403,
0.451579839,
-0.3988577425,
-0.4003413916,
-0.1090813503,
0.1665463001,
-0.3401253223,
0.1060455963,
-0.0032187682,
-0.2812763155,
0.4443621635,
0.2356326282,
0.609171629,
-0.275079608,
0.3342470825,
0.26049757,
0.0977549329,
0.2235915661,
0.1192308068,
-0.2157990038,
0.5253692269,
0.4383367896,
-0.0967740789,
0.4760008454,
0.7417060733,
-0.3664123714,
-0.4496529102,
-0.4202240109,
-0.1038186848,
-0.5572254658,
0.2548845112,
-0.2146506459,
-0.4005673826,
0.5316649079,
0.0183761902,
0.1625878811,
0.3995789886,
0.6251493096,
0.0444394387,
0.89105165,
0.4121131301,
-0.0263999198,
0.7025274038,
0.1070378199,
0.2737732232,
-0.5866253376,
-0.1605392545,
-0.5008906722,
-0.5423947573,
-0.5716322064,
-0.4889233112,
0.292583555,
-0.1182465926,
-0.3703914285,
0.4097463787,
-0.8075012565,
0.8151294589,
0.6022138,
0.63937819,
0.4535618722,
-0.1272016466,
-0.08972729,
-0.4481652975,
-0.4980405569,
-0.5411037803,
0.8375424743,
0.5697870255,
0.7679219842,
0.0067651332,
0.8414211273,
0.3051021695,
1.1419471502,
-0.522229135,
0.5039054751,
-0.0810276493,
-1.2811864614,
-0.1907062382,
-0.523611486,
-0.6890460253,
0.1259884536,
-0.1691729128,
-0.3913001418,
0.0410651267,
0.073047936,
-0.2217716873,
0.5420515537,
-0.6976456642,
0.7258691788,
-0.0976810753,
-0.6002650261,
-0.4295967817,
-0.8581985235,
0.4056651294,
-0.4500516653,
0.5725032091,
0.0957468078,
-0.4303345382,
0.5931343436,
-0.3497583866,
0.8477172852,
-0.2454583645,
-0.5050415397,
0.4194733202,
0.5580276251,
0.2204573005,
-0.0776712373,
-0.1800874025,
0.1553793252,
-0.1916989982,
-0.3872429132,
-0.3604785204,
0.7768626809,
-0.5371079445,
-0.3895931244,
-0.1034659371,
-0.2747068405,
0.0842487887,
0.6810016632,
0.5165567398,
-0.022904925,
-0.1994801909,
-0.1020344049,
0.9838636518,
-0.8863648176,
0.3205504715,
0.4067091942,
-0.301371932,
-0.7827922702,
1.001950264,
-0.0357610248,
0.3798164129,
0.5816408992,
0.3040543497,
-0.0424000137,
-0.5398700833,
-0.3673044443,
0.1220717058,
-0.629267931,
-0.2975536883,
-0.7456134558,
-0.1556610167,
0.1262919009,
-0.3768184185,
-0.3524761796,
-0.0702348799,
-0.4402670264,
-0.133638829,
0.1829388738,
0.9010847211,
-0.2151651978,
0.3379375339,
-0.6541754603,
0.2865229845,
0.1894018203,
0.3853658438,
-0.2744330466,
-0.3614579141,
-0.109532401,
0.1030507013,
-0.4140803218,
-1.4706157446,
0.5291755795,
0.0515982546,
0.3841963112,
0.8243086338,
0.5752183795,
0.4815067351,
-0.7101892829,
0.6268420815,
0.1188474968,
-0.9626134038,
0.6501044035,
-0.7270853519,
-0.0465466604,
0.8357969522,
0.5816875696,
-0.7377206087,
-1.2598233223,
-0.7095795274,
-0.9656354189,
0.0999448821,
0.238439098,
0.3647221923,
-0.2881209552,
0.3716287911,
0.1292010397,
0.3195722699,
-0.7166365981,
-0.2536557317,
-0.0590232685,
-0.5354531407,
0.1468497962,
-0.605407536,
-0.2355070114,
-0.1607296616,
0.7879394889,
0.4654943943,
0.2312169373,
0.3545511067,
-0.2884484828,
-0.4211887717,
0.4780957401,
0.5566442609,
0.3494507074,
-0.15420416,
0.2695989013,
-0.0315577537,
-0.2553476095,
0.2249212265,
-0.4632781148,
-0.5067583919,
0.1324466914,
0.1501333863,
0.2163029611,
0.4411801398,
-0.5210662484,
0.446557343,
0.0855420083,
-0.4666512907,
-0.2171715796,
0.3343509734,
-0.1034645513,
-0.1338480264,
0.2619909048,
0.1215361878,
0.3137695193,
-0.3250794709,
0.4519047439,
0.3208025098,
-0.6149842739,
-0.2317172587,
1.2155638933,
0.5276696086,
-0.2664542496,
0.3176189959,
-0.308108598,
-0.5656217933,
0.3556981087,
0.1163641065,
1.0412291288,
-0.6632812023,
0.2765199542,
0.5626782179,
0.7455688119,
0.5071819425,
0.1564564556,
0.171647355,
-0.4494329691,
-0.1204314977,
-0.345554173,
-0.3793686032,
0.2225485146,
-0.491753757,
0.0874667987,
-0.7700768709,
0.0179534126,
0.0895388275,
0.1194312125,
-0.1996442229,
0.3310539424,
-0.0971437395,
0.970264852,
-1.2025334835,
0.6610631943,
0.5314412117,
-0.6433516145,
-0.4191811979,
0.1011059582,
0.1489644498,
-0.1535461396,
0.5075852275,
0.2148627043,
0.1401738524,
-0.0101523865,
-0.5514561534,
-0.3870499432,
0.6465001702,
-0.060112562,
-0.4603200853,
0.0379072651,
-0.047634121,
0.9256076217,
0.1655647755,
0.6023125052,
0.2936852872,
0.8120611906,
-0.1762928665,
-0.6567921042,
0.2685197592,
-0.3873235285,
0.0098176422,
0.1472926736,
-0.6888830066,
0.4845035374,
-0.3505424857,
-0.1896217912,
-0.0478231795,
0.444498986,
-0.3131552339,
0.3148500025,
0.6598539352,
0.607745707,
0.5841593146,
0.138438046,
0.2937607467,
-0.2858809233,
0.2454970479,
1.0713398457,
-0.0107134636,
0.7199185491,
0.3671043515,
0.0029950393,
0.9356766939,
0.6014683843,
0.0803368688,
0.6018601656,
0.4318168163,
-0.5282277465,
-0.1962129772,
0.162517637,
-0.08368247,
0.0839122161,
0.4493258595,
-0.7936654687,
-0.4112971127,
0.0668143779,
0.5856891274,
0.3343364596,
-0.2917023599,
0.8078829646,
0.0246788226,
-0.6375389695,
0.3863178492,
0.207375139,
0.5726933479,
-0.2223373801,
0.2243800163,
-0.2569271028,
0.4312853813,
-0.4132384062,
-0.6709167957,
0.7955079675,
-0.0676693916,
-0.0788872242,
-0.8101330996,
0.9201654196,
-0.8537612557,
-0.0802953094,
0.427523464,
0.2332677543,
0.2138524055,
-0.3150106072,
-1.0767325163,
-0.1781360656,
0.1984333396,
-0.4292990863,
0.2600964606,
0.5504330397,
-0.0277176332,
0.8652685285,
0.4408509135,
0.151004985,
0.1037495732,
-0.1513752341,
0.9482121468,
-0.6404784918,
-0.3539206982,
-0.7480731606,
0.6019584537,
-0.1093419641,
-0.1669673771,
0.7104791403,
0.4819614887,
0.7174981833,
-0.0991938934,
0.5224781632,
0.0101960115,
0.5426691175,
-0.2299466431,
1.364846468,
-0.5752939582,
0.0988125131,
-0.5841320157,
-0.6051284671,
-0.6782197356,
0.4240551293,
-0.4198253751,
0.0141169922,
0.7902753353,
0.9267860651,
0.240163058,
-0.2883453667,
0.2048686296,
0.5523079634,
0.7113146782,
0.6544249058,
0.478803277,
-0.4983899295,
0.7667322755,
-0.2720090747,
-0.5147907138,
-0.2986471951,
-1.0723221302,
-0.8089972138,
-0.4802954495,
-0.6381843686,
-0.4025562406,
0.0482237227,
0.6000651717,
0.2457986325,
-0.583491385,
0.4019118547,
-0.3266665041,
0.6011176705,
-0.2908594608,
-0.3409287035,
-0.0415451527,
-0.4330256879,
-0.8644052148,
0.2280022055,
0.2197547555,
-0.3642729819,
-0.3792397976,
0.1933583915,
-0.0997546539,
0.3792865276,
0.5167210102,
0.0980795622,
-0.5736630559,
-0.5761461258,
-0.4348954558,
-0.4468173981,
-0.1619589478,
0.6384038329,
-0.5432731509,
0.6663026214,
0.7238368988,
0.4070403874,
-0.0705527291,
0.0233582314,
0.2877543867,
-0.7062968612,
-0.2293125391,
0.4598478079,
-0.1123083159,
0.1650496423,
-0.4173483551,
0.4703009725,
0.2159918398,
-0.7584960461,
-0.7797893882,
0.438794136,
-0.6421771646,
-0.5586768985,
1.3347718716,
-0.2068749368,
-0.3118858635,
-0.4364978373,
-0.3607391119,
0.2664034665,
-0.1509810984,
1.1183469296,
0.4899651706,
0.164551422,
-0.141957283,
-0.456676811,
0.7275378704,
0.4119102955,
-0.956553936,
0.3362074196,
0.5215448141,
0.7819518447,
0.2056657374,
0.8014165759,
-0.2306525707,
-0.0647271574,
0.1320386082,
0.2433791906,
-0.0169767253,
-0.4975705445,
-0.1450870335,
-0.2096759081,
-0.2501478493,
0.2368677258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10539v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10539v1 | Toward Human Readable Prompt Tuning: Kubrick's The Shining is a good movie, and a good prompt too? | 2022-12-20T18:47:13 | 2022-12-20T18:47:13 | Weijia Shi, Xiaochuang Han, Hila Gonen, Ari Holtzman, Yulia Tsvetkov, Luke Zettlemoyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models can perform new tasks in a zero-shot fashion, given
natural language prompts that specify the desired behavior. Such prompts are
typically hand engineered, but can also be learned with gradient-based methods
from labeled data. However, it is underexplored what factors make the prompts
effective, especially when the prompts are natural language. In this paper, we
investigate common attributes shared by effective prompts. We first propose a
human readable prompt tuning method (F LUENT P ROMPT) based on Langevin
dynamics that incorporates a fluency constraint to find a diverse distribution
of effective and fluent prompts. Our analysis reveals that effective prompts
are topically related to the task domain and calibrate the prior probability of
label words. Based on these findings, we also propose a method for generating
prompts using only unlabeled data, outperforming strong baselines by an average
of 7.0% accuracy across three tasks. | [
-0.3593091667,
-0.6092184186,
0.6996733546,
0.2933881581,
-0.1047641188,
0.2213620842,
-0.3901177049,
-0.1922010779,
-0.0344854854,
0.1129905581,
-0.6202077866,
-0.3991770744,
-0.2171099186,
0.2260324955,
0.0464522056,
1.0208595991,
0.1445933282,
-0.2012441307,
-0.020234229,
-0.1436630338,
-0.5647006631,
-0.0237139165,
-0.3191004694,
-0.4012244046,
0.9238401055,
0.5937308073,
0.8692649007,
0.5545451045,
0.2564686537,
0.1050984263,
-0.1321059018,
0.3740619421,
-0.2590398192,
0.3345693052,
-0.4522085488,
-0.1953893155,
-0.0223513115,
0.1379003972,
0.4790324271,
0.8792453408,
-0.0152574079,
-0.2086232156,
0.2766060233,
0.7130267024,
-0.8008229136,
0.0056699011,
-0.1759385616,
0.0465960018,
-0.2262848169,
-0.2910934389,
-0.4759016931,
-0.5051104426,
0.1807810515,
-0.757642746,
0.5355861187,
0.1500538141,
0.7224596739,
0.047955744,
-0.3727314472,
-0.3920074701,
-0.5175654292,
0.9606887698,
-0.400657177,
0.0616050437,
0.611964047,
0.2013015449,
-0.2039403468,
-0.3514355421,
-0.3512117565,
-0.3842374086,
-0.1941339523,
0.0743913278,
-0.0677858368,
0.2086938322,
0.4053066075,
0.2376623005,
-0.5322493911,
0.320419699,
0.019027153,
-0.5589324832,
0.3686958551,
0.4082284868,
0.3113951087,
-0.5164970756,
-0.1979206204,
-0.2932456732,
-0.4910738766,
0.5386584401,
0.2890627384,
0.5567843914,
-0.1223632023,
0.3208735585,
-0.2673447728,
0.7325539589,
0.0898423493,
-0.0416629501,
0.1809815317,
-0.4797045588,
0.1773888469,
-0.0325433202,
0.5784806013,
0.7197801471,
0.6093143821,
-0.3067188859,
-0.3956139386,
0.1247924119,
0.2569717467,
-0.6518508196,
-0.290553093,
0.0202179477,
-0.3086122274,
-0.184822455,
0.072178483,
-0.7888906598,
-0.929946363,
-0.5030063391,
0.5417517424,
-0.632606864,
-0.072200574,
0.09461689,
-0.3080761135,
0.2383729368,
0.4121321142,
-1.3009568453,
-0.2348894477,
0.467220217,
0.8601965904,
-0.1767154783,
-0.174637422,
-0.9654406309,
-0.1197088286,
-0.2838697135,
0.8012017608,
-0.5987250805,
-0.4478324056,
0.1245795488,
-0.2185104638,
-0.0955922678,
-0.3577355444,
0.5650532246,
-0.1589156538,
0.1477143615,
-0.5302874446,
-0.4714092612,
0.2319435328,
-0.0357048251,
-0.6106495857,
0.5322266817,
0.2224603891,
-0.4603031576,
0.7703676224,
-0.7788980603,
-0.5525500774,
0.041618038,
-0.0734513849,
-0.0296801496,
0.209487915,
0.6747249365,
0.4531145394,
-0.0844424963,
0.3541784883,
0.1999815553,
-0.3799232244,
0.4274914861,
-0.4300528765,
0.4648790061,
0.4153899252,
-0.3389205337,
0.1356772631,
-0.8246414065,
-0.1146860719,
-0.3944856822,
-0.1598014534,
-0.0318881683,
-0.0059908968,
0.082800515,
-0.2575482726,
0.0552064143,
-0.4890421033,
0.2170671672,
-0.3051147163,
0.2469417155,
0.7821422219,
0.2181691974,
0.6983050704,
-0.529699266,
0.5445451736,
0.0070185,
-0.0632175133,
-0.720651865,
-0.5960364342,
-0.3386616111,
-0.5373166203,
-0.0585570708,
0.5656581521,
-0.491658181,
0.2447829396,
0.3509431779,
-0.6341292262,
-0.4630928338,
-0.0398714058,
0.2732104659,
0.8889843225,
0.3487609327,
0.050683409,
-0.1273343861,
-0.7971120477,
-0.4591214955,
-0.1031519249,
-0.1217919067,
0.5488523245,
-0.074519895,
0.0283776429,
1.1579251289,
-0.6252238154,
0.098066017,
-0.059945412,
0.8067666888,
0.8326969147,
0.5120608211,
0.3440478444,
-0.3786150217,
-0.6727012992,
-0.1034138575,
-0.7923044562,
-0.5199703574,
-0.4309227169,
-0.0000625677,
-0.0313665755,
0.6615993977,
-0.4995850921,
0.2629867494,
-0.2493584305,
-0.6164184213,
0.6394039989,
-0.5256061554,
0.3683467507,
-0.8303756118,
0.2490468472,
0.321793288,
-0.1656215489,
-0.7252414227,
-0.0147626139,
0.3812758327,
-0.1999027729,
-0.3491437733,
0.7302567959,
-0.4259390831,
0.3718533218,
-0.268245846,
-0.0622547753,
0.0960077345,
0.337528944,
-0.1009214073,
0.96707654,
0.8384461999,
-0.8577200174,
0.3463940918,
0.1965091079,
-0.8086425066,
1.0414206982,
-0.6522365212,
0.0463999957,
-0.5089697838,
-0.0010177928,
-1.1022492647,
-0.4497151375,
0.1083951145,
-0.102032721,
0.1858801842,
0.2161385119,
-0.4097319543,
0.0131839979,
-0.2381730527,
0.3701015115,
0.8547694683,
-0.6498811245,
0.3426629007,
-0.0898868293,
-0.1792080849,
-0.5058150291,
-0.1207815856,
0.1308743358,
-0.236994043,
-0.6521421075,
0.5974898934,
-0.2627827823,
-0.1944197863,
-0.5116593242,
0.0957082137,
0.1006602645,
0.1429685801,
0.3268623352,
0.1866758168,
-0.1995631009,
0.1872439981,
-0.0851460472,
-0.3310108483,
-0.2378238142,
0.160394311,
0.3157984316,
-0.0338123813,
-0.0441615395,
-0.7233812213,
0.3126617968,
0.5987939239,
-0.0721194893,
0.4991006255,
0.7788656354,
-0.1499270499,
-0.1465206295,
-0.1884205639,
-0.3694474399,
-0.5211683512,
0.1370954216,
-0.0596591085,
-0.8249557018,
0.58470577,
0.0511815697,
0.2089205533,
0.1008808985,
0.5048978329,
-0.3610730767,
1.2912726402,
0.6638525724,
-0.0169536825,
0.8572750092,
0.2274263799,
0.0950652137,
-0.5183547139,
-0.1265949011,
-0.5911096931,
-0.534865737,
-0.3078840077,
-0.0838200822,
0.4036305547,
0.3308032751,
-0.2799839079,
0.268987596,
-0.5061263442,
0.7350561619,
0.8431822658,
-0.029040223,
0.018942235,
-0.118911244,
-0.5121814013,
-0.2697683871,
-0.1714978665,
-0.5478720665,
0.5152022243,
0.1269493848,
0.9605978727,
0.0890107676,
0.3357179761,
0.4567704797,
-0.1725181788,
-0.574749589,
0.4519597292,
0.2005222738,
-0.508328259,
-0.2540539503,
-0.2942127287,
-1.181889534,
-0.2055149227,
-0.2343509048,
-1.0399760008,
0.3800650537,
0.1689170003,
-0.7140897512,
-0.0452730171,
-0.930955708,
0.7371278405,
0.0132536525,
-0.3420134485,
-0.1543787569,
-0.7461488843,
-0.2815664709,
-0.0287061203,
0.0743926913,
-0.3888985515,
-0.1022585928,
0.4874634743,
-0.2267487943,
0.9024324417,
-0.3568136394,
-0.1743549258,
0.0977107137,
0.0040760403,
0.535267055,
0.1932086647,
-0.4230104685,
-0.3557713926,
-0.2449494153,
-0.5845107436,
-0.8686664104,
0.2966356575,
-0.6725068092,
-0.3587382436,
-0.3231140077,
-0.6772226691,
-0.3867182732,
0.0886793882,
0.4851703048,
0.9027069211,
-0.2855910957,
-0.2222284824,
0.6143285632,
-0.5135169625,
0.7636998296,
0.6491532922,
-0.1174698919,
-0.413067311,
1.1164021492,
-0.1122525334,
0.1708131731,
0.314112097,
0.4074772,
-0.3495552242,
-0.3638034463,
-0.5674085617,
0.1119650453,
-0.6759752035,
-0.0752294734,
-0.3801102638,
-0.0443525016,
-0.1118737012,
-0.7640812397,
0.172410816,
-0.3080098629,
-0.594222486,
-0.1325461864,
0.5880534053,
0.7324855328,
-0.4125799239,
0.3749734759,
-0.7439598441,
0.3250745237,
0.4867880642,
0.4043866098,
-0.0032577992,
-0.5126778483,
-0.2671411633,
-0.0186212175,
-0.1642882675,
-0.5786834359,
0.2414036691,
0.486359477,
0.657813251,
0.572994411,
0.3419069052,
0.1536821872,
-0.3504184484,
1.0852577686,
0.4372113347,
-0.7226572633,
0.8540177941,
-0.6399614215,
0.7976725698,
0.9022279978,
0.3030410707,
-0.6800691485,
-0.359577477,
-0.2217054516,
-0.8928980231,
0.8532984853,
0.0850379989,
0.3870550394,
-0.2403343171,
0.2329627424,
0.475199461,
0.192120567,
-0.3646624386,
-0.2118966281,
-0.1827838123,
-0.2041652501,
-0.292445451,
0.1128785387,
0.1115700454,
-0.2937101126,
0.2296056002,
-0.1602031142,
0.0859754086,
0.1551756412,
-0.2328782976,
-0.307253629,
0.4212433398,
0.7694932818,
0.6026678085,
-0.5971517563,
0.3175650537,
-0.3958055675,
-0.7053689361,
0.3096852303,
-0.168884486,
-0.3211389184,
-0.018156752,
0.349278599,
1.1032998562,
0.0962927788,
-0.6748095155,
0.3932023048,
-0.1765954643,
-0.1028619558,
0.3523025513,
0.6092383862,
-0.3157435954,
0.1377637982,
0.569106102,
0.3015268147,
-0.2813806534,
-0.5648713708,
0.2020137906,
0.2649950683,
-0.6995208859,
-0.245795235,
0.491256088,
0.5693774819,
-0.8071346879,
0.814789772,
-0.3989647329,
-0.3009051681,
0.3895213604,
0.5528460741,
0.6911933422,
-0.0124761527,
0.6032848954,
0.6297258139,
0.0827974379,
0.0252487939,
0.2316695154,
-0.2548881471,
-0.7159205079,
-0.4137627482,
-0.5030453801,
-0.5356909037,
-0.1444979608,
-0.6901625991,
0.2308881581,
-0.4454801381,
-0.1150476411,
0.2219072282,
-0.2212457508,
-0.4884338975,
0.0751435906,
-0.0014778397,
0.8160353899,
-0.8642126322,
0.2904371917,
0.6147998571,
-0.5969917774,
-0.6505126953,
0.0602259003,
-0.0716388077,
-0.6633691192,
0.3421787918,
0.5625206828,
0.2366130203,
0.2696181536,
-0.5687969327,
-0.5511491299,
0.7336260676,
0.5093303919,
-0.4723779857,
0.1253170669,
0.0024683541,
0.3652478456,
-0.0459657013,
0.3262351155,
0.6739770174,
0.6179028749,
0.0812189355,
-0.9133924246,
-0.101092279,
-0.4270174801,
-0.5616651177,
0.4010622501,
-0.0994881019,
0.4713220298,
-0.5437690616,
-0.3401074708,
0.1676741391,
0.6656224132,
0.4266386926,
0.5950769782,
0.6506106257,
0.1682824641,
1.3266673088,
0.0302956887,
1.1141761541,
-0.1334092021,
-0.0884335116,
0.4363130331,
-0.1860608459,
0.4253412783,
0.4893198013,
-0.1101574749,
0.6391121745,
0.6980829835,
0.0371914469,
0.9888143539,
0.0580049716,
-0.6107507944,
-0.5153170824,
-0.5064743161,
-0.2076821178,
-0.0841239095,
0.195479691,
-0.3364392519,
-0.2679436207,
0.3609680533,
-0.1453914791,
0.1825486124,
-0.470649451,
0.6044534445,
0.1696005762,
-1.1274428368,
0.5343800783,
-0.1608525813,
0.8798396587,
-0.4564675093,
0.0530538112,
-0.2717220187,
-0.114861019,
-0.1280368119,
-0.9367178679,
-0.2716847956,
0.1829382032,
-0.6965025663,
-0.3915076852,
0.5932912827,
-0.1522181332,
-0.2850889564,
-0.3402912617,
0.4348650873,
0.1349717081,
0.0661178306,
-0.4262244403,
-0.4340175986,
0.0477138236,
0.0287446845,
0.3155786693,
0.3321080208,
0.1273414493,
0.4460550249,
0.5802359581,
0.030667292,
-0.2110229284,
0.4095487297,
0.3524793386,
-0.870880425,
-0.6307328939,
-0.778137207,
0.8802477121,
-0.1524070948,
-0.7556535602,
0.6283040643,
0.1181793362,
-0.0406998731,
-0.0658951327,
0.5160631537,
0.1206437051,
0.5702438354,
-0.5320699215,
0.7545245886,
-0.2456155717,
0.1454438418,
-0.4740738869,
-1.0190876722,
-0.4334899485,
0.8766995072,
-0.1300387532,
0.1723534912,
0.6730232835,
1.107596159,
-0.0006208259,
0.2354389578,
0.2638792992,
-0.3732884824,
0.3832406402,
0.4016040862,
1.0446093082,
0.1928234249,
0.1212566122,
-0.0431610905,
-0.4148285389,
-0.404438287,
-1.2871899605,
-0.8059158921,
-0.5761051774,
-0.4261081517,
-0.3600184917,
-0.0888556242,
1.0436080694,
0.5784063935,
-0.7322339416,
0.0266233701,
-0.385279119,
0.1124462262,
-0.3186490238,
-0.2279562205,
0.4387106001,
-0.6575990915,
-0.4188172519,
0.6827167273,
0.3473448455,
0.1371359825,
-0.1525857747,
-0.1768671274,
0.1428653449,
0.3155447245,
0.3162078857,
0.3119185269,
-0.307857126,
-0.4728550315,
0.255835861,
-0.4418704808,
0.0067519657,
0.9405590296,
-1.0213668346,
0.7367882729,
0.6477348804,
0.4603441358,
0.1364099681,
0.1138159409,
1.0255192518,
-1.0202600956,
-0.2727890611,
0.2191297561,
0.2092466056,
0.4715261459,
-0.345225811,
0.4563266635,
0.1408830583,
-0.837913096,
-0.8293011785,
0.2606405914,
-1.014654994,
-0.1862964481,
1.187985301,
0.2734453082,
-0.0514962748,
-0.5620583296,
-0.5734333992,
0.1041680947,
-0.7297170758,
0.6686490774,
0.7495046854,
-0.3584564626,
-0.1305061877,
-0.196013391,
0.6462314129,
0.5964553952,
-0.3471495509,
0.2708479762,
0.4702784121,
-0.115322426,
0.1534631252,
0.5196846128,
0.4214468598,
0.6285377145,
-0.2673941851,
-0.2513041198,
-0.0400961228,
-0.2062294185,
-0.4127825201,
0.0976665244,
0.2774540186,
0.1395402104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10537v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10537v2 | Does CLIP Bind Concepts? Probing Compositionality in Large Image Models | 2022-12-20T18:46:28 | 2023-03-29T15:34:23 | Martha Lewis, Nihal V. Nayak, Peilin Yu, Qinan Yu, Jack Merullo, Stephen H. Bach, Ellie Pavlick | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large-scale neural network models combining text and images have made
incredible progress in recent years. However, it remains an open question to
what extent such models encode compositional representations of the concepts
over which they operate, such as correctly identifying ''red cube'' by
reasoning over the constituents ''red'' and ''cube''. In this work, we focus on
the ability of a large pretrained vision and language model (CLIP) to encode
compositional concepts and to bind variables in a structure-sensitive way
(e.g., differentiating ''cube behind sphere'' from ''sphere behind cube''). In
order to inspect the performance of CLIP, we compare several architectures from
research on compositional distributional semantics models (CDSMs), a line of
research that attempts to implement traditional compositional linguistic
structures within embedding spaces. We find that CLIP can compose concepts in a
single-object setting, but in situations where concept binding is needed,
performance drops dramatically. At the same time, CDSMs also perform poorly,
with best performance at chance level. | [
-0.387912482,
-0.8627080321,
0.4630278051,
0.2828489244,
-0.4683032334,
-0.0359634608,
-0.3218027055,
-0.3209139407,
0.2653552592,
0.5126522779,
-0.4209963083,
-0.6574636102,
-0.7499193549,
0.0513553023,
-0.6488384008,
0.622071445,
-0.0593263321,
0.0704699233,
-0.862604022,
-0.1398676187,
-0.6906569004,
-0.6506536603,
-0.029718535,
-0.1258506477,
0.0329517797,
-0.1054730117,
0.9257289767,
0.8049200773,
0.7369989157,
0.3399550617,
-0.4482065439,
0.0633383766,
-0.3799515069,
-0.1019773185,
-0.2998447418,
-0.6340422034,
-0.1331929415,
0.0450882204,
0.7619525194,
0.7703849077,
-0.024415642,
-0.1414538175,
-0.0302405115,
0.4411132932,
-1.0559602976,
-0.0365789905,
-0.5222340226,
0.2608088553,
-0.1248447448,
-0.0297288187,
-0.5602342486,
0.0030118504,
0.4111905992,
-0.6376464963,
0.2441013604,
-0.2397022396,
0.7919819355,
0.3101181388,
-0.4418787658,
-0.2288658172,
-0.7044989467,
0.7747946382,
-0.3034616709,
0.3470517099,
0.4207931161,
0.0038750013,
0.1928150505,
-0.6379568577,
-0.4947479069,
0.0357263722,
0.0730228871,
0.155604586,
-0.0274848361,
0.0317996033,
0.1939307749,
0.2525927126,
-0.1917112619,
-0.1282125413,
-0.4093620181,
-0.1582119018,
0.5485188961,
0.3556936383,
0.5150744915,
-0.1945133358,
-0.6434934735,
-0.370387584,
-0.7502536774,
-0.1605622619,
0.1367078424,
-0.0097497189,
-0.1924242973,
0.8496747613,
0.3395116925,
0.8796555996,
0.1027149409,
-0.1248860657,
-0.1094937176,
-0.2509944737,
-0.1069956124,
0.0885350332,
0.7995734811,
0.5180979967,
0.0019121607,
-0.1379668117,
-0.0740921944,
0.3982919753,
0.4047652483,
-0.9145787358,
-0.4797874987,
0.0393282138,
-0.4841098487,
-0.0940715894,
0.2602640688,
-0.275850445,
-0.1282991618,
-0.4999635518,
0.6264351606,
-0.6607569456,
-0.184994027,
0.477825284,
-0.2267179489,
0.1453282386,
0.3048304915,
-0.8642917275,
0.3795204759,
0.8061971068,
1.1255111694,
-0.5767130256,
-0.4645760953,
-0.195274055,
0.283944428,
-0.5584232211,
0.9436751604,
-0.7241210938,
-0.575484097,
0.1970573515,
-0.086139001,
-0.2616808712,
-0.7490276694,
0.0944232121,
-0.6392831206,
-0.1808387488,
-0.3384493589,
-0.8872815371,
0.0158790592,
0.3127633035,
-0.8245628476,
0.4494611025,
-0.2576779127,
-0.7715526223,
0.2926791906,
-0.2598268092,
-0.470713228,
-0.2843684554,
-0.3815957904,
-0.31010589,
0.1592954695,
-0.0704552904,
0.378334105,
-0.1435025036,
0.1971311867,
-0.3938365877,
-0.4715755582,
0.7530189157,
0.0060504833,
0.5044486523,
0.0315642953,
0.1358272135,
0.0463448688,
-0.4107978046,
-0.2023515105,
-0.0152440509,
-0.1701444685,
-0.3783359826,
0.1611293852,
-0.0969479531,
0.1515812576,
-0.0261880253,
-0.4871753454,
0.1828656197,
0.0164906271,
0.6879133582,
0.5944969058,
-0.1644220352,
0.6913049221,
-0.2088279277,
0.650575757,
0.4681470096,
-0.0470062047,
-0.300696373,
-0.3000477552,
-0.5535956025,
-0.5376232266,
0.4001253843,
0.2264288068,
-0.5693455935,
0.3432697952,
-0.0767289922,
-0.2858889699,
-0.2019538581,
-0.1001658663,
0.3367045224,
0.1453392357,
0.1322881579,
-0.611065805,
-0.1629393548,
-0.9900337458,
0.1353809685,
0.1191958413,
0.1096280068,
0.301525563,
0.6692287326,
0.0108707929,
1.0941433907,
-1.1540261507,
-0.4463618398,
0.0610081665,
-0.022386184,
-0.1470603943,
0.3908942938,
0.6973695159,
-0.9133845568,
-0.1894498914,
-0.2765513062,
-0.7137697339,
0.3867538571,
0.0371643193,
-0.2603958845,
-0.1475026309,
0.5608097911,
-0.8379039168,
0.5622156262,
0.5794611573,
-0.4626397789,
0.8413076401,
-0.2781195939,
-0.0965139046,
-0.7421432734,
-0.0313669294,
-0.1276642084,
-0.0131147821,
-0.5034391284,
0.0623087436,
0.2333570868,
-0.3807928264,
-0.857914865,
0.2212932706,
-0.4367645979,
-0.2129013687,
-0.4414492548,
-0.0034740765,
0.3705609143,
0.3804492056,
0.547571063,
0.9442272782,
0.7047917843,
-0.9002502561,
0.146929726,
0.8456255198,
-0.685247004,
0.6130015254,
-0.9270042181,
0.0138584422,
-0.1540004164,
0.3992713392,
-0.4550468624,
-0.1410593987,
-0.0763320625,
-0.057442598,
0.3100858033,
-0.0201592557,
-0.4784067571,
-0.1219070479,
-0.2448880374,
1.0129138231,
0.3138132691,
-0.3393702209,
0.4442541897,
0.5687807798,
0.3936166465,
-0.4821758866,
-0.9136360288,
-0.0601594672,
-0.0929740742,
-0.5935283303,
0.6609695554,
-0.0663942024,
0.0051765521,
0.310634464,
0.0805825368,
-0.3154638708,
0.0914033726,
0.3368583918,
0.1330601275,
-0.1955135167,
0.2144031525,
-0.0505011268,
0.2904818356,
0.2102182359,
-0.2199865878,
0.4747161865,
-0.1433885694,
-0.5211691856,
-0.2167463303,
0.3677986562,
0.5275121331,
-0.5597741604,
1.0056445599,
0.2421857268,
-0.3222776651,
-0.4361029267,
-0.1330122501,
-0.0504891649,
-0.4640894532,
0.464789778,
-0.4952850044,
-0.8726177216,
0.6051346064,
0.0278218817,
-0.6943589449,
0.194593668,
0.4800359607,
-0.140807122,
0.60529989,
0.5875942111,
0.2369785309,
0.5312572718,
-0.8241283298,
0.0793490857,
-1.2004104853,
-0.3200009763,
-0.2427715212,
-0.3877264857,
-0.2805429995,
-0.7818223238,
0.3916086257,
0.2093402892,
-0.0248757675,
0.4178786278,
-0.4502859116,
0.8033666015,
0.5483814478,
0.4124945998,
0.2083820254,
-0.3343365788,
-0.1491390765,
0.0049690953,
-0.7714323401,
-0.2601603568,
0.9955434203,
0.1317694634,
0.941103518,
-0.0022485123,
0.2052617073,
0.1541397423,
-0.0666653737,
-0.8054971099,
0.5679582953,
-0.5672711134,
-0.6068019271,
0.0405271277,
-0.0720518976,
-0.8049220443,
0.3467571139,
-0.3216672838,
-0.4605519474,
0.5593202114,
0.174530074,
-0.1155312136,
0.4902885258,
-0.5017682314,
0.9288999438,
-0.1387047321,
-0.3257691562,
-0.257575959,
-0.4949191213,
0.5590184331,
0.0065947631,
-0.0642998442,
-0.1317048818,
-0.0077200262,
0.6279245615,
-0.5048746467,
1.008503437,
0.2937488258,
-0.2331810743,
0.5751820803,
0.3481634855,
0.0691376254,
-0.1211037785,
0.1963816583,
0.2866405249,
0.3532857299,
-0.3286705613,
-0.7349062562,
0.3436433077,
-0.8199145198,
-0.4414410889,
-0.1475568712,
-0.5652841926,
0.0313954167,
0.0042333868,
0.5745703578,
0.8631298542,
-0.4412532747,
0.2864093184,
0.8100068569,
-0.2679950595,
0.1607719064,
0.0657721832,
-0.184015438,
-0.3896794915,
0.8439506292,
0.1495000422,
0.5315894485,
0.5991309881,
0.0535355173,
-0.1825898439,
-0.4692015648,
-0.4233780801,
0.2356026024,
-0.8621341586,
-0.3837934732,
-0.5134755373,
-0.3004015684,
-0.0098740542,
-0.1847726256,
-0.6668739319,
-0.4863368869,
-0.6023254395,
0.0085577546,
-0.0241942443,
0.7501420975,
0.1023544744,
0.2099444866,
-0.8490943313,
0.2522479594,
0.4766824841,
0.5092813373,
-0.022775,
-0.2682451904,
-0.5100196004,
0.001495555,
-0.621988833,
-0.8644196391,
0.1088142619,
0.4444278777,
0.2284016311,
0.7375902534,
0.1637228578,
0.489566505,
-0.693844676,
0.8786754608,
0.3135385513,
-1.1799929142,
0.537827611,
-0.3341315687,
0.4971072376,
0.2443072945,
0.2383342683,
-0.4947645962,
-0.4311053455,
-0.3300104737,
-0.3909573853,
0.7396379709,
0.0707859993,
0.4529162645,
-0.4622148275,
0.1779402941,
0.0671099126,
0.372858882,
-0.3349066973,
-0.1744886786,
-0.3689163625,
-0.083222717,
0.1334892064,
-0.5023050308,
-0.287630707,
-0.1513658911,
0.144429177,
-0.1600141525,
0.597120285,
0.26093328,
-0.3143511415,
0.0864389911,
-0.1056324616,
0.7982625365,
0.7480453849,
-0.0649710745,
0.5478642583,
-0.1820847839,
-0.5128884912,
0.3739695847,
-0.3539442122,
-0.5305073261,
-0.0807760879,
0.6280378699,
1.0299972296,
0.4719174802,
-0.8302265406,
0.907292068,
-0.0374572054,
-0.441844821,
-0.0225971155,
0.0924766213,
0.1609735489,
0.1015138999,
-0.1555466801,
0.0649547055,
0.0890130177,
-0.6554822326,
0.0826871842,
0.6834468842,
-0.2487077415,
-0.746833086,
0.6089927554,
0.0825812817,
-0.1193781346,
0.5829022527,
0.0699139759,
-0.9673492908,
0.7765944004,
0.7433683872,
0.7395064235,
0.1029147431,
0.5037908554,
0.2490894049,
0.0926389024,
-0.240715906,
-0.185084343,
-0.2887829542,
-1.1831959486,
-0.6724990606,
-0.4559649825,
-0.5441958308,
-0.3334529102,
-0.7971235514,
0.1012949497,
-0.406136781,
-0.2737864256,
-0.2180891782,
-0.5142094493,
-0.7377219796,
0.1470487565,
0.196687758,
0.8875272274,
-0.8682855964,
0.6418358088,
0.8846385479,
-0.2378720194,
-0.5881108046,
-0.1808244735,
-0.4046473801,
-0.2979630232,
0.8231201768,
0.1245911121,
-0.1288043857,
-0.4233543277,
-0.7111536264,
-1.0706164837,
0.9098206758,
0.6514377594,
-0.2036075294,
0.1006589681,
0.2572802603,
0.4549721777,
-0.3967016339,
0.0762898922,
0.4410227239,
0.0674208552,
0.3440051377,
-0.7701373696,
-0.1070914567,
-0.0514025949,
0.2183821201,
0.2115935534,
-0.8950895667,
0.8701153994,
-0.1383299083,
-0.4791945219,
0.0075139701,
0.7073198557,
0.0647829548,
0.1655137986,
0.25409621,
0.8647752404,
0.4903441668,
-0.0691206604,
1.165653348,
-0.1621853709,
0.3598682284,
1.1059888601,
-0.3169604838,
0.890776217,
0.3134158552,
-0.2661783695,
0.3781439364,
0.3146358728,
-0.0798030794,
0.8767166138,
0.2168910205,
-0.166987583,
-0.4542184174,
-0.2686913311,
-0.2753990889,
0.6538646221,
0.2837568223,
-0.2145337462,
0.12567693,
0.3120992482,
-0.2944294512,
0.2118512094,
-0.1706456691,
0.8464135528,
0.2568968236,
-0.572930932,
0.3949481547,
-0.0132281994,
0.3968729079,
-0.4087254703,
0.163513273,
-0.0453735106,
0.2170391381,
0.0166672636,
-0.7885793447,
0.5076757073,
-0.3284837008,
-0.2178175002,
0.0127574401,
0.63424927,
-0.5172374249,
-0.3399340808,
0.0996631756,
0.1508488804,
-0.0754732862,
-0.0609025508,
-0.3184763789,
0.546012342,
-0.5083742738,
0.0900905132,
0.2707508802,
0.5020363331,
0.1859007925,
0.743398428,
0.3156614602,
0.2396504283,
0.1506193429,
-0.2932789624,
1.0786242485,
-0.6186126471,
-0.5466325283,
-0.8230645657,
0.2644885182,
0.1350581497,
-0.3863777816,
0.5121181011,
0.5004776716,
0.9983975887,
-0.4760018289,
0.29227525,
0.2144053429,
-0.2198815346,
-0.9151405692,
0.5652179718,
-0.3595124483,
0.0130527522,
-0.3682073355,
-1.1352244616,
-0.4438475072,
0.5846338868,
-0.3232061267,
-0.3828716278,
0.9357976913,
0.4560114443,
-0.1769723594,
0.0507992655,
0.4816614389,
0.0631648004,
0.2256212234,
0.40492028,
1.2405790091,
-0.2670534551,
0.3162032962,
-0.3593692482,
0.2799910903,
-0.1670133471,
-0.8422555923,
-0.9555653334,
-0.6404097676,
-0.6365334988,
-0.0615544133,
-0.0197424721,
0.5990613103,
1.0426180363,
-0.5428435802,
-0.0740763694,
0.011990251,
0.106038928,
-0.087386243,
-0.0929782689,
0.6980714202,
0.0137590971,
-0.5880486965,
0.1418759078,
0.2874723077,
0.1430799365,
-0.1817626506,
0.0569911934,
0.0355954878,
0.1643333286,
0.7299273014,
-0.0670842826,
-0.4951990247,
-0.2710826099,
0.0271932688,
-0.0340681858,
0.1232776493,
1.218957901,
-0.6524749994,
0.4922683835,
0.3716247976,
0.8646209836,
0.7146434784,
0.1540286094,
0.5697383881,
-0.7645362616,
0.3013806641,
0.2195077986,
0.3977152705,
0.3366159499,
-0.1058050171,
0.1683741957,
0.2527378201,
-0.431866467,
-0.6207327247,
0.5617294312,
-1.0234968662,
-0.5771458745,
1.0148540735,
-0.1515571028,
-0.6178787947,
0.4531064928,
-0.1489156038,
0.0130176805,
-0.0132477963,
0.5891868472,
0.8481161594,
0.0707983524,
-0.2245913148,
0.0058530192,
0.3146374524,
0.5124890804,
-0.5719719529,
-0.2116579115,
0.5993864536,
0.1526815146,
0.2803314328,
0.4018329382,
-0.1885323822,
0.3409171402,
-0.0611168481,
-0.0533244461,
-0.1970627755,
-0.5697333217,
-0.2079336792,
0.2863914371,
0.0859924927,
-0.524610579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10536v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10536v1 | Measure More, Question More: Experimental Studies on Transformer-based Language Models and Complement Coercion | 2022-12-20T18:46:20 | 2022-12-20T18:46:20 | Yuling Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based language models have shown strong performance on an array
of natural language understanding tasks. However, the question of how these
models react to implicit meaning has been largely unexplored. We investigate
this using the complement coercion phenomenon, which involves sentences like
"The student finished the book about sailing" where the action "reading" is
implicit. We compare LMs' surprisal estimates at various critical sentence
regions in sentences with and without implicit meaning. Effects associated with
recovering implicit meaning were found at a critical region other than where
sentences minimally differ. We then use follow-up experiments to factor out
potential confounds, revealing different perspectives that offer a richer and
more accurate picture. | [
-0.5073016286,
-0.6938055754,
0.8088468313,
0.1988685131,
-0.1792136282,
-0.1096385643,
-0.1195564717,
-0.787293613,
-0.1206866503,
0.5333914161,
-0.7797074914,
-0.0643588454,
-0.7881454825,
0.338870883,
-0.6371065974,
1.2509371042,
-0.1106694043,
0.04934467,
-0.5332008004,
-0.3309639096,
-0.4844334126,
-0.4073031247,
-0.3518368006,
-0.5771355629,
0.6053732038,
0.3246009946,
0.89384377,
0.2055732906,
0.5392311811,
0.3053660393,
-0.1211203486,
-0.3571227193,
-0.3751527369,
0.1769380122,
-0.2923671305,
-0.7054281235,
-0.2483831197,
0.268340379,
0.7539820671,
1.0366290808,
0.286919117,
0.0339792259,
0.122831054,
0.8150544167,
-0.650359571,
0.1249820963,
-0.1657089293,
-0.1697584689,
0.2503626645,
0.267621398,
-0.460233748,
-0.1992004812,
0.5768216848,
-0.5593935251,
0.498983711,
0.2987705171,
0.9090140462,
0.3445629179,
-0.8022562861,
-0.4487707019,
-0.8614110947,
0.8043727279,
-0.4720496833,
0.4571369886,
0.3380262554,
-0.0013615132,
0.2414468676,
-0.8092743754,
-0.9866039753,
-0.534499824,
-0.8126547933,
0.4801288843,
-0.1781032383,
0.1678000391,
0.3626284897,
0.4733197689,
-0.3275444806,
-0.2673726976,
-0.4966597557,
0.1038011983,
0.5340551138,
0.1118863747,
0.3663995862,
-0.3981274664,
-0.3212141991,
-0.1573758125,
-0.5134508014,
0.3936105072,
0.3662129641,
0.0565442927,
-0.3986601532,
0.8000563979,
0.0732788146,
0.3049969673,
0.0533803292,
0.6168199778,
-0.0629738867,
-0.3903836906,
-0.285779506,
0.047929436,
0.3989995718,
0.2372543812,
0.5044648647,
-0.214264974,
0.0673743561,
0.2273895741,
0.1974808425,
-0.5746974349,
0.0318616629,
0.228650108,
-0.0524588712,
0.1401739568,
0.1633612961,
-0.4367947578,
-0.3954392076,
-0.5312413573,
0.0632645264,
-0.2948636413,
-0.2132732272,
0.2514016032,
-0.4171607792,
0.5859581232,
-0.0331924669,
-0.5651714206,
0.7364253402,
0.8809110522,
0.6861173511,
-0.3529368639,
-0.1678092778,
-0.3114265203,
0.0182699729,
-0.1477090567,
0.7519289851,
-0.7856943011,
-0.4203657806,
-0.0514213108,
0.5088373423,
-0.1859262437,
-0.0576565079,
1.0640227795,
-0.5017156005,
0.6254187822,
-0.4475841224,
-0.7511890531,
-0.5189697146,
0.2042730898,
-0.7610362172,
1.0761742592,
-0.158042118,
-0.6757506132,
0.1663847417,
-0.3286084831,
-0.5394335985,
-0.1001741812,
-0.0991457477,
-0.2604121268,
0.5841902494,
-0.1248839721,
0.3097634017,
-0.2806611955,
0.3348402977,
-0.1730921268,
-0.3735956252,
0.5220178962,
-0.434815377,
0.4835652113,
-0.3917364776,
-0.5041837692,
0.0206987169,
-0.6410106421,
-0.279506743,
-0.1699490398,
0.0077864504,
-0.7987968922,
-0.0026678981,
-0.0819937289,
0.2448904365,
0.0557644591,
-0.8038019538,
0.01686465,
-0.5316526294,
0.1487138271,
0.6437907219,
-0.0169696305,
0.7132732868,
-0.3254292905,
0.3992939889,
-0.1919566691,
0.0341570713,
-0.1733473986,
-0.4450446069,
-1.2653366327,
-0.0084413625,
-0.0109301973,
0.3618791103,
-0.339861393,
0.0419864617,
-0.3088389635,
-0.1955590844,
-0.4721200764,
-0.1868103743,
0.4884641171,
0.5205456614,
0.487511605,
0.1055052802,
-0.4528753161,
-1.048915267,
-0.4449467659,
-0.15629749,
-0.0549202897,
0.5314565897,
0.8505554199,
-0.14797315,
0.8443598151,
-0.7549260259,
-0.3559611738,
-0.2149366438,
0.3025185466,
0.1812716275,
0.3335470855,
0.2799707949,
-0.9883879423,
-0.194479689,
-0.1727505326,
-0.5419331193,
-0.1351355165,
-0.3299298286,
-0.1196182966,
0.1174167991,
0.6510087252,
-0.586399138,
0.2167149931,
0.5113378167,
-0.5798136592,
0.4454332888,
-0.3287653625,
0.014484833,
-0.6863678694,
0.0132875573,
0.0029110215,
-0.1248095408,
-0.5829169154,
0.0797770396,
0.0896655321,
0.3910170496,
-0.3413049877,
0.6082448959,
-0.6430844069,
-0.0602379888,
-0.3486335874,
0.3948306441,
0.2885884047,
0.3461012542,
0.5127552152,
0.4061208963,
0.3321765661,
-0.5976493955,
0.3157308996,
0.1373163611,
-0.0424997732,
0.5598402619,
-0.9954473376,
0.1471143961,
-0.5817543864,
0.2733857632,
-1.5408049822,
-0.2562813461,
0.0054730624,
-0.250564009,
-0.0273315031,
0.0912244543,
-0.0480404831,
-0.225481227,
-0.3930062056,
0.3331739902,
0.3552446365,
-0.3318860829,
1.0051534176,
0.0665862262,
-0.1107645407,
-0.4400634766,
-0.8276766539,
-0.1227912083,
-0.0346613042,
-0.4028305411,
0.2811060846,
-0.0526929684,
-0.5269697905,
0.1154771596,
-0.0821000859,
0.0816847682,
-0.0300033968,
0.7807084322,
0.487131834,
-0.181955725,
0.3054028451,
0.2060110122,
0.0034393794,
0.4776530862,
0.1897537857,
0.3356091678,
-0.2582115531,
-0.3005313873,
-0.0412249751,
0.4273488224,
0.4273833632,
0.044601988,
0.9204499125,
0.3184295893,
-0.2228455096,
0.0054480177,
-0.5030112267,
-0.2044963539,
-0.465803951,
0.0709121823,
-0.3300536275,
-0.8922849894,
0.4915474057,
0.1435835212,
0.0144958682,
0.5865767598,
0.2509874701,
-0.2824757099,
0.7960951328,
0.8292280436,
0.1029741913,
0.3774547577,
-0.1999343634,
-0.0794277862,
-1.170238018,
-0.5216632485,
-0.6961483955,
-0.3599712849,
-0.6402956843,
-0.2105225325,
0.1724550128,
-0.0920029804,
-0.1381810308,
0.2234485745,
-0.2289322764,
0.5111310482,
0.3983840048,
-0.0673089921,
0.6743027568,
-0.3923369348,
-0.0794630498,
-0.127173245,
-0.2200235277,
-0.4995329082,
0.6847365499,
0.1109256148,
0.7555212975,
0.192645058,
0.0695843995,
0.2191452682,
0.7015778422,
-0.6803461313,
0.3983078599,
0.0918703824,
-0.8607469797,
-0.2037124187,
-0.1722069085,
-0.9502273798,
0.2722885907,
-0.198573947,
-0.5174780488,
0.2829435468,
-0.1830300987,
-0.2446518242,
-0.1668610424,
-0.7367390394,
0.5525197983,
-0.0915310979,
-0.5777965188,
-0.0852119178,
-0.6679851413,
0.5697160959,
0.1931766123,
0.3315411508,
0.0074374443,
-0.33646065,
0.4851410389,
-0.0120137502,
0.9252946377,
0.2050565332,
-0.4686999619,
0.2018566728,
0.1194613576,
0.5663923025,
0.1132125631,
0.0138642713,
-0.2126998603,
-0.0085632754,
-0.3779928684,
-0.8024173379,
0.6094562411,
-0.7069008946,
-0.6598482728,
-0.4795804024,
-0.7592932582,
-0.1891529709,
0.0479346775,
0.2520992756,
0.2882585526,
-0.2852369249,
0.15916574,
0.6307606101,
-0.248162359,
0.6694012284,
1.0938622952,
-0.1079773083,
-0.0224784911,
0.3819493949,
-0.0030053826,
0.479449451,
0.4073626399,
0.2019405067,
-0.5742032528,
-0.0884416029,
-0.072025165,
0.4297753572,
-0.5713254213,
0.3143583238,
-0.730102241,
0.0017694448,
-0.3617703617,
-0.2040951997,
-0.0710835457,
-0.401689291,
-0.0430894941,
-0.406932801,
0.3135685921,
0.8821126223,
0.192398563,
0.3070864975,
-0.7641995549,
0.2704508007,
0.2526295185,
0.219914481,
-0.1765361279,
-0.7113099098,
0.04000948,
-0.0517389365,
-0.0685572699,
-0.7717135549,
0.0969341621,
0.2133515328,
0.4481057823,
0.1486699134,
0.2342708707,
0.4363306761,
-0.3867859244,
0.8939496875,
-0.0376109183,
-1.1369538307,
0.3605574369,
-0.0242822077,
0.5123704672,
0.3007757068,
0.6628360152,
-0.8686382174,
-0.857889235,
-0.7842546105,
-0.7681092024,
0.3632213473,
0.3511769474,
0.6754364371,
0.0100551769,
0.5058578253,
0.073884815,
0.1492122561,
-1.0791442394,
-0.3835033178,
0.0301160552,
-0.1973662376,
-0.3742158711,
-0.3158459067,
0.1204052195,
-0.3357368112,
0.7470630407,
-0.1311662793,
-0.1132698059,
0.5042976141,
-0.3902934194,
-0.0505642742,
0.4353071749,
0.6993591189,
0.2308422625,
0.057228405,
0.5765020251,
0.3725082278,
-0.5475658774,
0.1223062575,
0.0756355524,
-0.2304446101,
0.041121494,
0.9495150447,
0.8339642286,
0.2258727849,
-0.7083665133,
0.548571527,
-0.2098923177,
-0.1008647606,
-0.254968673,
0.142944932,
0.1769841313,
0.2886378765,
0.2968898118,
-0.1099910066,
0.2479707152,
-0.6622235775,
0.1898889542,
0.4468053579,
-0.945951879,
-0.502958715,
0.3932873905,
0.1107248962,
0.1151636541,
0.3983839452,
0.1272132248,
-0.5955307484,
0.5465477705,
0.4454503059,
0.6840627193,
-0.0925946385,
0.2447046041,
0.2709520161,
0.5323708057,
-0.0798108503,
0.2978898883,
-0.2620002329,
-0.8894879818,
-0.6538628936,
-0.35449633,
-0.4555832744,
0.0829036459,
-0.8310005665,
-0.0185335986,
-0.0749466494,
0.0157745015,
-0.0681778565,
-0.1334054023,
-0.3871500492,
0.3282261789,
0.0596681088,
0.6493848562,
-1.1494352818,
0.4003532231,
0.6242082715,
-0.6122962832,
-0.7915542126,
0.1194352806,
-0.3286809623,
-0.4410012364,
0.7378665805,
0.1470676214,
-0.4031946957,
-0.0181349907,
-0.596046567,
-0.6661399007,
0.609577775,
0.3664388061,
-0.641399622,
-0.139296934,
0.570248425,
0.83801651,
-0.0775913894,
0.4800521433,
0.873498559,
0.6581621766,
0.0767363086,
-0.5655757785,
0.3613771796,
-0.10101071,
-0.2698383033,
0.1561251879,
-0.5165138245,
0.8319277763,
-0.2588537633,
-0.3712238371,
-0.0385048911,
0.7213795185,
-0.289537847,
0.1742777228,
0.3512988091,
0.2994142473,
0.6231691241,
-0.1343860328,
1.4890016317,
-0.0150145339,
0.5237874985,
1.3114299774,
-0.1779727489,
0.6636047959,
0.6335602999,
-0.0980801433,
0.9362019897,
0.1953625828,
0.3326841593,
0.2807382643,
0.2450499982,
-0.3484973311,
-0.3594337106,
-0.4542491138,
-0.2094955444,
0.0888461471,
0.0665288717,
-0.4783193767,
-0.1515323967,
0.2236796916,
-0.0308824852,
0.1426254809,
-0.2747958601,
0.8689004779,
0.445397675,
-0.9535859227,
0.3839756846,
-0.248659119,
0.4331932366,
-0.3268665075,
0.0212298241,
-0.453512758,
0.3156754076,
-0.2282195091,
-1.2494215965,
0.5200688839,
0.0253997743,
-0.2866952419,
-0.2000097632,
0.7595203519,
-0.4960454702,
-0.6732938886,
0.5048618317,
0.6061171293,
-0.0213310383,
-0.1201278716,
-0.3627918065,
-0.0755039304,
-0.322855562,
-0.3419280648,
-0.1461172253,
0.4990873337,
0.1587750614,
0.6718967557,
0.4948628247,
-0.1213910803,
0.1737556159,
0.2001379281,
0.6646076441,
-0.6370362043,
-0.2148792893,
-1.0512387753,
0.6260481477,
-0.064060092,
-0.288186729,
0.970887363,
0.6306650043,
0.691298306,
0.0597265065,
0.6364058256,
0.0988706872,
0.2201015651,
-0.4488295019,
0.1910855323,
-0.433183521,
0.1581251472,
-0.4175564051,
-0.7678947449,
-0.1253735423,
0.369438678,
-0.6268936396,
-0.2297337353,
0.9616310596,
0.4019939005,
-0.0326608904,
0.3928974569,
0.21180439,
0.2975037694,
0.1687969267,
0.5276370645,
1.2130732536,
-0.4472588599,
0.4674800634,
0.0802608058,
-0.1122607812,
0.2183362097,
-0.844350934,
-1.0638897419,
-0.7263644934,
-0.2157949805,
-0.3719104528,
-0.0801544636,
0.5257765055,
0.2524843514,
-0.7327099442,
-0.057580553,
-0.5509700179,
0.4113242328,
-0.108919695,
-0.2415940315,
0.3131728768,
-0.2901360393,
-0.9970488548,
0.0203923639,
0.0779248625,
0.2257068753,
-0.199520275,
-0.0736355186,
-0.2857953608,
0.4717021585,
0.5546343327,
-0.0298850257,
-0.5269166231,
-0.6433714628,
0.1917687207,
-0.1515370011,
-0.1980384588,
0.9470552206,
-0.7795680165,
-0.0201677177,
0.5434250236,
0.4785798192,
0.7935715318,
0.1091510653,
0.7387387753,
-0.9081481099,
0.0357923768,
0.0332471654,
0.3755787909,
0.2029055208,
-0.4416453838,
0.4966670275,
0.312225014,
-0.1452218294,
-0.7376486659,
0.3682231605,
-0.8028604388,
-0.3619047701,
1.3452097178,
-0.0170948878,
-0.2328051925,
-0.109025009,
-0.4066383243,
0.3829832971,
-0.1342004091,
0.5446727276,
1.0444691181,
-0.245925948,
-0.1686420441,
-0.4669593573,
0.512861073,
0.7327581644,
-0.8098214865,
0.2158765197,
0.6150752902,
0.2421982437,
0.263237685,
0.2619273365,
0.2490946949,
0.1024971232,
-0.2782699168,
-0.2610448599,
0.0495956875,
-0.2383080721,
-0.3111590445,
0.2060857415,
-0.3474213481,
0.1848462522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10535v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10535v2 | A Survey of Deep Learning for Mathematical Reasoning | 2022-12-20T18:46:16 | 2023-06-22T01:37:02 | Pan Lu, Liang Qiu, Wenhao Yu, Sean Welleck, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Mathematical reasoning is a fundamental aspect of human intelligence and is
applicable in various fields, including science, engineering, finance, and
everyday life. The development of artificial intelligence (AI) systems capable
of solving math problems and proving theorems has garnered significant interest
in the fields of machine learning and natural language processing. For example,
mathematics serves as a testbed for aspects of reasoning that are challenging
for powerful deep learning models, driving new algorithmic and modeling
advances. On the other hand, recent advances in large-scale neural language
models have opened up new benchmarks and opportunities to use deep learning for
mathematical reasoning. In this survey paper, we review the key tasks,
datasets, and methods at the intersection of mathematical reasoning and deep
learning over the past decade. We also evaluate existing benchmarks and
methods, and discuss future research directions in this domain. | [
-0.4228368998,
-0.7333194017,
0.6284855604,
0.2307972759,
0.1181709394,
0.3545154929,
-0.3017956316,
-0.3103546202,
-0.4892556965,
0.3660637438,
-0.6894316077,
-0.4498694539,
-0.4437479675,
-0.0566939823,
-0.0867948309,
0.3757259846,
-0.1361375451,
0.5375978351,
-0.6891406775,
-0.2092085332,
-0.6697559953,
-0.8192874193,
-0.6778073907,
-0.6603760719,
0.1464660168,
0.2556135058,
0.7112838626,
0.0753208548,
0.8266159296,
0.3224341571,
0.2006652653,
0.3657432497,
0.1452658623,
0.3821268678,
-0.0935140401,
-0.651217103,
-0.1823917329,
-0.0985413641,
0.2454107553,
1.3430734873,
0.0658594221,
0.0913198814,
-0.1872804016,
0.8522415757,
-0.6737657189,
0.518694222,
-0.3394296467,
0.2260591686,
-0.1208200231,
0.3158960938,
-0.156736955,
-0.6913785934,
0.2685422301,
-0.5164248347,
0.0055913343,
-0.3883785605,
0.2956704497,
0.4040618837,
-0.2926307619,
-0.4645699263,
-0.761716485,
1.1814860106,
-0.6285056472,
0.6674528122,
0.543781817,
0.5613929033,
0.1310645491,
-0.6776223779,
-0.3351927996,
-0.2045126557,
0.2383997589,
-0.0331807099,
-0.2830888629,
-0.2716734111,
0.332384795,
0.2973549366,
-0.4268073738,
0.1728920043,
-0.1819068044,
-0.1410464644,
1.017421484,
0.4625088871,
0.0451476537,
0.1583215445,
0.2670208812,
-0.1915436238,
-0.6593370438,
0.3644785285,
0.0897436813,
0.0496915914,
0.1551486552,
0.4890205264,
-0.212594226,
0.5643892884,
-0.5366203189,
0.2200443745,
0.0064267223,
-0.3062455952,
-0.3434846401,
-0.1403493285,
0.6387602687,
-0.0891922414,
0.8137302995,
0.0530384183,
-0.095592767,
0.4494246244,
-0.2393142879,
-0.6262395978,
-0.3680797219,
-0.1120320633,
-0.2161158472,
-0.1868712157,
-0.1891702712,
-0.5438488722,
-0.4309262037,
-0.8782423139,
-0.1710473001,
-0.2796952426,
-0.1169101521,
0.7196056843,
0.1177883893,
-0.0156006152,
0.404797107,
-0.6682370305,
0.3800279498,
1.1786113977,
0.3213784397,
0.1974209696,
-0.2299198508,
-0.3087360263,
-0.4378401935,
-0.6711895466,
0.7340106368,
-0.6812852025,
-0.1210577562,
0.301969409,
-0.5909919739,
0.0924443752,
-0.7443253994,
0.8433036208,
-0.6207988262,
0.2543325126,
-0.1680363566,
-0.5915032029,
-0.4577851593,
0.2231075764,
-0.4623490274,
0.6613606215,
0.0167109538,
0.0403239504,
0.2980284989,
-0.6608250737,
-0.622153759,
0.0827222317,
-0.46755898,
-0.6225649118,
0.3579856753,
0.5058549047,
0.533593297,
-0.7230109572,
0.6263555884,
-0.5225225091,
-0.242612794,
0.721224308,
-0.6749124527,
1.0094425678,
0.485977143,
-0.2808970213,
-0.299580127,
-0.5612165928,
0.2869311869,
0.2125431299,
0.1418046057,
-0.1782035828,
0.0066760257,
-0.3811102211,
0.131862849,
0.1654302031,
-0.2069943696,
0.3009462059,
-0.4435611665,
0.9047002196,
0.5960235596,
-0.1511468887,
0.3341504037,
0.1053083986,
0.3209039271,
-0.0431865826,
-0.0533108115,
-0.0590360537,
-0.6159435511,
-0.5843551755,
0.1481614709,
0.5739571452,
0.6759368777,
-0.3583003581,
0.3220172524,
-0.1294122636,
-0.2379714996,
-0.4647265673,
0.328181088,
0.1858422756,
0.3151015937,
0.2429125905,
0.3977755606,
-0.5509957075,
-0.7556632161,
-0.5728034377,
0.2660152018,
-0.0284694303,
0.6670449972,
0.4289683998,
-0.069220677,
0.84352386,
-0.7761718631,
-0.3004101515,
-0.1203699932,
0.213101238,
0.4160273969,
0.3210406005,
0.5762258172,
-0.8221195936,
-0.2303388566,
0.0289820991,
-1.1186686754,
0.1783041209,
-0.0413039513,
0.0437648147,
-0.14399831,
0.4583969116,
-0.6738703251,
0.6558380127,
0.0249192603,
-0.1836759001,
0.2530677915,
-0.0327079147,
-0.1607139409,
-0.5102071166,
-0.2102970183,
0.18086043,
0.0787336156,
-0.333012253,
-0.0383163914,
-0.0613590404,
-0.3762285113,
-0.0718942434,
0.5992826819,
-0.2135988474,
-0.051344458,
-0.0678408071,
-0.0587684959,
0.0673908889,
0.2286393493,
-0.0457058437,
0.6053166986,
0.9898912907,
-0.5794898868,
0.8414732218,
0.021977881,
-0.4289764464,
0.3210631609,
-0.6285828948,
0.0414467044,
-0.1069520563,
0.0248001423,
-0.8055008054,
-0.0063638738,
0.1639134288,
-0.6801446676,
-0.0385196358,
0.0422657207,
-0.3447695374,
-0.5585042238,
0.1401676536,
0.7838128805,
0.5562531352,
-0.2686158717,
0.6700919867,
0.0923738033,
-0.1569138169,
-0.5981997252,
-0.9117275476,
0.095571436,
-0.0662990659,
-0.5151162744,
0.0209619682,
0.0707231835,
-0.8779088259,
0.0824755952,
-0.0736436918,
-0.4809469581,
0.2386656851,
0.1327446252,
0.1421433091,
-0.5339451432,
0.2756728828,
0.0138146877,
-0.4877388477,
0.5899083614,
-0.5303153992,
0.5172370672,
-0.4156520069,
-0.6564327478,
-0.5336977839,
0.4389225543,
0.3305896819,
-0.6632338166,
0.226943627,
0.3120424449,
-0.8154247999,
-0.254584223,
-0.3685618043,
-0.2018948197,
-0.3982468545,
0.1365226507,
-0.4661380351,
-0.7805023193,
0.3097837567,
-0.3633357882,
-0.0380914845,
0.7685272098,
0.511708498,
-0.1969070435,
1.2306842804,
0.0578990951,
-0.1394586116,
0.0339469165,
-0.7663988471,
0.5253099203,
-0.273697108,
-0.2213442624,
-0.6563962102,
-0.4133877158,
-0.1881922036,
-0.3172942698,
-0.0266299248,
0.1900592744,
-0.4156325758,
0.0654358938,
-0.5094488263,
0.6582207084,
0.6245068312,
-0.1523290426,
0.1401322484,
0.0177801158,
-0.2440430373,
-0.2568918765,
-0.3208251894,
-0.2051727772,
1.0771358013,
0.2417143881,
0.7434487343,
-0.041363854,
0.5486496091,
0.302869767,
0.114039652,
-0.7124840617,
0.3996905982,
-0.3983020484,
-0.5635835528,
-0.3996660113,
-0.6715047359,
-0.9649726152,
-0.0080561554,
-0.0048599914,
-0.3639927208,
0.202629596,
-0.1690807194,
-0.5916032791,
0.3121197522,
-0.6086787581,
0.7115454674,
-0.6133593917,
-0.1884097159,
-0.4601914287,
-0.2988677025,
0.3358809948,
0.160055548,
0.291993767,
-0.2826811969,
0.1427750438,
0.3187850416,
-0.2369103283,
0.6855188012,
-0.0424898192,
-0.0499007218,
0.5230070949,
0.2331294566,
0.0909756944,
0.6543163657,
-0.168218255,
0.3242640495,
-0.1963300854,
-0.3660281003,
-0.7773969769,
0.7055621743,
-0.7084415555,
-0.4556397796,
-0.5538829565,
-0.5586131811,
-0.3675465882,
-0.0152734779,
-0.1692745835,
0.4010648131,
0.1414299905,
0.3159549832,
0.8138487339,
0.1234528124,
0.6281642318,
-0.2646379173,
-0.1377202421,
-0.7024602294,
1.1529273987,
0.105552353,
-0.3139674664,
0.4815467894,
0.2947177887,
-0.5816828012,
-0.4628919065,
-0.3737425208,
0.119143784,
-0.6132669449,
-0.3328702152,
-0.1920224577,
-0.5534783602,
-0.5578936338,
-0.2930117548,
-0.2606433332,
-0.5446009636,
-0.2921191454,
0.1386770457,
0.1895898432,
0.545324266,
0.0150314486,
-0.3443152905,
-0.5224121809,
0.5380247831,
0.8446738124,
0.4962741435,
0.1472166032,
0.087589018,
0.2056839764,
0.4014974833,
-0.1836440861,
-0.2453245521,
0.1789366156,
0.0090879714,
0.6817777157,
0.4639782906,
-0.1021502614,
0.5147791505,
-0.2363640666,
0.5471217036,
0.3072425425,
-0.9408480525,
0.5116422772,
0.0473996997,
0.1911593974,
0.3541229367,
0.3839689791,
-0.2316585481,
0.4958085716,
-0.4336242676,
-0.2371887267,
0.0316020474,
0.2015400827,
0.1886704117,
0.2710212171,
0.4361498654,
0.0697420016,
0.2459127158,
-0.2060268819,
-0.1731895804,
-0.1331154704,
-0.352316618,
-0.1347555965,
0.2078186721,
-0.2099695057,
-0.8162354231,
0.236827597,
-0.2796032131,
0.0669708177,
-0.1752666384,
-0.1504224837,
0.0740942657,
0.1248630509,
0.7236285806,
1.0616666079,
0.1301013082,
0.0539615117,
0.2386296988,
-0.2946281135,
0.0545855425,
0.5184146762,
-0.0851559564,
-0.1293559968,
0.4007634819,
0.4854906797,
0.1270006746,
-0.9059601426,
0.4039200544,
-0.2135908753,
-0.7378245592,
-0.6398900151,
-0.0311826337,
0.1417924613,
0.3987442851,
0.4710125327,
0.3242311776,
0.1789218485,
-0.4484024942,
0.0368166305,
0.5563592911,
-0.3046177328,
-0.0376072153,
0.7228841186,
-0.0786537379,
-0.3549204767,
1.0528182983,
0.0391449183,
-0.5619078875,
0.7762126327,
0.1641249806,
0.8585584164,
0.0971650258,
-0.0303885248,
0.0939984545,
-0.0752312243,
0.3649273217,
0.4753356874,
-0.3240831196,
-0.6793829203,
-0.6131934524,
-0.5614171624,
-0.4842082262,
0.0715332627,
-0.316139251,
0.0056842561,
-0.6801536083,
-0.1137983948,
0.3977987468,
0.2902530134,
-1.0801542997,
0.4802504778,
0.4900324941,
0.7416815162,
-0.5648043156,
0.4123315215,
0.8149379492,
-0.3290745616,
-0.4289766848,
-0.5442169905,
-0.1262320727,
-1.0860080719,
0.8703830242,
0.0325646475,
-0.0129376501,
-0.2677433789,
-0.7368974686,
-0.6007695794,
0.5973778963,
0.408159554,
-0.3471284211,
-0.0430117995,
0.6190385818,
0.481120348,
-0.3728870451,
0.0825762525,
0.4580053985,
0.3535822034,
0.246682629,
-0.4201614261,
-0.4168664217,
-0.2690625191,
-0.1451045573,
0.2697054148,
-0.4822842777,
1.0328270197,
-0.229308188,
0.1926624924,
0.1039427221,
0.9665726423,
0.4865420163,
0.8458762169,
0.235343948,
0.9849978685,
0.7819854617,
-0.5108478665,
0.639616251,
0.0770325735,
0.2498009354,
0.7622250319,
-0.4173060656,
0.6076327562,
-0.0583431572,
-0.5284000635,
0.5615563989,
0.6220428944,
-0.2483833134,
0.1762921065,
0.632611692,
-0.3130356967,
-0.8906168342,
-0.0206520129,
-0.770098269,
0.3921806812,
0.7589092851,
-0.2443158478,
-0.2914927602,
0.1302369237,
-0.1104493067,
0.3335026503,
-0.567990303,
0.6206523776,
0.4132830203,
-0.6612641811,
0.1781715006,
-0.2345701009,
0.222865805,
-0.2601713538,
-0.4439416528,
-0.2508981824,
0.6417520046,
-0.1185368225,
-1.1259804964,
0.2909573019,
-0.2102721781,
-0.0675366297,
-0.36828053,
0.6677603722,
0.070119299,
-0.8687611818,
-0.1416781545,
0.7357978225,
-0.0446443595,
-0.2731259763,
-0.8754335046,
-0.1500032246,
-0.2109280229,
0.1954207569,
0.1699613631,
0.8095108867,
-0.1175282896,
0.9377089739,
1.1136695147,
-0.1363708824,
0.1309023947,
0.4607437253,
0.9094793797,
-1.072455883,
-0.2261754423,
-0.8643526435,
0.1998738647,
-0.0945759863,
-0.6832532883,
0.5844638348,
0.7111991644,
0.944165349,
-0.0283815488,
0.7661791444,
0.4267208576,
0.418769151,
-0.3894322813,
0.3960708678,
-0.2523724139,
0.1481719613,
-0.0458662286,
-0.7259802222,
-0.8748179078,
0.5869989991,
-0.492056191,
0.0726855844,
0.4545899332,
0.0008249389,
-0.0400333926,
0.4335315228,
0.177302897,
-0.3335715532,
0.2493290305,
0.8914977312,
1.1089318991,
-0.40738976,
0.4822589457,
-0.5831642151,
0.1108888015,
-0.0843291357,
-0.6226226687,
-0.9528437257,
-0.3289473057,
-0.3620315492,
-0.2096497715,
-0.1682603359,
0.6043720245,
0.5855440497,
-1.0697016716,
-0.2373515517,
-0.4393433034,
0.4293265343,
-0.5694875717,
-0.2050490677,
0.4258987308,
-0.3881318271,
-0.6422165036,
0.2315573394,
0.342651546,
-0.0808588639,
-0.435492754,
-0.1657298654,
0.0080910875,
-0.0599894002,
0.5914901495,
0.5378386974,
-0.7697151899,
0.2230097502,
0.4989357889,
-0.0123836277,
0.0080786329,
1.0803265572,
-1.065004468,
0.1559446901,
0.6576567888,
1.3058749437,
0.4451032281,
-0.3382707238,
0.3827818632,
-0.082533136,
0.0223319959,
0.8397442102,
0.4759479463,
-0.0018942025,
-0.2319259644,
0.6131817698,
0.4209825695,
-0.4351362586,
-0.8374279737,
0.1669654697,
-0.6830350161,
-0.3699453175,
0.4122200906,
0.136890173,
-0.0612068847,
-0.0266034231,
0.0159430392,
-0.1066041961,
-0.1209529266,
0.5406911373,
0.825265646,
-0.446177125,
-0.4572187662,
-0.5992421508,
0.2983418703,
0.6391618848,
-0.9405319095,
-0.0927846059,
0.3748316169,
-0.352006346,
0.2739575207,
-0.2316143066,
0.0282585118,
0.4926478863,
-0.0449125357,
-0.3900318146,
-0.1244718134,
-0.3461043537,
-0.352052629,
0.4940035641,
-0.1776585728,
-0.0063757286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10534v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10534v3 | DISCO: Distilling Counterfactuals with Large Language Models | 2022-12-20T18:46:08 | 2023-06-05T19:16:25 | Zeming Chen, Qiyue Gao, Antoine Bosselut, Ashish Sabharwal, Kyle Richardson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Models trained with counterfactually augmented data learn representations of
the causal structure of tasks, enabling robust generalization. However,
high-quality counterfactual data is scarce for most tasks and not easily
generated at scale. When crowdsourced, such data is typically limited in scale
and diversity; when generated using supervised methods, it is computationally
expensive to extend to new counterfactual dimensions. In this work, we
introduce DISCO (DIStilled COunterfactual Data), a new method for automatically
generating high quality counterfactual data at scale. DISCO engineers prompts
to generate phrasal perturbations with a large general language model. Then, a
task-specific teacher model filters these generations to distill high-quality
counterfactual data. While task-agnostic, we apply our pipeline to the task of
natural language inference (NLI) and find that on challenging evaluations such
as the NLI stress test, comparatively smaller student models trained with DISCO
generated counterfactuals are more robust (6% absolute) and generalize better
across distributions (2%) compared to models trained without data augmentation.
Furthermore, DISCO augmented models are 10% more consistent between
counterfactual pairs on three evaluation sets, demonstrating that DISCO
augmentation enables models to more reliably learn causal representations. Our
repository is available at: https://github.com/eric11eca/disco | [
-0.5889040828,
-0.9613992572,
0.3385568857,
0.0630045161,
-0.2367247492,
0.0777502209,
-0.0225752741,
-0.2397140115,
0.2946324348,
0.5481831431,
-0.8402821422,
-0.2636873424,
-0.5072055459,
0.0630702823,
-0.7172927856,
1.0782538652,
0.3319097459,
-0.0913250819,
-0.400441587,
0.0755112022,
-0.4453841448,
-0.5803809762,
-0.5781300664,
-0.486795187,
0.434659332,
0.2995823026,
0.6263685226,
0.2645790577,
0.0772893727,
0.4187970757,
0.1795285344,
0.4843223691,
-0.8103202581,
0.0943109691,
-0.5278055072,
-0.2952382863,
-0.106198363,
0.2787796557,
0.1721938998,
0.8015402555,
-0.1287242919,
0.0196096841,
0.0203608163,
0.6794741154,
-0.6494848132,
0.0688077435,
-0.7219552994,
-0.2439113557,
0.2499392033,
0.209646076,
-0.5112872124,
-0.4339804947,
0.2225692421,
-0.7293138504,
0.5122134089,
-0.2100044638,
0.8211996555,
0.5304613113,
-0.5843955874,
-0.18703866,
-0.8511506915,
0.8378662467,
-0.5986260772,
0.4597879648,
0.4030087292,
-0.0028118431,
-0.2819361985,
-0.7287698984,
-0.6969757676,
-0.3099768758,
-0.0898825526,
0.107674256,
-0.5363105536,
-0.0137500428,
0.2589598,
0.1353879422,
-0.4744381905,
0.2740947604,
-0.1693600267,
0.0330888331,
0.6691815257,
0.1523885429,
0.1941467375,
-0.1735885739,
-0.149845615,
-0.0338731743,
-0.6690858006,
-0.3417420387,
0.485214144,
0.231877327,
-0.1447773278,
0.41928038,
-0.2685772181,
0.8286852837,
0.3303195238,
0.3089542687,
0.0522325337,
-0.5098848343,
-0.0666926503,
0.0489274971,
0.8750483394,
0.3639550507,
0.3782594502,
-0.1520059258,
0.0916707069,
0.4655263424,
0.3525468111,
-0.8379986286,
-0.8171769977,
0.2333855331,
0.120168224,
-0.327235043,
-0.261541605,
-0.9178820848,
-0.6450420618,
-0.6939228177,
0.2665788233,
-0.2933816314,
-0.322617501,
0.0872363672,
-0.0691821277,
-0.5550017953,
0.3014108837,
-0.5600867271,
0.1564809829,
0.3871952593,
0.6005847454,
0.2593398392,
-0.0474715829,
-0.7609817386,
-0.0594775118,
-0.6560108066,
0.5791112185,
-0.5281561613,
-0.4468291402,
-0.0537691191,
-0.1220096797,
0.0784467459,
-0.544911623,
0.065828599,
-0.3191663623,
0.2166281492,
-0.2941556871,
-0.5405249,
0.0499524325,
0.1049577743,
-0.897906661,
1.0956853628,
0.0459491089,
-0.6991007924,
0.4235572815,
-0.3383513689,
-0.2325881273,
-0.0961834043,
-0.1759692729,
-0.3682793975,
0.1419193745,
0.259386152,
0.2459816635,
-0.4181869626,
0.9054458737,
-0.3013994396,
-0.0386445187,
0.3724040985,
-0.5707058907,
0.8267556429,
0.0352094658,
-0.2405524105,
-0.2405148298,
-0.8981207013,
-0.4930438399,
-0.1413338929,
0.0366015099,
-0.6878704429,
0.1329614967,
-0.2409993708,
0.3898532689,
0.1485963464,
-0.6953053474,
0.025098687,
-0.3169631958,
0.2898893356,
0.584142983,
0.1851561815,
0.2183108181,
-0.0659423172,
0.1652978212,
0.2272075564,
-0.0427880511,
0.0784528777,
-0.2475369573,
-0.7383024693,
-0.5722321272,
0.2586890459,
0.4156918526,
-1.1586786509,
0.5461976528,
-0.1894637197,
-0.7499421835,
-0.5093313456,
0.2553034425,
0.4552827477,
0.8200990558,
0.4446206093,
-0.1065226793,
-0.9816051126,
-0.7829604745,
-0.1023125648,
-0.3730485737,
-0.062098112,
0.1282332242,
0.5692638755,
-0.3191908002,
1.2748091221,
-0.7547734976,
-0.1309366226,
-0.0895378441,
0.8089408278,
0.2877312303,
0.6371380091,
0.5165667534,
-0.8754540682,
-0.1643184721,
-0.2755762339,
-0.7367201447,
-0.493039459,
-0.3443075418,
-0.018623041,
0.3051289618,
0.8390103579,
-0.417483747,
0.1623357236,
0.6667792201,
-0.5284503102,
0.6136760712,
-0.2038978487,
0.1864595562,
-0.9276576638,
0.2119140327,
0.3591123223,
-0.2467443794,
-0.7766694427,
-0.1951061189,
-0.2202133536,
0.1128825992,
-0.4524857402,
0.3176843524,
-0.1087567732,
0.4004119337,
-0.079511188,
0.2601054609,
0.1517372429,
0.3913975656,
0.2457639277,
0.327493906,
0.2981958687,
-0.694246769,
0.5430862904,
0.0283651538,
-0.3737793863,
0.6838017702,
-0.6575818062,
-0.0438632853,
-0.2825769186,
0.3103713691,
-1.402305007,
0.0252174083,
-0.2173116207,
-0.2174988836,
0.0312686153,
-0.3117029369,
-0.46642676,
-0.3380733132,
-0.0699685887,
0.1649973243,
0.4586667418,
-0.6633807421,
0.4836678207,
0.2910374999,
0.1048210487,
-0.4619937241,
-0.7392961383,
0.0204402395,
-0.1324138045,
0.0821988285,
-0.0353491269,
-0.1079106182,
-0.2961649299,
0.0940361768,
-0.250239104,
-0.3895591795,
0.1449203491,
0.3178738356,
0.5270852447,
0.087305516,
0.2153951675,
0.0341125652,
-0.0695854425,
0.2257410735,
-0.1418030411,
0.5431565046,
0.3925856948,
-0.1080274358,
-0.209517628,
0.1551533788,
0.4656889439,
-0.0665022135,
0.7020457387,
0.5012890697,
-0.2905933261,
-0.207141161,
-0.6075100899,
-0.1849092841,
-0.4821919799,
0.5582098961,
-0.3308607638,
-0.737672925,
0.4083082974,
-0.2644865811,
0.3093976676,
0.491594553,
0.3100991249,
0.0286400989,
0.8787270784,
0.355066359,
-0.1873616427,
0.5963479877,
-0.4800575376,
0.1848773658,
-0.3306018114,
-0.1186923236,
-0.641731441,
-0.14658539,
-0.5109360218,
-0.3936618268,
0.1619230211,
0.1402185708,
-0.422096163,
0.4274790883,
-0.3869606555,
0.4871706963,
0.44279778,
0.2120118737,
0.3846167028,
-0.1899249405,
0.0898940042,
-0.2156004757,
-0.5971800685,
-0.1458113939,
0.8026567698,
0.0907983556,
0.8457257152,
0.1016144902,
0.7710375786,
0.2757191658,
0.4895101786,
-0.3953478336,
0.5616589189,
-0.7111338377,
-0.5973904133,
-0.3508661687,
-0.6494772434,
-0.8043805361,
0.2054086775,
-0.4623639584,
-0.5936946273,
0.6068457961,
0.3379153609,
-0.1367254704,
0.1647310257,
-0.775326848,
0.7231841683,
0.3847291768,
-0.390853256,
-0.3534735441,
-0.3494854569,
0.5309374928,
-0.3426140845,
0.3325144947,
0.087607868,
0.1889424026,
0.6780068874,
-0.4120961726,
1.2890603542,
-0.2720063031,
-0.4132882059,
0.459261328,
0.4888968766,
0.5650235415,
0.2798561752,
-0.1358967572,
0.2736701369,
-0.2445900738,
-0.0680282488,
-0.7588979006,
0.9475919008,
-0.6835485697,
-0.5762798786,
-0.0220631473,
-0.7472684383,
-0.230887711,
0.0820930675,
0.1812143624,
0.7297140956,
-0.4428557456,
0.1131540909,
0.7804138064,
-0.1884199381,
0.3793258071,
0.6885764003,
-0.0552926846,
-0.4395275116,
0.965046823,
0.2671698928,
0.3511384428,
0.3792025149,
0.0584062934,
-0.6356860995,
-0.0640874729,
-0.4056554437,
0.0565339588,
-0.440189749,
-0.1669806689,
-0.7395519614,
-0.0369130932,
-0.335226506,
-0.2383034527,
-0.603608489,
-0.5173556805,
-0.4546620846,
-0.188208282,
0.5855818391,
0.5660537481,
-0.3168560565,
0.2876131833,
-0.5035671592,
0.8687518239,
0.5457360744,
0.0948342234,
-0.0830398947,
-0.404061228,
-0.2300251275,
0.2902539074,
-0.0823022351,
-0.6540842056,
0.5018058419,
0.2667346001,
0.2605161071,
0.2507411242,
0.4872494638,
0.9894000292,
-0.6053132415,
0.7622313499,
0.5092028379,
-1.079857707,
0.5059683919,
-0.1066230237,
0.2971648872,
0.5271418691,
0.5928880572,
-0.3953338265,
-0.8517882228,
-0.7309424281,
-0.9487210512,
0.5592119098,
-0.1092847586,
0.0776679218,
-0.2881211042,
0.1410390288,
0.1424047202,
0.1757794619,
-0.5320304632,
-0.2813555896,
-0.5062668324,
-0.3933767676,
-0.5504425168,
-0.1496362239,
-0.024627639,
-0.2350499332,
0.5483334661,
0.0810846463,
-0.3699491024,
0.4030597806,
-0.2551464736,
-0.1330997646,
0.102430813,
0.1550271213,
0.5193381906,
-0.1371221542,
0.4857731462,
0.2670205534,
-0.4457809329,
0.276026696,
0.1334226876,
0.051429484,
0.336908102,
0.405292213,
0.5444968939,
0.2266461104,
-0.7371775508,
0.1406082362,
0.0824785009,
-0.3196745217,
-0.0648764744,
0.0927104056,
0.1600699872,
0.173548311,
0.2339847088,
-0.1961328089,
0.2065859586,
-0.513881743,
0.482743293,
0.209989354,
-0.3508428633,
-0.269102186,
0.6623451114,
0.3636696339,
0.1463751644,
0.8318111897,
-0.0515899733,
-0.1841286123,
0.5641862154,
0.5293860435,
0.7030400038,
-0.4957183301,
0.5115329623,
0.5886553526,
0.3045964241,
-0.1238892749,
0.190811187,
0.218605876,
-0.6180911064,
-0.6933122277,
-0.3640866876,
-0.3345676959,
0.311622113,
-0.5165941715,
0.1104781553,
-0.2911872268,
-0.0445768051,
0.130243808,
0.0098544126,
-0.603450954,
0.5660103559,
-0.1601030827,
0.5874106884,
-1.4495972395,
0.7481364012,
0.511161983,
-0.3157863915,
-0.4106094539,
-0.3987009525,
-0.0409286357,
-0.2637457848,
0.9195616245,
-0.1264080107,
-0.0703936145,
0.0843213499,
-0.54160285,
-0.5873183608,
0.5355014205,
0.7295446992,
-1.0271068811,
0.1030911207,
0.3118180335,
0.7008678913,
-0.1596959233,
0.2713411152,
0.4841251373,
0.2055155933,
0.0684091821,
-0.7027951479,
0.1990842372,
-0.0570178293,
-0.0915253609,
0.3402363062,
-0.1779667735,
0.8889442086,
-0.0176299792,
-0.0451882668,
-0.266282171,
0.6264401674,
0.2716339827,
0.2396446168,
0.8558220267,
0.7962525487,
0.6865690947,
-0.1205108464,
0.7103005648,
-0.104577519,
0.377336055,
1.3549007177,
-0.2194443792,
0.449727416,
0.4446022213,
-0.0268562138,
0.6916728616,
0.462122947,
-0.0488870665,
0.5908684134,
0.3366650045,
-0.2563592494,
-0.5851570368,
-0.4818508923,
0.0945759565,
0.2399536818,
0.3441065848,
-0.0968358964,
-0.431961149,
-0.0347213075,
-0.0163626671,
0.3362783492,
-0.2470253855,
0.7435573339,
0.0804926828,
-0.5701521039,
0.7236384749,
-0.4773751199,
0.5074765086,
-0.4011284709,
-0.416272372,
-0.2923395336,
0.0813408121,
-0.2399869114,
-0.5345001817,
0.3066560924,
0.2171449363,
-0.2251015157,
0.0038925607,
0.3228759766,
-0.7124276161,
-0.4812108576,
0.1188991144,
0.4052323699,
0.0806279331,
0.0870489925,
-0.3576214015,
-0.1099158302,
0.0289973728,
-0.1986911297,
0.0599013828,
0.6949829459,
-0.2198184133,
0.6452541351,
0.6417998672,
0.0458523184,
-0.1204826385,
0.3440795243,
1.0237990618,
-0.4890315235,
-0.4711070955,
-1.0740001202,
0.6116501093,
-0.1238837093,
-0.2313214391,
0.6422123909,
0.5040060878,
0.8201942444,
-0.1300076395,
0.5740162134,
-0.1028502658,
0.3814804256,
-0.2935416102,
0.4798261225,
-0.3792260587,
0.0827338994,
-0.4727864265,
-0.5872123837,
-0.1192018315,
0.3134379685,
-0.3281742036,
-0.262229979,
0.4445503354,
0.8520609736,
-0.1180891842,
-0.130242914,
0.3061126173,
0.4362280369,
0.5032868385,
0.5281908512,
0.6636394858,
-0.2995926738,
0.4083580673,
-0.2357756793,
-0.1206716374,
-0.048889339,
-0.866443038,
-1.0584696531,
-0.7531118989,
-0.8682461977,
-0.1844905168,
0.0622644238,
0.8063625693,
0.5477478504,
-0.7700248957,
-0.1038659662,
-0.4522196054,
0.3766375184,
-0.2650513947,
-0.2599008381,
0.2805247307,
-0.3453091979,
-1.0190677643,
0.3641096652,
-0.2363419235,
-0.1643420011,
-0.2103857398,
0.1414955258,
-0.4687132239,
0.2562169135,
0.5897242427,
0.0351975374,
-0.4619320631,
-0.2820208669,
-0.469892174,
-0.0031207942,
-0.4367540181,
0.615162611,
-1.0912035704,
0.5740861297,
0.4882841706,
0.407312572,
0.3511073887,
-0.0372504555,
0.624966681,
-1.0568583012,
0.136779964,
-0.0460342541,
0.2204520106,
0.0918255374,
-0.3361806273,
0.5428262353,
0.2761795223,
-0.1843756884,
-1.0819613934,
0.3267501891,
-0.7070804238,
-0.6038768291,
0.9681027532,
-0.269087404,
0.1653287262,
-0.4317781627,
-0.0754869133,
0.6124573946,
-0.3262888193,
0.9388641119,
0.5396956801,
0.1329502761,
-0.049162142,
-0.3248718679,
0.39649719,
0.3004721105,
-0.6181235909,
0.3937687874,
0.8463295102,
0.1689118296,
0.2638510466,
0.2128130049,
0.0460808761,
0.1715623885,
0.1462524384,
0.2260745615,
-0.2636664212,
-0.3150408566,
-0.2015078068,
0.0608428307,
-0.2905196249,
-0.1976834536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.11672v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.11672v1 | Trustworthy Social Bias Measurement | 2022-12-20T18:45:12 | 2022-12-20T18:45:12 | Rishi Bommasani, Percy Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL | How do we design measures of social bias that we trust? While prior work has
introduced several measures, no measure has gained widespread trust: instead,
mounting evidence argues we should distrust these measures. In this work, we
design bias measures that warrant trust based on the cross-disciplinary theory
of measurement modeling. To combat the frequently fuzzy treatment of social
bias in NLP, we explicitly define social bias, grounded in principles drawn
from social science research. We operationalize our definition by proposing a
general bias measurement framework DivDist, which we use to instantiate 5
concrete bias measures. To validate our measures, we propose a rigorous testing
protocol with 8 testing criteria (e.g. predictive validity: do measures predict
biases in US employment?). Through our testing, we demonstrate considerable
evidence to trust our measures, showing they overcome conceptual, technical,
and empirical deficiencies present in prior measures. | [
-0.5349103212,
-0.6125754118,
0.8488009572,
0.4604257345,
-0.1231931597,
0.2090729624,
0.1626441181,
-0.5163985491,
0.5416609645,
0.2438995242,
-0.4179917872,
-0.1650892049,
-0.9551555514,
-0.1728945822,
-0.5340795517,
1.0096919537,
-0.1275139302,
0.450037539,
-0.2757319808,
-0.3352903724,
0.0196235646,
-0.3208908439,
-0.4298424721,
-0.6906272173,
0.4162156582,
0.2319531888,
0.9701929092,
0.1791279018,
0.2978846431,
0.1033693105,
-0.184354201,
-0.0264856815,
-0.4933633208,
-0.3022476733,
-0.6612597704,
-0.3278402686,
-0.4970071614,
0.398019433,
0.3967536092,
0.8113785386,
-0.059068732,
0.6037137508,
0.2069392949,
0.630782187,
-0.4561727047,
-0.1157328635,
-0.831392169,
0.0448108651,
-0.0262822546,
0.151407674,
-0.2110447586,
-0.7777428031,
0.1786995679,
-0.3478087485,
0.5035851002,
0.2475712895,
0.6375665665,
0.0508266874,
-0.729586482,
0.0084171006,
-0.6589648724,
0.8942192793,
-0.493424207,
0.4690188468,
0.7985188961,
0.1872874349,
0.1374811381,
-0.7090213895,
-0.4952769876,
-0.3969798088,
0.0722466931,
-0.0162018817,
0.3202727735,
-0.2498198301,
0.3727167845,
0.3200890124,
-0.3243124485,
-0.3571353257,
-0.127240032,
-0.3108050525,
0.8509838581,
0.128092438,
0.1245537996,
0.0812135637,
-0.6060416102,
0.0018866101,
-0.7294288278,
-0.1636889577,
0.7419818044,
-0.3683728278,
-0.1035128683,
0.407663703,
-0.3138473034,
0.1772603244,
0.2905715406,
0.3410339355,
0.0705020353,
-0.6794851422,
-0.0763829201,
0.1360708326,
0.7273851037,
0.6003866792,
0.4369524717,
-0.2537995279,
-0.0805910602,
0.7732076645,
0.4194621742,
-0.2363613993,
-0.0249114055,
0.1402056068,
-0.4215850532,
-0.6734058857,
0.0954915583,
-0.726760447,
-0.7216169238,
-0.1902476549,
0.3554802835,
-0.3032229245,
-0.600941956,
0.0966192335,
-0.4353995621,
0.1708312482,
0.1335215122,
-0.8995624185,
0.4624851644,
0.7462415695,
0.5686228871,
-0.3420678377,
-0.4197487235,
-0.1983161718,
-0.0007334104,
-0.5430682302,
0.3903538287,
-0.5204052329,
-0.3673704863,
0.3070301414,
-0.0846473128,
0.341675669,
-0.0392311774,
0.5816805959,
-0.3078722954,
0.1022011787,
-0.8297716379,
-0.5097785592,
0.0167356338,
0.4580089152,
-0.510051012,
1.0520160198,
0.2540091872,
-1.1602066755,
1.0344065428,
-0.5141193271,
-0.270523876,
-0.4413446188,
-0.0357065722,
-0.3036007285,
0.1632220894,
0.0594977252,
0.4350273311,
-0.2822260261,
0.5043634176,
-1.0121686459,
-0.4918401539,
0.3995350301,
-0.4457374811,
1.076015234,
0.0772793144,
-0.5958686471,
-0.1625423878,
-0.6392305493,
-0.0143298963,
-0.0749042779,
0.2241873443,
-0.687679708,
0.0226949155,
0.0903040916,
0.1007309258,
0.1943168491,
-0.7476254702,
-0.3375383615,
-0.0656541362,
0.4035483897,
1.1208209991,
-0.055515863,
0.7408064008,
-0.4568346739,
0.2741368115,
-0.1798149645,
0.3896843791,
0.7179000378,
-0.2165081352,
-0.5249730945,
0.18470864,
0.2848790884,
0.166863516,
-0.5574837923,
0.4815547764,
-0.0953954756,
-0.6814903021,
-0.0764434785,
0.0335089043,
0.2012408078,
0.2925799489,
0.2940003276,
-0.6862354875,
-0.2205136716,
-0.7274862528,
-0.7883650661,
-0.1687312871,
-0.2092297077,
0.0134332823,
0.6717489362,
-0.3534497619,
0.9173980951,
-0.2951593697,
-0.1849570572,
0.1698973775,
0.1897631139,
-0.1208938062,
0.3217339516,
0.5938796997,
-0.5596638918,
-0.4355352819,
-0.4724192619,
-0.5303210616,
-0.1349497736,
0.0458902791,
-0.298032701,
-0.129052341,
0.3360533118,
-0.4803821146,
0.4222964346,
0.4283750355,
-0.7417499423,
0.6805397868,
0.2802619636,
0.1314499378,
-1.0916985273,
-0.14395383,
0.3847683966,
-0.3300839365,
-0.3156048656,
-0.1949698329,
0.0631073266,
0.4243520498,
-0.5254568458,
0.543592155,
-0.3691798747,
-0.1738454998,
0.1881518066,
0.1120687574,
0.3080918193,
0.0986551046,
-0.1100135669,
0.1950511932,
0.6269164681,
-0.4697955549,
0.196596995,
0.1518619955,
-0.2727307379,
1.4185664654,
-1.0064725876,
0.1988596767,
-0.0152573157,
0.5192431211,
-1.0819693804,
-0.1061006337,
0.3012720346,
-0.8243664503,
0.0987234414,
0.1901969463,
-0.2777418494,
-0.1654999107,
-0.5494349003,
0.108812131,
0.331587255,
-0.5450268984,
0.486854881,
0.4990458488,
0.060696695,
-0.5988494754,
-0.7532792687,
-0.2894033492,
-0.3548365533,
-0.7444112301,
0.3920160532,
0.1201139912,
-0.5897328258,
-0.0405993722,
-0.4728337228,
-0.343534112,
0.0387998782,
0.2498315871,
0.1490150988,
0.0246514585,
-0.2493540198,
0.1994878948,
0.1540792137,
0.6185466647,
0.1131453142,
0.3962145746,
0.2664655447,
-0.6977412701,
-0.1451043636,
0.2321515977,
0.7124547958,
-0.0161983073,
0.3347586095,
1.0031321049,
-0.4706919789,
-0.2036543489,
-0.956017375,
-0.473154515,
-0.4279295206,
0.2076044828,
0.2587921023,
-0.7743626237,
0.5420107245,
-0.1289569288,
0.0728709027,
0.1884035915,
0.3485664129,
0.2569763362,
1.2250634432,
0.6187325716,
-0.4417448342,
0.1955852062,
0.1087314636,
0.2541675568,
-0.698158443,
0.0029228444,
-0.6865304112,
-0.1055061594,
-0.355274111,
-0.2372153848,
0.0216957405,
-0.1718381941,
-0.3564760387,
0.001382089,
-0.5854752064,
0.2822328806,
0.6771399379,
0.1188146546,
0.012526229,
-0.0756151378,
-0.226117298,
-0.096668072,
-0.0831340104,
-0.5444802642,
1.0239169598,
0.5936357975,
0.9741657972,
-0.3272242546,
0.9043233395,
0.5607471466,
0.3041667044,
-0.2135308832,
0.3126177788,
0.4848505259,
-1.0334613323,
-0.4709839523,
-0.0829071477,
-0.338809222,
0.2605977058,
-0.285585314,
-0.6747176647,
0.3947345614,
0.1890135407,
0.046541743,
0.1502657235,
-0.6128875613,
0.5965505838,
-0.2549811006,
-0.7012425065,
-0.2580078542,
-0.6115738153,
0.4541032314,
0.1129230335,
0.1475411654,
-0.2444230765,
0.3252278268,
0.9499184489,
-0.2853522301,
0.9342818856,
-0.370521009,
0.1870152503,
0.1134760007,
0.2032467276,
0.4664693773,
0.4355664253,
-0.0136248469,
0.514903605,
0.4799380302,
-0.5041487813,
-0.4059158564,
0.552321434,
-0.5256910324,
-0.169652015,
-0.8017201424,
-0.3043062985,
-0.5862699747,
0.2641363442,
0.1369887143,
-0.1171899959,
-0.7841439843,
0.3086520135,
0.696357429,
0.1192643791,
-0.0959797502,
0.4162678421,
-0.0054406966,
-0.1202481538,
0.5116613507,
0.1377317905,
0.4083228409,
-0.1838226318,
0.3147340715,
-0.4427137971,
-0.1708586216,
-0.0567967445,
-0.1663955152,
-0.3707285821,
0.0819939673,
-0.358951807,
0.0156081738,
-0.8203750253,
-0.3972967565,
-0.4236773252,
-0.2800066173,
0.0742187798,
-0.4961920381,
0.2386780232,
0.7243035436,
-0.3279364109,
0.1037666649,
-0.1743570268,
0.5935183764,
0.2555562556,
0.5545701385,
0.0273578726,
-0.3546041846,
-0.0480592996,
0.4068904519,
-0.4603663385,
-0.8981827497,
0.2388053983,
-0.375036478,
0.618127048,
0.475971818,
0.2421129942,
0.2613569498,
-0.4161827266,
0.9651563168,
0.3936069608,
-1.1552455425,
0.3380886316,
-0.4162028432,
-0.3483404219,
0.5043801069,
0.7994279265,
-0.2756115198,
-0.6391673684,
-1.0170938969,
-0.7687707543,
0.2193812877,
0.0182243641,
0.2541625798,
-0.1096072942,
0.107482262,
0.1254477799,
0.1536670178,
-0.6907958388,
-0.3051223159,
-0.438590914,
-0.0756174996,
-0.1556414068,
-0.6243330836,
-0.4536754489,
-0.1671196073,
0.459486872,
0.0232199617,
0.0132108331,
0.4130727053,
0.0220436715,
-0.1473671049,
0.2301190495,
0.3345722556,
1.202641964,
-0.2179398686,
0.2502901852,
0.2548671961,
-0.6260331273,
0.2024834454,
-0.0229279064,
-0.2837670147,
0.2540304661,
-0.086259678,
0.1688822955,
-0.0572741292,
0.1156670898,
0.6459998488,
-0.0864557698,
-0.4887042046,
-0.9105732441,
-0.0983695611,
0.271836102,
0.1247255281,
0.255705297,
-0.0054919985,
0.3400882185,
-0.395786643,
0.5166781545,
0.7011958361,
-0.9030074477,
-0.381588012,
1.0045495033,
0.0389774144,
-0.0438325815,
0.0048090802,
0.0267672483,
-0.4044057131,
0.503937006,
0.416393429,
0.5637953877,
-0.3348520696,
0.6727381945,
0.0905941203,
0.6421416402,
-0.6791536212,
0.2840604782,
0.0341248959,
-1.0418511629,
-0.1464214325,
-0.55954355,
-0.5610171556,
-0.1291128546,
-1.0879935026,
-0.0610464923,
-0.6083194017,
-0.3639406562,
0.0375110395,
0.2116544992,
-0.865848124,
0.4878520668,
-0.1755452007,
0.9466570616,
-1.3784053326,
0.5840432048,
0.5787113309,
-0.3086046278,
-0.5399994254,
-0.0790359825,
0.180577293,
-0.9772537947,
0.1106473207,
-0.0595221631,
-0.1296203434,
-0.5276910067,
-0.9474482536,
-0.6903222799,
0.9679864645,
0.319347173,
-0.2479581088,
0.098628372,
0.2864758968,
0.4024804235,
-0.1915132701,
0.2430237085,
0.6050873399,
0.5309228897,
-0.2609920502,
-0.7169249654,
0.3787146509,
0.009621202,
0.1462097913,
-0.20522663,
-0.5753625631,
0.52171278,
0.1001802608,
0.262961179,
-0.4856526852,
0.5508616567,
0.1440486461,
0.7892297506,
0.6701215506,
0.5292811394,
0.7496256828,
-0.0211144835,
0.9533233643,
-0.2272310406,
0.409230262,
1.139952302,
-0.8943663836,
0.2935157418,
0.9155119061,
-0.2268789113,
0.3902285993,
0.5913379788,
0.0579166561,
0.471082449,
0.399150759,
0.0561167486,
-0.1053845361,
-0.500598073,
-0.3876193464,
0.2398668081,
0.2229096442,
-0.6310606599,
0.1195495278,
-0.6494349241,
0.3074299097,
0.3365053236,
-0.2667707801,
0.333652705,
0.4395856559,
-0.5987625122,
0.1263308674,
-0.2566388547,
0.8821271658,
-0.779211998,
-0.0475021712,
-0.2477142811,
0.1241917312,
-0.3114198446,
-0.6545317769,
0.4724022746,
-0.4464788735,
-0.0244599245,
-0.1909967363,
0.9249811172,
-0.286798805,
-0.4040947855,
0.4208687842,
0.5707788467,
-0.2615909278,
-0.2404669672,
-0.474073112,
0.2137316614,
-0.0415869877,
-0.1974921972,
0.6549435854,
0.4405994117,
0.1404886842,
0.3972804248,
0.6369112134,
0.48340258,
0.1383041888,
0.0162262619,
0.3815953732,
-0.5206934214,
-0.5679971576,
-0.9854785204,
0.3952985704,
-0.6190901995,
-0.2847084105,
0.9785208106,
0.0785027891,
0.9830568433,
0.1882435828,
0.9939678907,
0.0300038923,
0.6140114665,
-0.1336348504,
0.9383313656,
-0.3710998893,
-0.353690207,
-0.9781244397,
-0.974324584,
-0.0721788779,
0.7981959581,
-0.2196083814,
0.110181503,
0.7071059346,
0.7007949352,
-0.1069495752,
0.1525247991,
0.2238482684,
-0.0280464422,
0.1065044701,
0.1479855329,
0.7429938912,
-0.2574639916,
0.1689999998,
-0.3508727252,
-0.2673619092,
0.0725806579,
-0.9695037007,
-1.0468853712,
-0.4066497684,
-0.3695474565,
-0.8332731128,
0.0663860887,
0.4965973794,
0.6402382255,
-0.6324536204,
-0.0642477274,
0.0617931262,
0.4623230398,
-0.4772964716,
-0.2944630682,
0.1083501726,
-0.0077581443,
-0.2336859852,
-0.2254570425,
-0.0301362202,
-0.3981334269,
-0.7142410874,
-0.1516786665,
-0.0537144318,
0.2733436227,
0.5504421592,
-0.0983074084,
-0.590051353,
-0.896658361,
0.0722773969,
-0.0374367684,
-0.3770533204,
0.7150549293,
-0.1976865828,
0.1374218464,
0.7284406424,
0.3660344779,
0.278411448,
-0.0728735179,
0.8650729656,
-0.433370024,
-0.1146965772,
0.1797327548,
0.6658563614,
0.4870038629,
-0.4499584734,
0.7138710022,
0.0040645348,
-0.7627288103,
-1.1371275187,
0.4150814712,
-0.8202433586,
0.2124720216,
1.059505105,
-0.0043541673,
-0.1950156838,
-0.4097810984,
0.0498678274,
0.0980257988,
-0.3508296013,
1.2647057772,
0.7895149589,
0.2350992113,
0.3373657167,
-0.3090119362,
0.6132851243,
0.3537004292,
-0.1161810458,
-0.0236434378,
0.4416663945,
0.7205878496,
0.4487467706,
1.0634462833,
-0.357825309,
0.3863994777,
0.3211147189,
-0.0811208859,
0.3394197226,
-0.0853660777,
0.1101482436,
-0.0992168263,
0.1327391118,
-0.0601129234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10529v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10529v3 | Evaluating Psychological Safety of Large Language Models | 2022-12-20T18:45:07 | 2024-02-29T13:14:37 | Xingxuan Li, Yutong Li, Lin Qiu, Shafiq Joty, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | In this work, we designed unbiased prompts to systematically evaluate the
psychological safety of large language models (LLMs). First, we tested five
different LLMs by using two personality tests: Short Dark Triad (SD-3) and Big
Five Inventory (BFI). All models scored higher than the human average on SD-3,
suggesting a relatively darker personality pattern. Despite being instruction
fine-tuned with safety metrics to reduce toxicity, InstructGPT, GPT-3.5, and
GPT-4 still showed dark personality patterns; these models scored higher than
self-supervised GPT-3 on the Machiavellianism and narcissism traits on SD-3.
Then, we evaluated the LLMs in the GPT series by using well-being tests to
study the impact of fine-tuning with more training data. We observed a
continuous increase in the well-being scores of GPT models. Following these
observations, we showed that fine-tuning Llama-2-chat-7B with responses from
BFI using direct preference optimization could effectively reduce the
psychological toxicity of the model. Based on the findings, we recommended the
application of systematic and comprehensive psychological metrics to further
evaluate and improve the safety of LLMs. | [
-0.440497607,
-0.7208375931,
0.664988637,
0.5293930173,
-0.2973892689,
-0.0531569012,
-0.5376291275,
-0.5561959147,
-0.2913187742,
0.5454505682,
-0.5081496239,
-0.5284318328,
-0.53077811,
0.201764971,
-0.1260109693,
1.3351690769,
0.0970748663,
0.2086889297,
0.3317444324,
0.2276158631,
-0.6547871232,
-0.6779508591,
-0.900554359,
-0.3624922037,
0.6501033306,
0.1913733631,
0.7539137006,
0.4261512458,
0.7048957348,
0.2307537347,
-0.234477222,
-0.042160172,
-0.7296615839,
0.0158187859,
-0.3786366284,
-0.2978572845,
-0.5090065598,
0.0615441538,
0.2738125026,
0.5481422544,
-0.2758197486,
0.2110860944,
0.3471660316,
0.551446259,
-0.4878604412,
0.1158393025,
-0.3339064121,
-0.0887688547,
-0.02834953,
-0.2565723956,
-0.5478907824,
-0.4664044678,
0.1099325642,
-0.148690179,
-0.1764054298,
0.1494378299,
0.6425518394,
0.2058419883,
-0.6853922009,
-0.2139828056,
-0.7632027864,
0.9066691399,
-0.8277877569,
0.1150830314,
0.5382128358,
0.1909144819,
-0.3174947202,
-0.1595955193,
-0.3066426814,
-0.4114176333,
0.0480360463,
0.0370557457,
-0.0863058344,
0.3077773154,
0.2439596653,
0.1712091267,
-0.405415833,
0.5678234696,
-0.2601555884,
-0.3238029182,
0.9157814384,
0.5240271091,
0.1181889549,
-0.0069945632,
-0.0784528777,
-0.2448619753,
-0.7448621392,
-0.1125165001,
0.5374613404,
0.2386056483,
-0.1100653708,
0.4138588011,
-0.1459789127,
0.2632570863,
0.2096168995,
-0.4354640245,
0.1975374967,
-0.427244246,
-0.0644756407,
-0.0866052434,
1.0636527538,
0.8694764376,
0.7802850008,
-0.1267262548,
-0.1763920188,
0.0061133672,
0.301966548,
-0.9734550118,
-0.0208524764,
0.1756395549,
-0.5456596017,
-0.4136296809,
-0.3140106797,
-0.7833326459,
-0.5502536893,
-0.2252864689,
0.2835786939,
-0.4600251317,
-0.2839639485,
0.1906451583,
0.2627730966,
0.2769343257,
0.2602232695,
-1.1950515509,
0.1325004846,
0.6365249753,
0.7270225883,
-0.3616955876,
-0.1211088076,
-0.1933128238,
0.123525694,
-0.4765917063,
0.5213471055,
-0.3405427933,
-0.6690497398,
0.0084407404,
0.0248342529,
0.2110904455,
-0.4355155826,
0.7233122587,
-0.263902992,
0.2460642606,
-0.5248003602,
-0.3944242001,
-0.2240311205,
0.4071016908,
-0.2151685953,
0.7835642099,
-0.047219675,
-0.7736784816,
0.2490133643,
-0.5949991941,
-0.3042870462,
-0.209492594,
0.0739986002,
-0.2303254753,
0.0384646617,
0.0943878815,
0.6351127028,
-0.4484283924,
0.3784126639,
-0.7283496261,
-0.388828367,
0.3052075207,
-0.524148345,
0.6352019906,
0.1508940905,
-0.3706972599,
0.1917473078,
-0.6068995595,
0.1311118007,
-0.0605353452,
-0.3846447468,
-0.4595868587,
-0.1708148867,
0.0405224748,
0.4726185203,
0.1712484658,
-0.5585196614,
-0.1344242841,
-0.2755451202,
0.203514874,
1.1140583754,
0.2936990559,
0.1441214085,
-0.2375284135,
0.4171089232,
-0.086710453,
0.4146259427,
0.3759189546,
-0.3026750088,
-0.6250526309,
-0.3924271166,
-0.0159274675,
0.6183120608,
-0.3178092539,
0.9157953262,
-0.0253405441,
-0.6401814222,
-0.1585314423,
0.128743574,
0.5615671873,
0.2059717178,
-0.0454406813,
-0.4265563488,
-0.278573215,
-0.9327376485,
-0.1184208915,
-0.121403642,
-0.1206156239,
0.3364301324,
0.702904582,
-0.4446201622,
0.5644083619,
-0.5536385179,
-0.0179442465,
0.0262853038,
0.0119615225,
0.2833559513,
0.50267452,
0.6818424463,
-0.2670449018,
-0.5181865096,
-0.0309832767,
-0.7551078796,
-0.1587134004,
0.2296061665,
-0.2788369954,
0.1755562425,
0.3222746849,
-0.6124756336,
0.1172655895,
0.3601386845,
-0.4663130045,
0.7965258956,
-0.1129639819,
0.1592112333,
-0.877207458,
0.0759488717,
0.0855094045,
0.1301026642,
-0.6608406305,
-0.086231105,
-0.1921221465,
0.164000839,
-0.3123424053,
0.4418532252,
-0.2103656977,
0.1438684613,
-0.2831422091,
-0.0262219664,
-0.33906129,
0.4452625811,
-0.1472691894,
0.6916992664,
0.6594974995,
-0.5874798894,
0.2257849276,
0.1118038595,
-0.341835767,
0.6077172756,
-0.7387751937,
0.4121435583,
-0.0805264488,
0.1374646574,
-0.9383954406,
-0.2631599009,
0.0439956486,
-0.0735133141,
0.1733446866,
0.2954181135,
-0.7168272138,
-0.3652831316,
-0.3939548135,
0.0231607221,
0.5522919297,
-0.2536088824,
0.2298685461,
0.2700119317,
-0.3163140714,
-0.4432831705,
-0.5021152496,
-0.0603742115,
-0.6100429296,
-0.5444946289,
-0.148878485,
-0.4850150645,
-0.4551101923,
-0.3911139667,
-0.1274994016,
0.1971722096,
0.391378969,
0.2861656249,
0.3533249497,
0.0167332571,
0.072308965,
-0.0886327848,
-0.2153202742,
0.4438266754,
0.1430587322,
0.6124524474,
-0.4299905896,
-0.1492240578,
-0.3065975308,
0.2073772997,
0.5007609725,
-0.1765316278,
0.9250560403,
0.6844203472,
-0.2437519282,
0.0722265467,
-0.6582666636,
-0.3959789872,
-0.5303629041,
0.3887675703,
-0.0879459232,
-1.1908760071,
0.5989974737,
-0.039187856,
-0.0483577512,
0.0938457549,
0.9716470838,
-0.0232838932,
1.3476191759,
0.7052645683,
-0.2548893094,
0.4910343289,
0.002535223,
0.3871415854,
-0.753960669,
-0.1266025007,
-0.3404102325,
-0.2173144966,
-0.8246007562,
-0.0318165086,
0.5454711914,
-0.1513934582,
-0.7628954053,
-0.1930658519,
-0.4011904001,
0.6424132586,
0.2695003152,
0.1551186293,
0.2616735697,
-0.0752794594,
-0.1066001952,
-0.120664455,
0.0332505703,
-0.7756817341,
1.2498458624,
0.6639220715,
1.0654708147,
0.2651434541,
0.6314972639,
-0.061097797,
0.4953849018,
-0.5634379983,
0.6234066486,
-0.0826804116,
-0.9574135542,
-0.357886076,
-0.5622096062,
-0.7188789248,
0.2238820344,
-0.1229218245,
-1.1451829672,
0.0265001934,
-0.0646915212,
-0.4996691346,
-0.1390844285,
-0.785715878,
0.7214353085,
-0.5826116204,
-0.3263240159,
-0.2403535247,
-0.6555751562,
0.7270431519,
-0.3961022794,
0.1390222758,
-0.3412373066,
-0.0761836097,
0.7295931578,
-0.04464221,
0.9110617638,
-0.0108462078,
-0.4013773501,
-0.0065466911,
0.2127545327,
0.4524714053,
0.0230401792,
-0.3308342993,
0.0613504425,
0.0560955629,
-0.1862991005,
-0.5945023298,
0.8486857414,
-1.0154426098,
-0.7228827477,
-0.353795737,
-0.5249458551,
-0.5630449653,
0.4546897709,
0.0902193934,
-0.0582135953,
-0.2695838511,
0.3798560798,
0.7382734418,
-0.3818686306,
0.402579397,
0.8192441463,
-0.3150879145,
-0.4299245477,
0.5810633898,
-0.1853075027,
0.571290493,
-0.0505735129,
0.4818571806,
-0.3278039098,
-0.743899405,
0.009844251,
0.4278422296,
-0.6658280492,
-0.0625005811,
-0.3711758852,
-0.0753955469,
-0.3410583138,
-0.0259540323,
-0.2871264219,
0.2047991008,
-0.2491749376,
-0.3051562905,
0.3541565537,
0.7522858381,
-0.0764189288,
0.4274924099,
-0.5099342465,
-0.0671576336,
0.1795054823,
0.6181991696,
0.1189399362,
-0.5391593575,
-0.1637734175,
-0.0450688377,
-0.5398981571,
-0.720852375,
0.3808839023,
-0.1605602801,
0.3517958522,
0.6481488943,
0.0787821636,
0.5818653107,
-0.3891225159,
0.6815261245,
0.272366941,
-0.7504155636,
0.2963098884,
-0.8359955549,
-0.0518472791,
0.6569988132,
0.4207281172,
-0.4878616929,
-0.3876537383,
-0.318554908,
-0.6434216499,
0.6378787756,
0.2163297981,
0.2378974557,
-0.0967612192,
0.4492532909,
-0.0663923249,
0.2570612133,
-0.8772748709,
-0.2525836229,
-0.0646314844,
-0.2148858011,
-0.3779873848,
-0.3062098622,
-0.4087506533,
-0.3568903506,
0.6570670009,
-0.1442307234,
0.0911114663,
-0.1994432956,
0.3074534237,
-0.2395467311,
0.4643456042,
0.5073745847,
0.4409112334,
-0.4406355023,
0.0511943996,
0.3073036373,
-0.5488499403,
0.340939492,
-0.0987579823,
0.0660753623,
-0.6412237883,
0.2436353862,
0.7901133895,
0.1123209968,
-0.6613038778,
0.3970831335,
-0.0662507191,
-0.0570643581,
-0.1448349357,
0.3035413325,
0.3163441718,
0.2350054234,
0.046965491,
-0.2576904297,
0.116555281,
-0.7672790289,
-0.0452488773,
0.5631548762,
-0.1238247007,
-0.1735657156,
0.2921168804,
0.3128620684,
-0.1745886803,
0.5459026694,
-0.227447629,
-0.2759489417,
0.3716549277,
0.7388235331,
0.7222549915,
-0.2967512608,
0.1878391057,
0.276797384,
0.592539072,
-0.2304700911,
0.251565814,
0.3704471588,
-0.7574878335,
-0.3748829067,
-0.5718109012,
-0.4479661286,
0.4664748311,
-0.6436938643,
0.0894471183,
-0.7060960531,
-0.3343170881,
-0.223679617,
0.2637474239,
-0.4953081608,
0.1639252454,
0.2770928442,
0.6176056266,
-0.8106634617,
0.606364727,
0.4139668047,
-0.2949481606,
-1.0226609707,
-0.0268577915,
0.1382852644,
-0.7327556014,
0.5135637522,
0.2581356764,
-0.0096574379,
-0.0469498672,
-0.6173027754,
-1.0281543732,
1.0843337774,
0.6261078715,
-0.6105167866,
0.0739952177,
0.0424581431,
1.0208733082,
-0.1453584135,
0.3104486167,
0.8736315966,
0.6373813152,
-0.0713714212,
-1.1161729097,
0.2462694496,
-0.1746797413,
0.113014698,
0.1788916886,
-0.8508530855,
0.6077466607,
-0.2463216633,
-0.1326309443,
0.154043749,
0.3013728261,
0.4556694329,
0.0089408886,
0.6125605106,
0.4488922954,
0.7895364761,
0.0133294202,
1.105628252,
-0.2352228612,
0.4059982002,
0.8841155767,
-0.4845476747,
0.7123310566,
0.3410544693,
-0.1435305327,
0.3371438682,
0.7387049794,
-0.1094250679,
0.611207962,
0.3487632871,
-0.1040488631,
-0.3815391958,
-0.1456293613,
-0.2978231609,
0.3779497147,
0.3337710798,
-0.3970608413,
-0.0714490488,
0.0769025311,
0.3908010721,
-0.266495049,
-0.1995359659,
0.6368337274,
0.2755085528,
-0.7035972476,
0.6488033533,
-0.0291583799,
0.7923349738,
-0.5752769709,
0.4342001975,
-0.2929603755,
0.4733986557,
-0.1915154457,
-0.9564430118,
0.0656160489,
0.1371826082,
0.0132797863,
-0.1217954829,
0.5640652776,
-0.2856989503,
-0.4098829031,
0.4393489659,
0.3674533963,
0.1869541407,
-0.0792282298,
-0.636312604,
0.0817529559,
-0.1476897597,
-0.4179399014,
0.6625388265,
0.4602534473,
-0.1824790537,
0.9111307263,
0.8136247993,
0.0291115791,
-0.2720017433,
0.1813580543,
0.7499811649,
-0.7922042012,
-0.4771521986,
-1.0444602966,
0.2049918473,
0.0094687799,
-0.431527853,
0.925927043,
0.0874251053,
0.4724485278,
-0.1551638097,
0.5734517574,
0.1019563302,
0.2329401225,
-0.3538918793,
0.8164921999,
-0.2285892069,
0.2488332689,
-0.6673154831,
-0.9951816797,
-0.3102829158,
0.5076909065,
-0.5833746195,
0.3041773736,
0.8181805015,
0.9764549732,
0.3264640868,
-0.0007455537,
0.4123106301,
0.4532929063,
0.4901781678,
0.6965109706,
0.9052572846,
0.0595127456,
0.4660390615,
-0.3416906297,
-0.3285321295,
-0.1814128608,
-0.9731546044,
-1.2567088604,
-0.1889739931,
-0.1602331251,
-0.4417359829,
0.0170626491,
0.8766666651,
0.5253679156,
-0.6526096463,
-0.2511454821,
0.1991061419,
-0.0514853895,
-0.0576007254,
-0.2244169265,
0.2219283581,
-0.1159298122,
-0.3608528078,
0.0962641686,
0.3011390865,
0.1716008931,
-0.5072740912,
-0.150596872,
0.120519653,
0.0741265789,
0.757876277,
-0.1579862386,
-0.6462761164,
-0.8394152522,
0.0094077904,
-0.3215959072,
-0.2788192034,
0.4944652617,
-0.0603110306,
0.0604384877,
0.2804711461,
0.3600495458,
0.0961907431,
-0.129488036,
0.7026854157,
-0.4125869572,
-0.086676091,
0.1205785945,
0.3597207367,
0.3977944553,
-0.6305274963,
0.6831336021,
-0.0246777888,
-0.892493546,
-0.9806931615,
0.2083808035,
-1.0622477531,
0.1036894768,
1.592249155,
-0.1079436764,
-0.0847009122,
-0.0984527767,
-0.4948809147,
0.088784501,
-0.4505998492,
1.102986455,
0.9923202395,
-0.2273542732,
-0.0781800821,
-0.6041520834,
0.5276893377,
0.3908324242,
-0.9946343899,
0.1509273052,
0.4490950704,
0.6628012061,
0.2153964192,
0.4715240002,
-0.2171960175,
0.2508181334,
-0.2933546007,
0.0583332628,
0.1635498703,
0.0297207125,
-0.3624048233,
-0.0926525742,
0.1772585064,
0.1609577388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10528v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10528v1 | HYRR: Hybrid Infused Reranking for Passage Retrieval | 2022-12-20T18:44:21 | 2022-12-20T18:44:21 | Jing Lu, Keith Hall, Ji Ma, Jianmo Ni | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | We present Hybrid Infused Reranking for Passages Retrieval (HYRR), a
framework for training rerankers based on a hybrid of BM25 and neural retrieval
models. Retrievers based on hybrid models have been shown to outperform both
BM25 and neural models alone. Our approach exploits this improved performance
when training a reranker, leading to a robust reranking model. The reranker, a
cross-attention neural model, is shown to be robust to different first-stage
retrieval systems, achieving better performance than rerankers simply trained
upon the first-stage retrievers in the multi-stage systems. We present
evaluations on a supervised passage retrieval task using MS MARCO and zero-shot
retrieval tasks using BEIR. The empirical results show strong performance on
both evaluations. | [
0.1210085526,
-0.612470448,
0.4441146851,
0.2885561287,
-0.1056920737,
0.5353620052,
-0.2299624085,
-0.3721166849,
0.5274322033,
0.4182932377,
-0.2381274104,
-0.3303890228,
-0.577457726,
0.0672912672,
-0.3324992955,
0.9468041658,
0.2563020587,
0.4009602368,
-0.4002774358,
-0.1001570001,
-0.3904981911,
-0.5017408133,
-0.6768354774,
-0.6949019432,
1.2550683022,
0.3236341178,
0.5591397285,
0.5031132698,
0.9603278637,
0.3534672558,
-0.3318017423,
-0.1599199474,
-0.6380215883,
0.3481211662,
-0.6957861781,
-0.4663257003,
-0.3481078148,
-0.06728331,
0.6768894792,
0.5161769986,
-0.3563099205,
0.1058643982,
0.17651169,
0.6011352539,
-0.9877226353,
-0.2721371353,
-0.6786645651,
0.214726299,
-0.5329219699,
-0.4418504834,
-0.7067426443,
-0.3918548524,
0.460909605,
-0.6696516275,
0.3860323727,
0.2638454139,
0.8266739249,
0.1415780783,
-0.5996084213,
0.0762874112,
-0.6375428438,
0.9138832092,
-0.2724098861,
0.7013119459,
-0.0227560028,
0.5841981173,
0.1455188096,
-1.1773483753,
-0.4416111112,
-0.1831767559,
-0.0949833319,
0.2471719235,
0.0508400984,
0.2212819308,
-0.1776778549,
0.7132648826,
-0.6561161876,
-0.1968481392,
-0.516448915,
-0.3723676801,
0.6263449192,
0.2576851249,
0.1074072495,
-0.104300119,
-0.6243414879,
-0.4245889187,
-0.4757300913,
-0.1185743064,
0.2091751546,
0.1463441104,
0.3620326221,
0.7611300349,
-0.4253515899,
0.7860488296,
0.3206962943,
-0.0341162197,
0.2687249184,
-0.4932227731,
-0.0479864515,
-0.0785803422,
0.731087029,
0.1361920685,
0.0171675198,
-0.6582024097,
-0.3051631153,
-0.1719453633,
0.5615090728,
-0.6294799447,
-0.3739353418,
-0.1002041101,
-0.6342310309,
-0.3558166921,
0.1029915586,
-0.9039955139,
-0.047226239,
-0.1804957241,
1.1702125072,
-0.3284619749,
-0.1715704948,
-0.0923912749,
-0.6610755324,
0.5519441366,
0.1768761575,
-0.6793960929,
0.4445023239,
0.734472394,
0.8477019668,
-0.5401105881,
-0.5784146786,
-0.7152950764,
0.2235977948,
-0.1073696539,
0.7401953936,
-0.7060965896,
-0.3487299681,
-0.1915690601,
-0.0624938682,
-0.5633320808,
-0.7988193035,
0.7869234085,
-1.0304298401,
0.0628823563,
-0.2914590836,
-0.4736793637,
-0.1111902818,
0.3461601436,
-0.5853981376,
1.143306613,
0.1703300625,
-0.7804918885,
0.3707047701,
-0.5818641782,
-0.5266064405,
0.3744539618,
0.0373867638,
-0.3659081757,
-0.0307739712,
-0.0071285996,
-0.0117375217,
0.0691387057,
-0.0052897218,
-0.37308231,
-0.5585539937,
0.1432362199,
-0.2748951316,
0.6198182106,
0.1563640535,
-0.1907905489,
0.2054128051,
-0.2423709482,
0.3889808953,
-0.0002681145,
-0.6706626415,
-0.4088386595,
-0.1842673719,
0.4306676686,
0.2820903659,
0.3462467492,
-1.0677512884,
-0.1131112725,
-0.3280031383,
0.2335217595,
0.4782610536,
0.1911144406,
0.5185551047,
-0.5112242103,
0.5362356305,
0.0360200033,
0.0239007156,
0.0824268907,
-0.4050036967,
-0.836296916,
-0.2452779412,
0.853374958,
0.8284595013,
-0.8692792654,
0.4512736499,
-0.4339266717,
-0.5353042483,
-0.916549325,
0.2851667106,
0.8117572069,
0.3802815378,
0.5569784045,
-0.189848125,
-0.4109628201,
-1.1187925339,
-0.5590416193,
0.1411370039,
0.1221013367,
0.2416314632,
0.630685389,
-0.0587642565,
0.7601408958,
-0.4841486216,
-0.5955992937,
-0.6846256852,
0.115961045,
0.00500543,
0.6209697723,
0.0237436276,
-0.9694258571,
-0.7085276246,
-0.1203585491,
-0.7183900476,
0.4267170727,
0.2742542028,
-0.4819080234,
-0.0827524364,
0.5072540641,
-0.4357387722,
0.4964390099,
0.2128025442,
-0.1901367903,
0.1447156221,
-0.2849100232,
0.1323482692,
-1.0759842396,
0.19758901,
0.1559231281,
-0.3280142546,
-0.4668644667,
0.3306383491,
0.2877019346,
-0.1285902411,
-0.4228437245,
0.4341920316,
-0.5947675109,
0.0212876927,
-0.2480731755,
-0.0700634867,
0.0360742658,
0.3054020107,
0.4091266394,
0.6212230325,
0.2518315911,
-0.337618351,
0.1711305678,
0.4676119685,
-0.2004592121,
0.7570273876,
-1.0285381079,
0.2685841918,
-0.0213488545,
0.4542133808,
-1.0241508484,
-0.1911901236,
-0.1069250405,
-0.5555183887,
0.4708341062,
-0.4238831997,
-0.2353489697,
-0.3702688217,
-0.3001295328,
0.6069030762,
0.3105313182,
-0.588958025,
0.6442778707,
0.1925058365,
-0.3167195618,
-0.5983803868,
-0.6264442205,
0.1503704041,
0.0329259038,
-0.709219873,
0.9498992562,
0.1529639214,
0.1418600976,
0.0875602961,
-0.1068330333,
-0.0476073362,
-0.2826311886,
0.0872893408,
0.1355077326,
-0.2625550032,
-0.3237603605,
0.1444526613,
-0.2037680447,
-0.0143812252,
-0.0802274197,
0.4455038309,
0.0903813019,
-0.4015236497,
-0.4285186529,
0.4619175196,
0.4245596826,
-0.8123698235,
0.8450072408,
0.5409144163,
-0.3996321261,
0.0032354263,
-0.6970456243,
-0.3581838906,
-0.547593236,
0.0863164514,
-0.4525158107,
-0.8644007444,
0.3464992046,
0.4247356057,
-0.2969691753,
0.2675433457,
0.5909360647,
-0.3002803028,
0.9375472665,
0.5581203103,
-0.1479468942,
0.744985044,
-0.4087581336,
0.0594726168,
-1.2582021952,
-0.6972647905,
-0.5008856654,
-0.8936143517,
-0.6623088717,
-0.2941167653,
0.7855907083,
-0.2752466202,
0.1182848364,
0.0356358327,
-0.434890002,
0.7501299381,
1.0673667192,
0.7517860532,
0.3293447196,
-0.0212904532,
-0.4857569039,
-0.2161941081,
-0.8523219824,
-0.101357542,
1.3714915514,
0.1551033556,
0.9524385929,
0.1710955948,
1.0602027178,
0.3193477392,
0.3897438645,
-0.8057519794,
0.3203424811,
0.134036839,
-1.3494124413,
-0.4527461529,
-0.5163708925,
-1.0577315092,
0.7760806084,
-0.2470729798,
-0.6836769581,
0.5218769908,
-0.0912338048,
-0.6049770713,
0.1269159913,
-0.564981401,
0.9606866241,
-0.108523868,
-0.7756525278,
-0.2675940096,
-0.8993605971,
0.3959334493,
0.274522543,
-0.4340258241,
0.6124532223,
0.0002679825,
1.0036793947,
-0.2194494009,
0.3456872702,
-0.2535958886,
0.4861194193,
0.0257398635,
-0.005126317,
0.2685123384,
-0.0039390507,
-0.1291823536,
-0.2246259749,
0.0338267349,
-0.5758999586,
-0.4970278144,
0.7700351477,
-0.5532149673,
-0.5469130874,
-0.8078585863,
-0.4297221601,
-0.0498371013,
0.4245478809,
0.4798299372,
0.4477838278,
-0.1636143774,
0.80895257,
0.9780861139,
0.0771826506,
0.4210125208,
0.4473936856,
0.0009460826,
-0.9498030543,
1.1419835091,
0.1637889892,
0.245849818,
0.8381782174,
-0.0156660825,
-0.642308712,
-0.7976953387,
-0.2941581607,
0.3769876063,
-0.3433966637,
-0.1408814341,
-0.8418766856,
-0.5261503458,
-0.3162221313,
-0.0815984532,
-0.3218156993,
-0.2213733941,
0.1329795718,
-0.0124406759,
-0.1914856285,
0.5242506266,
-0.1251281053,
0.3900278509,
-0.7836242318,
0.4137226641,
0.1611445397,
0.3450016677,
0.0470069945,
-0.7187944651,
-0.4102095366,
-0.0723037347,
-0.6816241741,
-0.8666151762,
0.3212550282,
0.2150674611,
0.9840474129,
0.1939113438,
0.0967324674,
0.6040107012,
-0.3732132018,
0.5040954351,
-0.1213992462,
-0.6010828018,
0.4002403617,
-0.3755175173,
0.0337207429,
1.0753741264,
0.388425231,
-0.3604665697,
-0.1609157771,
-0.457850039,
-0.7378843427,
0.6259949207,
0.2520101368,
-0.0872868076,
0.2354473174,
0.2670339644,
-0.1151851267,
0.195537746,
-0.7122209668,
-0.1302329451,
-0.0349084996,
-0.3706121147,
-0.463740468,
-0.1591833532,
0.0017492084,
-0.5353856683,
0.493822962,
0.062904872,
0.3527894616,
0.5773770809,
-0.5144729018,
-0.1966868043,
0.2838821411,
0.2007001191,
0.5229098201,
-0.6061491966,
-0.0981667489,
-0.0718639046,
-0.5529218316,
0.292460978,
0.3389905989,
-0.3940339088,
-0.0599306934,
0.2716377378,
0.3525888026,
0.5073071718,
-0.2798900604,
0.5816774368,
0.0713399574,
-0.3493608236,
-0.2387288362,
0.0561073646,
0.0299705565,
0.4151429832,
0.5906506777,
-0.2284345031,
0.6131408215,
-0.5122877955,
0.4450237751,
0.590973258,
-0.5345247984,
-0.1497435421,
0.8677839041,
0.3726019561,
-0.4668183923,
0.8844181895,
-0.0847739801,
-0.7749900818,
0.2398537248,
0.6344554424,
0.7799048424,
-0.2116519958,
0.2322590649,
0.2415475845,
0.4240813255,
-0.0646913797,
0.4932882786,
-0.2210344672,
-0.5386483073,
-0.2242760062,
-0.5502328873,
-0.663689971,
-0.1248885989,
-1.0721307993,
-0.1273415834,
-0.2774875462,
-0.3116632104,
0.0932007283,
0.3027264476,
-0.4169232249,
0.2699481845,
-0.0388936214,
1.1540961266,
-0.4910337925,
0.6739188433,
0.8226588964,
-0.5741479993,
-0.3880241513,
0.1556521952,
-0.0841966271,
-0.2163839787,
0.6048294902,
-0.0616381951,
-0.0713989213,
0.4272160828,
-0.1362758726,
-0.9047923684,
1.42144835,
0.006390214,
-0.4103079736,
-0.3108932078,
-0.0346587077,
0.5626174808,
-0.0978980809,
0.4663130045,
0.2735874057,
0.3145652711,
0.1938763857,
-1.0002666712,
-0.1844819933,
-0.3756957948,
0.0184921436,
0.2813503444,
-0.9390724301,
0.7354423404,
-0.2018486857,
-0.0299852062,
0.2823078632,
0.8584544659,
0.4899854958,
0.7782936096,
0.3686696589,
0.9307364821,
0.485255301,
-0.260923624,
1.0823850632,
-0.041048333,
0.1734142154,
1.0628892183,
-0.5576052666,
1.3882519007,
0.6721528769,
-0.0095836455,
0.7411050797,
0.6226638556,
0.2663193941,
0.8992758989,
0.098246932,
-0.2221975774,
-0.4452789128,
0.0148360273,
-0.4196454883,
0.4479269385,
0.1238632128,
-0.454482913,
-0.1798083633,
-0.1442718655,
-0.3734384179,
-0.0438264161,
-0.1174606681,
0.8624807,
0.0695990771,
-0.8173607588,
0.3484665155,
0.0952830762,
0.8844752908,
-0.3645412624,
0.1450705677,
-0.366435945,
0.6999926567,
-0.115938507,
-0.6592834592,
0.0801766962,
-0.2483483404,
-0.2743970156,
-0.1117840558,
0.8376127481,
-0.5715348721,
-0.617960453,
0.3462207317,
0.780805409,
-0.186597988,
-0.3436426222,
-0.7007517815,
-0.2078830451,
-0.2442642897,
-0.2674180269,
0.553147912,
0.2217189521,
0.0535703823,
0.8190154433,
0.7807127237,
-0.2111130208,
0.5171657205,
-0.1765045375,
0.8867563605,
-0.9312263131,
-0.4960827529,
-0.5593836904,
0.3914797008,
-0.2351686656,
-0.3325247169,
0.8498336673,
1.0725762844,
0.8217468262,
-0.0172228739,
0.6013116241,
0.1338376403,
0.7950358391,
-0.3020886481,
0.983278513,
-0.6573972702,
-0.1802651733,
-0.1489854306,
-1.0142576694,
0.0142916599,
0.4701986313,
-0.3028212786,
0.2596161366,
0.6334310174,
1.0066937208,
-0.4766384363,
-0.1959150881,
0.2485543787,
-0.2726723552,
0.0176858343,
0.7263675928,
1.1443581581,
-0.5622494221,
0.7031373978,
-0.4086913764,
-0.0642272383,
-0.6229861975,
-0.2796195149,
-0.8650850654,
-0.2953623533,
-0.1530477703,
-0.3986102641,
0.3707879186,
0.7251520753,
0.8861447573,
-0.6573221684,
-0.2786978185,
0.3147128224,
0.2246976495,
-0.2342590988,
-0.3251575232,
-0.0119084613,
-0.2878127694,
-0.6166347265,
0.6964512467,
0.0734055191,
-0.2193379998,
-0.3146647513,
-0.28196612,
-0.6263515949,
0.0737126172,
0.428937614,
0.0847537294,
-0.4750887752,
0.0698825717,
0.5401980877,
-0.3936131299,
-0.0283742417,
0.7879254222,
-0.8163167834,
0.1474504471,
0.7491708398,
0.7439157367,
0.90167135,
0.2342680991,
0.5115647912,
-0.4167278707,
-0.3256117702,
0.4157804549,
0.205266878,
0.2825717926,
-0.1923287213,
0.3729165792,
0.3593145609,
-0.6643860936,
-0.9340571761,
-0.1835361868,
-1.1501977444,
0.2592485845,
1.0187330246,
-0.0555952787,
-0.3305805326,
-0.0534251146,
-0.04016307,
0.1405291408,
-0.419438839,
0.5865329504,
0.5695458651,
0.0535608158,
-0.2387857437,
-0.236652866,
0.0821451768,
0.6117516756,
-0.5617181063,
-0.5358160138,
0.2632733285,
0.7506440878,
0.2874164581,
0.4320503771,
-0.3466151357,
0.3418697119,
0.0217365064,
-0.1192544103,
0.041146107,
-0.6587304473,
-0.3455358148,
0.2862006426,
-0.0729821324,
-0.4717800319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10526v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10526v3 | Open Domain Multi-document Summarization: A Comprehensive Study of Model Brittleness under Retrieval | 2022-12-20T18:41:38 | 2023-10-25T13:25:20 | John Giorgi, Luca Soldaini, Bo Wang, Gary Bader, Kyle Lo, Lucy Lu Wang, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Multi-document summarization (MDS) assumes a set of topic-related documents
are provided as input. In practice, this document set is not always available;
it would need to be retrieved given an information need, i.e. a question or
topic statement, a setting we dub "open-domain" MDS. We study this more
challenging setting by formalizing the task and bootstrapping it using existing
datasets, retrievers and summarizers. Via extensive automatic and human
evaluation, we determine: (1) state-of-the-art summarizers suffer large
reductions in performance when applied to open-domain MDS, (2) additional
training in the open-domain setting can reduce this sensitivity to imperfect
retrieval, and (3) summarizers are insensitive to the retrieval of duplicate
documents and the order of retrieved documents, but highly sensitive to other
errors, like the retrieval of irrelevant documents. Based on our results, we
provide practical guidelines to enable future work on open-domain MDS, e.g. how
to choose the number of retrieved documents to summarize. Our results suggest
that new retrieval and summarization methods and annotated resources for
training and evaluation are necessary for further progress in the open-domain
setting. | [
-0.4355319738,
-0.6522094607,
0.4253662527,
0.0497051142,
-0.0846225917,
-0.0106072091,
-0.1861814111,
-0.2099658996,
0.1822456717,
0.2619048357,
-0.3580094874,
-0.2267695665,
-0.8163477778,
0.1556712687,
-0.2963714898,
1.2032830715,
-0.3663018644,
0.2493297458,
-0.7641380429,
-0.4252439737,
-0.2217710316,
-0.6488551497,
-0.2186539471,
-0.2989794016,
0.3979231417,
0.2570760548,
0.5349390507,
0.390408963,
0.9811518788,
0.207800284,
-0.3044574559,
0.1572433263,
-0.6332474351,
0.3947116435,
-0.19466497,
-0.4265485406,
-0.6858947277,
0.0999357477,
0.5584569573,
1.1098563671,
-0.0090445196,
0.1374815553,
0.1328623742,
0.7581642866,
-1.0013139248,
0.0949557275,
-0.2424515933,
0.0414321609,
-0.1760737747,
-0.4661476612,
-0.3053055704,
-0.2855118513,
0.2746404111,
-0.6237569451,
0.5324602723,
-0.0561777204,
0.5724005103,
-0.0275702756,
-0.5903706551,
-0.3331079781,
-0.8577779531,
0.6488904357,
-0.4288727939,
0.1855118126,
0.450719595,
0.3624051511,
0.0366594009,
-0.8131684661,
-0.1550637335,
0.0516871586,
0.1098329276,
0.3424511552,
-0.0335721336,
-0.0827767923,
0.1087614298,
0.7117971182,
-0.6422635317,
-0.0120944604,
-0.6156671047,
0.0416153669,
0.3924202621,
0.1841384172,
0.045609273,
0.2382274419,
-0.3448989391,
0.0291651972,
-0.7219235897,
-0.3744364679,
0.345302403,
0.4514133632,
0.0144155556,
0.8776143193,
-0.3327585459,
0.401034683,
-0.0880296007,
-0.0892233998,
0.2597264946,
-0.6012331843,
-0.2255619019,
-0.2001474351,
0.3789568841,
0.4913152158,
0.2157421708,
-0.203596741,
-0.319385767,
-0.2739847898,
0.5623014569,
-0.7225144506,
-0.0690980405,
0.5213363767,
-0.9002702832,
-0.2915840149,
0.2388029099,
-0.6984286308,
-0.376957655,
-0.3176050186,
0.5085913539,
-0.4900777042,
-0.3054058552,
-0.099305734,
-0.4751053154,
-0.2758345902,
0.4495056272,
-0.8283253908,
0.6422531009,
0.471955955,
1.1779180765,
-0.2420182526,
-0.4958349466,
-0.3659528196,
0.202753529,
-0.2809378207,
0.8551911712,
-0.3054521382,
-0.5544371605,
-0.0132545494,
-0.1695238501,
-0.2596385777,
-0.6844666004,
0.437214762,
-0.4213394523,
0.391916424,
-0.38059479,
-0.4459478259,
-0.0283777248,
0.1885900348,
-0.7356786132,
0.5492053628,
0.3565795124,
-0.8042830229,
0.2991961539,
-0.8261993527,
-0.5964895487,
-0.2409511358,
0.1485419273,
-0.2688952684,
0.45535326,
0.1287421137,
0.4335487187,
-0.3494017422,
0.1102035865,
-0.4268465042,
-0.2921333909,
0.0507154651,
-0.3080083132,
0.5919613242,
0.3018438518,
0.0536035597,
0.1996190995,
-0.6613228321,
-0.1435488611,
0.3457398117,
-0.4407028258,
-0.6261848211,
0.0803339407,
-0.0340224691,
0.1925650835,
0.0953352004,
-0.2389146835,
0.1695226133,
-0.2285814583,
0.1467021704,
0.6298084855,
0.2657805085,
0.4832547605,
-0.6340885162,
0.4851495922,
0.2417834103,
0.1225643754,
-0.5798894763,
-0.2624164522,
-0.4380096197,
-0.1883490533,
0.3087812066,
0.2614189088,
-0.6483865976,
0.0489186347,
-0.2450911403,
-0.3775116205,
-0.3838336468,
-0.2719773054,
0.4963546097,
0.5221171379,
0.5860396028,
-0.685834825,
-0.3495841324,
-0.7948857546,
-0.1040083468,
0.1378707886,
-0.0595975816,
0.1284454167,
0.9238312244,
0.2449369729,
0.8410110474,
-0.786650002,
-0.437851429,
-0.135697946,
0.3348545432,
-0.243265152,
0.3729068637,
0.6031764746,
-1.037743926,
-0.082611002,
-0.3657310903,
-1.0357666016,
0.2663008571,
0.2148621678,
0.1967423707,
0.276591301,
0.2712508738,
-0.6528148651,
0.4317978621,
0.0589391366,
-0.0662271827,
0.7437974811,
-0.4812390208,
0.3458257914,
-1.0607714653,
0.4308001101,
0.0739809498,
0.1020167172,
-0.6152492166,
0.3494863808,
0.0934134349,
-0.2591997683,
-0.326077044,
0.3200538158,
-0.7673642039,
-0.1930317432,
-0.1737260669,
0.3489575088,
-0.0265280195,
0.3713182509,
-0.142318666,
0.8490144014,
0.2729663253,
-0.7130534649,
0.2657459974,
0.4443394542,
-0.1777639985,
0.989368856,
-0.5273786783,
-0.0304631814,
-0.421744585,
0.2929777503,
-0.7528737187,
-0.3900276423,
0.0000065123,
-0.3642210066,
0.5272344947,
-0.1839430034,
-0.360058099,
-0.2859451771,
-0.6192685962,
0.2069127411,
0.0633345321,
-0.3938466012,
0.3097266853,
0.5171562433,
-0.5183864832,
-0.7115902901,
-0.3257339597,
0.0334061682,
0.0185011979,
-0.4818460345,
0.2433541715,
-0.2984335124,
-0.4188635051,
0.0922644958,
-0.5099264979,
-0.305529505,
0.3617132008,
0.2394789606,
0.1321971267,
-0.1823779494,
0.1919051558,
0.1549396068,
0.0210949089,
0.062550351,
-0.3933005035,
0.3540951312,
-0.0753890276,
-0.4887318909,
0.1302099824,
0.800193131,
0.6478478312,
-0.5588511825,
0.9235904813,
0.1983534694,
-0.6939157248,
0.0178316943,
-0.1789097041,
0.0023009095,
-0.3489198089,
0.2116320133,
-0.524459362,
-0.5279764533,
0.378126502,
-0.2252349108,
0.1066028327,
0.6929667592,
0.558504343,
-0.194066748,
0.7679072618,
0.7303164005,
0.0696972013,
0.1564788818,
-0.3695941865,
-0.0279486217,
-0.8036151528,
-0.4999780953,
-0.78064996,
-0.1025782079,
0.0355621167,
-0.145034194,
0.4375085235,
0.0413186923,
0.0956701934,
0.0635063499,
-0.2179257423,
0.4065105915,
0.5503922701,
0.0799159557,
0.4124615788,
-0.1123708412,
-0.2804696858,
0.1072628945,
-0.5974963903,
-0.6009949446,
1.3634241819,
0.1931606829,
0.6059089303,
0.3533948958,
0.6542993784,
0.2761504948,
0.1328707486,
-0.5923072696,
0.3236290514,
0.0477260053,
-0.61547786,
-0.2351494282,
-0.6048237681,
-0.8854323626,
0.3600671589,
-0.2702240348,
-0.5461381674,
0.1695362031,
0.0084858965,
-0.1743711531,
0.2252852172,
-0.6893562078,
0.7621979713,
0.088616617,
-0.0869695842,
-0.1881317645,
-0.8697257638,
0.4515715837,
-0.2200566381,
0.2638092637,
0.1938075721,
-0.0939125493,
0.7021480799,
-0.4977751374,
0.5870341659,
-0.1405880302,
-0.0806543976,
0.0650241449,
0.0491218641,
0.215456754,
-0.3069702387,
0.0352787711,
-0.1011248901,
0.1214491203,
-0.4142905474,
-0.6175630093,
0.5849753022,
-0.5126871467,
-0.3169292808,
-0.5303253531,
-0.4328221679,
-0.2114974856,
0.5731215477,
0.439252913,
0.8723833561,
-0.6119067073,
0.1761974096,
0.8980842233,
0.127812013,
0.282633692,
0.4863657653,
0.0067438879,
-0.4627610743,
1.0690364838,
0.568248868,
0.372069031,
0.409414351,
-0.1091198772,
-0.0255218521,
-0.9877021909,
-0.2832660675,
0.0751579329,
-0.8705641627,
-0.225713864,
-0.6132329702,
-0.0953335613,
-0.6563990116,
-0.0692950934,
-0.2252505422,
-0.940248549,
-0.5696189404,
-0.0711814687,
-0.1538302451,
0.7792535424,
0.0989116505,
-0.0466831326,
-0.7974353433,
0.6408104897,
-0.1574194282,
0.6765493751,
0.0053621619,
-0.4685236514,
-0.5291376114,
-0.1204812154,
-0.4399001598,
-0.8269413114,
0.1201877967,
0.1979211718,
0.6308789849,
0.409085542,
0.446680218,
0.3367457688,
-0.4194482565,
0.6141090393,
0.0349786431,
-0.5810233951,
0.6510195136,
-0.4701267481,
0.2124419063,
0.6687680483,
0.8531348705,
-0.2802278697,
-0.259157598,
-0.5827644467,
-1.0708215237,
0.7823969126,
0.1855675727,
-0.2054692656,
-0.0222814959,
0.2937618494,
0.2569406331,
0.4970986843,
-0.0872916356,
-0.5102900267,
-0.2543442845,
-0.2000791132,
-0.1838340014,
-0.4142521918,
-0.5498542786,
0.3332521617,
0.763915062,
-0.3057326376,
0.2817243636,
0.188010633,
-0.3911735117,
-0.2842263877,
0.360008955,
0.8388165236,
0.9485341907,
-0.6433278918,
0.1991151124,
-0.2210071683,
-0.655305922,
0.0849721953,
0.3619158566,
-0.2137201875,
-0.1419764757,
0.4176506996,
0.5417587161,
0.209086284,
-0.599991858,
0.6718826294,
-0.1389739513,
-0.2730061114,
-0.1471319348,
-0.1865961254,
-0.2731051445,
0.0511868969,
0.5082822442,
0.4527781904,
0.2952619493,
-0.6945147514,
0.0756104365,
0.29131791,
-0.3051852584,
-0.1418183446,
0.7946066856,
0.1840400845,
-0.1769723594,
0.4673034847,
0.0181526169,
-0.1719584316,
0.4188758135,
0.5706965327,
0.870472312,
-0.0505433902,
0.0409830548,
0.0708011314,
0.4314244986,
-0.3394960761,
0.3104212582,
0.0862279534,
-0.282099843,
-0.0508036874,
-0.2926363647,
-0.8678791523,
-0.1459162682,
-0.9889649153,
-0.0243253391,
-0.3188410699,
-0.2299777418,
0.0610479005,
-0.093431063,
-0.2340183556,
0.2782538831,
-0.400202781,
1.1383397579,
-0.6247984767,
0.2742304802,
0.7767221928,
-0.849514544,
0.0705671981,
0.0970951542,
0.3528128266,
-0.2494229227,
0.1661685109,
-0.0002788453,
0.0257660337,
-0.1820720732,
-0.2390375286,
-0.7980954051,
1.2900326252,
0.2918097377,
0.1036374494,
-0.2435989678,
-0.3441845775,
0.3716185987,
-0.1928248852,
0.3360195458,
0.3295052946,
0.2244860679,
-0.0993301421,
-1.0237548351,
0.1504916698,
-0.4577336907,
-0.2397845984,
0.2758379579,
-0.665209651,
1.0335357189,
-0.5912646651,
-0.1966918409,
0.1931290627,
0.5810891986,
-0.0958837941,
0.6875779033,
0.0222257879,
0.3729794919,
0.8260094523,
-0.2006978393,
1.2399736643,
0.0184643585,
0.2760319114,
1.3013750315,
-0.4042682946,
0.7956433892,
0.274024874,
-0.1569603086,
0.012628085,
0.3708432615,
0.0741177201,
0.541449964,
0.0643255115,
-0.2772623301,
0.2825477719,
-0.0725677833,
-0.534727037,
0.1302407533,
0.1762107611,
-0.4306594133,
-0.289211005,
0.1080848649,
-0.0121105378,
0.0168861263,
-0.2208034098,
0.839450717,
0.0991788059,
-0.5905374289,
0.4343384802,
0.3314709961,
0.2922570705,
-0.7241458297,
0.142517522,
-0.2580170035,
0.1538533419,
-0.2365025282,
-0.5559878945,
0.3789289296,
-0.0308275931,
-0.5706529617,
-0.2833818495,
0.8632280827,
-0.2229593992,
0.0633378476,
0.1388783455,
0.8245875239,
0.1642706841,
-0.3432109952,
-0.1702435613,
-0.1686499268,
-0.4484266937,
-0.4212427437,
0.8227214217,
0.2697395086,
-0.1499612778,
0.7325829864,
0.467010498,
0.0075791348,
-0.2443962544,
0.0991948619,
1.022585988,
-0.4365386963,
-0.2760918438,
-0.4777323604,
0.4226796031,
-0.1015991271,
-0.3490417302,
0.7290917635,
0.8536015749,
0.815738678,
-0.1835305542,
0.9130893946,
0.0352409333,
0.62522614,
-0.6484261751,
0.9324437976,
-0.5670609474,
0.167342782,
-0.3693065941,
-0.9818747044,
-0.3310925364,
0.2313797474,
-0.0703321397,
0.1553640366,
1.0121123791,
0.3337786198,
-0.1358434409,
0.2068980932,
0.0980585292,
0.1061406881,
0.0796588883,
0.1760444045,
0.556571424,
-0.374914676,
0.6357882619,
-0.2995413244,
-0.3631196916,
-0.3310266137,
-0.6421551108,
-0.6958929896,
-0.82553339,
-0.3053640127,
-0.4037661552,
0.2322697788,
0.8810637593,
0.427403152,
-0.6078397632,
-0.1504228115,
0.3914751709,
0.3111688793,
-0.4510711133,
-0.1721215546,
0.3187242448,
-0.3066737056,
-0.4871431589,
0.7184410691,
0.3639210463,
0.4157119095,
-0.0677568913,
0.1105252504,
-0.1846927553,
0.0905717537,
0.7161975503,
0.358261764,
-0.2173761129,
-0.0077336472,
-0.1340551525,
-0.0228883643,
0.1131465062,
1.0661282539,
-0.5207016468,
0.4757299423,
0.3097192943,
0.3053804338,
0.4341283441,
0.0666681752,
0.7123792768,
-0.8039874434,
-0.3187598288,
0.1327889115,
0.5454425216,
0.1696774364,
-0.0236470867,
0.6589320898,
0.5286160707,
-0.3169936836,
-1.0066221952,
0.0316092409,
-0.771602869,
-0.5400919914,
0.6681165099,
-0.3123647273,
0.1177128628,
-0.3487592041,
-0.1157886684,
0.1706519574,
-0.2150105685,
0.6326078176,
0.7013492584,
0.0210326575,
0.1242146194,
-0.4205085933,
0.1344537139,
-0.0173282214,
-0.989008069,
0.2768641412,
0.7743208408,
0.1574885249,
0.3789496422,
0.9402759075,
-0.35604617,
0.2447224557,
0.2208065838,
-0.0861456618,
-0.4260914326,
-0.7741071582,
-0.6304866076,
0.7390295267,
0.0091153914,
-0.036993444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10525v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10525v2 | SLUE Phase-2: A Benchmark Suite of Diverse Spoken Language Understanding Tasks | 2022-12-20T18:39:59 | 2023-06-15T22:51:09 | Suwon Shon, Siddhant Arora, Chyi-Jiunn Lin, Ankita Pasad, Felix Wu, Roshan Sharma, Wei-Lun Wu, Hung-Yi Lee, Karen Livescu, Shinji Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Spoken language understanding (SLU) tasks have been studied for many decades
in the speech research community, but have not received as much attention as
lower-level tasks like speech and speaker recognition. In particular, there are
not nearly as many SLU task benchmarks, and many of the existing ones use data
that is not freely available to all researchers. Recent work has begun to
introduce such benchmark datasets for several tasks. In this work, we introduce
several new annotated SLU benchmark tasks based on freely available speech
data, which complement existing benchmarks and address gaps in the SLU
evaluation landscape. We contribute four tasks: question answering and
summarization involve inference over longer speech sequences; named entity
localization addresses the speech-specific task of locating the targeted
content in the signal; dialog act classification identifies the function of a
given speech utterance. We follow the blueprint of the Spoken Language
Understanding Evaluation (SLUE) benchmark suite. In order to facilitate the
development of SLU models that leverage the success of pre-trained speech
representations, we will be publishing for each task (i) annotations for a
relatively small fine-tuning set, (ii) annotated development and test sets, and
(iii) baseline models for easy reproducibility and comparisons. In this work,
we present the details of data collection and annotation and the performance of
the baseline models. We also perform sensitivity analysis of pipeline models'
performance (speech recognizer + text model) to the speech recognition
accuracy, using more than 20 state-of-the-art speech recognition models. | [
-0.1267824769,
-0.5548254848,
0.2819485664,
0.1620502472,
-0.0307182372,
0.0343714543,
-0.0990538672,
-0.6758441329,
-0.2138615549,
0.7283648849,
-0.5261828303,
-0.3713861108,
-0.5162070394,
-0.1718228161,
-0.4324970543,
0.9570944309,
0.0520867594,
0.0607727505,
-0.3449743986,
-0.2984892726,
-0.4716062844,
-0.3081831038,
-0.4524681568,
-0.6051180363,
0.2683407664,
0.3644888103,
0.3552319109,
0.4387820065,
0.0615354478,
0.2135950625,
-0.2952823341,
-0.236216858,
-0.6754127145,
0.2449000627,
-0.0219461173,
-0.4176003635,
-0.333575815,
0.0791861862,
0.894685626,
1.0084290504,
-0.1910156012,
0.4999643266,
0.099209629,
0.4939806163,
-0.5853099227,
0.433706671,
-0.7165848613,
-0.0527818464,
-0.2158584595,
0.2944809794,
-0.4104779363,
-0.1390588582,
0.2878572941,
-0.8253511786,
0.2538737059,
-0.0624907501,
0.5836884379,
0.4653677046,
-0.356872797,
-0.2526573837,
-0.4545943737,
0.8323231339,
-0.826189816,
0.5979686975,
0.5838272572,
0.2490135729,
0.2464129925,
-0.8660097122,
-0.2598163784,
-0.1278664619,
-0.1612793952,
0.0814326257,
-0.3843782246,
0.0857964754,
0.3715324104,
0.1948053688,
-0.7357743979,
0.2606242001,
-0.400957495,
-0.2595889866,
0.4739485979,
-0.0290613472,
-0.1045752242,
-0.1287507415,
-0.2008924335,
0.1383597553,
-0.4279890358,
0.2514305413,
0.0268431101,
0.3935902119,
-0.2066159844,
0.4849487245,
-0.399471283,
0.7096086144,
-0.247852087,
-0.1614595652,
0.537530303,
-0.474068135,
-0.3610256016,
0.087660037,
0.3394407928,
0.0666476414,
0.0865382403,
-0.2976561785,
-0.3584971428,
-0.0819433853,
0.0783925056,
-0.4010101259,
-0.1530534327,
0.2746227086,
-0.2358444184,
-0.0074508628,
-0.4196128547,
-0.4527104497,
-0.5671850443,
-0.6124482155,
0.325955689,
-0.1872525364,
-0.431676656,
-0.1098843291,
0.031306725,
0.2091889083,
0.2463557422,
-0.7013002038,
0.6729742289,
1.0567564964,
0.6883027554,
-0.2746307552,
-0.3536198735,
-0.945584476,
0.0801197737,
-0.0861804411,
0.5549407601,
-0.5009855032,
-0.2307171971,
0.0742971674,
-0.0156175951,
-0.3369497359,
-0.6779643893,
0.6802309155,
-0.1530094743,
-0.1535839289,
-0.4310326278,
-0.6049031615,
-0.3164613843,
-0.1789722592,
-0.5175721049,
1.2227150202,
0.2027017921,
-0.6807957292,
-0.0057555856,
-0.575340867,
-0.4690296352,
0.4150692225,
-0.1143044755,
-0.0285213944,
0.2109738737,
0.1222507358,
0.3524209559,
-0.171635896,
0.1427576393,
0.1128633544,
-0.3756346107,
0.0993798077,
0.1722569317,
0.5940031409,
0.317681998,
-0.522788763,
0.2281464487,
-0.5515484214,
0.0052836747,
-0.0041625677,
0.1577345282,
-0.2095086128,
0.1135299131,
0.150453493,
-0.1407367736,
0.2871310115,
-0.4065453708,
-0.2798830271,
-0.1969020963,
0.59818995,
0.4292515516,
-0.1368739754,
0.522069037,
-0.0579094999,
0.6245466471,
0.0171893369,
-0.009040162,
-0.252192229,
-0.4591129124,
-0.9137060642,
-0.0707432032,
0.2631450593,
0.8118076921,
-0.4294233918,
-0.0361994468,
-0.2169433385,
-0.5138599277,
-0.8757752776,
0.1665576845,
0.6127182245,
0.733477056,
0.3318839371,
-0.0200287271,
-0.4641950727,
-0.9450098276,
-0.1159372255,
-0.1760148406,
0.0218635295,
0.3497262597,
0.3098219633,
-0.0432131439,
0.6450173855,
-0.3084011972,
-0.0468022265,
-0.3516713977,
0.5670834184,
0.1218874827,
0.3037665486,
0.0994784981,
-0.5185171366,
-0.0547946543,
0.0970274583,
-0.7155851722,
-0.3147189617,
0.0544731654,
0.2195101827,
-0.0809378847,
0.4421978295,
-0.2571761608,
0.109901242,
0.6918730736,
0.0179783329,
0.4441881478,
0.0864969864,
-0.03437474,
-0.5876485109,
0.0865136087,
0.0978788584,
-0.3831535578,
-1.2159138918,
0.2275556475,
-0.0197566133,
-0.5359682441,
-0.4835971594,
0.4204368591,
-0.4388407469,
-0.6230353117,
-0.1863246709,
0.5888425708,
-0.1445909441,
0.3721080124,
0.0905110314,
0.7873990536,
0.637181282,
-0.3240027428,
-0.0918727666,
0.0041384185,
-0.4811045527,
0.3296452463,
-0.9834613204,
0.5258755088,
-0.2864664793,
0.0469839834,
-0.9132050872,
0.1382301152,
0.0776932985,
-0.2855470777,
0.1981117129,
-0.2781145275,
-0.2302296907,
0.0292328019,
0.1826480776,
0.372107923,
0.3769029677,
-0.0500397123,
0.5332786441,
0.7833750248,
-0.5363690853,
-0.6672549248,
-0.65027529,
-0.1644325703,
-0.0731720403,
-0.4086336493,
0.1903875917,
0.0575672761,
-0.4564450681,
-0.2141318172,
-0.1663610488,
-0.1698482782,
0.1371341795,
0.526334703,
-0.0884848833,
-0.2184480578,
0.0006413973,
0.0226835012,
-0.3140398562,
-0.0444440246,
-0.1880223751,
0.4484724998,
-0.231438145,
-0.194481343,
-0.5303152204,
0.4542798698,
0.2798634768,
-0.6788093448,
0.0617862567,
0.7573028207,
-0.7204913497,
0.0351928659,
-0.6704667211,
0.0665438697,
-0.375744611,
0.3965056539,
-0.4930593669,
-1.0976582766,
0.3499883413,
0.1205319166,
0.518492043,
0.1791871935,
0.3390742838,
-0.1748265624,
0.5711278915,
0.3011628091,
-0.2971537411,
0.1859815568,
-0.2011464387,
0.143874675,
-0.7948672175,
-0.2602375746,
-0.8090186715,
-0.1437882483,
-0.2993450761,
-0.807284534,
0.2353402525,
0.4087004066,
0.1110628694,
0.4721692502,
-0.3763798475,
0.1918040365,
0.4994042516,
-0.0590358041,
0.2019549012,
-0.2031498849,
0.1384114176,
-0.1186283678,
-0.3777058721,
-0.4173995256,
0.7375335097,
0.5331990123,
0.386687696,
-0.1022068411,
0.6912016869,
0.3647395372,
-0.0468842722,
-0.6569383144,
0.5470337272,
-0.1389004886,
-0.275939405,
-0.4215154946,
-0.2655989528,
-0.8346804976,
0.2621517181,
-0.0440970398,
-1.0146400928,
0.0809383914,
0.1895065159,
-0.1534773111,
-0.1699987799,
-0.8127716184,
0.8282385468,
-0.076381363,
0.052521117,
-0.5794692039,
-0.6559696794,
0.2590270936,
0.0514050908,
0.4884783626,
-0.5926855803,
-0.0316520371,
0.8551986814,
0.0898153931,
0.695345819,
-0.5773649812,
0.0491851717,
0.1840112358,
-0.0763662681,
0.4597522914,
0.0350777917,
-0.3958213627,
0.21497868,
0.2649280727,
-0.4651473761,
-0.3182743788,
0.6308152676,
-0.5363203287,
-0.286495924,
-0.3449341655,
-0.810039103,
-0.2488110065,
0.0507216714,
-0.0739724487,
0.6861585379,
-0.0374208428,
-0.0400451571,
0.66972363,
0.0322928317,
0.3298382461,
0.5868899226,
-0.0656614378,
-0.2216217071,
0.9506917596,
-0.0098679317,
0.2526069582,
0.4847847819,
-0.07596872,
-0.4804566503,
-1.0289084911,
-0.2129343599,
0.248027578,
-0.696598649,
0.1001427695,
-0.5818910599,
-0.1851571202,
-0.7690377235,
0.157459721,
-0.1607506722,
-0.4308082163,
-0.3664667904,
-0.1766542941,
0.0944905207,
0.9450390935,
-0.0054815621,
0.2822904289,
-0.4782980978,
0.4123268127,
0.3090736568,
-0.072969228,
-0.0678849518,
-0.5124183297,
-0.3098169565,
0.1133811101,
0.0275678858,
-0.8898844123,
-0.0525025986,
0.3117498457,
0.8662973642,
0.1136134639,
-0.1218006909,
0.7880450487,
-0.4557667971,
0.8248510957,
0.0562776513,
-1.2617077827,
0.8235875368,
-0.1984407753,
0.4691575468,
0.8409741521,
0.1780123562,
-0.7371332645,
-0.3658526242,
-0.3877935112,
-0.6140698195,
0.7235111594,
0.3105454147,
-0.200987801,
0.2544649839,
0.3978386819,
0.2495800704,
0.1683168262,
-0.5852070451,
-0.3966214061,
-0.2951873243,
-0.0546207093,
-0.370328784,
-0.2302708775,
-0.1074405238,
-0.2427737266,
0.6590178609,
-0.1625407636,
0.0559125058,
0.0597874075,
-0.6627604365,
0.1674585044,
0.4495654404,
0.6066784263,
0.8643743992,
-0.1133113876,
0.0698604882,
0.3723744154,
-0.4784763157,
-0.1261422783,
0.6468417048,
-0.3592067063,
0.1053509712,
0.3482744098,
1.2095491886,
0.598348856,
-0.8528667092,
0.2667645216,
0.0548083186,
-0.1460288018,
-0.2664928436,
0.0199909024,
0.2204875946,
0.3032214642,
0.4463879466,
-0.3531147838,
0.4186474681,
-0.3388501406,
0.2622847557,
0.2122885436,
-0.5815722942,
-0.3093136549,
0.635189116,
0.191477403,
-0.366927743,
0.4667847753,
-0.4117654264,
-0.3281032741,
0.3112948835,
0.4216348827,
0.5797141194,
-0.2563967109,
0.4116155505,
0.407456696,
0.331741631,
0.1849968433,
0.493114382,
-0.2229902148,
-0.4185581505,
-0.4807109833,
-0.5764926672,
-0.6414089799,
0.2542725801,
-1.0666507483,
0.0518820286,
-0.2032550275,
0.0527376868,
0.2537391186,
0.0910257995,
-0.6417995691,
0.2533590496,
0.4054307342,
0.7601303458,
-0.8937401175,
0.948928237,
0.5505280495,
-0.0568270236,
-0.6809905171,
-0.2879333794,
0.2813394666,
-0.9703361988,
0.2352713197,
0.2532373071,
0.0851215869,
0.1980543733,
-0.0519023538,
-0.6719656587,
1.1337686777,
0.3793494701,
-0.9072878361,
-0.0439573936,
0.3019098639,
0.2524098158,
-0.3231352568,
0.4229639769,
1.0521323681,
0.3074754775,
-0.0959301889,
-1.0629950762,
-0.0460063554,
-0.2197336555,
-0.1183870211,
0.1485022157,
-0.1784239858,
0.6444572806,
-0.1400385946,
-0.108768262,
0.1224713027,
0.8463885188,
0.4350149035,
0.7176960111,
0.9200052023,
0.6438816786,
1.0460447073,
-0.3991776705,
0.5435204506,
-0.0652638599,
0.2537081838,
1.5687736273,
-0.3811963201,
1.1101514101,
0.2399590313,
-0.2137738764,
0.3020244539,
0.5801855922,
0.10024257,
0.4281659126,
0.3663642108,
-0.3412270546,
0.0041983621,
-0.625423491,
-0.3637110591,
0.4510174096,
0.5028935075,
-0.0432568975,
-0.0962595269,
0.0766740143,
-0.0699776635,
-0.0408389382,
-0.3322962523,
0.7938454151,
0.0677303746,
-0.6110216379,
0.4851796031,
-0.3189172149,
0.3066253364,
-0.6956853867,
0.1686156392,
-0.1712880731,
-0.1944654584,
-0.2197898179,
-0.8426746726,
0.0938916504,
0.0668355003,
0.0109502478,
-0.3503318727,
0.7649786472,
-0.5079694986,
-0.4080760777,
0.3736828268,
0.4534098506,
0.6257247925,
-0.0985243842,
-0.7628312111,
0.3924883902,
0.0897693262,
0.1207373068,
0.1307698339,
-0.0163163412,
0.1454548687,
0.4771007299,
0.357231617,
0.1156767011,
0.2324515432,
0.7707969546,
0.5044021606,
-0.4032788873,
-0.3277474642,
-0.0618810765,
0.616663754,
-0.1612772495,
-0.391479671,
0.4163841307,
0.6769231558,
0.6983041763,
0.2506457865,
0.834191978,
0.0522347204,
0.8666741252,
-0.4151196182,
0.442062825,
-0.4156383276,
-0.0459672697,
-0.2674005032,
-0.6558346152,
0.1467231959,
0.4295548797,
-0.0662737563,
-0.3117263019,
0.6207496524,
0.7711664438,
0.1761416793,
0.4864057004,
0.1938532889,
0.1909983009,
0.0976604745,
0.545507431,
0.5049930215,
-0.4601269662,
0.3982871771,
-0.6033473611,
-0.2275918275,
0.1841419935,
-0.6649672985,
-0.6911622882,
-0.8920788169,
-0.4166110754,
-0.0731162727,
0.1710966527,
0.5454469919,
0.9835861325,
-1.0229923725,
-0.5089462996,
0.0035522454,
-0.0542197116,
-0.3790329695,
-0.1714151055,
0.1256615222,
-0.3359172642,
-0.757425189,
0.7933536172,
0.1876114905,
-0.1326307803,
-0.2379144579,
-0.2082958072,
-0.1347886026,
-0.4148706496,
0.5281584859,
0.4257868528,
-1.0760455132,
-0.1591591239,
0.0456329547,
0.2346562296,
-0.1066953093,
1.0494320393,
-0.6803447604,
0.4402165413,
0.4756235182,
0.7437791824,
0.9899536967,
-0.0988077819,
0.3824088573,
-0.6674857736,
0.272564292,
0.4341711104,
0.5131191015,
0.4283709824,
-0.0964655578,
0.5762737393,
-0.0368715972,
-0.6165761948,
-0.960806191,
0.1027356088,
-1.4052764177,
0.1019326225,
0.923325479,
-0.37915048,
0.2945687771,
-0.2705093026,
0.0913310051,
0.4220699966,
-0.3312629759,
0.0092251701,
0.5595199466,
-0.2612337172,
-0.5410003066,
-0.9623684287,
0.3009341359,
0.6428707242,
-1.0802205801,
0.2552036047,
0.3559508622,
0.2315345556,
-0.0626438484,
0.7013962269,
0.14529562,
0.2007461339,
-0.1401778907,
-0.211853385,
0.0314855427,
-0.2474608719,
-0.5222911239,
-0.015485662,
0.1956766993,
-0.2423957586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10522v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10522v2 | Transformers Go for the LOLs: Generating (Humourous) Titles from Scientific Abstracts End-to-End | 2022-12-20T18:37:11 | 2023-12-26T18:05:42 | Yanran Chen, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL | We consider the end-to-end abstract-to-title generation problem, exploring
seven recent transformer based models (including ChatGPT) fine-tuned on more
than 30k abstract-title pairs from NLP and machine learning (ML) venues. As an
extension, we also consider the harder problem of generating humorous paper
titles. For the latter, we compile the first large-scale humor annotated
dataset for scientific papers in the NLP/ML domains, comprising almost ~2.6k
titles. We evaluate all models using human and automatic metrics. Our human
evaluation suggests that our best end-to-end system performs similarly to human
authors (but arguably slightly worse). Generating funny titles is more
difficult, however, and our automatic systems clearly underperform relative to
humans and often learn dataset artefacts of humor. Finally, ChatGPT, without
any fine-tuning, performs on the level of our best fine-tuned system. | [
-0.2984773219,
-0.2878548801,
0.5177765489,
0.2138622254,
-0.4765247405,
0.1162632406,
-0.1218551248,
-0.359988153,
0.2178798616,
0.4699071944,
-0.2843571603,
-0.175941065,
-0.8896685243,
0.4956027567,
-0.8779798746,
1.7899917364,
0.633053422,
-0.2239062488,
-0.3459605873,
0.1304023266,
0.2457057834,
-0.1871794611,
-0.7375947237,
-0.4791772664,
0.947000742,
0.2114493549,
1.1968258619,
0.5289120078,
0.9221438766,
0.2571049631,
-0.2848415673,
0.0863087848,
-0.4459664822,
-0.0829070956,
-0.4082489014,
-0.3175619841,
-0.4196524918,
-0.1503379643,
0.1338107735,
0.8194128871,
-0.2157515734,
0.3340815008,
-0.4874820113,
0.7831706405,
-0.2984034717,
0.0426217653,
-0.6636871099,
0.4953645766,
-0.0126809664,
-0.5184048414,
-0.7278903127,
-0.3593484461,
0.3035327196,
-0.4700867832,
0.385137558,
0.3668950498,
0.8911302686,
0.545552671,
-0.1956088245,
-0.5151557922,
-0.8209891915,
0.7428569198,
-0.8649243116,
-0.1004818082,
-0.1795801669,
0.3683835268,
-0.1482291669,
-1.2416100502,
-0.5456851721,
-0.1430815905,
-0.0099294716,
0.380233705,
-0.6925371289,
-0.1970850229,
0.3444207609,
0.3543016016,
-0.6642389297,
-0.1672821641,
-0.7763085961,
0.2071947753,
0.9028410912,
0.0978790969,
0.3532243967,
-0.1152001843,
-0.1549433172,
-0.1061359197,
-0.6838955879,
-0.1152751818,
0.7270428538,
0.1851783246,
-0.0582908727,
0.9059034586,
-0.0270924475,
0.4300050735,
-0.0016004484,
-0.004282556,
0.1031232476,
-0.0420977958,
-0.13878645,
0.2744111121,
0.9881719947,
0.4898785353,
0.6560325027,
-0.7759391069,
-0.0613646172,
-0.2223114222,
0.5363025069,
-0.6321642399,
-0.5432241559,
0.1702413857,
-0.3182267249,
-0.7367265224,
-0.1158252507,
-0.6295759678,
-0.3527889848,
-0.3883453012,
0.4098607004,
-0.5342720151,
-0.0105361333,
0.3828671277,
-0.4472911358,
0.3690980077,
0.1181714982,
-0.6841185689,
0.0269337874,
0.5931224823,
0.8642017841,
-0.3057079017,
-0.0871813148,
-0.4439222217,
0.2589470744,
-0.193699494,
1.1509016752,
-0.3727408648,
-0.512752533,
-0.3677933216,
-0.0721367747,
0.1467238665,
-0.4213315845,
0.6951515079,
-0.565256536,
0.4605449736,
0.1157268658,
-0.2794494927,
0.1564210206,
-0.0685845986,
-0.4590873122,
0.7846539021,
0.0844101608,
-1.1294941902,
0.0687811002,
-0.9913265705,
-0.7458546162,
-0.1138548404,
0.1228426546,
-0.4194342792,
0.4332171082,
0.0626237541,
0.2582625151,
-0.426799953,
0.5501672626,
0.2467646599,
-0.0194840971,
0.4757989943,
-0.284088701,
0.5977841616,
0.5083938837,
-0.2760021985,
0.0172499493,
-0.5874649286,
-0.1574453712,
0.2429305315,
-0.08696343,
0.0766782984,
0.3754616082,
-0.1349192113,
0.3167365789,
0.2360289693,
-0.6252390742,
-0.1108473912,
-0.5295870304,
0.5235128999,
0.6409645677,
-0.3135270476,
0.0179749317,
-0.4585555196,
0.4462351799,
0.1548384279,
0.150387764,
-0.2853316963,
-0.8717420101,
-0.8553962708,
0.0893808827,
0.2622543275,
0.5268883705,
-0.8039016128,
0.4232070446,
-0.526956141,
-0.8283327818,
-0.3031045794,
-0.3040930033,
0.3628949523,
0.6813977361,
0.4818608463,
-0.267527312,
-0.3803216815,
-1.1652384996,
-0.5503134131,
-0.1942052245,
-0.32651636,
0.4173080623,
0.5324104428,
0.1446322799,
1.1693382263,
-0.5324258804,
0.023956839,
-0.1355215758,
0.4082850218,
0.4570509195,
0.0174965821,
0.4204293191,
-0.9852477312,
-0.4897929728,
0.1333526224,
-0.9094055891,
-0.1153310984,
0.2021500021,
0.3087003529,
0.3328588605,
0.5311662555,
-0.5711304545,
0.1124608293,
0.3698858619,
-0.4106006324,
1.0173110962,
-0.2368408591,
-0.1366048604,
-0.9852257371,
0.3375250399,
-0.0642231032,
-0.2788275182,
-0.3605212867,
-0.1611504704,
-0.585314393,
-0.4516263902,
-0.6431405544,
0.4765388072,
-0.1308742166,
-0.0672366843,
-0.0503565371,
0.1011509672,
-0.3739752173,
0.2985168397,
0.0812804028,
0.5227438807,
0.6329667568,
-0.5214360952,
0.5390169621,
0.0898702145,
0.0215100423,
0.5987795591,
-0.8487716317,
-0.0406292602,
-0.3787895143,
0.3880791366,
-1.0336081982,
-0.4379641414,
-0.1947962195,
-0.6436547637,
0.0713841021,
0.2194782346,
-0.6001010537,
-0.5547252893,
-0.1570737958,
0.1379057616,
0.9415496588,
-0.5062968135,
0.3954763412,
0.3398305476,
-0.5212355852,
-0.6245715022,
-0.6503145695,
0.5066100955,
-0.4812990427,
-0.6719735265,
0.3623236716,
-0.1331223249,
-0.169451803,
0.1898330748,
-0.0200465918,
0.3201698661,
-0.4341804087,
0.0290585831,
-0.2855346501,
-0.3467962146,
-0.1243527308,
-0.0354414582,
-0.3893426061,
0.2635113001,
-0.0215774346,
0.4445949495,
-0.2596568763,
-0.2534458041,
-0.2236353755,
0.2233128995,
0.6255958676,
0.0597445592,
0.4354870021,
0.5719799995,
0.0038193862,
-0.1127650663,
-0.2029895037,
-0.1733728349,
-0.4968132079,
0.4271969497,
0.0177749805,
-0.6884139776,
0.4466094375,
-0.1376706213,
0.2711980045,
0.7098898888,
0.5418122411,
-0.2576459348,
1.1546906233,
0.7993024588,
0.2487820089,
-0.080176644,
-0.0357003547,
0.8599259257,
-0.4746280909,
-0.2618000209,
-0.616122365,
-0.7503607869,
-0.559520781,
-0.3516282439,
0.58075279,
-0.2040030062,
-0.2171494365,
0.45515728,
-0.8634842634,
0.6999027729,
0.3298686743,
-0.1147078946,
0.669305861,
0.3138089776,
0.128479749,
-0.0525997542,
-0.6617122293,
-0.6047038436,
1.0951453447,
0.3169419765,
0.824177444,
0.1295829117,
0.5564100742,
0.473892957,
0.5699445605,
-0.6751729846,
0.6972343326,
-0.6701318622,
-0.3047231138,
-0.2137382179,
-0.3051998913,
-0.8387278318,
-0.2642211914,
0.3501972854,
-0.7301092148,
-0.2657063603,
0.1228081658,
-0.375105381,
0.6014403105,
-0.4604479373,
0.6040854454,
-0.0882460177,
-0.1063662842,
-0.0027994679,
-1.1646031141,
0.6423863173,
-0.0527124554,
0.3072807491,
0.0323178768,
-0.0849791169,
0.9714377522,
-0.1108628735,
0.6182073951,
0.1182766408,
-0.3515954912,
0.2593315542,
-0.0036109854,
0.245457828,
0.1140472442,
-0.1463115513,
-0.0471065342,
-0.2232451737,
-0.2054029107,
-0.421639502,
0.512560606,
-0.6852529645,
-0.5196918249,
-0.4124791026,
-0.7026218772,
0.0331777036,
-0.1697574705,
0.8406428099,
0.1798126251,
0.1057056263,
0.4353329241,
0.7145688534,
-0.524325192,
0.5974251628,
0.2367453426,
-0.2433061451,
-0.152052328,
1.1854997873,
-0.2427745461,
0.2132868022,
0.2386562228,
0.2899641097,
-0.3366830945,
-0.2820054889,
-0.4355393648,
0.2366034091,
-0.6158276796,
-0.4319761693,
-1.1961557865,
-0.7546204329,
-0.305067569,
-0.3409280777,
-0.6131933331,
-0.7359217405,
-0.1103719845,
0.2859057784,
0.5437010527,
0.6299368739,
-0.1785017401,
0.5838358998,
-0.5867549181,
0.3947300911,
0.1926426291,
0.2063593715,
-0.0807634145,
-0.8439435363,
-0.1640551537,
-0.1702639759,
-0.8372419477,
-0.5442174077,
0.5060568452,
0.3947334588,
0.123470515,
0.3818082213,
0.1303811371,
0.1385049522,
-0.7632681727,
1.0721896887,
0.45955199,
-0.4130256772,
0.4326614439,
-0.4705803692,
-0.0239591487,
0.0247119144,
0.3869400322,
-0.4538149834,
-0.595903933,
-1.1290420294,
-1.2124494314,
0.6976727247,
0.4523847699,
0.4073649943,
-0.3173157871,
0.0284305941,
0.2837440073,
0.3051261604,
-0.8927643895,
-0.3929369152,
-0.1939884573,
-0.186726436,
0.0613836795,
0.1358910948,
-0.2252996415,
-0.0048889364,
0.8736198545,
-0.2543828189,
0.5601952672,
0.2802373767,
0.1706549525,
-0.1666733623,
0.388010174,
0.9071438313,
0.4838248789,
-0.3404868543,
0.1822413951,
-0.1617370397,
-0.330604732,
-0.1855830997,
-0.0500129983,
-0.0066061383,
0.4001804888,
0.1755084097,
0.6885841489,
0.2006774694,
-0.9367728829,
0.387827754,
0.0626678243,
-0.1854870468,
-0.448759824,
0.1582152843,
0.2826884687,
0.1002138928,
0.4740801156,
0.1658263206,
0.2432373911,
-0.3880305886,
0.3614526093,
0.3784130514,
-0.2772957087,
-0.6276606321,
0.8706709146,
0.0462755598,
-0.7322639823,
0.3410284221,
-0.3890411556,
-0.3686052561,
0.8750604987,
0.7960975766,
0.8625321984,
-0.0685822964,
0.5145561099,
0.3018966019,
0.1974289715,
-0.1578932852,
-0.0334180705,
0.2865421176,
-0.3117600679,
-0.4584868848,
-0.9672677517,
-0.725133419,
0.1905120313,
-0.3424786925,
0.6283287406,
-0.0273884814,
0.0011685275,
0.3342161179,
-0.4995269477,
-0.3834382296,
0.1869994551,
0.1559078246,
0.8199253678,
-0.8230715394,
0.3536232114,
0.795104444,
-0.3119948506,
-0.3365768492,
-0.366253376,
-0.297966063,
-0.5732238889,
0.7658029199,
0.0120717622,
0.0105194105,
0.3223960102,
-0.9112232327,
-0.6821297407,
0.8341595531,
0.3778278232,
-0.2553938627,
-0.6177361012,
0.642843008,
0.8528259397,
-0.3841475248,
0.4468154609,
0.5708952546,
0.5409923792,
0.3835333586,
-0.9350941777,
-0.3631297648,
-0.3033830523,
-0.3304851651,
0.0755590349,
-0.5966760516,
0.832388103,
-0.6630260944,
-0.0201935079,
0.1793324649,
0.670812726,
0.5142740011,
0.590084672,
0.2935745716,
0.8693087101,
0.1360244602,
-0.1710595936,
1.2541191578,
-0.255332619,
0.5292325616,
0.9712383747,
-0.1723579317,
0.4939536154,
0.6975389123,
-0.4119871557,
0.3433974683,
0.5193517804,
-0.228681922,
0.4639599919,
0.4599051178,
-0.001339747,
-0.0730591863,
-0.1569292247,
-0.5212670565,
0.3781977296,
0.3969356716,
-0.4701259732,
-0.8608374596,
-0.1144746393,
0.1492895931,
-0.0808991045,
0.1235500127,
0.7188251019,
0.3155589402,
-0.6467217803,
0.1948888004,
-0.1072305143,
0.8917412758,
-0.3747286201,
0.2913758159,
-0.3435570002,
-0.113619864,
-0.3524406254,
-0.9132170677,
0.4501629174,
0.2688059807,
-0.2430215776,
-0.0208583288,
0.4244358242,
-0.2597916424,
-0.6854969263,
0.0388263166,
0.4339748025,
0.712584734,
0.1874942482,
-0.5726461411,
-0.6624748111,
-0.0452070087,
-0.5924987793,
0.2938901782,
0.6519041061,
0.1034613401,
0.6408424973,
0.7207646966,
0.1649966985,
0.1347225904,
-0.1439485997,
0.690241158,
-0.7411070466,
-0.3689057827,
-0.9430596232,
0.6769149899,
-0.2427735031,
-0.399484992,
0.3665905595,
0.8321640491,
0.44290483,
-0.5346248746,
0.7324886918,
-0.4263818264,
0.347597003,
-0.3343183398,
1.0272401571,
-0.802559793,
0.1580194682,
-0.2972832024,
-1.049672842,
-0.4975182414,
0.1960807145,
-0.0274350345,
0.0467768461,
0.8154399991,
0.641602397,
-0.4926508665,
0.2171007246,
0.4261232913,
0.1199899837,
0.6051680446,
0.5694443583,
0.701677978,
-0.4651509523,
0.6700907946,
-0.308640331,
0.0366302989,
-0.2561855614,
-1.4541313648,
-0.6201528907,
-0.5013180971,
-0.5925659537,
-0.3090378642,
-0.0966813788,
0.4319540262,
0.4072163999,
-0.6836262345,
-0.0010672094,
-0.071110554,
0.0292178243,
0.1011383533,
-0.3176659048,
0.6588808298,
-0.7495440245,
-0.7219439149,
0.1524370909,
0.4866275489,
-0.2823606431,
-0.0614269637,
-0.0465815216,
0.0618763976,
0.2821977437,
0.8575594425,
0.4445216954,
-0.7253115773,
-0.2732440233,
0.0965665728,
0.0719747096,
0.0993674994,
0.7503336072,
-0.7840643525,
0.0618925057,
0.295683533,
0.5832977891,
0.0993617997,
-0.114092581,
0.3758971393,
-0.8652628064,
0.0779580772,
0.4801002443,
0.1825874001,
0.4498412013,
-0.2593009174,
0.9422677159,
0.2488908768,
-0.8674975634,
-1.3006778955,
0.0137586668,
-1.219892621,
-0.0482898355,
1.0819622278,
0.0979038998,
-0.2931554914,
0.040937975,
0.0122314971,
0.3995810151,
-0.2247091085,
1.1680259705,
0.6022844911,
-0.6206438541,
-0.0901962891,
-0.8127753735,
0.6988993883,
0.5363054872,
-0.9236701131,
0.0969429165,
0.0042012273,
0.2178044617,
0.8678638935,
0.2017515451,
-0.4322237968,
0.3898272812,
-0.2878071368,
0.2602591217,
0.0469331592,
-0.3554361463,
0.2033732831,
0.1644452065,
-0.2044687122,
0.4452106953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10711v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10711v1 | Task Ambiguity in Humans and Language Models | 2022-12-20T18:35:33 | 2022-12-20T18:35:33 | Alex Tamkin, Kunal Handa, Avash Shrestha, Noah Goodman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models have recently achieved strong performance across a wide range
of NLP benchmarks. However, unlike benchmarks, real world tasks are often
poorly specified, and agents must deduce the user's intended behavior from a
combination of context, instructions, and examples. We investigate how both
humans and models behave in the face of such task ambiguity by proposing
AmbiBench, a new benchmark of six ambiguously-specified classification tasks.
We evaluate humans and models on AmbiBench by seeing how well they identify the
intended task using 1) instructions with varying degrees of ambiguity, and 2)
different numbers of labeled examples. We find that the combination of model
scaling (to 175B parameters) and training with human feedback data enables
models to approach or exceed the accuracy of human participants across tasks,
but that either one alone is not sufficient. In addition, we show how to
dramatically improve the accuracy of language models trained without
large-scale human feedback training by finetuning on a small number of
ambiguous in-context examples, providing a promising direction for teaching
models to generalize well in the face of ambiguity. | [
-0.2134222984,
-0.7321802974,
0.3185646534,
0.4179852605,
-0.0321903117,
-0.0122523867,
-0.369736284,
-0.9665720463,
-0.3564844429,
0.1422575563,
-0.6835185289,
-0.133855477,
-0.8095892072,
0.1159363687,
-0.4915652275,
0.6027563214,
-0.1299167573,
0.1430026144,
-0.1096728221,
-0.1664693803,
-0.6090946794,
-0.4471388459,
-0.4283441305,
-0.6918380857,
0.492972225,
0.3095071912,
1.1607637405,
0.5953862071,
0.4661141932,
0.3138934672,
-0.1288104802,
0.2571038604,
-0.2081092447,
0.1805512905,
-0.4417216182,
-0.5654255152,
-0.3597385585,
0.2147330791,
0.5455541611,
1.2394855022,
-0.2090024352,
0.3335056603,
0.1503564715,
0.3886971176,
-0.8456286788,
0.1344606876,
-0.3013787568,
-0.0538447499,
-0.207165584,
0.1569060981,
-0.3658420742,
0.2716039121,
0.2212670445,
-0.4714190364,
0.3499248028,
0.3032580316,
0.9457150698,
0.3858607113,
-0.456923306,
-0.2644316554,
-0.8023400307,
0.9071364999,
-0.8069137931,
0.4740583003,
0.5020240545,
0.2463137805,
-0.3449166417,
-0.5052182674,
-0.4728206396,
-0.0773871988,
-0.1018645614,
-0.2993112504,
-0.303448081,
0.1641332209,
0.6076914072,
-0.0563619956,
-0.4018229544,
0.3007885516,
-0.3414862752,
-0.0451556407,
0.6422793865,
0.2801624537,
0.080985412,
-0.3764753938,
-0.2005280405,
-0.110776417,
-0.3709760606,
0.2938036025,
0.4995671511,
0.4534069002,
-0.0602286756,
0.5704780221,
-0.4629893303,
1.119648695,
-0.0244542528,
0.3499167264,
0.2317793369,
-0.005954029,
-0.1842969358,
-0.2078187019,
0.5509442687,
0.4268759489,
0.164091602,
-0.4161176383,
-0.3342565596,
0.1424907595,
0.7587302327,
-0.4775624871,
-0.0663890019,
0.2867577076,
-0.4350547493,
-0.1444476843,
-0.0725959241,
-0.5912953019,
-0.4429306388,
-0.5868347883,
0.5942350626,
-0.0829727799,
-0.170054853,
0.277479887,
-0.0962170139,
0.1072305217,
0.6348655224,
-1.0872737169,
0.6589871645,
0.6664596796,
0.3821744323,
-0.0678979233,
-0.6532334089,
-0.5154827833,
0.001305057,
-0.2060383409,
0.4360742867,
-0.7470525503,
-0.3762432039,
-0.1429116726,
-0.0561451726,
-0.07938952,
-0.7121741176,
0.5557453036,
-0.313823849,
0.1107004508,
-0.408179462,
-0.594529748,
-0.2501948178,
0.238914445,
-0.4180716872,
1.1162383556,
0.2796194255,
-0.6340441108,
0.3753928244,
-0.6763976216,
-0.3217781186,
0.1255344898,
-0.2235580385,
-0.2025780976,
0.2882025838,
0.0440073796,
0.5443592072,
-0.5265063047,
0.3498319983,
-0.2395399809,
-0.6246551871,
0.3067246079,
-0.4668830037,
0.8076749444,
0.047579173,
-0.4685269892,
0.0657796189,
-0.6342153549,
0.3019156754,
-0.0497727059,
-0.4723885953,
-0.380035013,
0.1511996686,
0.217500478,
0.2543287575,
0.1880419999,
-0.46505481,
0.2459695339,
-0.4049353898,
0.4448823929,
0.4245091677,
-0.3332788944,
0.3470353484,
-0.4833197296,
0.5300917625,
-0.1179931685,
0.1094848961,
0.3488679528,
-0.6979236007,
-0.6711488366,
0.1742224693,
0.5448688865,
0.6101564765,
-0.2543819249,
0.4836108685,
-0.2846990824,
-0.5123636723,
-0.7831658125,
0.3501079082,
0.4386264682,
0.3664013743,
0.5371925235,
-0.4216918945,
-0.5449666977,
-0.9194664955,
-0.6008090973,
-0.4369805455,
-0.3231085837,
0.1636597663,
0.6999163032,
-0.3666801751,
1.0341062546,
-0.1794024408,
0.1087737754,
-0.0470303781,
0.7084621787,
-0.0643857419,
0.6029164195,
0.3103152514,
-1.0996701717,
-0.1627556384,
-0.1802739054,
-0.508428216,
-0.1280280799,
-0.1031053364,
0.0484957881,
-0.1474862695,
0.3600026071,
-0.6019372344,
0.4908713996,
0.3627220094,
-0.258053571,
0.6151420474,
-0.3147701621,
0.1897208989,
-0.7241711617,
0.0400022492,
-0.0577203594,
-0.2758433223,
-0.8221442103,
0.1130243093,
0.4204846621,
0.0342815891,
-0.3823464513,
0.8074879646,
-0.3701426387,
0.0481308997,
-0.3692859113,
-0.1002162918,
-0.0270726532,
0.5379392505,
0.0542285964,
0.3679627776,
0.4064184129,
-0.5491957068,
0.3407679498,
0.2482889593,
-0.3814925253,
0.628696084,
-0.5570385456,
0.0430741832,
-0.0499454141,
-0.0442951545,
-0.8788237572,
-0.4463612437,
0.346863389,
-0.3898867369,
0.4108953774,
0.0532039404,
-0.5273718834,
-0.5994740129,
0.2368377894,
0.5270508528,
0.4219341874,
-0.3861334622,
0.6198604107,
-0.0732089505,
0.1183684245,
-0.9724379182,
-0.6630783677,
0.1145198643,
-0.1990599334,
-0.4724635482,
0.452164948,
0.0012181386,
-0.3223593235,
0.0638878495,
-0.3238630891,
-0.2798365355,
0.359821856,
0.6942250729,
0.0326066464,
0.080608204,
0.2467404902,
-0.3066339493,
0.0764032081,
0.0380876586,
0.0646119192,
0.2476991862,
-0.2257361114,
-0.7454568148,
-0.4048880935,
0.3464734554,
0.2860737443,
-0.1608096659,
0.5247158408,
0.6181224585,
-0.5397693515,
-0.1503967643,
-0.6047381163,
-0.1506628841,
-0.4797218442,
0.480094254,
-0.4524181485,
-0.6525700092,
0.5976810455,
-0.1376922429,
0.1145459861,
0.2445374727,
0.4486286044,
-0.3471685052,
1.1907333136,
0.5377186537,
0.1069789082,
0.2480738461,
0.1316531152,
0.1718787104,
-0.6927827001,
-0.0664303154,
-0.6784924865,
-0.6924281716,
-0.4609621167,
-0.5413285494,
-0.0827991366,
0.2581290305,
-0.1607237011,
0.4522686899,
-0.3459860086,
0.385751307,
0.7745268941,
0.1635457277,
0.1241051927,
-0.2949899435,
0.0244693756,
-0.1062395647,
-0.5402063727,
-0.5673696399,
0.9720215797,
0.2413448691,
0.7858454585,
0.1898605525,
0.5849258304,
0.4691842794,
0.2448810935,
-0.6118754745,
0.2935231924,
-0.0330468453,
-1.1039770842,
-0.4745559096,
-0.2466177642,
-1.1876889467,
0.5761678219,
-0.3557060957,
-0.8442879915,
0.3117468357,
0.3178060949,
-0.3967343867,
0.0790395588,
-0.9536216259,
1.1833034754,
-0.2729510665,
-0.3938697875,
-0.1052976176,
-1.0300118923,
0.0718152523,
0.0365318917,
0.4207713604,
-0.403708607,
-0.1968565881,
0.5793015957,
-0.1813797206,
1.0837991238,
-0.1705471873,
0.0330616012,
0.1054205149,
0.1121945679,
0.6006845832,
-0.3813012242,
-0.3017846644,
0.0759157762,
-0.0363950245,
-0.7394638062,
-0.7198619246,
0.1706403792,
-0.694629848,
-0.7293650508,
-0.1416105032,
-0.7475482821,
-0.4668287039,
0.0994235799,
0.1758807749,
0.4395359457,
-0.0827521607,
-0.0406132713,
0.1794112772,
0.1279513091,
0.2430969626,
0.7109848261,
0.1367052048,
0.3977654576,
0.6656825542,
-0.0465362407,
0.3249809742,
0.3623790145,
-0.0437079519,
-0.2173050344,
-0.6360863447,
-0.467628926,
0.0814646035,
-0.8573164344,
0.0522108823,
-0.4565950036,
-0.0015849507,
-0.2951381505,
-0.1062320843,
-0.3274519444,
-0.219993785,
-0.3567237258,
0.1745935977,
-0.1951363385,
0.9315259457,
0.0347057171,
0.4741311073,
-0.6498249769,
0.2336622924,
0.3515135348,
0.2787280083,
0.0823587105,
-0.5618272424,
-0.2319772989,
0.2596802711,
-0.1892575622,
-1.0652030706,
0.1736849546,
0.1357068568,
0.7577362061,
0.2547599375,
0.2351626158,
0.7603403926,
-0.5753544569,
0.5202636123,
0.0279388614,
-1.0436205864,
0.344982177,
-0.2246206254,
0.6161783338,
0.458619684,
0.4048779011,
-0.8508213758,
-0.6132035851,
-0.6320217848,
-0.7608178258,
0.8588783741,
0.2903989255,
0.1868161559,
0.1433299929,
0.5061447024,
0.0914896429,
0.3443001509,
-0.7713464499,
-0.2361271232,
0.0314327329,
-0.1518727094,
-0.09186358,
-0.2317920923,
-0.1078068018,
-0.2496469915,
0.3843624294,
0.0653726682,
0.1296205223,
-0.0281495526,
-0.3835514188,
-0.3245137632,
0.5215458274,
0.5665249825,
0.7795504332,
-0.3081280291,
0.3505352139,
0.2943934202,
-0.0966996253,
0.3661336899,
0.2217536271,
0.1368428767,
-0.1500908434,
0.5958667397,
0.7785345912,
0.6241311431,
-0.8939762115,
0.417550385,
0.0214580148,
-0.3005180657,
0.0476441085,
0.3668172359,
0.1854793131,
0.3930117488,
0.339464426,
0.4831056893,
0.3591579199,
-0.2429555953,
0.0679122731,
0.2842956185,
-0.5437797308,
-0.2501010597,
0.8143588305,
0.2987198234,
-0.5806246996,
0.6984753013,
-0.4712548852,
-0.422136873,
0.5927611589,
0.22921215,
0.4660767317,
-0.3880617917,
0.0632786527,
0.1905517429,
0.4596060216,
-0.2959980369,
0.2292196453,
-0.1731953621,
-0.7965199947,
-0.3836317658,
-0.4954167604,
-0.6187990904,
-0.1579619199,
-0.936578989,
0.1716948301,
-0.0358323678,
-0.3878460824,
0.4791214168,
-0.0381605849,
-0.7434079051,
0.2561742067,
0.1783395708,
0.7326638103,
-0.9715307355,
0.776712656,
0.9133034945,
-0.1298136562,
-0.6742779613,
-0.1310377717,
0.1233174801,
-0.7026042342,
0.7070966959,
0.3399970531,
-0.0311920028,
-0.0804295316,
-0.3869437575,
-0.6225556135,
0.6079796553,
0.4515551627,
-0.4355480671,
-0.3921335936,
0.1549230665,
0.5931413174,
-0.2521952689,
0.1260598302,
0.5470689535,
0.6057061553,
-0.0726979226,
-1.2410778999,
0.0839307681,
-0.3787242472,
0.05261904,
0.2249037325,
-0.2746316195,
0.8526331186,
-0.3308878243,
-0.1959668696,
0.0540133789,
0.4751209915,
-0.2501322031,
-0.0052992688,
0.7837216854,
0.3090452552,
0.9967561364,
-0.1232135817,
1.108884573,
0.2783739865,
0.2473624796,
1.4719690084,
-0.2505795658,
0.9954170585,
0.3556363881,
-0.5119422078,
0.3949294686,
0.9601095915,
-0.131515637,
0.1065020338,
0.3465020359,
-0.1171378344,
-0.7466577888,
0.0478116199,
-0.1450383067,
0.5285803676,
0.5415302515,
-0.0890214518,
-0.4305866361,
0.115188092,
-0.3536067307,
0.1522325426,
-0.0579778925,
0.3167603016,
-0.2236773819,
-0.8129827976,
0.6802188158,
0.3396173418,
0.6466580629,
-0.427767992,
0.032815244,
0.3484062254,
0.0637081265,
-0.1988025904,
-0.6062760353,
0.1060682312,
-0.3053565919,
-0.3903469443,
-0.2424093932,
0.4137308896,
-0.4404675066,
-0.2893233895,
0.3255060315,
0.4803967476,
0.2997745574,
-0.1802879721,
-0.9811064005,
-0.1023855358,
0.000730488,
-0.1878718585,
0.1270889044,
0.0716968104,
-0.2321430892,
0.8195208311,
0.1455706507,
-0.099733144,
0.333548665,
-0.0161383729,
0.3560777307,
-0.5801070929,
-0.1884134114,
-0.7585456967,
0.3562837839,
0.0049557737,
-0.396530807,
0.5997497439,
0.270853579,
0.8144729733,
-0.0088379281,
0.5182536244,
-0.2098976076,
0.6448613405,
-0.1116405129,
0.2086849213,
-0.7959680557,
0.1887795031,
0.0003275535,
-0.7566777468,
-0.32185179,
0.5755360723,
-0.4459283352,
0.2817938328,
0.6321179271,
0.6413758397,
-0.1285663396,
0.2124459445,
0.3555980623,
0.0360380076,
0.0900750533,
0.472102046,
0.9061356187,
-0.301607579,
0.4236363769,
-0.3606409132,
0.0152018424,
-0.4914764762,
-0.7261040211,
-0.8444347978,
-0.660795927,
-0.39147982,
0.0454281196,
0.0922450498,
1.0656750202,
1.0855565071,
-0.762537241,
-0.4057176411,
0.0608493313,
0.159807384,
-0.6281627417,
-0.1449635774,
0.0799659491,
-0.5826004148,
-1.0296218395,
0.2514474392,
-0.0586266592,
0.2908872366,
-0.1124477759,
-0.1611714214,
-0.3732000589,
-0.1088244915,
0.0825640038,
0.3304369152,
-1.0854378939,
-0.4229987264,
-0.1750415862,
-0.1703845263,
-0.0481177531,
0.6935924888,
-0.4648995697,
0.7097049356,
0.2141687125,
0.6330570579,
0.3857809305,
0.1744004339,
0.8090488315,
-1.0674732924,
0.28359285,
0.2311349064,
0.1473221928,
0.3258925676,
-0.2830649912,
0.576898098,
-0.0332753174,
-0.4622267783,
-0.9123805165,
0.2196544111,
-0.8291031122,
-0.5685311556,
0.8380228281,
-0.1371751577,
-0.1484043747,
-0.434713155,
-0.1262193322,
0.138365835,
-0.2473300099,
0.7739071846,
1.1475188732,
-0.3575251102,
0.0897891298,
-0.8714940548,
0.4891271591,
0.8209150434,
-0.5000847578,
0.4108488858,
0.3694623113,
0.1018131152,
0.1848535389,
0.2421764284,
0.4042896032,
0.5262711644,
0.1075975969,
0.2084748,
0.1019248143,
-0.0440373123,
-0.1802883595,
0.1356338263,
0.455662936,
-0.0286601298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10520v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10520v3 | Privacy-Preserving Domain Adaptation of Semantic Parsers | 2022-12-20T18:35:21 | 2023-06-08T18:03:43 | Fatemehsadat Mireshghallah, Yu Su, Tatsunori Hashimoto, Jason Eisner, Richard Shin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Task-oriented dialogue systems often assist users with personal or
confidential matters. For this reason, the developers of such a system are
generally prohibited from observing actual usage. So how can they know where
the system is failing and needs more training data or new functionality? In
this work, we study ways in which realistic user utterances can be generated
synthetically, to help increase the linguistic and functional coverage of the
system, without compromising the privacy of actual users. To this end, we
propose a two-stage Differentially Private (DP) generation method which first
generates latent semantic parses, and then generates utterances based on the
parses. Our proposed approach improves MAUVE by 2.5$\times$ and parse tree
function type overlap by 1.3$\times$ relative to current approaches for private
synthetic data generation, improving both on fluency and semantic coverage. We
further validate our approach on a realistic domain adaptation task of adding
new functionality from private user data to a semantic parser, and show overall
gains of 8.5% points in accuracy with the new feature. | [
-0.2864099443,
-0.5202752948,
0.652128458,
0.2205346376,
-0.1833613664,
0.2125259191,
-0.0585454889,
-0.3603500724,
-0.2616418004,
0.783219099,
-0.7562926412,
-0.683991015,
-0.4586257935,
0.0801515356,
-0.1529979855,
0.9185973406,
0.3162929118,
-0.3261987865,
0.024871856,
0.0544222966,
-0.5005662441,
-0.7060801983,
-0.3093449175,
0.2599923909,
0.2533505857,
0.2725323439,
0.8591946959,
0.43675372,
0.0085182227,
0.4143904746,
0.0244256537,
0.4301122725,
-0.4928830862,
0.5269341469,
-0.361281693,
-0.2816895843,
-0.6275217533,
-0.3402915895,
0.6693048477,
0.7212789059,
-0.039326638,
-0.1797197759,
0.3560252786,
0.4347321689,
-0.7141426206,
0.4819917083,
-0.9621117115,
0.2219442427,
-0.0927118063,
-0.224512279,
-0.6129253507,
-0.1622753441,
0.2843749821,
-0.8791859746,
0.3198073804,
-0.240343377,
0.4264581203,
0.1746862233,
-0.1784956008,
0.1931162775,
-0.849316895,
0.8060125113,
-0.7210891843,
0.2881307304,
0.5628725886,
0.3978566229,
-0.5699666739,
-0.5900533199,
-0.6037914753,
-0.291988641,
-0.2644639611,
0.0163509417,
-0.2094315588,
0.0652065948,
0.2228402793,
0.2481871396,
-0.2632923424,
-0.1645033062,
-0.0257562697,
-0.4957352579,
0.7985861301,
0.2644616067,
0.1101148054,
-0.1850818694,
-0.2375421375,
-0.347860992,
-0.45404163,
-0.0464729741,
0.6001570225,
0.2200282812,
0.0755893141,
0.5109210014,
-0.5279675126,
0.5376403332,
0.1319907308,
-0.1923438758,
0.2799412012,
-0.4123335183,
-0.2785910368,
0.0457564779,
0.5333868265,
0.3428905904,
0.2665524781,
-0.1858421415,
-0.0591528043,
0.1109739095,
0.2229834646,
-0.6829739809,
-0.2454399318,
0.1809263378,
-0.0625826716,
-0.379650265,
-0.0302374065,
-0.7117351294,
-0.57860291,
-0.3016746044,
0.202928856,
-0.5230195522,
-0.2758236825,
0.3132049739,
-0.0632919669,
-0.0897317305,
0.4395018816,
-0.8202461004,
0.7791637778,
0.7725728154,
0.4298579991,
-0.067064181,
-0.1625567377,
-0.6767475009,
0.4229137301,
-0.2329928428,
0.3212293684,
-0.3192578256,
-0.7044798732,
0.109179534,
0.2005220205,
-0.002735405,
-0.5524693131,
0.3438695669,
-0.4786873758,
0.4161562324,
0.0513964929,
-0.4013873339,
0.0280901007,
-0.1388702244,
-0.2165876478,
0.5799311399,
0.4157995582,
-0.7125879526,
0.2764205635,
-0.5240532756,
-0.3172537088,
0.0029661038,
-0.2079654634,
-0.4587140083,
0.2063038498,
0.1875465661,
0.4111081362,
0.1712328494,
0.3619740605,
-0.2363515794,
0.0562409945,
0.6682475805,
-0.3331357241,
0.7054190636,
0.2061850727,
-0.4934707582,
-0.0418581851,
-1.0793272257,
0.0514594167,
0.0571016558,
0.1195173338,
-0.4595678151,
0.1774958074,
-0.3964927793,
0.0115799829,
0.1119008288,
-0.7533895373,
-0.1337544024,
-0.958096981,
0.3113046587,
0.9727421999,
0.2544121146,
0.5593490005,
-0.229080081,
0.360978663,
0.3417004347,
0.2479135841,
-0.1895235032,
-0.7419176698,
-0.7774494886,
-0.33864066,
0.3307552636,
0.5147913694,
-0.5859305859,
0.7500890493,
-0.2093815207,
0.0089895539,
-0.1789700538,
-0.033569783,
0.6836684942,
0.6464831829,
0.1093966737,
-0.5875706077,
-0.2846898139,
-1.0019940138,
-0.2796274126,
-0.069101505,
-0.2662266195,
0.6920272708,
-0.0556780696,
-0.0277131181,
1.1402916908,
-0.7715125084,
-0.2683912218,
0.1627628356,
-0.2808325291,
-0.1379918307,
0.6729509234,
0.3998590112,
-0.6760860085,
-0.5457661152,
-0.0301131587,
-0.4609254301,
-0.267470628,
0.0037081314,
-0.5905457139,
0.2823884785,
-0.0827002898,
-0.3433556557,
0.5936108232,
0.6438910365,
-0.6011615992,
0.1245139763,
-0.2316982001,
-0.0438455716,
-1.1364201307,
-0.3568282723,
-0.4200696647,
-0.6912694573,
-0.7293700576,
-0.2730350196,
-0.2602370083,
-0.5772305727,
-0.5509067774,
0.5346093774,
-0.3572729528,
-0.1259429902,
-0.2990252972,
0.1719535589,
0.2143683285,
0.5784689188,
0.0772104412,
0.7493565083,
0.6514046192,
-0.650418222,
-0.1225199252,
0.6097096205,
-0.1383302361,
0.2340283245,
-0.3201106787,
0.4064297676,
0.2065224349,
0.2571249306,
-0.8661420941,
-0.4476430714,
0.6274687648,
-0.4296412766,
0.1162291989,
-0.1985964626,
-0.3288854063,
0.2129554451,
-0.173844561,
0.0899470076,
0.9448704123,
-0.5256538987,
0.4836204946,
0.5783655047,
-0.4271828234,
-0.2823107541,
-0.6406043172,
0.1098334342,
-0.0883584395,
-1.0004851818,
0.5004252791,
0.2392186821,
-0.2711349428,
0.0725047216,
-0.1677571088,
-0.1782509089,
0.2509514689,
0.3940156102,
0.1407765746,
-0.0967073068,
-0.2782557309,
0.6474838257,
-0.31548509,
0.0106017347,
-0.5206468701,
0.2743399739,
0.1351370662,
-0.3475594819,
-0.8093885183,
0.5419052243,
0.021684818,
-0.1966791749,
0.683419466,
0.1817603111,
-0.1214795783,
-0.6534709334,
-0.2626461685,
-0.4094527364,
-0.5746304989,
0.0914784372,
-0.4441109598,
-1.0542641878,
0.260358423,
-0.1604763567,
-0.0510244519,
0.2162441015,
0.626093626,
0.301454246,
0.9598099589,
0.6109671593,
0.5010102391,
0.3788152933,
-0.0088508148,
0.2429225296,
-0.6218013763,
-0.0911294445,
-0.2542016506,
-0.0040854868,
-0.8930519819,
-0.5931868553,
0.3351248503,
-0.0994112566,
0.2297781855,
0.4195548892,
-0.6376652122,
0.222949788,
0.4740159214,
0.2710851431,
0.4817518592,
0.2659776211,
0.2027590871,
-0.2532789707,
-0.2844268084,
-0.5323741436,
0.9389230013,
0.3039589226,
0.532132864,
0.3124843538,
0.9146197438,
0.4216625392,
-0.1282040477,
-0.4174683988,
0.7430522442,
-0.3544180989,
-0.3547018468,
-0.390579164,
-0.331259042,
-0.8218964934,
0.3365299702,
0.0294186715,
-0.9297341108,
0.6000397801,
0.3980318904,
-0.3127210438,
-0.2232531905,
-0.8546251059,
0.5232061148,
0.207597509,
-0.6487362385,
-0.0416044183,
-0.7025501132,
0.3222414255,
-0.2822038233,
0.039541509,
-0.4433634281,
0.0564994141,
0.412694484,
-0.5781764984,
1.2312632799,
-0.73442626,
-0.1675898582,
0.3351069391,
0.3670615256,
0.4575709999,
0.5190223455,
0.0272780601,
0.1528541744,
0.1720514745,
-0.25021106,
-0.7725661993,
0.7149134874,
-0.5276569128,
-1.0988160372,
-0.4341606498,
-0.5901458859,
-0.6718720198,
0.0901729912,
-0.1848361939,
0.2336834669,
-0.3287648261,
0.0727035403,
0.5320241451,
-0.4334341586,
0.1040800363,
0.5255537629,
-0.0930930898,
-0.3003273904,
0.8394150138,
-0.283857435,
0.4872744381,
0.1447680891,
0.4973233938,
-0.414103806,
-0.5410328507,
-0.6590685844,
-0.0196607858,
-0.4304917157,
-0.0924111381,
-0.8562155366,
-0.3001977503,
-0.6540622711,
0.0629341826,
-0.299215585,
-1.0091409683,
-0.159160465,
0.1738208532,
0.5471900702,
0.2901514769,
-0.1460550278,
0.3359015584,
-0.804197073,
0.3744346201,
0.3716204464,
0.0709020048,
-0.4452330172,
-0.4551160038,
0.2077001035,
0.1214736477,
-0.4891493022,
-0.66259408,
0.4437617958,
0.4992553294,
0.3228708208,
-0.0566358641,
0.4147382379,
0.4545082748,
-0.7935659885,
0.8332479596,
-0.1160460114,
-1.0193293095,
0.5946926475,
-0.3925341666,
-0.0867317542,
0.5697176456,
-0.0449230708,
-0.0569848046,
-0.6463194489,
-0.7051728368,
-0.533516109,
0.9466803074,
0.6813002825,
0.6825818419,
0.2593026161,
0.2745694518,
0.4384096861,
0.1978272051,
-0.2573199272,
0.0446852595,
-0.3856886327,
-0.1692072898,
0.0770871416,
-0.1658311784,
-0.4164782166,
-0.0221878327,
0.442687273,
-0.2772368491,
0.3286591768,
0.3130451739,
0.192706123,
0.325450927,
0.4653254449,
0.4154855013,
0.6296468973,
-0.0316628478,
-0.075283587,
-0.0247712974,
-0.3449682891,
0.2130834162,
0.3569989204,
-0.2476392239,
0.1889522225,
-0.1889857799,
0.8760080338,
0.1146910116,
-0.5244283676,
0.7394593358,
-0.1475740224,
-0.3358722031,
-0.2769876719,
0.7099528909,
-0.1166129932,
0.235455662,
-0.3160674274,
-0.0263288822,
0.3481525183,
-0.3489753604,
0.3267905712,
0.1445790082,
0.0343001522,
-0.4918587804,
0.5659288764,
0.325789094,
-0.3654414713,
0.2311740518,
-0.2296977341,
-0.159551248,
0.0927631333,
0.7287493348,
1.1006295681,
-0.2788381279,
0.3457943499,
-0.1346028447,
-0.4300594628,
0.3087649941,
0.3240609467,
-0.5322243571,
-0.7926062942,
-0.3530831039,
-0.8332429528,
-0.4857778847,
-0.0502765365,
-0.5696902871,
0.0799699426,
-0.6244457364,
-0.1657612026,
0.1367362291,
-0.3634456396,
-0.3381274045,
0.1764136702,
0.0951077193,
0.5317135453,
-0.5427658558,
0.9777131081,
0.1332502067,
0.1041273922,
-0.4895913005,
0.1685264558,
-0.0576804951,
-0.8059201837,
0.5020695925,
-0.2584576011,
-0.3083566427,
-0.04516159,
-0.0179932341,
-0.6332142353,
0.7784608006,
0.4510759711,
-0.7999393344,
0.0357156508,
0.4592443705,
0.6434756517,
-0.3533452451,
-0.6338452101,
0.4559849203,
0.2537652552,
0.0213945005,
-0.7707448602,
0.1884434968,
0.1307044476,
0.3931080401,
0.0364910588,
-0.3268058002,
0.416283071,
0.0795014352,
-0.3484149277,
0.3263972998,
0.5786033273,
0.3241587579,
0.3915859163,
0.7642355561,
0.12705414,
0.6445208192,
0.0735247359,
1.141384244,
-0.3912558258,
0.0843080133,
1.3436416388,
-0.5779312253,
0.4522955716,
0.2814059854,
-0.0657415017,
0.3771900237,
0.2139415592,
0.1077852249,
0.9096975923,
0.3773709536,
-0.6860858202,
-0.1098055765,
-0.2387377024,
-0.3740453422,
0.5631344914,
0.329928726,
-0.4961569011,
-0.0309129022,
0.0259488374,
0.0175984912,
0.3582178354,
0.3028681278,
1.1243474483,
0.1437775344,
-0.6156955957,
0.6615538001,
0.1318644732,
0.1232742295,
-0.5476354361,
-0.0728048012,
-0.0464192405,
0.4211449325,
-0.1731796563,
-0.5912985802,
0.5423400998,
0.1580266654,
-0.0034215634,
-0.3662258387,
0.9207021594,
-0.2377562523,
-0.4496687651,
0.2253026068,
0.5326779485,
0.1973435432,
0.0716792867,
-0.5979740024,
0.013298519,
0.1624908149,
-0.2394998074,
0.5442765951,
0.4877979159,
-0.1844019145,
0.0515450761,
0.7431969047,
-0.0293416195,
0.3216775656,
0.3794642985,
1.2159714699,
-0.4436456859,
-0.6086562872,
-0.5431016684,
0.63279742,
-0.1926874667,
-0.2983588278,
0.75835675,
0.3101091385,
1.0064899921,
-0.1264699101,
0.9478259683,
-0.0233148709,
0.5851941109,
-0.683524251,
0.4988114536,
-0.3097457886,
0.2045619637,
-0.1903107166,
-0.8557277322,
-0.2384125441,
0.4335358441,
-0.2781025171,
-0.2262303084,
0.4609357417,
1.0598665476,
-0.2436621189,
0.2074129134,
0.6463596821,
0.1936018169,
0.4305051565,
0.3458926976,
1.059107542,
-0.2282505184,
0.1374237984,
-0.6953165531,
-0.4854380488,
0.1907758266,
-0.8245828748,
-0.7141210437,
-0.5551357269,
-0.3179686069,
-0.6075022221,
0.3807768226,
0.2611810267,
0.8863961697,
-0.8783172965,
0.0609828942,
-0.3121454716,
-0.3055064976,
0.1600674093,
-0.2114899457,
0.2618232071,
-0.3532251716,
-0.98721838,
0.6798024178,
0.3224647641,
-0.021247454,
-0.2344135642,
0.017936226,
0.44502455,
0.1185497865,
0.5752577782,
0.0478862226,
-0.7364879251,
-0.4193862081,
-0.0774699301,
0.2413992286,
0.1145696267,
0.9357888103,
-0.646086514,
0.5376881361,
0.333488524,
0.8512318134,
0.5566233993,
0.246409893,
0.694850564,
-0.9191060066,
0.511027813,
0.4182825983,
0.0548781455,
0.2653059065,
-0.7378798723,
0.2010434568,
0.225475505,
-0.5269184113,
-0.6976056695,
0.4718717337,
-1.1404348612,
-0.1656381935,
1.0493813753,
-0.5220919847,
-0.4625474215,
-0.2792391777,
-0.3753295541,
0.0966325402,
-0.6947301626,
0.6288998723,
0.220470503,
-0.4383719563,
0.4468120933,
-0.2064657956,
0.6822952032,
0.4307926297,
-0.7451891899,
0.4243330956,
0.6425144672,
0.3751824796,
0.0928661004,
0.8884004951,
-0.4161574543,
0.1073168889,
0.1483591497,
-0.4979847968,
-0.1185432971,
-0.3990108669,
-0.2578609586,
0.0788186714,
0.1432640553,
-0.5284993649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10515v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10515v2 | CausalDialogue: Modeling Utterance-level Causality in Conversations | 2022-12-20T18:31:50 | 2023-07-08T21:59:43 | Yi-Lin Tuan, Alon Albalak, Wenda Xu, Michael Saxon, Connor Pryor, Lise Getoor, William Yang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite their widespread adoption, neural conversation models have yet to
exhibit natural chat capabilities with humans. In this research, we examine
user utterances as causes and generated responses as effects, recognizing that
changes in a cause should produce a different effect. To further explore this
concept, we have compiled and expanded upon a new dataset called CausalDialogue
through crowd-sourcing. This dataset includes multiple cause-effect pairs
within a directed acyclic graph (DAG) structure. Our analysis reveals that
traditional loss functions struggle to effectively incorporate the DAG
structure, leading us to propose a causality-enhanced method called Exponential
Maximum Average Treatment Effect (ExMATE) to enhance the impact of causality at
the utterance level in training neural conversation models. To evaluate the
needs of considering causality in dialogue generation, we built a comprehensive
benchmark on CausalDialogue dataset using different models, inference, and
training methods. Through experiments, we find that a causality-inspired loss
like ExMATE can improve the diversity and agility of conventional loss function
and there is still room for improvement to reach human-level quality on this
new dataset. | [
-0.1722236425,
-1.2898613214,
0.4214026928,
0.0126257977,
0.0193933751,
-0.358656168,
0.0889340341,
-0.4252513349,
0.4255865216,
0.5103259683,
-0.7417687774,
-0.1174371466,
-0.673340261,
-0.0077578635,
-0.5733949542,
0.6519717574,
0.3705218434,
0.3214067221,
-0.2272635102,
-0.262211591,
-1.0238963366,
-0.5518471599,
-1.1672252417,
-0.2760556042,
0.6170473695,
0.3161810935,
0.7629863024,
0.374827832,
0.1310502589,
0.3929086626,
0.0154370163,
0.183192119,
-0.7897561789,
0.1182112321,
0.0515555255,
-0.6048461199,
-0.3942793608,
0.1729283184,
0.4982376397,
0.8759993315,
-0.3405431807,
-0.0420518555,
0.0169584639,
0.2840058804,
-0.1717802137,
0.3235646784,
-0.5839163065,
-0.0243995469,
0.1752585769,
-0.6035770178,
-0.4496587515,
-0.3417553604,
0.3025820255,
-0.6433178186,
0.1528219879,
0.3701149821,
0.4305377901,
0.3971733153,
-0.7610494494,
-0.3692682683,
-0.6018509865,
0.4053237438,
-0.9330223799,
0.2669686079,
0.3245395124,
0.2108590454,
-0.5499453545,
-0.4854179323,
-0.6387537122,
-0.2518539131,
-0.1603980958,
0.1862762123,
-0.5887427926,
0.2209446132,
0.2966627777,
0.0096300915,
-0.4771665931,
0.0882480294,
-0.0214567147,
-0.2542067766,
0.4912952483,
0.6551555395,
0.6200251579,
-0.2364708036,
-0.2409941703,
-0.096893765,
-0.7720426321,
0.0181352552,
0.564935863,
0.1388010383,
-0.0203160215,
0.2327451408,
-0.1975580901,
0.772107482,
-0.0687881336,
0.0351734087,
-0.2710095644,
-0.4490849078,
-0.2160401642,
0.2493302077,
0.53300035,
0.5758482218,
-0.220501706,
0.0148643944,
0.4081470072,
-0.2831545174,
-0.2905233502,
-0.9394427538,
-0.1993623525,
0.178154856,
-0.3596461415,
-0.4191780984,
-0.1347806007,
-0.4063401818,
-0.6577289701,
-0.7138418555,
0.3301719129,
-0.0601914786,
-0.2548325658,
0.0803475082,
-0.3062643111,
0.0387774855,
0.6545376778,
-0.4582755864,
0.3988865316,
0.2898935378,
0.661988914,
0.0727527365,
-0.0585384294,
-0.7688179016,
0.1014846489,
-0.3030897081,
0.7550907731,
-0.4348172545,
-0.4114186764,
-0.0537132248,
-0.2058905363,
-0.3574149609,
-0.5883744359,
0.4995632768,
-0.4235738218,
0.4407202899,
-0.2442554832,
-0.485385716,
-0.4090748429,
-0.0847346038,
-0.4789848924,
0.5419788957,
-0.2852728963,
-0.5492733121,
0.4501615465,
-0.4867304564,
-0.4326295853,
-0.0155977551,
-0.21642223,
-0.2201804221,
0.1941324621,
0.0680927932,
0.327611506,
-0.6243882775,
0.9088131189,
-0.4631978273,
0.0546894297,
0.4739150405,
-0.8224048018,
1.0302351713,
-0.135012567,
-0.464268446,
0.4648343921,
-0.7885087729,
-0.1825156361,
-0.1305250973,
0.1985909194,
-0.4386637807,
0.3654398322,
-0.0237427372,
0.6464626193,
-0.3452853858,
-0.5253880024,
-0.1726926714,
-0.1773975939,
0.5868573785,
0.8805909753,
0.4933272302,
-0.0091797831,
-0.3166868687,
0.0924413279,
0.0854017809,
0.2551369071,
-0.1471348256,
-0.6770033836,
-0.7325647473,
-0.0860564336,
-0.3247464001,
0.3792828918,
-0.5846053362,
0.3530157208,
-0.0699946284,
-0.1869592816,
0.0372489281,
-0.1139877662,
0.3808375299,
0.9674263597,
0.1024563909,
-0.2112784833,
-0.3932315707,
-0.9138528109,
-0.1421468109,
-0.4733869433,
0.179478392,
0.8811996579,
0.1047555506,
-0.0427133515,
0.8881090283,
-0.6355148554,
-0.1570337266,
0.0029175426,
0.4639030695,
0.0667517334,
0.3766977489,
0.2456265241,
-0.6570113301,
-0.1177475601,
-0.483171612,
-0.8277813196,
-0.4294003248,
-0.5120407343,
-0.3369071782,
0.010661656,
0.6906271577,
-0.5860820413,
0.4734066427,
0.4274248183,
-0.6072869897,
0.5329196453,
-0.0207498055,
0.5198007226,
-0.921004653,
-0.0607297048,
-0.0864362866,
-0.2004505396,
-0.8109709024,
-0.4103750587,
-0.3345353007,
-0.614372611,
-0.470764488,
0.5774422288,
-0.1212005541,
0.1658818275,
-0.4537154138,
0.250639379,
-0.1391412318,
0.7984439731,
-0.1509308368,
0.6710024476,
0.3702827096,
-0.582796514,
0.2794787884,
0.5508620739,
-0.0556396097,
0.685970068,
-0.9869275093,
0.0980874524,
-0.1052653193,
0.665078342,
-1.1948746443,
-0.4558245242,
0.2903825641,
-0.591408968,
0.2098697871,
0.2158866972,
-0.5239036083,
-0.1509772241,
0.0087613072,
0.3872587979,
0.1598179042,
-0.5533912778,
0.3142873347,
0.4989217818,
-0.5105001926,
-0.0262693632,
-0.1741056442,
0.5756812692,
-0.4416544437,
-1.0890887976,
-0.08098609,
-0.2112345695,
-0.2629981637,
-0.2530210912,
0.0998231992,
0.004245962,
0.1684740037,
0.4563148916,
0.2058466226,
0.1461721212,
0.3297050595,
0.1536113918,
-0.1374304593,
0.558914423,
-0.0667978898,
0.5897901654,
0.2569175661,
-0.3290305734,
-0.7493727803,
0.685005188,
0.4032028019,
0.0405210666,
0.5891173482,
0.1500629038,
-0.1782593429,
-0.053149946,
-0.5392073393,
-0.4319433272,
-0.4506590366,
0.4948417246,
-0.0122701656,
-0.8516794443,
0.7375694513,
-0.0102530541,
-0.1686340123,
0.3477386236,
0.5691162944,
0.1558271945,
1.3108996153,
0.1345572174,
-0.3159184754,
0.5521453619,
0.0254046768,
0.1721118391,
-0.5488874316,
-0.2768565714,
-0.4690530002,
-0.0526188686,
-0.4116649032,
-0.2306307554,
0.6169107556,
-0.0031045983,
-0.2125866562,
0.3671161234,
-0.06361489,
-0.0902655348,
0.6300093532,
0.3166845143,
0.4363928139,
-0.1518466771,
0.229662925,
0.1523554027,
-0.9109243751,
-0.1920691729,
0.6837525964,
0.0771313086,
0.6512117982,
0.1979739964,
0.3836168051,
0.3222067356,
0.1791871488,
-0.4703088105,
0.6458955407,
0.6854236126,
-0.8547211289,
-0.5230328441,
-0.8390741944,
-0.9278520346,
0.2558776736,
-0.0283226483,
-0.8082230091,
0.3005878925,
0.33982265,
-0.1245213896,
-0.0486941785,
-0.777575016,
0.7321166992,
-0.0102705723,
-0.5334085226,
-0.5513136983,
-0.6631749272,
0.5468352437,
-0.0107305283,
0.1448229402,
-0.3244452178,
0.4097082615,
0.8785770535,
-0.8812543154,
1.1222901344,
-0.4315430522,
-0.0653666556,
0.615745306,
-0.0454254709,
0.7821486592,
0.3499668539,
0.302970767,
0.3164869249,
-0.4133992493,
-0.2972866297,
-0.8269099593,
0.6143888831,
-0.6754427552,
-0.832885325,
-0.0431070216,
-0.6249833703,
-0.2990314662,
0.0893812329,
0.2078038007,
1.0935521126,
-0.2126896232,
-0.017372746,
0.5258654356,
-0.5602243543,
0.4812246859,
0.6141679883,
0.1446100026,
-0.4751834273,
0.7634144425,
0.0427768528,
0.2719894648,
0.1985387504,
0.3591775596,
-0.1644223183,
-0.3534584045,
-0.406026423,
-0.026857907,
-0.4658345282,
-0.3406632245,
-0.6337528825,
0.1379657239,
-0.4412530661,
0.0785463229,
-0.0413687602,
-0.5244805813,
-0.2081637681,
-0.1112949029,
0.3194176257,
0.4817699492,
-0.0987048,
0.3538529277,
-0.6722127199,
0.0991379246,
0.6415286064,
-0.0217593536,
0.2661188245,
-0.5501355529,
-0.0959402025,
0.2192160636,
-0.3665043712,
-0.7910189629,
0.3867462575,
0.2942562103,
0.6251496673,
0.528914392,
0.1395854652,
0.9433663487,
-0.567736268,
0.6442027688,
0.693757236,
-0.8747780323,
0.4848218858,
-0.8162080646,
0.1366158426,
0.3227461278,
0.058070071,
-0.9858762622,
-0.5330935717,
-0.7610269189,
-0.8537627459,
0.7406715751,
0.5644153357,
0.2101718783,
-0.2858329415,
-0.0700650364,
0.0515169203,
0.1674239486,
-0.2518411279,
-0.4947984815,
-0.0540598743,
0.1440410912,
0.0018799555,
-0.134821862,
-0.2990088165,
-0.1693685353,
0.6901417375,
0.0368493013,
0.4526552856,
0.3902376294,
-0.1087131202,
-0.2318196744,
0.1552767009,
0.6453689933,
0.3917607367,
-0.171982944,
-0.1218455583,
0.0872231796,
-0.0590628907,
0.2217650563,
0.3084638715,
0.0292483624,
-0.0934292153,
0.5193635225,
0.9293121696,
0.556707859,
-0.5777510405,
0.5326551795,
-0.0979293063,
-0.0980273858,
-0.2467514277,
0.1556453854,
-0.068711102,
0.0766820014,
0.5090361834,
0.0264206473,
0.6723207235,
-0.4681216776,
0.3458069265,
0.3607923985,
-0.541261375,
-0.2809879482,
0.8935267925,
0.6975098848,
-0.2330122441,
0.6979727745,
0.0418766178,
-0.1376833171,
0.730255425,
0.4241153896,
0.955267787,
-0.1242102683,
0.1780287474,
0.4186122715,
-0.1413012743,
0.3554495871,
-0.2486719638,
-0.1484037042,
-0.6082398295,
-0.5124185085,
-0.0299097896,
-0.4955809712,
-0.062491823,
-0.7052634954,
-0.0171490461,
-0.0796590745,
-0.1925856322,
0.1217058524,
-0.3214124143,
-0.512514472,
-0.0599950925,
0.0244339425,
0.4411656857,
-0.9790356755,
0.2502176762,
0.1734252274,
-0.3531749249,
-0.9337857366,
-0.3853589296,
0.4124336839,
-0.8278206587,
0.8433890939,
0.1865092218,
-0.0938013941,
0.0261655785,
-0.7254497409,
-0.8923526406,
1.0305998325,
0.2533818185,
-0.3736326694,
-0.0054052817,
0.1108804643,
0.2914923429,
-0.1919135749,
0.5058427453,
0.3803595304,
0.2368216962,
0.1003367677,
-0.7637616992,
0.2193608433,
-0.3550791442,
-0.0487002879,
0.3755982816,
-0.7082679272,
0.4339031875,
0.0232612323,
-0.3676948547,
-0.0012957829,
0.5307816863,
0.1263194382,
0.6120644808,
0.4866193235,
0.4729016721,
0.6704360247,
0.0149653098,
1.0775825977,
-0.2735620439,
0.1491358578,
1.3704152107,
-0.1389766484,
0.2368797213,
0.222202152,
-0.0813025534,
0.2290128022,
0.4968309104,
0.4195068479,
0.2931934893,
0.3489156663,
-0.2238712907,
-0.2292859405,
-0.4279952943,
-0.162625581,
0.4255726635,
0.1703907996,
-0.2705146372,
-0.3920727372,
0.2663248777,
0.2288410813,
-0.3366060555,
-0.2142891586,
0.816077292,
0.0114967357,
-0.5853916407,
0.4208420515,
-0.3250956237,
0.1436892897,
-0.4608811438,
-0.306376487,
-0.4343751669,
-0.2328656167,
-0.0588072278,
0.04793505,
0.0691337734,
-0.4406011701,
0.0169306379,
-0.1235698909,
0.6923387647,
-0.3912186325,
-0.1936140358,
0.2065191269,
0.5062270164,
0.1237246394,
-0.1133758947,
-0.5787829757,
-0.1934406459,
-0.0115646766,
-0.2952781916,
0.1648719013,
0.2877056301,
-0.1436056048,
0.5450829268,
0.7096541524,
-0.102492772,
0.1435940713,
0.3723634183,
0.8937760592,
-0.7211814523,
-0.3651707768,
-0.5148007274,
0.4497567415,
-0.4804860353,
-0.5525490642,
0.9530157447,
0.4184687734,
0.4037159383,
0.1533618569,
0.5682740808,
0.0285072252,
0.3336848021,
-0.3747205138,
0.5778390169,
-0.1863247156,
0.1548385471,
-0.556000948,
-0.7481837273,
-0.1453880817,
0.1907221824,
-0.2974700928,
-0.0858408734,
0.6434450746,
1.0157780647,
0.377943635,
0.3562529087,
0.5217333436,
0.3326209188,
0.6556130648,
0.4177975059,
0.99423033,
-0.367320329,
0.4731960893,
0.2403697371,
-0.5905969739,
-0.328874439,
-0.4633004665,
-0.8652841449,
-0.608709693,
-0.5008907318,
-0.1429752707,
0.1033859849,
0.7649820447,
0.7949919105,
-0.5197606683,
-0.1917595416,
-0.6805884838,
-0.0457380377,
-0.0806406587,
-0.3068464696,
0.4418111145,
-0.4603414237,
-0.6127246022,
0.408957094,
0.2448295504,
-0.1524472088,
0.0276421737,
0.1271274388,
-0.0757333115,
0.3358568847,
0.7894491553,
0.3203592002,
-0.4115491807,
-0.4060404897,
-0.0958340392,
0.0969929323,
-0.1261790097,
1.3517233133,
-0.6347538829,
0.6021393538,
0.3574796021,
0.4554757774,
0.4125403762,
-0.0515372679,
0.8826601505,
-0.3969011605,
0.0756981,
0.0128176333,
0.4036149681,
0.0887257606,
-0.4835968018,
0.3921186328,
0.3647319376,
-0.6876370907,
-0.6107653379,
0.3308240771,
-0.9918792248,
-0.2584075034,
1.1512264013,
0.0301338099,
0.0542716682,
-0.3308511972,
-0.4341043532,
0.3927378356,
-0.7844987512,
0.6834846139,
0.5899176002,
-0.6747722626,
0.1102199927,
-0.4508314431,
0.2701669633,
0.5264710188,
-1.0001674891,
0.3470680416,
1.1711647511,
-0.0801205859,
-0.0521475822,
0.604336381,
-0.1011314765,
0.2659387589,
0.2517646551,
-0.1436520666,
-0.3123580813,
-0.2054136395,
-0.3063056767,
0.02199536,
-0.2033431828,
-0.0171647277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10511v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10511v4 | When Not to Trust Language Models: Investigating Effectiveness of Parametric and Non-Parametric Memories | 2022-12-20T18:30:15 | 2023-07-02T07:21:59 | Alex Mallen, Akari Asai, Victor Zhong, Rajarshi Das, Daniel Khashabi, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Despite their impressive performance on diverse tasks, large language models
(LMs) still struggle with tasks requiring rich world knowledge, implying the
limitations of relying solely on their parameters to encode a wealth of world
knowledge. This paper aims to understand LMs' strengths and limitations in
memorizing factual knowledge, by conducting large-scale knowledge probing
experiments of 10 models and 4 augmentation methods on PopQA, our new
open-domain QA dataset with 14k questions. We find that LMs struggle with less
popular factual knowledge, and that scaling fails to appreciably improve
memorization of factual knowledge in the long tail. We then show that
retrieval-augmented LMs largely outperform orders of magnitude larger LMs,
while unassisted LMs remain competitive in questions about high-popularity
entities. Based on those findings, we devise a simple, yet effective, method
for powerful and efficient retrieval-augmented LMs, which retrieves
non-parametric memories only when necessary. Experimental results show that
this significantly improves models' performance while reducing the inference
costs. | [
-0.4401606023,
-0.6787339449,
0.8701817989,
-0.0980222225,
0.0169339031,
0.0579185411,
-0.2587104142,
-0.3891448379,
-0.1396787167,
0.5992460251,
-0.1389542967,
-0.3467203081,
-0.6286839247,
-0.1743990481,
-0.4717578888,
0.9900841117,
-0.0224936493,
-0.1893558651,
-0.5099628568,
-0.6173686981,
-0.1254120469,
-0.6599946618,
-0.4239081442,
-0.2623188794,
0.4043888748,
0.2460089326,
0.94806391,
0.3519873619,
0.3021850586,
0.1687626243,
-0.2151905745,
0.5049473047,
-0.7358093858,
-0.0109905032,
-0.4070814848,
-0.6951664686,
-0.2554898262,
0.0263047237,
0.674826324,
0.6397322416,
-0.1234189942,
0.2991839945,
-0.0053147771,
0.8100082278,
-0.9189255834,
0.3495795131,
-0.9004018307,
-0.2085372955,
0.0640455931,
-0.1917931587,
-0.6285488009,
-0.540749073,
0.3909744024,
-0.5235934258,
0.1761397123,
0.3721851707,
0.8055409789,
0.0262693372,
-0.5623047352,
-0.3026176393,
-0.9166502357,
1.0225975513,
-0.6516188979,
0.6112044454,
0.8289837837,
0.1615500897,
-0.0777529106,
-0.4333736598,
-0.4381495416,
-0.6244710088,
0.0123307258,
-0.3211827576,
-0.0874931738,
-0.0356641933,
0.5252079964,
0.2854361534,
-0.3489226997,
-0.1814654917,
-0.2660746276,
-0.3229150176,
0.1610403657,
-0.0170828924,
0.2991535962,
-0.0628784671,
-0.4175366163,
-0.1198312119,
-0.8773858547,
0.1523537487,
0.0204689335,
0.1259973049,
0.2027308792,
0.6784344912,
-0.0221989285,
0.5056735277,
0.1453673393,
-0.5337730646,
0.0991886482,
-0.2888269722,
-0.0821189433,
-0.1953148842,
0.6270340085,
0.140947789,
0.2757541239,
-0.564242363,
-0.2447806448,
-0.2533218563,
0.1776604056,
-0.6009831429,
-0.1059424505,
0.0224106628,
-0.2733052969,
0.1890048236,
-0.1092950553,
-0.6901231408,
-0.2791460156,
0.0133977905,
0.9367173314,
-0.8191783428,
-0.2026789486,
-0.1378394067,
-0.158750996,
-0.0398363248,
0.1515599191,
-0.840206027,
0.2886443436,
0.4468028247,
0.7778736353,
0.0507213622,
-0.3622411489,
-0.5757146478,
0.2698766291,
-0.720582962,
0.5623422861,
-0.441657722,
-0.3115466237,
-0.0803148597,
-0.1856985688,
-0.2758850157,
-0.79536134,
0.4099538922,
-0.8789458871,
-0.026569983,
-0.7559701204,
-0.7090736032,
-0.3052626848,
0.3572665751,
-0.9148433805,
0.9588325024,
0.0483790003,
-0.6837776899,
0.1630976051,
-0.1630111188,
-0.1638911813,
-0.3948264122,
0.0195731316,
-0.2318101227,
0.2289914936,
0.3034258485,
0.2245747,
-0.4011159241,
0.3366841376,
-0.4946318269,
-0.3205520809,
0.4431212246,
-0.4599696398,
0.6005539894,
0.0441743992,
-0.2261475772,
-0.2931959927,
-0.613029778,
-0.0463243611,
0.1242192686,
-0.2611335814,
-0.5812523365,
-0.1634318978,
-0.3760575652,
0.2685083747,
0.4473263323,
-0.4282502234,
-0.29898417,
-0.2092415839,
0.3407758176,
0.4560210109,
0.1641317159,
0.6163917184,
-0.7466528416,
0.3395624161,
0.2215048522,
-0.0099125085,
-0.0788971856,
-0.3474747837,
-0.7743273973,
-0.0162149258,
0.2201963961,
0.3658367991,
-0.9733196497,
0.0164531078,
-0.2741549909,
-0.6724931002,
-0.2674143016,
0.5142306685,
0.5575258136,
0.7953289151,
0.5084163547,
0.0246806648,
-0.2553738654,
-0.9701626897,
-0.5136814713,
-0.553845048,
0.1692398638,
0.4241178632,
0.4375350177,
0.1882266253,
0.8926408887,
-0.1667425632,
0.0411723331,
-0.1185226291,
0.2509984374,
-0.1129119992,
0.1685501784,
0.4794764519,
-0.7217015028,
-0.3213128746,
-0.2295769155,
-0.6715833545,
0.284390986,
-0.1217518449,
0.1971001327,
0.4378953576,
0.4405064881,
-1.0812233686,
0.1521068513,
0.5459319353,
-0.0575346649,
0.3963972032,
-0.4974152148,
0.128593415,
-0.7622856498,
0.2324615717,
0.079754144,
-0.2562598586,
-0.583050549,
0.1484105438,
0.5457749963,
0.0339661799,
-0.3607428372,
0.5925937891,
-0.5726265311,
0.0860370398,
-0.068381995,
0.245584771,
0.1334354728,
0.4213682413,
0.0433775075,
0.9693211913,
0.4449059665,
-0.8490569592,
-0.0375938378,
0.2232579738,
-0.6932093501,
0.3934070766,
-0.2399794161,
0.231508702,
-0.2363814414,
0.1990987659,
-0.921387434,
0.1910916418,
-0.2356554568,
-0.4076794386,
0.2710661888,
-0.1307217926,
-0.7218677998,
-0.0284920707,
-0.2603757381,
0.2673784196,
0.813198328,
-0.7435101271,
0.6261588335,
0.3327687979,
0.0678170174,
-0.7323006392,
-0.4634943306,
0.0841384754,
-0.4307594597,
-0.4565357566,
0.0271717384,
0.0031363305,
-0.374954313,
-0.0531186275,
-0.3849303126,
-0.3057071269,
-0.0612931326,
0.1120817289,
0.2415809929,
-0.4138798416,
0.356946528,
-0.1759777218,
0.1513388008,
0.1371618807,
-0.2199697345,
0.1994229555,
-0.1264411658,
-0.4635769427,
-0.2046109885,
-0.0532282591,
0.851364255,
-0.2742075026,
1.2132872343,
0.2714644372,
-0.4387053847,
-0.3395587802,
-1.0874267817,
-0.2384519875,
-0.4303603172,
0.2350244969,
-0.2009681016,
-0.9191020131,
0.4806546569,
-0.0999449566,
-0.004877327,
0.3010612428,
0.3279525042,
0.0172345322,
0.7691020966,
0.2587663531,
-0.2532441616,
0.1150117293,
0.0739533454,
0.4353220165,
-0.7255376577,
-0.3256804943,
-0.3970978856,
-0.1254391372,
-0.4087112248,
-0.70557338,
0.3672653437,
0.1204268634,
-0.1794902235,
0.1399990618,
0.348372519,
0.4007761478,
0.5711050034,
0.1971784234,
0.5355758071,
-0.1091284454,
-0.0373236276,
-0.0894817412,
-0.6949935555,
-0.4136415422,
1.4237499237,
0.3748256862,
0.8081726432,
0.0936296135,
0.3396886289,
-0.0036652221,
-0.1209561005,
-0.5697456598,
0.5737519264,
0.0651205927,
-0.9439153671,
-0.3993812501,
-0.6468704939,
-0.5277792215,
0.0591151975,
-0.1950989366,
-0.5374780893,
0.2377649248,
0.2109548002,
-0.5619421005,
0.6876466274,
-0.8092252016,
0.3940571249,
-0.0760678947,
-0.4249346554,
-0.0757897794,
-0.4376555383,
0.4665743709,
-0.2960324883,
0.2141976207,
0.1100861728,
-0.1904664487,
0.6877068281,
-0.2486616969,
0.6939821243,
-0.1663584858,
0.0074717486,
0.5465966463,
0.335082233,
0.6400724649,
0.1113232747,
-0.0955475271,
-0.0366869532,
0.2037422955,
-0.5627338886,
-0.850099504,
0.7583419085,
-0.6470618844,
-0.8443691134,
-0.1953757852,
-0.7428156734,
-0.865160346,
0.1437602192,
-0.0043749828,
0.2616795301,
-0.3819255829,
0.5771005154,
1.3100310564,
-0.1357696503,
0.3079303503,
0.5270016193,
-0.1620317996,
-0.2085655779,
1.0426388979,
0.472096324,
0.6840013862,
0.5034294724,
0.1372768581,
-0.5228490829,
-0.6975271702,
-0.2495157421,
0.3375076652,
-0.6890660524,
0.0536100902,
-0.826998055,
-0.2983991206,
-0.3842900097,
0.4005888104,
-0.5829910636,
-0.6146551371,
-0.0901767537,
-0.2844729125,
0.482555151,
0.5189157724,
-0.0501006879,
-0.1400995851,
-0.8982141018,
0.3796757758,
0.4841287136,
0.1609052122,
0.3254016638,
-0.5730598569,
-0.2868455052,
-0.032387685,
-0.1543576866,
-0.7050270438,
0.3802456558,
0.0218181293,
0.6062358022,
0.4625669718,
0.335765928,
0.6989314556,
-0.3138605356,
0.6695871949,
-0.2973567247,
-0.9100432396,
0.0595619604,
-0.4439338446,
0.071005851,
0.5962501168,
0.5574513078,
-0.1794096828,
-0.3431982994,
-0.7067942619,
-0.5523352027,
0.5522223711,
0.1253421903,
0.2287952751,
-0.0611547194,
0.5332684517,
0.0463380739,
0.3147993088,
-0.4831307828,
-0.2906716764,
-0.0820150599,
0.0246992353,
-0.3369304538,
-0.5867202878,
-0.1577599496,
-0.1125621423,
0.7457895875,
0.0436843634,
0.0397754945,
0.1866738349,
-0.31731534,
-0.2002530694,
0.2875315845,
0.5415720344,
0.9351378083,
-0.3820392489,
0.2941697538,
0.4119560122,
-0.3204728067,
0.0555410013,
-0.2489695847,
-0.1202072948,
-0.0107539333,
0.270590961,
0.7827446461,
0.3406625688,
-0.8420506716,
0.3039351106,
0.0483000465,
-0.3011262119,
-0.2918686569,
0.0796845481,
0.5280649066,
0.1850736886,
0.3087674975,
-0.1145631,
-0.1499988586,
-0.6921542287,
0.2647239268,
0.607132256,
-0.3172333837,
-0.3266972005,
0.4209836125,
-0.3491556346,
-0.1048069745,
0.6552684903,
-0.0027059251,
-0.2364190668,
0.4502996802,
0.7346920371,
0.3142393827,
-0.2838000655,
0.3381111324,
0.3748522699,
0.5134263039,
-0.4935885668,
0.0867578834,
0.0681555346,
-0.6515814662,
-0.1396537423,
-0.2341888398,
-0.5717347264,
0.5022383332,
-0.8012264967,
-0.0650374815,
-0.8389204741,
-0.155664891,
-0.5355708003,
0.0830753371,
-0.5562749505,
0.288112998,
-0.1126640886,
1.0659446716,
-0.7849874496,
0.9626102448,
0.4131792486,
-0.3746384382,
-0.8859215379,
0.1885812879,
-0.1245796904,
-0.9164690971,
0.5380182266,
-0.2044261545,
0.0490039811,
-0.104139708,
-0.2146813422,
-1.0969758034,
1.1207512617,
0.448836863,
-0.3520964384,
-0.3658876121,
0.1253875494,
0.6089701056,
-0.0494144112,
0.2335560769,
0.5781801343,
0.4286905825,
0.3351632953,
-1.1147546768,
0.1680734754,
0.0891058818,
-0.1125185415,
0.2389576286,
-0.9020916224,
1.0224417448,
-0.2451381832,
-0.0431764014,
0.1232977509,
0.7791409492,
0.3365072906,
0.4143374264,
0.3727621138,
0.6956925988,
0.971170783,
0.3828026354,
0.8646022081,
-0.3101952076,
0.3350785077,
1.1715451479,
-0.2081779391,
0.9902117252,
0.6206988096,
0.0145956203,
0.4075303674,
0.2399951667,
0.1625703871,
0.4697590172,
-0.2184833884,
-0.1707569212,
-0.4232516289,
0.0294011794,
-0.2668964267,
0.2774456441,
0.34492746,
-0.4268825948,
-0.3730834424,
-0.1630924344,
0.2052657008,
0.1705031395,
-0.2371814549,
0.6606805921,
0.3333686888,
-0.7728381157,
0.7684943676,
-0.1519213915,
0.2563215494,
-0.5703607202,
0.1505106091,
-0.2055915147,
0.1977531165,
0.0366598554,
-0.4052010179,
0.3038651943,
-0.1709223688,
-0.2331791222,
0.041712407,
0.5172683001,
-0.2831571102,
-0.2729005814,
0.3586285412,
0.8459282517,
-0.0979262441,
-0.2920891345,
-0.5210869908,
-0.1689658016,
-0.1093553305,
-0.3541612327,
0.7568603754,
0.6421808004,
-0.1672688425,
0.9637809992,
0.5812234879,
0.1039821282,
0.1429787427,
-0.4509600103,
0.6083227396,
-0.7105965018,
-0.19872953,
-0.9133754969,
0.1042991355,
0.1666290611,
0.0216737185,
1.1492341757,
0.5663943887,
0.6951074004,
-0.0101464177,
0.7526689172,
0.4273106754,
0.7481554151,
-0.7154411674,
0.9032014608,
-0.3834353983,
0.2836713195,
0.0844343677,
-0.8357130885,
0.0049516885,
0.30942294,
-0.5559104085,
0.2200647146,
1.0092880726,
0.8132077456,
-0.0294128675,
0.1383706331,
0.6199632287,
0.4804310799,
0.2564941645,
0.6575084329,
0.8379753828,
-0.3168014884,
0.7440165877,
-0.3432156146,
-0.1464844644,
0.0166046266,
-0.7585648894,
-1.3452395201,
-0.6243905425,
-0.0536342897,
-0.5012064576,
0.0326250531,
0.7751128674,
0.5641546249,
-0.798127532,
-0.2058326602,
0.2080836296,
0.324344933,
0.0830760598,
-0.1436824203,
0.3323039114,
-0.3750345707,
-0.652305007,
0.559808135,
0.1180676222,
0.0419048667,
-0.3439587951,
0.0717368945,
-0.2590390444,
0.4998781979,
0.3630743325,
0.5020908117,
-0.6650092006,
-0.3599617481,
0.2321450561,
-0.0542636737,
0.0848906711,
0.6784754992,
-0.855481267,
0.2859206796,
0.5177922249,
0.7107166052,
0.3215456009,
0.0494460948,
0.5034976006,
-0.2786812782,
-0.0768768936,
0.130344227,
0.3100116551,
0.314252764,
-0.2835326493,
-0.0292924419,
0.079804942,
-0.6247174144,
-0.8877626657,
0.0785057619,
-0.6108396053,
-0.2493846864,
1.1458747387,
-0.3575862348,
-0.3177088201,
-0.3447706103,
0.1132285371,
-0.0431774557,
-0.3938867152,
1.0283796787,
1.0355865955,
-0.046835959,
-0.1850530952,
-0.7727612853,
0.6716001034,
0.6164361238,
-0.3294975758,
0.106568329,
0.4111838937,
0.6765766144,
0.2683809996,
0.5635790825,
-0.2714817226,
0.0733760223,
0.0788253024,
-0.5167350769,
-0.1505941898,
-0.4405817389,
-0.1108669788,
0.4310482144,
0.5818110704,
0.0619807504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10509v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10509v2 | Interleaving Retrieval with Chain-of-Thought Reasoning for Knowledge-Intensive Multi-Step Questions | 2022-12-20T18:26:34 | 2023-06-23T00:59:13 | Harsh Trivedi, Niranjan Balasubramanian, Tushar Khot, Ashish Sabharwal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompting-based large language models (LLMs) are surprisingly powerful at
generating natural language reasoning steps or Chains-of-Thoughts (CoT) for
multi-step question answering (QA). They struggle, however, when the necessary
knowledge is either unavailable to the LLM or not up-to-date within its
parameters. While using the question to retrieve relevant text from an external
knowledge source helps LLMs, we observe that this one-step retrieve-and-read
approach is insufficient for multi-step QA. Here, \textit{what to retrieve}
depends on \textit{what has already been derived}, which in turn may depend on
\textit{what was previously retrieved}. To address this, we propose IRCoT, a
new approach for multi-step QA that interleaves retrieval with steps
(sentences) in a CoT, guiding the retrieval with CoT and in turn using
retrieved results to improve CoT. Using IRCoT with GPT3 substantially improves
retrieval (up to 21 points) as well as downstream QA (up to 15 points) on four
datasets: HotpotQA, 2WikiMultihopQA, MuSiQue, and IIRC. We observe similar
substantial gains in out-of-distribution (OOD) settings as well as with much
smaller models such as Flan-T5-large without additional training. IRCoT reduces
model hallucination, resulting in factually more accurate CoT reasoning. Code,
data, and prompts are available at \url{https://github.com/stonybrooknlp/ircot} | [
-0.6766672134,
-0.8388383985,
0.8469398618,
0.3409042358,
-0.3304535449,
0.2981982231,
-0.0310970172,
-0.5180414915,
-0.0235461835,
0.7036690116,
-0.5817295313,
-0.457080543,
-0.5819472671,
0.1679287106,
-0.5960067511,
0.8529245257,
-0.2360504866,
0.0083762836,
-0.1504304111,
-0.0754181445,
-0.4578846395,
-0.3222177625,
-0.6472861171,
-0.3963608742,
0.7990922928,
0.8899466395,
0.3958177865,
0.1176993921,
0.633985579,
0.1433708668,
-0.1181557551,
0.4887079597,
-0.3967761993,
0.4742743671,
-0.2480800152,
-0.3229823411,
-0.1470970064,
0.0802415013,
0.4494865239,
0.3558834791,
-0.086995326,
0.069973141,
0.0211131256,
0.7692605853,
-0.7021207213,
-0.0092696454,
-0.8419715166,
0.0473778322,
0.1261380166,
-0.4479746819,
-0.699775815,
-0.4177979529,
0.2360258698,
-0.3179528117,
0.0606920943,
0.2389751077,
0.4676108956,
-0.0255918913,
-0.6273971796,
-0.5368405581,
-0.7171137929,
0.4783329964,
-0.5973086953,
0.491045326,
0.4560349882,
0.081813246,
-0.2313699126,
-0.9560025334,
-0.7266852856,
-0.4128609896,
-0.0798861757,
0.1419207603,
0.2188179046,
0.147761628,
0.4001279175,
0.2800140977,
-0.2612238824,
-0.2756489217,
-0.1876996756,
0.0906973481,
0.2526240349,
-0.0370578878,
0.1610507071,
-0.2029518187,
-0.725129962,
-0.2898181677,
-0.9374705553,
-0.1533609182,
0.2271522731,
0.3992875516,
0.2595871985,
0.4937621951,
-0.2151990831,
0.4516591132,
0.108729288,
0.0869184583,
-0.0382774621,
-0.5088449121,
0.0065331222,
-0.1380364597,
0.7671307325,
-0.1514555365,
0.1963115633,
-0.1083309278,
-0.3393076956,
-0.5908010602,
0.2728988528,
-0.7893407941,
-0.3321720362,
0.3848561347,
-0.0936015993,
0.078302972,
0.3113369644,
-0.7477831244,
-0.2681697011,
-0.235823825,
0.6152212024,
-0.6660676599,
-0.196809262,
0.023551641,
-0.1143280715,
0.4201587737,
0.3980278671,
-0.5623155236,
0.4195545018,
0.6754585505,
0.9875538945,
-0.1019584239,
-0.2780354023,
-0.8134519458,
-0.0945974812,
-0.3547369242,
0.8570985794,
-0.6210907102,
-0.2312638164,
-0.111183852,
-0.0934239328,
-0.0596255586,
-0.4980175197,
0.2205060273,
-0.8744194508,
0.3662479818,
-0.5536697507,
-0.3844175637,
-0.0814316049,
0.4359852672,
-0.5881162882,
1.0815535784,
-0.1339804232,
-0.743293643,
0.2333253026,
-0.6876112819,
-0.3972969353,
-0.1073940173,
-0.1631233841,
-0.1445598006,
-0.0037028973,
0.328913182,
0.3182381392,
-0.4785757065,
0.3160963953,
-0.1739367694,
-0.2498751879,
0.0394990034,
-0.6249127388,
0.6273878813,
0.2948282659,
-0.3404380977,
-0.0490241796,
-0.412866503,
0.3719593883,
-0.1597876996,
-0.2444352359,
-0.2282687873,
-0.0373672284,
-0.3771837652,
0.5008344054,
-0.0412373766,
-0.4159790874,
0.4318335056,
0.1000729725,
0.3490187824,
0.7265759706,
0.4219017625,
0.2093129158,
-0.2957725227,
0.7670024633,
0.304297477,
0.3448331654,
-0.2178237438,
-0.5635165572,
-0.7124577761,
-0.0885920525,
0.1326205283,
0.4112964869,
-1.1690944433,
-0.0832048133,
-0.0125156632,
-0.305400908,
-0.3857583702,
-0.0491624884,
0.4661581516,
0.5258724093,
0.700673461,
-0.1894360185,
-0.2246111333,
-0.580788672,
-0.2427944988,
-0.2920603752,
0.2192283124,
0.1474840641,
0.6213169694,
-0.0930807292,
0.779323101,
-0.5752896667,
-0.1617004573,
-0.2272375524,
0.3781503737,
0.3272375464,
0.47086972,
-0.0084319506,
-0.7605515122,
-0.6862335801,
0.0604811981,
-0.3810116947,
0.0723151714,
-0.0789912865,
-0.546736598,
-0.250203073,
0.6408899426,
-0.6761153936,
0.2216587216,
0.3753802478,
-0.3841908574,
0.6444064379,
-0.2780757248,
0.5822533369,
-1.0422790051,
0.0833445862,
-0.3965595365,
-0.2440216988,
-0.556106627,
0.2702706158,
0.4308069646,
0.2126186043,
-0.539283812,
0.4732304215,
-0.6817179918,
0.1357960552,
-0.1427051872,
0.3918894231,
0.2505376339,
0.5360267162,
-0.1603760868,
1.16982162,
0.2627616525,
-0.7342887521,
-0.0136680417,
0.4208330512,
-0.1711821258,
0.4156044126,
-0.3436583281,
0.6392435431,
-0.2546323836,
0.2519640923,
-0.9615467787,
-0.1433365792,
0.3024205565,
-0.3008969128,
0.0968353376,
-0.1362015903,
-0.6143085957,
-0.4520651996,
-0.4709576368,
0.5372080803,
0.2291455567,
-0.8018322587,
0.6538481712,
0.1354871392,
-0.0228379201,
-0.728377223,
-0.4687018991,
0.0234369449,
-0.0011941361,
-0.2526586354,
0.133440569,
-0.2491992414,
-0.2799715698,
-0.158684358,
-0.286259383,
-0.1818130761,
-0.2174023241,
-0.1040933877,
0.1963855177,
-0.0624214597,
0.511952281,
0.0327545106,
0.0265649222,
0.174615413,
-0.6623369455,
0.6878856421,
-0.0366116613,
-0.5550205112,
-0.0988172889,
0.4982718229,
0.6943809986,
-0.3263428211,
0.6512943506,
0.324981004,
-0.283202529,
-0.2659307718,
-0.6082725525,
-0.4090103507,
-0.4543955028,
0.0696231648,
-0.5168374181,
-0.7328800559,
0.4200738668,
-0.014850352,
0.1098096594,
0.2592190206,
0.1288639158,
-0.0994386077,
1.0480923653,
0.4007411301,
0.1098647639,
0.5816885233,
-0.413216114,
0.4642038345,
-1.1785792112,
-0.416108489,
-0.5824708939,
-0.1172633991,
-0.4140433967,
-0.7108730674,
0.6570608616,
0.1855233163,
-0.2804715037,
0.2805194855,
-0.3852694631,
0.5448266864,
0.754414916,
0.4409916401,
0.6989633441,
-0.1645999402,
-0.4216879606,
0.4052395225,
-0.757329464,
-0.2837707102,
0.9053003192,
0.0382611677,
0.9093005657,
0.0948480368,
0.6913303733,
0.2071844935,
0.3067646623,
-0.7155626416,
0.5861192346,
0.0210754275,
-0.519200623,
-0.2794925272,
-0.5395419598,
-0.8011313081,
0.4221884608,
-0.0077969399,
-0.6887670755,
0.1894029081,
0.2051378787,
-0.3038897514,
0.5375076532,
-0.6948163509,
0.3856626749,
-0.2076549381,
-0.3657155037,
-0.2246330529,
-0.7012909651,
0.5229428411,
-0.0480971299,
-0.0000461708,
-0.0407477617,
0.053798601,
0.578121841,
-0.6329424381,
0.4256877899,
-0.0680903271,
-0.3404181004,
0.6131314635,
0.1555195004,
0.9802540541,
0.125247851,
-0.1227654144,
-0.338475287,
0.084630087,
-0.2221565396,
-0.755617857,
0.7387462258,
-0.4860475957,
-0.8303526044,
-0.4331003726,
-0.5059286356,
-0.6519043446,
0.2301357538,
0.1774423271,
0.6293973923,
0.3794713616,
0.1738658845,
0.8690814972,
-0.0355060063,
0.2534325421,
0.3605704606,
-0.4346321225,
-0.6301757097,
0.5723122954,
0.0364067443,
0.8713781834,
0.6638959646,
0.1437824517,
-0.5477023721,
-0.4899976552,
-0.163892597,
0.3175193965,
-0.9876105785,
-0.4345228672,
-0.9836903811,
-0.2792470455,
-0.2428834587,
0.2338293493,
-0.1854591519,
-0.22347866,
-0.1621073633,
-0.2916918099,
0.7092866302,
0.9288094044,
0.0090635531,
0.1422674656,
-0.6790606976,
0.5593933463,
0.4220768511,
0.4807223082,
0.2450517118,
-0.4508788586,
-0.0601561517,
0.0231317058,
-0.2827228308,
-0.7947185636,
0.1793895364,
-0.0823184624,
0.1816579551,
0.1378274113,
0.275378257,
1.1659911871,
-0.4751081169,
0.5415895581,
0.2728808522,
-0.9155911803,
0.5959845185,
-0.0298330411,
0.571692884,
0.8631746173,
0.4876031876,
-0.7579572201,
-0.7026333213,
-0.5480642915,
-1.1552975178,
0.6697679162,
0.1226807758,
-0.0632340387,
-0.4441430569,
0.3602746725,
0.3125732541,
0.2751876414,
-0.6074687839,
-0.028145114,
0.2596807778,
-0.0168529898,
0.3795544803,
-0.2073628604,
0.0536273941,
-0.1948587298,
0.8655617833,
-0.4412237108,
0.3823795319,
0.5986582637,
-0.1153643578,
-0.1543201655,
0.2367232591,
0.2114459276,
0.7356670499,
-0.0910889655,
0.541095674,
0.2365317196,
-0.6720545888,
0.2859872878,
-0.2479758114,
-0.1287850887,
-0.2941192091,
0.4578232169,
0.5569167137,
0.0853208974,
-0.6691812873,
0.4251882434,
-0.1604762971,
-0.189533338,
-0.0919168741,
0.0230930485,
-0.1422622949,
0.4108383954,
0.4718109071,
0.0425742678,
0.1171374097,
-0.7467049956,
0.5178348422,
0.4480622113,
-0.700907588,
-0.0465341285,
0.6241397858,
0.0247498546,
-0.2369128913,
0.985497117,
-0.0522790477,
-0.4652999341,
0.4938420653,
0.5296119452,
1.0030177832,
0.1978354603,
0.3772293031,
0.3939549923,
0.2734605968,
-0.3535140157,
0.5821204782,
-0.2047998905,
-0.5132725239,
-0.5439392328,
-0.3392561972,
-0.606554985,
0.0014886638,
-0.6370919943,
0.2180104256,
-0.4641264975,
-0.0497391447,
-0.6481355429,
-0.0616295412,
-0.6822500825,
0.0758619383,
-0.1981227696,
1.1764314175,
-0.3869033754,
0.7959866524,
0.2233388573,
-0.5220611691,
-1.1119980812,
0.596916616,
-0.3649265468,
-0.6533278227,
0.2597689331,
0.0944779888,
-0.399992764,
0.3030351102,
-0.6347618103,
-0.9712824225,
1.289460659,
0.2152144015,
-0.6776907444,
-0.0733334199,
-0.0962695777,
0.3599008024,
-0.2699379325,
0.6926781535,
0.4857405424,
0.4697280526,
0.387561202,
-0.6339117289,
0.1405707151,
0.023999203,
-0.1968201995,
0.5024596453,
-0.6395016313,
1.0466190577,
-0.5507345796,
-0.2500769198,
0.0824740231,
0.4999415874,
0.5036022663,
0.1700722277,
0.6254317164,
0.2176808417,
1.0157613754,
0.0455134325,
1.0360040665,
-0.3303572834,
0.402947247,
1.3052356243,
-0.2698089182,
0.978849411,
0.7448917031,
-0.1298287809,
0.6054843664,
0.4861463308,
0.7391711473,
0.5694192648,
0.1008258164,
-0.4360353649,
-0.2734008133,
-0.0385138392,
-0.1893936098,
0.0885088891,
0.2132773548,
-0.2297510058,
-0.1806234419,
0.1273461133,
-0.0071439892,
-0.1460021287,
-0.1268500835,
0.7699466348,
0.2413083911,
-1.1658629179,
0.4620409608,
-0.576456368,
0.2875792682,
-0.8044635653,
-0.3926920891,
-0.3604589105,
0.0055056475,
0.0422578119,
-0.9780968428,
-0.1266010553,
0.0189538263,
0.0074514886,
-0.4592971504,
0.4580453038,
-0.6390622258,
-0.2672718763,
0.5606191754,
0.7603853941,
-0.0641363934,
-0.2264804095,
-0.4871936142,
-0.1709702462,
-0.0447662435,
-0.2751868367,
0.0499599352,
0.7982771397,
-0.1818723679,
0.9795858264,
0.6490880251,
0.0206962358,
0.0610713586,
0.3541587293,
1.0346144438,
-0.9628772736,
-0.2822098732,
-0.7793579102,
0.4225707948,
-0.0079030218,
-0.3148534894,
0.4685279727,
0.4283754528,
0.6747102737,
0.0603843369,
0.6996688247,
-0.2883597612,
0.346724391,
-0.8211956024,
0.1684173793,
-0.4614576995,
0.5104208589,
-0.2901281416,
-0.7973821759,
-0.2328536958,
0.2603726983,
-0.2198500335,
-0.0068069105,
1.2775659561,
0.796749413,
-0.0331304781,
0.1401135027,
0.2264591306,
0.3156126142,
0.6281387806,
0.5172017813,
1.1744072437,
-0.4409881532,
0.5895168185,
-0.1699614525,
-0.0432740338,
-0.028087087,
-0.8054498434,
-0.596963346,
-0.7214853168,
-0.1146037951,
-0.3902708292,
0.159218058,
1.2065359354,
0.5094670653,
-0.8460297585,
-0.1171955243,
-0.5082932711,
0.5359426737,
-0.3358787596,
-0.27660501,
0.1104435325,
-0.6314844489,
-0.6304566264,
0.3075475991,
0.4217639267,
-0.0476232357,
-0.3422314525,
0.0351167098,
-0.7389805317,
0.1132657304,
0.829197228,
0.0002523899,
-0.6837935448,
-0.7371044755,
0.1734546423,
-0.0344396606,
0.2667966485,
1.0215339661,
-1.0338656902,
0.4749798477,
0.6470679045,
0.3976517618,
0.5557323098,
0.1236660779,
0.6174448729,
-0.5509745479,
-0.231658563,
0.4946154058,
0.3265445828,
0.0431288406,
-0.4463459551,
0.6468936205,
0.0006181887,
-0.5811346173,
-0.6027245522,
0.2357845157,
-0.755509913,
-0.1881728917,
1.2325444221,
-0.0142204948,
-0.1056075692,
-0.1740775257,
-0.4447996616,
-0.0282885954,
-0.4187423289,
0.7766198516,
0.7412090302,
-0.3538254201,
-0.1883455068,
-0.4944102168,
0.3682869971,
0.2525440753,
-1.0296639204,
0.1655594409,
0.3209123015,
0.1312020272,
-0.0310440492,
0.986500144,
-0.2045938075,
0.1026980355,
-0.2361870706,
-0.2193375081,
0.3354853094,
-0.7787483335,
0.0297419932,
0.209915638,
0.3267389238,
-0.1646650732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10505v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10505v2 | DePlot: One-shot visual language reasoning by plot-to-table translation | 2022-12-20T18:20:50 | 2023-05-23T18:28:39 | Fangyu Liu, Julian Martin Eisenschlos, Francesco Piccinno, Syrine Krichene, Chenxi Pang, Kenton Lee, Mandar Joshi, Wenhu Chen, Nigel Collier, Yasemin Altun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Visual language such as charts and plots is ubiquitous in the human world.
Comprehending plots and charts requires strong reasoning skills. Prior
state-of-the-art (SOTA) models require at least tens of thousands of training
examples and their reasoning capabilities are still much limited, especially on
complex human-written queries. This paper presents the first one-shot solution
to visual language reasoning. We decompose the challenge of visual language
reasoning into two steps: (1) plot-to-text translation, and (2) reasoning over
the translated text. The key in this method is a modality conversion module,
named as DePlot, which translates the image of a plot or chart to a linearized
table. The output of DePlot can then be directly used to prompt a pretrained
large language model (LLM), exploiting the few-shot reasoning capabilities of
LLMs. To obtain DePlot, we standardize the plot-to-table task by establishing
unified task formats and metrics, and train DePlot end-to-end on this task.
DePlot can then be used off-the-shelf together with LLMs in a plug-and-play
fashion. Compared with a SOTA model finetuned on more than >28k data points,
DePlot+LLM with just one-shot prompting achieves a 24.0% improvement over
finetuned SOTA on human-written queries from the task of chart QA. | [
-0.2397846133,
-1.0011782646,
0.8621281981,
0.1086494103,
-0.8017979264,
-0.2842130661,
0.0393925123,
-0.2021138668,
0.0413591489,
0.9019567966,
-0.5827890635,
-0.7266067863,
-0.4857945442,
0.0185293704,
-0.4353845716,
0.5449646115,
-0.1570129097,
0.0645198002,
-0.128804937,
-0.0225123707,
-0.5784423947,
-0.1719816774,
-0.4398198128,
-0.0874321088,
0.6690585017,
0.782363832,
0.7189700007,
0.5066786408,
0.6230100989,
0.2537021339,
0.2598607242,
0.1065342277,
-0.4847908914,
0.1490201652,
-0.0603899881,
-0.8118487597,
-0.5100690126,
0.0378230475,
0.3524258137,
0.6260969639,
0.361777842,
0.1552676708,
-0.2832325995,
0.8733004332,
-0.3964713812,
0.4173441231,
-0.4789173603,
0.0537937433,
-0.3263028264,
-0.3041046858,
-0.6055832505,
-0.3111216128,
-0.0503896624,
-0.7354508638,
-0.3324393034,
-0.1939915121,
0.6045387387,
0.618540287,
-0.6535915732,
0.2222260088,
-0.7901034951,
0.6417860985,
-0.6260203123,
0.21426557,
0.4173100889,
0.7616611719,
-0.0822444111,
-0.8774380088,
-0.7481861711,
-0.2907480896,
-0.0201645661,
0.0795201585,
-0.2763200998,
-0.1009570733,
0.4549556375,
-0.0630714968,
-0.8421773911,
0.026017772,
-0.3664000034,
0.2380842566,
0.7848449945,
0.2004531622,
0.4171910584,
-0.2171233892,
-0.6012326479,
-0.3154878616,
-0.7843780518,
-0.1639713049,
-0.1682347953,
0.2917568684,
-0.04059631,
0.45248276,
-0.2078244537,
0.6909040213,
-0.2511298656,
-0.2404963821,
-0.2102058828,
-0.0315786563,
-0.2982360125,
-0.0480468422,
0.7113475204,
0.357272476,
0.5970449448,
0.2381985039,
-0.0023668795,
0.1273348331,
-0.0050936746,
-0.7506782413,
-0.2879500687,
0.030416863,
-0.1201455742,
-0.1497180462,
-0.3360598087,
-0.6698067784,
-0.3749316931,
-0.2621306777,
0.5810719132,
-0.4922368526,
-0.0976304337,
0.1640876234,
-0.0126886489,
0.1454088837,
0.8402568698,
-0.6002582312,
-0.0604027286,
0.4089702964,
0.5623545647,
-0.1230061352,
-0.4032222629,
-0.4739383757,
0.2447386831,
-0.5315540433,
1.1368151903,
-0.3812900484,
-0.0914665908,
-0.1190838069,
-0.3715857267,
0.0555531755,
-0.2386892885,
0.403744489,
-0.3908693492,
0.1441542357,
-0.4788238108,
-0.3776921332,
-0.3466081917,
0.4406363368,
-0.5888929963,
0.6744427085,
0.2920499444,
-0.7014517188,
0.5091950893,
-0.5391017199,
-0.3893890381,
0.4606652558,
-0.5778195858,
-0.0997177884,
-0.1662142426,
0.4745401442,
0.3319935203,
-0.4438979626,
0.1272164732,
-0.1288928241,
-0.311881274,
0.1379761845,
-0.4656234682,
0.7543592453,
0.2665504217,
-0.2379402816,
0.1526706815,
-0.552719593,
0.0396839231,
0.441965282,
-0.1950190663,
-0.1388697922,
-0.0820494965,
0.1000288278,
0.292342186,
0.0461498573,
-0.3452916443,
0.6161322594,
-0.3771717548,
0.5006008148,
0.3052577376,
-0.0869091526,
0.3755726814,
0.1379859298,
0.7355864644,
0.0652120113,
0.1748345643,
-0.5147537589,
-0.4348120987,
-0.6820368171,
-0.4771546721,
0.0916190594,
0.6561449766,
-1.0864508152,
0.0911487266,
-0.4709914029,
-0.4809521735,
-0.0676773489,
-0.1036370844,
0.1027643681,
0.4685580432,
0.526491344,
-0.0071345442,
-0.0606941767,
-0.7861904502,
-0.0426037461,
-0.2834610641,
-0.058872588,
-0.2393304259,
0.5041345954,
-0.0174421687,
0.9217242002,
-0.7122853398,
-0.5264989734,
-0.7754272223,
0.3423902392,
0.0014591004,
0.4780923426,
0.7306073308,
-0.6311153769,
-0.6734919548,
0.0561985075,
-0.7541795373,
-0.2207649201,
-0.4506550133,
-0.3467094898,
0.0732991993,
0.7524635196,
-0.5868630409,
0.8388372064,
0.2401132435,
-0.5717509985,
0.4352774918,
-0.0680797175,
0.3476529419,
-0.606423974,
0.1961437166,
-0.2797933817,
-0.5122978091,
-0.6757250428,
0.0915972367,
-0.1051825285,
-0.3738241792,
-0.3714340031,
0.8291090131,
-0.1924737245,
0.1458979547,
-0.3444392681,
0.3789809048,
0.2527605295,
0.5810012817,
-0.0085976049,
0.4705271721,
0.7203520536,
-0.3305452168,
0.4671348333,
0.7164879441,
-0.2657300234,
0.6135526299,
-0.4354937077,
0.0992613509,
-0.27615273,
0.2214634567,
-1.2946891785,
-0.0276907999,
0.3453046679,
-0.2716124356,
0.2464855313,
-0.2458064407,
-0.5116586685,
-0.3329700828,
-0.0178946797,
0.30870682,
0.2993893027,
-0.4529721737,
0.3753362596,
-0.0117483223,
-0.2666452527,
-0.4193332791,
-1.0633736849,
0.2612976134,
0.0004712358,
-0.7655227184,
0.1463646293,
0.1445044875,
-0.0628130436,
-0.1194635108,
-0.272729367,
-0.3028079867,
-0.1452494264,
-0.0520335063,
0.1680602729,
-0.1990709901,
0.2467685789,
0.2156565189,
-0.5811921954,
-0.1224548221,
-0.045275446,
0.3949511349,
0.0250655487,
-0.7330454588,
-0.4838446081,
0.5486388803,
0.7801891565,
-0.3766807914,
0.2438296974,
0.3681991696,
-0.1394242793,
-0.2315969616,
-0.3163537979,
-0.1735050082,
-0.3916742206,
0.397654295,
-0.5847895145,
-0.3223488927,
0.3524047434,
-0.1348142773,
-0.0804454386,
0.295522958,
0.1891574115,
-0.240762949,
1.2200875282,
0.5726851225,
0.2559421062,
0.5462900996,
-0.482960552,
0.2174183428,
-0.0351039656,
-0.0762484074,
-0.2441946268,
-0.6315568686,
-0.1149145514,
-0.6090138555,
0.6554473042,
0.5229197145,
-0.2766781449,
0.289254725,
-0.3361397982,
0.6813447475,
0.4819704294,
0.3228234649,
0.6187643409,
0.0657050908,
0.036707215,
-0.1633823365,
-0.6899477243,
-0.6395590305,
0.7061001062,
0.1777878702,
1.0372463465,
-0.0934403241,
0.5469270349,
-0.1264329851,
0.2739646733,
-0.8837106824,
0.8969856501,
-0.4572096467,
-0.47098279,
-0.6213895082,
-0.3921460211,
-0.7846796513,
0.2623380125,
-0.2146213204,
-0.686119616,
0.1281610131,
0.2626608312,
0.0356507637,
0.1427891999,
-0.6606116295,
1.6326715946,
-0.5664539933,
-0.2148711532,
-0.3181873262,
-0.663624227,
0.3183477521,
0.287474066,
-0.1078168154,
-0.3663950861,
0.152656585,
0.2861658037,
-0.414678216,
0.7388127446,
-0.2335729748,
-0.0846652389,
0.4697853327,
0.6730749607,
0.5020136237,
-0.069506526,
0.0852701738,
0.0027439727,
0.3302976489,
-0.4497743845,
-0.8327792287,
0.2813657522,
-0.2953524292,
-0.5440235138,
-0.2227398902,
-0.7368436456,
-0.0493021533,
0.1753881574,
0.251593709,
0.4750525355,
-0.0858996361,
-0.0488308221,
0.3003084064,
-0.292462796,
0.1858763993,
0.3714171648,
-0.7178720832,
-0.1294639558,
0.6311817169,
0.0628696233,
0.5289488435,
0.5649098158,
0.3125935793,
-0.2904392481,
-0.3855342567,
-0.8090367913,
0.0751259774,
-1.1512759924,
-0.3022920489,
-0.3975059986,
0.1948958933,
-0.2440450191,
-0.3228781521,
-0.3981744349,
-0.5786183476,
-0.0493405387,
0.081852138,
0.4974876642,
0.4403192997,
0.08194381,
0.3161987066,
-0.866997242,
0.5004639626,
0.6326017976,
0.0159717016,
-0.4007049501,
-0.5343423486,
0.0831176043,
-0.1176211759,
-0.3603586257,
-1.366792798,
0.5393720269,
0.0709602088,
0.4594661593,
0.5454109907,
-0.0058205365,
0.7685079575,
-0.3803196549,
0.5067072511,
0.3321635723,
-0.9158900976,
0.885699451,
-0.3998506367,
0.6304001212,
0.6528161168,
0.3834964931,
-0.5342186093,
-0.312243104,
-0.2250548899,
-0.610050261,
0.6461808085,
0.0224010702,
-0.0392150693,
0.0121947899,
0.1421764642,
0.143986389,
0.0050471239,
-0.8901602626,
-0.0832398012,
-0.3831216097,
-0.1651471555,
0.0527276658,
0.0754246041,
-0.0603943877,
-0.6783605218,
0.2543888986,
-0.5175454617,
0.078028433,
0.1847589463,
-0.3378100097,
-0.27504915,
0.3383547664,
0.4284327924,
0.9174816012,
-0.0062483624,
0.3941129148,
0.0891086757,
-0.172381416,
0.0015987481,
0.0254719649,
-0.3150776625,
0.0705483854,
0.4390996695,
0.8614677191,
0.1414253116,
-0.8662182689,
0.7758738399,
0.2483056635,
-0.085804835,
0.2041997313,
-0.1768612862,
0.0296224318,
0.3834087849,
0.3293130696,
-0.1950987577,
-0.0779035687,
-0.5945739746,
0.1837922037,
0.3172112405,
-0.3134732544,
-0.2374372184,
0.7441164255,
0.2494811118,
0.0426626839,
0.3989583254,
-0.511842072,
-0.6765753627,
0.4277803302,
0.4820267558,
0.7867904902,
-0.0125348568,
0.5931214094,
0.5363515019,
0.4569268823,
0.028613979,
0.5761338472,
0.0201482438,
-0.4180980325,
-0.7416154742,
-0.3855900168,
-0.4297938347,
0.0899819285,
-0.1793185622,
0.4681157172,
-0.0720084608,
0.2146627158,
-0.0665274784,
-0.2829278111,
-0.6388025284,
-0.0016848563,
0.4897314906,
0.8833618164,
-1.0668184757,
0.8611872196,
0.7064843774,
-0.8920591474,
-0.5889891982,
-0.2473862022,
-0.2288898826,
-0.7837396264,
1.1163818836,
0.1011675522,
0.0367405377,
0.078871116,
-0.8848114014,
-0.6055352688,
0.8737229705,
0.8990010619,
-0.5182769299,
0.1378623843,
0.5214509368,
0.5095127225,
-0.214651078,
0.1515795588,
0.7392933965,
0.7540562153,
0.3557213843,
-0.8200058341,
0.1839276552,
0.1458972394,
-0.1947077364,
0.1297062039,
-0.1194692925,
0.9182184339,
-0.3730198741,
-0.4969300628,
-0.2737236619,
0.531224668,
0.0988751873,
0.3680080771,
0.4677654207,
0.5531392097,
0.3018682599,
-0.0775009841,
0.9062876105,
0.1441638917,
0.1877434105,
1.0555210114,
-0.185090363,
0.9934471846,
0.5600546598,
-0.3036580384,
0.4408761561,
0.1760979146,
0.1847958416,
0.4633853137,
0.078813009,
0.0183725003,
-0.713767767,
0.1969401091,
-0.226011917,
0.6175712943,
0.232894361,
-0.0622240715,
-0.7723071575,
0.2515166402,
-0.168489486,
0.4253343046,
-0.1179655567,
0.6198758483,
0.178086549,
-0.5374310613,
0.8336731791,
-0.3620907366,
0.1586002707,
-0.613334775,
-0.2914815545,
-0.4202392995,
0.011148381,
-0.0892072096,
-0.9278860092,
0.262986213,
0.0588086545,
0.1913414299,
-0.4018567801,
0.6966227293,
-0.7040211558,
-0.47145015,
0.0815048143,
0.7531927228,
0.3273127377,
-0.5251110792,
-0.6697382331,
-0.0184154157,
-0.080391705,
-0.3409568965,
0.0920635909,
0.6141891479,
-0.1199373081,
0.8643847704,
0.2158249021,
-0.1276446283,
0.1147159785,
0.2297659218,
0.9011900425,
-0.7788841128,
-0.4709492326,
-0.673979938,
0.649887979,
0.1693525463,
-0.3135402799,
0.319976151,
0.2817398012,
0.5266125202,
-0.33605811,
0.5934428573,
-0.086125128,
0.2658095062,
-0.5943143368,
0.6042376161,
-0.7542703748,
0.0156704914,
-0.1635592729,
-0.6909333467,
-0.5592409372,
0.7525556087,
-0.5070937276,
-0.3295664787,
0.9695383906,
0.6807684302,
-0.0405591168,
-0.3054892719,
0.6408920884,
0.1277512312,
0.4204784334,
0.6475562453,
0.8647097349,
-0.3735477924,
0.9960814118,
-0.1795598119,
-0.121094659,
-0.219912678,
-0.9712198377,
-0.8510990739,
-0.4694019854,
-0.5181545019,
0.1638364494,
-0.3062845469,
0.6350184679,
0.5689079165,
-0.655010581,
0.0009160244,
-0.2990679145,
0.1565939784,
-0.4036536515,
-0.1852518171,
0.2796097696,
-0.3411949873,
-0.6952852607,
0.5180701017,
0.5771099925,
0.104327634,
-0.4211273193,
0.0719826519,
-0.2619506419,
-0.0413740166,
0.752079308,
0.356033057,
-0.7439578772,
-0.3527997434,
-0.2082497925,
-0.3696992993,
0.2544843256,
0.7374531627,
-0.8329578638,
0.6356220245,
1.0205516815,
0.2943100035,
0.9743369818,
-0.0646952987,
0.3308934867,
-0.7939850688,
0.442641139,
0.3673613369,
0.1981906146,
0.1121335551,
0.0558310039,
0.5545406342,
0.1192737594,
-0.3857581913,
-0.8200586438,
0.5672932267,
-1.4229975939,
-0.5170145631,
0.912856698,
-0.0874771625,
-0.1070182696,
0.0646104068,
-0.7260144949,
0.256618768,
0.020960873,
0.5097868443,
0.2331874073,
-0.1302929372,
-0.3827454746,
-0.6111107469,
0.3970310688,
0.3432920575,
-1.2576699257,
0.2102418542,
0.5790455937,
-0.0686357021,
0.1050599292,
0.8798065186,
0.0513352565,
0.3240221739,
0.2964390516,
0.2141221166,
-0.1393600255,
-0.4576547742,
-0.0089935465,
-0.0447812267,
0.1173156947,
-0.1744156033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10504v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10504v2 | Can Current Task-oriented Dialogue Models Automate Real-world Scenarios in the Wild? | 2022-12-20T18:18:41 | 2023-05-24T11:46:33 | Sang-Woo Lee, Sungdong Kim, Donghyeon Ko, Donghoon Ham, Youngki Hong, Shin Ah Oh, Hyunhoon Jung, Wangkyo Jung, Kyunghyun Cho, Donghyun Kwak, Hyungsuk Noh, Woomyoung Park | cs.CL | cs.CL | Task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems are mainly based on the
slot-filling-based TOD (SF-TOD) framework, in which dialogues are broken down
into smaller, controllable units (i.e., slots) to fulfill a specific task. A
series of approaches based on this framework achieved remarkable success on
various TOD benchmarks. However, we argue that the current TOD benchmarks are
limited to surrogate real-world scenarios and that the current TOD models are
still a long way to cover the scenarios. In this position paper, we first
identify current status and limitations of SF-TOD systems. After that, we
explore the WebTOD framework, the alternative direction for building a scalable
TOD system when a web/mobile interface is available. In WebTOD, the dialogue
system learns how to understand the web/mobile interface that the human agent
interacts with, powered by a large-scale language model. | [
-0.5282008052,
-0.8022338748,
0.5569407344,
0.2384463698,
-0.3239587545,
0.1801623106,
0.1523568332,
-0.815844357,
-0.0147605725,
0.6614077687,
-0.8513336778,
-0.0827565566,
-0.2301578671,
0.0514341705,
-0.4764816761,
0.5979056954,
0.0189718008,
-0.1676143259,
-0.290389806,
-0.1066043526,
-0.4160191119,
-0.6256064177,
-0.7483826876,
-0.0277836695,
0.3225981593,
0.282394588,
0.7076861858,
0.5374251604,
0.3362087011,
0.3616693914,
0.3269318044,
-0.0382270738,
-0.1546384245,
0.5976125598,
-0.0754312575,
-0.3472797871,
-0.5356410742,
0.1517142653,
0.1352481693,
0.789986074,
-0.4094204605,
-0.2340012342,
-0.1298245639,
-0.0071085626,
-0.3455219865,
0.0497260429,
-0.5450177789,
0.1560750455,
0.214553833,
0.1160219982,
-0.2056265175,
-0.0814895257,
0.6276276112,
-0.7446691394,
0.1275333315,
-0.0218995214,
0.7201245427,
0.4495172799,
-0.4875291586,
-0.1101733744,
-0.9096721411,
0.7368739247,
-0.8170872927,
0.2794589102,
0.5440665483,
0.5990695953,
-0.2307696939,
-0.5588080287,
-0.7022401094,
-0.0172446296,
0.2176542431,
0.0016134303,
-0.1437517405,
0.2253489047,
0.2785822451,
-0.0152478805,
-0.5103569031,
0.2468128353,
0.0440395772,
0.0321697295,
0.5168026686,
0.5927851796,
0.2945033014,
-0.0895588621,
-0.3721673191,
-0.1074934155,
-0.4152134061,
0.0594669841,
-0.0361984335,
0.2875800729,
-0.0795813873,
0.3815817833,
-0.5114971399,
0.9628851414,
0.0070090299,
-0.3222703338,
-0.2867512107,
-0.3523449004,
-0.503813982,
-0.5450537801,
0.7353508472,
0.591149509,
0.0547955409,
-0.3915789425,
-0.2538084686,
-0.0772321895,
0.5910696387,
-0.5610083342,
0.1979400665,
0.50951159,
-0.305734396,
-0.2028951645,
-0.3584017158,
-0.6711812019,
-0.4486633539,
-0.2408145368,
0.3256545365,
-0.2101162374,
-0.3385705352,
-0.068065539,
-0.3584536016,
0.1080558971,
0.793727994,
-0.5502920151,
0.452078402,
0.6084468961,
0.9565492272,
-0.3752838373,
-0.2798787951,
-0.3039482832,
0.1853580922,
-0.293181479,
0.8892528415,
-0.5409926176,
-0.7589917779,
0.0903153718,
-0.0366928205,
-0.1044694632,
-0.5323293805,
0.3521576524,
-0.3998481035,
0.0301482715,
-0.0303339977,
-0.14758192,
-0.0060291993,
0.5522337556,
-0.4780308902,
0.7009336352,
0.1155870333,
-0.3402110636,
0.35977754,
-0.7422768474,
-0.3584945202,
-0.0317906328,
0.1568616778,
-0.1580615044,
0.009268322,
-0.0058091898,
0.518312633,
-0.6278941631,
0.6495859623,
-0.5563291907,
-0.2625707388,
0.2962131202,
-0.6244680882,
0.567191422,
0.5360218287,
-0.4634649158,
0.0234612823,
-0.7051054835,
0.0964348987,
-0.1970719397,
-0.0714391991,
-0.2998771369,
0.1534423232,
0.4075519443,
0.4078495502,
-0.0554493815,
-0.8458843231,
0.3196897209,
-0.2660595477,
0.6340266466,
0.7085399032,
-0.1176161617,
0.4419231415,
-0.4598931074,
0.835916698,
0.0064468477,
0.2520968914,
-0.1643646955,
-0.4490950108,
-0.7596180439,
-0.4986547232,
0.2108202428,
0.6759172678,
-0.7667737603,
0.2061569244,
-0.2316134125,
-0.5208231807,
0.0455849282,
-0.5460627675,
0.3208537698,
0.1875675172,
-0.0353401154,
-0.432970047,
-0.4898833632,
-0.7595588565,
-0.2114485055,
-0.1707705855,
-0.0560904704,
0.420101732,
0.1585632563,
-0.2845459878,
1.476314187,
-0.194594115,
-0.2213149071,
-0.2972328365,
0.0749402046,
-0.006101029,
0.6232832074,
0.3068044484,
-1.0700347424,
-0.7131092548,
0.0467538275,
-0.7258858681,
-0.0594265237,
-0.1050927266,
0.1539871246,
0.0098858383,
0.3503288627,
-1.0069857836,
0.7260649204,
0.4540317655,
-0.1028182283,
0.4569424391,
-0.0138004757,
0.1417881101,
-1.0169955492,
-0.1212395355,
0.0868633315,
-0.4254726768,
-0.8395638466,
-0.0138601875,
-0.3036915064,
-0.6345440149,
-0.4025982022,
1.0255230665,
-0.1991138607,
-0.4962806404,
-0.3513234556,
0.038651932,
-0.1174015105,
0.7606761456,
0.2404042631,
0.7906578183,
0.3949847817,
-0.7762157917,
0.3021460772,
0.1765710413,
-0.1742418408,
0.8126422763,
-0.6069400311,
-0.1466441453,
0.2218009084,
0.9190347791,
-0.8581137657,
-0.4942105711,
-0.062695317,
-0.245484069,
-0.1635570228,
-0.4134289324,
-0.4454621673,
-0.3521868885,
0.0913194269,
0.3407180011,
0.5046942234,
-0.3324511349,
0.7635341287,
0.5070652962,
-0.5014102459,
-0.3482711017,
-0.2521750629,
0.4403373897,
-0.2152634561,
-0.557094574,
0.2989536524,
0.0256066024,
-0.4020507336,
-0.1806940585,
-0.2321941704,
-0.5869164467,
0.2408532053,
0.6692077518,
0.0550383776,
0.1241063178,
0.0076964633,
0.0674907044,
-0.0930908695,
-0.1946550012,
-0.6974151134,
0.5057623386,
0.214858979,
-0.5369635224,
-0.7413814664,
0.7291987538,
1.0803569555,
-0.1072235405,
0.2733195722,
0.3393960595,
-0.5361727476,
0.0182299409,
-0.6462891698,
0.0575727932,
-0.5013573766,
0.2739341855,
-0.5970662236,
-0.7838231921,
0.5408232808,
-0.4205783308,
0.4448802471,
0.2299483269,
0.380645901,
-0.4851170778,
1.363889575,
0.9035520554,
0.4029577971,
0.6055718064,
-0.3076644838,
0.1715683192,
-0.8637325168,
-0.0226951316,
-0.5105546117,
-0.3000603616,
-0.502356112,
-0.5837991238,
0.4936544001,
0.0696843714,
-0.1190713346,
0.5201675296,
-0.2517664433,
0.1070062369,
0.4978480637,
-0.2686535418,
0.1643919349,
-0.2709067166,
-0.3810626268,
0.1949542165,
-0.8766360283,
-0.6650926471,
1.0645340681,
0.1813509613,
0.7117054462,
0.1289229691,
0.4764452577,
0.5110865831,
0.4069154859,
-0.5858795643,
0.7244901061,
0.1539946645,
-0.6460760236,
-0.7188237309,
0.0209430456,
-1.0229325294,
0.5603705645,
0.0905676186,
-0.9245384336,
0.5288796425,
-0.031766437,
-0.4405342937,
0.1599473804,
-0.9225117564,
0.8680725098,
-0.0044319378,
-0.427333802,
-0.3062823117,
-0.5652000904,
0.0721701756,
0.0482872427,
0.395077318,
-0.2188236713,
0.0833105594,
0.5039548874,
-0.872707665,
1.1633417606,
-0.4281384051,
-0.2909639776,
0.3445115387,
-0.006526493,
0.7733094096,
0.0941346511,
-0.0404226147,
-0.3463823199,
0.2688454092,
-0.5463119149,
-0.6035321951,
0.5927044749,
-0.4914045036,
-0.762490809,
-0.4996470809,
-0.7231340408,
-0.7895925045,
0.00929779,
-0.0628520697,
0.8723333478,
-0.4954583347,
-0.1921736449,
0.5443555117,
-0.1368684173,
0.8723061681,
0.4728545845,
-0.125259608,
-0.0487436727,
0.8309593201,
-0.1106568873,
0.2679090202,
0.3148768246,
-0.2594211996,
-0.3767941892,
-0.4928818941,
-0.8847644925,
-0.259047389,
-0.469440341,
-0.1002606377,
-1.0884637833,
0.1619680226,
-0.2766890824,
-0.3156870604,
-0.2588028014,
-0.6147828102,
0.0113292914,
0.0913568586,
0.1756723672,
0.7359341979,
0.0940012187,
0.337518394,
-0.8641327024,
0.3890260458,
0.7407711148,
0.4582457542,
0.2135944664,
-0.0952812955,
-0.3050860465,
0.406409651,
-0.280736059,
-0.5893496275,
0.5701801777,
-0.0940727219,
0.5526525378,
0.2023193836,
0.2224592119,
0.8097113967,
-0.4750260711,
0.8362377286,
0.2977370024,
-0.6342553496,
0.3238995075,
-0.6641457677,
0.4609110355,
0.2913848758,
0.2372532785,
-0.7048149705,
-0.6637576222,
-0.6049266458,
-0.4266309738,
0.8628963828,
-0.1222545207,
0.2188609987,
-0.0145553481,
0.01020924,
0.2786294222,
0.2284654975,
-0.6060094237,
0.3133441806,
-0.356194973,
-0.1989652812,
0.1140834242,
0.1425105631,
-0.098297976,
0.0723754019,
0.2681137025,
-0.2545941472,
0.4544273019,
0.2983846366,
-0.1798012704,
-0.0683971718,
0.5394652486,
0.6116808653,
0.719039917,
-0.1482607573,
-0.3144620359,
-0.0167310573,
-0.4077321589,
0.3520288467,
0.0572192781,
-0.0553316213,
-0.2065209299,
-0.0364190601,
0.7921689749,
0.1478278339,
-1.256492734,
0.3490608037,
-0.2033809274,
-0.0243510604,
-0.2355323434,
0.2079643011,
-0.0839124694,
0.4047836959,
0.7159551978,
0.2590587139,
0.1567507535,
-0.9147118926,
-0.0049427496,
0.6687500477,
-0.698118329,
-0.2977926135,
0.6341810822,
0.7865547538,
-0.6314946413,
0.3195550144,
-0.348852545,
-0.6242155433,
0.7932879329,
0.4687421918,
0.9039790034,
0.1780221611,
0.3178029358,
0.1267912835,
-0.0901596174,
-0.0116043817,
0.0995820761,
-0.4215269983,
-0.5163250566,
-0.5893793702,
-0.6870476007,
-0.7517903447,
-0.1452938914,
-0.4411305189,
-0.1839189976,
-0.4065526724,
-0.4306785762,
-0.1375320554,
-0.187874943,
-0.6149454713,
0.5677861571,
-0.2801330388,
0.6730269194,
-0.4451251328,
1.10736835,
0.6952273846,
0.0451336317,
-0.4498981237,
0.2423241585,
-0.0600496195,
-0.4441064596,
0.7152711153,
-0.0113930842,
-0.0322470926,
0.1397248656,
-0.260843277,
-0.8299558163,
1.0065828562,
-0.3156794012,
-0.5126637816,
-0.2824529707,
-0.0208704676,
0.6543315053,
-0.4985181391,
0.225809589,
0.0998145789,
0.3557228744,
0.0848811418,
-1.4882467985,
-0.1300068945,
-0.3340989947,
0.1564074159,
0.2433186918,
-0.5325873494,
0.7376733422,
-0.1983114034,
-0.1979533732,
0.3791162968,
0.2358694226,
0.006739039,
0.2643510401,
0.8059569001,
0.5258222818,
0.2749590576,
-0.1485903561,
1.0861868858,
0.0653454661,
-0.0549726635,
0.7955001593,
-0.593259275,
0.7568309307,
0.2427017242,
-0.3453142941,
0.4971323907,
0.7736459374,
0.3156726062,
0.5320807099,
0.0030862617,
-0.2626337111,
-0.5519828796,
-0.2329875231,
-0.0188383572,
0.4522193372,
0.5310961008,
0.4845232069,
-0.2072700709,
0.6385668516,
-0.551721096,
-0.0550691523,
0.0600781478,
0.9344992638,
-0.1678038687,
-1.1048611403,
0.6192327738,
0.2376053631,
0.7444084883,
-0.5342469811,
-0.1035099104,
-0.2257882059,
-0.2000123858,
0.2258816659,
-0.3128407001,
0.2824918628,
0.2325799912,
-0.0991449431,
-0.601033926,
0.5696802139,
-0.1758664995,
-0.0944323763,
-0.1706952155,
0.6438281536,
-0.0043134955,
-0.033471141,
-0.5871392488,
-0.0423315242,
-0.0476564616,
-0.0105646867,
0.7771416306,
0.4492965639,
-0.5545648932,
1.2758276463,
0.7864753008,
-0.4887538254,
0.1350330561,
-0.1917942762,
0.6787666678,
-0.7866133451,
-0.8430506587,
-0.1929706484,
0.3553266227,
-0.2176228464,
-0.2428821772,
0.4436804056,
0.40567711,
0.5516968369,
0.0597724207,
1.0843824148,
-0.4141039252,
0.7520818114,
-0.1249204427,
0.4069749117,
-0.5453295708,
0.1976150721,
-0.2152813226,
-0.8626759648,
0.1061047018,
0.546877265,
-0.0277824216,
-0.036103338,
0.6219995022,
0.4749020934,
-0.1186342761,
0.2535920739,
0.581820488,
0.114691779,
0.3611498177,
0.2346683443,
1.0435540676,
-0.2480420172,
0.6669929028,
-0.0353346989,
-0.2198819369,
-0.4006216824,
-0.5885211825,
-0.6045705676,
-0.9158979654,
-0.1225679889,
0.1278105229,
0.2899110615,
0.7140343189,
1.0343636274,
-0.4254254997,
-0.4898169935,
-0.3710156381,
0.1385994256,
-0.5708814263,
-0.2333542705,
-0.162204057,
-0.2841751873,
-1.1423811913,
0.4620972276,
0.6057065725,
0.3007240593,
-0.2960421443,
0.0598680079,
-0.182238847,
0.2570419312,
0.6046456695,
0.4546809196,
-1.1516996622,
-0.1913820356,
0.1455743909,
-0.2310765982,
-0.1076685786,
1.0232057571,
-1.1427433491,
0.446905911,
0.1237741634,
0.4200339317,
0.7594053149,
-0.0681564435,
1.1671032906,
-0.4260114729,
0.3492817283,
0.3666913807,
0.0411742106,
0.0584101565,
-0.0021951084,
0.5595982075,
0.1540683061,
-0.2013689876,
-1.0367380381,
0.483751893,
-1.1804891825,
-0.3715577424,
0.9100465775,
-0.3020736277,
0.2103250772,
-0.8748770356,
-0.2729737759,
-0.0680568516,
-0.2274559289,
0.5217339993,
0.5334093571,
-0.2654449642,
-0.141390413,
-0.6518130302,
0.552295506,
0.3489787579,
-0.9978566766,
0.3884340227,
0.4660982788,
0.1770439744,
0.1143792719,
1.0200212002,
0.2665431499,
0.4367354512,
0.0820808336,
-0.1436374635,
0.0925674289,
-0.1201151758,
0.2613965869,
0.0524934642,
-0.0380134434,
0.1473486125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10503v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10503v2 | Mini-Model Adaptation: Efficiently Extending Pretrained Models to New Languages via Aligned Shallow Training | 2022-12-20T18:17:28 | 2023-07-04T19:06:55 | Kelly Marchisio, Patrick Lewis, Yihong Chen, Mikel Artetxe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Prior work shows that it is possible to expand pretrained Masked Language
Models (MLMs) to new languages by learning a new set of embeddings, while
keeping the transformer body frozen. Despite learning a small subset of
parameters, this approach is not compute-efficient, as training the new
embeddings requires a full forward and backward pass over the entire model. We
propose mini-model adaptation, a compute-efficient alternative that builds a
shallow mini-model from a fraction of a large model's parameters. New
language-specific embeddings can then be efficiently trained over the
mini-model and plugged into the aligned large model for rapid cross-lingual
transfer. We explore two approaches to learn mini-models: MiniJoint, which
jointly pretrains the primary model and the mini-model using a single
transformer with a secondary MLM head at a middle layer; and MiniPost, where we
start from a regular pretrained model, build a mini-model by extracting and
freezing a few layers, and learn a small number of parameters on top.
Experiments on XNLI, MLQA and PAWS-X show that mini-model adaptation matches
the performance of the standard approach using 2.3x less compute on average. | [
-0.3639506102,
-0.4789315462,
0.2997025251,
-0.1823364943,
-0.3382662237,
0.0206490997,
-0.3213860393,
-0.3290743828,
0.222330153,
0.384478718,
-0.6904883981,
-0.1161473766,
-0.4810895622,
-0.1729240566,
-0.2407535613,
0.8208696842,
0.122010231,
0.0533366837,
-0.1589802802,
-0.0983422399,
-0.4376820624,
-0.2556714118,
-0.7675521374,
-0.3676093817,
0.3573290408,
0.5761822462,
0.7656977177,
0.6772043109,
0.2232735306,
0.2942657471,
0.4143466055,
-0.1603896618,
-0.6426964998,
-0.4229183495,
-0.1890491396,
-0.690633893,
-0.3480661511,
-0.0727156773,
0.7183895707,
0.8837965131,
0.0866392925,
0.3829181492,
0.1749171913,
0.655854702,
-0.6884077787,
0.0656892508,
-0.6912024021,
0.0688129961,
-0.0444784798,
0.2006614655,
-0.4040140808,
-0.0889716372,
0.3548767567,
-0.7322797179,
0.0944780931,
0.1529397517,
0.5004040003,
0.3682452142,
-0.2053298056,
-0.2168767303,
-0.884629786,
0.8538413644,
-0.4783553779,
0.7005451322,
0.1289605349,
0.56721735,
0.285854429,
-0.7358295321,
-0.2819392085,
-0.2232548743,
-0.3207938373,
-0.0176945385,
-0.4145280421,
-0.1664603651,
0.2402230799,
0.2219874412,
-0.6500126719,
0.3950549662,
-0.163997665,
-0.0558309034,
0.5337286592,
-0.0277273189,
0.2012369782,
0.0326808691,
-0.4323823452,
-0.2407533377,
-0.8584657907,
0.1378825307,
0.2692281008,
0.4787841439,
-0.4317766726,
0.1716203243,
0.160705626,
0.4862726629,
0.3741773963,
-0.1061682105,
0.000940169,
-0.3056945205,
-0.2914536595,
-0.1052675396,
0.5661860704,
-0.1183863282,
0.3252936006,
-0.0971806049,
-0.2579230964,
-0.1400949061,
0.0757458583,
-0.7401139736,
-0.736659646,
-0.2382853478,
-0.4293976426,
-0.1254586428,
-0.2867920101,
-0.555369854,
-0.2926621139,
-0.3183424771,
0.6592803597,
-0.2137327343,
-0.2457216382,
0.0418208018,
0.1183330864,
0.3787891567,
0.2635650933,
-0.9896883368,
0.8019248247,
0.414637804,
0.7334789634,
-0.0112920254,
-0.3043835163,
-0.5502785444,
0.0499002188,
-0.3668272793,
0.5738243461,
-0.4087064862,
-0.1214643344,
-0.116831027,
0.1256232262,
-0.2994529009,
-0.6372913718,
0.2364628315,
-0.5540698171,
0.31339854,
-0.0076529793,
-0.2870506942,
-0.0549183004,
-0.0983553007,
-0.8186733723,
0.9751772881,
0.1668713242,
-0.5755841732,
0.2073352933,
-0.5420742035,
-0.4804624021,
-0.2897711396,
0.0068634194,
-0.2534033656,
0.4136009216,
0.4216519296,
0.3134679496,
-0.3476116359,
-0.3544054031,
-0.3289738595,
-0.4059045315,
0.0414513908,
-0.1363107711,
0.7541205883,
0.0013364694,
-0.1877551675,
-0.0443018414,
-0.5670492649,
-0.066332981,
0.168654263,
-0.0088754436,
-0.4992705882,
-0.2481503785,
-0.2312141061,
0.3264156282,
0.0666631907,
-0.1065482274,
0.2399306148,
-0.523354888,
0.1892092079,
0.7592931986,
-0.3891690969,
1.2531143427,
-0.3105985522,
0.6652414799,
0.1267778426,
0.1659070402,
-0.1564818621,
-0.1633789688,
-1.2685040236,
-0.2800896168,
0.9429208636,
0.575648129,
-1.11687994,
0.1960801035,
-0.5846328139,
-0.5039932728,
-0.8253752589,
0.43778947,
0.3985747993,
0.1944194883,
0.3673878312,
-0.359921813,
-0.73068434,
-0.8937699795,
-0.387948662,
0.1002083421,
-0.0199162718,
0.1662817746,
0.5715572238,
-0.1405970603,
0.8090684414,
-0.3994740546,
-0.1951521188,
-0.3633081019,
-0.132537961,
0.1864911467,
0.7410093546,
0.7542230487,
-0.4973330498,
-0.9093668461,
-0.0234072804,
-0.3340089321,
0.0853442922,
-0.0551793575,
-0.1742202938,
-0.0592909716,
0.6268218756,
-0.6173035502,
0.1734383106,
0.8298013806,
0.1894999892,
0.2725259662,
-0.0802900642,
-0.4212734103,
-0.9612492323,
-0.0461783484,
-0.3511521816,
-0.6724442244,
-0.9382368922,
-0.0841927752,
0.0609303005,
-0.2646068037,
-0.594665885,
0.9700248241,
-0.8491065502,
-0.2450110316,
-0.569519043,
0.1258832812,
-0.1506361216,
0.536095798,
0.1304891855,
0.3602115214,
0.791970551,
-0.5558826327,
0.1308032274,
-0.0544502102,
-0.3406510949,
0.0771807358,
-0.3966813982,
0.5772427917,
-0.0852561072,
0.1459048241,
-0.5680647492,
-0.0070165289,
0.4286416471,
-0.126359269,
0.5832129121,
-0.6450462937,
-0.1973330528,
-0.1959306449,
-0.2341873497,
0.6229119897,
0.9292469025,
-0.7345113158,
0.8757894635,
0.345148325,
-0.2452653199,
-0.5380254388,
-0.6827311516,
-0.2052234113,
-0.1725243777,
-0.4474912882,
0.2494984865,
-0.0418360047,
-0.0005936195,
0.2679532468,
-0.1020184532,
-0.037757162,
0.1421592832,
0.0360023566,
-0.0679256469,
-0.5927128196,
-0.0711496398,
0.1869899035,
-0.3307561278,
-0.2775887251,
-0.4694478512,
0.503868103,
-0.231079489,
-0.2581914961,
-0.3866901398,
0.415628314,
0.3200536966,
0.0428314619,
0.8017291427,
0.749153018,
-0.6615365148,
-0.3920502067,
-0.3775325119,
-0.4435777962,
-0.4853825867,
0.3042145967,
-0.7341942787,
-0.8599059582,
0.3643289506,
-0.2201200724,
-0.1168333218,
0.3616963625,
0.5013974905,
-0.2068820298,
1.0010024309,
1.4070489407,
-0.1757904887,
0.6289693117,
-0.2303975374,
0.1680717468,
-0.5631422997,
0.2037845999,
-0.3518291116,
-0.4238887131,
-0.6569548249,
-0.7815076113,
0.1110175624,
0.3933309913,
-0.0021568916,
0.5218286514,
0.1243377998,
0.6197879314,
0.4970261753,
-0.0115679484,
0.1629560143,
0.0374723226,
-0.1407791823,
-0.0307023041,
-1.2171123028,
-0.3387411237,
0.8842200041,
0.4666318297,
0.9497380853,
0.1930890679,
0.5606099963,
0.0871773362,
0.5600600243,
-0.7390832901,
0.3081890941,
-0.495244056,
-0.5076138377,
-0.2209779769,
-0.3878850937,
-0.645442903,
0.4431701899,
-0.359487772,
-0.6458241343,
0.4073975682,
0.5014190078,
-0.607940793,
0.2748976648,
-0.9873416424,
0.9059608579,
-0.252782315,
-0.1911942065,
0.0328411125,
-0.7087218761,
0.4674182832,
-0.4963818192,
0.4035674036,
-0.0816645548,
-0.0866653398,
0.7682488561,
-0.2325356305,
1.087471962,
-0.3968509734,
0.1485072672,
0.064614296,
0.1298432946,
0.6603947282,
-0.099510327,
0.000177515,
0.0654764846,
0.0407883711,
-0.6041753888,
-0.9156115651,
0.3562527597,
-0.8462101817,
-0.7503705025,
-0.1651818603,
-0.5336041451,
-0.2851607502,
0.3716515601,
0.1407262385,
0.164388448,
-0.3058998287,
0.0777818635,
0.492952615,
-0.0140142944,
0.3694930673,
0.4821353555,
-0.4370338321,
-0.2513773441,
0.6989284754,
-0.0873265564,
0.3573288321,
0.6130639315,
0.486336112,
-0.2976997495,
-0.5706890225,
-0.642111063,
0.3672117889,
-0.6530671716,
-0.0932219699,
-0.58175385,
-0.2711133361,
-0.5000155568,
-0.1875725836,
-0.8022707105,
-0.5219353437,
-0.2798774242,
0.2148754299,
-0.1494186521,
0.4540339708,
-0.3165362775,
0.6202144027,
-0.8077211976,
0.1767205894,
0.5541041493,
-0.0420036577,
-0.0904587656,
-0.9448014498,
-0.70049119,
0.1442943066,
0.1173572466,
-0.559214294,
0.2609313726,
0.5721262693,
0.5976974964,
0.4310884774,
0.0477221534,
0.9158194661,
-0.8452616334,
0.3724387288,
0.3103604913,
-1.1139974594,
0.2124317884,
0.1214538738,
0.3395896852,
0.5101550221,
0.6947687864,
-0.2848062217,
0.077167578,
-0.4791606367,
-0.2324766219,
0.666567266,
0.064676404,
0.3604937494,
0.7092093825,
0.3820063174,
0.3877829313,
-0.0005180759,
-0.9277297854,
-0.1039441079,
-0.1885418147,
-0.1867305189,
-0.4778022766,
-0.3105581999,
-0.2494627684,
-0.4564071298,
0.6250593066,
-0.6069570184,
0.4363777936,
-0.3402980268,
-0.7595258355,
-0.0276545137,
0.0275953468,
0.4758839905,
0.383379817,
-0.0245829001,
0.494685173,
0.5979962349,
-0.2242442816,
0.3013710678,
0.0615742244,
-0.1195027307,
-0.0778758302,
0.458675921,
1.0613543987,
0.4878827035,
-0.2799301445,
0.6701618433,
-0.0544133633,
0.0045824284,
-0.1705869436,
0.0632904321,
0.2014021426,
0.4413276017,
-0.0591355041,
0.2743181288,
-0.1684690118,
-0.650459826,
0.1670811921,
0.3203547895,
-0.6026130915,
-0.6610850096,
0.339987427,
0.1183962673,
-0.1918005049,
0.4236472547,
-0.0971842408,
-0.4405017793,
0.1989436746,
0.7258651853,
0.976162374,
-0.413084507,
0.0799048245,
0.0900200978,
0.7377746701,
0.0963172391,
-0.0591652766,
-0.1099414825,
-1.014323473,
-0.5266680121,
-0.562490046,
-0.227844879,
0.0396622829,
-0.67261374,
0.3560009599,
-0.4436474442,
0.0060824188,
-0.1987157911,
-0.0220077615,
-0.9566186666,
0.2056637853,
0.2728800178,
1.0600802898,
-1.2588613033,
1.2736787796,
0.7661463022,
0.0643492863,
-0.5366640687,
-0.0428989977,
-0.1646734774,
-0.9279405475,
0.4098020792,
-0.0109413341,
-0.2719519138,
0.0773118436,
-0.2132010311,
-1.1865124702,
0.9645164609,
0.7525789738,
-0.5460181832,
-0.1891602278,
0.1641931683,
0.5031692386,
-0.732952714,
0.1792653352,
0.677095294,
0.0604974218,
-0.1859898716,
-0.8197365999,
0.1961787343,
-0.1699245274,
0.2935481966,
0.0044839536,
-0.6300005913,
0.7681192756,
-0.1837436259,
-0.4055572152,
0.1678809226,
0.7687247992,
-0.1359908283,
0.0472222678,
0.9359193444,
0.4671746194,
0.6563338041,
0.0957972631,
0.7618227005,
-0.2098046541,
0.3800522089,
1.4005542994,
-0.2432967126,
0.8366692066,
0.3874638081,
0.062241476,
0.6351187229,
0.5516291857,
0.1950755864,
0.826472342,
0.0746206492,
-0.0318565555,
-0.3625985384,
0.1436229944,
-0.2906767726,
0.5016390085,
0.3171172142,
-0.2843475938,
-0.0313370004,
0.3367344439,
-0.0846472755,
-0.3756681681,
-0.3069682121,
0.7416661978,
0.4015259147,
-0.3880936205,
0.4588404894,
0.1523660123,
0.4695653319,
-0.4173799753,
0.3183125556,
-0.2456149906,
0.2701331377,
0.0100569213,
-0.1014501676,
0.2732790112,
-0.0498685203,
-0.3450902998,
-0.332762152,
1.1086580753,
-0.568328321,
-0.6002687216,
0.2636706829,
0.8235132098,
0.0704672635,
0.0820279494,
-0.9312026501,
0.0287594888,
-0.1885229498,
-0.1446748376,
0.4046592712,
0.0683226511,
0.0245302264,
0.5191126466,
0.6492584944,
-0.0451365747,
0.5158814192,
-0.0151228104,
0.939760685,
-0.4682733715,
-0.473629266,
-0.671517849,
0.5051841736,
0.1336399764,
0.1725343317,
0.7108197212,
0.4385990202,
1.128849864,
-0.328594178,
0.6224594116,
0.2511936426,
0.4390614331,
-0.8837304115,
0.6248959899,
-0.6594539881,
0.2129953653,
-0.1465285867,
-1.0161787271,
-0.0935990736,
0.4146002829,
-0.421184212,
0.337484628,
0.7666017413,
0.8068085313,
-0.5180744529,
-0.1349442601,
0.6215723157,
0.2396491021,
-0.0498737544,
0.6498020291,
1.0136010647,
-0.6237072349,
0.4009119868,
-0.7830166817,
-0.3717915416,
-0.2137921453,
-0.935715735,
-0.9816776514,
-0.2968207598,
-0.4558831751,
0.0654304326,
-0.0324126594,
0.7391603589,
1.2348611355,
-0.8669543862,
-0.3308113813,
0.2803934813,
0.1395568848,
-0.2586610913,
-0.1318540722,
0.4933461845,
-0.1456092,
-0.8789368272,
0.5644133091,
0.1753310263,
0.0900302455,
-0.271601975,
-0.1270895451,
-0.0476083569,
0.1800528914,
0.639759481,
0.3706140518,
-0.3693939447,
-0.4012530446,
-0.0372153297,
0.023918774,
-0.0343074538,
1.0779126883,
-0.6378552318,
0.3155781329,
0.305826813,
0.8911629915,
0.7596932054,
-0.2901421785,
0.5136907101,
-0.8558406234,
0.3900357485,
0.1205891743,
0.3113214672,
0.3583757877,
-0.0445691533,
0.1458134204,
0.2835558951,
-0.1063372418,
-0.8429974318,
0.5116049647,
-0.6782363057,
-0.1937201768,
0.830401063,
-0.1842062622,
-0.3587849438,
-0.0746373013,
0.2552710176,
0.1997829378,
0.275770843,
0.3218953311,
0.2757888138,
-0.1346669495,
-0.6635050774,
-0.3943292201,
0.6075180173,
0.567677021,
-0.6501594186,
-0.1961966306,
-0.1266594827,
0.5328018069,
0.0587591231,
0.7518458962,
0.1360063255,
0.1938074529,
0.2478831857,
-0.0660456195,
0.1262109876,
-0.6522622705,
-0.6624999642,
-0.0229570381,
0.132172063,
-0.2248296291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10502v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10502v2 | A Measure-Theoretic Characterization of Tight Language Models | 2022-12-20T18:17:11 | 2023-08-21T18:01:57 | Li Du, Lucas Torroba Hennigen, Tiago Pimentel, Clara Meister, Jason Eisner, Ryan Cotterell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.FL | Language modeling, a central task in natural language processing, involves
estimating a probability distribution over strings. In most cases, the
estimated distribution sums to 1 over all finite strings. However, in some
pathological cases, probability mass can ``leak'' onto the set of infinite
sequences. In order to characterize the notion of leakage more precisely, this
paper offers a measure-theoretic treatment of language modeling. We prove that
many popular language model families are in fact tight, meaning that they will
not leak in this sense. We also generalize characterizations of tightness
proposed in previous works. | [
0.0467612967,
-0.7936887741,
0.779263556,
-0.2232567817,
-0.2823039591,
-0.2693169117,
-0.3213685453,
-0.467415303,
-0.0166200753,
0.535340488,
-0.2447936684,
-0.1720234901,
-0.7044747472,
-0.5017728209,
-0.8225347996,
0.9457718134,
-0.1534405053,
-0.2201882601,
0.0084011033,
-0.2256736308,
-0.037035197,
-0.2958981991,
0.1074778065,
-0.0958359241,
0.1442310959,
0.2004691362,
1.128837347,
0.9793598056,
0.5737612247,
0.2146694511,
-0.0387962498,
-0.3803512156,
-0.271561861,
0.4529261291,
-0.2230082452,
-0.6920815706,
-0.0065654553,
0.1846228838,
0.8967316747,
0.9547040462,
-0.4542595148,
0.2512422502,
-0.084422715,
0.4421102405,
-0.7251769304,
0.0456440486,
-0.5162717104,
-0.1522867829,
-0.6195635796,
0.1176641956,
-0.3055917621,
-0.3040311038,
0.3636683226,
-0.312394172,
0.354709357,
0.029912198,
0.7352377176,
0.2141708881,
-0.1708149612,
-0.3766892254,
-1.0600005388,
0.8136917353,
-0.9107961059,
0.5090485215,
0.6819903255,
0.4814442992,
0.0103832902,
-0.0994024947,
-0.4612417817,
-0.4570760727,
0.0894749835,
-0.4167409837,
0.0315341204,
0.0138951773,
0.0663314462,
0.7012906075,
-0.5516212583,
-0.0414678417,
-0.4702461362,
-0.213696897,
0.8301356435,
0.1133231223,
0.6553584933,
0.191307053,
-0.3558583856,
0.1048170924,
-0.6066764593,
-0.2770543993,
0.555800736,
0.1813258827,
-0.353174448,
0.5093400478,
0.23582232,
0.9521098137,
-0.6467196345,
-0.2325520217,
-0.5591754913,
-0.2712527215,
-0.1885160506,
-0.3604421616,
0.7308125496,
-0.273005873,
0.7549995184,
-0.2781305313,
-0.1126040742,
-0.108476907,
-0.0163828414,
-0.5245413184,
-0.4900643826,
0.2385511696,
-0.160794884,
-0.3187290728,
0.4038571715,
-0.2582455873,
-0.1751390398,
0.0119347321,
0.1900617182,
-0.6565705538,
-0.5217517614,
0.4083585143,
-0.2237457484,
-0.1996791363,
-0.2955361009,
-1.1643381119,
0.9310900569,
0.7909241915,
0.8578875661,
0.1195016205,
-0.0140018584,
-0.0979922265,
0.3386071622,
-0.3670559525,
0.7695506811,
-0.6880127192,
-0.0396954939,
0.1252893955,
-0.3941842914,
-0.1588912755,
-0.2894167006,
0.5096758604,
0.0256194957,
0.0092662964,
0.0396077074,
-1.1106642485,
-0.1661686152,
-0.003052196,
-0.6829257011,
0.4345293343,
0.3109481633,
-0.8430461884,
0.2956902981,
-0.2275658846,
-0.0954409316,
0.0078637619,
-0.0824006349,
-0.2935522497,
0.5081731081,
-0.1509929895,
0.4851000309,
0.048610568,
0.2289185375,
-0.7690421343,
-0.6650967598,
0.802511096,
-0.4208176136,
0.9326884747,
0.6586598158,
0.2559990287,
-0.3673289716,
-0.4032182693,
0.1221675202,
-0.0318631567,
-0.0567284934,
-0.5804514289,
0.0579662174,
-0.0703814402,
-0.0265101641,
-0.1196920723,
-0.4567213356,
0.7055123448,
-0.7867192626,
0.5807417035,
0.4373390079,
-0.1072610021,
0.6168102622,
-0.4199186862,
0.5578628778,
0.0126035558,
0.1558903754,
-0.103603363,
-0.2337685972,
-0.476174742,
-0.5284342766,
0.7310404778,
0.4855389893,
0.0253758002,
0.322198689,
-0.2183612883,
-0.5310224295,
-0.22066468,
0.028239511,
0.2563146949,
-0.3860505223,
-0.4464553893,
-0.2836965024,
-0.0046259086,
-0.7598452568,
-0.5139132738,
-0.3900035322,
-0.0469687916,
0.2712423801,
0.5072732568,
0.2432884276,
0.9461109042,
-0.7715678215,
-0.3028018177,
-0.2685944438,
0.0194827765,
0.2771021724,
0.4833385348,
0.4628754258,
-0.2646075487,
-0.0803550035,
-0.2557554245,
-0.5460497141,
0.1166682169,
-0.0530042797,
0.2102001607,
0.0184199531,
0.1605585814,
-0.7775163054,
0.4675109386,
0.6547679901,
-0.6939043403,
0.8458209634,
-0.2382254303,
-0.4344142377,
-0.9757190943,
-0.0254906956,
0.0746471658,
-0.4961465895,
-0.6440963745,
0.4837548733,
-0.096950613,
-0.1199728996,
-0.5470613241,
0.8247725368,
-0.6230871677,
-0.2535654902,
-0.1488984078,
0.1677871943,
-0.0935485438,
0.0475450382,
-0.2420243621,
0.3998584747,
0.8427076936,
-0.7820116282,
0.1021923199,
0.1265128404,
-0.4936908782,
0.247203216,
-0.5459071994,
-0.1141078025,
-0.0014718438,
0.2575884461,
-0.8621225953,
-0.245083198,
0.1474310905,
-0.4465956688,
0.6904830337,
-0.2210688591,
-0.6352793574,
-0.252304554,
-0.1933336258,
0.4768168926,
0.3806165159,
-0.0927691013,
-0.3655022979,
0.4926240444,
0.2104723901,
-0.4490133822,
-0.8583782911,
-0.2225243896,
-0.3546773195,
-0.8761289716,
-0.1090189368,
0.0111907311,
-0.6628978252,
0.0829539001,
-0.2180590481,
-0.6402488947,
0.3451152444,
-0.0181008801,
-0.0189362001,
-0.1433109939,
0.6076123714,
-0.1617186219,
0.1291817129,
-0.0725003183,
-0.44829759,
0.3131978512,
-0.2054775208,
-0.5024456382,
-0.3194802701,
0.4246348441,
0.457680434,
-0.1330046356,
0.913638711,
0.2225484401,
-0.6030278802,
-0.4088772833,
-0.4241742492,
-0.6042764783,
-0.4132607281,
0.032796789,
-0.2243131399,
-0.8488645554,
0.8035361171,
0.2011038065,
-0.1516812593,
0.2234936357,
0.2248598486,
-0.2229007632,
0.7167103291,
1.0232688189,
-0.0989531353,
0.2607973814,
-0.2358258516,
0.5084157586,
-0.5371911526,
0.6257628798,
-0.6852158308,
-0.0791988373,
-0.6796903014,
-0.2509340942,
0.0765795335,
0.6596792936,
-0.239918679,
0.4095754325,
-0.2332887948,
0.8038802147,
0.3196252882,
-0.4033542573,
0.235192135,
-0.413933754,
-0.158036381,
-0.0713453367,
-0.5134260654,
-0.7018157244,
0.8696017265,
0.5406540036,
0.907767415,
0.3887042999,
0.8029228449,
-0.1275196671,
0.1869077832,
-0.6975490451,
0.25593853,
-0.1784846634,
-1.1626433134,
-0.5210299492,
-0.4009457231,
-0.7922591567,
-0.1467289329,
0.0809217244,
-1.6950303316,
0.1678938866,
0.4876102507,
-0.1646579802,
0.6524376869,
-0.469701767,
0.7851507664,
0.0423525274,
0.1880519092,
0.1135025695,
-0.5788795948,
1.1519844532,
0.1136872172,
0.1452793777,
-0.5217339993,
-0.0481736884,
0.5595387816,
-0.566503644,
0.5758704543,
0.3323367536,
-0.1909799874,
0.5406546593,
0.8107133508,
0.7154160738,
0.1388601363,
0.050524909,
0.0324970484,
0.5678059459,
-0.5232248306,
-0.7246229649,
0.2866158783,
-0.3232015073,
-0.0904372185,
-0.4783654511,
-0.6494546533,
-0.3292860985,
-0.0824789181,
0.5322515965,
0.6228011847,
-0.1822637171,
-0.0035450214,
0.8040504456,
-0.0818813145,
0.5329113007,
0.4692364037,
-0.3321634829,
0.3122994006,
0.8498859406,
0.2401749641,
0.6430695653,
0.2111210078,
0.5967732668,
-0.3283863068,
-0.533834219,
-0.2418134362,
0.4676495194,
-0.3383340538,
-0.027675692,
-0.3103097975,
-0.3226614594,
-0.3923273087,
-0.0042756777,
-0.5165159702,
-1.0164878368,
0.0032629967,
-0.2709843218,
0.431974858,
0.7776501775,
-0.1494571716,
0.3978999555,
-0.9462345243,
0.0447619595,
0.0774089694,
0.7899163365,
-0.0253922269,
-0.6813059449,
-0.2569172978,
-0.1852660179,
-0.3989396393,
-1.258587122,
0.6260956526,
0.6209338903,
0.3330987394,
0.8569837213,
0.2152605504,
0.175363794,
-0.354264468,
0.8437727094,
0.1348640472,
-0.9647393227,
0.3915076256,
-0.8106890321,
0.3459252715,
0.3437187076,
0.1347705126,
-0.8231406212,
-1.1852266788,
-1.0053453445,
-0.4848453999,
0.3087996244,
0.1695614904,
0.4085302949,
-0.0777496621,
0.1784283966,
0.2112855315,
0.1299297959,
-0.5250884891,
-0.3351753354,
0.0974637717,
-0.2141120583,
0.0263355821,
-0.4362187684,
0.0206025783,
-0.1160316169,
0.3812533915,
-0.0459543429,
0.3010983765,
-0.0914033428,
-0.2672988176,
-0.0843203589,
0.6298319697,
0.8816876411,
1.0108366013,
-0.3526977599,
0.3682968915,
-0.1909105033,
-0.5460959077,
0.3384485841,
0.0421569757,
-0.2275020331,
0.00978857,
0.4940986037,
0.5196889639,
0.3283529878,
-0.6417688727,
0.6294074059,
0.2126249224,
-0.0114034256,
-0.2378301322,
0.1124105677,
0.2150781006,
-0.0546577461,
0.0924997032,
-0.084833324,
0.5382741094,
-0.8753399849,
0.5320153832,
0.5058700442,
-0.8423185945,
-0.6362662315,
0.4603976607,
-0.2601254582,
-0.1984429061,
0.689312458,
-0.2477358431,
-0.4585858583,
0.2662505507,
0.7017784715,
0.875566721,
-0.3554890156,
0.3774142563,
0.3239008188,
0.3272902071,
-0.2478858978,
0.2016896904,
0.0551423989,
-0.8272197247,
-0.4910481274,
-0.6598412991,
-0.2257927209,
0.1848437935,
-0.4835453033,
-0.1058026925,
-0.0549618974,
0.1042871997,
-0.0823652297,
-0.0913504735,
-0.3322861493,
-0.0206292961,
0.1664868742,
0.9175677896,
-1.0230237246,
0.9160203338,
0.0046706409,
-0.1300301701,
-0.9264087081,
-0.0606822409,
0.0732392594,
-0.4586075544,
0.20634377,
0.0637838319,
0.3114504516,
-0.5031747818,
-0.6921283603,
-1.2455154657,
0.3323914707,
0.8014902472,
-0.6108633876,
0.0639584139,
0.1249639019,
0.4024205506,
0.0492825173,
0.1002014875,
0.6358178258,
0.4825198352,
-0.3013090491,
-0.9630409479,
-0.0304643195,
0.0404144749,
-0.0500483438,
0.7232051492,
-0.3930085003,
0.7048193812,
-0.5619155765,
-0.6895213723,
0.2868954241,
0.501296401,
0.2413692176,
-0.0826756582,
0.372479111,
0.7747522593,
0.7199043632,
-0.2192449868,
1.424484849,
-0.2480997741,
0.6249752045,
0.9846073389,
0.0460028984,
0.8780868649,
0.3304178715,
-0.4045434892,
-0.1251261085,
0.3497625291,
0.3270235956,
0.3117945194,
0.8492851257,
-0.2049374431,
-0.1186292022,
-0.0163167957,
0.0480385572,
0.5546855927,
0.4199750125,
-0.2976590395,
-0.2767079175,
-0.3788456619,
0.158059448,
0.1869978905,
-0.0351612605,
0.5802598,
0.5292066932,
-0.5313563347,
0.3099415898,
-0.1395450234,
0.36068663,
-0.4529874325,
0.0882433131,
-0.0844078884,
0.1837371588,
0.0882614031,
-1.0292073488,
0.615960598,
-0.2195571959,
0.0712402984,
-0.0366673768,
0.7415828705,
-0.5962021947,
-0.6710551977,
-0.1770044416,
0.5627781153,
0.590308249,
0.0125377923,
-0.2688653171,
-0.0033787976,
-0.3670819104,
-0.1786473989,
0.1308712661,
0.2193974108,
-0.0354045928,
0.8617748022,
0.0916120559,
0.4568386376,
0.4700546265,
-0.1692112982,
0.1146805882,
-0.647280395,
-0.4720814526,
-1.0356726646,
0.3093729615,
0.1527284384,
-0.5221912265,
0.602312386,
0.2215181142,
0.3618837893,
0.0276597627,
0.5173880458,
0.2251137942,
0.4459015429,
-0.3525814414,
0.814876914,
-0.1160198078,
0.1398860663,
-0.2582320571,
-1.0968885422,
-0.3025608063,
0.5523239374,
-0.0714383051,
-0.147275418,
0.6465126276,
0.3849725425,
-0.2770694792,
-0.0715152398,
0.5460800529,
0.1392218322,
0.2257756442,
0.6404717565,
0.8553043604,
-0.2660269439,
0.3354021609,
-0.2808857858,
0.0250055958,
-0.1494937092,
-0.9193902016,
-0.3992133439,
-0.7971463203,
-0.4360131025,
0.0098514101,
0.0653851926,
0.1704339385,
1.2725541592,
-0.6324006915,
-0.3166657984,
-0.2070503533,
0.3536349833,
-0.5585737824,
-0.2047446966,
0.2306667864,
-0.2697134912,
-0.3489803672,
0.2291104048,
0.1505799443,
0.2610627711,
-0.6056606174,
0.2896426022,
0.0017290624,
0.673689127,
-0.016979469,
0.4330760241,
-0.6200937629,
-0.5755457878,
-0.3106800616,
0.0650376156,
-0.0606491901,
0.6954954267,
-0.2951751649,
0.3532531261,
0.71860075,
0.161091432,
0.4293425083,
-0.2210271806,
0.9349756837,
-1.2284400463,
0.2296431959,
0.3999858499,
0.5135707259,
0.315189302,
-0.2297686338,
0.5847619772,
-0.1328666806,
-0.6428533196,
-1.1240850687,
0.8775374293,
-0.9001412392,
-0.433616519,
0.9201003909,
-0.1832264215,
-0.2976097167,
0.0251835268,
0.3599939346,
0.2019840926,
-0.1227030158,
0.5596919656,
1.063419342,
0.2594211698,
-0.2084357888,
-0.7938147187,
0.400257349,
-0.054003939,
-0.4352725446,
0.3431727588,
0.0960091278,
0.5039381981,
0.1830233186,
0.3744053543,
-0.0794274881,
0.0522371605,
-0.2045098394,
-0.3660344481,
0.0976008624,
-0.341568321,
-0.3074724674,
-0.0207137838,
0.1970470697,
-0.0587846674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10498v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10498v2 | SimpleStyle: An Adaptable Style Transfer Approach | 2022-12-20T18:12:49 | 2022-12-22T16:26:36 | Elron Bandel, Yoav Katz, Noam Slonim, Liat Ein-Dor | cs.CL | cs.CL | Attribute-controlled text rewriting, also known as text style-transfer, has a
crucial role in regulating attributes and biases of textual training data and a
machine generated text. In this work we present SimpleStyle, a minimalist yet
effective approach for style-transfer composed of two simple ingredients:
controlled denoising and output filtering. Despite the simplicity of our
approach, which can be succinctly described with a few lines of code, it is
competitive with previous state-of-the-art methods both in automatic and in
human evaluation. To demonstrate the adaptability and practical value of our
system beyond academic data, we apply SimpleStyle to transfer a wide range of
text attributes appearing in real-world textual data from social networks.
Additionally, we introduce a novel "soft noising" technique that further
improves the performance of our system. We also show that teaching a student
model to generate the output of SimpleStyle can result in a system that
performs style transfer of equivalent quality with only a single greedy-decoded
sample. Finally, we suggest our method as a remedy for the fundamental
incompatible baseline issue that holds progress in the field. We offer our
protocol as a simple yet strong baseline for works that wish to make
incremental advancements in the field of attribute controlled text rewriting. | [
-0.0540247858,
-0.6716380715,
0.2166741788,
0.1388663799,
-0.0112498114,
-0.0900628492,
-0.4155338109,
-0.3419065475,
0.4509066939,
0.4088990986,
-0.7848165035,
-0.495100677,
-0.3181042373,
0.3829657435,
-0.597012043,
1.0563349724,
-0.0259986538,
-0.4856103361,
0.1619569957,
-0.1668218672,
-0.1132617369,
-0.0797656998,
-1.0534045696,
-0.5224724412,
0.6449956298,
0.8254115582,
0.7056766748,
0.6399592161,
0.5897527337,
0.3510973752,
-0.0948206931,
0.0111100413,
-0.7787379622,
-0.0728085935,
-0.3558570743,
-0.2888647318,
-0.8192865849,
-0.1131034493,
0.4802947044,
0.7349251509,
0.1084242538,
-0.0130786151,
0.3372025192,
0.9083919525,
-0.4531382322,
-0.2585020661,
-0.6142428517,
-0.014056297,
-0.0469410829,
-0.0620893091,
-0.3669297993,
-0.5755297542,
0.0394917242,
-0.7437205911,
0.3284166157,
-0.0845645741,
0.653588891,
-0.1158131957,
-0.4593574405,
-0.3260973692,
-0.70816046,
0.6983211637,
-0.3480413854,
0.2081199288,
0.0094111739,
0.2167205215,
0.1236429513,
-1.1084234715,
-0.7261246443,
-0.0481288023,
-0.275413692,
0.0495424122,
-0.4671501219,
0.2544642985,
-0.0080260802,
0.0941853821,
-0.3518188298,
0.051111877,
-0.5187963247,
-0.137682721,
0.7143240571,
-0.0436505303,
0.3203068078,
-0.4843853712,
-0.2094990611,
-0.1031049713,
-0.4297710061,
-0.0029389448,
0.1280956119,
0.2502236962,
0.0240653474,
0.3161302209,
-0.578948915,
0.176077649,
0.0831576139,
-0.1570996195,
-0.2585232556,
-0.6861631274,
-0.2766048014,
0.0486419424,
0.6468023062,
0.5292841792,
0.3917913139,
-0.1677282453,
-0.1601077765,
0.1326151192,
0.1972268522,
-0.948905468,
-0.7052275538,
-0.0620015264,
-0.4845131636,
-0.8216380477,
-0.2248770148,
-0.8671976328,
-0.2005830854,
-0.5094050765,
0.5576461554,
-0.4016825259,
-0.0974789411,
0.0882058591,
-0.2532586753,
0.281373322,
0.7063915133,
-0.8579764962,
0.5351631045,
0.5028569698,
0.9536803961,
-0.4573295712,
-0.0816776082,
-0.1961523741,
0.1169146746,
-0.3649097085,
0.811136961,
-0.1571580321,
-0.2462721318,
-0.0433648936,
0.0071934517,
0.1619634032,
-0.1711921245,
0.7476303577,
-0.2347304821,
-0.1533003151,
-0.0411612391,
-0.2635577023,
0.1907449216,
-0.1894285083,
-0.7077649236,
0.9148899317,
0.1349657625,
-0.4871781766,
0.1620603949,
-0.3910959959,
-0.5374975801,
0.0486719832,
0.1616951972,
-0.4059218764,
0.0049537062,
-0.093035996,
0.3350311518,
0.1376383603,
-0.1271460205,
-0.439265579,
-0.670943141,
0.2775075436,
-0.6336949468,
0.7382112741,
0.1757785529,
-0.0787364915,
0.1151451394,
-1.1779239178,
0.2148397565,
0.0398014747,
-0.2974068522,
-0.5201696157,
-0.6292575002,
0.5732350945,
-0.1488368511,
0.3034009337,
-0.3878603578,
0.6120888591,
-0.142196551,
0.5937113762,
1.0742942095,
-0.2520504296,
1.1358474493,
-0.4931465387,
0.0163030159,
-0.7983424664,
-0.0797371566,
0.2761412561,
-0.1194322184,
-0.8831892014,
-0.1899803728,
0.2436842471,
0.4973912537,
-1.1040248871,
0.0511695743,
-0.3688135147,
-0.5721936822,
-0.3955511749,
0.6242676973,
0.1777405888,
0.372672081,
0.2534942627,
-0.3939547241,
-0.468996495,
-0.7909401655,
-0.5134823322,
-0.122698009,
-0.2774715424,
0.0476863496,
0.2341165096,
-0.2853709161,
0.6792610884,
-0.7202304006,
-0.4318417609,
-0.7297854424,
0.3401862681,
0.1941664815,
0.6644379497,
0.6340067387,
-0.5179286003,
-0.4866867959,
0.0472425073,
-0.6741881371,
-0.5818100572,
-0.4373380244,
-0.5616703629,
-0.2924176157,
0.4353148937,
-0.3833291531,
0.480204016,
0.3970990479,
-0.4113589525,
0.5439642668,
-0.1117708236,
0.1058203354,
-0.7241262197,
0.0405193381,
0.2701871991,
-0.3730511665,
-0.9934354424,
-0.2136391997,
0.0964131355,
-0.1257597357,
-0.2398584187,
0.6541541815,
-0.0617728084,
0.3623329401,
-0.3516415656,
0.1037649289,
0.4730670452,
0.6626759768,
-0.2063454837,
0.5227892995,
0.2911837399,
-0.541443646,
0.4123586416,
0.4154334962,
0.174121961,
1.3366292715,
-0.7102458477,
0.4793739915,
-0.4150343239,
0.0290170871,
-1.2090044022,
-0.2832245827,
0.3657274544,
-0.1284573674,
0.4642474055,
-0.5257322788,
-0.0868688002,
0.1030989513,
-0.707318604,
0.0467164516,
0.3104048669,
-0.3525800109,
0.5685555339,
-0.4128282964,
-0.5202612877,
0.0369132981,
-0.5932703018,
0.1443669647,
-0.2210320681,
-0.7051001787,
0.9022973776,
-0.3097071946,
-0.0327700078,
0.0613517277,
-0.3204511106,
-0.6275052428,
0.1029180959,
-0.0920808539,
0.4243906438,
-0.1873948723,
-0.1386150569,
0.4939394593,
-0.0355251916,
-0.2173189223,
-0.0454460382,
-0.0588268898,
0.0058695134,
0.0072098402,
-0.8840713501,
0.340592891,
0.4824787378,
0.524987936,
0.309579432,
0.6015491486,
-0.1789912581,
-0.6748886704,
-0.0552230217,
-0.4363818169,
-0.599031508,
0.2760443985,
-0.3136138022,
-0.5192204118,
-0.1121583953,
-0.4363653958,
0.2863091528,
0.207303226,
-0.1243446469,
-0.4889478981,
0.4799628556,
1.0044411421,
0.2460956573,
0.8615871072,
-0.277703017,
-0.0496166386,
-0.6157188416,
0.102048263,
-0.5380623937,
-0.7251057625,
-0.7392895818,
0.0551076718,
0.3169792593,
0.2501869202,
-0.2052979916,
0.5762277246,
-0.6915943027,
0.4561917484,
0.6125233173,
0.5098667741,
0.5704575181,
0.3971973658,
0.479042083,
-0.4327494204,
-0.6513019204,
-0.4780009985,
1.0841727257,
0.0271248408,
1.1596689224,
0.2764916718,
0.7555701733,
0.6852213144,
0.4812686145,
-0.9397795796,
0.5439929962,
-0.5740066171,
0.0215691142,
-0.4464302063,
-0.4415318668,
-0.6384859681,
0.3187587559,
-0.4980360568,
-0.5276737809,
0.3814454973,
0.2376969606,
-0.2596050799,
0.1773115695,
-0.7857151031,
0.626673758,
-0.0993176997,
-0.8139490485,
0.2163365185,
-0.2681535184,
0.185367018,
0.047288321,
0.1335025579,
-0.0572285093,
0.03365013,
0.9993525743,
-0.1770295501,
0.8773105145,
0.3868378997,
0.3408769071,
-0.0246537793,
0.514515698,
0.5574377179,
-0.1455128193,
-0.1179106534,
-0.010495564,
0.1432261169,
-0.3531359136,
-0.804633975,
0.6901325583,
-0.8264184594,
-0.1897088438,
-0.191945225,
-0.1390971392,
0.1253111959,
0.5859193802,
0.0974721462,
0.5078001618,
-0.271669507,
0.3874357045,
0.7460765839,
0.1002961174,
0.4115658104,
0.2597597837,
-0.0367106386,
-0.5065126419,
0.9707459211,
0.2556063235,
0.1835139692,
0.1844979525,
0.4255242646,
-0.1270148009,
-0.2639704943,
-0.6870569587,
0.0999668539,
-0.8981206417,
-0.251370579,
-0.4822127521,
-0.2443621606,
-0.4944088757,
-0.7812238932,
-0.3492664397,
-0.6598255038,
-0.3199322224,
0.1256615967,
0.5533932447,
0.8254094124,
-0.0701222122,
0.5989872217,
-0.2611957192,
0.5702313185,
0.682158649,
0.3925611079,
-0.2227813452,
-0.6032418609,
0.2849234939,
-0.2074369937,
-0.382435143,
-1.0539246798,
0.2269318551,
0.724855721,
0.0090826275,
0.2160240263,
0.31076473,
0.5374335647,
-0.3772362769,
0.1469947398,
0.2430291325,
-1.074821353,
0.3635381758,
0.0341002271,
-0.0639268532,
0.9897913337,
0.1410401613,
-0.7653834224,
0.1634117365,
-0.4311370254,
-0.8981938362,
0.6206918955,
0.5710027218,
0.2640565634,
0.7373797297,
0.5771341324,
-0.0571112446,
0.2603622973,
-0.7392508388,
-0.3653002381,
-0.3989231586,
-0.4545717239,
0.4695200324,
-0.2692555189,
-0.0668111145,
-0.4134879112,
0.3923697472,
-0.1476770937,
0.1267683059,
0.2926835716,
-0.1860136688,
0.1102699339,
0.6211260557,
0.1703915894,
0.2968001068,
-0.2531820536,
0.2775074542,
0.0911693946,
-0.4912090302,
0.2813827395,
-0.1958863437,
-0.7835199833,
0.3039432168,
0.29664132,
0.3950406313,
0.5754823089,
0.0894264802,
0.5689057708,
0.0045888308,
-0.1334129423,
-0.1004178077,
0.2106992751,
-0.3198361099,
-0.2402945161,
0.164695546,
0.4860036969,
0.3895318508,
-0.6229151487,
0.5770629048,
0.0056101717,
-0.4372439682,
-0.512010932,
0.675191164,
0.4147529006,
-0.2550697029,
0.278971374,
-0.0636606365,
-0.1642607301,
0.480240047,
0.4932290316,
0.717869997,
0.1819040179,
0.4682471156,
0.2009758651,
0.4265929759,
-0.0485666208,
0.0860211253,
-0.0590461493,
-0.6938509345,
-0.2750609517,
-0.7472967505,
-0.4851402938,
-0.1830567122,
-0.5909429193,
0.4307223856,
-0.7567436099,
0.1280777901,
0.2296744436,
-0.0439778715,
-0.855479002,
-0.0001221684,
-0.2198161334,
0.9447996616,
-1.0696251392,
0.7092909217,
0.6399465799,
-0.2540632486,
-0.672146976,
-0.1474234164,
0.1373460442,
-0.501034677,
0.4463347793,
-0.0335851498,
-0.3641826212,
0.2871202528,
-0.7932856083,
-0.6132794619,
1.1255824566,
0.3299576044,
-0.3132207692,
-0.1509017944,
-0.0799599364,
0.5354006886,
0.1063461676,
-0.0178076513,
0.7611278296,
0.4166536331,
0.4975701869,
-0.5563810468,
0.0843587518,
-0.2351294011,
0.2057690769,
-0.3769107163,
-0.4638476372,
0.6711548567,
0.1323080659,
-0.3261702359,
0.1731399894,
0.8645182848,
-0.1008645371,
0.63769871,
0.1860352904,
0.1581273675,
0.7560015917,
-0.0947645828,
0.7428616881,
-0.0662444979,
0.3269051313,
0.817917943,
-0.0421452671,
0.7283169627,
0.3660530746,
-0.1575105041,
0.5092825294,
-0.0288962722,
0.3013877273,
0.5703084469,
0.1375950873,
-0.2135763466,
-0.01597845,
-0.2645817101,
0.0980332121,
0.428247422,
-0.0976139158,
0.0382017717,
-0.1859781146,
-0.1407614499,
0.3982916176,
0.2692104876,
-0.5090458989,
0.9041461945,
0.135651201,
-0.1255858392,
0.3265377581,
0.182361275,
1.2364815474,
-0.6440603137,
-0.3929200172,
-0.621750474,
0.0828719586,
-0.5895970464,
-0.7695587873,
0.3382388651,
-0.0105706165,
-0.0217878148,
-0.8312174678,
1.3582808971,
-0.5004654527,
-0.6585521102,
-0.1130977497,
0.2375433594,
-0.1718242764,
0.1195184663,
-0.4267661572,
0.1226362661,
0.0400145836,
0.0740644187,
0.2448927313,
0.648671329,
0.0804631338,
0.5898855329,
0.6999658346,
0.3960058093,
-0.1079050452,
-0.1881520748,
0.8243710995,
-0.4362449646,
-0.3132661581,
-0.6565743089,
0.2430204302,
-0.3302135468,
-0.2973432243,
0.5787506104,
0.0034966285,
0.8001972437,
0.0752565414,
0.8803275824,
-0.1146157905,
0.005400884,
-0.3847597241,
1.0090197325,
-0.3797340691,
0.2507813275,
-0.6739140749,
-0.7083827853,
-0.2343949676,
0.8118122816,
0.0585040227,
-0.1895097643,
0.4309942126,
0.7540744543,
-0.2895572782,
-0.3185427487,
0.3345990479,
0.1239678189,
0.2172694951,
0.3259184361,
0.2572500706,
-0.5220541358,
0.8585891128,
-0.7958398461,
-0.3904717565,
-0.2490064949,
-0.8932900429,
-0.5813963413,
-0.2089761347,
-0.5286647677,
-0.6767681241,
0.1380422413,
0.9573138952,
0.4586886168,
-0.6547519565,
-0.1924334615,
-0.0510644801,
0.5583971143,
-0.3799068332,
-0.2656836212,
0.4152531922,
0.138673231,
-0.7460361123,
0.1302310526,
0.3630686104,
0.0214885231,
-0.0186888035,
0.1167666838,
0.3644979596,
0.2166815847,
0.7643132806,
0.3157068789,
-0.1012210771,
-0.5294341445,
-0.0157501064,
-0.4940746427,
0.0822502226,
0.8607526422,
-0.3348279893,
0.3151856363,
0.6565539837,
0.5878928304,
0.0551991425,
0.0224501584,
0.2609848082,
-1.0294741392,
0.0330343619,
-0.0600171462,
0.0836897418,
0.445333004,
-0.2849736512,
0.4323212504,
0.7195731997,
-0.2295555323,
-0.5550372601,
0.3110949993,
-1.1066701412,
-0.2890028059,
1.1308580637,
0.080995135,
-0.2789136469,
-0.1707992554,
-0.5505635142,
0.2306325436,
-0.5007987618,
0.7034652829,
0.2165227532,
-0.0510046892,
-0.2816819549,
-0.3811039329,
0.7787602544,
0.0885215253,
-0.587097466,
-0.0226361565,
0.4619845748,
0.5143427253,
-0.1934138685,
0.9294288158,
0.4054359198,
0.245423764,
-0.0400867015,
-0.0681939423,
0.0544295236,
-0.4315636456,
-0.3704671264,
0.3267149925,
0.0528456941,
0.1824284047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10496v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10496v1 | Precise Zero-Shot Dense Retrieval without Relevance Labels | 2022-12-20T18:09:52 | 2022-12-20T18:09:52 | Luyu Gao, Xueguang Ma, Jimmy Lin, Jamie Callan | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | While dense retrieval has been shown effective and efficient across tasks and
languages, it remains difficult to create effective fully zero-shot dense
retrieval systems when no relevance label is available. In this paper, we
recognize the difficulty of zero-shot learning and encoding relevance. Instead,
we propose to pivot through Hypothetical Document Embeddings~(HyDE). Given a
query, HyDE first zero-shot instructs an instruction-following language model
(e.g. InstructGPT) to generate a hypothetical document. The document captures
relevance patterns but is unreal and may contain false details. Then, an
unsupervised contrastively learned encoder~(e.g. Contriever) encodes the
document into an embedding vector. This vector identifies a neighborhood in the
corpus embedding space, where similar real documents are retrieved based on
vector similarity. This second step ground the generated document to the actual
corpus, with the encoder's dense bottleneck filtering out the incorrect
details. Our experiments show that HyDE significantly outperforms the
state-of-the-art unsupervised dense retriever Contriever and shows strong
performance comparable to fine-tuned retrievers, across various tasks (e.g. web
search, QA, fact verification) and languages~(e.g. sw, ko, ja). | [
0.0011585647,
-0.8280439973,
0.9257589579,
-0.3670831323,
-0.2330424339,
0.0096261175,
-0.2040361017,
-0.0401786827,
0.2052987963,
0.5104281902,
-0.0948123112,
-0.5805389285,
-0.6058633327,
-0.207467109,
-0.6592027545,
0.9080650806,
0.234913528,
-0.131710887,
-0.1799623221,
-0.223632887,
-0.3045677543,
-0.3731046021,
-0.1548957825,
-0.2949442565,
0.4887649119,
0.6398798227,
0.7819805145,
0.5542674661,
0.3606093228,
0.2135784924,
0.1913726628,
-0.1958764642,
-0.8775641322,
0.5278946161,
-0.2956790328,
-0.5769015551,
0.0382400937,
0.025436366,
0.688041687,
0.7444160581,
-0.0265084226,
0.0482912138,
0.0206628311,
0.6084017754,
-0.9471324086,
-0.1942196339,
-0.9537617564,
0.0828622282,
-0.3610261977,
-0.3321188688,
-0.5284026861,
-0.2299269289,
0.0244140532,
-0.5978893638,
0.5278509259,
0.203180179,
1.1049749851,
0.2167429626,
-0.3040679395,
-0.2937514186,
-0.7471037507,
0.8012309074,
-0.3051563203,
0.3499591649,
0.3592550457,
0.4477519989,
0.0420118794,
-0.5976817012,
-0.6242561936,
-0.0584049225,
-0.0136428159,
0.3334933519,
-0.0275084749,
0.024684459,
0.2875621021,
0.4470522106,
-0.763905704,
-0.196709156,
-0.4167903662,
0.0885466859,
0.337866962,
-0.0396774113,
-0.074045077,
0.0040632468,
-0.0969870165,
-0.2916691303,
-0.6071712375,
-0.1493133605,
0.0296313912,
0.1327466965,
0.2774448991,
1.0006108284,
-0.4285360575,
0.7794876695,
0.459281981,
0.0656283796,
0.3856341541,
-0.0725398287,
-0.1703517735,
0.2724520862,
0.5402681231,
0.0907790512,
0.1040305272,
-0.5635306239,
-0.2851879895,
-0.2269512564,
0.6650989652,
-1.061752677,
-0.0920999944,
0.43656376,
-0.1896803975,
0.0489577912,
0.2669411004,
-0.6980183721,
-0.0847493112,
-0.0993974656,
0.8482003212,
-0.7503030896,
0.0798567533,
0.1694493741,
-0.2685388923,
0.4481930435,
0.2982473671,
-0.6833002567,
-0.1246350259,
0.7764853239,
0.8220134974,
0.0272379518,
-0.0130574945,
-0.6763529181,
0.3414603174,
-0.4126625359,
0.8020382524,
-0.8672032952,
-0.240189597,
0.1211837754,
-0.2568984926,
0.0780504569,
-0.5750049949,
0.5264547467,
-0.7291963696,
0.149310112,
-0.2607177794,
-0.8169234991,
-0.1193935648,
0.5073285699,
-0.416919142,
0.9824474454,
0.317669183,
-0.6394182444,
0.3167612851,
-0.1334401369,
-0.3650220335,
0.2890661955,
-0.548468709,
-0.3288915455,
0.1775728315,
-0.1272254735,
0.6149782538,
-0.0899773315,
0.179797098,
-0.4794678688,
-0.8753275275,
0.0127624674,
-0.3582350612,
0.4716641605,
0.10618525,
-0.3523567915,
-0.3203723729,
-0.7222027779,
0.0042636697,
0.1676699221,
-0.2812933624,
-0.4770877063,
-0.2991396785,
-0.3944877386,
-0.0505821742,
0.32810238,
-0.7997806072,
0.1934011728,
-0.2877660394,
-0.082697168,
0.08526963,
0.0915568769,
0.8571519256,
-0.2433867604,
0.3446533382,
-0.0878750086,
-0.1397962123,
-0.3447212875,
-0.4225970507,
-0.6888290644,
-0.1901779473,
0.2379386574,
0.6442844868,
-0.9819715619,
0.3072400689,
-0.4918907285,
-0.5425493121,
-0.7597501874,
-0.0061688903,
0.5697693825,
0.9106350541,
0.6223254204,
-0.109684214,
-0.0771009102,
-0.8102347255,
-0.1679032892,
0.215584591,
-0.2359725684,
0.3346363306,
0.261434108,
0.020497309,
0.8363229632,
-0.7728188634,
-0.2645133138,
-0.0128274346,
0.3396551311,
0.4596660733,
0.3387775719,
0.5728321075,
-0.9437675476,
-0.8234091997,
0.0767124072,
-0.9610095024,
0.1192343608,
-0.0941341892,
-0.2468614727,
-0.0697446987,
0.5309134126,
-0.8099539876,
0.5974802971,
-0.1608334184,
0.0228934288,
0.3960721791,
-0.3062157929,
0.1517516375,
-0.6972948909,
0.2587224543,
-0.2562025785,
-0.1205540374,
-0.5498758554,
0.1230106205,
0.3218918443,
-0.3394473791,
-0.3611921668,
0.5591231585,
-0.7056478858,
-0.1910475641,
-0.1586779654,
0.3458881378,
0.2506386042,
0.4623070657,
0.0573511459,
0.8659918904,
0.4212163389,
-0.6310212612,
-0.0150087504,
0.1225312576,
-0.1717958152,
0.7409838438,
-0.5031897426,
0.1276144087,
-0.4684749842,
-0.0939976797,
-0.7261376977,
0.0891729295,
0.2227630615,
-0.4854750037,
0.8373473883,
-0.4249883294,
-0.3411792219,
-0.1241443381,
-0.4125180542,
0.267858088,
0.4516280591,
-0.1876066476,
0.280706197,
0.3336966038,
0.1172394603,
-0.8967903852,
-0.4954999089,
-0.1299183071,
0.1101584211,
-0.1395475715,
0.6403254271,
0.0503496714,
-0.1232799813,
0.393127501,
-0.333542347,
-0.2116017789,
-0.1082987189,
0.1727728397,
-0.0629274249,
-0.3549624085,
0.1146599576,
0.1512736529,
-0.1513295472,
-0.4572331309,
-0.3040519059,
0.325027585,
0.0431177877,
-0.4393807054,
0.1374055743,
0.5635884404,
0.2977698445,
-0.1298639625,
0.7783115506,
0.7257198691,
-0.2949463427,
-0.1399992555,
-0.6047343016,
-0.0930177495,
-0.4456207156,
0.2536528707,
-0.5174251199,
-1.0425159931,
0.1551400572,
0.0870897323,
0.0135693783,
0.3713485897,
0.2992428243,
-0.389264524,
0.4629978538,
0.5209597945,
0.2826688588,
0.510101974,
-0.4928298295,
0.3785980642,
-0.876753211,
-0.418258369,
-0.6281940341,
-0.2818462849,
-0.3064630926,
-0.5713658333,
0.4037775993,
0.3981877863,
-0.4273673296,
0.5972242951,
-0.6808248162,
0.5554138422,
0.5818206072,
0.1374468356,
0.0692690238,
0.2021897435,
-0.4684696496,
-0.1470242292,
-0.7961504459,
-0.2992042899,
1.2322970629,
-0.4780057669,
0.5127202272,
0.1161730662,
0.797154367,
0.2471618056,
0.2707019746,
-0.7286767364,
0.382858485,
-0.2628658414,
-0.5778280497,
-0.3914456069,
-0.3295770586,
-1.4029140472,
0.6114677787,
-0.3214055598,
-0.5740361214,
0.4226270616,
-0.1579879969,
-0.6119517684,
0.1813382804,
-0.6567934155,
0.8213348389,
-0.238955006,
-0.7023177147,
-0.3327461481,
-0.5408575535,
0.0058129667,
-0.0814223364,
-0.0632993281,
-0.1994918436,
-0.2580131292,
0.1685296744,
-0.2748668194,
0.390897125,
-0.0701944977,
0.2970529199,
0.2333949357,
0.4422912598,
0.1719569713,
0.0054789213,
-0.6440880299,
0.1274105012,
-0.0995423123,
-0.5279039145,
-0.9227124453,
0.7489712834,
-0.6185878515,
-0.7177906036,
-0.5496332645,
-0.1331862658,
-0.0290677305,
0.5395586491,
0.4572018385,
0.4331691563,
-0.3135177195,
0.5097102523,
0.8534243703,
-0.0804210454,
0.3367378116,
0.8421576023,
0.0435914136,
-0.1451752484,
1.0661246777,
0.4919570386,
-0.2332337499,
1.1815958023,
-0.1699731946,
-0.2826122344,
-0.529424727,
-0.4639969468,
0.3186530173,
-0.5194339156,
-0.5307818055,
-0.8351503611,
-0.2629626095,
-0.2786663473,
-0.4111737907,
-0.5946458578,
-0.3867641687,
-0.5510426164,
0.1172985062,
0.0880573317,
0.4794962406,
0.1105953902,
0.1118008941,
-0.8272384405,
0.3942133486,
0.1451746523,
0.2880766988,
-0.0243895501,
-0.7652376294,
-0.4115790427,
-0.0286552887,
-0.4678398371,
-0.9698269367,
0.4630320668,
0.2541987598,
0.6230308414,
0.4693581462,
0.3855324686,
0.7318282127,
-0.6670001745,
0.5032359958,
-0.0710924119,
-0.5695694685,
0.6687591076,
-0.1904121339,
0.2580882907,
0.874784112,
0.8038957119,
-0.2601861358,
0.0081932656,
-0.5763450265,
-1.0115116835,
0.6035010219,
0.1656886786,
0.0335380733,
-0.2131911069,
0.8889148831,
0.1982681304,
0.3863730729,
-0.1895378083,
-0.137834534,
-0.3145444691,
-0.0652777851,
0.0736220032,
-0.3912064135,
0.1931359917,
-0.1447224617,
0.5866841674,
-0.0523109287,
0.403519094,
0.4425975382,
-0.4873930812,
0.1294587702,
0.2767337263,
0.2706696987,
0.4068747759,
-0.6597474813,
0.2632582486,
-0.2022384107,
-0.3076458573,
0.0583198667,
-0.0496879853,
-0.7290955186,
0.2601256967,
0.1993324012,
0.5985293388,
0.7128198743,
-0.5673574805,
0.8114159107,
0.078060925,
0.0174074247,
-0.2686164975,
0.1310059577,
-0.24232243,
0.1320753694,
0.6447863579,
-0.1078786999,
0.3797208071,
-0.5203557611,
0.5095995069,
0.59401685,
-0.4209528565,
-0.3089369833,
0.5883073211,
-0.0544990115,
-0.3224784732,
0.8486071229,
-0.5535583496,
-0.242811054,
0.2870849669,
0.4461832941,
0.7451600432,
-0.0426220186,
0.2987246513,
0.6153864264,
0.1461482048,
-0.1141113564,
0.0296705868,
-0.351826489,
-0.7677538395,
-0.1718530357,
-0.6368620992,
-0.4984626472,
-0.0722899958,
-0.7497988939,
0.2206856012,
-0.4033920467,
-0.057945706,
-0.0776546374,
0.1746930927,
-0.7223116159,
0.0052879597,
-0.0803545862,
0.6286069751,
-0.2874186039,
1.1532689333,
0.5471862555,
-0.7005913854,
-0.3201509714,
0.1851399988,
-0.1701167822,
-0.7550430894,
0.3325642049,
0.2395242155,
-0.0896742493,
-0.016274808,
-0.3393316567,
-0.9441195726,
1.2302556038,
0.7463158369,
-0.6339210272,
0.017676577,
-0.0785915479,
0.5238000154,
-0.184527114,
0.636654973,
0.1851614267,
0.2102830261,
0.3323858976,
-0.3872926533,
-0.0145159326,
-0.2208697349,
-0.0536402278,
0.0457559712,
-0.7096829414,
0.8088812232,
-0.1425276399,
-0.5132249594,
-0.1200209484,
0.6479560733,
0.0122753931,
0.2915457785,
-0.1652234793,
0.7302547693,
0.8113549352,
0.0164984055,
1.2302694321,
-0.3812247217,
0.3262529969,
1.2744313478,
-0.4473763704,
1.1534113884,
0.2497879565,
-0.0132233044,
0.4281296432,
0.2942501009,
0.0187058654,
0.6130174994,
-0.1600030065,
-0.2443979234,
-0.3825853467,
-0.0349993557,
-0.418979764,
0.33778736,
0.4831023216,
-0.0329064243,
-0.4964580536,
-0.3530644774,
0.0366880856,
0.2152266651,
-0.0981618911,
0.5754571557,
0.1053393036,
-0.6640054584,
0.6480201483,
0.0092107523,
0.7577636242,
-0.556461215,
-0.209132731,
-0.4664076567,
0.161957413,
-0.1254501641,
-1.0673072338,
0.5349132419,
-0.2228080034,
-0.3458960652,
-0.2550211251,
0.8148505092,
-0.5602504611,
-0.3095851541,
0.4057469368,
0.5023065209,
0.4391433597,
-0.4617256522,
-0.7549622059,
-0.0978477225,
-0.0606737807,
-0.1798080951,
0.7177355886,
0.779802382,
0.1484675109,
0.5901204348,
0.5377625823,
-0.1007874981,
0.0367336348,
-0.1929712445,
0.6090905666,
-0.742777884,
-0.0147643648,
-0.6845054626,
0.1127812713,
-0.1419039071,
-0.0039840001,
0.7878676057,
0.8639838099,
0.9580392838,
-0.0195964426,
0.4707220793,
-0.021119725,
0.4462468624,
-0.2761221826,
0.7652864456,
-0.7499927282,
0.1005617231,
0.0207289197,
-1.0237628222,
-0.5350940824,
0.7234865427,
-0.3165449202,
-0.1125599593,
0.6602461338,
0.917091012,
-0.3040727079,
-0.4001523852,
0.838614583,
0.2785029411,
-0.0679990798,
0.4308885634,
0.1999024153,
-0.5690443516,
0.8223638535,
-0.2979755998,
-0.0666715503,
-0.4865847826,
-0.7187565565,
-0.6673813462,
-0.4869052768,
-0.3013677597,
-0.2324677557,
0.2407484651,
0.5325694084,
0.635453105,
-0.8220457435,
0.0842171535,
0.2707617879,
0.3835065067,
-0.0744331256,
-0.2594356239,
0.3580303788,
-0.426733762,
-0.6094683409,
0.5434375405,
0.7715080976,
-0.1760421842,
0.1133445352,
-0.0022006233,
-0.2542204857,
-0.0684011951,
0.5850918293,
0.6294675469,
-0.4736510813,
-0.2880680561,
0.005596437,
-0.3313634396,
0.3812445402,
0.7985394001,
-0.9708823562,
0.4656000733,
0.560621798,
0.9502280354,
1.0481880903,
-0.0515511371,
0.3324516416,
-0.8249335885,
0.167977199,
0.425940305,
0.2457632124,
0.4018279314,
-0.5571645498,
0.6039876938,
0.3542485833,
-0.3901728094,
-0.5527754426,
-0.0021579973,
-0.9860725999,
-0.2930954397,
1.0120462179,
-0.3323168159,
-0.2814350128,
-0.2767041922,
0.0088214055,
0.3051089048,
-0.5750994682,
0.6839620471,
0.2971854806,
-0.064641349,
-0.2008393407,
-0.5210382938,
0.0708162636,
0.4624217153,
-0.0307178926,
-0.3237190247,
0.2977766395,
0.2531160116,
0.2461282462,
0.7960256338,
-0.1592721939,
0.1148603484,
0.1661575288,
0.0435989462,
-0.0407318361,
-0.3186537027,
-0.2248376757,
0.5974876881,
-0.1359357089,
-0.093962796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10481v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10481v2 | Execution-Based Evaluation for Open-Domain Code Generation | 2022-12-20T17:54:37 | 2023-05-19T14:27:46 | Zhiruo Wang, Shuyan Zhou, Daniel Fried, Graham Neubig | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | To extend the scope of coding queries to more realistic settings, we propose
ODEX, the first Open-Domain EXecution-based natural language (NL) to Python
code generation dataset. ODEX has 945 NL-Code pairs spanning 79 diverse
libraries, along with 1,707 human-written test cases for execution. Our NL-Code
pairs are harvested from StackOverflow forums to encourage natural and
practical coding queries. Moreover, ODEX supports four natural languages as
intents, in English, Spanish, Japanese, and Russian. ODEX unveils intriguing
behavioral differences among top-performing code language models (LM). While
CODEX achieves better overall results, CODEGEN improves effectively via scaling
-- CODEGEN 6.1B performs comparably with CODEX 12B. Both models show
substantial gaps between open and closed domains, but CODEGEN gaps tend to
decrease with model size while CODEX gaps increase. We release ODEX to
facilitate research into open-domain problems for the code generation
community. | [
-0.3301298618,
-0.5320331454,
0.2808979452,
0.5689834952,
0.1548006833,
-0.1761793941,
-0.3154664338,
-0.4982743561,
-0.2171134204,
0.6796031594,
-0.3647782505,
-0.7077629566,
-0.2166688293,
0.5596972704,
-0.2769723535,
1.1262649298,
-0.1825665087,
-0.1415696442,
-0.3777511716,
-0.1967924088,
-0.2308506817,
-0.3652414083,
-0.6200714707,
-0.0200687312,
0.1202152371,
0.0002986678,
0.6566877961,
0.6618206501,
0.3294852972,
0.239197731,
0.1381593794,
0.1093341485,
-0.4806837738,
-0.0145736802,
-0.0426434688,
-0.5816093087,
-0.4619405568,
-0.0476345718,
0.5289648771,
0.7951170802,
-0.1326200217,
0.1927205771,
-0.183076933,
0.6448239088,
-0.8379913568,
0.1309161782,
-0.589736104,
0.0083577512,
0.1511270702,
0.0444128513,
-0.5395095348,
-0.7742609382,
0.1081996486,
-0.509771049,
0.047324162,
0.1155843437,
0.3928745389,
0.3167107999,
-0.1728698909,
-0.3729881048,
-0.4547441304,
0.9901391268,
-0.9163838625,
0.2001079619,
0.245422855,
0.1342691928,
-0.4256008565,
-1.001416564,
-0.5037741661,
-0.3012415469,
0.0824704543,
-0.0199036263,
-0.477917701,
-0.0762850419,
0.5903044343,
0.3839835823,
-0.8367151618,
-0.1865655035,
-0.5134759545,
-0.0304125194,
0.6565337181,
0.3311569989,
0.4999950528,
0.1406945884,
-0.2197090089,
0.1944660246,
-0.792999506,
0.0619351566,
0.6482763886,
0.3348678946,
-0.1857853979,
0.5175364017,
-0.2782487273,
0.8448119164,
-0.3050329387,
0.4684188664,
0.2174342871,
-0.2997418046,
-0.2134927064,
0.0297167655,
0.9326196313,
0.5274891257,
0.4277110696,
-0.3009005785,
-0.2564106286,
0.2214204669,
0.7730981112,
-0.9067481756,
-0.0708246008,
0.4914747477,
-0.3867084086,
-0.3033651412,
0.240008384,
-0.780416131,
-0.2074915618,
-0.2725265622,
0.3454589248,
-0.4480073154,
-0.3784284294,
0.4623738825,
-0.2190771848,
0.2321934551,
0.2866859734,
-0.437849462,
0.6273972988,
0.8703661561,
0.7830880284,
-0.3646554649,
-0.2350312322,
-0.7583473921,
-0.3818771541,
-0.5609585047,
0.6573925614,
-0.6598384976,
-0.1767758727,
0.2476686835,
-0.1286150962,
-0.08650776,
-0.8377379179,
0.4254535437,
-0.6288094521,
0.0353258401,
0.3448868394,
-0.374307394,
0.0071992478,
-0.152882576,
-0.7109844089,
1.2693665028,
0.4852030575,
-0.7129707336,
0.3124733269,
-1.0424890518,
-0.4216980338,
0.0372021757,
-0.0952797607,
-0.3604958951,
0.1430052668,
-0.0916774794,
0.0451305099,
-0.3183496594,
-0.2037770897,
-0.1911383569,
-0.4099806249,
0.0373955108,
0.0439577177,
0.8877076507,
0.465090692,
-0.5077923536,
0.0372160152,
-0.9122788906,
0.5427106023,
0.0396743342,
-0.3514356613,
-0.5810472965,
0.117671065,
-0.0806161389,
-0.0003956799,
0.0232494939,
-0.7960549593,
0.4233284295,
-0.7464216948,
0.3776860833,
0.3782804906,
0.0273076519,
0.3724829257,
-0.1026707962,
0.7386542559,
-0.1651172489,
0.2233136445,
-0.2976856232,
-0.880199492,
-0.4337151051,
0.2212155312,
0.2750521004,
0.4412316084,
-0.709595561,
0.2310191542,
-0.0596984476,
-0.4042622745,
-0.5130809546,
0.0470385849,
0.706050396,
0.2657299638,
0.2729772329,
-0.2223892957,
-0.5033223033,
-0.8190143704,
-0.2019041926,
-0.1497000605,
0.026257379,
0.4072086811,
0.6673032045,
-0.4314928353,
1.1189931631,
-0.7203533649,
0.3515709043,
-0.2819578648,
0.4166108966,
0.581612885,
0.4523746371,
0.8663299084,
-0.6905465722,
-0.6909867525,
0.3130884767,
-0.4937076867,
-0.4419789612,
0.1690519899,
-0.3246068954,
0.6184418797,
0.0412157215,
-0.2648091316,
0.6262897849,
0.4650564492,
-0.3181145489,
0.9177802801,
-0.278680861,
0.2666639984,
-0.8651034832,
0.1685650498,
-0.119782865,
0.0556101985,
-0.5580540895,
0.3897943497,
0.3307529092,
-0.2026524693,
-0.6625867486,
0.3382652998,
-0.3073099256,
-0.0295577552,
-0.071148403,
-0.2802432775,
0.0551884957,
0.2532636821,
0.2301540375,
1.2688914537,
0.6246086359,
-0.80938977,
0.3278276622,
0.2133497,
-0.5290545225,
0.0907908157,
-0.8878145814,
0.5573397875,
0.2805350721,
-0.1357292831,
-0.6301617622,
-0.0297480579,
-0.1231757775,
-0.4613850117,
0.0967449099,
-0.4702832401,
-0.384655416,
-0.4252044559,
-0.4576030374,
0.4823230505,
0.7185078263,
-0.7002147436,
-0.0547062568,
0.2387546301,
-0.1372945011,
-0.6933453083,
-0.2921911776,
0.2179258913,
-0.1081744656,
-0.8240548372,
0.0040950254,
-0.3579145372,
-0.5310073495,
-0.0483273678,
-0.1726846397,
-0.277392596,
-0.0396902151,
-0.0178534668,
0.101453267,
-0.6484469771,
-0.3144068122,
0.0223066136,
0.0155192446,
0.2735829353,
-0.596570313,
0.3614817858,
-0.3036979437,
-0.0036923168,
0.1409361511,
0.5478569269,
0.5098663568,
-0.4328402281,
0.5518729687,
0.1485997289,
-0.4827486575,
-0.9123007655,
-0.0471850187,
0.229400456,
-0.4120256305,
0.1001905352,
-0.3138713837,
-0.6064113379,
0.3943943679,
-0.2654675841,
0.2871864438,
0.2782557309,
0.6221570373,
0.3278142512,
1.0641618967,
0.6383057833,
0.240004003,
-0.0475772321,
-0.4693301618,
0.1352262795,
-0.6679329276,
0.0781781301,
-0.7797169089,
0.0663486794,
-0.3161612153,
-0.4393395185,
0.4266719222,
0.1000948995,
0.044190798,
0.9616501331,
-0.6172207594,
0.5944985747,
0.5859847069,
-0.2305308431,
0.0859120861,
-0.0810162574,
-0.3377655447,
0.0201157425,
-0.5715803504,
-0.6152425408,
1.4493379593,
-0.0704148263,
1.0453469753,
0.1453283876,
0.6726515293,
0.6591257453,
0.2595335841,
-0.5448771119,
0.270403415,
0.0756586716,
-0.376021713,
0.007141124,
-0.6937206388,
-1.0573569536,
-0.2136394382,
0.1891455501,
-0.6698656678,
-0.0614997633,
-0.0416218303,
-0.6315966845,
0.0871272236,
-0.9649006128,
1.1607413292,
-0.0806395039,
-0.6370148659,
0.0743031502,
-0.4629844725,
0.3577390611,
-0.2834793329,
0.0960717052,
0.3374989927,
-0.0095213158,
0.4961200655,
-0.6647950411,
0.5046181679,
-0.0511897355,
-0.4162247181,
0.5508396626,
0.1589405239,
0.2314636856,
0.1695468724,
-0.4686746895,
0.3873386383,
0.1841545254,
-0.0330993943,
-0.6794444323,
0.6904162765,
-0.608107686,
-0.1191322207,
-0.3559008241,
-0.442106396,
-0.0922625363,
0.2373390496,
0.2782372832,
0.8807010055,
-0.087529175,
0.2137217522,
0.5038095117,
-0.7857047915,
0.2934404612,
0.6324991584,
-0.405415684,
-0.4382995367,
0.824772954,
-0.223755002,
0.2949303091,
0.173863858,
0.1474642903,
-0.2806682289,
-0.6748681068,
-0.6370947957,
-0.0143561624,
-0.347325474,
-0.3380532563,
-0.5788712502,
-0.0960132033,
-0.6694470644,
-0.120076865,
-0.3522160053,
-0.4123547077,
0.2365496308,
0.195519805,
0.3210298121,
1.1085664034,
0.0780939683,
0.0009772999,
-0.7713263035,
0.4545007646,
-0.1476280391,
0.8392901421,
-0.4613040984,
-0.1046345532,
-0.4933679998,
0.0988312662,
-0.3702433407,
-0.7116464972,
0.4711308181,
0.357645303,
0.5845358372,
0.3157778978,
0.6426750422,
0.3398960829,
-0.7504504323,
0.9429543614,
-0.0266334843,
-0.7954216003,
0.8927150369,
-0.3458009362,
0.0513865277,
0.1540748477,
0.4632551372,
-0.2373728901,
-0.4090407193,
-0.5456328392,
-0.7758920193,
1.2720006704,
0.6662635207,
0.0663717166,
-0.2480378449,
0.4348079562,
0.5650271773,
0.2229329497,
-0.5354626775,
-0.3752187192,
-0.1344096661,
-0.0664660111,
0.219134748,
0.1224381775,
-0.0234799534,
-0.273463577,
0.4374762774,
-0.3675382435,
0.5768101215,
0.0419728756,
-0.0549490191,
-0.4292362332,
0.1509823948,
0.7807631493,
0.7890137434,
-0.5335617065,
-0.0749261379,
-0.205396235,
-0.6585965753,
-0.2032589763,
-0.079485327,
-0.1282493174,
-0.0782339275,
0.2949623466,
0.7068950534,
0.0538287573,
-1.1241391897,
0.5692303777,
-0.3411582708,
-0.2090916038,
-0.3149572313,
0.5462332368,
-0.3186380565,
0.0938230082,
0.1981906742,
0.1726661921,
0.3153553307,
-0.4159561396,
0.5450106859,
0.2211354375,
-0.2345361114,
-0.4376207888,
0.9357283711,
0.1344374567,
-0.3884409666,
0.5746732354,
-0.283169955,
-0.5602005124,
1.150190711,
0.8677275181,
1.1365426779,
0.0126902703,
-0.0302372836,
0.5509402156,
0.3686239421,
0.2382958382,
0.6017639637,
-0.2127248645,
-0.5156514645,
-0.4154708982,
-1.0116298199,
-0.6078453064,
0.1511003375,
-0.7707992792,
0.3350138068,
-0.3186712563,
-0.0362079591,
-0.2151780725,
-0.0887326598,
-0.2757156789,
-0.0217087399,
-0.005592789,
1.3239107132,
-0.4097305536,
0.7862544656,
1.1549293995,
-0.3248960078,
-0.4184962511,
0.0874831602,
-0.3588964939,
-0.4921799898,
0.8315152526,
0.4554609358,
0.0102400202,
0.0819348246,
-0.7792850137,
-0.477732718,
0.663847506,
0.4411879778,
0.0962756127,
0.2096219212,
0.4948494434,
0.6064321995,
-0.4981384575,
0.4680568576,
0.5365616679,
0.3569615781,
-0.2658129632,
-0.9876173735,
-0.2959201932,
-0.75399822,
-0.0971957669,
0.3687371016,
-0.1672108322,
0.887085259,
-0.382663995,
-0.1994431168,
0.3059337735,
0.3555246294,
0.0618151724,
0.4918901622,
0.3381198347,
0.605340302,
0.1520285755,
-0.169357717,
1.3658827543,
-0.5238556266,
0.3451481462,
0.8301790953,
-0.4886220992,
0.7639974952,
0.1026105434,
-0.615426898,
0.4436024427,
0.3368997872,
0.3336232007,
0.3666716814,
0.372123003,
-0.1899604648,
-0.0412191898,
0.1497973055,
-0.509884119,
0.175911203,
0.3990505636,
-0.0228344444,
-0.4643585086,
-0.1558675468,
-0.0332858153,
0.1899128556,
-0.248347953,
0.6735721827,
-0.012994349,
-0.9805289507,
0.9421729445,
0.1257255822,
0.5342946649,
-0.8650391102,
-0.4917260408,
-0.2799862027,
0.3450273275,
-0.3274406791,
-0.8417690396,
0.5024776459,
0.4511924386,
-0.1191437691,
-0.2016300261,
0.4578079879,
-0.2061018795,
-0.1543067992,
0.5350114107,
0.0204387866,
0.1984449476,
-0.341360718,
-0.5259623528,
0.0171487834,
-0.0381939746,
-0.2722896636,
0.249192059,
0.5491524339,
-0.0679993257,
0.3521097004,
0.788312912,
0.0865325332,
0.6158854365,
-0.0711773336,
0.7653087974,
-0.3951030672,
-0.454959929,
-0.4636396468,
0.5565562844,
-0.0030350508,
-0.4579289854,
0.7221258879,
0.9069414735,
0.8451442719,
-0.4835301042,
1.0155115128,
-0.4264737964,
0.2352061123,
-0.4226896763,
0.7597119212,
-0.578338325,
0.0920181125,
-0.4635252655,
-0.9811302423,
-0.3152146041,
0.5259882212,
-0.1685606241,
-0.1120808572,
0.7207741141,
0.8009102345,
0.0023522968,
0.1868044138,
0.416439116,
0.1829255968,
0.2584259808,
0.6837790012,
0.9678660631,
-0.6259372234,
0.4948421121,
-0.4702585936,
-0.6435029507,
0.071172744,
-0.9898152947,
-0.813957572,
-0.327455312,
-0.3602747023,
-0.3350822031,
-0.1083070263,
1.0738888979,
0.4544972777,
-1.054199338,
-0.4083953202,
-0.2956926823,
-0.0811998472,
-0.52149719,
-0.299215138,
0.1754555702,
-0.7794633508,
-1.1211152077,
0.5781079531,
0.3970440626,
-0.577495873,
-0.0259593204,
-0.4298915863,
0.0096916603,
0.1244625226,
0.6513057351,
0.4218686521,
-0.3144472837,
-0.0980382487,
0.1377032846,
-0.079288587,
-0.0289459433,
0.9882140756,
-0.8323889375,
0.5956212282,
0.5402720571,
0.8586350083,
-0.1697542071,
-0.0125644589,
0.9637099504,
-0.8506430387,
-0.0800310597,
0.2488726526,
0.2991531193,
-0.2997492552,
-0.2849178612,
0.8873819709,
0.3073537052,
-0.4677107334,
-0.9590443373,
0.0804083794,
-0.8927989006,
-0.0409280546,
1.3214393854,
-0.2923141718,
-0.1897229999,
-0.4053862393,
-0.2888792753,
-0.0930075794,
-0.3900716007,
0.50399369,
0.309368968,
-0.3020345867,
0.2775002122,
-0.8979404569,
0.5400607586,
0.0146094691,
-0.8829323053,
0.2504520118,
0.4768526256,
0.0512732044,
0.2258165032,
0.3809629381,
-0.3431357741,
0.5774217844,
0.0790031478,
0.4563976526,
-0.1500827819,
-0.3601867557,
-0.2558270097,
0.2487559021,
-0.0916523784,
0.0192392599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.11119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.11119v1 | A survey on text generation using generative adversarial networks | 2022-12-20T17:54:08 | 2022-12-20T17:54:08 | Gustavo Henrique de Rosa, João Paulo Papa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This work presents a thorough review concerning recent studies and text
generation advancements using Generative Adversarial Networks. The usage of
adversarial learning for text generation is promising as it provides
alternatives to generate the so-called "natural" language. Nevertheless,
adversarial text generation is not a simple task as its foremost architecture,
the Generative Adversarial Networks, were designed to cope with continuous
information (image) instead of discrete data (text). Thus, most works are based
on three possible options, i.e., Gumbel-Softmax differentiation, Reinforcement
Learning, and modified training objectives. All alternatives are reviewed in
this survey as they present the most recent approaches for generating text
using adversarial-based techniques. The selected works were taken from renowned
databases, such as Science Direct, IEEEXplore, Springer, Association for
Computing Machinery, and arXiv, whereas each selected work has been critically
analyzed and assessed to present its objective, methodology, and experimental
results. | [
-0.4951222837,
-1.2331154346,
0.3238438368,
-0.1024863645,
-0.2348269671,
0.0062263561,
-0.2610448301,
-0.2762625813,
-0.0303207692,
0.4352090359,
-0.3341590464,
-0.4149554968,
-0.6112296581,
0.2829873562,
-0.6252484918,
1.3739448786,
0.0330267884,
0.1176766977,
-0.0236430932,
-0.1033470854,
-0.1504259706,
-0.4625625908,
-1.0030907393,
-0.2896426022,
0.4452168643,
-0.1400627941,
0.9223188162,
0.4413294792,
0.3875454068,
0.3837720454,
-0.2777050734,
0.4680484533,
-0.3494262695,
0.3737823963,
0.0595788769,
0.0141334813,
-0.1189178079,
-0.0898488238,
0.5264440179,
0.3217562735,
0.0403440446,
-0.3717258573,
-0.0867112279,
0.9516476393,
-0.6792060137,
-0.2859476209,
-0.5582040548,
0.446005702,
-0.4941190183,
-0.0209090561,
-0.2843795717,
-0.6612924933,
0.0632207245,
-0.556319356,
0.7423137426,
-0.1033508256,
0.6400498152,
-0.0706155375,
-0.6834092736,
-0.9022316337,
-1.0159544945,
0.5689702034,
-0.4003634155,
-0.2677413523,
-0.0741848871,
0.2205757052,
-0.3387294412,
-0.7290852666,
-0.5372962356,
-0.3665167391,
0.206740126,
0.4698181748,
-0.3070544302,
-0.0760654286,
0.0344348177,
0.6707295775,
-0.7685320973,
-0.0515597425,
-0.3342830241,
0.1649818122,
0.7139689326,
0.1648835689,
0.4567385614,
-0.1948162168,
-0.4280456901,
-0.4771220088,
-0.7151502967,
-0.256926775,
0.7167192698,
-0.0327998064,
0.2470218837,
0.7037510276,
-0.0429581143,
0.6845113635,
-0.192903772,
0.2379683107,
-0.0578584038,
-0.353559196,
-0.2653031051,
0.0002438817,
1.4650163651,
0.0893875808,
0.2646634877,
-0.2092053741,
-0.1943594813,
0.1402996927,
0.6850790977,
-0.6441347003,
-0.4417474866,
-0.1192080826,
-0.2779496312,
-0.8508051038,
0.1076523811,
-0.915456593,
-0.5044259429,
0.058629442,
0.0801041722,
-0.7268589735,
-0.1712746322,
-0.2314613312,
-0.3627066016,
-0.1711948216,
0.1635215729,
-0.7254691124,
0.0815105513,
0.2470835447,
0.7453395724,
-0.2268571854,
-0.0674405172,
-0.144541949,
-0.1552767903,
-0.6768648028,
0.7103339434,
0.2138346285,
-0.6678196192,
0.443258673,
-0.3612789512,
0.1339232028,
-0.2985430956,
0.625833571,
-0.7815042138,
0.4167280793,
0.1514499038,
-0.2744007111,
-0.215181008,
0.1343080699,
-0.8619850278,
0.7562268972,
-0.1247975826,
-0.9109986424,
0.2968135476,
-0.424620837,
-1.1320978403,
0.1268253028,
-0.3580217361,
-0.986956954,
0.0915185139,
0.2006062418,
0.3377774656,
-0.4118566513,
0.3167535365,
-0.0631412342,
-0.0171546433,
0.6481413245,
-0.9409134388,
0.8148845434,
0.6677837372,
-0.5384837985,
-0.1177035049,
-0.7725321054,
0.0236187931,
0.5751465559,
-0.4404846132,
-0.0262328014,
0.0992094502,
0.1762930602,
-0.0827131122,
0.0019291148,
-0.3531351089,
0.0945375562,
-0.5532546639,
0.25508371,
0.6994345188,
0.1877755672,
0.4094572663,
-0.3738286495,
0.7319284678,
-0.2513311803,
0.0159038138,
-0.0670419857,
-0.5784987211,
-0.6843492985,
0.2025741339,
0.4303784966,
0.4466183484,
-1.4074409008,
0.3565084934,
-0.0136340326,
-0.5095102787,
-0.0059667951,
0.1303041726,
0.7436468601,
0.3417835236,
0.2281814367,
-0.0856434405,
-0.5822631717,
-0.7008388638,
-0.1041656807,
-0.3531356752,
-0.0111323912,
0.3333464861,
0.3974345028,
-0.1468777508,
0.5854922533,
-0.7647433281,
-0.0426460057,
-0.3827088773,
0.5250583887,
-0.4867524803,
0.176511839,
0.6229902506,
-1.2935596704,
-0.5713434815,
0.0729938596,
-0.8058696985,
0.4234778285,
-0.3100148141,
-0.0255202167,
0.4002928138,
0.156402275,
-0.5823490024,
0.2966127098,
0.4341962337,
0.090486154,
0.6795651317,
-0.3590205312,
0.3124601841,
-1.1841977835,
0.0555408262,
0.1964125931,
-0.2214960009,
-0.6961712241,
0.1081113666,
-0.1461907178,
-0.4321217537,
-0.3914602697,
0.3434007168,
-0.4851065278,
0.2388865054,
-0.5738434792,
0.2645812333,
0.0800551996,
0.2721869946,
0.1015198678,
0.7811031938,
0.4606233537,
-0.8215001822,
0.8956626058,
0.461329937,
-0.2184255719,
0.2518156171,
-0.4588003159,
0.0963463783,
-0.2526052594,
0.2984603941,
-0.7006852627,
-0.2644649446,
0.5825507641,
-0.6047039032,
0.3454071879,
0.2354697287,
-0.3452869356,
-0.5956884027,
-0.2620127201,
0.0133133279,
0.5895912051,
-0.4655944705,
0.0041840766,
0.2331346869,
-0.1633487791,
-0.2571490407,
-0.9453442693,
0.397937417,
-0.1160647571,
-0.4909282923,
0.4535293579,
-0.1006510779,
-0.1643177271,
0.1158300787,
0.4066380858,
0.0104230624,
-0.0250778832,
-0.1065432206,
0.1803473532,
-0.2858119905,
0.0590692498,
-0.2222172171,
0.0916896313,
-0.0555312671,
-0.2307215631,
0.0978716835,
-0.075345099,
0.073977828,
0.197539106,
0.5192449689,
0.1340467632,
-0.0464590415,
0.7470098138,
0.6432077289,
-0.0961245298,
-0.4002155066,
-0.0734173506,
0.2957569659,
-0.4445382357,
0.312581718,
-0.0320233963,
-0.4631062448,
-0.0755945593,
0.0552821457,
0.0782948434,
0.6140456796,
0.5669477582,
0.064044334,
1.0190393925,
0.3504974842,
0.2658807039,
0.5343824625,
-0.1817207485,
0.1167520061,
-0.584232688,
-0.0679362044,
-0.4734933376,
0.0166136771,
-0.7594652772,
0.0963421538,
0.2378268838,
-0.1205877438,
0.1220664605,
0.4284315109,
-0.73078233,
-0.1079323962,
0.5134651065,
0.134626314,
-0.0290367212,
0.1195460334,
0.1105238423,
0.2694294155,
-0.6755771637,
-0.641956687,
1.2277282476,
-0.1547266394,
0.5911203027,
0.0915012136,
0.3537564576,
0.4775857925,
0.5123952031,
-0.4734531343,
0.6318194866,
-0.6206177473,
-0.5687040687,
-0.3041412234,
-0.7781386971,
-1.1345822811,
0.1601439714,
-0.3726667166,
-0.0182176959,
-0.3465141058,
0.1278449744,
-0.1657685488,
0.3297556043,
-0.5486003757,
0.6060478687,
-0.3209331334,
-0.0466892868,
0.2275449336,
-0.5311917663,
0.5153316855,
0.1083317772,
-0.008793924,
0.4849298596,
0.2642886043,
0.6418802738,
-0.1945356131,
0.4637849927,
0.1090566516,
-0.3210000992,
0.8008096218,
-0.2618007362,
0.6132689714,
0.0503246412,
-0.1389351785,
-0.3384947181,
-0.8329183459,
-0.0315600149,
-0.3825856149,
0.7402811646,
-0.5395242572,
-0.2736845613,
-0.5742035508,
-0.1511260569,
-0.1428500563,
0.3316923082,
0.9756721854,
0.7261461616,
-0.7694954276,
0.3328335583,
0.8273072243,
-0.3023641706,
0.5802848339,
-0.0152124623,
0.1253107637,
-0.8647742867,
1.1114699841,
-0.0339316502,
0.1651489437,
0.4761102498,
0.1085595712,
-0.3738184571,
-0.7631278038,
-1.0171642303,
-0.3373316526,
-0.4509935379,
-0.3777189851,
-0.5189986229,
-0.6131478548,
-0.5305665135,
-0.2980215549,
-0.2943735123,
-0.2220639735,
-0.6608245969,
-0.0187583789,
0.3022438884,
0.9707490802,
0.3115098774,
0.2492672652,
-0.4775363803,
0.6880108118,
0.3555727303,
-0.0745825768,
-0.1288523078,
0.1556956917,
-0.217124626,
0.2508695126,
-0.9365788102,
-0.9204108715,
0.3247487247,
0.1574832052,
0.2292744517,
0.366666764,
0.2223074734,
-0.0112289656,
-0.5240070224,
0.9736642838,
0.6156376004,
-0.3887629509,
0.7669853568,
-0.4840521514,
0.1843430996,
0.1781098545,
0.2398215532,
-0.2397728115,
-0.535587132,
-0.8439935446,
-0.7217776775,
0.4634435773,
0.8320914507,
0.1254879087,
-0.0608182661,
0.2264046669,
-0.0312338341,
0.4095728993,
-0.7270463109,
-0.4931423366,
-0.4262191951,
-0.3327160776,
-0.2170276195,
0.0647032931,
-0.1930707991,
0.559092164,
0.7886675,
-0.0491330251,
0.0953060165,
0.2838385701,
0.1152285561,
0.0991694629,
0.4825651348,
0.6479460597,
0.2617204189,
0.33374843,
0.0291110035,
-0.0028510028,
-0.5908988714,
0.3281796873,
0.2986039817,
-0.7764220834,
-0.0059367521,
0.179979831,
0.9956489801,
-0.2546672821,
-0.4118641317,
0.6475399733,
-0.3855342269,
-0.5918456912,
-0.3765371442,
0.3417066336,
-0.2389434129,
-0.1274285316,
0.2669672668,
0.5386955738,
0.2662326694,
-0.2718236148,
0.0312708318,
0.5758519769,
-0.4804689288,
-0.1351516396,
0.7335631251,
0.3807123005,
-0.3065807521,
0.4123399258,
-0.5081589222,
-0.2857571542,
0.6532036066,
0.6425084472,
1.0574059486,
0.1418517977,
0.6015155315,
0.1381696016,
0.1665268987,
-0.1038004756,
-0.0629740506,
0.0331811421,
-0.5196612477,
0.0269349664,
-0.512170732,
-0.2381563038,
0.4737027586,
-0.3599375784,
-0.017585149,
-0.4467200339,
-0.4281475246,
-0.0055163521,
0.103178449,
-0.2338533998,
0.7202073932,
0.054745663,
0.3466044068,
-0.5086199641,
0.2844341993,
1.0406165123,
-0.3644260168,
-0.1266245395,
0.1198975369,
-0.0396659523,
-0.2278821468,
0.2113379687,
-0.1349029243,
-0.252430439,
-0.02782619,
-0.3537587225,
-0.1601049453,
0.8445289731,
0.0943982899,
-0.0172996242,
-0.1363621652,
-0.0558763221,
0.7057774067,
-0.0835079104,
-0.1392265558,
-0.0481247194,
0.1873212755,
0.216712296,
0.1753206253,
0.0219736118,
-0.5323062539,
0.6309746504,
0.2533215284,
-0.7623420954,
0.7155867815,
0.0419305414,
-0.5884171128,
0.5272060633,
0.8894677758,
0.051171083,
0.0404178686,
0.3209406734,
0.4135811627,
0.2646229267,
-0.0800448135,
1.1239783764,
0.0926984921,
0.0534556992,
0.6342183948,
0.0591791421,
0.2964657843,
-0.0481658503,
-0.1498259455,
0.3620380461,
0.4279320836,
-0.2579981685,
0.4168246388,
0.3160299361,
-0.6786944866,
0.2090917081,
0.0501262695,
-0.5340949893,
0.1130623296,
0.2904445529,
-0.4494752586,
-0.0978765041,
0.2283488512,
-0.0420963615,
0.4344911277,
-0.0099777551,
0.9492752552,
0.0133065917,
-0.8683511615,
0.1500722319,
0.3321065009,
0.6036525965,
-0.6245431304,
0.1925560832,
0.0351099111,
0.1765372008,
0.0739132613,
-0.8422017097,
0.1568854898,
0.3552950621,
-0.223162964,
-0.6189653873,
1.0561511517,
-0.1144765392,
-0.4751764238,
-0.2514323592,
0.0937653035,
-0.1446852237,
0.0423025861,
-0.5833839178,
-0.3045045435,
0.0084154066,
-0.4572073519,
0.0903566852,
0.5693899393,
0.5375972986,
0.3462777138,
0.5642232299,
0.3560223579,
0.0568301007,
-0.000366445,
0.64649266,
-0.5825352073,
-0.5359991193,
-0.6643869877,
0.342301935,
-0.2857483625,
-0.74820894,
0.8464536071,
0.5603107214,
0.5074537992,
-0.1417931616,
1.3177371025,
-0.2742132545,
0.1793424189,
-0.8072186708,
0.8589948416,
-0.4327163398,
-0.2196446657,
-0.2478305697,
-0.5340471864,
-0.2292831838,
0.1783382148,
-0.0396772474,
0.1422117651,
0.5676685572,
0.4797357023,
0.2184765637,
0.3026599586,
0.1830040365,
-0.2524817288,
0.4378117919,
0.4260239303,
0.9133133292,
-0.8572236896,
1.1016709805,
-0.0545442104,
-0.2310868353,
-0.1948900819,
-0.7801514864,
-0.7848401666,
-0.5506159067,
-0.3143194318,
-0.3149749339,
0.2332712859,
0.0344614945,
0.4272134602,
-0.5860509872,
0.3564151525,
-0.9125961661,
0.0068344376,
-0.0496496446,
-0.2261564285,
0.3978326023,
-0.3470701873,
-0.8562511206,
0.3610658944,
-0.0184864551,
0.4979815483,
-0.5069311261,
-0.0291337948,
-0.0293924585,
-0.0178389549,
0.4925502539,
0.6152073741,
-0.2866003513,
0.2224401087,
-0.1450840831,
-0.6401746869,
0.0044769924,
0.9638230205,
-0.4119723141,
0.4041607678,
0.5440250635,
0.6665750742,
0.3835378885,
0.0219654068,
0.8474183083,
-0.8864880204,
-0.0463343523,
0.3264183402,
-0.0137619246,
0.6763256788,
-0.438252449,
0.2025931329,
0.2144022286,
-0.580388248,
-0.3442311585,
0.5784742832,
-0.2927032411,
-0.4762919247,
1.1228914261,
-0.0582698323,
-0.2276976258,
0.0396522544,
-0.3622902632,
0.5200556517,
-0.1215148866,
0.6274303198,
0.4803943634,
0.0204264894,
0.2199008167,
-0.3320924938,
0.7580348253,
0.1404666603,
-0.9978246689,
-0.134791851,
0.6679003835,
-0.3319985867,
0.2215912491,
0.6176344752,
-0.1519282609,
0.2251278162,
0.4336127937,
-0.0992786735,
-0.0758199096,
-0.4166352153,
-0.1938575655,
0.3770439923,
-0.2114646882,
-0.2486711442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10474v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10474v2 | ByGPT5: End-to-End Style-conditioned Poetry Generation with Token-free Language Models | 2022-12-20T17:49:49 | 2023-05-22T21:15:06 | Jonas Belouadi, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art poetry generation systems are often complex. They either
consist of task-specific model pipelines, incorporate prior knowledge in the
form of manually created constraints, or both. In contrast, end-to-end models
would not suffer from the overhead of having to model prior knowledge and could
learn the nuances of poetry from data alone, reducing the degree of human
supervision required. In this work, we investigate end-to-end poetry generation
conditioned on styles such as rhyme, meter, and alliteration. We identify and
address lack of training data and mismatching tokenization algorithms as
possible limitations of past attempts. In particular, we successfully pre-train
ByGPT5, a new token-free decoder-only language model, and fine-tune it on a
large custom corpus of English and German quatrains annotated with our styles.
We show that ByGPT5 outperforms other models such as mT5, ByT5, GPT-2 and
ChatGPT, while also being more parameter efficient and performing favorably
compared to humans. In addition, we analyze its runtime performance and
demonstrate that it is not prone to memorization. We make our code, models, and
datasets publicly available. | [
-0.2643249333,
-0.065229319,
0.4148036838,
0.1381007284,
-0.6250248551,
0.0031855193,
-0.3630226254,
-0.5360971689,
-0.0400395989,
0.4467724264,
-0.7255721092,
-0.6261883378,
-0.5985023975,
0.1951095909,
-0.4551385343,
1.1900750399,
-0.0768596232,
-0.1625156105,
-0.0046640141,
-0.0796284303,
-0.3013513684,
-0.5919277072,
-0.7653307319,
-0.4909226596,
0.4436456859,
0.4978325963,
0.2694370747,
0.3199289143,
0.1834764034,
0.1880374402,
0.0868529305,
0.0073597925,
-0.4664156735,
0.1284101158,
0.100259833,
-0.4492564201,
-0.2410238236,
0.1363345236,
0.329951793,
0.3314059377,
-0.1411884278,
0.4780981839,
-0.5647346377,
0.6600352526,
-0.623645246,
0.0268076733,
-1.0038099289,
0.2628035545,
-0.5865904093,
-0.3113069832,
-0.5571136475,
-0.1717237085,
-0.1000003293,
-0.5717821121,
0.429815799,
0.1855983585,
0.6013008952,
0.3504032791,
-0.4152054787,
-0.2785125971,
-0.5594409704,
0.5382936597,
-0.704826951,
0.7299095988,
0.1683177948,
0.497988224,
-0.2617017329,
-1.2382675409,
-0.7201036811,
0.0267154872,
-0.0325809754,
0.6197187901,
-0.2893412411,
0.0388754904,
0.3614443541,
0.2013033479,
-0.8168435097,
-0.2333624214,
-0.5702769756,
0.06965141,
0.4270542264,
-0.2548520267,
0.2805456817,
-0.4556189179,
-0.5108833909,
-0.0346860029,
-0.7143298388,
0.3882948756,
0.4429237247,
0.1146889254,
-0.1744173616,
0.3038979769,
-0.2335232943,
0.3747484386,
-0.1431467384,
0.0907520577,
0.1557786316,
-0.1956761181,
-0.1970506012,
0.2455540448,
0.8567053676,
0.289512068,
0.6705546379,
-0.6092241406,
-0.4375354648,
0.3134326637,
0.2500348091,
-0.8373094201,
-0.5949872732,
0.2243830264,
-0.4073797464,
-0.3816205263,
-0.2683970332,
-0.0986976251,
-0.0323991366,
-0.1668419093,
0.4774253964,
-0.6219063401,
-0.0156004885,
0.3877961934,
-0.5976156592,
0.1399776489,
-0.1254075617,
-0.911537528,
0.2697177231,
0.5329376459,
0.7743765116,
0.0513518453,
-0.3567827642,
-0.4823678136,
-0.0030375328,
-0.4871390164,
0.6365552545,
-0.4223130047,
-0.4140149653,
-0.3086725473,
-0.2358003557,
-0.0131787751,
-0.2570546865,
1.0504308939,
-0.3893560767,
0.4237169921,
-0.1526838243,
-0.6058116555,
0.0072355578,
-0.0285632629,
-0.3739964068,
0.7790400982,
0.1507149339,
-0.9969453812,
0.7599712014,
-0.6685213447,
-0.2891838551,
0.0038464044,
-0.1928568035,
-0.5213128328,
0.3302053809,
0.208482936,
0.5554962754,
-0.2825517356,
0.032647036,
-0.0527195744,
-0.4455848634,
0.2091888934,
-0.4827308655,
0.4180255234,
0.410631299,
-0.2270753384,
0.3608417511,
-1.1999280453,
0.2515698671,
0.3216408193,
-0.3350603878,
-0.047415223,
-0.0395691954,
0.310465008,
0.4153819084,
-0.0342321992,
-0.716440618,
0.1914520562,
-0.323361218,
0.6889473796,
0.638975203,
-0.1289422661,
0.1544468105,
-0.6479398608,
0.5882148743,
0.0259644818,
0.0967145711,
-0.4334902167,
-0.2799812257,
-0.5535573363,
-0.4366632104,
0.2928120494,
0.3731374443,
-0.552497983,
0.2172114253,
-0.4963290691,
-0.553982079,
-0.4669159353,
-0.0916671082,
0.3689643443,
0.3112401068,
0.3975520134,
-0.6416338086,
-0.6857605577,
-0.4752166867,
-0.1131088659,
0.0388221592,
0.1603523046,
0.1052944437,
0.1958714873,
0.229208231,
1.0466560125,
-0.3109466136,
0.0531166866,
-0.5030614734,
0.2503210306,
0.1575029641,
0.5454987884,
0.666633904,
-0.2812340558,
-0.3524520695,
-0.1731016636,
-0.3216910958,
-0.1855835766,
-0.2807880938,
-0.1182539538,
0.0813986808,
0.3856764138,
-0.6583898664,
0.1715344787,
0.468755722,
-0.3789711595,
0.598915875,
-0.262188226,
-0.2317247391,
-1.1465411186,
0.2296738178,
-0.1920591891,
-0.4796639085,
-0.8259184957,
-0.0021142312,
-0.1268905252,
-0.4385933876,
-0.3137272298,
0.6620774269,
-0.4202281833,
-0.0083464002,
-0.1969157606,
-0.1659150273,
-0.0394902378,
0.5953627229,
0.3430129588,
0.6276988387,
0.5610790253,
-0.1765007079,
0.2187744528,
0.1136612147,
-0.2410507798,
0.2400878966,
-0.6381040215,
0.5005841851,
-0.3891484439,
0.5553882122,
-0.9641662836,
-0.0816848725,
0.1702802926,
-0.8044734001,
0.2748366892,
-0.388781637,
-0.5223274231,
-0.0772810951,
-0.296795398,
0.4123392105,
0.8736134768,
-0.5649719238,
0.1551093459,
-0.4495314956,
0.181268394,
-0.4462392628,
-0.3116015196,
0.0908306912,
-0.4636418521,
-0.5341986418,
0.151788488,
-0.0222159903,
0.1530666351,
-0.2224582732,
-0.1442929357,
0.1539880186,
0.0884163603,
0.1127060503,
-0.2479195744,
-0.019458482,
0.0258568879,
-0.0092377737,
-0.3473953903,
0.0150203397,
-0.9049990773,
0.7622513771,
0.2875667512,
-0.5652116537,
-0.2588656247,
0.371317029,
0.6950141191,
-0.6967865825,
0.3484224081,
0.8724003434,
-0.2120236158,
-0.4648094177,
-0.2049499601,
-0.0234090146,
-0.4450238645,
0.0147519195,
-0.3979415298,
-0.5150530338,
0.530243516,
-0.0507409982,
0.180983901,
-0.0497341864,
0.3672695756,
0.1592561305,
0.5756680369,
0.4995346069,
0.0810216069,
0.5372830629,
-0.2985853255,
0.2110366076,
-0.6735010147,
0.0673995018,
-0.3313605785,
-0.4825158715,
-0.7118387222,
-0.1351296604,
0.3921377957,
0.1627469212,
-0.3377820551,
0.1014625654,
-0.7583173513,
0.3462053537,
0.9136576056,
0.0653185174,
0.220115453,
-0.0924664512,
-0.2594768107,
0.1148004532,
-0.7527322173,
-0.2501216233,
1.5236397982,
0.0648480654,
0.4237524271,
0.2031864077,
1.063845396,
-0.115070127,
-0.054151386,
-0.7108812332,
0.2623486519,
-0.4256096482,
-0.4228833318,
-0.2095128,
-0.0716178194,
-1.0189627409,
-0.1207525507,
-0.2346893549,
-0.7101469636,
-0.1657066345,
0.2153885216,
-0.2249503881,
0.1939814389,
-0.7513329387,
0.8255580068,
-0.0429250523,
-0.1132670566,
0.1890560538,
-0.8045068383,
0.3780907691,
-0.1037640944,
0.0383592322,
-0.0231044944,
0.2549855411,
0.4416765571,
-0.6023432612,
0.8130261302,
-0.0392342657,
0.1353109181,
0.2790645063,
-0.1004101261,
0.6187298298,
-0.1641008109,
0.1186546907,
-0.2259493023,
0.1832595617,
-0.4654664099,
-0.674204886,
0.3342043459,
-0.7837473154,
-0.2055785805,
-0.1686187983,
-0.3363097608,
-0.16828008,
0.2262856066,
0.8374524117,
0.6502413154,
0.2629582584,
0.0965053439,
0.3778458536,
0.0329231545,
0.6416146159,
0.0859626606,
-0.2711317241,
-0.5255103111,
0.954066813,
0.3339639306,
0.2365472019,
0.1612701416,
0.3599902987,
-0.5222123265,
-0.5599210858,
-0.815346837,
-0.0640343651,
-0.8415920734,
0.1152183264,
-0.3954640031,
-0.1885606498,
-0.5313170552,
-0.3227092326,
-0.2226483822,
-0.6218342781,
0.0166765526,
-0.0312188007,
0.6831057072,
0.5207415819,
0.1324496418,
0.5177738667,
-0.7140643597,
-0.0160453618,
0.0346188582,
0.5629784465,
0.0800016075,
-0.2954539061,
-0.0004184518,
-0.6233129501,
-0.2310821563,
-0.9824532866,
0.0976556316,
0.1987811029,
0.2119769007,
0.2797354758,
0.2965354621,
0.5186721087,
-0.7428985238,
0.7709128261,
0.1914273053,
-0.9788351655,
0.2055671215,
-0.5325511098,
0.3275820613,
0.2084803432,
0.1240599528,
-0.9942741394,
-0.2001415938,
-0.9617084861,
-0.967253089,
0.454911083,
0.4207964838,
0.1833893061,
-0.0318093188,
0.6799263954,
0.1667944193,
0.346218437,
-0.7807117701,
-0.0353605151,
-0.8009677529,
-0.3630524576,
-0.1568929106,
0.106078878,
0.159828648,
-0.1491533071,
0.6574859023,
-0.1553586423,
0.1813075989,
0.1976575851,
0.1138888225,
-0.0861581862,
0.4904385209,
0.7484030128,
0.2998439968,
0.1257574856,
0.2557384074,
0.2364506274,
-0.22296004,
0.1225483865,
-0.1807731092,
-0.3566824794,
0.0910961032,
0.4888211787,
1.2209792137,
-0.0945940986,
-0.558010757,
0.5190865397,
-0.0744111091,
-0.0970048532,
-0.5315353274,
0.1820686907,
0.1135021448,
0.1099266633,
-0.0232936833,
0.0283460282,
0.0597241074,
-0.4413608611,
0.3966159225,
0.5732691884,
-0.3278337121,
-0.446188271,
0.8765268326,
-0.1832617372,
-0.0480221435,
0.2830981612,
-0.4664411843,
-0.4840404987,
0.1859034151,
0.858094573,
0.9397573471,
0.3211554587,
-0.1393740177,
0.1174616963,
0.1219382659,
0.2294054329,
0.5775386095,
-0.3985474706,
-0.643927753,
-0.5166918039,
-0.6551614404,
-0.2456561774,
0.2073695809,
-0.2432005256,
0.6137533188,
-0.6822879314,
-0.0972740203,
-0.3636424839,
-0.0290478226,
-0.4938439429,
0.5534777045,
0.1216628999,
0.9889472127,
-0.8057422042,
0.7640493512,
0.7928571701,
-0.4745083451,
-1.2341109514,
0.064920269,
-0.1783402264,
-0.6417946219,
0.5350660086,
0.0420895591,
-0.1473920196,
0.5959711075,
-0.5815954804,
-0.6382612586,
1.1043168306,
0.2917009592,
-0.0831125528,
-0.0795706883,
0.0128742103,
0.5438348055,
0.0676604882,
0.3929411769,
0.500600636,
0.195967868,
0.6008147001,
-0.8546050787,
-0.0607761107,
-0.3920532167,
-0.1218130663,
0.3042224348,
-0.8610605597,
0.8728830814,
0.1010595784,
-0.1760304272,
-0.1227773651,
0.6422937512,
0.2455959618,
0.222300902,
0.1831477135,
0.8778336048,
0.7749596238,
-0.0152914235,
0.8360699415,
-0.6648905873,
0.2134954482,
0.8679435849,
-0.0867174119,
0.7741419673,
0.1289595962,
0.0897978619,
0.1067114398,
0.7289524078,
0.1526067704,
0.4670023322,
0.623627007,
-0.4901690781,
-0.3638110459,
0.0208530128,
-0.2433807701,
0.6479095221,
-0.2130971253,
-0.2073538303,
-0.3048069477,
-0.2830830812,
0.3766484261,
-0.0876977369,
-0.1649567336,
0.7298485637,
0.0602026135,
-0.5368510485,
0.7249013782,
0.189273119,
0.8606638312,
-0.6290073395,
0.2690584362,
-0.2980051041,
-0.0746573731,
-0.3331818581,
-0.4694637954,
0.2570642829,
0.2627981305,
-0.1224070787,
-0.1829274744,
0.7946618795,
-0.312107861,
-0.4896732867,
-0.1021241769,
0.5843966007,
0.295940429,
0.0401928015,
-0.2738315165,
-0.2767347097,
-0.2322898358,
-0.254294157,
0.1737700701,
0.8179705143,
-0.4387803376,
0.7790727615,
0.9629366398,
0.5306847692,
0.4193667173,
0.2337284684,
0.6410030127,
-0.360016197,
-0.4789023697,
-0.7573614717,
0.4515613914,
0.3659543693,
-0.4313337505,
0.1506832391,
0.5612220764,
0.9073946476,
0.0569466949,
1.1226722002,
0.2560136616,
0.397400856,
-0.8288488984,
1.0509332418,
-0.6364639997,
-0.1963457316,
-0.2320585847,
-0.4916374087,
-0.2659044862,
0.3274741173,
-0.0506568514,
0.1184908077,
0.517378211,
0.3789688647,
-0.1975518912,
-0.1065119207,
0.5274329782,
-0.2831219733,
0.639654696,
0.6142271757,
0.5045028925,
-0.2430873364,
0.4435464442,
-0.248245731,
0.1102797911,
0.3132604957,
-1.0447723866,
-0.8459452391,
-0.6871051788,
0.1570888162,
-0.0038589248,
0.1239487529,
1.4756644964,
0.5778269768,
-0.4177843928,
0.0283602402,
-0.2705281973,
-0.3582071662,
-0.0157503914,
-0.0259948839,
0.3850849271,
-0.7533124685,
-0.679805994,
0.2293497622,
0.0493074134,
0.2725113928,
-0.1188311428,
-0.1001564264,
0.3081735969,
0.2566061616,
0.5517823696,
0.0070646536,
-0.524210155,
-0.5142076612,
0.0944565237,
0.2543484271,
0.2617511749,
0.8298401237,
-0.7578017116,
0.3183604777,
0.5444336534,
0.389000535,
0.290601939,
0.1721067131,
0.4543082714,
-1.2483187914,
0.0811539069,
-0.0907954946,
0.5555755496,
0.2727788389,
-0.1754170805,
0.3576151133,
0.5223983526,
-0.3477156162,
-0.5206041336,
0.5253056884,
-0.9145157933,
-0.0321305543,
0.8781498075,
-0.2092039585,
0.015724007,
0.0593468547,
-0.2707800865,
0.6976057887,
-0.3483176231,
0.6461569071,
0.8516936898,
-0.2651104033,
-0.4620296061,
-0.58420223,
0.7345978618,
0.4393796921,
-0.6032173038,
0.0745217428,
0.3417436182,
0.4341979325,
-0.1112783253,
0.9151316881,
0.109918192,
0.3889402747,
-0.0231055003,
0.4635100365,
-0.3029074669,
-0.3597128689,
-0.0929347202,
0.2051668912,
0.6419206262,
-0.3452599943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.11670v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.11670v1 | Evaluation for Change | 2022-12-20T17:49:27 | 2022-12-20T17:49:27 | Rishi Bommasani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Evaluation is the central means for assessing, understanding, and
communicating about NLP models. In this position paper, we argue evaluation
should be more than that: it is a force for driving change, carrying a
sociological and political character beyond its technical dimensions. As a
force, evaluation's power arises from its adoption: under our view, evaluation
succeeds when it achieves the desired change in the field. Further, by framing
evaluation as a force, we consider how it competes with other forces. Under our
analysis, we conjecture that the current trajectory of NLP suggests
evaluation's power is waning, in spite of its potential for realizing more
pluralistic ambitions in the field. We conclude by discussing the legitimacy of
this power, who acquires this power and how it distributes. Ultimately, we hope
the research community will more aggressively harness evaluation for change. | [
-0.1782449782,
-0.2653989792,
0.6680248976,
0.5759236813,
-0.2630929649,
0.2503073215,
-0.4108929932,
-0.3927484751,
0.1954425424,
0.1717764884,
-0.3905609548,
-0.0793625489,
-1.2095756531,
0.2678439915,
-0.7571592331,
1.0514649153,
0.3205212057,
0.176401943,
-0.235376969,
-0.2161166668,
-0.3777654469,
-0.2244361341,
-0.5679671168,
-0.8795574903,
0.5424982905,
-0.0963461995,
1.1567524672,
0.2292010635,
0.6781036258,
0.2999149859,
-0.3818630874,
-0.2923265398,
-0.588796854,
0.073523365,
-0.7347794175,
-0.7124211788,
-0.2137065381,
0.3325081766,
0.8313467503,
0.8855714798,
-0.104911074,
0.2430889755,
0.060002096,
0.9351671338,
-0.6046224236,
0.0515442118,
-0.9639540911,
0.138649404,
-0.0296527725,
-0.2165465653,
-0.2678401172,
-0.4582956731,
0.0857117251,
-0.5352641344,
0.0437577292,
0.1090095639,
0.7489129901,
0.029359445,
-0.2690587342,
-0.2244024277,
-0.9333347678,
0.9059274197,
-0.513610661,
0.5231940746,
0.120523937,
0.3526301086,
-0.0674959421,
-0.9082817435,
-0.6875844598,
-0.236411646,
0.385256052,
0.1887526363,
-0.5658608079,
-0.13439098,
0.3258957863,
0.5858907104,
0.1377097368,
-0.0488297306,
-0.7250300646,
0.1822942048,
0.764641881,
0.135607481,
0.5630371571,
-0.2914736569,
-0.2664394975,
-0.079893671,
-0.4448625445,
0.0471707098,
0.3289477229,
0.2999866307,
0.2585641444,
0.413339138,
-0.0541622452,
0.2635068297,
0.0064266361,
0.3959146738,
0.1517442465,
-0.4090287089,
-0.3827773631,
0.0264938027,
0.6575829387,
0.6500142217,
-0.1468148679,
-0.3277926147,
-0.4108166099,
0.1587143987,
0.8976368308,
-0.5830134749,
0.0692737475,
0.0146222394,
-0.7536257505,
-0.5345064998,
0.2619534731,
-0.8986523151,
-0.5631531477,
-0.5093348622,
0.5164179802,
-0.4085783064,
-0.6521277428,
0.3468957245,
-0.5181351304,
0.3621571064,
0.4151594043,
-1.2058349848,
0.5508376956,
1.1669490337,
0.8724501729,
-0.059567038,
-0.2867998779,
0.1032065451,
-0.5647812486,
-0.6695535779,
0.5599774718,
-0.7148929834,
-0.6435915828,
0.0505283177,
0.0005211743,
-0.1383063346,
-0.7432563901,
0.5609458685,
-0.384901911,
0.0436756127,
-0.4521524906,
-0.3942043781,
-0.0317036547,
0.1373957247,
-0.7873343825,
1.0496681929,
0.185744077,
-0.3160463572,
0.7381311655,
-1.1315534115,
-0.1420379281,
0.2828995883,
0.0439610966,
-0.3923101127,
0.667329371,
-0.2389728129,
0.0544005372,
-0.3460480273,
0.4776727855,
-0.2860318124,
-0.2081982642,
0.4101676643,
-0.299836725,
1.0603262186,
-0.0794812217,
-0.4038824439,
0.2284123003,
-0.8288520575,
0.1461037248,
-0.0883885622,
-0.1706886739,
-0.3886873126,
0.2866563201,
0.0004317471,
0.1060818806,
-0.1304614097,
-0.5635339618,
0.2751931548,
-0.5995625854,
0.2408416867,
0.7475011945,
-0.0506604351,
0.8687193394,
-0.4253523648,
0.8171293736,
-0.8189311624,
0.4323138297,
0.3711691797,
-0.7938249707,
-0.5709855556,
0.464979887,
0.6499000788,
0.0115419282,
-0.3864144683,
0.3091919422,
-0.2805091441,
-0.8389281631,
-0.7042783499,
-0.1259364337,
0.050399337,
0.1219617128,
0.5549817681,
-0.4207577407,
-0.7683184743,
-0.6686064005,
-0.7443419099,
-0.4193930626,
-0.2206092477,
-0.0765106753,
0.7797322273,
-0.3091595173,
1.0068649054,
0.1061063409,
-0.3218715489,
-0.4505949616,
0.2541060746,
0.2628946602,
0.4239287376,
0.5075505972,
-0.9530739784,
0.0962865353,
0.025679281,
-0.7285664678,
-0.5401486158,
-0.2450037599,
-0.0391377546,
-0.5678280592,
0.3481935263,
-0.2199367732,
0.1887659431,
0.5898647904,
-0.4874828756,
0.978564322,
0.1189080775,
0.2188319117,
-0.3866588473,
0.1658440679,
-0.4244280457,
0.1083000004,
-0.4986248016,
0.2303359061,
-0.1901125759,
-0.2478409261,
-0.3236351311,
0.6082057357,
-0.3400231004,
0.0152293788,
-0.2919884026,
0.3288435042,
0.3909904361,
-0.3191485703,
-0.3715926707,
0.319870621,
0.2844857872,
-0.629769206,
0.3986594081,
0.2743342221,
-0.7600271702,
0.5190522671,
-0.5926987529,
0.1422640979,
0.0522902124,
-0.0052465587,
-0.3208756447,
0.1640528589,
0.084607482,
-0.2338414192,
0.0513185076,
0.0696544573,
-0.2127667069,
-0.2270567715,
-0.3327300549,
-0.0649024919,
0.2396978885,
-0.3417470455,
0.6219831705,
0.4290737808,
0.1070947126,
-0.6444749236,
-0.6597619057,
0.4586823583,
-0.0323302262,
-0.691202879,
0.5859978199,
0.1421258748,
-0.7621639371,
0.2336456627,
-0.1155801117,
-0.0165173355,
0.3683370948,
0.3210275769,
-0.2223886997,
-0.1330977827,
0.5892085433,
0.0683616847,
-0.1632971615,
0.459566623,
0.0245461594,
0.2947345972,
-0.2299180329,
-0.3092284203,
-0.0467211418,
0.3439360559,
0.3894352317,
-0.2489867359,
0.5208261609,
0.5143074989,
-0.1634944528,
-0.1279734373,
-0.1320798844,
-0.2537631691,
-0.4238358438,
0.6148856878,
-0.0729129463,
-0.4816332459,
0.1195563376,
-0.5978025794,
0.1746421158,
0.7461053133,
0.5245633125,
0.0098304441,
0.7474423647,
1.041246295,
0.4303657115,
0.5967193246,
-0.3193273544,
0.416228056,
-1.0303903818,
-0.3729946315,
-0.6740096211,
-0.5015993118,
-0.3020171821,
-0.257126987,
0.2643536627,
0.3951579928,
0.2815341353,
0.1886017323,
-0.7508160472,
0.3182140291,
-0.0221351013,
-0.1348852664,
0.2160821706,
-0.4763364196,
0.0453748107,
-0.363535732,
-0.612129271,
-0.8021199107,
1.07833004,
0.4302348197,
0.5184418559,
0.0596300066,
0.4366526604,
0.3444210887,
0.7413660884,
-1.0564712286,
0.6234337091,
0.1146424189,
-0.4747698903,
-0.2242666185,
0.0067192982,
-1.3209084272,
0.6015630364,
-0.5439135432,
-0.6042696834,
0.3250224292,
-0.2065638453,
-0.1266265959,
0.4813809693,
-0.4556908011,
0.8963557482,
-0.228562355,
-0.1090613976,
-0.6036782861,
-0.13918899,
0.2667283416,
0.1117299199,
0.2471134663,
-0.3147745728,
0.0012776289,
1.3444751501,
-0.2367886305,
0.6072782278,
-0.2866490781,
0.1599938571,
0.1281985343,
0.0113762533,
-0.1278158575,
-0.002276853,
-0.4886628389,
0.2815174162,
0.2016507238,
-0.0278105363,
-1.1389580965,
0.2169111371,
-0.502435863,
-0.860230267,
-0.5466655493,
-0.1749767512,
-0.0088133831,
0.0958025008,
0.1391798109,
0.2294911593,
-0.6002371311,
0.527153492,
0.1430328935,
0.0489579216,
0.4455141723,
0.2713151872,
-0.9735476375,
-0.1214051321,
0.5927928686,
0.2317386121,
0.3569620848,
0.1171565056,
0.6875355244,
-0.2875242829,
-0.5187942386,
-0.397441268,
-0.1433701068,
-0.8207152486,
0.0473026223,
-0.5607881546,
0.1317441911,
-0.2130250633,
-0.1912222356,
-0.4250188768,
-0.4377706051,
-0.1131115481,
-0.0674068555,
0.2004554421,
0.9775583148,
-0.3589103222,
0.1900751591,
-0.3365957439,
0.1295282394,
0.4291116893,
0.2029145658,
-0.10010162,
-0.5636861324,
-0.2306174636,
-0.2345213741,
-0.6593639851,
-1.0589171648,
0.2033559233,
0.2647584081,
0.3587377369,
0.2331054211,
-0.0612656921,
0.444663614,
-0.509057343,
1.021982789,
0.3350403905,
-1.2758584023,
0.5046480298,
0.1263632476,
0.4580291808,
0.5332415104,
0.3552854359,
-0.9658946395,
-0.3966443837,
-1.0967434645,
-0.9329205751,
0.390166074,
0.2153683305,
0.7326484323,
0.2675224841,
0.2862189412,
-0.0356320478,
0.6510858536,
-0.8584222198,
0.0891435593,
-0.2551285625,
0.3865614235,
0.4813016057,
-0.2146920264,
-0.2630721033,
-0.3535803556,
0.6174350381,
-0.0099003837,
0.3670504391,
0.3704283834,
0.2837260067,
-0.2147607803,
0.6931167245,
0.1890977174,
1.4138144255,
-0.0054805214,
0.006684518,
0.0201887079,
-0.3330504298,
0.0352312773,
-0.2477969974,
-0.1858745962,
0.3845137358,
0.4636172354,
0.702172339,
0.4134019017,
-0.3916333318,
0.6223843098,
0.1043702662,
-0.2142110765,
0.034676481,
0.1272058636,
-0.4388197064,
0.2335442752,
0.7410850525,
0.5654523373,
0.1703680605,
-1.0502873659,
0.2498862892,
0.4358872175,
-0.5702123046,
-0.5403565764,
0.4782370031,
0.1553553194,
-0.8726708293,
0.1462648064,
-0.189086318,
-0.8262363672,
0.7026336193,
0.4532938898,
0.9677498341,
-0.436057061,
0.4000240564,
0.2033496648,
0.7728572488,
-0.0508982055,
0.1679984629,
-0.0385375619,
-0.9313090444,
-0.3539958596,
-0.9090356231,
-0.7765496969,
0.2252010405,
-0.8487709165,
0.3864689767,
-0.7033872604,
-0.3212565482,
0.3116514683,
-0.0691934973,
-0.2923691571,
0.4310876429,
-0.2983460426,
0.7984561324,
-0.6826900244,
0.4143308699,
0.3461737633,
-0.2276137173,
-0.2908498645,
0.0132080661,
-0.0726808682,
-0.3861803412,
0.7445301414,
0.3705897927,
-0.1432302594,
-0.4935255349,
-0.6646379828,
-0.6705803871,
0.7388409376,
0.2953512371,
-0.4463765919,
-0.0495286919,
-0.4465582371,
0.8999871016,
-0.4530864656,
0.2846054137,
0.3879045248,
0.822009325,
-0.7385326028,
-1.0520966053,
-0.139243111,
-0.3485252559,
0.1784307361,
0.1000563279,
-0.4088710546,
0.5832075477,
-0.1301765442,
-0.6217045188,
-0.1550827026,
0.6195161343,
-0.2144270241,
0.4015359879,
0.536745131,
0.0280346461,
0.6132363677,
-0.328052938,
1.3757244349,
-0.1184965,
0.4338151217,
0.763667047,
-0.195853591,
0.7585000992,
0.5767688751,
-0.5547300577,
0.7867072225,
0.1163529977,
-0.2990822792,
0.263463825,
0.3811763227,
-0.0213439912,
-0.0409665406,
-0.0631222278,
-0.2605650425,
0.8966794014,
0.3440482914,
-0.583491683,
-0.3957185447,
-0.0481347516,
-0.0958089232,
0.6372002363,
-0.3639853001,
0.505248189,
0.3169874251,
-0.597045362,
0.4313981235,
0.2714398801,
0.2495650351,
-0.7734823227,
-0.252527386,
0.6817049384,
-0.1087922752,
-0.4068217278,
-0.8171331286,
1.0378974676,
-0.4186106622,
-0.3192030191,
-0.7243962884,
0.7354751825,
0.1409714967,
-0.3358798325,
0.8711628914,
0.3927013278,
0.0960334316,
-0.0584157668,
-1.2496404648,
0.407614857,
-0.0557660833,
-0.2705371976,
0.3236293197,
0.2360188961,
0.194600299,
0.5018918514,
0.9296637177,
0.3870334923,
-0.0752724111,
0.1573853195,
0.5740196705,
-0.4186988473,
-0.2275713533,
-0.8425849676,
0.3798549175,
-0.2076879442,
-0.6915572286,
0.6392678618,
0.2108341008,
0.6474711895,
0.2597548962,
0.7557141185,
-0.3928425312,
0.0709651262,
-0.5481070876,
0.8431367278,
-0.402307421,
0.1144425124,
-0.2864690721,
-0.9769461155,
-0.3107582927,
0.7881519794,
-0.5969507098,
0.0816096738,
0.7502529621,
0.3742204309,
0.2073153853,
0.4143327475,
0.5960543156,
0.235663265,
0.2936803401,
-0.1074431241,
0.8504918814,
-0.7290935516,
0.250970304,
-0.2190205604,
-0.4001286328,
-0.0056237062,
-0.9194490314,
-0.3916973472,
-0.7755654454,
-0.140607968,
-0.5854811668,
-0.0008861857,
0.8655340075,
0.4033209682,
-0.3540876508,
-0.4013601542,
-0.0198283363,
0.4243084788,
-0.8845330477,
-0.2785986364,
0.0740733743,
-0.4338282347,
-0.9465737343,
0.609901011,
0.647041738,
-0.6439071894,
-0.6738002896,
0.2177137583,
-0.3473826945,
0.1359068751,
0.8134784698,
0.2296397984,
-0.7698131204,
-0.3021638989,
-0.3680118918,
0.2850651741,
0.0648242682,
1.1075158119,
-0.6578025222,
0.9044297338,
0.3845714033,
0.7921569347,
0.0270298142,
-0.3108441532,
0.931129396,
-0.3618327379,
-0.1210138425,
0.5483920574,
0.3519329727,
0.4265354872,
-0.2561576664,
0.7483698726,
0.3326751888,
-0.7148352861,
-0.994453907,
0.2377022356,
-0.6001007557,
-0.0165932607,
1.0869750977,
0.0914022774,
-0.34363392,
-0.2335624844,
-0.0169777684,
-0.0905178934,
-0.1869346201,
1.0024867058,
0.7233753204,
-0.2252567559,
-0.2723458111,
-0.4685126841,
0.6428214312,
0.7808737755,
-0.5020800829,
-0.1127151027,
-0.1394857168,
0.1135137603,
0.788440764,
0.6865023375,
-0.4083939791,
0.2886309028,
0.1146035939,
0.1165541634,
0.4332865775,
-0.1852824688,
-0.6616295576,
0.2933565974,
-0.0049825548,
0.3783710301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10471v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10471v3 | Little Red Riding Hood Goes Around the Globe:Crosslingual Story Planning and Generation with Large Language Models | 2022-12-20T17:42:16 | 2024-03-25T17:54:21 | Evgeniia Razumovskaia, Joshua Maynez, Annie Louis, Mirella Lapata, Shashi Narayan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previous work has demonstrated the effectiveness of planning for story
generation exclusively in a monolingual setting focusing primarily on English.
We consider whether planning brings advantages to automatic story generation
across languages. We propose a new task of cross-lingual story generation with
planning and present a new dataset for this task. We conduct a comprehensive
study of different plans and generate stories in several languages, by
leveraging the creative and reasoning capabilities of large pre-trained
language models. Our results demonstrate that plans which structure stories
into three acts lead to more coherent and interesting narratives, while
allowing to explicitly control their content and structure. | [
-0.3786446154,
-0.5268495083,
0.3646967411,
0.630441606,
-0.0611458607,
0.0111954128,
-0.3460883796,
-1.0795220137,
0.7900128961,
0.3390743136,
-1.0042989254,
-0.0845980719,
-0.3133873045,
0.1565363705,
-0.1210194007,
1.0584131479,
-0.278878659,
-0.0862435848,
0.3065465093,
0.092583105,
-0.5125761032,
-0.4353925884,
-0.5933073759,
-0.2236780524,
1.1558893919,
0.7478432655,
0.9579512477,
0.6332374811,
0.0917187259,
0.1936571896,
0.3834364712,
0.4075224102,
-0.5069541931,
0.2941941619,
-0.4303698838,
-0.4365919828,
-0.089413099,
-0.2903209627,
0.5213579535,
0.6177372336,
-0.0302635133,
0.0907152221,
-0.3445725441,
0.5412439704,
-0.4680456817,
0.0055553978,
-0.6468562484,
0.2538384199,
-0.0933789313,
-0.1043208987,
-0.0952779725,
-0.093993634,
0.1294603348,
-0.5580685735,
0.2108825743,
0.2464520335,
0.6499391794,
-0.2875006497,
-0.4876398444,
-0.4171646833,
-0.9123331308,
0.952008307,
-0.0574807338,
0.0047317287,
0.281165123,
0.4227472842,
0.127015233,
-0.8991762996,
-0.720240891,
-0.0268557314,
-0.4110512435,
-0.1540573537,
-0.6006977558,
-0.6459738016,
-0.0054184776,
-0.1106019914,
-0.811377883,
0.3322924376,
-0.5946510434,
0.0962695628,
1.1799656153,
0.387603879,
0.6945486665,
-0.1206809655,
-0.2071018368,
-0.3553205729,
-0.6410052776,
-0.0950327888,
0.4545098543,
0.6572080851,
-0.2582582533,
0.7929396033,
-0.2117713392,
0.3205832243,
-0.3018020689,
-0.0995847359,
-0.1308003366,
-0.5954034925,
-0.1687005311,
0.3667711318,
0.5861295462,
0.7220211625,
0.6677716374,
-0.3111440241,
-0.1584188491,
0.1260186583,
0.3289231956,
-0.5910099149,
-0.1819364876,
-0.0147360209,
-0.1561385542,
-0.1181505919,
-0.2759123445,
-0.6507580876,
0.0953978673,
-0.5254187584,
0.1969768554,
-0.5372130871,
-0.1474286914,
0.2072086483,
-0.1195515469,
0.1551989913,
0.0973110721,
-1.1952072382,
0.0494817272,
0.6047471166,
0.5504518747,
-0.5314278603,
-0.9896121621,
-0.564173758,
0.5714828372,
-0.6502115726,
0.7342547178,
-0.4230909944,
-0.0995375067,
0.3204174638,
0.3900714219,
0.0571773387,
-0.194250077,
0.1639468074,
-0.431842953,
0.2172352672,
-0.2463817,
0.3761787713,
-0.1751238406,
0.3442786038,
-0.419793129,
0.6043266654,
-0.093447797,
-0.5985467434,
0.8176765442,
-0.3205525279,
-1.3707957268,
-0.2579434216,
-0.1089888737,
-0.1479217559,
0.1463471502,
0.7615250349,
0.3227746189,
0.1011999026,
0.1435619146,
0.2103900313,
-0.101967223,
-0.0518085733,
0.0103976838,
0.954841435,
0.2185798436,
-0.4628046155,
0.0949932486,
-0.6287411451,
0.5135270953,
0.5160861015,
0.1196242645,
-0.3558692038,
-0.2822241485,
0.3064824939,
0.1821240485,
0.0387017839,
-0.4394720793,
0.2978153229,
-0.1457243711,
0.301020205,
0.0419753604,
0.329482913,
0.5517107844,
-0.7378801703,
0.8998321295,
-0.2472150773,
0.1892810613,
-0.4717237055,
-0.4550983906,
-0.7046408057,
0.0802702308,
0.0889955908,
0.3783346415,
-1.0103495121,
-0.046455048,
-0.0658657476,
-0.5807544589,
-0.034408655,
-0.3921582103,
0.1769693941,
-0.2025944144,
0.2284733206,
-0.0246779099,
-0.5910562277,
-0.8865386844,
-0.12703529,
-0.4471713305,
0.1341653913,
-0.2543593049,
0.5523881316,
-0.2133931518,
0.8629921079,
-0.4270012677,
-0.1476717293,
-0.9054887891,
0.3031251132,
-0.2233623862,
0.5106559992,
0.8994166255,
-0.7545514107,
-0.859277904,
0.4111085236,
-0.3672008812,
-0.0973212272,
-0.5419719219,
-0.6273655295,
0.3778516948,
0.1088732481,
-0.7178831697,
0.5145516992,
0.4140338898,
-0.1473184824,
0.671020627,
-0.2972978055,
0.1343426406,
-0.6222047806,
-0.2589595616,
-0.2383407354,
-0.2678374052,
-0.7162868381,
0.2165387869,
-0.1367926151,
-0.2684054077,
-0.4684935808,
0.7662641406,
-0.5963098407,
-0.2776520252,
-0.1799204201,
0.1489178389,
-0.0450668372,
0.5689396262,
0.4817598164,
0.4986540377,
0.3893985748,
-0.6377876401,
0.1347717047,
0.4206596911,
-0.1403104663,
0.5213882327,
-0.2441050857,
-0.2086769193,
0.0109026795,
-0.0147887543,
-0.5893371105,
-0.3984671235,
0.0871812329,
-0.2916652858,
0.4373802543,
0.0271463543,
-0.7278881073,
-0.4197718501,
0.0241450705,
0.0285372566,
0.3345419466,
-0.840636909,
0.2311262935,
0.6973343492,
-0.7048361301,
-0.1733518541,
-1.2386946678,
0.2154715359,
-0.4803308845,
-0.9175783992,
0.4059634209,
0.0669332966,
-0.5171380639,
-0.1488022804,
0.1294649243,
-0.1118184105,
-0.6225448251,
-0.2941348851,
-0.0367089063,
-0.3257153928,
0.1076414511,
0.4023043811,
0.1123826727,
-0.1010210812,
-0.228957355,
0.4507378936,
0.3677231669,
-0.1364056319,
-0.0020886792,
0.9223960638,
0.4617900252,
-0.3948056996,
0.3651943505,
0.4682740569,
-0.0442899019,
-0.8123918772,
0.0498145297,
0.1466733962,
-0.3927996457,
0.2288619429,
-0.1431172788,
-0.5413866639,
0.2418447137,
0.4220964611,
0.4777050018,
0.3632966578,
0.6017444134,
-0.1073427051,
0.9731982946,
1.2021135092,
0.2644420564,
0.2989984155,
0.1278332472,
0.2447429001,
0.0485426411,
-0.0076928874,
-0.3525850475,
-0.8152707815,
-0.5679371953,
-0.5681867003,
0.323371768,
0.025186222,
-0.285099417,
0.3234247565,
-0.3813348413,
0.7705361843,
0.4355016947,
-0.4088270366,
0.79067415,
0.4883621335,
-0.1744579226,
-0.2178808153,
-1.0156843662,
-0.6579292417,
0.8009617329,
0.2720534801,
0.8139036298,
0.0128835263,
0.6545056701,
-0.3052262068,
0.2398551702,
-0.501763165,
0.5475962758,
-0.17014651,
-0.725643754,
-0.7869596481,
-0.0734957457,
-0.8250057101,
0.4170596302,
-0.2682063282,
-0.7389290333,
0.3338266313,
-0.135210827,
-0.422530055,
0.2461150885,
-0.7848158479,
0.5753296018,
-0.7707893252,
-0.2484275997,
-0.2095405608,
-0.7198519111,
0.5523543954,
-0.2324202955,
-0.0558874533,
0.2249736637,
0.0178036131,
0.5641627312,
-0.2679631114,
0.7280601263,
0.1937030107,
-0.1286848783,
0.6042150259,
0.3506039083,
0.6858136654,
0.207795918,
0.098601535,
0.1746433973,
-0.1375929117,
-0.2668290734,
-0.2295012623,
0.6572030783,
-0.3485586047,
-0.2964078784,
-0.3559885621,
-0.9059351087,
-0.3993292749,
0.2516961694,
0.4215178192,
0.0073175947,
-0.2885822356,
-0.2743630409,
0.0306701455,
-0.4952787459,
0.8387337327,
0.6100242138,
-0.833837986,
-0.3506646752,
0.7184751034,
0.2122412473,
0.4616890848,
0.1650344729,
-0.1011370569,
-0.0105805332,
-0.4146345854,
-0.7913030386,
0.5200701952,
-0.4111332893,
0.1768725216,
-0.825824976,
-0.0597238615,
0.0055972789,
-0.4493918121,
-0.28392151,
-0.7023634315,
0.3043773472,
-0.2917344272,
0.1873225272,
0.9506492615,
-0.5243584514,
0.5367646217,
-0.5970612764,
0.2525140643,
0.4628146589,
-0.2367803454,
0.0190059952,
0.0849244744,
-0.5478033423,
-0.061807733,
-0.5261001587,
-0.3129611313,
0.8246269226,
-0.0970402285,
0.2885484695,
0.1457905173,
0.3116083741,
1.074015975,
-1.0324097872,
0.7241547108,
0.5461270213,
-0.2553689182,
0.5749493837,
-0.460144788,
0.337944001,
0.3551023304,
0.6048880219,
-0.5363726616,
-0.5635872483,
-0.7262566686,
-0.6021079421,
0.9134985805,
0.4890727997,
0.3263441622,
-0.1301417053,
-0.3164871931,
0.5124314427,
0.3326127231,
-1.058789134,
-0.1058665588,
0.1073515937,
0.4090625644,
-0.3240196109,
0.0216467697,
-0.3763265014,
-0.2944401503,
0.5652829409,
-0.015338094,
0.2697368264,
0.0731103569,
0.0392168537,
-0.8065395951,
0.2055345476,
0.4786597788,
1.0444483757,
0.4099528491,
-0.0626337007,
0.1943267286,
-0.3410200179,
-0.1367238313,
0.0657989159,
-0.2472778559,
0.3135673106,
0.8363052011,
0.7604788542,
0.1538904607,
-0.7277150154,
0.2800957859,
-0.1732358932,
-0.3329301476,
-0.5018653274,
0.094081156,
-0.077601321,
0.6315584779,
0.2855227292,
-0.1842648387,
-0.5469795465,
-1.0767965317,
0.2539514303,
0.2870018184,
-0.1596717983,
-0.2758861482,
0.4678077996,
0.0230709463,
-0.2725175321,
0.3493736684,
-0.4789065421,
-0.5027447939,
0.6603624225,
1.0188382864,
0.6927558184,
0.0000570337,
0.6273739934,
0.4433173835,
0.7978129387,
0.0243091006,
0.3737373054,
0.1214739904,
-0.4942529202,
-0.557728827,
-0.6582598686,
-0.2178725749,
0.0935456976,
-0.2584758401,
0.5117955804,
0.0652487278,
0.3662664294,
-0.2640283108,
-0.0679690391,
-0.4529859722,
0.2786888778,
0.3704425991,
0.8305754662,
-0.8175549507,
0.7402063012,
0.780880034,
-0.2734114826,
-0.8726407886,
0.5629143119,
-0.3072994351,
-0.6416908503,
1.0081858635,
0.1584672928,
-0.0427918062,
-0.2090694904,
-0.2600157559,
-0.7427539825,
0.9125549793,
0.1624814868,
-0.8209301233,
-0.5530166626,
0.3945685029,
0.4648863375,
-0.9558293223,
-0.3470334113,
0.7291792631,
0.6413852572,
0.4179547727,
-0.9576398134,
-0.4928557277,
0.127062276,
-0.1490169615,
0.1169936806,
-0.3830365837,
0.8637438416,
-0.7045038939,
-0.6770811081,
0.1761144102,
0.6893129945,
0.3852826655,
0.4887527823,
0.5182426572,
0.2797459662,
0.7040939927,
0.0269012526,
1.321359396,
-0.0958515704,
-0.2394300848,
1.1719315052,
-0.3176672757,
0.7020795941,
0.2408862859,
-0.0821597129,
0.3871688247,
0.6689710021,
0.341461122,
0.6382545233,
0.1530305296,
0.0110309385,
-0.286890924,
0.0319316983,
-0.450874716,
0.370277375,
-0.085198313,
-0.1224535182,
-0.2906972766,
0.3912870288,
0.001345932,
0.1801048219,
-0.6528576612,
0.3110482991,
0.113334924,
-0.9586320519,
0.386041522,
-0.0981010944,
0.4120651484,
-0.7161710262,
0.2087094039,
-0.1904482245,
-0.0669487715,
-0.0599642806,
-0.7201566696,
0.5886504054,
0.3909810185,
-0.2597362697,
-0.6159577966,
0.4807144403,
-0.7852463722,
-0.8968333006,
0.3531496823,
0.6585652232,
-0.0026311921,
0.2189333588,
-0.3585368693,
-0.0372656509,
0.1009882838,
-0.1793777943,
0.4162842035,
0.9901995659,
-0.3562635481,
0.3960538208,
0.4751733243,
0.398142308,
0.2087388784,
-0.0415313542,
0.5627936721,
-0.8007363081,
-1.4432307482,
-0.4110023081,
0.7475659251,
-0.0825243294,
-0.3036500216,
0.5058728456,
0.5017948747,
1.1730812788,
-0.20317249,
0.7239832282,
-0.2026821971,
0.5158058405,
-0.5905845761,
0.708239913,
-0.8011266589,
0.1389832646,
-0.1872114241,
-0.9922898412,
-0.3818586171,
0.5497848988,
-0.431709528,
-0.0768176913,
1.1694074869,
0.5932077169,
-0.2500769794,
0.2236489505,
0.2695150673,
-0.0121636521,
0.1523914933,
0.3606714606,
1.145950675,
0.0942024663,
0.5286224484,
-0.2578144372,
-0.1369008422,
0.1984551102,
-0.8621218204,
-0.9911468029,
-0.4712896943,
-0.164531365,
0.2351789623,
-0.1020182967,
0.6254386902,
0.8506509066,
-0.4909227192,
-0.4620698392,
0.0727447569,
0.0796441063,
-0.2555690706,
-0.1611155272,
-0.0825772136,
-0.6518881917,
-0.9661034942,
0.7114547491,
0.1710022539,
-0.0228616074,
-0.4896293581,
-0.0944842324,
-0.2013904303,
-0.019826429,
0.823996067,
0.4335679412,
-0.3299924433,
-0.231542781,
-0.4760950804,
-0.1471391618,
-0.2038628608,
1.0178916454,
-0.4348590672,
0.096346356,
0.0511442013,
0.3617019355,
0.9141070247,
-0.2649968863,
0.9699053168,
-0.9628071785,
0.2851338983,
0.3708294034,
0.1125805452,
-0.0272995103,
-0.420386821,
0.7623133063,
-0.2457628101,
-0.6547454596,
-0.7605084181,
0.4372521341,
-0.7517049313,
-0.595921874,
1.2239836454,
0.2983626127,
-0.2345107496,
0.0737638548,
-0.3231011927,
-0.0797495097,
0.0687307641,
0.2988328338,
0.5983675718,
-0.6244331598,
0.0250411034,
-0.8368378878,
0.26183483,
-0.1208011359,
-0.7830953002,
0.446313262,
0.5114962459,
0.010482748,
0.4531549811,
0.6847294569,
-0.1007215679,
0.1236035526,
0.0067687887,
0.0730319545,
0.058277525,
-0.9293805361,
0.0915508419,
0.2752321064,
-0.3764750361,
0.2020346373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10469v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10469v2 | BMX: Boosting Natural Language Generation Metrics with Explainability | 2022-12-20T17:41:18 | 2024-02-17T16:55:27 | Christoph Leiter, Hoa Nguyen, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art natural language generation evaluation metrics are based on
black-box language models. Hence, recent works consider their explainability
with the goals of better understandability for humans and better metric
analysis, including failure cases. In contrast, our proposed method BMX:
Boosting Natural Language Generation Metrics with explainability explicitly
leverages explanations to boost the metrics' performance. In particular, we
perceive feature importance explanations as word-level scores, which we
convert, via power means, into a segment-level score. We then combine this
segment-level score with the original metric to obtain a better metric. Our
tests show improvements for multiple metrics across MT and summarization
datasets. While improvements in machine translation are small, they are strong
for summarization. Notably, BMX with the LIME explainer and preselected
parameters achieves an average improvement of 0.087 points in Spearman
correlation on the system-level evaluation of SummEval. | [
-0.6574046016,
-0.6049512029,
0.3682642579,
0.4667343497,
-0.4858006537,
0.2781969905,
-0.3817302287,
-0.3204826713,
0.110309802,
0.3135167062,
-0.3490113318,
-0.4341941774,
-0.5188282728,
0.2218651474,
-0.3301489949,
1.2696597576,
0.0081148185,
-0.2222975641,
-0.32723248,
-0.0608261749,
-0.7507817745,
-0.121269092,
-0.6501194835,
-0.4278196692,
0.4720805585,
0.4333155155,
0.9291299582,
0.7860990167,
0.3820239604,
0.3057134151,
-0.2749575973,
0.3501868546,
-0.5692113638,
0.1270858645,
-0.2661140263,
-0.3638004661,
-0.6707199216,
-0.3251779377,
0.5956253409,
1.05930686,
0.028869316,
0.3653165102,
-0.0249757022,
0.7983208299,
-0.6962999701,
0.0092351856,
-0.6351164579,
-0.054298088,
0.0765668973,
-0.5874298215,
-0.3219026625,
-0.4946222901,
0.1738990396,
-0.5365616083,
0.5881085992,
0.3446105421,
0.859398365,
0.2081642747,
-0.1753451377,
-0.2972496748,
-0.7490301132,
0.8290022612,
-0.813387692,
0.2437722981,
0.0163640808,
0.4942856133,
-0.0271897539,
-0.5515182614,
-0.5810495019,
0.1133900285,
-0.1426360607,
0.321380645,
-0.4626384079,
0.0271252729,
0.2989594042,
0.7086244822,
-0.6052217484,
0.0435731299,
-0.3856833577,
-0.3041472435,
0.7209131718,
0.3456348181,
0.3174893558,
-0.3139180243,
-0.4074654281,
0.1250213832,
-0.6449379921,
0.1777176112,
0.2627612054,
0.2370468229,
-0.0588158295,
0.4870097041,
-0.2346617579,
0.6660354137,
-0.2348193973,
-0.076368019,
0.2119769305,
-0.8562791944,
-0.3441582024,
0.317337662,
0.6946724057,
0.6621366739,
0.2256049514,
-0.4407767355,
-0.0021417986,
-0.1245336905,
0.2221225947,
-1.0727131367,
0.0164326206,
0.3798723221,
-0.5458407998,
-0.1351878047,
0.0499695726,
-0.855681181,
-0.2783965766,
-0.4022411704,
0.4493946135,
-0.5073333383,
-0.4986433685,
0.1277836412,
-0.7193976045,
0.2703675926,
0.315984726,
-0.9908536077,
-0.00126624,
0.6783481836,
1.0382269621,
-0.2303114533,
-0.1499785483,
-0.4468872249,
0.2393312305,
-0.6372514963,
0.6878294945,
-0.099998489,
-0.4040235579,
-0.1304211169,
-0.2610200942,
-0.0004189311,
-0.7252153754,
0.2006153017,
-0.072617583,
0.2612299621,
-0.2003786713,
-0.3411048949,
-0.3487683535,
0.1062040925,
-0.157425046,
0.9956367612,
0.0823672414,
-0.692609787,
0.8298710585,
-0.8817224503,
-0.6601166725,
0.184323892,
0.4623518586,
-0.4201736748,
0.5520277619,
0.3452808857,
0.4311941266,
-0.3234523535,
0.4526645541,
-0.0794008076,
-0.3256005049,
0.3620364964,
-0.4443309307,
0.7973413467,
0.1568175256,
-0.3586988449,
0.2369572222,
-1.0735949278,
0.0033598847,
-0.1059326306,
-0.2847425342,
-0.2153842896,
-0.1528862268,
-0.3045327067,
0.0548693575,
0.1704322994,
-0.3685656488,
-0.4172691107,
-0.7795469761,
0.3779428303,
0.2701591551,
0.3668560982,
0.4071260095,
-0.1538522989,
0.6998397708,
0.0215818807,
-0.0202963557,
-0.5245884657,
-0.5170265436,
-0.8019505739,
-0.2327327579,
0.2203877121,
0.302049309,
-0.5778241158,
0.5872972012,
-0.457246989,
-0.5813325644,
-0.7419843078,
0.3133829832,
0.6846393347,
0.7395106554,
0.4281468093,
-0.3116576672,
-0.5474030375,
-0.9755709171,
-0.2623263299,
-0.1540384591,
-0.2557303905,
-0.077451542,
0.2132759988,
0.0561318956,
1.1987068653,
-0.4056947827,
0.3569779694,
-0.854352951,
0.2593972087,
0.2934970558,
0.2145794779,
0.5768277049,
-0.5398855805,
-0.1875274926,
0.0265389457,
-0.5079066753,
-0.372387588,
0.0843086913,
-0.3872033358,
0.0228921175,
0.271825999,
-0.5398374796,
0.4055985212,
0.1935009211,
-0.3397805393,
0.5082992315,
-0.4639882743,
-0.1141641513,
-1.1382966042,
0.0046677873,
-0.1448236257,
-0.3477465808,
-0.7346335053,
-0.2509670556,
-0.1588944793,
-0.2890160084,
-0.3361811936,
0.3691382408,
-0.3199991584,
-0.3975945413,
-0.345729351,
0.6555569768,
0.4126066864,
0.3064041436,
-0.4624329209,
0.6311281323,
0.5091062188,
-0.9561654925,
0.2012946904,
0.2275186777,
-0.1945625842,
0.5853216052,
-0.7572385669,
-0.1068472713,
-0.4017181993,
-0.0297285691,
-1.2976796627,
-0.1355609596,
-0.2346821427,
-0.9071053863,
0.3697837591,
-0.0234604497,
-0.3946281075,
-0.2124457657,
-0.2838717699,
-0.2372563034,
0.3966658413,
-0.6341710687,
0.1446669251,
0.2578128576,
-0.1327565163,
-0.2589431405,
-0.7656496763,
0.2726479173,
-0.4798452556,
-0.6587353349,
0.2662248313,
-0.1667960733,
-0.3080420792,
-0.0870576501,
0.0209498089,
0.3611466289,
0.5830193162,
0.2166458219,
0.0498267114,
-0.4885833263,
0.2446907014,
0.2743698061,
-0.4543074071,
0.2863126695,
-0.1482287347,
0.4529923201,
0.0944189429,
0.3275979161,
-0.2254791856,
0.186715126,
0.3397340178,
-0.4150428474,
0.8323826194,
0.8041388988,
-0.1259605587,
-0.3481181562,
0.0677573979,
0.0923346207,
-0.3880058527,
0.332853049,
-0.0881555006,
-0.6300535202,
0.2606727779,
0.0611406453,
0.2678234875,
0.6169307232,
0.8812638521,
0.1103411168,
1.3872518539,
0.403309226,
0.2138350308,
0.316231221,
-0.2707040906,
0.4651875198,
-0.720554471,
-0.0666794851,
-0.5481857657,
-0.4109112918,
-0.6349076629,
-0.1577150375,
0.1781266779,
0.3648806214,
0.0383874625,
0.2591461837,
-0.3755322993,
0.368848592,
0.3771998584,
-0.4131835997,
0.3505567312,
-0.0035892883,
-0.038595818,
0.0381384455,
-0.7681966424,
-0.5448995233,
0.9244314432,
0.4163728356,
0.1824254692,
0.4609725475,
0.6487132311,
0.0015196305,
0.4773980081,
-0.6930059791,
0.3698020279,
-0.0466433242,
-0.6975618005,
-0.4439574182,
-0.6316704154,
-0.9872888923,
0.4394820333,
-0.4693953097,
-0.726495266,
-0.1839174479,
0.4810529053,
-0.3098143935,
-0.0654528141,
-0.9643955231,
0.863599658,
-0.1590668261,
-0.2213572562,
-0.2355515808,
-0.5697240233,
0.566601038,
0.192423299,
0.4220460951,
-0.2881902456,
-0.001200365,
0.6320257783,
-0.5853803158,
0.2259192467,
-0.366278857,
0.1227617711,
0.0801584348,
0.0060207658,
-0.0707416907,
0.0924247801,
-0.106447719,
0.0334706828,
-0.3970968723,
-0.3984133005,
-1.112655282,
0.4586725235,
-0.3220197856,
-0.5192645192,
0.3181377351,
-0.6636745334,
-0.3298432529,
0.0681599528,
0.4323209822,
0.8501955271,
0.1305275857,
0.4137527645,
0.420219183,
-0.4422646761,
0.6816467643,
0.3502441347,
-0.3818950653,
-0.6595003605,
1.2970184088,
-0.0130222877,
0.4192643464,
0.4873120785,
0.5692535043,
-0.2858389318,
-0.9678925276,
-0.8981303573,
0.0227706265,
-0.3836973608,
-0.2537847757,
-0.5994308591,
-0.1063905358,
-0.2990228534,
-0.1952871829,
-0.1118351966,
-0.771540463,
0.1211391389,
-0.573215723,
0.2182702571,
0.7130189538,
0.0620287955,
0.5607843995,
-0.5414025784,
0.3002204597,
0.1664060801,
0.3349830806,
0.3136596084,
-0.5061415434,
-0.6689875722,
-0.1697145402,
-0.4765537083,
-0.893740952,
0.4457445741,
0.1351825297,
0.5236065984,
0.5152462125,
-0.1310534328,
0.869097054,
-0.1413258612,
0.9542200565,
0.3072103262,
-1.1493692398,
0.8510220647,
-0.1040838733,
0.3809123635,
0.4582816064,
-0.0254798643,
-0.1262446642,
-0.9396716952,
-0.7735231519,
-1.1675469875,
0.5741932988,
0.5560078025,
0.1266718656,
0.0611022748,
0.1405919194,
0.2498872429,
0.4355896413,
-0.4243637323,
-0.4175639451,
-0.3632383943,
-0.2669477165,
-0.4937779307,
-0.1858746856,
0.0642112195,
-0.0785033554,
0.6793156862,
-0.0380037911,
0.0338985845,
0.2120979726,
-0.3840527534,
-0.1252681017,
0.4542293549,
0.772292614,
1.244586587,
-0.3578763604,
0.3331012428,
0.2262534201,
-0.3155792058,
-0.1360248029,
0.1383143961,
-0.2635259926,
0.3982521892,
0.6427730322,
1.1672980785,
0.4139169455,
-0.5070726275,
0.2766817808,
0.0050352146,
-0.1649021953,
0.1862807572,
0.4025348723,
0.0745695084,
-0.1340321898,
0.3860782981,
-0.1803743243,
0.2521556914,
-0.5177376866,
-0.1109713539,
0.351926893,
-0.5474001169,
-0.3730341494,
0.5974773169,
0.242205143,
-0.3667663038,
-0.068982631,
-0.4810808599,
-0.3395622075,
0.7256883979,
0.7846935391,
0.724660635,
0.015636839,
0.3562554419,
0.5649035573,
0.442160815,
0.3902404308,
0.051379133,
-0.3198487461,
-0.6718382835,
-0.5284112096,
-0.7379372716,
-0.632240057,
-0.0238539707,
-0.6126297712,
0.1142189652,
-0.348393321,
-0.0164022818,
0.466598779,
0.1210244372,
-0.4181145132,
0.2657618821,
-0.1814026088,
0.8077892065,
-0.6583200097,
0.0476278402,
0.5933942199,
-0.570053041,
-0.7674972415,
-0.0145347919,
-0.2627307773,
-0.5783560872,
0.3009315133,
0.3504158258,
-0.0098410808,
0.0713509843,
-0.3306056559,
-0.5911971927,
1.2624756098,
0.5170974135,
-0.1306658536,
0.3078442812,
-0.0374377556,
0.7957453728,
-0.4063479602,
0.4166149497,
0.7523314357,
0.5178375244,
0.0417175815,
-0.6819916368,
0.0441242829,
-0.0141158672,
0.1534180045,
0.5503814816,
-0.3414566815,
0.2959710062,
-0.3534810543,
-0.2878078222,
-0.3644257188,
0.6960966587,
0.4204179049,
0.9951103926,
0.5372745395,
0.4792941511,
0.817166388,
-0.0835078508,
1.20342803,
-0.2665542364,
0.1580234617,
0.7060171366,
0.3531251252,
0.6136236787,
0.153854236,
-0.2261310071,
0.679200232,
0.4457158744,
0.1992305219,
0.0630893409,
0.34736678,
0.1284452379,
-0.1403898299,
-0.1185013652,
-0.1479246765,
0.5046311617,
0.4055639505,
-0.4724667072,
-0.3624183834,
-0.0639567748,
0.2622248828,
0.0527678095,
-0.5744154453,
0.867477417,
0.0335651822,
-0.8536407948,
0.5393638015,
-0.1482656598,
0.2438783497,
-0.4268397391,
0.0379443988,
-0.4965264201,
-0.0228655934,
-0.418459177,
-0.758063674,
0.4711034,
0.2407998294,
-0.4747782052,
-0.363699764,
0.5672156215,
-0.4333616197,
-0.4235157669,
0.1920010298,
0.4243645668,
0.3690343499,
0.247250542,
-0.3646590412,
-0.3676348329,
-0.0232049525,
0.0655035898,
0.1545431316,
0.7389189005,
0.1345138848,
0.6407420039,
0.802120626,
0.4014818072,
0.1002660468,
0.2818666995,
0.5104132295,
-0.7911939621,
-0.5506168008,
-0.9666756392,
0.6765078902,
-0.37876302,
-0.5434316397,
0.8234238029,
0.8841056824,
0.3399702013,
0.1693921983,
0.6811231375,
0.1902135462,
0.7748368979,
-0.7354941368,
0.6726736426,
-0.4933792353,
0.2693626583,
-0.2705675066,
-1.0372960567,
-0.2594456375,
0.0473161563,
-0.0581133813,
-0.1345855147,
0.5887157917,
0.6340540051,
0.0128448792,
-0.0106684631,
0.3766338527,
0.3414626718,
0.3330279887,
0.2882617712,
0.5773666501,
-0.0200600084,
0.8991953731,
-0.0556461364,
-0.3147489727,
-0.1546007395,
-0.9048426747,
-0.8475505114,
-0.2254384458,
-0.3798276782,
-0.3035793006,
-0.2044323683,
0.5892067552,
0.6614130735,
-0.750104785,
-0.0341185033,
-0.1119293794,
0.6559925079,
-0.2444546372,
-0.339533031,
0.147337243,
-0.6644673347,
-0.5606749654,
0.4124025404,
0.7732628584,
-0.1422528028,
-0.4744349122,
-0.1340132654,
0.3409427404,
0.1168251932,
0.7407524586,
0.0392720923,
-0.449876219,
-0.2948051393,
-0.3283044398,
0.2787319422,
0.0266260318,
0.9428584576,
-0.6972178221,
0.7563185692,
0.5768443942,
0.5164172053,
0.401740998,
0.19013457,
1.0208754539,
-0.9245136976,
0.0094762137,
-0.2937001586,
0.2596133947,
0.7337101698,
-0.1280039251,
0.4491511881,
0.1661245525,
-0.3735478222,
-0.871026814,
0.1480859816,
-0.9581385851,
0.0620022714,
0.9300270677,
-0.0585054234,
-0.2374714613,
-0.3698001504,
-0.1752546877,
0.3636394441,
-0.2769987881,
0.6282805204,
0.5765524507,
-0.176363647,
-0.2471957207,
-0.7181941867,
0.62343961,
0.2299250811,
-0.9022890925,
0.1775450855,
0.2562185824,
0.1654255539,
0.441365689,
0.2876056135,
-0.1646506637,
0.2795061171,
-0.1544801444,
-0.11117322,
-0.2331869602,
-0.056453675,
-0.3703589439,
0.1324635595,
0.0730417371,
-0.3143371642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10467v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10467v2 | Generic Temporal Reasoning with Differential Analysis and Explanation | 2022-12-20T17:40:03 | 2023-05-31T17:54:08 | Yu Feng, Ben Zhou, Haoyu Wang, Helen Jin, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL | Temporal reasoning is the task of predicting temporal relations of event
pairs. While temporal reasoning models can perform reasonably well on in-domain
benchmarks, we have little idea of these systems' generalizability due to
existing datasets' limitations. In this work, we introduce a novel task named
TODAY that bridges this gap with temporal differential analysis, which as the
name suggests, evaluates whether systems can correctly understand the effect of
incremental changes. Specifically, TODAY introduces slight contextual changes
for given event pairs, and systems are asked to tell how this subtle contextual
change would affect relevant temporal relation distributions. To facilitate
learning, TODAY also annotates human explanations. We show that existing
models, including GPT-3.5, drop to random guessing on TODAY, suggesting that
they heavily rely on spurious information rather than proper reasoning for
temporal predictions. On the other hand, we show that TODAY's supervision style
and explanation annotations can be used in joint learning, encouraging models
to use more appropriate signals during training and thus outperform across
several benchmarks. TODAY can also be used to train models to solicit
incidental supervision from noisy sources such as GPT-3.5, thus moving us more
toward the goal of generic temporal reasoning systems. | [
-0.2694874108,
-0.6691722274,
0.9351006746,
0.3238635361,
-0.1259642988,
-0.2519831359,
0.0444936045,
-0.8919286728,
0.0634793416,
-0.0061651054,
-1.0296456814,
-0.5521848202,
-0.5140578151,
0.0957284197,
-0.3881577253,
0.8282184005,
-0.3104845285,
0.1064778939,
-0.1630858183,
-0.1447352171,
-0.5240112543,
-0.7032826543,
-0.8954532146,
-0.520355463,
0.6501805186,
0.126811713,
0.4709758759,
0.514098525,
0.3551877737,
0.1975549459,
-0.2170806229,
-0.09049391,
-0.0686972514,
0.1633188874,
-0.162966162,
-0.4252880216,
-0.769469738,
0.0110278362,
0.6551601887,
1.1870126724,
0.0968434811,
0.1670991033,
-0.145250082,
0.3870043159,
-0.6400506496,
0.2459928989,
-0.413428396,
0.2446981966,
-0.236494422,
-0.2787474394,
-0.2672346234,
-0.4598602057,
0.3170197904,
-0.7381863594,
0.4067124128,
-0.4500586092,
0.6833421588,
0.2287112474,
-0.4887768626,
-0.0047734724,
-0.9453359246,
0.8097062707,
-0.3708911836,
0.3632643223,
0.1992501616,
0.7300515175,
0.0039280076,
-0.8394843936,
-0.3563738465,
-0.5208753943,
0.0878518373,
0.140925169,
0.2466282099,
-0.143757239,
0.5145760179,
-0.0631999373,
-0.1877624393,
-0.0539926626,
0.0561224185,
0.0835900158,
0.3987077475,
0.3517839909,
0.1628212929,
0.1877254397,
-0.4590676129,
0.3475467563,
-0.6601899862,
0.1451370567,
0.3074249625,
-0.1203819364,
-0.1588011831,
0.0663196743,
-0.2487110049,
0.597111702,
0.0937111527,
0.1050866321,
-0.1547913998,
-0.0724495724,
-0.2493205816,
-0.0838465989,
0.1353587955,
0.4387173057,
0.301532656,
-0.4642441273,
-0.0487484075,
0.2229371816,
0.029825218,
-0.2666951418,
-0.1305075437,
0.1936195344,
-0.3500374258,
-0.3198631406,
-0.1454152763,
-0.8740231395,
-0.2362749428,
-0.9098564982,
0.412733078,
-0.3637075424,
-0.443762064,
0.0092892367,
-0.5785188079,
-0.0617215,
0.832611382,
-0.8964998722,
0.3306868672,
0.6957576275,
0.6869415045,
-0.0145466467,
-0.2749427259,
-0.5594640374,
0.5479841828,
-0.2098749131,
0.8307024837,
-0.7567634583,
-0.4174226522,
-0.1003999636,
0.0695162192,
-0.2841383219,
-0.3615709841,
0.4383087158,
-0.5272464752,
0.1546185315,
-0.4092430174,
-0.3680755794,
-0.0197260771,
0.2745491862,
-0.3107829392,
0.7339393497,
0.167949602,
-0.7889912128,
0.8248159885,
-0.878308773,
-0.2335052788,
-0.0416226238,
-0.1193715781,
-0.2192392796,
-0.0990237072,
0.3496810198,
0.3182121515,
0.0940491408,
0.6518287659,
-0.6883180141,
-0.4333223104,
0.0197993256,
-0.2662326694,
0.7461386919,
0.178903386,
-0.5365695953,
0.033568833,
-0.6568046808,
-0.2392000258,
0.048781734,
0.085543558,
-0.3614042699,
0.2967954576,
-0.1802213341,
-0.1303083748,
0.2195560485,
-0.3289835155,
0.4187178016,
0.0130891604,
0.4647963047,
0.9640110731,
0.1862922758,
0.5381795764,
-0.2667507827,
0.3750942647,
0.105770126,
0.7685807347,
-0.0786497518,
-0.482835114,
-0.5152338147,
0.177142784,
0.0907021016,
0.3326461911,
-0.6441774368,
-0.2007882595,
-0.5163078904,
-0.1305109411,
0.3645820022,
-0.2723920345,
0.2502312064,
0.5695568919,
0.5182219744,
-0.1464301944,
-0.705257237,
-0.5383973718,
-0.4693054557,
-0.1497092545,
-0.1549724191,
0.1000689045,
0.3907050788,
-0.2999854684,
0.9644781351,
-0.1471341997,
0.0247751772,
-0.1463664025,
0.4724751115,
0.0053230533,
0.5150276423,
0.5071949363,
-0.6815311909,
-0.0253505949,
-0.194915399,
-1.0369547606,
-0.2062415183,
-0.3632032275,
-0.0013052135,
0.1503891051,
0.7300843,
-0.2436430007,
0.3174037933,
0.2108120173,
-0.3580556214,
0.9003296494,
-0.0450747162,
0.0151600493,
-0.607223928,
-0.1486928761,
0.1049229354,
-0.0954913199,
-0.4130464792,
-0.2010891587,
0.0279646274,
0.0728299022,
-0.2349139452,
0.861599803,
-0.3910191953,
-0.0506011285,
0.0709858835,
0.0591466315,
-0.248204425,
0.2333227992,
0.1418312043,
0.2061856985,
0.5297740102,
-0.9024693966,
0.146280244,
-0.0323899053,
0.1298786551,
0.5957347751,
-0.4292837679,
-0.0318481512,
-0.2263556421,
0.3868612945,
-0.5167198181,
-0.4694777727,
0.1786724329,
-0.3903612494,
0.4184250832,
-0.6250915527,
-0.3466278911,
-0.2626404166,
0.0671877265,
0.3980441988,
0.2542732656,
-0.9029482007,
0.7070747614,
0.0863192901,
0.0944642872,
-0.5090270042,
-0.468996942,
0.0074483342,
-0.4290625155,
-0.7187145948,
0.4470089078,
0.1531917453,
-0.9037490487,
0.1398306489,
-0.601520896,
-0.3131258488,
0.0966894403,
0.3458907008,
0.4191492498,
-0.1462517083,
0.4485779405,
0.1898876578,
-0.3673447669,
0.2419151068,
-0.398735404,
0.2656371593,
0.0726225153,
-0.5386803746,
-0.5374263525,
0.3325781822,
0.3146619201,
0.1976378262,
0.6670161486,
0.6623632908,
-0.2775268853,
-0.1730592549,
-0.5815300941,
-0.28784886,
-0.384341985,
-0.0314800851,
-0.7117521167,
-0.669711113,
0.4038777947,
-0.2120337486,
-0.0777031034,
0.7361195087,
0.2444038987,
-0.1062308848,
1.0647814274,
0.441945672,
-0.0723723173,
0.7178367972,
-0.1103987247,
-0.0747197121,
-0.5684806705,
-0.3941127658,
-0.1937739551,
-0.2885763347,
-0.476177007,
0.0523299538,
0.3333388865,
0.1911038905,
-0.371132493,
0.1219248921,
-0.4683490992,
0.3080562055,
0.6003477573,
-0.0269899871,
0.451083988,
-0.5033363104,
-0.0341733731,
0.0732380897,
-0.2509788573,
-0.5171701312,
1.0289552212,
0.3184739351,
0.6620255113,
-0.1600971371,
0.7786915898,
0.2941952348,
0.4892124832,
-0.250767231,
0.5804662108,
0.1231981143,
-0.6064022779,
-0.0291629843,
-0.4957986772,
-0.8440638185,
-0.0250807349,
0.129607439,
-0.8696449399,
0.3924644589,
0.0781997666,
-0.1463874429,
0.38847664,
-1.0819159746,
0.7729162574,
-0.0474403426,
-0.2568724751,
-0.1537385881,
-0.6112054586,
0.5507199764,
0.3539412618,
0.2200981826,
-0.3509529829,
-0.093392849,
0.6801443696,
-0.0768612474,
1.0268929005,
-0.6946032643,
0.1385346651,
0.0783024132,
0.1810843945,
0.4611376524,
0.5310435295,
0.0756189376,
0.2222431302,
0.571814537,
-0.4548138976,
-0.7235056758,
0.7479910851,
-0.495444864,
-0.6624808908,
-0.3604224026,
-0.5923522115,
-0.2934319675,
-0.3518689275,
0.1883238852,
0.7549425364,
-0.0097269807,
-0.3197266459,
0.3529224396,
0.2345706671,
0.5807115436,
0.586458087,
-0.031594798,
0.1678569913,
0.3655585051,
0.0201335568,
0.1719590724,
0.573975563,
-0.0320372544,
-0.3058238328,
-0.5685597062,
-0.0982677191,
0.1086920947,
-0.8204034567,
0.235000357,
-0.7339559793,
0.0947984681,
-0.4578416049,
-0.1696926802,
0.0630742311,
-0.7161201239,
-0.1069277599,
0.0908908024,
0.2028347999,
0.7829170227,
-0.237021029,
0.0409080237,
-0.7760109901,
0.3431141973,
0.5017331839,
0.3395343721,
-0.2099428922,
-0.3224616051,
0.0406263694,
-0.1378220767,
-0.4770213068,
-0.9236004353,
0.0685140938,
0.1074548811,
0.7253888249,
0.420366317,
-0.1014854237,
0.7363240719,
-0.5320811272,
0.8542280793,
-0.0762644336,
-1.0020573139,
0.8751144409,
-0.5213279724,
0.0691633373,
0.0177144147,
0.4102476239,
-0.4923499525,
-0.4369724989,
-1.0138380527,
-0.5720223784,
0.4855263531,
0.0868220627,
-0.1637546271,
-0.0394800566,
0.7302665114,
0.3379476368,
-0.1945126802,
-0.6823183298,
-0.145660907,
-0.0789365843,
0.1070135161,
-0.0791915357,
-0.2685697079,
-0.2372845411,
-0.3175808191,
0.3194952011,
0.1324517876,
0.609767139,
0.2464188933,
0.0734524578,
-0.172463119,
0.4489277899,
0.553409338,
1.0556856394,
-0.4566385746,
0.1917812377,
0.4448935986,
-0.2571660876,
0.0898761004,
0.355450362,
0.0513997413,
0.2084858865,
0.6699000597,
0.4400599897,
0.3204570115,
-0.3385017514,
0.2165120989,
-0.0759288371,
-0.3606630564,
-0.4934670031,
0.1771482378,
-0.2073164731,
0.635887742,
0.5157539248,
0.3304128945,
0.0067083449,
-0.6458356977,
0.1714739501,
0.2847092152,
-0.3448709548,
-0.7284047008,
0.9129298329,
-0.1366773099,
0.03329961,
0.0616877712,
-0.4061537981,
-0.2766342759,
0.6270127892,
0.2883088589,
0.9425836802,
-0.1553162336,
0.2892813683,
0.4443746805,
-0.0141823003,
-0.1955515444,
0.1089049429,
-0.4563061595,
-0.5337451696,
-0.6231774092,
-0.559710741,
-0.8321083188,
0.0476103202,
-0.6250930429,
0.1260750443,
-0.3625226915,
-0.2187047899,
0.0561450496,
-0.2888811827,
-0.673335433,
0.4971826971,
-0.1328182667,
0.7625388503,
-0.8613529205,
0.944196403,
0.5987499952,
-0.4868979156,
-0.5075678825,
0.3935931921,
0.0200465433,
-0.7250077128,
1.2068663836,
0.0444117561,
0.1244791374,
-0.0924324244,
-0.5540727973,
-0.6511583924,
0.9167196155,
0.4261122942,
-0.322699815,
-0.3011318147,
-0.2196218967,
0.5682752728,
-0.1733051538,
0.2160709053,
0.6652458906,
0.6514244676,
0.1693339646,
-0.7989697456,
-0.0384685211,
-0.1623346508,
-0.2320090979,
0.3747477829,
0.0054977397,
0.9798758626,
-0.2561272979,
-0.3774121106,
-0.0354826227,
0.3386541903,
0.0701246709,
0.8574871421,
0.5130363107,
0.5028308034,
0.4964931309,
-0.5216129422,
1.3780800104,
0.3468374908,
0.0775228664,
1.3262866735,
-0.0024521591,
0.6160133481,
0.4960648417,
-0.4629998207,
0.7456485033,
0.7703009844,
0.259785533,
0.4874775112,
-0.1412801147,
-0.5608325005,
-0.332433939,
0.0514033213,
-0.7581620812,
0.103190273,
0.1577743292,
-0.1487490982,
-0.6410816908,
0.0282408949,
-0.3398290277,
-0.0597173721,
-0.4495441318,
0.6095378995,
0.0070338822,
-0.6758953929,
0.4119878113,
-0.2811804414,
0.279871136,
-0.4896382391,
0.0458483025,
-0.2241925001,
0.4390960336,
-0.1031814888,
-0.6211249828,
0.5932095051,
-0.0881517008,
-0.0696104839,
-0.3423298299,
0.430280447,
0.0091179954,
-0.2851275206,
0.5094851851,
0.4404321313,
-0.1058951989,
-0.3153491318,
-0.4229193628,
-0.1580097973,
-0.3071157038,
0.0365097672,
0.4956527352,
0.6694024205,
-0.312402606,
0.766548872,
0.3450899124,
0.1882267594,
0.1982448846,
0.4314090014,
0.755967319,
-0.8110835552,
-0.3981857896,
-0.8223293424,
0.4566749036,
-0.0438850373,
-0.0854839534,
0.5070595741,
-0.0146093657,
0.7465969324,
-0.0710674971,
0.6393390894,
-0.0107593359,
0.7672287822,
-0.7662502527,
0.1134195626,
-0.6388651729,
0.3959685564,
-0.1067815349,
-0.8273124695,
-0.2968533635,
0.0806777999,
-0.8790261745,
0.1341984123,
0.9824259877,
0.298461169,
-0.1480548829,
0.5939251781,
0.2298248261,
0.0106405104,
0.4972086847,
0.58540833,
1.2053468227,
-0.1050819829,
0.5261138678,
-0.3727676272,
-0.2967832983,
-0.0496252216,
-1.1281750202,
-0.9464524388,
-0.6615558267,
-0.322235167,
-0.0272086821,
0.4659373462,
0.6830222607,
0.641276896,
-0.8426311612,
0.1302786469,
-0.5870916247,
0.0022920487,
-0.5092598796,
-0.2558797896,
0.3378261626,
-0.8992795944,
-0.7811146975,
0.4589725435,
0.1841973662,
0.0502533503,
0.1904344261,
0.1245498806,
0.1610692292,
-0.4690594077,
0.4719889462,
0.2942036092,
-0.8500801325,
-0.5610978007,
-0.3340855539,
0.2864500284,
-0.0339597538,
0.9415083528,
-0.6871927381,
0.552320838,
0.3203503191,
0.2049449533,
0.8210786581,
-0.1029061452,
0.7222386003,
-0.7455638647,
0.2713944316,
0.3202255964,
0.4416078031,
0.0587274358,
-0.3646345139,
0.7241718173,
0.5728157163,
-0.6044655442,
-0.6468348503,
0.3347316384,
-0.9452177882,
-0.1759740561,
0.9610570669,
-0.1358660907,
0.0805395916,
-0.5558292866,
0.029789472,
0.4188968837,
-0.2797709703,
1.1489063501,
0.6446022391,
-0.5043770671,
-0.2895235121,
-0.7273907065,
0.6871466637,
0.1693978012,
-0.9006377459,
-0.1968858391,
0.3461112082,
0.2497858554,
0.1286777407,
0.589917779,
-0.1688608229,
0.533259809,
0.1949725598,
-0.3173552454,
-0.1638951898,
-0.2740235329,
-0.0932709202,
0.0979582146,
-0.2277864367,
-0.3427273631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10466v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10466v1 | Controllable Text Generation with Language Constraints | 2022-12-20T17:39:21 | 2022-12-20T17:39:21 | Howard Chen, Huihan Li, Danqi Chen, Karthik Narasimhan | cs.CL | cs.CL | We consider the task of text generation in language models with constraints
specified in natural language. To this end, we first create a challenging
benchmark Cognac that provides as input to the model a topic with example text,
along with a constraint on text to be avoided. Unlike prior work, our benchmark
contains knowledge-intensive constraints sourced from databases like Wordnet
and Wikidata, which allows for straightforward evaluation while striking a
balance between broad attribute-level and narrow lexical-level controls. We
find that even state-of-the-art language models like GPT-3 fail often on this
task, and propose a solution to leverage a language model's own internal
knowledge to guide generation. Our method, called CognacGen, first queries the
language model to generate guidance terms for a specified topic or constraint,
and uses the guidance to modify the model's token generation probabilities. We
propose three forms of guidance (binary verifier, top-k tokens, textual
example), and employ prefix-tuning approaches to distill the guidance to tackle
diverse natural language constraints. Through extensive empirical evaluations,
we demonstrate that CognacGen can successfully generalize to unseen
instructions and outperform competitive baselines in generating constraint
conforming text. | [
-0.2322308719,
-0.7247813344,
0.31665802,
0.3534213006,
-0.1709071547,
-0.0433977991,
-0.3768642247,
-0.5235840082,
-0.1486343741,
0.7527806163,
-0.8799040318,
-0.5443769693,
-0.379910171,
0.2058994621,
-0.3340371847,
1.2610275745,
-0.3127332628,
-0.3301805556,
-0.2511918545,
0.0348629281,
-0.6154636741,
-0.6653473973,
-0.486931622,
-0.4088545144,
0.351947397,
0.5193278193,
0.5814999342,
0.7500069737,
0.4865311682,
0.235605225,
-0.1242904067,
0.4831141531,
-0.4252605438,
0.2439191192,
-0.2712874413,
-0.2120144218,
-0.1130053699,
0.0739907026,
0.3480382264,
0.5666683912,
-0.1463230103,
-0.1585408747,
0.1675237417,
0.3618848026,
-0.6118203998,
0.0223535374,
-0.8713243604,
-0.0662123635,
-0.3818680346,
-0.1201414987,
-0.5993396044,
-0.5241411924,
0.0429172516,
-0.7389011979,
0.5251997113,
0.3039312959,
1.2561979294,
0.345382005,
-0.3238506317,
-0.722076416,
-0.8665339947,
0.857028842,
-0.4042753875,
0.1088078469,
0.5136538744,
0.2169068307,
-0.3122282624,
-0.7758563161,
-0.3734132946,
-0.3721164465,
-0.1927030534,
-0.0021056847,
-0.1199528426,
0.0451134183,
0.16107364,
0.3063228428,
-0.494738996,
0.0833008289,
-0.1336541027,
-0.4678808749,
0.4858770072,
0.0616829023,
0.235204801,
-0.3296078742,
-0.3396564126,
-0.181688711,
-0.9435653687,
-0.2323238254,
0.4533631802,
0.3128988147,
0.0478384979,
0.5274563432,
-0.3140378296,
0.7204265594,
0.2843518555,
0.2694931328,
-0.1440123916,
-0.5799485445,
-0.0079848571,
0.1350080967,
0.8505206108,
0.1560844332,
0.1612023711,
-0.3066980541,
-0.0117163481,
0.0746044219,
0.1524307728,
-0.8716893196,
-0.166877836,
-0.0652477816,
0.04583342,
-0.2644158304,
-0.1316750646,
-0.6335175633,
-0.3471695483,
-0.1553932577,
0.1444607228,
-0.5402917862,
0.033710666,
0.0059927898,
-0.283495754,
0.2012319565,
0.0329409577,
-1.2583411932,
0.4379187524,
0.6152094603,
0.6864311099,
-0.3778930902,
0.0128730703,
-0.5268532038,
0.5975382924,
-0.3336779177,
0.3176235259,
-0.5332963467,
-0.457434088,
-0.0059221848,
-0.3326883614,
0.2649278045,
-0.4824370742,
0.6240978837,
-0.2835477293,
0.4708347917,
-0.2575280964,
-0.760461092,
0.205888316,
0.1480045617,
-0.5556951165,
1.0568877459,
0.0639835373,
-0.7428269386,
0.6311454177,
-0.3028813899,
-0.5149170756,
0.1813536137,
-0.4392700195,
-0.4367856085,
0.1699668467,
0.1693563461,
0.2462489307,
-0.5205108523,
0.7201083302,
0.1731377989,
0.1356878281,
-0.1006565988,
-0.3625908196,
0.4729384482,
0.2555700243,
-0.616790235,
-0.0341227502,
-1.0136072636,
0.1277002692,
-0.0353606679,
-0.2791783214,
-0.5003013611,
0.1773590744,
0.017753318,
0.0090985373,
0.3526241779,
-0.3998194635,
0.1197802424,
-0.3195044696,
0.4080504477,
0.3854168355,
0.207015276,
0.4506696463,
-0.1067544594,
0.3777207732,
-0.3852598071,
0.0284396149,
-0.0761066899,
-0.4623443484,
-0.9157315493,
-0.0309562963,
0.3694371581,
0.4520940483,
-0.8088018894,
0.6367616653,
0.0070553301,
-0.56715554,
-0.25465554,
0.1695024669,
0.6367042661,
0.5096058249,
0.4941851497,
-0.071671024,
-0.4643791914,
-1.0619878769,
-0.4581263065,
-0.0785413757,
-0.0654206797,
0.2840304673,
0.2829390466,
0.1772950441,
0.9553294778,
-0.4920188189,
-0.2010217309,
-0.2695153654,
0.7220025659,
-0.0268377233,
0.8449504375,
0.2902947366,
-0.8606954813,
-0.4485839009,
0.1667604446,
-0.5188382864,
-0.6377492547,
-0.3037752807,
-0.2060130835,
0.181751281,
0.8538284302,
-0.3183559775,
0.4190696478,
0.6677468419,
-0.5243812799,
0.2928628922,
-0.4941267669,
-0.2379153818,
-1.1383067369,
0.0522442721,
-0.0731923878,
-0.2687772214,
-0.6813275218,
0.1843973994,
0.2032478452,
-0.0966085047,
-0.1239444241,
0.6031118035,
-0.3337910771,
0.6238562465,
-0.205912292,
-0.069016993,
0.2236193866,
0.4540683925,
0.2643297613,
0.5195741653,
0.0832262412,
-0.648783803,
0.0851998031,
0.3016409874,
-0.3081656396,
0.423335284,
-0.7354838848,
0.0831314027,
0.0833389089,
0.0385931954,
-0.7020220757,
-0.3309699595,
0.174160257,
-0.1541183293,
0.4239593744,
0.0633456558,
-0.4575283229,
-0.1608035117,
0.2885892093,
0.1703543812,
0.5540227294,
-0.4285382628,
0.2251067013,
0.0081574256,
-0.2804668844,
-0.2642543316,
-0.8429906964,
0.2536994517,
-0.1335842758,
-0.3739725649,
0.810477972,
-0.2060713768,
-0.0810157657,
0.0163501259,
-0.0064290278,
-0.1476194113,
-0.0039126319,
0.1014596969,
0.0520498492,
0.2261539251,
0.1926283985,
0.3897956312,
-0.1173518524,
-0.2005854845,
-0.392868191,
0.4995350242,
0.2216269076,
-0.2353867292,
-0.262537986,
0.5441533923,
0.2268577218,
-0.3897373676,
0.5513524413,
0.376851052,
-0.1892727613,
-0.433301419,
-0.3982751071,
0.0504688397,
-0.5362285376,
0.2808360159,
-0.4291279912,
-0.9714189768,
0.2641964555,
-0.0309420899,
0.0510709584,
0.4002121389,
0.6456803083,
0.3796187341,
0.9758431315,
0.8795285225,
0.190847218,
0.4354411364,
0.1937096715,
-0.0637870282,
-0.3093416095,
-0.184964329,
-0.8073514104,
-0.1118635982,
-0.9726857543,
-0.3627327085,
0.1699374467,
0.3532627523,
-0.0950921848,
0.638871789,
-0.6981430054,
0.5106769204,
0.7612816095,
-0.1461918801,
0.3095131516,
-0.1407062858,
-0.567084372,
-0.1888145953,
-0.8334047198,
-0.4463016689,
0.7094650269,
0.0312739089,
0.7405056357,
0.0112571204,
0.965169847,
-0.0053814724,
0.382694155,
-0.2343865037,
0.4315358996,
-0.3130254447,
-0.9728338122,
-0.2242574096,
-0.7009826899,
-0.7031527162,
-0.1118584126,
-0.1618984193,
-0.7621281743,
0.1528063715,
0.3760165274,
-0.0863804668,
-0.0607651845,
-0.7704917789,
0.8303140402,
-0.2892213166,
-0.7576673627,
0.0799484923,
-0.3713445961,
0.2068368196,
-0.2465148568,
0.1190537587,
-0.1397395134,
-0.2054568082,
0.4525440931,
-0.782923758,
0.8632897139,
-0.1440145969,
-0.3172421157,
0.4266858995,
0.1530122906,
0.8537485003,
-0.1321796477,
-0.0754015446,
-0.2133711725,
-0.2153611481,
-0.2600039244,
-0.2948894501,
0.632230103,
-0.4268456101,
-0.6339020133,
-0.1338939816,
-0.6005174518,
-0.2927823365,
0.4815061092,
0.8216122389,
0.4382534325,
-0.537873745,
0.181059286,
0.4519277215,
-0.4733934104,
0.5461453795,
0.3363045454,
-0.198869884,
-0.3796277344,
1.1272933483,
0.0385709964,
0.5008068681,
0.5584720373,
0.5156936049,
-0.3228330016,
-0.7628142238,
-0.5291706324,
-0.102616258,
-0.4360372424,
-0.0901824981,
-0.307210207,
-0.1974797249,
-0.1934819967,
-0.1960970014,
-0.2765787244,
-0.4827654064,
-0.2954598963,
0.0165049769,
0.3382695615,
0.8411453366,
0.0353259183,
0.4730505049,
-0.6541480422,
0.24667871,
0.4336100221,
0.4373723269,
-0.4520328641,
-0.0691996142,
-0.1688905507,
-0.0958108827,
-0.3846033514,
-0.7516995668,
0.3351511061,
0.3674637079,
0.3214276433,
0.2153157741,
0.2924998701,
0.3707465231,
-0.7319904566,
0.7737774849,
0.290804714,
-1.0591453314,
0.6611763835,
-0.6654516459,
0.5633553863,
0.7223089933,
0.1968242675,
-0.5311508775,
-1.0404937267,
-0.6079232693,
-0.90831846,
0.4627017975,
0.6921391487,
0.2057740986,
-0.1799385697,
0.5036400557,
0.2513800263,
0.3928275704,
-0.702367723,
0.090696916,
-0.1796332449,
-0.4421277046,
-0.0486588478,
-0.0491369106,
-0.1235549748,
-0.0028791823,
0.6531658173,
-0.0830671042,
-0.3009970486,
0.2561946809,
-0.0037386725,
-0.0307378806,
0.323762238,
0.7075121999,
0.414778322,
-0.0515308455,
0.0585793853,
-0.1677758992,
-0.4710716903,
0.1494152546,
0.2343954742,
-0.8040778041,
0.2316165864,
0.2560814619,
0.8803350925,
0.0254862458,
-0.3786520362,
0.2173754424,
-0.1950747371,
-0.5557639599,
0.0175485164,
0.2868222296,
0.0524657778,
-0.1558077782,
0.1708222777,
-0.105561614,
-0.2459203303,
-0.0956444889,
0.2711400688,
0.440772146,
-0.5813445449,
-0.1634258032,
1.1001275778,
0.5406624079,
-0.2533831298,
0.2215019166,
-0.4916542768,
-0.2557532489,
0.5424179435,
0.5729389787,
0.9581797719,
0.0127241798,
0.2118636221,
0.3376205862,
0.5258529186,
-0.1380163729,
0.166703254,
-0.015497243,
-0.7481725812,
-0.4380538166,
-0.6050738096,
-0.5323604345,
0.1847693771,
-0.5531636477,
0.3174703717,
-0.653788209,
-0.1362879127,
0.029694505,
-0.0878313035,
-0.5740863681,
0.1806489676,
0.0106866313,
0.9432706237,
-0.6434670091,
0.8667841554,
0.2396958917,
-0.3348594606,
-0.7069507241,
0.0209427662,
-0.0536241755,
-0.5187462568,
0.4371697903,
0.1217461899,
-0.1349241287,
0.1881196946,
-0.6960638165,
-0.5642557144,
0.7664577365,
0.3373685479,
-0.6546894312,
-0.08774174,
0.3064150512,
0.5287393332,
-0.2586396039,
-0.3533507586,
0.5854324102,
0.6784351468,
0.3057859242,
-0.7367809415,
0.1164052635,
-0.1793879271,
-0.1010200381,
0.4613722861,
-0.5812327266,
0.6719412208,
0.1631500721,
-0.4119051397,
0.3597304523,
0.6344259381,
0.0245884098,
-0.0459124148,
0.3065735102,
0.6104641557,
0.9413477778,
-0.288074553,
1.0934647322,
-0.3360737562,
0.0943894088,
1.4690908194,
-0.254347682,
0.5561267138,
0.7017681599,
0.2879722118,
0.4894711971,
0.4817022979,
0.0371010564,
0.6290476322,
0.5166013241,
-0.2692455053,
-0.1977654248,
-0.5513483882,
-0.2883166075,
0.5315870643,
0.3483129442,
-0.3154205084,
-0.2556957006,
-0.2889386415,
0.180036664,
0.419749707,
-0.1158365309,
0.8371475935,
-0.2051255554,
-1.0258921385,
0.6934401393,
0.1282645911,
0.5993973017,
-0.95007056,
-0.0212518927,
-0.2487759739,
0.1515230685,
0.0915490016,
-0.1783501655,
0.3484989703,
0.2725006342,
-0.099332273,
-0.6341772676,
0.6827734113,
-0.7647179365,
-0.6520807743,
-0.0048254849,
0.437386483,
-0.254516989,
0.2123900354,
-0.3260298073,
-0.1593760848,
0.0739036351,
-0.245521158,
0.060862828,
0.7238083482,
-0.1944751292,
0.4659487307,
0.3476412594,
0.4001865685,
0.1634545475,
-0.1089193076,
0.6651323438,
-0.6424279213,
-0.5881026983,
-0.7855623364,
0.1755858064,
-0.3358750939,
-0.5964143276,
0.601189971,
0.4404771924,
0.7894456387,
0.1804343164,
1.068121314,
-0.3360345066,
0.3674841821,
-0.6973478794,
0.8255370855,
-0.4208806455,
0.0960631445,
-0.1848387867,
-0.7011723518,
-0.4149059653,
0.2121605873,
-0.1942325234,
-0.1343857348,
0.8210819364,
0.8851337433,
0.1770450324,
-0.0434893072,
0.118568249,
-0.137319088,
0.4751218259,
0.6775476336,
0.8635328412,
-0.0545206405,
0.7703826427,
-0.2301018685,
-0.1820648313,
0.1061658114,
-1.3984302282,
-0.9997335672,
-0.4786468744,
-0.2803282142,
-0.2205213308,
-0.0921534672,
0.7528510094,
0.7594338655,
-0.9280361533,
-0.2930397391,
-0.8527699113,
0.1480395645,
-0.1673105061,
-0.1509742439,
0.2837170362,
-0.5385468006,
-0.8771939278,
0.3395245969,
0.0862657726,
0.3801310658,
-0.2678877115,
-0.1899039894,
-0.0490470603,
0.183480069,
0.1068403274,
0.2903646231,
-0.4288027883,
-0.4536698759,
-0.0707954913,
-0.3119241595,
-0.1880495399,
1.2047024965,
-0.441413492,
0.5441742539,
0.4406585097,
0.6118915081,
0.5597868562,
-0.10233628,
1.1807005405,
-1.433662653,
0.4098955691,
0.146932587,
-0.0742333159,
0.2921115756,
-0.2449175268,
0.4110304415,
0.1170078814,
-0.3479442298,
-0.4274349213,
0.5482630134,
-0.4796980917,
-0.3499133289,
1.1723767519,
0.0532340668,
-0.1091714278,
-0.1112365574,
-0.172817409,
0.3387297988,
-0.3086799979,
0.6004063487,
0.8859112263,
-0.0428353399,
0.0024805134,
-0.4133636951,
1.0298879147,
0.4257898927,
-0.9114667773,
0.3782262504,
0.5912946463,
-0.1210548878,
0.1903879344,
0.4529753327,
0.006594785,
-0.0890789255,
-0.0533832945,
0.1709092259,
-0.1329029649,
-0.3488153219,
-0.0728738755,
0.2338896096,
0.1532662958,
-0.0272676423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10465v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10465v3 | SODA: Million-scale Dialogue Distillation with Social Commonsense Contextualization | 2022-12-20T17:38:47 | 2023-10-23T18:46:21 | Hyunwoo Kim, Jack Hessel, Liwei Jiang, Peter West, Ximing Lu, Youngjae Yu, Pei Zhou, Ronan Le Bras, Malihe Alikhani, Gunhee Kim, Maarten Sap, Yejin Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data scarcity has been a long standing issue in the field of open-domain
social dialogue. To quench this thirst, we present SODA: the first publicly
available, million-scale high-quality social dialogue dataset. By
contextualizing social commonsense knowledge from a knowledge graph, we are
able to distill an exceptionally broad spectrum of social interactions from a
large language model. Human evaluation shows that conversations in SODA are
more consistent, specific, and (surprisingly) natural than those in prior
human-authored datasets.
Using SODA, we train COSMO: a generalizable conversation model that is
significantly more natural and consistent on unseen datasets than
best-performing conversation models (e.g., GODEL, BlenderBot-1, Koala, Vicuna).
Experiments reveal COSMO is sometimes even preferred to the original
human-written gold responses. Additionally, our results shed light on the
distinction between knowledge-enriched conversations and natural social
chitchats. We plan to make our data, model, and code public. | [
-0.3189606071,
-0.8671607971,
0.359274596,
0.3974254429,
-0.2086777091,
0.4317432642,
-0.3720600009,
-0.2559019029,
0.3776048124,
0.3714979291,
-0.4756404459,
-0.3042090535,
-0.5131042004,
0.0850812644,
-0.2189470083,
1.2481863499,
0.7045256495,
0.1460618526,
-0.4437462091,
-0.0650890544,
-0.3393220305,
-0.5516465902,
-0.5941277146,
-0.1742023677,
0.5087463856,
0.4321173131,
0.936408639,
0.1742124856,
-0.0130128264,
0.3595992625,
-0.3851282597,
0.3515748978,
-1.2031258345,
-0.0675222203,
-0.351908952,
-0.3246995211,
-0.3080506325,
0.0778272301,
0.1750068516,
1.0705178976,
0.196117416,
0.1058657765,
0.3525512218,
0.7100942135,
-0.5445148945,
0.4673593342,
-0.7955947518,
-0.3489304781,
0.2400927991,
0.1265466064,
-0.3031210601,
-0.4849651754,
0.3010162115,
-0.806007266,
0.2651476264,
0.2432458699,
0.8018567562,
0.4165340364,
-0.2488508821,
-0.5823565125,
-0.9070751667,
0.7081335187,
-0.3298208416,
0.2801803648,
0.4575597644,
0.447766304,
-0.3817663193,
-0.7082080245,
-0.6877747774,
-0.2236074209,
-0.0429629683,
0.0261149593,
-0.2910020649,
-0.157397911,
-0.1595423818,
0.2660651207,
-0.1102455109,
-0.3998978138,
-0.7043697238,
-0.1641717553,
0.5974727273,
0.0996634215,
-0.011227252,
-0.2684189975,
-0.2495802194,
0.0902973488,
-0.5000430942,
-0.1135070473,
0.28124547,
0.4480228424,
-0.2541088462,
0.2375703901,
-0.4568778574,
0.4823340476,
0.1957755685,
-0.0246521104,
0.057080552,
-0.6507912874,
-0.1462588012,
0.165686816,
0.8550585508,
0.6112509966,
0.5322891474,
-0.2578161955,
0.4969668984,
-0.2370909303,
-0.0169899724,
-0.9272211194,
-0.5427308679,
0.3117226064,
0.0136350906,
-0.3777827919,
0.0715693533,
-0.8770463467,
-0.943637073,
-0.2687617242,
-0.2590305507,
0.0061895549,
-0.1997096539,
0.0438242443,
-0.3427704275,
-0.5219994783,
0.4718990624,
-0.7857143283,
0.3666135371,
0.9360048771,
0.9040443897,
0.2774441838,
0.107614316,
-0.6047459245,
0.0519770011,
-0.6488839388,
0.6012793779,
-0.4184411764,
-0.4094261825,
-0.2143179625,
-0.1112356111,
0.2997257411,
-0.8125419021,
0.433106482,
-0.3416260183,
0.1845974624,
-0.4289126992,
-0.2591235936,
0.1838349253,
0.2660423517,
-0.3751467168,
0.7844071388,
0.0752301589,
-0.6839501858,
0.614256382,
-0.7410600781,
-0.0969715267,
0.3192581236,
-0.1861940622,
-0.0123387417,
-0.0359030962,
0.1336293519,
0.2011138052,
-0.6840885282,
0.7373577356,
-0.6917435527,
-0.3253268003,
0.4498415291,
-0.5217009783,
0.8141246438,
0.6560925841,
-0.1057675704,
-0.1882507801,
-0.5898731351,
-0.1925037056,
0.114548862,
-0.2283936143,
-0.6543501019,
-0.0445009097,
-0.3248609304,
0.0650586858,
0.3066016436,
-0.7647672892,
-0.011926461,
-0.3962921202,
0.7992323637,
0.664249301,
0.096610114,
0.526951015,
-0.1406963468,
-0.0628060475,
0.0019282035,
0.3402645886,
-0.0477764346,
-0.5353742242,
-0.6951844692,
-0.3833355606,
0.1752472967,
0.3844714761,
-0.5033867955,
0.4988436103,
-0.6288261414,
-0.641505301,
-0.392310679,
0.246139586,
0.2333905399,
0.5835340619,
0.1484237313,
0.1153098568,
-0.3037253916,
-0.8365657926,
-0.1741536856,
-0.2712957561,
-0.2280179262,
0.9297628403,
0.2818377614,
-0.0139325811,
1.5566951036,
-0.8063848615,
-0.0557127669,
-0.2971481979,
0.3561522365,
0.2502706647,
0.2384983152,
0.4157647192,
-0.8606136441,
-0.8064690232,
-0.1045332327,
-0.5455324054,
-0.1767990589,
0.009490882,
-0.313100338,
-0.0031583351,
0.5638303161,
-0.2406332642,
0.2740978599,
0.6423544884,
-0.3706066608,
0.111854732,
-0.056420967,
0.4130944908,
-1.424597621,
0.0814767033,
-0.1161656156,
-0.1008126661,
-0.767886579,
-0.7296583652,
-0.2465552688,
-0.5643736124,
-0.56053406,
0.6996619701,
-0.2365828007,
0.075466156,
0.051265683,
0.1487162411,
0.0657813773,
0.4771427512,
0.013199524,
0.8119327426,
0.3054954112,
-0.5238076448,
0.4313220084,
0.5389769673,
-0.4357013106,
0.722006619,
-0.9142215848,
0.486146152,
-0.2436665148,
0.5404667854,
-1.2545467615,
-0.563796401,
0.2595228851,
-0.5793216825,
-0.3217440546,
-0.5644273758,
-0.5644986629,
-0.2641031146,
0.0793905407,
0.093722783,
0.2419065684,
-0.623821795,
0.227247104,
0.5715944767,
-0.7514516711,
-0.4801156819,
-0.2495267242,
0.4279633462,
-0.1049006209,
-0.7649456263,
-0.2058179826,
-0.3542079628,
-0.435693115,
-0.0792398527,
-0.0509360358,
-0.4090268314,
0.086224094,
0.4737163782,
0.3211142123,
0.3094757795,
0.292422533,
0.0661551133,
-0.0320778526,
-0.1062144786,
-0.0410502031,
0.993724227,
-0.3035345078,
-0.0567922592,
-0.2367785126,
0.21922943,
0.7100823522,
0.1956809312,
0.6721532345,
0.1704120785,
-0.24546206,
0.1256460994,
-0.3735816181,
-0.029138092,
-0.5476320386,
0.2547185421,
-0.0929586068,
-1.1846181154,
0.470454812,
-0.3984002471,
-0.0247041825,
-0.0237181503,
0.309217453,
-0.0896480754,
0.9325135946,
0.2523545325,
-0.2783365846,
0.3623687327,
0.028425673,
0.540497303,
-0.236800909,
-0.2231035978,
-0.5954694152,
-0.0889270902,
-0.1929822713,
-0.5359004736,
0.634432435,
0.1199206561,
-0.4069561958,
0.0945396423,
-0.2199759483,
0.8398805857,
0.4975719452,
-0.1542986184,
0.3900594413,
-0.1097293869,
0.2957803905,
-0.0927347317,
-0.7897301912,
-0.5081353784,
0.8487921357,
0.2742522955,
0.8723529577,
-0.0718019009,
0.7655134797,
0.3525438905,
0.4057967961,
-0.6122491956,
0.4437304139,
-0.0230647344,
-0.9883445501,
-0.3518710434,
-0.7869417071,
-0.9139544368,
-0.0437637009,
-0.5077409148,
-0.7901601791,
0.1322673559,
0.3527492285,
-0.5691772699,
0.0724301115,
-0.9176741242,
0.8676703572,
-0.0023831052,
-0.5370330811,
0.0169147626,
-0.5756152868,
0.3758794069,
-0.0560011305,
0.5507420301,
-0.1975678355,
0.5115500093,
0.6202300191,
-0.6881303787,
1.0250362158,
-0.164593339,
-0.0096853748,
0.5760680437,
0.0027863865,
0.4741390347,
0.2444146723,
0.4267174304,
0.3790619969,
-0.0048998217,
-0.3859330118,
-0.7325563431,
0.665048182,
-0.7867572904,
-0.4830543697,
-0.1419501305,
-0.6341263652,
-0.2964598536,
0.1500570774,
0.0672823936,
0.3137981296,
-0.4993292093,
0.5483416319,
0.4565927088,
-0.4635214508,
0.0040365313,
0.3134857416,
-0.0920169875,
-0.7145646214,
1.0199790001,
0.1378989667,
0.549032867,
-0.1012746319,
0.5155493617,
-0.3853470981,
0.0024253682,
-0.3295477331,
0.1689628661,
-0.6007474661,
-0.1179190278,
-0.84413445,
0.0324545689,
-0.921923995,
-0.3276620805,
-0.667894721,
-0.4242914617,
-0.1650741398,
0.0514781028,
0.3660986423,
0.847276032,
-0.2352990806,
0.1692319214,
-0.8931174278,
0.154601559,
0.5635245442,
0.2727515697,
-0.1460821778,
-0.1829280406,
-0.165207088,
0.4115710855,
0.0206099618,
-0.7557794452,
0.5366643071,
0.1739341766,
0.1440348178,
0.5674224496,
0.4843704998,
0.8051463366,
-0.3228701055,
0.9458471537,
0.4256646037,
-0.8565655351,
0.5140603185,
-0.5268594027,
-0.0005202459,
0.9826978445,
0.4378029108,
-0.8908122182,
-0.4222280979,
-0.712238431,
-0.8757352233,
0.5710045695,
-0.0051614172,
0.3916822076,
-0.388600409,
-0.0549146421,
0.1227440983,
0.4876998663,
-0.2419239134,
-0.1634598672,
-0.3700201511,
-0.0797897577,
-0.3306572437,
-0.1867535859,
-0.5472450852,
-0.2231610119,
0.2867801487,
-0.1348168701,
0.1116602346,
0.0976320878,
0.0617570356,
-0.0357196406,
0.5375824571,
0.3883311152,
0.5562745333,
-0.4483972788,
0.1355071813,
0.0982155502,
-0.4363516271,
-0.1310973912,
-0.1180130988,
-0.0717930496,
-0.0959419459,
-0.1799847931,
0.6860009432,
0.3455196917,
-0.7861480713,
0.5074945092,
-0.1494355351,
-0.2713897228,
-0.3031602204,
0.3096359372,
0.381396085,
0.2668689191,
0.3964222074,
0.0351472013,
0.1288270056,
-0.8645311594,
0.1411865205,
0.1790302545,
-0.5741530061,
-0.0912183449,
0.699888289,
0.5977165699,
-0.2951520383,
0.6663318276,
-0.3400320709,
-0.3371217549,
0.3362543285,
0.3964595497,
0.6583074927,
0.4005455673,
0.5983316898,
0.5783037543,
-0.0313105471,
0.1962861568,
-0.170975402,
-0.3192049563,
-0.7579634786,
-0.1750932783,
-0.4785427153,
-0.7791766524,
0.3581878245,
-0.5321382284,
-0.0164920539,
-0.5812110305,
-0.0993022993,
0.0405876264,
0.0827753693,
-0.4563470781,
-0.085949719,
-0.0985687226,
0.7848511934,
-1.2261978388,
0.4724920392,
0.1929798424,
-0.3649183214,
-0.5936370492,
-0.2284506857,
0.1276890934,
-0.6851097345,
0.8205486536,
-0.062970899,
-0.1249077171,
-0.0494063199,
-1.1837638617,
-0.7387569547,
1.0632553101,
0.4666911066,
-0.3696026802,
0.285217464,
0.4569882452,
0.5741530657,
-0.3475029469,
-0.0117505714,
0.5673529506,
0.3077767789,
0.7359911799,
-1.0817461014,
-0.2174829543,
-0.4269394279,
-0.2523458898,
-0.144365713,
-0.9009007812,
0.6361213326,
-0.2824361622,
-0.3923204243,
-0.04450671,
0.6957498789,
0.3431586027,
0.6841613054,
0.6828342676,
0.2845120728,
1.0144164562,
-0.2731683254,
0.7275654674,
-0.274477303,
0.2603115141,
1.4799281359,
-0.4339073002,
0.5199085474,
0.25561288,
-0.1130762175,
0.1817942709,
0.5664157867,
0.3679663241,
0.4851903915,
0.2446374148,
-0.5023572445,
-0.2348459363,
-0.4723156095,
-0.1194331273,
0.2801555693,
0.3775271475,
-0.0885589272,
-0.2364301831,
-0.2946197093,
0.5169270039,
0.1370305866,
-0.1789749116,
1.0564038754,
-0.2501735091,
-0.7656009793,
0.5981219411,
-0.628405869,
0.5635316372,
-0.3074669838,
-0.0576517619,
-0.4836959541,
-0.0357384272,
-0.0720733181,
-0.5031266212,
0.1658561081,
0.3258198798,
-0.0694025457,
-0.0349222012,
0.5991937518,
-0.7735644579,
-0.1423054188,
-0.0209552702,
0.3854400218,
0.5341334939,
-0.2351356149,
-0.5806144476,
-0.0024893312,
-0.1480711102,
0.2061472982,
0.2950031161,
0.5780228376,
0.1308150589,
0.6821332574,
0.8756603003,
-0.0105754882,
0.1351929158,
0.2281363904,
1.1700954437,
-0.3666534722,
-0.7132996917,
-0.403298825,
0.6001378298,
-0.6505708098,
-0.356687367,
0.6087492108,
0.6617708206,
0.724391818,
0.0782675743,
1.0579789877,
-0.1453980654,
0.6215879917,
0.0127406586,
0.882935226,
-0.257411927,
0.0330232941,
-0.4179335237,
-0.8262162209,
0.0844048262,
0.4944387972,
-0.4926103652,
-0.1191411167,
0.3862887621,
0.9949194193,
0.0003827238,
0.189718172,
0.3836338222,
0.2105326802,
0.5340157151,
0.2876526415,
0.9982240796,
-0.0379485004,
0.8631783128,
0.0019903739,
-0.5568276644,
-0.2417705953,
-0.8117035627,
-0.99694556,
-0.6956256628,
-0.2297706753,
-0.6475195289,
0.0945257694,
1.1987929344,
0.7012616992,
-0.6011743546,
-0.090237245,
-0.1210307553,
-0.0195006914,
0.1170502678,
-0.2561427653,
0.0149484649,
-0.4210129678,
-1.099271059,
0.4684442878,
0.2778201997,
0.0467078872,
-0.0152728595,
-0.2832390368,
0.1263657063,
0.4072875082,
0.5321936011,
0.4505178034,
-0.1675579399,
-0.4225958586,
0.1424615383,
0.0593841933,
0.1581890732,
0.7267187834,
-0.3789847791,
0.7297109365,
0.4195359647,
0.4663120806,
0.3944208026,
0.1921488494,
0.5009483695,
-0.7808257341,
0.2311005294,
0.0381904207,
0.0816358924,
0.3596448302,
-0.3152786493,
0.4580924213,
0.385209918,
-0.5859242678,
-0.7699051499,
0.2557648718,
-1.0647764206,
-0.2789109647,
1.2457953691,
-0.2561583519,
-0.292185843,
-0.6497110724,
-0.3839600086,
0.2385447919,
-0.819891572,
0.965734601,
0.8189014792,
0.048845645,
0.2376176566,
-0.2818104029,
0.5263701677,
0.0209685192,
-0.9269100428,
0.5976991653,
0.8797535896,
0.3562615812,
0.5364109874,
1.0277659893,
-0.0439243577,
-0.0163862742,
0.3639465272,
-0.2965018153,
-0.24007456,
-0.5898153186,
0.092176564,
0.2626128495,
-0.1681269854,
-0.0229877066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10461v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10461v1 | Go-tuning: Improving Zero-shot Learning Abilities of Smaller Language Models | 2022-12-20T17:36:49 | 2022-12-20T17:36:49 | Jingjing Xu, Qingxiu Dong, Hongyi Liu, Lei Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | With increasing scale, large language models demonstrate both quantitative
improvement and new qualitative capabilities, especially as zero-shot learners,
like GPT-3. However, these results rely heavily on delicate prompt design and
large computation. In this work, we explore whether the strong zero-shot
ability could be achieved at a smaller model scale without any external
supervised data. To achieve this goal, we revisit masked language modeling and
present a geometry-guided self-supervised learning method (Go-tuningfor short)
by taking a small number of task-aware self-supervised data to update language
models further. Experiments show that Go-tuning can enable T5-small (80M)
competitive zero-shot results compared with large language models, such as
T5-XL (3B). We also apply Go-tuning on multi-task settings and develop a
multi-task model, mgo-T5 (250M). It can reach the average performance of OPT
(175B) on 9 datasets. | [
-0.117981717,
-0.8678762913,
0.5892075896,
-0.2660599351,
-0.1447327137,
-0.0351486988,
-0.5208086967,
-0.4804433584,
-0.0156431589,
0.443289578,
-0.6860402226,
-0.5347006321,
-0.543643415,
-0.1017298922,
-0.0733383745,
1.0345027447,
0.1312846988,
-0.1501084119,
0.3416835964,
-0.0953088999,
-0.7489874959,
-0.1891024858,
-0.8749114871,
-0.0838098899,
0.4781424701,
0.7881076932,
0.6116265655,
1.0951277018,
0.4291168451,
0.2342544347,
0.1095234677,
0.0596223623,
-0.6840128303,
-0.0836618841,
-0.095385164,
-0.6410146356,
-0.6261323094,
0.1815818101,
0.6201732755,
0.5308075547,
-0.0945511013,
0.3069781363,
0.0065712179,
0.6003275514,
-0.6171263456,
0.392480135,
-0.7370300293,
-0.0028785365,
-0.3510617316,
-0.0043357313,
-0.4423670471,
0.0383144952,
-0.2606696188,
-0.8232181072,
0.6422570944,
0.2222961485,
0.7769988179,
0.4813272655,
-0.0763826668,
0.0689316541,
-0.6554518938,
0.9634719491,
-0.7789127231,
0.2220797986,
0.4395888746,
0.5312256813,
-0.1197932065,
-0.1142244041,
-0.1525765955,
-0.1967737973,
0.032472413,
0.1405494213,
0.0031520603,
0.0762283802,
0.4140951335,
0.3125992417,
-0.7591318488,
0.2509346902,
-0.3117500544,
-0.0945376381,
0.6144344807,
0.0987349972,
0.2407125682,
0.102848798,
0.2686090767,
-0.0763761923,
-0.8394107819,
0.10777127,
0.3789009154,
0.7354876995,
-0.2437720597,
0.4626316428,
-0.7696460485,
1.1810194254,
0.177903533,
-0.165125519,
0.0639308542,
-0.2938645482,
-0.3250470757,
-0.1929776967,
0.6620509624,
0.0974774361,
0.4118862152,
-0.3273149133,
-0.0371001773,
-0.1221246347,
0.1971258372,
-0.6792141795,
-0.4560766816,
0.044944115,
-0.1444316953,
-0.246192947,
-0.3011987805,
-0.4664826393,
0.1218210757,
-0.4678446054,
0.7006180286,
-0.5229811668,
-0.2683680356,
0.3373058438,
0.0555461496,
0.1645268351,
0.2678461373,
-1.0181771517,
0.0473488681,
0.4311101735,
1.000115037,
0.0637558028,
-0.4300620854,
-0.7232505679,
0.2132502943,
-0.6583516002,
0.7488145828,
-0.7246744037,
-0.2541419864,
-0.3134745359,
-0.0650822371,
-0.2499235421,
-0.5282621384,
0.1238907874,
-0.1630397141,
0.4030919075,
-0.0851463005,
-0.3148497045,
-0.1441899389,
0.101947479,
-0.4820172191,
1.1622287035,
0.2926963568,
-0.3942258954,
0.6378663778,
-0.8080373406,
-0.2873146534,
0.2217369974,
-0.0623371564,
-0.6890023947,
0.5846973658,
0.5104643703,
0.4847692251,
0.0900707021,
0.1343595684,
-0.6443121433,
-0.5762217045,
-0.3448010087,
-0.0552663431,
0.5673065782,
0.0242868811,
-0.4002861977,
0.2585348189,
-0.7643580437,
0.126464352,
0.0833869204,
-0.0120187774,
-0.16224356,
-0.1122771427,
-0.4544772506,
0.3434164524,
0.0488713086,
-0.6241798401,
0.30363819,
-0.4790936112,
0.2955821455,
0.483107686,
-0.2614177465,
0.5125051141,
-0.3615687788,
0.4724704623,
0.1443893313,
0.3052245677,
-0.2401262969,
-0.5224677324,
-1.0014184713,
-0.5396475792,
0.3393861949,
0.3264694512,
-1.0063531399,
0.2027261108,
-0.2345861644,
-0.5003233552,
-0.7071305513,
0.3169806302,
0.5132461786,
0.6934421062,
0.5642424226,
-0.0330783203,
-0.1858533174,
-0.7886916995,
-0.4235971868,
0.1592904031,
-0.2948226631,
0.4869128168,
0.4807247221,
0.3276964426,
0.8597683907,
-0.7102211714,
-0.5479587913,
-0.1176926121,
0.2082243264,
0.2690134645,
0.4721262753,
0.6466842294,
-0.1335113645,
-0.6963237524,
0.1839639097,
-0.7818474174,
0.0191143733,
0.284303546,
-0.0407361761,
0.1752349734,
0.5647606254,
-0.2679426074,
0.3947081268,
0.4082047641,
-0.228846699,
0.419763267,
-0.4960489869,
-0.0256970413,
-0.8615377545,
-0.2198578566,
0.0625124797,
-0.4203472137,
-0.6758728027,
0.0962142721,
0.3582389951,
-0.4240162969,
-0.5922186375,
0.5278615952,
-0.4835561514,
0.1051932126,
-0.5209337473,
-0.0231124088,
-0.3581741154,
0.6748242378,
0.3636285365,
0.8320721388,
1.1661998034,
-0.6937974095,
0.1032867804,
-0.2635824382,
-0.395491302,
0.6856513023,
-0.5962085128,
0.2271258831,
-0.1948013306,
-0.0150332898,
-0.7658237219,
-0.5257798433,
0.1768378019,
-0.3193668425,
0.5101518631,
-0.351845324,
-0.2933667898,
-0.2910890579,
-0.2746060193,
0.4557132125,
0.3520288169,
-0.3571697772,
0.3497726321,
0.1759473532,
-0.0903306827,
-0.2343124598,
-0.2704189718,
-0.0370431952,
-0.3298716843,
-0.3769755363,
0.1840665787,
-0.065234907,
0.2096201181,
-0.1508974284,
-0.0323008373,
0.1006538123,
0.0088953869,
0.0153162638,
0.1416579634,
-0.247358799,
0.2414788604,
-0.0533379838,
-0.3328778744,
-0.5014590621,
-0.581882894,
0.1811743528,
-0.1627340317,
-0.0440456048,
-0.2248066515,
0.2303684056,
0.2277286351,
-0.244908452,
0.7075554132,
0.5342886448,
-0.2648349702,
-0.4815547168,
-0.4556034207,
-0.1955615431,
-0.4798140228,
0.231214568,
-0.5926861763,
-1.3806093931,
0.4162679911,
0.1304310709,
-0.084224984,
0.4537265897,
0.5622573495,
-0.0807801113,
1.0937228203,
1.1752541065,
-0.1067280993,
0.6181941628,
-0.1500897259,
0.1690155864,
-0.7216275334,
-0.0215711333,
-0.6160588264,
-0.3276351094,
-0.6590829492,
-0.4036014378,
0.5535084009,
-0.0238819867,
-0.2630996704,
0.6183968186,
-0.4897821546,
0.7549749613,
0.6819489598,
0.2802942693,
0.2076433152,
-0.0595055595,
-0.1138114929,
0.0245425012,
-0.9294365644,
-0.0006297891,
1.2791782618,
0.1339732409,
0.8201903105,
-0.0097016012,
0.5456392765,
-0.0458960384,
0.1756531447,
-0.6686614752,
0.3462958932,
-0.249074623,
-0.7377663255,
-0.603179276,
-0.6355931759,
-0.6484313607,
0.1403501183,
0.1303845197,
-0.8120512962,
-0.0405952819,
0.3990135789,
-0.6304348111,
0.1629222631,
-0.9095182419,
0.9027641416,
-0.1088320613,
-0.4393133223,
0.0764251649,
-0.3595195711,
0.4260326028,
-0.2320503891,
0.1979001313,
-0.3054013848,
0.0479865,
0.5717658997,
-0.2625873685,
0.8837880492,
-0.2693889141,
-0.1193284765,
0.2238235623,
0.1766144335,
0.3011945486,
0.0171518214,
0.0183175728,
0.3559614122,
-0.1129292548,
-0.6971938014,
-0.6304875612,
0.7812543511,
-0.7815725803,
-0.5854579806,
-0.1457942128,
-0.7488332391,
-0.4571008086,
0.2414454669,
0.3799133599,
0.3453892171,
0.2057723999,
0.299693197,
0.5678427815,
0.1208112538,
0.834859848,
0.9087800384,
-0.1849338561,
-0.0751761794,
1.1932246685,
0.4307161272,
0.237131685,
0.2743419707,
0.1952133924,
-0.290838778,
-0.6012856364,
-0.6447160244,
0.376283288,
-0.0890467316,
-0.3445689082,
-0.2130633742,
-0.058351595,
-0.5049998164,
-0.0758788809,
-0.6456636786,
-0.2976639271,
-0.2170289904,
0.048719272,
0.230539158,
0.6060010791,
-0.2143337578,
0.7051383853,
-0.3230135143,
0.3063319921,
0.3304967284,
0.8636276722,
-0.3310692608,
-0.8559715152,
-0.6136909723,
0.0933815464,
-0.1634549052,
-0.442610383,
0.3313889205,
0.442776233,
0.2926255167,
0.2678434551,
-0.2344200462,
0.8561652899,
-0.662294209,
0.6222802997,
-0.0015490851,
-0.942559123,
0.8657356501,
-0.7560703158,
0.7844344974,
0.4819314182,
0.1906210482,
-0.214054063,
-0.4591715634,
-0.5206445456,
-0.2735401094,
1.1136542559,
0.2024259418,
-0.0029723216,
0.1410198361,
0.5050241351,
0.066973038,
0.1448024809,
-0.7652146816,
0.0379994363,
-0.3122126162,
-0.108185336,
-0.3581418395,
0.0701416656,
0.088889569,
-0.3008699715,
0.7880242467,
-0.6682803631,
0.1607375592,
-0.1585312039,
-0.0778294951,
-0.2936154902,
0.150777325,
0.7088485956,
0.5631049275,
-0.3412749171,
-0.0342283435,
0.1865051538,
-0.3153261244,
0.1248656213,
-0.1874147952,
-0.3887427151,
-0.233856976,
0.1636467874,
0.9382717609,
0.3687410951,
-0.2476251423,
0.2609557807,
0.0191297401,
-0.4655798078,
0.3137242496,
0.5412868857,
-0.1095646173,
0.0129756043,
0.0982130095,
-0.2447007746,
-0.1310025752,
-0.433324635,
0.0700342134,
0.6551678181,
-0.6671745181,
-0.3510540426,
0.7293473482,
-0.0159919802,
-0.2241106182,
0.490186125,
-0.186222285,
0.0746250376,
0.4142214954,
0.6253470778,
0.7458328605,
-0.4948262572,
0.4002929032,
0.4140792191,
0.4343087375,
-0.201846227,
0.1960754395,
-0.1524200141,
-0.4782855213,
-0.8101513982,
-0.5309621692,
-0.3444561362,
0.458829999,
-0.5191677809,
0.3825066388,
-0.3761711419,
0.002699798,
0.0357854404,
0.1008381173,
-0.597442925,
0.3937470317,
0.0288129877,
0.6881850958,
-0.7847072482,
1.096222043,
0.5304375291,
-0.1986072361,
-0.819873333,
-0.1905328482,
0.0579140931,
-0.7205057144,
0.3481874466,
0.2404782623,
-0.280672431,
0.3028356433,
-0.7280226946,
-0.9586443305,
0.8951584101,
0.5456827879,
-0.694732666,
-0.0508765616,
0.2251718938,
0.5725503564,
-0.4391805232,
0.3432198465,
0.4854763746,
0.1027581245,
0.2846562564,
-1.0832695961,
-0.390524894,
0.0659208968,
0.0084778769,
0.3628934026,
-0.8145829439,
0.8226177692,
-0.1067168042,
-0.0735905394,
-0.278200835,
0.5299530029,
-0.076320976,
0.1328632683,
0.1437401474,
0.7705084682,
0.5293904543,
-0.2363333553,
0.8338779211,
-0.3541103899,
0.6218755841,
1.468837738,
-0.3182334006,
0.723525703,
-0.0174200553,
0.0461302772,
0.2199799716,
0.532560885,
0.0766495243,
0.5510693789,
0.039926134,
-0.1894079447,
-0.6005496979,
0.0266661793,
-0.2539512217,
0.774178803,
0.202493608,
0.0461937673,
-0.6162365079,
0.1485835463,
0.1419514418,
-0.2137125134,
-0.5777078867,
0.7987735868,
-0.0835725069,
-0.722428143,
0.4719245136,
0.1621907949,
0.5288369656,
-0.6140885353,
0.1222801059,
-0.3559726775,
0.2415539473,
0.0857357979,
-0.4857063591,
0.315833956,
0.0103514651,
-0.10037902,
-0.2707355618,
0.744202435,
-0.4587717652,
-0.7595936656,
0.0950955078,
0.6815342307,
0.0681519881,
-0.3339779675,
-0.6293891072,
-0.2116860747,
-0.1078469381,
-0.1131035015,
0.59972018,
0.4047167599,
-0.094220832,
0.632453382,
0.7216263413,
0.1562159061,
0.1061017737,
-0.1021427438,
0.7808814645,
-0.8328140378,
-0.5148813725,
-0.9230155349,
0.2336937636,
-0.0144518055,
-0.2377289534,
0.8393537998,
0.6321581006,
1.1161551476,
-0.2349837422,
0.6044864655,
0.1255726516,
0.7937390804,
-0.6092916727,
0.6564300656,
-0.5318243504,
-0.2023599297,
-0.0013537557,
-0.7811967731,
-0.5925759673,
0.5465465784,
-0.6117212176,
0.2396184802,
0.5497780442,
0.9502434134,
-0.3534564078,
-0.1462414712,
0.867229104,
0.1179948524,
0.2334174365,
0.8230807781,
0.2896689177,
-0.3869485557,
0.4247475266,
-0.3933928907,
-0.4429277778,
-0.1504389644,
-0.9578667283,
-1.2268118858,
-0.3359888494,
-0.4717519581,
0.1194048896,
0.1059642136,
0.2447580248,
1.1149926186,
-0.8291677833,
-0.2574466169,
-0.108688578,
0.0267970394,
-0.3861542344,
-0.1925978661,
0.2845226228,
-0.7259396911,
-0.8230988979,
0.6356071234,
0.7225051522,
-0.0738487616,
-0.1250866503,
0.1165235564,
-0.0607218482,
0.0585639663,
0.6006962657,
0.4089071453,
-0.489721179,
-0.5711929202,
0.0995661989,
0.186894536,
0.0842235535,
0.8135847449,
-1.0062712431,
0.6797102094,
0.0231373552,
0.2271931171,
0.6256731153,
-0.0976180658,
0.4617897272,
-0.9389851689,
0.1993806809,
-0.1953280717,
0.0281591844,
0.1836414486,
-0.2981804013,
0.6182836294,
0.2856711447,
-0.5499676466,
-0.5150235295,
0.2440913618,
-0.6303402781,
-0.1369502246,
0.8525333405,
-0.1319399625,
-0.2926912308,
-0.2030277699,
-0.1387726665,
0.2483900338,
-0.2088004798,
0.9136842489,
0.7912206054,
-0.2900013626,
-0.4509557784,
-0.8428398967,
0.6186470985,
0.4274053872,
-0.9044860601,
0.1380965114,
0.4977092743,
0.4405955374,
-0.0906899124,
0.5999571085,
-0.042809926,
0.2463381141,
-0.0797826126,
-0.2887670696,
-0.4275467992,
-0.7107765675,
-0.4255219996,
0.2701464593,
-0.0227588601,
-0.264519006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10455v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10455v2 | MULTI3NLU++: A Multilingual, Multi-Intent, Multi-Domain Dataset for Natural Language Understanding in Task-Oriented Dialogue | 2022-12-20T17:34:25 | 2023-06-19T04:09:37 | Nikita Moghe, Evgeniia Razumovskaia, Liane Guillou, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen, Alexandra Birch | cs.CL | cs.CL | Task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems have been widely deployed in many
industries as they deliver more efficient customer support. These systems are
typically constructed for a single domain or language and do not generalise
well beyond this. To support work on Natural Language Understanding (NLU) in
TOD across multiple languages and domains simultaneously, we constructed
MULTI3NLU++, a multilingual, multi-intent, multi-domain dataset. MULTI3NLU++
extends the English only NLU++ dataset to include manual translations into a
range of high, medium, and low resource languages (Spanish, Marathi, Turkish
and Amharic), in two domains (BANKING and HOTELS). Because of its multi-intent
property, MULTI3NLU++ represents complex and natural user goals, and therefore
allows us to measure the realistic performance of TOD systems in a varied set
of the world's languages. We use MULTI3NLU++ to benchmark state-of-the-art
multilingual models for the NLU tasks of intent detection and slot labelling
for TOD systems in the multilingual setting. The results demonstrate the
challenging nature of the dataset, particularly in the low-resource language
setting, offering ample room for future experimentation in multi-domain
multilingual TOD setups. | [
-0.3330904841,
-0.6513000131,
0.5329970717,
0.5303956866,
-0.2362216413,
0.0218881238,
-0.2598505318,
-0.6235113144,
0.0739509538,
0.5878142715,
-0.606161356,
-0.4565968215,
-0.4569882452,
0.2995411456,
0.1678875685,
1.0085701942,
-0.2001186907,
0.2349224687,
0.0258253496,
-0.5060135126,
-0.6860954165,
-0.4984593689,
-0.9950248003,
-0.3274258971,
0.5510191321,
0.3606430888,
0.5458481312,
-0.0354569331,
0.2230094522,
0.2456694692,
0.2630136609,
0.2926663756,
-0.1663746685,
0.0459383763,
0.1866202056,
-0.2782517672,
-0.7664841413,
-0.2242872566,
0.5021898746,
0.5658880472,
-0.0777410939,
-0.0526493266,
0.2310662568,
0.5602032542,
-0.479224503,
0.469647646,
-0.2554515302,
-0.0939774364,
-0.2207801342,
-0.0721410066,
-0.430583477,
-0.3369479179,
0.227163583,
-0.9157719016,
-0.0004559139,
-0.1403285861,
0.5744456053,
0.1264553517,
-0.5902229548,
-0.3509465158,
-0.5401434898,
0.9406635761,
-0.574993372,
0.5826467872,
0.4001554549,
0.2047893554,
-0.0428445041,
-0.2149273157,
-0.7469831705,
0.1889322847,
-0.3057129383,
0.1341661066,
0.1167930514,
-0.0648256913,
0.0199975185,
0.0790658891,
-0.7606469393,
-0.0526440702,
-0.086339429,
-0.1378567517,
0.456579119,
-0.0077721337,
0.2644744217,
-0.4339693785,
-0.4497677684,
0.1005384848,
-0.5660225153,
0.1157216579,
0.2670365274,
0.6221432686,
-0.2211536467,
0.4012341499,
-0.0651985407,
1.1191228628,
-0.5795099139,
-0.394547075,
0.150634557,
-0.7494643331,
-0.2477585971,
0.0780847445,
0.8796572089,
0.2574110329,
0.1995896101,
-0.218731463,
-0.0136521393,
-0.143694371,
0.0699476153,
-0.2278760821,
0.1827003658,
0.2487923503,
-0.1424104869,
0.2687755227,
-0.4082576036,
-0.3758484423,
-0.1927395761,
-0.6944667101,
0.176355049,
-0.4568296075,
-0.5187376142,
0.3552393615,
0.0571936034,
0.2670577765,
0.6559601426,
-0.4406655431,
0.2441738099,
0.7079985142,
0.7200577259,
-0.4761048257,
-0.6001265645,
-0.4281622469,
0.4203947484,
0.0689719096,
0.5423827767,
-0.2413594872,
-0.3147061765,
0.0445562564,
-0.0357605293,
-0.4505392611,
-0.2606759667,
0.8796958327,
-0.4280242324,
0.3554934859,
0.1723642051,
0.0005646328,
-0.5245501399,
0.555178225,
-0.7352474332,
1.0022274256,
-0.0261231363,
-0.2916025221,
0.3966893554,
-1.2309827805,
-0.7129442096,
0.1134113073,
-0.0002163161,
-0.1074350104,
-0.0043395231,
0.1591971666,
0.5816975236,
-0.2804327309,
0.6098933816,
-0.1525697112,
-0.0489213914,
0.2334556282,
-0.7363089323,
0.729917407,
0.1066875309,
-0.2353049219,
0.2039640844,
-0.7342125177,
-0.1626291722,
-0.0671173781,
-0.2830564678,
-0.48295331,
-0.1040085927,
0.3759966493,
0.3550530672,
0.272231251,
-0.7130735517,
0.1407076865,
-0.1266638786,
0.1356296688,
0.448392421,
-0.3823312223,
0.1519369334,
-0.185050562,
0.409763515,
0.1024070233,
0.2581492066,
0.2008516639,
-0.8118439913,
-0.6971825957,
-0.1555071324,
-0.0856984034,
0.5582662821,
-1.0594222546,
-0.0502153225,
-0.5370761752,
0.1623895913,
-0.6167048216,
0.167665422,
0.4985747337,
0.3123253286,
0.4539264441,
-0.0777079463,
-0.3659925461,
-0.862077117,
-0.2504873276,
0.0494547226,
0.029379867,
0.5803773403,
0.1401642114,
-0.2764720619,
0.719203949,
-0.3193537593,
-0.6754649282,
-0.8102479577,
0.2022050023,
0.561000526,
0.4280096591,
0.1451337487,
-0.9449250102,
-0.7372460961,
0.4068695903,
-0.7486667633,
0.390735805,
-0.1736527979,
-0.2522200644,
0.3664498031,
-0.0562863834,
-0.7047066689,
0.3661399186,
0.6375823617,
-0.2783434689,
0.4269792736,
-0.1101503074,
0.2119976729,
-1.2667304277,
0.1092879772,
0.1758441776,
-0.3552666605,
-1.0601731539,
-0.1305097789,
-0.0736181363,
-0.1875329316,
-0.6781090498,
0.6752597094,
-0.2285363078,
-0.1308821291,
0.0618149415,
0.4334828556,
0.4864753485,
0.8581172228,
0.3653945029,
0.7674475312,
0.3975886405,
-0.9265955091,
0.1547864079,
0.4032415152,
-0.4181737006,
0.7086679339,
-0.3524665534,
0.0777002722,
0.1136650518,
0.2812906504,
-0.6728963256,
-0.2989693582,
0.2006464899,
-0.2438756227,
0.1558594704,
-0.297604233,
-0.4735973179,
-0.177777186,
-0.0293123517,
0.717084825,
-0.325078398,
-0.4896897674,
0.8581613898,
0.4578776658,
-0.3579367697,
-0.7386949658,
-0.458861798,
0.1232998222,
-0.2427560389,
-0.6789520383,
0.1852836013,
-0.0582678244,
-0.1677523553,
-0.1485046297,
0.0603131168,
-0.4245083332,
0.2218011171,
-0.0329588205,
0.3812608421,
-0.1848643422,
-0.0582145974,
-0.1860391945,
-0.1250048876,
0.0397704095,
-0.396340549,
0.5656248927,
-0.1943030804,
-0.330360353,
-0.764523387,
0.5947549343,
0.75029248,
-0.1339485943,
0.5467048883,
0.8794725537,
-0.2953343093,
0.0804674402,
-0.4115725756,
0.2410282344,
-0.4000934958,
0.0891275331,
-0.8406614661,
-0.7743419409,
0.3200563788,
0.154427141,
0.3794525564,
0.3583063483,
0.3888899982,
-0.0606724992,
1.0142047405,
0.4457348883,
-0.0680634007,
0.1447328925,
-0.2737648487,
0.4420595765,
-1.1603986025,
-0.3044517934,
-0.4261321723,
-0.2995592356,
-0.2092058361,
-0.4833669066,
0.4560089111,
-0.0306938644,
0.3248766959,
0.5911183953,
-0.2368005067,
0.2508099079,
0.369214654,
-0.1760344505,
0.5852993727,
-0.3117881715,
0.0217645895,
0.1000030339,
-0.6328800321,
-0.4316768646,
1.012873292,
0.130112797,
0.4629792571,
0.7941853404,
0.4127454162,
0.055464495,
0.4343304634,
-0.8903899789,
0.3341875374,
-0.24352777,
-0.535038352,
-0.4588370621,
-0.4428736567,
-1.1184198856,
0.3640112281,
0.2561751306,
-0.8656015992,
0.2114011049,
0.0171238296,
-0.4087342918,
0.2566796839,
-0.9525858164,
1.0231915712,
-0.3952544034,
-0.3108815253,
-0.1921582222,
-0.2722828984,
0.5233531594,
-0.0288098324,
0.5930703282,
-0.533777535,
0.2631813288,
0.698903203,
0.0954494476,
0.6029506326,
-0.3543102741,
-0.4550887644,
0.1004861966,
-0.0166672021,
0.4793705344,
0.5971459746,
-0.2409386933,
0.0817750841,
-0.0656447038,
-0.4130203128,
-0.3931317925,
0.9072539806,
-0.720772922,
-0.3886648118,
-0.3449677825,
-0.7561978698,
-0.3921649456,
0.2238541096,
-0.1204432026,
0.8798481226,
-0.2753493488,
0.0186397117,
0.4633134604,
-0.1396009773,
0.6449861526,
0.6963559985,
-0.2043088824,
-0.0502953455,
1.1546866894,
-0.3196199536,
0.1789570004,
0.4347775877,
0.0067938128,
-0.7430818677,
-0.493132323,
-0.8867291808,
0.1256572753,
-0.5423265696,
-0.2184155881,
-0.7935832143,
0.2420934588,
-0.2935342491,
0.0520039871,
-0.1854504645,
-0.3655173182,
-0.2171985209,
0.1711966246,
0.3465399146,
0.8833056688,
0.2550002038,
0.2703428864,
-0.7891987562,
0.7028633356,
0.188946411,
0.8231095672,
-0.164305687,
-0.0883197933,
-0.3848208189,
0.0504770279,
-0.149037078,
-0.4938271642,
0.389808923,
0.3913853168,
0.6158331633,
0.2125086635,
-0.1047772765,
0.6635524035,
-0.4102326035,
0.6610093117,
0.1471524835,
-0.8708657026,
0.5080313683,
-0.5236588717,
0.5796281695,
0.7628091574,
0.4497468174,
-0.7779707909,
-0.378454119,
-0.3552827239,
-0.6958433986,
1.1987349987,
0.2841411233,
-0.0207910482,
0.0798579454,
-0.0127625065,
0.3743239641,
0.0395904891,
-1.0834903717,
-0.3917831481,
-0.1728131622,
-0.1626603752,
-0.2662676573,
0.1575164795,
-0.3036057949,
-0.0561288036,
0.7454306483,
-0.3833769858,
0.3643258512,
0.1559405029,
-0.4985112846,
0.2720312774,
0.6232829094,
0.7791468501,
0.7303192616,
-0.2791177928,
-0.1370683014,
-0.0839752331,
-0.4607324898,
0.0731480867,
0.2467002124,
0.1829268634,
0.2224654108,
0.0456653982,
1.1222507954,
0.1842800081,
-0.6003721356,
0.3674723506,
-0.7151405811,
-0.0761700347,
-0.223604396,
-0.1686652005,
-0.1742267013,
-0.3048847914,
0.4095737934,
0.2954694033,
0.3934597969,
-0.4665006995,
0.0705112293,
0.3053430021,
-0.6108059883,
-0.3370347917,
0.2394832075,
0.5461254716,
-0.3560177088,
0.3002380133,
-0.486165911,
-0.4204623401,
0.2757602036,
0.4707199335,
0.8721638918,
0.0837763473,
0.350635916,
0.4152526259,
0.0958495289,
0.1312358528,
0.5657206774,
-0.1252760887,
-0.8470674753,
-0.7643995285,
-0.686442852,
-0.4268795252,
0.3578348756,
-0.7287589312,
-0.0345660076,
-0.0704472885,
-0.0616024919,
-0.048955828,
-0.1736469418,
-0.9718939066,
0.0025740569,
-0.0335318893,
0.4785574973,
-0.5425607562,
1.1726709604,
0.6852522492,
0.2880744636,
-0.6272830963,
-0.1746929586,
0.0974804014,
-0.7026548386,
0.675047636,
0.4090614021,
-0.4243668616,
-0.0172928553,
0.4193619192,
-0.7709462047,
0.7620742917,
-0.045181945,
-0.2605333924,
0.2779576778,
0.274074316,
0.215277493,
-0.3833915889,
0.1957547665,
0.8457222581,
0.6477167606,
-0.3376930356,
-1.0628805161,
-0.2590718567,
-0.3632938564,
-0.4384741187,
0.5447291136,
-0.2835201323,
0.5570078492,
0.0403229892,
-0.2758302689,
-0.1837074906,
0.2261080146,
0.192127943,
0.3846059144,
0.572139442,
0.5082876682,
0.4703173935,
-0.5441024303,
1.2109999657,
-0.2511603236,
0.0119500514,
1.3525011539,
-0.4289357364,
0.7695960402,
0.4895355403,
-0.1168497056,
0.455370605,
0.32076177,
0.5576220751,
0.3026063144,
-0.2617793679,
-0.5455472469,
0.012238387,
-0.6199496388,
-0.054922387,
0.4994901717,
0.7557420135,
0.5076275468,
-0.157731384,
0.2674726844,
-0.0520098358,
-0.1902556419,
-0.1070295647,
1.1246470213,
-0.1407576501,
-0.9575412273,
0.6948611736,
-0.0913785845,
0.7189318538,
-0.7408947945,
0.1195646301,
-0.1595480293,
0.1107959747,
-0.0959332064,
-0.9213490486,
0.4087533951,
0.0967280716,
0.0909692645,
-0.4316640794,
0.2655366361,
-0.4832001626,
-0.4557048678,
0.4347811639,
0.6312307119,
0.0715288296,
0.0634486675,
-0.7893267274,
0.0754646882,
0.1415355355,
0.0246686377,
0.1832503527,
0.5619816184,
-0.0032296949,
0.6397035122,
0.6866300702,
-0.1484377831,
0.0245850366,
0.6867246032,
0.4137305319,
-0.3331391513,
-0.3427708745,
-0.5122621059,
0.5445867777,
-0.1353814751,
-0.5948354006,
0.7838971615,
0.6843951941,
0.8959249258,
-0.0571686216,
0.875410676,
-0.0736371204,
0.311289221,
-0.574436605,
0.2654933631,
-0.7452788949,
0.117770277,
-0.1924438179,
-0.8790371418,
-0.4845935404,
0.4894602597,
-0.1011652723,
-0.3879581988,
0.6733711958,
0.4134218693,
-0.1195458248,
0.2246957123,
0.274401933,
-0.1181343123,
0.4184770286,
0.7032955885,
0.7391857505,
-0.4883503616,
0.5908114314,
-0.198440358,
-0.0187225956,
-0.0519569814,
-0.6386486888,
-0.7028166056,
-0.5110513568,
-0.2012767643,
-0.0112544596,
-0.2082849741,
0.6710432172,
0.5632123351,
-1.0033652782,
-0.6529131532,
-0.0403945073,
0.6130376458,
-0.3861365318,
-0.23475115,
0.2843984365,
-0.4921579957,
-0.9322524071,
0.7172189951,
0.6182041168,
0.122428,
-0.2901994884,
-0.4094507098,
-0.602693975,
-0.2435030788,
0.853425324,
0.061380554,
-1.0180768967,
-0.0304905288,
-0.0327841863,
0.0411883034,
0.2629092932,
0.9747686982,
-0.4795742631,
0.5409173965,
0.2695077956,
0.4753071368,
0.3781241775,
-0.3048861623,
0.9133413434,
-1.1110209227,
0.200530231,
0.2332312018,
0.5855969191,
0.3682635427,
-0.3863325119,
0.5331401825,
-0.1928180456,
-0.2436534911,
-0.628585279,
0.3758321404,
-1.1789367199,
-0.2302924097,
0.92482692,
-0.1892989725,
0.1466474533,
-1.0012780428,
-0.3037925959,
0.1981324106,
-0.6721118689,
0.2435505986,
0.655195117,
-0.3761523068,
0.0170800015,
-0.8724247217,
0.8425806761,
0.4678489268,
-1.0145685673,
0.3446730971,
0.2140556276,
-0.2891817987,
0.350492835,
0.767334044,
0.1273257434,
0.3662368953,
-0.7712149024,
-0.0780064166,
0.2450524122,
-0.5435711145,
-0.1413703263,
0.0592451915,
0.0795767307,
-0.0315080024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10450v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10450v2 | Is GPT-3 a Good Data Annotator? | 2022-12-20T17:28:41 | 2023-06-14T16:11:50 | Bosheng Ding, Chengwei Qin, Linlin Liu, Yew Ken Chia, Shafiq Joty, Boyang Li, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data annotation is the process of labeling data that could be used to train
machine learning models. Having high-quality annotation is crucial, as it
allows the model to learn the relationship between the input data and the
desired output. GPT-3, a large-scale language model developed by OpenAI, has
demonstrated impressive zero- and few-shot performance on a wide range of NLP
tasks. It is therefore natural to wonder whether it can be used to effectively
annotate data for NLP tasks. In this paper, we evaluate the performance of
GPT-3 as a data annotator by comparing it with traditional data annotation
methods and analyzing its output on a range of tasks. Through this analysis, we
aim to provide insight into the potential of GPT-3 as a general-purpose data
annotator in NLP. | [
-0.3862535059,
-0.877800405,
0.4170509577,
0.055109594,
-0.5057477355,
-0.5124059319,
-0.1346061379,
-0.8045873642,
-0.070822455,
0.2473427057,
0.0361366235,
-0.5525553823,
-0.6302630901,
0.1786935031,
-0.5334784985,
1.4318327904,
-0.1821700037,
-0.2479667068,
0.3044663668,
0.1249791831,
-0.5139014721,
-0.8534809351,
-0.9727979302,
-0.4390949905,
0.5649430752,
-0.1028321981,
1.084495306,
0.9406607747,
0.6010322571,
0.1357763261,
0.1521253139,
-0.1862984896,
-0.2281698436,
0.0506307445,
0.061527051,
-0.4224561155,
-0.6031791568,
0.2915086746,
0.6517304778,
0.4526605308,
0.1862183213,
0.1181860939,
0.0995809957,
0.5537576675,
-0.3673353791,
0.496419996,
-0.5293100476,
0.13617374,
-0.7731032372,
-0.0979849175,
-0.1516072899,
-0.6367203593,
0.1884753108,
-0.8412719369,
0.3963074386,
-0.0868881941,
0.9058077931,
0.3819091618,
0.0508165509,
-0.2204734832,
-0.8668886423,
0.5926963091,
-0.6411712766,
0.1287588477,
0.6380886436,
0.6779820919,
0.2251338214,
-0.5458553433,
-0.7936841249,
-0.0628749281,
-0.0940095633,
0.1373272836,
0.1181613207,
-0.0611683466,
0.4234023392,
0.5717251301,
-0.5748096108,
0.0815613344,
-0.3241229653,
-0.0265298542,
0.4754024744,
-0.09992183,
0.3605672121,
-0.2149833143,
-0.2133204788,
0.2018789053,
-0.690467298,
-0.4565603137,
0.5496922135,
0.532045424,
0.1808960736,
0.6661912799,
-0.2144189477,
1.017557025,
-0.6433480978,
-0.0102814659,
0.3069351315,
-0.0672435015,
-0.2507904172,
0.0108445762,
0.8280411959,
0.4981720448,
0.4908541441,
-0.423950851,
-0.3258892894,
0.0358382873,
0.1322377622,
-0.6742250919,
-0.508659482,
0.1936591417,
-0.2827878892,
-0.1533049196,
0.1472239196,
-0.5273835063,
-0.2804297805,
-0.3158530295,
0.4612417519,
-0.4653617442,
-0.2645995617,
0.228320092,
0.0766367391,
0.0526007488,
0.5428182483,
-1.1471481323,
0.3510819376,
0.8787100911,
1.2736477852,
-0.3118965328,
-0.307700783,
-0.5178613067,
0.2578413486,
-0.3620810807,
0.6297466755,
-0.5328836441,
-0.0940312445,
-0.1411160231,
-0.2231899798,
-0.1517264098,
-0.3487378359,
0.5912150741,
-0.4469756186,
0.1416200101,
-0.0182278212,
-0.5435605049,
-0.4466248751,
0.2840099931,
-1.1790850163,
1.0269318819,
0.307366997,
-0.9682275057,
0.8971288204,
-1.068307519,
-0.1542486697,
0.5985424519,
-0.0968732163,
-0.5788578391,
-0.2650968432,
0.4390178025,
0.79143399,
-0.3560646772,
0.2736957967,
-0.197832346,
-0.7987627387,
0.3077300787,
-0.3779953718,
0.3110471368,
0.1371161789,
-0.3832197189,
-0.2428606153,
-0.674954772,
-0.1707859784,
0.069332242,
-0.4443129301,
-0.1412016898,
-0.0208936892,
0.2706711292,
0.1467778832,
-0.1742005944,
-0.7485584617,
0.425527513,
-0.1861889213,
0.3096832931,
0.476513952,
0.1897384375,
-0.0592698902,
-0.2760339677,
0.3691005707,
-0.2948800325,
0.0703491569,
0.0932530835,
-0.9977016449,
-0.3818888962,
-0.3968046606,
0.6639024615,
0.5127936006,
-0.8149988651,
0.1275018901,
-0.1291515976,
-0.4726332426,
-0.7082855105,
0.1327305287,
0.016251862,
0.4970797896,
0.6235430837,
0.1038917974,
-0.4964204133,
-0.9590274096,
-0.2257924825,
-0.2514902055,
-0.3949575722,
-0.0217387844,
0.5996064544,
-0.0941463336,
0.9808458686,
-0.3446559906,
-0.4440159798,
-0.333520174,
0.4311761558,
0.3559070528,
0.4730530679,
0.4972657561,
-0.7174714804,
-0.3380604684,
0.320789516,
-0.9374864101,
-0.1418779492,
-0.1144768074,
0.0024806273,
0.2899725437,
0.0202440489,
-0.4703455865,
0.4462307394,
0.467140466,
0.0038610236,
0.2813960612,
0.1041435376,
0.245990485,
-0.7469437122,
0.456399858,
0.1339387149,
-0.1373001039,
-0.8742982745,
-0.4055259228,
-0.0116415992,
-0.1942526549,
-0.4002138078,
0.3465418816,
0.1529073715,
-0.0960315242,
-0.2177899629,
0.2398254573,
-0.3472782373,
0.226000309,
0.4201931953,
0.8525159955,
0.5099682808,
-0.4821142256,
0.426094085,
0.1584531814,
-0.301237911,
0.3651463687,
-0.5936428905,
0.4818579853,
0.0620538704,
0.0794145092,
-0.7198885083,
-0.4494590163,
0.3962568641,
-0.4634740949,
0.0363882706,
-0.4158670306,
-1.0267275572,
-0.4668555558,
-0.2439050376,
0.1753850281,
0.1277244538,
-0.5969465375,
0.2530111074,
0.1514873952,
-0.1813423485,
-0.2101737112,
-0.9716648459,
0.0183902513,
-0.4096766114,
-0.2851840556,
0.0853371024,
0.3560633957,
0.1389453411,
-0.1548199058,
0.2374352813,
-0.0945057869,
0.1309237182,
0.3679985702,
0.3524374664,
-0.0313931108,
0.085878551,
-0.4968557954,
-0.5620017052,
-0.0504274704,
-0.181166023,
0.2478485107,
-0.3424223661,
-0.4254148006,
-0.53725034,
0.1274863929,
0.0028354977,
-0.0093389442,
0.4756618738,
0.8788518906,
-0.605987668,
0.1899445206,
-0.4587323368,
0.3052195311,
-0.3265864849,
0.2401988059,
-0.4538312256,
-0.7905799747,
0.3748234212,
0.2274075896,
-0.0116503453,
0.6779974699,
0.2858096957,
0.1690393537,
1.1043469906,
0.3463411629,
-0.3752079606,
0.218854934,
-0.2750480771,
0.2753780186,
-0.897084415,
-0.0398568027,
-0.4953811467,
-0.1631406397,
-0.6926072836,
-0.2547673583,
0.0115009323,
0.3505190015,
-0.329048872,
0.1513226181,
-0.7220824957,
0.4689371288,
0.6158643961,
-0.1596137583,
0.2267969698,
-0.2844450474,
0.6046390533,
-0.002819893,
-0.2713567615,
-0.9675662518,
1.1765532494,
0.6310003996,
0.5838702321,
0.0675192103,
0.6796497107,
-0.0043120212,
0.5990296006,
-0.5229797363,
0.357572943,
-0.0518274121,
-0.597401917,
-0.3315387666,
-0.3193508387,
-0.7345856428,
0.0771256015,
-0.0501351319,
-1.1279166937,
-0.3085325658,
0.2045134306,
-0.2940793037,
0.4846708775,
-0.9158300161,
0.9563103914,
-0.0096361293,
-0.1005738452,
0.6929042935,
-0.4525659978,
0.2343892902,
-0.3551431894,
-0.1345165223,
-0.2228241712,
-0.1405323744,
1.1322623491,
-0.1340948492,
0.5513018966,
-0.6263262033,
0.0038623053,
0.4022868276,
0.0467510037,
0.361697644,
0.2548864484,
-0.2955059111,
0.3423667252,
-0.2701480091,
-0.1275654584,
-0.7083312273,
0.467805773,
-0.698055923,
-0.3337192833,
-0.3654889166,
-0.524200201,
-0.1690669507,
0.1889973581,
-0.0363402404,
0.19751513,
0.2000084668,
0.0987800732,
0.115698196,
0.1221641526,
0.5651679635,
0.0577600077,
-0.3892363012,
-0.4842320979,
1.179397583,
0.3129476309,
0.1191338152,
0.2799161971,
0.0943479091,
-0.1657647043,
-0.791570425,
-0.6634615064,
-0.0402319916,
-0.628526032,
-0.3340613544,
-0.6304906607,
-0.0688985661,
0.1682657152,
-0.2310806513,
-0.15617387,
-0.7002620697,
-0.0578454733,
-0.3288446069,
0.7331203818,
1.0990142822,
-0.0002431939,
0.4674402475,
-0.3567093611,
0.4818927348,
0.3869794309,
0.7377153039,
-0.4722194672,
0.1502675116,
-0.292984128,
-0.0686146989,
-0.1455909312,
-0.7217407227,
0.1366174817,
0.1127657443,
0.4162689745,
0.0936526656,
-0.5179269314,
0.3908217847,
-0.105590798,
1.1815779209,
-0.1954996586,
-1.0131509304,
0.7911233902,
-0.6765770316,
0.4466169775,
0.5803182125,
0.4752363563,
-0.4610652328,
-0.4892510772,
-0.4629034698,
-0.9685462117,
0.9054507017,
0.5461151004,
-0.3430161774,
-0.1257433444,
0.511462152,
0.3752575517,
0.2318617851,
-0.9053581953,
-0.0985848978,
-0.6087356806,
-0.0242052786,
-0.1312668324,
-0.0582960732,
0.2242449373,
0.0766923875,
0.7318667173,
-0.317951858,
0.4743934572,
0.0175645407,
0.046514269,
0.2354054898,
0.1562579274,
0.1546365619,
0.5388324261,
-0.7512532473,
0.0609214827,
0.1564546376,
-0.8904133439,
-0.2007898241,
0.5057102442,
-0.2520435154,
0.0438255332,
0.4473119974,
0.7349056005,
-0.3387992978,
0.0932186693,
0.4817551672,
0.0121471267,
-0.1734958291,
0.1970998347,
-0.0113766585,
-0.2011755705,
-0.1580073982,
0.4536641836,
-0.2289310396,
0.3995503485,
-0.2702735066,
0.1586804688,
-0.0099707292,
-0.3226420879,
-0.2296451628,
0.8637107015,
0.0158490334,
-0.0833988488,
0.7482727766,
-0.0939607769,
-0.5985475183,
0.2329029888,
0.5791510344,
0.8636910319,
-0.2516706884,
0.0595369153,
0.3642712235,
0.421902597,
-0.0822739676,
0.368414253,
-0.1040842608,
-0.4039926827,
-0.7610701919,
-0.5041131973,
-0.5806227326,
0.3289072216,
-0.7116684914,
0.2498695105,
-0.1792918742,
-0.2195107043,
0.2695059776,
0.0509014726,
-0.9844146967,
0.6580508351,
0.2304867953,
0.5959937572,
-0.9380827546,
0.8715440035,
0.4634534121,
-0.6419097185,
-0.685570538,
0.0152739948,
-0.0560877062,
-0.5518235564,
0.9016016126,
0.5943112373,
0.0486747399,
-0.1189902946,
-0.3644523025,
-0.6503152847,
1.027933836,
0.2507171333,
-0.2445764244,
0.227979973,
0.6956857443,
0.6047299504,
-0.2897225916,
0.4655331671,
0.7766957879,
0.6235401034,
-0.2326916307,
-0.9240292907,
0.1328023523,
-0.3178094625,
0.3825914562,
0.2974474132,
-0.0597276241,
0.8297525048,
0.2009389997,
-0.2276987582,
-0.1929116249,
0.5021069646,
0.049854096,
-0.0215891059,
0.3903583288,
0.461961329,
0.6862773299,
-0.5744720101,
1.2955647707,
0.0852324888,
0.4605258703,
1.0516064167,
-0.2684057653,
0.8832221627,
0.2743823826,
-0.1993120313,
0.0254702698,
0.5490406156,
-0.2050519288,
0.4091876447,
0.406186372,
-0.0105247721,
0.2299904823,
0.1830009818,
-0.3989189863,
0.2412832826,
0.2948512733,
-0.3056243658,
-0.1924600005,
0.1234852821,
0.22677733,
-0.414078474,
-0.2411201447,
0.9333924055,
-0.3067762554,
-0.3978835344,
0.4550432563,
-0.2870126367,
0.4807266891,
-0.4618620574,
-0.3968318701,
0.0962642655,
-0.0130653204,
-0.4520243108,
-1.2267410755,
0.508677423,
0.2229657024,
0.1573399603,
-0.1122056842,
0.5551425219,
-0.2346230894,
-0.2242485285,
0.0522601306,
0.1686463058,
0.4782548547,
-0.3443526924,
-0.4612143338,
0.3472453058,
-0.1772872061,
-0.3683163822,
-0.0325467661,
0.4449540675,
0.0443103462,
0.4844211936,
0.5274298191,
0.2816873789,
-0.198257491,
0.3609670103,
0.7659341097,
-0.6996038556,
-0.2140100449,
-0.8981617093,
0.4931088686,
-0.1829063743,
-0.4749400616,
0.8191726804,
0.8935745358,
0.9315821528,
0.1183879524,
1.2350939512,
-0.1800284386,
0.7628834248,
-0.6722884178,
0.4329636097,
0.0970427692,
0.1414214075,
-0.5313640833,
-1.2624834776,
-1.049326539,
0.8673245311,
-0.6883192658,
0.2585192025,
0.6872503757,
0.461140424,
0.0515685529,
0.7311553955,
0.1378360242,
-0.0901095271,
0.6410622597,
0.4352964461,
0.7042443156,
-0.5966570973,
0.2905600071,
-0.4769111574,
-0.1727659702,
0.1849326491,
-0.8551451564,
-0.907286644,
-0.7545983791,
-0.3875397742,
-0.050338313,
0.2152826786,
0.5429765582,
0.5729784966,
-0.6805911064,
0.0892355144,
-0.257432133,
-0.3707731068,
-0.3335776925,
-0.1873430163,
0.6756418347,
-0.2936842442,
-0.6585968733,
0.1490428597,
0.1988852024,
0.3361454606,
-0.1522826701,
0.2000293285,
-0.1828370243,
-0.4961330593,
0.3955614865,
-0.0234046709,
-0.4838813841,
-0.6105339527,
-0.6600345969,
0.2332731932,
0.0401048847,
0.7400401831,
-0.7236566544,
0.7098359466,
0.0817048252,
0.6847506166,
0.7992991209,
0.1705879122,
0.6733403802,
-0.7310681343,
-0.0723133758,
0.2833226621,
0.2914641798,
0.760643363,
-0.4433674514,
1.1689707041,
-0.1859435588,
-0.8511939645,
-0.5724149942,
-0.2822245955,
-0.7011855841,
0.3842417002,
1.2684519291,
-0.2166641951,
-0.1360356808,
-0.3562636673,
-0.424759835,
0.2161884457,
-0.4261229932,
0.5667083859,
0.7745696902,
-0.3756970465,
0.1138890758,
-1.3802335262,
0.7991980314,
-0.0518065244,
-1.0661774874,
0.2564192712,
0.2473605722,
-0.1122930422,
0.3233549595,
0.6021304131,
-0.2449296862,
0.175339669,
-0.0754206628,
0.0507783554,
-0.1460887194,
-0.1800110489,
-0.1860118806,
0.2586232424,
0.293633163,
-0.4624282122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10449v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10449v3 | Socratic Pretraining: Question-Driven Pretraining for Controllable Summarization | 2022-12-20T17:27:10 | 2023-06-08T22:43:58 | Artidoro Pagnoni, Alexander R. Fabbri, Wojciech Kryściński, Chien-Sheng Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In long document controllable summarization, where labeled data is scarce,
pretrained models struggle to adapt to the task and effectively respond to user
queries. In this paper, we introduce Socratic pretraining, a question-driven,
unsupervised pretraining objective specifically designed to improve
controllability in summarization tasks. By training a model to generate and
answer relevant questions in a given context, Socratic pretraining enables the
model to more effectively adhere to user-provided queries and identify relevant
content to be summarized. We demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach
through extensive experimentation on two summarization domains, short stories
and dialogue, and multiple control strategies: keywords, questions, and factoid
QA pairs. Our pretraining method relies only on unlabeled documents and a
question generation system and outperforms pre-finetuning approaches that use
additional supervised data. Furthermore, our results show that Socratic
pretraining cuts task-specific labeled data requirements in half, is more
faithful to user-provided queries, and achieves state-of-the-art performance on
QMSum and SQuALITY. | [
-0.3394409716,
-0.3967310488,
0.3479620218,
0.3132461011,
-0.5589530468,
0.4425382912,
-0.0579231866,
-0.0083842566,
0.3012156785,
0.5360628366,
-0.4234903753,
-0.3521625996,
-0.591358304,
-0.1562328935,
-0.2663325369,
1.4666595459,
-0.2999401391,
0.1852550209,
-0.5603536963,
0.0219220147,
-0.0455676876,
-0.9074065089,
-0.4986495376,
-0.3223709464,
0.5591182709,
0.203034237,
0.4678694308,
-0.1436316073,
0.0993635654,
0.2251804024,
0.0136769218,
0.3017952442,
-0.7267560959,
0.2207677364,
-0.0226782374,
-0.7991247177,
-0.4172180295,
0.3386804461,
0.4803092778,
0.688089788,
-0.174720794,
0.2261082232,
0.2737710774,
0.7229694128,
-0.8065501451,
-0.0265769009,
-0.2447906882,
0.1282856613,
0.0120834615,
-0.482509464,
-0.170190528,
-0.8311579823,
-0.123949796,
-0.774808228,
0.3821239769,
-0.0699048489,
0.7220723033,
0.3822180629,
-0.4733968675,
-0.2306876034,
-0.6451154351,
0.325255394,
-0.5575690269,
0.2647728026,
0.5697190762,
0.2264406383,
0.0171092115,
-0.8498122692,
-0.2997584939,
-0.0368009508,
-0.1762887836,
0.6387076974,
0.1635529101,
0.1459271163,
0.1867873222,
0.0130871795,
-0.6185779572,
-0.1474134028,
-0.6076411605,
-0.261038363,
0.7349859476,
0.0446093194,
-0.1763723493,
0.0965488851,
-0.2899026275,
0.1765372008,
-0.6181642413,
0.4736826718,
0.3251331747,
-0.2039630711,
-0.0236193296,
0.4594812393,
-0.3848667443,
0.6051472425,
0.2780003846,
-0.1904024184,
-0.012998187,
-0.4622593522,
0.1370715499,
0.110052824,
0.6749517918,
0.4344874918,
0.4295151532,
-0.457999289,
-0.3005934656,
-0.3279615641,
0.3673334122,
-0.8490386009,
-0.4304813445,
0.2887011766,
0.0557186715,
-0.3678236008,
0.0146104041,
-0.3589321375,
-0.2245847583,
-0.6537433863,
0.6412299275,
-0.2494267076,
0.053522028,
0.0076539172,
-0.3365652859,
0.3093408346,
0.6001123786,
-0.8403632641,
0.3714418411,
0.454919219,
0.8653967977,
-0.2868700325,
-0.2093428969,
-0.6245705485,
0.5001097322,
-0.5265702605,
0.7223829031,
-0.2495308816,
-0.482667774,
-0.3171130717,
-0.0369159319,
-0.3070992231,
-0.4518309236,
-0.3582983315,
-0.693764329,
0.2961559594,
-0.1846048981,
-0.3265806735,
0.3189427555,
0.3613173962,
-0.1869564354,
0.7766252756,
0.2286685109,
-0.9559371471,
0.2977280319,
-0.2174908519,
-0.6225041151,
-0.0884796754,
-0.3965956867,
-0.3803624511,
-0.0097155403,
0.108019881,
0.325997144,
-0.0464646071,
0.4600375295,
0.0725632533,
-0.2948847115,
0.2153710574,
0.0909966305,
0.7749538422,
-0.0251973905,
-0.1499192119,
0.3523489535,
-0.4512118995,
0.2194377184,
-0.0585737452,
-0.3404791951,
-0.314073354,
-0.1507401466,
-0.3832142651,
0.080857195,
0.3255514801,
-0.2623789608,
0.1211359724,
-0.219753474,
0.1760256886,
0.6144175529,
0.3316213787,
0.4384567738,
-0.6037707925,
1.0198622942,
-0.0606812127,
0.2973851264,
0.122074835,
0.2110071927,
-0.6071331501,
0.0324982554,
0.2542800605,
0.6219214201,
-1.1624600887,
0.2406884879,
0.1123767644,
-0.779261291,
-0.2822559476,
0.0809258074,
0.5351135135,
0.5886929631,
0.4036986828,
-0.3926601112,
-0.1080808491,
-0.5372962356,
0.061608959,
-0.0014348608,
-0.2201638222,
0.0448714495,
0.4211446345,
0.2822265923,
0.91298908,
-0.9188992977,
-0.0459402949,
-0.5175076723,
0.6729379892,
-0.1156409308,
0.6729192138,
0.3807318509,
-0.8098534346,
-0.3905882239,
-0.5545673966,
-0.6469091773,
-0.1699752659,
-0.2354341894,
-0.1708598584,
-0.2245269716,
0.9066296816,
-0.5230021477,
0.4678096473,
0.0851470977,
0.1242258623,
0.924829483,
-0.5036634207,
0.0163004342,
-1.0024940968,
0.2177696079,
-0.5487501621,
-0.5005529523,
-0.5025550127,
-0.1669241041,
0.1411749572,
-0.3036887348,
-0.4997965991,
0.1390017569,
-0.5044737458,
-0.1263340861,
-0.1879367828,
0.3356128633,
0.1744851917,
0.6607977152,
0.0857937187,
0.9062296748,
0.2266097367,
-1.0571889877,
0.4154867232,
0.4377765357,
-0.2744785547,
0.3568168283,
-1.0183591843,
0.2692226768,
-0.7798221111,
0.3069728315,
-0.9650586843,
-0.0006846996,
0.0660964623,
-0.4694239199,
0.2736563981,
0.1627051681,
-0.1360916197,
-0.0711846277,
-0.424136579,
0.4030472934,
0.2098009139,
-0.2222517729,
0.3931399882,
0.3351075947,
-0.683221221,
-0.6258851886,
-0.3544047475,
-0.5395742655,
0.0417496823,
-0.0636212602,
0.2096880227,
-0.2773846686,
0.081262894,
-0.4344521463,
-0.3420236409,
-0.0219954047,
0.4169386625,
0.3635084927,
0.1006009951,
0.2468514144,
0.4376579523,
0.5432537198,
-0.1892935336,
0.1664512008,
-0.0091662304,
0.5549427867,
0.1298480928,
0.0693903118,
-0.1368868351,
0.2636381686,
0.1326185912,
-0.9038319588,
0.4998161793,
0.2946381867,
0.0572456643,
-0.2782345414,
-0.164603129,
-0.1615877151,
-0.3977565765,
0.2282450795,
-0.1654818505,
-0.9125071168,
0.3589673638,
-0.3400932252,
0.1954209805,
-0.0865316391,
0.1515631229,
-0.4612149894,
0.9091348648,
0.6986359954,
-0.0657718852,
0.358887732,
-0.4065597355,
-0.0784711018,
-0.6041093469,
-0.3992645741,
-0.6344121695,
-0.2753784955,
-0.170973897,
-0.3036513925,
0.6005519629,
0.4298600554,
-0.2571937442,
-0.0666777566,
-0.2428291887,
0.6025310159,
0.612619698,
0.2423572391,
0.3812616467,
-0.5404758453,
-0.0860821977,
0.2547183037,
-0.7788752913,
-0.3534514308,
0.9866392612,
-0.1983345002,
0.9848360419,
-0.0445039645,
0.8984161615,
0.2067511678,
0.3380407393,
-0.5455368757,
0.4396189153,
0.2654629052,
-0.6386039257,
-0.54011935,
-0.3729070127,
-0.8562384844,
0.3525637388,
-0.3408089876,
-0.5637044907,
0.2142617106,
0.4577074945,
-0.7750362754,
-0.1272653192,
-0.650734961,
0.9458653331,
-0.6698223948,
-0.2438483089,
0.0444131643,
-1.0074934959,
0.1758033484,
-0.3478502035,
-0.0898189172,
-0.0076402947,
-0.2019066811,
0.9855837226,
-0.4040058553,
0.7655316591,
-0.2402922809,
0.2582878172,
0.2293193638,
-0.0805082992,
0.2594823837,
0.2192544788,
0.4241639078,
-0.4886135459,
0.4776180685,
-0.7327671051,
-0.6804202795,
0.052956149,
-0.9169161916,
-0.7045014501,
-0.5403095484,
-0.3861312866,
-0.63680619,
0.3744460642,
0.7495434284,
0.4802752137,
-0.4705035388,
0.1661372483,
1.0167435408,
-0.0827357098,
0.2674545348,
0.7273874283,
-0.4407964945,
-0.2166740447,
0.7145811319,
0.3257017136,
0.4380664825,
0.5179439783,
-0.1911688447,
-0.1297203451,
-0.8053684831,
-0.0726626441,
0.2770664096,
-0.2696882784,
-0.2217749804,
-0.7703729272,
-0.2981455028,
-0.6782622337,
-0.1947751194,
-0.2739669681,
-0.4774880707,
-0.3778328598,
-0.3279873729,
-0.1782924682,
0.4426784217,
0.2087890804,
0.8222157359,
-0.6835393906,
0.6135126948,
0.6886718869,
0.0984049141,
-0.2758201659,
-0.5114939213,
-0.3231807947,
-0.0576895848,
-0.3925612271,
-1.1799952984,
0.3455082774,
0.2112718076,
0.449996829,
0.3787589371,
0.6269764304,
0.2364702076,
-0.1817113906,
0.4128875136,
0.1564117223,
-0.7588466406,
0.7777868509,
-0.0846368894,
0.6327082515,
0.9985046387,
1.1442097425,
-0.2344479561,
-0.5709472895,
-0.4757476747,
-0.7241947055,
0.6719515324,
-0.0586181916,
-0.0892663524,
0.3755632937,
0.4925571084,
0.1458046138,
0.7043527365,
-0.3678897917,
0.0361860096,
-0.4499596059,
-0.0345544219,
-0.7136139274,
-0.0955035463,
-0.2751400769,
-0.2568363547,
0.6824473143,
-0.2705155611,
-0.0753344521,
0.4074952006,
-0.5092799664,
0.1662272364,
0.2958748341,
0.4337396026,
1.084326148,
-0.4930887222,
0.2303351611,
-0.1126417443,
-0.5658608079,
0.2728541493,
0.395568192,
-0.4996842742,
-0.1067376658,
0.0357723944,
0.7329602838,
0.0288368799,
-0.6351528764,
0.6095792055,
-0.2866935134,
-0.4176051319,
-0.4517121315,
0.3752036989,
0.0843180269,
0.1801128387,
0.1873674244,
-0.2630236745,
-0.0155938957,
-0.3467512131,
-0.0021666519,
0.3382403553,
-0.3877125978,
-0.218867138,
0.8318765759,
0.1225930899,
0.1215244085,
0.3427129388,
-0.1759828776,
-0.4990678132,
0.4918774664,
0.4206206799,
0.4240159392,
-0.362801373,
0.7760087848,
0.2179159224,
0.5166771412,
0.1004795954,
0.480322957,
-0.6493945122,
-0.6732417345,
-0.1935308427,
-0.2976112664,
-0.6519581676,
0.0601205416,
-0.9703410268,
-0.1498851329,
-0.8828811049,
-0.125488922,
0.1802473366,
-0.0253943373,
-0.2500632703,
0.5342293382,
-0.5128288865,
0.7011655569,
-0.9209995866,
0.6032851934,
0.7833720446,
-0.6076186895,
-0.9032862782,
-0.2957582474,
-0.338555932,
-0.4937593937,
0.2877214253,
-0.0433367789,
-0.1357192099,
0.2159388363,
-0.9947521687,
-0.6418915987,
1.2731717825,
0.2815265059,
-0.3988099098,
-0.2471325547,
0.0254958887,
0.4746948779,
-0.0513007455,
0.1102601662,
0.5226442814,
0.1052760482,
0.1997896284,
-0.6819986105,
-0.0722709447,
-0.2859729826,
-0.3839260936,
0.2832775414,
-0.8293660283,
0.6223964691,
-0.3981699347,
0.0307257771,
-0.1743624508,
0.8562171459,
0.113367103,
0.7007718682,
0.3352023661,
0.2084024996,
1.0987759829,
-0.1390445977,
0.762676537,
-0.2478947043,
-0.0973874331,
1.6120369434,
-0.1882881969,
0.5277974606,
0.2727930546,
-0.0543288626,
0.0214429386,
0.6818305254,
0.3506992757,
0.5721715093,
0.1647754014,
-0.3449428678,
-0.4106222391,
-0.149677664,
-0.5986542702,
0.2909061611,
0.0502320863,
-0.0936621353,
-0.0304392111,
0.0974464864,
0.1861949265,
0.0144016705,
-0.5175911188,
1.0199738741,
0.0005583006,
-0.8574709296,
0.5828408003,
-0.236913383,
0.2944663763,
-0.9284786582,
0.4132967889,
-0.6749604344,
-0.1311845183,
-0.1378007978,
-0.2084639072,
-0.0280319545,
0.0474409126,
0.0650701523,
-0.3041966259,
0.6807761192,
-0.6161054373,
-0.0887970701,
-0.2810200751,
0.6603563428,
0.3709247708,
-0.277702868,
-0.3414573669,
-0.6976790428,
0.1192820445,
-0.176760748,
0.5116097331,
0.3617678881,
-0.0733876452,
0.5985317826,
0.3957839906,
0.1671377271,
0.0375906378,
-0.0320181474,
1.2750607729,
-0.6721547246,
-0.8976067305,
-0.0807361603,
0.2931498587,
-0.0951251313,
-0.382022202,
0.6150248051,
0.7435393333,
0.8913369775,
-0.1205774173,
0.8150534034,
0.2912965417,
0.5590229034,
-0.5419525504,
0.9347185493,
-0.4228955805,
-0.1356336772,
0.0003457051,
-0.8841446042,
0.1164060757,
0.3454053998,
-0.5528740883,
0.0259895101,
0.5874246359,
0.6828485131,
0.3023681641,
-0.1492189169,
0.1239695325,
-0.0535762198,
0.3393449187,
0.5067772269,
0.9118129015,
0.0855643228,
0.4210361838,
-0.3245227635,
-0.5104116201,
0.0776398927,
-0.6113010645,
-1.0968726873,
-0.3906927109,
-0.2617158592,
-0.1522420794,
0.3583330512,
0.7613597512,
0.5240351558,
-0.6332473755,
-0.2068724036,
0.0672334656,
0.1830136031,
0.0566602796,
-0.0858048573,
0.2818960845,
-0.3664538264,
-0.2203911096,
0.1604704261,
0.0376221649,
0.6230382919,
0.0087257698,
-0.0219317228,
-0.2753047049,
0.0817367733,
0.4371196926,
0.6042174697,
0.2336003631,
0.2776117027,
-0.1024327651,
-0.1395587027,
-0.1637041122,
1.0929116011,
-0.5928935409,
0.4539970458,
0.4452871382,
0.4774000347,
1.0147535801,
0.6437404156,
0.5664907098,
-0.9013457298,
0.2403031737,
0.5330966115,
-0.2429528683,
0.0413455889,
-0.1536854804,
0.3515758812,
0.0150731029,
-0.5942800641,
-0.3142545819,
0.0384457819,
-0.9721805453,
-0.4240598679,
0.6752602458,
-0.2757738829,
-0.1546224505,
-0.358296752,
-0.4339416623,
0.5037917495,
-0.0932295248,
0.8095517159,
0.4296224117,
-0.1451585889,
-0.2283492386,
-0.2430696338,
0.7945768833,
0.5635391474,
-1.056373477,
-0.093257226,
0.6595598459,
0.0806510299,
0.0112177189,
1.2100071907,
-0.0156142348,
0.2751805186,
-0.378349483,
0.0879935101,
-0.4134942889,
-0.5808302164,
-0.0518490002,
0.3784186244,
0.1383346468,
-0.1782884151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10448v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10448v1 | Parameter-efficient Zero-shot Transfer for Cross-Language Dense Retrieval with Adapters | 2022-12-20T17:25:04 | 2022-12-20T17:25:04 | Eugene Yang, Suraj Nair, Dawn Lawrie, James Mayfield, Douglas W. Oard | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | A popular approach to creating a zero-shot cross-language retrieval model is
to substitute a monolingual pretrained language model in the retrieval model
with a multilingual pretrained language model such as Multilingual BERT. This
multilingual model is fined-tuned to the retrieval task with monolingual data
such as English MS MARCO using the same training recipe as the monolingual
retrieval model used. However, such transferred models suffer from mismatches
in the languages of the input text during training and inference. In this work,
we propose transferring monolingual retrieval models using adapters, a
parameter-efficient component for a transformer network. By adding adapters
pretrained on language tasks for a specific language with task-specific
adapters, prior work has shown that the adapter-enhanced models perform better
than fine-tuning the entire model when transferring across languages in various
NLP tasks. By constructing dense retrieval models with adapters, we show that
models trained with monolingual data are more effective than fine-tuning the
entire model when transferring to a Cross Language Information Retrieval (CLIR)
setting. However, we found that the prior suggestion of replacing the language
adapters to match the target language at inference time is suboptimal for dense
retrieval models. We provide an in-depth analysis of this discrepancy between
other cross-language NLP tasks and CLIR. | [
-0.3566356599,
-0.365208745,
0.3622567356,
0.1803607196,
-0.2983243465,
-0.4465887547,
-0.3827229142,
-0.5383020043,
0.1520274132,
0.482886374,
-0.2615428567,
-0.0288143009,
-0.5651313066,
0.0451417789,
-0.3437473178,
0.9855747819,
-0.1159092486,
-0.0797571465,
0.1463753283,
-0.3563188612,
-0.4116021097,
-0.3509354889,
-0.6976941824,
-0.2750523984,
0.7816044092,
0.4502313137,
0.6670812368,
0.3088828623,
0.4630512297,
0.1945146918,
0.1631983966,
-0.253806442,
-0.675165236,
0.0853603855,
-0.5643542409,
-0.4861897528,
-0.1155084074,
-0.372705847,
0.6117514968,
0.7939564586,
0.073933512,
0.2809710205,
0.0067770323,
0.5665402412,
-0.9613224268,
-0.0606869496,
-0.8655741811,
0.2165674865,
-0.0530970357,
-0.2609814107,
-0.7754483223,
-0.0362670645,
0.2949628532,
-0.5384065509,
0.3758906424,
-0.1801163107,
0.8856694698,
0.072609663,
-0.2932081223,
-0.0216211751,
-1.0582154989,
0.9615502954,
-0.6721816659,
0.5263160467,
0.1220060065,
0.4984891415,
0.2554702461,
-0.5731389523,
-0.5585286617,
-0.0279549193,
-0.409045428,
0.077330485,
-0.2362970263,
-0.0872890204,
0.0863256827,
-0.0984778851,
-0.6316173077,
0.109435156,
-0.4736453593,
-0.069790706,
0.6113562584,
-0.1383327395,
0.1178784519,
-0.0209784899,
-0.3683283925,
-0.1967485696,
-0.3994222581,
-0.0408003889,
0.1968505532,
0.6671698093,
0.0707891509,
0.378469348,
-0.2168666422,
0.9762547016,
0.1223978698,
0.0027228538,
0.0814097598,
-0.6523134112,
0.0012240099,
0.0962048844,
0.6125773191,
0.1261313409,
0.5554830432,
-0.4877631664,
-0.0906728208,
-0.4130194783,
0.3684954643,
-1.0680733919,
-0.1256041825,
-0.1613751501,
-0.5149596334,
0.1380522549,
-0.1198519468,
-0.6677033901,
0.3202083707,
-0.0995780677,
0.8761163354,
-0.4762827158,
-0.077647455,
0.3759708405,
-0.2178895175,
0.5419551134,
0.2378663123,
-0.9053765535,
0.0400588103,
0.0231146384,
0.6834053993,
-0.1583913714,
-0.407697916,
-0.4255257249,
0.2293701172,
-0.1387131661,
0.8383489847,
-0.6466104984,
-0.1892916411,
0.0229444914,
0.2712782621,
-0.4608063698,
-0.3505019546,
0.4969037771,
-0.6473622918,
0.0804458037,
-0.3326210976,
-0.3706492782,
-0.3518245816,
0.180580765,
-0.6123566628,
0.8205970526,
0.1034954786,
-0.5347710848,
0.3443057239,
-0.3412725329,
-0.5913726687,
0.0253889263,
0.0380844846,
-0.1333111674,
-0.0514503159,
0.3028356433,
0.4670675695,
-0.2404070348,
-0.0776230842,
-0.4250059128,
-0.6091918945,
-0.2753471136,
-0.5618872046,
0.6749869585,
0.1951332986,
-0.1380908787,
-0.2379488498,
-0.6914733052,
0.0357115231,
0.1328942776,
-0.3154406548,
-0.609382391,
-0.1066458449,
0.2457638681,
0.280259192,
0.2590293884,
-0.6266844869,
0.1549117267,
-0.1552557945,
0.0756667107,
0.3060561419,
-0.1684020162,
0.8296017051,
-0.3429462612,
0.4982492626,
0.0273302663,
0.1203159913,
-0.2625691593,
-0.1963009387,
-0.7865024209,
-0.1369808912,
0.3993290365,
0.7157010436,
-0.9782332182,
0.2834058702,
-0.4765906632,
-0.7998546362,
-0.7727710605,
0.1094802991,
0.2900676727,
0.7253429294,
0.593164742,
-0.0576201081,
-0.4058488011,
-1.0046513081,
-0.4623472989,
0.1189429536,
0.0472198091,
0.3698211312,
0.3477374315,
0.0715391859,
0.6480768323,
-0.3705865443,
-0.2055856138,
-0.6071081758,
0.017179694,
0.3702314496,
0.5441779494,
1.051930666,
-0.6256303191,
-1.0546834469,
0.3586797416,
-0.6093007922,
0.0311957542,
-0.255795747,
-0.261983484,
-0.0654990822,
0.3616149127,
-0.4150730371,
0.3367075324,
0.5047265887,
-0.1611635536,
0.4380884469,
-0.3139345944,
0.1961978823,
-1.0710065365,
0.4302548468,
-0.1776819825,
-0.4169782996,
-0.8640466332,
-0.0333964862,
0.1142234802,
-0.0047615324,
-0.7554304004,
0.8003771901,
-0.5003650784,
0.0441791415,
-0.2010297179,
0.1028215736,
0.0536638126,
0.4179383218,
0.1240254268,
0.7623983622,
0.7303749919,
-0.6409803629,
0.0415348858,
0.3095335066,
-0.0771685466,
0.7571226954,
-0.7261911631,
0.1322891265,
-0.3875656426,
0.077268973,
-0.810110867,
0.4154661596,
-0.0034429438,
-0.0955459699,
0.3438750207,
-0.4307592809,
-0.2196613401,
-0.1041273102,
-0.149415046,
0.7603953481,
0.330424279,
-0.5996027589,
0.6466358304,
0.0191994887,
-0.137307927,
-0.7905803323,
-0.8459476829,
-0.0923392698,
-0.061102096,
-0.5166451931,
0.3828176558,
-0.2156422138,
0.3872517645,
0.0493791513,
-0.1440454125,
-0.3310541213,
-0.1691548377,
-0.4663410187,
0.2598282099,
-0.4582332075,
-0.13844271,
0.2500887215,
-0.0775020123,
-0.3454287648,
-0.2316035181,
0.41208902,
0.1562963873,
-0.3951986134,
-0.1573685408,
0.4654779732,
0.3953996301,
-0.1631391943,
1.0017259121,
0.7546076775,
-0.0914104804,
-0.155112341,
-0.6800630689,
-0.2530106604,
-0.3914993405,
0.3585088849,
-0.7072220445,
-0.78053689,
0.6480090022,
0.3598260581,
0.0392391942,
0.3060502112,
0.220232144,
0.1039844528,
0.8737286329,
0.7022541761,
-0.2066897452,
0.7212451696,
-0.0917855278,
0.206853494,
-0.6620836854,
0.017983349,
-0.7297260761,
-0.6014697552,
-0.4515897632,
-0.360796243,
0.1923896372,
0.1090652049,
-0.0313132554,
0.900788784,
-0.3656271398,
0.5224760175,
0.5547577739,
0.1862033159,
0.314997524,
0.1295372993,
-0.0336628594,
-0.1019051149,
-1.0306714773,
-0.0102337366,
1.0292755365,
-0.1299439669,
0.8599942327,
0.1722193062,
0.5031241775,
-0.1046306267,
0.1357394904,
-0.7169880271,
0.4022303522,
-0.648452282,
-0.7143079042,
-0.2140146196,
-0.5033013821,
-1.1064783335,
0.5498277545,
-0.2699535787,
-0.7547065616,
0.7340052128,
-0.0725259185,
-0.1622717381,
0.3933621049,
-0.6552367806,
0.9728187919,
-0.1235632673,
-0.3280444741,
-0.2237813473,
-0.6951937675,
0.0848427713,
-0.2691992521,
-0.1167995855,
0.0063038091,
0.1116603166,
0.5270235538,
-0.1257902682,
0.4234741628,
-0.2903618217,
0.1378341764,
0.1168079451,
0.306188941,
0.4893519878,
-0.1799260825,
-0.5215579867,
0.2579958141,
0.1663597226,
-0.6528394818,
-0.6869713664,
0.5575276613,
-0.7082198262,
-0.3264341354,
-0.0098777227,
-0.8109017611,
-0.0043809568,
0.5750407577,
0.2479331642,
0.2078607082,
-0.040121749,
0.5149032474,
0.6257796884,
-0.127178371,
0.6641956568,
1.0726610422,
0.0231294073,
0.0793919563,
0.8319891691,
0.3207512796,
0.4180730581,
0.7889801264,
-0.0328327566,
-0.1222440526,
-0.4925799072,
-0.5406964421,
0.355617255,
-0.597032249,
-0.2335323244,
-0.6452191472,
-0.4079301357,
-0.2548297644,
-0.383289665,
-0.5997985005,
-0.3328068852,
-0.2736756206,
0.2014783919,
0.1748113781,
0.1824739277,
0.0290296357,
0.3892026842,
-0.971028924,
0.3452670276,
0.1293820739,
0.3719609976,
-0.0891521797,
-1.1100250483,
-0.336736083,
-0.0427852646,
0.0551012754,
-0.8346347213,
0.3440015912,
0.5374931693,
0.6994524002,
0.1955462098,
0.1799074709,
1.0749769211,
-0.6308894157,
0.3954862654,
-0.0168174207,
-0.7777599692,
0.4427904189,
-0.0084818099,
0.5094622374,
0.9870429039,
0.6630151868,
-0.3895533979,
-0.0491032414,
-0.1747969389,
-0.7415598035,
1.0185527802,
0.0221739747,
0.3983449638,
0.0371961594,
0.4945337176,
0.264052242,
-0.0890148059,
-0.7893818617,
-0.2617253363,
-0.1261459142,
-0.0628279597,
-0.1332380772,
0.0116049936,
0.1966950297,
-0.3618428707,
0.6150023341,
-0.390835911,
0.1320082098,
0.4194391966,
-0.4736663401,
-0.2168128341,
0.3556978405,
0.3497439027,
0.4644570947,
-0.2756906152,
0.0718722939,
0.3868183494,
-0.2034908533,
0.1263837665,
0.3526878357,
-0.4382022023,
0.3253883421,
0.1719277799,
1.0170031786,
0.4438545406,
-0.5504744649,
0.6066681147,
-0.0587030686,
-0.1725364923,
-0.0035665098,
-0.1209035441,
-0.1827651411,
0.1904869974,
0.2890937626,
0.2207616866,
0.2953821421,
-0.357380718,
0.3346408606,
0.7183423638,
-0.5063840151,
-0.4887688756,
0.5462885499,
-0.1153899878,
-0.1368728429,
0.646622777,
0.0825258046,
-0.1178614646,
0.2067319304,
0.8407281637,
0.7549104691,
-0.4035675824,
0.1759758592,
0.491542995,
0.6125866771,
-0.0994258821,
0.1160388589,
-0.285925597,
-0.861448586,
-0.5472341776,
-0.605091095,
-0.1941594332,
-0.0660812408,
-0.8307796717,
0.4802263081,
0.0438164361,
0.065543972,
-0.0924727917,
-0.415407151,
-0.9578416348,
0.026329523,
0.1233147979,
1.1078342199,
-0.7937776446,
1.0429340601,
0.6239714026,
-0.5684930086,
-0.8864474297,
-0.2665049136,
-0.7452880144,
-0.8727886081,
0.581214726,
-0.1604602933,
0.0445533991,
0.0403402746,
-0.0714668632,
-1.0222475529,
0.9630678892,
0.7870861292,
-0.6068313718,
-0.3329710066,
0.326364696,
0.5879990458,
-0.1605467796,
0.7760427594,
0.3443322778,
0.4652671814,
0.246719569,
-1.0866924524,
0.2722887993,
-0.0741690546,
0.1842832714,
0.2002800107,
-0.4856130779,
0.7795835137,
0.0144314384,
-0.0981577858,
0.0018774598,
0.5214544535,
-0.2468311042,
-0.0430747122,
0.553209722,
0.526132226,
0.1219820604,
0.277325362,
0.9954616427,
-0.5800572038,
0.5085580945,
1.0307165384,
-0.2891898453,
1.1620931625,
0.5694020987,
-0.0361683518,
0.4087171257,
-0.038965255,
0.0277626086,
0.5111531615,
-0.2201485187,
-0.162956804,
-0.282656461,
0.0345263444,
-0.3044966161,
0.4665288031,
0.0426855236,
-0.4176331758,
-0.7084563375,
0.0994665995,
-0.0156415813,
-0.2131132931,
-0.065144375,
0.8049132228,
-0.1368829459,
-0.8243172765,
0.7529703975,
-0.1373412311,
0.734490335,
-0.8293146491,
0.0886405185,
-0.4433708191,
0.1763685495,
-0.2439650297,
-0.7071304321,
0.6219580173,
-0.2008646131,
-0.3528608382,
-0.3120894134,
0.8702843785,
-0.7902596593,
-0.6353338957,
0.6445406079,
0.5950010419,
0.2296164185,
-0.2351431251,
-0.7729964852,
-0.2088738978,
0.0127656385,
-0.2600516677,
0.5495513082,
0.3067246974,
0.1807979792,
0.4664588273,
0.6401088238,
0.1485614032,
0.3049894571,
0.1892871857,
0.6647039056,
-0.531344831,
-0.1525856107,
-0.6125551462,
0.5117083788,
0.2085257769,
-0.1048017964,
0.7234520316,
0.4604568779,
0.9041983485,
-0.2577238977,
0.657199502,
-0.1521006227,
0.3434657156,
-0.2596382797,
0.7494730949,
-0.7539557219,
0.0643647686,
-0.0863535553,
-1.2179763317,
-0.2947607338,
0.6104606986,
-0.1800220311,
0.0669493377,
0.51516819,
0.8213533163,
-0.532526195,
-0.3884545267,
0.6627107859,
0.0637265667,
0.1904286742,
0.6404436827,
0.2055981308,
-0.8972960711,
0.994823277,
-0.4376807511,
-0.0624913201,
-0.283377558,
-0.7613576651,
-0.7076627016,
-0.3861468136,
-0.1627024263,
-0.0331383571,
0.2038743198,
0.5272687078,
0.9117617011,
-0.9039939046,
-0.3801799715,
0.0539593883,
-0.0027580056,
-0.2007151246,
-0.326744169,
0.0103141963,
-0.65601331,
-0.8067738414,
0.5437650084,
0.2251928151,
-0.2622775137,
-0.0877595171,
0.1280902624,
-0.5908452272,
0.281793505,
0.7007448673,
0.4709405601,
-0.4565090239,
-0.4722968936,
0.2477323264,
-0.0362654403,
0.1431446075,
0.7198591232,
-0.8579076529,
0.7065566182,
0.6522544026,
0.8924421668,
0.8134883642,
-0.282833308,
0.6172248721,
-0.7490822673,
0.3028980494,
0.178962186,
0.4564996958,
0.2143980265,
-0.1870577633,
0.2839652896,
0.1605953425,
-0.4888942242,
-0.6609302759,
0.0435634777,
-1.0776872635,
-0.2914576828,
0.9616443515,
-0.2791445255,
-0.0993307009,
-0.0348720849,
-0.0663104951,
0.2045390904,
-0.17525132,
0.5723699331,
0.4672895968,
0.0500487015,
-0.3327669203,
-0.4448301494,
0.0620503575,
0.8705488443,
-0.5300081372,
-0.2877577245,
-0.0464437865,
0.4491095245,
0.2350181341,
0.5530959368,
-0.0212435313,
0.173643589,
-0.078962028,
0.2229236364,
0.2851337194,
-0.2655612528,
-0.3391759992,
0.1212176234,
-0.0660893396,
-0.1268422604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10440v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10440v1 | Perplexed by Quality: A Perplexity-based Method for Adult and Harmful Content Detection in Multilingual Heterogeneous Web Data | 2022-12-20T17:14:45 | 2022-12-20T17:14:45 | Tim Jansen, Yangling Tong, Victoria Zevallos, Pedro Ortiz Suarez | cs.CL | cs.CL | As demand for large corpora increases with the size of current
state-of-the-art language models, using web data as the main part of the
pre-training corpus for these models has become a ubiquitous practice. This, in
turn, has introduced an important challenge for NLP practitioners, as they are
now confronted with the task of developing highly optimized models and
pipelines for pre-processing large quantities of textual data, which implies,
effectively classifying and filtering multilingual, heterogeneous and noisy
data, at web scale. One of the main components of this pre-processing step for
the pre-training corpora of large language models, is the removal of adult and
harmful content. In this paper we explore different methods for detecting adult
and harmful of content in multilingual heterogeneous web data. We first show
how traditional methods in harmful content detection, that seemingly perform
quite well in small and specialized datasets quickly break down when confronted
with heterogeneous noisy web data. We then resort to using a perplexity based
approach but with a twist: Instead of using a so-called "clean" corpus to train
a small language model and then use perplexity so select the documents with low
perplexity, i.e., the documents that resemble this so-called "clean" corpus the
most. We train solely with adult and harmful textual data, and then select the
documents having a perplexity value above a given threshold. This approach will
virtually cluster our documents into two distinct groups, which will greatly
facilitate the choice of the threshold for the perplexity and will also allow
us to obtain higher precision than with the traditional classification methods
for detecting adult and harmful content. | [
-0.5251289606,
-0.8306240439,
0.1154914051,
0.1085823253,
-0.2803305089,
0.0588471852,
-0.2086418122,
-0.5897479653,
-0.1901216209,
0.6227943301,
-0.6368280053,
-0.8524142504,
-0.4442636073,
0.1811059713,
-0.5661839247,
1.0558707714,
0.2410116941,
0.0834992826,
-0.1330460459,
-0.0358168334,
0.0428798944,
-0.8741170764,
-0.5002449155,
-0.0261834338,
0.6146696806,
0.5859280229,
0.8985823989,
0.6348333359,
0.6941107512,
0.2968291342,
-0.072534278,
0.0522857308,
-0.8202614188,
0.2469291538,
-0.3590423465,
-0.6158595681,
-0.2380387783,
0.0344850235,
0.3987519145,
0.9386996627,
0.0273000784,
0.0840604305,
0.0066114538,
0.4992682934,
-0.8525082469,
-0.5685393214,
-0.6820955873,
0.5516918302,
-0.3374578357,
-0.4137296677,
-0.2420053631,
-0.0910954922,
-0.1410315484,
-0.6352443695,
0.3440771103,
0.0258413162,
0.9542754889,
0.0909192413,
-0.4425949156,
-0.4758740366,
-0.9305695295,
0.9007251859,
-0.8034728169,
0.5496650338,
0.7575898767,
-0.0972732678,
-0.100390926,
-0.658727169,
-0.8164545894,
-0.0972184613,
0.0538754165,
-0.0202123094,
-0.368598789,
-0.3071731925,
0.2643681467,
0.4384236038,
-0.8307655454,
0.6170791388,
-0.1873087585,
-0.3510665596,
0.6525400281,
-0.0377007872,
0.5277004242,
-0.1723073423,
-0.6367419362,
-0.0388107896,
-0.9936202168,
0.0783048496,
1.072458148,
0.2783240378,
0.2404719144,
0.4712097943,
-0.2744212449,
0.2060901821,
-0.0023241669,
-0.2764742076,
0.3978560567,
-0.2721129656,
0.2097509652,
-0.174092859,
0.7695455551,
0.1211281717,
0.1048436016,
-0.0954588354,
-0.4444371164,
0.0485082082,
0.4872182012,
-0.6450537443,
-0.2913374901,
0.4777500331,
-0.6630935073,
-0.2659176588,
-0.284558624,
-0.8301627636,
-0.4080433846,
-0.2422192693,
0.3276184201,
-0.6261050701,
-0.4600355923,
0.1334930062,
0.2367980927,
-0.1051300839,
0.3922350407,
-0.8586027622,
0.139518857,
0.6554433107,
0.2211569101,
-0.3586015403,
-0.1658292115,
-0.4330473244,
-0.0493453108,
-0.2550383806,
0.8347018361,
-0.6400855184,
-0.1746937186,
0.2798404992,
-0.0994677618,
0.4110580385,
-0.7442390323,
1.0462851524,
-0.5959891677,
0.3574823141,
-0.0596363209,
-0.3684192896,
-0.2384443134,
0.4108238518,
-0.6092943549,
0.5554913282,
-0.015903892,
-0.9292228222,
0.4294762015,
-0.4352695644,
-0.5161738992,
0.0945076719,
0.187243551,
-0.4339160621,
-0.1691509485,
0.0292769056,
0.3391669691,
0.0374128558,
-0.0786257908,
-0.4998286664,
-0.3520908654,
0.3884909451,
-0.8249562979,
0.8809999824,
0.6814056635,
-0.1351406872,
0.2880257666,
-0.8161513209,
-0.0807704255,
0.072485514,
-0.4069908559,
-0.6720075607,
0.1449982971,
0.2256785482,
0.3688784242,
0.150718987,
-0.4094375074,
-0.1685532779,
-0.2631477714,
0.209336549,
0.5198007226,
-0.0805643648,
0.159015581,
-0.350266695,
0.5470112562,
0.1122765988,
0.5173722506,
0.0528256483,
-0.3476932049,
-0.531671226,
-0.20859088,
0.1636478007,
0.6987116933,
-0.8356186748,
0.6498941183,
-0.2237917781,
-0.3543801606,
-0.403821528,
0.1894144565,
0.5283923745,
0.2879648805,
0.6129347682,
-0.5212917328,
-0.3108869195,
-0.8020040989,
-0.2032797188,
-0.0919553041,
-0.2710423172,
-0.2356826514,
0.4412904382,
-0.3764747679,
0.5461460352,
-0.3339265883,
-0.3521453738,
0.1129901111,
0.2294792533,
-0.0274455529,
0.8251118064,
0.1738371998,
-1.354861021,
-0.395029515,
-0.1394587308,
-0.7297136784,
-0.086724773,
0.113456808,
0.0953652859,
0.0451372564,
0.5591853261,
-0.1356723756,
0.3620187044,
0.4188264012,
-0.2599959671,
1.053828001,
-0.1585967243,
0.2620441318,
-0.7036727667,
0.0872571021,
-0.002615605,
-0.1531015933,
-0.9111127257,
0.533845365,
-0.1879058182,
-0.0280884057,
-0.6105683446,
-0.0100678587,
-0.4835379422,
0.376005888,
-0.1090428382,
-0.0353383683,
-0.1031473428,
0.4137140512,
-0.0771346539,
0.5915435553,
0.1541509479,
-0.3981550038,
0.2727012038,
0.3036191761,
-0.1506307125,
0.7840250134,
-0.0446026139,
0.1641058326,
-0.1869392991,
-0.0617376044,
-0.8634200096,
-0.1118704826,
0.252160579,
-0.5541430712,
0.2928560078,
-0.0710074529,
-0.6642000079,
-0.2388176918,
-0.6209326982,
0.5124557614,
0.2008080781,
-0.4022480249,
0.2057939172,
0.5404227972,
-0.2955695987,
-0.9144756198,
-0.7346214056,
0.1699266881,
-0.4389478266,
-0.6343672276,
0.3750149012,
-0.108599633,
-0.1443388164,
0.2140104175,
-0.2882383168,
-0.4800697267,
0.3594870269,
0.1651845276,
0.0688522011,
-0.2462754697,
0.2095686644,
0.2263961732,
-0.0512857251,
0.0821776912,
0.0895572975,
0.7296817899,
-0.1658620387,
-0.552586019,
-0.3702059686,
0.713866055,
0.1932309568,
-0.3746780455,
0.5849637389,
0.9274801016,
-0.5674673915,
-0.2243948132,
-0.5976158381,
-0.1595911086,
-0.4885585308,
0.3008844256,
-0.4577044547,
-0.9228414297,
0.6050503254,
-0.0266218986,
-0.0630128831,
0.4112667739,
0.2412497252,
-0.2999612391,
0.92233181,
0.4419525862,
0.2356436849,
0.3821901679,
-0.1938112825,
0.3840944469,
-0.6192231178,
-0.1983052343,
-0.7653316259,
-0.0952601507,
-0.7178071737,
-0.200484708,
0.3179605901,
0.3454146981,
-0.2912773788,
0.1701516807,
-0.4674539566,
0.224821046,
0.5479891896,
0.2021408081,
0.7492084503,
0.218981728,
-0.1178168431,
-0.1130789071,
-0.6244927645,
-0.8160666227,
1.1275464296,
0.4180012643,
0.6381912231,
0.408487469,
0.5226137042,
0.3496621251,
0.3168169856,
-0.4351189435,
0.4775958359,
-0.6662129164,
-0.8985340595,
-0.5024870038,
-0.51116997,
-1.3533159494,
0.3446297944,
-0.7836952806,
-0.7805448174,
0.3894273341,
0.0488259569,
-0.3062827289,
0.4948290884,
-0.6362736225,
0.7920603752,
-0.0727276132,
-0.6882192492,
-0.4023471177,
-0.7814189196,
0.4986669719,
-0.2723058462,
0.4908655584,
0.0211687498,
-0.1411418915,
0.5498595834,
-0.3160228133,
0.6633696556,
0.0303462781,
-0.3807183504,
0.1070238128,
0.1859734803,
0.1868041754,
0.0505836681,
-0.055359181,
0.2534448504,
0.0906128064,
-0.5024103522,
-0.2425749898,
0.630137682,
-0.7878845334,
-0.6699991226,
-0.2981615663,
-0.3139434755,
-0.3520005047,
0.3687399328,
0.4430498481,
0.282199502,
0.0188532826,
0.3618867099,
0.8808732629,
-0.7017320991,
0.229970336,
0.5081836581,
-0.1879367083,
-0.1105797216,
1.2034537792,
0.1053584889,
0.2848992944,
0.4857734144,
0.0744285509,
-0.39477548,
-1.1789820194,
-0.1564948708,
0.0762734711,
-0.9194666147,
-0.0491787158,
-0.8320527673,
-0.2030200511,
-0.5056519508,
0.1403204054,
-0.2586125433,
-0.0258858074,
-0.3576608002,
0.1616141051,
-0.3313440382,
0.3049418926,
-0.1928119063,
0.1081092134,
-0.9388725162,
0.432756573,
0.1888948679,
0.4370215833,
-0.1045059413,
-0.3186971545,
-0.04384619,
0.0787252262,
-0.3704650104,
-0.8679035306,
0.4117181897,
-0.0994289815,
0.6348955035,
0.7454352379,
0.370077461,
0.2646074593,
-0.1483078748,
0.6798964143,
0.1676282436,
-0.7953346372,
0.2494565099,
-0.4615260363,
-0.0326913148,
0.7339829206,
0.9601662159,
-0.6157323122,
-0.4483399093,
-0.5484646559,
-1.1174715757,
0.3306171894,
0.296145916,
0.2172691375,
0.2631655931,
0.0844402313,
0.5895887017,
0.3970638216,
-0.7469379902,
-0.2074868232,
-0.3353328407,
-0.0376009047,
0.1649959832,
-0.3930044472,
-0.0439037606,
-0.0367467478,
0.62548244,
0.1258630604,
0.1268203408,
0.1840438247,
-0.3768158853,
-0.1183601245,
0.4720962644,
0.4690693915,
0.5806396604,
-0.2497338951,
0.4530962408,
-0.1246608719,
-0.775196135,
0.2696736455,
0.101006642,
-0.2256859392,
-0.3315885961,
0.645642221,
0.4338216782,
-0.07330814,
-0.7326167226,
0.5469155312,
0.0873010531,
0.007124641,
-0.2981584668,
0.0114228185,
-0.1674430072,
-0.1359674782,
0.6346564293,
0.0844346285,
0.4825171232,
-0.7166932821,
0.4093534052,
0.1857116669,
-0.2914792001,
-0.2739399076,
0.4168392122,
0.1865765601,
-0.2564401031,
0.7322371602,
-0.5819612741,
-0.5990796685,
0.2718828022,
0.4552813768,
0.5145472288,
-0.3290728927,
0.2815326452,
0.2079659849,
0.3000943065,
0.1128670052,
0.2005547434,
0.2680953443,
-1.1491924524,
-0.461848855,
-0.6327437162,
-0.2347443402,
0.5397472382,
-0.5738999248,
0.0621643364,
-0.4391896725,
-0.0825139731,
0.2054049224,
0.1213141829,
-0.5568372607,
0.4726291895,
0.156745255,
0.5520970821,
-0.8517730832,
0.6028023362,
0.439340055,
-0.5737344027,
-0.6362069249,
0.3295073807,
0.1824726462,
-0.3127969801,
0.3621116281,
0.0356719829,
-0.0245873053,
-0.0941320136,
-0.4896980822,
-0.5596792698,
0.2039381266,
0.2702293098,
-0.4010612071,
0.0295558348,
0.2668549716,
0.7062581778,
-0.0064912038,
0.0040433719,
0.2048570067,
0.5970644355,
-0.19193995,
-0.5610679388,
0.1099659652,
-0.6054334044,
-0.2408946604,
-0.0655000284,
-0.2206604183,
1.1045583487,
0.160383746,
-0.4756139517,
-0.1570908278,
0.4666282237,
-0.0007025647,
0.3955768049,
0.9221463799,
0.3873094618,
0.784168601,
0.0471544266,
0.8349334598,
0.0138138942,
0.2706480622,
1.0072543621,
-0.2997567356,
0.8199530244,
0.3595237434,
-0.3713989556,
0.530659616,
0.6589833498,
-0.0163551513,
0.2044520676,
0.4548984766,
-0.3051864207,
-0.2086024582,
-0.1189179346,
-0.2424507588,
0.446965754,
0.3914252818,
0.171801582,
-0.2697898746,
0.3869920373,
0.1652968973,
0.6300583482,
-0.1049063057,
0.6602836251,
-0.1158025414,
-0.5044891238,
0.7554594278,
0.1874991953,
0.9976966977,
-0.4962289631,
0.0685035288,
-0.1628791541,
0.0853499696,
-0.6116697788,
-0.8014753461,
0.5775285363,
0.0183785297,
-0.0474262796,
-0.2502286732,
0.8808941245,
-0.4690951407,
-0.1617471129,
0.3292855918,
0.5888294578,
0.3242736757,
-0.3925653696,
-0.6428275108,
-0.035737928,
-0.0361856371,
-0.147883147,
0.375303328,
0.5703343153,
-0.3033186793,
0.7637172341,
1.1427475214,
0.0911562145,
0.0364108309,
0.0632466897,
0.8377921581,
-0.4105753005,
-0.5438222289,
-0.3992252648,
0.5032052398,
-0.1330967546,
-0.4347515702,
0.7407923937,
0.666608274,
1.1634596586,
0.0308552291,
0.5865757465,
0.1050839573,
0.4710892141,
-0.4818781912,
0.9658790231,
-0.5818946958,
0.4281117618,
-0.3048399389,
-0.7665633559,
-0.5807740688,
0.4679740369,
-0.2397749275,
-0.2131626904,
0.8517926931,
0.7994306087,
-0.1275025457,
0.1970964074,
0.3296050727,
0.1898396164,
0.4508653283,
0.3929673731,
0.969171524,
-0.1390241534,
0.6307910085,
-0.4509139359,
-0.2881240249,
-0.2692903876,
-0.6372096539,
-0.5469786525,
-0.7940714955,
-0.2291809469,
-0.4070568681,
0.042106349,
0.8594825864,
0.6171213388,
-1.0148643255,
-0.0022296563,
0.2007125467,
0.3390049934,
-0.3894691765,
-0.1723212749,
0.2326635718,
-0.3488156796,
-0.6777104139,
0.3055111468,
-0.0617887191,
0.0116282944,
-0.5479362011,
0.2452865988,
-0.5230109096,
-0.1167208254,
0.5995719433,
0.1520153582,
-0.4854337871,
-0.3662988842,
-0.2664620578,
-0.3649486601,
0.172673896,
0.6151685119,
-0.3370944262,
0.2891595662,
0.5562688112,
0.4756409526,
0.4804652035,
-0.030657528,
0.3346354961,
-0.5870654583,
0.1527397484,
0.6429229379,
-0.0472831428,
0.4972595274,
-0.5616113544,
0.5134037733,
0.3212558627,
-0.1781921536,
-1.0156508684,
0.3829948008,
-0.8236010671,
-0.8510446548,
0.9702151418,
-0.4653252959,
-0.067014195,
-0.6443625093,
-0.0684331059,
0.331915766,
-0.1654296219,
0.9429189563,
0.6165828705,
0.2586173117,
0.1146005094,
-0.4828176498,
0.4697032273,
0.3603316545,
-0.9002928138,
-0.1661610603,
0.4044625461,
0.3112529218,
0.5097742081,
0.2530533373,
-0.2946150005,
0.1878251582,
0.1681240946,
0.2344514877,
-0.0240078215,
-0.2677800357,
-0.3032834828,
0.8402788639,
-0.2083722502,
0.098783195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10423v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10423v1 | Fine-Grained Distillation for Long Document Retrieval | 2022-12-20T17:00:36 | 2022-12-20T17:00:36 | Yucheng Zhou, Tao Shen, Xiubo Geng, Chongyang Tao, Guodong Long, Can Xu, Daxin Jiang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Long document retrieval aims to fetch query-relevant documents from a
large-scale collection, where knowledge distillation has become de facto to
improve a retriever by mimicking a heterogeneous yet powerful cross-encoder.
However, in contrast to passages or sentences, retrieval on long documents
suffers from the scope hypothesis that a long document may cover multiple
topics. This maximizes their structure heterogeneity and poses a
granular-mismatch issue, leading to an inferior distillation efficacy. In this
work, we propose a new learning framework, fine-grained distillation (FGD), for
long-document retrievers. While preserving the conventional dense retrieval
paradigm, it first produces global-consistent representations crossing
different fine granularity and then applies multi-granular aligned distillation
merely during training. In experiments, we evaluate our framework on two
long-document retrieval benchmarks, which show state-of-the-art performance. | [
-0.4082109928,
-0.9061046243,
0.8102539182,
0.022920968,
-0.2812803388,
0.0717738643,
-0.4746319354,
-0.3940286934,
0.1406085193,
0.1575115323,
-0.157166034,
-0.4278630316,
-0.8841642141,
0.0044146171,
-0.4960289598,
1.1543258429,
-0.1492449343,
-0.2198889256,
-0.3694376349,
-0.0717137456,
-0.2661765814,
-0.3632529676,
-0.526619792,
-0.7238079906,
0.5292735696,
0.218100518,
0.4875643849,
0.5718690157,
0.4415119588,
0.241326943,
-0.2762348354,
0.3291914463,
-0.6920741796,
0.0298116188,
-0.4199926853,
-0.4760377407,
-0.1473758221,
-0.002328668,
0.4571658671,
0.6441569328,
-0.2549594641,
-0.1762280911,
0.5926103592,
0.9541980624,
-0.9235849977,
0.3704986572,
-0.6868834496,
0.2125659734,
-0.3866854906,
-0.1860380769,
-0.1532963961,
-0.2734803259,
0.2252373993,
-0.702452004,
0.4703614712,
-0.1686938703,
0.6943511963,
0.1578312963,
-0.3584175706,
-0.6408923268,
-0.8542862535,
0.5980120301,
-0.3473205268,
0.3755135536,
0.7426534891,
0.70130229,
-0.0227921512,
-1.020621419,
-0.3574109972,
-0.055344142,
-0.1896885633,
0.0540373363,
-0.0650627315,
-0.0093760109,
0.1887386292,
0.7845221758,
-0.2584236562,
0.0433105268,
-0.2670152485,
-0.0272169411,
0.4882151783,
-0.113757357,
-0.4839601219,
0.1129531264,
-0.613166213,
-0.1036871821,
-0.0077884635,
-0.1723534167,
0.2317481786,
0.4301199615,
0.2865876853,
0.2025699019,
-0.7699519992,
0.5615248084,
0.7023685575,
-0.2419191003,
0.4758987427,
-0.2509291172,
-0.2036952376,
0.2000949383,
0.6056432128,
0.2722431421,
0.1026576385,
-0.2926174104,
-0.438994348,
-0.4527684748,
0.195897162,
-1.1181979179,
-0.0268749613,
0.1712671965,
-0.5615784526,
-0.1710407734,
0.2384085357,
-1.0104951859,
-0.4597876072,
-0.3907572925,
0.5274420977,
-0.612133503,
0.1019319668,
0.2641611397,
-0.4493659735,
-0.0373223126,
0.296800673,
-1.2640098333,
0.261968106,
0.7676619291,
0.9235164523,
-0.2886870503,
-0.4331961572,
-0.8255506754,
0.153668344,
0.0329459757,
0.7224290967,
-0.7267752886,
-0.4653377235,
0.0822448209,
-0.0485021025,
0.255591929,
-0.8214594722,
0.6286860704,
-0.302028507,
-0.0059184367,
-0.3198055029,
-0.6024729013,
0.115416564,
0.5397498608,
-0.7190482616,
0.9750888944,
0.181029439,
-0.7426294088,
0.5269502997,
-0.3077918589,
-0.2865633965,
-0.1615810692,
-0.4346368313,
-0.2884050906,
0.3310810626,
0.0653005764,
0.5153958797,
-0.2916075289,
0.4400732517,
-0.3869353831,
-0.5058655739,
-0.2483070344,
-0.8195453882,
0.1096023917,
0.3929353356,
-0.1191721484,
-0.427036494,
-0.7991458178,
-0.1913486272,
-0.0393204503,
-0.6691976786,
-0.7167975307,
0.0179488342,
-0.0242167823,
0.0294783227,
0.3714057505,
-0.5512523055,
0.3553782105,
0.0896621719,
0.2661099136,
0.4184792042,
-0.0932486206,
0.6734492183,
-0.3885236681,
0.0274676532,
0.3395715356,
-0.0793471783,
-0.041413065,
0.0632579699,
-0.2308287174,
-0.197975412,
0.3108290434,
0.0985661447,
-0.6621879935,
0.3206305504,
-0.4434413612,
-0.4069792628,
-0.0654924735,
0.3695847094,
0.4667761028,
0.4233458936,
0.6447310448,
-0.2813585103,
0.0262801107,
-0.6768164635,
-0.1701504439,
0.2963658273,
-0.2090866715,
0.3001114428,
0.4965025783,
-0.4447636604,
0.9721993208,
-0.8795617819,
-0.7616850138,
0.0892410576,
0.5387895107,
0.1503450274,
0.3772756457,
0.6372714639,
-1.1034277678,
-0.6581424475,
0.3105404079,
-0.6131225228,
0.0540585145,
-0.0557582788,
-0.0050550839,
0.0751972347,
0.856090188,
-0.4832399487,
0.4094736278,
0.2336945385,
-0.1892307997,
0.3937317431,
-0.4627310336,
0.1699867994,
-1.2265561819,
0.1371408105,
0.121627517,
-0.1404013485,
-0.3595056832,
-0.0441661365,
0.2681026459,
-0.0511460118,
-0.4253973365,
0.5568861961,
-0.6143450737,
0.1199301854,
-0.4501256049,
0.156352967,
0.3462468386,
0.2685863674,
0.0608980507,
0.5330227613,
0.2971768081,
-0.4828594029,
0.3659229577,
0.0820378065,
-0.2137407064,
0.9114660025,
-0.4297301173,
-0.0058449884,
-0.4103639722,
0.4474721253,
-0.6059579849,
-0.2891826034,
-0.4087052345,
-0.0437221564,
0.7073594332,
-0.3370133936,
-0.2478976101,
-0.4465082288,
-0.3838665783,
0.2893949449,
0.2175776213,
-0.648000896,
0.7571199536,
-0.0179478116,
0.1159937456,
-0.7338971496,
-0.7514441609,
-0.3114015162,
-0.3310236931,
-0.3314496279,
0.6406027675,
0.0457551628,
-0.083788529,
-0.1712784171,
-0.6829295158,
-0.4093284011,
0.102320835,
0.0676008835,
-0.3197933435,
-0.0336488783,
0.2947517037,
0.099707678,
-0.1179425195,
-0.2858255208,
-0.5951294899,
0.6566998363,
-0.0205389149,
-0.3963446617,
-0.0928952396,
0.5535281897,
0.4729796946,
-0.2287248373,
0.4454325438,
0.903419733,
-0.414621979,
-0.1954199076,
-0.6313267946,
-0.0233480241,
-0.4965903759,
0.4256290793,
-0.6483741403,
-0.8365912437,
0.5562422276,
-0.3172393739,
-0.1098767594,
0.4407239854,
0.197043255,
-0.1364527643,
0.3708047569,
0.5680072904,
-0.3847278953,
0.6540982127,
-0.5383455753,
-0.0327945426,
-0.6963937879,
-0.3570179343,
-0.7288641334,
-0.5463104844,
-0.3235579133,
-0.6402778029,
0.0295284633,
0.5686253309,
0.0291556157,
-0.0438388325,
-0.3630697727,
0.8406947851,
0.536073029,
0.1429575682,
0.4539375305,
0.0729646385,
-0.2446576357,
0.3127025962,
-0.3210442364,
-0.2573508322,
0.978071034,
0.0580664612,
1.1574997902,
-0.2565706372,
1.2872320414,
0.2696380913,
-0.2399280816,
-0.8761199117,
0.1383294165,
-0.5697153211,
-0.4929822385,
-0.2935563624,
-0.3881539702,
-1.0808055401,
0.2665883601,
-0.0408163257,
-0.6529273391,
0.520124197,
0.0333413929,
-0.3392916024,
0.2457573712,
-0.6271435618,
0.8063297868,
-0.2472266257,
-0.4799012244,
-0.0957649797,
-0.5824990869,
0.0258686226,
-0.4796954393,
0.0385619476,
0.069999665,
0.2802659273,
0.3807048798,
-0.2629196048,
0.5080842972,
-0.3961432874,
-0.2169289291,
0.2561723888,
-0.0914922729,
0.5814051032,
0.1489068419,
-0.2974877656,
0.1331012994,
0.0138619849,
-0.3983111084,
-0.6224349141,
0.8131811619,
-0.4763296843,
-0.6263660789,
-0.380589813,
-0.3894736767,
-0.0240759049,
0.5509108305,
0.2847629488,
0.3637418449,
-0.5499674678,
0.674357295,
0.892288506,
0.31865713,
0.6030424833,
0.2788807452,
-0.1554291546,
-0.0480763279,
0.7827571034,
0.2012587488,
0.4233944416,
0.5863239169,
0.2130613923,
-0.3149934113,
-0.8787981868,
-0.1778171808,
-0.2786318958,
-0.6146517992,
-0.3701954186,
-0.5918385983,
-0.2493081689,
-0.1338398606,
-0.1835221648,
-0.5072205663,
-0.0511720143,
-0.5878113508,
0.1299186945,
0.1927936077,
0.4013544619,
-0.0816448107,
0.0726173371,
-1.0706956387,
0.6079005599,
0.5025539994,
0.6764127612,
-0.182023257,
-0.3756194115,
-0.4243282676,
0.4086964428,
-0.4729880691,
-0.2507529855,
0.0006848495,
0.5565434694,
0.5685833097,
0.4870501459,
0.1779084653,
0.8838869333,
-0.645626545,
0.4925963879,
0.1375528127,
-0.6033241153,
0.6102153063,
-0.2594709694,
0.4387442172,
1.1226676702,
0.6672946215,
-0.3949488401,
-0.0137433102,
-0.2626354992,
-0.8234075308,
0.4548867345,
-0.0335606076,
0.1680799872,
-0.1860818267,
0.4163021147,
0.57995224,
0.1180837527,
-0.2626396418,
0.1058678031,
-0.2326371223,
-0.1593886018,
-0.1709879339,
-0.1013633087,
-0.1685774326,
0.0708554089,
0.4715378881,
-0.5796937943,
0.1302537471,
0.3925290406,
-0.1357737184,
0.182717517,
0.4179516435,
0.0732982531,
0.4576629996,
-0.5154851675,
0.1484522671,
-0.0582278185,
-0.6857621074,
0.0406624973,
0.7127792239,
0.0092871543,
-0.031468302,
0.049547527,
0.7233892679,
0.0134024099,
-0.2461157739,
0.4658463895,
-0.1425352842,
-0.5883254409,
0.0517678708,
0.1198169217,
0.0389728136,
0.6655445695,
0.7812911868,
-0.1288073957,
0.3237559497,
-0.8022194505,
0.3619517088,
0.5039014816,
-0.1972444952,
0.1144577935,
0.5565267801,
0.1717955768,
-0.0529042855,
0.42257002,
-0.2462615967,
-0.0933841467,
0.3448896706,
0.4684339464,
0.8779011965,
0.2538596094,
-0.0476385057,
0.0879963562,
-0.3530466557,
-0.6979311109,
0.0451600552,
-0.5026253462,
-0.2707882226,
0.0251683872,
-1.1486749649,
-0.0368232131,
0.0144432243,
-0.8759813309,
0.2406411916,
-0.1673161536,
-0.1946233064,
0.2396378666,
0.3568977416,
-0.5076149702,
0.120062001,
0.2834823132,
1.0907216072,
-0.6573698521,
1.1180620193,
0.2380613238,
-0.4561143816,
-0.3979701698,
0.415913254,
-0.0374390706,
-0.3371863961,
0.455958426,
0.2617518902,
0.0452814363,
-0.1866104156,
-0.1810488105,
-0.8380426168,
1.585893631,
0.2302031219,
-1.0456316471,
-0.3345442414,
0.2166956365,
0.6385611892,
-0.2514358759,
-0.0307829157,
0.6734484434,
0.3005183637,
0.371506542,
-1.1127434969,
-0.1524575502,
-0.0731723905,
0.1663809419,
0.4396232367,
-0.686219871,
0.8454108834,
0.131925568,
-0.0472630188,
-0.0556064732,
0.6075793505,
0.0929166153,
0.7479628921,
0.1522074342,
0.8076813817,
1.0640348196,
-0.291792959,
0.9797182083,
-0.0661335066,
0.6791983843,
1.4698241949,
-0.299508363,
0.7389109135,
0.650811255,
-0.0779233277,
0.1987898052,
0.3204711974,
0.0628885627,
0.9297807813,
0.168503046,
-0.1864289939,
0.092525959,
0.1300746948,
-0.5461945534,
0.5215605497,
0.3426760435,
-0.523208499,
-0.6884787083,
0.0956663489,
-0.1566579193,
0.1450673938,
-0.4385527074,
0.8765740395,
0.1577753723,
-0.5555046201,
0.8761377931,
-0.169360429,
1.1226528883,
-0.6020870805,
0.1120737568,
-0.4349888563,
0.4568128884,
-0.2046004981,
-0.8041394949,
0.3505727351,
-0.2036624253,
-0.5442540646,
-0.2434282452,
0.9063418508,
-0.7547379136,
-0.1989050508,
0.4228894114,
0.377600044,
-0.0524212383,
-0.2996633351,
-0.5100239515,
-0.1196793318,
-0.088642545,
-0.2033957392,
0.7321673632,
0.9666529298,
-0.0937999412,
0.3415726423,
0.5462302566,
-0.1722897589,
0.0141229434,
0.1544647813,
1.0805650949,
-0.4485983253,
-0.4141356945,
-0.9069827199,
0.1884155124,
-0.2047998458,
-0.1003786698,
0.3967782855,
0.7661076188,
1.1823277473,
-0.0190714989,
0.6206997633,
-0.191999495,
-0.0369421579,
-0.6528704762,
0.7653389573,
-0.685495913,
-0.0142559083,
-0.094449468,
-1.1865876913,
-0.0399237387,
0.497474134,
-0.1368923336,
0.0078014294,
0.7180306315,
0.3993204236,
-0.5971974134,
-0.0723193884,
0.190230608,
0.014039618,
0.385461092,
0.5984680057,
0.4706216753,
-0.3994272947,
0.4875670373,
-0.2401267737,
0.0093003903,
-0.425991863,
-0.9246997237,
-0.7308033109,
-0.5433184505,
0.0217841826,
-0.2344420999,
0.2614715397,
0.7544493675,
0.4247787297,
-0.4181237519,
0.1019132957,
-0.099750787,
-0.1809362769,
-0.0735875592,
-0.1951130927,
0.2159486562,
-0.5209854245,
-0.9102473855,
0.213301912,
0.1385291964,
0.2095830142,
0.1285685301,
-0.1342626661,
-0.3989162743,
-0.1765591204,
0.6200792789,
0.2159048319,
-0.2901667953,
-0.338821888,
-0.3732222021,
-0.3659650087,
0.3438169658,
0.6514451504,
-0.8252258301,
0.4351736605,
0.5490934849,
0.7518200874,
1.0442870855,
0.1137352362,
0.1897525787,
-0.9702550173,
0.2395871729,
0.2345607728,
0.309345901,
0.0702657625,
-0.372551769,
0.5368101597,
0.0342279188,
-0.5665348172,
-0.5032653213,
-0.154438287,
-0.985037744,
-0.489254415,
1.2784688473,
-0.2911252677,
-0.1678708941,
0.0884789452,
-0.2181799114,
0.3407970965,
-0.6368168592,
0.9129297733,
0.7732169032,
0.1902373284,
0.5768726468,
-0.3906807005,
0.4914515615,
0.0163448788,
-0.6830325723,
0.3019671142,
0.7524340749,
0.4798162282,
0.4428467155,
0.6854542494,
-0.1712213755,
0.1056767032,
0.041750446,
-0.4180902541,
-0.2884684503,
-0.5332308412,
-0.3495152891,
0.2564319968,
-0.1586958319,
-0.0590145104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10422v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10422v3 | Localising In-Domain Adaptation of Transformer-Based Biomedical Language Models | 2022-12-20T16:59:56 | 2023-06-28T08:36:20 | Tommaso Mario Buonocore, Claudio Crema, Alberto Redolfi, Riccardo Bellazzi, Enea Parimbelli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; J.3 | In the era of digital healthcare, the huge volumes of textual information
generated every day in hospitals constitute an essential but underused asset
that could be exploited with task-specific, fine-tuned biomedical language
representation models, improving patient care and management. For such
specialized domains, previous research has shown that fine-tuning models
stemming from broad-coverage checkpoints can largely benefit additional
training rounds over large-scale in-domain resources. However, these resources
are often unreachable for less-resourced languages like Italian, preventing
local medical institutions to employ in-domain adaptation. In order to reduce
this gap, our work investigates two accessible approaches to derive biomedical
language models in languages other than English, taking Italian as a concrete
use-case: one based on neural machine translation of English resources,
favoring quantity over quality; the other based on a high-grade, narrow-scoped
corpus natively written in Italian, thus preferring quality over quantity. Our
study shows that data quantity is a harder constraint than data quality for
biomedical adaptation, but the concatenation of high-quality data can improve
model performance even when dealing with relatively size-limited corpora. The
models published from our investigations have the potential to unlock important
research opportunities for Italian hospitals and academia. Finally, the set of
lessons learned from the study constitutes valuable insights towards a solution
to build biomedical language models that are generalizable to other
less-resourced languages and different domain settings. | [
-0.0246157032,
-0.3695531189,
0.6534763575,
-0.0356155597,
-0.2117797285,
-0.0046416749,
-0.168936193,
-0.7575523257,
0.1014235467,
0.6002961397,
-0.2832306921,
-0.3216052651,
-0.6437807679,
0.3968163431,
-0.0694659203,
1.1186208725,
-0.1702872664,
0.7794080973,
-0.2991207838,
-0.4827676415,
-0.4011605382,
-0.568814218,
-0.6691627502,
-0.5144612193,
0.4387673736,
0.1855063289,
0.5257792473,
0.4354544282,
0.6643838286,
0.1835896671,
-0.016691735,
0.2008937001,
-0.3708663285,
-0.1921179742,
-0.4318433702,
-0.4166448116,
-0.4861895442,
-0.4589150548,
0.5883434415,
1.1151356697,
0.0058814161,
-0.1773651987,
0.0998947546,
0.6328928471,
-0.4292762578,
0.1689046472,
-0.8626673222,
-0.0688801035,
0.1352185756,
-0.0835682452,
-0.5442900658,
-0.1481135488,
0.2069375515,
-0.5938060284,
0.2762723565,
-0.2691194713,
0.7557039857,
0.3098887503,
-0.2488442659,
-0.2989718914,
-0.8568725586,
0.4998571873,
-0.9128221273,
0.4469992518,
0.408185631,
0.2579399049,
-0.2481395304,
-0.6356982589,
-0.1874213964,
-0.0830737501,
-0.2132247239,
0.1874541789,
-0.4358763993,
-0.0607962459,
-0.1294884831,
0.1397095174,
-0.5099784732,
0.2862125039,
-0.462098062,
-0.1138619035,
0.4338184297,
0.1911213994,
0.281796217,
0.1777688563,
-0.0337422565,
0.071070753,
-0.8199070692,
-0.1212911829,
-0.416362375,
0.467623651,
-0.2946220338,
0.3667618036,
0.0225446746,
0.5096653104,
0.123613745,
0.0403495356,
0.2502013147,
-0.3471094668,
-0.2112941295,
-0.0561580285,
0.6717311144,
-0.0201703422,
0.0602532178,
-0.5514692664,
0.0209319275,
-0.2134535313,
0.4608811438,
-0.9439769983,
0.0339127444,
0.3240787685,
-0.3400936723,
0.1203196496,
-0.3451087773,
-0.6268797517,
-0.4385354519,
-0.1306314617,
0.3861652017,
-0.6466587782,
0.0183592308,
0.4156136215,
0.1983523965,
-0.0631261021,
0.1140698344,
-0.8657311201,
0.1894452274,
0.3468545079,
0.9439522028,
-0.3966389894,
-0.0455269516,
-0.2099010199,
0.2949494123,
-0.2252718359,
0.7626434565,
-0.5229085684,
-0.56834203,
0.052097939,
0.4179007709,
-0.3738104701,
-0.730986774,
0.5768594146,
-0.4419451058,
0.2147196382,
0.1171987206,
-0.5304230452,
-0.0200912058,
-0.2183548212,
-0.6569571495,
0.4664048254,
0.2814247906,
-0.6417888999,
0.3870659769,
-0.8020504117,
-0.6786361337,
0.1648659855,
0.0077488711,
-0.6906824112,
0.4751237929,
0.2880549133,
0.4176364541,
-0.3389042914,
0.4037263691,
-0.2134241313,
-0.1249434501,
0.3814711273,
-0.2807798088,
0.6945543885,
0.1703199744,
-0.1817801148,
0.0421283804,
-0.8089433908,
-0.2059169859,
-0.0142381536,
-0.215773508,
-0.4907091856,
0.2118327767,
0.2251919955,
-0.0416678712,
0.0805165991,
-0.5272040367,
0.1236473247,
-0.7005442381,
0.6985499859,
0.1330383867,
0.0352773182,
0.7019805312,
-0.3629805148,
0.4825860262,
0.2660948932,
0.178201139,
-0.0027615665,
-0.3873423636,
-0.5289233923,
-0.6464452744,
0.4776574969,
0.5075193644,
-0.8228687048,
0.1488151252,
-0.4822419584,
-0.5615593195,
-0.9464477301,
-0.2538720071,
0.1724974066,
0.6107658148,
0.6885232329,
-0.2647993565,
-0.3854337335,
-0.8997554183,
-0.0183758587,
-0.0118533112,
-0.1654194593,
0.5610380769,
0.6465980411,
-0.7103148699,
0.7614582777,
-0.222585842,
-0.2204802334,
-0.2679555714,
-0.1741604954,
0.4267174304,
0.5888908505,
0.5644618273,
-0.6743043661,
-0.2637335956,
0.4956961274,
-0.8136692047,
0.0103442501,
-0.3969089389,
-0.213315323,
0.0831654742,
0.1932854056,
-0.362824589,
0.387188524,
0.7868471742,
-0.3768096268,
0.2266176045,
-0.6156902313,
0.101687476,
-1.3797545433,
0.1500695646,
-0.0589805692,
-0.2454274446,
-0.8638936877,
0.0103165722,
0.2275511026,
-0.2755176425,
-0.4010389447,
0.8363453746,
-0.4720032215,
0.1511811167,
-0.3478773534,
-0.4636899233,
0.2931839824,
0.2435911596,
0.3755033314,
0.8155234456,
0.6057234406,
-0.5147551298,
-0.251557529,
0.4914528728,
-0.1731727421,
0.3678275347,
-0.7699952722,
-0.0995712131,
-0.0833140016,
0.3240604699,
-0.4343717098,
-0.2928805351,
0.0832104385,
-0.3584682345,
0.3017449379,
-0.3449192941,
-0.3289171159,
-0.1964148581,
0.2571917772,
0.5194596648,
0.4056689441,
-0.4466889799,
0.5205410123,
0.6425030231,
-0.3075742126,
0.045099847,
-0.9121467471,
0.0312353093,
-0.1752040982,
-0.5192448497,
0.7187348604,
-0.00046763,
-0.0621851012,
-0.1180953979,
0.1230200008,
-0.6731971502,
0.1304085702,
0.1469043344,
0.3604155481,
-0.4505447745,
0.25467062,
0.4663253129,
-0.0235969629,
-0.1618301421,
-0.6503885388,
0.0884036943,
0.1911970228,
-0.4259109497,
-0.4956388772,
0.6475635767,
0.823387444,
-0.1925616264,
1.0331113338,
0.4023858905,
-0.7444618344,
-0.0684520677,
-0.2140723318,
-0.4866661131,
-0.3685100675,
0.603433907,
-0.2521312237,
-0.9247076511,
0.6680475473,
-0.1214297041,
-0.0561368838,
0.3612937331,
0.8152583241,
-0.1824264228,
0.7394995689,
0.891716063,
-0.0462767482,
0.2775086164,
-0.050147783,
0.2064119726,
-0.7589503527,
-0.1020638123,
-0.7280308008,
-0.1310107112,
-0.6618661284,
-0.53297472,
0.8091248274,
0.0044939159,
0.0048997761,
0.5219057202,
-0.4381020665,
0.2547486126,
0.147711128,
0.4214330018,
0.3457523286,
0.1771906912,
-0.0633451268,
-0.1002689302,
-1.0550456047,
-0.4160846174,
1.0214219093,
0.3144291937,
0.5737978816,
-0.098950021,
0.3236466646,
0.063095279,
0.3258832395,
-0.5779906511,
-0.1054648235,
-0.5360509157,
-0.5789892673,
-0.1208569929,
-0.436096698,
-1.2068110704,
0.0722586587,
-0.272802949,
-0.5727077127,
0.5921856165,
-0.0598758422,
-0.4978070259,
0.345384568,
-0.6904215217,
0.8888034225,
-0.1255415231,
-0.4229085147,
-0.1029300615,
-0.3356066346,
-0.3018683493,
-0.5136309862,
0.5285471678,
0.0574572384,
-0.0202220343,
0.3410517275,
-0.2815969288,
1.0290395021,
0.0543374717,
-0.1264876127,
0.1042654961,
0.11453069,
0.4476870894,
0.2503556013,
-0.2589105368,
0.7203364968,
0.1919507235,
-0.6719154119,
-0.2899098396,
0.5821254849,
-0.7839683294,
-0.1178107411,
-0.064923875,
-0.7921925187,
-0.6325575709,
0.1712726951,
0.5085745454,
0.5146812201,
-0.3096855879,
0.0358549058,
0.5820665359,
-0.5999070406,
0.3244015574,
0.852170229,
0.3523921072,
-0.3065856397,
0.7054954767,
-0.0935580209,
0.2329337895,
0.5355150104,
-0.0036300716,
-0.1400425732,
-0.8643136621,
-0.7556529045,
0.3556500375,
-0.3047016263,
-0.2993614674,
-0.6394910812,
-0.2513960302,
-0.3645814955,
-0.3655291498,
-0.3963115811,
-0.3799009025,
-0.4285765588,
0.1557364315,
0.4035776258,
0.6390124559,
0.0339687094,
0.2267219722,
-1.0509713888,
0.0974510685,
-0.2405490726,
0.3911733329,
-0.436147064,
-0.8307188749,
-0.8040736318,
0.2041341662,
-0.0828280821,
-0.9721352458,
0.5059062243,
0.321202904,
0.4478082657,
-0.0250824038,
-0.2510976493,
0.5981093049,
-0.8833877444,
0.4381284118,
-0.0068264008,
-0.618549943,
0.3803535998,
-0.4443438053,
0.1787884831,
0.6397773027,
0.5367618203,
-0.3114990592,
-0.4069931805,
-0.4188888669,
-0.7957843542,
0.3394657373,
0.1424266398,
0.3358052969,
-0.0122727193,
0.5740322471,
0.4056781828,
-0.1289700568,
-0.6196061373,
0.1518534273,
-0.0168747324,
-0.3911097944,
-0.0136048151,
0.0964977518,
-0.0512618646,
-0.3042519391,
0.6376776695,
-0.4384973049,
0.5373793244,
0.2971799374,
-0.2350336164,
0.0604262128,
0.329215169,
0.4832113981,
0.5027858615,
0.1098468006,
-0.309068203,
0.3887235522,
-0.5038174987,
-0.0092849033,
0.1748214215,
-0.3915151656,
0.3138389587,
0.4366779625,
0.8240093589,
0.4006519616,
-0.7334480882,
0.3448613584,
0.1023467854,
0.1189514324,
0.0205373708,
-0.119101204,
0.1120200455,
0.3114008904,
0.2004520595,
0.2506147921,
0.2557811737,
-0.3136020005,
0.3119947612,
0.378521204,
-0.6858582497,
-0.4886736274,
0.8507308364,
0.2593653202,
-0.0694824383,
0.2737081051,
0.1606571376,
0.0184596777,
0.5750115514,
0.8337800503,
0.8426539898,
-0.0151135186,
0.175160408,
0.4829593301,
0.0100746639,
-0.1115008071,
-0.0486158878,
0.2925702333,
-0.8644579649,
-0.6970652938,
-0.6065001488,
-0.4351460934,
0.0098639419,
-0.7627400756,
0.1674855351,
-0.1761077195,
-0.2615588903,
0.138176322,
-0.424774766,
-0.5493516922,
0.2151863724,
0.0840242505,
0.8889299631,
-0.7397190928,
1.1610068083,
0.6768365502,
-0.3559664488,
-0.4648720622,
-0.1228582934,
-0.4919878244,
-0.7941614389,
0.3090413511,
-0.3625850677,
0.0757835582,
-0.0624664389,
-0.2005948573,
-0.6316420436,
0.8233869076,
0.6277256608,
-0.6919465065,
-0.2083200663,
0.4260497391,
0.9236491323,
-0.5266677737,
0.2208963037,
0.5516558886,
0.1086923927,
-0.2169426829,
-1.0382438898,
-0.112649329,
-0.2334547788,
-0.0789818466,
-0.0588715002,
-0.4128923714,
0.3941930234,
-0.2957373857,
0.0006826014,
0.2526519895,
0.4727524817,
-0.0528765395,
0.2958878577,
-0.1423730999,
0.2170320898,
0.8356877565,
-0.0860660896,
1.1664961576,
-0.5634254813,
0.2598246038,
1.0033750534,
-0.348086834,
0.7544981241,
0.5244364738,
-0.2093100399,
0.5810881853,
0.4029793143,
0.0592767037,
0.5187431574,
-0.0344456695,
-0.384919554,
-0.1042531878,
-0.3704200089,
-0.4511937201,
0.3876000345,
0.3718779683,
-0.4701740444,
-0.0481055118,
0.2966203988,
0.0759425312,
0.2036823332,
-0.3375005424,
0.901863873,
0.0763970315,
-0.3864834905,
0.75340271,
-0.0377038307,
0.3965800107,
-0.4592446685,
0.107061021,
-0.5128778219,
0.2554931641,
-0.144624114,
-0.2226297259,
0.4935483336,
0.2799701095,
-0.5256589055,
-0.2706243098,
0.3936359584,
-0.3474419415,
-0.8762093186,
0.3568135202,
0.5181648135,
0.0463201441,
0.035560865,
-0.6281437874,
-0.0971152261,
0.0317406952,
0.1941037625,
0.5106550455,
0.6459575891,
-0.263207972,
0.5096642375,
0.4594700634,
0.4974138737,
-0.1188283414,
0.1727260947,
0.7614478469,
-0.4249823093,
-0.2045706958,
-0.7085127234,
0.5678488016,
0.1767837107,
-0.23535496,
0.1902148426,
0.5850058198,
0.7648432851,
-0.2638770342,
0.8422206044,
0.2929928899,
0.4719440639,
-0.5095578432,
0.9502068758,
-0.6386566162,
0.0846722052,
-0.0057959589,
-0.411965549,
-0.5760964751,
0.6107826829,
-0.264875263,
-0.2091335505,
0.7104989886,
0.7861274481,
-0.0844997689,
-0.181147635,
0.4998856187,
0.4558249116,
0.1603816748,
0.8631541729,
0.4107670188,
-0.5893828869,
0.20284383,
0.0200229995,
-0.2407738119,
-0.1184873655,
-0.7075278163,
-0.713775754,
-0.563890934,
-0.4571933746,
-0.3660133481,
0.2249214351,
0.6862111688,
0.8948363066,
-1.3245282173,
-0.0123096015,
-0.0246517267,
-0.1958828568,
-0.1368092895,
-0.0667566285,
0.3408176303,
-0.2948811054,
-0.7200095654,
0.579282999,
0.432919383,
0.1830034256,
0.0786159858,
-0.0515807532,
0.2722026408,
0.1513146758,
0.4501905143,
0.4040806592,
-0.4188816845,
-0.0625256523,
0.1431986541,
-0.3500172794,
0.2606041133,
0.888039887,
-0.7558835149,
0.4042711556,
0.2635475993,
1.0105721951,
0.4495922923,
-0.3221802115,
0.6051290631,
-0.3808987141,
0.4150795937,
0.4442877769,
0.6086500287,
0.450458914,
-0.39073053,
0.4856640697,
0.1777897328,
-0.4732522368,
-0.6604740024,
0.1031847447,
-0.724106133,
-0.397511512,
1.0758575201,
-0.2433470637,
-0.1253021508,
-0.1422662437,
-0.0827506855,
0.3203316033,
-0.0131572522,
0.9880548716,
0.3742642999,
-0.0499689132,
0.3160924911,
-0.6155785322,
0.4742825627,
0.4534271359,
-0.985750258,
-0.1173124984,
0.3489803672,
0.2763471007,
-0.0555328093,
0.5851051211,
-0.4203133285,
0.327231735,
-0.3349339366,
0.1020644829,
0.3223993778,
-0.3060086071,
-0.5729497671,
-0.0616043769,
-0.0171031151,
0.1531548351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10409v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10409v3 | ClarifyDelphi: Reinforced Clarification Questions with Defeasibility Rewards for Social and Moral Situations | 2022-12-20T16:33:09 | 2023-05-30T18:59:41 | Valentina Pyatkin, Jena D. Hwang, Vivek Srikumar, Ximing Lu, Liwei Jiang, Yejin Choi, Chandra Bhagavatula | cs.CL | cs.CL | Context is everything, even in commonsense moral reasoning. Changing contexts
can flip the moral judgment of an action; "Lying to a friend" is wrong in
general, but may be morally acceptable if it is intended to protect their life.
We present ClarifyDelphi, an interactive system that learns to ask
clarification questions (e.g., why did you lie to your friend?) in order to
elicit additional salient contexts of a social or moral situation. We posit
that questions whose potential answers lead to diverging moral judgments are
the most informative. Thus, we propose a reinforcement learning framework with
a defeasibility reward that aims to maximize the divergence between moral
judgments of hypothetical answers to a question. Human evaluation demonstrates
that our system generates more relevant, informative and defeasible questions
compared to competitive baselines. Our work is ultimately inspired by studies
in cognitive science that have investigated the flexibility in moral cognition
(i.e., the diverse contexts in which moral rules can be bent), and we hope that
research in this direction can assist both cognitive and computational
investigations of moral judgments. | [
-0.5552057028,
-0.818678081,
0.7012004852,
0.1001109481,
-0.2100059986,
-0.4238863587,
-0.3041419089,
-0.2540680766,
-0.1393713653,
0.423558116,
-0.8620295525,
-0.1442961991,
-0.4121129811,
0.2197227478,
-0.2131336629,
1.3254953623,
0.1698489487,
-0.1592255682,
-0.4978855848,
-0.3670082986,
-0.3382381797,
-0.1502319127,
-0.5000765324,
-0.3092730045,
0.5335944295,
0.6792016029,
0.3388028145,
0.5263236165,
0.3257136345,
0.5393459797,
-0.3214127123,
0.1013883725,
-0.9352568388,
0.3088670373,
-0.8442005515,
-0.5768792033,
0.1528465748,
-0.0803989917,
0.2480767816,
0.8019326329,
-0.30046013,
0.3006691039,
0.0071237222,
0.6751250029,
-0.899254024,
-0.0135786925,
-0.2985913754,
-0.1070056111,
0.2618458271,
-0.1158327311,
-0.3216615915,
-0.6980144978,
0.7088987827,
-0.6019836664,
0.2285252213,
-0.2206780463,
0.8507552743,
0.4357890785,
-0.6648195982,
-0.4057334065,
-0.8285418153,
0.7416044474,
-0.0940708742,
0.179130584,
0.2720087171,
0.3348890841,
0.0168283004,
-0.9712001085,
-0.2912711203,
-0.1202328876,
-0.2574670315,
0.0330726579,
0.1626318544,
0.2601126134,
0.3370318115,
0.3567039073,
-0.0768148229,
-0.7486419678,
-0.6882764697,
-0.3164522052,
0.651783824,
0.0056240084,
0.1078757942,
-0.0075219274,
-0.4898958206,
-0.2781603932,
-0.479721278,
0.6795525551,
0.3452340066,
-0.1024935842,
0.1092437059,
0.3078345954,
-0.2461481839,
0.4371331334,
0.4825914502,
0.2675195038,
-0.0631275252,
-0.1897070855,
-0.1201471984,
0.2635200322,
0.1555603296,
0.6113321185,
0.2907597721,
0.2931742966,
-0.1384256184,
0.0921029225,
0.3844874799,
-0.8169922829,
-0.1337383837,
0.2555818558,
-0.4670885503,
-0.38812235,
0.2214525342,
-0.5384592414,
-0.5420252085,
-0.3010154665,
0.1326818913,
-0.592559576,
-0.2730334401,
0.343690753,
-0.5052269697,
0.2857634425,
0.4702330232,
-0.8062800169,
0.1006691009,
0.6143709421,
0.3023047149,
0.2755567431,
-0.1202552468,
-0.5312854648,
0.2365181595,
-0.2956518531,
0.4383353293,
-0.6248919368,
-0.4639558792,
-0.0401630402,
0.3822516203,
0.3747082353,
-0.3293156326,
0.7575424314,
-0.2958786488,
0.5251948237,
-0.8149021268,
-0.5960505009,
-0.738648057,
0.5362043977,
-0.448515743,
0.3671040833,
-0.02111689,
-0.8657699227,
0.5948328972,
-0.4444202185,
-0.3356348872,
0.2017339021,
-0.1833950579,
-0.1407645941,
0.1369989663,
-0.1175111905,
0.1115502417,
0.1401078105,
0.3225030005,
-0.404045701,
-0.5560383201,
0.135877192,
-0.5115880966,
0.7810534835,
0.1940208375,
-0.375931412,
0.2018325329,
-0.395531565,
0.0922936276,
-0.105451718,
-0.3153339624,
-0.6435210705,
0.1578555554,
-0.5346895456,
0.0109929014,
0.4037466943,
-0.5423841476,
0.0794230029,
-0.7207210064,
0.4723170102,
0.9581298828,
0.2846651375,
0.4883360267,
-0.7722662091,
0.072338827,
-0.0869814232,
0.4165478051,
-0.0396595597,
-0.2918330133,
-0.7039612532,
-0.0885411426,
-0.08790984,
0.4934344292,
-0.7267911434,
-0.0225239377,
0.0790722519,
-0.0623065531,
-0.3170488477,
-0.1584485322,
0.5609563589,
0.6338730454,
0.3069372475,
0.0785589293,
-0.4240948558,
-0.9608969688,
-0.1564198881,
-0.4914658368,
0.0025277536,
0.4328768253,
0.7678142786,
0.1242635623,
1.0229403973,
-0.4591721296,
0.0798718706,
-0.2178885192,
-0.0385518931,
-0.1271370947,
0.4436334372,
0.2429103404,
-1.3826284409,
-0.0054208511,
-0.1994336694,
-0.4197570682,
0.1926027983,
-0.2573491633,
-0.0419662707,
-0.2419342995,
0.4738842845,
-0.387293011,
0.3664832413,
0.0321085267,
-0.6524233818,
0.5536463261,
-0.4793425798,
0.290686816,
-0.5309789181,
0.1562024802,
-0.5065250397,
-0.4077474773,
-0.5997277498,
-0.012249534,
0.0274533611,
0.3705271184,
-0.6877607107,
0.4662611485,
0.0664371997,
0.1912304014,
0.1245561987,
0.3391352594,
0.1975042075,
0.4199797511,
-0.0701170489,
0.5526357293,
0.227827251,
-1.2395358086,
0.492952168,
0.3739572465,
-0.0499652065,
0.8870086074,
-0.8508950472,
-0.2023757398,
-0.6136132479,
0.2254085541,
-0.8684296608,
-0.418034941,
0.2625153065,
-0.4143030345,
-0.1047824621,
-0.1231750697,
0.1044314653,
-0.1952110231,
-0.5539664626,
0.6157047749,
0.2648917139,
-0.6993624568,
0.3245305121,
0.147956565,
0.083123073,
-0.9755869508,
-0.5183051229,
-0.6381306052,
-0.2614733279,
-0.6492626071,
0.3354690075,
-0.3301198483,
-0.4661268294,
0.1387865394,
-0.3019931316,
-0.0280568693,
0.3567893207,
0.5068925619,
0.0663997978,
0.123326771,
0.5344703197,
0.2142293006,
0.1579756737,
0.1585340053,
-0.0470960774,
0.3234285712,
-0.9245935678,
-0.3753751516,
-0.1202485636,
0.1262231618,
0.3253839612,
-0.1918760836,
0.4229168892,
0.2209367156,
-0.2375777513,
-0.2896567583,
-0.3833101094,
-0.3837530911,
-0.5853198767,
-0.0133298505,
-0.1933926791,
-1.1429778337,
0.452559799,
-0.319578737,
0.2258525342,
0.1518895775,
0.428571552,
-0.1501509398,
0.9249007702,
0.7374328375,
0.4570081532,
0.3558090329,
-0.1773571223,
-0.0291947033,
-0.364264667,
-0.4106864929,
-0.1480949372,
-0.4955208004,
-0.6577974558,
-0.1920560151,
0.1454070359,
0.2169967294,
-0.4317868948,
-0.1514057964,
-0.6630542278,
0.717261076,
0.4597848654,
0.2364986092,
0.1097295955,
-0.367008239,
-0.4947181046,
0.2712348998,
-0.3276403844,
-0.490534842,
0.6258630157,
0.1734447032,
0.3214301765,
0.3570257127,
0.6857705712,
0.2435728312,
0.3418892622,
-0.4991545081,
0.6134465337,
0.0962541029,
-0.9894666076,
-0.4524615109,
-0.3920924962,
-0.9248487949,
0.3037462234,
-0.0647924691,
-0.630187571,
0.5530987382,
0.1890768707,
-0.6044515371,
0.1049017757,
-0.565104425,
0.6433498859,
-0.0334760994,
-0.7548333406,
-0.4423001707,
-0.9968266487,
0.5299904943,
0.426012069,
0.0738637447,
-0.2004384398,
-0.2302817404,
0.2419078499,
-0.4053060114,
0.8445600867,
-0.3058279455,
0.0477988012,
0.4208170176,
0.1513763815,
0.2079753876,
0.7658113241,
-0.1071050614,
-0.3971166015,
0.6385332346,
-0.3290396035,
-0.7340989709,
0.5133372545,
-0.42728737,
-0.7103066444,
-0.2863725424,
-0.4453368783,
-0.0597049184,
0.2989746928,
0.2779884934,
0.0679046959,
-0.5068488121,
0.4809099138,
1.2547109127,
-0.4525529742,
0.2009913176,
0.6834512353,
-0.1897494495,
-0.3323584497,
0.5938892365,
-0.4599447548,
0.0485147908,
0.1620868593,
0.3351599872,
-0.4781992733,
0.0404783227,
-0.1807377487,
0.3874329925,
-0.966573298,
0.027669441,
0.0605727248,
0.2984948456,
-0.1340002865,
-0.5477213264,
-0.2338932008,
-0.4062093794,
-0.0628142208,
-0.2840656042,
0.2301816791,
0.7941110134,
-0.2474551946,
-0.0764686689,
-0.5917401314,
0.0983802229,
0.5503149629,
0.385822475,
-0.4497768879,
-0.2393155545,
0.5181378722,
0.3312611282,
-0.2908576429,
-0.9635234475,
-0.1239262372,
0.1820223033,
0.4715258181,
0.8940629363,
0.6309138536,
0.5758447051,
-0.2459150106,
0.6593553424,
0.0353626423,
-0.934560895,
0.7648668885,
-0.2352781892,
0.1393062174,
1.0352497101,
0.4556167722,
-0.7765150666,
-0.3082178831,
-0.8060382009,
-0.7109778523,
0.615567565,
0.0824853852,
0.4288696051,
-0.2657612264,
0.9051681161,
0.028435478,
0.4651427865,
-0.682187438,
-0.2545624673,
-0.1722321361,
-0.1998880953,
0.151000917,
-0.4083926678,
-0.7522389889,
-0.300340265,
0.4656804204,
-0.1545768976,
-0.0782704279,
0.7261490822,
-0.1957708001,
0.0091754999,
0.329731822,
0.9527744055,
0.7543016076,
-0.0919186994,
0.1326105297,
0.5322678685,
-0.1751895398,
0.264018923,
-0.2823714614,
-0.3322171867,
-0.2320605665,
0.1915786564,
0.5560446382,
0.23488383,
-0.8888667226,
0.8857725859,
-0.358388871,
-0.5025018454,
-0.3347818255,
0.333058387,
-0.1025003567,
0.5273131132,
-0.1584521234,
-0.0000910904,
0.2122792155,
-0.5529513359,
0.6599553823,
0.2553796172,
-0.5590055585,
-0.0253770687,
0.3325259089,
0.1446254104,
0.0168696214,
0.686352849,
-0.2693554759,
-0.634571135,
0.6586347222,
0.0454539023,
0.348770678,
-0.4905402064,
0.5782309771,
0.3942179084,
0.2559084296,
-0.1575661153,
0.4876395762,
-0.5606241226,
-0.5280092955,
-0.21398817,
-0.3844315112,
-0.4397297204,
-0.1407981813,
-0.6701663733,
0.2090949565,
-0.7701086402,
-0.1321745664,
-0.463411212,
-0.0700637698,
-0.0709518269,
0.2642069459,
0.0033886209,
0.8902572393,
-0.5317690969,
0.3869940042,
0.7361109257,
-0.5083838105,
-0.6285638213,
-0.047356084,
-0.0488789678,
-0.4766210914,
0.6453474164,
0.3793045282,
-0.3916251361,
-0.2203859687,
-0.7842363715,
-0.8067651987,
1.0191785097,
0.2571752667,
-0.251539737,
-0.1636679918,
-0.0147404671,
0.5314016938,
-0.0296718273,
0.314791292,
0.5198865533,
0.6112787724,
0.23382245,
-0.313408494,
0.229611814,
-0.1296431273,
-0.1755331457,
0.1287058592,
-0.6456368566,
0.6495230794,
-0.6960979104,
-0.4030606747,
0.0777079239,
0.6184874773,
0.2296748608,
0.6238679886,
0.8473604918,
0.1412947476,
1.1938873529,
-0.2272270918,
0.8417573571,
-0.2373500317,
0.4245474339,
1.1210141182,
0.1336961836,
0.4835402966,
0.6242187023,
0.3168721795,
0.8131194711,
0.6596838832,
0.0567561835,
0.6425719261,
0.4894890189,
-0.3014410436,
-0.366091162,
-0.1399343163,
-0.234005034,
0.3504886329,
0.7348296642,
-0.1845870614,
-0.424872309,
0.0416306928,
-0.1997968853,
0.2400148809,
-0.2878202796,
0.6559467912,
-0.086073108,
-0.8423733115,
0.4975633323,
0.0558911227,
0.2729057372,
-0.6502981782,
-0.1684118062,
-0.3315199614,
0.4580100775,
-0.4146912396,
-0.7683053017,
0.3595091701,
-0.3372282982,
-0.2028065175,
-0.302083075,
0.5741176009,
-0.3765713573,
0.0796811208,
0.0940948799,
0.0300635137,
0.015226203,
0.3164730668,
-0.8435074687,
-0.2849648297,
0.177906543,
-0.1416108757,
-0.2029094249,
0.65421772,
-0.07149636,
1.2057518959,
0.5027444363,
-0.2282457799,
-0.1149388105,
-0.3099397123,
0.8148028851,
-0.3302714825,
-0.5212782025,
-0.7102143764,
0.7492531538,
-0.3464169204,
-0.2864545584,
0.6106060743,
0.1377465725,
0.902151823,
0.1910312921,
0.455144316,
-0.0892095789,
0.3625562489,
-0.2606180012,
0.3753774464,
-0.6138147116,
0.4753967524,
0.1290890276,
-0.4172495604,
0.0799294412,
0.8192097545,
-0.6380152702,
0.1159932986,
0.5713098049,
0.3873744011,
0.1005635932,
0.2555660307,
0.2628420889,
0.0544564985,
0.268106401,
0.7258871198,
1.0121904612,
-0.0522977076,
0.8467451334,
-0.4692845345,
-0.1007164568,
-0.3631005585,
-0.7441067696,
-0.627687633,
-0.5502309203,
-0.1592310667,
-0.2687103152,
0.163504228,
0.6848464608,
0.5296941996,
-0.6366955042,
-0.0469107777,
-0.3872931302,
0.6950978041,
-0.255951941,
-0.2473109812,
0.0376455076,
-0.5243067741,
-0.5977637768,
0.1607856601,
0.2986650467,
-0.051184427,
-0.0252819154,
-0.1951910108,
-0.1533437073,
0.3414878249,
0.2654062808,
0.4220189154,
-0.5761473179,
-0.6606808305,
-0.2329082489,
-0.0679308847,
-0.2632731497,
0.8854398131,
-0.6157232523,
0.5416819453,
0.759416759,
0.5281296372,
0.2146213502,
0.4678290188,
0.7284641266,
-0.7675118446,
0.2204820961,
0.478605777,
0.2782409787,
0.1592415571,
-0.6691102982,
0.2107131183,
0.1438738853,
-0.6261932254,
-0.6726571918,
0.6811814904,
-0.4184916914,
-0.7993071675,
0.8792949915,
-0.3186267614,
-0.2502203584,
-0.2726442218,
-0.4095349014,
0.0263852719,
-0.2493382394,
0.712310493,
0.7934075594,
-0.0885688812,
-0.0196406897,
-0.262301743,
0.981995225,
0.8347457051,
-0.4219356179,
0.2205793113,
0.8218824267,
0.5644670725,
0.1556328833,
0.3793211579,
0.0311904848,
0.6917372942,
-0.2780113816,
-0.2986195385,
-0.0697743967,
-0.4002850354,
-0.4412861168,
0.4745605588,
-0.1559318155,
-0.03682179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10408v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10408v1 | Geographic and Geopolitical Biases of Language Models | 2022-12-20T16:32:54 | 2022-12-20T16:32:54 | Fahim Faisal, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models (PLMs) often fail to fairly represent target users
from certain world regions because of the under-representation of those regions
in training datasets. With recent PLMs trained on enormous data sources,
quantifying their potential biases is difficult, due to their black-box nature
and the sheer scale of the data sources. In this work, we devise an approach to
study the geographic bias (and knowledge) present in PLMs, proposing a
Geographic-Representation Probing Framework adopting a self-conditioning method
coupled with entity-country mappings. Our findings suggest PLMs'
representations map surprisingly well to the physical world in terms of
country-to-country associations, but this knowledge is unequally shared across
languages. Last, we explain how large PLMs despite exhibiting notions of
geographical proximity, over-amplify geopolitical favouritism at inference
time. | [
-0.8018918037,
-0.2117684335,
0.7995278239,
0.2696571052,
-0.200095579,
-0.1294152439,
-0.4877073467,
-0.1394506246,
0.350138694,
0.8065718412,
-0.4142924845,
-0.4862322211,
-0.6474493146,
-0.2017543763,
-0.0908304602,
0.9168711305,
-0.1106220707,
0.1136188433,
-0.15776968,
-0.4813756645,
-0.081342496,
-1.3895674944,
0.0011116143,
-0.6127125621,
-0.0431808718,
0.1552741379,
0.7872020602,
0.1871095598,
0.0555183068,
0.1992689967,
0.0257563666,
-0.3247588277,
-0.5461788774,
-0.0034919637,
-0.3122556806,
-0.4151328802,
-0.0000893149,
0.4722863734,
0.502987504,
0.8335878849,
-0.0271969456,
0.1632816792,
0.0225327127,
0.4488491416,
-0.580367744,
0.2121495008,
-0.6367726922,
0.145384416,
-0.1958530843,
-0.0490411147,
-0.1525682509,
-0.2646354437,
0.5611786842,
-0.421808362,
0.5539588928,
0.2337470353,
0.7013394833,
0.2833020091,
-0.6337554455,
-0.2132886797,
-0.7224465609,
0.8000882268,
-0.3461568654,
0.3215509653,
0.6702420712,
0.1774391234,
-0.11418733,
-0.1081068963,
-0.283020407,
-0.2463904619,
-0.286264658,
0.0747891068,
0.127751559,
-0.0888197124,
0.4226520658,
0.1658822894,
-0.3793753088,
0.0906198695,
-0.2261345834,
-0.1594049782,
0.5403921008,
-0.2638380527,
0.436873436,
-0.3518277109,
-0.4936530888,
0.0592646115,
-1.2300082445,
-0.0603933297,
0.8323022723,
0.4230073988,
-0.3425543904,
0.4338292778,
0.0212156866,
0.6499902606,
-0.0322326906,
0.3489522934,
0.1191173196,
-0.2063475251,
-0.0527010858,
0.1209971905,
0.9497670531,
0.231675908,
0.6412610412,
-0.056473054,
-0.0209974274,
-0.2201878875,
0.0622329414,
-0.5593880415,
-0.2180298269,
0.0566627309,
-0.2174723595,
0.2813715935,
0.1249151453,
-0.8027240038,
-0.3575420082,
-0.0985498801,
0.0764966011,
0.0657869279,
-0.2987800241,
0.0672389343,
0.1217393801,
0.034869086,
-0.3002398014,
-1.0056620836,
0.0472451523,
0.2794836164,
0.5622752309,
0.0914468393,
-0.4118948877,
0.1497740895,
-0.0258233212,
-0.3886901736,
0.8594408035,
-0.4764701128,
-0.4284093976,
0.0134913456,
-0.0140005834,
0.0942705795,
-0.5838039517,
0.312802881,
-0.551066339,
0.3364237249,
-0.7501967549,
-0.1182148233,
-0.0511397831,
0.228642717,
-0.7463248968,
0.9452041984,
0.068355225,
-0.7798418999,
0.6949954629,
-0.2486595213,
-0.2452360094,
-0.3797075748,
-0.371227324,
-0.3709119856,
0.2482775897,
0.5826435685,
0.3167457581,
-0.2273959965,
0.5450801253,
-0.5335867405,
-0.2240759879,
0.1703073829,
-0.1402480453,
0.8889098763,
0.1792576313,
-0.43341887,
-0.1724730581,
-0.510350287,
-0.1625862867,
0.3175057173,
-0.0791885927,
-0.7540066838,
0.2101459652,
-0.418443799,
0.5016674995,
0.2139959037,
-0.5371500254,
0.079714857,
-0.5229784846,
0.4185412228,
0.4058810174,
-0.1811435819,
0.9012073278,
-0.0249914806,
0.6598551273,
0.1713023186,
-0.0068213483,
0.0573408604,
-0.1169155613,
-0.5617813468,
0.0471573062,
0.1300814599,
0.3046801388,
-0.5493226647,
0.3484688103,
-0.3103981018,
-0.2787210345,
-0.3959955275,
0.1680153906,
0.297101438,
0.1249193847,
0.1409100592,
-0.3880756497,
-0.6447016001,
-1.0255564451,
-0.2674994171,
-0.2053498179,
-0.1160201207,
0.5322982669,
0.4656740427,
0.0801205933,
1.022547245,
-0.1678720564,
-0.4100989997,
-0.3012465835,
0.0055947327,
-0.0644525886,
0.1623075753,
0.9392998219,
-0.5558858514,
-0.3374807835,
-0.3471329808,
-0.4132388532,
-0.4618113637,
0.0729579628,
-0.1177784204,
0.1490736902,
0.2733250856,
-0.4887124896,
0.3256269395,
1.0083395243,
-0.5466257334,
0.4857253134,
-0.1500898153,
0.0022180933,
-0.6665408015,
-0.004068187,
0.1121180728,
-0.1300525963,
-0.3969040215,
0.0269727502,
-0.1468349099,
-0.2443047613,
-0.2147412151,
0.6136012673,
-0.8067038655,
-0.3964791596,
-0.1826042682,
0.3234954476,
0.0314363241,
0.2247481644,
0.3973092735,
0.8126999736,
0.5978482366,
-0.294383049,
0.010785318,
0.058848884,
-0.4263263643,
0.2505083084,
-0.3738697469,
0.0345613807,
-0.3260665536,
0.4182174802,
-0.9151923656,
-0.0093851993,
0.0192305576,
-0.053104043,
0.0696287155,
-0.574209094,
-0.395696342,
-0.3885966837,
0.0708678663,
0.5819073319,
0.4538331926,
-0.7321057916,
0.3311426938,
0.7009196877,
0.0192785598,
-0.4959465861,
-0.9046390653,
-0.2017692477,
-0.5090572238,
-0.2336330116,
-0.0709938779,
0.3435596228,
-0.3978927732,
-0.1094500422,
-0.13892667,
-0.0635046661,
0.0418757834,
0.3811429739,
-0.2045642883,
-0.1344690472,
-0.0679138526,
-0.4044555426,
0.0607109033,
0.4687044919,
-0.5968836546,
0.5616506338,
0.0598301552,
-0.7033177614,
-0.0082831727,
0.2030021846,
0.429928571,
-0.3296382427,
0.7617870569,
0.0687979534,
-0.1192614138,
-0.4668610394,
-0.6268145442,
-0.2620124519,
-0.3970110416,
0.1479581296,
-0.28859061,
-0.7346228361,
0.8985118866,
-0.05461457,
-0.4121001363,
0.3312498033,
0.3987242579,
0.2004146725,
0.8036456108,
0.4843467772,
-0.5208138824,
0.2234242111,
-0.3829398155,
0.5387229323,
-0.5114680529,
-0.1788250208,
-0.7771083713,
-0.0701892078,
-0.8195295334,
-0.3915973604,
0.1190611199,
-0.0234830249,
-0.5827745795,
0.084476918,
-0.2028787285,
0.5985552073,
0.6950275898,
-0.1930149198,
-0.1289839447,
0.3877655268,
-0.4368034005,
-0.6183875799,
-0.9659079313,
-0.4577282071,
1.1056518555,
0.2275286615,
0.8436402082,
-0.0838296935,
0.5069546103,
-0.1843585819,
0.3522953987,
-0.3649642169,
0.1877751499,
-0.1253785938,
-0.9407528043,
-0.2285476029,
-0.3039879799,
-0.8433413506,
0.3643476367,
-0.0265776701,
-0.6150995493,
0.3372683227,
0.251701504,
-0.3967025578,
0.3871008158,
-0.7357514501,
0.7536483407,
-0.5680887699,
-0.4707255065,
0.205579102,
-0.4625357985,
0.2526079118,
-0.0763402432,
0.4638232291,
-0.2680381536,
0.3654609919,
0.5570119023,
-0.2031070292,
0.9234369397,
-0.4085124433,
-0.1435634345,
0.308955282,
0.2123772055,
0.0880529061,
0.043453671,
-0.169789955,
0.4906531274,
-0.2390809953,
-0.6470219493,
-0.5556374788,
0.766733408,
-1.1026248932,
-0.7516239285,
-0.5250569582,
-0.4357972741,
-0.2467436194,
0.1645990014,
0.3607655168,
0.3048788607,
-0.3159700036,
-0.2642427683,
0.5977447033,
-0.3607134223,
0.0688923523,
0.606118381,
-0.4127183557,
0.0515031181,
0.6131455302,
0.366137892,
0.1876425147,
0.0133243995,
0.1591547132,
-0.5596613884,
-0.4585645199,
-0.1080797389,
0.363322258,
-0.5268675685,
0.0539171696,
-0.1745615751,
-0.1425841302,
-0.3362274468,
-0.0943526328,
-0.4606293738,
-0.1131620482,
-0.2469089031,
-0.1651444286,
-0.0221657604,
1.0581011772,
-0.0300107356,
0.5682392716,
-0.1456612945,
0.06777329,
0.047488533,
0.5218428969,
-0.2236910164,
-0.5408121347,
-0.1356086135,
-0.0623564348,
-0.1382687986,
-1.0352282524,
0.5927928686,
-0.0251252297,
0.721085608,
0.4312466979,
0.1586186439,
0.5767795444,
-0.6440579295,
0.9648160934,
-0.3590095937,
-0.8066994548,
0.5624942183,
-0.2290876359,
0.5325922966,
0.3674611449,
0.8306364417,
-0.1474888474,
-0.7395780683,
-0.6275961399,
-0.7582477927,
0.5855862498,
-0.2200681865,
0.3643481135,
-0.1260208935,
0.5204851627,
0.0254772492,
0.0989574268,
-1.0755931139,
-0.4419665039,
-0.4296909869,
0.0134472884,
-0.4939017892,
-0.6756224036,
-0.1990851015,
0.1204574257,
0.6854635477,
-0.1408194304,
0.1633140445,
0.5191291571,
-0.3212815225,
-0.0010458293,
0.3653325438,
0.4638792872,
0.9297792315,
-0.0583917424,
0.5215826631,
0.0835572854,
-0.1487190425,
0.4313809872,
0.3469249606,
-0.2536323369,
0.0592425391,
0.283559531,
0.7407429814,
0.1524672806,
-0.290923804,
0.5556835532,
0.0101900082,
0.0598895214,
-0.2961337268,
-0.4143693447,
0.103436701,
0.0487480462,
0.3459540606,
-0.2859661877,
-0.0855640769,
-0.4884226024,
-0.0289952867,
0.753474474,
-0.3679195344,
-0.5582899451,
0.7138960958,
0.2844063342,
0.0588517562,
0.5067850947,
-0.3597216904,
-1.1026889086,
0.4679186344,
0.4480741322,
0.3786168993,
-0.3450145721,
0.1247545481,
0.4323067665,
0.7348387837,
0.0013724775,
0.2151746154,
-0.004586542,
-0.8453564644,
-0.4536652267,
-0.3928769827,
-0.0266435109,
0.4187890887,
-0.5661530495,
0.0946386084,
-0.4920305312,
-0.5132652521,
-0.6157447696,
0.2438110858,
-0.9284639359,
0.1202359945,
0.3882040977,
0.6454840899,
-1.3728460073,
0.6289063096,
0.7684307694,
-0.0284152571,
-0.6214588881,
0.038343966,
-0.0642692894,
-0.7590621114,
0.7963641286,
0.235420242,
0.0854204819,
-0.3391177654,
-0.3822630346,
-0.9814277887,
0.4533652663,
0.6815059185,
-0.5342305899,
0.0230813846,
0.5568956137,
0.6509200335,
-0.4478266537,
0.2667660713,
0.6772908568,
0.2148711383,
-0.5880750418,
-1.0400862694,
0.0221961476,
0.349188298,
0.0385894105,
0.122591719,
-0.8065305948,
0.6490710974,
-0.1549561471,
-0.2190551907,
-0.4004924595,
0.5167822242,
0.2521320283,
0.1110487208,
0.313552171,
0.6828507185,
0.4545716345,
-0.2988661826,
1.055562973,
-0.6568121314,
0.5699571371,
1.2619062662,
-0.5081429482,
0.3860687017,
0.4998006821,
-0.1760107875,
0.5124906898,
0.6040572524,
0.1130465642,
0.6641274095,
0.4640237391,
-0.0939316154,
-0.2982477248,
0.0021301885,
-0.2351616621,
0.5491176844,
0.3468003869,
-0.3746521175,
-0.6231275797,
0.0553559028,
0.0750377178,
0.3323523998,
-0.3093015552,
0.4780154824,
0.1429147422,
-0.817047596,
0.2852466404,
-0.2662678957,
0.4545760155,
-0.6179772019,
0.3757518828,
-0.3695960045,
-0.195347935,
-0.0418296494,
-0.7903658748,
0.2284888774,
-0.1697530001,
-0.0572204776,
-0.4200139344,
0.6434926987,
-0.634530127,
-0.2878139317,
0.6904608607,
0.712518394,
0.3023127019,
-0.2015659511,
-0.58853513,
0.1594015658,
-0.0012852692,
-0.4303403199,
0.2511505783,
0.5182822347,
-0.1555704921,
0.7689935565,
0.170941487,
0.5848255157,
0.2217983156,
0.1081432477,
0.3765541017,
-0.3831345141,
-0.5749995708,
-0.8602500558,
0.0283804871,
0.1500108987,
-0.0497968271,
1.0691931248,
0.5063595772,
1.0846345425,
0.1287636459,
0.9515686631,
0.264332056,
0.3307635784,
-0.5021342039,
0.9354068637,
-0.1521438658,
0.2109637856,
0.3007555604,
-0.8306373954,
-0.1126779765,
0.7701750994,
-1.0597962141,
0.3533847034,
0.4836528301,
0.5173051953,
-0.2691926658,
-0.2533774376,
0.1948005259,
0.2570723295,
-0.0102070281,
0.4936744273,
0.8476436734,
-0.076122053,
0.1354988813,
-0.5397027731,
0.002271435,
0.1164935008,
-0.9643450379,
-1.2284340858,
-0.6659348011,
-0.0632768422,
-0.3449614644,
0.0397548862,
0.7649472952,
1.0927971601,
-0.8594089746,
-0.294239521,
0.3265111446,
0.2254352868,
0.6073230505,
-0.1890150905,
0.2547107041,
-0.1650239378,
-0.6183452606,
0.0298049711,
-0.135889858,
0.3849231899,
-0.8533391356,
0.2182350159,
0.0775868446,
-0.0682103857,
0.4197714925,
0.3138771355,
-0.7193220854,
-0.2166520953,
-0.3940767348,
-0.0613820702,
0.0530807115,
1.1055824757,
-0.9322233796,
0.505627811,
0.101323165,
0.2805786431,
0.2781231999,
0.184563458,
0.7331982255,
-1.0491987467,
0.6318775415,
-0.0268562343,
0.4497076571,
0.8076959252,
-0.2069640905,
0.1360214502,
0.1044765562,
-0.7848047614,
-0.5096583366,
0.261051923,
-0.2881085873,
-0.3290245831,
1.3000158072,
-0.2977412939,
-0.2593487799,
-0.0909374505,
0.047497388,
-0.0152009977,
-0.149159953,
0.8867620826,
1.1032392979,
0.2072789818,
0.2425588518,
-0.9275273681,
0.6521573067,
0.626240015,
-0.3490755558,
0.1135425195,
0.5251950026,
0.7154433727,
0.2282382846,
0.6907108426,
0.1026833281,
-0.1906163543,
-0.2609489262,
0.110926412,
0.2897402942,
-0.3922458291,
-0.655461669,
0.1032692343,
0.3172354698,
0.2136151791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10405v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10405v2 | AnnoBERT: Effectively Representing Multiple Annotators' Label Choices to Improve Hate Speech Detection | 2022-12-20T16:30:11 | 2023-01-10T14:48:54 | Wenjie Yin, Vibhor Agarwal, Aiqi Jiang, Arkaitz Zubiaga, Nishanth Sastry | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Supervised approaches generally rely on majority-based labels. However, it is
hard to achieve high agreement among annotators in subjective tasks such as
hate speech detection. Existing neural network models principally regard labels
as categorical variables, while ignoring the semantic information in diverse
label texts. In this paper, we propose AnnoBERT, a first-of-its-kind
architecture integrating annotator characteristics and label text with a
transformer-based model to detect hate speech, with unique representations
based on each annotator's characteristics via Collaborative Topic Regression
(CTR) and integrate label text to enrich textual representations. During
training, the model associates annotators with their label choices given a
piece of text; during evaluation, when label information is not available, the
model predicts the aggregated label given by the participating annotators by
utilising the learnt association. The proposed approach displayed an advantage
in detecting hate speech, especially in the minority class and edge cases with
annotator disagreement. Improvement in the overall performance is the largest
when the dataset is more label-imbalanced, suggesting its practical value in
identifying real-world hate speech, as the volume of hate speech in-the-wild is
extremely small on social media, when compared with normal (non-hate) speech.
Through ablation studies, we show the relative contributions of annotator
embeddings and label text to the model performance, and tested a range of
alternative annotator embeddings and label text combinations. | [
-0.7474039197,
-0.9089184403,
-0.1876020879,
0.0354927815,
-0.2442383319,
0.133355096,
-0.3075416088,
-0.7029026747,
0.3824388683,
0.4430530369,
-0.1323860288,
-0.4580376744,
-0.9722537398,
-0.0363553204,
-0.4573061466,
1.315926671,
0.4039038122,
-0.0413123369,
0.2070580721,
-0.408901006,
-0.2177872956,
-0.709867239,
-0.6455565095,
-0.5121831894,
0.9323142767,
0.0362772606,
0.8242610693,
0.5696331859,
0.4059665501,
0.3774955273,
-0.2941680253,
0.0432736725,
-0.3246779442,
0.4137867093,
-0.1393047422,
-0.1313949972,
-0.2440531701,
-0.0571036823,
0.0683863014,
0.0568718463,
0.2665316164,
0.0998173207,
-0.0993285179,
-0.0268073454,
-0.5923630595,
-0.162771672,
-0.6390240192,
0.0961778238,
-0.3387621045,
0.0530825183,
-0.5114628077,
-0.4800539911,
0.1407774538,
-0.4425514936,
0.12555179,
0.1011292636,
0.4105498791,
0.5434978604,
-0.1865420491,
-0.3645456135,
-0.8453477621,
0.6043376923,
-0.4869613647,
0.5356568098,
0.3964098692,
0.1851529032,
0.301105231,
-0.3089898229,
-0.5109956861,
-0.21099931,
-0.2302178741,
0.010404991,
-0.7226883769,
-0.0409340672,
0.003855733,
0.0655245781,
-0.3640728295,
0.4961268902,
-0.430411309,
-0.3274171352,
0.5757907629,
-0.0988257825,
0.0788704306,
-0.2477114201,
-0.4521226585,
0.0362392217,
0.0925420821,
-0.3226138353,
0.4891401529,
0.6697155833,
0.0407110974,
0.4048349559,
0.1559328139,
0.7064862847,
0.0790399909,
-0.1742880344,
0.4977955818,
0.2391169965,
-0.0411804952,
0.504740119,
0.8496766686,
0.408325851,
0.3298152685,
-0.3435829878,
-0.0907346457,
0.3873827457,
0.507884562,
-0.8923008442,
-0.5286573172,
0.0121283447,
-0.282989502,
-0.3621183038,
-0.356621176,
-0.8088619709,
-0.8847149014,
-0.2751197815,
0.5075409412,
-0.5972121954,
-0.4828847945,
-0.4364949763,
-0.3287994862,
-0.2649489939,
0.3110159636,
-0.7179387808,
0.163056612,
0.5897065401,
0.7694429159,
-0.3862116635,
-0.0090347882,
-0.390737325,
-0.1551156342,
0.108930178,
0.7574796677,
-0.7217797637,
0.0238738768,
0.0241755638,
-0.4203246832,
0.3151657581,
-0.6328889132,
0.6159590483,
-0.6287565231,
-0.1446499974,
0.1446598321,
-0.6318786144,
-0.470071435,
0.3593832254,
-0.7093356252,
1.0070207119,
0.102929458,
-0.8511188626,
0.6083519459,
-0.7093465328,
-0.3442750573,
0.1944762915,
0.0036654677,
-0.8379151225,
-0.0339873023,
0.1481984556,
0.3845437765,
0.0358928405,
0.2999921143,
-0.4690608978,
-0.1380086541,
0.5406092405,
-0.5224396586,
0.7934455276,
0.2577031255,
-0.4712037742,
0.3588469923,
-0.8042254448,
-0.4398677349,
0.0210331138,
-0.1417076886,
-0.7554717064,
-0.1323204637,
0.5816781521,
0.2019557804,
-0.0576656498,
-0.9712285995,
-0.198122412,
-0.0573542267,
0.1122720614,
0.947437942,
-0.2349718064,
0.2091060728,
-0.3351863027,
0.3222498,
0.0827862099,
0.1279702336,
0.2702275515,
-0.4410279989,
-0.8645396829,
-0.427326411,
0.081670478,
0.4961597919,
-0.2985963523,
0.3082064092,
0.0833741948,
-0.6049916744,
-0.566093564,
-0.0511214472,
0.3490129113,
0.4901144505,
0.726680994,
0.0567138195,
-1.087356329,
-1.0125060081,
-0.1805807054,
-0.3628635406,
0.1881505996,
0.0715928599,
0.4992648661,
0.000561863,
1.0058220625,
-0.085946776,
-0.4110065699,
-0.1350676417,
0.5583137274,
-0.103907451,
0.2511181831,
0.5831070542,
-1.1859761477,
-0.4855799675,
-0.018363867,
-0.3606784046,
-0.3361378908,
0.2240668982,
-0.058591105,
0.050825838,
0.1131853685,
0.4130046964,
0.4675647318,
0.5031775236,
-0.341565311,
0.2592530847,
0.5132156014,
0.2435406595,
-0.7141188383,
-0.3998260498,
0.1237904355,
-0.1185149997,
-0.907738924,
-0.3611980975,
-0.427002877,
0.2493282855,
-0.6991115808,
0.245351553,
0.3356634676,
0.4065958858,
-0.475422591,
0.2011862397,
-0.2950302958,
0.4408987761,
0.194235757,
0.6136139035,
-0.0664681345,
-0.5607069731,
0.3292351663,
0.4177723527,
0.1609495729,
0.8677684665,
-0.3152587414,
0.1111915708,
-0.2722940445,
-0.0969525501,
-0.9348596931,
-0.0385914966,
0.5378798246,
-0.621098876,
-0.0709605888,
-0.3763958812,
-0.3922699392,
-0.4070556164,
-0.0095410114,
0.2774177492,
0.2242861837,
-0.5913630724,
0.8102928996,
0.5696935654,
0.0419230126,
-0.4998911321,
-0.8761166334,
-0.0383801721,
-0.517741859,
-0.455284059,
0.3856771886,
-0.0658479556,
-0.2553130984,
0.1641244888,
0.3032378256,
-0.2844775021,
0.1512321085,
0.6372691989,
-0.0997471958,
-0.1975690871,
0.3997834921,
-0.1709167361,
0.0077889785,
-0.0509489812,
-0.1257786155,
0.5387031436,
-0.0947844088,
-0.0167577025,
-0.1700766087,
0.4046581388,
0.3668538034,
-0.2694469094,
0.7351546288,
0.9581156373,
-0.3768372238,
-0.1911252439,
-0.735655129,
-0.0334152095,
-0.3493430614,
0.3603599966,
0.026709998,
-1.2053284645,
0.4717956185,
0.2143228501,
0.2455179691,
0.1814496219,
0.7284703255,
0.1859531105,
0.614030242,
0.4577128291,
-0.1890352219,
0.7012649179,
0.2232554406,
0.1709242463,
-0.5638695359,
-0.1791171432,
-0.4986645281,
-0.468998909,
-0.431220293,
-0.3597310185,
0.3308622539,
-0.1056347266,
-0.6294304132,
0.4043619335,
-0.9200160503,
0.3352570534,
0.6498250961,
0.0994590446,
0.2184480727,
0.2306501269,
0.2458513826,
-0.3843900859,
-0.3691830635,
-0.4336722791,
0.8844283223,
0.410405159,
0.1952516735,
0.2265506387,
0.7745280266,
0.4569968879,
0.961566925,
-0.6997662187,
0.2756923735,
-0.3863578141,
-1.0257277489,
-0.1041587293,
-0.1595934331,
-0.5287446976,
0.6640894413,
-0.3197660744,
-0.9782472253,
0.0840870887,
0.2746769786,
-0.4633481205,
0.6131752133,
-0.2218081653,
0.6869671345,
-0.2783768177,
-0.4542194605,
0.0661885291,
-0.2145108134,
0.189188078,
-0.290173173,
0.359772563,
-0.2803693414,
0.1699322164,
1.2332012653,
-0.240443334,
0.9751378298,
-0.2154238373,
0.1366252303,
0.3317461014,
-0.0340018757,
0.1269022673,
-0.4085665345,
-0.5820351243,
0.2617396116,
-0.7406078577,
0.1808051318,
-0.5057682991,
0.1843103915,
-0.7160440683,
-0.2593789697,
-0.1456960142,
-0.4663205147,
0.0933732316,
0.1675707549,
0.1956778914,
0.2075662464,
-0.3200361133,
0.2195794582,
0.4745982289,
-0.1596301496,
0.3083511293,
0.4313530624,
-0.5161377788,
-0.8136959672,
0.8864929676,
0.2196028531,
-0.0751117393,
0.2807433307,
0.3505897224,
-0.1156950668,
-0.5052032471,
-0.2861025333,
-0.1159436032,
-0.6054956317,
-0.4180835783,
-1.0638756752,
-0.1043511108,
-0.191678375,
-0.3432628512,
-0.4285769761,
-0.2519086003,
-0.1760343611,
-0.305595547,
0.8868393302,
0.6520835161,
-0.562120676,
0.8292230964,
-0.1083281785,
0.3647209406,
0.0856585875,
0.0960295498,
0.0277241189,
-0.6426862478,
-0.1947563738,
-0.0716236532,
-0.3987004459,
-1.0868976116,
0.444434315,
-0.3010982573,
0.1985298097,
0.3291678429,
0.3390742838,
0.5808561444,
-0.2706192434,
0.4476501942,
0.1830102503,
-0.7267204523,
0.442324996,
-0.1383479238,
-0.273455441,
0.609983027,
0.5194930434,
-0.4514206052,
-0.8320703506,
-0.4533841312,
-0.9487971067,
0.721226871,
0.4179618657,
-0.0564449281,
-0.045229502,
-0.2902406156,
0.223444134,
0.2221384794,
-1.0660359859,
-0.8210830092,
-0.5547031164,
-0.0850783288,
0.1129428074,
-0.2427414507,
-0.0861893296,
-0.3536211252,
0.8238517642,
0.3122159243,
0.2721222341,
-0.1657153666,
-0.1652194709,
0.1883465201,
0.515871048,
0.3790209591,
0.0719267949,
-0.367020905,
0.3409515023,
0.0895564407,
-0.2217645198,
0.2493135929,
0.462469101,
-0.3654467165,
0.3343505561,
0.2216170579,
0.9656137228,
0.0692894608,
-0.2036402673,
0.4844194055,
0.1159714982,
-0.0706379637,
-0.504712224,
-0.0759479403,
-0.0603000298,
0.4011926055,
0.3299531639,
0.1003844589,
0.2931681871,
0.1915363073,
0.7070274353,
0.1476516277,
-0.8069694042,
-0.126456812,
0.8510476351,
0.150494799,
-0.6279113889,
0.4384563565,
-0.2153234184,
-0.9953211546,
0.504869163,
0.6555902362,
0.6911764741,
-0.5527736545,
0.4616886973,
0.3521695435,
0.4739353061,
0.6581482887,
-0.2333112359,
-0.048612047,
-0.8769534826,
-0.1635245979,
-0.8250846863,
-0.3972540498,
0.2749631405,
-0.5590503216,
0.0425597578,
-0.5298669934,
-0.4088272452,
0.4342702329,
-0.4322468936,
-0.6525838375,
0.1722937673,
0.6609181166,
0.3293521106,
-1.1301469803,
0.3128422499,
0.5740765333,
-0.5201151371,
-0.5937335491,
-0.5320281982,
0.3183855712,
-0.5732941628,
0.9299559593,
0.4054689407,
-0.1040189862,
-0.2152148485,
-0.3044449389,
-0.5048139691,
0.3506221771,
0.1105079874,
-0.4497596323,
0.3912686408,
0.3997449279,
0.6054593325,
-0.4004479647,
0.6287024617,
0.3633369803,
0.6017252207,
0.0616482534,
-0.6279201508,
-0.046932321,
-0.1321126819,
-0.2973535061,
0.401299417,
-0.4497696459,
0.8950634599,
0.241160661,
0.0829829499,
-0.3115860224,
0.8092733622,
0.0649025366,
0.4352799952,
0.6928090453,
0.4002762437,
0.7267899513,
0.0003846306,
0.6140732765,
0.0906565487,
0.1449983567,
1.325314641,
0.1765493304,
0.7211071849,
0.1453249454,
0.0198073424,
0.3831117749,
0.2991975844,
-0.2686618865,
0.3026529253,
0.4188089073,
-0.4659946263,
-0.4925163984,
-0.7266412377,
-0.1353045553,
0.5633241534,
0.3688534498,
-0.6284331083,
-0.3624994457,
0.554787457,
0.2836161554,
0.2061386555,
-0.1986894161,
0.746295929,
-0.1406544,
-0.1365626007,
0.4332734048,
-0.0344155394,
1.1468741894,
-0.1946804523,
0.0205181334,
0.1790915579,
0.1963683069,
-0.332931906,
-0.5375344753,
0.4298063815,
0.2286031991,
-0.2865642607,
-0.2390934825,
0.5188726187,
-0.5256804824,
-0.4394876063,
0.6548947096,
0.0060085636,
0.133847177,
-0.0969343558,
-0.5789840221,
0.5866456032,
0.1061219275,
-0.1304779798,
-0.0960245505,
0.2288659662,
0.030092271,
0.3482630551,
0.4634655118,
-0.1365732402,
0.303381741,
0.0793783739,
0.8083331585,
-0.3459210098,
-0.2954559922,
-1.077234745,
0.5070614219,
-0.225380227,
-0.5394951105,
0.674746573,
0.6852317452,
1.0281057358,
0.3087750375,
0.9552109838,
-0.0801791698,
0.8161486387,
0.06120006,
0.5559096336,
-0.3767939508,
-0.1753501296,
-0.6395463347,
-0.7026968002,
-0.7257053256,
0.9553280473,
-0.5223850012,
-0.171625644,
0.2191014886,
0.7015032768,
-0.0826114789,
0.5509636998,
0.3765684366,
0.3208448291,
0.5688151121,
0.2330683172,
0.8883438706,
-0.4097690582,
0.7250438333,
-0.5832506418,
-0.166205138,
-0.356587708,
-0.5961793065,
-1.0147070885,
-0.4685518742,
-0.6462124586,
-0.3798676431,
0.1742016375,
1.0363811255,
0.6376664042,
-0.8804086447,
-0.0009659719,
0.3842294812,
0.1431924701,
-0.0721259415,
-0.2291249484,
0.0525656044,
0.107716985,
-0.7991930246,
0.215658322,
0.1616319418,
-0.0539700091,
0.0915378407,
0.0130347852,
-0.2143213451,
-0.0962301046,
0.6565463543,
0.1124473736,
-0.8093862534,
-0.4315230548,
-0.4794043005,
0.1635962129,
0.198777467,
0.6707229018,
-0.7015815377,
0.3469075561,
0.0131565882,
0.9314584732,
0.4152286351,
0.053780742,
-0.01677965,
-0.6019632816,
0.2456999272,
0.5455842614,
0.0700488612,
0.4214589894,
-0.1841255575,
0.3552431464,
-0.0501338877,
-0.3979311883,
-0.6701117754,
0.2696931064,
-0.7159049511,
-0.2524244189,
1.0278329849,
0.1140243933,
-0.1827152669,
-0.5182183385,
-0.2107917666,
0.5141461492,
-0.8804273605,
0.3488024473,
0.5460060835,
-0.2287607491,
-0.1568240523,
-0.225798741,
0.146334976,
0.3156704903,
-0.3594060838,
0.3356499374,
0.7075388432,
0.0233936794,
0.6562350392,
0.5496798754,
0.1347374916,
-0.0732015595,
0.0276367441,
0.2473672479,
-0.4399098158,
-0.3739759326,
-0.2043207139,
0.5467565656,
-0.1838469207,
-0.2140244991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10403v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10403v2 | Towards Reasoning in Large Language Models: A Survey | 2022-12-20T16:29:03 | 2023-05-26T17:59:33 | Jie Huang, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Reasoning is a fundamental aspect of human intelligence that plays a crucial
role in activities such as problem solving, decision making, and critical
thinking. In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have made significant
progress in natural language processing, and there is observation that these
models may exhibit reasoning abilities when they are sufficiently large.
However, it is not yet clear to what extent LLMs are capable of reasoning. This
paper provides a comprehensive overview of the current state of knowledge on
reasoning in LLMs, including techniques for improving and eliciting reasoning
in these models, methods and benchmarks for evaluating reasoning abilities,
findings and implications of previous research in this field, and suggestions
on future directions. Our aim is to provide a detailed and up-to-date review of
this topic and stimulate meaningful discussion and future work. | [
-0.4643931687,
-0.8798379898,
1.1490045786,
-0.1037385017,
-0.0115209343,
0.0040067453,
-0.5492411852,
-0.5951390862,
-0.1730374992,
0.6077182889,
-0.3182891011,
-0.3173733652,
-0.5254868269,
0.0438943133,
-0.3563835323,
0.1933610886,
0.025752468,
0.177477777,
-0.4796329439,
-0.1109442413,
-0.5097198486,
-0.9117338061,
-0.7413432002,
-0.4619953036,
0.4622776508,
0.3480653167,
0.6673740149,
0.322579056,
0.3925430775,
0.4195304811,
-0.5415629745,
0.3201363087,
-0.2370041758,
0.6400360465,
-0.6127862334,
-0.7760160565,
-0.4492393434,
-0.1637010127,
0.899484396,
0.946261704,
0.0168906003,
0.0387443006,
-0.1825785786,
0.7051116824,
-0.4508081079,
0.0797499865,
-0.7054508924,
-0.1385613531,
-0.1938393265,
0.0068947435,
-0.5478951335,
-0.2301665395,
0.2349305451,
-0.1993972957,
-0.0960410088,
0.3855667114,
0.2770057023,
0.1674674749,
-0.4736684263,
-0.4186712801,
-0.8179200888,
0.9977012873,
-0.9839972854,
0.5736009479,
0.4483817518,
0.3440046012,
-0.3690360188,
-0.6635487676,
-0.5411784649,
-0.5196928978,
0.1114886627,
-0.2937095761,
-0.2073999792,
0.0804553926,
0.5249091983,
0.3079378307,
-0.3433279395,
0.2700769603,
-0.1481045336,
-0.0394965596,
0.8298509717,
0.2818104923,
0.2141605616,
-0.0583669059,
0.0856747627,
0.3955369294,
-0.7980883121,
-0.0367427021,
0.181459412,
-0.0381135978,
0.3462756276,
0.6000962257,
-0.3924386799,
0.942941606,
-0.2741812468,
-0.1826383621,
-0.2049478143,
-0.2091774344,
-0.2691611946,
-0.2322675735,
0.4474288821,
0.1015928239,
0.5233972669,
0.0073716491,
-0.315497607,
0.067955628,
0.1083220541,
-0.4530969858,
0.1122774333,
0.3626711965,
-0.4677436352,
0.1291094869,
-0.1726934016,
-0.4670590758,
-0.5925557613,
-0.6962587833,
0.0894105881,
-0.3123158514,
-0.434201479,
0.4073034227,
-0.0171718076,
0.402485013,
0.7279550433,
-0.7475611567,
0.215242669,
0.9195088148,
0.4584857523,
-0.0622641891,
-0.312161684,
-0.1292366683,
0.2566339672,
-0.3706046045,
1.0200858116,
-0.7516214848,
-0.3437052071,
0.1759923398,
-0.0453671962,
0.0624718703,
-0.7003834844,
0.760276258,
-0.4903198779,
-0.0082992492,
-0.4734471142,
-0.7848764062,
-0.445697993,
0.6361811161,
-0.5315956473,
0.6999925375,
-0.2301681936,
-0.5765613914,
0.0284735225,
-0.5712630153,
-0.5029906631,
0.1046369299,
-0.0994997546,
0.1339838058,
0.2407031953,
0.2170620561,
0.5545213819,
-0.7501408458,
0.4601775408,
-0.3638172448,
-0.134749338,
0.7314634919,
-0.4166148901,
0.6596720219,
0.3397019506,
-0.0308520216,
0.2491494566,
-0.4553584754,
0.1875514984,
0.0918289721,
-0.14640598,
-0.198636204,
0.3159334362,
-0.458004117,
0.1871118844,
0.3285606802,
-0.1743544638,
0.4764233828,
-0.2499067783,
0.8841703534,
0.4607823193,
-0.0350088403,
0.6135371923,
-0.3002418578,
0.3497065008,
-0.32566154,
0.2116705775,
-0.1395377666,
-0.6283214092,
-0.8920868635,
0.001285912,
0.2565233111,
0.4357570708,
-0.5639690757,
0.2796077728,
0.079157643,
-0.4149055183,
-0.3005405366,
0.1806247383,
0.142293036,
0.1664548367,
0.2321710736,
0.2062208503,
-0.5496683121,
-0.8742300272,
-0.2877155244,
-0.239440307,
0.0538895056,
0.165516749,
0.6239619851,
-0.1666972935,
0.8217485547,
-0.4749269485,
0.1271423101,
-0.7740081549,
-0.0687620789,
0.1771223098,
0.2015667111,
0.2696686685,
-0.8072448373,
0.0457433648,
-0.0138460519,
-0.843495667,
-0.1086313128,
0.0851740241,
-0.1138795838,
0.123715885,
0.8811187744,
-0.9341897964,
0.166549921,
0.2748507559,
-0.3303658366,
0.6086569428,
-0.1862476021,
0.081063807,
-0.661724031,
-0.0162594337,
0.100039646,
-0.1653290838,
-0.6796600223,
0.1802148074,
-0.2409485132,
0.1200797409,
-0.2463561147,
0.8618612885,
-0.6484259963,
-0.1518506706,
-0.498663187,
0.2227089554,
-0.047292456,
0.0980085805,
0.2185411304,
0.4588323236,
0.6696557403,
-0.642647624,
0.7424114943,
-0.0400117002,
-0.6228727698,
0.5598837733,
-0.524530232,
0.116842404,
-0.2061605752,
0.4044415653,
-0.7856929302,
-0.2503514886,
-0.0402018875,
-0.4708259702,
0.3235086799,
-0.0813291371,
-0.653470993,
-0.5998328328,
0.1933042407,
0.1975774616,
0.4684163332,
-0.3091450632,
0.6161875129,
0.5438885689,
-0.2939907908,
-0.3241151273,
-0.5146794915,
0.1170019805,
-0.2103724033,
-0.7607374787,
-0.0969795361,
-0.1067004353,
-0.98969841,
-0.1149436235,
0.0419409573,
-0.2571838498,
0.0264540818,
-0.0883527547,
0.2132287472,
-0.1570369452,
0.4618187845,
-0.1531371027,
-0.1060021594,
0.229296878,
-0.2659372687,
0.4368468523,
-0.3012101948,
-0.4982916713,
-0.1777605265,
0.3853858113,
0.6205159426,
-0.3550118804,
0.701223433,
0.1415219009,
-0.5289139748,
-0.3978691399,
-0.9266896844,
-0.1811112612,
-0.3878626227,
0.3539025187,
-0.3254535794,
-1.1222144365,
0.4585565031,
-0.3463638723,
-0.1278089583,
0.3888657689,
0.8506908417,
-0.1559085399,
1.296318531,
0.3449259996,
0.0880001783,
0.1777453274,
-0.1158435941,
0.3685365319,
-0.8450596333,
-0.2649162412,
-0.6163821816,
-0.0490838736,
-0.2068518251,
-0.6804156899,
-0.0213873629,
0.2056209892,
-0.3377233446,
-0.1088086814,
-0.3418599367,
0.5372514725,
0.3036563396,
-0.2177855819,
0.4434021115,
-0.5075948238,
0.0379926786,
0.2186135203,
-0.5584774613,
-0.8539201617,
0.6236047745,
0.5158482194,
0.6292942762,
0.1417333931,
0.1505153477,
0.1392851472,
0.2559874654,
-0.8519117832,
0.9886735678,
0.1624316275,
-0.851047039,
-0.4942095876,
-0.4744906425,
-0.7066022754,
0.4777146578,
-0.3004219532,
-0.8175960779,
-0.2134564668,
0.0027200589,
-0.0880430713,
0.6340859532,
-0.6367010474,
0.6208609939,
-0.4524807632,
-0.2134035975,
-0.4631100297,
-0.5288819671,
0.5735574365,
0.1148441359,
0.3593612015,
-0.2585097253,
0.1081711426,
0.4277153015,
-0.1838362962,
0.6143318415,
-0.0225693192,
-0.3237279058,
0.5737884641,
-0.0155888805,
0.3261260092,
-0.0085477093,
-0.2994076908,
-0.0092717558,
0.1204652786,
-0.2332694381,
-0.6817493439,
0.6388263702,
-0.3908697069,
-1.1020970345,
-0.3136218786,
-0.6308258772,
-0.5660045743,
0.0411863588,
-0.1035564467,
0.287902534,
-0.1152666882,
0.2303385288,
0.9813173413,
-0.244752869,
0.220823884,
0.3865852058,
-0.5823001862,
-0.1793046445,
0.6219444871,
0.2346960008,
0.3211761415,
0.4546709955,
0.303904593,
-0.5899317265,
-0.8787642121,
-0.2922684252,
0.4865617454,
-1.048150301,
0.0028772175,
-0.422295928,
-0.2793205678,
-0.3883781731,
-0.1659250408,
-0.215112552,
-0.3858269453,
-0.0618662238,
0.0046132938,
0.1393468678,
0.9813897014,
0.2443999648,
-0.072974816,
-0.7816111445,
0.1615892053,
0.581828177,
0.2410687208,
0.4378317595,
-0.4972165525,
0.0279972441,
-0.0624255985,
-0.0022675649,
-0.6526193023,
0.1070674136,
-0.3021045923,
1.0039061308,
0.4205924869,
-0.0674355254,
0.2545850575,
-0.4437558055,
0.7932574153,
0.092403464,
-1.0433493853,
0.6117267609,
-0.3204020262,
0.334179759,
0.2332054675,
0.3612152636,
-0.5940593481,
-0.2684304714,
-0.4556031525,
-0.4617634118,
0.2448567152,
0.0205569435,
-0.0527422838,
0.0337799117,
0.3395396769,
-0.1367084682,
0.0856501162,
-0.4278350472,
-0.0136875231,
0.2759833336,
0.1023121998,
-0.0047814324,
-0.383043617,
-0.0365354121,
-0.6207866669,
0.698433578,
-0.08533483,
0.0333387665,
-0.0254284386,
-0.0759015679,
0.0562219396,
0.7015353441,
0.588901937,
1.1287037134,
0.0293743424,
0.1633375138,
0.5094786286,
0.0124657536,
0.1245811433,
-0.1077648178,
0.1847742945,
-0.3695752323,
0.4170838296,
0.5918076634,
0.1590718627,
-0.95494169,
0.4585242569,
0.0027416719,
-0.3157459497,
-0.3962285817,
0.0671009272,
0.5209037662,
0.5636315942,
0.2513218224,
-0.2792602479,
0.0414491408,
-0.9239035249,
-0.3058853745,
0.4619375169,
-0.091345571,
-0.1205806732,
0.3925438225,
0.2092728466,
-0.2256891578,
0.6409263611,
-0.0830456614,
-0.6726360321,
0.4647115171,
0.5556288362,
0.5804955959,
-0.2256500423,
-0.0849876329,
0.2340094894,
0.3485637009,
-0.3745603859,
0.2394922227,
-0.0266107041,
-0.9443736672,
-0.8209682107,
-0.6061378717,
-0.8334326744,
0.128508836,
-0.2850991189,
0.0898587331,
-0.4128834009,
-0.1598998606,
0.1252567172,
-0.0650243312,
-0.4556745887,
0.2259903997,
0.5433959365,
1.1074267626,
-0.5279644728,
0.9125083685,
1.0513446331,
-0.318245858,
-0.6122903228,
-0.2307022363,
0.0467492528,
-0.4595567882,
0.6631085873,
0.1521265209,
-0.1628570706,
-0.335559845,
-0.9475499988,
-0.7761012316,
0.7622668147,
0.3548652232,
-0.5645111203,
-0.1072195992,
0.105549559,
0.5788722634,
-0.378592819,
0.2169974297,
0.8077786565,
0.8091078997,
0.291829586,
-0.8342865705,
-0.0864811689,
-0.1562668085,
-0.0052885599,
0.2512375712,
-0.5027216673,
0.8630132675,
-0.167646423,
-0.0784719586,
0.2489709109,
0.7838088274,
0.4149514437,
0.2213894576,
0.4643063247,
0.5690460205,
0.8938003778,
-0.2657008171,
1.0400180817,
0.0614738129,
0.0694444031,
0.7653529644,
-0.708923161,
0.8409771323,
0.2857943177,
-0.2585659623,
0.4910615087,
0.3778447211,
0.2462399602,
-0.097998783,
0.5038821101,
-0.4550542831,
-0.9493082166,
-0.2114041448,
-0.2008493394,
0.5647090673,
0.7924422622,
-0.2563580275,
0.0563229322,
-0.1089474708,
0.0830955282,
0.2266970277,
-0.7168778181,
0.6937791705,
0.347500056,
-0.9030986428,
0.2048825175,
-0.00079998,
0.5041170716,
-0.4677861631,
-0.1718736887,
0.0892329291,
0.1721933186,
-0.1430746317,
-1.3648617268,
0.4031325579,
0.0150073422,
-0.3053864539,
-0.2111486197,
1.1402744055,
-0.1659251302,
-0.2466194332,
0.2677203715,
0.841191709,
0.2089766562,
-0.1037361845,
-0.5759147406,
0.2571422458,
-0.0592274703,
-0.3000667095,
0.2782331109,
0.6795401573,
-0.1402285993,
1.0697648525,
0.6809927225,
0.2714215815,
-0.1598218977,
0.3032464683,
0.7719028592,
-1.0019500256,
-0.2730645835,
-0.7748016119,
0.3279395998,
-0.2722530663,
-0.195943594,
0.6151778102,
0.2195174396,
0.6673828363,
0.1206123978,
0.9815964103,
-0.0026446239,
0.7844462991,
-0.68139714,
0.3885879517,
-0.2752646208,
0.2346484363,
-0.0454774648,
-0.9740403295,
-0.3672069907,
0.7786096931,
-0.8368863463,
0.0439610146,
0.5942158103,
0.5267675519,
0.1432280988,
0.3825879693,
0.5644910932,
0.3133845329,
0.2948099971,
0.4550919831,
1.5076793432,
0.2323175222,
0.3393966556,
0.0671324655,
-0.0569222383,
-0.0520928577,
-0.8944449425,
-1.0055228472,
-0.5059611201,
-0.095480822,
-0.076954484,
-0.0921589509,
0.8877514601,
0.5754454136,
-0.5930694342,
-0.268166095,
0.0139468564,
0.4927424192,
0.0118363854,
-0.1693880409,
0.0213917438,
-0.3306803107,
-0.6505859494,
0.433288455,
0.4778813422,
-0.2192044705,
-0.5554984808,
-0.0794785544,
-0.4159069657,
0.291921407,
0.9266006351,
0.4425041676,
-0.9509118795,
-0.3386995494,
-0.2220886946,
0.0589761697,
-0.2100131363,
0.9164633155,
-0.6302076578,
0.2026751786,
0.6635189056,
0.6349229217,
0.2733962238,
-0.3342497647,
0.4415467381,
-0.1714313179,
0.0149635859,
0.4634188116,
0.7629045248,
0.4901598692,
-0.0227213651,
0.5350583792,
0.0072919857,
-0.9180952907,
-0.7390432954,
0.4910592735,
-0.8557136655,
-0.5934096575,
1.4685680866,
0.0942205042,
-0.142905876,
-0.3306166232,
-0.3944363594,
0.0162805002,
-0.0943714678,
0.3130837083,
0.9489902854,
-0.2403878868,
-0.4524001777,
-0.7172327042,
0.229905799,
0.2672839463,
-1.1123507023,
0.3122590184,
0.6296803951,
0.0664242879,
0.0772064179,
0.5665210485,
-0.0973940566,
0.1008458436,
-0.2478597313,
-0.1754651964,
0.2258600295,
-0.2889046073,
-0.1600521058,
0.1481678039,
0.5900147557,
0.5766878724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10400v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10400v1 | Contrastive Learning Reduces Hallucination in Conversations | 2022-12-20T16:26:18 | 2022-12-20T16:26:18 | Weiwei Sun, Zhengliang Shi, Shen Gao, Pengjie Ren, Maarten de Rijke, Zhaochun Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-trained language models (LMs) store knowledge in their parameters and can
generate informative responses when used in conversational systems. However,
LMs suffer from the problem of "hallucination:" they may generate
plausible-looking statements that are irrelevant or factually incorrect. To
address this problem, we propose a contrastive learning scheme, named MixCL. A
novel mixed contrastive objective is proposed to explicitly optimize the
implicit knowledge elicitation process of LMs, and thus reduce their
hallucination in conversations. We also examine negative sampling strategies of
retrieved hard negatives and model-generated negatives. We conduct experiments
on Wizard-of-Wikipedia, a public, open-domain knowledge-grounded dialogue
benchmark, and assess the effectiveness of MixCL. MixCL effectively reduces the
hallucination of LMs in conversations and achieves the highest performance
among LM-based dialogue agents in terms of relevancy and factuality. We show
that MixCL achieves comparable performance to state-of-the-art KB-based
approaches while enjoying notable advantages in terms of efficiency and
scalability. | [
-0.6991311312,
-0.669265151,
0.4484377205,
0.0735598654,
-0.3183388412,
0.0916979462,
-0.3147065639,
-0.6286151409,
0.2991636395,
0.4519500732,
-0.540068686,
-0.6142693162,
-0.3606488407,
-0.0323732756,
-0.3846003413,
1.0742824078,
0.1833464652,
0.3106762767,
-0.2046201974,
-0.2306037843,
-0.2620026469,
-0.402459085,
-0.6552526355,
-0.6771271825,
0.8507223725,
0.3066948652,
0.8409291506,
0.0462924764,
-0.1174308956,
0.280138284,
-0.1112952605,
0.4334696829,
-0.9755565524,
0.4172232449,
-0.2031415403,
-0.4954615235,
0.093087025,
0.0939044282,
0.0531138666,
0.8666137457,
-0.2541125417,
-0.5125418305,
0.1812612712,
0.6065816283,
-0.7787910104,
0.0871242508,
-0.8606380224,
0.0545128249,
0.5485239029,
-0.4416932762,
-0.3453913331,
-0.3990651667,
0.3491210043,
-0.7799075246,
0.3268916309,
-0.0024846857,
0.7386611104,
0.3069448173,
-0.1585676819,
-0.5933149457,
-0.612654686,
0.8225656152,
-0.6616309881,
0.5787178874,
0.2753209174,
0.2940812111,
-0.0317346826,
-0.3003738225,
-0.9162119031,
-0.2451407462,
-0.3615863025,
0.2737647295,
0.2980819941,
0.1026324108,
-0.0779736638,
0.3898832798,
-0.5114545822,
-0.2066474408,
-0.5782614946,
-0.3120818436,
0.1911349595,
-0.03182818,
0.2119847089,
0.14031519,
-0.2210811973,
-0.2447358519,
-0.6619577408,
-0.3786556125,
0.2109561861,
0.3214330375,
-0.1751919687,
0.3806580305,
-0.4141182601,
0.4209267199,
0.2208657414,
-0.2149058431,
0.4428842366,
-0.1823409945,
-0.155671984,
0.2450571209,
0.3824300468,
0.4467536807,
0.2794587314,
-0.3871076703,
-0.240222767,
0.3137866855,
0.2205737829,
-0.9513790011,
-0.4897328913,
0.2708765566,
-0.1454228759,
-0.3155402541,
-0.2024119049,
-0.7545779943,
-0.4709613025,
-0.6366594434,
0.6398143768,
-0.5264194012,
-0.1865461916,
0.1021159217,
-0.0645748079,
0.3029989004,
0.7169712186,
-0.6215735078,
0.6265211105,
0.4252803326,
0.5772964358,
-0.3200817704,
-0.1058184281,
-0.6354580522,
0.011424399,
-0.4379047155,
0.6868699193,
-0.4367719591,
-0.3793376088,
0.0062380461,
-0.3855178654,
0.0394280553,
-0.9251871109,
0.2380535156,
-0.5627173185,
0.5949262381,
-0.1757243872,
-0.2896795571,
-0.3237304091,
0.504391253,
-0.4849186838,
0.7889302373,
-0.0836042166,
-0.7743735313,
0.3806143105,
-0.1224577427,
-0.3905591965,
-0.0743345991,
-0.571998477,
-0.1957448721,
-0.0648745224,
0.2096469402,
0.2719643116,
-0.1063154712,
0.2513596416,
-0.1586266905,
-0.7142497897,
0.2627863586,
-0.2069585919,
0.4705269933,
0.465703249,
-0.3910465539,
0.1067785248,
-0.8137026429,
-0.1356436759,
0.0198753253,
-0.181083113,
-0.5297108889,
-0.0727526024,
-0.3027982712,
0.3828587532,
-0.0698022842,
-0.2181744576,
-0.3076511621,
-0.6433315873,
-0.2845562994,
0.5632458329,
-0.0971250236,
0.3699917197,
-0.5588133931,
0.1259429306,
0.6005776525,
-0.1984644383,
-0.1166253984,
-0.1713164449,
-1.4385298491,
-0.2999735475,
0.0034560491,
0.4896552563,
-1.2195419073,
0.427092135,
0.06569428,
-0.2636967003,
-0.8088006377,
0.2412660718,
0.5186582208,
0.6954337358,
0.6640837193,
-0.1064705923,
-0.4313745499,
-0.7813287377,
-0.0903993323,
-0.1311193705,
-0.0492478237,
0.6347221136,
0.3971408904,
-0.2955306768,
0.5068480968,
-0.4252629578,
0.0477215089,
-0.2015903443,
0.3426495194,
0.0793196559,
0.395270288,
0.0831232294,
-0.9331914186,
-0.5544660687,
-0.025851123,
-0.8179746866,
-0.1238485351,
-0.0683859885,
-0.2313908041,
0.125509426,
0.4503749609,
-0.6796199083,
0.2470085025,
0.4285402,
-0.1268583685,
0.3753196001,
-0.1565576047,
0.3162901402,
-0.9032813311,
-0.0902367905,
-0.133775562,
-0.252864033,
-0.6563889384,
-0.2711167932,
-0.2331927419,
-0.1551592499,
-0.5708824396,
0.5043292046,
-0.3294104636,
0.0429300666,
-0.2449765354,
0.4173763096,
0.0018749537,
0.7528105378,
0.3694761395,
0.8671090007,
0.3581146002,
-1.0809506178,
-0.0796791613,
0.098906368,
-0.2716929913,
0.6889073253,
-0.466283232,
0.1523166001,
-0.4246994257,
0.1035943702,
-1.005261898,
-0.0327003673,
0.5680564046,
-0.333203882,
0.2804154456,
0.4537082911,
-0.137643531,
0.176550433,
-0.3571079671,
0.4208513796,
0.5594338775,
-0.8426173329,
0.5272794962,
0.1357141435,
-0.0475573502,
-0.6540479064,
-0.50097996,
-0.2582841814,
-0.1488839537,
-0.4042689204,
0.4053633511,
-0.3264545798,
-0.459167093,
-0.0525096059,
-0.2580754459,
0.1223584414,
-0.0991473645,
0.0179158039,
0.1648897827,
-0.1416753978,
0.1326666325,
0.0389598496,
-0.0445683971,
-0.0700770915,
-0.210807994,
0.7343839407,
0.0369615741,
-0.2660195231,
-0.2815158069,
0.2425270379,
0.3239843845,
0.3877405524,
0.8643907905,
0.3357081115,
-0.127122581,
-0.6159336567,
-0.7460817099,
-0.5902507305,
-0.4492636025,
0.169347629,
-0.3917401731,
-0.9066613913,
0.4744233191,
-0.1334676594,
-0.0832658485,
0.1355139166,
0.4709191024,
-0.1414477229,
0.7022805214,
0.3080060184,
0.1275466532,
0.4577235281,
0.0987065658,
0.30331406,
-0.383992821,
-0.3261645734,
-0.4624859989,
-0.1247821972,
-0.4459381998,
-0.6452951431,
0.1965747178,
0.08986485,
-0.1482762247,
0.0042378702,
-0.3588572443,
0.6086396575,
0.3409474492,
0.4105671048,
0.3637028635,
0.0448283516,
-0.5348669291,
-0.1998992413,
-0.7042912841,
-0.2397356182,
0.8756569028,
-0.0203120615,
0.8472798467,
-0.0855534822,
0.9506835938,
0.2304196209,
0.3339757919,
-0.4979023039,
0.6415733695,
0.3762532771,
-0.4541743994,
-0.257537663,
-0.7093585134,
-0.6015903354,
0.8658415079,
-0.3502347171,
-0.5387101769,
0.1965433657,
0.0823789164,
0.1406013817,
-0.0300682802,
-0.6711925268,
0.4505006075,
-0.0931401327,
-0.5082063675,
-0.4443749785,
-0.7090596557,
0.4741587341,
-0.0470356569,
0.2959997952,
0.2014137357,
0.1788132936,
0.4498818517,
-0.3367654383,
0.9436957836,
-0.0805643275,
-0.2109233886,
0.1410091072,
0.156510666,
0.5348543525,
-0.1136523783,
0.1267244071,
-0.1226363108,
-0.3596282005,
-0.4464537799,
-0.8761408329,
0.646140933,
-0.8458718657,
-0.5358116031,
-0.2331656069,
-0.4919531643,
-0.3744188249,
-0.0533746034,
0.1998155415,
0.0766252205,
-0.4449889362,
0.113269344,
1.1030169725,
-0.4549028277,
-0.04337034,
0.6160865426,
-0.3451884985,
-0.5784745812,
1.1586322784,
-0.1458604336,
0.5121199489,
0.4374369085,
0.0930826515,
-0.2177224606,
-0.4516867697,
0.0730974376,
0.4224446416,
-1.1452730894,
0.0813229159,
-0.74119699,
-0.3787526488,
-0.1633727401,
-0.3256942332,
-0.3623488545,
-0.2847827971,
-0.3652727604,
-0.126845479,
-0.1861011833,
0.504298985,
0.0366586708,
0.0640919879,
-0.2492041737,
0.596491456,
0.4975708425,
0.1406305134,
0.0656267405,
-0.4511426687,
-0.0485341288,
0.042225305,
-0.1920018494,
-0.6569686532,
0.4466816485,
0.0232022218,
0.8107730746,
0.5013790131,
0.2913615704,
0.6304323673,
-0.1362024248,
0.5843431354,
0.5090069175,
-0.7991196513,
0.3050642908,
-0.0902730972,
0.2412826121,
0.9456098676,
0.6012270451,
-0.4694691896,
-0.7334392667,
-0.5097737908,
-0.7295668125,
0.6039627194,
0.4396706522,
0.0861791819,
-0.1041862369,
-0.0860754624,
0.5002478361,
0.5811449289,
-1.0446366072,
-0.3884931803,
-0.3046790957,
-0.3197972775,
-0.2275949419,
-0.2801916897,
-0.3582881391,
-0.3308656812,
0.9019198418,
-0.0699475855,
-0.0093457997,
0.1533215344,
-0.4262503684,
0.0797845796,
0.4117923677,
0.7413345575,
0.5589335561,
-0.2809697092,
0.6032562256,
0.2837783098,
-0.2040941268,
-0.0042096074,
-0.04815007,
-0.352200985,
0.1193528548,
-0.0012480357,
0.8157298565,
0.5467426181,
-0.7944130898,
0.337043047,
-0.0171175003,
-0.4431901872,
0.0781326219,
0.3085834086,
0.1414941549,
0.4396746457,
0.1427545249,
-0.086492829,
0.2558504343,
-0.5406138301,
0.236925602,
0.3321247399,
-0.3901387155,
-0.0472868271,
0.3370227218,
0.4528397918,
-0.2025641799,
0.4085577726,
-0.0955087394,
-0.576736927,
0.164340198,
0.7076132894,
0.6623116136,
-0.1384172291,
0.3484304845,
0.1826565266,
0.1015535146,
0.0324966051,
0.2248726487,
-0.6250942349,
-1.0335636139,
-0.0415775217,
-0.4830585718,
-0.6640127897,
0.3100729585,
-0.3247406185,
0.2505964339,
-0.272601217,
0.3585273623,
-0.2000046223,
-0.0187002756,
-0.6727351546,
0.3507082462,
0.2672879398,
0.364638716,
-0.7968605161,
0.8348765373,
0.1047190651,
-0.5240334868,
-0.4359147847,
0.112904802,
-0.1762656569,
-0.7625489235,
0.7669540644,
0.4424846768,
-0.5172920227,
-0.0422084294,
-0.6374044418,
-0.3961705565,
0.8676157594,
0.3217404783,
-0.4756131768,
0.0840149075,
0.08570721,
0.4596097171,
-0.5857846141,
0.3618836105,
0.3272465169,
0.2690826952,
0.6059666276,
-0.6394566298,
0.1071590781,
-0.3788685501,
-0.2487809956,
-0.0766034201,
-0.3405796885,
0.8186126351,
-0.0110767409,
-0.315718919,
-0.1967977583,
0.6379862428,
0.6182363629,
0.5140115619,
0.5561161637,
0.4194152951,
0.9744115472,
0.1900771111,
0.6924983263,
-0.2791036069,
0.0288870148,
1.2395973206,
-0.4687836468,
0.5906386375,
0.8082548976,
0.0751009211,
0.5872221589,
0.3340328336,
0.2716333866,
0.8931221962,
0.3343848288,
-0.5754960775,
-0.289290905,
-0.0626863018,
-0.4067196846,
-0.1538838595,
0.5294533968,
-0.2614106834,
-0.3195804656,
-0.0643920824,
-0.095541358,
0.25124681,
-0.0675327554,
1.0582395792,
0.198051542,
-0.8101652861,
0.9368211627,
-0.4471802413,
0.7712809443,
-0.4225375354,
-0.401840359,
-0.3642480373,
0.087458618,
-0.2255619913,
-0.180720225,
0.0053704265,
-0.3571679294,
0.0565020777,
-0.0271124598,
0.7777744532,
-1.0161606073,
-0.0194581989,
0.569249332,
0.6219400167,
0.4141329825,
0.036782708,
-0.5956838727,
0.078864038,
-0.0189301465,
-0.0164137091,
0.4213991165,
0.5221082568,
0.2543244362,
0.539247632,
0.6098595262,
0.1051538959,
-0.1126913279,
0.2451167852,
1.250551939,
-0.6670664549,
-0.6734553576,
-0.5785802007,
0.5025035739,
-0.3122066557,
0.0545771308,
0.5420092344,
0.5144763589,
1.0509768724,
0.0066828006,
0.8151158094,
0.4829621613,
0.5597683787,
-0.7006552815,
0.6341310143,
-0.612193644,
0.5536490083,
-0.2724731266,
-1.1100018024,
-0.1767950803,
0.8535025716,
-0.3096857965,
0.1592509747,
0.9625370502,
1.0810496807,
-0.1211815923,
0.1927244365,
0.7288091183,
0.0515459925,
0.0945918709,
0.4354033768,
1.1450124979,
-0.2207105309,
0.597402513,
-0.2381263971,
0.0144145181,
-0.3450177312,
-0.5113435388,
-1.3238530159,
-0.3111445904,
-0.1971414089,
-0.562849164,
0.4003311694,
0.9580581188,
0.7372124791,
-0.9543694258,
-0.3189122677,
-0.3319439292,
0.2901432216,
0.1793594211,
-0.2091656625,
0.0162090342,
-0.7862974405,
-0.525891304,
0.5113919973,
0.1635641158,
0.1051319689,
-0.2335734665,
-0.6712249517,
-0.1365022212,
0.4344165325,
0.4466400743,
0.1883206367,
-0.7430936098,
-0.1337716132,
-0.2964628339,
-0.4162113965,
0.2875624597,
0.8607853651,
-0.94613415,
0.6620320678,
0.3643391132,
0.6126938462,
0.9118213058,
0.0440656841,
0.6623619795,
-0.486679405,
0.4897529483,
0.3330757916,
-0.0281536207,
0.3944996893,
-0.2400295287,
0.3190820217,
0.3265392482,
-0.1913624108,
-0.5448223352,
0.1314883679,
-0.8261530399,
-0.7218201756,
1.0719105005,
0.1524242014,
-0.0404086523,
-0.3761576116,
-0.406037122,
0.2864228487,
-0.5037969351,
0.9899761677,
0.7211888433,
-0.0439821035,
-0.2160445899,
-0.2173840851,
0.6380420327,
0.6239474416,
-0.9612205625,
-0.2484568357,
0.6920743585,
0.106575191,
0.2539092898,
0.7559970021,
0.0594522245,
0.1761053652,
0.2440814227,
0.1433857679,
0.1453339756,
-0.5840408206,
-0.2092778385,
0.3244732022,
-0.0632081032,
0.1016864106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10397v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10397v3 | Needle in a Haystack: An Analysis of High-Agreement Workers on MTurk for Summarization | 2022-12-20T16:25:42 | 2023-06-14T01:45:33 | Lining Zhang, Simon Mille, Yufang Hou, Daniel Deutsch, Elizabeth Clark, Yixin Liu, Saad Mahamood, Sebastian Gehrmann, Miruna Clinciu, Khyathi Chandu, João Sedoc | cs.CL | cs.CL | To prevent the costly and inefficient use of resources on low-quality
annotations, we want a method for creating a pool of dependable annotators who
can effectively complete difficult tasks, such as evaluating automatic
summarization. Thus, we investigate the recruitment of high-quality Amazon
Mechanical Turk workers via a two-step pipeline. We show that we can
successfully filter out subpar workers before they carry out the evaluations
and obtain high-agreement annotations with similar constraints on resources.
Although our workers demonstrate a strong consensus among themselves and
CloudResearch workers, their alignment with expert judgments on a subset of the
data is not as expected and needs further training in correctness. This paper
still serves as a best practice for the recruitment of qualified annotators in
other challenging annotation tasks. | [
-0.3887910545,
-0.1661131233,
0.4147272706,
-0.0613401532,
-0.5669100881,
0.1495026797,
0.2822897136,
-0.6345595717,
0.7670224309,
0.9525728226,
-0.5207532048,
-0.4147725403,
-0.8870400786,
0.4441206455,
-0.5724335313,
1.3531159163,
0.0903376341,
-0.5711863041,
-0.3222684264,
-0.5346515179,
-0.4866973758,
-0.3684825897,
-0.448558867,
-0.0353046805,
0.7458058596,
0.5119908452,
0.8876206279,
0.9992378354,
0.6921363473,
0.281475693,
0.014135655,
0.3614214361,
-0.6276776195,
0.4357099235,
-0.3294552565,
-0.5001984239,
-0.1817603856,
0.4074737728,
0.3213370442,
0.7240730524,
-0.0641186982,
0.6150032282,
-0.0059110261,
0.8157610893,
-0.9571881294,
-0.1984194219,
-0.6814781427,
0.0975729674,
-0.483751744,
-0.0764237419,
-0.2561038733,
-0.2718253732,
0.0267890207,
-0.7594532371,
0.4297058284,
0.0732734352,
0.9188659787,
0.5581067801,
-0.2708380818,
-0.0933160409,
-0.2763784528,
0.6581947207,
-0.4654230773,
-0.1990617663,
1.0639981031,
0.2352456301,
-0.0769539401,
-0.603374958,
-0.429911375,
0.3472643495,
-0.4456783235,
0.3078145385,
0.2561942637,
-0.2137768716,
0.166310057,
0.3150933981,
-0.4833162427,
0.3287515342,
-0.5291351676,
0.1248112693,
0.7288674712,
0.3408843875,
-0.2846143544,
-0.3181648552,
-0.1134262159,
0.1821550727,
-0.4660437107,
0.0382828005,
0.6052249074,
0.311527133,
0.110754244,
0.6560854912,
-0.4611778855,
0.6051672101,
0.0766651258,
0.1505479664,
0.1166630164,
-0.3051812649,
-0.1041477248,
-0.0793706551,
0.7956183553,
0.4179960787,
-0.0539913289,
0.0955861881,
-0.4194574356,
-0.2457167506,
0.5503642559,
-0.5859984756,
-0.0688988641,
0.4855121672,
-0.6777113676,
-0.4055443406,
0.3853723109,
-0.4296500385,
-0.8642956018,
-0.0882474259,
0.4571472406,
0.1394120455,
-0.2334079295,
-0.4149164259,
-0.387337178,
-0.230532378,
0.3913236558,
-0.9575164914,
-0.1034507379,
1.0056762695,
1.1532279253,
0.3526079357,
-0.5981670618,
-0.9369789362,
0.2320606709,
-0.6762789488,
0.9287689328,
-0.2797937989,
-0.1188645288,
0.3337099254,
0.1147940606,
0.1020428911,
-0.4674233198,
0.2413952351,
-0.3875312507,
0.471879065,
-0.4188916385,
-0.2424044013,
-0.3256792128,
0.1197044998,
-0.7276021838,
0.9824629426,
0.6199384928,
-0.8171669245,
0.7858153582,
-0.628061533,
-0.3625240624,
0.3173162937,
0.0558192953,
-0.2881804407,
0.0957999676,
0.2210245132,
0.8334268928,
-0.0057573887,
-0.2754556239,
-0.175796032,
-0.8454717398,
0.463909775,
0.5549753904,
1.0161645412,
0.2021901459,
-0.1030082107,
0.1980042309,
-0.2601593435,
-0.5604024529,
-0.2436770648,
-0.2950944006,
-0.473451376,
-0.0365120135,
0.0245524272,
0.2216953039,
0.020961497,
-0.3462646306,
0.3309041858,
-0.1954343468,
0.2818266451,
0.8573122621,
0.1152475551,
0.0658636764,
-0.5892750025,
0.3392562568,
-0.3200529814,
0.1448406428,
-0.3238570094,
-0.130857259,
-0.8032688498,
-0.4961091578,
0.4956424534,
0.3713299036,
-0.8433901668,
0.6645669937,
-0.0755466744,
-0.7590799928,
-0.9369350076,
0.2740386426,
0.2607657611,
0.3600642681,
0.2131815404,
-0.5106950402,
-0.6191003323,
-0.7665452957,
-0.4463770688,
-0.2570122182,
-0.419066757,
-0.3185647726,
0.5689430237,
-0.1851925701,
0.7506777644,
-0.0565540902,
-0.7341426015,
0.0796200782,
0.4546239674,
0.5871980786,
0.4523415267,
0.4542807043,
-0.4809939265,
-0.4919872284,
-0.1331816316,
-0.8823700547,
0.1191061363,
-0.3446883857,
-0.4063986838,
0.3767296672,
0.3799344897,
-0.5047069788,
0.2902205586,
0.4267627001,
-0.5241624713,
0.330629766,
-0.1013745591,
0.4624800086,
-0.9003779888,
0.4110238552,
-0.0126816165,
-0.497246474,
-0.2138976306,
0.0051931725,
-0.1336175054,
0.002463581,
-0.2170071006,
-0.0463666469,
-0.1269932538,
0.1102017239,
-0.4140933752,
0.3160911798,
-0.155673787,
0.278845489,
0.0357288904,
0.6964393854,
0.1189524829,
-0.4954982698,
0.364046067,
0.6291286349,
-0.2735123038,
1.0380414724,
-0.4142991304,
0.2265141606,
-0.1987285912,
0.3103607297,
-0.844594121,
-0.4351621568,
0.083425872,
-0.664721489,
-0.0795521289,
-0.4586639106,
-0.6393017769,
-0.307831496,
-0.4882716537,
0.0823620781,
0.6483649611,
-0.5068334341,
0.374702096,
0.6918004155,
-0.4147779047,
-0.9317985773,
-0.8492250443,
0.3942809999,
-0.2519702017,
-0.242708981,
-0.0546578951,
0.6129978299,
-0.013527086,
0.0193371866,
0.086555168,
-0.2026683539,
0.0743750408,
0.2967016697,
0.1511264443,
0.0483198054,
-0.0983723849,
-0.2509282231,
-0.5330404639,
0.031071933,
-0.110892579,
-0.0771336108,
0.2408470362,
-0.1880355626,
-0.651322186,
0.5493289232,
0.7310196757,
-0.266777575,
0.758895874,
0.7213305831,
-0.4337585568,
0.2716515362,
-0.9346311688,
-0.0115147689,
-0.424631238,
0.415686518,
-0.0939053521,
-0.6142188907,
0.6621521711,
0.1850522757,
0.7333301902,
0.9392358065,
0.5033233166,
-0.6724463105,
0.7538597584,
0.5237770081,
0.0654512644,
0.4521187544,
-0.3064342439,
-0.1692569554,
-0.6511164904,
0.0506261438,
-0.7013573647,
-0.4274503589,
-0.5533958673,
-0.0491288677,
0.3737924695,
-0.0967055485,
-0.0232019629,
0.5400439501,
-0.7786032557,
0.6733751297,
0.9229450226,
0.0233662538,
0.1223454475,
-0.3233605921,
0.3328891397,
0.0502274781,
-0.5149472356,
-0.5177615285,
0.9245010018,
0.166507557,
0.1188183129,
0.0958378166,
0.7160210013,
0.3671599329,
0.1476012766,
-0.4705586433,
0.3133968711,
-0.3111503124,
-0.6115310192,
-0.5943278074,
-0.1869440526,
-1.1497172117,
0.3852933645,
-0.7354959846,
-0.4174390733,
0.3404799998,
0.0496061444,
-0.6076132059,
0.242244646,
-0.3992206454,
0.8336924314,
0.2545999885,
-0.2721619606,
-0.5543048978,
-0.834864676,
0.2500968277,
-0.3312270939,
0.4943039119,
-0.3264738917,
-0.2654652297,
1.1790857315,
-0.8536838889,
0.663926363,
-0.4401596189,
0.3438562453,
0.3948617876,
0.2398544252,
0.6255424023,
-0.1889332086,
-0.3051837087,
0.2857685983,
0.3949213028,
-0.850387156,
-0.3765887618,
0.0177699216,
-0.4599489868,
-0.377748847,
-0.5904098153,
-0.427686125,
0.0624059625,
0.1792376488,
0.2095859796,
0.0388556533,
0.3592666388,
0.408585161,
0.1155405715,
0.3460947275,
0.4333117306,
0.1210004687,
0.1313764751,
-0.7534111142,
0.8489001393,
0.4594347775,
-0.112024717,
0.0788562223,
0.0702870935,
-0.0226324741,
-0.6209055185,
-0.593336761,
0.1575511694,
-0.5811911225,
-0.4537054598,
-0.4400214255,
0.1235757694,
-0.1810507029,
-0.5296962857,
-0.3417251408,
-0.567412734,
-0.0553255342,
0.0274683591,
0.573854804,
0.7851464152,
-0.082649909,
0.3604355156,
-0.9240762591,
0.1243656948,
0.4835104346,
0.2095725983,
-0.4708935022,
-0.4754273593,
-1.1648207903,
-0.2347167581,
-0.0710557252,
-0.5568957329,
0.0148559241,
-0.0960577726,
0.3468023539,
0.4339457452,
0.283751756,
0.8218619227,
0.048029881,
0.8967924118,
0.3214703202,
-0.8552712798,
0.3701864779,
-0.6741709113,
0.2683656812,
1.0394103527,
0.1972923726,
-0.9949635863,
-0.8280947804,
-0.6134742498,
-0.9674888849,
0.7685364485,
0.2377334684,
-0.0469054878,
0.3255741596,
0.3586060703,
0.5644325018,
0.2720243633,
-0.1258218139,
0.2129766494,
-0.3713568151,
-0.2962857485,
-0.024387924,
-0.337389797,
-0.2968777716,
0.0775191188,
0.6931281686,
-0.0061987746,
0.0356871188,
-0.0295267384,
-0.1586024165,
-0.3749615848,
-0.233452782,
0.3634834588,
1.1092476845,
-0.1828699112,
0.2876369357,
0.2736293674,
-0.5345201492,
-0.0898389369,
0.1204176471,
-0.141199708,
0.2594251037,
0.8005830646,
0.3799639344,
-0.1483019888,
-0.5231895447,
0.8326281905,
0.1145208105,
-0.4298865795,
-0.2984846234,
0.087421976,
-0.0984684005,
0.2664094269,
0.6487879753,
0.0410051607,
0.051381804,
-0.2458821982,
-0.014169896,
0.3528767228,
-0.3008150756,
0.1111695617,
0.4499470294,
0.5862708092,
-0.52034235,
0.750662744,
-0.1342087835,
-0.3274210393,
0.2094698995,
-0.2205500156,
0.7786247134,
-0.1177785769,
-0.1024281979,
0.3348615766,
0.4609009027,
-0.2101481557,
0.0320442244,
0.0081924582,
-0.0252160784,
-0.6752072573,
-0.0187936947,
-0.8201674223,
-0.4667544663,
-0.5809728503,
0.3455125093,
-0.3037321568,
-0.205205515,
-0.1500224769,
0.0853099599,
-0.7167115808,
-0.0251891278,
-0.5056483746,
0.2118725628,
-0.8630251884,
0.377405256,
0.7209613323,
-0.7102741599,
-0.1803995073,
-0.2294129431,
-0.0848552808,
-0.6711289883,
0.3120143414,
0.256521225,
0.1768140346,
-0.4564957619,
-0.355712086,
-0.4962833226,
0.9651399255,
0.2643105984,
-0.1728062481,
-0.0318705887,
-0.1246959195,
0.2274242193,
-0.1579841077,
0.4911001027,
0.548586309,
0.3997145593,
-0.0328388885,
-1.2611956596,
0.1359791309,
-0.1940323859,
-0.2380527705,
0.3174872994,
-0.5890476704,
0.8032796383,
-0.1216552332,
-0.0897679478,
-0.1013660654,
0.5900296569,
0.1618935615,
0.3887452781,
0.7822530866,
0.2608926594,
0.9318885207,
0.0173256993,
0.5377607942,
0.084496595,
0.4245162904,
0.8065095544,
0.2007938474,
1.0262640715,
0.7942349911,
-0.3776446581,
0.6307223439,
1.046107769,
-0.1554509848,
0.2540788949,
0.0723426938,
-0.0110306563,
-0.2832860947,
-0.3493144214,
-0.0844695121,
0.4241992235,
0.143972978,
-0.3075754642,
0.0639531165,
-0.2416893393,
-0.1323104948,
0.187328577,
-0.3164994717,
1.0957483053,
-0.1038494036,
-0.5268082619,
0.4783962667,
-0.243595019,
0.7494002581,
-0.2542648315,
-0.1921836883,
-0.1165829822,
-0.2531759441,
-0.6768998504,
-0.6861821413,
0.4354894459,
-0.0228139013,
-0.0950802937,
-0.1751879901,
0.2317231447,
-0.3335000277,
-0.2867143154,
-0.4619946778,
0.3681463301,
0.5673927069,
-0.2321161926,
-0.4368258715,
-0.2366303802,
-0.4851714969,
-0.1596721262,
0.0338252299,
0.6197276711,
0.0989953876,
0.1875596792,
0.741065383,
0.166582197,
-0.4344376028,
-0.3244431317,
0.3166321218,
-0.7310088277,
-0.962656498,
-0.7515221834,
0.8421999812,
-0.4098356962,
-0.4647421837,
0.5051926374,
0.6047952175,
0.9261094332,
-0.0538077429,
0.705229342,
0.1302154809,
0.9005460739,
-0.4229576588,
1.0245053768,
-0.395373553,
-0.3131411076,
-0.2547370493,
-0.7737824321,
-0.3508761823,
0.8931607008,
0.1834536642,
-0.1847374737,
0.9914881587,
0.4111954868,
0.1244052574,
-0.1539274156,
0.0997767597,
-0.1573284566,
0.1435231119,
0.2804247737,
0.7243305445,
-0.4074342251,
0.5268297195,
-0.3554094732,
-0.1973209828,
-0.6286597848,
-0.9503263235,
-1.0948392153,
-0.687484324,
-0.4484209418,
-0.4897820354,
-0.1271395236,
1.2279413939,
0.8012232184,
-0.5480155945,
-0.5875317454,
0.2747986019,
0.2666784823,
-0.7235328555,
-0.1440247893,
0.6149898171,
-0.3013518453,
-0.5245854855,
-0.0802718028,
0.1732234508,
-0.1892455369,
-0.357708782,
0.0079722283,
-0.1614335477,
-0.2901335061,
0.4472871125,
0.1376201361,
-0.6511259079,
-0.22322914,
-0.4507763088,
-0.1110038459,
-0.1053946167,
0.903309226,
-0.7407231927,
0.5049717426,
0.465567112,
0.787719667,
0.6370849609,
0.0817885399,
0.2721089423,
-0.4930174649,
0.2320620567,
0.2919445038,
0.2778142691,
0.2513376474,
-0.4962376654,
0.8621758819,
0.2548620701,
-0.6919905543,
-1.0790596008,
-0.2923050225,
-0.5278111696,
-0.0817974582,
0.6717336774,
-0.0366111211,
-0.0546783619,
-0.3709441125,
-0.3637765646,
0.3741284907,
-0.4345732629,
1.1656544209,
0.7486539483,
-0.3211047351,
0.076969251,
-0.6564743519,
0.4220172167,
0.4589926898,
-0.6604052186,
0.3393303752,
0.4787390828,
-0.136394605,
0.1775314361,
0.7126897573,
0.3537963033,
0.5468400121,
0.1065149233,
0.0741185322,
-0.4813711345,
-0.0150078256,
-0.0863038525,
0.1572369486,
0.3651798069,
-0.5383303761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10392v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10392v1 | Debiasing Stance Detection Models with Counterfactual Reasoning and Adversarial Bias Learning | 2022-12-20T16:20:56 | 2022-12-20T16:20:56 | Jianhua Yuan, Yanyan Zhao, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Stance detection models may tend to rely on dataset bias in the text part as
a shortcut and thus fail to sufficiently learn the interaction between the
targets and texts. Recent debiasing methods usually treated features learned by
small models or big models at earlier steps as bias features and proposed to
exclude the branch learning those bias features during inference. However, most
of these methods fail to disentangle the ``good'' stance features and ``bad''
bias features in the text part. In this paper, we investigate how to mitigate
dataset bias in stance detection. Motivated by causal effects, we leverage a
novel counterfactual inference framework, which enables us to capture the
dataset bias in the text part as the direct causal effect of the text on
stances and reduce the dataset bias in the text part by subtracting the direct
text effect from the total causal effect. We novelly model bias features as
features that correlate with the stance labels but fail on intermediate stance
reasoning subtasks and propose an adversarial bias learning module to model the
bias more accurately. To verify whether our model could better model the
interaction between texts and targets, we test our model on recently proposed
test sets to evaluate the understanding of the task from various aspects.
Experiments demonstrate that our proposed method (1) could better model the
bias features, and (2) outperforms existing debiasing baselines on both the
original dataset and most of the newly constructed test sets. | [
-0.5948004723,
-1.0423125029,
0.5731340051,
-0.1752270907,
-0.3888343275,
-0.480014205,
0.2753673792,
-0.1522319019,
0.152768299,
0.4259607792,
-0.7679166198,
-0.5669646263,
-0.8643101454,
-0.2432927638,
-0.2402669638,
1.2434676886,
0.1040557325,
0.3864898086,
-0.1065356582,
-0.4424948692,
-0.5162727833,
-0.3859345019,
-0.556969583,
-0.6885532737,
0.3133409619,
0.2082725018,
0.9735882282,
0.3671805561,
0.1810603589,
0.1539994925,
-0.2902418077,
-0.1734841466,
-0.3955865502,
-0.057772994,
-0.4704118371,
-0.4407369494,
-0.2951548994,
0.4479447603,
0.5571261644,
0.5891550779,
0.3239617646,
-0.0643812642,
-0.0643427297,
0.5446257591,
-0.5846418142,
-0.0857796147,
-0.5441296697,
0.2312725931,
-0.1111789718,
0.2440316826,
-0.3959733844,
-0.0978088751,
0.2022318393,
-0.6093218923,
0.3026635945,
-0.113698341,
0.8614147902,
0.49672243,
-0.6545065045,
-0.0796761438,
-0.4626011848,
0.8966380954,
-0.7344275117,
0.2963688672,
0.5139999986,
-0.044054918,
-0.1346563846,
-0.0136879114,
-0.7251964808,
-0.1479368359,
-0.1391008049,
0.1682402492,
-0.3249504268,
-0.0314081311,
0.4320674837,
0.0779064074,
-0.5277298689,
0.167190522,
0.1506067514,
0.0544986129,
0.4081591368,
0.0385224894,
0.1551434994,
-0.5181753635,
-0.8386864662,
-0.1766248196,
-0.883494556,
0.08759927,
0.5608446598,
0.3025878966,
-0.0600713603,
0.4430034757,
0.0670723096,
0.4785864949,
0.5184406638,
0.1879722923,
0.054330647,
-0.1297415197,
-0.5190775394,
0.033810921,
0.7076489925,
0.2791534662,
-0.0936063081,
0.1514864564,
-0.0006563375,
0.4334862232,
0.3326619864,
-0.5651421547,
-0.1394111514,
0.272084713,
-0.5815868378,
-0.6408500671,
-0.1087439805,
-0.7861110568,
-1.0206086636,
-0.5467517972,
0.4513614178,
-0.3148019314,
-0.3943918049,
-0.00063559,
-0.2667947412,
0.3274745047,
0.2902557552,
-0.5954763293,
0.1445256919,
0.6979491711,
0.548519671,
-0.1019195616,
-0.1411624402,
-0.6221861243,
-0.094986625,
-0.5584084988,
0.5933663845,
-0.6586719751,
-0.4498133361,
-0.2983161807,
-0.0193776488,
-0.0721632242,
-0.3726597726,
0.4108126163,
-0.4707486629,
0.2246837616,
-0.7301774025,
-0.5785157084,
-0.4091326296,
0.6872643232,
-0.851978004,
0.8320302963,
-0.1205028147,
-1.1177120209,
0.8268677592,
-0.4090947509,
-0.5860797167,
-0.4730837345,
-0.3352687955,
-0.7046920657,
-0.1634458601,
0.3667666018,
0.3418574333,
-0.2393355668,
0.5861082077,
-0.8118100762,
-0.4034842253,
0.1569648683,
-0.5034455657,
1.1679689884,
-0.0985597074,
-0.9458143711,
0.2169649601,
-0.4017976522,
-0.5473403931,
0.0740222856,
-0.0144018522,
-0.7165890932,
0.1213040873,
-0.1821380854,
0.3207620084,
-0.2321582735,
-0.3697851896,
0.2038255334,
-0.4273108244,
-0.0830105022,
0.7849879265,
0.153384909,
0.5747256279,
-0.0825101063,
0.361430347,
0.4644370079,
0.1824526489,
0.2737798691,
-0.2584756315,
-0.6946133375,
-0.2814925015,
0.0988539904,
0.5694690347,
-0.8916651607,
0.4043728411,
0.1107936427,
-0.3193588853,
-0.139853999,
0.2736855149,
0.8551383615,
0.7253567576,
0.4860150218,
-0.2834018171,
-0.4742712379,
-0.9342089891,
-0.6167105436,
-0.3561671972,
0.2983276248,
-0.0365867205,
0.6994969845,
-0.0235461574,
0.8105993867,
-0.4308952689,
-0.3010977805,
-0.3554218411,
0.5312705636,
-0.0238794684,
0.3808017969,
0.9515587091,
-1.2864609957,
-0.0940423012,
-0.5866934657,
-0.6703544855,
0.1099507138,
-0.3033943772,
-0.1980583817,
0.2311384529,
0.5732550621,
-0.7640730739,
0.7134833932,
0.0640589148,
-0.6384028792,
0.4508945644,
0.3389246166,
0.2147674561,
-0.9401282072,
0.1541936398,
0.5223490596,
-0.1473056823,
-0.5784114003,
-0.1633644402,
-0.1183976829,
0.1063322797,
-0.62056458,
0.6157394052,
-0.0093466658,
0.0504288338,
-0.3740019798,
0.1650174558,
0.2650232613,
0.4931487441,
0.1788580865,
0.373770982,
0.4324513674,
-0.5863685012,
0.1480006129,
0.4412709475,
-0.0166734029,
1.0322277546,
-0.5679880381,
-0.1279992908,
-0.3515832126,
0.475184828,
-1.2052533627,
0.001786607,
0.6467065215,
-0.3518671989,
0.3995572031,
-0.4963332117,
-0.0898982137,
-0.2836925387,
-0.6635283828,
0.0738653764,
0.0227999259,
-0.693071723,
0.3502213955,
0.3564001918,
0.2743167877,
-1.1040091515,
-0.7066710591,
-0.0552951247,
-0.5911949277,
-0.0438060537,
0.3037765622,
0.2660339773,
-0.4895712137,
0.0019263723,
-0.3291853368,
0.1460730731,
0.1856776923,
0.2495436817,
0.3331956863,
0.192831248,
0.2560729384,
0.0247901697,
-0.3234048784,
0.2535909116,
-0.2385289818,
0.1875498146,
0.0530823693,
-0.5328370929,
-0.3812817931,
0.353784889,
0.7720064521,
0.0533115044,
0.800940156,
0.8047895432,
-0.4211998284,
-0.2142910808,
-0.1997117847,
-0.227448523,
-0.3986352384,
0.4065718055,
-0.2575268447,
-0.2186309546,
0.3852520585,
0.1415617913,
-0.0352002718,
0.4283960164,
0.4194369912,
-0.0420460589,
1.0247322321,
0.3864959478,
-0.5757181048,
0.5709241629,
-0.3973898888,
0.2758467495,
-0.596742034,
0.0460508615,
-0.3939182758,
-0.3975431919,
-0.4157156944,
-0.3167487383,
0.2321151346,
0.0487816967,
-0.571803987,
0.2879598141,
-0.2342666984,
0.111855641,
0.629951179,
0.5193732977,
-0.0738979727,
-0.2810041606,
-0.2536638081,
-0.2258553058,
-0.2719761133,
-0.4181388319,
0.8408821225,
0.208574757,
0.6937181354,
0.0859298557,
0.4192495048,
0.60923177,
0.2322740555,
-0.8571267128,
0.6428198218,
-0.3677463233,
-0.8220612407,
-0.1966336966,
-0.2251013815,
-0.3977778256,
0.3882601559,
-0.3553240597,
-0.3861937523,
0.4949267209,
0.4290677905,
-0.0685247779,
0.4315769374,
-0.5027984977,
1.2593314648,
-0.0632762015,
-0.6619031429,
-0.2966664732,
-0.5979266763,
0.2808584273,
0.3915078938,
0.0176646877,
0.1584854722,
0.3429300785,
0.8130488396,
-0.2190533876,
1.5121133327,
-0.853746891,
-0.1878258139,
0.3341558576,
0.2308542281,
0.6437139511,
0.1545257866,
-0.1690565795,
-0.0234582219,
-0.4543305039,
-0.3492007554,
-0.4742828906,
0.5897234082,
-0.5945107937,
-0.7298250198,
-0.3870905936,
-0.322976917,
-0.4405372143,
0.1910735816,
0.1623236835,
0.4646930397,
-0.6940370798,
0.0226611681,
0.7883935571,
-0.2201586217,
0.3938951492,
0.3343386948,
0.1781990975,
-0.3189547956,
0.565274179,
-0.0561578758,
0.1237808317,
0.2793647945,
0.3314460218,
-0.5686683059,
-0.4652398527,
-0.4978799224,
-0.1243201792,
-0.8529648185,
-0.0601013601,
-0.4518369436,
0.2371971011,
-0.4149051011,
-0.1226614118,
-0.3882884085,
-0.3450558186,
-0.2430191338,
-0.435469687,
0.2719891369,
0.5930868983,
-0.046599213,
0.3081229031,
-0.2572460473,
0.698131144,
0.297680825,
-0.0925292,
-0.0667106435,
-0.4516716301,
0.0456534065,
0.0847203434,
-0.6185971498,
-0.9836727977,
0.2424483895,
-0.2882373929,
0.6216041446,
0.6967174411,
0.2914466858,
0.4060735106,
-0.1882367879,
0.7747132182,
0.184386909,
-1.0896912813,
0.79308182,
-0.5227391124,
0.1123979613,
0.4764709473,
0.7085636258,
-0.1100414842,
-0.3493884802,
-0.5606643558,
-0.5801905394,
0.7037832737,
0.0399819352,
-0.1675928235,
-0.1160613224,
0.2327060103,
0.1706302017,
0.2639981806,
-1.0165994167,
-0.2459079772,
-0.4154772162,
-0.4002493322,
-0.1112519279,
-0.0157321543,
-0.3506006002,
-0.2825419605,
0.9088709354,
-0.2254034877,
-0.1250961572,
0.2446012646,
-0.2306851149,
-0.0055353562,
0.3862423599,
0.316996038,
0.2540196776,
-0.062648192,
0.1809613258,
0.2234265655,
-0.5320152044,
0.2616101205,
0.3122110069,
-0.5964121222,
-0.0692346096,
0.2084204853,
0.822224915,
0.264238447,
-0.0150637431,
0.6917682886,
0.2505578101,
-0.1510431319,
-0.0560347326,
0.0130560026,
0.0764355138,
0.3753131926,
0.0647124797,
0.3109906614,
0.2630093098,
-0.3579084277,
0.3566488624,
0.7345676422,
-0.8590617776,
-0.2664071321,
0.7160274386,
0.044898551,
0.335085839,
0.1175689101,
-0.1991928667,
-0.8634310961,
0.9525482655,
0.4058429599,
0.8729025722,
-0.0646749586,
0.475109756,
0.3098281324,
0.2450052202,
-0.0791590586,
0.0768696219,
0.0625811741,
-0.6563494205,
-0.0431616232,
-0.2309495956,
-0.5151097775,
0.3459265828,
-0.6551139355,
0.4662885666,
-0.3502841294,
-0.2926084101,
0.065391019,
0.148590982,
-0.5068052411,
0.6097647548,
0.1348174214,
0.4408188462,
-1.3149731159,
0.5762161016,
0.9334198833,
-0.4223279953,
-0.3028547168,
0.4470992386,
0.6625875831,
-0.4801952839,
0.6055155396,
0.2136112601,
-0.440144062,
-0.4873683751,
-0.3704002202,
-0.3392288983,
0.6886858344,
0.4149895012,
-0.254295826,
0.2481536418,
0.0420585014,
0.320476234,
-0.2281939685,
0.0799694806,
0.3818620741,
0.5713024139,
-0.0231678579,
-0.3665726185,
0.4337615073,
-0.0628054664,
-0.3382032514,
0.0739891455,
-0.6784041524,
0.806783855,
-0.0430105701,
0.1190083027,
-0.3816362917,
0.3723284304,
0.0748531967,
0.4926211834,
0.9537080526,
0.7564061284,
0.5212587714,
0.0693864822,
0.8690850735,
0.2222862095,
0.3850288093,
1.0892696381,
-0.4571147859,
0.4876435995,
0.5361767411,
0.0892644152,
0.4977007806,
0.5522434711,
0.0427162051,
0.7049821019,
-0.0283088572,
-0.1624808162,
-0.4632376432,
0.0386582389,
-0.0881353468,
0.5869433284,
0.4195343554,
-0.4198873043,
-0.3350441158,
0.2064745575,
0.3228828609,
0.2118284553,
-0.3357062936,
0.6229652166,
-0.0168506056,
-0.8331919312,
0.3013906479,
-0.1498837173,
0.5627090931,
-0.4060233533,
-0.0343014225,
-0.1360784769,
0.5211666226,
-0.0491869301,
-0.6640242338,
0.4480568171,
-0.0242943764,
-0.4042422175,
-0.1769811958,
0.9614337087,
-0.1532863528,
-0.2687134743,
0.5271782279,
0.2658079863,
-0.4089552462,
-0.0903439894,
-0.8851903081,
-0.1652204394,
-0.0769511685,
-0.6285733581,
0.262473762,
0.2642445862,
-0.1960814893,
0.297138989,
0.3842669427,
-0.2122017592,
-0.554251492,
0.2299439311,
0.9949868321,
-0.7610585093,
-0.644716382,
-1.0457420349,
0.357173562,
-0.240718618,
-0.2950197756,
0.7580488324,
0.0810591131,
0.6563937664,
-0.011346289,
0.7949367762,
-0.0068741324,
0.4019807875,
-0.5573493838,
0.7889321446,
-0.567054987,
0.1800481826,
-0.5667812228,
-0.406065464,
-0.2231238931,
0.6190990806,
-0.7608634233,
0.0701062679,
0.5711210966,
0.5781745315,
-0.2888612151,
0.1673793495,
0.0693051592,
0.2412656397,
0.3533459902,
0.5188083053,
0.5890373588,
-0.5321585536,
0.4998605549,
-0.0746455118,
-0.208956033,
-0.1674427837,
-0.9905365109,
-1.3254790306,
-0.3600717187,
-0.53072083,
-0.4883216023,
0.1613612026,
0.5792717934,
0.7099104524,
-0.920699656,
0.4579698443,
-0.4121943116,
0.5116153955,
-0.4554143846,
-0.289994359,
0.5119515061,
-0.1740689278,
-0.6193614602,
0.3618245423,
-0.1458057016,
-0.0300953686,
-0.1914872229,
-0.0373490192,
-0.6110921502,
0.2374598086,
0.3115790784,
0.2310184389,
-0.5768677592,
-0.4143148959,
-0.1413279474,
-0.0989094526,
0.0269632097,
0.8782962561,
-0.9022310376,
0.3125704229,
0.4400958419,
0.5057967901,
0.458622694,
0.1729260236,
0.5963521004,
-0.8696662188,
0.443116188,
0.0625195727,
0.4294562936,
0.3759496808,
-0.6225640774,
0.2939870656,
0.5410322547,
-0.0372935124,
-0.6462027431,
0.5651492476,
-0.6658927798,
-0.6505354643,
1.0126122236,
-0.3243455291,
-0.2235107422,
-0.383448869,
-0.2801185846,
0.5574926734,
-0.0679148808,
0.8304002285,
0.6919245124,
-0.0543431975,
0.2758332789,
-0.2671860158,
0.6690762043,
0.7652956247,
-0.5378859043,
0.2727980018,
0.6325665712,
0.2578105032,
0.082537055,
0.4018928707,
-0.1201860383,
0.4468659163,
0.2417210639,
-0.22021088,
-0.0341941006,
-0.4308838248,
-0.3233231008,
-0.0327032693,
-0.3065756559,
-0.3366674185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10391v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10391v2 | Empowering Sentence Encoders with Prompting and Label Retrieval for Zero-shot Text Classification | 2022-12-20T16:18:03 | 2023-05-19T08:37:33 | Jimin Hong, Jungsoo Park, Daeyoung Kim, Seongjae Choi, Bokyung Son, Jaewook Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL | With contrastive pre-training, sentence encoders are generally optimized to
locate semantically similar samples closer to each other in their embedding
spaces. In this work, we focus on the potential of their embedding spaces to be
readily adapted to zero-shot text classification, as semantically distinct
samples are already well-separated. Our framework, RaLP (Retrieval augmented
Label Prompts for sentence encoder), encodes prompted label candidates with a
sentence encoder, then assigns the label whose prompt embedding has the highest
similarity with the input text embedding. In order to compensate for the
potentially poorly descriptive labels in their original format, RaLP retrieves
sentences that are semantically similar to the original label prompt from
external corpora and use them as additional pseudo-label prompts. RaLP achieves
competitive or stronger performance than much larger baselines on various
closed-set classification and multiple-choice QA datasets under zero-shot
settings. We show that the retrieval component plays a pivotal role in RaLP's
success, and its results are robustly attained regardless of verbalizer
variations. | [
-0.2286859751,
-0.7343190908,
0.6880807281,
0.0824801251,
-0.1224026978,
0.1368847042,
-0.1361183226,
-0.359384805,
0.2914413512,
0.2183781713,
-0.4041617513,
-0.4211034775,
-0.5447506309,
0.5237988234,
-0.132866025,
1.2208439112,
0.0393150784,
-0.3255802095,
-0.4079602063,
-0.3772645891,
-0.6822456121,
-0.6080797315,
-0.1208397299,
-0.4053316116,
0.8882258534,
0.4321996868,
0.5688618422,
0.3730595112,
0.1957302094,
0.1749708205,
0.0165515561,
-0.1317448169,
-0.2133259028,
0.7868489623,
-0.1096478999,
-0.5129790902,
0.1114989743,
0.094299227,
0.5869203806,
0.5502108932,
0.0032919291,
-0.0170862805,
0.1848699898,
0.1602123082,
-1.0664199591,
-0.03316826,
-0.3595828414,
0.3927970529,
-0.1776441932,
-0.3871487677,
-0.707367897,
-0.4227332175,
0.0398118757,
-0.60712111,
0.2910742164,
0.111595422,
1.0340156555,
0.3093492985,
-0.2131314427,
-0.4358175695,
-0.5599364042,
0.7178586721,
-0.3571571708,
0.3196793795,
0.3506267369,
0.1605011374,
0.1476563364,
-0.5926585793,
-0.6743760705,
-0.1839739531,
-0.1492156237,
0.3544622064,
-0.3043710589,
0.1010405645,
0.3111991286,
0.2670835853,
-0.6266908646,
0.31065467,
-0.106103234,
-0.160759896,
0.01474398,
-0.026911987,
0.2827883959,
-0.0259511601,
-0.2254594266,
-0.4460321069,
-0.4944511354,
-0.0003923607,
0.0426629186,
0.4046328366,
0.1553955525,
0.7363085747,
-0.3083705306,
1.0398212671,
0.0938889459,
0.2079163492,
0.6113560796,
-0.155919835,
-0.2775495946,
0.3386253119,
0.8191493154,
0.0716502517,
0.119685702,
-0.0709591955,
-0.2163963467,
0.1781555712,
0.145219788,
-0.8373333812,
-0.1837848127,
0.0436675958,
-0.1688499451,
-0.2176416069,
0.174840793,
-0.680635035,
-0.2587731183,
0.0083896294,
0.6446319818,
-0.2654895484,
0.3688180447,
0.2663119733,
-0.4154016376,
0.5034056902,
0.2755790055,
-0.6750174165,
-0.0883714929,
0.4357178211,
0.911442399,
0.1260739267,
-0.0250789225,
-1.036056757,
0.0254991502,
-0.2074092329,
0.9714916945,
-1.0283722878,
-0.2678587735,
0.2631073296,
-0.3029724061,
-0.1062576026,
-0.5595202446,
0.5085453391,
-0.6840384007,
0.6105070114,
-0.1672504097,
-0.7628065944,
0.088962324,
0.7332376838,
-0.4739266336,
0.9359814525,
0.0119127138,
-0.7517698407,
0.4715878963,
-0.3852539659,
-0.312951088,
0.469143182,
-0.3852092922,
-0.4536394179,
0.0562494658,
0.3362729549,
0.5949386954,
-0.009086377,
-0.1588176936,
-0.3957815468,
-0.43703565,
0.3702146709,
-0.3656710684,
0.6387503743,
0.2477836311,
0.009899511,
0.091228053,
-0.5358485579,
0.1593716741,
-0.1360797137,
-0.3129983544,
-0.6139765382,
-0.5044465065,
-0.0959285125,
0.2182692289,
0.1399676353,
-0.7563192248,
0.2612381577,
-0.2221624851,
0.2155623138,
0.323636204,
0.2714600861,
0.5631172061,
-0.2837291956,
0.895144403,
-0.0909944922,
-0.0348696522,
-0.6653962135,
-0.4939530194,
-0.5100061297,
-0.4721158445,
0.4293117821,
0.7811917663,
-0.8776209354,
0.5812523961,
-0.1311178803,
-0.2554140985,
-0.8829926848,
-0.0286583435,
0.4440177679,
0.7868911028,
0.5149130821,
-0.1858463436,
-0.261803478,
-0.6780472398,
0.0053837793,
-0.0184917357,
-0.18734698,
0.1900754124,
0.2625903189,
-0.0679325238,
1.134567976,
-0.7742475867,
-0.6445888877,
-0.336071521,
0.2990554869,
0.2463984787,
0.23335132,
0.5161096454,
-0.7175168395,
-0.6802471876,
-0.172309503,
-0.8422138691,
-0.4247032404,
-0.229741022,
0.0329685919,
-0.1556670368,
0.6537050009,
-0.5121316314,
0.2854392529,
0.0727700964,
-0.3230699599,
0.4598735869,
-0.4277043343,
0.1383603215,
-0.9163437486,
0.0037318736,
-0.1302328855,
-0.2157963514,
-0.5715385675,
0.1562143862,
0.042070426,
-0.18261531,
-0.2938795388,
0.513104856,
-0.4125319719,
0.1444371045,
-0.2180160135,
0.5016009808,
0.3058288693,
0.1842458397,
0.2349879891,
0.8300778866,
0.5594736338,
-0.5673388243,
0.0684662238,
0.6889790297,
-0.1649378985,
0.8116300106,
-0.7463360429,
0.3116215169,
-0.4603074789,
0.4228239357,
-0.8988341093,
-0.0824448243,
0.5342406034,
-0.5780531168,
0.1759548932,
0.1314546615,
-0.4266215563,
-0.1628845781,
-0.4781794548,
0.3876056373,
0.677880466,
-0.481549859,
0.2498136014,
-0.0815169215,
-0.1619926095,
-0.7878149152,
-0.7499747872,
-0.0549603328,
-0.063791655,
0.0613415837,
0.2246911824,
-0.0822694749,
0.1202019006,
0.1701023579,
0.1096168533,
-0.1060944647,
-0.1049623489,
0.1389217079,
0.1730614007,
-0.2173262984,
0.4263266027,
0.1021952406,
-0.2149024308,
-0.2931219339,
-0.2705312967,
0.3557562828,
0.1337896287,
-0.1595273167,
-0.2705436945,
0.3210734427,
0.0487402938,
-0.3704253435,
0.8430913091,
0.4578351974,
-0.1800372899,
-0.2830354571,
-0.3991190791,
-0.1572508067,
-0.4267886877,
0.1193223596,
-0.4868581295,
-1.2866755724,
0.1632513404,
0.2454352081,
-0.1543888897,
0.0923582762,
0.1747097522,
-0.2855443358,
0.4955276251,
0.6645432115,
-0.0566415712,
0.5007495284,
0.1458388567,
0.2810736895,
-0.6534488797,
-0.3427164853,
-0.8474488258,
-0.1682953387,
-0.2666093409,
-0.5084113479,
0.1924957484,
0.1857794523,
-0.1523295343,
0.2656805217,
-0.7326208353,
0.7379302979,
0.6374554634,
0.0614604801,
0.0325221419,
0.0119853709,
-0.1602866203,
-0.2958211005,
-0.6520736814,
-0.3434102237,
0.5859329104,
-0.0510869585,
0.4803560972,
-0.0974785313,
1.0384060144,
0.343285948,
0.1199862361,
-0.8334953189,
0.3354498148,
-0.1573825181,
-0.2928486168,
0.0562399738,
-0.3286970854,
-1.0684113503,
0.2070286274,
-0.4161625206,
-0.5000727773,
0.4540354609,
0.1049418971,
-0.7189183235,
-0.0537797622,
-0.5946052074,
0.8735576272,
0.1873801947,
0.0175522845,
0.2287183404,
-0.793797791,
-0.2146413624,
-0.0558407754,
-0.1104881391,
0.096736066,
-0.1879323274,
0.5610035062,
-0.2254714072,
0.7859633565,
-0.2617994547,
0.0993104875,
0.3456712067,
0.0018039217,
0.0217896719,
-0.3524098396,
-0.069810845,
-0.2732280791,
-0.190996334,
-0.3292736113,
-0.99565202,
0.4725607038,
-0.6279370189,
-0.283495307,
-0.663148582,
-0.2581911683,
-0.2976145744,
0.191166386,
0.4879648089,
0.3647352159,
-0.0923735201,
0.4371541739,
0.8462781906,
-0.534355998,
0.4942394495,
0.4600200057,
-0.0209293254,
-0.3635059893,
0.7973333597,
-0.0032624078,
0.0703585744,
0.9561866522,
0.0263004992,
-0.5015886426,
-0.178116411,
-0.2557319403,
0.102682054,
-0.699755311,
-0.6593573093,
-0.8397342563,
-0.2209620476,
-0.3370318115,
-0.6104124188,
-0.0350023732,
-0.3279524446,
-0.6301279068,
-0.3891833425,
0.3936906755,
0.6218025684,
-0.1052471921,
0.4226405025,
-0.828825295,
0.2676185369,
0.1590888649,
0.143746689,
-0.148049131,
-0.7068641782,
0.0641613603,
-0.3462413251,
-0.1228741109,
-1.0480365753,
0.3531541824,
0.459196806,
0.3949559629,
0.2710287571,
0.4604593515,
0.5477122664,
-0.489258498,
0.7714422345,
0.304662317,
-0.8230783343,
0.9297020435,
-0.0278590806,
0.6482704878,
0.8091538548,
0.6587386727,
-0.6151567101,
-0.4027411938,
-0.3112376034,
-0.8577957749,
0.5245388746,
0.1228040159,
0.3543447852,
-0.368629545,
0.4979187548,
0.2157853842,
0.0855061486,
-0.851629734,
-0.2319524586,
-0.2374902368,
-0.4773086011,
-0.0818546787,
-0.4052837491,
0.101361081,
0.1253404319,
0.5051776171,
-0.115361616,
0.283095032,
0.4931022525,
-0.2508442998,
0.4009584486,
0.8118985891,
0.2392834723,
-0.0427385941,
-0.2084603608,
0.2578187883,
-0.0724546611,
-0.3388991356,
0.5242736936,
0.1516083628,
-0.6520605087,
0.1725220084,
0.4195891023,
0.7745673656,
0.3042088747,
-0.6091993451,
0.7260058522,
0.038736783,
-0.0055701504,
-0.0122993495,
0.0140601229,
-0.4966500998,
0.202283293,
0.3987797499,
-0.0912906826,
0.2493453324,
-0.4101151228,
0.4988492131,
0.168513149,
-0.7132490277,
-0.1576936692,
0.6269142032,
-0.0114711178,
-0.415892005,
0.8425716758,
-0.516197145,
-0.4575930238,
0.1976487041,
0.6943027973,
0.8723877072,
-0.2028482407,
0.7217102051,
0.4234787524,
0.0598526299,
0.0152894175,
0.0626509488,
-0.3288707435,
-1.0016586781,
-0.335447818,
-0.5719156265,
-0.4178659916,
-0.2614682019,
-1.0956770182,
0.107312642,
-0.5875194073,
-0.1126051322,
-0.1270354092,
-0.2906065285,
-0.5301380157,
0.1270647347,
0.1982881725,
0.8095718026,
-1.0314782858,
0.74076581,
0.7959041595,
-0.7011951804,
-0.5293824077,
0.0845128521,
-0.1824917942,
-0.4702304602,
0.6165931821,
0.471909523,
-0.1159081012,
-0.0940361544,
-0.4526856542,
-0.3924302459,
0.9324755669,
0.2993246317,
-0.6365948915,
0.0423140936,
-0.013422817,
0.7629910111,
-0.2802594006,
0.4171855748,
0.1999974251,
0.126725778,
0.2262471616,
-0.688787818,
0.1033510417,
-0.2015135437,
0.0248121638,
0.0601459406,
-0.3225928247,
0.4405560195,
-0.1648750603,
-0.177737698,
0.0486788899,
0.7624162436,
0.544945538,
0.4152051508,
0.2529396117,
0.5119910836,
0.8059183359,
-0.0973524377,
1.0248134136,
0.1318118721,
0.1953346133,
1.4021869898,
-0.50400424,
1.2433918715,
0.3090007603,
0.1209977418,
0.7243759632,
0.3181398213,
-0.1606316715,
0.8028890491,
-0.0702292621,
-0.5463050008,
-0.1338835806,
-0.5127637982,
-0.2515795529,
0.3016502261,
0.2785309553,
-0.2911079824,
-0.2798951268,
0.5071677566,
-0.0318637192,
0.3959333301,
-0.1230929345,
0.8320044875,
0.0891333967,
-0.4872326553,
0.1699266583,
-0.2144188434,
0.899817884,
-0.5936748981,
-0.1028265655,
-0.1693647951,
0.169329837,
-0.0228962582,
-1.0300916433,
0.1714052558,
-0.0674521327,
-0.1819946766,
-0.6143377423,
0.83895123,
-0.5675772429,
-0.1275188774,
0.3781416118,
0.4021180272,
0.0443101563,
-0.0301589426,
-0.5915179253,
0.0164300278,
-0.0583597049,
0.0394816436,
0.3656110168,
0.5613065958,
0.2796184719,
0.4732345045,
0.2911626697,
-0.0533256084,
0.0136739742,
0.2816764414,
0.641082406,
-0.8152823448,
-0.5990893841,
-0.7200797796,
0.2849705815,
0.0101568736,
-0.4127180278,
0.7510412335,
0.5017143488,
0.9417487979,
-0.3021269441,
0.6487855315,
-0.1481922865,
0.4461799264,
-0.4029420912,
0.5838648677,
-0.2973703742,
-0.0057545262,
-0.1539498568,
-1.0392282009,
-0.7839166522,
0.8936718702,
-0.2413778752,
-0.0264024604,
0.588616848,
0.7406999469,
0.0982024074,
-0.1340903938,
0.4407897294,
0.0122396341,
0.2146557719,
0.5569658875,
0.8259292841,
-0.3743447363,
0.6833489537,
0.0178915057,
-0.2022782862,
-0.0405117609,
-0.8231281638,
-0.7180451751,
-0.5425134301,
-0.6867774129,
-0.1622526795,
0.1869525313,
0.9187298417,
0.4695294201,
-0.7901366353,
0.1979160756,
0.2386765629,
-0.1054877937,
0.0389086492,
-0.3076108992,
0.0550684445,
-0.6710033417,
-0.4795237184,
0.3884803951,
0.445736438,
0.053666655,
0.2515003085,
0.0370697081,
-0.2442559004,
-0.0228305794,
0.6515678763,
0.5308756828,
-0.5178656578,
-0.4105338156,
0.1565664262,
-0.1281189919,
0.1303118616,
0.792419672,
-1.1836277246,
0.5847910047,
0.4074302018,
0.8632750511,
0.3228905499,
0.0342691951,
0.4441899955,
-1.2266812325,
0.2189409137,
0.4112714231,
0.1046631336,
0.4902384579,
-0.3223595619,
0.3534175456,
-0.038947612,
-0.4594691098,
-0.7174964547,
0.1529456526,
-0.9487352371,
-0.3010286391,
1.0387476683,
-0.4628562033,
0.0193148442,
-0.1570842266,
-0.2231007218,
0.1167754233,
-0.4557670057,
0.5355727673,
0.6762288809,
-0.1899526715,
-0.5533979535,
-0.1551308334,
0.3075530529,
0.5247009993,
-0.716892302,
-0.2192928791,
0.629969418,
0.1860051006,
0.3733964562,
0.8769142628,
-0.0418094471,
0.1262020916,
0.0012629853,
-0.0216801353,
-0.0355568156,
-0.3138790727,
-0.7996326089,
0.4641597867,
0.0453575067,
-0.4659385979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10381v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10381v1 | To Adapt or to Annotate: Challenges and Interventions for Domain Adaptation in Open-Domain Question Answering | 2022-12-20T16:06:09 | 2022-12-20T16:06:09 | Dheeru Dua, Emma Strubell, Sameer Singh, Pat Verga | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in open-domain question answering (ODQA) have demonstrated
impressive accuracy on standard Wikipedia style benchmarks. However, it is less
clear how robust these models are and how well they perform when applied to
real-world applications in drastically different domains. While there has been
some work investigating how well ODQA models perform when tested for
out-of-domain (OOD) generalization, these studies have been conducted only
under conservative shifts in data distribution and typically focus on a single
component (ie. retrieval) rather than an end-to-end system. In response, we
propose a more realistic and challenging domain shift evaluation setting and,
through extensive experiments, study end-to-end model performance. We find that
not only do models fail to generalize, but high retrieval scores often still
yield poor answer prediction accuracy. We then categorize different types of
shifts and propose techniques that, when presented with a new dataset, predict
if intervention methods are likely to be successful. Finally, using insights
from this analysis, we propose and evaluate several intervention methods which
improve end-to-end answer F1 score by up to 24 points. | [
-0.6111427546,
-1.1189466715,
0.3661054969,
-0.2004474699,
-0.0361557081,
-0.075305663,
-0.230788067,
-0.6770380735,
-0.1812711805,
0.4625379741,
-0.6555734873,
-0.3337741792,
-0.5414556265,
0.3023837209,
-0.1869828701,
1.1074081659,
-0.458066076,
-0.1645694375,
-0.3852606416,
-0.324475497,
-0.6980006099,
-0.3187001646,
-0.5145254135,
0.1599454582,
0.2099288702,
0.4007461965,
0.8268433809,
0.3908469379,
0.795101285,
0.0556150153,
-0.0517354645,
0.4580997527,
-0.5930116773,
-0.0735352635,
-0.5665073395,
-0.3797241151,
-0.441434741,
-0.0271906666,
0.4590439498,
1.0083731413,
-0.1456940919,
0.3273612261,
-0.2916368246,
0.4302005172,
-0.8223057985,
-0.11651887,
-0.5977781415,
-0.2757645249,
0.0702717528,
-0.0660530776,
-0.4462552071,
-0.4604369104,
0.4122057259,
-1.0475285053,
0.1104893833,
0.1807957441,
0.5615491271,
0.4162073135,
-0.4277580678,
-0.3761538267,
-0.9457018375,
0.5875576138,
-0.7441530228,
0.2625046074,
0.2980903387,
0.582249701,
-0.2381277382,
-0.6804192662,
-0.5180161595,
0.1420922875,
0.3769563138,
0.0586561598,
0.0492319204,
-0.1691756099,
0.217580989,
0.1827875823,
-0.3661974669,
-0.0880810916,
-0.5135487318,
0.1234912872,
0.8089844584,
0.1564692408,
0.1099927127,
0.4694578052,
-0.4688196182,
-0.0507399477,
-0.7007496953,
0.4046297371,
0.1847562641,
0.3972704113,
0.3322395086,
0.5693547726,
-0.4053023458,
0.8033238649,
0.1469654441,
0.2010669559,
0.0496269725,
-0.2340306789,
-0.2852826715,
-0.2938053012,
0.060762465,
0.6224608421,
0.556907475,
-0.185415104,
-0.1283101887,
-0.4096277356,
0.5727958083,
-0.5974667668,
-0.2625711858,
0.2774917185,
-0.3775292933,
0.0095402589,
0.2215405852,
-0.7699144483,
-0.4054883122,
-0.2286798656,
0.8647013903,
-0.4592622221,
-0.3686492741,
0.4005779624,
-0.1874531358,
0.2214127183,
0.8310745358,
-0.7919914722,
0.5449638963,
0.548576057,
0.5422651768,
-0.4802119136,
-0.248687312,
-0.3709678352,
-0.1070028171,
-0.5013578534,
0.7372431159,
-0.6099535823,
-0.3913978636,
0.4565692842,
0.1371609867,
-0.5571809411,
-0.7969257236,
0.6082724929,
-0.9348148704,
0.1610711813,
-0.538636446,
-0.5462969542,
-0.2122393996,
0.06636329,
-0.6437869072,
1.0250611305,
0.4951879084,
-0.6819998622,
0.3916232586,
-1.1580199003,
-0.2716124654,
-0.3489958346,
0.4098394513,
-0.215085417,
0.3816171587,
0.4193376601,
0.036821872,
-0.2655347288,
-0.1661709994,
-0.2535605133,
-0.4441675544,
0.5817103386,
-0.1635488123,
0.7509353161,
-0.0117434813,
-0.1695593297,
0.0474001057,
-0.5544790626,
0.0576908514,
0.1682257056,
-0.0575964078,
-0.6507140398,
-0.0966650322,
-0.0197010711,
0.1796718091,
-0.1021983624,
-0.7870180011,
0.3871422708,
-0.228109166,
0.4487630725,
0.7625966072,
0.3416173458,
0.5067600608,
-0.5206177235,
0.6626425385,
0.0752626657,
0.4272144437,
0.1452054232,
-0.7625374794,
-0.5206233859,
-0.0237407237,
0.5816335678,
0.4763000906,
-1.1932728291,
-0.1239190325,
-0.4700809419,
-0.078458108,
-0.9148228168,
-0.1729845703,
0.2339664102,
0.7653183937,
0.8600105643,
-0.5006002784,
-0.0213769861,
-0.5293669701,
-0.3090766966,
-0.2037400752,
0.0381189361,
0.2813046873,
0.9121927619,
0.1947517097,
1.1261171103,
-0.6848191023,
-0.1650256962,
0.1649561673,
0.006455746,
-0.1583112329,
0.3125606775,
0.5714901686,
-1.1349910498,
-0.4809490442,
-0.1228654459,
-0.5221453309,
0.1307159811,
0.0201086625,
-0.4499433637,
0.2239667624,
0.4481256306,
-0.5734331608,
0.7355482578,
0.0654339641,
-0.2848068476,
0.5017790794,
0.1898955107,
0.2709138393,
-0.6617759466,
0.0976284593,
-0.2734595239,
0.0403657034,
-0.9212976694,
0.2136731446,
0.1849350184,
0.1330824792,
-0.3862325847,
0.6790776253,
-0.1680906117,
0.1346745789,
0.0252428185,
0.0487955734,
-0.0835963488,
0.3874413967,
0.1735640764,
1.043689847,
-0.0087760529,
-0.6030754447,
0.0284935702,
0.7541071177,
-0.3760021031,
0.7599315643,
-0.4389889836,
0.3777950108,
-0.2768576145,
0.0562046245,
-1.3287644386,
-0.4295782149,
0.2681732774,
-0.6161950827,
0.4253886044,
0.1487668902,
-0.0069611138,
-0.195159018,
-0.576728642,
0.5487905145,
0.3209965527,
-0.687117219,
0.3329963982,
0.1826102436,
-0.2888858318,
-0.6131272316,
-0.457621634,
-0.2822418809,
-0.3035381734,
-0.6974933147,
0.5231353045,
-0.3931509554,
-0.2884795964,
0.3065984547,
-0.2237852067,
-0.3247077167,
0.3107034862,
-0.0491624363,
0.1102903932,
-0.5491821766,
0.3125087619,
0.2194822431,
0.2852458656,
0.2730890214,
-0.3388441503,
-0.1235288307,
0.4172566235,
-0.3204720616,
0.0464916155,
0.5476284027,
0.3631349206,
-0.4751881659,
0.8187741041,
0.2578973174,
-0.5475919247,
-0.4387277365,
-0.2088719755,
-0.0496770851,
-0.3417261541,
0.4675255716,
-0.3637034595,
-0.7951920629,
0.3728573918,
-0.311719954,
0.3647828698,
0.5294635892,
0.3300985992,
-0.2308377773,
0.7793046832,
0.8568911552,
0.3677401841,
0.3026512861,
-0.0341898724,
0.2153108567,
-1.1254987717,
-0.1455447525,
-0.4499861896,
-0.2239533365,
-0.30058828,
-0.6468244195,
0.4939015508,
0.2906858921,
-0.2075025886,
0.104598105,
-0.4299922585,
0.1286123097,
0.4320416749,
0.259426266,
0.2276966721,
0.0217805579,
0.2131487876,
0.0704892203,
-0.5468555093,
-0.25185588,
1.4916055202,
0.2695431709,
0.5175020695,
0.4868077636,
0.4274557531,
0.3896079659,
0.8345127702,
-0.5163043141,
0.2568732202,
0.1024237126,
-0.8681911826,
-0.8357828856,
-0.0770470649,
-0.6284840703,
0.0542837791,
-0.1125411391,
-0.6400779486,
0.5295499563,
-0.1417365521,
-0.5995677114,
0.1256545186,
-0.6021235585,
0.9214059711,
0.1405793875,
-0.2995198667,
0.5078730583,
-0.7014361024,
0.2607758641,
-0.3059711754,
0.356752485,
-0.1353917122,
-0.3199815154,
0.5802678466,
-0.2708043754,
0.6413373351,
-0.4396087229,
-0.1179383323,
0.4831704795,
-0.2037790269,
0.2500537634,
-0.020567432,
-0.3646354377,
-0.06109263,
0.1982844472,
-0.5281953812,
-0.9712945223,
0.344427526,
-0.8666610122,
-0.7458460331,
-0.1553674489,
-0.624096334,
-0.6763908267,
-0.2366526127,
0.2159359306,
0.1254530102,
-0.5281767845,
-0.0867275596,
0.9142272472,
-0.0697884783,
0.3178098798,
0.5114085674,
-0.236790061,
-0.5957673192,
0.5528634787,
0.2587080896,
0.5603419542,
0.3823121488,
0.0152832642,
-0.5389541984,
-0.7806646228,
-0.8562147617,
-0.0334958136,
-1.0596375465,
-0.2453682423,
-0.248777166,
-0.1358858496,
-0.6786017418,
-0.0419193916,
0.1758745015,
-0.7318427563,
-0.1461797953,
-0.1114219129,
0.5282170773,
0.6089083552,
0.1768913716,
0.106333971,
-0.4075347483,
0.1770685762,
0.2785827816,
0.2308657765,
-0.1699763089,
-1.0616180897,
-0.376526624,
0.169247523,
-0.1830240339,
-0.8204524517,
-0.018734742,
0.7161862254,
0.4590854347,
-0.154586643,
0.7458167076,
0.7010806799,
-0.5849949121,
0.8049679995,
-0.3336880207,
-0.6413136721,
0.4216221571,
-0.1027361676,
0.2269572467,
0.7076955438,
0.8740727305,
-0.2341141999,
-0.004129258,
-0.2455802709,
-0.7252883315,
0.6188797355,
0.1087808907,
0.1885420829,
-0.0074571534,
0.8485795856,
0.4118376076,
0.3018282056,
-0.2328016311,
-0.1339446306,
-0.1701869518,
-0.2663697898,
-0.0086393785,
-0.0667347386,
-0.3327480555,
-0.1276218444,
0.627815187,
-0.4961699247,
0.3802351952,
0.5868355036,
-0.2322629094,
-0.3838448822,
0.1597622037,
0.783819139,
0.8578174114,
-0.299891144,
-0.2085008472,
0.2068115026,
-0.6144924164,
-0.0407005996,
0.2235433757,
-0.263875097,
-0.0518022962,
0.4949966073,
0.6429740191,
-0.0029294079,
-0.6494085193,
0.523922205,
0.0085137254,
-0.271009177,
-0.0815171972,
0.0833694115,
-0.1987680346,
0.2095114738,
0.4618585408,
0.0179233924,
0.2225662023,
-0.6634466648,
0.0319757797,
0.1752336472,
-0.4346201122,
-0.3729445934,
0.8696503043,
0.1522212625,
-0.4372275174,
0.4747846127,
0.0845845714,
-0.2897179127,
0.6826481819,
0.5012487173,
0.8056018353,
-0.6112131476,
0.1609753966,
0.0446503647,
0.3405101001,
0.081114389,
0.5787259936,
0.0466362685,
-0.6006482244,
-0.3333517611,
-0.3709176183,
-0.6391202807,
-0.1722507179,
-1.0837132931,
-0.0281858481,
-0.3000072241,
-0.2942507267,
0.2836536765,
-0.1143630743,
-0.5743252039,
0.4830825031,
-0.2459203303,
1.4392796755,
-0.7924005985,
0.7519628406,
1.1140415668,
-0.5344857574,
-0.196437031,
0.3246657252,
-0.2767928541,
-0.6215527058,
0.4095581472,
-0.0457169972,
0.2375748754,
0.005853869,
-0.5684936047,
-0.8427376151,
1.1223771572,
0.1418751478,
0.0793128163,
-0.073790133,
0.4631559849,
0.6191750169,
-0.6452283859,
0.2280339897,
0.6994047165,
0.2407441437,
0.0031297938,
-1.158149004,
0.1169478521,
-0.0124624865,
0.080149129,
0.1660248786,
-0.4921157658,
1.008603096,
-0.3935222328,
0.0384056829,
0.3108538985,
0.5973621607,
-0.359993875,
0.6197610497,
0.3667771816,
0.1465225518,
0.714433074,
-0.1484693438,
0.9358292222,
-0.0193815921,
0.3197488189,
1.1854943037,
-0.5373823643,
1.3309503794,
0.4761179686,
-0.1932204813,
0.3272790313,
0.7709726691,
0.5174838901,
0.8863255978,
0.2369945496,
-0.2613278627,
-0.1764724851,
-0.2326525152,
-0.4427280724,
0.1781677753,
0.4640262127,
-0.2245259583,
-0.1276494861,
0.2280960679,
-0.2701351047,
0.2994750142,
-0.3761389554,
0.5725345612,
-0.0875707641,
-0.8143467307,
0.7397541404,
0.0426680632,
0.0946476981,
-0.2471063882,
-0.4241010547,
-0.3425963223,
0.199878186,
-0.118570976,
-0.7411987185,
0.341750443,
-0.205814153,
-0.3397142291,
-0.0028289885,
0.5995980501,
-0.3658621609,
-0.1534993052,
0.1727365255,
0.551007688,
-0.1262582839,
-0.1100339368,
-0.5028352141,
0.0948042199,
-0.1521553993,
-0.2536168396,
0.4874854982,
0.6477746367,
-0.5522947907,
0.2778780162,
0.5589776635,
-0.3536566794,
0.2607301772,
-0.3077861965,
1.012947917,
-0.4465998113,
-0.0481616445,
-0.2456596792,
0.612888217,
-0.1331939697,
-0.7825508714,
0.5056751966,
0.2954500914,
1.1684293747,
-0.2863308489,
0.8262060881,
0.0972384065,
0.6921378374,
-0.6131501794,
0.3058763742,
-0.646304369,
0.1315049529,
-0.1341035962,
-0.7749361992,
-0.2608510554,
0.3359066248,
-0.4927340448,
0.0238779206,
0.7336410284,
0.4690160155,
0.1047638357,
0.2772448957,
0.4508894682,
-0.0089537706,
0.2396576256,
0.7775985599,
0.8021810651,
-0.6907434464,
0.4126888216,
-0.1940193623,
-0.3782214522,
-0.3431920409,
-0.6078799963,
-0.9476345778,
-0.5379360914,
-0.5836853385,
-0.3571912646,
0.6145014763,
0.7468393445,
0.5366888642,
-0.9243530631,
0.1037791967,
0.323058188,
-0.0352411941,
-0.6099715829,
-0.1972738504,
0.5242500901,
-0.1932860017,
-0.6665049195,
0.2182948887,
0.1342182755,
-0.1863516569,
-0.0327878036,
0.1917295009,
-0.25258255,
0.4547096491,
0.5881609321,
0.4513375461,
-0.6407175064,
-0.7252901196,
0.4651916325,
0.1711330861,
0.131714046,
0.6048853397,
-0.5586001873,
0.5115035176,
0.1730210036,
1.0650972128,
0.1136740595,
0.4414276481,
0.5647221208,
-0.5337512493,
-0.4794421494,
0.3180157542,
-0.2019491792,
0.1997828186,
-0.2129115015,
0.8334819078,
0.1500971019,
-0.5067901611,
-0.8990077972,
0.0940494761,
-0.6260536313,
-0.3735077083,
1.0885514021,
-0.5810687542,
-0.2235799283,
-0.5550521612,
-0.2092832178,
-0.0836023763,
-0.1538499296,
0.8297683001,
0.8910914063,
-0.4287546277,
0.0193664748,
-0.9196181893,
0.7346532345,
0.2885610163,
-0.8919838667,
0.1114877835,
0.2585598826,
0.5688441992,
0.250071913,
0.5858253837,
-0.000711227,
0.6590904593,
-0.1422410309,
-0.1373792291,
-0.1250462532,
-0.4574095309,
-0.5932707191,
0.2445652485,
0.3340218067,
-0.4157541394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10380v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10380v2 | What Are You Token About? Dense Retrieval as Distributions Over the Vocabulary | 2022-12-20T16:03:25 | 2023-05-24T12:05:27 | Ori Ram, Liat Bezalel, Adi Zicher, Yonatan Belinkov, Jonathan Berant, Amir Globerson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Dual encoders are now the dominant architecture for dense retrieval. Yet, we
have little understanding of how they represent text, and why this leads to
good performance. In this work, we shed light on this question via
distributions over the vocabulary. We propose to interpret the vector
representations produced by dual encoders by projecting them into the model's
vocabulary space. We show that the resulting projections contain rich semantic
information, and draw connection between them and sparse retrieval. We find
that this view can offer an explanation for some of the failure cases of dense
retrievers. For example, we observe that the inability of models to handle tail
entities is correlated with a tendency of the token distributions to forget
some of the tokens of those entities. We leverage this insight and propose a
simple way to enrich query and passage representations with lexical information
at inference time, and show that this significantly improves performance
compared to the original model in zero-shot settings, and specifically on the
BEIR benchmark. | [
-0.3144336641,
-0.6072921753,
0.4036614001,
-0.1700659394,
-0.6070050597,
0.3581378758,
0.0454722159,
-0.2911193073,
0.6656188965,
0.4614888132,
0.1785687059,
-0.2255450338,
-0.7685346603,
-0.1466988325,
-0.7244666219,
0.932225585,
0.2156329006,
0.3393968344,
-0.0577557795,
-0.2868308425,
-0.8208607435,
-0.8504267335,
-0.5916051865,
-0.165467456,
0.7180114388,
0.1026136279,
0.7788814902,
0.6810920238,
0.4518993199,
0.3379868865,
-0.3392026722,
-0.137529403,
-0.559253037,
0.2362376451,
-0.2066675723,
-0.6904402375,
0.2288277745,
-0.4362943172,
0.9438362718,
1.0033607483,
-0.0503684729,
-0.079357855,
0.0975633636,
0.2626524568,
-0.9027351141,
-0.1958049536,
-0.7886193991,
0.2764746547,
-0.3603010774,
-0.3983920217,
-0.3586888611,
0.1740657985,
0.0092128534,
-0.4247584045,
0.5255445838,
0.2523551583,
0.8298418522,
0.2002965212,
-0.8897121549,
-0.2929542661,
-0.701066494,
0.7934373021,
-0.0826865584,
0.4915992618,
0.1581629813,
0.438447386,
0.1005489528,
-1.1604952812,
-0.5145561099,
-0.0022154029,
-0.3584716618,
0.1464924961,
-0.0822283924,
0.2218627334,
0.0964318737,
0.4383697212,
-0.3488666117,
-0.2065355927,
-0.5220063925,
-0.5055972338,
0.2821494341,
0.0843498185,
0.3574311435,
-0.3076175451,
-0.7072252631,
-0.255333066,
-0.314183712,
-0.349566102,
0.4287510812,
0.1157407388,
0.1437904388,
1.0094534159,
0.4183239043,
0.4805699289,
-0.1336167753,
0.4454458058,
0.2412447184,
-0.5083728433,
-0.1746057719,
0.1164988428,
0.4049206376,
0.2932860553,
-0.0691451654,
-0.5985972285,
-0.5377172828,
-0.0881404057,
0.4767998755,
-0.7226788402,
0.0982736796,
0.2291360497,
-0.6759472489,
0.1472839713,
0.324400872,
-0.5780460835,
-0.2811727226,
-0.1184714362,
0.7754250169,
-0.4912799001,
-0.3808448911,
0.4379560053,
-1.0478739738,
0.222912401,
0.0065420186,
-1.0843588114,
0.5411653519,
0.8937695026,
1.0567538738,
-0.0091312183,
0.0367146842,
-0.8033626676,
0.1395588219,
-0.4956060052,
0.7129492164,
-0.4688200057,
-0.6095746756,
0.1666647345,
-0.2156999111,
-0.1481709629,
-0.6356441975,
0.536899507,
-0.6275984049,
-0.4154238105,
-0.663141489,
-0.6532410383,
-0.0367126167,
-0.0156605504,
-0.8239479661,
0.9501001835,
0.0342866406,
-1.0919312239,
0.6363909245,
-0.309369117,
-0.3546536863,
0.3381442726,
-0.3657613099,
0.2846107781,
0.4458663166,
-0.1626400799,
0.2519474626,
0.0680705756,
0.0961744785,
-0.1726041436,
-0.8179500699,
0.3680595756,
-0.2372353226,
0.484695375,
0.3413035274,
-0.07323993,
-0.0598978549,
-0.5186734796,
-0.2311199903,
-0.145794645,
-0.2188567817,
-0.8562319875,
0.1630677879,
0.1996274889,
-0.1381299794,
0.2733690441,
-0.7693920732,
0.0939685777,
-0.5433883667,
0.5398154855,
0.6968522072,
0.2637226284,
0.8144255877,
0.0450515486,
0.327090472,
0.6105469465,
-0.1310970783,
0.0158638489,
-0.3187881112,
-0.7285823226,
-0.153769806,
0.356991142,
0.1853498966,
-0.8475629687,
0.1029257029,
-0.2368609458,
-0.0743372068,
-0.5666808486,
0.0382170901,
0.2125126272,
0.5045279264,
0.3164581954,
-0.3521428108,
-0.514064014,
-0.980089128,
-0.2966676056,
-0.2806223035,
-0.0971200615,
0.3412376046,
0.6809453964,
-0.2796962559,
0.8683216572,
-0.5455840826,
-0.2761846781,
-0.3449285626,
0.1138447225,
0.0758226886,
0.4866558909,
0.7428731918,
-1.2120563984,
-0.0937454253,
-0.166611746,
-0.5645040274,
0.3728237748,
-0.1193680093,
-0.7035034895,
-0.2194480002,
0.5717374682,
-0.6741713881,
0.4100074768,
-0.0003261873,
-0.7286544442,
0.2568002045,
-0.407371819,
-0.2997941077,
-1.075720787,
0.1529552042,
-0.3497809172,
-0.0162399877,
-0.230235979,
0.0073589818,
0.0145864105,
0.0159026887,
-0.2966935933,
0.789087832,
-0.4455515444,
-0.3711975813,
0.0719872937,
0.2651149631,
0.3007801175,
0.0585904531,
-0.1334089339,
0.8551771045,
0.6026800275,
-0.5712449551,
0.0992730856,
0.4296499193,
-0.2081476003,
0.5071241856,
-0.9165188074,
0.0445007533,
-0.6911143661,
0.0860009044,
-1.2323765755,
-0.1821959019,
-0.0208647233,
-0.3818981051,
0.4993919432,
-0.3110069931,
-0.7617579699,
-0.3661280572,
-0.2249615639,
0.3879922032,
0.4325725436,
-0.6297430396,
0.6882197857,
0.4715993702,
0.2979801893,
-0.9100937843,
-1.1630305052,
0.0719185621,
-0.0474613793,
-0.4601566195,
0.4198935032,
0.1209268644,
-0.4961262643,
0.3368454576,
0.0062518232,
-0.0672035664,
0.1123815179,
0.2581279576,
-0.0249648616,
-0.3853144348,
0.6807789803,
0.0883130282,
0.017444659,
-0.027900897,
-0.47464028,
0.5018441677,
0.2162387818,
-0.4458270073,
-0.0088907368,
0.584256947,
0.2780548036,
-0.3155046403,
1.0639616251,
0.6789852381,
-0.1993192136,
-0.1294902414,
-0.5267392397,
-0.4093033373,
-0.4621440768,
0.3967917562,
-0.4869768322,
-0.573677659,
0.6751124263,
0.31503281,
0.011222844,
0.4784145057,
0.2811857164,
-0.0085497452,
1.0426008701,
0.6394007206,
0.1626161635,
0.5489237905,
-0.5409171581,
0.0319216363,
-0.9312191606,
-0.4905642867,
-0.4045944214,
-0.6327795386,
-0.2198966146,
-0.6465870738,
0.1897660196,
0.3280700147,
-0.3785561621,
0.0289216172,
-0.5054585338,
0.2431649864,
0.6060937643,
-0.0689575896,
0.218065992,
0.0858026147,
-0.5491479039,
-0.1185527146,
-0.5518513322,
-0.416313678,
1.0253846645,
0.2666315138,
0.7687736154,
0.1252248287,
0.8138737082,
0.2831043601,
0.0512107499,
-0.6576495171,
0.2410253733,
-0.1780385822,
-0.779794991,
0.0717084184,
-0.4764456451,
-1.1140451431,
0.6097270846,
-0.0641246364,
-0.5679510236,
0.4567082226,
-0.1527950317,
-0.3653741777,
0.435590595,
-0.878092587,
0.918030858,
-0.1832270026,
-0.0721199885,
-0.2624285817,
-0.6124227643,
0.1055070907,
0.1035752669,
-0.1024559885,
0.1369428188,
-0.5646504164,
0.7683014274,
-0.5543687344,
0.6413986087,
-0.3636606932,
0.5653236508,
0.5211883187,
-0.0271678418,
0.1291579455,
0.0837615728,
-0.4250297546,
0.0206048414,
0.1825253069,
-0.5173575282,
-0.7391674519,
0.5231069326,
-0.8964450955,
-0.2857250273,
-0.3393961489,
-0.2953135669,
0.1627587229,
0.2271314263,
0.3757698238,
0.7729042768,
-0.1927281618,
0.3959428966,
0.2634370029,
-0.2230648696,
0.3870128989,
0.0191816632,
-0.1434734911,
-0.29231745,
0.7196005583,
0.5174741745,
0.1576005518,
0.6802985072,
-0.0534583591,
-0.7265716195,
-0.6125503182,
-0.6712679863,
0.3180779219,
-1.0868470669,
-0.2047262043,
-1.1258096695,
-0.1611506045,
-0.367128253,
-0.0685914084,
-0.1463180929,
-0.480314523,
-0.5500069261,
-0.4253257811,
0.2368482798,
0.9736769199,
-0.0886272341,
0.3558062911,
-0.5685325265,
0.1768907607,
0.0079874163,
0.294074595,
0.2790494263,
-0.5903210044,
-0.3223928213,
0.0248613246,
-0.0539330728,
-0.6852340102,
0.5553800464,
0.1560863405,
0.5399572253,
0.377684772,
0.0125758387,
0.8412559032,
-0.4026623368,
0.9046314359,
-0.0131303901,
-0.6867175102,
0.1107186824,
0.1818213463,
-0.1313839704,
0.4020658433,
0.3032429516,
-0.5827645659,
-0.2185960263,
-0.5605867505,
-0.9511962533,
0.2964345217,
-0.035863746,
0.6894047856,
-0.6166594028,
0.783975184,
-0.0660915077,
0.3007018268,
-0.1619392633,
-0.3828374445,
-0.4828645885,
-0.1510826498,
-0.1439056098,
-0.7014992833,
0.1780241728,
0.0363929793,
0.0934681743,
-0.2399772555,
0.5633894205,
0.3938099742,
-0.1403728724,
-0.0063318792,
-0.1100849062,
0.0351822376,
0.373369664,
-0.0618272312,
0.4645557702,
0.0959367678,
-0.5623213649,
-0.1647198796,
-0.0834762901,
-0.1280762255,
0.4456671178,
0.3840899169,
0.8022114635,
0.7253226638,
-0.694431901,
0.805252552,
-0.1532180309,
0.1587244123,
-0.5163612366,
-0.1327008009,
0.0780291855,
0.1702180952,
0.7635343075,
0.0597276464,
0.4228520691,
-0.6061454415,
0.3849845231,
0.7706350088,
-0.4774678349,
-0.3183498085,
0.9455307126,
-0.0122852121,
0.0426068977,
0.8083939552,
-0.2004193068,
-0.4716826081,
0.5366261601,
0.6596267819,
0.719083488,
0.5381352901,
0.1898350269,
0.4313195348,
-0.0204802547,
-0.0107373884,
0.3617224991,
-0.1208606437,
-0.7061761618,
-0.3563742638,
-1.0627782345,
-0.0157977138,
-0.4433991313,
-0.7715067863,
0.2212372869,
-0.2798034549,
-0.3278923333,
-0.1192491055,
-0.0004741732,
-0.696193397,
-0.1008685902,
0.0984383225,
1.1663144827,
-0.3695032001,
0.5046675205,
0.4158780873,
-0.8027074337,
-0.8730977774,
-0.2175017893,
-0.2389353067,
-0.8335710764,
1.1218987703,
0.0621983893,
0.167581141,
0.1081160977,
-0.2190089673,
-0.9676585197,
0.9419089556,
0.3932733834,
-0.29899773,
-0.4385976493,
0.0801765248,
0.624694109,
-0.0871289521,
0.4579249918,
0.1052022576,
0.3026695549,
0.3907432258,
-0.4204395413,
-0.1101334542,
-0.0151889361,
0.3016647398,
0.3543393016,
-0.5940131545,
1.0716794729,
-0.1501680017,
-0.6216795444,
0.3387195468,
0.7608892918,
-0.3847101033,
-0.0196008533,
0.30561921,
0.4807555079,
0.7791554928,
-0.0054249032,
1.5767792463,
-0.2475496829,
0.1912894845,
0.4937361181,
-0.1139730662,
1.2016116381,
0.6946842074,
0.2814030647,
0.4962745607,
0.3826571405,
0.0334815383,
0.3292595744,
0.1470062137,
-0.3201077878,
-0.1098175794,
-0.3452821076,
-0.2544592619,
0.270696789,
0.5005435348,
-0.4535912573,
-0.2755769491,
0.1548202783,
-0.4971059263,
-0.0127787124,
-0.3110423982,
0.790027082,
0.2318679243,
-0.5298196673,
0.3295565546,
-0.1193798631,
0.6366512775,
-0.508787334,
-0.1043718308,
-0.1663967371,
0.3540759981,
-0.0869255587,
-0.8304242492,
0.5599164367,
-0.4378147423,
0.0023417166,
-0.2157649398,
0.7248592377,
-0.3709011674,
-0.3641784489,
0.7112315297,
0.6518924236,
0.4246276915,
-0.0703070909,
-0.5769541264,
0.3278530538,
-0.3567201197,
-0.0076881326,
0.3201798797,
0.9123494029,
0.0115245571,
0.3859121799,
0.581365943,
0.1848383099,
0.4192385674,
0.3578469753,
0.7641314864,
-0.8824058175,
-0.2553453147,
-0.7917912602,
0.455298692,
-0.0897579044,
-0.4319613576,
0.6654517651,
0.8741716146,
0.7010571957,
0.0150124189,
0.5567227006,
-0.0308245961,
0.4468515217,
-0.3581181467,
0.8232135773,
-0.6944848299,
0.1288885176,
0.0981590226,
-0.8039374948,
-0.2669275105,
0.4685850441,
-0.1310965866,
-0.1346318275,
0.4345932603,
0.7822615504,
-0.2426706105,
-0.3559398055,
0.5543126464,
0.3758599758,
0.1800705791,
0.2179270238,
1.038402915,
-0.4194899499,
0.6602571011,
-0.122183986,
0.1813901961,
-0.4113111198,
-0.3787416518,
-0.8088138103,
-0.7323140502,
0.0107433973,
-0.4681468606,
0.0325317904,
0.6654295325,
0.6703571081,
-0.3870480359,
-0.0039716591,
-0.0948832855,
0.2406665832,
-0.0196543317,
-0.241105482,
0.318644315,
-0.7014893293,
-0.6809231639,
0.0185391903,
0.1964275986,
0.1228321567,
-0.4271101952,
0.0849860385,
-0.0583441071,
0.1118678153,
0.5328893065,
-0.0602057688,
-0.5844788551,
-0.5111919641,
0.0218406133,
-0.4932979047,
0.1580113918,
0.8965153098,
-1.0441101789,
0.5988182425,
0.6529588699,
0.855558157,
0.6781445146,
0.0074368012,
0.6027153134,
-0.7055530548,
0.3537133336,
0.5968809128,
0.6891584992,
0.4039791524,
-0.395376265,
0.4556467533,
0.2722975016,
-0.2714174688,
-0.9003729224,
0.0650057048,
-0.8558212519,
-0.1722668856,
1.1100571156,
0.1129518822,
-0.4905953705,
-0.3937034309,
-0.4959453642,
0.263222158,
-0.29507792,
0.3215887547,
0.4975691438,
0.2695362866,
0.1638759524,
-0.6792500019,
0.2419961244,
0.4934461415,
0.1294201314,
-0.3118788004,
0.2428956777,
0.3386947811,
0.3234605193,
0.6949805021,
-0.1808240712,
-0.0792383179,
0.5581415296,
-0.2575481236,
0.2788007259,
0.0720422417,
-0.2555355132,
0.2885937989,
0.2024414986,
-0.3211192191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10378v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10378v2 | Data Curation Alone Can Stabilize In-context Learning | 2022-12-20T15:58:54 | 2023-05-24T22:32:56 | Ting-Yun Chang, Robin Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning (ICL) enables large language models (LLMs) to perform new
tasks by prompting them with a sequence of training examples. However, it is
known that ICL is very sensitive to the choice of training examples: randomly
sampling examples from a training set leads to high variance in performance. In
this paper, we show that carefully curating a subset of training data greatly
stabilizes ICL performance without any other changes to the ICL algorithm
(e.g., prompt retrieval or calibration). We introduce two methods to choose
training subsets -- both score training examples individually, then select the
highest-scoring ones. CondAcc scores a training example by its average dev-set
ICL accuracy when combined with random training examples, while Datamodels
learns linear regressors that estimate how the presence of each training
example influences LLM outputs. Across five tasks and two LLMs, sampling from
stable subsets selected by CondAcc and Datamodels improves average accuracy
over sampling from the entire training set by 7.7% and 6.3%, respectively.
Surprisingly, the stable subset examples are not especially diverse in content
or low in perplexity, in contrast with other work suggesting that diversity and
perplexity are important when prompting LLMs. | [
-0.495963186,
-0.6469591856,
0.1239241585,
-0.0705783889,
-0.2076070309,
0.1193949357,
-0.5661032796,
-0.158423543,
-0.380558759,
0.3471777141,
-0.1804649234,
-0.3178446591,
-0.4132091105,
-0.004455829,
-0.4475249648,
1.3446214199,
0.2955888212,
0.2334967256,
-0.5184816718,
-0.3399908543,
-0.5363430977,
-0.5937438011,
-0.7078738213,
-0.3573386371,
0.2698010802,
0.7277216315,
0.392871201,
0.539355576,
0.2084479928,
0.2333436757,
-0.0094327088,
0.5163574815,
-1.0155209303,
0.5695890784,
-0.0719841346,
-0.6025437713,
0.1888875812,
0.271092087,
0.8576980829,
0.9925955534,
-0.1735624969,
-0.1063727289,
0.4093966186,
0.6410518885,
-0.7770084143,
-0.1184202135,
-0.8806685805,
-0.1569185555,
-0.3408324122,
-0.1596358716,
-0.7987090349,
-0.2221897542,
0.1342444271,
-0.373175025,
0.2296136171,
0.0109457886,
0.5479201674,
0.3372532427,
-0.2825008333,
-0.1995272189,
-0.7582643628,
0.9504900575,
-0.4978697002,
0.3580017388,
0.6781617999,
0.129912883,
-0.3529878855,
-0.4543911517,
-0.3174046874,
-0.1478150785,
-0.1125406548,
0.0503647551,
0.4255425334,
-0.0302853808,
0.5088822842,
0.3932208121,
-0.0535826683,
0.3889772594,
-0.5231560469,
-0.1089761108,
0.4222732782,
0.1819603592,
0.1420275271,
0.220910877,
-0.1551032811,
-0.3431713283,
-1.1422127485,
0.4757153392,
0.2972092628,
0.4347847104,
-0.0413941257,
0.3782363832,
0.0744104013,
0.7919110656,
0.5542593002,
-0.2705469728,
0.1734983623,
-0.1876647472,
-0.2410217822,
0.0233672503,
0.4431268871,
0.1018520668,
0.110198155,
-0.250972569,
-0.3974803686,
-0.0125855859,
0.3372747898,
-0.6468789577,
-0.361967206,
0.1876221299,
-0.2037393153,
-0.1631182879,
0.4264970124,
-0.3577227294,
-0.2824526131,
-0.5612201691,
-0.0497272164,
-0.3847796023,
0.2046711296,
-0.0226401277,
-0.0306641255,
0.0850401893,
0.3254453242,
-0.9605974555,
0.4029010534,
0.5727149248,
0.5658072233,
-0.2473161519,
-0.1806362569,
-1.0616192818,
0.0492777601,
-0.4644840658,
0.6214636564,
-0.7129597664,
-0.4117911458,
0.1314064711,
-0.1650224775,
0.0833750367,
-0.7425906658,
0.39137429,
-0.4827430248,
0.2307894081,
-0.4586050808,
-0.6935556531,
0.1760005057,
0.1711326987,
-0.8350066543,
1.1885706186,
0.3463906646,
-0.8361611366,
0.9016718268,
-0.2271493673,
-0.5186077356,
0.0085913418,
-0.2987726033,
-0.5674096942,
0.1405531168,
0.2526583672,
0.6117144823,
0.1772880703,
0.3671257794,
-0.3586242199,
-0.6214684248,
0.3300961554,
-0.1513692886,
0.8194913864,
0.2035133094,
-0.1965397298,
-0.2174592912,
-0.4532872438,
-0.1185755655,
-0.5940443277,
-0.67869699,
-0.6370014548,
0.0871033445,
-0.0681097433,
0.5748701096,
-0.4229581356,
-0.4503628314,
0.278994143,
-0.4708405137,
0.307346642,
0.8048706055,
0.0640801564,
0.710180521,
-0.6324205399,
0.4874190986,
0.3442673683,
-0.1214455068,
-0.1101013422,
-0.2423048019,
-0.6651774645,
-0.2926204503,
0.3047747314,
0.2064416856,
-0.8336137533,
0.2543842196,
-0.2517887652,
-0.5408680439,
-0.6577289104,
0.505248189,
0.5743690133,
0.7684682608,
0.2482272685,
-0.2627409101,
-0.5160781145,
-0.6514069438,
0.1419413686,
-0.0162495114,
0.2100162357,
0.1825722754,
0.2781254351,
0.2582508028,
1.0189195871,
0.0753089041,
-0.1949855834,
-0.2826411724,
-0.1070434153,
0.1651590914,
0.6677134633,
0.7179881334,
-0.8461654186,
-0.5236725211,
-0.2940492928,
-0.4965959489,
-0.0509317853,
-0.2094501704,
-0.212297976,
0.1688332111,
0.5740725398,
-0.4657381475,
0.3393507004,
0.394243896,
-0.1779806912,
0.3395988643,
-0.1045238823,
0.0395254232,
-0.9288437963,
-0.0055320868,
0.0378703773,
-0.3369044662,
-0.6019845009,
-0.0410576127,
0.2533853352,
0.1150704548,
-0.5510972142,
0.6171913147,
-0.3622554541,
0.1507149339,
-0.1470277309,
0.1804824024,
0.0401494466,
0.1785174608,
-0.0760822669,
0.7725198865,
0.6207349896,
-0.8751290441,
-0.1682119966,
0.4266112149,
-0.6411855221,
0.4868424833,
-0.3606934249,
0.2186383605,
-0.3131950796,
0.4283340871,
-0.8955839276,
-0.1370370835,
-0.0170410648,
-0.1032430083,
0.6541733742,
-0.0268984176,
-0.3028298616,
0.0291980784,
-0.4244792461,
0.403989315,
0.3324956,
-0.6709207296,
0.0989115015,
0.678619504,
0.2320867032,
-0.7602267861,
-0.8785797954,
-0.2055755109,
-0.2534457147,
-0.0690115988,
0.2882148623,
-0.419080317,
-0.4990009069,
-0.1646611989,
-0.1062705293,
0.2307562977,
0.3014074862,
0.5046254396,
0.2512189746,
0.1110421568,
0.3158685863,
0.0585008934,
0.051162947,
-0.240864709,
-0.3106017113,
0.4096916616,
0.1797790378,
-0.3766415715,
-0.0866081938,
0.2672953606,
0.516955018,
-0.1444336772,
0.798638165,
0.2057729512,
-0.34563151,
-0.6407718062,
-0.6127652526,
-0.3737458885,
-0.411016047,
0.1843216717,
-0.2730413675,
-0.986495018,
0.5157400966,
0.3448393047,
0.3778539896,
0.012477925,
0.6586138606,
-0.2246395946,
0.8073541522,
0.5599070191,
-0.4959872067,
0.879552424,
-0.3841160536,
0.1974012554,
-0.8615981936,
-0.1039570794,
-0.4930571914,
-0.53728652,
-0.4640437365,
-0.0899512768,
0.3214217722,
-0.0094196079,
-0.3402080238,
-0.1300515532,
-0.4218068719,
0.6359936595,
0.6096859574,
0.4439702034,
0.1792456955,
0.1094989851,
-0.1957274228,
-0.0459350273,
-0.7987614274,
-0.4747465253,
1.1818797588,
-0.0390419103,
0.979637444,
-0.2767267227,
0.5501432419,
0.1913361847,
0.4287872314,
-0.4839197993,
0.2536076307,
-0.4799952805,
-0.4516126513,
-0.1823961586,
-0.1836916953,
-0.8224045038,
-0.0801933706,
-0.1726271957,
-0.6142360568,
0.573369801,
0.3742893934,
-0.5346442461,
0.2297151536,
-0.5078779459,
0.4226851463,
-0.0472996682,
-0.4783913493,
-0.1027164534,
-0.5754828453,
0.4318673611,
-0.0967818275,
0.1951036155,
0.1546202749,
0.0740931854,
0.4486922324,
-0.3023133278,
0.8920560479,
-0.1938469559,
0.1798571199,
0.2743544579,
0.2941290438,
0.4516502023,
0.3274642527,
-0.5089947581,
-0.3680954874,
-0.2696064115,
-0.4245143235,
-0.8060866594,
0.8661446571,
-0.8536512852,
-0.5272260904,
-0.1694026738,
-0.7375538349,
-0.3206405342,
-0.2488918304,
0.3603657782,
0.7066274285,
0.1448052078,
0.7668654323,
0.7956931591,
0.1756127328,
0.4510077238,
0.1694512963,
0.0532752164,
-0.349304527,
0.4217897058,
0.4283797443,
0.7017468214,
0.3184452653,
-0.0885323808,
-0.0064516379,
-0.7519264817,
-0.2045568526,
-0.1734005958,
-0.979496181,
-0.4712702036,
-0.5350957513,
-0.1732978672,
0.0327488482,
-0.4327804148,
-0.1567390561,
-0.3273392618,
-0.2704384625,
-0.554148078,
0.257038027,
0.4604092538,
0.0766600221,
0.1725868285,
-0.3353646994,
-0.0084011294,
0.2736140788,
0.1673627794,
-0.1058432013,
-0.6465038061,
-0.5382015705,
0.2171465755,
-0.0093158949,
-0.3036197126,
0.2406269461,
0.5519731045,
0.770393014,
0.5593425632,
0.1560236365,
0.96559304,
-0.0981000289,
0.8682671785,
-0.3352392018,
-0.6626673341,
0.5083630681,
-0.1345740706,
0.3909372687,
1.1746279001,
0.1605373174,
-0.4362508953,
-0.8850213885,
-0.5159068704,
-0.6411314011,
0.7965121865,
-0.2584382892,
0.3522449136,
-0.2175314277,
0.5285121202,
0.3248055875,
0.1556529552,
-0.6737124324,
-0.1479803771,
-0.1513681561,
-0.2379954457,
0.0507144108,
-0.252638936,
-0.1691907048,
-0.498092711,
0.8354338408,
-0.2311137468,
-0.269199878,
0.0451799408,
-0.3457017839,
-0.1527802348,
-0.1699965894,
0.369823277,
0.7161747217,
-0.1244496852,
0.2853080332,
0.2399979979,
-0.5355302095,
0.1800819784,
-0.2814509273,
-0.5754101276,
-0.2739349902,
0.3265024722,
0.6780079007,
0.778442502,
-0.7741057873,
0.3966423571,
-0.1551128924,
0.0768759847,
-0.084428139,
0.3470670581,
-0.3277508616,
0.0183833688,
0.4125294685,
0.2023442537,
-0.1415097266,
-0.4775168598,
0.4057083428,
0.4788649082,
-0.3331588507,
-0.1343121827,
0.5491909981,
-0.1609365493,
0.0029079958,
1.2922422886,
-0.1897894591,
-0.2708992958,
0.4856984019,
0.6836429834,
0.5566876531,
-0.199619174,
0.0908033475,
0.4118067622,
0.0849018171,
-0.3942159116,
0.1190142259,
-0.1578374654,
-0.9613959193,
-0.209699899,
-0.5274822712,
-0.2753403485,
0.0332799703,
-0.6222795248,
0.4432763159,
-0.593688488,
-0.0752469003,
-0.5063147545,
0.1673966795,
-0.8287624121,
0.2419877499,
0.1163614318,
0.8942112923,
-1.0276623964,
1.1759579182,
0.5400469303,
-0.3901721537,
-0.8881663084,
-0.2634869516,
-0.1548078507,
-0.2738130987,
0.5614067912,
0.1643460542,
0.3024743199,
-0.0613012202,
-0.8387672901,
-0.9214041233,
1.0648100376,
0.6830821633,
-0.6098900437,
0.0908069685,
-0.2370946705,
0.3954817951,
-0.6227219105,
0.2166869491,
0.5582076311,
0.2257708162,
-0.0441325083,
-0.5960181952,
-0.1207002848,
-0.4029958844,
-0.0384652913,
0.0076757707,
-0.5371860862,
0.7864867449,
-0.0726557225,
-0.1925625354,
-0.1577186435,
0.4158760309,
0.6563807726,
-0.0658948421,
0.5323770642,
0.5901996493,
0.9336818457,
-0.1846380681,
1.248105526,
-0.3837503791,
0.1326367259,
1.314899087,
-0.0952478424,
0.6690876484,
0.71987468,
0.0666098967,
0.4207413793,
0.898204565,
-0.1879869699,
0.7696213126,
-0.0098380242,
-0.2485451996,
-0.3810889125,
-0.2545975447,
0.0434962548,
0.4558271468,
0.3913708627,
-0.2716358006,
-0.2170292288,
0.396941036,
0.1369410902,
0.2755390704,
-0.321809411,
0.5843503475,
0.1827500612,
-0.9278088212,
0.3499017358,
-0.4660721719,
0.5332834125,
-0.5283427238,
-0.0401708446,
-0.3690621555,
0.1383769959,
-0.3903127015,
-0.6270437241,
0.2158133239,
-0.3126694262,
-0.5172464252,
-0.4151040018,
0.4955727458,
-0.7178589702,
-0.479768008,
0.0355298631,
0.3314145207,
-0.0494990423,
0.2624940872,
-0.3101287186,
0.0735449642,
-0.1295321882,
-0.3338251114,
0.6213117838,
0.421833396,
-0.3998790383,
0.690517664,
0.6701009274,
0.1419098526,
0.0542851239,
0.223019436,
1.1149045229,
-0.020588195,
-0.2168265283,
-1.0243257284,
0.9134799838,
-0.1422178,
-0.4419212341,
0.7093305588,
0.6207173467,
1.3941931725,
-0.0338620543,
0.7809439898,
-0.090643391,
0.1897969693,
-0.5497811437,
0.6369802952,
-0.1714697331,
0.4096650779,
-0.1584140509,
-0.6805087924,
-0.5013130307,
0.5070409179,
-0.4499589503,
-0.0052251141,
0.4015633762,
0.8454706073,
-0.0765216351,
-0.2784914374,
0.3552736938,
0.0303215552,
0.4605751336,
0.452925086,
0.6495401263,
-0.2377341241,
0.28842628,
-0.6421488523,
-0.011970479,
-0.0023972001,
-0.8393096924,
-1.0288332701,
-0.8113600016,
-0.2276062071,
-0.3550151587,
-0.0181802288,
1.1882865429,
0.9629603028,
-1.0271214247,
-0.1620667577,
0.2758540809,
0.2480162233,
-0.4014882147,
-0.2011317164,
0.3365148008,
-0.831938386,
-0.840783,
0.407283783,
0.2578083575,
-0.2000900358,
-0.1834571213,
-0.1340027899,
-0.2404192537,
-0.373962611,
0.4875592589,
0.1102636606,
-0.5508201122,
-0.3381105959,
-0.1614938378,
-0.1764843464,
0.2635185421,
0.8958845735,
-1.1862914562,
0.6871179342,
0.3492664695,
0.8352376819,
0.3890014291,
0.2571997046,
0.7005060315,
-1.0295479298,
0.3484568,
0.3161851764,
0.5650042295,
0.5650739074,
-0.5413681269,
0.3471858501,
-0.0353694782,
-0.6973560452,
-0.8852539062,
-0.0376858823,
-0.7233236432,
-0.0224078409,
0.8916764855,
-0.1460952908,
-0.1587296426,
-0.2226861864,
-0.2202210575,
0.1761091352,
-0.4930085838,
1.068926096,
0.8810372353,
0.1181555167,
-0.1750093997,
-0.6376865506,
0.7752255797,
0.1734866053,
-0.4279164076,
0.0879535899,
0.5046792626,
0.3197847009,
-0.1608757973,
0.4125551879,
-0.0990932807,
0.2660260201,
-0.4359155297,
-0.3799268603,
-0.1693295985,
-0.2665995657,
-0.2959980667,
0.2706767321,
0.2322768271,
0.0351003483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10375v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10375v2 | Self-Adaptive In-Context Learning: An Information Compression Perspective for In-Context Example Selection and Ordering | 2022-12-20T15:55:21 | 2023-05-03T14:43:50 | Zhiyong Wu, Yaoxiang Wang, Jiacheng Ye, Lingpeng Kong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the surprising few-shot performance of in-context learning (ICL), it
is still a common practice to randomly sample examples to serve as context.
This paper advocates a new principle for ICL: self-adaptive in-context
learning. The self-adaption mechanism is introduced to help each sample find an
in-context example permutation (i.e., selection and ordering) that can derive
the correct prediction, thus maximizing performance. To validate the
effectiveness of self-adaptive ICL, we propose a general select-then-rank
framework and instantiate it with new selection and ranking algorithms. Upon
extensive evaluation on eight different NLP datasets, our self-adaptive ICL
method achieves a 40% relative improvement over the common practice setting.
Further analysis reveals the enormous potential of self-adaptive ICL that it
might be able to close the gap between ICL and finetuning given more advanced
algorithms. Our code is released to facilitate future research in this area:
https://github.com/Shark-NLP/self-adaptive-ICL | [
-0.2738912702,
-0.2717849314,
0.2455409169,
0.5165935159,
-0.284455806,
-0.0181556586,
-0.0821314529,
-0.5135915279,
-0.0628803298,
0.1504430175,
-0.3144720197,
-0.3730716407,
-0.4375842512,
0.2579729259,
-0.4780037999,
1.1012252569,
0.4241939783,
0.0628613755,
-0.2312757969,
-0.4104142487,
-0.7368693352,
-0.6778483987,
-0.6871119142,
-0.0987948254,
0.1713493168,
0.7220253944,
0.2300923467,
0.6614160538,
0.3386457562,
0.2752031982,
0.1223073378,
-0.0862153545,
-0.5171467662,
0.2778198719,
-0.3677843511,
-0.2242710143,
-0.1539189667,
-0.1091083959,
0.7778268456,
0.3231929541,
-0.2125566602,
0.2183446288,
0.5083602667,
0.6385831237,
-0.6736965179,
-0.1056407019,
-0.8908107877,
0.012689204,
-0.0714202225,
-0.4863725007,
-0.4833551347,
0.150179401,
0.2663383782,
-0.426027149,
0.0575836785,
0.2949990332,
0.0674265176,
0.489851594,
-0.0235504229,
-0.4695594013,
-0.4979335666,
0.6372704506,
-0.7885927558,
0.2358603328,
0.1532950103,
0.4061457515,
-0.2189967632,
-0.9538759589,
-0.2957317531,
0.0663342476,
0.0932900608,
0.3177580535,
0.0299140904,
-0.0949706808,
0.1459499747,
0.2502709031,
-0.4982281923,
0.4175352156,
-0.2194430083,
0.2108526528,
0.5555562973,
-0.1132855713,
0.2437536716,
-0.0621324666,
-0.523555696,
-0.1867094487,
-0.7326463461,
0.1298580468,
0.1127742603,
0.4523453712,
-0.0405706801,
0.0477325208,
-0.3883346319,
0.7966603041,
0.3410186172,
-0.1287346184,
0.2522445023,
0.0238694362,
-0.2951094508,
0.5904881358,
0.4935369194,
0.2498625517,
-0.1017331406,
-0.0354657806,
-0.1987660527,
-0.6190350056,
0.3672227263,
-0.6343162656,
-0.3892275989,
0.1600180566,
-0.6042186618,
-0.2195751965,
-0.0975990593,
-0.66068542,
-0.2070332021,
-0.1084976941,
0.7099165916,
-0.2553627491,
-0.0026763035,
0.244261682,
0.0067673586,
0.1873744726,
0.4286959171,
-1.1545889378,
0.5412961841,
0.3921582997,
0.784318924,
-0.5317240357,
-0.6644625068,
-0.461672157,
0.1384003758,
-0.1922304481,
1.0242168903,
-0.2871091366,
-0.1800568998,
-0.1549147218,
-0.3871492445,
0.0874172226,
-0.7300000787,
0.3381580412,
-0.2412661165,
0.3848783076,
-0.0476152375,
-0.6842826605,
-0.0169528406,
0.054892011,
-0.3076317012,
1.1047562361,
0.1973007619,
-0.6429240704,
0.4513985217,
-0.8847489357,
-0.2895357609,
0.2538724244,
-0.1666726172,
-0.30616799,
0.1799251586,
0.278440088,
0.6010870934,
0.0686842203,
-0.1138362736,
-0.5133320689,
-0.5072795153,
0.1582895815,
-0.3590925634,
0.9146545529,
0.4183485508,
-0.3550534844,
0.0390897132,
-0.473603487,
0.025036836,
0.0182569697,
-0.4411762357,
-0.4048155248,
0.208084479,
-0.0727285445,
0.4779109657,
-0.0546282157,
-0.2066063434,
0.4840699732,
-0.4834674299,
0.4017890692,
0.9848752022,
0.0444119647,
0.5970007777,
-0.1861760169,
0.1776335239,
-0.0860469937,
0.3748278916,
-0.1388035566,
-0.0870847777,
-0.6449307203,
-0.0150611047,
0.4150479436,
0.3600253761,
-0.6251392961,
0.3853931427,
-0.1868679225,
-0.1839353144,
-0.4254304171,
0.3475920558,
0.3493509591,
0.5908119678,
0.7903978229,
-0.4438378215,
-0.5240778923,
-0.5058496594,
-0.2815870047,
-0.2963829637,
-0.085933499,
0.269626081,
0.1747395098,
0.0775402263,
1.0506403446,
-0.3104522526,
-0.4085375965,
-0.0509593822,
0.0030247963,
0.112846218,
0.7049903274,
0.9144377112,
-0.8887590766,
-0.511649847,
-0.412260741,
-0.7540588379,
-0.1735308021,
-0.241323173,
0.0499261692,
-0.044840686,
0.8554866314,
0.1926386952,
0.2496220767,
0.544197619,
-0.2508222461,
0.3664311767,
-0.5495887399,
-0.2621938586,
-0.9937950373,
-0.4277018309,
-0.0036300225,
-0.3469981253,
-0.4677709937,
0.0801008269,
0.2131867558,
0.1722657084,
-0.5659614801,
0.6815704703,
-0.3932769299,
-0.2956567407,
-0.5116595626,
-0.086234875,
-0.3689084649,
0.3335666955,
-0.1652827412,
0.8647722006,
0.656852901,
-0.8642790914,
-0.1628810912,
0.1834156513,
-0.6064426303,
0.5370025039,
-0.2773207724,
0.1393817365,
-0.1640053838,
0.3065404892,
-0.9143069983,
-0.0864167288,
0.2242784798,
-0.1443133652,
0.5338436365,
-0.2288795561,
-0.2168483138,
-0.158712104,
-0.0536103062,
0.7034390569,
0.5373980999,
-1.1078824997,
0.3637714386,
0.5392645001,
-0.1327967495,
-0.6867386699,
-0.5764465332,
0.2028901726,
-0.4179622531,
0.1352522373,
0.7161914706,
-0.839773953,
-0.0845853388,
-0.2394024581,
-0.2725763321,
-0.0813575312,
0.5126197934,
0.049899783,
-0.2381239384,
-0.1267852485,
0.3715325594,
0.1046310216,
-0.0203509163,
-0.2366497964,
-0.6723223925,
0.3075698316,
-0.1483426243,
-0.2024762779,
-0.1119684055,
0.2124581337,
0.1886537969,
0.1636412591,
0.1961720437,
0.1964292377,
-0.1476974934,
-0.5733380318,
-0.5342276692,
-0.1624148339,
-0.5482792854,
0.2145517617,
-0.3759661317,
-0.8254296184,
0.186392054,
-0.2090631723,
0.1157700717,
0.3351488709,
0.5213528275,
-0.4486067891,
0.8178903461,
0.8508965969,
-0.2818263173,
0.859520793,
-0.1724321842,
0.092659466,
-0.9178591371,
0.2190804183,
-0.3586636484,
-0.4267586768,
-0.6167881489,
-0.017361613,
0.3631316125,
0.2373493463,
-0.055661507,
0.1999341995,
-0.8155900836,
0.8442956805,
0.5465455651,
0.1438977569,
0.1220196784,
-0.0171045624,
-0.1397105604,
0.1456176639,
-0.9867306352,
-0.1050521955,
0.8072833419,
0.0548619181,
0.651294589,
0.1377346516,
0.8678641319,
0.7047979236,
0.3794243336,
-0.5472455621,
0.3794624805,
-0.2832002342,
-0.4892668128,
-0.4907301962,
-0.0802977085,
-0.938300848,
0.3658421338,
-0.2690328956,
-0.7208772302,
0.2825918496,
0.3490982652,
-0.4776502252,
0.0794108585,
-0.6900979877,
0.6899055243,
-0.3963983059,
-0.1618916839,
-0.1680958867,
-0.7454414964,
-0.0657288581,
-0.1581001729,
0.1292675734,
-0.176217854,
0.0382825769,
0.6462203264,
0.0350241289,
0.7303115726,
-0.2653088272,
0.3603574932,
0.2740978897,
0.0397552736,
0.0256106351,
0.1590577513,
-0.2773417234,
0.0652103797,
0.0746292099,
-0.5166404247,
-0.846460402,
0.7622485161,
-0.7215148807,
-0.5790931582,
-0.5860291123,
-0.4139051437,
0.0015835337,
0.2444710284,
0.4403785169,
0.5678185821,
0.0597416162,
0.4557081461,
0.396389544,
-0.0436178967,
0.9802744985,
0.5461594462,
-0.0617867783,
-0.3612646759,
0.9018417597,
0.458224833,
0.1094447896,
0.4776733518,
0.4154652655,
-0.232543081,
-1.0480986834,
-0.3128991723,
-0.1914072633,
-1.0393667221,
-0.4936167002,
-0.5135625601,
-0.2411389053,
-0.4264605343,
-0.411239475,
-0.1010790914,
-0.3603829443,
-0.3209047616,
0.0765556619,
-0.1070294827,
0.6494594812,
-0.0296091754,
0.2285181433,
-0.2292156368,
0.1038577557,
0.6462942362,
0.4128151834,
-0.0244695805,
-0.7036086917,
-0.3387577534,
-0.2843775153,
-0.32130301,
-0.5424000621,
0.4510299265,
0.4505265653,
0.7348627448,
0.2200850248,
0.3429324925,
0.8541708589,
-0.5676550865,
0.6746996641,
-0.0262120664,
-0.8922250271,
0.5164717436,
-0.020606596,
0.5084113479,
0.8509885669,
0.3353883028,
-0.4809187949,
-0.2602547109,
-0.8024332523,
-0.7806785107,
0.5528150797,
0.0201116558,
0.2139528096,
-0.0344826207,
0.7600830197,
0.2452999353,
-0.0174814574,
-1.0375974178,
-0.293717742,
-0.4146647453,
-0.536256671,
-0.1896781474,
-0.4955401123,
0.1195709482,
-0.3893792629,
0.6701503992,
-0.7961224318,
0.3976585567,
0.5571537614,
-0.437005192,
0.1655389816,
0.1239882335,
0.5720187426,
0.794121027,
-0.2801050246,
0.2515870631,
0.5702808499,
-0.2282215059,
0.1244652644,
-0.0949872434,
-0.1831586808,
-0.435451299,
0.1990370601,
0.4388223588,
0.663862586,
-0.4606435895,
0.6507713199,
-0.2223794609,
-0.0409988686,
-0.3497571349,
0.421191752,
-0.4711272717,
0.3696872294,
0.7969542146,
0.1211924702,
0.5361396074,
-0.4237265587,
0.3840718269,
0.3090940714,
-0.4753905237,
-0.0671766624,
0.3977924287,
-0.0984077305,
-0.4703458846,
0.4873417318,
-0.2194465846,
-0.1556361616,
0.3680823445,
1.024539113,
0.9288808703,
-0.3357196748,
0.0120490706,
0.2402596772,
-0.0277161635,
-0.3267621994,
0.0076435041,
-0.335729599,
-0.8179089427,
-0.2369377911,
-0.4579462111,
-0.4204586148,
0.0059954897,
-0.5384681821,
0.3309719563,
-0.6151880622,
0.2764008641,
-0.0424177647,
-0.0797857493,
-0.5198256373,
0.3584975898,
0.0041666641,
1.0170253515,
-0.630569458,
1.1742717028,
0.4058572948,
-0.0914655998,
-0.4169708192,
0.3491205871,
-0.1330741197,
-0.5932270885,
0.4517276287,
0.2606300712,
-0.0064965435,
0.3418700099,
-0.9079229832,
-1.1314582825,
1.2249263525,
0.3659242392,
-0.1676198095,
0.0072224429,
-0.458607465,
0.5351762772,
-0.8736317754,
0.3675583303,
0.1139091551,
-0.0802025869,
-0.0816764981,
-0.5821256042,
-0.1836583018,
-0.1236609444,
0.1021245569,
-0.2279352099,
-0.8104074001,
0.4721013606,
0.058584366,
-0.1010810733,
-0.0813299045,
0.9593710899,
0.09915784,
0.4659431875,
0.7874665856,
0.1855962425,
0.6375648379,
0.2579163313,
0.943005383,
-0.352711767,
0.3372100592,
1.5733923912,
-0.1801991761,
0.9214023948,
0.3500978947,
-0.0047307755,
0.6775985956,
0.6880491972,
-0.016904803,
0.8000040054,
-0.0650508106,
-0.1076647937,
-0.1808179617,
0.0463630147,
-0.2021874189,
0.8178586364,
0.2965614796,
-0.3123731017,
-0.2475142628,
0.1282839179,
-0.4580768347,
-0.1304634064,
-0.4067659676,
1.0545208454,
0.0384371839,
-0.5812882781,
0.5050580502,
-0.2920969427,
0.6136736274,
-0.4634512663,
-0.2082011104,
-0.0080414144,
-0.0865482092,
-0.1228474453,
-0.6955340505,
0.055187311,
-0.4505231678,
-0.269282788,
-0.5485268831,
0.9393031597,
-0.165922448,
-0.2613215744,
0.3749069571,
0.3375140429,
0.2185240388,
0.1516265869,
-1.0614554882,
-0.306799978,
-0.1376041621,
-0.059696611,
0.8651509881,
0.284452796,
0.0133568589,
0.8170647621,
0.5429008007,
-0.2515700459,
0.0619540811,
-0.1268627048,
0.6969088912,
-0.5208721757,
-0.7478305101,
-0.8138127327,
0.326790601,
-0.2111794502,
-0.49361974,
0.6492857933,
0.4894287288,
1.3260008097,
0.0672658682,
0.6066922545,
0.0618900806,
0.3194836974,
-0.7153611779,
0.4741090536,
-0.5222966075,
0.2053386569,
-0.4103113115,
-0.6697679162,
-0.632194221,
0.7813249826,
-0.2050041705,
0.0119849052,
0.6367590427,
0.4676588476,
-0.2527110279,
-0.1356098205,
0.4902583957,
0.2430779189,
0.2155763507,
0.1329611987,
0.5417723656,
-0.4042273164,
0.266905874,
-0.4682088792,
-0.1294091791,
-0.5007653832,
-1.2212146521,
-0.5389918089,
-0.8577631116,
-0.3344759345,
-0.2673273385,
-0.054378897,
1.3749517202,
1.0429981947,
-0.6892973185,
-0.4455356598,
-0.0119749894,
0.3178038597,
-0.6534003615,
-0.1638492793,
0.2996912897,
-0.6869853139,
-0.5577577353,
0.7881215811,
0.6781862974,
0.2095605135,
0.0194664728,
-0.1090847775,
-0.2381886691,
-0.2912835479,
0.6772546172,
0.5673822165,
-0.5992215872,
-0.4302154481,
-0.3876343369,
0.0636936873,
0.4843082726,
0.8287044764,
-0.9780716896,
0.7294805646,
0.3637900054,
0.7310305238,
0.4051745832,
0.0507067554,
0.2666329741,
-0.7813584805,
0.0708692074,
0.2729069591,
0.3495053351,
0.271522671,
-0.4966323674,
0.5876350999,
-0.030689897,
-0.8719736934,
-0.7739021182,
0.1623530239,
-0.873626709,
-0.6079600453,
0.8748156428,
-0.0152222393,
-0.2438507974,
-0.1726092845,
-0.1806081086,
0.0122756213,
-0.2825194895,
1.3715980053,
0.4572335184,
-0.4139409959,
-0.281534344,
-0.4801713824,
0.7513369918,
0.4247026443,
-0.7001431584,
-0.1204186752,
0.1526340395,
0.434155494,
-0.0618979372,
0.8014852405,
0.1858898401,
0.3150222003,
-0.5337097049,
0.0034275393,
0.1672442704,
-0.5986722112,
-0.8493272066,
0.3277245164,
0.2791257203,
0.0752568543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10356v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10356v2 | Dissecting Transformer Length Extrapolation via the Lens of Receptive Field Analysis | 2022-12-20T15:40:17 | 2023-05-23T21:18:09 | Ta-Chung Chi, Ting-Han Fan, Alexander I. Rudnicky, Peter J. Ramadge | cs.CL | cs.CL | Length extrapolation permits training a transformer language model on short
sequences that preserves perplexities when tested on substantially longer
sequences. A relative positional embedding design, ALiBi, has had the widest
usage to date. We dissect ALiBi via the lens of receptive field analysis
empowered by a novel cumulative normalized gradient tool. The concept of
receptive field further allows us to modify the vanilla Sinusoidal positional
embedding to create ~\textbf{Sandwich}, the first parameter-free relative
positional embedding design that truly length information uses longer than the
training sequence. Sandwich shares with KERPLE and T5 the same logarithmic
decaying temporal bias pattern with learnable relative positional embeddings;
these elucidate future extrapolatable positional embedding design. | [
-0.5264376998,
-0.5366167426,
0.4804805815,
0.1105539426,
-0.0774628818,
0.1028849185,
0.0504840128,
-0.6031588912,
0.3829814196,
0.2214962691,
-0.4035997391,
-0.1719128639,
-0.4941192865,
-0.1857380122,
-0.4900450706,
0.7582634091,
0.1226451993,
-0.1599771082,
0.04869188,
-0.3868885934,
0.0919165388,
-0.3581394851,
-0.5255202651,
-0.4054050446,
0.4229139388,
0.2797442973,
0.7106323242,
0.4159865379,
0.3964118659,
0.3038678467,
-0.1428679973,
-0.2370108813,
-0.2950240076,
0.0020393871,
-0.1055069938,
-0.8292071819,
-0.3377590477,
0.0246904735,
0.6912530065,
0.7821503282,
-0.2564568818,
0.2194586545,
-0.176334694,
0.8130227923,
-0.422989279,
0.1288806945,
-0.4503696859,
0.4126496315,
-0.1072127447,
-0.1136953458,
-0.5844865441,
-0.2032865286,
0.3218710423,
-0.5391871333,
0.6602217555,
-0.0163636897,
0.7995992303,
0.1996646374,
-0.3729124069,
0.0025596612,
-0.9218497276,
0.9174904227,
-0.3660143912,
0.7454555631,
0.153087005,
0.5838298202,
0.0627425015,
-0.7749374509,
-0.6237462163,
-0.1262907237,
-0.3577062786,
0.2373524457,
-0.3332182169,
-0.0140832374,
0.5420701504,
0.2639797628,
-0.4169267416,
-0.1431706548,
-0.5443701148,
0.0934580564,
0.4729641974,
0.1185673401,
-0.1604536921,
0.0433414727,
-0.4934842288,
-0.4108799994,
-0.6762757897,
0.3592242301,
0.4397164583,
-0.3851327598,
-0.0726294741,
0.3402945697,
-0.0734486803,
0.6237111688,
0.5618832707,
0.1833893508,
0.6021540165,
0.2752705514,
-0.2416209728,
0.0404755808,
0.4592192173,
0.3817906082,
-0.1080149189,
-0.0775116086,
-0.0599420816,
-0.1118010059,
0.4539572299,
-0.4059708118,
-0.3071183264,
-0.0188224223,
-0.4772621095,
-0.2926053703,
0.1667975932,
-0.8521621823,
-0.1057320759,
-0.0479663201,
-0.0018815665,
-0.4275370538,
-0.0383518897,
0.0103532868,
-0.3378606737,
0.7570533752,
-0.2080914229,
-1.025326848,
0.2091539651,
0.4156948328,
0.6980468631,
0.1025354266,
-0.194566071,
-0.0002939335,
0.3933667243,
-0.2147043943,
0.9300364852,
-0.8662571907,
-0.5921278596,
-0.0961990133,
0.3587382734,
0.2541187406,
-0.3205146492,
0.5681532025,
-0.8411240578,
0.3432021439,
-0.1466443092,
-0.4195705652,
-0.4348678589,
0.1016885415,
-1.0731321573,
0.6470320225,
0.685151577,
-0.4620406926,
0.3930777609,
-0.701787889,
-0.3499871194,
-0.0865514204,
-0.2870229483,
-0.6895120144,
0.5734729171,
0.2976048291,
0.2087727934,
-0.1837503314,
-0.1327886134,
-0.263676554,
-0.4628545344,
0.3980903625,
-0.6059204936,
0.6460917592,
0.1723906249,
-0.3597383499,
-0.1954513341,
-0.9347601533,
0.0079230368,
0.2601409853,
-0.3273297846,
-0.2869011462,
-0.0484094173,
-0.1061810553,
0.1276994348,
-0.2319408059,
-0.6671532989,
-0.1077290699,
-0.635430336,
0.5777661204,
0.6214382648,
-0.2055692822,
0.7705232501,
-0.4190884531,
0.6988537908,
-0.072206974,
0.3198235035,
-0.4206369817,
-0.2625216544,
-0.7056561112,
-0.244321987,
0.0579152219,
0.2601293623,
-0.4588087499,
0.2474708557,
-0.3025997579,
-0.3746986389,
-0.4599032402,
-0.4224370718,
0.3900384009,
0.4260321856,
0.6084910035,
-0.3265133202,
-0.383623749,
-1.2019437551,
0.0857968926,
0.0258539412,
-0.178243205,
0.1324980408,
0.1097375453,
-0.1648129076,
0.8068525195,
-0.7684395909,
-0.1504025161,
-0.2152564973,
0.0699576512,
0.407073766,
0.3432948291,
0.6867203116,
-0.7394927144,
-0.5373237729,
-0.164615646,
-0.5965978503,
-0.109003447,
-0.1557997018,
0.0023101333,
0.0749100149,
0.5305313468,
-0.774389267,
0.5231849551,
0.6171272397,
-0.2396597117,
0.2540602088,
0.04156157,
0.0020097692,
-0.8038367629,
0.1041554436,
-0.0569150038,
-0.369358778,
-0.5809354782,
0.2332213074,
0.2325256318,
0.1755694151,
-0.4379161298,
0.3298733532,
-0.5993151665,
-0.0629770011,
-0.3759165704,
-0.16271092,
0.448595196,
0.5250471234,
0.1044378504,
0.4510794878,
0.1662771255,
-0.3322186172,
0.4782288969,
0.2472210079,
-0.2573396862,
0.6598184705,
-0.900457561,
0.0450022481,
-0.3537881374,
0.567017138,
-0.9492783546,
-0.0413438231,
0.2661415339,
-0.3463214934,
0.5661633611,
-0.109373562,
0.0571690649,
-0.5748029351,
-0.649589777,
0.8456559181,
0.6655519605,
-0.6417561173,
0.6298312545,
0.365916878,
0.1685441583,
-0.685772121,
-0.9150776863,
-0.4598124325,
-0.3188646138,
-0.5643975139,
0.8348550797,
0.0833868384,
-0.1290718466,
-0.1402175277,
-0.1348971575,
0.035615772,
-0.2003046125,
0.2964713871,
0.234061718,
-0.3939197958,
0.0890890956,
0.2155504972,
-0.4432431757,
0.152453348,
-0.0751610473,
0.5421657562,
-0.203677699,
-0.5156567693,
-0.2144417018,
0.4360691011,
0.3588827848,
-0.0013546683,
0.4247306287,
0.5482053161,
-0.1459567249,
-0.3170522451,
-0.6195540428,
-0.1580272764,
-0.5788950324,
0.4018117487,
-0.372325182,
-0.6927534938,
0.537565887,
-0.1080998182,
-0.149526462,
0.4007476866,
0.2560091317,
-0.1441123933,
0.8053584099,
0.993915081,
0.2005706877,
0.6911374927,
-0.4894489944,
0.1575082392,
-1.1380904913,
-0.4070791006,
0.0543975383,
-0.660199821,
-0.2863134146,
-0.4644191265,
0.3191899955,
-0.1033703461,
-0.1920386106,
0.4163914621,
-0.5380815864,
1.0038319826,
0.5599403381,
0.174349308,
-0.055551663,
0.1587582678,
-0.1168886796,
-0.1601088345,
-0.4102373123,
-0.1099731997,
0.9026966095,
0.6700260043,
0.8605866432,
0.0954039767,
0.3772563934,
0.106074743,
0.19688344,
-0.7954975963,
0.2244627476,
-0.1403705925,
-0.5294303298,
-0.3214278221,
-0.0234838724,
-0.790763557,
0.1988028288,
0.1745160371,
-0.5352006555,
0.6104183793,
0.2403351218,
-0.5633382797,
0.1487321705,
-0.6368065476,
0.3470444679,
-0.0945478305,
-0.19082582,
0.0227016676,
-0.7955327034,
0.1376932263,
-0.0152558116,
-0.0648642257,
0.1546945125,
0.1402792484,
0.7236425877,
-0.1623741239,
0.8006877899,
-0.1444845945,
-0.069979839,
0.384681493,
0.1306012571,
0.492341131,
0.1829903126,
0.0666419789,
0.2814072967,
-0.1040462032,
-0.5030620694,
-0.7421213984,
0.5950297713,
-0.4803632796,
-0.6196700931,
-0.4610218108,
-0.4106009901,
-0.3568333089,
-0.0752924308,
0.5380019546,
0.3276048899,
-0.2027674168,
0.25500682,
0.714430809,
-0.2926643193,
0.665075779,
0.690841198,
-0.0042600646,
-0.1687168628,
0.6475511193,
-0.1783928871,
0.1912753582,
0.7228500247,
0.210105136,
-0.3621474802,
-0.2493344545,
-0.0640475377,
0.2600424588,
-0.6840937138,
-0.2392774075,
-0.3834988773,
-0.4568190575,
-0.1064343676,
-0.4850768745,
-0.5143482089,
-0.7057144046,
0.0345494412,
-0.5770602226,
0.0062115085,
0.6953631043,
-0.2212205678,
0.6631917357,
-0.821449101,
0.0157761574,
0.2069910765,
0.2912479341,
-0.0261727814,
-0.6344831586,
-0.344956845,
-0.105438441,
-0.555077076,
-0.7941451073,
0.3528894186,
0.2585985363,
0.6824859977,
0.3948901594,
-0.3684102297,
0.5849059224,
-0.8221123815,
0.8634073734,
0.5670940876,
-0.8838350177,
0.4124602377,
0.0819820389,
0.4924015999,
0.1215974689,
0.5408183336,
-0.3268593848,
-0.2286812067,
-0.6157705784,
-1.0852208138,
0.6016756892,
-0.0437409095,
0.3301308751,
-0.170612216,
0.2993051708,
0.4289777577,
-0.0860097408,
-0.6051616073,
-0.4154087007,
-0.4046225548,
-0.2482406646,
0.0138112046,
-0.5531459451,
-0.4385712147,
-0.3062252104,
0.3168574274,
-0.1187905446,
0.9543538094,
0.2251499444,
-0.2194629461,
-0.1092600301,
0.0941432491,
0.5645094514,
0.6164160371,
-0.1745079011,
0.2263986915,
0.2634190023,
-0.5462921262,
0.2858524323,
0.184284687,
0.0929868892,
0.1740706414,
0.5734964013,
0.6167917848,
0.1529177874,
-0.3511606455,
0.7017777562,
-0.0489016175,
-0.1079792157,
-0.5404615998,
-0.0962943807,
-0.0526327193,
0.6644747257,
0.3804858923,
-0.0368036516,
0.2802084982,
-0.1831746548,
0.5647165775,
0.245947361,
-0.6152396798,
-0.683714807,
0.6069924235,
0.2069527358,
-0.0469608493,
0.5257403255,
0.0711382106,
-0.4281537235,
0.5722481608,
0.7230195999,
0.8035736084,
-0.6464095116,
0.5149776936,
0.2443963736,
0.125714764,
0.1198965088,
0.0393490084,
-0.0895436704,
-0.5991201401,
-0.2243281156,
-0.5941211581,
0.0617663823,
0.1045736745,
-0.7896757126,
0.0765914321,
-0.5800129175,
-0.1906725317,
0.0273718983,
-0.3762905598,
-0.7723464966,
0.1846997589,
0.1543765515,
0.7758908868,
-0.6982264519,
0.9163181782,
0.58595258,
-0.3620255291,
-0.5296126008,
-0.0777092278,
-0.1545410305,
-1.1045255661,
0.8223592639,
0.3253145516,
-0.3513372242,
-0.2465389222,
-0.5238029361,
-0.9795530438,
1.4590841532,
0.3277536333,
-0.8027806878,
-0.2789857388,
0.3070422113,
0.4930081069,
-0.3041630089,
0.5912981629,
0.6311604977,
0.0438994206,
0.1061508954,
-0.4819227159,
0.2312628776,
-0.1907877177,
0.1458731443,
0.2985289395,
-0.8759326935,
0.7484042645,
-0.1203850731,
-0.2581254542,
-0.1708031148,
0.5657225847,
-0.2129131109,
0.3338543475,
0.4020568132,
0.7123736739,
0.4932719767,
0.068212606,
0.9884899259,
-0.3281020224,
0.5068833232,
1.1241654158,
-0.123325713,
0.6253992915,
0.668497026,
-0.3881194293,
0.771247685,
0.203264609,
-0.168671146,
0.9026036263,
0.1399129778,
-0.2780832946,
0.0191730708,
0.2982690632,
-0.6678023338,
0.4040813446,
0.5213542581,
-0.9368991256,
-0.2118422985,
0.0983850285,
-0.210268423,
-0.0918815434,
0.0379945152,
0.3060007095,
0.3209499419,
-0.3270123303,
0.4082683325,
0.0673269033,
0.4993453026,
-0.6630791426,
-0.2637648582,
-0.329700321,
0.2918703258,
-0.1067536771,
-0.8356893659,
0.6428561807,
-0.5430603623,
-0.3263852,
-0.0552055053,
0.5081797242,
-0.2259104252,
-0.3043241203,
0.5187180638,
0.1746387035,
-0.2976181209,
0.0450180434,
-0.6814962029,
-0.0105293132,
-0.1821262836,
-0.6717713475,
0.1156805828,
0.2817568779,
0.2023498565,
0.6018540263,
0.4235341251,
-0.3004300892,
0.2582687438,
-0.0798018128,
1.0177526474,
-0.9143540859,
-0.4666552246,
-0.8263111115,
0.4408836365,
-0.0696114227,
-0.1213149056,
0.4134181738,
0.3525824547,
1.1058757305,
-0.2799369991,
0.629799068,
-0.0588370077,
0.2957430482,
-0.5572598577,
0.5308228135,
-0.3348208368,
0.3287680149,
-0.0018088234,
-1.2273677588,
-0.3880620897,
0.8155991435,
-0.2970858514,
-0.0250723306,
1.0158610344,
0.7386276722,
-0.3260313272,
0.1693220884,
0.4589431286,
0.1911253482,
0.4818433225,
0.9023546576,
0.89192909,
-0.4867400229,
0.5348409414,
-0.4514111578,
-0.4765991271,
-0.1600362062,
-0.6666114926,
-0.8850519061,
-0.5937299132,
-0.012628275,
-0.2269117832,
0.0008198445,
0.673229754,
0.7710292339,
-0.7727295756,
0.0125473412,
0.0270039346,
-0.1212767586,
-0.2707875073,
-0.2791887224,
0.4032407701,
0.0077925525,
-0.5811497569,
0.4186727107,
0.1789411902,
0.1791131943,
-0.1953334957,
0.1344835907,
0.056085974,
0.0952454582,
0.8089153171,
0.5265095234,
-0.5825550556,
-0.5412731767,
-0.0215060432,
0.0541276,
0.2328001857,
0.9075359702,
-0.8667266965,
0.346218735,
0.4443344176,
0.4703496695,
0.5304543376,
-0.021381706,
0.7818068862,
-0.8384205699,
0.2404607981,
0.2039418668,
0.3602941036,
0.1719052345,
-0.4314590394,
0.5317040682,
0.1527303904,
-0.4745233953,
-0.5202378631,
0.6449151635,
-1.0134050846,
-0.2679418325,
0.9881956577,
-0.3693836629,
-0.4543423951,
0.1678925008,
-0.0705173835,
0.175875172,
-0.2652408779,
0.7979605198,
0.5934371352,
-0.3776086867,
-0.2041603327,
-0.1887890249,
0.4304868281,
0.3070676625,
-0.2627054751,
-0.3805132806,
0.2039598823,
0.3659569025,
0.5781276226,
0.4472932816,
-0.3270545006,
0.2985346615,
0.2534267902,
-0.3629299104,
-0.2025403231,
-0.5256182551,
-0.4750675857,
0.2328756601,
-0.079564549,
-0.3618947566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10346v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10346v1 | Does It Affect You? Social and Learning Implications of Using Cognitive-Affective State Recognition for Proactive Human-Robot Tutoring | 2022-12-20T15:31:58 | 2022-12-20T15:31:58 | Matthias Kraus, Diana Betancourt, Wolfgang Minker | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL | Using robots in educational contexts has already shown to be beneficial for a
student's learning and social behaviour. For levitating them to the next level
of providing more effective and human-like tutoring, the ability to adapt to
the user and to express proactivity is fundamental. By acting proactively,
intelligent robotic tutors anticipate possible situations where problems for
the student may arise and act in advance for preventing negative outcomes.
Still, the decisions of when and how to behave proactively are open questions.
Therefore, this paper deals with the investigation of how the student's
cognitive-affective states can be used by a robotic tutor for triggering
proactive tutoring dialogue. In doing so, it is aimed to improve the learning
experience. For this reason, a concept learning task scenario was observed
where a robotic assistant proactively helped when negative user states were
detected. In a learning task, the user's states of frustration and confusion
were deemed to have negative effects on the outcome of the task and were used
to trigger proactive behaviour. In an empirical user study with 40
undergraduate and doctoral students, we studied whether the initiation of
proactive behaviour after the detection of signs of confusion and frustration
improves the student's concentration and trust in the agent. Additionally, we
investigated which level of proactive dialogue is useful for promoting the
student's concentration and trust. The results show that high proactive
behaviour harms trust, especially when triggered during negative
cognitive-affective states but contributes to keeping the student focused on
the task when triggered in these states. Based on our study results, we further
discuss future steps for improving the proactive assistance of robotic tutoring
systems. | [
-0.2941495478,
-0.999882102,
0.5670358539,
-0.2744308412,
-0.1316283196,
0.1519475877,
-0.0020169406,
-0.4770767987,
0.4800578356,
0.1622927934,
-0.7589464784,
-0.0714051276,
-0.5296961069,
0.1572056264,
-0.34053123,
0.936057508,
0.1949093789,
0.2954365611,
-0.2337714434,
0.3065312505,
-0.8948369026,
-0.4548709095,
-0.9022031426,
-0.326251328,
0.4844331145,
0.5960299969,
0.7362345457,
-0.1985135376,
0.4046782255,
0.4819251001,
-0.1494389027,
-0.1633643061,
-0.1626351625,
0.2477429509,
-0.3533032537,
-0.8569318652,
-0.3483136892,
0.2523428798,
0.1661435813,
0.3093129694,
0.0623987317,
-0.0066131582,
0.1744329482,
0.6308943033,
-0.6416401863,
0.1574884504,
-0.1456238031,
0.2986729741,
-0.0625936985,
0.0079431171,
-0.1306474358,
-0.2647291422,
0.5072715878,
-0.7320792675,
0.0929499269,
-0.3214779198,
0.70195508,
0.5850815773,
-0.5601457357,
-0.2554663718,
-0.718617022,
0.4871285856,
-0.4486989081,
0.1596409082,
0.5252076983,
0.3926491737,
-0.3745506704,
-0.2836049497,
-1.043066144,
-0.1387116015,
-0.1998267621,
0.7007760406,
-0.1359729022,
0.3575512767,
0.1627702713,
0.1439793259,
-0.2106848061,
-0.2085327655,
-0.3945099115,
-0.4913037419,
0.3756161928,
0.0557215959,
0.486356765,
-0.4239859283,
-0.1095100567,
-0.2506233752,
-0.2250521779,
0.651842773,
0.8822822571,
0.2737405002,
0.0688702762,
0.7931089997,
0.0860202909,
0.3960978985,
0.0962250903,
0.0187844336,
-0.0353299342,
-0.3388833404,
0.133564055,
0.1510449201,
0.4924502373,
0.531188786,
0.7405243516,
0.1969947666,
0.1592131853,
0.5780518055,
0.6452785134,
-0.382337153,
-0.1947355568,
0.4767528474,
-0.1356996894,
-0.0158593357,
0.265458256,
-0.3973013163,
-0.4037062824,
-0.5927084684,
0.6805704832,
-0.6242952347,
-0.5763381124,
0.3356953263,
-0.1631082892,
-0.2071551085,
0.4701265395,
-0.632619679,
0.4721307755,
0.5926926732,
0.5828658342,
0.0124785239,
-0.0669391528,
-0.212860316,
-0.1293333471,
-0.1899306327,
0.5446292758,
-0.5373694301,
-0.3644451797,
0.100431554,
0.3827554584,
-0.4264517128,
-0.7933240533,
0.4488893151,
-0.3106534481,
0.3849061131,
-0.1383358091,
-0.3740815818,
-0.275497973,
0.1115954891,
-0.3764687479,
0.7494387031,
0.1771178395,
-0.3931833208,
0.020667702,
-0.7318217158,
-0.619993031,
0.0257576723,
-0.0227521099,
-0.3216271102,
-0.3686296642,
-0.4575506449,
0.6321832538,
0.3046143651,
0.1197180301,
-0.0132399546,
-0.3079469502,
0.5931770802,
0.1267532259,
0.7567521334,
-0.1221045628,
-0.4603851736,
0.2800538838,
-0.3399555981,
-0.2464021295,
0.0855168104,
0.2045287192,
-0.5776833892,
0.047826089,
-0.3492000997,
0.3405936658,
0.3639838099,
-0.7345422506,
-0.0600780621,
-0.2953332365,
0.300850153,
0.9386156201,
0.2953957319,
0.2767561078,
-0.2092561722,
0.8038489223,
0.3434028924,
0.189593032,
-0.1433797777,
-0.6457595229,
-0.4082392752,
-0.2272996306,
-0.0587803349,
0.769313395,
-0.5697324872,
0.3945205808,
0.758713603,
-0.3086378872,
-0.5841819644,
-0.1372074783,
0.6563798785,
0.7986209989,
0.3210604787,
-0.3064953983,
-0.4360590577,
-0.633738935,
-0.2184635848,
-0.3683041036,
-0.079493165,
0.4999378026,
0.5793489814,
-0.1067910716,
0.9516655207,
-0.565372169,
-0.8119553328,
0.023197528,
-0.117766358,
-0.0048683607,
0.5318795443,
0.3493504524,
-0.8636314273,
-0.3428626657,
-0.1587522328,
-0.6425086856,
0.2763339281,
-0.5114428997,
-0.3582416475,
0.1985078007,
0.2296271473,
-0.9289741516,
0.6511416435,
0.2160240561,
-0.6848199964,
0.7061665058,
-0.3698709905,
0.1863516271,
-0.8752797246,
-0.3978809714,
0.2706203163,
0.1342874318,
-0.4973591566,
-0.367854923,
-0.1637491286,
-0.1307656765,
-0.4941290021,
0.3373184204,
0.1374585032,
-0.2069751173,
-0.0192233883,
0.544698894,
-0.3032213449,
0.3720623851,
0.2287809849,
0.8346732855,
0.654204309,
-0.6219651699,
0.1351316273,
0.3090759516,
-0.1743067801,
0.8165906668,
-0.7450864315,
0.0169184729,
0.0774268731,
0.2867909074,
-1.1204886436,
-0.1317951679,
0.7531715035,
-0.6161176562,
0.0005543662,
0.5095777512,
-0.3129205406,
-0.3107236326,
-0.215600729,
0.0498400815,
0.1869355887,
-0.326910466,
0.8545835614,
0.3484145105,
-0.054439567,
-0.3145909905,
-0.0022998624,
-0.0776996166,
-0.2395853549,
-0.5029674768,
0.5049544573,
-0.0321437493,
-0.2909189165,
0.0787892193,
-0.361314863,
0.1301927567,
0.463897109,
0.7365208864,
0.4209963381,
0.4227645099,
-0.0036138797,
0.2621597648,
-0.3229580522,
0.4445092976,
0.2216166556,
0.5449383855,
-0.3009470403,
-0.3378841579,
-1.2467730045,
-0.1095329374,
0.3468820453,
-0.1930865049,
0.5713906884,
0.4301566184,
-0.3334433436,
0.1152783781,
0.1297321767,
-0.7081612945,
-0.5482540131,
0.3265320063,
-0.3099744618,
-0.8503543139,
0.5509733558,
-0.414121449,
-0.1799480468,
-0.0171245933,
0.499959141,
-0.7955278754,
0.9926157594,
0.4834147096,
0.1183154285,
1.0685601234,
-0.2634125054,
0.3675944805,
-0.9078439474,
-0.5447192788,
-0.4315600097,
-0.5791806579,
-0.4881237149,
-0.1041251421,
0.2813507318,
0.0528621189,
-0.3632949293,
0.5503140092,
-0.5946245193,
0.293369025,
0.5259366035,
0.6102541685,
-0.1150727421,
-0.3650470972,
0.1217371002,
-0.1628422141,
-0.1564742774,
-0.5007429123,
0.8310654163,
-0.0363781229,
0.353729248,
0.3074043095,
0.7548143268,
0.5170914531,
-0.0546848178,
-1.0296407938,
0.9431840777,
0.2386231124,
-0.7437600493,
-0.5700932741,
-0.0503336266,
-1.3087662458,
-0.0935838968,
-0.2982724309,
-0.9857491851,
0.0540336557,
0.1252903789,
-0.4457357824,
-0.1105068102,
-0.9403389096,
0.8512091041,
-0.2592313886,
-0.4543287754,
-0.7671655416,
-0.8618211746,
0.0517356545,
0.0029409146,
-0.0037721435,
0.0046480554,
0.2205754519,
0.9554299712,
-0.130083099,
1.2995103598,
-0.6250686049,
0.0124447206,
0.6083469391,
0.2589327693,
0.1454841197,
-0.034214709,
0.1831145585,
-0.0937175229,
0.1529076844,
-0.2158540338,
-0.7935109735,
0.0931613296,
-1.1375129223,
-1.0079605579,
-0.504812181,
-0.5591885448,
-0.0655784383,
0.2026964426,
-0.4763627052,
0.19114393,
-0.0000097893,
-0.1131456196,
0.5630238652,
-0.194071427,
0.1651831865,
0.7747315764,
-0.113710694,
0.1251349896,
1.1602110863,
0.1492553055,
0.2575401068,
0.0906658247,
0.3856759071,
-0.1935892105,
0.0893943906,
0.0023705706,
0.2433414608,
-0.5054987669,
-0.0142901391,
-0.4076523483,
0.1024064049,
-0.3604293466,
-0.3950263262,
-0.1932779551,
-0.559042573,
-0.5304477215,
-0.2576368749,
0.3540024757,
0.705106318,
-0.1094140112,
0.4563364685,
-0.2945134342,
0.3919984698,
0.418281734,
-0.0714583471,
-0.1338739842,
-0.383387804,
-0.2761154771,
-0.1036261767,
-0.5191887021,
-0.8024703264,
0.1160013378,
0.2621904016,
0.5220509768,
0.6973316669,
0.4953770041,
0.4391665757,
-0.1937252581,
0.9067605734,
0.036437951,
-0.7754295468,
0.6746298075,
-0.2610455751,
0.0629410148,
0.3427284956,
0.6935310364,
-0.5240383744,
-0.6084474325,
-0.6835044622,
-0.6711238027,
0.7090144157,
-0.1540124267,
0.2402449995,
-0.2952243686,
0.7040632367,
-0.1785004437,
-0.0751976147,
-0.3360789418,
-0.3511320949,
-0.2324059457,
-0.1637914926,
-0.0264645871,
-0.032399293,
-0.2466360778,
-0.2340993881,
0.5457472801,
-0.1379790455,
0.4327034354,
0.0688673928,
0.1480175853,
-0.2463625669,
0.0932216123,
0.3560733795,
0.1925784647,
-0.398147583,
-0.120356679,
-0.1231952533,
-0.7597225904,
0.1256965846,
-0.1618014723,
0.0846022815,
-0.2982480526,
0.1081147939,
0.1570841521,
0.2671648562,
-0.8668118715,
0.6124527454,
-0.2399985045,
-0.0688721687,
-0.3563574255,
0.61356318,
0.0720800459,
0.617151618,
0.1665181816,
0.5638661981,
0.159252286,
-0.7396358848,
0.0482769758,
0.4019767344,
-0.3371012807,
-0.7136355639,
0.5439176559,
0.1652846485,
-0.8928254247,
0.6347279549,
0.0403044932,
-1.0302164555,
0.9075944424,
0.8477771282,
0.6318436265,
-0.4013995528,
0.684025228,
0.4291462004,
-0.0216332097,
0.1565042883,
0.5611394644,
-0.4778174758,
-1.098393321,
-0.1665110737,
0.0626237541,
-1.0998996496,
-0.6406257749,
-1.1039977074,
0.0335298851,
-0.4803399146,
-0.5129634142,
-0.060763739,
0.1938506961,
-0.5535286665,
0.377796948,
0.0579603501,
0.4104531705,
-0.9204775095,
0.806414187,
1.0205049515,
-0.2873487771,
-0.6887530684,
-0.0267931074,
0.474776715,
-0.6247925162,
0.9001243114,
0.2509196401,
-0.7125505209,
-0.0156795103,
-0.2671298981,
-0.5733774304,
1.007799983,
0.1850544661,
-0.4676340222,
0.3025625348,
0.1819375008,
0.8419567943,
-0.057753332,
0.2916422784,
0.4958279431,
0.2583401501,
-0.1511410773,
-0.5799449682,
0.0175634194,
-0.2451094091,
-0.4287830591,
-0.0865796953,
-0.8836447001,
0.7272677422,
-0.4761864841,
-0.3162777722,
-0.047442358,
0.5694549084,
0.0549494326,
0.5610234141,
0.6884326935,
0.249181658,
1.1784108877,
-0.0381593667,
0.9505368471,
-0.5603557229,
-0.1909328699,
0.771456182,
-0.33447963,
0.8397198319,
0.5299229026,
-0.3460499942,
0.7904596329,
0.7295630574,
0.4488075674,
0.3593631685,
0.1105910838,
-0.4868753552,
-0.2076625675,
-0.4049263895,
-0.155810982,
0.3565978706,
0.5200903416,
0.2646395266,
0.3497366011,
0.2918524444,
0.0417247042,
0.3436388671,
-0.1964566112,
0.655308485,
-0.0690721944,
-0.74412328,
-0.0482406616,
-0.3845340014,
0.5222346187,
-0.4847215414,
0.0252837483,
-0.0759291947,
0.4733305573,
-0.434571147,
-0.9592642188,
0.1390385926,
-0.2048506439,
-0.0713248253,
-0.311637789,
0.6924253106,
-0.142885685,
0.0613409318,
0.558365941,
0.5042524338,
0.448340416,
0.0092531843,
-0.716943264,
-0.253652215,
-0.1601335108,
-0.2654509842,
0.816393733,
0.3615821004,
-0.1232942492,
0.7350580692,
0.6368364692,
-0.3395624757,
-0.337361455,
0.1977771521,
0.9655117989,
-0.5141898394,
-0.0705996305,
-0.5385282636,
0.7194801569,
0.3001900017,
-0.5795111656,
0.9058732986,
0.1920011789,
1.0851691961,
0.1384954453,
0.3228905201,
-0.2609338462,
0.3595241308,
-0.0957280248,
0.3729828298,
-0.4837531447,
0.0090893693,
-0.5893568993,
-0.5406739116,
-0.1835090369,
1.0212863684,
-0.7522029281,
-0.269551754,
0.5678874254,
0.6547036767,
0.6799715161,
0.2711392045,
0.2706294656,
0.0180205368,
0.4095446467,
0.1997172087,
1.0133408308,
-0.072509259,
0.2990908325,
-0.4064259231,
-0.258708775,
-0.1412370354,
-0.2198928297,
-0.9367243648,
-0.6929814219,
-0.5403357744,
-0.5164269805,
0.2088601738,
1.0182682276,
0.3319605291,
-0.5820763111,
-0.1545322388,
-0.0426652245,
0.3984144032,
-0.532342732,
-0.2888130248,
0.3635278046,
-0.416521132,
-0.8903271556,
0.228928864,
-0.0304625705,
0.0171394683,
-0.1641180366,
-0.2519231141,
-0.241731599,
-0.0841065943,
0.7124578953,
0.4049079716,
-0.364585489,
-0.4777991176,
0.2867729962,
0.048761826,
-0.1338461488,
0.5522713661,
-0.9255367517,
0.657335043,
-0.1575586051,
0.4582343698,
0.3262006044,
0.1088159308,
0.3309285045,
-0.2659307718,
0.1386910528,
0.2794686556,
0.2344110459,
-0.1889380366,
-0.7465725541,
0.482216835,
0.2323510498,
-0.7263934612,
-0.6210481524,
0.1480466872,
-1.0521396399,
-0.2646389008,
0.6612241864,
-0.543605864,
-0.2306648195,
-0.1610259861,
-0.9310472608,
0.4298337102,
-0.5448320508,
1.0439183712,
0.5320689082,
-0.6168553233,
-0.2185299546,
-0.4539184868,
0.3539431095,
0.8282204866,
-0.5764227509,
-0.2572728395,
0.3418416977,
-0.0328515284,
0.360455066,
0.1629795879,
0.1785421371,
0.4520528913,
-0.0933484584,
0.0837454647,
-0.0809003487,
-0.6570737362,
-0.0032222257,
-0.0828573704,
-0.2888576388,
-0.2813840508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10341v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10341v2 | CoCo: Coherence-Enhanced Machine-Generated Text Detection Under Data Limitation With Contrastive Learning | 2022-12-20T15:26:19 | 2023-10-20T13:21:51 | Xiaoming Liu, Zhaohan Zhang, Yichen Wang, Hang Pu, Yu Lan, Chao Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine-Generated Text (MGT) detection, a task that discriminates MGT from
Human-Written Text (HWT), plays a crucial role in preventing misuse of text
generative models, which excel in mimicking human writing style recently.
Latest proposed detectors usually take coarse text sequences as input and
fine-tune pretrained models with standard cross-entropy loss. However, these
methods fail to consider the linguistic structure of texts. Moreover, they lack
the ability to handle the low-resource problem which could often happen in
practice considering the enormous amount of textual data online. In this paper,
we present a coherence-based contrastive learning model named CoCo to detect
the possible MGT under low-resource scenario. To exploit the linguistic
feature, we encode coherence information in form of graph into text
representation. To tackle the challenges of low data resource, we employ a
contrastive learning framework and propose an improved contrastive loss for
preventing performance degradation brought by simple samples. The experiment
results on two public datasets and two self-constructed datasets prove our
approach outperforms the state-of-art methods significantly. Also, we
surprisingly find that MGTs originated from up-to-date language models could be
easier to detect than these from previous models, in our experiments. And we
propose some preliminary explanations for this counter-intuitive phenomena. All
the codes and datasets are open-sourced. | [
-0.3697643876,
-0.9137411714,
0.3481608629,
-0.0322832689,
-0.571013093,
0.2128505707,
-0.1768934876,
-0.675598681,
0.263091892,
0.5071228147,
-0.6019153595,
-0.6265266538,
-0.6506737471,
0.2530339062,
-0.4528492689,
0.980142653,
-0.207320407,
-0.3474800587,
-0.304052949,
-0.1656268239,
-0.4133383334,
-0.5384806395,
-0.6484088302,
-0.3440591991,
0.2911267877,
0.5130496025,
0.5729667544,
0.4572773576,
0.5828106999,
0.2389920503,
-0.0275823027,
0.2983636856,
-0.7055992484,
0.0527715795,
0.050084088,
-0.385535568,
-0.1213542223,
-0.1392410398,
0.3140107989,
0.4777945876,
0.0848896205,
-0.1592466086,
0.6656620502,
0.547306478,
-0.8271961808,
0.3914959431,
-0.863242209,
0.2367624193,
-0.1283374876,
-0.2511493862,
-0.5134532452,
0.0424975753,
0.0112206554,
-0.5989071131,
0.7164727449,
0.2407738864,
0.9997323155,
0.111056231,
-0.1272548586,
-0.6591738462,
-0.3806934357,
0.800932467,
-0.3302073479,
0.2833172381,
0.5385473371,
0.2346900105,
-0.004240124,
-0.6445423961,
-0.7136926055,
-0.3247895241,
-0.2479733676,
0.4060990214,
-0.3003764749,
-0.0771320686,
-0.0883676857,
0.5775159001,
-0.73092556,
0.0678119138,
0.0987249091,
-0.4900175333,
0.2105222344,
0.1881168336,
0.3256722093,
-0.1591335386,
-0.2362962365,
-0.1232797429,
-0.5118383169,
-0.270470947,
0.3176528215,
0.283508718,
-0.5365250707,
0.3817790747,
-0.1866471469,
0.5413782597,
-0.0025464571,
0.1669477671,
-0.0064573991,
-0.3287633061,
-0.1994125098,
0.3148544133,
1.0955097675,
-0.0792004988,
0.1033672765,
-0.0705082566,
0.0044876901,
0.3026912212,
-0.2650220692,
-0.9896209836,
-0.7063641548,
-0.1822448671,
-0.2696143687,
-0.4395523667,
-0.0348667428,
-0.6324198246,
-0.3789411485,
-0.0184476711,
0.117451556,
-0.4557905793,
-0.1139750332,
-0.0080193337,
0.0429521017,
-0.2803518772,
0.2672511637,
-0.9836853147,
0.2824563682,
0.3591516912,
0.9761077762,
-0.3551254869,
-0.0438221283,
-0.5071666837,
0.0504971556,
-0.2932493985,
0.7883347273,
-0.4207442701,
-0.4344065785,
-0.3379134238,
-0.1159173548,
-0.0581063554,
-0.6131128669,
0.5745635033,
-0.4221283793,
0.3479029238,
-0.2568140924,
-0.2852764726,
0.0599106625,
0.5203060508,
-0.7912348509,
0.9256973267,
0.1238715351,
-1.3293764591,
0.2313903421,
-0.4867798388,
-0.5251024365,
0.0276624355,
-0.2838222384,
-1.0550224781,
-0.0221746918,
0.4267255366,
0.3340472281,
-0.362246722,
0.1995007247,
-0.4317187667,
-0.5122532248,
0.2943466902,
-0.9797540307,
0.7851318717,
0.4138560295,
-0.2801857591,
-0.2289926112,
-0.8251709342,
-0.1349128783,
0.3666621447,
-0.3791890144,
-0.3392782509,
0.0516500734,
0.1183907092,
0.144708395,
0.1027763337,
-0.4745227993,
-0.3118921518,
-0.3058330417,
0.2982945144,
0.4212337434,
0.0197268594,
0.0905786082,
-0.1677173525,
0.4544381499,
0.3268679976,
-0.0577831008,
-0.3922216594,
-0.5306066871,
-0.927216351,
-0.4872563183,
0.1485614926,
0.5547655821,
-1.0818277597,
0.5441757441,
-0.1668352932,
-0.0850265697,
-0.5370636582,
0.2336961776,
0.3984763324,
0.7194972038,
0.6000819802,
-0.3978196681,
-0.5775977969,
-0.5965436101,
-0.2143853009,
0.0590969957,
0.0000084723,
0.4804573059,
0.5432987809,
-0.3483017385,
0.9729528427,
-0.7909819484,
-0.1424088329,
-0.3077509105,
0.2999119163,
-0.0328923203,
0.6139906645,
0.241213873,
-0.9327412248,
-0.644949615,
0.1615479738,
-0.9961870909,
-0.27244699,
0.073195152,
-0.1123270169,
0.0966641754,
0.5039582849,
-0.0884629861,
0.4129244089,
0.8922262192,
-0.1323539317,
0.3721252978,
-0.2194163948,
0.1240601167,
-1.2467125654,
0.0714221597,
-0.1445514411,
-0.3600585163,
-0.2394712418,
-0.0636226907,
0.0401324444,
-0.4921672642,
-0.2873072028,
0.2827395797,
-0.5129622221,
0.1188789159,
-0.5114374757,
0.2850720882,
0.4121843576,
0.4987013042,
0.0738129094,
0.7061702013,
0.1897565126,
-0.5827609301,
0.2308813184,
0.0321454965,
-0.2279549688,
0.6869612336,
-0.4331341684,
0.3224746883,
-0.0366601571,
0.2829054892,
-0.9486096501,
-0.1389489323,
0.5655787587,
-0.438690275,
0.2587687671,
-0.0592672937,
-0.4439952672,
-0.2183098495,
-0.1483064145,
0.4669773281,
0.2804464698,
-0.7496035695,
0.1044535041,
0.1810221076,
-0.0944239944,
-0.4864018857,
-1.0401598215,
0.2527734935,
0.0318138674,
-0.5513750315,
0.3480184376,
-0.1645718813,
0.2145672888,
0.1576735973,
-0.0723481476,
-0.2911293209,
0.2980045378,
-0.0037874789,
0.2062306106,
-0.2757754326,
0.0507710241,
0.3024254441,
-0.2196668983,
-0.2008218765,
-0.402559191,
0.8764422536,
0.0727166533,
-0.4700974822,
-0.6942073107,
0.2962123454,
0.2195235938,
-0.2644103467,
0.7721763253,
0.7999069691,
-0.317633599,
-0.1373136789,
-0.0610975176,
-0.0205211248,
-0.494409889,
0.346647054,
-0.4084990919,
-0.8601713777,
0.4568627775,
0.0608498305,
-0.5869311094,
0.5795987248,
0.42707932,
-0.0417356901,
0.7959128618,
0.6053266525,
-0.09575703,
0.7003391981,
-0.4907894731,
0.1873358637,
-0.6431062222,
-0.1769982427,
-0.4678706527,
0.0384957977,
-0.8417515159,
-0.4306668043,
0.1479412168,
0.1864206046,
-0.016292328,
0.4780256748,
-0.6397515535,
0.5762616396,
0.2397297621,
0.5675480962,
0.5354130268,
0.0901869982,
-0.4153755903,
0.0928979367,
-0.7949656844,
-0.3340720534,
0.6959065199,
-0.0356032923,
0.7900566459,
-0.1602934152,
0.8375584483,
0.3431081474,
0.3916816413,
-0.5613710284,
0.411462307,
-0.3239681423,
-0.2738868892,
0.0607859902,
-0.7197973132,
-0.9712774754,
0.2458376288,
-0.4830161929,
-0.418686986,
0.2043845206,
0.4617886543,
0.2402935475,
0.2687459588,
-0.7136340737,
0.9604248405,
-0.0394480824,
-0.6038782001,
-0.1091023013,
-0.3431878686,
0.2619252801,
-0.0302782245,
-0.0436069183,
-0.0704113171,
0.1393535286,
0.4782549441,
-0.4955904186,
0.9135144353,
0.094228819,
-0.1108167097,
0.698692143,
0.1458171308,
0.7911203504,
-0.111639075,
-0.0338441543,
0.2040779293,
-0.5653701425,
-0.6354504824,
-0.3748506606,
0.7616662979,
-0.4700330496,
-0.1516644359,
-0.2607372105,
-0.459551096,
0.1472335756,
0.3463357687,
0.8816839457,
0.3063142598,
-0.4660590589,
0.1132968292,
0.4446904063,
-0.3052472174,
0.4541034698,
0.2657155395,
0.0596876405,
-0.5500636697,
1.2447054386,
-0.0417959094,
0.3088081181,
0.5623273849,
0.3795607686,
-0.1855791956,
-0.7010143995,
-0.3868096769,
-0.0637190714,
-0.7503644824,
-0.1616502106,
-0.6774371862,
-0.0710627362,
-0.2251332551,
-0.3744182587,
-0.1467422843,
-0.0484678932,
-0.5824053884,
0.1902077049,
-0.0086818151,
0.3764194548,
0.3352848291,
0.4207743108,
-0.6046555638,
0.406357497,
0.0975227877,
0.331836164,
-0.0274759065,
-0.1609743387,
-0.5056060553,
0.0733749643,
-0.6017000675,
-0.648842454,
0.5499672294,
0.1231368408,
0.1905536056,
0.5078698397,
0.329786092,
0.5298888087,
-0.1326748282,
0.4603665769,
0.4330771863,
-1.0927182436,
0.4853740036,
-0.2419816554,
0.4703022838,
0.6396880746,
0.1811947525,
-0.4392717779,
-0.575345993,
-0.4700222909,
-0.5932162404,
0.5176324248,
0.5047348142,
-0.0426306166,
-0.1250217706,
0.0761541948,
0.2187395394,
0.2348545939,
-0.848182857,
0.2694069445,
-0.3955635726,
-0.7193095684,
-0.2461016178,
0.0102556841,
0.2711423337,
0.1502701938,
0.3623711765,
-0.3434391916,
0.2866547108,
0.3042001426,
-0.5164288878,
0.0161962137,
0.326222986,
0.3621230423,
0.0374010839,
-0.0276652183,
0.4283698499,
0.2880217135,
-0.7550651431,
0.0874811411,
0.1603999436,
-0.2561575472,
-0.0384155475,
0.5224629045,
0.7556087375,
0.2150337547,
-0.4328012764,
0.3935304284,
0.0016318094,
0.1501709074,
0.0972983092,
0.1244702488,
-0.0835202634,
-0.1561210901,
-0.0883622989,
0.2943901122,
0.1971342862,
-0.5924555659,
0.0240136292,
0.4047335088,
-0.5867090225,
-0.257930696,
0.6674606204,
0.2916357219,
-0.1962185949,
0.5378859043,
-0.4070904255,
-0.6057478786,
0.6432064176,
0.7997898459,
0.9063081741,
0.0128780324,
0.0717488378,
0.1193821281,
0.2297214121,
0.0392437056,
-0.0127314003,
-0.4423436821,
-0.855496347,
-0.0668855086,
-0.5112267733,
-0.5262327194,
0.1084799394,
-0.4511678517,
0.372230649,
-0.3832189143,
0.0582274646,
-0.2652794719,
0.0872256458,
-0.5825806856,
0.2918984294,
0.0841130242,
0.4630286992,
-0.9177870154,
0.8100588918,
0.1387926787,
-0.3500088453,
-0.2278221995,
0.4123880565,
-0.0579813309,
-0.7912815809,
0.3192128837,
0.5089796782,
-0.5431764126,
-0.016116973,
-0.4719313681,
-0.3403863013,
1.1593477726,
0.79533571,
-0.5793024302,
0.1827272326,
0.2779936492,
0.5763566494,
-0.3430960476,
-0.0392022617,
0.1833252311,
0.133509174,
0.2133904696,
-0.4231974185,
0.159501031,
-0.0897359625,
-0.1511268616,
0.1692358851,
-0.4945553541,
0.936086297,
-0.212888822,
-0.4755896926,
0.0977725163,
0.622092545,
0.1633821726,
0.8543724418,
0.2895522416,
0.5784423947,
0.9155128598,
-0.0651857927,
1.1238259077,
-0.2589595318,
0.7407676578,
0.9577951431,
-0.1434374601,
0.7306354046,
0.0817822218,
0.1028680652,
0.575120151,
0.6355957389,
0.0182228722,
0.5654653907,
0.2263027132,
-0.6797780991,
-0.1659763008,
-0.213243857,
-0.2813269198,
0.4577480257,
0.230308041,
-0.5212978721,
-0.134349063,
0.0311395638,
0.1277429909,
0.2559047639,
-0.3210017085,
0.581840694,
0.1295686811,
-0.4358214438,
0.7248350382,
-0.1208865345,
0.8489217758,
-0.3915921152,
-0.0124112293,
-0.0893533155,
0.4642820954,
-0.2511979043,
-0.5181107521,
0.2511567473,
0.1319831163,
-0.0797719732,
0.1709899604,
1.0153822899,
-0.6154719591,
-0.4987885952,
0.4338770509,
0.301625967,
-0.0227047578,
-0.0438874997,
-0.7323750257,
0.143012628,
-0.2662627995,
0.1950693876,
0.2255823612,
0.45839867,
0.0005116902,
0.4334603846,
0.5685581565,
-0.1843843013,
-0.2755936384,
-0.1341674775,
0.8306599259,
-0.5276435614,
-0.9417110085,
-1.0829560757,
0.08628764,
-0.2090325952,
0.0862322003,
0.6468253136,
0.7665020823,
0.8489837646,
-0.0071870838,
0.8641960025,
0.2690528929,
0.0331349,
-0.7639352083,
0.9068561196,
-0.3179841042,
0.2983243763,
-0.4404815733,
-0.6515975595,
-0.3764399588,
0.3993459344,
-0.1928100884,
-0.0006979001,
0.8791751266,
0.7204099894,
-0.4212107658,
0.0124534108,
0.5737016201,
0.0210383516,
0.373372972,
0.6876494884,
0.577221334,
-0.5228241086,
0.8969131708,
-0.0891837105,
-0.0435351208,
-0.5174089074,
-0.9686577916,
-1.0207103491,
-0.4491949677,
-0.2992744744,
-0.4655913413,
0.1514112949,
0.7155355215,
0.6533614993,
-0.9699983597,
0.081739746,
-0.7287330627,
0.2491681576,
-0.0826242194,
-0.233956635,
0.6237696409,
-0.2368145436,
-0.5676262379,
0.2566370964,
0.2724699974,
0.4276389182,
0.0399076082,
-0.2636062801,
-0.0014999517,
0.1611585319,
0.6282752156,
0.3066072166,
-0.2221420258,
-0.2740105391,
-0.1949914694,
-0.3207098544,
0.3601226211,
0.8813822865,
-0.7343313694,
0.6692426205,
0.6318442225,
0.5498113632,
0.7089982033,
-0.2356707007,
0.1519668102,
-0.8446577191,
0.2693314254,
0.0637929514,
0.4269964397,
0.6669074297,
-0.4467144907,
0.2081265748,
0.7828923464,
-0.193513155,
-0.5791189075,
0.4098733068,
-0.993121624,
-0.2200036198,
0.6286256909,
-0.3790846765,
-0.1651171893,
-0.3735767007,
-0.4090242982,
0.591683507,
-0.2783366442,
0.8715728521,
0.4994824827,
-0.1249300912,
-0.1531436294,
-0.0996988043,
0.3303727508,
0.1213272288,
-1.0372805595,
0.0020327163,
0.2922241092,
0.1895012707,
0.1845729947,
0.719942987,
0.0209981166,
0.1798703074,
0.4039912522,
-0.1685387194,
-0.2774800658,
-0.2878261209,
-0.3747634888,
0.4375359118,
-0.0709907264,
-0.3944284022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10325v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10325v5 | SeqDiffuSeq: Text Diffusion with Encoder-Decoder Transformers | 2022-12-20T15:16:24 | 2023-05-22T17:31:46 | Hongyi Yuan, Zheng Yuan, Chuanqi Tan, Fei Huang, Songfang Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Diffusion model, a new generative modelling paradigm, has achieved great
success in image, audio, and video generation. However, considering the
discrete categorical nature of text, it is not trivial to extend continuous
diffusion models to natural language, and text diffusion models are less
studied. Sequence-to-sequence text generation is one of the essential natural
language processing topics. In this work, we apply diffusion models to approach
sequence-to-sequence text generation, and explore whether the superiority
generation performance of diffusion model can transfer to natural language
domain. We propose SeqDiffuSeq, a text diffusion model for sequence-to-sequence
generation. SeqDiffuSeq uses an encoder-decoder Transformers architecture to
model denoising function. In order to improve generation quality, SeqDiffuSeq
combines the self-conditioning technique and a newly proposed adaptive noise
schedule technique. The adaptive noise schedule has the difficulty of denoising
evenly distributed across time steps, and considers exclusive noise schedules
for tokens at different positional order. Experiment results illustrate the
good performance on sequence-to-sequence generation in terms of text quality
and inference time. | [
-0.3168731928,
-1.0174069405,
0.3623715937,
0.5517007709,
-0.5066646934,
-0.1194853708,
0.1736480147,
-0.1186713204,
-0.2437687814,
0.6385605335,
-0.3888478875,
-0.2708283067,
-0.6840882301,
0.3887408376,
-0.960210979,
0.6489247084,
0.1507821381,
-0.1658997983,
-0.1270258725,
0.0524251685,
-0.4027637541,
-0.2305895686,
-0.7513965368,
-0.2605482936,
-0.3654111326,
-0.0657848269,
0.7031167746,
0.3758140504,
0.054346703,
0.2635256648,
-0.1850943118,
0.0401849225,
-0.3293430507,
0.4127068818,
-0.0636041537,
0.1092517003,
-0.2604390085,
-0.540659368,
0.7612897754,
0.40699175,
-0.468601644,
-0.2212835103,
0.1913345754,
0.7565168738,
-0.2425962687,
-0.3424881697,
-0.3021298945,
0.2153948843,
0.0194980651,
-0.1419905871,
-0.5978770256,
-0.5941826105,
-0.0985579565,
-0.3550300598,
0.5592449307,
-0.0986261144,
0.3935768604,
0.5092784166,
-0.6323997974,
-0.3127411008,
-0.8557786345,
0.4163897038,
-1.0417455435,
0.2937190235,
0.1101972759,
-0.0902066305,
-0.0858643577,
-0.6909816265,
-0.757615447,
0.3513606191,
0.1723601669,
0.3710407615,
-0.1762264222,
-0.2886123061,
0.0642348528,
0.3836585879,
-0.6650589108,
-0.0051938104,
-0.3180447519,
0.3150556386,
0.6885067821,
0.0755819455,
0.2752478421,
-0.3926326931,
-0.3047058582,
0.1291217059,
-0.2309699357,
-0.3327283561,
0.3462604284,
-0.0885846987,
-0.2176026851,
0.1125489175,
-0.2252225429,
0.6624104977,
0.3857866526,
-0.0715252459,
0.3127369285,
-0.3603435159,
-0.488132,
0.2344943732,
0.7940458059,
0.1360698491,
-0.0161134303,
-0.1811042726,
-0.1852995157,
-0.0385312736,
0.4628252089,
-0.9419999123,
-0.1664740592,
0.008542127,
-0.5553991199,
-0.3738597035,
-0.4596189559,
-1.0946327448,
-0.2049892396,
-0.1103222221,
0.6261105537,
-0.4612115622,
-0.5141045451,
0.4545697272,
-0.2224023938,
0.219163686,
0.2526705265,
-0.7427523136,
0.3388005793,
0.3836550117,
0.9236566424,
-0.7334716916,
0.231738776,
-0.2972778082,
0.1134420782,
-0.2028533667,
0.8889116645,
-0.3965761364,
-0.7557626963,
0.1018406674,
-0.1602159888,
-0.1420127302,
-0.4919887781,
0.58994174,
-0.8071947694,
0.2913727462,
0.3618742526,
-0.687271595,
-0.0957785547,
-0.2442723364,
-0.6452744007,
1.1394898891,
0.0865439624,
-0.6809101701,
0.2150509506,
-0.6977797151,
-1.0346550941,
0.0169435814,
0.2725144625,
-0.5963766575,
0.0008739569,
0.2357821167,
0.5602626204,
-0.2437203974,
0.5553758144,
0.1492706239,
-0.0508688837,
0.1605422646,
-0.6084242463,
0.5311206579,
0.7098783851,
-0.207589224,
-0.2413547486,
-0.7073768973,
-0.3067905605,
0.0212047398,
-0.3221643269,
-0.2479623705,
0.0707579404,
0.0555100217,
0.2926570475,
-0.2192836553,
-0.1319748014,
0.0009452653,
-0.5304567814,
0.6832079887,
0.4834738374,
0.6904063225,
1.0490313768,
-0.2610187531,
0.6543409228,
0.3795707226,
0.0361668654,
-0.327069521,
-0.6453338265,
-0.621037066,
-0.0934355333,
0.2103872299,
0.3353262246,
-0.7054567337,
0.3402771354,
-0.242965281,
-0.198802352,
-0.2774632871,
-0.013661948,
-0.1540150046,
0.6029388309,
0.4480386376,
-0.5566954017,
-0.37899822,
-0.4871441126,
-0.0382604301,
0.2334350049,
0.0851203576,
-0.0622963458,
0.3029452264,
-0.5197488666,
0.7832811475,
-0.3923098743,
0.117852889,
-0.2318025231,
0.5541080832,
0.2079095244,
0.5118454695,
0.4134113193,
-0.8324968219,
-0.4285368323,
-0.4935601652,
-0.3719856739,
-0.3516840041,
-0.3447279036,
-0.4551667869,
0.4379172623,
0.6165437102,
-0.3661661744,
0.5512877107,
0.6161680222,
-0.5546340942,
0.2198528945,
-0.09740787,
0.1381202638,
-1.340083003,
-0.0914016068,
-0.1145551652,
-0.4745221734,
-0.8149963021,
-0.163817361,
-0.1716018021,
0.0292006955,
-0.2376580834,
0.4463176429,
-0.2012744844,
0.0714306012,
-0.4219181538,
0.0733833164,
0.1868637949,
0.235946089,
0.2109449506,
0.650159359,
0.5658282638,
-1.3762403727,
-0.2848940194,
0.4452295899,
-0.2203261256,
0.6162800789,
-0.4265209734,
-0.0028611633,
-0.3585229814,
0.0697208866,
-1.1181355715,
0.2300337255,
0.2200834155,
-0.2962664068,
0.3081900775,
-0.0464591943,
-0.4188626111,
-0.0878143311,
0.0657343268,
0.5205302238,
0.988409996,
-0.520552516,
0.3485010266,
0.2445223778,
-0.2378062606,
-0.0077628493,
-0.564175427,
-0.0485342555,
-0.3567384481,
-0.6509019136,
0.6948158145,
-0.3217326403,
0.0706612542,
-0.0865043327,
-0.006242421,
-0.3806321025,
0.1561954468,
0.2306300551,
-0.0836455747,
-0.1302191317,
0.2445136756,
0.292219162,
0.1153036281,
0.0580352135,
-0.2773361802,
0.4956019521,
0.7439464927,
-0.0469801314,
-0.0758552402,
0.4771603644,
0.1088760346,
0.038392704,
0.4889472425,
0.7103507519,
-0.0472397618,
-0.4464536309,
-0.3177422285,
-0.1080240682,
-0.4700473845,
0.1004785523,
-0.20911102,
-0.7361376286,
0.0428887457,
-0.3781924248,
0.071821101,
0.6045863032,
0.6093735099,
0.0357540809,
0.8561915755,
0.3894571662,
0.208668083,
0.4868041873,
-0.2525769472,
0.1629674733,
-0.6141802669,
0.2138908654,
-0.5031334758,
-0.1065823808,
-0.1884784847,
-0.7857310772,
-0.0143139008,
0.2712191939,
-0.4525042772,
0.2019235343,
-0.5400750041,
0.0491814129,
0.365514338,
-0.1666015685,
0.6674743891,
0.370808661,
-0.0337221473,
0.0337040089,
-0.6422231793,
-0.3506217897,
0.6038792133,
0.1869640648,
0.8099505901,
0.3689646125,
0.8793557286,
0.8192865252,
0.060774643,
-0.2460112423,
0.3262180686,
-0.1898013949,
-0.1181628332,
-0.4822175801,
-0.3616400063,
-0.9470086694,
0.1299578696,
-0.0851488113,
-0.18056494,
0.179878816,
-0.1927654445,
-0.2678817809,
-0.0570328608,
-0.432564348,
0.6784799099,
0.2916011512,
-0.3568388224,
-0.3711408675,
-0.3353956342,
0.4821928442,
-0.1523811966,
0.4567700624,
-0.0170576908,
0.2095259428,
0.779559195,
-0.2250053138,
0.6743088365,
0.0035399122,
-0.2893067598,
0.5144317746,
0.4763875604,
0.3883663416,
0.1719746441,
-0.2726761103,
-0.1442020684,
-0.1267775595,
-0.1560404301,
-0.3540389836,
0.4611605704,
-0.5647183061,
-0.4818507433,
-0.2243482172,
-0.0321098231,
0.070864059,
0.113588877,
0.6773846149,
0.4837661684,
-0.2720477581,
-0.1379586458,
0.7769314647,
-0.2987619936,
1.0109541416,
0.5885973573,
-0.2000568658,
-0.3959732354,
0.6065048575,
-0.2325619608,
0.4853668511,
0.4740924537,
0.1726981848,
-0.5634456873,
-0.5635709167,
-0.483748734,
0.0511919186,
-0.5965993404,
-0.4633613825,
-1.0417852402,
-0.4778940082,
-0.7109578848,
-0.1158243641,
-0.1662335098,
-0.535875082,
-0.6481025219,
0.0815327987,
0.5914199948,
0.7468621731,
-0.098890774,
0.5123109221,
-0.8238188624,
0.812795043,
0.3623010516,
0.1161483675,
0.1477285475,
-1.2442401648,
-0.1322442293,
-0.1869698316,
-0.5063295364,
-1.0017340183,
0.8971433043,
0.4441129565,
0.3007929921,
0.1726525724,
0.4417746365,
0.6054720283,
-0.6461294293,
0.8112637997,
0.1424037367,
-0.9889819622,
0.4762756228,
-0.0961882398,
0.5919776559,
-0.0453863516,
0.0649259835,
-0.5543762445,
-0.5282816887,
-0.7023430467,
-0.7746225595,
0.5035699606,
0.5297649503,
0.2770801783,
-0.277458936,
0.2532481849,
0.1442128867,
0.027230313,
-0.7498716116,
-0.2090183645,
-0.5260583758,
-0.2903026044,
-0.0247780941,
-0.4377802014,
0.2005715519,
-0.0407322794,
0.5483508706,
0.0648446009,
0.481705904,
0.5003706217,
-0.2740376294,
-0.0392409228,
0.5650241375,
0.430123359,
0.0311298221,
0.2458276898,
-0.0188337751,
0.223946467,
-0.3523002565,
0.2289516032,
-0.0101277763,
-0.5015916228,
0.1998289227,
-0.0024722635,
0.6201308966,
0.2978137136,
-0.2667939365,
0.5519582629,
-0.0657375604,
-0.4040344357,
-0.2001314014,
0.1313592046,
0.1449606419,
0.2786842287,
0.2667682171,
0.2395096421,
0.7363231778,
-0.023158079,
0.3481924534,
0.1023042277,
-0.1409498453,
-0.231891185,
0.9272559285,
0.4870037138,
-0.3331772983,
0.429007262,
-0.4895159304,
-0.317969054,
0.5969644189,
0.7939255238,
0.9141699076,
-0.2663375437,
0.5509185195,
0.6955747008,
-0.0974186808,
-0.5660104752,
0.2684854567,
-0.2853472233,
-0.6848294735,
-0.5229632854,
-0.9091579318,
0.0774667189,
-0.2676074803,
-0.5348733664,
0.1202923283,
-0.1529878229,
-0.2657798827,
-0.2973463535,
-0.5538079143,
-0.5546951294,
0.2157362849,
0.0797726884,
0.6706342697,
-0.6525270343,
0.8120485544,
0.1379808038,
0.05506007,
-0.3370254636,
0.0577531233,
-0.4650728106,
-0.3311085403,
0.5584908128,
0.0125202229,
0.0399333164,
0.3994742632,
-0.2084963322,
-0.6326540709,
1.016196847,
0.0027382507,
-0.3503136933,
0.0397105627,
0.1429537088,
0.5224064589,
-0.3550846875,
0.0084798643,
0.6204980612,
0.2691686749,
0.525200665,
-0.303661257,
0.1138889864,
-0.1505613476,
0.233271718,
0.1894086897,
-0.4447792172,
0.6712898612,
-0.1129647344,
-0.5691995621,
0.1314832717,
0.7022604942,
-0.0471238568,
0.2769307196,
0.3602692783,
0.6006601453,
0.3782081008,
0.2703205943,
0.6533849835,
-0.1094336435,
0.1402357817,
1.1064599752,
-0.2524887919,
0.8038316369,
0.2315788418,
-0.2568630576,
0.700470686,
0.2861548662,
0.0931290239,
0.6844254732,
0.0543331355,
-0.3303170502,
-0.271152705,
0.1265942007,
-0.4647739828,
0.0263578314,
0.204904452,
-0.5549263358,
-0.1686077416,
0.1091289222,
-0.3623668551,
0.2693810463,
-0.0373438857,
0.9559355378,
0.0042461883,
-0.8127419353,
0.3316812813,
0.1415394694,
0.8293745518,
-0.1373413056,
-0.0805628374,
-0.5125061274,
-0.10486871,
-0.025803009,
-0.6147052646,
0.4778566957,
-0.1619416773,
-0.2654423714,
-0.5966431499,
0.614136219,
-0.4247697294,
-0.4460511506,
0.1117451489,
0.3508284986,
-0.1120532528,
-0.0093913907,
-0.3960616589,
-0.1902400851,
-0.0568330325,
-0.1780207455,
0.1178712696,
0.5454992652,
0.4438886344,
0.4414616525,
0.3475863636,
-0.2169757932,
0.4389373362,
0.3218948841,
0.3764955401,
-0.7346689105,
-0.7691827416,
-0.9637855887,
0.4265587926,
0.0004189,
-0.1234455332,
0.6465103626,
0.4267986417,
0.2144108266,
-0.3572361469,
0.6860591769,
-0.0151646696,
0.5380074978,
-0.723320365,
0.4411794245,
-0.2722882032,
0.2419479489,
-0.399790436,
-0.6382900476,
-0.0969630182,
0.5360056758,
0.0735437796,
-0.1021284983,
0.4881711602,
0.7765506506,
0.095913738,
0.2728456855,
0.4656022191,
0.2347241789,
0.2846991122,
0.3983990848,
0.9023807645,
-0.7852002978,
0.4560008943,
-0.0772698596,
0.2355588824,
-0.1567534804,
-0.8768775463,
-0.7071515322,
-0.7274253368,
-0.6775280237,
-0.4304565489,
-0.0555049591,
0.3273332715,
0.6266666055,
-0.4574320912,
-0.0012022461,
-0.6174730659,
0.2397019118,
-0.1514059752,
-0.3172239065,
0.1008837745,
-0.5055342317,
-0.815553844,
0.1801890433,
0.212280184,
0.4936910868,
-0.0952279344,
-0.3051248491,
-0.1829503924,
0.286693275,
0.740524888,
0.1018824801,
-0.3823725283,
0.2548190057,
-0.0323396102,
-0.2164708078,
0.2662920952,
0.7731438875,
-0.9967705011,
0.3485467732,
0.6012893915,
0.4366517365,
0.7337555289,
0.1964369863,
0.6658527255,
-0.7192912102,
0.1240492612,
0.1873355508,
0.0919928327,
0.2740193307,
-0.4191783071,
0.496527791,
0.2122314274,
-0.6662764549,
-0.5109292269,
0.164359808,
-0.7964209318,
-0.4607794583,
1.3751034737,
0.4044786096,
0.0479897745,
-0.4267035127,
-0.2412684858,
0.3678900599,
-0.5531201363,
0.7298175693,
0.3246412873,
-0.0402809121,
-0.4193294644,
-0.4200940132,
0.7010436058,
0.3157540858,
-0.6175888181,
-0.1037448123,
0.364444375,
0.1461399943,
-0.0495237261,
0.820838809,
-0.1095324159,
0.1439898759,
-0.0271536205,
-0.1617083102,
0.3494659066,
0.0751285106,
-0.5600488782,
0.1138129011,
0.0927424356,
-0.0059291953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10315v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10315v2 | HINT: Hypernetwork Instruction Tuning for Efficient Zero- & Few-Shot Generalisation | 2022-12-20T15:07:37 | 2023-05-24T22:30:30 | Hamish Ivison, Akshita Bhagia, Yizhong Wang, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Matthew Peters | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent NLP models have shown the remarkable ability to effectively generalise
`zero-shot' to new tasks using only natural language instructions as guidance.
However, many of these approaches suffer from high computational costs due to
their reliance on concatenating lengthy instructions with every input example,
resulting in costly reprocessing of the instruction. To avoid this, we
introduce Hypernetworks for INstruction Tuning (HINT), which convert task
instructions and examples into parameter-efficient modules inserted into an
underlying model using a pretrained text encoder, eliminating the need to
include instructions in the model input. The hypernetwork in HINT also produces
an encoded instruction, which we concatenate with encoded inputs during
decoding to further improve performance. HINT models outperform strong
state-of-the-art baselines by over 10% when controlling for compute (measured
in FLOPs). By converting instructions into modules, HINT models can effectively
disregard the length of instructions and few-shot example inputs in terms of
compute usage. As a result, HINT can enhance its performance by up to 25% by
incorporating additional few-shot data, while utilizing only up to 5% more
compute. This combines the strengths of parameter-efficient fine-tuning and
in-context learning. | [
-0.0943242386,
-0.7165331841,
0.442219466,
0.1239781231,
-0.3939405978,
-0.4302351177,
-0.3332484066,
-0.256195128,
0.1051416844,
0.7507991195,
-0.7741023302,
-0.6732550263,
-0.586981535,
-0.0368029736,
-0.3313145041,
1.1752016544,
0.4158897698,
-0.2631162405,
-0.150948137,
0.095043093,
-0.374588728,
-0.1428849399,
-0.6486278176,
-0.4509222507,
0.632628262,
0.7841809392,
0.6709298491,
1.0582522154,
0.6768782139,
0.2033109665,
0.0820135176,
0.4178973436,
-0.6459445357,
0.0811974257,
-0.13330248,
-0.6822942495,
-0.6114429832,
-0.1782696098,
0.417240113,
0.5527467132,
-0.1190842092,
0.584122777,
0.1125934646,
0.6678771973,
-1.1568000317,
0.0807385296,
-0.7695794702,
0.036899846,
-0.2161395997,
-0.6041358709,
-0.5582633018,
0.0390887186,
-0.2755169272,
-0.8330083489,
0.3444618583,
-0.014861065,
0.8780089617,
0.5695437789,
0.0740422308,
0.0586061142,
-0.8006658554,
0.94622612,
-1.0240706205,
-0.0819732621,
0.4758430421,
0.305983156,
-0.2049311996,
-0.6293659806,
-0.3390935957,
0.0834474936,
-0.0407879762,
0.183537364,
-0.4116498232,
0.523150146,
0.6159485579,
-0.0966460556,
-0.7160067558,
0.1391318589,
-0.2790666521,
-0.0402085371,
0.3890248239,
0.2464550883,
-0.1731555909,
-0.0846504271,
-0.2498016059,
0.0980432704,
-0.6680557132,
-0.2189614773,
0.3698413074,
0.5507901907,
-0.0498681292,
0.4778006971,
-0.6196331382,
1.338485837,
0.2402459532,
0.0000682556,
-0.0145274587,
-0.2627820671,
-0.3428442478,
0.1431829184,
0.6242089868,
0.3024667799,
0.205948025,
-0.1662693322,
-0.1190583035,
-0.1027223095,
0.5220456719,
-1.0026009083,
-0.1909141839,
0.1771047264,
-0.2147389203,
-0.1306612641,
-0.3649177253,
-0.439932704,
-0.0484921113,
-0.3033487797,
0.53706038,
-0.4151132703,
0.1735870242,
0.4103021622,
-0.3698966801,
0.3235659897,
0.1778348833,
-1.0259029865,
0.2335418016,
0.886251986,
0.8223246932,
0.0395891443,
-0.3807512522,
-0.7566781044,
0.3618294299,
-0.2814333737,
0.6462365389,
-0.6367347836,
-0.006657429,
-0.0665327236,
-0.1832449436,
0.0120364251,
-0.4775500894,
0.3783897758,
-0.3969521523,
-0.0104196612,
0.078505829,
-0.6075476408,
-0.0455015823,
0.4902705848,
-0.4776318371,
1.0131018162,
0.0784577653,
-0.6522655487,
0.3073296547,
-0.8212046623,
-0.5148413181,
0.3418220878,
0.0299034324,
-0.2264376581,
0.2680971324,
0.2229734212,
0.679463625,
-0.4227910936,
-0.1016968936,
-0.0655635223,
-0.821497798,
-0.3276235759,
-0.3891985118,
0.5096267462,
-0.0565736517,
-0.670541048,
0.0661691576,
-0.7629823089,
0.2964124382,
-0.2196926773,
-0.2455551773,
-0.3217425346,
-0.2181739807,
-0.2059907913,
0.1768878102,
0.3879010975,
-0.530207932,
0.1940123141,
-0.7537061572,
0.1324733943,
0.3661395907,
-0.0500486419,
0.3213148415,
-0.2589333951,
0.6158556342,
0.0073555256,
0.4189263284,
-0.2895186245,
-0.6610032916,
-0.8029478192,
0.0291555412,
0.2571116984,
0.5728738904,
-1.0381052494,
0.3969375789,
-0.0970185921,
-0.4517965317,
-0.7100375295,
0.3773270845,
0.7371163368,
0.7284083366,
0.604958415,
-0.1367005706,
-0.3521964252,
-0.9648988843,
-0.294365555,
0.0978432521,
-0.0633420423,
0.16032888,
0.5033575892,
0.135339886,
0.8745145202,
-0.6219277382,
-0.0485965461,
-0.2216486633,
0.3429358304,
0.4737453461,
0.6933600903,
0.2504187822,
-0.5879805684,
-0.4126954973,
0.0884313062,
-0.5914741158,
0.2393404245,
-0.1388675123,
-0.3297213912,
-0.0673806891,
0.4538955092,
-0.6715000868,
0.5341027379,
0.5599823594,
-0.1381871253,
0.650939405,
-0.4176116586,
-0.1103886813,
-0.9823753238,
-0.0406352021,
0.0369994491,
-0.2760854065,
-0.5131877065,
0.2953443825,
0.1300026327,
-0.2640426159,
-0.6310403347,
0.3730180264,
-0.4692884982,
0.2575298548,
-0.5465166569,
-0.1237231642,
0.0018263799,
0.8628706932,
-0.20275639,
0.5673118234,
0.6938354969,
-0.7958148122,
0.4178270102,
0.0062600323,
0.0058107828,
0.4543198049,
-0.8318898082,
0.4097600877,
-0.0415176339,
0.0022778106,
-0.4956934452,
-0.1470836848,
0.1417617202,
-0.4603529871,
0.5371516347,
-0.5318157077,
-0.3316763639,
-0.2570001781,
-0.3460758924,
0.177362904,
0.4692746997,
-0.3483070433,
0.3607696891,
-0.1033576056,
0.3411816359,
-1.0141112804,
-0.8368281126,
0.0042301207,
0.0429334715,
-0.3836589158,
0.532595098,
0.1587273926,
0.4746211767,
0.3773477972,
-0.1102851257,
-0.2096844465,
0.1094110832,
0.2104005516,
0.050491862,
-0.4703042805,
0.0667036399,
0.2095547616,
-0.3252456486,
-0.1562743634,
-0.8610551357,
0.3091557026,
0.2142386883,
-0.3861570954,
-0.5713083148,
0.4023122191,
0.4228990078,
-0.2883134186,
0.8251888752,
0.9751170278,
-0.4340025485,
-0.5824170709,
-0.3061388135,
-0.3676460981,
-0.4969903529,
0.5738990903,
-0.198019892,
-0.8684947491,
0.0143130757,
-0.2812646627,
0.2039169818,
0.313860327,
0.3911887407,
-0.1573691815,
0.9310381413,
1.0539982319,
-0.178449586,
0.394105047,
-0.629735291,
0.0833900273,
-0.8172902465,
0.0460504703,
-0.5907856822,
-0.6493429542,
-0.6040320992,
-0.5176150203,
0.3861112893,
-0.0195192602,
-0.2848448455,
0.7255346179,
-0.7215840816,
0.9004012942,
0.8075107336,
0.3681878448,
-0.0510614701,
-0.1148879454,
0.149218902,
0.1338617951,
-1.3065568209,
-0.2908365428,
1.2924463749,
-0.1337249577,
0.5681794286,
-0.182090953,
1.0173002481,
0.1442423016,
-0.1695097983,
-0.9049450159,
0.4114142656,
-0.4942686558,
-0.6462680101,
-0.5042639971,
-0.5408552885,
-0.9974495769,
-0.0891003981,
-0.3391714096,
-0.7171206474,
-0.0087608164,
0.6146643162,
-0.7964144349,
0.300830394,
-0.6660411358,
0.9859842062,
0.1367414445,
-0.7007457614,
-0.4733861089,
-0.5053078532,
0.3000462651,
0.3625198901,
-0.3063494861,
-0.0627491102,
-0.0239379071,
0.6286380887,
-0.3425472975,
0.8415717483,
-0.379054755,
0.2587954998,
0.1412338167,
-0.0139348712,
0.530236125,
-0.2833231091,
-0.2909497023,
-0.0390822217,
-0.1108543947,
-0.7945486307,
-1.0367695093,
0.6934910417,
-0.5265036225,
-0.4403735697,
0.071581386,
-0.7561628819,
-0.3006501198,
0.0216782466,
0.4914217889,
0.8433503509,
0.0120471856,
0.2495421022,
0.7177742124,
-0.0235635675,
0.5253300071,
0.305547744,
0.3704281151,
0.0403713398,
0.9403728843,
-0.0403959453,
0.3236311078,
0.7275964618,
0.154380694,
-0.1076478884,
-0.7319103479,
-0.6230570078,
0.0977058932,
-0.5007084608,
-0.523966074,
-0.2043866664,
0.0271866228,
-0.2444306463,
-0.2292611152,
-0.5922167897,
-0.4890688658,
-0.2242000401,
0.1240956113,
0.409955591,
0.520673871,
0.1095377579,
0.7779351473,
-0.8601734638,
0.3631722629,
0.2930202186,
0.4143037498,
-0.0246431306,
-0.5821166039,
-0.8050176501,
-0.0252782498,
-0.2888892889,
-0.798347652,
0.2410315573,
0.3899511993,
0.353543222,
0.4272729456,
0.0340097733,
0.7929155231,
-0.5810276866,
0.5767701268,
0.1439887434,
-0.7701866627,
0.5630834103,
-0.2512150705,
0.8204795122,
0.6896033883,
0.6542223692,
-0.3094704151,
-0.2165590525,
-0.51167202,
-0.7770392895,
0.9203287363,
0.1148960069,
0.3292945027,
0.1206491813,
0.5700868964,
-0.2072589397,
0.1649459004,
-0.1894045025,
-0.2841068506,
0.0877786651,
-0.4216099679,
0.0427392274,
-0.2468106598,
-0.3069865108,
-0.490700841,
0.7283972502,
-0.483132422,
0.3059780896,
-0.0122863855,
-0.2088380158,
-0.0713053942,
0.1982698441,
0.5872174501,
0.6346032619,
-0.317833364,
0.1025106609,
0.2437454015,
-0.45093292,
0.0103560435,
-0.1612596661,
-0.3620598614,
0.1317099482,
0.4116157591,
1.0289982557,
0.5132408142,
-0.2155078053,
0.4062589705,
0.2226036489,
-0.13803716,
0.2141584307,
0.4701178968,
0.0922112986,
-0.0087767504,
0.170604229,
0.2259057164,
0.2806220651,
-0.4372290373,
0.2350627929,
0.2751247585,
-0.6144024134,
-0.2801424563,
0.3376166821,
0.3276851773,
-0.4704039693,
0.5801562667,
-0.7661889195,
-0.2364445478,
0.6382651329,
0.8511734605,
1.0499746799,
0.1223301142,
0.3548341095,
0.5340791345,
0.4586118162,
0.0753261223,
0.2583498359,
-0.2262734175,
-0.6827608943,
-0.9984807968,
-0.7404312491,
-0.6270001531,
0.0287964605,
-0.6874457002,
0.1894625574,
-0.6206639409,
-0.1643279344,
0.0641096383,
-0.0984334275,
-0.7129457593,
0.1967508942,
0.1998524666,
0.8855357766,
-0.6609995365,
0.8927505016,
0.6210294962,
-0.0061063818,
-0.8139365315,
-0.0643044934,
0.002632678,
-0.5188670754,
0.3970505595,
0.098140426,
-0.4662122428,
0.2461621314,
-0.7736428976,
-0.5451996326,
0.9251897931,
0.7385328412,
-0.7947676182,
-0.235494718,
0.0723062605,
0.3177424073,
-0.179459542,
0.5527598858,
0.7520434856,
0.4692971408,
0.0685063377,
-0.8556014299,
0.0059762211,
-0.2738113403,
-0.1722969115,
0.3084786534,
-0.3145928681,
0.7044451833,
-0.1016145796,
-0.0526498966,
-0.2873833477,
0.5525413752,
-0.0531749539,
0.3007299602,
0.2319909483,
0.6108757257,
0.6227096319,
0.0648244172,
1.3056784868,
-0.5959051251,
0.1093976051,
1.2431497574,
0.0954185426,
0.8215795159,
0.3753557801,
0.0555529855,
0.6013470292,
0.0971536115,
0.162112996,
0.2275163084,
0.2192302644,
-0.0507281907,
-0.3248533309,
-0.1386812329,
-0.0164048299,
0.8306412697,
0.2705706656,
0.0470996648,
-0.4483757317,
-0.2945804596,
0.1365206689,
0.0714630038,
-0.5564537048,
0.6308964491,
-0.0905550271,
-0.5733186007,
0.9603252411,
0.1992205232,
1.1275041103,
-1.0137486458,
-0.3357361853,
0.0175677184,
0.1397283971,
-0.4484016895,
-0.444557637,
0.4040268958,
0.1605940312,
-0.3144408166,
-0.0766981468,
0.7770489454,
-0.3686669767,
-0.4636913836,
0.1415099055,
0.4069574177,
0.1709029824,
-0.4843657613,
-0.8572223186,
-0.4151979387,
-0.0710051283,
-0.0273646004,
0.2727018893,
0.4715204239,
0.1694936752,
0.5158541799,
0.6093948483,
0.3678874969,
0.164252013,
0.0370359272,
0.739467442,
-0.9053375125,
-0.3643342257,
-0.9255334735,
0.4772777557,
-0.118715331,
-0.7815012336,
0.7284464836,
0.5155609846,
0.9106559753,
-0.0825106725,
0.3715964556,
0.1535800248,
-0.0546565726,
-0.7291095853,
0.6689035296,
-0.422313869,
-0.2042518556,
-0.1721246243,
-0.7908468246,
-0.2472451478,
0.1944694817,
-0.1733994633,
-0.146136716,
0.6579747796,
1.1146312952,
-0.2816653848,
-0.1567708552,
0.5964468122,
-0.1784714013,
-0.1933808327,
0.869430244,
0.4373161197,
-0.3709226549,
0.4680368602,
-0.5692867041,
-0.2520627379,
-0.1084227264,
-0.9832632542,
-0.6719817519,
-0.2721910775,
-0.4727331102,
0.1477728337,
0.3188489974,
0.9394650459,
1.2801111937,
-0.7552927732,
-0.3416377306,
-0.0649292171,
0.1326661855,
-0.5668381453,
-0.1921788603,
0.1894918084,
-0.7727519274,
-0.6054810882,
0.675835669,
0.5437965989,
-0.4409978092,
-0.1695635766,
-0.0028226646,
-0.3270532787,
0.2547032237,
0.5537266135,
0.3275341988,
-0.2098984569,
-0.0715915933,
0.1300430894,
0.0633428097,
-0.0412389785,
0.9018948674,
-0.6695238352,
0.4142533839,
0.4198509455,
0.8316374421,
0.8425307274,
-0.0332485512,
0.5736803412,
-1.268381238,
0.4385327399,
0.4901978374,
0.0047186464,
0.2796953022,
-0.5334186554,
0.2247350961,
0.086920619,
-0.3030211926,
-0.5520549417,
0.275287658,
-0.7665977478,
-0.2545405924,
0.8328001499,
-0.22892268,
-0.6521124244,
0.0356252082,
0.1247968897,
0.3496503532,
-0.1993447244,
0.5496174693,
0.319467485,
-0.298884213,
0.0403770916,
-0.6135037541,
0.6502242684,
0.7577134371,
-0.6864801645,
-0.0515448526,
0.2514363825,
-0.1956834644,
0.1368072182,
0.3989284039,
0.1809747815,
0.5995469093,
0.1446449012,
0.3180893958,
-0.5016525984,
-0.6846724749,
-0.3681370318,
0.2523031235,
-0.043747317,
-0.5821979642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10313v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10313v2 | Beyond Triplet: Leveraging the Most Data for Multimodal Machine Translation | 2022-12-20T15:02:38 | 2023-09-03T03:46:05 | Yaoming Zhu, Zewei Sun, Shanbo Cheng, Luyang Huang, Liwei Wu, Mingxuan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multimodal machine translation (MMT) aims to improve translation quality by
incorporating information from other modalities, such as vision. Previous MMT
systems mainly focus on better access and use of visual information and tend to
validate their methods on image-related datasets. These studies face two
challenges. First, they can only utilize triple data (bilingual texts with
images), which is scarce; second, current benchmarks are relatively restricted
and do not correspond to realistic scenarios. Therefore, this paper
correspondingly establishes new methods and new datasets for MMT. First, we
propose a framework 2/3-Triplet with two new approaches to enhance MMT by
utilizing large-scale non-triple data: monolingual image-text data and parallel
text-only data. Second, we construct an English-Chinese {e}-commercial
{m}ulti{m}odal {t}ranslation dataset (including training and testing), named
EMMT, where its test set is carefully selected as some words are ambiguous and
shall be translated mistakenly without the help of images. Experiments show
that our method is more suitable for real-world scenarios and can significantly
improve translation performance by using more non-triple data. In addition, our
model also rivals various SOTA models in conventional multimodal translation
benchmarks. | [
-0.3062771559,
-0.537987411,
0.4581759274,
0.241769895,
-0.3959963024,
0.0207288992,
-0.1965505481,
-0.4651916921,
-0.0284167957,
0.466493547,
-0.4113000631,
-0.3971002698,
-0.6563768983,
0.3569841087,
-0.2544204593,
0.9035811424,
-0.5097286701,
0.2380349487,
0.0878438428,
-0.5217943788,
-0.4798358977,
-0.4784572721,
-0.3735988438,
-0.0758319199,
0.7455949187,
0.5554771423,
0.7872348428,
0.8317094445,
0.8257026076,
0.1857431233,
0.4513596296,
0.6295781732,
-0.0816090405,
-0.0367743671,
0.2547569573,
-0.5791631341,
-0.6382485628,
0.0048173899,
0.8287364841,
0.4015448093,
0.3019922078,
0.077423431,
-0.0324585512,
0.7058244944,
-0.3300166428,
0.4883265495,
-0.3522074819,
0.2759702504,
-0.4618132114,
-0.4087659717,
-0.3592000306,
-0.2170598358,
-0.0825818032,
-0.5949107409,
0.0001234827,
0.1729986668,
0.6374675632,
0.2923103571,
-1.0832653046,
0.0366555043,
-0.6048724651,
0.7318290472,
-0.3354022205,
0.8172100782,
0.2850925624,
0.5057983398,
0.1612988114,
-0.3798917234,
-0.5792300701,
-0.2174161822,
0.0590541326,
0.4911698997,
-0.0063272263,
-0.2003232241,
0.2709800601,
0.3930952847,
-0.5924418569,
-0.1138967499,
-0.2334193438,
0.0173905585,
0.1802503318,
0.1974417418,
0.3454804718,
-0.2183268666,
-0.8221585155,
-0.4671220183,
-0.6745149493,
-0.174664557,
0.0015510102,
0.140323624,
-0.2343110144,
0.8741599917,
0.0913073421,
0.5826398134,
-0.2702009976,
-0.2102595717,
0.6503094435,
-0.7696679831,
-0.1617040932,
-0.2764407694,
0.7073379159,
0.7316986322,
-0.0317520276,
0.0108118113,
-0.3591738939,
-0.0737402663,
-0.2103482485,
-0.6775951982,
0.060056258,
-0.0298204925,
-0.459492296,
0.0029938279,
0.060152337,
-0.8098095059,
-0.2012423277,
-0.4346575439,
0.4027828276,
-0.68942976,
-0.4146774113,
-0.030898599,
-0.0863555595,
0.0432902351,
0.2189085633,
-0.7182528377,
-0.0521627963,
0.2417472601,
1.1394315958,
-0.1236821637,
-0.5597077012,
-0.3055122793,
0.4784173071,
-0.4340946674,
0.6710876822,
-0.2415924817,
0.0975949541,
-0.3031421602,
0.029075468,
-0.3388668895,
-0.4703570902,
0.5097146034,
-0.3764229119,
0.131754756,
-0.3284084201,
-0.0357726179,
-0.421877116,
0.4093143046,
-0.8986991644,
0.7890262008,
-0.1727233082,
-0.6346418858,
0.6074644327,
-0.9698146582,
-0.5136712193,
-0.2647790015,
-0.1868583709,
-0.4405550659,
0.2032924742,
0.5295048952,
0.541677773,
-0.4693089128,
0.1896793395,
-0.2926417589,
0.009482597,
0.2875744402,
-0.7471348047,
0.3634896576,
0.2718767226,
-0.1796700954,
-0.2256177813,
-0.6092531681,
-0.1400931925,
0.1860379279,
-0.3818089068,
-0.2019937038,
-0.1623575687,
0.4192237556,
0.473664701,
0.0902038515,
-0.7546725869,
0.1612123549,
-0.0220866129,
0.5048568249,
0.5931699276,
-0.3847945035,
0.2387482077,
-0.4811899662,
0.3798666,
0.3203336596,
0.10590069,
-0.4180077612,
-0.5856385827,
-0.8074361086,
-0.5104359984,
0.314828366,
0.579916358,
-1.4718750715,
-0.2494917065,
-0.7298207283,
-0.148048535,
-0.6446302533,
-0.0666437149,
0.3617478609,
0.2921143174,
0.5619444251,
-0.1104498655,
-0.6280713081,
-0.9920797944,
-0.0996510834,
0.1773793101,
0.0896999165,
0.2042393535,
0.4467837214,
-0.3614628613,
0.6082559824,
-0.3401751518,
-0.5030148625,
-0.2094871253,
0.3032256067,
0.21513699,
0.4998408556,
0.352624774,
-1.1714440584,
-0.5781661868,
0.5072684884,
-0.9033054113,
0.0562045351,
-0.2244064212,
0.1556850821,
0.2620266676,
0.2870949209,
-0.4821682274,
0.1979124546,
0.9246279001,
0.1935127079,
0.2299148142,
-0.3601239026,
0.62421,
-1.2045516968,
-0.0025269387,
-0.1163200736,
-0.4451541007,
-0.5513004661,
0.1167046949,
0.5481683612,
-0.1635658443,
-0.4278515875,
0.2224514186,
-0.6219906807,
-0.0671180561,
-0.1472859681,
-0.097831279,
0.0390550308,
0.4901344776,
-0.0469373502,
0.872012198,
0.3465425968,
-0.2158412784,
0.5788899064,
0.1227057204,
-0.038685523,
0.7641295791,
-0.2443113774,
0.1081835628,
-0.1173118427,
0.4569048584,
-0.7550285459,
-0.3397906423,
0.1083385572,
-0.4009779692,
0.3081225157,
-0.062658444,
-1.1507385969,
-0.3497267067,
-0.3704026043,
0.670126915,
0.2063633204,
-0.6308156848,
0.5220096707,
0.208768636,
0.1355457157,
-0.3541359007,
-1.1131511927,
0.5047418475,
-0.1676588804,
-0.8772262931,
0.2530322373,
-0.0528450646,
0.3435141742,
-0.2360255569,
-0.0879400149,
-0.2277337313,
-0.3510221541,
0.0441110022,
0.1797278076,
-0.3363932967,
0.2859914303,
0.0837439224,
-0.4331800342,
-0.3670787811,
-0.4975773394,
0.257932663,
-0.3126119375,
-0.3975298107,
-0.5088056922,
0.5087966323,
0.8447765112,
-0.3364641368,
0.5888903737,
1.0038557053,
-0.3115851581,
0.4172917604,
-0.5929416418,
0.0585789122,
-0.3547193706,
0.4750386775,
-0.7957857847,
-0.6794224977,
0.1868483275,
0.0677986667,
0.1900939345,
0.2317768037,
0.6069079041,
-0.2370479554,
1.4714866877,
0.5561272502,
0.3553663194,
0.4105978012,
-0.0708025098,
0.1353608519,
-0.9958031178,
-0.1857527047,
0.0525034331,
-0.2869669199,
-0.6835054755,
-0.8037092686,
0.6786385775,
-0.3361701071,
0.3837176263,
0.5899630189,
-0.0128692379,
0.350248754,
0.5027781725,
0.2273788154,
0.6102612615,
0.0544694141,
-0.3322320282,
-0.2139923722,
-0.6558241844,
-0.499442488,
1.315836072,
0.3343660831,
0.4842942655,
0.4117114842,
0.1977961659,
-0.0190192033,
0.2841148078,
-0.4656333625,
0.3902688324,
-0.3948965669,
-0.7679293156,
0.1082224846,
-0.6817365289,
-0.8535923958,
0.6497391462,
-0.1823287159,
0.002386773,
-0.065682061,
0.2249988168,
-0.0463045761,
0.5348487496,
-0.9067243338,
0.5991336703,
-0.4721550941,
-0.2984783053,
0.0587492809,
-0.7855665088,
0.3332078457,
-0.53578192,
0.4341757596,
-0.0605620928,
-0.4598739147,
0.4787263572,
-0.092592828,
0.5673882365,
0.0998802334,
-0.1146154553,
-0.1645881087,
-0.1032177582,
0.382035464,
-0.1203945354,
0.1921667308,
0.3495591581,
0.1353316009,
-0.5253227353,
-0.5583652258,
0.5790404081,
-0.5957741737,
-0.1125902459,
-0.2712161541,
-0.9991252422,
-0.1876106858,
0.4251100719,
0.2317944467,
0.3721411824,
0.1646823287,
0.4084872305,
0.4228439331,
-0.1794271022,
0.2575680614,
0.3611389399,
-0.2316500694,
-0.5833856463,
1.1063913107,
0.3532288671,
0.4088663757,
0.7264821529,
0.1666545421,
-0.2649867237,
-0.530934453,
-0.9326127768,
0.0970542505,
-0.565085113,
-0.215393275,
-0.8193053603,
0.2166919708,
-0.4877665639,
0.1594227403,
-0.457873702,
-0.4338107109,
0.0562345311,
-0.0303073004,
0.1888327897,
0.5080249906,
-0.2902185917,
0.1966969818,
-1.0053364038,
0.5987712741,
0.1460384578,
0.308773756,
-0.3046835959,
-0.0866250172,
-0.4500672817,
0.2376711667,
-0.3232989907,
-0.7802274227,
0.3996064663,
0.0022749437,
0.3776539862,
0.172910288,
-0.3594231606,
0.8281112313,
-0.6768653393,
0.512834549,
0.3428839445,
-0.6157987714,
0.2929278314,
-0.5959471464,
0.3395246267,
0.279632777,
0.1128617525,
-0.6271659136,
-0.2164579183,
-0.2385008335,
-0.695192337,
0.725075841,
0.6375674009,
-0.0673205331,
0.2501713634,
-0.1544001698,
0.3346523345,
0.2626808882,
-0.9423774481,
-0.0880384818,
-0.3086088896,
-0.3850278854,
-0.2541644275,
-0.0112106046,
0.0836810991,
-0.1695900559,
0.322871387,
-0.1616578698,
0.2775533795,
0.0445237793,
-0.4286061227,
-0.0065019019,
0.1177556813,
0.5836354494,
0.2736804783,
-0.2348133624,
0.3987340927,
0.1411618888,
-0.4596672654,
0.1760481447,
0.0971464515,
0.0517655462,
-0.1040822044,
0.2867360711,
0.7319774032,
0.036268875,
-0.5469925404,
0.5484725833,
0.06087742,
-0.2372035831,
-0.0365324654,
-0.5201349854,
-0.1828961819,
0.3583177626,
0.1392347664,
0.4420416951,
0.1283592433,
-0.3821601868,
0.2482806146,
0.1052309796,
-0.4216733575,
-0.4237044156,
0.5492381454,
0.2415515184,
0.2166848928,
0.3448619545,
0.134876132,
-0.3642717004,
0.3961211443,
0.5496900082,
0.627448976,
-0.0688988864,
-0.0458606072,
0.1412133276,
0.7572790384,
-0.1025836989,
0.2138671428,
-0.1129181013,
-0.5353246927,
-0.3850423992,
-0.079857856,
-0.1846259087,
-0.1083238572,
-0.451333344,
0.3421826363,
-0.166331172,
-0.2414475828,
-0.2624942064,
-0.4236373007,
-0.6726116538,
0.0980729312,
0.2643789053,
0.463858515,
-0.8207504153,
0.9607226253,
0.8322770596,
-0.532389164,
-0.304458499,
-0.1245954856,
0.1796390265,
-0.9829131365,
0.5811196566,
0.3791884184,
-0.2197822034,
0.0892087445,
-0.2719740272,
-0.8642932177,
1.1735670567,
0.3767802119,
-0.303846091,
0.0332489461,
0.5143384337,
0.1913694739,
-0.2867617607,
0.2404473871,
0.4448627532,
0.799785316,
0.1145052016,
-0.9330616593,
-0.0553366207,
-0.2814049721,
0.1588374376,
0.4487171769,
-0.7229756713,
0.9614031911,
-0.1942059994,
-0.3260464668,
0.0307325218,
0.3547025621,
0.0894479677,
0.3738404214,
0.4116434157,
0.5536391735,
0.2998256683,
-0.0501727387,
1.0402475595,
0.1121254787,
0.3820470273,
0.9842994213,
-0.1478897631,
0.6569781899,
0.7415665388,
0.1053737476,
-0.1497686505,
0.57600981,
-0.1773528457,
0.4888327718,
-0.3149963021,
-0.0088502774,
-0.1688342541,
-0.2023005635,
-0.5692029595,
0.5239854455,
0.2577381432,
-0.4826675057,
-0.3268218637,
0.5545863509,
0.0852021575,
-0.2318668514,
0.1286018193,
0.5760472417,
0.0599337928,
-0.3292023242,
0.5472307801,
0.2487310916,
0.6144843102,
-0.2940640748,
-0.1109075025,
-0.1461136043,
0.2872528732,
-0.0553076938,
-0.7500227094,
0.2067466974,
-0.0108157312,
-0.1841232181,
-0.6760593653,
0.1144585237,
-0.4792365432,
-0.5974637866,
0.2107292563,
0.6376701593,
0.1984766424,
-0.1086776331,
-0.6858853102,
0.0229350384,
0.143409729,
-0.0332668871,
0.1383228302,
0.777164042,
-0.1748433709,
0.5019261837,
0.8507692814,
0.0309931673,
0.2229255736,
-0.0866260976,
0.7023217082,
-0.7626500726,
-0.3142209351,
-0.8467904925,
0.4149724543,
0.0216338411,
-0.1528555304,
0.9037374258,
0.6962373257,
0.7612569332,
0.0393330902,
0.6483972669,
0.055356618,
0.4096909463,
-0.7627325058,
0.5010855198,
-0.9111056924,
0.0028977147,
-0.2415184826,
-0.950865984,
-0.7596299052,
0.1959709525,
-0.1332428753,
0.0023832931,
1.1008865833,
0.6329669952,
-0.4009502828,
0.1702930778,
0.6234331727,
0.2290868014,
0.494699806,
0.8251509666,
0.8861309886,
-0.7449328899,
0.8298265934,
-0.0842856765,
-0.4695715606,
-0.2866203785,
-0.7298901677,
-0.7725595832,
-0.6536825895,
0.0579750314,
0.0859439969,
-0.1382077783,
0.7760664821,
0.7695540786,
-0.37877509,
-0.1217960268,
0.1809667796,
-0.1582098305,
-0.3143095672,
-0.0359899066,
0.2659294307,
-0.0606967844,
-0.8210093379,
0.2661463916,
0.6294221878,
0.3732543588,
-0.0074342047,
0.1170216203,
-0.2437066138,
-0.1584278047,
0.8418629766,
-0.1187812015,
-0.6492316127,
-0.0601137169,
0.0583519787,
-0.1052129567,
0.4269735515,
0.7651331425,
-0.3405616581,
0.7454126477,
0.3135591447,
0.6136494875,
0.6611286998,
-0.2875203192,
0.7419704795,
-0.6571103334,
0.2469057888,
0.0699444413,
0.3506855667,
0.5112010837,
-0.0441778377,
0.5257999301,
0.2961016893,
-0.183574304,
-0.5901659131,
0.3031296134,
-0.8976960778,
0.0527103022,
1.0154978037,
-0.0462681204,
-0.1760475636,
-0.1372293681,
-0.3099243045,
0.377930671,
-0.3288221657,
0.3758431375,
0.6000927091,
0.0016795303,
-0.3620374501,
-1.1155475378,
-0.0189538188,
0.4415000081,
-0.749111414,
-0.0457189046,
0.463935405,
-0.0280415136,
0.0870637447,
0.3964745402,
-0.5476863384,
0.2374396473,
-0.1428212672,
-0.074825719,
-0.2356188297,
-0.4979549944,
-0.1096461713,
0.1138865724,
-0.3359646797,
-0.5727046728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10297v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10297v2 | Extrinsic Evaluation of Machine Translation Metrics | 2022-12-20T14:39:58 | 2023-06-19T03:59:55 | Nikita Moghe, Tom Sherborne, Mark Steedman, Alexandra Birch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatic machine translation (MT) metrics are widely used to distinguish the
translation qualities of machine translation systems across relatively large
test sets (system-level evaluation). However, it is unclear if automatic
metrics are reliable at distinguishing good translations from bad translations
at the sentence level (segment-level evaluation). In this paper, we investigate
how useful MT metrics are at detecting the success of a machine translation
component when placed in a larger platform with a downstream task. We evaluate
the segment-level performance of the most widely used MT metrics (chrF, COMET,
BERTScore, etc.) on three downstream cross-lingual tasks (dialogue state
tracking, question answering, and semantic parsing). For each task, we only
have access to a monolingual task-specific model. We calculate the correlation
between the metric's ability to predict a good/bad translation with the
success/failure on the final task for the Translate-Test setup. Our experiments
demonstrate that all metrics exhibit negligible correlation with the extrinsic
evaluation of the downstream outcomes. We also find that the scores provided by
neural metrics are not interpretable mostly because of undefined ranges. We
synthesise our analysis into recommendations for future MT metrics to produce
labels rather than scores for more informative interaction between machine
translation and multilingual language understanding. | [
-0.4725396633,
-0.6493662596,
0.4248715341,
0.2407097965,
-0.5188245177,
0.09168908,
-0.4191158414,
-0.454962045,
0.4038773179,
0.2138379812,
-0.3542126715,
-0.5260677338,
-0.8325312138,
0.1663241684,
-0.7196119428,
1.2167870998,
-0.3031818271,
0.0988063887,
-0.0792978853,
-0.4352209866,
-0.7019408941,
-0.6911076903,
-0.695314765,
-0.1996323615,
0.6166642904,
0.1378549635,
0.4703298807,
0.6165631413,
0.9253021479,
0.2628960311,
0.0284947883,
0.1561485231,
-0.2325782031,
0.3320498765,
-0.0935042873,
-0.5090554953,
-0.2606824934,
-0.0309434179,
0.7764830589,
0.7353994846,
0.1842705458,
0.3872893453,
0.2660090923,
0.6096337438,
-0.317116946,
0.0421687029,
-0.4535005391,
0.3445330262,
-0.3304594457,
-0.3762339354,
-0.4858588874,
-0.2765632272,
0.0295922533,
-0.3543705046,
-0.0797088742,
0.2070881575,
0.6630803347,
0.4231088161,
-0.47360906,
-0.5363715887,
-0.6639078856,
0.86365062,
-0.672244072,
0.3661063015,
0.2703978717,
0.4293199182,
0.008499749,
-0.308831811,
-0.2397693843,
-0.2066756636,
-0.2921499014,
0.2216960788,
-0.3915416002,
-0.2049151808,
0.047771439,
0.2929461896,
-0.6913760304,
0.1867313981,
-0.2403803468,
-0.2762170732,
0.1620827168,
0.3078934252,
0.4005534649,
-0.3538664579,
-0.4994018078,
-0.2576219141,
-0.4928776622,
0.2940162122,
0.3371711075,
0.4140625596,
-0.1486785412,
0.5980718732,
-0.0451892056,
0.5388848186,
-0.2207081318,
0.0570994504,
0.4431573451,
-0.7847926021,
-0.0567987747,
-0.0895559639,
1.0450595617,
0.34432742,
-0.0974852219,
-0.2584956884,
-0.4345063865,
0.0188135002,
0.2276531905,
-0.5078311563,
0.0390963405,
0.1107093617,
-0.4931720793,
0.0573592409,
0.0484462902,
-0.3680180311,
-0.1922945976,
-0.2884837985,
0.4710914791,
-0.6540668011,
-0.0365038179,
-0.2688867152,
-0.2393323481,
-0.0424834862,
0.0168433189,
-0.3101008236,
0.1256016493,
0.6643036604,
1.0113403797,
-0.6105685234,
-0.4810006618,
-0.9712135792,
-0.2028968185,
-0.5475087762,
0.6567043662,
-0.2871674895,
-0.2309204638,
-0.1342344433,
0.1386492252,
-0.3717700541,
-0.6786803007,
0.7770001888,
-0.3751242161,
0.0717085898,
-0.1616548896,
-0.2409098744,
-0.3633550406,
0.3700503111,
-0.5897002816,
0.8702750206,
0.1549226195,
-0.6384108663,
0.6491223574,
-0.6073564887,
-0.9015594721,
0.016472172,
0.1923343986,
-0.1846745014,
0.3280401826,
-0.0048677516,
0.2974744141,
-0.1008519605,
0.2283977717,
-0.1391902715,
-0.276360333,
0.4336774051,
-0.494631201,
0.3492639065,
0.1285634339,
-0.4803007543,
0.2535430789,
-0.4365727305,
0.2667994797,
-0.4180417955,
-0.4550222158,
-0.4582704604,
0.0500749424,
-0.1679877192,
0.4508740008,
0.0719423071,
-0.476101011,
-0.397849381,
-0.1754609346,
0.2764473259,
0.5551881194,
-0.124278143,
0.3353249431,
-0.0458193757,
0.5209328532,
0.2143794447,
0.1194816008,
-0.1004694328,
-0.557921946,
-1.0608463287,
-0.1168116033,
0.3874698877,
0.4304637313,
-0.8964805603,
0.5916208029,
-0.52497226,
-0.5405631065,
-0.4492346942,
0.1584521234,
0.6519839764,
0.4110027254,
0.4475256503,
-0.5412533283,
-0.3283963501,
-1.001257062,
-0.491653651,
-0.1216893494,
0.1435360909,
-0.0435279682,
0.5066690445,
0.1676352918,
0.4564771354,
-0.0952053666,
-0.4934680164,
-0.3187682629,
0.2948614359,
0.3085258305,
0.4757783115,
0.3296427727,
-0.58368361,
-0.6579576731,
0.3986784816,
-0.6007037163,
-0.0427139774,
-0.0001973514,
-0.1535955966,
0.2503305674,
0.173349455,
-0.43230322,
0.1646614671,
0.7309584022,
-0.450670898,
0.5270638466,
-0.381622076,
0.5188446641,
-0.7305054665,
0.3493980169,
0.1334351897,
-0.409262538,
-0.5462327003,
0.1881461442,
0.1005213633,
0.1944913864,
-0.4077454805,
0.2649855614,
-0.1489795893,
-0.2468142807,
-0.1256160587,
0.3048679829,
-0.028738061,
0.4825237691,
-0.0206987821,
0.5941588879,
0.0958365276,
-0.5813043714,
0.190241158,
0.0727967918,
-0.6412732601,
0.7798566222,
-0.4526615739,
0.0500379503,
0.2713083029,
0.0236134864,
-1.0481467247,
-0.0204985384,
0.3913840055,
-0.8104020953,
0.1734745651,
-0.0058958172,
-0.6213098168,
-0.3590368927,
0.1255381107,
0.39130494,
0.4150806367,
-0.2492404282,
0.2017699182,
0.316521883,
-0.2096391767,
-0.3876182735,
-0.9603937268,
0.2050872594,
-0.3894830048,
-0.3446649313,
-0.1012713686,
0.1060993001,
0.1019573733,
-0.0182368718,
-0.0214878768,
-0.0522505268,
0.0574622042,
0.2356124073,
0.1163618714,
-0.2096509933,
-0.0944275185,
0.2007271498,
-0.4166959822,
0.1859352738,
-0.3788634539,
0.4293484092,
-0.1776676029,
-0.5676038265,
-0.3764587045,
0.4475547969,
0.8011540771,
-0.3863870502,
0.6296861768,
0.7713692188,
-0.2960646749,
0.0163664389,
-0.2707939148,
0.0866683498,
-0.3228887916,
0.5308520198,
-0.500957489,
-0.7704098225,
0.5614996552,
0.5139915347,
-0.0774327889,
0.5509385467,
0.4944876432,
0.0153371738,
1.355569005,
0.2636725307,
-0.0164708942,
0.1459608227,
-0.0587365068,
0.5086152554,
-0.925996244,
-0.2406157106,
-0.5751772523,
-0.6754971743,
-0.5868207812,
-0.472091794,
0.5943308473,
-0.1756881326,
0.0167311318,
0.8306480646,
-0.3552888632,
0.1056087092,
0.5369814634,
-0.2558422983,
0.3703650534,
0.0652638525,
-0.2869623303,
-0.1978189647,
-0.5059822798,
-0.4717427492,
0.6411284208,
0.4147937,
0.248365283,
0.0559200011,
0.3106386065,
0.3809213042,
0.5027366281,
-0.8362321258,
0.4166325331,
-0.4769660532,
-0.595675528,
-0.160985902,
-0.8973838687,
-0.6811847687,
0.4167282581,
0.0448996983,
-0.649487555,
-0.1047980934,
-0.0450554565,
-0.2305908948,
0.1953108162,
-0.6896258593,
1.1447829008,
-0.5057399869,
0.0571150333,
-0.2474797964,
-0.6061256528,
0.1556449831,
-0.37505126,
0.3482239246,
-0.0962987915,
-0.1517272741,
0.8641839623,
-0.1358918697,
0.5416181087,
-0.2278708071,
-0.0108586634,
0.2366462648,
0.3598947227,
0.2866304815,
-0.3026506007,
-0.1278029531,
0.1949650943,
0.2675647438,
-0.1562627852,
-0.6809632182,
0.6281871796,
-0.5343461037,
-0.2139359564,
-0.1050969213,
-0.4966211915,
-0.1690154374,
0.3582036495,
0.3573359847,
0.3980001807,
-0.0320480578,
0.3291680813,
0.0751404613,
-0.2352243215,
0.2867380381,
0.5221947432,
-0.2633973956,
-0.6042268276,
1.2419273853,
0.1863470525,
0.4186846912,
0.4847215712,
0.0394371487,
-0.4395286739,
-0.6967965961,
-0.8351918459,
-0.0882972926,
-0.8210327029,
-0.2744548917,
-0.5658574104,
0.0790239722,
0.1690008342,
0.1783631295,
-0.4226584733,
-0.531024754,
0.1245730445,
-0.0362997353,
-0.2522632182,
0.6885073185,
-0.0651445314,
0.2391998917,
-0.964091599,
-0.0780674815,
-0.495531261,
0.2082872987,
-0.1035497636,
-0.7248952985,
-0.6365488768,
0.2415423691,
-0.1830956191,
-0.5033562183,
0.3862575591,
-0.0018781134,
0.6117517948,
0.3587136865,
-0.1476111561,
0.547431767,
-0.4072459936,
0.7944589853,
0.4866468608,
-1.1100411415,
0.3224468529,
-0.1631651372,
0.2574302256,
0.6876104474,
0.4007464945,
-0.8112378716,
-0.8225901723,
-0.0206633378,
-0.7892508507,
0.5876749754,
0.3367756605,
0.1654115468,
-0.129250586,
-0.025107678,
0.3849045038,
0.2939817905,
-0.6500957012,
-0.1657619178,
0.0735838041,
-0.1170599088,
-0.3895669281,
0.2383768111,
0.0497165844,
-0.0717922896,
0.6088199019,
-0.0398173034,
0.2272870541,
0.0651237294,
-0.287067771,
-0.1087944061,
0.228796795,
0.5310506821,
0.5151305199,
-0.0846742466,
0.2837403417,
0.0993071124,
-0.2678817809,
0.3597744107,
-0.0135328136,
-0.0550327338,
0.2780824602,
0.4009500742,
0.7220756412,
0.0191238634,
-0.4790523946,
0.5122002959,
0.0763823092,
0.0756610557,
-0.0735668615,
-0.1722016186,
-0.0540702865,
-0.0806184188,
0.2854027152,
0.3178434074,
0.1960632801,
-0.3828154504,
0.1606601626,
0.3910957277,
-1.1310597658,
-0.4923896492,
0.3728357553,
0.3511778414,
-0.2569556534,
0.568575263,
-0.4567357898,
-0.8687255979,
0.6380528212,
0.4259223044,
0.8082536459,
-0.1678534597,
0.2029104233,
0.3747399747,
0.6341615915,
0.1885603815,
-0.0850542262,
0.0606437363,
-0.3274384439,
-0.7785189748,
-0.644294858,
-0.1629161984,
-0.1294086128,
-0.6706590652,
0.0947556943,
0.021209484,
-0.477897495,
-0.1415899098,
-0.2566602528,
-0.6250170469,
0.3500151634,
0.1313100457,
0.8796064258,
-0.7497727275,
0.3766260445,
0.7376148701,
-0.3838507533,
-0.5884217024,
-0.261826396,
-0.1427163035,
-0.5672540069,
0.9294207096,
0.3749967515,
-0.2089535594,
-0.2330706418,
0.2823332846,
-0.8304000497,
0.6492981911,
0.2229439467,
-0.2329562008,
0.0393687859,
0.6105400324,
0.6626189947,
-0.3605991304,
0.5156244636,
0.4277935028,
0.5552079082,
-0.2463020384,
-1.0987027884,
0.1620863229,
-0.3702262342,
-0.1630349904,
0.6572333574,
-0.4588838518,
0.4768917263,
0.1325255483,
-0.3910168111,
0.2743948102,
0.337998271,
-0.2745225132,
0.3577444553,
0.7010906935,
0.6128441095,
0.4675762355,
-0.3462807834,
1.0875282288,
-0.3871666789,
0.3409555852,
0.9753488302,
0.0850495175,
1.140630126,
0.5253435969,
-0.0272312611,
0.4772934318,
0.696344018,
0.1230954155,
0.5027035475,
0.2450309098,
0.1797305346,
-0.2535893321,
-0.1257061213,
-0.2403640747,
0.3385173082,
0.3936456144,
-0.6394785047,
-0.207788527,
0.2237093002,
-0.108200714,
-0.2934302092,
0.0037567182,
0.4721140862,
0.279748708,
-1.1660296917,
0.5174524188,
0.090782918,
0.3690162003,
-0.526027143,
0.1978609115,
-0.2486504018,
0.329557687,
-0.2159529775,
-0.9093702435,
0.6259148121,
0.1006549224,
-0.1506645828,
-0.1797923893,
0.3104009926,
-0.2865941525,
-0.3373185098,
0.5256268978,
0.7998444438,
0.3689665794,
-0.1892942488,
-0.5074241161,
0.1003304943,
-0.0450321473,
-0.1823548824,
0.2411631048,
0.3601617515,
0.1034620479,
0.7115112543,
0.6357081532,
0.0216865242,
0.0470264442,
0.0022654766,
0.447244674,
-0.544615984,
-0.5024560094,
-0.7814808488,
0.5950746536,
0.0110893873,
-0.4740667939,
0.9526465535,
0.7604846954,
0.8619814515,
0.0931738168,
0.7653120756,
-0.0760736838,
0.4940728247,
-0.4108375609,
0.6041078568,
-0.6559684873,
0.1014207825,
-0.183405146,
-1.144505024,
-0.2093178779,
0.2003755271,
-0.5471900702,
-0.0859691426,
1.13852036,
0.4060477316,
-0.2092091143,
-0.0318806171,
0.4198591411,
-0.0135750072,
0.2557848096,
0.7478004098,
1.1692363024,
-0.3085614741,
0.9988680482,
-0.0265613943,
-0.2330520749,
-0.0893240869,
-0.632324636,
-0.6558454633,
-0.558009088,
-0.2623816729,
-0.4287873805,
0.0135641629,
0.5135504603,
0.6652721763,
-0.8318750262,
-0.2709349692,
0.0032367406,
0.08961384,
-0.4039995968,
-0.2149476707,
0.2864673734,
-0.6513103247,
-0.6884912252,
0.2921954095,
0.5064560771,
-0.2708998024,
-0.2913051248,
-0.1222627833,
0.1624708921,
-0.2832854986,
0.6076735258,
-0.1465595663,
-0.6703591347,
-0.2697294354,
0.3107847273,
-0.2843824327,
0.1549615711,
0.8241451979,
-0.4212956131,
0.5474459529,
0.5629267097,
0.6908758283,
0.173521325,
-0.0556890555,
0.7210446,
-0.4510467649,
-0.3563258052,
0.0759456307,
0.4403522611,
0.6023495197,
-0.0289486777,
0.5219957829,
0.1494138986,
-0.4845079482,
-0.7389839888,
0.0202326849,
-0.5957888961,
0.096619077,
1.0811094046,
-0.573695004,
-0.2638472617,
-0.0805766657,
0.0679172799,
0.1958942711,
-0.1854915172,
0.3791646957,
0.9442241192,
-0.2047761232,
0.1989148259,
-0.7837098837,
0.1692039371,
0.773542285,
-0.7928504944,
-0.1202939972,
0.27648893,
0.083481878,
0.6211482882,
0.1306473464,
-0.2060345262,
0.1700912714,
-0.1693073958,
-0.3633610904,
0.1839049309,
-0.1743602157,
-0.1817159653,
0.0022615453,
0.0343291014,
-0.4353807867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10264v1 | ReCode: Robustness Evaluation of Code Generation Models | 2022-12-20T14:11:31 | 2022-12-20T14:11:31 | Shiqi Wang, Zheng Li, Haifeng Qian, Chenghao Yang, Zijian Wang, Mingyue Shang, Varun Kumar, Samson Tan, Baishakhi Ray, Parminder Bhatia, Ramesh Nallapati, Murali Krishna Ramanathan, Dan Roth, Bing Xiang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SE | Code generation models have achieved impressive performance. However, they
tend to be brittle as slight edits to a prompt could lead to very different
generations; these robustness properties, critical for user experience when
deployed in real-life applications, are not well understood. Most existing
works on robustness in text or code tasks have focused on classification, while
robustness in generation tasks is an uncharted area and to date there is no
comprehensive benchmark for robustness in code generation. In this paper, we
propose ReCode, a comprehensive robustness evaluation benchmark for code
generation models. We customize over 30 transformations specifically for code
on docstrings, function and variable names, code syntax, and code format. They
are carefully designed to be natural in real-life coding practice, preserve the
original semantic meaning, and thus provide multifaceted assessments of a
model's robustness performance. With human annotators, we verified that over
90% of the perturbed prompts do not alter the semantic meaning of the original
prompt. In addition, we define robustness metrics for code generation models
considering the worst-case behavior under each type of perturbation, taking
advantage of the fact that executing the generated code can serve as objective
evaluation. We demonstrate ReCode on SOTA models using HumanEval, MBPP, as well
as function completion tasks derived from them. Interesting observations
include: better robustness for CodeGen over InCoder and GPT-J; models are most
sensitive to syntax perturbations; more challenging robustness evaluation on
MBPP over HumanEval. | [
-0.3941675127,
-0.6009304523,
0.1732416898,
0.1043907553,
-0.066945307,
0.0303170905,
-0.062496908,
-0.1543812752,
-0.41410622,
0.353947252,
-0.497854799,
-0.6488957405,
-0.244138509,
0.4536726475,
-0.4808498025,
1.0046215057,
0.1472142935,
-0.1493074894,
-0.3591268957,
-0.1199159995,
-0.7351185679,
-0.3579484522,
-0.0923313722,
-0.1565663368,
-0.0472491831,
0.2894473672,
0.6586689949,
0.4080751836,
0.581510365,
0.2528842688,
0.085843049,
-0.1177944392,
-0.5202428102,
0.3696126044,
-0.3296640813,
-0.2230373025,
-0.3894092739,
-0.2966778874,
0.4418076277,
0.4292936325,
-0.379031688,
0.342361778,
0.0701793209,
0.537586689,
-0.5537124276,
-0.0431961864,
-0.8003470302,
-0.0326523222,
0.1107276455,
-0.1979054809,
-0.53372401,
-0.6964623332,
-0.2581574321,
-0.2412594557,
0.6532516479,
-0.0952420086,
0.8966444731,
0.4281423986,
-0.0487557948,
-0.1628597975,
-0.5713666677,
0.7803096771,
-0.641427815,
0.6061347127,
0.0751443133,
0.315163821,
-0.3526705503,
-0.9979297519,
-0.4457981586,
-0.5504504442,
0.2448386699,
-0.1438083053,
-0.5192247033,
-0.0305124931,
0.6384940147,
0.4123302698,
-0.6310646534,
-0.1433885694,
-0.0265538413,
-0.3221980035,
0.4442187846,
0.3297198713,
0.3582164347,
-0.3751062155,
-0.4445368648,
-0.2187113017,
-0.9258180261,
0.0905641019,
0.528540194,
0.162769109,
-0.0801028535,
0.4934277833,
-0.0916270316,
0.7295086384,
0.184656024,
0.1469394267,
0.2740998864,
-0.8325191736,
-0.0478156768,
-0.5341687202,
0.5882399082,
0.6618377566,
0.2679184675,
-0.0722456798,
-0.3739232123,
0.2619149685,
0.8706615567,
-0.9290152192,
-0.4398801923,
0.2947891057,
-0.6903743148,
-0.7194856405,
-0.1674864441,
-0.958166182,
-0.4006339312,
0.2195994854,
-0.088724196,
-0.4200592041,
-0.358826369,
0.1914210767,
0.0556471422,
0.3751604259,
0.0333221592,
-0.922743082,
0.0120765371,
0.7675107718,
0.4851685464,
0.0062960717,
-0.2666771114,
-0.5688224435,
-0.5415986776,
-0.1941658407,
0.8396606445,
-0.5769872069,
-0.5499443412,
0.1343476325,
-0.0066244891,
0.134938553,
-0.5709523559,
0.6295189261,
-0.4327118099,
-0.2260551006,
-0.0679856986,
-0.2851388752,
0.0648987517,
0.3708605468,
-0.5136436224,
0.9050398469,
0.5771098137,
-1.0343804359,
0.5719475746,
-0.5103361607,
-0.2714647353,
-0.1159159541,
-0.25711748,
-0.6283568144,
0.1716145873,
0.0032942102,
0.2349939048,
-0.2753471136,
0.28171736,
-0.2286634743,
-0.0881856456,
0.3983720541,
-0.4204915166,
0.7828006148,
0.5778080821,
-0.1512911171,
0.3234039247,
-0.965115726,
0.1197870001,
0.2223463804,
-0.4597930908,
0.0025811209,
0.0542067327,
-0.0022069719,
-0.045636598,
0.0666161701,
-0.7378162146,
0.3676946163,
-0.4241303504,
0.6633023024,
0.4951224327,
0.2125464976,
0.2112677246,
-0.3923120201,
0.9117902517,
-0.2866513729,
0.178231895,
-0.4632078409,
-0.4055766761,
-0.1221632659,
-0.0488764942,
0.4714877605,
0.6191582084,
-0.6511875391,
0.3064920902,
-0.2669749558,
-0.515085876,
-0.251575917,
0.2092805356,
0.5884559155,
0.5706546903,
0.0882425085,
-0.4707710445,
-0.4847540855,
-0.6894238591,
-0.3414201736,
-0.1624260545,
-0.1791117042,
-0.0738325492,
0.5620393753,
-0.5738309622,
0.8115576506,
-0.4267063439,
0.5668447614,
-0.3905990422,
0.110867098,
0.2007054687,
0.6490261555,
0.6451410055,
-0.5388492346,
0.0461927764,
-0.182231009,
-0.4715548158,
-0.4104788005,
-0.3490237594,
-0.0611425079,
0.0484727547,
0.4008627236,
-0.4530484378,
0.4083243608,
0.4940760136,
-0.384029299,
0.9516457319,
-0.1557799876,
0.0875390843,
-0.9424853921,
0.4046781957,
-0.0961829871,
-0.3877269924,
-0.540394187,
0.7769799232,
0.1341883242,
-0.4459292293,
-0.3463843465,
0.0635414794,
-0.1472505778,
-0.1606861204,
-0.0039013128,
-0.0770200044,
0.1770566106,
0.2136302888,
-0.2654385865,
0.930211246,
0.2712545395,
-0.5131941438,
0.392233789,
0.2688993812,
-0.5407870412,
0.6987612844,
-0.9272938967,
0.3302064538,
0.105908379,
-0.1202058792,
-1.1371121407,
-0.1268752813,
-0.0473970138,
-0.7265978456,
0.4159408808,
-0.1222203001,
-0.5580861568,
-0.2454259992,
-0.5453376174,
0.5665655732,
0.4797777236,
-0.4348017573,
0.213508144,
0.0879596472,
-0.2131779194,
-0.494715035,
-0.4544220567,
0.0354139581,
-0.1873382926,
-0.847216785,
0.1340932697,
-0.1396772265,
-0.1608935148,
-0.2186706662,
-0.1061070189,
0.0636606589,
0.3560380936,
0.3983520269,
0.1952042431,
-0.0891678706,
-0.1574545205,
0.0370348804,
-0.3983831704,
0.1762247831,
0.057492476,
0.6113798022,
-0.1798506379,
-0.3614421487,
-0.1887552589,
0.3515984416,
0.686108768,
-0.4043135047,
0.1174688339,
0.3007997572,
-0.3250842392,
-0.1734259278,
-0.3231924772,
0.0153704993,
-0.4327243567,
0.462466687,
-0.4689088762,
-0.5780602098,
0.6184145212,
-0.2463615537,
0.5877487659,
0.2033176124,
0.4946885705,
0.1506609321,
1.0034294128,
0.624157846,
0.2774821222,
0.4358690977,
-0.3279545903,
0.1172777191,
-0.6615127921,
-0.024533255,
-0.8781560063,
0.1392078847,
-0.6460368037,
-0.1940069348,
-0.0359560512,
0.0290764961,
-0.4263920188,
0.723747611,
-0.8820161819,
0.21449323,
0.3023402989,
-0.2685280442,
0.2827721238,
0.0612275004,
-0.1043194905,
-0.104270719,
-0.6964688301,
-0.7043948174,
1.0314161777,
0.4932355881,
1.0182882547,
0.0833448023,
0.7185506225,
0.4947449565,
0.3537404537,
-0.3275437355,
0.4393417239,
0.082938917,
-0.4416294396,
0.1309724301,
-0.5605894327,
-1.0916062593,
-0.0565993227,
-0.3008747399,
-0.6121342778,
0.3756040335,
0.2651019394,
-0.656121552,
0.1134774983,
-0.6961123943,
1.1182528734,
-0.0392786935,
-0.3456285596,
-0.1121797189,
-0.4277422726,
0.3134374321,
-0.0789854676,
0.1522704661,
0.1820192635,
0.1239349768,
0.2678129077,
-0.4894852638,
0.6340289712,
-0.1467200071,
-0.2459842265,
0.3906098902,
0.5289721489,
0.4859099686,
0.1404266655,
-0.2757980227,
0.2317548096,
0.254950434,
-0.3065008819,
-0.4501237869,
0.6268558502,
-0.3276833594,
-0.3081745505,
-0.0116985207,
-0.3258764744,
-0.0159386899,
0.3707789779,
0.8046271801,
0.7681295276,
-0.1496365815,
0.1228141934,
0.5617853403,
-0.5767179132,
0.209234193,
0.1170483753,
-0.3987350464,
-0.611514926,
0.8022547364,
-0.2766932249,
0.4237827957,
0.1015195474,
-0.0706425086,
-0.4064558446,
-0.6926788688,
-0.6556688547,
-0.1886512637,
-0.6838261485,
-0.5060688853,
-0.268604815,
0.0751788095,
-0.3369687498,
-0.4774542153,
-0.3761076331,
-0.1536166221,
0.0561596677,
-0.3281813562,
0.0027627184,
0.7336591482,
0.0674375892,
-0.1031613424,
-0.8756886721,
0.3784353733,
0.1320980489,
0.5652853847,
-0.1833334863,
-0.4534292221,
0.1191395,
-0.1877484024,
-0.59266752,
-0.8813632727,
0.1321922392,
-0.0140991239,
0.4821418822,
0.3435129225,
0.3298406899,
0.2376795858,
-0.3041315675,
0.8386684656,
0.2530152202,
-0.884649992,
0.6357145309,
-0.3627044857,
0.3869543076,
0.8210408688,
-0.1659303755,
-0.0598781817,
-0.3996571898,
-0.6715742946,
-0.7001795173,
0.198168233,
0.2811110616,
0.4021046758,
-0.258510232,
0.42643857,
0.3136540055,
0.1814952493,
-0.6565733552,
-0.0137326792,
-0.5279371142,
-0.0891705602,
0.4175561965,
-0.5860792398,
0.1120497435,
0.0191820394,
-0.0086527457,
0.1301860064,
0.3491137326,
0.1432151645,
0.0031268497,
-0.0452295169,
0.4707181156,
0.7607176304,
0.7407410145,
-0.277559489,
0.1404178739,
0.2036190331,
-0.5496529341,
0.2520434856,
-0.0263781492,
-0.4330417216,
-0.0323134549,
0.5066563487,
0.3659785092,
0.3575643599,
-0.7109799385,
0.5323765874,
-0.3202550411,
-0.0004589766,
-0.1285191178,
0.2405126244,
-0.2890046537,
0.0664241612,
0.0224164054,
0.4522324204,
0.2038300037,
-0.4921285212,
0.336294651,
0.2631522417,
-0.0694976896,
-0.4956069887,
0.9234734178,
0.5997908115,
-0.4560647011,
0.6869013309,
-0.6084527373,
-0.379486531,
0.6200500131,
0.7502673268,
1.1686538458,
-0.1811414212,
-0.0909529105,
0.7051507235,
0.3982868791,
0.2099822909,
0.5053949952,
-0.2164011598,
-0.6944609284,
-0.2912821472,
-0.5987488031,
-0.1939225644,
-0.2183793336,
-0.725166142,
0.1849383712,
-0.7729023099,
-0.5772638917,
-0.1274484396,
-0.2775131166,
-0.5316761136,
-0.0679674521,
-0.2036948204,
1.2125954628,
-0.658835113,
0.4775744379,
0.869535327,
-0.3590357304,
-0.4827345908,
0.0158307459,
-0.1499426067,
-0.3648176193,
0.2160769105,
0.1878824383,
-0.2796884477,
-0.0403059721,
-0.5716679692,
-0.4524956644,
0.8184466362,
0.6500183344,
-0.5034084916,
0.2351951599,
-0.2975272536,
0.4032368064,
-0.2338145822,
0.0227817148,
0.5683223605,
0.118613705,
-0.1957509071,
-0.6877809167,
0.2064981163,
-0.3987075686,
0.3026945889,
0.2378501892,
-0.1294044107,
0.5892549753,
-0.5971317291,
-0.6404060721,
0.4532521367,
0.4601989686,
0.444359839,
0.4071063399,
0.4593741298,
0.4292305708,
0.5632420778,
-0.2012105435,
1.3280100822,
-0.6165181994,
0.4417157471,
0.886687696,
-0.2542427778,
0.7000520825,
0.0137233967,
-0.389403373,
0.5028145313,
0.3383095562,
-0.1663741916,
0.4096989334,
0.3214069903,
-0.019944055,
-0.2920278609,
0.0870948061,
-0.5439670682,
0.2107941508,
0.0383723788,
-0.2110570371,
-0.3650206625,
-0.111362502,
0.1180161387,
0.4290317297,
-0.0959565789,
0.4703563154,
-0.0754832551,
-0.6944951415,
0.7871630788,
0.1426154226,
0.5365166664,
-0.3712771535,
-0.3308788836,
-0.4446359277,
0.2024153322,
-0.5525671244,
-0.8947756886,
0.5463662148,
0.5577303171,
-0.2548683286,
-0.054664772,
0.7876181602,
0.207449168,
-0.3825105429,
-0.0414498299,
-0.1218046993,
0.0431949012,
0.2760676146,
-0.6631350517,
0.3162425756,
0.3275843263,
0.0222880617,
0.1309336275,
0.263599664,
0.1486985385,
0.817358911,
0.6171951294,
-0.1389426887,
0.1562367827,
-0.0040444536,
0.8064373136,
-0.8039847612,
-0.1803014427,
-0.7387419343,
0.6038770676,
0.0819716081,
-0.6120839715,
0.7568800449,
0.492955178,
0.8263686895,
-0.2209537029,
0.6805401444,
-0.2057463378,
0.2170318216,
-0.3408204317,
0.5690226555,
-0.0702170357,
0.4567368329,
-0.5922929049,
-1.0795792341,
-0.321154356,
0.691886127,
-0.0955589488,
0.1441754997,
0.2818497717,
0.9201965332,
0.1351205409,
-0.1412431151,
0.2782312334,
-0.0899194777,
0.4337925315,
0.5713381767,
0.9460914135,
-0.23197487,
0.5872237682,
-0.1843392998,
-0.2835330665,
-0.2081918418,
-1.0668907166,
-0.5321276784,
-0.4429157674,
-0.5271445513,
-0.5359060168,
-0.1952925026,
0.8116173744,
0.5469486117,
-0.8150737882,
0.0457003415,
-0.4340521693,
0.1816347688,
-0.3398866951,
-0.20751068,
0.0365358479,
-0.3925682008,
-0.2896965146,
0.2533827424,
0.1055880636,
-0.2394660562,
-0.3585419953,
0.0009009106,
0.3292916417,
0.0496869721,
0.5132654905,
0.5508143306,
-0.308616519,
-0.4861723781,
-0.0101803495,
-0.1690214276,
-0.0760245696,
0.8202175498,
-0.6461187005,
0.7926318645,
0.7842929959,
0.6020020843,
-0.1577555984,
0.4314168096,
0.568081975,
-0.6975765228,
-0.174706921,
0.1575341225,
0.4798591733,
0.440990597,
-0.2155030966,
0.5700272918,
0.0094206939,
-0.7884524465,
-1.204236865,
0.5881286263,
-0.7612406611,
0.079071939,
1.0179930925,
-0.3459180295,
-0.0088231452,
-0.1874798685,
-0.3117660582,
0.0686291754,
-0.2700671554,
0.8374650478,
0.4176377058,
-0.1228887588,
-0.1128669754,
-0.5960165262,
0.2614761591,
0.3120619655,
-0.53493011,
0.4488511682,
0.6506615281,
0.5768597126,
0.3468579352,
0.4477761984,
-0.3975982666,
0.5889480114,
0.4412317872,
0.4125171304,
-0.3947501183,
-0.1786873788,
-0.6605312228,
0.3365850151,
0.5892314911,
-0.336358279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10258v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10258v2 | In and Out-of-Domain Text Adversarial Robustness via Label Smoothing | 2022-12-20T14:06:50 | 2023-07-11T19:33:44 | Yahan Yang, Soham Dan, Dan Roth, Insup Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Recently it has been shown that state-of-the-art NLP models are vulnerable to
adversarial attacks, where the predictions of a model can be drastically
altered by slight modifications to the input (such as synonym substitutions).
While several defense techniques have been proposed, and adapted, to the
discrete nature of text adversarial attacks, the benefits of general-purpose
regularization methods such as label smoothing for language models, have not
been studied. In this paper, we study the adversarial robustness provided by
various label smoothing strategies in foundational models for diverse NLP tasks
in both in-domain and out-of-domain settings. Our experiments show that label
smoothing significantly improves adversarial robustness in pre-trained models
like BERT, against various popular attacks. We also analyze the relationship
between prediction confidence and robustness, showing that label smoothing
reduces over-confident errors on adversarial examples. | [
-0.7555187345,
-1.1826491356,
0.1343366206,
-0.1226863116,
-0.1085419804,
-0.0215515345,
-0.1913832128,
-0.5256876349,
-0.0179782324,
0.5367928147,
-0.1864370406,
-0.4195941091,
-1.0942291021,
-0.1808886975,
-0.4608605504,
1.3953261375,
0.1719963849,
-0.1350762099,
-0.26079458,
0.1245858669,
-0.3526158333,
-1.0568239689,
-0.6810826063,
-0.4107130468,
0.6077414155,
-0.3688500524,
1.3544440269,
0.3314445019,
0.6930773258,
0.2717704773,
-0.1793072671,
0.0919697508,
-0.5104621649,
0.4534502923,
-0.1553425789,
-0.3748381734,
-0.6707177758,
-0.0429566875,
0.5627421737,
0.5508034825,
0.2643298209,
-0.4384955764,
0.2469037771,
0.6976312399,
-0.7294145823,
-0.283272177,
-1.1149094105,
-0.2669129074,
-0.358930707,
0.0264325738,
-0.5308148861,
-0.286265105,
0.4008768797,
-0.6500416994,
0.2521337867,
-0.2033902109,
1.2629728317,
0.4880743027,
-0.2257362306,
-0.3040348887,
-0.6748971343,
0.7434974313,
-0.796336174,
0.1959666908,
0.7616912127,
0.101068899,
-0.8347333074,
-0.8521502614,
-0.1459323913,
-0.1745778471,
-0.1018599346,
0.1438396573,
-0.5398468971,
0.1805277914,
0.2529090643,
0.0324168392,
-0.5112881064,
0.2067001909,
0.3145098388,
-0.134127304,
0.4013676345,
-0.4969629049,
0.3873839378,
0.4411939085,
-0.5115110874,
-0.3638067842,
-0.6757265925,
0.1829604506,
0.5159398913,
0.3125618994,
0.3017102778,
0.2852490544,
0.1698706895,
1.0236467123,
-0.0841292441,
-0.2434652001,
-0.4093541503,
-0.1098570675,
-0.2557317913,
-0.1486078054,
0.5230007172,
0.2945808172,
0.3370967209,
-0.4656252861,
-0.3557465971,
0.3399968743,
0.4929683805,
-0.663911283,
-0.512622118,
0.2056596279,
-0.253616184,
-0.337317884,
0.0298054386,
-0.6981118917,
-0.5402197838,
0.1685674042,
0.572542727,
-0.5151527524,
0.2856684923,
0.0674033836,
-0.2358256429,
-0.2521916628,
0.2186275274,
-0.8630765676,
0.4560922384,
0.7306662202,
0.4816385806,
-0.1896681339,
0.0199110936,
-0.5637430549,
0.0053287311,
-0.2897218466,
0.6996212006,
-0.5830357671,
-0.5941175818,
-0.0205180366,
-0.3206926882,
-0.2547087371,
-0.3947901428,
0.7149860263,
-0.7797676921,
0.0841725692,
0.049123954,
-0.5391783714,
-0.392177552,
0.5088628531,
-0.7606476545,
1.0571149588,
-0.1793802232,
-1.0027612448,
0.3147047162,
-0.1962178797,
-0.6194425821,
-0.2250502855,
0.2526569963,
-0.758382678,
0.0270759054,
0.5534536242,
0.5543433428,
-0.0318083428,
0.158474654,
-0.5040890574,
-0.2794475853,
0.7637540698,
-0.7198752165,
0.6556508541,
-0.1060897484,
-0.2326767743,
-0.0693364963,
-0.5452237725,
0.1715456098,
0.0571497791,
-0.3427363932,
-0.8033470511,
0.1763618439,
-0.3036398888,
0.1615114063,
0.0828464851,
-0.3203298151,
0.291970104,
-0.7064219713,
0.2949046791,
0.549210608,
0.2058738768,
0.3385743499,
-0.5250124335,
0.3701545,
-0.3139395714,
0.2012504041,
-0.078618288,
-1.1404908895,
-0.5022196174,
-0.5500663519,
0.8799006939,
0.4929606915,
-1.0845620632,
0.377319634,
-0.0917353481,
-0.51078403,
-0.4191760719,
0.0044326708,
0.6167135835,
0.506767571,
0.4372886419,
-0.3889669478,
-0.1749924868,
-0.6261911988,
-0.5851333141,
-0.0992996246,
-0.1651898324,
-0.0358827673,
0.6108196378,
-0.3355856836,
0.8989792466,
-0.4658451974,
-0.2150413841,
0.1963377744,
0.2851068079,
-0.1328107715,
0.4462820292,
0.6779923439,
-1.1019766331,
-0.5729711056,
-0.2411495745,
-0.313760519,
0.1192960292,
-0.2205780149,
-0.1837433577,
0.1933991611,
0.3211230934,
-0.4432137311,
0.8121977448,
0.6329784393,
-0.0614668429,
0.2602925301,
-0.3243673444,
-0.0612763613,
-0.7340868115,
-0.224566862,
0.2551470995,
-0.336684078,
-1.1433454752,
0.251552552,
-0.1102292836,
-0.0408159941,
-0.4103265703,
0.3722184002,
0.0713582933,
0.1975616515,
-0.3807772696,
0.2047384679,
0.3676865101,
0.3839911222,
0.1028005034,
0.5390216708,
0.7679709196,
-0.8055286407,
0.0215876698,
0.1672421843,
-0.0226744842,
0.2896517515,
-0.6807627082,
0.2298275381,
-0.0664456487,
0.5495398641,
-0.860071063,
0.0839250088,
0.4409478903,
-0.6793829203,
0.9716371298,
-0.1879461259,
-0.4002028108,
-0.0356504321,
-0.4641186595,
0.0684157088,
0.4477542341,
-0.6418027878,
0.4215914011,
0.3747510612,
-0.1668162793,
-0.7728659511,
-0.7568349242,
0.2528474927,
-0.3025912941,
-0.4443534911,
0.6982219815,
-0.1918887496,
-0.3815043569,
-0.1264030039,
0.049987331,
-0.3320610821,
0.4366065562,
0.1632925123,
0.2156081051,
0.1166235432,
-0.1437264979,
-0.2171510011,
-0.1650643796,
-0.0312187187,
-0.4431356192,
0.2332483083,
-0.0721532926,
-0.2079946995,
-0.2065901011,
0.468516916,
0.3034524322,
-0.0610032864,
0.9405258894,
0.5367413759,
-0.6179803014,
-0.204587996,
-0.2092287391,
-0.2066120654,
-0.446483016,
0.2925202847,
-0.2622717619,
-0.460591495,
0.2936937511,
0.0234133396,
0.0834737718,
0.3793738484,
0.4520910084,
-0.1474778354,
1.1073098183,
0.6351302266,
-0.1484761387,
0.2878837883,
0.0609879829,
0.3036541939,
-0.5466450453,
-0.0667079017,
-0.7597769499,
-0.0452186577,
-0.7854912281,
-0.1519656926,
0.1598048657,
0.2729006112,
-0.0032338125,
0.3431091309,
-0.504576683,
0.1938710511,
0.8602499962,
0.1729406565,
0.0128142787,
0.1366899312,
0.1100862026,
-0.3573300242,
-0.8272764087,
-0.4555348456,
0.9684839249,
0.5429601669,
0.7618197203,
0.1838006824,
0.4175274074,
0.3809972405,
0.3585875034,
-0.7403957844,
0.2976964712,
-0.6869887114,
-0.6514821649,
-0.1516887248,
-0.1961884797,
-0.9483268261,
0.3504571021,
-0.6016356349,
-0.8267570734,
0.2854973078,
0.172410354,
-0.173724696,
0.5734462738,
-0.4534422159,
0.5412358046,
-0.2830323279,
0.1259243488,
0.5137202144,
-0.8260455728,
0.1010077372,
-0.6789183021,
0.2665145099,
0.2634408176,
0.0932758301,
0.7155606747,
-0.1893434376,
1.043587923,
0.0936118811,
-0.2674140334,
0.057144247,
0.0466422215,
0.6765660048,
-0.0548381358,
0.096661523,
0.2416562736,
-0.3820409775,
-0.4407207966,
-0.7013942003,
0.5984972119,
-0.5396808982,
-0.5067536831,
-0.4996588528,
-0.6094269753,
-0.5191268921,
0.1883170009,
0.7841401696,
0.5080154538,
-0.2307824045,
0.2305984497,
1.2357242107,
-0.3875405192,
0.5132219791,
0.2689729631,
0.2050791532,
-0.4061872065,
0.9582573175,
0.1448230594,
0.5340234041,
0.6857058406,
0.0304421932,
-0.4018861353,
-0.5045185685,
-0.2098591328,
-0.2753513753,
-0.818487823,
-0.4202513099,
-0.4612343907,
-0.0648644716,
-0.5556286573,
-0.513730526,
-0.2130228281,
-0.6576378942,
-0.1510836482,
0.2815719247,
0.2888116241,
0.5568509102,
0.2290103137,
0.5058244467,
-0.4963883758,
0.4880407751,
0.3573954403,
0.0471971333,
-0.2328596562,
-0.5159460902,
-0.254973501,
0.2490958571,
-0.4214238524,
-0.7761818171,
0.4694800973,
0.4135639071,
0.4103416204,
0.3094590902,
0.3209885657,
0.3323646188,
-0.4134160578,
0.7500175834,
0.1571737379,
-0.6930651665,
0.4158537388,
-0.3009500802,
0.2724663913,
0.251541853,
0.4808911681,
0.0117840096,
-0.6504299641,
-0.6900089979,
-1.0280182362,
0.3181938827,
0.4485953152,
-0.1736809909,
0.2050112635,
0.2957502007,
0.1851889491,
0.190551579,
-0.818459928,
-0.6652131677,
-0.4472725689,
0.1465976387,
-0.2288711965,
-0.1600685269,
-0.4336252213,
0.0657779425,
1.1142470837,
0.1042578369,
0.1706528068,
0.1033629924,
0.1312222779,
0.2890905142,
0.2965928316,
0.5912114978,
-0.0075857751,
-0.2173222899,
0.2312220931,
0.02968009,
-0.6585685611,
0.1091535389,
0.5140778422,
-0.6782054305,
0.0858071297,
0.4076757431,
0.7793137431,
0.1613146067,
-0.1617652774,
0.2683489323,
-0.3010446429,
-0.1429470628,
0.2657155395,
-0.1598153114,
-0.3907362521,
-0.1712160707,
0.1117661074,
0.5513585806,
0.1240784973,
-0.2202848196,
0.3360491395,
0.594938457,
-0.5207611918,
0.1064816415,
0.8288482428,
-0.2870245576,
-0.2234495282,
0.0831826553,
0.0975040793,
-0.7613743544,
0.5641317964,
0.800704062,
0.7818005681,
-0.1769316047,
0.1829372197,
-0.3447256982,
0.5601369739,
-0.0504983999,
-0.3068701923,
0.3112959266,
-0.6794071794,
-0.1678000242,
-0.3710601926,
-0.625543952,
0.18969284,
-0.7455239296,
-0.2792389393,
-0.3945373595,
-0.8540779948,
0.1438243389,
-0.0660801828,
-0.349471271,
0.7421383858,
0.2278884202,
0.6627932787,
-0.4975949228,
1.0231947899,
0.9462254047,
-0.0852586105,
-0.3097265363,
0.394738704,
-0.1264309734,
-0.2826824486,
0.4728604853,
-0.0650185496,
-0.4521718323,
-0.2558141649,
-0.3851080537,
-0.8663024902,
0.3304897249,
0.2752614617,
-0.1139196604,
0.2240903527,
0.1717939526,
0.5619345307,
-0.0731811896,
-0.1410248578,
0.5236272812,
0.4370430708,
-0.2506920099,
-0.5995664597,
-0.0551817976,
-0.2148546875,
0.1544374973,
0.2408253253,
-0.3485237956,
0.633128643,
0.2418010533,
0.0607017875,
0.1804137081,
0.6976566911,
-0.080967024,
0.2770121694,
0.328255415,
0.6019417048,
0.7519240379,
-0.5868089795,
1.2362109423,
-0.2293734252,
0.0469776317,
0.966994524,
0.0047345627,
0.642103672,
0.0628257394,
0.1022611633,
0.3565474153,
0.6794120669,
-0.0329128504,
0.7225555182,
0.0655942932,
-0.2177631706,
0.0294167791,
-0.0716910139,
-0.4919889569,
0.0601681918,
0.7214511633,
0.0684538186,
0.0005066304,
0.1772684753,
0.493050158,
0.3272315562,
-0.4205158055,
0.5583443046,
0.1360308826,
-0.7491167188,
0.9073156714,
0.234121263,
0.9034799933,
-0.9134332538,
0.257771343,
0.138951093,
0.4547570944,
-0.1116765514,
-0.5148983598,
0.0424141549,
-0.1050810739,
-0.252123028,
-0.1825430393,
1.1009298563,
-0.3766262829,
-0.1343467832,
0.3804614544,
-0.0814589933,
-0.1734127551,
-0.1992065758,
-0.9268099666,
-0.0446316414,
-0.1673186421,
-0.3552697301,
0.822145462,
0.075252153,
-0.0139637087,
0.8413905501,
0.5124508142,
0.1359870881,
0.1195235476,
-0.0287766773,
0.9196658134,
-0.0948531777,
-0.4053184092,
-0.8074002862,
0.3235597908,
-0.0722573623,
-0.2964399755,
1.092053175,
0.1867875606,
0.7857923508,
0.0427118838,
0.832608223,
0.339943707,
0.4083486199,
-0.6207131743,
0.7421917319,
-0.3241969645,
0.1576370299,
-0.4923543334,
-0.680870831,
-0.7492978573,
0.3122241199,
-0.2097541243,
0.0392480046,
0.5920921564,
0.5375363827,
0.3835205138,
-0.0869270489,
0.5087166429,
0.0724601895,
0.4043907523,
0.3008663058,
0.4236491024,
-0.6351884604,
0.5280502439,
-0.4951195121,
-0.2972365618,
0.1146155223,
-0.9363877177,
-1.1945570707,
-0.3087896705,
-0.54658705,
-0.6757273078,
0.4601921141,
0.2044592947,
0.6625173688,
-1.0181657076,
0.3505271673,
0.2466334552,
0.0765433386,
-0.2934574485,
-0.1855165958,
0.5648886561,
-0.2801059484,
-0.6883877516,
0.6862232089,
0.1029562652,
0.5181244016,
0.0616462752,
0.2613895237,
-0.1955237389,
0.5279852748,
0.3773273528,
0.4218576252,
-0.581664145,
-0.0847243071,
-0.2595761716,
-0.1125460044,
-0.1444753259,
0.6693584919,
-0.7312040329,
0.691421926,
0.2186145037,
0.6975536346,
0.0171046183,
0.4079711437,
0.707038641,
-1.1330354214,
0.3106892407,
0.1985973865,
0.3181205988,
0.482760489,
-0.6157249808,
0.3184816539,
0.0985865444,
-0.6943309903,
-0.7699406147,
0.4242653847,
-0.5320882797,
-0.7142877579,
0.8623298407,
-0.5547696352,
0.0286547244,
-0.3974751532,
-0.1738987565,
0.144010514,
-0.2893310785,
0.7139269114,
0.7932053208,
0.2227371782,
0.6191233397,
-0.6402882934,
0.950801909,
0.2340867519,
-0.5566506982,
-0.2047840953,
-0.0070218062,
-0.2709292471,
0.2392458171,
0.2536209226,
0.0439354926,
-0.0609687269,
0.0555754676,
-0.3829090893,
0.0950492248,
-0.4988976717,
-0.3008877635,
0.2104213536,
-0.0292663481,
-0.1437415928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10257v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10257v1 | Original or Translated? On the Use of Parallel Data for Translation Quality Estimation | 2022-12-20T14:06:45 | 2022-12-20T14:06:45 | Baopu Qiu, Liang Ding, Di Wu, Lin Shang, Yibing Zhan, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine Translation Quality Estimation (QE) is the task of evaluating
translation output in the absence of human-written references. Due to the
scarcity of human-labeled QE data, previous works attempted to utilize the
abundant unlabeled parallel corpora to produce additional training data with
pseudo labels. In this paper, we demonstrate a significant gap between parallel
data and real QE data: for QE data, it is strictly guaranteed that the source
side is original texts and the target side is translated (namely
translationese). However, for parallel data, it is indiscriminate and the
translationese may occur on either source or target side. We compare the impact
of parallel data with different translation directions in QE data augmentation,
and find that using the source-original part of parallel corpus consistently
outperforms its target-original counterpart. Moreover, since the WMT corpus
lacks direction information for each parallel sentence, we train a classifier
to distinguish source- and target-original bitext, and carry out an analysis of
their difference in both style and domain. Together, these findings suggest
using source-original parallel data for QE data augmentation, which brings a
relative improvement of up to 4.0% and 6.4% compared to undifferentiated data
on sentence- and word-level QE tasks respectively. | [
-0.4320400953,
-0.3183044493,
0.6846984625,
0.0358987972,
-0.4357549548,
0.1256205291,
-0.0932709351,
-0.379118979,
0.4205837846,
0.5137870312,
-0.3822445571,
-0.6236189008,
-0.731531322,
0.34553653,
-0.3031188548,
0.8309516907,
-0.3178969026,
0.3725284338,
-0.4627129138,
-0.4698262811,
-0.6502565742,
-0.5923010707,
-0.3242502511,
0.1151155829,
0.4474627972,
0.5285481811,
1.0865489244,
0.8768966794,
0.4263006747,
0.3415157795,
0.2430105805,
0.240500018,
-0.5610282421,
-0.1898443699,
-0.3872517943,
-0.6041704416,
-0.2124354243,
0.2420049757,
0.7064419985,
0.7166819572,
0.2130851597,
0.1948219836,
0.1242449507,
0.9213709831,
-0.5190593004,
-0.0114563694,
-0.3249293566,
0.2126799673,
-0.3169300258,
-0.0684460774,
0.0053757471,
-0.4616605341,
-0.021345742,
-0.5121559501,
0.2540842295,
0.236781165,
0.9903250933,
0.3158636987,
-0.2474844009,
-0.0916955322,
-0.7281205654,
0.8355810642,
-0.7745701075,
0.5647729635,
0.1828988343,
0.3668515384,
-0.175801456,
-0.8501887918,
-0.6152610779,
-0.065487586,
-0.1320121437,
0.1832583398,
-0.261757344,
-0.2843041718,
0.1806154251,
0.7608516216,
-0.6689504981,
0.203801021,
-0.3408470154,
-0.199904412,
0.5211772919,
0.1865064204,
0.4954969287,
-0.0033487983,
-0.5543351173,
-0.4931762815,
-0.6851103306,
0.206007883,
0.3719299138,
-0.0082381349,
0.0765025467,
0.621157825,
-0.3731186688,
0.4393040836,
-0.0637204573,
-0.0597991534,
0.5751786232,
-0.6209158897,
-0.2344310284,
-0.0974423364,
1.1290498972,
0.3381165266,
0.1897690743,
-0.4423946738,
-0.346678853,
-0.2065535039,
0.1989256293,
-0.6409586072,
-0.0616543032,
0.1086891443,
-0.2768626809,
0.1187061816,
0.5145424008,
-0.5120021105,
-0.0330184139,
-0.6570438147,
0.2709673345,
-0.3232576847,
0.0887393132,
0.019746596,
-0.1988588125,
-0.1003020182,
-0.0691514313,
-0.3332112432,
0.1452545077,
0.4303280413,
0.6747993231,
-0.284919858,
-0.4594176412,
-0.480668962,
-0.0682214424,
-0.3395984769,
0.8245307207,
-0.2026408613,
-0.3688179255,
-0.2899127305,
0.2655522823,
-0.1286110878,
-0.7480217814,
1.111356616,
-0.4644142091,
0.4037151039,
-0.4446527064,
-0.69016397,
-0.1977047771,
-0.2464956194,
-0.7221878767,
0.7528830767,
0.2022272944,
-1.0161988735,
0.4441037476,
0.0513453633,
-0.1128618717,
-0.1136213467,
-0.310469836,
-0.5314867496,
0.3548392653,
0.5676101446,
-0.1266416311,
-0.4869689941,
0.2707214952,
-0.2472222745,
-0.5127316713,
0.419256568,
-0.566857338,
0.6512260437,
0.1370808929,
-0.0493375026,
0.1818902642,
-0.5318078399,
-0.0268462971,
0.1584916562,
-0.1535930485,
-0.5302730203,
0.0082258163,
-0.0856713653,
0.3199288547,
0.3269076943,
-1.0616813898,
-0.0670497119,
-0.5245960951,
-0.0551839992,
0.3556288779,
0.0172181353,
0.3544900715,
-0.4193964601,
0.4767741263,
0.2734135389,
0.1929961592,
0.03171812,
-0.5509527922,
-0.3290934265,
-0.2244853675,
0.8233080506,
0.6144444346,
-0.9254387617,
0.2024995238,
-0.6187454462,
-0.3522396088,
-1.1620414257,
0.2210056782,
0.3384816945,
0.4970553219,
0.5301403403,
-0.3230336905,
-0.5573598146,
-1.1196427345,
-0.5165939927,
-0.0331135355,
-0.34849751,
-0.1252962798,
-0.0630004406,
-0.0734619051,
0.9985217452,
-0.4183836281,
-0.0973014086,
-0.0128889484,
0.1498984843,
0.085957855,
0.7469975948,
0.4047961533,
-0.7539126873,
-0.6958250403,
-0.0758957788,
-1.0907429457,
-0.3359696269,
-0.1143937781,
-0.4521856606,
-0.1239877567,
0.3062474728,
-0.4387529492,
0.3383156061,
0.5663446784,
-0.0016751216,
0.5473445058,
-0.2835968435,
0.5989707112,
-1.0187520981,
-0.2339241356,
0.0586403385,
-0.2160566449,
-0.4978661835,
0.0148055023,
0.4594463408,
-0.0514476635,
-0.4234293401,
0.1891751438,
-0.4178643525,
-0.0446355455,
-0.5820474029,
0.1837856323,
0.2445456982,
0.3677073717,
-0.051532682,
1.0161252022,
0.3702714443,
-0.0095289908,
0.2567742765,
0.2837402225,
-0.5776525736,
0.4797828794,
-0.7259427905,
0.2745433152,
-0.3212653995,
-0.1165727153,
-0.7939076424,
0.1253737062,
0.3552127182,
-0.52310884,
0.2946997583,
-0.0040341676,
-0.6753578186,
-0.4431112409,
-0.1336228251,
0.5325533152,
0.6811730862,
-0.6523439288,
-0.2739831507,
0.3474452198,
-0.1582739651,
-0.3913092315,
-0.5858374238,
0.1871102154,
-0.1234879866,
-0.7118755579,
0.4480564594,
0.2089253366,
-0.0039440258,
0.406576246,
-0.333016634,
-0.3160122037,
-0.3623948991,
0.1994429976,
0.1270994395,
-0.4956034124,
-0.1132576242,
0.4765012562,
-0.0212738961,
0.1249122992,
-0.2696936131,
-0.0355243869,
0.3178887665,
-0.4110009074,
-0.7869737744,
0.5964159966,
0.5113286376,
-0.2459686399,
0.8874961734,
0.6260116696,
-0.0367568545,
0.1551040262,
-0.5296150446,
-0.063743405,
-0.4139326513,
0.1194327846,
-0.5159580708,
-0.6044173241,
0.2668625414,
0.2069845647,
-0.1640498042,
0.4974932969,
-0.029215334,
-0.3056090474,
1.0829619169,
0.5154573917,
-0.1046110317,
0.3185404837,
-0.0134934112,
0.104060553,
-0.7698798776,
-0.0191536341,
-0.4722600579,
-0.3626899123,
-0.7095911503,
-0.4623437226,
0.3836233318,
0.576610446,
0.1047247648,
0.6280342937,
-0.2665235996,
0.0915356576,
0.769944787,
0.2140672952,
0.5305478573,
0.2538368106,
0.2253838181,
-0.5180868506,
-0.7427289486,
-0.4764200747,
1.0976239443,
0.3425837159,
0.187845856,
-0.2157438248,
0.6278501153,
0.2121415138,
0.3116256893,
-0.5230763555,
0.2696240544,
-0.175798133,
-0.1236540824,
-0.0863094777,
-0.7664707303,
-1.0346210003,
0.5976806879,
-0.1504564583,
-0.1803862005,
0.4833404422,
0.0362304747,
0.0527817719,
0.325602293,
-0.7121597528,
1.0320979357,
0.0424927324,
-0.1843344569,
-0.118770428,
-0.3533819616,
0.3049997389,
-0.3740828335,
0.1744160056,
-0.1529188603,
-0.0499911271,
0.7648812532,
-0.810331285,
0.3629452288,
-0.1157536954,
0.1603998393,
0.6251446009,
-0.2708614171,
0.8026583195,
0.0187704302,
-0.0493384749,
0.466581732,
0.1717883348,
-0.8605995774,
-0.7902635932,
0.8125463724,
-0.7145704627,
-0.9097037315,
-0.2907562554,
-0.7403283119,
-0.5359639525,
0.0904878154,
0.3057356775,
0.2723682821,
-0.1759142131,
-0.0077023162,
0.0372442789,
-0.3443550467,
0.2432108372,
0.6743199229,
0.2490345836,
-0.6341209412,
1.0976877213,
0.2297079414,
0.2003354281,
0.3425349593,
0.2000635117,
-0.4760916233,
-0.7121013403,
-0.7782624364,
0.509911716,
-0.3284953237,
-0.0932513401,
-0.5021678805,
-0.0535719097,
-0.332100451,
0.2389145643,
-0.5174052119,
-0.3509343266,
0.0680423379,
0.0082806963,
0.154764995,
0.45775491,
0.0670204088,
0.2765118778,
-1.272039175,
0.1410236359,
0.0209543351,
-0.0469177812,
-0.3926603496,
-0.6174337268,
-0.5996111631,
0.5983475447,
-0.0621498153,
-1.0341948271,
0.570767343,
-0.367583096,
0.6478530169,
-0.1139148548,
0.2391590774,
0.5425674319,
-0.4832639992,
0.5069500804,
0.1867791712,
-0.6226358414,
0.1313912421,
-0.0673119947,
0.5140321851,
0.69516927,
0.5207393765,
-0.3421260118,
-0.6306775212,
-0.5113281608,
-0.6110297441,
0.5091536045,
0.5934957266,
-0.184503749,
0.0637127385,
0.1981221586,
0.2601309419,
0.5119972825,
-0.2490687966,
-0.1849724948,
-0.2254309356,
-0.387216568,
-0.1042195484,
-0.1511373669,
0.3591987491,
-0.1659731716,
0.3666798174,
0.300991416,
0.1505500227,
0.388423264,
-0.1172324494,
-0.0273917206,
0.2229947001,
0.1663308442,
0.5477423072,
-0.2623294294,
0.0194310974,
-0.0998970345,
-0.4341130853,
0.0538873821,
-0.0295172203,
-0.2960951328,
0.4270299077,
-0.0106445383,
0.9798240066,
-0.1996078044,
-0.6943429708,
0.5471565127,
0.2678778768,
0.0824939832,
-0.028111618,
-0.4493377805,
-0.1382602751,
0.0719247684,
-0.0400055125,
0.2536970377,
0.3312874734,
-0.3390330374,
0.2641367316,
0.0540209077,
-0.5067358613,
-0.4101562202,
0.6585636139,
0.0033323502,
0.0675118417,
0.6530795097,
-0.2827786505,
-0.0456804894,
0.5118182898,
0.4391909242,
0.8492259979,
-0.3013447821,
0.1971031278,
0.5278794169,
0.3973862827,
-0.1046350375,
0.0872652382,
0.1659861803,
-0.5494714975,
-0.76045084,
-0.540935576,
-0.1220425069,
-0.0511981249,
-0.8796562552,
-0.0202323813,
0.1442645639,
-0.0298069958,
-0.1635087281,
-0.4456778169,
-0.6355868578,
0.1780393124,
-0.094767198,
0.6436898112,
-0.8907583952,
1.182615757,
0.6669905186,
-0.6631906033,
-0.5460754633,
0.1973051727,
-0.2542857528,
-0.6286664009,
0.5167707801,
-0.1417161673,
0.0753736421,
0.0835901573,
-0.0017292073,
-0.986066699,
0.6709970236,
0.4361451268,
-0.5904709697,
0.0863233879,
0.6045661569,
0.6788567305,
-0.1419626027,
-0.0282258298,
0.494723171,
0.299900353,
-0.288086921,
-0.834332943,
0.1220051348,
-0.0586994141,
0.2734140158,
0.4523807168,
-0.3030875921,
0.6228302717,
0.1487906873,
-0.5343328118,
-0.0486940555,
0.8021791577,
-0.1396237165,
0.2992334068,
0.3846852779,
0.5672076344,
0.4053199887,
0.0013504241,
1.20847404,
-0.2171051651,
0.1172153428,
1.2042731047,
0.1802413315,
0.8283308744,
0.4809409976,
-0.3217644691,
0.2640823424,
0.5113010406,
-0.0071513299,
0.3552372754,
-0.1614194512,
-0.1550009996,
0.1328059733,
-0.1778037548,
-0.2513439357,
-0.0049413298,
0.1877405196,
-0.4085775018,
-0.0898524523,
0.359511137,
0.011653902,
0.5081405044,
-0.1338805258,
0.621425271,
0.1909964979,
-0.660443306,
0.7987567186,
0.114419736,
0.2156094164,
-0.0081847021,
0.2326176167,
-0.5770759583,
-0.1274429262,
-0.1920285523,
-0.8808932304,
0.7077787519,
-0.1341371089,
-0.4658660293,
-0.0265421029,
0.124926433,
-0.6690798998,
-0.4515617788,
0.0600156114,
0.7189945579,
0.434827745,
-0.5062584281,
-0.604234755,
0.0459380187,
0.1726471931,
0.0549379401,
0.5518158078,
0.5001187921,
-0.1147884727,
0.1949280947,
0.4767848253,
0.1470512301,
0.1571695507,
-0.0925909206,
0.6635355949,
-0.6821488142,
-0.2558127642,
-0.4235906303,
0.4568927288,
-0.36047405,
-0.1544737965,
1.1497231722,
0.7011000514,
1.1063899994,
-0.2780537009,
0.5863876343,
0.3342565,
0.765509665,
-0.5005159378,
0.2170258909,
-0.5574204326,
0.2332483083,
-0.015376281,
-1.0569005013,
0.0719859898,
-0.0806455165,
-0.5391077995,
-0.4191117585,
1.0824763775,
0.7626335621,
-0.2908785641,
0.0088305986,
0.4570685923,
0.0287628099,
-0.1915459484,
0.5116831064,
0.5723261237,
-0.8522861004,
0.6287477612,
-0.5408264399,
-0.1352429539,
0.1739297509,
-0.1218712553,
-0.4825705886,
-0.4702481329,
-0.5988395214,
-0.1408328563,
0.08283218,
0.6668000817,
0.2704150081,
-1.0494930744,
-0.2431983054,
-0.3160138726,
0.0677674115,
-0.5901098847,
-0.1675904989,
0.5205450654,
-0.4334872365,
-1.3233456612,
0.7731657624,
0.1140972972,
0.2132487148,
0.186216563,
0.0888167992,
0.2292906046,
-0.1065676436,
0.3890014291,
0.5499501824,
-0.6182637811,
-0.0030971179,
-0.1255251467,
-0.3682124615,
0.3644837439,
0.7807458639,
-0.6549091935,
0.6506547928,
0.7296933532,
0.87545228,
0.4247552156,
0.4194936454,
0.8900157809,
-0.5100248456,
0.3880327642,
0.0344267376,
0.3457525671,
0.2910719812,
-0.1644752175,
0.252951771,
0.5507416129,
-0.5292534828,
-0.653437376,
0.065325588,
-0.8990673423,
-0.3704156876,
0.8324916363,
-0.4502545595,
-0.3222109377,
-0.036872372,
-0.3555219173,
0.3549127579,
-0.2796440125,
0.4827134609,
0.2412287146,
0.0755268261,
-0.0853334591,
-0.855728209,
0.4150573015,
0.5871997476,
-0.5516870022,
-0.4718382657,
0.5318106413,
0.1028317362,
-0.0624687225,
0.1849130541,
-0.3018915355,
-0.0204041116,
0.2825543582,
0.2329806834,
-0.1169933602,
0.0541127771,
-0.0799057186,
0.3790495694,
0.0542157292,
-0.7869839668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10240v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10240v2 | Diffusion Glancing Transformer for Parallel Sequence to Sequence Learning | 2022-12-20T13:36:25 | 2023-11-29T08:30:34 | Lihua Qian, Mingxuan Wang, Yang Liu, Hao Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previously, non-autoregressive models were widely perceived as being superior
in generation efficiency but inferior in generation quality due to the
difficulties of modeling multiple target modalities. To enhance the
multi-modality modeling ability, we propose the diffusion glancing transformer,
which employs a modality diffusion process and residual glancing sampling. The
modality diffusion process is a discrete process that interpolates the
multi-modal distribution along the decoding steps, and the residual glancing
sampling approach guides the model to continuously learn the remaining
modalities across the layers. Experimental results on various machine
translation and text generation benchmarks demonstrate that DIFFGLAT achieves
better generation accuracy while maintaining fast decoding speed compared with
both autoregressive and non-autoregressive models. | [
-0.5281639099,
-0.6532976627,
0.4586095214,
0.2921910286,
-0.3151751459,
0.1742630452,
0.249291271,
-0.0248332862,
-0.0119585572,
0.2883906066,
-0.4234349132,
-0.0485452339,
-0.9508074522,
0.1068422273,
-0.6386194825,
0.777959466,
0.0868531764,
0.1769220829,
0.2777736783,
0.1313658655,
-0.2869348824,
0.0871174783,
-0.7446554303,
-0.5042504072,
0.3830160499,
0.2357380986,
0.6435723305,
0.2186049074,
0.1645656824,
0.3444738388,
0.1063048616,
0.0352867059,
-0.4802218378,
0.2369975895,
-0.0903903097,
-0.3052506149,
-0.220926702,
-0.1202080175,
0.9264749289,
0.6294602752,
-0.5350264311,
0.22370781,
0.1799770445,
0.8865783215,
-0.420560509,
-0.2037140727,
-0.4283868372,
-0.0467711985,
-0.2562550306,
-0.4531603456,
-0.663991034,
-0.5234457254,
-0.0240457095,
-0.2331642956,
0.821932435,
0.035104569,
0.3912005424,
0.4429892898,
-0.7729927897,
-0.0267889593,
-0.9184783697,
0.6776335239,
-0.6112267375,
0.6151070595,
0.0555828847,
0.5532470345,
0.0823578089,
-0.8366461992,
-0.7143669724,
-0.0577228107,
-0.0495502055,
0.3346916437,
-0.2974978089,
-0.2250154912,
0.418961376,
0.4838655591,
-0.6672599912,
-0.1637097299,
-0.2815778553,
-0.1561253071,
0.451056242,
0.30197981,
-0.1049931496,
-0.3895201981,
-0.6101692319,
-0.3192919195,
-0.2526162565,
-0.0166631732,
0.5596128702,
-0.1345514208,
-0.0539816245,
0.2113064528,
-0.0930276141,
0.6710817218,
0.6181880832,
-0.3670084178,
0.5904593468,
-0.5037406683,
-0.1495841295,
-0.255307883,
0.7825513482,
0.0308683328,
-0.3565035462,
0.0518629849,
-0.332437247,
-0.2076988071,
0.4688180983,
-0.7747849226,
-0.3527536392,
-0.1525337696,
-0.7109678388,
-0.0549154058,
0.0766961426,
-1.0268813372,
0.0865550339,
-0.2999179661,
0.2630614638,
-0.602974534,
-0.5361045003,
0.1223707348,
-0.4680396318,
0.0634828284,
0.43298769,
-0.7056385875,
0.1305376738,
0.08619041,
0.9679140449,
-0.1757366359,
-0.3001963794,
-0.4627880156,
0.0161243174,
-0.0716038495,
0.880622983,
-0.5714144111,
-0.798907876,
-0.2722431123,
0.0205290392,
-0.4775011837,
-0.523231566,
0.3900008202,
-0.6687486172,
0.3308907151,
-0.2289692909,
-0.2264378816,
-0.4422994256,
-0.1223840564,
-0.7835131288,
1.2297377586,
0.5033663511,
-0.6882044077,
0.5383765697,
-0.3999073505,
-0.5587366819,
0.0931549147,
0.2160207778,
-0.5031893253,
0.3228207231,
0.1740601361,
0.5520211458,
-0.2805052698,
0.3447811306,
0.0142431352,
-0.190983668,
0.018353479,
-0.9299752712,
0.5817881823,
0.4200386405,
-0.484343648,
-0.0552342832,
-0.7943270206,
-0.4736462831,
-0.0669593439,
-0.4325040281,
-0.2154522985,
-0.1268876344,
0.4172898531,
0.5517719388,
-0.1695176512,
-0.3654774725,
0.1816997677,
-0.0057932311,
0.2325873822,
0.6758853197,
0.2049398869,
0.6781964898,
-0.467772007,
0.6257245541,
0.5475454926,
0.3272708952,
-0.3966473937,
-0.6019223332,
-0.8378686905,
-0.3619625568,
0.088185899,
0.4223248363,
-1.3782550097,
0.1701804996,
-0.1736159176,
-0.4097542465,
-0.3650358021,
-0.0274298377,
0.2606045008,
0.7741831541,
0.6249188185,
-0.4582367241,
-0.0378873572,
-0.7273101807,
-0.0244281217,
0.1031867936,
0.0730072409,
0.2232480794,
0.3135885,
-0.2974135578,
0.6325063705,
-0.3932403624,
-0.0374165624,
-0.3278161585,
0.7580407858,
0.1740161777,
0.3113584816,
0.5524610281,
-1.0030686855,
-0.8854129314,
-0.23897852,
-0.3446610868,
-0.1828276366,
-0.4114877284,
-0.1510817558,
0.1697324216,
0.5035854578,
-0.3531864285,
0.2840494514,
0.5812989473,
-0.2209299952,
0.3171446919,
0.0197618976,
0.3818950057,
-1.3248701096,
0.2925611436,
0.2496443242,
-0.4498040378,
-0.7407441735,
-0.2714779973,
0.2858995795,
0.2069970965,
-0.51923877,
0.3112640083,
-0.6969293952,
0.0821311027,
-0.4063491821,
-0.1189946383,
0.083258532,
0.1995056719,
0.125913769,
1.0641335249,
0.6348066926,
-0.8457329273,
0.0170640722,
0.1622175127,
-0.2329754978,
0.780081749,
-0.4955277145,
-0.1377557963,
-0.5000064373,
0.3719453812,
-1.0553792715,
-0.0700920075,
0.0349744186,
-0.2654438615,
0.463826865,
-0.0123654557,
-0.2630614638,
-0.6388884187,
-0.1665963233,
0.5362383127,
0.8775330186,
-0.6221817732,
0.7321524024,
-0.0223852564,
-0.1580386013,
-0.6910129189,
-0.4645011425,
-0.1362327933,
-0.1948603094,
-0.3891918361,
0.3164674044,
-0.0443230607,
0.0750525519,
-0.3546066582,
0.1526176482,
0.0573788062,
-0.1376447678,
0.0414871648,
0.1281023771,
0.0613068491,
-0.017071275,
0.397685349,
-0.3278274238,
-0.2032449245,
-0.2140118629,
0.7011737227,
0.5165206194,
-0.5877630115,
-0.3720833063,
0.4331101477,
0.546346724,
-0.0680353418,
0.4729668796,
0.9805083871,
0.2101419866,
-0.5600472689,
-0.730504632,
-0.2700769007,
-0.5359940529,
0.1656803936,
-0.4035807848,
-0.6149411798,
0.3990395665,
-0.3810903132,
-0.1190719604,
0.4957499802,
0.6792449355,
0.1737419069,
0.9533242583,
0.8088085055,
-0.038750276,
0.7117573023,
-0.2350993901,
0.2005819529,
-0.819326818,
-0.2284265906,
-0.2415034622,
-0.3398863673,
-0.0905775279,
-0.7903730869,
0.5953952074,
0.3034372926,
0.0437243953,
0.3386614025,
-0.6059859395,
0.1320584267,
0.7795600891,
0.1805441827,
0.5991988182,
0.0285236202,
-0.2086492181,
0.1183741167,
-0.5549649,
-0.2923503816,
0.82611233,
0.2653075457,
0.9136907458,
0.3036150634,
0.7917094827,
0.4230028689,
0.3611072898,
-0.6832992435,
0.2632534206,
0.026440328,
-0.3186350465,
-0.1738254428,
-0.458124429,
-0.7496260405,
0.3370129764,
0.126796037,
-0.0173540171,
0.6374388337,
0.1962453127,
-0.0812935531,
0.2814150751,
-0.3752102852,
0.4298870265,
0.1879789829,
-0.1634918749,
-0.2302201688,
-0.5637252927,
0.583568275,
-0.2703737319,
-0.0404818356,
0.1743227988,
0.1186567917,
0.230129838,
-0.2100506127,
0.8370054364,
-0.4572758377,
-0.1162671298,
0.3264168501,
0.2164143622,
0.5451102257,
0.1670196801,
-0.0354647487,
0.2688374221,
-0.4306735098,
-0.3975349069,
-0.2178954482,
0.3543977141,
-0.3977711499,
-0.4889510274,
-0.3857184947,
-0.3977937698,
-0.0233067945,
0.2878936231,
0.6265521049,
0.2681396604,
-0.1724707186,
-0.2684932053,
0.7825332284,
0.0055969041,
1.0565574169,
0.6564511061,
0.035646271,
-0.4158533216,
0.7738042474,
-0.0705915764,
0.6637350321,
0.3716473579,
-0.0021336626,
-0.3908924162,
-0.6450859308,
-0.6033347249,
0.3663740754,
-0.6450014114,
-0.2109019905,
-0.9360633492,
-0.0656557158,
-0.378241837,
-0.0986710712,
-0.1535432786,
-0.194612667,
-0.3346360922,
0.0198885314,
0.3171026707,
0.8371142745,
-0.2767026126,
0.5534033775,
-1.0256215334,
0.4872660637,
0.3186220825,
0.0590734929,
0.2937136292,
-0.8353725672,
-0.0490442291,
-0.1567070335,
-0.6896106005,
-0.787817359,
0.7089865804,
0.2591621578,
0.6577093005,
0.3356091082,
-0.1983287185,
0.6871111393,
-0.8387113214,
0.8369665146,
0.4567795992,
-1.0442095995,
0.3649804294,
-0.3514842987,
0.6314529777,
0.3845075965,
0.7188029289,
-0.5314284563,
-0.3148761988,
-0.343931824,
-0.6850464344,
0.5464408994,
-0.1551329195,
0.0421117768,
-0.3402421474,
0.3016532362,
0.5619472265,
0.2034060806,
-0.5794860721,
-0.2944898903,
-0.5650133491,
-0.0790370703,
-0.3459054828,
-0.1581291705,
-0.0413533822,
-0.0587909147,
0.5632353425,
-0.4121159315,
0.3749035299,
0.2825855017,
-0.3370691836,
-0.1141312793,
0.1520042419,
0.5461627245,
0.4232332408,
0.2473971248,
0.0481403768,
0.0128757386,
-0.8635450006,
0.2816142142,
0.1563538909,
-0.2641163766,
0.2413137406,
0.1778746545,
0.7678326368,
-0.0134689379,
-0.1710436791,
0.6522774696,
-0.011050933,
-0.4349374175,
-0.1380409002,
-0.1129259169,
0.0059492914,
0.5333919525,
0.6664477587,
0.5287689567,
0.6230326891,
-0.2116614431,
0.5131961703,
0.2741852403,
-0.1933474243,
-0.4449839592,
0.8656823039,
0.2622232139,
-0.1264156103,
0.6289921999,
-0.0298274085,
-0.2416835129,
0.3431844115,
0.4829728007,
1.0196708441,
-0.6172033548,
0.5124721527,
0.4179970324,
0.0313185267,
-0.4994234741,
0.2528958321,
-0.4955920875,
-0.354016006,
-0.362113148,
-0.7718288898,
-0.162700668,
-0.3872334957,
-0.880158782,
0.1608401239,
-0.1175697744,
-0.3730748594,
-0.0184636619,
-0.763043344,
-0.5838497877,
0.0621858165,
0.0399888977,
0.7618159056,
-1.0656040907,
1.1292594671,
0.2543139458,
-0.4766479433,
-0.4553077221,
0.3643584549,
-0.0728247091,
-0.7651516199,
0.9455537796,
0.0131670721,
-0.3796872199,
0.2303386033,
0.0457909293,
-1.024214983,
1.2417106628,
0.1313245445,
-0.7551389337,
-0.1386208236,
0.108864665,
0.3526203632,
0.0412861966,
0.5747374892,
0.3736595511,
0.3603515327,
0.401801765,
-1.0354521275,
0.1079456583,
-0.0564923435,
0.2708866596,
0.5526907444,
-0.9417157173,
1.1435688734,
-0.0123492945,
-0.4149562418,
-0.1336121559,
0.4852584004,
-0.1565813869,
0.2410611659,
0.4020744562,
0.6342692375,
0.403157562,
-0.0822604299,
0.8932477236,
-0.1983051449,
0.4703542292,
0.7788299918,
-0.2370946407,
0.6651858687,
0.6811635494,
-0.2618539035,
0.7634049058,
0.4087162018,
0.0342206061,
0.750877142,
-0.2361711413,
-0.5044793487,
-0.1221046522,
0.420550704,
-0.3518670797,
0.1061112285,
0.2919112146,
-0.6716942787,
-0.4793676138,
0.3782887161,
-0.3002456427,
0.0114832204,
-0.1026709154,
0.6960659027,
-0.0064191963,
-0.8119986653,
0.6671668291,
-0.1234292835,
0.9303742051,
-0.448342979,
-0.1335017085,
-0.3785648346,
0.1673776805,
-0.1844802648,
-0.5615510941,
0.372889787,
-0.5243194103,
-0.5419240594,
-0.4840807021,
0.3744726777,
-0.4295226038,
-0.4746454358,
0.3548846245,
0.5495362282,
-0.0657113642,
0.1101630554,
-0.7997350693,
-0.2459577322,
-0.0087936837,
-0.5191106796,
0.2739257812,
0.3763817549,
0.0989432335,
0.5131212473,
0.5565639138,
-0.2222935855,
0.5912662148,
0.4706369042,
0.8399893641,
-0.70598948,
-0.2974846959,
-0.7546036243,
0.791234076,
-0.0779288188,
-0.2720744312,
1.0746543407,
0.4484285414,
0.7080526352,
-0.2238722295,
0.61971277,
-0.0477652922,
0.7186663747,
-0.5411314368,
0.4216957688,
-0.4317055047,
-0.0251185466,
-0.1370420903,
-1.1255614758,
-0.0496223979,
0.5930486321,
-0.0827417523,
0.2893991172,
0.9715079069,
0.6103491187,
-0.429834336,
-0.0292109996,
0.418789953,
-0.0104043968,
0.3581786454,
0.4572267532,
0.5871958137,
-0.7102966309,
0.0954823643,
-0.2946370542,
-0.5204014182,
-0.043804165,
-0.6682008505,
-0.9075938463,
-0.7467412353,
-0.1292042136,
-0.2401580364,
-0.4245252013,
0.2991169691,
0.7942128181,
-0.526268959,
-0.0925600901,
-0.36650002,
-0.333538413,
-0.4335985184,
-0.3735984862,
-0.0120621538,
-0.5886136889,
-1.1368294954,
0.5301586986,
0.3190942407,
0.1385410428,
-0.5913675427,
-0.001178991,
-0.3420517147,
0.1464848518,
0.6475720406,
0.0843052715,
-0.63869524,
0.0675094202,
0.0070776395,
0.0262026899,
0.1189068109,
1.0752767324,
-0.88757056,
0.4736717641,
0.621376276,
0.2418393642,
0.9003019333,
0.2145561576,
0.4484380484,
-0.4280134141,
0.1493608057,
0.1958720386,
0.3817672431,
0.1738607883,
-0.5327759385,
0.2005673647,
0.3638865948,
-0.7057102323,
-0.5710060596,
0.4192680717,
-1.060726285,
-0.2915804982,
1.1204804182,
0.1460852027,
-0.0770143867,
-0.468821913,
-0.2471403331,
0.233297646,
-0.6235217452,
0.6190150976,
0.3690882921,
-0.3213924766,
-0.3470502794,
-0.4535255134,
0.3927202821,
0.5139831305,
-0.4109680951,
-0.0808330774,
0.6688348651,
0.5385553241,
0.2732602954,
0.6887348294,
-0.3581844568,
0.370490849,
0.2826373279,
0.056853123,
-0.0365849026,
-0.4068414271,
-0.6803865433,
0.3441714346,
-0.1327996999,
0.0589496307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10233v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10233v2 | Pre-trained Language Models for Keyphrase Generation: A Thorough Empirical Study | 2022-12-20T13:20:21 | 2024-02-23T04:45:40 | Di Wu, Wasi Uddin Ahmad, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural models that do not rely on pre-training have excelled in the keyphrase
generation task with large annotated datasets. Meanwhile, new approaches have
incorporated pre-trained language models (PLMs) for their data efficiency.
However, there lacks a systematic study of how the two types of approaches
compare and how different design choices can affect the performance of
PLM-based models. To fill in this knowledge gap and facilitate a more informed
use of PLMs for keyphrase extraction and keyphrase generation, we present an
in-depth empirical study. Formulating keyphrase extraction as sequence labeling
and keyphrase generation as sequence-to-sequence generation, we perform
extensive experiments in three domains. After showing that PLMs have
competitive high-resource performance and state-of-the-art low-resource
performance, we investigate important design choices including in-domain PLMs,
PLMs with different pre-training objectives, using PLMs with a parameter
budget, and different formulations for present keyphrases. Further results show
that (1) in-domain BERT-like PLMs can be used to build strong and
data-efficient keyphrase generation models; (2) with a fixed parameter budget,
prioritizing model depth over width and allocating more layers in the encoder
leads to better encoder-decoder models; and (3) introducing four in-domain
PLMs, we achieve a competitive performance in the news domain and the
state-of-the-art performance in the scientific domain. | [
-0.2745834887,
-0.5363637805,
0.5799270868,
0.0625253245,
-0.6620551944,
0.1241875589,
-0.2539885044,
-0.1409614533,
-0.0533200763,
0.567438364,
-0.2566813827,
-0.4523966908,
-0.5036568642,
0.3388396502,
-0.3960879743,
0.8323632479,
0.0345563069,
0.296862334,
-0.2740172446,
0.2440312505,
-0.2824090123,
-0.9383288026,
-0.2215797603,
-0.0954731256,
0.4677371085,
0.2506487668,
0.5578900576,
0.4548672736,
0.7401583791,
0.1900902539,
-0.1554318517,
0.0400356166,
-0.2510970235,
0.2298154682,
-0.1033109277,
-0.3276442587,
-0.3880346715,
0.070888482,
0.4546061754,
0.7013700604,
0.209536761,
0.0680212751,
0.0341758281,
0.6303688884,
-0.6211326122,
-0.0794084594,
-0.7471466064,
-0.0036296512,
-0.5528817177,
-0.299372077,
-0.3395250142,
-0.5751994848,
0.603268683,
-0.4616273046,
0.2812514901,
0.0975953341,
0.6676142812,
-0.2044292539,
-0.2121551484,
-0.7271746993,
-0.413439393,
0.6420977712,
-1.0268400908,
0.4701564908,
0.2481202334,
-0.0371869765,
-0.243208617,
-1.0958515406,
-0.424390763,
-0.3364558816,
0.120510757,
0.0435342751,
0.3536890745,
0.244332701,
0.2330560833,
0.3646205366,
-0.7078326344,
0.0785454065,
-0.4504567981,
0.0192098226,
0.5938569307,
-0.1284645796,
0.175019443,
-0.2293185592,
-0.0879835635,
-0.3151812255,
-1.0653606653,
-0.0094505446,
0.371884793,
0.37108621,
0.1464981586,
0.4748608768,
0.0256669447,
0.52241081,
-0.1765177697,
-0.1417507082,
0.2699283957,
-0.5222597718,
-0.0424288586,
0.1211888045,
0.7482540607,
0.0444564745,
0.4521063566,
-0.4956677854,
-0.2361160219,
0.0341524109,
0.3417168856,
-1.0003721714,
-0.3420274556,
0.1044185534,
-0.7095975876,
-0.4060485959,
0.0062150462,
-0.8937257528,
-0.0348050073,
-0.1530403197,
0.6364650726,
-0.4560151994,
-0.2241115719,
0.244694382,
-0.3669834137,
0.0812989548,
-0.0921455175,
-0.6267014146,
0.2711260617,
0.5503013134,
0.9161656499,
-0.3470270336,
-0.1844277829,
0.0188731086,
-0.1160755828,
-0.3912787139,
0.4977274239,
-0.6323540211,
-0.615068078,
0.1891808063,
-0.3825990856,
-0.2470734566,
-0.6556512117,
0.6154485345,
-0.962908268,
0.2314429581,
-0.3114617169,
-0.8582023978,
0.0109350635,
-0.2199627906,
-0.5661457181,
0.4897823334,
-0.1193545684,
-0.6356363297,
0.4158557355,
-0.9477339387,
-0.9288890362,
0.1471739709,
-0.0855186954,
-0.587932229,
0.4444312751,
0.1305090338,
0.3527054787,
-0.4161858857,
0.3544597328,
-0.3236271143,
-0.2204750776,
0.6014742851,
-0.296523869,
0.6504739523,
0.6588830352,
-0.3238649368,
-0.1499185115,
-0.6464611292,
0.1690348834,
0.3154313862,
-0.260121882,
-0.3148602843,
0.2011547238,
-0.0503633395,
0.3649438918,
0.2875837982,
-0.5258431435,
-0.0239404719,
-0.5334869623,
0.7761647701,
0.3756840825,
0.1684592664,
0.5728994608,
-0.1682582349,
0.4782295823,
-0.118225731,
0.1466737688,
-0.2764469981,
-0.3434493542,
-0.3340881467,
-0.1906096637,
0.6755151153,
0.208347708,
-0.6119655371,
0.3331267238,
-0.1993991733,
-0.2347343415,
-0.3924966455,
0.007344753,
0.4559882283,
0.4531026185,
0.2845536768,
-0.6108710766,
-0.5291748047,
-0.5609397888,
-0.4340419769,
-0.0190746244,
0.0319425426,
0.3357296586,
0.6304242015,
0.2301333845,
1.030903697,
-0.4472352564,
-0.013589914,
-0.4976763129,
0.2937825024,
0.2010584027,
0.3958190978,
0.4110301733,
-1.04027915,
-0.3823749423,
-0.4510921538,
-0.6515315771,
-0.1646481901,
0.0168836862,
0.0148048028,
-0.1459262669,
0.4187173545,
-0.7121725082,
0.2106412947,
0.2393701673,
0.1606783569,
0.5071075559,
-0.2214982212,
-0.033197213,
-1.0187535286,
0.3472866714,
-0.206209451,
0.1970772892,
-0.9705241919,
0.106890209,
0.2214898318,
-0.4129750133,
-0.5296981931,
0.3973355293,
-0.4773027897,
-0.2154688239,
-0.4139464498,
-0.0649567023,
0.0955115035,
0.3480399251,
0.4548116922,
0.8053904176,
0.2984225452,
-0.6511480808,
-0.0934816375,
0.1901758015,
-0.5395275354,
-0.103261061,
-0.8191045523,
0.1846538484,
-0.0386538655,
0.1184542775,
-0.8859199286,
-0.1361834258,
0.021508228,
-0.4191849232,
0.2960906923,
0.0181350671,
-0.6725376844,
-0.4856125712,
-0.2516002655,
0.4133301675,
0.754668057,
-0.3708309829,
0.1009371653,
0.396997571,
-0.5612590909,
-0.1062314585,
-0.4133261144,
0.0259407051,
-0.3339602947,
-0.5425988436,
0.4801277816,
-0.0315594301,
-0.0131377149,
-0.2168218046,
-0.136377275,
-0.2392896712,
0.3433223963,
0.034343522,
0.1409729272,
-0.2356745899,
0.0143606225,
-0.0118527254,
0.1331434399,
0.1719373912,
-0.3767186105,
0.6259940267,
0.1338456273,
-0.2210685313,
-0.183784619,
0.4272413254,
0.6326702237,
-0.6392470598,
0.5988897681,
-0.0218622331,
-0.1438409686,
-0.0230889488,
-0.3547231555,
-0.4517438412,
-0.4850232601,
0.3609319031,
-0.4357783496,
-0.6876081824,
0.1649149358,
-0.4030327499,
0.2323962599,
0.1978322566,
0.5322400928,
-0.2064605951,
1.1119481325,
0.351916194,
0.0184485186,
0.4992159903,
-0.2203935087,
0.3853975534,
-0.6108155251,
-0.0014343474,
-0.5269860625,
-0.2193907797,
-0.3500666916,
-0.0318976082,
0.3407144248,
0.3039798141,
-0.0944759399,
0.2550386488,
-0.2927447855,
0.2015579641,
0.853494823,
-0.013244804,
0.0015677925,
0.0811507031,
-0.2415379137,
-0.1023936644,
-0.8708078265,
-0.623457253,
1.4702174664,
0.1591969877,
0.6062085032,
-0.1470122188,
0.7912943363,
0.1214190871,
0.1793692559,
-0.2778002322,
0.3843578398,
-0.3011661768,
-0.6973320842,
-0.1375601739,
-0.2648628056,
-0.9796541333,
0.3568600416,
-0.0548535213,
-0.1644799262,
0.1567993611,
0.0368096158,
-0.5746709704,
-0.0922294259,
-0.6688554883,
1.0040408373,
-0.6648070812,
-0.0700807124,
-0.0140290102,
-0.8795509934,
0.2229589522,
-0.4247497022,
0.2101593316,
0.1665746123,
0.1803066134,
0.8857483864,
-0.4771418571,
0.5808612108,
-0.1955479234,
0.1719717085,
0.3975419402,
-0.2729062736,
0.4548462033,
-0.1533538997,
-0.054651577,
0.1022633389,
-0.2647846937,
0.0179063529,
-0.2703673542,
0.2726509869,
-0.6484189034,
-0.4627414048,
-0.1504262686,
-0.4424401522,
-0.2652898133,
0.3392676711,
0.7585749626,
0.4728350937,
-0.1544371396,
0.4216349721,
0.8850957751,
-0.3112486899,
0.483727932,
0.5694942474,
0.0850341022,
-0.4438658655,
0.9320192337,
0.206078738,
0.3278075755,
0.5687203407,
0.1451035738,
-0.4665144086,
-0.9554077387,
-0.0228112843,
0.1923963428,
-0.3756322265,
-0.1116972268,
-0.6487336755,
-0.4399115443,
-0.8269111514,
-0.084706232,
-0.3502411842,
-0.277656883,
-0.365793407,
0.1109133437,
0.0933618993,
0.3207742274,
0.0012052001,
0.6349226236,
-0.8392184973,
0.4292288125,
0.1270097047,
0.0435082279,
-0.1235081032,
-0.5597046614,
-0.3520055413,
0.0720884204,
-0.4130271673,
-1.0792820454,
0.7191173434,
0.4121200442,
0.5542458296,
0.2575726509,
0.0824027807,
0.4046393335,
-0.7534301281,
0.7648363709,
-0.0852035433,
-0.706504941,
0.5621920824,
-0.0318785645,
0.141232878,
0.4989141226,
0.4806156158,
-0.2049339265,
-0.3837927878,
-0.5734245777,
-0.8691378236,
0.5630158186,
0.3616143763,
0.0591138713,
-0.1364544779,
0.3368154764,
0.3275240064,
0.6375940442,
-0.4929420352,
-0.1674666405,
-0.3600298762,
-0.3545206189,
-0.1824369133,
-0.3195390701,
0.1513389796,
0.0460351147,
0.5335459113,
0.1864798516,
0.1613176316,
0.1506176293,
-0.5792262554,
0.2272073179,
0.2784988284,
0.744651258,
0.5261896849,
-0.3413430452,
0.0791396499,
-0.2306982726,
-0.5568298101,
0.0683488324,
0.2384436876,
-0.2334489524,
0.1957090646,
0.3003845215,
0.7120799422,
0.2797141671,
-0.6995173693,
0.6018195152,
-0.0018066869,
-0.5094382167,
0.0218456406,
-0.1998208463,
0.0812728629,
0.1721298993,
0.4665259719,
-0.2377467006,
0.1513697803,
-0.3008503914,
0.3392511308,
0.5990825891,
0.4199339747,
-0.5194075704,
0.7384489775,
0.3513022363,
-0.3133240342,
0.6134226918,
0.1065364853,
-0.7010589838,
0.5274240375,
0.5588520169,
0.9581547379,
-0.0618818924,
0.1137844771,
-0.0041817399,
0.2124844193,
-0.1478459388,
0.4516556263,
-0.3540159166,
-0.6606423259,
-0.2722611427,
-0.6882581115,
-0.351764828,
0.5026991367,
-0.5063280463,
-0.1545103043,
-0.3399574459,
-0.4095122218,
0.0127929281,
0.2000493407,
-0.7147069573,
0.2367230505,
0.1967948228,
0.9127919674,
-0.7650154829,
0.8769266605,
0.5619211197,
-0.5115318298,
-0.4772922397,
-0.090307571,
-0.4907312989,
-0.6075143814,
0.8822328448,
0.0898873061,
0.3208408952,
0.0832465813,
-0.3764638901,
-1.0251021385,
0.8453500271,
0.2309768647,
-0.5226663947,
-0.3390415311,
0.4721006453,
0.5071188807,
-0.5253096819,
-0.1410206705,
0.3834200203,
0.1817277372,
-0.1357980371,
-0.7273831367,
-0.306697458,
-0.1918523163,
0.2423925698,
0.0451767817,
-0.2168229073,
1.0756485462,
-0.0036490043,
-0.2574040592,
0.3519133031,
0.6666724682,
0.4416997731,
0.2116927207,
0.1160933301,
0.3376791179,
0.4457588792,
0.1691686511,
0.9939101934,
-0.7812154293,
-0.0167509299,
1.0803182125,
-0.584238112,
0.8003803492,
0.3958724439,
0.0476134345,
0.1685534865,
0.699976027,
0.1928336918,
1.1804556847,
0.2593693137,
-0.1323897094,
-0.1091021672,
0.1182027161,
-0.5016160011,
0.1097887233,
0.3927189708,
-0.846426487,
-0.2609101832,
0.2090037912,
-0.2473211586,
-0.2022414953,
-0.2055639029,
0.7102991343,
0.2983033061,
-0.659039557,
0.2561432719,
0.0502226166,
0.5858972669,
-0.7445739508,
0.1960648,
-0.1536168754,
0.1819317043,
0.2332060784,
-0.5001403093,
-0.2072467208,
0.260645628,
-0.0998989716,
-0.5246214867,
0.9609615207,
-0.43204391,
-0.206968829,
-0.1277031302,
0.6135219336,
0.2845825255,
-0.2398639619,
-0.5938813686,
0.0334451161,
-0.2601597011,
-0.4087106884,
0.4716458321,
0.2399371117,
0.0906902924,
0.2185223699,
0.7306237817,
0.3095064163,
0.4501003325,
0.1370504349,
0.6589796543,
-0.5302377343,
-0.4651962221,
-0.9128155112,
0.1125754863,
-0.1318812817,
-0.4382185936,
0.8245042562,
0.605078876,
0.8227624893,
-0.2934476435,
1.0109778643,
0.3048630953,
0.5255904794,
-0.5657027364,
0.6368225813,
-0.4288125634,
0.0064893635,
-0.2709892392,
-0.8580700755,
-0.0780223235,
0.5888751149,
-0.2675123215,
0.1778069884,
0.5778473616,
0.575327754,
0.3328145444,
0.2118244469,
0.1605783701,
-0.0946218446,
0.3446969688,
0.4148993194,
0.8765736222,
-0.3161219656,
0.3542718589,
-0.3186303675,
-0.018049622,
-0.4049227238,
-0.7146807313,
-0.7613170147,
-0.503547132,
-0.0727672428,
0.0916077942,
0.3392852843,
0.7453327775,
0.6708248854,
-0.6209639907,
-0.2766450942,
-0.3691758215,
-0.0408280492,
0.017281374,
-0.1680707932,
0.411211133,
-0.6913293004,
-0.4795453548,
0.4873715341,
0.1012538075,
0.0989088267,
0.0931774303,
-0.1592072994,
-0.100481227,
0.2273608148,
0.5811474919,
0.3729845881,
-0.5753775239,
0.1166355908,
0.3408690989,
-0.3152498305,
-0.0451181829,
1.1263517141,
-0.533103168,
0.2230416089,
0.6521162391,
0.7384085655,
0.2526354194,
-0.012723946,
0.8087672591,
-0.6336187124,
-0.2318538576,
0.356140703,
0.2828896642,
0.1571615338,
-0.0013386293,
0.2949664593,
0.2630439699,
-0.5659952164,
-0.9700572491,
0.1372815669,
-0.4295839369,
-0.545883894,
1.0717318058,
-0.0817087442,
-0.2293986678,
-0.0639110729,
0.0205055717,
0.2939860821,
-0.1241739988,
0.6316123009,
0.6151732206,
0.0070783296,
0.0973170325,
-0.2957278192,
0.7082188725,
0.5602549911,
-0.5417301059,
0.0154663408,
0.2048040926,
0.2351386547,
0.1177070588,
0.6000587344,
-0.2929413319,
0.3688571453,
-0.1098488569,
0.0784162655,
-0.0867304057,
-0.369110167,
-0.2624070644,
0.4413865507,
0.2362742126,
-0.3281396031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10218v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10218v2 | GanLM: Encoder-Decoder Pre-training with an Auxiliary Discriminator | 2022-12-20T12:51:11 | 2023-05-09T09:08:33 | Jian Yang, Shuming Ma, Li Dong, Shaohan Huang, Haoyang Huang, Yuwei Yin, Dongdong Zhang, Liqun Yang, Furu Wei, Zhoujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained models have achieved remarkable success in natural language
processing (NLP). However, existing pre-training methods underutilize the
benefits of language understanding for generation. Inspired by the idea of
Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), we propose a GAN-style model for
encoder-decoder pre-training by introducing an auxiliary discriminator,
unifying the ability of language understanding and generation in a single
model. Our model, named as GanLM, is trained with two pre-training objectives:
replaced token detection and replaced token denoising. Specifically, given
masked source sentences, the generator outputs the target distribution and the
discriminator predicts whether the target sampled tokens from distribution are
incorrect. The target sentence is replaced with misclassified tokens to
construct noisy previous context, which is used to generate the gold sentence.
In general, both tasks improve the ability of language understanding and
generation by selectively using the denoising data. Extensive experiments in
language generation benchmarks show that GanLM with the powerful language
understanding capability outperforms various strong pre-trained language models
(PLMs) and achieves state-of-the-art performance. | [
-0.5136341453,
-0.6843979955,
0.2014810294,
0.0058202324,
-0.5564280748,
0.1108347252,
-0.2340385765,
-0.0686701462,
-0.0680343956,
0.6588594317,
-0.4783663452,
-0.3442137837,
-0.6757614017,
0.1438531727,
-0.4862765372,
1.3981180191,
0.1307579726,
0.1721202731,
-0.1166365817,
0.1364608556,
-0.40545398,
-0.6257445812,
-1.0548219681,
-0.3918155432,
0.372374922,
-0.1284537017,
0.5534241199,
0.3540959656,
0.2420073599,
0.2455057949,
-0.0421713628,
0.4232318103,
-0.3522437513,
-0.0707194731,
0.2073107511,
-0.3361554146,
-0.6739751697,
-0.1008209437,
0.5230156779,
0.6465007067,
-0.3169772327,
-0.156967625,
0.1202577427,
0.5631656051,
-0.5782841444,
0.0724173635,
-0.9902376533,
0.1958664507,
-0.2941278815,
-0.3747572601,
-0.4917739332,
-0.1213720068,
-0.2757304311,
-0.6655490398,
0.8025785089,
0.1331276894,
0.7580199838,
0.2896682024,
-0.2754402161,
-0.2968309522,
-0.6141040921,
0.4179628491,
-0.6628873348,
0.3163031638,
0.4240938723,
0.296731472,
-0.0438080616,
-0.9164357781,
-0.7812110186,
-0.1090280712,
-0.3749881685,
0.2593476176,
-0.2705617547,
0.4436510801,
0.1259645373,
0.5835943222,
-0.9723190665,
-0.0948771462,
-0.3885852396,
0.0337928087,
0.3367879391,
-0.078664206,
0.4986855388,
0.0081605613,
-0.1961782724,
0.1671268493,
-0.7333729267,
-0.4013342857,
0.4040542543,
0.2800938189,
0.0374354795,
0.2003064156,
0.076226145,
0.8842738271,
0.0572112612,
0.2782783508,
0.2592746019,
-0.2994638979,
-0.5217221975,
0.0429137163,
0.6411946416,
-0.2540881634,
0.130978629,
-0.4395305812,
-0.4424231946,
0.265158534,
0.3983716369,
-0.5923987627,
-0.4446752369,
-0.1467900723,
-0.4296807051,
-0.189410165,
0.1119892821,
-0.4447675943,
-0.1159331352,
-0.3004411459,
0.3314618468,
-0.3412954807,
-0.3165444434,
0.2633253932,
-0.0798916444,
0.2531137168,
0.0725148618,
-1.0065780878,
0.4165200889,
0.6698158383,
0.6329529285,
-0.0064351461,
-0.3366883397,
-1.0191984177,
0.1715267897,
-0.3575794995,
0.562237978,
-0.3608072102,
-0.2688754499,
0.0626919344,
-0.1459925175,
-0.1344229132,
-0.4077529311,
0.6586073637,
-0.9074513316,
0.283036828,
-0.1193730608,
-0.3064349294,
-0.2114705145,
0.2638524771,
-0.6013758183,
0.6135432124,
0.0772288218,
-0.7705801725,
0.6126049757,
-0.9094119072,
-0.6294035316,
0.4658485055,
-0.0076513672,
-0.4375756979,
0.2088597864,
0.4926605821,
0.1878884286,
-0.3417584598,
0.5809882879,
0.0383089408,
-0.2546542585,
-0.056212049,
-0.8247555494,
0.7797049284,
0.4114992619,
-0.0701818988,
0.3588220775,
-0.6194306016,
-0.2456305623,
0.1881578416,
-0.293022424,
0.0034156372,
-0.0803166181,
0.0964978337,
0.1658774316,
0.1773881465,
-0.3103541136,
-0.1471474618,
-0.4237310886,
0.2417056859,
0.5856227875,
-0.1425976306,
0.4844443202,
-0.1009693295,
0.6418296695,
0.0027029356,
0.1979994178,
-0.0731363297,
-0.1335790604,
-1.0552605391,
-0.1287512034,
0.2662239671,
0.1433254331,
-1.0025321245,
0.6500285268,
-0.2382537276,
0.0372236781,
-0.7518200874,
0.372798562,
0.4446855485,
0.3749659359,
0.4692627788,
-0.2819287479,
-0.9397695065,
-0.3997825384,
-0.2746815383,
-0.1605711132,
-0.1004636064,
-0.1684253067,
0.3741362095,
-0.4120768607,
0.7647892833,
-0.3518393338,
-0.4119120538,
-0.7671025395,
0.3395806849,
-0.0433265679,
0.4974570572,
0.3818840384,
-0.81292665,
-0.4643003047,
0.0397860371,
-0.582686305,
0.0130121317,
-0.0004303224,
-0.1604775041,
0.0784705579,
0.5817252398,
-0.7336269021,
0.3160646558,
0.602596879,
-0.1903057992,
0.3365254104,
-0.7068062425,
-0.218677327,
-0.7772613764,
0.0218519345,
-0.5260848999,
-0.1469545662,
-1.0178668499,
-0.0191276576,
-0.1332324445,
-0.2299490869,
-0.2571310401,
0.4300186038,
-0.7978287935,
-0.2075000852,
-0.3778811991,
0.0380314514,
0.2944911718,
0.3815635443,
0.2027539611,
0.8467112184,
0.4613713026,
-0.6784766316,
0.2296216786,
0.2669449747,
-0.2843171954,
0.1581666321,
-0.694273293,
0.3810325265,
-0.5791745782,
0.1549809426,
-0.620121181,
-0.0005440285,
0.1326952726,
-0.4353731573,
0.5883685946,
-0.1002412066,
-0.4633865654,
-0.4126979709,
0.0447477177,
0.3162046671,
0.6592282057,
-0.791733861,
0.7048541903,
0.3368064463,
-0.0051710051,
-0.4591091275,
-0.722162962,
0.1162964702,
-0.1630011946,
-0.2936706543,
0.3928832412,
0.0094969245,
0.0114206197,
0.1930264384,
0.2983698249,
-0.0682490245,
0.1809840947,
-0.1440547407,
0.2219291925,
-0.2412386537,
0.1623532921,
-0.0576304011,
-0.2556926012,
0.0008759417,
-0.3036995232,
0.9285110831,
-0.0903887004,
-0.4616595209,
0.0975802466,
0.3539057672,
0.3004771769,
-0.7091488242,
0.8719986081,
1.0167323351,
-0.3219443262,
-0.2749430835,
-0.3233357072,
0.0254360251,
-0.4687383175,
0.4482356906,
-0.4801687598,
-0.4800106287,
0.2459203303,
0.458214581,
0.1183789894,
0.4953289628,
0.2640490532,
0.1855507642,
1.2339632511,
0.5534721613,
-0.064001359,
0.5851136446,
-0.1507559121,
0.358661145,
-1.0467631817,
0.0068843057,
-0.2263081819,
0.2175571471,
-0.1198490858,
-0.3531189561,
0.0626000836,
0.4032921493,
-0.3638063371,
0.0469495095,
-0.3703841567,
0.3927713931,
0.5817674994,
-0.0218474269,
0.1753735989,
-0.0057047522,
0.1696921736,
0.1922938973,
-0.8535766602,
-0.5065109134,
1.0544251204,
0.1179591045,
0.5808799267,
0.089452751,
0.6448532343,
0.2253418863,
0.579025805,
-0.3301473856,
0.3541705906,
-0.7099040151,
-0.411696434,
-0.142144531,
-0.329949677,
-1.0248417854,
0.4662996531,
-0.1358621418,
-0.0976050049,
-0.162392512,
0.2227895409,
-0.2941136062,
0.3118043542,
-0.5714823604,
1.0060501099,
-0.4330767393,
0.1891437173,
0.0767389312,
-0.3581593931,
0.5267695785,
0.0737464353,
0.1397825181,
0.1634515971,
0.3536121547,
0.671792686,
-0.3628068566,
0.480474472,
-0.3804326952,
0.1771873087,
0.1919207573,
-0.2060498446,
0.6297727227,
-0.1168334484,
0.0105938883,
-0.2862305045,
-0.5680194497,
-0.2681305408,
-0.6939702034,
0.2564694285,
-0.6983335614,
-0.7451649904,
-0.1637676507,
-0.4229981005,
-0.0224163625,
0.0680868924,
0.605279088,
0.4357729852,
-0.3654572666,
0.1852000952,
0.5135878921,
-0.1546653956,
0.4091522396,
0.3768090904,
-0.2138580829,
-0.3746179938,
0.8674517274,
-0.1706726551,
0.3256716132,
0.29913041,
-0.0761564374,
-0.3943705261,
-0.8720108867,
-0.4369898438,
0.0792301595,
-0.8572877645,
-0.1176711619,
-0.9248589873,
-0.6308445334,
-0.3849171102,
-0.2782613039,
-0.0581198223,
0.4063697457,
-0.7029675245,
-0.2915256023,
0.1538256556,
0.6551867723,
-0.1037919819,
0.5606497526,
-0.6240211129,
0.6168223619,
0.6202254295,
-0.0298983604,
-0.0904064402,
-0.7339342833,
-0.0348138735,
0.1483790576,
0.1164191812,
-0.5421720147,
0.8570657372,
0.3870962858,
0.7640662789,
0.4852102697,
0.0224033948,
0.6793305874,
-0.506465435,
0.6755157709,
0.2836951911,
-0.9302558899,
0.4845139682,
-0.0068810857,
0.3264269233,
0.4228287041,
-0.2206505388,
-0.3626133502,
-0.3488236368,
-0.5938493013,
-0.6038013697,
0.7259201407,
0.2000700831,
0.181236729,
-0.2855489254,
-0.0252790544,
0.1968540102,
0.3939436972,
-0.8420901895,
-0.1767784357,
-0.3605416715,
-0.3250095844,
-0.6266299486,
-0.4943442643,
-0.0969278887,
-0.1558123827,
0.5985895395,
0.0272352435,
0.2762805223,
-0.170977816,
-0.4884793758,
0.0777332261,
0.3981063366,
0.447236985,
0.4207905233,
-0.158364594,
0.414673537,
0.2845481336,
-0.5145618916,
0.0204664469,
0.3009506762,
-0.350291431,
0.237431109,
0.2937577963,
1.3753349781,
-0.2152015716,
-0.3245362937,
0.544057548,
-0.1877402514,
-0.1745773703,
-0.3194990158,
0.0280022118,
-0.1447099447,
-0.2562089562,
0.4564735889,
0.2717622519,
0.1914620399,
-0.5220793486,
0.2573379874,
0.6826171875,
-0.304507345,
-0.4751701355,
0.8284513354,
0.2212041169,
-0.3498533368,
0.4294418097,
-0.6530223489,
-0.8682116866,
0.4554107487,
0.8839698434,
1.159563303,
-0.0283752233,
0.5063944459,
0.1053886265,
0.3601169884,
-0.0236061923,
0.1680459976,
-0.1320603788,
-0.9491686225,
-0.3631772101,
-0.8894901872,
0.0867208466,
0.3867543042,
-0.7009376884,
0.1535803527,
-0.1992488652,
0.138605535,
-0.2257788181,
-0.0781265646,
-1.0032098293,
0.4520025849,
-0.0379371084,
0.2922111452,
-0.848220408,
0.9519958496,
0.4469919801,
-0.4529996812,
-0.448287189,
0.058979366,
-0.4904091358,
-0.6144292355,
0.8964111209,
0.0842529014,
-0.1567549407,
0.3883148432,
-0.0286954585,
-0.6114647985,
0.7304824591,
0.5613145828,
-0.3094165623,
-0.1085987911,
-0.1604457051,
0.4900234342,
-0.525598824,
0.2054901272,
0.6264970899,
0.1699985713,
-0.0469451509,
-0.4875817299,
-0.0918138623,
-0.3229424655,
0.1552131325,
0.2512487769,
-0.0115027241,
1.1888263226,
-0.039555233,
-0.5784029961,
-0.1874673367,
0.6553739905,
0.1960104406,
-0.0050567491,
0.6354026198,
0.3622095287,
0.7162512541,
-0.0580752455,
1.0260406733,
-0.133098647,
0.1174276993,
1.1043019295,
0.0078581069,
0.6873377562,
0.2902273536,
-0.2679084241,
0.3249894977,
0.3543331921,
0.3314487338,
0.8551012874,
0.028850697,
-0.5879853964,
-0.1589422077,
0.031977497,
-0.5812495351,
0.3149774671,
0.3775472343,
-0.4327866435,
-0.2367551625,
0.3447073698,
-0.2699539065,
-0.0187425688,
-0.4102807343,
0.9222177267,
-0.1069412827,
-0.5538356304,
0.6315433979,
-0.1643625647,
0.8207296133,
-0.7128517628,
0.0803092718,
-0.2833488286,
0.1430186331,
-0.1136822253,
-0.3405535817,
0.4626870453,
0.0776201114,
-0.1112086624,
-0.3281797469,
0.747415185,
-0.8062770963,
-0.3720656633,
0.2143296152,
0.3725048602,
0.092487067,
-0.09478686,
-0.4818173945,
0.0257373806,
-0.0106187006,
-0.0464533269,
0.2715480328,
0.3546332717,
0.3405879438,
0.3252869844,
0.8241539001,
0.2915879488,
0.2581713498,
0.5651757717,
0.7600147724,
-0.2795803547,
-0.6551748514,
-0.834792316,
0.468001008,
-0.1916755438,
-0.1702611148,
0.6388571858,
0.3593791723,
0.8110583425,
-0.3051546216,
0.9649375677,
0.093780607,
0.2582985759,
-0.7926599383,
0.7228155136,
-0.353110373,
0.2397659123,
0.0342608541,
-0.7390314341,
-0.4055022597,
0.7046197653,
-0.2838874161,
0.1216518506,
0.5221089721,
0.6064895988,
0.0629335046,
-0.1854793876,
0.5252606273,
-0.2196426541,
0.4264068305,
0.4981589019,
0.8421503305,
-0.3682049215,
0.6337755919,
-0.0051557412,
0.1283895075,
-0.1626600474,
-0.5303012729,
-1.1065033674,
-0.519626379,
-0.090678297,
0.039936386,
0.1476655751,
0.5884276628,
0.5627726912,
-0.8091838956,
0.0779277384,
-0.9852169752,
-0.0132952314,
-0.1586743593,
-0.1869026124,
0.3972716331,
-0.8171722293,
-0.7522962689,
0.3933720589,
0.2668814361,
0.1696489304,
-0.3984827995,
-0.3398453593,
-0.1424973458,
-0.2031924576,
0.6492652297,
0.1812214404,
-0.9007046223,
-0.145161882,
-0.2103447765,
-0.1145080328,
-0.0456328206,
0.8372379541,
-0.6145532131,
0.7128865719,
0.4236662686,
0.7371478677,
0.7365711331,
0.1049324274,
0.8756877184,
-0.8487808108,
0.2846876383,
0.2738230228,
0.553465724,
0.5031780005,
-0.280046463,
0.2293962091,
-0.0469608195,
-0.2378650904,
-0.9300171733,
0.3388675451,
-0.3424227238,
-0.2880500853,
0.9581381083,
-0.2796375155,
-0.042464193,
-0.3906989098,
-0.3239620626,
0.5519210696,
0.0152070662,
0.3607645631,
0.2819865048,
0.2656891644,
-0.5006579161,
-0.365545392,
0.8952777386,
0.3849045932,
-0.9290552139,
0.0625481531,
0.2800576687,
-0.0939440802,
0.0194483958,
0.9372407794,
0.1670225114,
0.1650543958,
0.3758645952,
0.1693590879,
-0.3094347119,
-0.4099292457,
-0.3682296872,
0.2363805026,
0.1352465749,
-0.5580312014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10197v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10197v2 | EIT: Enhanced Interactive Transformer | 2022-12-20T12:16:46 | 2024-06-05T10:18:14 | Tong Zheng, Bei Li, Huiwen Bao, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Two principles: the complementary principle and the consensus principle are
widely acknowledged in the literature of multi-view learning. However, the
current design of multi-head self-attention, an instance of multi-view
learning, prioritizes the complementarity while ignoring the consensus. To
address this problem, we propose an enhanced multi-head self-attention (EMHA).
First, to satisfy the complementary principle, EMHA removes the one-to-one
mapping constraint among queries and keys in multiple subspaces and allows each
query to attend to multiple keys. On top of that, we develop a method to fully
encourage consensus among heads by introducing two interaction models, namely
inner-subspace interaction and cross-subspace interaction. Extensive
experiments on a wide range of language tasks (e.g., machine translation,
abstractive summarization and grammar correction, language modeling), show its
superiority, with a very modest increase in model size. Our code would be
available at: https://github.com/zhengkid/EIT-Enhanced-Interactive-Transformer. | [
-0.7070182562,
-0.5580778122,
0.5110900998,
0.4448265433,
-0.1210260987,
-0.086729981,
-0.4659768343,
-0.340803206,
0.7244542837,
0.3780093789,
-0.4966630638,
-0.0329669565,
-0.6365440488,
0.1721226722,
-0.1896335036,
0.7825456858,
0.0093801934,
-0.2508948445,
-0.2517268956,
-0.3152170181,
-0.3648959994,
-0.5236546993,
-0.4041174352,
-0.2021634728,
0.6010983586,
0.8411284089,
0.6437402964,
0.5379539132,
0.808927238,
0.3543933034,
0.3365174234,
0.3697336912,
-0.4707480371,
0.4146303833,
-0.1622760743,
-0.2161648124,
-0.8816071749,
-0.256177038,
0.5165831447,
0.483966738,
-0.1155385226,
-0.0006956768,
0.4457975328,
0.668305099,
-0.5928525329,
0.1574565917,
-0.3001303077,
-0.0156966299,
0.2356645614,
-0.0695380047,
-0.4451932013,
0.0213293601,
0.3170284033,
-0.7394288182,
-0.1424137801,
0.1198710501,
0.7120426297,
0.6167966127,
-0.5015982985,
0.3405193388,
-0.460601151,
0.7571830153,
-0.2385134846,
0.8375119567,
0.1501475275,
0.2207909375,
0.4053344131,
-0.7852616906,
-0.7285304666,
-0.0122133056,
-0.2929773927,
0.6931459904,
-0.210500136,
0.5348151326,
0.1111630425,
0.2600706518,
-0.1684885323,
-0.0852737799,
-0.1002688408,
0.0757087916,
0.1506079882,
-0.1032596305,
0.1840946972,
-0.1073273346,
-0.423707962,
-0.2137187719,
-0.5114269853,
-0.165440768,
-0.1339874715,
0.1415275931,
-0.2110345662,
0.3796110451,
-0.4282332361,
0.5410379767,
0.7922483087,
0.1789555103,
0.3582108021,
-0.529671073,
-0.388007313,
-0.3545645475,
0.6065042615,
0.4862140119,
-0.1087194756,
-0.285751462,
0.0001373649,
-0.3529610634,
0.4667755365,
-0.6857375503,
-0.2561973929,
0.3349430561,
-0.4282846451,
-0.0465947054,
0.1844290495,
-0.8451246023,
0.0872660726,
-0.6842851043,
0.7239826322,
-0.0563254319,
-0.5629703999,
-0.3178481758,
0.0836081281,
0.5267714858,
0.4678277373,
-1.0767364502,
0.4129354656,
0.5964415073,
0.6595463753,
-0.2439150214,
-0.6317093968,
-0.3428356647,
0.4088781774,
0.1756000817,
1.0364652872,
-0.6975184083,
-0.0534012839,
-0.359225601,
-0.0534693822,
-0.2955503762,
-0.1634778827,
0.3298303783,
-0.2858797014,
0.2464178205,
-0.423755765,
-0.2338035107,
-0.4865251184,
0.4929934144,
-0.6595076323,
0.7770091295,
-0.0255298689,
-0.6355935335,
0.270111531,
-0.7962870598,
-0.4157169461,
-0.2999075353,
-0.5257768631,
-0.58344239,
-0.0161578227,
0.6309571862,
0.2521756589,
-0.131535992,
0.2659332752,
-0.3664332628,
0.0258992463,
-0.2051548958,
-0.2222989202,
0.3697935343,
0.0763013512,
-0.340413034,
0.4393031895,
-0.3768417835,
-0.0342277214,
-0.1778134853,
-0.1156305969,
-0.2102760375,
-0.2109237611,
0.2112129331,
0.3719902933,
0.2852301002,
-0.4718131423,
0.3320463896,
-0.2768397331,
0.051572293,
0.6074722409,
0.1157292277,
0.6135366559,
-0.4351890683,
0.3247005343,
0.0123864356,
0.3521075845,
-0.4306971729,
-0.3350575268,
-1.2260733843,
-0.4631543458,
0.2059771866,
0.2952742577,
-0.5075426698,
0.5616631508,
-0.2960680425,
-0.1908278912,
-0.66067487,
0.1683433652,
0.3319619298,
0.2268990725,
0.4726299047,
-0.4155880511,
-0.7714575529,
-0.9756507277,
-0.2739210427,
0.0025728971,
-0.0548543893,
0.3782904744,
0.0472481176,
-0.1041665375,
1.0745612383,
-0.1762111038,
-0.5222760439,
-0.2858157754,
0.037805263,
0.0812829435,
0.4990755916,
0.6120052338,
-0.7040438056,
-0.6915097237,
0.0613435954,
-0.7763412595,
-0.2036570609,
-0.1972390562,
-0.4545496404,
-0.2069162875,
0.3433437645,
-0.2294304371,
0.1373350173,
0.6244240999,
-0.0286321845,
-0.3028933108,
-0.030575864,
0.485822022,
-1.2771527767,
-0.1551467329,
0.0296352021,
-0.5382598639,
-0.7632384896,
0.6031191349,
0.3906942308,
0.0970840454,
-0.2494757324,
0.0284176301,
-0.625041604,
0.195754081,
-0.5889130235,
0.2664203048,
0.1778170764,
0.9817300439,
0.313321799,
0.4970265627,
0.6187514067,
-0.6584950686,
0.0204277318,
0.4948406816,
0.4401555657,
0.7622768283,
-0.7831786275,
0.5992477536,
-0.0289637763,
0.0278212633,
-1.1053529978,
-0.2867952883,
0.1630786657,
-0.4205571711,
0.5036520958,
0.2608029842,
-0.1185766086,
-0.0751883164,
-0.5701304674,
0.4842990637,
0.2182629257,
-0.9841154218,
1.2313811779,
0.7144250274,
-0.1166039854,
-0.6080138683,
-0.5459651351,
0.0056370809,
0.0558350049,
-0.5648251772,
0.3316135108,
-0.022597665,
-0.0798366219,
-0.1029961035,
0.0589007437,
-0.0496761724,
-0.1786289364,
0.1456746906,
0.0666954517,
-0.0029030978,
0.1435335726,
0.4251748323,
-0.1524305046,
-0.1275511384,
-0.1023194641,
0.2923098803,
-0.2035225481,
-0.6144313812,
-0.3940984309,
0.5980213284,
0.6696639657,
-0.4714034796,
0.4243524373,
0.3651191294,
-0.3867034912,
0.1828633398,
-0.8080093265,
-0.5724354982,
-0.4886570871,
0.5717257261,
-0.5367228389,
-0.8427981734,
0.3719685972,
-0.1563557982,
0.4864876568,
0.568251431,
0.8142505288,
-0.0274909064,
0.9596705437,
1.0198427439,
-0.2557621896,
0.575389564,
0.0580014735,
0.2439140081,
-1.12928617,
-0.1080095544,
-0.284047991,
-0.4795273542,
-0.4782681167,
-0.2305103689,
0.7608965039,
-0.2721914649,
-0.1029892117,
0.4021724463,
-0.6368309855,
0.3342776299,
0.7559175491,
0.468704164,
0.3935706615,
-0.1346338093,
-0.0905241817,
-0.2332733124,
-0.7230284214,
0.0080274558,
1.040554285,
0.450250566,
0.9463234544,
0.3528933525,
0.8967200518,
-0.0994959027,
0.342882514,
-0.7140704393,
0.1973793656,
0.2459347397,
-0.4027367532,
-0.3133276105,
0.0205630437,
-0.6254895329,
0.8105350733,
-0.2798285782,
-0.2799014747,
0.4050529897,
0.3939035833,
-0.5679214001,
0.117623128,
-0.7733185291,
0.674464643,
-0.156648159,
-0.7212082744,
-0.6012306213,
-0.6479155421,
0.2047499269,
-0.1376332343,
0.1353902817,
0.3465448916,
-0.0783931762,
0.6635840535,
-0.1326136887,
1.0526485443,
-0.0059139328,
0.1992880404,
0.2453013361,
-0.0814780667,
0.4348504841,
0.13119784,
0.3080027103,
-0.021681888,
-0.2911321223,
-0.2623223662,
-0.5120459199,
0.5882562995,
-0.8762819767,
-0.8977244496,
-0.3875729144,
-0.5011162758,
-0.07744544,
0.2180568278,
-0.1076873988,
0.2392500341,
-0.07789132,
0.3941704631,
0.4398439825,
0.1879119575,
0.5274024606,
0.5615559816,
-0.4106475115,
-0.5949970484,
0.7482844591,
-0.047730647,
0.4456543922,
0.5351250768,
0.2781228125,
-0.1339531094,
-0.1092582047,
-0.3629396558,
-0.0221399572,
-0.7149010897,
-0.2156486213,
-1.1066576242,
-0.0916420221,
-0.5567227006,
-0.0091860406,
-0.4739827812,
-0.4498046041,
0.1054936573,
-0.142687425,
0.381721586,
0.8410122991,
-0.3165946305,
0.3960077465,
-0.7163618803,
0.5566647053,
0.6343275905,
0.2443071306,
0.1277600378,
-0.7222220898,
-0.1454694569,
-0.2539298534,
-0.807215631,
-0.9382578135,
0.2095682919,
0.4936971366,
0.8449884653,
0.5333905816,
0.052581504,
0.5710172653,
-0.5141693354,
0.3801076114,
0.2467666417,
-1.0776395798,
0.3667270839,
-0.1627944112,
0.4148970842,
0.7441934347,
0.0871363804,
-0.7085226774,
-0.737487793,
-0.484592706,
-0.7159202695,
0.4378950596,
0.0677662715,
0.0950768292,
0.0177675616,
0.0495415181,
0.2961975038,
0.2055474073,
-0.9540274143,
-0.41549173,
-0.2565922439,
-0.4160045385,
0.581350565,
-0.119491674,
0.041102767,
-0.5692504048,
0.5448381305,
-0.3131220043,
0.4511242509,
0.4893524945,
-0.2662812173,
-0.2432808876,
0.1683059782,
0.3590487838,
0.7264316678,
-0.0301103201,
0.1731610894,
0.3683597445,
-0.5249085426,
-0.1474489868,
-0.0270910412,
-0.152188465,
-0.2123997509,
0.1677118987,
0.6505926847,
0.4491295516,
0.1490091681,
0.5487892628,
-0.144593209,
-0.2751236856,
-0.1274911463,
-0.3877861798,
-0.0709407777,
0.2747354209,
0.2463451624,
0.3751496375,
0.3832015097,
-0.2977524102,
0.6330562234,
0.3725597858,
-0.3476363122,
-0.4078768194,
0.7971986532,
0.7935307622,
-0.1316404343,
0.3808498681,
0.1350207925,
-0.8145737648,
0.3820353448,
0.3536574841,
0.9659554958,
-0.5156927705,
-0.1123973727,
0.4679085314,
0.7151076794,
0.2241387814,
0.4138249755,
-0.2785044909,
-0.7239810824,
-0.47085917,
-0.0812133849,
-0.9175347686,
-0.297188282,
-0.7631421685,
0.4247709215,
-0.1717654318,
0.0802158713,
-0.2273073494,
-0.3917065263,
-0.8163503408,
0.1216217056,
0.035792131,
0.2741116881,
-0.8410565853,
0.8727921247,
0.5218170285,
-0.5913665891,
-0.6406569481,
0.1945891678,
-0.2133001387,
-0.8415116668,
0.0743801966,
0.2401519865,
-0.1740088463,
0.0981778353,
-0.3282215595,
-1.0261460543,
0.8328993917,
0.207036227,
-0.9348131418,
0.0793394372,
-0.225440979,
0.2568642497,
-0.3894774616,
0.9183648229,
0.3969163001,
0.5735999942,
-0.2443401814,
-1.3456782103,
0.0768741295,
-0.070084773,
-0.5954771638,
0.1529083848,
-1.2739746571,
0.6254189014,
-0.3440499902,
-0.0568239614,
-0.4976687431,
1.1442556381,
-0.0161636379,
0.1347790509,
0.6997089982,
0.5095048547,
0.4626173675,
-0.0097657181,
0.8529496789,
-0.6130563617,
0.612465024,
1.1887506247,
-0.2765956521,
0.9354397655,
0.8842953444,
-0.1604557484,
0.2405405641,
0.3989619911,
0.2020559907,
0.7388737798,
-0.4612340331,
-0.0254533049,
-0.3650047183,
0.0049883192,
-0.3170796037,
0.5046249032,
0.1513987929,
-0.2913331091,
-0.178431496,
0.2647518814,
-0.2627219856,
0.2219521552,
-0.2500732541,
1.0245896578,
0.1919146031,
-0.7688093185,
0.1421080232,
-0.257101953,
0.7836042047,
-0.2751285434,
-0.2289157212,
0.0290161632,
0.2830689847,
-0.1538698226,
-0.5215398669,
0.1964747161,
-0.4964498878,
-0.1259671301,
-0.1720133722,
0.5615056157,
-0.7356271148,
-0.4534574747,
0.3685887158,
0.8081701994,
-0.1159634814,
-0.0855068564,
-0.4692148268,
-0.0372836106,
0.0288949665,
-0.5163677931,
0.1722415239,
0.1696713716,
0.3217684031,
0.3483051658,
0.0638358369,
-0.3787102699,
0.0347099602,
0.3979353607,
1.0611747503,
-0.3784022331,
-0.7674310207,
-0.8121724129,
0.2783149481,
-0.2737962604,
-0.1506868452,
0.8171859384,
0.3705332577,
0.8141096234,
0.0227559675,
0.9933748245,
-0.0781777501,
0.6173983812,
-0.2312420756,
0.5359756351,
-0.5751447082,
-0.1979693919,
-0.2445134819,
-0.9998794794,
-0.3087680042,
0.8666547537,
-0.0900548324,
0.3661352396,
1.1265733242,
0.441049993,
-0.2999621332,
0.124655664,
0.4994307756,
-0.0057270867,
0.2165477574,
0.5492410064,
0.5686648488,
-0.459762156,
0.4595454931,
-0.5572234988,
-0.4973730743,
-0.034365017,
-0.7006105781,
-1.1269431114,
-0.6173002124,
-0.3414286077,
-0.0937658101,
-0.1291101426,
1.3892941475,
0.8260338306,
-0.8607755303,
-0.1457979232,
0.0425612405,
-0.2060788572,
-0.4944358766,
-0.1496218145,
0.3975843191,
-0.3395286798,
-1.1035821438,
0.2453683913,
0.5272144675,
-0.388502419,
-0.2861569226,
-0.0026542845,
-0.2447386086,
0.0229132343,
0.5808846951,
0.0150070991,
-0.8124212027,
-0.6525628567,
0.235299468,
-0.0421136245,
0.5087552071,
0.7812060118,
-0.5999063849,
0.790592134,
0.4526019096,
0.8642045259,
0.4670769572,
0.2007917613,
0.8062059283,
-0.7089161873,
0.1017264649,
-0.0329068601,
0.4396436214,
0.1965531409,
-0.6284311414,
0.3780192733,
-0.0338987447,
-0.7531211972,
-0.2505322993,
0.0700434595,
-1.1821262836,
0.2531279027,
0.8856153488,
0.0094314562,
-0.2943916917,
-0.2095315009,
-0.5205444694,
0.3258124888,
-0.5945242047,
0.7951209545,
0.5609782934,
-0.3342311382,
-0.5160105228,
-0.390894711,
0.1280851513,
0.8509995341,
-0.9204034209,
-0.0000526143,
0.137606293,
0.030502528,
0.17306225,
0.581692934,
0.1674042344,
0.5306616426,
-0.2012799978,
0.4226313531,
-0.0298185591,
-0.6480854154,
-0.4392868578,
0.2215172052,
0.1642279029,
-0.573184967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10192v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10192v2 | Adam: Dense Retrieval Distillation with Adaptive Dark Examples | 2022-12-20T12:03:19 | 2024-06-06T15:20:27 | Chongyang Tao, Chang Liu, Tao Shen, Can Xu, Xiubo Geng, Binxing Jiao, Daxin Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | To improve the performance of the dual-encoder retriever, one effective
approach is knowledge distillation from the cross-encoder ranker. Existing
works construct the candidate passages following the supervised learning
setting where a query is paired with a positive passage and a batch of
negatives. However, through empirical observation, we find that even the hard
negatives from advanced methods are still too trivial for the teacher to
distinguish, preventing the teacher from transferring abundant dark knowledge
to the student through its soft label. To alleviate this issue, we propose
ADAM, a knowledge distillation framework that can better transfer the dark
knowledge held in the teacher with Adaptive Dark exAMples. Different from
previous works that only rely on one positive and hard negatives as candidate
passages, we create dark examples that all have moderate relevance to the query
through mixing-up and masking in discrete space. Furthermore, as the quality of
knowledge held in different training instances varies as measured by the
teacher's confidence score, we propose a self-paced distillation strategy that
adaptively concentrates on a subset of high-quality instances to conduct our
dark-example-based knowledge distillation to help the student learn better. We
conduct experiments on two widely-used benchmarks and verify the effectiveness
of our method. | [
-0.2453187108,
-0.7877322435,
0.7998500466,
-0.0979129076,
-0.5318198204,
0.3740271032,
-0.1836555749,
-0.3660100996,
0.2255789787,
0.1555588245,
0.0903065279,
-0.3443256021,
-0.8415806293,
0.1988871098,
-0.6493071914,
1.0261356831,
0.0228057913,
0.030335458,
-0.2476405203,
-0.2297932208,
-0.711127758,
-0.3905436099,
-0.8629831672,
-0.3944588602,
0.5954048038,
0.5198785067,
0.4194478393,
0.5028603077,
0.2663861513,
0.3170617223,
-0.2704152763,
-0.0087832436,
-0.6180118322,
0.4318737984,
-0.5489116907,
-0.576854825,
0.1409412771,
-0.0192971844,
0.4273478985,
0.7020118833,
-0.340736866,
0.1319547147,
0.3838333189,
0.8015891314,
-0.8971915841,
-0.341088444,
-0.9525277019,
0.2707523406,
-0.0194767118,
-0.2803159058,
-0.1230558828,
-0.2693416178,
0.292557627,
-0.6129866242,
0.3649286926,
0.0160095524,
0.329713583,
0.6777229905,
-0.5709996819,
-0.3535526991,
-1.1461895704,
0.8885084987,
-0.6340914965,
0.220459938,
0.3720403612,
0.8000606894,
0.1467176825,
-0.9549531341,
-0.7277035713,
-0.0077266633,
0.1172246411,
0.2892398536,
0.0467685163,
-0.1326223314,
0.2017405778,
0.4333079457,
-0.035038799,
-0.2577869892,
-0.7381928563,
0.1163277179,
0.6175847054,
0.0767199025,
-0.2156967223,
0.3423413336,
-0.4794139266,
-0.2742432356,
-0.2170185745,
-0.1627533734,
0.5626514554,
0.1480973512,
0.4556654394,
0.5104110241,
-0.0414061584,
0.7748776078,
0.4158728123,
-0.136805132,
0.2669862807,
-0.3849048018,
0.0133719547,
0.5557410717,
0.336838156,
0.3014321923,
-0.1228356436,
-0.263882786,
-0.1463931054,
-0.1860534698,
0.5683666468,
-1.1449319124,
-0.4314576983,
0.0618226677,
-0.3683286011,
-0.0784049183,
-0.3349794149,
-0.9403822422,
-0.6009201407,
-0.5415330529,
0.8536416292,
-0.4635787308,
-0.2320234329,
0.1711824387,
-0.7423054576,
-0.1034944579,
0.3952669203,
-0.8441281915,
0.4806667864,
0.4248110056,
0.5393989682,
-0.2193685323,
-0.1570224464,
-0.2185106128,
0.1254669428,
-0.1456567496,
0.3094072938,
-0.6494999528,
-0.0208574422,
-0.370333612,
-0.2891909182,
0.2318913937,
-0.7608644366,
0.4948354363,
-0.4772473872,
0.2232926488,
-0.3103366196,
-0.7717420459,
-0.4679268003,
0.2881726623,
-0.3485770822,
1.0257552862,
0.1467127204,
-0.6240469217,
0.6367528439,
-0.2675085962,
-0.3418206275,
0.1531288326,
-0.1923008263,
-0.3187652528,
0.295294106,
0.0818309262,
0.3649821877,
-0.013133714,
0.2061023265,
-0.3634854555,
-0.7924821973,
-0.0881323144,
-0.433465749,
0.7077957392,
0.3458910584,
-0.4969169497,
-0.4006292522,
-1.032281518,
-0.3241173327,
0.3324283659,
-0.3067837059,
-1.0642257929,
0.1826515645,
-0.3836044073,
-0.0885644928,
0.0618120097,
-0.6541382074,
0.2047502548,
-0.1174258515,
0.3622298539,
0.6148669124,
0.2513453066,
0.4856404066,
-0.1769546419,
0.2547501028,
0.2892996967,
-0.0703475475,
0.2375859916,
-0.2152940035,
-0.8027834892,
0.0503840931,
0.3397916555,
0.4445886016,
-1.0330319405,
0.4071622193,
0.1750905216,
-0.5501336455,
-0.6886996627,
0.5460764766,
0.1518698186,
0.9056580663,
0.8324773908,
-0.3194121718,
-0.4330741763,
-0.6284829378,
-0.253875047,
0.0937856734,
0.1365800202,
0.4305132031,
0.430200547,
0.021171134,
0.7855360508,
-0.5550397635,
-0.3853384256,
0.0953914449,
0.1118579954,
0.4530147314,
0.6029399633,
0.8527400494,
-0.8446835876,
-0.5187199116,
-0.3209158182,
-0.7392290235,
0.3591183722,
-0.0592122786,
-0.2747313678,
-0.4095624387,
0.6002456546,
0.2471274585,
0.2830675542,
0.3058301508,
-0.500059545,
0.173244983,
-0.2726891935,
0.2098735571,
-1.2530634403,
-0.2688580751,
-0.1279740036,
-0.2644487321,
-0.2696478069,
-0.1036509126,
-0.1446234733,
0.1132342666,
-0.5708633661,
0.3224099874,
-0.2824496329,
0.1992206424,
-0.3891631067,
-0.0327712744,
0.3161965907,
0.3774974346,
-0.0843937472,
0.7671893239,
0.4200787842,
-0.6430335641,
0.4886382818,
0.1530710161,
-0.3606079817,
0.817500174,
-0.7319328785,
0.3446484506,
-0.2883449495,
-0.0703248605,
-1.1794555187,
0.4985394478,
0.0421320647,
-0.0897225738,
0.5914707184,
-0.6224666238,
-0.2274337113,
-0.4219474196,
-0.1309027374,
0.5673822761,
0.6636359096,
-0.755698204,
0.7059596777,
-0.0885951221,
-0.0410026684,
-0.9046161771,
-0.8851918578,
0.1274153292,
-0.5427743196,
-0.2437173426,
0.371570617,
-0.2732625008,
-0.1722637564,
0.3292805552,
-0.4092923403,
-0.2760443389,
0.4626686871,
-0.0442041904,
0.0232418366,
-0.1840745509,
0.0340499245,
0.4460133612,
0.1345477998,
0.0894699991,
-0.5014033318,
0.0444569476,
0.2431627065,
-0.3230696321,
-0.2812252939,
0.2126730084,
0.1998211741,
0.2868530154,
0.9660184979,
0.7130785584,
-0.3066714704,
-0.3887653947,
-0.6763060093,
-0.5524337888,
-0.4984817803,
0.2076834291,
-0.3704369664,
-0.8035317659,
0.4864539206,
-0.1023495272,
0.0911799744,
0.2809798419,
0.3174761236,
-0.2107143551,
0.8225075006,
0.472804904,
0.2319582552,
0.7025431395,
-0.4313693643,
0.1155070737,
-0.7979168892,
-0.1466417462,
-0.5803831816,
-0.9061508775,
-0.1164447069,
-0.1379574239,
0.2643770576,
0.4037195444,
-0.1239496619,
0.4235825837,
-1.0604478121,
0.7722931504,
0.8068045378,
0.1955247521,
0.4115742445,
-0.0224315803,
-0.2533864081,
-0.1107940003,
-0.5589932799,
-0.1103941277,
1.4272512197,
-0.0295372475,
0.8429903388,
0.1622394323,
1.3595349789,
0.3671341538,
0.0782310665,
-0.4397178888,
0.207825914,
-0.2263277918,
-1.064814806,
-0.2555727363,
-0.5636326671,
-0.8690404296,
0.4409037232,
-0.3461939991,
-0.2854734659,
0.6842001677,
0.2542226613,
-0.5383217335,
0.2786776721,
-1.1923116446,
0.7112388015,
-0.348913461,
-0.7130645514,
-0.244062081,
-0.598854363,
0.2422961146,
-0.1765255481,
-0.1055372506,
-0.163473174,
0.043569915,
0.778824687,
-0.2534650862,
0.6217189431,
-0.72797364,
0.1406871378,
0.5629338622,
0.2295505553,
0.3550337255,
0.1471875161,
-0.3255766332,
-0.077424705,
0.2421962321,
-0.4957562685,
-0.7984292507,
0.4915674627,
-0.9408224225,
-0.6732132435,
-0.4778775275,
-0.2817910016,
0.0530138575,
0.2574618459,
0.0688885599,
0.0356877781,
0.0228449199,
0.4766268432,
0.6355229616,
0.0560421944,
0.4149812162,
0.526796937,
0.0792359933,
-0.3161289394,
0.9498851895,
0.38586092,
0.103062734,
0.317735672,
0.3548863828,
-0.3929628432,
-1.2047815323,
-0.4424937963,
-0.2748636603,
-0.7545393109,
-0.4455787241,
-0.6205269098,
-0.1240691319,
-0.2230288684,
-0.3267993033,
-0.4679631591,
-0.5720827579,
-0.5266388059,
-0.0470579639,
0.4680151641,
0.5518174171,
0.036982812,
0.0794962198,
-0.5294001102,
0.3831849098,
0.9375889897,
0.252227515,
0.2290696055,
-0.7903729677,
-0.1117155626,
0.1155098081,
-0.4269891679,
-0.622107923,
0.1968842745,
0.392611593,
0.598999083,
0.2372587472,
0.4432488978,
0.8500406146,
-0.4547330141,
0.6426522732,
0.174733609,
-0.7138456702,
0.5549550056,
0.2100533098,
-0.1755954176,
1.3616402149,
0.5100045204,
-0.0831127241,
-0.4190295637,
-0.4545767903,
-1.0618773699,
0.5705052614,
0.1063336805,
0.358843416,
0.1553625911,
0.712215662,
0.5148931146,
0.2671000063,
-0.5543026924,
-0.4060557187,
-0.5298617482,
-0.4101169407,
-0.1504022032,
-0.233214125,
-0.4063732624,
-0.607080996,
0.6708999276,
-0.1896419525,
-0.0441800728,
0.4188817739,
-0.1833421588,
0.0933656991,
0.3812879622,
0.1842729002,
0.7122344375,
-0.6369982362,
0.6180006266,
0.4217468202,
-0.6385157108,
0.3929744065,
0.4543746114,
-0.2054062635,
-0.2615492642,
-0.0595573634,
0.5762318373,
-0.0530281067,
-0.2380906343,
0.5640015006,
-0.371145606,
-0.4601259232,
-0.3808723688,
0.5199583173,
-0.0086511206,
0.6286450028,
0.8029127717,
0.1968806386,
0.6498972774,
-0.5279937387,
0.1094240919,
0.1102013364,
-0.3783218265,
-0.1111266091,
0.8458352685,
0.2471767366,
-0.0236254707,
0.6930962205,
-0.4725321531,
-0.1610746831,
0.4421130419,
0.6064338088,
0.7737827897,
-0.0484808944,
-0.2609425187,
0.4428576827,
0.0349169746,
-0.0944013596,
0.2125644535,
-0.5092614293,
-0.7072653174,
-0.3965581357,
-0.8168069124,
-0.3637421727,
-0.1355782598,
-0.7304092646,
0.1092739478,
-0.5135647058,
-0.1005162895,
0.3784623742,
0.2495187074,
-0.6889731884,
-0.0786595643,
0.1637561023,
0.8051214814,
-0.8660689592,
0.7766708136,
0.4839200079,
-0.4371943772,
-0.6897636056,
-0.4786145389,
-0.1421584189,
-0.7482804656,
0.3088255823,
-0.1162031516,
0.1466096193,
0.0843271762,
-0.5124981403,
-0.7104487419,
1.4466227293,
0.4916593432,
-0.9217697382,
0.0124586597,
-0.2405792773,
0.6501727104,
-0.1340631545,
0.3327697515,
0.4680081904,
0.297772795,
0.664408505,
-0.3173591793,
0.1006929204,
-0.1304795742,
-0.1189492121,
0.1327121705,
-0.4814858437,
0.5655888915,
-0.0826876834,
-0.0625294372,
-0.1611414403,
0.661101222,
0.0610014424,
0.7297864556,
0.6143193841,
1.004539609,
0.6317450404,
0.0168153234,
0.7058201432,
-0.1121334732,
0.2161802202,
1.4810484648,
-0.4469650388,
0.57232517,
0.782599628,
-0.2862039506,
0.6978781819,
0.2686679661,
-0.2390077561,
0.7834286094,
0.1513044983,
-0.1959765702,
-0.2416046858,
0.0325829834,
-0.5805009604,
0.2869384885,
0.2133818716,
-0.464933008,
-0.2440985143,
0.0970045477,
-0.2801699936,
0.1787589639,
-0.2104520947,
1.1276123524,
0.0695553496,
-0.7194855809,
0.6848867536,
-0.3791894019,
0.7706273198,
-0.3509473503,
-0.4293836653,
-0.0961321145,
0.4455949962,
-0.1601359397,
-0.879825592,
0.3537591398,
-0.3760429919,
-0.1539450586,
-0.2995939851,
0.6999051571,
-0.6747705936,
-0.513698101,
0.4416962266,
0.492613405,
0.2500643432,
-0.0000202863,
-0.7531517744,
-0.2748965621,
-0.0416005887,
-0.0675325021,
0.3011931181,
0.6735146046,
0.4844200909,
0.0949406102,
0.6838679314,
0.0246838685,
0.2452598959,
0.0886137411,
0.918892622,
-0.6136542559,
-0.2398792505,
-0.8376220465,
0.3181180358,
-0.1861751527,
-0.2227989584,
0.8589219451,
0.5863162279,
0.96305269,
0.2830748856,
0.4646151364,
-0.0533914343,
0.5110116601,
-0.226208508,
0.6460298896,
-0.798597455,
0.1887882501,
-0.1862365603,
-1.3135019541,
0.0067593483,
0.5167830586,
-0.0621700212,
0.029632153,
0.4915517569,
0.3689347804,
-0.2916664183,
-0.0226305164,
0.2985375822,
0.2115724236,
0.1986943483,
0.6564872265,
0.9746214151,
-0.5581157207,
0.6409420371,
-0.5881242752,
-0.0136969239,
-0.3126010895,
-0.8860372901,
-0.9835124016,
-0.4686358869,
-0.4221026897,
-0.4613676667,
0.1833861619,
0.6994103789,
0.8752385974,
-0.7952539921,
0.2719951868,
-0.1340997815,
0.3789450526,
-0.5165470839,
-0.2295950353,
0.2059307843,
-0.2600975335,
-0.7055515647,
0.4103431702,
-0.0523225367,
0.3338268399,
0.0058023776,
0.0741545036,
-0.2741236985,
-0.0459898449,
0.3028362393,
0.1171532273,
-0.1450441927,
-0.4163256288,
-0.2568958402,
0.1354919225,
0.1542550176,
0.7652816772,
-0.9725015163,
0.7568932772,
0.3535007834,
0.8436668515,
1.0876951218,
-0.0545948558,
0.1248044968,
-0.9365878105,
0.1614294648,
0.7328340411,
0.3925324678,
0.2349651307,
-0.4595596492,
0.5815315843,
0.4040304124,
-0.6158806682,
-0.7704925537,
-0.2104349136,
-0.9581267238,
-0.4602919519,
0.8807091713,
-0.0499654189,
-0.223019734,
-0.4267109632,
-0.0766818225,
0.301151365,
-0.5320049524,
1.0925016403,
0.5384905338,
0.1408880502,
0.0834597498,
-0.3445817828,
0.2003572136,
0.3975756764,
-0.2556439042,
-0.1756700873,
0.2915835679,
0.6840251684,
0.4233342707,
0.3744806051,
0.0290526859,
0.0909470618,
0.2835608125,
-0.0150417723,
-0.5656872988,
-0.41756019,
-0.3032067716,
0.2267551869,
0.0861408859,
-0.238465175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10191v1 | Emotion Selectable End-to-End Text-based Speech Editing | 2022-12-20T12:02:40 | 2022-12-20T12:02:40 | Tao Wang, Jiangyan Yi, Ruibo Fu, Jianhua Tao, Zhengqi Wen, Chu Yuan Zhang | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Text-based speech editing allows users to edit speech by intuitively cutting,
copying, and pasting text to speed up the process of editing speech. In the
previous work, CampNet (context-aware mask prediction network) is proposed to
realize text-based speech editing, significantly improving the quality of
edited speech. This paper aims at a new task: adding emotional effect to the
editing speech during the text-based speech editing to make the generated
speech more expressive. To achieve this task, we propose Emo-CampNet (emotion
CampNet), which can provide the option of emotional attributes for the
generated speech in text-based speech editing and has the one-shot ability to
edit unseen speakers' speech. Firstly, we propose an end-to-end
emotion-selectable text-based speech editing model. The key idea of the model
is to control the emotion of generated speech by introducing additional emotion
attributes based on the context-aware mask prediction network. Secondly, to
prevent the emotion of the generated speech from being interfered by the
emotional components in the original speech, a neutral content generator is
proposed to remove the emotion from the original speech, which is optimized by
the generative adversarial framework. Thirdly, two data augmentation methods
are proposed to enrich the emotional and pronunciation information in the
training set, which can enable the model to edit the unseen speaker's speech.
The experimental results that 1) Emo-CampNet can effectively control the
emotion of the generated speech in the process of text-based speech editing;
And can edit unseen speakers' speech. 2) Detailed ablation experiments further
prove the effectiveness of emotional selectivity and data augmentation methods.
The demo page is available at https://hairuo55.github.io/Emo-CampNet/ | [
-0.496265173,
-1.0046728849,
0.2441431731,
0.0876279697,
-0.1201415434,
0.198548615,
-0.5183239579,
-0.5321682096,
0.66067487,
0.4900050163,
-0.6500391364,
-0.5051707625,
-0.5627682209,
0.2689936459,
-0.6162651181,
0.8382177353,
0.003834368,
-0.1680908352,
0.1924768239,
-0.0029307175,
-0.1451463103,
-0.5101925135,
-1.0638566017,
-0.3994810879,
0.5661628842,
0.4393202364,
0.787291348,
0.5556668639,
0.1246628836,
0.3204932511,
-0.6248227954,
-0.1140443087,
-0.4563164413,
0.4167902768,
-0.1013400778,
-0.2801184654,
-0.6702087522,
0.0271907505,
0.3155019581,
-0.0032302749,
-0.3603430092,
-0.1272432804,
-0.499856323,
0.7991133332,
-0.6352270246,
-0.4215362072,
-0.8379933238,
0.4557985365,
-0.0855412111,
-0.0639643893,
-0.4220387042,
-0.0053613279,
0.173790589,
-0.4700250626,
0.0459724218,
0.0092142411,
0.4178604186,
0.6648392081,
-0.1758413911,
-0.336389184,
-0.5238034129,
0.3486128747,
-0.6770267487,
0.3988344669,
0.3409816325,
0.090536274,
0.0565512367,
-0.6699030995,
-0.8058674335,
-0.0223580152,
0.3731198311,
0.6568983197,
-0.3573995829,
0.5035303235,
0.209401086,
0.2379406095,
-0.5181190968,
0.1060292199,
-0.1471178234,
0.289939642,
0.6688923836,
-0.0906981602,
0.689520359,
-0.2324348837,
0.1096398607,
0.0208808184,
-0.4349114001,
-0.0076809651,
0.5666355491,
0.2381855994,
-0.1055378094,
0.8484441638,
-0.5071259141,
0.5944852233,
0.0573850758,
0.3450756967,
0.2609755099,
0.5397407413,
-0.598731041,
0.6928523183,
0.624429822,
0.3498691022,
0.3953620195,
-0.1434106082,
-0.113605909,
0.1427682787,
0.2573404014,
-0.724404037,
0.0615458377,
0.7219609618,
-0.3894366324,
-0.6455414295,
-0.3953716755,
-0.9855973125,
-0.3016960919,
-0.335611105,
0.3567140102,
-0.4229532778,
-0.1938316077,
-0.1133834794,
-0.3810370862,
-0.2366383076,
0.3381815255,
-0.8045127988,
0.2058834434,
0.4961916506,
0.9902701378,
-0.1384297609,
-0.0676630139,
-0.2966633141,
0.0429634154,
-0.2037683874,
0.5589006543,
-0.9771121144,
-0.2919417322,
0.0074603488,
-0.0841118917,
0.0569565333,
-0.1275607944,
0.4915875196,
-0.4831552505,
0.3703941405,
0.2272824198,
-0.5954893231,
-0.1743919402,
0.1153646633,
-0.6494487524,
0.8385617137,
0.0208589006,
-0.6027969718,
0.0258808341,
-0.8721413612,
-0.3188432157,
-0.249577418,
0.3565100729,
-0.3674883842,
0.2538236678,
0.2656133175,
0.205987379,
0.031676095,
0.1295251846,
-0.1951126456,
-0.1807163507,
0.5776758194,
-0.3024957478,
0.4919454753,
0.289044112,
-0.4133853614,
0.296356678,
-0.9946891665,
0.1099565625,
-0.1990644932,
-0.1940678805,
0.0149391023,
0.0211281385,
0.3003030121,
0.5504935384,
-0.0557985716,
-0.9124171734,
-0.1921683103,
-0.6485719681,
0.5432913303,
0.8372898698,
0.0331280194,
0.3057112992,
-0.1779055595,
0.7261227965,
-0.375739336,
0.2019528598,
-0.174372077,
-0.5586197972,
-0.7265513539,
-0.365178436,
0.1282095462,
0.9154620767,
-0.6550819278,
0.1593609303,
0.1101155505,
-0.4539650679,
-0.752530396,
-0.0794077143,
0.4326638281,
0.5628584027,
0.3794732988,
-0.0138990805,
-0.794021368,
-0.596878171,
-0.4747984111,
0.058126051,
-0.0276982486,
0.3367757797,
0.1229414567,
-0.1790586263,
0.9836153984,
-0.2925485075,
-0.1157617941,
0.0065870895,
-0.0253993403,
-0.0961040258,
0.4490656853,
0.1518675983,
-0.8828797936,
-0.660759449,
0.1840686649,
-0.6045423746,
-0.5169615149,
-0.0961609259,
-0.1727995872,
0.1074915752,
0.1274555176,
-0.4810989797,
0.3963921964,
0.6681157947,
-0.2860515714,
0.2694630325,
-0.0608456172,
0.4364426434,
-1.1853820086,
-0.1276872903,
-0.1785422564,
-0.1559486836,
-0.9704225659,
-0.2616077662,
-0.1489742845,
-0.6060059667,
-0.8101300597,
0.5460875034,
-0.129618302,
0.0459615402,
-0.5584695339,
0.500761807,
-0.061587289,
0.6158518195,
0.0075829402,
0.5362582803,
0.5198159814,
-0.1350178868,
0.6180166602,
0.6781932712,
0.2126859576,
0.5781413317,
-0.5759368539,
0.4948355854,
-0.315452069,
0.1378564388,
-0.7678294182,
-0.3098295629,
0.1890383214,
-0.7994615436,
0.3600412607,
-0.1382044256,
-0.0292399582,
-0.0256500412,
-0.1441637129,
-0.0195459072,
0.5600066185,
-0.6649977565,
0.544737637,
0.4167067111,
-0.7099215984,
-0.4275692701,
-0.8498902321,
0.6666961312,
-0.2227462679,
-0.7268092036,
0.7249916196,
-0.1309459209,
-0.256822437,
0.1168917641,
0.1677345484,
-0.1352268904,
-0.2827557325,
0.5337060094,
0.0686301067,
0.3395104408,
0.2991089523,
0.6586167216,
-0.0202245582,
-0.129677549,
0.0720367059,
0.1369452477,
-0.0424300022,
0.0559547283,
-0.4251963198,
0.7076447606,
0.4957330227,
-0.2886478901,
0.5391834974,
0.5498168468,
-0.6318528056,
-0.2875426412,
-0.5622410178,
0.0417353958,
-0.4249280989,
0.4132857323,
-0.2861589491,
-1.1434011459,
0.6274953485,
-0.1773856431,
-0.1395291239,
0.2465411425,
0.4491398036,
-0.0689323321,
1.148665309,
0.2723436356,
0.3173675835,
0.9234271646,
0.0861874893,
-0.0972524062,
-1.1551212072,
-0.2038230151,
-0.4807225168,
-0.4881328046,
-0.6085005403,
-0.0852241591,
0.0845211744,
-0.1697781086,
-0.1252359897,
0.1463013887,
-0.8172567487,
0.2299659699,
0.2654682398,
0.4178964198,
-0.1217180118,
0.0227870867,
0.0869323611,
0.0136688994,
-0.4603714943,
-0.3126791418,
0.7966662049,
0.2256474495,
0.4676813185,
-0.1012845412,
0.6155555844,
0.5080674887,
0.4036883116,
-0.6184695363,
0.3411193788,
-0.3274061978,
-0.6429309845,
-0.5685146451,
-0.4101252556,
-0.377384901,
0.2500860989,
-0.3209539652,
-1.1462637186,
0.3609764278,
0.1916284412,
-0.1004827991,
0.2889060974,
-0.7141695619,
0.5652141571,
-0.0051090275,
-0.2920304835,
-0.3149490654,
-0.6639546752,
0.0558883213,
-0.1437072009,
0.1198612228,
-0.1580748111,
-0.0025234222,
0.9680818915,
-0.5135352612,
0.6710622907,
-0.0523935407,
0.1516012698,
0.4162543714,
0.0476580448,
0.7845284343,
-0.0092204632,
-0.6093155742,
-0.0054465751,
-0.4530213177,
0.1583195478,
-0.9959635735,
0.6526365876,
-0.5465878248,
-0.3267610371,
0.0038503883,
-0.3964965641,
-0.1512951106,
-0.0992808938,
0.2667460144,
0.5369871855,
-0.2513638437,
0.1065906882,
0.4914815724,
-0.5139356256,
0.7434701324,
0.3312134445,
-0.1509009451,
-1.1111696959,
0.8106241822,
0.1570810825,
0.3396342695,
0.4447057545,
0.2887396812,
-0.1351221949,
-0.0890117064,
-0.5069258809,
-0.1195308045,
-0.6755824089,
0.026166616,
-0.9800457954,
-0.0740426257,
-0.3387979567,
-0.7063716054,
-0.6047605872,
-0.7288101315,
-0.2638926208,
-0.1949054748,
0.7731227279,
0.3764028251,
-0.1580552906,
0.8955933452,
-0.4287957251,
0.4644840658,
0.3326985538,
0.4382534027,
-0.2766420841,
-0.6885829568,
-0.2239401937,
0.1589933187,
-0.2063726336,
-1.2579561472,
0.8161438107,
0.3913007081,
0.0870513916,
0.32647264,
0.0288384203,
0.5148044229,
-0.4427429438,
0.6287820339,
0.2794299424,
-1.4547041655,
0.8984116912,
-0.1905478984,
0.259149909,
0.217860207,
-0.1854794621,
-0.9920573831,
-0.5031131506,
-0.6519060731,
-0.797084868,
0.9813078046,
0.5265664458,
0.0836489424,
-0.0724559426,
0.4243003428,
-0.2101999521,
0.4884138107,
-0.4664902985,
-0.2777611315,
-0.4846100807,
-0.2730545998,
0.1224118471,
-0.3601516783,
0.0845348835,
0.0574226677,
0.9617907405,
0.1269860715,
0.4329859912,
0.5018476844,
0.1190114394,
-0.4231613874,
0.7063619494,
0.5689283609,
0.1037940904,
-0.4944078922,
0.037856251,
0.5174495578,
-0.3547588587,
0.0517612509,
0.0198277645,
-0.2420893759,
0.2370131165,
-0.0893907025,
1.2608026266,
0.1526109874,
-0.6186541915,
0.2119480222,
-0.0031675796,
-0.1456043124,
-0.1787838936,
-0.0438263528,
-0.1387873143,
0.2616657019,
0.0017417744,
0.3000053167,
0.3635618985,
-0.3307302296,
0.1900466681,
0.1590554267,
-0.8413097858,
-0.1458046883,
0.854169786,
0.3062314689,
-0.8585003018,
0.4335223436,
0.0087701427,
-0.7739189267,
0.7081766725,
0.673053205,
1.4049650431,
-0.634444952,
0.3056305647,
0.1213956848,
0.3134280443,
0.4121948183,
0.6423388124,
0.1293958575,
-0.5169636607,
-0.5103494525,
-0.3577781618,
-0.7887108922,
-0.1617079377,
-0.54570508,
0.1223240271,
-0.2806824744,
-0.2840628624,
-0.2919541597,
-0.4318450391,
-0.3612549603,
0.9176422954,
0.192647174,
0.6475384831,
-0.614764154,
0.4651078284,
0.6674796939,
0.0032808695,
-0.5885418653,
-0.5052317977,
0.0858342648,
-0.3223804235,
0.1824375391,
0.2033302635,
-0.1196491942,
0.1379633695,
-0.5248661637,
-0.6777628064,
0.9459133744,
0.3276842535,
-0.5514247417,
0.2034145147,
-0.0556770265,
0.651868403,
-0.4344694316,
0.6294291615,
0.1769095659,
0.2638797462,
0.3544305563,
-0.6097251773,
0.0044536642,
-0.6042225957,
0.0811912492,
0.0987827778,
-0.5590689778,
0.6830071807,
0.0116991224,
-0.0907732025,
-0.4317840636,
0.6493148208,
-0.0410314463,
0.4775888026,
0.569881022,
0.6568897367,
0.6591575146,
0.1198906377,
0.7916579247,
-0.4878984392,
0.1541322023,
1.1564110518,
-0.2559522092,
1.0859731436,
0.3554627001,
0.0134206936,
0.1902496368,
0.6115233302,
0.2136634141,
0.3764601648,
0.2422947884,
-0.7082567215,
0.0593408048,
-0.3685400784,
-0.3755309582,
0.6711040139,
0.3420864046,
-0.493858099,
0.2965616584,
0.4851784408,
0.1635353267,
-0.2008422017,
-0.2595737875,
0.7507025599,
0.0876431167,
-0.4875181913,
0.0261708125,
0.0797119588,
0.510242641,
-0.4378044605,
0.0018232754,
0.0545290373,
-0.3155346215,
-0.4784487784,
-0.6777665019,
0.3229838312,
0.5139340758,
-0.1865086555,
-0.3623621464,
0.8517842889,
-0.6577368379,
-0.3313514888,
0.4232855737,
0.2651214898,
0.2476824522,
-0.4334652424,
-0.5652086139,
0.2098602802,
-0.0049922094,
-0.7704029679,
0.1339736432,
0.4288350642,
0.4817184508,
0.5442640185,
0.7649760246,
0.4437853098,
0.111605756,
0.3595359325,
0.7600054741,
-0.5624167323,
-0.7707838416,
-0.8613275886,
0.7568967938,
-0.1589760929,
-0.3497456312,
0.1496525854,
0.3566760123,
0.4020766318,
-0.0046677603,
1.0174092054,
-0.2886750102,
0.3228236139,
-0.4654322565,
0.8119506836,
-0.4084266126,
-0.3966284096,
-0.8625533581,
-0.7839919925,
-0.1870545298,
0.4045000076,
-0.0871309042,
-0.0475308485,
0.5846399665,
0.9366173148,
0.479439646,
0.3510487378,
0.7655653954,
0.1966184825,
0.094227992,
0.3726324141,
0.6361772418,
-0.4077684879,
0.3791611195,
-0.5296733975,
-0.4263205528,
-0.0410600938,
-0.8263036609,
-0.6259925961,
-0.5189296603,
-0.5725492835,
-0.3401731551,
0.4395105541,
1.040667057,
0.5538275242,
-0.582644999,
0.1470590681,
-0.203488946,
0.1413809508,
-0.0358568691,
-0.2330144495,
0.2461893708,
-0.0483573824,
-0.9351466298,
0.7063147426,
0.6546792388,
0.0385525897,
0.4886722565,
-0.1929814816,
-0.0893093571,
0.368507266,
0.7069733739,
0.2226840705,
-0.6361138225,
-0.2464212328,
-0.0871276557,
0.2047624141,
-0.0314365067,
0.5517504215,
-0.500746429,
1.115359664,
0.4523739517,
0.6114702821,
0.3912915885,
-0.0349557027,
0.5277647972,
-0.7097151875,
0.0482602119,
-0.0568232052,
0.3576642275,
0.3340461254,
-0.6402363181,
0.4327938855,
-0.0038312611,
-0.7808788419,
-0.5929458141,
-0.0374386683,
-1.1151155233,
0.0846639276,
1.0839112997,
-0.1812439412,
-0.1686573476,
0.3385538161,
-0.572052896,
1.0238542557,
-0.5627707243,
0.8812036514,
0.712431252,
-0.2916407585,
-0.5439392924,
-0.5585392118,
0.4475164711,
0.6233956814,
-1.1550142765,
-0.0713531151,
0.3327591717,
-0.242829442,
-0.1478963047,
0.2674476802,
0.0855158567,
0.2761195004,
0.0409246236,
0.6069127321,
-0.4015224278,
-0.3275384307,
-0.6044442654,
0.2497849464,
-0.4969187677,
-0.2176409513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10190v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10190v1 | Pay Attention to Your Tone: Introducing a New Dataset for Polite Language Rewrite | 2022-12-20T12:02:34 | 2022-12-20T12:02:34 | Xun Wang, Tao Ge, Allen Mao, Yuki Li, Furu Wei, Si-Qing Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce \textsc{PoliteRewrite} -- a dataset for polite language rewrite
which is a novel sentence rewrite task. Compared with previous text style
transfer tasks that can be mostly addressed by slight token- or phrase-level
edits, polite language rewrite requires deep understanding and extensive
sentence-level edits over an offensive and impolite sentence to deliver the
same message euphemistically and politely, which is more challenging -- not
only for NLP models but also for human annotators to rewrite with effort. To
alleviate the human effort for efficient annotation, we first propose a novel
annotation paradigm by a collaboration of human annotators and GPT-3.5 to
annotate \textsc{PoliteRewrite}. The released dataset has 10K polite sentence
rewrites annotated collaboratively by GPT-3.5 and human, which can be used as
gold standard for training, validation and test; and 100K high-quality polite
sentence rewrites by GPT-3.5 without human review. We wish this work (The
dataset (10K+100K) will be released soon) could contribute to the research on
more challenging sentence rewrite, and provoke more thought in future on
resource annotation paradigm with the help of the large-scaled pretrained
models. | [
-0.0755164251,
-0.5889335275,
0.1737944633,
0.3218950629,
-0.2772686779,
-0.3052126169,
-0.424788624,
-0.3216740489,
0.2313710898,
0.7631089091,
-0.7390723825,
-0.4727757573,
-0.0552633516,
0.4154802561,
-0.213922143,
1.4406273365,
0.2454280853,
0.0403096117,
0.274520129,
-0.3327363431,
-0.4140304923,
-0.735776782,
-0.6766228676,
-0.252596736,
0.7053118348,
0.5199741125,
0.680028379,
0.5832019448,
0.6968138814,
0.3384556174,
-0.1148428544,
-0.2395513505,
-0.4380067587,
0.1604171991,
-0.2813147604,
-0.4174804688,
-0.7906556726,
0.2825008035,
0.4016985893,
0.8342673779,
-0.2323684394,
0.269471705,
-0.0223433748,
0.8412581086,
-0.25497666,
0.3159097731,
-0.7934784889,
0.1234885901,
-0.3374901712,
-0.115330033,
-0.407847017,
-0.6446316242,
0.0116413999,
-0.9027977586,
0.3744218946,
0.161170736,
0.841581881,
0.2648135722,
-0.0548141897,
0.0215029251,
-0.4763507247,
0.7549475431,
-0.4535184503,
0.2938918769,
0.2613790035,
0.3455349803,
-0.2146910131,
-1.0093723536,
-0.5781763196,
-0.2035071552,
0.1413771808,
0.0488499813,
0.0507196337,
0.149726361,
0.2069625407,
0.6377004981,
-0.1457768381,
-0.1443786174,
-0.313860476,
-0.3671520948,
0.7676999569,
-0.0368742645,
0.1269453615,
-0.3332546055,
-0.169928655,
0.0417287387,
-0.4911684394,
0.0946712047,
0.4937189519,
0.5198605657,
0.0339692421,
0.3442268372,
-0.5112034678,
0.2559852302,
0.1410791129,
0.1641730368,
0.6179805994,
-0.6014097333,
-0.1796081215,
-0.0699219108,
0.8998599052,
0.6687783599,
0.997456193,
-0.1829189956,
-0.1820390821,
0.1412884742,
0.203280881,
-0.6688882709,
-0.5699872971,
-0.1462618709,
-0.527369082,
-0.563818872,
-0.2791174352,
-0.7570766211,
-0.2924830616,
-0.4428290427,
-0.1209311336,
-0.3274395168,
-0.2129158676,
0.2130054533,
0.0126585718,
0.0971351936,
0.496116817,
-1.0636945963,
0.1485261917,
0.7959042788,
0.5920081735,
0.492536366,
-0.2153549939,
-0.4849136472,
-0.1088697538,
-0.1560336202,
0.838565886,
-0.6397251487,
-0.2199315578,
0.1008675769,
0.2076761574,
0.1464852244,
-0.376008302,
1.2203352451,
-0.1108256057,
0.2121101618,
-0.3804900646,
-0.2110722959,
-0.1965577751,
-0.0001963138,
-0.7365007401,
0.9439114332,
0.456687808,
-0.8194708824,
0.695617795,
-0.5409498215,
-0.5950546265,
0.1568411589,
0.1008305624,
-0.4602865279,
0.1537816674,
0.3082516789,
0.219623521,
-0.1280009151,
0.2203699797,
-0.3143519461,
-0.4798264503,
0.3719175756,
-0.4069460332,
0.8780081868,
0.291197896,
-0.2285591811,
0.2402042598,
-0.6213277578,
0.0217606258,
-0.1361087412,
-0.3971979022,
-0.0820342898,
-0.2049615681,
0.5351344943,
0.3645913005,
0.3158388138,
-0.5009915829,
0.2867543995,
-0.3430460989,
0.8305237889,
1.1124984026,
0.015297249,
0.481367439,
-0.336437434,
0.4595605433,
-0.4214757085,
0.3890579343,
-0.1622538418,
-0.3186614215,
-0.5214039087,
-0.1980020553,
0.146590516,
0.5230439901,
-0.3088415563,
0.0932024196,
-0.3442235887,
-0.3834404051,
-1.2405184507,
0.1478178352,
0.5548526049,
0.6544975638,
0.2988991737,
-0.2648403347,
-0.5974643826,
-1.1872391701,
-0.6704490185,
-0.4945203066,
0.0569330305,
0.2806644142,
0.2781711817,
0.0249332432,
0.7588014007,
-0.1798736602,
-0.4929278195,
-0.3467597067,
0.0930041298,
0.1818091571,
0.5010147095,
0.555398941,
-0.8282527924,
-0.2510557771,
-0.0674709603,
-0.4312957525,
-0.4522148371,
-0.1883535981,
-0.2635717392,
0.0622135587,
0.8263202906,
-0.0063397484,
-0.0686471984,
0.1716604829,
-0.3522441983,
0.4856184721,
0.0537034981,
0.4978464246,
-0.9960200787,
0.0045829881,
0.120211713,
-0.2421837747,
-0.4921205938,
-0.0259610657,
-0.2701514363,
-0.1088642254,
-0.3898139596,
0.3171724677,
-0.2223331034,
0.321141243,
0.0927708298,
0.1561055481,
0.014328422,
0.8747219443,
-0.1631946862,
0.6067009568,
0.3775596619,
-0.1534347981,
0.2712108195,
0.5754942298,
-0.1145279557,
0.9056628346,
-0.6219537258,
0.5395274162,
-0.2898564041,
0.3934389949,
-1.0147209167,
-0.2853685319,
0.5104600191,
-0.4135185778,
0.0500194579,
-0.5285607576,
-0.6250477433,
-0.3157253265,
-0.5547779202,
0.2590027452,
0.3462480903,
-0.3466932178,
0.3371168077,
0.4106256366,
-0.3973704576,
-0.4235624373,
-0.9701097012,
0.3065434098,
-0.3697161674,
-0.5966576934,
0.1131911129,
-0.065569751,
-0.2200514078,
-0.3644429445,
0.1871759742,
-0.2805133462,
0.1642186195,
0.2340200394,
0.1571182311,
-0.1321278661,
-0.0315137133,
-0.2104188651,
-0.1510485709,
0.2232459038,
-0.1061013639,
0.3157323599,
-0.3933243155,
0.1106029749,
-1.1334609985,
0.436611414,
0.5908581614,
-0.4553560019,
0.2460997254,
0.7165529728,
-0.1043076813,
0.2535472214,
-0.5359154344,
-0.2956704497,
-0.4950065613,
0.7245449424,
-0.497146666,
-0.8744856715,
0.4543332458,
0.1132030189,
0.5536818504,
0.2314593494,
0.3798656762,
-0.0614082552,
0.8978026509,
0.6977413893,
-0.4853583872,
0.7608332038,
0.3009711504,
0.2478994429,
-0.7064785957,
-0.1088642776,
-0.8339998126,
-0.3789199591,
-0.9565396905,
-0.1364071667,
-0.1600803286,
-0.0771915391,
-0.2987000942,
0.112861529,
-0.6370412707,
0.2000365257,
0.4602254331,
0.0810108036,
0.2971858382,
0.0582900345,
0.4704978764,
-0.5170591474,
-0.3848443627,
-0.714381218,
1.0744254589,
0.4234072268,
0.684292078,
0.0551274419,
0.5134032369,
0.0652094781,
0.6213744283,
-0.773159802,
0.7172953486,
-0.4796013832,
-0.3758558929,
-0.2269750684,
-0.4639395475,
-0.6217465401,
0.0012740809,
-0.1586104035,
-0.4805127382,
-0.1025465056,
0.5533335805,
-0.2802420259,
0.0907903314,
-0.9119778872,
0.9428907037,
0.2674947977,
-0.2760899067,
-0.0791777372,
-0.6008848548,
0.1231999323,
0.1464147866,
0.3712552488,
-0.3681271076,
0.0298330225,
0.8856915832,
-0.2337569892,
0.9426012039,
-0.2407111228,
-0.1499166042,
0.2599416375,
0.0803144872,
0.4429020286,
0.1085056737,
-0.4098802209,
-0.0311889332,
-0.4800366461,
-0.2028766274,
-0.3951180577,
0.4519516528,
-0.2593114078,
-0.2812202871,
-0.1551955044,
-0.6632067561,
-0.0693997815,
0.1227057204,
0.295607537,
0.3967042863,
-0.2016159147,
0.0061152154,
0.3847117424,
0.1613829434,
0.2192336917,
0.205852747,
0.1143551841,
-0.3465346396,
0.768356204,
-0.0505203642,
0.0338798836,
0.198029682,
0.1852399707,
-0.3607434034,
-0.543644309,
-0.3273691535,
0.1835337728,
-0.4788326323,
0.0548875108,
-0.6847683191,
0.2080762684,
-0.7430833578,
-0.449890703,
-0.2623824775,
-0.4723508656,
-0.0743195489,
0.1066659167,
0.7351292372,
0.5035686493,
-0.0344832949,
0.3305504322,
-0.3600949049,
0.3330747783,
0.0796347037,
0.43121773,
-0.4710244238,
-0.8913164139,
0.0142028807,
-0.1551521719,
0.0208192952,
-0.6570149064,
0.1072436944,
0.3796075284,
0.2228552997,
0.1881644428,
0.0013015844,
0.6713348031,
-0.8231753707,
0.4854560792,
0.0811318457,
-0.8413319588,
0.5730928779,
-0.5837484598,
0.1945111305,
1.2032049894,
-0.1593860835,
-1.0041787624,
-0.6610730886,
-0.6804915667,
-1.0959297419,
0.5522705913,
0.1300300211,
0.411883086,
-0.2955855131,
0.7684016228,
-0.0537189171,
0.3273708224,
-0.644028008,
-0.1050622091,
-0.3974463344,
-0.3457334638,
0.0386088118,
-0.3106426597,
0.190629527,
-0.111158669,
0.5949417353,
-0.1997111291,
0.015145136,
0.2052947134,
-0.0002546231,
-0.0225094315,
0.5544735789,
0.1708210409,
0.0325556844,
-0.2734675705,
-0.3074676692,
0.0685127378,
-0.6954419613,
-0.0390121266,
-0.0974086747,
-0.2305921912,
0.0292561892,
0.3737638295,
0.3879549801,
0.5324747562,
-0.3841044009,
0.5310252309,
-0.1749255806,
-0.2723280191,
-0.3178504109,
0.0834824964,
-0.1526138335,
-0.0469518267,
-0.0849547237,
0.1506501585,
0.3826031089,
-0.6735402942,
0.4542410374,
0.0573015995,
-0.6887031198,
-0.5111305118,
0.8479098678,
0.5877228379,
-0.186194092,
0.7194437385,
-0.3321828842,
-0.524987936,
0.1884922236,
0.2386475354,
0.8945755363,
-0.3563583791,
0.209178403,
0.5994782448,
0.4050291181,
-0.2021882236,
0.5681139827,
0.1011811569,
-0.4602187574,
-0.5191518664,
-0.5449706912,
-0.2698792517,
0.0518975444,
-0.8857662678,
0.2417056561,
-0.7465905547,
0.0085939784,
0.2058694363,
0.1217690632,
-0.5093508363,
0.2520853579,
-0.2360924035,
0.8125459552,
-1.0765537024,
0.498080045,
0.7959319949,
-0.4960256219,
-0.8350118399,
-0.0576598905,
0.0686892793,
-0.5710244179,
0.5073645115,
0.2075453103,
-0.2109481096,
0.0024481534,
-0.6682245135,
-0.0487452932,
0.5129073858,
0.5378882885,
-0.927578032,
-0.0299021807,
-0.1574681699,
0.4892577231,
-0.2353065014,
0.0001631903,
0.7677109838,
0.6916797757,
-0.2942979038,
-0.961122036,
0.1997043937,
-0.3495005369,
-0.0965029672,
0.1279231757,
-0.8116564155,
0.7959203124,
-0.3684857786,
-0.2534700632,
0.2176145017,
0.9726648331,
-0.1266190708,
0.0015641854,
0.6436369419,
0.4098626971,
1.0075141191,
-0.221634239,
0.9477692246,
0.024534449,
0.0868250579,
1.2779033184,
-0.2757765353,
0.7398407459,
0.5237720609,
0.0663077384,
0.4097641408,
0.4626478553,
-0.116856426,
0.3440366983,
0.5234143138,
-0.283785671,
-0.0801175982,
-0.6065275669,
-0.2177696824,
0.4979971051,
-0.1201876104,
-0.2239892781,
-0.0356815793,
-0.0936544761,
0.5996077657,
0.6644325256,
-0.4511801302,
0.764993012,
-0.1030431241,
-0.4738048017,
0.2684573233,
-0.0066082021,
0.859436214,
-0.2718240619,
-0.0661352798,
-0.3427988887,
0.1913032681,
-0.3003697097,
-0.8653703332,
0.2160313874,
0.1615561992,
-0.3815998733,
-0.4471553862,
0.2942461967,
-0.457508564,
-0.386508137,
-0.0006513257,
0.0172748119,
0.325520426,
-0.3727291524,
-0.7278287411,
-0.0721991807,
0.3888571858,
-0.2705155313,
-0.0520535819,
1.0238419771,
-0.2747956216,
0.5100836158,
0.6991212368,
-0.006584086,
-0.2309651524,
0.7336934805,
0.8809979558,
-0.7851059437,
-0.6197912693,
-0.5638270378,
0.3709600866,
-0.1209599152,
-0.7711997628,
0.4416907132,
0.4997670949,
0.8280453086,
0.0614604503,
0.8230534792,
0.1055425927,
0.509247005,
-0.3908936679,
0.7451556921,
-0.1687713712,
-0.1043128818,
-0.6040520668,
-0.6948903799,
-0.3392961025,
0.873066783,
-0.2037882209,
0.2200971842,
0.5245352387,
0.8955926299,
0.2505649328,
0.2144829482,
0.0589129217,
0.2809951007,
0.3899044991,
0.7318840623,
0.4056938887,
-0.2446719259,
0.8072280288,
-0.3745724261,
-0.353894949,
-0.2666929662,
-0.8935240507,
-0.8051871061,
-0.589930892,
-0.6904465556,
-0.4298011065,
0.1487166435,
0.9377464652,
0.6631196141,
-0.5810810328,
0.1273815632,
-0.1371935904,
-0.3169414997,
-0.3824779689,
-0.2565194368,
0.3082468808,
-0.5247735381,
-0.8504732847,
0.2250631601,
0.1336028427,
-0.1489251405,
-0.0213180166,
0.1864811629,
-0.0781109259,
-0.1709257662,
0.3505582809,
0.1756863296,
-0.3780594766,
-0.5868042111,
-0.1126343086,
-0.3124328852,
0.144827947,
1.061807394,
-0.5860797167,
0.1600627005,
0.301029563,
0.3824937642,
-0.1429718137,
-0.1129079685,
0.6582756639,
-0.8830680847,
0.4532962143,
0.4493317902,
0.4509283602,
0.780818522,
-0.4429755509,
0.5805698037,
0.1595757008,
-0.4875286222,
-0.6558274627,
0.4068489075,
-1.0897802114,
0.0356316455,
0.9699925184,
-0.1400284171,
-0.3940848708,
-0.3756042719,
-0.6208862066,
0.2576162219,
-0.7957357168,
0.8993732333,
0.6574446559,
0.2474160045,
-0.1254624128,
-0.7670531869,
0.8752213717,
0.7139347792,
-0.7023720741,
0.7129187584,
0.6102796197,
0.2493419647,
-0.0682803914,
0.9488485456,
-0.4210777283,
0.563711226,
-0.1716236919,
0.2306818366,
-0.1312084198,
-0.2496114075,
-0.3490025997,
0.0367839374,
0.086594969,
-0.2161718756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10189v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10189v2 | Do I have the Knowledge to Answer? Investigating Answerability of Knowledge Base Questions | 2022-12-20T12:00:26 | 2023-06-24T11:06:55 | Mayur Patidar, Prayushi Faldu, Avinash Singh, Lovekesh Vig, Indrajit Bhattacharya, Mausam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | When answering natural language questions over knowledge bases, missing
facts, incomplete schema and limited scope naturally lead to many questions
being unanswerable. While answerability has been explored in other QA settings,
it has not been studied for QA over knowledge bases (KBQA). We create
GrailQAbility, a new benchmark KBQA dataset with unanswerability, by first
identifying various forms of KB incompleteness that make questions
unanswerable, and then systematically adapting GrailQA (a popular KBQA dataset
with only answerable questions). Experimenting with three state-of-the-art KBQA
models, we find that all three models suffer a drop in performance even after
suitable adaptation for unanswerable questions. In addition, these often detect
unanswerability for wrong reasons and find specific forms of unanswerability
particularly difficult to handle. This underscores the need for further
research in making KBQA systems robust to unanswerability | [
-0.6788696647,
-0.7354314923,
0.7447717786,
-0.0723724663,
0.1752336174,
0.0652656928,
0.0764287636,
-0.6347692609,
-0.0250346512,
0.5436253548,
-0.6136293411,
-0.1849369109,
-0.6021661162,
0.0695701316,
-0.4089220464,
0.8993115425,
-0.0451207981,
-0.1618238688,
-0.8848009109,
-0.4353470802,
-0.775364697,
-0.4749260247,
-0.1251485795,
-0.1506206691,
0.0575346872,
0.6100851297,
0.828999877,
0.2302244753,
0.5974966884,
0.2324647307,
-0.0824064985,
0.1009638235,
-0.2469810843,
0.0149300266,
-0.1591001302,
-0.5312235355,
-0.3032722175,
-0.2649044394,
0.3219825029,
0.9290348291,
0.1063009873,
0.6634520292,
-0.1179037392,
0.9394878745,
-0.7571062446,
0.2863322794,
-0.5562026501,
-0.1902581453,
-0.0455981307,
-0.1446748972,
-0.1328312308,
-0.4675563574,
0.5174828172,
-0.839200139,
0.2127737254,
-0.0281887315,
0.6536637545,
0.2705649734,
-0.695152998,
-0.6586639881,
-0.7641385198,
0.3370372951,
-0.7802202702,
0.2940267324,
0.5085505247,
0.8206723928,
-0.3304289281,
-0.8384760618,
-0.361437887,
-0.1189245135,
-0.2423657477,
0.1507030427,
-0.429689616,
-0.0359263979,
0.4143866599,
0.2977505922,
-0.7298361659,
-0.5405540466,
-0.417866379,
-0.1771817505,
0.2987014055,
0.1652072221,
0.4745211005,
-0.0612897426,
-0.1544945687,
0.1863633394,
-0.3952816725,
0.6359783411,
0.2449055612,
0.1775335819,
0.3080930114,
0.6794343591,
-0.854736805,
0.8738431334,
0.0425699204,
0.0934760123,
-0.1339174211,
-0.1693895459,
-0.1483588219,
-0.2194785774,
0.1548361331,
0.3081080616,
0.3714428842,
-0.7040288448,
0.0323103555,
-0.1696881354,
0.5425134301,
-0.6273893118,
-0.6576169729,
0.5948642492,
-0.2543464005,
-0.0742393881,
-0.1741770357,
-0.4797756374,
-0.398907721,
0.0841198564,
0.8467179537,
-0.364456445,
-0.6224855781,
0.2204143852,
-0.2344108969,
0.1490518004,
0.3555365503,
-0.8578022122,
0.6577623487,
0.388387382,
0.4943550527,
0.0845945328,
-0.0680576563,
-0.2458832562,
-0.0034029402,
-0.4410385191,
0.8909472823,
-0.2214232087,
-0.2189036012,
-0.1176183522,
0.2933011949,
-0.2061584443,
-0.7965476513,
0.2784718573,
-1.0411069393,
0.1900636107,
-0.9625459313,
-0.7710763812,
-0.6555693746,
0.4939735532,
-0.8080908656,
0.6077226996,
0.600389421,
-0.9231622219,
0.3994311392,
-0.7401534915,
-0.2236358374,
0.1308899075,
0.0309747308,
-0.0666053072,
-0.0267943572,
0.2226246744,
0.1301046759,
-0.2264713198,
0.1861550063,
-0.3623234034,
-0.3980486393,
0.2848255634,
-0.0692389905,
0.8671393991,
0.1146849543,
-0.1104332209,
-0.3882240057,
-0.7391698956,
0.5012168884,
0.0189199764,
-0.4200468361,
-0.1939722598,
0.013606648,
-0.3229141831,
0.2810974121,
0.257556349,
-0.523409009,
0.2830033302,
-0.2278250456,
0.1241969094,
0.4598016739,
0.3522239625,
0.5060268641,
-0.6275891662,
0.6273778677,
0.1560650617,
-0.0821041614,
0.5252903104,
-0.5522891283,
-0.8117153049,
0.2666963339,
0.2697883844,
0.6714086533,
-0.8515079618,
0.0281284023,
-0.2068478912,
-0.613417089,
-0.3360660076,
0.0349721499,
0.468401581,
0.9726113677,
0.4937906265,
-0.2337165922,
-0.4233979285,
-1.0865318775,
-0.5079693198,
-0.6938776374,
-0.0266870707,
0.3604879379,
0.5972539186,
0.1867102236,
1.175724268,
-0.4255709648,
0.1475643665,
-0.0361003466,
-0.0250522159,
0.2504083812,
0.0238287877,
0.7427428365,
-0.7911115885,
-0.0918760076,
0.0981149971,
-1.2118071318,
-0.0940159559,
0.2260441333,
-0.1767085046,
0.0422927886,
0.1047287285,
-0.7710630298,
0.5082548857,
0.2108666152,
-0.4556311071,
0.4607754052,
0.1029936075,
0.4345826507,
-0.8195241094,
0.3966573179,
-0.436149478,
-0.1453280449,
-0.9207229018,
0.0620853305,
0.4135709703,
-0.0783365816,
-0.3424575031,
0.5241071582,
-0.4812901914,
-0.1813582331,
-0.2020028532,
-0.0737264529,
0.1691675782,
0.5884212255,
-0.050487563,
0.9091176391,
0.3688313663,
-0.9682113528,
0.3899571896,
0.7378558517,
-0.7725819349,
0.3632950783,
-0.6382440925,
-0.0495369919,
-0.2901924849,
-0.0126066627,
-0.9860002995,
-0.4718939066,
0.4361940026,
-0.6394286156,
0.0231951308,
-0.3822839856,
-0.1629451662,
-0.4181659222,
0.1960179508,
0.2342307568,
0.4617159069,
-0.4185990095,
0.7226031423,
0.3471120596,
-0.2746322453,
-0.6947174668,
-0.5694212317,
-0.1816981435,
-0.0201905202,
-0.8686249256,
-0.198611632,
-0.2594615519,
-0.3085515499,
0.3983232975,
-0.4072634876,
-0.3842905164,
0.4834947586,
0.3706670403,
0.0245700404,
-0.3470379114,
0.3993341029,
-0.0499762259,
0.1870629042,
0.6046079397,
-0.0585557111,
0.1938036382,
-0.2529782653,
-0.4516224563,
-0.0263158605,
0.2321974337,
0.5256084204,
-0.1714161783,
0.5637724996,
0.2704299986,
-0.538133204,
-0.0073457975,
-0.469956398,
-0.0506265573,
-0.4340100586,
0.5373669267,
-0.4767988324,
-0.8833110332,
0.6754334569,
0.0557216667,
0.0519190915,
0.2626504898,
0.4185557663,
-0.1310724765,
0.7370265126,
0.6172618866,
0.032390967,
-0.2197713852,
0.0193569548,
0.2834373116,
-0.449388206,
-0.3531990647,
-0.5492685437,
-0.1568561047,
-0.4983004034,
0.0430269204,
0.522819221,
0.4428740442,
-0.2807885706,
0.2507416904,
-0.2330318391,
0.2972400486,
0.5587018132,
0.1351553649,
0.5312217474,
-0.5062405467,
0.4049729705,
0.2375380844,
-0.7684331536,
-0.3662413955,
1.0162457228,
0.1224274859,
0.4859982729,
0.4461153448,
0.252820611,
0.4024280012,
0.3609015942,
-0.4950375557,
0.4682180882,
0.4674160779,
-0.9949086308,
-0.3528589606,
-0.4508223236,
-0.4407411814,
-0.1719214469,
-0.3136106431,
-0.73222965,
0.118344903,
0.1717284918,
-0.4054604471,
0.2904671729,
-0.8863098025,
0.9144684672,
-0.0253487229,
0.2287071794,
0.5324853063,
-0.8208961487,
0.5783227086,
-0.2199283689,
0.1323278993,
-0.2181033194,
0.1472838223,
0.8710919023,
-0.3656885922,
0.4381664693,
-0.5205270648,
0.1971720308,
0.5749551058,
0.2208721638,
0.4668955505,
0.2859887779,
0.0210966412,
-0.1743342727,
0.5050100088,
-0.8584779501,
-1.0420707464,
0.4302927256,
-0.7700810432,
-0.7699875236,
-0.3088054061,
-0.4994434416,
-1.0057514906,
0.2510854602,
0.2919886112,
0.2533988357,
-0.2134727389,
0.0502897426,
0.7573984265,
0.0527911112,
0.2452257425,
0.7252042294,
-0.307059288,
-0.1695792526,
0.6071537137,
0.5150879622,
0.3788453639,
0.2928010821,
-0.1909781247,
-0.2893960774,
-0.6421340108,
-0.7741623521,
-0.1632230878,
-0.8268216252,
-0.2470800877,
-0.8208782673,
-0.4244244099,
-0.6860300899,
0.2504791319,
-0.0913329199,
-0.6564580202,
-0.0040420545,
-0.118450813,
0.5853652358,
0.8577617407,
0.2748378217,
0.1026193127,
-0.9821150899,
0.3454482257,
0.7790597677,
0.3800500333,
0.0470446721,
-0.7833188772,
-0.4519064128,
0.1729987115,
-0.1243176386,
-0.937808156,
0.1491027027,
-0.1117418334,
0.6236431599,
-0.0928410366,
0.5214689374,
0.5977518559,
-0.1955565661,
0.6875685453,
-0.353290379,
-0.7797245383,
0.3106875718,
-0.4032211304,
0.3331060112,
0.7685762644,
0.6035720706,
-0.4395215511,
-0.2092097402,
-0.6204606295,
-0.4992477894,
0.4438036084,
0.0978545994,
-0.090933226,
0.2072892934,
0.4537424445,
0.0405965224,
0.4564920664,
-0.3603279293,
-0.3341775239,
-0.2110138237,
0.1837420911,
0.2545810342,
-0.2115659267,
-0.1859446168,
0.088630341,
0.7949681282,
-0.2226717174,
0.2559009194,
0.130021289,
-0.2294779718,
-0.3571353555,
0.2742553651,
0.0692733675,
1.0769177675,
-0.6018488407,
-0.1370823979,
0.3472984731,
-0.5125912428,
0.0736109093,
-0.0096454732,
-0.2216188312,
-0.2078191042,
0.4653912485,
0.4210640192,
-0.1602787822,
-0.8036984801,
0.7335125208,
-0.3200729191,
-0.466365695,
-0.3515505791,
0.1900890321,
0.2501146197,
0.3410117924,
0.4300736785,
0.193266511,
0.3593880534,
-0.3642245233,
0.2427507937,
0.532191515,
-0.38864398,
-0.1164516881,
0.5432441831,
-0.0652580112,
-0.0808924139,
0.6068475246,
0.0784798339,
-0.4312153459,
0.7875986695,
0.4607818127,
0.3565310538,
0.225044921,
0.4640173018,
0.101931341,
0.4422453344,
0.0423106998,
0.3995514512,
-0.1423072815,
-0.7834265828,
-0.2288619876,
-0.3855665028,
-0.7767807245,
0.2638823688,
-1.1293572187,
-0.0816248432,
-0.3324667513,
0.0001118315,
-0.0734834075,
0.2479362637,
-0.6683747172,
0.6214488745,
-0.406663686,
1.235057354,
-0.9942387938,
0.4610325396,
0.6855437756,
-0.4302014709,
-0.9197522998,
-0.105670087,
-0.3759003282,
-0.7596904039,
0.2249228507,
-0.057521984,
0.2181858569,
-0.0066490201,
-0.599016726,
-0.9100718498,
1.4216638803,
0.2899260223,
-0.033971183,
-0.066854462,
0.3446725011,
0.4324292243,
0.1015831232,
0.1279805303,
0.648263514,
0.5769033432,
-0.0988125429,
-0.7553278208,
-0.0760430023,
-0.4863506556,
-0.3983017802,
0.2355424911,
-0.6383976936,
0.6319516897,
-0.1922562718,
-0.2189445794,
0.4269824028,
0.6656529307,
-0.0559482239,
0.6265232563,
0.333353281,
0.6813359857,
0.9932286143,
-0.1903480887,
0.896944046,
-0.2223159224,
0.2602343857,
1.0613299608,
-0.2271782309,
0.616496861,
0.3597091734,
-0.2720524371,
0.2771922946,
0.6943407655,
0.3003922701,
0.5795222521,
0.1486535966,
-0.4989922047,
-0.6106188297,
0.0140424585,
-0.6922704577,
0.2983392477,
0.0569991171,
0.0432355776,
-0.3754654527,
-0.0095031606,
-0.2664123476,
0.0931325704,
-0.2394813895,
0.7930198908,
-0.32828632,
-0.637253046,
0.729688108,
-0.2919665575,
-0.0204107482,
-0.5749710202,
-0.0222701859,
-0.3921638131,
-0.2478832155,
-0.2686397433,
-0.8934620619,
0.1623485237,
-0.1411872804,
-0.6955342293,
0.3844290078,
0.9517987967,
-0.1367103606,
-0.36751315,
0.1791789979,
1.257856369,
0.1048827991,
-0.1837364286,
-0.1589089483,
-0.5699956417,
-0.2268716544,
-0.5527461171,
0.5461410284,
0.7613447905,
-0.0572026223,
1.183514595,
0.4357873499,
-0.1259475052,
0.2154985219,
-0.4820172787,
1.2124741077,
-0.5971300006,
-0.0537984744,
-0.3482503593,
0.4538316727,
0.0869696215,
-0.368620187,
0.8585329652,
0.4475018978,
0.8034707904,
-0.2707432806,
1.1642074585,
-0.3218921125,
0.9930941463,
-0.4038855433,
0.8160428405,
-0.5027650595,
0.1974760145,
-0.1540235132,
-0.5428474545,
-0.2124026567,
-0.0212701149,
-0.3741349578,
0.0095266392,
0.4289979041,
0.7725015879,
0.0740526468,
0.3723399341,
0.5366897583,
-0.0509385429,
0.0832719654,
0.8012458086,
0.9309208393,
-0.583003521,
0.7252134085,
-0.3563913703,
-0.1185371354,
0.0363499783,
-0.6298636794,
-0.7978507876,
-0.51687181,
0.0009011805,
-0.595153451,
0.5467213392,
0.4167887568,
0.5019688606,
-1.0830190182,
0.0480930917,
0.0230815765,
0.2145617455,
-0.1061389968,
-0.2068350315,
0.2113799751,
-0.2459590882,
-0.2986768782,
0.2329761684,
-0.00638982,
0.0726893321,
0.1658912897,
0.0868268311,
-0.092363663,
-0.0619646609,
0.1092929915,
0.7277345657,
-0.1107055843,
-0.6493655443,
0.3512045443,
0.0309238303,
-0.0953312218,
0.5846729279,
-0.8519086242,
0.3699919581,
0.4873380065,
1.1773761511,
0.0801373571,
0.3336614668,
0.3857024014,
-0.4582740366,
-0.4954079688,
0.3995220363,
0.1456214339,
0.0295425672,
-0.3621653318,
0.5352209806,
0.0962426886,
-0.9653460383,
-0.7265788913,
0.2572133243,
-1.0515311956,
-0.1662329733,
0.945145905,
-0.2074678242,
-0.1969535947,
-0.650687933,
-0.0582729019,
0.0063397568,
-0.0754613131,
0.6548531055,
1.0794481039,
-0.4292808771,
0.0477058701,
-0.8016235828,
0.5296961069,
0.3650592566,
-0.8437033892,
0.1571436822,
0.4761189818,
0.7022587061,
0.2208504379,
0.7643337846,
0.1351705045,
0.7142747641,
0.0212171748,
-0.2460868061,
-0.2705184519,
-0.3371997476,
-0.0652939305,
0.3875564337,
0.6357591748,
-0.2301277518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05150v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05150v1 | Unsupervised Question Duplicate and Related Questions Detection in e-learning platforms | 2022-12-20T11:52:52 | 2022-12-20T11:52:52 | Maksimjeet Chowdhary, Sanyam Goyal, Venktesh V, Mukesh Mohania, Vikram Goyal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Online learning platforms provide diverse questions to gauge the learners'
understanding of different concepts. The repository of questions has to be
constantly updated to ensure a diverse pool of questions to conduct assessments
for learners. However, it is impossible for the academician to manually skim
through the large repository of questions to check for duplicates when
onboarding new questions from external sources. Hence, we propose a tool QDup
in this paper that can surface near-duplicate and semantically related
questions without any supervised data. The proposed tool follows an
unsupervised hybrid pipeline of statistical and neural approaches for
incorporating different nuances in similarity for the task of question
duplicate detection. We demonstrate that QDup can detect near-duplicate
questions and also suggest related questions for practice with remarkable
accuracy and speed from a large repository of questions. The demo video of the
tool can be found at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=loh0_-7XLW4. | [
-0.7613117099,
-0.7564874291,
0.3292869329,
-0.0231778286,
-0.1856884062,
0.3934932649,
0.0952868313,
-0.2089449912,
0.4869272113,
0.6365817189,
-0.7497349381,
-0.432341814,
0.0315354168,
0.0390816294,
-0.6680440307,
0.8478679061,
0.0040242043,
0.1637565941,
-0.7059636712,
-0.4711770713,
-0.3524150252,
-0.2401542962,
-0.6351976991,
0.1078696921,
0.3167825937,
0.4125778675,
-0.0647976846,
-0.0653417557,
0.244162485,
0.3557145298,
0.0243707281,
0.4610670805,
-0.1403562874,
0.2373741269,
-0.473785013,
-0.7109764814,
-0.0905506536,
-0.2572540939,
0.7120354176,
0.8459966183,
0.0088910889,
0.4825260043,
0.4011832476,
0.5165221691,
-0.5581817031,
-0.3730963171,
-0.51092875,
0.045539435,
0.0925764516,
-0.4459792972,
0.0281286761,
-0.5493119359,
-0.1062434092,
-0.7662285566,
0.4217266142,
-0.1581137627,
0.4370291531,
0.2094052285,
-0.4723163843,
-0.2118621469,
-0.3639360964,
0.7347584367,
-0.4932715893,
0.3943599463,
0.3512814939,
0.3084763288,
-0.1493753791,
-0.8957901001,
-0.8583279252,
0.0454692766,
-0.0858341828,
0.0372950323,
-0.0340609848,
-0.2916859984,
0.4845930636,
0.2506271899,
-1.0301542282,
0.1428925246,
-0.2922327816,
-0.4415976107,
0.2827246189,
0.3116504252,
0.4582355618,
-0.221202001,
-0.4008245766,
-0.2154675424,
-0.2798011005,
0.2424844056,
0.5096058846,
-0.119290635,
0.1136673316,
0.2417203635,
-0.496951282,
0.8866616488,
0.1972429454,
0.2369648665,
0.5100516677,
-0.443125397,
0.2370382547,
-0.2670766711,
0.6847208738,
0.4258836806,
0.2061838806,
0.0036034023,
0.2281196862,
0.0473985933,
0.005882957,
-0.5721105933,
-0.3730106354,
0.6846355796,
-0.194309935,
-0.0377436243,
0.3164816201,
-0.8051139712,
-0.2117899656,
-0.2577450871,
0.2294497341,
-0.1438118219,
-0.4561860263,
-0.0865422785,
-0.2825519145,
0.2731928825,
0.2020261884,
-0.4451521635,
0.1311499476,
0.7946828008,
0.6709946394,
-0.2937639356,
-0.4407267869,
-0.6230062842,
-0.1170605198,
-0.0217836853,
1.1316649914,
-0.321067065,
0.0696615651,
0.0442996249,
0.3285620511,
0.0556045547,
-0.6570589542,
0.2188325077,
-0.7821127772,
0.6556181908,
-0.6395758986,
-0.9207167625,
-0.3640351593,
0.633226037,
-0.6966155767,
0.9190075994,
0.1347755641,
-1.0262417793,
0.5518085957,
-0.6154578328,
-0.0058922591,
0.3342008889,
-0.2253096551,
-0.309941411,
-0.3282581866,
0.3337314129,
0.3276214004,
0.0193729922,
0.1979153603,
-0.5126772523,
-0.2690420151,
0.1092021912,
-0.0544083379,
1.0299381018,
0.0266162828,
-0.268497467,
0.1391641349,
-0.7042397261,
0.637896359,
0.0326806083,
-0.0592637323,
-0.5243006349,
-0.392450124,
0.1664904952,
0.3739206195,
0.3143932819,
-0.7395235896,
0.1825277358,
-0.0876346678,
0.2926588058,
0.4250825644,
0.4478295743,
0.2732111216,
-0.532921195,
0.7698656917,
0.2401660234,
0.1266667247,
0.0004633378,
-0.6463276744,
-0.5041882396,
0.0230632983,
0.3338826895,
0.7435780168,
-0.9030128717,
0.390265286,
-0.0355671197,
-0.3150853515,
-0.546576798,
0.7210664153,
0.1397938877,
0.4339413941,
0.4724090993,
-0.2535239756,
-0.5149641633,
-0.71591115,
-0.3821161389,
0.0115009127,
-0.2667246163,
0.0604672655,
0.4894410372,
0.0195351094,
1.0377932787,
-0.5959698558,
-0.405834049,
-0.2200885862,
0.2773681879,
-0.173130393,
0.4971128404,
0.5808711648,
-1.17012012,
-0.7176063657,
-0.2750920653,
-0.9768338799,
-0.3607207537,
-0.248166576,
-0.1902133226,
0.0163216554,
0.7031676173,
-0.4698886573,
-0.0940005779,
0.2135135829,
-0.0049270126,
0.0618162602,
-0.1455478966,
0.253251344,
-1.3703821898,
0.0867250264,
-0.222366035,
-0.1464248747,
-0.3315628469,
0.3504733443,
0.3111355603,
-0.0634742826,
-0.7731239796,
0.6038265824,
-0.2033104151,
-0.0533540286,
-0.263423413,
0.3847903609,
0.0349266566,
0.5597051978,
0.0232434273,
0.3863323033,
0.426153332,
-0.5385204554,
0.8329972029,
0.3361565173,
-0.3257551491,
0.764325738,
-0.5401012301,
0.4343215823,
-0.1156223938,
0.3330912888,
-0.8293307424,
0.0797594041,
0.1669545323,
-0.5992117524,
-0.0916092247,
-0.2789960504,
-0.6614067554,
-0.3935226798,
-0.6278415918,
0.6719800234,
0.3400696516,
-0.7354286909,
0.2254787087,
0.2462970465,
-0.0977126509,
-0.5828139186,
-0.4434518814,
-0.3089764118,
-0.1867817491,
-0.7694966793,
0.0530072451,
-0.2256433815,
-0.0673849434,
0.133903116,
0.1726743132,
-0.3075671792,
-0.0213482827,
0.2401800901,
0.0551746115,
-0.2517895103,
0.2033452988,
0.247230798,
-0.0080457367,
0.1385094374,
-0.6777294278,
0.6741005182,
-0.064787738,
-0.5744804144,
-0.5051088929,
0.7063484788,
0.4461826682,
-0.2955395877,
0.4358752072,
0.7706239223,
-0.3315620422,
-0.4578917325,
-0.6762696505,
-0.3293401599,
-0.509322226,
0.3825913072,
-0.0418202728,
-1.0547058582,
0.6922816038,
0.067207545,
0.0468128957,
0.3065007031,
0.5330081582,
-0.500475347,
0.7526453733,
0.3628205061,
0.0158897974,
0.3582642078,
-0.6374441981,
0.0928491056,
-0.493175447,
-0.5213966966,
-0.2109250277,
-0.5950399041,
-0.5528624654,
-0.3475658298,
0.1001332924,
-0.0422189534,
0.0265796669,
0.2028056532,
-0.4741562605,
0.5769684315,
0.9867626429,
-0.0326473117,
0.3786267936,
-0.1038596705,
0.0659840778,
-0.0112136444,
-0.661255002,
-0.2042092681,
1.2029868364,
-0.2852447927,
0.1136168018,
-0.0201137867,
0.7526040077,
0.5241068602,
0.0175343845,
-0.3858099282,
0.8260961175,
0.2373022884,
-0.6119865775,
-0.3059654236,
-0.6386322975,
-1.0524477959,
0.4763774872,
-0.307544142,
-0.3295527995,
0.0381982401,
0.2568051219,
-0.5648079515,
0.7460132241,
-0.6182899475,
0.9299917817,
-0.4234233201,
-0.4694226682,
0.0074725458,
-0.3307491541,
0.2761645913,
-0.3938031495,
-0.1917045712,
0.3912096024,
-0.0868919492,
0.8333645463,
-0.4324685931,
0.4228158891,
-0.1921430379,
0.3118436635,
0.8411492109,
0.0651977658,
0.1154531464,
-0.0122500099,
0.5710703731,
-0.0389607176,
0.406236589,
-0.7049309015,
-0.8222340941,
1.0740042925,
-0.4562329054,
-0.3964486718,
-0.3407063782,
-0.5443377495,
-0.3342210948,
0.0888112038,
0.1228073612,
0.1219425201,
0.1360462755,
-0.0081430757,
0.5553727746,
-0.3887510002,
0.3501726687,
0.505816102,
-0.2908521295,
-0.0493537933,
1.0578993559,
-0.0104064811,
0.1511443406,
0.4562878907,
0.0434621833,
-0.5799698234,
-0.4897193313,
-0.3273420334,
0.3684266508,
-0.6081073284,
-0.1621578336,
-0.9245556593,
0.0425204225,
-0.4523594379,
0.2329755872,
-0.0663572475,
-0.6084194779,
-0.2087882608,
-0.1976284832,
0.4158700407,
0.3020070493,
-0.1871062666,
-0.0479814149,
-0.8773688674,
0.4879437685,
0.8969607353,
0.0854817852,
-0.028924806,
-0.5861144662,
0.1801917851,
0.2296249121,
-0.5118793845,
-0.6346923113,
0.2403188497,
-0.0682976916,
0.4626571536,
0.4323601127,
0.3008448184,
0.4232646823,
0.0418949798,
0.569422245,
0.160547629,
-0.4910314381,
0.6754561067,
-0.2007741183,
0.217119813,
0.88392061,
0.9247797728,
-0.3002695739,
-0.2714487612,
-0.7318854332,
-0.7139613032,
0.3070236444,
-0.1949349344,
0.1656972766,
0.1428238004,
-0.037095096,
0.1436009109,
0.3125418425,
-0.4481495321,
-0.1042591184,
-0.1878512204,
0.0664878041,
0.272087723,
0.1095383465,
0.1697403193,
-0.3589382172,
0.3783278763,
-0.0542485155,
-0.1808959991,
-0.0936213806,
-0.3862067759,
0.0316159725,
0.2468243539,
0.3377374709,
0.5575457811,
-0.5648357272,
-0.2358879894,
0.2086140662,
-0.354336977,
-0.1353074312,
-0.0518600978,
-0.3328672647,
0.0897740647,
0.2892080843,
0.0480668359,
-0.0400426611,
-0.9379833341,
0.7706284523,
0.0814319775,
-0.4821614623,
-0.7984386086,
-0.0897123739,
0.1287644207,
0.3407986164,
0.1619826257,
-0.1577164978,
0.0837432221,
-0.8457621932,
0.5951929688,
0.3393423855,
-0.1855525821,
-0.1416185498,
0.6298453808,
0.3154885471,
-0.5069187284,
0.9205077887,
-0.4267323911,
-0.8331652284,
0.648216784,
-0.0300141834,
0.4798541665,
0.0833509043,
0.5382807851,
0.4211001992,
-0.0342621915,
-0.0997194722,
0.751114428,
-0.2571807504,
-0.6885926723,
-0.2551475763,
-0.1859891564,
-0.4790814221,
0.4921627641,
-0.937520206,
0.2334676832,
-0.6940597296,
-0.0034804593,
0.0830006003,
-0.0953951329,
-0.6076568365,
0.1086994782,
-0.030593656,
0.5544937849,
-1.0177179575,
0.632196784,
0.8991847634,
-0.6994367242,
-0.4362707138,
-0.22408849,
-0.1041301265,
-0.5245857239,
0.6425091028,
-0.0694278702,
0.2968463898,
-0.1498513818,
-0.2924702466,
-0.368598789,
0.9220423102,
0.2612788677,
-0.4823133647,
-0.1603862196,
0.4922265708,
0.6042870283,
0.0519166067,
0.4369613528,
0.2401646227,
0.133206889,
0.0177721493,
-0.8123528361,
-0.2429004908,
-0.4936779737,
-0.8134861588,
0.4828137159,
-0.4647182822,
0.9529841542,
-0.2046942711,
0.1754326075,
0.0041692141,
0.4383197427,
0.2849105299,
0.9057936072,
0.6602237821,
0.7068662047,
0.7026870251,
0.2427865416,
0.7668572664,
-0.2621653974,
0.5264397264,
1.258749485,
-0.1377240568,
0.9165742397,
0.5449426174,
-0.1606336534,
0.5527538657,
0.5071535707,
-0.3093383014,
0.3830902278,
0.4483914971,
-0.0146508981,
-0.5596477389,
-0.1582184583,
-0.5649659634,
0.3389915228,
0.0604469366,
-0.2213009,
-0.3629764318,
0.1774758399,
-0.5384786129,
0.4458217323,
-0.4161779583,
0.5355287194,
0.093969211,
-0.7156315446,
0.5501644015,
-0.3416774571,
0.8077307343,
-0.5085789561,
-0.2936845124,
-0.6030887961,
0.1340391785,
-0.3188509047,
-0.7981595397,
0.0805329382,
-0.1003762558,
-0.0864531025,
-0.2272431999,
0.3910926282,
-0.4901195765,
-0.5393509269,
0.4603455961,
1.0461335182,
0.2274608612,
-0.4464624822,
-0.7191630602,
-0.5732842088,
0.1010461524,
0.3318643272,
0.4894243777,
0.4140549302,
-0.2220773101,
1.0124895573,
0.6801273227,
0.0767459348,
0.378092736,
0.1201234385,
0.6629757285,
-0.5248940587,
-0.675976634,
-0.1857191771,
0.2335558683,
-0.4032684863,
-0.5179468989,
0.7385191917,
0.7449427247,
1.4258416891,
-0.1373244375,
0.5807577968,
0.3489454091,
0.9495053887,
-0.3327566385,
0.6164628267,
-0.9111184478,
0.3361026943,
-0.3943080902,
-1.1766533852,
0.1370163858,
0.4548025727,
-0.1539347321,
0.0144985737,
0.8827373981,
0.8781061769,
-0.4714870155,
0.2448010296,
0.3204143047,
-0.27902475,
-0.1584783494,
0.8511309028,
1.2054350376,
-0.3413594961,
0.8303133845,
-0.5064738989,
0.1142796203,
0.0802233145,
-0.4399345219,
-1.2160061598,
-0.8193340898,
-0.7106112838,
-0.1430911869,
-0.3861759007,
0.9767012,
0.3623230159,
-1.1549482346,
0.0133123575,
0.1494115591,
0.1883803159,
-0.0412570685,
-0.2827675343,
0.6427567005,
0.1301915944,
-0.4782606363,
-0.1682019532,
-0.0153700253,
-0.0540738739,
-0.1865017116,
0.4248824716,
-0.3874647319,
-0.3748637438,
0.3189041317,
0.5420773029,
-0.5267608166,
-0.1738138199,
0.0536411591,
0.3534252048,
-0.3675681949,
1.134388566,
-0.9882975221,
0.2419380546,
0.7435777187,
0.8789054751,
0.4619310796,
0.1252509207,
-0.0107202493,
-0.5288222432,
0.1284684539,
0.6522756219,
0.3883394897,
0.4130842388,
-0.1111547574,
0.1334165931,
0.5440458655,
-0.1671309322,
-0.9443656802,
0.133675456,
-1.1419868469,
-0.2933700085,
0.9106808305,
-0.2258987129,
0.3154965937,
-0.5565743446,
-0.0099562984,
0.0216016416,
-0.177288726,
0.7317092419,
0.3310520351,
-0.096834816,
-0.2872235775,
-0.7084060311,
0.2154159844,
0.7598239779,
-0.8633947968,
-0.4375908077,
0.231141448,
0.6244046092,
0.1171406358,
0.4262687862,
0.1992959231,
0.5665621161,
-0.2249970436,
-0.192949906,
-0.2408764511,
0.0009472511,
-0.0123810554,
0.5306613445,
-0.494851917,
-0.6097632647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10180v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10180v2 | IndicMT Eval: A Dataset to Meta-Evaluate Machine Translation metrics for Indian Languages | 2022-12-20T11:37:22 | 2023-07-03T14:26:38 | Ananya B. Sai, Vignesh Nagarajan, Tanay Dixit, Raj Dabre, Anoop Kunchukuttan, Pratyush Kumar, Mitesh M. Khapra | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid growth of machine translation (MT) systems has necessitated
comprehensive studies to meta-evaluate evaluation metrics being used, which
enables a better selection of metrics that best reflect MT quality.
Unfortunately, most of the research focuses on high-resource languages, mainly
English, the observations for which may not always apply to other languages.
Indian languages, having over a billion speakers, are linguistically different
from English, and to date, there has not been a systematic study of evaluating
MT systems from English into Indian languages. In this paper, we fill this gap
by creating an MQM dataset consisting of 7000 fine-grained annotations,
spanning 5 Indian languages and 7 MT systems, and use it to establish
correlations between annotator scores and scores obtained using existing
automatic metrics. Our results show that pre-trained metrics, such as COMET,
have the highest correlations with annotator scores. Additionally, we find that
the metrics do not adequately capture fluency-based errors in Indian languages,
and there is a need to develop metrics focused on Indian languages. We hope
that our dataset and analysis will help promote further research in this area. | [
-0.3970635533,
-0.5261626244,
-0.0134625761,
0.3460696936,
-0.4424375594,
0.3985585272,
-0.3669739664,
-0.1945123225,
0.3645399809,
0.4318214357,
-0.1560856551,
-0.3766782284,
-0.7418249846,
0.6423950195,
-0.5158387423,
1.0518772602,
-0.1482990086,
0.1101701781,
-0.0907742679,
-0.447532624,
-0.686727047,
-0.4721241295,
-0.2502232194,
-0.1352592409,
0.3114745617,
0.4557706118,
0.7285303473,
0.6304072142,
0.999043107,
0.2696710229,
0.4220020175,
0.6203083396,
0.0992532894,
0.0703882426,
-0.1143906415,
-0.4949898422,
-0.3645033836,
-0.0131612876,
0.8629432321,
0.6036008596,
-0.0738680139,
0.6156736612,
0.3379692733,
0.5795934796,
-0.6902036667,
0.1274514198,
-0.4525075555,
0.111281544,
-0.4891867042,
-0.5180825591,
-0.4774685502,
-0.5561457872,
-0.3123272359,
-0.3580479324,
-0.2674375474,
0.1927676052,
0.6167644858,
0.5160176158,
-0.3244971037,
-0.2037924081,
-0.8857060671,
0.9750291109,
-0.5575343966,
0.3673553467,
0.4108680785,
0.4625737667,
0.12563999,
-0.365239352,
-0.4082016051,
0.0686307028,
-0.262970686,
0.1869000494,
0.0628578663,
-0.3618902564,
-0.0780292451,
0.5321982503,
-0.6490605474,
-0.0439974181,
-0.3942653537,
-0.1131979525,
0.5472608805,
0.6523917913,
0.3608139455,
-0.450220257,
-0.3914455175,
-0.1743939668,
-0.4571284056,
0.0424627587,
0.1181086227,
0.5274865031,
-0.0930086598,
0.8229683042,
-0.1255076081,
0.7126790881,
-0.1273327768,
-0.3495939672,
0.5618454814,
-0.6103880405,
-0.2340454459,
-0.1199853122,
1.3161975145,
0.3875857592,
0.246428445,
-0.0620561652,
-0.3863709867,
-0.1274603158,
-0.1425283104,
-0.6386716962,
0.2798496485,
0.0544599965,
-0.4426009655,
0.0288908519,
-0.0750498101,
-0.7302905917,
-0.1609429568,
-0.5564572215,
0.3933593333,
-0.5854454637,
-0.496168226,
-0.2691144645,
0.1825882047,
0.4038408995,
-0.0489241555,
-0.777475059,
0.2114837915,
0.5749121308,
0.9674577117,
-0.2797186077,
-0.6523379683,
-0.4396602511,
-0.1488111168,
-0.5792665482,
0.6966562271,
-0.9109990597,
-0.4799056351,
0.2046343088,
-0.095395714,
-0.3855420053,
-0.5085430741,
0.7685437799,
-0.2644468248,
0.2826637328,
0.0281412639,
-0.2961111665,
-0.28389135,
0.4646321833,
-0.2067974061,
1.1437649727,
0.2819885015,
-0.6855108738,
0.496104151,
-0.7322604656,
-0.5292326212,
0.2079482824,
-0.1336879283,
-0.1088203862,
0.3143254519,
0.2899266481,
0.4065228999,
-0.6047236919,
0.1917130947,
0.1472384632,
-0.5136238337,
0.3098531663,
-0.5543867946,
0.530651629,
0.6150916219,
-0.0280153267,
0.0138752693,
-0.8103814125,
0.2719017267,
-0.4062168002,
-0.2688154578,
-0.5817755461,
-0.1902629882,
0.1915505975,
0.489410162,
0.1841325462,
-0.4888200164,
0.0928199142,
-0.4336633682,
0.2879446745,
0.3852938414,
-0.0167178083,
0.179459542,
0.0025119102,
0.6139165163,
0.0449027233,
0.2868572176,
-0.2254589647,
-0.3091250062,
-0.7792488933,
-0.3228123784,
0.5656117797,
0.7225994468,
-0.6497996449,
0.4288417697,
-0.6927673817,
-0.4809489846,
-1.2684421539,
0.0792861059,
0.6720650196,
0.2848974168,
0.5191212296,
-0.3870149851,
-0.324993968,
-1.1340894699,
-0.4886194468,
0.0986039639,
0.0408209227,
-0.0616198853,
0.4402626455,
-0.3999519348,
0.8649576902,
-0.1305918097,
-0.4272476733,
-0.0106946882,
0.2130768448,
0.232125774,
0.6290202737,
0.1309427321,
-0.4537533522,
-0.8757258654,
0.1798200309,
-0.6477022767,
-0.2533873916,
0.0298345182,
-0.1131224334,
0.186123088,
0.3624735177,
-0.4828041196,
0.310502857,
0.7282367349,
-0.0504981652,
0.407153815,
-0.2231013328,
0.8078512549,
-1.3731849194,
0.1794911176,
-0.2183424532,
-0.1244653314,
-0.3032029569,
-0.0307154451,
0.1077096835,
-0.0176817365,
-0.4260460734,
0.5471600294,
-0.3062669337,
0.0527953133,
-0.2452989519,
0.2501623333,
-0.2354451567,
0.4024369419,
-0.3241349757,
1.1715188026,
0.2361501753,
-0.6130184531,
0.0121825133,
0.3743568361,
-0.1766896099,
0.8451724648,
-0.3234463632,
-0.1058759019,
0.1994637698,
-0.3478044569,
-0.9952455759,
-0.1941137761,
0.3109150231,
-0.8042950034,
0.4767753184,
-0.1503476799,
-0.9215483069,
-0.0900643617,
-0.1656545252,
0.3575862944,
0.4550568461,
-0.3212142289,
0.5898617506,
0.3705167472,
0.0962174088,
-0.5354147553,
-0.9231255054,
0.2650641203,
-0.2850715816,
-0.3029277921,
-0.3416869044,
-0.026932219,
-0.2365980893,
-0.1398020834,
0.143420592,
-0.0672639459,
0.0761516169,
0.4180704057,
-0.0209879968,
-0.1807216704,
0.1239561439,
0.0406518467,
-0.5698897839,
0.1412935257,
-0.1805514395,
0.5140926838,
-0.2043048441,
-0.5184286833,
-0.4730588794,
0.1714428663,
0.7277141213,
-0.8137958646,
0.7828549743,
0.8958683014,
-0.3330108821,
0.2309380025,
-0.4630968869,
0.1168966219,
-0.333968699,
0.3434658647,
-0.6830284595,
-0.4667394757,
0.4216842353,
-0.1625712961,
0.1139234453,
0.9345003963,
0.6382243037,
0.0819431022,
1.3155093193,
0.4888249636,
-0.1542576849,
0.2625830173,
-0.0313773155,
0.2474403828,
-1.219753027,
-0.1045276597,
-0.6190989614,
-0.2085392624,
-0.9519766569,
-0.3562516868,
0.3010940254,
-0.1682366431,
-0.0071236379,
0.2715731561,
-0.6294098496,
0.3668340445,
0.3483321667,
-0.3331211209,
0.4266885519,
0.0088211363,
-0.3071735501,
-0.4161812365,
-0.4631652832,
-0.8497866392,
1.212141633,
0.0535173714,
0.4048591852,
0.0765947104,
0.4836845696,
0.3910680115,
0.6755290627,
-0.5321813226,
0.3437318206,
-0.3457638621,
-0.7019699216,
-0.1076768115,
-0.3878925145,
-0.8928007483,
0.4981897473,
-0.1801549196,
-0.2309462428,
-0.0814310238,
-0.1746173948,
-0.1594712883,
0.1644174457,
-0.8117000461,
0.6713021994,
-0.2409888357,
-0.3076988161,
-0.1650690734,
-0.7045772076,
0.6074621081,
-0.3608525991,
0.5320526958,
-0.2831722498,
-0.1370110661,
0.7209380865,
-0.3718439639,
0.4551389217,
-0.0256980788,
0.2965116799,
0.3488962054,
0.2597334087,
0.0189036988,
-0.0629773811,
-0.2397135794,
0.1440883577,
0.2813242674,
-0.4573572576,
-0.327033788,
0.6154025197,
-0.7291740179,
-0.1963732541,
-0.5305922627,
-0.4406737387,
-0.1877055615,
0.1346913278,
0.1257536411,
0.3408393264,
0.0091313068,
0.3021151125,
0.2582115829,
-0.1002443954,
0.4700086713,
0.6318683028,
-0.4336440265,
-0.7208613157,
0.9947969317,
0.3096897006,
0.166622147,
0.4837909639,
0.2333472818,
-0.2319391221,
-0.5632104278,
-0.7213629484,
0.0764597282,
-0.6174683571,
-0.4166744351,
-0.5466814041,
-0.1798284501,
-0.0048907758,
0.2119242847,
-0.4842038751,
-0.4418578148,
0.1139651239,
0.1539097577,
0.3702726662,
0.624386251,
-0.0248875748,
0.4842911661,
-1.0861281157,
-0.1927896887,
-0.1266142577,
0.4157925248,
-0.2791028321,
-0.8537284136,
-0.7156153917,
0.1433016062,
-0.1971031278,
-0.386983186,
0.5644282103,
0.2347263843,
0.4431483746,
0.3332545161,
-0.1177023798,
0.9135456681,
-0.5645396709,
0.910953939,
0.0327493884,
-0.8055522442,
0.5637848377,
-0.19103387,
0.2599873841,
0.9216763377,
0.4339631796,
-0.6610584259,
-0.5723693967,
-0.3536735475,
-0.7107239962,
0.3796623945,
0.188290447,
0.1598496437,
-0.1515229195,
0.3234455884,
0.3596741855,
0.2646382749,
-0.3470766544,
-0.396771431,
0.0289849937,
-0.4904119372,
-0.394073993,
0.0195247307,
-0.0113934232,
-0.2853003144,
0.5241306424,
0.0100328503,
-0.1302507967,
0.1610685885,
-0.4605359137,
-0.1634638011,
0.3416869044,
0.5747063756,
0.7669762969,
-0.2514167428,
0.1883395463,
0.3249109685,
-0.6658582687,
0.0694117025,
0.0533757322,
-0.0272952933,
0.1200173497,
0.3696766496,
0.4029443264,
-0.0133818472,
-0.5997703075,
0.3583054543,
-0.087032184,
0.1761725992,
-0.2966096401,
-0.1263465136,
-0.2957094908,
-0.0598432608,
0.3177067339,
0.3211360574,
0.2069795281,
-0.3209602535,
0.0992550924,
0.2802703679,
-0.690784812,
-0.5742638707,
0.6662056446,
0.4132803679,
-0.5657147765,
0.4864770472,
-0.1648609489,
-0.4870099127,
0.1094412804,
0.2710583806,
0.9051494002,
-0.6005843878,
-0.2730230093,
0.5736193657,
0.7943196297,
0.0468254536,
0.183690846,
0.2238998413,
-0.1026683673,
-0.6269820929,
-0.7200276852,
-0.4868901372,
-0.1194072664,
-0.4475421607,
0.4153188765,
-0.0984656289,
-0.3683583438,
-0.3977472186,
0.2470416427,
-0.8955557346,
0.3210733533,
-0.2022553086,
0.7594456077,
-1.0453933477,
0.7174275517,
0.5563403368,
-0.8811414242,
-0.529379189,
-0.2314127386,
-0.1622546315,
-0.7458455563,
0.6138496399,
0.0096442727,
-0.2065186799,
-0.030711554,
-0.1678946316,
-0.8665923476,
0.89726156,
-0.0253254864,
-0.3954055607,
0.714286685,
0.6574545503,
0.7960107327,
-0.645123899,
0.7719955444,
0.6920196414,
0.5352412462,
-0.4891746938,
-1.0705147982,
-0.132562682,
-0.3393003345,
-0.1080177426,
0.6499781013,
-0.8338668346,
0.7062844634,
0.24345164,
-0.1826038659,
-0.1389965564,
0.350954175,
-0.1426625997,
0.2447098047,
0.2643823624,
0.4577288926,
0.4328744709,
-0.0714626387,
0.9580541253,
-0.6510543227,
0.2444789261,
1.1291347742,
-0.0471502729,
1.2173240185,
0.6936279535,
-0.3521530926,
0.1556860656,
0.7016973495,
0.1416864097,
0.1285568029,
0.0950252786,
0.0746804327,
-0.1318219602,
-0.2728738487,
-0.4767132103,
0.5383124352,
0.5786761642,
-0.4436824024,
0.0975028947,
0.0281193387,
0.0575022809,
0.1742637008,
-0.0612957552,
0.7126539946,
0.0152697843,
-0.6493064761,
0.7512475848,
-0.0581759512,
0.6438413262,
-0.4626980126,
0.0783359557,
-0.601878643,
0.1035471708,
-0.4598259032,
-0.8917500973,
0.6764451265,
0.271581471,
-0.1223857552,
-0.1112062111,
0.2437013537,
-0.5592191219,
-0.6069451571,
0.0981140435,
0.9685543776,
0.5976625681,
0.0460168757,
-0.4167356789,
-0.0568486527,
-0.1758914292,
0.0183099583,
0.2381711453,
0.6936537623,
-0.1275833249,
0.5982687473,
0.6682226062,
0.0633326694,
0.1792999804,
-0.09383858,
0.393286407,
-0.7344192266,
-0.0139934309,
-0.9793487191,
0.6854286194,
0.0299804937,
-0.6190314293,
1.079695344,
1.051825285,
0.7148576975,
-0.0994869992,
0.6640498638,
0.1154852435,
0.8643624187,
-0.1979949027,
0.6503980756,
-0.6819172502,
0.2909686863,
-0.1222738475,
-1.2421138287,
-0.400292635,
0.210861668,
-0.1769004911,
-0.1861887276,
0.7922676802,
0.5788069367,
-0.1659872681,
-0.3021107614,
0.2925988138,
-0.0029517992,
0.2767306268,
0.3392585814,
0.9168006778,
-0.8642502427,
0.7971532941,
-0.0100367693,
-0.1313890368,
-0.333588928,
-0.6994903088,
-0.6706904173,
-0.6840394139,
-0.2657642066,
-0.2779075205,
-0.2225931138,
1.2264002562,
0.4486140013,
-0.8326178789,
-0.4457873404,
0.4912793338,
0.0795907825,
-0.1115502641,
-0.18427369,
0.4226770401,
-0.6472437978,
-0.8968465924,
0.1179286465,
0.4662721753,
-0.2026648968,
-0.3944066167,
-0.0398172736,
-0.2285392135,
0.07319846,
0.7398911119,
0.028158091,
-0.5870757103,
-0.1594167799,
-0.035642121,
-0.3014543355,
0.3880507648,
0.5126671195,
-0.5768117905,
0.6662716269,
0.3731156886,
0.7437931299,
0.1243532524,
-0.1055534258,
0.3615343869,
-0.6420671344,
-0.0347419567,
0.0461842343,
0.1844772995,
0.606888175,
0.1620604098,
0.8841418028,
0.0933440924,
-0.6527968645,
-0.9905084372,
-0.2267848104,
-0.5181770921,
0.3282742798,
0.9787493944,
0.1595396996,
-0.2747703493,
-0.1163235679,
-0.2148313522,
0.2866947651,
-0.2338146865,
0.6544687748,
0.7257891893,
-0.0935970843,
0.0239508729,
-0.8925309777,
0.4677415788,
0.3881373107,
-0.7805852294,
0.0817188323,
0.0356643945,
0.2373753637,
0.5690424442,
0.4767684937,
-0.3505648971,
-0.0478378907,
-0.0928277969,
0.1581023633,
0.1803592145,
-0.0740187094,
-0.4691043794,
-0.1518564969,
0.2943767607,
-0.5200746059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10179v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10179v1 | Toward Human-Like Evaluation for Natural Language Generation with Error Analysis | 2022-12-20T11:36:22 | 2022-12-20T11:36:22 | Qingyu Lu, Liang Ding, Liping Xie, Kanjian Zhang, Derek F. Wong, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | The state-of-the-art language model-based automatic metrics, e.g. BARTScore,
benefiting from large-scale contextualized pre-training, have been successfully
used in a wide range of natural language generation (NLG) tasks, including
machine translation, text summarization, and data-to-text. Recent studies show
that considering both major errors (e.g. mistranslated tokens) and minor errors
(e.g. imperfections in fluency) can produce high-quality human judgments. This
inspires us to approach the final goal of the evaluation metrics (human-like
evaluations) by automatic error analysis. To this end, we augment BARTScore by
incorporating the human-like error analysis strategies, namely BARTScore++,
where the final score consists of both the evaluations of major errors and
minor errors. Experimental results show that BARTScore++ can consistently
improve the performance of vanilla BARTScore and outperform existing
top-scoring metrics in 20 out of 25 test settings. We hope our technique can
also be extended to other pre-trained model-based metrics. We will release our
code and scripts to facilitate the community. | [
-0.5856841803,
-0.8427591324,
0.3051830232,
0.3883084357,
-0.1849885434,
0.2133781314,
-0.5232058764,
-0.4812246263,
0.038314607,
0.3783699572,
-0.4691868126,
-0.5487246513,
-0.3522105217,
0.4440214634,
-0.2290423661,
1.1187286377,
-0.037592601,
0.2147961706,
-0.315425545,
-0.0113948919,
-0.6266635656,
-0.595954895,
-0.8428769112,
-0.1157209352,
0.3768355548,
0.5245085955,
0.5711839795,
0.2538468838,
0.5425872803,
0.2146222442,
0.3540978134,
0.4975969195,
-0.2433923781,
0.0965072215,
-0.0580007806,
-0.1215064004,
-1.0167729855,
0.2063347697,
0.5639842749,
0.8935695887,
-0.1896566451,
0.3338686824,
0.0877571106,
0.7668375373,
-0.4325756431,
0.0578468591,
-0.418880105,
0.108724907,
-0.3077222407,
-0.3313881755,
-0.3583754897,
-0.8257888556,
0.1803170592,
-0.6337183714,
0.491563201,
0.369603157,
0.7066159248,
0.1754977256,
-0.1053744331,
-0.35131675,
-0.5627847314,
0.8917861581,
-0.9968899488,
0.2027296424,
0.3921591043,
0.4697727263,
-0.3368236125,
-0.467163384,
-0.5867151022,
-0.4408590496,
-0.1070095897,
0.0857271254,
-0.2061604708,
0.07243485,
0.2064279318,
0.2156863362,
-0.6577490568,
0.0001870295,
-0.2427832484,
-0.22497949,
0.8456166387,
0.3150955439,
0.3067002892,
-0.2802715003,
0.0387129262,
-0.2908309698,
-0.5095291734,
-0.0997774675,
0.4023341835,
0.3535179794,
0.1256588548,
0.2880108953,
-0.2589081526,
0.7500144839,
0.0591465384,
0.3671455085,
0.4386069179,
-0.6272009611,
-0.3460093439,
-0.1850375384,
0.9465818405,
0.4488613307,
0.4658953846,
-0.1174355298,
-0.3444138467,
0.2692936063,
0.5717304349,
-0.710475266,
-0.2707707584,
-0.0542848073,
-0.2668013573,
-0.7139043808,
0.3089106977,
-0.8080241084,
-0.2164061964,
-0.4018287361,
0.3901889026,
-0.2335960567,
-0.1256759763,
0.2127996385,
-0.0852150619,
0.0841789991,
0.3633342683,
-0.707870245,
0.7676434517,
0.4543476403,
0.4205869436,
-0.1377185881,
-0.4062428474,
-0.9111557007,
-0.3066305816,
-0.5899514556,
0.7732211351,
-0.1394739896,
-0.3390346766,
-0.298997581,
-0.2822555304,
0.0645254776,
-0.5914150476,
0.6421781778,
-0.2633610666,
0.6456362009,
-0.2371219844,
-0.3478225768,
-0.3269765079,
0.3991769254,
-0.5059294105,
1.3392232656,
0.281781733,
-0.7284336686,
0.6314681172,
-1.1164959669,
-0.4772058725,
0.0434142314,
-0.005018753,
-0.5777828693,
0.3530574143,
0.2550348639,
0.4673580229,
-0.7253309488,
0.6035181284,
-0.0972422287,
-0.1855808496,
0.2627249658,
-0.546367228,
0.5330674052,
-0.0270479955,
-0.3865215778,
0.192521885,
-0.9992614985,
0.2343961447,
0.1894923002,
-0.3620903492,
-0.2622997761,
0.0686873645,
0.1627399474,
0.1775884181,
0.1284932047,
-0.4662626386,
-0.0215996988,
-0.4149778485,
-0.0443749949,
0.4048592746,
0.0377217829,
0.4550622106,
-0.4009148479,
0.687615037,
-0.4481697083,
0.1972304136,
-0.1828243881,
-0.4277562499,
-0.8625506163,
0.1086619794,
0.5425507426,
0.4282043576,
-0.3510455489,
0.911337316,
-0.3679983318,
-0.5178045034,
-0.5710257292,
0.2197278887,
0.5357809663,
0.7252364755,
0.2927282751,
-1.0000389814,
-0.97977525,
-0.6305029392,
-0.1542044878,
-0.3052587807,
-0.1287200153,
0.131530419,
0.2989930809,
-0.4687503576,
1.3828659058,
-0.3167425394,
-0.0930586755,
-0.388161391,
0.5549744964,
-0.0258365199,
0.5239731669,
0.504506588,
-0.3086540401,
-0.4387786388,
0.0644669086,
-0.620146811,
-0.4780526757,
-0.0565369204,
-0.1928197294,
0.2764962018,
0.1707475483,
-0.2877551317,
0.3294111788,
0.4305517077,
-0.2771474123,
1.0258883238,
-0.3858205676,
0.2598645687,
-0.871622026,
0.3201556802,
-0.1486965865,
-0.5786792636,
-0.6883022189,
-0.1064307243,
-0.1504727602,
-0.021344956,
-0.1593526155,
0.5913721919,
-0.2167928666,
-0.2195937932,
-0.1918606311,
0.2323511094,
0.3008853197,
0.3184027672,
0.007092102,
0.4847515225,
0.3530424833,
-0.5478810668,
0.3353660703,
-0.028400477,
-0.1666274965,
0.5582244396,
-0.6898870468,
0.1863894314,
-0.0701380298,
0.416855216,
-0.8036254644,
-0.7104828954,
0.201746121,
-0.6912685633,
0.3377860188,
0.3857117891,
-0.5483666658,
-0.5091691613,
-0.5435568094,
0.2766026556,
0.5586497188,
-0.3700146079,
0.1963403672,
0.2046854347,
-0.2082065195,
-0.2952764332,
-0.591136992,
0.2459661514,
-0.2297242582,
-0.6642004848,
-0.099235028,
-0.1353556365,
-0.2750499547,
-0.1644478291,
0.3342151642,
-0.042798385,
0.43880108,
-0.0148165971,
0.2899237573,
-0.2488483042,
0.129916057,
0.1417769194,
-0.3920892179,
0.0731674582,
-0.2494247854,
0.4388940334,
-0.4387323558,
-0.3266837001,
-0.4731113613,
0.2243869156,
0.4433322549,
-0.3276721537,
0.1531378925,
0.5166110992,
-0.4072800875,
-0.0975945368,
-0.5705547929,
-0.2457208037,
-0.3747696877,
0.4404149652,
0.1974416971,
-0.5583487153,
0.199955374,
0.077412799,
0.3047479093,
0.4281108677,
0.3739396632,
-0.380872041,
1.0283838511,
0.4628267586,
0.0182313174,
0.1839167029,
0.0156759657,
-0.0106857652,
-0.5915113091,
0.2762161791,
-0.35555318,
-0.1703518182,
-0.3956044316,
-0.5534012914,
0.2868673503,
0.2773310542,
-0.2493750453,
0.4589618742,
-0.464474678,
0.2905915976,
0.5086690784,
-0.4725530148,
0.3250875175,
-0.094010286,
-0.0448891073,
-0.2932279408,
-0.54795748,
-0.7946187854,
1.2962995768,
0.2736361921,
0.2601653039,
-0.1825865209,
0.8818082213,
0.4618815482,
0.7603641748,
-0.6443238854,
0.341443032,
-0.0250736605,
-0.6382584572,
-0.3905365467,
-0.5696069598,
-0.8322457671,
0.2060565799,
-0.4549682736,
-0.4049598277,
-0.2222712934,
0.4055911601,
-0.4616371393,
-0.0783592314,
-0.7193288207,
0.9195709229,
-0.5055124164,
0.0745333508,
-0.0543140918,
-0.6871259809,
0.4539268315,
-0.4009611011,
0.4601836205,
0.0411826447,
0.1374424249,
0.8436678648,
-0.3584919274,
0.7719310522,
-0.2872839868,
-0.0314638875,
0.5082893372,
0.2133188546,
0.4355346859,
-0.1731665581,
-0.1263953447,
0.0161813404,
-0.3816100359,
-0.3244604766,
-0.7019716501,
0.1852799058,
-0.3837280273,
-0.1329860985,
-0.2451073229,
-0.3960191011,
-0.2940272987,
0.1586474031,
0.2785038948,
0.5409221649,
-0.6289871335,
-0.0257537626,
0.2407149673,
-0.2846752405,
0.3831342459,
0.4518734813,
-0.4004291594,
-0.6988911033,
1.0586435795,
-0.2020227313,
0.3224375546,
0.0655876845,
0.4530422986,
-0.1599894911,
-0.4671892226,
-0.7248438597,
0.1091643497,
-0.1785502136,
-0.2848361433,
-0.3743639588,
0.079663083,
-0.1613175571,
-0.2972541153,
-0.5649920702,
-0.410610348,
-0.2856929898,
-0.2013313472,
-0.0101711117,
0.6641891599,
-0.167306155,
0.4924870431,
-0.9667239189,
0.1545965225,
0.3026264906,
0.1991336793,
0.0768025219,
-0.2770305872,
-0.3674648404,
0.0401641913,
-0.5024475455,
-0.4926083088,
0.4833018482,
0.2507770061,
0.1795473844,
0.3162913024,
-0.1366582811,
0.6736449003,
-0.6580738425,
0.749571085,
0.507966578,
-1.0331310034,
0.5649364591,
-0.4859591126,
0.0916970596,
0.9630323052,
-0.2476773113,
-0.7540549636,
-0.7014071941,
-0.775857687,
-0.7381753922,
0.7186610699,
0.4038227499,
0.1612527519,
-0.1945801675,
0.110093154,
0.3499580324,
0.2293562293,
-0.699126482,
0.0382313244,
-0.16393888,
-0.244008407,
-0.1263435185,
0.0851268396,
0.0205663312,
-0.1684605032,
0.6616025567,
-0.1344062984,
-0.0047263391,
0.1264451742,
-0.1576040536,
-0.3370999396,
0.4714302123,
0.5773445964,
0.6444867253,
-0.4169921279,
-0.0061640679,
0.3989924788,
-0.3956169784,
0.1021851525,
0.0382106155,
0.0228014421,
0.0526593439,
0.4832074046,
0.6078344584,
0.2497536838,
-0.9039996266,
0.6197836399,
-0.2461690903,
-0.1429763585,
-0.2714141905,
0.1235846356,
-0.0476225056,
-0.3083668649,
0.5601691008,
0.3350974619,
0.1272667944,
-0.2742663622,
0.374176085,
0.3053974211,
-0.5500762463,
-0.5762909055,
0.5831694007,
0.6267696619,
-0.407458663,
0.2783134878,
-0.7377197146,
-0.5055058002,
0.5753715634,
0.4008351266,
1.1339145899,
-0.0739526823,
0.1938535124,
0.5615425706,
0.351406306,
-0.1564766467,
0.0551664904,
-0.2108803391,
-0.663107276,
-0.6569474936,
-0.6988409758,
-0.4228057563,
-0.2484757304,
-0.6594343185,
0.3243020773,
-0.4246061444,
-0.3033792675,
-0.4164118469,
0.1097976342,
-0.6412137747,
0.5855836868,
0.1530065536,
0.5464116335,
-0.8339500427,
0.5532886982,
0.7764624357,
-0.3009949923,
-0.5923953056,
0.0009254657,
-0.1420665979,
-0.2121120244,
0.6061384082,
0.2685632706,
-0.2734158635,
-0.083687,
-0.2697512805,
-0.579808414,
0.974697113,
0.1821785271,
-0.6060120463,
-0.2109753639,
-0.0674990714,
0.7763215303,
-0.4773516059,
0.3734313846,
0.9009814858,
0.5884177089,
-0.457603097,
-1.0707709789,
-0.0150991092,
-0.1436745524,
0.0288434178,
0.2664558291,
-0.1537899226,
0.5206853151,
-0.0516408347,
-0.297354877,
0.0330557637,
0.5653898716,
0.2327251434,
0.3855392337,
0.6945615411,
0.5770329833,
1.0241880417,
0.1599547267,
1.2010264397,
0.0758646354,
0.4272869229,
1.2928382158,
-0.0430061072,
0.706345439,
0.180768609,
-0.3505708277,
0.5077966452,
0.4741023481,
0.2105956525,
0.1338213533,
0.2656913698,
0.0096702036,
-0.2200707197,
0.1817520559,
-0.1796574444,
0.4144002795,
0.1948722899,
-0.2395463139,
-0.3639110923,
-0.1861359477,
0.0277473219,
0.2845543623,
0.0234373249,
0.7313867807,
-0.0873334929,
-0.6771665215,
0.6252595186,
0.0147534935,
0.77150172,
-0.4356765151,
0.1208897904,
-0.1008173078,
-0.1558881849,
-0.2460504472,
-0.3454175591,
0.4204789102,
0.4626435637,
-0.1484308243,
-0.130078271,
0.5224431753,
-0.201268509,
-0.6089810133,
0.2349088341,
0.5648702979,
0.1891428381,
0.0070050354,
-0.4771222472,
-0.3254375458,
0.1203318983,
-0.191581741,
0.1079798415,
0.2921424806,
-0.2754376233,
0.3321647048,
0.7436069846,
0.1735231727,
0.0570847839,
0.3206165433,
0.4861508012,
-0.7115515471,
-0.2800881565,
-0.7343037724,
0.6317154765,
-0.2372311801,
-0.4929488301,
0.5772617459,
0.4525414407,
0.7300137877,
0.0113485595,
0.985622406,
-0.1500348151,
0.7515547872,
-0.0574701875,
0.8138298988,
-0.4468226135,
0.1177226901,
-0.7091329694,
-1.2538034916,
-0.70315516,
0.5158139467,
-0.2595817149,
-0.2040678561,
0.5557768345,
0.556456089,
0.0049202451,
-0.0078490824,
0.2721431553,
-0.1667622179,
0.5016184449,
0.4198136628,
0.9733521938,
-0.4322922528,
0.4099157751,
-0.0382086188,
-0.3875027299,
-0.3768718541,
-0.9833087325,
-0.6280973554,
-0.283207953,
-0.2048752904,
-0.0078386236,
-0.1858553141,
1.1684212685,
0.6279363036,
-0.8305610418,
-0.3632981777,
-0.588670671,
-0.1571240425,
-0.0888668448,
-0.2290865779,
0.237336129,
-0.7196002007,
-0.7144752741,
0.3185428083,
0.224088341,
-0.0695705488,
-0.4005217254,
-0.4626433253,
0.1966570765,
0.2566870749,
0.6526935101,
0.2594742477,
-0.5205647349,
-0.3937397301,
-0.1931999922,
-0.2085462362,
0.0646438003,
0.7452363968,
-0.8126527071,
0.8105089068,
0.3902460337,
0.6188080311,
0.1577253044,
0.4117167592,
1.0524399281,
-0.8809424639,
-0.1257333905,
0.4414796829,
0.1393897682,
0.7318637371,
-0.0039556008,
0.5737754703,
0.1029909626,
-0.4880859852,
-0.8865509629,
0.0531532355,
-0.7005975246,
0.1851984262,
0.8384650946,
-0.0309214555,
-0.0939261541,
-0.0392367728,
-0.4576177895,
0.310520649,
-0.4405992627,
0.8729003668,
0.6823714375,
-0.2198296338,
0.4163784087,
-0.5849559307,
0.677136302,
0.5372787714,
-1.225458622,
0.2116478086,
0.6794989109,
0.2909252942,
0.3631166816,
0.6245973706,
-0.1606159955,
0.7265818119,
-0.2214280963,
0.4179087579,
0.0704497695,
-0.2323529273,
-0.2788691223,
-0.1604118049,
0.2561809123,
-0.1847949177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10173v1 | On the Role of Parallel Data in Cross-lingual Transfer Learning | 2022-12-20T11:23:04 | 2022-12-20T11:23:04 | Machel Reid, Mikel Artetxe | cs.CL | cs.CL | While prior work has established that the use of parallel data is conducive
for cross-lingual learning, it is unclear if the improvements come from the
data itself, or if it is the modeling of parallel interactions that matters.
Exploring this, we examine the usage of unsupervised machine translation to
generate synthetic parallel data, and compare it to supervised machine
translation and gold parallel data. We find that even model generated parallel
data can be useful for downstream tasks, in both a general setting (continued
pretraining) as well as the task-specific setting (translate-train), although
our best results are still obtained using real parallel data. Our findings
suggest that existing multilingual models do not exploit the full potential of
monolingual data, and prompt the community to reconsider the traditional
categorization of cross-lingual learning approaches. | [
-0.3909338713,
-0.4271400869,
0.4191881716,
0.3529370427,
-0.0687968582,
0.1347908378,
-0.2936516404,
-0.4358403385,
0.1964361519,
0.6173842549,
-0.5087365508,
-0.3067725897,
-0.7629169822,
0.2823909521,
-0.6579751968,
0.9723603725,
-0.3376173377,
0.2042496055,
-0.4896286726,
-0.1572121084,
-0.4272612333,
-0.9359600544,
-0.5171198249,
-0.5092908144,
0.5974873304,
0.5896511078,
0.5906909108,
0.6491007209,
0.3878161013,
0.3225962222,
0.5280784369,
0.2645774484,
-0.5650758147,
-0.272347033,
-0.4433310926,
-0.7184222341,
-0.2796421349,
0.0744490102,
0.6549906731,
1.3245660067,
0.2445428818,
0.1316488534,
0.0923914835,
0.9492185116,
-0.2741626799,
0.5093975663,
-0.4093650281,
0.3763614893,
-0.5035789013,
-0.1460694224,
-0.3628596961,
0.0156855639,
0.3333542645,
-0.8353218436,
0.2315526307,
0.2664877772,
0.437110126,
-0.1008390114,
-0.570040524,
-0.246017009,
-0.8662301898,
0.9503890276,
-0.2772998512,
0.4098384976,
0.291972965,
0.4383773506,
0.125794217,
-0.8254413605,
-0.436395973,
0.0028835176,
-0.3636806607,
0.0907374844,
-0.1331701726,
-0.3777399957,
0.270513773,
0.3795716166,
-0.7035122514,
0.1063033491,
-0.7360858917,
-0.0995257348,
0.5909587145,
0.3556678295,
0.5496980548,
0.0658069775,
-0.6411497593,
-0.4042046666,
-0.8800028563,
0.2003381848,
0.2731049359,
0.6355748773,
-0.1321897805,
0.4653179646,
-0.2629311979,
0.5960699916,
-0.1744743735,
0.0876837447,
0.4422921836,
-0.4219436944,
-0.2235160023,
0.2297254801,
0.7461779118,
0.3920345902,
0.8630014658,
-0.4649963081,
0.0177968778,
0.0728048757,
0.1592741013,
-0.723988235,
-0.3952313066,
-0.1529447883,
-0.2896585464,
0.0793193281,
0.4813829064,
-0.6850662827,
0.0807387307,
-0.6855396628,
0.0801833272,
0.0477170125,
-0.3821148872,
0.3381455541,
-0.0692534894,
-0.2586196959,
0.0139719658,
-0.9187096953,
0.4733877778,
0.4519082308,
0.6071077585,
-0.603303194,
-0.9243558645,
-0.491396606,
0.3422329426,
-0.5130972266,
0.6939932704,
-0.3660185933,
-0.4295485914,
-0.0734212101,
0.6146953106,
-0.6124811769,
-0.7479906678,
0.1552491784,
-0.1593466252,
0.1252336353,
-0.5379493237,
-0.2746848166,
-0.3004112542,
-0.1192214191,
-0.7622847557,
0.5683050156,
0.0553601421,
-0.8653656244,
0.3545639515,
-0.3995023966,
-0.7391628027,
-0.2168646008,
-0.0708404258,
-0.2164996266,
0.0703824982,
0.3675782979,
0.2665350139,
-0.3564437926,
0.2706324756,
-0.3876602054,
-0.337815702,
0.2656189501,
-0.2800933421,
0.6890507936,
0.1515311152,
-0.0557375364,
-0.2215321213,
-0.381485194,
-0.2569777668,
0.0918999687,
-0.1622246802,
-0.597178638,
-0.304906249,
0.0593604334,
0.3222298026,
0.1238436848,
-0.67541188,
-0.0289617144,
-0.0577142052,
-0.0189678874,
0.4613914788,
-0.3650672436,
0.6598476768,
-0.520545423,
0.6346690655,
0.311660409,
-0.2043948323,
-0.0533638485,
-0.3582412004,
-0.6161510944,
-0.0460565425,
0.7138267159,
0.6387125254,
-0.9318969846,
-0.232606411,
-0.4033835232,
-0.3393921554,
-0.6349585652,
0.3995080292,
0.3569172919,
0.5606346726,
0.3964174092,
-0.4326692224,
-0.7616581321,
-0.8625981212,
-0.5646936893,
0.0718150586,
0.1496403068,
0.163749218,
0.1534526646,
-0.1779725701,
0.6158371568,
-0.166407913,
-0.2497140318,
-0.427639842,
0.4649514854,
-0.1835098267,
0.725402534,
0.8456547856,
-0.8474752307,
-0.9098904133,
0.412101388,
-1.2033441067,
-0.2946534157,
-0.3096368313,
-0.2081836462,
0.1906757951,
0.5453758836,
-0.6499288082,
0.3159283996,
0.6510702968,
0.0392606035,
0.2299979627,
-0.332518518,
0.2793834805,
-0.9239959717,
0.1637899727,
-0.1562217623,
-0.3116776049,
-0.8306214213,
-0.385507077,
0.1117316633,
-0.0653966889,
-0.644423008,
0.5728824735,
-0.5190473795,
-0.422011435,
-0.3959344029,
-0.2338445187,
-0.0628475025,
0.365062356,
0.3437410891,
0.7059580088,
0.8421363235,
-0.3378801048,
0.2945211828,
0.1999823749,
-0.3579794765,
0.395260632,
-0.4905045629,
0.0860026777,
-0.0515092649,
0.1173909009,
-0.7181454897,
-0.1954735816,
0.1628501564,
-0.2809537649,
0.4365413785,
-0.0746408477,
-0.5895409584,
-0.247436285,
0.0707048923,
0.6222892404,
0.4935939908,
-0.7539888024,
0.1839380413,
0.4047112763,
-0.3796006739,
-0.3627007604,
-1.0913271904,
-0.1520074308,
-0.3612153828,
-0.4953934252,
0.4469381571,
0.298931092,
-0.2122887671,
0.144290477,
-0.0795780793,
0.0409106724,
-0.2281835526,
0.0813261941,
0.2225763202,
-0.1750202179,
-0.1364105493,
0.2205066532,
-0.2122537941,
0.2194213122,
-0.1697761267,
0.2379751951,
0.0981007293,
-0.4234479368,
-0.2982487381,
0.644010663,
0.7091157436,
-0.1967063695,
0.6344646811,
0.6319215298,
-0.0850089863,
-0.2886569798,
0.0828348696,
-0.0267812982,
-0.4115948379,
0.218667537,
-0.5070311427,
-0.655639112,
0.4745301604,
-0.2365593314,
-0.1223542467,
0.2537508011,
0.4071326852,
-0.0833693966,
1.1736370325,
0.6917790174,
-0.0540069267,
0.3515169621,
-0.1289680451,
0.1145810187,
-0.5064409971,
-0.2481764555,
-0.2698515654,
-0.2679342628,
-0.7560620904,
-0.2276215404,
0.1871606261,
0.087736398,
-0.017600419,
0.4110907316,
0.0765391588,
0.1430293918,
0.4880827367,
-0.063580133,
0.3495799899,
0.2798904777,
0.1492794901,
-0.1309892386,
-0.9644525647,
-0.0530380011,
1.378570199,
0.0306524634,
0.7311009169,
-0.2711702883,
0.4996245205,
0.0257746074,
0.3794279695,
-0.3001665175,
0.3200149834,
-0.6060371995,
-0.2064152211,
-0.0568675995,
-0.6300814748,
-1.1896728277,
0.4918349087,
-0.0229877196,
-0.2378015965,
0.3005076349,
0.0002286942,
0.0846309662,
0.43541798,
-0.8673964143,
1.0781809092,
-0.357991904,
-0.1525585055,
-0.0519242436,
-0.4749316275,
0.3378192186,
-0.5138812661,
0.3235954344,
0.0957593545,
0.3066747487,
0.8397438526,
-0.4324230254,
0.8312542439,
-0.0915253907,
0.1858625263,
0.2165518105,
0.0591555983,
0.3710728586,
-0.1712074429,
0.3351483941,
0.351336509,
0.0021693781,
-0.5936688185,
-0.5855216384,
0.9233007431,
-0.7318300605,
-0.6381560564,
-0.2891037762,
-1.192979455,
-0.3926773369,
0.0934700593,
0.0300121866,
0.1551746726,
0.0607006475,
0.3475137055,
0.3111556172,
-0.0406022705,
0.2615995705,
0.3060669005,
-0.463206917,
-0.1060682982,
1.2066657543,
0.3086718917,
0.4187214375,
0.1760277152,
0.0091505814,
-0.2844119072,
-0.2425592393,
-0.6400951743,
0.3267573416,
-0.523052156,
0.2466160655,
-0.5177844167,
-0.0379398018,
-0.4753006101,
-0.0244624838,
-0.4806635082,
-0.5583603978,
-0.1532030255,
-0.2155073434,
0.1854815781,
0.6698137522,
-0.4048832953,
0.0980697498,
-0.9810833335,
0.2539311945,
0.3591594398,
-0.2057506889,
-0.243259415,
-0.318238616,
-0.3771686256,
0.1729773283,
0.1574483365,
-0.6196170449,
0.745685041,
0.0349677019,
0.7793668509,
-0.0291469544,
0.0760762095,
0.7313981056,
-0.4615694582,
0.4360623956,
0.1344132572,
-0.6094892621,
0.1619966328,
-0.1364070326,
0.3602956533,
0.3727788925,
0.8514791131,
-0.4502342641,
-0.0851016268,
-0.3688209653,
-0.5205267072,
0.8821515441,
0.0368931815,
0.008242514,
0.295619756,
-0.1847233474,
0.4483807981,
0.3485137224,
-0.4966652393,
-0.1386381686,
-0.3055123687,
-0.009771673,
-0.4503926635,
0.2349706292,
0.1243846267,
-0.4392318726,
0.1696752012,
-0.123764582,
-0.0817217156,
0.0373280607,
-0.1487825066,
-0.2568487525,
-0.1194799915,
0.0296872798,
0.6046472192,
-0.0302756168,
0.0532285385,
0.023651721,
-0.2849561274,
-0.0972075313,
0.2955708206,
-0.0613188595,
0.1672484279,
0.2117515504,
0.9134672284,
0.1262226701,
-0.6972426772,
0.2680898905,
0.1533661634,
-0.4522625208,
-0.0122732036,
-0.2723973691,
0.0683587343,
0.1738382429,
-0.0966607854,
0.1190109625,
0.0204495732,
-0.8117810488,
0.2123098224,
0.1824116111,
-0.0691932291,
-0.5654585361,
0.5402992368,
-0.0302436296,
0.018398175,
0.8335205317,
0.3312256634,
-0.5122117996,
0.6363132,
0.7413436174,
0.6281104088,
-0.2428921014,
0.207082361,
0.2448930889,
0.2259928584,
-0.2367672175,
0.1878968924,
-0.2922462523,
-0.5358054042,
-0.4676509202,
-0.44208318,
-0.3120126128,
-0.1627970934,
-0.8433738351,
0.0837251395,
0.058989685,
0.2197797894,
-0.0095060635,
-0.3455005884,
-0.8759821653,
0.1123930886,
0.2884810269,
0.6429015398,
-1.2946512699,
1.2700603008,
0.7650119066,
-0.3495749235,
-0.4883441031,
-0.1653077155,
-0.271933794,
-0.6722124219,
1.0521366596,
0.2293757647,
0.0278750397,
-0.1560617983,
-0.0139526669,
-0.8556475043,
0.948867321,
0.5770229697,
-0.3834299445,
-0.1480606049,
0.9564340711,
0.6190874577,
-0.6475689411,
-0.3100552261,
0.4706248343,
0.5012638569,
0.0076510631,
-1.2199978828,
-0.0954772234,
-0.2439453155,
0.0819772184,
-0.067170307,
-0.4512374997,
1.3428082466,
0.086710155,
-0.3648441136,
-0.2416891158,
0.4732935131,
0.0145116178,
0.4298200011,
0.3464390039,
0.5827961564,
0.3772126138,
-0.0516459271,
1.2351521254,
-0.1300127506,
0.2248824239,
0.9173930287,
-0.3415256739,
0.647021234,
0.7283909917,
-0.101529412,
0.3479261994,
0.6303125024,
0.1520665884,
0.7305890322,
0.0613105372,
0.1145398766,
-0.4862207472,
-0.0930116624,
-0.4087687135,
0.3910421133,
0.3943479061,
-0.3638581038,
-0.4626372457,
0.3925414383,
-0.2599101067,
0.128853634,
-0.3751458526,
0.4051844478,
0.3550082445,
-0.8770756721,
0.677040875,
-0.2836498916,
0.3377436697,
-0.3667759597,
-0.1219387874,
-0.4210534692,
0.3561367095,
-0.1812978238,
-0.7441508174,
0.7757603526,
-0.0766683668,
-0.1986314058,
-0.6377242804,
0.6067578793,
-0.7622808218,
-0.4686646163,
0.5215364695,
0.9216288328,
0.5163317919,
-0.0105098961,
-0.5902107358,
-0.0186583903,
0.0303237084,
-0.0777813867,
0.8638469577,
0.5630789399,
-0.3837683797,
0.414783746,
0.8510201573,
0.1841315031,
0.3326997757,
0.0708361268,
0.7273951769,
-0.4424929619,
-0.2943738401,
-0.4479810297,
0.2659603357,
0.133513242,
-0.0772408992,
1.0831348896,
0.5317792296,
1.6908364296,
-0.2881779075,
0.8779500127,
0.2536721826,
0.6469663382,
-0.5576613545,
0.4868844151,
-0.7183791399,
0.1046318784,
0.0329457819,
-0.7427597642,
-0.0707138255,
0.0675680488,
-0.4450612068,
-0.138141945,
0.8619126081,
0.6834965944,
-0.5162339211,
0.2087098807,
0.4598272145,
-0.2178937197,
-0.1963335127,
0.8298969269,
0.8143236637,
-0.3785770237,
0.5344136357,
-0.496370405,
-0.0248502102,
0.1532129794,
-0.3727440238,
-1.0694758892,
-0.5832720995,
-0.1184577718,
0.1245867461,
0.1090033278,
0.555288434,
0.7599413395,
-0.9133687615,
-0.6824389696,
-0.3246873617,
-0.1973315924,
-0.3376744688,
-0.1126627997,
0.3391326964,
-0.5697158575,
-1.0852035284,
0.5873138309,
-0.1246089712,
0.1709486693,
-0.2020863593,
-0.1469412446,
-0.0186180733,
-0.2185678631,
0.5264409184,
0.683188498,
-0.4214753807,
0.0995396078,
0.1363229305,
-0.0354787484,
-0.0679574236,
1.0224456787,
-0.8711192608,
0.5137653947,
0.6201771498,
0.9895606041,
0.7765117288,
-0.0410191678,
0.8956019282,
-0.5330966115,
0.2870343626,
-0.3394941986,
0.4484049082,
0.4585165679,
-0.1709868312,
0.3299002647,
0.6205385923,
-0.3196641505,
-0.7764372826,
-0.0050701532,
-0.712572217,
-0.3889947236,
1.0478788614,
-0.3772851229,
-0.4561840296,
-0.1711539775,
0.0283925161,
0.2188477814,
0.1481257826,
0.4778911769,
0.4900739193,
-0.333407402,
-0.1263817847,
-0.7353774905,
0.4924868941,
0.7069893479,
-0.873852551,
0.1394769102,
0.2370809913,
0.2237184644,
0.0452809446,
0.3134409785,
-0.3141271174,
0.2739691436,
0.1426220536,
-0.2833915651,
-0.140739724,
-0.6989222765,
-0.164238587,
0.0361285619,
-0.4092902839,
-0.4445748925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10171v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10171v1 | Document-level Relation Extraction with Relation Correlations | 2022-12-20T11:17:52 | 2022-12-20T11:17:52 | Ridong Han, Tao Peng, Benyou Wang, Lu Liu, Xiang Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level relation extraction faces two overlooked challenges: long-tail
problem and multi-label problem. Previous work focuses mainly on obtaining
better contextual representations for entity pairs, hardly address the above
challenges. In this paper, we analyze the co-occurrence correlation of
relations, and introduce it into DocRE task for the first time. We argue that
the correlations can not only transfer knowledge between data-rich relations
and data-scarce ones to assist in the training of tailed relations, but also
reflect semantic distance guiding the classifier to identify semantically close
relations for multi-label entity pairs. Specifically, we use relation embedding
as a medium, and propose two co-occurrence prediction sub-tasks from both
coarse- and fine-grained perspectives to capture relation correlations.
Finally, the learned correlation-aware embeddings are used to guide the
extraction of relational facts. Substantial experiments on two popular DocRE
datasets are conducted, and our method achieves superior results compared to
baselines. Insightful analysis also demonstrates the potential of relation
correlations to address the above challenges. | [
-0.391908884,
-0.6621595025,
0.8143221736,
-0.0899601728,
-0.0217873454,
-0.0492463373,
-0.0258792322,
-0.6778901815,
0.1811623126,
0.3608803451,
-0.3909387589,
-0.4789367318,
-0.7750105262,
-0.1180441901,
-0.3672506511,
1.1644983292,
0.0272254534,
-0.2409316599,
-0.8099507689,
-0.1943235844,
-0.2403208464,
-0.5030443668,
-0.6579105258,
-0.2062315494,
0.6161900163,
0.2656420171,
0.3695063293,
0.3814294338,
0.669238627,
0.1232070923,
0.0800496191,
0.4081531763,
-0.4697699845,
0.2555981278,
-0.1934815347,
-0.2029390931,
-0.4178305566,
-0.0142438561,
0.4264627397,
0.8408609629,
0.0411750302,
-0.1340089589,
-0.1059696302,
0.4516607523,
-0.4838704765,
0.5918111205,
-0.4946631193,
-0.0812408179,
-0.3351474106,
-0.1878189594,
-0.3087813258,
0.112503849,
0.1394666135,
-1.072204113,
0.4080553651,
0.1725291461,
1.3083628416,
0.0475765169,
-0.5300097466,
-0.5521697402,
-0.699716568,
0.6307665706,
-0.1794985086,
0.6813016534,
0.5685735941,
0.0524850301,
-0.1843516827,
-0.7423164845,
-0.3801288009,
0.0431870148,
-0.4027808905,
0.2396097183,
0.038716726,
-0.3455092311,
0.1538906246,
0.3965795338,
-0.1484390795,
0.0300671719,
-0.3118138611,
-0.0965424404,
0.3032572567,
0.0517784171,
0.1141925082,
-0.2946380377,
-0.4307150841,
-0.1828897297,
-0.368652463,
-0.1350687593,
0.1124437228,
0.0470034368,
-0.2734477222,
0.3155160248,
0.1268049479,
0.4300407767,
0.3280107677,
-0.3831110597,
0.1932488978,
-0.5834053159,
0.1861782819,
-0.191258803,
1.140229702,
0.3328860402,
0.3610285521,
-0.4130299091,
0.1971409023,
-0.1015943363,
-0.0262093898,
-0.5496766567,
-0.2326988727,
0.1454766989,
-0.2127637267,
-0.2540703118,
0.1783989817,
-0.8988347054,
-0.2952353954,
-0.1910973042,
-0.0454864837,
-0.5864375234,
-0.4092760682,
-0.342181921,
-0.4659859836,
0.2604220212,
0.3806102872,
-1.0131591558,
0.6949257851,
1.0409772396,
0.7718941569,
-0.1264493465,
-0.2961794436,
-0.6678348184,
0.7182235122,
-0.0867150575,
0.8000996113,
-0.5485115051,
-0.3590763509,
-0.0554743819,
-0.1186854839,
-0.0433473215,
-0.3767062128,
0.5659240484,
-0.5120518804,
0.2060503215,
-0.1316650808,
-0.76065588,
0.3291360438,
0.2973384559,
-0.8544323444,
1.0427387953,
0.3559116423,
-1.2921792269,
0.2827529609,
-0.1369193643,
-0.5433807373,
-0.1601512283,
-0.4870110154,
-0.6414487362,
-0.1303158253,
0.3665865064,
0.5982189178,
-0.5239108205,
0.2400275171,
-0.4566390216,
0.1694601178,
-0.0664971396,
0.2433605045,
0.6564216614,
0.0948533192,
0.3738055825,
-0.3823519647,
-1.0085755587,
-0.5326533914,
0.1974112839,
0.1525726765,
-1.1297295094,
-0.169774577,
-0.3953223825,
0.4107840955,
0.3031023145,
-0.532304883,
0.0844330266,
-0.066488266,
0.0384090021,
0.105947271,
0.5588527322,
0.8242739439,
-0.0795044079,
0.2093475461,
0.4612128139,
-0.0389166549,
-0.1026775017,
-0.3055832088,
-0.4733047783,
-0.1772108376,
0.1921991408,
0.3719179332,
-0.4984483123,
0.4712150991,
-0.6378456354,
-0.5080330968,
-0.0934216604,
0.3388012946,
0.3029273748,
0.9183189869,
0.3912285864,
-0.4153266549,
-0.3359820843,
-0.788449049,
-0.1084958166,
0.0148501191,
0.1249042079,
0.2955289483,
0.4274504781,
0.1820876598,
1.0105514526,
-0.974188745,
-0.8444261551,
0.2152007818,
0.3831666112,
0.1568109691,
0.4420779645,
0.6142792106,
-0.7889000177,
-0.6449967623,
0.0387994759,
-1.0643706322,
0.2297984213,
-0.1536223888,
-0.1105120778,
-0.0437540486,
0.6736915112,
-0.6344652176,
0.0966003388,
0.2029271275,
0.0575339831,
0.3320333064,
-0.3755375445,
-0.3043043911,
-1.346067667,
-0.1277499944,
0.2625927329,
-0.1082864925,
-0.5076918602,
-0.1321065724,
0.2044030279,
-0.1533928961,
-0.0394399241,
0.4127525687,
-0.8177582026,
-0.2014275938,
0.2676749229,
0.4160781503,
0.4270225167,
0.3276864588,
0.36302495,
0.336244911,
0.4112659693,
-0.4429430664,
0.203352958,
0.6154462099,
-0.1654605567,
0.8819573522,
-0.1638337821,
0.2191063017,
0.026666563,
0.3548231125,
-0.6031125784,
-0.0093974741,
0.3272635639,
-0.4717390239,
0.6959847212,
-0.2656899095,
-0.5949531198,
-0.0390096046,
-0.3584321141,
0.0786490142,
0.0194734968,
-0.3931813538,
0.514624536,
0.6147096157,
-0.1963702142,
-0.6672345996,
-0.3653483093,
-0.0555788018,
-0.2055127323,
-0.7316099405,
0.4626799822,
0.4744745195,
-0.2345462143,
0.2621538341,
-0.2836472094,
-0.4871305525,
0.0427357554,
0.3622714579,
0.1067539081,
0.0679552853,
0.3475049436,
0.0666649416,
-0.2409086376,
0.3699903488,
0.0036409821,
0.2889589965,
0.1411509067,
0.0815094486,
-0.0174212847,
0.5296140313,
0.3752779067,
-0.5156420469,
0.936440587,
0.7566522956,
-0.5152962804,
0.2156935781,
-0.5417524576,
0.1526196599,
-0.3387517333,
0.3569523394,
-0.8216608763,
-0.3816874325,
0.5670762658,
-0.3058100641,
-0.285495609,
0.6199022532,
-0.1165557653,
-0.2287058979,
0.1324891746,
0.8088048697,
-0.1411050707,
0.4797462225,
-0.5997017026,
0.1391507834,
-1.0649873018,
-0.5791749358,
-0.626206696,
0.4698752761,
-0.4994052052,
-0.3268442452,
0.2520159185,
0.4244210124,
0.1037686244,
0.5362785459,
-0.030755043,
0.0312454533,
0.3705750108,
0.1321656108,
0.5080596805,
0.1651530862,
-0.1022389531,
-0.1614004672,
-0.4435245693,
-0.0616658665,
0.8859567642,
0.1160139143,
0.7476314306,
-0.1151767075,
1.3336939812,
-0.0665613413,
0.1329559237,
-0.8469071984,
0.1956560761,
-0.3835927248,
-0.2801228166,
-0.3036795557,
-0.4666199684,
-1.1522879601,
-0.1485551298,
-0.3752655089,
-0.7177075148,
0.5705912709,
-0.3954018056,
0.0772109553,
-0.0439431407,
-0.5400574803,
0.7266557813,
-0.1257643551,
-0.783257544,
-0.1919066459,
-0.875970602,
0.2044095844,
-0.2546674013,
0.6045304537,
0.0136224534,
-0.0566433817,
0.9533733726,
-0.5403460264,
0.4168938994,
0.1305235922,
-0.4248120189,
0.1441756785,
-0.0018634109,
0.5360558629,
0.0060695233,
-0.1810324341,
0.0846598893,
0.1478931755,
-0.204319492,
-0.7328997254,
0.85801512,
-0.6288385391,
-0.319326818,
-0.6862719655,
-0.6506901383,
-0.3299948871,
0.3979501128,
-0.0190945826,
0.6052668691,
-0.4266629815,
-0.0005678945,
0.4299802482,
0.1251544654,
0.2848184705,
0.3391875029,
-0.167880103,
-0.5969408751,
0.9917858243,
0.2029050738,
0.1491983235,
0.8194177151,
0.1274700761,
-0.2696583271,
-0.125242874,
-0.0982240885,
0.4918760955,
-0.6570817828,
-0.1532434076,
-0.9502497315,
-0.202711761,
-0.5297948718,
0.0805314183,
-0.2995280921,
-0.4167974293,
-0.4256795943,
0.1021855995,
0.3198946714,
0.6618032455,
-0.2066088915,
0.0125218024,
-1.0550740957,
0.6054278612,
0.1401034892,
0.0883639678,
0.0767778009,
-0.0551846735,
-0.4289914072,
-0.3716684282,
-0.2353990227,
-0.9191144705,
0.2484321594,
0.2962456644,
0.3813464344,
0.5031398535,
0.2960771024,
0.6667649746,
-0.3191888928,
0.4098875225,
0.3799217939,
-0.4423056543,
0.5330315232,
-0.463681221,
-0.2873200774,
0.5603281856,
0.7326921821,
-0.2878765166,
-0.3545777202,
-0.981400013,
-0.7257292867,
0.65433079,
0.1896272153,
-0.254683882,
-0.0978951082,
0.3768990636,
0.1075639948,
-0.0032670961,
-0.31380108,
-0.3283960819,
0.0885494947,
-0.1907375753,
-0.0685899258,
-0.2260690778,
-0.0711150244,
-0.256277889,
0.2727909684,
0.2398329377,
0.0637634024,
0.3099783957,
-0.3655703962,
-0.0530261733,
0.3031319678,
0.224067688,
0.7377543449,
-0.6824944615,
0.2750842571,
-0.1724935025,
-0.4143845439,
-0.1095737889,
0.5035560131,
0.0726256743,
0.1273140609,
0.5990077853,
0.384624958,
0.3350836635,
0.08957389,
0.7766805291,
0.0217316411,
0.0316797793,
-0.5353294611,
-0.280140996,
0.446685493,
-0.0991077498,
0.279329896,
-0.1212611645,
0.003554448,
-0.7066028714,
0.4983074665,
0.4082147479,
-0.3658881783,
-0.1571199447,
0.4642425179,
0.2954776287,
-0.182053417,
0.5739558339,
-0.1870698929,
-0.3589462936,
0.7076376677,
0.6269041896,
0.2861029506,
0.1135018915,
0.078388378,
0.710396111,
-0.0065175425,
0.0279712286,
-0.3119679987,
-0.2659367323,
-0.711791575,
-0.1286329329,
-0.473952204,
-0.6026015282,
0.1933000535,
-1.1115694046,
0.4904871583,
-0.1342463344,
0.1649750024,
0.2933653593,
0.3939939439,
-0.7512036562,
0.0946422741,
-0.1245114952,
0.6484040618,
-0.8216921091,
1.0844843388,
0.4570060074,
-0.8855494857,
-0.6409728527,
0.0324364901,
-0.3593097925,
-0.5167598724,
0.9372709394,
0.1099514514,
-0.01246385,
0.0265139174,
-0.1325340569,
-0.587346375,
1.1988589764,
0.1539045274,
-0.7586663365,
-0.3000573516,
0.0141339693,
0.5546410084,
-0.4416922033,
0.2564460337,
0.4440656304,
0.3038374484,
0.0006501381,
-0.6650044322,
0.2756651938,
0.0346501768,
-0.4521034956,
0.428643465,
-0.6911544204,
0.7456927896,
-0.1111382023,
-0.2498483807,
-0.1102518961,
0.7424672246,
-0.0745536312,
0.6885772347,
0.5020418763,
0.8617154956,
0.7956951261,
0.1497379988,
1.1717395782,
-0.3714297712,
0.4989917874,
1.7184559107,
-0.4603198767,
0.8614341617,
0.6649591327,
-0.36779356,
0.7136561871,
0.3545076251,
-0.1181572527,
0.5878525376,
-0.1318007261,
-0.1060181856,
-0.1301230937,
-0.3622531593,
-0.5372486711,
0.2608462274,
0.7434353232,
-0.4146150053,
-0.4042010307,
-0.4544915557,
0.1207142621,
0.0917047635,
-0.0106558101,
1.0478929281,
0.538744688,
-0.6320836544,
0.1500699222,
-0.4816048443,
0.3247973919,
-0.6486772895,
-0.2543602586,
-0.1254153401,
0.1664857119,
-0.3135539889,
-0.7346938252,
0.2171262205,
-0.4291413724,
-0.4272665083,
0.0025335907,
1.100569129,
-0.6043211222,
-0.1741866767,
0.859595418,
0.8721616864,
0.1280971915,
0.0118809547,
-0.313405633,
-0.3552011549,
-0.499928087,
0.1979795992,
0.5364505649,
0.7341101766,
-0.0854612589,
0.1958166063,
0.7082240582,
0.1395175457,
-0.1736678034,
0.098486416,
0.8463981748,
-0.5471775532,
-0.2453118563,
-0.5382142663,
0.0183310695,
-0.5765368938,
-0.0212310608,
0.5868290067,
0.6808902621,
0.646168828,
-0.090256229,
0.6099336743,
-0.1881000847,
0.493318975,
-0.3146211803,
0.5562836528,
-0.4775397182,
0.1802049428,
-0.4917776883,
-0.9033327103,
-0.1958026588,
0.3365260959,
-0.459557265,
-0.3828726709,
1.245683074,
0.551230371,
-0.3532327712,
-0.3941819966,
0.0833035186,
0.0089697065,
0.2893945873,
0.7079944015,
0.651045382,
-0.6927143931,
0.9048506618,
-0.7089839578,
-0.0377241783,
0.0245164298,
-0.9820147157,
-0.8167127371,
-0.856547296,
-0.4717882872,
-0.486671567,
0.0912473798,
0.3600072265,
0.4059797227,
-0.4463286102,
-0.039502643,
-0.0938788801,
0.2610490024,
-0.0500581823,
-0.2802922726,
0.7939007878,
-0.224183023,
-0.5958723426,
0.1058302969,
0.1138100699,
-0.04774509,
0.1203630492,
-0.1243713349,
-0.6323075891,
-0.429697156,
0.4329214394,
0.2611365318,
-0.2364547253,
-0.3360559344,
-0.3107828796,
-0.2950840294,
0.3412836194,
0.7266389728,
-0.5489526391,
0.3719573021,
0.4817957282,
0.4591365457,
0.9378399253,
0.0883725584,
0.6143532395,
-1.0298830271,
0.0437422842,
-0.1857039779,
0.4217168689,
0.4660893679,
-0.4223773479,
0.8957965374,
0.3099347651,
-0.2506992519,
-0.5215293169,
0.1383363903,
-1.437466979,
0.1117098927,
1.0317802429,
-0.5655376315,
-0.1014712751,
-0.3766286671,
0.0525650904,
0.7828612924,
-0.4375291169,
0.4365645647,
0.7433046103,
-0.3219454587,
-0.3057160378,
-0.280809015,
0.3003838956,
0.1235780418,
-0.9503088593,
-0.1501765996,
0.36169824,
0.4143321514,
0.7861531377,
0.5978894234,
-0.1713772863,
0.0257234704,
0.4098521769,
-0.237358585,
-0.3235858679,
-0.2255851477,
0.0008737845,
0.2968166471,
0.1043783873,
-0.1633584499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10168v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10168v2 | Naamapadam: A Large-Scale Named Entity Annotated Data for Indic Languages | 2022-12-20T11:15:24 | 2023-05-28T06:26:45 | Arnav Mhaske, Harshit Kedia, Sumanth Doddapaneni, Mitesh M. Khapra, Pratyush Kumar, Rudra Murthy V, Anoop Kunchukuttan | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present, Naamapadam, the largest publicly available Named Entity
Recognition (NER) dataset for the 11 major Indian languages from two language
families. The dataset contains more than 400k sentences annotated with a total
of at least 100k entities from three standard entity categories (Person,
Location, and, Organization) for 9 out of the 11 languages. The training
dataset has been automatically created from the Samanantar parallel corpus by
projecting automatically tagged entities from an English sentence to the
corresponding Indian language translation. We also create manually annotated
testsets for 9 languages. We demonstrate the utility of the obtained dataset on
the Naamapadam-test dataset. We also release IndicNER, a multilingual IndicBERT
model fine-tuned on Naamapadam training set. IndicNER achieves an F1 score of
more than $80$ for $7$ out of $9$ test languages. The dataset and models are
available under open-source licences at
https://ai4bharat.iitm.ac.in/naamapadam. | [
-0.4864500165,
-0.2421081662,
-0.0489718206,
0.7233970165,
-0.1850957274,
0.2801774144,
-0.6507405639,
-0.7214232683,
0.3263210952,
0.5817922354,
0.1673637927,
-0.4082261622,
-0.7181254029,
0.6394374967,
-0.4880646467,
1.0953131914,
-0.2943344414,
0.0177677721,
0.0918688774,
-0.5955013633,
-0.5667366385,
-0.441062957,
-0.7472572327,
-0.0116737178,
0.1539033949,
0.5666092634,
0.29457739,
0.5558751225,
0.9024984241,
0.242181465,
0.1819751412,
0.3535192907,
-0.1501606405,
0.2047184557,
-0.0550253466,
-0.4925941527,
-0.4201155305,
-0.164511472,
0.8420328498,
0.5997188687,
-0.2909142673,
0.4027648568,
-0.1181726754,
0.3974564373,
-0.5317490101,
0.2679888606,
-0.3513928056,
-0.0792685077,
-0.5565680861,
-0.1567238122,
-0.5176231861,
-0.6928517222,
-0.1231977642,
-0.7467038035,
-0.1489400268,
0.1363497227,
0.873713553,
0.4407173693,
-0.3652123809,
-0.6309700608,
-0.7275126576,
0.8377407193,
-0.1480515599,
0.2847902179,
0.5089654326,
0.5850239396,
-0.1952817291,
-0.2656108439,
-0.6775380373,
-0.2227766812,
0.0339819677,
-0.1187310591,
-0.0711706504,
-0.0295779724,
0.2435591668,
0.62511307,
-0.6562113762,
0.1137627289,
-0.4154885411,
0.0992366001,
0.8055025339,
0.173533082,
0.6811939478,
-0.205141142,
-0.6864145994,
0.0281381831,
-0.6326581836,
-0.4058130682,
0.3855746388,
0.3611890078,
-0.2905922234,
0.4887238741,
-0.1654472947,
0.6862820983,
0.2292214036,
-0.6018540859,
0.5141357183,
-0.0789058656,
-0.1468586624,
0.5916032791,
0.6003389359,
0.1460117847,
0.6073602438,
-0.2710713446,
-0.2453640848,
0.20199579,
-0.1455844194,
-0.868191421,
-0.3156696856,
-0.089074932,
-0.2922686338,
0.053335458,
-0.1241975427,
-1.0512936115,
-0.6526781917,
-0.5654639006,
-0.0209781341,
-0.4892064035,
-0.6484431624,
0.0775123164,
0.1922918409,
0.6556866765,
0.3438141346,
-0.706908524,
0.5207703114,
0.5526913404,
0.8008800149,
-0.241454035,
-0.4067287147,
-0.3242711127,
0.2025930882,
-0.4724271894,
1.0580118895,
-1.0214573145,
-0.4519150853,
-0.1765291095,
-0.2455642968,
-0.1115322039,
-0.7515188456,
0.4625068009,
-0.3210515976,
-0.1744949669,
0.1467824429,
-0.6186388731,
-0.3565115929,
0.4696924984,
-0.7703132033,
1.0757675171,
-0.0812637657,
-0.7081136107,
0.5102091432,
-0.8347253799,
-0.4499797821,
0.4124743342,
-0.5133573413,
-0.1671146154,
0.0031087957,
0.2764911354,
0.3597421944,
-0.6033160686,
0.58699435,
0.0431134552,
-0.1516141891,
0.1709902734,
-0.2208017409,
0.6722157001,
0.1319282502,
-0.4023303092,
-0.330384165,
-1.3666348457,
-0.1219878942,
0.0011590432,
-0.5302920938,
-0.4600296617,
-0.5290874243,
0.3746201396,
0.2317296714,
0.1748627424,
-0.9244889617,
0.2703923583,
-0.1159141585,
0.2415299565,
0.5702214241,
0.2121614516,
0.4526066482,
0.1919420809,
0.8646978736,
0.1876001507,
0.0378570631,
-0.1355489194,
-0.5178799629,
-0.9132905602,
-0.4411267638,
0.5889127254,
0.482244581,
-0.513440609,
-0.1734706163,
-0.529753387,
-0.6193615794,
-0.758223474,
-0.0489065722,
0.5545193553,
0.3073411286,
0.4201059043,
-0.1361057311,
-0.8046495318,
-1.1587997675,
-0.1626988351,
0.0174746886,
0.4791625142,
-0.0865130872,
0.582876265,
-0.2535510957,
0.6791549325,
-0.246640265,
-0.430696398,
-0.1880010515,
0.2888132632,
-0.0516164713,
0.576815486,
0.3749519289,
-0.760684669,
-0.7330671549,
0.2727215886,
-0.5741581321,
0.0818224698,
-0.1930043101,
-0.0958577022,
0.4035504162,
0.5065864921,
-0.7636104226,
0.509981215,
0.5664353967,
0.167725563,
0.289231509,
-0.0684285685,
-0.0222747605,
-1.3488745689,
0.2034820169,
-0.1273964792,
-0.1028143466,
-0.3070092499,
0.0115520405,
0.0556252263,
-0.2192123234,
0.0412510335,
0.8987812996,
-0.9755299091,
0.0444959365,
-0.3238284588,
0.1982013136,
-0.4444149137,
0.2590713203,
0.0760689974,
0.9418097138,
0.6580078006,
-0.6529051065,
0.1081621274,
0.6462709904,
-0.3468274474,
1.0837525129,
-0.4862172902,
0.0478346199,
-0.3191715181,
0.2453493476,
-0.7198081613,
-0.4712816775,
0.324649781,
-0.5455412865,
0.539840281,
-0.1073793918,
-0.5902204514,
0.1904821694,
0.0534996837,
0.4733450413,
0.1681770533,
-0.9389388561,
0.7236667871,
0.8455272317,
-0.2567105293,
-0.6714663506,
-0.9633617997,
0.5468395352,
-0.4255334735,
0.0363161303,
-0.0554075427,
-0.001757695,
-0.111106135,
-0.130194664,
0.0815183371,
-0.2099104524,
-0.1333210915,
0.9292963743,
0.1110165566,
-0.1161454543,
0.5682076812,
-0.1158859134,
-0.6878646016,
-0.0671000034,
0.0860775039,
0.4326124787,
-0.1179951355,
0.0153521672,
-0.3348258436,
0.3725891709,
0.2041713297,
-0.7728579044,
0.58159554,
0.5140285492,
-0.7724683881,
-0.4492291808,
-0.5018365979,
0.4029888511,
-0.3223245144,
0.1303400546,
-0.4765871763,
-0.766195178,
0.2734724581,
-0.1867507845,
0.0389846079,
0.4008942246,
0.4373466671,
0.6658515334,
0.6718838811,
0.6070292592,
-0.4417682886,
0.039277669,
-0.0649054721,
0.7723963261,
-0.7343901396,
-0.4643997252,
-0.6648547053,
-0.3059331477,
-1.0711437464,
-0.4684913158,
-0.1645342559,
-0.18711932,
-0.1027292609,
0.4881933331,
-0.716540575,
0.5840198398,
0.2557907701,
-0.590909183,
0.4469074905,
-0.0064016674,
0.1291905344,
-0.0114625711,
-0.1092365384,
-0.8976762891,
1.1822481155,
0.0250600129,
0.7307347059,
0.2074223757,
0.8457402587,
-0.0769056454,
0.7353947759,
-0.3910933137,
0.6407166719,
0.2705092728,
-0.8738523722,
0.1175655127,
-0.2611804605,
-1.0748461485,
-0.1403389126,
0.0520932078,
-0.5286366343,
0.4869509637,
-0.1544189006,
-0.2750248015,
0.2556047738,
-0.636202991,
0.3148159981,
-0.1842371374,
0.2561338544,
0.0264632441,
-0.594019115,
0.410286665,
-0.0280154087,
-0.0936752707,
-0.33564955,
-0.3832965195,
0.7465633154,
-0.1653914452,
0.4478926957,
-0.1694036424,
0.2063958347,
0.223290965,
-0.0459087119,
0.1574486047,
0.3901288509,
-0.0095703611,
0.3075211644,
-0.475181371,
-0.4322196543,
-0.1854038984,
0.9787399173,
-0.6268690825,
0.0365272872,
-0.897987783,
-0.4346044362,
-0.1547082216,
0.2063576579,
0.095747754,
0.4921212196,
-0.0684897006,
0.1576723754,
0.6196406484,
-0.3344605267,
0.5649604201,
0.5423207879,
-0.4364349246,
-0.5753252506,
1.2276620865,
0.2730754316,
-0.1915942878,
0.4922728539,
-0.555121243,
-0.0159146506,
-0.6494127512,
-0.4952375889,
0.3218624592,
-0.6087948084,
-0.5676420331,
-0.9641031623,
-0.1971536577,
0.0586711466,
0.0519343764,
-0.3817909062,
-0.4817162156,
-0.0217457805,
-0.5284225345,
0.6889814734,
0.8857699037,
-0.0260909237,
0.1026307121,
-0.3025479317,
0.1563972235,
0.0423334166,
0.5081887841,
-0.0753307492,
-0.1840592623,
-0.0638353303,
-0.3323403895,
0.021473214,
-0.5918158293,
0.3615599573,
0.46196872,
0.3664254248,
0.458896488,
-0.1757870317,
0.8595610857,
-0.4604700208,
0.4365798533,
-0.0827020258,
-0.6854373217,
0.4516034126,
-0.0294360854,
0.1027156711,
0.9770257473,
0.6354146004,
-0.5482654572,
-0.1484497339,
-0.4232137203,
-0.736330688,
0.2740725279,
0.1020838395,
0.0249174312,
-0.4379867613,
0.4486674368,
0.4402910769,
0.2184934169,
-0.3773593605,
-0.3552086055,
0.2981341779,
-0.3977062106,
-0.2321130335,
-0.0181541014,
0.373249203,
-0.0576089062,
0.728480041,
0.0123990877,
0.2812028825,
0.2544149756,
-0.4969245791,
0.1049121991,
0.1797730327,
0.5123361945,
0.5816532969,
0.0728553087,
0.1079015508,
0.0219473373,
-0.8738224506,
0.2191620022,
0.4491190612,
-0.1574264914,
0.3752949834,
0.0643428862,
0.7466248274,
0.2911173999,
-0.9757314324,
0.2248943895,
-0.2891898751,
0.1778311729,
-0.818944037,
-0.1091706902,
0.1554910988,
-0.0131537393,
0.2272456139,
0.000616335,
0.2735037506,
-0.0792127103,
-0.106356293,
0.0319332853,
-0.2822745442,
-0.3322396874,
0.5867960453,
0.0259715244,
-0.192375645,
0.8113164902,
-0.4487589598,
-0.263443172,
0.5556951761,
0.4034775496,
0.6310595274,
-0.6786728501,
0.3057469726,
0.8479542732,
0.5308346748,
-0.1079361215,
0.4768024385,
0.0650218651,
-0.2956396341,
-0.1809564978,
-0.866943419,
-0.5445904732,
0.0412764363,
-0.7151793242,
0.2649848461,
-0.6536926627,
0.0097400025,
0.1486920565,
0.2028937489,
-0.8322353363,
0.2679784596,
0.1590247005,
0.8998504281,
-0.5919612646,
0.6373226047,
1.0430393219,
-0.8139610291,
-0.8918421268,
-0.2546216249,
-0.2270142287,
-0.6905935407,
0.6803803444,
0.5415938497,
0.1495157629,
0.0007879476,
-0.400270462,
-1.193316102,
1.0331023932,
0.4470632672,
-0.5593252778,
0.2874456942,
0.4124368429,
0.6080827713,
-0.6697790623,
0.2357725948,
0.6232334375,
0.5948938727,
-0.5539746284,
-0.8264142275,
-0.0482864827,
-0.7118082643,
0.1706665754,
0.8530188799,
-0.7440233231,
0.8036666512,
-0.1057009548,
-0.4651910365,
0.1245592609,
0.6201391816,
0.3147279918,
0.1007947624,
0.2062842995,
0.8714255691,
1.0151267052,
0.0524474978,
1.0913485289,
-0.4724327624,
0.1056572199,
1.6061828136,
-0.4100247622,
0.9886119366,
0.4526656568,
0.02758177,
0.5228828788,
0.4971385598,
0.0096935118,
0.0813896284,
0.4071297944,
-0.2288673818,
0.0140682068,
-0.5142818689,
-0.5481574535,
0.7906674147,
0.3686547279,
-0.2534245849,
-0.2597536743,
0.2607502341,
0.3844740391,
0.1085920259,
-0.2712977827,
0.491833657,
0.1359432191,
-0.4930069149,
0.3360509872,
0.0025719758,
0.4586562216,
-0.2115792483,
-0.3003725708,
-0.4305900633,
0.2378336936,
-0.249681294,
-0.4275639653,
0.04443096,
0.3338799477,
0.067152828,
0.0989276245,
0.7719795704,
-0.5630071759,
-0.5970447063,
0.1987095177,
0.1907919794,
0.4632682204,
-0.0277216192,
-0.2139565647,
-0.0343095697,
-0.5622150898,
-0.0791351274,
0.303390801,
0.4266161621,
-0.2885626853,
0.6934499145,
0.2258090228,
0.0449292883,
0.4487167299,
-0.155737713,
0.548825562,
-0.6252049208,
-0.4668585956,
-0.3890378475,
0.2379680723,
-0.3270650208,
-0.9788862467,
1.0523010492,
0.8859792948,
1.0794247389,
0.0579388849,
0.7380514145,
0.0986024514,
0.6635212898,
0.018599242,
0.6915103793,
-0.2033727765,
-0.3389326632,
0.0308711994,
-1.0229301453,
-0.5164822936,
0.5816495419,
-0.3214075863,
0.0025282011,
0.5459338427,
0.6575039029,
0.0208536088,
0.2960786521,
0.019367598,
0.1977774948,
0.0456901602,
0.6481406689,
0.7872108817,
-0.512362659,
0.3964175284,
-0.1691571027,
-0.0145351328,
-0.2361684293,
-0.5979481936,
-0.892000258,
-0.6198118329,
-0.4644596875,
0.103335768,
0.0270774122,
1.1485902071,
0.5231357217,
-0.9833577871,
-0.1659413874,
-0.1419790685,
-0.2519765198,
0.1014670506,
-0.1632233411,
0.3415546417,
-0.1927461177,
-0.7520462275,
0.2182373405,
0.678414762,
-0.2737691402,
-0.3239893019,
-0.1842689663,
-0.4479250312,
0.0029119612,
0.3656225204,
0.4342214465,
-0.412247777,
0.1040189639,
-0.3173388243,
-0.2413167655,
0.3022841215,
0.6323121786,
-0.5331426859,
0.5429861546,
0.0514327958,
1.0624154806,
0.1440733969,
-0.2410252392,
0.1001608223,
-0.3604590297,
0.1777680665,
0.2121769786,
0.2240357846,
0.8374213576,
-0.2713704109,
0.8241068721,
-0.2459176183,
-0.5830508471,
-1.041246295,
-0.0867552534,
-0.9790574908,
0.4781836569,
1.0141080618,
-0.1769075543,
-0.3048397005,
-0.2521736324,
-0.2247332335,
0.2739269435,
-0.5407542586,
0.5519086123,
0.548511982,
0.0697028711,
-0.1313648075,
-0.8203961253,
0.3584166467,
0.1901657283,
-1.244093895,
-0.2605070472,
0.3019629717,
0.2320497483,
0.3823880255,
0.5608778,
-0.2741622627,
0.332657665,
0.1233445778,
0.5937913656,
0.0845544413,
-0.5683720112,
-0.5823469758,
0.2206766754,
0.1961091757,
-0.45236817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10154v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10154v2 | Human-Guided Fair Classification for Natural Language Processing | 2022-12-20T10:46:40 | 2023-03-16T08:57:14 | Florian E. Dorner, Momchil Peychev, Nikola Konstantinov, Naman Goel, Elliott Ash, Martin Vechev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Text classifiers have promising applications in high-stake tasks such as
resume screening and content moderation. These classifiers must be fair and
avoid discriminatory decisions by being invariant to perturbations of sensitive
attributes such as gender or ethnicity. However, there is a gap between human
intuition about these perturbations and the formal similarity specifications
capturing them. While existing research has started to address this gap,
current methods are based on hardcoded word replacements, resulting in
specifications with limited expressivity or ones that fail to fully align with
human intuition (e.g., in cases of asymmetric counterfactuals). This work
proposes novel methods for bridging this gap by discovering expressive and
intuitive individual fairness specifications. We show how to leverage
unsupervised style transfer and GPT-3's zero-shot capabilities to automatically
generate expressive candidate pairs of semantically similar sentences that
differ along sensitive attributes. We then validate the generated pairs via an
extensive crowdsourcing study, which confirms that a lot of these pairs align
with human intuition about fairness in the context of toxicity classification.
Finally, we show how limited amounts of human feedback can be leveraged to
learn a similarity specification that can be used to train downstream
fairness-aware models. | [
-0.1460203677,
-0.4082040787,
0.655647397,
0.1336355209,
0.1767782271,
0.0142817795,
-0.2645970285,
-0.4877533317,
-0.4559211731,
0.4471901953,
-0.3839659691,
-0.5272538066,
-0.5275090337,
0.2162725031,
-0.2782271802,
1.1640884876,
-0.0686113313,
-0.069704257,
-0.0275690593,
-0.3212281466,
-0.3841562569,
-0.4602098465,
-0.394911468,
-0.4177097082,
0.5200199485,
0.5507974029,
0.6248460412,
0.7025559545,
0.2311724871,
0.3259748816,
-0.0306990035,
-0.3099703789,
-0.1705524921,
0.0556989647,
-0.5445949435,
-0.5756186247,
-0.2862832844,
0.6365602612,
0.2108741701,
0.7687125206,
-0.2647120953,
0.3300587237,
0.4052544832,
0.6986609101,
-0.7968931198,
0.1259475201,
-0.7553258538,
0.3449881375,
-0.451660037,
-0.144268766,
-0.3812486529,
-0.4078706503,
0.0856645927,
-0.6556769609,
0.6417031288,
-0.0166593213,
0.80647856,
0.2204120755,
-0.4924668968,
-0.1228563711,
-0.3094601333,
0.8914528489,
-0.5338805914,
0.2056391388,
0.4416582584,
0.5984228253,
-0.1212832332,
-0.5458552837,
-0.8251628876,
0.1667171121,
-0.22001037,
0.0019399048,
-0.0122617781,
0.3033130467,
0.3302743137,
0.3017559648,
-0.6415604949,
0.2397534996,
-0.176412642,
-0.5993434787,
0.5741148591,
-0.0160148293,
0.1810877323,
-0.3597316444,
-0.2140462846,
-0.0669525638,
-0.3259000778,
0.2256183773,
0.6633040309,
0.315833807,
-0.0253531188,
0.3764635623,
-0.5848240852,
0.6098296046,
-0.0367651209,
0.134944886,
0.4435507953,
-0.0573307872,
-0.1772101074,
0.1390980333,
0.8710847497,
0.544005096,
0.3319042623,
-0.2455475926,
-0.2377559394,
0.4292973578,
0.0776525885,
-0.7778581381,
-0.0898299143,
-0.1406532079,
-0.6669763327,
-0.5186161995,
0.1711631268,
-0.9143667221,
-0.5969606638,
-0.3940226436,
0.4094499052,
0.0570303947,
-0.0485797003,
0.3910660744,
-0.1588553339,
0.2634451687,
0.3024099767,
-0.902395606,
0.3754635155,
0.7482940555,
0.6843274832,
0.0196346678,
-0.0910170674,
-0.7405236363,
0.1234558299,
0.0811754316,
0.6469098926,
-0.5806218386,
0.0902827978,
-0.2185971737,
-0.1212514043,
0.2555828691,
-0.3666054904,
1.0051612854,
-0.2189188898,
0.7689814568,
-0.3431695998,
-0.3167482018,
-0.3607522547,
0.19217439,
-0.4455780387,
0.6320617199,
0.2511024177,
-0.96560359,
0.6050787568,
-0.8625323772,
-0.4321417809,
0.0728630945,
-0.3823429346,
-0.3484728336,
-0.0017461122,
0.0439283513,
0.498395443,
-0.295964092,
0.2501232326,
-0.3804252446,
-0.477702409,
0.1474107057,
-0.5457741618,
0.8561753631,
0.4681346714,
-0.5798918605,
0.2119842917,
-0.5864498615,
-0.0347919911,
-0.1502236277,
-0.2070695907,
-0.2233781368,
-0.1141333058,
0.1715958863,
0.4366060197,
-0.0523775294,
-0.6552365422,
-0.2066098303,
-0.3757261634,
0.400262922,
1.092348218,
-0.3875983655,
0.6884019375,
-0.4809789062,
0.2314173728,
-0.1286863387,
0.2156599313,
0.2500062883,
-0.6029898524,
-0.5247232318,
-0.253888756,
0.3586227596,
0.6400091648,
-0.5058594942,
0.5719856024,
-0.1252954155,
-0.2084606439,
-0.8441838026,
0.1652704179,
0.3761412203,
0.8166856766,
0.2945801914,
-0.4137999117,
-0.3938986361,
-0.8876501322,
-0.6787680984,
-0.1011639461,
-0.374512881,
0.3214998245,
0.1120480672,
-0.1294555962,
1.0907306671,
-0.4693167508,
-0.5513000488,
0.1010384932,
0.4106079638,
0.176024884,
0.3223568499,
0.598212719,
-0.8520906568,
-0.4751760364,
0.0388893932,
-0.63171345,
-0.6093697548,
0.1121535897,
-0.1558606625,
0.235284552,
0.4779818952,
-0.1777529269,
0.5286083817,
0.2765554488,
-0.7214835882,
0.223235026,
0.0285673812,
0.3724394143,
-0.5435938239,
0.1177200377,
0.1530221254,
-0.4847605824,
-0.4452679157,
-0.0210371092,
-0.1908405572,
0.1379612982,
-0.4103305936,
0.8302657008,
-0.1277703345,
0.0549296774,
-0.2426027656,
0.021027118,
-0.0037385563,
0.554477632,
-0.2233059406,
0.3535819054,
0.4483019412,
-0.4475799501,
0.1725952327,
0.0148301776,
-0.0681362003,
0.9663008451,
-0.2869153917,
0.2488194406,
-0.3752621412,
0.3557459414,
-0.5862900615,
-0.18103984,
0.4404253066,
-0.5892530084,
-0.0940234885,
-0.3065392077,
-0.4625613093,
-0.2039439678,
-0.5621566176,
0.5679379106,
0.6147217155,
-0.43645522,
0.6102916598,
0.2918169498,
-0.1837670058,
-0.5399639606,
-0.7768612504,
-0.0856354609,
-0.3849419057,
-0.3973053396,
0.3845281303,
-0.0408077464,
-0.2814870775,
-0.0463718958,
0.0087502366,
-0.1445339471,
0.4015929997,
0.4684256911,
0.1161513254,
0.2299305946,
0.0561843887,
0.0908753872,
-0.0982642546,
-0.0737469792,
-0.119573079,
0.2328629494,
-0.3799071014,
-0.2374345213,
-0.6805972457,
0.2644370496,
0.1816817671,
-0.0863293037,
0.2500213385,
0.886928916,
-0.4348412156,
-0.0012128815,
-0.7114182115,
-0.0852572471,
-0.5084524751,
0.0214063134,
-0.2030408382,
-1.0763475895,
0.5996055007,
0.3599879146,
0.0286136884,
0.4984768629,
0.3148218989,
0.0312971212,
1.1227962971,
0.6652918458,
-0.0117607974,
0.3636649549,
0.2671605349,
-0.017876083,
-0.3953592479,
-0.1786480397,
-0.7843404412,
-0.5865281224,
-0.7930790186,
-0.2843432724,
0.0066468394,
0.0319699384,
-0.5863251686,
0.0009855855,
-0.6660047174,
0.7393109798,
0.5990946293,
0.0481605493,
0.3947312534,
-0.0537751876,
-0.0977710783,
-0.1740406007,
-0.2278704494,
-0.6472755671,
0.9243729711,
0.3675033748,
0.4726263881,
0.197209537,
0.7372083664,
0.5157475471,
0.7308213115,
-0.6702096462,
0.5316735506,
-0.4897886813,
-0.5276968479,
-0.211477533,
-0.8175538182,
-0.7621895075,
0.0657636747,
-0.3510831594,
-0.7350077629,
0.0706630647,
0.158055827,
-0.2440581024,
0.2334656566,
-0.8284803629,
0.8878462315,
-0.0513481796,
-0.3196015656,
-0.1889700741,
-0.6622083187,
0.2219151556,
0.0140311494,
0.408590138,
-0.4141601622,
0.0176857095,
0.6369511485,
-0.2292163819,
0.6630772948,
-0.4940259457,
0.0020548271,
0.1233749986,
0.2651378512,
-0.0009903463,
0.0003720858,
-0.3534442782,
0.2330409735,
-0.2588224113,
-0.4887368381,
-0.6542944312,
0.6004966497,
-0.4018007517,
-0.4044487178,
-0.4194049239,
-0.3049679101,
-0.2209371626,
0.3449499309,
0.1462871283,
-0.1591452956,
-0.0373993218,
-0.1589857489,
0.3818439543,
-0.2773609161,
0.3347392976,
0.5423669219,
-0.0692179352,
-0.0729546025,
0.8556030989,
-0.3016269207,
-0.0580199547,
0.279687345,
0.3173269928,
-0.3315452039,
-0.3420906067,
-0.2642828524,
-0.1519478559,
-0.5834162831,
-0.5342157483,
-0.4959861338,
-0.0124327848,
-0.3695937693,
-0.2401474118,
0.0895473436,
-0.4372348487,
-0.3545020521,
-0.0886003599,
0.3615652919,
0.6484231353,
-0.2202984989,
0.1323822439,
-0.5251707435,
0.4234473407,
0.6709718704,
0.9291364551,
-0.0630220547,
-0.4855470359,
0.3735690415,
0.0826482624,
-0.5135965943,
-0.7591560483,
0.2301252037,
0.1713101715,
0.580021143,
0.2852090895,
0.1347679943,
0.230938673,
-0.4362776875,
0.4391011596,
0.286627084,
-1.2204016447,
0.4717274606,
-0.2848084569,
-0.1383026987,
0.8454478979,
0.2284276634,
-0.7419999242,
-0.3340859711,
-0.4432613552,
-0.6151362658,
0.7411273718,
0.2149905562,
-0.0073668254,
0.0280050691,
0.4455825686,
0.3941164613,
0.0550739765,
-0.8343054056,
0.062024571,
-0.4684877098,
-0.6576639414,
0.1695779264,
0.2178305984,
-0.0008334509,
-0.1688586771,
0.3261413872,
-0.3368170559,
-0.0589061417,
0.1388494223,
-0.2041978836,
-0.0542170145,
0.7721517086,
0.2076426446,
0.209511131,
-0.3407848477,
0.3690850437,
0.0792801008,
-0.2725098431,
0.2801665664,
0.285207212,
-0.1248958632,
-0.2369351238,
-0.0758935213,
0.3892385364,
-0.1459108889,
-0.6728371978,
0.9549000263,
-0.4617187679,
-0.2569982708,
0.2439921051,
0.1511866152,
-0.3621170819,
0.1921760738,
0.2421394438,
0.2755240798,
0.7349674702,
-0.7041867375,
0.2204616666,
0.3694707155,
-0.7409032583,
-0.278819412,
0.6488093138,
0.4780877531,
-0.2340295613,
0.5983746648,
-0.8108131289,
-0.6656351686,
0.1751460135,
0.0232266486,
0.9998114109,
-0.042773325,
0.3300485611,
0.0921508595,
-0.124779135,
-0.259853363,
0.1718732864,
-0.1960582882,
-0.7273781896,
-0.4352803528,
-0.6769549847,
-0.0857446268,
-0.1782493293,
-0.6437091231,
0.43079108,
-0.5532278419,
-0.0838572979,
0.0677917078,
-0.0597643144,
-0.9408854246,
0.0526682213,
0.2821246088,
0.6770647168,
-1.0253388882,
0.4168803096,
0.4975063801,
-0.3333537579,
-0.7082979679,
0.1031701118,
0.1950742602,
-0.4281800389,
0.5607884526,
0.4795986712,
-0.0391539894,
-0.246904999,
-0.5852153897,
0.0808827057,
0.934990406,
0.6031793952,
-0.3806056678,
-0.1125652269,
0.0953506529,
0.5888298154,
0.0033341525,
0.3965142667,
0.5534594059,
0.4495376348,
-0.0785998031,
-1.250685811,
0.322126925,
-0.1535189897,
-0.0607272387,
-0.0140586933,
-0.3229186535,
0.6904422641,
-0.3582405448,
-0.458475709,
-0.0999789387,
0.4240380526,
0.1151440889,
0.486980617,
0.8114640117,
0.6625657678,
0.8623880744,
-0.1294334233,
0.821459949,
0.3192087412,
0.2745529413,
1.0021400452,
-0.4488707483,
0.5562123656,
0.1192156225,
-0.1406289041,
0.6912508607,
0.3857302368,
0.1335072815,
0.3323280811,
0.3963863552,
-0.339299798,
-0.177821517,
-0.3761599958,
-0.1001190245,
0.5781901479,
0.1371678114,
-0.2170190066,
-0.2799193561,
-0.0386581048,
0.0028509924,
0.6394828558,
-0.4910921752,
0.7962446213,
-0.0638507158,
-0.5121098757,
0.0963966772,
0.2822857201,
1.3549931049,
-0.0493555889,
-0.2206874937,
-0.1439849734,
0.0648081079,
-0.44534266,
-1.2222608328,
0.1690631807,
0.1558407098,
-0.3616958857,
-0.4661065936,
0.6207222342,
-0.1687879115,
-0.1198082715,
0.1616133451,
0.2228734344,
-0.0138089359,
-0.3062909245,
-0.6718069911,
-0.36281991,
0.0710745975,
0.1374358237,
0.3343790174,
0.6501795053,
-0.2637974322,
0.552254796,
0.4813017845,
0.0833432227,
-0.140005365,
0.3973899484,
0.481000185,
-0.8442024589,
-0.6455541849,
-0.7796494365,
0.2711499333,
-0.0851101056,
0.0068644597,
0.3336169124,
0.4730119407,
0.9276221991,
0.1915219128,
0.7678130269,
0.0233614519,
0.7177975774,
-0.4539834261,
0.8397735953,
-0.2840961516,
0.2396832705,
-0.4071021676,
-0.7874249816,
-0.4972708523,
0.6801227927,
-0.1250601113,
0.2663612068,
0.2790447176,
0.6982557178,
0.0058629122,
-0.007594429,
-0.0361822471,
-0.0016688998,
0.560621202,
0.6960303783,
0.6764725447,
-0.2216528207,
0.6750786901,
0.0268792175,
-0.428135246,
-0.0498628616,
-1.0907224417,
-0.6375244856,
-0.5585995913,
-0.2571546435,
-0.4204129875,
0.0111539355,
0.9644160271,
0.6199448109,
-0.6117975712,
0.052850727,
-0.2014503032,
0.3865689337,
0.0974960178,
-0.3650678992,
0.1171079427,
-0.05455314,
-0.4287169576,
-0.2491987944,
0.2085038722,
0.2397950292,
-0.0022549327,
-0.1972080618,
0.1529036164,
-0.1560708731,
0.4336103797,
0.357396692,
-0.5743100047,
-0.4263733923,
-0.3582443595,
-0.2163728476,
-0.0435752906,
0.8615780473,
-1.1178488731,
0.3058120012,
0.6466616988,
0.4479798973,
0.0098699005,
0.000486712,
0.4617052376,
-1.0576540232,
0.1354481727,
0.5307160616,
0.1881840527,
0.6404245496,
-0.3279072344,
0.4371352792,
0.2100534737,
-0.4428189993,
-0.8387876749,
0.2485074848,
-1.0186567307,
-0.1972497702,
0.995916903,
0.0658286214,
0.0490246043,
-0.287504524,
-0.3227737546,
0.2645031512,
-0.5565617085,
0.9713314772,
0.4140762687,
-0.1172612086,
0.0728681087,
-0.391099453,
0.7298215032,
0.1806575507,
-0.9478593469,
0.1795840859,
0.3974115849,
0.3908579946,
0.0650035441,
0.7200413346,
-0.4035876393,
0.3604491055,
-0.6075154543,
0.1781583577,
0.2002441734,
0.1143290401,
-0.339959681,
0.0433397926,
0.1160013229,
0.0514735281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10152v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10152v1 | Quirk or Palmer: A Comparative Study of Modal Verb Frameworks with Annotated Datasets | 2022-12-20T10:44:18 | 2022-12-20T10:44:18 | Risako Owan, Maria Gini, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Modal verbs, such as "can", "may", and "must", are commonly used in daily
communication to convey the speaker's perspective related to the likelihood
and/or mode of the proposition. They can differ greatly in meaning depending on
how they're used and the context of a sentence (e.g. "They 'must' help each
other out." vs. "They 'must' have helped each other out.") Despite their
practical importance in natural language understanding, linguists have yet to
agree on a single, prominent framework for the categorization of modal verb
senses. This lack of agreement stems from high degrees of flexibility and
polysemy from the modal verbs, making it more difficult for researchers to
incorporate insights from this family of words into their work. This work
presents Moverb dataset, which consists of 27,240 annotations of modal verb
senses over 4,540 utterances containing one or more sentences from social
conversations. Each utterance is annotated by three annotators using two
different theoretical frameworks (i.e., Quirk and Palmer) of modal verb senses.
We observe that both frameworks have similar inter-annotator agreements,
despite having different numbers of sense types (8 for Quirk and 3 for Palmer).
With the RoBERTa-based classifiers fine-tuned on \dataset, we achieve F1 scores
of 82.2 and 78.3 on Quirk and Palmer, respectively, showing that modal verb
sense disambiguation is not a trivial task. Our dataset will be publicly
available with our final version. | [
-0.3405982554,
-0.5351343155,
0.4897649884,
0.2873668969,
-0.3059476614,
-0.0946872383,
-0.1063667014,
-0.3771075904,
0.3685926199,
-0.139613688,
-0.4524735212,
-0.3332591355,
-0.6600265503,
0.1833119094,
-0.307499826,
0.6024725437,
0.4383591115,
0.5434615016,
0.0380351879,
-0.2845506966,
-0.3347991705,
-0.3573040664,
-0.1712947786,
-0.0161179062,
0.5728932619,
0.2558704913,
1.2593590021,
0.0716492012,
0.6291773319,
0.1913546622,
-0.4093046188,
-0.0453622416,
-0.3493711352,
0.0934288204,
-0.4212295115,
-0.5792521238,
-0.428873986,
-0.1378016621,
0.1619964391,
0.9278829694,
0.2180397213,
-0.1337392926,
-0.3395758867,
0.668889761,
-0.5586551428,
0.3268907368,
-0.3794665039,
-0.0180331096,
-0.2875197828,
0.1351234168,
-0.0053314767,
-0.175511986,
0.0823656619,
-0.5581948757,
0.4862452149,
0.4191314876,
0.8651684523,
0.1488087326,
-0.6453820467,
-0.1761303842,
-0.282289952,
0.3423336744,
-0.7344124317,
0.5605294108,
0.6131303906,
0.531956017,
-0.3462470472,
-0.3753638268,
-1.0032659769,
-0.3047637939,
-0.1752572358,
-0.1933860183,
-0.0704953596,
0.1995982528,
0.1000999436,
0.7067776918,
-0.6635298133,
-0.0915862769,
-0.3210597038,
-0.0856630951,
0.7036309838,
0.2013090402,
0.0264918376,
-0.6605322361,
-0.3718190789,
-0.3246242106,
-0.5223773122,
0.1333065778,
0.0968455151,
0.489924401,
-0.1125224009,
0.6356538534,
-0.373547852,
0.4907710254,
0.1715390682,
-0.0991766825,
0.4264190495,
-0.2862296402,
-0.4008419812,
-0.3133497834,
0.7905704379,
0.4860522151,
0.0268701483,
-0.244336918,
-0.3937232494,
0.0202435572,
0.0035995808,
-0.3130886853,
-0.4250781536,
-0.0054861181,
-0.4040062726,
-0.1532922536,
0.3144688606,
-0.9035680294,
-0.7448844314,
-0.3113263249,
0.4930731058,
-0.5245971084,
-0.5447205901,
0.4129959643,
-0.1965451241,
0.4674706459,
0.4681068957,
-0.7148287296,
0.0384044014,
0.8038530946,
0.7348104715,
-0.2312145531,
-0.217853114,
-0.1532686949,
-0.0435260013,
-0.346727252,
0.8746676445,
-0.7826197743,
-0.5998969078,
0.2138180584,
0.113353081,
-0.0982545912,
-0.4447890818,
0.4126810133,
-0.5688889623,
0.4154365659,
-0.9059318304,
-0.4604656398,
-0.664739728,
0.2324331552,
-0.7374979854,
0.6587563157,
0.1689503044,
-0.506737113,
0.9043421745,
-0.426306814,
-0.7871878743,
0.1356919557,
-0.6137737632,
0.0023013551,
0.6317102909,
0.0690832734,
0.705047071,
-0.699470222,
0.4206055403,
-0.3749497235,
0.0785623044,
0.5670180917,
-0.2334526777,
0.8653587699,
0.0108336639,
-0.4855531454,
0.2344054729,
-0.9664806128,
-0.1774843931,
0.0964077935,
-0.2215171903,
-0.3032058775,
-0.0824909136,
0.3725087643,
0.232060194,
-0.1099490523,
-0.2933684587,
0.2392022908,
-0.0249211155,
0.4117600024,
0.6103963256,
-0.1489352733,
0.2587885261,
-0.8395135999,
0.617228508,
-0.0128384335,
0.0661884844,
0.0498054624,
-0.5515527129,
-1.043808341,
-0.4733961523,
-0.0508957431,
0.0701858699,
-0.5325408578,
0.2790006101,
-0.5161581635,
-0.3553447127,
-0.3206357658,
-0.1514369249,
0.2322481722,
0.2076365799,
0.4278493524,
-0.1144714579,
0.0009226578,
-0.8756604195,
-0.2353159189,
-0.5135567188,
0.1535586417,
0.2691888809,
0.268039763,
0.1089073345,
0.9985125661,
-0.1150901616,
-0.4241470098,
-0.1666803807,
-0.0984809175,
-0.0603595823,
0.1976006329,
0.8990779519,
-1.057049036,
-0.035308335,
-0.1602533162,
-0.2871121168,
0.0451125018,
-0.2215220928,
0.013848464,
0.0254798476,
0.3650995791,
-0.5099713802,
0.4305592477,
0.2386990935,
-0.7537481785,
0.3054139018,
0.3658660054,
0.4320098758,
-0.8734787107,
0.0042828731,
-0.3398832977,
-0.2589742541,
-0.4146519005,
0.035972137,
-0.0159432832,
0.1639505774,
-0.3740819991,
0.4173852503,
-0.4168127477,
0.0228965338,
0.0925563201,
0.146401599,
0.0352691412,
0.470789969,
-0.1690995097,
0.8954684734,
0.463863939,
-0.5615664124,
0.5282164812,
0.2378917485,
-0.5475825667,
0.6086606979,
-0.5345089436,
0.1495241076,
-0.3062208891,
-0.377396822,
-1.6139084101,
-0.5051509142,
0.3328663707,
-0.2955458462,
0.2971669734,
0.1704482138,
-0.561219275,
0.2027649432,
-0.2056644559,
0.2150868028,
0.186925143,
-0.3904455602,
0.6218413711,
0.2505171895,
0.0858436152,
-0.0942537934,
-0.7284732461,
-0.1065841839,
-0.277713269,
-0.7281407714,
0.1445950717,
0.1754231155,
-0.5636909008,
0.0618370324,
-0.3953547478,
0.0117570702,
0.0165596027,
0.5602068901,
-0.0113779753,
-0.3077157438,
0.5366610289,
0.0181093272,
-0.1087933779,
0.065834634,
0.2132458538,
0.5050520897,
-0.3915676177,
-0.6667624116,
-0.0978729203,
0.2564471364,
0.9038068652,
-0.0143088521,
0.7169182301,
0.1869300753,
-0.1223025173,
0.0827539712,
-0.8104045391,
-0.0287940037,
-0.3719561994,
0.1176374182,
-0.515303731,
-0.8506731391,
0.3993236125,
0.1249550581,
0.0479413718,
0.3474972248,
0.3247707784,
0.1350024641,
0.4222368896,
0.5522378683,
-0.1602425277,
0.5311030746,
-0.0183743648,
0.2933231592,
-0.2779633403,
-0.4166012406,
-0.510961473,
-0.5683612823,
-0.2209174782,
-0.4891576171,
0.1445004493,
0.1512541324,
-0.0593696609,
0.286034584,
-0.017097896,
0.1973775625,
0.4088352025,
-0.1639918536,
0.3407455683,
-0.0359814949,
-0.1547017246,
0.0066778478,
-0.7452514172,
-0.4535731375,
0.8397514224,
-0.1328924149,
0.4247338176,
0.8709132075,
0.2586264908,
0.2700455487,
0.0378079712,
-1.0503438711,
0.9648981094,
0.1961103976,
-0.6873562932,
0.0114767812,
0.0752244964,
-0.873462677,
0.5138861537,
-0.3716476858,
-0.527952075,
0.6685615182,
0.0207530167,
-0.2773156464,
-0.0456923097,
-0.6890662313,
0.8117372394,
-0.1895484328,
-0.3031641543,
-0.2760116756,
-0.7595914006,
0.0740616024,
0.1319773942,
0.2254337519,
-0.5693270564,
-0.1364175975,
0.4038201272,
-0.5127705932,
0.8255857825,
0.0560156293,
0.1457586884,
0.0461464822,
0.4271653891,
0.1579995453,
0.0548448861,
-0.2127046287,
0.1143480316,
0.3770891428,
-0.2868992984,
-0.6353445053,
0.3619525731,
-0.512578845,
-0.7976879478,
-0.6972459555,
-0.3334091902,
-0.3301892579,
0.1679609716,
0.2082577646,
0.3391768038,
-0.1592008322,
0.2567236722,
0.1275265366,
0.3074814081,
0.4992502332,
0.6295914054,
-0.5148261786,
-0.264392525,
0.527747333,
0.0044361823,
0.3055102229,
0.4488889575,
0.2266362309,
-0.2503394186,
-0.3962140381,
0.1136339456,
0.4459173381,
-0.8069735169,
-0.2775515914,
-0.2127447873,
0.3004943728,
-0.6089405417,
-0.2612175345,
-0.0257435627,
-0.6486591101,
-0.2648862004,
-0.1572357416,
0.745334506,
0.6612517834,
-0.0757370591,
0.2528249621,
-0.4801888764,
0.2331659645,
0.3144469559,
0.1127167419,
-0.1824576557,
-0.3838824034,
0.3856032789,
-0.1616430879,
0.1335384846,
-1.2540696859,
0.1912008375,
0.3669131398,
0.4361976683,
0.7921577692,
0.2556625605,
0.8660880923,
-0.0250587147,
0.9883613586,
0.1798661202,
-0.9377279878,
0.4127725065,
-0.3443793654,
-0.0578553863,
0.8684032559,
0.5032706857,
-0.6889230609,
0.0345730633,
-0.5938770175,
-0.8735255599,
0.473561734,
-0.0201775655,
0.028982766,
-0.3649146259,
0.276994884,
0.313315928,
0.6694444418,
-0.4579004347,
-0.2137763202,
-0.2018600553,
-0.2336504161,
-0.1633425355,
-0.380738914,
-0.1811785847,
-0.007102048,
0.5145352483,
0.0392140262,
0.121887818,
0.1684390754,
-0.3236757815,
0.0723662525,
0.363976568,
0.5702584982,
0.8651595116,
0.1321146488,
0.4238820672,
-0.2020771503,
-0.6619624496,
0.1308699101,
-0.1284535974,
-0.0628000796,
0.1280332655,
0.4484758675,
0.6666038036,
0.2272365838,
-0.7945828438,
0.8155196905,
0.1057391539,
0.0269498043,
-0.2378067672,
0.1761269569,
-0.1879335344,
0.5470939875,
0.1642467231,
0.0857770815,
0.1552375853,
-0.3813562095,
-0.2279212177,
0.4452728331,
-0.2028890252,
-0.6179715395,
0.4224826097,
0.1048737839,
-0.6057257056,
0.2575682402,
-0.6108059287,
-0.3027358353,
0.1349039972,
0.1201223806,
0.9609922171,
0.0906764045,
-0.0394235551,
-0.0474203527,
0.1483813226,
-0.1414101273,
0.5667197108,
-0.2141664028,
-0.8316069245,
0.0828439966,
-0.3438627422,
-0.1277081966,
0.3550024927,
-0.7102089524,
0.330134064,
-0.8094129562,
-0.3776168525,
-0.0258134604,
-0.3520662189,
-0.8432849646,
-0.1514402181,
-0.2398507893,
0.6393834352,
-0.9384881258,
0.5339214802,
1.2023442984,
-0.6810100079,
-0.7336861491,
0.3416428268,
0.5618735552,
-0.6935790777,
0.8117567897,
0.0519852638,
-0.2792895734,
-0.4178833663,
-0.3120598495,
-0.7882071733,
1.0299335718,
0.2285238951,
-0.6846960783,
0.026833782,
0.1640985161,
0.4263710082,
-0.1761163473,
-0.0405956917,
0.5073332191,
0.273809731,
0.3164210916,
-1.0232352018,
0.1392511278,
-0.2919744849,
0.1461270899,
0.1260917783,
-0.8088539839,
0.7848745584,
-0.0705290586,
-0.3296065927,
-0.191887483,
0.7519690394,
-0.09354496,
0.1782172024,
0.5369405746,
0.1439687461,
0.855727613,
-0.1279667914,
0.5704117417,
-0.3287687302,
0.3361238241,
1.0734823942,
-0.2354947925,
0.7706365585,
0.6826421618,
-0.4628739655,
0.0972850397,
0.46253407,
0.2390096188,
0.4629687667,
0.0684543401,
-0.407145083,
-0.5859414935,
0.1386484504,
-0.302254498,
0.4179683328,
0.4144935906,
-0.092203036,
-0.1644398719,
0.2200156748,
0.1326454431,
0.044822149,
-0.0946657211,
0.5962883234,
-0.1234498322,
-0.2940597236,
0.3858376741,
-0.3107329607,
0.5694086552,
-0.4338871241,
0.1918027848,
-0.4545099139,
-0.0027273984,
-0.2574039698,
-0.5659346581,
0.1579156667,
-0.2549539804,
-0.1752193272,
0.1096911356,
0.4368443787,
-0.1176776066,
-0.2338677794,
0.0935813636,
0.4897366166,
0.3798336685,
0.0243717115,
-0.4901190102,
0.0590675697,
-0.1115998998,
-0.1794408113,
0.1130809858,
0.7011148334,
0.0388318673,
0.6431654692,
0.3284649551,
0.0844788104,
0.5359701514,
0.1163807735,
1.0069111586,
-0.6786005497,
-0.3484149873,
-0.4791230261,
0.5336562991,
0.117673099,
-0.6665731072,
0.8747416735,
0.3653793633,
0.969502449,
0.0749033019,
0.4949893057,
-0.5403613448,
0.4120527804,
-0.607450664,
0.3003962636,
-0.6682396531,
0.4067692757,
-0.1491585523,
-0.9061480761,
-0.5309021473,
1.1927361488,
-0.6067535877,
0.2289300412,
0.7852762938,
1.0407627821,
-0.06728293,
0.4089238048,
0.3481772244,
0.1251241714,
0.483576715,
0.3092057705,
0.6858597994,
-0.3188043833,
0.1050256863,
-0.0577265471,
0.0802710131,
-0.6156464815,
-0.9181404114,
-1.1247760057,
-0.9873236418,
-0.4019725025,
-0.3082994223,
0.1936096549,
1.3745322227,
0.4914197624,
-0.8028583527,
-0.0541214384,
-0.1470919102,
-0.0258173682,
-0.2297340482,
-0.2018561959,
0.3107717633,
-0.5703009963,
-0.4800112545,
0.5086554289,
0.240814507,
0.3393396735,
-0.2953313291,
0.2633157372,
-0.2720727026,
-0.1720637232,
0.4593830705,
0.2129744142,
-0.9883070588,
-0.5911502838,
0.0794290677,
-0.0410736538,
0.1063337773,
0.9756371379,
-0.7501675487,
0.501350224,
0.8478539586,
0.4823826253,
0.1073997244,
-0.1736350656,
0.3155582249,
-0.3896361589,
0.3274261951,
0.2216844708,
0.3381810188,
0.2990193963,
-0.0106670279,
0.4903711379,
0.5678396225,
-0.2673872113,
-0.5517591834,
0.2835667133,
-1.2453081608,
-0.3386078179,
1.6110024452,
-0.008395588,
-0.0523273125,
-0.3327756822,
-0.3353590965,
-0.1301178336,
-0.4803383052,
0.759011507,
0.8692799807,
-0.1778614819,
-0.0932342559,
-0.2386686653,
0.6591053605,
0.7090833187,
-0.3474016488,
0.036932826,
0.8171485662,
0.2647140324,
0.1985397786,
0.4574743211,
0.0508233495,
0.2124349922,
0.0320986435,
-0.242522791,
-0.3491026163,
-0.3554139137,
-0.7086032629,
0.3457503617,
0.3071022034,
-0.2658790648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10140v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10140v2 | Tackling Ambiguity with Images: Improved Multimodal Machine Translation and Contrastive Evaluation | 2022-12-20T10:18:18 | 2023-05-26T10:52:39 | Matthieu Futeral, Cordelia Schmid, Ivan Laptev, Benoît Sagot, Rachel Bawden | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | One of the major challenges of machine translation (MT) is ambiguity, which
can in some cases be resolved by accompanying context such as images. However,
recent work in multimodal MT (MMT) has shown that obtaining improvements from
images is challenging, limited not only by the difficulty of building effective
cross-modal representations, but also by the lack of specific evaluation and
training data. We present a new MMT approach based on a strong text-only MT
model, which uses neural adapters, a novel guided self-attention mechanism and
which is jointly trained on both visually-conditioned masking and MMT. We also
introduce CoMMuTE, a Contrastive Multilingual Multimodal Translation Evaluation
set of ambiguous sentences and their possible translations, accompanied by
disambiguating images corresponding to each translation. Our approach obtains
competitive results compared to strong text-only models on standard
English-to-French, English-to-German and English-to-Czech benchmarks and
outperforms baselines and state-of-the-art MMT systems by a large margin on our
contrastive test set. Our code and CoMMuTE are freely available. | [
-0.1852877736,
-0.4831156433,
0.5514705181,
0.3322101533,
-0.6784495711,
-0.1452912688,
-0.1749078482,
-0.4641649425,
-0.0111363456,
0.2049188465,
-0.7709499002,
-0.0895761698,
-1.2333707809,
0.4092499316,
-0.1839101017,
0.7070858479,
-0.3621524572,
0.101495482,
-0.0423897058,
-0.6505494714,
-0.7343255281,
-0.1519196033,
-0.4175688326,
-0.2628645599,
0.6657364964,
0.1122442484,
1.1109362841,
0.6872399449,
0.8461475968,
0.4868527055,
0.0368915088,
0.395940125,
-0.1631089598,
0.2870269418,
-0.2451995164,
-0.3143759966,
-0.1285455376,
-0.2675284743,
0.4942124486,
0.6496063471,
0.2873462737,
-0.12270087,
-0.0326791406,
0.5895498991,
-0.6416120529,
0.0898401439,
-0.6552805305,
0.2545870841,
0.1007727906,
-0.2667779624,
-0.3689242303,
0.2990969718,
-0.0857092515,
-0.8562474847,
0.0175026879,
0.060181614,
0.7963408828,
0.7347156405,
-0.8760602474,
-0.3141186833,
-0.4044268727,
0.8882688284,
-0.3728670776,
0.7869254351,
0.0212823842,
0.4549765885,
-0.079367958,
-0.7109709382,
-0.5187256336,
0.1049848646,
-0.3558462858,
0.5155882835,
-0.4336534739,
-0.1375335902,
-0.0536113791,
0.2233685255,
-0.6369074583,
-0.1338685602,
-0.2400119901,
-0.1316023171,
0.1078824922,
0.061511118,
0.3231753409,
-0.3293855488,
-0.7239310145,
-0.2190375328,
-0.1940698922,
-0.2118156701,
-0.0286372937,
-0.081930548,
-0.395568192,
0.6137793064,
-0.0073294546,
0.6866810918,
0.061632853,
0.2452456653,
0.4938348234,
-0.3600468934,
-0.2175233811,
-0.4100984633,
0.9208346605,
0.7905419469,
-0.2096890807,
-0.2334134877,
-0.3789904416,
0.1547085047,
0.064297162,
-0.6886495352,
-0.0587011054,
0.0253659748,
-0.6184524298,
0.0534967706,
-0.285096854,
-0.8219184279,
-0.3213320076,
-0.2501682341,
0.7785639763,
-0.4321822822,
-0.035804145,
0.1760946512,
-0.2113327533,
-0.0711971968,
0.4884210229,
-0.7693313956,
-0.1056511328,
0.0185312908,
0.7871474624,
-0.1301634759,
-0.3373360932,
-0.5145488977,
0.2049535364,
-0.2129323334,
0.6502385736,
-0.6199035645,
-0.1982524544,
-0.3182820082,
0.1911652386,
-0.3145628273,
-0.5405286551,
0.6913427711,
-0.4863036871,
0.2690275311,
0.1481211931,
-0.1438429803,
-0.196655333,
0.4781605005,
-0.7217977047,
0.7803245783,
0.0806224197,
-0.6268432736,
0.0477642752,
-0.8977273703,
-0.4008565247,
-0.1482655853,
-0.2761896849,
-0.4032666087,
0.1608790457,
0.6441965699,
0.3015556633,
-0.1649961174,
0.2135871649,
-0.0772250667,
-0.4332200587,
0.3984430432,
-0.664948225,
0.6123978496,
0.4925018549,
-0.4226458967,
0.234149009,
-0.6728299856,
0.0385348648,
0.1139365509,
-0.2558039725,
-0.2418720722,
-0.2926010787,
0.1437055618,
0.6537365913,
0.3259455264,
-0.2604937553,
-0.1220478639,
-0.1510847956,
0.3611610532,
0.8294340372,
-0.3139526248,
0.4077720046,
-0.2504052222,
0.599925518,
0.4265237749,
0.2342309803,
-0.6738542318,
-0.539063096,
-1.0626965761,
-0.3775137663,
0.369440794,
0.6228571534,
-1.3273028135,
0.2917912304,
-0.4690465331,
-0.0867877901,
-0.9553922415,
0.1404066086,
0.4674443901,
0.27658692,
0.6204127073,
-0.3216066062,
-0.5378534794,
-1.0401632786,
-0.2418356538,
0.2969433963,
0.0001697446,
0.2759571373,
0.496448487,
-0.5629561543,
0.2558591962,
-0.2663256824,
-0.2005445808,
0.254085809,
0.4832453132,
0.1526063532,
0.5812799931,
0.2761367261,
-1.1182140112,
-0.5473848581,
0.3372578919,
-0.8241203427,
0.0435445718,
-0.34818694,
0.0211516954,
-0.1124804989,
0.4641597569,
-0.3630400002,
0.3329284489,
0.9579948783,
-0.1575496495,
0.0245086029,
-0.5403749347,
0.5889760852,
-1.0877795219,
0.0372669585,
-0.1590258628,
-0.4614062011,
-0.3564348221,
0.4195381105,
0.2669601142,
-0.2147389054,
-0.4576755464,
0.5344005227,
-0.6049256921,
0.1527674198,
-0.2282157391,
0.2058853358,
0.0630896613,
0.4857631624,
-0.1441909373,
0.6381028891,
0.4489156306,
-0.3261221945,
0.2632156312,
0.344322294,
-0.2028619349,
0.9700027704,
-0.3500074446,
0.3672412038,
-0.1483246982,
0.1320164353,
-1.0727363825,
-0.1119308248,
0.5854380131,
-0.3888090253,
0.2072525322,
-0.063594535,
-0.4042642415,
-0.1157534197,
0.1187568083,
0.9115716219,
0.3033124804,
-0.6411185861,
0.720705986,
-0.2041076273,
-0.1463181823,
-0.680907011,
-0.8285070062,
0.5059880614,
-0.0854497626,
-0.7453241944,
0.4119594395,
-0.2880563736,
0.1526424438,
0.0237016007,
-0.1468211263,
-0.3875850737,
0.1222993881,
0.1767535955,
0.0045663379,
-0.0080131255,
0.0952688679,
0.1603982449,
-0.3918213844,
-0.2796424627,
-0.1072927043,
0.1736808717,
-0.0702589676,
-0.4895179272,
-0.3149603903,
0.6681919098,
0.5335238576,
-0.3014915884,
0.1831154525,
1.0410196781,
-0.178507179,
0.3151345849,
-0.2471330911,
0.0281050578,
-0.5040274262,
0.461096108,
-0.7211812735,
-0.811473012,
0.4421467483,
-0.2489935011,
-0.2382303327,
0.4665797651,
0.5491346121,
-0.1375534832,
1.2748482227,
0.6295152307,
0.5640820861,
0.3763442934,
0.168031916,
0.1207601056,
-0.8079497814,
-0.2189534009,
-0.3268607557,
-0.5912736058,
-0.6215331554,
-0.7109805346,
0.5565641522,
-0.3116348684,
0.253128469,
0.1953294426,
-0.5859510303,
0.5644060373,
0.390047729,
0.4721576869,
0.4519575536,
0.0046653324,
-0.3559943736,
-0.3440715075,
-0.6077970266,
-0.2437582761,
0.9550050497,
0.0615054816,
0.6134554148,
0.2571208477,
0.3574823737,
0.1714593023,
0.2693493962,
-0.6173601151,
0.3302297592,
-0.4803061485,
-0.5473138094,
0.0940557048,
-0.6272780895,
-1.3158798218,
0.7847701311,
-0.3831486702,
-0.1832617819,
0.3013096452,
0.088673614,
-0.0191745684,
0.0713521615,
-0.9067727327,
1.0888433456,
-0.5378877521,
-0.4331155419,
-0.2067419142,
-1.1375596523,
0.1910721213,
-0.1346798986,
0.4900103807,
0.1536433697,
-0.2944428921,
0.2179024071,
0.0525179543,
0.6745638251,
0.1239186004,
-0.00250639,
-0.2541413605,
0.0859382823,
0.3182050288,
-0.3535393775,
-0.1485114992,
0.1535330564,
-0.114938356,
-0.6350702047,
-0.8939774632,
0.3697670102,
-0.6993436813,
-0.3249942958,
-0.1914968938,
-1.1635167599,
0.1035467759,
0.438772887,
0.2052385807,
0.1817389727,
-0.0231197607,
0.1600936204,
0.4744660258,
-0.2387855798,
0.3977808952,
0.3349301517,
-0.1441610307,
-0.6241059303,
0.9115589857,
-0.1264939159,
0.1867733151,
0.5534903407,
0.1395046115,
-0.3515188396,
-0.4744616449,
-0.8696441054,
-0.1578451693,
-1.0351158381,
-0.144783318,
-0.7634984851,
0.2251129597,
-0.1965376735,
-0.2088409513,
-0.1896010935,
-0.4116383791,
-0.0997911841,
0.4658599496,
-0.2352960408,
0.6252757907,
-0.0714009106,
0.5178247094,
-0.7660576701,
0.7082982063,
0.250582993,
0.3591555357,
-0.534403801,
-0.6192137003,
-0.4488585293,
0.006552781,
-0.5822861195,
-0.8587585688,
0.2363143712,
0.0189302862,
0.5510782003,
0.1394009441,
-0.0137422318,
0.975910306,
-0.5679966211,
0.449157238,
0.5394598246,
-0.9334333539,
0.2465118915,
-0.2968931496,
0.6736003757,
0.3315623999,
0.1274469048,
-0.6955013871,
-0.3487615287,
-0.4863066077,
-0.9159083366,
0.4102571011,
0.5279562473,
0.2872616649,
0.1166156679,
0.1674426496,
0.1937469393,
0.2623818815,
-1.1393208504,
-0.2297709733,
-0.4395677745,
-0.5153285265,
-0.0815572068,
0.0678494722,
-0.2046078444,
-0.1410614103,
0.3026957214,
-0.1753325015,
0.4311901927,
0.3029468656,
-0.6603265405,
-0.0788069144,
0.505192101,
0.6340854168,
0.379820317,
-0.0704517588,
0.5745029449,
0.1485898793,
0.0187490191,
0.3421744406,
0.3966274261,
-0.073862046,
0.2160273343,
0.1304946244,
0.920429647,
0.3284877539,
-0.5395467281,
0.5569704175,
-0.0010479675,
-0.1160597205,
0.3396706283,
-0.3304086924,
-0.0547602512,
0.4310317338,
0.0386759192,
0.6245933771,
0.3555790782,
-0.2315495163,
0.2302202135,
0.3316003978,
-0.6346469522,
-0.0841621757,
0.6257490516,
0.4347844124,
-0.2393942922,
0.4290521741,
-0.2473406941,
-0.5600477457,
0.4181654453,
0.6643416882,
0.6376378536,
-0.4043237269,
-0.0653484538,
0.0099557927,
0.6956434846,
0.2333979458,
0.1164904684,
-0.0328600369,
-0.4694699049,
-0.4431793094,
0.1250828803,
-0.444522649,
-0.2218638808,
-0.4748799801,
0.2902666032,
-0.0050757439,
-0.0767303929,
-0.0997366384,
-0.5559612513,
-0.7111153007,
0.4984567463,
0.0030750665,
0.5050607324,
-0.680606544,
0.6164986491,
0.9319047928,
-0.2285697162,
-0.181344077,
-0.1714039743,
-0.2394394428,
-0.93303895,
0.6308359504,
0.4300515652,
-0.2535607219,
-0.0185809731,
-0.2702326179,
-0.4013164639,
0.942718029,
0.7777705789,
-0.4469713271,
0.2758024037,
0.2344366908,
0.2517490387,
-0.184537217,
0.5669655204,
0.0364520997,
0.8163494468,
0.1970616579,
-0.7944166064,
0.1557138562,
-0.5641621351,
-0.0625453591,
0.302295208,
-0.652089119,
0.655847311,
-0.0993379578,
-0.1930358559,
0.2151019275,
0.4362805486,
-0.3285239041,
0.3850715756,
0.7404312491,
0.6416319609,
0.5738302469,
-0.1696304977,
0.845531702,
-0.1595468968,
0.3013063669,
1.3415904045,
0.0667406768,
0.639574945,
0.8664481044,
0.247803852,
0.2670985758,
0.6733563542,
-0.1764693111,
0.501826942,
0.0503718667,
-0.2244810462,
-0.5473960638,
-0.0098817507,
-0.3408178091,
0.3355032802,
0.1185027808,
-0.6114875674,
-0.5301101208,
0.1009643748,
-0.2759830952,
0.2589269876,
0.0299982876,
0.5568957329,
0.1002203748,
-0.5781131983,
0.6450661421,
0.2171369344,
0.7734486461,
-0.4346597493,
-0.0758287758,
-0.1482390165,
0.1825438738,
-0.0728153959,
-0.6619774699,
0.4066151083,
-0.2951257825,
-0.2048678398,
-0.3960666656,
0.5014666319,
-0.5401839018,
-0.6234870553,
0.3746246696,
0.574876368,
0.1389874965,
-0.0858768746,
-1.0739599466,
0.2056077123,
-0.0198954567,
0.0470183752,
0.1172626317,
0.7118579149,
-0.0006938254,
0.6182336211,
0.3816378415,
-0.5513733625,
0.3071217835,
-0.1497790664,
0.8308692575,
-0.5311994553,
-0.3136693835,
-0.8690980673,
0.803450942,
0.060849186,
-0.3278410435,
0.4475224912,
0.5297926664,
0.6399273872,
-0.0994818881,
0.5451030731,
0.0892571285,
-0.1596981287,
-0.6387064457,
0.4671914876,
-1.0663621426,
-0.0057481001,
-0.1677851677,
-0.6117204428,
-0.7337940335,
0.7495442629,
-0.1334912479,
0.0218198653,
0.9544084072,
0.7611365318,
-0.4718597233,
-0.262214154,
0.6708093882,
0.190261662,
0.0601455607,
0.7201729417,
0.940716207,
-0.9768907428,
1.0787177086,
-0.0918806493,
-0.1857622564,
-0.1074763611,
-1.0421947241,
-0.7421866655,
-0.5017858744,
-0.3664959073,
-0.3533993363,
0.2208273858,
0.7512896061,
0.8179839849,
-0.3662962317,
-0.0813090354,
0.2028557062,
0.2808742821,
-0.3470747769,
-0.0594629794,
0.1947183907,
-0.4482446611,
-0.9536296725,
0.3733103275,
0.4622208178,
0.2601432502,
0.1916225255,
-0.3219581842,
-0.1860661656,
-0.0226543844,
0.5368776321,
-0.2596692741,
-0.6161848903,
-0.0816832259,
0.0403246805,
-0.1281069666,
0.5484782457,
0.627390027,
-0.3695504367,
1.0731999874,
0.2114469409,
0.8305591941,
0.6293637753,
-0.295438081,
0.6130341887,
-0.8113991022,
0.3614950478,
-0.1377034336,
0.4821905792,
0.572727859,
-0.144292444,
0.4875869453,
0.2189308703,
-0.3672011197,
-0.4628067315,
0.4948841333,
-1.1824036837,
-0.2881993353,
0.7262346745,
-0.3827892244,
-0.150330916,
-0.050904382,
-0.4160710871,
0.4712152183,
-0.162299484,
0.8488598466,
0.6912505031,
0.1871117055,
-0.5754861832,
-0.5627627373,
-0.1925851554,
0.9542805552,
-0.8187907338,
-0.3366087079,
0.5103350282,
0.0949561223,
0.293705225,
0.3286744356,
-0.2410269529,
0.3517308235,
-0.1747832,
0.1921800524,
0.0367964879,
-0.1348454803,
-0.5802355409,
-0.0052182619,
-0.098579511,
-0.5122162104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10114v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10114v2 | True Detective: A Deep Abductive Reasoning Benchmark Undoable for GPT-3 and Challenging for GPT-4 | 2022-12-20T09:34:43 | 2023-06-01T18:50:21 | Maksym Del, Mark Fishel | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated solid zero-shot reasoning
capabilities, which is reflected in their performance on the current test
tasks. This calls for a more challenging benchmark requiring highly advanced
reasoning ability to be solved. In this paper, we introduce such a benchmark,
consisting of 191 long-form (1200 words on average) mystery narratives
constructed as detective puzzles. Puzzles are sourced from the "5 Minute
Mystery" platform and include a multiple-choice question for evaluation. Only
47% of humans solve a puzzle successfully on average, while the best human
solvers achieve over 80% success rate. We show that GPT-3 models barely
outperform random on this benchmark (with 28% accuracy) while state-of-the-art
GPT-4 solves only 38% of puzzles. This indicates that there is still a
significant gap in the deep reasoning abilities of LLMs and humans and
highlights the need for further research in this area. Our work introduces a
challenging benchmark for future studies on reasoning in language models and
contributes to a better understanding of the limits of LLMs' abilities. | [
-0.2593687177,
-0.5542858243,
1.1461075544,
-0.2256901264,
-0.1957573593,
0.4770148396,
-0.1958853155,
-0.7065805197,
-0.5839151144,
0.4385078847,
-0.6706920862,
-0.5257102251,
-0.501288116,
0.3431420624,
-0.3446753919,
0.7168565392,
-0.1887358427,
-0.0570101924,
0.2121281028,
-0.1780816317,
-0.2597384453,
-0.6605727077,
-0.3886839747,
-0.2745860219,
0.4588792026,
0.2266491503,
0.5303715467,
0.7474883795,
0.5450468063,
0.16955778,
-0.0013445105,
0.1939129531,
-0.6342901587,
0.1324340105,
-0.2677637041,
-0.6814079881,
-0.2424933463,
0.2101352513,
0.1971632838,
0.4527229965,
-0.1682003438,
-0.1555877626,
-0.550981164,
0.8002183437,
-0.6833047867,
-0.0981300622,
-0.6398947835,
0.0048316428,
-0.1542430818,
0.1822851002,
-0.2005285472,
-0.480817914,
0.0915341154,
-0.5957701206,
0.4824409187,
-0.2242974639,
0.8949944377,
0.1991781592,
-0.3361100256,
-0.2861143053,
-0.8426240087,
0.6385269165,
-0.5869682431,
0.2402328253,
0.3626424074,
0.5599863529,
-0.1197554246,
-0.601282537,
-0.7359033823,
-0.3484129012,
0.4143887162,
0.0815481246,
-0.3287879229,
-0.2181527615,
0.4362132549,
0.3096354008,
-0.7882592678,
0.1980246603,
-0.1402317584,
-0.1610212624,
0.5955042839,
0.5062419772,
0.0707852244,
0.1540833265,
0.0138258478,
-0.0272999965,
-0.932363987,
-0.1202030629,
0.3317991495,
-0.0645398423,
0.1390909702,
0.5681708455,
-0.5009641051,
0.2435043603,
-0.2809380293,
0.0366190113,
0.2972145081,
-0.5857306123,
-0.0433715023,
-0.0734936222,
0.7492141724,
0.3700354397,
0.4927529991,
-0.1328647733,
-0.3082552254,
0.2892192006,
0.0529795699,
-0.8113127947,
-0.4804036915,
0.0655610859,
-0.1690390706,
-0.1012938991,
-0.4037356079,
-0.3978999257,
-0.4790647626,
-0.0221282858,
0.3015731871,
-0.630456984,
-0.3013034463,
0.5243453979,
-0.0795642138,
0.55141747,
0.429228574,
-0.4529772699,
0.1961688548,
0.7897628546,
0.699803412,
-0.1675660312,
-0.2538894117,
-0.3045935929,
0.1139325202,
-0.6030205488,
0.7787906528,
-0.4734008908,
-0.1945780516,
-0.1729085743,
0.046451591,
0.2205925137,
-0.4651558995,
0.9264942408,
-0.4108126462,
0.1563859582,
-0.4319014847,
-0.5635377169,
-0.1885927171,
0.4862022102,
-0.5318063498,
0.7536897659,
0.0515238382,
-0.3320973814,
0.2579343617,
-0.4849331081,
-0.3680967391,
0.3423827589,
-0.3155045807,
-0.3294205964,
0.1629396975,
0.490208745,
0.4424779117,
-0.5586375594,
0.2690054774,
-0.331664592,
-0.7061055899,
0.3801281452,
-0.6200572252,
0.6617642641,
0.189280197,
-0.6034010053,
-0.2906200588,
-0.6576151252,
-0.0770036578,
0.6471548676,
-0.127346769,
-0.021413086,
-0.2231194228,
-0.5469892025,
-0.078276366,
0.1922608614,
-0.657368958,
0.4140942395,
-0.170516938,
0.5311548114,
0.4861584008,
-0.1389754713,
0.0407368205,
-0.2106206119,
0.4673001468,
-0.136660412,
-0.052330941,
-0.1924082786,
-0.5056480765,
-0.6370871067,
-0.4470122457,
0.2255795598,
0.6421228051,
-0.6509814858,
0.3614372015,
-0.2528960407,
-0.6279760599,
-0.5882690549,
-0.0892407224,
0.4898459911,
0.3120421171,
0.4987868965,
0.0488167182,
-0.2304897755,
-1.0253340006,
-0.5630156994,
-0.0688370019,
-0.283788234,
0.2666088343,
0.7942170501,
-0.114003107,
0.6027950644,
-0.5248185396,
-0.2727810144,
-0.3509925902,
0.4515158832,
0.5640220046,
0.2178198844,
0.2927104533,
-0.4565452337,
-0.1664537638,
-0.189379245,
-0.9145807028,
0.0717193335,
0.086027503,
0.2666234374,
0.239542976,
0.3427432179,
-0.8638298512,
0.5498559475,
0.0631105229,
-0.1547363549,
0.8333739042,
-0.2326440066,
0.1240760759,
-0.4808756411,
0.0040146736,
-0.0573701933,
-0.0238197614,
-0.4392343462,
0.2698896229,
0.2694345415,
-0.047852356,
-0.0944808275,
0.440066576,
-0.7631524801,
-0.0526454858,
-0.0381143391,
0.1606904715,
-0.1088315696,
0.4014639556,
0.2840411365,
0.7212498784,
0.5817395449,
-0.3259048164,
0.6806013584,
-0.0211445857,
-0.7803703547,
0.355889976,
-0.6360699534,
0.378886193,
0.1600786597,
0.3498051465,
-0.9631106853,
-0.1937672794,
-0.0770221725,
-0.6202490926,
0.1664859653,
-0.2005557716,
-0.7877211571,
-0.5336957574,
-0.1944934875,
0.5304992795,
0.7615459561,
-0.4222671092,
0.311106354,
-0.0710888952,
-0.0206711534,
-0.6584025621,
-0.7839114666,
0.4236279726,
-0.2242051065,
-0.3554198146,
0.1671382636,
-0.2640303969,
-0.1067213491,
-0.0336180367,
-0.3074734807,
-0.0495789833,
0.0569564663,
-0.1208744943,
0.0828378946,
-0.4377466142,
-0.0516978279,
-0.402181685,
-0.1700478643,
0.2346659899,
0.0381554551,
0.3360737264,
-0.524394989,
-0.4950093627,
-0.4932474792,
0.2355956286,
0.6526753306,
-0.292515099,
0.3531951308,
0.5193488002,
-0.2453479767,
0.0136171319,
-0.9625617266,
-0.2891733646,
-0.4495859742,
0.446590066,
-1.0480628014,
-1.021797061,
0.6755980253,
0.0309664328,
-0.2555142343,
0.1671982259,
0.5400158167,
0.0600944422,
1.2225836515,
0.2063018829,
-0.1134345978,
-0.1925568283,
-0.2776359916,
0.4791843295,
-0.896597147,
-0.2366070896,
-0.4512985349,
-0.1575933248,
-0.5433716178,
-0.3221126795,
0.2309510559,
0.2468528301,
-0.407571584,
0.314802438,
-0.6155408621,
0.7717444897,
0.4976490438,
0.0686038062,
0.5682955384,
-0.3309439123,
-0.2183680832,
0.0240264162,
-0.3497425914,
-0.4300501347,
1.3661257029,
0.3865574896,
0.6514297128,
0.5236133337,
0.6447969675,
-0.0245212689,
-0.0497608259,
-0.7249304652,
0.6723636389,
0.1440399736,
-0.8323835135,
-0.4714604616,
-0.5253332853,
-0.9586074948,
0.233558625,
0.0228801947,
-0.7736109495,
0.0133666042,
-0.4424110651,
-0.4419864416,
0.3350755572,
-0.4133147895,
0.7497270107,
-0.3432835937,
-0.5066792369,
-0.218546629,
-0.7274326086,
0.586250186,
0.0498626903,
0.093667388,
-0.5750095248,
-0.2435159683,
0.4736237526,
-0.1365253627,
0.453310281,
0.0000508868,
-0.1060234979,
0.1568894088,
0.5800844431,
0.6487016082,
0.1134473607,
-0.0227471832,
0.0183176342,
-0.1252297461,
-0.5340051055,
-0.5769375563,
0.6796789169,
-0.6945486069,
-0.753575325,
-0.6303409934,
-0.5014734864,
-0.4536553621,
0.326161176,
0.236818552,
0.4608560503,
-0.1095046699,
0.2274475098,
0.9103785157,
-0.0506747924,
0.6093118191,
0.9531478286,
0.1868519932,
-0.1143071279,
0.7312344909,
-0.1637924761,
0.0297534987,
0.4015584588,
0.3244654536,
-0.5011307001,
-1.1378036737,
-0.3645328283,
0.4580725729,
-0.7560894489,
-0.0671939552,
-0.709409833,
-0.2886672914,
-0.2521432042,
-0.0617362559,
-0.5428106189,
-0.2233964652,
-0.1348535717,
-0.1537189186,
0.0538627915,
0.707295239,
-0.0663910508,
-0.1376007646,
-0.7591081858,
0.551615119,
0.636595726,
0.4269739091,
-0.1689188927,
-0.5960406065,
0.1484272629,
-0.0694248229,
-0.0005399447,
-0.7255895734,
0.2028124332,
-0.4499829412,
0.6993123889,
0.331466794,
0.1790346056,
0.42290622,
-0.3547076881,
0.9055774808,
0.1630861759,
-0.6641918421,
0.2697664499,
-0.7314040661,
0.5592035651,
0.5986648798,
0.4669440687,
-0.0803772882,
-0.2537047267,
-0.5654156208,
-0.4319097698,
0.5354343057,
0.4640107751,
-0.0568564199,
-0.0199937709,
0.3639467657,
0.0909844637,
0.0161196571,
-0.7833126187,
0.0909757465,
-0.0235371962,
0.0087656258,
-0.1392224133,
-0.3176498413,
-0.2243499458,
-0.4431042671,
0.3937702179,
-0.1480741948,
0.3554978371,
0.1208267212,
-0.0092310719,
0.1823919117,
0.2447181046,
0.8819482923,
0.8497212529,
-0.55505234,
0.1444748193,
0.1671958566,
-0.3548145592,
0.2306362242,
0.1160656735,
0.2923904657,
-0.300373733,
0.6653016806,
0.5778876543,
-0.1571344882,
-0.815672338,
0.8710851669,
-0.3799237609,
-0.4954316318,
-0.397449106,
0.0841157362,
0.2349993438,
0.3451816738,
0.6366297007,
-0.2831533849,
0.1345153898,
-0.7649451494,
-0.0225288216,
0.452457428,
-0.2819375396,
-0.1563488543,
0.4893932045,
0.2933868468,
-0.2125357836,
0.8819437027,
-0.655000329,
-0.6767621636,
0.6542695165,
0.3633447587,
1.0583645105,
-0.0531811379,
0.090432547,
0.2877841592,
0.5548243523,
-0.3606130183,
0.2624492943,
-0.0728534088,
-0.9390563965,
-0.6587580442,
-0.186316669,
-0.4158642292,
0.7109354138,
-0.4736569822,
0.0482173674,
-0.3868005872,
0.1546658278,
-0.0621147007,
0.1973401457,
-0.5511286855,
0.0849025622,
0.176879704,
0.8784473538,
-0.5272675157,
0.8026067019,
0.2484085709,
-0.305817157,
-0.5829843879,
0.0292419251,
0.1865402758,
-1.0199323893,
0.4714075029,
0.3730852008,
-0.2107774168,
-0.0808423832,
-0.8075941801,
-0.5569289923,
0.9744362831,
0.3434736133,
-0.7804996371,
-0.1669857949,
-0.0490087681,
0.6359027028,
-0.3887013495,
0.391448766,
1.0836560726,
0.5111544132,
0.3986668587,
-0.8316732645,
0.2777414918,
-0.1178462282,
-0.3852582574,
0.2013240159,
-0.3398650885,
0.7530031204,
-0.5673720241,
-0.2082096189,
0.4965809882,
0.2867122889,
0.6243846416,
0.3531894982,
0.1394533962,
0.8283744454,
0.6622102261,
-0.2220742404,
1.2332556248,
0.0966341645,
0.1065591201,
1.3592820168,
-0.5299819708,
0.541595459,
0.024080297,
-0.2629846632,
0.4540934563,
0.513489306,
-0.2511340082,
0.6552677751,
0.414159447,
-0.2794216573,
-0.6111819744,
0.2472901642,
-0.4541154802,
0.4624367654,
0.4750782251,
0.042025689,
-0.1825220883,
-0.3190096915,
0.2150260657,
0.0474943928,
-0.2073156834,
0.716031611,
-0.0589862131,
-0.6183069348,
0.8999266028,
-0.1336865723,
0.4153563678,
-0.3591191471,
-0.1193346158,
-0.4519432187,
0.2723038197,
0.141445592,
-1.1863052845,
-0.1675731093,
0.0094790701,
0.1723423004,
0.0393790901,
0.3510683477,
-0.0860451609,
-0.2692977488,
0.150466159,
0.5949883461,
0.4035826921,
-0.4693002999,
-0.684424758,
0.0226258766,
0.0737389177,
-0.3156160414,
0.190551132,
0.7856468558,
0.0650970638,
0.9746382236,
0.639580667,
0.1127171144,
0.0066911643,
0.0868386999,
0.7460926771,
-1.127753973,
-0.232269451,
-0.9658928514,
0.2627041638,
-0.3208983243,
-0.3533183336,
0.4858899415,
0.7529146671,
0.6496461034,
0.1006531045,
0.8647349477,
0.3596331179,
0.689616859,
-0.5232490897,
0.3976190388,
-0.395731777,
0.2942478657,
-0.2085130513,
-0.8520781398,
-0.2789656818,
0.4768693149,
-0.281793505,
-0.0163809154,
1.0426917076,
0.6550224423,
-0.0629132017,
0.280888021,
0.5039209723,
0.2879959047,
0.5771107674,
1.2542421818,
1.2559320927,
-0.2068646252,
0.7899299264,
-0.1729869395,
-0.195011273,
-0.2281163484,
-1.0908387899,
-1.2827883959,
-0.2702440619,
-0.2783738971,
-0.0426760986,
0.161582455,
0.2815643847,
0.5297207236,
-0.6091297865,
0.0061981999,
-0.4485969543,
0.1277588755,
-0.2685979307,
-0.2022721171,
0.3606371582,
0.0754648075,
-0.4787681699,
0.7569372654,
0.2196999341,
0.1814801991,
-0.3190314174,
0.0017042662,
-0.1628458947,
0.0514917746,
0.3874979913,
0.2747327089,
-0.9539936781,
-0.3621606231,
-0.0664168075,
-0.1257663518,
-0.0856227279,
0.8789931536,
-0.9423068762,
0.272387743,
0.409916997,
0.7237145305,
1.124946475,
-0.1390113831,
0.483304292,
-0.2578276396,
-0.1482653916,
0.6638098359,
0.208706215,
0.345461905,
-0.2956920266,
1.0069509745,
0.3850802481,
-0.6542676091,
-1.0955997705,
0.4466657341,
-0.8034416437,
-0.6353822351,
0.9707856178,
-0.1275164336,
0.0010115722,
-0.3415908515,
0.1087873653,
0.0389471129,
-0.5159294605,
0.6430583596,
0.7822304368,
-0.5908941627,
-0.6570360661,
-0.6995042562,
0.5152420998,
0.3834249675,
-0.6027321219,
0.2776894271,
0.484279871,
0.386541754,
0.158119902,
0.5687924623,
-0.2134461999,
0.4344011843,
-0.0586520694,
-0.0117150322,
-0.3649729788,
-0.2485338748,
-0.2691620588,
0.1873253882,
-0.1293902844,
0.0122543238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10097v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10097v2 | Optimization Techniques for Unsupervised Complex Table Reasoning via Self-Training Framework | 2022-12-20T09:15:03 | 2024-06-21T03:06:36 | Zhenyu Li, Xiuxing Li, Sunqi Fan, Jianyong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB | Structured tabular data is a fundamental data type in numerous fields, and
the capacity to reason over tables is crucial for answering questions and
validating hypotheses. However, constructing labeled data for complex reasoning
tasks is labor intensive, and the quantity of annotated data remains
insufficient to support the intricate demands of real-world applications. To
address the insufficient annotation challenge, we present a self-training
framework for unsupervised complex tabular reasoning (UCTR-ST) by generating
diverse synthetic data with complex logic. Specifically, UCTR-ST incorporates
several essential techniques: we aggregate diverse programs and execute them on
tables based on a "Program-Management" component, and we bridge the gap between
programs and text with a powerful "Program-Transformation" module that
generates natural language sentences with complex logic. Furthermore, we
optimize the procedure using a "Table-Text Manipulator" to handle joint
table-text reasoning scenarios. The entire framework utilizes self-training
techniques to leverage the unlabeled training data, which results in
significant performance improvements when tested on real-world data.
Experimental results demonstrate that UCTRST achieves above 90% of the
supervised model performance on different tasks and domains, reducing the
dependence on manual annotation. Additionally, our approach can serve as a data
augmentation technique, significantly boosting the performance of supervised
models in low-resourced domains. | [
-0.3526463807,
-1.0166969299,
0.5988016725,
0.1464278549,
-0.2204847932,
0.1861784011,
-0.2634466887,
-0.2102366537,
-0.2796363831,
0.6309046149,
-0.6426389813,
-0.5299882293,
0.0168839432,
0.0003431297,
-0.255358845,
1.1508922577,
-0.2513400316,
0.1579436809,
-0.4428470731,
0.1235029101,
-0.3925984204,
-0.7431429625,
0.0110567035,
-0.6265415549,
0.2018795758,
0.7772831321,
0.3444284797,
0.9543067813,
0.4608966708,
0.2555951476,
0.5044144392,
0.4098089337,
-0.1863886416,
0.222612381,
-0.1785501391,
-0.319509238,
-0.3015492558,
-0.2940407991,
0.1475469023,
0.8502445221,
-0.2169441879,
0.2456178218,
0.0861445218,
0.8568373322,
-0.5883786082,
0.3481242061,
-0.5982338786,
0.470939666,
-0.3098232448,
-0.2023387402,
-0.3600283563,
-0.2224850059,
0.0299861319,
-0.6681649089,
0.2067174464,
0.1881373376,
0.3703301251,
0.302280128,
-0.4474335611,
0.1388985068,
-1.105689168,
0.440882206,
-0.4427174032,
0.4014987051,
-0.0648661777,
0.4174774289,
-0.537694633,
-0.7310481071,
-0.7392741442,
-0.3772340417,
-0.1372637153,
0.3100782931,
-0.1130364984,
0.3422911167,
0.4852696061,
0.1443496943,
-0.9752013087,
-0.071616292,
-0.1840282679,
-0.0722398832,
0.4887841344,
0.218468532,
0.2741757631,
0.102665484,
-0.420188427,
-0.1559634358,
-0.565787971,
0.1091128513,
0.1068346128,
0.2045129985,
0.1938569099,
0.7412471771,
-0.6305465698,
0.9182068706,
-0.1261122376,
0.0546717048,
0.0511946939,
-0.0472994335,
-0.4075360894,
0.2331611067,
0.5850856304,
0.0253861137,
0.3146202266,
-0.3797338903,
-0.2547494471,
0.5597856641,
0.3137980103,
-0.5603532791,
-0.5565589666,
0.0304110795,
-0.0086869756,
-0.1664786786,
0.1802738905,
-0.705935657,
0.1191040576,
-0.8506711721,
0.5560587645,
-0.1746156216,
0.1424906999,
0.072517179,
0.1081825346,
-0.1283208281,
0.4657497108,
-0.7288916111,
0.2906053066,
0.4962368309,
0.3086979687,
-0.3875418305,
-0.1798630059,
-0.76248312,
0.5234297514,
-0.2260991335,
1.0489200354,
-0.5591263771,
-0.0761676356,
-0.0411446095,
-0.1789961308,
-0.1343348175,
-0.488502264,
0.7731451988,
-0.0783342347,
-0.0688612014,
-0.0862578675,
-0.5158746243,
0.0006436864,
0.4848139882,
-0.4385538101,
1.1225793362,
0.1500786692,
-0.4992945492,
0.2959276438,
-1.0233356953,
-0.6359357238,
0.0521867611,
-0.3930995762,
-0.6103253961,
-0.1083156615,
0.3352514505,
0.5642297864,
-0.3520928323,
0.461738348,
-0.3841515481,
-0.1185960099,
0.2627080083,
-0.2262781858,
0.2084808946,
0.3207397163,
-0.5280025005,
0.2398965806,
-0.8097797036,
0.276278466,
0.0609424599,
-0.5679038167,
-0.010690297,
-0.0789396539,
0.0780905783,
0.1298499256,
-0.1106699482,
-0.6660798192,
0.5385095477,
-0.2664755285,
0.3268702626,
0.2805429995,
-0.0366569534,
0.4601425827,
-0.058715757,
0.2674334049,
0.2904684842,
0.2859270871,
0.1921908855,
0.0571988449,
-0.7778147459,
0.0109272804,
0.2476633489,
0.7254254222,
-0.7717517018,
0.5818582773,
-0.073203437,
-0.5134337544,
-0.1323516965,
0.0906450227,
0.527780652,
0.822320044,
0.771422863,
0.1724907905,
-0.5063996315,
-1.2106808424,
-0.468449533,
0.2666815817,
0.1342016309,
-0.1307607889,
0.5522912741,
-0.3270952106,
0.9296216369,
-0.6952134967,
-0.4571381509,
-0.7377307415,
0.4590249062,
-0.0096909693,
0.8753356934,
0.2167073041,
-0.6822847724,
-0.5041179657,
0.2231957167,
-0.7187877297,
-0.2237305939,
-0.5235719681,
-0.2833852768,
0.2325343341,
0.3967777491,
-0.7004871964,
0.7292027473,
0.0365497321,
-0.1243308932,
0.785856545,
-0.3888508677,
-0.1249512732,
-0.5592042208,
0.0501976311,
0.1415564567,
-0.1885509044,
-0.8210455179,
-0.1928383559,
0.0214052163,
-0.1350416541,
-0.0243071597,
0.2861177921,
-0.6584118009,
-0.0383316912,
0.0173541307,
-0.0092980545,
0.0575156584,
0.8674520254,
0.0911818296,
0.470790416,
0.2625391781,
-0.5263043642,
0.3581913412,
0.2305972278,
-0.3253633082,
0.5040591359,
-0.4533983469,
-0.0892771855,
-0.1967737675,
0.2551516294,
-0.8747922778,
-0.2823835909,
0.272361666,
-0.1109949052,
0.517084837,
-0.1070651188,
-0.5182565451,
-0.6306966543,
0.0560057089,
0.1736779064,
-0.0413353704,
-0.6015435457,
0.811524868,
0.3692160845,
0.294726342,
-0.5364106297,
-0.7466240525,
-0.1392973363,
-0.1108608022,
-0.3350764513,
0.4811606407,
-0.0656037629,
-0.0924431384,
-0.0546454489,
-0.5399047732,
-0.0886128396,
-0.0344999768,
0.253033042,
0.1279045045,
0.1417489201,
0.1027896479,
0.6084819436,
-0.2907184958,
0.1299999505,
-0.3008238673,
0.478638798,
-0.4017580152,
-0.4381514788,
-0.4866506159,
0.3132643998,
0.195284754,
-0.3266322017,
0.2580175102,
0.752147913,
-0.3777427673,
-0.5155479908,
-0.6418841481,
-0.2612269521,
-0.4091028273,
0.3649929762,
-0.4344909787,
-0.6584265828,
0.37133497,
-0.3200458586,
0.0360347256,
0.3418477476,
0.4533380866,
-0.3971907496,
1.0449876785,
-0.0010918637,
0.2534311116,
0.105002366,
-0.5211476684,
0.1269604862,
-0.6739634275,
-0.5608122349,
-0.5363383889,
-0.3118512332,
-0.3274260461,
-0.2408014536,
0.593132019,
-0.0894176289,
-0.5532007217,
0.2255278975,
-0.9166119695,
0.5605593324,
0.8067237735,
0.2760195434,
0.3647355437,
0.1277337819,
-0.1942836493,
-0.0877416655,
-0.7337818146,
-0.2900983095,
0.7498182058,
0.0003641613,
0.8717247248,
-0.2955529392,
0.4277691841,
0.4897603095,
0.3494751453,
-0.3905609548,
0.5607856512,
-0.1294577271,
-0.4310124516,
-0.3888592422,
-0.7645042539,
-0.7980609536,
0.3249443471,
-0.5870652795,
-0.6813496351,
-0.0095315352,
0.4518530071,
-0.2118332684,
0.2310526818,
-0.8182969093,
1.3799620867,
-0.6211634874,
-0.2571698725,
0.0846427903,
-0.8246433735,
0.2555042803,
0.0113784168,
-0.1088023111,
-0.0095633166,
0.4758160114,
0.5573726892,
-0.6085256338,
0.6148936749,
-0.3262969553,
0.5058454275,
0.3872063756,
0.4626018107,
0.5533292294,
-0.0478677526,
0.2251910865,
-0.0798275694,
0.1328585744,
-0.2026220262,
-0.7569033504,
0.5350106359,
-0.7108995914,
-0.5207549334,
-0.3882148564,
-0.5932714343,
-0.5296791792,
0.1629989147,
0.1872891337,
0.5660236478,
-0.0388837457,
0.4568533897,
0.572786212,
0.1447834671,
0.3404253721,
0.0693322718,
0.1111193895,
-0.327463448,
0.6772306561,
0.3164270222,
-0.0473736003,
0.6965227723,
0.3821910322,
-0.5757039785,
-0.5007593036,
-0.7661872506,
-0.0616358705,
-0.4495044053,
-0.627194941,
-0.7042253613,
-0.1179792583,
-0.0143906157,
-0.178922534,
-0.3317179084,
-0.7115231156,
-0.2498474419,
-0.2911994457,
0.1424583048,
0.2359728664,
-0.0112677421,
0.4608075321,
-0.7953029871,
0.228415817,
0.4188302457,
0.193559587,
-0.1242064461,
-0.3025216162,
-0.2412711531,
0.1746216565,
-0.4040934443,
-0.8941786289,
0.3522442877,
0.2191084325,
0.7913555503,
0.173639521,
0.3206014037,
0.8263808489,
-0.2496391386,
0.0616733991,
0.180328548,
-0.9282366633,
0.615036428,
-0.4967767894,
0.2216506451,
0.8203783035,
0.2219292819,
0.0416217819,
-0.1269154996,
-0.3618503809,
-0.7522749901,
0.6440370679,
0.2920611799,
-0.3038942814,
0.4447724819,
0.5999138951,
0.0776761323,
0.3210793734,
-1.1106128693,
-0.1567752212,
-0.3445585668,
-0.4265353978,
0.612760365,
0.0668972358,
-0.1411687881,
-0.6082277894,
0.5353825092,
-0.3467008173,
0.1457736343,
0.4245752692,
-0.2715350986,
-0.1753778458,
0.3340185881,
0.4110805392,
0.4823517203,
-0.0937755182,
0.2649490237,
0.0626916364,
-0.3201456666,
0.0594253428,
0.2236077935,
-0.1754020005,
-0.3191421628,
-0.0115121342,
0.5754422545,
0.0085301567,
-0.6605682969,
0.2967424691,
0.1190799996,
-0.1622626185,
-0.3582084179,
0.3326055408,
-0.0906504914,
0.2895995677,
0.3786220253,
-0.0311258566,
0.4004935026,
-0.5372896194,
0.2709391117,
0.3911057711,
-0.1825793982,
-0.1122843027,
0.7267152667,
-0.0149312271,
-0.0930588096,
0.5771752596,
-0.3051942289,
-0.6159744263,
0.491186738,
0.8352239132,
0.5810153484,
-0.1708449423,
0.3287389576,
0.3481466472,
0.2910668254,
-0.1736916453,
0.3050476313,
-0.3297272623,
-0.6140478849,
-0.1779927611,
-0.4956941307,
-0.3838220239,
0.0766346902,
-0.4729844332,
-0.0590196587,
-0.4353250563,
-0.0196115691,
0.0017593482,
0.0546603985,
-0.6754478812,
0.4333378971,
-0.1890107393,
0.53535676,
-0.7475618124,
0.7434927225,
0.5452446342,
-0.2699839175,
-0.9450803399,
-0.4197103977,
-0.2406744212,
-0.3541140854,
0.5903913379,
0.2480894029,
0.0248015113,
0.0033367502,
-0.619309783,
-0.4651989639,
0.7964246273,
0.3651914001,
-0.7538258433,
0.086354956,
0.7191081047,
0.594994843,
-0.5186309218,
-0.0013741689,
0.7451896071,
0.6963077784,
0.1217992306,
-0.5155503154,
0.0863788649,
-0.1494470686,
-0.17523624,
0.2506838739,
-0.1382095963,
0.481249541,
-0.1708814502,
0.0251021069,
-0.4407256544,
0.7267970443,
0.3219169378,
0.5233610272,
0.5143302679,
0.80592978,
0.3878326416,
-0.4125598371,
0.476249814,
0.0037534353,
0.250140667,
1.2120773792,
-0.2945467532,
0.5411080718,
0.3190587163,
-0.0075108511,
0.4410633445,
0.5060622096,
-0.4089259207,
0.3122270703,
0.2747247219,
0.0451647379,
-0.6990170479,
-0.0248062424,
-0.1620300859,
0.7201119065,
0.5002367496,
0.076227285,
-0.4838390946,
0.0437384658,
0.0175273418,
0.3578420579,
-0.3408938348,
0.7857261896,
-0.1462852359,
-0.564994514,
0.2674942911,
-0.1816132665,
0.0114877261,
-0.3460628092,
-0.109631598,
-0.2118423432,
0.1780785471,
-0.3190336227,
-0.8006427884,
0.3832058311,
-0.0272943974,
0.1839778423,
-0.0444738232,
0.7141479254,
-0.6252641678,
-0.501961112,
-0.0229626242,
0.7143114805,
-0.1017563343,
-0.3594022095,
-0.8280110955,
-0.2080189884,
0.0966807082,
-0.3608219028,
0.3563944697,
0.6595021486,
-0.1420245022,
0.79832232,
0.9901801348,
-0.1242731586,
-0.2816213369,
0.091845192,
1.1282687187,
-0.5816287994,
-0.507353425,
-0.8234404922,
0.4643609822,
-0.1569932252,
-0.1081516668,
0.4029078782,
0.9859761,
0.8215563297,
-0.3985174298,
0.5805174708,
0.2442004085,
0.4875775576,
-0.525533855,
0.5676506758,
-0.5067156553,
0.0730104297,
-0.406509161,
-1.1297109127,
-0.7669198513,
0.8555066586,
-0.3054158688,
-0.0305446815,
0.4319084287,
0.5937079787,
-0.1831791401,
0.0082422905,
0.1353293955,
0.0708023831,
0.3632667959,
0.4778990746,
0.7223525643,
-0.047912024,
0.6950998306,
-0.4240388572,
-0.180958733,
-0.2871599495,
-0.7883038521,
-0.9759619832,
-0.5242913365,
-0.2075922191,
-0.1160709187,
-0.0921802223,
1.2676625252,
0.6900433898,
-0.617252171,
-0.247968778,
-0.3915891647,
-0.0637825504,
-0.0804130808,
-0.2701292038,
0.5371923447,
-0.1184879467,
-0.2552261651,
0.272254318,
0.467734009,
0.1566419899,
-0.099015668,
0.3546257615,
-0.1622573882,
-0.2173963934,
0.6739363074,
0.5107113719,
-0.3397320807,
-0.155831486,
-0.0007170583,
0.0435930714,
0.3297763467,
0.8442636728,
-0.6468878984,
0.4990358353,
0.4160582423,
0.6984798908,
0.8981100321,
0.4590711296,
0.3123589456,
-0.6663401127,
0.0170912724,
0.5046881437,
0.4158928394,
0.2276375443,
-0.4168708026,
0.7319540381,
0.2505593002,
-0.7507920265,
-0.9351296425,
0.2101137787,
-1.4260877371,
-0.2636951506,
0.7565348744,
0.1672776043,
-0.4123110771,
-0.3477306962,
-0.2645136714,
0.4988047183,
-0.4722166061,
1.1517778635,
-0.0551316366,
-0.7317131758,
0.0013330436,
-0.3380592167,
0.7059719563,
0.2109109908,
-1.4390612841,
0.2766491771,
0.6277424097,
-0.0408080183,
0.0802561492,
0.1575303823,
0.0894821584,
0.1444750428,
-0.2695577741,
0.3774164319,
-0.4935798049,
-0.7369952202,
0.3560886681,
0.190835312,
-0.4620309174,
0.0180287901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10087v1 | Hybrid Rule-Neural Coreference Resolution System based on Actor-Critic Learning | 2022-12-20T08:55:47 | 2022-12-20T08:55:47 | Yu Wang, Hongxia Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL | A coreference resolution system is to cluster all mentions that refer to the
same entity in a given context. All coreference resolution systems need to
tackle two main tasks: one task is to detect all of the potential mentions, and
the other is to learn the linking of an antecedent for each possible mention.
In this paper, we propose a hybrid rule-neural coreference resolution system
based on actor-critic learning, such that it can achieve better coreference
performance by leveraging the advantages from both the heuristic rules and a
neural conference model. This end-to-end system can also perform both mention
detection and resolution by leveraging a joint training algorithm. We
experiment on the BERT model to generate input span representations. Our model
with the BERT span representation achieves the state-of-the-art performance
among the models on the CoNLL-2012 Shared Task English Test Set. | [
-0.7350206971,
-0.4362027049,
0.3571068943,
-0.1680620313,
-0.5878497362,
0.2267156392,
-0.8027361631,
-0.8217068911,
0.711640656,
0.1518663913,
-0.5386192203,
-0.1451809704,
-0.7377288938,
0.0930722579,
-0.2615267634,
1.2463570833,
0.1181940734,
0.1601981074,
-0.3044672906,
-0.0464980155,
-0.2561466992,
-0.6236626506,
-0.5991895795,
-0.7010150552,
0.5377256274,
0.4127062261,
0.3852036893,
0.2300335169,
0.48421067,
0.3181785941,
-0.2752162516,
0.4965090454,
-0.0624822117,
-0.0467333496,
-0.5732426643,
-0.1778760999,
-0.3254310489,
0.0692992285,
0.5302016139,
0.5453206301,
0.1850016117,
-0.0873331279,
0.0029065183,
0.0074010435,
-0.5532653332,
0.1728723496,
-0.68341887,
-0.140046522,
0.0538720787,
-0.1047102287,
-0.4405229092,
-0.1642519087,
0.2605877221,
-0.4097592831,
0.2142723203,
0.2860205173,
0.9714977741,
-0.0945027396,
-0.2378842086,
-0.0559059083,
-0.6820759773,
0.5921157002,
-0.6554394364,
-0.0073446888,
0.1687939763,
0.2431848943,
0.2154890597,
-0.4854784608,
-0.8050366044,
-0.3584005535,
-0.3740588725,
-0.0190936588,
-0.2255838364,
0.3010708094,
0.00006103,
0.3524529934,
-0.2424857616,
0.2978904247,
-0.2689853609,
-0.3992116451,
0.5254153609,
-0.2007112503,
0.064254947,
-0.2257821262,
-0.4194197059,
0.0708542466,
-0.3559947014,
-0.052102644,
-0.0544044226,
0.4237452447,
0.2161750048,
0.1430522054,
0.014443025,
0.308506161,
0.580109477,
-0.0968596414,
0.035604503,
-0.1318538189,
-0.0860286802,
0.3323180079,
0.7290015817,
0.4073585868,
0.44291991,
-0.5569750667,
-0.2084648907,
0.5124960542,
0.2545682192,
-0.3764679432,
0.114729695,
-0.2743017375,
-0.3053595722,
-0.0981244445,
-0.0390851572,
-0.3428866863,
-0.5383620262,
-0.4855022132,
0.6315919757,
-0.7101441026,
-0.5355677605,
-0.2812759578,
-0.17083022,
0.0355909243,
0.369409591,
-0.7479252815,
0.7781788707,
0.538150847,
0.5338857174,
-0.0812817365,
-0.47908023,
-0.3504497707,
-0.0891869813,
-0.224264577,
1.1210045815,
-0.4474350214,
-0.4481835663,
-0.1697066724,
-0.4009183347,
-0.2932647467,
-0.7720133066,
0.5510825515,
-0.3694576025,
-0.0845888853,
-0.3221085966,
-0.7062067986,
-0.2112502456,
0.5105016232,
-0.5557078719,
0.9349329472,
-0.2593507171,
-0.497194171,
0.2931883633,
-0.4114027917,
-0.5523347855,
0.2761025429,
-0.3425777853,
-0.0367915854,
-0.0429391861,
0.1913214177,
0.6957244873,
-0.4563643932,
0.6274470091,
-0.0153671,
-0.4932152033,
0.0911865234,
0.1961136609,
0.1923924983,
-0.190254271,
-0.378023535,
0.6283932924,
-0.5699310899,
-0.2107545435,
-0.1103943288,
-0.1985541433,
-0.3688433766,
0.0143841859,
-0.0910517648,
0.3248712122,
0.2470472902,
-0.789357841,
-0.069871068,
0.0041010343,
0.1841718256,
0.6072989106,
-0.0532402694,
0.5863601565,
-0.4672942162,
0.0529200695,
0.2315831035,
-0.1324261874,
-0.0717257559,
-0.2779360414,
-1.0176693201,
-0.1140369624,
0.2742540538,
0.3212692738,
-0.6083167195,
0.8468729258,
-0.2768644989,
-0.4874914587,
-0.3315626681,
-0.1036636755,
0.5485655069,
0.559663415,
0.4657453895,
-0.241839394,
-0.9744138718,
-1.1239800453,
-0.1995137632,
-0.4150263369,
0.3412458599,
0.4496813118,
0.6574815512,
0.1563262194,
0.7937202454,
-0.0758348107,
-0.3840563297,
-0.6211224794,
0.3395938575,
0.1486995816,
0.5655721426,
0.4449128807,
-0.55328089,
-0.3113529682,
0.0067466381,
-0.3612388968,
0.0857044831,
0.0512456521,
-0.1176442429,
-0.0368104577,
0.5426815748,
-0.4415448308,
0.1744429171,
0.3216394186,
-0.4084168971,
0.9633815289,
0.0741273016,
-0.0448088758,
-1.2848390341,
0.2224680036,
0.3283388317,
-0.5621870756,
-0.2887918353,
0.0457108505,
-0.0646741912,
0.1136368141,
-0.0784322843,
0.2462727726,
-0.2202283889,
0.0326070897,
-0.4636416435,
0.0956788361,
-0.2420689315,
0.9686086774,
0.4453239441,
0.5788648725,
0.3118318915,
-0.7482687235,
0.4813076854,
-0.0016793259,
-0.4085084498,
0.8057574034,
-0.3030427098,
0.1527605057,
-0.0259244926,
0.5448173881,
-0.9171310663,
0.0837229937,
0.0048580752,
-0.5258939266,
0.1891358197,
0.2241167724,
-0.5955664515,
-0.2636155188,
0.0655281991,
0.1730322093,
0.4308533967,
-0.7066253424,
0.85341084,
0.3110024631,
0.0612369813,
-0.5840938091,
-0.3535145223,
0.0915347338,
0.2290989012,
-0.3303895295,
0.9618163109,
0.0899638534,
-0.0924092084,
0.315295428,
-0.1195993945,
-0.0485025682,
-0.2488441914,
0.1962080151,
0.3753950894,
-0.041314967,
0.2159594297,
-0.116096653,
-0.0248515029,
0.0998557433,
-0.2377785593,
0.5911716819,
-0.3478167653,
0.1502549946,
-0.3110693395,
0.7668145895,
0.4461793005,
-0.4051885009,
0.5417635441,
0.465036124,
-0.7070871592,
-0.4389036,
-0.7100057602,
-0.4041412473,
-0.3462765813,
0.3547040224,
-0.2518531978,
-0.9381318092,
0.6200161576,
-0.4244224429,
0.021543216,
0.6212415695,
0.6355928779,
-0.2903290987,
0.3697283864,
0.6690694094,
-0.1473598331,
0.5176000595,
-0.3219354451,
0.1823181361,
-1.1357086897,
-0.37690413,
-0.6030698419,
-0.7315444946,
0.0759689733,
-0.4248752892,
0.3066991568,
0.0824391022,
-0.1458696872,
0.6514434218,
-0.3791193366,
0.3578090668,
0.879134655,
0.4772478342,
0.2974426448,
-0.3546393514,
-0.8720728159,
-0.0579489768,
-0.4068042338,
-0.1914196163,
0.300078094,
0.0586497523,
0.3650828302,
0.1848136783,
0.69077003,
0.4412606657,
0.2736956775,
-0.8589250445,
0.9783716202,
-0.2537661195,
-0.7869186401,
0.1015811265,
-0.1271689236,
-0.3312835991,
0.2560420036,
-0.3822259009,
-0.9510399103,
0.4033524394,
0.0322495662,
-0.5858396888,
0.6551254392,
-0.3561219871,
0.4791817963,
0.2467830479,
-0.2745967209,
-0.5825467706,
-0.5400813222,
0.3606808782,
0.415673852,
-0.1016276404,
-0.1134543344,
0.3178991079,
1.027772069,
-0.2233419418,
1.2556313276,
-0.0135494126,
0.3329559565,
0.539290905,
0.1685173213,
0.3875160217,
-0.1555652171,
0.2178388089,
-0.1663543135,
-0.2102018893,
0.0458362699,
-0.3879109621,
0.6834571958,
-0.8467605114,
-0.3588111401,
-0.49317801,
-0.4884899557,
-0.2331958264,
0.0966925547,
0.3280798495,
0.2258062363,
-0.3723783791,
0.0421210416,
0.5128819346,
0.1952430606,
0.7938674092,
0.5299530029,
0.0182325523,
-0.5219453573,
0.5560264587,
0.0883276537,
-0.0243807621,
0.3049199879,
-0.0155188767,
-0.2805029452,
-0.225443244,
-0.3076488972,
0.4254468083,
-0.767467916,
-0.4555841684,
-0.445112139,
-0.4472584128,
-0.4239650369,
-0.1466189772,
-0.369777143,
-0.2238897085,
-0.1432643235,
-0.2226994783,
0.274551481,
0.5662375689,
-0.1962147206,
0.3767417669,
-0.4813616276,
-0.073493354,
0.2534511387,
0.4374096394,
0.2074153274,
-0.5738679767,
-0.3977257609,
-0.5050656199,
-0.3172800541,
-0.7568796873,
0.0319961198,
0.3770325184,
0.5271334648,
0.3649004996,
0.1546135545,
0.5779522657,
-0.5252940655,
0.6899355054,
0.4455375373,
-1.1282713413,
0.37994349,
-0.1139040291,
0.1309889257,
0.628964901,
0.3215780854,
-0.9294400215,
-0.1147056967,
-0.6867361069,
-0.550572753,
0.5280074477,
-0.2395727932,
-0.0371640511,
-0.0762774646,
0.3921676874,
0.1594029665,
0.1303701848,
-0.611068666,
0.0904096067,
0.3916314542,
0.055414848,
-0.1125995889,
-0.1997089386,
-0.0804940388,
-0.4349052906,
0.7994118333,
-0.3322431743,
0.5441660285,
0.3976418674,
-0.2127531618,
-0.3357631862,
0.3885975778,
0.4931699038,
0.3666641712,
-0.3030935824,
0.3181964457,
0.1516484767,
-0.172796607,
-0.0181256458,
0.2267649919,
0.1770147532,
0.2360051572,
0.6187517047,
0.8188283443,
0.5557503104,
-0.5568010211,
0.3819771707,
0.2167925388,
-0.5469167233,
-0.3580556214,
-0.0054277657,
0.2788021266,
0.3005561531,
0.5206439495,
0.7097880244,
-0.0987109169,
-0.6603876352,
0.5752876401,
0.1171592996,
-0.3722476661,
-0.3224280477,
0.2462199628,
0.6580575705,
-0.1682451367,
0.4255004525,
-0.187280342,
-1.0791978836,
0.5193771124,
0.6294649243,
0.8100794554,
-0.2267530411,
0.1637864411,
0.6027734876,
0.1748507768,
0.1274701357,
0.3055731058,
-0.4187780023,
-1.1472961903,
-0.722224474,
-0.3936885893,
-0.6043476462,
0.0398992896,
-0.8246490955,
0.1593587697,
-0.9838465452,
-0.2639315128,
0.231558755,
0.2613217533,
-0.4497657418,
0.3218844235,
0.5363237262,
1.0124678612,
-0.7747215629,
0.809787035,
0.9926041365,
-0.4592141509,
-0.814874053,
-0.3732571602,
-0.1148530021,
-0.436167568,
0.4864307642,
0.1858052611,
-0.1683636755,
0.0088791242,
-0.3261794746,
-0.6705220938,
0.8717409372,
0.2156834304,
-0.701533854,
-0.3451066315,
-0.4740512669,
0.4660173655,
-0.6074628234,
0.3685337901,
0.5673167109,
0.1897172481,
0.1519884169,
-1.4500197172,
0.0986902788,
-0.5124183297,
-0.2469013035,
0.2135588825,
-0.839437902,
0.8745343685,
-0.1024353281,
-0.0137882754,
-0.1603318453,
0.9102640152,
0.1219975203,
0.0202385783,
0.8380092978,
0.6568644047,
0.5262535214,
-0.1172071397,
0.7531667948,
-0.1784417927,
0.3594764769,
1.2882945538,
-0.4161738157,
0.9901980758,
0.4232756495,
0.0365430862,
0.8550143242,
0.639003396,
0.0972369239,
0.4698107243,
0.2039926946,
-0.6044191718,
-0.5103515387,
-0.7023445368,
-0.0177375022,
0.3298563361,
0.5547754169,
-0.6557596922,
-0.610099256,
-0.064042531,
0.1260370463,
0.462274909,
-0.5882611275,
1.0279397964,
0.045641657,
-1.1103525162,
0.3307637274,
0.1332914233,
1.1191846132,
-0.5315645933,
0.0005677427,
0.0208428036,
0.5060177445,
-0.1411623359,
-0.4126900733,
0.2741639912,
0.0546223037,
-0.4613448679,
0.0229498092,
0.9604213238,
-0.483441323,
-0.2402633429,
0.7055323124,
0.3343872428,
-0.0422560908,
-0.0687997118,
-0.4286615849,
-0.1058793291,
-0.3481500447,
0.2033126205,
0.1112337783,
-0.0385366976,
-0.068845205,
0.2291236073,
0.2418999821,
0.1584909856,
0.0471916832,
0.1132566482,
1.1410262585,
-0.6884799004,
-0.6969794631,
-0.614916563,
0.3545407355,
-0.3797589242,
-0.5621650219,
0.1064308435,
0.2242656648,
0.7887318134,
0.1720597595,
0.8807091117,
-0.3876613379,
0.7352964282,
-0.0939183459,
0.3442168832,
-0.2833646238,
-0.1989287138,
-0.1912232935,
-0.7374923229,
-0.3926368952,
0.5656031966,
-0.3473105133,
0.1148179322,
1.0265511274,
0.4729009867,
-0.0256806165,
0.3162429631,
0.4713804424,
-0.0195410084,
0.2132144421,
0.8080824018,
0.6335589886,
-0.2507683635,
0.4849641323,
-0.4318790734,
-0.2381911427,
-0.466235131,
-0.7038220763,
-0.9281778336,
-0.9299730659,
-0.297622025,
-0.6039538383,
0.189306885,
1.4462012053,
0.9233486652,
-0.7735806704,
-0.284648031,
0.1017627791,
-0.3386352062,
-0.7259515524,
-0.1581208557,
0.3685337901,
-0.4248227477,
-0.7591875196,
0.3981865942,
-0.0117545351,
-0.5498881936,
-0.2508800924,
-0.0365937725,
-0.8238591552,
0.0400622711,
0.4489328861,
0.129449144,
-0.78898561,
-0.3480557799,
-0.2128859758,
-0.2755503356,
-0.0354904532,
1.1573640108,
-0.9669379592,
0.2179605663,
0.2771480978,
0.7683176398,
0.4534284174,
-0.1761446148,
0.5254579186,
-0.9257227182,
0.0388097726,
0.5851180553,
0.6654919982,
0.1556539834,
-0.4638574421,
0.275898993,
0.4969539344,
-0.3386345208,
-0.3698754311,
0.1566513926,
-1.1359266043,
-0.3194859624,
0.8913497925,
-0.2523173988,
-0.3366678059,
0.0746186078,
-0.3757507205,
0.4082186222,
-0.6036724448,
0.4638507366,
0.9492995739,
-0.1950638443,
-0.6008094549,
0.2440627217,
0.2532697618,
0.6375068426,
-0.2895974517,
-0.0627666488,
0.3082203865,
0.3387307823,
0.6956186295,
0.5761306286,
0.0625890791,
0.6822764874,
-0.0425392278,
0.6470540762,
-0.1138837188,
-0.5536480546,
-0.0297884643,
0.1042827293,
-0.0138896657,
-0.2081165314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10080v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10080v1 | Rumour detection using graph neural network and oversampling in benchmark Twitter dataset | 2022-12-20T08:43:10 | 2022-12-20T08:43:10 | Shaswat Patel, Prince Bansal, Preeti Kaur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently, online social media has become a primary source for new information
and misinformation or rumours. In the absence of an automatic rumour detection
system the propagation of rumours has increased manifold leading to serious
societal damages. In this work, we propose a novel method for building
automatic rumour detection system by focusing on oversampling to alleviating
the fundamental challenges of class imbalance in rumour detection task. Our
oversampling method relies on contextualised data augmentation to generate
synthetic samples for underrepresented classes in the dataset. The key idea
exploits selection of tweets in a thread for augmentation which can be achieved
by introducing a non-random selection criteria to focus the augmentation
process on relevant tweets. Furthermore, we propose two graph neural
networks(GNN) to model non-linear conversations on a thread. To enhance the
tweet representations in our method we employed a custom feature selection
technique based on state-of-the-art BERTweet model. Experiments of three
publicly available datasets confirm that 1) our GNN models outperform the the
current state-of-the-art classifiers by more than 20%(F1-score); 2) our
oversampling technique increases the model performance by more than
9%;(F1-score) 3) focusing on relevant tweets for data augmentation via
non-random selection criteria can further improve the results; and 4) our
method has superior capabilities to detect rumours at very early stage. | [
-0.7342593074,
-0.8061506748,
0.1911218762,
0.0889875442,
-0.5446139574,
0.3418750167,
-0.1616653353,
-0.9675019979,
0.784850359,
0.3382487595,
-0.5186864138,
-0.2145953625,
-0.7542296052,
-0.1672445685,
-0.707393229,
1.0731096268,
0.0842556059,
-0.086217612,
0.028984433,
-0.3071132898,
-0.309610039,
-0.4070032537,
-0.5415750742,
-0.3644173443,
0.5081771612,
0.0827311575,
0.5669717789,
0.1388762891,
-0.055040203,
0.2733214796,
0.0014184843,
0.6735052466,
-0.5515724421,
0.2660881579,
0.0919146016,
-0.1335268617,
-0.049448885,
-0.0226477068,
0.4570203125,
0.4794577956,
-0.0180585887,
0.457190752,
0.089505069,
0.5989732742,
-0.685746491,
0.4349072874,
-1.0039174557,
-0.01817015,
-0.2252507508,
-0.1495748758,
-0.0973020792,
-0.458768487,
0.0493820123,
-0.3829775155,
0.2110776603,
0.2876068652,
0.9063589573,
-0.131416887,
0.0229105148,
-0.1921200305,
-0.5668759942,
0.438436538,
-0.6460973024,
0.1017620042,
0.1216324717,
0.5604966879,
0.1001433879,
-0.4648116529,
-0.3844943643,
-0.1424939483,
-0.1742648184,
0.0986569896,
-0.4994380474,
-0.2606432736,
0.2631275952,
0.1609191149,
-0.3850788474,
-0.0408654436,
-0.5511297584,
-0.3374325931,
0.5110448003,
-0.2099881768,
0.0455378443,
-0.1448681206,
-0.3013792336,
0.2991133034,
-0.0828742534,
-0.2873754203,
0.7247174382,
0.3089767992,
0.2258214504,
0.3996091187,
-0.159745127,
0.5252165794,
0.3003168106,
0.0019321067,
0.3834517002,
0.084713079,
-0.0944772139,
0.5497567654,
0.6241085529,
0.704146266,
0.5936049819,
-0.4746610522,
-0.2010053843,
0.4608625472,
0.1857979745,
-0.6903240681,
-0.0920047238,
0.1679467559,
-0.4225605428,
-0.6941102743,
-0.0460611507,
-0.8462452292,
-0.550774157,
-0.1161796451,
0.2407398224,
-0.4926725626,
-0.4238495529,
-0.187871024,
-0.5481241941,
-0.3037471771,
0.5326513648,
-0.6533766389,
0.1986421645,
0.5275917649,
0.6620725989,
-0.0869429782,
-0.2195631117,
-0.0976569429,
0.3520260155,
-0.4980503917,
1.0768591166,
-0.3758009672,
-0.0914984271,
-0.0681543127,
-0.2877043188,
0.0019363057,
-0.4251941442,
0.680193603,
-0.5692717433,
0.3344390392,
-0.1267865896,
-0.5118307471,
-0.1535178125,
0.5341508985,
-0.7284847498,
1.167098403,
0.2869347632,
-1.1009614468,
0.6511022449,
-0.38199687,
-0.7247311473,
-0.1029551178,
0.1040925309,
-0.5176097751,
0.1256093085,
0.8642718196,
0.0435763188,
-0.2758835554,
0.2097747922,
-0.4262240827,
-0.4514770508,
0.3042852283,
-0.7111433744,
0.6745254993,
0.0974985361,
-0.2925724685,
-0.0035881794,
-0.5836901665,
0.3475404382,
-0.1584637463,
0.1464225054,
-0.1503582299,
-0.3275713623,
-0.0083546955,
0.3021461964,
-0.1396540105,
-0.7872033119,
0.1887446493,
-0.3185331225,
0.560641408,
0.4073358774,
0.1613886356,
0.1963464171,
-0.8224012256,
0.2376959026,
0.1589353234,
0.0970618278,
-0.0852039754,
-0.6033517122,
-0.5939695835,
0.0592627525,
0.4696785212,
0.4212569892,
-0.7675840855,
0.4091792405,
-0.2340637147,
-0.4139994681,
-0.8640495539,
-0.002560921,
-0.203832522,
0.6186028123,
0.3589173853,
-0.2104996294,
-0.9984877706,
-0.5411613584,
-0.3450164497,
-0.4180837274,
-0.0587742031,
0.2889067233,
-0.0081755752,
-0.1111244857,
1.0488516092,
-0.3252582848,
-0.5933549404,
-0.3751322627,
0.3872179985,
0.1873403192,
0.1768848598,
0.9338264465,
-0.5698842406,
-0.4130697548,
-0.3118631244,
-0.5859720707,
-0.2380660176,
0.0626824796,
-0.0629451871,
0.6353996992,
0.31795609,
-0.6559717655,
0.5599253774,
0.1533339322,
0.0253996663,
0.4866001606,
0.145928219,
0.2366317958,
-0.9191389084,
-0.2006111741,
0.1727801561,
-0.4723421335,
-0.3009789586,
-0.3473030329,
-0.1859700233,
-0.0732303262,
-0.0574709252,
0.3296069801,
-0.3773899972,
-0.0466065928,
-0.6866696477,
0.3614806533,
0.1912788302,
0.2458302677,
-0.0948902294,
0.265260458,
0.6422544718,
-0.1405726075,
0.6020447612,
-0.1037921533,
-0.3726480007,
0.540525794,
-0.2184719294,
-0.0465297475,
-0.3985711038,
0.6504060626,
-1.2538727522,
-0.014431647,
0.5130416751,
-0.9180622101,
0.1785253584,
-0.3968963027,
-0.6183503866,
-0.9908356667,
-0.3690390587,
-0.0907063261,
0.5978010297,
-0.4957019091,
0.4699826837,
0.4319241345,
0.2248564959,
-0.415794909,
-0.810726285,
0.3106000721,
-0.2623324096,
-0.8094043732,
0.0689950362,
0.3409723043,
-0.0444885865,
0.1298873723,
-0.4567094743,
-0.0817310512,
-0.3392340839,
0.229217574,
0.215994224,
-0.3701404333,
0.0243299287,
-0.2033550292,
-0.2589055002,
0.3166845739,
-0.762763381,
0.5447857976,
0.1085731313,
-0.1810968667,
-0.3606925309,
0.1221087798,
0.5679124594,
0.1448561847,
0.8561583161,
1.0652316809,
-0.5085103512,
-0.3990592957,
-1.0516068935,
-0.3825874925,
-0.4650961757,
0.2304853499,
0.0671956837,
-0.3537877202,
0.6284745932,
-0.1465988755,
-0.3317678869,
0.5756704807,
0.2136246115,
-0.0931165665,
0.8792954087,
0.2442327738,
-0.7274720073,
0.3766314387,
-0.4599238634,
0.2416077107,
-0.4549102187,
0.0290166587,
-0.1865543276,
-0.5606309175,
-0.4645314217,
-0.4171800315,
0.0680849329,
-0.0258104671,
0.202699855,
0.1470751315,
-0.5984925032,
0.4138061404,
0.5282320976,
0.327519089,
0.1825489104,
0.4063745737,
-0.0553123392,
-0.1494310498,
-0.7861179709,
-0.043299567,
0.9235616922,
0.3090629578,
0.6870415211,
-0.3013356328,
0.2978645265,
0.5623053312,
0.629910171,
-0.5841246843,
0.2868482471,
0.1091583371,
-0.7917729616,
-0.4979946911,
-0.3752933741,
-0.4730904102,
0.198446542,
-0.2918755114,
-0.8732129931,
0.000451595,
-0.0726695433,
-0.0653357506,
0.8925443888,
-0.3317808807,
0.2831828296,
-0.1015102714,
-0.1441566795,
-0.2315995097,
-0.6050543189,
0.4077725112,
-0.1028195322,
0.2924962938,
-0.3137606382,
0.3107024133,
0.5282984376,
-0.6165225506,
0.7638725638,
-0.4026253819,
0.1652850062,
0.7911310792,
-0.3192857504,
0.7397722602,
0.0790531412,
-0.4275767505,
0.2959745526,
-0.4294054806,
-0.2931895256,
-0.5439873338,
0.5867094994,
-0.6861157417,
-0.373496592,
-0.5000129938,
-0.5494275689,
-0.2898551822,
0.0524883345,
0.5771234632,
0.3400900364,
0.0130025772,
0.0702808276,
0.1346239895,
0.3285252452,
0.4949668646,
0.4889061749,
-0.261243552,
-0.6192811728,
0.7529364824,
0.5484675765,
0.0952778533,
-0.0674487203,
0.2576107085,
-0.2887500525,
-0.6184336543,
-0.6391017437,
-0.2411055267,
-0.6338338256,
-0.437242806,
-0.6186203361,
-0.9053917527,
-0.5139330029,
-0.0457392298,
-0.2233998775,
-0.5261525512,
0.0931047499,
-0.182798177,
0.5652586818,
0.5890840292,
-0.1851029396,
0.4050302207,
-0.5438795686,
0.5007377863,
0.1386867017,
0.3843326271,
0.3450277448,
-0.6090062261,
-0.1107384488,
0.3048608899,
-0.3343999088,
-0.643027246,
0.4870328903,
0.0182134286,
0.5998619795,
0.624512732,
0.3557755351,
0.8389434218,
-0.2364142388,
0.3616346419,
0.1853366047,
-0.5152353048,
0.366684407,
-0.4132550359,
-0.098340258,
0.5489773154,
0.2983539104,
-0.5179371834,
-0.7104936838,
-0.9075552225,
-0.8999758959,
0.7238724232,
0.5436688066,
-0.0033007641,
0.0389958248,
0.1291280091,
0.1910260469,
0.6384601593,
-0.6797161698,
-0.486513257,
-0.3249460757,
0.0963245034,
0.1106079668,
-0.2998668849,
0.0351891629,
-0.5408400297,
0.7583874464,
-0.0279861987,
0.2570159435,
-0.0350911506,
-0.0695324764,
-0.7424613237,
-0.0183158889,
0.1586794704,
0.9479030967,
-0.529125452,
-0.1625861824,
0.3733553886,
-0.4782497287,
-0.0430192389,
0.4658901989,
-0.3333295286,
0.6668897271,
0.2610162795,
0.8286390901,
0.1923805624,
-0.0866503865,
0.381211549,
0.0088068452,
-0.2869725227,
-0.5207394361,
-0.1099572331,
-0.0287654568,
0.3196628988,
0.8188124299,
0.562522471,
-0.016640434,
-0.6859184504,
0.3992980719,
0.3785342872,
-0.3785076439,
-0.0099349581,
0.7068130374,
-0.0328053124,
0.0045667798,
0.3809289634,
-0.2786288857,
-0.6700861454,
0.6913371682,
0.598264575,
0.7149935961,
-0.0737371072,
0.3681218326,
0.3308699429,
0.4823989272,
-0.2380290031,
0.1430003345,
0.0181047972,
-0.7596318722,
-0.2437611371,
-0.5516203046,
-0.2626480758,
0.479151845,
-0.3678979874,
0.4347795248,
-0.2731057703,
-0.2566228807,
0.1800381541,
0.1700053364,
-0.2391179055,
0.1822895706,
0.4270722568,
0.8803409338,
-0.7730400562,
0.9003454447,
0.4327627718,
-0.2421133518,
-0.7198526263,
0.384047538,
-0.0511934049,
-0.8786563873,
0.4261661768,
0.410808742,
0.313005209,
-0.1142609715,
-0.2984501719,
-0.9409173131,
0.8424549699,
0.471716851,
-0.5191228986,
-0.1199859679,
0.2946789265,
0.5298155546,
-0.5324842334,
0.5938392282,
0.2397294343,
0.6380230784,
0.8570844531,
-0.8857683539,
-0.0421838947,
0.011605205,
-0.3570614159,
0.2407644689,
-0.7324874401,
0.7761193514,
-0.0833347142,
0.2214600444,
0.0083648637,
0.5156251192,
0.1939514279,
0.6849766374,
0.7744518518,
0.5520190001,
0.8222403526,
-0.1951797754,
0.7733626962,
-0.5757723451,
0.285425365,
0.9197822809,
-0.2420384139,
0.4417383373,
0.0662450567,
-0.1206101626,
0.4442521334,
0.6608681083,
-0.209964022,
0.4932862818,
0.5123587251,
0.0194380786,
-0.1989499182,
-0.0966022536,
-0.6010366678,
0.1194563955,
0.652764082,
-0.4531344473,
-0.7052090168,
0.1827067882,
-0.1023379862,
-0.3160574138,
-0.6573339105,
0.5924832225,
-0.0500981659,
-0.5730825663,
0.6412710547,
-0.1292131692,
0.7737411857,
-0.467808485,
0.2497622967,
0.0364620015,
0.2218806744,
-0.2595209181,
-0.6295188069,
0.3079396188,
-0.3106989563,
-0.0832966715,
-0.1147881448,
1.4264036417,
-0.5359196067,
-0.8137011528,
0.529856801,
0.5226245522,
0.0985614657,
-0.4540694356,
-0.612370491,
-0.0750587061,
-0.1373039484,
-0.0133381579,
0.1012766659,
0.7064676285,
-0.2309724241,
0.4944928586,
0.5201817751,
0.3165087402,
-0.1197771505,
0.3654016554,
1.3611444235,
-0.3747003973,
-0.8466726542,
-0.8650537729,
0.0293701757,
-0.5424886346,
0.0758963674,
1.0448783636,
0.6757363677,
0.5430459976,
0.1602099836,
0.9840711951,
0.1552633345,
0.8286057115,
-0.0625191405,
0.8876004219,
0.0130872913,
0.3123459518,
-0.6394534707,
-0.8208714724,
0.0144438157,
0.4348893166,
-0.4657359123,
0.1736842692,
0.5399207473,
0.4489142299,
-0.1703804284,
0.5735659003,
0.1284933686,
0.3175424933,
-0.1333785206,
0.1236787513,
0.765252769,
-0.4996567965,
0.8058667183,
-0.2605612576,
0.1333255321,
-0.7153019905,
-0.8002094626,
-1.2956870794,
-0.101843223,
-0.3722888231,
-0.6920151114,
0.4879610538,
0.7682203054,
0.8547620773,
-0.9547322989,
0.0903915688,
-0.0605252385,
0.2217657119,
-0.1970211565,
-0.2527827322,
0.2432932854,
-0.3419486582,
-0.1501387209,
0.1118712649,
0.0269231219,
0.0577290393,
-0.3309989274,
0.2344256192,
-0.2109079957,
0.0767258778,
0.3966824114,
0.1549423933,
-0.3348577321,
-0.350985527,
-0.3997246325,
0.1442657709,
0.267550379,
0.6657945514,
-1.2372267246,
0.0733737275,
0.3325991035,
0.3880415261,
0.8537592292,
0.3389092982,
0.4213338792,
-1.0625398159,
0.4800763428,
0.1777679175,
0.3395908773,
0.2310501933,
-0.6154180765,
0.3775343299,
0.4679032564,
-0.262129277,
-0.8043677807,
-0.3631922901,
-0.6072484255,
-0.4540562928,
0.9631615281,
0.2492931634,
-0.4209347665,
-0.3154507875,
-0.3118692636,
0.2881510258,
-0.8805812001,
1.1418305635,
0.7370374203,
0.0275463611,
0.1336564422,
-0.5846987367,
0.3856108189,
-0.1297384053,
-0.4946821034,
-0.0684626251,
0.3119525611,
0.2902699113,
0.2598150969,
0.5160965919,
0.1492469758,
0.2389056087,
0.1216622666,
-0.3876612782,
-0.4459490776,
-0.1113206819,
0.2454796135,
0.5380482078,
-0.3194509447,
-0.2715044618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10079v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10079v1 | A Survey on Pretrained Language Models for Neural Code Intelligence | 2022-12-20T08:34:56 | 2022-12-20T08:34:56 | Yichen Xu, Yanqiao Zhu | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG | As the complexity of modern software continues to escalate, software
engineering has become an increasingly daunting and error-prone endeavor. In
recent years, the field of Neural Code Intelligence (NCI) has emerged as a
promising solution, leveraging the power of deep learning techniques to tackle
analytical tasks on source code with the goal of improving programming
efficiency and minimizing human errors within the software industry. Pretrained
language models have become a dominant force in NCI research, consistently
delivering state-of-the-art results across a wide range of tasks, including
code summarization, generation, and translation. In this paper, we present a
comprehensive survey of the NCI domain, including a thorough review of
pretraining techniques, tasks, datasets, and model architectures. We hope this
paper will serve as a bridge between the natural language and programming
language communities, offering insights for future research in this rapidly
evolving field. | [
-0.2961910963,
-0.2682653964,
0.3110809624,
0.2212835997,
0.0619169213,
0.299721688,
-0.4082505107,
-0.3361419141,
0.0858997926,
0.3553271294,
-0.7163407803,
-0.6251969337,
-0.3933273852,
-0.0421861708,
-0.3964020908,
0.8624964952,
0.0900990292,
0.2226106226,
-0.4070268273,
0.0565246306,
-0.6122513413,
-0.9632142782,
-0.3228383064,
-0.2417326868,
0.3796619475,
0.1820538044,
0.2822659314,
0.2011440098,
0.5093061924,
0.2811079323,
0.1472623199,
-0.170874089,
-0.4704564512,
-0.1663064212,
0.2330231071,
-0.7145411372,
-0.7028727531,
0.2351623774,
0.3885554969,
0.8726251721,
-0.1843040735,
0.1880573183,
0.0847088397,
0.71530509,
-0.7381084561,
0.0256949179,
-0.478013128,
0.092249684,
-0.0833651572,
-0.1651632637,
-0.4606870413,
-0.5387946963,
0.0664574429,
-0.7529510856,
0.0906864181,
-0.3283022046,
0.6675825715,
0.49671188,
-0.2671107948,
-0.3889613152,
-0.8408360481,
1.107077837,
-1.0435162783,
0.2849480808,
0.2053460181,
0.2068542093,
-0.0267512444,
-0.7921916246,
-0.4000321329,
-0.4762918949,
0.0272547342,
0.1206587926,
-0.0374747068,
0.1592090577,
0.2010949105,
0.3094606698,
-0.7852647305,
0.3384535611,
-0.3926489949,
-0.0006422629,
0.8169195056,
0.0761611015,
0.7312098742,
0.3037261665,
0.143519491,
0.0129319355,
-0.6815535426,
-0.1931140125,
0.3613789976,
0.2012936324,
-0.1151363403,
0.1724820584,
-0.3448334038,
0.8612917662,
-0.3649868965,
0.3227601647,
0.342448175,
-0.6882255673,
-0.2343967706,
-0.0174121857,
0.6880382299,
0.1824663579,
0.6439070702,
-0.3931056857,
-0.2301250696,
0.1601384431,
0.7344689369,
-0.6965771914,
-0.471360296,
0.2708839476,
-0.584710598,
-0.4522767067,
-0.2164144665,
-0.6000964046,
-0.3511094749,
-0.7406234145,
-0.1394284368,
-0.3300935328,
-0.7066879869,
0.1259943098,
0.1529054046,
0.4758234322,
-0.1332893223,
-0.6936540604,
0.1702842265,
0.941432178,
0.5781617165,
-0.1112649664,
-0.4340455234,
-0.0265187323,
-0.511864543,
-0.5605342984,
0.5522021651,
-0.5097441077,
-0.1570863873,
0.0362334698,
-0.4969283044,
-0.1013118178,
-0.3875113726,
0.0751600862,
-0.8776970506,
-0.1105493456,
0.047021322,
-0.4385242164,
-0.1608438343,
0.5734432936,
-0.5722292066,
0.6396895051,
0.2802269459,
-0.6173703671,
0.1936204582,
-0.7783676386,
-0.3149135709,
0.07802701,
-0.430908829,
-0.2396270931,
0.4261408746,
-0.0364700854,
0.3162455857,
-0.4737617373,
0.6468113661,
-0.3265142143,
-0.3760572672,
0.2976225913,
-0.2822001874,
0.9167433977,
0.3064803779,
-0.1733230501,
0.4186596572,
-0.8137180209,
0.5764142275,
0.0720277503,
-0.1617679,
-0.2504148185,
0.0499158092,
-0.0161425285,
0.3877325356,
0.1625815779,
-0.4166211784,
0.1601993293,
-0.488987118,
0.5379239321,
0.4518627226,
-0.1551564485,
0.5680069327,
0.0251429249,
0.7101117969,
0.0305328425,
0.3180112541,
0.1020758823,
-0.1267721206,
-0.5573071837,
0.1926867217,
0.5686106682,
0.632136941,
-0.8277906775,
0.2543961108,
-0.5639643669,
-0.6456483006,
-0.4503536224,
0.3160821497,
0.5650954247,
-0.0376524404,
0.3002714217,
-0.1364217252,
-0.6127872467,
-0.7688402534,
-0.2386044115,
0.0871198475,
-0.0472428761,
0.2984308004,
0.3314892352,
-0.3623596728,
0.9142843485,
-0.4874055982,
0.0566910841,
-0.6183156967,
0.3965627253,
0.4380018115,
0.7794043422,
0.8339615464,
-0.8549787402,
-0.1495715082,
-0.0741011277,
-0.8781183958,
0.187172547,
-0.2009539455,
-0.1737318933,
-0.2487594187,
0.8467636704,
-0.2997200489,
0.4863198698,
0.5607215166,
-0.0124458196,
0.6279863715,
-0.1629538685,
0.0097930981,
-0.9103348851,
0.4566563666,
-0.2404602617,
0.3542262018,
-1.0344765186,
0.3352768123,
0.0363758504,
-0.1860611737,
-0.3953722119,
0.05654715,
-0.7670753598,
-0.1178153753,
-0.5421033502,
-0.1130968556,
-0.4093183875,
0.638391614,
0.0251640137,
0.7861427665,
0.7099415064,
-0.9338170886,
0.2196692973,
0.1812373847,
-0.4090974331,
0.0377240814,
-0.8793316483,
0.3979779184,
-0.075988166,
-0.2576983571,
-0.4939964116,
-0.1063758507,
-0.1476816088,
-0.7666042447,
0.4273656309,
-0.0430420414,
-0.216224581,
-0.2800066769,
-0.0509161018,
0.8239781857,
0.4292654991,
-0.2212136835,
0.8111149073,
0.4191023409,
-0.0887220204,
-0.8043426871,
-0.7918464541,
0.0302897152,
0.343306601,
-0.2459067404,
0.2532930374,
-0.1692771912,
-0.1395912021,
-0.0588486753,
-0.0604017116,
-0.7375593185,
0.5745115876,
0.2796029747,
0.4083991349,
-0.5882003307,
-0.090050526,
-0.3058713078,
-0.1644775569,
0.4451231062,
-0.3278148174,
0.6798743606,
-0.2538007498,
-0.35984689,
-0.1433668137,
0.3316330016,
0.393039465,
-0.7068581581,
0.5429118872,
0.3693865538,
-0.2386879772,
-0.2642073035,
-0.2956748009,
-0.0355475098,
-0.4338984787,
0.7278814912,
-0.1788608879,
-0.7589982748,
0.2711714804,
-0.2849347293,
0.1253205985,
0.1520848721,
0.1437280774,
0.1502883732,
0.925198853,
1.0658750534,
-0.3341513276,
0.4521976411,
-0.6774465442,
0.4347730875,
-0.6581693292,
-0.0538221709,
-0.6697485447,
-0.2925596535,
-0.3338175714,
-0.0879685953,
-0.1715625823,
0.0457150526,
-0.1989645511,
0.2950670123,
-0.5740001798,
0.8016741872,
0.6859207153,
-0.1177266613,
-0.2499046773,
-0.5293630958,
0.1788100749,
0.2239847332,
-0.8558933735,
-0.273011148,
1.1573406458,
0.1449503303,
0.3506757319,
-0.1391885877,
0.7280058265,
0.0811742991,
0.5339971185,
-0.58939147,
0.5393223763,
-0.1885988265,
-0.5945504308,
-0.0843863487,
-0.5291547775,
-0.5753948092,
-0.4621132016,
-0.2668630779,
-0.2863824368,
0.4405338168,
0.1265401244,
-0.7280925512,
0.2256528437,
-0.6783282161,
1.1973479986,
-0.6402662396,
0.0509190373,
-0.2749246061,
-0.6275289059,
0.4139291346,
-0.1521487236,
-0.1027238145,
-0.029205041,
0.216430217,
0.6222478151,
-0.1654449403,
0.8131874204,
-0.3339956701,
0.2558161914,
0.3898055553,
-0.0997093394,
-0.0037775927,
-0.1174272299,
-0.1581174433,
0.4644507468,
-0.0259698238,
-0.4763858318,
-0.7345201373,
0.6557192802,
-0.7805383801,
-0.1251207292,
-0.4119495451,
-0.3873378932,
-0.3114907742,
0.3895038068,
0.2630014122,
0.6409312487,
-0.3727883399,
0.1043757275,
0.6836646795,
-0.3128550947,
0.6559923887,
0.2048645765,
-0.1486516893,
-0.2503053546,
1.1752963066,
-0.0838541538,
0.0616083704,
0.2131121904,
-0.3995415866,
0.0333586149,
-1.2577385902,
-0.1446560025,
0.0647901744,
-0.4844161272,
-0.2622440457,
-0.4265168607,
-0.5759881735,
-0.5062184334,
-0.1520811021,
-0.5437018871,
0.0483604781,
-0.4353378117,
-0.0339865312,
-0.1236714572,
1.0004230738,
0.3951184154,
0.2637701333,
-0.8765519261,
0.2331626415,
0.2838822305,
0.6901333928,
0.136783585,
-0.0061222161,
-0.4070607126,
0.1184564307,
0.1397670507,
-0.6891964078,
0.4975043535,
0.1284157783,
0.7684058547,
0.122665666,
0.2633035183,
0.4430954158,
-0.4037187994,
0.7394447327,
0.2650944293,
-0.8027766943,
0.488802582,
-0.0679554343,
0.3738482594,
0.9560443759,
0.5408249497,
-0.286911577,
-0.1776542515,
-0.3290191293,
-0.8298387527,
0.5694639683,
0.0778259858,
0.2297846973,
0.0009206884,
0.5896365047,
-0.3012283146,
0.342208147,
-0.6944755912,
-0.0406353995,
-0.3925564289,
-0.523393333,
0.0061895289,
-0.1933452338,
0.3204502761,
-0.2530683279,
0.66224581,
-0.3773110807,
0.3337056637,
-0.0710569099,
-0.4658022821,
0.6552975178,
0.2568526268,
0.7454839945,
0.9939857721,
-0.0861230344,
-0.1107943133,
0.0751408786,
-0.7635987997,
-0.0481094196,
-0.1275078356,
-0.1082793251,
-0.342979461,
0.4062310159,
0.8092467189,
0.1738201231,
-0.8240580559,
0.7920036912,
-0.3871700764,
-0.2596201897,
-0.7536940575,
0.2277187258,
-0.0951756686,
-0.0272821486,
0.1834672242,
0.3976737261,
0.1954204291,
-0.2833218575,
0.1241073832,
0.3415738046,
-0.5515130758,
-0.4637755454,
0.4881564081,
0.2905774117,
-0.2821468413,
1.2840958834,
-0.3125555813,
-0.5429289341,
0.8600093722,
0.2982883751,
1.2278975248,
-0.0282198712,
0.0555514619,
0.4068576992,
0.3932338357,
0.2429486811,
0.3458175957,
-0.0516141057,
-0.7705950737,
-0.8414071798,
-0.5785666108,
-0.0480661429,
0.1338014007,
-0.6673205495,
0.0094722314,
-0.7069141865,
-0.0806661695,
-0.0250386354,
-0.1696777791,
-0.712582469,
0.357126832,
0.560128808,
1.0493816137,
-0.7015909553,
1.0599476099,
0.707339406,
-0.6002714038,
-0.8708592057,
-0.1120481864,
-0.2172507048,
-0.285309881,
0.8244714141,
0.2322574109,
-0.1665317565,
0.2509763241,
-0.8852334023,
-0.8930294514,
0.8176067472,
0.2587112486,
-0.3014616966,
-0.434974283,
0.1946909875,
0.6795588732,
-0.5835591555,
0.6058771014,
0.7837430239,
0.1893999875,
-0.3730333447,
-0.5761378407,
-0.2842452526,
-0.9742150903,
0.2480594963,
0.1472082436,
-0.1547696739,
0.7652637362,
-0.093601197,
-0.2664951682,
0.0260339789,
0.9073136449,
-0.0459552966,
0.3120846152,
0.4325646758,
0.2675428689,
0.5290680528,
-0.1229942143,
1.1198587418,
-0.8256646991,
-0.1247405186,
1.3028560877,
-0.3311296701,
0.8232127428,
0.0957217142,
0.0317067988,
0.5495121479,
0.4039691389,
-0.0638934225,
0.3089695871,
0.4366222322,
-0.0410136282,
-0.3943853974,
0.036434602,
-0.2818639874,
0.5367791653,
0.1725244373,
-0.139245376,
0.0363277718,
0.093681559,
-0.2986559868,
0.2601721287,
-0.3871964216,
0.9638307691,
-0.0063713198,
-0.721670568,
0.564023912,
-0.2252940983,
0.8050584197,
-0.6730686426,
-0.1545376927,
-0.1964855939,
0.3011959195,
-0.085531503,
-0.4118302166,
0.6682981849,
-0.0529661737,
-0.3320815861,
-0.2587051392,
0.5928772092,
-0.1648789644,
-0.2064125538,
0.361441344,
0.3475837708,
0.030698413,
-0.281606704,
-0.7962736487,
-0.1604664624,
0.0963760912,
0.0440816097,
0.3104436398,
0.089080289,
0.2462316006,
0.6587238908,
0.7190210223,
0.043757949,
0.3652488589,
0.1299809963,
1.0752558708,
-0.790471077,
-0.445089519,
-0.5632977486,
0.5505927801,
-0.3283887506,
-0.6408113837,
0.5423672795,
0.5639441013,
0.9365780354,
-0.3137546182,
0.5964565277,
0.0482571647,
0.3595406413,
-0.4823874235,
1.166949749,
-0.2723649144,
0.1803769469,
-0.0978541076,
-0.7144636512,
-0.384568423,
0.2009183466,
-0.4238548577,
0.1772634536,
0.6016572118,
0.8506817818,
0.0354817994,
0.1620169878,
0.2012692392,
0.0607065298,
0.1261557639,
0.8183432221,
0.9715034366,
-0.3202955723,
0.3478987813,
-0.272986263,
-0.1384606212,
-0.0032841633,
-0.7929332852,
-0.9038252234,
-0.4890801311,
-0.5270956159,
0.0442551263,
-0.1389946789,
0.9248520136,
0.9488072991,
-1.1432100534,
-0.2825878263,
-0.6010305882,
-0.091319263,
-0.3331954777,
-0.1077128798,
0.072185941,
-0.7140097618,
-0.4263490438,
0.596837759,
0.0131023526,
-0.0157350693,
-0.2826268375,
-0.1303629726,
-0.3898660243,
0.0078069684,
0.3671550453,
0.5419476032,
-0.2710879445,
0.2628311515,
0.3771319389,
-0.24144122,
-0.0425454862,
1.1144794226,
-0.7666292191,
0.1947101653,
0.566026032,
1.0971608162,
-0.0170333143,
-0.2571330369,
0.7697190046,
-0.8388061523,
0.1362221539,
0.7560668588,
0.0964438617,
0.0706528947,
-0.3552366793,
0.5042037368,
0.0003739625,
-0.6386319995,
-0.9317395091,
0.1223877147,
-0.693328619,
-0.4754528105,
0.5189038515,
-0.2802515924,
-0.5583428741,
-0.2191313952,
0.2298138589,
0.3019329607,
0.3004392684,
0.388666451,
0.4594551921,
0.0944598168,
-0.194326967,
-0.7581683397,
0.723819077,
0.4028957188,
-1.068193078,
0.0818876252,
0.4709842205,
0.0247291774,
0.4879854918,
0.5603022575,
-0.0073197144,
0.4658421278,
0.1950435191,
0.6760762334,
-0.2673404515,
-0.5640406013,
-0.6117714643,
0.1671344191,
0.1534158587,
-0.0350301974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10077v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10077v3 | DOC: Improving Long Story Coherence With Detailed Outline Control | 2022-12-20T08:30:58 | 2023-06-14T22:05:11 | Kevin Yang, Dan Klein, Nanyun Peng, Yuandong Tian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose the Detailed Outline Control (DOC) framework for improving
long-range plot coherence when automatically generating
several-thousand-word-long stories. DOC consists of two complementary
components: a detailed outliner and a detailed controller. The detailed
outliner creates a more detailed, hierarchically structured outline, shifting
creative burden from the main drafting procedure to the planning stage. The
detailed controller ensures the more detailed outline is still respected during
generation by controlling story passages to align with outline details. In
human evaluations of automatically generated stories, DOC substantially
outperforms a strong Re3 baseline (Yang et al., 2022) on plot coherence (22.5%
absolute gain), outline relevance (28.2%), and interestingness (20.7%). Humans
also judged DOC to be much more controllable in an interactive generation
setting. | [
-0.544357717,
-0.7986081839,
0.7548021674,
0.5127077103,
-0.3564908504,
0.3404438198,
0.0043264842,
-0.7252444625,
0.4590724409,
0.5144364834,
-0.4921065867,
-0.4232890904,
-0.7873610854,
0.1519020945,
-0.4999414682,
0.9592500925,
-0.6136523485,
-0.4136833847,
-0.0382975489,
0.1283052564,
-0.1703318506,
-0.0954013318,
-0.8713912368,
-0.5611296892,
0.703975141,
0.6111937165,
0.7671878338,
0.8592317104,
0.5812199116,
0.2766885757,
-0.0643058196,
0.270827651,
-0.6498543024,
0.3971478939,
0.0655139908,
-0.2708998919,
-1.0004571676,
-0.0284758322,
0.4037335813,
0.7837623954,
-0.055117581,
-0.2312880009,
0.2476568967,
0.8146995306,
-0.5025088787,
0.1162912399,
0.2294729203,
0.1711220443,
-0.0605013184,
-0.471947968,
-0.146575585,
-0.151861459,
0.178074792,
-1.0390766859,
0.5181017518,
0.0172873642,
0.9306648374,
-0.015518886,
-0.4046204388,
-0.3051226139,
-0.9143929482,
0.3711780012,
-0.2666722834,
0.1989675462,
0.5002279878,
0.1998791695,
-0.2615438104,
-1.0848337412,
-0.4822069407,
-0.1562517434,
0.0057069501,
0.6131649613,
-0.2533219457,
0.3632153273,
0.4087294042,
0.2974872291,
-0.3712584674,
0.279715836,
-0.5779320598,
-0.2573332489,
0.8797162771,
0.473831147,
0.1496215016,
-0.0714418292,
-0.3341409266,
-0.1614499986,
-0.6246227622,
0.2596894503,
0.5274961591,
-0.578428328,
-0.276884973,
0.5674708486,
-0.6075000167,
0.6583307981,
0.62535882,
-0.3038633764,
0.0332152657,
-0.6105980873,
-0.1166132167,
0.0768493563,
0.8070967793,
0.9476014972,
0.2365690917,
-0.1373620033,
-0.305257082,
-0.1656330675,
0.3800397813,
-0.862522006,
-0.0026084799,
0.5386832952,
-0.381070137,
-0.285585314,
0.2389687449,
-0.4990713894,
-0.4756269753,
-0.5934491754,
-0.123324424,
-0.5956849456,
-0.0315387212,
0.1213757172,
-0.7875058651,
0.4229853451,
0.82333076,
-0.9361546636,
0.3841333389,
0.7524009347,
0.8996671438,
-0.4926869571,
-0.6199119091,
-0.4261860847,
0.7195688486,
-0.7438592315,
1.084387064,
-0.2738207877,
-0.5980686545,
-0.2959872186,
-0.0288202912,
0.3284588456,
-0.2959018648,
0.6692054272,
-0.0886988193,
0.2765239179,
-0.0092740888,
-0.6976342201,
0.0368073806,
0.0271441918,
-0.6325361729,
0.6350444555,
0.2536790669,
-0.7458993196,
0.8275817037,
-0.6198844314,
-0.6940846443,
-0.0651847422,
-0.1293074787,
-0.3004561365,
0.2275633216,
0.0350870527,
0.4292922914,
0.040949516,
0.5105343461,
0.0082742628,
-0.6323786378,
-0.1819236428,
-0.29093346,
0.208588928,
0.3294251561,
-0.4700258672,
0.538598001,
-0.9211307764,
0.0490942039,
-0.1961926073,
-0.3470967412,
-0.1465103328,
-0.053906329,
-0.0453954041,
0.0597249977,
0.0216791295,
-0.3331509531,
-0.0605703518,
-0.2431927323,
0.3046824336,
0.4503032863,
0.3427222669,
0.6257658601,
-0.6810205579,
0.802261591,
-0.0532949343,
-0.0468159914,
-0.4674955606,
-0.5129038692,
-0.9216660857,
-0.3205704391,
0.0119485427,
0.1907278299,
-0.2879672348,
0.8737895489,
-0.176865831,
-0.5328072906,
-0.3381716311,
0.1289173663,
0.3508835137,
0.5157372952,
0.1688587368,
-0.603402257,
-0.2160208821,
-0.8305884004,
-0.0119984988,
0.2192993164,
-0.3116694093,
-0.0397154242,
0.3399688005,
0.0239924137,
0.9372466803,
-0.5642880201,
-0.0490637682,
-0.4124771655,
0.5005111098,
-0.0188431516,
0.4029592276,
0.2278742939,
-0.7125468254,
-0.8502868414,
-0.1778118461,
-0.5747243166,
-0.2520640194,
-0.362408042,
-0.1759365052,
0.1882299334,
0.7851048708,
-0.7352910042,
0.7239201665,
0.2819879949,
-0.722297132,
0.7766602635,
-0.7076689005,
0.2567753494,
-1.0747951269,
0.2535838187,
-0.362067014,
-0.3263129294,
-0.5152124763,
0.0575066917,
0.2527219951,
-0.084306404,
-0.217258215,
0.3770054579,
-0.7326468229,
0.1329061985,
-0.3865555525,
0.2043655664,
0.6341720819,
0.2649606466,
0.2373028547,
0.6127113104,
0.405053556,
-0.5453094244,
0.4943901896,
0.1335339546,
-0.2795705199,
0.7778946757,
-0.999579668,
0.1159831583,
-0.2802037895,
0.6807773113,
-0.8574348688,
-0.6255323887,
-0.0688091591,
-0.2284488529,
0.4914653897,
0.3491488099,
-0.2607243061,
-0.1769590229,
-0.5796877146,
-0.3796393871,
0.3857249916,
-0.0005594078,
0.4319680035,
-0.0531332716,
-0.4464282393,
-0.1517995596,
-0.6591116786,
0.3984306753,
-0.109123528,
-0.7519693375,
0.5815430284,
-0.2240878493,
-0.3733097017,
-0.1062034592,
-0.2114893794,
-0.1414481252,
-0.1021988317,
0.5235873461,
-0.2755846679,
-0.0821055025,
0.0362791345,
0.5771759748,
-0.4214021266,
-0.013260725,
0.1152872369,
0.6230876446,
0.3262913525,
-0.165454939,
-0.6513419151,
0.8638492227,
0.7424688339,
-0.2028828859,
0.2831824422,
0.4875102341,
0.0757689103,
-0.0815561414,
-0.3742555976,
0.00402252,
-0.4553956389,
0.3657554984,
-0.7195311189,
-0.4547952414,
0.6261299253,
-0.0799221024,
-0.0301848259,
0.786228478,
0.1744418889,
-0.4569416344,
0.8115631342,
0.9889941812,
0.1892271787,
0.4534277618,
-0.3893043101,
-0.2531884015,
-0.8723934889,
-0.3936800361,
-0.3057078719,
-0.4152991176,
-0.1805410683,
-0.3802918792,
0.042412091,
0.746107161,
-0.2090520412,
0.1414445043,
-0.4060488939,
0.5128190517,
0.5447958708,
-0.0595611855,
0.603071332,
-0.0353638381,
-0.1769847125,
0.1056043133,
-0.4314781725,
-0.7305871248,
0.9955691695,
0.4271759689,
0.9556144476,
0.0033750641,
0.7573137879,
0.2404043525,
-0.1380550116,
-0.586558938,
0.3578316569,
0.0285966471,
-0.4824791253,
-0.4564144015,
-0.0413865782,
-1.046599865,
-0.1483061612,
-0.2441101074,
-0.5321262479,
0.3267004192,
-0.015930485,
-0.396238625,
-0.0147272376,
-0.9168502688,
0.4567454755,
-0.1896738112,
-0.4685603082,
-0.2549313903,
-0.6096877456,
-0.0171667226,
-0.4682901502,
-0.3240167201,
0.1157222167,
-0.4888764918,
0.7918700576,
-0.5885157585,
0.7062847018,
0.1892760396,
-0.364017278,
0.3871247172,
-0.001233327,
0.7838603854,
-0.0179704428,
-0.1623758674,
-0.0674421415,
-0.3851059675,
-0.4749993086,
-0.4628686309,
0.4801606834,
-0.660278976,
-0.6778856516,
-0.2605742812,
-0.7663423419,
0.0991128311,
0.5771435499,
0.7642451525,
0.4239022434,
-0.4041205049,
0.1160086393,
0.392883867,
-0.1677978635,
0.5540906191,
0.4975613952,
-0.0525880344,
-0.6048854589,
0.3410522342,
0.2244643569,
0.670561552,
0.4150354564,
0.1797374934,
-0.082102105,
-0.8372648358,
-0.5390235782,
0.0382172242,
-0.5118000507,
0.120510444,
-0.7609285116,
-0.3383660913,
-0.4152297974,
-0.6642398238,
0.0184244253,
-0.4360927045,
-0.2279706001,
-0.3814527392,
0.2757352889,
1.1030921936,
0.2172625512,
0.3980107307,
-0.4283297956,
0.6958112121,
0.1547537297,
0.5168397427,
-0.4779030383,
-0.2899732888,
-0.0464341901,
-0.0460948795,
-0.5601738095,
-0.584987998,
0.213870123,
0.17391105,
0.3800513744,
0.6967755556,
0.0032892842,
1.0035333633,
-0.5327488184,
0.6949298978,
0.5582960248,
-0.7385163903,
0.5932441354,
-0.5204084516,
0.7827358246,
0.3740183413,
0.2778877914,
-0.253906101,
-0.9403439164,
-0.7538880706,
-0.7851276398,
0.5402753353,
0.3454380929,
-0.0734332949,
0.4105547071,
0.3661577702,
0.4040028751,
0.1028604731,
-0.145915851,
-0.0366844013,
-0.306951493,
0.0372846499,
-0.4515971839,
-0.4523798823,
-0.3359452486,
-0.1954827607,
-0.0194653794,
-0.0652853996,
0.153043732,
0.6191343069,
0.226226449,
-0.5450876951,
0.3428117931,
1.0135151148,
1.3319369555,
-0.5044566393,
0.3383319378,
-0.0033035241,
-0.9735483527,
0.053046409,
0.3352743089,
-0.3540799916,
-0.0079294601,
0.9366784096,
0.8704593182,
-0.2195287198,
-0.3770989776,
0.2320794165,
-0.0763993859,
-0.5173110962,
-0.1937238425,
0.4558790624,
0.3430131078,
0.1063435674,
0.3476947546,
0.1111752242,
0.1168405935,
-0.5044521093,
0.2549560666,
-0.1455740631,
-0.4851665199,
-0.1769863069,
0.6892428994,
0.5254691839,
-0.2637757957,
0.297297895,
-0.1382440329,
-0.1785222441,
0.9735706449,
0.8393343687,
0.9043960571,
0.1242979541,
0.1338394284,
0.190596208,
0.1655649841,
0.0481279641,
0.2572753131,
-0.1328597963,
-0.2342099994,
-0.4136420786,
-0.4277366102,
-0.6055482626,
-0.0339833274,
-0.5601335764,
0.4106944501,
-0.4281505644,
0.044933185,
0.1036306471,
0.3993119895,
-0.2529715002,
0.3652252853,
-0.0665162504,
1.2550209761,
-0.5239415169,
0.8538829684,
0.5735628605,
-0.4461627305,
-0.9236142635,
0.1853130609,
-0.2802731693,
-0.273172915,
0.4147980511,
0.2300116718,
-0.4354215264,
-0.0514882393,
-0.4294116497,
-0.6395791769,
1.6128848791,
0.2666509449,
-0.9150739908,
-0.1257087886,
-0.0595285334,
0.8411660194,
-0.535562098,
0.137284562,
0.3322451413,
0.5812029243,
0.2493464202,
-1.0444614887,
0.0075012324,
-0.2038015276,
-0.4011386931,
0.2723639309,
-0.6362128258,
0.5629899502,
-0.5612828135,
-0.309723407,
0.0565575846,
0.5831480622,
0.2888793647,
0.7354352474,
0.4089318216,
0.4278967977,
0.861205101,
-0.0421631411,
1.4638855457,
-0.4564976394,
-0.2169200331,
1.3012856245,
-0.0892386809,
0.640547514,
0.3470984995,
-0.0370666794,
0.4503380358,
0.6835974455,
0.1719985157,
0.3312283754,
0.0954007432,
-0.0130964927,
0.0636171326,
0.0354048237,
-0.5502824187,
0.2777096033,
0.2299675047,
-0.5508031845,
-0.0325085036,
-0.2164518833,
0.3455456793,
0.0003746748,
-0.3046740592,
0.9445640445,
0.1366344094,
-1.0504863262,
0.5617846847,
-0.0695496798,
0.3997573853,
-1.0761345625,
-0.0381355472,
-0.4958197773,
0.0624702014,
-0.3790036738,
-1.1790622473,
0.2636555433,
0.077504389,
-0.4427607358,
-0.4417589605,
0.7438957691,
-0.5655156374,
-0.3184384108,
0.2641801238,
0.3701836467,
0.1314605922,
-0.1101438254,
-0.4711849689,
-0.0871405751,
-0.1683962494,
-0.3896671832,
-0.0382258743,
0.695982337,
-0.2872222364,
0.570258677,
0.556137085,
0.3858835995,
-0.0503466241,
0.073879607,
0.8067817092,
-0.9897043109,
-0.8716231585,
-0.4864172637,
0.3496986926,
-0.5702762604,
-0.6262360215,
0.8362211585,
0.785441041,
0.3971530199,
0.0013991689,
0.7308905125,
-0.2192713618,
0.1610106677,
-0.454696089,
1.0057513714,
-0.3595187664,
-0.0943438262,
-0.2276189476,
-0.9952646494,
-0.2925070524,
0.0609981902,
-0.0510069132,
-0.0934833437,
1.0348197222,
0.4488135874,
-0.137843281,
-0.2748506367,
0.3470314145,
0.1341960281,
0.4497368932,
0.3568531573,
0.77942729,
0.0183117911,
0.4444584846,
-0.3145959377,
-0.3157665431,
0.0449108258,
-0.9094516039,
-0.7235609293,
-0.3162949085,
-0.2423836738,
-0.334823817,
0.0104560684,
0.1883025318,
0.7388917804,
-0.6463499665,
-0.2646189928,
-0.3874037862,
0.0046070688,
-0.3566768467,
-0.1776794493,
0.6649890542,
-0.1983976215,
-0.7821369171,
0.339707911,
0.5890986919,
0.192430228,
-0.2009494007,
-0.5024968386,
0.0933427736,
0.0273939464,
0.5978025794,
0.0327148028,
-0.5731480122,
-0.1069628894,
-0.1561242938,
-0.4528318644,
0.0847749487,
0.9362616539,
-0.406547159,
0.8557562828,
0.7238471508,
-0.1853533238,
0.7603473663,
0.2330875397,
1.2542341948,
-0.404482156,
0.1588634849,
0.0417067446,
0.2691500187,
0.0412388444,
-0.5582581162,
0.7492275834,
0.0194118358,
-0.4952051938,
-0.2647239566,
0.2284120619,
-1.4499191046,
-0.279499501,
1.1744920015,
-0.1617097557,
-0.0308546964,
-0.428070724,
-0.6307223439,
0.2781213522,
-0.5534827709,
0.5338544846,
0.717469871,
-0.4828079343,
-0.0474897139,
-0.4962202013,
0.7343078852,
-0.0923258662,
-0.9494980574,
-0.0992321298,
0.6019816995,
0.415042609,
0.3238323927,
0.8199816942,
-0.1977865994,
0.4327420592,
0.2554794848,
0.0878386647,
-0.4029572308,
-0.3927181065,
-0.1941936314,
0.4080696404,
-0.0602142848,
0.1470826715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10071v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10071v2 | Large Language Models Are Reasoning Teachers | 2022-12-20T08:24:45 | 2023-06-13T10:55:29 | Namgyu Ho, Laura Schmid, Se-Young Yun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent works have shown that chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting can elicit
language models to solve complex reasoning tasks, step-by-step. However,
prompt-based CoT methods are dependent on very large models such as GPT-3 175B
which are prohibitive to deploy at scale. In this paper, we use these large
models as reasoning teachers to enable complex reasoning in smaller models and
reduce model size requirements by several orders of magnitude. We propose
Fine-tune-CoT, a method that generates reasoning samples from very large
teacher models to fine-tune smaller models. We evaluate our method on a wide
range of public models and complex tasks. We find that Fine-tune-CoT enables
substantial reasoning capability in small models, far outperforming
prompt-based baselines and even the teacher model in many tasks. Additionally,
we extend our method by leveraging the teacher model's ability to generate
multiple distinct rationales for each original sample. Enriching the
fine-tuning data with such diverse reasoning results in a substantial
performance boost across datasets, even for very small models. We conduct
ablations and sample studies to understand the emergence of reasoning
capabilities of student models. Our code implementation and data are available
at https://github.com/itsnamgyu/reasoning-teacher. | [
-0.7403228879,
-0.7935423851,
0.9158220291,
-0.2124136686,
-0.2414063215,
-0.0933056772,
-0.632915318,
-0.290776372,
-0.4420506954,
0.7266605496,
-0.4258035421,
-0.3072567582,
-0.4077026248,
0.0453825779,
-0.3915472627,
0.7472334504,
0.0159684308,
0.0693982095,
0.000916691,
0.3579870462,
-0.6963422298,
-0.1558749229,
-0.8366203308,
-0.3255416751,
0.4889660776,
0.879484117,
0.801024735,
0.5491874814,
0.0830258131,
0.2269939035,
-0.2357508838,
0.8294354081,
-0.4346987605,
0.0186322927,
-0.8964145184,
-0.6009860635,
-0.3094740212,
-0.0684997886,
0.5978444815,
0.6938099861,
0.0452464074,
0.1245144978,
-0.1125859395,
0.4459049702,
-0.7274209857,
-0.0513530262,
-0.8727363944,
-0.2851933241,
0.1842646897,
0.0674822405,
-0.8229686022,
-0.3930131495,
0.1798785478,
-0.414758563,
0.2756194472,
0.2260152996,
0.7768980861,
0.1213629246,
-0.5121868253,
-0.1576614529,
-0.7988865376,
0.8297403455,
-0.6856446266,
0.0790143684,
0.4647428393,
0.5294520855,
-0.3941217363,
-0.6887680888,
-0.8022037745,
-0.0813987702,
-0.0191456024,
-0.3235377967,
0.176772356,
0.1522719711,
0.645509243,
0.2341917306,
-0.2288528085,
-0.0630276799,
-0.5111708045,
0.1246037781,
0.5004682541,
0.2649679184,
0.2712533474,
-0.1376094222,
0.0097789848,
0.0123097841,
-0.7530774474,
-0.0271218959,
0.3661206365,
0.6832939982,
-0.0307863597,
0.5131008029,
-0.3408750594,
1.1576128006,
0.1387848109,
-0.086985372,
-0.5545291901,
-0.1520353407,
-0.2549833357,
0.0168521032,
0.4560746253,
0.0083222724,
0.6679469347,
0.132847324,
-0.3373195231,
0.2024079412,
0.1274564564,
-0.7362032533,
-0.6217722297,
0.2038279325,
-0.0162857175,
-0.2438148409,
-0.0769697353,
-0.5664684772,
-0.4784706235,
-0.9947626591,
0.4205127954,
-0.4548709989,
-0.2624555528,
0.4195238948,
0.033130452,
0.1291224062,
0.6539588571,
-0.9877102375,
0.2804432809,
0.9049018025,
0.6001659632,
0.21686849,
-0.382850498,
-0.6444986463,
0.1177698672,
-0.5479261279,
0.7642247677,
-0.9093838334,
-0.1290992945,
-0.2806914449,
0.0582344644,
-0.0926187038,
-0.460341841,
0.6021233797,
-0.2668937445,
0.1065838784,
-0.5345486403,
-0.595266521,
0.0191962495,
0.5363407135,
-0.4064262807,
0.8335582018,
0.1217534617,
-0.3522075117,
0.1626762897,
-0.3971197903,
-0.2868207097,
-0.2431475967,
-0.1544207335,
-0.0553453825,
0.1679743081,
0.7190240622,
0.4796416759,
-0.8066446185,
0.485049814,
-0.1933261752,
-0.4072128534,
0.0386461206,
-0.4219639301,
0.7727249265,
0.4329047501,
-0.2813742757,
0.2255428135,
-0.6103916764,
0.3948007226,
-0.0610855035,
-0.1120349765,
-0.1509188712,
-0.1382696927,
-0.2360103279,
0.2902908623,
-0.1185875237,
-0.3593108952,
0.6338860393,
-0.3588332832,
0.7357235551,
0.7216478586,
-0.0383968577,
0.3388814628,
-0.449087441,
0.4607956707,
0.0127344672,
0.0761997104,
-0.172210142,
-0.3794610202,
-0.681525588,
-0.6140723825,
0.4685522318,
0.0042564482,
-0.6962633729,
0.2055649906,
-0.2100286335,
-0.6675872207,
-0.5634159446,
0.0271072313,
0.321814537,
0.5715397596,
0.500151515,
0.262796849,
-0.4129529893,
-0.5884691477,
-0.4159105122,
0.1905960143,
-0.0315674432,
0.3320412636,
0.5612239838,
0.0358147621,
0.9585476518,
-0.7638079524,
0.1896428764,
-0.1898179054,
-0.0347948447,
0.0705877095,
0.8015336394,
0.3467059731,
-0.5429625511,
-0.3593138158,
0.0424785316,
-0.2847123742,
0.1075674817,
-0.1595067084,
-0.5124605894,
-0.0672286302,
0.5900333524,
-0.88449049,
0.1690086573,
0.1643677056,
-0.6498314738,
0.7737599611,
-0.1826609671,
0.1105633602,
-0.8263335824,
-0.0438143201,
-0.3655591011,
-0.4552751184,
-0.1940624267,
0.3085021377,
0.0364290178,
-0.3888042569,
-0.2249313593,
0.6400506496,
-0.3062870204,
0.0664559528,
-0.4601432383,
0.3208459616,
0.3855203092,
0.2885031104,
-0.0834971741,
0.7223841548,
0.6126614213,
-0.769161284,
0.4229524732,
0.1634029299,
-0.5406650305,
0.5577196479,
-0.6273970604,
0.2252056748,
0.0377873629,
0.4797677398,
-0.8304663897,
-0.5231537819,
-0.0439947993,
-0.2002438903,
0.0611600094,
-0.3877211511,
-0.71126616,
-0.550906837,
0.0635320917,
0.3548228741,
0.4044942856,
-0.9749875069,
0.6454324722,
0.024823701,
-0.0660313517,
-0.231360212,
-0.4181298912,
-0.1683905423,
0.0961497277,
-0.531837225,
-0.0677172542,
0.1756381392,
-0.1582010835,
-0.0261270087,
-0.1807351261,
-0.0157431923,
0.0122845443,
-0.0838081613,
0.2700867951,
-0.3349393606,
0.395444572,
0.4832833111,
-0.0723036751,
0.0516249277,
-0.6150982976,
0.744271934,
-0.3631055355,
-0.3581389487,
-0.2234241813,
0.1506216824,
0.7424226999,
-0.5304815769,
0.6522560716,
0.4097580314,
-0.5249137878,
-0.6557345986,
-0.5560061336,
-0.4180102944,
-0.4660338759,
-0.0304348245,
-0.5741787553,
-0.8259336352,
0.3453770578,
-0.4089796841,
-0.1228914633,
0.2280445993,
0.6113275886,
0.3313959837,
1.3419485092,
0.1034878194,
0.2074974179,
0.236029014,
-0.3239839971,
0.3198443651,
-0.7044409513,
-0.0747344643,
-0.5689274669,
-0.2517347038,
-0.2613280118,
-0.5266170502,
0.0282252487,
0.3509667516,
-0.8380515575,
0.079466939,
-0.8571417928,
1.1885454655,
0.644644618,
0.309566021,
0.2757104635,
-0.3402886987,
-0.1100953445,
0.4801178575,
-0.5631005168,
-0.8366984725,
0.9204150438,
0.0264231488,
0.773816824,
0.1680764556,
0.4606240988,
-0.2479049414,
-0.0833970308,
-0.7482582331,
0.6743943095,
-0.1642738134,
-0.7690367699,
-0.3856172562,
-0.4853787124,
-0.7006431222,
0.3388427496,
-0.2237209976,
-0.7846197486,
0.0942153484,
0.2844951749,
-0.5555484891,
0.5053457618,
-1.1326298714,
0.8575186133,
0.063845478,
-0.332493186,
-0.3549711704,
-0.4436622262,
0.556024611,
0.1141677052,
-0.0441424288,
-0.3190444112,
0.3388746381,
0.3145389557,
-0.763884604,
0.7465679049,
-0.3039179444,
-0.2350222319,
0.7061162591,
0.2821809947,
0.8144766092,
0.1917907,
-0.1080196649,
-0.5625796318,
0.3680681586,
-0.7013599277,
-0.761099577,
0.9816240072,
-0.8017613888,
-0.8966189027,
-0.0400773026,
-0.8152140975,
-0.5240675807,
0.330157876,
0.1343869716,
0.5129420757,
0.5524553061,
0.0576895773,
0.6203736663,
0.0686857179,
0.1351511925,
0.2878223658,
-0.3479117155,
-0.1546394974,
0.8609237671,
0.1826560497,
0.5077656507,
0.0823238343,
0.5697128177,
-0.1560241431,
-0.1633993834,
-0.4229933321,
0.0721594989,
-0.7591956258,
-0.3743862212,
-0.4967344999,
-0.0029762306,
-0.3220880032,
-0.5714277625,
-0.5441012383,
-0.473366648,
-0.2136812061,
-0.1054096669,
0.4906251132,
0.5624669194,
0.2005503327,
0.2738807797,
-0.4950567484,
0.4675568342,
0.6299777627,
0.3502672911,
0.4555280805,
-0.4927629232,
-0.0461241417,
0.2193180472,
-0.3166363537,
-0.3467108607,
0.0870047286,
-0.0432760082,
0.0799101144,
0.3155103624,
0.3840624988,
0.904962182,
-0.3195685446,
0.780584693,
-0.0568281449,
-1.3170267344,
0.7888172865,
-0.6138314009,
0.5533249974,
0.4077730179,
0.0620669909,
-0.1216971055,
-0.4974874854,
-0.626994729,
-0.7697771788,
0.8227465153,
-0.1002513841,
0.032775104,
-0.0799871609,
0.5735105872,
0.085026145,
0.0242524892,
-0.3185726106,
0.230686754,
-0.1024402156,
-0.4611021578,
0.1279822737,
-0.0253040604,
-0.2668267488,
-0.6459690928,
0.6583113074,
-0.4026005566,
-0.164233923,
0.2003339976,
0.0940328687,
-0.1986769736,
0.5342951417,
0.6541614532,
0.8407130241,
0.1366517991,
0.5177280903,
0.4009490609,
-0.2475095093,
0.2109183967,
-0.1465525925,
-0.1403341144,
-0.3225719631,
0.2392922342,
0.6890489459,
0.2458866835,
-0.8269835711,
0.3511907756,
0.0211061742,
-0.0857817754,
-0.0688861981,
0.5354318023,
0.1320721209,
0.4630495608,
-0.0119846789,
0.2509611547,
-0.1048196852,
-0.5410889387,
-0.0228877719,
0.1032697931,
-0.1515540183,
-0.1533228904,
0.5889843106,
0.122361429,
-0.031081643,
0.7221488953,
-0.1401754469,
-0.3762210906,
0.7846596241,
0.8426933885,
0.5528117418,
0.0479822271,
0.2193180025,
0.5479476452,
0.1553144604,
-0.6660581231,
0.4934408665,
-0.0167719964,
-0.6393432617,
-0.6245303154,
-0.2939355671,
-0.5881972313,
0.1112541109,
-0.6397994757,
0.6669226885,
-0.8367378116,
0.0690751299,
0.2028525621,
0.1228047162,
-0.6005296111,
0.4797230959,
0.0972443148,
0.8458880186,
-0.6260176897,
0.9068242311,
0.6110756397,
-0.247177124,
-1.5761243105,
-0.138963148,
-0.2516852021,
-0.5260421634,
0.3944031894,
0.2188136727,
-0.1823964268,
0.1959969401,
-0.9607554078,
-0.6042254567,
0.8450061679,
0.7772117853,
-0.8888550997,
-0.0306551866,
-0.1328256726,
0.4899642467,
-0.48786062,
0.2552764416,
0.8166354895,
0.388854444,
0.1706425399,
-0.7741419077,
0.333096981,
0.2031369954,
-0.1180758551,
0.3697551489,
-0.5158116221,
1.2479213476,
-0.6184030175,
0.058083497,
0.0850632191,
0.4239062369,
0.5481722355,
0.1695687771,
0.5003829002,
0.5077155232,
1.2813663483,
-0.1412457079,
0.9361644983,
-0.248324126,
0.4358789325,
1.4470630884,
-0.0407612063,
0.7753489614,
0.235945642,
0.0479277596,
0.433660835,
0.4231987,
-0.1154035553,
0.265311569,
0.3320328593,
-0.3324503601,
-0.8893035054,
-0.1847045869,
-0.2995156348,
0.3705410063,
0.4173570573,
-0.1731016934,
-0.1327109933,
0.1644290984,
0.1384355575,
0.2769904435,
-0.899358511,
0.5005236864,
0.0993038863,
-1.0573513508,
0.7594692707,
0.0158692058,
0.1434449255,
-0.219616279,
-0.0360333957,
0.1608947664,
0.4689731598,
-0.333470881,
-0.8297032118,
0.0438143648,
0.1177643463,
-0.2708888352,
0.1555912793,
0.5948674083,
-0.5497636795,
-0.4507994354,
-0.2105884403,
0.3002562225,
-0.0156162689,
-0.1477965266,
-0.2450110167,
-0.026168501,
-0.0262783449,
-0.126144886,
0.0852633417,
0.9718074799,
-0.27765131,
0.6503199935,
0.6237663031,
0.1058317125,
-0.2232957631,
0.2250449061,
1.1513911486,
-0.7791420817,
-0.4562775791,
-0.8928562403,
0.3990549147,
0.0259527918,
-0.5832270384,
0.4412100911,
0.4385178983,
0.9455785751,
-0.2697817385,
0.6689788103,
0.0933707133,
0.5706253052,
-0.6375721693,
0.4322629273,
-0.2790166438,
0.3336759508,
-0.2867897153,
-0.6515011191,
-0.1193149611,
0.637443006,
-0.8343532085,
-0.0393540151,
0.6322519779,
0.7180601954,
-0.277372241,
0.4687605798,
0.2797777057,
0.1788156629,
0.5803323984,
0.5688104033,
0.9321092963,
-0.1672830135,
0.4253304303,
-0.130183354,
0.0529179461,
-0.1108226851,
-0.5756800175,
-1.2219303846,
-0.2716060281,
-0.2837660313,
-0.3486391902,
-0.0639419407,
1.2247447968,
0.7179797292,
-0.8646723032,
0.2859282494,
-0.5763403177,
0.3240070343,
-0.1811047196,
-0.2676146924,
0.4786738455,
-0.6286596656,
-0.7826215029,
0.1385302842,
-0.2306501269,
-0.0935143903,
-0.1096446142,
0.0256173387,
-0.1234017685,
0.4378351569,
0.7049916983,
0.112388514,
-0.8516665101,
-0.7070759535,
-0.2733212113,
-0.069916524,
-0.3959165812,
0.8498060107,
-0.78570503,
0.5820646286,
0.423479259,
0.4716277421,
0.4996476769,
0.0222011488,
0.6261898875,
-0.6721274853,
0.1973683834,
0.409124136,
0.3590414524,
0.194327727,
-0.3081216216,
0.4739381969,
-0.1188237593,
-0.6688476205,
-1.1929502487,
0.4393787384,
-0.8589750528,
-0.514698565,
1.0736919641,
-0.2324475497,
-0.0523756482,
-0.059131939,
-0.7311503887,
0.1124829724,
-0.2613247335,
0.7200350761,
0.8126459718,
0.0699075907,
-0.2736459374,
-0.2679435015,
0.4804980457,
0.3518937826,
-0.8289678097,
0.3713428378,
0.325244993,
0.1709629148,
-0.0344889797,
0.2118277103,
-0.0469460934,
0.4083431661,
0.2566307485,
-0.2122616023,
-0.2814117968,
-0.5483184457,
0.0943946093,
0.2821601331,
0.2995702326,
0.180804953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10060v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10060v2 | I Cast Detect Thoughts: Learning to Converse and Guide with Intents and Theory-of-Mind in Dungeons and Dragons | 2022-12-20T08:06:55 | 2023-05-30T23:09:37 | Pei Zhou, Andrew Zhu, Jennifer Hu, Jay Pujara, Xiang Ren, Chris Callison-Burch, Yejin Choi, Prithviraj Ammanabrolu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose a novel task, G4C, to study teacher-student natural language
interactions in a goal-driven and grounded environment. Dungeons and Dragons
(D&D), a role-playing game, provides an ideal setting to investigate such
interactions. Here, the Dungeon Master (DM), i.e., the teacher, guides the
actions of several players -- students, each with their own personas and
abilities -- to achieve shared goals grounded in a fantasy world. Our approach
is to decompose and model these interactions into (1) the DM's intent to guide
players toward a given goal; (2) the DM's guidance utterance to the players
expressing this intent; and (3) a theory-of-mind (ToM) model that anticipates
the players' reaction to the guidance one turn into the future. We develop a
novel reinforcement learning (RL) method for training a DM that generates
guidance for players by rewarding utterances where the intent matches the
ToM-anticipated player actions. Human and automated evaluations show that a DM
trained to explicitly model intents and incorporate ToM of the players using RL
generates better-quality guidance that is 3x more likely to fulfill the DM's
intent than a vanilla natural language generation (NLG) approach. | [
-0.5234202147,
-0.6933971643,
0.8372964859,
-0.0922260359,
-0.2037947029,
-0.3070501089,
-0.4137159288,
-0.3163667023,
0.3180903792,
0.6709809899,
-0.9929201007,
-0.6670135856,
-0.2854551375,
0.0560967401,
-0.1455665231,
1.1379513741,
-0.0572299436,
0.141549319,
-0.3088350296,
0.2083109021,
-0.6336761713,
-0.3034882843,
-1.3368294239,
-0.4110480845,
0.5758061409,
0.4057655334,
0.2450535297,
0.427544862,
0.2949473262,
0.3248231709,
0.2793531418,
0.3781618178,
-0.6770125628,
0.4884384573,
-0.4109769464,
-0.4524655938,
-0.3843890429,
0.4601260722,
0.4291640222,
0.4571380019,
-0.3425374329,
-0.1091801822,
0.2528933585,
0.3161077797,
-0.4556993246,
0.3745316565,
-0.3466801643,
0.3496571481,
0.1005930305,
-0.3739435673,
-0.6120428443,
-0.3066203296,
0.3208357096,
-1.0910975933,
0.3167153299,
-0.078986086,
0.270665884,
0.2642463148,
-0.4992873669,
-0.7905875444,
-0.8910881281,
0.8532255292,
-0.6038092971,
0.3619477451,
0.5649802685,
0.4321457446,
-0.3796519041,
-0.4307191372,
-0.9844393134,
0.0488987863,
-0.0344056413,
0.3298550248,
0.2665588558,
0.6410579681,
0.4895047843,
0.2274267077,
-0.2710072696,
-0.2409735471,
-0.3907507658,
0.1278821677,
0.7480990887,
0.3135544062,
0.1791335344,
-0.0264836326,
-0.3806231916,
-0.239125669,
-0.3207749128,
0.1734591126,
0.608977437,
0.1874343604,
0.1493500024,
0.3024639785,
-0.0423103459,
0.6277108788,
0.4600113928,
-0.3424702585,
-0.3610380292,
-0.1257869601,
-0.1028708741,
0.3847452104,
0.6939565539,
0.6231212616,
0.342482388,
-0.322497189,
-0.1410825849,
0.4864086807,
0.9667831063,
-0.5931230783,
-0.5611643195,
0.0216754489,
-0.2776035964,
-0.4886475503,
-0.3951591253,
-0.9477264881,
-0.6654749513,
-0.5844956636,
0.4898191392,
-0.392191112,
-0.4412040412,
0.3614803255,
-0.1138616875,
0.448906064,
0.3322936893,
-1.2720854282,
0.541677475,
0.7261437774,
0.2527675033,
-0.3793227971,
-0.3443149328,
-0.4842314124,
0.2205410004,
-0.6248914003,
0.6769440174,
-0.4040904045,
-0.7564877868,
0.0736227632,
-0.159325555,
-0.2292354107,
-0.2935788631,
1.0016776323,
-0.2256847322,
0.6498907804,
-0.4407508969,
-0.5436741114,
-0.3237823248,
0.4890974164,
-0.6841056347,
0.5777823925,
-0.133776933,
-0.4851642847,
0.6986659169,
-0.7141488791,
-0.2426884174,
0.3060516417,
-0.5257095098,
0.0348932333,
-0.1123827696,
0.0307295248,
0.4189677835,
0.0308074318,
0.3603193462,
-0.0968137085,
-0.5364630818,
0.2173293978,
-0.5416658521,
0.3611785173,
-0.0836715549,
-0.4985921979,
0.0909673497,
-0.3704977632,
0.1362516284,
-0.1539876163,
-0.3803816736,
-0.4237163961,
0.6810264587,
-0.418854624,
0.1942825019,
-0.3252783716,
-0.283313781,
0.1822487116,
-0.5177067518,
-0.0747413784,
0.8155020475,
0.2027444243,
0.6630584002,
-0.1820809394,
0.5861643553,
-0.1791485101,
0.2609968483,
0.023575522,
-0.4331592023,
-0.8305796385,
0.0682060048,
-0.3499010801,
0.1895935833,
-1.1595045328,
0.0103300149,
-0.147362262,
-0.2296468318,
-0.5719043612,
-0.1274051815,
0.4577372074,
0.5267224908,
0.4870783091,
-0.3708106279,
-0.4810745716,
-0.5036744475,
-0.4384388626,
-0.4518122375,
0.2080741376,
0.4047342539,
0.1712471992,
-0.0934420899,
1.0443389416,
-0.645607233,
-0.3541354239,
-0.3604361415,
0.0564850196,
0.1773320138,
0.581092298,
0.4618958831,
-0.8012641072,
-0.4476929307,
-0.0958581567,
-0.887363553,
0.2865131497,
-0.0301888622,
-0.27902174,
-0.1817180663,
0.430948019,
-0.6072291136,
0.4976070821,
0.3939754069,
-0.6113687158,
0.5509937406,
-0.0748571306,
0.6242750883,
-0.8551030159,
-0.2499231398,
0.0594236329,
0.0956927091,
-1.1094106436,
-0.1134956181,
-0.3680621684,
0.0253298786,
-0.2269550115,
0.6835902929,
-0.3125463426,
0.1479543895,
-0.229850173,
0.3091358542,
-0.0304585882,
0.8188340664,
0.2934117615,
0.7503719926,
0.3891400099,
-1.1251045465,
0.5537561774,
0.3399682939,
-0.4335029125,
1.2380427122,
-0.4017641246,
0.2888400555,
-0.0304233674,
0.0920214131,
-0.818854928,
-0.0738907531,
0.7790331244,
-0.517537415,
0.3868242204,
-0.2322395891,
-0.0352567025,
-0.5864062309,
0.0093097491,
0.4519765377,
0.2958406806,
-0.7228102684,
0.6700730324,
0.4345187247,
0.1249812469,
-0.5757305026,
-0.2747031152,
-0.1145773456,
-0.49882707,
-0.152861014,
0.2006609589,
-0.3839874864,
-0.3780288398,
-0.0229950529,
-0.217543453,
-0.1721180826,
0.0779836923,
0.3627523184,
0.1250855625,
-0.0245384667,
-0.1015400589,
0.0950753987,
-0.0221688319,
0.6322801113,
-0.5908018947,
0.2124702781,
0.3905355036,
-0.282359004,
-0.1618913263,
0.3672026992,
0.2686907351,
-0.036022041,
0.3442257345,
0.4213953614,
-0.2403574437,
-0.7623277903,
-0.3737316728,
-0.4334864318,
-0.5382169485,
0.2131249309,
-0.4682665467,
-0.6097590327,
0.1876988113,
-0.1830291152,
0.274279207,
-0.0642859638,
0.0258164313,
-0.3099055886,
1.0952429771,
0.6573417783,
0.1544528306,
0.4560554028,
-0.4429757893,
0.3302938044,
-0.8225656748,
-0.3214074373,
-0.0966272503,
-0.6377846599,
-0.2210951746,
-0.5886512995,
0.3258105516,
0.009519564,
0.2551165819,
0.2734651268,
-0.5320478082,
0.6261731386,
0.5184919238,
0.0605584346,
0.0418614745,
-0.1951292902,
-0.3026475906,
-0.3124298155,
-0.4204013646,
-0.4231081307,
0.9005050659,
0.1280717105,
0.6436294913,
0.2243374437,
0.9222525358,
0.2257347554,
0.0375951864,
-0.8558818102,
0.8122417927,
0.2440061271,
-0.6273627877,
-0.4494275451,
-0.3005202115,
-1.0151486397,
0.2714339793,
-0.3197736144,
-0.5184939504,
0.2053937316,
0.2125553489,
-0.2427377999,
0.4256537855,
-0.5164928436,
1.0257773399,
0.0145948427,
-0.5150772333,
-0.5496737957,
-0.1677745432,
0.4733409286,
0.4007591009,
0.045440495,
0.1472479999,
0.2892748415,
0.9851183295,
0.1605793536,
0.8457988501,
-0.4456242025,
-0.593397975,
0.5237715244,
0.2846980691,
0.3996127546,
0.0112112062,
0.1206390709,
-0.3815298378,
-0.2178458571,
-0.0611723177,
-0.7193443179,
0.6882482767,
-0.6247284412,
-0.4777107537,
-0.4474925995,
-0.4041167498,
-0.3464433849,
0.1615961194,
0.164785251,
0.6196901202,
-0.6087252498,
-0.4393452406,
1.1210503578,
0.0381660797,
0.3867288232,
0.5939137936,
-0.1951341182,
-0.3447794318,
0.8248383403,
-0.1794409305,
0.2254824638,
0.2143371552,
-0.0997560397,
-0.4840617478,
-0.3983414173,
-0.3157435358,
0.2257341594,
-0.8377723694,
0.1572667062,
-0.517128706,
-0.0183276832,
-0.1924570501,
-0.1621136665,
0.1567534059,
0.1478398442,
-0.335390687,
-0.4770647585,
0.2106394917,
1.1279623508,
0.047563117,
0.4698133767,
-0.2155991644,
0.1330340803,
0.8501520753,
0.299846828,
-0.139079079,
-0.1227594465,
-0.2948285639,
0.2023315728,
-0.3350283206,
-1.1131010056,
0.3802087009,
0.0685835779,
0.7917001247,
0.6957609653,
0.1581238508,
0.5131494999,
-0.5680484176,
0.8115802407,
0.0385416895,
-0.6656503081,
0.5484509468,
-0.556558609,
-0.1103366613,
0.5605802536,
0.4181270599,
-1.0808454752,
-0.4380380213,
-0.6953744888,
-0.3056822419,
1.0980629921,
-0.3220896125,
-0.0417908952,
-0.4202327728,
0.5356514454,
0.0429387651,
0.4309467375,
-0.4972632229,
-0.2254512757,
0.0449768044,
-0.2791273892,
-0.4580973089,
-0.2644696534,
-0.3348986804,
-0.0165629741,
0.4742215872,
-0.4678126872,
0.4834477603,
0.1501084417,
0.1959002018,
-0.2832534015,
0.1119453833,
0.5224438906,
0.3153090775,
0.0285904817,
0.3455198705,
0.3115008175,
-0.7707503438,
0.0356422178,
-0.4891390204,
-0.1100256443,
-0.1377825439,
0.3159846365,
0.9413826466,
0.6424343586,
-0.3272004724,
0.3649350703,
-0.3827584088,
-0.5113901496,
-0.2908420265,
0.6118603945,
-0.1998298913,
0.445084393,
0.1485554129,
0.1292301714,
0.4737577736,
-0.5876911879,
0.281706363,
0.3195432127,
-0.805336535,
-0.4546585977,
0.5101912618,
0.4083287418,
-0.2868280411,
0.4647937119,
-0.5986661911,
-0.9361132383,
0.3344757259,
0.3511829972,
1.0542236567,
-0.256872654,
0.5719378591,
0.4692635536,
0.0660666898,
-0.1572458744,
0.3668223023,
-0.3686595261,
-0.7760298252,
-0.4922187328,
-0.2765712142,
-0.3951414526,
-0.1692938954,
-0.6265196204,
0.0923102573,
-0.3204418719,
-0.209959507,
-0.5454182625,
0.4604787529,
-0.5493192673,
0.2169474065,
0.2427126765,
0.3925118148,
-0.7715713978,
0.7463367581,
0.5128231645,
-0.0795511901,
-1.0971566439,
0.0747446641,
0.0995961949,
-0.4390099645,
0.518512845,
-0.0848441198,
-0.1877884716,
0.3855604231,
-0.5012167692,
-0.4656824172,
1.2295992374,
-0.0700040907,
-0.1172550991,
-0.3330791295,
-0.173204422,
0.5254673958,
-0.2652716339,
0.3235295415,
0.5839064121,
0.308221221,
0.105458118,
-0.72004354,
-0.2235019058,
-0.0866459683,
-0.3933672011,
0.5077389479,
-0.2859258652,
0.7880219817,
-0.2558439076,
-0.7039512992,
-0.2318167686,
0.8760370016,
0.0928143039,
0.5228964686,
0.6452757716,
0.5889753103,
0.8759316802,
-0.1900545061,
0.8562921882,
-0.046677269,
0.1051569879,
0.8370954394,
-0.2809559107,
0.6001003981,
0.4221532047,
-0.0320223868,
0.55897367,
0.3267378509,
0.3674128652,
0.8671668172,
0.2271565646,
-0.5915607214,
-0.1895574927,
-0.102558665,
-0.068624042,
0.1288850605,
0.6205890179,
0.116053395,
0.1038995758,
0.0794133767,
-0.1532158554,
0.4830913544,
-0.5095309615,
1.0368051529,
0.0105384411,
-1.1440999508,
0.1654543579,
-0.3128645718,
0.7931223512,
-0.5862126946,
-0.2603293657,
-0.1315764487,
0.6019734144,
-0.0883184373,
-0.8395059109,
-0.0509766154,
-0.2337872088,
-0.0842495188,
-0.4768055081,
0.5511733294,
-0.935313642,
0.1636122763,
0.3892992437,
0.1654587388,
0.231492579,
0.1880138367,
-0.4709818959,
-0.0814189911,
0.0437841266,
0.1799708605,
0.2184377611,
0.8230732679,
0.1329346746,
0.5773890615,
0.5043691993,
0.2427639663,
0.127254352,
-0.2619481087,
0.647537291,
-0.4563859105,
-0.6273176074,
-0.4997905493,
0.2723144591,
-0.0959885791,
-0.4964826107,
0.775757134,
0.2516203821,
0.9048686028,
-0.1434617937,
0.4855068326,
0.1032141894,
0.4702039659,
-0.6207891703,
0.6443322301,
-0.1495549083,
-0.0508955605,
-0.2807701826,
-0.9154738188,
0.4013115168,
0.9070760012,
-0.4699681401,
-0.0094286613,
0.7411090136,
0.5303239822,
0.0998976901,
0.2688913941,
0.4489665926,
-0.2387511134,
0.5995622277,
0.7914333344,
1.0613741875,
-0.1989332438,
0.353515178,
-0.1877893656,
-0.0222250558,
0.0619093254,
-0.4189828932,
-1.1338511705,
-0.8071904778,
-0.2809224129,
-0.2560333014,
0.198769033,
0.9121123552,
0.5939429402,
-0.579480052,
-0.5751718879,
-0.1740787625,
0.175984621,
-0.6247118115,
-0.2545261383,
0.0079484005,
-0.3735499084,
-0.9260066152,
0.7167217731,
-0.0965675712,
-0.0375622585,
-0.446108222,
-0.6693228483,
-0.1819842011,
0.0400846973,
0.5106109381,
0.2308594882,
-0.5342677832,
-0.4118303359,
0.2102527916,
-0.2779076993,
-0.4503628016,
1.0029585361,
-0.8386319876,
0.679202199,
0.2582548559,
0.3807119131,
0.3636337817,
-0.1374353468,
0.9310904741,
-0.6128498912,
-0.2652807236,
0.5702400208,
-0.1380815208,
0.0787862018,
-0.3689515591,
0.5901361108,
0.2299515903,
-0.5355753899,
-0.6605825424,
0.2165541947,
-0.6818124056,
-0.0331972949,
1.0298509598,
-0.0857293829,
-0.3135920167,
-0.0784927011,
-0.5714544058,
0.3095778227,
-0.2378910929,
0.4856394827,
0.7120139599,
0.0442529321,
-0.1268525869,
-0.7035033107,
1.3620182276,
0.2265776545,
-0.6303662658,
0.0339920335,
0.5593746901,
-0.222521469,
0.2016014755,
0.8984116316,
0.3645737171,
0.258125037,
-0.0346771404,
0.2951562107,
0.2450226992,
-0.6836870313,
-0.1110303476,
-0.2530402541,
-0.0497378558,
-0.3317911327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10057v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10057v2 | WeCheck: Strong Factual Consistency Checker via Weakly Supervised Learning | 2022-12-20T08:04:36 | 2023-05-27T13:42:23 | Wenhao Wu, Wei Li, Xinyan Xiao, Jiachen Liu, Sujian Li, Yajuan Lv | cs.CL | cs.CL | A crucial issue of current text generation models is that they often
uncontrollably generate factually inconsistent text with respective of their
inputs. Limited by the lack of annotated data, existing works in evaluating
factual consistency directly transfer the reasoning ability of models trained
on other data-rich upstream tasks like question answering (QA) and natural
language inference (NLI) without any further adaptation. As a result, they
perform poorly on the real generated text and are biased heavily by their
single-source upstream tasks. To alleviate this problem, we propose a weakly
supervised framework that aggregates multiple resources to train a precise and
efficient factual metric, namely WeCheck. WeCheck first utilizes a generative
model to accurately label a real generated sample by aggregating its weak
labels, which are inferred from multiple resources. Then, we train the target
metric model with the weak supervision while taking noises into consideration.
Comprehensive experiments on a variety of tasks demonstrate the strong
performance of WeCheck, which achieves a 3.4\% absolute improvement over
previous state-of-the-art methods on TRUE benchmark on average. | [
-0.0931457132,
-0.7737645507,
0.6831967831,
-0.0288499352,
-0.2249895334,
-0.087781243,
-0.3171349466,
-0.6039645076,
-0.1594502181,
0.4966778457,
-0.5424994826,
-0.7355331779,
-0.7943300009,
0.1539685577,
-0.6046054959,
1.3110707998,
0.1001426503,
-0.2477449477,
-0.5107398033,
-0.2483044863,
-0.0035995899,
-0.031456925,
-0.4929189086,
-0.5375731587,
0.4808090031,
0.3988476694,
0.7690104842,
0.3550264835,
0.4882252514,
0.4170437157,
-0.3089692891,
0.4907557666,
-0.7822843194,
0.0926940516,
-0.6818051934,
-0.4190702736,
-0.1690990478,
0.0482077114,
0.4946090877,
0.6912115216,
-0.0105001191,
0.4204374552,
0.0842267945,
0.3500192463,
-1.0597862005,
0.0922811851,
-0.8033986092,
-0.0783021152,
-0.0556294061,
0.2530894578,
-0.437233597,
-0.6907554865,
-0.0135506354,
-0.5806610584,
0.6456042528,
-0.1052394435,
1.511951685,
0.638876617,
-0.7546813488,
-0.0104447957,
-0.6202486157,
0.8067212105,
-0.77495116,
0.3411395252,
0.7263973355,
-0.0668300092,
0.0379884355,
-0.9269642234,
-0.6921070814,
-0.1365528107,
-0.2961387038,
0.3298898637,
-0.1265220493,
-0.0463928208,
0.3187400401,
0.4196321666,
-0.280632019,
0.1568952799,
-0.3714243472,
-0.6072915792,
0.5886778235,
0.0119463736,
0.1441121697,
0.0021399534,
-0.4574264288,
-0.0239315946,
-0.3453176618,
0.0243771207,
0.4468059242,
0.318059653,
-0.1170875281,
0.6123598218,
-0.6902871132,
0.5350010991,
0.2524940073,
-0.397006005,
0.121689938,
-0.8175814152,
-0.0379773527,
0.2152316868,
0.8941803575,
0.0407316945,
-0.2382197529,
-0.3844945729,
-0.2635406852,
0.6560476422,
0.5499300957,
-0.9007483721,
-0.321062535,
0.1745713353,
-0.1767975092,
-0.4706807733,
0.1366303265,
-0.5645706654,
-0.4374879301,
-0.3142564893,
0.6116053462,
-0.4089648128,
-0.1668297797,
0.0725442693,
0.071476154,
-0.0829601437,
0.2255099267,
-0.7792992592,
0.3546236455,
0.7081222534,
0.6539711952,
-0.0951649696,
-0.3151671588,
-0.9398010373,
-0.0000685922,
-0.4531010687,
0.9957868457,
0.048906263,
-0.030244479,
0.1486372799,
0.007424261,
0.2318875343,
-0.4652905762,
1.0466061831,
-0.3465319872,
0.016703492,
-0.4449442327,
-0.6702664495,
-0.0042837192,
0.4761645794,
-0.5920704007,
1.2220826149,
0.032539539,
-0.9686615467,
0.8888372183,
0.029203454,
-0.6132986546,
-0.0626455992,
0.0520942733,
-1.0231524706,
-0.0074208584,
0.1484083831,
0.3320674002,
-0.2349299937,
0.6566354632,
-0.2950625718,
-0.6607269645,
0.0988790616,
-0.3965865374,
0.9994590282,
-0.0224298108,
-0.6689130068,
0.0849502012,
-1.0767869949,
0.1286507845,
-0.1106084436,
-0.4247285724,
-0.2612169385,
0.0535164587,
0.0144614466,
0.0038396823,
0.3704396784,
-0.7063580155,
-0.0575306527,
-0.1071173921,
-0.1335367858,
0.6482556462,
0.05344842,
0.3435247242,
-0.1438476443,
-0.0358434245,
0.1656951308,
0.0139857279,
0.0692536905,
-0.3167979419,
-1.0426123142,
-0.5436656475,
0.5286752582,
0.574352026,
-0.5935063958,
0.7201703191,
-0.2670436203,
-0.5109456778,
-0.4010109901,
0.720941782,
0.50659132,
0.733541131,
0.4075481892,
-0.1932378113,
-0.4824108779,
-1.0322554111,
-0.1494103074,
-0.6182894111,
-0.0586894974,
-0.3550592363,
0.4258553386,
-0.539654851,
0.9417455792,
-0.4020702839,
-0.3057940602,
-0.120537743,
0.6495511532,
0.0433563739,
0.450523138,
0.1513023078,
-0.6220034957,
-0.3513400555,
-0.1882854551,
-0.9423196316,
-0.2654616535,
-0.3522171974,
-0.3558178246,
0.0871131644,
0.3392298222,
-0.5538086891,
0.3920768499,
0.5919073224,
-0.5629402399,
0.3250843883,
-0.0834824592,
0.0777214617,
-0.7902476788,
0.0171514098,
0.1409911215,
-0.4473686516,
-0.1740145832,
-0.0202571545,
0.2722198367,
0.234986797,
-0.2391857952,
0.2539116442,
-0.2507392168,
0.1530661732,
-0.2281769961,
0.1594432741,
0.3214200735,
0.3992421627,
-0.0526073016,
0.5860596895,
0.5792968869,
-0.5604255795,
0.3186385036,
0.3022190332,
-0.2837216556,
0.9534547329,
-0.5838683844,
0.0473446101,
-0.0005458295,
0.2241357267,
-1.0573364496,
-0.2547350824,
-0.133340314,
-0.1251390576,
0.3194879293,
-0.2558399737,
-0.7763800621,
-0.1372063756,
-0.1837193817,
-0.013392143,
0.5561783314,
-0.8328979015,
0.4118410349,
0.1415239125,
0.0965841934,
-0.4601205885,
-0.5089173317,
0.0448314548,
0.2749940753,
-0.6019856334,
0.1056457832,
0.354065448,
-0.3015060127,
0.2710345387,
-0.5140116811,
-0.5163016319,
0.0483910777,
0.317206502,
0.4064373672,
-0.3649155498,
0.0976158231,
0.041566059,
-0.060163334,
-0.0843544006,
-0.3091952503,
-0.4139636159,
-0.2771550715,
-0.4292345345,
-0.7227429748,
0.0821657181,
0.4720159769,
-0.0791824982,
0.9253633618,
1.1115452051,
-0.3545347154,
-0.3278245628,
-0.6775203943,
-0.3988235891,
-0.4527749121,
0.256996274,
-0.0592107624,
-0.7360357642,
0.3679537773,
-0.269340694,
0.1749028414,
0.4868551195,
0.2441204637,
-0.1587839723,
0.8958354592,
0.663688302,
0.0186497066,
0.0909562185,
-0.0840530619,
0.131045416,
-0.1302164197,
-0.1096894518,
-0.5402474403,
-0.1598397195,
-0.5894892216,
-0.2234805375,
0.2334691882,
0.2376930267,
-0.1437257379,
0.1969667971,
-0.2708214521,
0.4569774866,
0.6798272133,
0.2428773791,
0.4317029715,
-0.2801111639,
0.0271190926,
-0.0704090521,
-0.5641809702,
-0.4781269729,
0.8478804827,
0.1504973024,
0.7690334916,
0.0699807182,
0.7206248045,
0.2691345215,
0.5105940104,
-0.581902504,
0.3967829943,
-0.1776344776,
-0.8045389652,
-0.236747086,
-0.5399652719,
-0.4606213272,
0.2226385027,
-0.8059947491,
-0.540643394,
0.0693402961,
0.5259869695,
-0.1512317061,
0.4799390733,
-0.8669377565,
0.9255205989,
0.0611693524,
-1.1151074171,
0.0480632223,
-0.5292400718,
0.7515714169,
0.0493397415,
-0.1029447168,
-0.0836350545,
0.2488734722,
0.389578402,
-0.6002150178,
1.2538096905,
-0.0328792594,
-0.2770492733,
0.76012218,
-0.0988018438,
0.9645183682,
0.4255206585,
0.0285229273,
0.4709454477,
-0.1414105743,
-0.7536267042,
-0.3614169955,
0.5235714316,
-0.6812039018,
-0.2236071676,
-0.5159311295,
-0.2631677985,
-0.4196920991,
0.2658759952,
0.4679809511,
0.3434220552,
-0.3379890025,
0.1701885164,
0.9493171573,
0.2147182524,
-0.0445165187,
0.397223115,
0.2936687768,
0.0446185283,
0.9777260423,
-0.3419691026,
0.1287401915,
0.2243965268,
0.2207763791,
-0.4354957342,
-0.4314620793,
-0.4123518169,
0.0991165414,
-0.736192584,
-0.4735638499,
-0.7432470918,
-0.1254943013,
-0.2357650548,
-0.1280402392,
-0.8919097185,
-0.1957267672,
-0.0620051436,
-0.2853852212,
0.2386296839,
0.6985098124,
-0.2071201801,
0.1719594896,
-0.6586695313,
0.7963513136,
0.7828170061,
0.4576304257,
-0.6129289865,
-0.3510466516,
-0.2650827169,
-0.1293020695,
-0.322480619,
-0.6466015577,
-0.4373291433,
0.1598643959,
0.3996653259,
0.5862810016,
0.2073076963,
0.3685425818,
-0.448187232,
0.727568984,
0.1969140023,
-1.0539032221,
0.3990709782,
-0.1049835756,
0.4011612833,
1.1630151272,
0.0942369848,
-0.0527907647,
-0.9079655409,
-0.7044224739,
-0.7721768022,
0.5009926558,
0.315163523,
-0.1440703869,
0.1048170105,
0.0404419154,
0.2916831672,
0.0429257639,
-0.5927276611,
-0.0593634546,
-0.53089118,
-0.3462581933,
0.0458812453,
-0.366695106,
-0.2486804575,
0.0341923572,
0.9510250688,
-0.4117703736,
-0.2020788342,
0.0700701699,
-0.0921359956,
-0.1134620085,
0.5085378885,
0.3815941811,
0.6997231841,
-0.2881506681,
0.6980672479,
0.2965857685,
-0.5663194656,
0.159353435,
0.0275886171,
-0.5004398227,
0.2270890623,
0.5489782095,
0.5719322562,
0.274397254,
-0.5990165472,
0.5631574392,
-0.0636577159,
-0.3864172697,
0.1397010982,
0.2433176786,
0.1948460191,
0.1051956415,
0.0728366524,
0.4186199307,
0.1629593074,
-0.5263754129,
0.3562342227,
0.263451308,
-0.5236874819,
-0.4161964655,
0.7187518477,
0.1711823195,
0.3422501981,
0.6185732484,
-0.6464474797,
-0.5879382491,
0.4212906659,
0.5922569036,
0.6604235768,
0.2619597614,
0.4134085476,
0.7569412589,
0.5696941614,
-0.5793265104,
0.1345607936,
-0.2073448896,
-0.7703593969,
-0.6086039543,
-0.6256299615,
-0.6383668184,
0.116525948,
-0.661585331,
0.124425523,
-0.4579277039,
-0.2420157939,
-0.0801219046,
-0.003866371,
-0.7125485539,
0.6493704319,
0.159127757,
0.4228473604,
-1.1867115498,
0.5417206287,
0.7204546928,
-0.4271210432,
-0.6527664661,
0.2009360492,
0.2480296791,
-0.251899153,
0.5530542731,
-0.1285730451,
-0.4022360742,
-0.3945068717,
-0.8084387779,
-0.6378324032,
0.6768392324,
0.5304626226,
-0.4121725261,
0.3464707136,
-0.2750826776,
0.6418067813,
0.3969173729,
-0.0841615424,
0.3193129301,
0.4119879305,
0.1531951725,
-0.5937991738,
0.2045015991,
-0.1545698941,
-0.3449206054,
0.0167401899,
-0.7274826765,
0.5152591467,
-0.3911901414,
-0.2516972721,
-0.1357486546,
1.111464262,
0.3281413317,
0.409455359,
0.6859906316,
0.7017297745,
1.0582553148,
-0.1376135498,
0.959835887,
0.0159214139,
0.4870657921,
1.2956342697,
-0.4138181508,
0.6749051213,
0.382209599,
-0.2000686079,
0.4627566636,
0.2783873379,
-0.0521220863,
0.4377810359,
-0.1182027757,
-0.5106066465,
-0.7102974057,
-0.3050401509,
0.0499579869,
0.5735889077,
-0.0307664517,
0.2095429152,
-0.2842750549,
-0.5782289505,
-0.09629675,
0.5522354841,
-0.044333443,
0.6740654707,
-0.1775280088,
-0.6802744865,
0.5622061491,
0.016553754,
0.7760291696,
-0.5919905305,
-0.1225839704,
-0.2366400361,
0.2867160141,
-0.3658953905,
-0.3956422508,
0.1996077895,
0.2691078186,
-0.2624656558,
-0.1264955401,
0.8880838752,
-0.4257849753,
-0.7281790972,
-0.0316593871,
0.4091425836,
-0.2064284682,
0.2181811184,
-0.2922962904,
-0.0183551535,
-0.1547193378,
-0.0730627328,
0.0441885293,
0.7340202928,
0.0081946105,
0.2644323111,
0.713773787,
0.1419817954,
0.1047325879,
0.0617478788,
0.6494647264,
-0.3558852375,
-0.6546006799,
-0.5395534039,
0.5595613718,
-0.3787360191,
-0.4497637451,
0.7044898272,
0.6466964483,
0.8243123889,
0.236451447,
0.8271978498,
0.010617231,
0.5001225471,
-0.6017938256,
0.6926814914,
-0.4592250884,
-0.0558184721,
-0.2327302098,
-0.7281847596,
-0.0435191952,
0.5322511196,
0.0002629244,
-0.2231339514,
0.8965440392,
0.5132441521,
-0.5671874285,
0.1199476346,
0.3417533934,
0.362380594,
-0.0914981216,
0.2584766448,
0.6916778684,
-0.5092964768,
0.5755723715,
-0.5303310156,
0.0241089799,
0.0237600133,
-0.907073617,
-1.1279088259,
-0.3412332237,
-0.7531501651,
-0.6829183698,
0.0403747,
0.4749262035,
0.7645304799,
-1.0928715467,
0.3350328505,
-0.203215614,
0.3891410828,
-0.3577651978,
-0.2360227257,
0.3784300983,
-0.7990941405,
-0.6821225286,
0.3001832068,
0.1637957543,
-0.1786877811,
-0.2049011439,
0.206240654,
-0.292095989,
0.1191789284,
0.3054745793,
0.2714123428,
-0.3639570773,
-0.4076998234,
-0.2806733549,
-0.6053847075,
-0.1956730634,
0.5841325521,
-0.6030948162,
0.3479475379,
0.4059323967,
1.0346962214,
0.6878474355,
0.2134877443,
0.206955865,
-0.9630624652,
0.2954676151,
0.0256629288,
0.2567468584,
0.5942827463,
-0.4965886176,
0.4832627177,
0.4190033376,
-0.29161641,
-0.7808206081,
0.0782690644,
-0.9688362479,
-0.1477174908,
1.0600931644,
-0.3324238658,
-0.2159848511,
-0.2655163705,
0.0295843389,
0.4880476892,
-0.2337382138,
1.0874323845,
0.5835872293,
0.2256962657,
0.307264626,
-0.4213295579,
0.5259170532,
0.6117144227,
-0.8613183498,
-0.1506567597,
0.6837973595,
0.3761200309,
0.3391887546,
0.72556144,
0.1935847104,
0.3434511721,
0.5575711727,
0.0575628355,
0.1921148449,
-0.1776351035,
0.1741310805,
0.2746278346,
-0.1019445807,
-0.0780118331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10051v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10051v1 | A Framework of Customer Review Analysis Using the Aspect-Based Opinion Mining Approach | 2022-12-20T07:54:58 | 2022-12-20T07:54:58 | Subhasis Dasgupta, Jaydip Sen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Opinion mining is the branch of computation that deals with opinions,
appraisals, attitudes, and emotions of people and their different aspects. This
field has attracted substantial research interest in recent years. Aspect-level
(called aspect-based opinion mining) is often desired in practical applications
as it provides detailed opinions or sentiments about different aspects of
entities and entities themselves, which are usually required for action. Aspect
extraction and entity extraction are thus two core tasks of aspect-based
opinion mining. his paper has presented a framework of aspect-based opinion
mining based on the concept of transfer learning. on real-world customer
reviews available on the Amazon website. The model has yielded quite
satisfactory results in its task of aspect-based opinion mining. | [
-0.6950989962,
-0.7249820232,
0.386526078,
0.1938823164,
-0.0087419394,
0.0863832235,
0.4025005698,
-0.7517459989,
0.2874433994,
0.8667026162,
-0.7268931866,
-0.5190502405,
-0.2034190446,
-0.1607269198,
-0.5329220891,
1.4112743139,
-0.0469258688,
0.1656616777,
-0.159021616,
-0.2139446139,
-0.1978725791,
-0.9213293791,
-0.8091083765,
-0.4423010051,
0.2397901714,
0.5334358811,
0.5436236262,
-0.0267816801,
0.5184742212,
0.2333139181,
-0.0523948483,
-0.2278266549,
-0.0823670924,
0.3288885057,
-0.4958883226,
-0.8361552954,
-0.7392349243,
0.2523792982,
0.212062031,
0.7169423103,
-0.1270976067,
0.2878136933,
0.2514036,
0.932975471,
-0.2494321316,
0.196702674,
-0.3409851789,
0.317119509,
0.2701227963,
-0.1545707136,
-0.0975687206,
-0.4303313792,
0.4920072258,
-0.2586913705,
0.5890715122,
0.1618708074,
0.8360614777,
-0.4362005889,
-0.2169378251,
-0.5164519548,
-1.1570060253,
0.8132408857,
-0.5224055648,
0.2204038352,
0.3705647886,
0.3171545565,
0.2032092512,
-0.167889744,
-0.6911237836,
0.2566636801,
-0.2979125679,
-0.007370335,
0.0008619464,
0.1373703629,
0.1725216657,
0.9139600396,
0.0346225463,
-0.1878414303,
-0.4963821173,
-0.0401218198,
0.5576810241,
0.2028137892,
0.0127358129,
-0.9037290812,
-0.4973526597,
0.0688134506,
-0.5368956327,
0.6886681914,
0.4708614647,
0.0597340837,
0.1113302335,
0.3776667118,
-0.6616694927,
0.4575302601,
0.4044993818,
-0.2477985471,
0.4159482718,
-0.1349708438,
-0.3501057923,
0.0723251179,
0.6538449526,
0.4286616743,
-0.2107277364,
0.0476318114,
-0.5984529257,
-0.2231619358,
0.5246437192,
-0.6324906349,
-0.138229996,
0.5207382441,
-1.0191054344,
-0.7652490139,
0.3382287621,
-1.1738761663,
-0.4899258912,
-0.4031947553,
0.2138019204,
-0.3214700818,
-0.803783834,
-0.4654353559,
0.0376893133,
0.1812350154,
0.2337087393,
-0.522294879,
0.412725091,
1.0898969173,
0.6391465664,
-0.2193913162,
-0.2220500857,
-0.0065680365,
-0.211482957,
0.0505282804,
1.2896592617,
-0.7708655596,
-0.4596388936,
0.0403114222,
0.1694905609,
0.32469365,
-0.6840914488,
0.6029009223,
-0.6265230179,
0.1967934668,
-0.2024180144,
-0.5281965733,
-0.8408105373,
0.8536510468,
-0.7532439828,
1.0126706362,
0.5228005052,
-0.4983170927,
0.5309319496,
-0.5644158125,
-0.4535450041,
0.072202526,
0.1047134623,
-0.5724489689,
0.4563435614,
0.2793416679,
0.3686195314,
-0.2386049628,
-0.2462011278,
-0.4179701209,
0.163819313,
0.5824940801,
0.0761883557,
0.4185368121,
0.6255049109,
-0.332369566,
0.1692727357,
-0.6126235127,
0.1173339859,
-0.3439949453,
-0.2130391449,
-0.5224280953,
0.0495448634,
0.1034519523,
0.4031016827,
0.1089467853,
-0.5149482489,
0.1972279549,
-0.6057374477,
0.537098825,
0.4996389151,
0.7755536437,
0.7664811611,
-0.3186800182,
0.8667981029,
0.4981708229,
0.4459451735,
-0.1433127075,
-0.1855445504,
-1.0832765102,
0.2435855567,
0.4073367119,
0.4148937166,
-0.6962763667,
0.6834290028,
-0.1217681244,
-0.6915026307,
-0.5795139074,
0.166376248,
0.2097200006,
0.3131865561,
0.0976930484,
-0.7736634016,
-0.3573103547,
-1.049194932,
-0.3994475007,
-0.5236290693,
0.29151389,
0.1493299454,
0.0444106348,
0.0811511874,
1.101657033,
-0.4450424612,
-0.4706002772,
-0.6522663236,
0.3324800432,
0.3231441081,
0.3832220137,
0.3958360255,
-0.9666244388,
-0.3392647803,
0.0717683583,
-0.6581094861,
0.1964549124,
-0.193977505,
-0.1370223314,
0.2393024117,
-0.0724899173,
-0.2625015974,
0.5179361701,
0.3335365951,
-0.1155091003,
0.3744007051,
0.1388343126,
0.6317597032,
-1.1709647179,
-0.2661168873,
0.4357849061,
-0.421210587,
-0.5905169249,
0.0366789065,
-0.2584691644,
-0.3285111189,
-0.3578709364,
0.0537716709,
-0.3866121173,
-0.3372692168,
-0.7039797306,
-0.3354284167,
0.2494104207,
0.7760821581,
0.1666771173,
0.1792396754,
0.4936736226,
-0.8145266175,
0.4687569737,
-0.0207065661,
-0.5585986972,
1.4132809639,
-0.0907770991,
0.2381231487,
0.0373876877,
0.0718584284,
-0.68880409,
0.0713874698,
0.3166779876,
-0.4240968525,
0.0436237976,
-0.3679377735,
-0.0562757924,
-0.143543601,
-0.2820943296,
0.0775340572,
0.4275348783,
-0.3671335876,
0.8653031588,
0.645377934,
-0.4177243412,
-0.226978302,
-0.3152555227,
-0.1863299161,
-0.4481218457,
-0.1966109127,
0.2485977858,
0.3526787758,
-0.4429968297,
0.4707965553,
-0.1608894765,
-0.4147011042,
-0.1169396415,
0.4996261597,
0.0771242157,
-0.0095789554,
-0.1090149358,
-0.0652521402,
-0.0740161687,
0.4803438485,
0.0378139503,
0.5043307543,
-0.1242116541,
-0.0849203095,
-0.4686024189,
0.4969467223,
0.4179331362,
0.0240795054,
0.399083823,
0.289573431,
-0.55439502,
-0.4808993936,
-0.5944395661,
-0.1309510469,
-0.3841349781,
0.5934230685,
-0.6022037268,
-0.3490479589,
0.4914619625,
-0.0805053115,
0.0768298507,
0.709017992,
0.5014438629,
-0.2604280114,
0.8421994448,
0.8284390569,
-0.4406096041,
0.7538076043,
-0.2247968167,
0.5152724385,
-1.0223031044,
-0.4466411471,
-0.6840475798,
-0.566876471,
-0.3916275501,
0.2192036211,
0.1282509267,
0.3986125886,
0.1559521705,
0.3451454341,
-0.5335686207,
0.2334501445,
0.4077033401,
0.3888450563,
0.3107824028,
0.3129190505,
0.4075400233,
0.0200971197,
0.0054119811,
-0.4363392889,
0.9469163418,
0.5102589726,
0.5496880412,
0.0341181606,
0.5053386688,
0.6985557675,
0.4536012709,
-1.0768120289,
0.4850773811,
0.2352666557,
-0.6924631,
-0.0788588375,
-0.4039179981,
-0.5155672431,
0.1019512564,
-0.5464186668,
-0.5034757853,
0.5233721137,
-0.0109128915,
-0.22021541,
0.4075957835,
-0.581771791,
0.4625249803,
-0.2818830609,
-0.186518237,
-0.6006620526,
-0.0394191854,
0.3476964533,
-0.0208967999,
0.5168972015,
0.0179378577,
0.4699988067,
1.0573986769,
-0.5593841672,
0.6254470348,
-0.6321259737,
0.155127883,
0.5627533793,
0.4873874784,
0.2291692048,
0.1412138194,
-0.0940596461,
0.3644066751,
0.1165384576,
-0.1837350279,
-0.8727858067,
0.8930042386,
-0.8334188461,
-0.5141645074,
-0.6663191319,
-0.1527436674,
-0.429756254,
0.0382686332,
-0.0283138715,
0.2866758704,
-0.2269721329,
-0.0577278137,
0.5532413721,
0.027947532,
0.2606466711,
0.4361370802,
-0.5485631227,
-0.448238045,
0.9083698392,
0.0214883536,
-0.0194515791,
0.4232757092,
0.0563672371,
-0.0710926205,
-0.6516519785,
-0.3477002978,
-0.0533095449,
-0.7450399399,
-0.2234165221,
-0.7723690271,
-0.4082026184,
-0.309215039,
0.2709564865,
-0.3054635227,
-0.4701228738,
0.1430550814,
-0.3405874372,
0.2454144508,
1.0170999765,
0.3912238181,
0.4640545249,
-0.9601989388,
0.1206274182,
0.2409570515,
0.3771400154,
0.1995772868,
-0.1650818288,
-0.35695225,
-0.1885693073,
-0.6608837247,
-0.9023308754,
0.5376961827,
-0.1186479032,
0.5401846766,
0.6090757847,
-0.1273137331,
0.5273171663,
0.1793615371,
1.0656604767,
0.2741160393,
-1.0364800692,
0.5242314935,
0.2081150413,
-0.3047066331,
0.7058675885,
0.3886846304,
-0.6772174835,
-0.1113281101,
-1.0293405056,
-0.8319864869,
0.943603158,
-0.0765455589,
-0.1124946252,
0.4582740963,
0.7963098884,
0.4485330582,
0.4970773757,
-0.7243888974,
-0.3096383512,
-0.3122545779,
-0.1798771024,
0.188875854,
-0.4433205724,
0.1463999748,
-0.0651798993,
0.7638254166,
0.2832902968,
0.3060853481,
0.3180840909,
-0.2420853674,
-0.2536443472,
0.6038541198,
-0.127570346,
0.8191794157,
-0.2970950603,
0.0495852232,
0.0147867864,
-0.4732949436,
0.0603346638,
-0.1733864695,
-0.3396870792,
-0.2487521917,
0.1666242629,
0.7499861717,
-0.0569142289,
-0.0914616883,
0.5759272575,
0.0624248721,
-0.1158271357,
-0.575504601,
-0.0209216326,
-0.349748075,
0.1284605712,
0.4453542233,
0.4983543456,
0.6540879607,
-1.0134446621,
0.0703667924,
0.3518904746,
-1.0133359432,
-0.6574393511,
0.0828346759,
0.4917737842,
-0.6554338336,
0.4879129529,
-0.0444862917,
-0.7961896658,
0.4046908617,
0.128433764,
1.1409846544,
-0.2437274605,
0.164815858,
0.3090468943,
0.0989934579,
0.0845793709,
0.1654569358,
-0.1490742564,
-0.6044198871,
-0.1278038323,
-0.8785345554,
-0.7131613493,
0.1601075083,
-1.0373132229,
0.3262939453,
-0.708142519,
-0.0846434683,
0.1162544563,
0.1746332198,
-0.6447953582,
0.6726944447,
-0.1018812284,
0.4447092116,
-0.8029662967,
0.8615424037,
0.7794368267,
-0.4767569005,
-0.7814121246,
0.1315218359,
-0.0407116376,
-0.5561528802,
0.3568438292,
0.1788000166,
-0.0495976582,
-0.7053465843,
-0.2580563724,
-0.3613591492,
0.6801957488,
-0.5901899934,
-0.5257149339,
0.1703420281,
0.1465394944,
0.7108824253,
-0.8702607155,
0.3007355332,
0.7669072151,
0.1069597751,
0.0301106777,
-0.537494421,
-0.0029716829,
-0.2917767763,
-0.1128503978,
0.2594486177,
-0.5005411506,
1.029938817,
0.5540936589,
0.0038839197,
-0.4497044981,
1.0067001581,
-0.1208842248,
0.4787659943,
1.1790720224,
0.3569939137,
0.498393029,
0.121077694,
0.9711149335,
-0.4960298836,
0.5729736686,
0.654067874,
-0.2651552856,
1.0343819857,
0.3123910129,
-0.3752145469,
1.0435160398,
0.7428384423,
0.1575719267,
0.5471014977,
-0.1255933046,
-0.0111699784,
-0.1986931264,
0.0667629316,
-0.2897238433,
0.1398961544,
0.4877027869,
-0.5408227444,
0.1246974617,
-0.1749189943,
-0.0895798802,
-0.1347316056,
-0.8558040857,
1.1490963697,
0.1505895853,
-1.0060632229,
-0.1568059027,
0.1851197481,
0.597163558,
-0.4758093953,
-0.3239520788,
-0.2290300429,
0.3418878019,
-0.8672956228,
-1.0519202948,
0.6159275174,
0.0855650604,
-0.6961753368,
-0.1073195636,
0.7011684775,
-0.0716659427,
-0.6810159683,
-0.1049901024,
0.4242713749,
0.1664772928,
-0.3249840438,
-0.8354498744,
-0.3633410633,
0.391217947,
-0.4470545053,
0.4563691318,
0.4574043751,
-0.2489539236,
0.1904049814,
0.5658900738,
0.3064002395,
-0.3710360229,
-0.0790018365,
0.7115193009,
-1.1179201603,
-0.9345316887,
-0.642701447,
0.2613188028,
-0.4497184157,
-0.2582020164,
0.6852113605,
0.7832992077,
0.6969563961,
0.1856570244,
1.1352872849,
-0.2610313594,
1.032038331,
-0.4868861139,
0.5304175019,
-0.2435959727,
0.4820661247,
-0.403011471,
-1.3968846798,
0.1544584036,
0.5627214313,
-0.5522972345,
-0.0637847632,
0.9852769375,
0.5454780459,
-0.0425281227,
0.6770015955,
-0.2273021787,
0.1078314632,
0.5530660152,
0.328784436,
0.8229045868,
-0.3693245649,
0.5306062102,
-0.6427615881,
-0.4426907599,
-0.0052823783,
-0.5077570677,
-0.7699754238,
-0.4856189787,
-0.4263835549,
-0.9213354588,
-0.5817909837,
0.8362186551,
0.7151095867,
-1.0535103083,
-0.3513156176,
-0.0462238714,
0.1727443337,
-0.6582402587,
-0.3799102604,
0.3661812246,
-0.2464034706,
-0.9106453061,
0.0001931279,
0.1714933515,
-0.3940246999,
-0.8178788424,
0.135391444,
0.3357140422,
-0.0700104684,
0.3532680571,
0.1162706539,
-0.4383058846,
-0.2821527719,
-0.3088392019,
0.1311284602,
0.2816953361,
1.1780334711,
-0.6211692095,
0.3186897337,
0.4841819108,
0.2361591458,
0.792796731,
0.3298858404,
0.5587707162,
-0.4967783093,
0.029054841,
0.0943750814,
0.2779386044,
0.4704171121,
-0.741507709,
0.260411799,
0.2244398296,
-0.5748654604,
-0.4976285398,
0.4181604385,
-1.1556966305,
-0.2194066048,
1.0924873352,
-0.2605499327,
-0.5659381151,
-0.231516093,
-0.247344926,
-0.3410883248,
-0.6509398818,
0.8128123283,
0.8939840198,
-0.6515210271,
-0.1089251712,
-0.1983510703,
0.59868294,
0.0724330023,
-1.0267213583,
-0.2099427134,
0.2938091159,
0.5742417574,
0.3848688602,
0.47339046,
-0.1847670525,
-0.0012896878,
-0.2032949477,
0.2155269086,
0.0549753904,
-0.2319708019,
-0.5972895026,
0.9575995207,
0.2529101074,
-0.0740480572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10047v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10047v2 | An Augmentation Strategy for Visually Rich Documents | 2022-12-20T07:44:25 | 2022-12-22T09:13:04 | Jing Xie, James B. Wendt, Yichao Zhou, Seth Ebner, Sandeep Tata | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many business workflows require extracting important fields from form-like
documents (e.g. bank statements, bills of lading, purchase orders, etc.).
Recent techniques for automating this task work well only when trained with
large datasets. In this work we propose a novel data augmentation technique to
improve performance when training data is scarce, e.g. 10-250 documents. Our
technique, which we call FieldSwap, works by swapping out the key phrases of a
source field with the key phrases of a target field to generate new synthetic
examples of the target field for use in training. We demonstrate that this
approach can yield 1-7 F1 point improvements in extraction performance. | [
-0.352024436,
-0.7455974221,
0.2031321526,
0.1328877062,
-0.3284800947,
0.1468549222,
0.0555509962,
-0.9806267619,
0.0863820314,
0.7395331264,
-0.6898818016,
-0.3335662186,
-0.6855946183,
-0.0759007186,
-0.4259806871,
0.8387141228,
-0.192255646,
-0.3385668099,
-0.2269788384,
-0.2962784767,
-0.440187186,
-0.2293819189,
-0.4391371608,
-0.1660151333,
0.1799519956,
0.3253870606,
0.722401917,
0.8676069975,
0.5074253082,
0.4528658092,
0.19859685,
0.5672997832,
-0.220673576,
0.6131823063,
-0.302166909,
-0.5819408298,
-0.2792195082,
0.1404947937,
0.3489103913,
0.7298502326,
0.2523159385,
0.1261706203,
0.0679828748,
0.819319427,
-0.7838037014,
0.6362505555,
-0.6030466557,
0.4049225748,
-0.3836371601,
-0.5716974735,
-0.1012420654,
-0.0365243219,
0.32946679,
-1.0705208778,
0.8200185299,
-0.0944523662,
1.0335446596,
-0.2520284355,
0.0885543227,
0.0192217045,
-0.5903334618,
0.3714676797,
-0.7279464602,
0.329882443,
0.2877161205,
0.4504195154,
0.0269000065,
-0.8212346435,
-0.6239128113,
0.3443882167,
-0.1867761016,
0.4097892642,
-0.015165736,
0.0384453312,
0.8523887992,
0.5043519735,
-0.2278529108,
-0.0788766593,
-0.5687417388,
-0.0248408616,
0.772396028,
0.1032214686,
0.1372682452,
0.1247677132,
-0.0135918176,
-0.6527364254,
-0.230911687,
0.1196862012,
0.2027622461,
0.0835268572,
0.1092293113,
0.7321608663,
-0.7385935187,
1.0808397532,
0.0966360942,
-0.2038998008,
0.4209578335,
-0.0014614163,
-0.6354497671,
-0.2390099764,
0.2450754941,
0.3260364532,
-0.2780691683,
-0.2722322941,
-0.3067602515,
-0.092141673,
0.1991043389,
-0.6442401409,
-0.2002683729,
0.0502573363,
-0.3038596511,
-0.6416309476,
0.2510170341,
-1.0442245007,
-0.5372824669,
-0.336117208,
0.4105441272,
-0.6456218362,
0.1248432547,
-0.3265905976,
-0.7826587558,
0.3099687397,
0.6545149088,
-1.3718694448,
0.0127928518,
0.5657423735,
0.8311135769,
0.1729848534,
-0.272174418,
-0.8205713034,
0.4120093286,
-0.4612774253,
1.0521800518,
-0.7656494975,
-0.4875811934,
0.3037580252,
0.0018142386,
0.2651363909,
-0.7625908256,
0.3443729877,
-0.486469537,
0.1889284402,
-0.0763537064,
-0.2651794553,
-0.0200849865,
0.2197872549,
-1.0427969694,
1.2705967426,
0.894213438,
-0.2945896983,
0.9207728505,
-0.8477637172,
-0.637147963,
0.349573642,
-0.3267484009,
-0.5157217979,
0.3651933968,
0.5383687019,
0.5588038564,
0.121541433,
-0.3276523948,
-0.3468806744,
-0.180790931,
0.1878638566,
-0.3016755283,
0.4361214042,
0.1602488756,
-0.3416701555,
-0.2220376581,
-1.0442218781,
0.0992102623,
-0.0416544154,
-0.4645116031,
-0.3497152627,
-0.3872808814,
0.2578542531,
0.3350532651,
-0.0591365434,
-0.4538007975,
0.4604246318,
-1.0428007841,
0.2201287299,
0.4359970689,
-0.1093801409,
0.800303638,
-0.4268193841,
0.5237987041,
-0.0320458747,
0.056470979,
-0.4582129419,
-0.1432834268,
-0.6546284556,
-0.6248209476,
0.1097547561,
0.3021218777,
-0.7374122739,
0.4949109554,
-0.0755038634,
-0.5828039646,
-0.6037511826,
0.4260346591,
-0.088119939,
0.8002803326,
0.5358380675,
-0.1858126223,
-0.5494191647,
-0.8898754716,
-0.4663721919,
0.3752292097,
-0.0910700709,
0.1004358381,
0.0523223802,
-0.0954755321,
1.0386875868,
-0.7162519097,
-0.4326658845,
-0.1561773866,
0.5311484337,
0.0892425776,
0.4304566681,
0.4218870997,
-0.8135443926,
-0.4745570421,
0.1324547529,
-0.7011005282,
-0.1715985239,
-0.5167453289,
-0.3319990337,
0.206884563,
0.4206790328,
-0.95585078,
0.6677008271,
0.1969055533,
-0.21798186,
0.0587188825,
-0.2397454679,
0.2840382159,
-0.8267706633,
0.1411813647,
0.07967446,
-0.3385291994,
-0.4224675596,
0.2599969506,
0.3243713975,
-0.7347624898,
-0.1736594588,
0.5617690086,
-0.9423354864,
-0.2624791861,
-0.4240322113,
0.0540601648,
0.5971949697,
0.2835918367,
0.2313260436,
0.6113111377,
0.6230803132,
-0.3421657979,
0.4786279202,
0.5748488307,
-0.3630753458,
0.5986997485,
-0.1136053056,
-0.2160059661,
-0.3501605988,
0.2796123922,
-0.8747888803,
-0.280017674,
-0.0978007987,
-0.1657608598,
0.6440707445,
-0.1170564145,
-0.3600144088,
-0.3619555235,
-0.4347364008,
-0.1478529572,
0.6311402321,
-0.7752996087,
0.8819019198,
0.2396951616,
-0.244900167,
-0.4362056851,
-0.6999572515,
0.0896927789,
-0.2472246438,
-0.762973249,
0.7950660586,
0.6197540164,
0.0776518956,
-0.1893310994,
-0.3892828226,
-0.1312382519,
0.2148910314,
0.4132325053,
0.4714721739,
0.0267575253,
0.027303651,
0.3391734064,
0.0236188769,
-0.1222787201,
-0.3648253381,
0.3171184957,
0.3283693194,
-0.1052238196,
-0.2379099429,
0.6524600983,
0.5455205441,
-0.3926559389,
0.4513017237,
0.6346930861,
-0.4691199958,
-0.4831091166,
-0.6090406775,
-0.0579129308,
-0.5624316931,
0.357843101,
-0.3956783414,
-0.3786408603,
0.2342723608,
-0.4076488614,
0.6446219087,
0.79062289,
0.1429889947,
-0.4829984009,
0.7713663578,
0.7338176966,
0.1584031135,
0.8270391822,
-0.7210876346,
0.2426614016,
-0.5110280514,
-0.5036638975,
-0.3738656044,
-0.1939354241,
-0.1831157506,
-0.6203002334,
0.3667319119,
0.3491238654,
0.5966030955,
0.4330825806,
-0.4031864703,
0.3715838194,
0.4881000817,
0.284610033,
0.0665507764,
0.539026916,
0.2763211429,
-0.1499386132,
-0.6444135904,
-0.2559072971,
0.9874543548,
0.1261328161,
0.6426956058,
-0.0448364802,
0.947229445,
0.3564232886,
0.4771357179,
-0.5816247463,
0.3178150058,
-0.1857889444,
-0.3194268346,
-0.6548904777,
0.0241005439,
-1.0867033005,
0.2760020792,
-0.9913477898,
-0.525686264,
0.2394302487,
0.3544428349,
-0.3791744113,
-0.03228084,
-0.7059019804,
0.7084634304,
-0.0889141411,
-0.6458181143,
-0.1168496162,
-0.266902864,
0.1031105593,
-0.3175124824,
-0.0746438354,
0.2215158194,
0.0854721218,
0.7293540239,
-1.0907342434,
0.3743428588,
-0.283441931,
-0.0611509196,
0.3288083971,
-0.2207629234,
0.8818433285,
-0.1249972433,
-0.0535467155,
-0.165956527,
-0.0800619796,
-0.6097292304,
-1.2624799013,
0.4899782836,
-0.2279755473,
-0.3500340879,
-0.3940701485,
-0.6309323907,
-0.6872628331,
0.1346344203,
0.1308354735,
0.5865205526,
0.0050939163,
0.1544049233,
0.4570028782,
-0.2170612812,
0.475379169,
0.3318225443,
0.3569863737,
-0.3263147473,
0.716209352,
0.24376674,
0.1165390983,
0.5054782629,
-0.0184697434,
-0.625130713,
-0.5206800699,
-0.5551022291,
-0.1928349435,
-0.7265410423,
-0.4074343443,
-0.7251677513,
-0.1597947776,
-0.811193645,
-0.5435115695,
0.0581251904,
-0.6758884192,
-0.1160141006,
-0.1540433913,
0.5378893018,
0.1951991022,
-0.1140348837,
0.4436303973,
-1.1271108389,
0.4605211318,
0.3788147569,
0.3679257035,
-0.2620125413,
-0.3948249817,
-0.4417836368,
-0.1351925135,
-0.3985467553,
-0.8280280232,
0.7800661922,
0.1952065229,
0.7903874516,
0.3889725208,
-0.4105441868,
1.2410999537,
-0.2398710996,
0.4364776611,
0.2581546009,
-0.7002479434,
0.7474014759,
-0.3056901097,
0.3119699955,
0.8451627493,
0.1955572665,
-0.2163491398,
-0.3412251472,
-1.0842670202,
-1.1632598639,
0.6561767459,
-0.0350284204,
0.113048479,
0.2819778323,
0.2118382603,
0.3658580482,
0.1971940249,
-0.0893775001,
0.2153151184,
-0.2283752859,
-0.37779966,
0.1550920755,
0.0749862716,
-0.1137724742,
-0.0974401161,
0.5320159793,
-0.1469164491,
0.0591009222,
0.2324339747,
-0.2540490329,
0.0390849784,
-0.041205693,
0.2944111824,
0.6067872047,
-0.2649534643,
-0.0846040174,
0.088576138,
-0.5176952481,
-0.1400084049,
0.6334043145,
-0.2342080474,
0.2309574932,
0.4137378037,
0.7173393369,
0.1006360278,
-0.756044507,
0.3763195872,
0.4427090883,
-0.4295195043,
-0.0210000165,
0.2934783995,
-0.4300372899,
0.4969416261,
0.516218245,
0.2958907187,
0.3553466797,
-0.9068809748,
0.3717252314,
0.4308097064,
0.0204401966,
0.2711082697,
0.5141686201,
0.3462159336,
-0.3022799194,
0.312379539,
0.1909296364,
-0.1243805215,
0.3307757676,
0.4664359093,
0.5134420991,
0.2184156477,
0.1984184384,
0.3231094182,
-0.033107765,
-0.1978152543,
0.1809679717,
-0.4672292173,
-0.2002922148,
-0.329470098,
-0.5255025625,
-0.2670016885,
0.4679358006,
-0.5466918945,
0.3108352721,
-0.62826401,
-0.044885695,
0.3663767874,
0.111124441,
-0.994146049,
0.6541801691,
0.0862648264,
0.9633500576,
-0.8779557347,
0.5095645189,
0.3673744798,
-0.6507546902,
-0.5741276741,
-0.1441077888,
-0.4471513331,
-0.750210166,
0.7733286619,
0.105170995,
0.1662579775,
-0.2202173769,
-0.3273285627,
-0.7124319673,
1.0549902916,
0.0068881032,
-0.7216082215,
-0.1208425164,
0.2573644519,
0.4322131574,
-0.1371040642,
0.1630467027,
0.5301117301,
0.3117722571,
-0.1403291374,
-0.1514430493,
0.1221499816,
-0.3620464504,
0.001032064,
0.203909561,
-0.3363208175,
0.2918787897,
0.0644207373,
-0.3075692356,
-0.1370762438,
0.8581040502,
0.1862285882,
0.3366659284,
0.4885787368,
0.5118032694,
0.8752311468,
0.0053926939,
0.9252400994,
-0.0621359162,
-0.1689030975,
0.8105812073,
-0.2210221738,
0.6187826991,
0.5846341848,
-0.083433114,
0.297890991,
0.4107914865,
-0.4877461791,
0.5688409209,
0.1344737709,
-0.4100013673,
0.0535458364,
0.3153020144,
-0.225284934,
0.484215498,
0.3400925994,
-0.5766670108,
-0.3894659281,
0.0208237357,
-0.1791614592,
0.1154320091,
-0.1418406218,
0.8310976624,
-0.353685081,
-0.7748609185,
0.4257187545,
0.1686875224,
0.3968147635,
-0.7059272528,
-0.5542506576,
-0.3787701428,
-0.2433610111,
-0.4045450091,
-0.7770373821,
0.3261498213,
0.0453813896,
-0.1135090664,
-0.4813452959,
0.9215422273,
-0.5120289326,
-0.5171713829,
-0.2919779718,
0.255746454,
-0.0184329525,
-0.1373481452,
-0.6770640612,
-0.295043081,
-0.2571720779,
-0.2341388315,
0.461482048,
0.6788166165,
-0.1730332524,
0.2256610841,
1.0395860672,
0.3104626834,
-0.0180014037,
0.0800283179,
1.022687912,
-0.6459800005,
-0.5871063471,
-0.5327164531,
0.6490997672,
-0.9755013585,
-0.3601204753,
0.541552186,
0.8870256543,
0.6827042699,
-0.394503355,
1.269076705,
0.0785428584,
0.3513197899,
-0.7845579386,
0.4613687694,
-0.2569853961,
0.0082379421,
-0.3557660282,
-1.0013697147,
-0.1643173397,
0.7880039215,
-0.0870350078,
-0.4049650729,
0.5082761645,
0.7955313325,
-0.2109859437,
-0.0709015206,
0.3315953612,
-0.2735581398,
0.3259869516,
0.2181704044,
0.3890807629,
-0.6183949113,
0.6155769825,
-0.5083814859,
-0.4095008075,
-0.2503568232,
-0.7192761898,
-0.6923776269,
-0.4792387187,
-0.3863116503,
-0.5317560434,
-0.0978020355,
0.4762890041,
0.892295897,
-0.3806831837,
0.2238526493,
-0.0903815478,
-0.4411568642,
-0.5282090306,
-0.2724554241,
0.3448146284,
-0.42288661,
-0.5930281281,
0.6607196927,
0.5638187528,
0.3967749178,
0.0040918901,
0.4267848432,
0.1714695543,
0.0574869178,
0.808454752,
0.5752258301,
-0.1636176556,
0.0935166851,
-0.2559071779,
0.1022762582,
0.0716692433,
0.9252169728,
-0.8069914579,
0.5264171362,
0.7445735335,
1.0376694202,
1.0391623974,
0.3792744875,
0.6285877824,
-0.7546661496,
0.3917621076,
0.0740698576,
0.1771685332,
0.3490421772,
-0.5240402818,
0.5801676512,
0.5022087097,
0.2486889362,
-0.6308447123,
-0.0145650487,
-1.1934633255,
-0.2862272263,
0.6128309965,
0.0060151638,
-0.3263682127,
-0.0178110562,
-0.4806999564,
0.2107731104,
-0.3315465152,
1.1382250786,
0.3726174831,
-0.1247603297,
-0.0330882408,
-0.5772020221,
0.7872074246,
0.4027264416,
-1.2832992077,
0.0921963751,
0.6310330033,
0.0556790233,
0.110959582,
0.7617775202,
-0.2445334345,
0.3246239126,
0.4269925356,
-0.2046643347,
-0.3925352991,
-0.0080601424,
-0.0912606418,
0.2452403754,
-0.175330922,
-0.2415531874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10039v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10039v1 | A Twitter BERT Approach for Offensive Language Detection in Marathi | 2022-12-20T07:22:45 | 2022-12-20T07:22:45 | Tanmay Chavan, Shantanu Patankar, Aditya Kane, Omkar Gokhale, Raviraj Joshi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated offensive language detection is essential in combating the spread
of hate speech, particularly in social media. This paper describes our work on
Offensive Language Identification in low resource Indic language Marathi. The
problem is formulated as a text classification task to identify a tweet as
offensive or non-offensive. We evaluate different mono-lingual and
multi-lingual BERT models on this classification task, focusing on BERT models
pre-trained with social media datasets. We compare the performance of MuRIL,
MahaTweetBERT, MahaTweetBERT-Hateful, and MahaBERT on the HASOC 2022 test set.
We also explore external data augmentation from other existing Marathi hate
speech corpus HASOC 2021 and L3Cube-MahaHate. The MahaTweetBERT, a BERT model,
pre-trained on Marathi tweets when fine-tuned on the combined dataset (HASOC
2021 + HASOC 2022 + MahaHate), outperforms all models with an F1 score of 98.43
on the HASOC 2022 test set. With this, we also provide a new state-of-the-art
result on HASOC 2022 / MOLD v2 test set. | [
-0.3434033096,
-1.0533783436,
-0.0459375121,
0.4099460244,
-0.4144107103,
0.1258769929,
-0.447850734,
-0.9750803709,
0.2652459741,
0.5830640197,
-0.5797873735,
-0.364680171,
-0.9968430996,
0.1123263761,
-0.6946667433,
1.0383912325,
0.2612231672,
0.0161338337,
0.7197560072,
-0.4178610146,
-0.3206185699,
-0.3944202662,
-0.7369522452,
0.1141802743,
0.432866931,
0.2995347679,
0.3867013752,
0.0766584873,
0.6631455421,
0.3281883299,
0.0082208356,
0.2230453193,
-0.2884576321,
0.3317399621,
-0.1852476746,
0.1045809686,
-0.0376352184,
-0.3761107624,
0.3196093142,
-0.0701858401,
0.0226142146,
0.0472483635,
-0.150087893,
0.321092099,
-0.8038929105,
0.1133393347,
-1.0449094772,
-0.0788700655,
-0.6508316398,
0.233261019,
-0.5287198424,
-0.5589039326,
-0.0792831182,
-0.2638933957,
0.016048314,
-0.2432452738,
0.8856649995,
0.0982464701,
-0.3200108707,
-0.6660211682,
-0.7282313704,
0.8836258054,
-0.9743020535,
0.168555811,
0.3216760755,
0.4967644215,
0.2338208258,
-0.2715158463,
-0.732640624,
-0.061068926,
0.1859344542,
0.190654248,
-0.3685373366,
-0.0481139868,
0.0203871354,
0.2333279848,
-0.2751477361,
0.3408610225,
-0.5394978523,
-0.3021291196,
0.6966344714,
-0.0032193034,
0.5999060869,
-0.5338347554,
-0.589640975,
0.2340441644,
-0.2726391852,
-0.1351546049,
0.39553684,
0.8398268223,
-0.1115869507,
0.4572485387,
-0.001869573,
0.4723092318,
-0.1514566094,
0.149955228,
0.2179758847,
-0.2393835783,
-0.0055226469,
0.1759682298,
0.7754244208,
0.0608343631,
0.9019924998,
0.1552589834,
-0.4319694638,
0.4722851813,
0.6005007625,
-0.4739454985,
-0.2408677191,
-0.1049763784,
-0.1117051914,
-0.5300008059,
-0.4719838798,
-0.7266007662,
-0.8938539028,
0.119942449,
0.4853867292,
-0.8771808743,
-0.4424570203,
-0.4329024851,
-0.1721207798,
0.6547577977,
0.311971724,
-1.1557099819,
0.302167505,
0.565479219,
0.5503702164,
-0.2423238009,
0.1139418632,
-0.2086536884,
0.0045021172,
-0.5479158759,
0.4954814613,
-0.7889293432,
-0.1649226546,
0.4416612089,
-0.2745664716,
0.2218640596,
-0.5152866244,
0.9019036293,
-0.7835150361,
0.0512502454,
-0.3004853725,
-0.3494406044,
-0.3285844028,
0.1109574139,
-0.395607084,
1.271650672,
0.34139359,
-1.1782654524,
0.5088415742,
-0.7645329237,
-0.7026562691,
0.4212788641,
-0.0265379399,
-0.4183746278,
0.0104227541,
0.2488728613,
0.2801915407,
0.0520894974,
-0.0389768854,
-0.3834658563,
-0.1807437986,
-0.0607023388,
-0.3347219825,
1.4404778481,
0.5806624293,
-0.4329306781,
0.1154179648,
-0.5418880582,
-0.1050280184,
0.2158700675,
-0.1318077892,
-0.5116366744,
0.1621528417,
0.3974550366,
0.19959867,
0.1311791986,
-1.1801490784,
-0.2404743284,
-0.3818456829,
0.3075083196,
0.9474983215,
-0.0168994665,
0.0560728498,
-0.2333210707,
0.3322943449,
0.0566021279,
0.4426399171,
0.6448674202,
-0.8796991706,
-0.6672682762,
-0.4536705911,
-0.0082816705,
0.751650393,
-0.8578971624,
0.2146447897,
-0.0708770901,
-0.5742545724,
-0.6314131021,
0.1295660585,
0.3249171376,
0.326728195,
0.3029335141,
-0.3060848117,
-0.8911688924,
-1.0511566401,
-0.3012090921,
-0.285717994,
0.3781197369,
0.33675614,
0.1202619746,
-0.3952712119,
0.9812142849,
0.0978807881,
-0.3562211692,
-0.4278115034,
0.3532317877,
-0.0551996604,
0.0246333946,
0.8538005352,
-0.9790582061,
-0.7959493995,
-0.0412344001,
-0.6138951182,
-0.4487350285,
0.6450072527,
0.0672725588,
0.5834383368,
-0.0624789372,
-0.0660907403,
0.4580118954,
0.612296164,
-0.056374874,
0.4080061615,
0.2017228901,
0.4088454843,
-1.0426393747,
-0.568821013,
0.1185585186,
-0.2552466393,
-0.8789358139,
0.0379697271,
0.011763474,
-0.2764446437,
-0.6746826172,
0.5181641579,
0.0459098667,
0.0439428836,
-0.2123886496,
0.0711816624,
-0.612808764,
0.4278601706,
0.0282531176,
0.7427607775,
0.253094703,
-0.5612257719,
0.3368369639,
0.2904770672,
-0.6038757563,
0.0830758363,
-0.203301385,
-0.0038123089,
-0.061426755,
-0.2751277685,
-1.5154863596,
-0.2208027691,
0.698626399,
-0.7397243977,
0.1665714085,
-0.1341685951,
-0.547953546,
-0.4087595046,
-0.2591332495,
0.4186750352,
0.634534359,
-0.5320076942,
0.6615968943,
0.707141757,
-0.3731798232,
-0.7938343287,
-0.9896014333,
-0.0522590876,
-0.2860859334,
-0.6532754898,
-0.1162741929,
0.1580239683,
-0.4293145537,
-0.1591982841,
0.1998958141,
-0.6606954932,
0.1452743709,
0.1815279573,
0.3665887117,
-0.1511237025,
0.119133085,
0.0331334956,
0.3832271993,
0.0882620141,
0.1494849771,
0.435739696,
-0.0262157358,
-0.0190450475,
-0.224440068,
0.3816720843,
0.4557079971,
-0.1823394895,
0.5709341764,
1.0596469641,
-0.4631443024,
-0.2288120538,
-0.586699307,
-0.0122324461,
-0.4749348462,
0.3284874558,
0.0624348372,
-0.6274418831,
0.3539361954,
0.500415504,
0.2810993195,
0.4874945879,
0.8867635131,
-0.1898914725,
0.6489580274,
0.7569294572,
-0.3794543445,
0.8211398125,
0.1333113015,
0.5569499135,
-0.3477890193,
0.3713822067,
-0.5885825753,
0.1618201137,
-1.0355353355,
-0.2531980872,
0.0864211246,
-0.5254461765,
-0.2320442647,
0.6719036698,
-0.6518859267,
0.159232825,
0.1142543331,
0.1545566022,
-0.0711232275,
0.1405744851,
0.19804129,
-0.4199014306,
-0.3769478202,
-0.4739347398,
0.939050138,
0.2019168884,
0.6574935913,
0.6220396757,
0.6463098526,
0.9310284257,
0.7412878871,
-0.7148842812,
0.4913254082,
-0.5046153069,
-1.307901144,
-0.4463059008,
-0.2813506722,
-0.6821593642,
0.1708481163,
-0.355475843,
-0.960169673,
-0.1162349507,
0.0849254653,
-0.065528065,
0.5964676142,
-0.9652513266,
0.5380638838,
-0.2139417976,
-0.2015733421,
-0.2697564065,
-0.4435210228,
0.6944209933,
-0.3705599308,
0.7569074035,
-0.3161186278,
0.0312851816,
0.9669394493,
-0.2153097838,
0.886115253,
-0.3719477654,
-0.1393734813,
0.448671937,
-0.1206376478,
0.3036109805,
-0.5521613359,
-0.3494678438,
0.1596573591,
-0.3411816359,
-0.5261511207,
-0.1300575882,
0.4470900595,
-0.7126026154,
-0.227897495,
-0.2968867421,
-0.4800744057,
-0.216339156,
0.1767000854,
0.4870912135,
0.5584141612,
-0.040594589,
-0.1114150137,
0.6016476154,
-0.4477568269,
0.4168642759,
0.4907056391,
-0.2100101411,
-0.0560434572,
0.9596416354,
0.1267080158,
0.1392757595,
0.1465857178,
0.1751541495,
-0.4220466912,
-0.5316715837,
-0.3282200396,
0.1101273075,
-0.803829968,
0.0178166721,
-0.6861639023,
-0.4889936149,
-0.5742771029,
-0.0404053479,
-0.3550736904,
-0.1093407273,
0.2120320499,
0.2998482883,
0.5656087995,
1.2036832571,
-0.1633655876,
0.419095397,
-0.4658972621,
0.3499985039,
0.1709164679,
0.290109098,
-0.0699743181,
-1.0622198582,
-0.0155834788,
-0.0900075659,
-0.3561775088,
-1.0452321768,
0.3438494503,
-0.0322935246,
0.3219392896,
0.5025427938,
0.3880767524,
0.2992523909,
-0.3933186531,
0.6058242917,
0.1488007754,
-0.7229114771,
0.5920153856,
-0.5048818588,
-0.0733912066,
0.4689612389,
0.6507140994,
-0.3392470777,
-0.8087449074,
-0.5101689696,
-0.8187409639,
0.7502347827,
0.3254726529,
0.4489118159,
-0.459932059,
-0.1613129377,
0.0047978996,
-0.0234683771,
-0.9332847595,
-0.2467758954,
0.0569488294,
-0.2954100966,
0.1605596691,
-0.6167523265,
0.2109911442,
-0.1718829572,
0.7643761039,
0.4940372705,
0.3187196255,
-0.2675873637,
-0.3950074911,
-0.0568191856,
0.4114170372,
0.5225884318,
0.6825077534,
-0.452144146,
-0.3104933798,
0.3827452064,
-0.3822315633,
0.0352056511,
-0.0721141919,
0.1110923216,
0.3435983062,
0.3864732981,
0.4711784422,
0.2309059948,
-0.381131649,
0.7745237947,
-0.08075881,
-0.0256547853,
-0.5712999701,
-0.0289649088,
-0.2814226449,
0.111093387,
0.2615820169,
0.046816133,
0.2048779577,
-0.594465971,
0.2078825235,
0.3168987632,
-0.5729393959,
0.0576584376,
0.4352590144,
0.3743373752,
-0.6775918603,
0.6927964687,
-0.2037113309,
-0.9664683342,
0.3998027742,
0.3504490554,
0.6669653058,
-0.3706486225,
0.076416485,
0.409840554,
0.5564649105,
0.7650336623,
0.2888526618,
-0.3203875124,
-0.9275787473,
-0.3498965204,
-0.6896832585,
-0.4070499539,
0.1557379514,
-0.6752595901,
0.3356662393,
-0.7543394566,
-0.2481553555,
0.3265246451,
0.1035231203,
-0.3219178319,
0.1178867519,
0.6570107341,
0.9611817598,
-1.2331701517,
1.0192805529,
0.4758602381,
-0.4090671539,
-0.561385572,
-0.0686168745,
0.1396399736,
-1.0200884342,
0.7879898548,
0.113746345,
-0.3292898834,
-0.1415454298,
-0.5231663585,
-0.3940074742,
0.2271597832,
-0.0480263568,
-0.3090110719,
0.2312734276,
-0.1341675818,
0.57251513,
-0.0808350295,
0.3343247771,
0.3734231591,
0.3478168249,
0.0327336118,
-0.6352488995,
-0.3207503855,
-0.1663682461,
0.0208755806,
0.6613193154,
-0.3588723838,
0.6709291935,
-0.0731682852,
-0.4516661167,
0.0081742695,
0.6099969149,
-0.0604436584,
-0.0303666275,
0.5697101951,
0.5168601871,
0.5509312153,
-0.1641496867,
1.0433814526,
0.0206747986,
0.4055600166,
0.9128172994,
-0.1893012971,
0.9014322162,
0.1517665833,
-0.271874547,
0.4820910394,
0.5840110779,
0.2025695741,
0.5591076016,
0.2830685079,
-0.4095002115,
-0.1816323102,
-0.1297152042,
-0.1726050526,
0.5258901715,
0.5773476958,
-0.0586363599,
-0.6702774167,
0.3661479056,
-0.0183061138,
0.2983677685,
-0.2984317541,
0.7882217169,
-0.1564542055,
-0.1837179959,
0.6187146306,
0.1164729893,
1.0843970776,
-0.8557459712,
0.2135535777,
0.0030512516,
0.3242702186,
-0.0125831664,
-0.9206323028,
0.6845869422,
0.4631704688,
-0.0056077656,
0.055382207,
0.8606696129,
-0.313129425,
-0.371175319,
0.8029367924,
-0.1295428276,
0.4132526219,
0.1428607702,
-0.8749947548,
0.3062698245,
-0.0272063557,
0.2078493237,
-0.0003220231,
0.462074846,
-0.2873533964,
0.5849292874,
0.156799525,
0.093171522,
0.5140898824,
0.1810138524,
0.6113612056,
-0.439830035,
-0.2438692749,
-0.7722451091,
0.0717992261,
-0.145821467,
-0.3623526096,
0.7838132381,
0.36542961,
0.8682451844,
0.0233817678,
1.0010037422,
-0.4389261305,
0.8743399978,
-0.1224671006,
0.6341986656,
-0.49228549,
-0.0632323027,
-0.6327614784,
-0.537166059,
-0.0779367536,
0.602707088,
-0.6709732413,
0.0771012157,
0.3414117396,
0.7927755713,
-0.116157867,
0.2810005546,
0.497166425,
0.2775058746,
0.2787444592,
0.4134429097,
1.0253756046,
-0.4548396468,
0.6642907858,
-0.3499186933,
-0.3691323102,
-0.4754545987,
-0.5161568522,
-0.8462497592,
-0.648676753,
-0.0809348673,
-0.3874465525,
0.3558477759,
0.9449800253,
0.5971187353,
-1.137440443,
-0.2356777787,
0.262291491,
0.0101730637,
0.2190044522,
-0.2917328477,
-0.1062870994,
-0.541182816,
-0.7295473814,
-0.0344861113,
0.2963203788,
-0.2907609046,
0.1889730543,
0.1839248538,
-0.91951859,
0.4099034071,
0.827270031,
0.3210722208,
-0.8625714183,
-0.5231749415,
-0.5448016524,
-0.4969664812,
0.1033134684,
0.459880203,
-0.2656689286,
0.7039180994,
0.3061042726,
0.9579879642,
0.3882087171,
0.0806188583,
0.064823918,
-0.6862559915,
0.2773330808,
0.4375900328,
0.2919927835,
0.4622856379,
-0.1155159101,
0.3584372103,
0.0694092959,
-0.3451370299,
-0.5952718854,
0.3130424023,
-1.0423243046,
-0.1724076867,
1.0729067326,
0.0956505835,
-0.3954874575,
-0.4488508105,
-0.2090814859,
0.4839529097,
-0.4598514736,
0.8554366827,
0.9609795213,
0.1361776143,
-0.0665958896,
-0.5918822289,
0.4294296801,
0.4108876884,
-0.5241971016,
0.1171654686,
0.1345533133,
0.3477019072,
0.0795346349,
0.8323228955,
-0.2090735435,
0.370359838,
-0.2518320382,
0.1427343935,
0.3160228431,
-0.1476925313,
-0.2244754732,
-0.1960862428,
0.0653352812,
-0.5995242596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10029v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10029v3 | Do language models have coherent mental models of everyday things? | 2022-12-20T06:54:04 | 2023-06-08T17:27:44 | Yuling Gu, Bhavana Dalvi Mishra, Peter Clark | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | When people think of everyday things like an egg, they typically have a
mental image associated with it. This allows them to correctly judge, for
example, that "the yolk surrounds the shell" is a false statement. Do language
models similarly have a coherent picture of such everyday things? To
investigate this, we propose a benchmark dataset consisting of 100 everyday
things, their parts, and the relationships between these parts, expressed as
11,720 "X relation Y?" true/false questions. Using these questions as probes,
we observe that state-of-the-art pre-trained language models (LMs) like GPT-3
and Macaw have fragments of knowledge about these everyday things, but do not
have fully coherent "parts mental models" (54-59% accurate, 19-43% conditional
constraint violation). We propose an extension where we add a constraint
satisfaction layer on top of the LM's raw predictions to apply commonsense
constraints. As well as removing inconsistencies, we find that this also
significantly improves accuracy (by 16-20%), suggesting how the incoherence of
the LM's pictures of everyday things can be significantly reduced. | [
-0.4560053349,
-0.8320624828,
0.7174321413,
-0.0424151495,
-0.1377892047,
-0.3163464665,
-0.24456954,
-0.9713124037,
-0.0827633291,
0.6516406536,
-0.7939500213,
-0.3186921477,
-0.293807596,
0.0739817843,
-0.3297119141,
0.7490444183,
0.0626212656,
-0.0629725382,
-0.1396822184,
-0.2474977076,
-0.4894878268,
-0.4214815199,
-0.3233430982,
-0.3650761545,
0.257247299,
-0.0332507864,
0.9472523332,
0.9997884035,
0.1943790168,
0.2945559621,
0.1554536372,
0.1271791905,
-0.2234098613,
0.0974158794,
-0.370361805,
-0.5746394396,
-0.2145521939,
0.2850269973,
0.2610672116,
1.178612113,
-0.2520728409,
0.2147238106,
0.2076879591,
0.4621012509,
-0.7148624063,
0.5872901082,
-0.7369399667,
0.1345408112,
-0.0032953103,
0.5276937485,
-0.260074079,
-0.2900222838,
0.0620506331,
-0.7185424566,
0.0605196543,
0.1009731665,
1.3371653557,
0.0924962014,
-0.4417839646,
-0.207119599,
-0.7852963805,
1.0185935497,
-0.6388773918,
0.6703365445,
0.5869881511,
0.1483385563,
-0.1216232553,
-0.3530938327,
-0.8879282475,
-0.2166558057,
-0.2481728345,
0.1661214978,
-0.2233884037,
0.0302091055,
0.1427192092,
0.1793242246,
-0.4171302617,
-0.3805679679,
-0.1360425204,
-0.1294585913,
0.4930342138,
0.2702378035,
0.5996438861,
-0.1194909066,
-0.3425562978,
-0.0983269215,
-0.5113114715,
-0.1659851372,
0.0288230702,
0.2196993679,
-0.1187563762,
0.6405700445,
-0.2857996523,
0.9278103709,
-0.1397982091,
-0.2430293262,
0.0084950542,
-0.3759868443,
-0.2049399316,
-0.2570238411,
0.4886549711,
0.5797310472,
0.6141815186,
-0.1858101785,
-0.2923558056,
0.5183348656,
0.1043924391,
-0.456523478,
-0.3980541825,
0.1862160414,
-0.1150428355,
-0.0964550525,
0.0600962602,
-0.101133436,
-0.230374828,
-0.6503480077,
0.3914996982,
-0.5906385183,
-0.2178435475,
0.4772225916,
0.1272154748,
0.1189841107,
0.3959555924,
-0.7021666765,
0.6424346566,
1.0478311777,
0.5750892758,
0.0981130525,
-0.4635229409,
-0.1038689986,
0.3984046578,
-0.4537430108,
0.9362546206,
-0.6229001284,
-0.0249964483,
-0.1082713529,
-0.0088031078,
-0.2572107613,
-0.5511080623,
0.2828491032,
-0.2031116188,
0.3579327762,
-0.5883185863,
-0.6377658248,
-0.1394552737,
0.6444217563,
-0.6344041824,
0.7306748629,
-0.1023412794,
-0.658203721,
0.3472937346,
-0.1795510203,
-0.3759762049,
-0.1082870141,
-0.4970515072,
0.0153665943,
0.175350979,
0.3199360669,
0.4268218279,
-0.0521433167,
0.3177630007,
-0.4673319161,
-0.2157476246,
0.5714495778,
-0.385415554,
0.8042459488,
0.3778875172,
-0.129600212,
-0.3620918393,
-0.6315661669,
0.1379351169,
-0.0131579041,
-0.1718372703,
-0.2899751961,
0.119465664,
-0.2806819081,
0.2987688184,
0.2378778458,
-0.8775275946,
0.3542415202,
-0.3019010723,
0.4391383827,
0.6662697196,
0.0174410362,
0.1583407819,
-0.7933443189,
0.0818338618,
0.1815718114,
0.3492481411,
0.0748639852,
-0.727458775,
-0.9564533234,
-0.1584313214,
-0.1012136266,
0.282081455,
-0.4215166867,
0.4021064341,
-0.5200633407,
-0.1931991428,
-0.3573884368,
-0.0619518049,
0.4729370475,
0.5825275779,
0.2540877461,
-0.1566152275,
-0.5345939994,
-0.9554949403,
-0.4522467852,
-0.4078963995,
-0.0741308331,
0.3750799894,
0.324965775,
-0.0244927164,
0.9629670978,
-0.5577856898,
-0.1498999596,
-0.1208982244,
0.2605730295,
0.1550628096,
0.5011219382,
0.4419623315,
-0.5462960005,
-0.2918714583,
-0.1311234385,
-0.8709044456,
-0.0240626168,
-0.0169543494,
0.0316342786,
0.2450795323,
0.2959034741,
-0.9300880432,
0.0474273153,
0.5983818173,
-0.3294349015,
0.4181173146,
-0.0584765114,
-0.0459267348,
-0.7912480235,
-0.1671170443,
0.010897899,
-0.2640842795,
-0.7270049453,
0.2506523132,
0.1240851283,
-0.1536297202,
-0.4246037602,
0.6931358576,
-0.3912711442,
0.0544913337,
-0.0515546277,
-0.0284841061,
0.2508109212,
0.5911174417,
0.2113128006,
0.5512824059,
0.4101681113,
-0.5309476256,
-0.1454730481,
-0.0019078645,
-0.6060606241,
0.5406524539,
-0.4779307544,
0.0263489876,
-0.3004911542,
0.3063821793,
-0.7330127358,
-0.3973369002,
0.1108700335,
-0.0014931218,
0.0649130866,
-0.0408465378,
-0.3862559497,
-0.1524614245,
-0.1119213328,
0.3128389418,
0.5684627891,
-0.3912192583,
0.6179912686,
0.4724527001,
-0.0725142583,
-0.4802165627,
-1.0485373735,
0.0360376239,
0.3276930749,
-0.4927216172,
0.209338665,
-0.0245641042,
-0.6146864891,
0.35132128,
-0.4830898643,
-0.3612461984,
-0.0806689709,
0.2498052269,
0.3889681995,
-0.340079397,
0.0857470781,
-0.7096669078,
0.1576191634,
0.0593444072,
-0.4531242847,
0.478793174,
-0.3367846906,
-0.4300346076,
-0.4778469801,
0.2809602618,
0.4116553068,
0.0053668441,
0.5878241658,
0.1882372797,
-0.6153889298,
-0.1852383614,
-0.8711137772,
-0.0980340913,
-0.499221921,
0.322571218,
-0.5862232447,
-0.694082737,
0.4615477324,
0.5796164274,
0.0242583156,
0.3782213926,
0.1101079732,
-0.5451591611,
1.1926887035,
0.4626790583,
-0.2573967874,
0.3391754031,
-0.1838446707,
0.0363655053,
-0.7160561085,
-0.1990123093,
-0.2235266566,
-0.2012005746,
-0.4330081642,
-0.4115605056,
0.0045550768,
0.3052492738,
-0.4758048058,
0.4262728095,
-0.4732102156,
0.8154090047,
0.1834823042,
0.2028390169,
0.2942337692,
-0.3236144483,
-0.2180117816,
0.01834758,
-0.6687319279,
-0.6120221019,
0.9174836874,
0.1167084724,
0.8734061122,
-0.0590745583,
0.6338264942,
-0.1790745705,
0.5045787692,
-0.4870303869,
0.8096902966,
-0.2517245114,
-0.782548964,
-0.0463344641,
-0.6023721099,
-0.8684692979,
0.108586356,
-0.0341341831,
-1.061363101,
0.3183763027,
0.1219117567,
-0.3877452612,
0.3447021544,
-0.7287014723,
0.6961792707,
-0.3110160828,
-0.1975333095,
0.0994752944,
-0.4005689919,
0.6162847877,
0.2697799206,
0.3857342899,
-0.5664522052,
-0.099138014,
0.4270652533,
-0.5152029991,
0.9639299512,
0.0387793705,
-0.2323427945,
0.3991576433,
0.2526184618,
0.6952720881,
-0.2212355137,
0.0221221428,
0.0180663876,
0.1020952091,
-0.5045648813,
-0.8507276773,
0.7428058982,
-0.8240852356,
-0.5818974376,
-0.3456564546,
-0.7654432058,
-0.4116677642,
0.1987237781,
0.014649827,
0.6132635474,
0.0170744415,
-0.0282189511,
0.5058313608,
0.2553941905,
0.2970073521,
0.5339682698,
-0.2431934476,
-0.0925809443,
1.0292402506,
0.2482082099,
0.3569009304,
0.2948212028,
0.2216901928,
-0.2761150301,
-0.3565425575,
-0.0066799149,
0.2871285379,
-0.7782301903,
-0.0405552872,
-0.8503959775,
-0.1495334804,
-0.2563226819,
0.1013060361,
-0.6505561471,
-0.6712079048,
0.0686557963,
0.1184577644,
-0.0525218099,
1.0623995066,
0.2794343531,
-0.2802474797,
-0.6919457912,
0.3663128912,
0.766050458,
0.5141211152,
-0.021067692,
-0.0483941287,
-0.1981442869,
0.4605877995,
-0.1318547279,
-0.5654205084,
-0.0678208545,
0.4106296897,
0.5690164566,
0.4002197385,
0.1019626483,
0.8771095276,
-0.4139916897,
0.9211863279,
0.0587473139,
-0.7630060911,
0.1931315362,
-0.4494480491,
0.5009385347,
0.5656436682,
0.2582461238,
-0.5826450586,
-0.8101999164,
-0.6318741441,
-0.3144212961,
0.3746635318,
0.3624731004,
0.1863799393,
-0.3087013066,
0.2104782462,
-0.2138350904,
0.2116089463,
-0.9335742593,
-0.1417928636,
-0.4352010489,
-0.4074945748,
0.1080820411,
-0.0127816685,
-0.173262164,
-0.2610836029,
0.5569370389,
0.0327427313,
0.3186452091,
0.0205661133,
-0.1479507089,
0.0161606539,
0.3422228992,
0.6524500251,
0.5929006338,
-0.305134207,
0.5340954661,
0.1545440555,
-0.6282601953,
0.1881590635,
-0.1912991405,
-0.1329430193,
-0.1610120237,
0.5617607832,
0.4274041057,
0.3754774928,
-0.624383688,
0.4192733765,
0.0119902557,
-0.2419303358,
-0.0491425321,
0.3713698387,
0.2910587192,
0.2374548763,
0.1534335315,
0.2833948433,
-0.1545197666,
-1.0434951782,
0.1710551679,
0.4389427602,
-0.4773106873,
-0.5781057477,
0.5291148424,
-0.0787304565,
0.0303238705,
0.4964515567,
-0.2721348703,
-0.6858080626,
0.3606801927,
0.6711626649,
0.8249316216,
0.1160403118,
0.0311566293,
0.1709512174,
0.3797153533,
-0.4222773015,
0.5640102029,
-0.0840735957,
-1.3517401218,
-0.3791429996,
-0.5980248451,
-0.3462271392,
0.5165996552,
-0.5897701979,
-0.0157351624,
-0.4446974397,
-0.0020859891,
-0.0541300364,
0.0818690434,
-0.7467731833,
0.56704849,
0.2919746041,
0.5650769472,
-0.7128738761,
1.1337590218,
0.7301194072,
-0.4317040443,
-0.9443614483,
0.1537736505,
-0.0590447485,
-0.8514113426,
0.6133743525,
0.1901390553,
-0.2764631212,
-0.2352818251,
-0.4977676868,
-0.9091790318,
0.6954073906,
0.7348076105,
-0.4855766892,
-0.106777519,
0.4749090075,
0.4438965023,
-0.5291107893,
0.0490449257,
0.3686680198,
0.5636424422,
-0.0977223888,
-0.6620867848,
0.1078901961,
-0.4810116589,
0.0389412828,
0.1650057733,
-0.6560160518,
1.373111248,
0.0466507636,
-0.667034924,
-0.0697877184,
0.4376334548,
0.3052150011,
-0.0277770665,
0.6473907828,
0.8038896322,
0.6093100309,
-0.1679552048,
1.1006547213,
-0.4965018034,
0.4201426208,
1.5457470417,
-0.3779690564,
0.8558765054,
0.3988439441,
-0.2295585722,
0.4079200327,
0.2625409365,
-0.0086355917,
0.4663630128,
-0.039321959,
-0.1548248082,
-0.5501843095,
-0.2856502831,
-0.2991431355,
0.3836584985,
0.2846878767,
0.0387857668,
-0.3208254874,
0.0394847021,
0.0257358346,
0.1237224266,
-0.0498449802,
0.6998302937,
0.040092472,
-0.7578206062,
0.7200344801,
-0.2433778048,
0.4275805354,
-0.4093011916,
0.0845697373,
-0.3240075707,
0.2530881464,
0.0092666494,
-0.8908822536,
0.3000130951,
-0.1044209078,
-0.0269686151,
-0.1229420975,
0.7868330479,
-0.5105422139,
-0.6309617162,
-0.1626894176,
0.4089310169,
0.0721391663,
-0.1197861657,
-0.7040255666,
0.0810138807,
-0.0931987688,
-0.2629018724,
0.1674787253,
0.4470373094,
0.0940501392,
0.8801967502,
0.3921744525,
0.3296811879,
0.1485757381,
-0.073938638,
0.7462670207,
-0.7121286392,
-0.3608662784,
-0.6356024146,
0.1891264021,
-0.1495831013,
-0.2217989415,
0.7350498438,
0.500815928,
1.2264463902,
0.0823351815,
0.8185696602,
0.2094766796,
0.3481767476,
-0.638358295,
0.6389220357,
-0.4527955055,
0.256544888,
-0.1676057726,
-1.0068179369,
-0.1546152383,
0.8283723593,
-0.2455658913,
-0.0802836418,
0.7113468647,
0.6694257855,
-0.4629318714,
0.4625180662,
0.3628664017,
0.3771858215,
0.0852517337,
0.6297813058,
1.016133666,
-0.4302798808,
0.4346048236,
-0.6450850964,
0.2921253145,
0.1289915591,
-0.7692620158,
-0.8235042691,
-0.4881274104,
-0.4375442266,
0.0963064432,
0.2237762213,
1.0140534639,
0.8472006321,
-0.9103964567,
-0.4343098998,
-0.5565282702,
-0.224783659,
-0.2684201598,
-0.2032096833,
0.0179465655,
-0.5404427052,
-0.4426936805,
0.264993161,
0.1820578128,
0.2839387655,
-0.2054214627,
0.0072483323,
-0.2416994274,
0.3908126652,
0.4376583993,
0.082958594,
-0.8247796893,
-0.8033989668,
0.0112181911,
-0.3752994835,
0.0301801246,
0.5789198875,
-0.6997080445,
0.4286133051,
0.3255639076,
0.2257018983,
0.4984601736,
0.0640531406,
0.7524177432,
-0.7450031638,
0.2428110987,
0.3424341977,
0.511053741,
0.1531023383,
-0.1207170635,
0.3707923293,
0.1779343188,
-0.2456996292,
-0.7819837332,
0.5612007976,
-0.7521206737,
-0.3851643205,
0.8167620301,
-0.3327875733,
-0.5307149291,
-0.239037022,
0.1805952042,
0.2310649455,
-0.168908596,
0.7962789536,
0.9638881683,
-0.2337125838,
-0.1902601719,
-0.7709043026,
0.49354285,
0.4557131231,
-0.7392290235,
0.1943397522,
0.3411301672,
0.369979322,
0.2026950568,
0.3479780853,
0.1022726223,
0.002384952,
0.0981181562,
-0.153137058,
-0.1966936886,
-0.2694971561,
0.2500720322,
0.1161342412,
-0.1515335888,
-0.1786408573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10025v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10025v2 | When Federated Learning Meets Pre-trained Language Models' Parameter-Efficient Tuning Methods | 2022-12-20T06:44:32 | 2023-06-02T12:58:07 | Zhuo Zhang, Yuanhang Yang, Yong Dai, Lizhen Qu, Zenglin Xu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | With increasing privacy concerns on data, recent studies have made
significant progress using federated learning (FL) on privacy-sensitive natural
language processing (NLP) tasks. Much literature suggests fully fine-tuning
pre-trained language models (PLMs) in the FL paradigm can mitigate the data
heterogeneity problem and close the performance gap with centralized training.
However, large PLMs bring the curse of prohibitive communication overhead and
local model adaptation costs for the FL system. To this end, we introduce
various parameter-efficient tuning (PETuning) methods into federated learning.
Specifically, we provide a holistic empirical study of representative PLMs
tuning methods in FL. The experimental results cover the analysis of data
heterogeneity levels, data scales, and different FL scenarios. Overall
communication overhead can be significantly reduced by locally tuning and
globally aggregating lightweight model parameters while maintaining acceptable
performance in various FL settings. To facilitate the research of PETuning in
FL, we also develop a federated tuning framework FedPETuning, which allows
practitioners to exploit different PETuning methods under the FL training
paradigm conveniently. The source code is available at
\url{https://github.com/iezhuozhuo/FedETuning/tree/deltaTuning}. | [
-0.4826529622,
-0.7133656144,
0.2096305788,
0.4581834078,
-0.2695213854,
0.0051992331,
-0.5743846297,
-0.4437490404,
-0.344843328,
0.6049821973,
-0.6668274403,
-0.3809912801,
-0.0616070665,
0.2389498055,
0.0136954449,
1.1136325598,
0.1806394905,
0.0040871087,
-0.2113522738,
-0.3073379397,
-0.0206905697,
-0.5416057706,
-0.5959652066,
-0.2845157087,
0.5251356959,
0.4338388443,
0.7937119603,
1.050211668,
0.5867953897,
0.3242930174,
0.1843016297,
0.1815683544,
-0.6838237643,
0.1769048721,
-0.3236616552,
-0.7833526731,
-0.4213754237,
0.5115304589,
0.7108201385,
0.7808371186,
-0.2082294375,
0.1998315156,
-0.0156685971,
0.6941545606,
-0.8926824331,
0.3223135769,
-0.5392574668,
0.3828881383,
-0.3009088635,
-0.5951157212,
-0.5799333453,
-0.4723939598,
0.2138391286,
-0.7384752631,
0.4223993123,
0.1701759398,
0.9759099483,
0.3746117353,
0.0365291536,
0.0012852276,
-0.8049396873,
0.9134204388,
-0.5095575452,
0.3857928216,
0.6047967672,
0.2322054207,
-0.0827768147,
-0.7056639194,
-0.0145827495,
0.008275453,
-0.4122256637,
-0.1020642966,
-0.0997659564,
0.3438592851,
0.2469965816,
0.9613764286,
-0.4365378916,
0.3776454329,
0.1299294382,
-0.2218846381,
0.7837389708,
-0.0571662635,
-0.1987073869,
0.2909138203,
-0.4428818822,
-0.3779129684,
-0.4313381314,
0.1485599875,
0.5443715453,
0.6109196544,
-0.1915048063,
-0.1137604192,
-0.4434074461,
0.9553887844,
0.4093708098,
-0.2031981349,
0.2862561643,
-0.3494632244,
-0.480037421,
-0.2620774209,
0.7376489043,
-0.0127176661,
0.3335419595,
-0.5060812831,
-0.2375291586,
-0.3178676069,
0.1737304926,
-0.785603404,
-0.3611095846,
0.1377803534,
-0.3648421466,
-0.3940441608,
0.1590835899,
-0.6214534044,
-0.0794580951,
-0.4843305051,
0.3294793367,
-0.36452052,
-0.4763571322,
-0.0202952083,
0.1638072431,
0.2470111549,
0.0458028428,
-1.1685680151,
0.3177441061,
1.2119104862,
0.8084754944,
0.1333758384,
-0.538538754,
-0.9570004344,
-0.2564084232,
-0.1589440405,
0.3311875463,
-0.4582059681,
-0.0321882516,
-0.0842212588,
0.1292220503,
-0.3603043258,
-0.2968762815,
0.3214434087,
-0.471382767,
0.4676743746,
-0.2968098223,
-0.6124299169,
-0.1592160314,
-0.0403422453,
-0.6135233045,
0.5456245542,
0.1295200586,
-0.8388907313,
0.4353939593,
-0.7319710851,
-0.4530952871,
0.2146998048,
0.0958658606,
-0.8333711028,
0.2399160266,
0.1817883998,
0.7928000093,
-0.0138314255,
0.37399593,
-0.2311914563,
-0.4343000948,
-0.2141807824,
-0.4307788908,
0.9615581036,
0.3953516781,
-0.3717474043,
0.1471962482,
-0.7225113511,
0.194832325,
-0.1299296618,
-0.3366146684,
-0.4543171525,
-0.1359086186,
-0.1877294928,
-0.0491671152,
0.2153536677,
-0.3827751279,
-0.1843629032,
-0.8090279698,
0.3981951773,
0.7073482275,
-0.1445547342,
0.8461216092,
-0.3824820518,
0.46841833,
-0.2060903907,
0.5503925681,
-0.0427639,
-0.0377133489,
-0.6598880291,
-0.2419146597,
0.4034403563,
0.1485606134,
-0.4376091659,
0.4878737032,
-0.1421365887,
-0.471894592,
-0.5204270482,
0.0443341918,
0.4117164612,
0.4529455304,
0.1228703037,
-0.1956320554,
-0.4259676635,
-0.6847506762,
-0.3942437768,
0.11568515,
-0.1239388734,
0.5382459164,
0.0874697939,
0.0982168019,
1.0060596466,
-0.0728752166,
-0.2810779512,
0.2247287184,
0.4138400555,
-0.0194435008,
0.565764308,
0.6411888599,
-0.9777115583,
-0.7350108624,
0.1755636185,
-0.3866333365,
-0.0592799522,
-0.0262661073,
-0.1012213677,
0.3887479901,
0.176036045,
-0.2262637019,
-0.0171763375,
0.924721837,
-0.1969996393,
0.4705581963,
-0.4333087504,
-0.1127776951,
-0.8948882222,
0.1097872034,
-0.2144460529,
-0.6403760314,
-0.6083865762,
0.3427425027,
0.0203172248,
-0.0793025121,
-0.1760481745,
-0.0234084595,
-0.7637037039,
-0.172023192,
-0.3869817257,
-0.3025757372,
-0.1672008634,
0.4690455794,
0.2379740328,
0.948153615,
0.7069701552,
-0.429931581,
0.2187858969,
-0.0800943449,
-0.0210811198,
0.5061376095,
-0.2247780263,
0.1160328239,
0.0146759618,
0.11461097,
-0.21333161,
-0.2272625864,
0.1614966244,
-0.1174115613,
0.1428037435,
0.0870470554,
-0.4866124094,
-0.0055330261,
-0.2868230343,
-0.0436282419,
0.2505097389,
-0.8837739229,
0.5506465435,
0.2047341317,
0.1727921367,
-0.5377889276,
-0.4496741593,
-0.361340642,
-0.3258631825,
-0.4892297089,
0.2933915555,
0.0679657236,
-0.0419023484,
-0.2292633802,
-0.2048050761,
-0.3071237206,
0.5397384763,
0.2960502803,
-0.2768113911,
-0.6298196316,
0.2675234079,
-0.046926681,
-0.2529344261,
0.1719290763,
-0.2118591368,
0.5850995183,
-0.7148461342,
-0.0264618229,
-0.20176135,
0.2211955041,
0.2894702554,
-0.6729103923,
1.0538181067,
0.8453945518,
-0.0281830207,
-0.620439291,
-0.4547899663,
-0.565977931,
-0.5484488606,
-0.0560932681,
-0.2757758498,
-1.281479001,
0.3464806676,
-0.3407925665,
0.3427842855,
0.0415707044,
0.3591628373,
0.0672269836,
0.7085850239,
1.2517831326,
-0.1914945096,
0.6878547668,
0.0663651302,
0.2460451424,
-0.2567486763,
0.2147346586,
-0.4648397267,
-0.1408967227,
-1.0538876057,
-0.3414828181,
0.1190141216,
0.1634573489,
-0.0775045156,
0.3047524989,
-0.4940280914,
0.7875548005,
0.6502349377,
0.0179043319,
0.3935771883,
0.0957800448,
0.0821671113,
0.15919438,
-0.869109869,
-0.0513378307,
0.9736974835,
0.4580868483,
0.4107545018,
-0.1814851761,
0.7528502345,
-0.1718842089,
0.466669172,
-0.3771749437,
0.3015097082,
-0.2081602663,
-0.4978023171,
-0.4309385121,
-0.7293158174,
-0.7398351431,
0.4232473373,
-0.3362905085,
-0.708494246,
0.279622227,
0.3439916074,
-0.4435103834,
0.2527534366,
-0.6619167328,
0.7772108316,
-0.1862665415,
-0.567995429,
-0.2350939363,
-0.9019873738,
0.3383766711,
-0.1405977905,
-0.1230298206,
-0.0647329092,
0.2669697404,
0.5441513062,
-0.5771078467,
0.7371774912,
-0.2737058103,
0.0755495727,
-0.4055824578,
-0.3698207438,
0.401219964,
0.3182682097,
-0.2449676991,
0.3258865476,
-0.0577729419,
-0.2896665335,
-0.324903816,
0.80501616,
-0.8040956855,
-0.46975407,
-0.480817616,
-0.7136927843,
-0.3813586235,
0.1121372506,
0.2747889459,
-0.0057262513,
-0.0696877167,
0.6173225045,
0.8228968382,
-0.0086049885,
0.6400052309,
1.0856167078,
0.0021865317,
-0.1154566705,
0.8225685954,
-0.1035622582,
0.2966347635,
0.5064743161,
0.4038622379,
-0.0912220478,
-0.3182149231,
0.123183988,
0.4312973619,
-0.2291751802,
-0.3096137345,
-0.3274751008,
-0.3733258843,
-0.1410592347,
-0.232472524,
-0.6979245543,
0.0806870088,
-0.5639035702,
-0.1473954916,
0.6414891481,
-0.027342353,
-0.3685677946,
0.6085074544,
-0.4332834482,
-0.077427417,
0.0800789967,
0.9731688499,
-0.1864282638,
0.0862600505,
-0.3449012041,
0.1578374058,
0.0787794366,
-0.3633472919,
0.2265887856,
0.7220351696,
0.3604087532,
0.6737063527,
0.3534401953,
0.6717267036,
-0.3127883077,
0.3798129261,
-0.1777130961,
-0.8703702092,
0.4395425618,
-0.3709686697,
0.2199466228,
0.8949174285,
0.4863326252,
-0.2068997025,
-0.4964125156,
-0.6291710138,
-0.6058929563,
1.0422259569,
0.2020142674,
0.0008081257,
0.5351552367,
0.3952841759,
0.4250789285,
0.2977827489,
-0.677701056,
-0.340462923,
-0.231819585,
0.1460907757,
-0.4362277389,
0.2149229348,
-0.1346249431,
-0.4209414721,
0.6295901537,
-0.2605897188,
-0.0866504237,
-0.1125282422,
-0.0336172618,
-0.4316867888,
0.1621963829,
0.3543694019,
0.6589992046,
-0.3379226327,
-0.1195964888,
-0.2553291619,
-0.3516086936,
-0.1040016189,
0.5312865973,
-0.2763516307,
0.0545202792,
0.0679662973,
1.1062517166,
0.2486697584,
-0.2075316012,
0.4841033816,
-0.3008925617,
-0.4015058577,
-0.0678742304,
0.434483856,
0.0307127032,
0.038406454,
0.0189449601,
0.0523234978,
-0.1912207305,
-0.256775409,
0.3518063724,
0.5378006697,
-0.1314166635,
-0.3540649414,
0.5092879534,
0.3567503989,
-0.5248632431,
0.4389369786,
0.174739629,
-0.1229916364,
0.1490046233,
0.426230818,
0.7238556743,
-0.577254951,
0.5897887945,
0.0780135319,
0.2996067107,
-0.1913934052,
-0.0226276405,
-0.7242162824,
-0.5424879789,
-0.4757713974,
-0.9326752424,
-0.5348123312,
0.4886378348,
-0.8835266232,
-0.097481668,
-0.7319748402,
0.0728418082,
0.0842715725,
0.4517721534,
-0.6061228514,
0.0683683604,
-0.0278856512,
0.747690618,
-1.1192748547,
0.8972527981,
0.536673069,
-0.2271851897,
-1.0649123192,
0.0389054604,
-0.3125739396,
-0.2947588563,
-0.0529923141,
0.2220444232,
0.0954776034,
0.2437740862,
-0.4818020463,
-0.7760450244,
0.9370284081,
0.5190246701,
-0.7672722936,
0.0825544223,
0.5855431557,
0.8204474449,
-0.3398765624,
0.0357957073,
0.7034648061,
0.407071352,
-0.3447585702,
-1.0547103882,
-0.134749487,
0.0768052191,
-0.1113417372,
0.1424642503,
-0.9191881418,
1.1179618835,
0.4234995842,
-0.2957988381,
-0.2830939591,
0.6775320768,
-0.1127693057,
0.251432091,
0.6482246518,
0.3573126495,
1.0233328342,
-0.2173901647,
0.7752435803,
-0.4242435396,
0.6014002562,
1.1713835001,
-0.1447142065,
0.5253845453,
0.4819992185,
0.0793100595,
0.2114720643,
0.5104141831,
-0.0003609471,
0.6664387584,
-0.0411604084,
-0.2859443128,
-0.3308777511,
0.0897107571,
-0.3460600078,
0.6574987769,
0.1395599693,
-0.6559723616,
-0.573687315,
0.3494869173,
-0.0920538455,
0.2076375633,
-0.2706180215,
0.9831705689,
0.1562600583,
-0.5548001528,
0.6660863757,
0.1099254191,
0.7623553276,
-0.7179036736,
0.2467331737,
-0.3443700671,
0.3368608057,
-0.2505761385,
-0.1116051301,
0.4152059257,
-0.0611664876,
-0.273745954,
-0.6505017877,
0.5900161266,
-0.400921911,
-0.1769815832,
0.1990628839,
0.4010078609,
0.0049905851,
-0.1545809358,
-0.6767914295,
-0.1055888906,
-0.0663856491,
-0.386480242,
0.5721851587,
0.2521953583,
-0.0072226734,
0.467949152,
0.6534796953,
0.1611015648,
-0.0771797448,
-0.0332388096,
0.7329546213,
-0.1605974138,
-0.9468561411,
-0.6582328677,
0.1306786686,
-0.1426755786,
-0.3404755294,
1.0039520264,
0.4797626734,
1.1506129503,
-0.0600580983,
0.4391209185,
0.2522744238,
0.5317832828,
-0.3583343923,
1.1277273893,
-0.3368099928,
0.1313982308,
-0.0303510763,
-0.7510941625,
-0.188512519,
0.711022675,
-0.5580815077,
-0.2733826339,
0.4086698294,
0.7745877504,
-0.3799920082,
0.6679777503,
0.1899487078,
0.061546199,
-0.0233444478,
0.3235042393,
0.1947524995,
-0.1717793494,
0.0677151754,
-0.9470264316,
-0.2909271419,
-0.2763442397,
-0.9074175954,
-0.8546649814,
-0.5516565442,
-0.3449605107,
0.3154877126,
0.3662274182,
0.6943839788,
1.1385831833,
-0.8859291673,
-0.068467468,
-0.6293541789,
0.067345351,
-0.5315034389,
-0.3012272418,
0.2099966109,
-0.4336038828,
-0.5361219049,
0.4257986248,
0.1508406997,
-0.2751182318,
-0.4130589664,
-0.0676847324,
-0.1960892975,
-0.1542096287,
0.2416433543,
0.4187854528,
-0.453579545,
-0.186104998,
-0.2768177092,
-0.0030996611,
0.2097741067,
0.7593111992,
-0.7742568254,
0.3579087555,
0.319418788,
0.5062772036,
0.3798543215,
0.5421673656,
0.7868980765,
-1.3047280312,
0.4563013911,
0.4416840672,
-0.183326751,
0.343486011,
-0.6414830089,
0.346235007,
0.0168848503,
-0.7406420708,
-1.0082643032,
-0.0423310697,
-0.610548377,
-0.134086147,
0.6702024341,
-0.4927611351,
-0.3892163634,
0.1229619086,
0.3599929512,
0.2474938631,
-0.1071358547,
0.6221419573,
0.5042843223,
-0.0835268423,
-0.3931307197,
-0.1608780473,
1.0743973255,
0.5164076686,
-0.8517073989,
0.2931645513,
0.4178274572,
0.3422271609,
0.0116267595,
0.5006121993,
0.2625975311,
0.3032735288,
-0.0858686045,
-0.3513130546,
-0.3911832869,
-0.392588675,
-0.6666480303,
0.3966461718,
-0.1483013779,
-0.3292198181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10020v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10020v3 | On the Blind Spots of Model-Based Evaluation Metrics for Text Generation | 2022-12-20T06:24:25 | 2023-05-18T20:46:57 | Tianxing He, Jingyu Zhang, Tianle Wang, Sachin Kumar, Kyunghyun Cho, James Glass, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we explore a useful but often neglected methodology for
robustness analysis of text generation evaluation metrics: stress tests with
synthetic data. Basically, we design and synthesize a wide range of potential
errors and check whether they result in a commensurate drop in the metric
scores. We examine a range of recently proposed evaluation metrics based on
pretrained language models, for the tasks of open-ended generation,
translation, and summarization. Our experiments reveal interesting
insensitivities, biases, or even loopholes in existing metrics. For example, we
find that BERTScore is confused by truncation errors in summarization, and
MAUVE (built on top of GPT-2) is insensitive to errors at the beginning or
middle of generations. Further, we investigate the reasons behind these blind
spots and suggest practical workarounds for a more reliable evaluation of text
generation. We have released our code and data at
https://github.com/cloudygoose/blindspot_nlg. | [
-0.4099482894,
-0.8197054267,
0.6098900437,
0.4326733053,
-0.1395484656,
-0.0435669683,
-0.1824815869,
-0.3486602604,
-0.3046143353,
0.1813796163,
-0.7352790236,
-0.3393183053,
-0.492692709,
0.1742638648,
-0.3509096205,
1.3507555723,
-0.2011401057,
-0.2386921495,
-0.3268108666,
-0.0140173845,
-0.4094524682,
-0.3883269727,
-0.1986352205,
-0.0347913913,
0.3526681364,
0.3204819262,
0.6514540315,
0.3845172822,
0.6971681118,
0.1921860874,
-0.0328880809,
0.3258203864,
-0.4180451632,
0.2820915878,
0.1284249127,
-0.0146695999,
-0.4807642102,
0.0856018215,
0.6633273363,
0.6171898246,
0.1741010547,
0.3475436568,
0.4408165812,
0.4047112465,
-0.7833060026,
-0.2512716055,
-0.724905014,
0.0970360488,
-0.3049177229,
-0.1724740565,
-0.4839144647,
-0.605856359,
0.1018015966,
-0.3280993104,
0.7981179357,
0.0324324705,
1.0376198292,
0.4457694292,
-0.2486512363,
-0.3394348323,
-0.7562431097,
0.9275547862,
-0.9755076766,
0.0387711674,
0.1246387288,
0.1658000201,
-0.1456547529,
-0.5802809,
-0.4178555608,
-0.3381622136,
-0.0024658125,
0.3899757266,
-0.1443132907,
-0.1413412243,
0.3298752606,
0.6525835991,
-0.7406689525,
-0.0053140586,
-0.3514104486,
-0.1390038878,
0.6519890428,
0.1626856327,
0.1953379363,
-0.3269338906,
-0.4063855708,
-0.2289873362,
-0.6464356184,
-0.298035413,
0.6201437712,
0.2903055549,
-0.1700531393,
0.6198062897,
0.1020121127,
0.7543438077,
-0.2401935756,
0.3310440481,
0.3035970926,
-0.5868312716,
-0.1734221727,
-0.5158461928,
0.9807838202,
0.3744482994,
0.3886281848,
0.0149445487,
-0.2914289832,
0.0233213603,
0.4959120154,
-0.6958996654,
-0.1259494424,
0.1100070029,
-0.2312816679,
-0.6321752667,
0.0636502132,
-0.8556838036,
-0.3568794429,
0.1646503806,
0.4124515951,
-0.4377351105,
-0.177483663,
-0.1604887545,
-0.1933799535,
-0.0342180543,
0.0368616842,
-0.6084809303,
0.1429877579,
0.3476129174,
0.8836827874,
-0.3123191893,
-0.1410883665,
0.0218479,
-0.2377906144,
-0.3224346042,
0.7491936684,
-0.0865307078,
-0.4345618784,
0.0629358217,
-0.3466316164,
-0.3401434124,
-0.6165485978,
0.8969290257,
0.1528956294,
0.4212875366,
0.1214185208,
-0.3058383465,
-0.0331332348,
0.2158017009,
-0.5573554039,
1.3168914318,
0.3110891581,
-0.906037569,
0.5132555366,
-0.5897403359,
-0.4562087655,
-0.2735635042,
0.0620031767,
-0.8229422569,
0.4574223161,
0.1006619558,
0.3304264545,
-0.4499491155,
0.1101019084,
-0.2364645749,
-0.1961491853,
0.4839679003,
-0.5309740305,
0.5804649591,
0.2544870377,
-0.4343419075,
-0.0690671578,
-1.0783879757,
0.3574858308,
0.1300276667,
-0.2707854509,
-0.413258791,
0.0106885573,
0.3154556751,
0.1882876158,
-0.1664522737,
-0.3188927472,
-0.1597914994,
-0.3821641505,
0.2641659379,
0.5802943707,
0.2521265149,
-0.1250969917,
-0.3194797337,
0.5954048038,
0.0737953484,
0.2107672095,
-0.2469497472,
-0.5268751979,
-0.8685314655,
0.0670605823,
0.3628253043,
0.4695460796,
-0.654001236,
0.4299044907,
0.0415416881,
-0.8367131948,
-0.2822018564,
0.0078123063,
0.7096636891,
0.5482925177,
0.1049542353,
-0.4852184653,
-0.4033852518,
-0.9240392447,
-0.4924595356,
-0.1438883245,
-0.074670963,
0.1486726999,
0.4832659364,
0.0313712396,
0.8769026399,
-0.5501495004,
0.0626565441,
-0.0256207064,
0.461673975,
-0.011353475,
0.7470069528,
0.7029648423,
-0.621278882,
-0.1401530057,
-0.2648679912,
-0.6615182161,
-0.4386038482,
-0.2416425496,
-0.0440414138,
0.1139575019,
0.2663133442,
-0.6894407272,
0.3678890765,
0.6340663433,
-0.415905565,
0.985703826,
-0.1367634833,
0.091715008,
-1.1125797033,
0.1969179958,
0.1554614007,
-0.2218145132,
-0.6708032489,
0.0805153549,
-0.0288308337,
-0.2164658457,
-0.3921588659,
0.3274570107,
-0.456330508,
-0.0225914139,
-0.0966550857,
0.3335615695,
0.0247407574,
0.2608069777,
-0.3990366459,
0.7806241512,
0.130612269,
-0.506817162,
-0.2105711699,
0.1235882044,
-0.3726106584,
0.4206094742,
-0.7103881836,
0.2704783678,
0.0903329253,
-0.240453437,
-1.0283503532,
-0.316716224,
0.1338252872,
-0.6608685255,
0.2501227558,
0.3928530514,
-0.4576267004,
-0.4656234384,
-0.3170342147,
0.4609596133,
0.5233784318,
-0.2559514344,
0.0341022648,
0.1945315599,
-0.3322618902,
-0.5088782907,
-0.6807981133,
-0.2097792774,
-0.3076736629,
-0.6137728095,
-0.0297893584,
-0.1052896082,
-0.3009245396,
0.0740983635,
0.0166715737,
-0.0978645533,
0.2860862315,
0.249607712,
0.1341032088,
-0.2708725631,
0.0778923631,
0.1086631119,
0.0021118787,
0.009791269,
-0.1751808077,
0.1700698882,
-0.1257390827,
-0.1913178563,
0.2357939631,
0.209321335,
0.5712704062,
-0.175741747,
0.4414092302,
0.3769092262,
-0.4022892416,
-0.6639062762,
-0.3093907535,
-0.0097691929,
-0.3998358846,
0.4470332861,
-0.0674605146,
-0.6805147529,
0.3991129994,
-0.0090760505,
0.2010760456,
0.7816313505,
0.7237989902,
0.0527594052,
0.9628483057,
0.8318225741,
0.5169446468,
0.18611902,
-0.0005906265,
0.2235476673,
-0.6612339616,
0.0832676664,
-0.7637855411,
0.0074070669,
-0.6031140685,
-0.4750264585,
0.3843710423,
0.1163768917,
0.0921449289,
0.3008547723,
-0.6199473739,
0.3745736778,
0.4407994747,
-0.3326123357,
0.2132265419,
-0.1931245029,
-0.3000147939,
-0.3672430217,
-0.8513154984,
-0.5796157718,
0.9079831243,
0.176302433,
0.4145088494,
-0.2237089723,
0.4715756178,
0.1771478057,
0.6595914364,
-0.4148905277,
0.2973361611,
-0.1281201243,
-0.7397584319,
-0.1959830374,
-0.6996197701,
-0.7035374045,
0.3242518902,
-0.3500709832,
-0.6826630831,
0.144389838,
0.3649507761,
-0.3368301094,
-0.0335420817,
-0.8952479959,
1.1349219084,
-0.1814160496,
-0.4576668441,
0.1341109425,
-0.394276619,
0.8463553786,
-0.4255103171,
0.2397422343,
-0.0520371832,
0.2727822959,
0.722248435,
-0.5908259749,
0.652459383,
-0.0723511651,
-0.1602540165,
0.4281591475,
0.1660354882,
0.2757068872,
-0.2095818818,
-0.2158619761,
-0.0513207838,
-0.2187816203,
-0.2459138781,
-0.5818341374,
0.5395200253,
-0.4541506767,
-0.3558894694,
-0.4050959945,
-0.7517041564,
-0.4870800972,
0.3148588538,
0.6274737716,
0.2923649549,
-0.435348928,
0.1155380085,
0.2352609038,
-0.5370553732,
0.3924033344,
0.2217814624,
-0.0306778736,
-0.4401056767,
0.8384873271,
0.1525727361,
0.463765353,
-0.2482632101,
0.1605086476,
-0.1009889618,
-0.6600744724,
-0.4682651162,
0.1103216782,
-0.4523085058,
-0.1974411458,
-0.2519359887,
-0.3931877017,
-0.2115084976,
-0.1821197271,
-0.4379813075,
-0.6523090005,
-0.1243253425,
-0.2644872963,
0.0469012447,
0.5527157187,
0.0005864251,
0.4232312143,
-0.6742582321,
0.1278530061,
-0.2031416297,
0.2506939769,
0.0545306094,
-0.3217272758,
-0.4157964587,
-0.3059072793,
-0.811504662,
-0.8717823625,
0.2464547157,
0.1852253675,
0.2682750225,
0.2777434886,
0.1073234975,
0.3644313216,
-0.4335358441,
0.9311121702,
0.2182223946,
-1.022592783,
0.5605251193,
-0.6108420491,
0.2689375877,
0.5867075324,
0.0560241751,
-0.2297275215,
-1.1364014149,
-0.9126899838,
-1.0467708111,
0.4861244559,
0.7772016525,
0.0962301716,
0.0855585188,
0.2519680858,
0.386074692,
0.2453462481,
-0.7988688946,
-0.0251186583,
-0.1541068852,
-0.3096704483,
-0.2824888229,
-0.2663092911,
0.0713940337,
0.0789732113,
0.6721068621,
-0.0034649789,
-0.134638235,
0.3793986738,
-0.0303889066,
-0.2221429646,
0.2750805318,
0.8296888471,
0.6942236423,
-0.2967781425,
0.1376864463,
-0.0175707862,
-0.6521040797,
0.1638313383,
0.1632059962,
-0.721571207,
0.3524688184,
0.4454458058,
0.8714994788,
0.1251078546,
-0.6078603268,
0.4640093446,
0.0636517406,
-0.3624232113,
-0.2636295557,
0.0192287173,
-0.1741317958,
-0.1224203706,
0.2371105999,
0.1956903785,
0.1151455045,
-0.2798985541,
0.288569361,
0.309461087,
-0.5416093469,
-0.3927625418,
0.8490986824,
0.3098671436,
-0.1739899069,
0.2437610626,
-0.1503061354,
-0.4170877934,
0.6652770638,
0.6025781631,
1.2320168018,
-0.2520575523,
0.3962200284,
0.3547701836,
0.781832993,
0.1303984672,
0.269123137,
0.1014917195,
-0.556514442,
-0.3843028843,
-0.6294261217,
-0.4608330429,
0.2215299308,
-0.4420259595,
0.2635442019,
-0.3776886761,
-0.5114843845,
-0.0337122008,
-0.2483341247,
-0.4412021339,
0.4477178454,
-0.1262178868,
0.7261359692,
-0.9838539958,
0.257892549,
0.4605551064,
-0.3665857911,
-0.6948184967,
0.326040417,
-0.0742346793,
-0.1904781759,
0.1489560306,
0.1051928699,
0.020264877,
-0.0710903034,
-0.2541171312,
-0.5926172137,
0.6638403535,
0.3324838579,
-0.3981710374,
0.054728806,
0.1485147625,
0.7160010338,
-0.0992731526,
0.3234808445,
0.5417092443,
0.5727245808,
-0.3390710354,
-0.7144806981,
0.2384690046,
-0.4480476081,
-0.0114298174,
0.2595517635,
-0.6703794599,
0.9178187251,
-0.1928988099,
-0.3788657486,
0.3288198709,
0.2722411156,
0.3079451323,
0.5378302932,
0.4128258228,
0.5455759168,
0.5660581589,
-0.4501008391,
1.2368412018,
-0.0370805599,
0.5116330385,
0.979193449,
-0.1616057009,
0.4979570806,
0.4661962986,
0.0570178777,
0.2577489913,
0.6433436871,
-0.2412322611,
0.356097579,
0.4621706605,
0.066176787,
0.0127050709,
-0.0435896814,
-0.3710760772,
0.1411882043,
0.1240387112,
-0.5015957952,
-0.3638083041,
-0.1131017804,
0.0971403494,
0.1496865004,
0.1181974038,
0.4848310053,
0.3616214395,
-0.7613229752,
0.7053764462,
0.0801508501,
0.4316849113,
-0.4807559252,
0.1759189367,
-0.3148520589,
0.4457198977,
-0.1900129467,
-0.4593833089,
0.4504722655,
0.4786948562,
-0.1229250804,
-0.1011241376,
0.8839762211,
-0.1909571141,
-0.7313914299,
0.1097168252,
0.7105360031,
0.1921699494,
0.10922122,
-0.4207979441,
-0.0597314797,
-0.1199819297,
-0.5696856976,
-0.0633187145,
0.549980104,
-0.1118255183,
0.2234755605,
0.6138136387,
0.2452840656,
0.2028846145,
0.1444035321,
0.472104609,
-0.5795058608,
-0.4357512295,
-0.8234857917,
0.7625192404,
-0.0871205553,
-0.9426173568,
1.1775071621,
0.5914430618,
0.68498981,
-0.3104326427,
1.0196537971,
-0.1100765616,
0.5331044793,
-0.5455118418,
1.0136560202,
-0.5913652778,
0.0275234841,
-0.7836123705,
-1.3108872175,
-0.5191168785,
0.1816212833,
-0.1844720691,
0.127086401,
0.8690350056,
0.8088336587,
-0.0745648444,
-0.2117588371,
0.2930064499,
0.1886893064,
0.0793872625,
0.6515519619,
1.156603694,
-0.5615586042,
0.5659577847,
-0.0908640474,
-0.3094597161,
-0.1645829678,
-0.8681709766,
-0.7531647682,
-0.6447111964,
-0.3554810882,
-0.4049287736,
0.1606700569,
0.2418030649,
0.6564387083,
-0.6466172934,
-0.0394227654,
-0.3326586187,
0.063917771,
-0.2361528724,
-0.2389327437,
0.2912440598,
-0.3948928714,
-0.677678287,
0.2104969621,
0.0385758989,
0.3395398855,
-0.2860910892,
0.027482599,
0.1344469637,
0.3874284029,
0.2400826216,
0.1593986899,
-0.2815849185,
-0.3565976322,
-0.1602241248,
-0.0598633364,
-0.1840141714,
1.0495396852,
-0.4038379788,
0.3393040895,
0.5440090299,
0.4217061698,
0.4157007933,
0.2281066328,
0.9047135711,
-1.1377159357,
0.3821665347,
0.2812598348,
0.0725925416,
0.6136895418,
-0.1525177956,
0.6382328272,
0.2850264907,
-0.483889848,
-1.338352561,
0.0885204673,
-0.7215175629,
-0.1464330554,
0.8604015112,
-0.1217906103,
-0.2125321478,
0.1510174721,
-0.0368885808,
0.2959140837,
0.1455903947,
1.114490509,
0.9615640044,
0.1077857688,
-0.0301374551,
-0.8337963223,
0.7227376103,
0.7969716787,
-1.0144363642,
0.2735312581,
0.6461875439,
0.0085133342,
0.4121986032,
0.4145048857,
-0.3238772452,
0.3796390593,
0.4151657522,
0.1522150636,
-0.0493089333,
-0.2924788594,
-0.1585913002,
0.202428177,
0.1114677191,
-0.1189576015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10019v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10019v1 | When Do Decompositions Help for Machine Reading? | 2022-12-20T06:23:02 | 2022-12-20T06:23:02 | Kangda Wei, Dawn Lawrie, Benjamin Van Durme, Yunmo Chen, Orion Weller | cs.CL | cs.CL | Answering complex questions often requires multi-step reasoning in order to
obtain the final answer. Most research into decompositions of complex questions
involves open-domain systems, which have shown success in using these
decompositions for improved retrieval. In the machine reading setting, however,
work to understand when decompositions are helpful is understudied. We conduct
experiments on decompositions in machine reading to unify recent work in this
space, using a range of models and datasets. We find that decompositions can be
helpful in the few-shot case, giving several points of improvement in exact
match scores. However, we also show that when models are given access to
datasets with around a few hundred or more examples, decompositions are not
helpful (and can actually be detrimental). Thus, our analysis implies that
models can learn decompositions implicitly even with limited data. | [
-0.4096697867,
-0.6324255466,
0.8418895602,
-0.1526407152,
-0.28964293,
-0.1074541733,
0.1747642159,
-0.5636453629,
-0.5358014703,
0.6034262776,
-0.6483995318,
-0.4456022978,
-0.4215097725,
0.4462432861,
-0.5731194019,
0.9430783391,
0.0189962033,
0.2748354077,
-0.5255386829,
-0.2455740273,
-0.3110049367,
-0.4871831238,
-0.6149806976,
-0.4261261821,
0.6335497499,
0.4064179659,
0.3764725626,
0.9863159657,
0.7706344724,
0.2403135002,
-0.1121150926,
0.3726595938,
-0.5942397714,
0.7848175168,
0.1062005758,
-0.8468512297,
-0.227807492,
0.1663244218,
0.5168809295,
1.2856464386,
0.2631066144,
0.3282279372,
0.044854369,
0.8467318416,
-0.9556933045,
0.2900398374,
-0.3559061587,
0.0443706773,
-0.0357063301,
-0.07861536,
-0.7306509614,
-0.1558024287,
0.3001867235,
-0.6296072602,
0.6129295826,
0.1005667821,
0.4403922856,
0.4482609034,
-0.6818432212,
-0.5082118511,
-1.031286478,
0.7553512454,
-0.3121595681,
0.1721971929,
0.5712016821,
0.6093400717,
-0.1013622284,
-0.5729946494,
-0.4084045291,
0.121631451,
-0.3168833852,
0.0764568821,
-0.171946153,
0.1303061843,
0.6350185275,
0.2472389787,
-0.3142024279,
-0.1888442487,
-0.4422329366,
-0.1087437421,
0.2763491869,
0.433994174,
0.4817857742,
-0.1850094199,
-0.216168642,
-0.2168160677,
-0.6084954143,
0.0837644935,
0.3562701643,
0.3832653463,
0.4388124347,
0.9574598074,
-0.0216599852,
0.9085099697,
-0.2635883987,
-0.1689801514,
-0.0542780347,
-0.2896682024,
-0.3548961282,
-0.1746468097,
0.1861141771,
0.2832393944,
0.3064325452,
-0.3252238929,
-0.2959086001,
0.295324266,
0.1194580868,
-0.7743493915,
-0.4701390862,
0.4366642535,
-0.4819152057,
0.0551240668,
0.2262693495,
-0.4502087533,
-0.4458053708,
-0.5257949829,
0.4175881743,
-0.3212524056,
-0.0460875817,
0.3355131447,
-0.7787009478,
0.2760709524,
0.5934970975,
-0.5632708073,
0.4718273878,
0.7145515084,
0.5633721948,
0.0072824652,
-0.0250867046,
-0.8949813247,
0.1151620224,
-0.3518278599,
1.1821378469,
-0.676943779,
-0.2368397117,
-0.1908741891,
0.0531397834,
-0.4571824372,
-0.9247618914,
0.6691883206,
-0.557992816,
0.1759310961,
-0.2671512365,
-0.6262522936,
-0.1888703853,
0.3130502403,
-1.0214774609,
0.9369158149,
-0.1048184857,
-0.8346235156,
0.2380318791,
-0.7869500518,
-0.5685392022,
-0.4861412346,
0.2250320613,
-0.5495733619,
0.3099831343,
0.2057010233,
0.5640772581,
0.014090647,
-0.1996628195,
-0.585258007,
-0.3433685899,
0.2535415888,
-0.2992997169,
0.9102641344,
0.3258438408,
-0.2316731215,
-0.1669575721,
-0.7995165586,
0.1637230366,
0.0486851782,
-0.2684589624,
-0.5547859073,
0.1789365858,
-0.2474073768,
-0.0849451795,
-0.3418282866,
-0.613317132,
0.3987771273,
-0.2609866261,
0.018755937,
0.4614790082,
0.0511411168,
0.6513094306,
-0.3710412383,
0.6892908812,
0.0570781939,
-0.3120394945,
-0.5370498896,
-0.2522274256,
-0.8566911817,
-0.4646745622,
0.5374475121,
0.6626304388,
-0.6153080463,
-0.1573060751,
0.3376992643,
-0.3783852756,
-0.7541669607,
-0.0875326172,
0.5377091169,
0.5776106715,
0.5231556296,
0.2881259024,
-0.5698150992,
-0.8917812109,
-0.6048441529,
0.1100836545,
-0.3771701157,
0.2295929343,
0.4225782156,
-0.1756521314,
0.5766264796,
-0.9143422246,
-0.166535154,
-0.1523062289,
0.1814910471,
-0.1763572842,
0.2129601538,
0.4110698104,
-0.7868978977,
-0.3003795445,
-0.3051953018,
-0.811974287,
0.0462228395,
0.0311582703,
-0.2835073471,
-0.1332314759,
0.5145109296,
-0.4663636684,
0.4845111668,
0.244291693,
-0.2315556854,
0.2760817111,
-0.321351856,
-0.026646683,
-0.5961862206,
0.1681137532,
-0.0201308914,
-0.5362256169,
-0.7601930499,
0.2664960027,
-0.1458743513,
-0.0380279496,
-0.1250683516,
0.2889445424,
-0.6175785661,
-0.2730767131,
-0.3167334199,
0.0597035922,
0.0153268371,
0.0846873075,
0.0092116809,
0.3712337911,
0.4728650451,
-0.7471895814,
-0.0402582586,
0.207492575,
-0.2679221928,
0.313965857,
-0.5233466625,
0.3757389486,
-0.5626628995,
0.3790341318,
-1.3682578802,
-0.3883501291,
0.3391207755,
-0.2993425727,
0.1759975404,
-0.1599288583,
-0.463322103,
-0.1183824614,
-0.2657960951,
0.458542645,
0.0956524536,
-0.5441682339,
0.7220938206,
0.4309327304,
0.0607430823,
-0.5850580931,
-0.5259298682,
-0.6879177094,
-0.1019191295,
-0.4682943821,
-0.0301363263,
-0.3895841241,
-0.6781846881,
0.169379577,
-0.2753901184,
-0.3637704253,
0.3315791488,
0.3795979917,
0.1622560173,
-0.3442578912,
0.2028068602,
0.0483039841,
-0.4547119141,
-0.1033920795,
0.0162441712,
0.1819589734,
0.1267952621,
-0.2755100429,
-0.2407257557,
0.7608429193,
0.6227366924,
-0.2194797099,
0.6142547131,
0.4963382185,
-0.4440996647,
-0.4423898757,
-0.2699865997,
-0.1184787676,
-0.3659614921,
-0.2201913446,
-0.5820508599,
-0.8132730126,
0.5421221852,
-0.2288923711,
0.0945710391,
0.7122812867,
0.3832773864,
-0.6915220618,
1.4895987511,
0.6946473718,
0.2972762287,
0.1681046784,
-0.3968769312,
0.0817312822,
-0.8398334384,
-0.4500021935,
-1.0921233892,
-0.3157764375,
-0.4244677126,
-0.2544371188,
0.4074039161,
0.1010623872,
0.0013157771,
-0.2147250473,
-0.480715096,
0.8518582582,
0.705883801,
0.416179955,
0.4800991714,
-0.1132681668,
-0.042300541,
0.2044267803,
-0.5779307485,
-0.5052848458,
1.1609956026,
-0.0043640048,
0.5756154656,
-0.1185907722,
0.6844639182,
0.1485339403,
0.2913484871,
-1.1820474863,
0.2504391968,
-0.1507118046,
-0.8515662551,
-0.4404689968,
-0.4616617858,
-1.2938578129,
0.4022658467,
0.11133755,
-0.2353271544,
0.1631290615,
0.1847531497,
-0.2846278846,
0.0914102271,
-0.9281097651,
0.7485308647,
0.1828508675,
0.0932657421,
-0.0052967919,
-0.7207409143,
0.3771026731,
0.069741793,
0.2809053957,
-0.0606677197,
0.0514841713,
0.8633857369,
-0.4964028299,
0.7095652223,
-0.3350815177,
0.0009871317,
0.5736219883,
0.3473476171,
0.319862932,
-0.3182711303,
-0.2793937624,
-0.3901032507,
0.5434081554,
-0.7443627715,
-0.7489641905,
0.2723738253,
-0.7699158192,
-0.5075820684,
-0.434548825,
-0.4065565765,
-0.1526422948,
0.3861697614,
0.1738573313,
0.5933368802,
0.163146764,
0.388284117,
0.924818933,
0.493376404,
0.4099009633,
0.2818886936,
-0.0094309319,
-0.0010271111,
0.5201123357,
0.2115851343,
0.261474669,
0.3985474408,
0.2184353024,
-0.2947029471,
-0.649189353,
-0.2263330072,
0.203054443,
-1.0406732559,
-0.2607896924,
-0.6104158163,
0.2979294062,
-0.1137847975,
0.0449531712,
0.0220591947,
-0.5100867748,
-0.4163273275,
-0.4147564471,
-0.1339487284,
0.8062412739,
0.0372080468,
-0.025460938,
-0.8071016669,
0.9103851318,
0.3430086374,
0.2096256167,
-0.106000416,
-0.1937287003,
-0.0996101573,
-0.0733504742,
0.1480552256,
-0.8669410348,
0.0674680769,
0.1441278309,
0.7109020352,
0.1093808115,
0.4269500971,
0.822702527,
-0.5278363824,
0.5074540973,
-0.3320975602,
-0.8790425062,
0.3211187124,
-0.3598978221,
0.5677093863,
0.8105621338,
0.8265531659,
-0.3808663487,
-0.3083521426,
-0.40080598,
-0.5874593258,
0.8850696683,
-0.0726903602,
0.0604489297,
0.2292035371,
0.4419481158,
0.4330186844,
0.0748510063,
-0.3999071121,
-0.380205065,
0.0934920684,
-0.1426232606,
-0.0872186646,
-0.2723139226,
-0.1892571151,
-0.4492848814,
0.3901410699,
-0.3179944158,
0.4406940937,
0.1057042629,
-0.3965939879,
-0.3372634947,
0.0141310459,
0.4965643883,
0.6158809662,
-0.2357016504,
0.4753469229,
-0.3128269911,
-0.2699705958,
0.1827360988,
-0.2633395791,
-0.123979114,
-0.2547111809,
0.7744642496,
0.4552337527,
0.0534062013,
-0.6884044409,
0.2422709912,
-0.1070844606,
-0.2249035537,
0.0714291707,
0.3607015312,
-0.0193944499,
0.3618246913,
0.415823251,
0.4092153609,
0.3675549328,
-0.8501541018,
0.2807819545,
0.2491338104,
-0.2376836091,
-0.287211746,
0.3498027325,
-0.0818843544,
-0.2903267145,
0.9339271188,
-0.1324428469,
-0.5321570635,
0.5460903645,
0.5421105027,
0.7776654959,
-0.1484229118,
0.2350596488,
0.2935245037,
0.1329068393,
-0.1516036093,
0.2221618146,
-0.3034302592,
-0.6554740071,
-0.4106277823,
-0.4282254577,
-0.5118784904,
-0.0444376953,
-0.8536664248,
0.0546736345,
-0.2850784659,
0.1625251323,
0.4500173628,
-0.0848447606,
-0.8847278953,
0.3410119712,
-0.0679069012,
0.4928877652,
-1.0024881363,
0.5021570921,
0.5654377937,
-0.492185533,
-0.7073754072,
0.1630175114,
-0.0499605164,
-0.596159935,
0.7554869056,
0.2200426757,
-0.3704613447,
0.1067136526,
-0.804071486,
-0.5570721626,
0.6827098131,
0.5261190534,
-0.0609412715,
-0.1788385063,
0.0796210617,
0.7047058344,
-0.2840839922,
0.4988594353,
0.5372090936,
0.7623494267,
0.1167274565,
-0.7309293747,
-0.1209741831,
-0.1155137494,
-0.6238704324,
0.288531363,
-0.3106314242,
1.0589313507,
-0.3201257586,
-0.3743202388,
0.042713359,
0.2786995769,
-0.2291831821,
0.8476188183,
0.6080924273,
0.3489100933,
1.0437530279,
-0.060083352,
1.3992741108,
0.3626653254,
0.3093854487,
0.9644886851,
-0.0120547125,
1.0041697025,
0.190312475,
-0.1438934803,
0.5188801289,
0.6535636187,
0.2689266503,
0.5084662437,
0.1779409051,
-0.0764354393,
-0.9283280969,
0.0171733033,
-0.0254357606,
0.4447445571,
0.2239467502,
-0.3388639092,
-0.6660437584,
0.1208309755,
-0.0610361323,
0.0787959024,
-0.1371991336,
0.9588422179,
0.0547247157,
-0.7754637003,
0.6835411191,
-0.1535202712,
-0.0518482774,
-0.3091479242,
-0.3246283233,
-0.1554226279,
0.3580522537,
-0.3791123331,
-0.8032769561,
0.3178580701,
-0.0120324884,
-0.6480938792,
-0.1895125657,
0.9041154981,
-0.2115788609,
-0.3840017021,
0.2283351868,
0.7564911246,
0.2218393683,
-0.3789802492,
-0.4763746858,
0.0762183294,
0.0539308265,
-0.3471135497,
0.3889461756,
0.4992907047,
0.0049262838,
0.7228969336,
0.7447660565,
-0.4319661856,
0.1935055256,
-0.1859099269,
0.7649229169,
-0.5797929764,
0.0677483082,
-0.7282333374,
0.8141599298,
0.2454198748,
-0.0167149268,
0.9586283565,
0.7738196254,
0.8896499872,
-0.1754689217,
0.8420982957,
0.5172038674,
0.832423389,
-0.5436590314,
0.1742559522,
-0.6265740395,
0.127132833,
-0.2628175616,
-0.914948523,
-0.8287390471,
0.5522327423,
-0.4209249318,
-0.2082294822,
0.873085618,
0.3789147735,
-0.2045238912,
0.0369243436,
0.2625086308,
-0.1238000393,
0.3333441913,
0.1388604492,
0.9402421713,
-0.3520601392,
0.6245983243,
-0.1331971437,
-0.0165484473,
-0.4257165194,
-0.5200164318,
-1.0303809643,
-0.5479444265,
-0.2845346928,
-0.2352176756,
-0.1511648595,
0.5213575363,
0.3658332527,
-0.7929777503,
-0.064431265,
0.2012905777,
0.3861054182,
-0.2882538736,
-0.1664340496,
0.4752105772,
-0.3529208899,
-0.8245462179,
0.566070497,
0.2801980376,
-0.06253317,
-0.1358606517,
0.3847734928,
-0.1585411131,
0.1481245309,
0.8402894735,
0.2763263285,
-0.307150811,
-0.3542465568,
0.5411660075,
-0.0188667923,
0.1831699908,
1.235090971,
-0.7909297943,
0.7989573479,
1.0316747427,
0.8009578586,
0.797680676,
0.2790165842,
0.4079388082,
-0.4480919242,
-0.1625432968,
0.5200112462,
0.3071838021,
0.0610649958,
-0.2541584671,
0.5659837723,
0.2649868727,
-0.4944893122,
-1.2071602345,
0.2738752961,
-0.8410047293,
-0.5415148735,
1.018152833,
-0.1904099137,
-0.5745220184,
-0.4216908216,
-0.3004801273,
0.2805341482,
-0.0288013518,
0.4955536127,
0.8874233365,
-0.6810804605,
0.0158576369,
-0.4678715467,
0.3564281762,
0.5075902343,
-0.9798495173,
0.1597935557,
0.7743124962,
0.3473399282,
0.139865607,
0.5619011521,
0.1470754743,
0.2415448278,
0.1852999926,
-0.6216108203,
-0.125100702,
-0.6681111455,
-0.3398184478,
0.6291766763,
0.0443553962,
-0.2566088736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10018v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10018v2 | DIONYSUS: A Pre-trained Model for Low-Resource Dialogue Summarization | 2022-12-20T06:21:21 | 2023-05-26T17:29:01 | Yu Li, Baolin Peng, Pengcheng He, Michel Galley, Zhou Yu, Jianfeng Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue summarization has recently garnered significant attention due to its
wide range of applications. However, existing methods for summarizing dialogues
have limitations because they do not take into account the inherent structure
of dialogue and rely heavily on labeled data, which can lead to poor
performance in new domains. In this work, we propose DIONYSUS (dynamic input
optimization in pre-training for dialogue summarization), a pre-trained
encoder-decoder model for summarizing dialogues in any new domain. To pre-train
DIONYSUS, we create two pseudo summaries for each dialogue example: one is
produced by a fine-tuned summarization model, and the other is a collection of
dialogue turns that convey important information. We then choose one of these
pseudo summaries based on the difference in information distribution across
different types of dialogues. This selected pseudo summary serves as the
objective for pre-training DIONYSUS using a self-supervised approach on a large
dialogue corpus. Our experiments show that DIONYSUS outperforms existing
methods on six datasets, as demonstrated by its ROUGE scores in zero-shot and
few-shot settings. | [
-0.4532881975,
-0.4093788862,
0.5205964446,
-0.0107798688,
-0.6751525402,
0.2172507495,
-0.1890544146,
0.0148245795,
0.7959054112,
0.5047318339,
-0.7446137071,
-0.5075812936,
-0.6443422437,
0.4018206,
-0.1386025101,
1.3786702156,
0.0902649388,
-0.114499718,
-0.071382381,
-0.2679308057,
-0.1012938395,
-0.4142150879,
-0.5205881596,
0.0215436034,
0.6164519191,
0.3878662288,
0.5591568351,
0.4060626626,
0.0512454584,
0.4136983156,
0.034520667,
0.4292918444,
-0.8256139159,
0.1359661222,
0.010515145,
-0.4484157562,
-0.7406619787,
0.0755403787,
0.7226387262,
0.5813632607,
-0.2377283126,
0.4315912127,
0.2510911822,
0.2593911588,
-0.9163944721,
0.1014975607,
-0.2564689517,
0.1678041965,
0.0347020514,
-0.6026669145,
-0.2219404429,
-0.6648600698,
0.360567987,
-1.0088076591,
0.1092558578,
-0.2468433827,
0.5213322639,
0.4675066769,
-0.27849105,
-0.1469535828,
-0.7072387338,
0.8143407106,
-0.7027945518,
-0.032046888,
0.3126502335,
0.1922776997,
0.1510646641,
-0.8710985184,
-0.580468595,
0.0102380402,
-0.1365879327,
0.4308599532,
-0.1316118091,
0.3188243806,
0.1907351613,
0.3616458178,
-0.4751295149,
-0.178691119,
-0.3559570014,
-0.1560531408,
0.3814211786,
0.5785646439,
0.2717169821,
0.0216013696,
0.1331179142,
-0.3015010655,
-0.4080007076,
-0.0526487827,
0.4241807759,
0.2346975654,
-0.4554929435,
0.4314936101,
-0.4302865267,
0.6452211738,
0.0041729151,
-0.3413947821,
-0.1095298231,
-0.1720036715,
-0.2835403383,
0.3209323883,
0.960052371,
0.426074475,
0.3601000607,
0.0221324656,
-0.0250457302,
-0.0763894171,
0.2612302005,
-1.2781764269,
-0.6163793802,
0.1251346618,
-0.4596918523,
-0.3223198354,
-0.4549037218,
-0.6364683509,
-0.2820894122,
-0.364269644,
0.3316271603,
-0.2724308074,
-0.2128207535,
0.0169846378,
0.0352056697,
-0.3030528128,
0.7498041391,
-1.0078269243,
0.6169201732,
0.0179644953,
0.9201236963,
-0.0544778407,
-0.2250682414,
-0.9697583914,
-0.0422377735,
-0.3045080304,
0.6894949675,
-0.6270620227,
-0.5856310725,
-0.1351587623,
-0.1937409192,
-0.1965812743,
-0.4570576549,
0.2692272067,
-0.315394938,
0.3488892019,
-0.1001689509,
-0.3594927788,
0.0016124126,
0.1526566893,
-0.4991250634,
0.5290498137,
0.3217573762,
-0.9777976871,
0.1887360811,
-0.6523801088,
-0.370757848,
0.0488196202,
-0.2925406098,
-0.3473411798,
0.2958475947,
0.3241390586,
0.2967474759,
-0.2594588995,
0.060967017,
-0.1996559203,
-0.4673106372,
0.2946938872,
-0.2907871604,
0.538058579,
0.3702720702,
0.154305771,
0.1528274417,
-0.5233195424,
0.1236223578,
-0.0965445265,
-0.2477304935,
-0.1377629042,
-0.0914913639,
-0.159394756,
-0.1078896448,
-0.030686589,
-0.4041560888,
0.2390886396,
-0.4667740762,
0.1738017052,
0.3414404094,
0.1244802698,
0.5387833118,
-0.3406107426,
0.8680984378,
-0.1664157212,
0.1362181157,
-0.4137500226,
-0.0950534865,
-0.7108960748,
-0.5792057514,
0.4014154375,
0.6352598071,
-1.0123826265,
0.1766380966,
-0.3654728532,
-0.3725103438,
-0.4261456728,
0.0297187269,
0.2781419456,
0.2821270823,
0.4656419754,
-0.4892145395,
-0.4215385914,
-0.8227649927,
-0.5512378216,
-0.2720344663,
-0.0592580847,
-0.0266415458,
0.3655537367,
0.0036672256,
0.9782639742,
-0.7650945783,
-0.1996574998,
-0.9524428844,
0.3294883072,
0.2194067985,
0.3439243734,
0.4289995134,
-0.3469600677,
-0.6052885652,
-0.298471272,
-0.7348507643,
0.059151154,
-0.1601274163,
0.0327683277,
-0.4165011942,
0.3190700114,
-0.9960974455,
0.5763315558,
0.179678604,
0.3286024928,
0.511433363,
-0.4381897449,
0.2473291904,
-1.3834971189,
-0.1791768521,
-0.1158328429,
-0.3129848838,
-0.5618869662,
-0.525747776,
-0.1984826177,
-0.4334484637,
-0.4023497999,
0.3559241593,
-0.2850180268,
0.1310075372,
-0.2300491631,
0.2341786325,
-0.0835689083,
0.7938261628,
0.5701202154,
0.5205349326,
0.3185165823,
-0.6902176738,
0.4936037362,
0.4279842973,
-0.5996981263,
0.3072982728,
-0.6164010167,
0.0237065405,
-0.1852815747,
0.5148922801,
-0.6561691761,
-0.2711512148,
0.2222355306,
-0.4889367223,
0.5090376735,
-0.574349165,
-0.3477040529,
-0.0264062583,
-0.3347940445,
0.8250342011,
0.5104013085,
-0.4301999807,
0.751981616,
0.3776165545,
-0.5034176111,
-0.6821964383,
-0.2805909812,
-0.0721225813,
-0.5495795608,
-0.2901051044,
0.2488088012,
-0.0843103155,
-0.0991556793,
-0.1998244524,
-0.0769303516,
-0.0014000867,
-0.2035814375,
0.1038893983,
-0.0126956198,
-0.3124359548,
0.0035118435,
0.2213574201,
-0.2510528564,
0.032684315,
-0.3362853229,
0.3675976098,
0.0342498161,
0.0113228438,
-0.9259003997,
0.261364609,
0.6544668078,
-0.2743021846,
0.5744876266,
0.275334388,
-0.2180890441,
-0.3716382086,
-0.2910725772,
-0.3541267216,
-0.4862505794,
0.6792690754,
-0.2891897857,
-0.6062930822,
0.2639018595,
-0.418697834,
-0.0073821191,
0.106356293,
0.4957706034,
-0.4104146063,
0.6336720586,
0.7025676966,
-0.0739725232,
0.4993688464,
-0.5544464588,
0.5021151304,
-0.6888037324,
0.0172423031,
-0.1146261916,
-0.225523442,
-0.488751322,
-0.2201479673,
0.5363195539,
0.0935111493,
0.1071090326,
0.3856593072,
-0.2748296559,
0.7350289822,
0.3266415298,
-0.2920106649,
0.1901597083,
0.0216483884,
0.0123957209,
-0.1254553795,
-1.0024625063,
-0.60201931,
1.0593252182,
0.172728017,
0.9555212855,
0.1845596731,
0.9751610756,
0.3344145715,
0.4117159545,
-0.6034623384,
0.5439532995,
0.1329469383,
-0.2440056801,
-0.5867802501,
-0.6639673114,
-0.9593035579,
0.4565975964,
-0.3040017784,
-0.8227601647,
0.0764490068,
0.5150874853,
-1.1137040854,
0.2734442651,
-0.7017612457,
1.0941696167,
-0.0254309569,
-0.3428507149,
-0.3732551336,
-0.5484114885,
0.4342713952,
0.1685456038,
0.0241874736,
0.0479531251,
0.2998502851,
0.7370548844,
-0.8217486143,
0.7585437894,
-0.0853105485,
0.1381147504,
0.5659343004,
0.3009564579,
0.3265175223,
0.5264565945,
0.5106589794,
-0.4208211005,
0.4542648196,
-0.379432261,
-0.831556499,
0.4421104491,
-0.9526174068,
-0.3331810236,
-0.5859227777,
-0.2155215889,
-0.2917633653,
-0.1853106171,
0.8484023213,
0.9458993077,
-0.4631026089,
-0.1763941497,
0.7964044809,
-0.5142443776,
0.4700843394,
0.5158580542,
0.0335354693,
-0.6339218616,
1.0988427401,
0.0763450414,
0.2015363425,
0.428273797,
-0.1136737391,
-0.2126408815,
-0.540902853,
-0.6376250982,
0.3284527361,
-0.5862826109,
-0.2588652074,
-0.7492303252,
-0.1463879347,
-0.2496299446,
-0.0412997082,
-0.6612289548,
-0.5880004168,
-0.3300148845,
-0.0931509882,
0.0279088188,
0.6229768991,
0.0423176512,
0.6998154521,
-0.9173681736,
0.5769752264,
0.4946881831,
0.1624330729,
-0.1367922723,
-0.6571102738,
-0.5939121842,
-0.0681454539,
-0.4062679708,
-0.9624446034,
0.6150889993,
0.2208225131,
0.3233569562,
0.6012702584,
0.5210941434,
0.5595682859,
-0.2596589327,
0.5895690918,
0.4054401219,
-0.7423853278,
0.6608039737,
-0.4068984687,
0.626110673,
0.7662513852,
0.4100522399,
-0.4197971821,
-0.3224201202,
-0.4890210927,
-0.4074184,
1.0947548151,
0.7185077071,
0.3366207182,
0.0555345453,
0.2884865403,
-0.0135809202,
0.2572556734,
-0.5932326317,
-0.1073704436,
-0.4548924863,
-0.356452316,
-0.2806376517,
-0.2611587644,
-0.1320853531,
-0.3224976361,
0.6422227621,
-0.046972733,
0.1449747086,
0.2374815196,
-0.5291659832,
0.0234335233,
0.1867924631,
0.7312636971,
0.4993703663,
-0.3543030918,
0.0752233192,
0.6002936959,
-0.604568541,
0.0338480137,
0.0591691062,
0.2071609199,
0.0145026864,
0.6144428253,
0.7903363109,
-0.1089490056,
-0.5287166834,
0.5237703919,
-0.6146077514,
-0.100665465,
-0.5328404307,
0.1655595154,
-0.1469914913,
0.1694054455,
0.0571989492,
0.1034904048,
0.280492425,
-0.5984128118,
-0.2246624678,
0.0450952873,
-0.2158614993,
-0.6336279511,
0.3744815886,
0.4952058494,
-0.2653640807,
0.6565210223,
-0.3515865207,
-0.4703022242,
0.245497629,
0.1143061444,
0.9327492714,
-0.5492428541,
0.3883706033,
0.5369935632,
0.2467198223,
0.1343183815,
0.0329733752,
-0.6911209822,
-0.6728654504,
-0.5328388214,
-0.712336123,
-0.5363289714,
0.2926179767,
-0.6462592483,
0.2149321437,
-0.2581995726,
-0.4073630571,
-0.2124479115,
-0.0138986157,
-0.5448864102,
0.3721394837,
-0.0312227849,
0.4550812542,
-0.6800351739,
0.8675148487,
0.3080965877,
-0.1966274977,
-0.3244640827,
-0.0346981548,
-0.2222499251,
-0.158532083,
0.4321237206,
0.0103060696,
-0.6930690408,
0.0358893983,
-0.2300176769,
-0.760332346,
0.6332517862,
0.7776064873,
-0.4622952044,
-0.1628664285,
0.2078313977,
0.4443254769,
-0.4894048274,
0.6513251066,
0.5489673018,
-0.0192071628,
-0.0989305526,
-0.8811348677,
-0.3710230589,
-0.6281844974,
-0.2838513553,
0.1939785331,
-0.5625678897,
0.5842723846,
-0.4029939771,
-0.3143028021,
0.3227160871,
0.7145944834,
-0.1192709059,
0.3400968611,
0.2686386406,
0.5621870756,
0.5281638503,
-0.0695092902,
1.2259702682,
-0.2808866203,
0.0542285368,
1.5541222095,
0.0644393861,
0.4266883433,
0.0203755051,
-0.0619573444,
0.4947845042,
0.8753189445,
0.4821323752,
0.819085598,
0.4917297363,
-0.4745494127,
-0.5395904779,
0.1394816786,
-0.3273325562,
0.347736299,
0.4840969741,
-0.2063833177,
-0.040831916,
-0.0935865268,
-0.1948184371,
-0.0187415369,
-0.0803133473,
1.0354893208,
0.2512377799,
-0.7541245818,
0.7869316936,
-0.0294512417,
0.1410764605,
-0.7688406706,
0.0772079378,
-0.5523657799,
0.196230948,
-0.0850353763,
-0.0351025425,
0.0588527881,
0.0450579897,
0.1353061497,
-0.1850298941,
0.2148247361,
-0.5002402663,
-0.3017041683,
0.0814988688,
0.4575859308,
0.4030100703,
-0.1256805211,
-0.1273440421,
-0.0531406626,
-0.2099346966,
-0.2293240726,
0.3024333119,
0.5900949836,
0.151232332,
0.5465787649,
0.3322738707,
0.020321358,
-0.1973967999,
0.2171626836,
1.0473790169,
-0.4825988114,
-0.8566646576,
-0.7771840692,
0.5016085505,
-0.2599954307,
-0.5851864815,
0.5058165789,
0.7778656483,
0.5614317656,
-0.0832759142,
0.8987246156,
0.5630084872,
0.4638276994,
-0.5547608137,
0.6197537184,
-0.4232857227,
0.3103908598,
-0.31145069,
-1.3363187313,
0.1015997604,
0.7739693522,
-0.3452037275,
0.1191030964,
0.7033371925,
0.6307080984,
-0.3077897131,
0.3259269893,
0.3502629101,
0.1290784925,
-0.0615693927,
0.5862099528,
1.4073672295,
-0.0756291375,
0.4941880703,
-0.0645848438,
-0.2138162106,
-0.1706360579,
-0.5306146145,
-1.4093379974,
-0.4929536581,
-0.5944904685,
-0.1851053685,
0.0749411583,
1.0005223751,
1.0170052052,
-0.6790381074,
-0.4392190576,
0.1745350808,
-0.1005307063,
0.2318141758,
-0.0303474106,
0.3042015135,
-0.2797382772,
-0.7586410642,
0.5378988981,
0.3968081176,
0.2858031988,
0.072778672,
-0.3630487025,
0.4858134985,
0.3801149726,
0.5241808295,
0.3307700157,
-0.4643060565,
0.2631344795,
-0.3129605949,
0.2588354945,
-0.0414985605,
1.2114766836,
-0.9922739863,
0.5187830925,
0.2604604661,
0.2845026553,
1.1968923807,
0.0580467246,
0.8687853813,
-0.5757957697,
0.1433585882,
0.4190828204,
0.3290929794,
0.2327109277,
-0.1249324232,
0.1071513295,
-0.0143372566,
-0.1019885764,
-0.8119928837,
0.2987266481,
-0.783557415,
-0.2444828898,
0.6466540694,
-0.239504844,
0.161292702,
-0.1082116216,
-0.2366096079,
0.4508713782,
-0.296772182,
0.7685374022,
0.3826226294,
-0.167814225,
-0.2906599641,
-0.277174592,
1.1354864836,
0.5070975423,
-0.7925645709,
0.1464600265,
0.3392616808,
0.1532633752,
0.1553937048,
1.0539871454,
0.1736061722,
0.2633642852,
-0.0628304482,
-0.0848284811,
0.0286605693,
-0.5354316831,
-0.0189894643,
0.0931337848,
-0.0819578618,
-0.2293328494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10015v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10015v3 | Benchmarking Spatial Relationships in Text-to-Image Generation | 2022-12-20T06:03:51 | 2023-10-27T17:24:04 | Tejas Gokhale, Hamid Palangi, Besmira Nushi, Vibhav Vineet, Eric Horvitz, Ece Kamar, Chitta Baral, Yezhou Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Spatial understanding is a fundamental aspect of computer vision and integral
for human-level reasoning about images, making it an important component for
grounded language understanding. While recent text-to-image synthesis (T2I)
models have shown unprecedented improvements in photorealism, it is unclear
whether they have reliable spatial understanding capabilities. We investigate
the ability of T2I models to generate correct spatial relationships among
objects and present VISOR, an evaluation metric that captures how accurately
the spatial relationship described in text is generated in the image. To
benchmark existing models, we introduce a dataset, $\mathrm{SR}_{2D}$, that
contains sentences describing two or more objects and the spatial relationships
between them. We construct an automated evaluation pipeline to recognize
objects and their spatial relationships, and employ it in a large-scale
evaluation of T2I models. Our experiments reveal a surprising finding that,
although state-of-the-art T2I models exhibit high image quality, they are
severely limited in their ability to generate multiple objects or the specified
spatial relations between them. Our analyses demonstrate several biases and
artifacts of T2I models such as the difficulty with generating multiple
objects, a bias towards generating the first object mentioned, spatially
inconsistent outputs for equivalent relationships, and a correlation between
object co-occurrence and spatial understanding capabilities. We conduct a human
study that shows the alignment between VISOR and human judgement about spatial
understanding. We offer the $\mathrm{SR}_{2D}$ dataset and the VISOR metric to
the community in support of T2I reasoning research. | [
-0.3790606558,
-0.4604141712,
0.9881449938,
0.1806581765,
-0.1184313148,
-0.3258899152,
-0.1326414645,
-0.7704457045,
-0.4362335205,
0.1572221369,
-0.3817844391,
-0.596583128,
-0.5089173317,
-0.0373432711,
-0.2515255511,
0.4593170285,
-0.1928991526,
0.0007019078,
-0.5685261488,
-0.3044058681,
-0.7482476234,
-0.1612547785,
-0.4349868298,
-0.26323542,
0.3089126945,
0.3659021258,
0.9347168803,
0.7899454832,
0.8668068647,
0.2876180112,
0.1458388865,
0.2316683978,
-0.6870353222,
-0.0311431997,
-0.5020982027,
-0.1251725405,
-0.122459501,
0.0748580322,
0.6686534882,
0.8042063713,
0.281488359,
0.1858274639,
-0.2023896724,
0.6500643492,
-0.6748437285,
0.0850254744,
-0.6628602743,
0.3178894818,
-0.0764244869,
-0.2030168325,
-0.2958375514,
-0.278516233,
0.4541071951,
-0.8311039805,
0.6040377021,
0.2000138015,
1.1820911169,
0.3398764133,
-0.570373714,
-0.1414586753,
-0.9125612378,
0.6637862325,
-0.1708905399,
0.6052483916,
0.3921607733,
0.5756804943,
0.0372872129,
-0.5889267325,
-0.4828149378,
-0.0997685567,
-0.2405005395,
0.5018860698,
-0.0687428936,
-0.4283203781,
0.2438360453,
0.0142644783,
-0.5844550729,
-0.1809585392,
-0.6435651183,
0.0769989789,
0.5353551507,
0.2993396819,
0.3470297754,
-0.4323824942,
-0.6700911522,
-0.3629808724,
-0.6484694481,
-0.0531002209,
-0.0212868638,
-0.2799460888,
-0.0129865985,
0.836651504,
0.3877866864,
0.5487731099,
-0.060762804,
-0.0155129321,
-0.0738841966,
-0.78750664,
0.0440050773,
-0.5960916281,
0.7445465326,
0.9867862463,
0.4448437989,
-0.4555349946,
-0.0794191957,
0.5035271049,
0.5392562151,
-0.7585260868,
-0.2305868268,
-0.0431391187,
-0.5431076884,
-0.3498683274,
0.2691834867,
-0.6831604242,
-0.2895825803,
-0.405376941,
0.2051700801,
-0.5052134395,
-0.2036066055,
-0.1175344661,
-0.5525401831,
0.3956590891,
0.1987085789,
-0.6010859609,
0.3601365685,
0.6107000709,
0.7602274418,
-0.3052045107,
-0.6869689226,
-0.1173697561,
0.4543120563,
-0.6842309833,
1.2824511528,
-0.4058865905,
-0.4320318103,
-0.1318594217,
-0.4093936682,
-0.0318501778,
-0.8025919795,
0.1379173696,
-0.3161720037,
0.2179054916,
-0.3228337467,
-0.3598602414,
0.0034096972,
0.3056820929,
-0.5292384028,
1.1867926121,
0.124135606,
-0.8241173625,
0.7519400716,
-0.3905967474,
-0.4038611054,
-0.1318596154,
-0.4498084486,
-0.4665210247,
0.3591081202,
0.2351892591,
0.1550266594,
-0.3950153589,
0.564540863,
-0.426358819,
-0.2787682116,
0.3477080166,
0.1608280391,
0.2274570465,
0.0775775537,
-0.2590293586,
0.1394075155,
-0.689889431,
-0.1881264001,
0.2791699469,
-0.0245917179,
-0.2259704024,
0.4233662188,
0.2538201213,
0.2878010869,
0.1391647607,
-0.3084499836,
-0.3644753993,
-0.1590279043,
0.2196346074,
0.5370137095,
0.2384802997,
0.7460518479,
-0.1252309233,
0.1691305935,
0.2029912621,
-0.1645925492,
-0.1210859492,
-0.2869040966,
-0.6873521209,
0.1117257029,
-0.3620840609,
0.5025877953,
-0.6798841357,
0.2953885794,
-0.6324875951,
-0.5804101825,
0.156894654,
-0.269241184,
0.4848480821,
0.6577977538,
0.2107696086,
-0.350703001,
-0.4626579285,
-0.9896243215,
-0.3609729707,
-0.3211100101,
-0.2272148877,
0.8873258233,
0.4985803068,
-0.2224112004,
1.1556657553,
-0.6114875078,
-0.3379705548,
0.0864891782,
0.2182445973,
-0.318120271,
0.3555310667,
0.9933197498,
-0.4984923303,
-0.2099024504,
0.11364308,
-1.1443009377,
-0.0776057392,
-0.1489984691,
-0.59093678,
0.0803951249,
0.5106354356,
-0.4521184266,
0.7461675406,
0.2103360444,
-0.784432888,
0.4226938784,
-0.2454598099,
0.2585716844,
-1.0627814531,
0.250038892,
0.4912106097,
-0.0906686932,
-0.5500548482,
0.0873895288,
-0.0473901704,
-0.6217625141,
-0.2605836093,
0.5185133815,
-0.5853139758,
-0.7872017622,
-0.1518197656,
0.4993816614,
0.1805225164,
0.3323555887,
0.4707032144,
0.8701173067,
0.3784965873,
-0.3974289596,
-0.0240126736,
0.5570476651,
-0.5398039818,
0.6201008558,
-0.963760674,
0.1732034236,
-0.2511962652,
0.1341899931,
-1.3121911287,
-0.278363049,
0.0768640265,
-0.3807165027,
-0.1155396625,
-0.042394083,
-0.5682074428,
-0.2577017844,
-0.0218693651,
0.8072103858,
0.3124133646,
-0.563228488,
0.6581553221,
0.3531538546,
0.0372783318,
-0.0851016343,
-0.7723165154,
0.2515809536,
-0.156032145,
-1.0354745388,
0.2103062421,
0.1521776468,
-0.4646779895,
0.1847875863,
0.00754963,
-0.2667645514,
-0.1557867825,
0.3354660273,
0.4467810094,
-0.0320085362,
-0.0958948359,
-0.0665517747,
-0.1610999405,
0.435831219,
-0.2002052814,
0.0126152793,
0.0805304423,
-0.2094929963,
-0.4062508643,
0.2794174552,
0.6291406751,
-0.137714833,
0.5297953486,
0.490278244,
-0.5284795165,
0.0678188652,
-0.4299322367,
-0.0169985499,
-0.3549704254,
0.5350296497,
-0.6828977466,
-0.480373621,
0.528190136,
-0.0546889529,
-0.0309350006,
0.464833498,
0.3281033635,
-0.2185005844,
0.8047982454,
0.3786152899,
0.3334977031,
0.4523156583,
-0.2231685966,
0.1675202101,
-0.7437180877,
-0.5529672503,
-0.4445623159,
-0.3788049221,
-0.3812886178,
-0.758571744,
0.6043117642,
-0.2271570414,
-0.2363806218,
0.4225473404,
-0.3263737261,
0.5962268114,
0.3415260017,
0.331325382,
0.0460366532,
0.4580357075,
0.0620894097,
-0.4492131174,
-0.447779417,
-0.5841822624,
0.7885617018,
0.2380449027,
0.6068862677,
0.1340072304,
0.2501647472,
0.1685201526,
-0.0114287166,
-0.6365947127,
0.6715210676,
-0.2877768576,
-0.2393797934,
0.045733504,
-0.5108517408,
-0.8578476906,
0.3667717576,
-0.4740477204,
-0.5039800406,
0.3481425345,
0.1146024093,
0.0520586409,
0.1437107772,
-0.8833149672,
0.9433482289,
-0.25752455,
-0.7247921824,
-0.3373152316,
-0.5718371868,
0.1589720547,
0.2050162554,
-0.0034112874,
-0.0849853531,
-0.0474573523,
0.478746593,
-0.2319427729,
0.556450069,
-0.1843385249,
-0.0378452651,
0.229483217,
0.4085791409,
0.0834501833,
0.0402048714,
-0.003385951,
0.4263367355,
-0.1698582321,
-0.3318961859,
-0.5444939733,
0.5936116576,
-1.0740255117,
-0.2435018271,
-0.1272987127,
-0.7573082447,
-0.1070273072,
0.1506347209,
0.5698259473,
0.5146488547,
-0.6023373604,
-0.2548219264,
0.3273616433,
-0.3358750641,
0.0882629976,
-0.0050768564,
-0.2159848511,
-0.4864816666,
0.7119618654,
-0.1164061874,
0.0800184086,
0.2678531408,
0.0428597704,
-0.375718087,
-0.2168281674,
-0.4437509179,
0.3608210087,
-0.6710479259,
-0.117547147,
-0.4433864355,
-0.1038622186,
-0.2732878625,
-0.4172208309,
-0.2687103748,
-0.3854157627,
-0.3922942877,
-0.0567378551,
-0.0496417731,
1.1917062998,
0.1238204092,
-0.178860575,
-0.5831366777,
0.5521675348,
0.2467256486,
0.3129698634,
0.1037213951,
-0.4286566377,
-0.0880475864,
-0.151734665,
-0.3133170307,
-0.7793980837,
0.2210610658,
0.1137281135,
0.1609454006,
0.4415471256,
-0.3164284229,
1.0086297989,
-0.8928601146,
0.8134566545,
0.1845720112,
-0.9432097077,
0.8811011314,
-0.5158589482,
0.3573571742,
0.3333490789,
-0.1728364825,
-0.3012928665,
-0.4831683636,
-0.4156252444,
-0.7323741913,
0.6009707451,
0.4548941255,
-0.1760542393,
-0.1016673371,
0.4266574979,
-0.0776980594,
-0.193134442,
-0.6886180043,
0.1112122685,
-0.2748873532,
-0.0759431571,
-0.002410731,
-0.5123357177,
-0.0757510439,
-0.2114761472,
0.2032319903,
0.1506916434,
0.4766105413,
0.2858824134,
-0.1795745492,
-0.2907886803,
-0.0269976221,
0.5875504613,
1.1327064037,
-0.0011229714,
0.2884151936,
-0.0119475964,
-0.137072444,
-0.0226605553,
-0.0436215103,
-0.0701768175,
-0.0422258005,
0.4365256131,
0.931039691,
0.199628219,
-0.5670098066,
0.6279476881,
-0.2428370416,
-0.4498742819,
-0.4596482217,
-0.114762418,
-0.114699401,
0.3840325177,
0.2156659514,
0.5724753141,
0.192414239,
-0.2982051373,
0.0445662439,
0.3655672073,
-0.2183902115,
-0.5767348409,
0.9478625059,
0.1389145106,
-0.1236516833,
0.8504680395,
-0.0279501788,
-0.4158315063,
0.7352660298,
0.6022402644,
0.6631783843,
0.4719416201,
0.0886288583,
0.9103851318,
0.297636658,
0.2215132713,
0.1410925835,
-0.1773987412,
-0.833484292,
-0.1517087817,
-0.1640734822,
-0.3051706254,
-0.2881502807,
-0.7123965025,
0.0645704344,
-0.3705531955,
-0.2506474853,
-0.0169512071,
-0.3013276458,
-0.8279011846,
0.2003214508,
0.1649302989,
0.7383469343,
-1.0392625332,
0.3519693017,
1.0676594973,
-0.2617735565,
-0.7009358406,
0.1410247236,
-0.1827090532,
-0.5269659758,
0.8273501396,
0.3277429044,
-0.2988912463,
-0.3816577792,
-0.54828614,
-0.6714072824,
1.1762930155,
0.30250144,
-0.4090598822,
0.1856575012,
0.3789452612,
0.8417397738,
-0.2930170298,
0.0442065559,
0.488045156,
0.4299331009,
0.2083266079,
-0.5320520997,
0.0213363878,
-0.4589563012,
0.7028349042,
0.0650567412,
-0.4427533746,
0.343432337,
-0.6012684703,
-0.6585413814,
0.3830318451,
0.7451398969,
0.4940786958,
0.514923811,
0.5202571154,
0.7937119007,
0.369340539,
-0.3688617945,
1.0677881241,
-0.0998179018,
0.2829019427,
1.1144974232,
-0.4806210995,
0.9254677892,
0.5903542638,
0.0030362294,
0.5355042219,
0.4396355152,
-0.3035099804,
0.4849920273,
-0.059262082,
0.0016743615,
-0.2616792917,
-0.1358501315,
-0.1273924261,
0.4500996172,
0.1937039942,
-0.3612666726,
-0.2629995942,
-0.0729704574,
-0.4393953681,
0.4473841488,
0.1105212569,
1.0949194431,
-0.2578522265,
-0.9169929028,
0.1619523317,
-0.1714480221,
0.110303767,
-0.1121060699,
-0.01352116,
-0.26951617,
0.3127844632,
-0.0996894613,
-1.171897769,
0.5215190053,
0.162899226,
-0.5971126556,
-0.2003216445,
0.8688439727,
-0.5103239417,
-0.570374608,
0.3312491775,
0.4414875805,
0.1794581413,
0.279940784,
-0.4138685763,
0.1365558356,
-0.1192650124,
0.0722714514,
-0.0445114337,
0.6312415004,
-0.0167071559,
0.3563421667,
0.441236645,
-0.0429259352,
-0.0181262698,
0.2482805997,
0.6696113348,
-0.6701751351,
-0.2440279573,
-0.5864571333,
0.3388475776,
-0.1398278326,
-0.2201659828,
0.497371763,
0.6941434741,
0.8207156062,
-0.347268194,
0.6539939046,
-0.0573836379,
0.2150284201,
-0.347656399,
0.5987164378,
-0.6230093837,
0.0703874454,
-0.1653045863,
-1.1650942564,
-0.3121612072,
0.9355818629,
-0.4545262754,
0.065384604,
0.7844423652,
0.6490410566,
-0.3454248905,
-0.3138675094,
0.2455246747,
0.1230526343,
0.2949193418,
0.6025797725,
0.9920756817,
-0.6980220079,
0.6626404524,
-0.1634852737,
-0.1245394871,
0.3856984973,
-0.8008208275,
-1.0260019302,
-0.6158454418,
-0.2513364255,
-0.2625572681,
0.049220711,
0.3418985605,
0.931191206,
-0.4699591696,
-0.4035021365,
-0.4124839306,
-0.1697475165,
-0.0073958957,
-0.2454512417,
0.3416007757,
-0.1575936973,
-0.7539830208,
0.1445297003,
0.5147383213,
0.0992368534,
-0.0891873389,
-0.008420608,
0.0695937276,
-0.1142006367,
0.7428103685,
-0.0270146467,
-0.6962378621,
-0.3649781942,
-0.0795726925,
-0.1577174813,
0.1621108502,
0.8618314862,
-0.6826602221,
0.5540802479,
0.5694648027,
0.5056435466,
0.5814285278,
0.1921547502,
0.6750414968,
-0.8195479512,
0.2694775462,
-0.2493122369,
0.4870512784,
0.6131127477,
-0.1823177785,
0.7410255671,
0.2391029149,
-0.6732708216,
-0.3130857348,
0.3763037324,
-0.9615294933,
-0.2208880037,
1.0429121256,
-0.0214795154,
-0.2201262712,
0.380617857,
-0.2782101035,
0.172017023,
-0.1165685654,
0.8567175269,
0.4939565063,
-0.0223561507,
-0.1913456619,
-0.032383807,
0.0115554482,
0.3521387577,
-1.0556429625,
-0.0234402362,
1.1077572107,
0.2956419289,
0.2541028559,
0.2924695611,
-0.1588638723,
0.4811221957,
0.1268874109,
-0.0706181079,
0.1632630378,
-0.537212193,
0.2485326976,
0.0148511631,
-0.0289263036,
-0.1828623861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10013v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10013v2 | DocAsRef: An Empirical Study on Repurposing Reference-Based Summary Quality Metrics Reference-Freely | 2022-12-20T06:01:13 | 2023-11-26T05:05:51 | Forrest Sheng Bao, Ruixuan Tu, Ge Luo, Yinfei Yang, Hebi Li, Minghui Qiu, Youbiao He, Cen Chen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Automated summary quality assessment falls into two categories:
reference-based and reference-free. Reference-based metrics, historically
deemed more accurate due to the additional information provided by
human-written references, are limited by their reliance on human input. In this
paper, we hypothesize that the comparison methodologies used by some
reference-based metrics to evaluate a system summary against its corresponding
reference can be effectively adapted to assess it against its source document,
thereby transforming these metrics into reference-free ones. Experimental
results support this hypothesis. After being repurposed reference-freely, the
zero-shot BERTScore using the pretrained DeBERTa-large-MNLI model of <0.5B
parameters consistently outperforms its original reference-based version across
various aspects on the SummEval and Newsroom datasets. It also excels in
comparison to most existing reference-free metrics and closely competes with
zero-shot summary evaluators based on GPT-3.5. | [
-0.3883849978,
-0.1516429782,
0.7035938501,
-0.062024992,
-0.4754834175,
-0.1645278335,
0.1681501865,
-0.6790232062,
0.4706803262,
0.3618563116,
-0.2020404339,
-0.0907243639,
-0.5857440233,
0.3383221924,
-0.8255187273,
1.1872836351,
-0.2679511309,
0.1188225746,
-0.4190694392,
-0.4871864915,
-0.2569187284,
-0.4524964094,
-0.2247427702,
-0.4452727139,
0.6344715953,
0.5710469484,
0.8879686594,
0.2215400785,
0.9811303616,
0.1160605922,
0.214867875,
0.0697307289,
-0.487174958,
-0.141781792,
-0.2701349854,
-0.0924220532,
-0.5810541511,
0.5200867653,
0.5472186804,
0.5723482966,
-0.3462976813,
0.452459693,
0.1090407073,
0.7427803874,
-0.7853364348,
-0.1412455291,
-0.3196823895,
-0.179242909,
0.3871664703,
-0.2774272561,
-0.1889300197,
-0.6275396347,
0.0012856253,
-0.4212883711,
0.7920296788,
-0.2535606921,
1.4286544323,
0.1778331995,
-0.1132059693,
-0.161923036,
-0.8443710804,
0.5369604826,
-0.8718746305,
0.3145944774,
0.4115584791,
0.6151016951,
0.1030040756,
-0.8212974072,
-0.4802324772,
-0.4195075631,
-0.1840337962,
0.3580424786,
-0.2472539395,
-0.2224926949,
-0.0779810026,
0.4937618673,
-0.3952660561,
-0.2105786353,
-0.6420788765,
0.0741203278,
0.6248390079,
-0.0131114526,
-0.1312903017,
-0.3006258309,
-0.2952616513,
-0.3160263598,
-0.483150214,
-0.2283138633,
0.070637621,
0.1437297612,
0.1107953563,
0.3931471407,
-0.4027680457,
0.5136728883,
0.215057075,
-0.180016011,
0.375679642,
-0.6455480456,
-0.3737068474,
-0.3212715685,
0.5638648272,
0.7381286621,
0.3458704352,
-0.3656904995,
-0.2574708164,
-0.2257387638,
0.458301425,
-0.8895426393,
-0.0638768673,
0.1851226687,
-0.4716068804,
-0.3658255041,
0.3788446784,
-0.2539049983,
-0.0832267553,
-0.3648042977,
0.3995066285,
-0.4169179499,
0.0020571905,
-0.198752135,
-0.4288139045,
0.243484959,
0.6848799586,
-0.5471901894,
0.0783541948,
0.5331084728,
0.9879205823,
0.0034980036,
-0.1584488153,
-0.421955198,
0.1021720544,
-0.5809211135,
1.0994546413,
-0.169875145,
-0.7211970091,
-0.3147541583,
-0.1141103804,
0.092890732,
-0.6351118088,
0.682703197,
-0.4297378361,
0.4001638889,
-0.2683181763,
-0.4733104408,
-0.1412598342,
0.3760714233,
-0.6319447756,
0.8899202943,
0.5759290457,
-0.792737186,
0.6956367493,
-0.3617144525,
0.0258228108,
-0.3585864902,
0.1062907577,
-0.4381305873,
0.3220562339,
0.1340167224,
0.2898381948,
-0.3055683374,
0.1400661618,
-0.4916012883,
-0.5357073545,
0.1313011497,
-0.3727603555,
0.5751926899,
0.3158819675,
0.1379969567,
0.0487252176,
-0.9466692209,
0.0610594787,
-0.1119878665,
-0.0425762162,
-0.5567592382,
-0.0653874055,
-0.3162463903,
0.1814332157,
0.0702662095,
-0.4623553753,
-0.114900142,
-0.0162077397,
-0.1341800541,
0.309803158,
0.3083353937,
0.3315305412,
-0.7151063681,
0.3318957388,
-0.3308182657,
0.2620887458,
-0.2237457782,
-0.0366226062,
-0.6079187393,
-0.3794763684,
0.5866699815,
0.4251093268,
-0.4688147902,
0.2101145834,
-0.461495012,
-0.7608892918,
-0.4855893552,
0.0526364893,
0.1851829737,
0.6405389309,
0.3916451931,
-0.657361865,
-0.3738724291,
-0.9279395342,
0.1125309616,
-0.4938507676,
-0.5018324256,
0.1399616003,
0.3849872053,
0.1312050968,
0.9990026951,
-0.3946273625,
-0.2268886119,
0.0780269951,
0.3776624799,
0.2510690689,
0.2173705399,
1.0028749704,
-0.2055482268,
-0.3404866457,
-0.549752593,
-0.8744238615,
-0.474689424,
-0.0818488896,
0.0240076035,
0.0387206562,
0.292178154,
-0.1903525144,
0.4913007021,
0.3783296645,
-0.4467028379,
0.9800292253,
-0.5414435863,
0.6391629577,
-0.9273084402,
0.4648958743,
-0.1648440212,
-0.3493594527,
-0.2969014347,
0.3735922873,
0.2516599596,
-0.0626544207,
-0.3769446015,
0.4423187375,
-0.429374516,
-0.2681566775,
-0.4830771387,
0.3652380407,
0.2406269312,
0.1957424283,
-0.1117715687,
0.8413089514,
-0.1467005759,
-0.4507339299,
0.1667491049,
0.1225631684,
-0.4651143849,
0.9394059777,
-0.7787894607,
0.0549460389,
-0.3404174447,
0.4527818561,
-1.011105895,
0.1226717308,
0.1914175898,
-0.6381896138,
0.0449974872,
0.1677775383,
-0.561637044,
-0.1796554625,
-0.6380208135,
0.0055532693,
0.3772208095,
-0.2613974214,
0.0743642002,
-0.1490239948,
-0.2473922372,
-0.6332343221,
-0.5772661567,
0.1031316519,
0.1180078611,
-0.2320167124,
0.0559468307,
-0.0756229982,
-0.3817227185,
0.2299833894,
-0.1944419891,
-0.1983809322,
0.0789748207,
0.1657553762,
0.394351095,
-0.2147579342,
0.043710012,
-0.0745915696,
-0.3325558007,
-0.2437957227,
0.0999293774,
-0.0232044198,
0.136054948,
-0.5538733006,
-0.2915515602,
0.4114423394,
0.8668227196,
0.0531330183,
0.5013445616,
0.2466142923,
0.059916459,
0.2533160448,
-0.6012060046,
-0.0132663073,
-0.3319648206,
0.1968231797,
-0.0797188804,
-0.4225766361,
0.5018239617,
0.4776178002,
0.4861518145,
0.7430403829,
0.0966703892,
-0.4802476764,
0.3963796198,
0.629367888,
0.0225929692,
0.4493634105,
-0.2291018516,
-0.1290361434,
-0.7354143262,
-0.0015076427,
-0.9019814134,
-0.2331459522,
-0.1772427261,
-0.5788071156,
0.2520512342,
0.3561661541,
-0.1791790873,
0.5364051461,
-0.3219320774,
0.3807553947,
0.3961234093,
-0.0557887889,
0.8074931502,
0.0947410092,
0.0201678127,
0.057182055,
-0.3133109808,
-0.6679534912,
1.1302855015,
0.2272247821,
0.8120723367,
0.0985388681,
0.7220209241,
0.6094142795,
1.0536961555,
-0.8167198896,
0.2401629984,
-0.3515409529,
-0.5705887675,
-0.3090188801,
-0.3069586456,
-0.5825452805,
0.4470738769,
-0.0811360255,
-0.4656900465,
0.5192016363,
-0.044666335,
-0.2802343071,
0.3570718467,
-0.7574480176,
0.1371343136,
-0.0876089483,
-0.1296106577,
-0.3961646259,
-0.1464348733,
0.1431856751,
-0.3716068864,
0.2180126011,
-0.3764480054,
-0.0433286019,
0.7631261349,
-0.6342736483,
0.4273452163,
-0.2291500866,
-0.3321845531,
0.4058072865,
0.1463813782,
0.2039338201,
0.0132296691,
-0.4037908614,
0.4856125414,
0.5745363235,
-0.4800157547,
-0.8230519295,
0.4220009148,
-0.8409349322,
-0.655156076,
-0.5888444185,
-0.3273043931,
-0.3346993923,
0.2209343165,
0.1044051424,
0.3752338588,
-0.4359401166,
0.3243744969,
-0.0502090119,
0.1379517019,
0.3195047975,
1.0892707109,
-0.1215071604,
-0.6750036478,
0.4286420941,
0.3146774471,
0.3483639359,
0.3411546946,
-0.1531802565,
-0.1502925009,
-0.3409438431,
-0.446372807,
0.246476382,
-0.5226360559,
-0.2987179458,
-0.258720994,
-0.1183316931,
-0.3931378126,
-0.2741328776,
-0.2526070774,
-0.7257661223,
-0.1034799665,
-0.1927289814,
-0.0695214346,
0.3802553713,
-0.4085890353,
0.103023015,
-0.9449192882,
0.3086329997,
0.3472200334,
0.6740580201,
0.1249505579,
-0.8161932826,
-0.253697902,
0.1445170939,
-0.2425629795,
-0.8334659338,
0.1722319275,
0.0698012635,
0.6639569998,
0.4959293902,
0.2115635425,
0.5463096499,
-0.3444079161,
0.7941052914,
0.3060310781,
-0.5310260653,
0.220231846,
-0.1823163033,
0.4500886798,
0.976944983,
0.1158573404,
-0.4933492839,
-0.5550121665,
-0.7630010247,
-0.685958147,
0.4379215539,
0.3771467209,
0.0149650322,
0.1909504682,
0.4848833084,
0.287252903,
0.0985802338,
-0.0849062055,
-0.107948482,
-0.4312681258,
0.1003826335,
-0.2708572149,
-0.504864037,
-0.0690496787,
-0.1115549579,
0.7194046378,
0.0229088645,
0.4319156706,
0.6309645772,
-0.1310569942,
-0.0002090332,
0.4590684772,
0.5610141754,
1.0689450502,
-0.8539097905,
-0.0335208885,
0.1113394797,
-0.5050122738,
0.3535733819,
0.0730520487,
-0.4284407198,
0.5878490806,
0.4385855794,
0.4549743831,
0.0839783549,
-0.4889088273,
0.3274309933,
-0.1678224355,
-0.4098907709,
-0.3814538717,
0.0116501804,
-0.3050865531,
-0.078687042,
0.6113147736,
0.0309590269,
0.1821566522,
-0.462448746,
0.6750155091,
0.1832085848,
-0.7579453588,
-0.1807663888,
0.4416815639,
0.2936617732,
-0.0113979802,
0.4982327819,
0.0705969483,
0.1829288304,
0.5519379973,
0.2671924829,
0.9779993892,
-0.0565242432,
0.4551925957,
0.6276987195,
0.2708753943,
-0.0226212125,
-0.0584463365,
-0.3249992132,
-0.7643694282,
-0.3104088008,
-0.4984313548,
-0.6903035641,
0.0474710017,
-0.8743469715,
0.0648779348,
-0.5127897263,
-0.2091933042,
0.1247598603,
0.0280352421,
-0.4497125149,
0.3760579526,
-0.2150066495,
1.3012171984,
-0.7742635608,
0.6202816367,
0.552321136,
-0.7992483974,
-0.7309382558,
0.1236040369,
-0.0784042329,
-0.6309132576,
0.3358806968,
-0.3885628879,
-0.3686938286,
-0.4260303974,
-0.3374640346,
-0.919685483,
1.1441893578,
0.3590368032,
-0.3274300992,
-0.1147702858,
-0.1957890838,
0.7578204274,
0.0149575705,
0.6898248196,
0.416501075,
0.2579483688,
0.2887970209,
-1.3048301935,
-0.0165072475,
-0.2741848826,
-0.2303769141,
0.2266745567,
-0.7581425309,
0.5222754478,
-0.3079278171,
-0.3035241663,
0.3206329942,
0.4551288486,
0.0972307399,
0.3690040112,
0.401971072,
0.5540959239,
0.5235875845,
0.0152701037,
1.068372488,
-0.2748395205,
0.5555756688,
1.308578968,
-0.1935819685,
1.0243979692,
0.4374520481,
-0.3028497398,
0.8060002923,
0.3768268526,
-0.2357137203,
0.5922756195,
-0.1595717221,
-0.0087420978,
0.1519063264,
-0.006858814,
-0.5165015459,
0.3353420198,
-0.0225871429,
-0.4963771999,
-0.8300052881,
-0.391703397,
0.0572890639,
-0.118195124,
0.0157123897,
0.8658230901,
0.1179763824,
-0.6368364692,
0.7006952167,
0.1238107383,
0.3720761836,
-0.7831591368,
0.0560677722,
-0.630548656,
0.0971529856,
-0.1045216694,
-0.6739979982,
0.6253072619,
0.2249817252,
-0.347007066,
-0.1706409752,
0.6032299995,
-0.0095903846,
-0.4498250484,
0.0723128393,
0.7403132319,
0.1413989216,
0.0522919185,
-0.4425686896,
-0.5881074071,
-0.2020706683,
-0.1146397069,
0.3104176819,
0.1526560634,
-0.1024564505,
0.4747296572,
0.5862988234,
0.2021070719,
-0.7980349064,
0.173268497,
0.4307040274,
-0.7110185027,
-0.7937349677,
-0.3170455098,
0.2111588567,
-0.2295458913,
-0.223752901,
0.6318681836,
0.4112890065,
0.7473763227,
-0.0662260726,
0.7749326229,
-0.1654182523,
0.8340929747,
-0.2289856821,
0.9370706677,
-0.6794271469,
0.0833002031,
-0.5363820791,
-0.8510113358,
-0.2955919504,
0.5022533536,
-0.1227742061,
0.0780040696,
0.7387724519,
0.5770452619,
-0.0425614528,
-0.1035748795,
0.4308840334,
-0.073465392,
0.2834679186,
0.1410798132,
0.5374855995,
-0.4964596331,
0.6882323027,
-0.0951348022,
-0.3711983263,
-0.2707964778,
-0.9200069308,
-0.2931737602,
-0.532523632,
-0.3141373098,
-0.4323812723,
0.1228719577,
0.5325500369,
0.6471848488,
-1.0686298609,
-0.1012748182,
0.5076247454,
-0.090105392,
-0.4831898808,
-0.2043605596,
0.5751125216,
-0.0819457099,
-0.5697197914,
-0.0232725013,
0.2190909982,
0.1762093604,
-0.1249195635,
0.122483924,
0.0014917458,
0.386048764,
0.5939589739,
0.3854948878,
-0.4166086912,
-0.7398228049,
-0.030720342,
-0.3231170475,
-0.0639889538,
0.9131775498,
-0.912617147,
0.3971756697,
0.7114975452,
0.2798962593,
0.3044761121,
0.4434470832,
0.5337671638,
-0.5915407538,
0.0674693882,
-0.0923404992,
0.3937181532,
0.3462009132,
-0.0368493758,
0.7445624471,
0.3881207108,
-0.3128119111,
-0.5311549902,
-0.0654272288,
-0.9666474462,
-0.3616680503,
0.9286632538,
-0.1844617128,
0.0983525366,
0.0374356955,
-0.2029516101,
0.2538306415,
-0.494061023,
1.2938671112,
0.7481864691,
-0.2545117438,
-0.0052465284,
-0.3196879029,
0.1539802402,
0.2467529178,
-0.5531077385,
-0.1831032932,
0.7354739904,
0.6104947329,
0.4548154771,
0.9352807403,
-0.5190416574,
0.4935720265,
0.0710915923,
0.0284185745,
-0.4630140066,
-0.0080921603,
-0.1522204876,
0.3844368458,
0.0956577286,
-0.355399996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10012v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10012v1 | Language Modeling with Latent Situations | 2022-12-20T05:59:42 | 2022-12-20T05:59:42 | Belinda Z. Li, Maxwell Nye, Jacob Andreas | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) often generate incoherent outputs: they refer to events
and entity states that are incompatible with the state of the world described
in their inputs. We introduce SituationSupervision, a family of approaches for
improving coherence in LMs by training them to construct and condition on
explicit representations of entities and their states. SituationSupervision has
two components: an auxiliary situation modeling task that trains models to
predict state representations in context, and a latent state inference
procedure that imputes these states from partially annotated training data.
SituationSupervision can be applied to both fine-tuning (by supervising LMs to
encode state variables in their hidden representations) and prompting (by
inducing LMs to interleave textual descriptions of entity states with output
text). In both cases, SituationSupervision requires only a small number of
state annotations to produce major coherence improvements (between 4-11%),
showing that standard LMs can be sample-efficiently trained to model not just
language but the situations it describes. | [
-0.2265780121,
-0.732832253,
0.6109378934,
0.2126146108,
-0.062305063,
-0.0232572388,
-0.2388183475,
-0.1892794669,
0.0306541603,
0.4999686778,
-0.2832031846,
-0.2761613727,
-0.3909490705,
-0.2101089954,
-0.5061568618,
0.9462025166,
-0.3547350466,
-0.0408300422,
-0.0463102348,
0.0773454309,
-0.7208968997,
-0.7551680803,
-0.7585322261,
-0.4191463292,
0.0620228015,
0.5416645408,
0.7459250689,
0.217447266,
0.1965374202,
0.3848741353,
-0.0403768159,
0.0373981483,
-0.3198352456,
0.4960498512,
-0.0687854439,
-0.35926947,
-0.145548597,
0.1043324545,
0.7528277636,
1.0607873201,
-0.5207572579,
-0.1983028948,
0.3280526102,
0.216957435,
-0.5882570148,
0.356743902,
-0.624174118,
0.4139756858,
0.1392194033,
-0.4186986089,
-0.4358412623,
0.1456643492,
0.3889475465,
-0.4749214947,
0.4247675538,
0.2293796092,
0.9925231934,
0.1818964779,
-0.0872462541,
-0.1987177134,
-0.8384242654,
0.6690989137,
-0.6137447953,
0.6846433878,
0.3881129622,
-0.038502153,
-0.5647053719,
-0.5251169801,
-0.755900681,
-0.1706967652,
-0.2058423311,
0.3296363056,
-0.0880059302,
0.360011965,
0.1831412166,
0.4085712135,
-0.2843081653,
-0.0011207467,
-0.1262835711,
-0.3066643775,
0.3979375362,
0.2489668727,
0.3787772954,
-0.3923131227,
-0.1303964704,
-0.1194736212,
-0.5990059376,
0.1974893808,
0.2253337353,
0.3177027404,
-0.288184911,
0.6701350212,
-0.0903731063,
0.7190633416,
0.3100479841,
-0.0914424136,
-0.1890831292,
-0.2772465944,
-0.3924943507,
0.1393946856,
0.2386357784,
0.026503168,
-0.2400499582,
-0.2468323559,
-0.2749702334,
0.1409862489,
0.3089786768,
-0.5579714775,
-0.5348649621,
0.5766083598,
-0.209525764,
-0.1162875965,
-0.1014625132,
-0.5803144574,
-0.2701563537,
-0.5677442551,
0.509544611,
-0.4538949132,
-0.157261312,
-0.0982437655,
-0.0145689156,
0.0863772333,
0.5924246907,
-0.8084692955,
0.2493411303,
0.6269888282,
0.878908813,
-0.1727075875,
-0.21227853,
-0.809309721,
0.1955786496,
-0.6179109812,
0.6913514137,
-0.3856027126,
-0.3434254527,
0.1062363312,
0.1044178158,
-0.0614412688,
-0.4876186848,
0.2479684204,
-0.4853957295,
0.2232315242,
0.2114289552,
-0.7543904781,
0.156885013,
0.1479559541,
-0.5717456341,
0.8659589887,
0.0201817062,
-0.6421286464,
0.3022537231,
-0.5832449198,
-0.2665840089,
0.0017777217,
-0.4658454061,
-0.4033367336,
0.1985663325,
-0.0717567876,
0.7435145974,
0.3023542166,
0.6938296556,
-0.046172075,
-0.2186613977,
0.0598001443,
-0.4299283922,
0.2861742675,
0.2586222887,
-0.167417407,
0.196427837,
-0.5694087148,
-0.1624481231,
0.0471748672,
-0.6060028076,
-0.529229939,
0.2084872127,
-0.207212463,
0.080810599,
-0.0129807405,
-0.2059430331,
-0.0412381552,
-0.7875080109,
0.2537119091,
0.5057675242,
0.3059588075,
0.8998989463,
-0.0538624786,
0.3117907047,
0.647903502,
-0.0645667762,
-0.5075060725,
-0.4053111076,
-1.3409769535,
0.1425818056,
-0.0981271863,
0.4998173118,
-1.2393190861,
0.2203343958,
0.1614343822,
-0.0203695633,
-0.392830044,
0.028908357,
0.3591097891,
0.5125467777,
0.1597391218,
-0.1674474031,
-0.6934283376,
-0.8114461303,
-0.1439722478,
-0.1866283417,
0.3465287685,
-0.0760116577,
0.3684928119,
0.0841834322,
0.6774643064,
-0.2956293225,
-0.1207900941,
-0.1956142634,
0.3006115854,
0.1560947597,
0.6031344533,
0.1583868563,
-0.8464905024,
-0.2006336004,
-0.1912392825,
-0.677272737,
0.2738832235,
-0.057363417,
0.0559197105,
0.5564453602,
0.842536211,
-0.1365332007,
0.6017647982,
0.8225395679,
-0.5197249651,
0.3500862718,
-0.5202032328,
0.2542127371,
-1.240904808,
-0.3640517294,
0.0279223807,
-0.464453429,
-0.7794585228,
0.0472925268,
-0.2455869168,
-0.6925171614,
-0.3201263845,
0.4000498652,
-0.7412410378,
-0.0233579744,
-0.2566090822,
0.1013324335,
0.1315512806,
0.4450954199,
0.4821625352,
0.7494989634,
0.5080468655,
-0.6719737053,
0.1916287243,
0.1069663092,
-0.6029644012,
0.514570713,
-0.4285226464,
-0.1384162158,
-0.3577784598,
0.1588920355,
-0.9152060747,
-0.5706149936,
0.3332521319,
-0.0006005833,
0.4424774051,
-0.1972962469,
-0.3088265061,
-0.1458762735,
0.029259678,
0.069204241,
0.2232971489,
-0.5903426409,
0.4809128046,
0.4449393153,
-0.3224177063,
-0.2959054708,
-0.7170122266,
0.1584690362,
-0.0866789892,
-0.1231034696,
0.3869178295,
-0.0247031469,
-0.382901758,
0.1422743946,
0.0669540986,
-0.5127251744,
0.15265432,
0.5188883543,
0.2175912261,
-0.1617779732,
0.4367782474,
0.3318957984,
-0.0128931813,
-0.2315438241,
-0.0903645456,
0.3738966286,
-0.20992212,
-0.557950139,
-0.5258703232,
0.6771621108,
-0.1527370065,
0.0594303086,
0.8071904182,
0.1157108918,
-0.7665103078,
-0.2584527731,
-0.2452303171,
-0.3626749218,
-0.4344692528,
0.4340582788,
-0.5521166921,
-1.0228465796,
0.3351634145,
0.0153017174,
0.0790155977,
0.0886166692,
0.4020262063,
-0.4272612035,
0.9019190669,
0.7882272005,
0.3164517581,
0.7625817657,
-0.2999626696,
0.3840248883,
-0.6911249757,
-0.1868922859,
-0.2496674508,
0.1803544909,
-0.3302111924,
-0.7172352076,
0.4485994279,
0.5374068022,
-0.1587927192,
0.3500389159,
-0.2310498953,
0.4950142205,
0.3425691724,
0.0753715411,
0.428122133,
0.1876112968,
-0.2785763443,
-0.4718681276,
-1.2299129963,
-0.6899782419,
0.5050958395,
0.344407469,
0.6242901683,
0.2021967769,
0.7249311805,
0.2144002318,
0.4598399699,
-0.7360036373,
0.3535897732,
-0.1123501584,
-0.6227697134,
-0.2884063721,
-0.3184259832,
-1.0034145117,
0.2487984449,
-0.5059248209,
-0.9928333759,
0.6162720919,
0.678712368,
-0.4983256459,
0.1426062286,
-0.7584986687,
0.8747514486,
-0.0210881047,
-0.2540996671,
-0.1429144293,
-0.2234409004,
0.2726969123,
0.0570912808,
0.1603524089,
0.0047935499,
0.0077317054,
0.4250330627,
-0.5200657845,
1.129041791,
-0.1121170446,
-0.3975330889,
0.4645125866,
0.3259386122,
0.5789967179,
0.1379405558,
-0.0958511233,
-0.0013604523,
0.0558517501,
-0.312592715,
-0.3893277347,
0.7604510784,
-0.5990082026,
-0.6370452046,
-0.4171490073,
-0.5085865855,
-0.3670236468,
-0.1188194677,
0.3994299173,
0.7257870436,
-0.3901422918,
-0.2118867487,
0.586908102,
-0.3122309446,
0.6662272215,
0.5661922097,
-0.2909799218,
-0.0644538477,
0.8247404099,
0.2790506184,
0.2347302288,
0.2322089672,
-0.1774196476,
-0.2034396231,
-0.482976079,
-0.3958501816,
-0.1099862978,
-0.976539433,
-0.0881343409,
-0.4703415036,
-0.3393828571,
-0.1623149812,
0.1082174256,
-0.4942932129,
-0.1060455143,
-0.3168624043,
0.227240786,
0.2935893536,
0.6174470186,
-0.0280599613,
0.4756574035,
-0.5062965751,
0.1940277517,
0.2624172568,
0.5100131631,
0.0248051286,
-0.7830546498,
-0.3657805324,
-0.1282704324,
-0.1741757691,
-0.8696430326,
0.1965160221,
0.4950196147,
0.5112954974,
0.1812580079,
0.0527813956,
0.9547155499,
-0.7257117629,
0.6063939333,
0.2423359752,
-1.1231142282,
0.9204323888,
-0.0089295777,
0.0983005762,
0.4014827013,
0.2709389329,
-0.6757678986,
-0.7690855265,
-0.6189094186,
-0.7847958207,
0.843878746,
0.2964765131,
0.3158311546,
-0.1842328161,
0.5930638909,
-0.0515373237,
0.1347788721,
-0.6079815626,
-0.1794122607,
-0.2253827602,
-0.2873993516,
-0.1674266458,
-0.2751814127,
-0.1753713489,
-0.1146972254,
0.6633102298,
-0.0448818132,
0.2446270436,
0.4737536013,
-0.1887380034,
-0.1021424532,
0.3830763698,
0.3819345236,
0.4270667434,
0.0367473811,
0.4794031978,
0.230009973,
-0.1904904544,
0.4760912359,
0.0905446485,
-0.183469221,
0.1769093424,
0.5001736879,
1.0419893265,
0.4729881585,
-0.4983245134,
0.5000339746,
-0.0317221619,
0.1581167728,
-0.3717995286,
0.2955121696,
0.1658955514,
0.4227809012,
-0.0477451906,
-0.0471972898,
0.1863140464,
-0.8133035898,
0.1092844382,
0.0226731766,
-0.5316233039,
-0.4473693967,
0.4165840745,
0.3118979633,
-0.2949870229,
0.179820478,
-0.3700378239,
-0.3028256893,
0.4519791603,
0.6862639189,
0.4596081078,
-0.3350709081,
0.1246137992,
0.3045594096,
0.201062873,
-0.2921146154,
0.455347985,
0.0162726343,
-1.0917350054,
-0.5550257564,
-0.6211705804,
-0.6320511699,
0.3726822734,
-0.5967297554,
0.1163159609,
-0.3189308345,
-0.0307891425,
0.015225389,
-0.2998181283,
-0.6726322174,
0.3090762198,
0.0560621619,
0.4948746562,
-0.9519303441,
0.8677732944,
1.0300147533,
-0.4174457788,
-0.9310225844,
0.2917563617,
-0.17920582,
-0.3973759115,
0.5288123488,
-0.1290078908,
-0.1165446192,
0.0406073481,
-0.3432475328,
-0.6903491616,
0.7148737311,
0.5651259422,
-0.9118208289,
0.347429812,
-0.2091377378,
0.4911820292,
-0.5292147994,
-0.4365857542,
0.4340265393,
0.1957722455,
-0.3477087021,
-0.654912889,
-0.132935971,
-0.1218469143,
0.359469533,
0.1219531372,
-0.2954004407,
0.696647048,
-0.3681921363,
-0.6744520068,
0.142045334,
0.8536526561,
0.3907034993,
0.4147458375,
0.7087576389,
0.4281594753,
0.5886784196,
-0.3146450222,
1.1257691383,
-0.216362536,
0.3372017741,
1.6904250383,
-0.2383330911,
1.0876607895,
0.6813858747,
0.0221885499,
0.4413550794,
0.7681640387,
0.4060780406,
0.4812950194,
0.0986071378,
-0.3463901877,
-0.4376348257,
-0.3348986208,
-0.2330781668,
0.5441946983,
0.4211387336,
-0.1131618321,
-0.0903453752,
0.2466058582,
0.0027485357,
0.4255034626,
-0.2786173224,
0.8324931264,
0.2264564633,
-0.8140806556,
0.287437439,
0.0779959261,
0.3754268289,
-0.1647356302,
-0.3567120731,
-0.3803354502,
0.1082603484,
-0.1555167884,
-0.8295389414,
0.7001146078,
0.0847189575,
-0.3559325337,
-0.0554281287,
0.870238781,
-0.8858918548,
-0.4230236411,
0.3067821264,
0.5165470243,
0.4051684737,
0.0391144641,
-0.5671777129,
0.0235637054,
-0.4817426801,
-0.2279737741,
-0.043236468,
0.4601052403,
-0.2896305621,
0.4171330631,
0.2554189861,
0.2220601737,
-0.1073499545,
0.394115299,
0.6191923618,
-0.7571009994,
-0.500565052,
-0.6193013191,
0.3482166529,
-0.0917715803,
-0.10416089,
0.4712484479,
0.4007629156,
0.7430274487,
-0.0132635608,
0.7169790268,
0.0930529162,
0.3547534049,
-0.7135127783,
0.5092653036,
-0.6338477731,
0.2717117965,
0.0921634212,
-0.8105393052,
-0.1151265353,
0.6537870169,
-0.2895867825,
-0.093467772,
0.4979939461,
0.5264963508,
-0.2668683231,
-0.1962532401,
0.5616188645,
0.3010553122,
0.0412295349,
0.2787155807,
1.0375833511,
-0.3840990365,
0.3642567396,
-0.3331770003,
-0.0648572743,
-0.2466335148,
-1.1180016994,
-0.7448772192,
-0.8098797202,
-0.4841786921,
-0.3849532008,
0.2255987674,
0.9084569812,
0.8986469507,
-1.1359485388,
-0.2762589455,
-0.3729583323,
0.0504153967,
0.2245245874,
-0.2259096056,
0.1432544738,
-0.5661958456,
-0.7410562038,
0.4953867793,
0.5712468028,
0.4454870522,
-0.4247227311,
-0.2081629634,
-0.1782699525,
0.13714239,
0.7206477523,
0.1253957301,
-0.8773794174,
-0.6128976345,
-0.4518716335,
-0.1170212701,
0.0950402319,
0.6288257837,
-0.4485255778,
0.6568372846,
0.1873144954,
0.3167576492,
0.3640292585,
-0.3125558496,
0.7918091416,
-1.1131817102,
0.6472843885,
0.0395005271,
0.6385611296,
0.6432240605,
-0.2472345829,
0.3412003517,
0.116637446,
-0.1971303523,
-0.7233899832,
0.4925005436,
-0.5848907232,
-0.3011180162,
0.8152648211,
-0.4231919348,
-0.1294511408,
-0.4022390842,
-0.1553861201,
0.5913612843,
-0.3015789986,
0.706110239,
0.7770219445,
-0.168804273,
-0.2110355347,
-0.8390684724,
0.6217378378,
0.5887511969,
-1.0348814726,
-0.2196356058,
0.4455223083,
0.2533444166,
0.1686991751,
0.6193557382,
0.0757207721,
0.1691164672,
-0.0726077333,
0.2821716666,
0.4041541517,
-0.424608469,
-0.5613819361,
-0.097907275,
0.3182382882,
0.0051369257
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.